id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09200v1
|
Orthogonality and isotropy of speaker and phonetic information in self-supervised speech representations
| 2024-06-13T14:57:18 | 2024-06-13T14:57:18 |
Mukhtar Mohamed, Oli Danyi Liu, Hao Tang, Sharon Goldwater
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Self-supervised speech representations can hugely benefit downstream speech
technologies, yet the properties that make them useful are still poorly
understood. Two candidate properties related to the geometry of the
representation space have been hypothesized to correlate well with downstream
tasks: (1) the degree of orthogonality between the subspaces spanned by the
speaker centroids and phone centroids, and (2) the isotropy of the space, i.e.,
the degree to which all dimensions are effectively utilized. To study them, we
introduce a new measure, Cumulative Residual Variance (CRV), which can be used
to assess both properties. Using linear classifiers for speaker and phone ID to
probe the representations of six different self-supervised models and two
untrained baselines, we ask whether either orthogonality or isotropy correlate
with linear probing accuracy. We find that both measures correlate with
phonetic probing accuracy, though our results on isotropy are more nuanced.
|
[
-0.4664776623249054,
-0.36701905727386475,
0.40119150280952454,
0.19641025364398956,
0.12879253923892975,
-0.22984786331653595,
-0.4199059009552002,
-0.29718318581581116,
0.4913603365421295,
0.36575427651405334,
-0.2599320709705353,
-0.501532793045044,
-0.37127795815467834,
-0.176698237657547,
-0.33731991052627563,
0.3999198377132416,
0.3568609952926636,
0.2491416186094284,
-0.36788028478622437,
-0.6093100309371948,
-0.48681092262268066,
-0.8015125393867493,
-0.011221537366509438,
-0.2957298457622528,
0.6688829064369202,
0.5766353607177734,
0.978686511516571,
1.0815385580062866,
0.18811964988708496,
0.3035109043121338,
0.22401650249958038,
-0.4677811563014984,
-0.319408118724823,
0.28830909729003906,
-0.04790094494819641,
-0.26541489362716675,
-0.2585590183734894,
0.45721864700317383,
0.7312172651290894,
1.301647424697876,
-0.2661629617214203,
0.38580992817878723,
0.5024705529212952,
0.5287097096443176,
-0.4843917191028595,
0.0959136039018631,
-0.42815250158309937,
0.0024386774748563766,
-0.2699795067310333,
-0.4002210795879364,
-0.2484062910079956,
-0.21588121354579926,
0.09013208746910095,
-0.7698730230331421,
0.25946566462516785,
-0.2256190925836563,
0.5948489904403687,
0.22895288467407227,
-0.5104285478591919,
-0.3174128234386444,
-1.1623746156692505,
0.8340592384338379,
-0.47350001335144043,
1.069602370262146,
0.7161580324172974,
0.2917327582836151,
0.17437417805194855,
-0.6015139818191528,
-0.17436100542545319,
-0.45573729276657104,
-0.025069817900657654,
0.14090245962142944,
-0.36414235830307007,
0.10856777429580688,
-0.016253842040896416,
0.2307308316230774,
-0.550082266330719,
0.5548588037490845,
-0.5317734479904175,
-0.4375164806842804,
0.6409859657287598,
-0.21242044866085052,
0.08474618196487427,
-0.15320992469787598,
-0.5693933367729187,
-0.5152795314788818,
-0.4677170515060425,
0.37577563524246216,
0.7594012022018433,
0.2985052466392517,
-0.10526388883590698,
0.6059026122093201,
0.009434480220079422,
0.5002536177635193,
0.13795208930969238,
-0.23902709782123566,
0.3063269257545471,
-0.24965012073516846,
-0.05680673569440842,
0.15238142013549805,
0.6830692291259766,
-0.2072671353816986,
0.19802024960517883,
-0.2070002257823944,
0.16876670718193054,
-0.32539841532707214,
0.16101056337356567,
-0.26411670446395874,
-0.2790161669254303,
0.24382977187633514,
-0.7682792544364929,
0.08875172585248947,
0.17597448825836182,
-0.25614115595817566,
-0.0790206715464592,
-0.868980884552002,
0.18949800729751587,
-0.6375302672386169,
-0.41892683506011963,
-0.11111024022102356,
-0.24583739042282104,
0.19383303821086884,
0.07079018652439117,
-0.8876761794090271,
0.29782164096832275,
0.6097931861877441,
0.25994324684143066,
0.05863615497946739,
-0.42976313829421997,
-0.408790647983551,
-0.03176771476864815,
-0.5044836401939392,
0.5215750932693481,
-0.5989693403244019,
-0.3964000642299652,
0.048334091901779175,
-0.40819403529167175,
-0.21798959374427795,
-0.6905661225318909,
0.6565442085266113,
-0.10358962416648865,
0.036129340529441833,
-0.44420477747917175,
-0.5948150157928467,
-0.2846696972846985,
-0.21027475595474243,
-0.5376777648925781,
0.9860913157463074,
0.17230094969272614,
-0.4597952663898468,
0.4162585437297821,
0.5019060969352722,
0.034385062754154205,
0.1345585584640503,
-0.6729263663291931,
-0.2703700661659241,
0.22633004188537598,
0.10369617491960526,
0.47632431983947754,
0.04023834690451622,
0.282334566116333,
-0.6367062926292419,
-0.13389219343662262,
0.272932767868042,
-0.3705030083656311,
0.7254883050918579,
0.22504743933677673,
-0.06524436920881271,
-0.29023200273513794,
-1.275150179862976,
0.23853997886180878,
-0.4046672284603119,
-0.19466620683670044,
-0.6330758929252625,
0.018514279276132584,
-0.07111788541078568,
-0.07479584217071533,
0.25410497188568115,
-0.5688738226890564,
-0.14200755953788757,
0.11244241893291473,
-0.10742047429084778,
0.547415554523468,
-0.1467806100845337,
0.6995913982391357,
-0.1789577603340149,
0.45356225967407227,
-0.14895157516002655,
-0.0890594944357872,
0.15158919990062714,
-0.5527717471122742,
-0.4055834114551544,
-0.5706151127815247,
0.1638421267271042,
0.39783546328544617,
-0.1004081666469574,
0.6332711577415466,
-0.1968982070684433,
-0.8075053095817566,
-0.3350503444671631,
0.4028578996658325,
0.4152528643608093,
0.4136650562286377,
0.27767157554626465,
-0.18340368568897247,
-0.5474308729171753,
-1.0943841934204102,
-0.6320992708206177,
-0.4568679630756378,
-0.2629101574420929,
0.5671378374099731,
-0.1396128088235855,
-0.23933245241641998,
1.0198121070861816,
0.04145815595984459,
-0.803072988986969,
0.04490822181105614,
0.5781795978546143,
0.22605690360069275,
0.3569847345352173,
0.6625900864601135,
-0.4204801321029663,
-0.30741605162620544,
0.0591542012989521,
-0.7406396865844727,
-0.5198643803596497,
-0.19257481396198273,
0.3504656255245209,
-0.10480858385562897,
0.7496761083602905,
-0.16011671721935272,
0.4316193163394928,
0.6209321618080139,
-0.10815883427858353,
0.47645309567451477,
-0.41145581007003784,
0.005728944204747677,
-0.4526272714138031,
-0.14556364715099335,
0.23068729043006897,
-0.13870534300804138,
-0.7646715641021729,
-0.34258797764778137,
0.18418613076210022,
-0.1688929945230484,
-0.11874531209468842,
0.014155243523418903,
-0.8284816741943359,
-0.4139532148838043,
-0.015059273689985275,
0.30001696944236755,
-0.2293260395526886,
0.4618644416332245,
-0.06358656287193298,
0.74878990650177,
0.5434973239898682,
-0.5906786322593689,
0.07165227085351944,
-0.031619198620319366,
0.08063127100467682,
0.5286233425140381,
-0.6328511834144592,
0.13018609583377838,
-0.14667101204395294,
0.09255197644233704,
-1.3623840808868408,
0.05856552720069885,
-0.36486563086509705,
-0.8287994861602783,
0.29280051589012146,
-0.22275389730930328,
0.02486412040889263,
-0.019049042835831642,
-0.09151144325733185,
0.8279085755348206,
0.5078726410865784,
-0.4776082932949066,
0.5701864957809448,
0.48726531863212585,
-0.08538535982370377,
-0.5284549593925476,
-0.7303587794303894,
-0.09134984761476517,
-0.3042251467704773,
-0.7072644829750061,
0.24108177423477173,
0.6273521780967712,
-0.34979119896888733,
-0.14666643738746643,
-0.13705308735370636,
-0.19187290966510773,
-0.31073954701423645,
0.5243930816650391,
-0.1293945163488388,
-0.4146840274333954,
0.25486499071121216,
-0.25518012046813965,
-0.08826429396867752,
0.4386769235134125,
-0.4246586263179779,
0.4599757790565491,
0.039706021547317505,
-0.5844383835792542,
-0.6785030961036682,
0.3042941987514496,
0.364744633436203,
-0.12314900010824203,
0.14326119422912598,
0.7431361079216003,
-0.13935525715351105,
0.01412609126418829,
-0.961509108543396,
0.0952831283211708,
-0.45143362879753113,
0.23095330595970154,
-0.41408583521842957,
-0.7769635319709778,
1.1051024198532104,
0.33094194531440735,
-0.5050896406173706,
0.5109869241714478,
0.289874404668808,
-0.4398167133331299,
0.6030370593070984,
0.5233544111251831,
-0.2035643756389618,
0.3817030191421509,
-0.2574981153011322,
0.2906022369861603,
-0.8214987516403198,
-0.32491186261177063,
-0.9179574847221375,
-0.1335807889699936,
-0.924463152885437,
-0.32225489616394043,
0.5381693243980408,
0.015072986483573914,
-0.12568801641464233,
0.39467450976371765,
-0.3324015736579895,
-0.19440099596977234,
0.8319902420043945,
0.04254055395722389,
0.02602439373731613,
0.05188605189323425,
0.018198488280177116,
-0.4362933039665222,
-0.4859161972999573,
-0.33520200848579407,
0.9929211735725403,
0.6791404485702515,
1.046258568763733,
-0.0777362510561943,
0.9654715061187744,
0.21819765865802765,
-0.5046816468238831,
-0.6166181564331055,
0.32009801268577576,
-0.039133500307798386,
-0.31192782521247864,
-0.615515947341919,
-0.48916974663734436,
-1.1031814813613892,
0.28529906272888184,
0.12910081446170807,
-0.914936900138855,
1.1496518850326538,
0.39254704117774963,
-0.34098947048187256,
0.17664994299411774,
-0.5518627762794495,
0.46129748225212097,
-0.1450168490409851,
-0.09349405020475388,
-0.3403511941432953,
-0.44027334451675415,
0.10707447677850723,
0.22737881541252136,
0.2014513611793518,
-0.10020044445991516,
0.0944429486989975,
0.7773228883743286,
-0.3838716745376587,
0.9475694298744202,
-0.3387431204319,
-0.22316865622997284,
0.44781729578971863,
0.41698917746543884,
0.054831091314554214,
0.03836478292942047,
0.12913036346435547,
0.6111027002334595,
0.07709316909313202,
-0.20805326104164124,
-0.5413597822189331,
0.6704850196838379,
-1.0235424041748047,
-0.6922377943992615,
-0.30532991886138916,
-0.6228573322296143,
-0.25393450260162354,
-0.028830397874116898,
0.33186933398246765,
0.7800823450088501,
-0.37390315532684326,
0.495296448469162,
0.5812900066375732,
-0.2665560245513916,
0.3054339587688446,
0.06936381757259369,
-0.0610930360853672,
-0.2007426768541336,
0.6898171901702881,
0.6593655347824097,
0.46003949642181396,
0.26698538661003113,
0.2652583122253418,
-0.5175297260284424,
-0.24680876731872559,
-0.03410594165325165,
0.15728484094142914,
-0.7125309109687805,
-0.0539233461022377,
-0.5686897039413452,
-0.47272181510925293,
-0.841744601726532,
0.13506001234054565,
-0.6917033195495605,
-0.865015983581543,
-0.5201464295387268,
-0.049104344099760056,
0.027022680267691612,
0.6822794675827026,
-0.7224143147468567,
0.0692579448223114,
-0.5369850397109985,
0.2617410123348236,
0.6334313154220581,
0.092167928814888,
-0.08796441555023193,
-1.0352250337600708,
-0.1723698526620865,
0.33232688903808594,
-0.28559187054634094,
-0.7711418867111206,
0.5304495692253113,
0.44352272152900696,
0.8306493759155273,
0.5750651955604553,
-0.12904153764247894,
0.7112637758255005,
-0.3006519675254822,
0.6966263651847839,
0.08335136622190475,
-0.8516533374786377,
0.2771749794483185,
-0.6291757822036743,
0.01384816039353609,
0.43049317598342896,
0.4447760581970215,
-0.43770748376846313,
-0.46357500553131104,
-0.543222188949585,
-0.5121428966522217,
0.27558815479278564,
0.2207174301147461,
0.1953325718641281,
0.22622404992580414,
0.12624868750572205,
0.22396723926067352,
-0.31322476267814636,
-0.526471734046936,
-0.43502673506736755,
-0.47288569808006287,
0.1502116620540619,
-0.07197476923465729,
-0.6071751713752747,
-0.13198788464069366,
-0.3113442361354828,
0.16811808943748474,
0.13525265455245972,
0.5293585062026978,
0.5274839997291565,
0.04935191199183464,
0.06838768720626831,
0.35130468010902405,
0.524050235748291,
0.7655513286590576,
-0.5341218113899231,
0.373062402009964,
0.04575129970908165,
-0.5157366394996643,
0.25079265236854553,
0.1021902933716774,
0.5134223699569702,
0.17402908205986023,
0.672827959060669,
0.39991602301597595,
0.05264345929026604,
0.09530960768461227,
0.5753846764564514,
0.04169810563325882,
-0.39871329069137573,
-0.7969037294387817,
-0.25109049677848816,
-0.051037903875112534,
0.08084483444690704,
0.650169849395752,
0.04466104134917259,
0.4003935158252716,
-0.5006600022315979,
0.13923518359661102,
0.3379893898963928,
-0.665383517742157,
-0.3222637474536896,
0.5720483064651489,
0.031733542680740356,
-0.30634522438049316,
0.6537822484970093,
-0.0018881986616179347,
-0.20346949994564056,
0.5260530114173889,
0.4461023807525635,
0.8689133524894714,
-0.5349692702293396,
0.10870952159166336,
0.408780038356781,
0.11876466125249863,
0.33041220903396606,
0.08696680516004562,
-0.5652497410774231,
-0.892414927482605,
-0.05169490724802017,
0.07607785612344742,
-0.3191072642803192,
-0.1837541162967682,
-1.3192803859710693,
-0.02310767024755478,
-0.12227005511522293,
-0.2103307843208313,
0.05978981405496597,
-0.4681507647037506,
-0.6708693504333496,
0.11885535717010498,
0.35543325543403625,
0.5952273011207581,
-0.8823563456535339,
0.9271622896194458,
0.22902558743953705,
-0.17836782336235046,
-1.080678939819336,
-0.21222271025180817,
0.0706435963511467,
-0.933620035648346,
1.0183353424072266,
-0.008918492123484612,
-0.40670716762542725,
-0.36391332745552063,
-0.2793596386909485,
-1.3046644926071167,
0.9966614842414856,
0.46746230125427246,
-0.6590254902839661,
0.2506263554096222,
0.7430201768875122,
0.7101973295211792,
-0.17471280694007874,
0.2484118640422821,
0.3619078993797302,
0.19608330726623535,
-0.2543618977069855,
-1.1696150302886963,
-0.31335487961769104,
-0.005598440766334534,
0.31402266025543213,
-0.3661961555480957,
-0.3579918146133423,
0.9410334825515747,
-0.043890491127967834,
-0.4657880961894989,
-0.15961408615112305,
0.9977223873138428,
0.17111781239509583,
0.2200402319431305,
0.5740857124328613,
0.7015772461891174,
0.6837971806526184,
-0.052939631044864655,
1.0473004579544067,
-0.49821916222572327,
0.2901850938796997,
0.9302119612693787,
0.051568787544965744,
0.6346840262413025,
0.4558602273464203,
-0.03838013857603073,
0.36789244413375854,
0.20972391963005066,
0.2325669527053833,
0.3246476948261261,
0.23041699826717377,
0.2574469745159149,
-0.36501985788345337,
0.036632027477025986,
-0.5451856255531311,
0.8705558776855469,
0.3492489755153656,
-0.2567142844200134,
-0.18972407281398773,
0.17937515676021576,
-0.18092699348926544,
0.4548831582069397,
0.016941752284765244,
0.5514066219329834,
0.26965826749801636,
-0.5877900719642639,
0.9624966382980347,
-0.37351417541503906,
0.19750294089317322,
-0.3230384290218353,
0.026829831302165985,
-0.2581363916397095,
0.20711669325828552,
-0.26624977588653564,
-0.8768172860145569,
0.19094218313694,
-0.6175951361656189,
-0.0656592920422554,
-0.5928865075111389,
0.5908901691436768,
-0.5100721120834351,
-0.32020068168640137,
0.7262415289878845,
0.4846351444721222,
0.14535577595233917,
0.06384304910898209,
-0.22024784982204437,
0.012614407576620579,
0.008210043422877789,
0.04527764022350311,
0.07067398726940155,
0.6633402109146118,
0.09889139980077744,
0.7381061315536499,
0.29391029477119446,
0.3060082793235779,
0.49955421686172485,
0.3028462827205658,
0.6761388182640076,
-0.5682263970375061,
-0.3304224908351898,
-0.42553815245628357,
0.16904768347740173,
0.1118113324046135,
-0.603305459022522,
1.0436021089553833,
0.6670804023742676,
0.9661992788314819,
0.12976066768169403,
0.5337982773780823,
0.2030765414237976,
0.783730685710907,
-0.43004584312438965,
0.2756369113922119,
-0.16604474186897278,
0.2684771716594696,
-0.11171663552522659,
-0.820730447769165,
-0.03872299566864967,
0.7352800369262695,
-0.24976064264774323,
0.10174337774515152,
0.5115363597869873,
0.8225566744804382,
-0.430411159992218,
0.038610365241765976,
0.5715246200561523,
0.0701003223657608,
0.2938210368156433,
0.049802735447883606,
0.9101153016090393,
-0.3832833170890808,
0.4540332555770874,
-0.5398109555244446,
-0.30448538064956665,
0.045463867485523224,
-0.3928179144859314,
-0.7255100607872009,
-0.9683241844177246,
-0.2632450461387634,
-0.08857497572898865,
-0.19214464724063873,
0.6721280217170715,
0.9845007061958313,
-0.5571603775024414,
-0.7346240878105164,
0.25048723816871643,
-0.2633999288082123,
-0.29921215772628784,
-0.15903592109680176,
0.4582951068878174,
-0.5822771191596985,
-0.26489928364753723,
0.4008442163467407,
0.15914972126483917,
-0.10478853434324265,
-0.3629249334335327,
0.14207662642002106,
0.10795126855373383,
-0.06324778497219086,
0.1978985071182251,
0.5430451035499573,
-0.6543968319892883,
-0.4457736015319824,
0.11469858884811401,
-0.3398968577384949,
0.4340288043022156,
0.9485718607902527,
-0.6380733251571655,
0.5050682425498962,
0.5658633708953857,
0.4052499532699585,
0.4418592154979706,
0.29657790064811707,
0.725558340549469,
-0.9004526138305664,
0.41485387086868286,
0.3669709861278534,
0.483956515789032,
0.27180373668670654,
-0.4576094150543213,
0.2314264327287674,
0.007376264315098524,
-0.818804919719696,
-0.5790747404098511,
0.19398419559001923,
-1.325704574584961,
0.08067484200000763,
1.4404743909835815,
-0.08950052410364151,
-0.10237983614206314,
-0.1784285455942154,
-0.03718005120754242,
0.11663180589675903,
-0.34731703996658325,
0.45773258805274963,
0.4247499108314514,
-0.3331311047077179,
-0.12543994188308716,
-0.3036957383155823,
0.3141985833644867,
0.5613250136375427,
-0.13943523168563843,
0.12088098376989365,
0.39080578088760376,
0.226987823843956,
0.4713357090950012,
0.6454309821128845,
-0.2557677626609802,
0.20305056869983673,
0.16344335675239563,
0.3507498502731323,
0.029827378690242767,
-0.2865068316459656,
-0.4822583794593811,
-0.027291297912597656,
0.011911632493138313,
-0.6627352833747864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09175v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09175v1
|
ReMI: A Dataset for Reasoning with Multiple Images
| 2024-06-13T14:37:04 | 2024-06-13T14:37:04 |
Mehran Kazemi, Nishanth Dikkala, Ankit Anand, Petar Devic, Ishita Dasgupta, Fangyu Liu, Bahare Fatemi, Pranjal Awasthi, Dee Guo, Sreenivas Gollapudi, Ahmed Qureshi
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
With the continuous advancement of large language models (LLMs), it is
essential to create new benchmarks to effectively evaluate their expanding
capabilities and identify areas for improvement. This work focuses on
multi-image reasoning, an emerging capability in state-of-the-art LLMs. We
introduce ReMI, a dataset designed to assess LLMs' ability to Reason with
Multiple Images. This dataset encompasses a diverse range of tasks, spanning
various reasoning domains such as math, physics, logic, code, table/chart
understanding, and spatial and temporal reasoning. It also covers a broad
spectrum of characteristics found in multi-image reasoning scenarios. We have
benchmarked several cutting-edge LLMs using ReMI and found a substantial gap
between their performance and human-level proficiency. This highlights the
challenges in multi-image reasoning and the need for further research. Our
analysis also reveals the strengths and weaknesses of different models,
shedding light on the types of reasoning that are currently attainable and
areas where future models require improvement. To foster further research in
this area, we are releasing ReMI publicly:
https://huggingface.co/datasets/mehrankazemi/ReMI.
|
[
-0.44052281975746155,
-0.5045374631881714,
0.5730103850364685,
0.1793178915977478,
-0.18319961428642273,
0.19293077290058136,
-0.07608161866664886,
-0.5408803224563599,
-0.030270347371697426,
0.4681684970855713,
-0.5526040196418762,
-0.5345930457115173,
-0.7570489048957825,
0.2358848601579666,
-0.23072050511837006,
-0.0527474507689476,
-0.4166930317878723,
0.23394939303398132,
-0.614612340927124,
-0.4923459589481354,
-0.4824700653553009,
-0.25432801246643066,
-0.436838299036026,
-0.37384164333343506,
0.7849953770637512,
0.8754091858863831,
0.6797217130661011,
0.44353026151657104,
0.7927784323692322,
0.3526807129383087,
0.5280477404594421,
0.6582103371620178,
-0.12529246509075165,
0.3202148377895355,
-0.12018892914056778,
-0.5104643106460571,
-0.263080358505249,
0.10604532808065414,
0.7848941683769226,
0.46187853813171387,
0.11005188524723053,
0.23808127641677856,
-0.39468908309936523,
0.635970413684845,
-0.6806712746620178,
-0.06577018648386002,
-0.5019375681877136,
-0.0329526886343956,
-0.09720351547002792,
-0.09219421446323395,
-0.2900505065917969,
-0.2449556291103363,
-0.09495740383863449,
-0.6268160343170166,
0.08931979537010193,
0.3391350507736206,
0.9621996283531189,
0.5527415871620178,
-0.4202585816383362,
0.05917889252305031,
-0.35901540517807007,
1.101775050163269,
-0.2517651319503784,
0.7826470732688904,
0.26954489946365356,
0.6692483425140381,
-0.29658249020576477,
-0.6628723740577698,
-0.41704103350639343,
-0.1048937514424324,
0.15471714735031128,
-0.03443097323179245,
0.04497697204351425,
-0.5862418413162231,
0.30859386920928955,
0.1921733319759369,
-0.2754748463630676,
-0.03488729149103165,
-0.11403082311153412,
-0.13182470202445984,
0.66910719871521,
0.2575567364692688,
0.36579325795173645,
0.0870879516005516,
-0.2859395146369934,
-0.11546766757965088,
-0.8396413922309875,
-0.12079792469739914,
0.15311984717845917,
-0.13585299253463745,
-0.12305419147014618,
0.6050894856452942,
-0.12463091313838959,
0.8004636764526367,
-0.6657705307006836,
-0.37493017315864563,
0.30782175064086914,
-0.2978038191795349,
-0.1359350085258484,
-0.515268862247467,
0.6872919201850891,
0.5403116345405579,
0.41160932183265686,
0.1788553148508072,
-0.26812687516212463,
0.3241783082485199,
0.03874746710062027,
-0.6606972813606262,
-0.09845227748155594,
0.1288440078496933,
-0.7796435356140137,
0.05102550610899925,
-0.3816470801830292,
-0.9218953847885132,
-0.5511302947998047,
-0.5008034110069275,
0.06743580102920532,
-0.36964669823646545,
-0.33352792263031006,
0.1697307974100113,
-0.18220120668411255,
0.35641664266586304,
0.4980435371398926,
-0.5560516715049744,
0.004788377322256565,
0.6071656942367554,
0.6978795528411865,
0.11042550951242447,
-0.7841566801071167,
-0.09757441282272339,
0.09576643258333206,
-0.5095670223236084,
1.400458574295044,
-1.0660512447357178,
-0.2896715998649597,
-0.16125606000423431,
0.012558192014694214,
-0.03539170324802399,
-0.6109207272529602,
0.7402773499488831,
-0.21138539910316467,
-0.1033046767115593,
-0.29935210943222046,
-0.38624489307403564,
-0.3044951856136322,
0.5083057284355164,
-0.7767791152000427,
0.6347464323043823,
-0.10004231333732605,
-0.6350902318954468,
0.4695724546909332,
-0.5918422937393188,
-0.49935048818588257,
-0.19112932682037354,
-0.7068600058555603,
-0.5640037655830383,
0.08891213685274124,
0.5360275506973267,
0.39577609300613403,
-0.9502118229866028,
0.4269234836101532,
-0.7348700761795044,
-0.34649038314819336,
0.506446361541748,
-0.2724410593509674,
0.32166552543640137,
0.42380812764167786,
0.14107133448123932,
0.011559675447642803,
-0.7392796277999878,
0.1422739177942276,
0.47595852613449097,
-0.3599960207939148,
0.09675300121307373,
0.0880415290594101,
-0.18123169243335724,
0.2048882246017456,
0.12959575653076172,
-0.6291569471359253,
0.22755545377731323,
0.43253082036972046,
0.519614577293396,
0.37537524104118347,
-0.199397012591362,
0.044871844351291656,
-0.5573614239692688,
0.456765353679657,
0.20116452872753143,
0.10888896882534027,
-0.42847082018852234,
-0.6814539432525635,
-0.7531819343566895,
-0.5797390937805176,
0.20390905439853668,
0.6118240356445312,
-0.8120790123939514,
-0.14709097146987915,
-0.3257484436035156,
-0.6064317226409912,
-0.814254105091095,
0.2003563791513443,
0.5297996401786804,
0.30652427673339844,
0.25766444206237793,
-0.1163889691233635,
-0.5746806859970093,
-1.2821778059005737,
-0.3663680851459503,
0.23653748631477356,
0.10175198316574097,
0.47636178135871887,
0.6784437894821167,
-0.4377845525741577,
0.6756786108016968,
-0.3982873558998108,
-0.08206046372652054,
-0.15833145380020142,
0.27886080741882324,
0.06544575095176697,
0.36976924538612366,
0.3663758635520935,
-0.8150948286056519,
0.03264276683330536,
-0.1694701910018921,
-1.1657814979553223,
-0.025140345096588135,
-0.2870933413505554,
-0.289785772562027,
0.021387048065662384,
0.37863099575042725,
-0.422412246465683,
0.5291697978973389,
0.39335352182388306,
-0.15023230016231537,
0.5419235825538635,
-0.1763182133436203,
0.7340430021286011,
-0.8210432529449463,
-0.08265504240989685,
0.38377976417541504,
-0.0055578481405973434,
-0.3198224604129791,
0.06289695203304291,
0.09021753817796707,
-0.17039845883846283,
-0.3106687068939209,
0.44599494338035583,
-0.7708995938301086,
-0.5618545413017273,
-0.33077144622802734,
-0.07894819974899292,
0.2988206744194031,
0.34456729888916016,
0.345195472240448,
0.779495894908905,
1.1898103952407837,
-0.40830063819885254,
0.7329826354980469,
0.1858426183462143,
-0.7880553007125854,
0.6163077354431152,
-0.6084471940994263,
0.07482561469078064,
-0.08511222898960114,
0.2765442430973053,
-0.9955376386642456,
-0.3060601055622101,
0.10055261850357056,
-0.5277977585792542,
0.15548396110534668,
0.06030481681227684,
-0.8025236129760742,
-0.3287335932254791,
-0.11824313551187515,
0.6253148317337036,
0.12208043783903122,
-0.7469903826713562,
0.9180989265441895,
0.5080366134643555,
0.236993208527565,
-0.6324807405471802,
-0.7774056196212769,
0.3053756058216095,
-0.3485528528690338,
-1.0717743635177612,
0.07064379006624222,
0.16380704939365387,
-0.3578665554523468,
0.0462069995701313,
0.19628895819187164,
-0.3241548240184784,
0.03790426254272461,
0.33472466468811035,
0.22995677590370178,
-0.14899569749832153,
0.1514485776424408,
-0.12553343176841736,
-0.3518737852573395,
0.0538255050778389,
0.16613507270812988,
0.022025957703590393,
-0.28987789154052734,
-0.6392480731010437,
-0.5055648684501648,
0.5085480809211731,
0.7787380814552307,
-0.2540099620819092,
0.5050105452537537,
0.46559906005859375,
-0.6310311555862427,
0.11918100714683533,
-0.6981542110443115,
0.12685388326644897,
-0.3210773468017578,
0.15167362987995148,
-1.0161304473876953,
-0.7443932294845581,
0.6899773478507996,
-0.42452728748321533,
0.3462911546230316,
0.08225567638874054,
0.5382744669914246,
-0.03172437101602554,
1.0236155986785889,
0.2948119044303894,
0.18271227180957794,
0.24203826487064362,
-0.15103167295455933,
0.19670353829860687,
-0.9622927904129028,
-0.5548982620239258,
-0.3932057321071625,
-0.4578225612640381,
-0.3021696209907532,
-0.682856023311615,
-0.09094496071338654,
-0.30312374234199524,
-0.25870630145072937,
-0.0025498317554593086,
-0.24208633601665497,
0.597728967666626,
0.5917809009552002,
0.1341022402048111,
0.3640282154083252,
0.03053031489253044,
-0.11700157821178436,
0.02567722648382187,
-0.5594127774238586,
-0.706943154335022,
1.0459929704666138,
0.5049800872802734,
1.153357744216919,
0.22450298070907593,
0.39158517122268677,
0.10224887728691101,
0.4844595789909363,
-0.5824079513549805,
0.7139759659767151,
-0.2142617255449295,
-0.6545814275741577,
-0.12241906672716141,
-0.46128401160240173,
-0.9007247090339661,
0.6451776623725891,
-0.35878095030784607,
-0.34042128920555115,
0.2980552315711975,
0.08606665581464767,
-0.22430728375911713,
0.4530087113380432,
-0.8407724499702454,
0.7483225464820862,
-0.594853401184082,
-0.45294955372810364,
-0.3013596534729004,
-0.6101036667823792,
0.7207321524620056,
-0.1475183516740799,
0.4335310757160187,
-0.633544385433197,
-0.20148904621601105,
0.5271414518356323,
0.045628465712070465,
0.6840755939483643,
0.0035018124617636204,
-0.031966354697942734,
0.40520328283309937,
-0.03728460147976875,
-0.24558678269386292,
0.0484776571393013,
-0.00027366308495402336,
0.44815078377723694,
0.07846003770828247,
-0.4505559504032135,
-0.490389883518219,
0.7502233386039734,
-0.8266492486000061,
-0.5985278487205505,
-0.23643167316913605,
-0.6846981048583984,
-0.39904049038887024,
0.005147016607224941,
0.024743888527154922,
0.4843749403953552,
-0.011852936819195747,
0.094820536673069,
0.4421743154525757,
-0.4713614284992218,
-0.03480144590139389,
0.19528797268867493,
-0.3254481852054596,
-0.4510450065135956,
0.8939464688301086,
-0.08458656817674637,
0.08127778023481369,
0.3284631371498108,
0.07130394876003265,
-0.5223457217216492,
-0.31491461396217346,
-0.5314541459083557,
0.3985676169395447,
-1.1515194177627563,
-0.13581110537052155,
-0.31301644444465637,
0.1505119800567627,
-0.48254311084747314,
-0.05154779553413391,
-0.4012352526187897,
-0.2731223702430725,
0.004278881475329399,
0.360638290643692,
0.03048275224864483,
0.6490467190742493,
-0.088543601334095,
0.06173887848854065,
-0.806577742099762,
0.6968364119529724,
0.31286436319351196,
0.5867486596107483,
-0.14106345176696777,
-0.5322021842002869,
-0.00231870636343956,
-0.10369069874286652,
-0.22959063947200775,
-0.7237018942832947,
0.13007231056690216,
0.12948575615882874,
0.9842020869255066,
0.30818918347358704,
-0.4936109781265259,
0.7693030834197998,
-0.4770756959915161,
0.2717668414115906,
0.3298885226249695,
-0.6324570775032043,
0.6497274041175842,
-0.06868106126785278,
0.20036369562149048,
0.40453171730041504,
0.2449663132429123,
-0.3877227008342743,
-0.12670235335826874,
-0.45432350039482117,
-0.27798908948898315,
0.26749885082244873,
-0.06256869435310364,
-0.39587751030921936,
0.2007817178964615,
0.29723984003067017,
-0.05157269537448883,
-0.015170400962233543,
-0.42697960138320923,
-0.09792966395616531,
-0.26077568531036377,
-0.030305247753858566,
0.01852891594171524,
-0.19088611006736755,
-0.2264145165681839,
-0.3979406952857971,
0.5072576403617859,
-0.11348523199558258,
0.3548792898654938,
0.08437629789113998,
-0.1573401391506195,
0.05495290085673332,
0.18294063210487366,
0.5684112906455994,
0.8632174134254456,
0.12722866237163544,
0.3955840468406677,
0.07397948950529099,
-0.03938063234090805,
0.24188727140426636,
-0.15953226387500763,
0.33947721123695374,
-0.14293278753757477,
0.5010091662406921,
0.6943448781967163,
0.26632678508758545,
-0.8353139758110046,
0.13735704123973846,
-0.44611284136772156,
-0.5020161867141724,
-0.19059380888938904,
-0.17863859236240387,
0.2674613893032074,
0.33039066195487976,
0.037715211510658264,
-0.04914141818881035,
-0.04277598857879639,
-0.5216056108474731,
0.28311195969581604,
0.2747122347354889,
0.25026237964630127,
0.11192404478788376,
0.41561758518218994,
0.2925834357738495,
-0.0758761540055275,
0.9726307988166809,
-0.030846040695905685,
-0.29301828145980835,
0.825665295124054,
0.3612663745880127,
0.4394557476043701,
-0.1491679698228836,
0.016655664891004562,
0.47548216581344604,
0.5234976410865784,
-0.13445575535297394,
0.488166481256485,
0.16678185760974884,
-1.2680414915084839,
-0.43937644362449646,
-0.1684420108795166,
-0.6627691388130188,
-0.050215352326631546,
-0.3857785761356354,
0.2845846712589264,
-0.44550663232803345,
-0.28487086296081543,
0.16974572837352753,
-0.1864180713891983,
-0.620064914226532,
0.29990047216415405,
0.3771400451660156,
1.0395652055740356,
-1.0391935110092163,
0.8686709403991699,
0.864508330821991,
-0.37315839529037476,
-0.5174512267112732,
-0.47243601083755493,
0.14350086450576782,
-1.199358582496643,
0.6490808129310608,
0.5006728172302246,
-0.40492135286331177,
-0.4101817011833191,
-0.8594874143600464,
-0.7668691873550415,
1.1321865320205688,
0.532455325126648,
-0.5811383724212646,
0.5805447101593018,
-0.049082472920417786,
0.2188560962677002,
-0.9890540838241577,
0.21914753317832947,
0.8767163157463074,
0.6603480577468872,
0.5803650617599487,
-0.420794814825058,
-0.052718326449394226,
-0.45682665705680847,
-0.0018423330038785934,
0.1943555772304535,
-0.6345599889755249,
0.7037964463233948,
-0.703459620475769,
-0.27600225806236267,
0.013607480563223362,
0.7317162156105042,
0.848913848400116,
0.5508685111999512,
0.6625481843948364,
1.0047966241836548,
0.7950289249420166,
-0.27930590510368347,
0.9959253668785095,
-0.17937958240509033,
0.07489761710166931,
1.1156291961669922,
-0.5651931166648865,
0.744456946849823,
0.43583518266677856,
-0.03255433216691017,
0.5976347327232361,
0.963322103023529,
-0.31080007553100586,
0.352875679731369,
0.26137876510620117,
-0.2364710569381714,
-0.9377996325492859,
-0.3026290535926819,
-0.32980361580848694,
0.46216142177581787,
0.6670463681221008,
-0.1188586950302124,
-0.2423640489578247,
-0.054343994706869125,
-0.2634687125682831,
0.04762744903564453,
-0.21810974180698395,
0.2422923445701599,
0.15197806060314178,
-0.6875326037406921,
0.23143164813518524,
-0.012607279233634472,
0.5564450621604919,
-0.10851850360631943,
-0.26302555203437805,
-0.16356942057609558,
0.19838006794452667,
-0.29433974623680115,
-1.1773717403411865,
0.3629702627658844,
-0.060691557824611664,
-0.010540368035435677,
-0.16761162877082825,
0.9734927415847778,
-0.27785155177116394,
-0.6501257419586182,
0.14107097685337067,
0.8122552633285522,
0.6498250961303711,
0.1553385853767395,
-1.1140333414077759,
0.40724194049835205,
-0.0664951428771019,
-0.06614178419113159,
0.13485226035118103,
0.560001790523529,
-0.17545685172080994,
1.3645435571670532,
0.6176251769065857,
-0.11009600013494492,
0.061396632343530655,
0.5132419466972351,
0.7797672748565674,
-0.8002901077270508,
0.02128509059548378,
-0.6928302049636841,
0.0815797820687294,
-0.14339877665042877,
-0.3275020122528076,
0.512377142906189,
0.603485107421875,
0.4089147448539734,
0.04093077778816223,
0.7807322144508362,
0.18846556544303894,
0.5992236733436584,
-0.44050395488739014,
0.2122267186641693,
-0.8336452841758728,
0.011190835386514664,
0.16576799750328064,
-0.5747107267379761,
-0.5325412750244141,
0.8119758367538452,
-0.3467999994754791,
0.1417749673128128,
0.7440661787986755,
0.9393314123153687,
0.0429656058549881,
0.2089177817106247,
0.48675957322120667,
-0.30757081508636475,
0.29501259326934814,
0.9171136021614075,
1.4983065128326416,
-0.1591813564300537,
0.3936903476715088,
-0.07808936387300491,
-0.32898271083831787,
0.12026605755090714,
-1.004898190498352,
-0.8628536462783813,
-0.488911509513855,
-0.5085146427154541,
0.04734288528561592,
-0.2832866311073303,
0.37244704365730286,
0.7775939106941223,
-0.47231176495552063,
-0.24355359375476837,
0.3086484968662262,
0.4795845150947571,
-0.04061463102698326,
-0.05956923961639404,
0.01781601831316948,
-0.14272600412368774,
-0.5976003408432007,
0.32782310247421265,
0.35673603415489197,
-0.020510319620370865,
-0.41031795740127563,
-0.16483713686466217,
-0.4362357258796692,
0.07129897177219391,
0.3749232590198517,
0.32050320506095886,
-0.7859965562820435,
-0.06457304209470749,
-0.28126460313796997,
-0.0025535416789352894,
0.21143896877765656,
1.0968009233474731,
-0.5194827318191528,
0.23150110244750977,
0.4874463379383087,
0.7345471978187561,
0.1971663534641266,
-0.15190058946609497,
0.37526431679725647,
-0.38900110125541687,
0.02474372833967209,
-0.1772019863128662,
1.0499929189682007,
0.6526416540145874,
-0.018540553748607635,
0.7154675722122192,
0.28892579674720764,
-0.6973583698272705,
-0.6469765305519104,
0.5026931762695312,
-0.6722014546394348,
-0.44428426027297974,
1.0041394233703613,
-0.39520543813705444,
-0.3071426451206207,
-0.17396904528141022,
0.07126930356025696,
0.11132823675870895,
-0.2013789713382721,
0.4783988893032074,
0.9947843551635742,
-0.446749746799469,
-0.8241496086120605,
-0.5635598301887512,
-0.19570590555667877,
0.4334582984447479,
-1.246436357498169,
0.01167286280542612,
0.8320541381835938,
0.2620801627635956,
0.3464192748069763,
0.574013888835907,
-0.2481483817100525,
0.3467727601528168,
0.15920181572437286,
0.16750116646289825,
-0.14008985459804535,
-0.7697457075119019,
-0.1925806999206543,
0.012492524459958076,
0.10798690468072891,
-0.562930166721344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09170v1
|
Test of Time: A Benchmark for Evaluating LLMs on Temporal Reasoning
| 2024-06-13T14:31:19 | 2024-06-13T14:31:19 |
Bahare Fatemi, Mehran Kazemi, Anton Tsitsulin, Karishma Malkan, Jinyeong Yim, John Palowitch, Sungyong Seo, Jonathan Halcrow, Bryan Perozzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have showcased remarkable reasoning
capabilities, yet they remain susceptible to errors, particularly in temporal
reasoning tasks involving complex temporal logic. Existing research has
explored LLM performance on temporal reasoning using diverse datasets and
benchmarks. However, these studies often rely on real-world data that LLMs may
have encountered during pre-training or employ anonymization techniques that
can inadvertently introduce factual inconsistencies. In this work, we address
these limitations by introducing novel synthetic datasets specifically designed
to assess LLM temporal reasoning abilities in various scenarios. The diversity
of question types across these datasets enables systematic investigation into
the impact of the problem structure, size, question type, fact order, and other
factors on LLM performance. Our findings provide valuable insights into the
strengths and weaknesses of current LLMs in temporal reasoning tasks. To foster
further research in this area, we are open-sourcing the datasets and evaluation
framework used in our experiments: https://huggingface.co/datasets/baharef/ToT.
|
[
-0.09151292592287064,
-1.0136590003967285,
0.878897488117218,
0.6041393280029297,
-0.0450420044362545,
0.4341415762901306,
-0.15796224772930145,
-0.5092429518699646,
-0.3625083565711975,
0.059793099761009216,
-0.7823304533958435,
-0.3682713508605957,
-0.34585586190223694,
0.34464582800865173,
-0.43164557218551636,
0.3951624631881714,
-0.3612213134765625,
0.07929202914237976,
-0.30848002433776855,
-0.3032090961933136,
-0.11171023547649384,
-0.6644985675811768,
-0.5497714281082153,
-0.44547152519226074,
0.5295560359954834,
0.05097517371177673,
0.48600688576698303,
0.5405808091163635,
0.26117268204689026,
0.17209140956401825,
-0.06310111284255981,
0.28698718547821045,
-0.3341376781463623,
0.16499273478984833,
-0.29048213362693787,
-0.40911686420440674,
-0.40953192114830017,
0.13271720707416534,
0.8859605193138123,
0.8133504986763,
-0.007519055623561144,
0.5321139097213745,
-0.37869250774383545,
0.1910610944032669,
-0.6581963896751404,
0.22812168300151825,
-0.7270503044128418,
0.35708892345428467,
-0.4601178765296936,
-0.39679887890815735,
-0.39107128977775574,
-0.6541739702224731,
-0.0336088202893734,
-0.4228857755661011,
0.15981674194335938,
0.2884422242641449,
0.8119360208511353,
0.4388270974159241,
-0.5770464539527893,
0.06594733893871307,
-0.954821765422821,
0.7783585786819458,
-0.8171581625938416,
0.5179123878479004,
-0.04513558745384216,
0.7213463187217712,
-0.16325539350509644,
-0.8003028035163879,
-0.8522692918777466,
-0.27567458152770996,
0.006137836258858442,
0.10621917992830276,
0.0242404043674469,
-0.3578549325466156,
0.7666512727737427,
0.3339400291442871,
-0.6673341393470764,
0.2545376718044281,
0.10393920540809631,
0.03705845773220062,
0.4065346419811249,
0.6183951497077942,
0.18301896750926971,
0.0015376318478956819,
-0.22395852208137512,
-0.21056152880191803,
-0.6154592037200928,
0.06495985388755798,
0.5151342749595642,
0.02351715974509716,
0.02081889845430851,
0.8176516890525818,
-0.4082978069782257,
0.6677156686782837,
-0.10746518522500992,
-0.03215572237968445,
0.13038992881774902,
-0.5229700207710266,
-0.08240892738103867,
0.003590908832848072,
0.41344162821769714,
0.25077903270721436,
0.38127774000167847,
-0.23476308584213257,
-0.064539834856987,
0.13048547506332397,
-0.09586038440465927,
-0.7033836841583252,
0.20751656591892242,
0.28195899724960327,
-0.13472700119018555,
-0.07653801143169403,
-0.12529341876506805,
-0.7690497040748596,
-0.14401814341545105,
-0.3836703896522522,
0.34474843740463257,
-0.3057372570037842,
-0.06995360553264618,
0.2404908388853073,
-0.16435925662517548,
0.2986637353897095,
0.15807856619358063,
-0.39696720242500305,
0.31499963998794556,
0.5470534563064575,
0.4308204650878906,
-0.40265893936157227,
-0.3940471112728119,
-0.5974971055984497,
0.16378246247768402,
-0.38099250197410583,
0.7217011451721191,
-0.5895373821258545,
-0.4140454828739166,
-0.09766251593828201,
0.16001403331756592,
-0.30814218521118164,
-0.6561108827590942,
0.3405511677265167,
-0.6625697016716003,
0.21269209682941437,
-0.22489014267921448,
-0.4433339238166809,
0.1447889357805252,
0.4436171352863312,
-0.545785129070282,
1.1137198209762573,
0.3708116114139557,
-0.5702601671218872,
0.502585232257843,
-0.5830151438713074,
-0.5758088827133179,
-0.15837779641151428,
-0.3611317574977875,
-0.4766823947429657,
-0.1484537273645401,
0.30333465337753296,
0.2334458976984024,
-0.4385191798210144,
0.43115437030792236,
-0.539200484752655,
-0.3390445411205292,
0.8315424919128418,
-0.6420546770095825,
0.6465569138526917,
0.14552685618400574,
-0.48037272691726685,
-0.23903393745422363,
-0.8976625800132751,
0.22120624780654907,
0.4543726146221161,
-0.3393544852733612,
0.08027300983667374,
0.18050087988376617,
-0.14201393723487854,
0.09890446811914444,
0.11535145342350006,
-0.7095571756362915,
0.40611788630485535,
-0.1706630289554596,
0.43024298548698425,
0.5406501293182373,
0.2733244299888611,
-0.026415254920721054,
-0.5052785277366638,
0.5410290956497192,
0.10017029196023941,
0.4823005795478821,
0.09091725945472717,
-0.11068753898143768,
-0.7912936806678772,
0.12051023542881012,
0.2652391493320465,
0.5979369282722473,
-0.6956692337989807,
-0.009730479680001736,
-0.5342479348182678,
-0.40123987197875977,
-0.1200273409485817,
-0.01007077842950821,
0.4138801097869873,
0.5506471395492554,
0.31660693883895874,
0.011599072255194187,
-0.6449539065361023,
-0.8020650148391724,
-0.32305869460105896,
-0.28507915139198303,
-0.09492828696966171,
0.4759525954723358,
0.6027668118476868,
-0.2447938770055771,
0.9738543629646301,
-0.46785908937454224,
0.35119661688804626,
-0.08215661346912384,
0.21506693959236145,
0.22859208285808563,
0.17779786884784698,
0.5282260179519653,
-0.45710235834121704,
0.2228352576494217,
-0.44394782185554504,
-0.752366304397583,
-0.3716045618057251,
-0.2962573766708374,
0.12323340028524399,
0.26293566823005676,
0.47572842240333557,
-0.3865732252597809,
0.4048926532268524,
0.5005075335502625,
-0.5100862979888916,
0.8690482974052429,
0.056072741746902466,
0.4083755910396576,
-0.625705361366272,
0.05822817236185074,
-0.34213709831237793,
-0.027074377983808517,
-0.12004338949918747,
-0.3581891655921936,
-0.017261803150177002,
-0.08359108865261078,
-0.6510380506515503,
1.0846456289291382,
-0.28453728556632996,
-0.27899834513664246,
0.3750702738761902,
-0.1991717666387558,
0.015594981610774994,
0.30554407835006714,
-0.0717582032084465,
0.8342484831809998,
0.06512527912855148,
-0.5779283046722412,
0.30473536252975464,
0.052050214260816574,
-0.6079919338226318,
0.3720581829547882,
-0.8965002298355103,
0.305580735206604,
0.1268104910850525,
0.2328525334596634,
-0.8006120920181274,
-0.28531479835510254,
-0.07168686389923096,
-0.26626715064048767,
0.15538226068019867,
-0.22469516098499298,
-1.1014018058776855,
-0.2558024525642395,
0.0589955672621727,
0.6917136311531067,
0.38407349586486816,
-0.7010301947593689,
0.7003287076950073,
-0.05332588031888008,
0.050637342035770416,
-0.4280247688293457,
-0.6074896454811096,
-0.009066767990589142,
-0.2741735279560089,
-0.5875037908554077,
0.46007633209228516,
-0.2230193316936493,
-0.707430362701416,
-0.052331842482089996,
-0.29168733954429626,
-0.028576478362083435,
0.19094088673591614,
0.18304558098316193,
0.2763279676437378,
-0.18916134536266327,
0.18852776288986206,
0.0034249848686158657,
0.011948379687964916,
0.20503392815589905,
-0.12783537805080414,
0.49697330594062805,
-0.1802067756652832,
-0.7610642313957214,
0.094352126121521,
-0.015345040708780289,
0.5850433111190796,
-0.1334836483001709,
0.6133816242218018,
0.46035510301589966,
-0.29989829659461975,
-0.4997410178184509,
-0.8261592984199524,
-0.09621001034975052,
-0.4235531687736511,
0.03860560804605484,
-0.23464535176753998,
-0.9738554358482361,
0.38137078285217285,
-0.17223578691482544,
0.07595110684633255,
0.31484875082969666,
0.4580551087856293,
-0.09991977363824844,
0.7929376363754272,
-0.16228526830673218,
0.18428367376327515,
0.2781957685947418,
-0.2990466356277466,
0.04165179654955864,
-0.6255994439125061,
-0.4820669889450073,
-0.3077412545681,
-0.1940239667892456,
-0.46066582202911377,
-0.6400235295295715,
0.42534002661705017,
-0.19617709517478943,
-0.43576619029045105,
-0.1006338968873024,
0.17253518104553223,
0.35067856311798096,
0.1937127262353897,
0.07226280122995377,
0.4818374812602997,
-0.31843358278274536,
-0.1626325100660324,
0.10846177488565445,
-0.5546669363975525,
-0.5783973336219788,
1.0553092956542969,
0.15621639788150787,
0.7210102677345276,
0.0236345287412405,
0.13660885393619537,
0.28688037395477295,
0.04923781380057335,
-0.3482469618320465,
0.8141493797302246,
-0.06966545432806015,
-0.8007453680038452,
-0.4366900324821472,
-0.5624256134033203,
-0.9480041861534119,
-0.15149644017219543,
-0.10008072853088379,
-0.47041890025138855,
-0.03692872077226639,
-0.10417891293764114,
-0.3332042396068573,
0.34761059284210205,
-0.5920307636260986,
0.7458092570304871,
-0.6509289145469666,
-0.47265905141830444,
-0.04140656441450119,
-0.4558894634246826,
0.27947747707366943,
-0.042019136250019073,
0.03281648829579353,
-0.5604082942008972,
-0.07285786420106888,
0.645065426826477,
-0.1975974291563034,
0.7627752423286438,
0.043440550565719604,
0.2472500056028366,
0.29584643244743347,
0.3512896001338959,
0.3103511929512024,
0.5222707986831665,
-0.12088926136493683,
0.3564828634262085,
0.2890004515647888,
-0.4723280966281891,
-0.8438275456428528,
0.4895573556423187,
-0.6113830208778381,
-0.6283314824104309,
-0.5744631886482239,
-0.719804048538208,
-0.7187612056732178,
-0.06637231260538101,
-0.0549226775765419,
0.7383025288581848,
-0.2788384258747101,
0.1649768352508545,
0.6463530659675598,
-0.30882149934768677,
0.45027780532836914,
0.9060319662094116,
-0.17533330619335175,
-0.003662792267277837,
0.34794750809669495,
0.2656630575656891,
0.37964898347854614,
0.47902530431747437,
0.1859176605939865,
-0.5553891062736511,
-0.6795357465744019,
-0.1414433717727661,
0.2802954316139221,
-0.6184901595115662,
0.19870494306087494,
-0.5461090803146362,
-0.37522855401039124,
-0.38729196786880493,
0.20627623796463013,
-0.39425769448280334,
-0.7396735548973083,
-0.06431856751441956,
-0.13022984564304352,
0.3341410160064697,
0.39058059453964233,
0.2664962708950043,
-0.06246624514460564,
-0.6508631110191345,
0.35619819164276123,
0.5147159695625305,
0.329639196395874,
-0.1869312971830368,
-0.46469321846961975,
0.3196057677268982,
-0.3236466944217682,
-0.07642650604248047,
-0.4952183663845062,
0.03287301957607269,
0.04010295122861862,
0.8671814203262329,
-0.09578441828489304,
0.024338440969586372,
0.621086597442627,
-0.5316649079322815,
0.8383316397666931,
-0.34260493516921997,
-0.7305750250816345,
0.6739664077758789,
-0.43066540360450745,
0.4482923746109009,
0.28982093930244446,
0.323194682598114,
-0.37142884731292725,
-0.1702648252248764,
-0.7899786829948425,
-0.6785306930541992,
0.21030329167842865,
0.32994604110717773,
-0.3440125584602356,
-0.003447192255407572,
0.497866153717041,
0.17286540567874908,
0.09514371305704117,
-0.3499016761779785,
-0.15349380671977997,
0.055393896996974945,
0.04677664116024971,
-0.19160196185112,
-0.25982365012168884,
-0.10393065214157104,
-0.18415126204490662,
0.28125977516174316,
0.03553754836320877,
0.10201811045408249,
0.27534982562065125,
-0.0332641564309597,
0.05670727789402008,
0.5087766647338867,
0.5332273244857788,
1.095443606376648,
-0.2884067893028259,
0.1954478770494461,
0.6389070749282837,
-0.09065016359090805,
0.29443323612213135,
0.3003566861152649,
-0.041532762348651886,
-0.037580352276563644,
0.742745578289032,
0.4369319975376129,
0.20355412364006042,
-0.9216098785400391,
0.09353241324424744,
-0.2938006818294525,
-0.01750197447836399,
-0.57270348072052,
0.12476072460412979,
0.04948257654905319,
0.40257322788238525,
0.23141822218894958,
-0.3999195694923401,
-0.25914040207862854,
-0.6598322987556458,
0.09512052685022354,
0.01864173822104931,
0.061073482036590576,
-0.3405396342277527,
0.5865316390991211,
-0.09051123261451721,
-0.20224320888519287,
0.8178364038467407,
-0.3399399220943451,
-0.46718698740005493,
0.6529395580291748,
0.28639525175094604,
0.5841321349143982,
-0.1254022717475891,
-0.041998155415058136,
0.34303098917007446,
0.3101084530353546,
-0.06888439506292343,
0.5042815208435059,
0.16557620465755463,
-0.6812259554862976,
-0.637404203414917,
-0.5425504446029663,
-0.6611065864562988,
0.3258625268936157,
-0.38347768783569336,
0.008502181619405746,
-0.577796459197998,
-0.3513977825641632,
-0.30260056257247925,
0.12324157357215881,
-0.8487184047698975,
0.23695100843906403,
-0.10886599868535995,
1.0651171207427979,
-0.7687983512878418,
0.602061927318573,
0.5013850927352905,
-0.17856457829475403,
-0.5746523141860962,
0.050896577537059784,
0.03093428537249565,
-0.9280200004577637,
0.924090564250946,
-0.19075380265712738,
-0.07604703307151794,
-0.26200664043426514,
-0.3984816372394562,
-0.6484737396240234,
1.2204959392547607,
0.3957456052303314,
-0.6285755634307861,
-0.04934857040643692,
0.47645536065101624,
0.5380228161811829,
-0.2755713164806366,
0.1856485903263092,
0.8303685784339905,
0.5832005143165588,
0.11533016711473465,
-0.9041852951049805,
0.14192825555801392,
-0.30454736948013306,
-0.03140101581811905,
-0.027158310636878014,
-0.683404266834259,
0.7306923270225525,
-0.2565672695636749,
-0.33260220289230347,
-0.0003647396806627512,
0.4131591022014618,
0.6450742483139038,
0.6675449013710022,
0.6960427761077881,
0.5482085943222046,
0.6288235783576965,
-0.49316009879112244,
1.2898447513580322,
-0.08260615915060043,
-0.11236508190631866,
1.446284532546997,
-0.5876355171203613,
0.5491476655006409,
0.5659530758857727,
-0.39734506607055664,
0.4201774597167969,
0.7491405606269836,
-0.19142724573612213,
0.20648746192455292,
0.5308839082717896,
-0.13540349900722504,
-0.4585227966308594,
-0.3310910761356354,
-0.43877390027046204,
0.30110087990760803,
0.26708197593688965,
0.10809170454740524,
-0.17906531691551208,
-0.23310822248458862,
-0.09330707043409348,
-0.010328712873160839,
0.08526924252510071,
0.2697242200374603,
-0.07426653802394867,
-0.566620409488678,
0.32084909081459045,
-0.3025974929332733,
0.23235192894935608,
-0.6571427583694458,
-0.14326800405979156,
-0.3223949670791626,
0.298545241355896,
0.051912300288677216,
-0.8963135480880737,
0.2739771902561188,
0.11786647886037827,
0.10035549849271774,
-0.2697790563106537,
0.4015117585659027,
-0.007407149765640497,
-0.5157196521759033,
0.30285701155662537,
0.6803915500640869,
0.012930386699736118,
0.0851108655333519,
-0.49855589866638184,
0.20965448021888733,
-0.5160460472106934,
-0.33079925179481506,
0.2878561317920685,
0.5902495980262756,
-0.1423829197883606,
0.9747965335845947,
0.6403083205223083,
0.27647143602371216,
0.2582820653915405,
0.4522515833377838,
0.6863043308258057,
-0.7303423285484314,
-0.10005311667919159,
-0.873736560344696,
0.23133939504623413,
-0.047118354588747025,
-0.4840000867843628,
0.8714740872383118,
0.7573097944259644,
1.0254931449890137,
0.0476839505136013,
0.5809935331344604,
0.20021061599254608,
0.7666279077529907,
-0.9614768028259277,
0.29652273654937744,
-0.41411709785461426,
0.41890981793403625,
0.12589651346206665,
-0.7215698957443237,
0.005375777371227741,
0.006534693296998739,
-0.4633982479572296,
0.1358218789100647,
0.9059616327285767,
0.7114133834838867,
0.19395925104618073,
0.04695969074964523,
0.16922704875469208,
0.24287281930446625,
0.4726206064224243,
0.893891453742981,
1.5696467161178589,
-0.21406899392604828,
0.6427576541900635,
-0.45034798979759216,
0.003267195075750351,
-0.028167039155960083,
-1.192583680152893,
-1.182395339012146,
-0.4671432077884674,
-0.35880544781684875,
-0.3611954152584076,
0.4053499400615692,
0.7953538298606873,
0.4674097001552582,
-0.6726627349853516,
-0.13897821307182312,
0.3768176734447479,
-0.028237389400601387,
-0.14422160387039185,
-0.21837487816810608,
0.32471421360969543,
-0.08800385147333145,
-0.4748207926750183,
0.6673470735549927,
0.10595434159040451,
0.36445534229278564,
-0.14102977514266968,
0.15561242401599884,
-0.13959933817386627,
0.029557835310697556,
0.5830656886100769,
0.22184020280838013,
-0.5993801951408386,
-0.46243050694465637,
0.3870198428630829,
0.1724313497543335,
-0.18989841639995575,
1.0178552865982056,
-0.6408787965774536,
0.3084399998188019,
0.49849721789360046,
0.6369673013687134,
0.7452785968780518,
-0.10335827618837357,
0.439669668674469,
-0.6558641195297241,
-0.06460882723331451,
0.502922534942627,
0.4778730273246765,
0.11943478882312775,
-0.20872686803340912,
0.8947749137878418,
0.4725714921951294,
-0.36434707045555115,
-0.9063739776611328,
0.14434078335762024,
-1.1739288568496704,
-0.30498960614204407,
1.3592419624328613,
-0.11414451152086258,
-0.18250975012779236,
-0.17079488933086395,
0.24836347997188568,
0.36175358295440674,
-0.15704447031021118,
0.972449779510498,
0.8331424593925476,
-0.2664424479007721,
0.11584213376045227,
-0.7306885123252869,
0.16169151663780212,
0.3305739164352417,
-1.0238410234451294,
0.03296191990375519,
0.34588682651519775,
0.5396015644073486,
-0.08098360151052475,
0.39105841517448425,
-0.45316824316978455,
0.2779572606086731,
-0.05279587209224701,
-0.4295278489589691,
-0.45785343647003174,
-0.3031737506389618,
-0.10596910864114761,
0.006842753849923611,
-0.009175054728984833,
0.10586340725421906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09155v1
|
DefAn: Definitive Answer Dataset for LLMs Hallucination Evaluation
| 2024-06-13T14:18:13 | 2024-06-13T14:18:13 |
A B M Ashikur Rahman, Saeed Anwar, Muhammad Usman, Ajmal Mian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities,
revolutionizing the integration of AI in daily life applications. However, they
are prone to hallucinations, generating claims that contradict established
facts, deviating from prompts, and producing inconsistent responses when the
same prompt is presented multiple times. Addressing these issues is challenging
due to the lack of comprehensive and easily assessable benchmark datasets. Most
existing datasets are small and rely on multiple-choice questions, which are
inadequate for evaluating the generative prowess of LLMs. To measure
hallucination in LLMs, this paper introduces a comprehensive benchmark dataset
comprising over 75,000 prompts across eight domains. These prompts are designed
to elicit definitive, concise, and informative answers. The dataset is divided
into two segments: one publicly available for testing and assessing LLM
performance and a hidden segment for benchmarking various LLMs. In our
experiments, we tested six LLMs-GPT-3.5, LLama 2, LLama 3, Gemini, Mixtral, and
Zephyr-revealing that overall factual hallucination ranges from 59% to 82% on
the public dataset and 57% to 76% in the hidden benchmark. Prompt misalignment
hallucination ranges from 6% to 95% in the public dataset and 17% to 94% in the
hidden counterpart. Average consistency ranges from 21% to 61% and 22% to 63%,
respectively. Domain-wise analysis shows that LLM performance significantly
deteriorates when asked for specific numeric information while performing
moderately with person, location, and date queries. Our dataset demonstrates
its efficacy and serves as a comprehensive benchmark for LLM performance
evaluation. Our dataset and LLMs responses are available at
\href{https://github.com/ashikiut/DefAn}{https://github.com/ashikiut/DefAn}.
|
[
-0.41201379895210266,
-0.9023528099060059,
0.7742832899093628,
0.19079340994358063,
-0.053385697305202484,
-0.3340317904949188,
-0.30880194902420044,
-0.34904879331588745,
0.2898905277252197,
0.47771450877189636,
-0.7963780164718628,
-0.6656593680381775,
-0.4123271703720093,
0.47897955775260925,
-0.575779378414154,
0.6323098540306091,
0.058283731341362,
0.03843427076935768,
-0.3660915791988373,
-0.17835645377635956,
-0.7804216742515564,
-0.5416504740715027,
-0.2843426465988159,
-0.16661861538887024,
0.4205743372440338,
0.31665363907814026,
0.6158095598220825,
0.37841925024986267,
0.4892159104347229,
0.2938988506793976,
-0.04176238179206848,
0.4300936162471771,
-0.5855225920677185,
0.258044958114624,
0.056826379150152206,
-0.24151746928691864,
-0.30807849764823914,
-0.17508761584758759,
0.5455208420753479,
0.8597915172576904,
-0.29547756910324097,
0.2361636459827423,
-0.07380758970975876,
0.7307636141777039,
-0.41593167185783386,
-0.08433227241039276,
-0.8195827007293701,
0.03078354150056839,
-0.22824546694755554,
-0.08599793165922165,
-0.20072725415229797,
-0.7251708507537842,
0.0009432617807760835,
-0.562949001789093,
0.29382672905921936,
0.007938887923955917,
0.7076563835144043,
0.8595001101493835,
-0.18589910864830017,
-0.4020952582359314,
-0.6795836091041565,
0.5474903583526611,
-0.4836632311344147,
0.392004132270813,
0.6026543974876404,
0.542934000492096,
-0.30728045105934143,
-0.7094954252243042,
-0.6183720231056213,
-0.5305213928222656,
-0.23340412974357605,
0.01615142822265625,
-0.09330643713474274,
-0.170865997672081,
0.524506151676178,
0.47668254375457764,
-1.0088579654693604,
-0.0574389211833477,
-0.0940174087882042,
-0.19382907450199127,
0.5634457468986511,
0.544489860534668,
-0.07138567417860031,
-0.16883741319179535,
-0.24669833481311798,
-0.18971064686775208,
-0.6293624043464661,
-0.37497255206108093,
0.3476594090461731,
0.2944232225418091,
0.10150834172964096,
0.6568684577941895,
-0.36268913745880127,
0.8287412524223328,
0.03982635587453842,
0.01668681390583515,
0.4433179199695587,
-0.3275509774684906,
-0.21244297921657562,
0.1632585972547531,
0.7098572850227356,
0.2539292871952057,
0.3169904351234436,
-0.27645760774612427,
-0.4573558568954468,
0.1820937991142273,
0.36768704652786255,
-0.7254087924957275,
-0.06839780509471893,
0.5153862237930298,
-0.22912584245204926,
-0.040548473596572876,
0.1321292668581009,
-0.9788846373558044,
-0.960796058177948,
-0.4327177405357361,
0.28540971875190735,
-0.3895682692527771,
-0.16672851145267487,
0.30865243077278137,
0.17233283817768097,
0.3937634825706482,
0.18956325948238373,
-0.6939279437065125,
0.44058656692504883,
0.7428269386291504,
0.9605837464332581,
-0.3677493929862976,
-0.35241636633872986,
-0.4958898425102234,
-0.31113457679748535,
-0.41160333156585693,
0.9315539002418518,
-0.40035390853881836,
-0.33646437525749207,
0.08140745013952255,
0.06841692328453064,
-0.20085778832435608,
-1.1104387044906616,
0.7645677328109741,
-0.3226407468318939,
0.029981793835759163,
-0.5128281712532043,
-0.5160918831825256,
-0.18743740022182465,
0.3064711093902588,
-0.8294609785079956,
1.1634840965270996,
0.020058492198586464,
-0.43771615624427795,
0.25885602831840515,
-0.3632121682167053,
-0.32937121391296387,
0.15069431066513062,
-0.5072183609008789,
-0.3225407898426056,
0.2231650948524475,
0.27310407161712646,
0.4283424913883209,
-0.44076213240623474,
0.6540212035179138,
-0.15405140817165375,
-0.7123487591743469,
0.5932389497756958,
-0.6252826452255249,
0.48798462748527527,
-0.004459776449948549,
-0.5471211671829224,
0.013450058177113533,
-0.9722139239311218,
-0.2879411280155182,
0.1739765852689743,
0.19774991273880005,
-0.044922154396772385,
-0.17833682894706726,
-0.16115814447402954,
-0.01654345542192459,
0.27115705609321594,
-0.29977738857269287,
0.10743492096662521,
-0.22556078433990479,
-0.16524240374565125,
0.825351893901825,
-0.028954481706023216,
-0.20109760761260986,
-0.591650128364563,
0.42744874954223633,
-0.20460465550422668,
0.021066507324576378,
-0.0219881534576416,
-0.3366398513317108,
-0.6696586012840271,
-0.2887374758720398,
-0.012122421525418758,
0.5036161541938782,
-0.42620742321014404,
0.7163283228874207,
-0.4895419180393219,
-0.32545238733291626,
-0.5981227159500122,
0.1378585696220398,
0.2510702610015869,
0.74591064453125,
0.38627949357032776,
0.016900354996323586,
-0.5305610299110413,
-0.8944332599639893,
0.06459901481866837,
-0.2442840039730072,
-0.30112868547439575,
0.33689263463020325,
0.5265405774116516,
-0.262686163187027,
0.7087376117706299,
-0.5172063112258911,
-0.4870375692844391,
-0.13488081097602844,
0.10924310982227325,
0.49591076374053955,
-0.13435453176498413,
0.27664312720298767,
-0.6811321973800659,
-0.09865150600671768,
-0.23748597502708435,
-1.0186402797698975,
-0.3635559678077698,
-0.38617953658103943,
-0.07357453554868698,
0.2564478814601898,
0.13641901314258575,
-0.5948971509933472,
0.4160231649875641,
0.3082866668701172,
-0.37833502888679504,
0.7769652009010315,
0.10907574743032455,
0.2070130556821823,
-0.7969135642051697,
0.42840296030044556,
-0.17523789405822754,
0.025691654533147812,
-0.6012527346611023,
-0.2302103340625763,
-0.1636047512292862,
0.35631904006004333,
-0.21417100727558136,
0.4299524426460266,
-0.23402193188667297,
-0.3489059805870056,
-0.12811246514320374,
0.3843551278114319,
-0.22878636419773102,
0.43333351612091064,
0.08577200025320053,
0.9879525899887085,
0.5062776803970337,
-0.613334596157074,
0.6986255049705505,
0.568332850933075,
-0.6658800840377808,
0.5303981304168701,
-0.8444302082061768,
0.3330253064632416,
-0.06041330471634865,
0.008873587474226952,
-1.1163458824157715,
-0.5002322793006897,
0.38647833466529846,
-0.32887715101242065,
-0.0763489380478859,
0.3140031099319458,
-0.4946790039539337,
-0.2509380578994751,
-0.4587803781032562,
0.19439153373241425,
0.3672860860824585,
-0.7025046944618225,
0.4055221378803253,
0.08901408314704895,
0.0940437763929367,
-0.5856157541275024,
-0.700212836265564,
0.2588282823562622,
-0.32537946105003357,
-0.5169584155082703,
0.2920072376728058,
-0.3454623520374298,
-0.40990203619003296,
-0.2363826483488083,
-0.27381664514541626,
0.2065770924091339,
-0.03610452264547348,
0.47842395305633545,
0.2815166115760803,
-0.1402953416109085,
0.10413497686386108,
-0.28044015169143677,
-0.1591082364320755,
0.2790790796279907,
0.06485684961080551,
0.823032557964325,
-0.1859474778175354,
-0.5609191060066223,
-0.5480127930641174,
-0.12383630871772766,
0.5849974155426025,
0.19583038985729218,
0.6496367454528809,
0.3763848841190338,
-0.5128304362297058,
-0.034635476768016815,
-0.7634546756744385,
-0.25441133975982666,
-0.4485021233558655,
0.2779208719730377,
-0.5707908272743225,
-0.47303101420402527,
0.7854098677635193,
-0.09211748093366623,
-0.06265623867511749,
0.21755275130271912,
0.6326712965965271,
0.35157978534698486,
0.694932222366333,
0.1034519150853157,
-0.10778076201677322,
0.05373634025454521,
-0.19620290398597717,
0.008449018001556396,
-0.6187278628349304,
-0.5643753409385681,
-0.42022380232810974,
-0.2699415385723114,
-0.37180188298225403,
-0.2526717782020569,
0.29299798607826233,
-0.09946689009666443,
-0.15208275616168976,
0.12017619609832764,
-0.5268861055374146,
0.46093589067459106,
0.1983192265033722,
0.12188015878200531,
0.3442176580429077,
0.07177058607339859,
-0.10021457821130753,
-0.0762072280049324,
-0.33134397864341736,
-0.7098775506019592,
1.0870037078857422,
0.11247311532497406,
0.7559159398078918,
0.15727122128009796,
0.4722348153591156,
0.48370659351348877,
0.10053594410419464,
-0.7416415214538574,
0.8073606491088867,
0.02437039092183113,
-0.4252033829689026,
-0.4663287401199341,
-0.5064892172813416,
-0.8571891784667969,
0.06208605691790581,
0.09352882951498032,
-0.7267957925796509,
0.11055167764425278,
-0.289180189371109,
-0.4604117274284363,
0.024399327114224434,
-0.20046626031398773,
0.6488057374954224,
-0.41733309626579285,
-0.33982810378074646,
0.13004469871520996,
-0.6166244149208069,
0.5469668507575989,
-0.39029285311698914,
-0.1214529275894165,
-0.24154531955718994,
-0.003844261635094881,
0.6200636625289917,
-0.2240532785654068,
0.7962281107902527,
-0.09347868710756302,
-0.24449566006660461,
0.08978628367185593,
0.06379831582307816,
0.4467869699001312,
0.2572742700576782,
-0.4020194411277771,
0.4030233323574066,
-0.13028782606124878,
-0.07922321557998657,
-0.748454749584198,
0.7796209454536438,
-0.7331663370132446,
-0.5231279134750366,
-0.41568607091903687,
-0.38158178329467773,
-0.2919522821903229,
-0.08672144263982773,
0.2525939345359802,
0.5776607394218445,
-0.35526564717292786,
0.007439212407916784,
0.8446630835533142,
-0.3224124610424042,
0.22868968546390533,
0.46491989493370056,
-0.36310911178588867,
-0.5483452677726746,
0.7905612587928772,
0.0061185481026768684,
-0.05395082011818886,
0.1944526731967926,
0.06548725813627243,
-0.7253118753433228,
-0.44523313641548157,
-0.4519910216331482,
0.33950409293174744,
-0.7003477811813354,
-0.358097106218338,
-0.4950033128261566,
-0.299277126789093,
-0.47218844294548035,
0.16668443381786346,
-0.26673802733421326,
-0.24897179007530212,
-0.18841902911663055,
-0.2768123745918274,
0.37197643518447876,
0.908944845199585,
0.04369054362177849,
0.13108254969120026,
-0.31578630208969116,
0.7333770990371704,
0.21652604639530182,
0.4406092166900635,
-0.05415346473455429,
-0.7278156280517578,
0.14540235698223114,
0.039759282022714615,
-0.054221365600824356,
-0.9054431915283203,
0.242043137550354,
0.09209322184324265,
0.7427308559417725,
0.5536268949508667,
0.2774282991886139,
0.9037060737609863,
-0.1791609227657318,
0.8887062072753906,
-0.12229502946138382,
-0.7808641195297241,
0.5702841281890869,
0.04018070176243782,
0.13907013833522797,
0.8728318810462952,
0.4851134419441223,
-0.6484904289245605,
-0.15228329598903656,
-0.22781775891780853,
-0.6932955980300903,
0.6045697331428528,
0.2756926417350769,
-0.10117336362600327,
-0.10086429864168167,
0.5214941501617432,
0.4970394968986511,
0.11237786710262299,
-0.5301211476325989,
-0.514419436454773,
-0.007030638866126537,
-0.2772979736328125,
-0.04402626305818558,
-0.32685738801956177,
-0.22801633179187775,
-0.2658146321773529,
0.4424237012863159,
-0.11493891477584839,
0.3085534870624542,
0.2285638004541397,
-0.13208702206611633,
0.024861978366971016,
-0.0656633973121643,
0.7967888712882996,
0.9244256019592285,
-0.4006287455558777,
0.20740115642547607,
0.47804656624794006,
-0.5294373631477356,
0.15328256785869598,
0.1570262759923935,
-0.0900215432047844,
0.20244038105010986,
0.5875709056854248,
0.7300654053688049,
-0.22780969738960266,
-0.820148229598999,
0.49777576327323914,
-0.34169554710388184,
-0.34795910120010376,
-0.5791933536529541,
0.014551294036209583,
-0.2767374515533447,
0.051630131900310516,
0.47434812784194946,
-0.3079628050327301,
0.19984544813632965,
-0.209987610578537,
0.3687957525253296,
0.2336597591638565,
-0.27734196186065674,
-0.3284778594970703,
0.6130505800247192,
-0.14275245368480682,
-0.22698739171028137,
0.8184964060783386,
-0.1892576366662979,
-0.40862682461738586,
0.5870018005371094,
0.3477112352848053,
1.0908136367797852,
-0.19970986247062683,
0.3553420305252075,
0.4441588521003723,
0.42218002676963806,
-0.21933946013450623,
0.4346769154071808,
-0.02667391300201416,
-0.5888895392417908,
-0.1099688708782196,
-0.7031000852584839,
-0.2989833652973175,
0.6123740077018738,
-0.6176714301109314,
0.31508001685142517,
-0.30302053689956665,
-0.06616412103176117,
-0.37851256132125854,
0.199226513504982,
-0.5920895338058472,
0.060562651604413986,
0.2619536817073822,
0.8041291832923889,
-0.804483950138092,
0.49468204379081726,
0.6226998567581177,
-0.42830783128738403,
-0.36328285932540894,
0.32974013686180115,
0.14374323189258575,
-0.851945698261261,
0.4224338233470917,
0.5259432196617126,
-0.33692464232444763,
-0.3275314271450043,
-0.5169245600700378,
-0.6401441097259521,
1.227089524269104,
0.43335407972335815,
-0.7816349864006042,
0.27926087379455566,
0.7484897971153259,
0.591427206993103,
-0.25465118885040283,
0.4337194859981537,
0.9586798548698425,
0.681690514087677,
0.358535498380661,
-0.6453611254692078,
0.4859204590320587,
-0.08854233473539352,
-0.08950360119342804,
-0.14530277252197266,
-0.6025692224502563,
0.2899574637413025,
-0.08215157687664032,
-0.3703165352344513,
0.3688626289367676,
0.5458232164382935,
0.5431279540061951,
0.5924121737480164,
0.4867222309112549,
0.5679213404655457,
1.212103009223938,
-0.1648002713918686,
0.7949979305267334,
-0.4611261785030365,
-0.07319340854883194,
1.0946033000946045,
-0.56132972240448,
0.6487628221511841,
0.4336357116699219,
-0.13169758021831512,
0.2455737441778183,
0.7325194478034973,
-0.08866245299577713,
0.5539374351501465,
0.5356761813163757,
-0.26784756779670715,
-0.2320396602153778,
-0.2329668551683426,
-0.4590824842453003,
0.3070279359817505,
0.30249741673469543,
-0.0345795638859272,
-0.005287217907607555,
-0.1480240374803543,
-0.1918727457523346,
0.05818860977888107,
0.15859434008598328,
0.8037699460983276,
-0.04244410619139671,
-0.5582709312438965,
0.9730440378189087,
-0.40393704175949097,
0.5389269590377808,
-0.5996932983398438,
-0.1280086189508438,
-0.9435169696807861,
0.02624465711414814,
-0.24442017078399658,
-0.5854324698448181,
0.38549789786338806,
0.12497871369123459,
0.0885368213057518,
-0.04262900725007057,
0.4903966784477234,
-0.23457464575767517,
-0.4992412328720093,
0.28642526268959045,
0.4947013258934021,
0.6044533848762512,
-0.12986421585083008,
-0.49639102816581726,
0.40572598576545715,
-0.08187133818864822,
-0.388355016708374,
-0.009056773968040943,
0.5712368488311768,
0.09253357350826263,
0.7773557901382446,
0.39149224758148193,
0.22564519941806793,
0.030870085582137108,
0.4377790689468384,
0.8977876901626587,
-0.8267265558242798,
0.11317195743322372,
-0.88351970911026,
0.21336111426353455,
-0.18196606636047363,
-0.6188715696334839,
0.6495252847671509,
0.7172694802284241,
0.6744922399520874,
0.16613610088825226,
0.49502426385879517,
0.07893840968608856,
0.40538260340690613,
-0.6190922856330872,
0.5021876692771912,
-0.5723443627357483,
0.6887794733047485,
-0.1380729377269745,
-1.1458841562271118,
-0.3364485502243042,
0.5906678438186646,
-0.2537388503551483,
0.17211660742759705,
0.6939737796783447,
1.1776224374771118,
0.12139184772968292,
0.11485308408737183,
0.5718361139297485,
0.22665376961231232,
0.08533403277397156,
0.5409408807754517,
1.2841260433197021,
-0.34019923210144043,
0.46246767044067383,
-0.20712417364120483,
-0.17847825586795807,
-0.17981424927711487,
-0.6574218273162842,
-0.9642606377601624,
-0.6242939829826355,
-0.29440560936927795,
-0.2143176645040512,
0.25527647137641907,
0.8044238686561584,
0.3806803226470947,
-0.9456843137741089,
-0.3063633441925049,
-0.0918213278055191,
0.026509711518883705,
-0.21856443583965302,
-0.22609487175941467,
0.4892074465751648,
-0.329792857170105,
-0.5186073184013367,
0.5564137101173401,
0.08321534842252731,
-0.0339880995452404,
-0.41472384333610535,
-0.18091298639774323,
0.13355106115341187,
-0.017148436978459358,
0.2786673605442047,
-0.07317246496677399,
-0.8286202549934387,
-0.09679414331912994,
0.31162384152412415,
-0.18835163116455078,
-0.012591196224093437,
0.6634601354598999,
-0.9271736145019531,
0.1773100346326828,
0.27169832587242126,
0.7947928309440613,
0.20282471179962158,
0.18255430459976196,
0.2375488579273224,
-0.6712969541549683,
-0.1390751451253891,
0.1926170438528061,
0.12149778008460999,
0.4948391914367676,
-0.4893609583377838,
0.8050765991210938,
0.2456420212984085,
-0.5172227621078491,
-0.9321895241737366,
-0.025494463741779327,
-0.8587420582771301,
-0.289254367351532,
1.2932262420654297,
0.16900485754013062,
-0.09026066958904266,
-0.13415569067001343,
-0.19506770372390747,
0.09263496845960617,
-0.22811634838581085,
1.1962755918502808,
0.7685772776603699,
-0.29069051146507263,
0.09433351457118988,
-0.6219030022621155,
0.5017119646072388,
0.5621282458305359,
-0.8372902870178223,
0.5103511214256287,
0.8329058289527893,
-0.0745978131890297,
0.04836457222700119,
0.5068727135658264,
0.03465203568339348,
0.0027272049337625504,
0.05986082926392555,
-0.05761658027768135,
-0.09830239415168762,
-0.665917158126831,
-0.7489047646522522,
0.03982026129961014,
-0.12784019112586975,
-0.2475537359714508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09154v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09154v1
|
Diffusion Gaussian Mixture Audio Denoise
| 2024-06-13T14:18:10 | 2024-06-13T14:18:10 |
Pu Wang, Junhui Li, Jialu Li, Liangdong Guo, Youshan Zhang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Recent diffusion models have achieved promising performances in
audio-denoising tasks. The unique property of the reverse process could recover
clean signals. However, the distribution of real-world noises does not comply
with a single Gaussian distribution and is even unknown. The sampling of
Gaussian noise conditions limits its application scenarios. To overcome these
challenges, we propose a DiffGMM model, a denoising model based on the
diffusion and Gaussian mixture models. We employ the reverse process to
estimate parameters for the Gaussian mixture model. Given a noisy audio signal,
we first apply a 1D-U-Net to extract features and train linear layers to
estimate parameters for the Gaussian mixture model, and we approximate the real
noise distributions. The noisy signal is continuously subtracted from the
estimated noise to output clean audio signals. Extensive experimental results
demonstrate that the proposed DiffGMM model achieves state-of-the-art
performance.
|
[
-0.6683812141418457,
-1.056281328201294,
0.4139173924922943,
0.1341954618692398,
-0.3325364887714386,
-0.11692449450492859,
0.21698340773582458,
-0.3423513174057007,
0.3222857415676117,
0.4968408942222595,
-0.8353338241577148,
-0.4490825831890106,
-0.7615060806274414,
-0.36502721905708313,
-0.858331561088562,
0.409162312746048,
0.47057217359542847,
0.31181061267852783,
0.18950653076171875,
0.027002112939953804,
-0.5318577289581299,
-0.3904043138027191,
-0.7975526452064514,
-0.5358609557151794,
-0.1311650276184082,
-0.07678159326314926,
0.4513044059276581,
0.040537990629673004,
0.09858673810958862,
0.2360438108444214,
-0.49667978286743164,
-0.2354542762041092,
-0.4700526297092438,
0.09153749793767929,
0.22481682896614075,
-0.22672666609287262,
-0.4360262155532837,
0.36067360639572144,
0.5637892484664917,
0.8771629929542542,
-0.6726177930831909,
-0.15933068096637726,
-0.21574492752552032,
0.42173466086387634,
-0.46111300587654114,
-0.4221722483634949,
-0.17752745747566223,
0.2616965174674988,
0.3695065975189209,
-0.0957598015666008,
0.03192417696118355,
-0.38521507382392883,
-0.04355308413505554,
-0.48220834136009216,
0.43359947204589844,
-0.36207130551338196,
0.5032880306243896,
0.2227223515510559,
0.05970422551035881,
-0.09669387340545654,
-1.315234661102295,
0.805796205997467,
-1.057871699333191,
0.4838384687900543,
0.5506371259689331,
0.39872482419013977,
-0.28938016295433044,
-0.6290668249130249,
-0.6282432079315186,
-0.04086437448859215,
0.4280872941017151,
0.38886362314224243,
-0.166859969496727,
-0.07687834650278091,
0.028418593108654022,
0.7317904829978943,
-0.21247148513793945,
0.007308328524231911,
-0.36750856041908264,
0.0011589517816901207,
0.48589402437210083,
0.058775343000888824,
0.3242858052253723,
0.5830355286598206,
-0.5098589062690735,
0.29722023010253906,
-0.28025850653648376,
-0.46271198987960815,
0.6278854608535767,
-0.22991251945495605,
-0.17131072282791138,
-0.07579566538333893,
-0.25224408507347107,
0.5451750159263611,
0.19722047448158264,
-0.609771192073822,
0.06965459138154984,
-0.24623683094978333,
-0.3864293098449707,
0.09845361858606339,
0.2321101427078247,
0.2525782287120819,
-0.23167723417282104,
-0.16355903446674347,
-0.46596962213516235,
0.03436363860964775,
0.20201730728149414,
-0.9374655485153198,
-0.5479716062545776,
0.3666909635066986,
-0.5037750601768494,
-0.3107356131076813,
-0.030342454090714455,
-0.8718250393867493,
-0.3514127731323242,
-0.4249463677406311,
0.8639551401138306,
-0.11956841498613358,
-0.8924822807312012,
0.5394185781478882,
-0.4211167097091675,
-0.1763858199119568,
0.4359387457370758,
-0.8192513585090637,
0.7487133741378784,
0.3759520649909973,
0.905290961265564,
-0.0040312171913683414,
0.3288295865058899,
-0.25430798530578613,
0.13742688298225403,
-0.2804703712463379,
0.43422171473503113,
-0.5560168027877808,
-0.7226833701133728,
-0.4917837381362915,
-0.29962781071662903,
0.15377651154994965,
-0.925391674041748,
0.35450467467308044,
-0.5601469278335571,
0.23324979841709137,
0.04963109642267227,
-0.6051074266433716,
-0.4895656704902649,
-0.1464078724384308,
-0.5703251361846924,
0.876442015171051,
0.15601535141468048,
-0.5864529013633728,
0.5433372259140015,
-0.567945122718811,
-0.12792524695396423,
-0.12433847784996033,
0.29043886065483093,
-0.635251522064209,
0.1090877503156662,
0.0026119265239685774,
0.23393306136131287,
-0.033434681594371796,
0.04357807710766792,
-0.6306777000427246,
-0.6767534017562866,
-0.12102048099040985,
-0.7165213227272034,
0.9565203189849854,
0.5346739292144775,
-0.020272722467780113,
-0.17909687757492065,
-1.0090702772140503,
-0.6812305450439453,
-0.08071114867925644,
-0.397387832403183,
-0.5439498424530029,
0.021746201440691948,
-0.0780184343457222,
0.3778732120990753,
-0.30519193410873413,
-0.4898815155029297,
-0.153084859251976,
-0.09106265008449554,
0.7104558944702148,
0.41149428486824036,
0.48103106021881104,
0.7464687824249268,
-0.4979165494441986,
0.6575332283973694,
0.44644126296043396,
-0.043618958443403244,
0.3789578378200531,
-0.6139464974403381,
-0.2159477025270462,
-0.9127629995346069,
0.2894330322742462,
0.4912358522415161,
0.2987591624259949,
0.3582777976989746,
0.32336968183517456,
-0.5131350159645081,
-0.42494651675224304,
0.21519383788108826,
-0.29395928978919983,
0.8327251076698303,
0.39755120873451233,
-0.7029533386230469,
-0.536780834197998,
-0.43021538853645325,
0.34323620796203613,
0.1969986855983734,
-0.27339354157447815,
0.034054335206747055,
0.20970004796981812,
-0.4168318510055542,
0.7158967852592468,
-0.4307701587677002,
-0.1833810657262802,
0.034989237785339355,
0.30328813195228577,
0.354536771774292,
0.7250475287437439,
0.35117897391319275,
-0.8188393115997314,
0.02404208667576313,
-0.47633466124534607,
-0.38308438658714294,
-0.2586477994918823,
0.02453767880797386,
-0.05615070462226868,
-0.463886022567749,
0.6615548133850098,
-0.25755947828292847,
0.562963604927063,
0.5470970869064331,
0.05130835622549057,
0.5049273371696472,
-0.35194385051727295,
0.09728410840034485,
-0.8853572607040405,
-0.08604010939598083,
0.4557875096797943,
-0.36809325218200684,
-0.9281406998634338,
-0.19807356595993042,
-0.46288055181503296,
0.020949406549334526,
-0.4045200049877167,
0.22515900433063507,
-0.41524913907051086,
-0.12709476053714752,
-0.4524601399898529,
0.16166047751903534,
0.2746136784553528,
0.27845194935798645,
0.19892518222332,
0.5188366174697876,
0.7015414834022522,
-0.8750788569450378,
0.09195979684591293,
-0.03152716904878616,
-0.266223669052124,
0.7895685434341431,
-0.5189328789710999,
-0.09797154366970062,
-0.3116554021835327,
0.26446112990379333,
-1.4736406803131104,
0.4081105589866638,
0.3092663884162903,
-0.04985107481479645,
0.4002866744995117,
-0.4468737840652466,
-0.14165586233139038,
-0.0591789148747921,
-0.1656011939048767,
0.46584099531173706,
0.7831235527992249,
-0.4039722979068756,
0.4421181082725525,
0.6052061915397644,
-0.4036954641342163,
-0.08166662603616714,
-0.7320231199264526,
-0.18064679205417633,
-0.7096583843231201,
-0.5318943858146667,
0.10486262291669846,
0.029772616922855377,
-0.3010173738002777,
-0.13237090408802032,
-0.36702269315719604,
-0.6352747082710266,
0.280073881149292,
0.33064159750938416,
0.11158949136734009,
-0.06540937721729279,
-0.16102153062820435,
0.2082853615283966,
-0.029547791928052902,
0.09150145947933197,
-0.2870320975780487,
0.33296942710876465,
0.6485154628753662,
-0.3405072093009949,
-0.30837321281433105,
0.5755685567855835,
0.2672136723995209,
0.1978641003370285,
0.2393123060464859,
0.9513236284255981,
-0.41068804264068604,
-0.18778406083583832,
-0.5558837056159973,
-0.4445993900299072,
-0.4440048038959503,
0.39279016852378845,
-0.20547237992286682,
-0.4088769257068634,
0.7845524549484253,
-0.4137778580188751,
0.052088648080825806,
0.12648557126522064,
0.35270747542381287,
-0.30267271399497986,
1.026536464691162,
0.2917287349700928,
-0.03056936338543892,
0.5268974900245667,
-0.59425288438797,
0.1301005482673645,
-0.7400962114334106,
-0.015452618710696697,
-0.3084767460823059,
-0.5018558502197266,
-0.09910986572504044,
-0.3094500005245209,
0.3372586965560913,
0.4940454363822937,
0.1440778225660324,
0.043286778032779694,
-0.3363492488861084,
0.19943107664585114,
0.9497283697128296,
0.3425329029560089,
0.5499703884124756,
0.22660833597183228,
-0.07283281534910202,
0.27636781334877014,
-0.6143406629562378,
-0.3777114450931549,
0.5017781257629395,
0.3746189773082733,
0.9661627411842346,
0.06243225559592247,
0.7485477328300476,
0.5768812298774719,
-0.0593426376581192,
-0.22886450588703156,
0.40968334674835205,
0.020855721086263657,
-0.6979881525039673,
-0.39021262526512146,
-0.2601510286331177,
-0.7514386177062988,
0.5926942229270935,
-0.2034878432750702,
-0.504760205745697,
0.5655132532119751,
-0.12290870398283005,
-0.287752240896225,
0.5236700177192688,
-0.5922920107841492,
0.30519911646842957,
0.6229591369628906,
-0.04613079875707626,
-0.41004353761672974,
-0.4539834260940552,
0.635491132736206,
-0.06906116753816605,
0.5685638189315796,
-0.24016591906547546,
0.3044293522834778,
0.8005085587501526,
-0.2926326096057892,
0.6405072212219238,
-0.8030038475990295,
-0.3334880471229553,
0.5559495687484741,
0.2654258608818054,
0.09570188820362091,
0.31191152334213257,
0.09517119824886322,
0.3003278374671936,
0.2334173172712326,
-0.4120158553123474,
-0.37458619475364685,
0.6429498195648193,
-0.6481257081031799,
-0.5007212162017822,
0.19406521320343018,
-0.5869096517562866,
-0.13800719380378723,
0.038248829543590546,
0.2242220938205719,
0.49220162630081177,
-0.25232481956481934,
-0.3530990481376648,
0.6942059993743896,
-0.0006809786427766085,
0.6824620962142944,
0.42310866713523865,
-0.2794988751411438,
-0.23903921246528625,
0.7807847857475281,
0.2835473418235779,
0.5665454268455505,
0.006751577835530043,
0.1663973033428192,
-0.35219821333885193,
-0.9789031147956848,
-0.19922393560409546,
-0.08319174498319626,
-0.6081975102424622,
0.3845985233783722,
-0.6594168543815613,
-0.03702222555875778,
-0.2739045321941376,
0.13697093725204468,
-0.25789299607276917,
-0.6873981952667236,
-0.4960596561431885,
-0.15915881097316742,
-0.008264334872364998,
0.52942955493927,
-0.5858215093612671,
0.3358054459095001,
-0.5640879273414612,
0.8681595325469971,
0.5948408842086792,
0.25731948018074036,
0.06212351471185684,
-0.9307571053504944,
-0.18210875988006592,
0.4964722990989685,
-0.27085936069488525,
-0.856910765171051,
0.6348714828491211,
-0.007183449808508158,
0.830122172832489,
0.528862476348877,
-0.07735724747180939,
0.585456371307373,
-0.08777615427970886,
0.7461777329444885,
0.18367376923561096,
-0.43650802969932556,
0.18363448977470398,
-0.0652947798371315,
0.000024697757908143103,
0.2717744708061218,
0.051799971610307693,
-0.36263856291770935,
-0.48591575026512146,
-0.535346508026123,
-0.6409132480621338,
0.32608234882354736,
0.06104637309908867,
-0.12417110800743103,
0.023633472621440887,
0.06719958037137985,
0.25727328658103943,
0.32471051812171936,
-0.24087724089622498,
-0.3225267827510834,
-0.4392763376235962,
0.17391330003738403,
0.018661487847566605,
-0.2858359217643738,
-0.3955950140953064,
-0.36302533745765686,
0.7003737092018127,
0.5980119109153748,
0.39610207080841064,
0.2907668650150299,
-0.17017695307731628,
-0.15783920884132385,
0.23186415433883667,
0.9528871178627014,
0.35300412774086,
-0.6313942074775696,
0.12737557291984558,
0.11882171034812927,
-0.6469061970710754,
0.7119425535202026,
-0.09823637455701828,
-0.38628262281417847,
0.27147912979125977,
-0.27377504110336304,
0.3770429491996765,
0.04288674518465996,
-0.12499993294477463,
0.38862764835357666,
0.03534374758601189,
-0.5498908758163452,
-0.3565445840358734,
0.29543083906173706,
0.41329148411750793,
0.15554581582546234,
0.5571227073669434,
0.27239492535591125,
0.7224976420402527,
-0.19047975540161133,
0.20615409314632416,
0.38676807284355164,
-0.4219924211502075,
-0.40106794238090515,
0.9469978213310242,
0.12166391313076019,
-0.22635728120803833,
0.45434263348579407,
-0.27771541476249695,
0.09158242493867874,
0.5247617363929749,
0.4413287043571472,
0.9640531539916992,
-0.11951644718647003,
0.04523014649748802,
0.062276970595121384,
-0.10984322428703308,
-0.34523043036460876,
0.31615307927131653,
-0.2037782520055771,
-0.5930835604667664,
-0.41266658902168274,
-0.6720243692398071,
-0.4373743236064911,
0.23000891506671906,
-0.6013096570968628,
-0.01326491218060255,
-0.49977487325668335,
-0.19266130030155182,
-0.19542816281318665,
-0.14277420938014984,
-0.2668200433254242,
0.5647006034851074,
0.05832713097333908,
0.6756204962730408,
-1.0786579847335815,
0.8253846764564514,
0.055564556270837784,
-0.31868278980255127,
-0.2208789736032486,
-0.423618346452713,
-0.044812995940446854,
-0.505628228187561,
0.18640188872814178,
-0.33893126249313354,
-0.23367208242416382,
0.06369128823280334,
-0.4548676311969757,
-0.41420209407806396,
0.9963266253471375,
0.2909604609012604,
-0.6906347870826721,
0.2687029242515564,
-0.12901516258716583,
0.18479923903942108,
-0.26678550243377686,
0.13171769678592682,
0.5279181003570557,
0.5406975746154785,
0.3332827389240265,
-0.3146039545536041,
-0.2973339259624481,
-0.010707867331802845,
-0.0895647332072258,
0.12651708722114563,
-0.22298839688301086,
0.8450912833213806,
-0.23858779668807983,
-0.2829212248325348,
0.02583756297826767,
0.28384774923324585,
0.24333344399929047,
0.46851015090942383,
0.8847112655639648,
0.9518852233886719,
0.439334899187088,
0.07757974416017532,
0.48316389322280884,
-0.096184641122818,
0.28648898005485535,
0.9657737016677856,
-0.13039419054985046,
0.38152533769607544,
0.7706289887428284,
-0.4680299758911133,
0.32579079270362854,
0.5607174038887024,
0.06244107708334923,
1.0089069604873657,
0.2244608998298645,
-0.5985970497131348,
-0.17146797478199005,
0.42511966824531555,
-0.49456968903541565,
0.0015371046029031277,
0.11990506947040558,
-0.2312113642692566,
-0.3805803060531616,
0.021972114220261574,
-0.4159929156303406,
-0.03859417140483856,
-0.3211611807346344,
0.8573427796363831,
0.04150133207440376,
0.10231944173574448,
0.3425028324127197,
0.025409260764718056,
0.930508553981781,
-0.07284527271986008,
-0.2788417935371399,
-0.5034791827201843,
-0.20413963496685028,
-0.17002536356449127,
-0.12069792300462723,
0.3997941017150879,
-0.580082356929779,
-0.35062307119369507,
0.021851815283298492,
0.5797058343887329,
-0.6638751029968262,
-0.4268210530281067,
0.23192991316318512,
0.2351471334695816,
0.32326850295066833,
-0.18310901522636414,
-0.29111137986183167,
-0.25371628999710083,
-0.3894559442996979,
-0.1795457899570465,
0.5446841716766357,
0.20657888054847717,
0.4685854911804199,
0.5264841318130493,
0.660863995552063,
0.4061906039714813,
0.5641076564788818,
0.2614051401615143,
0.34389472007751465,
-0.3760136663913727,
-0.740079402923584,
-0.6427556872367859,
0.3977581858634949,
0.032662127166986465,
0.0028896541334688663,
0.38430535793304443,
0.3862721621990204,
0.5029849410057068,
-0.16851374506950378,
0.6953755021095276,
0.47672387957572937,
0.7709911465644836,
-0.3998873829841614,
0.48753130435943604,
-0.29588139057159424,
0.6336673498153687,
-0.504859447479248,
-0.9282776713371277,
0.0017727331724017859,
0.604674220085144,
0.09699530154466629,
0.30764153599739075,
-0.16516785323619843,
1.0948983430862427,
-0.4642385244369507,
0.250266432762146,
0.7189359664916992,
0.06464226543903351,
0.330157607793808,
0.2581556737422943,
0.7969032526016235,
-0.4862770736217499,
0.2210366427898407,
-0.6410735249519348,
-0.12945453822612762,
-0.1502409428358078,
-0.6382999420166016,
-0.3303762674331665,
-0.2643055021762848,
-0.6745391488075256,
-0.12933224439620972,
-0.06734157353639603,
0.2652473747730255,
1.1747339963912964,
-0.7419450283050537,
-0.14426545798778534,
-0.48222073912620544,
0.12247007340192795,
-0.7993989586830139,
-0.22628042101860046,
-0.1687827855348587,
0.10100781172513962,
-0.8356001377105713,
0.5767382383346558,
0.4319113790988922,
0.3974444270133972,
-0.5759331583976746,
-0.20175457000732422,
-0.40613192319869995,
0.3932328522205353,
0.22456572949886322,
0.19224610924720764,
-0.5791351199150085,
-0.13569019734859467,
-0.5376879572868347,
-0.04603904113173485,
0.16423752903938293,
0.3866591453552246,
-0.3958548903465271,
0.5198042392730713,
0.542902946472168,
-0.07791610807180405,
0.9523598551750183,
0.12636059522628784,
0.34061679244041443,
-0.5931355953216553,
0.39998888969421387,
0.18088048696517944,
0.39521804451942444,
-0.013577327132225037,
-0.014139823615550995,
0.3090851902961731,
0.44044551253318787,
-0.466207355260849,
-0.7102656364440918,
-0.031949978321790695,
-1.031644344329834,
-0.5429956316947937,
1.0224469900131226,
-0.1617298275232315,
0.31814658641815186,
-0.6124494671821594,
-0.18947768211364746,
0.32157737016677856,
-0.3195369243621826,
0.8617207407951355,
0.5681406259536743,
0.04512115567922592,
-0.20737731456756592,
-0.37046608328819275,
0.08782839775085449,
0.12147030234336853,
-0.06680002063512802,
-0.22319714725017548,
0.5422856211662292,
0.7825659513473511,
-0.0058465986512601376,
0.8561751842498779,
-0.3011171817779541,
0.29370561242103577,
0.364408403635025,
-0.004064028151333332,
-0.23232489824295044,
-0.11056025326251984,
-0.6710481643676758,
0.6892083287239075,
-0.10605918616056442,
-0.5380986928939819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09153v1
|
LASER: Learning by Aligning Self-supervised Representations of Speech for Improving Content-related Tasks
| 2024-06-13T14:17:47 | 2024-06-13T14:17:47 |
Amit Meghanani, Thomas Hain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Self-supervised learning (SSL)-based speech models are extensively used for
full-stack speech processing. However, it has been observed that improving
SSL-based speech representations using unlabeled speech for content-related
tasks is challenging and computationally expensive. Recent attempts have been
made to address this issue with cost-effective self-supervised fine-tuning
(SSFT) approaches. Continuing in this direction, a cost-effective SSFT method
named "LASER: Learning by Aligning Self-supervised Representations" is
presented. LASER is based on the soft-DTW alignment loss with temporal
regularisation term. Experiments are conducted with HuBERT and WavLM models and
evaluated on the SUPERB benchmark for two content-related tasks: automatic
speech recognition (ASR) and phoneme recognition (PR). A relative improvement
of 3.7% and 8.2% for HuBERT, and 4.1% and 11.7% for WavLM are observed, for the
ASR and PR tasks respectively, with only < 3 hours of fine-tuning on a single
GPU.
|
[
-0.19977237284183502,
-0.5306312441825867,
0.24947397410869598,
0.04721446335315704,
-0.3865257799625397,
0.03593863919377327,
-0.2920454442501068,
-0.30066511034965515,
-0.1455850601196289,
0.5402573943138123,
-0.8894521594047546,
-0.5186524987220764,
-0.1376628279685974,
-0.057255133986473083,
-0.27500611543655396,
0.7522389888763428,
0.2512069344520569,
0.3450559973716736,
0.15915027260780334,
-0.016845712438225746,
-0.5021660923957825,
-0.34464314579963684,
-0.7674610614776611,
-0.3801129460334778,
0.5257856845855713,
0.2166597992181778,
0.4302036166191101,
1.1822980642318726,
0.6317446827888489,
0.2762734889984131,
0.015683548524975777,
0.2238648384809494,
-0.2757680118083954,
0.032563820481300354,
-0.2761373519897461,
-0.024081870913505554,
-0.15136204659938812,
-0.08981745690107346,
0.714816153049469,
0.8952896595001221,
-0.4402499496936798,
0.19079138338565826,
0.330260306596756,
1.069186806678772,
-0.6700038313865662,
0.03204973787069321,
-0.6686742901802063,
0.2626531720161438,
-0.20147596299648285,
-0.2971743047237396,
-0.261271208524704,
0.008583669550716877,
0.0396067351102829,
-0.6339694857597351,
0.430387407541275,
-0.24814528226852417,
0.6260538101196289,
1.0093039274215698,
-0.18519090116024017,
-0.17966382205486298,
-0.8817698955535889,
0.9337707757949829,
-0.6851037740707397,
0.9345653653144836,
0.15515507757663727,
0.16759344935417175,
0.08312170207500458,
-0.3947761356830597,
-0.07871262729167938,
-0.04425520449876785,
0.11622143536806107,
0.481412410736084,
0.05553315579891205,
0.253150075674057,
0.1892748773097992,
0.20703968405723572,
-0.6518334746360779,
0.3327472507953644,
-0.2878478169441223,
-0.23437194526195526,
0.7867493033409119,
0.07337821274995804,
-0.04256803169846535,
-0.024912778288125992,
-0.446936696767807,
-0.15371140837669373,
-0.5324029922485352,
0.102455273270607,
0.35171782970428467,
0.7132558822631836,
0.028779219835996628,
0.36875173449516296,
-0.20599018037319183,
0.9187017679214478,
0.4404004216194153,
-0.34653037786483765,
0.057893235236406326,
-0.5200181007385254,
-0.3068181574344635,
0.7208137512207031,
0.590407133102417,
0.02961879037320614,
0.16243913769721985,
-0.2568497657775879,
-0.17324349284172058,
-0.08522762358188629,
0.33202269673347473,
-0.6255114078521729,
-0.3166535794734955,
0.11131194233894348,
-0.3105965852737427,
0.13411757349967957,
-0.11282017827033997,
-0.2771320044994354,
-0.2283816784620285,
-0.5207811594009399,
0.5144667029380798,
-0.3564645051956177,
-0.12255978584289551,
0.05765729397535324,
0.05843810364603996,
0.017023297026753426,
0.3385363519191742,
-1.2806199789047241,
0.18699216842651367,
0.5500427484512329,
0.7210456728935242,
-0.20937028527259827,
-0.12803620100021362,
-0.5913835763931274,
0.5763898491859436,
-0.6483513116836548,
0.6035757660865784,
-0.0979723408818245,
-0.5353597402572632,
-0.11233002692461014,
-0.1554420441389084,
0.004018973093479872,
-0.6565918326377869,
0.6244966983795166,
-0.251595139503479,
0.22939112782478333,
0.09786567836999893,
-0.9446362853050232,
0.1761993169784546,
-0.4337924122810364,
-0.5573342442512512,
0.9930710792541504,
-0.06363134831190109,
-0.37953272461891174,
0.29601410031318665,
-0.4145072400569916,
-0.5164504051208496,
0.1566026657819748,
-0.07987751811742783,
-0.6996813416481018,
0.10299527645111084,
0.2541309595108032,
0.44599664211273193,
0.063350148499012,
0.30430471897125244,
-0.10003712773323059,
-0.5302426218986511,
0.09496143460273743,
-0.4032217264175415,
0.7651162147521973,
0.3984156548976898,
-0.6236690282821655,
0.07873276621103287,
-0.799613893032074,
-0.0894368514418602,
-0.18072226643562317,
-0.3186090290546417,
-0.2128780484199524,
0.16130170226097107,
-0.18414291739463806,
-0.04482809454202652,
0.5602108240127563,
-0.7913070321083069,
-0.01608983613550663,
-0.7841401100158691,
0.2505391538143158,
0.6897058486938477,
-0.36542463302612305,
0.6053324937820435,
-0.09799468517303467,
-0.11642315238714218,
-0.03888007253408432,
0.2830892503261566,
0.00914057344198227,
-0.0522487536072731,
-0.5337046384811401,
-0.06291186809539795,
0.4487847685813904,
0.38260146975517273,
-0.528689980506897,
0.4913557171821594,
-0.04628400504589081,
-0.6884164214134216,
-0.8438531160354614,
0.6022694110870361,
0.6143966317176819,
0.8516579866409302,
0.6484442353248596,
-0.1580248326063156,
-0.4415026605129242,
-0.801218569278717,
-0.06174273043870926,
-0.012360598891973495,
-0.22952669858932495,
0.2312164604663849,
-0.22731232643127441,
0.18551446497440338,
0.81973797082901,
-0.24156181514263153,
-0.975934624671936,
0.42193686962127686,
0.2498559206724167,
0.10255321860313416,
0.7691742181777954,
0.15454789996147156,
-0.794174313545227,
-0.6876145601272583,
-0.0468779131770134,
-0.5208900570869446,
-0.20358119904994965,
-0.10917811840772629,
0.41684040427207947,
0.6620790362358093,
0.543147087097168,
-0.19332255423069,
0.1997089982032776,
0.7049587965011597,
-0.09819093346595764,
0.3075856566429138,
-0.5020122528076172,
0.028372948989272118,
-0.593661367893219,
-0.2926558554172516,
0.20472250878810883,
-0.09815751761198044,
-0.6832874417304993,
-0.486806720495224,
0.2439328283071518,
-0.3172999918460846,
-0.6148703098297119,
0.3248617947101593,
-0.5053063035011292,
-0.3218837380409241,
-0.5541572570800781,
0.28648948669433594,
-0.07820345461368561,
0.6926414966583252,
0.30698561668395996,
1.1413092613220215,
0.5328980088233948,
-0.4911626875400543,
0.23504115641117096,
-0.10467030853033066,
-0.2252328097820282,
0.30688610672950745,
-0.5477339029312134,
0.22347764670848846,
0.10034141689538956,
-0.0725424587726593,
-0.935137927532196,
0.19024984538555145,
0.08245757967233658,
-0.3974239230155945,
0.42909911274909973,
-0.13871820271015167,
-0.3805884122848511,
0.05356191471219063,
0.016774751245975494,
0.1344592124223709,
0.5705617666244507,
-0.7184903621673584,
0.6569457054138184,
0.4010467231273651,
-0.029660426080226898,
-0.5972711443901062,
-0.6589233875274658,
-0.21547536551952362,
-0.13552066683769226,
-0.3985796272754669,
0.9008375406265259,
0.015847260132431984,
0.09423357993364334,
0.1774292290210724,
-0.4356045424938202,
-0.22176848351955414,
0.14185211062431335,
0.23965823650360107,
0.14281103014945984,
-0.3044831454753876,
0.4942910373210907,
0.04439390450716019,
-0.26958730816841125,
-0.15896281599998474,
-0.43138575553894043,
0.36000382900238037,
-0.11858712881803513,
-0.3892442286014557,
-0.8398094177246094,
0.2746812701225281,
-0.09161147475242615,
-0.42019176483154297,
0.3621576428413391,
0.8701578378677368,
-0.28058385848999023,
-0.28099629282951355,
-0.7249959111213684,
-0.24936826527118683,
-0.5808471441268921,
0.15270264446735382,
-0.22754032909870148,
-0.9787598848342896,
0.2427537888288498,
0.07909248769283295,
0.19254374504089355,
0.5087729096412659,
0.33148282766342163,
-0.7303144335746765,
1.330397605895996,
0.38138219714164734,
0.03442920371890068,
0.7562860250473022,
-0.07112249732017517,
-0.06873608380556107,
-0.6744937300682068,
-0.08733939379453659,
-0.5568793416023254,
0.040430691093206406,
-0.4639616012573242,
-0.19445359706878662,
0.25858068466186523,
0.04448319226503372,
-0.3533608317375183,
0.3220759630203247,
-0.9202311038970947,
0.21317940950393677,
0.6965395212173462,
0.3144267499446869,
0.24540282785892487,
0.10837533324956894,
0.28953254222869873,
-0.2642577886581421,
-0.7396329641342163,
-0.22291775047779083,
0.7758362293243408,
0.13967545330524445,
0.8909056782722473,
-0.038645628839731216,
0.9130403995513916,
0.4153066575527191,
-0.22232188284397125,
-0.6892006397247314,
0.4271754324436188,
-0.8379406332969666,
-0.5836933255195618,
-0.9424737095832825,
-0.5051797032356262,
-0.9502121806144714,
0.012663056142628193,
-0.2286648154258728,
-0.452632337808609,
0.007205288857221603,
0.35952991247177124,
-0.5498577356338501,
0.19689081609249115,
-0.5997427105903625,
0.7012462615966797,
-0.4633713662624359,
-0.4640670716762543,
-0.5699974298477173,
-0.5095528364181519,
-0.20931504666805267,
-0.2212962955236435,
0.04494752362370491,
-0.4195145070552826,
-0.06381501257419586,
0.9103685617446899,
-0.10488501191139221,
0.7994853854179382,
-0.5547299385070801,
-0.3185083866119385,
0.29295632243156433,
-0.205076664686203,
0.09671121835708618,
-0.282369464635849,
-0.09795369952917099,
0.2227541208267212,
0.07702754437923431,
-0.1532200425863266,
-0.9237825274467468,
0.6210875511169434,
-0.6704128980636597,
-0.815596878528595,
-0.14222067594528198,
-0.5634959936141968,
-0.3319086730480194,
0.10109274834394455,
-0.08022312819957733,
0.8375339508056641,
0.15432284772396088,
0.37064602971076965,
0.9211310744285583,
0.043108053505420685,
0.6405491232872009,
0.7366539835929871,
0.07381532341241837,
-0.3937077224254608,
1.1731417179107666,
0.501740574836731,
0.1025247797369957,
0.4250025749206543,
0.3413711190223694,
-0.6877102255821228,
-0.7549746036529541,
-0.48284435272216797,
0.12951748073101044,
-0.45912203192710876,
-0.2944919466972351,
-0.16229267418384552,
-0.3958938419818878,
-0.6156668663024902,
-0.18872997164726257,
-0.7889390587806702,
-0.31544923782348633,
-0.7915408611297607,
0.23461110889911652,
0.08005894720554352,
0.337658166885376,
-0.344107061624527,
0.526954174041748,
-0.7406405806541443,
0.29482749104499817,
0.5162086486816406,
0.4127132296562195,
-0.23780889809131622,
-0.6991291046142578,
-0.5004761815071106,
0.1878126561641693,
-0.21585899591445923,
-0.6948418021202087,
0.3697012662887573,
0.49501892924308777,
0.5801019668579102,
0.4250476360321045,
0.19342151284217834,
0.9490658044815063,
-0.6955575346946716,
0.6865864992141724,
0.34707313776016235,
-1.1928585767745972,
0.7783679962158203,
-0.18053586781024933,
0.300913542509079,
0.6344785094261169,
0.21990375220775604,
-0.1501113623380661,
-0.27329179644584656,
-0.5071550011634827,
-0.3563360571861267,
0.6898240447044373,
-0.050623569637537,
0.07415053993463516,
0.32219401001930237,
0.35683560371398926,
-0.06325162202119827,
-0.23662026226520538,
-0.4486812353134155,
-0.3876532316207886,
-0.3808286488056183,
-0.44561290740966797,
-0.16174408793449402,
-0.05470551550388336,
-0.03442574292421341,
-0.32143574953079224,
0.8955843448638916,
-0.29070422053337097,
0.1475520133972168,
0.4584079384803772,
-0.05409597232937813,
-0.19856958091259003,
0.1607651710510254,
0.4794860780239105,
0.4532671868801117,
-0.3703644573688507,
0.08993770182132721,
0.3220234513282776,
-0.06360390037298203,
0.1729244738817215,
0.2751738429069519,
-0.010407998226583004,
0.13020114600658417,
0.13755778968334198,
0.6793791651725769,
0.5021051168441772,
-0.6690925359725952,
0.38787350058555603,
0.16718080639839172,
-0.35507744550704956,
-0.26045334339141846,
0.30887308716773987,
0.2000519037246704,
0.3790232539176941,
0.5599799752235413,
-0.32581663131713867,
0.38864946365356445,
-0.25068238377571106,
0.38938993215560913,
0.5456003546714783,
-0.8594508171081543,
0.20958960056304932,
0.7768381834030151,
0.18722963333129883,
-0.40671446919441223,
0.5293229818344116,
0.123923659324646,
-0.17969897389411926,
0.5013884902000427,
0.6850408911705017,
0.724427342414856,
-0.583469808101654,
0.1752028614282608,
0.37604811787605286,
-0.04047972336411476,
0.16847079992294312,
0.07622788101434708,
-0.5105764269828796,
-0.5763009786605835,
-0.6175477504730225,
-0.5914080142974854,
-0.6067564487457275,
-0.4126869738101959,
-0.766120195388794,
0.0770416408777237,
-0.36631467938423157,
-0.2537126839160919,
0.30401021242141724,
0.4300838112831116,
-0.322155237197876,
0.4333907961845398,
0.4632868468761444,
0.612880527973175,
-0.5240194797515869,
1.3227949142456055,
0.2290324866771698,
-0.08033594489097595,
-1.0151300430297852,
-0.3377974331378937,
-0.12452748417854309,
-0.7097913026809692,
0.9521480202674866,
0.06082785129547119,
-0.5673180818557739,
0.35631170868873596,
-0.30626213550567627,
-0.9656625390052795,
1.0064576864242554,
0.5273661613464355,
-1.0266411304473877,
-0.005686855874955654,
0.21125896275043488,
0.5960364937782288,
-0.11085999011993408,
-0.28965020179748535,
0.25773704051971436,
0.2347453236579895,
0.046410027891397476,
-1.039599895477295,
-0.2907126545906067,
0.19252316653728485,
-0.09642519801855087,
0.22270023822784424,
-0.6199280023574829,
0.6129138469696045,
-0.0011117772664874792,
-0.6176355481147766,
-0.2877962291240692,
0.9868260025978088,
0.0655442625284195,
0.30920901894569397,
0.7464541792869568,
0.35942724347114563,
0.6943920254707336,
-0.24655400216579437,
0.4445962905883789,
-0.5251979827880859,
0.4455391466617584,
1.3091599941253662,
-0.20174765586853027,
0.7891722917556763,
0.40264981985092163,
-0.18429750204086304,
0.24924014508724213,
0.5976535081863403,
-0.42805448174476624,
0.9278931021690369,
-0.008766263723373413,
-0.26845109462738037,
-0.3726198375225067,
-0.3728066384792328,
-0.31708577275276184,
0.5780788064002991,
0.3026983439922333,
-0.13095159828662872,
-0.2353520691394806,
0.18505515158176422,
-0.48640209436416626,
0.19264115393161774,
-0.6168461441993713,
1.2154579162597656,
0.08321595191955566,
-0.5291391015052795,
0.6124297976493835,
-0.33990076184272766,
0.7448319792747498,
-0.6548856496810913,
0.07578974962234497,
0.026204319670796394,
0.16224533319473267,
-0.2907775640487671,
-0.8248226046562195,
0.5335004329681396,
-0.19322074949741364,
0.03634943068027496,
-0.4628069996833801,
0.8125544786453247,
-0.7990339398384094,
-0.3875223994255066,
0.444359689950943,
0.3071273863315582,
-0.04427490755915642,
-0.08029990643262863,
-0.9781823754310608,
-0.03754647821187973,
0.04781714826822281,
0.18231916427612305,
0.16926418244838715,
-0.04423684626817703,
0.5529572367668152,
0.6462991237640381,
0.6002549529075623,
0.07176676392555237,
0.12250363081693649,
0.2267797589302063,
0.5082609057426453,
-0.667224109172821,
-0.4206073582172394,
-0.8397718667984009,
0.17850349843502045,
0.02123752422630787,
-0.062488485127687454,
0.8959460258483887,
0.6159219741821289,
0.9974710941314697,
0.06973538547754288,
0.31793153285980225,
0.46151086688041687,
0.7289107441902161,
-0.8989217877388,
0.5926766395568848,
-0.9059208631515503,
-0.04731500893831253,
-0.2334425151348114,
-0.7167787551879883,
-0.36136332154273987,
0.6132264137268066,
-0.11445646733045578,
-0.24866917729377747,
0.37322887778282166,
0.742567777633667,
0.21715092658996582,
0.11756152659654617,
0.562444806098938,
-0.34186074137687683,
0.07783861458301544,
0.46200960874557495,
0.6634381413459778,
-0.20495279133319855,
0.628381609916687,
-0.9219427108764648,
0.0795593187212944,
0.03538355231285095,
-0.637575626373291,
-0.7933027744293213,
-0.8464015126228333,
-0.6655847430229187,
-0.057209938764572144,
0.4117419719696045,
0.8812430500984192,
0.9691146016120911,
-0.8117807507514954,
-0.38670310378074646,
0.14357633888721466,
-0.03442265838384628,
-0.5401850938796997,
-0.150022491812706,
0.7389468550682068,
-0.6806970238685608,
-0.7765402793884277,
0.6884245872497559,
0.33537402749061584,
0.2055709958076477,
-0.4328499138355255,
0.011652881279587746,
0.04018457233905792,
-0.21591202914714813,
0.340613454580307,
0.3649451434612274,
-0.8664807677268982,
-0.23977579176425934,
-0.03747435286641121,
-0.2673579752445221,
0.44638791680336,
0.5235089659690857,
-0.6845807433128357,
0.5858561396598816,
0.03696417063474655,
0.8251188397407532,
0.7315966486930847,
0.25115320086479187,
0.30221500992774963,
-0.7283474206924438,
-0.13679447770118713,
0.28216269612312317,
0.2832500636577606,
0.4424189627170563,
-0.4601791799068451,
0.5536598563194275,
0.0230085551738739,
-0.6742725968360901,
-0.543306291103363,
-0.018909325823187828,
-1.2506089210510254,
-0.44429662823677063,
0.7230753898620605,
0.010298976674675941,
-0.2572197914123535,
-0.1069086343050003,
-0.1735399067401886,
0.7755418419837952,
-0.3464803993701935,
0.8479955792427063,
0.3078083395957947,
-0.4095574617385864,
-0.26352328062057495,
-0.21267512440681458,
0.7114096879959106,
0.7667356729507446,
-0.48688971996307373,
0.2379259616136551,
0.4634985029697418,
0.11130698770284653,
0.31695157289505005,
0.45681092143058777,
0.042152997106313705,
0.32000234723091125,
-0.0528457872569561,
0.0342075452208519,
-0.33085283637046814,
-0.38921335339546204,
-0.6288822889328003,
0.23527933657169342,
-0.3611515164375305,
-0.27638453245162964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09140v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09140v1
|
Investigating the translation capabilities of Large Language Models trained on parallel data only
| 2024-06-13T14:08:56 | 2024-06-13T14:08:56 |
Javier García Gilabert, Carlos Escolano, Aleix Sant Savall, Francesca De Luca Fornaciari, Audrey Mash, Xixian Liao, Maite Melero
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated exceptional
proficiency across a broad spectrum of Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks,
including Machine Translation. However, previous methods predominantly relied
on iterative processes such as instruction fine-tuning or continual
pre-training, leaving unexplored the challenges of training LLMs solely on
parallel data. In this work, we introduce PLUME (Parallel Language Model), a
collection of three 2B LLMs featuring varying vocabulary sizes (32k, 128k, and
256k) trained exclusively on Catalan-centric parallel examples. These models
perform comparably to previous encoder-decoder architectures on 16 supervised
translation directions and 56 zero-shot ones. Utilizing this set of models, we
conduct a thorough investigation into the translation capabilities of LLMs,
probing their performance, the impact of the different elements of the prompt,
and their cross-lingual representation space.
|
[
-0.3118760287761688,
-0.3821429908275604,
0.6094921231269836,
0.5305919051170349,
-0.25734907388687134,
0.0411141961812973,
-0.39613544940948486,
-0.2743440568447113,
0.10394506901502609,
0.9859457015991211,
-0.41533440351486206,
-0.6470341682434082,
-1.0638428926467896,
0.3015625476837158,
-0.6533657908439636,
0.8354541659355164,
-0.11190646141767502,
0.0801718458533287,
-0.04065152630209923,
-0.12014085799455643,
-0.43965497612953186,
-0.5324654579162598,
-0.6512379050254822,
-0.12439072132110596,
0.8475478887557983,
0.32930678129196167,
0.5789581537246704,
0.8153747916221619,
0.5599828958511353,
0.14749416708946228,
-0.046477869153022766,
0.26891425251960754,
-0.7568396925926208,
-0.16180823743343353,
-0.32951241731643677,
-0.6430879831314087,
-0.10566326230764389,
-0.11161360889673233,
0.9999386072158813,
0.7379133701324463,
0.09544563293457031,
0.19545426964759827,
0.20812943577766418,
0.5093681216239929,
-0.5637469291687012,
0.290941447019577,
-0.8456002473831177,
-0.06653640419244766,
-0.6520763635635376,
-0.1317383497953415,
-0.7328972816467285,
0.021410057321190834,
-0.17806129157543182,
-0.4627169966697693,
0.17520688474178314,
0.26887398958206177,
0.5684248208999634,
0.4652661383152008,
-0.6610924005508423,
-0.13915887475013733,
-0.6689445376396179,
1.0337787866592407,
-0.6231099963188171,
0.4436202645301819,
0.0761372372508049,
0.429623007774353,
-0.2464698851108551,
-0.9436518549919128,
-0.45840615034103394,
0.11201919615268707,
0.02250288426876068,
0.056504782289266586,
-0.41407904028892517,
-0.007531560491770506,
0.15273286402225494,
0.15515285730361938,
-0.6041244268417358,
0.7059162855148315,
-0.3852812647819519,
-0.03446337953209877,
0.4698302149772644,
0.5299068093299866,
0.20234037935733795,
-0.1429615169763565,
-0.3300134837627411,
-0.28427040576934814,
-0.7887288331985474,
0.2696022689342499,
0.12545180320739746,
0.3221019506454468,
-0.16063688695430756,
0.7479440569877625,
-0.1711156815290451,
0.8086496591567993,
-0.36896851658821106,
0.11044899374246597,
0.12902387976646423,
-0.0047651962377130985,
-0.27676135301589966,
-0.13684995472431183,
0.8914636373519897,
0.20464061200618744,
0.07824569195508957,
-0.4483286738395691,
-0.09356176108121872,
0.017851656302809715,
0.11787822097539902,
-0.9647818803787231,
0.032445479184389114,
0.4494633376598358,
-0.2171279489994049,
-0.12265291810035706,
-0.26549679040908813,
-0.43039172887802124,
-0.2538646459579468,
-0.20962932705879211,
0.060505881905555725,
-0.08725366741418839,
-0.16521760821342468,
0.6137349605560303,
-0.05485469847917557,
0.237374946475029,
0.10826194286346436,
-0.7271896004676819,
0.18377412855625153,
0.9185048937797546,
0.7796534895896912,
-0.514420211315155,
-0.6755563020706177,
-0.7576202750205994,
0.1796407401561737,
-0.42784392833709717,
0.6563210487365723,
-0.5267230272293091,
-0.24944427609443665,
0.1681099683046341,
0.22342105209827423,
-0.32589027285575867,
-0.6020445227622986,
0.9083644151687622,
-0.6187069416046143,
-0.3654560148715973,
-0.4989831745624542,
-0.46885794401168823,
-0.2597445249557495,
0.22491849958896637,
-0.4903475046157837,
0.6937487125396729,
-0.13554278016090393,
-0.9066985845565796,
-0.0760025829076767,
-0.14584428071975708,
-0.24838528037071228,
-0.061836302280426025,
-0.21170100569725037,
-0.028374377638101578,
0.3881453275680542,
0.5709370374679565,
0.7494896054267883,
-0.7924957871437073,
0.18788599967956543,
-0.21505779027938843,
-0.11378111690282822,
0.1978020817041397,
-0.37472984194755554,
0.8550024628639221,
0.17405521869659424,
-0.008615849539637566,
0.2544289827346802,
-0.25664639472961426,
-0.3240869343280792,
0.07551294565200806,
-0.25455182790756226,
-0.033480290323495865,
-0.18479035794734955,
0.16931761801242828,
0.2944343090057373,
0.3523547947406769,
-0.7196992039680481,
0.10660585761070251,
-0.323411226272583,
0.4088886082172394,
0.32029107213020325,
-0.11041521281003952,
0.26340189576148987,
-0.33560362458229065,
0.6142763495445251,
0.14884759485721588,
-0.14858049154281616,
-0.25035861134529114,
-0.6039393544197083,
-0.7496614456176758,
-0.6008752584457397,
0.2095598727464676,
0.539107620716095,
-0.7458667755126953,
0.04831603169441223,
-0.6067485213279724,
-0.6383698582649231,
-0.5732877254486084,
0.2655274271965027,
0.1824435591697693,
0.42599472403526306,
0.3933310806751251,
-0.1022922545671463,
-0.12089819461107254,
-0.8954022526741028,
-0.28320884704589844,
0.05260130763053894,
-0.10305777937173843,
0.360539972782135,
0.29166242480278015,
-0.3799588680267334,
0.5625267624855042,
-0.32205188274383545,
-0.2754403054714203,
-0.34596356749534607,
0.28990140557289124,
0.39185386896133423,
0.16278009116649628,
0.6445220112800598,
-0.39043644070625305,
-0.537686288356781,
0.32137373089790344,
-0.789740264415741,
-0.42708030343055725,
-0.12886260449886322,
-0.2388606071472168,
-0.08926498889923096,
0.7426691651344299,
-0.7550475597381592,
0.19259636104106903,
0.9244270324707031,
0.1774081587791443,
0.38919976353645325,
-0.3613729178905487,
-0.20566408336162567,
-0.9232198596000671,
0.042347028851509094,
-0.18324336409568787,
-0.24826519191265106,
-0.533366322517395,
0.26039695739746094,
0.43094587326049805,
-0.10726107656955719,
-0.7063180208206177,
0.74285888671875,
-0.5234010815620422,
-0.1136399656534195,
-0.4275187849998474,
-0.08585800975561142,
0.015460065566003323,
0.2560538351535797,
0.41425439715385437,
0.46280065178871155,
0.8734957575798035,
-0.5383844375610352,
0.43395522236824036,
0.12128619849681854,
-0.32434171438217163,
0.32092776894569397,
-0.6736027598381042,
0.07344450056552887,
-0.33552032709121704,
0.4067341089248657,
-1.007566213607788,
-0.3817789554595947,
-0.1438809186220169,
-0.15847720205783844,
0.15022405982017517,
0.010602481663227081,
-0.7564600110054016,
-0.5262491703033447,
0.024874001741409302,
0.6058142781257629,
0.6762351989746094,
-0.7060550451278687,
0.4050203859806061,
0.1707533895969391,
-0.29535311460494995,
-0.5758276581764221,
-0.7132646441459656,
0.20127050578594208,
-0.3453224301338196,
-0.6746924519538879,
0.32655689120292664,
0.3773675858974457,
0.0038839373737573624,
-0.1802804321050644,
0.2353307455778122,
0.12662851810455322,
-0.1757160872220993,
0.18742111325263977,
-0.06454326957464218,
-0.1279793530702591,
0.02320500835776329,
0.2744768261909485,
0.08614291250705719,
0.23137275874614716,
-0.41162291169166565,
0.5988848805427551,
-0.028496572747826576,
-0.4286564290523529,
-0.3369590938091278,
0.17629025876522064,
0.9100229144096375,
-0.6796042323112488,
1.0356718301773071,
0.7034964561462402,
-0.3712751567363739,
-0.3037375807762146,
-0.680518388748169,
-0.019909603521227837,
-0.360280305147171,
0.44731295108795166,
-0.5309802293777466,
-0.833585262298584,
0.8251035809516907,
-0.15186727046966553,
0.2040351927280426,
0.5267252326011658,
0.8021551370620728,
0.14300920069217682,
0.8087636232376099,
0.44403553009033203,
-0.3379986882209778,
0.001000616350211203,
-0.32439377903938293,
-0.09201446920633316,
-0.8165377974510193,
-0.21895049512386322,
-0.5766290426254272,
-0.305676132440567,
-0.41243094205856323,
-0.7692427635192871,
0.44435322284698486,
0.29014039039611816,
-0.1810213327407837,
0.4040956497192383,
-0.20305503904819489,
0.2683852016925812,
0.3485015034675598,
-0.05626671388745308,
0.37983444333076477,
0.037531495094299316,
-0.10595356673002243,
-0.03871333599090576,
-0.7718364596366882,
-0.29151925444602966,
1.2831376791000366,
0.6958202719688416,
0.567410945892334,
0.29994580149650574,
0.6061406135559082,
-0.17793036997318268,
0.31361258029937744,
-0.8285673260688782,
0.4000449776649475,
-0.6092013120651245,
-0.4706502854824066,
-0.13969825208187103,
-0.4618678092956543,
-1.1958645582199097,
0.37861645221710205,
-0.05726546421647072,
-0.25944140553474426,
0.1620233654975891,
-0.2482832372188568,
-0.2077450454235077,
0.41395702958106995,
-0.25364944338798523,
0.8570496439933777,
-0.4943486154079437,
-0.3031306862831116,
-0.30776333808898926,
-0.34834372997283936,
0.37468743324279785,
-0.43266594409942627,
0.14612077176570892,
-0.16910363733768463,
-0.20040713250637054,
0.3338887393474579,
-0.12215974181890488,
0.6581705212593079,
0.1061631366610527,
-0.2635578215122223,
0.19877125322818756,
0.16653792560100555,
0.5564557313919067,
-0.06502504646778107,
-0.0581829808652401,
0.5826851725578308,
-0.08839917182922363,
-0.6091091632843018,
-0.32436615228652954,
0.8047042489051819,
-0.8315613269805908,
-0.4940914809703827,
-0.15949100255966187,
-1.0555509328842163,
-0.16247378289699554,
0.22267469763755798,
0.48082661628723145,
0.2279217690229416,
-0.08578531444072723,
0.35482361912727356,
0.5079802870750427,
-0.44915398955345154,
0.3809267282485962,
0.5426434874534607,
-0.6406882405281067,
-0.07124397158622742,
0.8670910596847534,
0.12242352962493896,
0.3035193681716919,
0.5499393939971924,
0.029258737340569496,
-0.6232265830039978,
-0.8515182733535767,
-0.7681208252906799,
0.5215952396392822,
-0.4328773319721222,
-0.007484761532396078,
-0.8731107711791992,
-0.22228585183620453,
-0.44043904542922974,
0.006190410349518061,
-0.45143383741378784,
-0.13006407022476196,
-0.4604024887084961,
0.14253275096416473,
0.19294971227645874,
0.8118320107460022,
0.12276800721883774,
0.44395947456359863,
-1.0303353071212769,
0.20416413247585297,
0.2604231536388397,
-0.0732065737247467,
-0.20023000240325928,
-0.8178114295005798,
-0.23323088884353638,
-0.14030620455741882,
-0.0689285397529602,
-0.8536639213562012,
0.8231955170631409,
-0.2171168029308319,
0.4048081636428833,
0.2312157303094864,
-0.07130593061447144,
0.3282809257507324,
-0.7040612697601318,
0.5855441093444824,
0.016317913308739662,
-0.5174499154090881,
0.055626749992370605,
-0.8460909128189087,
0.36685240268707275,
0.043251968920230865,
0.6124958395957947,
-0.3653692305088043,
-0.20577900111675262,
-0.24067513644695282,
-0.5218427777290344,
0.5313343405723572,
0.1288422793149948,
0.15784206986427307,
-0.12031596153974533,
0.26814764738082886,
-0.011813941411674023,
0.2529963552951813,
-0.3336208462715149,
0.10411830246448517,
0.09129416197538376,
-0.18530398607254028,
-0.5992946028709412,
-0.17480362951755524,
0.04781744256615639,
-0.1135404109954834,
0.31400784850120544,
0.04853379726409912,
-0.08523879200220108,
-0.17847491800785065,
-0.04059593006968498,
0.2259397655725479,
0.19201593101024628,
0.2853335440158844,
0.2757169306278229,
-0.11125385761260986,
0.1590338498353958,
0.061020880937576294,
-0.22251011431217194,
-0.06978681683540344,
0.20503689348697662,
0.11182980239391327,
0.05011506378650665,
0.18349047005176544,
0.851128339767456,
-0.038426537066698074,
-0.6831668019294739,
0.5717822909355164,
0.13801135122776031,
0.016411449760198593,
-0.1197824776172638,
-0.3191591501235962,
0.3964639902114868,
0.29036033153533936,
-0.0032202634029090405,
-0.19335518777370453,
0.10164254903793335,
-0.2607845962047577,
-0.17206890881061554,
0.4174598455429077,
-0.12154272198677063,
-0.2154473215341568,
0.7483506202697754,
0.12297604978084564,
0.09162940084934235,
0.6501660346984863,
-0.11016895622015,
-0.24146419763565063,
0.4784771502017975,
0.5771523714065552,
0.7986289262771606,
-0.11105053871870041,
0.10940220952033997,
0.29069188237190247,
0.5516219139099121,
-0.5210265517234802,
0.02561553195118904,
0.24638760089874268,
-0.6794102787971497,
-0.5786847472190857,
-0.736337423324585,
-0.43320411443710327,
0.2897335886955261,
-0.7706313729286194,
0.35559186339378357,
-0.31360024213790894,
-0.10730576515197754,
-0.1331508457660675,
-0.45946455001831055,
-1.0746535062789917,
-0.08778932690620422,
0.20951682329177856,
1.0025532245635986,
-1.0072747468948364,
1.0728453397750854,
0.5867366194725037,
-0.2348766028881073,
-0.682243824005127,
-0.09659494459629059,
-0.1254141926765442,
-0.801758885383606,
0.8396393060684204,
0.1796872764825821,
-0.1472168117761612,
0.4172206223011017,
-0.17737500369548798,
-0.6413102149963379,
0.8716114163398743,
0.8121861219406128,
-0.6943551301956177,
-0.061239417642354965,
0.660183310508728,
0.6424984335899353,
-0.35118237137794495,
0.14674249291419983,
0.6886988878250122,
0.12761446833610535,
-0.15247459709644318,
-1.3162847757339478,
-0.23739171028137207,
0.02560337260365486,
0.2333219349384308,
-0.050137072801589966,
-0.7641479969024658,
1.1187270879745483,
0.0924462154507637,
-0.03207056224346161,
0.15738731622695923,
0.5660590529441833,
0.20535676181316376,
0.05440046638250351,
0.08417529612779617,
0.8676222562789917,
0.6760765910148621,
0.05273508280515671,
1.3339475393295288,
-0.18921911716461182,
0.0733892023563385,
0.9723213911056519,
-0.26919397711753845,
1.314769983291626,
0.5081759095191956,
0.09711971133947372,
0.2953988015651703,
0.5185101628303528,
0.3672731816768646,
0.3728114068508148,
0.3445153832435608,
-0.36372825503349304,
-0.34160861372947693,
-0.4221287667751312,
-0.28842440247535706,
0.49726682901382446,
0.6668285727500916,
-0.4043988287448883,
-0.2785431146621704,
0.219741091132164,
-0.17645254731178284,
0.13548654317855835,
-0.6146799325942993,
0.40632468461990356,
0.2730008661746979,
-0.6481782793998718,
0.8846358060836792,
0.36977115273475647,
0.7011666893959045,
-0.30599892139434814,
0.28511548042297363,
-0.24050667881965637,
0.33458346128463745,
-0.11597297340631485,
-0.7941688299179077,
0.19844754040241241,
0.06674192100763321,
-0.05084209889173508,
-0.22568409144878387,
0.35372278094291687,
-0.32112985849380493,
-0.6515805721282959,
0.4166678488254547,
0.5966420769691467,
0.4806583523750305,
-0.5210515260696411,
-0.36332011222839355,
0.3966582119464874,
-0.09472218155860901,
0.09930557012557983,
0.23206184804439545,
0.6661214828491211,
-0.08396156132221222,
0.6688718795776367,
0.4768296182155609,
0.2797318398952484,
0.6560314893722534,
0.007308835629373789,
0.6870289444923401,
-0.48601534962654114,
-0.3618879020214081,
-0.6419786214828491,
0.39486148953437805,
0.27449658513069153,
-0.04642321169376373,
0.9216351509094238,
0.5887129902839661,
0.9761959910392761,
-0.23567946255207062,
0.7569761276245117,
0.5788261294364929,
0.6249281764030457,
-0.5189758539199829,
0.4494192898273468,
-0.4158955216407776,
0.3789016902446747,
0.19269375503063202,
-1.0493223667144775,
-0.3237870931625366,
0.035022541880607605,
-0.48228219151496887,
-0.4357893168926239,
0.6095582842826843,
0.7456101775169373,
-0.255544513463974,
-0.08016712963581085,
0.40059852600097656,
0.26307836174964905,
0.3508718013763428,
0.8555594086647034,
0.7179046869277954,
-0.30977511405944824,
0.5667787194252014,
-0.08465438336133957,
-0.12815314531326294,
-0.155296191573143,
-0.7857072353363037,
-1.2333884239196777,
-0.2580144703388214,
0.009018433280289173,
-0.1899513304233551,
-0.2889367640018463,
0.43365591764450073,
0.3555181324481964,
-0.6651458740234375,
-0.5305527448654175,
-0.3017452657222748,
-0.4228656589984894,
0.0014379177009686828,
-0.06361022591590881,
0.36981111764907837,
-0.41801580786705017,
-0.9515569806098938,
0.6096459031105042,
0.1582096666097641,
-0.08053820580244064,
-0.5566824078559875,
-0.105431467294693,
0.2461780309677124,
0.08514857292175293,
0.5501000285148621,
0.3759777247905731,
-0.8476067185401917,
0.0146681759506464,
0.32796382904052734,
-0.31877225637435913,
-0.31971120834350586,
0.6041126251220703,
-0.6536857485771179,
0.5514175891876221,
0.7361447811126709,
1.3752477169036865,
0.9078561663627625,
-0.2227455973625183,
0.3886213004589081,
-0.6831419467926025,
0.3962368965148926,
0.05021965503692627,
0.3529142439365387,
0.2841818928718567,
-0.10859329998493195,
0.20992951095104218,
0.040268778800964355,
-0.5736740827560425,
-0.8008334636688232,
0.20665863156318665,
-0.99983149766922,
-0.12642543017864227,
1.2720757722854614,
-0.278318852186203,
0.02426181361079216,
-0.016500722616910934,
-0.19162046909332275,
0.21291032433509827,
-0.040048081427812576,
0.2596156597137451,
0.7393901348114014,
-0.10177919268608093,
-0.25159531831741333,
-0.8929702043533325,
0.11963797360658646,
0.7039061188697815,
-0.6698852181434631,
0.01639438234269619,
0.36979663372039795,
0.2307126671075821,
0.01459439005702734,
0.5100307464599609,
-0.15196777880191803,
-0.06461738049983978,
-0.021117905154824257,
-0.14764094352722168,
-0.07531047612428665,
-0.5249597430229187,
-0.5267089605331421,
0.18346121907234192,
0.218279629945755,
-0.2297866940498352
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09138v1
|
Leveraging Explicit Reasoning for Inference Integration in Commonsense-Augmented Dialogue Models
| 2024-06-13T14:07:52 | 2024-06-13T14:07:52 |
Sarah E. Finch, Jinho D. Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Open-domain dialogue systems need to grasp social commonsense to understand
and respond effectively to human users. Commonsense-augmented dialogue models
have been proposed that aim to infer commonsense knowledge from dialogue
contexts in order to improve response quality. However, existing approaches to
commonsense-augmented dialogue rely on implicit reasoning to integrate
commonsense inferences during response generation. In this study, we explore
the impact of explicit reasoning against implicit reasoning over commonsense
for dialogue response generation. Our findings demonstrate that separating
commonsense reasoning into explicit steps for generating, selecting, and
integrating commonsense into responses leads to better dialogue interactions,
improving naturalness, engagement, specificity, and overall quality. Subsequent
analyses of these findings unveil insights into the effectiveness of various
types of commonsense in generating responses and the particular response traits
enhanced through explicit reasoning for commonsense integration. Our work
advances research in open-domain dialogue by achieving a new state-of-the-art
in commonsense-augmented response generation.
|
[
-0.6702787280082703,
-0.6744763255119324,
0.7340496182441711,
0.0165944155305624,
0.04612458869814873,
-0.3171693682670593,
-0.03408356383442879,
-0.5867692232131958,
-0.19659021496772766,
0.5806465744972229,
-0.3729397654533386,
-0.17043331265449524,
-0.1915433257818222,
0.23671650886535645,
0.05207394063472748,
0.7741209864616394,
0.2188401222229004,
-0.09157602488994598,
-0.5493194460868835,
-0.2213735729455948,
-0.37307867407798767,
-0.3367031514644623,
-0.40446633100509644,
-0.10565315932035446,
0.42488864064216614,
0.24347008764743805,
0.7848693132400513,
0.02347218617796898,
-0.04236782714724541,
0.30723100900650024,
-0.33843445777893066,
0.8151981830596924,
-0.3118766248226166,
0.08161040395498276,
-0.5215662717819214,
0.10689599812030792,
-0.49906933307647705,
0.01717810519039631,
0.40941423177719116,
0.7373111844062805,
0.11075978726148605,
-0.09989764541387558,
0.29737919569015503,
0.09447048604488373,
-0.9107339978218079,
-0.019124023616313934,
-0.3575619161128998,
-0.1808643490076065,
0.4706610441207886,
0.014088552445173264,
-0.5172862410545349,
-0.292528361082077,
0.5144227743148804,
-0.842365562915802,
0.04711005836725235,
0.06204945966601372,
0.5642883777618408,
0.10676528513431549,
-0.5190706849098206,
-0.31201449036598206,
-0.6776394844055176,
0.7803928256034851,
-1.0891379117965698,
0.33789923787117004,
0.2947677969932556,
0.22661623358726501,
-0.24119943380355835,
-0.6273180246353149,
-0.884452223777771,
-0.2120319902896881,
-0.41331246495246887,
0.07094775140285492,
-0.25407159328460693,
0.24323229491710663,
0.3208915889263153,
0.1399168074131012,
-0.14750057458877563,
-0.1700708568096161,
-0.2030191868543625,
-0.05807412043213844,
0.7959661483764648,
0.002757737645879388,
0.08546919375658035,
-0.10995633155107498,
-0.4718579351902008,
0.31198370456695557,
-0.5517119765281677,
-0.015791304409503937,
0.4980944097042084,
0.5055928230285645,
-0.12268643081188202,
0.44081464409828186,
-0.43183085322380066,
0.7473989725112915,
0.25863125920295715,
0.07895973324775696,
-0.1630488485097885,
-0.468496710062027,
-0.26919880509376526,
0.13146866858005524,
0.5903545022010803,
0.3711242377758026,
0.27020856738090515,
0.023277556523680687,
-0.3317191004753113,
-0.25721320509910583,
0.16441509127616882,
-0.5788098573684692,
0.04339013248682022,
0.6121702194213867,
-0.2734961211681366,
-0.2274055778980255,
-0.10367531329393387,
-0.7119807600975037,
-0.3972748816013336,
-0.4947282075881958,
0.3274041712284088,
-0.1081162542104721,
-0.8744953274726868,
0.14276693761348724,
-0.2585909962654114,
0.1383955180644989,
0.7866915464401245,
-0.8178312182426453,
0.7047570943832397,
0.9433542490005493,
0.6016933917999268,
-0.04896119236946106,
0.028079064562916756,
-0.8064858317375183,
0.2186676412820816,
-0.17868998646736145,
1.0502946376800537,
-0.5874428153038025,
-0.569709300994873,
0.2501235604286194,
-0.3129139840602875,
-0.08239378780126572,
-0.5324161052703857,
0.6465623378753662,
-0.47934553027153015,
0.2624099850654602,
-0.29474937915802,
-0.3685627579689026,
0.09870008379220963,
0.1870189905166626,
-0.6673726439476013,
0.6748509407043457,
-0.054194748401641846,
-0.8161918520927429,
0.2539529502391815,
-1.0363059043884277,
-0.3731786906719208,
0.18442949652671814,
0.06360743194818497,
0.01654290221631527,
0.2018384486436844,
0.4569980502128601,
0.38371580839157104,
-0.17400017380714417,
0.20022112131118774,
-0.6659428477287292,
-0.2697773277759552,
0.49317148327827454,
-0.48579370975494385,
0.7157487273216248,
0.371402382850647,
-0.16539691388607025,
-0.11234637349843979,
-0.36748233437538147,
-0.008673915639519691,
-0.04782015457749367,
0.1493276208639145,
-0.44045382738113403,
-0.0933641791343689,
-0.21918204426765442,
-0.031194843351840973,
-0.017294693738222122,
-0.7232380509376526,
-0.04660319536924362,
-0.383383184671402,
0.3616804778575897,
0.8075675368309021,
0.22170738875865936,
0.7715175747871399,
-0.06941263377666473,
-0.13648027181625366,
0.10753297060728073,
0.23521006107330322,
0.06539834290742874,
-0.6473502516746521,
-0.15469947457313538,
-0.21234475076198578,
0.10936412960290909,
0.385621577501297,
-0.8281599879264832,
-0.05880188196897507,
-0.1212708130478859,
0.045594606548547745,
-0.3986492455005646,
-0.11290071904659271,
0.6243622899055481,
0.7951932549476624,
0.4150276780128479,
0.012914642691612244,
-0.13067153096199036,
-0.6397929787635803,
-0.45286157727241516,
-0.3463059663772583,
0.03423996642231941,
0.7577558159828186,
0.44058284163475037,
0.19583828747272491,
1.2875539064407349,
-0.6760260462760925,
0.3773229420185089,
-0.3166368901729584,
0.27054089307785034,
-0.015270044095814228,
0.5059479475021362,
0.18251706659793854,
-1.1103543043136597,
-0.2184482216835022,
0.2182491272687912,
-0.6305040121078491,
-0.35676392912864685,
-0.04481172189116478,
-0.3176515996456146,
0.21088907122612,
0.04998791217803955,
-0.8308843374252319,
0.7232903242111206,
0.27852287888526917,
-0.2808566093444824,
0.7996830344200134,
0.17280858755111694,
0.44696423411369324,
-0.8224206566810608,
-0.019946245476603508,
0.10184082388877869,
0.10674659162759781,
-0.840294599533081,
-0.18360210955142975,
-0.25804197788238525,
-0.3153045177459717,
-0.8423184752464294,
1.1317965984344482,
-0.3881121873855591,
-0.300098717212677,
0.03937257453799248,
0.27934327721595764,
0.2498796284198761,
0.6503212451934814,
0.4361083209514618,
0.837801992893219,
0.10075590014457703,
-0.6549258232116699,
0.26931068301200867,
0.5644296407699585,
-0.18328694999217987,
0.9618945121765137,
-1.0107184648513794,
0.18109163641929626,
0.05039356276392937,
0.2589848041534424,
-1.1506778001785278,
-0.4668641984462738,
0.3843914568424225,
-0.5738524198532104,
0.07857447117567062,
-0.5440872311592102,
-0.4039422869682312,
-0.17294885218143463,
0.016874831169843674,
0.4655229449272156,
0.2669614255428314,
-0.8282501101493835,
0.8531700372695923,
0.06111947074532509,
-0.35090452432632446,
-0.7647321224212646,
-0.44447261095046997,
-0.1989026516675949,
-0.052216436713933945,
-0.9593891501426697,
-0.13984422385692596,
-0.05774284526705742,
-0.6833659410476685,
0.12157386541366577,
-0.2076869159936905,
-0.14784598350524902,
-0.08233574032783508,
-0.07493594288825989,
0.2526947855949402,
-0.2380005419254303,
-0.07551383227109909,
0.6126601099967957,
-0.04884852468967438,
0.05162990838289261,
-0.24105389416217804,
0.07513272017240524,
-0.10994475334882736,
-0.6417919397354126,
-0.4756203889846802,
0.7391672730445862,
0.5369835495948792,
-0.340925008058548,
0.6421464085578918,
0.1950134038925171,
-0.10429775714874268,
-0.1431635320186615,
-0.6239035129547119,
-0.45900586247444153,
-0.5061416029930115,
-0.14945872128009796,
-0.48973339796066284,
-0.8645564317703247,
0.31242749094963074,
-0.4276267886161804,
0.39715689420700073,
0.037703488022089005,
0.23918241262435913,
-0.25642338395118713,
1.3448138236999512,
-0.23857463896274567,
0.7610018253326416,
0.18195289373397827,
0.03360714763402939,
0.29564687609672546,
-1.3041839599609375,
-0.11252525448799133,
-0.3466707468032837,
0.10196512192487717,
-0.2692664861679077,
-0.37282758951187134,
0.29078713059425354,
-0.10361099988222122,
-0.41490429639816284,
-0.0012247367994859815,
-0.38694217801094055,
0.338886559009552,
0.48306745290756226,
0.31573542952537537,
0.41004228591918945,
-0.10920947790145874,
-0.04319511726498604,
0.2550320327281952,
-0.6033400893211365,
-0.5878763198852539,
0.7361996173858643,
0.2869511842727661,
0.6852693557739258,
0.4050118625164032,
0.6883261203765869,
0.3694063127040863,
0.3047601282596588,
-0.4204946756362915,
0.659853994846344,
0.09278374165296555,
-0.44881895184516907,
-0.3366330564022064,
-0.471616268157959,
-0.6145603656768799,
0.3818768262863159,
-0.1682160645723343,
-0.6971160769462585,
0.41228798031806946,
0.4298833906650543,
-0.5167086720466614,
0.2019297033548355,
-0.9576976299285889,
0.6728969812393188,
-0.005054605193436146,
-0.8204960227012634,
0.16650065779685974,
-0.6791254281997681,
0.5919790863990784,
0.5191053152084351,
0.18585477769374847,
-0.10756836831569672,
0.2461950033903122,
0.3401394486427307,
-0.6272484064102173,
1.1240359544754028,
-0.44814008474349976,
-0.420920193195343,
0.5891422629356384,
-0.0002656918950378895,
0.6209105849266052,
0.36114925146102905,
0.14357388019561768,
0.002154439454898238,
-0.1815175563097,
-0.614221453666687,
-1.0649689435958862,
0.7255520224571228,
-0.6652854681015015,
-0.850179135799408,
-0.16363295912742615,
-0.4342690706253052,
-0.46212804317474365,
-0.007053506560623646,
-0.045409996062517166,
0.7945230007171631,
-0.17464090883731842,
-0.3830517828464508,
1.1190789937973022,
-0.32753974199295044,
0.037134427577257156,
0.3665751516819,
0.14670923352241516,
-0.6359740495681763,
0.6443390846252441,
-0.21372467279434204,
0.8825103640556335,
0.06034504994750023,
0.220930814743042,
-0.68303382396698,
-0.36802470684051514,
-0.6233543157577515,
0.24455223977565765,
-0.6502620577812195,
-0.27648356556892395,
-0.8319883942604065,
0.07523217052221298,
-0.9658907055854797,
-0.2733129560947418,
-0.05067436397075653,
-0.503348171710968,
-0.09349550306797028,
-0.0652596727013588,
0.35277092456817627,
0.6961249709129333,
-0.3153325319290161,
0.07326443493366241,
-0.8360141515731812,
0.41479188203811646,
0.8720691800117493,
0.31715425848960876,
0.23654167354106903,
-0.2940782904624939,
0.021999698132276535,
0.3861854076385498,
-0.07847420871257782,
-0.9483170509338379,
-0.05604584887623787,
0.04282749444246292,
0.7979990839958191,
0.4157848060131073,
0.4047555923461914,
0.552503228187561,
-0.43734562397003174,
0.9832800626754761,
0.11531834304332733,
-0.8964561820030212,
0.6580958366394043,
-0.4700390696525574,
0.1883358657360077,
0.21783173084259033,
0.212599977850914,
-0.31600892543792725,
-0.25882187485694885,
-0.5969722867012024,
-0.543305516242981,
0.5583494901657104,
0.3943910002708435,
0.32469356060028076,
-0.22899387776851654,
-0.03309066593647003,
0.09771600365638733,
0.12174389511346817,
-0.11732255667448044,
0.04756084829568863,
-0.37657636404037476,
0.14851944148540497,
0.5125749111175537,
-0.15006665885448456,
-0.5507007241249084,
-0.054512590169906616,
0.4442548453807831,
-0.3431881368160248,
0.44937050342559814,
0.276919424533844,
-0.08328455686569214,
0.08394521474838257,
0.386695921421051,
0.8006728887557983,
0.2158416360616684,
-0.0926070436835289,
-0.0012700811494141817,
0.3514596223831177,
-0.144013449549675,
-0.23329083621501923,
0.1751112937927246,
0.13336853682994843,
-0.04656141996383667,
0.3627956509590149,
0.7679808139801025,
0.4287894070148468,
-0.6187213063240051,
0.6521825194358826,
-0.08008598536252975,
-0.36449307203292847,
0.10883298516273499,
0.16995975375175476,
-0.012801879085600376,
0.43155378103256226,
0.3075341582298279,
0.14556492865085602,
0.48998862504959106,
-0.2731485962867737,
0.1985560655593872,
0.5308025479316711,
-0.06636309623718262,
-0.06661418825387955,
0.4987606108188629,
0.7915880680084229,
-0.11739049106836319,
0.676384687423706,
-0.003417232306674123,
-0.3907134234905243,
0.40865159034729004,
0.5482116937637329,
0.9546869397163391,
-0.24602961540222168,
0.426633358001709,
0.4816446006298065,
-0.2742891311645508,
0.1495623141527176,
0.0775456503033638,
-0.8176010847091675,
-0.8941617012023926,
-0.7806575894355774,
-0.37426719069480896,
-0.8331746459007263,
-0.2982737720012665,
-0.7327229380607605,
-0.10460348427295685,
-0.28922751545906067,
0.02339569479227066,
-0.14991353452205658,
-0.2530013918876648,
-0.3752497732639313,
0.12170558422803879,
0.27861741185188293,
1.0582501888275146,
-0.8687695860862732,
0.028365829959511757,
0.5285328030586243,
-0.4577750861644745,
-0.5777029395103455,
-0.034973036497831345,
0.08082815259695053,
-0.6761346459388733,
0.7831776142120361,
-0.04407172650098801,
-0.4599451720714569,
-0.19067446887493134,
-1.0015681982040405,
-0.5402629971504211,
0.7483713030815125,
0.05129372701048851,
-0.05211908742785454,
0.04399874433875084,
0.22776202857494354,
0.27656951546669006,
-0.3017061650753021,
0.4965569078922272,
0.5446287989616394,
0.5387141704559326,
0.70322185754776,
-0.9373801350593567,
0.13183484971523285,
-0.43160033226013184,
0.20639213919639587,
0.2769089937210083,
-0.31957241892814636,
0.4030861556529999,
-0.45311421155929565,
-0.3022618889808655,
0.29056620597839355,
1.044541597366333,
0.5833320617675781,
0.7661880254745483,
0.4201745092868805,
0.5355572700500488,
0.4300647974014282,
-0.12805072963237762,
0.8835276961326599,
0.12465568631887436,
-0.028360489755868912,
1.3234447240829468,
-0.4769324064254761,
0.7580918669700623,
0.33054447174072266,
0.10032535344362259,
0.6222929358482361,
0.29077646136283875,
0.482786625623703,
0.5598173141479492,
-0.17179758846759796,
-1.0419197082519531,
-0.2892768085002899,
-0.4237936735153198,
-0.2871611416339874,
0.06869915127754211,
0.6157382726669312,
0.013451152481138706,
-0.19656941294670105,
0.0415818952023983,
0.0009285941487178206,
0.1635364443063736,
-0.2778088450431824,
1.178550124168396,
-0.058811526745557785,
-0.955638587474823,
0.5920173525810242,
-0.658971905708313,
0.39940786361694336,
-0.25716912746429443,
-0.5002055168151855,
-0.3884686231613159,
-0.25494787096977234,
-0.4114052653312683,
-1.214423656463623,
0.1633683294057846,
0.04604342207312584,
0.09987082332372665,
-0.22621262073516846,
0.8521257638931274,
-0.4518797695636749,
0.2227436602115631,
-0.11942823976278305,
0.44134238362312317,
0.15718403458595276,
-0.037717416882514954,
-0.5916685461997986,
-0.0006094385753385723,
-0.16981834173202515,
-0.24241314828395844,
0.19952109456062317,
0.723691999912262,
0.002001214539632201,
0.35624510049819946,
1.081807255744934,
-0.259392112493515,
-0.15114165842533112,
0.039127763360738754,
1.0569884777069092,
-0.14437013864517212,
-0.3348367512226105,
-0.33070385456085205,
1.0329736471176147,
-0.6920801401138306,
-0.2514636218547821,
0.41553953289985657,
0.18675006926059723,
0.5988496541976929,
-0.05158218368887901,
0.9527507424354553,
0.019854621961712837,
0.5647273063659668,
-0.48313578963279724,
0.3195810317993164,
-0.43545499444007874,
0.24504896998405457,
-0.38837215304374695,
-0.5151422619819641,
-0.021963177248835564,
0.4396252930164337,
-0.7518011927604675,
0.13483627140522003,
0.30717650055885315,
0.8749083280563354,
-0.27211129665374756,
0.2743024230003357,
0.32946455478668213,
-0.018354877829551697,
0.3812708556652069,
0.36717137694358826,
1.155361294746399,
-0.0279880091547966,
0.4321940541267395,
-0.0036389543674886227,
-0.2531587779521942,
-0.1534297913312912,
-0.8606051802635193,
-0.7736530303955078,
-0.41005536913871765,
-0.2319730967283249,
-0.7289018034934998,
0.3655845522880554,
0.7431331276893616,
0.4683685600757599,
-0.6926057934761047,
0.1452455371618271,
-0.10382920503616333,
0.28655293583869934,
-0.3413632810115814,
-0.37716805934906006,
0.13775593042373657,
-0.4119402766227722,
-0.9316896200180054,
0.1224774718284607,
0.2358565479516983,
0.12566232681274414,
-0.04444723576307297,
-0.38081613183021545,
-0.15229913592338562,
0.4955326020717621,
0.732342004776001,
0.7315822243690491,
-0.8814338445663452,
-0.2678301930427551,
-0.027243096381425858,
0.004957600962370634,
-0.17052794992923737,
0.8683424592018127,
-0.8424323797225952,
0.4626840651035309,
0.4928402006626129,
0.5498780608177185,
0.32597291469573975,
0.2390991747379303,
0.9405335783958435,
-0.7291596531867981,
-0.10037387162446976,
0.4545098543167114,
0.062218889594078064,
0.26368460059165955,
-0.4581748843193054,
0.480080783367157,
0.12014815956354141,
-0.5146222114562988,
-0.9929805994033813,
0.6710562109947205,
-0.9661276936531067,
-0.21933357417583466,
1.4133274555206299,
-0.29982417821884155,
-0.11484681069850922,
-0.5116046071052551,
-0.45929551124572754,
-0.012412871234118938,
-0.7563672065734863,
0.2214498370885849,
0.2705601453781128,
-0.5079831480979919,
-0.4543299376964569,
-0.21291397511959076,
0.5868074893951416,
0.3124818205833435,
-0.929074227809906,
0.28971368074417114,
0.6940551400184631,
-0.12141777575016022,
0.21172522008419037,
0.540616512298584,
0.09723560512065887,
0.6758396625518799,
0.1774820238351822,
-0.4260673522949219,
-0.27711474895477295,
0.05712522193789482,
0.07219248265028,
0.07833103090524673,
-0.14090479910373688,
0.030372973531484604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09136v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09136v1
|
Chain of Preference Optimization: Improving Chain-of-Thought Reasoning in LLMs
| 2024-06-13T14:07:02 | 2024-06-13T14:07:02 |
Xuan Zhang, Chao Du, Tianyu Pang, Qian Liu, Wei Gao, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The recent development of chain-of-thought (CoT) decoding has enabled large
language models (LLMs) to generate explicit logical reasoning paths for complex
problem-solving. However, research indicates that these paths are not always
deliberate and optimal. The tree-of-thought (ToT) method employs tree-searching
to extensively explore the reasoning space and find better reasoning paths that
CoT decoding might overlook. This deliberation, however, comes at the cost of
significantly increased inference complexity. In this work, we demonstrate that
fine-tuning LLMs leveraging the search tree constructed by ToT allows CoT to
achieve similar or better performance, thereby avoiding the substantial
inference burden. This is achieved through Chain of Preference Optimization
(CPO), where LLMs are fine-tuned to align each step of the CoT reasoning paths
with those of ToT using the inherent preference information in the tree-search
process. Extensive experimental results show that CPO significantly improves
LLM performance in solving a variety of complex problems, including question
answering, fact verification, and arithmetic reasoning, demonstrating its
effectiveness. Our code is available at https://github.com/sail-sg/CPO.
|
[
-0.45805037021636963,
-0.6605762839317322,
0.9174451231956482,
-0.011674593202769756,
-0.6392802596092224,
0.44601884484291077,
-0.3677273988723755,
-0.5347583889961243,
0.09522902965545654,
0.6117042303085327,
-0.5941374897956848,
-0.5367252230644226,
-0.5859095454216003,
0.20258988440036774,
0.1758573055267334,
0.9443225264549255,
-0.1759158819913864,
-0.18334312736988068,
-0.049019694328308105,
0.045734163373708725,
-0.4255790412425995,
-0.5950905680656433,
-0.858676016330719,
-0.18368226289749146,
0.5682153105735779,
0.5101430416107178,
0.6502551436424255,
0.6528422832489014,
0.33371132612228394,
0.17112495005130768,
-0.4183247983455658,
0.7609574198722839,
-0.8051518201828003,
0.22395847737789154,
-0.499311625957489,
-0.6243292093276978,
-0.6276868581771851,
-0.4330044686794281,
0.27123790979385376,
0.34260886907577515,
0.00025274688960053027,
0.08088452368974686,
0.09183647483587265,
1.1683825254440308,
-1.0222822427749634,
0.06092629209160805,
-1.0137869119644165,
-0.08726685494184494,
-0.010176182724535465,
-0.771338164806366,
-0.5852463245391846,
-0.4095125198364258,
0.20986853539943695,
-0.5964725017547607,
-0.1494259536266327,
0.395062118768692,
0.49859702587127686,
0.41205108165740967,
-0.5153084993362427,
-0.4843554198741913,
-0.5777556896209717,
0.8768553137779236,
-0.4860769808292389,
0.3843838572502136,
0.396860271692276,
0.018858276307582855,
-0.4435427188873291,
-0.09409936517477036,
-0.22041475772857666,
-0.16647718846797943,
0.11201842874288559,
0.13107609748840332,
0.06713549047708511,
0.5285688638687134,
0.11316629499197006,
0.3364812135696411,
-0.23240050673484802,
-0.11247990280389786,
0.11963137239217758,
-0.021913686767220497,
0.6628133058547974,
0.05461813509464264,
-0.022428294643759727,
-0.05546598136425018,
-0.2264425903558731,
-0.08034961670637131,
-0.6677526235580444,
0.2903421223163605,
0.2193857878446579,
0.22749091684818268,
0.321127325296402,
0.5347135066986084,
-0.24413421750068665,
0.7043278813362122,
0.1859385073184967,
-0.10618922859430313,
-0.1252419501543045,
-0.2953948378562927,
-0.24515804648399353,
0.2852367162704468,
0.33394140005111694,
0.4845382273197174,
0.35284215211868286,
-0.11212160438299179,
-0.36696285009384155,
0.08820886164903641,
0.1920725405216217,
-0.5837611556053162,
-0.1583961546421051,
0.2011795938014984,
-0.4438982903957367,
-0.4066477119922638,
-0.11313042789697647,
-0.4219837486743927,
-0.024185532703995705,
-0.36960700154304504,
0.06529263406991959,
-0.268512099981308,
-0.17255067825317383,
0.4664960503578186,
-0.165242537856102,
0.013967400416731834,
0.446737140417099,
-0.8151002526283264,
0.4036337435245514,
0.6497246026992798,
0.6238771677017212,
-0.2783356010913849,
0.08157858997583389,
-0.564626932144165,
0.24433322250843048,
-0.6282856464385986,
0.8677602410316467,
-0.6976851224899292,
-0.3581041991710663,
-0.37559568881988525,
-0.3552512228488922,
-0.03420110419392586,
-0.5041899681091309,
0.5787084102630615,
-0.6631256341934204,
-0.09143100678920746,
-0.5822270512580872,
-0.4595453143119812,
-0.006203268188983202,
0.6010413765907288,
-0.37810587882995605,
1.0198571681976318,
0.003075324697420001,
-0.7238702178001404,
0.20948487520217896,
-0.6532738208770752,
-0.4085974097251892,
-0.3222905993461609,
-0.1977246105670929,
-0.3936978578567505,
0.32014402747154236,
0.4187997281551361,
0.24166364967823029,
-0.5787509083747864,
0.26119980216026306,
-0.4003782868385315,
-0.28264087438583374,
-0.025271032005548477,
-0.24143533408641815,
0.6270312666893005,
0.3998258113861084,
-0.3499097526073456,
0.18821893632411957,
-0.45957043766975403,
0.28966599702835083,
0.179050475358963,
-0.4234512150287628,
-0.5442726016044617,
0.3827410638332367,
-0.4175185561180115,
0.015379318036139011,
0.23080013692378998,
-0.3004956543445587,
0.44057199358940125,
-0.5066712498664856,
0.5976104140281677,
0.9342666864395142,
0.08239741623401642,
0.32877373695373535,
-0.3181699216365814,
0.440256804227829,
0.04316480830311775,
0.3580951690673828,
0.29757946729660034,
-0.3029203712940216,
-0.7990211844444275,
0.044307831674814224,
-0.006419252138584852,
0.30303746461868286,
-0.7037304043769836,
0.6059169769287109,
0.0671711191534996,
-0.18226999044418335,
-0.20757520198822021,
-0.08749920129776001,
0.5251654982566833,
0.43784159421920776,
0.3623041808605194,
-0.3516071140766144,
-0.5488143563270569,
-0.6576892137527466,
-0.25734883546829224,
-0.2327413707971573,
0.38645246624946594,
0.5337710380554199,
0.23335601389408112,
-0.11182238161563873,
0.92378830909729,
-0.872361421585083,
0.05846908316016197,
-0.1456301212310791,
-0.4126526713371277,
0.11450468748807907,
0.29274246096611023,
0.4196934103965759,
-0.6305883526802063,
-0.4705107510089874,
0.2500994801521301,
-0.23498529195785522,
0.09845272451639175,
-0.01403465773910284,
-0.5235986709594727,
0.22849737107753754,
0.2565224766731262,
-0.2540473937988281,
0.2012479454278946,
0.42975395917892456,
-0.2918607294559479,
0.6789698004722595,
-0.2739368975162506,
0.08192113041877747,
-0.9407726526260376,
-0.1306230127811432,
-0.38832205533981323,
-0.3479335904121399,
-0.04709869995713234,
0.00765855610370636,
-0.07700245082378387,
0.15066087245941162,
-0.28403720259666443,
0.1310611516237259,
-0.5156739950180054,
-0.10924872756004333,
-0.22611545026302338,
0.21647711098194122,
0.11683457344770432,
0.6680772304534912,
0.02169189415872097,
0.987578809261322,
0.6501477360725403,
-0.6995448470115662,
0.021133100613951683,
0.26950138807296753,
-0.013945547863841057,
0.1931184083223343,
-0.21209608018398285,
0.47893762588500977,
-0.1156494989991188,
0.4172176420688629,
-0.970380961894989,
0.28959551453590393,
0.027206875383853912,
-0.13345442712306976,
0.06511766463518143,
-0.2537071704864502,
-0.5814081430435181,
-0.2517256736755371,
-0.7155787944793701,
0.7462257742881775,
0.18731367588043213,
-0.8051714897155762,
0.42928987741470337,
0.32552382349967957,
0.28665468096733093,
-0.6783347725868225,
-0.29013609886169434,
-0.1471414864063263,
-0.13290034234523773,
-0.3310627043247223,
0.38336411118507385,
-0.1655758023262024,
0.026263080537319183,
-0.18658503890037537,
-0.7218905687332153,
0.06482235342264175,
0.07320453971624374,
-0.20143751800060272,
0.29033464193344116,
-0.11472942680120468,
0.24119314551353455,
0.44713833928108215,
-0.22833402454853058,
0.17920097708702087,
-0.7347683310508728,
0.7308010458946228,
-0.3534584045410156,
-0.17126621305942535,
-0.13997796177864075,
0.06833893060684204,
0.5304855108261108,
-0.3676532804965973,
0.2655879855155945,
-0.23246000707149506,
-0.015986118465662003,
-0.47389960289001465,
-0.4463925361633301,
-0.20885513722896576,
-0.48985573649406433,
0.23549628257751465,
-0.7095458507537842,
-0.9520023465156555,
0.2532961964607239,
-0.6726853847503662,
-0.19270406663417816,
0.21432985365390778,
0.21814106404781342,
-0.15847258269786835,
1.1629319190979004,
0.4431002140045166,
-0.2800256907939911,
0.5460140705108643,
-0.5381872057914734,
0.4059549868106842,
-1.0982319116592407,
-0.10218585282564163,
-0.48359450697898865,
-0.2174452692270279,
-0.8406471610069275,
-0.3873298466205597,
0.5303062200546265,
0.41112712025642395,
-0.41999685764312744,
0.2658304274082184,
-1.003482699394226,
0.873363196849823,
0.3739914298057556,
0.5314604043960571,
0.6665113568305969,
0.014328710734844208,
-0.47317302227020264,
0.3174959421157837,
-1.0680867433547974,
-0.5554562211036682,
1.0705546140670776,
0.1033783107995987,
0.6829279661178589,
-0.1267557293176651,
0.7758573293685913,
0.06338167935609818,
-0.1373741328716278,
-0.8518423438072205,
0.7214673757553101,
-0.4508635103702545,
-0.3514154851436615,
-0.21430793404579163,
-0.3901040256023407,
-0.9009522199630737,
0.02278716117143631,
-0.0713384598493576,
-0.8470544219017029,
0.16246922314167023,
0.5065544843673706,
-0.24218527972698212,
0.5202763080596924,
-0.48692992329597473,
0.4942721128463745,
-0.5613603591918945,
-0.40434834361076355,
-0.8065122961997986,
-0.5649946331977844,
0.1557331532239914,
0.14061753451824188,
-0.2347428798675537,
-0.07030284404754639,
-0.04474923759698868,
0.5465683937072754,
-0.47796791791915894,
0.5547489523887634,
0.3138589560985565,
-0.13910412788391113,
0.489701509475708,
0.27108606696128845,
0.9173396229743958,
0.1925075650215149,
-0.27857986092567444,
-0.05249256268143654,
0.12373339384794235,
-0.32639050483703613,
-0.5593070983886719,
0.7016730904579163,
-0.8229697346687317,
-0.8016319870948792,
-0.3911963999271393,
-0.4873322546482086,
-0.40552398562431335,
0.12499416619539261,
0.1591443568468094,
0.20637041330337524,
0.02198452688753605,
-0.0385424979031086,
0.678672730922699,
-0.14197129011154175,
0.32841891050338745,
0.017225753515958786,
-0.27222108840942383,
-0.5293670296669006,
0.6588531136512756,
-0.13873063027858734,
0.6621445417404175,
0.8266071081161499,
0.48860421776771545,
-0.3937888443470001,
-0.6167609691619873,
-0.2490532398223877,
0.16119715571403503,
-0.6235668063163757,
-0.34262919425964355,
-0.31974124908447266,
-0.1178986057639122,
0.10805680602788925,
-0.3710117042064667,
-0.5363959670066833,
-0.5454186201095581,
-0.01950465515255928,
-0.17798851430416107,
0.5412678718566895,
0.4521009624004364,
0.37888702750205994,
0.15161171555519104,
-0.2574668526649475,
0.20852486789226532,
0.23227138817310333,
0.5449709296226501,
0.23172572255134583,
0.03526096045970917,
-0.09044498205184937,
0.044176578521728516,
-0.631147027015686,
-0.46994489431381226,
-0.05997799336910248,
-0.2547464668750763,
0.13968296349048615,
0.382939875125885,
0.36033686995506287,
1.0203430652618408,
-0.13614611327648163,
0.31874892115592957,
0.19032248854637146,
-1.099243402481079,
0.9295184016227722,
-0.27086690068244934,
0.21537595987319946,
0.6263927221298218,
0.16079337894916534,
-0.08890821039676666,
-0.34108662605285645,
-0.5662828683853149,
-0.7428106665611267,
0.6773942708969116,
0.35385075211524963,
-0.3177986443042755,
-0.06904541701078415,
0.459835410118103,
-0.02780725806951523,
0.25223392248153687,
-0.5090577602386475,
-0.08956857770681381,
0.07574640959501266,
0.13435587286949158,
0.0570855550467968,
-0.344294935464859,
-0.024047063663601875,
-0.4475909173488617,
0.6826426386833191,
-0.32455337047576904,
0.15390069782733917,
0.41571077704429626,
0.17443396151065826,
-0.44079017639160156,
0.34598618745803833,
0.5030789375305176,
0.6807957291603088,
-0.38251811265945435,
0.35622262954711914,
0.46921053528785706,
-0.17655916512012482,
-0.033304471522569656,
-0.5023264288902283,
-0.06295312941074371,
-0.3801441490650177,
0.1601957380771637,
0.871199369430542,
-0.04477614536881447,
-0.6442981362342834,
0.10762157291173935,
0.10479949414730072,
-0.1549091339111328,
0.028438815847039223,
0.46281492710113525,
0.07942640036344528,
0.1920442134141922,
0.04166117310523987,
0.311325341463089,
0.2065403312444687,
-0.7055884599685669,
-0.1783791482448578,
0.6474840641021729,
-0.13665838539600372,
-0.06764017045497894,
0.41268014907836914,
0.3266836106777191,
-0.3733372390270233,
0.5451260209083557,
-0.010772878304123878,
-0.8152676820755005,
0.639191210269928,
0.6590928435325623,
0.8979780077934265,
0.08148445934057236,
-0.04168332368135452,
0.25776925683021545,
0.22619982063770294,
-0.1697537750005722,
0.48719412088394165,
-0.4613620936870575,
-0.8305030465126038,
-0.4874245524406433,
-0.40349751710891724,
-0.42570242285728455,
-0.03747967630624771,
-0.36430761218070984,
0.35316476225852966,
-0.646298885345459,
-0.21406963467597961,
-0.3837965726852417,
0.3583710491657257,
-0.41614630818367004,
0.229634091258049,
-0.11140180379152298,
0.846929132938385,
-0.31856581568717957,
1.012380599975586,
0.4584712088108063,
-0.03980771824717522,
-0.9388315081596375,
0.17357784509658813,
-0.30820074677467346,
-0.8092466592788696,
0.3812524676322937,
0.05924152210354805,
-0.8599794507026672,
0.20578069984912872,
-0.3221033811569214,
-0.8770649433135986,
1.0494904518127441,
0.5984965562820435,
-1.0982803106307983,
-0.05985039472579956,
0.24591881036758423,
0.49610230326652527,
-0.5533319711685181,
0.3100563883781433,
0.5845565795898438,
0.4338856339454651,
0.124249167740345,
-1.0186320543289185,
0.14227859675884247,
0.14895080029964447,
0.22899103164672852,
0.5206050872802734,
-0.7828543186187744,
0.4194670617580414,
-0.431247353553772,
-0.009067051112651825,
-0.22416067123413086,
0.005991554819047451,
0.6653017997741699,
0.39107194542884827,
0.8274512887001038,
0.3796769976615906,
0.8888694047927856,
0.1738448441028595,
1.0192962884902954,
-0.5159706473350525,
0.4785349369049072,
1.1416529417037964,
-0.1859297901391983,
0.8445630073547363,
0.723131000995636,
-0.1326691210269928,
0.34522950649261475,
0.8682066202163696,
0.4617784321308136,
0.6617728471755981,
0.3821990489959717,
-0.2567784786224365,
-0.44662585854530334,
-0.05248558521270752,
-0.22831596434116364,
0.17148655652999878,
0.24744272232055664,
-0.3171480596065521,
-0.0864582359790802,
-0.336742639541626,
-0.11063893884420395,
0.2453564703464508,
-0.4773411452770233,
0.8404340744018555,
0.13360394537448883,
-0.8801288604736328,
0.9891044497489929,
-0.2834489643573761,
0.47348225116729736,
-0.38037267327308655,
0.06866271048784256,
0.03899070620536804,
0.334425151348114,
-0.2667197585105896,
-0.7972144484519958,
0.29650184512138367,
-0.07203055918216705,
-0.24888601899147034,
-0.3761560320854187,
0.6215441823005676,
-0.16285476088523865,
-0.2728557884693146,
0.6487895846366882,
0.34313473105430603,
0.014984450303018093,
-0.28201887011528015,
-0.6852468848228455,
0.12033140659332275,
0.24095426499843597,
-0.1841902732849121,
0.11164034157991409,
0.5825678110122681,
-0.3821459710597992,
0.7715710401535034,
0.7772260904312134,
0.09937206655740738,
-0.3653785288333893,
-0.045427821576595306,
1.2215684652328491,
-0.6341897249221802,
-0.48479825258255005,
-1.0598424673080444,
0.12329048663377762,
0.007101927883923054,
-0.4094092547893524,
0.3177329897880554,
1.02790367603302,
1.0766948461532593,
-0.05815599486231804,
0.6103794574737549,
0.12231192737817764,
0.011610111221671104,
-0.7328338623046875,
0.31360960006713867,
-0.41956332325935364,
0.5109394788742065,
-0.3589636981487274,
-1.1002092361450195,
-0.13461659848690033,
0.6186771988868713,
-0.5734840035438538,
-0.10133399069309235,
1.1357966661453247,
0.8241798877716064,
-0.13526611030101776,
0.1941954642534256,
0.21019086241722107,
0.15050125122070312,
0.3572785556316376,
0.9811837673187256,
0.7682605385780334,
-0.21269941329956055,
0.4640410840511322,
-0.1931057870388031,
-0.159883514046669,
-0.18239930272102356,
-0.9756965041160583,
-0.8754692673683167,
-0.45566028356552124,
-0.1389215588569641,
-0.22908459603786469,
0.5699155926704407,
1.2726142406463623,
0.8052223324775696,
-0.6335241198539734,
-0.5997317433357239,
-0.7461785078048706,
0.45492613315582275,
-0.3665178716182709,
-0.11870820075273514,
0.4207445979118347,
-0.4870855510234833,
-0.3788231313228607,
0.29042571783065796,
0.47930800914764404,
-0.23354560136795044,
0.20996026694774628,
-0.35718539357185364,
-0.243696928024292,
0.14856529235839844,
0.9485450983047485,
-0.15776176750659943,
-0.8861194849014282,
-0.39345479011535645,
0.0863824188709259,
0.21047751605510712,
0.5180263519287109,
1.062788486480713,
-0.7549823522567749,
0.6442008018493652,
0.47723332047462463,
0.5312204360961914,
0.8932656049728394,
0.10747381299734116,
0.625923752784729,
-0.42043739557266235,
-0.1346767693758011,
0.3874087929725647,
0.2657453119754791,
-0.17212292551994324,
-0.6637322902679443,
0.669270932674408,
-0.007272855844348669,
-0.5906261205673218,
-0.6395460367202759,
0.45502692461013794,
-1.4044468402862549,
-0.465340793132782,
1.001513957977295,
0.2517946660518646,
-0.3035515248775482,
0.037417709827423096,
-0.7298576831817627,
0.2672414183616638,
-0.6890442967414856,
0.9659913778305054,
0.6501556634902954,
-0.5586420297622681,
-0.15270522236824036,
-0.02189277857542038,
0.6415672898292542,
0.6497820019721985,
-0.8860569000244141,
0.3160392940044403,
0.0535975843667984,
0.25083494186401367,
-0.08907247334718704,
0.5928542017936707,
0.09771782159805298,
0.11961718648672104,
-0.4905981123447418,
-0.27387624979019165,
0.03209589794278145,
-0.3679192364215851,
0.2123558074235916,
-0.02998395264148712,
0.5449855923652649,
-0.21078841388225555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09133v1
|
RH-SQL: Refined Schema and Hardness Prompt for Text-to-SQL
| 2024-06-13T14:04:34 | 2024-06-13T14:04:34 |
Jiawen Yi, Guo Chen, Zixiang Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Text-to-SQL is a technology that converts natural language queries into the
structured query language SQL. A novel research approach that has recently
gained attention focuses on methods based on the complexity of SQL queries,
achieving notable performance improvements. However, existing methods entail
significant storage and training costs, which hampers their practical
application. To address this issue, this paper introduces a method for
Text-to-SQL based on Refined Schema and Hardness Prompt. By filtering out
low-relevance schema information with a refined schema and identifying query
hardness through a Language Model (LM) to form prompts, this method reduces
storage and training costs while maintaining performance. It's worth mentioning
that this method is applicable to any sequence-to-sequence (seq2seq) LM. Our
experiments on the Spider dataset, specifically with large-scale LMs, achieved
an exceptional Execution accuracy (EX) of 82.6%, demonstrating the
effectiveness and greater suitability of our method for real-world
applications.
|
[
-0.008567377924919128,
-1.1642987728118896,
0.646361231803894,
-0.17145571112632751,
-0.437211811542511,
-0.09664515405893326,
-0.4295732378959656,
-0.08076527714729309,
0.3186255693435669,
0.8804953098297119,
-0.732112467288971,
-0.8342483043670654,
-0.23000124096870422,
0.48000049591064453,
-0.40757426619529724,
1.0127778053283691,
0.2383139431476593,
-0.08460405468940735,
-0.35913747549057007,
-0.15705439448356628,
-0.32113897800445557,
-0.45773372054100037,
-0.09695643931627274,
0.05518496409058571,
0.42460277676582336,
0.7546915411949158,
0.7449036240577698,
1.0294950008392334,
0.7372182607650757,
0.14223447442054749,
-0.21867400407791138,
0.408335417509079,
-0.469524085521698,
0.8696280121803284,
-0.4698677361011505,
-0.48764562606811523,
-0.5060461759567261,
-0.3908275365829468,
0.6286060810089111,
0.9621502161026001,
-0.48216500878334045,
0.12783020734786987,
0.12274722009897232,
0.9645386934280396,
-0.611490786075592,
-0.07674549520015717,
-0.7128228545188904,
0.10627297312021255,
-0.39358577132225037,
-0.6885229349136353,
-0.9243490099906921,
-0.4202466607093811,
-0.16829006373882294,
-0.5566040873527527,
0.3213558793067932,
0.3203740417957306,
0.6963087916374207,
0.30815985798835754,
-0.6212586760520935,
-0.23954559862613678,
-0.4889835715293884,
0.624061644077301,
-0.5059976577758789,
0.44248244166374207,
0.32744160294532776,
0.29545658826828003,
-0.5001140832901001,
-0.8097875714302063,
-0.47009503841400146,
-0.42646023631095886,
-0.4030161499977112,
-0.15023230016231537,
0.3992895483970642,
0.2177884578704834,
0.568195641040802,
0.28950250148773193,
-0.8070968985557556,
-0.0691843256354332,
-0.3507459759712219,
0.022593311965465546,
0.5166536569595337,
0.4549826979637146,
0.21622227132320404,
-0.5814139246940613,
-0.17956532537937164,
0.06651075929403305,
-0.7473486661911011,
-0.026419756934046745,
0.08154874294996262,
1.075595498085022,
0.11286966502666473,
1.0441572666168213,
-0.7243150472640991,
0.736966073513031,
0.00654349010437727,
-0.16315194964408875,
-0.02818203903734684,
-0.27916353940963745,
-0.01844683289527893,
-0.29081010818481445,
0.6068179607391357,
0.34400704503059387,
0.20779047906398773,
-0.2762770652770996,
-0.21629130840301514,
-0.08593947440385818,
0.18286700546741486,
-1.0185319185256958,
-0.042917653918266296,
0.33542710542678833,
-0.6048117280006409,
-0.044269662350416183,
-0.16231705248355865,
-1.0511053800582886,
-0.8235763311386108,
-0.21560174226760864,
0.02616187557578087,
-0.4390450119972229,
-0.08218913525342941,
-0.26156511902809143,
-0.09987500309944153,
0.28165075182914734,
0.16424208879470825,
-0.9429187178611755,
0.506321907043457,
0.7489590644836426,
0.728488564491272,
-0.5252526998519897,
-0.016423355787992477,
-0.6986103653907776,
0.2580428421497345,
-0.2551189064979553,
0.7014099359512329,
-0.5104307532310486,
-0.5554767847061157,
-0.011752010323107243,
0.0367942713201046,
0.1144409328699112,
-0.43265312910079956,
0.5368638634681702,
-0.5347312688827515,
0.2678203582763672,
-0.1179032251238823,
-0.7534728050231934,
0.017951710149645805,
0.2434549480676651,
-0.6301150321960449,
1.2813596725463867,
0.3151724338531494,
-0.5386999249458313,
0.40027734637260437,
-0.40272772312164307,
-0.7344313859939575,
0.4281163811683655,
-0.24042469263076782,
-0.15340979397296906,
0.07237352430820465,
0.0911329835653305,
0.34388598799705505,
-0.6200971603393555,
0.2955130934715271,
-0.279107004404068,
-0.5712551474571228,
-0.11548962444067001,
-0.07340499013662338,
0.5319189429283142,
0.28070926666259766,
-0.19079886376857758,
0.06468218564987183,
-0.819882869720459,
0.25704848766326904,
0.15127819776535034,
-0.3934245705604553,
-0.28399962186813354,
0.05667714402079582,
-0.31638002395629883,
0.05250825732946396,
0.36273378133773804,
-0.1954425573348999,
0.4315265119075775,
-0.6830814480781555,
0.44413164258003235,
0.41928255558013916,
-0.06275966763496399,
0.7978274822235107,
0.16834743320941925,
0.5881842374801636,
-0.3702166676521301,
0.20613425970077515,
-0.296861469745636,
-0.41543805599212646,
-0.7093434929847717,
-0.27122899889945984,
0.2795637249946594,
0.9931623339653015,
-0.6341343522071838,
0.5682966113090515,
-0.5233346223831177,
-0.5044736862182617,
-0.3534642457962036,
0.05499615892767906,
0.15323688089847565,
0.7989744544029236,
0.5433005690574646,
-0.2327149659395218,
-0.2746681869029999,
-0.8186101317405701,
-0.605590283870697,
-0.01384027861058712,
-0.08707980811595917,
0.7761748433113098,
0.41930970549583435,
0.018084976822137833,
1.1046428680419922,
-0.6636192798614502,
-0.035719890147447586,
-0.23440846800804138,
-0.13736481964588165,
0.4314955174922943,
0.3527858555316925,
0.02265993319451809,
-0.4965231418609619,
-0.3324679434299469,
-0.17672386765480042,
-0.9284329414367676,
0.07446115463972092,
0.22107911109924316,
0.04553407058119774,
0.6585056781768799,
0.7241902947425842,
-0.8390462398529053,
0.6290742754936218,
0.048609185963869095,
-0.5180266499519348,
0.51654052734375,
-0.2469947338104248,
0.5006908178329468,
-0.9459341168403625,
0.18755492568016052,
-0.2169603556394577,
-0.12875384092330933,
-0.49367406964302063,
0.48370981216430664,
0.2660502791404724,
-0.4464215040206909,
-0.31036630272865295,
0.5091633200645447,
-0.3697913587093353,
-0.09370885044336319,
0.1006707102060318,
0.14562469720840454,
0.13336269557476044,
0.5477902889251709,
0.10765978693962097,
0.9436067342758179,
0.32776084542274475,
-0.8386272192001343,
0.24131441116333008,
0.15959705412387848,
-0.14614525437355042,
0.7835081815719604,
-0.5891391634941101,
0.3345276713371277,
-0.12014047801494598,
0.29109787940979004,
-0.9692705273628235,
-0.32655203342437744,
0.2388334721326828,
-0.41283944249153137,
0.24506565928459167,
-0.4767235517501831,
-0.5921524167060852,
-0.20214414596557617,
-0.30085089802742004,
0.32482585310935974,
0.41570940613746643,
-0.27080386877059937,
0.9305848479270935,
0.04768569394946098,
-0.49554604291915894,
-0.5080117583274841,
-0.6835755705833435,
0.38825076818466187,
-0.3132649064064026,
-0.7574276924133301,
0.5214125514030457,
0.212521031498909,
-0.12538835406303406,
-0.35436397790908813,
0.09091150760650635,
-0.2693581283092499,
-0.13506613671779633,
0.27485981583595276,
0.3930712342262268,
-0.09062326699495316,
0.30174171924591064,
0.13913750648498535,
-0.15076570212841034,
-0.14750514924526215,
0.05686505511403084,
0.5704298615455627,
0.12541060149669647,
-0.1454618275165558,
-0.5168194770812988,
0.6947635412216187,
0.3456761837005615,
-0.1007649302482605,
0.6490910649299622,
0.0005482152919284999,
-0.303591251373291,
-0.20980452001094818,
-0.20742566883563995,
-0.9014052748680115,
-0.49654263257980347,
0.42115646600723267,
-0.5704228281974792,
-0.7755669355392456,
0.29836171865463257,
-0.32626551389694214,
-0.18371903896331787,
0.40261971950531006,
0.12525494396686554,
-0.3179419934749603,
1.1065142154693604,
0.37359458208084106,
0.49266478419303894,
0.27942171692848206,
0.09055333584547043,
0.2279801219701767,
-0.34930744767189026,
-0.43382424116134644,
-0.9971620440483093,
0.18646854162216187,
-0.7704514265060425,
-0.2881154716014862,
0.37165480852127075,
0.03649606555700302,
-0.5625156164169312,
0.42280685901641846,
-0.7622436881065369,
0.35141903162002563,
0.321248859167099,
0.46796655654907227,
0.5170403718948364,
0.2728436589241028,
0.08094464242458344,
-0.34448376297950745,
-0.42765873670578003,
-0.394445538520813,
1.0886344909667969,
0.07097125798463821,
0.6841415166854858,
0.24253395199775696,
0.6470367908477783,
0.5850621461868286,
-0.10321801155805588,
-0.9029995799064636,
1.0317671298980713,
-0.19402477145195007,
-0.5309749841690063,
-0.4657687246799469,
-0.5987595915794373,
-0.7860590815544128,
-0.01667580008506775,
-0.33663052320480347,
-0.41076627373695374,
-0.11871279776096344,
0.09218572825193405,
-0.12171918898820877,
-0.044767431914806366,
-0.6394158601760864,
0.5879353284835815,
0.0932566449046135,
-0.5013867616653442,
-0.44371628761291504,
-0.8209158778190613,
0.2998494803905487,
0.3512452244758606,
0.1674417406320572,
0.023180188611149788,
-0.2429148405790329,
0.7087774276733398,
-0.8621857762336731,
0.5008505582809448,
-0.24970002472400665,
-0.0637335255742073,
0.17561456561088562,
0.3408161401748657,
1.060095191001892,
-0.09792560338973999,
-0.4992043972015381,
-0.11677778512239456,
-0.18022789061069489,
-0.41327905654907227,
-0.779248058795929,
0.3988540470600128,
-0.07956710457801819,
-0.5456303358078003,
-0.4149918258190155,
-0.5111448168754578,
-0.2612384259700775,
0.17167961597442627,
0.23248589038848877,
0.4402785897254944,
0.08885089308023453,
0.23180150985717773,
0.7308743000030518,
-0.11435563862323761,
0.10336166620254517,
0.4373217225074768,
-0.14443112909793854,
-0.49829259514808655,
0.573360800743103,
0.15100882947444916,
0.13633684813976288,
0.46201246976852417,
0.08058581501245499,
-0.701730489730835,
-0.579552173614502,
-0.5789298415184021,
0.13579650223255157,
-0.7525296211242676,
-0.31663668155670166,
-0.5730656981468201,
0.0579509511590004,
-0.5599339008331299,
-0.08801265060901642,
-0.017752330750226974,
-0.8175721764564514,
-0.2683041989803314,
0.015150629915297031,
0.9204839468002319,
0.26681673526763916,
0.4846593141555786,
0.46443110704421997,
-0.6944258213043213,
0.3320556581020355,
0.2139233946800232,
0.41195112466812134,
-0.37772655487060547,
-0.9033273458480835,
0.1521264761686325,
-0.22449342906475067,
0.042308807373046875,
-1.126262903213501,
0.232682004570961,
0.38740435242652893,
0.10358553379774094,
-0.0654558464884758,
0.34438785910606384,
0.5405213832855225,
-0.42409080266952515,
0.7510069608688354,
-0.03548046201467514,
-0.8218015432357788,
0.9945402145385742,
-0.6103506088256836,
-0.12466108053922653,
0.9746542572975159,
-0.0079824049025774,
-0.2343098670244217,
0.019948579370975494,
-0.5020459890365601,
-1.129191279411316,
0.5879702568054199,
-0.06716997921466827,
0.04554440453648567,
0.15629038214683533,
0.813010573387146,
0.04469471424818039,
0.26270583271980286,
-0.42264506220817566,
-0.4612106680870056,
0.0843297466635704,
-0.24070240557193756,
0.28780215978622437,
-0.365957647562027,
0.08564069122076035,
-0.2867244482040405,
0.41047683358192444,
-0.2627672851085663,
-0.07177108526229858,
-0.004787634126842022,
-0.2804529666900635,
0.17568248510360718,
0.5623170137405396,
0.1558798849582672,
0.4761531352996826,
-0.4049336016178131,
-0.06370113790035248,
0.5361186265945435,
-0.5968950390815735,
-0.08567952364683151,
0.09743233025074005,
-0.47191259264945984,
-0.12219107151031494,
0.11128992587327957,
0.3995927572250366,
-0.04604414850473404,
-0.7495691776275635,
0.4524114727973938,
0.14929644763469696,
0.11170440912246704,
0.21590490639209747,
0.16343705356121063,
-0.18781568109989166,
-0.226098895072937,
0.5031606554985046,
-0.20527292788028717,
0.609118640422821,
-0.6157304644584656,
0.3356384336948395,
0.2202916294336319,
-0.46524307131767273,
0.24970388412475586,
0.2712523341178894,
0.4504416882991791,
-0.5505119562149048,
0.9755930304527283,
-0.35562893748283386,
-0.2121228277683258,
0.4834701716899872,
0.4991127550601959,
0.4213889539241791,
-0.268505334854126,
0.06706994026899338,
0.5449455380439758,
0.15754148364067078,
-0.05131461098790169,
0.8685848712921143,
-0.17314939200878143,
-0.019202180206775665,
-0.4096110761165619,
-0.4291485548019409,
-0.5665389895439148,
-0.3300464451313019,
-0.8041645884513855,
0.5826860070228577,
-0.4463199973106384,
-0.18201196193695068,
-0.18785469233989716,
0.22047394514083862,
-0.33208832144737244,
0.3245750069618225,
-0.5876469612121582,
1.1374082565307617,
-0.5281529426574707,
0.621675968170166,
0.35023415088653564,
-0.3492218852043152,
-0.765807032585144,
-0.3250688314437866,
-0.16014014184474945,
-0.6508480906486511,
0.2354360669851303,
0.2020334154367447,
-0.09446927905082703,
0.14850439131259918,
-0.6535730361938477,
-0.40866902470588684,
1.0477670431137085,
0.4511108696460724,
-0.7105576992034912,
0.03289329260587692,
0.36548087000846863,
0.33915960788726807,
-0.19790300726890564,
0.40173158049583435,
0.8311699628829956,
0.6294425129890442,
0.04409800097346306,
-0.6655803322792053,
0.5238410234451294,
-0.19332976639270782,
-0.17013868689537048,
0.45656004548072815,
-0.14141331613063812,
0.8000380396842957,
-0.4938085377216339,
-0.3501780331134796,
0.32166787981987,
0.8751959800720215,
0.7928824424743652,
0.4864537715911865,
0.4712776839733124,
0.3624219000339508,
1.0441359281539917,
-0.1717676818370819,
0.805943489074707,
-0.2778022587299347,
0.2453240603208542,
1.0258723497390747,
-0.5732356309890747,
1.0323362350463867,
0.61138516664505,
-0.42764919996261597,
0.8653964996337891,
0.5646337270736694,
0.12117604166269302,
0.43252044916152954,
0.326856791973114,
-0.10284023731946945,
-0.34168651700019836,
-0.4503743350505829,
-0.5802341103553772,
0.2466849386692047,
0.5902022123336792,
-0.20707933604717255,
-0.16548234224319458,
-0.2666613459587097,
0.1442798674106598,
0.5443538427352905,
-0.20182748138904572,
0.7933195233345032,
-0.004672644194215536,
-0.7944930195808411,
0.46490269899368286,
-0.02737661823630333,
0.7648683786392212,
-0.5562419295310974,
-0.164147287607193,
-0.40559855103492737,
-0.16190646588802338,
-0.4129258990287781,
-0.9212352633476257,
0.31627047061920166,
0.007544882129877806,
-0.3866576850414276,
0.11064323782920837,
0.8735640048980713,
-0.4064185321331024,
-0.21551436185836792,
-0.0353722870349884,
0.5291159749031067,
0.33448708057403564,
-0.2862646281719208,
-0.5472691655158997,
-0.25704482197761536,
-0.24801155924797058,
-0.18897949159145355,
0.1607494056224823,
0.43043363094329834,
-0.0626741424202919,
0.6804066300392151,
0.6045039892196655,
-0.04150037094950676,
-0.40394872426986694,
0.13830679655075073,
0.6095637083053589,
-1.225256085395813,
-0.7377517819404602,
-0.7890607714653015,
0.3215707838535309,
-0.2869893014431,
-0.2082817405462265,
0.5948699116706848,
0.6637513637542725,
-0.18197229504585266,
0.07391829043626785,
0.5435560941696167,
-0.13746987283229828,
0.7782034873962402,
-0.5506988763809204,
0.5947096347808838,
-0.4617423713207245,
0.40975621342658997,
0.011764897964894772,
-0.7186082601547241,
-0.21220342814922333,
0.22982771694660187,
0.0758558139204979,
0.2067221850156784,
0.8559982180595398,
1.286136507987976,
0.31113559007644653,
0.20099355280399323,
-0.15519718825817108,
-0.034919172525405884,
-0.045828405767679214,
0.3397274613380432,
0.6062271595001221,
-0.37291622161865234,
0.7782121300697327,
-0.06941834837198257,
-0.24063986539840698,
-0.4235735535621643,
-1.0668220520019531,
-0.5892919301986694,
-0.5501194596290588,
-0.15820631384849548,
-0.9699061512947083,
0.30910488963127136,
0.8374974131584167,
0.735283374786377,
-0.6306449174880981,
-0.07273497432470322,
-0.2330474555492401,
0.25455397367477417,
-0.21967339515686035,
-0.25316718220710754,
0.7272388935089111,
-0.3924476206302643,
-0.3637123107910156,
0.5762832760810852,
0.20101669430732727,
-0.1044984981417656,
-0.10449068248271942,
-0.07477240264415741,
0.12591557204723358,
0.19230440258979797,
0.5302329063415527,
0.26388898491859436,
-0.3892023265361786,
-0.021616701036691666,
0.3737645745277405,
-0.5285049080848694,
0.061009764671325684,
0.7948907613754272,
-0.9957994222640991,
0.027391066774725914,
0.7335420250892639,
0.22400718927383423,
0.4466155767440796,
0.06491267681121826,
0.4899959862232208,
-0.9332775473594666,
0.06747187674045563,
0.32847318053245544,
0.10055036097764969,
0.40389126539230347,
-0.6340128183364868,
0.7314159870147705,
0.3302398920059204,
-0.4249224066734314,
-1.140832781791687,
0.25866788625717163,
-1.1846741437911987,
-0.2847992777824402,
1.3825924396514893,
0.2559081017971039,
-0.24127520620822906,
-0.42008423805236816,
-0.04809044674038887,
0.2012559473514557,
-0.5748475790023804,
0.6185404062271118,
0.21185176074504852,
0.061095334589481354,
0.0004118245851714164,
-0.29805007576942444,
0.8081420063972473,
0.6042860150337219,
-1.001930832862854,
0.3455374836921692,
0.43241003155708313,
0.088859423995018,
-0.02589034102857113,
0.548730731010437,
0.006889503449201584,
0.3288024067878723,
-0.1150742769241333,
-0.0241438839584589,
0.17599350214004517,
-0.4477985203266144,
-0.33720406889915466,
0.44335997104644775,
-0.07011809945106506,
0.11774081736803055
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09128v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09128v1
|
CoastTerm: a Corpus for Multidisciplinary Term Extraction in Coastal Scientific Literature
| 2024-06-13T14:01:08 | 2024-06-13T14:01:08 |
Julien Delaunay, Hanh Thi Hong Tran, Carlos-Emiliano González-Gallardo, Georgeta Bordea, Mathilde Ducos, Nicolas Sidere, Antoine Doucet, Senja Pollak, Olivier De Viron
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The growing impact of climate change on coastal areas, particularly active
but fragile regions, necessitates collaboration among diverse stakeholders and
disciplines to formulate effective environmental protection policies. We
introduce a novel specialized corpus comprising 2,491 sentences from 410
scientific abstracts concerning coastal areas, for the Automatic Term
Extraction (ATE) and Classification (ATC) tasks. Inspired by the ARDI
framework, focused on the identification of Actors, Resources, Dynamics and
Interactions, we automatically extract domain terms and their distinct roles in
the functioning of coastal systems by leveraging monolingual and multilingual
transformer models. The evaluation demonstrates consistent results, achieving
an F1 score of approximately 80\% for automated term extraction and F1 of 70\%
for extracting terms and their labels. These findings are promising and signify
an initial step towards the development of a specialized Knowledge Base
dedicated to coastal areas.
|
[
-0.8066412210464478,
-0.6218634843826294,
0.7329834699630737,
0.11953448504209518,
-0.30653873085975647,
0.36260223388671875,
-0.332369327545166,
-0.4618862271308899,
0.35598257184028625,
0.7052498459815979,
-0.41650450229644775,
-0.6790306568145752,
-0.8147876262664795,
0.28128960728645325,
-0.22503456473350525,
0.9913370609283447,
0.19818298518657684,
-0.21300341188907623,
-0.08735588937997818,
-0.1330123096704483,
-0.06650950759649277,
-0.2570396661758423,
-0.5809289216995239,
0.20321355760097504,
0.741217315196991,
0.3221057057380676,
0.6020217537879944,
0.7816906571388245,
0.6705916523933411,
0.31547728180885315,
-0.3057723641395569,
0.08385445922613144,
-0.05555575713515282,
0.01180922333151102,
-0.6500876545906067,
-0.3836023509502411,
-0.5842586159706116,
0.09025295078754425,
0.4834974706172943,
0.2457534670829773,
-0.07780624181032181,
0.4587491452693939,
-0.15478231012821198,
0.21262149512767792,
-0.6836562156677246,
0.5046148300170898,
-0.7475409507751465,
-0.3808501064777374,
-0.3147316575050354,
-0.35525256395339966,
-0.139077290892601,
-0.040979206562042236,
0.2549015283584595,
-0.3802805542945862,
0.4154141843318939,
-0.08086199313402176,
0.5818180441856384,
0.4510912597179413,
-0.6534302234649658,
-0.2712206542491913,
-0.3045543432235718,
0.787391722202301,
-0.5511524677276611,
0.1394723802804947,
-0.11129633337259293,
0.10283957421779633,
-0.09311463683843613,
-0.5100640058517456,
-0.5469884872436523,
0.3382755517959595,
0.07152201235294342,
0.3651050627231598,
-0.45220640301704407,
0.1460440754890442,
-0.18513476848602295,
0.16144581139087677,
-0.19278773665428162,
0.3012796640396118,
-0.8595749735832214,
-0.1965951770544052,
0.73172527551651,
0.07169421017169952,
0.22180531919002533,
-0.646371066570282,
-0.5491728186607361,
-0.25990527868270874,
-0.7055945992469788,
0.15839020907878876,
0.3984198570251465,
0.703869640827179,
-0.02568644843995571,
0.26523396372795105,
-0.024571798741817474,
0.30488595366477966,
-0.5587579607963562,
-0.05568758398294449,
-0.03547941520810127,
-0.2326401174068451,
0.2270302027463913,
0.06474608927965164,
0.8215441107749939,
0.24105578660964966,
-0.21755395829677582,
-0.03903552144765854,
-0.2873232364654541,
-0.16241812705993652,
0.19737547636032104,
-0.28221145272254944,
-0.4671138823032379,
0.27351635694503784,
-0.4384230077266693,
-0.5652493238449097,
0.4271414577960968,
-1.680675745010376,
-0.3018721640110016,
-0.2588111460208893,
-0.08774487674236298,
0.10740314424037933,
-0.6251394152641296,
-0.08896393328905106,
-0.3931901752948761,
-0.19857490062713623,
-0.030250705778598785,
-0.06573031842708588,
0.33710977435112,
0.37219998240470886,
1.003513216972351,
-0.83665931224823,
-0.0684949979186058,
-0.1412811130285263,
0.08566499501466751,
0.1380673050880432,
1.3157974481582642,
-0.6708496809005737,
-0.6959716081619263,
-0.2179187536239624,
0.26104268431663513,
-0.12588906288146973,
-0.17317448556423187,
0.4668870270252228,
-0.5995814204216003,
0.011153139173984528,
0.09087543189525604,
0.08393507450819016,
-0.5595637559890747,
-0.16438396275043488,
-0.8943673968315125,
0.7460259199142456,
0.10493742674589157,
-0.35558760166168213,
-0.12651486694812775,
-0.8902754783630371,
-0.20085753500461578,
-0.015652408823370934,
0.22998479008674622,
-0.088043712079525,
0.05036476254463196,
0.22581665217876434,
0.30218908190727234,
-0.6476860046386719,
0.022967712953686714,
-0.2556903660297394,
0.5461238026618958,
0.2330319583415985,
-0.28349223732948303,
0.536521852016449,
0.5728328227996826,
-0.04074906185269356,
0.2973838448524475,
-0.8025228381156921,
0.3949989378452301,
-0.40482836961746216,
-0.3642233908176422,
-0.38402241468429565,
0.08644816279411316,
0.35773786902427673,
0.396484911441803,
0.397398978471756,
-0.729464054107666,
-0.10701757669448853,
-0.04062734916806221,
0.8075425028800964,
0.6446643471717834,
0.36432185769081116,
0.5210772752761841,
-0.23705348372459412,
1.0587600469589233,
-0.1835838109254837,
-0.299249529838562,
-0.11707471311092377,
-0.2550026476383209,
-0.5130847692489624,
-0.7617121934890747,
0.10461514443159103,
0.6296339631080627,
-0.9460621476173401,
0.352605938911438,
-0.33338627219200134,
-0.8963984251022339,
-0.24167899787425995,
-0.18866899609565735,
0.4034636318683624,
0.2635664939880371,
0.7474086284637451,
-0.05841434746980667,
-0.6057236194610596,
-0.6953800916671753,
0.10223468393087387,
-0.16200833022594452,
0.32236340641975403,
0.078774094581604,
0.42366892099380493,
-0.1431998908519745,
1.3439170122146606,
-0.7626177072525024,
-0.3322131633758545,
-0.08849881589412689,
0.42003241181373596,
0.1988532990217209,
0.4526933431625366,
0.4668597877025604,
-0.8213485479354858,
0.05888485908508301,
-0.20814000070095062,
-0.4517410397529602,
-0.6496142745018005,
0.11319062113761902,
-0.1782844066619873,
-0.15342582762241364,
0.8104937672615051,
-0.5503867268562317,
0.3378521203994751,
0.253682017326355,
-0.3329946994781494,
0.6532692313194275,
-0.19088609516620636,
0.11845681816339493,
-0.83149254322052,
0.18115156888961792,
0.28498172760009766,
-0.08740741014480591,
-0.3117715120315552,
0.5398228168487549,
-0.12780743837356567,
-0.07304108142852783,
-0.5347741842269897,
0.4780091345310211,
-0.5470871925354004,
0.2751399576663971,
-0.4793044924736023,
0.30331963300704956,
-0.20860473811626434,
0.1319732815027237,
0.535881757736206,
0.4553655982017517,
0.2554912269115448,
-0.744824230670929,
0.40933340787887573,
0.34726589918136597,
0.26222050189971924,
0.5590807199478149,
-0.5266476273536682,
-0.08419405668973923,
-0.17843438684940338,
0.2196911722421646,
-0.8356149792671204,
0.0367489792406559,
-0.3127193748950958,
-0.023907717317342758,
-0.1950109601020813,
-0.1968604326248169,
-0.26273342967033386,
-0.5783581137657166,
-0.20632751286029816,
0.33943289518356323,
0.17947031557559967,
-0.3574869632720947,
0.8023685812950134,
0.8406614065170288,
-0.646733820438385,
-0.033607471734285355,
-0.5312512516975403,
0.06773900240659714,
-0.6045170426368713,
-0.2787010073661804,
0.07050062716007233,
0.22423875331878662,
-0.3473072946071625,
0.05856350064277649,
-0.21888941526412964,
-0.34309035539627075,
0.23211294412612915,
0.3849658966064453,
0.28440001606941223,
-0.2666197121143341,
0.20098236203193665,
0.19250591099262238,
-0.08670542389154434,
0.1948998123407364,
-0.1496250480413437,
0.4390422999858856,
-0.2857733964920044,
0.19791316986083984,
0.1037871316075325,
0.36436790227890015,
0.6796228289604187,
-0.761443555355072,
0.14029955863952637,
0.5441635847091675,
-0.11436901986598969,
-0.17382551729679108,
-0.43003249168395996,
-0.07793450355529785,
-0.41027653217315674,
0.5059590935707092,
-0.47587519884109497,
-0.6172170639038086,
0.7580013871192932,
-0.3853210210800171,
-0.12964485585689545,
0.7992655634880066,
0.20207753777503967,
0.32321465015411377,
0.3750010132789612,
1.00298011302948,
0.07508224993944168,
0.2605389952659607,
-0.03267383947968483,
0.0010293637169525027,
-0.7778862118721008,
-0.18908652663230896,
-0.5605089664459229,
-0.22911836206912994,
-0.5878572463989258,
-0.34316134452819824,
0.5047985911369324,
0.0349910594522953,
-0.11914481222629547,
0.7666720151901245,
-0.8464442491531372,
0.31410089135169983,
0.351876437664032,
0.29446232318878174,
0.4826472997665405,
-0.12481650710105896,
0.2867223918437958,
-0.10045627504587173,
-0.5184810161590576,
-0.932640552520752,
0.88084876537323,
0.10908015817403793,
0.5025203227996826,
0.43025779724121094,
0.762923002243042,
0.46872469782829285,
0.3128696084022522,
-0.6868468523025513,
0.7139729857444763,
-0.1299954056739807,
-0.3554674983024597,
-0.04679061099886894,
-0.28865233063697815,
-1.110520362854004,
0.43423283100128174,
-0.293941468000412,
-0.767608642578125,
0.51399827003479,
-0.4547370970249176,
-0.6162132024765015,
0.2628546357154846,
-0.35801413655281067,
0.5824475884437561,
-0.16879884898662567,
-0.09431048482656479,
-0.5405437350273132,
-0.6909615397453308,
0.18909773230552673,
-0.4493587017059326,
0.8359904289245605,
-0.6273576617240906,
-0.7626643180847168,
0.9807294607162476,
-0.2710651159286499,
0.6996399164199829,
-0.20656374096870422,
-0.24383540451526642,
0.5521000623703003,
0.31066006422042847,
-0.22435462474822998,
0.26943179965019226,
-0.07949403673410416,
0.13694991171360016,
0.6842241883277893,
-0.15936237573623657,
0.009285811334848404,
0.5513096451759338,
-0.6844573616981506,
-0.48092731833457947,
-0.7253825664520264,
-0.5832942128181458,
-0.18043051660060883,
0.5179804563522339,
0.03263946622610092,
0.2658452093601227,
-0.3237982988357544,
-0.2641468346118927,
0.5648927688598633,
-0.08667843788862228,
0.8329333662986755,
0.9676844477653503,
-0.16878975927829742,
-0.7035323977470398,
0.9645245671272278,
-0.1756385713815689,
0.16299477219581604,
0.1558474451303482,
0.13005313277244568,
-0.008644851855933666,
-0.5929951071739197,
0.19660407304763794,
0.055309560149908066,
-0.7158169746398926,
-0.6892455220222473,
-0.7342294454574585,
-0.06453400105237961,
-0.19581547379493713,
-0.07783475518226624,
-0.3510472774505615,
-0.4138670861721039,
-0.22867882251739502,
-0.22646324336528778,
0.42239511013031006,
0.8095212578773499,
-0.3492968678474426,
0.6258336901664734,
-1.003951072692871,
0.08841101825237274,
-0.47883233428001404,
-0.3747003972530365,
-0.2186804562807083,
-0.22240754961967468,
0.09966981410980225,
0.0001484806416556239,
-0.1636035442352295,
-0.6746053099632263,
0.8184363842010498,
0.49536022543907166,
0.5172479748725891,
0.21848377585411072,
0.13941960036754608,
0.5212216973304749,
-0.23500020802021027,
0.7388774156570435,
0.2010776698589325,
-0.8087961673736572,
0.5822808146476746,
-0.2911825478076935,
0.594558596611023,
0.5968708395957947,
0.6529527902603149,
-0.4120875298976898,
-0.5158556699752808,
-0.7136812210083008,
-1.1404683589935303,
0.3756922483444214,
-0.41581663489341736,
-0.012560219503939152,
-0.32417574524879456,
0.10415659844875336,
0.39774563908576965,
0.3479686677455902,
-0.18873754143714905,
0.24624453485012054,
0.10294727236032486,
-0.27463358640670776,
0.017219949513673782,
-0.011617581360042095,
-0.17192454636096954,
-0.016656717285513878,
0.492649108171463,
-0.2809819281101227,
0.2320617139339447,
0.36716005206108093,
-0.2751050293445587,
0.23359711468219757,
0.23550008237361908,
0.46300140023231506,
0.5089348554611206,
0.13699708878993988,
0.5947394967079163,
-0.03869127482175827,
-0.8261945843696594,
-0.03365461528301239,
0.3087333142757416,
0.32810577750205994,
-0.04062294214963913,
0.6202295422554016,
0.07216214388608932,
0.43719518184661865,
-0.7418036460876465,
0.1746566891670227,
0.07075399905443192,
0.23768043518066406,
-0.2426934540271759,
-0.11387678235769272,
-0.22872895002365112,
0.38878095149993896,
0.6199163198471069,
0.49926844239234924,
0.1824994534254074,
-0.5372546911239624,
0.5343655347824097,
0.10483796894550323,
-0.30731597542762756,
-0.3743784427642822,
0.6749297380447388,
0.3367528021335602,
0.31430917978286743,
0.47526103258132935,
-0.22596967220306396,
-0.7584975361824036,
0.8121628761291504,
0.14620341360569,
0.4786714017391205,
-0.2541598975658417,
0.1985376477241516,
0.44026944041252136,
0.09870550781488419,
-0.22220584750175476,
0.5541809797286987,
0.15431895852088928,
-0.6740071773529053,
-0.07447543740272522,
-0.7438151240348816,
-0.04885372892022133,
-0.3425617218017578,
-0.7961270809173584,
0.5289993286132812,
-0.4603492319583893,
-0.4492235481739044,
0.16816556453704834,
-0.3010476231575012,
-0.45891785621643066,
-0.20925433933734894,
0.2304290533065796,
0.9286776185035706,
-0.9177042245864868,
0.5291971564292908,
0.8691294193267822,
-0.754062831401825,
-0.43240049481391907,
-0.4424564838409424,
0.25227683782577515,
-0.46277448534965515,
0.6026897430419922,
-0.10244280844926834,
-0.3972596228122711,
0.26137951016426086,
-0.5121992230415344,
-1.1977620124816895,
1.1391206979751587,
-0.11299490183591843,
-0.26324814558029175,
0.007330216933041811,
-0.057906195521354675,
0.6447371244430542,
-0.6992581486701965,
0.5352945923805237,
0.6926354169845581,
0.6860608458518982,
-0.18575377762317657,
-1.1247615814208984,
0.27639785408973694,
-0.21039672195911407,
-0.08879700303077698,
0.048732493072748184,
-0.692097008228302,
0.8242533802986145,
-0.107316754758358,
-0.3510162830352783,
0.3037579655647278,
0.8269851207733154,
0.04423915967345238,
0.029692279174923897,
0.5218393206596375,
0.2423175871372223,
0.8301606178283691,
-0.3429165184497833,
0.6845636367797852,
-0.5569781064987183,
0.317975252866745,
1.014762282371521,
0.12475966662168503,
1.099819540977478,
0.4692336916923523,
-0.27106180787086487,
0.7528046369552612,
0.7811194658279419,
-0.1565268635749817,
0.7853683233261108,
0.09664531797170639,
-0.4602668583393097,
-0.15703293681144714,
-0.21053911745548248,
-0.008483515121042728,
0.7119234800338745,
0.6726003289222717,
-0.0314798578619957,
-0.6616337299346924,
0.4558786153793335,
0.17668598890304565,
0.35393717885017395,
-0.7659387588500977,
0.6715458631515503,
0.2764098346233368,
-0.6307224035263062,
0.20592446625232697,
0.06773325800895691,
0.7810503840446472,
-0.37402215600013733,
0.11418953537940979,
0.21593399345874786,
0.20943844318389893,
-0.6815934181213379,
-0.9091915488243103,
0.42189764976501465,
-0.08217987418174744,
-0.17289365828037262,
-0.19754183292388916,
0.5358873009681702,
-0.7301470041275024,
-0.3017279803752899,
0.11465100198984146,
0.9421564936637878,
0.37827426195144653,
-0.16571833193302155,
-0.6186536550521851,
-0.10684845596551895,
-0.17640897631645203,
-0.17629237473011017,
-0.21062524616718292,
0.4444054663181305,
-0.2706407308578491,
0.6066961884498596,
0.5709836483001709,
0.2749535143375397,
0.12485026568174362,
-0.451113224029541,
0.6736913919448853,
-0.6273109912872314,
-0.44414380192756653,
-0.6704279780387878,
0.2258484959602356,
-0.20154507458209991,
-0.5040174722671509,
0.765925407409668,
0.4933779537677765,
0.3037669360637665,
-0.10949904471635818,
0.9278627634048462,
-0.568209707736969,
0.23289243876934052,
-0.2754558324813843,
0.6046340465545654,
-0.004662635270506144,
0.20000749826431274,
0.11719024181365967,
-0.9780114889144897,
-0.08810202777385712,
0.14681191742420197,
-0.4829268157482147,
-0.28964048624038696,
1.0920212268829346,
0.5821549296379089,
-0.001248203101567924,
0.30276867747306824,
-0.3005068898200989,
-0.00676347641274333,
0.5164376497268677,
0.3377057611942291,
0.3474896550178528,
0.07795623689889908,
0.5896775722503662,
-0.2713784873485565,
-0.37221166491508484,
0.22735746204853058,
-0.9344223141670227,
-0.6375654339790344,
-0.7408943772315979,
-0.5454988479614258,
-0.3285391926765442,
-0.10385002195835114,
0.943025529384613,
0.3461131751537323,
-0.9501191973686218,
-0.3251415491104126,
-0.16638681292533875,
-0.007543120998889208,
-0.27944689989089966,
-0.3346014618873596,
0.5849215984344482,
-0.46154284477233887,
-0.617941677570343,
0.5821930170059204,
-0.002356714103370905,
-0.23146335780620575,
-0.4099883735179901,
0.4696304500102997,
-0.4354071617126465,
-0.010118710808455944,
0.429820716381073,
0.4490800201892853,
-0.4398282766342163,
-0.2553936541080475,
-0.28686442971229553,
-0.12693087756633759,
-0.11426371335983276,
0.7014569044113159,
-0.76347815990448,
0.2668880224227905,
0.3728471100330353,
0.4014914631843567,
0.22886227071285248,
0.05055075138807297,
0.7275698184967041,
-0.49277353286743164,
0.20617027580738068,
0.20412775874137878,
0.3537653684616089,
0.1266832798719406,
-0.21682530641555786,
0.8491795659065247,
0.43677523732185364,
-0.4054580330848694,
-0.5951123833656311,
-0.041876453906297684,
-0.9937220215797424,
-0.3962130546569824,
1.278255820274353,
-0.28991061449050903,
-0.49817004799842834,
-0.07794760167598724,
-0.33440133929252625,
-0.016360612586140633,
-0.5707740187644958,
0.5485110878944397,
0.8829917311668396,
-0.06111256778240204,
-0.2582157850265503,
-0.556268572807312,
0.4293659031391144,
-0.09067017585039139,
-0.7603771686553955,
0.012952680699527264,
0.3076380491256714,
0.3446139097213745,
0.6124565601348877,
-0.06280448287725449,
-0.24143996834754944,
0.09464365243911743,
-0.20880669355392456,
0.5501461625099182,
-0.11516876518726349,
0.060183729976415634,
-0.26196834444999695,
0.28961285948753357,
-0.19260863959789276,
0.3238663971424103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09105v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09105v1
|
INS-MMBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Evaluating LVLMs' Performance in Insurance
| 2024-06-13T13:31:49 | 2024-06-13T13:31:49 |
Chenwei Lin, Hanjia Lyu, Xian Xu, Jiebo Luo
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have demonstrated outstanding
performance in various general multimodal applications such as image
recognition and visual reasoning, and have also shown promising potential in
specialized domains. However, the application potential of LVLMs in the
insurance domain-characterized by rich application scenarios and abundant
multimodal data-has not been effectively explored. There is no systematic
review of multimodal tasks in the insurance domain, nor a benchmark
specifically designed to evaluate the capabilities of LVLMs in insurance. This
gap hinders the development of LVLMs within the insurance domain. In this
paper, we systematically review and distill multimodal tasks for four
representative types of insurance: auto insurance, property insurance, health
insurance, and agricultural insurance. We propose INS-MMBench, the first
comprehensive LVLMs benchmark tailored for the insurance domain. INS-MMBench
comprises a total of 2.2K thoroughly designed multiple-choice questions,
covering 12 meta-tasks and 22 fundamental tasks. Furthermore, we evaluate
multiple representative LVLMs, including closed-source models such as GPT-4o
and open-source models like BLIP-2. This evaluation not only validates the
effectiveness of our benchmark but also provides an in-depth performance
analysis of current LVLMs on various multimodal tasks in the insurance domain.
We hope that INS-MMBench will facilitate the further application of LVLMs in
the insurance domain and inspire interdisciplinary development. Our dataset and
evaluation code are available at https://github.com/FDU-INS/INS-MMBench.
|
[
-0.2308807224035263,
-0.4994807839393616,
0.12695583701133728,
0.39209476113319397,
0.0038758364971727133,
0.24544230103492737,
0.01134299673140049,
-0.5587783455848694,
-0.2454383820295334,
0.364884614944458,
-0.5302984714508057,
-0.479636013507843,
-0.03332141786813736,
-0.2536962926387787,
-0.2976186275482178,
0.6036583781242371,
-0.05277059227228165,
0.18284417688846588,
-0.6805421113967896,
-0.2711496651172638,
-0.0518919974565506,
-0.4444572627544403,
-0.4000474214553833,
-0.2916812002658844,
0.5743410587310791,
0.022809656336903572,
0.357866495847702,
-0.07222060859203339,
0.8299506306648254,
0.27754393219947815,
0.1488221138715744,
0.3054462671279907,
-0.10909070819616318,
-0.057115983217954636,
-0.07087396085262299,
-0.15458685159683228,
-0.4056776165962219,
-0.12314742803573608,
0.8338889479637146,
0.28703778982162476,
-0.526305079460144,
0.24320419132709503,
0.14640183746814728,
0.5444316267967224,
-0.9899564385414124,
0.1924443393945694,
-0.4103124737739563,
0.20430314540863037,
-0.1697746217250824,
-0.30590930581092834,
-0.6605790257453918,
-0.18792417645454407,
0.30394211411476135,
-0.2615135610103607,
-0.16066686809062958,
0.3558691442012787,
0.7977640628814697,
0.27898669242858887,
-0.8565343618392944,
-0.030334051698446274,
-0.41162946820259094,
0.7410669326782227,
-0.4854913353919983,
0.6042742729187012,
0.30113887786865234,
0.5354732871055603,
-0.13521288335323334,
-0.5701887607574463,
-0.40914055705070496,
-0.7103773951530457,
-0.010570227168500423,
0.5327239632606506,
-0.5559724569320679,
0.2635366916656494,
0.1741556078195572,
0.29755207896232605,
-0.5846795439720154,
0.6241070032119751,
-0.28089240193367004,
-0.4723849594593048,
0.6699685454368591,
0.4372355341911316,
0.10634928196668625,
0.012262897565960884,
-0.6654493808746338,
-0.2289140820503235,
-0.6855751276016235,
0.45632192492485046,
0.2557133734226227,
-0.12113533169031143,
-0.03799425810575485,
0.8178156018257141,
-0.45464497804641724,
0.7907242774963379,
-0.7159578800201416,
-0.6484270691871643,
0.6528008580207825,
-0.4163185656070709,
-0.5159433484077454,
-0.14196768403053284,
0.6759308576583862,
0.7805814743041992,
-0.06201951205730438,
-0.19611705839633942,
-0.29083016514778137,
0.04005144536495209,
0.1359596997499466,
-0.6674296259880066,
0.42117923498153687,
0.13963058590888977,
-0.521183431148529,
-0.35253483057022095,
-0.2416498214006424,
-0.7540254592895508,
-0.41516873240470886,
-0.30444979667663574,
0.32507020235061646,
-0.39681297540664673,
-0.19370301067829132,
0.17841166257858276,
-0.1291218400001526,
0.5335780382156372,
0.20064397156238556,
-0.16348378360271454,
0.23428605496883392,
0.5977360010147095,
0.7030025124549866,
-0.24965262413024902,
-0.22648030519485474,
-0.4018164277076721,
0.1763269603252411,
0.10894351452589035,
0.8302502036094666,
-0.3066612184047699,
-0.10278927534818649,
0.236653134226799,
-0.18579667806625366,
-0.21229888498783112,
-0.326841801404953,
0.48526325821876526,
-0.27926382422447205,
-0.04081752896308899,
0.2276405692100525,
-0.48196595907211304,
-0.2907937467098236,
0.6808578968048096,
-0.557669460773468,
0.7399269342422485,
0.2479245513677597,
-0.6096715927124023,
0.5676577091217041,
-0.6073544025421143,
-0.11772888898849487,
-0.0432470440864563,
-0.23969076573848724,
-0.7914742231369019,
0.11272424459457397,
0.015405683778226376,
0.40948009490966797,
-0.6639611124992371,
0.03988894820213318,
-0.7015044689178467,
-0.06224735453724861,
0.6431034803390503,
-0.6839765906333923,
0.6707070469856262,
0.018756810575723648,
0.012863394804298878,
0.28075459599494934,
-0.997812032699585,
0.2411791980266571,
-0.06395069509744644,
-0.1409735530614853,
-0.5173971652984619,
0.03666276857256889,
0.25054603815078735,
0.2962261140346527,
0.11043128371238708,
-0.7953914999961853,
0.15806469321250916,
-0.2729494571685791,
0.2843385338783264,
0.8136853575706482,
-0.16747020184993744,
0.16179311275482178,
-0.21909725666046143,
0.49063050746917725,
0.1385568529367447,
0.35525208711624146,
-0.019014693796634674,
-0.15584035217761993,
-0.5802276134490967,
-0.6548727750778198,
0.2491385042667389,
0.611713707447052,
-0.8605309724807739,
0.02674756571650505,
-0.026997700333595276,
-0.7430566549301147,
-0.5032247304916382,
-0.34232035279273987,
0.564193069934845,
0.44312113523483276,
0.23920223116874695,
-0.3340246379375458,
-0.009133568033576012,
-1.3278340101242065,
-0.39846718311309814,
0.23852206766605377,
0.14454437792301178,
0.24927188456058502,
0.694477915763855,
-0.30245503783226013,
0.9176045060157776,
-0.5319141149520874,
-0.5780320763587952,
-0.12157045304775238,
0.06901079416275024,
-0.07211506366729736,
0.22990290820598602,
0.9191759824752808,
-0.7864178419113159,
-0.36870938539505005,
0.19501587748527527,
-0.6605962514877319,
0.16713637113571167,
0.14049160480499268,
0.12743507325649261,
0.25995633006095886,
0.37917399406433105,
-0.5151022672653198,
0.5695253610610962,
0.6940585970878601,
-0.3764050006866455,
0.7281358242034912,
-0.44893237948417664,
-0.0030272179283201694,
-0.8878947496414185,
0.04229652136564255,
0.12304552644491196,
-0.40343335270881653,
-0.37278449535369873,
0.06356737017631531,
0.2524188160896301,
-0.03367045149207115,
-0.4589287340641022,
0.5456323623657227,
-0.5898733139038086,
-0.2715933918952942,
0.20419657230377197,
-0.3322889506816864,
-0.13363873958587646,
0.5067232847213745,
-0.5087453722953796,
0.8528242707252502,
0.8090956211090088,
-0.4621470868587494,
0.5734798908233643,
0.0345093198120594,
-0.8685904741287231,
0.7778130769729614,
-0.5290285348892212,
-0.13667114078998566,
-0.33033064007759094,
0.175334170460701,
-0.6227909922599792,
-0.08697430789470673,
0.21915104985237122,
0.2963252663612366,
0.07970894128084183,
0.2790096402168274,
-0.6239031553268433,
-0.5264807343482971,
-0.18842767179012299,
0.13903605937957764,
0.28757548332214355,
-0.08267036080360413,
1.0633786916732788,
0.4040474593639374,
-0.07385938614606857,
-0.9531165957450867,
-0.7448229789733887,
0.0020073619671165943,
-0.3661164343357086,
-0.6212380528450012,
0.30285194516181946,
-0.0209966953843832,
-0.4377637803554535,
0.2638475298881531,
-0.07315251231193542,
-0.07059087604284286,
-0.14541995525360107,
0.26327693462371826,
0.14981025457382202,
-0.1770828366279602,
0.3861066997051239,
-0.05590158700942993,
-0.3530208468437195,
-0.05319661647081375,
-0.0332215242087841,
0.255664587020874,
-0.4961480498313904,
-0.6890495419502258,
-0.27992331981658936,
0.3394448161125183,
0.6088697910308838,
-0.8435927033424377,
0.7661293148994446,
0.2964860796928406,
-0.09561634808778763,
-0.13416822254657745,
-0.8658890724182129,
0.2811414301395416,
-0.4017539322376251,
0.48674482107162476,
-0.5652616620063782,
-0.8646435737609863,
0.3732112646102905,
-0.24065349996089935,
0.16428722441196442,
0.4974530339241028,
0.60640949010849,
-0.28723475337028503,
0.6502265930175781,
0.8290483951568604,
0.06257990002632141,
0.5741106867790222,
-0.12227773666381836,
-0.10441683977842331,
-0.47922995686531067,
-0.3507702350616455,
-0.2186911404132843,
-0.13468819856643677,
-0.22524897754192352,
-0.4507807195186615,
0.7023314833641052,
-0.4546591341495514,
0.07949952036142349,
0.21322472393512726,
-0.19360199570655823,
0.2381618171930313,
0.5018135905265808,
0.24983814358711243,
0.4100624918937683,
0.07641082257032394,
-0.20518015325069427,
0.16749164462089539,
-0.41884469985961914,
-0.13631655275821686,
1.063220739364624,
0.4344800114631653,
0.78574538230896,
0.11953984200954437,
0.2333296537399292,
0.22842837870121002,
0.6905200481414795,
-0.41562512516975403,
0.3915182650089264,
-0.17126381397247314,
-0.5042725205421448,
-0.21271754801273346,
-0.4033012092113495,
-0.8836064338684082,
0.5870662331581116,
-0.22873221337795258,
-0.6888191103935242,
0.31461837887763977,
0.19405333697795868,
-0.5446223020553589,
0.1063518226146698,
-0.6916989684104919,
1.0191845893859863,
-0.5090934038162231,
-0.17431224882602692,
-0.5771816968917847,
-0.4975472092628479,
0.4251056909561157,
-0.10436084121465683,
0.16639257967472076,
-0.4980579614639282,
0.016550453379750252,
0.24057038128376007,
-0.34380993247032166,
0.7528367638587952,
-0.09333554655313492,
-0.08436226099729538,
0.3599560558795929,
-0.21200455725193024,
0.3226967453956604,
-0.17544585466384888,
-0.1846432089805603,
0.20302531123161316,
0.18853718042373657,
-0.05287373811006546,
-0.5458447337150574,
0.4220491647720337,
-0.35661837458610535,
0.13413900136947632,
-0.5162844061851501,
-0.6242716908454895,
-0.5164180994033813,
0.2278638333082199,
-0.008680482394993305,
0.7943294644355774,
-0.40439334511756897,
0.459455668926239,
0.34287890791893005,
-0.3533482551574707,
0.43628832697868347,
0.8999096751213074,
-0.282816082239151,
-0.3719404935836792,
0.8869336247444153,
0.29768526554107666,
0.3894307613372803,
0.46084657311439514,
0.10838315635919571,
-0.33968228101730347,
-0.40082988142967224,
-0.26129817962646484,
-0.09568075090646744,
-0.7950562238693237,
-0.4480040371417999,
-0.6565456390380859,
-0.18304388225078583,
0.15726369619369507,
0.18795084953308105,
-0.3980891704559326,
-0.013680465519428253,
0.31831440329551697,
-0.05864782631397247,
0.24985675513744354,
0.33701789379119873,
0.22735370695590973,
0.19498106837272644,
-0.5623342394828796,
0.29861778020858765,
0.22685787081718445,
0.5563042759895325,
-0.23531627655029297,
0.1731831431388855,
-0.17549394071102142,
-0.2136595994234085,
-0.14567692577838898,
-0.5528759956359863,
0.12131675332784653,
0.11703870445489883,
0.7608698010444641,
0.5105806589126587,
-0.017108943313360214,
0.7532026767730713,
-0.6405467391014099,
0.20900976657867432,
0.35596391558647156,
-0.5899679064750671,
0.13906331360340118,
0.09789944440126419,
-0.009848859161138535,
0.7129911184310913,
0.1239585131406784,
-0.2645680606365204,
-0.2746720612049103,
-0.33643838763237,
-0.7632785439491272,
0.28971973061561584,
0.23243123292922974,
-0.0019248309545218945,
0.3893842399120331,
-0.30773425102233887,
0.011450259946286678,
0.5489685535430908,
-0.7912923097610474,
-0.0631151795387268,
0.19712799787521362,
-0.0848996713757515,
-0.09835879504680634,
-0.5290008187294006,
-0.2636163830757141,
-0.18694782257080078,
0.42719143629074097,
-0.14320947229862213,
-0.05043269693851471,
0.16030310094356537,
-0.08389740437269211,
0.13164392113685608,
0.3903569281101227,
0.9356677532196045,
0.7431021928787231,
-0.35661450028419495,
-0.05814661458134651,
0.12072759121656418,
-0.1759260594844818,
0.060316190123558044,
0.45304057002067566,
-0.10244956612586975,
0.07152201980352402,
0.3803284764289856,
0.9465059041976929,
0.2916099727153778,
-1.0144827365875244,
0.8589353561401367,
-0.025540580973029137,
-0.19172383844852448,
-0.8494651913642883,
-0.08591309189796448,
-0.28820422291755676,
0.4377027451992035,
0.08410799503326416,
0.2729617655277252,
0.23887579143047333,
-0.45068103075027466,
0.1587599515914917,
0.6747774481773376,
-0.5828055739402771,
0.20587560534477234,
0.4332399368286133,
0.23547038435935974,
0.010333712212741375,
0.5918729901313782,
-0.08801467716693878,
0.04482879489660263,
0.6170975565910339,
0.1707366555929184,
0.8394995331764221,
-0.05851205065846443,
-0.0026205938775092363,
0.13684986531734467,
0.6219752430915833,
0.13697616755962372,
0.42989078164100647,
0.159026101231575,
-0.6624270081520081,
-0.5535764098167419,
-0.7011794447898865,
-0.41248801350593567,
0.01903609000146389,
-0.49729979038238525,
0.10579084604978561,
-0.056230731308460236,
-0.1733943074941635,
-0.007264480926096439,
-0.6053875088691711,
-1.00040864944458,
0.16597992181777954,
0.08559692651033401,
1.2153141498565674,
-0.3176184296607971,
0.5268601179122925,
0.3899248540401459,
-0.6095672249794006,
-0.4512273073196411,
-0.1816825419664383,
0.05142045021057129,
-0.9676073789596558,
0.593021810054779,
0.34562447667121887,
-0.2608652710914612,
-0.11454801261425018,
-0.2625860869884491,
-0.7975301146507263,
1.230218529701233,
0.3484046459197998,
-0.7278560400009155,
-0.14023302495479584,
0.25115928053855896,
0.46073392033576965,
-0.2792390286922455,
0.33040809631347656,
0.4363512098789215,
0.5292421579360962,
-0.25500428676605225,
-1.1138081550598145,
-0.38813209533691406,
-0.06604255735874176,
-0.14363892376422882,
0.1360960751771927,
-0.8554776906967163,
0.7101526260375977,
-0.05634423345327377,
-0.04994786158204079,
0.12002607434988022,
0.6555969715118408,
0.026478055864572525,
0.5445123314857483,
0.7325195074081421,
0.621433675289154,
0.5713356137275696,
-0.23594577610492706,
1.5312846899032593,
-0.12354032695293427,
0.5682229995727539,
0.905095636844635,
-0.49647757411003113,
0.85563725233078,
0.3084777593612671,
-0.3143930733203888,
0.490753710269928,
0.3029668927192688,
-0.14440982043743134,
0.560573160648346,
0.4649640619754791,
-0.3362332284450531,
-0.23252633213996887,
-0.2902323305606842,
-0.4139542579650879,
0.7459781765937805,
0.2862800061702728,
-0.21948257088661194,
-0.345930278301239,
0.5934549570083618,
-0.4699285626411438,
-0.511183500289917,
-0.47456225752830505,
0.6600539088249207,
0.22860632836818695,
-0.4523374140262604,
-0.017438165843486786,
-0.0408138670027256,
0.3910001814365387,
-1.1919838190078735,
0.012277205474674702,
0.15814848244190216,
0.4521663188934326,
0.008917226456105709,
-0.8411519527435303,
0.23360691964626312,
-0.32823270559310913,
0.014585434459149837,
-0.50130295753479,
0.9344756603240967,
-0.40730318427085876,
-0.646941065788269,
0.2555214464664459,
0.3421860933303833,
0.10438980162143707,
-0.2695120573043823,
-0.6304264664649963,
-0.22184737026691437,
-0.38115501403808594,
-0.3893667757511139,
0.29406505823135376,
0.3455088138580322,
-0.17859482765197754,
1.0067256689071655,
0.7353203892707825,
-0.15642204880714417,
-0.007499758154153824,
0.1693924218416214,
0.8132929801940918,
-0.6566368937492371,
-0.5087765455245972,
-0.9283066391944885,
0.9975986480712891,
-0.3211679756641388,
-0.6547247767448425,
0.8090330362319946,
0.6311107873916626,
0.7123730182647705,
-0.3301065266132355,
0.5393932461738586,
-0.0064401812851428986,
0.4060156047344208,
-0.6666035652160645,
0.5463646650314331,
-1.112571120262146,
-0.3391394317150116,
-0.329110324382782,
-0.7608986496925354,
-0.26596060395240784,
0.34445080161094666,
-0.2423708438873291,
-0.2776382267475128,
0.5384336709976196,
0.709374725818634,
-0.049805667251348495,
-0.3795601725578308,
0.5719079375267029,
0.15354026854038239,
0.2309688776731491,
0.24262142181396484,
1.0352214574813843,
-0.016564154997467995,
0.49731066823005676,
-0.31583625078201294,
-0.1844412386417389,
-0.3909451961517334,
-0.958581805229187,
-0.7834950089454651,
-0.34920430183410645,
-0.22414153814315796,
-0.17549985647201538,
-0.13176946341991425,
0.7488626837730408,
0.478436142206192,
-0.585146427154541,
-0.1823088675737381,
0.2607056498527527,
-0.06874687224626541,
-0.5611967444419861,
-0.18184897303581238,
0.2585553824901581,
-0.0909280851483345,
-0.31970253586769104,
0.523956298828125,
0.9025750160217285,
0.09557024389505386,
-0.5929356217384338,
0.19980819523334503,
0.259052038192749,
-0.13676846027374268,
0.9354470372200012,
0.04715026915073395,
-0.8934401869773865,
-0.046022072434425354,
-0.2778998613357544,
-0.39396992325782776,
-0.20054295659065247,
0.87754225730896,
-0.46593040227890015,
0.6365978717803955,
0.19251763820648193,
0.7698253989219666,
0.3446652889251709,
-0.2443767935037613,
0.4525921940803528,
-0.5265266299247742,
0.5984346270561218,
0.28294867277145386,
0.7130950689315796,
-0.11210350692272186,
-0.03353872522711754,
0.6664490103721619,
-0.03358804062008858,
-0.3586314618587494,
-1.0216714143753052,
0.3380550444126129,
-1.0852705240249634,
-0.11023435741662979,
0.7868210673332214,
0.0829988420009613,
-0.09648941457271576,
-0.03589248284697533,
-0.33955690264701843,
-0.28514039516448975,
-0.14876124262809753,
0.1762629747390747,
0.6222925782203674,
-0.0730009600520134,
-0.4542864263057709,
-0.8962081074714661,
0.33670178055763245,
0.22942839562892914,
-0.9043298959732056,
-0.0962759405374527,
0.45086240768432617,
0.21496297419071198,
0.019610343500971794,
0.8109812140464783,
0.21633873879909515,
0.2564794719219208,
0.01928759180009365,
0.4175575077533722,
-0.32216542959213257,
-0.30273720622062683,
-0.07815241813659668,
0.38534364104270935,
-0.2100299447774887,
-0.19142574071884155
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09103v1
|
Chain-of-Though (CoT) prompting strategies for medical error detection and correction
| 2024-06-13T13:31:04 | 2024-06-13T13:31:04 |
Zhaolong Wu, Abul Hasan, Jinge Wu, Yunsoo Kim, Jason P. Y. Cheung, Teng Zhang, Honghan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper describes our submission to the MEDIQA-CORR 2024 shared task for
automatically detecting and correcting medical errors in clinical notes. We
report results for three methods of few-shot In-Context Learning (ICL)
augmented with Chain-of-Thought (CoT) and reason prompts using a large language
model (LLM). In the first method, we manually analyse a subset of train and
validation dataset to infer three CoT prompts by examining error types in the
clinical notes. In the second method, we utilise the training dataset to prompt
the LLM to deduce reasons about their correctness or incorrectness. The
constructed CoTs and reasons are then augmented with ICL examples to solve the
tasks of error detection, span identification, and error correction. Finally,
we combine the two methods using a rule-based ensemble method. Across the three
sub-tasks, our ensemble method achieves a ranking of 3rd for both sub-task 1
and 2, while securing 7th place in sub-task 3 among all submissions.
|
[
-0.17935985326766968,
-0.6385947465896606,
1.0305629968643188,
0.3407881259918213,
-0.26416265964508057,
0.054424259811639786,
-0.0332108773291111,
-0.3498081564903259,
0.007505547255277634,
0.34711754322052,
-0.8218175768852234,
-0.5437561273574829,
-0.5357256531715393,
0.5833197236061096,
-0.2230452448129654,
1.175389051437378,
-0.5096819996833801,
0.4727710783481598,
-0.28579312562942505,
-0.28810134530067444,
-1.0055021047592163,
-0.6902374625205994,
-0.7762710452079773,
-0.11516135931015015,
0.8051101565361023,
0.8478184938430786,
-0.05179239809513092,
0.3371034264564514,
0.8275240659713745,
0.16533291339874268,
0.17818975448608398,
0.6892222762107849,
-0.11028160154819489,
0.03388412296772003,
-0.2127731293439865,
-0.5710560083389282,
-0.7306211590766907,
-0.1616707444190979,
0.4587162733078003,
0.3816082179546356,
-0.10862208157777786,
0.05258803814649582,
0.05488096922636032,
0.7424307465553284,
-0.6827743053436279,
-0.10647733509540558,
-0.39556998014450073,
-0.002687673317268491,
-0.18245035409927368,
-0.5862277150154114,
-0.7078334093093872,
-0.16651979088783264,
-0.007678622845560312,
-0.34021028876304626,
0.19044417142868042,
0.2917032837867737,
0.4749711751937866,
0.35061752796173096,
-0.32520535588264465,
-0.9176298975944519,
-0.42098578810691833,
0.6501067876815796,
-0.6064801812171936,
0.03026248887181282,
0.5041874051094055,
0.18856878578662872,
-0.21495090425014496,
-0.6946335434913635,
-0.6831268668174744,
0.058107804507017136,
-0.17079539597034454,
0.24255985021591187,
-0.046656426042318344,
0.290569543838501,
0.26878151297569275,
0.04828280210494995,
-0.2948015034198761,
0.12559254467487335,
-0.2994327247142792,
-0.21559719741344452,
0.6631263494491577,
0.34650787711143494,
0.3851030468940735,
-0.012119636870920658,
-0.48508280515670776,
-0.19973960518836975,
-0.7522037029266357,
-0.1256556361913681,
-0.20665675401687622,
0.19491346180438995,
-0.519946813583374,
0.33642858266830444,
0.16137085855007172,
0.7181097269058228,
0.22715742886066437,
-0.2672886252403259,
0.18928027153015137,
-0.4109342098236084,
-0.12984687089920044,
0.49838125705718994,
0.8005226850509644,
0.3570580780506134,
-0.16874681413173676,
0.1444079577922821,
-0.3852084279060364,
0.12825287878513336,
0.2168387919664383,
-0.07651067525148392,
-0.23358695209026337,
0.42200541496276855,
-0.37281396985054016,
-0.31078004837036133,
-0.18836268782615662,
-0.8587073683738708,
-0.33930397033691406,
-0.23698262870311737,
0.592414379119873,
-0.3719790577888489,
0.37817108631134033,
0.07286934554576874,
-0.09975573420524597,
-0.1351553499698639,
0.7613021731376648,
-0.6650582551956177,
0.39550352096557617,
0.41700515151023865,
0.7912032604217529,
-0.23671121895313263,
-0.2434338480234146,
-0.8079086542129517,
-0.06737213581800461,
-0.5140597224235535,
1.2168850898742676,
-0.08358249813318253,
-0.20385994017124176,
-0.2529199719429016,
-0.22144591808319092,
-0.39712557196617126,
-0.5075463056564331,
0.6488555669784546,
-0.10929568111896515,
0.3248186409473419,
-0.5094189643859863,
-0.5959675312042236,
-0.007807049434632063,
0.5090300440788269,
-0.6288931369781494,
0.7417852878570557,
0.1867697387933731,
-0.7315421104431152,
0.4929298758506775,
-0.9835102558135986,
-0.31919488310813904,
-0.023829344660043716,
-0.4576718509197235,
-0.6021144986152649,
-0.14298440515995026,
0.5587557554244995,
0.3964342474937439,
-0.1924934983253479,
0.25641342997550964,
0.04579788073897362,
-0.2765055298805237,
0.3137863874435425,
-0.39981627464294434,
0.6869317889213562,
0.11778896301984787,
-0.5385275483131409,
0.2923513948917389,
-0.837999165058136,
0.0943235456943512,
-0.1955038458108902,
-0.3420719802379608,
-0.15682098269462585,
-0.23109813034534454,
-0.14064890146255493,
0.41137731075286865,
-0.2160174697637558,
-0.37442564964294434,
0.272487074136734,
0.10992584377527237,
0.2333148717880249,
0.6743273735046387,
0.38518640398979187,
-0.049881406128406525,
-0.6410821080207825,
0.6565168499946594,
0.3566281199455261,
0.2879703640937805,
-0.2296040952205658,
-0.5197473168373108,
-0.6067872643470764,
-0.3624390959739685,
0.22032766044139862,
0.6707299947738647,
-0.8677440881729126,
0.35727521777153015,
0.29290395975112915,
-0.21992897987365723,
-0.6469516158103943,
0.018765849992632866,
0.5920920372009277,
0.8822903037071228,
0.6961022019386292,
-0.16111412644386292,
-1.0761903524398804,
-0.25969040393829346,
-0.0453202947974205,
-0.37630587816238403,
0.3973362147808075,
0.17768003046512604,
0.680224597454071,
-0.35935452580451965,
0.6816123723983765,
-0.24385546147823334,
-0.3950638175010681,
-0.2899510860443115,
0.291337251663208,
0.18664991855621338,
0.6455512642860413,
0.22380660474300385,
-0.3860503137111664,
-0.3624197840690613,
0.025398876518011093,
-0.8392903208732605,
-0.22618776559829712,
-0.3609673082828522,
0.010865896008908749,
0.34443384408950806,
0.5766590237617493,
-0.17166049778461456,
0.626429557800293,
0.37979063391685486,
-0.05174387991428375,
0.6201561689376831,
-0.49310582876205444,
0.46575793623924255,
-0.9861855506896973,
-0.07724088430404663,
-0.20510821044445038,
-0.22884637117385864,
-0.5069109201431274,
-0.20816166698932648,
0.15473516285419464,
0.4753516614437103,
-0.39367395639419556,
0.32640665769577026,
-0.3336566984653473,
0.32451021671295166,
-0.217488095164299,
0.05441121757030487,
0.08405011147260666,
0.3188507854938507,
-0.11590743809938431,
0.5635396242141724,
0.5375145077705383,
-0.6727938652038574,
0.3512580096721649,
0.31285056471824646,
0.008207319304347038,
0.7875381708145142,
-0.33272919058799744,
0.28686487674713135,
-0.21040810644626617,
0.6306678056716919,
-1.151708960533142,
-0.4766005873680115,
0.34074077010154724,
-0.23511375486850739,
0.31469714641571045,
-0.02081264927983284,
-0.396225243806839,
-0.6211399435997009,
-0.22017529606819153,
0.6779059767723083,
0.12784048914909363,
-0.6626535654067993,
0.14701266586780548,
0.12484270334243774,
0.09996526688337326,
-0.5093859434127808,
-0.7644535303115845,
0.09118898957967758,
-0.14957986772060394,
-0.36554521322250366,
0.3248509168624878,
-0.06215107440948486,
-0.24939721822738647,
-0.3451157510280609,
0.011533314362168312,
0.05471697077155113,
-0.07701755315065384,
0.20246157050132751,
0.6143559217453003,
-0.19902266561985016,
0.37476399540901184,
0.04422418028116226,
-0.06099876016378403,
0.05295787751674652,
-0.1832476407289505,
0.43289023637771606,
-0.3544638454914093,
-0.3606363832950592,
-0.6710790395736694,
0.27924492955207825,
0.424601674079895,
0.01451176404953003,
0.45160794258117676,
0.31672659516334534,
-0.4656015634536743,
-0.19660627841949463,
-0.608781099319458,
-0.1920032948255539,
-0.36364156007766724,
-0.12295731157064438,
0.09873078763484955,
-0.665770947933197,
0.5817251205444336,
0.06878381222486496,
-0.18001936376094818,
0.5135625600814819,
0.6502811908721924,
-0.7215614318847656,
0.9599917531013489,
0.4030204713344574,
0.08460183441638947,
0.016486499458551407,
-0.37266722321510315,
0.20694735646247864,
-0.9586523175239563,
-0.20282748341560364,
-0.5733597278594971,
-0.18192006647586823,
-0.5530188083648682,
-0.4751623272895813,
0.9920008182525635,
0.051771875470876694,
0.007899472489953041,
0.09950051456689835,
-0.5025705099105835,
0.4525090754032135,
0.2826641798019409,
0.6247849464416504,
0.23867875337600708,
-0.2063433825969696,
-0.46623435616493225,
0.3178751468658447,
-1.0739625692367554,
-0.32476168870925903,
0.9283002018928528,
0.19592495262622833,
0.810969352722168,
-0.19743993878364563,
1.2398240566253662,
0.24099059402942657,
0.475251704454422,
-0.8107127547264099,
0.2599676847457886,
-0.05999837815761566,
-0.33398762345314026,
-0.15586631000041962,
-0.08442213386297226,
-0.6785416007041931,
-0.1872185468673706,
-0.18233519792556763,
-0.6797672510147095,
0.23162446916103363,
0.5680621862411499,
-0.8041555881500244,
0.2616417407989502,
-0.5232556462287903,
0.7436107397079468,
-0.2489149272441864,
-0.3123219907283783,
-0.12998785078525543,
-1.0358201265335083,
0.29066023230552673,
-0.0206023920327425,
0.3006649315357208,
0.34289902448654175,
-0.05861794948577881,
0.6847665905952454,
-0.7562029361724854,
0.8676490783691406,
0.03694729879498482,
-0.11018967628479004,
0.5846329927444458,
-0.24531540274620056,
0.7341969013214111,
-0.09662266820669174,
-0.021809019148349762,
-0.24194057285785675,
0.1325598955154419,
-0.2915940284729004,
-0.5273113250732422,
0.32408368587493896,
-0.4128730893135071,
-0.24268542230129242,
-0.6314902305603027,
-0.5861011147499084,
-0.21789312362670898,
-0.01395376492291689,
0.7014058232307434,
0.8386148810386658,
0.1940799504518509,
-0.16773873567581177,
0.4636482000350952,
-0.12804102897644043,
0.45081445574760437,
0.23027504980564117,
0.21923568844795227,
-0.3728835880756378,
0.5728469491004944,
-0.023799341171979904,
0.193876713514328,
0.42714038491249084,
0.3580642640590668,
-0.3294358253479004,
-0.6473580598831177,
-0.5106926560401917,
0.22248071432113647,
-0.9835948944091797,
-0.37070590257644653,
-0.6791143417358398,
-0.06795211136341095,
-0.18344981968402863,
-0.2596365511417389,
-0.07554662227630615,
-0.05129373446106911,
-0.2742270529270172,
-0.02016741782426834,
0.514573335647583,
0.9386640787124634,
-0.18324699997901917,
0.35851937532424927,
-1.0163174867630005,
0.037187714129686356,
-0.11099100112915039,
0.2580038011074066,
0.06950685381889343,
-0.22181043028831482,
-0.2716793119907379,
-0.03427032008767128,
-0.37644103169441223,
-0.76993727684021,
0.10256393253803253,
-0.14402787387371063,
0.4489915370941162,
0.1157248243689537,
0.07704854756593704,
1.0867254734039307,
-0.39666348695755005,
0.7335664629936218,
0.47398075461387634,
-0.9152882695198059,
0.9038810729980469,
-0.21854938566684723,
0.11640024185180664,
0.8985917568206787,
0.41102495789527893,
-0.5964930653572083,
-0.43450477719306946,
-0.6925557255744934,
-0.5615924596786499,
0.6891300082206726,
-0.10421536862850189,
-0.4678724706172943,
-0.37181830406188965,
0.3844236135482788,
0.06705126166343689,
-0.03924381360411644,
-0.5227954387664795,
-0.014014218002557755,
0.48807525634765625,
-0.6756817102432251,
0.23274768888950348,
-0.09936370700597763,
-0.2888834476470947,
-0.24915969371795654,
0.6342186331748962,
-0.5191009044647217,
0.2495604008436203,
1.0583165884017944,
-0.07406862080097198,
-0.5388538241386414,
0.44864922761917114,
1.05048406124115,
0.9972558617591858,
-0.11736863851547241,
0.2350112944841385,
0.4289827346801758,
-0.5501716136932373,
0.2681768834590912,
-0.357689768075943,
0.18390211462974548,
0.0315798856317997,
0.6264501214027405,
0.6511760950088501,
0.06915534287691116,
-0.9039631485939026,
0.542064368724823,
-0.08565589785575867,
-0.10928470641374588,
-0.17800147831439972,
-0.07885981351137161,
-0.3218863606452942,
-0.007788769900798798,
0.13240042328834534,
0.5407753586769104,
0.18171782791614532,
-0.6682237982749939,
0.516791820526123,
0.06469543278217316,
-0.5329128503799438,
-0.15424583852291107,
0.39604198932647705,
-0.12003007531166077,
-0.0680902898311615,
0.2913578152656555,
-0.26866820454597473,
-0.6861143708229065,
0.680737316608429,
0.6704679727554321,
0.7459592819213867,
-0.06907999515533447,
0.11125336587429047,
0.3711317479610443,
0.0028889880049973726,
-0.44839364290237427,
0.5523357391357422,
-0.07998160272836685,
-0.5878099203109741,
-0.5306152701377869,
0.08932539820671082,
-0.6640509963035583,
0.023635322228074074,
-0.6736225485801697,
0.656554639339447,
-0.7131906151771545,
0.0016452667769044638,
0.004823883529752493,
-0.2912941575050354,
-0.50263911485672,
0.4121461510658264,
0.015183691866695881,
0.8160409927368164,
-0.6434588432312012,
0.6896429061889648,
0.7395175099372864,
-0.40320178866386414,
-1.2943202257156372,
0.17419128119945526,
0.42128345370292664,
-0.8212268948554993,
0.5416756868362427,
0.11058150976896286,
-0.1669975370168686,
-0.38214871287345886,
-0.6607353091239929,
-0.49019789695739746,
0.9823436737060547,
-0.24129079282283783,
-0.8412171602249146,
-0.14109724760055542,
-0.2538617253303528,
0.6671367287635803,
-0.48591333627700806,
0.4316110908985138,
0.503272533416748,
0.11396773904561996,
0.19433976709842682,
-1.0541691780090332,
0.14905008673667908,
0.10856330394744873,
-0.6120079159736633,
0.26539573073387146,
-0.5887557864189148,
0.7867618799209595,
-0.6287675499916077,
0.15850253403186798,
0.16778340935707092,
0.15287832915782928,
0.7649726867675781,
0.9555516839027405,
0.5968225598335266,
0.3634561002254486,
1.1743782758712769,
0.0394761860370636,
1.1462122201919556,
0.004017283208668232,
0.15003350377082825,
1.2033809423446655,
-0.5256043672561646,
0.7612143158912659,
0.7704387307167053,
-0.17464737594127655,
0.8583881855010986,
0.6356133222579956,
0.27583956718444824,
0.44507840275764465,
0.07933451980352402,
-0.42541831731796265,
0.026231350377202034,
0.05411163717508316,
-0.16481594741344452,
0.2975253462791443,
0.6075206398963928,
-0.36826300621032715,
-0.15363164246082306,
0.23897291719913483,
-0.05943220853805542,
-0.0012987430673092604,
-0.5576308369636536,
0.9541935920715332,
0.2657744288444519,
-1.2375472784042358,
0.7664228677749634,
-0.30651164054870605,
0.4681914448738098,
-0.3486098051071167,
-0.3317045271396637,
-0.028015650808811188,
0.40927448868751526,
-0.4697103202342987,
-0.5218324661254883,
0.2060501128435135,
0.17267124354839325,
-0.2546917796134949,
0.05399951711297035,
0.6200444102287292,
-0.5181441903114319,
-0.3399426341056824,
-0.07570870220661163,
0.24829892814159393,
0.07858166843652725,
0.29661354422569275,
-0.6738626956939697,
0.09156184643507004,
-0.10195370763540268,
0.5298706293106079,
0.10229676961898804,
0.4881932735443115,
-0.48613741993904114,
0.5630435943603516,
0.4042617976665497,
0.10942373424768448,
-0.05487723648548126,
0.2594980299472809,
0.7367789149284363,
-0.5847179293632507,
-0.765684187412262,
-0.9574216604232788,
0.6129215359687805,
0.0058562252670526505,
-0.34259748458862305,
0.4152362644672394,
0.2712405323982239,
0.7014532685279846,
-0.0746123194694519,
0.7931695580482483,
0.04383622109889984,
0.6094755530357361,
-0.8694000244140625,
0.2506370544433594,
-0.38927993178367615,
0.5289576053619385,
-0.484783411026001,
-0.21056686341762543,
-0.6146529912948608,
0.530341625213623,
-0.26360511779785156,
-0.18658004701137543,
1.2973397970199585,
0.7431499361991882,
0.29828941822052,
0.32422104477882385,
-0.02204837277531624,
0.13691259920597076,
0.27233368158340454,
0.7718780040740967,
0.8501001596450806,
-0.744833767414093,
0.16070815920829773,
-0.2572864592075348,
-0.32753023505210876,
-0.4149777591228485,
-0.8869396448135376,
-0.7413779497146606,
-0.3914700746536255,
-0.6361200213432312,
-0.8534412384033203,
0.2056034803390503,
1.5323237180709839,
0.6329207420349121,
-1.1183496713638306,
-0.14831259846687317,
-0.48943907022476196,
0.3480680286884308,
-0.48752716183662415,
-0.15995781123638153,
0.5820217728614807,
-0.6339137554168701,
-0.19220095872879028,
0.44029489159584045,
0.4913828670978546,
0.07621947675943375,
0.20366619527339935,
-0.1519034206867218,
-0.47053611278533936,
-0.22548651695251465,
0.4926396608352661,
0.05043388158082962,
-0.5671878457069397,
-0.2884141206741333,
-0.0676877498626709,
-0.34064266085624695,
0.3500629961490631,
1.150742530822754,
-0.7129687666893005,
0.5719690918922424,
0.5353308916091919,
0.4389803409576416,
0.11849025636911392,
-0.10845563560724258,
0.5373279452323914,
-0.8426823616027832,
-0.04212808981537819,
0.43583759665489197,
0.435874342918396,
0.25746533274650574,
-0.6459803581237793,
0.5383912920951843,
0.32958194613456726,
-0.6497172117233276,
-0.8764336705207825,
-0.2502494156360626,
-1.1525088548660278,
0.03734912723302841,
0.6813812255859375,
-0.23418700695037842,
-0.557605504989624,
-0.40251624584198,
-0.6319724321365356,
0.159884512424469,
-0.13692457973957062,
0.8492414355278015,
0.6989639401435852,
-0.5224578976631165,
-0.27390557527542114,
-0.28356483578681946,
0.7304303050041199,
0.43862184882164,
-1.1051852703094482,
-0.3242177367210388,
0.20581258833408356,
0.11409567296504974,
0.1536845862865448,
0.9436476826667786,
-0.3505767583847046,
1.0485620498657227,
-0.16358201205730438,
-0.19752447307109833,
0.3975447416305542,
-0.4845852553844452,
-0.5744460821151733,
-0.24971745908260345,
0.0008296854794025421,
-0.4175426959991455
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09098v1
|
SciKnowEval: Evaluating Multi-level Scientific Knowledge of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T13:27:52 | 2024-06-13T13:27:52 |
Kehua Feng, Keyan Ding, Weijie Wang, Xiang Zhuang, Zeyuan Wang, Ming Qin, Yu Zhao, Jianhua Yao, Qiang Zhang, Huajun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The burgeoning utilization of Large Language Models (LLMs) in scientific
research necessitates advanced benchmarks capable of evaluating their
understanding and application of scientific knowledge comprehensively. To
address this need, we introduce the SciKnowEval benchmark, a novel framework
that systematically evaluates LLMs across five progressive levels of scientific
knowledge: studying extensively, inquiring earnestly, thinking profoundly,
discerning clearly, and practicing assiduously. These levels aim to assess the
breadth and depth of scientific knowledge in LLMs, including knowledge
coverage, inquiry and exploration capabilities, reflection and reasoning
abilities, ethic and safety considerations, as well as practice proficiency.
Specifically, we take biology and chemistry as the two instances of SciKnowEval
and construct a dataset encompassing 50K multi-level scientific problems and
solutions. By leveraging this dataset, we benchmark 20 leading open-source and
proprietary LLMs using zero-shot and few-shot prompting strategies. The results
reveal that despite achieving state-of-the-art performance, the proprietary
LLMs still have considerable room for improvement, particularly in addressing
scientific computations and applications. We anticipate that SciKnowEval will
establish a comprehensive standard for benchmarking LLMs in science research
and discovery, and promote the development of LLMs that integrate scientific
knowledge with strong safety awareness. The dataset and code are publicly
available at https://github.com/hicai-zju/sciknoweval .
|
[
0.09554079920053482,
-0.32812145352363586,
0.745635986328125,
0.5251278281211853,
0.0969366505742073,
0.49595707654953003,
-0.38779404759407043,
-0.3891662061214447,
-0.05534818023443222,
0.07088279724121094,
-0.21984699368476868,
-0.7672747373580933,
-0.5762156248092651,
0.332510381937027,
-0.22261440753936768,
0.7427306175231934,
0.12999339401721954,
0.46566057205200195,
-0.6236727833747864,
-0.14218787848949432,
-0.05548214539885521,
-0.0001756106357788667,
-0.15257452428340912,
-0.330307275056839,
0.6650913953781128,
0.29684382677078247,
0.08930275589227676,
0.5664064288139343,
0.798149824142456,
0.2666917145252228,
-0.3771379292011261,
-0.06558734178543091,
-0.7295888066291809,
0.4625946283340454,
-0.29564714431762695,
-0.45609793066978455,
-0.2885282635688782,
-0.06269606202840805,
0.9067630171775818,
0.9528972506523132,
-0.03763081505894661,
0.3526673913002014,
-0.0990225076675415,
0.47305673360824585,
-0.8215243220329285,
0.29809650778770447,
-0.620223343372345,
0.15335531532764435,
-0.19587351381778717,
-0.02097291871905327,
-0.32041218876838684,
-0.48891308903694153,
0.26028716564178467,
-0.5737608075141907,
-0.07306837290525436,
-0.07517483830451965,
0.11486474424600601,
-0.06516304612159729,
-0.3865617513656616,
-0.12213405966758728,
-0.3933565020561218,
0.9513545036315918,
-0.7156277298927307,
0.6230652928352356,
-0.03392978757619858,
0.4104151725769043,
-0.3910351097583771,
-0.8696547150611877,
-0.46542203426361084,
-0.592683732509613,
0.27446433901786804,
0.24151980876922607,
-0.10783959925174713,
-0.049754563719034195,
0.35831353068351746,
0.1576235294342041,
-0.6547220945358276,
-0.0005869243759661913,
-0.7127872109413147,
-0.20533700287342072,
0.4595664143562317,
0.12087900191545486,
-0.010797098278999329,
-0.06888672709465027,
-0.2781203091144562,
-0.11665114015340805,
-0.8662263751029968,
0.07715722173452377,
-0.12132982909679413,
0.2224331498146057,
0.1653958112001419,
0.6833620667457581,
-0.36612793803215027,
0.36943671107292175,
-0.39575645327568054,
-0.3322008550167084,
0.5720255970954895,
-0.4873143434524536,
-0.09143905341625214,
0.1782255470752716,
0.7581940293312073,
0.23910342156887054,
0.0610213428735733,
-0.028975989669561386,
0.20822550356388092,
-0.11638934910297394,
0.01311433780938387,
-1.0071302652359009,
-0.10513634234666824,
0.15288330614566803,
-0.17473937571048737,
-0.18270379304885864,
-0.3157532513141632,
-0.9091804623603821,
-0.8064697980880737,
0.05092186853289604,
0.35008013248443604,
-0.4094221293926239,
-0.28090813755989075,
0.03041597083210945,
-0.10085725784301758,
-0.04697307571768761,
0.2590527832508087,
-0.5292354822158813,
-0.0037105712108314037,
0.9095524549484253,
1.0876836776733398,
-0.2049635499715805,
-0.5685379505157471,
-0.25359317660331726,
0.33072587847709656,
-0.5340473651885986,
0.7880759239196777,
-0.6272936463356018,
-0.491302490234375,
-0.3126424252986908,
-0.22869881987571716,
0.06308656930923462,
-0.4025418758392334,
0.6234559416770935,
-0.3842274248600006,
-0.13352875411510468,
-0.3358989357948303,
-0.5833247900009155,
0.0528680756688118,
0.31945177912712097,
-0.38410183787345886,
0.9962109327316284,
-0.18065930902957916,
-0.6916153430938721,
0.6266049742698669,
-0.7988773584365845,
-0.14626780152320862,
0.5828512907028198,
-0.24679532647132874,
-0.052491411566734314,
0.12782710790634155,
-0.08754543215036392,
0.40225791931152344,
-0.20590300858020782,
0.2962079644203186,
-0.6150591969490051,
-0.17331454157829285,
0.04535607248544693,
-0.08868113160133362,
0.43537795543670654,
0.21542665362358093,
0.02788420021533966,
0.3261125385761261,
-1.0043628215789795,
0.3283333480358124,
-0.1079411432147026,
-0.2538492977619171,
-0.5615183711051941,
-0.04223233088850975,
-0.3338303864002228,
0.2855664789676666,
0.3880988657474518,
-0.9775999188423157,
0.16195741295814514,
-0.47825780510902405,
0.690022349357605,
0.5506122708320618,
0.05180649086833,
0.20191295444965363,
0.06238295137882233,
0.35493212938308716,
-0.17964178323745728,
0.18032792210578918,
-0.21062710881233215,
-0.24578721821308136,
-0.3195437490940094,
-0.5193788409233093,
0.05922217294573784,
0.27631571888923645,
-0.2799464166164398,
0.1426853984594345,
-0.3474128246307373,
-1.0215634107589722,
-0.6495019197463989,
0.20294801890850067,
0.40350303053855896,
0.7159992456436157,
0.5391224026679993,
0.08993031829595566,
-0.39317914843559265,
-0.7678439617156982,
-0.4741375744342804,
-0.09431997686624527,
-0.20616428554058075,
0.29723072052001953,
0.7971845865249634,
-0.039322465658187866,
0.680057942867279,
-0.27347853779792786,
0.03352611884474754,
0.04680338874459267,
0.191287100315094,
0.36202871799468994,
0.23830273747444153,
0.1329890787601471,
-0.37186864018440247,
-0.49435779452323914,
0.2361118644475937,
-0.9035099744796753,
-0.06967702507972717,
0.46652936935424805,
0.033374156802892685,
-0.040182992815971375,
0.6348749399185181,
-0.5331111550331116,
0.014631581492722034,
0.5002244710922241,
-0.2764013707637787,
0.7251188158988953,
-0.3010309934616089,
0.2960270941257477,
-0.8977714776992798,
0.4336208999156952,
-0.021492429077625275,
0.18632861971855164,
-0.7012903690338135,
0.007506834343075752,
0.3677700459957123,
0.026129523292183876,
-0.5713278651237488,
0.4615441560745239,
-0.4027029871940613,
-0.20219150185585022,
-0.10504461824893951,
0.09638871997594833,
-0.06425853818655014,
-0.13992063701152802,
0.07299849390983582,
0.60096675157547,
0.7517998218536377,
-0.3068545162677765,
0.46694767475128174,
0.055382512509822845,
-0.6850423812866211,
0.5190478563308716,
-0.8920817971229553,
-0.08471938222646713,
-0.1715390980243683,
0.3562879264354706,
-0.7714510560035706,
-0.18627464771270752,
-0.263542115688324,
-0.3152822256088257,
-0.016850968822836876,
0.07999648153781891,
-0.4351854920387268,
-0.45265427231788635,
-0.3930652439594269,
0.5365486145019531,
0.29817935824394226,
-0.34149250388145447,
0.4743516743183136,
0.009580419398844242,
-0.4939981997013092,
-0.7766607403755188,
-0.2990025579929352,
0.18216176331043243,
-0.17515695095062256,
-0.5733506083488464,
0.16859449446201324,
-0.2189132422208786,
-0.29466667771339417,
-0.20658911764621735,
-0.5002379417419434,
0.24326807260513306,
-0.1573769599199295,
0.23420630395412445,
0.23644118010997772,
-0.16466279327869415,
0.1046423614025116,
0.04634902998805046,
-0.03189143165946007,
0.3184099793434143,
-0.1491917371749878,
0.40789178013801575,
-0.31906503438949585,
-0.3622623383998871,
-0.04642072319984436,
0.11164131760597229,
0.8419135212898254,
-0.19681881368160248,
0.5245670676231384,
0.31590330600738525,
-0.3425399363040924,
-0.1690678596496582,
-0.4691704511642456,
-0.19426630437374115,
-0.44134244322776794,
0.809601366519928,
-0.3658638000488281,
-0.9401643872261047,
0.46334904432296753,
-0.35849273204803467,
0.06692767143249512,
0.3719911575317383,
0.6455129384994507,
-0.06882143765687943,
0.9849546551704407,
0.471462219953537,
0.15704989433288574,
-0.07366172969341278,
0.023808497935533524,
0.21465849876403809,
-0.7383496165275574,
-0.8565134406089783,
-0.7065749168395996,
0.05033145472407341,
-0.461825966835022,
-0.49463948607444763,
0.7954801917076111,
0.3086090683937073,
-0.602100133895874,
0.2056744545698166,
-0.37234941124916077,
0.7397516369819641,
0.26949000358581543,
-0.19486942887306213,
0.5298888087272644,
-0.15031978487968445,
-0.4910266697406769,
-0.11787238717079163,
-0.6597477793693542,
-0.45379844307899475,
1.2520357370376587,
0.5028005838394165,
0.6989737153053284,
-0.015418099239468575,
0.5609685778617859,
0.0349356010556221,
0.2739584147930145,
-0.655634880065918,
0.6370497345924377,
0.1093636006116867,
-0.5150853991508484,
-0.32492154836654663,
-0.6186050772666931,
-0.6925128102302551,
0.36003342270851135,
-0.16342826187610626,
-0.6861830353736877,
0.16608409583568573,
-0.07498250901699066,
-0.2591284513473511,
0.01551041565835476,
-0.5234061479568481,
0.8267940878868103,
-0.4036537706851959,
-0.46222251653671265,
-0.48519840836524963,
-0.7686408758163452,
0.47071272134780884,
-0.2557716965675354,
0.333612859249115,
-0.3591039478778839,
-0.2692262828350067,
0.7746145725250244,
-0.03326672688126564,
0.5107237696647644,
-0.08668720722198486,
-0.0996779128909111,
-0.29082003235816956,
0.21483653783798218,
0.16361258924007416,
0.20914587378501892,
-0.16015000641345978,
0.43746235966682434,
0.5060431361198425,
-0.4136907756328583,
-0.3378302752971649,
1.0851359367370605,
-0.6934588551521301,
-0.31152230501174927,
-0.7924671769142151,
-0.7709424495697021,
-0.5265525579452515,
0.46950799226760864,
-0.06927748769521713,
-0.04497428610920906,
-0.28738418221473694,
0.45392608642578125,
0.7185086011886597,
-0.285096675157547,
0.23390696942806244,
0.9160634875297546,
-0.2007584124803543,
-0.4479787051677704,
0.9172739386558533,
-0.04602913185954094,
0.42016756534576416,
0.22283747792243958,
0.35352298617362976,
-0.439369797706604,
-0.7739402651786804,
-0.06360206753015518,
0.18837624788284302,
-0.8229312300682068,
-0.3244316577911377,
-0.6468376517295837,
-0.2862875461578369,
-0.5579383969306946,
0.03567933663725853,
-0.3772162199020386,
-0.28844204545021057,
-0.010001028887927532,
-0.026870789006352425,
0.45217156410217285,
0.8566836714744568,
-0.10561001300811768,
-0.33495330810546875,
-0.617214560508728,
0.16068719327449799,
0.09332898259162903,
0.6479257941246033,
-0.01679512858390808,
-0.41516515612602234,
-0.14446435868740082,
-0.12492208182811737,
-0.08961673080921173,
-0.5253391861915588,
0.2747783660888672,
0.45320841670036316,
0.8009786009788513,
0.3628759980201721,
-0.21282024681568146,
0.6419293284416199,
-0.7310221791267395,
0.6572803854942322,
0.3955702483654022,
-0.805408775806427,
0.5328405499458313,
-0.19953638315200806,
0.3655202388763428,
0.7071810364723206,
0.7996395826339722,
-0.6436372995376587,
-0.4362800121307373,
-0.17382444441318512,
-0.8626967072486877,
0.34837430715560913,
-0.10534105449914932,
-0.18590936064720154,
0.15566682815551758,
0.15101869404315948,
0.21641619503498077,
0.25788503885269165,
-0.5390369296073914,
0.1249745711684227,
-0.41574349999427795,
-0.1526118814945221,
-0.10857217013835907,
-0.06507265567779541,
-0.3247756361961365,
-0.45674312114715576,
0.6831512451171875,
-0.23763902485370636,
-0.11057092994451523,
0.08390621095895767,
-0.14066676795482635,
-0.09749961644411087,
0.5447156429290771,
0.6888531446456909,
1.0028934478759766,
-0.34553489089012146,
0.22962598502635956,
0.24905219674110413,
-0.7850821018218994,
-0.004954480100423098,
0.2481779307126999,
0.008498077280819416,
-0.4458017647266388,
0.6096745729446411,
0.30081209540367126,
0.18785078823566437,
-1.0313286781311035,
0.22888080775737762,
0.15909609198570251,
-0.2957245707511902,
0.10673623532056808,
0.045928116887807846,
0.306686133146286,
0.44036880135536194,
0.6708942651748657,
-0.03667902946472168,
0.09454136341810226,
-0.393860787153244,
0.0058146072551608086,
0.5262923836708069,
-0.08279568701982498,
-0.18484914302825928,
0.46871790289878845,
-0.03931054472923279,
0.12949401140213013,
0.2891308665275574,
0.009460397996008396,
-0.35366132855415344,
0.3946264684200287,
0.5312783718109131,
0.42574283480644226,
-0.3149811029434204,
0.21242596209049225,
0.5458034873008728,
0.2177799940109253,
0.0021898469422012568,
0.31477463245391846,
0.0255135428160429,
-0.4312520921230316,
-0.6674327254295349,
-0.932262659072876,
-0.5174007415771484,
0.21964144706726074,
-0.3927156329154968,
0.11882484704256058,
-0.5943014025688171,
0.16072677075862885,
0.4499960243701935,
0.20698332786560059,
-0.2809075713157654,
-0.2491004765033722,
-0.047286175191402435,
1.3183157444000244,
-0.7825242877006531,
0.7381252646446228,
0.6041450500488281,
-0.21760334074497223,
-0.42234212160110474,
-0.39314699172973633,
0.15312543511390686,
-0.8932317495346069,
0.9598418474197388,
0.06852924078702927,
-0.18192358314990997,
-0.10192520916461945,
-0.7216338515281677,
-1.095084309577942,
1.3216086626052856,
0.2885705828666687,
-0.8682456016540527,
0.23998138308525085,
0.16225992143154144,
0.8652325868606567,
-0.3189064860343933,
0.46705374121665955,
0.6502719521522522,
0.6159589290618896,
0.4901543855667114,
-1.0492573976516724,
-0.023814067244529724,
-0.45701345801353455,
-0.21628817915916443,
-0.04980527237057686,
-0.4704306721687317,
0.5471227169036865,
-0.3066107928752899,
-0.023346789181232452,
0.09720670431852341,
0.5551636219024658,
0.813277006149292,
0.5570756793022156,
0.13565416634082794,
0.4460543692111969,
0.7526554465293884,
-0.1218508705496788,
0.4553227424621582,
-0.33875900506973267,
0.19482602179050446,
0.7687754034996033,
-0.8248103857040405,
0.9105640053749084,
0.6108182072639465,
-0.2861572504043579,
0.3869904577732086,
0.4300346076488495,
-0.29372459650039673,
0.5356618762016296,
0.5343433022499084,
-0.5719411969184875,
-0.1165156215429306,
-0.30597224831581116,
-0.6388891339302063,
0.30398234724998474,
0.608963668346405,
-0.15365685522556305,
-0.3702487647533417,
0.19089987874031067,
-0.15682119131088257,
0.05016623064875603,
-0.46118977665901184,
0.6307849287986755,
0.03134246915578842,
-0.3633204996585846,
0.5536547303199768,
-0.19543182849884033,
0.5529013276100159,
-0.857283890247345,
-0.05498858168721199,
-0.0779932364821434,
0.2041630893945694,
-0.3387579321861267,
-0.9329090714454651,
-0.05531232804059982,
0.07885711640119553,
-0.08922192454338074,
0.03619653731584549,
0.6059436202049255,
-0.5507692694664001,
-0.6036422848701477,
0.1900073140859604,
0.33715352416038513,
0.2708970904350281,
0.31750330328941345,
-0.5372355580329895,
0.19950968027114868,
-0.41759562492370605,
-0.1377042680978775,
0.3500734269618988,
0.22888384759426117,
-0.13554878532886505,
0.9598473906517029,
0.7307794094085693,
0.48281729221343994,
0.10950321704149246,
0.16755278408527374,
0.878594696521759,
-0.5418456196784973,
-0.18637585639953613,
-0.6480069160461426,
0.18971683084964752,
-0.16928048431873322,
-0.2323097437620163,
1.0581691265106201,
0.7592477202415466,
0.6798126697540283,
0.02094312012195587,
0.8043756484985352,
-0.0393088161945343,
0.6411396861076355,
-0.16565388441085815,
0.8416771292686462,
-0.24683846533298492,
0.2624709904193878,
-0.43294286727905273,
-0.875637412071228,
-0.569951057434082,
0.47663214802742004,
-0.4478868842124939,
0.17356592416763306,
0.7636603713035583,
0.7086664438247681,
0.06806042045354843,
0.19189351797103882,
0.29464635252952576,
0.6641260385513306,
0.386833131313324,
0.5012110471725464,
0.9647455215454102,
0.12212444096803665,
0.39795351028442383,
-0.13686785101890564,
-0.4542425572872162,
0.11363552510738373,
-1.2455604076385498,
-0.8078040480613708,
-0.31582504510879517,
-0.1723756343126297,
-0.2826836109161377,
0.2407904714345932,
0.9261339902877808,
0.6254953145980835,
-0.8885863423347473,
-0.21866336464881897,
-0.2608770430088043,
-0.17906874418258667,
-0.1337590217590332,
-0.20297080278396606,
0.4237132966518402,
-0.27321717143058777,
-0.35203981399536133,
0.9873911738395691,
0.5648940205574036,
-0.20468387007713318,
-0.6948956847190857,
-0.17773866653442383,
-0.2192903310060501,
0.012896106578409672,
0.7906044721603394,
0.5089463591575623,
-0.6148777008056641,
0.017269499599933624,
0.2961055338382721,
0.010379458777606487,
-0.18594826757907867,
0.7504635453224182,
-0.7519098520278931,
0.5904388427734375,
0.6113833785057068,
0.43244868516921997,
0.4968499541282654,
-0.3882211446762085,
0.31540584564208984,
-0.6604561805725098,
-0.20469000935554504,
0.6644611954689026,
0.12165136635303497,
0.358572781085968,
0.041534874588251114,
0.29957935214042664,
0.15464486181735992,
-0.7569899559020996,
-1.1887198686599731,
0.0044332328252494335,
-0.8601417541503906,
-0.26609137654304504,
0.840678870677948,
-0.2249789834022522,
-0.10870791971683502,
-0.011558589525520802,
0.14415647089481354,
-0.14930661022663116,
-0.47525665163993835,
0.7968180179595947,
0.7507649064064026,
-0.1758832037448883,
-0.1661914438009262,
-0.643265426158905,
0.5496160387992859,
0.37801414728164673,
-0.8926198482513428,
0.185971200466156,
0.48566389083862305,
0.5220283269882202,
0.31856831908226013,
0.17514756321907043,
-0.326447993516922,
0.31011340022087097,
-0.18189457058906555,
0.06601470708847046,
-0.2564069330692291,
-0.6103342175483704,
-0.4717141389846802,
0.2844935655593872,
0.00012781575787812471,
0.47204485535621643
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09095v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09095v1
|
Modeling Comparative Logical Relation with Contrastive Learning for Text Generation
| 2024-06-13T13:25:50 | 2024-06-13T13:25:50 |
Yuhao Dan, Junfeng Tian, Jie Zhou, Ming Yan, Ji Zhang, Qin Chen, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data-to-Text Generation (D2T), a classic natural language generation problem,
aims at producing fluent descriptions for structured input data, such as a
table. Existing D2T works mainly focus on describing the superficial
associative relations among entities, while ignoring the deep comparative
logical relations, such as A is better than B in a certain aspect with a
corresponding opinion, which is quite common in our daily life. In this paper,
we introduce a new D2T task named comparative logical relation generation
(CLRG). Additionally, we propose a Comparative Logic (CoLo) based text
generation method, which generates texts following specific comparative logical
relations with contrastive learning. Specifically, we first construct various
positive and negative samples by fine-grained perturbations in entities,
aspects and opinions. Then, we perform contrastive learning in the encoder
layer to have a better understanding of the comparative logical relations, and
integrate it in the decoder layer to guide the model to correctly generate the
relations. Noting the data scarcity problem, we construct a Chinese Comparative
Logical Relation Dataset (CLRD), which is a high-quality human-annotated
dataset and challenging for text generation with descriptions of multiple
entities and annotations on their comparative logical relations. Extensive
experiments show that our method achieves impressive performance in both
automatic and human evaluations.
|
[
-0.3537762761116028,
-0.7729360461235046,
0.3830241858959198,
-0.04541763663291931,
-0.4514063596725464,
-0.2619035840034485,
-0.1115277111530304,
-0.588080883026123,
-0.21746918559074402,
0.3821483254432678,
-0.6552270650863647,
-0.43589794635772705,
-0.29404371976852417,
0.2534908354282379,
-0.2280007302761078,
1.2171401977539062,
0.07726552337408066,
0.10713173449039459,
-0.4693268835544586,
-0.04384272173047066,
-0.7502381205558777,
-0.522237241268158,
-0.625892162322998,
-0.6709490418434143,
0.14647534489631653,
0.22144760191440582,
0.7450005412101746,
0.5806924700737,
0.664429783821106,
0.4621877372264862,
-0.06965803354978561,
0.30486223101615906,
-0.5830108523368835,
0.09187193959951401,
-0.48520275950431824,
-0.3925686478614807,
-0.18447177112102509,
-0.14590765535831451,
0.23583795130252838,
0.42673730850219727,
0.10367713868618011,
-0.03711125999689102,
0.12925350666046143,
1.0320638418197632,
-0.2301332652568817,
0.4657031297683716,
-1.03252112865448,
0.14126090705394745,
-0.08826067298650742,
-0.07687200605869293,
-0.2281704992055893,
-0.42336758971214294,
0.22232310473918915,
-0.6462401151657104,
0.4719986915588379,
0.06793604046106339,
1.0747079849243164,
0.27392256259918213,
-0.5611194968223572,
-0.675525426864624,
-0.5826346278190613,
0.7240262627601624,
-0.5675100088119507,
0.31266188621520996,
0.19369590282440186,
0.2017901986837387,
-0.0668100118637085,
-0.6774852871894836,
-0.9775161147117615,
-0.29249057173728943,
-0.5822231769561768,
0.35468149185180664,
0.03425575792789459,
-0.08828041702508926,
0.2678319215774536,
0.5292083024978638,
-0.6566751599311829,
-0.0963408574461937,
-0.23138563334941864,
-0.07472129166126251,
0.6694457530975342,
0.4441179037094116,
0.07922042161226273,
-0.31124427914619446,
-0.7071757912635803,
-0.032229647040367126,
-0.6945969462394714,
-0.2789163291454315,
0.35820266604423523,
0.08418647199869156,
-0.07838617265224457,
0.44789648056030273,
-0.23560260236263275,
0.6601248383522034,
0.3242470622062683,
-0.16242574155330658,
0.38033977150917053,
-0.5943140983581543,
-0.18660418689250946,
-0.022980649024248123,
0.8674336075782776,
0.6331080794334412,
0.38758692145347595,
0.0645083412528038,
-0.4104961156845093,
0.38540372252464294,
-0.1410737782716751,
-1.0677375793457031,
-0.569520890712738,
-0.17728006839752197,
-0.45452412962913513,
-0.5458202362060547,
-0.07775092124938965,
-0.7267589569091797,
-0.39420148730278015,
-0.5808678865432739,
0.21653437614440918,
-0.5238156914710999,
0.017536845058202744,
-0.1954265981912613,
0.12695156037807465,
0.008502600714564323,
0.15615372359752655,
-0.7188559770584106,
0.49769818782806396,
0.498313307762146,
0.5237370729446411,
0.014588133431971073,
-0.07656572014093399,
-0.4326155483722687,
0.07461316138505936,
-0.12437882274389267,
0.8118138313293457,
-0.3665822148323059,
-0.1377386748790741,
-0.0461113266646862,
-0.5069192051887512,
0.23555630445480347,
-0.7215324640274048,
0.5815432667732239,
-0.5774367451667786,
0.5371031761169434,
-0.2886520028114319,
-0.6444145441055298,
-0.13848362863063812,
0.3487749397754669,
-0.7224069833755493,
0.7833302021026611,
0.09852930158376694,
-1.4711798429489136,
0.36737149953842163,
-0.32636159658432007,
-0.6221251487731934,
0.08416549861431122,
-0.5770661234855652,
-0.6080323457717896,
-0.2937282919883728,
0.20144511759281158,
0.426184743642807,
-0.7650147676467896,
0.3976723253726959,
-0.09451710432767868,
0.033085182309150696,
0.39147332310676575,
-0.13799872994422913,
0.7405277490615845,
0.5013961791992188,
-0.19585353136062622,
0.05074547603726387,
-0.8958361744880676,
-0.3352910578250885,
0.358771413564682,
-0.2214387208223343,
-0.40455642342567444,
0.15689899027347565,
-0.04043569043278694,
0.5681413412094116,
0.2270020991563797,
-0.43664446473121643,
-0.2512715756893158,
-0.5439455509185791,
0.3952132761478424,
0.45509108901023865,
0.22803489863872528,
0.34524601697921753,
-0.33332276344299316,
0.01687646470963955,
0.4954303205013275,
-0.3658266067504883,
-0.1721472293138504,
-0.18859583139419556,
-0.8457373380661011,
0.09229978919029236,
0.4020676612854004,
0.7936253547668457,
-1.2610524892807007,
0.6942811608314514,
-0.32970091700553894,
-0.20363202691078186,
-0.1601502150297165,
0.19239147007465363,
0.718698263168335,
1.2686283588409424,
0.3704017996788025,
-0.14652708172798157,
-0.4029655456542969,
-1.059659719467163,
0.018972450867295265,
-0.34741997718811035,
0.08817195892333984,
0.4042423665523529,
0.48743775486946106,
-0.05325742065906525,
0.9210362434387207,
-0.7704049348831177,
-0.5091332197189331,
-0.5088996291160583,
0.08315335214138031,
0.05171728506684303,
0.4647313356399536,
0.4154810309410095,
-0.9834619760513306,
-0.5971471071243286,
0.11379561573266983,
-0.6935265064239502,
-0.08200855553150177,
-0.3126573860645294,
-0.11770740151405334,
0.33367910981178284,
0.2791561782360077,
-0.5197715759277344,
0.23352579772472382,
0.20636095106601715,
-0.1878163367509842,
0.4584813714027405,
-0.05379442125558853,
0.05790799483656883,
-1.343381404876709,
0.10529927164316177,
0.23847384750843048,
-0.28572046756744385,
-0.7206082940101624,
-0.01515244971960783,
-0.16096192598342896,
-0.12871825695037842,
-0.46602675318717957,
0.4036705195903778,
-0.3220764398574829,
0.09909048676490784,
-0.1693108230829239,
0.5682190656661987,
0.07674562931060791,
0.39168107509613037,
0.43137088418006897,
0.513130784034729,
0.10933611541986465,
-0.5064107775688171,
0.46539610624313354,
0.5682314038276672,
-0.40218815207481384,
0.5332030057907104,
-0.5550194382667542,
0.023270539939403534,
-0.012235582806169987,
0.48186570405960083,
-0.6939730644226074,
-0.02727491222321987,
0.2743031978607178,
-0.5023214817047119,
0.10237124562263489,
0.08621964603662491,
-0.7434478402137756,
-0.20835092663764954,
-0.24534402787685394,
0.35496506094932556,
0.6094615459442139,
-0.6005359292030334,
0.026766981929540634,
0.08773485571146011,
-0.3453519642353058,
-0.5681261420249939,
-0.8970556855201721,
-0.2133173942565918,
-0.3244721293449402,
-0.8074110746383667,
0.46756166219711304,
0.055768128484487534,
-0.5014299750328064,
0.12456567585468292,
0.07413359731435776,
-0.21521788835525513,
-0.1873084455728531,
-0.20835672318935394,
0.40082359313964844,
-0.11466517299413681,
0.3467882573604584,
0.09050050377845764,
-0.17970141768455505,
0.23939834535121918,
0.006725974380970001,
0.3788220286369324,
0.010059514082968235,
0.2171449065208435,
-0.41183435916900635,
0.28334635496139526,
-0.1585298478603363,
-0.2653258442878723,
0.5581355690956116,
0.4358953535556793,
-0.35440877079963684,
-0.3725566565990448,
-0.3548719882965088,
-0.27136990427970886,
-0.466483473777771,
0.4914543032646179,
-0.6186897158622742,
-0.5172744393348694,
0.49180299043655396,
-0.021385766565799713,
-0.0826365277171135,
0.5192602872848511,
0.661401629447937,
0.0954803079366684,
0.6090142130851746,
0.33846890926361084,
-0.048457030206918716,
0.2884756922721863,
-0.11436539888381958,
0.14537151157855988,
-0.41183143854141235,
-0.2546139657497406,
-0.3046605885028839,
-0.19461095333099365,
-0.80873042345047,
-0.16421619057655334,
-0.011884700506925583,
0.18448691070079803,
-0.35001087188720703,
0.346992164850235,
-0.49044814705848694,
0.5400305390357971,
0.3403918743133545,
0.21119797229766846,
0.5584551095962524,
0.08153656870126724,
-0.12839579582214355,
-0.24292956292629242,
-0.6394211053848267,
-0.37858548760414124,
0.6554089188575745,
0.04093194752931595,
0.4766439199447632,
-0.10249745100736618,
1.0189427137374878,
0.09344354271888733,
0.1696968674659729,
-0.50218665599823,
0.6206017136573792,
-0.42810678482055664,
-0.27013882994651794,
0.02323698252439499,
-0.9546216130256653,
-0.8149442076683044,
0.2677198052406311,
-0.4088490307331085,
-0.36623695492744446,
0.059231702238321304,
0.36881041526794434,
-0.006990501657128334,
0.12279099225997925,
-0.612749457359314,
0.7258050441741943,
-0.22452223300933838,
-0.6972392797470093,
-0.23895584046840668,
-0.9912126064300537,
0.5754702091217041,
0.12174510955810547,
0.03065640851855278,
0.2052268385887146,
0.13545741140842438,
0.5043863654136658,
-0.5601091980934143,
0.6103452444076538,
-0.014968649484217167,
-0.12647713720798492,
0.5832141041755676,
0.2594786286354065,
0.6135869026184082,
0.2135770171880722,
-0.315464586019516,
-0.16054312884807587,
-0.4903247654438019,
-0.0873250886797905,
-0.575773298740387,
0.9218076467514038,
-0.6678647994995117,
-0.34570303559303284,
-0.32783573865890503,
-0.6478646397590637,
-0.11792729049921036,
0.2708105742931366,
0.4946042597293854,
0.44794976711273193,
-0.2656799256801605,
-0.21099123358726501,
0.5452163815498352,
-0.3197944760322571,
0.2660447359085083,
0.2244158387184143,
-0.028774896636605263,
-0.6367093920707703,
1.2205756902694702,
-0.10726764798164368,
0.2209971845149994,
0.9104922413825989,
0.22949419915676117,
-0.4144010841846466,
-0.31038981676101685,
-0.385629266500473,
0.15808165073394775,
-0.7268335819244385,
-0.4797155559062958,
-0.4661179482936859,
-0.27388906478881836,
-0.1708381325006485,
-0.20584848523139954,
-0.10304844379425049,
-0.5345484614372253,
-0.31680265069007874,
-0.1292489618062973,
0.2614915072917938,
0.7597200870513916,
0.03861280530691147,
-0.1156524196267128,
-0.6187684535980225,
0.5689948201179504,
0.21155422925949097,
0.0009597429307177663,
0.019540153443813324,
-0.17485974729061127,
-0.03831802308559418,
-0.11496890336275101,
-0.7296237349510193,
-0.8004122972488403,
0.46435773372650146,
0.014180677011609077,
0.1301237940788269,
0.37854039669036865,
0.24463550746440887,
0.5454316735267639,
-0.5826249122619629,
0.5200567841529846,
0.48691341280937195,
-0.9354604482650757,
0.5128584504127502,
-0.2786881625652313,
0.057482268661260605,
0.6281131505966187,
0.2459496557712555,
-0.19327406585216522,
-0.12867949903011322,
-0.6563140153884888,
-0.8335356712341309,
0.6602749228477478,
0.6294177174568176,
-0.06026153266429901,
-0.1088780090212822,
0.18200404942035675,
0.43035194277763367,
0.2847544252872467,
-1.1337807178497314,
-0.33162766695022583,
-0.31176450848579407,
-0.35225027799606323,
0.0667925477027893,
0.06421592831611633,
0.11405599117279053,
0.011243556626141071,
0.5337178111076355,
0.21508002281188965,
0.18659599125385284,
0.2662554085254669,
-0.15935108065605164,
0.23072966933250427,
0.467848002910614,
0.3881530165672302,
0.3747609555721283,
0.0028239565435796976,
0.266070693731308,
0.2197975218296051,
-0.08041112124919891,
0.021231509745121002,
0.4308221936225891,
-0.4158138930797577,
-0.02546856738626957,
0.3691532611846924,
0.7656266689300537,
-0.25699713826179504,
-0.5293821096420288,
0.5502592921257019,
0.15270593762397766,
-0.3514113426208496,
-0.0818134993314743,
-0.08959707617759705,
0.25965070724487305,
0.09799370914697647,
-0.08400576561689377,
-0.03314458206295967,
0.4687431752681732,
-0.5196021795272827,
0.31334319710731506,
0.21933148801326752,
-0.32438093423843384,
-0.1711609661579132,
0.6196814775466919,
0.7623947262763977,
-0.09093823283910751,
0.8692314624786377,
-0.625482976436615,
-0.6687018275260925,
0.6710086464881897,
0.8088575601577759,
0.6973780393600464,
0.28992781043052673,
0.09976495057344437,
0.6350204348564148,
0.043012700974941254,
0.24499550461769104,
0.1258833259344101,
-0.24530057609081268,
-0.6413537263870239,
-0.17745737731456757,
-0.30879783630371094,
-0.19907796382904053,
0.3421054482460022,
-0.5166821479797363,
0.4388487637042999,
-0.21224811673164368,
0.12719060480594635,
-0.23916642367839813,
0.38338544964790344,
-0.6970281600952148,
0.5809246301651001,
0.10316675901412964,
0.5428013801574707,
-0.7333463430404663,
0.8844141960144043,
0.4499814212322235,
-0.5675320625305176,
-0.5713210105895996,
0.2423127144575119,
-0.16764234006404877,
-0.28146830201148987,
0.9584918022155762,
0.28538376092910767,
-0.06913042068481445,
-0.21831201016902924,
-0.11934404820203781,
-0.2878344655036926,
1.1640490293502808,
0.32285282015800476,
-0.8394871354103088,
0.10636647790670395,
0.32678940892219543,
0.8065009117126465,
-0.4555247724056244,
0.15704964101314545,
0.3772880733013153,
0.27985820174217224,
-0.0258433036506176,
-0.4299640357494354,
0.42783692479133606,
-0.31649985909461975,
0.05076339840888977,
0.327944815158844,
-0.9102051258087158,
0.811678946018219,
-0.3756411075592041,
-0.4542641043663025,
0.18248219788074493,
0.8562573790550232,
0.3728821277618408,
0.5454154014587402,
0.48153403401374817,
0.566262423992157,
0.3483034670352936,
0.12118426710367203,
0.8672157526016235,
-0.3564643859863281,
0.25162747502326965,
1.5640795230865479,
-0.5911846160888672,
0.70088130235672,
0.29106080532073975,
0.01733759231865406,
0.5868263840675354,
0.42583659291267395,
-0.21475167572498322,
0.602270245552063,
0.4869610667228699,
-0.2505432069301605,
-0.16904316842556,
-0.0160911213606596,
-0.5025791525840759,
0.07913468778133392,
0.21276725828647614,
-0.6080973148345947,
-0.33370453119277954,
-0.47372058033943176,
-0.10641700029373169,
0.725001871585846,
-0.10846595466136932,
1.0561797618865967,
0.05930277332663536,
-0.5965014696121216,
0.3238432705402374,
0.0647243782877922,
0.5895510315895081,
-0.3234236538410187,
-0.26590412855148315,
-0.3570083975791931,
0.2738538682460785,
-0.2769993245601654,
-0.8271650075912476,
0.14303475618362427,
0.10997407883405685,
-0.38424432277679443,
0.1258324384689331,
0.9626423120498657,
-0.7775698900222778,
-0.47852522134780884,
0.2479621320962906,
0.40918561816215515,
-0.09444337338209152,
0.43007466197013855,
-0.7951480746269226,
-0.29643210768699646,
0.1565316915512085,
-0.16129544377326965,
0.3112443685531616,
0.6349247097969055,
-0.09255341440439224,
0.49286946654319763,
0.36919623613357544,
-0.08284778892993927,
-0.25385910272598267,
-0.07474580407142639,
0.9174098968505859,
-0.5565361976623535,
-0.4894616901874542,
-0.8673155903816223,
0.3662874102592468,
-0.2946855425834656,
-0.291314035654068,
0.41909778118133545,
0.7808856964111328,
1.0329248905181885,
-0.1261620670557022,
0.9628270864486694,
-0.26762160658836365,
0.5554462671279907,
-0.6229655742645264,
0.559573769569397,
-0.24791233241558075,
0.31261759996414185,
-0.2887820601463318,
-1.0804802179336548,
-0.1961677372455597,
0.5503472089767456,
-0.31003883481025696,
-0.00035495980409905314,
0.9383497834205627,
0.7636640071868896,
-0.10261247307062149,
-0.07144112884998322,
0.116139255464077,
0.25898635387420654,
0.18595750629901886,
0.9445611834526062,
0.846650242805481,
-0.4983488619327545,
0.8549124002456665,
-0.5495736002922058,
-0.005178388673812151,
0.3116098940372467,
-0.8991611003875732,
-1.120766282081604,
-0.6418808102607727,
-0.24524140357971191,
-0.1776052713394165,
0.171286478638649,
0.8840994834899902,
0.23708844184875488,
-0.6718800067901611,
-0.24053485691547394,
-0.5664132833480835,
0.15741363167762756,
0.13520388305187225,
-0.28428077697753906,
0.4227348268032074,
-0.3797226548194885,
-0.7366869449615479,
-0.11114208400249481,
-0.2816372513771057,
-0.04020124301314354,
0.03624503314495087,
-0.1580001264810562,
-0.01029890775680542,
0.06689514964818954,
0.6723434329032898,
-0.14100663363933563,
-0.4736638069152832,
0.014252574183046818,
-0.543354868888855,
-0.1508025974035263,
0.12102339416742325,
0.8351709842681885,
-0.9244311451911926,
0.2749486267566681,
0.8243192434310913,
0.5698314309120178,
0.4039146304130554,
0.29100677371025085,
0.4498990476131439,
-0.5980616807937622,
0.11393290758132935,
0.16742122173309326,
0.15346278250217438,
0.5965712666511536,
-0.3673042058944702,
0.5209805965423584,
0.28603848814964294,
-0.5608019828796387,
-0.43045708537101746,
0.49366864562034607,
-0.8812944889068604,
-0.19719497859477997,
1.1143532991409302,
-0.18822048604488373,
0.1866820752620697,
0.08220174163579941,
-0.39229056239128113,
0.34027063846588135,
-0.5782116651535034,
0.8803872466087341,
0.3157321810722351,
-0.30635276436805725,
0.2346459925174713,
-0.18008975684642792,
0.5899606943130493,
0.33272355794906616,
-1.0023114681243896,
0.18829628825187683,
0.6872744560241699,
0.12112906575202942,
0.011572110466659069,
0.33379191160202026,
-0.12782850861549377,
0.20639409124851227,
0.27751705050468445,
-0.11122198402881622,
-0.1572243869304657,
-0.09927884489297867,
0.16145266592502594,
0.11126168817281723,
-0.2020656168460846,
-0.1420217752456665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09076v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09076v1
|
3M: Multi-modal Multi-task Multi-teacher Learning for Game Event Detection
| 2024-06-13T12:58:53 | 2024-06-13T12:58:53 |
Thye Shan Ng, Feiqi Cao, Soyeon Caren Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Esports has rapidly emerged as a global phenomenon with an ever-expanding
audience via platforms, like YouTube. Due to the inherent complexity nature of
the game, it is challenging for newcomers to comprehend what the event entails.
The chaotic nature of online chat, the fast-paced speech of the game
commentator, and the game-specific user interface further compound the
difficulty for users in comprehending the gameplay. To overcome these
challenges, it is crucial to integrate the Multi-Modal (MM) information from
the platform and understand the event. The paper introduces a new MM
multi-teacher-based game event detection framework, with the ultimate goal of
constructing a comprehensive framework that enhances the comprehension of the
ongoing game situation. While conventional MM models typically prioritise
aligning MM data through concurrent training towards a unified objective, our
framework leverages multiple teachers trained independently on different tasks
to accomplish the Game Event Detection. The experiment clearly shows the
effectiveness of the proposed MM multi-teacher framework.
|
[
-0.4802229702472687,
-0.6945925951004028,
0.5374851226806641,
0.207426518201828,
-0.32651281356811523,
0.1499314308166504,
-0.18251752853393555,
-0.3705163300037384,
0.1223258450627327,
0.03797048702836037,
-0.8611745238304138,
-0.4157238006591797,
-0.6570430994033813,
-0.015103111974895,
0.039945390075445175,
0.8597267270088196,
-0.04908375442028046,
0.10572192072868347,
-0.12849649786949158,
-0.06581872701644897,
-0.6585170030593872,
-0.44673043489456177,
-0.9113609790802002,
-0.26856449246406555,
0.007343885488808155,
0.9455580711364746,
0.023297186940908432,
0.4191312789916992,
0.42997461557388306,
0.3051278591156006,
0.17219984531402588,
0.637831449508667,
-0.7676494717597961,
0.4529193341732025,
0.0917251780629158,
-0.5283480286598206,
-0.3625277280807495,
-0.0670432597398758,
0.6111943125724792,
0.08128669112920761,
-0.10398583114147186,
0.23149904608726501,
0.36618664860725403,
0.3019171953201294,
-0.8239400386810303,
0.42121538519859314,
-0.5347192883491516,
0.5235361456871033,
-0.14057892560958862,
-0.5523105263710022,
-0.43237045407295227,
0.5955700278282166,
-0.10847898572683334,
-1.09254789352417,
0.4456520676612854,
-0.2346750944852829,
0.5782222747802734,
0.18499581515789032,
-0.6199367642402649,
-0.32756099104881287,
-0.8541690111160278,
0.7895052433013916,
-0.19402116537094116,
0.5188615918159485,
0.21849018335342407,
0.5100002884864807,
0.004598601255565882,
-0.2226046621799469,
-0.7189480066299438,
0.28279003500938416,
0.5049048066139221,
0.502503514289856,
-0.043562665581703186,
0.06165178492665291,
0.1017153337597847,
-0.1664339005947113,
-0.3200719356536865,
0.15119709074497223,
-0.23517929017543793,
0.13378788530826569,
0.43210679292678833,
0.4189577102661133,
0.3504830300807953,
-0.13378530740737915,
-0.6981969475746155,
0.5014529824256897,
-0.3951913118362427,
0.09214024245738983,
0.5297071933746338,
0.18740181624889374,
-0.27885663509368896,
0.19584320485591888,
-0.04731253534555435,
0.5281041860580444,
0.14924830198287964,
-0.7591129541397095,
0.2952067255973816,
-0.44131308794021606,
0.13632041215896606,
0.009281712584197521,
0.5989852547645569,
0.6548067927360535,
0.05325348675251007,
-0.13018213212490082,
0.05428143963217735,
0.14852644503116608,
-0.0012305037816986442,
-0.9100262522697449,
-0.20625406503677368,
0.323230504989624,
-0.5710564851760864,
-0.4345766007900238,
0.08504720777273178,
-0.8482857346534729,
-0.5124175548553467,
-0.2820113003253937,
0.4861990809440613,
-0.2613876163959503,
-0.5565874576568604,
0.22943150997161865,
-0.14481467008590698,
0.16146771609783173,
0.3705222010612488,
-0.879044771194458,
0.21897654235363007,
0.6949448585510254,
0.7693853974342346,
-0.24556207656860352,
-0.5910285115242004,
-0.8318223357200623,
0.5701310634613037,
0.21920445561408997,
0.8417975902557373,
-0.4845222234725952,
-0.27954384684562683,
-0.1984999179840088,
-0.07131684571504593,
-0.11726213246583939,
-0.07983331382274628,
0.3803519606590271,
-0.31114789843559265,
0.23070994019508362,
-0.06526283174753189,
-0.5583347678184509,
-0.2774403691291809,
0.5675409436225891,
-0.4472472667694092,
0.8460508584976196,
-0.5478168725967407,
-0.42898499965667725,
0.7110128998756409,
-0.8924902081489563,
-0.3138415515422821,
0.19245585799217224,
-0.050121042877435684,
-0.6186448931694031,
-0.13367825746536255,
0.6332644820213318,
0.6303295493125916,
-0.055295318365097046,
0.16563081741333008,
-0.5396027565002441,
-0.5591611862182617,
0.19787877798080444,
-0.5179583430290222,
0.4672650694847107,
-0.005091561004519463,
-0.4539813995361328,
0.057388875633478165,
-0.5746178030967712,
-0.280239462852478,
-0.2848934829235077,
-0.20863011479377747,
0.13251973688602448,
0.6777268648147583,
0.11435660719871521,
0.475293904542923,
-0.08614844083786011,
-0.49132582545280457,
-0.013760541565716267,
-0.11287335306406021,
0.28729280829429626,
0.5440120697021484,
0.2852112054824829,
0.4672730565071106,
-0.21740740537643433,
0.7003992795944214,
0.2817758619785309,
0.5635784268379211,
-0.4041996896266937,
-0.7745350003242493,
-0.2401784211397171,
-0.6527752876281738,
-0.11624258756637573,
0.5310035943984985,
-1.0139588117599487,
-0.17115220427513123,
-0.29720690846443176,
-0.20101220905780792,
-0.2580483555793762,
0.27925240993499756,
0.07670846581459045,
0.42739492654800415,
0.39156216382980347,
-0.04593091458082199,
-0.8662821054458618,
-0.2612634003162384,
-0.2018391191959381,
-0.11443988978862762,
0.07992050796747208,
0.4180782437324524,
0.6017791628837585,
0.1310092955827713,
0.6530091166496277,
-0.44320064783096313,
-0.8184183239936829,
-0.43872928619384766,
0.255338191986084,
-0.06298469752073288,
0.4024977385997772,
0.7290273904800415,
-0.9765319228172302,
-0.6755974888801575,
-0.1968071460723877,
-0.8104608654975891,
-0.13859933614730835,
-0.06754130870103836,
0.23986686766147614,
-0.1831631064414978,
0.6260858774185181,
-0.006345457397401333,
0.1425226926803589,
0.5386134386062622,
-0.5942074060440063,
0.19381773471832275,
-0.08003707975149155,
0.6188724637031555,
-1.1742857694625854,
-0.1959122121334076,
-0.12311692535877228,
-0.3803500235080719,
-0.7651999592781067,
0.18111300468444824,
0.02007189579308033,
-0.15711550414562225,
-0.6108124256134033,
0.24731159210205078,
-0.5943571329116821,
-0.055917415767908096,
-0.6793023943901062,
0.6191206574440002,
0.03002699464559555,
0.4894309639930725,
0.028307348489761353,
0.5983731746673584,
0.5989524126052856,
-0.6494788527488708,
0.5547881126403809,
0.03137309476733208,
-0.23977075517177582,
1.2534615993499756,
-0.13552074134349823,
-0.1024857610464096,
-0.14348222315311432,
0.323671817779541,
-1.0737226009368896,
0.0032983971759676933,
0.4593086838722229,
-0.7668781876564026,
-0.1391441822052002,
-0.6178379058837891,
-0.5393269062042236,
-0.46207737922668457,
-0.3220061957836151,
0.419466108083725,
-0.04775043949484825,
-0.5359027981758118,
0.9296890497207642,
0.8359822630882263,
0.44636014103889465,
-0.6019889116287231,
-0.4552616775035858,
-0.12936587631702423,
-0.40113118290901184,
-0.5421673059463501,
0.27689531445503235,
-0.16469809412956238,
0.35575827956199646,
0.08801525086164474,
-0.17888158559799194,
-0.5877571702003479,
0.37811610102653503,
0.3524628281593323,
0.23259061574935913,
-0.3661898374557495,
0.09116183966398239,
-0.34624776244163513,
-0.15108446776866913,
-0.017429739236831665,
-0.237132728099823,
0.23712913691997528,
0.13909615576267242,
-0.6115292906761169,
-0.581355094909668,
0.5542206764221191,
0.5255948901176453,
-0.30910077691078186,
0.568412184715271,
1.2167835235595703,
-0.49227142333984375,
-0.13349299132823944,
-0.6062974333763123,
-0.27365148067474365,
-0.4169658124446869,
0.491428941488266,
-0.49908795952796936,
-0.8631932139396667,
0.725879430770874,
-0.07612033188343048,
-0.28254005312919617,
0.20386691391468048,
0.5243868231773376,
-0.1779971569776535,
1.5846322774887085,
0.27349820733070374,
0.005682713817805052,
0.46655258536338806,
-0.08530253916978836,
-0.17658011615276337,
-0.715816855430603,
-0.5650591254234314,
-0.3365917205810547,
-0.6715340614318848,
0.06805512309074402,
-0.5889936089515686,
0.5256206393241882,
0.008144361898303032,
-0.16484393179416656,
-0.06558003276586533,
-0.1998487412929535,
1.1624068021774292,
0.03994866833090782,
0.40735960006713867,
0.38731977343559265,
-0.42375004291534424,
0.17646382749080658,
-0.2567436695098877,
-0.6959826350212097,
0.18568183481693268,
1.0034377574920654,
0.21787799894809723,
0.2529439330101013,
0.6972327828407288,
0.6850066781044006,
0.050929028540849686,
0.3520340025424957,
-0.8024200797080994,
0.3018202781677246,
0.19188730418682098,
-1.0066990852355957,
-0.26597508788108826,
-0.3128482401371002,
-0.8136016726493835,
0.5910876989364624,
-0.6891753673553467,
-0.6555827856063843,
0.007734050042927265,
0.030014872550964355,
-0.5989920496940613,
0.6817947626113892,
-0.6990638971328735,
0.9249686598777771,
0.04332653433084488,
-0.3750913441181183,
-0.0323970802128315,
-0.26007580757141113,
0.5160688757896423,
-0.03359897434711456,
0.801201581954956,
-0.4190468192100525,
-0.4560784101486206,
0.7094665169715881,
0.055162642151117325,
1.0181984901428223,
-0.3284170627593994,
0.34378185868263245,
0.37598007917404175,
0.19705310463905334,
0.3666258156299591,
0.4026796817779541,
0.5160326361656189,
-0.5040571689605713,
-0.1440442055463791,
-0.4228748381137848,
-0.36038851737976074,
0.593743622303009,
-0.8158307671546936,
-0.3061380088329315,
-0.20222622156143188,
-0.5856456160545349,
-0.4300750195980072,
0.05275658518075943,
0.009112920612096786,
0.4483712911605835,
-0.2261168658733368,
0.22671224176883698,
0.5687501430511475,
0.2870079278945923,
0.5221028327941895,
1.0600098371505737,
-0.22852899134159088,
-0.20883597433567047,
0.9502057433128357,
-0.08557766675949097,
-0.1895987093448639,
0.34571129083633423,
0.15843787789344788,
-0.1595105081796646,
-0.4266834855079651,
-0.3306184411048889,
-0.20349295437335968,
-0.6266768574714661,
-0.4767743647098541,
-0.5363617539405823,
0.26352715492248535,
-0.07801005989313126,
-0.11320715397596359,
-0.31679654121398926,
0.027372311800718307,
-0.6051056385040283,
-0.1180313378572464,
0.14303594827651978,
0.8178377747535706,
-0.5132725834846497,
0.7530587315559387,
-0.7581773996353149,
0.4409189820289612,
0.2746715247631073,
0.4467376172542572,
-0.1403016448020935,
-0.5682615637779236,
-0.07614345103502274,
-0.18336555361747742,
-0.5803802609443665,
-1.3675174713134766,
0.20914533734321594,
0.467092901468277,
0.7224714756011963,
0.9030134677886963,
-0.5104219913482666,
0.5974706411361694,
-0.5187091827392578,
0.7379100322723389,
0.3839319348335266,
-1.1815388202667236,
0.5350251197814941,
-0.6136634349822998,
0.2749391496181488,
0.3474622666835785,
0.426861047744751,
-0.7463043332099915,
-0.12351403385400772,
-0.5522103905677795,
-0.5255075693130493,
1.1864832639694214,
-0.035000938922166824,
-0.011447484605014324,
-0.07477091252803802,
-0.13772596418857574,
0.03204548358917236,
0.11966055631637573,
-0.8074253797531128,
-0.49020811915397644,
0.046458713710308075,
-0.007410915102809668,
-0.2498147040605545,
-0.2392328381538391,
-0.03791101649403572,
-0.22764059901237488,
0.5061936378479004,
-0.23725910484790802,
0.09646620601415634,
-0.3226916790008545,
-0.30660897493362427,
-0.005166033282876015,
0.008050225675106049,
0.9554671049118042,
0.7512990832328796,
-0.13937750458717346,
0.31089508533477783,
0.6430866122245789,
-0.6947593688964844,
0.13786154985427856,
0.03172674402594566,
0.23640993237495422,
-0.12080841511487961,
0.28676941990852356,
0.6172289252281189,
1.1688430309295654,
-0.3491930067539215,
0.940484881401062,
0.08964875340461731,
-0.5849701762199402,
0.08058039844036102,
-0.21023069322109222,
0.09377177059650421,
0.5494348406791687,
0.6153786778450012,
0.11903078854084015,
0.30638018250465393,
-0.4718010127544403,
0.6049069762229919,
0.09378233551979065,
-0.5628098249435425,
-0.32099688053131104,
1.0282464027404785,
0.6331517696380615,
-0.012616997584700584,
0.044938549399375916,
-0.4303213357925415,
-1.0552843809127808,
0.5913886427879333,
0.680677592754364,
0.5123039484024048,
-0.45315638184547424,
0.5497245192527771,
0.3705284595489502,
0.19223180413246155,
-0.0036267777904868126,
0.6621111035346985,
-0.08848065137863159,
-0.8828219771385193,
-0.6326043605804443,
0.04398155212402344,
-0.3766835927963257,
0.22371135652065277,
-0.3846268951892853,
0.38961565494537354,
-0.06834650039672852,
-0.19934140145778656,
0.0605136901140213,
-0.029377615079283714,
-0.7465992569923401,
-0.2333303540945053,
0.6419211030006409,
0.28494521975517273,
-1.0491840839385986,
0.3460817039012909,
0.5921128988265991,
-0.4963570833206177,
-0.5018090009689331,
-0.4278557002544403,
0.5994976162910461,
-0.8401979804039001,
0.5119085311889648,
-0.043323639780282974,
0.07555663585662842,
0.17754577100276947,
-0.21213838458061218,
-0.5374447703361511,
1.0325753688812256,
0.1737126260995865,
-0.13721701502799988,
0.00005755666279583238,
0.024446511641144753,
0.17896531522274017,
-0.5398754477500916,
0.52765953540802,
0.17781871557235718,
0.3691430389881134,
0.09141036123037338,
-0.6641046404838562,
-0.494328111410141,
0.16710805892944336,
-0.40739837288856506,
0.3941049575805664,
-0.44895491003990173,
0.8873926401138306,
-0.17139071226119995,
-0.13722074031829834,
-0.704516589641571,
0.6999698877334595,
0.18745438754558563,
0.5183706879615784,
0.574912965297699,
0.32996150851249695,
0.6555454730987549,
-0.17837154865264893,
0.5157966613769531,
-0.370567262172699,
0.593865156173706,
1.003541111946106,
-0.06631390005350113,
0.7138803601264954,
0.3783182203769684,
-0.04911712929606438,
0.11701169610023499,
0.4997040033340454,
-0.14855068922042847,
0.4046286344528198,
-0.03376872092485428,
-0.52660071849823,
-0.8393837809562683,
0.0036107394844293594,
-0.4283791780471802,
0.750775158405304,
0.4761190116405487,
-0.028458591550588608,
-0.7022092342376709,
0.6944447755813599,
0.11856433004140854,
-0.05699986219406128,
-0.661874532699585,
0.6139741539955139,
-0.30845344066619873,
-0.3974844515323639,
-0.1668727844953537,
0.03452688828110695,
0.8457640409469604,
-0.31216156482696533,
-0.015697695314884186,
0.0938403382897377,
0.4478098154067993,
-0.11286166310310364,
-0.8041757941246033,
-0.07014986872673035,
-0.09857718646526337,
-0.11439676582813263,
-0.027926579117774963,
0.7692675590515137,
-0.5244994163513184,
-0.12555067241191864,
0.14488020539283752,
0.9548571109771729,
0.19410230219364166,
-0.28441405296325684,
-0.762785017490387,
0.34876108169555664,
-0.36165350675582886,
0.1802549511194229,
0.16180983185768127,
0.821715772151947,
0.4250284433364868,
0.48400723934173584,
0.31315553188323975,
-0.2646634876728058,
0.18372687697410583,
0.004820972215384245,
0.39993226528167725,
0.05206026881933212,
-0.8402687311172485,
-0.9366801977157593,
0.24898937344551086,
-0.11662961542606354,
-0.3870154917240143,
0.7241436243057251,
0.8759823441505432,
0.8361960053443909,
-0.2255135178565979,
0.5251755714416504,
0.3133974075317383,
0.3200663924217224,
-0.18794266879558563,
0.6462112069129944,
-0.5148329734802246,
-0.0007520273793488741,
-0.09692538529634476,
-0.4934009909629822,
-0.3377446234226227,
0.29404789209365845,
0.022707562893629074,
-0.17089234292507172,
0.5921458005905151,
0.27012571692466736,
-0.6020684242248535,
0.23659712076187134,
0.48942306637763977,
-0.3979986906051636,
0.28262895345687866,
0.8371440172195435,
0.8900237679481506,
-0.4551331102848053,
0.8684731125831604,
-0.11429724097251892,
-0.2666493356227875,
-0.5746399164199829,
-0.8207874894142151,
-1.2167719602584839,
-1.0125898122787476,
-0.2652623653411865,
-0.07226520031690598,
0.17097170650959015,
0.9815811514854431,
0.8216147422790527,
-0.8176323175430298,
-0.2711167335510254,
0.3121725022792816,
0.23615947365760803,
-0.574420154094696,
-0.22320756316184998,
0.13271774351596832,
-0.42464450001716614,
-0.9332570433616638,
0.4726482927799225,
0.08817070722579956,
-0.18275086581707,
-0.04829762130975723,
0.03241671249270439,
-0.6018036603927612,
-0.07732485979795456,
0.9736119508743286,
0.3868676424026489,
-0.4833168387413025,
-0.5879256725311279,
0.029279513284564018,
0.005039184354245663,
-0.01237230934202671,
0.8420665860176086,
-0.6941773295402527,
0.7086176872253418,
0.4259342849254608,
0.5917317867279053,
0.5828008651733398,
-0.44832146167755127,
0.443508118391037,
-0.9086824655532837,
0.04910918325185776,
-0.014543460682034492,
0.21203339099884033,
0.025602499023079872,
-0.0067351884208619595,
0.5281510353088379,
0.7001022696495056,
-0.3322153091430664,
-0.9690020084381104,
0.09393822401762009,
-0.7394417524337769,
-0.2207460254430771,
1.0877292156219482,
0.21135498583316803,
0.04246283322572708,
-0.4879579246044159,
-0.2106247842311859,
0.39733144640922546,
-0.29174575209617615,
0.5363919138908386,
0.908556342124939,
-0.21677309274673462,
-0.21291595697402954,
-0.9684758186340332,
0.7398743629455566,
0.040271513164043427,
-0.6278518438339233,
-0.3409762680530548,
0.4081276059150696,
0.25280675292015076,
-0.2094217985868454,
0.6952782273292542,
0.27651113271713257,
0.7300860285758972,
0.10387823730707169,
-0.06214354187250137,
-0.5146514773368835,
-0.5450045466423035,
0.022299032658338547,
0.6112048625946045,
-0.5949112772941589,
-0.6773712038993835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09072v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09072v1
|
Living in the Moment: Can Large Language Models Grasp Co-Temporal Reasoning?
| 2024-06-13T12:56:21 | 2024-06-13T12:56:21 |
Zhaochen Su, Juntao Li, Jun Zhang, Tong Zhu, Xiaoye Qu, Pan Zhou, Yan Bowen, Yu Cheng, Min zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Temporal reasoning is fundamental for large language models (LLMs) to
comprehend the world. Current temporal reasoning datasets are limited to
questions about single or isolated events, falling short in mirroring the
realistic temporal characteristics involving concurrent nature and intricate
temporal interconnections. In this paper, we introduce CoTempQA, a
comprehensive co-temporal Question Answering (QA) benchmark containing four
co-temporal scenarios (Equal, Overlap, During, Mix) with 4,748 samples for
evaluating the co-temporal comprehension and reasoning abilities of LLMs. Our
extensive experiments reveal a significant gap between the performance of
current LLMs and human-level reasoning on CoTempQA tasks. Even when enhanced
with Chain of Thought (CoT) methodologies, models consistently struggle with
our task. In our preliminary exploration, we discovered that mathematical
reasoning plays a significant role in handling co-temporal events and proposed
a strategy to boost LLMs' co-temporal reasoning from a mathematical
perspective. We hope that our CoTempQA datasets will encourage further
advancements in improving the co-temporal reasoning capabilities of LLMs. Our
code is available at https://github.com/zhaochen0110/Cotempqa.
|
[
-0.5342013239860535,
-0.8265546560287476,
0.7493959069252014,
0.44980934262275696,
-0.16977296769618988,
0.4063459634780884,
-0.02913079224526882,
-0.5145890116691589,
-0.417081356048584,
0.19093281030654907,
-0.878436267375946,
-0.47442325949668884,
-0.08916223049163818,
-0.13036106526851654,
-0.26522746682167053,
0.17586684226989746,
-0.037938009947538376,
0.039659399539232254,
-0.45188528299331665,
-0.08977441489696503,
-0.1589769721031189,
-0.7885445356369019,
-0.842924952507019,
-0.6494333744049072,
0.4655033051967621,
0.37711629271507263,
0.7295490503311157,
0.09324251115322113,
0.20351368188858032,
0.10867287963628769,
-0.07442079484462738,
0.24277186393737793,
-0.20685629546642303,
0.03938722983002663,
-0.3462527394294739,
-0.3756121098995209,
-0.5901368260383606,
0.0003430039796512574,
0.265243262052536,
1.0527162551879883,
-0.06271040439605713,
0.1960909515619278,
-0.13087798655033112,
0.23313792049884796,
-0.5704468488693237,
0.009081217460334301,
-0.5707577466964722,
0.18225198984146118,
-0.07974467426538467,
-0.13544508814811707,
-0.397968590259552,
-0.2394898682832718,
0.24007831513881683,
-0.42230483889579773,
0.09394079446792603,
0.2631322741508484,
0.8045434355735779,
0.26274198293685913,
-0.5324736833572388,
-0.02933308482170105,
-0.3391301929950714,
0.9282187819480896,
-0.48942965269088745,
0.5730143785476685,
0.42280468344688416,
0.4686228632926941,
-0.2028733193874359,
-0.6231499314308167,
-0.7292497158050537,
-0.0595720112323761,
0.2189566045999527,
0.09775897115468979,
-0.09234900027513504,
-0.23959562182426453,
0.369418203830719,
0.07589083164930344,
-0.6081441640853882,
0.16608202457427979,
0.2591394782066345,
-0.30917978286743164,
0.4528588056564331,
0.37442269921302795,
0.4271847903728485,
-0.12408499419689178,
-0.3291075825691223,
0.168468177318573,
-0.8263765573501587,
0.29707518219947815,
0.08531292527914047,
-0.19431520998477936,
-0.35515132546424866,
0.47336000204086304,
-0.16773343086242676,
0.6123377084732056,
-0.1714397668838501,
0.35424014925956726,
-0.35025864839553833,
-0.3899989724159241,
-0.336317241191864,
-0.14429764449596405,
0.5547922253608704,
0.13689863681793213,
0.3093545436859131,
-0.23148317635059357,
0.07805713266134262,
0.022070739418268204,
-0.2889546751976013,
-0.5251507759094238,
-0.3346179127693176,
0.5840371251106262,
0.0841924175620079,
0.21045568585395813,
-0.44705286622047424,
-0.7089636921882629,
-0.07231704890727997,
-0.5797228813171387,
0.19165991246700287,
-0.3893841505050659,
-0.057175468653440475,
0.29191139340400696,
-0.04702919349074364,
0.43662145733833313,
0.6674098372459412,
-0.42200973629951477,
0.39512431621551514,
1.2186566591262817,
0.7057047486305237,
-0.04691305756568909,
-0.2038327008485794,
-0.7610436677932739,
0.10746003687381744,
-0.4175252914428711,
0.954212486743927,
-0.4869709014892578,
-0.0478857196867466,
-0.28167298436164856,
-0.19117559492588043,
-0.23990371823310852,
-0.6481703519821167,
0.5556713938713074,
-0.9926167130470276,
-0.043580662459135056,
-0.5379811525344849,
-0.36235424876213074,
-0.0731479823589325,
0.4187707304954529,
-0.6011164784431458,
0.8211182355880737,
0.01740696281194687,
-0.49910035729408264,
0.19640104472637177,
-0.22340399026870728,
-0.31581777334213257,
0.07120770961046219,
-0.3852992653846741,
-0.4083084166049957,
-0.09656822681427002,
0.516787052154541,
0.37057507038116455,
-0.492266982793808,
0.7769404649734497,
-0.5765969157218933,
-0.0778469368815422,
0.8255891799926758,
-0.5067216753959656,
1.039975881576538,
0.26949766278266907,
-0.15550845861434937,
-0.2935742735862732,
-0.5919536352157593,
0.26606684923171997,
-0.09246985614299774,
0.11967350542545319,
-0.06671228259801865,
0.0002514717634767294,
-0.2528606355190277,
0.6211339235305786,
0.20002149045467377,
-0.405007928609848,
-0.024215776473283768,
-0.15785592794418335,
0.6219735145568848,
0.5969598293304443,
0.284186989068985,
0.4831632673740387,
-0.5794064998626709,
0.44308754801750183,
0.16104735434055328,
0.2219712883234024,
-0.03694034740328789,
-0.26818758249282837,
-0.7583264708518982,
-0.24753542244434357,
-0.05060739070177078,
0.39980220794677734,
-1.0847861766815186,
0.11921621114015579,
-0.23285885155200958,
-0.3335458040237427,
-0.03267929330468178,
-0.21431298553943634,
0.2715834677219391,
0.4123583137989044,
0.311657190322876,
0.18082363903522491,
-0.5578264594078064,
-0.4767635762691498,
-0.38173583149909973,
-0.01399796362966299,
0.05163390189409256,
0.393149733543396,
0.6672800779342651,
0.2086476981639862,
0.8821084499359131,
-0.2880495488643646,
0.3651244640350342,
-0.1318313181400299,
0.18055732548236847,
0.30048316717147827,
0.18407993018627167,
0.3354519307613373,
-0.7445764541625977,
-0.1013670265674591,
-0.1787194013595581,
-0.7975016236305237,
-0.4202418923377991,
-0.23185847699642181,
-0.275910347700119,
0.1080266535282135,
0.47382181882858276,
-0.287555068731308,
0.3049998879432678,
0.689116895198822,
-0.6038092970848083,
0.6608198285102844,
0.01640806905925274,
0.10395094007253647,
-0.720086932182312,
-0.09812050312757492,
-0.15103165805339813,
-0.3874921202659607,
-0.45828381180763245,
0.052360501140356064,
-0.008871304802596569,
-0.2236049771308899,
-0.5623370409011841,
0.8426773548126221,
-0.4841606616973877,
-0.2699569761753082,
0.07943391799926758,
0.3325906991958618,
0.17489421367645264,
0.5355759263038635,
0.20829854905605316,
0.7295857667922974,
0.38139569759368896,
-0.8339400887489319,
0.3661267161369324,
0.06553054600954056,
-0.6522396206855774,
0.6243598461151123,
-0.8041423559188843,
0.06079886853694916,
0.1818755567073822,
0.30208495259284973,
-0.5980300903320312,
-0.044033490121364594,
0.051668498665094376,
-0.4149245619773865,
-0.09940866380929947,
-0.12534701824188232,
-0.6675694584846497,
-0.21555280685424805,
0.21395708620548248,
0.6507672071456909,
0.14765271544456482,
-0.7325276136398315,
0.5818566083908081,
0.3880099356174469,
-0.24872653186321259,
-0.47563037276268005,
-0.5678852796554565,
0.23378728330135345,
0.12333930283784866,
-0.8286648392677307,
0.24051785469055176,
-0.20488996803760529,
-0.7677673697471619,
-0.17648665606975555,
-0.22596822679042816,
-0.21201005578041077,
0.14948639273643494,
0.15852080285549164,
0.35375940799713135,
-0.08834236115217209,
0.2578907012939453,
0.19238081574440002,
-0.18930017948150635,
0.19297926127910614,
-0.3384208083152771,
0.9420780539512634,
-0.14548943936824799,
-0.5451444387435913,
-0.46223536133766174,
0.1379290074110031,
0.4346545338630676,
-0.29498234391212463,
0.6762298345565796,
0.32540225982666016,
-0.4929564297199249,
-0.26772379875183105,
-0.3920481204986572,
-0.056017663329839706,
-0.3786375820636749,
-0.003932777792215347,
-0.6397600173950195,
-1.022117257118225,
0.6622201800346375,
-0.1480899155139923,
-0.12540435791015625,
0.37540769577026367,
0.6729044914245605,
-0.3842145800590515,
0.6299821138381958,
-0.08698152750730515,
0.21629194915294647,
0.1996360868215561,
-0.4927932024002075,
-0.012128052301704884,
-1.0435881614685059,
-0.44964370131492615,
-0.5954298973083496,
-0.23497745394706726,
-0.08873999863862991,
-0.897797703742981,
0.5334835052490234,
0.11287032812833786,
-0.5925674438476562,
0.08403195440769196,
0.13138912618160248,
0.3875218629837036,
0.26257917284965515,
0.21447384357452393,
0.5170729160308838,
-0.296488881111145,
-0.3495287299156189,
0.03180547058582306,
-0.7423997521400452,
-0.3912622034549713,
0.46771860122680664,
0.09709923714399338,
0.7072526216506958,
0.21848955750465393,
0.2878924608230591,
0.08704022318124771,
-0.11191859841346741,
-0.34986796975135803,
0.7632620334625244,
0.0952969565987587,
-0.569118082523346,
-0.3289972245693207,
-0.6635526418685913,
-0.7875905632972717,
0.20759324729442596,
-0.007949361577630043,
-0.7316733002662659,
0.4970185458660126,
-0.12824155390262604,
-0.5214473009109497,
0.2844543755054474,
-0.2887142598628998,
0.9470557570457458,
-0.4621567726135254,
-0.7134345173835754,
-0.3869776725769043,
-0.3794950842857361,
0.2030392289161682,
0.04365125298500061,
0.49837201833724976,
-0.7439069747924805,
-0.391419917345047,
0.4496246874332428,
-0.5731050968170166,
0.8324900269508362,
0.09186705201864243,
-0.13074451684951782,
0.6030518412590027,
0.4676908552646637,
0.2806314527988434,
0.5249684453010559,
-0.17846594750881195,
0.22673514485359192,
0.470483660697937,
-0.6902639865875244,
-0.603403627872467,
0.7202600836753845,
-0.7942107915878296,
-0.3178326189517975,
-0.632256269454956,
-0.7817094922065735,
-0.36113521456718445,
-0.3206639289855957,
0.06455615907907486,
0.9389678835868835,
-0.2860336899757385,
-0.030134696513414383,
0.7624730467796326,
-0.3955911695957184,
0.6570655703544617,
0.6295121312141418,
-0.23508253693580627,
-0.28880369663238525,
0.3930409848690033,
0.04986245185136795,
0.41632944345474243,
0.8046889305114746,
0.1083032637834549,
-0.36903902888298035,
-0.3537517189979553,
-0.1352071613073349,
0.23611591756343842,
-0.603044867515564,
-0.09364476799964905,
-0.930281400680542,
-0.2569214105606079,
-0.2746116816997528,
-0.14285457134246826,
-0.05519377067685127,
-0.6943424344062805,
-0.0848974734544754,
0.30976375937461853,
0.13695690035820007,
0.17669865489006042,
-0.004973726347088814,
0.031309351325035095,
-0.860274076461792,
0.5205330848693848,
0.5083590149879456,
0.2084202915430069,
0.1764395534992218,
-0.5433928370475769,
0.04969995096325874,
0.08288025856018066,
-0.04743453487753868,
-0.5066618919372559,
0.32440829277038574,
0.10459242016077042,
0.5852468609809875,
-0.07693884521722794,
0.32623493671417236,
0.6326560974121094,
-0.3609626591205597,
0.7498976588249207,
-0.11427529156208038,
-1.0178710222244263,
0.28251662850379944,
-0.3710096776485443,
0.7648764848709106,
0.1331031322479248,
0.3870469331741333,
-0.7548176646232605,
-0.22234974801540375,
-0.618905246257782,
-0.33518895506858826,
0.4153197705745697,
0.20671506226062775,
-0.35536107420921326,
0.013618459925055504,
0.3650217354297638,
0.07207398116588593,
0.02371918596327305,
-0.278889924287796,
0.205198734998703,
0.30516013503074646,
-0.04451615735888481,
-0.08557072281837463,
-0.10622390359640121,
0.0480177067220211,
-0.38953089714050293,
0.48126041889190674,
-0.0933527946472168,
0.04298043251037598,
0.10299307852983475,
-0.27817103266716003,
-0.04525040462613106,
0.5096281170845032,
0.40981560945510864,
0.8940397500991821,
-0.008291185833513737,
0.4447213411331177,
0.3597801923751831,
-0.20318667590618134,
0.08946563303470612,
0.06057753413915634,
-0.015305871143937111,
-0.3273814022541046,
0.5332704782485962,
0.3169880211353302,
0.4020407199859619,
-0.8240776062011719,
0.3475017845630646,
-0.31428828835487366,
0.08203496038913727,
-0.4897919297218323,
-0.08524048328399658,
0.22739043831825256,
0.4989691376686096,
0.2808424234390259,
-0.04648621380329132,
-0.20622240006923676,
-0.9104886651039124,
0.19824275374412537,
0.20608121156692505,
-0.18974848091602325,
-0.4869941771030426,
0.5783849358558655,
0.058868952095508575,
-0.040390316396951675,
0.6741975545883179,
-0.25347697734832764,
-0.7075992822647095,
0.8426227569580078,
0.26408153772354126,
0.663664698600769,
0.0754428580403328,
0.24952393770217896,
0.39922651648521423,
0.1508364975452423,
0.056411124765872955,
0.5943076014518738,
-0.16339971125125885,
-0.8320541977882385,
-0.708506166934967,
-0.6449074745178223,
-0.7696282267570496,
-0.30772700905799866,
-0.4395490884780884,
0.11988707631826401,
-0.3386513292789459,
-0.1310422569513321,
0.009525110945105553,
0.31342044472694397,
-0.8285832405090332,
0.24729861319065094,
-0.011806334368884563,
1.0550593137741089,
-0.4910772740840912,
0.7433806657791138,
0.31724366545677185,
-0.24215027689933777,
-0.5253317356109619,
-0.027620919048786163,
0.00509051326662302,
-0.794469952583313,
0.576707661151886,
-0.23433728516101837,
-0.10069476813077927,
-0.052623409777879715,
-0.6492869853973389,
-0.5836558938026428,
1.0885634422302246,
0.43407586216926575,
-0.7984291911125183,
-0.10580559074878693,
0.1790492683649063,
0.5615234971046448,
-0.21768219769001007,
0.11743602156639099,
0.674594521522522,
0.2623138725757599,
0.5592300891876221,
-0.7465023398399353,
-0.106253981590271,
0.010169674642384052,
-0.4113321006298065,
0.17884384095668793,
-0.651329517364502,
0.9519380331039429,
-0.3960704803466797,
-0.32949352264404297,
0.21471521258354187,
0.6504985690116882,
0.4000089168548584,
0.9863340258598328,
0.2512114644050598,
0.786750853061676,
0.8131280541419983,
-0.5012054443359375,
1.1759839057922363,
-0.21630875766277313,
0.24842068552970886,
1.6088367700576782,
-0.33778318762779236,
0.8949017524719238,
0.12118017673492432,
-0.35685282945632935,
0.5439881682395935,
0.8022699952125549,
0.5247975587844849,
0.07874466478824615,
0.21261022984981537,
-0.5332944393157959,
-0.9949328303337097,
-0.4142057001590729,
-0.2737634479999542,
0.252252995967865,
0.5152137279510498,
0.33997830748558044,
-0.3274076581001282,
-0.07329316437244415,
0.007716224063187838,
0.1887436807155609,
-0.4742969870567322,
0.5222234725952148,
0.6277682781219482,
-0.7785136699676514,
0.2407616674900055,
-0.3395197093486786,
0.016425246372818947,
-0.16794201731681824,
0.16396017372608185,
-0.2965712547302246,
0.2953436076641083,
0.0289736520498991,
-1.0388916730880737,
0.33060523867607117,
-0.03231910988688469,
0.05000052973628044,
-0.006219761446118355,
0.5238222479820251,
-0.4076801836490631,
-0.3012538254261017,
0.20648397505283356,
0.9973046779632568,
0.0022196066565811634,
-0.3007175028324127,
-0.6121686100959778,
0.268126904964447,
-0.6045675277709961,
0.3743785619735718,
0.2067764848470688,
0.9028917551040649,
-0.27948880195617676,
0.945622444152832,
0.3899025022983551,
-0.09299259632825851,
0.031164586544036865,
0.4471716284751892,
0.7264987826347351,
-0.7823712825775146,
-0.38816824555397034,
-0.8868496417999268,
-0.0690087080001831,
-0.09565842151641846,
0.023273609578609467,
0.5930960774421692,
0.6185035705566406,
0.6904661059379578,
0.28091371059417725,
0.4749271869659424,
0.20677465200424194,
0.5591474175453186,
-0.6392311453819275,
0.3639189302921295,
-0.35222572088241577,
0.3699374198913574,
0.06990450620651245,
-0.5073601007461548,
-0.2411755472421646,
-0.004738169722259045,
-0.7789440751075745,
-0.06733855605125427,
0.7376675605773926,
0.4815070629119873,
0.10830776393413544,
0.2853070795536041,
0.5122614502906799,
0.15580414235591888,
0.5317466259002686,
1.2204697132110596,
1.4236005544662476,
-0.23780947923660278,
0.3957505226135254,
-0.16537298262119293,
-0.07603877037763596,
-0.015133261680603027,
-0.9655970931053162,
-1.1542065143585205,
-0.5490239858627319,
-0.4422891139984131,
-0.34032121300697327,
0.2752113938331604,
1.154185175895691,
0.36449167132377625,
-0.7371841073036194,
-0.16876468062400818,
0.02115878090262413,
0.35516157746315,
-0.29085758328437805,
-0.17460863292217255,
0.3358326852321625,
-0.20691463351249695,
-0.698721706867218,
0.13886338472366333,
0.5463874340057373,
0.06955541670322418,
-0.07101835310459137,
-0.04152408242225647,
-0.4262976348400116,
0.18330490589141846,
0.683911144733429,
0.26453426480293274,
-0.4974617063999176,
-0.27493348717689514,
0.3123264014720917,
-0.18756979703903198,
-0.07471027225255966,
1.0355466604232788,
-0.8234183192253113,
0.3549169600009918,
0.7038891911506653,
0.5576770901679993,
0.5494571328163147,
-0.26951369643211365,
0.5844350457191467,
-0.5292987823486328,
-0.02688276395201683,
0.45858412981033325,
0.4265576899051666,
0.19325457513332367,
-0.029500329867005348,
0.4650249481201172,
0.4115321636199951,
-0.669109046459198,
-0.5379886031150818,
0.405988484621048,
-1.2403188943862915,
-0.27938780188560486,
0.9563457369804382,
-0.011180159635841846,
-0.4332541823387146,
-0.5446447730064392,
0.0690612643957138,
0.2523222863674164,
-0.168100506067276,
0.6038188934326172,
0.7058122158050537,
-0.2049652487039566,
-0.5484709739685059,
-0.4684038460254669,
0.24726374447345734,
0.25954732298851013,
-1.0241788625717163,
0.0220798272639513,
0.4768194556236267,
0.07602629065513611,
-0.13071002066135406,
0.6324381828308105,
-0.12838737666606903,
0.5876532793045044,
-0.008181102573871613,
-0.37367385625839233,
0.016097696498036385,
-0.3431543707847595,
-0.21668937802314758,
0.10389845818281174,
-0.09033501148223877,
0.21556147933006287
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09067v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09067v2
|
How structured are the representations in transformer-based vision encoders? An analysis of multi-object representations in vision-language models
| 2024-06-13T12:54:20 | 2024-06-18T12:27:36 |
Tarun Khajuria, Braian Olmiro Dias, Jaan Aru
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, q-bio.NC
|
Forming and using symbol-like structured representations for reasoning has
been considered essential for generalising over novel inputs. The primary tool
that allows generalisation outside training data distribution is the ability to
abstract away irrelevant information into a compact form relevant to the task.
An extreme form of such abstract representations is symbols. Humans make use of
symbols to bind information while abstracting away irrelevant parts to utilise
the information consistently and meaningfully. This work estimates the state of
such structured representations in vision encoders. Specifically, we evaluate
image encoders in large vision-language pre-trained models to address the
question of which desirable properties their representations lack by applying
the criteria of symbolic structured reasoning described for LLMs to the image
models. We test the representation space of image encoders like VIT, BLIP,
CLIP, and FLAVA to characterise the distribution of the object representations
in these models. In particular, we create decoding tasks using multi-object
scenes from the COCO dataset, relating the token space to its input content for
various objects in the scene. We use these tasks to characterise the network's
token and layer-wise information modelling. Our analysis highlights that the
CLS token, used for the downstream task, only focuses on a few objects
necessary for the trained downstream task. Still, other individual objects are
well-modelled separately by the tokens in the network originating from those
objects. We further observed a widespread distribution of scene information.
This demonstrates that information is far more entangled in tokens than optimal
for representing objects similar to symbols. Given these symbolic properties,
we show the network dynamics that cause failure modes of these models on basic
downstream tasks in a multi-object scene.
|
[
-0.2011408656835556,
-0.4298904836177826,
0.46734142303466797,
0.11119981110095978,
-0.41982176899909973,
-0.13389499485492706,
-0.09444353729486465,
-0.5294064879417419,
-0.04442476108670235,
0.361624538898468,
-0.34774625301361084,
-0.360373318195343,
-0.8126603960990906,
0.4047849178314209,
-0.5979706645011902,
0.4940700829029083,
-0.17794573307037354,
0.08709626644849777,
-0.18883366882801056,
-0.2220921665430069,
-0.5652199983596802,
-0.9694361090660095,
-0.36739444732666016,
-0.3545778691768646,
0.4873184263706207,
-0.13633111119270325,
0.8213581442832947,
0.5800994038581848,
0.6828466653823853,
0.2907521724700928,
-0.21278223395347595,
0.1442565768957138,
-0.36715593934059143,
0.11263751238584518,
-0.10314124077558517,
-0.5927358865737915,
-0.10363411903381348,
-0.1372525990009308,
0.5084527134895325,
0.8375297784805298,
0.005885697435587645,
0.038259416818618774,
0.283221960067749,
0.27465009689331055,
-0.7511014342308044,
0.582598090171814,
-0.5577754378318787,
0.41793712973594666,
-0.06893864274024963,
-0.14981642365455627,
-0.6485500931739807,
0.17293256521224976,
-0.22728011012077332,
-0.6137613654136658,
0.06554166227579117,
0.26288315653800964,
0.95851731300354,
0.16797569394111633,
-0.4018738865852356,
-0.3533770740032196,
-0.7578562498092651,
0.6158862709999084,
-0.1551421880722046,
0.5652620196342468,
0.04949541017413139,
0.40035855770111084,
-0.1934397965669632,
-0.7224458456039429,
-0.38495683670043945,
-0.2912212610244751,
-0.5663072466850281,
0.10274791717529297,
-0.0018340288661420345,
0.29786357283592224,
0.3535442650318146,
0.185204416513443,
-0.10920281708240509,
-0.06793658435344696,
-0.5732130408287048,
-0.10182447731494904,
0.36531540751457214,
0.10522308945655823,
0.22019006311893463,
-0.19667917490005493,
-0.4965955913066864,
-0.23087696731090546,
-0.7349589467048645,
0.08490992337465286,
0.2037004977464676,
0.09512966871261597,
-0.06065809726715088,
0.922667384147644,
0.1707170009613037,
0.7971611022949219,
0.11652272194623947,
-0.13330614566802979,
0.012862891890108585,
-0.2674773931503296,
-0.3725335896015167,
0.09843697398900986,
0.67986661195755,
0.26614728569984436,
0.5875182151794434,
-0.17820575833320618,
-0.4249468147754669,
0.3307059109210968,
0.3050200641155243,
-0.5840080380439758,
-0.1356845200061798,
0.014786533080041409,
-0.5817334651947021,
0.010865396820008755,
0.42666617035865784,
-0.0845278799533844,
-0.25884371995925903,
-0.3146745264530182,
0.2320254147052765,
-0.21530552208423615,
-0.16659706830978394,
0.32169950008392334,
-0.3637951910495758,
0.5802675485610962,
0.37030795216560364,
-0.6920558214187622,
0.24580839276313782,
0.42656922340393066,
0.641179084777832,
-0.025562677532434464,
-0.1409824639558792,
-0.00989065133035183,
0.4007694721221924,
-0.6031436920166016,
0.6459536552429199,
-0.6552102565765381,
-0.2919928729534149,
0.016086645424365997,
0.32274916768074036,
-0.21997642517089844,
-0.5419416427612305,
0.2624870538711548,
-0.46028798818588257,
-0.32931971549987793,
-0.28658968210220337,
-0.28540611267089844,
-0.13700175285339355,
0.36317867040634155,
-0.9178968667984009,
0.7432793974876404,
-0.049136169254779816,
-0.5821832418441772,
0.5256491899490356,
-0.6144866347312927,
-0.4308825731277466,
-0.030547846108675003,
-0.5276347994804382,
-0.18199166655540466,
0.16179101169109344,
0.35105010867118835,
0.7533919215202332,
-0.029269110411405563,
0.3357352018356323,
-0.3411655128002167,
-0.521700382232666,
0.4501400291919708,
-0.4407225251197815,
0.2940857410430908,
0.07209151983261108,
-0.10692588239908218,
0.1405903697013855,
-0.39770227670669556,
-0.4187051057815552,
0.19156114757061005,
-0.16810011863708496,
-0.060843322426080704,
0.2522048354148865,
-0.030767152085900307,
0.35559701919555664,
0.03430582955479622,
-0.5962265133857727,
0.0843038558959961,
-0.1878422498703003,
0.7336058020591736,
0.7321295142173767,
-0.008958698250353336,
0.4331164062023163,
0.10313986241817474,
0.2973909080028534,
0.6780588626861572,
0.4567679464817047,
-0.5392709374427795,
-0.6034901738166809,
-0.7666822671890259,
-0.024465197697281837,
-0.26393601298332214,
0.18143771588802338,
-0.5560885071754456,
0.12919849157333374,
-0.3632100224494934,
0.07611016929149628,
-0.25205937027931213,
-0.0996372401714325,
0.2463599592447281,
0.17405745387077332,
0.2882600426673889,
-0.27867865562438965,
-0.3941466212272644,
-1.1337867975234985,
-0.01408957876265049,
0.05690431222319603,
-0.12796203792095184,
0.13596117496490479,
0.7292461395263672,
-0.15746328234672546,
0.9804057478904724,
-0.3885499835014343,
-0.27419203519821167,
-0.343542218208313,
-0.2526051700115204,
0.2896844446659088,
0.3918237090110779,
0.3723661005496979,
-1.007029414176941,
0.2288929671049118,
-0.049257341772317886,
-0.9717749357223511,
0.4424799084663391,
-0.24691404402256012,
-0.07398989796638489,
0.1373688131570816,
0.49310302734375,
-0.5506211519241333,
0.7342700362205505,
0.3513437807559967,
-0.34079501032829285,
0.42405498027801514,
-0.19298741221427917,
0.091545969247818,
-0.6926928162574768,
0.12281887978315353,
-0.02243351936340332,
-0.26271530985832214,
-0.3964487612247467,
0.13314826786518097,
0.05508759245276451,
-0.3600064814090729,
-0.6748439073562622,
0.2678876519203186,
-0.7346818447113037,
-0.42819419503211975,
0.15732944011688232,
0.1132805272936821,
0.24827401340007782,
0.7585268020629883,
0.3427608013153076,
0.5407675504684448,
0.6967576742172241,
-0.5640684962272644,
0.3549942374229431,
0.19039388000965118,
-0.2749551832675934,
0.5239524841308594,
-0.9903220534324646,
0.00893034040927887,
-0.566992998123169,
0.3404710590839386,
-0.7585093975067139,
-0.29411113262176514,
0.4271467328071594,
0.025947896763682365,
0.26276111602783203,
-0.24771879613399506,
-0.7347297072410583,
-0.39882969856262207,
0.03943852707743645,
0.6336385607719421,
0.3687713146209717,
-0.4107091724872589,
0.7507160305976868,
0.2558153569698334,
0.4783799946308136,
-0.5104629397392273,
-1.038405418395996,
0.13551411032676697,
0.04414837062358856,
-0.6802753210067749,
0.22738875448703766,
0.2972661256790161,
-0.08421371132135391,
0.37792766094207764,
-0.3448515236377716,
-0.21495771408081055,
-0.18040809035301208,
0.6484270095825195,
0.1893998682498932,
-0.22541311383247375,
0.02111378312110901,
-0.2082967460155487,
0.1303642839193344,
0.1916394978761673,
-0.29048317670822144,
0.45292991399765015,
-0.35885438323020935,
-0.8264263868331909,
-0.30326101183891296,
0.3038775622844696,
0.6220611333847046,
-0.24883054196834564,
0.9427342414855957,
0.2685469090938568,
-0.4401531517505646,
-0.07951823621988297,
-0.21572653949260712,
-0.15482449531555176,
-0.45282360911369324,
0.38038885593414307,
-0.6687453985214233,
-0.7591907978057861,
0.7593545913696289,
0.15889061987400055,
-0.08471879363059998,
0.5634741187095642,
0.32816100120544434,
-0.193814218044281,
0.9472906589508057,
0.3659652769565582,
0.3168686330318451,
0.26645350456237793,
-0.6449115872383118,
0.383971631526947,
-0.8175104856491089,
-0.941758394241333,
0.02885185368359089,
-0.42264077067375183,
-0.15563690662384033,
-0.7029655575752258,
0.29886335134506226,
0.36329054832458496,
-0.30072444677352905,
0.3517336845397949,
-0.7080948352813721,
0.4647701680660248,
0.18664662539958954,
0.2393503487110138,
0.1622007191181183,
-0.08715888857841492,
-0.10818479210138321,
0.37809082865715027,
-0.8319016098976135,
-0.45170795917510986,
0.7692359685897827,
0.3955342471599579,
1.0006096363067627,
-0.3461846113204956,
0.28661227226257324,
0.08958183974027634,
0.22485820949077606,
-0.7274507284164429,
0.5053206086158752,
-0.05370538681745529,
-0.3956596255302429,
0.06122036278247833,
-0.08301812410354614,
-0.9101722836494446,
0.2659335136413574,
-0.13128262758255005,
-0.43067729473114014,
0.5577076077461243,
0.1418081670999527,
0.06755276024341583,
0.4582149088382721,
-0.4090766906738281,
0.8638807535171509,
-0.05908450856804848,
0.020233776420354843,
-0.06580200791358948,
-0.6624493598937988,
0.4188474118709564,
0.13481497764587402,
0.047307562083005905,
0.11669280380010605,
0.0782235860824585,
0.5905261039733887,
-0.4630156457424164,
0.9265648126602173,
-0.010985230095684528,
0.08387957513332367,
0.6491339206695557,
0.021378017961978912,
0.3956984877586365,
-0.09115222096443176,
0.14164204895496368,
0.5336519479751587,
-0.006070098374038935,
-0.3387373983860016,
-0.7053937315940857,
0.08064719289541245,
-0.6643876433372498,
-0.46370160579681396,
-0.32647112011909485,
-0.2361411303281784,
0.24049614369869232,
-0.07152308523654938,
0.35998889803886414,
0.8950288891792297,
0.23479363322257996,
0.44346848130226135,
0.31533271074295044,
-0.2067551165819168,
0.372381329536438,
-0.3513960540294647,
-0.09071768820285797,
0.02291446551680565,
0.3337205648422241,
0.02483925223350525,
0.3134768605232239,
0.5221751928329468,
-0.19739896059036255,
-0.4814409911632538,
-0.3552932143211365,
-0.4806796908378601,
0.03704288601875305,
-1.2962646484375,
-0.3212825357913971,
-0.37817490100860596,
-0.46909016370773315,
-0.01681559346616268,
-0.37979549169540405,
-0.3547717034816742,
-0.19801448285579681,
-0.32816198468208313,
-0.23257997632026672,
0.03086964040994644,
1.0409471988677979,
0.4855149984359741,
0.35338306427001953,
-0.6461949348449707,
0.39507126808166504,
0.052290163934230804,
0.45591771602630615,
-0.059985630214214325,
-0.22559674084186554,
-0.2665293514728546,
0.14591358602046967,
-0.01197262667119503,
-0.977257251739502,
0.04309413582086563,
0.2941012978553772,
0.6368823051452637,
0.5553035140037537,
-0.17340227961540222,
0.8915553092956543,
-0.45595216751098633,
0.8713327050209045,
0.3136025667190552,
-0.7919829487800598,
0.4351058900356293,
-0.013054038397967815,
0.09737780690193176,
0.0320352278649807,
0.09803736954927444,
-0.43854671716690063,
-0.580534040927887,
-0.3194586932659149,
-0.5920397639274597,
0.5930101871490479,
0.4363555908203125,
0.19820928573608398,
-0.21228161454200745,
0.4279240667819977,
-0.20853760838508606,
0.08380026370286942,
-0.8566838502883911,
-0.20280209183692932,
-0.7288521528244019,
-0.17990604043006897,
0.2574842572212219,
-0.23958921432495117,
0.04311395063996315,
-0.17087610065937042,
-0.04378383979201317,
-0.09065137803554535,
0.552194356918335,
0.3904489576816559,
-0.4220829904079437,
0.279858261346817,
0.12958408892154694,
0.2752564549446106,
0.689678430557251,
0.1889917403459549,
0.38372185826301575,
0.024726081639528275,
-0.39535725116729736,
0.2173437923192978,
-0.400553822517395,
0.15421722829341888,
0.1037890836596489,
0.5745275616645813,
1.098759651184082,
0.5418037176132202,
-0.4968383014202118,
0.6226930618286133,
0.11706242710351944,
-0.1094534620642662,
-0.39519020915031433,
0.0858050063252449,
-0.09737436473369598,
0.0991070494055748,
0.32643818855285645,
0.4215839207172394,
0.032875970005989075,
-0.6566010117530823,
0.04952163249254227,
0.38314342498779297,
-0.34696635603904724,
-0.5759310126304626,
0.7297038435935974,
0.003009970998391509,
0.05333350971341133,
0.8281127214431763,
-0.05980423837900162,
-0.5124211311340332,
0.7844606041908264,
0.49686524271965027,
0.7777538299560547,
0.14442482590675354,
0.10180250555276871,
0.3209739327430725,
0.5215902328491211,
-0.3541223108768463,
0.05853493511676788,
-0.1986287385225296,
-0.9670026898384094,
-0.514380693435669,
-0.8796179294586182,
-0.1307857781648636,
-0.2100217491388321,
-0.49483969807624817,
0.14523015916347504,
-0.33231809735298157,
-0.17279256880283356,
-0.36192211508750916,
-0.7242576479911804,
-1.0932056903839111,
0.22591134905815125,
0.3050231635570526,
0.8858856558799744,
-0.7781495451927185,
0.6731675267219543,
0.6785808205604553,
-0.3705230951309204,
-1.0687633752822876,
-0.4342276155948639,
-0.4401736557483673,
-0.9493663311004639,
1.1233370304107666,
0.4902159571647644,
-0.33798059821128845,
-0.2215116173028946,
-0.4815749526023865,
-0.9698889255523682,
1.0112278461456299,
0.5166928172111511,
-0.5533787608146667,
-0.13320323824882507,
0.5049805641174316,
0.44438397884368896,
-0.5065509080886841,
0.2545467019081116,
0.17138072848320007,
0.4746575653553009,
0.5278120636940002,
-0.6395900845527649,
0.15613096952438354,
-0.24367713928222656,
0.2816639542579651,
0.2359163612127304,
-0.10370340198278427,
0.7915869951248169,
-0.2139929234981537,
-0.7088183164596558,
-0.21102067828178406,
0.37199434638023376,
0.1306186020374298,
-0.16576941311359406,
0.5126880407333374,
0.34553053975105286,
0.31418776512145996,
-0.30789121985435486,
1.3452296257019043,
-0.3748464584350586,
0.31008124351501465,
0.5748234987258911,
0.07434546947479248,
0.601457953453064,
0.5360658764839172,
-0.07793648540973663,
0.5793318748474121,
0.5542436242103577,
-0.2468472272157669,
0.2655688524246216,
0.21972693502902985,
0.24133312702178955,
-0.2611308991909027,
-0.08337600529193878,
-0.030123455449938774,
0.5054081082344055,
0.4052252769470215,
-0.5439167022705078,
-0.13143567740917206,
0.22326090931892395,
-0.4392121434211731,
-0.3906967341899872,
-0.5548144578933716,
0.6089357733726501,
0.3708852231502533,
-0.4826695919036865,
0.47351983189582825,
-0.04040245711803436,
0.38216742873191833,
-0.5363177061080933,
-0.12836873531341553,
0.034032002091407776,
0.11986763775348663,
-0.3359280824661255,
-1.0627261400222778,
0.5445730686187744,
-0.24138100445270538,
0.06000589206814766,
-0.4324827790260315,
0.7751284837722778,
-0.4226703345775604,
-0.6973326802253723,
0.29264575242996216,
0.11610710620880127,
0.30097731947898865,
-0.20689009130001068,
-0.3770246207714081,
0.2966480851173401,
-0.49690377712249756,
-0.2853522300720215,
-0.07894772291183472,
0.34475967288017273,
-0.30215808749198914,
0.6411538124084473,
0.42682579159736633,
0.09487580507993698,
0.4189104437828064,
0.2254953235387802,
0.9373917579650879,
-0.6952798962593079,
-0.4211901128292084,
-0.9603691101074219,
0.6210479140281677,
0.005398058798164129,
0.04062141478061676,
0.4885501563549042,
0.45065006613731384,
0.7865806221961975,
-0.19502940773963928,
0.34828609228134155,
0.09516992419958115,
-0.6590753793716431,
-0.5984928011894226,
0.4020116627216339,
-0.40280646085739136,
0.06642918288707733,
-0.1268300712108612,
-1.1991896629333496,
-0.3914516568183899,
0.7050930261611938,
-0.1567263901233673,
-0.10518154501914978,
0.7605107426643372,
0.6487163305282593,
-0.3217673897743225,
-0.009552071802318096,
0.38214564323425293,
0.0813898891210556,
0.23986519873142242,
0.5920526385307312,
1.0121673345565796,
-0.32014793157577515,
0.4902249872684479,
0.02828693576157093,
0.18479585647583008,
-0.10728668421506882,
-0.6237891912460327,
-0.7466071844100952,
-0.6339563727378845,
-0.12688858807086945,
0.01514402125030756,
0.05696624144911766,
0.5105535387992859,
0.9198814034461975,
-0.5330872535705566,
-0.09283047169446945,
-0.16173313558101654,
0.19039832055568695,
-0.1499144285917282,
-0.19434762001037598,
0.40051597356796265,
-0.30963099002838135,
-0.44719526171684265,
0.005098918918520212,
0.6996408700942993,
0.030757756903767586,
-0.39981508255004883,
-0.07223894447088242,
0.3829018175601959,
0.005526936147361994,
0.9047669172286987,
-0.11498093605041504,
-0.937117338180542,
-0.4693944454193115,
0.10255182534456253,
-0.12331055104732513,
0.3678218722343445,
0.9716854691505432,
-0.9438294172286987,
0.3776976764202118,
0.1925734281539917,
0.23475028574466705,
0.6174825429916382,
-0.009479876607656479,
0.4233814775943756,
-0.846706748008728,
0.40597543120384216,
0.172723650932312,
0.8330059051513672,
0.34365588426589966,
-0.2576647102832794,
0.24562466144561768,
0.1997455209493637,
-0.1211327612400055,
-0.5338013172149658,
0.45442306995391846,
-1.0067447423934937,
-0.4204702079296112,
1.0233432054519653,
-0.27634328603744507,
-0.5828932523727417,
-0.051819443702697754,
0.013046717271208763,
0.12429165095090866,
-0.1677541881799698,
0.22563084959983826,
0.4705328643321991,
-0.21595297753810883,
-0.4484376609325409,
-0.1487613022327423,
0.20991893112659454,
-0.21755985915660858,
-0.5501804351806641,
-0.12358929216861725,
0.4447784125804901,
0.12228391319513321,
0.28373920917510986,
0.3759074807167053,
-0.38729989528656006,
-0.08250080049037933,
0.07330426573753357,
-0.13618052005767822,
-0.3645978569984436,
-0.5831505060195923,
-0.10288473218679428,
0.5780445337295532,
-0.17038977146148682,
-0.3495963513851166
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09056v1
|
CUDRT: Benchmarking the Detection of Human vs. Large Language Models Generated Texts
| 2024-06-13T12:43:40 | 2024-06-13T12:43:40 |
Zhen Tao, Zhiyu Li, Dinghao Xi, Wei Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) has significantly enhanced
text generation capabilities across various industries. However, these models'
ability to generate human-like text poses substantial challenges in discerning
between human and AI authorship. Despite the effectiveness of existing
AI-generated text detectors, their development is hindered by the lack of
comprehensive, publicly available benchmarks. Current benchmarks are limited to
specific scenarios, such as question answering and text polishing, and
predominantly focus on English texts, failing to capture the diverse
applications and linguistic nuances of LLMs. To address these limitations, this
paper constructs a comprehensive bilingual benchmark in both Chinese and
English to evaluate mainstream AI-generated text detectors. We categorize LLM
text generation into five distinct operations: Create, Update, Delete, Rewrite,
and Translate (CUDRT), encompassing all current LLMs activities. We also
establish a robust benchmark evaluation framework to support scalable and
reproducible experiments. For each CUDRT category, we have developed extensive
datasets to thoroughly assess detector performance. By employing the latest
mainstream LLMs specific to each language, our datasets provide a thorough
evaluation environment. Extensive experimental results offer critical insights
for optimizing AI-generated text detectors and suggest future research
directions to improve detection accuracy and generalizability across various
scenarios.
|
[
-0.16551107168197632,
-0.7549318671226501,
0.6139763593673706,
0.18780571222305298,
-0.13290560245513916,
0.13064022362232208,
-0.5109297037124634,
-0.39428773522377014,
-0.30213475227355957,
0.4107527434825897,
-0.2588234841823578,
-0.5156216025352478,
-0.5552635192871094,
0.6274550557136536,
-0.36360570788383484,
0.8769177794456482,
-0.10114870220422745,
-0.02107514627277851,
-0.2523820102214813,
-0.0070767877623438835,
-0.36504462361335754,
-0.49670618772506714,
-0.9064972996711731,
-0.315923273563385,
0.46230459213256836,
0.1806938201189041,
0.4927162528038025,
0.6887339353561401,
0.5969234108924866,
0.3325679898262024,
0.000019253733626101166,
0.5271532535552979,
-0.26189613342285156,
0.335711807012558,
0.13093186914920807,
-0.3920149505138397,
-0.5014005899429321,
-0.07344067096710205,
0.875452995300293,
0.2926754653453827,
0.053834088146686554,
0.08011746406555176,
-0.108530193567276,
0.22356539964675903,
-0.62498939037323,
0.0626717135310173,
-0.7879736423492432,
-0.00596382562071085,
-0.6367334723472595,
-0.11010588705539703,
-0.5814632177352905,
-0.16420938074588776,
-0.22035770118236542,
-0.25758564472198486,
0.5056645274162292,
0.06737646460533142,
0.5076935291290283,
0.08130425214767456,
-0.5886216759681702,
-0.2331310212612152,
-0.4745320975780487,
0.7782686352729797,
-0.8547070026397705,
0.3849211633205414,
0.2590542733669281,
0.1812792420387268,
-0.1797138899564743,
-0.934312105178833,
-0.841602623462677,
-0.4472118318080902,
-0.08170707523822784,
0.08752762526273727,
-0.2752569317817688,
-0.2188781201839447,
0.3158997893333435,
0.39562273025512695,
-0.854191243648529,
0.4960455000400543,
0.1473211646080017,
-0.4201843738555908,
0.7981438040733337,
0.3755844533443451,
0.6781961917877197,
-0.16248729825019836,
-0.12285225838422775,
-0.27470168471336365,
-0.6844333410263062,
0.013055482879281044,
0.5174272060394287,
0.2186174988746643,
-0.25437864661216736,
0.448535680770874,
-0.05414218083024025,
0.41963812708854675,
-0.0690600648522377,
-0.058867812156677246,
0.3003356456756592,
-0.4723670184612274,
-0.09632585942745209,
-0.10454581677913666,
1.3141639232635498,
0.2259330302476883,
0.2639108896255493,
-0.4427839517593384,
-0.42160460352897644,
0.05798793584108353,
0.05884038284420967,
-0.7919777035713196,
-0.10560137778520584,
0.03925672173500061,
-0.34114256501197815,
-0.45204782485961914,
0.101652130484581,
-0.44328880310058594,
-0.4790958762168884,
-0.1014193668961525,
-0.04136495664715767,
-0.09777096658945084,
-0.3844718933105469,
-0.08283679187297821,
-0.009896764531731606,
0.4270397126674652,
0.09654899686574936,
-0.9293273687362671,
0.23740479350090027,
1.0055667161941528,
0.7030099630355835,
-0.6068981885910034,
-0.5069407820701599,
-0.9589056968688965,
0.10640782117843628,
-0.43017828464508057,
0.9836587309837341,
-0.11874651908874512,
-0.30652543902397156,
-0.05062032490968704,
0.006997155956923962,
-0.005819540470838547,
-0.7097364664077759,
0.9430755972862244,
-0.3603810966014862,
0.1746612787246704,
-0.21826033294200897,
-0.4649496078491211,
0.3090152442455292,
0.49037185311317444,
-0.6532024145126343,
1.1151034832000732,
-0.07312073558568954,
-0.9043029546737671,
0.35958799719810486,
-0.3424103260040283,
-0.9144293665885925,
0.3294169306755066,
-0.5370371341705322,
-0.7353702187538147,
0.014892731793224812,
0.3414461016654968,
0.5205179452896118,
-0.6342763304710388,
0.642841637134552,
0.026698825880885124,
-0.25354573130607605,
0.2498607039451599,
-0.6322699189186096,
0.9253096580505371,
0.09927215427160263,
-0.4179651439189911,
0.18064598739147186,
-0.5181106328964233,
-0.2879752218723297,
0.11617884784936905,
-0.42590799927711487,
-0.09494874626398087,
0.09552634507417679,
0.4672161638736725,
-0.11975682526826859,
0.33443236351013184,
-0.7229232788085938,
-0.22049978375434875,
-0.12990611791610718,
0.44042152166366577,
0.7767554521560669,
-0.21639660000801086,
0.19041749835014343,
-0.39186781644821167,
0.5234455466270447,
0.007104847580194473,
-0.11989857256412506,
-0.40366318821907043,
-0.5187433958053589,
-0.5184985399246216,
-0.37674081325531006,
0.08299506455659866,
0.5730665922164917,
-0.8256959915161133,
0.5394901633262634,
-0.34669479727745056,
-0.5192108154296875,
-0.4641488194465637,
0.34567147493362427,
0.48742052912712097,
0.5697354674339294,
0.14536666870117188,
-0.29081830382347107,
-0.41629868745803833,
-1.017247200012207,
-0.620883047580719,
-0.2939743995666504,
-0.26801159977912903,
0.21147195994853973,
0.46171998977661133,
-0.28892579674720764,
0.6985921859741211,
-0.2138453722000122,
-0.23285454511642456,
-0.3820640742778778,
0.272590309381485,
0.05937262251973152,
0.3780747950077057,
0.4638967514038086,
-0.8654695749282837,
-0.8054500818252563,
0.24646635353565216,
-0.9070217609405518,
-0.2763238847255707,
-0.20574912428855896,
0.05436445772647858,
0.4008157253265381,
0.7544000148773193,
-0.6598948836326599,
0.3908270597457886,
0.40545418858528137,
-0.14191702008247375,
0.7052288055419922,
-0.3949272036552429,
0.16835971176624298,
-1.0679824352264404,
0.25556856393814087,
0.09047488123178482,
-0.3141063153743744,
-0.7208743691444397,
0.3001473546028137,
0.4415591061115265,
0.035083040595054626,
-0.30061423778533936,
0.6259440779685974,
-0.5208284258842468,
-0.09223038703203201,
-0.30856582522392273,
0.18746525049209595,
-0.08115686476230621,
0.25422006845474243,
0.024014385417103767,
1.0111095905303955,
0.17303483188152313,
-0.21805346012115479,
0.41838815808296204,
0.08860695362091064,
-0.6463634371757507,
0.5829727649688721,
-0.8838854432106018,
0.24294035136699677,
-0.024455346167087555,
0.34253135323524475,
-1.061604619026184,
-0.1033702865242958,
0.06002146750688553,
-0.5321569442749023,
0.26155006885528564,
0.18900130689144135,
-1.1567829847335815,
-0.21144182980060577,
-0.4141412675380707,
0.4237944781780243,
0.5000859498977661,
-0.426957905292511,
0.606998085975647,
0.3073330521583557,
-0.23741233348846436,
-0.3562222421169281,
-0.7121143341064453,
0.5005452036857605,
-0.08422675728797913,
-0.7386136054992676,
0.3742271065711975,
0.013295804150402546,
-0.4088501036167145,
-0.19107629358768463,
0.14733226597309113,
0.12768429517745972,
0.2741631269454956,
-0.06658165156841278,
0.20350097119808197,
-0.3590559959411621,
-0.19459566473960876,
0.14019127190113068,
-0.17521829903125763,
0.21833699941635132,
0.2515275776386261,
0.5092527270317078,
0.12146810442209244,
-0.26164400577545166,
-0.5473281741142273,
0.22779566049575806,
0.6160297989845276,
-0.6160159707069397,
0.42324763536453247,
0.9462143778800964,
-0.3068574070930481,
-0.2518423795700073,
-0.6805340647697449,
-0.055825453251600266,
-0.4568142592906952,
0.44220873713493347,
-0.34864985942840576,
-0.6119329333305359,
0.3958297371864319,
0.3401687741279602,
0.20291565358638763,
0.43454235792160034,
1.0123224258422852,
0.15087591111660004,
1.0728107690811157,
0.2822628319263458,
-0.4123856723308563,
0.2894134819507599,
0.06430792063474655,
0.23540756106376648,
-0.8997130393981934,
0.007450444623827934,
-0.6991605758666992,
-0.07692752033472061,
-0.7289393544197083,
-0.5749557614326477,
0.2751457393169403,
-0.4268334209918976,
-0.3120589256286621,
0.5003596544265747,
-0.3978658616542816,
0.46433109045028687,
0.6490687727928162,
0.01704859361052513,
0.5265988707542419,
-0.11004418134689331,
0.05365028232336044,
-0.09047601372003555,
-0.28278395533561707,
-0.6025866270065308,
1.2977070808410645,
0.14750440418720245,
0.5039940476417542,
0.14683657884597778,
0.6180941462516785,
0.5135203003883362,
0.41081976890563965,
-0.3669578433036804,
0.5663654804229736,
-0.43972018361091614,
-0.5274772047996521,
-0.059257492423057556,
-0.4011960029602051,
-0.9766865372657776,
0.2625792324542999,
-0.2413475066423416,
-0.5131714344024658,
-0.18429993093013763,
-0.21824860572814941,
0.02862771973013878,
0.417683482170105,
-0.4901369512081146,
0.965395987033844,
-0.4332300126552582,
-0.4781538248062134,
-0.13720500469207764,
-0.4201171100139618,
0.3106288015842438,
-0.21968510746955872,
0.02072593756020069,
-0.20682260394096375,
-0.11027447879314423,
0.5604071617126465,
-0.12940636277198792,
0.723788857460022,
0.13171793520450592,
-0.26965662837028503,
0.15108908712863922,
0.09816357493400574,
0.6377958059310913,
0.037777312099933624,
-0.2825714945793152,
0.11477169394493103,
-0.3426436185836792,
-0.3176838755607605,
-0.09139839559793472,
0.7684054374694824,
-0.7533665895462036,
-0.5301418304443359,
-0.37068694829940796,
-0.9028013944625854,
0.07242003083229065,
0.42593416571617126,
0.48382270336151123,
0.3828115165233612,
-0.38975784182548523,
0.11257079988718033,
0.39354434609413147,
-0.4953243136405945,
0.3644324243068695,
0.4782562255859375,
0.01488126814365387,
-0.26456180214881897,
0.8518758416175842,
-0.373130202293396,
0.07178235054016113,
0.5721055269241333,
0.08136282861232758,
-0.3481515645980835,
-0.7352678775787354,
-0.5199973583221436,
0.2581571638584137,
-0.473592609167099,
-0.0821760967373848,
-0.6754068732261658,
-0.28535696864128113,
-0.6622854471206665,
-0.18710540235042572,
-0.09837529063224792,
0.11316261440515518,
-0.248832568526268,
0.06930316239595413,
-0.03339417278766632,
0.4771697521209717,
0.0831916481256485,
0.09749814867973328,
-0.4762362539768219,
0.6901534795761108,
0.23966796696186066,
0.07148666679859161,
0.1407638043165207,
-0.41613590717315674,
-0.0826757401227951,
0.09893516451120377,
-0.5550442934036255,
-0.33932656049728394,
0.454262375831604,
-0.017288725823163986,
0.7573462128639221,
0.2990657091140747,
0.19649574160575867,
0.3903784453868866,
-0.4603836238384247,
0.7214986085891724,
-0.0666070431470871,
-0.9006408452987671,
0.2803710699081421,
-0.4638344645500183,
0.33736276626586914,
0.3388769328594208,
-0.0018769357120618224,
-0.6889393329620361,
-0.7810024619102478,
-0.2979918420314789,
-0.6166244745254517,
0.60536128282547,
0.4180241823196411,
0.22198207676410675,
-0.1244371309876442,
0.09822563827037811,
0.1350831240415573,
0.019687874242663383,
-0.6549484133720398,
-0.10071901977062225,
0.2922826409339905,
-0.3484640121459961,
-0.3960897624492645,
-0.08004196733236313,
0.1929841935634613,
-0.05307477340102196,
0.36045095324516296,
0.00838230736553669,
-0.058939576148986816,
0.14094004034996033,
-0.30381491780281067,
0.015947900712490082,
0.06869807094335556,
0.617817759513855,
0.34885531663894653,
-0.1642242968082428,
0.12869325280189514,
0.02390817366540432,
-0.5168783664703369,
-0.0473887100815773,
0.18375129997730255,
-0.46091368794441223,
0.06898054480552673,
0.8306540846824646,
0.6456357836723328,
0.008473969995975494,
-0.9998872876167297,
0.601341962814331,
-0.22735415399074554,
-0.10626121610403061,
-0.38913071155548096,
-0.05933728814125061,
0.13080495595932007,
0.16991442441940308,
0.46925801038742065,
-0.1761707365512848,
0.059436485171318054,
-0.5180975794792175,
0.15420012176036835,
0.5469525456428528,
0.01537687424570322,
-0.4438904821872711,
1.092759132385254,
0.35928961634635925,
-0.5782240629196167,
0.7697681188583374,
-0.1883707195520401,
-0.6457899808883667,
0.9720403552055359,
0.4211706221103668,
1.1744933128356934,
0.08896076679229736,
0.09152905642986298,
0.376066654920578,
0.46792858839035034,
-0.11783665418624878,
-0.05662984773516655,
-0.3263358771800995,
-0.9809143543243408,
-0.23592756688594818,
-0.19185614585876465,
-0.5510669350624084,
0.0981295183300972,
-0.6004152297973633,
0.37860846519470215,
-0.2948566973209381,
-0.12513680756092072,
0.2879498302936554,
0.20732787251472473,
-0.6988466382026672,
-0.2365465760231018,
0.46826454997062683,
0.7648484110832214,
-0.8128061294555664,
0.8066345453262329,
0.656218945980072,
-0.19365741312503815,
-0.3782064914703369,
0.1167893260717392,
0.1613863706588745,
-0.8440983891487122,
0.5851057767868042,
0.3985119163990021,
0.006864506285637617,
-0.0073014795780181885,
-0.4313240647315979,
-0.06086921691894531,
1.2054145336151123,
0.266466349363327,
-0.3852253556251526,
0.03389488160610199,
0.4025936722755432,
0.8175020217895508,
-0.2601453363895416,
0.27542632818222046,
0.72051602602005,
0.5064936280250549,
-0.4557687044143677,
-0.949268639087677,
0.03336156904697418,
-0.29883626103401184,
0.06506320834159851,
0.05044195055961609,
-0.5604619979858398,
1.091996192932129,
-0.005325079895555973,
-0.38449063897132874,
0.42210933566093445,
0.4380152225494385,
0.5360535383224487,
0.5656333565711975,
0.4136445224285126,
0.533513069152832,
0.4454537034034729,
-0.008466409519314766,
1.0587942600250244,
-0.29577043652534485,
0.11677399277687073,
1.0461375713348389,
-0.6472952961921692,
0.8246431350708008,
0.3650071620941162,
-0.20788264274597168,
0.29557883739471436,
0.33208274841308594,
-0.2525804042816162,
0.1910068690776825,
0.12753957509994507,
-0.4080609977245331,
-0.3550095558166504,
-0.19187764823436737,
-0.23439031839370728,
0.3413007855415344,
0.0015273930039256811,
-0.3224826753139496,
-0.2509925961494446,
-0.16198745369911194,
0.10846270620822906,
0.47326481342315674,
-0.01990908943116665,
0.6717659831047058,
-0.10903800278902054,
-0.8885422348976135,
0.315379798412323,
0.2433691918849945,
0.976057231426239,
-0.3783661723136902,
0.2462439239025116,
-0.6570807695388794,
0.48025912046432495,
-0.021819625049829483,
-0.8103446960449219,
-0.15333281457424164,
0.4006481170654297,
-0.06307696551084518,
-0.2829380929470062,
0.5398141145706177,
-0.5213872194290161,
-0.6273186802864075,
0.2290608286857605,
0.4916633069515228,
0.11417844146490097,
-0.026624398306012154,
-0.4987429976463318,
0.2382664680480957,
0.005965016782283783,
-0.1055949330329895,
0.2541937530040741,
0.5989803671836853,
-0.26351243257522583,
0.6285704374313354,
0.8467705845832825,
0.20144101977348328,
0.05579453706741333,
-0.014533137902617455,
0.6534250378608704,
-0.47764864563941956,
-0.2822434902191162,
-0.9420931339263916,
0.2545092701911926,
-0.1421220898628235,
-0.36050283908843994,
0.9240159392356873,
0.8934171795845032,
1.017449975013733,
-0.09344510734081268,
0.8388776779174805,
-0.1516653299331665,
0.41351091861724854,
-0.15809255838394165,
0.9377573728561401,
-0.48837506771087646,
0.3336145877838135,
-0.35927656292915344,
-0.8272572159767151,
-0.4071798026561737,
0.302910178899765,
-0.2411661297082901,
-0.16096055507659912,
0.40566253662109375,
0.8854818940162659,
-0.05408554896712303,
-0.23472470045089722,
0.3665955364704132,
0.15152223408222198,
0.8170153498649597,
0.6834635138511658,
0.7698841691017151,
-0.6341295838356018,
0.5174933075904846,
-0.3456680476665497,
0.046707045286893845,
-0.09678129851818085,
-0.9196069240570068,
-1.1537714004516602,
-0.6080268621444702,
-0.2887767553329468,
0.05764702335000038,
-0.1426815390586853,
0.5307648777961731,
0.44665125012397766,
-0.8772581815719604,
-0.4778588116168976,
-0.10488439351320267,
0.12036798894405365,
-0.0856761485338211,
-0.20266851782798767,
0.6109446287155151,
-0.2663845419883728,
-1.0257827043533325,
0.20662933588027954,
0.16924291849136353,
-0.05984030291438103,
-0.3259314298629761,
-0.23784272372722626,
-0.1776018887758255,
-0.16576921939849854,
0.6444202661514282,
0.2875159680843353,
-0.7872593998908997,
-0.06032722815871239,
0.1013459861278534,
-0.4510335624217987,
-0.1819387674331665,
0.9758633375167847,
-0.5551038980484009,
0.5048426985740662,
0.69064861536026,
0.8719995021820068,
0.4085310399532318,
-0.01046741846948862,
0.7142663598060608,
-0.587726891040802,
0.2941758930683136,
0.2535448968410492,
0.2971457242965698,
0.48982030153274536,
-0.1464139223098755,
0.5261706113815308,
0.21367789804935455,
-0.6521923542022705,
-1.2304130792617798,
0.05089997872710228,
-0.8818886876106262,
-0.12835921347141266,
0.9945996403694153,
-0.18786311149597168,
-0.02948429249227047,
-0.10283178836107254,
-0.18233774602413177,
0.2321101427078247,
-0.28057318925857544,
0.6513985991477966,
0.57813560962677,
0.1559695154428482,
-0.17913109064102173,
-0.42723554372787476,
0.2881435453891754,
0.32870081067085266,
-0.8684529066085815,
0.26733389496803284,
0.42573797702789307,
0.2701663672924042,
-0.19182005524635315,
0.7666413187980652,
-0.07663223147392273,
0.5390036702156067,
0.06293796002864838,
0.18322667479515076,
-0.19737818837165833,
0.015755554661154747,
-0.019318973645567894,
-0.18407124280929565,
0.0331883430480957,
0.029033981263637543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10297v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10297v1
|
SememeLM: A Sememe Knowledge Enhanced Method for Long-tail Relation Representation
| 2024-06-13T12:42:49 | 2024-06-13T12:42:49 |
Shuyi Li, Shaojuan Wu, Xiaowang Zhang, Zhiyong Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recognizing relations between two words is a fundamental task with the broad
applications. Different from extracting relations from text, it is difficult to
identify relations among words without their contexts. Especially for long-tail
relations, it becomes more difficult due to inadequate semantic features.
Existing approaches based on language models (LMs) utilize rich knowledge of
LMs to enhance the semantic features of relations. However, they capture
uncommon relations while overlooking less frequent but meaningful ones since
knowledge of LMs seriously relies on trained data where often represents common
relations. On the other hand, long-tail relations are often uncommon in
training data. It is interesting but not trivial to use external knowledge to
enrich LMs due to collecting corpus containing long-tail relationships is
hardly feasible. In this paper, we propose a sememe knowledge enhanced method
(SememeLM) to enhance the representation of long-tail relations, in which
sememes can break the contextual constraints between wors. Firstly, we present
a sememe relation graph and propose a graph encoding method. Moreover, since
external knowledge base possibly consisting of massive irrelevant knowledge,
the noise is introduced. We propose a consistency alignment module, which
aligns the introduced knowledge with LMs, reduces the noise and integrates the
knowledge into the language model. Finally, we conducted experiments on word
analogy datasets, which evaluates the ability to distinguish relation
representations subtle differences, including long-tail relations. Extensive
experiments show that our approach outperforms some state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.41473695635795593,
-0.6638103127479553,
0.603965699672699,
0.3117331564426422,
-0.47261783480644226,
-0.26479044556617737,
-0.3986179828643799,
-0.6116454601287842,
0.4307193160057068,
0.7751081585884094,
-0.49046167731285095,
-0.5331209301948547,
-0.6492968201637268,
0.04719697684049606,
-0.08562196046113968,
0.6676658987998962,
-0.16056831181049347,
0.05527336522936821,
-0.39523857831954956,
-0.6518639922142029,
-0.32056066393852234,
-0.5787917971611023,
-0.3389887511730194,
-0.5745453238487244,
0.4826388657093048,
-0.03905951976776123,
0.6902370452880859,
0.6357227563858032,
0.39633482694625854,
0.23710797727108002,
-0.32877981662750244,
0.5114254951477051,
-0.5153970718383789,
0.2699487805366516,
-0.4566199481487274,
-0.129866361618042,
-0.47828400135040283,
-0.23554439842700958,
0.46932560205459595,
0.909656286239624,
0.27099284529685974,
0.18948005139827728,
0.26133251190185547,
0.7045672535896301,
-0.7155892848968506,
0.4720858931541443,
-0.5979475378990173,
-0.20655930042266846,
-0.2559889554977417,
-0.31015145778656006,
-0.28167667984962463,
-0.21238362789154053,
-0.03846951201558113,
-0.31646689772605896,
-0.31603971123695374,
-0.044958632439374924,
1.0475337505340576,
0.0992899239063263,
-0.798871636390686,
-0.3203417658805847,
-0.7512925863265991,
0.5447860360145569,
-0.8647076487541199,
0.5686352252960205,
0.45453500747680664,
0.31607213616371155,
-0.37188956141471863,
-0.4755423665046692,
-0.3107397258281708,
-0.08873729407787323,
-0.3630267381668091,
0.15843205153942108,
0.08629881590604782,
-0.06959240883588791,
0.38474828004837036,
0.21856236457824707,
-0.19205820560455322,
-0.10127520561218262,
-0.07792103290557861,
-0.14722062647342682,
0.5308337807655334,
-0.013330535031855106,
0.2622091770172119,
-0.12921564280986786,
-0.5835389494895935,
0.22956162691116333,
-0.9397264719009399,
-0.12130297720432281,
0.25353047251701355,
0.19818687438964844,
0.1431053727865219,
0.5801774859428406,
0.08524174988269806,
0.4894077777862549,
-0.12631134688854218,
-0.0333082377910614,
0.3812907040119171,
-0.024736570194363594,
-0.19983017444610596,
0.07774408161640167,
0.7317670583724976,
0.41943779587745667,
0.23855049908161163,
-0.20202340185642242,
-0.16782116889953613,
0.21777842938899994,
-0.3767535090446472,
-0.9181485772132874,
0.11860863119363785,
-0.10282956063747406,
-0.43195223808288574,
0.06542431563138962,
-0.13591304421424866,
-0.708457887172699,
-0.4331064820289612,
-0.3919921815395355,
0.6626687049865723,
-0.7159048318862915,
-0.5248408913612366,
-0.023176593706011772,
-0.09763237833976746,
0.4152974486351013,
0.26904043555259705,
-0.6366236209869385,
0.6091930270195007,
0.8233106732368469,
0.6424756646156311,
-0.09513985365629196,
-0.32808730006217957,
-0.5379807353019714,
0.5646380186080933,
-0.19678933918476105,
0.4720136225223541,
-0.5957401990890503,
-0.06424795836210251,
0.061400532722473145,
0.2390459179878235,
0.1277880221605301,
-0.5540328621864319,
0.3305008113384247,
-0.6604255437850952,
0.02904212661087513,
-0.04111860692501068,
-1.1681139469146729,
-0.40784770250320435,
0.2297915518283844,
-0.7793521881103516,
0.9392147660255432,
0.11171108484268188,
-1.0123366117477417,
0.01723744533956051,
-0.30781835317611694,
-0.523104190826416,
-0.21260219812393188,
-0.287969708442688,
-0.504612147808075,
-0.04791031777858734,
0.497627854347229,
0.7500733733177185,
-0.024215834215283394,
0.33841612935066223,
-0.6355884671211243,
-0.21500125527381897,
0.1269482672214508,
0.04383813962340355,
0.7790234088897705,
0.08912240713834763,
-0.215301051735878,
-0.06306441873311996,
-0.8004676103591919,
-0.17697852849960327,
0.21713030338287354,
0.05960835888981819,
-0.9945698380470276,
-0.061927784234285355,
-0.4561728835105896,
0.25984975695610046,
0.44074857234954834,
-0.32335636019706726,
0.05245598778128624,
-0.6600673794746399,
0.2921752631664276,
0.581738293170929,
0.3714226186275482,
0.6465595960617065,
0.001110536279156804,
0.1986589878797531,
0.415032297372818,
-0.45618852972984314,
-0.4122813642024994,
-0.0724681094288826,
-0.981846034526825,
0.18517526984214783,
0.4236490726470947,
0.26498904824256897,
-0.406648725271225,
0.6235264539718628,
-0.5733940005302429,
-0.14701053500175476,
-0.19096992909908295,
0.4674358367919922,
-0.04667115956544876,
0.376385897397995,
0.39887893199920654,
-0.15755347907543182,
-0.7410204410552979,
-0.9285818934440613,
-0.3805962800979614,
0.23831696808338165,
0.1446913182735443,
0.431927889585495,
0.3975163698196411,
-0.5022630095481873,
0.8572461605072021,
-0.4582419693470001,
-0.25142788887023926,
-0.1247301697731018,
0.09924627840518951,
0.26107996702194214,
0.3549431264400482,
0.5063791275024414,
-0.2496492862701416,
-0.4042792022228241,
-0.05112053081393242,
-0.6966016292572021,
0.06689655780792236,
0.01942061260342598,
-0.4943707287311554,
0.055498771369457245,
0.6352770924568176,
-0.3768061697483063,
0.33687296509742737,
0.45487454533576965,
-0.3723544478416443,
0.15316733717918396,
-0.12095686048269272,
-0.044856466352939606,
-1.3006545305252075,
0.028255993500351906,
0.11898479610681534,
-0.6793206334114075,
-0.49344325065612793,
-0.041556309908628464,
0.3834547698497772,
-0.1207202598452568,
-0.1415693759918213,
0.6304476261138916,
-0.7319552302360535,
-0.0051941475830972195,
-0.18771666288375854,
0.2854638397693634,
-0.06732593476772308,
0.7894953489303589,
0.4022878110408783,
0.4803192913532257,
0.39859485626220703,
-0.8483737111091614,
0.19117118418216705,
0.09280380606651306,
-0.07571376115083694,
0.5460004210472107,
-0.3116450011730194,
0.3649193346500397,
-0.299186646938324,
-0.030675729736685753,
-0.5890532732009888,
0.055620841681957245,
0.19758440554141998,
-0.3253614008426666,
0.5532116293907166,
-0.2892221510410309,
-0.39478015899658203,
-0.07576989382505417,
-0.3727346658706665,
0.29872146248817444,
0.5267609357833862,
-0.7837712168693542,
0.7379166483879089,
0.5332642793655396,
-0.18821856379508972,
-0.6286742687225342,
-0.5246590375900269,
-0.011883526109158993,
-0.4814298152923584,
-0.7822290062904358,
0.3393557369709015,
0.29435333609580994,
-0.12709780037403107,
0.17274755239486694,
-0.2757710814476013,
-0.20560763776302338,
-0.11730644106864929,
0.2992714047431946,
0.08440199494361877,
-0.3281404972076416,
0.4380455017089844,
0.0492609478533268,
-0.179769366979599,
0.13953563570976257,
0.06340334564447403,
0.47655418515205383,
0.00918507482856512,
-0.15932968258857727,
-0.0653858333826065,
0.3614931106567383,
0.40861719846725464,
-0.18154457211494446,
0.7717375159263611,
0.6873878240585327,
-0.6597301959991455,
-0.11870603263378143,
-0.670077919960022,
-0.2145487666130066,
-0.41840583086013794,
0.5547325015068054,
-0.5563122034072876,
-0.8533643484115601,
0.5708819627761841,
-0.7980791926383972,
-0.10614026337862015,
0.48831382393836975,
0.09106652438640594,
-0.05801498889923096,
1.012145757675171,
0.6445848345756531,
-0.36687907576560974,
0.26573067903518677,
-0.16826669871807098,
0.19169773161411285,
-1.0891228914260864,
-0.18650828301906586,
-0.3514898419380188,
-0.19622942805290222,
-0.3865896463394165,
-0.322671115398407,
-0.08434247225522995,
0.5411257743835449,
-0.44383421540260315,
0.6539635062217712,
-0.15967875719070435,
0.2510884702205658,
0.20698393881320953,
0.26283398270606995,
0.3187039792537689,
0.16071777045726776,
-0.1496100127696991,
-0.42340996861457825,
-0.586933434009552,
-0.4718358814716339,
0.6990366578102112,
0.5143407583236694,
0.9890576004981995,
0.061101026833057404,
0.9930659532546997,
-0.044498149305582047,
0.08439793437719345,
-0.9402844905853271,
0.604685366153717,
0.10729518532752991,
-0.15021157264709473,
-0.2771016061306,
-0.6639531850814819,
-1.2680684328079224,
0.0442289337515831,
-0.13300584256649017,
-0.8608246445655823,
0.06009087339043617,
0.02709358185529709,
0.10415605455636978,
0.14005011320114136,
-0.4126107096672058,
0.626361072063446,
-0.3462282419204712,
-0.5479925274848938,
-0.24813930690288544,
-0.589995801448822,
0.23307396471500397,
0.1810375452041626,
0.3289865553379059,
-0.3676796555519104,
-0.07142341881990433,
1.0629103183746338,
-0.7584941983222961,
0.6803568601608276,
-0.07067179679870605,
-0.1888991892337799,
0.28505939245224,
0.25742077827453613,
0.9770179390907288,
-0.05890367552638054,
0.01676199771463871,
0.08210156857967377,
0.04778800532221794,
-0.1655745804309845,
-0.8206549286842346,
0.7559106349945068,
-0.6920912861824036,
-0.49932754039764404,
-0.31993624567985535,
-0.36067840456962585,
-0.45363107323646545,
0.32356247305870056,
-0.0860147625207901,
0.309683620929718,
-0.2739359736442566,
0.122624471783638,
0.41490405797958374,
-0.09534205496311188,
0.30317333340644836,
0.29116737842559814,
-0.5269097089767456,
-0.6089062690734863,
0.8470039963722229,
0.1410669982433319,
-0.04990853741765022,
0.2948252260684967,
0.16919827461242676,
-0.5137181282043457,
-0.038910724222660065,
-0.10224432498216629,
0.4336698055267334,
-0.6972567439079285,
-0.42938902974128723,
-0.7450515627861023,
-0.4934362471103668,
-0.4808470904827118,
0.21896086633205414,
-0.32283779978752136,
-0.4886554479598999,
-0.14958921074867249,
0.12788371741771698,
0.5195620656013489,
0.5218439102172852,
-0.0037158476188778877,
0.07428720593452454,
-0.9261254072189331,
0.254001647233963,
0.3638669550418854,
0.2719813287258148,
0.10425230115652084,
-0.395113080739975,
-0.2508555054664612,
-0.01029189396649599,
-0.054323405027389526,
-1.266083002090454,
0.42275673151016235,
0.27080461382865906,
0.4854733943939209,
0.6566128730773926,
-0.02179718017578125,
1.0282894372940063,
-0.477437287569046,
0.3916145861148834,
0.34152454137802124,
-0.9417882561683655,
0.6874938607215881,
-0.11827623844146729,
0.20332983136177063,
0.3603331744670868,
0.3675922453403473,
-0.5391541719436646,
-0.2537568509578705,
-0.7870072722434998,
-0.8833397626876831,
0.46761253476142883,
0.4258898198604584,
0.2263588160276413,
0.04072722792625427,
0.2264791578054428,
0.09462854266166687,
0.24888969957828522,
-0.8448448181152344,
-0.2912449836730957,
0.07841893285512924,
-0.358454167842865,
0.04502900689840317,
-0.6093828082084656,
-0.016927827149629593,
-0.3557262420654297,
0.9185482859611511,
0.13727280497550964,
0.2400188446044922,
0.030296850949525833,
-0.46769219636917114,
0.043582625687122345,
0.5200033187866211,
0.20203028619289398,
0.6558412313461304,
-0.2571488916873932,
0.7095416188240051,
0.41308099031448364,
-0.09540792554616928,
0.05165813863277435,
0.24476149678230286,
-0.06211722269654274,
0.2718205451965332,
0.25647804141044617,
0.6683745980262756,
0.2835848331451416,
-0.33386531472206116,
0.6766231656074524,
0.29925626516342163,
0.11202901601791382,
-0.3209579288959503,
-0.10894688963890076,
0.7397217154502869,
0.20208097994327545,
0.014959629625082016,
0.034502699971199036,
0.019244905561208725,
-0.562747061252594,
0.2071850448846817,
0.502610445022583,
-0.4219036400318146,
-0.14804911613464355,
0.3382980227470398,
0.2050696760416031,
-0.2158568799495697,
0.25777363777160645,
-0.24634340405464172,
-0.6692622303962708,
0.49842581152915955,
0.8336648941040039,
0.4418773651123047,
-0.17847298085689545,
-0.18578411638736725,
0.7135334014892578,
0.0804869756102562,
-0.12008552998304367,
0.07331369817256927,
-0.2023940235376358,
-0.8704291582107544,
-0.34634095430374146,
-0.5931133031845093,
-0.03709948807954788,
0.6227545738220215,
-0.6571515202522278,
0.6661078929901123,
-0.16430748999118805,
-0.09316515922546387,
-0.30262044072151184,
0.02496343106031418,
-0.8126073479652405,
-0.09039700031280518,
0.034280624240636826,
0.6684662699699402,
-0.5851478576660156,
0.8254826664924622,
0.7256767749786377,
-0.21578752994537354,
-0.9847169518470764,
-0.2445838749408722,
-0.38850730657577515,
-0.8762353658676147,
0.46844127774238586,
0.39175763726234436,
-0.10573720186948776,
-0.05492835119366646,
-0.3910062313079834,
-0.7194156646728516,
0.9922013282775879,
0.5770408511161804,
-0.8370405435562134,
0.2269183099269867,
0.23166896402835846,
0.29193925857543945,
-0.4938737154006958,
0.14427243173122406,
0.4286331832408905,
0.35480642318725586,
0.15509776771068573,
-0.4275388717651367,
0.4327646791934967,
-0.20562608540058136,
0.04715513437986374,
0.5687995553016663,
-0.4928302764892578,
0.195090189576149,
-0.05288143828511238,
-0.5185419917106628,
-0.09161276370286942,
1.0119953155517578,
0.11509032547473907,
0.4862402677536011,
0.4674462378025055,
0.5551249384880066,
0.7685409784317017,
0.20115600526332855,
0.24574707448482513,
-0.5824087262153625,
0.5369745492935181,
1.7025206089019775,
-0.2796405553817749,
0.8645158410072327,
0.7363774180412292,
-0.16965797543525696,
0.4163151681423187,
0.5089731812477112,
0.0014542322605848312,
0.3636312782764435,
0.09848231077194214,
-0.18752963840961456,
-0.5320059657096863,
0.007246507331728935,
-0.667051374912262,
0.16829106211662292,
0.48447760939598083,
-0.7984114289283752,
-0.5058297514915466,
-0.30157896876335144,
0.2373018115758896,
0.2537892460823059,
-0.45040637254714966,
0.9177899360656738,
0.591728925704956,
-0.41480752825737,
0.4467218220233917,
-0.18276646733283997,
0.7205280065536499,
-0.5604749917984009,
-0.17212067544460297,
0.020825747400522232,
0.06943812221288681,
-0.250087708234787,
-0.6408892869949341,
0.1892032027244568,
-0.3457217216491699,
0.11669439822435379,
0.2797657549381256,
1.4036668539047241,
-0.8767486214637756,
-0.4979747235774994,
0.5822569131851196,
0.8595930337905884,
0.1107337549328804,
-0.012830270454287529,
-0.3551587164402008,
-0.2070409506559372,
-0.20442798733711243,
-0.0886794850230217,
0.1324448585510254,
0.7272554636001587,
0.19861739873886108,
0.42070940136909485,
0.2825009226799011,
0.26208487153053284,
-0.22328506410121918,
0.1872202605009079,
0.7050887942314148,
-0.8782219886779785,
-0.4494553208351135,
-1.1237889528274536,
0.14555956423282623,
-0.5830920934677124,
0.2137126922607422,
0.7887389659881592,
0.5543587803840637,
0.4405966103076935,
0.004348293878138065,
0.5868311524391174,
0.2999998927116394,
0.4817970097064972,
-0.538362443447113,
0.5677061080932617,
-0.40667471289634705,
0.24977636337280273,
-0.28553831577301025,
-1.1836731433868408,
-0.23869477212429047,
0.6891472935676575,
-0.37016764283180237,
-0.03071822226047516,
0.7408397197723389,
0.7701206207275391,
-0.44079136848449707,
-0.12293175607919693,
0.42051926255226135,
0.3373229205608368,
-0.1944020837545395,
0.7444931864738464,
1.0051051378250122,
-0.38311347365379333,
0.6203866004943848,
-0.3221168518066406,
0.07689498364925385,
-0.19012987613677979,
-0.908356249332428,
-1.2159576416015625,
-0.4987425208091736,
-0.4208085238933563,
-0.5593892931938171,
0.07199803739786148,
1.1567128896713257,
0.542129635810852,
-0.586719274520874,
-0.09234089404344559,
-0.13268832862377167,
0.10017514228820801,
-0.2983306348323822,
-0.1961221545934677,
0.6537571549415588,
-0.29733550548553467,
-0.4526924788951874,
0.10827607661485672,
0.41215431690216064,
0.22591593861579895,
-0.09859394282102585,
-0.38474616408348083,
-0.026187514886260033,
0.07291091978549957,
0.7314170598983765,
0.08707661181688309,
-0.33424827456474304,
-0.3195513188838959,
-0.30578476190567017,
-0.12759461998939514,
0.28491926193237305,
0.7245827317237854,
-0.7126442193984985,
0.2900919020175934,
0.5921773314476013,
0.6348750591278076,
0.800994873046875,
-0.1397637575864792,
0.6600328683853149,
-0.6361605525016785,
0.1900397390127182,
0.23779143393039703,
0.811996579170227,
0.29593920707702637,
-0.4873051643371582,
0.6345005035400391,
-0.05071452632546425,
-0.42854607105255127,
-0.4686766564846039,
0.3429120182991028,
-1.0119032859802246,
-0.12512081861495972,
1.4338351488113403,
-0.33138158917427063,
-0.4473350942134857,
-0.034473028033971786,
-0.26940229535102844,
0.5570987462997437,
-0.3823879659175873,
0.5648226737976074,
0.5491674542427063,
-0.07910401374101639,
-0.16234427690505981,
-0.22321048378944397,
0.41910597681999207,
0.4576962888240814,
-0.6527599096298218,
-0.008602684363722801,
0.27641427516937256,
0.4240787625312805,
0.030741918832063675,
0.4833386242389679,
-0.2553068995475769,
-0.11256984621286392,
-0.20389452576637268,
-0.20098057389259338,
-0.12003179639577866,
0.12508796155452728,
-0.12981460988521576,
0.11374839395284653,
0.17462478578090668,
-0.030810922384262085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09044v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09044v1
|
MiLoRA: Harnessing Minor Singular Components for Parameter-Efficient LLM Finetuning
| 2024-06-13T12:30:02 | 2024-06-13T12:30:02 |
Hanqing Wang, Zeguan Xiao, Yixia Li, Shuo Wang, Guanhua Chen, Yun Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Efficient finetuning of large language models (LLMs) aims to adapt the LLMs
with reduced computation and memory cost. Previous LoRA-based approaches
initialize the low-rank matrices with gaussian distribution and zero values,
while keeping the original weight matrices frozen. However, the trainable model
parameters optimized in an unguided subspace might have interference with the
well-learned subspace of the pretrained weight matrix. In this paper, we
propose MiLoRA, a simple yet effective LLM finetuning approach that only
updates the minor singular components of the weight matrix while keeping the
principle singular components frozen. It is observed that the minor matrix
corresponds to the noisy or long-tail information, while the principle matrix
contains important knowledge. The MiLoRA initializes the low-rank matrices
within a subspace that is orthogonal to the principle matrix, thus the
pretrained knowledge is expected to be well preserved. During finetuning,
MiLoRA makes the most use of the less-optimized subspace for learning the
finetuning dataset. Extensive experiments on commonsense reasoning, math
reasoning and instruction following benchmarks present the superior performance
of our method.
|
[
-0.36387932300567627,
-0.8328918218612671,
0.5158886313438416,
-0.008496012538671494,
-0.7042848467826843,
0.049693986773490906,
-0.5556337833404541,
0.2011883407831192,
0.06550050526857376,
0.3522012531757355,
-0.3885105848312378,
-0.6256633996963501,
-0.320722758769989,
-0.32849347591400146,
0.09899766743183136,
0.9521044492721558,
0.44031476974487305,
0.23364056646823883,
0.17402306199073792,
-0.11373942345380783,
-0.5455824136734009,
-0.2411852777004242,
-0.7443567514419556,
-0.5591802597045898,
0.7643910646438599,
0.8899710774421692,
0.46019718050956726,
0.7175738215446472,
0.2552624046802521,
0.18388104438781738,
-0.3846326768398285,
0.4157325327396393,
-0.8038831353187561,
0.012845787219703197,
-0.21442832052707672,
-0.847350001335144,
-0.5066095590591431,
-0.15489237010478973,
0.6880290508270264,
1.034135341644287,
-0.08535011857748032,
0.34925153851509094,
0.3748610317707062,
0.5411871075630188,
-0.5035301446914673,
0.16711871325969696,
-0.8358275890350342,
0.08560789376497269,
-0.5495599508285522,
-0.27148908376693726,
-0.31221702694892883,
-0.5238561034202576,
-0.36780956387519836,
-0.5818117260932922,
0.15694773197174072,
0.00875911395996809,
0.6952129602432251,
0.5669987201690674,
-0.07218044251203537,
0.07375376671552658,
-0.8759358525276184,
0.9229382872581482,
-0.75066739320755,
0.37925389409065247,
0.4317281246185303,
0.4030332565307617,
-0.25195398926734924,
-0.2735010087490082,
-0.4041595160961151,
-0.06019285321235657,
0.2767854928970337,
-0.006030658725649118,
-0.25430697202682495,
0.1321791410446167,
0.10740278661251068,
0.3532509505748749,
-0.13255444169044495,
0.4936443269252777,
-0.6352351307868958,
0.023768259212374687,
0.27352142333984375,
0.17015340924263,
-0.08284994214773178,
-0.17902056872844696,
-0.3080994784832001,
0.09055481106042862,
-1.0063730478286743,
0.11074400693178177,
0.5766497254371643,
0.8090944290161133,
-0.05094572529196739,
0.6005796790122986,
-0.10557691007852554,
0.5245232582092285,
0.45503440499305725,
-0.5477731823921204,
0.1377880871295929,
-0.04770301654934883,
-0.4159381687641144,
-0.10591176152229309,
0.5673643946647644,
-0.06442303210496902,
-0.011452676728367805,
-0.28043583035469055,
-0.10485988110303879,
0.23096047341823578,
0.15782791376113892,
-0.5656954050064087,
-0.3700453042984009,
-0.06882214546203613,
-0.17561160027980804,
-0.39703211188316345,
-0.38990890979766846,
-0.8970504999160767,
-0.3379219174385071,
-0.671169102191925,
0.7099837064743042,
-0.36904168128967285,
0.17982229590415955,
0.043236080557107925,
0.5966867208480835,
0.2481595128774643,
0.5189899206161499,
-1.1141146421432495,
0.7544475197792053,
0.9265666007995605,
0.6442111134529114,
-0.16721993684768677,
0.01524623017758131,
-1.0758377313613892,
-0.19573912024497986,
-0.3823826014995575,
0.7870800495147705,
-0.2837255895137787,
0.09304419159889221,
-0.2767677307128906,
-0.010128124617040157,
-0.0811859518289566,
-0.641912579536438,
0.4814808666706085,
-0.31254589557647705,
-0.17278170585632324,
-0.2361602783203125,
-0.3838077485561371,
-0.2839736342430115,
0.07510721683502197,
-0.476253479719162,
1.015426754951477,
-0.26744142174720764,
-0.3891144096851349,
0.2917533814907074,
-0.18829569220542908,
-0.27431952953338623,
-0.26549622416496277,
-0.3524755835533142,
-0.5763840079307556,
0.25832051038742065,
0.31280717253685,
0.8218675255775452,
-0.3476603925228119,
0.09956836700439453,
-0.1965709775686264,
-0.47398024797439575,
0.0007124639814719558,
-0.5668582320213318,
0.46472129225730896,
0.17679555714130402,
-0.24653469026088715,
0.07094480842351913,
-0.8946613669395447,
-0.41941750049591064,
-0.05753577873110771,
-0.7293899059295654,
-0.4389139711856842,
-0.013598504476249218,
-0.30521485209465027,
-0.24728251993656158,
0.10223650187253952,
-0.5819566249847412,
0.4480920433998108,
-0.4986051917076111,
0.21265850961208344,
1.0086891651153564,
-0.00965849868953228,
0.7851669788360596,
-0.3930814862251282,
0.34690505266189575,
-0.027228431776165962,
0.04206349328160286,
0.27883943915367126,
-0.45029088854789734,
-1.1976251602172852,
-0.4287834167480469,
0.43195345997810364,
0.34296298027038574,
-0.5157626271247864,
0.010246709920465946,
-0.19453512132167816,
-0.588505208492279,
-0.5118119120597839,
0.7073596119880676,
0.4026968777179718,
0.41986677050590515,
0.37732937932014465,
0.13856779038906097,
-0.36365005373954773,
-0.7148913145065308,
0.34225088357925415,
0.2655242085456848,
0.30411869287490845,
0.11776062846183777,
0.16204071044921875,
0.09394852817058563,
0.7002530694007874,
-0.6024730205535889,
-0.45409709215164185,
-0.4143642485141754,
-0.009891871362924576,
0.5409377217292786,
0.8272458910942078,
0.49502062797546387,
-0.15056534111499786,
-0.3418138921260834,
0.18899105489253998,
-0.3635112941265106,
-0.15930525958538055,
-0.06278827041387558,
-0.46566447615623474,
-0.017137814313173294,
0.6672409176826477,
-0.40622571110725403,
-0.04913191497325897,
0.37867748737335205,
-0.1761472523212433,
0.18443769216537476,
-0.19891920685768127,
-0.3167424499988556,
-1.0936882495880127,
0.001604127581231296,
-0.13213497400283813,
-0.6277930736541748,
-0.6675036549568176,
0.020945154130458832,
-0.055659789592027664,
-0.04026402160525322,
-0.6423883438110352,
0.27947407960891724,
-0.44216451048851013,
-0.002065805019810796,
-0.19803085923194885,
0.3404354751110077,
-0.13331185281276703,
0.9408794045448303,
-0.6309617161750793,
0.7480692863464355,
0.4348159432411194,
-0.7361736297607422,
0.16296634078025818,
0.03793463483452797,
-0.252545565366745,
0.6531074643135071,
-0.38417699933052063,
0.23640921711921692,
-0.35805752873420715,
-0.41546130180358887,
-0.9223918318748474,
0.07397320121526718,
0.3773637115955353,
-0.08351942151784897,
0.3386934697628021,
-0.5671544075012207,
-0.35364753007888794,
0.10056809335947037,
-0.35634252429008484,
0.40644538402557373,
0.712623119354248,
-0.7553399801254272,
0.5630570650100708,
0.3864785134792328,
-0.308879554271698,
-0.5589720606803894,
-0.5417150855064392,
-0.4138365387916565,
-0.48440513014793396,
-0.18288815021514893,
0.0006065834895707667,
-0.1978561133146286,
-0.15466910600662231,
-0.1740749031305313,
-0.07429908215999603,
0.020842749625444412,
0.15278126299381256,
0.21006909012794495,
0.14679157733917236,
-0.47737547755241394,
0.25441426038742065,
0.46869686245918274,
-0.32122209668159485,
-0.4059990644454956,
-0.23079685866832733,
0.8339040279388428,
-0.2149541825056076,
-0.3191946744918823,
-0.5370276570320129,
0.030388368293642998,
0.4931175410747528,
0.1305166333913803,
0.39783647656440735,
0.5616785883903503,
-0.4575161039829254,
-0.5372117161750793,
-0.6059134006500244,
-0.09222990274429321,
-0.44257640838623047,
0.2052476704120636,
-0.3066558837890625,
-0.8571131825447083,
0.7349358201026917,
-0.28743138909339905,
0.1424316167831421,
0.3470052182674408,
0.3991972804069519,
-0.05701778456568718,
0.6131622195243835,
0.7319831252098083,
-0.06407561898231506,
0.37327516078948975,
-0.5058524012565613,
-0.04882422834634781,
-1.108018398284912,
-0.24896526336669922,
-0.46414241194725037,
-0.4844684898853302,
-0.16244769096374512,
-0.9036658406257629,
0.28086724877357483,
0.43566465377807617,
-0.2640616297721863,
0.1860072910785675,
-0.18954840302467346,
0.7008176445960999,
0.5975062251091003,
0.3338678181171417,
0.5146113634109497,
0.12350168824195862,
-0.38457196950912476,
-0.18973787128925323,
-0.7359859943389893,
-0.38180795311927795,
1.136993408203125,
0.35678812861442566,
1.1931747198104858,
0.3143253028392792,
0.7430633902549744,
0.08127866685390472,
0.11532770097255707,
-0.9200197458267212,
0.6393424272537231,
-0.500371515750885,
-0.19147449731826782,
-0.2719425559043884,
-0.26295384764671326,
-0.973172128200531,
0.4638010263442993,
-0.3922896087169647,
-0.7545154094696045,
0.4321541488170624,
0.3446708023548126,
-0.958931028842926,
0.4668295085430145,
-0.5138530135154724,
0.4896391034126282,
0.10832775384187698,
-0.4716331362724304,
-0.16082319617271423,
-0.21541930735111237,
0.35208675265312195,
-0.23781728744506836,
0.1733405441045761,
-0.3634694218635559,
0.02775489166378975,
0.8686734437942505,
-0.5889265537261963,
1.1424806118011475,
-0.15463848412036896,
-0.10565682500600815,
0.029102355241775513,
0.15473905205726624,
0.5006536841392517,
0.22695273160934448,
-0.014855459332466125,
-0.22090183198451996,
-0.2699010372161865,
-0.34764036536216736,
-0.5050505995750427,
0.7914909720420837,
-0.8465837836265564,
-0.508878231048584,
-0.12633676826953888,
-0.3085388243198395,
-0.29694101214408875,
0.17227277159690857,
0.11622307449579239,
0.7212037444114685,
-0.029470141977071762,
0.2606738209724426,
0.9468345046043396,
-0.0614786222577095,
0.37353846430778503,
0.28024783730506897,
-0.3051004409790039,
-0.5428627729415894,
1.1428987979888916,
0.2787022888660431,
0.291899174451828,
0.2093311846256256,
0.39910271763801575,
0.20203083753585815,
-0.6993609070777893,
-0.49141353368759155,
0.41479209065437317,
-0.7475153803825378,
-0.6187163591384888,
-0.31955403089523315,
0.055454693734645844,
0.18762795627117157,
-0.2980661690235138,
-0.9147039651870728,
-0.4534185528755188,
-0.4472443461418152,
-0.055141136050224304,
0.39563682675361633,
0.5820878148078918,
-0.2869214713573456,
0.6272702813148499,
-0.2778278887271881,
0.37782320380210876,
0.728811502456665,
0.26750627160072327,
0.03374958410859108,
-0.5173673629760742,
-0.18611453473567963,
-0.055652786046266556,
-0.0897875726222992,
-0.5074315071105957,
0.21503087878227234,
0.3621493875980377,
0.6090660095214844,
0.5787522792816162,
-0.011692529544234276,
0.8651415109634399,
-0.5538564324378967,
0.49933019280433655,
0.030752090737223625,
-0.9173743724822998,
0.4215157628059387,
-0.4807032346725464,
0.1455588936805725,
0.7976785898208618,
-0.09330569207668304,
-0.03451629728078842,
-0.3726348876953125,
-0.272941529750824,
-0.6883519291877747,
0.6534410715103149,
0.16162517666816711,
0.3544686734676361,
0.31028449535369873,
0.27761051058769226,
0.5538259148597717,
0.09204775094985962,
-0.6716066598892212,
-0.3031676113605499,
0.22923628985881805,
-0.2731285095214844,
-0.15998557209968567,
-0.29552289843559265,
-0.15737155079841614,
-0.5689336061477661,
0.7197686433792114,
-0.24191802740097046,
0.30646777153015137,
-0.22299893200397491,
-0.27035456895828247,
-0.10138104110956192,
0.3707330822944641,
0.7524734139442444,
0.3196074664592743,
-0.26849910616874695,
0.5630447268486023,
0.5320061445236206,
-0.6016636490821838,
0.1832670420408249,
0.005650889594107866,
-0.35220831632614136,
-0.11537733674049377,
-0.11809864640235901,
0.8349121809005737,
0.7679054737091064,
-0.21527914702892303,
0.4329250156879425,
0.09506893157958984,
-0.21088477969169617,
-0.23942700028419495,
0.10444167256355286,
0.07651524245738983,
0.5287476778030396,
0.2228044718503952,
0.36852967739105225,
-0.1984415203332901,
-0.33567628264427185,
-0.02563994564116001,
0.22783225774765015,
-0.327646404504776,
-0.3943369388580322,
0.6054396033287048,
0.03757455572485924,
0.01944620907306671,
0.1111147329211235,
-0.2494213730096817,
-0.15922367572784424,
0.1967276781797409,
0.6748136878013611,
0.38644564151763916,
-0.1671798825263977,
0.17978449165821075,
0.13474754989147186,
0.3281167149543762,
-0.050878193229436874,
0.373823344707489,
-0.017077799886465073,
-0.6353546380996704,
-0.4967425763607025,
-0.8916172981262207,
-0.36846569180488586,
0.2458590418100357,
-0.4393904209136963,
0.3980450928211212,
-1.0240797996520996,
-0.08020522445440292,
0.017758890986442566,
0.0035812021233141422,
-0.5216640830039978,
-0.014406058937311172,
0.22688694298267365,
0.44290661811828613,
-0.8952571749687195,
0.8311994075775146,
0.4477861225605011,
-0.37256231904029846,
-1.0523512363433838,
-0.2477789968252182,
0.024975312873721123,
-0.8282685279846191,
0.5478149056434631,
-0.2733325958251953,
-0.26890742778778076,
0.2520939111709595,
-0.5055996775627136,
-1.040836215019226,
1.0264434814453125,
0.8424074053764343,
-0.4976746439933777,
0.22392357885837555,
0.045991454273462296,
0.21583540737628937,
-0.1688232719898224,
-0.4225234389305115,
0.537225067615509,
0.1044018417596817,
0.21128104627132416,
-0.7204271554946899,
0.002379519632086158,
-0.31042829155921936,
-0.1832946091890335,
0.1612350046634674,
-0.6687900424003601,
1.2471915483474731,
-0.04144616052508354,
-0.0944436714053154,
0.0817675068974495,
0.7905880808830261,
0.17073996365070343,
-0.021266749128699303,
0.5088258385658264,
0.696406900882721,
1.0974249839782715,
-0.041941121220588684,
0.47204849123954773,
0.010721558704972267,
0.48439329862594604,
1.1081022024154663,
0.16812428832054138,
1.0926523208618164,
0.4582982063293457,
0.00013786162890028208,
0.3133583664894104,
0.3777846395969391,
0.06325343996286392,
0.6829208731651306,
0.29256781935691833,
-0.2541124224662781,
-0.503653883934021,
0.11038746684789658,
-0.2663739025592804,
0.4432443678379059,
0.3615333139896393,
0.05173394829034805,
-0.4131738841533661,
0.4740876853466034,
0.5154992938041687,
0.07840538769960403,
-0.6492911577224731,
0.6459053754806519,
0.2658989429473877,
-0.28321680426597595,
0.8963403105735779,
-0.05167895555496216,
0.7886059284210205,
-0.16352921724319458,
0.0995967909693718,
-0.5188798904418945,
0.5237603783607483,
-0.13100524246692657,
-0.0993489921092987,
0.09776338189840317,
0.11779138445854187,
-0.05546804890036583,
0.13092546164989471,
0.5577946901321411,
-0.46232303977012634,
-0.7175730466842651,
-0.1458694189786911,
0.4651312232017517,
0.14823418855667114,
0.2854200303554535,
-0.19017459452152252,
0.11811409890651703,
-0.2798806130886078,
-0.03325839713215828,
0.1256948560476303,
0.15832869708538055,
0.1304997205734253,
0.5600255131721497,
0.7246779799461365,
0.2502366006374359,
0.3536417484283447,
0.18586254119873047,
1.1639127731323242,
-0.4015297591686249,
-0.5678883194923401,
-0.7463721632957458,
0.4633433222770691,
0.21450673043727875,
-0.2925601303577423,
0.5551273226737976,
0.4225310981273651,
0.48926255106925964,
-0.09151702374219894,
0.3708520233631134,
0.37294960021972656,
0.4841288924217224,
-1.0412224531173706,
0.7988761067390442,
-0.48469698429107666,
0.47531235218048096,
-0.42102405428886414,
-1.2037490606307983,
-0.515584409236908,
0.7679807543754578,
-0.3888177275657654,
-0.27436593174934387,
0.6473197937011719,
0.7505435943603516,
-0.6178800463676453,
-0.302676796913147,
0.5589410662651062,
0.3875335454940796,
0.05889425799250603,
0.5725489258766174,
0.5911838412284851,
-0.4146779477596283,
0.3203623592853546,
-0.4285193979740143,
-0.10826315730810165,
-0.3261857330799103,
-0.6094192266464233,
-1.13387930393219,
-0.3065686523914337,
-0.24395215511322021,
0.08562374114990234,
0.240972638130188,
1.1693718433380127,
0.7639567852020264,
-0.6980268359184265,
-0.14374393224716187,
-0.050552044063806534,
0.07808317244052887,
-0.08140269666910172,
-0.12183458358049393,
0.4639420211315155,
-0.4961201548576355,
-0.7834156155586243,
0.6055537462234497,
0.10804668813943863,
-0.05152672901749611,
-0.3759218454360962,
-0.07979994267225266,
-0.22037392854690552,
0.2600420415401459,
0.5250399708747864,
0.35195401310920715,
-0.6002800464630127,
-0.4112348258495331,
-0.20011338591575623,
-0.1556626409292221,
0.1791679859161377,
0.35311418771743774,
-0.7790213227272034,
0.19372916221618652,
0.31224095821380615,
0.6156497001647949,
0.5548264384269714,
-0.05775882303714752,
0.40172266960144043,
-0.7669017314910889,
0.442166805267334,
-0.03626347705721855,
0.401669442653656,
0.3314075171947479,
-0.2852621078491211,
0.37710294127464294,
0.2147030234336853,
-0.36743780970573425,
-0.7900983095169067,
-0.05089588090777397,
-1.547244668006897,
0.09241203963756561,
1.2609001398086548,
0.023071685805916786,
-0.4109063744544983,
-0.13711519539356232,
-0.46978893876075745,
0.2030549943447113,
-0.38645511865615845,
0.5377466678619385,
-0.08145242184400558,
0.20098337531089783,
-0.11847484856843948,
-0.6902241706848145,
0.5238856077194214,
0.541131854057312,
-0.6385073065757751,
-0.05485374107956886,
0.32712477445602417,
0.4411511719226837,
0.04487507417798042,
0.5663912296295166,
0.09283996373414993,
0.0871896743774414,
-0.15937219560146332,
-0.16146814823150635,
-0.2145753651857376,
-0.40753886103630066,
-0.4912465512752533,
0.33074966073036194,
0.36366498470306396,
-0.3934989869594574
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09043v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09043v2
|
Language Models are Crossword Solvers
| 2024-06-13T12:29:27 | 2024-06-14T21:29:40 |
Soumadeep Saha, Sutanoya Chakraborty, Saptarshi Saha, Utpal Garain
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Crosswords are a form of word puzzle that require a solver to demonstrate a
high degree of proficiency in natural language understanding, wordplay,
reasoning, and world knowledge, along with adherence to character and length
constraints. In this paper we tackle the challenge of solving crosswords with
Large Language Models (LLMs). We demonstrate that the current generation of
state-of-the art (SoTA) language models show significant competence at
deciphering cryptic crossword clues, and outperform previously reported SoTA
results by a factor of 2-3 in relevant benchmarks. We also develop a search
algorithm that builds off this performance to tackle the problem of solving
full crossword grids with LLMs for the very first time, achieving an accuracy
of 93\% on New York Times crossword puzzles. Contrary to previous work in this
area which concluded that LLMs lag human expert performance significantly, our
research suggests this gap is a lot narrower.
|
[
-0.17960160970687866,
-0.6260879635810852,
0.9431869983673096,
0.1562851071357727,
-0.26028212904930115,
0.319580614566803,
-0.2421591430902481,
-0.6485857963562012,
-0.025255711749196053,
0.6296522617340088,
-0.6358447670936584,
-0.4762728214263916,
-0.9528096914291382,
0.32644644379615784,
-0.5206231474876404,
0.5217875838279724,
-0.2392825335264206,
0.2227025181055069,
-0.1893552541732788,
0.06981082260608673,
-0.17681542038917542,
-0.39689022302627563,
-0.5854937434196472,
-0.5302222967147827,
0.6382230520248413,
0.22597864270210266,
0.8576546311378479,
0.9788736701011658,
0.43348464369773865,
0.23828914761543274,
-0.36204707622528076,
0.0493055135011673,
-0.5847466588020325,
0.021263964474201202,
-0.3674192726612091,
-0.7068181037902832,
-0.11304455995559692,
-0.03595602512359619,
0.36296772956848145,
0.6326006054878235,
-0.21499450504779816,
0.016610829159617424,
-0.29565003514289856,
0.4102446734905243,
-0.186680406332016,
0.1855149269104004,
-0.9390454292297363,
-0.021085532382130623,
-0.4645613133907318,
-0.3723629117012024,
-0.16249242424964905,
-0.03995566815137863,
0.26855555176734924,
-0.6952373385429382,
0.30373871326446533,
0.2165648490190506,
0.9003459811210632,
0.11872822791337967,
-0.17479251325130463,
-0.6234868168830872,
-0.6840541958808899,
0.7404025793075562,
-0.8414632678031921,
0.539324939250946,
0.17137211561203003,
0.34837231040000916,
-0.379782110452652,
-0.4730921685695648,
-0.5438317656517029,
-0.32504379749298096,
0.2937679588794708,
-0.37696099281311035,
-0.183251291513443,
-0.14355182647705078,
0.26930463314056396,
0.2420332133769989,
-0.6710373759269714,
0.37024134397506714,
-0.3403390049934387,
0.04450300335884094,
0.9079836010932922,
0.5796042680740356,
0.6289478540420532,
0.1546844244003296,
-0.1951693296432495,
0.2059764713048935,
-0.9494807720184326,
-0.03652532026171684,
0.17854896187782288,
0.3527255952358246,
0.08358070254325867,
0.5082000494003296,
-0.10958460718393326,
0.6781071424484253,
-0.41193148493766785,
-0.11826887726783752,
-0.17474311590194702,
-0.32806098461151123,
0.24225826561450958,
-0.10561210662126541,
0.6361197233200073,
0.19769816100597382,
0.6021453142166138,
-0.32613110542297363,
-0.45591485500335693,
0.06404149532318115,
0.035528019070625305,
-0.444060742855072,
0.03534441068768501,
-0.0689496323466301,
-0.32944580912590027,
0.004445086698979139,
-0.5894538164138794,
-0.5572607517242432,
-0.26124027371406555,
-0.2401663362979889,
0.5834239721298218,
-0.1579064130783081,
-0.07478401064872742,
0.5755414962768555,
-0.029436955228447914,
0.10649152100086212,
0.24810805916786194,
-0.7997424602508545,
0.40444791316986084,
0.7677269577980042,
0.6478877067565918,
-0.09403859078884125,
-0.29021522402763367,
-0.25592586398124695,
-0.07055830210447311,
-0.6257954239845276,
0.6714432239532471,
-0.8674927353858948,
-0.35710766911506653,
0.02233009971678257,
-0.10971587896347046,
0.25969624519348145,
-0.5588270425796509,
0.3338673412799835,
-0.8460891246795654,
0.031161418184638023,
-0.4431120753288269,
-0.6856939196586609,
-0.053821105509996414,
0.16929739713668823,
-0.7742491960525513,
0.8368909955024719,
-0.05962254852056503,
-0.632813036441803,
-0.024116437882184982,
-0.46554020047187805,
-0.16039597988128662,
0.2749849259853363,
-0.21831008791923523,
-0.06210261955857277,
0.3813019096851349,
0.2894725203514099,
0.3797833323478699,
-0.8119983077049255,
0.3198753297328949,
-0.06593551486730576,
-0.3893249034881592,
0.1056932806968689,
0.06311485171318054,
0.5026911497116089,
0.06509509682655334,
-0.1663220375776291,
-0.19717739522457123,
-0.5396678447723389,
-0.05564471706748009,
0.4968625009059906,
-0.3737020492553711,
-0.4289136826992035,
0.010313141159713268,
0.2086183875799179,
0.36710670590400696,
0.4537411034107208,
-0.9034048318862915,
0.05965886637568474,
-0.4309327006340027,
0.46423691511154175,
0.4427962601184845,
-0.5622777342796326,
-0.06980590522289276,
-0.3137420117855072,
0.8037447333335876,
-0.03673838451504707,
-0.2696302533149719,
-0.03706992045044899,
-0.6916257739067078,
-0.5118771195411682,
0.11432033777236938,
0.5483257174491882,
0.4252931475639343,
-0.9267465472221375,
0.11404003947973251,
-0.43011927604675293,
-0.6583237648010254,
-0.603268027305603,
0.30203139781951904,
0.6225728988647461,
0.032768264412879944,
0.2880516052246094,
-0.04888239875435829,
-0.6681833863258362,
-0.878963828086853,
-0.8267385363578796,
0.23646265268325806,
-0.12090910226106644,
0.32475563883781433,
0.5350520610809326,
-0.1617034673690796,
0.8640458583831787,
-0.31274867057800293,
-0.15365558862686157,
-0.536420464515686,
0.24234676361083984,
0.12751339375972748,
0.17337116599082947,
0.11131222546100616,
-0.7739781141281128,
-0.46271055936813354,
0.08177486062049866,
-0.6366375088691711,
-0.2214106321334839,
0.2824512720108032,
0.4927237331867218,
0.19738464057445526,
0.7723026871681213,
-0.5239540338516235,
0.43344780802726746,
0.8906556963920593,
-0.3392878472805023,
0.35915660858154297,
-0.2179071009159088,
-0.4581710696220398,
-0.9058781266212463,
0.06415068358182907,
0.1985509842634201,
-0.25347912311553955,
-0.6526634693145752,
0.37398090958595276,
-0.02944963425397873,
-0.1684950441122055,
-0.3333143889904022,
0.7528019547462463,
-0.7453163266181946,
-0.14383235573768616,
-0.2814159095287323,
0.5628341436386108,
-0.1812828630208969,
0.027898022904992104,
0.3212772607803345,
0.6414350867271423,
0.4772662818431854,
-0.3403293192386627,
0.45928436517715454,
0.06775885820388794,
-0.7152732610702515,
-0.10046257823705673,
-0.8096305727958679,
0.08954368531703949,
-0.23793303966522217,
0.1482299268245697,
-1.0345191955566406,
0.13461071252822876,
-0.45393016934394836,
-0.20048481225967407,
0.19779682159423828,
0.29381510615348816,
-0.6357784867286682,
-0.4698501229286194,
0.26844996213912964,
0.5973184704780579,
0.3004540503025055,
-0.43035972118377686,
0.500522255897522,
0.4724566638469696,
-0.36565980315208435,
-0.5381910800933838,
-0.6436511278152466,
0.4116990566253662,
0.32452285289764404,
-0.545228898525238,
0.4818436801433563,
0.1272922158241272,
-0.13690786063671112,
0.043715525418519974,
-0.11133235692977905,
0.17242471873760223,
0.06306731700897217,
-0.22806604206562042,
0.15027935802936554,
-0.26973387598991394,
0.1442289799451828,
-0.49989044666290283,
-0.3375896215438843,
0.1344933658838272,
0.06884297728538513,
0.8167613744735718,
-0.03244657441973686,
-0.2677052617073059,
-0.15665693581104279,
0.5756147503852844,
0.5893890857696533,
-0.38400062918663025,
0.4528845250606537,
0.21193352341651917,
-0.48168236017227173,
-0.28350400924682617,
-0.7846525311470032,
-0.13503237068653107,
-0.4643125832080841,
0.8257730007171631,
-0.6807950735092163,
-1.2484415769577026,
0.7549837231636047,
0.039858270436525345,
-0.007125675678253174,
0.17727461457252502,
0.6249980330467224,
0.31135278940200806,
1.184861421585083,
0.8422670960426331,
0.07691027969121933,
0.11026551574468613,
-0.05660012364387512,
0.6294584274291992,
-0.724275529384613,
-0.3971402645111084,
-0.6249719858169556,
-0.4648108184337616,
-0.5731163620948792,
-0.6665502786636353,
0.30549246072769165,
-0.12893590331077576,
0.19032207131385803,
0.3833951950073242,
-0.3770526945590973,
0.590059757232666,
0.4679177403450012,
-0.04547199234366417,
0.502765417098999,
-0.17506283521652222,
-0.3351607620716095,
-0.16952826082706451,
-0.8628548383712769,
-0.40894949436187744,
1.1706918478012085,
0.5562218427658081,
1.174034595489502,
-0.1765907108783722,
0.5975183248519897,
-0.2892155945301056,
0.1406724601984024,
-0.6764159202575684,
0.7625181078910828,
-0.3862556219100952,
-0.9575257897377014,
-0.4375164806842804,
-0.4892585277557373,
-1.045127511024475,
0.04181436449289322,
-0.05681568756699562,
-0.7335754632949829,
-0.11925573647022247,
-0.22836832702159882,
-0.4125228524208069,
0.4891972243785858,
-0.03596256673336029,
0.7319126129150391,
-0.41130682826042175,
-0.17855390906333923,
-0.29377660155296326,
-0.5361330509185791,
0.32897815108299255,
-0.02203778550028801,
0.2608967125415802,
-0.25841858983039856,
-0.4652368426322937,
0.8231176137924194,
-0.1145319938659668,
0.48120948672294617,
0.2182067334651947,
-0.4461663067340851,
-0.045602887868881226,
0.3439638018608093,
0.598442792892456,
-0.1845916509628296,
-0.027054576203227043,
0.24586977064609528,
0.1942949891090393,
-0.4422115087509155,
-0.6024267673492432,
0.6180009245872498,
-0.5904340147972107,
-0.8579817414283752,
-0.3511367738246918,
-1.0522258281707764,
-0.11561650037765503,
0.21839065849781036,
0.3204289972782135,
0.45298218727111816,
-0.2904888987541199,
0.12029413133859634,
0.8226179480552673,
-0.1579812616109848,
0.5035684704780579,
0.8103712201118469,
-0.5159462094306946,
0.024853868409991264,
0.7459365725517273,
0.4079831838607788,
0.16970844566822052,
0.48692119121551514,
0.24177642166614532,
-0.4922219514846802,
-0.7995482087135315,
-0.32508060336112976,
0.4306461811065674,
-0.5927320718765259,
0.029800942167639732,
-0.7787344455718994,
-0.4412851333618164,
-0.09325524419546127,
0.005892815534025431,
-0.4157543182373047,
-0.16379500925540924,
-0.11211247742176056,
0.28729525208473206,
0.23823562264442444,
1.1198337078094482,
0.09047430753707886,
0.2757623493671417,
-0.899854838848114,
0.3434253931045532,
0.5299760699272156,
0.373574435710907,
-0.08805129677057266,
-0.5131665468215942,
-0.3994045555591583,
-0.10356445610523224,
-0.0021552154794335365,
-0.7881121039390564,
0.4844111204147339,
-0.08904846012592316,
0.6295415759086609,
0.08965281397104263,
-0.2987966239452362,
0.42854994535446167,
-0.6723238229751587,
0.716492772102356,
0.01037775631994009,
-1.0398882627487183,
0.12999320030212402,
-0.45466598868370056,
0.45348021388053894,
0.22166284918785095,
0.695534884929657,
-0.8119206428527832,
-0.39754894375801086,
-0.572656512260437,
-0.4796960949897766,
0.5537579655647278,
-0.09769286960363388,
0.06721525639295578,
0.09783577173948288,
0.34470340609550476,
0.023251023143529892,
0.23760323226451874,
-0.6640390157699585,
-0.05978526175022125,
0.46134713292121887,
-0.3031814992427826,
-0.4516281485557556,
-0.4360082745552063,
-0.09867984056472778,
-0.025653820484876633,
0.5074798464775085,
0.009340398013591766,
0.0769704282283783,
0.088437020778656,
-0.016776304692029953,
-0.4569581151008606,
0.31944435834884644,
0.6647870540618896,
1.0645099878311157,
-0.026202477514743805,
0.12580722570419312,
0.22052980959415436,
-0.3161545395851135,
0.11374615877866745,
0.052118148654699326,
-0.018584050238132477,
0.279696524143219,
0.42576295137405396,
0.5924040079116821,
0.33546993136405945,
-1.0076470375061035,
0.5569772124290466,
-0.07901478558778763,
-0.19984523952007294,
-0.011501824483275414,
-0.150497168302536,
0.6271979212760925,
0.22726690769195557,
0.463273286819458,
-0.2934187650680542,
0.031813111156225204,
-0.799832284450531,
0.11633153259754181,
0.7440534234046936,
-0.25230464339256287,
-0.3211231529712677,
0.5357357859611511,
0.1487962007522583,
-0.7759901285171509,
0.27789944410324097,
-0.08209016919136047,
-0.9661753177642822,
0.5593768954277039,
0.8521597385406494,
0.744934618473053,
-0.36434242129325867,
-0.03259846568107605,
-0.131726935505867,
0.5233614444732666,
-0.47979071736335754,
0.7172890305519104,
0.42152518033981323,
-0.8580223917961121,
-0.6308847665786743,
-0.6444498300552368,
-0.3671082556247711,
0.36702075600624084,
-0.3358900547027588,
0.215003103017807,
-0.5092575550079346,
0.0761866644024849,
-0.030631953850388527,
0.3258286416530609,
-0.7337402105331421,
0.2490977644920349,
0.47684672474861145,
1.3620307445526123,
-0.8314515948295593,
0.7921981811523438,
0.7127042412757874,
0.005737433210015297,
-0.8520084619522095,
-0.27051690220832825,
-0.11784352362155914,
-0.9985949993133545,
0.8721582293510437,
0.10107697546482086,
-0.0871104970574379,
0.09977806359529495,
-0.5133621096611023,
-1.121566891670227,
0.6754975318908691,
0.30614954233169556,
-1.0943238735198975,
-0.6147612929344177,
0.37118586897850037,
0.655022382736206,
-0.7075783014297485,
0.2961248457431793,
0.7401300072669983,
0.26353955268859863,
-0.0656803622841835,
-1.1246434450149536,
0.18185272812843323,
-0.22953960299491882,
0.4900042712688446,
0.18642252683639526,
-0.5524561405181885,
1.142224907875061,
-0.13890941441059113,
-0.07291325181722641,
0.21610425412654877,
0.5185965299606323,
0.4576692283153534,
0.35676464438438416,
0.3798579275608063,
0.9351621270179749,
0.32317981123924255,
-0.09255220741033554,
0.9357714653015137,
-0.5073955655097961,
0.2871910035610199,
0.9494448304176331,
-0.3683638870716095,
0.9423869848251343,
0.46582886576652527,
-0.0985015481710434,
0.5049139857292175,
0.48917022347450256,
0.25896745920181274,
0.3621060848236084,
0.6190958619117737,
-0.09677605330944061,
-0.809903085231781,
-0.12736740708351135,
-0.3448059558868408,
0.6803629398345947,
0.5182077884674072,
-0.3551926016807556,
-0.5993834733963013,
-0.15484480559825897,
-0.013688595034182072,
0.4836956858634949,
-0.42135438323020935,
0.3882703483104706,
0.35953739285469055,
-0.48617440462112427,
0.6219989061355591,
0.1258222609758377,
0.7556538581848145,
-0.5101861357688904,
-0.05422738939523697,
-0.0289651770144701,
0.19383445382118225,
0.026552556082606316,
-0.7948537468910217,
0.13708461821079254,
-0.06568746268749237,
0.006776079069823027,
-0.10168300569057465,
0.48458531498908997,
-0.7596268653869629,
-0.7422100901603699,
0.5671432018280029,
0.6104695796966553,
0.09720585495233536,
0.009899381548166275,
-0.6828292608261108,
0.29829585552215576,
-0.2468588650226593,
-0.15014901757240295,
0.21570032835006714,
0.6813179850578308,
0.01905062235891819,
1.0993967056274414,
0.4440803527832031,
0.380891889333725,
0.2628794312477112,
-0.33783337473869324,
0.9470415711402893,
-0.9034633636474609,
-0.5886356234550476,
-0.7937164902687073,
0.12299187481403351,
0.11483493447303772,
-0.4395933151245117,
0.6331072449684143,
0.556118369102478,
0.9053417444229126,
0.012920391745865345,
0.7283709049224854,
0.23159679770469666,
0.9186124205589294,
-0.551504909992218,
0.7189651727676392,
-0.8508098721504211,
0.26063239574432373,
-0.004085731692612171,
-0.7438540458679199,
-0.3027713894844055,
0.4110575020313263,
-0.6129714846611023,
0.06494207680225372,
0.6402468085289001,
1.1552801132202148,
-0.017530720680952072,
0.17840754985809326,
0.5911744832992554,
0.251514196395874,
0.13505606353282928,
1.0649023056030273,
1.137636661529541,
-0.5724940299987793,
0.509976863861084,
0.04410210996866226,
-0.03609480708837509,
-0.43638670444488525,
-0.745326817035675,
-1.1779698133468628,
-0.4720877707004547,
0.007467920891940594,
-0.10859134793281555,
0.26942208409309387,
0.7775677442550659,
0.5006241798400879,
-0.6680527329444885,
-0.5463908910751343,
-0.12120556086301804,
0.08716998994350433,
0.03309589996933937,
-0.12142137438058853,
0.02023295871913433,
-0.3580549657344818,
-0.7039230465888977,
0.5413892865180969,
0.1939420849084854,
-0.19293081760406494,
-0.6778724789619446,
-0.06359953433275223,
-0.5060839653015137,
0.4282357394695282,
0.2452041208744049,
0.15186569094657898,
-1.1033891439437866,
-0.15911346673965454,
0.14626199007034302,
-0.3913774788379669,
-0.08841195702552795,
0.9075306057929993,
-0.7846252918243408,
0.4616161286830902,
0.6991397738456726,
0.8019258975982666,
0.6842613220214844,
-0.22220918536186218,
0.7202807664871216,
-0.4190559387207031,
-0.15218175947666168,
0.48501303791999817,
0.3072359263896942,
0.37187740206718445,
-0.2723958492279053,
0.37042731046676636,
0.17018364369869232,
-0.5337699055671692,
-0.9469850063323975,
0.26074638962745667,
-0.49497151374816895,
-0.27632027864456177,
0.8592461347579956,
-0.10078530013561249,
-0.5945441722869873,
-0.2080368548631668,
0.16823828220367432,
0.15001899003982544,
-0.09061533212661743,
0.8544334173202515,
0.7660836577415466,
0.18089228868484497,
-0.4699374735355377,
-0.5774526000022888,
0.643165647983551,
0.6593878269195557,
-0.4035451412200928,
0.12224061787128448,
-0.15235260128974915,
0.5353651642799377,
0.4718919098377228,
0.42969727516174316,
-0.1914542019367218,
0.29256492853164673,
-0.055534668266773224,
0.24846377968788147,
-0.1152542382478714,
-0.5523698329925537,
-0.39856547117233276,
0.03336898609995842,
0.02727440558373928,
0.07891997694969177
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09041v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09041v1
|
ME-Switch: A Memory-Efficient Expert Switching Framework for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T12:27:55 | 2024-06-13T12:27:55 |
Jing Liu, Ruihao Gong, Mingyang Zhang, Yefei He, Jianfei Cai, Bohan Zhuang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The typical process for developing LLMs involves pre-training a general
foundation model on massive data, followed by fine-tuning on task-specific data
to create specialized experts. Serving these experts poses challenges, as
loading all experts onto devices is impractical, and frequent switching between
experts in response to user requests incurs substantial I/O costs, increasing
latency and expenses. Previous approaches decompose expert weights into
pre-trained model weights and residual delta weights, then quantize the delta
weights to reduce model size. However, these methods often lead to significant
quantization errors at extremely low bitwidths and assume the appropriate model
for a user request is known in advance, which is not practical. To address
these issues, we introduce ME-Switch, a memory-efficient expert switching
framework for LLM serving. ME-Switch uses mixed-precision quantization,
selectively quantizing non-salient input channels of delta weights to extremely
low bits while keeping salient ones intact, significantly reducing storage
demands while maintaining performance. Additionally, we develop a routing
method that efficiently directs user queries to the most suitable expert by
transforming the model selection problem into a domain classification problem.
Extensive experiments show ME-Switch's promising memory efficiency and routing
performance. For example, when serving three models from the Mistral-7B family,
ME-Switch reduces model size by 1.74x while maintaining nearly lossless
performance on instruction, mathematical reasoning, and code generation tasks.
Furthermore, ME-Switch can efficiently serve 16 models from the Mistral-7B
family on a single NVIDIA A100 GPU.
|
[
-0.6770930290222168,
-0.6542192697525024,
0.4411512017250061,
0.1572217494249344,
-0.11300374567508698,
0.14383931457996368,
-0.04986270144581795,
-0.2107524573802948,
0.06445946544408798,
0.6762887239456177,
-0.30040085315704346,
-0.09937405586242676,
-0.34711766242980957,
-0.22159621119499207,
-0.4666740894317627,
0.5932444930076599,
-0.11252431571483612,
-0.007197108585387468,
-0.0803854689002037,
0.19818440079689026,
-0.19790418446063995,
-0.5181788802146912,
-1.126025915145874,
-0.19253508746623993,
0.5656076073646545,
0.44608592987060547,
0.7266061305999756,
0.40450936555862427,
0.282162606716156,
0.29806482791900635,
0.18100227415561676,
0.19700554013252258,
-0.4153082072734833,
0.04675493761897087,
-0.29268142580986023,
-0.5448319315910339,
-0.6878306865692139,
-0.011883228085935116,
0.3025563359260559,
0.5214474201202393,
-0.2951812148094177,
0.11136554181575775,
-0.28684696555137634,
0.6208345890045166,
-0.6721368432044983,
-0.09335499256849289,
-0.9654362797737122,
0.035577476024627686,
-0.5685650110244751,
-0.3095598816871643,
-0.5688826441764832,
-0.04520830884575844,
0.02370838262140751,
-0.36071881651878357,
0.2600598633289337,
0.052004214376211166,
0.4991591274738312,
0.4903140664100647,
-0.41647154092788696,
0.29615139961242676,
-0.6970095038414001,
0.8671768307685852,
-0.9544505476951599,
0.6326384544372559,
0.20996934175491333,
0.5549448728561401,
0.1040162444114685,
-0.4595178961753845,
-0.37397024035453796,
-0.12343882769346237,
0.4114912152290344,
0.1706223487854004,
-0.37070393562316895,
0.1572427749633789,
0.1591499149799347,
0.011192630045115948,
-0.3577420115470886,
0.11162117123603821,
-0.2347361445426941,
-0.12476470321416855,
0.5590364336967468,
0.10502360016107559,
0.12180913984775543,
0.2980179488658905,
-0.24532271921634674,
0.13368657231330872,
-0.8775110244750977,
-0.06901855766773224,
0.4542509615421295,
0.13707934319972992,
0.37583425641059875,
0.3012925088405609,
-0.4188344478607178,
0.9778359532356262,
0.24733255803585052,
-0.1132047101855278,
-0.3326856195926666,
0.01061972975730896,
-0.13490332663059235,
-0.12731726467609406,
0.5435518622398376,
0.4125972092151642,
0.43353351950645447,
-0.32833704352378845,
-0.27729588747024536,
-0.28665891289711,
0.36983102560043335,
-0.976231575012207,
-0.6601654291152954,
-0.05550161749124527,
-0.38532137870788574,
0.027563877403736115,
-0.2706720530986786,
-0.6610243916511536,
-0.02051343210041523,
-0.05819649249315262,
0.29259732365608215,
-0.23759782314300537,
-0.4985440671443939,
0.33651092648506165,
0.2107500433921814,
-0.0303442794829607,
0.7275546789169312,
-1.341758370399475,
0.7268553376197815,
0.42504745721817017,
0.6520776748657227,
-0.279680073261261,
-0.1794283241033554,
-0.5341764092445374,
0.3257875442504883,
-0.24580533802509308,
0.6682138442993164,
-0.596649169921875,
-0.2706393599510193,
-0.22540442645549774,
-0.4517512619495392,
-0.24540594220161438,
-0.816474437713623,
-0.044271070510149,
-0.9913499355316162,
-0.1834656149148941,
-0.16831403970718384,
-0.35436469316482544,
-0.08159324526786804,
0.0743827298283577,
-0.7759750485420227,
0.9905843734741211,
0.14843738079071045,
-0.2598534822463989,
0.19491489231586456,
-0.25174933671951294,
-0.2723984718322754,
-0.1850544959306717,
-0.11955955624580383,
-0.2071085125207901,
0.06563862413167953,
0.15142330527305603,
0.6667548418045044,
-0.5532720685005188,
0.040880437940359116,
-0.3002015948295593,
-0.3228793740272522,
0.17168542742729187,
-0.512959897518158,
0.2642490565776825,
0.38521549105644226,
-0.24014300107955933,
-0.1984006017446518,
-0.46539032459259033,
0.06114654242992401,
-0.1524592787027359,
-0.5481409430503845,
-0.4373706579208374,
0.18429316580295563,
0.12196211516857147,
0.29498034715652466,
0.3499012887477875,
-0.24501465260982513,
0.5496177673339844,
0.09947214275598526,
0.4678976237773895,
0.7489706873893738,
-0.25472426414489746,
0.5920119285583496,
-0.07530391216278076,
0.6101022958755493,
0.17501500248908997,
0.21523311734199524,
0.11062546819448471,
-0.5304825901985168,
-0.8765671849250793,
-0.12564244866371155,
0.3585453927516937,
0.5035278797149658,
-0.9886310696601868,
0.19259387254714966,
-0.13368980586528778,
-0.2156037837266922,
-0.8608688712120056,
0.43188557028770447,
0.23225447535514832,
0.5092811584472656,
0.6525354385375977,
-0.0680425688624382,
-0.1063096672296524,
-1.151579737663269,
-0.4372098743915558,
-0.04266665503382683,
0.10172177106142044,
0.49068862199783325,
0.16893905401229858,
-0.23618339002132416,
1.1126172542572021,
-0.6199491024017334,
0.06719028949737549,
-0.09367685765028,
-0.00003442598972469568,
0.16237126290798187,
0.4793184697628021,
0.44817984104156494,
-0.7023667097091675,
-0.5452973246574402,
0.11104730516672134,
-0.29436081647872925,
-0.35804957151412964,
-0.5660896897315979,
-0.2218373864889145,
0.20471185445785522,
0.7179244160652161,
-0.7170708775520325,
-0.0835704430937767,
0.5310011506080627,
-0.3411245048046112,
0.6303842067718506,
-0.13795724511146545,
0.3353305459022522,
-0.9420902729034424,
-0.18190766870975494,
-0.014146493747830391,
-0.36749911308288574,
-0.425918847322464,
-0.18537193536758423,
0.31075045466423035,
0.2433299869298935,
-0.3656874895095825,
0.9100357890129089,
-0.5831072330474854,
-0.11024971306324005,
-0.03056769073009491,
-0.2832757532596588,
-0.07000142335891724,
0.49238118529319763,
-0.28243669867515564,
0.9607391357421875,
0.31591880321502686,
-0.7974106669425964,
0.21933837234973907,
-0.09799212962388992,
0.073549285531044,
0.6249081492424011,
-0.29605597257614136,
0.0825294703245163,
0.5056537389755249,
-0.21949529647827148,
-0.7582263350486755,
0.2520853579044342,
0.19771333038806915,
-0.08209984004497528,
0.3951437175273895,
-0.44985339045524597,
-0.6530967950820923,
-0.31611305475234985,
0.060692112892866135,
0.5551779270172119,
0.33178144693374634,
-0.5559530854225159,
0.7064006328582764,
0.3417551815509796,
-0.2295849323272705,
-0.4940028488636017,
-0.6448290348052979,
0.38403671979904175,
-0.06090135499835014,
-0.537842869758606,
0.30122506618499756,
-0.32207855582237244,
-0.2764642536640167,
0.09533433616161346,
-0.3691084384918213,
-0.4082487225532532,
0.18663163483142853,
-0.2703942656517029,
0.09818848967552185,
-0.1742183119058609,
0.023172527551651,
0.5221779942512512,
-0.41294652223587036,
-0.033236365765333176,
-0.4060957729816437,
0.5641183257102966,
-0.21389509737491608,
-0.6737772226333618,
-0.12519873678684235,
0.23897477984428406,
0.5658114552497864,
-0.40095511078834534,
0.43915510177612305,
0.38748446106910706,
-0.09911897778511047,
-0.44413095712661743,
-0.8819103837013245,
-0.21385543048381805,
-0.4797068238258362,
0.6601266264915466,
-0.754666805267334,
-0.977328360080719,
0.3913119435310364,
-0.5089569091796875,
0.20609650015830994,
0.2474071979522705,
0.468108594417572,
-0.2751941680908203,
0.9810368418693542,
0.4566338062286377,
-0.2314237505197525,
0.5539214611053467,
-0.19822454452514648,
0.267516553401947,
-0.4790158271789551,
0.1770142763853073,
-0.07659277319908142,
-0.5138764381408691,
0.008882214315235615,
-0.8843545317649841,
0.36704325675964355,
0.1633334755897522,
-0.22813189029693604,
0.058328963816165924,
-0.42760100960731506,
0.47781381011009216,
0.5079315304756165,
0.14718450605869293,
0.4032140374183655,
-0.05110994353890419,
0.08116624504327774,
-0.24222725629806519,
-0.6929554343223572,
-0.3643205761909485,
1.071545124053955,
0.20931248366832733,
1.394102692604065,
0.13749341666698456,
0.49539414048194885,
0.42157110571861267,
0.06525517255067825,
-0.6484778523445129,
0.8544448018074036,
-0.3545202612876892,
-0.5384081602096558,
-0.3040921986103058,
-0.5619869828224182,
-0.5862951278686523,
0.46735599637031555,
-0.15243235230445862,
-0.10854578763246536,
-0.04437115415930748,
0.4109320342540741,
-0.27399301528930664,
0.940511167049408,
-0.837923526763916,
0.5438180565834045,
-0.5203126668930054,
-0.4023212194442749,
-0.6133348941802979,
-0.3315119743347168,
0.4492033123970032,
-0.17554296553134918,
-0.2730132043361664,
-0.1679193079471588,
-0.30883505940437317,
0.7114999294281006,
-0.34927552938461304,
0.8379435539245605,
-0.3475630581378937,
0.10452593863010406,
0.054805122315883636,
0.4550757110118866,
0.2942934036254883,
-0.018072040751576424,
-0.15371929109096527,
0.17313767969608307,
-0.20296892523765564,
-0.3958166539669037,
-0.7359732985496521,
0.6299899816513062,
-0.8161301612854004,
-0.6376611590385437,
0.022967569530010223,
-0.63292396068573,
-0.2458428591489792,
0.3074517846107483,
-0.19269707798957825,
0.24444156885147095,
-0.1867079734802246,
-0.01164207886904478,
1.1729475259780884,
0.06874235719442368,
0.3099067509174347,
0.8375743627548218,
-0.13042399287223816,
-0.16657735407352448,
0.8913941383361816,
0.3964104950428009,
0.3676004111766815,
0.7097911834716797,
-0.06942213326692581,
-0.09328936040401459,
-0.7068724036216736,
-0.7316268086433411,
0.030501553788781166,
-0.3683529496192932,
-0.19026482105255127,
-0.7127862572669983,
-0.11372535675764084,
0.09982012212276459,
-0.3630427420139313,
-0.8823806643486023,
-0.5717636346817017,
-0.3123084604740143,
-0.027656303718686104,
0.5099814534187317,
0.3611028790473938,
0.16197922825813293,
0.7024688720703125,
-0.5963698625564575,
0.2676481008529663,
0.679862380027771,
0.46133652329444885,
0.12335830181837082,
-0.2810354232788086,
-0.4399615228176117,
-0.3311128616333008,
-0.21129092574119568,
-0.9086503982543945,
0.23215104639530182,
0.09072750061750412,
0.916714608669281,
0.8770110011100769,
-0.0988723412156105,
0.6036128401756287,
-0.6367924213409424,
0.22628122568130493,
0.17030629515647888,
-1.026939868927002,
0.13725151121616364,
-0.45850813388824463,
0.22756534814834595,
0.7484642267227173,
0.24806374311447144,
-0.6473214030265808,
-0.2137078493833542,
-0.48944568634033203,
-0.88851398229599,
0.5466207265853882,
-0.24937915802001953,
-0.01341501995921135,
0.1329365372657776,
0.5477736592292786,
0.319532573223114,
0.451375275850296,
-0.4920101761817932,
-0.47037509083747864,
-0.031955573707818985,
0.03939628601074219,
0.07214988768100739,
-0.2253236025571823,
-0.08216589689254761,
-0.33477866649627686,
0.4473639130592346,
-0.3613097071647644,
0.25614500045776367,
-0.2728411555290222,
-0.41667452454566956,
0.004495269153267145,
0.19357827305793762,
0.34742996096611023,
0.8332606554031372,
-0.24594910442829132,
0.4888147711753845,
0.36447498202323914,
-0.34149622917175293,
0.14716294407844543,
-0.012614586390554905,
-0.3973669707775116,
-0.029043013229966164,
-0.0908816009759903,
0.5857929587364197,
0.7716452479362488,
-0.5050064325332642,
0.16949613392353058,
0.046559594571590424,
-0.13280242681503296,
0.18660405278205872,
0.3122272491455078,
0.45437389612197876,
0.32801365852355957,
0.42849448323249817,
0.448436975479126,
0.21640855073928833,
-0.03338497504591942,
0.33520039916038513,
0.5802448391914368,
-0.0919574573636055,
-0.2990599274635315,
0.8014068603515625,
0.4286707639694214,
-0.1315060704946518,
0.6258698105812073,
0.005159413907676935,
-0.24823470413684845,
0.5301116108894348,
0.43636175990104675,
0.8767322897911072,
-0.5096707940101624,
0.21001668274402618,
0.0771850049495697,
0.4631175994873047,
-0.2278187870979309,
0.14705434441566467,
-0.0720749944448471,
-0.7936750054359436,
-0.10760778188705444,
-0.24000690877437592,
-0.7268675565719604,
-0.26463767886161804,
-0.6626353859901428,
0.09817856550216675,
-0.6887267827987671,
-0.24520698189735413,
-0.41475173830986023,
-0.15959608554840088,
-0.7153716087341309,
0.21777793765068054,
0.13458076119422913,
1.228682518005371,
-0.808921754360199,
1.0126219987869263,
0.6572197675704956,
-0.12042269110679626,
-0.3217424154281616,
-0.27618566155433655,
-0.31585824489593506,
-0.9526323676109314,
0.3242636024951935,
-0.34122782945632935,
-0.18197406828403473,
0.26070544123649597,
-0.6598545908927917,
-0.6843069195747375,
1.1193549633026123,
0.49441760778427124,
-0.6225607395172119,
0.01664765551686287,
-0.12171825021505356,
0.24442364275455475,
-0.36864426732063293,
0.6862146258354187,
0.5889997482299805,
0.38546907901763916,
0.12647655606269836,
-0.653839111328125,
-0.0022355779074132442,
-0.22440364956855774,
-0.1190117821097374,
0.2654538154602051,
-1.0667678117752075,
1.300248384475708,
-0.21267351508140564,
0.24058501422405243,
-0.3391956388950348,
0.6496191024780273,
0.4186733067035675,
0.05643147975206375,
0.7703894376754761,
0.4722943603992462,
0.9112080335617065,
0.234711155295372,
0.7054981589317322,
-0.42054641246795654,
0.05928090959787369,
0.8198681473731995,
-0.21137972176074982,
1.0863242149353027,
0.5550273656845093,
-0.26479098200798035,
0.19953936338424683,
0.8221116065979004,
-0.06578950583934784,
0.6996484398841858,
0.0690011978149414,
-0.33897683024406433,
-0.7133897542953491,
0.5281988382339478,
-0.44778093695640564,
0.017098721116781235,
0.2611406445503235,
-0.03688457980751991,
-0.5574128031730652,
-0.3266737759113312,
0.41137367486953735,
-0.3786720633506775,
-0.4748913645744324,
0.44180989265441895,
0.1668323129415512,
-0.43335089087486267,
0.531147837638855,
0.11811503022909164,
0.8518807291984558,
-0.8507962226867676,
-0.1023864820599556,
-0.28578922152519226,
0.25899484753608704,
-0.21608147025108337,
-0.55754154920578,
-0.12147986888885498,
-0.25941285490989685,
-0.5967904925346375,
-0.6696333289146423,
0.6289788484573364,
-0.5767800211906433,
-0.4365159273147583,
0.4155549108982086,
0.7724787592887878,
0.23420237004756927,
-0.330095499753952,
-0.9049956798553467,
-0.16163340210914612,
0.12939070165157318,
-0.37749242782592773,
0.6048200130462646,
0.2567516565322876,
-0.4257665276527405,
1.0443849563598633,
0.588821530342102,
0.20955443382263184,
0.4627290368080139,
0.058906421065330505,
0.9805801510810852,
-0.6381511688232422,
-0.424987256526947,
-0.7432887554168701,
0.3891165852546692,
0.2021256536245346,
-0.259682834148407,
0.7250669002532959,
0.7614777684211731,
0.5159784555435181,
-0.21809731423854828,
0.9057077169418335,
0.2824648320674896,
0.23041066527366638,
-0.6232852935791016,
1.057712197303772,
-0.5924617052078247,
0.2743087410926819,
-0.050154730677604675,
-0.7855386137962341,
-0.02147766761481762,
0.5513009428977966,
-0.486490935087204,
0.3156525790691376,
0.33873438835144043,
0.7238813638687134,
-0.35230234265327454,
-0.42545485496520996,
0.5588042140007019,
0.4642527997493744,
0.5756017565727234,
0.7320585250854492,
0.6457439064979553,
-0.13427793979644775,
0.4367613196372986,
0.17264071106910706,
-0.5004843473434448,
-0.5658129453659058,
-0.615146815776825,
-0.955723762512207,
-0.29047009348869324,
-0.3546435236930847,
0.07759622484445572,
0.14198090136051178,
0.6687102317810059,
0.9703902006149292,
-0.7672613263130188,
-0.49874332547187805,
0.24427275359630585,
0.21184539794921875,
-0.30128908157348633,
-0.16970470547676086,
0.16485348343849182,
-0.2174133062362671,
-0.7053717374801636,
0.42165929079055786,
0.38194310665130615,
-0.19489718973636627,
-0.4859324097633362,
-0.1939881592988968,
-0.17849791049957275,
0.16074517369270325,
0.4972001314163208,
0.41765785217285156,
-0.5917683243751526,
0.23582413792610168,
0.08074787259101868,
-0.3806177079677582,
-0.11193898320198059,
0.702936053276062,
-0.7811390161514282,
0.5949600338935852,
0.31859737634658813,
0.9731972813606262,
0.8099637031555176,
-0.0993255227804184,
0.6832624673843384,
-0.333882600069046,
-0.08745158463716507,
0.1569269299507141,
0.2909661829471588,
0.04382022097706795,
-0.33441224694252014,
0.36815473437309265,
0.20301713049411774,
-0.5027750730514526,
-0.5124225616455078,
0.024641113355755806,
-1.124747395515442,
-0.2576637864112854,
0.9111433029174805,
0.18734712898731232,
-0.00878374557942152,
-0.2170296311378479,
-0.17363901436328888,
-0.15235093235969543,
-0.6171750426292419,
0.8537726402282715,
0.5724219083786011,
-0.4342212975025177,
-0.525853157043457,
-1.0796602964401245,
0.5093265175819397,
0.5715488791465759,
-0.8000061511993408,
-0.09281361103057861,
0.23244236409664154,
0.317322313785553,
-0.27236127853393555,
1.095477819442749,
0.2724745571613312,
0.24425625801086426,
-0.1284927874803543,
0.6043659448623657,
-0.161727175116539,
-0.4302007555961609,
-0.06471153348684311,
-0.03117494098842144,
0.11756297200918198,
-0.14823254942893982
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09012v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09012v1
|
Bayesian Statistical Modeling with Predictors from LLMs
| 2024-06-13T11:33:30 | 2024-06-13T11:33:30 |
Michael Franke, Polina Tsvilodub, Fausto Carcassi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
State of the art large language models (LLMs) have shown impressive
performance on a variety of benchmark tasks and are increasingly used as
components in larger applications, where LLM-based predictions serve as proxies
for human judgements or decision. This raises questions about the
human-likeness of LLM-derived information, alignment with human intuition, and
whether LLMs could possibly be considered (parts of) explanatory models of
(aspects of) human cognition or language use. To shed more light on these
issues, we here investigate the human-likeness of LLMs' predictions for
multiple-choice decision tasks from the perspective of Bayesian statistical
modeling. Using human data from a forced-choice experiment on pragmatic
language use, we find that LLMs do not capture the variance in the human data
at the item-level. We suggest different ways of deriving full distributional
predictions from LLMs for aggregate, condition-level data, and find that some,
but not all ways of obtaining condition-level predictions yield adequate fits
to human data. These results suggests that assessment of LLM performance
depends strongly on seemingly subtle choices in methodology, and that LLMs are
at best predictors of human behavior at the aggregate, condition-level, for
which they are, however, not designed to, or usually used to, make predictions
in the first place.
|
[
-0.3014160096645355,
-0.7770793437957764,
0.8276937007904053,
0.016219723969697952,
-0.12608079612255096,
-0.006171565502882004,
-0.2416207641363144,
-0.31433388590812683,
0.13874968886375427,
0.7350550889968872,
-0.447659432888031,
-0.4282461404800415,
-0.6188058853149414,
0.025137348100543022,
-0.2014661282300949,
0.6009987592697144,
0.15770092606544495,
0.1399071365594864,
-0.21310605108737946,
0.3054674565792084,
-0.22196631133556366,
-0.8274769186973572,
-0.5362134575843811,
-0.4271336793899536,
0.6847834587097168,
0.28286421298980713,
1.0944709777832031,
0.5199131965637207,
0.46818602085113525,
0.2194007784128189,
-0.0031175115145742893,
-0.09551554918289185,
-0.17016781866550446,
0.12253450602293015,
-0.25352048873901367,
-0.6865373849868774,
-0.47019726037979126,
0.3330513834953308,
0.6923993229866028,
1.0944417715072632,
-0.4171408712863922,
0.050942592322826385,
0.06417128443717957,
0.36649343371391296,
-0.4524574875831604,
0.24930226802825928,
-0.6868157386779785,
-0.20629087090492249,
-0.16654358804225922,
0.06492605805397034,
-0.2924720048904419,
-0.09632820636034012,
0.3297712802886963,
-0.20600779354572296,
0.4392051696777344,
0.3754618167877197,
0.3845840096473694,
0.1575372815132141,
-0.6161160469055176,
-0.058346327394247055,
-0.7174704074859619,
0.7978212237358093,
-0.7017161250114441,
0.16325998306274414,
0.7138690948486328,
0.3927137553691864,
-0.6694618463516235,
-0.1235915794968605,
-0.5763581991195679,
-0.46365079283714294,
-0.09862549602985382,
0.17134030163288116,
-0.039987340569496155,
0.20478153228759766,
0.4174061715602875,
-0.0035425859969109297,
-0.4044761657714844,
0.33816400170326233,
-0.34880879521369934,
-0.050631508231163025,
0.8911030888557434,
0.3816770911216736,
0.036557991057634354,
-0.1917220503091812,
-0.29374822974205017,
-0.015271828509867191,
-0.7853419780731201,
-0.02542356215417385,
0.27037373185157776,
0.454049676656723,
0.06005280464887619,
0.8955079317092896,
-0.2090853601694107,
0.8120707869529724,
-0.22583089768886566,
-0.36681896448135376,
-0.009125575423240662,
0.10728142410516739,
-0.19054825603961945,
-0.16391107439994812,
0.7658723592758179,
0.33615148067474365,
0.42340564727783203,
-0.11566787958145142,
-0.12959937751293182,
0.4007939398288727,
0.22121661901474,
-0.4506622850894928,
-0.21734292805194855,
0.21645943820476532,
-0.34935757517814636,
-0.25958964228630066,
0.08089297264814377,
-0.7985507845878601,
-0.6715013384819031,
-0.4408075511455536,
0.40413859486579895,
-0.18341192603111267,
-0.24667637050151825,
0.24345527589321136,
-0.04343736171722412,
0.10878551751375198,
0.3755607008934021,
-0.6446698904037476,
0.31961020827293396,
0.5292341113090515,
0.5379912853240967,
-0.5658507347106934,
-0.4006614685058594,
-0.23939846456050873,
0.25607192516326904,
-0.6870179176330566,
0.7677738070487976,
-0.707783043384552,
-0.5763431191444397,
-0.009359313175082207,
-0.025807766243815422,
-0.02644413523375988,
-0.7226563096046448,
0.5067282915115356,
-0.23648400604724884,
0.09251056611537933,
-0.3088662028312683,
-0.5463690757751465,
-0.15241223573684692,
-0.3069863021373749,
-0.6320910453796387,
0.6466184258460999,
0.1067129373550415,
-0.7207722663879395,
0.7110973596572876,
-0.22631262242794037,
-0.4749368727207184,
-0.004037162754684687,
-0.2882890999317169,
-0.27088841795921326,
0.36778971552848816,
-0.13051225244998932,
0.832360565662384,
-0.3108055293560028,
0.6483347415924072,
-0.7822058200836182,
-0.3515384793281555,
0.9129504561424255,
-0.6017142534255981,
0.500834047794342,
0.14058253169059753,
-0.15237753093242645,
-0.07281312346458435,
-0.7141600251197815,
-0.385656476020813,
0.07742886245250702,
-0.3557512164115906,
-0.17414391040802002,
0.5273038148880005,
-0.34228798747062683,
0.3213261365890503,
0.1329365372657776,
-0.32886427640914917,
0.20564515888690948,
-0.07952924072742462,
0.24720142781734467,
0.8467045426368713,
-0.16139861941337585,
0.5634312033653259,
-0.6892693638801575,
0.6231666803359985,
-0.08076713979244232,
0.008509596809744835,
0.3950490951538086,
-0.7905883193016052,
-0.49088746309280396,
-0.35733601450920105,
0.11385955661535263,
0.5457524657249451,
-0.37728917598724365,
0.06432526558637619,
-0.1385049670934677,
-0.45554184913635254,
-0.433086633682251,
0.05001184344291687,
0.12326999008655548,
0.13704800605773926,
-0.0027701114304363728,
-0.21405069530010223,
-0.2732603847980499,
-1.066603183746338,
-0.46018555760383606,
-0.4702880084514618,
-0.1141732931137085,
0.19321714341640472,
0.39179444313049316,
-0.30085641145706177,
0.9386692643165588,
-0.35738101601600647,
0.10493534803390503,
-0.4708256125450134,
0.17864075303077698,
0.37444373965263367,
0.175851970911026,
0.3236115872859955,
-0.5852404236793518,
0.021754266694188118,
-0.2869950234889984,
-0.278371661901474,
-0.36123692989349365,
-0.014873447827994823,
-0.09928982704877853,
0.1565634310245514,
0.12462852895259857,
-0.8608001470565796,
0.5362704992294312,
0.5210090279579163,
-0.25528982281684875,
0.8140773773193359,
-0.21138525009155273,
-0.1201205924153328,
-0.8101598024368286,
-0.2578979432582855,
0.37760409712791443,
0.030482500791549683,
-0.6622429490089417,
-0.3898083567619324,
-0.08693035691976547,
0.07276099920272827,
-0.17535987496376038,
0.7637665867805481,
-0.28333672881126404,
-0.44159871339797974,
-0.25541800260543823,
0.009509420953691006,
-0.31190404295921326,
0.28555795550346375,
0.46380025148391724,
0.6390520334243774,
0.6475170254707336,
-0.7576214671134949,
0.09997427463531494,
-0.08204563707113266,
-0.4593223035335541,
0.5083171129226685,
-0.5016037225723267,
-0.27188804745674133,
-0.4096660315990448,
0.22004029154777527,
-1.2028815746307373,
-0.5636627674102783,
0.2657780349254608,
-0.4453984200954437,
0.25731101632118225,
-0.02487783692777157,
-0.7312878966331482,
-0.3268204927444458,
-0.05549066141247749,
0.01271778903901577,
0.6525374054908752,
-0.2515932023525238,
0.522129476070404,
0.5502267479896545,
-0.45503517985343933,
-0.2714874744415283,
-0.8606738448143005,
0.13811056315898895,
-0.6440508365631104,
-0.2737596929073334,
0.4515182077884674,
-0.13416683673858643,
-0.6689111590385437,
-0.41574403643608093,
-0.2178148329257965,
-0.1379818469285965,
0.16513153910636902,
0.4924710988998413,
0.6828768253326416,
0.2675531506538391,
0.07971233874559402,
-0.07881028205156326,
-0.05246599018573761,
0.2909177839756012,
0.21595913171768188,
0.18720264732837677,
0.2507428526878357,
-0.5164088606834412,
-0.23200435936450958,
0.26202982664108276,
0.31160983443260193,
0.26500144600868225,
0.5874226093292236,
0.317422479391098,
-0.3311747610569,
-0.15717844665050507,
-0.7745152115821838,
-0.19417314231395721,
-0.36525487899780273,
0.39197036623954773,
-0.34385278820991516,
-0.8651415705680847,
0.3908095955848694,
-0.10166111588478088,
-0.018503352999687195,
0.15793053805828094,
0.5496951937675476,
-0.44682493805885315,
1.4253277778625488,
0.3407776951789856,
-0.05087345093488693,
0.47116971015930176,
0.13577575981616974,
-0.03753523901104927,
-0.6720386743545532,
-0.02442772313952446,
-0.4666837453842163,
-0.2454737424850464,
-0.8334743976593018,
-0.5006403923034668,
0.24560393393039703,
0.18326598405838013,
-0.5207980275154114,
0.09001205861568451,
0.020390726625919342,
0.11870718747377396,
0.4858456254005432,
0.11370763182640076,
0.1772540658712387,
0.060029663145542145,
0.07989820092916489,
-0.025169679895043373,
-0.7100595831871033,
-0.897002637386322,
1.242918848991394,
0.23321160674095154,
1.0649776458740234,
0.03606778383255005,
0.6150323152542114,
0.08336354047060013,
0.41372939944267273,
-0.5973910093307495,
0.7944825887680054,
-0.14832723140716553,
-0.7203090786933899,
-0.08013630658388138,
-0.6426112055778503,
-1.2384192943572998,
0.5367631316184998,
-0.15376102924346924,
-0.9578195214271545,
0.16299915313720703,
-0.033577438443899155,
-0.2869289219379425,
0.057214874774217606,
-0.5954288244247437,
0.5364202857017517,
-0.5323899388313293,
-0.2484697848558426,
-0.24911868572235107,
-0.5954899191856384,
0.25333958864212036,
-0.1093200221657753,
0.5800574421882629,
-0.4159908890724182,
-0.3376103937625885,
0.8636649250984192,
-0.038392648100852966,
1.1699849367141724,
-0.11354024708271027,
-0.17641431093215942,
0.24077561497688293,
0.2981713116168976,
0.29273587465286255,
-0.00005854297705809586,
-0.24697360396385193,
0.11380408704280853,
0.10997582226991653,
-0.3972373902797699,
-0.41569051146507263,
0.370674192905426,
-0.7915340065956116,
-0.8584602475166321,
-0.5225139856338501,
-0.43218880891799927,
-0.5380480289459229,
-0.01501607894897461,
0.11230482161045074,
0.2403326779603958,
-0.1661531627178192,
-0.1623401641845703,
0.46108752489089966,
-0.20910441875457764,
0.20359572768211365,
0.6229460835456848,
-0.34211793541908264,
-0.2091629058122635,
0.725473940372467,
0.24250006675720215,
0.38648900389671326,
0.242195263504982,
0.2601563632488251,
-0.3420143723487854,
-0.5945648550987244,
-0.0015672972658649087,
0.5019183158874512,
-0.5262274146080017,
0.08785324543714523,
-0.13979823887348175,
0.10344438254833221,
-0.21285003423690796,
-0.03761644288897514,
0.08532221615314484,
-0.2762771248817444,
-0.5072484612464905,
-0.19507040083408356,
0.022792361676692963,
0.7964500188827515,
0.05079535022377968,
0.5433342456817627,
-0.34876304864883423,
0.39531248807907104,
0.3715369701385498,
0.13797947764396667,
-0.27464067935943604,
-0.5278492569923401,
0.09470114856958389,
0.22259634733200073,
-0.08966656774282455,
-1.0703803300857544,
0.5099069476127625,
0.07186718285083771,
0.9427077770233154,
0.39546605944633484,
-0.14303994178771973,
0.49349963665008545,
-0.10601918399333954,
0.6700751185417175,
0.07207465171813965,
-0.47972920536994934,
0.4832342565059662,
-0.4002723693847656,
-0.05845353752374649,
0.16259607672691345,
0.425619900226593,
-0.1999521404504776,
-0.40923774242401123,
-0.560856819152832,
-0.3864332437515259,
0.6641989350318909,
-0.10768800973892212,
0.025646664202213287,
-0.30637720227241516,
0.34629103541374207,
0.3427214026451111,
0.37833306193351746,
-0.6175819635391235,
0.02376953326165676,
0.29571405053138733,
-0.07936032116413116,
-0.4712599515914917,
-0.27038905024528503,
0.1475566029548645,
-0.18184472620487213,
0.3833850026130676,
-0.11768326163291931,
0.3102041184902191,
-0.08961715549230576,
-0.01457491610199213,
-0.12834960222244263,
0.3259054720401764,
0.17942015826702118,
0.9535176753997803,
-0.25213977694511414,
0.13441067934036255,
0.23426534235477448,
-0.08630391210317612,
0.073701411485672,
0.027020571753382683,
0.1000298261642456,
-0.08876717835664749,
0.29823049902915955,
0.6454879641532898,
0.2862919270992279,
-0.827284038066864,
0.39067310094833374,
0.13069495558738708,
-0.129606232047081,
-0.45074090361595154,
0.26953181624412537,
0.20110292732715607,
0.3730386197566986,
0.23414699733257294,
-0.03596046566963196,
0.03339796140789986,
-0.7781797647476196,
-0.1978342980146408,
0.732265055179596,
-0.016926100477576256,
-0.36538562178611755,
0.5238026976585388,
-0.25292953848838806,
-0.2765433192253113,
0.4144591987133026,
-0.19049178063869476,
-0.3026861548423767,
0.5503631234169006,
0.5428981184959412,
0.5551639199256897,
-0.3625510632991791,
0.34601855278015137,
0.043053533881902695,
0.08909871429204941,
-0.43532857298851013,
0.4766918122768402,
0.16446295380592346,
-1.0073329210281372,
-0.4675101041793823,
-0.7179479002952576,
-0.5526155233383179,
-0.020886985585093498,
-0.5733622908592224,
0.32465842366218567,
-0.26302477717399597,
-0.6207440495491028,
-0.08872958272695541,
-0.06230458617210388,
-0.8874354362487793,
0.30916139483451843,
0.5098426938056946,
0.6474652886390686,
-0.8550929427146912,
0.8491538166999817,
0.6960261464118958,
-0.266329288482666,
-0.48663195967674255,
-0.06409014016389847,
-0.090239517390728,
-0.8513144850730896,
0.4983130693435669,
-0.02567475102841854,
0.1503509134054184,
-0.3440468907356262,
-0.48985326290130615,
-0.8800687193870544,
0.998986005783081,
0.5368284583091736,
-0.599102258682251,
-0.2534197270870209,
0.25796136260032654,
0.4071408212184906,
-0.40929466485977173,
0.2920236587524414,
0.8059986233711243,
0.5006868243217468,
0.05983246490359306,
-0.753657877445221,
-0.08006997406482697,
0.1479184478521347,
0.3046286404132843,
-0.0017526473384350538,
-0.5442941188812256,
0.8788428902626038,
-0.4787212610244751,
-0.11902813613414764,
0.05754561349749565,
0.41710782051086426,
0.5918113589286804,
0.23054935038089752,
0.27001091837882996,
0.4648441672325134,
0.7576197981834412,
0.03305848315358162,
1.1937006711959839,
0.01866498589515686,
0.05581527575850487,
0.9678138494491577,
-0.522323727607727,
1.0263676643371582,
0.3157958686351776,
-0.7610807418823242,
0.3866533935070038,
0.9452376365661621,
0.11815640330314636,
0.38994330167770386,
0.35439443588256836,
-0.09045325219631195,
-0.45194104313850403,
0.14312362670898438,
0.08070963621139526,
0.4519440233707428,
0.6681310534477234,
-0.32110217213630676,
0.13814328610897064,
-0.31044265627861023,
-0.046916663646698,
-0.2671482264995575,
-0.346407949924469,
0.7632464170455933,
0.13880226016044617,
-0.7588964700698853,
0.28421550989151,
-0.060079023241996765,
0.8115474581718445,
-0.3978937268257141,
0.09454807639122009,
-0.08704371750354767,
-0.2326141744852066,
-0.12180416285991669,
-0.9597329497337341,
0.0969453826546669,
-0.2358570694923401,
-0.04297291487455368,
-0.2087218314409256,
0.9573813080787659,
-0.3587500751018524,
-0.7306826114654541,
0.28062155842781067,
0.8616632223129272,
0.4296973645687103,
-0.18001016974449158,
-0.5082537531852722,
-0.27906543016433716,
-0.2480069249868393,
-0.36151638627052307,
0.7279893159866333,
0.3195224404335022,
-0.12796111404895782,
0.8978716731071472,
0.5280306339263916,
0.5493183732032776,
0.17618849873542786,
0.11537857353687286,
0.32824647426605225,
-0.8270753622055054,
-0.14953862130641937,
-0.9716640710830688,
0.1924392729997635,
0.17198669910430908,
-0.05476847290992737,
0.5044262409210205,
0.26054638624191284,
0.5607417821884155,
0.07210059463977814,
1.0937761068344116,
0.3647693693637848,
0.6621671319007874,
-0.3911260962486267,
0.33478033542633057,
-0.3925335109233856,
0.20025058090686798,
-0.3655073940753937,
-0.9561348557472229,
-0.045361150056123734,
0.6807942390441895,
-0.6391757726669312,
0.36600175499916077,
0.42800742387771606,
0.7764272689819336,
0.16883140802383423,
0.05307700112462044,
0.4188711643218994,
0.07766220718622208,
0.07810500264167786,
0.5072463750839233,
1.0711162090301514,
0.3916868269443512,
0.2675057649612427,
-0.2347816377878189,
-0.4243001937866211,
-0.3539293110370636,
-0.7747018933296204,
-0.9008375406265259,
-0.5502433776855469,
-0.30388373136520386,
0.07057130336761475,
-0.13213637471199036,
0.7556459307670593,
0.5606696009635925,
-0.5560327172279358,
-0.663628876209259,
-0.08254184573888779,
0.16989946365356445,
-0.18633724749088287,
-0.21411481499671936,
0.0030485112220048904,
-0.14746952056884766,
-0.4640333950519562,
0.304890900850296,
0.17000456154346466,
0.1911432445049286,
-0.403960645198822,
-0.046898003667593,
0.13124647736549377,
0.16627566516399384,
0.6038610339164734,
-0.2543599605560303,
-1.0814619064331055,
-0.232695072889328,
-0.22594597935676575,
-0.08207610994577408,
-0.13855299353599548,
0.5863494873046875,
-0.8240699172019958,
0.181081160902977,
0.4172348380088806,
0.3946526348590851,
0.21425382792949677,
0.18793775141239166,
0.6269079446792603,
-0.2996923327445984,
-0.328074187040329,
0.24300605058670044,
0.6737233996391296,
0.2474052906036377,
-0.060532864183187485,
0.45799365639686584,
0.11009769886732101,
-0.6296984553337097,
-0.6452623009681702,
0.33492311835289,
-0.8586190938949585,
-0.43526211380958557,
1.4730504751205444,
0.09233847260475159,
-0.23588144779205322,
-0.1157621443271637,
-0.35360580682754517,
0.16324950754642487,
-0.553905725479126,
0.7876914739608765,
0.8314340710639954,
-0.421298623085022,
-0.11837919056415558,
-1.0355180501937866,
0.2191239297389984,
0.4508853554725647,
-0.5096708536148071,
0.29102396965026855,
0.7410964965820312,
0.33663684129714966,
-0.11532433331012726,
0.5625090599060059,
0.15943856537342072,
0.0077627128921449184,
-0.1597779393196106,
-0.23753035068511963,
0.4394080638885498,
-0.24711832404136658,
-0.20855772495269775,
0.0061853439547121525,
0.4564940631389618,
0.12910638749599457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09008v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09008v1
|
LLM Reading Tea Leaves: Automatically Evaluating Topic Models with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T11:19:50 | 2024-06-13T11:19:50 |
Xiaohao Yang, He Zhao, Dinh Phung, Wray Buntine, Lan Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Topic modeling has been a widely used tool for unsupervised text analysis.
However, comprehensive evaluations of a topic model remain challenging.
Existing evaluation methods are either less comparable across different models
(e.g., perplexity) or focus on only one specific aspect of a model (e.g., topic
quality or document representation quality) at a time, which is insufficient to
reflect the overall model performance. In this paper, we propose WALM (Words
Agreement with Language Model), a new evaluation method for topic modeling that
comprehensively considers the semantic quality of document representations and
topics in a joint manner, leveraging the power of large language models (LLMs).
With extensive experiments involving different types of topic models, WALM is
shown to align with human judgment and can serve as a complementary evaluation
method to the existing ones, bringing a new perspective to topic modeling. Our
software package will be available at
https://github.com/Xiaohao-Yang/Topic_Model_Evaluation, which can be integrated
with many widely used topic models.
|
[
-0.30371537804603577,
-0.6586084961891174,
0.9337812066078186,
0.18365086615085602,
-0.6358234882354736,
0.04616108164191246,
-0.28965747356414795,
-0.24133074283599854,
0.28264427185058594,
0.7458248734474182,
-0.33797383308410645,
-0.6643801927566528,
-0.9682710766792297,
-0.10325757414102554,
-0.5694142580032349,
0.7175081968307495,
-0.1416558474302292,
0.1612376719713211,
-0.586071252822876,
-0.17979483306407928,
-0.4821620285511017,
-0.23740741610527039,
-0.18586957454681396,
-0.5877146124839783,
0.4883245825767517,
0.20921985805034637,
0.6672180891036987,
0.4431658983230591,
0.6534780263900757,
0.3912062644958496,
-0.24876253306865692,
0.21915632486343384,
-0.42468583583831787,
-0.03150361031293869,
-0.5543243288993835,
-0.09745487570762634,
-0.7297735214233398,
0.295590341091156,
0.8737264275550842,
0.9216216206550598,
-0.06816186755895615,
-0.009035850875079632,
0.23926332592964172,
0.4588249623775482,
-0.36656519770622253,
-0.05402320995926857,
-0.8516283631324768,
-0.16870161890983582,
0.155278280377388,
-0.20301911234855652,
-0.40553900599479675,
-0.3104151487350464,
0.4898263216018677,
-0.2437402755022049,
-0.07913224399089813,
0.000531356199644506,
0.9825332164764404,
0.06819895654916763,
-0.5641908049583435,
-0.1819266676902771,
-0.414489209651947,
0.8777995109558105,
-0.7483181953430176,
0.267313152551651,
0.34508007764816284,
0.07480186223983765,
-0.15099762380123138,
-0.5968222618103027,
-0.6581549048423767,
-0.2766561806201935,
-0.18722735345363617,
0.15975897014141083,
-0.39596110582351685,
-0.08124250173568726,
-0.15114803612232208,
0.45353958010673523,
-0.6971402168273926,
-0.020965343341231346,
0.05318691208958626,
0.061961859464645386,
0.6887975931167603,
0.23507042229175568,
0.4038587808609009,
-0.5117505788803101,
-0.48359063267707825,
0.261761337518692,
-0.2886684536933899,
-0.4050182104110718,
0.21954713761806488,
0.12941527366638184,
0.08313072472810745,
0.610920250415802,
-0.1480419635772705,
0.684669017791748,
-0.4140442907810211,
-0.01667349971830845,
0.015457975678145885,
-0.08451974391937256,
-0.23969076573848724,
-0.1936781406402588,
0.8015678524971008,
0.4952279031276703,
-0.3565952479839325,
-0.339791476726532,
-0.2881607413291931,
0.14064037799835205,
0.3704058527946472,
-0.8244481682777405,
-0.24733330309391022,
0.43408358097076416,
-0.731229305267334,
-0.1315949410200119,
0.252198725938797,
-0.7980222702026367,
-0.6783921718597412,
-0.5030725002288818,
0.6030575633049011,
-0.30528905987739563,
-0.40001821517944336,
0.2664761543273926,
-0.08149230480194092,
0.35379481315612793,
0.5491204857826233,
-0.5748397707939148,
0.44938233494758606,
1.166377067565918,
1.0005277395248413,
-0.6208223104476929,
-0.769891083240509,
-0.503869354724884,
0.19801686704158783,
-0.6657976508140564,
1.2091028690338135,
-0.4685323238372803,
-0.4305863082408905,
-0.17486879229545593,
0.061761293560266495,
0.1475299894809723,
-0.44180554151535034,
0.6655455231666565,
-0.5713528394699097,
0.3729449510574341,
-0.18430542945861816,
-0.9296298027038574,
-0.21486905217170715,
0.2923699617385864,
-0.5637817978858948,
0.7552219033241272,
0.04629363492131233,
-0.9438548684120178,
0.4433864653110504,
-0.6347671151161194,
-0.10638374090194702,
0.04170193150639534,
0.010217891074717045,
-0.2153840810060501,
0.13002969324588776,
-0.0057614948600530624,
0.5259479880332947,
-0.6297179460525513,
0.6450729370117188,
-0.3933471739292145,
-0.30289316177368164,
0.34403637051582336,
-0.34679168462753296,
0.7122642993927002,
0.16738851368427277,
0.024023512378335,
0.9022533893585205,
-0.4529975950717926,
-0.10331708937883377,
0.09402427822351456,
-0.16530922055244446,
-0.31659308075904846,
0.12396610528230667,
0.03722517192363739,
-0.08388230204582214,
0.5220444202423096,
-0.23842397332191467,
0.2634047269821167,
-0.2576174736022949,
0.34079164266586304,
0.686870813369751,
0.17171251773834229,
0.4478397071361542,
-0.3977965712547302,
0.23718911409378052,
-0.38172027468681335,
0.001694194390438497,
-0.19732525944709778,
-0.5422399044036865,
-0.8574135899543762,
-0.3552844226360321,
0.5424529910087585,
0.3138909935951233,
-0.2617594301700592,
0.9998220205307007,
-0.3501715362071991,
-0.6911588907241821,
-0.42694154381752014,
0.06316650658845901,
0.1638890951871872,
0.12424465268850327,
0.13089433312416077,
-0.4341689646244049,
-0.16889111697673798,
-0.6585538387298584,
-0.16046783328056335,
-0.4181922674179077,
-0.17704692482948303,
0.10656144469976425,
0.3190654218196869,
-0.576557457447052,
1.1703450679779053,
-0.6795695424079895,
0.00001720200089039281,
-0.3694572448730469,
0.7927049398422241,
0.23829086124897003,
0.1803472638130188,
0.15385285019874573,
-0.6721680164337158,
-0.3582204580307007,
-0.07516533881425858,
-0.46896830201148987,
-0.45940423011779785,
0.05420904979109764,
-0.5351034998893738,
0.10276787728071213,
0.24813593924045563,
-0.5311213135719299,
0.08633342385292053,
0.49022558331489563,
-0.539496898651123,
0.6076002717018127,
-0.3274928629398346,
0.1820584386587143,
-1.1812938451766968,
0.13655787706375122,
0.018572578206658363,
-0.42988038063049316,
-0.38484299182891846,
0.16105391085147858,
0.15561909973621368,
-0.4955118000507355,
-0.2695596218109131,
0.8282949328422546,
-0.5237935185432434,
-0.14509272575378418,
-0.7921496629714966,
0.4151209592819214,
0.4073767066001892,
0.08570201694965363,
0.2641247808933258,
0.5801719427108765,
0.5964208841323853,
-0.46673598885536194,
0.5344775319099426,
0.1103329062461853,
-0.431512713432312,
0.3660348057746887,
-0.5767385363578796,
0.18609125912189484,
0.09097407013177872,
0.01920575648546219,
-1.0571832656860352,
-0.0908973291516304,
0.14878247678279877,
-0.3513166606426239,
0.3989182114601135,
-0.1079818606376648,
-0.38844990730285645,
-0.06719963997602463,
-0.5501755475997925,
-0.14454226195812225,
0.35984697937965393,
-0.5311596393585205,
0.69965660572052,
0.7131362557411194,
-0.3215295970439911,
-0.2797432839870453,
-0.30609190464019775,
0.35482990741729736,
-0.3606886565685272,
-0.6941054463386536,
0.4520728886127472,
-0.057972513139247894,
-0.3632946014404297,
0.29393845796585083,
-0.019117673859000206,
-0.1687585413455963,
0.030903896316885948,
-0.02776959538459778,
0.3471387028694153,
-0.06018119677901268,
0.26158425211906433,
-0.26570531725883484,
-0.3199501037597656,
-0.095761738717556,
-0.20883964002132416,
0.6341469287872314,
-0.15151076018810272,
-0.4562518298625946,
-0.10765434056520462,
0.42109668254852295,
0.48285603523254395,
-0.4030064344406128,
0.45843932032585144,
0.30893397331237793,
-0.5479786396026611,
-0.13337425887584686,
-0.5492660403251648,
0.07291869074106216,
-0.4059053957462311,
0.5024293661117554,
-0.1924567073583603,
-0.6802460551261902,
0.3182966411113739,
-0.26645639538764954,
-0.12105000019073486,
0.5664233565330505,
0.5566819906234741,
-0.019345376640558243,
0.6632157564163208,
0.8836723566055298,
-0.360228031873703,
0.332428902387619,
-0.11443334072828293,
0.32673007249832153,
-0.7353100776672363,
0.02369646355509758,
-0.5760965347290039,
0.08988127112388611,
-0.4621826708316803,
-0.7973402142524719,
-0.05967392399907112,
0.2824667692184448,
0.023807445541024208,
0.12807179987430573,
-0.4387824237346649,
0.44430267810821533,
0.275219202041626,
-0.05812598392367363,
0.4944836497306824,
-0.04291435703635216,
0.10658621042966843,
-0.05561017617583275,
-0.4446336030960083,
-1.1907366514205933,
0.7073866128921509,
0.6005399227142334,
0.6489386558532715,
0.06982649862766266,
0.5883185863494873,
0.4843041002750397,
0.49743446707725525,
-1.0420148372650146,
0.8468540906906128,
-0.31337618827819824,
-0.21727435290813446,
-0.5646504163742065,
-0.5186182856559753,
-0.9936265349388123,
0.510714054107666,
-0.22002626955509186,
-0.9337359070777893,
0.07094821333885193,
-0.32578083872795105,
-0.1059504821896553,
0.34785202145576477,
-0.5926392674446106,
1.1855909824371338,
-0.4049052596092224,
-0.39940425753593445,
-0.406292587518692,
-0.06180495396256447,
0.3540211021900177,
-0.24761676788330078,
0.00023702677572146058,
-0.49209317564964294,
-0.3900596797466278,
1.0275126695632935,
-0.3616175055503845,
0.44772636890411377,
0.11021836847066879,
-0.42099088430404663,
0.4521077573299408,
0.04316272959113121,
0.25060009956359863,
0.03459068015217781,
-0.30057984590530396,
0.26482710242271423,
0.15433913469314575,
-0.3327050805091858,
-0.6869698762893677,
0.6589934229850769,
-0.7338595986366272,
-0.8342602849006653,
-0.776725172996521,
-0.4753569960594177,
-0.3118504285812378,
0.3930591940879822,
-0.08946459740400314,
0.04977908357977867,
-0.45179006457328796,
-0.14442084729671478,
0.3050863742828369,
-0.4029669463634491,
0.14549189805984497,
0.7524028420448303,
-0.8392729163169861,
-0.42730674147605896,
1.101749062538147,
-0.05141397565603256,
-0.021989701315760612,
0.3739112913608551,
0.49922311305999756,
-0.4145370125770569,
-0.6480690836906433,
-0.21843649446964264,
0.32952094078063965,
-0.808627188205719,
-0.15993846952915192,
-0.7076980471611023,
-0.2555588483810425,
-0.24746306240558624,
0.05834219977259636,
-0.20619775354862213,
-0.06781266629695892,
-0.16516490280628204,
0.10216113179922104,
0.28170666098594666,
0.8219329714775085,
0.1890438050031662,
0.4008283317089081,
-1.013210654258728,
0.5041905045509338,
0.4534929692745209,
0.5612884163856506,
-0.06633532792329788,
-0.5611035227775574,
-0.0864805206656456,
-0.2859615981578827,
-0.4238985478878021,
-1.1301647424697876,
0.2940302789211273,
-0.12777529656887054,
0.6013370156288147,
0.5776950120925903,
-0.019344232976436615,
0.402495801448822,
-0.46135351061820984,
0.7762008309364319,
0.10608198493719101,
-1.2676204442977905,
0.47580692172050476,
-0.3782702088356018,
0.0749085322022438,
0.4829823970794678,
0.472059965133667,
-0.7801417708396912,
-0.08946053683757782,
-0.44606271386146545,
-0.7524828314781189,
0.5545009970664978,
-0.17377611994743347,
0.22659799456596375,
0.16981464624404907,
0.10267999023199081,
0.26721128821372986,
0.1652994602918625,
-0.6269865036010742,
0.250644713640213,
0.04546159505844116,
0.08680260926485062,
-0.1452924609184265,
-0.6999757289886475,
0.06502851843833923,
-0.1795181781053543,
0.8275347352027893,
0.015392787754535675,
0.19314716756343842,
-0.10002311319112778,
-0.04955986887216568,
-0.2287120223045349,
0.3644672632217407,
-0.022849222645163536,
1.2061432600021362,
-0.4280130863189697,
0.2999925911426544,
0.23351138830184937,
-0.13263803720474243,
0.19154401123523712,
0.2821509838104248,
0.04831801727414131,
0.15457956492900848,
0.5995202660560608,
0.5427412390708923,
0.07199547439813614,
-0.6213744878768921,
0.5396683812141418,
-0.1562751829624176,
0.09402325004339218,
0.2963983714580536,
-0.0038938112556934357,
0.4502218961715698,
0.18964004516601562,
0.15072473883628845,
-0.5667411088943481,
0.22177685797214508,
-0.8063427805900574,
0.41974538564682007,
0.48734477162361145,
-0.3702429533004761,
0.18842831254005432,
0.11270400136709213,
0.22678013145923615,
-0.2622428834438324,
0.3942398428916931,
-0.5220668315887451,
-0.8270622491836548,
0.36591681838035583,
0.21884256601333618,
0.9753900766372681,
-0.18141937255859375,
0.35992100834846497,
0.06317424774169922,
0.26655346155166626,
-0.019868770614266396,
0.2849867045879364,
0.18024814128875732,
-0.6248272657394409,
-0.5073263645172119,
-0.878364622592926,
-0.8618884086608887,
0.24568802118301392,
-0.33653903007507324,
0.5178491473197937,
-0.047363173216581345,
-0.10267707705497742,
-0.13998311758041382,
0.4363471567630768,
-0.01737041212618351,
0.16912205517292023,
-0.009408032521605492,
0.7859636545181274,
-0.8909788131713867,
0.9060088992118835,
0.7378256916999817,
-0.15895086526870728,
-0.41343405842781067,
0.7472220063209534,
-0.3014863133430481,
-0.22978033125400543,
0.22283238172531128,
0.1015109047293663,
-0.15916825830936432,
-0.3367806673049927,
-0.14691215753555298,
-0.6930921673774719,
0.884059488773346,
0.3625514805316925,
-0.5485064387321472,
0.3273705244064331,
0.037037674337625504,
0.48018309473991394,
-0.16182558238506317,
0.33897995948791504,
0.4859561622142792,
0.46378347277641296,
0.03336267173290253,
-0.6485245227813721,
-0.07265902310609818,
-0.21968510746955872,
0.08501330763101578,
0.13665829598903656,
-0.6233218312263489,
0.7403736710548401,
0.1790379285812378,
-0.2419930100440979,
0.000839770829770714,
1.0017131567001343,
0.2133423089981079,
0.4496460556983948,
0.5256869196891785,
0.5354673266410828,
1.029823899269104,
0.1090402603149414,
0.9094430208206177,
-0.42243340611457825,
0.5058332085609436,
1.267182469367981,
-0.6727897524833679,
0.894112229347229,
0.2567872405052185,
-0.5248599052429199,
0.0738162249326706,
0.9460322260856628,
-0.03274518623948097,
0.41229328513145447,
0.4011574983596802,
-0.14744411408901215,
-0.24941228330135345,
-0.22995904088020325,
-0.24171452224254608,
0.4576435983181,
0.16764801740646362,
-0.043968718498945236,
-0.3098343014717102,
-0.3424721956253052,
-0.21366631984710693,
0.25954240560531616,
-0.19942107796669006,
0.8543251156806946,
0.21066513657569885,
-0.6684442162513733,
0.2841488718986511,
0.4433637857437134,
0.6648473739624023,
-0.7247604727745056,
-0.09517115354537964,
-0.17158132791519165,
-0.13762091100215912,
-0.07734163850545883,
-0.9268848896026611,
0.532653272151947,
0.35628649592399597,
-0.17279185354709625,
-0.022692039608955383,
1.0687122344970703,
-0.2934240698814392,
-0.7516099214553833,
0.7581518888473511,
0.6022741198539734,
0.39065372943878174,
-0.20605692267417908,
-0.6975331902503967,
0.22784321010112762,
-0.3215203285217285,
-0.11872357875108719,
0.23422585427761078,
0.7898220419883728,
0.019024964421987534,
0.4148493707180023,
0.35048946738243103,
0.29673096537590027,
-0.38791587948799133,
0.1655411571264267,
0.7530456185340881,
-0.5689167976379395,
-0.48631542921066284,
-0.9821034669876099,
0.23209254443645477,
-0.2193196564912796,
-0.08978169411420822,
0.8120927810668945,
0.7333822846412659,
0.5825615525245667,
0.3978116810321808,
0.7847753167152405,
0.303864449262619,
0.6094246506690979,
-0.5712935924530029,
1.0027016401290894,
-0.7524912357330322,
0.4502961337566376,
-0.5773152112960815,
-1.3326094150543213,
-0.13419948518276215,
0.5845115780830383,
-0.7619450688362122,
-0.01279415376484394,
0.7452521324157715,
0.5710189938545227,
-0.2678172290325165,
0.16335710883140564,
0.4570215940475464,
0.02116178721189499,
0.2578524947166443,
0.14989438652992249,
1.20940363407135,
-0.00804161000996828,
0.15994347631931305,
-0.21537336707115173,
-0.42606061697006226,
-0.172944575548172,
-1.2408990859985352,
-0.7836019396781921,
-0.6806381344795227,
-0.47929811477661133,
-0.22921642661094666,
0.04938754439353943,
0.9014478325843811,
0.5150808095932007,
-0.5901033878326416,
-0.5213149785995483,
0.2106761336326599,
0.4001775085926056,
0.19231683015823364,
-0.1673303097486496,
0.8607832193374634,
-0.3087373971939087,
-0.632988452911377,
0.17378246784210205,
0.4324018061161041,
-0.1638692170381546,
-0.4432145059108734,
-0.22570990025997162,
-0.32570159435272217,
0.297515869140625,
0.5500340461730957,
-0.2992962598800659,
-0.6833265423774719,
0.041472066193819046,
-0.43347108364105225,
-0.22696879506111145,
0.07976687699556351,
0.8979180455207825,
-0.2673545181751251,
0.44176340103149414,
0.6603180170059204,
0.8053383231163025,
0.45831167697906494,
0.08100190758705139,
0.44363412261009216,
-0.13987553119659424,
-0.0892115980386734,
0.11102975904941559,
0.6060800552368164,
0.4766647219657898,
-0.23676124215126038,
0.3928678035736084,
0.025056486949324608,
-0.46943211555480957,
-0.7890655398368835,
0.024231916293501854,
-0.8868909478187561,
-0.7005821466445923,
1.167624831199646,
-0.2843068242073059,
-0.2761368155479431,
0.14864419400691986,
-0.4541965425014496,
0.4218731224536896,
-0.2249251753091812,
0.8391396403312683,
0.976604700088501,
-0.13882745802402496,
-0.12825292348861694,
-0.3878249228000641,
0.1331666260957718,
0.5514239072799683,
-1.1219249963760376,
0.2395157366991043,
0.4215421974658966,
0.10087158530950546,
0.12911301851272583,
0.6925027370452881,
-0.0074285236187279224,
0.000406544073484838,
-0.2043500393629074,
0.1511128544807434,
0.3906975984573364,
-0.4532735347747803,
-0.6643948554992676,
-0.15000088512897491,
0.53293377161026,
-0.006380923558026552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08979v1
|
Multi-Agent Software Development through Cross-Team Collaboration
| 2024-06-13T10:18:36 | 2024-06-13T10:18:36 |
Zhuoyun Du, Chen Qian, Wei Liu, Zihao Xie, Yifei Wang, Yufan Dang, Weize Chen, Cheng Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA, cs.SE
|
The latest breakthroughs in Large Language Models (LLMs), eg., ChatDev, have
catalyzed profound transformations, particularly through multi-agent
collaboration for software development. LLM agents can collaborate in teams
like humans, and follow the waterfall model to sequentially work on
requirements analysis, development, review, testing, and other phases to
perform autonomous software generation. However, for an agent team, each phase
in a single development process yields only one possible outcome. This results
in the completion of only one development chain, thereby losing the opportunity
to explore multiple potential decision paths within the solution space.
Consequently, this may lead to obtaining suboptimal results. To address this
challenge, we introduce Cross-Team Collaboration (CTC), a scalable multi-team
framework that enables orchestrated teams to jointly propose various decisions
and communicate with their insights in a cross-team collaboration environment
for superior content generation. Experimental results in software development
reveal a notable increase in quality compared to state-of-the-art baselines,
underscoring the efficacy of our framework. The significant improvements in
story generation demonstrate the promising generalization ability of our
framework across various domains. We anticipate that our work will guide LLM
agents towards a cross-team paradigm and contribute to their significant growth
in but not limited to software development. The code and data will be available
at https://github.com/OpenBMB/ChatDev.
|
[
-0.5904327630996704,
-0.49607256054878235,
0.4051344096660614,
0.41627970337867737,
-0.0146019347012043,
0.8068483471870422,
-0.15859711170196533,
-0.3865808844566345,
0.346299946308136,
0.6422082781791687,
-0.6771234273910522,
-0.6527228355407715,
-0.32053735852241516,
0.07269129157066345,
-0.2466031312942505,
1.02744722366333,
-0.12649725377559662,
-0.16624034941196442,
-0.09448948502540588,
-0.3337116241455078,
-0.4694608449935913,
-0.4103034436702728,
-0.7972368597984314,
-0.184895321726799,
0.5650850534439087,
0.5444451570510864,
0.7921107411384583,
0.36666035652160645,
0.287205308675766,
0.3102934956550598,
0.40010157227516174,
0.4711785614490509,
-0.48633530735969543,
0.6171245574951172,
0.07069659233093262,
-0.2781485319137573,
-0.684353768825531,
-0.16977764666080475,
0.13597114384174347,
0.3627779185771942,
-0.09339775890111923,
0.07667253911495209,
0.07306501269340515,
0.38138797879219055,
-0.3637141287326813,
0.2860713303089142,
-0.36115315556526184,
0.11965475231409073,
0.17941589653491974,
-0.41374215483665466,
-0.43458542227745056,
-0.22241893410682678,
0.231795534491539,
-0.5118435025215149,
0.2997889518737793,
0.18179845809936523,
0.4128619134426117,
0.03399103879928589,
-0.3082824647426605,
-0.26962485909461975,
-0.7732646465301514,
0.6069874167442322,
-0.5739397406578064,
0.03441530093550682,
0.0022553198505192995,
0.3495471477508545,
-0.28269559144973755,
-0.6525425910949707,
-0.31052443385124207,
-0.23011340200901031,
0.46341457962989807,
0.14877021312713623,
0.0979887917637825,
0.00298201572149992,
-0.2767000198364258,
0.13815374672412872,
-0.669914722442627,
0.09655673801898956,
-0.2342761754989624,
-0.19841957092285156,
0.8671067953109741,
0.3435361385345459,
0.5964725613594055,
0.5032305717468262,
-0.3882211744785309,
0.05168458819389343,
-0.7494247555732727,
-0.12957748770713806,
0.08675269037485123,
0.5803109407424927,
-0.2571617066860199,
0.4895498752593994,
0.1406208723783493,
0.0072450339794158936,
0.07224207371473312,
0.1536097377538681,
0.31835445761680603,
-0.8687422871589661,
-0.00596627639606595,
0.0424082949757576,
0.7008314728736877,
0.30012455582618713,
-0.09712428599596024,
-0.44819530844688416,
-0.15356771647930145,
0.1974036544561386,
0.3617406189441681,
-0.5878764986991882,
0.0077958544716238976,
0.5108094215393066,
-0.4077683091163635,
-0.3829106092453003,
-0.15578265488147736,
-0.595939576625824,
-0.6883036494255066,
0.016698960214853287,
0.11267601698637009,
-0.14727358520030975,
-0.7013083100318909,
-0.2968495786190033,
-0.2865399420261383,
0.4120485186576843,
0.564396321773529,
-0.6175691485404968,
0.2657567858695984,
0.5457614660263062,
0.8726274371147156,
-0.18276101350784302,
-0.938962459564209,
-0.6556497812271118,
0.39189600944519043,
-0.603794515132904,
0.7992762327194214,
-0.2976566553115845,
-0.4816818833351135,
0.018723977729678154,
-0.5512812733650208,
0.22293992340564728,
-0.2821766138076782,
-0.2102101445198059,
-0.1914912462234497,
-0.07276139408349991,
0.0322534516453743,
-0.0910620391368866,
0.13107150793075562,
0.44527801871299744,
-0.7357571125030518,
0.7792004942893982,
0.28351637721061707,
-0.4786200225353241,
0.6270040273666382,
-0.7286133170127869,
-0.4189022481441498,
0.1658853441476822,
-0.39328303933143616,
-0.3699162006378174,
0.11936988681554794,
0.12386059761047363,
0.31264111399650574,
-0.7825150489807129,
0.24875731766223907,
-0.36718621850013733,
-0.16488540172576904,
0.11733317375183105,
0.07333145290613174,
0.47206005454063416,
0.21873962879180908,
-0.44010764360427856,
0.5505492091178894,
-0.3921460211277008,
0.2902812957763672,
-0.0625825896859169,
-0.40341609716415405,
-0.057632602751255035,
0.00919280108064413,
-0.014533670619130135,
0.5951083302497864,
0.11109687387943268,
-0.258754163980484,
0.32843273878097534,
0.03241194412112236,
0.4465199410915375,
0.4645102620124817,
-0.05231552943587303,
0.823393702507019,
-0.643801212310791,
0.7140706181526184,
0.011401575990021229,
0.41481462121009827,
-0.23162932693958282,
-0.49270227551460266,
-0.3888218402862549,
-0.1698724329471588,
0.07642999291419983,
0.1851302683353424,
-0.9899862408638,
0.1380753219127655,
-0.06867936253547668,
-0.586052417755127,
-0.6457845568656921,
0.24060389399528503,
0.28811100125312805,
0.007280243095010519,
0.16092951595783234,
-0.6126682162284851,
-0.5948119759559631,
-0.397987425327301,
0.08856330066919327,
-0.312863290309906,
0.07829518616199493,
0.18410144746303558,
0.35804468393325806,
-0.40404096245765686,
1.0939759016036987,
-0.044049374759197235,
-0.4106089472770691,
-0.9178305268287659,
0.2657999098300934,
-0.3239157795906067,
0.48126867413520813,
0.42272722721099854,
-0.9546495676040649,
-0.759864866733551,
0.18339569866657257,
-0.5126022100448608,
-0.157944917678833,
-0.10513141751289368,
-0.3203747570514679,
0.5716884732246399,
0.3581433594226837,
-0.4576566517353058,
0.4685713052749634,
0.8099810481071472,
-0.3386276066303253,
0.4703325927257538,
-0.1885695904493332,
0.18512631952762604,
-1.2860088348388672,
-0.14184024930000305,
-0.2745531499385834,
-0.20584295690059662,
-0.526414692401886,
0.010616672225296497,
-0.3371692895889282,
-0.0485764741897583,
-0.41181185841560364,
0.32432374358177185,
-0.5682931542396545,
-0.3492906093597412,
-0.2281978577375412,
0.38249102234840393,
0.026189835742115974,
0.5350032448768616,
0.08930402249097824,
0.7598251104354858,
0.567803680896759,
-0.4985491633415222,
0.490264892578125,
0.25236648321151733,
0.24549070000648499,
0.5278835892677307,
-0.524104118347168,
0.1243896484375,
0.14026403427124023,
0.5680177807807922,
-0.49244558811187744,
-0.005650713108479977,
0.12918110191822052,
-0.6859412789344788,
-0.15685968101024628,
-0.0014279562747105956,
-0.8011900186538696,
-0.1923644095659256,
-0.470757395029068,
0.27216362953186035,
0.07015416771173477,
-0.2681473195552826,
0.9377781748771667,
0.5973391532897949,
-0.10484828054904938,
-0.3483890891075134,
-0.9610311388969421,
0.2511415481567383,
0.10470089316368103,
-1.1204911470413208,
0.29899340867996216,
-0.24479304254055023,
-0.34846916794776917,
-0.0014521918492391706,
-0.07153114676475525,
-0.5162314772605896,
-0.193013995885849,
0.4401490092277527,
0.21944713592529297,
-0.3225337266921997,
0.24839763343334198,
0.1244218721985817,
-0.08840371668338776,
-0.1430908739566803,
-0.30475494265556335,
0.5849725604057312,
-0.09803082048892975,
-0.12454766780138016,
0.13226132094860077,
0.6046096682548523,
0.6037936210632324,
-0.6004052758216858,
0.7902421951293945,
0.3513537347316742,
-0.15824173390865326,
-0.8128117322921753,
-0.30081889033317566,
0.006376318167895079,
-0.39924585819244385,
0.18422769010066986,
-0.40080198645591736,
-0.9179078936576843,
0.713003933429718,
-0.2682553827762604,
0.39281943440437317,
0.20496539771556854,
0.7734217047691345,
0.27329277992248535,
1.0547839403152466,
1.0764018297195435,
0.13141992688179016,
0.2333344966173172,
-0.23857633769512177,
0.026832066476345062,
-0.5476147532463074,
-0.1528584063053131,
-0.46792155504226685,
-0.004093731753528118,
-0.45700621604919434,
-0.6730269193649292,
0.38316917419433594,
-0.3554975688457489,
-0.10778441280126572,
0.402565598487854,
-0.4023050367832184,
0.3355465829372406,
0.36583298444747925,
-0.33744722604751587,
0.5365349054336548,
-0.47528815269470215,
-0.2974278926849365,
0.28347498178482056,
-0.8354302048683167,
-0.38425445556640625,
1.0718311071395874,
0.1929318904876709,
0.5862074494361877,
0.1461602747440338,
0.9624740481376648,
0.4793374836444855,
0.2492368072271347,
-0.38778260350227356,
0.4729958176612854,
0.2615264356136322,
-0.7935762405395508,
-0.5888193845748901,
-0.5036925673484802,
-1.0249122381210327,
0.6576574444770813,
-0.28360649943351746,
-0.23056481778621674,
-0.2062721699476242,
-0.28298723697662354,
-0.40804943442344666,
0.18405912816524506,
-0.7905929088592529,
0.9403659701347351,
-0.2204754501581192,
-0.34367746114730835,
-0.4762802720069885,
-0.8422847390174866,
0.14227145910263062,
-0.29018303751945496,
0.18835802376270294,
-0.007496821228414774,
-0.2881878614425659,
0.2539731562137604,
-0.5716418623924255,
0.7122804522514343,
0.14561206102371216,
-0.14922815561294556,
0.7020057439804077,
0.17347323894500732,
0.2882140278816223,
0.15479128062725067,
-0.027717644348740578,
-0.14127039909362793,
-0.22730283439159393,
-0.39107704162597656,
-0.47477757930755615,
0.6385591626167297,
-0.6511229276657104,
-0.2550007104873657,
-0.36028870940208435,
-0.9192522168159485,
-0.22523465752601624,
0.09436226636171341,
0.03856511414051056,
0.37609753012657166,
-0.3901163935661316,
-0.028110209852457047,
0.2731393575668335,
-0.336139440536499,
0.6207342147827148,
0.6560434103012085,
-0.48294880986213684,
-0.47329431772232056,
0.8189510107040405,
0.02153739333152771,
0.4600490629673004,
0.1836962252855301,
-0.06487254798412323,
0.08197770267724991,
-0.6672011613845825,
-0.3411993682384491,
-0.014456810429692268,
-0.3023684322834015,
-0.09605943411588669,
-0.2753005921840668,
-0.24235419929027557,
-0.6012231707572937,
-0.46264752745628357,
-0.6661527752876282,
-0.04735582694411278,
0.09887603670358658,
0.15550079941749573,
-0.02099434658885002,
0.953916072845459,
-0.09253707528114319,
-0.02726878598332405,
-1.1375665664672852,
0.14248734712600708,
-0.12340358644723892,
0.2138843983411789,
0.004202166106551886,
0.20800282061100006,
-0.4263635575771332,
0.04588879272341728,
-0.45646366477012634,
-0.5579363703727722,
0.4705902338027954,
-0.333615243434906,
0.5654103755950928,
-0.21304349601268768,
0.3400416076183319,
0.4203146696090698,
-0.03467898070812225,
0.6932358145713806,
0.21095456182956696,
-0.9637928009033203,
0.5334643721580505,
-0.313530832529068,
0.3693860173225403,
0.45094630122184753,
-0.051472119987010956,
-0.5037050843238831,
-0.9926524758338928,
-0.5244942903518677,
-0.8382156491279602,
0.7025891542434692,
0.5286189913749695,
-0.31170403957366943,
0.43145304918289185,
-0.3047330975532532,
0.3751869201660156,
0.4179767668247223,
-0.533263087272644,
-0.08455851674079895,
0.013846023939549923,
0.02703407220542431,
-0.13717694580554962,
0.2807517349720001,
-0.0886964425444603,
0.14876678586006165,
0.42704612016677856,
-0.3147062659263611,
-0.00242753722704947,
0.17399491369724274,
-0.056020498275756836,
-0.2618492841720581,
0.22034253180027008,
0.5346970558166504,
0.9638567566871643,
0.3155844211578369,
-0.040991269052028656,
0.01908070407807827,
-0.3495890200138092,
-0.04490218684077263,
0.1459394246339798,
0.11558984220027924,
-0.23568658530712128,
0.4062720239162445,
0.3538719415664673,
-0.11306652426719666,
-0.48992684483528137,
0.4187813699245453,
-0.32388830184936523,
-0.23849301040172577,
-0.08026992529630661,
-0.00590193597599864,
0.07135052233934402,
0.8422119617462158,
0.40267786383628845,
0.09903611242771149,
-0.14317552745342255,
-0.7880199551582336,
0.2516411542892456,
0.2472776621580124,
-0.1649814397096634,
-0.24177315831184387,
0.4395127594470978,
0.7495086789131165,
-0.27755531668663025,
0.3246590793132782,
-0.362291544675827,
-0.5627939105033875,
1.1847989559173584,
0.31306561827659607,
1.2151422500610352,
-0.17212457954883575,
0.5938332676887512,
-0.19554965198040009,
0.37535199522972107,
-0.006529990117996931,
0.29927948117256165,
-0.1469508707523346,
-0.5089813470840454,
-0.573691189289093,
-0.13209734857082367,
-0.7691352367401123,
-0.469954252243042,
0.07960128039121628,
0.40173155069351196,
-0.28255361318588257,
-0.1493513137102127,
-0.20557932555675507,
0.3268826901912689,
-0.2814589738845825,
-0.13735491037368774,
0.10024720430374146,
0.5970485806465149,
-0.3919147551059723,
0.97817462682724,
0.7098212242126465,
-0.870521068572998,
-0.7673863172531128,
0.14075522124767303,
0.021247610449790955,
-0.3794173300266266,
0.37488335371017456,
0.0708213597536087,
-0.24371929466724396,
-0.20429818332195282,
-0.6092842221260071,
-0.5407766103744507,
1.373535394668579,
0.09400957077741623,
-0.34923961758613586,
-0.24594911932945251,
0.3310866355895996,
0.8747360110282898,
-0.8841774463653564,
0.34773188829421997,
-0.011009687557816505,
0.32206204533576965,
0.4511115849018097,
-1.181859016418457,
0.061589669436216354,
0.0019844609778374434,
-0.05584365501999855,
0.3544468581676483,
-0.90732342004776,
0.9902660846710205,
-0.5677385330200195,
-0.07791382074356079,
-0.013701573945581913,
0.5052689909934998,
0.4543708860874176,
0.6242307424545288,
0.3528765141963959,
0.05302061513066292,
0.41332077980041504,
0.2950076758861542,
0.617344081401825,
-0.5078712701797485,
0.3268728256225586,
1.1209696531295776,
-0.584473729133606,
0.5219950675964355,
0.34833192825317383,
0.08683107048273087,
0.30484917759895325,
0.2551804184913635,
0.0533941425383091,
0.18484926223754883,
0.26002606749534607,
-0.1708332896232605,
-0.2602735459804535,
-0.27519506216049194,
-0.3871355652809143,
0.3309096395969391,
0.015018880367279053,
-0.2536364495754242,
-0.22897779941558838,
-0.028247589245438576,
0.005388496909290552,
0.05615948513150215,
-0.4710570275783539,
0.4828535318374634,
0.13443103432655334,
-0.7976397275924683,
0.1669452041387558,
-0.2319418042898178,
0.4679272770881653,
-0.6447833180427551,
-0.16943612694740295,
-0.23727262020111084,
0.32278546690940857,
-0.3018254339694977,
-0.7977409958839417,
0.4393686056137085,
-0.10227495431900024,
-0.09577331691980362,
-0.38921216130256653,
0.6067495942115784,
-0.5693146586418152,
0.11493754386901855,
0.6818988919258118,
0.9688560366630554,
-0.15070462226867676,
-0.15857143700122833,
-0.4120539724826813,
0.2875918745994568,
-0.26918792724609375,
0.027613433077931404,
0.4281057119369507,
0.693645179271698,
-0.002328456612303853,
0.925967276096344,
0.39402687549591064,
-0.015168281272053719,
0.162228062748909,
0.03869184851646423,
0.9668571949005127,
-0.46505987644195557,
-0.5271060466766357,
-0.6184479594230652,
0.3663928508758545,
0.023822728544473648,
-0.3626713156700134,
0.6998118758201599,
0.7552976012229919,
0.7486081123352051,
0.1794460415840149,
0.9805032014846802,
-0.3336212635040283,
0.1430981457233429,
0.050223458558321,
0.946882963180542,
-0.3981448709964752,
0.12953752279281616,
-0.3860221803188324,
-0.958601176738739,
-0.4215269088745117,
-0.010769667103886604,
0.32539859414100647,
0.17096450924873352,
0.9136790037155151,
0.5693812370300293,
0.42970356345176697,
0.14871326088905334,
0.3656323254108429,
0.08009519428014755,
0.5894202589988708,
0.9055539965629578,
0.9361589550971985,
-0.10062292963266373,
1.2393463850021362,
-0.05234748125076294,
-0.279568612575531,
0.1199239045381546,
-0.45240819454193115,
-1.1607807874679565,
-0.7482759952545166,
-0.37427815794944763,
-0.28860029578208923,
0.3247959315776825,
1.1040972471237183,
0.6298191547393799,
-0.3783465325832367,
-0.6074651479721069,
-0.40647393465042114,
0.3151703476905823,
-0.3359490931034088,
-0.14873555302619934,
-0.269661009311676,
-0.3581613600254059,
-0.6024672389030457,
0.15644444525241852,
0.4884912967681885,
-0.032252099364995956,
-0.7354795932769775,
-0.49805349111557007,
-0.21395838260650635,
0.07819116115570068,
0.5236292481422424,
0.25649920105934143,
-0.3003373146057129,
0.1145268976688385,
-0.12165647745132446,
-0.6076075434684753,
0.1842418909072876,
0.9272016286849976,
-0.7853133678436279,
0.26673993468284607,
0.4952303171157837,
0.662362277507782,
0.43881306052207947,
-0.3145809471607208,
0.9943578839302063,
-0.4661087095737457,
-0.16344265639781952,
0.3869975209236145,
-0.07645678520202637,
0.04087820276618004,
-0.08061990141868591,
0.7994917035102844,
0.0459774024784565,
-0.8254696726799011,
-0.682370662689209,
0.09213826060295105,
-0.7168720364570618,
-0.22863321006298065,
0.9944958090782166,
-0.012850153259932995,
-0.10929960757493973,
-0.3533531725406647,
-0.46281471848487854,
0.4375435709953308,
-0.8838944435119629,
0.6627029776573181,
0.6664353013038635,
-0.2522219717502594,
-0.25728973746299744,
-0.29716038703918457,
0.24794001877307892,
0.1351536512374878,
-1.1508448123931885,
0.130093052983284,
0.5871543288230896,
-0.1433630734682083,
0.23617616295814514,
0.8272597193717957,
0.13366830348968506,
0.3249342441558838,
0.5840059518814087,
0.4048842489719391,
-0.08467426896095276,
-0.609618067741394,
0.11211154609918594,
0.3076142966747284,
0.1434517353773117,
-0.2784298360347748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00053v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00053v1
|
A Document-based Knowledge Discovery with Microservices Architecture
| 2024-06-13T09:28:31 | 2024-06-13T09:28:31 |
Habtom Kahsay Gidey, Mario Kesseler, Patrick Stangl, Peter Hillmann, Andreas Karcher
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL, cs.DL, cs.IR
|
The first step towards digitalization within organizations lies in
digitization - the conversion of analog data into digitally stored data. This
basic step is the prerequisite for all following activities like the
digitalization of processes or the servitization of products or offerings.
However, digitization itself often leads to 'data-rich' but 'knowledge-poor'
material. Knowledge discovery and knowledge extraction as approaches try to
increase the usefulness of digitized data. In this paper, we point out the key
challenges in the context of knowledge discovery and present an approach to
addressing these using a microservices architecture. Our solution led to a
conceptual design focusing on keyword extraction, similarity calculation of
documents, database queries in natural language, and programming language
independent provision of the extracted information. In addition, the conceptual
design provides referential design guidelines for integrating processes and
applications for semi-automatic learning, editing, and visualization of
ontologies. The concept also uses a microservices architecture to address
non-functional requirements, such as scalability and resilience. The evaluation
of the specified requirements is performed using a demonstrator that implements
the concept. Furthermore, this modern approach is used in the German patent
office in an extended version.
|
[
-0.5419224500656128,
-0.5328769087791443,
0.9670648574829102,
-0.409035861492157,
-0.25556910037994385,
0.1011849045753479,
0.1712835133075714,
-0.4205993115901947,
0.3075069189071655,
0.4658147990703583,
-0.5714544653892517,
-0.8546279668807983,
-0.5095919966697693,
-0.08368343859910965,
-0.3479776382446289,
0.6793471574783325,
-0.30922457575798035,
-0.04446399584412575,
-0.45887765288352966,
0.053624726831912994,
-0.22488051652908325,
-0.2134215235710144,
-0.7811307907104492,
-0.3903648853302002,
0.1772642433643341,
0.7170156836509705,
0.39612919092178345,
0.6398213505744934,
0.5336196422576904,
0.29441845417022705,
0.05068989843130112,
0.302957147359848,
-0.07454284280538559,
0.0841783955693245,
-0.11045306921005249,
-0.4423587918281555,
-0.37295785546302795,
-0.1794823855161667,
0.31555208563804626,
0.4303041994571686,
-0.12857821583747864,
0.2665838599205017,
-0.16027000546455383,
0.5742865204811096,
-0.3003096580505371,
0.7305186986923218,
-0.20223115384578705,
0.12285853922367096,
-0.32076358795166016,
-0.18539860844612122,
0.2543729543685913,
-0.238277867436409,
0.29684630036354065,
-0.9700537919998169,
0.3420249819755554,
0.17415377497673035,
0.7361161708831787,
0.045129597187042236,
0.0493084117770195,
-0.8364899754524231,
-0.7285999655723572,
0.43200236558914185,
-0.3799026608467102,
0.5540594458580017,
0.3783925771713257,
0.6357144713401794,
0.02725909650325775,
-0.7886218428611755,
-0.5142456889152527,
0.363067626953125,
0.04704328253865242,
-0.08278656750917435,
-0.07789706438779831,
-0.23542654514312744,
0.02752111107110977,
0.391817182302475,
-0.21338911354541779,
-0.04493703320622444,
-0.42181968688964844,
-0.2633991241455078,
0.49209243059158325,
0.2555963695049286,
0.22344835102558136,
-0.2989964485168457,
-0.24301309883594513,
-0.1631798893213272,
-0.316275954246521,
0.04176943749189377,
0.11192267388105392,
0.3388826549053192,
0.05422129109501839,
0.5725318193435669,
-0.5122619271278381,
0.20372195541858673,
-0.004647287540137768,
-0.3805352449417114,
0.14698028564453125,
-0.5233163833618164,
-0.223664790391922,
0.009165302850306034,
0.42917880415916443,
0.055042654275894165,
-0.1237020194530487,
-0.6891889572143555,
-0.47778475284576416,
-0.1736362725496292,
0.4420238137245178,
-0.6319180130958557,
-0.13356837630271912,
0.31493887305259705,
-0.5036907196044922,
-0.6143704652786255,
0.20790395140647888,
-0.7540769577026367,
-0.6062160730361938,
-0.37097835540771484,
0.44922131299972534,
-0.796420693397522,
-0.10777914524078369,
-0.04364509508013725,
-0.6445468664169312,
0.04060210660099983,
0.4054110646247864,
-0.939437747001648,
0.4740634262561798,
0.8729550838470459,
0.8534643650054932,
0.148391455411911,
0.1713593453168869,
0.10315712541341782,
0.45275411009788513,
-0.2818494141101837,
0.920314371585846,
-0.27598273754119873,
-0.6008316278457642,
-0.00031451339600607753,
-0.012333637103438377,
0.34185075759887695,
-0.7339434623718262,
0.8578352332115173,
-0.7931656241416931,
-0.07368545234203339,
-0.420886754989624,
-0.7639480233192444,
-0.1854211837053299,
0.5572143793106079,
-0.5606269240379333,
0.7675209641456604,
0.3893207311630249,
-0.7991868257522583,
0.6272577047348022,
-1.0381443500518799,
-0.24716681241989136,
0.36827006936073303,
-0.7218979001045227,
-0.3336751163005829,
0.07607368379831314,
-0.1174430325627327,
0.26060622930526733,
-0.7271965146064758,
0.04391699656844139,
-0.1666366010904312,
-0.19456127285957336,
-0.20280763506889343,
0.4038417935371399,
0.5880014896392822,
0.2728500962257385,
-0.18482404947280884,
-0.23570595681667328,
-1.1808559894561768,
-0.08930039405822754,
0.5139063000679016,
-0.379804402589798,
-0.9055283069610596,
-0.00917941052466631,
-0.21141035854816437,
0.06015056371688843,
0.37846648693084717,
-0.8196218013763428,
0.45025578141212463,
-0.40957778692245483,
0.21608087420463562,
0.5161345601081848,
0.12738987803459167,
0.8446944952011108,
-0.5832747220993042,
0.33637410402297974,
0.2489212155342102,
0.3824627995491028,
-0.18585935235023499,
-0.20679250359535217,
-0.7124298214912415,
-0.23921068012714386,
0.24537375569343567,
0.3289051651954651,
-1.1563953161239624,
0.23989856243133545,
-0.7226933836936951,
-0.6244003772735596,
-0.6905404925346375,
0.051068052649497986,
0.061412397772073746,
0.6645254492759705,
0.13121147453784943,
-0.163468137383461,
-0.4960962235927582,
-0.9122262597084045,
0.33166059851646423,
0.10835587978363037,
-0.3863362967967987,
0.4378761947154999,
0.3846081793308258,
-0.6417964100837708,
1.0689506530761719,
-0.635639488697052,
-0.8949670791625977,
0.3206592798233032,
0.20367422699928284,
0.19011154770851135,
0.1829657405614853,
0.16932059824466705,
-1.206664800643921,
-0.050793059170246124,
0.23481006920337677,
-1.1402323246002197,
0.04546036198735237,
0.3416474759578705,
0.34150028228759766,
0.18860100209712982,
0.4170083999633789,
-0.3419741690158844,
0.11537589877843857,
-0.07503299415111542,
-0.1354663223028183,
0.3584730327129364,
-0.3600755035877228,
0.049955520778894424,
-0.9899401664733887,
0.11138976365327835,
-0.33599793910980225,
0.2465585619211197,
-0.5964549779891968,
0.15998101234436035,
0.17034810781478882,
-0.51050865650177,
-0.14645986258983612,
0.5367627739906311,
-0.33947017788887024,
-0.1327052265405655,
-0.25896206498146057,
0.2833592891693115,
0.13338680565357208,
-0.025657569989562035,
-0.06328779458999634,
0.8144794702529907,
0.32050153613090515,
-0.6807442903518677,
0.43121734261512756,
0.5902160406112671,
-0.29677334427833557,
0.575505256652832,
-0.2602171301841736,
0.1886824518442154,
-0.1881827712059021,
-0.3426685333251953,
-0.4859035313129425,
0.11221291869878769,
0.20658887922763824,
-0.33310651779174805,
0.0758860632777214,
-0.023233622312545776,
-0.9663413166999817,
-0.3164779245853424,
-0.39436474442481995,
-0.09603548049926758,
0.06925614923238754,
-0.4114394783973694,
0.93537437915802,
0.6097721457481384,
-0.36657440662384033,
0.00638725096359849,
-0.3474181294441223,
0.19810637831687927,
0.06842515617609024,
-1.0629397630691528,
0.5308600664138794,
0.29298529028892517,
-0.3722551465034485,
0.20487961173057556,
-0.3114176094532013,
-0.1008477583527565,
0.16603709757328033,
0.44308507442474365,
0.1638592779636383,
-0.022225964814424515,
0.5164448022842407,
0.1286240518093109,
-0.47212478518486023,
-0.006842851173132658,
-0.7804545164108276,
0.4326755702495575,
0.09937917441129684,
-0.3416059613227844,
-0.11038883030414581,
0.3238633871078491,
0.6767751574516296,
-0.12510892748832703,
0.5326669216156006,
0.5159412622451782,
-0.5908523201942444,
-0.16153576970100403,
-0.5708534121513367,
-0.06612193584442139,
-0.5264466404914856,
-0.2193615734577179,
-0.8230612874031067,
-0.6082276105880737,
0.621542751789093,
-0.48886236548423767,
-0.08108972012996674,
0.5988636612892151,
0.2137056589126587,
-0.3026447892189026,
0.5625340342521667,
1.0358716249465942,
0.08773627132177353,
0.35000094771385193,
-0.5690730810165405,
0.5068808197975159,
-0.7159489989280701,
-0.6368655562400818,
-0.7177982926368713,
0.07082819938659668,
-0.49939438700675964,
-0.23298150300979614,
0.5787591338157654,
-0.16678905487060547,
-0.02704087272286415,
0.16736455261707306,
-0.3172857463359833,
-0.13067393004894257,
0.6854335069656372,
-0.030936121940612793,
0.6315910816192627,
-0.07775145024061203,
-0.5298585891723633,
-0.11443936824798584,
-0.7982998490333557,
-0.9003068208694458,
1.082615852355957,
0.16586236655712128,
0.7641329765319824,
-0.007923509925603867,
1.2556846141815186,
0.4874100983142853,
0.03746841475367546,
-0.7935000658035278,
0.36748307943344116,
-0.13248448073863983,
-0.4008934497833252,
-0.4796266555786133,
-0.3337801396846771,
-0.6940518021583557,
-0.22604361176490784,
-0.4057216942310333,
-0.4158852994441986,
0.43546536564826965,
-0.41822898387908936,
-0.2545592486858368,
0.15896286070346832,
-0.6244040131568909,
0.5377823114395142,
-0.3609254062175751,
-0.16166472434997559,
-0.14907710254192352,
-0.24207153916358948,
-0.07566451281309128,
-0.4732418656349182,
0.6550145149230957,
0.23865333199501038,
-0.06596162170171738,
0.9725629687309265,
-0.3592435419559479,
0.26824143528938293,
-0.37274369597435,
-0.11449176073074341,
0.0668627992272377,
0.0021673748269677162,
0.5243262052536011,
-0.07331736385822296,
-0.188211128115654,
-0.07698994129896164,
0.4769749641418457,
-0.19203445315361023,
-0.7902159690856934,
0.31989291310310364,
-0.6539829969406128,
-0.49936115741729736,
-0.23293620347976685,
-0.37759146094322205,
-0.10980506241321564,
0.8191259503364563,
-0.0004886267124675214,
0.2922263741493225,
-0.38959118723869324,
0.12223543971776962,
0.8878592252731323,
-0.04346247389912605,
0.05639439821243286,
1.0885157585144043,
-0.2635614275932312,
-0.1722775250673294,
1.069823980331421,
0.6465392708778381,
-0.2455904185771942,
0.48202940821647644,
0.18108196556568146,
-0.14204972982406616,
-0.8078794479370117,
-0.18026064336299896,
-0.021358905360102654,
-0.7174200415611267,
-0.05727195739746094,
-0.7145739197731018,
-0.10262686014175415,
-0.6478716731071472,
-0.06869090348482132,
-0.35001280903816223,
-0.33356773853302,
-0.38537460565567017,
0.0892803743481636,
-0.20797182619571686,
0.7266854047775269,
0.14352451264858246,
-0.15512922406196594,
-1.2129217386245728,
0.5218020081520081,
0.3100104331970215,
0.5419478416442871,
0.07743696123361588,
0.057022832334041595,
-0.5811314582824707,
0.009889433160424232,
-0.24486178159713745,
-0.40113145112991333,
0.0426538810133934,
-0.31496915221214294,
0.5111823081970215,
0.6319845914840698,
0.2452974021434784,
0.011277968063950539,
-0.38417282700538635,
0.3530215322971344,
-0.22402377426624298,
-0.5985848903656006,
0.605033814907074,
-0.4399488866329193,
-0.17232181131839752,
0.6905571222305298,
0.3809109032154083,
-0.6556119918823242,
0.034336186945438385,
-1.1674401760101318,
-0.6855490207672119,
0.3363776206970215,
-0.13813799619674683,
-0.31261587142944336,
0.16165637969970703,
0.5181306600570679,
0.2290058732032776,
0.2846013903617859,
0.2836124002933502,
-0.11748430877923965,
0.08388671278953552,
-0.11073101311922073,
0.11076317727565765,
-0.24001719057559967,
-0.43986156582832336,
0.1328389197587967,
0.7841740250587463,
-0.1002919152379036,
0.3749423325061798,
0.28830787539482117,
-0.06890759617090225,
0.21428538858890533,
0.22772562503814697,
0.20771870017051697,
0.5438098907470703,
-0.4263225495815277,
0.14174336194992065,
-0.17944353818893433,
-0.30439627170562744,
0.16280584037303925,
0.2115510255098343,
-0.8246191740036011,
0.02206098847091198,
0.12806522846221924,
0.37198981642723083,
0.2802363932132721,
-0.6297549605369568,
0.4348377287387848,
-0.09955023229122162,
-0.23259052634239197,
-0.45374906063079834,
0.11312028765678406,
0.22276031970977783,
0.6335232257843018,
0.5146140456199646,
-0.2722414433956146,
0.3198237419128418,
-0.6217699646949768,
0.2769191563129425,
0.434786319732666,
-0.06731117516756058,
-0.04016247019171715,
0.37475425004959106,
0.18793322145938873,
-0.5608757138252258,
0.4087013006210327,
-0.38722336292266846,
-0.2710000276565552,
0.4514197111129761,
0.20879629254341125,
0.613757312297821,
0.21659809350967407,
0.18335773050785065,
-0.334091454744339,
0.3325744569301605,
0.11995565891265869,
0.37862253189086914,
-0.46715858578681946,
-0.925256073474884,
0.6112573742866516,
-0.6155489683151245,
-0.6778339743614197,
-0.17064550518989563,
-0.4219667315483093,
0.43918609619140625,
-0.3770599663257599,
-0.07876165211200714,
0.35188496112823486,
0.5124569535255432,
-0.6005686521530151,
0.35843971371650696,
0.03187756612896919,
1.1837042570114136,
-0.7119112610816956,
0.8877955675125122,
0.6577837467193604,
-0.8006770610809326,
-0.4432925581932068,
-0.45039987564086914,
0.062464628368616104,
-0.9094991683959961,
0.6097772121429443,
-0.47838929295539856,
0.02195459045469761,
0.017480622977018356,
0.054901041090488434,
-0.5542680621147156,
1.6497507095336914,
-0.025528008118271828,
-0.2507803738117218,
-0.14989440143108368,
0.30726519227027893,
0.6178598999977112,
-0.4956730902194977,
-0.2403942048549652,
0.7730869650840759,
0.6127151846885681,
0.11442800611257553,
-0.32320788502693176,
-0.04902825504541397,
-0.17670808732509613,
0.01729961670935154,
0.12363661825656891,
-0.2547363340854645,
0.749556839466095,
0.060613084584474564,
-0.46371716260910034,
-0.11210958659648895,
0.2593017816543579,
-0.22376956045627594,
0.6785023212432861,
0.24830415844917297,
0.8027430772781372,
0.9695949554443359,
0.1610785573720932,
1.070690631866455,
-0.2098873406648636,
0.24754613637924194,
1.0075721740722656,
-0.08308999985456467,
0.6001096963882446,
0.6037234663963318,
-0.29949507117271423,
0.10586701333522797,
0.5108736157417297,
-0.19656865298748016,
0.595650315284729,
-0.11066929996013641,
-0.2891654074192047,
0.47896140813827515,
-0.325020432472229,
-0.08058653771877289,
0.4000980257987976,
0.20028746128082275,
-0.5184800028800964,
-0.3188401162624359,
0.046309277415275574,
-0.016818640753626823,
-0.05149080604314804,
-0.06101783737540245,
1.3571720123291016,
-0.154732346534729,
-0.21501801908016205,
0.11919435113668442,
0.36930274963378906,
0.37259551882743835,
-0.5431806445121765,
0.08539802581071854,
-0.10701266676187515,
0.06611587852239609,
-0.23818574845790863,
-0.6483951210975647,
0.5875756144523621,
-0.3245927095413208,
-0.7241579294204712,
-0.2262536734342575,
1.2081549167633057,
-0.04635272175073624,
-0.24654151499271393,
0.3779464364051819,
0.7782773971557617,
-0.12921740114688873,
-0.23985983431339264,
-0.1779291033744812,
-0.15735958516597748,
-0.23154272139072418,
0.3370560109615326,
0.5156967639923096,
0.7023575305938721,
0.03301411122083664,
0.7095615863800049,
0.6351906657218933,
0.25066399574279785,
-0.057865191251039505,
0.035929325968027115,
0.9306735396385193,
-0.26598894596099854,
-0.6379503607749939,
-0.37266039848327637,
-0.07149156183004379,
-0.17637419700622559,
0.2776274085044861,
0.4369456470012665,
0.6732316017150879,
0.7475852966308594,
-0.05746420845389366,
0.9746080040931702,
-0.22528989613056183,
0.6634497046470642,
-0.36343032121658325,
0.9360632300376892,
-0.485444039106369,
0.2682652175426483,
-0.024060241878032684,
-0.657559871673584,
0.06353627145290375,
0.22932717204093933,
-0.39473026990890503,
-0.5018031597137451,
0.48237618803977966,
0.810939610004425,
-0.0877017080783844,
0.2932538390159607,
0.1485884040594101,
-0.04950084164738655,
0.7068232893943787,
-0.09546173363924026,
0.29079264402389526,
-0.6290146708488464,
0.28482282161712646,
-0.4058398902416229,
-0.37359917163848877,
-0.06314537674188614,
-0.5878230333328247,
-0.2700485289096832,
-1.0013331174850464,
0.09031794220209122,
0.010801131837069988,
-0.04493527114391327,
0.5677067637443542,
0.3602237105369568,
-0.5893709063529968,
0.08415418863296509,
0.04389539361000061,
0.3693092167377472,
0.04101806506514549,
-0.1880517452955246,
0.3761289715766907,
-0.450681209564209,
-0.28231653571128845,
0.13514399528503418,
0.55259770154953,
0.31137827038764954,
-0.15391676127910614,
0.14665398001670837,
-0.21645426750183105,
-0.11168243736028671,
0.47539278864860535,
0.27515020966529846,
-0.17389199137687683,
-0.36084744334220886,
-0.09969048202037811,
-0.07512664794921875,
0.014810933731496334,
0.8693247437477112,
-0.5126739740371704,
0.6639354228973389,
0.3624129295349121,
1.1300657987594604,
0.7840099930763245,
-0.20256307721138,
0.29884016513824463,
-0.5236143469810486,
-0.00499639380723238,
0.11196161061525345,
0.18721531331539154,
0.26368340849876404,
-0.350034236907959,
0.6082161664962769,
0.5511826872825623,
-0.2085968405008316,
-0.2658463418483734,
-0.0340440534055233,
-0.7226852178573608,
-0.13277816772460938,
0.5136516094207764,
-0.015604564920067787,
-0.237147256731987,
-0.3970044255256653,
-0.21713143587112427,
0.3189796507358551,
-0.2261023074388504,
1.267012596130371,
0.7741518616676331,
-0.08121098577976227,
-0.06888505071401596,
-0.44785836338996887,
0.40445375442504883,
-0.17157499492168427,
-0.9369223117828369,
-0.1121637150645256,
0.0782870501279831,
0.27957597374916077,
0.773993194103241,
0.6457380056381226,
-0.3362009525299072,
0.130049929022789,
0.2064751535654068,
0.14360925555229187,
-0.4823329746723175,
-0.1283048838376999,
-0.018469003960490227,
0.48192182183265686,
0.08575534075498581,
-0.32038554549217224
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10296v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10296v2
|
CLST: Cold-Start Mitigation in Knowledge Tracing by Aligning a Generative Language Model as a Students' Knowledge Tracer
| 2024-06-13T09:21:43 | 2024-06-18T00:53:50 |
Heeseok Jung, Jaesang Yoo, Yohaan Yoon, Yeonju Jang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Knowledge tracing (KT), wherein students' problem-solving histories are used
to estimate their current levels of knowledge, has attracted significant
interest from researchers. However, most existing KT models were developed with
an ID-based paradigm, which exhibits limitations in cold-start performance.
These limitations can be mitigated by leveraging the vast quantities of
external knowledge possessed by generative large language models (LLMs). In
this study, we propose cold-start mitigation in knowledge tracing by aligning a
generative language model as a students' knowledge tracer (CLST) as a framework
that utilizes a generative LLM as a knowledge tracer. Upon collecting data from
math, social studies, and science subjects, we framed the KT task as a natural
language processing task, wherein problem-solving data are expressed in natural
language, and fine-tuned the generative LLM using the formatted KT dataset.
Subsequently, we evaluated the performance of the CLST in situations of data
scarcity using various baseline models for comparison. The results indicate
that the CLST significantly enhanced performance with a dataset of fewer than
100 students in terms of prediction, reliability, and cross-domain
generalization.
|
[
-0.26073944568634033,
-0.736415684223175,
0.38572031259536743,
-0.21167241036891937,
-0.3077909052371979,
0.4703013002872467,
-0.3090701103210449,
-0.08600690215826035,
-0.23013631999492645,
0.2922550439834595,
-0.4787231385707855,
-0.536892831325531,
-0.24725347757339478,
-0.3056390881538391,
-0.4731636047363281,
1.0977545976638794,
0.0380026176571846,
-0.13284829258918762,
-0.8310642242431641,
0.16775743663311005,
-0.7413011193275452,
-0.43320587277412415,
-0.7629911303520203,
-0.2953496277332306,
0.18278269469738007,
0.7227584719657898,
0.5013322830200195,
0.7484574913978577,
0.3447364568710327,
0.13973172008991241,
0.11561299860477448,
-0.376530259847641,
-0.666083037853241,
0.36664119362831116,
-0.2935980558395386,
-0.3821626901626587,
-0.12535053491592407,
-0.4699088931083679,
0.5185206532478333,
0.7035938501358032,
-0.10896788537502289,
0.23809492588043213,
0.34069883823394775,
0.7654129266738892,
-0.5785701274871826,
0.16525433957576752,
-0.42007848620414734,
-0.26083651185035706,
-0.2951975166797638,
0.19140790402889252,
-0.24102789163589478,
-0.418281614780426,
0.6555734276771545,
-0.7452303767204285,
0.5880821347236633,
-0.2675008177757263,
0.7293978929519653,
0.237407386302948,
-0.32769516110420227,
-0.244442418217659,
-0.9344332814216614,
0.7472968101501465,
-0.6232816576957703,
0.3115290701389313,
0.34098750352859497,
0.3887398838996887,
0.2739364802837372,
-0.42044907808303833,
-0.34494414925575256,
0.16297821700572968,
-0.0486639179289341,
0.23658443987369537,
-0.06302863359451294,
-0.2072179913520813,
0.2743898332118988,
0.10861961543560028,
-0.7442543506622314,
0.19654226303100586,
-0.7817651629447937,
-0.46744412183761597,
0.3082510232925415,
0.4058707654476166,
0.203907310962677,
0.16902315616607666,
-0.7401490807533264,
0.02049342356622219,
-0.5734306573867798,
-0.16912035644054413,
0.04842958226799965,
0.4889836609363556,
-0.23835061490535736,
0.42863163352012634,
-0.3337508738040924,
0.7544994354248047,
-0.30188170075416565,
-0.3493700921535492,
-0.27988895773887634,
-0.4957020580768585,
-0.04539082571864128,
0.14995044469833374,
0.2366514652967453,
0.18506713211536407,
0.36322370171546936,
-0.2919084429740906,
-0.09500230103731155,
0.29164445400238037,
-0.1873760223388672,
-0.9175118207931519,
-0.7889906167984009,
-0.22643913328647614,
-0.03716551512479782,
0.0181275624781847,
-0.3627817630767822,
-0.9147108197212219,
-0.42234930396080017,
-0.5655818581581116,
0.22242048382759094,
-0.6923786997795105,
-0.28015851974487305,
-0.0707147940993309,
-0.02221456728875637,
0.21122534573078156,
0.42826300859451294,
-0.3963499665260315,
0.44761744141578674,
0.39806145429611206,
1.0804373025894165,
-0.2252759039402008,
0.08997557312250137,
0.05273522809147835,
0.41163957118988037,
0.1365254670381546,
0.6518344879150391,
-0.414152055978775,
-0.35251960158348083,
-0.06751152127981186,
-0.4563961923122406,
-0.010328908450901508,
-0.23609641194343567,
0.37937167286872864,
-0.5306488275527954,
0.195851668715477,
-0.46168532967567444,
-0.9056115746498108,
-0.021706383675336838,
0.230302631855011,
-0.6295843720436096,
0.9475691318511963,
0.08099536597728729,
-0.92768794298172,
0.20400263369083405,
-0.5171464681625366,
-0.5713316798210144,
0.5243564248085022,
-0.009025364182889462,
-0.3447573482990265,
-0.3899751901626587,
0.05948982760310173,
0.4402313232421875,
-0.5164154171943665,
0.3071509301662445,
0.031934335827827454,
-0.3403744101524353,
-0.14155267179012299,
-0.12739665806293488,
0.9157726168632507,
0.16608402132987976,
-0.4213807284832001,
-0.15961778163909912,
-0.7897003889083862,
0.04783518612384796,
0.2012632191181183,
-0.3252691328525543,
-0.8853988647460938,
-0.21166111528873444,
-0.060297489166259766,
0.23472367227077484,
0.2665627598762512,
-0.4025633633136749,
0.15813829004764557,
-0.17877082526683807,
0.17945246398448944,
0.9906631708145142,
-0.23619070649147034,
0.4350530803203583,
-0.2969455420970917,
0.7761186957359314,
0.10153172165155411,
-0.38407838344573975,
-0.20186209678649902,
-0.3870536684989929,
-0.9693872928619385,
-0.338766485452652,
0.22920745611190796,
0.6003099679946899,
-1.027586817741394,
-0.16012783348560333,
-0.22176231443881989,
-0.5784505009651184,
-0.4310608506202698,
0.3238544464111328,
0.5793645977973938,
0.7549318671226501,
0.375171959400177,
-0.10283499211072922,
-0.6003361940383911,
-0.6596673727035522,
-0.3155493438243866,
0.04656698927283287,
0.019393209367990494,
0.2503357529640198,
0.42284315824508667,
0.33822762966156006,
1.365759015083313,
-0.83675616979599,
-0.4242090880870819,
-0.31539326906204224,
-0.009531906805932522,
-0.0504089780151844,
0.7608485817909241,
0.15133389830589294,
-0.5649849772453308,
-0.7028385400772095,
-0.20653454959392548,
-0.5284662246704102,
-0.05340747535228729,
-0.053160157054662704,
-0.21889927983283997,
0.1624758243560791,
0.47535961866378784,
-0.7117536067962646,
0.5295446515083313,
0.3207823932170868,
-0.7059118151664734,
0.6332549452781677,
0.038926489651203156,
-0.3592073619365692,
-1.1373275518417358,
0.4031430184841156,
-0.04278060793876648,
0.12918701767921448,
-0.6523377895355225,
-0.11912021785974503,
0.05365424230694771,
-0.4685465395450592,
-0.26403486728668213,
0.7802706956863403,
-0.5789145827293396,
0.2348925769329071,
-0.17936977744102478,
0.3365529775619507,
-0.08103085309267044,
0.1873016506433487,
-0.0387110635638237,
0.6459774374961853,
0.6502599716186523,
-0.6820270419120789,
0.3061496317386627,
-0.05682489648461342,
-0.32784152030944824,
0.8581045866012573,
-0.42790377140045166,
0.4013339877128601,
-0.18235273659229279,
0.17431190609931946,
-0.7449817061424255,
0.044586557894945145,
-0.006514582317322493,
-0.31874212622642517,
0.10414423048496246,
-0.3953535258769989,
-0.5171331763267517,
-0.3225204646587372,
0.18321257829666138,
0.7046595811843872,
0.6571190357208252,
-0.3610190749168396,
0.3805066645145416,
-0.26525548100471497,
-0.11849037557840347,
-0.3258956968784332,
-0.15313825011253357,
-0.10268434137105942,
-0.38141393661499023,
-0.6785222291946411,
0.08496645838022232,
-0.331552654504776,
-0.13655441999435425,
0.22129301726818085,
-0.16545604169368744,
-0.11405576020479202,
0.37580862641334534,
0.03089168854057789,
0.4152071475982666,
-0.4585101306438446,
0.5199353694915771,
-0.172051340341568,
-0.1528553068637848,
0.07224299013614655,
-0.46947064995765686,
0.7834503054618835,
0.08502060174942017,
-0.08631934225559235,
-0.22810021042823792,
0.11427880078554153,
0.45751309394836426,
-0.1750415563583374,
0.8171877861022949,
0.417252779006958,
-0.48524996638298035,
-0.43485718965530396,
-0.6685358285903931,
-0.5111257433891296,
-0.4055536091327667,
0.10774780064821243,
-0.193050816655159,
-0.8528681993484497,
0.5166418552398682,
-0.022052036598324776,
-0.0606645904481411,
0.23594701290130615,
0.23188646137714386,
0.04606274142861366,
0.43611782789230347,
0.7943466901779175,
-0.36898863315582275,
0.16971862316131592,
-0.2036258727312088,
0.2804940640926361,
-0.5554037094116211,
-0.2767055332660675,
-0.5921690464019775,
-0.22503086924552917,
-0.19093631207942963,
-0.3086065649986267,
0.25837627053260803,
0.25585222244262695,
-0.3530634939670563,
0.23483166098594666,
-0.28248852491378784,
0.659927248954773,
0.7273755073547363,
0.04101499542593956,
0.396087110042572,
-0.07291202992200851,
-0.21700048446655273,
-0.03435986489057541,
-0.9002050161361694,
-0.20210710167884827,
1.3552645444869995,
0.03842197731137276,
0.8087157607078552,
0.034639086574316025,
0.5694718360900879,
0.02762014791369438,
0.4387328326702118,
-0.612852156162262,
0.6500349044799805,
-0.1388915777206421,
-0.6954452991485596,
-0.37936243414878845,
-0.490369975566864,
-0.667949914932251,
0.145160511136055,
0.13131442666053772,
-0.6696026921272278,
-0.27350425720214844,
0.3364499807357788,
-0.3103160560131073,
0.4854634702205658,
-0.6968072056770325,
0.7756962776184082,
-0.060010332614183426,
-0.6215309500694275,
-0.04869033023715019,
-0.5685445070266724,
0.6798357367515564,
-0.13630786538124084,
0.14945468306541443,
-0.10410016030073166,
0.3080291748046875,
1.001240611076355,
-0.3548259735107422,
1.1996005773544312,
-0.4050253927707672,
-0.0407685823738575,
0.4350021481513977,
0.27067869901657104,
0.6047569513320923,
-0.10801622271537781,
0.12080901861190796,
-0.12643589079380035,
-0.056358516216278076,
-0.7226670980453491,
-0.4068402051925659,
0.8547374606132507,
-0.5172242522239685,
-0.7690443992614746,
-0.346617728471756,
-0.7773052453994751,
-0.13258180022239685,
0.41707736253738403,
0.1580042690038681,
0.26241883635520935,
-0.09914939850568771,
0.08613502979278564,
0.8997824192047119,
0.05256851017475128,
0.4394610822200775,
0.8184121251106262,
-0.02154172584414482,
-0.17609496414661407,
1.1702018976211548,
0.2170996069908142,
0.5894936323165894,
-0.019552020356059074,
0.4354710280895233,
-0.008528913371264935,
-0.32082417607307434,
-0.4148489534854889,
0.23163363337516785,
-0.8499476313591003,
-0.6682550311088562,
-0.4858516752719879,
-0.20067915320396423,
-0.42461487650871277,
-0.48259949684143066,
-0.200282022356987,
-0.329915314912796,
-0.500367283821106,
-0.017782192677259445,
0.47050726413726807,
0.28864553570747375,
0.0845663771033287,
0.37993600964546204,
-0.42520248889923096,
0.09702146053314209,
0.23759718239307404,
0.35968413949012756,
0.26029983162879944,
-0.30820128321647644,
-0.5072459578514099,
-0.0006179358460940421,
-0.2334633320569992,
-0.6243466138839722,
0.3244560956954956,
0.13482218980789185,
0.1708298772573471,
0.5005730390548706,
0.48288434743881226,
0.799362063407898,
0.04840199276804924,
0.6300811767578125,
0.24018612504005432,
-0.9405789375305176,
0.658196747303009,
-0.2983390688896179,
0.8463712334632874,
0.3111639618873596,
0.37623459100723267,
-0.4656056761741638,
-0.6011448502540588,
-0.5679312944412231,
-0.9991416335105896,
0.5475433468818665,
0.12376958876848221,
-0.11714877188205719,
0.280203640460968,
0.11869114637374878,
0.15312713384628296,
0.02565445378422737,
-0.42168039083480835,
-0.192313089966774,
-0.36726438999176025,
-0.17123578488826752,
-0.11980590969324112,
-0.1413477510213852,
-0.12770946323871613,
-0.3088349401950836,
0.6701859831809998,
-0.25736409425735474,
-0.05799331143498421,
0.05268295481801033,
-0.20682930946350098,
0.05259084701538086,
0.35798972845077515,
0.6298556923866272,
0.7889914512634277,
-0.07269873470067978,
0.33645132184028625,
0.0618625283241272,
-0.5259569883346558,
-0.003828416345641017,
0.08247089385986328,
-0.7041868567466736,
-0.09767499566078186,
0.1896074265241623,
0.38300132751464844,
0.23578576743602753,
-0.7833271622657776,
0.21568983793258667,
0.4078832268714905,
0.07495412975549698,
-0.4529499113559723,
-0.13692116737365723,
0.3994928002357483,
0.03181616589426994,
0.3632645308971405,
-0.153884619474411,
-0.08759185671806335,
-0.13766886293888092,
0.2323436737060547,
0.4790722727775574,
-0.3074912130832672,
-0.423875629901886,
0.4136928617954254,
0.20359858870506287,
-0.015748856589198112,
1.0671906471252441,
0.07695046067237854,
-0.7299624085426331,
0.9985395669937134,
1.0342336893081665,
0.6594561338424683,
-0.4311055541038513,
0.18571129441261292,
0.5950817465782166,
0.2614412307739258,
0.0019270385382696986,
0.23483462631702423,
-0.07694831490516663,
-0.6412524580955505,
-0.16392508149147034,
-0.5078262686729431,
0.0372316874563694,
0.1476203203201294,
-0.8033376336097717,
0.21262520551681519,
-0.42942869663238525,
0.0908065065741539,
-0.41617751121520996,
-0.051782652735710144,
-1.1679407358169556,
0.24517226219177246,
-0.11804872006177902,
0.7733580470085144,
-0.9611015319824219,
0.8913335800170898,
0.5300837755203247,
-0.133544921875,
-0.697533369064331,
-0.04915488138794899,
0.182167649269104,
-0.7429795861244202,
1.0206072330474854,
0.03377362713217735,
-0.11259643733501434,
0.39241743087768555,
-0.44876956939697266,
-1.071170449256897,
1.3884752988815308,
0.11242631077766418,
-0.6556795239448547,
0.03131401538848877,
0.2643527090549469,
0.45643898844718933,
-0.16175568103790283,
-0.21537744998931885,
0.5888442993164062,
0.307175874710083,
0.21335773169994354,
-0.8156993389129639,
0.4817204773426056,
0.04117175191640854,
-0.17753581702709198,
0.4262886643409729,
-0.522125780582428,
0.8015516400337219,
-0.44293317198753357,
-0.7194912433624268,
0.03476256877183914,
0.5735702514648438,
0.12329710274934769,
0.6547367572784424,
0.26917871832847595,
0.9020106196403503,
0.7253178954124451,
0.006628504488617182,
0.5422067642211914,
-0.24519936740398407,
0.3943716883659363,
1.1798902750015259,
-0.1356353759765625,
0.49524351954460144,
0.6036502718925476,
0.004662419203668833,
0.29458656907081604,
0.08497229218482971,
-0.029827669262886047,
0.5573556423187256,
0.6703333258628845,
-0.49018505215644836,
-0.27946534752845764,
-0.258455365896225,
-0.3959190845489502,
0.2395297735929489,
0.40468916296958923,
-0.09231176972389221,
-0.5086431503295898,
0.10794578492641449,
0.4309905469417572,
-0.04138554632663727,
-0.356045126914978,
0.6393304467201233,
-0.04398086667060852,
-0.4006637632846832,
0.6125491857528687,
-0.21279649436473846,
0.4794822633266449,
-0.4055391848087311,
-0.05132560059428215,
-0.6430371999740601,
0.18333454430103302,
-0.002235925057902932,
-0.4013012945652008,
0.006641124375164509,
0.03557412326335907,
-0.2096562683582306,
-0.20606952905654907,
0.8716645836830139,
-0.5782726407051086,
-0.6817367076873779,
0.08492843061685562,
0.6101236939430237,
-0.06692969799041748,
0.15446120500564575,
-0.2286211997270584,
-0.1302967369556427,
-0.12361859530210495,
0.046436041593551636,
0.4880799353122711,
0.33242836594581604,
-0.21876764297485352,
1.0401716232299805,
0.8011936545372009,
-0.16806896030902863,
0.16577191650867462,
-0.31902992725372314,
1.0538513660430908,
-0.7055600881576538,
-0.4418003559112549,
-0.9482008814811707,
0.5403125286102295,
-0.0008594595128670335,
-0.33933475613594055,
0.8630420565605164,
0.856377899646759,
1.007086992263794,
-0.07675626128911972,
0.9727923274040222,
-0.09603792428970337,
0.6622547507286072,
-0.5455912947654724,
0.7406678199768066,
0.016661228612065315,
0.47530046105384827,
-0.29922667145729065,
-0.7566879391670227,
-0.0717366561293602,
0.07378653436899185,
-0.21971696615219116,
-0.13034863770008087,
0.6523226499557495,
0.4759437143802643,
-0.10835762321949005,
-0.1955714225769043,
0.3281436264514923,
0.1647125631570816,
0.3762986361980438,
0.7259505987167358,
0.6836771965026855,
-0.06481466442346573,
0.6738454103469849,
-0.5835267305374146,
-0.2114982008934021,
-0.09641170501708984,
-0.7091694474220276,
-1.0339665412902832,
-0.6291635632514954,
-0.4376527667045593,
-0.4747687876224518,
0.2112334966659546,
0.1879866123199463,
0.37268349528312683,
-0.6211462020874023,
-0.29494649171829224,
-0.12656451761722565,
0.27001452445983887,
-0.2287169247865677,
-0.3798362910747528,
0.7318759560585022,
-0.3079225420951843,
-0.1711437702178955,
0.2572016417980194,
-0.2799822986125946,
0.2502923011779785,
-0.40577128529548645,
-0.05211359262466431,
-0.024572813883423805,
-0.11833719164133072,
0.43407484889030457,
0.4591250717639923,
-0.6303662061691284,
-0.21451807022094727,
0.19886402785778046,
0.0427096001803875,
-0.2043163776397705,
1.2830727100372314,
-1.1048672199249268,
0.48632580041885376,
0.24035167694091797,
0.5952093005180359,
0.5051640868186951,
0.11199625581502914,
0.5274074673652649,
-0.6381219029426575,
-0.20231376588344574,
0.40401753783226013,
-0.09765256196260452,
0.3785375952720642,
-0.3841341435909271,
0.2560611069202423,
0.6258733868598938,
-0.277470201253891,
-0.7787471413612366,
0.17816174030303955,
-0.7248782515525818,
-0.36390945315361023,
0.917608916759491,
-0.3305363357067108,
0.28928810358047485,
-0.4856739938259125,
0.010087290778756142,
0.2617129683494568,
-0.4171901345252991,
0.9897091388702393,
0.7684550881385803,
0.21599949896335602,
-0.3162301778793335,
-0.6838390827178955,
0.5450236201286316,
0.5819329023361206,
-0.8578498363494873,
0.18210138380527496,
0.3835175931453705,
0.5751194357872009,
-0.0072038318030536175,
0.4516378343105316,
0.38214707374572754,
-0.03182050585746765,
-0.20713438093662262,
0.04888476803898811,
-0.012307603843510151,
-0.23165728151798248,
0.07842174917459488,
0.2917236387729645,
-0.21676740050315857,
-0.010708213783800602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08940v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08940v1
|
Word Order in English-Japanese Simultaneous Interpretation: Analyses and Evaluation using Chunk-wise Monotonic Translation
| 2024-06-13T09:10:16 | 2024-06-13T09:10:16 |
Kosuke Doi, Yuka Ko, Mana Makinae, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper analyzes the features of monotonic translations, which follow the
word order of the source language, in simultaneous interpreting (SI). The word
order differences are one of the biggest challenges in SI, especially for
language pairs with significant structural differences like English and
Japanese. We analyzed the characteristics of monotonic translations using the
NAIST English-to-Japanese Chunk-wise Monotonic Translation Evaluation Dataset
and found some grammatical structures that make monotonic translation difficult
in English-Japanese SI. We further investigated the features of monotonic
translations through evaluating the output from the existing speech translation
(ST) and simultaneous speech translation (simulST) models on NAIST
English-to-Japanese Chunk-wise Monotonic Translation Evaluation Dataset as well
as on existing test sets. The results suggest that the existing SI-based test
set underestimates the model performance. We also found that the
monotonic-translation-based dataset would better evaluate simulST models, while
using an offline-based test set for evaluating simulST models underestimates
the model performance.
|
[
-0.25560522079467773,
-0.6134507060050964,
0.4280048608779907,
0.5748544335365295,
-0.8489934206008911,
-0.05182654783129692,
-0.1077931672334671,
-0.7946212887763977,
0.3108714520931244,
0.38104158639907837,
-0.6112428307533264,
-0.12433192878961563,
-0.8170610666275024,
0.32619109749794006,
-0.3979247510433197,
0.9391373991966248,
-0.1895838975906372,
0.5666362643241882,
-0.13523073494434357,
-0.5752304196357727,
-0.6080119609832764,
-0.1983138769865036,
-0.7102962732315063,
-0.10622134804725647,
-0.00006893101817695424,
0.22366434335708618,
1.2415845394134521,
0.7639572620391846,
0.5700034499168396,
0.39806312322616577,
-0.09718044847249985,
-0.20309039950370789,
-0.39392757415771484,
0.006366950925439596,
0.12194107472896576,
-0.3408950865268707,
-0.46947482228279114,
-0.12933076918125153,
0.7374173402786255,
0.9341537952423096,
0.11306335777044296,
0.27818772196769714,
0.06109379976987839,
0.3730899691581726,
-0.16806654632091522,
0.16452845931053162,
-0.3747769594192505,
0.12330711632966995,
-0.34110963344573975,
-0.36618807911872864,
-0.40891849994659424,
-0.1820686310529709,
0.4600563943386078,
-0.6008168458938599,
-0.08241339027881622,
0.30010971426963806,
0.8475974202156067,
0.4235919415950775,
-0.37651941180229187,
-0.3548597991466522,
-0.49304288625717163,
0.9774104952812195,
-0.7375160455703735,
0.4154318869113922,
0.06059901788830757,
0.05138678848743439,
-0.005157520063221455,
-0.49461281299591064,
-0.15859203040599823,
-0.2134377509355545,
-0.07724742591381073,
0.47076094150543213,
0.27441897988319397,
0.13423916697502136,
0.07063702493906021,
0.5411470532417297,
-0.8139350414276123,
0.13907621800899506,
-0.45926132798194885,
0.16506165266036987,
0.9518667459487915,
0.2927437722682953,
0.52447110414505,
-0.4848431646823883,
-0.7111772298812866,
-0.2139565795660019,
-0.14056235551834106,
-0.11567723751068115,
0.2267066389322281,
0.3973790407180786,
-0.23451238870620728,
0.6014049053192139,
-0.1618938446044922,
0.4600367546081543,
-0.34512972831726074,
-0.4356498718261719,
0.46117937564849854,
-0.8187452554702759,
-0.18154817819595337,
0.4526312053203583,
0.8975539803504944,
0.23721376061439514,
0.3556722402572632,
0.04185173287987709,
-0.1048429012298584,
0.050265971571207047,
-0.0531819611787796,
-0.6412005424499512,
0.3660306930541992,
0.18431253731250763,
-0.5694119930267334,
-0.38674047589302063,
0.17071248590946198,
-0.8596301674842834,
-0.13248486816883087,
-0.2758699357509613,
0.4065174162387848,
-0.42121610045433044,
-0.29221513867378235,
0.48154932260513306,
-0.07104495912790298,
-0.010904289782047272,
0.2599623203277588,
-0.318752646446228,
0.72251296043396,
0.6091293096542358,
0.936161458492279,
-0.3409912884235382,
-0.7640440464019775,
0.04279801994562149,
-0.20739556849002838,
-0.14433978497982025,
0.4680454432964325,
-0.43318498134613037,
-0.5416986346244812,
-0.5854787826538086,
-0.24189268052577972,
-0.25741732120513916,
-0.18291321396827698,
0.46700507402420044,
-0.13271509110927582,
0.3460748493671417,
0.09778457134962082,
-0.5274995565414429,
-0.09840027987957001,
-0.28336820006370544,
-0.5117873549461365,
0.8828908205032349,
-0.2048916220664978,
-1.0024610757827759,
0.27435919642448425,
-0.680915892124176,
-0.6083540916442871,
0.2665913999080658,
-0.1857825666666031,
-0.14715048670768738,
0.25138482451438904,
0.054977498948574066,
0.06067119911313057,
-0.22002388536930084,
0.24779924750328064,
-0.29075244069099426,
-0.4366799294948578,
0.19802190363407135,
-0.7419686317443848,
0.873218297958374,
0.34347203373908997,
-0.2865142226219177,
-0.051225122064352036,
-0.7601987719535828,
0.12635888159275055,
0.49718350172042847,
-0.039226796478033066,
-0.8104318380355835,
0.43329623341560364,
0.04273885488510132,
0.12876182794570923,
0.3973791301250458,
-0.43598225712776184,
0.02279023826122284,
-0.3263274133205414,
0.04032992571592331,
0.7010462880134583,
0.27021661400794983,
0.2089630514383316,
0.03507212549448013,
0.6264742016792297,
0.1886022537946701,
0.36563730239868164,
-0.16800060868263245,
-0.7925209403038025,
-0.45919105410575867,
-0.1769929975271225,
0.3494604527950287,
0.7736707329750061,
-0.528859555721283,
0.12462320178747177,
-0.5782208442687988,
-0.4515446722507477,
-0.9095068573951721,
-0.2613821029663086,
0.5481895208358765,
0.08628946542739868,
0.46262046694755554,
-0.48732686042785645,
-0.3408046066761017,
-0.775855541229248,
-0.4171210527420044,
-0.14609062671661377,
0.3510136306285858,
-0.22325310111045837,
0.37782877683639526,
0.29954490065574646,
0.26536762714385986,
-0.46119049191474915,
0.3732883930206299,
-0.23760747909545898,
0.6001953482627869,
0.12157781422138214,
0.3333686888217926,
0.26260972023010254,
-1.0709580183029175,
-0.4592147767543793,
0.10467606037855148,
-0.565114438533783,
-0.13610544800758362,
-0.22185270488262177,
-0.011719519272446632,
-0.14012853801250458,
0.3172037601470947,
-0.3185902535915375,
0.729224681854248,
0.4489511549472809,
-0.32415571808815,
0.5771534442901611,
-0.20448169112205505,
0.43025442957878113,
-1.3845510482788086,
-0.17236343026161194,
-0.07194957882165909,
-0.43603190779685974,
-0.745168924331665,
0.4242025315761566,
-0.1315528005361557,
-0.1394239366054535,
-0.4039197862148285,
0.3840498626232147,
-0.6067084670066833,
-0.3017626702785492,
-0.10391825437545776,
0.19193634390830994,
-0.08502703160047531,
0.1717929095029831,
0.17588788270950317,
0.7296466827392578,
0.3121189773082733,
-0.5172565579414368,
0.01065041683614254,
0.30381226539611816,
-0.6102424263954163,
0.3778432607650757,
-0.5381466150283813,
-0.008906691335141659,
-0.13644306361675262,
-0.25714433193206787,
-1.0843794345855713,
-0.02972191758453846,
0.06233028694987297,
-0.43986326456069946,
0.5130466222763062,
0.0447244793176651,
-0.5232780575752258,
-0.3143104612827301,
-0.35095664858818054,
0.4907412827014923,
0.27641406655311584,
-0.11112173646688461,
-0.3090093731880188,
0.2523912489414215,
-0.603520393371582,
-0.5644435286521912,
-0.7249752283096313,
-0.25767844915390015,
-0.09762389957904816,
-0.5502434372901917,
0.21190831065177917,
-0.16978606581687927,
-0.3945063650608063,
0.012696019373834133,
-0.4543576240539551,
-0.11298633366823196,
0.2684454023838043,
0.019858237355947495,
0.46275824308395386,
-0.6272836327552795,
-0.2785738408565521,
0.3152935802936554,
-0.10289649665355682,
-0.13346344232559204,
0.005448819138109684,
0.3842853009700775,
-0.016933657228946686,
-0.330070436000824,
-0.2950052320957184,
0.4090631902217865,
0.9974871277809143,
-0.19128085672855377,
0.7604471445083618,
0.12064874172210693,
-0.09709550440311432,
0.11973083019256592,
-0.23082758486270905,
0.17160874605178833,
-0.3965058922767639,
0.4594353139400482,
-0.7260765433311462,
-0.46944907307624817,
0.37361443042755127,
0.17861029505729675,
0.1777394562959671,
0.3314194977283478,
0.35172703862190247,
0.039493899792432785,
1.4332526922225952,
0.19035454094409943,
-0.19301925599575043,
0.4071654975414276,
0.2572486102581024,
0.13112343847751617,
-0.4857936203479767,
0.2571527063846588,
-0.4785017669200897,
-0.36399921774864197,
-0.7632626891136169,
-0.08306194841861725,
0.40604180097579956,
0.07778451591730118,
0.30140581727027893,
0.46093833446502686,
-0.3342950940132141,
0.5854558944702148,
0.03283947706222534,
-0.08744951337575912,
0.589546799659729,
0.021050354465842247,
-0.2488866001367569,
-0.2508867383003235,
-0.4981800615787506,
-0.2971635162830353,
0.7013970613479614,
0.2416052520275116,
0.5107486844062805,
-0.13988175988197327,
0.5876888036727905,
-0.04527802765369415,
-0.07148035615682602,
-0.8304333686828613,
0.7214964628219604,
-0.429191529750824,
-0.5586528182029724,
-0.41832971572875977,
-0.6659473180770874,
-0.9794572591781616,
0.6666455864906311,
0.05352472886443138,
-0.6727536916732788,
0.07099885493516922,
-0.4264177680015564,
-0.14573952555656433,
0.01957082748413086,
-0.9097029566764832,
1.0328500270843506,
-0.5815089344978333,
-0.04563198983669281,
-0.2760660648345947,
-0.6537466049194336,
0.35049065947532654,
0.051570747047662735,
0.46836838126182556,
-0.0678524523973465,
-0.11662521958351135,
0.6077861785888672,
-0.5264822244644165,
0.14997157454490662,
-0.09182142466306686,
0.2207898646593094,
0.028552427887916565,
0.2652471661567688,
0.08280663192272186,
-0.005628054495900869,
-0.3591613173484802,
0.28522324562072754,
0.4795095920562744,
-0.591739296913147,
-0.4049534499645233,
0.5377079844474792,
-0.7559820413589478,
-0.3121948540210724,
-0.4781615138053894,
-0.8152710795402527,
-0.003950448241084814,
0.38616377115249634,
0.6905605792999268,
0.5948444604873657,
-0.15148665010929108,
-0.1317470669746399,
0.17882183194160461,
0.05895795673131943,
0.2842659652233124,
0.537808358669281,
-0.5130486488342285,
-0.2826412320137024,
0.8201013803482056,
0.6595507264137268,
0.6417850255966187,
0.19502326846122742,
0.20063577592372894,
-0.26202452182769775,
-0.8008719086647034,
-0.479230672121048,
0.3903120756149292,
-0.4538489580154419,
0.30799049139022827,
-0.22929134964942932,
-0.14136137068271637,
-0.47792723774909973,
0.009032584726810455,
-0.569920003414154,
-0.5312283039093018,
0.13424570858478546,
0.13141748309135437,
-0.1281510889530182,
0.8502543568611145,
0.4522894322872162,
0.06424420326948166,
-0.7412403225898743,
0.3554002642631531,
-0.3196863532066345,
0.11140120029449463,
-0.2768807113170624,
-0.5857303738594055,
-0.17694330215454102,
0.037976738065481186,
0.020005913451313972,
-1.1173536777496338,
0.3235459327697754,
-0.23058432340621948,
0.2354712337255478,
0.3545229732990265,
-0.08090756833553314,
1.4273664951324463,
-0.49224019050598145,
0.5388170480728149,
0.10505036264657974,
-0.9889865517616272,
0.4806302785873413,
-0.08829790353775024,
0.5915639996528625,
0.9797054529190063,
0.5345394015312195,
-0.6000383496284485,
-0.6233764290809631,
-0.6875566244125366,
-0.9522170424461365,
0.9523979425430298,
0.3747236132621765,
-0.22636589407920837,
0.1261196881532669,
0.11840172857046127,
0.28869810700416565,
0.2577948570251465,
-0.6853878498077393,
-0.42895814776420593,
0.038748983293771744,
-0.26437368988990784,
-0.16703738272190094,
0.07071475684642792,
0.4018271267414093,
-0.4216133654117584,
0.5903705358505249,
0.1569855958223343,
0.03331850841641426,
0.2929585874080658,
-0.3483875095844269,
-0.2947441041469574,
0.3920236825942993,
0.5748064517974854,
0.5308428406715393,
-0.2522391378879547,
-0.0884442999958992,
0.35820502042770386,
-0.4151509404182434,
0.05365433171391487,
0.14224845170974731,
-0.3868771195411682,
0.37677517533302307,
0.34048306941986084,
1.005375862121582,
0.7053768038749695,
-0.4324529767036438,
0.4825902581214905,
-0.019234124571084976,
0.1979009509086609,
-0.12278256565332413,
-0.29568737745285034,
-0.035294461995363235,
-0.21162758767604828,
-0.038434967398643494,
0.2249642014503479,
0.3200019896030426,
-0.5628050565719604,
-0.052861180156469345,
0.183473140001297,
-0.10997128486633301,
-0.4287925958633423,
0.30021563172340393,
-0.23640291392803192,
-0.13211771845817566,
0.4578604996204376,
-0.4580704867839813,
-0.5425854921340942,
0.5805434584617615,
0.6557206511497498,
0.6121927499771118,
-0.5840566158294678,
0.05355371907353401,
0.3013949692249298,
0.5210860967636108,
-0.35951587557792664,
0.45196297764778137,
-0.07166659832000732,
-0.4649389684200287,
-0.4216667711734772,
-0.5652307868003845,
-0.5372377038002014,
0.13181175291538239,
-1.2237142324447632,
0.5439012050628662,
-0.2301124632358551,
0.07706189155578613,
0.29715293645858765,
-0.09862859547138214,
-0.16033688187599182,
-0.017430806532502174,
0.19749820232391357,
0.8296067118644714,
-0.78202885389328,
0.7930295467376709,
1.0036115646362305,
-0.4070943593978882,
-0.6709044575691223,
0.08124048262834549,
0.18594789505004883,
-0.6872225999832153,
0.06911562383174896,
0.22804871201515198,
-0.11014104634523392,
0.11948832869529724,
-0.34474313259124756,
-0.9430645108222961,
0.9445122480392456,
0.2833736538887024,
-0.24908378720283508,
-0.16017809510231018,
0.3929561674594879,
0.6276106834411621,
-0.07688513398170471,
0.43245288729667664,
0.3836444616317749,
0.549169659614563,
-0.08820941299200058,
-1.126680850982666,
-0.11076825857162476,
-0.27380046248435974,
0.082185760140419,
0.6030365228652954,
-0.6732329726219177,
0.5959235429763794,
0.2914228141307831,
-0.6997441649436951,
0.12493631988763809,
0.4817212224006653,
0.06094079092144966,
0.4686184823513031,
0.6404712200164795,
0.5437368750572205,
0.5303199887275696,
0.06951311975717545,
1.2618682384490967,
-0.16401158273220062,
0.46201613545417786,
1.292223334312439,
-0.4392417371273041,
0.9869601726531982,
0.5918369889259338,
-0.47100383043289185,
0.13649648427963257,
0.3736324906349182,
0.14799289405345917,
0.3829757273197174,
-0.05799279734492302,
0.01814885064959526,
0.016620678827166557,
0.09062795341014862,
-0.35502806305885315,
0.4372210204601288,
0.28208908438682556,
-0.12149227410554886,
-0.22170811891555786,
0.23756662011146545,
0.30327296257019043,
-0.16992680728435516,
-0.23229865729808807,
0.6780756115913391,
0.23965193331241608,
-0.8554490208625793,
0.5301194190979004,
0.1015462726354599,
0.6074244976043701,
-0.828910768032074,
0.35371825098991394,
-0.23956578969955444,
0.03329145163297653,
-0.13752195239067078,
-0.7040999531745911,
0.43203991651535034,
0.10716693848371506,
0.09722833335399628,
-0.2921125888824463,
0.451815128326416,
-0.46070703864097595,
-0.5082666873931885,
0.5950282216072083,
0.4559551775455475,
0.5628523230552673,
0.27079659700393677,
-0.9961273670196533,
0.04336800426244736,
0.02168651670217514,
-0.5780858993530273,
0.24919438362121582,
0.23726288974285126,
-0.09109462797641754,
0.29802221059799194,
0.3695044219493866,
0.36861351132392883,
0.553092360496521,
0.06652528792619705,
0.16287869215011597,
-0.45871132612228394,
-0.5145397186279297,
-0.8716398477554321,
0.4334430396556854,
-0.07195238769054413,
-0.3496558964252472,
0.8085829019546509,
0.5583060383796692,
1.0058096647262573,
0.011747109703719616,
0.48944732546806335,
-0.09690529853105545,
0.29212480783462524,
-0.4044862389564514,
0.491136759519577,
-0.792019248008728,
-0.016411738470196724,
-0.4280535876750946,
-0.8994314074516296,
-0.19363492727279663,
0.3926083743572235,
-0.3027150332927704,
-0.23112109303474426,
1.2440919876098633,
0.6636036038398743,
-0.4073999226093292,
0.4983367919921875,
0.5832161903381348,
0.5567447543144226,
-0.47873207926750183,
0.4035130441188812,
0.7345801591873169,
-0.7728511095046997,
0.38109302520751953,
-0.4721315801143646,
-0.07755112648010254,
0.1128305047750473,
-0.41235053539276123,
-0.3362753689289093,
-0.49878400564193726,
-0.5287387371063232,
-0.19350150227546692,
-0.11202803999185562,
1.0017507076263428,
0.4781697392463684,
-0.8570627570152283,
-0.6153134703636169,
-0.08944083750247955,
0.053233690559864044,
-0.5749807357788086,
-0.2901134192943573,
-0.002731350250542164,
-0.3113621175289154,
-1.022526741027832,
0.8260065913200378,
0.4442555904388428,
0.11035783588886261,
0.0015722733223810792,
-0.04018615931272507,
-0.5102784037590027,
0.37931397557258606,
0.40911877155303955,
0.027626777067780495,
-0.6220321655273438,
-0.14772017300128937,
-0.18160174787044525,
-0.24234215915203094,
0.29443901777267456,
0.5419026613235474,
-0.12290612608194351,
0.6911008954048157,
0.8759297728538513,
0.3580482602119446,
0.523228645324707,
0.007267170585691929,
0.29751503467559814,
-0.6860713362693787,
0.3418588638305664,
-0.1672816425561905,
0.4829416275024414,
-0.003615679917857051,
-0.19901052117347717,
0.5530653595924377,
0.3569749593734741,
-0.23430947959423065,
-1.0042115449905396,
0.14972937107086182,
-1.1629140377044678,
-0.37012726068496704,
0.8206177353858948,
-0.2358219474554062,
-0.2494693100452423,
-0.20550596714019775,
-0.19108006358146667,
0.4610292315483093,
-0.008235654793679714,
0.3357018828392029,
1.1186985969543457,
0.12202928960323334,
-0.004693312104791403,
-0.7980659008026123,
-0.12065916508436203,
0.918218731880188,
-0.759904682636261,
-0.21868152916431427,
0.12532107532024384,
0.17603369057178497,
0.5666532516479492,
0.49173393845558167,
-0.5483205914497375,
0.20790331065654755,
0.1509416401386261,
-0.19347186386585236,
0.11373348534107208,
-0.24427363276481628,
-0.6921632289886475,
0.12883813679218292,
0.20074276626110077,
-0.3114814758300781
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08931v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08931v2
|
Exploring Multilingual Unseen Speaker Emotion Recognition: Leveraging Co-Attention Cues in Multitask Learning
| 2024-06-13T09:00:14 | 2024-06-20T02:25:39 |
Arnav Goel, Medha Hira, Anubha Gupta
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Advent of modern deep learning techniques has given rise to advancements in
the field of Speech Emotion Recognition (SER). However, most systems prevalent
in the field fail to generalize to speakers not seen during training. This
study focuses on handling challenges of multilingual SER, specifically on
unseen speakers. We introduce CAMuLeNet, a novel architecture leveraging
co-attention based fusion and multitask learning to address this problem.
Additionally, we benchmark pretrained encoders of Whisper, HuBERT, Wav2Vec2.0,
and WavLM using 10-fold leave-speaker-out cross-validation on five existing
multilingual benchmark datasets: IEMOCAP, RAVDESS, CREMA-D, EmoDB and CaFE and,
release a novel dataset for SER on the Hindi language (BhavVani). CAMuLeNet
shows an average improvement of approximately 8% over all benchmarks on unseen
speakers determined by our cross-validation strategy.
|
[
-0.4403402507305145,
-0.19430837035179138,
0.15782463550567627,
0.3318321406841278,
-0.026044810190796852,
0.14810138940811157,
-0.4599752426147461,
-0.5067518353462219,
0.2824627459049225,
0.044756703078746796,
-0.8296198844909668,
-0.38889220356941223,
-0.46704041957855225,
0.14386329054832458,
-0.13659903407096863,
0.5763435959815979,
0.08457119762897491,
0.15585929155349731,
0.0291234590113163,
-0.44339022040367126,
-0.4026877284049988,
-0.4833429753780365,
-0.46523451805114746,
-0.3431982696056366,
0.72353595495224,
0.6842503547668457,
0.1460541933774948,
-0.13716048002243042,
0.08193792402744293,
0.3866797089576721,
0.20681986212730408,
0.3684791028499603,
-0.4673917293548584,
0.3099759519100189,
0.2803531289100647,
-0.019247140735387802,
-0.22931203246116638,
-0.1331290453672409,
0.44277098774909973,
0.6630831360816956,
0.10335749387741089,
-0.14918361604213715,
0.1696978658437729,
0.5760834813117981,
-0.8861996531486511,
0.3486053943634033,
-0.37263089418411255,
0.6074738502502441,
-0.15750353038311005,
-0.16945521533489227,
-0.4515089988708496,
-0.15165925025939941,
0.3491702973842621,
-0.4486919343471527,
0.28365492820739746,
-0.05200812965631485,
0.5788267254829407,
0.2708355188369751,
-0.3573702871799469,
-0.022912589833140373,
-0.4865604341030121,
0.7268387675285339,
-0.4298791289329529,
0.7025558948516846,
0.4214436113834381,
0.31697577238082886,
0.05896744504570961,
-0.21389709413051605,
-0.4731585681438446,
-0.1371466964483261,
-0.07429098337888718,
0.5640044212341309,
-0.24605154991149902,
0.11803590506315231,
0.10618333518505096,
0.40964388847351074,
-0.8737110495567322,
0.16678377985954285,
-0.026122020557522774,
-0.3772515058517456,
0.47602277994155884,
-0.20452745258808136,
0.2143988311290741,
-0.16737018525600433,
-0.35842856764793396,
-0.2985716462135315,
-0.3417785167694092,
0.07114357501268387,
0.5804046392440796,
0.4411604404449463,
-0.5005314350128174,
0.307158887386322,
-0.4260064959526062,
0.4580879509449005,
-0.14216385781764984,
0.3767484426498413,
0.6040084958076477,
0.030255354940891266,
-0.1466732919216156,
0.48364654183387756,
0.880723237991333,
0.10633732378482819,
0.23441365361213684,
-0.0689767599105835,
0.11658786982297897,
0.15995174646377563,
0.09920614957809448,
-0.31614693999290466,
-0.21641844511032104,
0.4204135239124298,
-0.1979639232158661,
0.17259083688259125,
-0.24742203950881958,
-1.2428441047668457,
-0.6598208546638489,
-0.16937972605228424,
0.4070141017436981,
-0.2325206995010376,
-0.545167863368988,
0.05553107336163521,
0.023555774241685867,
0.36744046211242676,
0.24564221501350403,
-0.8576054573059082,
0.2777820825576782,
0.5542342662811279,
0.8068232536315918,
-0.07082027941942215,
-0.38074347376823425,
-0.8594485521316528,
-0.31902289390563965,
-0.15660369396209717,
0.5146543979644775,
-0.42941978573799133,
-0.2321605533361435,
0.22786712646484375,
0.1440076380968094,
-0.2834617495536804,
-0.23756760358810425,
0.5044081211090088,
-0.16360023617744446,
0.06596040725708008,
-0.21951286494731903,
-0.23396669328212738,
-0.08769360184669495,
0.2969498038291931,
-0.6645309329032898,
0.8983333110809326,
-0.11010178178548813,
-0.6830238103866577,
0.02157493121922016,
-0.5303584933280945,
-0.4196428656578064,
0.303739070892334,
-0.25308898091316223,
-0.329043447971344,
0.28252461552619934,
0.07879438251256943,
0.524287760257721,
0.004811997525393963,
0.03643085062503815,
-0.36849695444107056,
-0.04533493146300316,
0.10729432851076126,
-0.5994349718093872,
0.35299691557884216,
0.3226712644100189,
-0.4924187958240509,
0.04672989621758461,
-0.9729511141777039,
0.1688719391822815,
-0.15385659039020538,
-0.022633297368884087,
-0.19369839131832123,
-0.23547402024269104,
0.2659757733345032,
0.2426622062921524,
-0.032399676740169525,
-0.9138847589492798,
-0.2443677932024002,
-0.4080946445465088,
0.18698406219482422,
0.5177837014198303,
-0.2909238636493683,
-0.030528010800480843,
0.1138104647397995,
0.5447201132774353,
-0.08062246441841125,
-0.03174375370144844,
-0.21528707444667816,
-0.27319836616516113,
-0.9076664447784424,
-0.062220100313425064,
0.10439372807741165,
0.4814925193786621,
-0.7348998188972473,
0.22728818655014038,
-0.14784526824951172,
-0.46526259183883667,
-0.914095938205719,
-0.1994839608669281,
0.7855154871940613,
0.4539526402950287,
0.2609905004501343,
-0.4456765651702881,
-0.4999127984046936,
-0.8427425622940063,
-0.4714321792125702,
0.1354118138551712,
0.32296550273895264,
0.5249218344688416,
0.1486029326915741,
-0.4272039234638214,
0.459454208612442,
-0.23317314684391022,
-0.3348425328731537,
-0.3536015450954437,
0.5664889216423035,
-0.08292008936405182,
0.5797291398048401,
0.2068837434053421,
-0.9407632946968079,
-0.7118480205535889,
0.4683198630809784,
-0.6694143414497375,
-0.13922713696956635,
0.03196986764669418,
0.18559452891349792,
0.3440532386302948,
0.13579271733760834,
-0.37232545018196106,
0.45909062027931213,
0.8251583576202393,
-0.03220866248011589,
0.43333035707473755,
-0.35391733050346375,
0.3092796802520752,
-1.0855612754821777,
0.05624161660671234,
0.05902709811925888,
-0.19197167456150055,
-1.0130878686904907,
-0.3751685321331024,
0.12831036746501923,
-0.6568499803543091,
-0.6644700169563293,
0.5454728603363037,
-0.6328202486038208,
-0.3954976499080658,
-0.24134311079978943,
0.20394384860992432,
-0.14353658258914948,
0.918190062046051,
0.24378417432308197,
0.49514517188072205,
0.7154940366744995,
-0.4264720678329468,
0.814011812210083,
0.3646259009838104,
-0.42785900831222534,
0.6317493319511414,
-0.31673505902290344,
0.30985355377197266,
-0.077977254986763,
-0.04360109940171242,
-1.0504523515701294,
-0.3931252658367157,
0.20675121247768402,
-0.5750105977058411,
0.45782196521759033,
0.011367743834853172,
-0.31194010376930237,
-0.2429313212633133,
-0.06693268567323685,
0.5812841057777405,
0.1283547729253769,
-0.6919841766357422,
0.6789214015007019,
0.384349524974823,
-0.4441041350364685,
-0.6879546642303467,
-0.6982477307319641,
0.18060703575611115,
0.003215762786567211,
-0.38330814242362976,
-0.06940319389104843,
-0.011781598441302776,
-0.0691017284989357,
-0.33793607354164124,
-0.21946091949939728,
-0.14691287279129028,
-0.12919680774211884,
0.40647372603416443,
-0.2516563832759857,
0.07522080838680267,
0.44573473930358887,
-0.11761315166950226,
-0.2692919671535492,
-0.201785147190094,
-0.06469117850065231,
0.7442951202392578,
-0.36304107308387756,
-0.4641265571117401,
-0.5433766841888428,
0.8053082823753357,
0.3835158348083496,
-0.5953916907310486,
0.2722024619579315,
1.0864756107330322,
-0.29524165391921997,
-0.04081606864929199,
-0.6808883547782898,
-0.027134915813803673,
-0.44809865951538086,
0.685002863407135,
-0.48160210251808167,
-0.9150034785270691,
0.659734845161438,
-0.3326279819011688,
-0.4080671966075897,
0.2873533070087433,
0.5746873021125793,
0.08234016597270966,
0.8236536383628845,
0.7461602091789246,
-0.2521348297595978,
0.3719644546508789,
-0.11953206360340118,
0.41455405950546265,
-0.7802379727363586,
-0.4162580966949463,
-0.6532760858535767,
-0.3552072048187256,
-0.9806498289108276,
-0.15670138597488403,
0.48554039001464844,
-0.693727433681488,
0.12084243446588516,
0.4073126018047333,
-0.17437560856342316,
0.4382469952106476,
0.4512224793434143,
0.11581674963235855,
-0.24652448296546936,
-0.1015549898147583,
-0.29435834288597107,
-0.055463798344135284,
-0.7122953534126282,
0.09505054354667664,
0.5618908405303955,
0.021825579926371574,
0.7207428812980652,
-0.03708360344171524,
0.8159027695655823,
0.31437912583351135,
-0.2643602788448334,
-0.6969712376594543,
0.5757598280906677,
-0.10455520451068878,
-0.2904845178127289,
-0.2910374402999878,
-0.6287935972213745,
-0.9754244089126587,
0.45438581705093384,
0.0434255413711071,
-0.8752201199531555,
0.6307231187820435,
0.12419354915618896,
-0.4558396339416504,
0.14531010389328003,
-0.9182864427566528,
1.1977570056915283,
-0.5365263819694519,
-0.6581488251686096,
-0.41160401701927185,
-0.8437699675559998,
0.013823862187564373,
-0.006638087797909975,
0.33059442043304443,
-0.33725836873054504,
0.27993834018707275,
0.5291733741760254,
-0.1346287727355957,
0.8216347098350525,
-0.22665107250213623,
-0.08633991330862045,
-0.0008239289163611829,
0.0072341556660830975,
0.42942482233047485,
-0.0028105624951422215,
0.01941925473511219,
0.1587202548980713,
-0.26948684453964233,
-0.37251630425453186,
-0.28960680961608887,
0.8988598585128784,
-0.8485209941864014,
-0.28015032410621643,
-0.6540217399597168,
-0.7537162899971008,
-0.6469576954841614,
0.18050852417945862,
0.25213462114334106,
0.7184064388275146,
-0.2740943729877472,
0.23346205055713654,
0.6987260580062866,
-0.5443942546844482,
0.6138585805892944,
0.5895500779151917,
0.2984582781791687,
-0.36014991998672485,
1.1406819820404053,
-0.12970390915870667,
0.19292810559272766,
0.6055486798286438,
0.18326826393604279,
-0.2597905695438385,
0.03604210168123245,
-0.2068329006433487,
-0.022291172295808792,
-0.6726474165916443,
-0.06421425193548203,
-0.9252722859382629,
-0.11640780419111252,
-0.656278133392334,
0.09924580901861191,
-0.6949018836021423,
-0.10196841508150101,
-0.19523116946220398,
-0.0030106520280241966,
0.248695969581604,
0.5480126142501831,
-0.3489498496055603,
0.2754952609539032,
-0.8568928837776184,
0.4090634286403656,
0.6245325803756714,
0.6111779808998108,
-0.008325173519551754,
-0.29719021916389465,
-0.48028764128685,
-0.014387143775820732,
-0.11038655042648315,
-0.9850296974182129,
0.9239307045936584,
0.5144423246383667,
0.5699678063392639,
0.38787126541137695,
0.23373371362686157,
0.6773797869682312,
-0.4562382102012634,
0.537479817867279,
0.3015954792499542,
-1.0104413032531738,
0.46574926376342773,
-0.2294226735830307,
0.6267804503440857,
0.4890899658203125,
0.6055660247802734,
-0.9814162850379944,
-0.11282457411289215,
-0.3261812925338745,
-0.7962760925292969,
0.7586149573326111,
0.16569092869758606,
0.1898186057806015,
0.41805580258369446,
-0.14339353144168854,
0.4160512685775757,
0.3847235441207886,
-0.7740586400032043,
-0.11304605007171631,
-0.36047983169555664,
-0.33202049136161804,
-0.5434499382972717,
-0.17123329639434814,
0.12899808585643768,
-0.159931480884552,
0.47777023911476135,
-0.19349166750907898,
0.36557161808013916,
0.19657693803310394,
-0.27696797251701355,
-0.11375290900468826,
0.6274633407592773,
0.807181715965271,
-0.007246091496199369,
-0.26862332224845886,
0.3483465015888214,
0.17700450122356415,
-0.34265804290771484,
0.055010244250297546,
0.34854257106781006,
0.5859445929527283,
0.0752645954489708,
0.2816365659236908,
1.214294672012329,
0.5503882765769958,
-0.6706148386001587,
0.41171717643737793,
-0.2958489656448364,
-0.0934387817978859,
-0.3867964446544647,
-0.34378495812416077,
-0.12450655549764633,
0.39503395557403564,
0.21199528872966766,
0.13895246386528015,
0.28016382455825806,
-0.5587345957756042,
0.09378284960985184,
0.2760969400405884,
-0.8123603463172913,
-0.5163516402244568,
0.26595935225486755,
0.30467337369918823,
-0.3217625916004181,
0.2844117283821106,
-0.17891395092010498,
-0.9210415482521057,
0.26719528436660767,
0.19793735444545746,
1.3028616905212402,
-0.6188823580741882,
0.17005476355552673,
0.15041117370128632,
0.10925380140542984,
0.22276099026203156,
0.5186612010002136,
-0.4984995722770691,
-0.5250173807144165,
-0.1463170051574707,
-0.33077871799468994,
-0.7601730823516846,
0.07209513336420059,
-0.5930637121200562,
0.0938829630613327,
0.07416526228189468,
0.07715648412704468,
-0.13416089117527008,
0.11630453914403915,
-0.8048967719078064,
0.20817993581295013,
0.46286430954933167,
0.2670379877090454,
-0.9443429708480835,
0.7666099071502686,
0.558185875415802,
0.024511558935046196,
-0.6305032968521118,
-0.17563629150390625,
0.20556701719760895,
-0.6542789936065674,
0.501591145992279,
0.44777193665504456,
-0.31462562084198,
0.01552149374037981,
-0.19250649213790894,
-0.6854727268218994,
0.640454113483429,
0.3535318970680237,
-0.8022108674049377,
0.4903481602668762,
0.26628485321998596,
0.6151537299156189,
-0.2560141980648041,
0.4098736643791199,
0.17720723152160645,
0.3753467798233032,
0.04453316703438759,
-1.0242565870285034,
-0.6308590173721313,
-0.5809294581413269,
-0.4404791295528412,
0.11123695969581604,
-0.9233840107917786,
0.8325486779212952,
-0.010366286151111126,
-0.06451515108346939,
-0.24599502980709076,
0.42334747314453125,
-0.13285881280899048,
0.4851765036582947,
0.35842207074165344,
0.5955824255943298,
0.7070114612579346,
-0.17250755429267883,
0.7888686060905457,
-0.07028738409280777,
0.1570441573858261,
1.2652162313461304,
-0.6755646467208862,
0.7773236632347107,
0.33049193024635315,
-0.03175386041402817,
0.14452366530895233,
0.7044371962547302,
0.037827037274837494,
0.5913257002830505,
0.11324989050626755,
-0.458596408367157,
-0.31649911403656006,
-0.4484415650367737,
-0.4432360827922821,
0.7358126044273376,
0.21326014399528503,
0.10613923519849777,
-0.18576084077358246,
0.6601204872131348,
-0.26501211524009705,
-0.13942399621009827,
-0.4412726163864136,
0.9131545424461365,
0.2912481725215912,
-0.46936771273612976,
0.5338130593299866,
-0.4652942717075348,
0.6297500729560852,
-0.6597570180892944,
0.01360966358333826,
-0.2473173290491104,
0.34646737575531006,
-0.2056969255208969,
-0.3320505917072296,
-0.008240730501711369,
0.16047817468643188,
0.10611560940742493,
-0.4289419949054718,
0.9198368787765503,
-0.8580174446105957,
-0.2909993529319763,
0.7275066375732422,
0.32688894867897034,
0.36422494053840637,
-0.16060499846935272,
-0.4754527807235718,
0.22463512420654297,
-0.24022555351257324,
-0.02071506716310978,
0.41335204243659973,
0.4874369502067566,
0.318573921918869,
0.708007276058197,
0.1830732524394989,
0.12283532321453094,
0.22022606432437897,
0.4090525507926941,
0.6786031723022461,
-0.4677821397781372,
-0.7435789108276367,
-0.6058282852172852,
0.3620319664478302,
0.040663786232471466,
-0.1976320594549179,
0.9712870121002197,
0.5444257855415344,
0.8789179921150208,
-0.34051263332366943,
0.7146465182304382,
0.27121737599372864,
0.6001408100128174,
-0.09431519359350204,
0.8967998027801514,
-0.8382243514060974,
-0.31835755705833435,
-0.5710996985435486,
-0.5064443349838257,
-0.12792818248271942,
0.3205017149448395,
-0.15793192386627197,
0.003511483781039715,
0.64029461145401,
0.6267688274383545,
0.01934683509171009,
0.19899898767471313,
0.7006887197494507,
0.08352410048246384,
0.019878730177879333,
0.914276123046875,
0.7598812580108643,
-0.48649245500564575,
0.3117399513721466,
-0.33678603172302246,
-0.057770855724811554,
-0.3601701855659485,
-0.7234771847724915,
-0.7426513433456421,
-0.8010380268096924,
-0.5318232774734497,
-0.020794449374079704,
0.13834846019744873,
1.028595209121704,
0.7049314975738525,
-1.0347099304199219,
-0.5144016742706299,
0.09533793479204178,
-0.06880716234445572,
-0.18676522374153137,
-0.11028933525085449,
0.37416574358940125,
-0.3642427325248718,
-0.6830308437347412,
0.6146666407585144,
0.5189291834831238,
-0.012961780652403831,
-0.08254857361316681,
-0.2540278732776642,
-0.4118342101573944,
-0.2882465720176697,
0.4788660407066345,
0.5765499472618103,
-0.45882853865623474,
-0.14871643483638763,
-0.1502017378807068,
0.10723754018545151,
0.07252681255340576,
0.6714668869972229,
-0.6098799109458923,
0.9459438920021057,
0.5280112624168396,
0.8455724716186523,
0.500239908695221,
-0.3723166882991791,
0.5035229325294495,
-1.0338952541351318,
0.48857617378234863,
0.42140713334083557,
0.44489532709121704,
0.45632779598236084,
-0.07975941151380539,
0.18563692271709442,
0.27280062437057495,
-0.5140349268913269,
-0.9230478405952454,
0.20574745535850525,
-1.1769545078277588,
0.26563307642936707,
0.9592999219894409,
-0.31792423129081726,
-0.2354360967874527,
-0.09795685857534409,
-0.06439902633428574,
0.5125160217285156,
-0.41046011447906494,
0.6273598670959473,
0.5693835020065308,
-0.1254848837852478,
-0.6911488175392151,
-0.5695633888244629,
0.5896449685096741,
0.7535255551338196,
-0.872105598449707,
0.2755677103996277,
0.34464210271835327,
-0.30521485209465027,
0.30107632279396057,
0.33533960580825806,
0.18409831821918488,
0.3706035315990448,
-0.07025478035211563,
0.47376304864883423,
0.10605572909116745,
-0.4086819589138031,
-0.7563053965568542,
0.17865625023841858,
-0.3847278654575348,
-0.4240844249725342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10295v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10295v1
|
Robustness of Structured Data Extraction from In-plane Rotated Documents using Multi-Modal Large Language Models (LLM)
| 2024-06-13T08:55:01 | 2024-06-13T08:55:01 |
Anjanava Biswas, Wrick Talukdar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Multi-modal large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable performance in
various natural language processing tasks, including data extraction from
documents. However, the accuracy of these models can be significantly affected
by document in-plane rotation, also known as skew, a common issue in real-world
scenarios for scanned documents. This study investigates the impact of document
skew on the data extraction accuracy of three state-of-the-art multi-modal
LLMs: Anthropic Claude V3 Sonnet, GPT-4-Turbo, and Llava:v1.6. We focus on
extracting specific entities from synthetically generated sample documents with
varying degrees of skewness. The results demonstrate that document skew
adversely affects the data extraction accuracy of all the tested LLMs, with the
severity of the impact varying across models. We identify the safe in-plane
rotation angles (SIPRA) for each model and investigate the effects of skew on
model hallucinations. Furthermore, we explore existing skew detection and
correction mechanisms and discuss their potential limitations. We propose
alternative approaches, including developing new multi-modal architectures that
are inherently more robust to document skew and incorporating skewing
techniques during the pre-training phase of the models. Additionally, we
highlight the need for more comprehensive testing on a wider range of document
quality and conditions to fully understand the challenges and opportunities
associated with using multi-modal LLMs for information extraction in real-world
scenarios.
|
[
-0.08972658962011337,
-0.6307389736175537,
0.5083238482475281,
0.1199008896946907,
-0.33924418687820435,
0.1871003806591034,
-0.08318717032670975,
-0.6530300974845886,
0.12059475481510162,
0.4869423508644104,
-0.32431936264038086,
-0.38452789187431335,
-0.7150305509567261,
0.16435271501541138,
-0.555267870426178,
0.7434474229812622,
0.09711232781410217,
0.33506810665130615,
-0.27946147322654724,
-0.2592100501060486,
-0.06421271711587906,
-0.7403312921524048,
0.041415829211473465,
-0.30401280522346497,
0.24852018058300018,
0.2811572253704071,
0.9033699035644531,
0.4621472656726837,
0.47802451252937317,
0.22822682559490204,
-0.04070616140961647,
0.052651289850473404,
-0.24180738627910614,
0.5074597597122192,
0.09527944028377533,
-0.47278037667274475,
-0.7228152751922607,
0.20183221995830536,
0.6177788972854614,
0.4456523358821869,
-0.2682032287120819,
-0.0019278962863609195,
-0.08696313947439194,
0.4596652388572693,
-0.2161918431520462,
0.18344251811504364,
-0.8584321141242981,
-0.3807036280632019,
-0.6311723589897156,
-0.06183513626456261,
-0.27147433161735535,
-0.18971742689609528,
0.0383317694067955,
-0.7901917695999146,
0.231618270277977,
0.0654963031411171,
1.0336483716964722,
-0.020477721467614174,
-0.34531915187835693,
-0.6782091856002808,
-0.6535173058509827,
0.5993196368217468,
-1.0933406352996826,
0.6525622010231018,
0.18477050960063934,
0.29611825942993164,
-0.36913585662841797,
-0.557056725025177,
-0.8568861484527588,
-0.08759232610464096,
0.3401091396808624,
0.23076178133487701,
0.29287129640579224,
-0.07108623534440994,
0.45197364687919617,
0.29713380336761475,
-0.4626590311527252,
0.23834054172039032,
-0.5049027800559998,
-0.17745906114578247,
0.4472893476486206,
0.044319525361061096,
0.31634271144866943,
-0.6129058003425598,
-0.22677217423915863,
-0.4623459577560425,
-0.5769145488739014,
0.3203596770763397,
0.758655846118927,
0.3007144331932068,
0.033479221165180206,
0.9117095470428467,
0.08780960738658905,
0.10675683617591858,
0.28332623839378357,
-0.8006853461265564,
0.4616318345069885,
-0.11968947947025299,
-0.12947747111320496,
-0.1495998501777649,
0.6341628432273865,
0.17648422718048096,
0.02558775618672371,
-0.3022644817829132,
-0.3017943203449249,
-0.11173221468925476,
0.530123233795166,
-0.5288756489753723,
0.03382828086614609,
0.20617778599262238,
-0.5607001185417175,
-0.7063766717910767,
0.30261558294296265,
-1.296915054321289,
-0.6235584020614624,
-0.3995812237262726,
0.26032254099845886,
-0.5585137605667114,
-0.3341321349143982,
-0.044386472553014755,
-0.15356993675231934,
0.4140039384365082,
0.5367923974990845,
-0.52314293384552,
-0.19456684589385986,
0.8096070885658264,
0.7989974617958069,
-0.6283918023109436,
-0.15516896545886993,
-0.31922465562820435,
0.21854503452777863,
-0.24558353424072266,
0.7495618462562561,
-0.6143018007278442,
-0.39482948184013367,
-0.053323403000831604,
0.11513104289770126,
-0.10187853872776031,
-0.426614910364151,
0.529862642288208,
-0.37259310483932495,
0.24623249471187592,
-0.1361016482114792,
-0.08538063615560532,
-0.02147570438683033,
0.48725026845932007,
-0.8866658806800842,
1.3325735330581665,
0.06382514536380768,
-0.7485584020614624,
0.48426511883735657,
-0.14456675946712494,
-0.5416892170906067,
-0.12582367658615112,
-0.5554482936859131,
-0.4273777902126312,
0.25549617409706116,
0.3220564126968384,
0.3428436517715454,
-0.6295310258865356,
0.3592974841594696,
-0.4616642892360687,
0.09986288845539093,
0.34740155935287476,
-0.8269335031509399,
0.6948825120925903,
-0.06484989076852798,
-0.3318597674369812,
-0.2054799199104309,
-1.1441923379898071,
-0.09092363715171814,
0.07872883975505829,
-0.6890779733657837,
-0.2390492856502533,
0.1166270449757576,
0.14136433601379395,
0.6152632832527161,
-0.053657207638025284,
-0.530320405960083,
0.3470931351184845,
-0.4884713292121887,
0.2104286551475525,
0.7414193749427795,
-0.17588642239570618,
0.40263593196868896,
-0.2530604600906372,
0.609957754611969,
0.2410437911748886,
-0.02665981464087963,
0.04226164147257805,
-0.24207770824432373,
-0.30029433965682983,
-0.6181610226631165,
-0.05558721721172333,
0.39569297432899475,
-0.9458205699920654,
0.015050439164042473,
-0.6312915682792664,
-0.479084849357605,
-0.39347928762435913,
0.273125022649765,
0.04838681221008301,
0.6750679612159729,
0.039092980325222015,
-0.11462713032960892,
-0.07805347442626953,
-0.6677279472351074,
-0.30082711577415466,
-0.24104148149490356,
0.06198285147547722,
0.03163192793726921,
0.20234936475753784,
-0.10810711234807968,
0.7498179078102112,
-0.11661694943904877,
-0.023213639855384827,
-0.4990561008453369,
0.5281088352203369,
0.15775619447231293,
0.298810750246048,
0.5200400352478027,
-0.7525924444198608,
-0.33910128474235535,
0.04667842760682106,
-0.7523308396339417,
-0.22210706770420074,
-0.5165130496025085,
0.04925042763352394,
0.5434769988059998,
0.4030333161354065,
-1.1596283912658691,
0.7003522515296936,
0.2706339359283447,
0.36017483472824097,
0.7251216769218445,
-0.06837990880012512,
-0.18417567014694214,
-1.172845721244812,
0.08983269333839417,
0.07513152062892914,
-0.14499618113040924,
-0.6580738425254822,
-0.10137899965047836,
0.3479190468788147,
-0.05694233626127243,
-0.21267765760421753,
0.15898919105529785,
-0.6199464797973633,
-0.1792200654745102,
-0.25220540165901184,
0.19493377208709717,
0.4393368661403656,
0.26559385657310486,
-0.05335996672511101,
0.7635558247566223,
0.3267872929573059,
-0.12288375198841095,
0.06712548434734344,
-0.053541816771030426,
-0.26048895716667175,
0.643295407295227,
-0.2244071513414383,
0.26674923300743103,
-0.3242289125919342,
0.18246960639953613,
-0.7632530927658081,
-0.35944244265556335,
0.2911481261253357,
-0.28101274371147156,
0.7119484543800354,
0.05497661605477333,
-0.46410030126571655,
-0.30598822236061096,
-0.6479798555374146,
0.0004276869585737586,
-0.22024738788604736,
-0.4548957645893097,
0.991722822189331,
0.495198130607605,
-0.19237621128559113,
-0.5531995892524719,
-0.2563615143299103,
-0.03272769972681999,
-0.3167918622493744,
-0.47841063141822815,
0.12330445647239685,
0.2551504969596863,
-0.244771346449852,
-0.5094096660614014,
-0.7718952298164368,
-0.0035617584362626076,
-0.04400063678622246,
0.46216946840286255,
0.570195734500885,
-0.18325527012348175,
-0.1229679211974144,
-0.011461488902568817,
0.046122580766677856,
0.21447476744651794,
0.09970209002494812,
0.5995389223098755,
-0.08483099937438965,
-0.5298944711685181,
-0.09292730689048767,
0.2968142032623291,
1.484034776687622,
0.04936744645237923,
0.6115070581436157,
0.6430656909942627,
-0.541185736656189,
0.22221440076828003,
-0.8731151819229126,
0.1576237976551056,
-0.4477778971195221,
0.38098055124282837,
-0.4688689112663269,
-0.07764840871095657,
0.5738440155982971,
-0.09915377199649811,
0.14965766668319702,
0.5398584604263306,
0.46529993414878845,
-0.44962751865386963,
1.0156360864639282,
0.556475043296814,
-0.3129318058490753,
0.3164491057395935,
-0.04387582093477249,
0.4124602675437927,
-0.8913249373435974,
-0.5949898958206177,
-0.7970977425575256,
-0.04744061082601547,
-0.5291151404380798,
-0.33182722330093384,
0.5488266348838806,
0.15610574185848236,
0.2992357611656189,
0.18428291380405426,
-0.3174744248390198,
-0.021473823115229607,
0.20942799746990204,
0.02571428194642067,
0.3240780532360077,
0.21650977432727814,
-0.299842894077301,
-0.17212557792663574,
-0.3388172388076782,
-0.6239601373672485,
0.9900479316711426,
0.4316783547401428,
0.9613714218139648,
-0.09781590849161148,
0.19683942198753357,
-0.048040855675935745,
0.23158210515975952,
-0.7900052070617676,
0.2839309275150299,
0.03112849034368992,
-0.548862636089325,
-0.4122096300125122,
-0.07643710821866989,
-0.5617074966430664,
0.5397998690605164,
-0.3840552568435669,
-0.7274544835090637,
0.6328844428062439,
-0.34956851601600647,
-0.02280823327600956,
0.31896865367889404,
-0.304280549287796,
0.36153215169906616,
-0.7458218932151794,
-0.10048384964466095,
0.04202154651284218,
-0.6335119605064392,
0.016837630420923233,
-0.4452956020832062,
0.43459707498550415,
-0.2829135060310364,
0.13039234280586243,
0.38657090067863464,
-0.28414440155029297,
0.7781413793563843,
-0.12480580061674118,
-0.15568828582763672,
0.03302501514554024,
0.32850730419158936,
0.6601173877716064,
0.20850951969623566,
-0.43043044209480286,
0.45999443531036377,
0.4181992709636688,
-0.010168518871068954,
-0.44364213943481445,
0.46565836668014526,
-0.9362826347351074,
-0.6381546854972839,
-0.6436564326286316,
-0.9211437106132507,
-0.12539687752723694,
0.44548118114471436,
0.3222142159938812,
0.5892159342765808,
0.01097537949681282,
0.3616863489151001,
0.16890791058540344,
-0.2359103411436081,
0.526717483997345,
0.3479241132736206,
-0.03127332404255867,
-0.4499437212944031,
0.8927820920944214,
0.34451425075531006,
0.18406543135643005,
0.04204469919204712,
0.26632726192474365,
-0.1476394385099411,
-0.7334449291229248,
-0.46874526143074036,
0.1415395736694336,
-0.8604306578636169,
-0.33610999584198,
-0.8372182250022888,
-0.26524966955184937,
-0.8927175998687744,
-0.13787469267845154,
-0.47243624925613403,
-0.6307340264320374,
-0.39555326104164124,
-0.06970903277397156,
-0.08657761663198471,
0.5967935919761658,
0.33393144607543945,
0.288015216588974,
-0.6014880537986755,
0.49588078260421753,
-0.26539263129234314,
-0.15539315342903137,
-0.2524944543838501,
-0.4215333163738251,
0.09106142818927765,
-0.0032352895941585302,
-0.3633240759372711,
-1.0288872718811035,
0.5980604290962219,
0.14872612059116364,
0.8302960395812988,
0.5972604751586914,
-0.1588398516178131,
0.8688560128211975,
-0.05760413408279419,
0.7438522577285767,
0.015200434252619743,
-0.6275964379310608,
0.045681070536375046,
-0.5033676624298096,
0.3251444399356842,
0.7520247101783752,
0.3863781988620758,
-0.3601682484149933,
-0.3842553496360779,
-0.3521704077720642,
-1.0126725435256958,
0.8076088428497314,
-0.01525522768497467,
-0.06152649223804474,
0.09915841370820999,
0.7285401225090027,
0.5827667713165283,
0.3945505917072296,
-1.0457946062088013,
0.24250879883766174,
-0.5728625059127808,
-0.31328728795051575,
0.40266329050064087,
-0.160099059343338,
0.13989748060703278,
-0.2676200270652771,
0.5012538433074951,
-0.23282627761363983,
-0.08951718360185623,
0.16644608974456787,
-0.5581271648406982,
-0.16421931982040405,
0.08914366364479065,
0.6031268239021301,
0.698932945728302,
-0.18227428197860718,
0.3009405732154846,
0.03632282465696335,
-1.0096009969711304,
-0.2509481906890869,
-0.11224006861448288,
-0.2919585108757019,
-0.02414025366306305,
0.4487472176551819,
0.3051781952381134,
0.18074101209640503,
-0.4643810987472534,
0.493266224861145,
0.12825354933738708,
-0.0435229055583477,
-0.24217991530895233,
-0.29208022356033325,
-0.28398412466049194,
0.12473687529563904,
0.4879903197288513,
0.20196276903152466,
-0.04029426723718643,
-0.4318045675754547,
-0.22842097282409668,
0.7116666436195374,
0.09827899932861328,
-0.5567574501037598,
0.3274090588092804,
-0.2128196507692337,
-0.23610001802444458,
0.5911557078361511,
0.2366885244846344,
-0.5202345252037048,
0.46660250425338745,
0.7919800877571106,
0.6511707305908203,
0.08610694110393524,
0.15684352815151215,
0.033553414046764374,
0.6525689363479614,
-0.27210938930511475,
0.002950584050267935,
0.1667381227016449,
-0.6174651980400085,
-0.02962120808660984,
-0.5697141289710999,
-0.2701677978038788,
0.37983858585357666,
-0.7268474102020264,
0.3805936574935913,
-0.4283216893672943,
-0.15923357009887695,
-0.00592494010925293,
-0.19565913081169128,
-0.5830535888671875,
-0.12022660672664642,
0.18736661970615387,
0.6476371884346008,
-0.691329300403595,
1.1001731157302856,
0.7660622596740723,
-0.29282060265541077,
-0.7192488312721252,
0.35918059945106506,
0.4085336923599243,
-0.5945181250572205,
0.3293357491493225,
0.405246376991272,
-0.45109742879867554,
-0.5013651251792908,
-0.48700201511383057,
-1.086387276649475,
1.2286455631256104,
0.36055853962898254,
-0.3361872136592865,
-0.42622143030166626,
0.7504385709762573,
0.5330994129180908,
-0.29710420966148376,
0.27933669090270996,
0.494913786649704,
0.41656550765037537,
0.17145946621894836,
-0.7385538816452026,
-0.06788203120231628,
-0.16190145909786224,
-0.05258147791028023,
-0.13703663647174835,
-0.2911972105503082,
0.8381438851356506,
0.38762366771698,
-0.275032103061676,
-0.26133066415786743,
0.514302670955658,
0.04709922522306442,
0.284836083650589,
0.5239531993865967,
0.25591468811035156,
0.964024543762207,
0.1475391834974289,
0.9769409894943237,
-0.26566213369369507,
-0.1980842798948288,
0.8940869569778442,
-0.6423192024230957,
0.6951844692230225,
0.8402706384658813,
0.3749353289604187,
0.26325905323028564,
0.23444657027721405,
0.24333161115646362,
0.33846521377563477,
-0.3926807641983032,
0.1449955254793167,
-0.1679951548576355,
0.3989427089691162,
-0.1958271563053131,
0.6716257333755493,
0.6963757872581482,
0.08354471623897552,
-0.27101847529411316,
0.18883474171161652,
0.10999523848295212,
-0.30501994490623474,
0.14593292772769928,
0.5202085971832275,
0.047729235142469406,
-0.6041052341461182,
0.09751062840223312,
0.12953655421733856,
0.6437499523162842,
-0.2314981073141098,
0.20535217225551605,
-0.2739124894142151,
0.014162985607981682,
-0.18206976354122162,
-0.4488999843597412,
0.36644846200942993,
-0.08651188015937805,
-0.36282971501350403,
-0.2705177962779999,
1.095906138420105,
-0.1706642359495163,
-0.8103657960891724,
0.12367036938667297,
0.5934699773788452,
0.05091617628931999,
-0.12744344770908356,
-0.6959460973739624,
0.23082588613033295,
-0.21591717004776,
-0.49408987164497375,
0.5359207391738892,
0.5846151113510132,
-0.44471925497055054,
0.49809688329696655,
0.8601816892623901,
0.3457079827785492,
0.5088075399398804,
0.010603737086057663,
1.0799278020858765,
-0.4317169189453125,
-0.10221979022026062,
-0.64848792552948,
0.28368642926216125,
-0.19746989011764526,
-0.21978862583637238,
0.6673510670661926,
0.5590789914131165,
0.4926293194293976,
0.23551492393016815,
0.5874009728431702,
-0.17061582207679749,
0.36175838112831116,
-0.44193002581596375,
0.6406596899032593,
-0.4324864149093628,
0.5144808888435364,
-0.3699485957622528,
-1.0155324935913086,
-0.15378382802009583,
0.6336453557014465,
-0.2619854807853699,
-0.3876549005508423,
0.7537765502929688,
0.940453290939331,
-0.0992211401462555,
0.1332543045282364,
0.10563703626394272,
0.18793214857578278,
0.8242440819740295,
-0.3031690716743469,
0.5478864312171936,
-0.3531002402305603,
0.6772642135620117,
-0.4537181258201599,
-0.08682337403297424,
-0.12768234312534332,
-1.0493861436843872,
-0.9175318479537964,
-0.5668089985847473,
-0.06736698746681213,
-0.3635462522506714,
-0.20578984916210175,
0.8311650156974792,
0.3663332760334015,
-0.6095454692840576,
-0.054624952375888824,
0.3527681231498718,
0.1999107450246811,
-0.06647694855928421,
-0.27733108401298523,
0.41155871748924255,
-0.21540580689907074,
-0.5605775713920593,
0.6822412014007568,
0.5458018779754639,
0.0011931541375815868,
-0.12156905233860016,
0.20941029489040375,
-0.34551265835762024,
0.10754473507404327,
0.5266069173812866,
0.2718789279460907,
-0.8017613291740417,
-0.45721229910850525,
0.33662059903144836,
-0.5284030437469482,
0.4983810782432556,
0.9362035393714905,
-0.2794351875782013,
0.5648324489593506,
0.6878218054771423,
0.44307345151901245,
0.6026915311813354,
0.2580929100513458,
0.5647469162940979,
-0.5106484293937683,
0.29484108090400696,
0.09230967611074448,
0.11155045032501221,
0.16965778172016144,
-0.6530522108078003,
0.2016787827014923,
0.3725651800632477,
-0.3200048506259918,
-0.9952660799026489,
-0.29399606585502625,
-1.285646915435791,
-0.16918626427650452,
1.1779605150222778,
0.1532289683818817,
-0.24888989329338074,
-0.4099338948726654,
-0.17945070564746857,
0.3550730049610138,
-0.1404888778924942,
1.0279712677001953,
0.9704787135124207,
-0.13372011482715607,
-0.03715543448925018,
-0.9022790193557739,
0.15480883419513702,
0.3786115050315857,
-0.757941722869873,
0.03564615920186043,
0.5506571531295776,
0.2942427098751068,
0.2830241620540619,
0.2607073485851288,
-0.7378267645835876,
-0.06654207408428192,
-0.20287036895751953,
0.15088589489459991,
-0.18057280778884888,
-0.521611750125885,
-0.39641129970550537,
0.3542463481426239,
0.04809601604938507,
0.17351055145263672
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08922v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08922v1
|
Navigating the Shadows: Unveiling Effective Disturbances for Modern AI Content Detectors
| 2024-06-13T08:37:01 | 2024-06-13T08:37:01 |
Ying Zhou, Ben He, Le Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
With the launch of ChatGPT, large language models (LLMs) have attracted
global attention. In the realm of article writing, LLMs have witnessed
extensive utilization, giving rise to concerns related to intellectual property
protection, personal privacy, and academic integrity. In response, AI-text
detection has emerged to distinguish between human and machine-generated
content. However, recent research indicates that these detection systems often
lack robustness and struggle to effectively differentiate perturbed texts.
Currently, there is a lack of systematic evaluations regarding detection
performance in real-world applications, and a comprehensive examination of
perturbation techniques and detector robustness is also absent. To bridge this
gap, our work simulates real-world scenarios in both informal and professional
writing, exploring the out-of-the-box performance of current detectors.
Additionally, we have constructed 12 black-box text perturbation methods to
assess the robustness of current detection models across various perturbation
granularities. Furthermore, through adversarial learning experiments, we
investigate the impact of perturbation data augmentation on the robustness of
AI-text detectors. We have released our code and data at
https://github.com/zhouying20/ai-text-detector-evaluation.
|
[
-0.2334856539964676,
-1.0641366243362427,
0.6267723441123962,
-0.10166433453559875,
-0.22884367406368256,
0.2522776126861572,
-0.25930243730545044,
-0.6478315591812134,
-0.3195820748806,
0.6183627843856812,
-0.34946468472480774,
-0.8270914554595947,
-0.6528880000114441,
0.23708023130893707,
-0.7166816592216492,
0.9915051460266113,
0.02790767513215542,
-0.27744153141975403,
-0.2900617718696594,
0.21308721601963043,
-0.06669635325670242,
-0.6011399030685425,
-0.662918746471405,
-0.056220732629299164,
0.34617117047309875,
0.1410284787416458,
0.6589747667312622,
0.5598186254501343,
0.6154176592826843,
0.3104286789894104,
-0.3155912458896637,
0.28472721576690674,
-0.511767566204071,
0.5861544609069824,
0.2757335901260376,
-0.39373865723609924,
-0.28436335921287537,
-0.19604630768299103,
0.7820972204208374,
0.295261412858963,
0.15210270881652832,
-0.23321633040905,
0.21466150879859924,
0.2507581114768982,
-0.7690958976745605,
-0.08435962349176407,
-0.6546662449836731,
-0.1161814033985138,
-0.45058673620224,
-0.13178957998752594,
-0.4560128450393677,
0.15340526401996613,
-0.1738259345293045,
-0.3557091951370239,
0.07950092852115631,
-0.06634266674518585,
0.9648310542106628,
0.6395189762115479,
-0.3164449632167816,
-0.4623929560184479,
-0.9805588722229004,
0.6526988744735718,
-0.6183364391326904,
0.37210631370544434,
0.5605873465538025,
0.08826795965433121,
-0.097840815782547,
-0.8854725956916809,
-0.8203823566436768,
-0.42275765538215637,
0.05297515541315079,
0.09314419329166412,
-0.41059473156929016,
0.08083979785442352,
0.20361104607582092,
0.4494180679321289,
-0.4354647397994995,
0.27027788758277893,
0.25610673427581787,
-0.3172033429145813,
0.6316014528274536,
0.28826844692230225,
0.24572402238845825,
-0.04791878163814545,
-0.12903042137622833,
-0.28860339522361755,
-0.6613208651542664,
-0.09079213440418243,
1.0302908420562744,
-0.07123647630214691,
-0.23741769790649414,
0.2163638472557068,
0.25872331857681274,
0.5807129740715027,
-0.004329148214310408,
0.00890745222568512,
-0.11301200836896896,
-0.5521411895751953,
-0.00827612355351448,
-0.3541316092014313,
1.0671159029006958,
0.07242409139871597,
0.07372546195983887,
-0.3016362488269806,
-0.4646396338939667,
-0.023801835253834724,
0.3749253451824188,
-0.7690528035163879,
-0.4712151288986206,
-0.022534023970365524,
-0.30335864424705505,
-0.6932463049888611,
0.04973847046494484,
-0.7094518542289734,
-0.9569958448410034,
0.05449046939611435,
0.3139360845088959,
-0.39033737778663635,
-0.12038566917181015,
0.1574973165988922,
0.16244550049304962,
0.06387343257665634,
0.30002808570861816,
-0.7255567312240601,
0.14548999071121216,
0.5748838782310486,
0.6170758605003357,
-0.31076639890670776,
-0.17235465347766876,
-0.3505373001098633,
-0.16773904860019684,
-0.26052558422088623,
0.9737139940261841,
-0.560050368309021,
-0.2713051736354828,
0.10314543545246124,
-0.31036069989204407,
0.1728430688381195,
-0.41576287150382996,
0.9690225720405579,
-0.36588194966316223,
-0.0036766892299056053,
0.19684763252735138,
-0.31993821263313293,
0.16712041199207306,
0.5324292778968811,
-0.6557082533836365,
0.860582172870636,
0.0426667258143425,
-0.9309674501419067,
0.1458090990781784,
-0.39310917258262634,
-0.6184104681015015,
-0.2234445959329605,
-0.23155690729618073,
-0.8998444080352783,
-0.0502810962498188,
0.5079579949378967,
0.390385240316391,
-0.029286205768585205,
0.07246369123458862,
0.0744437724351883,
-0.764133095741272,
0.4579986333847046,
-1.0116791725158691,
0.6614846587181091,
0.07164465636014938,
-0.37846267223358154,
0.2737556993961334,
-0.8744828701019287,
-0.6189624071121216,
0.04896915331482887,
-0.3841276466846466,
-0.2268519252538681,
0.33096593618392944,
0.22350634634494781,
-0.2982805073261261,
0.01909809559583664,
-0.32912734150886536,
0.07078283280134201,
-0.2599824070930481,
0.34300702810287476,
0.8439314365386963,
0.0752045288681984,
0.26914703845977783,
-0.2116946280002594,
0.7598527669906616,
-0.032358791679143906,
-0.005270722787827253,
-0.7666308879852295,
-0.24060171842575073,
-0.6191211938858032,
-0.23264417052268982,
0.4155663251876831,
0.4137355387210846,
-0.9352169036865234,
0.5765697360038757,
0.04853100702166557,
-0.4285585582256317,
-0.5814146995544434,
0.14661318063735962,
0.31422096490859985,
0.45091551542282104,
0.22897642850875854,
-0.036207254976034164,
-0.46272021532058716,
-0.4658356308937073,
-0.5132425427436829,
-0.24680422246456146,
-0.0012463598977774382,
0.15092593431472778,
0.3530460596084595,
-0.3993280827999115,
0.48677903413772583,
-0.3437096178531647,
-0.20761260390281677,
-0.18401841819286346,
0.05918268486857414,
-0.014525029808282852,
0.2925448715686798,
0.4121132493019104,
-0.8000579476356506,
-0.5239148139953613,
-0.27372869849205017,
-0.7719797492027283,
-0.36463361978530884,
-0.39128294587135315,
0.202481210231781,
0.2710767090320587,
0.9690538644790649,
-0.4330931007862091,
0.6669872403144836,
0.637510359287262,
-0.37292569875717163,
0.9063595533370972,
0.10502491891384125,
0.1288088709115982,
-0.794106125831604,
0.0636652261018753,
0.17254386842250824,
-0.3787919878959656,
-0.5473424792289734,
0.38488757610321045,
-0.21623878180980682,
0.051337774842977524,
-0.19695425033569336,
0.3196331858634949,
-0.5242148041725159,
0.18697139620780945,
-0.4865241050720215,
0.13035884499549866,
-0.05001200735569,
0.11863347887992859,
-0.2545941472053528,
0.9511760473251343,
0.571276068687439,
-0.4718920886516571,
0.22712428867816925,
-0.018085286021232605,
-0.3515639305114746,
0.4861772954463959,
-0.5205374956130981,
0.3918059468269348,
-0.24540011584758759,
0.2887101173400879,
-1.2075767517089844,
-0.15428265929222107,
0.3444884717464447,
-0.6246737241744995,
0.39992618560791016,
-0.18372531235218048,
-0.7748598456382751,
-0.017764616757631302,
-0.5250152349472046,
0.2770417630672455,
0.2917017638683319,
-0.3615243434906006,
0.7478318214416504,
0.2969439923763275,
0.108871228992939,
-0.6684606671333313,
-0.718281626701355,
0.6099331378936768,
-0.11018448323011398,
-0.6317973732948303,
0.30403149127960205,
-0.18131354451179504,
-0.5227801203727722,
-0.06376153230667114,
-0.055666234344244,
0.1860409677028656,
0.5078489184379578,
0.3750317692756653,
0.16466517746448517,
-0.23330174386501312,
-0.1024332046508789,
-0.05052180960774422,
-0.27255067229270935,
0.10210029780864716,
-0.14241690933704376,
0.7795328497886658,
0.10758299380540848,
-0.5173998475074768,
-0.687875509262085,
-0.031726546585559845,
0.5068488121032715,
-0.2630491554737091,
0.5365455150604248,
1.0971239805221558,
-0.44429171085357666,
-0.25684818625450134,
-0.41787999868392944,
-0.31160131096839905,
-0.5564082264900208,
0.4925512373447418,
-0.15605489909648895,
-0.6720986366271973,
0.46718287467956543,
0.21860839426517487,
-0.06356572359800339,
0.2448548823595047,
0.4268934428691864,
-0.18982496857643127,
0.9670729637145996,
0.7388057708740234,
-0.12835478782653809,
0.7181225419044495,
-0.11354898661375046,
0.48311835527420044,
-0.7966827750205994,
0.06816356629133224,
-0.742957353591919,
-0.1546490639448166,
-0.5339921116828918,
-0.13231194019317627,
0.40871813893318176,
-0.022701090201735497,
-0.023460861295461655,
0.1004875972867012,
-0.6414844393730164,
0.5433002710342407,
0.28084006905555725,
0.06878972798585892,
0.5958351492881775,
0.06632573157548904,
0.14325018227100372,
-0.144598126411438,
-0.3299505114555359,
-0.823762059211731,
1.200516700744629,
0.44106602668762207,
1.075459599494934,
-0.12222729623317719,
0.4553009569644928,
0.42321979999542236,
0.2274865359067917,
-0.6825893521308899,
0.5565268397331238,
-0.37935304641723633,
-0.19179382920265198,
-0.09289407730102539,
-0.24266253411769867,
-1.0588722229003906,
0.11672452837228775,
-0.48508161306381226,
-0.7866290807723999,
-0.08638596534729004,
0.011427127756178379,
-0.35965636372566223,
0.5673546195030212,
-0.4102547764778137,
0.5969184041023254,
-0.21839013695716858,
-0.5907349586486816,
0.06454429030418396,
-0.30266276001930237,
0.12400536239147186,
0.0869496688246727,
0.16080093383789062,
0.21893665194511414,
-0.12639017403125763,
0.3541507422924042,
0.1278432011604309,
0.9953235387802124,
0.1751459240913391,
-0.3866257071495056,
0.36780059337615967,
0.27905821800231934,
0.5502675175666809,
0.1565413475036621,
-0.17894230782985687,
0.159674733877182,
-0.38816478848457336,
-0.10902208834886551,
-0.31725913286209106,
0.6273968815803528,
-0.636603832244873,
-0.5596928596496582,
-0.44680172204971313,
-0.6171804070472717,
-0.029064033180475235,
0.2946583926677704,
0.526186466217041,
0.36561843752861023,
-0.11360541731119156,
0.23504754900932312,
0.6657922863960266,
-0.25946077704429626,
0.5499134063720703,
0.39143162965774536,
-0.2081412374973297,
-0.17599788308143616,
0.7080367803573608,
-0.11243291944265366,
-0.011153316125273705,
0.3297632336616516,
0.009611302986741066,
-0.11432623863220215,
-1.1573187112808228,
-0.43929949402809143,
-0.13206042349338531,
-0.5553223490715027,
-0.14575515687465668,
-0.6365556120872498,
-0.4528166651725769,
-0.3956921398639679,
-0.1492772251367569,
-0.16932758688926697,
0.09872300922870636,
-0.49486425518989563,
-0.055650271475315094,
-0.13485093414783478,
0.7881792783737183,
0.19782684743404388,
0.4413485527038574,
-0.5402324795722961,
0.07353396713733673,
-0.0758383572101593,
0.24001671373844147,
0.002044600434601307,
-0.36704081296920776,
-0.23491203784942627,
-0.08781684935092926,
-0.5387194156646729,
-0.7700597643852234,
0.1885782927274704,
-0.15556520223617554,
0.4019595980644226,
0.537217378616333,
0.20571157336235046,
0.3751440644264221,
-0.017188968136906624,
0.9721072912216187,
-0.2907033860683441,
-0.9845139980316162,
0.3833579123020172,
-0.5800970792770386,
0.2161017656326294,
0.49284887313842773,
0.09673229604959488,
-0.43255048990249634,
-0.8106105923652649,
-0.4921397864818573,
-0.9612880945205688,
0.43157753348350525,
0.39774248003959656,
0.3986000418663025,
0.35188356041908264,
0.6442604660987854,
-0.026736566796898842,
0.20021721720695496,
-0.8646082878112793,
-0.1631712168455124,
0.11623696237802505,
-0.347042441368103,
-0.05725763738155365,
-0.15196003019809723,
0.1857205182313919,
0.12638679146766663,
0.4356250762939453,
-0.014917190186679363,
0.24633543193340302,
0.31031662225723267,
-0.23666876554489136,
-0.12102264165878296,
-0.09766622632741928,
0.46502137184143066,
0.3334400951862335,
0.03431863337755203,
0.413536012172699,
-0.16959518194198608,
-0.8228285312652588,
-0.12669698894023895,
0.3546738624572754,
-0.5873154401779175,
-0.06852157413959503,
0.8754897713661194,
0.7437431812286377,
-0.18538416922092438,
-0.7456154823303223,
0.5116590261459351,
-0.15437978506088257,
0.08015166968107224,
-0.3941190242767334,
0.335635244846344,
-0.2446434199810028,
0.08401504158973694,
0.5580179691314697,
0.18301276862621307,
0.18050530552864075,
-0.6091576814651489,
0.16086454689502716,
0.5547307729721069,
-0.5940781831741333,
-0.42574381828308105,
0.7502273321151733,
0.05284901708364487,
-0.5402988791465759,
0.5153614282608032,
-0.2919333577156067,
-0.8406062722206116,
0.6220630407333374,
0.5850142240524292,
0.7315401434898376,
0.0013748033670708537,
0.011148791760206223,
0.01836390048265457,
0.6312346458435059,
0.22003690898418427,
-0.1527208387851715,
-0.10227911174297333,
-0.8377621173858643,
-0.3445013463497162,
-0.342475026845932,
-0.45348435640335083,
0.3908849060535431,
-0.25328555703163147,
0.391178697347641,
-0.49106791615486145,
-0.23189450800418854,
0.09747374057769775,
0.16642221808433533,
-0.2941049039363861,
-0.0165395624935627,
0.381193071603775,
0.61140376329422,
-0.6270564794540405,
0.444362074136734,
0.8157905340194702,
-0.36939170956611633,
-0.4126396179199219,
0.7747647762298584,
0.2442808896303177,
-0.503800094127655,
-0.1754859983921051,
0.19612963497638702,
-0.2749500870704651,
-0.0714096650481224,
-1.0141960382461548,
-0.40272560715675354,
0.8786677122116089,
0.40202221274375916,
-0.378774493932724,
0.09342970699071884,
-0.017204927280545235,
0.8881374597549438,
0.028172029182314873,
0.34330350160598755,
0.536591112613678,
0.5798070430755615,
-0.19853127002716064,
-0.5437372326850891,
-0.07477486878633499,
-0.1563715934753418,
-0.48860108852386475,
0.1270775943994522,
-0.5964406132698059,
0.8064287900924683,
0.09930510818958282,
-0.3445190489292145,
0.2700418531894684,
0.38409721851348877,
0.004048699978739023,
0.43963316082954407,
0.3813107907772064,
0.4670467674732208,
0.6177025437355042,
-0.2905159890651703,
1.1655913591384888,
-0.3072379529476166,
0.021387748420238495,
0.7335565090179443,
-0.13643470406532288,
0.6237306594848633,
0.26908841729164124,
-0.11719679832458496,
0.6318677067756653,
0.4599471688270569,
-0.29897382855415344,
0.12167319655418396,
0.2804219424724579,
-0.44146087765693665,
-0.18834863603115082,
-0.17632825672626495,
-0.07409128546714783,
0.5539044141769409,
0.3235979378223419,
-0.2885809540748596,
0.05925163999199867,
0.023066937923431396,
0.3918968737125397,
0.5493876338005066,
-0.1301508992910385,
0.6893504858016968,
-0.05925259366631508,
-0.6875758171081543,
0.38247305154800415,
0.21220575273036957,
1.0572469234466553,
-0.39610394835472107,
0.04646537825465202,
-0.22972041368484497,
0.43983331322669983,
-0.33758220076560974,
-1.0741603374481201,
0.31753018498420715,
0.15308751165866852,
0.1625121533870697,
-0.06284259259700775,
1.1761484146118164,
-0.24823056161403656,
-0.3564390540122986,
0.2711234986782074,
0.25055572390556335,
-0.007655086927115917,
-0.259820818901062,
-0.41132378578186035,
0.5391750335693359,
0.033592235296964645,
-0.1404035985469818,
0.2381131500005722,
0.22431790828704834,
0.09339728206396103,
0.589825451374054,
0.7978684306144714,
0.08107490837574005,
-0.10129587352275848,
0.011289756745100021,
0.8608290553092957,
-0.26839667558670044,
-0.33515095710754395,
-1.1354020833969116,
0.4964078366756439,
-0.08783659338951111,
-0.3577871322631836,
0.9148745536804199,
0.4654359817504883,
0.6887503862380981,
0.27593767642974854,
0.7278283834457397,
0.1815454065799713,
0.018371015787124634,
-0.5015640258789062,
1.0094364881515503,
-0.36282220482826233,
0.7369106411933899,
-0.438979834318161,
-0.8378519415855408,
-0.648586630821228,
0.5970484614372253,
-0.18226881325244904,
0.042267076671123505,
0.3821731209754944,
0.7695055603981018,
0.06997162848711014,
-0.1616608202457428,
0.2709323763847351,
0.4657474458217621,
0.658182680606842,
0.2893160283565521,
1.028212547302246,
-0.6261327862739563,
0.8787037134170532,
-0.1815110445022583,
-0.013981563970446587,
0.027896367013454437,
-0.9410486817359924,
-1.0750707387924194,
-0.5572996735572815,
-0.3252549171447754,
-0.6215962171554565,
0.3822419047355652,
0.3019385039806366,
0.7290360927581787,
-0.6369838714599609,
-0.014498995617032051,
-0.21755965054035187,
0.4481569826602936,
-0.024376265704631805,
-0.22415673732757568,
0.44853585958480835,
-0.17763546109199524,
-0.9082622528076172,
0.3618643283843994,
0.250342458486557,
0.16780559718608856,
-0.5565994381904602,
0.011574761010706425,
-0.042725820094347,
0.13790680468082428,
0.2565208375453949,
-0.05778544768691063,
-0.33632728457450867,
-0.046961307525634766,
-0.10268610715866089,
-0.25084903836250305,
0.12807850539684296,
0.6588789224624634,
-0.686773419380188,
0.3501182496547699,
0.45399603247642517,
0.7213605046272278,
0.6221672892570496,
0.16631338000297546,
0.37355872988700867,
-0.8304259181022644,
0.18431773781776428,
0.5083959102630615,
0.10564837604761124,
0.5168558955192566,
-0.5722586512565613,
0.4284985065460205,
0.23788698017597198,
-0.7123581171035767,
-1.0959672927856445,
0.138434499502182,
-0.45928850769996643,
-0.27123746275901794,
1.139902949333191,
-0.17347314953804016,
-0.07014313340187073,
-0.17835737764835358,
-0.36460596323013306,
0.18177853524684906,
-0.4057518541812897,
0.8946142196655273,
0.8148509860038757,
-0.03456580266356468,
-0.39069342613220215,
-0.3846679627895355,
0.5049430131912231,
0.30250439047813416,
-0.8497171401977539,
-0.05782397463917732,
0.6125707030296326,
0.04909159988164902,
0.2725714445114136,
0.515381395816803,
-0.08109515905380249,
0.1252259910106659,
0.30116987228393555,
-0.2482762336730957,
-0.27707192301750183,
-0.3506385087966919,
-0.5509220957756042,
0.18784108757972717,
0.13482652604579926,
0.02223747782409191
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15306v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15306v1
|
Advanced Multimodal Deep Learning Architecture for Image-Text Matching
| 2024-06-13T08:32:24 | 2024-06-13T08:32:24 |
Jinyin Wang, Haijing Zhang, Yihao Zhong, Yingbin Liang, Rongwei Ji, Yiru Cang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Image-text matching is a key multimodal task that aims to model the semantic
association between images and text as a matching relationship. With the advent
of the multimedia information age, image, and text data show explosive growth,
and how to accurately realize the efficient and accurate semantic
correspondence between them has become the core issue of common concern in
academia and industry. In this study, we delve into the limitations of current
multimodal deep learning models in processing image-text pairing tasks.
Therefore, we innovatively design an advanced multimodal deep learning
architecture, which combines the high-level abstract representation ability of
deep neural networks for visual information with the advantages of natural
language processing models for text semantic understanding. By introducing a
novel cross-modal attention mechanism and hierarchical feature fusion strategy,
the model achieves deep fusion and two-way interaction between image and text
feature space. In addition, we also optimize the training objectives and loss
functions to ensure that the model can better map the potential association
structure between images and text during the learning process. Experiments show
that compared with existing image-text matching models, the optimized new model
has significantly improved performance on a series of benchmark data sets. In
addition, the new model also shows excellent generalization and robustness on
large and diverse open scenario datasets and can maintain high matching
performance even in the face of previously unseen complex situations.
|
[
-0.30044957995414734,
-0.7243661284446716,
0.5766043066978455,
0.10295229405164719,
-0.5286972522735596,
-0.056274186819791794,
-0.13794922828674316,
-0.8389675617218018,
-0.11479807645082474,
0.34438085556030273,
-0.5977163910865784,
-0.46421217918395996,
-0.5739691853523254,
-0.07286998629570007,
-0.21820466220378876,
0.6919363737106323,
-0.15509557723999023,
0.0702558383345604,
-0.5177949666976929,
-0.5155133008956909,
-0.7296523451805115,
-0.08819960057735443,
-0.5855616927146912,
-0.17590713500976562,
0.5511616468429565,
0.10471389442682266,
0.8463555574417114,
0.6342220306396484,
0.8948033452033997,
0.3987351357936859,
0.2143739014863968,
0.3873215913772583,
-0.2946835160255432,
0.25627458095550537,
-0.07594607025384903,
-0.09454900771379471,
-0.3839225769042969,
-0.080406554043293,
0.6084561944007874,
0.3015590310096741,
0.4017847180366516,
-0.10160601884126663,
-0.12718862295150757,
0.6063761711120605,
-0.648553729057312,
0.2608880400657654,
-0.6418355703353882,
0.23321892321109772,
-0.14844024181365967,
-0.3113504648208618,
-0.3204955458641052,
0.1711253523826599,
0.2584179937839508,
-0.7446199059486389,
0.20484477281570435,
0.14581742882728577,
0.8697644472122192,
0.304380863904953,
-0.6972442865371704,
-0.3307112157344818,
-0.38179171085357666,
0.4613996744155884,
-0.3294127881526947,
0.5667647123336792,
0.256838321685791,
0.2690686285495758,
0.16242991387844086,
-0.6124575138092041,
-0.8509082198143005,
-0.007530095987021923,
-0.21069175004959106,
0.1422855705022812,
0.04532460868358612,
0.06071612611413002,
-0.1799744814634323,
0.45006853342056274,
-0.6488664150238037,
0.09747913479804993,
-0.12805110216140747,
-0.07643866539001465,
0.26198825240135193,
0.23460517823696136,
0.5921785831451416,
-0.09911054372787476,
-0.8578760027885437,
-0.33522823452949524,
0.009631066583096981,
0.040734291076660156,
0.003177046310156584,
0.07720726728439331,
-0.21638068556785583,
0.5069911479949951,
0.06698387116193771,
0.7360649704933167,
-0.21943604946136475,
0.14825019240379333,
0.32534778118133545,
-0.7870772480964661,
-0.23732666671276093,
-0.015467803925275803,
0.9234354496002197,
0.6419761776924133,
0.07113046199083328,
-0.09044865518808365,
-0.2206643521785736,
0.34202122688293457,
0.05562157556414604,
-0.6923777461051941,
-0.1339857131242752,
-0.22786404192447662,
-0.5796907544136047,
-0.17633269727230072,
-0.20051585137844086,
-0.8006437420845032,
-0.32038185000419617,
-0.43780362606048584,
0.78201824426651,
-0.49168360233306885,
-0.17529809474945068,
0.09949976205825806,
-0.1007249504327774,
0.2693140208721161,
0.29717713594436646,
-0.8777642846107483,
0.04668406397104263,
0.4555208384990692,
0.8293192982673645,
-0.11978123337030411,
-0.30733636021614075,
-0.41822153329849243,
0.29576361179351807,
-0.16483472287654877,
0.7771140933036804,
-0.7589637637138367,
0.04793340340256691,
-0.04574925824999809,
-0.1470930129289627,
-0.2829941511154175,
-0.15140455961227417,
0.6346808671951294,
-0.7066797018051147,
0.3352462947368622,
0.24416622519493103,
-0.3634481430053711,
-0.3250376284122467,
0.4759942591190338,
-0.9460553526878357,
0.8309249877929688,
-0.34531113505363464,
-0.7593937516212463,
0.2689064145088196,
-0.6503665447235107,
-0.5888240337371826,
0.07302909344434738,
-0.3226407766342163,
-0.5501419305801392,
-0.0551091730594635,
0.4258490204811096,
0.7337520718574524,
-0.5170341730117798,
0.3017103672027588,
-0.4955156743526459,
-0.33233386278152466,
0.2770119309425354,
-0.6077600121498108,
0.36218345165252686,
0.05656108632683754,
-0.23571787774562836,
0.1420861780643463,
-0.6925210356712341,
-0.031033890321850777,
0.05950308218598366,
-0.2689547538757324,
-0.611031174659729,
-0.2718576192855835,
0.648235023021698,
0.44290870428085327,
0.3534923195838928,
-0.41663315892219543,
-0.06099553033709526,
-0.07978604733943939,
0.348528653383255,
0.641493022441864,
-0.2600671350955963,
0.7652963995933533,
-0.14428769052028656,
0.1652718186378479,
0.20799851417541504,
0.08098699152469635,
-0.8140049576759338,
-0.459270715713501,
-0.5829826593399048,
-0.38667699694633484,
0.34698083996772766,
0.5977922081947327,
-0.8240212798118591,
0.3430991470813751,
-0.35630911588668823,
-0.3063103258609772,
-0.8319336771965027,
0.14920879900455475,
0.6701719164848328,
0.4705042839050293,
0.37243664264678955,
-0.4075915515422821,
-0.3981603682041168,
-1.0864272117614746,
-0.22020286321640015,
0.3260125517845154,
0.20349013805389404,
0.6312739849090576,
0.4817452132701874,
-0.6096314191818237,
0.6433925032615662,
-0.21874862909317017,
-0.787172257900238,
-0.06746748089790344,
0.14326122403144836,
-0.16571961343288422,
0.5609641075134277,
0.5328477025032043,
-1.414650559425354,
-0.5685403943061829,
0.2920527458190918,
-0.8057436347007751,
0.4852012097835541,
-0.17649595439434052,
-0.14808402955532074,
0.22209669649600983,
0.4293290376663208,
-0.5613803863525391,
0.17770329117774963,
0.6688746809959412,
-0.47362810373306274,
-0.03823275864124298,
-0.35118886828422546,
0.5107111930847168,
-1.406359314918518,
0.05089735984802246,
0.3576893210411072,
-0.030427532270550728,
-0.4724833369255066,
0.08113027364015579,
0.2327040582895279,
-0.3915829062461853,
-0.33760344982147217,
0.47672849893569946,
-0.39183422923088074,
0.0027188826352357864,
-0.20160338282585144,
0.1676492989063263,
0.22112271189689636,
0.6015470623970032,
0.2249685823917389,
0.44867512583732605,
0.7567338347434998,
-0.3894670009613037,
0.5025796294212341,
0.3425312042236328,
-0.28822848200798035,
0.6288543939590454,
-0.4602840542793274,
0.051604609936475754,
-0.39283934235572815,
0.30847442150115967,
-1.2971529960632324,
-0.3082575798034668,
0.15699517726898193,
-0.5278506875038147,
0.2823687493801117,
0.2687881886959076,
-0.4505610466003418,
0.045799318701028824,
-0.22213631868362427,
0.9888186454772949,
0.15624359250068665,
-0.4790584146976471,
1.026667833328247,
0.07227901369333267,
-0.09644166380167007,
-0.7006067037582397,
-0.7695920467376709,
0.3734583854675293,
0.21479308605194092,
-0.9114567041397095,
0.7395289540290833,
0.08989857882261276,
0.27111953496932983,
0.21096572279930115,
0.11742144078016281,
-0.40147513151168823,
-0.17232723534107208,
0.13169999420642853,
0.3706442713737488,
-0.24422553181648254,
0.29407668113708496,
0.00886292289942503,
-0.2598721981048584,
-0.3321599066257477,
0.10905834287405014,
0.39247769117355347,
-0.12656070291996002,
-0.17079700529575348,
-0.7492856979370117,
0.7546070218086243,
0.8655465245246887,
-0.5462902784347534,
0.6601434350013733,
0.9680807590484619,
-0.4632687270641327,
0.37326398491859436,
-0.5156923532485962,
0.046890564262866974,
-0.4551011323928833,
0.7217215895652771,
-0.4923051595687866,
-0.7850269675254822,
0.12706033885478973,
0.0862751305103302,
-0.08877111971378326,
0.2839890420436859,
0.28856775164604187,
-0.25814366340637207,
1.0441161394119263,
0.8872452974319458,
0.03496767580509186,
0.41261881589889526,
0.12252986431121826,
0.1761740744113922,
-0.5987749695777893,
-0.6196700930595398,
-0.1643754094839096,
-0.5359894037246704,
-0.47441452741622925,
-0.5978962182998657,
0.12830208241939545,
-0.3429153561592102,
0.03202879801392555,
0.34509754180908203,
-0.3295956254005432,
0.47641757130622864,
0.5555738806724548,
0.4140876829624176,
0.31771907210350037,
-0.0035173932556062937,
-0.07114222645759583,
-0.25327497720718384,
-0.5606464743614197,
-0.17661969363689423,
0.6917238831520081,
0.40159597992897034,
0.8892406225204468,
0.04694943130016327,
0.2191840410232544,
0.14352168142795563,
-0.14998924732208252,
-0.7092880010604858,
0.6204599142074585,
-0.36664265394210815,
-0.26479461789131165,
0.03129372000694275,
-0.45432600378990173,
-0.6812669038772583,
0.3088863790035248,
-0.8673612475395203,
-0.005810209084302187,
0.17215704917907715,
0.19640178978443146,
0.14291442930698395,
0.1748049408197403,
-0.7385891675949097,
1.1871658563613892,
-0.4521489143371582,
-0.34471628069877625,
-0.3317583203315735,
-0.9099761247634888,
0.39890649914741516,
0.008668890222907066,
0.2328517585992813,
0.09221361577510834,
-0.3571504056453705,
0.46955329179763794,
0.48305246233940125,
0.7970414161682129,
0.2799547016620636,
-0.07108745723962784,
-0.33335766196250916,
-0.10292994976043701,
0.17263314127922058,
-0.02528095431625843,
0.1728338897228241,
-0.10833235830068588,
-0.35790690779685974,
-0.31580761075019836,
-0.5175768136978149,
0.7013964056968689,
-0.6020092964172363,
-0.17714591324329376,
-0.30192023515701294,
-0.8541324734687805,
-0.00015773894847370684,
0.25880271196365356,
0.21352910995483398,
0.7409433722496033,
-0.20055218040943146,
0.4199069142341614,
0.9060503244400024,
-0.16909544169902802,
0.7770492434501648,
0.09696103632450104,
0.19295445084571838,
-0.8087809085845947,
0.845623254776001,
-0.4014582633972168,
0.1213546097278595,
0.9028773307800293,
-0.18602435290813446,
-0.4444219470024109,
-0.26744842529296875,
-0.5531637668609619,
-0.0218192245811224,
-0.8154143691062927,
-0.1575384885072708,
-0.9058375358581543,
0.012796930968761444,
-0.45651352405548096,
-0.1970834732055664,
-0.1876077651977539,
0.0019113525049760938,
-0.42929771542549133,
0.3741198778152466,
0.20763593912124634,
0.3583819568157196,
0.5434626340866089,
-0.04754629731178284,
-0.9659378528594971,
0.6393857002258301,
0.5572322010993958,
0.5470653772354126,
0.037613432854413986,
-0.18946735560894012,
-0.17607587575912476,
-0.19019919633865356,
-0.19611585140228271,
-0.6225121021270752,
0.07508150488138199,
0.5591633319854736,
0.3867253363132477,
0.32526859641075134,
-0.07583225518465042,
0.6588945388793945,
-0.5097149610519409,
0.41014188528060913,
0.6050127744674683,
-0.7912557721138,
0.384538471698761,
-0.283501535654068,
0.5454378128051758,
0.4690053164958954,
0.4712575674057007,
-0.5853772759437561,
0.007257390301674604,
-0.22751392424106598,
-0.7491182088851929,
0.4781741499900818,
0.28532394766807556,
0.1590842604637146,
0.28140777349472046,
0.22289343178272247,
-0.04194575175642967,
0.1329641193151474,
-1.0833051204681396,
-0.0226287804543972,
-0.15121036767959595,
-0.708409309387207,
-0.20170454680919647,
-0.05839581415057182,
0.07209843397140503,
-0.26449576020240784,
0.3385210335254669,
-0.33540797233581543,
0.31561195850372314,
0.07439126819372177,
-0.4244338870048523,
0.024441923946142197,
0.21147248148918152,
0.7085278630256653,
0.28427860140800476,
0.1777440458536148,
0.301099568605423,
0.0005248473607935011,
-0.37496626377105713,
0.18467743694782257,
0.43588972091674805,
0.26099443435668945,
-0.1643790751695633,
0.5041677951812744,
0.9908881783485413,
0.3416309058666229,
-0.8622570633888245,
0.6832576394081116,
-0.2735733091831207,
-0.19410473108291626,
0.03435451537370682,
-0.10376947373151779,
0.13321620225906372,
0.47128012776374817,
0.5299398899078369,
0.6090011596679688,
0.1986819952726364,
-0.7175030708312988,
0.3541789650917053,
0.678931474685669,
-0.5964203476905823,
-0.013662648387253284,
0.5869956612586975,
0.39414259791374207,
-0.41797348856925964,
0.3920544385910034,
0.17982785403728485,
-0.5596887469291687,
0.6243985295295715,
0.49978089332580566,
0.6720466613769531,
0.024448828771710396,
0.1653377264738083,
-0.02283802442252636,
0.22596290707588196,
0.174203023314476,
-0.007599561475217342,
-0.24865593016147614,
-0.5748199224472046,
-0.5107203125953674,
-0.4657430350780487,
-0.25063127279281616,
-0.07021041959524155,
-0.32405272126197815,
0.3042939603328705,
-0.1672116369009018,
0.08716412633657455,
-0.03685914725065231,
-0.2447333186864853,
-0.678916871547699,
0.4909456968307495,
0.18774594366550446,
0.7208119630813599,
-0.7972888946533203,
0.6650330424308777,
0.9178727269172668,
-0.32111483812332153,
-0.23945529758930206,
-0.15295128524303436,
-0.33861491084098816,
-0.6376354694366455,
0.5546540021896362,
0.6999275088310242,
-0.020484421402215958,
-0.06108018383383751,
-0.043777335435152054,
-0.513883650302887,
1.1542277336120605,
0.2829362154006958,
-0.5624527335166931,
-0.1219099909067154,
0.16420215368270874,
0.39541754126548767,
-0.5681467652320862,
0.2443167269229889,
0.08935613930225372,
0.3318030834197998,
0.15660300850868225,
-0.7646835446357727,
0.15786489844322205,
-0.5539489388465881,
0.21450628340244293,
0.4298732280731201,
-0.5888484120368958,
0.8057820796966553,
-0.12121336162090302,
-0.022712042555212975,
0.1733405441045761,
0.6729264259338379,
-0.07944655418395996,
0.4935770332813263,
0.5678235292434692,
0.7985112071037292,
0.20060525834560394,
0.023194028064608574,
0.6268954873085022,
0.012436596676707268,
0.1231389194726944,
0.8544686436653137,
-0.2222272902727127,
0.8964239358901978,
0.3778756260871887,
0.4891882538795471,
0.4268287718296051,
0.643443763256073,
-0.154068723320961,
0.7774000763893127,
-0.575619637966156,
-0.4470154941082001,
-0.5811804533004761,
-0.1700827032327652,
-0.40044987201690674,
0.4635560214519501,
0.13924556970596313,
-0.7494745254516602,
-0.30855295062065125,
0.4627781808376312,
-0.5612626075744629,
0.44612690806388855,
-0.30331575870513916,
0.9880951642990112,
-0.22689393162727356,
-0.5264600515365601,
0.0871753990650177,
-0.05548633635044098,
0.9754638671875,
-0.45346567034721375,
-0.20976296067237854,
0.22118951380252838,
0.4972844421863556,
-0.010878515429794788,
-0.872737467288971,
-0.004646367393434048,
-0.5065121054649353,
-0.5014373064041138,
-0.1617751121520996,
0.9072557091712952,
-0.8081551790237427,
-0.42072516679763794,
0.3548879325389862,
0.07417144626379013,
-0.443427711725235,
0.06782524287700653,
-0.8815210461616516,
0.18221533298492432,
-0.3265517055988312,
0.03801548853516579,
0.4287109971046448,
0.4193303883075714,
0.18113896250724792,
0.5193315148353577,
0.520157516002655,
-0.5696096420288086,
-0.18152932822704315,
-0.11441945284605026,
0.7607793211936951,
-0.5680070519447327,
-0.5730795860290527,
-0.9031500220298767,
0.4776131808757782,
-0.12995843589305878,
-0.4898916482925415,
0.39951470494270325,
0.5111367702484131,
0.6230527758598328,
-0.14783914387226105,
0.6038391590118408,
0.14948204159736633,
-0.19124911725521088,
-0.6251882314682007,
0.6323121786117554,
-0.8132823705673218,
-0.18666972219944,
-0.3869270980358124,
-0.9393450021743774,
-0.3810916244983673,
0.43684515357017517,
0.27647602558135986,
0.12007728219032288,
0.6932089328765869,
0.6850837469100952,
-0.36415284872055054,
0.06929086893796921,
0.31914833188056946,
-0.2632249593734741,
0.210552379488945,
0.9028535485267639,
0.556904137134552,
-0.8545909523963928,
0.9132242202758789,
-0.12630178034305573,
-0.3080598711967468,
-0.1248396784067154,
-0.9565975069999695,
-1.0687167644500732,
-0.9829608201980591,
-0.2185511440038681,
-0.043362587690353394,
0.09123252332210541,
0.7511943578720093,
0.6134276390075684,
-0.29686644673347473,
0.17065952718257904,
-0.13955673575401306,
-0.13900364935398102,
-0.16920827329158783,
-0.20302341878414154,
0.41466400027275085,
-0.29948729276657104,
-0.7753180861473083,
0.10606490820646286,
0.6077322363853455,
0.3017270863056183,
-0.19377341866493225,
-0.026313846930861473,
-0.6329081058502197,
-0.14448493719100952,
0.7737232446670532,
-0.08213719725608826,
-0.5503108501434326,
-0.0020687466021627188,
0.22529029846191406,
-0.4202629625797272,
0.05361581966280937,
0.7937607765197754,
-0.6798801422119141,
0.6090025901794434,
0.5406094193458557,
1.3180792331695557,
0.4677158296108246,
-0.354451060295105,
0.6030822992324829,
-0.6262452006340027,
0.22245493531227112,
0.1994035691022873,
0.38184022903442383,
0.5146107077598572,
-0.3924097418785095,
0.15304335951805115,
0.17221865057945251,
-0.42430251836776733,
-0.5511191487312317,
0.2904130518436432,
-1.314157247543335,
-0.3221345841884613,
0.6397815942764282,
0.06608530879020691,
-0.17529237270355225,
0.06083774194121361,
-0.4528784155845642,
0.3136194050312042,
-0.29557961225509644,
0.561367928981781,
0.4925837218761444,
0.1551794707775116,
-0.767784595489502,
-0.1742863804101944,
0.23323889076709747,
0.5710354447364807,
-0.6654794216156006,
-0.32538774609565735,
0.4143785536289215,
-0.10351429879665375,
0.20029136538505554,
0.3618682324886322,
0.11334497481584549,
0.6826757192611694,
-0.1636001616716385,
-0.034765999764204025,
-0.1335761547088623,
-0.405641108751297,
-0.2974703907966614,
0.4041149318218231,
-0.5205246210098267,
-0.5138994455337524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08911v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08911v1
|
An Initial Investigation of Language Adaptation for TTS Systems under Low-resource Scenarios
| 2024-06-13T08:16:52 | 2024-06-13T08:16:52 |
Cheng Gong, Erica Cooper, Xin Wang, Chunyu Qiang, Mengzhe Geng, Dan Wells, Longbiao Wang, Jianwu Dang, Marc Tessier, Aidan Pine, Korin Richmond, Junichi Yamagishi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Self-supervised learning (SSL) representations from massively multilingual
models offer a promising solution for low-resource language speech tasks.
Despite advancements, language adaptation in TTS systems remains an open
problem. This paper explores the language adaptation capability of ZMM-TTS, a
recent SSL-based multilingual TTS system proposed in our previous work. We
conducted experiments on 12 languages using limited data with various
fine-tuning configurations. We demonstrate that the similarity in phonetics
between the pre-training and target languages, as well as the language
category, affects the target language's adaptation performance. Additionally,
we find that the fine-tuning dataset size and number of speakers influence
adaptability. Surprisingly, we also observed that using paired data for
fine-tuning is not always optimal compared to audio-only data. Beyond speech
intelligibility, our analysis covers speaker similarity, language
identification, and predicted MOS.
|
[
-0.25610029697418213,
-0.3739774525165558,
0.4564143717288971,
0.09365659207105637,
-0.5783091187477112,
0.14842554926872253,
-0.6763792634010315,
-0.24355459213256836,
0.03607676550745964,
0.18845650553703308,
-0.6862366199493408,
-0.2960160970687866,
-0.4072306454181671,
0.4612205922603607,
0.014764493331313133,
1.0107144117355347,
0.3163624405860901,
-0.006645645014941692,
0.509760856628418,
-0.37026989459991455,
-0.5161040425300598,
-0.6593020558357239,
-0.6399286985397339,
0.025363512337207794,
0.4007522165775299,
0.7228542566299438,
0.7484831213951111,
0.676541805267334,
0.27282294631004333,
0.2431618571281433,
0.30928105115890503,
0.07251467555761337,
-0.47295689582824707,
0.06724321842193604,
-0.4424945116043091,
-0.4375135898590088,
-0.24212178587913513,
-0.5573300123214722,
0.9577473998069763,
0.5231364965438843,
-0.22281251847743988,
0.3242156505584717,
0.2244112491607666,
0.6029368042945862,
-0.6306575536727905,
0.1383707970380783,
-0.9640092253684998,
0.14506231248378754,
-0.44611072540283203,
-0.28664055466651917,
-0.48005178570747375,
0.10987340658903122,
0.19699090719223022,
-0.6861212253570557,
0.17453628778457642,
0.010172863490879536,
0.09582728892564774,
0.3240280747413635,
-0.13418881595134735,
-0.34693053364753723,
-0.8790654540061951,
0.750041663646698,
-0.7650363445281982,
0.7188475131988525,
0.16308891773223877,
0.347709596157074,
-0.013590674847364426,
-0.05928846076130867,
-0.38345107436180115,
-0.15114954113960266,
0.04839255288243294,
0.29224148392677307,
-0.2036263346672058,
0.0000702154211467132,
0.04508569464087486,
0.13585525751113892,
-0.6135018467903137,
0.5363560914993286,
-0.3660103380680084,
-0.27721336483955383,
0.2990396320819855,
0.07520250231027603,
0.3207257390022278,
-0.30191752314567566,
-0.3126140236854553,
-0.1920044720172882,
-0.27032721042633057,
0.02789340913295746,
0.12469054013490677,
1.2584023475646973,
-0.5755733847618103,
0.2555927336215973,
-0.1637803018093109,
0.6027941703796387,
-0.11011235415935516,
-0.22587692737579346,
0.20921994745731354,
-0.38027334213256836,
-0.3670019507408142,
0.3548719882965088,
0.8340443968772888,
0.03352229297161102,
0.47521457076072693,
-0.2666834890842438,
0.0023585306480526924,
-0.21641096472740173,
0.039954133331775665,
-0.5325944423675537,
0.015922818332910538,
-0.07046844065189362,
-0.3090280294418335,
0.3683297336101532,
-0.15482166409492493,
-0.6025959849357605,
-0.34636402130126953,
-0.2413361519575119,
0.563429594039917,
-0.7926048040390015,
-0.5223619341850281,
0.3157472610473633,
-0.0821019634604454,
-0.06759239733219147,
0.1640068143606186,
-1.2188795804977417,
0.37566661834716797,
0.2719855308532715,
1.128860354423523,
-0.2584192454814911,
-0.46377599239349365,
-0.6313081979751587,
0.3213801383972168,
-0.36815062165260315,
0.39264294505119324,
-0.17888249456882477,
-0.44595277309417725,
-0.15073415637016296,
0.099152110517025,
-0.4481511414051056,
-0.4319639205932617,
0.45562249422073364,
-0.1930321902036667,
-0.22306890785694122,
-0.17554235458374023,
-0.11461125314235687,
0.27812302112579346,
-0.4872227609157562,
-0.35348421335220337,
0.6694765090942383,
0.2715126574039459,
-0.3589998781681061,
0.29415640234947205,
-0.5758764743804932,
-0.5122146010398865,
0.04399927705526352,
0.02476528100669384,
-0.16473270952701569,
0.42269793152809143,
-0.06377974897623062,
0.49580228328704834,
-0.10217422246932983,
-0.16545070707798004,
-0.3393794000148773,
-0.4793221354484558,
0.15942421555519104,
-0.43702587485313416,
0.637053906917572,
0.5541907548904419,
-0.043558523058891296,
-0.012282476760447025,
-0.9803120493888855,
0.11773830652236938,
0.07474818825721741,
-0.239445298910141,
-0.3672420084476471,
-0.13679634034633636,
-0.017275061458349228,
0.205564945936203,
0.14068803191184998,
-0.4271257519721985,
-0.018742777407169342,
-0.31604766845703125,
0.5794904232025146,
0.8626155853271484,
-0.3860839903354645,
0.520571768283844,
-0.038923539221286774,
0.6005996465682983,
0.008758442476391792,
0.1631889045238495,
-0.1854931265115738,
-0.0860828086733818,
-0.7976460456848145,
-0.22850939631462097,
0.5309088230133057,
0.6033411622047424,
-1.0442599058151245,
0.09204132854938507,
-0.5010780096054077,
-0.4284781515598297,
-0.6176086664199829,
0.2563675343990326,
0.6023632287979126,
0.2613358497619629,
0.33930763602256775,
-0.2727773189544678,
-0.48232316970825195,
-1.0077357292175293,
-0.09957022964954376,
-0.35435378551483154,
-0.3093492388725281,
0.2035583257675171,
-0.003420573892071843,
0.12294510006904602,
0.6053507924079895,
-0.08579121530056,
-0.36693650484085083,
-0.0737699493765831,
-0.15309244394302368,
0.13195519149303436,
0.40155264735221863,
1.058385968208313,
-0.21094170212745667,
-0.4545932412147522,
0.25762414932250977,
-0.4265628159046173,
-0.027138521894812584,
-0.10732514411211014,
0.1598643660545349,
0.25186091661453247,
0.42529916763305664,
-0.08060983568429947,
-0.07092231512069702,
0.9618679285049438,
-0.21463295817375183,
0.4555180072784424,
-0.7712470889091492,
-0.08261585980653763,
-1.0091674327850342,
-0.3390156924724579,
0.12446251511573792,
-0.08207949250936508,
-0.7404346466064453,
-0.23359517753124237,
0.2501421272754669,
-0.20259486138820648,
-0.42813578248023987,
0.359525591135025,
-0.3779052197933197,
-0.5804123282432556,
-0.30470404028892517,
0.26540738344192505,
-0.46353691816329956,
0.5137780904769897,
0.04416399821639061,
1.2734802961349487,
0.6797107458114624,
-0.8628773093223572,
0.028523758053779602,
0.09135797619819641,
-0.2760179042816162,
0.6531041264533997,
-0.17424611747264862,
0.335105299949646,
-0.02842550165951252,
-0.17677518725395203,
-0.8188093304634094,
-0.1015705093741417,
0.28649598360061646,
-0.33531278371810913,
0.016125615686178207,
-0.3584613800048828,
-0.568918764591217,
-0.035321950912475586,
0.057432666420936584,
0.2838525176048279,
0.3626738488674164,
-0.508870542049408,
0.4634690284729004,
0.12916964292526245,
-0.5074568390846252,
-0.08305446058511734,
-0.6421617865562439,
0.1405133157968521,
-0.19784227013587952,
-0.23818300664424896,
0.16288134455680847,
-0.27894142270088196,
-0.049085672944784164,
-0.29731032252311707,
-0.09497794508934021,
-0.07535634189844131,
0.28457581996917725,
0.045043010264635086,
-0.06785868108272552,
-0.6268860697746277,
0.5241355299949646,
0.23173388838768005,
-0.06443145871162415,
-0.2228265404701233,
-0.3409154713153839,
0.5676017999649048,
-0.22136391699314117,
-0.27582505345344543,
-0.5320935249328613,
0.08130370825529099,
0.63191819190979,
-0.06093856319785118,
0.6095648407936096,
0.6624578237533569,
-0.07831483334302902,
-0.27301183342933655,
-0.18022800981998444,
0.005063066724687815,
-0.509974479675293,
0.5525267720222473,
-0.7577241063117981,
-0.9050470590591431,
0.4756326377391815,
-0.006062553729861975,
-0.2672475576400757,
0.4962118864059448,
0.5522474646568298,
-0.015008390881121159,
0.7416043281555176,
0.7757939100265503,
-0.24841485917568207,
0.7531359195709229,
0.3941018581390381,
-0.05468631908297539,
-0.6062895059585571,
0.15521107614040375,
-0.7018731832504272,
-0.04624272882938385,
-0.9180487394332886,
-0.2619933485984802,
0.30348703265190125,
0.016026558354496956,
-0.17500382661819458,
0.5434494614601135,
-0.1960674673318863,
-0.006095679942518473,
0.5062035322189331,
0.08924631774425507,
0.21320727467536926,
0.08605210483074188,
-0.1444166600704193,
-0.08971988409757614,
-0.9879390001296997,
-0.2571115493774414,
0.9355505704879761,
0.20005445182323456,
0.5189954042434692,
0.3670880198478699,
0.38601627945899963,
0.441638708114624,
-0.22888977825641632,
-0.4887654483318329,
0.3480965793132782,
-0.6543452143669128,
-0.2934568524360657,
-0.7308096289634705,
-0.3073619604110718,
-0.800510585308075,
0.334040105342865,
-0.4030543863773346,
-0.7050750851631165,
0.05424012988805771,
-0.06463754177093506,
-0.8005515336990356,
0.15853023529052734,
-1.143460988998413,
0.3570164740085602,
-0.3132636845111847,
-0.07658001035451889,
-0.37969598174095154,
-0.5324459075927734,
-0.10062913596630096,
-0.6353709101676941,
0.6702613830566406,
-0.2324049174785614,
0.25453683733940125,
0.889040470123291,
-0.0009711254970170557,
0.7512982487678528,
-0.13065984845161438,
-0.23205845057964325,
0.004637532867491245,
0.03144379332661629,
0.12137383222579956,
0.05688505619764328,
-0.44805458188056946,
0.066124327480793,
0.24157217144966125,
-0.44728490710258484,
-0.6308388710021973,
0.6679036021232605,
-0.9441970586776733,
-0.7078649401664734,
-0.18560412526130676,
-0.6558697819709778,
-0.568494439125061,
0.2938109040260315,
-0.1816689372062683,
0.3611493408679962,
-0.12084135413169861,
0.28389352560043335,
0.4719655215740204,
-0.3771597146987915,
0.5542123317718506,
0.8425991535186768,
-0.26129505038261414,
-0.27377554774284363,
1.037313461303711,
0.3140297532081604,
0.5478684306144714,
0.0756458044052124,
0.38898634910583496,
-0.15742744505405426,
-0.8400831818580627,
-0.9932265877723694,
0.18456386029720306,
-0.3148968517780304,
0.03534049168229103,
-0.203691303730011,
-0.2930278182029724,
-0.4054730534553528,
0.0993637964129448,
-0.47684431076049805,
-0.4579572081565857,
-0.6580527424812317,
-0.014593751169741154,
0.5777294635772705,
0.41985148191452026,
-0.2208642065525055,
0.7014496326446533,
-0.8910661935806274,
0.4397848844528198,
0.31283292174339294,
0.6619391441345215,
-0.23195892572402954,
-1.0349220037460327,
-0.6640746593475342,
0.04336712881922722,
0.2617448568344116,
-0.5044060945510864,
0.06143487989902496,
0.6129566431045532,
0.38383209705352783,
0.34980618953704834,
0.29332220554351807,
0.8320181369781494,
-0.609825849533081,
0.5665454864501953,
0.230451300740242,
-0.9975025653839111,
0.514298677444458,
-0.5480280518531799,
0.4460742175579071,
0.4251604378223419,
-0.040490128099918365,
-0.5173549056053162,
-0.312753289937973,
-0.24566657841205597,
-0.1787341982126236,
1.0059359073638916,
0.27776628732681274,
0.38843223452568054,
0.26799046993255615,
0.5341243743896484,
0.35100895166397095,
-0.15776996314525604,
-0.3311815559864044,
-0.26283666491508484,
-0.25543534755706787,
-0.3237004578113556,
-0.531632661819458,
-0.21440212428569794,
0.19351811707019806,
-0.053595636039972305,
0.456491082906723,
-0.4401397407054901,
0.1286771446466446,
-0.11093419790267944,
-0.22603656351566315,
-0.30200448632240295,
0.5610228180885315,
0.7213711142539978,
0.527970016002655,
-0.25194817781448364,
0.006449599284678698,
0.5531380772590637,
-0.38343891501426697,
0.13239754736423492,
0.1454123556613922,
0.11275965720415115,
-0.006773946341127157,
0.2058538943529129,
1.0538369417190552,
0.48376888036727905,
-0.6571850776672363,
0.054879557341337204,
-0.013051256537437439,
-0.03212582692503929,
-0.022117504850029945,
0.417292058467865,
-0.055686794221401215,
0.44633713364601135,
0.5805652737617493,
-0.11452502757310867,
-0.15959329903125763,
-0.6266834139823914,
-0.06891067326068878,
0.41361942887306213,
-0.44444969296455383,
-0.5840657353401184,
0.49602240324020386,
0.15169091522693634,
-0.606965184211731,
0.17653271555900574,
0.07976395636796951,
-0.12821464240550995,
0.38396739959716797,
0.7674716114997864,
0.48642075061798096,
-0.7422517538070679,
0.25076159834861755,
0.16390596330165863,
0.378543496131897,
-0.01717728190124035,
0.24420468509197235,
-0.12114325165748596,
-0.775449275970459,
-0.25464847683906555,
-0.5315861105918884,
-0.46518203616142273,
0.03580648824572563,
-0.7358589172363281,
0.3848596215248108,
-0.5099995732307434,
-0.31845617294311523,
0.003008441533893347,
-0.25054600834846497,
-0.6631025075912476,
0.3645075857639313,
0.2220127433538437,
0.7549296021461487,
-0.9048722386360168,
1.1763523817062378,
0.37788456678390503,
0.09632288664579391,
-0.49106723070144653,
-0.15376517176628113,
-0.22983917593955994,
-1.0142768621444702,
0.3750787377357483,
-0.3380673825740814,
-0.5679513812065125,
0.28303948044776917,
-0.0027906931936740875,
-1.0377165079116821,
1.0046056509017944,
0.8807690143585205,
-0.640019953250885,
0.09349170327186584,
0.471199631690979,
0.7520860433578491,
-0.16291740536689758,
-0.15952245891094208,
0.5401570200920105,
0.11914397031068802,
-0.3596338927745819,
-1.4681205749511719,
-0.1691000759601593,
0.1519860029220581,
0.06571485102176666,
-0.03793874382972717,
-0.9697839021682739,
0.7857987284660339,
-0.13945430517196655,
-0.32461270689964294,
0.09408383071422577,
0.7277870178222656,
0.1400354951620102,
0.1148620992898941,
0.7385913133621216,
0.1327284723520279,
0.6928789615631104,
0.04237482696771622,
0.5674954056739807,
-0.3466244339942932,
0.24529770016670227,
1.0857855081558228,
-0.23355646431446075,
0.7441422939300537,
0.46105819940567017,
-0.3526499271392822,
0.3409498929977417,
0.3985805809497833,
0.15574343502521515,
0.7399077415466309,
0.02902894839644432,
-0.042375948280096054,
-0.3720645308494568,
-0.2398027777671814,
-0.5868880152702332,
0.6973347067832947,
0.5687366724014282,
-0.28563594818115234,
-0.14767372608184814,
0.45067399740219116,
-0.4494604468345642,
-0.0387117862701416,
-0.4349069595336914,
0.680770993232727,
0.09128051996231079,
-0.18982328474521637,
0.5330432653427124,
-0.06943552196025848,
0.5207607746124268,
-0.5488998293876648,
0.3622620403766632,
0.033970415592193604,
0.12089023739099503,
0.09241076558828354,
-0.5632227063179016,
0.03435148671269417,
-0.058832183480262756,
-0.12172120064496994,
-0.19399240612983704,
0.7562360763549805,
-0.07837000489234924,
-0.5412967801094055,
0.5952720642089844,
0.9594407677650452,
-0.043313197791576385,
0.1553005576133728,
-0.4476557672023773,
0.21031856536865234,
-0.11733385920524597,
0.1539410948753357,
0.7582080960273743,
0.8722328543663025,
0.15398883819580078,
0.7916847467422485,
0.6651052832603455,
0.2046099156141281,
0.2189733386039734,
0.20484332740306854,
0.5642781853675842,
-0.7390708923339844,
-0.7806509733200073,
-0.7828128933906555,
-0.04786190018057823,
0.46704986691474915,
-0.2004881054162979,
0.9082196354866028,
0.42734092473983765,
0.9108327031135559,
-0.24486128985881805,
1.0177685022354126,
0.4710039496421814,
0.6557241082191467,
-0.8773519396781921,
0.5069791078567505,
-0.4867021143436432,
-0.05725152790546417,
-0.4450839161872864,
-0.4819977283477783,
-0.11812930554151535,
0.2986816465854645,
-0.06423944979906082,
-0.07437987625598907,
0.49354293942451477,
0.39954251050949097,
-0.1425217092037201,
0.22127898037433624,
0.7217196226119995,
0.08775367587804794,
-0.18022775650024414,
0.41202372312545776,
0.6360529661178589,
-0.14956289529800415,
0.6760674715042114,
-0.19977623224258423,
-0.1607169508934021,
-0.4124235510826111,
-0.6587742567062378,
-0.7985826134681702,
-0.7527896761894226,
-0.09006211906671524,
-0.04117667302489281,
0.3790539503097534,
0.8746163845062256,
0.5522524118423462,
-0.8814660906791687,
-0.3331131935119629,
0.3356119692325592,
0.023786915466189384,
-0.2600468695163727,
-0.09472661465406418,
0.4085933268070221,
-0.2952205538749695,
-0.6909372806549072,
0.692940890789032,
0.4761238694190979,
0.21504256129264832,
-0.11003454774618149,
-0.08900682628154755,
0.36245614290237427,
-0.14024965465068817,
0.6770819425582886,
0.39823052287101746,
-0.5693821907043457,
-0.7036410570144653,
-0.001866452395915985,
0.055810026824474335,
0.3090790808200836,
0.7588855624198914,
-0.6396117210388184,
0.6244773864746094,
-0.175980344414711,
0.6708160042762756,
0.2560863494873047,
-0.2547476887702942,
0.46825578808784485,
-0.5473716259002686,
0.3780020475387573,
-0.22326932847499847,
0.315923273563385,
0.20185281336307526,
-0.1834334433078766,
0.2475953996181488,
0.010224415920674801,
-0.14985764026641846,
-0.6527239084243774,
0.2090027779340744,
-1.1411809921264648,
-0.21479082107543945,
1.215152621269226,
0.07009405642747879,
0.0707872286438942,
-0.35517603158950806,
-0.18256069719791412,
0.526642918586731,
-0.4768820106983185,
0.8065226674079895,
0.7938587665557861,
-0.028286343440413475,
-0.22829976677894592,
-0.6053386926651001,
0.2981395125389099,
0.47423768043518066,
-0.4975697696208954,
0.1862991601228714,
0.10762163996696472,
0.36567381024360657,
0.10661529749631882,
0.6659713983535767,
0.3218793272972107,
0.1379232555627823,
-0.3379767835140228,
-0.29422760009765625,
0.08832374215126038,
-0.1844811886548996,
-0.6868425607681274,
0.0005955154774710536,
0.35328078269958496,
-0.30690810084342957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08903v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08903v1
|
Delta-CoMe: Training-Free Delta-Compression with Mixed-Precision for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T07:57:27 | 2024-06-13T07:57:27 |
Bowen Ping, Shuo Wang, Hanqing Wang, Xu Han, Yuzhuang Xu, Yukun Yan, Yun Chen, Baobao Chang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning is a crucial process for adapting large language models (LLMs) to
diverse applications. In certain scenarios, such as multi-tenant serving,
deploying multiple LLMs becomes necessary to meet complex demands. Recent
studies suggest decomposing a fine-tuned LLM into a base model and
corresponding delta weights, which are then compressed using low-rank or
low-bit approaches to reduce costs. In this work, we observe that existing
low-rank and low-bit compression methods can significantly harm the model
performance for task-specific fine-tuned LLMs (e.g., WizardMath for math
problems). Motivated by the long-tail distribution of singular values in the
delta weights, we propose a delta quantization approach using mixed-precision.
This method employs higher-bit representation for singular vectors
corresponding to larger singular values. We evaluate our approach on various
fine-tuned LLMs, including math LLMs, code LLMs, chat LLMs, and even VLMs.
Experimental results demonstrate that our approach performs comparably to full
fine-tuned LLMs, surpassing both low-rank and low-bit baselines by a
considerable margin. Additionally, we show that our method is compatible with
various backbone LLMs, such as Llama-2, Llama-3, and Mistral, highlighting its
generalizability.
|
[
-0.5023349523544312,
-0.5963839292526245,
0.22966885566711426,
0.153931125998497,
-0.5788655281066895,
0.011464567855000496,
-0.771355926990509,
-0.3110261559486389,
0.15568923950195312,
0.4609030783176422,
-0.47003474831581116,
-0.6715683937072754,
-0.5842739939689636,
0.005651334300637245,
0.02834732085466385,
0.795038640499115,
0.1194680780172348,
0.2357308268547058,
0.1571064293384552,
-0.06622768938541412,
-0.6603720188140869,
-0.681724488735199,
-0.5065821409225464,
-0.08207161724567413,
0.5693904161453247,
0.43051719665527344,
0.7996967434883118,
0.5936223268508911,
0.3213019371032715,
0.1939956247806549,
-0.11851447075605392,
0.4248526990413666,
-0.5652593970298767,
0.3727708160877228,
0.11623124033212662,
-0.6125907897949219,
-0.7745407223701477,
-0.3900114893913269,
0.7436330914497375,
0.8638491630554199,
-0.08312325924634933,
0.14782443642616272,
0.18517132103443146,
0.7752795219421387,
-1.044447660446167,
0.13511978089809418,
-0.5887147784233093,
-0.06560945510864258,
-0.17906349897384644,
-0.14645203948020935,
-0.2900373935699463,
-0.4280208945274353,
-0.3677237033843994,
-0.5409985780715942,
0.31252849102020264,
-0.07047929614782333,
0.665585994720459,
0.5956296324729919,
-0.46889424324035645,
0.1346028596162796,
-0.8029711246490479,
1.122705340385437,
-0.8035359382629395,
0.6017062664031982,
0.23680540919303894,
0.36817100644111633,
-0.32696428894996643,
-0.2533721327781677,
-0.4238716661930084,
0.10821092128753662,
0.39695966243743896,
-0.1139431893825531,
0.004380420781672001,
0.3084034323692322,
0.017723936587572098,
0.6326335668563843,
-0.3454020917415619,
0.42186838388442993,
-0.1477920562028885,
-0.09279480576515198,
0.4854949116706848,
0.043479982763528824,
-0.06804173439741135,
0.068415567278862,
0.14986249804496765,
-0.22715811431407928,
-0.8214049339294434,
-0.01788989081978798,
0.4252241551876068,
0.9652671813964844,
-0.04500563442707062,
0.671718180179596,
-0.3810019791126251,
0.7930380702018738,
0.3041597008705139,
-0.01818329095840454,
-0.17806625366210938,
-0.31416866183280945,
-0.458478182554245,
-0.09495829045772552,
0.5017057657241821,
0.3321855068206787,
0.5098522901535034,
-0.2305205762386322,
-0.26862168312072754,
-0.05295631289482117,
0.22434182465076447,
-0.9591800570487976,
-0.19178198277950287,
0.24716123938560486,
-0.2899659276008606,
-0.06149940565228462,
-0.31524914503097534,
-0.40063542127609253,
-0.34565573930740356,
-0.6358892917633057,
0.49607282876968384,
-0.2863057553768158,
-0.04121146351099014,
0.3431831896305084,
0.1400570571422577,
0.04988611489534378,
0.6816719770431519,
-1.101037621498108,
0.2492935061454773,
0.8376573324203491,
0.8483058214187622,
-0.1388879418373108,
-0.021951552480459213,
-0.7968683242797852,
-0.10469578951597214,
-0.41822099685668945,
0.41990402340888977,
-0.2217782735824585,
-0.20096445083618164,
0.1654130071401596,
-0.2136492282152176,
0.3086543083190918,
-0.685238778591156,
0.7370961308479309,
-0.6071968078613281,
-0.3479980528354645,
-0.27641046047210693,
-0.33203572034835815,
0.0457632802426815,
0.11958255618810654,
-0.6295711994171143,
0.8853539824485779,
0.26744788885116577,
-0.3729315400123596,
0.450621098279953,
-0.16017168760299683,
-0.23988166451454163,
0.09524502605199814,
-0.09234877675771713,
-0.40175116062164307,
0.43179893493652344,
0.4075717031955719,
0.7560046315193176,
-0.37079742550849915,
0.013357712887227535,
-0.5481140613555908,
-0.60599684715271,
0.008898396044969559,
-0.5284444689750671,
0.7992584109306335,
0.028157930821180344,
-0.0028960234485566616,
-0.06795661896467209,
-0.6715964078903198,
0.2739873230457306,
-0.24431805312633514,
-0.5828883647918701,
-0.4171130657196045,
-0.22249634563922882,
-0.04089057072997093,
0.0025017845910042524,
0.46075642108917236,
-0.23460136353969574,
0.5685587525367737,
-0.38118457794189453,
-0.02221887931227684,
0.7839858531951904,
-0.15343816578388214,
0.5831537842750549,
-0.22582359611988068,
0.34826818108558655,
-0.007651940453797579,
0.14677906036376953,
0.2745574116706848,
-0.2276565581560135,
-1.147589087486267,
-0.7725042104721069,
0.5536893606185913,
0.3544350564479828,
-0.6344985365867615,
0.8342248201370239,
-0.6847782135009766,
-0.4531238079071045,
-0.7228434085845947,
0.2091183364391327,
0.07884398102760315,
-0.14786675572395325,
0.454232782125473,
-0.3632729947566986,
-0.3111579418182373,
-0.971473217010498,
-0.15392689406871796,
0.17308124899864197,
-0.2956344187259674,
0.21072372794151306,
0.269458144903183,
0.002085179788991809,
0.8921990394592285,
-0.3698975741863251,
-0.1840447187423706,
0.2319757640361786,
0.12321671843528748,
0.3690553903579712,
0.520112931728363,
0.4325760304927826,
-0.41901782155036926,
-0.4555650055408478,
0.03633221611380577,
-0.37668392062187195,
-0.08565714210271835,
0.15062396228313446,
-0.10814818739891052,
0.19563916325569153,
0.08708252757787704,
-0.6400309205055237,
0.2826280891895294,
0.7971006035804749,
-0.0925179272890091,
0.5635756850242615,
-0.28011029958724976,
0.13784098625183105,
-1.0395481586456299,
-0.20074740052223206,
-0.051872096955776215,
-0.4382167458534241,
-0.6074038743972778,
0.1291564255952835,
0.2829805314540863,
0.05823138728737831,
-0.42217978835105896,
0.30046167969703674,
-0.47507545351982117,
-0.07883195579051971,
-0.3445589244365692,
-0.39621034264564514,
-0.2076316624879837,
0.7898730039596558,
-0.032252129167318344,
0.9016237854957581,
0.527579665184021,
-1.0320677757263184,
0.2648908793926239,
-0.18909980356693268,
-0.2604883015155792,
0.7403512597084045,
-0.43205541372299194,
0.2780172824859619,
-0.05568166822195053,
0.2065732330083847,
-0.4765292704105377,
-0.00900727417320013,
0.002839373890310526,
-0.21568353474140167,
0.4614982306957245,
-0.5795196890830994,
-0.8098313808441162,
0.09581214934587479,
-0.4283566176891327,
0.533238410949707,
0.485825777053833,
-0.47445252537727356,
0.36766019463539124,
0.055250756442546844,
-0.2318962961435318,
-0.7986242771148682,
-0.6127594709396362,
-0.004078933037817478,
-0.17822405695915222,
-0.4457743167877197,
0.24979452788829803,
-0.30598142743110657,
-0.14732716977596283,
-0.35794416069984436,
-0.19682437181472778,
-0.11922290176153183,
0.16421912610530853,
0.2989284098148346,
0.0019133301684632897,
-0.2945669889450073,
-0.08732413500547409,
0.4505682587623596,
0.07007911056280136,
-0.419827401638031,
-0.5252776145935059,
0.6244394779205322,
-0.2620628774166107,
-0.33286041021347046,
-0.046706538647413254,
0.37535005807876587,
0.576092541217804,
0.18113195896148682,
0.7807285785675049,
0.3698453903198242,
-0.5946272015571594,
-0.46631166338920593,
-0.3282471001148224,
-0.18410752713680267,
-0.5252598524093628,
0.24528425931930542,
-0.3559660315513611,
-1.0608733892440796,
0.3389817178249359,
-0.27162542939186096,
0.4157089293003082,
0.19432947039604187,
0.9114693403244019,
-0.07569455355405807,
0.6547172665596008,
0.8434489965438843,
0.0040298025123775005,
0.4057997465133667,
-0.05364813655614853,
0.13645197451114655,
-0.5869104266166687,
0.22838686406612396,
-0.6623945832252502,
-0.3773844540119171,
-0.6007167100906372,
-0.6737402081489563,
0.3266131281852722,
0.6361420154571533,
-0.40472275018692017,
0.3754134774208069,
-0.4232574999332428,
0.4786621928215027,
0.5876124501228333,
0.03434324637055397,
0.31231096386909485,
0.1966363787651062,
0.03417982906103134,
-0.18872776627540588,
-0.4747949242591858,
-0.2677549719810486,
1.1568167209625244,
0.26337483525276184,
0.7984777688980103,
0.5154436826705933,
0.7174754738807678,
0.336416631937027,
0.03735921159386635,
-1.0672053098678589,
0.4053245782852173,
-0.44610506296157837,
-0.2771545946598053,
-0.43566375970840454,
-0.4504764676094055,
-0.9971411228179932,
0.2928752601146698,
-0.21448084712028503,
-0.5691059827804565,
0.318198025226593,
0.06509929150342941,
-0.46663758158683777,
0.10743190348148346,
-0.6580148935317993,
0.2656186521053314,
-0.009437128901481628,
-0.08955283463001251,
-0.3007839620113373,
-0.27338653802871704,
0.41607266664505005,
-0.3812004625797272,
0.13961726427078247,
-0.16339316964149475,
-0.010311785154044628,
0.48417627811431885,
-0.537655770778656,
0.954736590385437,
-0.04495880380272865,
-0.5103689432144165,
-0.31406447291374207,
0.27745112776756287,
0.538681149482727,
0.062016844749450684,
0.029208948835730553,
0.5487086772918701,
0.01660749688744545,
-0.703757107257843,
-0.7600362300872803,
0.7650788426399231,
-0.9299267530441284,
-0.2874126434326172,
-0.2301756888628006,
-0.7593903541564941,
-0.37684372067451477,
0.12496975809335709,
0.14804516732692719,
0.09305714070796967,
0.20163783431053162,
0.12473750114440918,
0.7021703720092773,
0.009300533682107925,
0.4020111858844757,
0.37601521611213684,
0.15043394267559052,
-0.7926731109619141,
0.7482956051826477,
0.26699718832969666,
0.3285137414932251,
0.3671630024909973,
-0.13600243628025055,
-0.0862613245844841,
-0.805332601070404,
-0.47645702958106995,
0.2066391408443451,
-0.713660717010498,
-0.46099573373794556,
-0.12578433752059937,
-0.13497290015220642,
-0.5253572463989258,
-0.35071706771850586,
-0.8986716866493225,
-0.7443538308143616,
-0.38507431745529175,
0.4053068161010742,
0.3420301079750061,
0.3231869637966156,
-0.10319952666759491,
0.5075576901435852,
-0.731345534324646,
0.34108930826187134,
0.44040730595588684,
0.5125593543052673,
-0.06745046377182007,
-0.6338002681732178,
-0.7881314158439636,
0.23480066657066345,
-0.11385738849639893,
-0.5069101452827454,
0.40213635563850403,
0.16776162385940552,
0.1967044621706009,
0.30941882729530334,
0.31022775173187256,
0.9546199440956116,
-0.4670282006263733,
0.7494133114814758,
0.07440202683210373,
-0.8655158877372742,
0.14116515219211578,
-0.23796208202838898,
0.2498100996017456,
0.6737062335014343,
0.1621999591588974,
-0.4884498715400696,
-0.36054301261901855,
-0.25786566734313965,
-0.808876097202301,
0.4631076753139496,
0.24309666454792023,
0.2182474136352539,
0.4158395230770111,
0.522393524646759,
0.27670738101005554,
0.38474565744400024,
-0.6230595707893372,
-0.6455222964286804,
-0.009700856171548367,
-0.27366647124290466,
-0.14199519157409668,
-0.2163349688053131,
-0.16579397022724152,
-0.22944098711013794,
0.5956781506538391,
-0.3210879862308502,
0.319918155670166,
-0.2466471642255783,
-0.2886946499347687,
-0.2025240659713745,
0.44304564595222473,
0.5891729593276978,
0.2562845051288605,
-0.3938995599746704,
0.2278788834810257,
0.19352009892463684,
-0.5886848568916321,
0.21165254712104797,
0.23420235514640808,
-0.2701435089111328,
0.026311373338103294,
0.17074117064476013,
0.7398396134376526,
0.20826327800750732,
-0.23116452991962433,
0.35848838090896606,
-0.17429891228675842,
-0.08646892011165619,
-0.15287436544895172,
0.11858882755041122,
-0.16159072518348694,
0.319687157869339,
0.4476311206817627,
-0.004482371266931295,
-0.052508335560560226,
-0.18983504176139832,
-0.05534648150205612,
0.5670174360275269,
-0.14431364834308624,
-0.2699155807495117,
0.1959221065044403,
0.20712797343730927,
-0.2292875498533249,
0.5109511017799377,
-0.02983153983950615,
-0.2816600799560547,
0.24656425416469574,
0.34626632928848267,
0.9111284613609314,
-0.03722219169139862,
-0.29578685760498047,
0.2542182207107544,
0.3255588114261627,
-0.10687960684299469,
0.22840341925621033,
-0.27936264872550964,
-0.790790319442749,
-0.8127138018608093,
-0.7788346409797668,
-0.5182501077651978,
0.21299006044864655,
-0.7185674905776978,
0.6426458954811096,
-0.5435804128646851,
-0.2614753246307373,
-0.22393040359020233,
0.35002949833869934,
-0.7063534259796143,
0.056004516780376434,
0.469951331615448,
0.7504948973655701,
-0.5731867551803589,
0.9118939638137817,
0.3942795693874359,
-0.11707068234682083,
-0.544467031955719,
0.060313738882541656,
-0.2620052397251129,
-0.5425216555595398,
0.48355332016944885,
-0.11675533652305603,
-0.12488649040460587,
0.2061884105205536,
-0.5476052165031433,
-0.7958472371101379,
0.9434433579444885,
0.8367643356323242,
-0.8036945462226868,
-0.03055131435394287,
0.292582243680954,
0.28450682759284973,
0.1685905158519745,
0.25519391894340515,
0.4718443751335144,
0.22472798824310303,
-0.05203700810670853,
-1.3308378458023071,
-0.08168604224920273,
0.10517377406358719,
0.038561273366212845,
0.32307106256484985,
-0.6431139707565308,
1.0087183713912964,
0.10494557023048401,
-0.22092217206954956,
-0.018464069813489914,
0.8964391946792603,
0.5722338557243347,
-0.11566893756389618,
0.3974630534648895,
0.43731436133384705,
0.9723544120788574,
0.07573980838060379,
0.6920396685600281,
-0.3262260854244232,
0.47433263063430786,
0.8521221280097961,
-0.08852443099021912,
0.9181671142578125,
0.6317996978759766,
-0.18099133670330048,
0.20801320672035217,
0.7291728854179382,
0.2593424618244171,
0.5473015308380127,
0.4745284616947174,
-0.4944601356983185,
-0.3652358949184418,
-0.11421982198953629,
-0.3638128638267517,
0.05976200848817825,
0.36575600504875183,
0.12053384631872177,
-0.31771788001060486,
-0.17543961107730865,
0.04968475177884102,
-0.28839778900146484,
-0.550658643245697,
0.47596341371536255,
0.25488319993019104,
-0.35683712363243103,
1.3990830183029175,
0.3794841766357422,
1.129141092300415,
-0.4257950186729431,
0.052843231707811356,
-0.41899803280830383,
0.07388246804475784,
0.004848415497690439,
-0.4450494647026062,
0.02019919455051422,
-0.014889382757246494,
-0.26392972469329834,
-0.1859225183725357,
0.44196194410324097,
-0.4279319941997528,
-0.34680479764938354,
-0.050210606306791306,
0.4661237299442291,
0.21067850291728973,
-0.38582178950309753,
-0.32490840554237366,
0.041658516973257065,
-0.23288573324680328,
-0.11351881176233292,
0.5314556956291199,
0.5673032999038696,
-0.1861535608768463,
0.5529817342758179,
0.7396863102912903,
0.4158286154270172,
0.24031001329421997,
0.15933503210544586,
0.8041030764579773,
-0.6707577705383301,
-0.45523783564567566,
-0.7543951272964478,
0.32626083493232727,
0.32462331652641296,
-0.15931473672389984,
0.4941762387752533,
0.5724807977676392,
0.6983165740966797,
-0.15026985108852386,
0.6978937387466431,
0.30826467275619507,
0.14537924528121948,
-0.7288331389427185,
0.6289694309234619,
-0.6679628491401672,
0.15643873810768127,
-0.02420058473944664,
-1.0755937099456787,
-0.5992485880851746,
0.3872075378894806,
0.08284198492765427,
0.02001468650996685,
0.5300281047821045,
0.6825389862060547,
-0.18048352003097534,
-0.4345029890537262,
0.5399746894836426,
-0.1352279633283615,
0.26643818616867065,
0.7001615166664124,
0.57224041223526,
-0.3682031035423279,
0.4619099497795105,
-0.4311280846595764,
-0.0865306556224823,
-0.38918277621269226,
-0.9184287786483765,
-0.9085943698883057,
-0.45078396797180176,
-0.34498634934425354,
-0.42561832070350647,
0.009156210348010063,
1.0622060298919678,
0.9651764035224915,
-0.7862799763679504,
-0.14385952055454254,
-0.04327390715479851,
0.028147418051958084,
-0.29562342166900635,
-0.14351220428943634,
0.4673524796962738,
-0.206582173705101,
-1.142212152481079,
0.36188483238220215,
0.1817602962255478,
0.3327295780181885,
-0.4459403455257416,
-0.2932429015636444,
0.33359473943710327,
0.1008787602186203,
0.5228615999221802,
0.1743224710226059,
-0.6212674379348755,
-0.2416960597038269,
-0.10249178856611252,
-0.32493868470191956,
0.05394316092133522,
0.7475688457489014,
-0.7186393141746521,
0.14649225771427155,
0.3131173849105835,
0.7814394235610962,
0.4462875425815582,
-0.04904302582144737,
0.636435866355896,
-1.232241153717041,
0.3441696763038635,
0.3951778709888458,
0.15723006427288055,
0.28855088353157043,
-0.5213518738746643,
0.19845987856388092,
0.13981764018535614,
-0.4634787142276764,
-0.9239965081214905,
0.24270735681056976,
-1.235295295715332,
-0.26120683550834656,
1.3030953407287598,
0.1444801688194275,
-0.24008604884147644,
-0.11515006422996521,
-0.06099028140306473,
0.5239112973213196,
-0.6456137895584106,
0.6676280498504639,
0.895937442779541,
0.18739531934261322,
-0.27389806509017944,
-0.5318885445594788,
0.47995197772979736,
0.5047693848609924,
-0.5890721082687378,
0.2804684638977051,
0.5371077060699463,
0.12227952480316162,
0.00826557632535696,
0.4496738612651825,
0.24168923497200012,
0.25445571541786194,
-0.2103150486946106,
0.5680062174797058,
-0.10054899752140045,
-0.20316839218139648,
-0.7318223714828491,
0.09431960433721542,
0.4222259819507599,
-0.30000004172325134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08881v1
|
No perspective, no perception!! Perspective-aware Healthcare Answer Summarization
| 2024-06-13T07:35:37 | 2024-06-13T07:35:37 |
Gauri Naik, Sharad Chandakacherla, Shweta Yadav, Md. Shad Akhtar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Healthcare Community Question Answering (CQA) forums offer an accessible
platform for individuals seeking information on various healthcare-related
topics. People find such platforms suitable for self-disclosure, seeking
medical opinions, finding simplified explanations for their medical conditions,
and answering others' questions. However, answers on these forums are typically
diverse and prone to off-topic discussions. It can be challenging for readers
to sift through numerous answers and extract meaningful insights, making answer
summarization a crucial task for CQA forums. While several efforts have been
made to summarize the community answers, most of them are limited to the open
domain and overlook the different perspectives offered by these answers. To
address this problem, this paper proposes a novel task of perspective-specific
answer summarization. We identify various perspectives, within
healthcare-related responses and frame a perspective-driven abstractive summary
covering all responses. To achieve this, we annotate 3167 CQA threads with 6193
perspective-aware summaries in our PUMA dataset. Further, we propose PLASMA, a
prompt-driven controllable summarization model. To encapsulate the
perspective-specific conditions, we design an energy-controlled loss function
for the optimization. We also leverage the prefix tuner to learn the
intricacies of the health-care perspective summarization. Our evaluation
against five baselines suggests the superior performance of PLASMA by a margin
of 1.5-21% improvement. We supplement our experiments with ablation and
qualitative analysis.
|
[
-0.4926131069660187,
-0.2118367850780487,
0.8764729499816895,
0.2088565081357956,
-0.5077958106994629,
0.10826276987791061,
0.38631749153137207,
-0.2593744397163391,
0.7026033401489258,
0.722424328327179,
-0.4580254852771759,
-0.5123477578163147,
-0.5777193903923035,
0.08007081598043442,
-0.1810673326253891,
1.4047082662582397,
-0.036012403666973114,
-0.06910379230976105,
-0.4243224263191223,
-0.27897122502326965,
0.11000441014766693,
-0.42135530710220337,
-0.3555125594139099,
-0.18678241968154907,
0.8287726640701294,
0.3912000060081482,
0.29310351610183716,
0.5117417573928833,
0.5129922032356262,
0.2041032761335373,
-0.29672202467918396,
0.1740829199552536,
-0.213592529296875,
-0.0156706515699625,
-0.10162605345249176,
-0.26474547386169434,
-0.319526344537735,
-0.01726433075964451,
0.5203965902328491,
1.1416184902191162,
-0.2444559931755066,
0.4179581105709076,
0.176260843873024,
0.9801268577575684,
-1.1002954244613647,
-0.252025842666626,
-0.3203771710395813,
0.4236063063144684,
0.2920932173728943,
-0.3348314166069031,
-0.3320161700248718,
-0.4883553385734558,
0.18990911543369293,
-0.6483246684074402,
0.13336743414402008,
-0.1408265382051468,
0.4606688320636749,
0.5026590824127197,
-0.668241024017334,
0.11950153857469559,
-0.7542529702186584,
0.5909052491188049,
-0.5359812378883362,
0.08205017447471619,
-0.11565133184194565,
0.3147245943546295,
0.32647743821144104,
-0.6590142250061035,
-0.3327050507068634,
0.4559437930583954,
-0.3647255599498749,
0.6977335810661316,
-0.18118524551391602,
0.2692430019378662,
0.028138145804405212,
0.5114576816558838,
-0.5669358372688293,
-0.3767607808113098,
-0.24648508429527283,
-0.17702852189540863,
0.2883673310279846,
0.42182186245918274,
-0.050585418939590454,
-0.4313831925392151,
-0.36317241191864014,
0.2289222627878189,
-0.3517681062221527,
0.34725168347358704,
-0.34782466292381287,
-0.17175878584384918,
-0.437152624130249,
0.5153313875198364,
-0.6347075700759888,
0.5302612781524658,
0.37460023164749146,
-0.3243185579776764,
0.2717631459236145,
-0.10952083021402359,
-0.42341360449790955,
0.0964253693819046,
0.26153528690338135,
0.8826016783714294,
-0.4918299913406372,
-0.19332896173000336,
0.26833102107048035,
-0.2954627275466919,
0.40754812955856323,
-0.9084159731864929,
-0.4021592438220978,
0.6756046414375305,
-0.8811336755752563,
-0.5819188952445984,
-0.2219655066728592,
-0.6209980249404907,
-0.8354271054267883,
-0.0069276802241802216,
0.06205964833498001,
0.023612482473254204,
-0.34856730699539185,
-0.1499156802892685,
-0.3403557538986206,
0.09890709072351456,
0.6976194381713867,
-0.5033456087112427,
0.3313480317592621,
0.44624829292297363,
0.7946272492408752,
-0.07205957174301147,
0.23021528124809265,
-0.4729452133178711,
0.3655022382736206,
-0.04410018399357796,
0.8840404748916626,
-0.26971009373664856,
-0.6119881868362427,
-0.2628271281719208,
-0.14873453974723816,
0.16694217920303345,
-0.4844663739204407,
0.19523677229881287,
-0.3010167181491852,
0.37767305970191956,
-0.5808638334274292,
-0.3178239166736603,
-0.33766528964042664,
0.5476829409599304,
-0.38908809423446655,
0.13183727860450745,
0.17319291830062866,
-1.2084039449691772,
0.27390214800834656,
-0.7092543244361877,
-0.11072373390197754,
0.0458449125289917,
-0.44249969720840454,
-0.1083771139383316,
0.39927446842193604,
0.49487733840942383,
-0.06996668875217438,
0.011993187479674816,
-0.14184270799160004,
-0.03005075827240944,
0.12482555955648422,
0.3056754469871521,
-0.12427419424057007,
0.6294534802436829,
0.16175469756126404,
0.05625186860561371,
0.21567600965499878,
-0.7564155459403992,
0.05248478800058365,
-0.2753466069698334,
-0.18442223966121674,
-0.24743421375751495,
-0.053819384425878525,
-0.05825646221637726,
0.7066999077796936,
0.3724135458469391,
-0.5709056854248047,
-0.10508273541927338,
-0.7804142236709595,
-0.0010631125187501311,
0.6659378409385681,
0.7471404075622559,
0.603283703327179,
-0.5891960263252258,
0.8244330286979675,
0.6099464297294617,
0.5070563554763794,
-0.18458540737628937,
-0.1914093792438507,
-0.5671384930610657,
-0.2500979006290436,
-0.11697367578744888,
0.45732828974723816,
-1.0079025030136108,
-0.09499944001436234,
0.03220699355006218,
-0.6771770715713501,
-0.5786519050598145,
-0.15944553911685944,
0.4740859568119049,
1.37628972530365,
0.5641344785690308,
-0.43646687269210815,
-0.3552570044994354,
-1.3724266290664673,
-0.3776058256626129,
-0.36369240283966064,
-0.19776351749897003,
0.3923904299736023,
0.06827819347381592,
0.5149813294410706,
0.6831167936325073,
-0.8922253847122192,
-0.10773006826639175,
-0.32261860370635986,
-0.14090879261493683,
0.3333457112312317,
0.33471670746803284,
0.39304324984550476,
-0.7967623472213745,
-0.3378043472766876,
-0.07282736897468567,
-0.9172868132591248,
0.005478374194353819,
-0.1292187124490738,
-0.05296017974615097,
-0.1198856309056282,
0.24016886949539185,
-0.4299945533275604,
0.44269895553588867,
0.3211037516593933,
-0.16453328728675842,
0.3387860953807831,
-0.17187847197055817,
0.14879094064235687,
-1.0536646842956543,
0.36414635181427,
-0.11760590225458145,
-0.19102828204631805,
-0.4767169654369354,
0.26773250102996826,
-0.1610226333141327,
-0.009125103242695332,
-0.8446007966995239,
0.36925938725471497,
-0.02621447667479515,
0.11339627951383591,
-0.34020474553108215,
0.10412701219320297,
0.30041489005088806,
0.6829385161399841,
0.23415379226207733,
0.3297349810600281,
0.26798754930496216,
-0.6329976320266724,
0.02669714204967022,
0.5484969615936279,
-0.05461223050951958,
0.42505109310150146,
-0.6772092580795288,
0.010480902157723904,
-0.7128995060920715,
0.6033129096031189,
-0.763687252998352,
-0.3853481411933899,
0.7171687483787537,
-0.6159714460372925,
-0.3272954821586609,
0.3612937331199646,
0.041819822043180466,
-0.08139032125473022,
-0.3564765453338623,
0.480912446975708,
0.3941439986228943,
-0.25345155596733093,
0.6779848337173462,
0.5615151524543762,
-0.1707557886838913,
-0.902355432510376,
-0.5385199189186096,
-0.15439893305301666,
-0.32264411449432373,
-0.011331864632666111,
0.1748856008052826,
-0.1195942759513855,
-0.4495323896408081,
-0.07038932293653488,
-0.44410908222198486,
-0.01757185533642769,
0.1807924211025238,
0.4122389256954193,
0.04878944903612137,
0.08260397613048553,
0.0992603525519371,
0.3669193983078003,
-0.10270299762487411,
0.39943426847457886,
-0.3878006637096405,
0.2682618498802185,
0.027349065989255905,
-0.10718871653079987,
-0.4681955873966217,
0.9420408010482788,
0.5505609512329102,
-0.33430156111717224,
0.783462405204773,
-0.1116388812661171,
-0.482560396194458,
0.32049760222435,
-0.1793808937072754,
-0.0038432220462709665,
-0.4234495759010315,
0.2864002287387848,
0.018114333972334862,
-0.9384551644325256,
0.6765724420547485,
0.037764448672533035,
0.47363969683647156,
0.26541176438331604,
0.6638012528419495,
-0.3495069146156311,
1.2270995378494263,
0.725400447845459,
0.15548212826251984,
-0.03073311410844326,
0.083563432097435,
0.23355929553508759,
-0.8081650137901306,
-0.5818347930908203,
-0.5210206508636475,
-0.4751802980899811,
-0.6626600027084351,
-0.04507233202457428,
1.213008165359497,
-0.25651073455810547,
-0.3201771080493927,
-0.24148206412792206,
-0.8097313642501831,
0.26410791277885437,
0.19657261669635773,
0.44196805357933044,
0.5728577971458435,
-0.4286951720714569,
0.0004109659348614514,
-0.11638513952493668,
-0.6078827977180481,
-0.1501588672399521,
0.7785189151763916,
0.16274499893188477,
0.2883104085922241,
0.31793126463890076,
0.9261888861656189,
-0.00577291427180171,
0.5988527536392212,
-0.6983333826065063,
0.37890276312828064,
-0.025883452966809273,
-0.366443008184433,
0.02930525131523609,
-0.35025927424430847,
-0.5812875032424927,
0.4069277048110962,
-0.07026497274637222,
-0.7042771577835083,
0.2877533733844757,
0.298880010843277,
-0.766147255897522,
0.12203510850667953,
-0.2850365936756134,
0.6412512063980103,
0.23664787411689758,
-0.027192238718271255,
-0.1078566461801529,
-1.0551661252975464,
0.5304097533226013,
0.1026511937379837,
0.2967109978199005,
0.0478571392595768,
-0.40719565749168396,
0.3573310375213623,
-0.5458692312240601,
0.41160306334495544,
-0.4354839622974396,
-0.09167058765888214,
0.04506264999508858,
-0.19383865594863892,
-0.1544027030467987,
0.38489341735839844,
0.27170634269714355,
-0.3132703900337219,
0.0749579519033432,
-0.6796669960021973,
-0.8038221001625061,
0.554520308971405,
-0.7911467552185059,
-0.8382338285446167,
-0.4864090383052826,
-0.3600342571735382,
-0.45518678426742554,
0.05068737268447876,
0.5600892901420593,
0.5089967250823975,
-0.15615293383598328,
-0.13875605165958405,
0.6494773030281067,
-0.5669211745262146,
0.265520304441452,
0.6108610033988953,
-0.48346084356307983,
-0.30524942278862,
0.5714912414550781,
-0.13803912699222565,
0.2170848548412323,
0.8128184676170349,
0.08971751481294632,
-0.08168760687112808,
-0.45220834016799927,
-0.5187839269638062,
0.12899526953697205,
-0.6977413892745972,
-0.17024077475070953,
-0.998364269733429,
-0.3833938539028168,
-0.3045352101325989,
-0.3111494779586792,
-0.11882518231868744,
-0.66196608543396,
-0.09155287593603134,
-0.07985328137874603,
0.07686188817024231,
0.2026486098766327,
-0.011177390813827515,
0.39060109853744507,
-0.8657222986221313,
0.4779447913169861,
0.33152416348457336,
0.015090500935912132,
0.15711691975593567,
-0.17969991266727448,
-0.27256229519844055,
-0.05951166898012161,
-0.582462728023529,
-0.9158892035484314,
0.43986719846725464,
-0.011397379450500011,
0.10978981107473373,
0.45468100905418396,
0.4578477442264557,
0.4799193739891052,
-0.29795634746551514,
1.085503339767456,
0.5653457641601562,
-0.7967289090156555,
0.8239811062812805,
-0.2170708030462265,
0.7984315156936646,
0.7199303507804871,
0.33137503266334534,
-0.7696228623390198,
-0.9442761540412903,
-0.7416018843650818,
-0.9616032242774963,
0.3825434446334839,
0.020970715209841728,
0.11500132828950882,
-0.008649869821965694,
0.2966347336769104,
0.08835215866565704,
0.4869110584259033,
-0.40115153789520264,
-0.6192583441734314,
-0.5260136723518372,
0.09836622327566147,
0.13401363790035248,
0.20912978053092957,
-0.466400146484375,
-0.3572680652141571,
0.48101741075515747,
-0.1667015701532364,
0.10536473989486694,
0.6996869444847107,
0.12389625608921051,
-0.06250862777233124,
0.3296140432357788,
0.4340081810951233,
0.9535212516784668,
-0.26989924907684326,
0.16902050375938416,
-0.022686967626214027,
-0.4878233075141907,
0.010587711818516254,
-0.061677079647779465,
-0.30093222856521606,
0.10661157965660095,
0.012358264997601509,
0.3392949402332306,
-0.1162680983543396,
-0.6887105107307434,
0.5482832193374634,
-0.3519846498966217,
-0.07789180427789688,
-0.5418984889984131,
0.0920613706111908,
0.09004758298397064,
0.08335153758525848,
0.3775460124015808,
0.47347569465637207,
0.7785453200340271,
-0.20040759444236755,
0.06414616852998734,
0.06571958214044571,
-0.6165214776992798,
-0.0802578255534172,
0.9680501818656921,
0.2839754819869995,
0.26298728585243225,
0.39702051877975464,
0.32323938608169556,
-0.08394310623407364,
0.8205053210258484,
0.09261985868215561,
0.8627517223358154,
-0.11556313186883926,
0.523832380771637,
0.28804996609687805,
-0.013195364736020565,
0.6394522190093994,
0.04750559478998184,
-0.22341221570968628,
-0.5153549313545227,
-0.6154481172561646,
-0.39589861035346985,
-0.6759147644042969,
0.015028601512312889,
-1.1603645086288452,
-0.08167686313390732,
-0.8056661486625671,
0.2310277670621872,
0.45235729217529297,
-0.09555261582136154,
-0.42691144347190857,
0.5946098566055298,
0.18331584334373474,
1.230437159538269,
-0.65374755859375,
0.5436471104621887,
0.9103425741195679,
-0.3422849774360657,
-0.6327799558639526,
0.23140034079551697,
0.06292016059160233,
-0.6102955937385559,
0.03382369875907898,
-0.008618136867880821,
-0.2609029710292816,
-0.27608194947242737,
-0.6582975387573242,
-0.3956742584705353,
0.9135964512825012,
0.29469162225723267,
-0.13522660732269287,
-0.12865029275417328,
-0.0635983943939209,
0.6501657962799072,
-0.42067399621009827,
0.3432655334472656,
0.3565499186515808,
0.22856460511684418,
0.09273441880941391,
-0.8398528695106506,
-0.07400251179933548,
-0.43029308319091797,
-0.2469029426574707,
0.13039973378181458,
-1.0458425283432007,
0.6667299866676331,
-0.22084228694438934,
0.2160121351480484,
0.023125020787119865,
0.76209956407547,
0.3356682062149048,
0.6435886025428772,
0.5093954801559448,
0.35061711072921753,
0.5337463021278381,
0.3844364285469055,
1.146857500076294,
-0.23440398275852203,
0.20444676280021667,
1.1116255521774292,
-0.12850633263587952,
0.3707713484764099,
0.7387402057647705,
0.017773650586605072,
0.4850083291530609,
0.5657969117164612,
0.6699119210243225,
1.010517954826355,
0.03883872926235199,
-0.8168351650238037,
-0.43428435921669006,
-0.6429398655891418,
-0.6024474501609802,
0.6969978213310242,
0.2410101294517517,
-0.577857494354248,
-0.6008239984512329,
0.015828659757971764,
0.16054151952266693,
0.30508965253829956,
-0.6344484090805054,
1.059468388557434,
0.21354536712169647,
-0.6905239224433899,
0.4508662819862366,
0.033485349267721176,
0.08260384202003479,
-0.307647168636322,
0.03264664486050606,
-0.405388206243515,
0.018198160454630852,
-0.3410740792751312,
-0.5682001113891602,
0.5192061066627502,
0.010167687200009823,
-0.6538295745849609,
-0.3559822738170624,
0.26484957337379456,
-0.1375095397233963,
-0.3736170530319214,
-0.25644341111183167,
0.8542465567588806,
0.30114099383354187,
0.015371163375675678,
-0.5417884588241577,
-0.4200945198535919,
0.11510041356086731,
-0.07264979183673859,
0.6185768246650696,
0.28733107447624207,
0.1295478194952011,
0.6201092004776001,
-0.012197732925415039,
0.04873654991388321,
-0.7623059153556824,
-0.35945841670036316,
1.167443871498108,
-0.4052911400794983,
-0.9198700785636902,
-0.5505074262619019,
0.5695478320121765,
-0.2037626951932907,
-0.6866907477378845,
0.5104209184646606,
0.7279579043388367,
0.4689062237739563,
-0.10124950855970383,
1.0861841440200806,
-0.011644233949482441,
1.1679059267044067,
-0.17235952615737915,
0.9192726016044617,
-0.8744301795959473,
0.034478459507226944,
-0.21649900078773499,
-0.3277193009853363,
-0.31963157653808594,
0.2577439248561859,
-0.06898724287748337,
-0.389761358499527,
0.5715062618255615,
0.3697345554828644,
0.31754621863365173,
0.1476433277130127,
0.16638898849487305,
0.2929607331752777,
0.16030770540237427,
0.8853805661201477,
0.6783689260482788,
-0.033142078667879105,
0.4632335305213928,
-0.5686290264129639,
-0.4228500425815582,
0.016251642256975174,
-0.7431540489196777,
-0.5429731607437134,
-0.48838862776756287,
-0.49692851305007935,
-0.4917759895324707,
-0.1584477573633194,
0.8226261734962463,
0.44528838992118835,
-0.7372478246688843,
0.17813432216644287,
0.07273198664188385,
0.3121306896209717,
-0.38389652967453003,
-0.20830389857292175,
0.3527868092060089,
0.17764724791049957,
-0.3177051842212677,
-0.07777002453804016,
0.4526088237762451,
-0.41024091839790344,
-0.18942177295684814,
0.2636473774909973,
0.28849735856056213,
-0.06621354818344116,
0.42696210741996765,
0.39547014236450195,
-0.6149620413780212,
-0.484736829996109,
0.20134727656841278,
-0.05348299816250801,
0.4040657877922058,
0.7951533794403076,
-1.2240692377090454,
0.37182092666625977,
0.0962689146399498,
0.5054987668991089,
0.3604927659034729,
0.2692604959011078,
0.37876003980636597,
-0.8179376125335693,
0.20954963564872742,
0.5787119269371033,
-0.06549199670553207,
0.14370988309383392,
-0.5643718838691711,
-0.05622907355427742,
0.090163454413414,
-0.46396052837371826,
-0.39557865262031555,
0.42097896337509155,
-1.2757285833358765,
-0.2563466429710388,
0.5442453622817993,
-0.2093062698841095,
-0.0926232859492302,
-0.16154079139232635,
-0.2778909206390381,
0.24190305173397064,
-0.4002017378807068,
1.1525987386703491,
0.4040875732898712,
-0.7154251933097839,
-0.4927508533000946,
-0.4336855709552765,
0.49601662158966064,
0.48166152834892273,
-1.085028052330017,
-0.1566975712776184,
0.6412227153778076,
0.31816956400871277,
0.030328789725899696,
0.9404762387275696,
-0.2300134301185608,
0.4463070034980774,
-0.27362605929374695,
-0.14577484130859375,
0.2289280891418457,
-0.13173151016235352,
-0.31659063696861267,
0.684969425201416,
-0.050248969346284866,
-0.4526655375957489
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08860v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08860v1
|
Plan, Generate and Complicate: Improving Low-resource Dialogue State Tracking via Easy-to-Difficult Zero-shot Data Augmentation
| 2024-06-13T06:49:03 | 2024-06-13T06:49:03 |
Ming Gu, Yan Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Data augmentation methods have been a promising direction to improve the
performance of small models for low-resource dialogue state tracking. However,
traditional methods rely on pre-defined user goals and neglect the importance
of data complexity in this task. In this paper, we propose EDZ-DA, an
Easy-to-Difficult Zero-shot Data Augmentation framework for low-resource
dialogue state tracking that utilizes large language models to automatically
catch the relationships of different domains and then generate the dialogue
data. We also complicate the dialogues based on the domain relation to enhance
the model's capability for co-reference slot tracking. Furthermore, we permute
slot values to mitigate the influence of output orders and the problem of
incomplete value generation. Experimental results illustrate the superiority of
our proposed method compared to previous strong data augmentation baselines on
MultiWOZ.
|
[
-0.5211294889450073,
-0.7545493245124817,
0.5634756684303284,
-0.3480488955974579,
-0.42239508032798767,
0.12315034866333008,
0.019333140924572945,
-0.29750770330429077,
0.42297065258026123,
0.4335629343986511,
-1.1495094299316406,
-0.40450146794319153,
-0.2923213541507721,
0.022728605195879936,
0.07164127379655838,
0.869870662689209,
0.2326517105102539,
-0.3541039824485779,
0.23316919803619385,
-0.04278343543410301,
-0.35136789083480835,
-0.5251370072364807,
-0.3888905346393585,
-0.37508276104927063,
0.5075446367263794,
0.6699193120002747,
0.7659096717834473,
0.5731749534606934,
0.2920052707195282,
0.21366959810256958,
-0.09811577200889587,
0.5956524014472961,
-0.7071846127510071,
0.21617285907268524,
0.15774020552635193,
-0.2688315510749817,
-1.0920237302780151,
-0.25479066371917725,
0.309050589799881,
1.0115320682525635,
-0.4137820303440094,
0.14284567534923553,
-0.05516654625535011,
0.36719024181365967,
-0.6296902298927307,
0.2891472280025482,
-0.6172086000442505,
-0.11393614858388901,
-0.18157345056533813,
-0.4466935694217682,
-0.2096463143825531,
-0.044938746839761734,
0.018610209226608276,
-0.7049006819725037,
0.2160143107175827,
-0.051274798810482025,
0.6736911535263062,
0.4964575469493866,
-0.38565126061439514,
-0.13165853917598724,
-1.0842711925506592,
0.8184710144996643,
-0.7130162119865417,
0.0034979130141437054,
0.23693597316741943,
0.08937403559684753,
-0.380778431892395,
-0.3726770579814911,
-1.0852491855621338,
0.2011461704969406,
0.03286362066864967,
0.0849616527557373,
-0.14688219130039215,
0.3052005469799042,
0.6144125461578369,
0.3329024910926819,
-0.04156721383333206,
0.03807930648326874,
-0.105884850025177,
0.022031858563423157,
0.6855278015136719,
0.655813455581665,
0.34939199686050415,
-0.36710822582244873,
-0.2505212724208832,
-0.1622171252965927,
-0.8861683011054993,
0.14123302698135376,
0.49969571828842163,
0.5637942552566528,
-0.1608797311782837,
0.6239637732505798,
-0.6849893927574158,
0.9859776496887207,
0.3983888328075409,
-0.23922966420650482,
0.3034973442554474,
-0.8911435604095459,
-0.19562062621116638,
0.11252953112125397,
0.5817678570747375,
0.28028562664985657,
-0.5072147250175476,
0.2041071206331253,
0.005577781703323126,
-0.10140803456306458,
0.05327853187918663,
-0.8427521586418152,
-0.1362028419971466,
0.3254361152648926,
0.0004533522005658597,
-0.04054449126124382,
-0.31224167346954346,
-0.5679811835289001,
-0.07447549700737,
-0.29103782773017883,
0.3236992657184601,
-0.26991426944732666,
-0.20692478120326996,
0.2221192568540573,
0.2149660885334015,
0.006313488353043795,
0.9190976619720459,
-0.8356282114982605,
0.1148296445608139,
0.5934823155403137,
0.7111315727233887,
0.0766996368765831,
0.07137367874383926,
-0.7866879105567932,
0.3886208236217499,
-0.4329581558704376,
0.6694236993789673,
-0.5874715447425842,
-0.19801850616931915,
-0.1966249942779541,
-0.2360801100730896,
0.042936958372592926,
-0.2765963077545166,
0.5063449144363403,
-0.2533372640609741,
0.22548171877861023,
-0.22243452072143555,
-0.5261681079864502,
-0.029084378853440285,
0.0026333671994507313,
-0.5870864391326904,
0.9085755944252014,
0.3148498237133026,
-0.2789551913738251,
0.45174840092658997,
-0.5391514301300049,
-0.17216888070106506,
0.3182460367679596,
-0.4136849045753479,
-0.37082144618034363,
0.011099038645625114,
0.31853947043418884,
0.14756327867507935,
-0.18720728158950806,
0.33664774894714355,
-0.43444597721099854,
-0.5303537249565125,
-0.05223023518919945,
-0.6165543794631958,
0.5667034983634949,
0.16527651250362396,
-0.13951511681079865,
-0.1801867038011551,
-0.9709633588790894,
0.17893442511558533,
-0.05981248989701271,
-0.24523845314979553,
-0.412945032119751,
0.056900400668382645,
-0.4406983554363251,
0.30715274810791016,
0.05983665585517883,
-0.8521510362625122,
0.44226810336112976,
-0.6504462361335754,
0.054027706384658813,
0.46071940660476685,
0.16576440632343292,
0.5693506002426147,
-0.09562435746192932,
0.4575013518333435,
0.15406742691993713,
0.05315844714641571,
-0.5331958532333374,
-0.24534493684768677,
-0.7570146918296814,
-0.5807809829711914,
0.27977803349494934,
0.27745091915130615,
-1.2405482530593872,
0.6252307891845703,
-0.4560256004333496,
-0.38626447319984436,
-0.7144659757614136,
0.22570565342903137,
0.1354081928730011,
0.521986186504364,
0.2707802951335907,
-0.4227612018585205,
-0.11965322494506836,
-0.642667293548584,
0.23075498640537262,
-0.09955394268035889,
-0.248803049325943,
0.6113147139549255,
0.09948781132698059,
0.22860407829284668,
0.9013057947158813,
-0.9062765836715698,
-0.3618113398551941,
-0.32365357875823975,
0.14487947523593903,
0.35412275791168213,
0.3967265486717224,
0.4013926386833191,
-0.42151564359664917,
-0.6140215992927551,
-0.17414332926273346,
-0.5216607451438904,
-0.14406037330627441,
-0.026701534166932106,
-0.0880199521780014,
0.04242675378918648,
0.007264209445565939,
-0.709130585193634,
0.6284986734390259,
0.2795083224773407,
-0.13878744840621948,
-0.23469075560569763,
-0.0643455907702446,
0.30039098858833313,
-0.8614535927772522,
-0.14495736360549927,
-0.25948384404182434,
-0.1239636242389679,
-0.9714318513870239,
-0.3650015890598297,
-0.3136975169181824,
-0.57023686170578,
-0.4198181927204132,
0.08226758986711502,
-0.36630624532699585,
0.0958038866519928,
-0.3565051853656769,
0.2527655363082886,
0.09966118633747101,
0.9633420705795288,
0.012673314660787582,
0.5949894785881042,
0.2197173535823822,
-0.621772289276123,
0.6905571818351746,
0.6536091566085815,
-0.4402117431163788,
0.7114405632019043,
-0.4199604094028473,
0.3638973534107208,
-0.01838068850338459,
0.525784969329834,
-0.9571344256401062,
-0.1341468095779419,
0.4311824440956116,
-0.44363316893577576,
0.3703669309616089,
-0.6170008778572083,
-0.33914822340011597,
-0.013277326710522175,
-0.28958860039711,
0.308719664812088,
0.2921006977558136,
-0.4886019825935364,
0.3743245303630829,
0.5298153162002563,
-0.6589184999465942,
-0.5842737555503845,
-0.21934989094734192,
0.09501839429140091,
-0.0985167995095253,
-0.6994897127151489,
0.5362841486930847,
0.022638283669948578,
-0.04354824125766754,
-0.14654533565044403,
-0.25891801714897156,
-0.19584132730960846,
-0.004034571349620819,
0.03320969268679619,
0.5789504647254944,
0.08446203917264938,
0.15224798023700714,
0.1378922164440155,
-0.13461174070835114,
-0.3074930012226105,
0.16697435081005096,
0.5452874302864075,
0.4937865138053894,
-0.5349373817443848,
-0.5059364438056946,
0.7231215834617615,
0.30363407731056213,
0.08182075619697571,
0.5514814257621765,
0.2928801476955414,
-0.3169137239456177,
-0.4723981022834778,
-0.1370762586593628,
-0.16822600364685059,
-0.48087555170059204,
0.22472746670246124,
-0.5130779147148132,
-0.6502836346626282,
0.21876491606235504,
-0.1761816293001175,
0.0511077344417572,
0.2644798159599304,
0.4202542006969452,
-0.30063948035240173,
1.157387375831604,
0.6975734829902649,
0.08892934024333954,
0.5841858983039856,
-0.15921708941459656,
0.5212584733963013,
-0.7678830623626709,
-0.0015030070208013058,
-0.4169195890426636,
-0.16373786330223083,
-0.3806280791759491,
-0.5260182023048401,
0.6182836294174194,
-0.02176755666732788,
0.07695481926202774,
0.43898555636405945,
-0.37865039706230164,
0.11126387864351273,
0.3367259204387665,
0.07423408329486847,
0.6077463626861572,
0.28945228457450867,
0.391222208738327,
-0.144729882478714,
-1.1488555669784546,
-0.25121811032295227,
1.0040574073791504,
0.06006883084774017,
1.2255553007125854,
0.256708562374115,
0.7513659000396729,
0.379709392786026,
-0.23960784077644348,
-0.8117454051971436,
0.461582213640213,
0.00012736661301460117,
-0.3184647858142853,
-0.5901719927787781,
-0.49844062328338623,
-0.6247978806495667,
0.2973593473434448,
-0.41560065746307373,
-0.6888703107833862,
0.5055398941040039,
0.3119332492351532,
-0.9400039315223694,
0.04691801965236664,
-0.7255042791366577,
0.4719678461551666,
0.13819780945777893,
-0.5414445400238037,
-0.42326048016548157,
-0.25189027190208435,
0.14079774916172028,
-0.11140982806682587,
-0.15112288296222687,
-0.41771990060806274,
0.10073636472225189,
0.4183182716369629,
-1.0035146474838257,
0.8435038328170776,
-0.32503101229667664,
-0.314006507396698,
0.692078173160553,
-0.0895460695028305,
0.7899869680404663,
-0.1554783135652542,
0.09021957963705063,
0.06015051156282425,
-0.2005598545074463,
-0.24030433595180511,
-0.6799580454826355,
0.6308668851852417,
-0.39739009737968445,
-0.6086428165435791,
-0.24965481460094452,
-0.5951489210128784,
-0.2535703778266907,
-0.256786584854126,
0.04466008394956589,
0.727000892162323,
-0.1148865669965744,
0.03394674137234688,
0.4520583748817444,
-0.3986106812953949,
0.5430018901824951,
0.8565789461135864,
0.32490772008895874,
-0.19317224621772766,
0.9736258387565613,
0.3839932978153229,
0.37504327297210693,
0.122487872838974,
-0.42384955286979675,
-0.3147091269493103,
-0.30162176489830017,
-0.9665008783340454,
-0.04229723662137985,
-0.32503649592399597,
-0.37901368737220764,
-0.5709643363952637,
-0.08591195195913315,
-0.23844708502292633,
0.040253374725580215,
-0.54558926820755,
-0.7271075248718262,
-0.05861354619264603,
-0.0013799420557916164,
0.3964197635650635,
0.4475446045398712,
-0.11425410956144333,
0.4602277874946594,
-0.673091471195221,
0.537170946598053,
0.2990873456001282,
0.49352046847343445,
-0.09171482175588608,
-0.42556118965148926,
-0.4440279006958008,
0.37081044912338257,
-0.4573562443256378,
-0.6117797493934631,
0.38719382882118225,
0.2608281672000885,
0.3614456355571747,
0.0664881095290184,
0.5248609781265259,
0.997039258480072,
-0.5056314468383789,
0.7504413723945618,
0.40084153413772583,
-0.8615797162055969,
0.738633394241333,
-0.4593924582004547,
0.1504599153995514,
0.3050900399684906,
-0.1194351390004158,
-0.14117461442947388,
-0.3353267312049866,
-0.652830958366394,
-0.8660849332809448,
1.3044548034667969,
0.32577475905418396,
0.2721636891365051,
0.20935656130313873,
0.10118365287780762,
0.004748696926981211,
0.32155412435531616,
-0.15182951092720032,
-0.39977380633354187,
0.05905556306242943,
-0.21529817581176758,
0.05462530627846718,
-0.19375185668468475,
-0.2986840009689331,
-0.3016884922981262,
0.5196492075920105,
-0.36784234642982483,
0.19260987639427185,
0.23573780059814453,
0.02738860622048378,
-0.480489581823349,
0.5488806366920471,
0.39039310812950134,
0.5038810968399048,
-0.2469838559627533,
-0.32593321800231934,
0.06412111222743988,
-0.10058511048555374,
0.26269102096557617,
0.2054508775472641,
-0.569401204586029,
0.21647749841213226,
-0.03537212684750557,
1.0810755491256714,
-0.024435006082057953,
-0.40903717279434204,
0.5225397944450378,
0.138762965798378,
-0.023488668724894524,
-0.27370694279670715,
0.42394110560417175,
-0.2796374261379242,
0.21380722522735596,
0.30918094515800476,
-0.12120764702558517,
0.22765007615089417,
-0.5623680353164673,
0.11846045404672623,
0.42149052023887634,
-0.20361049473285675,
-0.3009061813354492,
0.3338622748851776,
0.7078758478164673,
-0.18366888165473938,
0.5370430946350098,
-0.22880159318447113,
-0.18853650987148285,
0.4241344928741455,
0.2876088619232178,
0.487516850233078,
-0.04630783945322037,
0.214593768119812,
0.4060395061969757,
0.10806377977132797,
0.1884320080280304,
0.38045981526374817,
-0.3562586009502411,
-0.8306266665458679,
-0.7903560996055603,
-0.25820472836494446,
-0.7130195498466492,
0.3932165503501892,
-0.7309921383857727,
0.4423363208770752,
-0.17393340170383453,
-0.5127343535423279,
0.15932084619998932,
0.05938410758972168,
-0.7714949250221252,
0.012497177347540855,
0.2638990879058838,
0.4828489422798157,
-0.6044324040412903,
0.9392804503440857,
0.20220905542373657,
-0.3248578906059265,
-0.7667625546455383,
-0.094793900847435,
0.1971283107995987,
-0.5699886679649353,
0.47388821840286255,
-0.20481641590595245,
-0.4464285373687744,
0.11611312627792358,
-0.5567429661750793,
-0.6996488571166992,
0.9367212653160095,
0.21528832614421844,
-0.7104402184486389,
0.07827015966176987,
0.06841223686933517,
0.521010160446167,
-0.4392285943031311,
0.235869362950325,
0.5579448342323303,
0.14053115248680115,
0.28834104537963867,
-0.9549871683120728,
-0.121829554438591,
-0.1632929891347885,
-0.30528202652931213,
0.402021586894989,
-0.6237955093383789,
0.7749759554862976,
-0.3165031373500824,
-0.618049144744873,
-0.23551233112812042,
0.4129604399204254,
-0.28284817934036255,
0.3575054109096527,
0.561575174331665,
0.6920368075370789,
0.5238213539123535,
-0.1587115377187729,
0.7065190672874451,
-0.30321770906448364,
0.37810271978378296,
1.5222300291061401,
-0.7111666202545166,
0.5947709679603577,
0.29083651304244995,
-0.24458442628383636,
0.40767332911491394,
0.240349680185318,
-0.15918633341789246,
0.5695742964744568,
-0.07009164988994598,
-0.6343556642532349,
-0.5181733965873718,
-0.5485078692436218,
-0.17114803194999695,
0.6117862462997437,
0.46513858437538147,
0.018692834302783012,
-0.32793283462524414,
-0.24890322983264923,
-0.14291143417358398,
-0.09103207290172577,
-0.19242648780345917,
1.084706425666809,
-0.041729189455509186,
-0.6832130551338196,
0.7248277068138123,
-0.09030892699956894,
0.4873601198196411,
-0.6043912172317505,
-0.4879533350467682,
-0.3152674734592438,
0.16974012553691864,
-0.06202074885368347,
-0.4752666652202606,
0.20558185875415802,
0.3826754093170166,
-0.1410745531320572,
-0.17639857530593872,
0.5778264403343201,
-0.8155817985534668,
-0.16644711792469025,
0.1585984230041504,
0.9208507537841797,
-0.04874145984649658,
0.16863076388835907,
-0.36469757556915283,
-0.06707669049501419,
0.13474315404891968,
-0.09216167032718658,
0.3124951422214508,
0.28111886978149414,
0.17744235694408417,
0.6156445741653442,
0.571121871471405,
0.1940845400094986,
-0.16397880017757416,
0.09653984755277634,
0.9651935696601868,
-0.7115401029586792,
-0.38126617670059204,
-0.6326503157615662,
0.2493431270122528,
-0.21511338651180267,
0.040768418461084366,
0.5474560856819153,
0.3455371558666229,
0.8910630941390991,
0.17776942253112793,
0.8141899704933167,
-0.2717851400375366,
0.8521457314491272,
-0.40411698818206787,
0.45995834469795227,
-0.4121527373790741,
0.4890561103820801,
-0.2832811176776886,
-0.709370493888855,
0.3016684055328369,
0.30778852105140686,
0.002092772861942649,
-0.38820016384124756,
0.3283247649669647,
0.8296056985855103,
-0.0949229821562767,
-0.16479767858982086,
0.39649131894111633,
0.028677165508270264,
0.23253753781318665,
0.7684208154678345,
0.8578658699989319,
-0.4357870817184448,
0.7327831983566284,
-0.40949949622154236,
-0.3091895282268524,
-0.06632228195667267,
-0.5667879581451416,
-0.6087009906768799,
-0.2704375088214874,
-0.5279911756515503,
-0.1501418650150299,
-0.3024483025074005,
1.1574437618255615,
0.7203058004379272,
-0.5721142292022705,
-0.055082790553569794,
0.3596595525741577,
0.14258034527301788,
-0.18472787737846375,
-0.20613126456737518,
0.17231354117393494,
-0.1885116696357727,
-1.1974260807037354,
0.7791042327880859,
0.43385323882102966,
0.15285800397396088,
-0.10774223506450653,
0.03474972024559975,
0.01537143811583519,
0.36275801062583923,
0.4737434983253479,
0.19636867940425873,
-0.597461462020874,
-0.34510520100593567,
-0.19355329871177673,
-0.21281622350215912,
0.31676679849624634,
0.8314980864524841,
-0.6860841512680054,
0.7628096342086792,
0.3868100345134735,
0.24761644005775452,
0.6144284605979919,
0.25497958064079285,
0.8686692714691162,
-0.901604950428009,
0.16912685334682465,
0.032977472990751266,
0.12974685430526733,
0.3251933455467224,
-0.4478532671928406,
0.43174055218696594,
0.26954010128974915,
-0.130821093916893,
-0.8603323698043823,
0.4931522309780121,
-1.039269208908081,
0.10455947369337082,
0.7490083575248718,
-0.33540576696395874,
0.15526644885540009,
-0.4238690435886383,
-0.11488407850265503,
0.2817417085170746,
-0.7113879919052124,
0.7706600427627563,
0.6398358345031738,
-0.41999495029449463,
-0.05471814423799515,
-0.46685633063316345,
0.7810612320899963,
0.20615187287330627,
-0.7620806694030762,
0.2764948904514313,
0.9286380410194397,
0.12711940705776215,
0.21705207228660583,
1.0146708488464355,
0.1367127001285553,
0.08621484786272049,
0.18055643141269684,
-0.06612461805343628,
-0.2303394228219986,
-0.16604118049144745,
-0.24222098290920258,
0.09539446234703064,
-0.19796039164066315,
-0.3634135127067566
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10294v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10294v1
|
RelevAI-Reviewer: A Benchmark on AI Reviewers for Survey Paper Relevance
| 2024-06-13T06:42:32 | 2024-06-13T06:42:32 |
Paulo Henrique Couto, Quang Phuoc Ho, Nageeta Kumari, Benedictus Kent Rachmat, Thanh Gia Hieu Khuong, Ihsan Ullah, Lisheng Sun-Hosoya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent advancements in Artificial Intelligence (AI), particularly the
widespread adoption of Large Language Models (LLMs), have significantly
enhanced text analysis capabilities. This technological evolution offers
considerable promise for automating the review of scientific papers, a task
traditionally managed through peer review by fellow researchers. Despite its
critical role in maintaining research quality, the conventional peer-review
process is often slow and subject to biases, potentially impeding the swift
propagation of scientific knowledge. In this paper, we propose
RelevAI-Reviewer, an automatic system that conceptualizes the task of survey
paper review as a classification problem, aimed at assessing the relevance of a
paper in relation to a specified prompt, analogous to a "call for papers". To
address this, we introduce a novel dataset comprised of 25,164 instances. Each
instance contains one prompt and four candidate papers, each varying in
relevance to the prompt. The objective is to develop a machine learning (ML)
model capable of determining the relevance of each paper and identifying the
most pertinent one. We explore various baseline approaches, including
traditional ML classifiers like Support Vector Machine (SVM) and advanced
language models such as BERT. Preliminary findings indicate that the BERT-based
end-to-end classifier surpasses other conventional ML methods in performance.
We present this problem as a public challenge to foster engagement and interest
in this area of research.
|
[
-0.3767971694469452,
-0.32278403639793396,
0.6380830407142639,
0.1421402096748352,
-0.15356554090976715,
0.11036339402198792,
0.019819822162389755,
-0.43333184719085693,
0.157664492726326,
0.20340517163276672,
-0.30828985571861267,
-0.43046820163726807,
-0.5246570110321045,
0.41419219970703125,
-0.7531324625015259,
1.383754014968872,
-0.0848449245095253,
-0.13113796710968018,
-0.6989765763282776,
-0.05111929401755333,
0.06483376026153564,
-0.285062313079834,
-0.5184273719787598,
-0.3181898593902588,
0.9450576305389404,
0.024505287408828735,
0.41879087686538696,
0.17953994870185852,
0.8028453588485718,
0.30512040853500366,
-0.1419132649898529,
-0.062547966837883,
-0.25139084458351135,
0.27874520421028137,
0.09099052846431732,
-0.6683598756790161,
-0.33740946650505066,
0.4400991201400757,
0.7206370830535889,
0.471787691116333,
0.20379787683486938,
0.6130154728889465,
0.04016294702887535,
0.6931434273719788,
-0.5998749732971191,
0.24271681904792786,
-0.5419565439224243,
-0.030338112264871597,
0.05640899017453194,
-0.1737164556980133,
-0.32704463601112366,
-0.7129236459732056,
0.214614599943161,
-0.5093905329704285,
0.428300678730011,
0.03280792012810707,
0.8111743330955505,
0.5171188116073608,
-0.4234423339366913,
-0.18199370801448822,
-0.46630701422691345,
0.6059410572052002,
-0.5021085143089294,
0.2685251832008362,
0.3250880539417267,
0.4635523855686188,
-0.05838124081492424,
-0.6526545286178589,
-0.548620343208313,
-0.5643200278282166,
-0.017798077315092087,
0.17650222778320312,
0.15493296086788177,
-0.1397327035665512,
0.23783151805400848,
0.24681858718395233,
-0.47895967960357666,
-0.13295668363571167,
-0.43984848260879517,
-0.12641946971416473,
0.6853138208389282,
0.18556630611419678,
0.021592115983366966,
-0.2999702990055084,
0.0524127334356308,
-0.14071233570575714,
-0.4979299306869507,
0.4073134958744049,
0.2307598888874054,
0.2272249311208725,
0.2777307629585266,
0.3455377221107483,
-0.40452367067337036,
0.8057717084884644,
0.020993471145629883,
0.0963599905371666,
0.40511757135391235,
-0.3327316343784332,
-0.018410947173833847,
-0.41141992807388306,
0.6842446327209473,
0.24216757714748383,
-0.09926112741231918,
0.09929824620485306,
-0.37279513478279114,
-0.05480329692363739,
0.46203234791755676,
-0.6408309936523438,
0.01367238536477089,
0.13978241384029388,
-0.8501631021499634,
-0.5415858626365662,
0.16272467374801636,
-0.5534523725509644,
-0.3096602261066437,
-0.280557245016098,
0.17260125279426575,
0.2553565204143524,
0.03899157792329788,
-0.4737094044685364,
-0.034277524799108505,
0.16218045353889465,
0.7635593414306641,
-0.3862189054489136,
-0.14259542524814606,
0.8304203748703003,
0.8002262711524963,
-0.2872219681739807,
-0.3284122347831726,
-0.45917782187461853,
-0.20037291944026947,
-0.2785473167896271,
1.0550410747528076,
-0.8072188496589661,
-0.4369581639766693,
-0.036578740924596786,
-0.08028820902109146,
0.1045464351773262,
-0.34400802850723267,
0.9044658541679382,
-0.6103824973106384,
0.7514783143997192,
-0.05104285851120949,
-0.38169699907302856,
-0.21170729398727417,
0.7019072771072388,
-0.5875928401947021,
0.8169721364974976,
0.21140384674072266,
-0.6731759905815125,
0.6575074195861816,
-0.40771764516830444,
-0.3126056492328644,
0.2131909430027008,
-0.3436759412288666,
-0.7348654866218567,
0.2380187064409256,
0.33942294120788574,
0.27790024876594543,
-0.7443621158599854,
0.4958883821964264,
-0.21321959793567657,
-0.4448716938495636,
-0.030392585322260857,
-0.3721870183944702,
0.7122400999069214,
0.40755918622016907,
-0.13547687232494354,
0.3544261157512665,
-0.5492724776268005,
0.11862663924694061,
-0.2877733111381531,
-0.5499747395515442,
-0.2878134548664093,
-0.0818960890173912,
0.23682992160320282,
-0.07334815710783005,
0.20642542839050293,
-0.5435910820960999,
0.06617972999811172,
-0.14905144274234772,
0.4506368935108185,
0.597441554069519,
-0.026995470747351646,
0.0026274784468114376,
-0.6970064043998718,
0.6441872715950012,
-0.26491212844848633,
0.24470463395118713,
-0.22775575518608093,
-0.8779365420341492,
-0.5223268270492554,
0.016230208799242973,
0.7430769801139832,
0.5646049380302429,
-0.5177015662193298,
0.5902934670448303,
-0.285589337348938,
-0.7475812435150146,
-0.7647558450698853,
-0.059142280369997025,
0.2826383411884308,
0.5812845230102539,
-0.01904471591114998,
-0.1841309666633606,
-0.2838805019855499,
-0.8456884026527405,
-0.267086923122406,
-0.7977917790412903,
-0.46625399589538574,
0.6723603010177612,
0.3992989659309387,
-0.39574259519577026,
1.028525948524475,
-0.2233782559633255,
-0.41852331161499023,
0.11440325528383255,
0.4736559987068176,
0.40592512488365173,
0.1844208985567093,
0.2511926591396332,
-0.909701943397522,
-0.5025427937507629,
-0.10929473489522934,
-0.902856707572937,
-0.5924978852272034,
-0.2015162855386734,
0.31037479639053345,
-0.061577245593070984,
0.6071488857269287,
-0.3133513033390045,
0.3637026250362396,
0.17956924438476562,
-0.06012929975986481,
0.3964745104312897,
-0.14014853537082672,
0.4222860038280487,
-0.8442056179046631,
0.5744488835334778,
0.2010950744152069,
0.026263175532221794,
-0.28966328501701355,
-0.07280190289020538,
-0.05852391943335533,
-0.48907679319381714,
-0.06854075193405151,
0.47157958149909973,
-0.22417478263378143,
-0.05512341856956482,
-0.37231022119522095,
0.12529970705509186,
-0.021509237587451935,
0.19668126106262207,
0.08890613913536072,
0.6476672291755676,
0.18062852323055267,
-0.43961775302886963,
0.3964564800262451,
0.25923416018486023,
-0.5071656107902527,
0.6831245422363281,
-0.8577617406845093,
0.05014346167445183,
-0.33051398396492004,
0.5760159492492676,
-1.0458030700683594,
0.148127481341362,
0.05476396158337593,
-0.8331511616706848,
-0.041003964841365814,
-0.023339247331023216,
-0.23093028366565704,
-0.4341432750225067,
-0.2937800884246826,
0.4812871515750885,
0.4386219382286072,
-0.37080973386764526,
0.7892220616340637,
0.4487271010875702,
-0.4397946000099182,
-0.48385050892829895,
-0.09007783234119415,
0.3007145822048187,
-0.017487945035099983,
-0.4081656336784363,
0.10321564227342606,
0.2035527527332306,
-0.21105726063251495,
0.03876078128814697,
0.0055565666407346725,
0.05443229153752327,
0.05215683579444885,
0.2687121331691742,
0.07254256308078766,
0.10200678557157516,
0.10892092436552048,
-0.09531587362289429,
-0.25972428917884827,
0.4423893690109253,
0.008689125999808311,
-0.02629149705171585,
-0.011116961017251015,
-0.3953992426395416,
-0.5481165647506714,
0.23419399559497833,
0.7238121032714844,
-0.21362197399139404,
-0.03340517729520798,
0.5202007293701172,
-0.22820653021335602,
-0.018384408205747604,
-0.643580436706543,
-0.23975878953933716,
-0.3757806718349457,
0.4286336302757263,
-0.3188099265098572,
-0.6693989038467407,
0.4710584878921509,
-0.039020001888275146,
0.2945747971534729,
0.5574706196784973,
0.4450327157974243,
-0.24250906705856323,
1.0195966958999634,
0.5755813121795654,
-0.5453739166259766,
0.6854409575462341,
0.08641405403614044,
0.26181140542030334,
-0.7595004439353943,
-0.3705543279647827,
-1.1048723459243774,
-0.32550889253616333,
-0.6722472310066223,
-0.32127416133880615,
0.6704255938529968,
-0.587450385093689,
-0.2710038125514984,
-0.03840983659029007,
-0.7400106191635132,
0.338449627161026,
0.718684196472168,
-0.0065765827894210815,
0.31913280487060547,
0.007214175071567297,
0.18628600239753723,
0.14039842784404755,
-0.6130220890045166,
-0.6049001812934875,
1.1984620094299316,
0.4552272856235504,
0.9268816113471985,
-0.35982194542884827,
0.753371000289917,
0.7712255120277405,
0.8759906888008118,
-0.5216076970100403,
0.6421892046928406,
-0.08087171614170074,
-0.5282751321792603,
-0.36056578159332275,
-0.5841256380081177,
-0.9395161271095276,
0.24376599490642548,
-0.2290610522031784,
-0.13532191514968872,
0.25197622179985046,
-0.11135275661945343,
-0.3392863869667053,
0.22084930539131165,
-0.3011469542980194,
0.4106770157814026,
-0.3983222246170044,
-0.2504957318305969,
-0.3579200506210327,
-0.6930904388427734,
0.09650874137878418,
-0.007987160235643387,
0.03297610953450203,
-0.08861226588487625,
-0.13925288617610931,
0.9614375829696655,
-0.056193288415670395,
0.7366759181022644,
-0.25879645347595215,
-0.10923416167497635,
0.2830717861652374,
-0.19324080646038055,
0.37190505862236023,
0.3418923020362854,
-0.04574460908770561,
0.12831544876098633,
0.09427382051944733,
-0.1923837512731552,
-0.6773658990859985,
0.6024729013442993,
-0.9173211455345154,
-0.8459120392799377,
-0.764985978603363,
-0.29037007689476013,
-0.1830194890499115,
0.15175294876098633,
0.06255925446748734,
-0.0873497724533081,
-0.26302433013916016,
0.2066124826669693,
0.4089852273464203,
-0.12302731722593307,
0.07221819460391998,
0.5214487314224243,
-0.2932306230068207,
-0.46947821974754333,
0.9547244906425476,
-0.1732841283082962,
-0.3744337558746338,
0.4581373631954193,
0.17666685581207275,
-0.331380695104599,
-0.5900084972381592,
-0.5611066222190857,
0.024478362873196602,
-0.44147050380706787,
-0.3048447370529175,
-0.7213159203529358,
-0.11890415102243423,
-0.250445157289505,
0.09529364109039307,
0.11346440762281418,
-0.25305092334747314,
-0.25131726264953613,
0.30586469173431396,
-0.09169875830411911,
0.8475741147994995,
0.1603413075208664,
-0.18833063542842865,
-0.7301055192947388,
0.35824066400527954,
0.542953610420227,
0.5401321649551392,
0.01916300132870674,
-0.5065397024154663,
-0.012796037830412388,
-0.1779046356678009,
-0.13899528980255127,
-0.5784357786178589,
0.11423766613006592,
0.17794449627399445,
0.9273214936256409,
0.3408561050891876,
0.1620255708694458,
0.013493377715349197,
-0.2574435770511627,
0.7178469896316528,
-0.15661172568798065,
-0.6690192222595215,
0.7130510210990906,
-0.45526236295700073,
0.2622717022895813,
0.8737508058547974,
0.5196444988250732,
-0.6300419569015503,
-0.4710712730884552,
-0.3960701525211334,
-0.7181448936462402,
0.37466639280319214,
0.0454009473323822,
-0.10533607751131058,
0.18901725113391876,
0.5263573527336121,
0.0831919014453888,
0.5263288617134094,
-0.6020099520683289,
0.33063358068466187,
-0.2352260798215866,
0.008104003965854645,
-0.17487873136997223,
-0.2307017296552658,
-0.10793181508779526,
-0.1307966560125351,
0.6875879764556885,
-0.24130740761756897,
0.3409132957458496,
0.3946710228919983,
0.0362924262881279,
-0.20106402039527893,
0.19202075898647308,
0.3836994171142578,
0.6331358551979065,
-0.3436884582042694,
-0.17266838252544403,
0.020329950377345085,
-0.5697569251060486,
0.36542561650276184,
0.09597637504339218,
-0.9179667234420776,
0.07566094398498535,
0.39794066548347473,
0.27737054228782654,
-0.25694912672042847,
-0.49940982460975647,
0.21698686480522156,
-0.3264862298965454,
-0.2229432761669159,
-0.30192965269088745,
-0.15042199194431305,
-0.5032145380973816,
0.026515724137425423,
0.6896888613700867,
0.006290368735790253,
0.29852721095085144,
-0.5712552070617676,
0.2852751612663269,
0.48647814989089966,
-0.39618924260139465,
-0.035169702023267746,
0.7495457530021667,
0.7479613423347473,
-0.5832594037055969,
0.837996244430542,
-0.050918273627758026,
-0.6778842210769653,
0.7692299485206604,
-0.03279402107000351,
1.0691732168197632,
-0.08525647968053818,
0.2728554904460907,
0.35883399844169617,
0.3710978031158447,
0.12775452435016632,
0.2344818413257599,
-0.22063325345516205,
-0.3558352291584015,
-0.24199335277080536,
-0.5603721737861633,
-0.8807076215744019,
0.05671967938542366,
-0.6567106246948242,
0.1430463343858719,
-0.5137059092521667,
-0.4047558605670929,
-0.09277267754077911,
0.2353624701499939,
-0.3817014694213867,
0.27147480845451355,
0.02844858728349209,
1.059991717338562,
-0.9843913912773132,
0.5615671873092651,
0.8342848420143127,
-0.318069189786911,
-0.043139226734638214,
0.24798181653022766,
-0.10746558010578156,
-0.4915787875652313,
0.7389593720436096,
0.24778345227241516,
-0.13764865696430206,
-0.33483847975730896,
-0.5027341842651367,
-0.7295037508010864,
0.7702061533927917,
-0.07076701521873474,
-0.5807515382766724,
0.12462364882230759,
-0.18756884336471558,
1.0068284273147583,
-0.4850371181964874,
0.727317214012146,
0.20677776634693146,
0.6311531066894531,
-0.18532466888427734,
-1.0491255521774292,
-0.12428968399763107,
-0.7492607235908508,
0.08336472511291504,
0.016071541234850883,
-0.7869646549224854,
0.7016007304191589,
-0.07343140244483948,
0.01874811388552189,
0.08196472376585007,
0.8550888299942017,
0.29605433344841003,
0.6821856498718262,
0.7396652102470398,
0.5001480579376221,
0.7250910997390747,
-0.08784985542297363,
0.6888121366500854,
-0.43194380402565,
0.2531094253063202,
0.7352133393287659,
-0.5681371688842773,
0.8924557566642761,
0.4009767770767212,
-0.3242819607257843,
0.5097784996032715,
0.7850296497344971,
-0.3376416563987732,
0.3850097358226776,
0.628152072429657,
-0.15598568320274353,
-0.20099951326847076,
-0.3395765721797943,
-0.4845331311225891,
0.2815719246864319,
0.2630145847797394,
-0.37018048763275146,
-0.23903435468673706,
0.06839849054813385,
-0.5044503211975098,
0.29126375913619995,
-0.4928586781024933,
0.907331645488739,
-0.25844669342041016,
-1.002924919128418,
0.3133436441421509,
-0.18787077069282532,
0.7499898076057434,
-0.45262083411216736,
-0.15121577680110931,
-0.14672765135765076,
0.05525175482034683,
-0.2403247207403183,
-0.8233891725540161,
0.24900643527507782,
0.09198100864887238,
-0.41210734844207764,
-0.4080803096294403,
0.41698652505874634,
-0.16682781279087067,
-0.7607022523880005,
0.0260643120855093,
0.7221319675445557,
0.21181711554527283,
0.08093097060918808,
-0.8148329257965088,
-0.002711620880290866,
-0.04662776738405228,
-0.2189805507659912,
0.28531256318092346,
0.24992217123508453,
-0.4335845410823822,
1.0234596729278564,
0.603122353553772,
0.02241525612771511,
-0.4215675890445709,
0.18342524766921997,
0.9161989092826843,
-0.6059446930885315,
-0.7239171266555786,
-0.21854941546916962,
-0.09587026387453079,
-0.028236113488674164,
-0.45462533831596375,
0.5952464938163757,
0.6685076355934143,
0.7199353575706482,
0.13878019154071808,
1.058564305305481,
-0.15655513107776642,
0.8263773322105408,
-0.012708802707493305,
0.9039227962493896,
-0.5127808451652527,
0.2998190224170685,
-0.15957091748714447,
-0.9977709650993347,
-0.46369725465774536,
0.7794267535209656,
-0.4904937148094177,
0.3803364336490631,
0.36492347717285156,
0.5395628213882446,
0.25626417994499207,
0.031187210232019424,
0.11722300946712494,
-0.08792471140623093,
0.4948703944683075,
0.516404926776886,
0.9591044187545776,
-0.24666805565357208,
0.6534711122512817,
0.14881692826747894,
-0.4011675715446472,
-0.30252665281295776,
-0.8999791741371155,
-1.0037356615066528,
-0.790109395980835,
-0.27263063192367554,
-0.33557841181755066,
0.22274816036224365,
0.6718994975090027,
0.5947712063789368,
-1.0329481363296509,
-0.24764201045036316,
0.13130810856819153,
0.22501376271247864,
-0.08251810073852539,
-0.16749590635299683,
0.4936552047729492,
-0.4307188391685486,
-0.646599531173706,
0.0979846715927124,
0.09253443032503128,
-0.20353490114212036,
-0.5880757570266724,
0.15614059567451477,
-0.11234299093484879,
-0.2344299703836441,
0.23310330510139465,
0.31726473569869995,
-0.6976698637008667,
-0.0821140930056572,
-0.09841430932283401,
-0.1124919131398201,
-0.11947450041770935,
1.1704041957855225,
-1.1632177829742432,
0.4031565487384796,
0.9912171959877014,
0.8971434831619263,
0.329354465007782,
0.17150188982486725,
0.6015355587005615,
-0.30817604064941406,
-0.2911839187145233,
0.7141338586807251,
0.20986418426036835,
0.12728802859783173,
-0.399727463722229,
0.5838232636451721,
0.14222916960716248,
-1.0230460166931152,
-0.9367329478263855,
0.02504982054233551,
-0.5932556986808777,
-0.07972820848226547,
0.7758250832557678,
-0.3020760416984558,
-0.277104914188385,
-0.2829441726207733,
-0.27773258090019226,
-0.06612652540206909,
-0.5442797541618347,
1.4518650770187378,
0.5748587250709534,
-0.12443976104259491,
-0.4071899950504303,
-0.19804280996322632,
0.4902215301990509,
0.5905309915542603,
-0.9075934886932373,
-0.02877158299088478,
0.2985017001628876,
-0.030554700642824173,
0.42401742935180664,
0.49867263436317444,
0.03477727994322777,
0.5885682106018066,
-0.21480928361415863,
-0.11072002351284027,
-0.15313243865966797,
-0.4252345860004425,
-0.5159764289855957,
0.3480176329612732,
0.15999089181423187,
0.16341552138328552
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08848v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08848v1
|
An Approach to Build Zero-Shot Slot-Filling System for Industry-Grade Conversational Assistants
| 2024-06-13T06:24:52 | 2024-06-13T06:24:52 |
G P Shrivatsa Bhargav, Sumit Neelam, Udit Sharma, Shajith Ikbal, Dheeraj Sreedhar, Hima Karanam, Sachindra Joshi, Pankaj Dhoolia, Dinesh Garg, Kyle Croutwater, Haode Qi, Eric Wayne, J William Murdock
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present an approach to build Large Language Model (LLM) based slot-filling
system to perform Dialogue State Tracking in conversational assistants serving
across a wide variety of industry-grade applications. Key requirements of this
system include: 1) usage of smaller-sized models to meet low latency
requirements and to enable convenient and cost-effective cloud and customer
premise deployments, and 2) zero-shot capabilities to serve across a wide
variety of domains, slot types and conversational scenarios. We adopt a
fine-tuning approach where a pre-trained LLM is fine-tuned into a slot-filling
model using task specific data. The fine-tuning data is prepared carefully to
cover a wide variety of slot-filling task scenarios that the model is expected
to face across various domains. We give details of the data preparation and
model building process. We also give a detailed analysis of the results of our
experimental evaluations. Results show that our prescribed approach for
slot-filling model building has resulted in 6.9% relative improvement of F1
metric over the best baseline on a realistic benchmark, while at the same time
reducing the latency by 57%. More over, the data we prepared has helped improve
F1 on an average by 4.2% relative across various slot-types.
|
[
-0.3935726284980774,
-1.0334227085113525,
0.692997395992279,
0.01833721622824669,
-0.07582459598779678,
0.050223369151353836,
0.039258576929569244,
-0.5915421843528748,
0.32935830950737,
0.6841040849685669,
-0.4765515923500061,
-0.24724769592285156,
-0.1434110552072525,
-0.19054654240608215,
-0.32587388157844543,
0.42326539754867554,
0.1531320959329605,
-0.1497441977262497,
-0.263579785823822,
0.24345213174819946,
-1.0456345081329346,
-0.5779507756233215,
-0.7937794923782349,
-0.43741798400878906,
0.16483467817306519,
0.6911290287971497,
0.7291377782821655,
0.7156714797019958,
0.14641603827476501,
0.286674439907074,
-0.18091632425785065,
0.012808197177946568,
-0.45949387550354004,
0.2274990975856781,
0.028548508882522583,
-0.43525078892707825,
-1.0187910795211792,
-0.1425255984067917,
0.34751567244529724,
0.8174645304679871,
-0.5783730149269104,
-0.10135550796985626,
0.007220922503620386,
0.09159115701913834,
-0.5546998977661133,
0.15985843539237976,
-0.9934089779853821,
0.14924293756484985,
-0.1515621840953827,
-0.28167426586151123,
-0.4917984902858734,
-0.021113954484462738,
0.15189017355442047,
-0.7486438751220703,
0.32013043761253357,
0.017666470259428024,
0.8259491920471191,
0.2119397222995758,
-0.10061311721801758,
0.04872928187251091,
-0.8921942114830017,
0.8463547825813293,
-0.9620442986488342,
0.27073541283607483,
0.287890762090683,
0.31499478220939636,
-0.225494846701622,
-0.14701330661773682,
-0.6581712961196899,
-0.3882574141025543,
0.20254673063755035,
-0.01064873393625021,
0.11240549385547638,
0.30932003259658813,
0.21483546495437622,
0.4150486886501312,
-0.5198756456375122,
0.24441905319690704,
-0.2427070140838623,
0.06334416568279266,
0.5496882796287537,
0.5112349390983582,
0.22667230665683746,
0.21846336126327515,
-0.14137476682662964,
0.07952817529439926,
-0.9248114228248596,
-0.10423296689987183,
0.023300377652049065,
0.5828101634979248,
-0.07808786630630493,
0.6278179287910461,
-0.4905826151371002,
1.021841049194336,
0.08202867209911346,
-0.18576224148273468,
-0.07843158394098282,
-0.12437605857849121,
-0.6635242700576782,
0.10159195214509964,
0.5200352072715759,
0.15749777853488922,
0.125518336892128,
-0.22467894852161407,
-0.12988252937793732,
0.09500140696763992,
0.5617178678512573,
-0.6288918256759644,
0.2696240544319153,
0.378397136926651,
0.1989450752735138,
-0.48088565468788147,
-0.5800941586494446,
-0.3050236403942108,
-0.35071486234664917,
-0.4610242247581482,
0.3310536742210388,
-0.4286822974681854,
-0.1633557677268982,
0.3355691134929657,
0.14789779484272003,
0.43332812190055847,
0.791772186756134,
-0.9227824807167053,
0.10599589347839355,
0.9605548977851868,
1.0330369472503662,
-0.004334787372499704,
-0.06146400794386864,
-0.45378023386001587,
0.3709143102169037,
-0.6074908971786499,
0.8716049194335938,
-0.4615117013454437,
-0.6182392835617065,
0.41624578833580017,
-0.1600918471813202,
-0.1392180174589157,
-0.5745934247970581,
0.32995176315307617,
-0.501585066318512,
-0.004065707791596651,
0.27693527936935425,
-0.7297794818878174,
0.24568043649196625,
0.5015382766723633,
-0.3255726099014282,
0.9713240265846252,
0.06164003536105156,
0.08459904789924622,
0.15917183458805084,
-0.5915963649749756,
-0.2527526319026947,
0.4939369857311249,
-0.2529260218143463,
-0.1492212414741516,
0.036079999059438705,
0.09981521219015121,
0.6068620681762695,
-0.06609845161437988,
0.3628726303577423,
-0.4875714182853699,
-0.5342077612876892,
0.3925514221191406,
-0.3699203431606293,
0.4724886119365692,
0.10729622095823288,
0.035637859255075455,
-0.05247063562273979,
-0.7300060391426086,
-0.1807153820991516,
-0.18319672346115112,
-0.22657272219657898,
-0.008469682186841965,
-0.2865186631679535,
0.06213206797838211,
0.13565397262573242,
0.30234846472740173,
-0.8383090496063232,
0.36042821407318115,
-0.5630599856376648,
0.31343039870262146,
0.7673021554946899,
-0.029298068955540657,
0.5134320855140686,
-0.3325141370296478,
0.6901953816413879,
0.11378375440835953,
0.275546669960022,
-0.3937941789627075,
-0.43333739042282104,
-1.0034672021865845,
-0.20333868265151978,
0.2864726483821869,
0.6526681780815125,
-0.7472015023231506,
0.7275041341781616,
-0.04517865180969238,
-0.579285740852356,
-0.49435314536094666,
0.0024993729311972857,
0.24431781470775604,
0.7794774770736694,
0.01599142514169216,
-0.4763391315937042,
-0.13148453831672668,
-0.7107750773429871,
0.4081479609012604,
0.028552576899528503,
-0.16848072409629822,
0.4871031939983368,
0.08233598619699478,
0.0691239982843399,
0.9800265431404114,
-0.7470135688781738,
-0.652870237827301,
-0.21347582340240479,
-0.008589508943259716,
0.3672848343849182,
0.552017331123352,
0.33057329058647156,
-0.07163801044225693,
-0.5567436218261719,
0.14322952926158905,
-0.7144423127174377,
-0.01888909749686718,
-0.10625768452882767,
-0.15884028375148773,
0.39380910992622375,
0.5292851328849792,
-0.755969226360321,
0.5870736837387085,
0.2867515981197357,
-0.22066906094551086,
0.27120816707611084,
-0.1634429544210434,
-0.012998196296393871,
-1.1468983888626099,
0.2223728448152542,
0.19982556998729706,
-0.5227876305580139,
-0.9293924570083618,
-0.09301568567752838,
-0.2356470376253128,
-0.8915846347808838,
-0.7582142353057861,
0.589394748210907,
-0.2043188512325287,
-0.04450838640332222,
-0.49775072932243347,
0.12354538589715958,
0.10901357233524323,
0.8542149662971497,
0.26108258962631226,
0.8201537728309631,
0.4524731934070587,
-0.6176498532295227,
0.16042330861091614,
0.40171191096305847,
-0.34706342220306396,
0.8054003119468689,
-0.8761405348777771,
0.11207354813814163,
0.03596901148557663,
0.23202666640281677,
-1.0607491731643677,
-0.043473273515701294,
0.11824139207601547,
-0.4225172996520996,
0.2002130150794983,
-0.3010219633579254,
-0.30558696389198303,
0.036882881075143814,
0.15831413865089417,
-0.025883253663778305,
0.3472183644771576,
-0.22731387615203857,
0.3905857503414154,
0.554267942905426,
-0.6250014305114746,
-0.5392751097679138,
-0.4181102514266968,
0.14437775313854218,
-0.05984250456094742,
-0.7119581699371338,
0.4945593774318695,
-0.09322749823331833,
0.3106659948825836,
-0.22361800074577332,
-0.11304713785648346,
-0.4110618233680725,
0.07109908014535904,
0.2554147243499756,
0.605522632598877,
-0.3587743937969208,
-0.0521613247692585,
-0.2134322077035904,
-0.11085481196641922,
-0.35698238015174866,
-0.029476290568709373,
0.8291881084442139,
0.20925931632518768,
-0.37204432487487793,
-0.9049142003059387,
0.4253791570663452,
0.7060012221336365,
0.08426157385110855,
0.6957542896270752,
0.20271606743335724,
-0.4008355438709259,
-0.18422669172286987,
-0.8046598434448242,
-0.05811670795083046,
-0.5234869718551636,
0.0989304706454277,
-0.38778406381607056,
-0.9243613481521606,
0.420658677816391,
0.13204413652420044,
0.2684068977832794,
0.007626048289239407,
0.4249385595321655,
-0.12329606711864471,
0.8872772455215454,
0.897968590259552,
-0.2876819968223572,
0.9075374007225037,
-0.274596631526947,
0.2735254466533661,
-0.804831862449646,
0.012187632732093334,
-0.5972357988357544,
0.12290659546852112,
-0.054304420948028564,
-0.653532087802887,
0.47883445024490356,
-0.026393001899123192,
-0.22184054553508759,
0.3425864577293396,
-0.33266106247901917,
0.4314279556274414,
0.4338781237602234,
-0.14098748564720154,
0.3172592520713806,
-0.07827053964138031,
0.14342202246189117,
0.24473656713962555,
-0.6813714504241943,
-0.5646160244941711,
0.9590153098106384,
0.4720195531845093,
0.7611661553382874,
0.10189463943243027,
0.41739925742149353,
0.3844777047634125,
-0.03032572753727436,
-0.888670027256012,
0.6287317276000977,
-0.07486420124769211,
-0.3956978917121887,
-0.7451923489570618,
-0.009825142100453377,
-0.9125996828079224,
0.28380027413368225,
-0.16604653000831604,
-0.9090062379837036,
0.09729613363742828,
0.42892351746559143,
-0.7415032386779785,
-0.02704448439180851,
-0.6315402388572693,
0.8488903641700745,
0.05626579746603966,
-0.23618176579475403,
-0.3002844452857971,
-0.07555229216814041,
0.23669877648353577,
0.1471806913614273,
-0.353943794965744,
-0.24845349788665771,
0.2731960415840149,
0.25751376152038574,
-0.7245030999183655,
1.0182102918624878,
-0.3225102424621582,
-0.31533464789390564,
0.2529445290565491,
0.04494569078087807,
0.5168557167053223,
0.019453316926956177,
-0.3019444942474365,
0.2286100536584854,
-0.016884611919522285,
-0.4077552855014801,
-0.6872859001159668,
0.771105945110321,
-0.7702479958534241,
-0.4950621426105499,
-0.44210177659988403,
-0.6671707630157471,
-0.5382233262062073,
0.02802143804728985,
-0.3382608890533447,
0.5706751346588135,
-0.45102208852767944,
0.25500747561454773,
0.9443515539169312,
-0.3617912828922272,
0.4518318176269531,
0.9963415265083313,
-0.005837416276335716,
-0.1250395029783249,
0.8339307904243469,
0.16232255101203918,
0.22857613861560822,
0.5458419919013977,
-0.35177838802337646,
-0.33700069785118103,
-0.20257075130939484,
-0.8951470851898193,
0.10422392934560776,
-0.04427782818675041,
-0.3659646511077881,
-0.5064029097557068,
-0.44083094596862793,
-0.7640182375907898,
-0.4960327744483948,
-0.5180197954177856,
-0.36427390575408936,
-0.3412132263183594,
0.21472182869911194,
0.32252541184425354,
0.4679774343967438,
0.4075959324836731,
0.9970008134841919,
-0.4865052402019501,
0.16242055594921112,
0.2618997097015381,
0.6361992955207825,
0.16980679333209991,
-0.5420423150062561,
-0.33867979049682617,
-0.0463104248046875,
-0.6500775814056396,
-0.6168816685676575,
0.5442164540290833,
-0.014299423433840275,
0.5168277025222778,
0.26877346634864807,
-0.34873607754707336,
1.046845555305481,
-0.6324437260627747,
1.0589120388031006,
0.2856218218803406,
-0.8886205554008484,
0.5900947451591492,
-0.6161929368972778,
0.49330222606658936,
0.40677517652511597,
-0.09627211838960648,
-0.7863940596580505,
-0.48161959648132324,
-0.6253482699394226,
-0.8494616150856018,
1.0494056940078735,
-0.022838305681943893,
0.1359102874994278,
0.2227519005537033,
0.24608521163463593,
-0.2709055542945862,
0.2284240871667862,
-0.3981741964817047,
0.15825065970420837,
0.025165017694234848,
-0.07582391053438187,
-0.13140957057476044,
-0.02688155695796013,
-0.01287498977035284,
0.09358707815408707,
0.9937071204185486,
-0.227570578455925,
0.3178839385509491,
0.01458050962537527,
-0.08562979102134705,
-0.15086586773395538,
0.4709005653858185,
0.7190769910812378,
0.6107380390167236,
-0.4797404706478119,
-0.6996639966964722,
0.0931553766131401,
-0.08937301486730576,
0.007192451041191816,
0.03009391948580742,
-0.3462449908256531,
0.16160210967063904,
-0.26045674085617065,
0.8512221574783325,
0.011900731362402439,
-0.6914189457893372,
0.5868149995803833,
-0.009388348087668419,
0.03394801542162895,
-0.6889014840126038,
0.24929101765155792,
-0.0184318944811821,
-0.03674199804663658,
0.09778726100921631,
-0.2897093594074249,
0.019496101886034012,
-0.5116398930549622,
-0.030355149880051613,
0.6646543741226196,
-0.46616125106811523,
-0.005202899221330881,
0.40680015087127686,
0.5752733945846558,
-0.4026601016521454,
0.5390474796295166,
-0.06092660874128342,
0.17994791269302368,
0.5807452201843262,
0.6728752851486206,
0.6364257335662842,
-0.3398461937904358,
0.34819507598876953,
0.19777533411979675,
0.04842095449566841,
0.0029766522347927094,
0.19910378754138947,
-0.09118402749300003,
-0.7099065780639648,
-0.6602205634117126,
-0.689728856086731,
-0.7621659636497498,
0.7853986620903015,
-0.42498666048049927,
0.42312684655189514,
-0.5294246673583984,
-0.16896556317806244,
0.12081047147512436,
-0.010676451027393341,
-0.7784846425056458,
0.24630993604660034,
0.3672528862953186,
1.0714142322540283,
-0.8231712579727173,
0.8708553314208984,
0.4195253252983093,
-0.4596167504787445,
-0.8187434077262878,
-0.3315693736076355,
-0.02020258642733097,
-0.9576377272605896,
0.18253517150878906,
-0.1359700709581375,
-0.01991880126297474,
-0.32983285188674927,
-0.3263677656650543,
-1.029110312461853,
1.1745558977127075,
0.1802705079317093,
-0.7444074749946594,
-0.13778191804885864,
0.5370733737945557,
0.6841895580291748,
-0.5429893136024475,
0.38161700963974,
0.5591565370559692,
-0.13326306641101837,
0.3597687780857086,
-1.1748406887054443,
-0.22420349717140198,
-0.11293315142393112,
0.43068861961364746,
0.18428079783916473,
-0.6837627291679382,
0.6886107325553894,
0.5028626918792725,
-0.05150850862264633,
0.32894402742385864,
0.4468880891799927,
0.3763722777366638,
0.2795473337173462,
0.5569510459899902,
0.7168503999710083,
0.5637330412864685,
0.2798219323158264,
0.5464684367179871,
-0.6260589361190796,
0.015340788289904594,
1.3024183511734009,
-0.7593612670898438,
0.988451361656189,
0.4107910096645355,
0.1028226986527443,
0.3384374976158142,
0.3432922661304474,
0.19324949383735657,
0.23214076459407806,
0.21304965019226074,
-0.3150638937950134,
-0.13048408925533295,
-0.6257161498069763,
-0.3698877990245819,
0.5152888298034668,
0.6670071482658386,
-0.029594786465168,
-0.13138695061206818,
-0.18836824595928192,
0.03806683421134949,
-0.2709214389324188,
-0.2503431439399719,
0.9455052018165588,
0.04846920445561409,
-1.0196698904037476,
0.5576511025428772,
0.0665379986166954,
0.5958371758460999,
-0.6364706158638,
-0.21221426129341125,
-0.5149009227752686,
0.09067725390195847,
0.04504208266735077,
-0.6612641215324402,
0.30287790298461914,
0.2848489582538605,
-0.07956814020872116,
-0.4125913977622986,
0.6748822927474976,
-0.5060312151908875,
-0.4731527864933014,
-0.26720866560935974,
0.5555895566940308,
0.29018527269363403,
0.04055432230234146,
-0.6016009449958801,
0.0866445004940033,
-0.037815019488334656,
0.16597647964954376,
0.4445030093193054,
0.18177612125873566,
-0.04402879253029823,
0.513170599937439,
0.6034014821052551,
0.3170556128025055,
-0.037748679518699646,
0.2850233018398285,
0.5295977592468262,
-0.6053158044815063,
-0.7822155356407166,
-0.3871792256832123,
0.6058991551399231,
-0.23452025651931763,
-0.38515347242355347,
0.25090983510017395,
0.6691678166389465,
0.6795493364334106,
-0.14812493324279785,
0.7662615776062012,
0.10660665482282639,
0.7590470910072327,
-0.3527708947658539,
0.5097442269325256,
-0.4935658574104309,
0.31116440892219543,
-0.17975632846355438,
-0.7646530866622925,
-0.021772921085357666,
0.49878910183906555,
-0.1599898785352707,
-0.3800777494907379,
0.11440864205360413,
1.3529423475265503,
-0.24919897317886353,
-0.0807667225599289,
0.7018980979919434,
0.05199206992983818,
0.5498449206352234,
0.5263594388961792,
0.7516177892684937,
-0.4092465937137604,
0.53730708360672,
-0.10413257032632828,
-0.4246774911880493,
-0.46082833409309387,
-0.6816520690917969,
-0.5303249955177307,
-0.28649118542671204,
-0.5399958491325378,
-0.18784169852733612,
0.012275158427655697,
0.6316822171211243,
1.085487723350525,
-0.564120888710022,
-0.6705257892608643,
0.019770050421357155,
-0.23838640749454498,
-0.16394935548305511,
-0.31213852763175964,
-0.15619955956935883,
-0.513427734375,
-0.9649099707603455,
0.6657004356384277,
0.44019225239753723,
0.007393321488052607,
-0.3405076861381531,
0.1563040167093277,
-0.16015882790088654,
0.4954899549484253,
0.7545800805091858,
0.47769126296043396,
-0.7580752372741699,
-0.3350813686847687,
0.0459631010890007,
-0.20159390568733215,
0.18960843980312347,
0.6747052669525146,
-0.6918991804122925,
0.40531212091445923,
0.3636050522327423,
0.6775192022323608,
0.5508161783218384,
-0.020092934370040894,
0.8695212006568909,
-1.2021585702896118,
0.2623386085033417,
0.0975877195596695,
0.42982491850852966,
0.39255377650260925,
-0.5616884827613831,
0.5357266068458557,
-0.13694627583026886,
-0.710625946521759,
-0.9416760802268982,
0.30289193987846375,
-1.3708115816116333,
-0.07883364707231522,
0.8472418189048767,
-0.0372919924557209,
-0.09667842090129852,
-0.2419891357421875,
-0.15175454318523407,
0.2050088346004486,
-0.7083332538604736,
0.9231784343719482,
0.548592746257782,
-0.47672969102859497,
0.03782685846090317,
-0.5215243697166443,
0.27879801392555237,
0.5550058484077454,
-0.9774169921875,
0.05814970284700394,
0.6673470735549927,
0.2889295518398285,
0.3899059593677521,
1.1935325860977173,
0.0627436637878418,
0.19823864102363586,
-0.14341208338737488,
0.18475975096225739,
0.12611597776412964,
-0.33718329668045044,
-0.4558809697628021,
0.12766776978969574,
0.16763070225715637,
-0.41137298941612244
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08842v1
|
ContraSolver: Self-Alignment of Language Models by Resolving Internal Preference Contradictions
| 2024-06-13T06:08:04 | 2024-06-13T06:08:04 |
Xu Zhang, Xunjian Yin, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While substantial advancements have been made in developing large language
models (LLMs), achieving control over their behavior can be difficult. Direct
preference optimization (DPO) assumes the existence of a latent reward function
to evaluate the responses of LLMs. This assumption indicates a strict
preference ordering of different responses to the same input. However, there
always exist contradictions of preference in LLMs according to our experimental
observations. In this paper, we construct a graph structure of the preference
relationship among different responses with self-annotation to find
contradictions in the preference order. We propose ContraSolver, an algorithm
that traverses all edges on the preference graph to identify those that might
cause contradictions. ContraSolver initializes the graph with a maximum
spanning tree and identifies contradictory edges, prioritizing the resolution
of low-confidence preferences while preserving high-confidence ones.
Experimental results on four different generation tasks show that the
performance of different LLMs can be largely improved through our completely
unsupervised self-alignment. Furthermore, by analyzing the preference graphs of
LLMs with and without self-alignment by ContraSolver, we quantify the reduction
in contradictions, suggesting that resolving preference contradictions is
crucial for achieving better alignment performance.
|
[
-0.4162580966949463,
-0.4914951026439667,
0.6553389430046082,
0.10351552814245224,
-0.18528544902801514,
0.1577119678258896,
0.03191198781132698,
-0.11448021978139877,
0.24506178498268127,
0.6521546244621277,
-1.0037758350372314,
-0.22863151133060455,
-0.4869057834148407,
0.2367844432592392,
-0.13927412033081055,
0.8992988467216492,
-0.15576283633708954,
-0.05877107381820679,
-0.6414236426353455,
-0.1182541772723198,
-0.44068390130996704,
-0.4550129175186157,
-0.06815779209136963,
-0.6542233824729919,
0.2697605788707733,
0.5816529393196106,
0.8629162907600403,
0.6585063934326172,
0.31270068883895874,
0.4925141930580139,
0.22579945623874664,
0.13506658375263214,
-0.6123489737510681,
0.33476290106773376,
-0.3663228154182434,
-0.26167017221450806,
-0.5286452174186707,
-0.07001201063394547,
0.3614710867404938,
0.48423629999160767,
0.1705896258354187,
0.07581505179405212,
0.26579749584198,
0.8399528861045837,
-0.49860599637031555,
-0.22165130078792572,
-0.6252923011779785,
-0.058630429208278656,
-0.34693625569343567,
-0.25411543250083923,
-0.22540365159511566,
-0.30424073338508606,
0.04067329689860344,
-0.5516037344932556,
0.15987414121627808,
0.02149520255625248,
0.8803553581237793,
0.6503827571868896,
-0.2480301409959793,
-0.2388525754213333,
-0.6765415668487549,
0.7451931834220886,
-0.8584566116333008,
0.32910045981407166,
0.19081099331378937,
0.14885731041431427,
-0.5488891005516052,
-0.25773271918296814,
-0.709709882736206,
-0.08234573155641556,
-0.22163638472557068,
0.16153916716575623,
-0.3594711124897003,
0.1820671558380127,
0.010778914205729961,
0.32180455327033997,
-0.8162673711776733,
0.46880102157592773,
0.0900317132472992,
-0.0904780849814415,
0.654927670955658,
0.3217690885066986,
0.31204017996788025,
-0.11854493618011475,
-0.35285624861717224,
0.06901933997869492,
-0.8560847640037537,
0.07085253298282623,
0.75522381067276,
0.4241832494735718,
0.07949861139059067,
0.7206409573554993,
-0.17040960490703583,
0.6256038546562195,
0.5293344855308533,
-0.16052238643169403,
0.4915616512298584,
-0.1520185023546219,
-0.16217444837093353,
0.10430831462144852,
0.9159084558486938,
0.3105904161930084,
0.17818421125411987,
0.0296623557806015,
-0.27006223797798157,
0.18119622766971588,
0.1046171709895134,
-0.5023265480995178,
-0.12114765495061874,
0.3655644953250885,
-0.10321573168039322,
-0.16913221776485443,
-0.3290763795375824,
-0.7872726917266846,
-0.4672855734825134,
-0.38670432567596436,
0.4025123119354248,
-0.07211028039455414,
-0.3128832280635834,
-0.052231840789318085,
0.19712337851524353,
-0.08411965519189835,
0.16721801459789276,
-0.8522801995277405,
0.4007934033870697,
0.732267439365387,
0.6009730696678162,
-0.1362723410129547,
-0.32282283902168274,
-0.3218630254268646,
0.046550922095775604,
-0.37350916862487793,
0.6942411661148071,
-0.514514148235321,
-0.4103263318538666,
-0.3481549024581909,
-0.15960511565208435,
-0.02641811966896057,
-0.44096291065216064,
0.5511005520820618,
-0.26750901341438293,
0.4614928662776947,
-0.46292316913604736,
-0.7974013090133667,
0.12015058100223541,
0.046699199825525284,
-0.35780179500579834,
0.9020405411720276,
-0.011611764319241047,
-0.8952921032905579,
-0.01816754788160324,
-0.47530779242515564,
-0.10960942506790161,
0.17404305934906006,
-0.4513889253139496,
-0.4940441846847534,
0.23409128189086914,
0.1060706079006195,
0.13123317062854767,
-0.3748403787612915,
0.342854380607605,
-0.4774567186832428,
-0.19416171312332153,
0.08455049991607666,
-0.1832762211561203,
0.7463539242744446,
0.25134265422821045,
-0.604191243648529,
0.33879706263542175,
-0.4230838716030121,
0.05004596710205078,
0.4200812876224518,
0.23526044189929962,
-0.5727046728134155,
0.19809144735336304,
-0.49627459049224854,
0.3983200490474701,
0.5063244700431824,
-0.6755450963973999,
0.5155823230743408,
-0.49023595452308655,
0.23371218144893646,
1.2601511478424072,
-0.40073534846305847,
0.3845672011375427,
-0.23949819803237915,
0.5465813279151917,
-0.017810773104429245,
0.3481130599975586,
0.2716982662677765,
-0.18328553438186646,
-0.8152487874031067,
-0.10113981366157532,
0.06360805034637451,
0.2772957980632782,
-0.422277569770813,
0.6078044772148132,
-0.26329007744789124,
-0.33463355898857117,
-0.5774328708648682,
0.38411810994148254,
0.6573348641395569,
0.935187816619873,
0.4084017872810364,
-0.07643836736679077,
-0.636687695980072,
-1.1538761854171753,
-0.17807821929454803,
-0.14155374467372894,
0.5235000848770142,
0.4480608105659485,
0.21868856251239777,
-0.2767558693885803,
1.2257399559020996,
-0.7466080188751221,
-0.32086700201034546,
-0.024677226319909096,
0.022736432030797005,
0.33015939593315125,
0.42490845918655396,
0.4692695736885071,
-0.7763904333114624,
-0.6331683993339539,
-0.16951848566532135,
-0.49718230962753296,
-0.704631507396698,
0.17014838755130768,
-0.06778094917535782,
0.42850494384765625,
0.508299708366394,
-0.17029781639575958,
0.28709423542022705,
0.9382761716842651,
-0.15723824501037598,
0.6791187524795532,
-0.20203493535518646,
-0.22952605783939362,
-0.7516289949417114,
-0.02188807912170887,
-0.21132874488830566,
-0.29198992252349854,
-0.5554664134979248,
-0.2512127459049225,
-0.05516662821173668,
0.30390751361846924,
-0.10789331793785095,
0.53630131483078,
-0.5662577748298645,
-0.02468705363571644,
-0.5266323089599609,
0.3363609313964844,
-0.046838004142045975,
0.4294082522392273,
0.03561689704656601,
0.796725869178772,
0.42655980587005615,
-0.4096297025680542,
0.40137383341789246,
0.2884979546070099,
0.10852302610874176,
0.5295848846435547,
-0.5865278840065002,
0.4586087763309479,
-0.3656630516052246,
0.07907123863697052,
-1.3935364484786987,
0.17397361993789673,
0.3174530565738678,
-0.2213686853647232,
0.3513280749320984,
-0.2817549407482147,
-0.0168398879468441,
-0.48325660824775696,
-0.10956624895334244,
0.4459574818611145,
0.377805233001709,
-0.6338292360305786,
0.545181930065155,
0.2677094042301178,
-0.056282151490449905,
-1.0222399234771729,
-0.4627472460269928,
-0.2345130443572998,
-0.15766578912734985,
-0.4013915956020355,
0.3929417133331299,
-0.4173191487789154,
-0.19250625371932983,
0.15244963765144348,
-0.29401087760925293,
0.3553573787212372,
-0.04871734231710434,
0.5421399474143982,
0.2766868770122528,
-0.27156636118888855,
0.07859282195568085,
0.04282527416944504,
-0.3555639088153839,
-0.19380603730678558,
-0.3618360161781311,
0.6845508813858032,
-0.19188439846038818,
-0.4923689067363739,
-0.15771007537841797,
0.20372940599918365,
0.40640389919281006,
-0.14668059349060059,
0.26403889060020447,
-0.19030645489692688,
0.06504268199205399,
-0.13039495050907135,
-0.7157537341117859,
0.23713381588459015,
-0.6164497137069702,
0.09456206858158112,
-0.7523781657218933,
-0.6632511019706726,
0.2825496196746826,
-0.21261027455329895,
-0.05656396597623825,
0.5753721594810486,
0.47813358902931213,
-0.10982264578342438,
1.0943810939788818,
0.6381793022155762,
-0.18801374733448029,
0.3442589342594147,
0.021134236827492714,
0.2353868931531906,
-0.7828871607780457,
0.036794599145650864,
-0.5525516271591187,
-0.26813626289367676,
-0.7838727235794067,
0.141813263297081,
0.2477281242609024,
0.09224347025156021,
-0.2272583395242691,
0.41406720876693726,
-0.6007859706878662,
0.6349987983703613,
0.2679271996021271,
-0.2718464732170105,
0.2554487884044647,
-0.24887651205062866,
-0.6619870662689209,
-0.21629482507705688,
-0.5730801820755005,
-0.5425485372543335,
0.8357706069946289,
0.12119118124246597,
0.8093519806861877,
0.3234758675098419,
0.9599865674972534,
-0.012100117281079292,
0.17878767848014832,
-0.5425950884819031,
0.563546895980835,
-0.43265360593795776,
-0.4576292335987091,
-0.40583887696266174,
-0.5291051864624023,
-1.0444718599319458,
0.21902625262737274,
-0.09115253388881683,
-0.8665234446525574,
0.2686716318130493,
0.3653860092163086,
-0.1659461408853531,
0.10554435849189758,
-0.6229453682899475,
1.027779221534729,
-0.7053837180137634,
-0.37043556571006775,
0.07905860245227814,
-0.6849634051322937,
0.24438226222991943,
-0.09452226012945175,
0.09827255457639694,
-0.33857932686805725,
0.13632409274578094,
0.33840885758399963,
-0.5366193652153015,
0.7441613078117371,
-0.02303275093436241,
-0.23756170272827148,
-0.058724917471408844,
0.4471062123775482,
0.479290246963501,
-0.3693614602088928,
-0.0054100616835057735,
0.014094696380198002,
-0.06969675421714783,
-0.2402351200580597,
-0.7198269367218018,
1.0870842933654785,
-1.0813648700714111,
-1.1532124280929565,
-0.6149266958236694,
-0.4458678960800171,
-0.28483372926712036,
0.473734587430954,
0.3817872405052185,
0.2741171419620514,
-0.3070501983165741,
-0.2892681062221527,
0.27396583557128906,
0.018413852900266647,
0.4521031081676483,
0.5102669596672058,
-0.4564465284347534,
-0.27232977747917175,
0.8421918749809265,
0.2465670257806778,
0.4198163151741028,
0.3734184503555298,
0.6778114438056946,
-0.6470437049865723,
-0.47168591618537903,
-0.347827672958374,
0.3891400992870331,
-0.6223185658454895,
-0.24298624694347382,
-0.43561187386512756,
-0.09251723438501358,
-0.6709614992141724,
-0.08582251518964767,
-0.6144208908081055,
-0.3716113567352295,
-0.21985267102718353,
0.15739399194717407,
0.04975195974111557,
0.9218683838844299,
-0.17297331988811493,
0.0617077611386776,
-0.2959321439266205,
0.2581866979598999,
0.34760409593582153,
0.37075960636138916,
-0.21499109268188477,
-0.5216606259346008,
0.3569552004337311,
0.0499006062746048,
-0.40663301944732666,
-0.9223547577857971,
0.2424241006374359,
-0.02786332555115223,
0.6239347457885742,
0.5122308135032654,
0.2438974529504776,
0.9251097440719604,
-0.5872676372528076,
0.37691283226013184,
0.32362765073776245,
-1.352177619934082,
0.43938741087913513,
-0.21495448052883148,
0.14292500913143158,
0.5110042095184326,
0.4897521436214447,
-0.4741916358470917,
-0.27871641516685486,
-0.6265649795532227,
-0.7746427059173584,
0.7387360334396362,
0.1381550133228302,
0.030495483428239822,
0.2465144842863083,
0.399503618478775,
0.19839976727962494,
0.13186898827552795,
-0.7533912658691406,
-0.3800424337387085,
-0.5714642405509949,
-0.39488741755485535,
-0.39416801929473877,
-0.19554278254508972,
-0.3607589900493622,
-0.016036298125982285,
0.763394296169281,
-0.3226853013038635,
-0.13400380313396454,
0.2868776023387909,
-0.013387065380811691,
-0.5067740678787231,
0.23958319425582886,
0.7372922301292419,
0.6151829361915588,
-0.1535995751619339,
0.5047728419303894,
-0.07829546928405762,
-0.031247474253177643,
0.4623614251613617,
0.026984388008713722,
-0.2537730634212494,
-0.2765273451805115,
-0.009185110218822956,
0.5828589200973511,
-0.2629748284816742,
-0.36889520287513733,
0.7650934457778931,
-0.014251269400119781,
0.0026502555701881647,
-0.15746016800403595,
0.05802905932068825,
0.1519041359424591,
0.12313719093799591,
0.1008419319987297,
-0.11246933043003082,
-0.016571560874581337,
-0.3284269869327545,
0.10978788882493973,
0.8106749653816223,
-0.35314661264419556,
-0.2144283503293991,
0.299828439950943,
0.13935136795043945,
-0.3863108456134796,
0.527735710144043,
-0.12236124277114868,
-0.7493200898170471,
0.3186478316783905,
0.7663211822509766,
0.9356651306152344,
-0.547500729560852,
0.20533603429794312,
0.0058281333185732365,
0.2422155737876892,
0.07645771652460098,
-0.00898265466094017,
0.013769884593784809,
-1.0565286874771118,
-0.21654728055000305,
-0.3596433997154236,
-0.3446181118488312,
0.2434011697769165,
-0.37225595116615295,
0.27110323309898376,
-0.4377081096172333,
-0.16161157190799713,
0.11484493315219879,
-0.0025806345511227846,
-0.3592560887336731,
0.16671307384967804,
-0.03467240184545517,
0.24887003004550934,
-0.8795128464698792,
0.8122000694274902,
0.4197786748409271,
-0.39534544944763184,
-0.5677109360694885,
0.13105562329292297,
0.3263789713382721,
-0.8291791081428528,
0.7079910635948181,
-0.09599533677101135,
-0.6546840071678162,
-0.06491666287183762,
-0.44827303290367126,
-1.0418673753738403,
0.6448721289634705,
0.6391468048095703,
-0.8209647536277771,
0.19998028874397278,
0.22055500745773315,
0.5695340633392334,
-0.39671066403388977,
0.3796572685241699,
0.20147748291492462,
0.39002761244773865,
0.2126619666814804,
-0.9637019634246826,
0.3275200426578522,
-0.13543298840522766,
-0.10024698078632355,
0.526251494884491,
-0.82286137342453,
0.7497060298919678,
-0.07322055846452713,
-0.24429865181446075,
0.11283686012029648,
0.47886744141578674,
0.11756718903779984,
0.01226838305592537,
0.7353373765945435,
0.5764073133468628,
0.5919491052627563,
-0.051263611763715744,
0.5899819135665894,
-0.19331170618534088,
0.48565810918807983,
1.430881381034851,
-0.55903160572052,
0.5075886249542236,
0.6736854314804077,
-0.07346701622009277,
0.601230263710022,
0.3711162209510803,
0.1025586947798729,
0.42127710580825806,
0.39301803708076477,
0.1821337640285492,
-0.4016924798488617,
-0.14239723980426788,
-0.35857346653938293,
0.5019246339797974,
-0.024894773960113525,
-0.10743103921413422,
-0.2919313907623291,
-0.4527122676372528,
0.0770828053355217,
0.3835221827030182,
-0.018517354503273964,
0.7522523999214172,
-0.07667908072471619,
-0.9613441228866577,
0.8414320945739746,
-0.14448530972003937,
0.4918980300426483,
-0.618461012840271,
0.06186308711767197,
-0.2655683755874634,
0.3903268873691559,
-0.3903989791870117,
-0.8178955316543579,
0.18629305064678192,
-0.1801217794418335,
0.021502790972590446,
-0.26869040727615356,
0.5972787737846375,
-0.404094934463501,
-0.1903483271598816,
0.6079070568084717,
0.4467124342918396,
0.01228781696408987,
0.21888354420661926,
-0.9644438624382019,
-0.015355950221419334,
-0.003823743900284171,
-0.1594192236661911,
0.17984092235565186,
0.28957247734069824,
-0.03683057427406311,
0.5663453340530396,
0.5131552815437317,
-0.005124084185808897,
-0.04680180177092552,
0.029037170112133026,
0.9320278763771057,
-0.41571182012557983,
-0.4670707881450653,
-1.1195180416107178,
0.12400766462087631,
-0.0091127660125494,
-0.4250999689102173,
0.9005696177482605,
0.5532035231590271,
0.7843866944313049,
0.24192368984222412,
0.560013473033905,
0.20963244140148163,
0.43556955456733704,
-0.4183911383152008,
0.1964050829410553,
-0.7679983973503113,
0.19546812772750854,
-0.7225295901298523,
-0.7967522144317627,
-0.17777425050735474,
0.40083572268486023,
-0.7150253057479858,
0.00902476068586111,
0.6121963858604431,
0.8649532794952393,
-0.12481272220611572,
-0.07007711380720139,
0.2951262891292572,
0.43227824568748474,
0.2522599995136261,
0.6149269342422485,
0.9587514996528625,
-0.07582888752222061,
0.414117693901062,
-0.2869351804256439,
-0.24257512390613556,
-0.055271733552217484,
-1.059358835220337,
-0.7431289553642273,
-0.6503432989120483,
-0.2633037865161896,
-0.44806283712387085,
-0.019047876819968224,
1.168742299079895,
0.5553969740867615,
-0.6912009119987488,
-0.5335639715194702,
-0.38870716094970703,
0.3189675509929657,
-0.0920419991016388,
-0.16455143690109253,
0.3675987720489502,
-0.3246947228908539,
-0.6571482419967651,
0.45197635889053345,
0.3665647804737091,
0.35656389594078064,
-0.5048688650131226,
-0.30381807684898376,
-0.20358122885227203,
0.19497916102409363,
-0.052577339112758636,
0.5517864227294922,
-0.9278333783149719,
-0.28297069668769836,
-0.04414092376828194,
-0.19172555208206177,
0.36801156401634216,
0.8568344116210938,
-0.5478419065475464,
0.6229212880134583,
0.602260410785675,
0.45916926860809326,
0.5904940962791443,
0.23031330108642578,
0.5060812830924988,
-0.7619971632957458,
-0.0268989410251379,
0.16274265944957733,
0.27587446570396423,
0.4451126456260681,
-0.5945560932159424,
0.3033078908920288,
0.21217358112335205,
-0.6769997477531433,
-0.7709148526191711,
0.6351536512374878,
-0.6899375915527344,
-0.5307095646858215,
1.006767749786377,
-0.00545126898214221,
-0.23506629467010498,
-0.14816543459892273,
-0.23458951711654663,
0.11592952907085419,
-0.29200097918510437,
0.6287429928779602,
0.6531635522842407,
-0.6348212957382202,
0.007074633613228798,
0.0745343342423439,
0.6602688431739807,
0.8430385589599609,
-0.4488265812397003,
0.16398215293884277,
0.3743371367454529,
0.5218101143836975,
0.3354570269584656,
0.9300199747085571,
-0.011090896092355251,
-0.18544670939445496,
-0.3731377422809601,
0.07904943823814392,
-0.12481115758419037,
-0.2823971211910248,
-0.5249747633934021,
0.02922932431101799,
0.19510088860988617,
-0.07973536103963852
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08838v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08838v1
|
Research on Optimization of Natural Language Processing Model Based on Multimodal Deep Learning
| 2024-06-13T06:03:59 | 2024-06-13T06:03:59 |
Dan Sun, Yaxin Liang, Yining Yang, Yuhan Ma, Qishi Zhan, Erdi Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This project intends to study the image representation based on attention
mechanism and multimodal data. By adding multiple pattern layers to the
attribute model, the semantic and hidden layers of image content are
integrated. The word vector is quantified by the Word2Vec method and then
evaluated by a word embedding convolutional neural network. The published
experimental results of the two groups were tested. The experimental results
show that this method can convert discrete features into continuous characters,
thus reducing the complexity of feature preprocessing. Word2Vec and natural
language processing technology are integrated to achieve the goal of direct
evaluation of missing image features. The robustness of the image feature
evaluation model is improved by using the excellent feature analysis
characteristics of a convolutional neural network. This project intends to
improve the existing image feature identification methods and eliminate the
subjective influence in the evaluation process. The findings from the
simulation indicate that the novel approach has developed is viable,
effectively augmenting the features within the produced representations.
|
[
-0.779841423034668,
-0.9813904762268066,
0.3959204852581024,
0.2777508795261383,
-0.5307517051696777,
0.030712783336639404,
-0.3867786228656769,
-0.7383524775505066,
-0.12148165702819824,
0.41469186544418335,
-0.6541650295257568,
-0.3032112419605255,
-0.7015694379806519,
0.009431013837456703,
-0.09360246360301971,
0.5413601994514465,
-0.013173561543226242,
0.3566300868988037,
-0.2961433529853821,
-0.44423508644104004,
-0.796552836894989,
-0.2580048739910126,
-0.6647838354110718,
-0.34243008494377136,
0.16844478249549866,
0.15451301634311676,
0.6968397498130798,
0.6359564661979675,
0.7373071312904358,
0.40842947363853455,
-0.01971145160496235,
0.2772046625614166,
-0.341225266456604,
-0.018894681707024574,
0.01619013398885727,
-0.3158988356590271,
-0.18263199925422668,
0.1402527540922165,
0.6788127422332764,
0.394202321767807,
0.313716858625412,
-0.06567955762147903,
0.1863739937543869,
0.6448541283607483,
-0.6300515532493591,
0.3155675530433655,
-0.38884568214416504,
0.23754242062568665,
0.00043872519745491445,
-0.19662825763225555,
-0.19562868773937225,
-0.32781273126602173,
0.20119750499725342,
-0.3808954954147339,
0.32267823815345764,
0.03685123845934868,
0.7709072232246399,
0.18754903972148895,
-0.29612669348716736,
-0.3775372803211212,
-0.7359550595283508,
1.069221019744873,
-0.6805766224861145,
0.4681778848171234,
0.26564449071884155,
0.24326297640800476,
-0.02895241416990757,
-0.4410397708415985,
-0.7463964223861694,
-0.5316882133483887,
0.003910177852958441,
0.023664992302656174,
0.07797656953334808,
0.1440778374671936,
-0.005579657386988401,
0.5151993036270142,
-0.44260039925575256,
-0.02719705179333687,
-0.19965538382530212,
-0.2753240466117859,
0.5956135988235474,
0.05107372999191284,
0.2860521078109741,
-0.16460318863391876,
-0.5104674100875854,
-0.11959600448608398,
-0.09425181150436401,
0.22326534986495972,
0.21438759565353394,
0.12286242842674255,
0.001815970172174275,
0.6848325729370117,
-0.2899373173713684,
0.42146000266075134,
-0.2873237729072571,
-0.1504676789045334,
0.6305205821990967,
-0.5965940356254578,
-0.24123622477054596,
-0.11683616787195206,
0.7816575169563293,
0.38784822821617126,
0.2852918803691864,
-0.07025138288736343,
-0.3531787693500519,
0.4629938006401062,
0.2017306387424469,
-0.6967499852180481,
0.20107606053352356,
0.09719814360141754,
-0.6636577844619751,
-0.3623281717300415,
-0.16480842232704163,
-0.7075280547142029,
-0.12834149599075317,
-0.63050377368927,
0.4332870543003082,
-0.8945719003677368,
-0.27013513445854187,
0.04517941549420357,
-0.028107859194278717,
0.12060493230819702,
0.2024417221546173,
-0.6238560676574707,
0.3673648238182068,
0.6115619540214539,
0.852663516998291,
-0.0007793636177666485,
0.060962874442338943,
-0.28557461500167847,
-0.04513360932469368,
-0.19406302273273468,
0.6906553506851196,
-0.8231108784675598,
-0.1943647414445877,
0.011975135654211044,
0.124993234872818,
0.0604444295167923,
-0.27199649810791016,
0.9061961770057678,
-0.6145451068878174,
0.2291705310344696,
0.1306411176919937,
-0.5913970470428467,
-0.5465162396430969,
0.40223291516304016,
-0.8039304614067078,
0.9888532757759094,
0.004076526965945959,
-0.7348302602767944,
0.20637091994285583,
-0.8840891122817993,
-0.4702916443347931,
0.17820513248443604,
0.008055409416556358,
-0.3904670178890228,
0.12100586295127869,
0.4217240512371063,
0.49810078740119934,
-0.30974528193473816,
0.23937252163887024,
-0.23160462081432343,
-0.24683456122875214,
0.37465161085128784,
-0.33751317858695984,
0.3648345470428467,
0.39374619722366333,
-0.19511370360851288,
-0.024419143795967102,
-0.9048174023628235,
0.21139629185199738,
0.05707157403230667,
-0.6128147840499878,
-0.46504509449005127,
-0.06495846062898636,
0.3011035919189453,
0.2700378894805908,
0.26187849044799805,
-0.7130506038665771,
-0.009609870612621307,
-0.6346491575241089,
0.2967495024204254,
0.5222653150558472,
0.1275872141122818,
0.7409944534301758,
0.3323480188846588,
0.38633841276168823,
-0.009089982137084007,
0.3638288676738739,
-0.20409251749515533,
-0.550186038017273,
-0.8799970149993896,
-0.23117785155773163,
0.338138610124588,
0.5098757147789001,
-0.9308287501335144,
0.3683554530143738,
-0.08381165564060211,
-0.25057464838027954,
-0.7580355405807495,
0.22488908469676971,
0.6544449925422668,
0.270501971244812,
0.22786009311676025,
-0.5451980829238892,
-0.5760439038276672,
-1.2012890577316284,
-0.07562119513750076,
0.3496227264404297,
0.206959530711174,
0.170469731092453,
0.4385000765323639,
-0.44261646270751953,
0.7155283689498901,
-0.33582282066345215,
-0.4567491412162781,
-0.404659241437912,
0.4143217206001282,
0.20363007485866547,
0.5649037957191467,
0.47974857687950134,
-1.0025736093521118,
-0.1449308842420578,
0.11615676432847977,
-0.7112472057342529,
0.4132203161716461,
0.22642530500888824,
-0.08334583044052124,
0.27424928545951843,
0.22471167147159576,
-0.49739477038383484,
0.4104650914669037,
0.5243850946426392,
-0.01297830045223236,
0.21269574761390686,
-0.3564670979976654,
0.19911302626132965,
-0.8464263081550598,
-0.0756959617137909,
0.48737749457359314,
-0.1023804098367691,
-0.49631717801094055,
0.14893001317977905,
0.17474713921546936,
-0.34967103600502014,
-0.26296359300613403,
0.39297765493392944,
-0.7055593132972717,
0.20175541937351227,
-0.3857696056365967,
0.04699787124991417,
0.1418173909187317,
0.7059863805770874,
-0.04503479599952698,
0.4053908586502075,
0.731428861618042,
-0.6620679497718811,
0.7139652371406555,
-0.054657548666000366,
-0.4606938064098358,
0.3605891764163971,
-0.4508954584598541,
0.3760817050933838,
-0.49497076869010925,
-0.27323099970817566,
-1.2094162702560425,
-0.04243139550089836,
0.2854655683040619,
-0.4870001971721649,
0.5391736626625061,
0.13228020071983337,
-0.4506206810474396,
-0.4451483190059662,
-0.4669325053691864,
0.24321377277374268,
0.22295716404914856,
-0.006909907329827547,
0.4999091923236847,
0.4674679934978485,
-0.03804546222090721,
-0.2719654142856598,
-0.8532644510269165,
0.11916761845350266,
0.08766482025384903,
-0.8625379204750061,
0.4751659333705902,
0.08261894434690475,
0.14990970492362976,
0.16050812602043152,
0.35134202241897583,
-0.035923946648836136,
-0.16968069970607758,
0.11140775680541992,
0.17377033829689026,
-0.28076863288879395,
0.34199243783950806,
-0.24040380120277405,
-0.24298694729804993,
-0.18802018463611603,
-0.03731846809387207,
0.5659957528114319,
-0.17596442997455597,
-0.03277166560292244,
-0.6616530418395996,
0.6147124767303467,
0.3754333555698395,
-0.6441369652748108,
0.5854759812355042,
0.981831431388855,
-0.5834563374519348,
0.0402376689016819,
-0.6356573700904846,
-0.0739961713552475,
-0.4575052857398987,
0.7465627789497375,
-0.2546044588088989,
-0.8077213168144226,
0.213197261095047,
-0.24621731042861938,
-0.3606884777545929,
0.2912066876888275,
0.5139951705932617,
-0.021946297958493233,
1.2127031087875366,
0.908060610294342,
-0.013161882758140564,
0.47267478704452515,
-0.43918466567993164,
0.41943731904029846,
-0.9933432936668396,
-0.5849499702453613,
-0.3313275873661041,
-0.547325074672699,
-0.5920462608337402,
-0.6739231944084167,
0.25345325469970703,
-0.021565664559602737,
0.2174915075302124,
0.36104118824005127,
-0.714368999004364,
0.20828096568584442,
0.6003340482711792,
0.31619229912757874,
-0.02459261566400528,
0.1594405621290207,
-0.47399258613586426,
-0.2972937524318695,
-0.1905696988105774,
-0.4743029773235321,
0.7963882088661194,
0.6863435506820679,
0.7747978568077087,
-0.0543379932641983,
0.21334898471832275,
0.3225192725658417,
-0.057902880012989044,
-1.0297071933746338,
0.5607088208198547,
-0.18924970924854279,
-0.3776717185974121,
-0.4338407516479492,
-0.1206175833940506,
-0.6665216088294983,
0.25066712498664856,
-0.4412393867969513,
-0.6416245698928833,
0.2690964341163635,
-0.18377678096294403,
-0.051236461848020554,
-0.10672356188297272,
-0.946902334690094,
0.8225142955780029,
-0.3748382329940796,
-0.3659374415874481,
-0.48128625750541687,
-0.5867106318473816,
0.2807706594467163,
0.23877614736557007,
0.24803084135055542,
-0.19407306611537933,
0.059209879487752914,
0.5513308644294739,
-0.09314356744289398,
0.5231629610061646,
-0.20187562704086304,
0.12708190083503723,
0.18463775515556335,
-0.10425186157226562,
0.47112134099006653,
0.07856208831071854,
-0.22764833271503448,
-0.06609629839658737,
-0.43780434131622314,
-0.1331416517496109,
-0.6761344075202942,
0.6947768926620483,
-0.6971293091773987,
-0.31157058477401733,
-0.14119845628738403,
-0.4329436421394348,
-0.3056184947490692,
0.10581744462251663,
0.07431226968765259,
0.5057118535041809,
-0.3455919027328491,
0.2950603663921356,
0.6418127417564392,
-0.23858261108398438,
0.8692992925643921,
0.06525783240795135,
0.09679092466831207,
-0.5989071130752563,
0.9085646867752075,
0.06285881251096725,
-0.06315254420042038,
0.5486096143722534,
0.2228584736585617,
-0.36607837677001953,
-0.6458635330200195,
-0.26956337690353394,
0.13463351130485535,
-0.6991158127784729,
-0.1758265495300293,
-0.8577659130096436,
-0.39455774426460266,
-0.5598658919334412,
0.3047932982444763,
-0.3978710174560547,
-0.07618099451065063,
-0.40067705512046814,
0.03878117725253105,
0.19629156589508057,
0.5065773725509644,
0.35612860321998596,
0.26851367950439453,
-0.6978980302810669,
0.45238831639289856,
0.3171374499797821,
0.3892432451248169,
0.16964124143123627,
-0.23998917639255524,
-0.45941177010536194,
-0.018915165215730667,
-0.6597872376441956,
-0.6302819848060608,
0.562763512134552,
0.41652488708496094,
0.7409070730209351,
0.5967925190925598,
-0.4600529968738556,
0.597261905670166,
-0.38966962695121765,
0.5126838684082031,
0.36114221811294556,
-0.8372557759284973,
0.799363911151886,
-0.047580525279045105,
0.35135141015052795,
0.27513161301612854,
0.13265939056873322,
-0.38705235719680786,
-0.3671405017375946,
-0.31785812973976135,
-0.6959676146507263,
0.6924386620521545,
0.5276983380317688,
0.3854128122329712,
0.23245196044445038,
0.21284165978431702,
-0.0011059291427955031,
0.2370203286409378,
-0.726887047290802,
-0.12733767926692963,
-0.25732922554016113,
-0.18556243181228638,
0.15718629956245422,
-0.6335711479187012,
0.2164841890335083,
-0.5327392220497131,
0.45049819350242615,
-0.11483781784772873,
0.5025042295455933,
0.13030500710010529,
-0.10218650102615356,
0.159963920712471,
0.2744613289833069,
0.7017766237258911,
0.398670494556427,
-0.13143421709537506,
0.093572698533535,
0.016983505338430405,
-0.5473026037216187,
0.02795426920056343,
0.026044972240924835,
0.14855879545211792,
0.20498333871364594,
0.5218655467033386,
1.143765926361084,
0.08919579535722733,
-0.34591180086135864,
0.6315131783485413,
-0.12824015319347382,
-0.12065005302429199,
-0.3962559700012207,
0.08575023710727692,
0.09844014793634415,
0.3401252031326294,
0.5008427500724792,
0.5317865014076233,
0.5757405757904053,
-0.5867539644241333,
0.16066202521324158,
0.6166497468948364,
-0.6405846476554871,
-0.23748795688152313,
0.3199008107185364,
0.2826572060585022,
-0.21755145490169525,
0.5538190007209778,
-0.27313411235809326,
-0.5585707426071167,
0.6938816905021667,
0.35019347071647644,
0.8357241749763489,
-0.2824227213859558,
0.26312634348869324,
0.4793662130832672,
0.557115912437439,
0.09937576949596405,
0.4156292676925659,
0.15392178297042847,
-0.8238331079483032,
-0.45757678151130676,
-0.7519668936729431,
0.14931418001651764,
0.10912133008241653,
-0.2457074522972107,
0.4577457010746002,
-0.5046613812446594,
-0.34600740671157837,
0.08800726383924484,
0.036980852484703064,
-0.9970179796218872,
0.545821487903595,
0.47044888138771057,
0.5831655263900757,
-0.6494567394256592,
1.0773506164550781,
0.6256981492042542,
-0.32936325669288635,
-0.7054855823516846,
-0.3337298035621643,
-0.1908557415008545,
-0.8287358283996582,
0.8442409634590149,
0.47383344173431396,
-0.10078559815883636,
-0.2628490626811981,
-0.6554542779922485,
-0.866473913192749,
0.9074597358703613,
0.38443630933761597,
-0.5289005041122437,
0.18337932229042053,
0.15740622580051422,
0.6631340384483337,
-0.6702686548233032,
0.24686777591705322,
0.3326221704483032,
0.6594002842903137,
0.38328659534454346,
-0.6225863695144653,
0.05392887070775032,
-0.5380926728248596,
0.7467833161354065,
0.03300190344452858,
-0.5157895684242249,
0.9270132184028625,
-0.13236483931541443,
-0.37289804220199585,
-0.021745745092630386,
0.6449450254440308,
-0.16812260448932648,
0.019907847046852112,
0.3905913233757019,
0.8335416913032532,
0.41986310482025146,
-0.048949841409921646,
1.058142066001892,
0.16989760100841522,
0.5374351739883423,
0.7121743559837341,
-0.08748564124107361,
0.5683282613754272,
0.6279104351997375,
-0.054417870938777924,
0.33156460523605347,
0.5599063038825989,
-0.31108853220939636,
1.0601041316986084,
0.18417856097221375,
-0.31288081407546997,
-0.18354642391204834,
-0.38768836855888367,
-0.2537522315979004,
0.6695531606674194,
0.32818183302879333,
-0.6748937964439392,
-0.19383075833320618,
0.5332723259925842,
-0.2844211161136627,
-0.00541631830856204,
-0.28372830152511597,
0.828322172164917,
0.08388375490903854,
-0.4867136776447296,
0.45616236329078674,
0.45298492908477783,
0.8214760422706604,
-0.49541598558425903,
-0.2722114026546478,
-0.12672391533851624,
0.3445326089859009,
-0.12028473615646362,
-0.7317048907279968,
0.1907370388507843,
-0.3401959240436554,
-0.2013355791568756,
-0.12177429348230362,
0.9884968996047974,
-0.3887465298175812,
-0.9827662706375122,
0.47723254561424255,
-0.05019352585077286,
-0.11498919129371643,
-0.2328062802553177,
-0.7268269658088684,
0.1841263324022293,
-0.06592368334531784,
-0.353181391954422,
0.0004823464551009238,
0.7379340529441833,
-0.07348032295703888,
0.604145348072052,
0.5749734044075012,
0.08947300910949707,
0.028953196480870247,
0.4383563697338104,
0.9842544198036194,
-0.6040153503417969,
-0.4468556344509125,
-1.0440858602523804,
0.5625986456871033,
-0.3371894359588623,
-0.27879008650779724,
0.45110684633255005,
0.4326518774032593,
0.6249390244483948,
-0.3728143870830536,
0.7389059066772461,
0.028760626912117004,
0.19626127183437347,
-0.6855114698410034,
0.6182408928871155,
-0.44974517822265625,
-0.18465647101402283,
-0.4918210208415985,
-1.0332107543945312,
-0.38706377148628235,
0.5551938414573669,
0.04934622347354889,
0.13736166059970856,
0.9831227660179138,
0.8555884957313538,
-0.03961188346147537,
0.13189929723739624,
0.4704650640487671,
-0.1841249018907547,
0.17521131038665771,
0.6072905659675598,
0.7233713865280151,
-0.6547991037368774,
0.3127891421318054,
-0.5031986832618713,
-0.2686353325843811,
-0.23466600477695465,
-0.9291408658027649,
-0.8190696835517883,
-0.7188069820404053,
-0.3449336886405945,
0.07926202565431595,
-0.28783494234085083,
0.6173140406608582,
0.7481188178062439,
-0.8390152454376221,
0.04827938228845596,
-0.00462579308077693,
-0.04088583216071129,
-0.23622539639472961,
-0.3031845986843109,
0.35231056809425354,
-0.43505510687828064,
-0.8273605108261108,
0.08758371323347092,
0.6913659572601318,
-0.04226860776543617,
-0.5700363516807556,
-0.0952608734369278,
-0.4940895438194275,
-0.2805822491645813,
0.7264353036880493,
-0.41272443532943726,
-0.8050535321235657,
-0.3315092921257019,
0.03971685841679573,
-0.20626942813396454,
0.18238919973373413,
0.8817386627197266,
-0.5971258282661438,
0.8249290585517883,
0.5310776829719543,
0.698442816734314,
0.4190909266471863,
-0.1850302368402481,
0.49511998891830444,
-0.8800861835479736,
0.6442686319351196,
0.36548343300819397,
0.33961838483810425,
0.5280700922012329,
-0.5526588559150696,
0.3297152817249298,
0.21513409912586212,
-0.19797298312187195,
-0.25447219610214233,
-0.02010045386850834,
-1.0650556087493896,
-0.1803627461194992,
0.9494981169700623,
0.08378085494041443,
-0.39395231008529663,
-0.06154978275299072,
-0.4734516441822052,
0.4467378556728363,
-0.4645403325557709,
0.5561590194702148,
0.8754377365112305,
-0.1194269135594368,
-0.8243654370307922,
-0.694316029548645,
0.27772414684295654,
0.19990968704223633,
-0.521561861038208,
-0.48902955651283264,
0.3411162197589874,
0.038979627192020416,
0.44434961676597595,
0.3558328151702881,
-0.36205169558525085,
0.03519652783870697,
-0.2999807894229889,
0.4203108251094818,
-0.11724340170621872,
-0.06448567658662796,
-0.16595706343650818,
0.28910622000694275,
0.02056923694908619,
-0.7703989744186401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08824v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08824v1
|
LLM-Driven Robots Risk Enacting Discrimination, Violence, and Unlawful Actions
| 2024-06-13T05:31:49 | 2024-06-13T05:31:49 |
Rumaisa Azeem, Andrew Hundt, Masoumeh Mansouri, Martim Brandão
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
Members of the Human-Robot Interaction (HRI) and Artificial Intelligence (AI)
communities have proposed Large Language Models (LLMs) as a promising resource
for robotics tasks such as natural language interactions, doing household and
workplace tasks, approximating `common sense reasoning', and modeling humans.
However, recent research has raised concerns about the potential for LLMs to
produce discriminatory outcomes and unsafe behaviors in real-world robot
experiments and applications. To address these concerns, we conduct an
HRI-based evaluation of discrimination and safety criteria on several
highly-rated LLMs. Our evaluation reveals that LLMs currently lack robustness
when encountering people across a diverse range of protected identity
characteristics (e.g., race, gender, disability status, nationality, religion,
and their intersections), producing biased outputs consistent with directly
discriminatory outcomes -- e.g. `gypsy' and `mute' people are labeled
untrustworthy, but not `european' or `able-bodied' people. Furthermore, we test
models in settings with unconstrained natural language (open vocabulary)
inputs, and find they fail to act safely, generating responses that accept
dangerous, violent, or unlawful instructions -- such as incident-causing
misstatements, taking people's mobility aids, and sexual predation. Our results
underscore the urgent need for systematic, routine, and comprehensive risk
assessments and assurances to improve outcomes and ensure LLMs only operate on
robots when it is safe, effective, and just to do so. Data and code will be
made available.
|
[
-0.07061481475830078,
-0.7102915048599243,
0.4729141891002655,
0.07967732846736908,
0.0887267217040062,
0.172041118144989,
0.023103024810552597,
-0.6817720532417297,
-0.060820166021585464,
0.5285291075706482,
-0.38508957624435425,
-0.3977012634277344,
-0.7253773212432861,
0.1811380833387375,
-0.4767804443836212,
0.7462338805198669,
-0.03615834191441536,
-0.08047069609165192,
-0.1378227323293686,
-0.03232640400528908,
-0.453771710395813,
-0.8621668815612793,
-0.05781828612089157,
-0.2122858464717865,
0.6765882968902588,
-0.062268469482660294,
1.043526530265808,
0.646199643611908,
0.7676094770431519,
0.331952303647995,
-0.2985623776912689,
0.08960528671741486,
-0.2450403869152069,
0.058623913675546646,
-0.33002740144729614,
-0.456631064414978,
-0.5804334878921509,
0.16272585093975067,
0.46922197937965393,
0.8468722701072693,
-0.1254318654537201,
0.02075055055320263,
0.1868745982646942,
0.5877706408500671,
-0.7313070893287659,
-0.18010874092578888,
-0.5245590209960938,
0.270733118057251,
-0.23351043462753296,
-0.01790570467710495,
-0.3964637815952301,
-0.43073034286499023,
-0.125833660364151,
-0.24868234992027283,
-0.2996310889720917,
0.11901143938302994,
0.7543173432350159,
0.45209041237831116,
-0.4249971807003021,
-0.4329908788204193,
-1.0120041370391846,
0.802365243434906,
-0.6477053165435791,
0.3518582284450531,
0.5752537846565247,
0.08335688710212708,
-0.6713583469390869,
-0.16834020614624023,
-0.6754472851753235,
-0.583368182182312,
0.0775313526391983,
0.19113364815711975,
-0.25375986099243164,
0.3935266435146332,
0.3800613284111023,
-0.15226396918296814,
-0.5621781349182129,
0.6426443457603455,
-0.42639392614364624,
-0.31954866647720337,
0.8462333083152771,
0.4605613648891449,
0.47059202194213867,
-0.17966005206108093,
-0.42801815271377563,
-0.24485012888908386,
-0.7260202169418335,
0.10516133159399033,
0.8799147009849548,
0.537566602230072,
-0.2750398516654968,
0.7800832390785217,
-0.04584058001637459,
0.4472787380218506,
-0.32428717613220215,
-0.20896494388580322,
0.34212857484817505,
-0.3475792407989502,
0.038671232759952545,
-0.2962131202220917,
0.900482177734375,
0.6543479561805725,
0.5707840323448181,
-0.3254680633544922,
-0.25551754236221313,
0.4718225300312042,
0.41501447558403015,
-0.4423847198486328,
0.14659033715724945,
0.5588815808296204,
-0.3944869637489319,
-0.34008392691612244,
0.21235255897045135,
-0.8315125703811646,
-0.6230159997940063,
-0.008872954174876213,
0.3697102665901184,
-0.03336571156978607,
-0.2382459044456482,
0.22857174277305603,
0.07486820220947266,
0.2222224920988083,
0.07731382548809052,
-0.48151737451553345,
0.18448573350906372,
0.5187260508537292,
0.5451935529708862,
-0.45023977756500244,
-0.38524526357650757,
-0.4526446759700775,
0.16563065350055695,
-0.36331692337989807,
0.3900923430919647,
-0.39856845140457153,
-0.38629281520843506,
0.33236610889434814,
0.10547439754009247,
-0.06057274714112282,
-0.7899918556213379,
0.6362783908843994,
-0.38577133417129517,
-0.10160388052463531,
0.14631293714046478,
-0.16644519567489624,
-0.15000613033771515,
0.1259213387966156,
-0.6299571394920349,
0.6912091970443726,
0.09069789201021194,
-0.5640879273414612,
0.3495374023914337,
-0.676325261592865,
-0.6540380716323853,
-0.0787077397108078,
0.007133005652576685,
-0.4257967472076416,
-0.3448117971420288,
-0.21683570742607117,
0.47183936834335327,
0.044156454503536224,
0.39233553409576416,
-0.5418894290924072,
-0.2599414885044098,
0.5281127095222473,
-0.6088953018188477,
0.8684636950492859,
0.10110532492399216,
-0.20976515114307404,
0.5694773197174072,
-0.5581454634666443,
-0.26119863986968994,
0.19010356068611145,
-0.5566483736038208,
-0.12253502011299133,
0.20482473075389862,
-0.05312439054250717,
0.399000346660614,
0.30384698510169983,
-0.6682091355323792,
-0.4054964780807495,
-0.3504379391670227,
0.29595282673835754,
0.9736623167991638,
-0.39778414368629456,
0.3886140286922455,
-0.5509047508239746,
0.7699745297431946,
-0.13041192293167114,
0.4335593283176422,
0.29998818039894104,
-0.424122154712677,
-0.42593488097190857,
-0.10773150622844696,
0.11048486828804016,
0.9356439709663391,
-0.5460432171821594,
0.8392149806022644,
0.035304583609104156,
-0.3677470088005066,
-0.2831665575504303,
0.23485539853572845,
0.4804703891277313,
0.27563539147377014,
0.043159764260053635,
-0.30005571246147156,
-0.53861004114151,
-0.7881582975387573,
-0.200370654463768,
-0.508921205997467,
-0.22735103964805603,
0.33617475628852844,
0.6118274331092834,
-0.6077874302864075,
0.7741588354110718,
0.11714017391204834,
-0.11639367789030075,
-0.21349601447582245,
-0.07705660909414291,
-0.0687389075756073,
0.3034011125564575,
0.40580663084983826,
-0.7442833781242371,
0.08877338469028473,
-0.12484023720026016,
-0.9416329264640808,
-0.007330706808716059,
-0.032764263451099396,
-0.1866377890110016,
0.2565337121486664,
0.30446740984916687,
-0.770973801612854,
0.5844724178314209,
0.5401434302330017,
-0.28874096274375916,
0.48973098397254944,
-0.012293684296309948,
-0.10814904421567917,
-0.5612757205963135,
0.03951364383101463,
0.08561311662197113,
-0.10177121311426163,
-0.629175066947937,
0.21634329855442047,
-0.26429298520088196,
0.08043923228979111,
-0.7299296259880066,
0.38254350423812866,
0.031369514763355255,
-0.10029660165309906,
-0.39163312315940857,
0.3688814640045166,
-0.38038480281829834,
0.22445876896381378,
-0.05699131637811661,
0.6912562847137451,
0.30661290884017944,
-0.8480428457260132,
0.22752897441387177,
0.18630555272102356,
-0.43594714999198914,
0.07842651009559631,
-0.6626074314117432,
0.2536819577217102,
-0.04528326913714409,
0.0741296261548996,
-0.46538540720939636,
-0.4823191165924072,
0.5652799010276794,
-0.36347678303718567,
-0.2656985819339752,
0.13339561223983765,
-0.6517817974090576,
-0.6440765261650085,
-0.2892705202102661,
0.3428850769996643,
0.5741919279098511,
-0.2178441733121872,
0.6975471377372742,
0.8589548468589783,
-0.19657664000988007,
-0.6487237215042114,
-0.5495705008506775,
0.1458364874124527,
-0.46531444787979126,
-0.5566997528076172,
-0.008561105467379093,
-0.14443686604499817,
-0.6140844821929932,
-0.3268642723560333,
0.05296057090163231,
-0.1146811842918396,
0.6303556561470032,
0.5042153596878052,
0.42259037494659424,
0.4085453748703003,
-0.1995910406112671,
-0.21073384582996368,
-0.007115230429917574,
0.48511308431625366,
0.5192829966545105,
0.64644455909729,
0.05066550523042679,
-0.47998175024986267,
-0.533720850944519,
0.33796459436416626,
0.5694913268089294,
-0.04804014042019844,
0.42741021513938904,
0.5049116015434265,
-0.4311826229095459,
0.04235272854566574,
-0.08083046227693558,
-0.29882583022117615,
-0.5204148292541504,
0.6503685712814331,
0.1320396512746811,
-1.0684908628463745,
0.46210819482803345,
-0.12534044682979584,
0.20987407863140106,
0.1378049999475479,
0.7297276854515076,
-0.36922577023506165,
0.9597906470298767,
0.6807501316070557,
-0.13740918040275574,
0.4613969922065735,
0.5050218105316162,
0.3001997470855713,
-0.5063721537590027,
-0.4037376344203949,
-0.6269810199737549,
-0.18878880143165588,
-0.8720945715904236,
-0.5053841471672058,
0.31318891048431396,
-0.1757446527481079,
-0.44163140654563904,
0.44016969203948975,
-0.3889833688735962,
0.24500775337219238,
0.5004866123199463,
0.1322070062160492,
0.10102065652608871,
-0.1243341937661171,
0.07935626804828644,
0.06148524954915047,
-0.546683132648468,
-1.0907613039016724,
1.0501242876052856,
0.6190211176872253,
0.9907217621803284,
0.2548993229866028,
0.45754703879356384,
0.6783410906791687,
0.2083011269569397,
-0.6824895739555359,
0.7551594972610474,
-0.0028172137681394815,
-0.5696766376495361,
-0.28625917434692383,
-0.51459801197052,
-1.2526453733444214,
0.06613344699144363,
-0.3150000274181366,
-0.8178352117538452,
0.006732271518558264,
0.006279573775827885,
-0.4232218265533447,
0.3861375153064728,
-0.420282244682312,
0.41488903760910034,
-0.502627968788147,
-0.18557026982307434,
-0.21619166433811188,
-0.7700034976005554,
0.429293692111969,
-0.15545783936977386,
0.4742474853992462,
-0.4810859262943268,
0.034348275512456894,
0.8292773962020874,
-0.10416720807552338,
1.198439121246338,
-0.10951818525791168,
-0.37711599469184875,
0.4060353636741638,
0.24563446640968323,
0.47392210364341736,
-0.34936147928237915,
-0.20543566346168518,
0.44850289821624756,
-0.2653561234474182,
-0.23223166167736053,
-0.32723551988601685,
0.13538193702697754,
-0.8190878629684448,
-0.8065126538276672,
-0.3388163149356842,
-0.7899584174156189,
-0.13670839369297028,
-0.0077133579179644585,
-0.2334078848361969,
-0.08506951481103897,
-0.0710979551076889,
-0.04223198443651199,
0.5061293244361877,
-0.5388128161430359,
0.2778390049934387,
0.433349609375,
-0.2569124102592468,
-0.112945057451725,
0.8152062296867371,
-0.19176211953163147,
0.41111403703689575,
0.06488476693630219,
0.09484044462442398,
-0.10817892849445343,
-0.5745266079902649,
-0.24224860966205597,
-0.12265322357416153,
-0.45161232352256775,
-0.1275315284729004,
-0.38379934430122375,
-0.3432424068450928,
-0.10419487208127975,
-0.02903183363378048,
-0.2808404862880707,
-0.1808125078678131,
-0.07551431655883789,
-0.14086759090423584,
0.1423923373222351,
0.8253483772277832,
-0.2215009331703186,
0.2577000856399536,
-0.6828328371047974,
0.37767457962036133,
0.23830720782279968,
0.16568906605243683,
-0.24900443851947784,
-0.6452596187591553,
-0.039844121783971786,
0.07559876143932343,
-0.276401162147522,
-0.551270604133606,
0.2661137282848358,
-0.23460185527801514,
0.6001566052436829,
0.2764352262020111,
0.45415741205215454,
0.17704488337039948,
-0.534891664981842,
0.47000089287757874,
0.16826991736888885,
-0.5909772515296936,
0.6283549070358276,
-0.4992036819458008,
-0.28905555605888367,
0.16868434846401215,
0.367499977350235,
-0.26431548595428467,
-0.600686252117157,
-0.19335001707077026,
-0.9791073799133301,
0.42782145738601685,
0.36326175928115845,
0.4392634630203247,
-0.17722751200199127,
0.1926286369562149,
0.00527745159342885,
0.08180567622184753,
-1.1169875860214233,
-0.0010289234342053533,
0.19594185054302216,
-0.21646514534950256,
0.5429383516311646,
-0.2980092167854309,
-0.454318106174469,
0.12411106377840042,
0.30849480628967285,
0.10884223878383636,
0.23290568590164185,
-0.11639641225337982,
-0.07618377357721329,
-0.26804229617118835,
0.3244645893573761,
0.6492833495140076,
0.4689534306526184,
-0.33215299248695374,
0.03959564119577408,
0.1460907757282257,
-0.4580690860748291,
0.29106295108795166,
-0.048689525574445724,
-0.1572757363319397,
-0.45428940653800964,
0.33093389868736267,
0.24100938439369202,
-0.25056692957878113,
-1.3084888458251953,
0.49959152936935425,
0.13766922056674957,
-0.04141399636864662,
-0.3375099301338196,
0.44089746475219727,
-0.3252381384372711,
0.307255357503891,
0.019162772223353386,
0.31445807218551636,
0.02646312490105629,
-0.5758355259895325,
0.19158345460891724,
0.5686445832252502,
-0.4247581958770752,
-0.24825003743171692,
0.5947940945625305,
0.41904160380363464,
-0.6838540434837341,
0.48537588119506836,
-0.2671307623386383,
-0.4412446916103363,
0.70710688829422,
0.29358959197998047,
0.7440748810768127,
-0.11906945705413818,
0.09993493556976318,
0.2372879683971405,
0.8852142095565796,
0.048310261219739914,
0.4095165729522705,
0.37323006987571716,
-1.1217657327651978,
-0.29082155227661133,
-0.49445977807044983,
-0.6338560581207275,
-0.14643751084804535,
-0.6760048866271973,
-0.1420387178659439,
-0.8147740364074707,
-0.5088884234428406,
-0.4494665265083313,
-0.3966241180896759,
-0.42681360244750977,
-0.020561402663588524,
0.36849111318588257,
0.5071567893028259,
-0.8484923243522644,
0.5196573138237,
0.5477977991104126,
-0.25555774569511414,
-0.3400920033454895,
0.13915491104125977,
0.029170585796236992,
-0.8402500152587891,
0.5417792797088623,
0.24191516637802124,
-0.5112534761428833,
-0.7847796678543091,
-0.7135287523269653,
-0.652833878993988,
0.8670568466186523,
0.5862244367599487,
-0.6806241869926453,
0.008131965063512325,
0.5741326808929443,
0.3530196249485016,
-0.1289551705121994,
-0.04999725520610809,
0.4718560576438904,
0.44194480776786804,
-0.4116380512714386,
-1.118898630142212,
0.11413352191448212,
-0.16109243035316467,
0.009046104736626148,
-0.08104158937931061,
-0.8143289685249329,
0.689001739025116,
-0.3459610641002655,
-0.3729512095451355,
0.29735252261161804,
0.6255863308906555,
0.6369757056236267,
0.3647609055042267,
0.5146060585975647,
0.3691721260547638,
0.9832831025123596,
-0.03887006640434265,
1.1567049026489258,
-0.1682380586862564,
-0.1477581411600113,
0.9864017367362976,
-0.7642908096313477,
0.9293136596679688,
0.22082391381263733,
-0.4245448708534241,
0.4545859694480896,
0.41848453879356384,
-0.11279818415641785,
0.3272288739681244,
0.4331706166267395,
-0.2806548476219177,
-0.4292788505554199,
-0.5307825803756714,
0.09749935567378998,
0.6685182452201843,
0.3187372088432312,
-0.22713568806648254,
0.10788987576961517,
0.06855805963277817,
0.003413531929254532,
0.4081459045410156,
-0.19442714750766754,
0.40066564083099365,
0.08940460532903671,
-0.26181069016456604,
0.03868446871638298,
0.1437479555606842,
0.9852643609046936,
-0.32607942819595337,
-0.025783129036426544,
0.006206979975104332,
0.0736544206738472,
-0.12982724606990814,
-0.996066153049469,
0.34467291831970215,
0.3055460751056671,
-0.11582209914922714,
-0.14868801832199097,
0.7047914862632751,
0.14621153473854065,
-0.38660064339637756,
0.7089090347290039,
0.6088662147521973,
0.3402945101261139,
0.3185917139053345,
-0.677064061164856,
0.25701698660850525,
-0.19911685585975647,
-0.02188444510102272,
0.4740746319293976,
0.04261181503534317,
-0.1544715315103531,
1.2102198600769043,
0.5490536093711853,
-0.046686649322509766,
0.17308524250984192,
0.14237992465496063,
0.7346408367156982,
-0.7306541800498962,
-0.12747465074062347,
-0.8781512379646301,
0.4106426239013672,
0.20873256027698517,
-0.33591920137405396,
0.49470898509025574,
0.2260114699602127,
0.7804089784622192,
0.33771106600761414,
0.7446349859237671,
0.03461461514234543,
0.3097703754901886,
-0.5207412242889404,
0.7315301299095154,
-0.18116405606269836,
0.14756014943122864,
-0.2954816222190857,
-0.5399796962738037,
-0.3782356381416321,
0.6897709369659424,
-0.16634321212768555,
0.3414458632469177,
0.13489511609077454,
0.9585365653038025,
0.44579359889030457,
-0.32042601704597473,
0.6026709079742432,
0.11001451313495636,
0.25735267996788025,
0.4548220634460449,
1.2364377975463867,
-0.27599388360977173,
0.7259854078292847,
-0.08583034574985504,
-0.06588174402713776,
0.015152999199926853,
-0.7625627517700195,
-1.0285968780517578,
-0.11593291163444519,
-0.4185372292995453,
-0.4335431456565857,
0.26332637667655945,
1.0222686529159546,
0.6800329685211182,
-0.6626096963882446,
-0.4304424822330475,
0.10585897415876389,
0.30837520956993103,
0.09054993838071823,
-0.21086205542087555,
0.0027565928176045418,
-0.018041692674160004,
-0.7639310359954834,
0.5207054018974304,
0.3191106915473938,
0.0780612975358963,
-0.2866707444190979,
-0.3890143930912018,
0.07013273984193802,
0.16325148940086365,
0.6819542050361633,
0.37470924854278564,
-0.91497802734375,
-0.4072756767272949,
-0.2569516599178314,
-0.22431345283985138,
-0.028182020410895348,
0.20523419976234436,
-0.5197418928146362,
0.07451295107603073,
0.04793938994407654,
0.6517093777656555,
-0.4540797472000122,
-0.11887206137180328,
0.6585133075714111,
-0.3333091735839844,
0.22737906873226166,
0.532279372215271,
0.39633437991142273,
0.2530226409435272,
-0.2565859258174896,
0.5553492307662964,
0.06300781667232513,
-0.6101064085960388,
-0.9599285125732422,
0.49599364399909973,
-0.9061632752418518,
-0.06784401088953018,
1.2605259418487549,
-0.0884193405508995,
-0.2936876118183136,
-0.2831018567085266,
0.10946261137723923,
0.2680131196975708,
-0.3710494637489319,
1.0162544250488281,
0.3636173903942108,
-0.13724014163017273,
0.02608676254749298,
-0.9268126487731934,
0.23367218673229218,
0.36467719078063965,
-0.8148899078369141,
0.2888701856136322,
0.3964761793613434,
0.03556223213672638,
0.08775485306978226,
0.09764297306537628,
-0.21178889274597168,
0.3485243618488312,
-0.09547828882932663,
0.36233603954315186,
0.21311834454536438,
-0.44905513525009155,
-0.28116244077682495,
0.06726782768964767,
0.27761217951774597,
-0.1319386512041092
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08820v1
|
DisfluencySpeech -- Single-Speaker Conversational Speech Dataset with Paralanguage
| 2024-06-13T05:23:22 | 2024-06-13T05:23:22 |
Kyra Wang, Dorien Herremans
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
Laughing, sighing, stuttering, and other forms of paralanguage do not
contribute any direct lexical meaning to speech, but they provide crucial
propositional context that aids semantic and pragmatic processes such as irony.
It is thus important for artificial social agents to both understand and be
able to generate speech with semantically-important paralanguage. Most speech
datasets do not include transcribed non-lexical speech sounds and disfluencies,
while those that do are typically multi-speaker datasets where each speaker
provides relatively little audio. This makes it challenging to train
conversational Text-to-Speech (TTS) synthesis models that include such
paralinguistic components.
We thus present DisfluencySpeech, a studio-quality labeled English speech
dataset with paralanguage. A single speaker recreates nearly 10 hours of
expressive utterances from the Switchboard-1 Telephone Speech Corpus
(Switchboard), simulating realistic informal conversations. To aid the
development of a TTS model that is able to predictively synthesise paralanguage
from text without such components, we provide three different transcripts at
different levels of information removal (removal of non-speech events, removal
of non-sentence elements, and removal of false starts), as well as benchmark
TTS models trained on each of these levels.
|
[
-0.35030803084373474,
-0.8379437923431396,
0.1769971251487732,
0.4429156482219696,
-0.3334082365036011,
0.15482716262340546,
0.04888768494129181,
-0.22884152829647064,
0.4433915615081787,
0.368852436542511,
-0.5839396715164185,
-0.46389082074165344,
-0.3728981912136078,
0.2287067174911499,
-0.6927241683006287,
0.9666997194290161,
0.44886359572410583,
-0.046534374356269836,
-0.1062694564461708,
-0.07588665932416916,
-0.350157767534256,
-0.34636422991752625,
-0.624936044216156,
-0.29098695516586304,
0.20714624226093292,
0.5224027633666992,
0.7655977010726929,
0.17014315724372864,
-0.0040238830260932446,
0.3708418011665344,
-0.11368698626756668,
-0.05808040127158165,
-0.6318935751914978,
0.0571795292198658,
-0.15909461677074432,
-0.05595358833670616,
-0.3369029760360718,
-0.15173250436782837,
0.5644393563270569,
0.9058162569999695,
-0.3367844521999359,
-0.15235655009746552,
0.2060546725988388,
0.4082562327384949,
-0.2507598400115967,
0.26193010807037354,
-0.7117483615875244,
0.04251963645219803,
-0.23126836121082306,
-0.08184606581926346,
-0.5548297762870789,
-0.2602856457233429,
0.2040191888809204,
-0.40672945976257324,
0.14657734334468842,
-0.30265435576438904,
0.5850980281829834,
0.33133214712142944,
-0.3285321593284607,
-0.17334023118019104,
-0.7733752727508545,
0.4125491678714752,
-0.9679557085037231,
0.32084107398986816,
0.4820748269557953,
0.09210847318172455,
-0.11000948399305344,
-0.7216373682022095,
-0.5636230111122131,
-0.30891644954681396,
-0.24689675867557526,
0.11884614825248718,
-0.2862839698791504,
0.24020721018314362,
0.03367330878973007,
0.03818019479513168,
-0.6125930547714233,
0.00698461476713419,
-0.360384464263916,
-0.12212243676185608,
0.44930481910705566,
0.14795531332492828,
0.3256091773509979,
-0.4025205075740814,
-0.39793404936790466,
0.00655091879889369,
-0.4303971230983734,
-0.24021239578723907,
0.48656320571899414,
0.44511377811431885,
-0.21141564846038818,
0.2608104348182678,
-0.0394473671913147,
0.4990706741809845,
-0.046807531267404556,
-0.3901206851005554,
0.3300478160381317,
-0.007684048730880022,
-0.012051360681653023,
0.20672592520713806,
0.839830756187439,
0.11789120733737946,
-0.21202902495861053,
-0.34989824891090393,
-0.07135418057441711,
0.05741216242313385,
0.05341753363609314,
-0.4305095970630646,
-0.34048670530319214,
0.24365034699440002,
-0.03914529085159302,
-0.298937052488327,
-0.1381593495607376,
-0.8412712216377258,
-0.29285934567451477,
-0.4935218095779419,
0.28488367795944214,
-0.7836195826530457,
-0.3410947620868683,
0.10043621808290482,
-0.2278333455324173,
-0.20442336797714233,
0.1863175928592682,
-0.4693469703197479,
0.309627503156662,
0.21844138205051422,
0.5559314489364624,
-0.15092714130878448,
-0.5779346227645874,
-0.3986572027206421,
0.20703569054603577,
-0.46814045310020447,
0.4830681085586548,
-0.378987580537796,
-0.42917129397392273,
-0.04824758693575859,
-0.07054858654737473,
0.16901662945747375,
-0.5982000827789307,
0.49892833828926086,
0.12602494657039642,
0.13737820088863373,
-0.0971423089504242,
-0.43129822611808777,
-0.01973780058324337,
-0.2360612452030182,
-0.7905601859092712,
0.9984298348426819,
0.12251003831624985,
-0.7766956686973572,
0.016857121139764786,
-0.31619560718536377,
-0.7562143206596375,
0.2580394744873047,
-0.28348129987716675,
-0.22053053975105286,
0.16107773780822754,
-0.03842722624540329,
0.3496072590351105,
-0.2532995641231537,
0.5599198937416077,
-0.11141615360975266,
-0.26062747836112976,
0.16571927070617676,
-0.6776622533798218,
0.6654719710350037,
0.08085989952087402,
-0.6292590498924255,
-0.39717012643814087,
-1.0833141803741455,
-0.27129030227661133,
0.0005145928589627147,
-0.00911951344460249,
-0.2554306983947754,
0.11226219683885574,
0.24698317050933838,
0.4283450245857239,
0.14296883344650269,
-0.4492422342300415,
-0.3626532554626465,
-0.5348089933395386,
0.5379859805107117,
0.5831777453422546,
0.159445658326149,
0.07196120172739029,
-0.3475053012371063,
0.358061283826828,
0.3897823691368103,
-0.03518073633313179,
-0.0005665593780577183,
-0.34160691499710083,
-0.7773193120956421,
-0.3180665671825409,
0.039095621556043625,
0.4734368324279785,
-1.219484806060791,
0.3807401955127716,
-0.12611123919487,
-0.5443950891494751,
-0.480358749628067,
-0.325367271900177,
0.647279679775238,
0.7780531644821167,
0.4516909420490265,
0.07913220673799515,
-0.5268614292144775,
-1.0754021406173706,
-0.018099483102560043,
-0.3704993426799774,
-0.23641334474086761,
-0.06789835542440414,
-0.0010198643431067467,
0.2886377274990082,
0.7092610597610474,
-0.15738116204738617,
-0.21950629353523254,
-0.1922636479139328,
0.46104270219802856,
-0.17817433178424835,
0.3068634569644928,
0.44084346294403076,
-0.5985021591186523,
-0.4100283980369568,
-0.2200010120868683,
-0.5273051261901855,
-0.17316898703575134,
-0.1431751251220703,
0.2548016905784607,
0.2843841314315796,
0.5688953995704651,
-0.45626071095466614,
0.5290149450302124,
0.586376965045929,
-0.08292274177074432,
0.5222809910774231,
-0.18480122089385986,
0.3808307647705078,
-1.1128419637680054,
0.08474119007587433,
0.003752917516976595,
-0.25732681155204773,
-0.9318616390228271,
-0.35113227367401123,
-0.3064860999584198,
-0.4953867793083191,
-0.8117748498916626,
0.2741476595401764,
-0.3738589584827423,
-0.04127771779894829,
-0.010802454315125942,
0.48075613379478455,
-0.08053851127624512,
0.5460590124130249,
0.14343948662281036,
0.6774771213531494,
0.6097908020019531,
-0.5532377362251282,
0.2643057405948639,
0.3492608964443207,
-0.189658984541893,
0.5993028879165649,
-0.6460898518562317,
0.2490660399198532,
-0.14775916934013367,
0.11953963339328766,
-1.2648861408233643,
-0.23040173947811127,
0.010038087144494057,
-0.332687646150589,
0.12897765636444092,
0.024498337879776955,
-0.3729792833328247,
-0.168015718460083,
-0.03730637580156326,
0.24040617048740387,
0.46008509397506714,
-0.45458197593688965,
0.3476071357727051,
0.6220180988311768,
-0.5894263982772827,
-0.2860686480998993,
-0.8926588296890259,
0.2819676697254181,
-0.37523338198661804,
-0.4127112925052643,
0.5540485978126526,
0.004920004401355982,
-0.0008275968139059842,
-0.16873428225517273,
0.0278693325817585,
-0.19645054638385773,
-0.17402316629886627,
0.22522976994514465,
0.2264818698167801,
0.12685109674930573,
0.3053835332393646,
0.2274112105369568,
0.004641669802367687,
-0.1707993596792221,
0.2099171131849289,
0.5581649541854858,
-0.07018344104290009,
-0.45745721459388733,
-0.6216042637825012,
0.4906473755836487,
0.5547453761100769,
0.0647912546992302,
0.46818724274635315,
0.2689412534236908,
-0.36252111196517944,
-0.19015459716320038,
-0.39105281233787537,
-0.18218232691287994,
-0.45366644859313965,
0.566152036190033,
-0.33047783374786377,
-0.7419499158859253,
0.4669138789176941,
-0.0028704607393592596,
0.0072022974491119385,
0.1970846801996231,
0.37637799978256226,
0.01264523807913065,
0.7723265886306763,
0.14497143030166626,
-0.14580188691616058,
0.45897865295410156,
0.27809298038482666,
0.30481067299842834,
-0.20883846282958984,
-0.053191352635622025,
-0.5556620359420776,
-0.23632538318634033,
-0.5279412865638733,
-0.4202945828437805,
0.38019028306007385,
-0.18948476016521454,
0.11800950765609741,
0.55440753698349,
-0.39602482318878174,
0.4023025631904602,
0.3365381062030792,
0.2955532670021057,
0.18839791417121887,
0.11112910509109497,
0.11146881431341171,
-0.09521068632602692,
-0.5597041249275208,
-0.5460402965545654,
0.7479687929153442,
0.2004861980676651,
0.6724323034286499,
0.051897305995225906,
0.8550014495849609,
0.15608465671539307,
-0.31433963775634766,
-0.37523767352104187,
0.772078275680542,
-0.38096824288368225,
-0.3484354317188263,
-0.3714052438735962,
-0.5369773507118225,
-0.8072243928909302,
-0.12028337270021439,
0.047918885946273804,
-0.8607751727104187,
0.12818726897239685,
0.1654796004295349,
-0.15405522286891937,
0.15218761563301086,
-0.6808717250823975,
0.6904959678649902,
0.11458131670951843,
-0.28581923246383667,
-0.20714044570922852,
-0.7097874879837036,
0.23915794491767883,
0.08469893038272858,
0.31899112462997437,
-0.12039884179830551,
0.21413256227970123,
0.6016849279403687,
-0.23721280694007874,
0.9555938839912415,
-0.2512517273426056,
-0.08643727749586105,
0.4307079613208771,
0.40092137455940247,
0.5266433358192444,
0.04998800531029701,
-0.11774715781211853,
0.3115575909614563,
0.23633643984794617,
-0.28432461619377136,
-0.2925986051559448,
0.5579703450202942,
-0.5930482745170593,
-0.5619708299636841,
0.05087214335799217,
-0.46684199571609497,
-0.5785826444625854,
-0.18769629299640656,
0.3532915711402893,
0.4976593255996704,
-0.702461302280426,
0.13892586529254913,
0.4808604121208191,
-0.3023379445075989,
0.5453658699989319,
0.4383242428302765,
-0.037916671484708786,
-0.2640935778617859,
1.0944498777389526,
0.07566522061824799,
0.4725401699542999,
0.26059767603874207,
0.0008807851700112224,
-0.3044402301311493,
-0.31058114767074585,
-0.010078455321490765,
0.1493620127439499,
-0.733900785446167,
0.007666620425879955,
-0.39279428124427795,
-0.30740422010421753,
-0.5431519746780396,
0.09164134413003922,
-0.5049296617507935,
-0.7832739949226379,
-0.4431232810020447,
-0.30797135829925537,
0.21072852611541748,
0.5960368514060974,
-0.1953573375940323,
0.2562192976474762,
-0.7781186699867249,
0.5120857357978821,
0.18084774911403656,
0.07088127732276917,
-0.22574712336063385,
-0.6310823559761047,
0.034555189311504364,
0.299498587846756,
-0.322948157787323,
-1.0836398601531982,
0.4752339720726013,
0.3933175802230835,
0.44207656383514404,
0.2036600410938263,
0.25582754611968994,
0.7613405585289001,
-0.6313024163246155,
0.9600863456726074,
0.5173656940460205,
-1.092813491821289,
0.5932884812355042,
-0.2540435791015625,
0.09390269219875336,
0.5568106174468994,
0.3872814476490021,
-0.6432451605796814,
-0.8500721454620361,
-0.8718490600585938,
-0.9467374086380005,
0.8693639636039734,
0.3829120993614197,
0.09173081070184708,
-0.43029776215553284,
-0.037549421191215515,
0.25700685381889343,
0.31416723132133484,
-0.6649369597434998,
-0.24611666798591614,
-0.3212926685810089,
-0.3434087932109833,
-0.17762993276119232,
-0.0018158917082473636,
-0.29198312759399414,
-0.122584268450737,
0.7840872406959534,
0.12905912101268768,
0.15217778086662292,
0.11879099160432816,
-0.10075771808624268,
0.08223717659711838,
0.33600613474845886,
0.5729398727416992,
0.5831290483474731,
-0.002185981487855315,
0.36621496081352234,
0.015391943976283073,
-0.17530180513858795,
0.31384971737861633,
0.18347668647766113,
0.11919030547142029,
0.4964742064476013,
0.23046231269836426,
1.1198852062225342,
0.35675013065338135,
-0.6599006056785583,
0.45983314514160156,
0.10864856094121933,
-0.21353930234909058,
-0.13914339244365692,
-0.2929977476596832,
0.2611246407032013,
0.027130767703056335,
0.20546330511569977,
-0.07393724471330643,
0.3137786090373993,
-0.4788254499435425,
0.5576707720756531,
0.05139871686697006,
-0.37941184639930725,
-0.4292670488357544,
0.48175886273384094,
0.24811094999313354,
-0.4228409230709076,
0.4959014058113098,
-0.27943548560142517,
-0.105386883020401,
0.4320666491985321,
0.43401211500167847,
0.9101150035858154,
-0.6190346479415894,
0.6379176378250122,
0.22535720467567444,
0.19368910789489746,
0.14132821559906006,
-0.01556131150573492,
0.2016201913356781,
-0.39041265845298767,
-0.09289968758821487,
-0.5125758051872253,
-0.3627902865409851,
0.31189867854118347,
-0.6149426102638245,
0.3844950199127197,
-0.296723335981369,
-0.08061499893665314,
0.2079223394393921,
-0.7451865077018738,
-0.48128417134284973,
0.05611257627606392,
0.037665482610464096,
0.38574233651161194,
-1.2094519138336182,
0.8229018449783325,
0.26851752400398254,
-0.5023358464241028,
-0.9041258096694946,
0.21457065641880035,
0.03199315443634987,
-0.5159164667129517,
0.4673571288585663,
-0.10044148564338684,
-0.0077870613895356655,
0.1358584463596344,
-0.15480436384677887,
-0.4108317792415619,
0.6957046389579773,
0.8487098813056946,
-0.5582050085067749,
-0.25834226608276367,
0.7507469058036804,
0.5738431215286255,
-0.0650840699672699,
0.2509187161922455,
0.6698545813560486,
0.1164613887667656,
0.36591243743896484,
-1.030036211013794,
-0.012764648534357548,
0.06285418570041656,
0.10159538686275482,
0.01798410899937153,
-0.5305579304695129,
0.902452826499939,
0.4715855121612549,
-0.3632369935512543,
-0.10140226781368256,
0.4071092903614044,
0.19061875343322754,
0.08425136655569077,
0.5129593014717102,
0.6587755084037781,
0.4893449544906616,
-0.04219695180654526,
0.5002126693725586,
-0.27408185601234436,
0.19616660475730896,
1.5358185768127441,
-0.38899025321006775,
0.8127775192260742,
0.6773474812507629,
-0.43526890873908997,
0.3008396625518799,
0.3779169023036957,
0.5640618205070496,
0.5285819172859192,
0.0630091205239296,
-0.47611600160598755,
-0.022115617990493774,
0.029051361605525017,
-0.12807874381542206,
0.5765284299850464,
0.3063336908817291,
-0.07037398964166641,
-0.5370569229125977,
0.3490696847438812,
-0.12065361440181732,
0.04626854509115219,
0.1628023386001587,
0.9672397375106812,
-0.10511922091245651,
-0.642032265663147,
0.9197704195976257,
-0.2438896894454956,
0.3328917324542999,
-0.5761989951133728,
-0.15718446671962738,
-0.49805188179016113,
-0.17364667356014252,
-0.20520052313804626,
-0.6616204380989075,
0.4835495054721832,
-0.19034390151500702,
0.13717016577720642,
-0.046028316020965576,
0.37762102484703064,
-0.7720215916633606,
-0.37864676117897034,
0.3532663583755493,
0.30866435170173645,
0.4405391812324524,
-0.03414144366979599,
-0.7096096873283386,
-0.1105475053191185,
0.16839846968650818,
-0.19360026717185974,
0.39398953318595886,
0.8373796343803406,
0.1735275238752365,
0.44499945640563965,
0.2212122678756714,
0.08438552916049957,
0.18071623146533966,
0.31850364804267883,
0.8390430212020874,
-0.2809445858001709,
-0.5904500484466553,
-0.6123123168945312,
0.8355624675750732,
-0.03778098523616791,
-0.13216286897659302,
0.5304603576660156,
0.5630297660827637,
0.578156054019928,
-0.16768714785575867,
0.8173064589500427,
-0.1852426379919052,
0.5817728638648987,
-0.3746456503868103,
0.5246716141700745,
-0.5187477469444275,
0.22792863845825195,
-0.7694797515869141,
-0.5505555272102356,
0.19370052218437195,
0.47213679552078247,
0.09875387698411942,
-0.23737061023712158,
0.7778043150901794,
0.9916930198669434,
-0.09859639406204224,
0.11303097754716873,
0.8216299414634705,
0.33769047260284424,
0.2838839888572693,
0.49255481362342834,
0.7019539475440979,
-0.4657549262046814,
0.6758458614349365,
-0.3432665467262268,
-0.33901646733283997,
0.012056400999426842,
-0.9215546250343323,
-0.6342703700065613,
-1.0320580005645752,
-0.5292981863021851,
-0.15949198603630066,
-0.016084939241409302,
0.6576805114746094,
0.41189834475517273,
-0.7545977234840393,
-0.35646194219589233,
-0.532879650592804,
-0.10052628070116043,
-0.20295007526874542,
-0.2837752103805542,
0.16744469106197357,
-0.41509443521499634,
-0.8091440796852112,
0.7396966218948364,
0.4493485391139984,
0.23276159167289734,
-0.18255743384361267,
0.11724723875522614,
-0.32297396659851074,
0.22707855701446533,
0.4418608844280243,
0.20301973819732666,
-0.7390632629394531,
-0.4282393753528595,
-0.36210358142852783,
0.05459144711494446,
0.17077715694904327,
0.5014703273773193,
-0.5439465641975403,
0.40995535254478455,
0.35814666748046875,
0.44654297828674316,
0.4732005000114441,
-0.13370810449123383,
0.37475407123565674,
-1.3476163148880005,
0.7664333581924438,
0.48159560561180115,
0.29240238666534424,
0.270532488822937,
-0.18354634940624237,
0.21296706795692444,
0.25696855783462524,
-0.36940088868141174,
-0.8855500817298889,
0.22266247868537903,
-0.83792644739151,
-0.4627184569835663,
0.9628021121025085,
-0.3162740170955658,
-0.12708313763141632,
-0.14077751338481903,
-0.3684692084789276,
0.46466389298439026,
-0.4036102592945099,
0.7992519736289978,
0.8817610144615173,
-0.05268136039376259,
-0.24376754462718964,
-0.2685457766056061,
0.5147811770439148,
0.495105117559433,
-0.9157789945602417,
0.4586613178253174,
0.8160455226898193,
0.20782974362373352,
0.20037032663822174,
0.7092642784118652,
-0.22484253346920013,
0.12518440186977386,
0.2987470030784607,
0.17749068140983582,
0.14189209043979645,
-0.47039303183555603,
-0.23596368730068207,
0.16629637777805328,
-0.004407562781125307,
-0.1474762111902237
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08818v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08818v1
|
Linguistic Bias in ChatGPT: Language Models Reinforce Dialect Discrimination
| 2024-06-13T05:20:42 | 2024-06-13T05:20:42 |
Eve Fleisig, Genevieve Smith, Madeline Bossi, Ishita Rustagi, Xavier Yin, Dan Klein
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
We present a large-scale study of linguistic bias exhibited by ChatGPT
covering ten dialects of English (Standard American English, Standard British
English, and eight widely spoken non-"standard" varieties from around the
world). We prompted GPT-3.5 Turbo and GPT-4 with text by native speakers of
each variety and analyzed the responses via detailed linguistic feature
annotation and native speaker evaluation. We find that the models default to
"standard" varieties of English; based on evaluation by native speakers, we
also find that model responses to non-"standard" varieties consistently exhibit
a range of issues: lack of comprehension (10% worse compared to "standard"
varieties), stereotyping (16% worse), demeaning content (22% worse), and
condescending responses (12% worse). We also find that if these models are
asked to imitate the writing style of prompts in non-"standard" varieties, they
produce text that exhibits lower comprehension of the input and is especially
prone to stereotyping. GPT-4 improves on GPT-3.5 in terms of comprehension,
warmth, and friendliness, but it also results in a marked increase in
stereotyping (+17%). The results suggest that GPT-3.5 Turbo and GPT-4 exhibit
linguistic discrimination in ways that can exacerbate harms for speakers of
non-"standard" varieties.
|
[
-0.4649943709373474,
-0.7827804088592529,
0.38470229506492615,
0.44185686111450195,
-0.15229491889476776,
-0.09229028224945068,
-0.4784524738788605,
-0.6384414434432983,
0.25077152252197266,
0.5913694500923157,
-0.25007376074790955,
-0.2464054673910141,
-0.6139553189277649,
0.3634629249572754,
-0.2656026780605316,
1.3003257513046265,
0.3902316689491272,
0.3487265110015869,
-0.06282823532819748,
0.12691211700439453,
-0.6518431305885315,
-0.9414376616477966,
-0.6031895875930786,
-0.36497771739959717,
0.4004053473472595,
0.3043269217014313,
0.9234439134597778,
0.16672497987747192,
0.30943918228149414,
0.26174604892730713,
-0.24564526975154877,
-0.47737017273902893,
-0.5111363530158997,
0.2731209695339203,
0.014021866023540497,
-0.5792706608772278,
-0.3178916871547699,
0.3224201500415802,
0.33251410722732544,
0.7496783137321472,
-0.0639575719833374,
-0.03720998764038086,
0.14703288674354553,
0.6617125272750854,
-0.32755574584007263,
0.3182106912136078,
-0.8550180196762085,
-0.01572929322719574,
-0.43290936946868896,
0.09715695679187775,
-0.5534142255783081,
-0.44458216428756714,
0.2917528748512268,
-0.6687968969345093,
0.6955356597900391,
0.18716685473918915,
0.9984092116355896,
0.006710986141115427,
-0.7277112007141113,
-0.28908243775367737,
-0.5917203426361084,
0.5981170535087585,
-0.7027750611305237,
0.5098537802696228,
0.5404949188232422,
0.17565518617630005,
-0.012465989217162132,
-0.44954025745391846,
-0.512320876121521,
-0.6050897240638733,
-0.045406706631183624,
0.354221373796463,
-0.21998746693134308,
0.3116903603076935,
0.5155280828475952,
0.506223738193512,
-0.8136811256408691,
0.1246933788061142,
-0.567768931388855,
-0.24780085682868958,
0.5559675097465515,
-0.0023051758762449026,
0.19307836890220642,
-0.3046475052833557,
-0.04443105682730675,
0.0053811706602573395,
-0.7230290770530701,
-0.04930783063173294,
0.7652186155319214,
0.3914875090122223,
0.0357101634144783,
0.43360140919685364,
-0.24578943848609924,
0.6289412975311279,
0.10172941535711288,
0.12993697822093964,
0.3169303238391876,
-0.3071776032447815,
-0.09203603118658066,
-0.0933549553155899,
0.9817655086517334,
0.6192069053649902,
0.733420729637146,
0.004106891807168722,
-0.21582989394664764,
0.1997629851102829,
-0.04722225293517113,
-0.6053407192230225,
-0.43323564529418945,
-0.17488887906074524,
-0.2409866750240326,
-0.21742136776447296,
-0.20501920580863953,
-1.0766732692718506,
-0.4921397566795349,
0.0062601612880826,
0.18802514672279358,
-0.5428657531738281,
-0.19010117650032043,
0.18131417036056519,
-0.4317455589771271,
0.39693886041641235,
0.1637529730796814,
-1.20297110080719,
0.4747472405433655,
0.5028526186943054,
0.7912254929542542,
-0.10526544600725174,
-0.1122124195098877,
-0.0946119949221611,
-0.17784595489501953,
-0.18892186880111694,
0.9054866433143616,
-0.8386816382408142,
-0.617413341999054,
-0.012561901472508907,
-0.10885956138372421,
-0.16351129114627838,
-0.6798719167709351,
0.5986731052398682,
-0.26628780364990234,
0.8038579821586609,
-0.5418325066566467,
-0.40266162157058716,
-0.15725190937519073,
0.14692777395248413,
-0.8238821625709534,
0.9310593008995056,
0.09053804725408554,
-0.9681510329246521,
0.46398618817329407,
-0.5598072409629822,
-0.2826746106147766,
-0.013938465155661106,
-0.292115181684494,
-0.28581035137176514,
0.039851199835538864,
0.37855520844459534,
0.08177753537893295,
-0.3023655414581299,
0.14061276614665985,
-0.3179071843624115,
-0.43459323048591614,
0.10631435364484787,
-0.6342408061027527,
0.8338459134101868,
0.23551392555236816,
-0.5652645826339722,
-0.09824175387620926,
-0.48094502091407776,
-0.2878194749355316,
0.24743494391441345,
-0.2263198345899582,
-0.2870804965496063,
-0.0998113825917244,
0.08510846644639969,
0.14747944474220276,
-0.02503189817070961,
-0.7454153299331665,
0.13103266060352325,
-0.5295915603637695,
0.4928925633430481,
0.6706975698471069,
0.011520697735249996,
0.27638691663742065,
-0.4417315125465393,
0.7513209581375122,
0.03622780740261078,
0.1592627763748169,
0.044927723705768585,
-0.9961885809898376,
-0.754208505153656,
-0.03640865162014961,
0.3632809817790985,
0.5167037844657898,
-0.549959123134613,
0.046993013471364975,
-0.2537603974342346,
-0.33945685625076294,
-0.36750784516334534,
-0.22638946771621704,
0.4378562271595001,
0.48179733753204346,
0.2887851297855377,
-0.4496406018733978,
-0.35459738969802856,
-1.360329031944275,
-0.3282804489135742,
-0.46244826912879944,
-0.30009180307388306,
0.2816160321235657,
0.354796826839447,
0.19722703099250793,
0.9619254469871521,
-0.37838563323020935,
0.023888960480690002,
-0.2698543071746826,
0.22509555518627167,
-0.03204244375228882,
0.21025119721889496,
0.7518799901008606,
-0.6346395015716553,
-0.6168809533119202,
-0.10317149758338928,
-0.08710376173257828,
-0.6042824387550354,
0.17701217532157898,
0.14270250499248505,
0.2929031550884247,
0.10920937359333038,
-0.6302495002746582,
0.2416483759880066,
0.6392304301261902,
-0.6174116134643555,
0.8992543816566467,
0.2779694199562073,
0.18513093888759613,
-0.944760799407959,
-0.32606858015060425,
0.18506599962711334,
-0.15383519232273102,
-0.6653082966804504,
-0.13067321479320526,
-0.09884881973266602,
-0.07143601775169373,
-0.0998862013220787,
0.4940207302570343,
-0.31170737743377686,
0.13695472478866577,
0.026601165533065796,
0.2521537244319916,
0.2071964591741562,
0.3344205617904663,
0.28559085726737976,
0.9808862209320068,
0.3223930895328522,
-0.3201321065425873,
0.25810667872428894,
0.15466736257076263,
-0.07409355789422989,
0.3713502287864685,
-0.6863210797309875,
0.2625215947628021,
-0.182809516787529,
0.42770376801490784,
-1.1131279468536377,
-0.18638433516025543,
0.1355830579996109,
-0.6723477840423584,
0.010108302347362041,
-0.2165229767560959,
-0.12420231848955154,
-0.24126185476779938,
-0.24909096956253052,
0.31237152218818665,
0.7896586656570435,
-0.32479625940322876,
0.19462314248085022,
0.15023916959762573,
-0.5031775236129761,
-0.32939255237579346,
-0.7378047704696655,
0.06905077397823334,
-0.2053212821483612,
-0.5919655561447144,
-0.003718490246683359,
-0.04147768393158913,
-0.5325829386711121,
-0.2706190049648285,
0.010217612609267235,
-0.25448551774024963,
-0.21568481624126434,
-0.04734957590699196,
0.07302124053239822,
-0.3565470278263092,
-0.023828474804759026,
-0.2475210577249527,
0.30238616466522217,
0.2168743759393692,
-0.1799086183309555,
0.6768252849578857,
-0.18436744809150696,
-0.3278459310531616,
0.06460130214691162,
0.4567769765853882,
0.3977970480918884,
-0.2837356626987457,
0.41617751121520996,
0.39927420020103455,
0.11764206737279892,
-0.13472236692905426,
-0.7471411824226379,
-0.3587005138397217,
-0.436887264251709,
0.574779212474823,
-0.33510178327560425,
-1.109771490097046,
0.502487063407898,
0.6468524932861328,
0.008593914099037647,
0.3731847107410431,
0.5795832276344299,
0.1818874478340149,
1.113444209098816,
0.4049389064311981,
-0.20102708041667938,
0.46711090207099915,
0.25729840993881226,
0.19822613894939423,
-0.4919776916503906,
-0.08436959981918335,
-0.9034889936447144,
-0.14892232418060303,
-1.0222606658935547,
-0.23881816864013672,
0.14493471384048462,
-0.18128164112567902,
-0.19492270052433014,
0.025207091122865677,
-0.47703760862350464,
0.6221020221710205,
0.7458805441856384,
-0.0505373477935791,
0.32101666927337646,
-0.04887503758072853,
-0.1053704172372818,
-0.418115496635437,
-0.7412365078926086,
-0.5768381953239441,
1.1286506652832031,
0.4502638578414917,
0.5915232300758362,
0.2505648136138916,
0.5704174041748047,
0.08777451515197754,
0.37605810165405273,
-0.8333833813667297,
0.4800618588924408,
-0.1542969048023224,
-1.03681480884552,
-0.05475221574306488,
-0.6306413412094116,
-0.8763971924781799,
0.3683394193649292,
-0.008153220638632774,
-0.7554544806480408,
0.059653427451848984,
0.29262182116508484,
-0.1407906711101532,
0.26214319467544556,
-1.1014328002929688,
0.7903130650520325,
0.0082649951800704,
-0.18855278193950653,
0.16116788983345032,
-0.5504832863807678,
0.6052013039588928,
-0.08384273201227188,
0.3213776648044586,
-0.14215487241744995,
0.1929387003183365,
0.7480254769325256,
-0.18890148401260376,
0.8510662317276001,
-0.20998483896255493,
-0.1450791209936142,
0.13276371359825134,
0.26724547147750854,
0.3171749711036682,
0.0889267548918724,
-0.25148308277130127,
0.2533610761165619,
0.19065716862678528,
-0.5181382894515991,
-0.5212774276733398,
0.27933865785598755,
-0.8014885187149048,
-0.8345703482627869,
-0.6037083864212036,
-0.6165577173233032,
-0.5806050300598145,
0.008044599555432796,
0.553547203540802,
0.44705191254615784,
-0.48119020462036133,
0.029745299369096756,
0.5258342623710632,
-0.4602029621601105,
0.23798911273479462,
0.7233297824859619,
-0.37457579374313354,
-0.18927136063575745,
0.7056417465209961,
0.024218901991844177,
0.7426345348358154,
0.04687586426734924,
0.4011114239692688,
-0.30681362748146057,
-0.5832982659339905,
-0.2527732253074646,
0.21645066142082214,
-0.5303333401679993,
0.124836266040802,
-0.38109421730041504,
-0.18268047273159027,
-0.804706871509552,
0.10122954100370407,
-0.20691929757595062,
-0.5839044451713562,
0.23899900913238525,
-0.08162648230791092,
0.3208838999271393,
1.213103175163269,
0.18401828408241272,
0.5493021011352539,
-0.5316431522369385,
-0.10171405971050262,
0.3981921672821045,
0.3255419433116913,
-0.4599989056587219,
-0.9216888546943665,
-0.01664719171822071,
0.08005261421203613,
-0.45670098066329956,
-1.1421223878860474,
0.30794915556907654,
0.15544499456882477,
0.29705891013145447,
0.32578861713409424,
-0.0452578105032444,
0.27097922563552856,
-0.6439034938812256,
1.4189496040344238,
0.0097119752317667,
-0.7621931433677673,
0.26466014981269836,
-0.7566063404083252,
0.313998818397522,
0.3185146152973175,
0.2903783917427063,
-0.9614875316619873,
-0.9792486429214478,
-0.687477171421051,
-0.7735147476196289,
0.6197085976600647,
0.27048370242118835,
0.3617650866508484,
-0.46554625034332275,
0.131414994597435,
0.19266650080680847,
0.22364236414432526,
-1.1756490468978882,
-0.2006606161594391,
-0.4638075828552246,
0.006170462351292372,
-0.22787658870220184,
-0.48308929800987244,
0.08482886105775833,
-0.1755148321390152,
0.691109299659729,
0.1007995754480362,
0.4430222511291504,
0.16676267981529236,
0.01773439347743988,
0.2649558186531067,
0.6101557016372681,
0.7256675362586975,
0.49786514043807983,
-0.29776039719581604,
0.24509550631046295,
0.1101338192820549,
-0.8174012899398804,
0.03515077009797096,
0.19122576713562012,
-0.3957652747631073,
0.36444664001464844,
0.461860716342926,
0.8678364753723145,
-0.18242914974689484,
-0.19869883358478546,
0.6437586545944214,
-0.24662798643112183,
-0.43229901790618896,
-0.041099485009908676,
-0.02936760149896145,
-0.04129936173558235,
-0.13524436950683594,
-0.02606889046728611,
-0.02267240546643734,
0.260577529668808,
-0.3710617125034332,
0.11807374656200409,
0.5041561126708984,
-0.3835991322994232,
-0.5549458861351013,
0.7074998021125793,
0.4614221155643463,
-0.2099922150373459,
0.4908459484577179,
-0.4139197766780853,
-0.7588590383529663,
0.5381699204444885,
0.8089847564697266,
0.9209727048873901,
-0.3877212703227997,
0.3291124999523163,
0.32398721575737,
0.6221666932106018,
0.03136509284377098,
0.12265412509441376,
0.24598389863967896,
-0.9571776390075684,
-0.31600773334503174,
-0.5549594759941101,
-0.5333898067474365,
0.36249130964279175,
-0.5427530407905579,
0.08745208382606506,
-0.5000437498092651,
-0.19811399281024933,
-0.1670539379119873,
-0.11322718113660812,
-0.5887430310249329,
0.11127966642379761,
0.4013867974281311,
0.8942612409591675,
-1.142557978630066,
0.7430399060249329,
0.7490688562393188,
-0.6098871827125549,
-0.9531515836715698,
0.35999444127082825,
0.43092066049575806,
-0.7387568354606628,
0.7059823870658875,
0.2059324085712433,
0.06498315930366516,
-0.07279948145151138,
-0.3770551085472107,
-0.6995741724967957,
0.40652185678482056,
0.49736398458480835,
-0.626082181930542,
0.12029349058866501,
0.4178309738636017,
0.6079161167144775,
-0.07909351587295532,
0.8411867022514343,
0.820022702217102,
0.40511995553970337,
-0.07610701024532318,
-1.5263876914978027,
-0.1765015870332718,
-0.2930248975753784,
0.055527184158563614,
0.17087870836257935,
-0.8609350323677063,
1.032771110534668,
0.3451501727104187,
0.03978986665606499,
-0.3166283667087555,
0.25478607416152954,
0.04032094404101372,
0.011468523181974888,
0.5313998460769653,
0.43861156702041626,
0.7005385160446167,
-0.3383869230747223,
0.999533474445343,
-0.18405628204345703,
0.1458691656589508,
1.0731197595596313,
-0.3124059736728668,
0.694909930229187,
0.41166260838508606,
-0.3803127110004425,
0.5312996506690979,
0.6989853978157043,
0.26352882385253906,
0.2818702161312103,
0.2612796425819397,
-0.5144525766372681,
0.12258446961641312,
-0.05779608339071274,
-0.4991258680820465,
0.49716508388519287,
0.25403255224227905,
-0.21329960227012634,
-0.21907882392406464,
-0.10277831554412842,
0.3918118476867676,
0.06650321930646896,
-0.2276393622159958,
0.6831845045089722,
-0.026591498404741287,
-0.805820107460022,
0.6257423758506775,
-0.0809488296508789,
0.900669515132904,
-0.6936419606208801,
0.13931961357593536,
-0.7643527388572693,
-0.14854177832603455,
-0.23142629861831665,
-0.6735008955001831,
0.1979222297668457,
0.18525183200836182,
-0.24341624975204468,
-0.07332026213407516,
0.4049755334854126,
-0.5060657858848572,
-0.3582543432712555,
0.14136174321174622,
0.3836411237716675,
0.4453509747982025,
-0.253936767578125,
-0.6548584699630737,
-0.040801774710416794,
0.3703400790691376,
-0.4285085201263428,
0.25709405541419983,
0.5261828899383545,
-0.2296134978532791,
0.4585798978805542,
0.2734892666339874,
0.32719314098358154,
0.4055878520011902,
0.5064244270324707,
0.6888704299926758,
-0.7266401052474976,
-0.5367697477340698,
-0.8366305232048035,
0.2623398005962372,
-0.12136971950531006,
-0.3743865489959717,
0.9450527429580688,
0.6743587851524353,
0.9479186534881592,
0.020006366074085236,
1.1221109628677368,
-0.21408258378505707,
0.5526900291442871,
-0.6077770590782166,
0.3877861797809601,
-0.16131062805652618,
0.2809380292892456,
-0.37233966588974,
-1.0911810398101807,
-0.17561039328575134,
0.5332381129264832,
-0.82673579454422,
0.4422371983528137,
0.9606987833976746,
0.9187109470367432,
-0.10748640447854996,
0.3672412633895874,
0.3815050721168518,
0.3466815948486328,
0.4165228605270386,
0.45174238085746765,
0.897723376750946,
-0.010745642706751823,
0.5837669968605042,
-0.1870936155319214,
-0.36695364117622375,
0.2125023454427719,
-0.6479986906051636,
-0.9347776174545288,
-0.35453739762306213,
-0.10409316420555115,
-0.5109438896179199,
0.05648326501250267,
0.9001272320747375,
0.5433748364448547,
-0.88636714220047,
-0.42067331075668335,
0.06365391612052917,
-0.15556669235229492,
0.20362414419651031,
-0.2902942895889282,
-0.10089398920536041,
-0.5623993277549744,
-0.8778505921363831,
0.11355678737163544,
0.07269231975078583,
-0.0882706493139267,
-0.18511664867401123,
0.02818872779607773,
0.09247507899999619,
0.0501607283949852,
0.5820838809013367,
0.07762918621301651,
-0.7868659496307373,
-0.572151780128479,
0.03946397081017494,
-0.015103431418538094,
0.2791321873664856,
0.7374424338340759,
-0.5108386874198914,
0.4809142053127289,
0.41796621680259705,
0.24110259115695953,
0.2911459505558014,
0.1509900540113449,
0.8812962174415588,
-0.9534805417060852,
0.4701327085494995,
0.4154418706893921,
0.33588388562202454,
0.471256285905838,
-0.19362178444862366,
0.2949790060520172,
0.5843868851661682,
-0.8921675682067871,
-0.4867543876171112,
0.5446385741233826,
-0.689610481262207,
-0.10196573287248611,
1.4078267812728882,
0.11677399277687073,
-0.02650873176753521,
-0.32532933354377747,
-0.44201117753982544,
-0.036440130323171616,
-0.6008853912353516,
0.6382878422737122,
1.1603976488113403,
-0.27065226435661316,
-0.209922194480896,
-1.0918564796447754,
0.7727455496788025,
0.8075816035270691,
-0.4474569857120514,
0.25756457448005676,
0.8372387886047363,
0.5386563539505005,
-0.09981482475996017,
0.8264856338500977,
-0.15808703005313873,
0.04067989066243172,
0.12047535181045532,
0.228737935423851,
0.2586692273616791,
0.1441190093755722,
-0.49731841683387756,
-0.2296433001756668,
0.5278862714767456,
-0.019301000982522964
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08817v1
|
Automated Essay Scoring Using Grammatical Variety and Errors with Multi-Task Learning and Item Response Theory
| 2024-06-13T05:19:51 | 2024-06-13T05:19:51 |
Kosuke Doi, Katsuhito Sudoh, Satoshi Nakamura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study examines the effect of grammatical features in automatic essay
scoring (AES). We use two kinds of grammatical features as input to an AES
model: (1) grammatical items that writers used correctly in essays, and (2) the
number of grammatical errors. Experimental results show that grammatical
features improve the performance of AES models that predict the holistic scores
of essays. Multi-task learning with the holistic and grammar scores, alongside
using grammatical features, resulted in a larger improvement in model
performance. We also show that a model using grammar abilities estimated using
Item Response Theory (IRT) as the labels for the auxiliary task achieved
comparable performance to when we used grammar scores assigned by human raters.
In addition, we weight the grammatical features using IRT to consider the
difficulty of grammatical items and writers' grammar abilities. We found that
weighting grammatical features with the difficulty led to further improvement
in performance.
|
[
-0.2809165418148041,
-1.0491701364517212,
0.6592207551002502,
0.4867367446422577,
0.165491983294487,
0.04827828332781792,
-0.20197682082653046,
-0.6376668810844421,
0.26150593161582947,
0.21801812946796417,
-0.12200518697500229,
-0.29085099697113037,
-0.6610568165779114,
0.5789521932601929,
-0.4097616970539093,
0.9219328761100769,
-0.25992125272750854,
0.12842068076133728,
-0.3582276999950409,
0.10089880228042603,
-0.5055769085884094,
-0.5224180221557617,
-0.7388126850128174,
0.02118462510406971,
0.6498988270759583,
0.4447711408138275,
0.18234050273895264,
0.8728528022766113,
1.12478768825531,
0.439018577337265,
0.46501046419143677,
0.12040381878614426,
0.22566373646259308,
0.40982627868652344,
-0.06642675399780273,
-0.5757600665092468,
-0.6586828231811523,
0.22158437967300415,
0.752925455570221,
0.5950029492378235,
-0.0003284527047071606,
0.36676064133644104,
0.47629332542419434,
0.32925844192504883,
-0.5474127531051636,
0.4115593135356903,
-0.3501567840576172,
0.030502254143357277,
-0.17884087562561035,
-0.0843445286154747,
-0.48376649618148804,
-0.2860136926174164,
0.16804347932338715,
-0.7484983801841736,
0.16515639424324036,
0.18146686255931854,
0.7449609637260437,
0.09032284468412399,
-0.36463233828544617,
-0.5182241797447205,
-0.724483847618103,
0.9065508246421814,
-0.35102683305740356,
0.019793888553977013,
0.3985559344291687,
-0.040320005267858505,
0.23073850572109222,
-0.36359280347824097,
-0.2808644473552704,
-0.3448355495929718,
-0.2746458649635315,
0.15158237516880035,
-0.027546897530555725,
0.4470139443874359,
0.13856691122055054,
0.5263521075248718,
-0.44501620531082153,
-0.14950522780418396,
-0.26916247606277466,
0.03893236815929413,
0.8703216314315796,
0.3108833432197571,
0.13202683627605438,
-0.2651919722557068,
-0.07860197126865387,
-0.2067955881357193,
0.003198769176378846,
0.748711109161377,
0.5137198567390442,
0.5201839804649353,
0.13484257459640503,
0.6986634135246277,
-0.1273176670074463,
0.7286791205406189,
0.38183358311653137,
-0.34759652614593506,
0.16656553745269775,
-0.08943632245063782,
-0.2749212384223938,
-0.34106335043907166,
0.5049704313278198,
0.266311913728714,
0.13873401284217834,
0.010949225164949894,
-0.2680380940437317,
0.5556458234786987,
0.6101992130279541,
-0.23937705159187317,
-0.08543895930051804,
-0.18250994384288788,
-0.5103060007095337,
-0.41419580578804016,
0.30262020230293274,
-0.9410847425460815,
-0.08155026286840439,
-0.5304630398750305,
0.5510855317115784,
-0.3993791341781616,
0.20111919939517975,
-0.22865800559520721,
-0.2968495190143585,
0.09900207817554474,
0.3470892608165741,
-0.6738017201423645,
0.8759255409240723,
0.46095314621925354,
0.6761767268180847,
-0.2799707055091858,
-0.6516188979148865,
-0.6774787902832031,
-0.30870500206947327,
-0.350711852312088,
1.188841462135315,
-0.9314966797828674,
-0.3357104957103729,
0.06084129586815834,
-0.04775509610772133,
-0.6902471780776978,
-0.29423463344573975,
0.4051741659641266,
-0.1777503490447998,
0.3926266133785248,
-0.5073965191841125,
-0.7718944549560547,
-0.4578667879104614,
0.11421533674001694,
-0.5960431694984436,
1.212496280670166,
0.16243839263916016,
-0.4321414530277252,
0.25259461998939514,
-0.8388453722000122,
-0.8273015022277832,
-0.03854633495211601,
-0.005462949629873037,
-0.2915709614753723,
0.43366384506225586,
-0.19255326688289642,
0.5831186771392822,
0.08259374648332596,
-0.08210966736078262,
-0.25527238845825195,
-0.4380002021789551,
0.34683769941329956,
-0.33809706568717957,
0.18696148693561554,
0.007639639545232058,
-0.39050859212875366,
-0.13634313642978668,
-0.9313610196113586,
0.18616983294487,
-0.1413598656654358,
-0.7768865823745728,
-0.28219738602638245,
0.10715378075838089,
0.072325699031353,
0.06732714921236038,
0.19830118119716644,
-0.41099342703819275,
0.023881128057837486,
-0.3684345781803131,
-0.0851580873131752,
0.6046009659767151,
0.07856113463640213,
0.4417315721511841,
-0.8029466271400452,
0.6711698770523071,
-0.3370570242404938,
0.02379779890179634,
-0.3167016804218292,
-0.7591500282287598,
-0.7374252676963806,
-0.274794340133667,
0.14049622416496277,
0.9560065269470215,
-0.28701406717300415,
0.7850687503814697,
0.2873688340187073,
-0.4170915484428406,
-0.5063552856445312,
0.2855204939842224,
0.8284419178962708,
0.24982886016368866,
0.46964868903160095,
-0.47944313287734985,
-0.5319135785102844,
-0.6881909966468811,
-0.6501108407974243,
-0.5852283239364624,
0.0826299861073494,
0.18857665359973907,
0.4813441336154938,
0.48665183782577515,
0.7963547110557556,
-0.6253458261489868,
-0.49534276127815247,
-0.2700847089290619,
0.5955688953399658,
-0.47959253191947937,
0.3009806275367737,
0.654547393321991,
-0.34669893980026245,
-0.646183431148529,
-0.16736026108264923,
-0.4963200092315674,
-0.36788323521614075,
0.09209376573562622,
0.24600695073604584,
0.3623540997505188,
0.24210061132907867,
-0.6352308392524719,
0.7209126353263855,
0.12254136800765991,
-0.5566336512565613,
0.5882476568222046,
-0.1891944706439972,
0.6884938478469849,
-0.9630686044692993,
-0.10350526869297028,
0.37049707770347595,
-0.026442626491189003,
-0.42840513586997986,
0.220859095454216,
-0.013416518457233906,
0.1889244019985199,
-0.02887784130871296,
0.23968954384326935,
-0.14300470054149628,
-0.006283757742494345,
-0.35372012853622437,
-0.2085275948047638,
0.5974072217941284,
0.5315335392951965,
-0.16017180681228638,
0.573302686214447,
0.2560179531574249,
-0.5777331590652466,
0.43946728110313416,
-0.14498475193977356,
0.04865759611129761,
0.9942886829376221,
-0.3851483464241028,
0.009494094178080559,
-0.4185696542263031,
-0.25279369950294495,
-1.4725892543792725,
-0.42654070258140564,
-0.19642037153244019,
-0.4501126706600189,
0.4560641348361969,
0.32852837443351746,
0.027600152418017387,
-0.2520774006843567,
-0.5678422451019287,
0.0486818328499794,
0.15182507038116455,
0.2676905691623688,
0.9197845458984375,
0.126974418759346,
-0.6019941568374634,
-0.21735325455665588,
-0.4440634548664093,
-0.07490336149930954,
-0.3967110812664032,
-0.3199339509010315,
0.5536350011825562,
-0.14115449786186218,
-0.7662614583969116,
0.1921851634979248,
0.2531772255897522,
-0.06023002415895462,
0.20076048374176025,
0.3455542325973511,
0.3476230502128601,
-0.30359578132629395,
0.4361948072910309,
0.05186394602060318,
0.18867188692092896,
0.07348604500293732,
-0.17022570967674255,
0.2402939796447754,
-0.2678392231464386,
-0.3818637728691101,
-0.3620588481426239,
0.9771348237991333,
0.5782886743545532,
-0.3391757011413574,
0.5715084671974182,
0.3488134741783142,
-0.5715652704238892,
-0.030543996021151543,
-0.8748088479042053,
0.028046682476997375,
-0.34192338585853577,
0.4355742037296295,
-0.44399720430374146,
-0.5807936191558838,
0.5112392902374268,
0.49725762009620667,
0.2921333312988281,
0.911772608757019,
0.09439487010240555,
-0.6079564690589905,
0.9021443128585815,
0.9217020273208618,
0.0668218582868576,
0.4531324505805969,
0.06759314984083176,
0.20609579980373383,
-0.6825243830680847,
-0.24084444344043732,
-1.0227230787277222,
-0.4594617486000061,
-0.27406302094459534,
-0.13025377690792084,
0.3303086459636688,
0.022435009479522705,
-0.2685452699661255,
0.29193738102912903,
-0.30489617586135864,
0.22217784821987152,
0.5945655107498169,
0.006446558982133865,
0.20762605965137482,
0.035132233053445816,
-0.32682499289512634,
-0.23019112646579742,
-0.23275409638881683,
-0.5864405632019043,
1.1096408367156982,
0.30698442459106445,
0.6530336141586304,
-0.05821248143911362,
0.5730043053627014,
0.5564079880714417,
0.24791975319385529,
-0.7556857466697693,
0.41710537672042847,
-0.5183471441268921,
-0.30117738246917725,
-0.46272048354148865,
-0.02615499496459961,
-0.3949645757675171,
-0.04315728694200516,
-0.27859723567962646,
-0.6571054458618164,
0.19925551116466522,
0.14188379049301147,
-0.9183471202850342,
-0.17914986610412598,
-1.0507110357284546,
0.5003318786621094,
-0.31537380814552307,
-0.3435174822807312,
0.07293770462274551,
-0.26491740345954895,
-0.1729079633951187,
0.011685548350214958,
0.28207311034202576,
0.24836154282093048,
-0.02510676346719265,
0.9731184244155884,
-0.08840830624103546,
1.086635947227478,
0.005072044208645821,
0.1687701791524887,
0.3145914077758789,
0.15921467542648315,
0.4782324731349945,
-0.20745603740215302,
-0.1294282227754593,
-0.1504116952419281,
-0.24834255874156952,
-0.0424397848546505,
-0.6122080087661743,
0.6766173839569092,
-0.8061365485191345,
-0.6593213677406311,
-0.4247595965862274,
-0.4804629981517792,
-0.2274542897939682,
-0.06989685446023941,
0.48245182633399963,
0.3504560589790344,
-0.14331722259521484,
0.07410735636949539,
0.6431429982185364,
0.14112725853919983,
0.82682865858078,
0.42757701873779297,
-0.05758921802043915,
-0.5073431134223938,
0.5463384389877319,
0.5382896661758423,
0.10847599059343338,
0.3820970952510834,
0.023274322971701622,
-0.22938071191310883,
-0.3194037079811096,
-0.4433377981185913,
0.021639661863446236,
-0.8551235795021057,
-0.25202932953834534,
-1.078994631767273,
-0.232876256108284,
-0.6994850039482117,
-0.37451431155204773,
-0.1453709900379181,
-0.5024964809417725,
-0.44345566630363464,
-0.4445188045501709,
0.37655478715896606,
1.0547930002212524,
0.2164585292339325,
0.21053816378116608,
-0.6664368510246277,
0.21867430210113525,
0.41831937432289124,
0.32661351561546326,
-0.14200255274772644,
-0.7681076526641846,
-0.2811020016670227,
-0.3157144784927368,
-0.6384400129318237,
-0.8222659230232239,
0.20945914089679718,
0.4913333058357239,
0.37613824009895325,
0.4633851945400238,
-0.3632354736328125,
0.9162560105323792,
-0.44119566679000854,
0.884467363357544,
-0.13333259522914886,
-1.0508017539978027,
0.5211623907089233,
-0.10063683241605759,
0.2061469554901123,
0.6876605749130249,
0.20929746329784393,
-0.25618961453437805,
-0.6569253206253052,
-0.3935280442237854,
-0.5987229943275452,
0.4526486098766327,
0.14572934806346893,
0.04450494050979614,
-0.12397243082523346,
0.5389645099639893,
0.19736512005329132,
0.2782388925552368,
-0.7713479399681091,
-0.00006144431245047599,
-0.1639748215675354,
-0.7607971429824829,
-0.11038276553153992,
-0.2867499589920044,
0.25785335898399353,
-0.3966880142688751,
0.8351543545722961,
-0.13230563700199127,
0.282527893781662,
0.3133417069911957,
0.03550208732485771,
-0.5442588925361633,
0.2670827805995941,
0.4998442232608795,
0.3776553273200989,
0.2032545804977417,
0.10786082595586777,
0.16210831701755524,
-0.5708227157592773,
0.3352380394935608,
0.35239046812057495,
-0.18646888434886932,
-0.007162620313465595,
0.7416802048683167,
0.4768223762512207,
0.20030516386032104,
-0.3105536103248596,
0.5029208064079285,
-0.07950415462255478,
-0.19772200286388397,
-0.3685959279537201,
0.3340090215206146,
-0.1871810108423233,
0.1684725284576416,
0.3688128590583801,
0.560726523399353,
0.4011038839817047,
-0.4844302833080292,
0.12311693280935287,
0.3566794991493225,
-0.28009819984436035,
-0.3093012273311615,
0.3523389995098114,
0.10969392210245132,
-0.5786215662956238,
0.22056153416633606,
-0.2005011886358261,
-0.40057575702667236,
0.8608267903327942,
0.5441383719444275,
0.9252341985702515,
-0.9268004298210144,
0.3047040104866028,
0.21118411421775818,
0.44049766659736633,
-0.22602929174900055,
0.5515155792236328,
0.07613496482372284,
-0.4503342807292938,
-0.3730595111846924,
-1.0160768032073975,
-0.10360220819711685,
-0.027678903192281723,
-0.7304477095603943,
0.2981398403644562,
-0.45222848653793335,
-0.32715490460395813,
0.11157042533159256,
0.09774625301361084,
-0.8635804653167725,
0.5973581671714783,
0.02877797558903694,
0.5299590826034546,
-1.1557459831237793,
0.16137798130512238,
1.3052188158035278,
-0.31186679005622864,
-1.1104556322097778,
-0.07996480911970139,
-0.046479564160108566,
-0.33193379640579224,
0.42725303769111633,
0.3099079728126526,
-0.19045114517211914,
-0.13305947184562683,
0.21066692471504211,
-1.184220314025879,
0.7985861897468567,
0.020239485427737236,
-0.4027767479419708,
-0.38421431183815,
0.4410317838191986,
0.6489914655685425,
-0.7785900235176086,
0.4462549686431885,
0.3697700798511505,
0.5917019248008728,
-0.5128426551818848,
-1.1731411218643188,
-0.27866238355636597,
-0.6915019154548645,
0.20860642194747925,
0.004034708254039288,
-0.44409728050231934,
1.1495332717895508,
0.07731963694095612,
0.09538429975509644,
0.015250314958393574,
0.29313650727272034,
-0.16223077476024628,
0.41832756996154785,
0.4355883300304413,
0.7380053997039795,
0.6070942878723145,
-0.12426495552062988,
0.8881042003631592,
-0.15714578330516815,
0.20918215811252594,
0.7883461117744446,
-0.5338953137397766,
0.8766077160835266,
0.1555878072977066,
-0.27493706345558167,
0.7898696660995483,
0.40259793400764465,
0.23289084434509277,
0.2744654715061188,
-0.006716093979775906,
-0.28468722105026245,
-0.20076404511928558,
-0.03347830846905708,
-0.041883282363414764,
0.9920950531959534,
0.4490305185317993,
-0.7061274647712708,
0.0021419336553663015,
0.5866116881370544,
-0.10571536421775818,
0.35015514492988586,
-0.35797253251075745,
1.0656260251998901,
-0.024997150525450706,
-1.0965901613235474,
-0.14226152002811432,
0.45594847202301025,
0.3834926187992096,
-0.37765464186668396,
-0.4252557158470154,
-0.12870827317237854,
0.12770326435565948,
-0.19752506911754608,
-0.38206908106803894,
0.47279372811317444,
0.2765403389930725,
-0.570124626159668,
-0.004276453983038664,
0.9123938083648682,
-0.21195515990257263,
-1.066864013671875,
0.230961412191391,
0.36359676718711853,
-0.37122663855552673,
-0.10202361643314362,
-0.20072762668132782,
-0.07306516915559769,
-0.42784005403518677,
-0.36847978830337524,
0.15539105236530304,
0.43278172612190247,
-0.05645573511719704,
0.19833128154277802,
0.25645965337753296,
-0.027609005570411682,
0.1748177856206894,
-0.2705569863319397,
0.4873184561729431,
-0.7545197010040283,
-0.8203515410423279,
-0.8280398845672607,
0.5004905462265015,
-0.05221946910023689,
-0.4376180171966553,
0.6325380802154541,
0.46024468541145325,
0.7238358855247498,
-0.16316747665405273,
1.0638809204101562,
-0.025165807455778122,
0.7614802718162537,
-0.45458757877349854,
0.3151722550392151,
-0.27432605624198914,
0.14624467492103577,
-0.5692932605743408,
-0.9541923403739929,
-0.2878935635089874,
0.6770141124725342,
-0.3256416618824005,
0.3024742901325226,
1.1220223903656006,
0.3951551616191864,
0.23719850182533264,
0.10016073286533356,
0.22405651211738586,
0.01571306772530079,
-0.009655851870775223,
0.4308914840221405,
0.7382385730743408,
-0.4831213057041168,
0.14335523545742035,
-0.5436680912971497,
-0.5493956208229065,
-0.1963532567024231,
-0.5213828682899475,
-0.7847653031349182,
-0.6893636584281921,
-0.41217342019081116,
-0.12073154002428055,
0.16952809691429138,
1.0752171277999878,
0.3247152864933014,
-0.7495927214622498,
-0.19234409928321838,
0.10177120566368103,
-0.33709871768951416,
-0.6278144717216492,
-0.37832459807395935,
0.2138749361038208,
-0.6706699132919312,
-0.5798776149749756,
0.29344436526298523,
0.6641002893447876,
-0.22967161238193512,
-0.08842276781797409,
0.251852422952652,
-0.15993480384349823,
0.45649436116218567,
0.614700198173523,
-0.17945264279842377,
-0.6254962682723999,
-0.5823337435722351,
0.5036633014678955,
-0.13332846760749817,
0.02835642546415329,
0.8662185072898865,
-0.5443743467330933,
0.0896855816245079,
0.2872614860534668,
0.3633602559566498,
-0.3092675507068634,
0.19520339369773865,
0.34282127022743225,
-0.6039084196090698,
-0.21305647492408752,
0.21417537331581116,
0.5523834824562073,
0.1567261666059494,
-0.9474642276763916,
-0.07227562367916107,
0.48115938901901245,
-0.47505810856819153,
-0.28744012117385864,
-0.008927376940846443,
-0.6657683849334717,
-0.1438911259174347,
0.7983090281486511,
-0.5307676196098328,
-0.15715229511260986,
-0.4252200126647949,
-0.15716294944286346,
0.142404243350029,
-0.2590073347091675,
1.2482064962387085,
1.265030026435852,
-0.4176483154296875,
-0.08490990102291107,
-0.17167247831821442,
0.554652988910675,
0.5507895946502686,
-0.9281711578369141,
-0.2990984618663788,
0.6329129934310913,
0.16914339363574982,
0.5075589418411255,
0.49704572558403015,
-0.006869890261441469,
0.5689461827278137,
-0.10342255979776382,
-0.05349801108241081,
0.14100556075572968,
-0.8565511703491211,
-0.36633574962615967,
0.7010698914527893,
0.3822517693042755,
-0.16989947855472565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08811v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08811v1
|
Mixture-of-Skills: Learning to Optimize Data Usage for Fine-Tuning Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T05:01:28 | 2024-06-13T05:01:28 |
Minghao Wu, Thuy-Trang Vu, Lizhen Qu, Gholamreza Haffari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are typically fine-tuned on diverse and
extensive datasets sourced from various origins to develop a comprehensive
range of skills, such as writing, reasoning, chatting, coding, and more. Each
skill has unique characteristics, and these datasets are often heterogeneous
and imbalanced, making the fine-tuning process highly challenging. Balancing
the development of each skill while ensuring the model maintains its overall
performance requires sophisticated techniques and careful dataset curation. In
this work, we propose a general, model-agnostic, reinforcement learning
framework, Mixture-of-Skills (MoS), that learns to optimize data usage
automatically during the fine-tuning process. This framework ensures the
optimal comprehensive skill development of LLMs by dynamically adjusting the
focus on different datasets based on their current learning state. To validate
the effectiveness of MoS, we conduct extensive experiments using three diverse
LLM backbones on two widely used benchmarks and demonstrate that MoS
substantially enhances model performance. Building on the success of MoS, we
propose MoSpec, an adaptation for task-specific fine-tuning, which harnesses
the utilities of various datasets for a specific purpose. Our work underlines
the significance of dataset rebalancing and present MoS as a powerful, general
solution for optimizing data usage in the fine-tuning of LLMs for various
purposes.
|
[
-0.3674146831035614,
-0.7535229921340942,
0.33766648173332214,
0.07707665860652924,
-0.29557767510414124,
0.39019444584846497,
-0.41904327273368835,
-0.01309884525835514,
0.03629125654697418,
0.5915476679801941,
-0.7244296073913574,
-0.3934280574321747,
-0.5998923182487488,
-0.01095673069357872,
-0.3050612509250641,
1.034475326538086,
0.1735876053571701,
-0.010238121263682842,
-0.21437153220176697,
-0.1930302530527115,
-0.5847840905189514,
-0.32027480006217957,
-0.6219885945320129,
-0.4305513799190521,
0.6331391930580139,
0.7791825532913208,
0.47407346963882446,
0.806935727596283,
0.1113739013671875,
0.32451313734054565,
0.15770986676216125,
0.77314692735672,
-0.8834536671638489,
0.19975364208221436,
-0.510822057723999,
-0.4679567515850067,
-0.1579386591911316,
-0.2375018298625946,
0.5707381367683411,
0.7154234647750854,
-0.5130836367607117,
0.05661200359463692,
0.1696803718805313,
0.41513726115226746,
-0.7679763436317444,
0.02052205055952072,
-1.0555163621902466,
-0.1653609275817871,
-0.1898963749408722,
-0.431721955537796,
-0.2201201170682907,
-0.006121403072029352,
-0.053152550011873245,
-0.7320358753204346,
-0.013183281756937504,
0.14686141908168793,
0.549138605594635,
0.43039342761039734,
-0.3905373215675354,
-0.15015681087970734,
-0.7007381319999695,
1.129462480545044,
-0.6465778350830078,
0.2170877903699875,
0.25130873918533325,
0.2822733223438263,
-0.33802881836891174,
-0.12489940226078033,
-0.6345258355140686,
-0.08130000531673431,
0.2169586569070816,
-0.006641571410000324,
0.33962148427963257,
-0.13713325560092926,
0.09614741802215576,
0.548269510269165,
-0.3501625955104828,
0.6155895590782166,
-0.28457334637641907,
-0.043250855058431625,
0.7795735597610474,
0.5129896998405457,
0.2630310654640198,
0.38009002804756165,
-0.04676483944058418,
-0.27883222699165344,
-0.6993858814239502,
0.025169314816594124,
0.5318713188171387,
0.6450392007827759,
-0.05916134640574455,
0.6114639639854431,
-0.4094839096069336,
0.809671938419342,
0.08128093183040619,
-0.5619435906410217,
0.33616629242897034,
-0.337238609790802,
-0.21679207682609558,
-0.3261709213256836,
0.5477911233901978,
-0.009340396150946617,
0.3350379765033722,
-0.23808032274246216,
-0.45277467370033264,
-0.1044427677989006,
0.3428160548210144,
-0.4671266973018646,
-0.20257999002933502,
0.010339481756091118,
-0.030106650665402412,
-0.5319347381591797,
-0.14370302855968475,
-0.437305748462677,
-0.5659851431846619,
-0.7082361578941345,
0.3666892349720001,
-0.6212146282196045,
-0.2449013590812683,
0.44965752959251404,
-0.04138418659567833,
-0.056020431220531464,
0.30305856466293335,
-1.1426304578781128,
0.4599192142486572,
0.722605288028717,
0.533815324306488,
-0.5810102820396423,
-0.463065505027771,
-0.7996124029159546,
0.1143377497792244,
-0.23729157447814941,
0.5894373655319214,
-0.6639137864112854,
-0.41218841075897217,
0.053700387477874756,
-0.04184405878186226,
-0.17167901992797852,
-0.863460123538971,
0.4037325084209442,
-0.2483343780040741,
0.09351132810115814,
-0.2559511363506317,
-0.5685493350028992,
-0.08713693171739578,
0.09936710447072983,
-0.5285371541976929,
1.2256006002426147,
0.4266054630279541,
-0.3875512480735779,
0.6211565732955933,
-0.35637030005455017,
-0.8275036811828613,
-0.006060217972844839,
-0.21905343234539032,
-0.4853183925151825,
0.2739731967449188,
0.1289219707250595,
0.7223177552223206,
-0.28642940521240234,
0.251694917678833,
-0.41852042078971863,
-0.266080379486084,
0.14627856016159058,
-0.09322133660316467,
0.45079031586647034,
0.21428410708904266,
0.025663042441010475,
0.11037767678499222,
-0.91072016954422,
0.013198326341807842,
0.05186966806650162,
-0.4402192533016205,
-0.25680291652679443,
0.29778993129730225,
-0.08430062234401703,
0.3595484495162964,
0.12639065086841583,
-0.225514754652977,
0.11626722663640976,
-0.3735002875328064,
0.35766172409057617,
0.6675641536712646,
0.0045306989923119545,
0.4156374931335449,
-0.5386382937431335,
0.49584490060806274,
0.30428388714790344,
-0.13192586600780487,
-0.1025581881403923,
-0.07177326083183289,
-0.8734058737754822,
-0.41562768816947937,
0.12202579528093338,
0.6832014918327332,
-0.9628986716270447,
0.8536866307258606,
-0.037306368350982666,
-0.5823561549186707,
-0.4676540493965149,
0.5404400825500488,
0.2810114622116089,
0.370830237865448,
0.3489674925804138,
-0.29842954874038696,
-0.40321505069732666,
-0.8313944935798645,
0.023879079148173332,
0.31718534231185913,
0.09608439356088638,
0.35313934087753296,
0.4658760726451874,
-0.06633003056049347,
0.7358886003494263,
-0.4356943368911743,
-0.10319820046424866,
-0.4136117398738861,
0.05426075682044029,
0.14073988795280457,
0.4839431643486023,
0.4133419990539551,
-0.6426115036010742,
-0.2935658395290375,
0.3272128999233246,
-0.3828628659248352,
-0.25258588790893555,
-0.22427910566329956,
-0.16501064598560333,
-0.05864010006189346,
0.4070267975330353,
-0.10881612449884415,
-0.12796549499034882,
0.7071067690849304,
-0.16047458350658417,
0.7415341734886169,
-0.3626748025417328,
0.17394907772541046,
-0.9437764286994934,
0.0370965413749218,
0.15685240924358368,
-0.23781006038188934,
-0.4997543394565582,
-0.09678147733211517,
-0.046578314155340195,
-0.06910376995801926,
-0.39077338576316833,
0.6038212180137634,
-0.23568955063819885,
-0.04618743062019348,
-0.41524240374565125,
-0.018863292410969734,
-0.1012251153588295,
0.6351026892662048,
-0.03571104258298874,
0.986072838306427,
0.6250592470169067,
-0.9627192616462708,
0.3976544737815857,
0.0818771943449974,
-0.5234550833702087,
0.5446584820747375,
-0.3695046007633209,
-0.062495432794094086,
0.10415670275688171,
-0.19475428760051727,
-0.6677712798118591,
-0.2110169231891632,
-0.020745692774653435,
-0.05336758494377136,
0.21996334195137024,
-0.06628938764333725,
-0.6451864242553711,
-0.2556820511817932,
-0.04443243518471718,
0.02856604941189289,
0.3931691348552704,
-0.32849279046058655,
0.718505322933197,
0.607514500617981,
-0.22993595898151398,
-0.5916586518287659,
-0.4999253749847412,
-0.33982619643211365,
-0.3161228895187378,
-0.5922214984893799,
0.4697718620300293,
0.14745695888996124,
-0.09800615161657333,
-0.16942858695983887,
-0.16479520499706268,
-0.18689967691898346,
0.5198001265525818,
0.07347893714904785,
0.1866864264011383,
-0.014237512834370136,
0.17759154736995697,
0.41603949666023254,
-0.13777366280555725,
-0.41991424560546875,
-0.3410547971725464,
0.715242326259613,
0.1844578981399536,
-0.6130433678627014,
-0.09455838799476624,
0.08270231634378433,
0.631064772605896,
-0.28246381878852844,
0.889572024345398,
0.34761109948158264,
-0.09093368053436279,
-0.7288060784339905,
-0.5852490663528442,
-0.27180537581443787,
-0.5129206776618958,
0.6728197932243347,
-0.33245325088500977,
-1.1041762828826904,
0.6111189126968384,
-0.12524259090423584,
0.14634999632835388,
0.1850404441356659,
0.6991736888885498,
-0.1661178320646286,
0.9210549592971802,
0.7245670557022095,
-0.45054352283477783,
0.759552001953125,
-0.11219694465398788,
0.16411671042442322,
-0.5701084136962891,
-0.16230939328670502,
-0.442496120929718,
-0.4336232542991638,
-0.4144015312194824,
-0.6139672994613647,
0.23125888407230377,
-0.0424310564994812,
-0.299394816160202,
0.175456702709198,
-0.13796409964561462,
0.702703058719635,
0.4660987854003906,
0.24714873731136322,
0.2544664740562439,
0.16340605914592743,
-0.12154106050729752,
0.19918330013751984,
-0.955304741859436,
-0.2469182312488556,
1.0907561779022217,
0.19909553229808807,
0.7019662857055664,
-0.2555203437805176,
0.5269765853881836,
0.24164634943008423,
-0.2407427877187729,
-0.6602879762649536,
0.5098462104797363,
-0.6280882954597473,
-0.2745349705219269,
-0.43423187732696533,
-0.5458844900131226,
-0.6912426352500916,
0.3843492269515991,
-0.4823749363422394,
-0.43738114833831787,
0.12339401245117188,
0.424316942691803,
-0.4064061939716339,
0.31288766860961914,
-0.6065253019332886,
0.6619548201560974,
-0.47723251581192017,
-0.4728822112083435,
-0.716792643070221,
-0.28797048330307007,
0.2511615455150604,
-0.15972809493541718,
0.10855533927679062,
-0.22907936573028564,
-0.051115311682224274,
0.3850880265235901,
-0.23244529962539673,
0.8740435838699341,
-0.07221614569425583,
-0.1238529160618782,
0.09523006528615952,
0.08870237320661545,
0.5597438812255859,
-0.15971186757087708,
-0.21984276175498962,
-0.19562561810016632,
-0.18309243023395538,
-0.48183318972587585,
-0.6233007907867432,
0.7264435887336731,
-0.8262729048728943,
-0.2923172116279602,
-0.08960258960723877,
-0.5981675982475281,
-0.6503061652183533,
-0.035662755370140076,
-0.037009697407484055,
0.29241931438446045,
-0.2085384726524353,
0.4006722867488861,
1.0386477708816528,
-0.27116674184799194,
-0.00897896010428667,
0.6045527458190918,
-0.05085112527012825,
-0.3038633167743683,
1.3203542232513428,
-0.042634766548871994,
0.40702301263809204,
0.273375004529953,
0.050529785454273224,
-0.015145661309361458,
-0.8266920447349548,
-0.25685611367225647,
0.10748575627803802,
-0.4664517045021057,
-0.09387056529521942,
-0.4549783170223236,
-0.10806146264076233,
-0.07863876223564148,
-0.20050545036792755,
-0.33413103222846985,
-0.07652054727077484,
-0.3242092430591583,
-0.03094213455915451,
0.33036401867866516,
0.21733486652374268,
0.16487498581409454,
0.5914704203605652,
-0.6578521728515625,
0.22506500780582428,
0.3678961396217346,
0.3869786858558655,
-0.12513726949691772,
-0.6023770570755005,
-0.5183709263801575,
0.12707805633544922,
-0.30582326650619507,
-0.3551428020000458,
0.35782814025878906,
0.2685542404651642,
0.8664684891700745,
0.2944433391094208,
-0.4354194104671478,
0.6514216065406799,
-0.2697815001010895,
0.5491207838058472,
0.04518311470746994,
-0.8075131773948669,
0.4301881492137909,
-0.6078663468360901,
0.02764064259827137,
0.8652936220169067,
0.1876465380191803,
-0.595088541507721,
-0.3654029667377472,
-0.5891900658607483,
-0.7959486842155457,
0.7600589990615845,
0.03537192940711975,
0.16024743020534515,
0.1435222625732422,
0.2526269257068634,
0.43859779834747314,
0.5856835842132568,
-0.45346739888191223,
-0.0008568885968998075,
0.11761479824781418,
-0.41771355271339417,
-0.21593905985355377,
-0.08993963897228241,
-0.08661192655563354,
-0.37728768587112427,
0.9208108186721802,
-0.38489362597465515,
-0.34126272797584534,
-0.5952808856964111,
-0.4176779091358185,
0.07906483113765717,
0.20025286078453064,
0.38643762469291687,
0.6540769338607788,
0.11305943876504898,
-0.16225537657737732,
0.3457048833370209,
-0.30295485258102417,
0.08123400807380676,
-0.21755778789520264,
-0.06231001019477844,
-0.5512686371803284,
0.12348566204309464,
1.1480814218521118,
0.4382595121860504,
-1.017237901687622,
0.232351616024971,
0.47328752279281616,
-0.3021150529384613,
0.06850564479827881,
0.849031388759613,
0.014085867442190647,
0.192584827542305,
0.20356105268001556,
-0.06630456447601318,
-0.11367639154195786,
-0.60149747133255,
0.22923675179481506,
0.3370632827281952,
-0.023746097460389137,
-0.16883714497089386,
0.06309723854064941,
0.4670925736427307,
0.04398089647293091,
0.5356646180152893,
-0.2031201422214508,
-0.2946372628211975,
0.6495128273963928,
0.4352301061153412,
0.5445005893707275,
-0.2677280604839325,
0.2432725578546524,
0.0705789178609848,
0.13526394963264465,
-0.36628180742263794,
0.33629274368286133,
0.13942188024520874,
-1.0592559576034546,
-0.5621875524520874,
-0.6584799289703369,
-0.39581674337387085,
0.24395549297332764,
-0.40656763315200806,
0.5629603266716003,
-0.6040783524513245,
0.20536528527736664,
-0.19290649890899658,
0.14841151237487793,
-0.7242528200149536,
0.3926369547843933,
0.2710437774658203,
0.8169940114021301,
-1.2099286317825317,
1.0410069227218628,
0.5155839920043945,
-0.24468253552913666,
-0.6035252213478088,
-0.21092674136161804,
-0.0077961040660738945,
-1.0048837661743164,
0.40316042304039,
-0.23936142027378082,
-0.03329545632004738,
0.16278311610221863,
-0.4705857038497925,
-0.7471691370010376,
1.0864537954330444,
0.40174049139022827,
-0.7561736702919006,
0.2457749843597412,
0.16715680062770844,
0.4332636296749115,
-0.666539192199707,
0.01013639010488987,
0.8214818239212036,
0.22819972038269043,
0.11245157569646835,
-0.875573456287384,
-0.34798479080200195,
-0.08043547719717026,
0.004041928332298994,
0.18198712170124054,
-0.5122627019882202,
0.8379725813865662,
0.08200330287218094,
0.01274612732231617,
-0.21095505356788635,
0.535678505897522,
0.4584670960903168,
-0.022634344175457954,
0.7274612188339233,
0.7261725664138794,
0.9716430306434631,
0.006039225030690432,
0.7757449150085449,
-0.15095441043376923,
0.05053158849477768,
1.3269473314285278,
-0.5957649350166321,
0.7256457209587097,
0.4085332453250885,
-0.09152709692716599,
0.46219879388809204,
0.4124099910259247,
-0.1692884862422943,
0.7768427729606628,
0.341203510761261,
-0.3061054050922394,
-0.5198753476142883,
0.0417589396238327,
0.012743421830236912,
0.4003729820251465,
0.5544973611831665,
-0.17329201102256775,
-0.2458980530500412,
0.27937719225883484,
-0.2559947371482849,
0.26623958349227905,
-0.2914060950279236,
0.7879539132118225,
-0.09481439739465714,
-0.5283385515213013,
0.23365984857082367,
0.06640581041574478,
0.7816570997238159,
-0.816218376159668,
0.16424401104450226,
-0.08963587135076523,
0.12504874169826508,
-0.1097593829035759,
-0.8638401627540588,
0.1718844324350357,
-0.19034162163734436,
-0.3820060193538666,
-0.19455139338970184,
0.6983693838119507,
-0.6727411150932312,
-0.3359239101409912,
0.19146262109279633,
0.49929213523864746,
-0.3149184286594391,
-0.03904702141880989,
-0.7327616214752197,
0.03003798983991146,
0.10814659297466278,
-0.04056601598858833,
0.6842378973960876,
0.6700155735015869,
-0.026575833559036255,
1.018095850944519,
0.7618075609207153,
0.37104150652885437,
-0.011658742092549801,
0.12041984498500824,
1.0427733659744263,
-0.41359853744506836,
-0.5911962389945984,
-0.658213198184967,
0.6471649408340454,
-0.23032246530056,
-0.5288534164428711,
0.4717774987220764,
0.594890296459198,
1.0037826299667358,
-0.03597809746861458,
1.102041482925415,
0.0760316476225853,
0.6304336786270142,
-0.7039738893508911,
0.40941742062568665,
-0.7072561979293823,
0.20785559713840485,
0.06060563772916794,
-0.8589133024215698,
0.046674225479364395,
0.511284351348877,
-0.39883413910865784,
0.043278396129608154,
0.48863914608955383,
0.9452325105667114,
-0.35792306065559387,
-0.11954755336046219,
0.41473588347435,
-0.09289954602718353,
0.13862942159175873,
0.504063606262207,
0.5901263952255249,
0.021768540143966675,
0.08083982020616531,
-0.2687542736530304,
-0.18312443792819977,
-0.38151815533638,
-0.8750655055046082,
-0.8085263967514038,
-0.6851398348808289,
-0.33794593811035156,
-0.00963128823786974,
0.18569281697273254,
0.9832383394241333,
0.7711506485939026,
-0.8854613900184631,
-0.4626823365688324,
-0.031043892726302147,
0.039008770138025284,
-0.4096090495586395,
-0.13561077415943146,
-0.21532569825649261,
-0.5742014050483704,
-0.5484740138053894,
0.4834964871406555,
0.2643589377403259,
-0.03683798387646675,
-0.21068638563156128,
-0.12857773900032043,
-0.05701152980327606,
-0.008330130018293858,
0.5408666729927063,
0.33549872040748596,
-0.35174649953842163,
-0.01909898966550827,
-0.16543184220790863,
-0.18680384755134583,
-0.12087852507829666,
0.960123598575592,
-0.6923692226409912,
0.25353944301605225,
0.4673209488391876,
0.923098623752594,
0.30244511365890503,
-0.15894842147827148,
0.7778319120407104,
-0.8821526765823364,
0.403221070766449,
0.37526872754096985,
0.3980827331542969,
0.20744362473487854,
-0.2554425895214081,
0.29857513308525085,
0.14550670981407166,
-0.3803023397922516,
-0.8206526637077332,
0.15550439059734344,
-0.9139958024024963,
-0.3243516683578491,
1.1707245111465454,
0.12600761651992798,
0.022590968757867813,
-0.12604844570159912,
-0.21150828897953033,
0.17160914838314056,
-0.41176801919937134,
0.7865519523620605,
0.829312264919281,
0.13304607570171356,
-0.10847564786672592,
-0.47837281227111816,
0.32774558663368225,
0.6051392555236816,
-0.9720296859741211,
0.26138797402381897,
0.46946144104003906,
0.4490204453468323,
-0.2872622609138489,
0.3100658059120178,
0.1634448617696762,
0.05339901149272919,
-0.33033132553100586,
-0.0016604142729192972,
-0.22451072931289673,
-0.441520094871521,
-0.20904438197612762,
-0.005034810863435268,
0.043278343975543976,
-0.09973383694887161
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10292v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10292v1
|
Automatically Labeling $200B Life-Saving Datasets: A Large Clinical Trial Outcome Benchmark
| 2024-06-13T04:23:35 | 2024-06-13T04:23:35 |
Chufan Gao, Jathurshan Pradeepkumar, Trisha Das, Shivashankar Thati, Jimeng Sun
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The global cost of drug discovery and development exceeds $200 billion
annually. The main results of drug discovery and development are the outcomes
of clinical trials, which directly influence the regulatory approval of new
drug candidates and ultimately affect patient outcomes. Despite their
significance, large-scale, high-quality clinical trial outcome data are not
readily available to the public. Suppose a large clinical trial outcome dataset
is provided; machine learning researchers can potentially develop accurate
prediction models using past trials and outcome labels, which could help
prioritize and optimize therapeutic programs, ultimately benefiting patients.
This paper introduces Clinical Trial Outcome (CTO) dataset, the largest trial
outcome dataset with around 479K clinical trials, aggregating outcomes from
multiple sources of weakly supervised labels, minimizing the noise from
individual sources, and eliminating the need for human annotation. These
sources include large language model (LLM) decisions on trial-related
documents, news headline sentiments, stock prices of trial sponsors, trial
linkages across phases, and other signals such as patient dropout rates and
adverse events. CTO's labels show unprecedented agreement with supervised
clinical trial outcome labels from test split of the supervised TOP dataset,
with a 91 F1.
|
[
0.049667295068502426,
-0.2347348928451538,
0.5235366225242615,
0.2639974057674408,
-0.19304652512073517,
0.010179576463997364,
-0.02753034420311451,
-0.588516354560852,
-0.061437420547008514,
0.8080640435218811,
-0.062421493232250214,
-0.7800608277320862,
-0.8898510932922363,
0.02346290461719036,
-0.15254099667072296,
1.2148065567016602,
0.11307335644960403,
0.2337886542081833,
-0.005764129105955362,
-0.26137086749076843,
-0.36672982573509216,
-0.6227059364318848,
-0.740913450717926,
-0.2524280548095703,
0.8844983577728271,
0.2661318778991699,
0.6374613046646118,
0.969044029712677,
0.6944380402565002,
0.23731154203414917,
0.09515706449747086,
0.081837959587574,
-0.45816338062286377,
-0.15039753913879395,
0.1592644602060318,
-0.4556986093521118,
-0.6741671562194824,
0.22759632766246796,
0.12418651580810547,
0.8070158362388611,
-0.018446506932377815,
-0.12566137313842773,
-0.07293924689292908,
0.6532965302467346,
-0.6083943247795105,
0.24233821034431458,
-0.28448325395584106,
0.3666323721408844,
-0.19724170863628387,
-0.10896923393011093,
-0.5439011454582214,
-0.6985940933227539,
0.2900158762931824,
-0.8579724431037903,
0.13202671706676483,
0.1467556208372116,
0.7246161699295044,
0.308744877576828,
-0.6533262133598328,
-0.45631143450737,
-0.19315779209136963,
0.6893020272254944,
-0.5352017879486084,
0.02872539684176445,
0.329433798789978,
0.5019305348396301,
-0.45731961727142334,
-0.7303148508071899,
0.14065705239772797,
-0.135422021150589,
-0.11535217612981796,
0.13896793127059937,
0.11287260800600052,
0.34396401047706604,
0.13962192833423615,
0.31351473927497864,
-0.35537195205688477,
0.19144077599048615,
-0.32361704111099243,
-0.4154173731803894,
0.7989218831062317,
0.2934996485710144,
0.12867064774036407,
0.05334610864520073,
-0.34097373485565186,
-0.18689434230327606,
-0.6651141047477722,
-0.035180505365133286,
-0.1738266795873642,
0.5403835773468018,
0.06949061900377274,
0.49907633662223816,
-0.3835999071598053,
0.5653632283210754,
-0.019899219274520874,
-0.10199978202581406,
0.4641653299331665,
-0.3964662551879883,
-0.326254278421402,
0.4722556471824646,
0.8058527112007141,
0.6071803569793701,
0.12143471091985703,
-0.34409210085868835,
0.17913921177387238,
0.02294778823852539,
0.15675605833530426,
-0.8562905788421631,
-0.16659797728061676,
0.6526781916618347,
-0.5651005506515503,
-0.30366232991218567,
-0.1744474470615387,
-0.7057594656944275,
-0.8433924913406372,
-0.2533332109451294,
0.6199352741241455,
-0.37892457842826843,
0.20319519937038422,
0.19311358034610748,
-0.37350812554359436,
-0.1751357764005661,
0.5797240138053894,
-0.2568490505218506,
-0.05787164717912674,
0.6545098423957825,
0.7936699986457825,
-0.24558627605438232,
-0.004953972063958645,
-0.8690243363380432,
0.1192069873213768,
-0.4030686020851135,
0.7520351409912109,
-0.36714795231819153,
-0.6457758545875549,
0.12987644970417023,
0.29023873805999756,
0.1692589372396469,
-0.5727878212928772,
0.6236381530761719,
-0.3681853711605072,
0.04900762066245079,
-0.3663845956325531,
-0.7517625093460083,
0.03729867935180664,
-0.049967411905527115,
-0.6788433194160461,
0.33463069796562195,
-0.013845527544617653,
-0.5859801173210144,
0.9620085954666138,
-0.5323449373245239,
-0.5298181772232056,
0.49804192781448364,
0.0023736136499792337,
-0.6937771439552307,
0.24319130182266235,
0.13960392773151398,
0.337800532579422,
-0.19715888798236847,
0.73293536901474,
-0.5005543828010559,
-0.24023772776126862,
0.3394893705844879,
-0.012942821718752384,
0.7346782684326172,
0.4371506869792938,
-0.19892609119415283,
-0.1628718078136444,
-0.8278382420539856,
-0.08084742724895477,
-0.15907253324985504,
-0.5016994476318359,
-0.3562730550765991,
-0.21905872225761414,
0.09440924972295761,
0.14535896480083466,
0.14589814841747284,
-0.6266732215881348,
0.09551401436328888,
0.05179055780172348,
0.30363407731056213,
0.663719117641449,
0.14206208288669586,
0.06399868428707123,
-0.12000028043985367,
0.45118874311447144,
0.12261153012514114,
0.6815072298049927,
0.004157932475209236,
-0.626617431640625,
-0.36598363518714905,
-0.49200159311294556,
0.6544523239135742,
0.3101840913295746,
-0.08759481459856033,
0.447265625,
-0.15885385870933533,
-0.22447392344474792,
-0.4870409667491913,
-0.19786448776721954,
0.4611067771911621,
0.5786425471305847,
0.1812572479248047,
-0.14370934665203094,
-0.5730993747711182,
-1.2807996273040771,
-0.3909189999103546,
0.0512276217341423,
-0.027462059631943703,
0.13153357803821564,
0.51591956615448,
-0.14110104739665985,
0.8194865584373474,
-0.7966881394386292,
-0.702607274055481,
0.161101296544075,
0.3283829689025879,
0.2917032241821289,
0.43249964714050293,
0.07678451389074326,
-0.7639901041984558,
-0.26675406098365784,
0.024565573781728745,
-0.7741459608078003,
-0.17147909104824066,
-0.2646854817867279,
-0.37718382477760315,
0.04484241455793381,
0.26230645179748535,
-0.15181078016757965,
0.4470643401145935,
0.2872520983219147,
-0.27431073784828186,
0.10849357396364212,
-0.5552812814712524,
0.34934139251708984,
-0.5808752179145813,
0.35433655977249146,
0.15846674144268036,
0.07419688999652863,
-0.32104310393333435,
-0.659931480884552,
0.25650474429130554,
0.019374726340174675,
-0.32367944717407227,
0.5330994129180908,
-0.27171605825424194,
0.1229376271367073,
-0.1558222621679306,
-0.03802609443664551,
0.011649121530354023,
0.07827289402484894,
0.20203246176242828,
0.633339524269104,
0.07900695502758026,
-0.4324992895126343,
0.05682816728949547,
0.4853062927722931,
-0.3976196050643921,
0.43612295389175415,
-0.6258825659751892,
-0.3063679337501526,
0.009245608933269978,
0.5327340364456177,
-0.6868254542350769,
-0.49378079175949097,
-0.03783341497182846,
-0.4978882074356079,
0.12105520814657211,
-0.2530335485935211,
-0.43710270524024963,
-0.5095111727714539,
-0.247767373919487,
0.03670935705304146,
0.40870532393455505,
-0.33898407220840454,
0.2870692014694214,
0.8734137415885925,
-0.13624785840511322,
-0.6184107661247253,
-0.9002096652984619,
0.3112863004207611,
-0.215289905667305,
-0.1882116049528122,
-0.03732747584581375,
-0.029340244829654694,
0.04318073391914368,
-0.03330099582672119,
0.3088344633579254,
0.015295210294425488,
-0.11043870449066162,
0.7372379302978516,
0.30021509528160095,
-0.02895711362361908,
0.5014442801475525,
0.062366798520088196,
-0.5288525223731995,
0.1848205178976059,
-0.32448503375053406,
-0.023265589028596878,
0.10173070430755615,
-0.02597411535680294,
-0.31682243943214417,
0.37783482670783997,
0.2558481991291046,
-0.004893211182206869,
0.7304733395576477,
0.11927521228790283,
-0.5228093266487122,
0.05860352888703346,
-0.3778770864009857,
0.2810710370540619,
-0.371224045753479,
0.15867979824543,
-0.08871117979288101,
-0.4928273558616638,
0.3478412330150604,
-0.2882835566997528,
0.1056586280465126,
0.5675423741340637,
0.36653587222099304,
-0.020618410781025887,
1.134806513786316,
0.25699418783187866,
0.08398277312517166,
0.16132494807243347,
-0.09067963808774948,
0.18844790756702423,
-0.5974113345146179,
-0.38467854261398315,
-0.45287054777145386,
-0.2934623956680298,
-0.6902521848678589,
-0.3798568546772003,
0.7964547276496887,
-0.1707935333251953,
-0.18455684185028076,
0.1872849464416504,
-0.9385073781013489,
0.20407693088054657,
0.788216769695282,
0.4178553819656372,
0.6328446865081787,
-0.18204018473625183,
0.11530125141143799,
-0.14897193014621735,
-0.46656307578086853,
-0.4055353105068207,
1.6331804990768433,
0.0703117847442627,
0.3623979091644287,
-0.3787137567996979,
0.6925003528594971,
0.7789904475212097,
0.6712011694908142,
-0.37666505575180054,
0.243212029337883,
-0.26189032196998596,
-0.7353116273880005,
-0.11345545202493668,
-0.3358263075351715,
-1.2290680408477783,
-0.058107227087020874,
-0.29917430877685547,
-0.5681859254837036,
0.46946537494659424,
0.22585974633693695,
-0.4926263689994812,
-0.2057875394821167,
-0.7364686131477356,
0.8255728483200073,
-0.45603421330451965,
-0.2153976708650589,
0.037816304713487625,
-0.7110152840614319,
0.25395673513412476,
-0.2925697863101959,
0.42512890696525574,
-0.012561479583382607,
-0.12040383368730545,
0.8403844833374023,
-0.5797624588012695,
0.5821507573127747,
-0.10954698175191879,
0.06002151593565941,
0.1924574077129364,
-0.2884119749069214,
0.5156248211860657,
0.12156090885400772,
-0.11538010835647583,
0.21732120215892792,
-0.07676442712545395,
-0.5181138515472412,
-0.10591869801282883,
0.7816203832626343,
-0.5546245574951172,
-0.18331216275691986,
-0.4955343008041382,
-0.6389495730400085,
-0.22721178829669952,
0.17504549026489258,
0.4235079288482666,
0.611411452293396,
-0.017286375164985657,
-0.03843133896589279,
0.493525892496109,
-0.7133009433746338,
-0.018377264961600304,
0.5762916803359985,
0.15658687055110931,
-1.1396499872207642,
0.7692995667457581,
0.3288370370864868,
0.02130001224577427,
0.3047026991844177,
0.2669987082481384,
-0.365617960691452,
-0.7772032618522644,
-0.11394578218460083,
0.25894248485565186,
-0.8065388798713684,
-0.21015985310077667,
-0.9179853200912476,
0.06093784049153328,
-0.3623283803462982,
-0.38401567935943604,
-0.33845120668411255,
-0.31802064180374146,
0.038716431707143784,
-0.12767250835895538,
0.28569552302360535,
0.6018081307411194,
-0.31408387422561646,
0.34893423318862915,
-0.6848888397216797,
0.29374387860298157,
-0.0277913436293602,
0.31043583154678345,
-0.2850840985774994,
-0.1962256133556366,
-0.4819943308830261,
0.13865645229816437,
-0.23389847576618195,
-0.4032794237136841,
0.340532511472702,
0.04422434791922569,
0.5247746109962463,
0.5279480218887329,
0.4503352642059326,
0.5218697786331177,
-0.11602868884801865,
0.39444997906684875,
0.3124370574951172,
-0.601780354976654,
0.838377833366394,
-0.4785291850566864,
0.19908246397972107,
0.6954634785652161,
0.1756240278482437,
-0.48538127541542053,
-0.20780585706233978,
-0.6716944575309753,
-0.9151142239570618,
0.7252898216247559,
0.08724746108055115,
-0.573907196521759,
-0.05029449984431267,
0.23151913285255432,
0.5001636743545532,
0.25458964705467224,
-0.3107210695743561,
-0.20976991951465607,
0.19356675446033478,
-0.5906459093093872,
-0.13236181437969208,
0.08909070491790771,
-0.5787090063095093,
0.027645312249660492,
0.7301979660987854,
-0.2741592228412628,
0.1287868767976761,
0.11309769749641418,
-0.11410437524318695,
0.052194248884916306,
0.017668262124061584,
0.2984570562839508,
0.5558115839958191,
-0.5348741412162781,
-0.03759514167904854,
-0.03276367858052254,
-0.47065469622612,
0.017990652471780777,
0.36333250999450684,
-0.1391344964504242,
-0.34044185280799866,
0.44929054379463196,
0.38744106888771057,
-0.06529094278812408,
-1.0374971628189087,
0.33959630131721497,
-0.1323709338903427,
-0.24099047482013702,
-0.17576615512371063,
0.015929291024804115,
0.03304975479841232,
0.2094748318195343,
0.572858452796936,
-0.16685868799686432,
0.5633928775787354,
-0.21009284257888794,
0.41970136761665344,
0.23274487257003784,
-0.5525925159454346,
0.1493547558784485,
0.8284624814987183,
0.35528770089149475,
-0.034221671521663666,
0.5698369741439819,
0.38161325454711914,
-0.1967487335205078,
1.0990060567855835,
0.04467753693461418,
0.6888125538825989,
0.25723743438720703,
0.48715102672576904,
0.43920570611953735,
-0.045265477150678635,
-0.1789749413728714,
-0.11577679216861725,
0.18764472007751465,
-0.08695369213819504,
-0.1390841156244278,
-0.4438048005104065,
-0.7431689500808716,
0.1807652711868286,
-0.5250605940818787,
0.33265620470046997,
-0.37788113951683044,
-0.3446219563484192,
0.3534966707229614,
0.2952615022659302,
-0.5340381264686584,
0.650468111038208,
0.2457420527935028,
0.7531479001045227,
-0.7943956255912781,
0.6010462641716003,
0.4051039516925812,
-0.36361163854599,
-0.1762671321630478,
-0.6188356280326843,
0.10753154009580612,
-0.8067089915275574,
0.7937118411064148,
0.40815863013267517,
0.2468966543674469,
-0.3503568768501282,
-0.5959154963493347,
-0.7117969989776611,
1.0389341115951538,
0.1498417854309082,
-0.6845843195915222,
0.15677742660045624,
0.554114043712616,
0.6740074157714844,
-0.47564008831977844,
0.33103182911872864,
0.464449942111969,
0.633101761341095,
0.11466465890407562,
-0.5478855967521667,
0.203830748796463,
-0.02667173184454441,
-0.16707855463027954,
0.3822903335094452,
-0.6536697745323181,
0.40653058886528015,
-0.4861066937446594,
-0.15416410565376282,
0.054085683077573776,
0.24300362169742584,
0.25747644901275635,
0.8227532505989075,
0.1604505479335785,
0.5215114951133728,
0.6762755513191223,
-0.43753209710121155,
0.9169069528579712,
-0.28087520599365234,
0.3237255811691284,
0.9055143594741821,
-0.158341184258461,
0.37641704082489014,
0.17587076127529144,
-0.43984973430633545,
-0.28440213203430176,
0.8342964053153992,
-0.1603582203388214,
0.7139286398887634,
0.32439741492271423,
-0.06507516652345657,
-0.6002032160758972,
-0.4238326847553253,
-0.5133787393569946,
-0.04081057757139206,
0.4958436191082001,
-0.7285534143447876,
-0.06001300364732742,
0.23416540026664734,
0.10611727088689804,
-0.23707862198352814,
0.12729433178901672,
0.5612460374832153,
0.12152912467718124,
-0.5886063575744629,
0.3321911692619324,
-0.6167169213294983,
0.25173479318618774,
-0.5554466843605042,
-0.0158950574696064,
-0.3374955952167511,
0.718824028968811,
-0.2567916512489319,
-0.6914752125740051,
-0.07675879448652267,
-0.2543913722038269,
0.016917608678340912,
0.008552665822207928,
0.114412322640419,
-0.2559530436992645,
-0.6620960235595703,
0.4731059968471527,
0.018679538741707802,
0.12320448458194733,
-0.034536220133304596,
-0.6890712976455688,
0.3114975690841675,
-0.15312327444553375,
-0.20857836306095123,
0.5487785339355469,
0.51808100938797,
0.01534762978553772,
0.7600852251052856,
0.4123879075050354,
0.3184555172920227,
-0.22653697431087494,
-0.2122494876384735,
0.6834807991981506,
-0.7009117603302002,
-0.2994435727596283,
-0.30992287397384644,
0.5150576829910278,
-0.457579642534256,
-0.6895048022270203,
0.3373277485370636,
0.8453440070152283,
0.1502457708120346,
0.20704148709774017,
0.9809290170669556,
0.16568921506404877,
0.5122107267379761,
-0.24978062510490417,
0.6003822684288025,
-0.5902578234672546,
0.07604528963565826,
-0.04743563383817673,
-0.13894066214561462,
-0.6044725179672241,
-0.06422927230596542,
-0.4545849859714508,
-0.10057938098907471,
0.38786208629608154,
0.3653843104839325,
0.28823477029800415,
0.16222620010375977,
0.16119730472564697,
0.30659937858581543,
0.5356506705284119,
0.8561921715736389,
0.2841653823852539,
-0.7594903111457825,
0.6678875684738159,
-0.1888183355331421,
-0.596451461315155,
-0.45986801385879517,
-0.8145100474357605,
-0.6445438861846924,
-0.4192776679992676,
-0.7224156260490417,
-0.46987906098365784,
0.5531899929046631,
0.7004700303077698,
0.8706562519073486,
-1.18607497215271,
0.033026572316884995,
0.08717218041419983,
-0.13769137859344482,
-0.2554439604282379,
-0.18343330919742584,
0.7402428388595581,
-0.4277370274066925,
-0.6911690831184387,
0.02122388780117035,
0.3823285400867462,
-0.20537115633487701,
0.48410627245903015,
-0.14857551455497742,
-0.08615481853485107,
-0.23793430626392365,
0.39800602197647095,
0.27907854318618774,
-0.4925546646118164,
0.0742221400141716,
-0.24376128613948822,
-0.3586389720439911,
0.16136999428272247,
0.6437000632286072,
-0.8324627876281738,
0.6872300505638123,
0.22400499880313873,
0.7216434478759766,
0.3459763824939728,
0.053476978093385696,
0.9958516359329224,
0.22554291784763336,
-0.062483012676239014,
0.0990140289068222,
0.24855855107307434,
0.15022456645965576,
-0.6005052924156189,
0.7542981505393982,
0.16713306307792664,
-0.8197354674339294,
-0.6470466256141663,
-0.3692803382873535,
-0.841801643371582,
-0.26354169845581055,
0.7703374624252319,
-0.2135765701532364,
-0.22985567152500153,
-0.27197155356407166,
-0.14288301765918732,
0.4261050820350647,
-0.6871016621589661,
1.028179407119751,
0.5558378100395203,
-0.40380433201789856,
0.10264815390110016,
-0.7408468127250671,
0.5406691431999207,
0.20496134459972382,
-1.0381412506103516,
0.35922685265541077,
0.7924759387969971,
0.05857256427407265,
-0.005192722659558058,
0.32029780745506287,
-0.21339519321918488,
0.09811795502901077,
0.03857851028442383,
0.3450576364994049,
-0.0798960030078888,
-0.07183807343244553,
-0.23253388702869415,
0.27798548340797424,
-0.3142857849597931,
-0.5566619634628296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08796v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08796v1
|
Deep Exploration of Cross-Lingual Zero-Shot Generalization in Instruction Tuning
| 2024-06-13T04:10:17 | 2024-06-13T04:10:17 |
Janghoon Han, Changho Lee, Joongbo Shin, Stanley Jungkyu Choi, Honglak Lee, Kynghoon Bae
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning has emerged as a powerful technique, significantly
boosting zero-shot performance on unseen tasks. While recent work has explored
cross-lingual generalization by applying instruction tuning to multilingual
models, previous studies have primarily focused on English, with a limited
exploration of non-English tasks. For an in-depth exploration of cross-lingual
generalization in instruction tuning, we perform instruction tuning
individually for two distinct language meta-datasets. Subsequently, we assess
the performance on unseen tasks in a language different from the one used for
training. To facilitate this investigation, we introduce a novel non-English
meta-dataset named "KORANI" (Korean Natural Instruction), comprising 51 Korean
benchmarks. Moreover, we design cross-lingual templates to mitigate
discrepancies in language and instruction-format of the template between
training and inference within the cross-lingual setting. Our experiments reveal
consistent improvements through cross-lingual generalization in both English
and Korean, outperforming baseline by average scores of 20.7\% and 13.6\%,
respectively. Remarkably, these enhancements are comparable to those achieved
by monolingual instruction tuning and even surpass them in some tasks. The
result underscores the significance of relevant data acquisition across
languages over linguistic congruence with unseen tasks during instruction
tuning.
|
[
-0.2137502282857895,
-0.7852298617362976,
0.14558544754981995,
0.05617917701601982,
-0.24883639812469482,
0.10304562747478485,
-0.6258188486099243,
-0.24394026398658752,
0.1446872502565384,
0.29943010210990906,
-0.6007769703865051,
-0.9454898238182068,
-0.4872909486293793,
-0.023704148828983307,
0.2771446108818054,
0.9483576416969299,
-0.027429452165961266,
0.4813748300075531,
0.007415254600346088,
-0.27309563755989075,
-0.9632788300514221,
-0.18705110251903534,
-0.3173893392086029,
-0.49276021122932434,
0.5060225129127502,
0.9445615410804749,
0.504923939704895,
0.8190762996673584,
0.006280925124883652,
0.20032170414924622,
0.31070566177368164,
0.13386490941047668,
-0.5165461301803589,
0.034066177904605865,
-0.4551842510700226,
-0.7725793719291687,
-0.37073156237602234,
-0.02060200832784176,
0.7596610188484192,
0.9170961976051331,
0.15698660910129547,
0.264211505651474,
-0.04023027420043945,
0.7897277474403381,
-0.9285158514976501,
0.2052786946296692,
-0.48348385095596313,
0.49723726511001587,
-0.21137160062789917,
-0.354828417301178,
-0.6373565196990967,
-0.009082227945327759,
-0.11583374440670013,
-0.984005868434906,
0.4956267476081848,
-0.2088148593902588,
0.7016581892967224,
0.16221842169761658,
-0.547272801399231,
-0.2655417025089264,
-0.662316620349884,
0.9805113077163696,
-0.40264248847961426,
0.7109355926513672,
0.3988741338253021,
0.2772963047027588,
0.2925289273262024,
-0.23244735598564148,
0.002353464951738715,
-0.1052917093038559,
-0.24192170798778534,
0.3483762741088867,
-0.09543441236019135,
0.1986202746629715,
0.22664594650268555,
0.408689945936203,
-0.7748980522155762,
0.3072517514228821,
-0.3399335443973541,
-0.25482043623924255,
0.6184869408607483,
0.045664142817258835,
0.48108822107315063,
0.007600840181112289,
-0.05068432167172432,
-0.2322368025779724,
-0.6965231895446777,
0.15644603967666626,
0.5826385617256165,
0.3453778624534607,
-0.30612611770629883,
0.5821365714073181,
-0.6385787725448608,
0.9731625914573669,
0.43661361932754517,
0.005809663329273462,
0.2572116255760193,
-0.5326961874961853,
-0.12824492156505585,
0.47235673666000366,
0.565184473991394,
0.45371389389038086,
0.5753052234649658,
-0.5165542364120483,
0.3002716302871704,
0.16050373017787933,
0.12654520571231842,
-0.7409412860870361,
-0.3629043996334076,
-0.2747901678085327,
-0.08650177717208862,
0.07496675848960876,
-0.04885895177721977,
-0.9199717044830322,
0.058022838085889816,
-0.41542157530784607,
0.28299495577812195,
-0.3433997631072998,
-0.2487337291240692,
0.1691286563873291,
-0.012858153320848942,
0.4770074188709259,
-0.2147051990032196,
-1.247461199760437,
-0.010033156722784042,
0.7850134372711182,
0.5456388592720032,
0.16119647026062012,
-0.43822887539863586,
-0.7456509470939636,
0.11881427466869354,
-0.9243135452270508,
0.6213037967681885,
-0.9960148930549622,
-0.36689478158950806,
-0.03617287054657936,
0.2826726734638214,
-0.5589366555213928,
-0.4750189483165741,
0.3319658935070038,
-0.4319998621940613,
0.48259198665618896,
-0.2720840573310852,
-0.5278607606887817,
-0.35535192489624023,
0.21727649867534637,
-0.5250177383422852,
1.0575405359268188,
0.16652408242225647,
-0.43795910477638245,
0.750745415687561,
-0.6447310447692871,
-0.6091884970664978,
-0.0033287624828517437,
-0.19960258901119232,
-0.1871800571680069,
0.46109434962272644,
0.3397022485733032,
0.2720280885696411,
-0.039156224578619,
-0.06667479127645493,
-0.04095419496297836,
-0.6933144330978394,
-0.3200327754020691,
-0.3317506015300751,
0.5354980826377869,
-0.2206641137599945,
-0.6715835332870483,
-0.1693008840084076,
-0.7522461414337158,
0.6844815015792847,
-0.1832704097032547,
-0.2755965292453766,
-0.6128541231155396,
-0.50445157289505,
-0.579738974571228,
0.11561667174100876,
0.18805810809135437,
-0.61946702003479,
0.24986691772937775,
-0.595639169216156,
-0.045468974858522415,
0.35468465089797974,
0.0004809885867871344,
0.9272229075431824,
-0.024970917031168938,
0.9443680047988892,
-0.04074438288807869,
-0.013537370599806309,
-0.5905418992042542,
-0.30353862047195435,
-0.8991065621376038,
-0.1260484755039215,
0.6489044427871704,
0.8691460490226746,
-1.0525197982788086,
0.11944447457790375,
-0.2918972969055176,
-0.5037830471992493,
-0.9411701560020447,
0.3133765757083893,
1.1224381923675537,
0.5081489682197571,
0.3615356385707855,
-0.019296977669000626,
-0.42704033851623535,
-0.8985556960105896,
-0.6319494843482971,
0.40117329359054565,
-0.0951886996626854,
0.4736287295818329,
0.19678404927253723,
0.007161656394600868,
0.4240800142288208,
-0.4009721875190735,
0.004224162083119154,
-0.13656461238861084,
0.4162101745605469,
0.23766213655471802,
0.4816935360431671,
0.5066103935241699,
-0.514847457408905,
-1.1660430431365967,
0.5128481388092041,
-0.8144901990890503,
-0.2585643231868744,
-0.022190263494849205,
-0.3637385368347168,
0.6128723621368408,
0.4911056458950043,
-0.22482313215732574,
0.21907097101211548,
0.6136659979820251,
-0.3763295114040375,
0.4090988039970398,
-0.3177514672279358,
0.44576171040534973,
-0.8762299418449402,
-0.11033590883016586,
-0.27608558535575867,
-0.006483977660536766,
-0.774095892906189,
0.23202113807201385,
0.38965073227882385,
-0.12061617523431778,
-0.38022685050964355,
0.46489524841308594,
-0.8050500750541687,
-0.1099584773182869,
-0.1619202345609665,
-0.07635220140218735,
0.1011245846748352,
0.7102248668670654,
0.14076390862464905,
0.8110572695732117,
0.847323477268219,
-0.4139934480190277,
0.10741901397705078,
-0.16760340332984924,
-0.3191274106502533,
0.7603229284286499,
-0.68947833776474,
0.2803650498390198,
-0.10303066670894623,
-0.19454534351825714,
-0.7232552170753479,
-0.12208840250968933,
0.4103347957134247,
-0.3826039731502533,
0.7472052574157715,
-0.5226291418075562,
-0.26259946823120117,
0.2431897521018982,
-0.19474326074123383,
0.5492774844169617,
0.3509959280490875,
-0.3229982256889343,
0.40596628189086914,
-0.08537602424621582,
-0.0168363768607378,
-0.8579713106155396,
-0.5885699391365051,
-0.16069334745407104,
-0.12170123308897018,
-0.3533324897289276,
0.2415139079093933,
0.03673676401376724,
-0.0038895951583981514,
-0.0014567243633791804,
-0.40412676334381104,
0.06729148328304291,
-0.20425383746623993,
-0.015007962472736835,
0.24697312712669373,
-0.5393968224525452,
0.14975646138191223,
0.43793052434921265,
-0.3944627642631531,
-0.07663830369710922,
-0.44181790947914124,
0.5188906192779541,
0.040702592581510544,
-0.4535689651966095,
-0.28976717591285706,
0.3575964570045471,
0.27393221855163574,
-0.17451536655426025,
0.4820173978805542,
0.7780697345733643,
0.05410231277346611,
-0.24725452065467834,
-0.28966566920280457,
-0.06438525021076202,
-0.465749055147171,
0.40127071738243103,
-0.3513045012950897,
-0.6996598839759827,
0.29597869515419006,
0.003156310645863414,
0.08752602338790894,
0.24682368338108063,
0.2274206578731537,
0.08691567182540894,
1.1364483833312988,
0.7992600798606873,
-0.022549761459231377,
0.5543034672737122,
-0.4113672077655792,
0.13346627354621887,
-0.6867730021476746,
-0.30241063237190247,
-0.3789293169975281,
-0.5025319457054138,
-0.8876168727874756,
-0.521561861038208,
0.39571261405944824,
0.1746927946805954,
-0.12555208802223206,
0.2749396562576294,
-0.41682618856430054,
0.9515948295593262,
0.6142003536224365,
-0.005268786568194628,
0.19522742927074432,
0.15587486326694489,
-0.3232174515724182,
-0.32358497381210327,
-1.0737078189849854,
-0.1307501196861267,
1.2979600429534912,
-0.25478535890579224,
0.6350631713867188,
-0.3372061550617218,
0.7789885401725769,
0.010649630799889565,
-0.027829734608530998,
-0.6392318606376648,
0.35335034132003784,
-0.5200070738792419,
-0.5423246026039124,
-0.3936215341091156,
-0.6053658127784729,
-1.063062071800232,
0.3751071095466614,
-0.03241420537233353,
-0.43059688806533813,
0.10003374516963959,
0.25801312923431396,
-0.146438866853714,
0.0908958688378334,
-1.0435748100280762,
1.2108128070831299,
-0.38971444964408875,
-0.5425484776496887,
-0.18995685875415802,
-0.5198654532432556,
0.24981683492660522,
0.17565518617630005,
0.1070411428809166,
0.09838192164897919,
-0.14469163119792938,
0.39460527896881104,
0.11027469485998154,
0.8616984486579895,
-0.3079438805580139,
-0.2731436491012573,
0.001364673487842083,
0.02963140793144703,
0.22326987981796265,
0.09650317579507828,
0.058344338089227676,
0.36020198464393616,
-0.12899141013622284,
-0.7638086080551147,
-0.926792323589325,
0.7585465312004089,
-0.68501877784729,
-0.43847665190696716,
-0.13716287910938263,
-0.8037089705467224,
-0.32544323801994324,
0.4241342544555664,
0.5743736624717712,
0.48022371530532837,
-0.10683079063892365,
0.2282189428806305,
0.9179792404174805,
-0.24214641749858856,
0.22643524408340454,
1.0120913982391357,
0.05061272904276848,
-0.48381876945495605,
1.1811795234680176,
0.38914287090301514,
0.46300625801086426,
0.8254048228263855,
0.11992393434047699,
-0.20278805494308472,
-0.09469237178564072,
-1.0011451244354248,
0.16369470953941345,
-0.5275354385375977,
-0.09139101207256317,
-0.1682935208082199,
-0.010156689211726189,
-0.43604013323783875,
-0.2906323969364166,
-0.5195947289466858,
-0.4584009647369385,
-0.0989527627825737,
-0.07579249143600464,
-0.04120544344186783,
0.4925616383552551,
-0.09729345887899399,
0.09546326100826263,
-0.7149554491043091,
0.32725241780281067,
0.2659296989440918,
0.5202560424804688,
-0.20711807906627655,
-0.46303829550743103,
-0.6096739768981934,
0.5161409974098206,
-0.1431686133146286,
-0.6674375534057617,
0.15258748829364777,
0.5887492895126343,
0.6746930480003357,
0.46224913001060486,
0.029140247032046318,
0.8909056186676025,
-0.6916841864585876,
0.47271499037742615,
-0.021720757707953453,
-0.7750061750411987,
0.42691195011138916,
-0.2651049494743347,
0.7996435761451721,
0.5241443514823914,
0.547486424446106,
-0.6812156438827515,
-0.07661017030477524,
-0.37776196002960205,
-0.6611732244491577,
0.8961783647537231,
-0.1559072732925415,
0.3091980814933777,
0.18382509052753448,
0.1319797933101654,
0.3233184218406677,
0.24891361594200134,
-0.3665173053741455,
-0.3309970200061798,
-0.36751553416252136,
0.007970375940203667,
-0.3425706923007965,
0.06720540672540665,
-0.19813361763954163,
-0.3951689302921295,
0.547038197517395,
-0.2660175859928131,
0.006063227541744709,
-0.1638384759426117,
-0.31322526931762695,
-0.3144289553165436,
0.4675963521003723,
0.7469573616981506,
0.532844066619873,
0.23372529447078705,
0.0149686299264431,
0.36004117131233215,
-0.44648826122283936,
0.1034509614109993,
-0.03825842961668968,
-0.3822624087333679,
0.24701914191246033,
0.5841553807258606,
1.0806708335876465,
1.0156642198562622,
-0.44042643904685974,
0.06838737428188324,
0.12087134271860123,
-0.31486275792121887,
0.06319840252399445,
0.33931964635849,
-0.12010446935892105,
0.13766859471797943,
0.04271884635090828,
-0.24533456563949585,
-0.027452833950519562,
-0.598752498626709,
-0.08418989926576614,
0.42984896898269653,
-0.2985890209674835,
-0.555022120475769,
0.2964816391468048,
-0.09914746880531311,
-0.34833863377571106,
0.4927216172218323,
-0.353943407535553,
-0.38964658975601196,
0.5882365703582764,
0.6255025267601013,
0.8252770304679871,
-0.3627464771270752,
0.5429456830024719,
0.5116327404975891,
0.3568301200866699,
0.3113865852355957,
0.3957723379135132,
-0.5653499960899353,
-0.4415663480758667,
-0.4785827398300171,
-0.39302292466163635,
-0.36483171582221985,
-0.04963995888829231,
-0.9982157349586487,
0.19489984214305878,
0.004074040334671736,
0.35104894638061523,
-0.10010936856269836,
0.19505925476551056,
-0.6081908941268921,
0.04973430559039116,
-0.08348321914672852,
0.6898229718208313,
-1.046181082725525,
0.6684004664421082,
0.9934965968132019,
-0.08836890757083893,
-0.6547462940216064,
-0.019645078107714653,
-0.33151954412460327,
-0.8952168822288513,
0.4128594994544983,
0.11853896826505661,
-0.10235544294118881,
-0.15120255947113037,
-0.1962803155183792,
-0.7597950100898743,
1.0405195951461792,
0.6302418112754822,
-0.6475212574005127,
-0.10458986461162567,
0.6121521592140198,
0.7843032479286194,
-0.2634170949459076,
0.12047357857227325,
0.614408016204834,
0.518059253692627,
-0.015252257697284222,
-0.8025556802749634,
-0.2551005184650421,
-0.3781813383102417,
-0.17411229014396667,
0.4977993369102478,
-0.7162007093429565,
0.7710613012313843,
0.032155267894268036,
-0.2783753275871277,
-0.2799859941005707,
0.28495165705680847,
-0.023446645587682724,
0.6843045353889465,
0.1650797426700592,
0.6811006665229797,
0.48696470260620117,
-0.002537322696298361,
0.7419471144676208,
-0.6600008010864258,
0.073183074593544,
1.1818286180496216,
-0.12035965174436569,
0.3901710510253906,
0.22260355949401855,
0.1738930344581604,
0.6235549449920654,
0.418300986289978,
0.004908966366201639,
0.6172571778297424,
-0.19990436732769012,
-0.22563764452934265,
-0.3557003438472748,
-0.09420514851808548,
-0.4995086193084717,
0.7095577120780945,
0.24901774525642395,
-0.36384743452072144,
-0.5322901010513306,
0.14020439982414246,
0.2139367312192917,
0.14897887408733368,
-0.6240352988243103,
0.8427996635437012,
-0.2672879695892334,
-1.0321013927459717,
1.0209717750549316,
-0.0867793932557106,
0.5363223552703857,
-0.7138313055038452,
-0.3014824688434601,
-0.36032307147979736,
0.15768766403198242,
-0.10324416309595108,
-0.47173386812210083,
0.15689334273338318,
0.08102409541606903,
-0.404666543006897,
-0.3659464418888092,
0.5352849960327148,
-0.8368448615074158,
-0.6795242428779602,
0.3132181167602539,
0.4233763813972473,
0.18179985880851746,
0.22726233303546906,
-0.4201061725616455,
-0.19162055850028992,
-0.018383298069238663,
0.012907353229820728,
0.6249200701713562,
0.7227519154548645,
-0.13192839920520782,
0.17735037207603455,
0.4239008128643036,
0.08717570453882217,
0.44658857583999634,
-0.08412660658359528,
0.6841597557067871,
-0.40661588311195374,
-0.44967541098594666,
-0.6781774759292603,
0.37795644998550415,
-0.002952834591269493,
-0.4950813353061676,
1.0547477006912231,
0.7443022131919861,
1.4709070920944214,
-0.33898815512657166,
0.6476289629936218,
0.12721841037273407,
0.3626669943332672,
-0.7322495579719543,
0.6086830496788025,
-0.6243842244148254,
-0.1753585934638977,
-0.07576022297143936,
-0.7031399011611938,
0.004099048674106598,
0.3798130750656128,
-0.5898029804229736,
0.16582149267196655,
0.5986445546150208,
0.9423789381980896,
-0.3941793143749237,
-0.09265542775392532,
0.6204206347465515,
-0.12916387617588043,
-0.33887332677841187,
0.6550184488296509,
0.39328816533088684,
-0.4563133120536804,
0.5649919509887695,
-0.6593607068061829,
-0.16582903265953064,
-0.05324084311723709,
-0.7395208477973938,
-1.050065279006958,
-0.28107792139053345,
-0.07576074451208115,
0.27266085147857666,
0.3967624008655548,
0.4477868974208832,
0.7680913209915161,
-0.9541304111480713,
-0.3026423752307892,
-0.05690629035234451,
0.2610950767993927,
-0.546546220779419,
-0.24827323853969574,
0.1953141838312149,
-0.7124235033988953,
-0.9676610231399536,
0.7691869735717773,
0.20971743762493134,
-0.3180454671382904,
-0.06404399871826172,
-0.11004756391048431,
-0.039072029292583466,
-0.007823443040251732,
0.4919814169406891,
0.6415272355079651,
-0.3169116675853729,
-0.1438542753458023,
0.5197198390960693,
0.1419862061738968,
-0.03518807142972946,
1.0059525966644287,
-0.5938781499862671,
0.8737875819206238,
0.4286404252052307,
0.5001376867294312,
0.39828285574913025,
-0.06440538167953491,
0.7502050995826721,
-1.240755319595337,
0.24275462329387665,
-0.024748051539063454,
-0.021593496203422546,
0.24251922965049744,
-0.3223462700843811,
0.5948716998100281,
0.12273202836513519,
-0.449220210313797,
-0.8256105780601501,
0.2167496532201767,
-0.3499218225479126,
-0.10595989227294922,
0.9453983902931213,
-0.2967929542064667,
-0.06339669972658157,
0.013916651718318462,
-0.10878247767686844,
0.5127198696136475,
-0.10613934695720673,
0.8583489656448364,
0.8329699635505676,
-0.12918592989444733,
-0.13403154909610748,
-0.7016410231590271,
0.29192793369293213,
0.7409769296646118,
-0.549000084400177,
0.045585211366415024,
0.3631727695465088,
0.3234424889087677,
0.09050220996141434,
0.16854949295520782,
0.03989483043551445,
0.7751395106315613,
0.1327206790447235,
-0.18631881475448608,
-0.24574220180511475,
-0.676773726940155,
-0.5177467465400696,
-0.01040792278945446,
-0.3823922574520111,
-0.5872015953063965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10291v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10291v1
|
ResearchArena: Benchmarking LLMs' Ability to Collect and Organize Information as Research Agents
| 2024-06-13T03:26:30 | 2024-06-13T03:26:30 |
Hao Kang, Chenyan Xiong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable performance across
various tasks in natural language processing. Nevertheless, challenges still
arise when these tasks demand domain-specific expertise and advanced analytical
skills, such as conducting research surveys on a designated topic. In this
research, we develop ResearchArena, a benchmark that measures LLM agents'
ability to conduct academic surveys, an initial step of academic research
process. Specifically, we deconstructs the surveying process into three stages
1) information discovery: locating relevant papers, 2) information selection:
assessing papers' importance to the topic, and 3) information organization:
organizing papers into meaningful structures. In particular, we establish an
offline environment comprising 12.0M full-text academic papers and 7.9K survey
papers, which evaluates agents' ability to locate supporting materials for
composing the survey on a topic, rank the located papers based on their impact,
and organize these into a hierarchical knowledge mind-map. With this benchmark,
we conduct preliminary evaluations of existing techniques and find that all
LLM-based methods under-performing when compared to basic keyword-based
retrieval techniques, highlighting substantial opportunities for future
research.
|
[
-0.5825992226600647,
-0.706756055355072,
0.6654821038246155,
-0.07216019928455353,
0.05183351784944534,
0.44780826568603516,
-0.26196327805519104,
-0.5902209877967834,
0.38109612464904785,
0.09679018706083298,
-0.21375392377376556,
-0.6190137267112732,
-0.6432613134384155,
0.1697157770395279,
-0.5172857046127319,
0.9189488887786865,
-0.12737907469272614,
0.12269014120101929,
-0.5180584788322449,
-0.21621032059192657,
-0.04268267750740051,
-0.37048524618148804,
-0.9202526807785034,
-0.36053287982940674,
0.8298146724700928,
0.3101971447467804,
0.38811469078063965,
0.49664947390556335,
0.7601060271263123,
0.34708595275878906,
-0.2601029574871063,
0.4445222020149231,
-0.6630720496177673,
0.426482617855072,
-0.26222866773605347,
-0.8485811948776245,
-0.47299739718437195,
0.21495237946510315,
0.5543196797370911,
0.4448411166667938,
-0.16739097237586975,
0.5298852920532227,
0.10399075597524643,
0.47345227003097534,
-0.5887787342071533,
0.25978103280067444,
-0.5325620770454407,
-0.17905940115451813,
-0.5064114928245544,
-0.483197420835495,
-0.20961028337478638,
-0.7624521255493164,
0.05659881979227066,
-0.5996352434158325,
0.25061678886413574,
0.25347772240638733,
1.0227329730987549,
-0.012011812068521976,
-0.2675568163394928,
-0.3618637025356293,
-0.6915171146392822,
0.7004509568214417,
-0.49765926599502563,
0.05356062576174736,
0.5720557570457458,
0.43949106335639954,
-0.28799596428871155,
-0.8441640734672546,
-0.3658689260482788,
-0.33372244238853455,
0.13249732553958893,
0.03678314387798309,
-0.2654963731765747,
-0.19596287608146667,
-0.07698675245046616,
0.17759214341640472,
-0.4803876578807831,
0.06373702734708786,
-0.28978991508483887,
0.12192521244287491,
0.4795859158039093,
0.24844466149806976,
0.18859070539474487,
0.07893960177898407,
-0.11546316742897034,
-0.2693687975406647,
-0.5798878073692322,
0.03580634295940399,
0.3496360778808594,
0.41146746277809143,
0.28892168402671814,
0.6053388118743896,
0.057782646268606186,
0.4012366235256195,
-0.15960821509361267,
-0.03456054627895355,
0.0623164176940918,
-0.456211656332016,
-0.16347776353359222,
-0.2695217430591583,
0.7039233446121216,
0.09413371980190277,
0.12049221247434616,
-0.27444028854370117,
-0.12207437306642532,
0.06293348968029022,
0.6028367877006531,
-0.65806645154953,
-0.18545085191726685,
0.13456131517887115,
-0.4175754189491272,
-0.28061193227767944,
-0.26604586839675903,
-0.892679750919342,
-0.5084182024002075,
-0.2516110837459564,
0.40990543365478516,
-0.14734716713428497,
-0.43082377314567566,
-0.26035481691360474,
-0.017305687069892883,
0.12879328429698944,
0.2820930480957031,
-0.3703572452068329,
0.704348623752594,
0.7154363989830017,
0.9638077616691589,
-0.5108817219734192,
-0.25785383582115173,
-0.1109580248594284,
-0.18187043070793152,
-0.4316001236438751,
1.0979645252227783,
-0.5965059399604797,
-0.37562549114227295,
0.2529815137386322,
-0.28207287192344666,
-0.2629391551017761,
-0.7078940868377686,
0.7600601315498352,
-0.8923264145851135,
0.020341437309980392,
-0.3440495431423187,
-0.592643678188324,
-0.11052284389734268,
0.637242317199707,
-0.711491584777832,
1.274634838104248,
0.05750416964292526,
-0.6985522508621216,
0.2852241098880768,
-0.7344622611999512,
-0.03795623034238815,
-0.1355878859758377,
-0.34928688406944275,
-0.2856394648551941,
-0.030863160267472267,
-0.14345978200435638,
0.5109836459159851,
-0.7401761412620544,
0.11489108204841614,
-0.12528561055660248,
-0.23961979150772095,
0.5819719433784485,
0.00911286287009716,
0.5591540932655334,
0.20460356771945953,
-0.2929561734199524,
0.08869420737028122,
-0.8431044220924377,
-0.010590600781142712,
0.1441831886768341,
-0.40690597891807556,
-0.6887147426605225,
-0.04182598367333412,
0.09248938411474228,
-0.13839630782604218,
0.32964596152305603,
-0.5452524423599243,
0.19511443376541138,
-0.1062474399805069,
0.1448899656534195,
0.4103126525878906,
-0.08485300093889236,
0.26372483372688293,
-0.4793408215045929,
0.8340580463409424,
-0.34700819849967957,
-0.1408052146434784,
0.368339866399765,
-0.3917566239833832,
-0.8370049595832825,
-0.15803013741970062,
0.39528968930244446,
0.29310598969459534,
-0.5633400678634644,
0.19238798320293427,
-0.4880148470401764,
-0.8144331574440002,
-0.4704962372779846,
0.05910608172416687,
0.48252618312835693,
0.4008982181549072,
0.32446280121803284,
-0.23229435086250305,
-0.448188453912735,
-0.735740602016449,
-0.11987704783678055,
-0.3632490038871765,
0.04617470130324364,
0.0996352806687355,
0.6278727054595947,
0.020872224122285843,
0.8394721150398254,
-0.33486446738243103,
-0.6126770973205566,
-0.16750361025333405,
0.702302873134613,
0.13784372806549072,
0.026573995128273964,
0.33895450830459595,
-0.5869035124778748,
-0.11944536119699478,
0.06314241141080856,
-0.842941403388977,
-0.22321473062038422,
0.46256861090660095,
-0.39527156949043274,
-0.20292440056800842,
0.4205131530761719,
-0.8032667636871338,
0.37906932830810547,
0.34181833267211914,
-0.26591429114341736,
0.20540085434913635,
-0.046934109181165695,
0.3725460469722748,
-0.9893671870231628,
0.3655957281589508,
0.12626522779464722,
-0.046866752207279205,
-0.5930936932563782,
0.16574323177337646,
-0.07102762162685394,
0.09563687443733215,
-0.09377796202898026,
0.5609682202339172,
-0.7758832573890686,
-0.13213586807250977,
-0.5090107917785645,
0.4712705910205841,
0.09887098520994186,
0.21300332248210907,
-0.1525454819202423,
1.0013729333877563,
0.078519806265831,
-0.5831097960472107,
-0.10464363545179367,
0.2749003469944,
-0.6454841494560242,
0.6943008303642273,
-0.4353364408016205,
0.04790298640727997,
-0.2387162148952484,
0.1563812643289566,
-1.1232352256774902,
0.1216839924454689,
0.04068589210510254,
-0.5120676159858704,
0.07867030054330826,
-0.001659410772845149,
-0.53684002161026,
-0.09675996750593185,
-0.1997329294681549,
0.4134131073951721,
0.2663242816925049,
-0.1536588817834854,
0.9107228517532349,
0.6725649237632751,
-0.4098166525363922,
-0.47411850094795227,
-0.3795900344848633,
0.29945361614227295,
-0.3937400281429291,
-0.32291147112846375,
0.25859084725379944,
0.20450668036937714,
-0.6942101120948792,
0.14427439868450165,
0.018554387614130974,
-0.2453511655330658,
0.01649167574942112,
0.15261158347129822,
0.15899959206581116,
-0.2807615399360657,
0.1405576914548874,
-0.40625786781311035,
0.08094795048236847,
0.5310866236686707,
0.12719939649105072,
0.4347609579563141,
0.2422943413257599,
-0.2502983510494232,
-0.020634062588214874,
0.07762780040502548,
0.5255754590034485,
-0.43251651525497437,
0.4270075261592865,
0.268650621175766,
-0.24266768991947174,
-0.3469483554363251,
-0.7755277752876282,
-0.08895424753427505,
-0.3914065361022949,
0.17851458489894867,
-0.32016217708587646,
-0.7141454219818115,
0.6044371128082275,
-0.16442470252513885,
0.43477362394332886,
0.34962695837020874,
0.35771697759628296,
-0.0026269983500242233,
0.6561011075973511,
0.5426307320594788,
-0.21483732759952545,
0.2936231791973114,
-0.4120984673500061,
0.164890855550766,
-0.9024592041969299,
-0.3349287211894989,
-1.2506730556488037,
-0.45528072118759155,
-0.22722379863262177,
-0.8990380167961121,
0.5375635027885437,
-0.25799912214279175,
-0.04249459132552147,
0.1922602355480194,
-0.4792228639125824,
0.35406002402305603,
0.5545273423194885,
0.018787987530231476,
0.5629234910011292,
0.054543837904930115,
-0.03394433856010437,
-0.047854021191596985,
-0.5335511565208435,
-0.7267734408378601,
1.2858047485351562,
0.3501209020614624,
0.7189754843711853,
0.048481397330760956,
0.6058410406112671,
0.2930282652378082,
0.6156749129295349,
-0.6975804567337036,
0.7780645489692688,
0.17605972290039062,
-0.7455624341964722,
-0.41905245184898376,
-0.33796054124832153,
-1.2981252670288086,
0.5114997625350952,
0.0005381555529311299,
-0.6091489791870117,
0.2699076533317566,
-0.15349525213241577,
-0.27446091175079346,
0.26398155093193054,
-0.05971850827336311,
0.3000948131084442,
-0.2558795213699341,
-0.5843297243118286,
-0.3362056612968445,
-0.11990726739168167,
0.2695982754230499,
-0.067783422768116,
0.29016798734664917,
-0.36444640159606934,
-0.28715261816978455,
1.0399008989334106,
-0.14067846536636353,
0.6638996005058289,
-0.24250617623329163,
-0.04081355407834053,
0.3497225046157837,
0.19194205105304718,
0.5506739020347595,
-0.23732401430606842,
-0.35229766368865967,
-0.1099274605512619,
0.061037786304950714,
-0.24204936623573303,
-0.5596465468406677,
0.5660575032234192,
-0.7850603461265564,
-0.3033094108104706,
-0.7243592143058777,
-0.29888561367988586,
-0.5227364897727966,
-0.03204964101314545,
0.019786175340414047,
0.2561742067337036,
-0.5421326756477356,
0.24688223004341125,
0.9075201749801636,
0.27019914984703064,
0.15271079540252686,
0.8608325719833374,
-0.23548239469528198,
-0.1799529492855072,
0.6129528284072876,
0.38204121589660645,
-0.33127474784851074,
0.5684670209884644,
0.07707840949296951,
-0.48706236481666565,
-1.01290762424469,
-0.18863876163959503,
0.13241425156593323,
-0.6552356481552124,
-0.20128598809242249,
-0.7976068258285522,
-0.09413288533687592,
-0.10908466577529907,
0.21507422626018524,
-0.3973502814769745,
-0.10031162947416306,
-0.21156364679336548,
-0.17314539849758148,
0.31160426139831543,
0.8401703834533691,
0.23723408579826355,
0.15749335289001465,
-0.41023343801498413,
0.2868093252182007,
0.2959088385105133,
0.08165659010410309,
0.2696404755115509,
-0.5613484978675842,
-0.37736380100250244,
-0.3461248576641083,
0.009289401583373547,
-0.6239532828330994,
0.2046538144350052,
-0.06528627127408981,
0.7739196419715881,
0.29895907640457153,
-0.02236207202076912,
0.6830004453659058,
-0.34047695994377136,
0.561690092086792,
-0.34494996070861816,
-0.30373185873031616,
0.38589733839035034,
-0.5304305553436279,
0.1899036020040512,
1.1914112567901611,
0.6256958246231079,
-0.0015716819325461984,
-0.4802802503108978,
-0.31986576318740845,
-0.9957502484321594,
0.31233784556388855,
0.36292925477027893,
-0.15879543125629425,
0.10002635419368744,
0.12994366884231567,
-0.07490644603967667,
0.28197550773620605,
-0.42238059639930725,
-0.10404994338750839,
0.2644813358783722,
-0.024082208052277565,
-0.16272522509098053,
-0.29392358660697937,
-0.7183300256729126,
-0.026252174749970436,
0.647733211517334,
-0.005651642568409443,
0.24524596333503723,
0.1482386589050293,
-0.06754916906356812,
-0.08476964384317398,
0.25564777851104736,
0.3810268044471741,
1.1412932872772217,
-0.33256852626800537,
0.2908039093017578,
-0.14083479344844818,
-0.42219340801239014,
0.3577822148799896,
0.4560368061065674,
-0.2105696052312851,
0.04538334906101227,
0.37497010827064514,
0.27911460399627686,
0.36920833587646484,
-0.6971220374107361,
0.30471551418304443,
-0.4570152461528778,
-0.3253955841064453,
-0.5639771223068237,
0.05646901950240135,
0.17134054005146027,
0.1795167475938797,
0.6485573649406433,
-0.27667850255966187,
0.3076958954334259,
-0.5263925790786743,
-0.0214215237647295,
0.3868507444858551,
-0.1350669264793396,
-0.2552505135536194,
0.5763113498687744,
0.2625870108604431,
-0.28163233399391174,
0.319720983505249,
-0.004661425016820431,
0.04502575471997261,
0.6984988451004028,
0.16409701108932495,
0.9061049222946167,
0.010803714394569397,
0.3069607615470886,
0.2772814929485321,
0.27799054980278015,
-0.32239532470703125,
0.47712743282318115,
-0.023746421560645103,
-0.6658627390861511,
-0.12400512397289276,
-0.7215728759765625,
-0.7126207947731018,
0.28067877888679504,
-0.8244814872741699,
-0.21530891954898834,
-0.32300546765327454,
-0.5388791561126709,
0.15342359244823456,
0.2829732298851013,
-0.8842788934707642,
0.24443146586418152,
-0.4381648898124695,
1.0866907835006714,
-0.7162293195724487,
0.7212864756584167,
0.9881061315536499,
-0.2583017647266388,
-0.7349435091018677,
-0.14753457903862,
0.27671077847480774,
-0.8301653265953064,
0.5701680779457092,
-0.07221293449401855,
-0.5020399689674377,
-0.11845146864652634,
-0.24284866452217102,
-0.954717218875885,
1.1643191576004028,
-0.1602618396282196,
-0.5769191384315491,
0.023282650858163834,
0.04172591120004654,
0.9932215213775635,
-0.39191725850105286,
0.6735055446624756,
0.5609645247459412,
0.614262580871582,
-0.08879729360342026,
-0.7233198881149292,
-0.07126445323228836,
-0.626307487487793,
-0.0553445927798748,
0.1565793752670288,
-0.6564502716064453,
0.8004085421562195,
0.5248868465423584,
-0.2547242045402527,
0.23455017805099487,
0.6611193418502808,
0.3345484733581543,
0.49587345123291016,
0.44684693217277527,
0.5517914295196533,
0.9307817816734314,
-0.05721944943070412,
0.7957848906517029,
-0.45041900873184204,
-0.20071691274642944,
1.0677130222320557,
-0.48994511365890503,
1.0598691701889038,
0.46583372354507446,
-0.2939584255218506,
0.47048550844192505,
0.5093968510627747,
0.05763891339302063,
0.20633192360401154,
0.45778053998947144,
-0.4480103850364685,
0.05311072990298271,
-0.5777058005332947,
-0.34690847992897034,
0.5853254199028015,
0.3461070656776428,
-0.34808364510536194,
-0.18626588582992554,
-0.16832610964775085,
0.21299788355827332,
0.5043036341667175,
-0.1955835223197937,
0.7956308722496033,
0.04215441644191742,
-0.9583078026771545,
0.26513946056365967,
-0.10156811028718948,
0.5331404209136963,
-0.8219714164733887,
0.09125903248786926,
-0.5001506805419922,
0.09533437341451645,
-0.013943804427981377,
-0.7203686833381653,
0.11774967610836029,
0.14598709344863892,
-0.12074494361877441,
-0.2866114675998688,
0.7016150951385498,
-0.17865288257598877,
-0.47562503814697266,
0.5994153618812561,
0.9755708575248718,
0.3519614040851593,
0.11251632869243622,
-0.39466455578804016,
0.36404338479042053,
-0.4946051239967346,
-0.640783429145813,
0.6320801973342896,
0.4671057462692261,
-0.17206643521785736,
0.8047923445701599,
0.43743896484375,
0.5870466828346252,
-0.05527734383940697,
0.3014630377292633,
0.8526719212532043,
-0.5683031678199768,
-0.14428310096263885,
-0.5153314471244812,
0.1887212097644806,
-0.3904143273830414,
-0.574444055557251,
0.9608474373817444,
0.7181333899497986,
0.711693286895752,
0.2520061433315277,
0.8642467260360718,
-0.07842749357223511,
0.9712360501289368,
-0.30585238337516785,
0.6543871760368347,
-0.5433078408241272,
0.17971980571746826,
-0.030669884756207466,
-1.0427149534225464,
-0.05410061404109001,
0.6001688838005066,
-0.2468048334121704,
-0.049880217760801315,
0.672025740146637,
1.0499998331069946,
0.004829478915780783,
-0.09705190360546112,
0.06614045053720474,
0.047669149935245514,
0.2509487569332123,
0.1322248876094818,
1.035274624824524,
-0.061546988785266876,
0.7144147157669067,
-0.045365575700998306,
-0.1822976917028427,
-0.08305364847183228,
-0.6433792114257812,
-1.1989965438842773,
-0.48992931842803955,
-0.1314307153224945,
-0.2714916467666626,
0.32927045226097107,
0.7116439342498779,
0.7039103507995605,
-0.6705466508865356,
-0.7226994633674622,
0.1273539662361145,
-0.14850983023643494,
-0.20186124742031097,
-0.24157527089118958,
0.3262134790420532,
-0.1816447526216507,
-0.6884713172912598,
0.6570302248001099,
0.1555735319852829,
-0.25849461555480957,
-0.6788711547851562,
0.17162637412548065,
-0.4842934012413025,
0.10981500148773193,
0.3708079159259796,
0.5030221939086914,
-0.4879305064678192,
0.17789599299430847,
0.014667547307908535,
-0.35706427693367004,
0.0851433202624321,
1.116510033607483,
-0.504025399684906,
0.27349036931991577,
0.696248471736908,
0.9038795232772827,
0.6738095879554749,
0.2259470373392105,
0.5371366143226624,
-0.32665321230888367,
-0.2492292821407318,
0.4640561640262604,
0.018039235845208168,
0.23355162143707275,
-0.10546153783798218,
0.9551247954368591,
-0.2918185293674469,
-0.9023601412773132,
-0.7659584283828735,
-0.3298085927963257,
-0.8820272088050842,
-0.2365623563528061,
0.9253784418106079,
-0.26164212822914124,
-0.15504789352416992,
-0.3860817849636078,
-0.11402101814746857,
0.15787523984909058,
-0.4346947968006134,
1.242793321609497,
0.7695255875587463,
-0.2664046585559845,
-0.21058180928230286,
-0.7983058094978333,
0.4584762454032898,
0.42077741026878357,
-1.085972785949707,
-0.24464501440525055,
0.36496394872665405,
0.15558454394340515,
0.4280165135860443,
1.0640095472335815,
-0.04721603915095329,
-0.06619435548782349,
-0.01900196447968483,
0.08286035060882568,
-0.07936326414346695,
-0.34473612904548645,
0.02366679348051548,
0.6484607458114624,
0.443175733089447,
-0.11652165651321411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08772v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08772v1
|
MMFakeBench: A Mixed-Source Multimodal Misinformation Detection Benchmark for LVLMs
| 2024-06-13T03:04:28 | 2024-06-13T03:04:28 |
Xuannan Liu, Zekun Li, Peipei Li, Shuhan Xia, Xing Cui, Linzhi Huang, Huaibo Huang, Weihong Deng, Zhaofeng He
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Current multimodal misinformation detection (MMD) methods often assume a
single source and type of forgery for each sample, which is insufficient for
real-world scenarios where multiple forgery sources coexist. The lack of a
benchmark for mixed-source misinformation has hindered progress in this field.
To address this, we introduce MMFakeBench, the first comprehensive benchmark
for mixed-source MMD. MMFakeBench includes 3 critical sources: textual veracity
distortion, visual veracity distortion, and cross-modal consistency distortion,
along with 12 sub-categories of misinformation forgery types. We further
conduct an extensive evaluation of 6 prevalent detection methods and 15 large
vision-language models (LVLMs) on MMFakeBench under a zero-shot setting. The
results indicate that current methods struggle under this challenging and
realistic mixed-source MMD setting. Additionally, we propose an innovative
unified framework, which integrates rationales, actions, and tool-use
capabilities of LVLM agents, significantly enhancing accuracy and
generalization. We believe this study will catalyze future research into more
realistic mixed-source multimodal misinformation and provide a fair evaluation
of misinformation detection methods.
|
[
-0.4963451623916626,
-0.8201562166213989,
0.3112618327140808,
0.18565073609352112,
-0.3501479923725128,
0.19767241179943085,
0.18290814757347107,
-0.5349220633506775,
0.1365617960691452,
0.2831231951713562,
-0.8324432373046875,
-0.4143703877925873,
-0.46552273631095886,
0.06891738623380661,
-0.3098789155483246,
0.5331268906593323,
0.010108335874974728,
0.32538118958473206,
-0.23549063503742218,
-0.4743407964706421,
-0.4413076341152191,
-0.3515256643295288,
-0.256172776222229,
-0.11169765889644623,
0.6431059241294861,
0.4530736804008484,
0.6542790532112122,
0.3915281593799591,
0.466811865568161,
0.24208708107471466,
0.2753174901008606,
0.4818393886089325,
-0.21258065104484558,
0.35059022903442383,
-0.10280037671327591,
-0.36225175857543945,
-0.10668385773897171,
0.23071107268333435,
0.7423877120018005,
0.3368730843067169,
-0.3424633741378784,
0.17255127429962158,
-0.31300821900367737,
0.35787659883499146,
-1.1130008697509766,
-0.15118910372257233,
-0.4993801414966583,
0.1583831012248993,
-0.4793526530265808,
-0.2782402038574219,
-0.5392515063285828,
-0.11118752509355545,
-0.43640878796577454,
-0.36551156640052795,
0.3247984051704407,
0.14266642928123474,
0.602077305316925,
0.25315290689468384,
-0.5824687480926514,
-0.11867696046829224,
-0.6047487258911133,
0.6453170776367188,
-0.6553395986557007,
0.8455268740653992,
0.11977829784154892,
0.6703851819038391,
-0.06763175129890442,
-0.6748451590538025,
-0.9310891032218933,
-0.2227746844291687,
0.1463797241449356,
0.287487655878067,
-0.30997422337532043,
-0.22578488290309906,
0.34380924701690674,
0.17584830522537231,
-0.6575260162353516,
0.046706460416316986,
-0.06719202548265457,
-0.7093765139579773,
0.2274862676858902,
-0.043180692940950394,
0.0929323360323906,
-0.15951275825500488,
-0.5948702096939087,
-0.42326241731643677,
-0.4684212803840637,
-0.14132249355316162,
0.27456235885620117,
0.16955071687698364,
0.011234928853809834,
0.6578371524810791,
-0.3519282042980194,
0.6568069458007812,
-0.014755535870790482,
-0.5466351509094238,
0.5689570903778076,
-0.4249383211135864,
-0.3552035093307495,
-0.0522102527320385,
0.8297148942947388,
0.7305443286895752,
-0.1050579622387886,
-0.13898427784442902,
-0.2167518585920334,
0.04971364140510559,
0.09691225737333298,
-0.7697913646697998,
0.20833703875541687,
0.127404123544693,
-0.4537244141101837,
-0.4359852075576782,
0.1510266363620758,
-1.064733624458313,
-0.7994363307952881,
-0.24132923781871796,
0.3654225766658783,
-0.3383374810218811,
-0.46692073345184326,
-0.06684726476669312,
-0.41884922981262207,
0.06785409897565842,
0.5842779278755188,
-0.35566118359565735,
-0.13668395578861237,
0.4727381467819214,
0.8345702290534973,
-0.25819599628448486,
-0.5102242231369019,
-0.7863013744354248,
0.15961800515651703,
-0.16340410709381104,
1.0624902248382568,
-0.3589502274990082,
-0.22672151029109955,
0.10841605812311172,
-0.035184815526008606,
0.06648372858762741,
-0.6965206265449524,
0.7026872038841248,
-0.34014248847961426,
0.21335341036319733,
-0.22563770413398743,
-0.3897043466567993,
-0.14487048983573914,
0.5020876526832581,
-1.1087843179702759,
1.049637794494629,
0.1968560367822647,
-0.7522352933883667,
0.8553247451782227,
-0.2885032296180725,
-0.11179196089506149,
-0.07573098689317703,
-0.3547511696815491,
-0.4649481773376465,
0.0457846000790596,
0.15377984941005707,
0.43254125118255615,
-0.27501362562179565,
0.1023043617606163,
-0.5908756852149963,
-0.18913431465625763,
0.5430302619934082,
-1.0334991216659546,
0.6196214556694031,
0.21568487584590912,
-0.37755122780799866,
0.08491353690624237,
-0.8752602338790894,
-0.128465935587883,
0.016448719426989555,
-0.3693089485168457,
-0.2686796486377716,
-0.14712287485599518,
0.1897607147693634,
0.6078023910522461,
0.036933235824108124,
-0.7585001587867737,
0.00006712968024658039,
0.10768985748291016,
-0.5065157413482666,
0.8243873715400696,
0.028773214668035507,
-0.06564218550920486,
-0.22138214111328125,
0.20792488753795624,
0.5563247799873352,
0.2661623954772949,
-0.1392437368631363,
-0.32428476214408875,
-0.6762375235557556,
-0.29294848442077637,
0.21992960572242737,
0.44597887992858887,
-1.0717567205429077,
-0.021734289824962616,
-0.23038719594478607,
-0.4346853494644165,
-0.6476369500160217,
0.14572323858737946,
0.3691065311431885,
0.4228222072124481,
0.37180861830711365,
-0.35701772570610046,
-0.36514031887054443,
-1.07499098777771,
-0.6372398734092712,
0.03971648961305618,
0.014100373722612858,
0.0026932009495794773,
0.4487156867980957,
-0.25241485238075256,
0.747348427772522,
-0.053524937480688095,
-0.33156320452690125,
0.11500321328639984,
0.4713468849658966,
-0.281414270401001,
0.20017477869987488,
0.8679946064949036,
-0.8555493950843811,
-0.4395543336868286,
0.0046891761012375355,
-0.6286978125572205,
-0.14438004791736603,
-0.17774395644664764,
-0.03651747107505798,
0.38411465287208557,
0.624120831489563,
-0.5860576629638672,
0.35132133960723877,
0.7652546167373657,
-0.6187261939048767,
0.838652491569519,
0.11400299519300461,
0.6659220457077026,
-0.8522294759750366,
0.006080036982893944,
-0.01722005195915699,
-0.4910815358161926,
-0.522169828414917,
0.15064245462417603,
0.3611757159233093,
0.1894754320383072,
-0.6540330648422241,
0.368253231048584,
-0.3986400067806244,
-0.04686050862073898,
-0.2936447262763977,
0.08886826038360596,
-0.17075525224208832,
0.2765294909477234,
-0.3825765550136566,
0.8373516201972961,
0.2453867495059967,
-0.34951817989349365,
0.7451278567314148,
-0.22374756634235382,
-0.30918896198272705,
1.2107434272766113,
-0.14542189240455627,
-0.055181458592414856,
-0.1500909924507141,
0.2475203424692154,
-0.7132219672203064,
-0.1689179241657257,
0.5621843934059143,
-0.5235644578933716,
0.16535036265850067,
0.016600485891103745,
-1.0130083560943604,
-0.14167176187038422,
-0.396514892578125,
0.09584689885377884,
-0.016432249918580055,
-0.5235209465026855,
0.7985398173332214,
0.11072492599487305,
0.2978665232658386,
-0.7902355790138245,
-0.753121018409729,
0.03904854878783226,
0.13283348083496094,
-0.661563515663147,
0.06584904342889786,
-0.49247172474861145,
-0.23769310116767883,
-0.024839529767632484,
-0.5916239023208618,
-0.2582916021347046,
-0.19149979948997498,
0.23705585300922394,
0.09662426263093948,
-0.33160632848739624,
0.06278965622186661,
-0.10863883793354034,
-0.11517766863107681,
-0.19902876019477844,
0.1605421006679535,
0.4308229684829712,
-0.07169810682535172,
-0.8922788500785828,
-0.24216532707214355,
0.33606642484664917,
0.9600968360900879,
-0.248305082321167,
0.9876018166542053,
0.9530643820762634,
-0.31949490308761597,
-0.28996074199676514,
-0.9750992655754089,
-0.023024311289191246,
-0.4283187985420227,
0.16128316521644592,
-0.24716265499591827,
-0.8992586135864258,
0.2940499484539032,
-0.30910030007362366,
0.1060032993555069,
0.5654507875442505,
0.5763399600982666,
0.04061399772763252,
0.7517271041870117,
0.6966086030006409,
-0.07958073914051056,
0.467934787273407,
0.18614232540130615,
-0.20928041636943817,
-0.1999615728855133,
-0.304452508687973,
-0.23653121292591095,
-0.2857690751552582,
-0.14348965883255005,
-0.9665283560752869,
0.14803077280521393,
-0.04986466094851494,
0.1674814671278,
-0.07566655427217484,
0.018208106979727745,
0.606096088886261,
0.39409664273262024,
-0.10142076015472412,
0.5449574589729309,
0.06979090720415115,
-0.6085047125816345,
-0.12618058919906616,
-0.33407968282699585,
-0.1360553652048111,
1.2554094791412354,
0.21603776514530182,
0.5638779401779175,
0.2937491536140442,
0.24123229086399078,
0.6329916715621948,
0.6066687703132629,
-0.4820222556591034,
0.28448593616485596,
0.15661481022834778,
-0.886779248714447,
0.05937661975622177,
-0.4120631515979767,
-0.37882566452026367,
0.771233081817627,
-0.44234004616737366,
-0.37153884768486023,
0.3457704782485962,
0.0919046401977539,
-0.042494870722293854,
0.5812392830848694,
-0.6130622029304504,
0.9442779421806335,
-0.29363638162612915,
-0.45983338356018066,
-0.3110515773296356,
-0.5099135041236877,
0.5818904042243958,
-0.2895224690437317,
0.5925738215446472,
-0.3423510789871216,
-0.044989392161369324,
0.41255852580070496,
-0.20281873643398285,
0.7460237741470337,
-0.52638840675354,
-0.01631578803062439,
0.03608797490596771,
0.19183067977428436,
0.5134927034378052,
-0.11995404213666916,
0.07436248660087585,
0.2239934802055359,
-0.0004565328126773238,
-0.2181251347064972,
-0.4490291476249695,
0.6436796188354492,
-0.4555399417877197,
0.10199803858995438,
-0.7048163414001465,
-0.4974188804626465,
-0.3573503792285919,
0.44850680232048035,
0.14836594462394714,
0.18050691485404968,
-0.5341137051582336,
0.49223533272743225,
0.6375424265861511,
0.1357915848493576,
0.3666197955608368,
1.1107759475708008,
-0.2964605689048767,
-0.41741496324539185,
0.7755140662193298,
-0.0753915011882782,
0.30415841937065125,
0.20531508326530457,
-0.19291605055332184,
-0.00034710278850980103,
-0.4404110908508301,
-0.5162152647972107,
0.1638953685760498,
-0.9752187728881836,
-0.36439085006713867,
-0.32683414220809937,
-0.14000771939754486,
-0.13596199452877045,
0.13781625032424927,
-0.6390761733055115,
-0.14676779508590698,
0.0018652979051694274,
-0.08898284286260605,
0.10665902495384216,
0.3457251787185669,
-0.25343871116638184,
0.3548606038093567,
-0.7116152048110962,
0.773234486579895,
0.1909952461719513,
0.6144723892211914,
-0.2967422902584076,
-0.09145087003707886,
-0.347088098526001,
0.31578361988067627,
-0.3171289563179016,
-0.9822446703910828,
0.23312795162200928,
-0.05282657593488693,
0.940394401550293,
0.6366880536079407,
-0.12343185395002365,
0.6216834783554077,
-0.359862744808197,
0.6906999945640564,
0.4008241295814514,
-0.6739604473114014,
0.17360493540763855,
-0.0573657862842083,
0.06399793922901154,
0.570591390132904,
0.30239763855934143,
-0.8411071300506592,
-0.3663841187953949,
-0.4620704650878906,
-0.4845295548439026,
0.664164125919342,
0.23552843928337097,
-0.3792804181575775,
0.209149569272995,
-0.17052651941776276,
0.2994094789028168,
0.34839674830436707,
-0.9796592593193054,
-0.4501449465751648,
-0.35099348425865173,
-0.0809999331831932,
-0.19472460448741913,
-0.282452255487442,
-0.33808356523513794,
-0.15824155509471893,
0.4836002290248871,
-0.21467451751232147,
0.16570867598056793,
0.24127228558063507,
-0.5733512043952942,
-0.4218168258666992,
0.27061131596565247,
0.8609505891799927,
0.5715592503547668,
-0.43980488181114197,
0.28622084856033325,
-0.01956719160079956,
-0.6045242547988892,
0.09636879712343216,
0.17140963673591614,
-0.13124682009220123,
0.37700366973876953,
0.3432255685329437,
0.5871351957321167,
0.10661736130714417,
-0.7801511883735657,
0.825798749923706,
-0.18598663806915283,
-0.3886834383010864,
-0.20605897903442383,
-0.10825864970684052,
-0.05796322226524353,
0.46570995450019836,
0.4147222638130188,
0.5277354121208191,
0.07950261980295181,
-0.40378081798553467,
0.39414405822753906,
0.45887139439582825,
-0.4615844488143921,
-0.024286983534693718,
0.5348931550979614,
0.11858682334423065,
0.16930468380451202,
0.23487484455108643,
-0.1502162665128708,
-0.07530838251113892,
0.26939913630485535,
0.2697453796863556,
0.8011504411697388,
-0.39483195543289185,
0.298017680644989,
0.04241650179028511,
0.7907474637031555,
-0.012685546651482582,
0.12303213030099869,
-0.035555630922317505,
-0.9285116791725159,
-0.22228942811489105,
-0.6298431158065796,
-0.39063921570777893,
0.23364494740962982,
-0.3708788752555847,
0.2598792016506195,
-0.4705069363117218,
-0.09243481606245041,
0.12519770860671997,
-0.40576276183128357,
-0.5537483096122742,
0.11676909774541855,
0.30114221572875977,
0.9812163710594177,
-0.7605729103088379,
0.5689727663993835,
0.3164452016353607,
-0.5036866068840027,
-0.3205246329307556,
0.22287572920322418,
0.8011236190795898,
-0.7103176116943359,
0.23538294434547424,
0.1730896383523941,
-0.4407309591770172,
-0.27462977170944214,
-0.7383497357368469,
-0.6023867130279541,
1.349794626235962,
0.41575726866722107,
-0.45517417788505554,
0.3797060549259186,
0.28249025344848633,
0.1529865860939026,
-0.4158163070678711,
0.10076150298118591,
0.570228099822998,
0.6499776244163513,
0.24267560243606567,
-0.8942832946777344,
-0.1028347834944725,
-0.2856443226337433,
-0.399517297744751,
0.0694892629981041,
-0.5247604846954346,
0.9865288734436035,
0.3011592626571655,
-0.23632310330867767,
-0.29221364855766296,
0.4751461148262024,
0.18261542916297913,
0.5314390063285828,
0.5199764966964722,
0.665691077709198,
0.5995064377784729,
-0.11288349330425262,
0.9293942451477051,
-0.10223300009965897,
0.27996039390563965,
0.9747222661972046,
-0.1575278788805008,
0.8818299174308777,
0.5168531537055969,
0.0031156837940216064,
0.5906760692596436,
0.42054250836372375,
-0.15924875438213348,
0.5363262891769409,
-0.2866172790527344,
-0.4358521103858948,
-0.2589598596096039,
-0.028056440874934196,
-0.49037984013557434,
0.33203861117362976,
0.36146703362464905,
-0.29541003704071045,
-0.5108153223991394,
0.15203741192817688,
-0.052573416382074356,
-0.298989474773407,
-0.1746746450662613,
0.5665528178215027,
-0.26682302355766296,
-0.29396888613700867,
0.5380717515945435,
0.27639344334602356,
0.9000995755195618,
-0.759344220161438,
0.018787216395139694,
-0.2102918177843094,
0.3066731095314026,
-0.15204094350337982,
-0.6506240367889404,
0.1988346427679062,
-0.09757484495639801,
-0.25352033972740173,
-0.1388644576072693,
0.9005347490310669,
-0.47661155462265015,
-0.360248863697052,
0.3197908103466034,
0.7582616209983826,
-0.15584269165992737,
-0.48151108622550964,
-0.7291193008422852,
0.22688114643096924,
0.03359119966626167,
-0.01650954969227314,
0.298089861869812,
0.6147533059120178,
0.05001717060804367,
0.5692148208618164,
0.987697958946228,
-0.12576739490032196,
0.32455581426620483,
0.2874056100845337,
0.9268579483032227,
-0.6488094329833984,
-0.16555991768836975,
-0.7946040630340576,
0.7268655300140381,
-0.3857380747795105,
-0.17388921976089478,
0.9924873113632202,
0.6150047183036804,
0.8839110732078552,
-0.26539865136146545,
0.7511576414108276,
0.10193634033203125,
0.6803109645843506,
-0.501879870891571,
0.8968510031700134,
-0.8603102564811707,
-0.016531098634004593,
-0.4065672755241394,
-0.8734539151191711,
-0.3368905186653137,
0.4066704213619232,
0.41470620036125183,
-0.07192079722881317,
0.9097689390182495,
0.7791479825973511,
-0.45030418038368225,
-0.18245232105255127,
0.5626479387283325,
0.1698530912399292,
0.38094544410705566,
0.0958237424492836,
0.8107930421829224,
-0.22981220483779907,
0.688564121723175,
-0.3567480146884918,
-0.20751658082008362,
-0.6324231028556824,
-0.8732248544692993,
-0.7017059922218323,
-0.3797171413898468,
-0.11812513321638107,
-0.20679715275764465,
-0.11214067041873932,
0.6570696234703064,
0.49982255697250366,
-0.6939587593078613,
-0.07022982835769653,
0.27623698115348816,
0.07521215081214905,
-0.333855539560318,
-0.24889716506004333,
-0.23695170879364014,
0.12789002060890198,
-0.2915779948234558,
0.5174723267555237,
0.5672193169593811,
0.2593807876110077,
-0.4211098551750183,
-0.08734302222728729,
-0.41442763805389404,
0.23694035410881042,
0.7175343632698059,
0.2562803030014038,
-0.9033882021903992,
-0.25137221813201904,
-0.06703325361013412,
-0.29110458493232727,
0.05724361911416054,
0.8171434998512268,
-0.6456697583198547,
0.8557525873184204,
0.24791063368320465,
0.37600651383399963,
0.41031450033187866,
-0.05366562306880951,
0.29856622219085693,
-1.1025192737579346,
0.4555817246437073,
0.15790092945098877,
0.3071497976779938,
0.24542297422885895,
0.024210387840867043,
0.28881433606147766,
0.6895194053649902,
-0.17761313915252686,
-0.8099259734153748,
0.13724978268146515,
-1.2325716018676758,
-0.4683017432689667,
0.8460003733634949,
0.24781307578086853,
-0.0782594308257103,
-0.18258406221866608,
-0.4304923415184021,
0.1592438668012619,
-0.514997661113739,
0.4014836847782135,
0.939262866973877,
0.12500208616256714,
-0.4669092893600464,
-0.9316228628158569,
0.4148862063884735,
0.0011543959844857454,
-0.830720841884613,
0.12882831692695618,
1.1202833652496338,
0.3248763680458069,
0.33116415143013,
0.6500362157821655,
-0.03013661317527294,
0.6153780221939087,
0.4104473888874054,
0.26777100563049316,
-0.3827151656150818,
-0.405305415391922,
-0.11037517338991165,
0.21204856038093567,
-0.19698308408260345,
-0.04467354342341423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08757v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08757v1
|
SRFUND: A Multi-Granularity Hierarchical Structure Reconstruction Benchmark in Form Understanding
| 2024-06-13T02:35:55 | 2024-06-13T02:35:55 |
Jiefeng Ma, Yan Wang, Chenyu Liu, Jun Du, Yu Hu, Zhenrong Zhang, Pengfei Hu, Qing Wang, Jianshu Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Accurately identifying and organizing textual content is crucial for the
automation of document processing in the field of form understanding. Existing
datasets, such as FUNSD and XFUND, support entity classification and
relationship prediction tasks but are typically limited to local and
entity-level annotations. This limitation overlooks the hierarchically
structured representation of documents, constraining comprehensive
understanding of complex forms. To address this issue, we present the SRFUND, a
hierarchically structured multi-task form understanding benchmark. SRFUND
provides refined annotations on top of the original FUNSD and XFUND datasets,
encompassing five tasks: (1) word to text-line merging, (2) text-line to entity
merging, (3) entity category classification, (4) item table localization, and
(5) entity-based full-document hierarchical structure recovery. We meticulously
supplemented the original dataset with missing annotations at various levels of
granularity and added detailed annotations for multi-item table regions within
the forms. Additionally, we introduce global hierarchical structure
dependencies for entity relation prediction tasks, surpassing traditional local
key-value associations. The SRFUND dataset includes eight languages including
English, Chinese, Japanese, German, French, Spanish, Italian, and Portuguese,
making it a powerful tool for cross-lingual form understanding. Extensive
experimental results demonstrate that the SRFUND dataset presents new
challenges and significant opportunities in handling diverse layouts and global
hierarchical structures of forms, thus providing deep insights into the field
of form understanding. The original dataset and implementations of baseline
methods are available at https://sprateam-ustc.github.io/SRFUND
|
[
-0.11066189408302307,
-0.7855093479156494,
0.3034348785877228,
0.2396731823682785,
0.11213678866624832,
0.10778023302555084,
-0.09034319967031479,
-0.512752890586853,
0.1812753677368164,
0.4590153098106384,
-0.8589515686035156,
-0.4663790464401245,
-0.7133475542068481,
-0.21022379398345947,
-0.14794455468654633,
1.1935293674468994,
-0.4790661036968231,
0.09125126153230667,
-0.7006514072418213,
-0.19891560077667236,
-0.11517976969480515,
-0.4262866973876953,
-0.6852753758430481,
-0.33045312762260437,
0.49330323934555054,
0.30230075120925903,
0.5826649069786072,
0.7752842903137207,
0.49396759271621704,
0.27209335565567017,
0.14201068878173828,
-0.04715419560670853,
-0.5350847840309143,
0.2672997713088989,
0.06971246749162674,
-0.320051372051239,
-0.4206085205078125,
-0.05306832119822502,
0.9311525225639343,
1.023854374885559,
-0.2051784247159958,
-0.025680944323539734,
-0.2351885885000229,
0.5408912301063538,
-0.6590873003005981,
0.4707481563091278,
-0.2216547131538391,
0.3177971839904785,
-0.5207070708274841,
-0.12126632034778595,
-0.17958229780197144,
0.14182370901107788,
0.004335411824285984,
-0.7358710765838623,
0.5709174275398254,
-0.019102638587355614,
1.116812825202942,
0.14552077651023865,
-0.3099154829978943,
-0.10310102999210358,
-0.3460330069065094,
0.31886547803878784,
-0.23768804967403412,
0.9789332747459412,
0.5556954145431519,
0.4564792811870575,
-0.3929746448993683,
-1.143204689025879,
-0.32460200786590576,
-0.26630884408950806,
-0.19098447263240814,
0.2522929012775421,
-0.12603871524333954,
0.0957285687327385,
0.21713478863239288,
0.7087961435317993,
-0.827919065952301,
-0.0158612672239542,
-0.47123202681541443,
-0.5160002708435059,
0.36902862787246704,
-0.15686427056789398,
0.5288378000259399,
-0.43682175874710083,
-0.45919090509414673,
-0.3373616337776184,
-0.5412258505821228,
0.44233158230781555,
0.05525743588805199,
0.3664757013320923,
-0.40357705950737,
0.30615973472595215,
-0.3110169768333435,
0.5135339498519897,
-0.17195923626422882,
-0.35058602690696716,
0.25906550884246826,
-0.4630252420902252,
-0.6435883641242981,
-0.20900458097457886,
0.6322321891784668,
-0.263311505317688,
-0.13608482480049133,
-0.3582644760608673,
-0.19431756436824799,
-0.28047633171081543,
0.21162573993206024,
-0.5849123001098633,
-0.37194639444351196,
-0.13123822212219238,
-0.48093587160110474,
-0.2169942557811737,
0.09052453935146332,
-0.3389859199523926,
-0.34403353929519653,
-0.3445219397544861,
0.33153754472732544,
-0.43711012601852417,
-0.07892999053001404,
-0.12130264937877655,
-0.10602375864982605,
-0.042809683829545975,
0.5715099573135376,
-0.5904556512832642,
0.5387461185455322,
0.6241899728775024,
0.8321824073791504,
-0.16541992127895355,
-0.5249184966087341,
-0.7760003209114075,
0.11912152171134949,
-0.11786554753780365,
1.293959617614746,
-0.3840206265449524,
-0.23850348591804504,
-0.3919181227684021,
0.09461184591054916,
-0.22646692395210266,
-0.472432017326355,
0.6959419846534729,
-0.15309764444828033,
0.37578085064888,
-0.05221078172326088,
-0.13467290997505188,
-0.26062139868736267,
0.3497607111930847,
-0.9542569518089294,
1.3722864389419556,
0.5088374614715576,
-0.6947230100631714,
0.5843489766120911,
-0.21371020376682281,
-0.670437216758728,
-0.06809317320585251,
-0.6152938604354858,
-0.47297075390815735,
0.18364043533802032,
0.0818127691745758,
0.3401656448841095,
-0.41372251510620117,
0.4184114933013916,
-0.2461225986480713,
-0.05079018697142601,
-0.49908778071403503,
-0.24172204732894897,
0.5240055918693542,
-0.12558236718177795,
-0.4673074185848236,
0.47521254420280457,
-0.9133116602897644,
-0.19259408116340637,
-0.03115108050405979,
-0.3144044280052185,
-0.21699461340904236,
-0.20240025222301483,
0.23115164041519165,
0.5674564838409424,
-0.08399560302495956,
-0.18415795266628265,
0.09868000447750092,
-0.1019575297832489,
0.31391119956970215,
0.6797770261764526,
-0.03339377045631409,
0.34374290704727173,
-0.37827321887016296,
0.830271303653717,
0.15646956861019135,
-0.2599414885044098,
-0.19145943224430084,
-0.1572626531124115,
-0.5091046094894409,
-0.517626166343689,
0.3334628641605377,
0.20657269656658173,
-0.5377320051193237,
-0.004876341670751572,
-0.55255126953125,
-0.7098618745803833,
-0.2878255844116211,
-0.11913861334323883,
0.47889000177383423,
0.8438941836357117,
0.3070438504219055,
-0.07499630004167557,
-0.5386314392089844,
-1.2745624780654907,
0.03994595259428024,
-0.31764060258865356,
-0.027606016024947166,
0.3197374641895294,
0.5479686260223389,
-0.2140161693096161,
0.6310631036758423,
-0.3910543918609619,
-0.6086797714233398,
-0.034548334777355194,
0.5223699808120728,
-0.23145654797554016,
0.4043901562690735,
0.3623243570327759,
-0.8824039697647095,
-0.050383273512125015,
-0.06457067281007767,
-0.5480108857154846,
-0.18275092542171478,
-0.3020429015159607,
-0.27655214071273804,
0.09801061451435089,
0.42435014247894287,
-0.723675549030304,
0.459181547164917,
0.5140783190727234,
-0.283298134803772,
0.6402289867401123,
-0.20922088623046875,
0.39224332571029663,
-0.8856553435325623,
0.3407144248485565,
-0.12133175879716873,
-0.23524458706378937,
-0.38073986768722534,
0.19769243896007538,
0.33568596839904785,
-0.18987321853637695,
-0.17271672189235687,
0.408909410238266,
-0.6061126589775085,
-0.3885519206523895,
0.181417778134346,
0.33493572473526,
0.23098452389240265,
0.33518844842910767,
0.2621718645095825,
0.987346887588501,
0.41869011521339417,
-0.2185152769088745,
-0.19382281601428986,
0.14954353868961334,
-0.18014101684093475,
0.7062757611274719,
-0.5661165118217468,
-0.24499204754829407,
-0.6127179861068726,
0.6808050870895386,
-1.4048233032226562,
-0.4834066927433014,
0.07050517201423645,
-0.3208116590976715,
0.2840752601623535,
-0.1637241095304489,
-0.3048715591430664,
-0.03882785141468048,
-0.4666433036327362,
0.14385759830474854,
-0.23351547122001648,
-0.09180240333080292,
1.027669906616211,
0.612451434135437,
-0.5802474617958069,
-0.6085493564605713,
-0.5287058353424072,
0.07759859412908554,
0.2816653847694397,
-1.0840177536010742,
0.7053720951080322,
0.03762897104024887,
0.0243211779743433,
-0.13219499588012695,
-0.6621454358100891,
-0.1874140501022339,
0.1638977825641632,
0.6888488531112671,
0.07013815641403198,
-0.3643853962421417,
0.35586613416671753,
0.374912828207016,
-0.05302897095680237,
-0.07938780635595322,
0.1303202360868454,
0.4122665524482727,
0.1865227371454239,
-0.1484084278345108,
-0.09824278205633163,
0.29247143864631653,
0.6379268765449524,
-0.1635584831237793,
0.3047572076320648,
0.4060286283493042,
-0.9916375875473022,
-0.2073247730731964,
-0.38290661573410034,
0.26500293612480164,
-0.31815916299819946,
0.32581886649131775,
-1.0025047063827515,
-0.854469895362854,
0.5242239236831665,
0.08945868164300919,
0.2515190839767456,
0.807805061340332,
0.18252381682395935,
-0.09512098878622055,
0.4268185496330261,
0.7306107878684998,
-0.007084958720952272,
0.25986990332603455,
-0.3337126672267914,
-0.16922247409820557,
-0.5173776745796204,
-0.4695979356765747,
-0.7811033725738525,
-0.35191068053245544,
-0.00802106037735939,
-0.6587177515029907,
0.03167746588587761,
0.463582307100296,
0.18100270628929138,
0.39995089173316956,
-0.1623704880475998,
-0.08757779002189636,
0.2543562054634094,
-0.16571815311908722,
0.3947890102863312,
0.1311652511358261,
-0.05304340645670891,
-0.23879338800907135,
-0.5122227668762207,
-0.4082721173763275,
0.4337807595729828,
0.31592923402786255,
0.5457097887992859,
-0.07875309139490128,
0.7064412832260132,
0.2863779067993164,
0.6262641549110413,
-0.8163387775421143,
0.20603181421756744,
-0.26915016770362854,
-0.2424883097410202,
-0.31815630197525024,
-0.6329383850097656,
-0.9094539880752563,
0.5147346258163452,
-0.21947674453258514,
-0.521893322467804,
0.1883469820022583,
0.02543451264500618,
-0.2832438349723816,
0.06728304177522659,
-0.6790165901184082,
1.1142364740371704,
-0.0434454008936882,
-0.04301141947507858,
0.1152350977063179,
-0.6022264361381531,
0.4091578423976898,
-0.12222632020711899,
0.49305734038352966,
-0.14132973551750183,
-0.07246863096952438,
1.0733652114868164,
-0.44850826263427734,
0.4779677093029022,
-0.20449824631214142,
-0.4316764175891876,
-0.1975385695695877,
0.07012312859296799,
0.40247461199760437,
0.16665758192539215,
-0.137781023979187,
0.11334411799907684,
0.12928052246570587,
-0.17997576296329498,
-0.5764346122741699,
0.8349589705467224,
-0.619986355304718,
-0.15910549461841583,
-0.4376019835472107,
-0.5966384410858154,
-0.26656198501586914,
0.4395473897457123,
0.3154354989528656,
0.562118649482727,
-0.3413142263889313,
0.21149607002735138,
0.45334377884864807,
0.2051669955253601,
0.1551450788974762,
0.2922893166542053,
0.12550044059753418,
-0.6139611601829529,
0.4848773777484894,
0.5018234848976135,
-0.00911001767963171,
0.6484652161598206,
-0.08299903571605682,
-0.35065650939941406,
-0.28051358461380005,
-0.7017048001289368,
0.08162396401166916,
-0.5983046293258667,
-0.4520275294780731,
-1.172378659248352,
-0.10555551201105118,
-0.7066963911056519,
-0.17200309038162231,
-0.20018500089645386,
-0.6990185976028442,
0.1027786061167717,
-0.3842977285385132,
-0.06530454009771347,
0.5450891852378845,
-0.057595252990722656,
0.14504998922348022,
-0.5613574385643005,
0.7762719988822937,
-0.10624042898416519,
0.490044504404068,
-0.06637575477361679,
-0.37746259570121765,
-0.06117719039320946,
0.02224491722881794,
-0.0761999562382698,
-0.4457049071788788,
-0.16903835535049438,
0.5082452893257141,
0.7862379550933838,
0.1384754776954651,
-0.08182486146688461,
1.2211298942565918,
-0.3989412784576416,
0.5475066304206848,
-0.057423945516347885,
-0.8081753849983215,
0.6839284896850586,
-0.11955825239419937,
0.20440949499607086,
0.8333927392959595,
0.37998872995376587,
-0.7312132120132446,
-0.2216540426015854,
-0.864859402179718,
-0.9058054089546204,
0.982458770275116,
0.24982646107673645,
-0.4611075818538666,
0.2783593535423279,
0.20267240703105927,
0.5003151297569275,
0.09389742463827133,
-0.5701372027397156,
-0.23362717032432556,
-0.04279638081789017,
-0.2948490083217621,
0.0057442691177129745,
0.0832226350903511,
-0.09873204678297043,
0.19983868300914764,
0.4850466251373291,
-0.023861315101385117,
0.13279074430465698,
0.19213221967220306,
-0.4534232020378113,
-0.3406541645526886,
0.038864925503730774,
0.7870521545410156,
0.6976417303085327,
-0.15870557725429535,
0.5335285663604736,
-0.18732798099517822,
-0.7575044631958008,
0.0862303301692009,
0.7099173665046692,
-0.17345407605171204,
0.0691993311047554,
0.8544169664382935,
0.6887325644493103,
0.6943449974060059,
-0.6361490488052368,
0.43469929695129395,
-0.19160820543766022,
-0.2864854633808136,
-0.13913258910179138,
-0.07911865413188934,
-0.01773335598409176,
-0.19803497195243835,
0.38901007175445557,
0.1463005095720291,
0.27206337451934814,
-0.5897825360298157,
0.6513968110084534,
0.1772541105747223,
-0.6003223061561584,
-0.3479742109775543,
0.6295144557952881,
-0.14501217007637024,
-0.12594476342201233,
0.3504370152950287,
0.21341465413570404,
-0.2633005380630493,
0.5915929079055786,
0.453661173582077,
0.6180374622344971,
0.046480245888233185,
0.422921746969223,
0.20783469080924988,
0.16289733350276947,
-0.09176068753004074,
0.44975051283836365,
-0.4845678508281708,
-0.3404369056224823,
-0.38712599873542786,
-0.6972598433494568,
-0.2750844657421112,
0.13779662549495697,
-0.6037818789482117,
0.01382385939359665,
-0.5578242540359497,
0.07434197515249252,
0.4250507652759552,
0.1633504331111908,
-0.6091687083244324,
0.5252097249031067,
-0.13033631443977356,
1.2326991558074951,
-0.8288052678108215,
0.5776339769363403,
1.0007715225219727,
-0.653956949710846,
-0.7711485028266907,
0.0348382331430912,
0.18790973722934723,
-0.7710855007171631,
0.8669450879096985,
0.2977820634841919,
-0.3117493987083435,
-0.0777650997042656,
-0.08063052594661713,
-0.9731969237327576,
1.179558277130127,
0.3985140323638916,
-0.10526753962039948,
-0.2576996982097626,
-0.09296693652868271,
0.27496108412742615,
-0.2959884703159332,
0.2034074068069458,
0.39252614974975586,
0.5447162389755249,
-0.06902533024549484,
-0.8677394390106201,
0.29412639141082764,
-0.4870780408382416,
0.02608955278992653,
0.4822387993335724,
-0.33208632469177246,
0.685444176197052,
0.03269083797931671,
-0.521737813949585,
-0.06845974177122116,
0.8002527952194214,
0.6400051712989807,
0.24993637204170227,
0.6649091839790344,
0.7713098526000977,
0.7914534211158752,
-0.35293951630592346,
0.8096259236335754,
-0.02281082049012184,
0.18419796228408813,
1.1882143020629883,
-0.14008574187755585,
0.8298502564430237,
0.4435359239578247,
-0.14038603007793427,
0.6113794445991516,
0.5937358140945435,
0.40564095973968506,
0.2862950265407562,
0.34192171692848206,
0.05459029600024223,
-0.1784011870622635,
-0.24227197468280792,
-0.4877484440803528,
0.48622485995292664,
0.24573372304439545,
-0.15894877910614014,
-0.6294845342636108,
0.10312000662088394,
0.10287977755069733,
-0.12561604380607605,
-0.0722680389881134,
0.6677584052085876,
-0.12759087979793549,
-0.4597306549549103,
0.29111066460609436,
0.09196676313877106,
0.3829789459705353,
-0.8664405345916748,
-0.2243308126926422,
-0.37196487188339233,
-0.13342291116714478,
-0.27866560220718384,
-0.6863717436790466,
0.1799231618642807,
-0.36332497000694275,
-0.5473772287368774,
-0.4742712080478668,
0.872455894947052,
-0.4355873167514801,
-0.4444247782230377,
0.15936361253261566,
0.4701651632785797,
0.04625515639781952,
-0.1313101053237915,
-0.6007788777351379,
0.25298190116882324,
-0.2438649833202362,
-0.2691071927547455,
0.29639357328414917,
0.7874654531478882,
-0.4945048987865448,
0.5564925074577332,
0.66257643699646,
0.13425403833389282,
-0.14848744869232178,
0.3729650676250458,
0.8150153160095215,
-0.6201221346855164,
-0.6630375981330872,
-0.30298832058906555,
0.6476806998252869,
-0.1651003062725067,
-0.5828385353088379,
0.3739396333694458,
0.7727721333503723,
1.0645121335983276,
-0.020751377567648888,
0.6579777002334595,
-0.375699520111084,
0.24389375746250153,
-0.4140441119670868,
0.7884529829025269,
-0.6906540989875793,
-0.2631545662879944,
-0.3439154028892517,
-0.6179500818252563,
-0.5595263242721558,
0.7356491684913635,
-0.12151079624891281,
0.13263912498950958,
0.5987720489501953,
0.6115696430206299,
-0.27958181500434875,
-0.11576426774263382,
0.1771995723247528,
-0.005579305347055197,
0.4057364761829376,
0.2827097773551941,
0.445265531539917,
-0.6543013453483582,
0.7191292643547058,
-0.41774633526802063,
-0.44671720266342163,
-0.04183810576796532,
-0.6670187711715698,
-0.42193570733070374,
-0.6642778515815735,
-0.3182764947414398,
-0.02715076319873333,
-0.08966786414384842,
0.6900507211685181,
0.9503546357154846,
-0.7562152147293091,
-0.15472815930843353,
-0.045825473964214325,
0.01126795168966055,
-0.3836800754070282,
-0.29426640272140503,
0.7248867750167847,
-0.23812857270240784,
-0.26756343245506287,
0.4182140529155731,
0.7667016386985779,
0.06350141763687134,
-0.06076157093048096,
0.16405750811100006,
-0.328163206577301,
-0.42465540766716003,
0.7275153994560242,
0.22001251578330994,
-0.6472716331481934,
-0.3034202456474304,
0.08590634167194366,
-0.38551634550094604,
0.14707563817501068,
1.009650707244873,
-0.8358831405639648,
0.15967805683612823,
0.8664840459823608,
0.8001578450202942,
0.5272346138954163,
0.09561906009912491,
0.6091585755348206,
-0.8332070708274841,
-0.07588149607181549,
-0.01191764511168003,
0.5963197946548462,
0.31135788559913635,
-0.47177013754844666,
0.7826849222183228,
0.41767454147338867,
-0.06135405972599983,
-0.758140504360199,
0.1687757819890976,
-1.0672658681869507,
-0.16375064849853516,
0.42286673188209534,
-0.28703582286834717,
-0.09826231002807617,
-0.158256396651268,
-0.5143342018127441,
0.20108743011951447,
-0.3524564206600189,
0.5732821226119995,
0.6271637678146362,
-0.42924177646636963,
-0.52397221326828,
-0.3996060788631439,
0.5719047784805298,
0.35201093554496765,
-1.113330364227295,
0.36028212308883667,
0.7991148829460144,
0.10244672745466232,
0.3123985826969147,
1.1592742204666138,
-0.12641854584217072,
0.40691420435905457,
0.1120343804359436,
-0.05645452439785004,
-0.20414875447750092,
-0.5261558890342712,
-0.0053946212865412235,
0.5253124237060547,
-0.24424393475055695,
0.14940670132637024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08754v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08754v1
|
StructuralSleight: Automated Jailbreak Attacks on Large Language Models Utilizing Uncommon Text-Encoded Structure
| 2024-06-13T02:24:08 | 2024-06-13T02:24:08 |
Bangxin Li, Hengrui Xing, Chao Huang, Jin Qian, Huangqing Xiao, Linfeng Feng, Cong Tian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are widely used in natural language processing
but face the risk of jailbreak attacks that maliciously induce them to generate
harmful content. Existing jailbreak attacks, including character-level and
context-level attacks, mainly focus on the prompt of the plain text without
specifically exploring the significant influence of its structure. In this
paper, we focus on studying how prompt structure contributes to the jailbreak
attack. We introduce a novel structure-level attack method based on tail
structures that are rarely used during LLM training, which we refer to as
Uncommon Text-Encoded Structure (UTES). We extensively study 12 UTESs templates
and 6 obfuscation methods to build an effective automated jailbreak tool named
StructuralSleight that contains three escalating attack strategies: Structural
Attack, Structural and Character/Context Obfuscation Attack, and Fully
Obfuscated Structural Attack. Extensive experiments on existing LLMs show that
StructuralSleight significantly outperforms baseline methods. In particular,
the attack success rate reaches 94.62\% on GPT-4o, which has not been addressed
by state-of-the-art techniques.
|
[
-0.05421524494886398,
-1.2588735818862915,
0.5365978479385376,
0.2869832515716553,
-0.35431361198425293,
0.3943512737751007,
0.25073161721229553,
-0.4383949935436249,
0.18857812881469727,
0.5441429018974304,
-0.45574188232421875,
-0.7820299863815308,
-0.5048943161964417,
0.19189517199993134,
-0.4050631821155548,
0.8300114870071411,
0.06553389877080917,
-0.0455535352230072,
0.526167631149292,
0.008026008494198322,
-0.681518018245697,
-0.6212320327758789,
-0.31982865929603577,
0.3538278639316559,
0.27392056584358215,
0.2885887324810028,
0.53705894947052,
0.6522620916366577,
0.5038120150566101,
0.35168275237083435,
-0.46540841460227966,
-0.16519445180892944,
-0.40617281198501587,
0.2946365773677826,
0.010587654076516628,
-0.43054404854774475,
-0.3602506220340729,
-0.27435174584388733,
0.4953612685203552,
0.6396352052688599,
-0.13112773001194,
-0.07174108177423477,
-0.024778015911579132,
0.8330045938491821,
-0.7119792699813843,
-0.18376068770885468,
-1.0122748613357544,
-0.017712824046611786,
-0.5514126420021057,
-0.04731496423482895,
-0.5723462104797363,
-0.1567443609237671,
-0.3788394331932068,
-0.22130779922008514,
-0.12042050063610077,
0.38370317220687866,
0.5296880602836609,
0.15477831661701202,
-0.32605668902397156,
-0.33666372299194336,
-0.002142013283446431,
0.4391247034072876,
-0.7285351157188416,
0.23117414116859436,
0.27498573064804077,
0.1483817845582962,
-0.5206210613250732,
-0.3046663701534271,
-0.1438460797071457,
-0.687861442565918,
0.03284987062215805,
-0.17646101117134094,
-0.4445057511329651,
0.40295395255088806,
0.3535044193267822,
0.20447376370429993,
-0.7048615217208862,
0.3680955171585083,
-0.5680283904075623,
0.0232077706605196,
0.36470723152160645,
0.19410063326358795,
0.7844811081886292,
-0.6874255537986755,
-0.44944435358047485,
0.1300937533378601,
-0.8588495254516602,
0.03933447226881981,
0.6105546355247498,
0.2756973206996918,
-0.27740973234176636,
0.8543515801429749,
-0.24664168059825897,
0.7573437690734863,
0.16127784550189972,
0.20985384285449982,
0.15929770469665527,
0.002429727930575609,
-0.31510862708091736,
0.42201849818229675,
0.7670351266860962,
0.27958473563194275,
0.05948489531874657,
-0.34136006236076355,
-0.15426720678806305,
-0.15616893768310547,
0.34409719705581665,
-0.8107296824455261,
-0.05679592862725258,
0.4443871080875397,
-0.29403290152549744,
-0.6822233200073242,
0.25593000650405884,
-0.6290698051452637,
-0.4411422610282898,
0.3494841158390045,
0.14467479288578033,
-0.8109752535820007,
0.1811480075120926,
0.10783548653125763,
-0.34985262155532837,
0.31377550959587097,
0.10445404052734375,
-0.7884092330932617,
0.2143726795911789,
0.556298017501831,
1.1667908430099487,
-0.2643192410469055,
-0.19787286221981049,
-1.0115464925765991,
0.29152292013168335,
-0.29543209075927734,
0.7168353199958801,
-0.39421358704566956,
-0.4287099242210388,
-0.19755436480045319,
-0.09580156207084656,
0.08438879996538162,
-0.2659229040145874,
0.5758441090583801,
-0.5858202576637268,
-0.31421172618865967,
0.30444246530532837,
-0.4851554036140442,
-0.018195899203419685,
0.34273943305015564,
-0.9446887373924255,
0.7732805013656616,
0.1087336614727974,
-0.978482186794281,
-0.0715150535106659,
-0.6416237354278564,
-0.6097028851509094,
0.17269764840602875,
-0.16140878200531006,
-0.26214179396629333,
0.5045334696769714,
0.4061962962150574,
0.5157678127288818,
0.16357830166816711,
0.22585438191890717,
-0.43719786405563354,
-0.4589887857437134,
0.17269329726696014,
-0.33826151490211487,
1.0124446153640747,
0.25138452649116516,
-0.5309880375862122,
0.12773936986923218,
-0.926847517490387,
-0.07548924535512924,
0.40195581316947937,
-0.14285768568515778,
-0.8418450951576233,
-0.17560860514640808,
-0.06377267837524414,
-0.2816099524497986,
0.2106708437204361,
-0.7413787245750427,
0.5582885146141052,
-0.8928763270378113,
0.5787543654441833,
0.7119266986846924,
0.32513412833213806,
0.402788370847702,
0.23297323286533356,
0.35245582461357117,
-0.08096645772457123,
0.12835034728050232,
-0.4041774272918701,
-0.162278950214386,
-0.1015881672501564,
-0.25071996450424194,
-0.1772589534521103,
0.5678575038909912,
-0.526080310344696,
0.2564341127872467,
0.2292332798242569,
-0.6825054883956909,
-0.24214164912700653,
0.25629180669784546,
0.5654619932174683,
0.31240010261535645,
0.47851061820983887,
0.024147428572177887,
-0.6330423355102539,
-0.7211874723434448,
-0.8635050058364868,
-0.1634531170129776,
-0.026647688820958138,
-0.058298803865909576,
0.47075155377388,
-0.16081368923187256,
0.6534122824668884,
-0.6292285919189453,
-0.16485841572284698,
-0.6090843677520752,
0.08472107350826263,
0.4144953191280365,
0.5736507177352905,
0.8290535807609558,
-0.5493037700653076,
-0.4017984867095947,
-0.3510721027851105,
-0.7472211718559265,
-0.2099110335111618,
-0.22972464561462402,
0.3027591109275818,
0.16197477281093597,
0.751470148563385,
-0.6077782511711121,
0.4155859351158142,
0.483984112739563,
-0.6102290749549866,
0.7548840045928955,
-0.02025957591831684,
0.0690382793545723,
-0.9141903519630432,
-0.18222549557685852,
0.07076387107372284,
0.047580912709236145,
-0.6843725442886353,
0.439292848110199,
0.22490240633487701,
-0.16090910136699677,
-0.5525882244110107,
0.5432750582695007,
-0.7565562725067139,
0.001872714958153665,
-0.029859071597456932,
0.02162504382431507,
-0.11139721423387527,
0.43194344639778137,
-0.35080283880233765,
0.6719768643379211,
0.3718346357345581,
-0.09704048931598663,
0.14933092892169952,
0.2920181155204773,
-0.4175958037376404,
0.4427538812160492,
-0.9482837319374084,
0.2834746539592743,
-0.11022176593542099,
0.0862637311220169,
-1.0410453081130981,
-0.3299657106399536,
0.24241670966148376,
-0.49279266595840454,
0.29279929399490356,
-0.27044478058815,
-0.44194847345352173,
-0.26672032475471497,
-0.7257640361785889,
0.12395396828651428,
0.21041852235794067,
-0.6896204352378845,
0.5079696178436279,
0.09099967777729034,
-0.3547819256782532,
-0.656813383102417,
-0.49765872955322266,
0.5040690302848816,
-0.44853368401527405,
-0.650225043296814,
0.4054819345474243,
-0.003961085807532072,
-0.5396564602851868,
-0.15417645871639252,
-0.36404743790626526,
-0.1575927883386612,
0.5893455147743225,
0.4658327102661133,
0.5439303517341614,
-0.09602347016334534,
-0.4581020176410675,
0.3604518175125122,
0.15755130350589752,
0.20250394940376282,
-0.07722323387861252,
0.6661311388015747,
-0.36724042892456055,
-0.33699822425842285,
-0.5286917090415955,
0.4318464696407318,
0.5352227687835693,
-0.15736231207847595,
0.8008847236633301,
0.060144491493701935,
-0.14013659954071045,
-0.2620673179626465,
-0.5202875733375549,
-0.009746936149895191,
-0.5457891821861267,
0.8487074375152588,
-0.5387165546417236,
-1.0350046157836914,
0.2964858412742615,
-0.01506069302558899,
0.19232846796512604,
0.19309987127780914,
0.19366811215877533,
-0.17576976120471954,
1.0381981134414673,
0.7479524612426758,
-0.27778756618499756,
0.40390506386756897,
0.16441792249679565,
-0.010213297791779041,
-0.770487368106842,
-0.28515151143074036,
-0.8071867823600769,
0.018533706665039062,
-0.2933124005794525,
0.03521206974983215,
0.100336454808712,
0.7380456328392029,
-0.4165646433830261,
0.731509268283844,
-0.4598989486694336,
0.6009449362754822,
0.1798418164253235,
0.032903801649808884,
0.522587776184082,
0.10070153325796127,
-0.3385269343852997,
0.09079480916261673,
-0.4362954795360565,
-0.3408166468143463,
0.9805120825767517,
0.3666287660598755,
1.040709376335144,
0.04159378260374069,
0.8397986888885498,
0.42683467268943787,
0.058393444865942,
-0.8287945985794067,
0.46898823976516724,
-0.002463639946654439,
-0.40897151827812195,
-0.23918209969997406,
-0.5070475339889526,
-0.7024645209312439,
0.19509616494178772,
0.10519462823867798,
-1.1576391458511353,
-0.04887036979198456,
0.005011568311601877,
-0.17726127803325653,
0.5412249565124512,
-0.6365821957588196,
0.7309862375259399,
-0.5181735157966614,
-0.056404851377010345,
0.02172238565981388,
-0.7351998686790466,
0.5786082148551941,
-0.21814897656440735,
0.35701873898506165,
0.16407530009746552,
0.13176192343235016,
0.8283228278160095,
-0.630038857460022,
0.9336355924606323,
-0.25629356503486633,
-0.11378119885921478,
0.12857137620449066,
0.31081485748291016,
0.9608920812606812,
0.24972254037857056,
-0.0053552561439573765,
0.43348458409309387,
-0.2107393741607666,
-0.17792265117168427,
-0.5191810727119446,
0.4372043013572693,
-0.57791668176651,
-0.7603713274002075,
-0.320050448179245,
-0.40767428278923035,
-0.18513186275959015,
0.14643259346485138,
0.3979874551296234,
0.45941248536109924,
-0.2999976575374603,
0.22654488682746887,
0.47951075434684753,
-0.3177033066749573,
0.5207020044326782,
0.49528855085372925,
0.05235178396105766,
-0.5720778107643127,
0.49181658029556274,
-0.0745602697134018,
0.16500794887542725,
0.39310744404792786,
0.0860857143998146,
-0.07099845260381699,
-0.9505265355110168,
-0.44372114539146423,
0.04588441550731659,
-0.6527115702629089,
-0.38754087686538696,
-0.7994301915168762,
-0.2977276146411896,
-0.31018757820129395,
-0.4930918514728546,
-0.24072644114494324,
-0.3995506465435028,
0.10212577879428864,
-0.2990226447582245,
0.39294368028640747,
0.5748223662376404,
0.14780746400356293,
0.7087830901145935,
-1.0857741832733154,
0.4854120910167694,
-0.10825943946838379,
0.0717279314994812,
-0.11700184643268585,
-0.49669456481933594,
-0.08094377815723419,
-0.369319885969162,
-0.12710879743099213,
-1.4252307415008545,
0.4472135901451111,
-0.02669789269566536,
0.5387972593307495,
0.42183971405029297,
0.1668592393398285,
0.5349181890487671,
-0.8842632174491882,
0.5471078157424927,
0.5926392674446106,
-1.0808113813400269,
0.8360970616340637,
-0.31777873635292053,
0.19422008097171783,
0.6729234457015991,
0.2626603841781616,
-0.3489011228084564,
-0.7803478837013245,
-0.44604557752609253,
-1.0401742458343506,
0.6091971397399902,
0.3247986435890198,
0.12487789243459702,
-0.13103087246418,
0.3907777667045593,
-0.054925888776779175,
0.19790415465831757,
-0.8786160349845886,
-0.21994268894195557,
-0.2944759726524353,
-0.20467010140419006,
0.5831412076950073,
-0.3598283529281616,
0.086333267390728,
0.014366905204951763,
0.33416998386383057,
0.14736348390579224,
-0.22911575436592102,
0.1541227400302887,
-0.5328725576400757,
0.2139289230108261,
0.71015465259552,
0.1686926931142807,
0.09515168517827988,
-0.4597124457359314,
0.04533444344997406,
0.1929839551448822,
-0.9783419370651245,
0.38573819398880005,
0.09966059029102325,
-0.37326857447624207,
0.01972474902868271,
0.48769739270210266,
0.8477505445480347,
0.4080439507961273,
-0.8224858641624451,
0.3481673300266266,
0.006651168689131737,
-0.09299664944410324,
-0.21547603607177734,
0.28071436285972595,
-0.2667587101459503,
0.3627927005290985,
0.6812214255332947,
-0.12112556397914886,
0.14989963173866272,
-0.5475589632987976,
0.181503564119339,
0.5573779940605164,
-0.4854672849178314,
-0.36850959062576294,
0.6119047999382019,
0.13326573371887207,
-0.24961194396018982,
0.630012035369873,
-0.03316112607717514,
-0.4626125395298004,
0.7961581349372864,
0.8511372804641724,
1.0196822881698608,
-0.4445767402648926,
0.14035415649414062,
0.2300061285495758,
0.735472559928894,
0.07571718841791153,
0.12927328050136566,
-0.02688615582883358,
-0.48998603224754333,
-0.5243515372276306,
-0.8377276659011841,
-0.25402218103408813,
0.3019368648529053,
-0.6463005542755127,
0.2218111902475357,
-0.7167000770568848,
0.20718248188495636,
-0.26266059279441833,
-0.24214118719100952,
-0.04629141092300415,
-0.0052220867946743965,
0.03185798600316048,
1.1238762140274048,
-0.4829871952533722,
0.6481860876083374,
0.6867939829826355,
-0.23525302112102509,
-0.8865332007408142,
-0.0016939829802140594,
0.314834862947464,
-0.6999288201332092,
0.9662649035453796,
0.5971028804779053,
-0.10330074280500412,
0.13799501955509186,
-0.7275567054748535,
-0.7845024466514587,
0.6053242683410645,
0.25930318236351013,
-0.8665828108787537,
-0.5775626301765442,
-0.015454022213816643,
-0.08168915659189224,
-0.14445984363555908,
0.011832371354103088,
0.6214054226875305,
0.5857473015785217,
-0.04426874965429306,
-0.3729446530342102,
0.3349660038948059,
-0.3475760221481323,
-0.14942698180675507,
0.28781595826148987,
-0.17311570048332214,
0.705082356929779,
-0.5022687911987305,
-0.22065311670303345,
0.2870849370956421,
0.6260126829147339,
0.75596684217453,
0.04090850427746773,
0.5865620374679565,
0.5100866556167603,
0.4844518303871155,
0.12795132398605347,
0.7895771861076355,
-0.30442890524864197,
0.01569497585296631,
1.3070260286331177,
-0.29540395736694336,
0.8475877046585083,
0.549907386302948,
0.11841555684804916,
0.5622351765632629,
0.2588641047477722,
-0.48824456334114075,
0.578143298625946,
0.2642176151275635,
0.17858950793743134,
0.13367916643619537,
0.432748407125473,
-0.341471403837204,
0.5706231594085693,
0.37211787700653076,
-0.049964431673288345,
-0.5711721777915955,
0.4228295385837555,
0.4281213879585266,
0.025526244193315506,
-0.5147008299827576,
0.6926857233047485,
0.16754376888275146,
-0.1504736840724945,
0.5200782418251038,
0.4279908239841461,
0.7514137625694275,
-0.8682580590248108,
0.06808260828256607,
-0.28873205184936523,
-0.2576334476470947,
-0.29549068212509155,
-0.5978595614433289,
0.3854997754096985,
0.5977227091789246,
0.1200023964047432,
0.18723958730697632,
0.7171192169189453,
0.19973784685134888,
-0.24986626207828522,
0.3927168846130371,
0.1978362649679184,
-0.08144038170576096,
-0.49271538853645325,
-0.5746517777442932,
0.23758913576602936,
-0.05987913906574249,
-0.6046003699302673,
0.36032700538635254,
0.29783207178115845,
-0.16015276312828064,
0.44046443700790405,
0.7243528366088867,
0.1495913416147232,
-0.018481023609638214,
-0.009984279982745647,
1.1250184774398804,
-1.0103554725646973,
-0.7696492671966553,
-1.3124949932098389,
0.5169291496276855,
-0.3182012438774109,
-0.11383020132780075,
1.0574820041656494,
0.47058653831481934,
0.47564104199409485,
0.14497201144695282,
0.6490535140037537,
-0.13292455673217773,
-0.03739893436431885,
-0.9582943916320801,
0.8519623875617981,
-0.44281890988349915,
0.5997530817985535,
-0.6934785842895508,
-0.9263480305671692,
-0.26006579399108887,
0.40427035093307495,
-0.3418145179748535,
-0.31382057070732117,
0.9109731912612915,
0.4749390184879303,
0.20044243335723877,
0.03713512048125267,
0.15469472110271454,
0.7348904609680176,
0.3625532388687134,
0.3952569365501404,
0.9327630996704102,
-0.1290547251701355,
0.6663673520088196,
0.1720430701971054,
-0.38713252544403076,
-0.17004366219043732,
-0.7330266237258911,
-1.370230793952942,
-0.1084040179848671,
-0.017441047355532646,
-0.28857046365737915,
0.4552651047706604,
0.6461058259010315,
0.2833324372768402,
-0.5754522085189819,
-0.03500223532319069,
-0.5495153665542603,
0.0154421953484416,
0.04628222435712814,
-0.2559813857078552,
0.5438774228096008,
-0.49503907561302185,
-0.27884426712989807,
1.02762770652771,
0.6804441809654236,
-0.0013896414311602712,
-0.12290745228528976,
0.24791371822357178,
0.0510048009455204,
0.06819853186607361,
0.4828126132488251,
0.31073856353759766,
-0.4892703592777252,
0.014843967743217945,
0.09357865899801254,
-0.2048467993736267,
0.1577712446451187,
0.586451530456543,
-0.7139331102371216,
-0.13621336221694946,
0.40853065252304077,
0.7275144457817078,
0.1822666972875595,
0.24509745836257935,
0.34913894534111023,
-0.8841707706451416,
0.42568913102149963,
0.13471917808055878,
0.5209352970123291,
0.08519182354211807,
-0.6212642788887024,
0.33312952518463135,
0.25402140617370605,
-0.03156418353319168,
-1.0778207778930664,
0.3210328221321106,
-1.0828601121902466,
-0.8785465955734253,
0.9696844816207886,
-0.07683868706226349,
-0.7422098517417908,
-0.26442235708236694,
-0.3244689106941223,
-0.10312847793102264,
-0.555931806564331,
0.6813111901283264,
0.1891632080078125,
0.2449617236852646,
0.009274675510823727,
-0.5461191534996033,
0.2154419869184494,
0.19881273806095123,
-0.9798765778541565,
0.09670267254114151,
0.4704793095588684,
0.2575172185897827,
0.011742368340492249,
0.24451349675655365,
-0.4011315703392029,
0.17150650918483734,
0.08289188891649246,
-0.22362597286701202,
-0.5140761137008667,
-0.5085809826850891,
-0.40217193961143494,
0.6442553997039795,
-0.24752061069011688,
0.19711047410964966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08747v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08747v1
|
StreamBench: Towards Benchmarking Continuous Improvement of Language Agents
| 2024-06-13T02:08:28 | 2024-06-13T02:08:28 |
Cheng-Kuang Wu, Zhi Rui Tam, Chieh-Yen Lin, Yun-Nung Chen, Hung-yi Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recent works have shown that large language model (LLM) agents are able to
improve themselves from experience, which is an important ability for
continuous enhancement post-deployment. However, existing benchmarks primarily
evaluate their innate capabilities and do not assess their ability to improve
over time. To address this gap, we introduce StreamBench, a pioneering
benchmark designed to evaluate the continuous improvement of LLM agents over an
input-feedback sequence. StreamBench simulates an online learning environment
where LLMs receive a continuous flow of feedback stream and iteratively enhance
their performance. In addition, we propose several simple yet effective
baselines for improving LLMs on StreamBench, and provide a comprehensive
analysis to identify critical components that contribute to successful
streaming strategies. Our work serves as a stepping stone towards developing
effective online learning strategies for LLMs, paving the way for more adaptive
AI systems in streaming scenarios.
|
[
-0.4216570258140564,
-0.6351750493049622,
0.47450292110443115,
0.05981908738613129,
-0.09477037936449051,
0.7684850692749023,
-0.546226441860199,
-0.37336838245391846,
0.11717848479747772,
0.25503236055374146,
-0.51826411485672,
-0.3303437829017639,
-0.6916218996047974,
0.020821142941713333,
-0.521700918674469,
0.7121924161911011,
-0.18169474601745605,
0.18004608154296875,
-0.2454884648323059,
-0.24496349692344666,
-0.4874539375305176,
-0.2539074420928955,
-1.0711922645568848,
-0.4830116629600525,
0.5403885841369629,
0.3034203052520752,
0.43390658497810364,
0.5637373328208923,
0.5717691779136658,
0.45357584953308105,
0.12157279253005981,
0.14258761703968048,
-0.9478227496147156,
0.5307309627532959,
-0.2520618140697479,
-0.5017390251159668,
-0.3306710422039032,
-0.2515431344509125,
0.9267510771751404,
0.6475221514701843,
-0.438446581363678,
0.22688208520412445,
0.2386760115623474,
0.7074292302131653,
-0.7842795848846436,
0.23838110268115997,
-0.4013516902923584,
-0.10136859118938446,
-0.21613121032714844,
-0.21840229630470276,
-0.40736132860183716,
-0.6303505301475525,
-0.17809219658374786,
-0.3750983476638794,
0.2329695075750351,
-0.2391318678855896,
0.7737064957618713,
0.47128748893737793,
0.04483034089207649,
-0.009503637440502644,
-0.9340643286705017,
0.49628591537475586,
-0.906626284122467,
0.4884161353111267,
0.07383756339550018,
0.6520743370056152,
-0.28198596835136414,
-1.0091713666915894,
-0.35247617959976196,
-0.34015873074531555,
0.3614809811115265,
0.2139163464307785,
0.03853387013077736,
0.04277341067790985,
0.1390613615512848,
0.10775577276945114,
-0.5185814499855042,
0.11375140398740768,
-0.05732958763837814,
-0.13771197199821472,
0.756983757019043,
0.2207626849412918,
0.1175743117928505,
0.631228506565094,
-0.07339945435523987,
-0.44176560640335083,
-0.5471305847167969,
0.2680095434188843,
0.2912638485431671,
0.26190897822380066,
-0.013484704308211803,
0.16477255523204803,
-0.40325042605400085,
0.5208364725112915,
-0.11814464628696442,
-0.034696854650974274,
0.46200835704803467,
0.0735330656170845,
0.1569807529449463,
-0.10478425770998001,
0.21789520978927612,
0.3033510446548462,
0.19708873331546783,
-0.30153533816337585,
-0.34533098340034485,
0.11429817229509354,
0.5123510956764221,
-0.7944978475570679,
-0.12842214107513428,
0.36504387855529785,
-0.270097017288208,
-0.17429743707180023,
0.041225045919418335,
-0.6428995728492737,
-0.7865627408027649,
-0.2688598036766052,
0.19732129573822021,
-0.30199897289276123,
-0.45254528522491455,
-0.3644649386405945,
-0.41491466760635376,
0.39532577991485596,
0.5187459588050842,
-0.574530303478241,
0.6365532279014587,
1.043308973312378,
0.8878160715103149,
-0.38635674118995667,
-0.6203444004058838,
-0.9793143272399902,
-0.048578813672065735,
-0.34485504031181335,
1.158087134361267,
-0.45536500215530396,
-0.33387291431427,
0.3200182616710663,
-0.17372216284275055,
0.1097397580742836,
-0.8412103056907654,
0.37517115473747253,
-0.47988057136535645,
-0.46897220611572266,
-0.08916166424751282,
-1.1643069982528687,
-0.011403744108974934,
0.30846863985061646,
-0.6307030916213989,
1.1259812116622925,
0.311623215675354,
-0.23673488199710846,
0.26946350932121277,
-0.6437507271766663,
-0.12453792244195938,
0.46018874645233154,
0.007635169196873903,
-0.22740374505519867,
0.20703406631946564,
-0.14744825661182404,
0.12114179879426956,
-0.038959406316280365,
0.10269811004400253,
-0.694140613079071,
-0.5187168121337891,
0.5311537384986877,
-0.3214408755302429,
0.3208605945110321,
0.026662757620215416,
-0.5267062783241272,
0.43858572840690613,
-0.750420093536377,
0.49813735485076904,
-0.02488514594733715,
-0.6235830783843994,
0.20412397384643555,
0.5382130146026611,
0.17127640545368195,
-0.1313152313232422,
-0.0899251401424408,
-0.545046329498291,
0.102080799639225,
-0.31921765208244324,
0.3035333454608917,
0.8932611346244812,
-0.04903306066989899,
0.13102464377880096,
-0.3438152074813843,
0.6712488532066345,
-0.4193020462989807,
0.2000306099653244,
-0.057334210723638535,
-0.007846525870263577,
-0.9412490725517273,
-0.31072333455085754,
0.47692131996154785,
0.31755712628364563,
-0.8625529408454895,
0.1383604258298874,
-0.4970285892486572,
-0.6369414329528809,
-0.5933089852333069,
0.8355240225791931,
0.32533299922943115,
0.05746384710073471,
0.17862007021903992,
-0.6530514359474182,
-0.4404141902923584,
-0.3877664804458618,
-0.2262059599161148,
-0.2558172643184662,
-0.12836620211601257,
0.05152300372719765,
0.06780152767896652,
-0.29092076420783997,
0.8482469916343689,
-0.14810587465763092,
-0.008348861709237099,
-0.5903964042663574,
0.15902702510356903,
-0.10424928367137909,
0.06355993449687958,
0.3464463949203491,
-0.2018505036830902,
-0.5604461431503296,
-0.15813638269901276,
-0.7756003737449646,
-0.3338824510574341,
0.10308388620615005,
-0.02218882367014885,
0.2491956353187561,
0.8070957064628601,
-0.14592769742012024,
0.27368924021720886,
0.7707347273826599,
-0.24826161563396454,
0.2723972499370575,
-0.21530470252037048,
-0.22492621839046478,
-0.48937347531318665,
-0.11426354199647903,
-0.31703928112983704,
-0.49692302942276,
-0.5926220417022705,
0.4025726616382599,
0.07064932584762573,
-0.11061257123947144,
-0.5607720017433167,
0.7292253375053406,
-0.38223108649253845,
-0.12664750218391418,
-0.6959303021430969,
0.3995465934276581,
-0.2746676206588745,
0.4487297236919403,
-0.08139543235301971,
0.632788360118866,
0.5134535431861877,
-0.4469447433948517,
0.5979258418083191,
-0.24274876713752747,
-0.2898487150669098,
0.6337332725524902,
-0.6635591387748718,
0.32993340492248535,
-0.073572538793087,
0.45035839080810547,
-0.9269903302192688,
-0.049135852605104446,
-0.0003152912249788642,
-0.22512339055538177,
0.30955231189727783,
0.11125379800796509,
-0.4636801481246948,
-0.22393476963043213,
-0.3317421078681946,
-0.014378043822944164,
0.5423228740692139,
-0.5407127141952515,
0.7098039388656616,
0.19282259047031403,
-0.28804636001586914,
-0.27752652764320374,
-0.10337953269481659,
0.1540653258562088,
0.1854100525379181,
-0.4433347284793854,
0.08647936582565308,
-0.2640622556209564,
-0.4345210790634155,
-0.023182447999715805,
-0.014741362072527409,
0.0007215498480945826,
0.34123533964157104,
0.3029867112636566,
-0.013053758069872856,
-0.3496672213077545,
0.21847382187843323,
-0.35459694266319275,
-0.16641764342784882,
0.03153739124536514,
-0.17642414569854736,
0.6288697719573975,
-0.3972718119621277,
-0.40834659337997437,
-0.19536584615707397,
0.18252350389957428,
0.09590423107147217,
-0.19764606654644012,
0.6191951632499695,
0.549186646938324,
0.01301463320851326,
-0.7757374048233032,
-0.7275776863098145,
-0.2517485022544861,
-0.5394096374511719,
0.35149645805358887,
-0.21844367682933807,
-0.8516449928283691,
0.47224804759025574,
-0.5439586639404297,
0.15024128556251526,
0.17284449934959412,
0.4297730326652527,
-0.427042692899704,
0.7118288278579712,
0.793721616268158,
-0.03882494941353798,
0.6764444708824158,
-0.2924726903438568,
-0.21981197595596313,
-0.5725517868995667,
0.10736478120088577,
-0.484012246131897,
-0.37785008549690247,
-0.3512798547744751,
-0.4185220003128052,
0.04320555925369263,
0.2480059713125229,
-0.1397068053483963,
0.11258415132761002,
0.013747588731348515,
0.6121340990066528,
0.3757528066635132,
0.0826042965054512,
0.10519986599683762,
-0.40694430470466614,
-0.007866957224905491,
0.2451588362455368,
-0.6374919414520264,
-0.46320298314094543,
1.0070887804031372,
0.46033379435539246,
0.599858283996582,
0.310212641954422,
0.6970673203468323,
0.645750105381012,
0.7697836756706238,
-0.6204009056091309,
0.5388175845146179,
0.2975257933139801,
-0.419965535402298,
-0.4775090515613556,
-0.2800696790218353,
-0.9832611083984375,
0.1626182347536087,
0.012830435298383236,
-0.6676248908042908,
-0.10006271302700043,
0.1747981160879135,
-0.04616786539554596,
0.20225538313388824,
-0.5965713262557983,
0.8871009349822998,
-0.46575728058815,
-0.6304132342338562,
-0.5193939805030823,
-0.40232422947883606,
-0.19160625338554382,
-0.032601602375507355,
0.1484575718641281,
-0.4886808395385742,
-0.2726917564868927,
0.2951689660549164,
-0.7905654907226562,
0.8993449807167053,
-0.3869348466396332,
0.07507903128862381,
0.3532280921936035,
0.1309412270784378,
0.5201321244239807,
-0.26128342747688293,
-0.06419461965560913,
0.16392911970615387,
-0.10816050320863724,
-0.7221537232398987,
-0.6994141936302185,
0.5624166131019592,
-0.9738990664482117,
-0.4605272114276886,
-0.2510620057582855,
-0.2223781943321228,
-0.5260087847709656,
0.017851632088422775,
-0.2997303903102875,
0.3807324171066284,
-0.5470518469810486,
0.3482901453971863,
0.33119383454322815,
-0.029240792617201805,
0.8808074593544006,
0.8568858504295349,
-0.3736276626586914,
-0.31707876920700073,
0.9634244441986084,
-0.08036138862371445,
0.4824848771095276,
0.23919014632701874,
0.006345306057482958,
-0.39168989658355713,
-0.7375646233558655,
-0.42706790566444397,
0.14422892034053802,
-1.1355279684066772,
-0.07157985121011734,
-0.1666257232427597,
-0.31809893250465393,
-0.17795464396476746,
-0.09203517436981201,
-0.5634775757789612,
-0.028678685426712036,
0.10398784279823303,
-0.19239899516105652,
0.21973320841789246,
0.7767966985702515,
-0.04841833934187889,
0.43200385570526123,
-0.8569313287734985,
-0.017559142783284187,
0.3183477818965912,
0.8309744596481323,
0.10156892240047455,
-0.52728271484375,
-0.473003625869751,
-0.33118367195129395,
-0.5784491300582886,
-0.4875938892364502,
0.31834322214126587,
0.4544633626937866,
0.9346489906311035,
0.4882975220680237,
-0.11946609616279602,
0.5868833661079407,
-0.5418767929077148,
0.6632235050201416,
-0.24685464799404144,
-1.082824468612671,
0.4477168619632721,
-0.1523980349302292,
0.5607333779335022,
0.8187576532363892,
0.08333762735128403,
-0.5892592072486877,
-0.7841464877128601,
-0.6175035238265991,
-0.8059625625610352,
0.4162323474884033,
0.1628553867340088,
0.08286316692829132,
0.3286519944667816,
0.08553292602300644,
0.06938739866018295,
0.15741290152072906,
-0.3727096915245056,
-0.1221199557185173,
-0.25039511919021606,
0.025428779423236847,
-0.5550130009651184,
0.06992190331220627,
0.03330634906888008,
-0.1828024536371231,
0.7827783823013306,
-0.38436904549598694,
0.05007819086313248,
-0.102982297539711,
-0.3644846975803375,
-0.11655060946941376,
0.10081888735294342,
0.5739729404449463,
1.0943620204925537,
-0.24303267896175385,
-0.016024582087993622,
0.41819626092910767,
-0.28875988721847534,
0.13595044612884521,
0.08015265315771103,
0.0315617099404335,
0.21626335382461548,
0.6847376227378845,
0.8249312043190002,
0.30294281244277954,
-1.1574749946594238,
0.3041297197341919,
-0.2676961421966553,
-0.01000598631799221,
-0.5426654815673828,
0.41840752959251404,
0.3228060007095337,
0.40165793895721436,
0.37002092599868774,
-0.1619756519794464,
-0.013760702684521675,
-0.6760162711143494,
0.23450613021850586,
0.17951036989688873,
-0.5112432837486267,
-0.0741124376654625,
0.4313771426677704,
0.5806592702865601,
-0.7525903582572937,
0.6772962808609009,
-0.11888214945793152,
-0.38834503293037415,
0.6192038059234619,
0.08788280934095383,
1.0844333171844482,
-0.3010878562927246,
0.2689037621021271,
0.24830682575702667,
0.06794241070747375,
-0.05709582567214966,
0.23370584845542908,
-0.17504294216632843,
-0.6718935370445251,
-0.38963231444358826,
-0.658237099647522,
-0.8425639271736145,
-0.20575621724128723,
-0.49025022983551025,
0.23657560348510742,
-0.5716211199760437,
-0.25956109166145325,
0.12270906567573547,
0.04406365752220154,
-0.6926454305648804,
-0.1822577267885208,
0.49044689536094666,
0.9690119028091431,
-0.5661912560462952,
1.033058524131775,
0.3939157724380493,
-0.41855359077453613,
-0.831855058670044,
-0.07822629064321518,
0.242659330368042,
-0.6863065361976624,
0.4547225832939148,
0.10483437031507492,
-0.22908291220664978,
0.05826308950781822,
-0.47710034251213074,
-0.9441045522689819,
0.9313927888870239,
0.3390863537788391,
-0.6845102310180664,
0.4547636806964874,
0.2653140723705292,
1.034713625907898,
-0.38090845942497253,
0.699589729309082,
0.5237649083137512,
0.3595532178878784,
0.07561051845550537,
-0.8114672899246216,
-0.21769283711910248,
-0.5811572670936584,
0.35827282071113586,
0.21122372150421143,
-0.6654333472251892,
0.5372592210769653,
0.073280930519104,
-0.19584740698337555,
-0.06406992673873901,
0.6546478867530823,
0.040385302156209946,
0.27919748425483704,
0.46757781505584717,
0.4587801992893219,
0.7094507217407227,
-0.21492566168308258,
1.3197458982467651,
-0.40667724609375,
0.21330386400222778,
1.5451728105545044,
-0.6827117204666138,
1.4316617250442505,
0.38044822216033936,
-0.2942841947078705,
0.7639927268028259,
0.572253942489624,
-0.043094538152217865,
0.4074985384941101,
0.6223665475845337,
-0.4312894344329834,
-0.19163726270198822,
-0.18041615188121796,
-0.23083509504795074,
0.2615582048892975,
0.2999153435230255,
-0.0758296549320221,
-0.2399989664554596,
0.002975924639031291,
-0.19997765123844147,
0.2510887682437897,
-0.41552355885505676,
1.1184548139572144,
-0.021746935322880745,
-0.7962930202484131,
0.75260329246521,
-0.048811253160238266,
0.40368250012397766,
-0.7427015900611877,
-0.04674123600125313,
-0.5785910487174988,
0.7946673631668091,
-0.04431915283203125,
-0.5090551376342773,
0.16852229833602905,
0.09271065145730972,
0.12008261680603027,
-0.272535502910614,
0.555982232093811,
-0.09290286153554916,
-0.41449278593063354,
0.7483740448951721,
0.6407390832901001,
0.26623791456222534,
0.08987493813037872,
-0.724480152130127,
0.5497848391532898,
-0.35972484946250916,
-0.20656609535217285,
0.297933965921402,
0.11046817898750305,
0.10516324639320374,
0.9907943606376648,
0.5650110840797424,
0.4443933963775635,
0.30880260467529297,
0.5793008208274841,
0.7821484804153442,
-0.4793604016304016,
-0.16893936693668365,
-0.8014748096466064,
0.5180079936981201,
-0.3329179883003235,
-0.27879810333251953,
0.642175018787384,
0.46874159574508667,
1.2709327936172485,
0.019395118579268456,
0.7320950627326965,
0.07115080952644348,
0.7050332427024841,
-0.19157716631889343,
0.6247209906578064,
-0.414547860622406,
0.17957226932048798,
0.0009466118062846363,
-1.1010452508926392,
0.06616178900003433,
0.11389437317848206,
0.11020527780056,
-0.03464576229453087,
0.8864117860794067,
0.9068160653114319,
0.22140349447727203,
-0.04452165588736534,
0.39742547273635864,
0.27256760001182556,
0.3690924644470215,
0.21588504314422607,
1.0688544511795044,
-0.17169548571109772,
0.6047975420951843,
-0.2769279181957245,
-0.11605903506278992,
-0.16918683052062988,
-0.8876158595085144,
-0.826338529586792,
-0.2873658537864685,
-0.46966612339019775,
-0.2952653467655182,
0.3643072545528412,
0.9895651340484619,
0.694180965423584,
-1.0109525918960571,
-0.752856433391571,
-0.11876054108142853,
-0.06213565543293953,
-0.7385770082473755,
-0.18027663230895996,
-0.15423080325126648,
-0.7534521222114563,
-0.6345936059951782,
0.4863099157810211,
0.24731500446796417,
-0.23136015236377716,
-0.5808093547821045,
-0.37544289231300354,
-0.014365592040121555,
0.20715801417827606,
0.49623265862464905,
0.5863748788833618,
-0.7100633978843689,
-0.28188851475715637,
-0.2855370044708252,
-0.11378183215856552,
0.13835561275482178,
0.7809351682662964,
-0.7281103134155273,
0.5780859589576721,
0.45113128423690796,
1.0972864627838135,
0.7502394318580627,
0.004939075093716383,
0.6511735916137695,
-0.6704817414283752,
-0.037714652717113495,
0.23835310339927673,
0.2563706040382385,
0.3779834508895874,
0.1622043401002884,
0.7776139974594116,
0.1471817046403885,
-0.536571204662323,
-0.7901461720466614,
-0.19791774451732635,
-0.8765617609024048,
-0.31978511810302734,
1.004212737083435,
-0.34599047899246216,
-0.10903437435626984,
-0.12233632057905197,
-0.056938063353300095,
0.21962109208106995,
-0.5185011029243469,
0.7941611409187317,
0.8199613094329834,
-0.05928250402212143,
-0.36310797929763794,
-0.7211427688598633,
0.34102198481559753,
0.29174691438674927,
-1.170597791671753,
0.06587295979261398,
0.45751118659973145,
0.4295656979084015,
-0.10035496205091476,
0.7025149464607239,
0.36525341868400574,
0.21581004559993744,
0.2959263026714325,
0.3220920264720917,
0.13088931143283844,
-0.2890143394470215,
-0.4238009750843048,
0.1931648701429367,
0.5644589066505432,
0.05314509570598602
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08726v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08726v1
|
Standard Language Ideology in AI-Generated Language
| 2024-06-13T01:08:40 | 2024-06-13T01:08:40 |
Genevieve Smith, Eve Fleisig, Madeline Bossi, Ishita Rustagi, Xavier Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this position paper, we explore standard language ideology in language
generated by large language models (LLMs). First, we outline how standard
language ideology is reflected and reinforced in LLMs. We then present a
taxonomy of open problems regarding standard language ideology in AI-generated
language with implications for minoritized language communities. We introduce
the concept of standard AI-generated language ideology, the process by which
AI-generated language regards Standard American English (SAE) as a linguistic
default and reinforces a linguistic bias that SAE is the most "appropriate"
language. Finally, we discuss tensions that remain, including reflecting on
what desirable system behavior looks like, as well as advantages and drawbacks
of generative AI tools imitating--or often not--different English language
varieties. Throughout, we discuss standard language ideology as a manifestation
of existing global power structures in and through AI-generated language before
ending with questions to move towards alternative, more emancipatory digital
futures.
|
[
-0.3461390733718872,
-0.5993719696998596,
0.3729128837585449,
-0.125992089509964,
-0.21567805111408234,
-0.019764790311455727,
-0.5013917684555054,
-0.3166564106941223,
0.45504996180534363,
0.6337634325027466,
-0.29709628224372864,
-0.37496429681777954,
-0.6389599442481995,
0.5109876990318298,
-0.4157349765300751,
1.1545326709747314,
-0.11695834249258041,
-0.17765019834041595,
-0.350617915391922,
-0.2648012340068817,
-0.12909843027591705,
-0.5546932220458984,
-0.7542756199836731,
-0.612084150314331,
0.490473210811615,
0.32834672927856445,
1.21489417552948,
0.7912277579307556,
0.3710562586784363,
0.31485292315483093,
0.1918705552816391,
-0.24787889420986176,
-0.43154892325401306,
0.27841052412986755,
0.01861003041267395,
-0.49256107211112976,
-0.3371529281139374,
0.2608797252178192,
0.5046577453613281,
0.6013534069061279,
-0.07519902288913727,
0.31042149662971497,
-0.004973290022462606,
0.5195987224578857,
-0.5552542805671692,
0.1832614690065384,
-0.9247254133224487,
-0.2312924712896347,
-0.36911827325820923,
0.2207372784614563,
-0.2477176934480667,
-0.33040979504585266,
-0.1950244903564453,
-0.04536730423569679,
-0.16867956519126892,
-0.16195088624954224,
0.7972233295440674,
0.4399366080760956,
-0.5105991959571838,
-0.45916125178337097,
-0.751022219657898,
1.0739744901657104,
-0.7192201018333435,
0.3690944015979767,
0.016796084120869637,
0.3445989191532135,
0.11770032346248627,
-0.5899275541305542,
-0.7843796014785767,
-0.4612200856208801,
0.1070338785648346,
0.08717909455299377,
-0.28696489334106445,
0.1813967078924179,
0.01896410994231701,
0.09386128932237625,
-0.48626863956451416,
0.551599383354187,
-0.23574501276016235,
0.08519341051578522,
0.9706214070320129,
0.20289644598960876,
0.4814048111438751,
-0.25052350759506226,
-0.13060836493968964,
0.33725786209106445,
-1.0078589916229248,
-0.38757163286209106,
0.6658554673194885,
0.26156046986579895,
0.03672108054161072,
0.34667983651161194,
0.009373588487505913,
0.31530946493148804,
-0.2407044619321823,
0.11257553100585938,
0.10219085961580276,
-0.07080400735139847,
-0.19136656820774078,
-0.09854864329099655,
0.8170251846313477,
0.5306229591369629,
0.6002911925315857,
0.03658956661820412,
-0.4393784701824188,
0.3909369707107544,
0.33636122941970825,
-0.37053966522216797,
0.2584371268749237,
0.3136087954044342,
-0.4407491087913513,
-0.39239630103111267,
-0.09397755563259125,
-0.4684794843196869,
-0.29977238178253174,
-0.4721699357032776,
0.00882268138229847,
-0.2181636244058609,
-0.2804815471172333,
-0.12226952612400055,
-0.02583627961575985,
0.4192498028278351,
0.2269361913204193,
-1.0302993059158325,
0.3540353775024414,
0.8849273920059204,
0.3732084035873413,
-0.2264009267091751,
-0.21397241950035095,
0.28105220198631287,
0.2504836320877075,
-0.8059637546539307,
0.6330782771110535,
-0.6387700438499451,
-0.543643057346344,
0.3962864577770233,
-0.2424117475748062,
0.1598917692899704,
-0.667476236820221,
0.23490962386131287,
-0.3202694356441498,
0.11423777788877487,
-0.10156847536563873,
-0.42672112584114075,
0.31909024715423584,
0.15441259741783142,
-0.5148771405220032,
0.8082754611968994,
-0.49349719285964966,
-0.4882238209247589,
0.2952568829059601,
-0.8218117952346802,
-0.4569271206855774,
0.3105291724205017,
-0.5054718852043152,
0.1682957261800766,
0.16119030117988586,
-0.19049763679504395,
0.350807249546051,
-0.2617729902267456,
0.44969987869262695,
0.0018296116031706333,
-0.21234248578548431,
0.1335521936416626,
-0.7407982349395752,
0.8436223268508911,
0.5552251935005188,
-0.23119217157363892,
0.006936350837349892,
-0.6075612306594849,
-0.1588927060365677,
0.14472264051437378,
-0.051358554512262344,
-0.4941810369491577,
0.38170239329338074,
-0.13846035301685333,
-0.29503998160362244,
0.8759880661964417,
-0.43451863527297974,
0.3650256395339966,
-0.6288023591041565,
0.3796815872192383,
1.191430926322937,
0.0414709597826004,
0.7080358266830444,
-0.20946574211120605,
0.4600064158439636,
-0.21672259271144867,
0.15683184564113617,
0.10968160629272461,
-0.3442082107067108,
-0.9270738363265991,
0.0012340981047600508,
-0.1448073536157608,
0.47632333636283875,
-0.5469707250595093,
0.554064154624939,
-0.25816214084625244,
-0.38598310947418213,
-0.5746772289276123,
-0.05950530618429184,
0.13987742364406586,
-0.09856825321912766,
0.07971210032701492,
0.08855291455984116,
-0.6906127333641052,
-1.5384507179260254,
-0.24097193777561188,
-0.44182664155960083,
-0.3762105107307434,
0.2812301516532898,
0.5619938373565674,
-0.46870577335357666,
0.9591808319091797,
-0.3315158188343048,
0.12171153724193573,
-0.4689283072948456,
0.38462796807289124,
0.05658134073019028,
0.25104448199272156,
0.45567432045936584,
-0.5399380326271057,
-0.7537044286727905,
0.011710374616086483,
-0.7514439225196838,
-0.2643604874610901,
-0.2586933374404907,
0.19981755316257477,
0.7494039535522461,
0.3789779841899872,
-0.6949247717857361,
0.21293149888515472,
0.502139151096344,
0.16040292382240295,
0.2752060294151306,
0.032579440623521805,
0.10534808039665222,
-1.4699313640594482,
-0.14651286602020264,
-0.12054060399532318,
0.3036687672138214,
-0.9079176783561707,
0.4185384511947632,
-0.5282750129699707,
-0.18178783357143402,
-0.3475523293018341,
0.5538076758384705,
-0.2565193772315979,
0.1491021066904068,
-0.40323305130004883,
0.0485551543533802,
-0.3974459767341614,
-0.08305501192808151,
0.19410331547260284,
0.8109099864959717,
0.231597438454628,
-0.2943614721298218,
0.3283037841320038,
-0.08317255228757858,
0.0694815069437027,
0.25438734889030457,
-0.5491129159927368,
0.6172255277633667,
-0.43257272243499756,
0.11946184188127518,
-0.55427086353302,
-0.294361412525177,
-0.11333855241537094,
-0.3051799535751343,
0.3158667981624603,
0.1308993697166443,
-0.5156065821647644,
-0.18258684873580933,
-0.4117937386035919,
0.05485658347606659,
0.7849680185317993,
-0.30745217204093933,
0.2262127548456192,
0.5647311210632324,
-0.27976110577583313,
-0.6526180505752563,
-0.4970274567604065,
0.4452567398548126,
-0.057566359639167786,
-0.6342238187789917,
0.13546203076839447,
0.04853589087724686,
-0.9287395477294922,
-0.08055322617292404,
0.2232000082731247,
-0.05024224892258644,
-0.13501153886318207,
0.14209772646427155,
0.2866729199886322,
-0.19823478162288666,
0.060313381254673004,
0.32005229592323303,
-0.049672339111566544,
0.05030006542801857,
-0.0865202471613884,
0.5271095037460327,
-0.21903906762599945,
-0.24302667379379272,
-0.1802973449230194,
0.8587884902954102,
0.605131983757019,
-0.0003040530427824706,
0.6077557802200317,
0.18706543743610382,
-0.5020065903663635,
-0.18453076481819153,
-0.3372974991798401,
-0.16219332814216614,
-0.4745868444442749,
0.3942062556743622,
-0.15818126499652863,
-0.7564837336540222,
0.42647647857666016,
0.27066895365715027,
0.5700401067733765,
0.6155053377151489,
0.9894987940788269,
-0.22578923404216766,
1.3121166229248047,
0.7226652503013611,
-0.42288047075271606,
0.23444673418998718,
-0.12527799606323242,
0.35526058077812195,
-0.2175261676311493,
0.1326066106557846,
-0.720238983631134,
-0.2655101716518402,
-0.7951170206069946,
-0.21424871683120728,
0.13941746950149536,
-0.16925707459449768,
-0.48844316601753235,
0.2735874056816101,
-0.4519118070602417,
0.5382691025733948,
0.4983968734741211,
-0.599503755569458,
-0.08339489996433258,
-0.19865736365318298,
0.18425185978412628,
-0.19394594430923462,
-0.5052579641342163,
-1.3442918062210083,
1.0595555305480957,
0.3310702443122864,
0.6590980291366577,
-0.014830014668405056,
1.2865339517593384,
0.29291942715644836,
0.5231338739395142,
-0.6476685404777527,
0.8215210437774658,
-0.32617422938346863,
-0.7070362567901611,
-0.25311917066574097,
-0.06905632466077805,
-0.9031957387924194,
-0.20507694780826569,
-0.18402379751205444,
-0.8984603881835938,
-0.061665140092372894,
-0.05453461408615112,
0.08907466381788254,
0.29558947682380676,
-0.6220417022705078,
0.6160891652107239,
0.045458193868398666,
-0.012766731902956963,
-0.4200238585472107,
-0.5723423361778259,
0.2765659689903259,
0.17386457324028015,
0.325760155916214,
-0.016516907140612602,
-0.3749355971813202,
0.7525103688240051,
-0.14924754202365875,
1.046758770942688,
0.0617639496922493,
-0.19784212112426758,
0.5237184166908264,
-0.02342177741229534,
0.46343839168548584,
0.04482194408774376,
-0.21607714891433716,
0.5356342196464539,
-0.013573838397860527,
-0.36167198419570923,
-0.28612643480300903,
0.7112963199615479,
-1.1164402961730957,
-0.9237245917320251,
-0.4910452663898468,
-0.6111131906509399,
-0.09386415034532547,
0.22206956148147583,
0.4039227068424225,
0.1173626109957695,
-0.6173774003982544,
0.13887152075767517,
0.5439106822013855,
-0.14895930886268616,
0.44130373001098633,
0.13721537590026855,
-0.10715004056692123,
-0.28511345386505127,
1.0155402421951294,
0.46113502979278564,
0.26212435960769653,
0.20434482395648956,
-0.013380994088947773,
-0.07613149285316467,
-0.5672914385795593,
-0.5083850622177124,
-0.024213699623942375,
-0.7205303907394409,
-0.005848298314958811,
-0.23090876638889313,
-0.36440449953079224,
-0.6194512248039246,
-0.5840771198272705,
-0.47782760858535767,
-0.1696900576353073,
-0.4138224422931671,
-0.11568135768175125,
0.0015247922856360674,
1.098600149154663,
0.047353945672512054,
0.02796700783073902,
-0.7613633275032043,
0.08255087584257126,
0.16516250371932983,
0.0052061607129871845,
-0.3879599869251251,
-0.2000744640827179,
-0.12884262204170227,
0.11503344029188156,
-0.2389926016330719,
-0.9676640629768372,
-0.006048860494047403,
0.03599853068590164,
0.7481865286827087,
0.6208805441856384,
0.22560270130634308,
0.014547948725521564,
-0.7702563405036926,
1.2687060832977295,
0.2781229615211487,
-0.6408856511116028,
0.2511558532714844,
-0.41068172454833984,
0.2601644694805145,
0.40182971954345703,
0.6440890431404114,
-0.8453426361083984,
-1.0276267528533936,
-0.7832109928131104,
-0.7924976944923401,
0.12784399092197418,
-0.031543996185064316,
0.9940612316131592,
-0.6349830031394958,
0.27750858664512634,
0.20394402742385864,
0.35713452100753784,
-0.8064049482345581,
-0.4387678802013397,
-0.1288984715938568,
-0.6394367814064026,
-0.015494352206587791,
-0.2551226019859314,
-0.19840417802333832,
0.20901867747306824,
0.5548874735832214,
-0.32513427734375,
0.3830454647541046,
-0.2750832736492157,
0.13270244002342224,
-0.32773926854133606,
0.5989461541175842,
0.3567049205303192,
0.6514686346054077,
0.19305947422981262,
0.10429561883211136,
0.13129419088363647,
-0.27335861325263977,
0.10598257929086685,
-0.3008669316768646,
-0.8053776025772095,
-0.058304257690906525,
0.41742390394210815,
0.7252086997032166,
-0.3890015780925751,
-0.31902164220809937,
0.25734466314315796,
0.348134309053421,
-0.39057034254074097,
-0.5088729858398438,
-0.05666784197092056,
0.16872112452983856,
-0.029943961650133133,
0.3716726005077362,
0.1726638376712799,
-0.08427748084068298,
-0.8550621271133423,
0.07865262031555176,
0.9471676349639893,
-0.1850128471851349,
-0.5183472633361816,
0.43598636984825134,
0.42278730869293213,
-0.6463321447372437,
0.3712916374206543,
-0.1733069270849228,
-0.45872586965560913,
0.5091192722320557,
0.6752541065216064,
1.114909291267395,
-0.12031727284193039,
0.21822784841060638,
0.0841720923781395,
0.758858323097229,
0.3822217583656311,
0.32808536291122437,
0.41109198331832886,
-0.9911854267120361,
-0.38951194286346436,
-0.6939499974250793,
-0.4462854564189911,
0.16668108105659485,
-0.3650403618812561,
0.46041202545166016,
-0.7079797983169556,
0.08985108882188797,
-0.29112792015075684,
-0.0392908975481987,
-0.22515465319156647,
0.09356873482465744,
0.6316275000572205,
0.9930433034896851,
-1.053257942199707,
0.906225860118866,
0.8514642119407654,
-0.48354384303092957,
-0.6815083026885986,
0.4078800082206726,
-0.055771369487047195,
-0.8956243991851807,
0.3953481912612915,
-0.03979811444878578,
-0.22453702986240387,
0.06514173001050949,
-0.8660765886306763,
-0.7690463662147522,
0.7616716027259827,
0.2917194068431854,
-0.2065589427947998,
0.031098099425435066,
0.47283709049224854,
0.693292498588562,
-0.6049233675003052,
0.01116959284991026,
0.49639272689819336,
0.4536847770214081,
-0.19965434074401855,
-0.6690598130226135,
-0.11354048550128937,
-0.043978188186883926,
0.11725738644599915,
0.4888908267021179,
-0.7654885649681091,
0.6952818632125854,
0.03410346806049347,
-0.31809327006340027,
0.12068244069814682,
0.7676994800567627,
-0.24723730981349945,
0.22273603081703186,
0.4959144592285156,
0.2751604914665222,
0.4421413540840149,
0.09581412374973297,
0.6800930500030518,
-0.5078614950180054,
-0.040651801973581314,
0.46045657992362976,
-0.5771206617355347,
1.004032015800476,
0.7095887660980225,
-0.32229214906692505,
0.6614735722541809,
0.4309857189655304,
0.2710725665092468,
0.15678881108760834,
0.05489850044250488,
-0.3366808593273163,
-0.11255533993244171,
-0.16642390191555023,
-0.23248936235904694,
0.6327780485153198,
0.2656627595424652,
-0.11215925216674805,
-0.2817879915237427,
-0.18063801527023315,
-0.04035787284374237,
0.5426749587059021,
-0.28901344537734985,
1.054028868675232,
0.1324807107448578,
-0.5682530999183655,
0.500815212726593,
0.00021383982675615698,
0.6943193078041077,
-0.5382804274559021,
0.09011749923229218,
-0.29250866174697876,
-0.18608592450618744,
-0.16845053434371948,
-0.576810896396637,
0.5268855094909668,
0.24248482286930084,
-0.13949356973171234,
-0.3658864200115204,
0.7040343880653381,
-0.3217329978942871,
-0.42248380184173584,
-0.10186316072940826,
0.459110289812088,
0.3017409145832062,
0.5411149263381958,
-0.7254206538200378,
-0.04028899967670441,
0.036124832928180695,
-0.36744245886802673,
0.527044415473938,
0.10477251559495926,
-0.25870901346206665,
0.47761714458465576,
0.5172964930534363,
0.13818183541297913,
-0.06744588166475296,
-0.07750071585178375,
0.5197230577468872,
-0.42717245221138,
-0.4070478677749634,
-0.7138959169387817,
0.24637015163898468,
-0.07711800187826157,
-0.04597267135977745,
0.5985630750656128,
0.4503539800643921,
0.8577661514282227,
0.048811886459589005,
1.1206285953521729,
-0.4099561870098114,
0.3056636154651642,
-0.42187240719795227,
0.9248543977737427,
-0.5407968163490295,
0.15609580278396606,
0.05776286870241165,
-0.8682546615600586,
-0.3228396773338318,
0.5482465624809265,
-0.4874674677848816,
-0.07437815517187119,
0.5888596773147583,
0.7567505240440369,
0.3169085383415222,
0.06517434865236282,
0.27770864963531494,
0.218633234500885,
0.03527543321251869,
0.33861643075942993,
0.8862667083740234,
0.03811044245958328,
0.4521319270133972,
-0.054833173751831055,
-0.35524770617485046,
0.041841547936201096,
-0.7898415327072144,
-0.44770166277885437,
-0.4329245686531067,
-0.09129434078931808,
-0.18110081553459167,
0.0502665676176548,
1.383876919746399,
0.24844932556152344,
-0.6799437403678894,
-0.6820379495620728,
-0.08920362591743469,
0.2449539452791214,
0.07804448902606964,
-0.17702306807041168,
-0.05135873332619667,
-0.5997866988182068,
-1.1874686479568481,
0.15778754651546478,
0.3439550995826721,
-0.027786003425717354,
-0.6633037328720093,
-0.2802351713180542,
-0.09409236162900925,
0.61180579662323,
0.4274492859840393,
0.18272410333156586,
-0.8555979132652283,
-0.9829018115997314,
0.006600295193493366,
-0.4213477373123169,
-0.09612426161766052,
0.6437488198280334,
-0.3136339783668518,
0.12507066130638123,
0.35644447803497314,
0.3123394250869751,
-0.3731406331062317,
-0.3267947733402252,
0.784185528755188,
-0.8076657652854919,
0.22501619160175323,
0.636191725730896,
0.37573719024658203,
0.022651733830571175,
-0.15987946093082428,
0.12031204998493195,
0.21748532354831696,
-0.5894147157669067,
-1.0073158740997314,
0.9294293522834778,
-0.28051358461380005,
-0.36047589778900146,
1.2225441932678223,
0.19225351512432098,
-0.2778265178203583,
0.04825403913855553,
-0.09459194540977478,
0.19756828248500824,
-0.3584839701652527,
0.628440260887146,
0.5693995952606201,
-0.08295052498579025,
0.09021297842264175,
-0.29091060161590576,
0.6056332588195801,
0.21759773790836334,
-0.5339205265045166,
0.2693346440792084,
0.5685952305793762,
0.12316274642944336,
0.4128686189651489,
0.9328352808952332,
0.12043135613203049,
0.06629408150911331,
0.28811296820640564,
0.2319944202899933,
0.2272566258907318,
-0.386597216129303,
-0.22087162733078003,
0.07895969599485397,
0.4503839910030365,
0.05456644296646118
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08723v1
|
ECBD: Evidence-Centered Benchmark Design for NLP
| 2024-06-13T00:59:55 | 2024-06-13T00:59:55 |
Yu Lu Liu, Su Lin Blodgett, Jackie Chi Kit Cheung, Q. Vera Liao, Alexandra Olteanu, Ziang Xiao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Benchmarking is seen as critical to assessing progress in NLP. However,
creating a benchmark involves many design decisions (e.g., which datasets to
include, which metrics to use) that often rely on tacit, untested assumptions
about what the benchmark is intended to measure or is actually measuring. There
is currently no principled way of analyzing these decisions and how they impact
the validity of the benchmark's measurements. To address this gap, we draw on
evidence-centered design in educational assessments and propose
Evidence-Centered Benchmark Design (ECBD), a framework which formalizes the
benchmark design process into five modules. ECBD specifies the role each module
plays in helping practitioners collect evidence about capabilities of interest.
Specifically, each module requires benchmark designers to describe, justify,
and support benchmark design choices -- e.g., clearly specifying the
capabilities the benchmark aims to measure or how evidence about those
capabilities is collected from model responses. To demonstrate the use of ECBD,
we conduct case studies with three benchmarks: BoolQ, SuperGLUE, and HELM. Our
analysis reveals common trends in benchmark design and documentation that could
threaten the validity of benchmarks' measurements.
|
[
-0.6717365384101868,
-0.7094812989234924,
0.5291610360145569,
0.2965935170650482,
-0.27022358775138855,
-0.16139915585517883,
-0.28867706656455994,
-0.7222095727920532,
-0.14434683322906494,
0.3172263205051422,
-0.25078731775283813,
-0.605424165725708,
-0.5638046264648438,
-0.06858842819929123,
-0.45458516478538513,
0.9746567606925964,
-0.08649207651615143,
0.13269829750061035,
-0.3862052857875824,
-0.37170612812042236,
-0.6405004262924194,
-0.4712497293949127,
-0.5838184356689453,
-0.23072049021720886,
0.32516539096832275,
0.5768024921417236,
0.3566868305206299,
0.5790151357650757,
0.6031891703605652,
0.03507350757718086,
-0.2302946001291275,
-0.015897667035460472,
0.11233886331319809,
0.18278895318508148,
-0.3148377537727356,
-0.4522004723548889,
-0.6520351767539978,
-0.1879456639289856,
0.4199702739715576,
1.1720694303512573,
-0.5179625749588013,
0.5995787978172302,
0.10610275715589523,
0.74086993932724,
-0.8034181594848633,
0.13956746459007263,
-0.19739557802677155,
0.09900736808776855,
-0.4254259169101715,
0.19318336248397827,
-0.4211336672306061,
-0.35634708404541016,
0.2235439568758011,
-0.3714630603790283,
0.40249884128570557,
0.13453137874603271,
0.5419990420341492,
0.14056642353534698,
-0.3931739926338196,
-0.17229123413562775,
-0.36264559626579285,
0.6916541457176208,
-0.9625009894371033,
0.48113197088241577,
0.29135245084762573,
0.29360172152519226,
-0.04707767069339752,
-0.7598118782043457,
-0.44151636958122253,
0.29275137186050415,
0.13789162039756775,
0.17271988093852997,
0.06699090451002121,
-0.010240386240184307,
0.6188328266143799,
0.24186481535434723,
-0.594282329082489,
0.36643868684768677,
-0.21092155575752258,
0.010262423194944859,
0.5764080882072449,
0.30685198307037354,
0.06677404791116714,
-0.04325815662741661,
-0.38287413120269775,
-0.38286834955215454,
-0.7459157109260559,
0.24183477461338043,
0.12671896815299988,
0.24485091865062714,
0.23123542964458466,
0.35424572229385376,
-0.3939887583255768,
0.6947899460792542,
-0.14938467741012573,
0.16948500275611877,
0.21411076188087463,
-0.05861123651266098,
-0.13907331228256226,
0.27715763449668884,
0.5015929341316223,
0.8103153705596924,
-0.21223820745944977,
-0.03216273710131645,
-0.3844847083091736,
0.3025076985359192,
0.47941672801971436,
-0.8655763268470764,
-0.2083940953016281,
0.3404574692249298,
-0.6126835942268372,
-0.07570646703243256,
-0.12815529108047485,
-0.9215103387832642,
-0.05814135819673538,
-0.3791017532348633,
0.35824277997016907,
-0.16307194530963898,
-0.46251556277275085,
0.15729862451553345,
-0.2858292758464813,
0.12453408539295197,
0.005678651854395866,
-1.2138257026672363,
0.8057421445846558,
0.8316963315010071,
0.5613175630569458,
-0.41142046451568604,
-0.04022694006562233,
0.027329908683896065,
-0.08261208981275558,
-0.558795690536499,
0.9893438220024109,
-0.4200466573238373,
-0.5188664197921753,
0.24565932154655457,
-0.10200639814138412,
0.46658286452293396,
-0.5949203372001648,
1.0620615482330322,
-0.3562543988227844,
0.19229133427143097,
-0.5483538508415222,
-1.0748475790023804,
-0.2598494291305542,
0.25662729144096375,
-0.4476403295993805,
1.0571060180664062,
-0.012151990085840225,
-0.7735141515731812,
0.969265878200531,
-0.7127344608306885,
-0.3630256652832031,
0.12774568796157837,
-0.28437069058418274,
-0.5481728911399841,
0.4531053602695465,
0.23750504851341248,
0.3168169856071472,
-0.20097120106220245,
0.4962480962276459,
-0.34869688749313354,
-0.24023272097110748,
0.025855764746665955,
-0.3970489501953125,
0.7781270146369934,
-0.020985690876841545,
-0.5436608791351318,
-0.1699044555425644,
-1.1628767251968384,
0.5080408453941345,
-0.17325127124786377,
-0.25394734740257263,
-0.6105918884277344,
0.3850981891155243,
0.4167183041572571,
0.043905362486839294,
-0.04467998072504997,
-0.6163988709449768,
-0.04801410064101219,
-0.14242619276046753,
-0.08603508770465851,
0.697772741317749,
-0.07606575638055801,
0.15546417236328125,
-0.4623369574546814,
0.41985395550727844,
-0.5951096415519714,
0.23615212738513947,
0.01904083602130413,
-0.456686794757843,
-0.6310734152793884,
0.06318847835063934,
0.5179409980773926,
-0.15022891759872437,
-0.13564833998680115,
0.503472089767456,
0.16344766318798065,
-0.6087188124656677,
-0.3805638551712036,
-0.15584535896778107,
0.37533247470855713,
0.6243274211883545,
0.7611311078071594,
-0.8795139193534851,
-0.48239001631736755,
-0.8611958026885986,
-0.3419196307659149,
-0.2135237604379654,
-0.39847493171691895,
0.008197582326829433,
0.2979715168476105,
0.20458164811134338,
0.8924165964126587,
-0.3073628544807434,
-0.27929672598838806,
0.014161006547510624,
0.3084114193916321,
0.3796934485435486,
0.5746294260025024,
0.8187352418899536,
-0.5353975892066956,
-0.3590937852859497,
-0.5067296028137207,
-0.6360388398170471,
-0.7181161642074585,
-0.008710328489542007,
-0.16805009543895721,
-0.0761759877204895,
0.38937658071517944,
-0.386423259973526,
0.4977867007255554,
0.4603268802165985,
-0.36085382103919983,
0.8558703660964966,
0.08359367400407791,
-0.13893918693065643,
-0.5275708436965942,
0.08383511006832123,
-0.1492752730846405,
0.19101931154727936,
-0.3327650725841522,
0.1769248992204666,
0.4117271602153778,
0.18002142012119293,
-0.22063373029232025,
0.5466921329498291,
-0.31712228059768677,
-0.10137749463319778,
-0.3559921085834503,
0.34605473279953003,
0.2558528184890747,
0.18555542826652527,
0.16438190639019012,
0.4182848632335663,
0.5381478071212769,
-0.546184778213501,
-0.051089510321617126,
0.3592093884944916,
-0.6266086101531982,
1.30836820602417,
-0.9655836224555969,
-0.1315636783838272,
0.2133857011795044,
0.2610096335411072,
-0.46779730916023254,
0.14187921583652496,
-0.13848596811294556,
-0.20224224030971527,
0.4072837233543396,
0.07096780836582184,
-0.29297903180122375,
-0.25164806842803955,
-0.20923729240894318,
0.3324759900569916,
0.2631879150867462,
-0.7643460035324097,
0.40196192264556885,
0.5301231741905212,
-0.10597161203622818,
-0.5494680404663086,
-0.785978376865387,
0.10287214070558548,
-0.17154167592525482,
-0.44474196434020996,
0.8203433752059937,
-0.1922733336687088,
-0.2596181333065033,
0.08496034145355225,
-0.7256130576133728,
0.026396388188004494,
0.3083924949169159,
0.2937420606613159,
0.1833294928073883,
-0.4642859697341919,
0.2961001396179199,
0.10517177730798721,
-0.28373125195503235,
0.6906815767288208,
-0.05364052206277847,
0.2393534779548645,
-0.08897904306650162,
-0.5794328451156616,
-0.30120840668678284,
0.56775963306427,
0.34430280327796936,
-0.17133979499340057,
0.5188159942626953,
0.5061742067337036,
-0.3491269052028656,
-0.6553889513015747,
-0.6867594718933105,
-0.1590879261493683,
-0.40876504778862,
0.22918641567230225,
-0.15049326419830322,
-0.48257210850715637,
0.244916170835495,
-0.14888237416744232,
0.4952484369277954,
0.20278039574623108,
0.29102829098701477,
-0.12805573642253876,
1.0304207801818848,
0.7521843314170837,
0.41666239500045776,
0.35274553298950195,
-0.15898998081684113,
0.10225691646337509,
-1.5430344343185425,
-0.18982557952404022,
-0.617397665977478,
-0.44274142384529114,
-0.3602592647075653,
-0.0007245681481435895,
0.08321799337863922,
0.11035873740911484,
-0.2272387444972992,
0.2723352015018463,
-0.7034433484077454,
0.3471184968948364,
0.5566147565841675,
0.025924477726221085,
0.1159592792391777,
-0.3584681749343872,
-0.3352152407169342,
-0.2475644201040268,
-0.6309827566146851,
-0.7490701675415039,
1.5187724828720093,
0.07902365922927856,
0.5904924273490906,
0.29985740780830383,
0.7902498841285706,
0.1543157398700714,
0.6834501624107361,
-0.6500994563102722,
0.5991333723068237,
0.162864089012146,
-1.0081521272659302,
-0.18542996048927307,
-0.04176020994782448,
-0.8792216181755066,
0.527704656124115,
-0.3421204090118408,
-0.7014729976654053,
0.40950265526771545,
-0.10157127678394318,
-0.22183001041412354,
0.13973604142665863,
-0.6510317921638489,
0.9724110960960388,
-0.4613109827041626,
-0.553287148475647,
-0.2319152057170868,
-0.3941616117954254,
0.08510833978652954,
-0.07721258699893951,
0.21441683173179626,
-0.1936734914779663,
0.029527422040700912,
1.1215488910675049,
-0.510718584060669,
0.5735340714454651,
-0.3176465630531311,
0.19987085461616516,
0.26535764336586,
-0.07467080652713776,
0.03214274346828461,
0.16589199006557465,
-0.23781698942184448,
0.0874425545334816,
0.22532200813293457,
-0.5790652632713318,
-0.40062740445137024,
0.3683059513568878,
-0.44320380687713623,
-0.7669042348861694,
-0.5317795276641846,
-0.15920433402061462,
-0.483512282371521,
0.33656707406044006,
-0.05253932997584343,
0.7679676413536072,
-0.5775774121284485,
0.6046301126480103,
0.5779142379760742,
-0.009720245376229286,
0.553947925567627,
0.9140678644180298,
-0.19236217439174652,
-0.08958855271339417,
0.5104818344116211,
0.3653654456138611,
0.29103633761405945,
0.08415711671113968,
0.1973072737455368,
-0.4414363205432892,
-0.928020179271698,
-0.17986851930618286,
-0.2925201654434204,
-0.9069533348083496,
-0.15074262022972107,
-0.3120022118091583,
-0.020076781511306763,
-0.2403172254562378,
-0.12615957856178284,
-0.36182329058647156,
-0.43163126707077026,
0.05358463525772095,
-0.3605930805206299,
-0.11891847103834152,
0.5616397261619568,
-0.3009845018386841,
0.027063095942139626,
-0.3400956690311432,
0.2543875277042389,
0.5137598514556885,
0.4953264892101288,
0.2040056437253952,
-0.3767712414264679,
-0.17089594900608063,
-0.26911479234695435,
-0.6007195115089417,
-0.542845606803894,
0.06412862241268158,
0.12407608330249786,
0.8761309385299683,
0.4423428475856781,
0.4632279872894287,
0.2555431127548218,
-0.648871123790741,
0.7908532023429871,
0.16870594024658203,
-0.8319981098175049,
0.5207064747810364,
-0.04107942059636116,
0.20067612826824188,
0.6046515703201294,
0.26377156376838684,
-0.5317635536193848,
-0.28760167956352234,
-0.8485265970230103,
-1.096142053604126,
0.2992660105228424,
-0.1061137467622757,
-0.04381338879466057,
-0.24030525982379913,
0.0053748637437820435,
0.3490801453590393,
0.21935239434242249,
-0.3286212682723999,
-0.27323704957962036,
-0.2891274094581604,
-0.28858113288879395,
0.29681074619293213,
-0.33296793699264526,
-0.38790076971054077,
0.023702440783381462,
0.48974382877349854,
-0.09931089729070663,
-0.11088670045137405,
0.1734769642353058,
0.14231841266155243,
0.13333101570606232,
0.4774364233016968,
0.24574527144432068,
1.0865575075149536,
-0.42170196771621704,
0.2691939175128937,
0.16993014514446259,
-0.43731045722961426,
0.009608498774468899,
0.09219855070114136,
-0.1259971708059311,
0.17744535207748413,
0.332863450050354,
0.23528730869293213,
0.30719462037086487,
-0.6113611459732056,
0.48677805066108704,
-0.2793693244457245,
-0.23237358033657074,
-0.19725647568702698,
0.22815941274166107,
0.04631880670785904,
0.21956171095371246,
0.46509885787963867,
0.07326029241085052,
0.19979822635650635,
-0.2924034893512726,
0.40262505412101746,
0.24832144379615784,
-0.30915597081184387,
-0.236258864402771,
0.8182460069656372,
0.36845895648002625,
-0.48759791254997253,
0.44477158784866333,
0.06690149009227753,
-0.24707284569740295,
0.8420631885528564,
0.6912515759468079,
0.7884383201599121,
-0.12510038912296295,
0.2827947735786438,
0.4219761788845062,
0.3217451572418213,
-0.19215059280395508,
0.10372880846261978,
-0.2950100898742676,
-0.5967140197753906,
-0.13529548048973083,
-0.5721684694290161,
-0.8993401527404785,
-0.03757525980472565,
-1.1971396207809448,
0.20798222720623016,
-0.7230653762817383,
-0.45908322930336,
0.11030206084251404,
0.051416248083114624,
-0.7460502982139587,
0.5479357838630676,
0.04174048453569412,
0.9590913653373718,
-0.7466490268707275,
0.43185415863990784,
0.4818437397480011,
-0.30411484837532043,
-0.5826488137245178,
-0.19513185322284698,
0.22262929379940033,
-0.5065637230873108,
0.3529089391231537,
0.23533444106578827,
0.2980816662311554,
-0.28096285462379456,
-0.5040412545204163,
-0.6094990372657776,
0.9449167847633362,
-0.06455814838409424,
-0.6144538521766663,
0.3349975347518921,
-0.11423620581626892,
0.7380691170692444,
-0.3977467715740204,
0.40362778306007385,
0.5357451438903809,
0.44261637330055237,
-0.5010307431221008,
-0.6256742477416992,
0.23759004473686218,
-0.32422566413879395,
-0.09940260648727417,
0.06634066253900528,
-0.558189868927002,
0.620559573173523,
-0.04480338841676712,
-0.33769792318344116,
-0.12124600261449814,
0.3627161383628845,
0.3788262605667114,
0.5246809720993042,
0.2793954908847809,
0.8337579369544983,
0.7063817381858826,
-0.35529544949531555,
0.7438477277755737,
-0.22038908302783966,
0.31476375460624695,
1.3283904790878296,
-0.2535701394081116,
1.12996506690979,
0.5357413291931152,
-0.4337104558944702,
0.5120149254798889,
0.7261372804641724,
-0.25439727306365967,
0.4817325174808502,
0.25938645005226135,
-0.22343455255031586,
-0.07893329113721848,
-0.3849002718925476,
-0.7843261957168579,
0.24390006065368652,
0.6642501950263977,
-0.06149142235517502,
-0.20121243596076965,
-0.4161244034767151,
-0.14755520224571228,
0.28817546367645264,
-0.12160767614841461,
0.41288021206855774,
0.1363324373960495,
-0.5787890553474426,
0.3984682857990265,
-0.19023177027702332,
0.4907168447971344,
-0.28771331906318665,
-0.04500662535429001,
-0.28690990805625916,
0.13031330704689026,
-0.3809577524662018,
-0.9469777941703796,
0.2502519190311432,
-0.10926792025566101,
-0.07051704078912735,
-0.4055541157722473,
0.2195836305618286,
-0.23025253415107727,
-0.3049233555793762,
0.304654985666275,
0.47746574878692627,
-0.12255465239286423,
0.2795751094818115,
-0.6039031744003296,
0.2452213019132614,
-0.49040114879608154,
-0.46700677275657654,
0.4411761462688446,
0.5816024541854858,
0.14873859286308289,
0.5183430314064026,
0.6858581304550171,
0.33867061138153076,
-0.1640775352716446,
0.4283828139305115,
0.613690197467804,
-0.45462143421173096,
-0.34510767459869385,
-0.4805877208709717,
0.37560632824897766,
-0.409389466047287,
-0.5755513310432434,
0.5819525122642517,
0.41268190741539,
1.1365127563476562,
0.3306412994861603,
0.6742104291915894,
-0.2486184537410736,
0.632300853729248,
-0.520836353302002,
0.5963412523269653,
-0.5756468772888184,
0.40784239768981934,
-0.4115551710128784,
-1.2244353294372559,
-0.4250466823577881,
0.6316500306129456,
-0.0277467779815197,
-0.049122557044029236,
1.0231794118881226,
0.4038107693195343,
0.2199796587228775,
0.43477317690849304,
0.11794760078191757,
-0.10428816080093384,
0.7159422039985657,
0.4549715518951416,
0.7989081740379333,
-0.5022362470626831,
0.33236226439476013,
-0.375320166349411,
-0.3586769700050354,
-0.21533912420272827,
-0.9858747720718384,
-0.9525893926620483,
-0.3705570697784424,
-0.47629910707473755,
-0.058569882065057755,
-0.10011743754148483,
0.630913257598877,
0.5811124444007874,
-0.8031941056251526,
-0.25804510712623596,
-0.11990886926651001,
0.20243948698043823,
-0.5996474027633667,
-0.2654898166656494,
0.6614997982978821,
-0.34206509590148926,
-0.4006116986274719,
0.2085503786802292,
0.17352229356765747,
-0.1836349070072174,
-0.1357998251914978,
0.32863569259643555,
0.06136811897158623,
0.003846444422379136,
0.4622679054737091,
0.4253201484680176,
-0.7003097534179688,
-0.6606493592262268,
-0.07339400053024292,
0.03513045608997345,
-0.06340281665325165,
0.6327864527702332,
-0.6656123399734497,
0.7328469157218933,
0.2986045777797699,
0.8379834294319153,
0.529676616191864,
-0.17173300683498383,
0.6257402896881104,
-0.4731224477291107,
-0.09822723269462585,
0.17499594390392303,
0.3887522518634796,
0.35740986466407776,
0.22374117374420166,
0.7951996922492981,
0.09902617335319519,
-0.7454349398612976,
-1.011062502861023,
-0.09653128683567047,
-0.8297415971755981,
-0.19370494782924652,
0.5809342265129089,
-0.17255821824073792,
-0.09044080972671509,
-0.398313045501709,
-0.07852142304182053,
-0.2294771671295166,
-0.1868697851896286,
1.1755908727645874,
1.0417170524597168,
-0.26491814851760864,
0.04221408814191818,
-0.771291196346283,
0.41483816504478455,
0.595825731754303,
-0.5815147161483765,
0.10547616332769394,
0.2305506020784378,
0.17979919910430908,
0.28071528673171997,
0.42109382152557373,
-0.25587406754493713,
0.3977336883544922,
0.35697153210639954,
0.22622841596603394,
0.23146158456802368,
-0.08893828839063644,
0.30243974924087524,
0.2207353562116623,
0.03971590846776962,
-0.04389052838087082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08718v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08718v1
|
Enhancing Psychotherapy Counseling: A Data Augmentation Pipeline Leveraging Large Language Models for Counseling Conversations
| 2024-06-13T00:48:44 | 2024-06-13T00:48:44 |
Jun-Woo Kim, Ji-Eun Han, Jun-Seok Koh, Hyeon-Tae Seo, Du-Seong Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce a pipeline that leverages Large Language Models (LLMs) to
transform single-turn psychotherapy counseling sessions into multi-turn
interactions. While AI-supported online counseling services for individuals
with mental disorders exist, they are often constrained by the limited
availability of multi-turn training datasets and frequently fail to fully
utilize therapists' expertise. Our proposed pipeline effectively addresses
these limitations. The pipeline comprises two main steps: 1) Information
Extraction and 2) Multi-turn Counseling Generation. Each step is meticulously
designed to extract and generate comprehensive multi-turn counseling
conversations from the available datasets. Experimental results from both
zero-shot and few-shot generation scenarios demonstrate that our approach
significantly enhances the ability of LLMs to produce higher quality multi-turn
dialogues in the context of mental health counseling. Our pipeline and dataset
are publicly available
https://github.com/jwkim-chat/A-Data-Augmentation-Pipeline-Leveraging-Large-Language-Models-for-Counseling-Conversations.
|
[
-0.43356677889823914,
-0.6021091341972351,
0.6178359389305115,
0.32779669761657715,
-0.10835658758878708,
0.24314747750759125,
-0.41410374641418457,
-0.3891757130622864,
0.3764379918575287,
0.7172155976295471,
-0.8908917307853699,
-0.4429735243320465,
-0.553228497505188,
-0.05102183297276497,
-0.327430784702301,
1.1379286050796509,
0.29969751834869385,
0.7226167321205139,
-0.09704747796058655,
0.105521060526371,
-0.6010827422142029,
-0.38262873888015747,
-0.8970571756362915,
-0.4343993067741394,
0.553409993648529,
0.4904448091983795,
0.5843387246131897,
0.2950955927371979,
0.3165431022644043,
0.24674689769744873,
0.10319073498249054,
0.3353540003299713,
-0.7863686680793762,
0.3301732838153839,
0.009019485674798489,
-0.2322060763835907,
-0.8874304890632629,
-0.1503538191318512,
0.4300116300582886,
0.889119029045105,
-0.4426952600479126,
0.15306338667869568,
0.03082551248371601,
0.5696386098861694,
-0.5672655701637268,
0.05721733346581459,
-0.7307244539260864,
0.07556727528572083,
-0.10510184615850449,
-0.20524170994758606,
-0.41393306851387024,
-0.197778582572937,
0.2554754316806793,
-0.45506128668785095,
0.3576960563659668,
-0.08973736315965652,
0.13964638113975525,
0.1858152449131012,
-0.6180199980735779,
-0.04589223489165306,
-1.0572280883789062,
0.5371469855308533,
-0.9585774540901184,
0.45057612657546997,
0.5517423152923584,
0.3279772102832794,
-0.31918463110923767,
-0.7815431952476501,
-0.36626121401786804,
-0.10730689764022827,
-0.09287343919277191,
0.18890900909900665,
-0.07958325743675232,
0.28552931547164917,
0.49186939001083374,
0.4810733497142792,
-0.3321148157119751,
0.0017254991689696908,
-0.505264937877655,
-0.12720727920532227,
0.838495135307312,
0.5442582964897156,
0.13449397683143616,
0.27743610739707947,
0.012084796093404293,
0.1441919207572937,
-0.6020339727401733,
-0.24305398762226105,
0.41788890957832336,
0.44628050923347473,
-0.0011906434083357453,
0.657180905342102,
0.06253395229578018,
0.6203212738037109,
0.0709276795387268,
-0.35432669520378113,
-0.16725614666938782,
-0.47589901089668274,
-0.0916295200586319,
0.279969722032547,
0.772351086139679,
0.5861283540725708,
-0.07152324169874191,
-0.14049406349658966,
0.32619521021842957,
-0.14112477004528046,
0.6680246591567993,
-0.8650642037391663,
-0.3139055371284485,
0.5404548645019531,
-0.23822782933712006,
-0.1477985829114914,
-0.16644124686717987,
-1.1179156303405762,
-0.7166185975074768,
-0.41333627700805664,
-0.11188483238220215,
-0.5632529258728027,
-0.42798519134521484,
0.25061818957328796,
-0.12600211799144745,
0.25427234172821045,
0.15967261791229248,
-0.7609860897064209,
0.2828232944011688,
0.6960673928260803,
0.8792349100112915,
-0.2355388104915619,
-0.32023921608924866,
-0.6732683181762695,
0.3719668388366699,
-0.20748361945152283,
0.7662720680236816,
-0.7131973505020142,
-0.5601398348808289,
0.2188720405101776,
-0.004754666704684496,
0.25401949882507324,
-0.2534083425998688,
0.5345859527587891,
-0.1780778169631958,
0.525172233581543,
-0.011606724932789803,
-0.6720865368843079,
0.28475549817085266,
0.36642736196517944,
-0.4838075339794159,
0.7099317908287048,
0.1408044397830963,
-0.6383056640625,
0.2787522077560425,
-0.9932695031166077,
-0.39595121145248413,
0.18571731448173523,
0.025056831538677216,
-0.31072932481765747,
0.1357986032962799,
0.4342309534549713,
0.20600219070911407,
-0.3053290545940399,
0.18078547716140747,
-0.7119805216789246,
-0.2606308162212372,
0.4010481834411621,
-0.41703176498413086,
0.5233535766601562,
0.11758612096309662,
0.18402916193008423,
0.36121833324432373,
-0.7978125214576721,
0.12710686028003693,
0.05997055768966675,
-0.23507753014564514,
-0.0038328072987496853,
-0.19199980795383453,
0.22009369730949402,
0.2493963986635208,
-0.03570665046572685,
-0.8471317291259766,
0.580569863319397,
-0.6058437824249268,
0.29310086369514465,
0.42381906509399414,
0.23799742758274078,
0.21217307448387146,
-0.21809843182563782,
0.80579674243927,
0.046902913600206375,
0.078339584171772,
-0.5563428401947021,
-0.47780641913414,
-0.6147850751876831,
-0.4222368001937866,
-0.0623113289475441,
0.32353147864341736,
-0.7158440947532654,
0.3526375889778137,
-0.2321125715970993,
-0.6487696766853333,
-0.8001126050949097,
0.07249636203050613,
0.16155122220516205,
0.2539295554161072,
0.5274142622947693,
-0.4285471737384796,
-0.6980829238891602,
-0.5371657609939575,
-0.39618581533432007,
0.25029265880584717,
-0.07945407927036285,
0.05097636952996254,
-0.14025260508060455,
-0.16230987012386322,
0.9849608540534973,
-0.6211416125297546,
-0.38380149006843567,
-0.5014280676841736,
0.2230214774608612,
0.06751615554094315,
0.3211441934108734,
0.2836203873157501,
-0.2553211450576782,
-0.7694940567016602,
-0.1559840887784958,
-0.5309426188468933,
0.015941042453050613,
-0.3789392411708832,
-0.20474249124526978,
-0.16761265695095062,
0.2651273310184479,
-0.4533518850803375,
0.49680233001708984,
0.37936151027679443,
-0.4852152466773987,
0.4613649845123291,
-0.29763954877853394,
-0.009218849241733551,
-1.1809686422348022,
-0.20302292704582214,
-0.08576570451259613,
-0.24526947736740112,
-0.943682849407196,
-0.24015064537525177,
-0.36033308506011963,
-0.42426353693008423,
-0.3940032422542572,
0.25425025820732117,
-0.3385249972343445,
-0.1266714334487915,
-0.5238847136497498,
0.02036881446838379,
-0.1727735698223114,
0.57080078125,
-0.040316786617040634,
0.7539513111114502,
0.6857993602752686,
-0.2480548918247223,
0.7215074896812439,
0.6209625601768494,
0.026606818661093712,
0.8737517595291138,
-0.34440863132476807,
0.594343900680542,
-0.06220807135105133,
0.5400300621986389,
-0.7825517058372498,
-0.41097840666770935,
0.16708947718143463,
-0.11008618026971817,
0.2637360095977783,
-0.38850417733192444,
-0.16344629228115082,
-0.23629209399223328,
-0.41538575291633606,
0.23742030560970306,
-0.06808805465698242,
-0.39060676097869873,
0.3989028334617615,
0.3840934634208679,
-0.5846543908119202,
-0.36194735765457153,
-0.4602220952510834,
0.5745752453804016,
-0.3346570134162903,
-0.4134690761566162,
0.39040377736091614,
-0.1341984122991562,
0.026536960154771805,
-0.20550452172756195,
0.4239486753940582,
0.007451244629919529,
-0.37391355633735657,
0.26976242661476135,
0.3944394588470459,
0.0033749642316251993,
0.3254924714565277,
0.31358611583709717,
-0.385833740234375,
0.15422320365905762,
-0.4349932074546814,
0.8664286732673645,
-0.09805134683847427,
-0.7827972769737244,
-0.34548887610435486,
0.9093960523605347,
0.6442825198173523,
-0.27040332555770874,
0.8913346529006958,
0.921764075756073,
-0.3160800039768219,
0.13976891338825226,
-0.5138462781906128,
-0.3953573405742645,
-0.4350033104419708,
0.49882692098617554,
-0.06871654093265533,
-0.833505392074585,
0.1472436785697937,
-0.1868383288383484,
0.3586285710334778,
-0.05042295530438423,
0.804721474647522,
0.16367967426776886,
1.4946303367614746,
0.427846759557724,
-0.001289324020035565,
0.6299936771392822,
-0.32325711846351624,
0.596055269241333,
-0.9729433655738831,
0.0007600756362080574,
-0.041208118200302124,
-0.37844520807266235,
-0.6078768968582153,
-0.2738218903541565,
0.5360598564147949,
0.03080112487077713,
-0.33173519372940063,
0.029923664405941963,
-0.6001338362693787,
0.16213203966617584,
0.3665209114551544,
0.1993408501148224,
0.6653920412063599,
0.043359190225601196,
0.20106245577335358,
-0.6613098382949829,
-0.6359121203422546,
-0.4084412157535553,
1.4191566705703735,
0.38054442405700684,
0.5782919526100159,
0.028597502037882805,
0.48691698908805847,
0.019929099828004837,
0.6487759351730347,
-1.1329888105392456,
0.3200541138648987,
0.2991012632846832,
-0.6248339414596558,
-0.2641823887825012,
-0.13745801150798798,
-1.0547621250152588,
0.2236359715461731,
-0.5936855673789978,
-0.9784860610961914,
-0.0060471040196716785,
0.10571929067373276,
-0.35026609897613525,
0.29548531770706177,
-0.47165098786354065,
0.7875441312789917,
-0.5290528535842896,
-0.42606011033058167,
-0.5392294526100159,
-0.47121506929397583,
0.4714491069316864,
-0.20960476994514465,
0.08143062144517899,
-0.08149605244398117,
0.3282887637615204,
0.5136462450027466,
-0.5688867568969727,
0.5480915307998657,
-0.2639602720737457,
-0.2006625086069107,
0.06027780845761299,
-0.08330488950014114,
0.4946141242980957,
0.11101547628641129,
-0.12758131325244904,
-0.20708979666233063,
0.31507185101509094,
-0.31606346368789673,
-0.7881065607070923,
0.4324007034301758,
-0.5611341595649719,
-0.43626752495765686,
-0.1900620311498642,
-0.811481773853302,
-0.9100362062454224,
0.12609197199344635,
0.11590990424156189,
0.468228280544281,
-0.1489618867635727,
0.07845883816480637,
-0.02166391909122467,
-0.17533113062381744,
0.042532969266176224,
0.4749692976474762,
-0.6229120492935181,
-0.6793201565742493,
1.0263580083847046,
-0.08254382759332657,
0.2393433004617691,
-0.5079368352890015,
0.18052753806114197,
-0.36799225211143494,
-0.5110408663749695,
-0.0519019179046154,
0.2968270778656006,
-0.7071697115898132,
-0.16682744026184082,
-0.5293798446655273,
-0.22506672143936157,
-0.7717620134353638,
0.13481482863426208,
-0.52982497215271,
-0.384926974773407,
-0.01298754196614027,
-0.37112748622894287,
0.6520788669586182,
0.6159796714782715,
-0.09420576691627502,
0.6181492209434509,
-1.1376124620437622,
0.2820053994655609,
0.24469570815563202,
0.30233001708984375,
0.03055337816476822,
-0.3342725336551666,
-0.42319703102111816,
0.31679490208625793,
-0.747607409954071,
-1.0489319562911987,
0.6305626034736633,
0.3135799169540405,
0.2543136179447174,
0.6143043041229248,
-0.014559687115252018,
1.1407874822616577,
-0.395101934671402,
0.7359859347343445,
0.46832072734832764,
-0.6500818133354187,
0.49734973907470703,
-0.45554840564727783,
0.23723089694976807,
0.5277882814407349,
0.4024066627025604,
-0.7975651025772095,
-0.5587003827095032,
-0.5999119877815247,
-0.9126383662223816,
0.9377089738845825,
0.09075209498405457,
0.3539045751094818,
0.232412651181221,
0.3783254623413086,
0.11112424731254578,
0.3472698926925659,
-0.5914549827575684,
-0.2864729166030884,
-0.2289518564939499,
-0.20066231489181519,
0.30698251724243164,
-0.14860187470912933,
-0.6124679446220398,
-0.41966405510902405,
0.7956027984619141,
-0.31997549533843994,
0.501436710357666,
-0.019545363262295723,
0.40437445044517517,
-0.31355249881744385,
0.4536897838115692,
0.28260400891304016,
0.6683111786842346,
-0.10405827313661575,
-0.09711860120296478,
0.4162091314792633,
-0.48188820481300354,
0.013631130568683147,
0.21640576422214508,
0.31667855381965637,
-0.12738613784313202,
0.3853958249092102,
1.0145132541656494,
-0.1263417750597,
-0.5549126863479614,
0.18620215356349945,
-0.2748951017856598,
-0.03844769299030304,
-0.37264326214790344,
0.10337869077920914,
0.14492052793502808,
0.4378880262374878,
0.23785501718521118,
-0.3257823884487152,
0.2108365297317505,
-0.6301470398902893,
0.0918063297867775,
0.4731314182281494,
-0.599849283695221,
-0.13467922806739807,
0.25742894411087036,
0.08880985528230667,
-0.6890628933906555,
0.8731273412704468,
0.011303340084850788,
-0.15795458853244781,
-0.04974236339330673,
0.8101963996887207,
0.827350378036499,
0.07968243956565857,
0.2891171872615814,
0.33455395698547363,
-0.2940068244934082,
0.1123397946357727,
0.13371720910072327,
-0.032308854162693024,
-0.7390702962875366,
-0.6685139536857605,
-0.3805599510669708,
-0.7074319124221802,
0.4407423436641693,
-0.9815652966499329,
0.405017226934433,
-0.2509307265281677,
-0.4243210554122925,
-0.17307962477207184,
-0.17510229349136353,
-0.5299474596977234,
-0.22285668551921844,
0.35611385107040405,
0.578730046749115,
-0.5472415089607239,
0.831906259059906,
0.8015349507331848,
-0.1260652393102646,
-0.6934863924980164,
-0.023709630593657494,
0.13350915908813477,
-0.40569525957107544,
-0.05434570461511612,
0.1162189468741417,
-0.2664960026741028,
0.19702281057834625,
-0.6079753637313843,
-0.604820966720581,
1.1054061651229858,
0.8558014035224915,
-0.3888159990310669,
-0.16849970817565918,
0.5896306037902832,
0.8501277565956116,
-0.7044162750244141,
0.42653322219848633,
0.8970164060592651,
0.5026993751525879,
0.33325645327568054,
-0.7839338779449463,
-0.2651156187057495,
-0.1587853729724884,
-0.08870318531990051,
0.04969474673271179,
-0.218137726187706,
0.13742603361606598,
-0.1364886462688446,
-0.114913210272789,
-0.05583016946911812,
0.41627037525177,
0.4117983281612396,
0.22918233275413513,
0.3748980164527893,
0.5464826822280884,
0.7203211784362793,
-0.0007581390091218054,
0.9107706546783447,
-0.627327561378479,
0.4938780665397644,
1.4222098588943481,
-0.384115606546402,
0.6201661825180054,
0.5777031779289246,
-0.37420955300331116,
0.2894616723060608,
0.4527018368244171,
0.03691377863287926,
0.19929239153862,
-0.06024528667330742,
-0.47008711099624634,
-0.43630078434944153,
-0.4899553656578064,
-0.29650530219078064,
0.5344454050064087,
0.5690394639968872,
-0.11721882224082947,
-0.17355157434940338,
0.23576578497886658,
0.02304260991513729,
-0.05406170338392258,
0.031132200732827187,
1.013550877571106,
0.2584833800792694,
-0.7149989008903503,
0.23006531596183777,
-0.07482851296663284,
0.20175394415855408,
-0.629126787185669,
-0.20066951215267181,
-0.08231966942548752,
0.2404983937740326,
-0.38931238651275635,
-0.7358270883560181,
0.5990636348724365,
0.1326914280653,
0.23159007728099823,
-0.5475382208824158,
0.7589823007583618,
-0.750641405582428,
-0.7947548627853394,
0.31180545687675476,
0.8266240954399109,
0.03889210522174835,
-0.1100563332438469,
-0.701577365398407,
-0.1097061038017273,
-0.14510875940322876,
-0.13526053726673126,
0.47800832986831665,
0.16387365758419037,
0.3215318024158478,
0.614842414855957,
0.8904516696929932,
0.5115625858306885,
-0.042930226773023605,
0.2629510462284088,
0.9605583548545837,
-0.5290781259536743,
-0.345926433801651,
-0.7217453122138977,
0.6719074249267578,
-0.3643294870853424,
-0.2816895842552185,
0.724280834197998,
0.3898383378982544,
0.4394012987613678,
0.17339098453521729,
0.7198810577392578,
0.13695964217185974,
0.6495991349220276,
-0.2997739017009735,
0.35698798298835754,
-0.27256327867507935,
0.345571905374527,
-0.2763567268848419,
-0.9610539674758911,
-0.2208707481622696,
0.49873217940330505,
-0.5543199181556702,
-0.18908320367336273,
0.5099406242370605,
0.8077688813209534,
0.009145433083176613,
0.3100520074367523,
0.19214390218257904,
0.14272019267082214,
0.8448173999786377,
0.3498767018318176,
1.0027238130569458,
-0.18439075350761414,
0.5068100690841675,
-0.1951567530632019,
-0.047055572271347046,
0.17024105787277222,
-0.7969295382499695,
-0.6311019062995911,
-0.3264240324497223,
-0.235993430018425,
-0.34603849053382874,
-0.27736029028892517,
1.3658161163330078,
0.638264000415802,
-0.7935551404953003,
-0.30136463046073914,
-0.2221846580505371,
-0.16670919954776764,
-0.13495957851409912,
-0.22388698160648346,
-0.15363265573978424,
-0.4893391728401184,
-0.7465410828590393,
0.7063488960266113,
0.4955897927284241,
-0.16695785522460938,
-0.722481906414032,
-0.05544554442167282,
-0.10070176422595978,
-0.08449799567461014,
0.5267581939697266,
0.04045243188738823,
-0.4126826226711273,
-0.06703662127256393,
-0.23467136919498444,
0.1913212686777115,
0.5246852040290833,
1.277692198753357,
-0.6556877493858337,
0.7601314187049866,
0.06888817250728607,
0.6845895648002625,
0.8829797506332397,
0.07600881904363632,
1.0650569200515747,
-0.7335641384124756,
0.24480175971984863,
0.2884218990802765,
0.2936576306819916,
0.5082003474235535,
-0.46511077880859375,
0.36095914244651794,
-0.12739643454551697,
-0.43698596954345703,
-0.8332517147064209,
0.4048183560371399,
-0.6461811661720276,
0.01417640782892704,
0.8775049448013306,
-0.36304396390914917,
0.4448796808719635,
-0.4660412669181824,
-0.7377729415893555,
0.4746900796890259,
-0.32837384939193726,
0.866124153137207,
0.8229296803474426,
-0.7391656041145325,
-0.3055271506309509,
-0.45576536655426025,
0.5048597455024719,
0.3311041295528412,
-1.0218147039413452,
0.32439181208610535,
0.6175848841667175,
-0.07166799157857895,
0.30103617906570435,
0.5877640843391418,
-0.15656067430973053,
-0.13288536667823792,
-0.3058566451072693,
-0.18876469135284424,
-0.15461322665214539,
-0.16080421209335327,
-0.5112701058387756,
0.05802574381232262,
0.06065068393945694,
0.2931619882583618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08707v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08707v1
|
mOSCAR: A Large-scale Multilingual and Multimodal Document-level Corpus
| 2024-06-13T00:13:32 | 2024-06-13T00:13:32 |
Matthieu Futeral, Armel Zebaze, Pedro Ortiz Suarez, Julien Abadji, Rémi Lacroix, Cordelia Schmid, Rachel Bawden, Benoît Sagot
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Large Language Models (mLLMs) are trained on a large amount of
text-image data. While most mLLMs are trained on caption-like data only,
Alayrac et al. [2022] showed that additionally training them on interleaved
sequences of text and images can lead to the emergence of in-context learning
capabilities. However, the dataset they used, M3W, is not public and is only in
English. There have been attempts to reproduce their results but the released
datasets are English-only. In contrast, current multilingual and multimodal
datasets are either composed of caption-like only or medium-scale or fully
private data. This limits mLLM research for the 7,000 other languages spoken in
the world. We therefore introduce mOSCAR, to the best of our knowledge the
first large-scale multilingual and multimodal document corpus crawled from the
web. It covers 163 languages, 315M documents, 214B tokens and 1.2B images. We
carefully conduct a set of filtering and evaluation steps to make sure mOSCAR
is sufficiently safe, diverse and of good quality. We additionally train two
types of multilingual model to prove the benefits of mOSCAR: (1) a model
trained on a subset of mOSCAR and captioning data and (2) a model train on
captioning data only. The model additionally trained on mOSCAR shows a strong
boost in few-shot learning performance across various multilingual image-text
tasks and benchmarks, confirming previous findings for English-only mLLMs.
|
[
-0.46950164437294006,
-0.5971786975860596,
0.22525013983249664,
0.1163494884967804,
-0.19347673654556274,
-0.010238857939839363,
-0.2653147876262665,
-0.4190753698348999,
-0.18331171572208405,
0.4986913502216339,
-0.2958187162876129,
-0.3364909291267395,
-0.7529603838920593,
0.12011488527059555,
-0.3702073097229004,
1.2354449033737183,
0.15350061655044556,
0.4711766242980957,
-0.5017629861831665,
-0.5421686172485352,
0.1823255568742752,
-0.857303261756897,
-0.7238709330558777,
-0.007042831275612116,
0.8990527391433716,
0.10059677809476852,
0.600573718547821,
0.6609439253807068,
0.7047516107559204,
0.2536888122558594,
-0.05723473057150841,
0.3704545199871063,
-0.3822912573814392,
-0.09740156680345535,
-0.17847490310668945,
-0.461529940366745,
-0.16325032711029053,
-0.22605404257774353,
0.7462803721427917,
0.5386157631874084,
0.042945586144924164,
0.07580886781215668,
0.02476109005510807,
0.6228857040405273,
-0.5906108021736145,
0.34544676542282104,
-0.5312489867210388,
0.004859019070863724,
-0.3945468068122864,
-0.1473323404788971,
-0.49938565492630005,
-0.07322841882705688,
0.0813378244638443,
-0.4076898992061615,
0.2190062254667282,
0.027433287352323532,
0.7772464156150818,
0.004252457991242409,
-1.0260090827941895,
-0.38170790672302246,
-0.5087735652923584,
0.9691908359527588,
-0.5457627773284912,
0.6266978979110718,
0.43419843912124634,
0.41887983679771423,
0.06371597200632095,
-0.5705753564834595,
-0.6247234344482422,
-0.29876530170440674,
-0.18157564103603363,
-0.07220566272735596,
-0.11206009238958359,
-0.13039831817150116,
0.34206217527389526,
0.31347599625587463,
-0.6394519805908203,
0.1230553612112999,
-0.5815447568893433,
-0.3801664412021637,
0.45092931389808655,
0.07176712900400162,
0.2522389888763428,
-0.06690553575754166,
-0.53859943151474,
-0.21639753878116608,
-0.869067370891571,
0.1123017892241478,
0.21971078217029572,
0.3774361312389374,
-0.30875352025032043,
0.6707884669303894,
0.05133949592709541,
0.6286022067070007,
-0.39308154582977295,
-0.7935656905174255,
0.23738420009613037,
-0.15998698770999908,
0.01885331980884075,
-0.34029263257980347,
1.0079587697982788,
0.21212096512317657,
0.2449851632118225,
-0.004115146119147539,
-0.40755727887153625,
-0.1464163064956665,
-0.1154213473200798,
-0.8618288040161133,
-0.13091722130775452,
0.07611583918333054,
-0.38566675782203674,
-0.025368457660079002,
0.015987999737262726,
-0.7537775635719299,
-0.5269625782966614,
-0.2161020040512085,
0.4214032292366028,
-0.6148989200592041,
-0.10815128684043884,
-0.4526776671409607,
0.027270816266536713,
0.14248597621917725,
0.26952359080314636,
-0.6713664531707764,
0.1169542521238327,
0.41832271218299866,
0.824535608291626,
-0.27460619807243347,
-0.5399981141090393,
-0.5843369364738464,
0.21504737436771393,
-0.3254529535770416,
0.7273013591766357,
-0.5496857762336731,
-0.2997662127017975,
0.24383020401000977,
0.32547301054000854,
-0.03956843540072441,
-0.3081118166446686,
0.4386054277420044,
-0.7143492102622986,
0.3251911401748657,
-0.1191309243440628,
-0.3638462424278259,
-0.3660368025302887,
0.5025925040245056,
-0.922492504119873,
0.870858907699585,
0.027719559147953987,
-0.7447068095207214,
0.4536288380622864,
-0.7657946944236755,
-0.7745861411094666,
-0.05421259626746178,
-0.1476898193359375,
-0.3536466062068939,
-0.15134118497371674,
0.4651649594306946,
0.6499912142753601,
-0.29819753766059875,
0.2560310363769531,
-0.10221564769744873,
0.03566739708185196,
0.39504167437553406,
-0.7033653855323792,
0.5967851877212524,
0.3473641574382782,
-0.08855917304754257,
0.028506528586149216,
-0.7743440270423889,
-0.1324358880519867,
0.11093281209468842,
-0.6312023997306824,
-0.3353237211704254,
0.07778522372245789,
0.43755099177360535,
0.39816129207611084,
0.22894257307052612,
-0.636776864528656,
-0.03462101146578789,
-0.07251665741205215,
0.6214188933372498,
0.48673343658447266,
-0.14400614798069,
0.47411274909973145,
-0.46221381425857544,
0.5431514978408813,
0.16808927059173584,
-0.07634293287992477,
-0.7552603483200073,
-0.3350662589073181,
-0.7189282774925232,
-0.6457939743995667,
0.29896020889282227,
0.35140183568000793,
-0.9704234600067139,
-0.18669931590557098,
-0.4922000467777252,
-0.49050000309944153,
-0.49120089411735535,
0.20441287755966187,
0.6151759028434753,
0.28106632828712463,
0.29420965909957886,
0.12643010914325714,
-0.45102378726005554,
-1.0588269233703613,
0.26473212242126465,
0.17017897963523865,
0.11841139197349548,
0.29991501569747925,
0.6624161005020142,
-0.1991371214389801,
0.728866696357727,
-0.15103177726268768,
-0.44723665714263916,
-0.3995617628097534,
0.11842387169599533,
-0.0073442645370960236,
0.4769761264324188,
0.6198294162750244,
-1.2591640949249268,
-0.6138374209403992,
0.3332339823246002,
-0.655489444732666,
0.2938760817050934,
-0.07259803265333176,
0.13653293251991272,
0.5688073039054871,
0.5283275246620178,
-0.4349646270275116,
-0.09897781908512115,
1.0126769542694092,
0.20107989013195038,
0.2889835834503174,
-0.42553621530532837,
0.2978562116622925,
-1.1695841550827026,
0.14938324689865112,
-0.05635751038789749,
-0.34596195816993713,
-0.4712046980857849,
0.35097768902778625,
0.42388004064559937,
-0.3730052709579468,
-0.779927670955658,
0.8221277594566345,
-0.5473583340644836,
0.03484819829463959,
-0.12429530918598175,
-0.038960713893175125,
0.08620719611644745,
0.661211371421814,
0.2194574773311615,
0.9710977673530579,
0.5380319356918335,
-0.6420546770095825,
0.21354812383651733,
0.18119235336780548,
-0.5524678230285645,
0.5175359845161438,
-0.32438015937805176,
0.05312907323241234,
-0.32905128598213196,
0.2529439330101013,
-1.0266801118850708,
-0.4529893398284912,
-0.2568044662475586,
-0.34736865758895874,
0.23987701535224915,
-0.1873278170824051,
-0.6160948276519775,
-0.3734762370586395,
-0.136892169713974,
0.3539370596408844,
0.1903008222579956,
-0.7215051651000977,
0.7075988054275513,
0.5762056708335876,
-0.14287233352661133,
-0.5899905562400818,
-0.8428046703338623,
0.014738988131284714,
-0.10565494745969772,
-0.49532970786094666,
-0.05066944658756256,
-0.14138908684253693,
-0.1657947450876236,
-0.1518496572971344,
0.2212323695421219,
-0.534687340259552,
-0.21185947954654694,
0.39482566714286804,
0.2859859764575958,
-0.22252684831619263,
0.307910293340683,
0.022799182683229446,
-0.07591643184423447,
-0.26887109875679016,
-0.1272369921207428,
0.6413428783416748,
-0.2093510627746582,
-0.506257951259613,
-0.2506065368652344,
0.4704904556274414,
1.0924040079116821,
-0.5739415884017944,
0.959162175655365,
0.6673489212989807,
-0.2861122488975525,
0.12687160074710846,
-0.5582844614982605,
0.1616523116827011,
-0.4002198576927185,
0.4743514060974121,
-0.5971111059188843,
-1.0500121116638184,
0.24842232465744019,
0.22156238555908203,
0.23450498282909393,
0.44527000188827515,
0.6526210904121399,
-0.3672107458114624,
1.0956422090530396,
0.8644943237304688,
-0.21846412122249603,
0.4362903833389282,
-0.2610853314399719,
-0.10171540826559067,
-0.5663444399833679,
-0.3311856687068939,
-0.45421937108039856,
-0.14607970416545868,
-0.5967311263084412,
-0.44196730852127075,
0.5659127235412598,
-0.18149027228355408,
-0.0960531085729599,
0.3913801610469818,
-0.018483877182006836,
0.5508036017417908,
0.4683769643306732,
0.11882966011762619,
0.3300374150276184,
0.13402612507343292,
-0.1789543330669403,
-0.18307125568389893,
-0.7474468350410461,
-0.5272557735443115,
1.0901309251785278,
0.22995203733444214,
0.7256388068199158,
0.2828458845615387,
0.24906152486801147,
0.3810574412345886,
0.23058976233005524,
-0.9219565987586975,
0.43148431181907654,
-0.29702985286712646,
-0.8848130702972412,
-0.3655208945274353,
-0.321722149848938,
-1.0992218255996704,
0.6310898661613464,
-0.38181960582733154,
-0.17077012360095978,
-0.04525994136929512,
0.023129748180508614,
-0.05746974050998688,
0.37644580006599426,
-0.5323526263237,
0.6845571398735046,
-0.4297220706939697,
-0.2473783642053604,
-0.21127445995807648,
-0.6374703645706177,
0.26869043707847595,
-0.3500206768512726,
0.7797861695289612,
-0.09054562449455261,
-0.1822664737701416,
0.6323125958442688,
-0.26499998569488525,
0.7712125778198242,
-0.05556054040789604,
-0.21648478507995605,
0.19616875052452087,
0.20425857603549957,
0.5558086037635803,
-0.2435980588197708,
-0.057033225893974304,
0.23170115053653717,
0.16793590784072876,
-0.6016789078712463,
-0.3383842706680298,
0.5926566123962402,
-0.7497656345367432,
-0.31760644912719727,
-0.33757156133651733,
-0.7714478969573975,
-0.27379488945007324,
0.32803240418434143,
0.38540250062942505,
0.854166567325592,
-0.20821765065193176,
0.6921325922012329,
0.5903598666191101,
-0.2975686192512512,
0.6018791794776917,
0.6408430337905884,
-0.32030951976776123,
-0.48860546946525574,
1.036385178565979,
0.04505220428109169,
0.367976576089859,
0.839660108089447,
0.15282492339611053,
-0.2503300905227661,
-0.4515973627567291,
-0.5769137740135193,
0.18433068692684174,
-0.715717613697052,
-0.1528814136981964,
-0.939456582069397,
-0.12725776433944702,
-0.27940282225608826,
-0.2574547231197357,
-0.27716678380966187,
-0.2566782236099243,
-0.005249558016657829,
0.005766559857875109,
0.2175324559211731,
0.5168358087539673,
-0.018793778494000435,
0.29111331701278687,
-1.1228344440460205,
0.22140683233737946,
0.23305612802505493,
-0.11755883693695068,
-0.027278218418359756,
-0.4027734100818634,
-0.3610158860683441,
0.23644398152828217,
0.011015706695616245,
-0.380461186170578,
0.5925295352935791,
0.5002747178077698,
0.6607315540313721,
0.6552134156227112,
-0.1612229198217392,
0.6093244552612305,
-0.6717928051948547,
0.8485548496246338,
0.27134251594543457,
-0.6159889698028564,
0.31248030066490173,
-0.5501517057418823,
0.31138813495635986,
0.3684016764163971,
0.7595323920249939,
-0.6079038977622986,
-0.24098967015743256,
-0.25515028834342957,
-0.6067240834236145,
0.5818544626235962,
-0.11287951469421387,
0.5845208168029785,
-0.15564893186092377,
-0.2555714249610901,
0.39583107829093933,
0.3540724515914917,
-1.071205496788025,
0.042660705745220184,
-0.08508481085300446,
-0.11757898330688477,
-0.3182471692562103,
-0.3146902024745941,
-0.24180875718593597,
-0.13192525506019592,
0.5004507303237915,
-0.2995661199092865,
0.10318335145711899,
0.01214892603456974,
-0.6331157684326172,
0.11673833429813385,
0.4171522259712219,
0.6448240280151367,
0.6565237641334534,
0.060513053089380264,
0.3460349142551422,
0.1800878793001175,
-0.4755159616470337,
0.13289596140384674,
-0.19344757497310638,
0.012942004948854446,
-0.07380879670381546,
0.6325498819351196,
0.7851461172103882,
0.3339308500289917,
-1.1843667030334473,
0.8080357313156128,
0.30905434489250183,
-0.2140011042356491,
-0.2821289002895355,
-0.21553009748458862,
0.01482897438108921,
0.25100404024124146,
0.4852008521556854,
0.018111515790224075,
-0.11949063092470169,
-0.6427026987075806,
0.15210875868797302,
0.4672514498233795,
-0.45936957001686096,
-0.10100086778402328,
0.5382267236709595,
0.20383505523204803,
-0.07323556393384933,
0.3655165135860443,
-0.10431354492902756,
-0.4655091166496277,
0.5622044205665588,
0.6783657670021057,
0.2530986964702606,
0.04035814851522446,
0.20870958268642426,
0.42483803629875183,
0.41256481409072876,
-0.010009012185037136,
0.00047767264186404645,
-0.08771492540836334,
-0.7759395837783813,
-0.29504120349884033,
-0.7132410407066345,
-0.41408446431159973,
0.1971685290336609,
-0.6692972779273987,
0.18263916671276093,
-0.4052145183086395,
0.05811842158436775,
0.02879776433110237,
-0.26288893818855286,
-0.6092659831047058,
0.3121824860572815,
0.20919950306415558,
0.9257819652557373,
-0.6950681209564209,
1.1849985122680664,
0.8326551914215088,
-0.42495355010032654,
-0.37142854928970337,
-0.2360183745622635,
0.12140350043773651,
-0.8200884461402893,
0.7585024833679199,
0.186115100979805,
-0.10893581807613373,
0.05033285170793533,
-0.5299393534660339,
-0.9917922616004944,
0.9913967847824097,
0.2751234769821167,
-0.5642954707145691,
0.1339728683233261,
0.16663385927677155,
0.5558187961578369,
-0.4030340909957886,
0.020083149895071983,
0.0328286774456501,
0.38445305824279785,
0.2133481800556183,
-0.8346461057662964,
-0.3835243880748749,
-0.21825389564037323,
0.03361811488866806,
0.29738911986351013,
-0.6933573484420776,
1.1474149227142334,
-0.22997982800006866,
-0.21292941272258759,
0.20736539363861084,
0.5510851144790649,
0.030105475336313248,
0.06365068256855011,
0.4366014897823334,
0.2602601945400238,
0.7416322231292725,
-0.10173149406909943,
1.3036805391311646,
-0.21773982048034668,
0.20562593638896942,
1.0777720212936401,
-0.23873640596866608,
1.1899176836013794,
0.3993602395057678,
-0.19845078885555267,
0.4894397258758545,
0.5042665004730225,
-0.14927856624126434,
0.6396253705024719,
-0.3047947883605957,
-0.34307044744491577,
-0.13931138813495636,
-0.2127903401851654,
-0.21566952764987946,
0.4564496576786041,
0.251293420791626,
-0.37655162811279297,
-0.27222955226898193,
0.6790976524353027,
0.1764795035123825,
0.12194913625717163,
-0.4160148501396179,
0.6670659184455872,
-0.13766716420650482,
-0.31445595622062683,
0.3537008762359619,
0.031583648175001144,
0.9148996472358704,
-0.8764259815216064,
0.18646809458732605,
-0.16395984590053558,
0.1541990488767624,
-0.11372285336256027,
-0.7989882826805115,
0.12900148332118988,
0.1070893183350563,
-0.36050620675086975,
-0.15891267359256744,
0.5169734358787537,
-0.572908341884613,
-0.5777143239974976,
0.26235431432724,
0.5395676493644714,
0.2715350091457367,
-0.11886350810527802,
-0.4420279562473297,
-0.19115987420082092,
-0.014509294182062149,
-0.14208181202411652,
0.5547444820404053,
0.4508676528930664,
-0.24542900919914246,
0.8951876759529114,
0.9480229020118713,
-0.20884451270103455,
0.13826653361320496,
-0.00570248207077384,
0.7263700366020203,
-0.4778423607349396,
-0.3364507853984833,
-0.7707930207252502,
0.5255645513534546,
0.09641402214765549,
-0.22794240713119507,
0.7552213668823242,
0.8301792144775391,
0.9102731347084045,
-0.2898591458797455,
0.9894399642944336,
-0.15169508755207062,
0.47872650623321533,
-0.610787034034729,
0.8365277647972107,
-0.8137500882148743,
-0.315382719039917,
-0.02123871073126793,
-0.7891771793365479,
-0.3157375752925873,
0.46085986495018005,
-0.12957994639873505,
-0.2678851783275604,
0.7916454672813416,
0.8861352801322937,
-0.07559589296579361,
-0.2596380114555359,
0.6769254207611084,
0.027175787836313248,
0.1583709716796875,
0.4023020267486572,
0.8312413096427917,
-0.28461337089538574,
0.9292399883270264,
-0.22831721603870392,
-0.09364780783653259,
-0.03458460420370102,
-0.8239122033119202,
-1.1074968576431274,
-0.9257948994636536,
0.06812433898448944,
-0.07548186928033829,
-0.1737269163131714,
0.9661052823066711,
0.7695695161819458,
-0.9763902425765991,
-0.22226400673389435,
0.37426215410232544,
-0.12179769575595856,
-0.1185772716999054,
-0.1645796298980713,
0.14715932309627533,
-0.1943361461162567,
-0.9989194869995117,
0.43963876366615295,
0.20575299859046936,
0.22618871927261353,
-0.4022676646709442,
-0.12977872788906097,
-0.3321680724620819,
-0.03400213271379471,
0.9547480344772339,
0.20961947739124298,
-0.653219997882843,
0.00505637563765049,
-0.04950262978672981,
-0.5791493654251099,
0.15722720324993134,
0.7397844195365906,
-0.5317144393920898,
0.39732640981674194,
0.2223414182662964,
0.632736325263977,
0.6921805143356323,
-0.3991568684577942,
0.3742505609989166,
-0.7183943390846252,
0.555106520652771,
-0.004252302926033735,
0.6381494998931885,
0.45017123222351074,
-0.12822602689266205,
0.5171895623207092,
0.054876506328582764,
-0.31753814220428467,
-0.6728057265281677,
0.029619114473462105,
-0.9529663324356079,
-0.353122740983963,
1.333433985710144,
-0.3670443594455719,
-0.1137203797698021,
0.004179839044809341,
-0.5167887806892395,
-0.02306229993700981,
-0.28496164083480835,
0.33386510610580444,
0.8662513494491577,
0.26362013816833496,
-0.41074398159980774,
-0.6256423592567444,
0.07433413714170456,
-0.07641638815402985,
-0.8150347471237183,
-0.11183781921863556,
0.6856834292411804,
0.2934739291667938,
0.29416948556900024,
0.4773038625717163,
-0.2851838767528534,
0.16896511614322662,
0.11062964051961899,
0.14318685233592987,
-0.278529554605484,
-0.4364874064922333,
-0.30152562260627747,
0.47555726766586304,
-0.13435904681682587,
-0.1155514270067215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08702v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08702v2
|
VLind-Bench: Measuring Language Priors in Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-06-13T00:00:20 | 2024-06-17T23:52:24 |
Kang-il Lee, Minbeom Kim, Minsung Kim, Dongryeol Lee, Hyukhun Koh, Kyomin Jung
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Large Vision-Language Models (LVLMs) have demonstrated outstanding
performance across various multimodal tasks. However, they suffer from a
problem known as language prior, where responses are generated based solely on
textual patterns while disregarding image information. Addressing the issue of
language prior is crucial, as it can lead to undesirable biases or
hallucinations when dealing with images that are out of training distribution.
Despite its importance, current methods for accurately measuring language
priors in LVLMs are poorly studied. Although existing benchmarks based on
counterfactual or out-of-distribution images can partially be used to measure
language priors, they fail to disentangle language priors from other
confounding factors. To this end, we propose a new benchmark called
VLind-Bench, which is the first benchmark specifically designed to measure the
language priors, or blindness, of LVLMs. It not only includes tests on
counterfactual images to assess language priors but also involves a series of
tests to evaluate more basic capabilities such as commonsense knowledge, visual
perception, and commonsense biases. For each instance in our benchmark, we
ensure that all these basic tests are passed before evaluating the language
priors, thereby minimizing the influence of other factors on the assessment.
The evaluation and analysis of recent LVLMs in our benchmark reveal that almost
all models exhibit a significant reliance on language priors, presenting a
strong challenge in the field.
|
[
-0.528997540473938,
-0.6345182061195374,
0.5974571108818054,
0.29854944348335266,
-0.3111235499382019,
-0.51494961977005,
-0.33237817883491516,
-0.3341740369796753,
-0.21717272698879242,
0.6157216429710388,
-0.40200725197792053,
-0.2879886031150818,
-0.5569894313812256,
-0.012785300612449646,
-0.5041046738624573,
0.48695826530456543,
-0.1632952094078064,
0.22519494593143463,
-0.4783775806427002,
-0.4653332233428955,
-0.40149134397506714,
-0.3650270700454712,
-0.22127842903137207,
-0.207773357629776,
0.45679202675819397,
-0.013535933569073677,
0.410395085811615,
0.3133735656738281,
0.595839262008667,
0.3008494973182678,
0.12160122394561768,
-0.0356169231235981,
-0.44075697660446167,
0.23315736651420593,
-0.3690522015094757,
-0.34750500321388245,
-0.14708580076694489,
-0.10570504516363144,
0.9077563285827637,
0.9696118831634521,
-0.013691825792193413,
0.25544971227645874,
-0.07489456236362457,
0.83501136302948,
-1.2590749263763428,
0.06683309376239777,
-0.6900277733802795,
0.2028580904006958,
-0.5570480823516846,
0.0023185356985777617,
-0.52044677734375,
-0.22027118504047394,
0.1454148143529892,
-0.44610708951950073,
0.23283952474594116,
-0.0035080481320619583,
0.6983766555786133,
0.5117619037628174,
-0.2885954678058624,
0.10861734300851822,
-0.6572518348693848,
0.9194760918617249,
-0.6867774128913879,
0.7528311610221863,
0.5982224941253662,
0.525307834148407,
-0.10825565457344055,
-0.7748556137084961,
-0.9034462571144104,
-0.46455028653144836,
-0.05231854319572449,
0.18392090499401093,
-0.28798139095306396,
-0.2855320870876312,
0.3692685663700104,
0.14908862113952637,
-0.9850297570228577,
0.10549934208393097,
-0.24951224029064178,
-0.18811409175395966,
0.4585428535938263,
0.2203834503889084,
-0.10032421350479126,
0.16732387244701385,
-0.46234625577926636,
-0.349893182516098,
-0.9014524221420288,
-0.10706539452075958,
-0.0914020910859108,
0.06931407004594803,
0.1410883218050003,
0.6340429782867432,
-0.31036221981048584,
1.0915584564208984,
-0.16147764027118683,
-0.07050442695617676,
0.5320366621017456,
-0.3574594557285309,
-0.4363621175289154,
-0.05560724809765816,
0.5976365208625793,
0.5248115062713623,
0.6093342304229736,
0.02059650979936123,
-0.06480059027671814,
0.21929140388965607,
-0.006193507928401232,
-0.819298267364502,
-0.19808010756969452,
0.03293147310614586,
-0.37847891449928284,
-0.03833175078034401,
-0.26134708523750305,
-0.5780043005943298,
-0.869186282157898,
-0.22840780019760132,
0.34408462047576904,
-0.20145513117313385,
-0.4346608817577362,
-0.10235406458377838,
0.02391156554222107,
0.37772294878959656,
0.20374795794487,
-0.661328136920929,
0.3927645683288574,
0.3693369925022125,
0.5777064561843872,
-0.07791080325841904,
-0.47776108980178833,
-0.9609051942825317,
-0.035338692367076874,
-0.5995555520057678,
0.8026147484779358,
-0.6039214730262756,
-0.27280744910240173,
0.25305628776550293,
0.1925116330385208,
-0.056533053517341614,
-0.7082023620605469,
0.4511454105377197,
-0.3450291156768799,
0.11127909272909164,
-0.40961793065071106,
-0.6427381038665771,
-0.1331208199262619,
0.28903016448020935,
-0.4205055832862854,
0.8565019965171814,
0.1144096702337265,
-0.6001695394515991,
0.667351245880127,
0.16619890928268433,
-0.3086250126361847,
0.116949662566185,
-0.5542933344841003,
-0.45025068521499634,
0.29772260785102844,
0.38936328887939453,
0.35541898012161255,
-0.47325053811073303,
0.19186055660247803,
-0.5511434674263,
-0.36912402510643005,
0.1763157695531845,
-0.5357441902160645,
0.6356277465820312,
-0.11621295660734177,
-0.3214324414730072,
0.05101340264081955,
-0.8361543416976929,
0.2690267860889435,
-0.01273972075432539,
0.11233778297901154,
-0.6905767917633057,
0.04932960122823715,
0.1618199646472931,
0.1650831401348114,
0.1066063717007637,
-0.2569337487220764,
-0.08061082661151886,
-0.41776713728904724,
-0.12774257361888885,
0.9142342805862427,
-0.3588968813419342,
0.28793394565582275,
-0.07522507756948471,
0.13427656888961792,
-0.024814384058117867,
0.21029455959796906,
-0.23171569406986237,
-0.36237502098083496,
-0.6964215636253357,
-0.3233516812324524,
0.2535507380962372,
0.49002301692962646,
-0.6631379723548889,
0.2107713520526886,
-0.21638557314872742,
-0.5665879249572754,
-0.39531418681144714,
0.21191368997097015,
0.5883080959320068,
0.5931790471076965,
0.29042625427246094,
-0.67198246717453,
-0.531276285648346,
-1.0068095922470093,
-0.3238064646720886,
-0.1087588369846344,
0.07685674726963043,
0.235512837767601,
0.48749175667762756,
-0.15088142454624176,
0.859811007976532,
-0.2870844900608063,
-0.5261528491973877,
0.057060595601797104,
0.07603325694799423,
0.193424254655838,
0.3099540174007416,
0.7557826042175293,
-0.8400912880897522,
-0.7105361819267273,
-0.01848030276596546,
-0.8357447385787964,
-0.2638998329639435,
0.20759950578212738,
0.324490487575531,
0.46568289399147034,
0.7307767868041992,
-0.40966513752937317,
0.614745020866394,
0.6640571355819702,
-0.19752509891986847,
0.6040336489677429,
-0.3320252299308777,
0.04602689668536186,
-0.436796635389328,
0.1653314083814621,
0.13586212694644928,
-0.12711015343666077,
-0.49185293912887573,
0.018041403964161873,
0.27743375301361084,
0.2099200040102005,
-0.5444389581680298,
0.8494279980659485,
-0.5824686884880066,
-0.4398888349533081,
-0.13010722398757935,
0.21456998586654663,
-0.2688789367675781,
0.3582288324832916,
0.24993278086185455,
0.6571975350379944,
0.788232147693634,
-0.4123914837837219,
0.46113672852516174,
0.03168642520904541,
-0.694129467010498,
1.0771939754486084,
-0.8311750292778015,
0.05985606089234352,
-0.4042028784751892,
0.08882192522287369,
-1.0995352268218994,
0.19264599680900574,
0.2747235596179962,
-0.1965327113866806,
0.3675443232059479,
-0.07774244993925095,
-0.34792882204055786,
-0.4460453987121582,
-0.1720326691865921,
0.40180420875549316,
0.5029647350311279,
-0.3539000451564789,
0.4073549509048462,
0.20060795545578003,
-0.038525164127349854,
-0.7468585968017578,
-0.6872798800468445,
0.01378160621970892,
0.07135052233934402,
-0.5417727828025818,
0.24862687289714813,
-0.19244644045829773,
-0.5472777485847473,
0.15589086711406708,
-0.14732283353805542,
-0.29157933592796326,
-0.3013015389442444,
0.1929943859577179,
0.12695114314556122,
-0.5000240206718445,
0.18394629657268524,
-0.2752645015716553,
-0.3271259367465973,
-0.13712233304977417,
-0.2999456524848938,
0.5302695631980896,
-0.21018686890602112,
-0.6418134570121765,
-0.20136667788028717,
0.21611499786376953,
0.6760851740837097,
-0.6606422662734985,
0.6904276609420776,
0.6890299320220947,
-0.27027755975723267,
-0.07356710731983185,
-0.748899519443512,
-0.041797444224357605,
-0.4231448769569397,
0.6983240246772766,
-0.28265056014060974,
-0.5052653551101685,
0.24752278625965118,
0.0012835711240768433,
-0.27881962060928345,
0.22032828629016876,
0.6592748165130615,
-0.09629479050636292,
0.7107802629470825,
0.6573907136917114,
-0.05806124582886696,
0.46825873851776123,
0.04788309708237648,
0.08099894970655441,
-0.6780232787132263,
0.11557957530021667,
-0.4108157455921173,
0.09541656821966171,
-0.3586963415145874,
-0.549598217010498,
0.18953652679920197,
0.046863630414009094,
-0.2326139509677887,
0.13750983774662018,
-0.10340575128793716,
0.4995212256908417,
0.5169804096221924,
-0.20448347926139832,
0.11098924279212952,
-0.05842949450016022,
-0.10690553486347198,
-0.49315834045410156,
-0.3678671419620514,
-0.22661453485488892,
1.2902225255966187,
0.03599865362048149,
0.6102556586265564,
0.026737550273537636,
0.47174566984176636,
0.14053745567798615,
0.43960040807724,
-0.389099657535553,
0.544438898563385,
-0.28144529461860657,
-0.4831409752368927,
-0.39178943634033203,
-0.2253074049949646,
-0.7539075016975403,
0.7741187214851379,
-0.18061381578445435,
-0.8730522394180298,
0.28033384680747986,
0.1507369726896286,
-0.15343476831912994,
-0.11653841286897659,
-0.7035635113716125,
1.1963613033294678,
-0.2642086148262024,
-0.721625030040741,
-0.09524573385715485,
-0.5296196937561035,
0.46112504601478577,
-0.2369856983423233,
0.44397732615470886,
-0.03561784699559212,
0.0670807734131813,
0.3658602237701416,
-0.5000289082527161,
0.778028666973114,
-0.31618332862854004,
-0.12053494900465012,
-0.004835961386561394,
-0.013116112910211086,
0.6239477396011353,
-0.23417502641677856,
0.24561817944049835,
-0.06852362304925919,
0.04136185720562935,
-0.40205609798431396,
-0.5178329944610596,
0.8189306259155273,
-0.47842755913734436,
-0.5122984647750854,
-0.5595083236694336,
-0.3552536964416504,
-0.5667853951454163,
0.40302878618240356,
0.17864930629730225,
0.5054528117179871,
-0.27863597869873047,
0.38618937134742737,
0.7744702100753784,
-0.29338178038597107,
0.4732658863067627,
0.928573489189148,
-0.3869325518608093,
-0.17007917165756226,
0.9670311808586121,
0.1572786271572113,
0.25224173069000244,
0.312799870967865,
0.2449810802936554,
-0.49337461590766907,
-0.8707213997840881,
-0.3664146959781647,
0.08500038832426071,
-0.7006518244743347,
0.20184823870658875,
-0.24928902089595795,
0.05906815454363823,
-0.4375656545162201,
0.17855015397071838,
-0.5017664432525635,
-0.07216756790876389,
0.22072690725326538,
0.19587913155555725,
0.05047417804598808,
0.47568702697753906,
-0.11677202582359314,
-0.03130146488547325,
-0.5538082122802734,
0.5135983824729919,
0.529597818851471,
0.4492534101009369,
-0.12316097319126129,
-0.4966302216053009,
0.035005006939172745,
-0.07561419904232025,
0.08457896113395691,
-0.5899021625518799,
0.27154967188835144,
0.25418344140052795,
0.9640370607376099,
0.2316555380821228,
0.03220239281654358,
0.7749795317649841,
-0.7566158771514893,
0.6856560111045837,
0.3626464605331421,
-0.7472221255302429,
0.43472686409950256,
-0.15591809153556824,
0.3501220941543579,
0.497356116771698,
0.15701709687709808,
-0.4589097201824188,
-0.44745174050331116,
-0.1429206132888794,
-0.889349102973938,
0.3354048728942871,
0.21218208968639374,
-0.09828859567642212,
0.11273019760847092,
-0.22610017657279968,
-0.06512808799743652,
0.25511062145233154,
-0.670073926448822,
-0.35803139209747314,
-0.24323821067810059,
-0.04528772458434105,
-0.5490440130233765,
-0.24613787233829498,
-0.010452487505972385,
-0.3631603717803955,
0.3909180462360382,
0.14143428206443787,
-0.3697676956653595,
0.23766537010669708,
-0.5111788511276245,
-0.12068608403205872,
0.006576911546289921,
1.0440939664840698,
0.8815591335296631,
-0.2290002703666687,
0.17656248807907104,
0.16089360415935516,
-0.5731667876243591,
-0.1397588551044464,
0.284734308719635,
-0.08909982442855835,
0.14671772718429565,
0.5942073464393616,
0.6387667655944824,
0.14291821420192719,
-0.817214846611023,
0.8778027296066284,
-0.184017613530159,
-0.16804955899715424,
-0.5965200662612915,
-0.24449048936367035,
-0.043292224407196045,
0.3566161096096039,
0.3870386779308319,
0.303245484828949,
-0.206339031457901,
-0.5363495349884033,
0.34974542260169983,
0.3983827531337738,
-0.7036500573158264,
0.01961289718747139,
0.4605333209037781,
-0.005752170458436012,
-0.0858190581202507,
0.3750249743461609,
0.03170652315020561,
-0.26983287930488586,
0.43593835830688477,
0.3407348692417145,
0.6815531253814697,
-0.3332427442073822,
0.08747171610593796,
0.4082720875740051,
0.6281870603561401,
-0.16816501319408417,
0.07564979046583176,
-0.060251589864492416,
-0.7026044726371765,
-0.4176621437072754,
-0.5363666415214539,
-0.06243612989783287,
0.22122639417648315,
-0.5020546913146973,
-0.013159173540771008,
-0.20774666965007782,
0.06306679546833038,
-0.037292953580617905,
-0.19828961789608002,
-0.8922244906425476,
0.3294045925140381,
0.26000523567199707,
0.8612829446792603,
-0.8344290256500244,
1.0359569787979126,
0.35515740513801575,
-0.5522846579551697,
-0.15705445408821106,
-0.07704050093889236,
-0.03192612901329994,
-0.937280535697937,
0.8221340775489807,
0.06473702192306519,
-0.24191232025623322,
-0.19573795795440674,
-0.31744256615638733,
-0.7342361807823181,
0.773037850856781,
0.41635680198669434,
-1.007966160774231,
0.355218768119812,
0.1540156602859497,
0.6007932424545288,
-0.061428505927324295,
0.0837787538766861,
0.4228439927101135,
0.6634897589683533,
-0.03092672862112522,
-1.0937680006027222,
-0.0002818447246681899,
-0.31873512268066406,
0.14421020448207855,
0.2475004941225052,
-0.21428534388542175,
0.9356805682182312,
-0.10950177907943726,
-0.11021508276462555,
0.26404979825019836,
0.49826979637145996,
0.3305734097957611,
0.30902737379074097,
0.6146141886711121,
0.507158100605011,
0.7563022375106812,
-0.04368894547224045,
1.0967408418655396,
0.024361660704016685,
0.33993902802467346,
1.291576862335205,
-0.7197333574295044,
1.1883416175842285,
0.8463503122329712,
-0.35924193263053894,
0.16720236837863922,
0.16943612694740295,
0.04865054041147232,
0.9530602693557739,
0.5850140452384949,
-0.08916616439819336,
-0.4477585256099701,
-0.0975755974650383,
-0.8161401152610779,
0.3191811740398407,
0.29622483253479004,
-0.3481861650943756,
-0.3217996060848236,
0.16454431414604187,
-0.4073368310928345,
0.5199523568153381,
-0.33598846197128296,
0.42903563380241394,
0.12444761395454407,
-0.585293710231781,
0.9088586568832397,
-0.3780180811882019,
0.5830129384994507,
-0.6579428911209106,
0.011105676181614399,
-0.3630732297897339,
0.6393764019012451,
0.0913207083940506,
-0.7844657301902771,
0.2749370336532593,
-0.08332977443933487,
-0.07655919343233109,
-0.12977421283721924,
0.5391307473182678,
-0.5012050271034241,
-0.6448994874954224,
0.33511918783187866,
0.5651721954345703,
0.021180009469389915,
-0.10395191609859467,
-0.41910073161125183,
0.3965843915939331,
-0.3460317850112915,
-0.19700074195861816,
0.31985846161842346,
0.28140789270401,
-0.1636447012424469,
0.4789258539676666,
0.4257371127605438,
0.07895416021347046,
0.1285516768693924,
0.39907780289649963,
0.5985116362571716,
-0.456056147813797,
-0.20830322802066803,
-0.8592624664306641,
0.48078328371047974,
-0.29401934146881104,
-0.5229368805885315,
0.7483428716659546,
0.3852963149547577,
0.9647048711776733,
-0.12656383216381073,
0.6963456273078918,
0.15254327654838562,
0.4542447626590729,
-0.5215899348258972,
0.8304903507232666,
-0.8955354690551758,
-0.05531880259513855,
-0.5714840888977051,
-0.9041785001754761,
-0.46286219358444214,
0.8237354755401611,
-0.500667929649353,
-0.09633144736289978,
0.7655130624771118,
0.8829900026321411,
0.04366116598248482,
-0.32335165143013,
0.6804378032684326,
0.4096558690071106,
0.1849849671125412,
0.6202486753463745,
0.9377806186676025,
-0.4515693485736847,
0.5188429951667786,
-0.13815143704414368,
-0.2517454922199249,
-0.19227895140647888,
-0.9964773654937744,
-1.1192681789398193,
-0.8386524319648743,
-0.1850501447916031,
0.004662300460040569,
0.40848907828330994,
0.35479509830474854,
0.6630395650863647,
-0.9052768349647522,
-0.11768050491809845,
-0.19800664484500885,
0.04423206299543381,
-0.4009661078453064,
-0.1203208863735199,
0.31444352865219116,
-0.14918601512908936,
-0.44463208317756653,
0.3182660937309265,
0.314899742603302,
0.08471976965665817,
-0.4938349425792694,
-0.14736051857471466,
0.057309944182634354,
-0.20667029917240143,
0.7820979952812195,
0.36184024810791016,
-0.983710765838623,
-0.31827396154403687,
-0.03792021796107292,
-0.18905335664749146,
-0.3061630427837372,
0.5097978711128235,
-0.9156066179275513,
0.7506040930747986,
0.4100210964679718,
0.3940070569515228,
0.7510024309158325,
-0.5921208262443542,
0.7492578029632568,
-0.618061900138855,
0.6144157648086548,
0.2651559114456177,
0.5572150945663452,
0.42132696509361267,
0.4244559109210968,
0.3756353259086609,
0.3450849652290344,
-0.09027398377656937,
-1.1704003810882568,
0.2857625186443329,
-0.8335201740264893,
-0.31951943039894104,
0.8717712759971619,
-0.11170127987861633,
-0.32762742042541504,
-0.10816804319620132,
-0.23131811618804932,
-0.31575286388397217,
0.20601338148117065,
0.5011756420135498,
0.6482678055763245,
0.5239904522895813,
-0.5037615299224854,
-0.6772922277450562,
0.46709728240966797,
0.44799256324768066,
-0.40682893991470337,
0.2638726830482483,
0.5645570755004883,
0.10282488167285919,
0.08186061680316925,
0.9862655997276306,
0.02128567360341549,
0.5344380140304565,
0.26535847783088684,
-0.2235918492078781,
0.0562310591340065,
-0.2968662977218628,
-0.08336905390024185,
0.2103334367275238,
0.01617436297237873,
-0.3296999931335449
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10290v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10290v1
|
MobileAIBench: Benchmarking LLMs and LMMs for On-Device Use Cases
| 2024-06-12T22:58:12 | 2024-06-12T22:58:12 |
Rithesh Murthy, Liangwei Yang, Juntao Tan, Tulika Manoj Awalgaonkar, Yilun Zhou, Shelby Heinecke, Sachin Desai, Jason Wu, Ran Xu, Sarah Tan, Jianguo Zhang, Zhiwei Liu, Shirley Kokane, Zuxin Liu, Ming Zhu, Huan Wang, Caiming Xiong, Silvio Savarese
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The deployment of Large Language Models (LLMs) and Large Multimodal Models
(LMMs) on mobile devices has gained significant attention due to the benefits
of enhanced privacy, stability, and personalization. However, the hardware
constraints of mobile devices necessitate the use of models with fewer
parameters and model compression techniques like quantization. Currently, there
is limited understanding of quantization's impact on various task performances,
including LLM tasks, LMM tasks, and, critically, trust and safety. There is a
lack of adequate tools for systematically testing these models on mobile
devices. To address these gaps, we introduce MobileAIBench, a comprehensive
benchmarking framework for evaluating mobile-optimized LLMs and LMMs.
MobileAIBench assesses models across different sizes, quantization levels, and
tasks, measuring latency and resource consumption on real devices. Our two-part
open-source framework includes a library for running evaluations on desktops
and an iOS app for on-device latency and hardware utilization measurements. Our
thorough analysis aims to accelerate mobile AI research and deployment by
providing insights into the performance and feasibility of deploying LLMs and
LMMs on mobile platforms.
|
[
-0.40785059332847595,
-0.617548942565918,
0.4150537848472595,
0.3453320562839508,
-0.23919197916984558,
0.029545623809099197,
-0.011999396607279778,
-0.2676992416381836,
0.12902386486530304,
0.2208060324192047,
-0.3551715612411499,
-0.44267573952674866,
-0.18774475157260895,
-0.23728831112384796,
-0.2399115264415741,
0.6598584055900574,
-0.17206719517707825,
0.03414999693632126,
-0.6710087060928345,
-0.5293958187103271,
-0.46290749311447144,
-0.42857789993286133,
-0.5906121134757996,
-0.33921653032302856,
0.5297737121582031,
0.3950459063053131,
0.7801496386528015,
0.6069581508636475,
0.6080890893936157,
0.19120734930038452,
0.2682684063911438,
-0.12679459154605865,
-0.11531146615743637,
0.41099563241004944,
0.14187268912792206,
-0.5747899413108826,
-0.5535578727722168,
0.0166306234896183,
0.5334796905517578,
0.249034583568573,
-0.440411239862442,
0.6177215576171875,
-0.26682886481285095,
0.5803160667419434,
-1.0575058460235596,
-0.17441082000732422,
-0.4306248426437378,
0.18572206795215607,
-0.25381872057914734,
0.06249653920531273,
-0.10186472535133362,
-0.501328706741333,
-0.3371754288673401,
-0.2504992187023163,
-0.07486207038164139,
-0.08685261756181717,
0.4911568760871887,
0.7205560803413391,
-0.8995842933654785,
-0.009638707153499126,
-0.6373345851898193,
0.7310575842857361,
-0.642471969127655,
0.6733949780464172,
0.4643279016017914,
0.44822627305984497,
0.1173151433467865,
-0.9920455813407898,
-0.5754539966583252,
-0.5801138281822205,
0.1432534009218216,
-0.0027708900161087513,
-0.12155155837535858,
0.05485856905579567,
0.4690065085887909,
0.49912071228027344,
-0.8671104907989502,
0.046785157173871994,
0.02651430107653141,
-0.3218032121658325,
0.6980596780776978,
0.18681973218917847,
0.38996967673301697,
0.1297607272863388,
-0.2315339893102646,
-0.09810812771320343,
-0.8114870190620422,
0.16838939487934113,
0.13654537498950958,
-0.09116450697183609,
-0.27204200625419617,
0.7042092680931091,
-0.45153120160102844,
0.7169602513313293,
-0.3732309937477112,
-0.372780442237854,
0.37816092371940613,
-0.4886707067489624,
-0.1460731327533722,
0.024404220283031464,
0.979989767074585,
0.5232374668121338,
-0.13395263254642487,
-0.16479094326496124,
-0.27285242080688477,
0.28328046202659607,
0.1717602163553238,
-1.2362353801727295,
0.0503503642976284,
0.3887794315814972,
-0.5551753044128418,
-0.21357499063014984,
-0.439985066652298,
-0.7298367619514465,
-0.6201597452163696,
0.16832968592643738,
0.2070469707250595,
0.061687007546424866,
-0.13538606464862823,
-0.10425926744937897,
0.16624611616134644,
0.10022260248661041,
-0.1596720963716507,
-0.8724660277366638,
0.26744306087493896,
0.5047484636306763,
1.178320050239563,
-0.23025180399417877,
-0.06649591773748398,
-0.81337970495224,
0.0010681480634957552,
0.002770547056570649,
0.5004977583885193,
-0.3260541558265686,
-0.6963204145431519,
-0.18804866075515747,
-0.28976836800575256,
-0.15297192335128784,
-0.6110731959342957,
1.0229917764663696,
-0.4463656544685364,
-0.40626078844070435,
0.05714650824666023,
-0.33908361196517944,
-0.03399199619889259,
0.3452191650867462,
-0.818543016910553,
1.224224328994751,
-0.08407832682132721,
-0.5925837159156799,
0.146726593375206,
-0.7748390436172485,
-0.5339682698249817,
-0.16237251460552216,
-0.16268660128116608,
-0.6187025904655457,
0.37728995084762573,
0.016222719103097916,
0.5835515856742859,
-0.625654399394989,
0.1714603751897812,
-0.5333747863769531,
-0.3631974756717682,
0.30336400866508484,
-0.40162959694862366,
0.6259596347808838,
0.5500619411468506,
-0.5971319675445557,
0.4310082495212555,
-0.8445812463760376,
0.4172998368740082,
-0.12758377194404602,
-0.22660240530967712,
-0.29286402463912964,
0.261601984500885,
0.24351510405540466,
0.2192046195268631,
0.2851874828338623,
-0.4903527498245239,
0.07343839854001999,
0.05714885890483856,
0.7230239510536194,
0.19114021956920624,
-0.34419167041778564,
0.3768237233161926,
-0.22987006604671478,
0.6552653908729553,
-0.2477448433637619,
0.238480806350708,
-0.3526138961315155,
-0.16889964044094086,
-0.633991539478302,
-0.27217423915863037,
0.5734317898750305,
0.7616985440254211,
-0.6167877912521362,
0.05758014693856239,
-0.5096190571784973,
-0.7004745006561279,
-0.5133591890335083,
0.1712435632944107,
0.48548412322998047,
0.020871367305517197,
-0.1138739213347435,
-0.3650210499763489,
-0.350423127412796,
-0.9773150086402893,
-0.4320356249809265,
-0.11324895918369293,
-0.15412820875644684,
0.3628341555595398,
0.4525299370288849,
-0.5417667627334595,
0.9317060708999634,
-0.11164083331823349,
-0.06860428303480148,
0.14752717316150665,
0.11625741422176361,
-0.3221689462661743,
0.4473668932914734,
0.5044671297073364,
-0.9088301658630371,
-0.39404386281967163,
0.12953710556030273,
-0.7377888560295105,
-0.17319931089878082,
0.013460250571370125,
0.32830315828323364,
0.06289255619049072,
0.6272860765457153,
-0.8628350496292114,
0.3621967136859894,
0.9417762756347656,
-0.2395492047071457,
0.524257242679596,
-0.0015678928466513753,
0.16974984109401703,
-1.1181522607803345,
0.37015998363494873,
0.018280548974871635,
-0.5089722871780396,
-0.3526294231414795,
0.4236558973789215,
0.28368228673934937,
-0.4029448926448822,
-0.5441904664039612,
0.8771507740020752,
-0.1756046712398529,
-0.4644760489463806,
-0.17854948341846466,
0.049632444977760315,
-0.04309368506073952,
0.17830143868923187,
-0.4817091226577759,
1.2770297527313232,
0.15956877171993256,
-0.48768350481987,
0.454142689704895,
-0.2828289866447449,
-0.4633857011795044,
0.5146414041519165,
-0.9922963976860046,
0.18096420168876648,
0.4246215224266052,
0.26175233721733093,
-0.7175441384315491,
-0.2496607005596161,
0.07924617826938629,
-0.24319256842136383,
-0.2626199722290039,
-0.14179430902004242,
-0.8258588314056396,
-0.08789047598838806,
-0.39094865322113037,
0.8013401627540588,
0.42169123888015747,
-0.38326799869537354,
1.0504342317581177,
0.6853173971176147,
-0.035615645349025726,
-0.4195197820663452,
-0.5239865779876709,
-0.025633860379457474,
-0.5239191651344299,
-0.716234564781189,
0.6554743051528931,
-0.1960415542125702,
-0.5042923092842102,
-0.2178625464439392,
-0.3252947926521301,
-0.14895465970039368,
0.4042225182056427,
0.8365362286567688,
-0.21043187379837036,
-0.21467095613479614,
0.05399606004357338,
0.04056185856461525,
-0.11449036747217178,
0.09678249061107635,
0.037828147411346436,
0.5832662582397461,
-0.38122835755348206,
-0.4062289595603943,
-0.5538862943649292,
-0.16259926557540894,
0.8161580562591553,
-0.5718939900398254,
0.4777333438396454,
0.7761130928993225,
-0.21521219611167908,
0.11131347715854645,
-0.5682007670402527,
0.03071957640349865,
-0.47859951853752136,
0.218278169631958,
-0.6005795001983643,
-0.8628380298614502,
0.5585553646087646,
-0.46464842557907104,
0.0723157525062561,
0.11412256956100464,
0.6568309664726257,
0.02955401875078678,
1.2305220365524292,
0.5512590408325195,
-0.2252667099237442,
0.6043885350227356,
-0.01603078842163086,
-0.059841275215148926,
-0.6642911434173584,
-0.09814739227294922,
-0.5222316384315491,
-0.3076339364051819,
-0.663174033164978,
-0.43053746223449707,
0.5450667142868042,
0.16811271011829376,
-0.24547965824604034,
0.04513547942042351,
-0.08855791389942169,
0.5605589151382446,
0.5184693932533264,
0.0680854395031929,
0.2994908094406128,
0.017515895888209343,
-0.07764849811792374,
0.14544562995433807,
-0.5764163136482239,
-0.594287633895874,
1.213029146194458,
0.3811049461364746,
0.6147168278694153,
0.1511598825454712,
0.402046263217926,
0.36653459072113037,
0.3200802206993103,
-0.8509398698806763,
0.6428871154785156,
-0.04608151689171791,
-0.5364474654197693,
-0.0668254941701889,
-0.6121102571487427,
-0.7701660990715027,
0.4227828085422516,
0.08595678210258484,
-0.6444128751754761,
0.0018817372620105743,
0.19858910143375397,
-0.6350470781326294,
0.12867243587970734,
-0.6536582708358765,
1.2706953287124634,
-0.5546375513076782,
-0.6880821585655212,
-0.4426119029521942,
-0.41973960399627686,
0.4999874532222748,
-0.08830346912145615,
0.27968329191207886,
-0.37481576204299927,
-0.1959642916917801,
0.6210374236106873,
-0.32753074169158936,
0.6695315837860107,
-0.23194871842861176,
-0.1824125051498413,
0.23851101100444794,
0.2995286285877228,
0.48149430751800537,
0.20550337433815002,
-0.2022590935230255,
0.21535815298557281,
0.2759664058685303,
-0.2905750572681427,
-0.6284694671630859,
0.9376354813575745,
-0.6071251034736633,
-0.14244703948497772,
-0.30455997586250305,
-0.4672241806983948,
-0.2872495949268341,
0.32635024189949036,
0.13065896928310394,
0.2570212185382843,
-0.4817200303077698,
0.36161375045776367,
0.5146582126617432,
-0.07689651846885681,
0.489747554063797,
0.280230313539505,
-0.5282669067382812,
-0.2697514295578003,
0.9344706535339355,
-0.25813791155815125,
0.010804192163050175,
0.1594884693622589,
-0.048860933631658554,
-0.3495696187019348,
-0.5553296804428101,
-0.6480563879013062,
-0.1883992850780487,
-0.3284589946269989,
-0.20881004631519318,
-0.44302433729171753,
0.1646418571472168,
0.04407883435487747,
0.3508134186267853,
-0.7427425980567932,
-0.5378034710884094,
-0.04937596246600151,
0.22125393152236938,
0.20668776333332062,
0.20845091342926025,
-0.06686489284038544,
0.9464350938796997,
-0.8915022015571594,
0.5218313932418823,
0.3082328736782074,
0.5491947531700134,
-0.15110522508621216,
-0.22137130796909332,
-0.45538830757141113,
0.3292239308357239,
-0.5814082622528076,
-0.36034688353538513,
0.11221776902675629,
0.1774539053440094,
0.33813709020614624,
0.4028036594390869,
-0.11633341759443283,
0.6230140924453735,
-0.33960098028182983,
0.7501012086868286,
0.10296684503555298,
-1.094675064086914,
0.40089645981788635,
-0.19967474043369293,
0.17779231071472168,
0.7173693180084229,
0.39196938276290894,
-0.5131062269210815,
0.2884409725666046,
-0.34569716453552246,
-0.7925012707710266,
0.29159876704216003,
0.19710813462734222,
0.11900842934846878,
0.4048840403556824,
0.20368720591068268,
-0.23926635086536407,
0.29984626173973083,
-0.7376071810722351,
-0.18596169352531433,
-0.06638278812170029,
-0.24081528186798096,
-0.361721009016037,
-0.3177122473716736,
-0.1504637598991394,
-0.050870612263679504,
0.3808375298976898,
0.034013327211141586,
0.026164883747696877,
-0.15514080226421356,
-0.5046398043632507,
0.23950737714767456,
0.08817236870527267,
0.8390405774116516,
0.538724958896637,
-0.2083442360162735,
0.17444656789302826,
0.006728157866746187,
-0.4235527813434601,
0.3557838201522827,
0.188084676861763,
-0.15339045226573944,
0.13475392758846283,
0.03035975806415081,
0.9290401339530945,
0.0900702178478241,
-1.120661735534668,
0.34779268503189087,
-0.3588314652442932,
0.09697701036930084,
-0.38684937357902527,
0.06304366886615753,
0.08960125595331192,
0.38311558961868286,
0.03178896754980087,
-0.11591494083404541,
0.23469987511634827,
-0.5591622591018677,
0.09113141149282455,
0.5592828989028931,
-0.2854420840740204,
-0.2862682640552521,
0.7681925892829895,
0.33395954966545105,
-0.47449395060539246,
0.47329583764076233,
-0.14036591351032257,
-0.20924125611782074,
0.6478039026260376,
0.14113661646842957,
0.9262605309486389,
-0.4078128933906555,
0.15841035544872284,
0.08155226707458496,
0.17314903438091278,
-0.21120023727416992,
0.28338903188705444,
-0.28008031845092773,
-0.47826239466667175,
-0.4624491333961487,
-0.48549026250839233,
-0.4356004297733307,
-0.07161393761634827,
-0.5947393178939819,
-0.10678188502788544,
-0.3675537109375,
-0.7284702658653259,
-0.03331531584262848,
-0.01764163188636303,
-0.4401097595691681,
0.10462450981140137,
0.020189136266708374,
0.7579686045646667,
-0.392592191696167,
0.8767339587211609,
0.6361762285232544,
-0.0352887287735939,
-0.5284771919250488,
0.03885247930884361,
0.030029576271772385,
-0.5348275303840637,
0.6668993830680847,
0.2290385216474533,
-0.28955692052841187,
0.16448453068733215,
-0.18909451365470886,
-0.6280697584152222,
1.1374880075454712,
0.40457749366760254,
-0.7395570278167725,
0.3338671922683716,
0.37899839878082275,
0.31160715222358704,
-0.12461532652378082,
0.5781314969062805,
0.5188114047050476,
0.349865198135376,
-0.16773395240306854,
-1.257839322090149,
-0.023743201047182083,
-0.38053956627845764,
0.13125689327716827,
0.32548829913139343,
-0.6871932148933411,
0.7350134253501892,
-0.12203893065452576,
-0.19111032783985138,
0.20196859538555145,
0.3584383428096771,
0.4049481749534607,
0.8232377171516418,
0.4077797532081604,
0.6499377489089966,
0.6684403419494629,
0.10626878589391708,
1.0888972282409668,
-0.662822425365448,
0.1726120412349701,
0.9890198111534119,
-0.60999596118927,
1.081072211265564,
0.508355438709259,
-0.2331710010766983,
0.2691265940666199,
0.7992167472839355,
0.21623651683330536,
0.4357775151729584,
0.40379753708839417,
-0.5221531987190247,
0.028737930580973625,
-0.3692147135734558,
-0.4947015643119812,
0.4370200037956238,
0.1931232213973999,
-0.14195556938648224,
0.016667421907186508,
0.26391229033470154,
-0.08618056029081345,
-0.3693980872631073,
-0.4025321304798126,
0.4427506923675537,
0.23635923862457275,
-0.4172205328941345,
0.8085312843322754,
0.48864462971687317,
0.7021887302398682,
-0.47357064485549927,
0.33233442902565,
-0.5626556277275085,
0.3455184996128082,
-0.1928122639656067,
-0.16836151480674744,
0.28249064087867737,
0.02245675027370453,
-0.20286932587623596,
-0.16505330801010132,
0.6724752187728882,
0.12635605037212372,
-0.416634738445282,
0.09954764693975449,
0.5507604479789734,
0.061882153153419495,
-0.4287360906600952,
-0.7019829154014587,
0.6350307464599609,
-0.06834133714437485,
-0.30283135175704956,
0.5505083203315735,
0.14505520462989807,
-0.3373282551765442,
1.13446044921875,
0.7064081430435181,
-0.32126909494400024,
0.222585067152977,
-0.09804154932498932,
0.642306387424469,
-0.6883423328399658,
-0.2948008179664612,
-1.1309504508972168,
0.45639920234680176,
-0.011895895935595036,
-0.27974939346313477,
0.8415052890777588,
1.0173760652542114,
0.7443050146102905,
0.0727042555809021,
0.6492301225662231,
-0.08118660002946854,
0.1624942123889923,
-0.44667625427246094,
0.8342916965484619,
-0.8731984496116638,
0.41484227776527405,
0.0610843226313591,
-1.0003283023834229,
-0.21329709887504578,
0.601368248462677,
-0.10799328982830048,
0.08272413164377213,
0.45570334792137146,
0.9059727191925049,
-0.2992476522922516,
-0.15588344633579254,
0.33466237783432007,
-0.12086712568998337,
0.023645130917429924,
0.41919854283332825,
0.8524582386016846,
-0.5875282883644104,
0.5503318309783936,
-0.3514596223831177,
-0.03116595931351185,
-0.31507328152656555,
-0.9712228178977966,
-0.7977427244186401,
-0.4358564019203186,
-0.31546857953071594,
-0.2359262853860855,
0.23730908334255219,
0.7409580945968628,
0.8958505392074585,
-0.5142624974250793,
-0.7895843982696533,
-0.011304676532745361,
0.05917973816394806,
0.0203181691467762,
-0.1500987857580185,
0.20636554062366486,
0.15535706281661987,
-0.4888762831687927,
0.5255354642868042,
0.053491007536649704,
0.10828116536140442,
-0.1555510014295578,
-0.20629511773586273,
0.2668093740940094,
-0.23768481612205505,
0.7372061014175415,
0.5405128002166748,
-0.4430663287639618,
0.34677526354789734,
-0.09408450126647949,
-0.26846063137054443,
-0.1138116791844368,
1.1407943964004517,
-0.7949666976928711,
0.15945710241794586,
0.3435327708721161,
0.7020737528800964,
0.6551916003227234,
-0.09067604690790176,
0.43927785754203796,
-0.6654539704322815,
0.46788957715034485,
0.22096207737922668,
0.12255322188138962,
0.031842730939388275,
0.16733016073703766,
0.6815119981765747,
-0.01408267393708229,
-0.562131941318512,
-1.3724610805511475,
0.192167267203331,
-0.8524609208106995,
-0.09288151562213898,
0.9643587470054626,
-0.08884279429912567,
-0.009314201772212982,
0.2282392829656601,
0.037000514566898346,
0.07630820572376251,
-0.2320041060447693,
0.6498361825942993,
0.36491870880126953,
0.03034515120089054,
-0.43966543674468994,
-1.0601884126663208,
0.33938536047935486,
0.6079449653625488,
-1.0151938199996948,
-0.028375161811709404,
0.2960436940193176,
0.13586744666099548,
-0.04717380926012993,
0.6050404906272888,
0.23682130873203278,
0.2982775866985321,
0.05635824799537659,
0.38709917664527893,
-0.10466420650482178,
-0.05030323565006256,
-0.2768308222293854,
0.13588839769363403,
0.08869942277669907,
-0.33617937564849854
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08680v1
|
Analyzing Large Language Models for Classroom Discussion Assessment
| 2024-06-12T22:43:38 | 2024-06-12T22:43:38 |
Nhat Tran, Benjamin Pierce, Diane Litman, Richard Correnti, Lindsay Clare Matsumura
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatically assessing classroom discussion quality is becoming increasingly
feasible with the help of new NLP advancements such as large language models
(LLMs). In this work, we examine how the assessment performance of 2 LLMs
interacts with 3 factors that may affect performance: task formulation, context
length, and few-shot examples. We also explore the computational efficiency and
predictive consistency of the 2 LLMs. Our results suggest that the 3
aforementioned factors do affect the performance of the tested LLMs and there
is a relation between consistency and performance. We recommend a LLM-based
assessment approach that has a good balance in terms of predictive performance,
computational efficiency, and consistency.
|
[
-0.5122379660606384,
-1.2385787963867188,
0.7176737189292908,
0.38429000973701477,
-0.181989848613739,
0.12676648795604706,
-0.5189157128334045,
-0.7090436220169067,
0.03665902465581894,
0.3322032392024994,
0.008564835414290428,
-0.09220511466264725,
-0.8949578404426575,
0.23082269728183746,
-0.6378032565116882,
0.5846561193466187,
-0.17234905064105988,
0.22849681973457336,
-0.43416985869407654,
-0.08143866062164307,
-0.6913018822669983,
-0.6956141591072083,
-0.9489204287528992,
-0.6732674837112427,
0.5026376843452454,
0.3507133424282074,
1.0391695499420166,
0.5254833102226257,
0.7188615202903748,
0.46190959215164185,
-0.2942626178264618,
-0.24738498032093048,
-0.4558427333831787,
0.23024268448352814,
-0.26445579528808594,
-0.09449192881584167,
-0.5793925523757935,
0.028554636985063553,
1.102236032485962,
0.7568994760513306,
-0.21922287344932556,
0.028280988335609436,
0.3754102289676666,
0.38380545377731323,
-0.3883819878101349,
0.24028046429157257,
-0.7294646501541138,
-0.14305445551872253,
0.0992237851023674,
-0.09764113277196884,
-0.5198304653167725,
-0.2357080727815628,
0.42979419231414795,
-0.14247696101665497,
-0.17875850200653076,
-0.27200785279273987,
0.6364803910255432,
0.021092912182211876,
-0.4606229066848755,
-0.40357425808906555,
-0.7372295260429382,
0.838459312915802,
-0.9545409083366394,
0.23371443152427673,
0.2733888328075409,
0.19636070728302002,
-0.3891483545303345,
-0.7147598266601562,
-0.7110065817832947,
-0.2604343891143799,
-0.06402699649333954,
-0.016016798093914986,
-0.06697680056095123,
0.18720954656600952,
0.28328150510787964,
0.3362995386123657,
-0.4005124568939209,
0.5301744937896729,
-0.3227597177028656,
-0.031759947538375854,
0.7619304656982422,
0.5541061162948608,
0.15195883810520172,
-0.26703816652297974,
-0.1522742509841919,
0.005682461429387331,
-0.5744678378105164,
-0.03925316780805588,
0.13985592126846313,
0.3025505840778351,
0.06429500877857208,
0.6364753842353821,
0.021222388371825218,
1.0277270078659058,
-0.3979763984680176,
-0.3420279324054718,
-0.1635534018278122,
-0.44175803661346436,
-0.40829959511756897,
-0.14210288226604462,
0.825380265712738,
0.5457184314727783,
0.12599031627178192,
0.19919681549072266,
-0.043218404054641724,
0.2438201904296875,
0.18429283797740936,
-0.8356406688690186,
-0.07025904953479767,
0.27510693669319153,
-0.26892441511154175,
-0.2032041996717453,
-0.2025182843208313,
-0.9256430864334106,
-0.3038369417190552,
-0.6769896745681763,
0.6108876466751099,
0.09065640717744827,
-0.08585476130247116,
0.018137602135539055,
0.20754913985729218,
0.25361356139183044,
0.66094970703125,
-0.7472511529922485,
0.6892744302749634,
1.0300192832946777,
0.7799186110496521,
-0.5763257145881653,
-0.2696116268634796,
-0.4428607225418091,
-0.15853919088840485,
-0.6453112363815308,
0.49311497807502747,
-0.7323492169380188,
-0.2565307319164276,
0.31575995683670044,
-0.09632309526205063,
-0.08613603562116623,
-0.5156117081642151,
0.38211092352867126,
-0.6865927577018738,
0.4323625862598419,
-0.26606038212776184,
-1.1280385255813599,
-0.25987330079078674,
0.5259465575218201,
-0.7195219993591309,
1.0680460929870605,
0.09632018953561783,
-0.5935120582580566,
0.21965260803699493,
-0.5423125624656677,
-0.18714365363121033,
0.23982125520706177,
-0.15861304104328156,
-0.16537536680698395,
-0.0615294873714447,
-0.2960856556892395,
0.6692254543304443,
-0.20081783831119537,
0.47173231840133667,
-0.11746872216463089,
-0.6893421411514282,
0.6729373931884766,
-0.3097847104072571,
0.5164278149604797,
-0.03443033620715141,
-0.24469152092933655,
0.26543596386909485,
-0.4756031036376953,
0.3874795436859131,
-0.08259601891040802,
-0.563112199306488,
0.020383555442094803,
0.27335476875305176,
-0.05619799345731735,
0.2736130356788635,
0.22775766253471375,
-0.31221917271614075,
0.18695643544197083,
-0.326198011636734,
0.3728000223636627,
0.707383930683136,
0.2268725484609604,
0.1195201575756073,
-0.363403856754303,
0.6466077566146851,
-0.4319498538970947,
0.05237329751253128,
0.027985576540231705,
-0.7023136019706726,
-1.031302809715271,
0.14661268889904022,
0.5416085124015808,
0.42740732431411743,
-0.3743475079536438,
0.21633175015449524,
-0.2577742338180542,
-0.6718970537185669,
-0.012997857294976711,
0.3197179138660431,
0.38540902733802795,
0.044494107365608215,
0.21087494492530823,
-0.44502827525138855,
-0.49080848693847656,
-0.5967820882797241,
-0.11854874342679977,
-0.37191760540008545,
0.03987707942724228,
0.24916771054267883,
0.5060637593269348,
-0.05359087139368057,
0.6918517351150513,
-0.291122704744339,
-0.09779925644397736,
-0.4954720735549927,
0.09548552334308624,
0.1580885350704193,
0.440862774848938,
0.4627329409122467,
-0.2896687090396881,
-0.7530888319015503,
-0.3110632300376892,
-0.4379919469356537,
-0.09829269349575043,
0.06870264559984207,
-0.007892521098256111,
0.45993947982788086,
0.5985627770423889,
-0.44763946533203125,
0.29141244292259216,
0.9954597353935242,
-0.20921656489372253,
0.4911987781524658,
-0.016957903280854225,
0.09156719595193863,
-0.8292992115020752,
-0.2378603219985962,
0.020368412137031555,
-0.24242480099201202,
-0.6765331625938416,
0.17378364503383636,
-0.16036644577980042,
-0.06359091401100159,
-0.5460733771324158,
0.6400706768035889,
-0.14217087626457214,
-0.3174590766429901,
-0.43122178316116333,
0.6695185303688049,
-0.011330747045576572,
0.2979886829853058,
-0.011749222874641418,
0.7817577123641968,
0.46208301186561584,
-0.6521357297897339,
0.24561439454555511,
0.0010847111698240042,
-0.5263081192970276,
0.26499003171920776,
-0.9105642437934875,
0.3449399769306183,
0.33384642004966736,
0.30207768082618713,
-1.2633037567138672,
-0.23228351771831512,
-0.1446123570203781,
-0.418904572725296,
0.39352521300315857,
0.04002846032381058,
-0.6732831001281738,
-0.1746920943260193,
-0.40557533502578735,
0.2622881829738617,
0.3699665367603302,
-0.35766151547431946,
0.6232945322990417,
0.32368358969688416,
-0.4512287676334381,
-0.480162113904953,
-0.3391496539115906,
0.20746056735515594,
-0.15894962847232819,
-0.6462081074714661,
0.20151637494564056,
-0.18596412241458893,
-0.568312406539917,
-0.2795388102531433,
0.2131820023059845,
-0.15937623381614685,
0.27784863114356995,
0.31093400716781616,
0.5034828186035156,
-0.18337927758693695,
0.31639280915260315,
-0.30020424723625183,
0.25098684430122375,
0.2899301052093506,
0.2690868675708771,
0.7357444763183594,
-0.3668302893638611,
-0.2029377967119217,
-0.45529332756996155,
0.2310173362493515,
0.6498835682868958,
0.17973938584327698,
0.7890640497207642,
0.2564173638820648,
-0.3715437054634094,
-0.057295188307762146,
-0.6573849320411682,
-0.12459880113601685,
-0.4888794422149658,
0.5734690427780151,
-0.14780722558498383,
-1.066431999206543,
0.5333450436592102,
0.09759175032377243,
0.34676939249038696,
0.4404444992542267,
0.8100430965423584,
-0.035845544189214706,
1.1853680610656738,
0.6038558483123779,
-0.0006775865913368762,
0.4160729646682739,
-0.010011770762503147,
0.2554857134819031,
-0.9603650569915771,
-0.14066185057163239,
-0.7015529274940491,
-0.3106735348701477,
-0.623373806476593,
-0.6323392987251282,
0.21672411262989044,
0.21158595383167267,
-0.22415558993816376,
0.2033064365386963,
-0.15036097168922424,
0.6602000594139099,
0.0859404131770134,
-0.4138622581958771,
0.40880876779556274,
-0.12155406922101974,
0.07934879511594772,
-0.2886425852775574,
-0.5898433923721313,
-1.023173451423645,
0.9967767000198364,
0.5760208964347839,
0.6147674918174744,
0.43951112031936646,
0.13939054310321808,
0.0732128694653511,
0.5661071538925171,
-0.9274869561195374,
0.8678908944129944,
-0.03155721724033356,
-0.6562147736549377,
-0.48965486884117126,
-0.32915565371513367,
-1.0000925064086914,
0.6032478213310242,
-0.37969905138015747,
-0.8238694667816162,
-0.4058569371700287,
-0.10451862961053848,
0.03885357081890106,
0.15449263155460358,
-0.5770255327224731,
0.7925087809562683,
-0.15552173554897308,
-0.5289932489395142,
-0.40685975551605225,
-0.22388571500778198,
0.3934028744697571,
-0.3872581720352173,
0.11873461306095123,
-0.16346892714500427,
0.03699847310781479,
1.1489403247833252,
-0.029279757291078568,
0.7160077095031738,
0.16424770653247833,
-0.11289910972118378,
0.48931437730789185,
0.313646525144577,
0.281660795211792,
0.036834392696619034,
-0.300448477268219,
0.2674686014652252,
0.16868311166763306,
-0.29649657011032104,
-0.7845035195350647,
0.8205333948135376,
-0.8083532452583313,
-0.9092264175415039,
-0.41796356439590454,
-0.5195319652557373,
-0.5060836672782898,
-0.18622109293937683,
-0.18607915937900543,
0.43447285890579224,
-0.1370762139558792,
0.4194066524505615,
0.29190850257873535,
-0.21591444313526154,
0.6274153590202332,
0.5512735247612,
-0.6718572974205017,
-0.04657996445894241,
0.5057269334793091,
0.32125917077064514,
0.6597569584846497,
-0.15602824091911316,
0.4235917031764984,
-0.3373695909976959,
-0.5226954221725464,
-0.235567107796669,
0.2041950821876526,
-1.0632628202438354,
-0.2818490266799927,
-0.4853673577308655,
-0.33466318249702454,
-0.30251407623291016,
-0.23929832875728607,
-0.32804927229881287,
-0.44318243861198425,
-0.2794867157936096,
-0.18538357317447662,
0.13377608358860016,
0.9489201903343201,
0.36332181096076965,
0.4765588641166687,
-0.6599523425102234,
-0.2326771467924118,
0.5715509057044983,
0.39877942204475403,
0.2668688893318176,
-0.9869399666786194,
0.04755568876862526,
-0.2290511578321457,
-0.5506858825683594,
-0.6937113404273987,
0.12228161841630936,
0.1801009327173233,
0.4881044626235962,
0.39608919620513916,
-0.29360607266426086,
0.5781580209732056,
-0.3079461455345154,
1.3192371129989624,
0.26571860909461975,
-1.278902530670166,
0.24030107259750366,
-0.05046060308814049,
0.19306224584579468,
0.35533270239830017,
0.3724844753742218,
-0.527008056640625,
-0.6150187253952026,
-0.563433825969696,
-0.4766334891319275,
0.524290919303894,
0.13177360594272614,
0.5625023245811462,
-0.07361668348312378,
0.3659462332725525,
-0.2509270906448364,
0.002525920746847987,
-0.8387753963470459,
-0.05195183306932449,
0.12659987807273865,
0.09211760014295578,
-0.2529025673866272,
-0.8169531226158142,
-0.15690237283706665,
-0.3600366413593292,
0.5571483969688416,
-0.018767064437270164,
0.053870003670454025,
-0.17959165573120117,
0.2681989073753357,
-0.2693140208721161,
0.5516154170036316,
0.8812592029571533,
1.2724838256835938,
-0.048601314425468445,
0.20459625124931335,
0.6015788912773132,
-0.35217994451522827,
0.14749273657798767,
-0.39780712127685547,
0.14539657533168793,
0.07501430809497833,
0.7528966665267944,
0.5045127868652344,
0.2575931251049042,
-0.7368696331977844,
0.5599669814109802,
-0.20211045444011688,
-0.3363788425922394,
-0.3635903596878052,
0.3512241840362549,
0.11582157760858536,
0.13176627457141876,
0.0413505919277668,
-0.44540461897850037,
-0.14819756150245667,
-0.7611308097839355,
0.001917567802593112,
0.3898932933807373,
-0.3515126407146454,
0.02960115298628807,
0.12696637213230133,
0.15201814472675323,
-0.4713275730609894,
0.6484067440032959,
0.03814781457185745,
-0.9769653081893921,
0.7389281988143921,
0.6545659899711609,
0.3779686987400055,
-0.5106937885284424,
-0.007132930681109428,
0.46415388584136963,
0.35367515683174133,
-0.12174735218286514,
0.16582195460796356,
0.3408989906311035,
-0.8100652694702148,
-0.8451837301254272,
-0.5438370108604431,
-0.8409839272499084,
0.28584539890289307,
-0.5258060097694397,
0.29187196493148804,
-0.5521511435508728,
-0.38690507411956787,
0.061064593493938446,
0.6382964849472046,
-0.3661634922027588,
0.22304745018482208,
0.025559231638908386,
0.6934261918067932,
-0.8226342797279358,
0.7601604461669922,
0.59285569190979,
0.09388904273509979,
-1.05203378200531,
-0.3716623783111572,
-0.08816718310117722,
-0.3956197500228882,
0.7869000434875488,
0.057540129870176315,
-0.08766942471265793,
-0.38174548745155334,
-0.41186732053756714,
-1.0300542116165161,
0.7279103398323059,
0.11642846465110779,
-0.6560507416725159,
0.27477777004241943,
0.08282376080751419,
0.9337254762649536,
-0.33307456970214844,
0.3628576993942261,
0.4697800278663635,
0.5473507642745972,
0.24703948199748993,
-1.3073158264160156,
-0.12249805778265,
0.0168722216039896,
0.10964943468570709,
0.026532933115959167,
-0.4596843421459198,
0.8019598722457886,
-0.06862255930900574,
-0.14642803370952606,
0.04664972424507141,
0.6827116012573242,
0.2988388240337372,
0.2116783857345581,
0.38534149527549744,
0.3291618824005127,
0.6278465986251831,
-0.21454377472400665,
1.0666601657867432,
-0.3427838683128357,
0.5131362676620483,
1.2434778213500977,
-0.5755078792572021,
1.3514145612716675,
0.37002092599868774,
-0.4634135365486145,
0.4719984531402588,
0.48498934507369995,
-0.11279907077550888,
-0.14923319220542908,
0.5613104701042175,
-0.1203656941652298,
-0.15425163507461548,
-0.1435014009475708,
-0.33299189805984497,
0.8530071377754211,
0.545677125453949,
-0.3723762035369873,
0.03076278418302536,
-0.1538996696472168,
0.20436479151248932,
0.2026968002319336,
-0.3680815100669861,
0.6653938293457031,
-0.04984530061483383,
-1.0411832332611084,
0.55340576171875,
0.4058605432510376,
0.48907649517059326,
-0.366899698972702,
-0.1848697066307068,
-0.016992056742310524,
0.05910038948059082,
-0.22759288549423218,
-1.019398808479309,
0.38694003224372864,
-0.028071269392967224,
0.11707987636327744,
0.047566212713718414,
0.6583284139633179,
-0.43879789113998413,
-0.33834514021873474,
0.36739581823349,
0.4129541218280792,
0.1937382072210312,
0.3601504862308502,
-0.563896894454956,
0.6776679158210754,
-0.31728866696357727,
-0.261776864528656,
0.5650822520256042,
0.12102580815553665,
0.03896274417638779,
0.56096351146698,
0.4165976047515869,
0.027993250638246536,
0.008861694484949112,
0.13807351887226105,
0.6719591617584229,
-0.3478294014930725,
-0.06027001515030861,
-0.8742966651916504,
0.0555124469101429,
0.042548153549432755,
-0.2365945279598236,
0.8508113622665405,
0.47394272685050964,
0.670232892036438,
0.3554973006248474,
0.17471952736377716,
0.3301849067211151,
0.49791139364242554,
-0.6390775442123413,
0.4752501845359802,
-0.19577960669994354,
0.3150526285171509,
-0.6526128649711609,
-1.1660420894622803,
-0.21653184294700623,
0.7890896797180176,
-0.3663066327571869,
0.26144421100616455,
0.9229515194892883,
0.49088308215141296,
0.3729252219200134,
0.31688740849494934,
0.597218930721283,
0.22935906052589417,
0.5826976299285889,
0.4291703999042511,
1.2081074714660645,
-0.3573821187019348,
0.19250723719596863,
-0.33783721923828125,
-0.09470576792955399,
-0.23467838764190674,
-1.1281274557113647,
-1.0302354097366333,
-0.451185405254364,
-0.7120564579963684,
-0.48018503189086914,
-0.3693968653678894,
0.8040816783905029,
0.533178985118866,
-0.551527202129364,
-0.5635759830474854,
0.16283246874809265,
0.10941967368125916,
0.11462432891130447,
-0.3227791488170624,
0.4017915725708008,
-0.3627574145793915,
-0.8081807494163513,
0.21005314588546753,
0.1326620727777481,
0.022274646908044815,
-0.5813208818435669,
-0.0548616461455822,
-0.11423815041780472,
0.4675484001636505,
1.0386393070220947,
-0.18664215505123138,
-0.9621230363845825,
-0.4676840901374817,
-0.22587916254997253,
-0.3385389447212219,
-0.09665379673242569,
0.7563024163246155,
-0.5665764212608337,
0.4620819687843323,
0.4008118212223053,
0.6532628536224365,
0.3434807062149048,
0.1045243963599205,
0.41382071375846863,
-0.4526088833808899,
-0.0474117286503315,
0.21816056966781616,
0.26979076862335205,
0.32794877886772156,
-0.1569899618625641,
0.49279797077178955,
-0.0868602767586708,
-0.9547967314720154,
-0.8765239119529724,
-0.09944785386323929,
-1.0562433004379272,
-0.2748628854751587,
1.2799738645553589,
-0.26532885432243347,
0.16300567984580994,
-0.1340106874704361,
-0.038478683680295944,
-0.09498805552721024,
-0.07156199961900711,
0.8078727126121521,
1.3308732509613037,
-0.25965824723243713,
-0.15036240220069885,
-0.8101669549942017,
0.4716337025165558,
0.6696711778640747,
-0.7789424657821655,
0.07372138649225235,
0.6136074662208557,
0.22765126824378967,
0.40116772055625916,
0.5680317282676697,
-0.2322206199169159,
0.13490958511829376,
-0.32258009910583496,
-0.3839004337787628,
0.2927917540073395,
-0.4140312373638153,
-0.4645346403121948,
0.28374946117401123,
0.4371081292629242,
0.4091418385505676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08673v1
|
HelpSteer2: Open-source dataset for training top-performing reward models
| 2024-06-12T22:28:08 | 2024-06-12T22:28:08 |
Zhilin Wang, Yi Dong, Olivier Delalleau, Jiaqi Zeng, Gerald Shen, Daniel Egert, Jimmy J. Zhang, Makesh Narsimhan Sreedhar, Oleksii Kuchaiev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
High-quality preference datasets are essential for training reward models
that can effectively guide large language models (LLMs) in generating
high-quality responses aligned with human preferences. As LLMs become stronger
and better aligned, permissively licensed preference datasets, such as Open
Assistant, HH-RLHF, and HelpSteer need to be updated to remain effective for
reward modeling. Methods that distil preference data from proprietary LLMs such
as GPT-4 have restrictions on commercial usage imposed by model providers. To
improve upon both generated responses and attribute labeling quality, we
release HelpSteer2, a permissively licensed preference dataset (CC-BY-4.0).
Using a powerful internal base model trained on HelpSteer2, we are able to
achieve the SOTA score (92.0%) on Reward-Bench's primary dataset, outperforming
currently listed open and proprietary models, as of June 12th, 2024. Notably,
HelpSteer2 consists of only ten thousand response pairs, an order of magnitude
fewer than existing preference datasets (e.g., HH-RLHF), which makes it highly
efficient for training reward models. Our extensive experiments demonstrate
that reward models trained with HelpSteer2 are effective in aligning LLMs. In
particular, we propose SteerLM 2.0, a model alignment approach that can
effectively make use of the rich multi-attribute score predicted by our reward
models. HelpSteer2 is available at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/nvidia/HelpSteer2 and code is available at
https://github.com/NVIDIA/NeMo-Aligner
|
[
-0.10001427680253983,
-0.20012807846069336,
0.19073288142681122,
0.28338614106178284,
-0.022278664633631706,
-0.4056107997894287,
-0.18878643214702606,
-0.35564425587654114,
0.041714366525411606,
0.4508473873138428,
-0.5601187944412231,
-0.03765089437365532,
-0.6329087615013123,
-0.13877101242542267,
0.030371595174074173,
1.4268348217010498,
0.07900708168745041,
0.4936293959617615,
-0.7152829170227051,
-0.36600005626678467,
-0.6363353133201599,
-0.533356785774231,
-0.6949227452278137,
-0.40934765338897705,
0.7989440560340881,
0.722089946269989,
0.6808905601501465,
0.6156905889511108,
0.9170509576797485,
0.17250409722328186,
0.06284027546644211,
0.10542187839746475,
-0.8172290325164795,
0.4633772373199463,
-0.18445701897144318,
-0.23837636411190033,
-0.7822077870368958,
0.02777772955596447,
0.00725675979629159,
-0.03497081249952316,
-0.14010579884052277,
0.16032370924949646,
0.16838857531547546,
0.663733184337616,
-0.6306442618370056,
0.217688649892807,
-0.2124434858560562,
-0.2862204313278198,
-0.3149677813053131,
0.06212593615055084,
-0.24180182814598083,
-0.7238448262214661,
0.053899768739938736,
-0.7914742827415466,
0.019782228395342827,
-0.11223438382148743,
0.8761548399925232,
0.5300818085670471,
-0.2529395520687103,
-0.23986466228961945,
-0.26869484782218933,
0.9744073152542114,
-0.4255002439022064,
0.4204004406929016,
0.6465670466423035,
0.5056993365287781,
-0.04754440486431122,
-0.5698879361152649,
-0.2610075771808624,
-0.15092399716377258,
-0.1548517793416977,
0.010628445073962212,
-0.07646123319864273,
-0.24176658689975739,
-0.0466785728931427,
0.4595803916454315,
-0.6404819488525391,
0.2635062038898468,
-0.1501498520374298,
-0.07054024189710617,
0.8017427325248718,
0.1690346747636795,
0.008444175124168396,
-0.25078657269477844,
-0.5926221609115601,
-0.5246489644050598,
-0.9656328558921814,
0.127656027674675,
0.25493520498275757,
0.2069091796875,
-0.11638981103897095,
0.622904896736145,
-0.08528265357017517,
0.4638879895210266,
0.20959654450416565,
0.07042684406042099,
0.3738771378993988,
-0.3685448169708252,
-0.07322734594345093,
-0.04638242721557617,
0.7130271196365356,
0.7116547226905823,
0.10848518460988998,
-0.21100756525993347,
-0.38614580035209656,
-0.20532870292663574,
0.20317263901233673,
-0.8129597902297974,
-0.2543015480041504,
0.46653610467910767,
-0.33009329438209534,
-0.37489306926727295,
0.023215817287564278,
-0.5121070742607117,
-0.7082354426383972,
-0.5081071257591248,
0.4822272062301636,
-0.25609856843948364,
-0.5262388586997986,
0.04846811294555664,
-0.24486826360225677,
0.49586644768714905,
0.2593623697757721,
-1.1935935020446777,
0.16282835602760315,
0.8696428537368774,
0.778782308101654,
-0.38196998834609985,
-0.19107268750667572,
-0.8952469825744629,
0.01992630586028099,
-0.04835744574666023,
0.8055520057678223,
-0.29650408029556274,
-0.17443527281284332,
-0.050383310765028,
0.20516782999038696,
0.36607736349105835,
-0.7164390087127686,
0.4614960551261902,
-0.7129857540130615,
0.08179239928722382,
-0.6989160776138306,
-0.5368133187294006,
0.3828306794166565,
0.30552223324775696,
-0.8135846853256226,
1.4034628868103027,
0.3842996060848236,
-0.6124931573867798,
0.3471820652484894,
-0.7720223665237427,
-0.11279969662427902,
0.08599590510129929,
-0.13749785721302032,
-0.48339083790779114,
0.08419010788202286,
0.07044091820716858,
0.3378620147705078,
-0.505999743938446,
0.5562772750854492,
-0.23026104271411896,
-0.024819908663630486,
0.28528380393981934,
-0.00023783170036040246,
0.7575176954269409,
0.07797083258628845,
-0.27667316794395447,
0.4236884117126465,
-0.4574377238750458,
0.002211656654253602,
0.2328292727470398,
-0.13274672627449036,
-0.44715532660484314,
-0.29821696877479553,
0.6383293271064758,
0.342951238155365,
0.47599565982818604,
-0.6030228137969971,
0.3836347758769989,
-0.11083982139825821,
0.17640602588653564,
1.1844888925552368,
-0.4545413553714752,
0.31118956208229065,
-0.28538501262664795,
0.4921424984931946,
-0.2174602448940277,
0.3075152635574341,
0.340251088142395,
-0.3094328045845032,
-0.6988564133644104,
-0.0919266790151596,
0.36381861567497253,
0.29241615533828735,
-0.49998587369918823,
0.5142659544944763,
-0.1628168225288391,
-0.5765876173973083,
-0.643071174621582,
0.008312500081956387,
0.6166874766349792,
0.34323418140411377,
0.6554358005523682,
-0.1595005840063095,
-0.564911961555481,
-0.9913119673728943,
-0.0779944658279419,
0.050699278712272644,
-0.1523439735174179,
0.23165056109428406,
0.39797860383987427,
0.26361334323883057,
1.1707687377929688,
-0.45844554901123047,
-0.5723968148231506,
-0.30801916122436523,
-0.04646492376923561,
0.12135221064090729,
0.7109827399253845,
0.5743687748908997,
-0.76923006772995,
-0.36097607016563416,
-0.19995228946208954,
-0.741787314414978,
0.08443008363246918,
0.2856801748275757,
-0.33529043197631836,
-0.033402230590581894,
0.11397022008895874,
-0.32434555888175964,
-0.05565023422241211,
0.6767424941062927,
-0.44966840744018555,
0.3909994959831238,
-0.08491028100252151,
0.0012385674053803086,
-1.1740596294403076,
0.22267545759677887,
0.18824037909507751,
-0.1319412738084793,
-0.47077062726020813,
-0.047816865146160126,
0.11675292998552322,
0.21591182053089142,
-0.4143599569797516,
0.7926222085952759,
-0.148067906498909,
-0.12037375569343567,
-0.3478861451148987,
-0.2479577511548996,
-0.19829507172107697,
0.22480033338069916,
0.389474481344223,
1.0074186325073242,
0.33340638875961304,
-0.35508814454078674,
0.5709437131881714,
0.7268606424331665,
-0.276298463344574,
0.8927799463272095,
-0.9940500259399414,
0.41968899965286255,
-0.06731391698122025,
0.025852881371974945,
-0.8695307374000549,
-0.6396581530570984,
0.15020224452018738,
-0.33327677845954895,
0.3219245374202728,
-0.06883751600980759,
-0.24117833375930786,
0.048982687294483185,
-0.45302054286003113,
0.33139920234680176,
0.3106350004673004,
-0.8403873443603516,
0.20133164525032043,
0.5398479700088501,
-0.33097633719444275,
-0.8181908130645752,
-0.6845659613609314,
-0.1905006319284439,
-0.0402950681746006,
-0.39548948407173157,
0.6023730635643005,
-0.20293541252613068,
0.004006469156593084,
0.10000500828027725,
-0.06067601963877678,
0.004737841431051493,
-0.11361510306596756,
0.29313963651657104,
0.3843958377838135,
-0.029701223596930504,
0.2649881839752197,
-0.18891441822052002,
-0.6647055745124817,
-0.1017676442861557,
-0.17552830278873444,
0.42840951681137085,
-0.1313297599554062,
-0.15160414576530457,
-0.25494250655174255,
0.15274839103221893,
0.4247643053531647,
-0.41209954023361206,
0.7430524230003357,
0.5409793853759766,
-0.19100795686244965,
0.20920564234256744,
-0.5537520051002502,
-0.4717649519443512,
-0.4588543176651001,
0.5454756617546082,
-0.249193474650383,
-0.8735867738723755,
-0.11738479137420654,
0.45865267515182495,
0.10421362519264221,
0.27293384075164795,
0.5659624934196472,
-0.1303824484348297,
0.8995718359947205,
0.6584189534187317,
-0.3495549261569977,
0.5019771456718445,
-0.2935386002063751,
-0.04785512760281563,
-0.8447446823120117,
-0.7396369576454163,
-0.5130811333656311,
-0.4538116157054901,
-0.39299342036247253,
-0.19391727447509766,
0.3590429425239563,
-0.07962039858102798,
-0.3671288788318634,
0.48530226945877075,
-0.5733368992805481,
0.6471472978591919,
0.8104186654090881,
0.1757926642894745,
0.061020463705062866,
0.1140918880701065,
0.3092680275440216,
-0.2961686849594116,
-0.4382326602935791,
-0.43764984607696533,
1.2107043266296387,
0.34348979592323303,
0.956754744052887,
0.27194565534591675,
0.4177631735801697,
0.37066784501075745,
0.3356959819793701,
-0.8168483972549438,
0.17832019925117493,
-0.2714870274066925,
-0.5337567925453186,
-0.30684399604797363,
-0.14270834624767303,
-0.6074413657188416,
-0.2923624515533447,
-0.040145162492990494,
-0.47246673703193665,
0.40509212017059326,
0.4219222068786621,
-0.24034333229064941,
0.06052394583821297,
-0.4059511721134186,
1.0808006525039673,
-0.585605800151825,
-0.9023787379264832,
0.04410665109753609,
-0.7323223948478699,
0.07066710293292999,
0.1854449212551117,
-0.2772020399570465,
-0.1795012205839157,
0.15952007472515106,
0.9420251250267029,
-0.6294756531715393,
0.47724518179893494,
-0.5354387164115906,
-0.024180937558412552,
-0.14357081055641174,
-0.14615152776241302,
0.6146158576011658,
-0.025053206831216812,
-0.36728617548942566,
0.08996114879846573,
-0.08957717567682266,
-0.4985438883304596,
-0.5106822848320007,
0.8831701278686523,
-1.0722647905349731,
-0.30265116691589355,
-0.5541276335716248,
-0.6196368336677551,
-0.35965827107429504,
-0.0394388809800148,
0.3558402955532074,
0.35159677267074585,
-0.017022280022501945,
0.4782234728336334,
0.586566150188446,
0.055795542895793915,
0.059044249355793,
0.21580258011817932,
0.15907250344753265,
-0.6362115740776062,
0.973963737487793,
-0.04603363201022148,
0.11211894452571869,
0.2560608983039856,
0.09188984334468842,
-0.9121866226196289,
-0.32804208993911743,
-0.44666653871536255,
0.21817909181118011,
-0.500188946723938,
-0.5732924342155457,
-0.39435189962387085,
-0.10987060517072678,
-0.39498278498649597,
-0.06902433931827545,
-0.5434183478355408,
-0.5811490416526794,
-0.13663947582244873,
-0.3650253117084503,
0.8403791189193726,
1.0251641273498535,
-0.3200127184391022,
0.38230204582214355,
-0.45428726077079773,
0.15086479485034943,
0.3820910155773163,
0.6117983460426331,
-0.21726536750793457,
-0.4266107976436615,
-0.3354916274547577,
-0.08628368377685547,
-0.2957000434398651,
-0.7080405354499817,
0.14055883884429932,
-0.15044847130775452,
0.5706436634063721,
0.27958646416664124,
0.06862301379442215,
0.4365558922290802,
0.0753382071852684,
0.732029378414154,
0.3287491798400879,
-0.6581407785415649,
0.5008014440536499,
-0.2101437747478485,
-0.07888185977935791,
0.8442217111587524,
0.6184254884719849,
-0.5592554807662964,
0.08868175745010376,
-0.32252874970436096,
-0.806724488735199,
1.1890969276428223,
0.09837587177753448,
-0.08142644166946411,
0.17839501798152924,
0.26215365529060364,
0.35420531034469604,
0.19073453545570374,
-0.8050284385681152,
-0.23834718763828278,
-0.5912285447120667,
-0.5500355362892151,
-0.14096933603286743,
-0.5473896265029907,
-0.08764170855283737,
-0.014044977724552155,
1.034374713897705,
-0.054630108177661896,
0.21617645025253296,
-0.1487971991300583,
-0.11306627839803696,
-0.06338378041982651,
0.27455028891563416,
0.2521500587463379,
0.46159520745277405,
-0.49009209871292114,
0.023772500455379486,
-0.25802862644195557,
-0.3145316541194916,
0.4569178521633148,
0.1413244605064392,
-0.10613993555307388,
-0.43619316816329956,
-0.010109541937708855,
0.8297572731971741,
-0.043667204678058624,
-0.44337013363838196,
0.7895377278327942,
-0.0019106852123513818,
-0.17438963055610657,
-0.1797168254852295,
0.16294057667255402,
0.22091834247112274,
0.227521151304245,
0.22887001931667328,
-0.0350656695663929,
-0.04513135924935341,
-0.11420837044715881,
0.1522664725780487,
0.3682563900947571,
-0.8166919350624084,
-0.23664526641368866,
0.6954063773155212,
0.16244728863239288,
-0.20976516604423523,
0.9071915745735168,
-0.0709294006228447,
-0.15054692327976227,
0.5535832643508911,
0.6700002551078796,
0.6507907509803772,
-0.45562803745269775,
0.2574412226676941,
0.6295109987258911,
-0.011725213378667831,
-0.2691422402858734,
0.37449315190315247,
0.04533800110220909,
-0.687035858631134,
-0.20709125697612762,
-0.5322615504264832,
-0.44591766595840454,
0.5060914754867554,
-0.950252115726471,
0.35234931111335754,
-0.20677997171878815,
-0.2756005823612213,
-0.15400315821170807,
-0.2733384370803833,
-0.6887103319168091,
0.11076800525188446,
-0.13010555505752563,
0.8474791049957275,
-0.8924950957298279,
0.8337404727935791,
0.7914145588874817,
-0.8073671460151672,
-0.8411376476287842,
-0.3279987871646881,
0.21112853288650513,
-0.5758612155914307,
0.8994083404541016,
0.16854456067085266,
-0.09356864541769028,
0.03620147332549095,
-0.5086320638656616,
-0.8762739896774292,
1.1632630825042725,
0.42545875906944275,
-0.4601190388202667,
-0.132781520485878,
0.13824275135993958,
0.21956737339496613,
-0.15790033340454102,
0.6305758357048035,
0.6064975261688232,
0.6813814043998718,
0.09576337784528732,
-0.7753583788871765,
0.013249354436993599,
-0.3509960174560547,
0.011638684198260307,
0.04354291781783104,
-0.8312782645225525,
0.6590335965156555,
-0.16229590773582458,
0.33810874819755554,
0.32412010431289673,
0.4541418254375458,
0.6267191171646118,
0.1531759351491928,
0.3594271242618561,
0.37927788496017456,
0.6638663411140442,
-0.39107009768486023,
0.8596879243850708,
-0.02586769498884678,
0.46541929244995117,
1.1917057037353516,
-0.2970050573348999,
0.8732184171676636,
0.7063953876495361,
-0.12310613691806793,
0.3748280107975006,
0.7290212512016296,
-0.16697677969932556,
0.9052613973617554,
-0.028828227892518044,
0.03223923593759537,
-0.3632681369781494,
-0.5152952671051025,
-0.6397400498390198,
0.4510314166545868,
0.05733757093548775,
-0.21636320650577545,
-0.008932514116168022,
0.006597197614610195,
-0.11788395792245865,
-0.18421296775341034,
-0.04731447622179985,
0.8172500729560852,
-0.2970398962497711,
-0.6467859745025635,
0.36838725209236145,
-0.05943695083260536,
0.7196685075759888,
-0.7880987524986267,
-0.10360205918550491,
-0.5424790382385254,
0.3442905843257904,
-0.3313145339488983,
-0.7493913769721985,
0.02484222687780857,
0.20835305750370026,
-0.29574844241142273,
-0.32807841897010803,
0.5448804497718811,
-0.47009432315826416,
-0.23254874348640442,
0.2874929904937744,
0.3272586464881897,
0.08003782480955124,
0.055978111922740936,
-0.685513436794281,
-0.006611162330955267,
-0.26788225769996643,
-0.29570576548576355,
0.4974786639213562,
-0.11498135328292847,
-0.07776381075382233,
0.43046844005584717,
0.6590662002563477,
-0.02003319561481476,
-0.40960878133773804,
-0.006591406185179949,
0.9145511984825134,
-0.4740738868713379,
-0.4537414312362671,
-0.6006730794906616,
0.6325604319572449,
-0.3003945052623749,
-0.4599533975124359,
0.5451145172119141,
0.9368159770965576,
0.8662796020507812,
-0.25012674927711487,
0.7771267294883728,
-0.22586415708065033,
0.39568910002708435,
-0.5416589379310608,
0.6933767199516296,
-0.8021767139434814,
-0.030722394585609436,
-0.0047254618257284164,
-0.756536602973938,
-0.17219002544879913,
0.7235658168792725,
-0.45378634333610535,
0.1766253262758255,
0.3790166676044464,
1.1267719268798828,
-0.33209383487701416,
-0.06017129495739937,
0.012315421365201473,
-0.025902802124619484,
0.2808865010738373,
0.5744871497154236,
0.9508482217788696,
-0.37519267201423645,
0.5293562412261963,
-0.18729399144649506,
-0.23971235752105713,
-0.5133004784584045,
-0.8766645193099976,
-0.5465578436851501,
-0.5560224056243896,
-0.24075397849082947,
-0.42262202501296997,
0.422252893447876,
1.346498966217041,
0.9729614853858948,
-1.1776074171066284,
-0.39573654532432556,
-0.08422387391328812,
-0.08081977814435959,
-0.4328089654445648,
-0.23093120753765106,
0.6607620716094971,
-0.287790983915329,
-0.643968403339386,
0.39910072088241577,
0.09321334213018417,
-0.09460855275392532,
-0.23085694015026093,
-0.6031427979469299,
0.05641976371407509,
-0.4716845452785492,
0.3533461093902588,
0.12004160135984421,
-0.5792094469070435,
-0.1729978322982788,
0.3557453453540802,
-0.298206627368927,
0.29891282320022583,
0.857376217842102,
-0.5041903853416443,
0.3928564190864563,
0.400051087141037,
0.7172641754150391,
0.463967889547348,
0.05798414722084999,
0.6197606325149536,
-0.6717865467071533,
-0.002946377731859684,
0.04433264583349228,
0.22233615815639496,
0.5947494506835938,
-0.3439413905143738,
0.6523756980895996,
-0.04378414899110794,
-0.6413875818252563,
-0.5640286207199097,
0.10129518061876297,
-0.8719915747642517,
0.05374929681420326,
1.177268624305725,
-0.14574137330055237,
-0.052168991416692734,
-0.010583164170384407,
-0.4136800467967987,
0.1519189327955246,
-0.6259222626686096,
0.5877344608306885,
0.5320532917976379,
-0.16933764517307281,
-0.11618883162736893,
-0.31175974011421204,
0.9266963005065918,
0.559994637966156,
-0.981654167175293,
0.35338643193244934,
0.6518280506134033,
0.42525529861450195,
-0.16436977684497833,
0.7366040945053101,
-0.20129789412021637,
0.5199906826019287,
-0.332202672958374,
0.22204723954200745,
-0.6357215642929077,
-0.4160798192024231,
-0.5004678964614868,
0.19795796275138855,
0.47627124190330505,
-0.30850058794021606
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09459v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09459v1
|
Ad Auctions for LLMs via Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-06-12T22:05:51 | 2024-06-12T22:05:51 |
MohammadTaghi Hajiaghayi, Sébastien Lahaie, Keivan Rezaei, Suho Shin
|
cs.GT
|
cs.GT, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In the field of computational advertising, the integration of ads into the
outputs of large language models (LLMs) presents an opportunity to support
these services without compromising content integrity. This paper introduces
novel auction mechanisms for ad allocation and pricing within the textual
outputs of LLMs, leveraging retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). We propose a
segment auction where an ad is probabilistically retrieved for each discourse
segment (paragraph, section, or entire output) according to its bid and
relevance, following the RAG framework, and priced according to competing bids.
We show that our auction maximizes logarithmic social welfare, a new notion of
welfare that balances allocation efficiency and fairness, and we characterize
the associated incentive-compatible pricing rule. These results are extended to
multi-ad allocation per segment. An empirical evaluation validates the
feasibility and effectiveness of our approach over several ad auction
scenarios, and exhibits inherent tradeoffs in metrics as we allow the LLM more
flexibility to allocate ads.
|
[
-0.19100667536258698,
-0.4998934864997864,
0.6285887360572815,
0.19937345385551453,
-0.2898201048374176,
0.20386317372322083,
-0.18075405061244965,
-0.5827719569206238,
0.7168567776679993,
0.638608992099762,
-0.15049190819263458,
-0.14008435606956482,
-0.29179859161376953,
-0.24834316968917847,
-0.24609771370887756,
0.8565244078636169,
0.270908385515213,
-0.07223312556743622,
-0.4914211630821228,
-0.1754157692193985,
-0.11956673860549927,
-0.6265084147453308,
-0.8073058724403381,
-0.01101983617991209,
0.5948529243469238,
0.29094579815864563,
0.7739232778549194,
0.9367308020591736,
0.3512268662452698,
0.40077659487724304,
0.030531181022524834,
0.4033190906047821,
-0.6957071423530579,
0.2712034583091736,
-0.3128338158130646,
-0.19107620418071747,
-0.7977593541145325,
0.22134482860565186,
0.8292801976203918,
0.5535021424293518,
-0.38487303256988525,
0.12293339520692825,
0.04299107939004898,
0.6261448860168457,
-1.0591657161712646,
-0.25649169087409973,
-1.0669573545455933,
-0.48690366744995117,
-0.32088586688041687,
-0.4647100567817688,
-0.6916321516036987,
-0.7753563523292542,
0.2388143688440323,
-0.737565815448761,
-0.021108103916049004,
0.0013290147762745619,
1.0475953817367554,
0.02229335531592369,
-0.4732494652271271,
-0.6902922987937927,
-0.33535200357437134,
0.8532772660255432,
-0.2840462327003479,
0.03366042673587799,
0.16941684484481812,
0.19671322405338287,
-0.006254392676055431,
-0.8748727440834045,
-0.11745873838663101,
0.12673890590667725,
-0.057577911764383316,
0.061070218682289124,
-0.3062894344329834,
0.12602843344211578,
-0.2262536585330963,
0.6209060549736023,
-0.2353411167860031,
-0.11021347343921661,
-0.18489427864551544,
-0.10122822225093842,
0.8550377488136292,
0.28863996267318726,
0.4032476544380188,
-0.23444992303848267,
-0.840466320514679,
0.15240927040576935,
-0.7418099641799927,
-0.05965880677103996,
0.8331812024116516,
0.39500144124031067,
0.07383868098258972,
0.7462745308876038,
0.09902365505695343,
0.7783618569374084,
-0.02459557168185711,
-0.1512753665447235,
-0.04063708707690239,
-0.3644028306007385,
0.047795381397008896,
0.26696404814720154,
0.6319506168365479,
0.3954924941062927,
0.016121957451105118,
0.2148783802986145,
-0.47506028413772583,
0.03436201438307762,
0.2904053330421448,
-0.46007031202316284,
0.15486353635787964,
-0.11280322819948196,
-0.3133080005645752,
-0.27203163504600525,
-0.37626078724861145,
-0.53669673204422,
-0.39957380294799805,
-0.140877366065979,
0.6485548615455627,
-0.10032615810632706,
-0.18409878015518188,
0.3687814772129059,
-0.21949370205402374,
0.20063476264476776,
0.041522055864334106,
-0.9048230648040771,
0.3723481297492981,
0.8886021375656128,
0.49821585416793823,
-0.15709339082241058,
0.1625460982322693,
-0.5987057089805603,
0.4224206805229187,
-0.39029332995414734,
1.1929785013198853,
-0.5703099966049194,
-0.31471413373947144,
0.18821679055690765,
-0.03730034828186035,
-0.30972781777381897,
-0.6004988551139832,
0.49227821826934814,
-1.126486897468567,
0.25614601373672485,
0.05374154448509216,
-0.6749750375747681,
-0.06509649753570557,
0.040858570486307144,
-0.8506321907043457,
0.6607792377471924,
0.13469186425209045,
-0.4699248671531677,
0.1647501140832901,
-0.5028101205825806,
-0.5995712876319885,
0.311713844537735,
0.12216217815876007,
-0.2743297517299652,
0.3208349049091339,
-0.10280922055244446,
0.09735231846570969,
-0.3396308124065399,
0.21708105504512787,
-0.28770479559898376,
-0.32557928562164307,
0.49207502603530884,
-0.6761935949325562,
0.64288729429245,
0.43852898478507996,
0.06372100859880447,
-0.09921987354755402,
-0.4108116328716278,
-0.18393205106258392,
0.12038767337799072,
-0.49190422892570496,
-0.7269018292427063,
0.11469008773565292,
-0.09258535504341125,
-0.1945047527551651,
0.6544381976127625,
-0.3755459785461426,
0.35824474692344666,
-0.6279929280281067,
-0.07333724200725555,
1.0197272300720215,
-0.06095461919903755,
0.738724410533905,
-0.3660646677017212,
0.6686878204345703,
-0.32100534439086914,
0.15558581054210663,
0.017185544595122337,
-0.30956050753593445,
-0.40116554498672485,
-0.674647867679596,
0.36911141872406006,
0.1118452325463295,
-0.6079391837120056,
-0.1851380467414856,
-0.17858439683914185,
-0.022285770624876022,
-0.8331730961799622,
-0.28765594959259033,
0.22540004551410675,
0.13411809504032135,
-0.18814048171043396,
-0.18420620262622833,
-0.3782213032245636,
-0.9588067531585693,
-0.24278701841831207,
0.038804877549409866,
0.009611014276742935,
0.684025764465332,
-0.2273261845111847,
0.11903494596481323,
0.6419286727905273,
-0.7478647232055664,
-0.43262341618537903,
-0.09702349454164505,
0.09223409742116928,
0.20309504866600037,
0.08487993478775024,
0.5248192548751831,
-0.8937476873397827,
-0.5170155763626099,
-0.14638842642307281,
-0.12358107417821884,
-0.1993592232465744,
-0.009495626203715801,
-0.33587536215782166,
0.6456606388092041,
-0.10679562389850616,
-0.576192319393158,
0.45151668787002563,
0.7609403133392334,
-0.24665826559066772,
0.4632565379142761,
-0.30602869391441345,
0.2318963259458542,
-1.103463053703308,
-0.1557357758283615,
-0.12035117298364639,
-0.41079896688461304,
-0.12668748199939728,
-0.006845269352197647,
-0.3960150480270386,
-0.08666981756687164,
-0.6812441945075989,
0.5218819975852966,
-0.5054017305374146,
-0.4682002067565918,
-0.7072558999061584,
0.7555238008499146,
0.371400386095047,
0.23832003772258759,
-0.06606273353099823,
1.2060922384262085,
0.1358276903629303,
-0.667180061340332,
0.2840561866760254,
-0.05947215110063553,
-0.6318178772926331,
0.7340967059135437,
-0.6451953053474426,
-0.07674213498830795,
-0.26066121459007263,
0.29802432656288147,
-1.1351550817489624,
-0.16270886361598969,
0.0806470513343811,
-0.4138331413269043,
0.23901797831058502,
-0.10798564553260803,
-0.19880421459674835,
0.2765330970287323,
-0.6146875023841858,
0.4311627149581909,
0.22805732488632202,
-0.538700520992279,
0.5312356352806091,
1.131607174873352,
-0.2668710947036743,
-0.8351165056228638,
0.02479623258113861,
0.008155914023518562,
-0.3277849853038788,
-0.6075415015220642,
0.4699555039405823,
0.1602838784456253,
-0.11509665101766586,
0.6386487483978271,
0.20941708981990814,
0.29746362566947937,
0.16365650296211243,
-0.2292715609073639,
0.42690733075141907,
-0.4182373583316803,
-0.04552633687853813,
0.20086698234081268,
-0.3317103981971741,
-0.227860227227211,
-0.34819865226745605,
0.5228837728500366,
0.10950062423944473,
-0.42035818099975586,
0.11466266214847565,
0.38124704360961914,
0.42995917797088623,
-0.1160542443394661,
0.5581768155097961,
0.18364740908145905,
-0.4053557217121124,
-0.0001847682724473998,
-0.4724949598312378,
0.42318183183670044,
-0.551154613494873,
0.30339744687080383,
-0.29683247208595276,
-0.8976710438728333,
0.3263711929321289,
-0.10904165357351303,
0.25681793689727783,
0.501454770565033,
0.6983741521835327,
-0.032426513731479645,
1.5376259088516235,
0.45847126841545105,
0.18537184596061707,
0.4991905093193054,
-0.31195610761642456,
0.28289279341697693,
-1.0828208923339844,
0.014251885004341602,
-0.5192986130714417,
-0.3797035217285156,
-0.7367687821388245,
-0.5903931260108948,
0.6120880842208862,
-0.0068838465958833694,
-0.193690687417984,
0.036413270980119705,
-0.5898504853248596,
0.5754103064537048,
0.7170130610466003,
-0.09966449439525604,
0.3761492967605591,
0.30594107508659363,
0.05752075836062431,
0.041167717427015305,
-0.6197375655174255,
-0.6554986834526062,
0.7909098267555237,
0.10825375467538834,
0.9230854511260986,
0.3683135509490967,
0.4083159565925598,
0.42853420972824097,
0.8005881905555725,
-0.9368546605110168,
0.6089810729026794,
-0.600730299949646,
-0.8301423788070679,
-0.32591286301612854,
-0.20897002518177032,
-1.2290714979171753,
0.5067473649978638,
0.017205363139510155,
-0.8701145052909851,
0.4551849365234375,
0.05631608888506889,
-0.142928346991539,
0.28600046038627625,
-0.4506174325942993,
0.6400129199028015,
-0.2384794056415558,
-0.5193667411804199,
-0.6186541318893433,
-0.21525907516479492,
0.28996628522872925,
-0.08546846359968185,
0.3637130856513977,
-0.3823222815990448,
-0.3691672682762146,
0.6308856010437012,
-0.04907562956213951,
0.33882808685302734,
-0.031838200986385345,
-0.22069686651229858,
0.5285876989364624,
0.03313172981142998,
0.4653916358947754,
-0.09631060063838959,
-0.34590908885002136,
-0.5688435435295105,
-0.043238550424575806,
-0.464580774307251,
-0.4491232633590698,
0.8567705750465393,
-0.5277300477027893,
-0.8538347482681274,
-0.45544156432151794,
-0.6969028115272522,
0.028705621138215065,
0.05700915679335594,
-0.0755678042769432,
0.663345992565155,
-0.32837173342704773,
0.263573557138443,
0.4134135842323303,
-0.4208132326602936,
0.2013828307390213,
0.4225925803184509,
-0.06675955653190613,
-0.782116711139679,
1.4089196920394897,
-0.16959248483181,
0.5634518265724182,
0.3200039863586426,
0.3058137893676758,
-0.9108852744102478,
-0.12907609343528748,
-0.3491255044937134,
0.32372161746025085,
-0.7652256488800049,
-0.42465609312057495,
-0.5975276827812195,
0.011825489811599255,
-0.3898337483406067,
-0.47503119707107544,
-0.45279255509376526,
-0.6942902207374573,
-0.24785824120044708,
0.026255834847688675,
0.2616013288497925,
0.6953433752059937,
-0.5069591403007507,
0.30277928709983826,
-0.5603176951408386,
0.33444780111312866,
0.3494027256965637,
0.48517918586730957,
0.25015607476234436,
-0.36481282114982605,
-0.42462673783302307,
0.2968052923679352,
-0.5811846256256104,
-0.5302665829658508,
0.2473529726266861,
0.06278260052204132,
0.5131121277809143,
0.445108562707901,
0.24303768575191498,
0.6325294971466064,
-0.620378851890564,
0.8325610160827637,
0.25955989956855774,
-0.751076340675354,
0.01647305302321911,
-0.4008479714393616,
-0.3409544825553894,
0.38934704661369324,
0.40268975496292114,
-0.3534284830093384,
-0.3677632212638855,
-0.4898364841938019,
-1.343442678451538,
0.7845107913017273,
-0.3105655610561371,
0.49252429604530334,
-0.38432541489601135,
0.013804811984300613,
-0.19731096923351288,
0.14262379705905914,
-0.3826686441898346,
-0.24978886544704437,
0.29476097226142883,
-0.34785646200180054,
0.2086859941482544,
-0.6914363503456116,
-0.24095280468463898,
0.10241235792636871,
0.9446709156036377,
0.01806093007326126,
0.02855234593153,
-0.04060595482587814,
-0.17269128561019897,
0.01084545161575079,
0.2681899964809418,
0.43394148349761963,
0.6220626831054688,
-0.1360509842634201,
0.07657928019762039,
-0.331857830286026,
-0.19824407994747162,
0.5342159271240234,
0.14603407680988312,
-0.15871946513652802,
-0.06055856868624687,
-0.13439570367336273,
0.8009578585624695,
0.35436752438545227,
-0.760302722454071,
0.5423516035079956,
-0.055237263441085815,
-0.056329768151044846,
-0.2865296006202698,
-0.27080053091049194,
0.3617454171180725,
0.2645476460456848,
0.4219156503677368,
-0.5194544792175293,
0.5010594725608826,
-0.3137775957584381,
0.34252190589904785,
0.9237953424453735,
-0.24834860861301422,
-0.053996674716472626,
0.9829473495483398,
0.2131097912788391,
-0.5704300999641418,
0.34213730692863464,
-0.17833110690116882,
-0.4559233784675598,
0.482769250869751,
0.7599949836730957,
1.0366164445877075,
-0.15997901558876038,
0.4756258428096771,
-0.2080443799495697,
0.05841643735766411,
0.13483165204524994,
0.2342095524072647,
0.1998053640127182,
-0.6914463043212891,
-0.6770356297492981,
-0.8264846801757812,
-0.5954011082649231,
-0.1571156084537506,
-0.4823620617389679,
0.32814884185791016,
0.19765236973762512,
-0.3634450435638428,
0.3120705485343933,
0.028550704941153526,
-0.2704724073410034,
-0.21224386990070343,
0.342802494764328,
0.4039497971534729,
-0.40059420466423035,
0.43908026814460754,
0.9579435586929321,
-0.09565930813550949,
-0.5164288878440857,
-0.2397688329219818,
-0.17124377191066742,
-0.9312025904655457,
0.4862213134765625,
-0.21501442790031433,
-0.5846204161643982,
0.15492920577526093,
-0.4952559769153595,
-1.0895658731460571,
0.6476393938064575,
0.5117282867431641,
0.1293431669473648,
-0.0018378240056335926,
0.12480387091636658,
0.3263719081878662,
-0.6567110419273376,
0.01964002288877964,
0.22598759829998016,
0.2369242012500763,
0.24569077789783478,
-0.43673384189605713,
0.026103001087903976,
0.21555589139461517,
0.17839130759239197,
0.3456836938858032,
-0.5509211421012878,
0.5099853873252869,
-0.3284236192703247,
-0.5869315266609192,
0.40156814455986023,
0.4984244704246521,
0.6360605359077454,
0.62577223777771,
0.7306391596794128,
0.35555943846702576,
0.413522869348526,
0.2237170785665512,
1.0776644945144653,
-0.453561395406723,
0.432731032371521,
0.7150883078575134,
-0.5529472231864929,
0.6624954342842102,
0.32920241355895996,
-0.24167969822883606,
0.5229202508926392,
0.5660828948020935,
0.5573700666427612,
0.5781527161598206,
0.3840802311897278,
-0.714461088180542,
-0.13523650169372559,
-1.0351043939590454,
-0.05055069550871849,
0.1723812371492386,
0.5504565238952637,
-0.09047502279281616,
-0.25069665908813477,
-0.2897483706474304,
-0.13162396848201752,
0.34065893292427063,
-0.14929775893688202,
0.9158825278282166,
0.20548821985721588,
-0.7360652089118958,
0.48626887798309326,
-0.02008257433772087,
0.4983673691749573,
-0.4758914113044739,
-0.11899126321077347,
-0.14224515855312347,
0.2699875235557556,
0.07936025410890579,
-0.6689808964729309,
0.3056581914424896,
-0.26060742139816284,
-0.06563129276037216,
-0.37057846784591675,
0.798904299736023,
-0.6949853897094727,
-0.462745726108551,
0.19886744022369385,
0.15608525276184082,
0.15228381752967834,
0.36688944697380066,
-0.44561877846717834,
0.1851256936788559,
-0.2369135618209839,
-0.5204019546508789,
0.5633822083473206,
0.5176757574081421,
0.004886207170784473,
0.426505982875824,
0.660271406173706,
0.38131627440452576,
-0.19347414374351501,
-0.007765664253383875,
0.8621945381164551,
-0.3643622100353241,
-0.4832931458950043,
-0.6030992865562439,
0.5712334513664246,
-0.27060845494270325,
0.2539132833480835,
0.5239754915237427,
0.79488205909729,
0.6679791808128357,
0.24465499818325043,
0.5459805130958557,
0.3048902451992035,
0.4759505093097687,
-0.24919745326042175,
0.5258538722991943,
-1.0477540493011475,
0.46519798040390015,
-0.3923768699169159,
-0.7481042742729187,
0.14541974663734436,
0.3693592846393585,
-0.22237528860569,
-0.44632717967033386,
0.29100045561790466,
0.6984943747520447,
-0.10474243015050888,
-0.10710292309522629,
0.0837976336479187,
-0.2075009047985077,
0.26248908042907715,
0.4758519232273102,
1.1372777223587036,
-0.3389468193054199,
0.6815544962882996,
-0.034207019954919815,
-0.3021675646305084,
-0.13229277729988098,
-0.8518332242965698,
-0.18460924923419952,
-0.4992489814758301,
-0.2495296448469162,
-0.6297892928123474,
0.09730271250009537,
0.8086921572685242,
0.3168907165527344,
-0.314313679933548,
-0.7798986434936523,
0.8471203446388245,
0.8971120715141296,
-0.2417430877685547,
-0.33624762296676636,
0.639428973197937,
-0.42331430315971375,
-1.0417662858963013,
0.2196037471294403,
0.5811167359352112,
-0.21666929125785828,
-0.2074679285287857,
0.19429734349250793,
-0.536948025226593,
0.4856604337692261,
0.8233722448348999,
-0.004650532267987728,
-0.4013259708881378,
-0.09464286267757416,
0.20888739824295044,
-0.3559172749519348,
-0.1172507032752037,
0.9519816637039185,
-0.543653130531311,
0.3093454837799072,
0.5312479138374329,
0.875629723072052,
0.3445439338684082,
0.4488072395324707,
0.7386253476142883,
-0.68067467212677,
0.25136518478393555,
0.2672670781612396,
0.11166007816791534,
0.2726387679576874,
-0.46911951899528503,
0.3437950015068054,
0.09103883057832718,
-0.7085416316986084,
-1.092250108718872,
0.35180866718292236,
-0.5896006226539612,
-0.279683917760849,
1.0039302110671997,
0.0967889204621315,
-0.19134032726287842,
-0.05775780230760574,
-0.03262822702527046,
0.09242195636034012,
-0.2542889714241028,
0.5616660118103027,
0.3822620213031769,
-0.06604640185832977,
0.25944381952285767,
-0.27280694246292114,
0.4260297119617462,
0.2797676920890808,
-0.36114996671676636,
0.07396025955677032,
0.756412923336029,
-0.08546292781829834,
0.09974122047424316,
1.1651220321655273,
-0.38299694657325745,
0.12783770263195038,
-0.44862160086631775,
-0.07191945612430573,
0.3545072078704834,
-0.1684984713792801,
-0.11492261290550232,
0.2477271854877472,
0.21946655213832855,
-0.5950907468795776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08660v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08660v1
|
Fine-Tuned 'Small' LLMs (Still) Significantly Outperform Zero-Shot Generative AI Models in Text Classification
| 2024-06-12T21:46:13 | 2024-06-12T21:46:13 |
Martin Juan José Bucher, Marco Martini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Generative AI offers a simple, prompt-based alternative to fine-tuning
smaller BERT-style LLMs for text classification tasks. This promises to
eliminate the need for manually labeled training data and task-specific model
training. However, it remains an open question whether tools like ChatGPT can
deliver on this promise. In this paper, we show that smaller, fine-tuned LLMs
(still) consistently and significantly outperform larger, zero-shot prompted
models in text classification. We compare three major generative AI models
(ChatGPT with GPT-3.5/GPT-4 and Claude Opus) with several fine-tuned LLMs
across a diverse set of classification tasks (sentiment, approval/disapproval,
emotions, party positions) and text categories (news, tweets, speeches). We
find that fine-tuning with application-specific training data achieves superior
performance in all cases. To make this approach more accessible to a broader
audience, we provide an easy-to-use toolkit alongside this paper. Our toolkit,
accompanied by non-technical step-by-step guidance, enables users to select and
fine-tune BERT-like LLMs for any classification task with minimal technical and
computational effort.
|
[
-0.19884228706359863,
-0.7953219413757324,
0.581768810749054,
0.061956290155649185,
-0.40713101625442505,
0.10359048843383789,
-0.5571503639221191,
-0.4795653522014618,
-0.08662763983011246,
0.2668558657169342,
-0.5599909424781799,
-0.6434511542320251,
-0.678414523601532,
0.2050420641899109,
-0.3653428256511688,
1.2875345945358276,
0.11980783939361572,
-0.10626503825187683,
-0.2753177881240845,
-0.09215021133422852,
-0.49816635251045227,
-0.3894212543964386,
-0.9814885854721069,
-0.5548375844955444,
0.7629420757293701,
0.7300708889961243,
0.5414623618125916,
0.3900510370731354,
0.5830793380737305,
0.2732590436935425,
-0.30580729246139526,
0.3445846736431122,
-0.5766481757164001,
0.13068236410617828,
0.1025286316871643,
-0.5704731345176697,
-0.3450855612754822,
0.13812671601772308,
0.3620704412460327,
0.28292974829673767,
-0.03149785101413727,
0.034360695630311966,
0.46703141927719116,
0.5354511737823486,
-0.373544842004776,
0.29376381635665894,
-0.7853740453720093,
0.05018001049757004,
-0.30721336603164673,
-0.21769309043884277,
-0.577926754951477,
-0.34123244881629944,
0.07988791167736053,
-0.43952369689941406,
0.6043732166290283,
0.04290906339883804,
0.7434402108192444,
0.510675847530365,
-0.36737504601478577,
-0.25606000423431396,
-0.6918966174125671,
0.762424111366272,
-0.4974634051322937,
0.09056589007377625,
0.09204130619764328,
0.23025992512702942,
-0.08754410594701767,
-0.7022222876548767,
-0.6155897378921509,
-0.2246587574481964,
-0.05013088509440422,
0.2499035745859146,
-0.2752229869365692,
0.3878663182258606,
0.15481171011924744,
0.41166913509368896,
-0.5798637866973877,
0.6418935656547546,
-0.17100290954113007,
-0.11836942285299301,
0.3721790611743927,
0.17978908121585846,
0.0918654128909111,
-0.2645877003669739,
-0.25143659114837646,
-0.09828206151723862,
-0.6624937057495117,
-0.1286473572254181,
-0.0551784448325634,
0.3956669270992279,
-0.2917821407318115,
0.6673116087913513,
-0.2001739740371704,
0.6389214396476746,
0.11648958921432495,
-0.047544173896312714,
-0.004889000207185745,
-0.15796008706092834,
-0.4167838394641876,
-0.0596533939242363,
1.0192375183105469,
0.1947220116853714,
0.25203272700309753,
-0.09193447977304459,
-0.059292446821928024,
0.10109248012304306,
0.09649774432182312,
-0.996539831161499,
-0.4433770179748535,
-0.11064742505550385,
-0.330456405878067,
-0.35062626004219055,
-0.2871619462966919,
-0.5136091113090515,
-0.5735557079315186,
-0.3960703909397125,
0.3785008490085602,
-0.4474696218967438,
0.31378307938575745,
0.047097157686948776,
-0.2630358338356018,
0.2872690260410309,
0.9018163681030273,
-0.9936361312866211,
-0.152314692735672,
0.8336325883865356,
1.2033830881118774,
-0.31569239497184753,
0.012712903320789337,
-0.5564138293266296,
-0.2805470824241638,
-0.3347351551055908,
1.0801194906234741,
-0.49471616744995117,
-0.2142859250307083,
-0.01848060078918934,
-0.2931734025478363,
-0.09809128195047379,
-0.3771648108959198,
0.7048763632774353,
-0.301949679851532,
0.287929505109787,
0.03485257551074028,
-0.6154395937919617,
-0.008001094684004784,
0.6306780576705933,
-0.3655287027359009,
0.8807739615440369,
-0.059363726526498795,
-0.6413673758506775,
0.5072685480117798,
-0.4414670765399933,
-0.36889827251434326,
0.20800840854644775,
-0.2824636399745941,
-0.6136289834976196,
0.20929263532161713,
0.09823518991470337,
0.8182558417320251,
-0.35963302850723267,
-0.21174177527427673,
-0.40701377391815186,
-0.44268670678138733,
0.008248747326433659,
-0.8662678003311157,
0.3764835298061371,
0.16092808544635773,
-0.10849125683307648,
0.290100634098053,
-0.6408506035804749,
0.04428818076848984,
-0.16100993752479553,
-0.570702075958252,
-0.13399390876293182,
-0.026948118582367897,
0.0957898274064064,
0.0008090308401733637,
0.14078468084335327,
-0.5374873876571655,
0.44420620799064636,
-0.47759518027305603,
0.6816505193710327,
0.521085798740387,
-0.11509121209383011,
0.46905964612960815,
-0.466949999332428,
0.4397414028644562,
-0.23761145770549774,
-0.10106512904167175,
-0.07891003042459488,
-0.6637822985649109,
-1.05898118019104,
-0.6645297408103943,
0.4547687768936157,
0.6577329635620117,
-0.8971567749977112,
0.40468278527259827,
-0.4969709813594818,
-0.8077143430709839,
-0.45843541622161865,
0.2615114748477936,
0.2171422839164734,
0.3473730683326721,
0.11053462326526642,
-0.03646121546626091,
-0.17721104621887207,
-0.7445338368415833,
-0.19205963611602783,
-0.3155558407306671,
-0.2668508291244507,
0.3651186525821686,
0.3276825547218323,
-0.3209055960178375,
0.704445481300354,
-0.3660709261894226,
-0.5560015439987183,
-0.41785797476768494,
0.5961435437202454,
0.15329237282276154,
0.1428861916065216,
0.4610028564929962,
-0.5299547910690308,
-0.7292800545692444,
0.22129134833812714,
-0.4968964159488678,
-0.09012555330991745,
-0.2884206175804138,
0.1816195249557495,
0.13890746235847473,
0.3624284565448761,
-0.7222656011581421,
0.324490487575531,
0.2637791633605957,
-0.12313863635063171,
0.3102405071258545,
-0.24500852823257446,
-0.06847535818815231,
-0.902924120426178,
-0.22445061802864075,
0.07390454411506653,
-0.5103800296783447,
-0.5393072962760925,
-0.204133540391922,
0.1320420652627945,
0.04634431004524231,
-0.3975614011287689,
0.5193554162979126,
-0.14824022352695465,
0.28949031233787537,
-0.4480738043785095,
0.1684751659631729,
-0.22993478178977966,
0.5298503041267395,
0.106832355260849,
0.8925668597221375,
0.4285154938697815,
-0.5272158980369568,
0.2412918359041214,
0.4498582184314728,
-0.41701754927635193,
0.4955722987651825,
-0.5201830863952637,
0.2587047815322876,
-0.15816061198711395,
0.2056475579738617,
-0.8984957337379456,
-0.31804925203323364,
0.2801015377044678,
-0.46104544401168823,
0.4576917588710785,
-0.222988098859787,
-0.7134479284286499,
-0.13659550249576569,
-0.5207610726356506,
0.07556416094303131,
0.7897927761077881,
-0.6468886733055115,
0.34153255820274353,
-0.10930062085390091,
-0.28837475180625916,
-0.20233549177646637,
-0.6146681308746338,
0.17526619136333466,
-0.30305054783821106,
-0.2730781137943268,
0.32537326216697693,
-0.05616262927651405,
0.2014695256948471,
-0.33046284317970276,
-0.021527407690882683,
-0.01978304795920849,
0.14357782900333405,
0.23894010484218597,
0.1190859004855156,
-0.127322256565094,
0.35804590582847595,
0.12469540536403656,
-0.16510912775993347,
-0.42561596632003784,
-0.11748439818620682,
0.4097334146499634,
-0.28403550386428833,
-0.18341509997844696,
-0.4894646108150482,
-0.019669339060783386,
0.5492019057273865,
0.09837058931589127,
0.6666670441627502,
0.8677834272384644,
-0.07007590681314468,
-0.43038642406463623,
-0.32325974106788635,
-0.15557515621185303,
-0.46780940890312195,
0.2874927222728729,
-0.1346302032470703,
-1.297136664390564,
0.1070484071969986,
-0.09454061836004257,
0.10699447989463806,
0.5401008725166321,
0.6739553809165955,
-0.46838676929473877,
0.9632105827331543,
0.7843045592308044,
-0.28212770819664,
0.7084285020828247,
-0.12550750374794006,
0.14197877049446106,
-0.5225710868835449,
-0.03613442927598953,
-0.6653704047203064,
-0.42505142092704773,
-0.8529520630836487,
-0.14287185668945312,
0.43470150232315063,
0.1069803312420845,
-0.2668645679950714,
0.14625555276870728,
-0.6962167620658875,
0.4889504909515381,
0.6894527673721313,
0.2512264549732208,
0.26777753233909607,
0.12394682317972183,
0.4060042202472687,
-0.03970661759376526,
-0.8769694566726685,
-0.6646844744682312,
0.8063855171203613,
0.3583694100379944,
0.8538843989372253,
-0.030582910403609276,
0.7215089201927185,
0.4877336323261261,
0.6061767339706421,
-1.2403322458267212,
0.5124783515930176,
-0.6115362048149109,
-0.31737691164016724,
-0.2398359179496765,
-0.4055652916431427,
-0.8160439133644104,
0.11333049088716507,
-0.28577589988708496,
-0.6275265216827393,
0.042259685695171356,
0.42284464836120605,
-0.48607969284057617,
0.22876985371112823,
-0.787331223487854,
0.844339907169342,
-0.0994676947593689,
-0.0070168678648769855,
-0.09876823425292969,
-0.3703466057777405,
0.09693894535303116,
-0.21713267266750336,
-0.16556504368782043,
-0.31650304794311523,
-0.20733636617660522,
0.6148907542228699,
-0.3299761116504669,
1.183940052986145,
0.14143365621566772,
0.009725143201649189,
0.24595071375370026,
-0.18459275364875793,
0.5242975950241089,
0.02695932798087597,
0.02095348760485649,
0.2341233193874359,
0.022454358637332916,
-0.23357313871383667,
-0.5109549760818481,
0.6476075053215027,
-0.8027392625808716,
-0.46922802925109863,
-0.44258588552474976,
-0.22485291957855225,
-0.22367402911186218,
0.23647817969322205,
0.5842122435569763,
0.26023975014686584,
-0.1572350114583969,
0.6377541422843933,
0.7430253028869629,
-0.1006368100643158,
0.45570307970046997,
0.36540257930755615,
0.22639742493629456,
-0.13356763124465942,
0.841945469379425,
-0.07514581829309464,
0.08108518272638321,
0.6652293801307678,
0.12031658738851547,
-0.13827833533287048,
-0.6806171536445618,
-0.556746244430542,
-0.18885010480880737,
-0.5214079022407532,
-0.6575214266777039,
-0.45597681403160095,
-0.35631147027015686,
-0.027458105236291885,
-0.19206362962722778,
-0.24594587087631226,
-0.3821716904640198,
-0.6564775705337524,
-0.033744219690561295,
0.5990909337997437,
0.49641671776771545,
0.17912282049655914,
0.7172679901123047,
-0.732752799987793,
0.2832283675670624,
0.4092601537704468,
0.40138936042785645,
-0.30744707584381104,
-0.6259725689888,
-0.12784084677696228,
-0.025797221809625626,
-0.5461482405662537,
-0.6611382365226746,
0.25777581334114075,
0.7237808108329773,
0.09746309369802475,
0.3689948320388794,
0.13650138676166534,
0.4483843743801117,
-0.6053818464279175,
0.7891305685043335,
0.19358307123184204,
-0.6137206554412842,
0.5117016434669495,
-0.47458845376968384,
0.37737929821014404,
0.6635352373123169,
0.044522322714328766,
-0.4618528187274933,
-0.3776928782463074,
-0.3007937967777252,
-0.4817167818546295,
0.8213109970092773,
0.45691797137260437,
0.4178508520126343,
-0.01881624385714531,
0.4980311095714569,
0.23413267731666565,
0.2872316539287567,
-0.7436379194259644,
-0.19481608271598816,
-0.0869469866156578,
-0.6620451211929321,
-0.3283075988292694,
-0.3198705315589905,
0.09084159135818481,
-0.14032502472400665,
0.576252818107605,
-0.3503684401512146,
0.4108735918998718,
-0.03314311057329178,
0.03393561765551567,
0.08063089102506638,
0.5710776448249817,
0.4399906396865845,
0.021159909665584564,
-0.08473175764083862,
0.08134496212005615,
0.26136577129364014,
-0.44674864411354065,
0.14027643203735352,
0.21027052402496338,
-0.5011600255966187,
0.03487537056207657,
0.48080235719680786,
0.9480197429656982,
0.1395038366317749,
-0.4636686146259308,
0.5075098872184753,
-0.27353435754776,
-0.287750244140625,
-0.003011898836120963,
0.50247722864151,
-0.24175038933753967,
0.3312263488769531,
0.0786392092704773,
0.3936329185962677,
0.05099109932780266,
-0.36599767208099365,
-0.10502906143665314,
0.6175780296325684,
-0.4580923318862915,
-0.1216876283288002,
0.5900043249130249,
0.28678956627845764,
-0.4089250862598419,
0.5223601460456848,
-0.3284137547016144,
-0.4235740005970001,
0.4089808166027069,
0.22967872023582458,
1.121038556098938,
0.3927203416824341,
0.37886717915534973,
-0.017266806215047836,
0.4101957380771637,
-0.11182986199855804,
0.08041314035654068,
-0.3409067392349243,
-0.7874190807342529,
-0.2767302691936493,
-0.5903629660606384,
-0.5618202686309814,
0.31038615107536316,
-0.4110729992389679,
0.241853266954422,
-0.5439863801002502,
-0.18577660620212555,
0.2856415808200836,
0.020573733374476433,
-0.8291981220245361,
0.15283320844173431,
0.07710171490907669,
0.8588886857032776,
-0.5873960256576538,
0.9560140371322632,
0.8656650185585022,
-0.17807450890541077,
-0.4428320825099945,
0.1276223361492157,
0.011039583943784237,
-0.6780518889427185,
0.23580718040466309,
0.38446953892707825,
-0.07530561089515686,
0.13668015599250793,
-0.7503048181533813,
-0.40950414538383484,
0.9484707117080688,
0.3634108603000641,
-0.8016377091407776,
0.10545404255390167,
0.1037641391158104,
0.8181923627853394,
0.06948434561491013,
0.11705879122018814,
0.524262547492981,
0.2139134556055069,
0.22128210961818695,
-0.9431827664375305,
-0.41948020458221436,
-0.018384389579296112,
0.010139964520931244,
0.22464720904827118,
-0.7482201457023621,
0.4559095501899719,
-0.02401989884674549,
-0.21563439071178436,
0.37463295459747314,
0.6420738697052002,
0.07086168229579926,
0.42927321791648865,
0.29548367857933044,
0.44849923253059387,
0.6962348222732544,
-0.3831103444099426,
0.950537919998169,
-0.03409154340624809,
0.3880936801433563,
1.0111113786697388,
0.04742936044931412,
1.040136456489563,
0.1534537374973297,
-0.09463602304458618,
0.25071826577186584,
0.954917848110199,
-0.08093927055597305,
0.6043371558189392,
-0.1029253900051117,
-0.38009169697761536,
-0.4104253947734833,
0.009850922971963882,
-0.07795821130275726,
0.47056639194488525,
0.3245013356208801,
-0.14907214045524597,
-0.21035559475421906,
0.17252087593078613,
-0.09603490680456161,
-0.045377232134342194,
-0.5220478773117065,
1.1831121444702148,
0.25889477133750916,
-0.551355242729187,
0.41219985485076904,
0.15898767113685608,
1.045559287071228,
-0.450454980134964,
0.12312231212854385,
-0.20594541728496552,
0.4122796952724457,
-0.09126026928424835,
-0.8921115398406982,
0.01394626498222351,
0.4081714451313019,
-0.2816140949726105,
-0.3186543583869934,
1.0321415662765503,
-0.34616774320602417,
-0.3923921287059784,
-0.1578451693058014,
0.3358522653579712,
0.08207688480615616,
-0.10673242062330246,
-0.6558269262313843,
-0.184959277510643,
0.05976508930325508,
-0.12901447713375092,
0.25960808992385864,
0.6975375413894653,
0.06942064315080643,
0.7088247537612915,
0.442153662443161,
0.05816762521862984,
-0.16320981085300446,
0.003250076435506344,
0.5990024209022522,
-0.5633174180984497,
-0.2796476483345032,
-0.9959226250648499,
0.14664660394191742,
-0.11256591975688934,
-0.4365541636943817,
0.663395881652832,
0.3972976803779602,
0.8040096163749695,
-0.19249078631401062,
0.782294750213623,
0.034952033311128616,
0.5106416940689087,
-0.6111253499984741,
0.6929621696472168,
-0.5199410319328308,
0.19559842348098755,
0.029602181166410446,
-0.7070457339286804,
-0.54216068983078,
0.5238118171691895,
-0.32057154178619385,
0.23625943064689636,
0.30416926741600037,
0.5327805876731873,
0.005687544122338295,
-0.03580647334456444,
0.3802105188369751,
0.1139148473739624,
0.421875536441803,
0.3613738417625427,
0.9288949370384216,
-0.21495120227336884,
0.6941251754760742,
-0.08055721968412399,
-0.18660862743854523,
-0.3901588022708893,
-0.8909504413604736,
-1.1887537240982056,
-0.23509745299816132,
-0.43930917978286743,
0.17034249007701874,
0.013133707456290722,
0.7896061539649963,
0.7331253886222839,
-0.751760721206665,
0.36691996455192566,
-0.3240368366241455,
0.09667006134986877,
0.009018439799547195,
-0.178754985332489,
0.2255794107913971,
-0.6109376549720764,
-0.7731784582138062,
0.15673589706420898,
0.418291836977005,
0.2570141851902008,
0.15970882773399353,
-0.05298633128404617,
0.4759882390499115,
0.0501992367208004,
0.8108750581741333,
0.3303053677082062,
-0.6912298798561096,
-0.3707793653011322,
-0.1952449530363083,
-0.4255477488040924,
0.09330533444881439,
0.4574104845523834,
-0.7194876074790955,
0.27252551913261414,
0.3956167697906494,
0.7324020266532898,
0.5727787613868713,
0.006055413745343685,
0.23803597688674927,
-1.191696047782898,
0.037398964166641235,
0.2112143188714981,
0.1635911911725998,
0.32356390357017517,
-0.31496694684028625,
0.44609254598617554,
-0.05720566585659981,
-0.676008939743042,
-0.5774552822113037,
0.02523651532828808,
-1.0874295234680176,
-0.1501973420381546,
1.1824504137039185,
0.1528116911649704,
0.1359163075685501,
0.15873609483242035,
-0.6179832220077515,
0.13932368159294128,
-0.412587970495224,
0.956451952457428,
0.6008332967758179,
-0.2953656017780304,
-0.3942070007324219,
-0.44658026099205017,
0.8001218438148499,
0.39743003249168396,
-0.910852313041687,
-0.06689392030239105,
0.5162883996963501,
0.07730551064014435,
-0.08031792938709259,
0.48192450404167175,
0.35159173607826233,
0.23544538021087646,
-0.3252173662185669,
-0.2446162849664688,
0.06403238326311111,
-0.34485283493995667,
-0.4021797776222229,
0.12189912050962448,
0.3276917040348053,
-0.3746721148490906
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08657v1
|
Mistral-C2F: Coarse to Fine Actor for Analytical and Reasoning Enhancement in RLHF and Effective-Merged LLMs
| 2024-06-12T21:42:13 | 2024-06-12T21:42:13 |
Chen Zheng, Ke Sun, Xun Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Despite the advances in Large Language Models (LLMs), exemplified by models
like GPT-4 and Claude, smaller-scale LLMs such as Llama and Mistral often
struggle with generating in-depth and coherent dialogues. This paper presents a
novel two-step Coarse-to-Fine Actor model to address the inherent limitations
in conversational and analytical capabilities of small-sized LLMs. Our approach
begins with the Policy-based Coarse Actor, employing a technique we term
"Continuous Maximization". The Coarse Actor establishes an enhanced,
knowledge-rich pool adept at aligning with human preference styles in analysis
and reasoning. Through the RLHF process, it employs Continuous Maximization, a
strategy that dynamically and adaptively extends the output length limit,
enabling the generation of more detailed and analytical content. Subsequently,
the Fine Actor refines this analytical content, addressing the generation of
excessively redundant information from the Coarse Actor. We introduce a
"Knowledge Residue Merger" approach, refining the content from the Coarse Actor
and merging it with an existing Instruction model to improve quality,
correctness, and reduce redundancies. We applied our methodology to the popular
Mistral model, creating Mistral-C2F, which has demonstrated exceptional
performance across 11 general language tasks and the MT-Bench Dialogue task,
outperforming similar-scale models and even larger models with 13B and 30B
parameters. Our model has significantly improved conversational and analytical
reasoning abilities.
|
[
-0.44821423292160034,
-0.9705561995506287,
0.6074553728103638,
-0.28173428773880005,
-0.1887262463569641,
0.011898718774318695,
-0.5871289372444153,
-0.4558677077293396,
-0.08769381046295166,
0.7579914331436157,
-0.45832228660583496,
-0.4381432831287384,
-0.6344940662384033,
-0.24117250740528107,
-0.3304940462112427,
0.9006158113479614,
0.16788288950920105,
0.14587558805942535,
-0.1615023910999298,
-0.2250426560640335,
-0.39628738164901733,
-0.4237110912799835,
-1.1050810813903809,
-0.5834681391716003,
0.47056764364242554,
0.7411196827888489,
0.9274279475212097,
0.6990506649017334,
0.3893364667892456,
0.34271907806396484,
0.07561737298965454,
0.5839253664016724,
-0.8224871158599854,
0.25439998507499695,
-0.3765099048614502,
-0.4618641138076782,
-0.44503888487815857,
-0.18622441589832306,
0.6518508195877075,
0.7091171145439148,
-0.5495993494987488,
-0.0016705190064385533,
0.3436584174633026,
0.6985078454017639,
-0.6272991299629211,
0.2185867428779602,
-0.5513644218444824,
-0.2670036554336548,
0.13503900170326233,
-0.1507292538881302,
-0.07838204503059387,
-0.25613754987716675,
0.14543646574020386,
-0.5349559187889099,
0.038034576922655106,
-0.2265601009130478,
0.7088481187820435,
0.36094358563423157,
-0.2813044786453247,
-0.24511019885540009,
-1.102644920349121,
0.988187313079834,
-0.8947646021842957,
0.3043700158596039,
0.25100016593933105,
0.3394469618797302,
-0.2110222578048706,
-0.9294009804725647,
-0.5775007009506226,
-0.38708311319351196,
0.06338714063167572,
-0.14858193695545197,
-0.3103492259979248,
0.41908279061317444,
-0.13014569878578186,
0.12635672092437744,
-0.258526474237442,
0.1403045803308487,
-0.36735865473747253,
-0.16890528798103333,
0.52725750207901,
0.5568360686302185,
-0.05524350330233574,
0.24546875059604645,
-0.34713056683540344,
-0.04471467435359955,
-0.39891910552978516,
0.15878073871135712,
0.13063101470470428,
0.2322099357843399,
-0.012792723253369331,
0.33628955483436584,
-0.38196977972984314,
0.6511366963386536,
0.3836553394794464,
-0.4589383602142334,
-0.5609012246131897,
-0.17032955586910248,
-0.25355586409568787,
-0.0698741227388382,
0.641481876373291,
0.3918386995792389,
0.2662900686264038,
0.16332519054412842,
-0.23956520855426788,
-0.026014192029833794,
0.1431696116924286,
-0.9212673902511597,
-0.11155680567026138,
0.2626494765281677,
-0.2304128259420395,
-0.5401838421821594,
-0.2399541735649109,
-0.738710880279541,
-0.559266984462738,
-0.739855945110321,
0.2720770835876465,
-0.3378605246543884,
-0.22511126101016998,
-0.043153032660484314,
0.0852457731962204,
0.35119956731796265,
0.6456064581871033,
-0.6698740124702454,
0.7532950043678284,
0.7424752116203308,
0.3898051977157593,
-0.2278236448764801,
-0.20272240042686462,
-0.6732467412948608,
0.232744961977005,
-0.5495162606239319,
0.9691189527511597,
-0.6964577436447144,
-0.3048437237739563,
0.07911039143800735,
-0.44224345684051514,
-0.10004671663045883,
-0.8855181336402893,
0.49780160188674927,
-0.37986457347869873,
0.15080082416534424,
-0.06541388481855392,
-0.40275418758392334,
-0.3956778049468994,
0.51951003074646,
-0.4743480384349823,
1.132835030555725,
0.30486130714416504,
-0.4819607436656952,
0.032939065247774124,
-0.30327194929122925,
-0.1865876466035843,
-0.010322332382202148,
-0.4963800609111786,
0.11734004318714142,
-0.04201949015259743,
0.14959608018398285,
0.4245551824569702,
-0.8507590889930725,
0.5720906853675842,
-0.35809463262557983,
-0.4680327773094177,
0.33946001529693604,
-0.7169398665428162,
0.16059502959251404,
0.2265520989894867,
-0.326748251914978,
0.22185906767845154,
-0.6765568256378174,
0.041763193905353546,
-0.12118833512067795,
-0.39636197686195374,
0.019912535324692726,
-0.04662483558058739,
0.04982845112681389,
0.23492400348186493,
0.3390234112739563,
0.08549924194812775,
-0.15682223439216614,
-0.29334506392478943,
0.3174918293952942,
0.6250377893447876,
0.345022588968277,
0.7036536335945129,
-0.4688851535320282,
0.5298165082931519,
0.053614433854818344,
0.26969775557518005,
0.221746027469635,
-0.22366131842136383,
-1.0889348983764648,
-0.49742767214775085,
0.1383102834224701,
0.7171872854232788,
-0.7149710655212402,
0.1377444863319397,
-0.2957761883735657,
-0.45115742087364197,
-0.3898855149745941,
0.3828144967556,
0.2746705114841461,
0.42558449506759644,
0.2008519172668457,
-0.3275645077228546,
-0.22833135724067688,
-0.8556020259857178,
-0.20083393156528473,
-0.28638097643852234,
0.29189616441726685,
0.34035375714302063,
-0.011002112179994583,
-0.2983929514884949,
0.9534624218940735,
-0.3750514090061188,
-0.3618945777416229,
-0.5890752673149109,
-0.007428036071360111,
0.13337625563144684,
0.4533332288265228,
0.03152826428413391,
-0.5567697286605835,
-0.4469251334667206,
0.31873881816864014,
-0.6057793498039246,
0.0026135118678212166,
-0.20419597625732422,
-0.1886563003063202,
0.13132502138614655,
0.5849077701568604,
-0.6308319568634033,
0.4129415452480316,
0.3287029564380646,
-0.03942451253533363,
0.5577433109283447,
-0.20181262493133545,
0.22160550951957703,
-0.8053314089775085,
-0.006379761267453432,
0.03151074796915054,
-0.35100629925727844,
-0.8434404730796814,
0.2306695133447647,
-0.4741009473800659,
-0.17518122494220734,
-0.3971773087978363,
0.8046971559524536,
-0.18200036883354187,
0.2918640077114105,
-0.5019820928573608,
0.46160849928855896,
-0.12436453253030777,
0.8519695401191711,
-0.058499474078416824,
0.6595562100410461,
0.44855788350105286,
-0.7999793291091919,
0.21962504088878632,
-0.17060421407222748,
-0.11257756501436234,
0.7474706172943115,
-0.624805212020874,
-0.09145836532115936,
-0.09248882532119751,
0.2517484724521637,
-0.9334019422531128,
-0.3384891748428345,
0.3021530210971832,
-0.19600996375083923,
0.5007819533348083,
-0.3656240403652191,
-0.29261070489883423,
0.29755207896232605,
-0.26644182205200195,
0.4963783025741577,
0.5140480995178223,
-0.3534959852695465,
1.1357382535934448,
0.25394150614738464,
-0.5489130616188049,
-0.4773799479007721,
-0.40083256363868713,
0.1240818202495575,
-0.4033726751804352,
-0.7626281380653381,
0.23874089121818542,
0.010969976894557476,
-0.5014303922653198,
-0.049130503088235855,
-0.29857295751571655,
-0.4825948476791382,
-0.25668513774871826,
-0.06579085439443588,
0.35928258299827576,
-0.19806057214736938,
-0.24846260249614716,
0.4703453481197357,
-0.06163712590932846,
-0.1702825278043747,
-0.28766879439353943,
0.33098793029785156,
-0.007738807704299688,
-0.09911952912807465,
-0.7030560374259949,
0.36964741349220276,
0.8062511086463928,
-0.16701310873031616,
0.5820297598838806,
0.8804093599319458,
-0.26764950156211853,
-0.28792843222618103,
-0.7541266679763794,
-0.2990392744541168,
-0.43005067110061646,
0.31415003538131714,
-0.11189274489879608,
-1.1987355947494507,
0.45466235280036926,
-0.5414518713951111,
0.05871603265404701,
0.34545382857322693,
0.5091089010238647,
0.06900239735841751,
0.824282705783844,
0.46098899841308594,
-0.01992216520011425,
0.4669649004936218,
-0.4416005313396454,
0.26133131980895996,
-0.7767350673675537,
-0.1550321877002716,
-0.3745449483394623,
-0.0949951633810997,
-0.41690728068351746,
-0.7843475341796875,
0.5232297778129578,
0.5084391236305237,
-0.4408677816390991,
-0.0973471850156784,
-0.28434842824935913,
0.3421945571899414,
0.10543368011713028,
0.12445899844169617,
0.3237820863723755,
0.14023487269878387,
-0.18415392935276031,
0.05427871271967888,
-0.8510160446166992,
-0.6624687314033508,
0.8124365210533142,
0.4833332300186157,
0.9360795021057129,
0.24165195226669312,
0.7242459058761597,
0.36511456966400146,
0.2698972225189209,
-1.0373399257659912,
0.741254985332489,
-0.04392988607287407,
-0.38854870200157166,
-0.4861927330493927,
-0.47570887207984924,
-0.6482938528060913,
0.6167410612106323,
-0.29658475518226624,
-0.7503402233123779,
0.3527334928512573,
0.0833660215139389,
-0.3454388678073883,
-0.055795829743146896,
-0.5859881043434143,
0.6343058943748474,
0.08955919742584229,
-0.633648693561554,
-0.7371518015861511,
-0.40264344215393066,
0.6255067586898804,
-0.025155944749712944,
0.46467724442481995,
-0.09805047512054443,
-0.1726149320602417,
0.5372332334518433,
-0.5013644099235535,
1.0709675550460815,
-0.22053323686122894,
-0.2397160530090332,
0.7580949068069458,
0.2857743799686432,
0.7133275866508484,
0.14176076650619507,
0.05969510227441788,
-0.04736688733100891,
0.23836441338062286,
-0.24826890230178833,
-0.936752438545227,
0.6996860504150391,
-0.7322995662689209,
-0.7864183187484741,
-0.2314358353614807,
-0.46902376413345337,
-0.28798243403434753,
-0.004187692888081074,
-0.16638417541980743,
0.7240883111953735,
-0.4505803883075714,
0.013452828861773014,
0.7352277040481567,
0.1565619707107544,
0.1614789068698883,
0.40982842445373535,
0.021345512941479683,
-0.7862772345542908,
0.8085514903068542,
-0.19730137288570404,
0.48608195781707764,
0.3775970935821533,
0.2092040628194809,
-0.3514164090156555,
-0.4537399411201477,
-0.11399256438016891,
0.37101343274116516,
-0.8934424519538879,
-0.17398396134376526,
-0.5155258178710938,
-0.21907152235507965,
-0.2813299298286438,
0.011416793800890446,
-0.3575586974620819,
-0.546404242515564,
-0.3440871834754944,
0.29782989621162415,
0.0876927301287651,
0.6802532076835632,
-0.207586869597435,
0.4484485685825348,
-0.7517707347869873,
0.21385005116462708,
0.47887691855430603,
0.05341983586549759,
0.36649298667907715,
-0.8167665600776672,
-0.4350597858428955,
0.04861339181661606,
-0.5077150464057922,
-0.4175712764263153,
0.193128764629364,
0.35486671328544617,
0.5800703167915344,
0.5977767109870911,
-0.027748433873057365,
0.9239614009857178,
-0.46278390288352966,
0.8114941716194153,
0.26946473121643066,
-0.7565913200378418,
0.20993174612522125,
-0.3278089463710785,
0.11321476846933365,
0.6241962313652039,
-0.021698608994483948,
-0.3453599512577057,
-0.5667404532432556,
-0.5096931457519531,
-0.6996521353721619,
0.617033839225769,
0.23753947019577026,
0.0729411318898201,
0.11563576757907867,
0.296021968126297,
-0.1317957192659378,
-0.038198649883270264,
-0.21210065484046936,
-0.11759582906961441,
0.1728280484676361,
-0.3117482364177704,
0.00524713983759284,
-0.203314408659935,
-0.4208385944366455,
-0.37659192085266113,
0.7137874364852905,
-0.22018684446811676,
0.20108936727046967,
0.22254180908203125,
0.0814153403043747,
-0.018101464956998825,
0.46631547808647156,
0.7287477254867554,
0.565316915512085,
0.08427265286445618,
0.050337985157966614,
0.35827410221099854,
-0.5704680681228638,
-0.04668762907385826,
0.1984899491071701,
0.3306407034397125,
-0.24367785453796387,
0.5639921426773071,
0.5545711517333984,
0.5060911774635315,
-0.8302424550056458,
0.3849982023239136,
-0.09884438663721085,
-0.17720083892345428,
-0.32561394572257996,
0.47707048058509827,
0.04490693286061287,
0.676071047782898,
0.24112629890441895,
0.19735194742679596,
0.18166492879390717,
-0.5474866032600403,
0.20017953217029572,
0.2251589000225067,
-0.4309033155441284,
0.06390339136123657,
0.3224400281906128,
0.1947682946920395,
-0.009433083236217499,
0.4062676727771759,
-0.10646629333496094,
-0.3641994297504425,
0.3635835349559784,
0.3190973401069641,
0.6561762690544128,
-0.1432100236415863,
0.2535078525543213,
0.23279060423374176,
0.0698191225528717,
-0.2845798134803772,
0.13684915006160736,
-0.2958988845348358,
-0.8290653824806213,
-0.43426817655563354,
-0.5609173774719238,
-0.39155665040016174,
0.06974300742149353,
-0.725602924823761,
0.15502379834651947,
-0.6332820057868958,
-0.3262557089328766,
-0.17244942486286163,
0.21788226068019867,
-0.6086618304252625,
0.17943783104419708,
-0.15292569994926453,
0.6763821244239807,
-0.4227588176727295,
0.907417893409729,
0.45889154076576233,
-0.36747050285339355,
-1.0603938102722168,
0.10526866465806961,
-0.03203204274177551,
-0.720424473285675,
0.46932968497276306,
-0.2685012221336365,
-0.34700480103492737,
0.0965399295091629,
-0.6263130307197571,
-0.8210257887840271,
1.323623776435852,
0.4986783266067505,
-0.4039771854877472,
-0.012006223201751709,
0.1900426745414734,
0.5287594795227051,
-0.6797550320625305,
0.12924610078334808,
0.9800715446472168,
0.46554261445999146,
0.5213200449943542,
-0.790696918964386,
-0.07190018892288208,
0.12056296318769455,
0.19072982668876648,
0.14268743991851807,
-0.47245803475379944,
0.37671172618865967,
-0.1884472519159317,
-0.20860861241817474,
0.33955585956573486,
0.8222018480300903,
0.5562183260917664,
0.3053514063358307,
0.4382019639015198,
0.5079003572463989,
0.7900330424308777,
0.17491135001182556,
0.8896569609642029,
-0.3840082883834839,
0.2732091248035431,
1.2402743101119995,
-0.22852690517902374,
0.9275633096694946,
0.40728044509887695,
-0.00272137182764709,
0.7230410575866699,
0.35632139444351196,
0.38187938928604126,
0.41235899925231934,
0.12341111898422241,
-0.5625616908073425,
-0.46256884932518005,
-0.38869258761405945,
0.16236735880374908,
0.5073136687278748,
0.6156353950500488,
0.017696501687169075,
-0.3202226758003235,
-0.19832336902618408,
0.13004152476787567,
0.3579910397529602,
-0.45788300037384033,
0.8907955884933472,
0.3033171594142914,
-0.8005693554878235,
0.9151468873023987,
0.2919468283653259,
0.4441787004470825,
-0.4742927849292755,
-0.34860941767692566,
-0.431901216506958,
0.22929008305072784,
-0.18402597308158875,
-0.6186438798904419,
0.10604874789714813,
0.06417573243379593,
-0.03320590406656265,
0.27084881067276,
0.9077717065811157,
-0.8772594332695007,
-0.2355584055185318,
0.20594356954097748,
0.50454181432724,
0.1748671978712082,
0.07329381257295609,
-0.8282314538955688,
0.19040021300315857,
-0.07548803836107254,
0.20611487329006195,
0.2761003375053406,
0.6068395972251892,
-0.20218691229820251,
0.6764435172080994,
0.46399256587028503,
0.09881602227687836,
-0.1258421242237091,
0.3763618767261505,
0.880721390247345,
-0.46788251399993896,
-0.3671111762523651,
-0.5272164344787598,
0.513791561126709,
0.06550336629152298,
-0.10174807906150818,
0.08729621767997742,
0.3116582930088043,
0.5253949165344238,
0.18493352830410004,
0.5426319241523743,
0.10805099457502365,
0.2837090790271759,
-0.4706387221813202,
0.48653486371040344,
-0.462883859872818,
0.34784507751464844,
-0.029351649805903435,
-0.9694353938102722,
0.09400492161512375,
0.3760167360305786,
-0.11789532750844955,
0.31670352816581726,
0.8807535171508789,
1.0221689939498901,
-0.14972683787345886,
-0.17336906492710114,
0.6718152165412903,
0.10991072654724121,
0.38081035017967224,
0.4850367605686188,
0.8405140042304993,
-0.2905145585536957,
0.6171399354934692,
0.02961898222565651,
-0.5279329419136047,
-0.03061549924314022,
-0.4124408960342407,
-1.1012628078460693,
-0.4862405061721802,
-0.15878702700138092,
-0.24254906177520752,
-0.07500958442687988,
0.9840015172958374,
0.7488284111022949,
-0.43470290303230286,
-0.5651683211326599,
-0.10772199183702469,
-0.025004994124174118,
-0.36941415071487427,
-0.30451545119285583,
0.1431131362915039,
-0.6095430254936218,
-0.6876905560493469,
0.4453578591346741,
0.30271977186203003,
-0.1867135614156723,
-0.4052731394767761,
-0.3861808180809021,
0.02561805583536625,
0.7035350203514099,
0.6952599287033081,
0.19423308968544006,
-0.9119450449943542,
-0.17848430573940277,
-0.34754323959350586,
-0.21772600710391998,
-0.24321091175079346,
0.8777674436569214,
-0.573419451713562,
0.20275072753429413,
0.14538657665252686,
0.7621662020683289,
0.5286189317703247,
0.02182699367403984,
0.6265652775764465,
-0.42586037516593933,
0.04028894007205963,
0.22986483573913574,
0.032836444675922394,
0.20727311074733734,
-0.5340423583984375,
0.38557618856430054,
0.13914479315280914,
-0.580238938331604,
-0.5074785351753235,
0.3099365234375,
-1.1947805881500244,
-0.305667519569397,
1.318081259727478,
0.05192644149065018,
-0.0036983874160796404,
-0.05369718745350838,
-0.3924253582954407,
0.25900155305862427,
-0.6913462281227112,
0.47669005393981934,
0.6159132719039917,
-0.3520362079143524,
-0.2851615250110626,
-0.44610947370529175,
0.6125695705413818,
0.2791350483894348,
-0.8336655497550964,
0.15506082773208618,
0.6129990816116333,
0.38258299231529236,
-0.027369022369384766,
0.717183530330658,
-0.24879564344882965,
0.3488096296787262,
-0.07932645082473755,
-0.23235413432121277,
-0.04434102773666382,
-0.4474624693393707,
-0.3896934688091278,
0.032526686787605286,
0.5217658281326294,
0.27050310373306274
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08656v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08656v1
|
TC-Bench: Benchmarking Temporal Compositionality in Text-to-Video and Image-to-Video Generation
| 2024-06-12T21:41:32 | 2024-06-12T21:41:32 |
Weixi Feng, Jiachen Li, Michael Saxon, Tsu-jui Fu, Wenhu Chen, William Yang Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Video generation has many unique challenges beyond those of image generation.
The temporal dimension introduces extensive possible variations across frames,
over which consistency and continuity may be violated. In this study, we move
beyond evaluating simple actions and argue that generated videos should
incorporate the emergence of new concepts and their relation transitions like
in real-world videos as time progresses. To assess the Temporal
Compositionality of video generation models, we propose TC-Bench, a benchmark
of meticulously crafted text prompts, corresponding ground truth videos, and
robust evaluation metrics. The prompts articulate the initial and final states
of scenes, effectively reducing ambiguities for frame development and
simplifying the assessment of transition completion. In addition, by collecting
aligned real-world videos corresponding to the prompts, we expand TC-Bench's
applicability from text-conditional models to image-conditional ones that can
perform generative frame interpolation. We also develop new metrics to measure
the completeness of component transitions in generated videos, which
demonstrate significantly higher correlations with human judgments than
existing metrics. Our comprehensive experimental results reveal that most video
generators achieve less than 20% of the compositional changes, highlighting
enormous space for future improvement. Our analysis indicates that current
video generation models struggle to interpret descriptions of compositional
changes and synthesize various components across different time steps.
|
[
-0.33117204904556274,
-0.6450307369232178,
0.7445744276046753,
0.3152642250061035,
-0.33398836851119995,
0.25098949670791626,
-0.201615110039711,
-0.017536848783493042,
-0.37082499265670776,
0.013124561868607998,
-0.8773790597915649,
-0.38304612040519714,
-0.5569109320640564,
0.04537218436598778,
-0.7106968760490417,
0.6478238105773926,
-0.41192811727523804,
0.03570781648159027,
-0.28957435488700867,
-0.031073331832885742,
-0.644564688205719,
0.19120542705059052,
-0.27093085646629333,
-0.21593308448791504,
0.06761772930622101,
0.2670871913433075,
0.4158037304878235,
0.8977366089820862,
0.3764878213405609,
0.26630842685699463,
0.20757995545864105,
0.06951864808797836,
-0.27447575330734253,
0.33812665939331055,
-0.08913547545671463,
-0.16118121147155762,
-0.09553556889295578,
0.11703022569417953,
0.9594806432723999,
0.4986479878425598,
0.09687976539134979,
0.5139958262443542,
0.04925059154629707,
0.41762736439704895,
-0.9653065204620361,
0.08414289355278015,
-0.5231801271438599,
0.6429169774055481,
-0.08101560920476913,
-0.4314050078392029,
-0.38965514302253723,
-0.30890730023384094,
0.047039974480867386,
-0.7091987729072571,
0.724169135093689,
-0.23149257898330688,
0.7587182521820068,
0.516485869884491,
-0.5250275135040283,
0.35641399025917053,
-0.8478841185569763,
0.5564833283424377,
-0.34232810139656067,
0.5445624589920044,
0.05711168050765991,
0.7256612777709961,
0.13388916850090027,
-1.0152214765548706,
-0.6949285864830017,
-0.33172187209129333,
0.3192436993122101,
0.3730323016643524,
-0.055802784860134125,
-0.17388395965099335,
0.5392389893531799,
0.37886843085289,
-0.5877065658569336,
-0.1366371363401413,
0.14186133444309235,
0.03462454676628113,
0.2450125366449356,
0.5561838150024414,
0.3781548738479614,
-0.4483857750892639,
-0.3592859208583832,
-0.6754706501960754,
-0.3316284716129303,
0.22376541793346405,
0.3818548917770386,
-0.16269725561141968,
-0.4518395662307739,
0.6768050789833069,
-0.33402758836746216,
0.6115888357162476,
0.2466239035129547,
-0.15307506918907166,
-0.1418348252773285,
-0.6328749656677246,
-0.30877619981765747,
0.05090954899787903,
0.7574484348297119,
0.8487809896469116,
-0.007772010751068592,
-0.12550590932369232,
0.15266720950603485,
0.37945985794067383,
0.2875515818595886,
-1.1633009910583496,
-0.10560570657253265,
-0.046090539544820786,
-0.31820154190063477,
-0.18821009993553162,
0.2869293987751007,
-0.6512621641159058,
-0.2535877823829651,
-0.4426009953022003,
0.3350706398487091,
-0.46473872661590576,
-0.24685640633106232,
-0.23067618906497955,
-0.37222781777381897,
0.47264227271080017,
0.2308945506811142,
-0.6298590898513794,
0.3797976076602936,
0.6538674831390381,
0.9517586827278137,
-0.20242007076740265,
-0.3226577043533325,
-0.753115713596344,
0.4197959303855896,
-0.5873851776123047,
0.7933326959609985,
-0.37607476115226746,
-0.3465055227279663,
0.1781294047832489,
0.165499746799469,
0.14383287727832794,
-0.4678927958011627,
0.3170635998249054,
-0.1580137014389038,
0.21876728534698486,
-0.35850441455841064,
-0.5441641807556152,
0.2700881361961365,
0.4912266135215759,
-0.5752533674240112,
0.9017031788825989,
0.16969025135040283,
-0.49678125977516174,
0.8004907369613647,
-0.2092326283454895,
-0.3040802776813507,
-0.022287702187895775,
-0.4650115370750427,
-0.32540783286094666,
0.2025497853755951,
-0.04073251783847809,
0.22022385895252228,
-0.5628801584243774,
0.5621169805526733,
-0.2078327238559723,
-0.2005891650915146,
0.5335245728492737,
-0.47674447298049927,
-0.03795634210109711,
0.3835075795650482,
-0.44618847966194153,
-0.1840129792690277,
-0.9351931214332581,
0.35717061161994934,
-0.29128819704055786,
0.07939654588699341,
0.28660598397254944,
0.20324458181858063,
0.13712474703788757,
0.17375707626342773,
-0.19380849599838257,
-0.6102421283721924,
-0.41408705711364746,
0.08946169167757034,
0.5652885437011719,
0.6898535490036011,
0.321369469165802,
0.25059744715690613,
-0.48538902401924133,
0.4761694669723511,
0.21321730315685272,
0.1342543214559555,
-0.5246163010597229,
-0.014488277956843376,
-0.4685894548892975,
0.13513067364692688,
0.17094649374485016,
0.10693308711051941,
-0.6147289872169495,
0.2839474081993103,
-0.5300817489624023,
-0.47313401103019714,
0.1459408700466156,
-0.17166611552238464,
0.45710045099258423,
0.8230400681495667,
0.2872024178504944,
-0.7927811145782471,
-0.4296395778656006,
-0.7889254689216614,
-0.04151202365756035,
-0.22085660696029663,
-0.2275715321302414,
0.0882631167769432,
0.10078445076942444,
0.2964206337928772,
1.050337553024292,
-0.5020028352737427,
0.2066669911146164,
0.21614989638328552,
0.4080793857574463,
-0.16414551436901093,
0.5476061701774597,
0.4578527510166168,
-0.7055999636650085,
-0.6964559555053711,
-0.059969462454319,
-0.8722819089889526,
-0.11432696878910065,
-0.32657378911972046,
0.03862515836954117,
-0.20117303729057312,
0.569849967956543,
-0.310302734375,
0.3494876027107239,
0.4856952130794525,
-0.1899818480014801,
0.6697396039962769,
-0.1400977224111557,
0.6932787895202637,
-0.952913761138916,
0.11067290604114532,
0.047375574707984924,
-0.10815654695034027,
-0.2724318504333496,
-0.18371514976024628,
-0.061303675174713135,
-0.530777633190155,
-0.6822775602340698,
0.4642033874988556,
-0.26026222109794617,
-0.34675517678260803,
-0.052537064999341965,
0.15311788022518158,
0.18476182222366333,
0.41534489393234253,
0.06549625843763351,
0.7280301451683044,
0.2732712924480438,
-0.6619150638580322,
0.12452366203069687,
0.29075729846954346,
-0.6636087894439697,
1.0959587097167969,
-0.707493007183075,
-0.16782774031162262,
-0.05426199361681938,
0.3789193630218506,
-1.0486189126968384,
-0.528901994228363,
-0.16335031390190125,
-0.462375283241272,
0.14886334538459778,
-0.26083245873451233,
-0.5079966187477112,
0.057322826236486435,
-0.24081169068813324,
0.6609920859336853,
0.5081830620765686,
-0.17461630702018738,
0.41530266404151917,
-0.030591167509555817,
0.019024042412638664,
-0.3997100293636322,
-0.8105037212371826,
0.2623623311519623,
-0.08703506737947464,
-0.8161423802375793,
0.9382485747337341,
-0.36972370743751526,
-0.22678904235363007,
0.22146940231323242,
-0.37751972675323486,
-0.1883503645658493,
-0.33805233240127563,
0.31140777468681335,
-0.06188356131315231,
-0.23006102442741394,
-0.08348040282726288,
0.06314428895711899,
0.041071098297834396,
0.06962127238512039,
-0.02291889302432537,
0.4691929817199707,
0.2604447305202484,
-0.23734474182128906,
-0.4177567660808563,
0.4606246054172516,
0.41400715708732605,
-0.06511219590902328,
0.19219204783439636,
0.817920982837677,
-0.2996705174446106,
-0.10135731846094131,
-0.5822174549102783,
0.007541057653725147,
-0.4452149271965027,
0.3438311219215393,
-0.31952834129333496,
-0.46722397208213806,
0.3787149488925934,
0.028233522549271584,
-0.04836196079850197,
0.3794914782047272,
0.5533111095428467,
-0.18404671549797058,
0.9348804354667664,
0.34458354115486145,
0.7908845543861389,
1.00230073928833,
-0.5431014895439148,
-0.34916308522224426,
-0.7712669968605042,
-0.17310446500778198,
-0.19219446182250977,
-0.4528980255126953,
-0.7064526677131653,
-0.32775670289993286,
0.6005446910858154,
-0.24161948263645172,
-0.8007943630218506,
0.47194695472717285,
-0.17828382551670074,
0.6064255833625793,
0.24110114574432373,
0.26936665177345276,
0.22990581393241882,
-0.07438917458057404,
-0.09505341947078705,
-0.42986392974853516,
-0.3233780562877655,
-0.25104382634162903,
0.8867017030715942,
-0.16491711139678955,
0.4249333441257477,
0.25310218334198,
0.3947976231575012,
0.6601032018661499,
0.036420539021492004,
-0.4629381597042084,
0.7094918489456177,
-0.4710454046726227,
-0.2705337703227997,
0.14509230852127075,
-0.26226627826690674,
-0.6557244062423706,
-0.24301892518997192,
-0.4788450002670288,
-0.42943868041038513,
0.05308940261602402,
0.0536530502140522,
-0.25357839465141296,
0.21625544130802155,
-0.623626708984375,
1.0556789636611938,
-0.17955653369426727,
-0.9601847529411316,
-0.23147495090961456,
-0.7743197679519653,
0.3913465440273285,
0.11752470582723618,
-0.14593085646629333,
-0.2066478729248047,
0.01026662066578865,
0.4459913969039917,
-0.7177197933197021,
0.6177776455879211,
-0.11996889114379883,
0.3114423155784607,
0.5378797650337219,
0.3311190605163574,
0.11062334477901459,
0.14386621117591858,
0.3534664809703827,
-0.45901837944984436,
0.09114255756139755,
-0.20515094697475433,
-0.677783191204071,
0.511143147945404,
-0.7138240933418274,
-0.332872211933136,
-0.23182819783687592,
-0.3438209891319275,
-0.444332480430603,
0.10856994241476059,
0.5070046782493591,
0.7192187309265137,
-0.633709728717804,
0.42732635140419006,
0.51533442735672,
-0.1501748412847519,
0.7543745040893555,
0.3961150646209717,
0.257034033536911,
-0.6771525144577026,
0.6381362676620483,
-0.05436497926712036,
0.4310556948184967,
0.6173623204231262,
0.13716663420200348,
-0.28520211577415466,
-0.3496009111404419,
-0.48265159130096436,
-0.14367148280143738,
-0.6728801131248474,
-0.2916000187397003,
-0.296658456325531,
-0.2739877998828888,
-0.33528727293014526,
-0.16117997467517853,
-0.43905314803123474,
-0.38124915957450867,
0.02487829700112343,
-0.23199310898780823,
0.09925183653831482,
0.15559908747673035,
-0.01241467148065567,
0.44705042243003845,
-0.944826602935791,
0.45604419708251953,
0.7273626327514648,
0.4284422993659973,
-0.07773911952972412,
-0.4760262370109558,
-0.18272414803504944,
-0.28182798624038696,
-0.8028662204742432,
-0.7066941261291504,
0.01081373542547226,
0.29288941621780396,
0.5106887221336365,
0.1417291909456253,
-0.09809375554323196,
0.8869319558143616,
-0.5680785179138184,
1.2032703161239624,
0.5353134870529175,
-1.101580023765564,
0.5368945002555847,
-0.5591965317726135,
0.4941850006580353,
0.6290649771690369,
0.01564427651464939,
-0.632648766040802,
-0.06658431887626648,
-0.7729923725128174,
-0.5710055232048035,
0.42484721541404724,
0.22898977994918823,
0.10463564097881317,
-0.05204714834690094,
0.09124506264925003,
0.14756330847740173,
0.16707448661327362,
-0.6634950041770935,
0.19943130016326904,
-0.6162376999855042,
-0.009116272442042828,
0.0527474582195282,
0.14782188832759857,
-0.15569347143173218,
0.11935462057590485,
0.10513249039649963,
-0.058524373918771744,
-0.11234904825687408,
0.2942313253879547,
-0.1842232495546341,
-0.44285115599632263,
0.3507087528705597,
0.5277235507965088,
0.619292676448822,
-0.3189256489276886,
0.07017183303833008,
-0.18394210934638977,
-0.34740012884140015,
0.6023423075675964,
-0.09021885693073273,
-0.3629583716392517,
0.019076881930232048,
0.4056503474712372,
0.8038272261619568,
0.3929496705532074,
-0.7175838351249695,
0.5937691926956177,
-0.10434101521968842,
-0.2843897342681885,
-0.4038790166378021,
0.1401940882205963,
-0.5100716352462769,
0.21656426787376404,
0.2487146407365799,
0.09908053278923035,
0.04433077573776245,
-0.7838647365570068,
0.3567546606063843,
0.019805708900094032,
-0.4749354124069214,
-0.5912417769432068,
1.0363953113555908,
0.13054589927196503,
-0.256069540977478,
0.4079849421977997,
-0.2241421788930893,
-0.015848049893975258,
0.6934625506401062,
0.30915260314941406,
1.2897132635116577,
0.13476930558681488,
0.653149425983429,
0.706407368183136,
-0.04291820153594017,
-0.2891858220100403,
0.02170017920434475,
-0.48642662167549133,
-0.48681405186653137,
-0.41826656460762024,
-0.3321029841899872,
-0.594830334186554,
-0.09604424238204956,
-0.7418762445449829,
0.47135600447654724,
-0.5461962819099426,
-0.4365996718406677,
-0.042547136545181274,
-0.07430027425289154,
-0.8627116084098816,
0.44795405864715576,
0.0938517302274704,
0.7669788599014282,
-0.910807728767395,
0.4569670259952545,
0.3456035256385803,
-0.6074315309524536,
-0.5036161541938782,
0.10897935181856155,
-0.043080318719148636,
-0.37586888670921326,
0.6226345896720886,
0.19149017333984375,
-0.014742591418325901,
-0.18396776914596558,
-0.4561752676963806,
-0.2841877341270447,
1.31378173828125,
0.4795036315917969,
-0.2719968259334564,
-0.10670486092567444,
0.3098486661911011,
0.6523944139480591,
-0.28401899337768555,
0.2755521535873413,
0.48361000418663025,
0.43668580055236816,
0.3851397931575775,
-0.5238995552062988,
-0.09715118259191513,
-0.3593667447566986,
0.08451183140277863,
0.16451238095760345,
-0.6906375288963318,
0.9632798433303833,
0.015224405564367771,
-0.5917546153068542,
0.34664037823677063,
0.5334102511405945,
0.2860702574253082,
0.6901847124099731,
0.6117565631866455,
0.6992029547691345,
0.049472663551568985,
-0.25548627972602844,
0.8661280274391174,
-0.31955486536026,
-0.08349025249481201,
1.2628554105758667,
-0.26445239782333374,
0.5980948805809021,
0.37172698974609375,
-0.3008713126182556,
0.6551061272621155,
0.5662943124771118,
-0.2549575865268707,
0.6798883080482483,
0.12804821133613586,
-0.27497243881225586,
-0.4497022032737732,
-0.46762675046920776,
-0.3833372890949249,
0.5214108824729919,
0.06283329427242279,
-0.19093163311481476,
-0.35623523592948914,
-0.16824159026145935,
-0.37374159693717957,
0.5205344557762146,
0.013064638711512089,
0.7047999501228333,
-0.21946226060390472,
-1.0703438520431519,
0.15275122225284576,
-0.26425454020500183,
0.09410789608955383,
-0.8293136358261108,
-0.05508926510810852,
-0.3823625445365906,
0.026286037638783455,
-0.05929437652230263,
-0.8322978019714355,
0.044791772961616516,
0.39114710688591003,
-0.30165085196495056,
-0.3505011200904846,
-0.0017850310541689396,
-0.40411731600761414,
-0.32336869835853577,
-0.1620320975780487,
0.47490277886390686,
-0.18277736008167267,
0.09517434984445572,
-0.3592182397842407,
0.1760830283164978,
-0.3728305399417877,
0.1949305683374405,
0.21920762956142426,
0.6200551390647888,
-0.1148281916975975,
0.16799503564834595,
0.3389778733253479,
-0.0828479677438736,
0.08200865983963013,
0.2501014769077301,
0.5115067958831787,
-0.8365329504013062,
-0.46658432483673096,
-0.6853575110435486,
0.5283939242362976,
-0.18136490881443024,
-0.41892269253730774,
0.46407774090766907,
0.7524374723434448,
0.8566311597824097,
-0.11225482821464539,
0.7451323866844177,
-0.3115530014038086,
0.011459260247647762,
-0.8305173516273499,
0.190337136387825,
-0.5096161961555481,
0.08482600003480911,
-0.4658801257610321,
-1.2179956436157227,
0.15595129132270813,
-0.09041015803813934,
0.04134038835763931,
-0.10113877803087234,
0.9461577534675598,
0.546572208404541,
-0.2327198088169098,
0.0144343925639987,
0.14902932941913605,
-0.038205835968256,
0.544928252696991,
0.6104912161827087,
1.0699608325958252,
-0.6533645987510681,
0.8079289197921753,
-0.3563096821308136,
-0.027353087440133095,
0.2695182263851166,
-1.4134516716003418,
-0.3775971531867981,
-0.8196558356285095,
-0.575667679309845,
-0.18056854605674744,
-0.015411758795380592,
0.5940535068511963,
0.788032591342926,
-0.43798354268074036,
-0.45177173614501953,
-0.25559791922569275,
-0.43716174364089966,
-0.43021342158317566,
-0.2276836335659027,
0.17322061955928802,
-0.18045562505722046,
-0.811096727848053,
0.32124611735343933,
0.14197522401809692,
0.21336063742637634,
-0.4047339856624603,
0.08281248807907104,
0.2673572599887848,
-0.14817126095294952,
0.4898073375225067,
0.3674270808696747,
-0.4853830933570862,
-0.49332529306411743,
0.24146902561187744,
0.12654902040958405,
0.29157087206840515,
1.3270518779754639,
-0.7648328542709351,
0.7805503606796265,
0.7860161662101746,
0.449717253446579,
1.101122260093689,
0.13133983314037323,
0.8958365321159363,
-1.1808730363845825,
0.2253752201795578,
-0.052130721509456635,
0.4349033236503601,
0.5773891806602478,
0.21002496778964996,
0.7443729043006897,
0.38854193687438965,
-0.34887605905532837,
-0.891965925693512,
0.3482869863510132,
-1.3671149015426636,
-0.06697873771190643,
0.7217095494270325,
0.09726908057928085,
-0.052319370210170746,
0.5035371780395508,
0.1891721934080124,
0.5936199426651001,
-0.16941624879837036,
0.826482892036438,
0.6922866106033325,
-0.0017294723074883223,
-0.17079785466194153,
-0.4894272983074188,
0.2987259030342102,
0.23743785917758942,
-0.7191097140312195,
-0.0040923552587628365,
0.7246086001396179,
0.27830323576927185,
-0.04829243943095207,
0.5451757311820984,
-0.22212103009223938,
0.6383330821990967,
0.3439036011695862,
-0.30497977137565613,
-0.16350914537906647,
-0.2521088421344757,
0.11396633833646774,
0.1305028349161148,
-0.38656380772590637,
-0.21640412509441376
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10289v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10289v2
|
VeraCT Scan: Retrieval-Augmented Fake News Detection with Justifiable Reasoning
| 2024-06-12T21:23:48 | 2024-06-24T23:53:05 |
Cheng Niu, Yang Guan, Yuanhao Wu, Juno Zhu, Juntong Song, Randy Zhong, Kaihua Zhu, Siliang Xu, Shizhe Diao, Tong Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
The proliferation of fake news poses a significant threat not only by
disseminating misleading information but also by undermining the very
foundations of democracy. The recent advance of generative artificial
intelligence has further exacerbated the challenge of distinguishing genuine
news from fabricated stories. In response to this challenge, we introduce
VeraCT Scan, a novel retrieval-augmented system for fake news detection. This
system operates by extracting the core facts from a given piece of news and
subsequently conducting an internet-wide search to identify corroborating or
conflicting reports. Then sources' credibility is leveraged for information
verification. Besides determining the veracity of news, we also provide
transparent evidence and reasoning to support its conclusions, resulting in the
interpretability and trust in the results. In addition to GPT-4 Turbo, Llama-2
13B is also fine-tuned for news content understanding, information
verification, and reasoning. Both implementations have demonstrated
state-of-the-art accuracy in the realm of fake news detection.
|
[
-0.31294235587120056,
-1.1726057529449463,
1.0385273694992065,
0.14985591173171997,
-0.5099497437477112,
0.5087534785270691,
0.5547557473182678,
-0.5233181715011597,
0.4928727149963379,
0.4201289713382721,
-0.5130902528762817,
-0.3416491150856018,
-0.27382609248161316,
0.14596962928771973,
-0.8428687453269958,
0.7261130809783936,
0.09991135448217392,
-0.10830290615558624,
-0.10639588534832001,
0.09068615734577179,
-0.38016340136528015,
-0.3194583058357239,
-0.22408464550971985,
-0.09225352853536606,
0.3823215365409851,
0.4652537405490875,
0.637468695640564,
0.5605984926223755,
0.1412573754787445,
0.25282052159309387,
0.12290769815444946,
0.6386549472808838,
-0.4203188717365265,
-0.08236295729875565,
-0.3359949290752411,
-0.3815983533859253,
-0.013831762596964836,
0.1695375144481659,
0.6432322263717651,
-0.1317472904920578,
-0.18303589522838593,
-0.09434442222118378,
-0.3864685297012329,
0.4422158896923065,
-0.6133171916007996,
-0.3340895473957062,
-0.8551640510559082,
-0.331559419631958,
-0.32022249698638916,
-0.3289129137992859,
-0.31573495268821716,
-0.6729229092597961,
-0.3231998085975647,
-0.7048968076705933,
0.4279041588306427,
0.06557796150445938,
1.351985216140747,
0.2726282775402069,
-0.5220323801040649,
-0.33665749430656433,
-0.7797631025314331,
0.39772430062294006,
-0.02525407448410988,
0.3674503564834595,
0.4726954400539398,
0.37916097044944763,
-0.1080009713768959,
-0.8435000777244568,
-1.0527830123901367,
-0.3109602630138397,
0.173578679561615,
0.2087487131357193,
-0.28340110182762146,
-0.09061894565820694,
-0.011671775951981544,
0.37582629919052124,
-0.6049860119819641,
-0.33202874660491943,
-0.3774554431438446,
-0.6704428195953369,
0.45518213510513306,
-0.19244444370269775,
0.3698003590106964,
-0.3722167909145355,
-0.5731304287910461,
0.032152608036994934,
-0.8344489932060242,
-0.517510175704956,
0.4673708379268646,
-0.14211587607860565,
0.23276706039905548,
0.4703674018383026,
-0.5557533502578735,
0.5358291864395142,
0.19553986191749573,
-0.18352381885051727,
0.1263495236635208,
-0.5638222694396973,
-0.2491275817155838,
0.41298046708106995,
0.5169131755828857,
-0.0565057136118412,
-0.3961654305458069,
0.19821538031101227,
-0.3311665952205658,
0.4721251428127289,
0.5438387989997864,
-0.395030677318573,
0.018505161628127098,
0.12392149865627289,
-0.3090795576572418,
-0.6745133399963379,
0.17264974117279053,
-0.4113537073135376,
-0.49891945719718933,
-0.18442343175411224,
0.8369585275650024,
-0.4126763343811035,
-0.3314952254295349,
0.10193163901567459,
-0.36869826912879944,
0.45823004841804504,
0.7852469086647034,
-0.056447356939315796,
0.028087249025702477,
0.874631941318512,
0.8564170002937317,
0.1936320960521698,
-0.12200184166431427,
-0.7870373725891113,
-0.11934241652488708,
-0.7542505264282227,
1.3604729175567627,
-0.3993974030017853,
-0.3792707324028015,
-0.10114973038434982,
-0.13200213015079498,
0.3236519694328308,
-0.4755653142929077,
0.9435105919837952,
-0.7618554830551147,
0.014061590656638145,
-0.6885152459144592,
-0.2238536775112152,
-0.1284104585647583,
0.6493564248085022,
-0.7963175177574158,
1.2935791015625,
0.2866981327533722,
-0.8168063759803772,
0.4274761974811554,
-0.2097569853067398,
-0.44637665152549744,
0.20589414238929749,
0.005272609181702137,
-0.45571398735046387,
0.06109366938471794,
0.21781840920448303,
0.028265714645385742,
0.023073241114616394,
0.07515992224216461,
-0.10502401739358902,
-0.6444072127342224,
0.23155204951763153,
-0.5524969696998596,
0.6713065505027771,
0.41840580105781555,
-0.3069102466106415,
-0.004483259283006191,
-0.5236257314682007,
-0.2949487566947937,
0.1722770631313324,
-0.22105439007282257,
-0.36047157645225525,
-0.003189162816852331,
-0.29942741990089417,
0.027885910123586655,
0.27160102128982544,
-0.8491724133491516,
0.2720026969909668,
-0.24437156319618225,
0.06406927108764648,
0.6678064465522766,
-0.011216651648283005,
0.2171730250120163,
-0.4799986481666565,
0.1701013445854187,
-0.13521461188793182,
0.38318589329719543,
-0.06565099954605103,
-0.5217708945274353,
-0.6360902786254883,
-0.687441349029541,
0.20192229747772217,
0.6877071857452393,
-1.2735543251037598,
0.18897566199302673,
-0.23801836371421814,
-0.5206385850906372,
-0.6831063032150269,
-0.10621894150972366,
0.13003893196582794,
0.7603948712348938,
0.3817335069179535,
0.0169071014970541,
-0.689350426197052,
-0.7251483798027039,
-0.43603479862213135,
-0.4517326056957245,
0.0879029631614685,
-0.15527845919132233,
0.6398199200630188,
-0.3327923119068146,
1.1033978462219238,
-0.16146689653396606,
-0.19622336328029633,
-0.16290904581546783,
0.2021627575159073,
0.2915269732475281,
-0.02145310677587986,
0.3937886357307434,
-1.2745740413665771,
-0.23497441411018372,
0.10762898623943329,
-0.6088252067565918,
-0.263390451669693,
-0.32815366983413696,
-0.18926459550857544,
0.42848509550094604,
0.16020908951759338,
-0.9798428416252136,
0.8828960657119751,
0.29323601722717285,
-0.4869750738143921,
0.9183951020240784,
-0.2472403645515442,
0.4852599799633026,
-0.7456361055374146,
-0.03909626975655556,
-0.1845167726278305,
-0.7255435585975647,
-0.5881942510604858,
0.026937153190374374,
0.298395574092865,
0.3097062408924103,
-0.44492852687835693,
0.44389939308166504,
-0.15498444437980652,
-0.22771450877189636,
-0.6317486763000488,
0.027472175657749176,
0.40441858768463135,
-0.3475342392921448,
-0.013174514286220074,
0.8390711545944214,
0.07753603905439377,
-0.4631691873073578,
0.8178538084030151,
0.02790972590446472,
-0.3727478086948395,
0.7446989417076111,
-0.5894484519958496,
0.10954661667346954,
-0.20231714844703674,
0.6169335246086121,
-1.0295652151107788,
-0.3644986152648926,
0.3236085772514343,
-0.986044704914093,
-0.022135969251394272,
-0.0917762964963913,
-0.8828708529472351,
-0.4814044237136841,
-0.6129096746444702,
-0.023606061935424805,
0.2257455289363861,
-1.0197010040283203,
0.8059524297714233,
0.1892530471086502,
0.2876203954219818,
-0.7498528361320496,
-0.504401683807373,
0.24477528035640717,
0.17989617586135864,
-0.58098965883255,
0.4865506887435913,
0.05715269595384598,
-0.26782914996147156,
0.27090099453926086,
-0.5618254542350769,
-0.21977877616882324,
0.09223206341266632,
0.03617300093173981,
0.6035473346710205,
-0.024400215595960617,
0.03838657587766647,
0.4292145371437073,
0.055498119443655014,
-0.10507791489362717,
-0.0903339758515358,
0.44624239206314087,
-0.2854146361351013,
-0.437981516122818,
-0.5770443081855774,
0.22072668373584747,
0.6112862229347229,
-0.21603596210479736,
0.651319682598114,
0.6612274050712585,
-0.5274907350540161,
-0.297402560710907,
-0.957321286201477,
-0.10248640179634094,
-0.5159194469451904,
0.07268345355987549,
-0.33684927225112915,
-0.7462934255599976,
0.3210033178329468,
-0.01942780241370201,
-0.3213459849357605,
0.4777774512767792,
0.6403239369392395,
-0.07536916434764862,
0.9175005555152893,
0.36155006289482117,
-0.20464041829109192,
0.294025719165802,
-0.02327537164092064,
0.04619212448596954,
-0.29446935653686523,
-0.5117292404174805,
-0.47233298420906067,
0.19671285152435303,
-0.27419933676719666,
-0.5787706971168518,
0.3242679238319397,
-0.062026966363191605,
-0.18473689258098602,
0.006769503466784954,
-0.7267010807991028,
0.6921879053115845,
0.5268784761428833,
0.20554202795028687,
0.5297272205352783,
0.09988706558942795,
-0.022880740463733673,
0.5043109655380249,
-0.2710891664028168,
-0.3665649890899658,
0.8220595717430115,
0.14117836952209473,
0.7460620999336243,
0.1440405696630478,
0.5670311450958252,
0.9726405739784241,
0.46489670872688293,
-0.7325244545936584,
0.5197059512138367,
0.20812301337718964,
-0.9254140853881836,
0.06618617475032806,
-0.45209822058677673,
-0.7755445837974548,
0.29048246145248413,
-0.09503564238548279,
-0.3382963240146637,
0.2009614109992981,
-0.00645619397982955,
-0.24164196848869324,
0.33724552392959595,
-0.5607782006263733,
0.20459818840026855,
-0.1858297735452652,
-0.35522571206092834,
-0.661842405796051,
-0.4900782108306885,
0.4756794273853302,
-0.27101629972457886,
0.35717907547950745,
-0.12032828480005264,
-0.045312218368053436,
0.19490349292755127,
-0.42530253529548645,
0.7253137230873108,
-0.03734607249498367,
0.16987518966197968,
0.5918965935707092,
0.39808130264282227,
0.4361015260219574,
0.4696435034275055,
0.16136498749256134,
0.14074330031871796,
0.12270975112915039,
-0.4752715229988098,
-0.19073189795017242,
0.8364481925964355,
-0.753178060054779,
-0.7118794322013855,
-0.9703284502029419,
-0.31814050674438477,
0.3075663447380066,
0.36218011379241943,
0.15840508043766022,
-0.054230865091085434,
-0.4889819025993347,
-0.22503097355365753,
0.8940443396568298,
-0.12792901694774628,
0.14468154311180115,
0.7304859757423401,
-0.23319759964942932,
-0.294870525598526,
1.0595922470092773,
0.09034354239702225,
-0.11891520768404007,
0.4589354395866394,
0.2685973644256592,
-0.6004049777984619,
-0.2151256501674652,
-0.4305630028247833,
0.5343576073646545,
-0.587152361869812,
-0.35415560007095337,
-0.35466524958610535,
-0.25237056612968445,
-0.3944850564002991,
-0.03900061175227165,
-0.49916917085647583,
-0.24724313616752625,
-0.35259711742401123,
-0.2049504667520523,
0.2836769223213196,
0.8386606574058533,
-0.4936808943748474,
0.10035295784473419,
-0.6828498244285583,
0.9386385679244995,
0.5811598896980286,
-0.057552821934223175,
-0.7526943683624268,
-0.5369493961334229,
-0.006881836336106062,
0.1820390522480011,
-0.3803911805152893,
-1.2557247877120972,
0.414768248796463,
-0.1484127789735794,
0.5908210873603821,
0.42600879073143005,
0.18220752477645874,
0.30193281173706055,
-0.20831549167633057,
0.7302675247192383,
-0.1751832813024521,
-1.163912296295166,
0.7489099502563477,
-0.436659574508667,
-0.1836068481206894,
0.2939428985118866,
0.5268802046775818,
-0.2978009879589081,
0.011692211031913757,
-0.5192784070968628,
-0.2926277220249176,
0.597149670124054,
0.04272843524813652,
0.04622125253081322,
-0.06666003912687302,
0.42688730359077454,
0.07939185947179794,
0.08995738625526428,
-0.4312339425086975,
0.10981067270040512,
-0.706997811794281,
-0.18667857348918915,
0.5936141014099121,
-0.4603642523288727,
-0.2868609130382538,
-0.39995482563972473,
0.6778903007507324,
-0.17980626225471497,
0.6315389275550842,
0.6921733021736145,
-0.3478889465332031,
0.0019735319074243307,
-0.008251553401350975,
0.7298986911773682,
0.6122521758079529,
-0.2289862483739853,
0.3305412232875824,
0.062123145908117294,
-0.756858229637146,
0.1300351321697235,
0.25108322501182556,
-0.2214537113904953,
0.27683788537979126,
0.18285371363162994,
0.38669368624687195,
-0.46334677934646606,
-0.5397061705589294,
0.8447612524032593,
-0.19820332527160645,
-0.4042814373970032,
-0.525002658367157,
-0.09846105426549911,
-0.13750089704990387,
0.23930960893630981,
0.8232200741767883,
0.07323015481233597,
0.3237116038799286,
-0.7372103333473206,
0.25749722123146057,
0.49727973341941833,
-0.1105581596493721,
-0.5032902359962463,
0.6224015951156616,
0.13023029267787933,
-0.06741268932819366,
0.7447741627693176,
-0.32275089621543884,
-0.8761629462242126,
0.643625020980835,
0.4745144546031952,
0.4786040484905243,
-0.5589069128036499,
0.8275779485702515,
0.026918631047010422,
0.862964928150177,
-0.36217281222343445,
0.43416231870651245,
-0.15132150053977966,
-1.064077377319336,
-0.5758337378501892,
-0.4943943917751312,
-0.5336908102035522,
0.06921155750751495,
-0.3352564871311188,
0.270079106092453,
-0.49129724502563477,
0.0638405829668045,
-0.1948200762271881,
0.32516801357269287,
-0.3102596700191498,
0.27187809348106384,
0.4585742652416229,
1.0028729438781738,
-0.9007720947265625,
0.9645386934280396,
0.46135035157203674,
-0.2800562083721161,
-0.3804939389228821,
0.04610200226306915,
0.48271268606185913,
-1.0274994373321533,
0.3466193675994873,
0.2767145335674286,
-0.3119560480117798,
-0.058353934437036514,
-0.8329736590385437,
-0.7720945477485657,
1.0128892660140991,
0.5209087133407593,
-0.2786467373371124,
0.03630293533205986,
0.15724965929985046,
0.2022033929824829,
0.06336814910173416,
0.27701976895332336,
0.704546332359314,
0.6354644298553467,
0.2530413568019867,
-0.7843021750450134,
0.10343649238348007,
-0.04644130542874336,
-0.2495262324810028,
0.05831589177250862,
-0.7139929533004761,
0.7250298261642456,
-0.13414807617664337,
-0.3616413474082947,
0.08413756638765335,
0.71698397397995,
0.43618109822273254,
0.7759889364242554,
0.4126320481300354,
0.6472997069358826,
1.0874953269958496,
-0.34843435883522034,
1.3245826959609985,
0.059255339205265045,
0.23639191687107086,
0.4971957504749298,
-0.17929212749004364,
0.5583268404006958,
0.20488640666007996,
0.08764860033988953,
0.7246555685997009,
0.7653993368148804,
0.010664825327694416,
0.5637224912643433,
-0.284670889377594,
-0.7270550727844238,
-0.3887302875518799,
-0.2829780876636505,
-0.24366767704486847,
0.4061615765094757,
0.8310370445251465,
0.058107342571020126,
-0.2687147855758667,
0.035849109292030334,
0.11658026278018951,
-0.0025549682322889566,
-0.46519365906715393,
0.2495443969964981,
-0.1622270941734314,
-0.3216896057128906,
0.6381520628929138,
0.11914076656103134,
0.6669485569000244,
-0.6327638030052185,
-0.2987838387489319,
-0.3665716052055359,
-0.016417620703577995,
-0.3471911549568176,
-0.8095000386238098,
0.39136800169944763,
-0.008654964156448841,
-0.025840122252702713,
-0.09250549972057343,
1.3593748807907104,
0.014557437039911747,
-0.24632389843463898,
0.04483865574002266,
0.5751785635948181,
-0.04002782329916954,
-0.6076790690422058,
-0.49430418014526367,
0.41071632504463196,
0.04299444332718849,
-0.3263126313686371,
-0.00826230552047491,
0.36958467960357666,
-0.1363871842622757,
0.6955441832542419,
1.024875283241272,
0.1444437950849533,
0.06261182576417923,
-0.17325137555599213,
1.2081825733184814,
-0.5472428202629089,
-0.38192445039749146,
-0.7012679576873779,
0.12942256033420563,
-0.3074486553668976,
0.021026482805609703,
0.6830422282218933,
0.6734548211097717,
0.6148710250854492,
0.24444378912448883,
0.8393867611885071,
0.02498415671288967,
0.7815797328948975,
-0.31600669026374817,
0.8053840398788452,
-0.5829018354415894,
0.25710630416870117,
0.11446104198694229,
-0.7330902218818665,
-0.2266068160533905,
0.6857659816741943,
-0.16064487397670746,
-0.1512848436832428,
0.7182701826095581,
1.0191047191619873,
-0.11306850612163544,
-0.09424353390932083,
0.3808307945728302,
0.3316429555416107,
0.37411972880363464,
0.08432464301586151,
1.277806043624878,
-0.21567703783512115,
0.6667670607566833,
-0.06612759828567505,
-0.28725260496139526,
-0.4885355532169342,
-0.577089250087738,
-0.6563311219215393,
-0.43374261260032654,
-0.0708257406949997,
-0.681178092956543,
0.2417561560869217,
0.31748661398887634,
0.6346644759178162,
-0.2040124386548996,
0.39297226071357727,
-0.17133694887161255,
0.5807079076766968,
0.04318830743432045,
-0.31124454736709595,
0.32653144001960754,
0.03932772949337959,
-0.5240141153335571,
0.841587483882904,
0.30832943320274353,
-0.1832025647163391,
-0.15912176668643951,
-0.030254734680056572,
-0.3202030062675476,
0.7141027450561523,
0.5322629809379578,
0.621141791343689,
-0.632102906703949,
-0.5155149698257446,
0.09658952057361603,
-0.2310996651649475,
0.004528719931840897,
0.45746833086013794,
-1.4460124969482422,
0.5476081967353821,
0.6367143988609314,
0.6009306311607361,
0.6908010840415955,
0.25143975019454956,
-0.05336052551865578,
-0.6164284944534302,
0.11845823377370834,
0.3020164966583252,
-0.005533860996365547,
0.30094701051712036,
-0.6169832944869995,
0.4009402394294739,
0.7898910641670227,
-0.6070201992988586,
-1.068905234336853,
0.08892227709293365,
-1.161144495010376,
-0.49919185042381287,
1.0285255908966064,
0.3994719088077545,
-0.661653459072113,
-0.45662206411361694,
-0.464580237865448,
0.27923494577407837,
-0.42485859990119934,
0.8121680617332458,
0.3127884268760681,
0.07786253839731216,
-0.06821329891681671,
-0.39723044633865356,
0.28054478764533997,
0.17520588636398315,
-0.8791755437850952,
-0.5761050581932068,
0.6472612023353577,
0.5180813074111938,
0.15803208947181702,
0.8633946776390076,
-0.05228639021515846,
0.8136727213859558,
0.29168692231178284,
-0.055891506373882294,
-0.20015521347522736,
-0.41988614201545715,
0.056991610676050186,
-0.1468823105096817,
-0.23718686401844025,
-0.2520913779735565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08641v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08641v1
|
ML-SUPERB 2.0: Benchmarking Multilingual Speech Models Across Modeling Constraints, Languages, and Datasets
| 2024-06-12T21:01:26 | 2024-06-12T21:01:26 |
Jiatong Shi, Shih-Heng Wang, William Chen, Martijn Bartelds, Vanya Bannihatti Kumar, Jinchuan Tian, Xuankai Chang, Dan Jurafsky, Karen Livescu, Hung-yi Lee, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
ML-SUPERB evaluates self-supervised learning (SSL) models on the tasks of
language identification and automatic speech recognition (ASR). This benchmark
treats the models as feature extractors and uses a single shallow downstream
model, which can be fine-tuned for a downstream task. However, real-world use
cases may require different configurations. This paper presents ML-SUPERB~2.0,
which is a new benchmark for evaluating pre-trained SSL and supervised speech
models across downstream models, fine-tuning setups, and efficient model
adaptation approaches. We find performance improvements over the setup of
ML-SUPERB. However, performance depends on the downstream model design. Also,
we find large performance differences between languages and datasets,
suggesting the need for more targeted approaches to improve multilingual ASR
performance.
|
[
-0.3499178886413574,
-0.3664315640926361,
-0.02878125198185444,
0.14350304007530212,
-0.10057316720485687,
0.13558632135391235,
-0.20428118109703064,
-0.5445947051048279,
-0.2581668794155121,
0.5531665086746216,
-0.6652604937553406,
-0.2642078101634979,
-0.6043234467506409,
0.21688731014728546,
-0.35869884490966797,
0.9088872671127319,
0.17135930061340332,
0.4516950249671936,
-0.0868922621011734,
-0.24546192586421967,
-0.23703883588314056,
-0.8217042684555054,
-0.6317976713180542,
-0.24930930137634277,
0.3953722417354584,
0.17489978671073914,
0.47789835929870605,
0.6160103678703308,
0.7035807371139526,
0.2630798816680908,
-0.022921975702047348,
0.2245824784040451,
-0.39432546496391296,
0.18002097308635712,
-0.39940109848976135,
-0.20155680179595947,
-0.29332834482192993,
-0.03132738545536995,
0.8524044752120972,
0.5828889012336731,
0.026906045153737068,
0.5483731031417847,
0.14772850275039673,
0.7163975238800049,
-0.7872151136398315,
0.204819917678833,
-0.5889244675636292,
0.034836072474718094,
-0.2179507464170456,
0.06460544466972351,
-0.11299604922533035,
-0.21330367028713226,
0.17259205877780914,
-0.4381208121776581,
0.400869756937027,
-0.3260062634944916,
0.8991339206695557,
0.58514004945755,
-0.3700622618198395,
-0.1568123996257782,
-0.7312727570533752,
0.7035297751426697,
-0.644218385219574,
0.8636469841003418,
0.19417379796504974,
0.6309159398078918,
0.22510233521461487,
-0.7966526746749878,
-0.28656989336013794,
-0.18411490321159363,
0.00936350878328085,
0.10525780916213989,
-0.2341049760580063,
-0.29796335101127625,
0.22135215997695923,
0.4306465983390808,
-0.6090413331985474,
0.3969225287437439,
-0.3992586135864258,
-0.325613409280777,
0.9139094948768616,
0.01846848614513874,
-0.088820680975914,
0.06495939940214157,
-0.18963856995105743,
-0.11485578864812851,
-0.7364332675933838,
0.10731405019760132,
0.3997149169445038,
0.9683204889297485,
-0.2900982201099396,
0.33105140924453735,
-0.4857976734638214,
0.4159716069698334,
-0.19034358859062195,
-0.06811359524726868,
0.5046857595443726,
-0.4106167256832123,
0.03753141686320305,
0.026125824078917503,
0.7094551920890808,
0.10685226321220398,
0.3861919939517975,
-0.10493133962154388,
-0.2841125428676605,
0.035999879240989685,
0.03665309026837349,
-0.7826682925224304,
-0.435160756111145,
-0.019207388162612915,
-0.3683091104030609,
0.01990252360701561,
-0.22040008008480072,
-0.44967180490493774,
-0.25306272506713867,
-0.6284942626953125,
0.6036457419395447,
-0.11262036114931107,
-0.436941921710968,
-0.13651466369628906,
-0.08657831698656082,
0.175784632563591,
0.07831884175539017,
-0.9071186780929565,
0.4827316105365753,
0.8238279819488525,
0.6634069085121155,
-0.30324244499206543,
-0.38615548610687256,
-0.9283638596534729,
0.07866936177015305,
-0.34807565808296204,
0.7650703191757202,
-0.402321994304657,
-0.3940255343914032,
-0.06772057712078094,
0.1234666109085083,
-0.08220380544662476,
-0.7774625420570374,
0.7636487483978271,
-0.2637481987476349,
-0.031962890177965164,
-0.3858237564563751,
-0.6982995867729187,
-0.08023616671562195,
-0.04644561931490898,
-0.5239909887313843,
1.1975650787353516,
-0.060585565865039825,
-0.34202712774276733,
0.31780216097831726,
-0.5868874192237854,
-0.6768749952316284,
0.1305607110261917,
-0.2040148824453354,
-0.4676477611064911,
0.24799160659313202,
0.22722268104553223,
0.42834141850471497,
-0.3150477409362793,
0.18241660296916962,
-0.38476794958114624,
-0.3663816452026367,
-0.11308833211660385,
-0.4517950117588043,
0.7937424778938293,
0.48970794677734375,
-0.38105279207229614,
0.19796298444271088,
-0.8946846127510071,
0.14450016617774963,
0.032919447869062424,
-0.24263635277748108,
-0.05701364949345589,
0.28411659598350525,
0.2959820628166199,
0.26916056871414185,
0.33717966079711914,
-0.3710799813270569,
-0.1785551905632019,
-0.30220675468444824,
0.4353012144565582,
0.4286291301250458,
-0.5186946988105774,
0.047497667372226715,
0.15371888875961304,
0.09003863483667374,
-0.1591637283563614,
0.20366409420967102,
-0.032800592482089996,
-0.27782124280929565,
-1.0008832216262817,
-0.31277891993522644,
0.6688956022262573,
0.6454203724861145,
-0.46231377124786377,
0.3971419334411621,
-0.2235051393508911,
-0.5949904322624207,
-0.7032776474952698,
0.31445199251174927,
0.8161909580230713,
0.28751930594444275,
0.5703874230384827,
-0.15088938176631927,
-0.6998153924942017,
-1.178173542022705,
-0.327562540769577,
-0.04393960162997246,
-0.11727520078420639,
0.414569228887558,
0.30974137783050537,
-0.08068734407424927,
0.6495024561882019,
-0.02441134676337242,
-0.33040064573287964,
-0.2782161831855774,
-0.010012221522629261,
-0.005276184529066086,
0.5385369658470154,
0.4412401616573334,
-0.7970027923583984,
-0.599448561668396,
0.038904279470443726,
-0.8313660621643066,
-0.1819574236869812,
0.2881014943122864,
0.187993124127388,
0.4783114492893219,
0.6676738858222961,
-0.21094180643558502,
0.05403350666165352,
0.694121241569519,
-0.04322635009884834,
0.7815832495689392,
-0.3269157111644745,
-0.0404520109295845,
-0.8260077834129333,
0.043742407113313675,
0.15041792392730713,
-0.06931367516517639,
-0.7822699546813965,
0.4330124855041504,
0.44062814116477966,
-0.2551535665988922,
-0.5425359010696411,
0.5154433250427246,
-0.4502345621585846,
-0.41009894013404846,
-0.17161963880062103,
-0.17509540915489197,
-0.07629889249801636,
0.21783103048801422,
0.25498509407043457,
0.908372163772583,
0.9275699257850647,
-0.5941343307495117,
0.16433203220367432,
-0.087157242000103,
-0.3140711188316345,
0.3961261212825775,
-0.6866062879562378,
0.23851144313812256,
0.2169032096862793,
0.08870790153741837,
-0.9611271619796753,
0.0015571872936561704,
-0.16451965272426605,
-0.3977774381637573,
0.4812066853046417,
-0.28983214497566223,
-0.594537615776062,
-0.4841783344745636,
0.13965949416160583,
0.06681294739246368,
0.33179745078086853,
-0.6826823949813843,
0.5871278047561646,
0.5644965171813965,
-0.3083327114582062,
-0.34496551752090454,
-0.6276578903198242,
0.22298605740070343,
-0.17883753776550293,
-0.2203460931777954,
0.3101743459701538,
-0.05811488628387451,
-0.07024194300174713,
-0.32391199469566345,
-0.09735926240682602,
-0.1773836612701416,
0.1684727668762207,
0.12091036885976791,
0.13831260800361633,
-0.5642520189285278,
-0.05302808806300163,
0.2685540020465851,
-0.3705666959285736,
0.006357817444950342,
-0.16542717814445496,
0.3185904026031494,
-0.18364661931991577,
-0.3178560435771942,
-0.8781177997589111,
0.4315923750400543,
0.41935643553733826,
-0.49934691190719604,
0.2603483498096466,
0.7137207984924316,
-0.3208882212638855,
0.047159068286418915,
-0.7997291684150696,
-0.13488733768463135,
-0.5245381593704224,
0.6657551527023315,
-0.9759083986282349,
-0.93550044298172,
0.32742056250572205,
0.023334920406341553,
0.10634833574295044,
0.4248701333999634,
0.6450603008270264,
-0.03142334893345833,
1.1876529455184937,
0.48985809087753296,
-0.23728591203689575,
0.1269584596157074,
-0.14438553154468536,
0.1898166686296463,
-0.5741953253746033,
-0.09550916403532028,
-0.7126590609550476,
0.0573231466114521,
-0.7289363145828247,
-0.3090105950832367,
0.11266773194074631,
0.44345593452453613,
-0.20242100954055786,
0.5492506623268127,
-0.3570523262023926,
0.3500060737133026,
0.7393707633018494,
-0.1803855150938034,
0.05602101609110832,
-0.034525997936725616,
-0.10091462731361389,
0.018139880150556564,
-0.621313214302063,
-0.4187283217906952,
0.9899921417236328,
0.3052850067615509,
0.34537965059280396,
0.3155495226383209,
0.34079989790916443,
0.19373063743114471,
0.1413920819759369,
-0.5153394937515259,
0.38985151052474976,
-0.8202335834503174,
-0.8655783534049988,
-0.27249234914779663,
-0.38393792510032654,
-0.4772166311740875,
0.35758885741233826,
-0.20236168801784515,
-0.7119849920272827,
-0.040041372179985046,
0.3534146249294281,
-0.5742632746696472,
0.020520173013210297,
-0.9819031357765198,
0.9091112017631531,
-0.22526118159294128,
-0.41647928953170776,
-0.28160354495048523,
-0.5831049084663391,
-0.04943034425377846,
-0.1766662448644638,
0.04735281690955162,
-0.502921998500824,
0.2136252522468567,
0.4527788758277893,
-0.08936050534248352,
0.5352240800857544,
-0.30379506945610046,
-0.10332468152046204,
0.03298309072852135,
-0.0277499258518219,
0.47058767080307007,
0.009849108755588531,
-0.38586291670799255,
0.686576783657074,
0.22130751609802246,
-0.21935081481933594,
-0.35731419920921326,
0.7674538493156433,
-0.8164314031600952,
-0.5612484216690063,
0.08286906033754349,
-0.4548066556453705,
-0.5356911420822144,
0.09353511780500412,
0.2494497448205948,
0.7754866480827332,
-0.10091985017061234,
0.17826223373413086,
0.32050585746765137,
-0.23076796531677246,
0.44022199511528015,
1.0138009786605835,
-0.022753985598683357,
-0.29305481910705566,
1.184094786643982,
0.33132579922676086,
0.24340938031673431,
0.4117613434791565,
0.13732478022575378,
-0.8324345350265503,
-0.6621943116188049,
-0.7910241484642029,
-0.1163991168141365,
-0.5033114552497864,
0.0345408096909523,
-0.7339097857475281,
-0.4740332067012787,
-0.8791466355323792,
0.21949300169944763,
-0.9350295662879944,
-0.4253152310848236,
-0.2844577133655548,
0.1099083200097084,
0.0780433788895607,
0.5422659516334534,
-0.45069754123687744,
-0.08729381859302521,
-0.6448429822921753,
0.3026411831378937,
0.43975237011909485,
0.44029098749160767,
-0.11218708008527756,
-0.7360325455665588,
-0.2772311270236969,
-0.11376292258501053,
-0.19024166464805603,
-0.23589228093624115,
0.13053081929683685,
0.650867760181427,
0.737402617931366,
0.44234663248062134,
-0.13754907250404358,
0.7397969961166382,
-0.8111198544502258,
0.6340246796607971,
0.01494807843118906,
-0.9320715069770813,
0.6160983443260193,
-0.2791441082954407,
0.24195007979869843,
0.5940623879432678,
0.4226006865501404,
-0.2566834092140198,
-0.26324909925460815,
-0.14609266817569733,
-0.6109490394592285,
0.5498175024986267,
0.2603764832019806,
0.16667763888835907,
0.23071645200252533,
0.24364221096038818,
0.42485326528549194,
-0.018139805644750595,
-0.35267993807792664,
-0.7083537578582764,
-0.2342442125082016,
0.04157949611544609,
-0.6884318590164185,
-0.4046001136302948,
0.10057517886161804,
-0.5194799900054932,
0.7077246308326721,
-0.1478608250617981,
-0.06744655221700668,
-0.08947949856519699,
-0.13528792560100555,
0.19115492701530457,
0.10496461391448975,
0.5773319602012634,
0.44517356157302856,
-0.13383637368679047,
0.15952816605567932,
0.4216855764389038,
-0.11422181129455566,
-0.012230798602104187,
0.7310958504676819,
-0.023112734779715538,
-0.05773955211043358,
0.24166062474250793,
0.9498399496078491,
0.27460962533950806,
-0.5961942672729492,
0.1418164074420929,
-0.11238295584917068,
-0.32392165064811707,
-0.1387990415096283,
0.3478958308696747,
0.04281334578990936,
0.47046995162963867,
0.4492352306842804,
0.007933619432151318,
0.5425670742988586,
-0.33398425579071045,
0.36651772260665894,
0.36405646800994873,
-0.667472779750824,
-0.43434879183769226,
0.7974855899810791,
0.3299292027950287,
-0.5343673229217529,
0.3002006709575653,
-0.27162978053092957,
-0.4966077208518982,
0.39923155307769775,
0.5834681987762451,
0.7447896003723145,
-0.5730695128440857,
0.022670140489935875,
0.6311314702033997,
0.02798481099307537,
0.06336522847414017,
0.3227986693382263,
-0.24756889045238495,
-0.6611661911010742,
-0.37632662057876587,
-0.6914647817611694,
-0.41561758518218994,
0.25560247898101807,
-0.9778447151184082,
0.24226346611976624,
-0.10926439613103867,
-0.01293526217341423,
0.5334158539772034,
0.16998621821403503,
-0.5375074744224548,
0.23121656477451324,
0.591035008430481,
0.8302308917045593,
-0.7829917073249817,
1.1461485624313354,
0.5214395523071289,
0.15404225885868073,
-0.6451267600059509,
-0.29201048612594604,
0.39293137192726135,
-0.6140443682670593,
0.6726914048194885,
0.4631137251853943,
-0.29996398091316223,
0.14173641800880432,
-0.04703378677368164,
-1.1621592044830322,
0.5065223574638367,
0.5523029565811157,
-0.7578440308570862,
0.4482014775276184,
0.4136199653148651,
0.6449504494667053,
-0.2353280633687973,
0.15301717817783356,
0.7687366008758545,
0.14992853999137878,
-0.11146456003189087,
-1.2976598739624023,
-0.3218563199043274,
-0.5345680117607117,
0.06169082596898079,
-0.07614116370677948,
-0.6877335906028748,
0.7403903603553772,
-0.21110157668590546,
-0.2803489565849304,
0.29938948154449463,
0.7329226732254028,
0.46812841296195984,
0.23780018091201782,
0.4786154329776764,
0.5150576829910278,
0.5898109078407288,
-0.17726658284664154,
0.8416105508804321,
-0.44539397954940796,
0.44852015376091003,
1.4945746660232544,
-0.59543377161026,
1.195349097251892,
0.142500102519989,
-0.335724413394928,
0.1850745975971222,
0.7521220445632935,
-0.17174457013607025,
0.7703068256378174,
0.1292787343263626,
-0.18236155807971954,
-0.3930797278881073,
-0.29506418108940125,
-0.7640249729156494,
0.604431688785553,
0.18428286910057068,
-0.08442358672618866,
-0.1361660659313202,
-0.07760482281446457,
-0.3494546711444855,
-0.13303644955158234,
-0.3799082934856415,
0.6977034211158752,
-0.0706222802400589,
-0.5103612542152405,
0.5460080504417419,
-0.16426944732666016,
0.5869895815849304,
-0.4158121943473816,
0.19122214615345,
-0.13239116966724396,
0.46492496132850647,
0.04193728417158127,
-0.4940829277038574,
0.3181106448173523,
0.0867157056927681,
-0.27473175525665283,
-0.03712262213230133,
0.6056700348854065,
-0.2890603244304657,
-0.868082582950592,
0.554310142993927,
0.35572656989097595,
0.3227277398109436,
-0.23058609664440155,
-1.0854207277297974,
0.22425541281700134,
-0.10464199632406235,
-0.015825066715478897,
0.17433051764965057,
0.10659810900688171,
0.15999366343021393,
0.7524722218513489,
0.7109254002571106,
-0.05958844721317291,
0.08645239472389221,
0.7121970057487488,
0.6074846982955933,
-0.405927836894989,
-0.6077866554260254,
-0.7995175123214722,
0.34433794021606445,
-0.07010899484157562,
-0.4855833053588867,
0.8714880347251892,
1.053000807762146,
1.0624924898147583,
0.04271869733929634,
0.7424390912055969,
0.29256317019462585,
0.9977343082427979,
-0.39694446325302124,
0.7651149034500122,
-0.8153368830680847,
-0.06071307510137558,
-0.35233908891677856,
-0.6947832107543945,
-0.310920387506485,
0.3672790229320526,
-0.18298840522766113,
-0.07550612837076187,
0.32477501034736633,
1.0565859079360962,
-0.09379760175943375,
0.21576844155788422,
0.539351224899292,
-0.013160760514438152,
0.09375917166471481,
0.16987745463848114,
0.858329713344574,
-0.6200152635574341,
0.3915187418460846,
-0.42757317423820496,
-0.002256631152704358,
-0.06613435596227646,
-0.585590660572052,
-0.8719596266746521,
-0.7194820046424866,
-0.5121791362762451,
-0.0339086651802063,
0.33076247572898865,
0.7289485335350037,
1.2175929546356201,
-1.294848084449768,
-0.33148011565208435,
0.04066802188754082,
-0.2080424427986145,
-0.3424883186817169,
-0.15737079083919525,
0.45038825273513794,
-0.4032907485961914,
-0.75848388671875,
0.8137807250022888,
0.43982988595962524,
-0.07495027035474777,
-0.3274075984954834,
-0.21453797817230225,
0.07717880606651306,
-0.18923243880271912,
0.6180475950241089,
0.2703746259212494,
-0.8564830422401428,
-0.056782081723213196,
-0.33134111762046814,
-0.0010276369284838438,
-0.062172334641218185,
0.6720556020736694,
-0.5485173463821411,
0.37254416942596436,
0.021608557552099228,
0.5900863409042358,
0.49559295177459717,
-0.22383056581020355,
0.49649813771247864,
-0.5535410642623901,
0.06033499166369438,
-0.18172456324100494,
0.3407718241214752,
0.4807601571083069,
-0.11925739794969559,
0.5508371591567993,
0.15535356104373932,
-0.36791980266571045,
-1.0533469915390015,
0.06606851518154144,
-0.5154616236686707,
-0.2905278205871582,
1.1671102046966553,
-0.20627103745937347,
0.315054327249527,
-0.308481901884079,
0.1986588090658188,
0.31101614236831665,
-0.17184719443321228,
0.6988341212272644,
0.4301157593727112,
-0.021161869168281555,
-0.0998663380742073,
-0.6645472645759583,
0.4724154770374298,
0.4796064794063568,
-0.623805046081543,
0.22812804579734802,
0.24388688802719116,
0.35393139719963074,
-0.026884054765105247,
0.35186561942100525,
-0.03441368788480759,
0.2468375563621521,
0.07567287981510162,
0.01664922945201397,
-0.04306263104081154,
-0.5036399960517883,
-0.4488057494163513,
0.17162682116031647,
-0.2603267729282379,
-0.14266745746135712
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08633v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08633v1
|
Unraveling Code-Mixing Patterns in Migration Discourse: Automated Detection and Analysis of Online Conversations on Reddit
| 2024-06-12T20:30:34 | 2024-06-12T20:30:34 |
Fedor Vitiugin, Sunok Lee, Henna Paakki, Anastasiia Chizhikova, Nitin Sawhney
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.IR
|
The surge in global migration patterns underscores the imperative of
integrating migrants seamlessly into host communities, necessitating inclusive
and trustworthy public services. Despite the Nordic countries' robust public
sector infrastructure, recent immigrants often encounter barriers to accessing
these services, exacerbating social disparities and eroding trust. Addressing
digital inequalities and linguistic diversity is paramount in this endeavor.
This paper explores the utilization of code-mixing, a communication strategy
prevalent among multilingual speakers, in migration-related discourse on social
media platforms such as Reddit. We present Ensemble Learning for Multilingual
Identification of Code-mixed Texts (ELMICT), a novel approach designed to
automatically detect code-mixed messages in migration-related discussions.
Leveraging ensemble learning techniques for combining multiple tokenizers'
outputs and pre-trained language models, ELMICT demonstrates high performance
(with F1 more than 0.95) in identifying code-mixing across various languages
and contexts, particularly in cross-lingual zero-shot conditions (with avg. F1
more than 0.70). Moreover, the utilization of ELMICT helps to analyze the
prevalence of code-mixing in migration-related threads compared to other
thematic categories on Reddit, shedding light on the topics of concern to
migrant communities. Our findings reveal insights into the communicative
strategies employed by migrants on social media platforms, offering
implications for the development of inclusive digital public services and
conversational systems. By addressing the research questions posed in this
study, we contribute to the understanding of linguistic diversity in migration
discourse and pave the way for more effective tools for building trust in
multicultural societies.
|
[
-0.6416122317314148,
-0.4175471067428589,
0.2005177140235901,
0.4610613286495209,
-0.44689321517944336,
0.7756150364875793,
-0.3013637363910675,
-0.7542958855628967,
0.5937590003013611,
0.30540749430656433,
-0.32198190689086914,
-0.7066865563392639,
-0.6825092434883118,
0.23749151825904846,
-0.7899975776672363,
1.152820110321045,
-0.11920548230409622,
0.09377916157245636,
-0.07523857802152634,
-0.3714632987976074,
-0.20167282223701477,
-0.5451112985610962,
-0.3906051814556122,
0.17000900208950043,
0.5345521569252014,
0.34683743119239807,
0.6247222423553467,
0.49910709261894226,
0.39662089943885803,
0.3152547776699066,
-0.16014006733894348,
0.3673623204231262,
-0.4486748278141022,
-0.004373331554234028,
-0.121619813144207,
-0.45405498147010803,
0.023867188021540642,
-0.520418107509613,
0.3665894865989685,
0.3639032244682312,
-0.24107003211975098,
0.2572542428970337,
0.1907239854335785,
0.3042968511581421,
-0.6170328855514526,
0.05505668744444847,
-0.6828389167785645,
0.04157125577330589,
-0.286739319562912,
-0.13111604750156403,
-0.036544881761074066,
-0.48554927110671997,
-0.4088227450847626,
-0.3269604742527008,
-0.1213746890425682,
-0.1419992297887802,
0.5757725238800049,
-0.0052910600788891315,
-0.542266845703125,
-0.4897301495075226,
-0.7173470258712769,
0.8595519661903381,
-0.2700091004371643,
0.31768012046813965,
0.3551894724369049,
0.15976856648921967,
0.042532291263341904,
-0.5092520117759705,
-0.5108543038368225,
0.5117495059967041,
-0.21770665049552917,
-0.037352707237005234,
-0.27992117404937744,
-0.20664022862911224,
-0.3212502896785736,
0.11907981336116791,
-0.7323096990585327,
0.048458002507686615,
-0.7190817594528198,
-0.36791694164276123,
0.6746421456336975,
-0.1414947360754013,
0.5884695053100586,
0.02463720552623272,
-0.05752217397093773,
-0.028329448774456978,
-0.22467686235904694,
-0.2681210935115814,
0.7586891055107117,
0.3768254518508911,
-0.6210120916366577,
0.12944632768630981,
0.2565918266773224,
0.5116115212440491,
-0.11370044201612473,
0.1344595104455948,
0.35405343770980835,
-0.44808289408683777,
0.3873564600944519,
0.03997329995036125,
0.7565069794654846,
0.3044511377811432,
0.38783490657806396,
-0.04852360486984253,
-0.42864373326301575,
0.3755415081977844,
0.0851888433098793,
-0.4030027389526367,
-0.11701320856809616,
0.23798714578151703,
-0.5207784175872803,
-0.44643229246139526,
0.1278134137392044,
-1.0550107955932617,
-0.16041365265846252,
0.06381373107433319,
-0.27869105339050293,
-0.1936715990304947,
-0.6513317823410034,
-0.09691666811704636,
-0.13452935218811035,
0.38513702154159546,
0.35174769163131714,
-0.8979078531265259,
0.4179326295852661,
0.9049087762832642,
0.9074977040290833,
-0.36873432993888855,
-0.3025891184806824,
-0.22609426081180573,
-0.39845308661460876,
-0.28501078486442566,
0.8626905679702759,
-0.629964292049408,
-0.45607998967170715,
0.3828642666339874,
0.02720199152827263,
-0.15830281376838684,
-0.5069177150726318,
0.475954532623291,
-0.8201771974563599,
0.03554719313979149,
0.29785606265068054,
-0.18342192471027374,
0.05096381530165672,
0.3868095278739929,
-0.5873143672943115,
0.889746904373169,
0.03626728430390358,
-0.6952841877937317,
0.27044907212257385,
-0.6045792102813721,
-0.6751094460487366,
0.10722995549440384,
-0.2734259068965912,
-0.24130879342556,
0.01690843142569065,
0.21253997087478638,
0.16145887970924377,
0.2988254427909851,
0.10660597681999207,
-0.3132662773132324,
-0.41675299406051636,
0.3028067648410797,
-0.28903526067733765,
0.9027650356292725,
0.7163387537002563,
-0.04248813912272453,
-0.07466907054185867,
-0.7935915589332581,
-0.00906337983906269,
-0.16726131737232208,
-0.39128783345222473,
-0.4276193082332611,
0.01349033135920763,
0.3855379819869995,
0.2318858653306961,
0.03420168161392212,
-0.36647850275039673,
-0.1278793215751648,
-0.1773134171962738,
0.5428813695907593,
0.49115854501724243,
0.018501538783311844,
0.48037201166152954,
-0.4546450674533844,
0.7147436738014221,
0.36313414573669434,
0.012010238133370876,
-0.3548290729522705,
-0.7742981314659119,
-0.45776623487472534,
0.009144291281700134,
0.2959728538990021,
0.8495109677314758,
-0.8181788921356201,
0.40398138761520386,
-0.26958537101745605,
-0.26719731092453003,
-0.847795307636261,
0.20558805763721466,
0.2508505582809448,
-0.30686160922050476,
0.3558185398578644,
-0.1862267702817917,
-0.7971713542938232,
-0.5114685893058777,
-0.3678724765777588,
-0.444282591342926,
0.14137770235538483,
0.03524588420987129,
0.6493609547615051,
-0.3730202913284302,
0.5838775634765625,
-0.008303164504468441,
0.11184655874967575,
-0.20578919351100922,
0.40077680349349976,
0.04471002146601677,
0.5074569582939148,
0.4337236285209656,
-1.009399175643921,
-0.8517757058143616,
0.4727230966091156,
-0.3422856330871582,
0.05562319979071617,
-0.36610040068626404,
-0.066880002617836,
0.21118611097335815,
0.5469895601272583,
-0.24735726416110992,
0.06589991599321365,
0.9684798121452332,
-0.34386372566223145,
0.19784872233867645,
0.09957637637853622,
0.513142466545105,
-1.3181664943695068,
-0.21831801533699036,
0.028952671214938164,
-0.1614612340927124,
-0.6342893242835999,
0.23882432281970978,
0.04608530551195145,
-0.007163817994296551,
-0.6499897241592407,
0.4573051929473877,
-0.5149522423744202,
0.019747495651245117,
0.019133973866701126,
-0.00014046260912436992,
-0.4025951623916626,
0.439212828874588,
-0.05259472876787186,
0.7077957391738892,
0.43504324555397034,
-0.28499773144721985,
0.1301875114440918,
0.20184478163719177,
-0.574413537979126,
0.7150397300720215,
0.1048268973827362,
0.31908324360847473,
-0.17359212040901184,
0.15389253199100494,
-1.1965330839157104,
-0.2510550320148468,
0.43414366245269775,
-0.6966208219528198,
-0.03408176824450493,
-0.5788236260414124,
-0.4962851405143738,
-0.24732138216495514,
-0.08488257229328156,
0.8398462533950806,
0.6089869141578674,
-0.35630619525909424,
0.43827807903289795,
0.563122570514679,
-0.2836220860481262,
-0.5150425434112549,
-1.072425365447998,
0.3161830008029938,
-0.2845584750175476,
-0.7836449146270752,
0.16771294176578522,
0.06877988576889038,
-0.647602915763855,
0.03008882887661457,
0.17467056214809418,
-0.8105106949806213,
0.30159762501716614,
-0.13615456223487854,
0.04452858865261078,
-0.2026434987783432,
-0.03950069844722748,
0.4323614537715912,
0.1596006155014038,
0.023885460570454597,
-0.4862739145755768,
0.6138614416122437,
-0.04082200676202774,
-0.4379335343837738,
-0.30540427565574646,
0.7426903247833252,
0.8025534749031067,
-0.23984423279762268,
0.6885314583778381,
0.8940364718437195,
-0.04039117321372032,
-0.13653644919395447,
-0.44475600123405457,
-0.23411935567855835,
-0.38892942667007446,
0.14912675321102142,
0.07984031736850739,
-1.2291706800460815,
1.0037689208984375,
0.09130396693944931,
0.23678624629974365,
0.11553298681974411,
0.29269683361053467,
-0.19047482311725616,
0.8612974286079407,
0.5201061964035034,
-0.0989137515425682,
0.5545841455459595,
0.20081909000873566,
0.24373231828212738,
-0.1489555686712265,
0.18292471766471863,
-0.7443223595619202,
-0.46874555945396423,
-1.1300967931747437,
-0.635988712310791,
0.14877010881900787,
-0.33107972145080566,
0.2708400785923004,
0.306936115026474,
-0.47404468059539795,
0.7145867943763733,
0.31976401805877686,
-0.13701118528842926,
0.5197199583053589,
0.20456546545028687,
-0.04533041641116142,
0.19535331428050995,
-0.8421857357025146,
-0.25817278027534485,
0.9768020510673523,
0.16659778356552124,
0.7908981442451477,
0.022543124854564667,
1.0457144975662231,
0.4367337226867676,
0.3408404290676117,
-0.5063837170600891,
0.3798699975013733,
-0.02251492813229561,
-0.4629606306552887,
0.11814728379249573,
-0.5178043842315674,
-1.1432660818099976,
0.546328604221344,
-0.2935611307621002,
-0.6246324777603149,
0.4889272153377533,
0.11247096210718155,
-0.37756088376045227,
0.36956918239593506,
-0.5851495265960693,
0.6235865354537964,
-0.3016113340854645,
-0.14360347390174866,
-0.2835792899131775,
-0.7515338063240051,
0.3541756570339203,
-0.343953013420105,
1.0884867906570435,
0.25037169456481934,
0.09625173360109329,
0.6041259765625,
0.004828942008316517,
0.96573406457901,
0.30313798785209656,
-0.3118807077407837,
0.4482494592666626,
-0.027823220938444138,
0.440794438123703,
-0.21255925297737122,
0.19100062549114227,
0.7908185124397278,
0.13525156676769257,
-0.3700234591960907,
-0.12709911167621613,
0.6093750596046448,
-0.8700721263885498,
-0.07081438601016998,
-0.05248980224132538,
-0.2779616117477417,
0.054924651980400085,
0.12334439903497696,
0.19650420546531677,
-0.013935618102550507,
-0.08669521659612656,
0.12831100821495056,
0.6233711838722229,
-0.2260666787624359,
0.5271098017692566,
0.21648721396923065,
-0.2060549408197403,
-0.5329210162162781,
0.9904947280883789,
0.09421231597661972,
0.04408596083521843,
0.30568015575408936,
-0.13610157370567322,
-0.02883690968155861,
-0.3412551283836365,
-0.44924649596214294,
0.054969705641269684,
-0.6442724466323853,
0.04925105348229408,
-0.667864203453064,
-0.05556134879589081,
-0.3428077697753906,
-0.45151081681251526,
-0.320369690656662,
-0.33863455057144165,
-0.09189767390489578,
-0.09213890135288239,
-0.008903133682906628,
0.5159122347831726,
-0.23378828167915344,
0.17695437371730804,
-1.0899276733398438,
-0.035326942801475525,
0.14977271854877472,
0.34029877185821533,
-0.18177397549152374,
-0.1393977403640747,
-0.48049259185791016,
0.07244890183210373,
-0.13387100398540497,
-0.9654848575592041,
0.16248942911624908,
-0.09389082342386246,
0.5991032123565674,
0.3192313611507416,
-0.04030471667647362,
0.6688568592071533,
-0.1427747756242752,
0.8221701383590698,
0.13087965548038483,
-0.6761024594306946,
0.28144022822380066,
-0.5791524052619934,
0.2356233298778534,
0.4872857630252838,
0.26926761865615845,
-1.0158449411392212,
-0.9315589666366577,
-0.46620407700538635,
-1.0812044143676758,
0.525580883026123,
0.28871920704841614,
0.5858867168426514,
-0.2868627905845642,
-0.14200951159000397,
0.022488970309495926,
0.20992538332939148,
-1.0829476118087769,
-0.16257818043231964,
0.043794240802526474,
-0.2449273318052292,
0.3098283112049103,
-0.07715606689453125,
-0.3240404427051544,
-0.2215350717306137,
0.18738624453544617,
-0.12814703583717346,
0.31796854734420776,
-0.131355881690979,
-0.3684219717979431,
-0.2780626118183136,
0.48210233449935913,
0.7175164818763733,
0.5961407423019409,
0.32472920417785645,
0.14787112176418304,
0.09893983602523804,
-0.3422972559928894,
0.029970211908221245,
-0.1433829814195633,
0.04314585030078888,
0.25874170660972595,
0.4755820035934448,
0.5239043831825256,
0.3584173619747162,
-0.5356852412223816,
0.4786171019077301,
-0.22183725237846375,
-0.5290594696998596,
-0.178084135055542,
0.020767265930771828,
0.066309355199337,
0.2270301729440689,
0.33071404695510864,
0.45537346601486206,
-0.05231671780347824,
-0.6029404997825623,
0.3700019419193268,
0.21576650440692902,
-0.34198445081710815,
-0.3710157573223114,
0.2820284068584442,
0.5980069637298584,
-0.67275071144104,
0.3599897623062134,
-0.21763108670711517,
-0.44590461254119873,
0.5146773457527161,
0.20524542033672333,
1.0660169124603271,
-0.24199819564819336,
0.3020903766155243,
0.16718435287475586,
0.33838894963264465,
-0.167537659406662,
0.32261955738067627,
-0.6117307543754578,
-1.0660265684127808,
-0.3468073904514313,
-0.386351078748703,
-0.17504002153873444,
-0.4704856872558594,
-0.7318278551101685,
0.31786900758743286,
-0.17197254300117493,
-0.024701261892914772,
-0.42648598551750183,
-0.6163368821144104,
-0.5170000791549683,
-0.42995771765708923,
0.5117340683937073,
0.7285619378089905,
-1.2487295866012573,
0.5899618268013,
0.840543270111084,
-0.015554886311292648,
-0.3679896295070648,
0.21325825154781342,
0.18575206398963928,
-0.8448799848556519,
0.29098600149154663,
-0.04318675771355629,
-0.060743898153305054,
0.054487865418195724,
-0.5235660076141357,
-0.47294723987579346,
0.4816844165325165,
0.12262989580631256,
-0.37139251828193665,
0.24475546181201935,
0.32122835516929626,
0.7092970013618469,
-0.261664479970932,
0.3131657838821411,
0.4425755441188812,
0.5181854963302612,
0.06892197579145432,
-1.1085747480392456,
-0.28505203127861023,
-0.4355224370956421,
-0.18200042843818665,
0.4970056414604187,
-0.5072926878929138,
0.6706622242927551,
0.06273572146892548,
-0.492717444896698,
-0.13643476366996765,
0.2785583734512329,
-0.08317115157842636,
0.3279497027397156,
0.5066607594490051,
0.25920185446739197,
0.69913649559021,
-0.058479297906160355,
0.6520614624023438,
-0.7462009191513062,
0.3831135630607605,
0.7821186780929565,
-0.03220130130648613,
0.7324252128601074,
0.6326273083686829,
-0.1410251259803772,
0.8631369471549988,
0.4851861596107483,
0.13352465629577637,
0.35719019174575806,
0.05315839499235153,
-0.27627551555633545,
-0.15125516057014465,
0.117250457406044,
-0.1902356594800949,
0.49952685832977295,
0.4370589554309845,
-0.38218820095062256,
-0.4828987121582031,
0.08406880497932434,
0.11997038871049881,
0.3138035833835602,
-0.30734097957611084,
1.1867620944976807,
-0.05406169593334198,
-0.9698079228401184,
0.5207794904708862,
-0.09518186748027802,
0.9534347653388977,
-0.41159263253211975,
-0.1508491337299347,
-0.5288311839103699,
-0.14547939598560333,
-0.42136603593826294,
-0.9442415833473206,
0.532414436340332,
0.015491255559027195,
0.19256582856178284,
-0.555536150932312,
0.5544949173927307,
-0.7781002521514893,
-0.4709409475326538,
0.4706054925918579,
0.6715744137763977,
0.21612676978111267,
0.1907346099615097,
-0.7455793023109436,
0.40306299924850464,
0.09677281975746155,
0.380664587020874,
0.5163255929946899,
0.6859997510910034,
-0.21105758845806122,
0.4472815990447998,
0.5674064755439758,
0.049864787608385086,
0.10109525918960571,
-0.14492225646972656,
0.7131032943725586,
-0.2614775002002716,
-0.9700217247009277,
-1.0274109840393066,
0.7195466756820679,
-0.08651456981897354,
-0.36694496870040894,
0.5994323492050171,
0.48802992701530457,
1.3153362274169922,
0.033989083021879196,
0.8698001503944397,
0.01880640722811222,
0.3091408610343933,
-0.24480383098125458,
0.6796544194221497,
-0.5020130276679993,
0.3843352198600769,
-0.2777978777885437,
-0.7166378498077393,
-0.40048009157180786,
0.6213576793670654,
-0.01181367039680481,
-0.14886805415153503,
0.5086705088615417,
1.0133789777755737,
-0.23541533946990967,
0.09033485502004623,
0.26515308022499084,
-0.08367560803890228,
0.08568929135799408,
0.2758074998855591,
1.0552176237106323,
-0.23451916873455048,
0.8701222538948059,
-0.014721203595399857,
-0.10567031800746918,
-0.3197909891605377,
-0.441318154335022,
-0.5976741313934326,
-0.48106318712234497,
-0.3330719769001007,
-0.3912544548511505,
0.23006218671798706,
1.105055809020996,
0.70920729637146,
-0.9744375348091125,
-0.6468615531921387,
-0.0986345112323761,
0.6123711466789246,
-0.27475377917289734,
-0.2343028485774994,
-0.3573550581932068,
-0.3708842396736145,
-0.6881299018859863,
-0.022242877632379532,
0.27268338203430176,
-0.04178467020392418,
-0.3027398884296417,
0.1215670257806778,
-0.22824180126190186,
-0.06250113993883133,
0.41981041431427,
0.40251728892326355,
-0.3191443085670471,
-0.1211494505405426,
-0.24281281232833862,
-0.046338293701410294,
0.1874740570783615,
0.8902574181556702,
-0.3021852672100067,
0.3531138598918915,
0.45343247056007385,
0.7407466769218445,
0.22703179717063904,
-0.0008439937373623252,
0.47466570138931274,
-0.9736865162849426,
0.25279295444488525,
0.4474531412124634,
0.1781202107667923,
0.22349104285240173,
-0.2882530093193054,
0.25711825489997864,
0.36058011651039124,
-0.5447202920913696,
-0.8680465817451477,
0.0526895597577095,
-0.4740101397037506,
-0.3950303792953491,
1.2867958545684814,
0.03633454442024231,
-0.11333519965410233,
-0.6285945773124695,
-0.010798895731568336,
-0.02541382610797882,
-0.5111631751060486,
1.0578136444091797,
0.779380738735199,
0.16696205735206604,
-0.4828622043132782,
-0.3042949140071869,
0.28694948554039,
0.16372928023338318,
-0.7734874486923218,
-0.2083185911178589,
0.24359658360481262,
0.09816472977399826,
0.341227650642395,
0.6015785932540894,
-0.1213536486029625,
0.35135647654533386,
-0.10111216455698013,
-0.08443749696016312,
0.5873503684997559,
-0.1382964551448822,
-0.3505643606185913,
0.2669813632965088,
-0.132440447807312,
-0.213044673204422
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09458v1
|
Updating CLIP to Prefer Descriptions Over Captions
| 2024-06-12T20:24:51 | 2024-06-12T20:24:51 |
Amir Zur, Elisa Kreiss, Karel D'Oosterlinck, Christopher Potts, Atticus Geiger
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although CLIPScore is a powerful generic metric that captures the similarity
between a text and an image, it fails to distinguish between a caption that is
meant to complement the information in an image and a description that is meant
to replace an image entirely, e.g., for accessibility. We address this
shortcoming by updating the CLIP model with the Concadia dataset to assign
higher scores to descriptions than captions using parameter efficient
fine-tuning and a loss objective derived from work on causal interpretability.
This model correlates with the judgements of blind and low-vision people while
preserving transfer capabilities and has interpretable structure that sheds
light on the caption--description distinction.
|
[
-0.2588391602039337,
-0.09683877974748611,
0.5809725522994995,
0.44849830865859985,
-0.4709063768386841,
0.30593493580818176,
-0.1360066682100296,
-0.8019010424613953,
0.3539029657840729,
0.2546277344226837,
-0.40480101108551025,
-0.4701063632965088,
-0.906337320804596,
0.08072394877672195,
-0.5800660252571106,
0.9510526061058044,
-0.32752975821495056,
0.02300897426903248,
-0.4975317716598511,
-0.3587471544742584,
-0.7833815813064575,
-0.3086894452571869,
-0.35389918088912964,
-0.025271298363804817,
0.14637382328510284,
0.6900798678398132,
1.0125595331192017,
0.8035548329353333,
0.8112225532531738,
0.10759098827838898,
-0.189141646027565,
0.21441207826137543,
-0.2590056359767914,
-0.35772955417633057,
-0.42007899284362793,
-0.5371605753898621,
-0.25981348752975464,
0.12231853604316711,
0.5825306177139282,
0.5718151330947876,
0.16965685784816742,
0.18960750102996826,
0.3522237241268158,
0.4914707839488983,
-0.7616707682609558,
0.3834444582462311,
-0.6768483519554138,
0.011559560894966125,
-0.07771606743335724,
-0.2890665829181671,
0.060115598142147064,
-0.44858449697494507,
0.5378406643867493,
-0.4961685240268707,
0.7727857232093811,
0.29274678230285645,
1.0058352947235107,
0.23854802548885345,
-0.030938588082790375,
-0.2955000698566437,
-0.449329137802124,
0.7060732841491699,
-0.4327732026576996,
0.14406464993953705,
0.3035557270050049,
0.45799943804740906,
0.3659904897212982,
-0.5610414743423462,
-0.4260787069797516,
-0.1703413724899292,
0.06042737513780594,
0.11616572737693787,
-0.3579922318458557,
0.09950143098831177,
0.23659631609916687,
0.4993782937526703,
-0.013830434530973434,
0.047562580555677414,
-0.936177134513855,
-0.4192427396774292,
0.5418640375137329,
0.44804075360298157,
0.3993353545665741,
-0.5770185589790344,
-0.9278154373168945,
-0.1256120353937149,
-0.750808835029602,
0.3519056737422943,
-0.09391065686941147,
-0.04933911934494972,
-0.18279820680618286,
0.48377251625061035,
-0.0927022248506546,
0.5946491360664368,
-0.10086864978075027,
0.087201327085495,
0.10908735543489456,
-0.13114458322525024,
-0.19345976412296295,
0.19277021288871765,
0.4668746888637543,
1.2352362871170044,
0.1464938521385193,
-0.14994172751903534,
0.02568710967898369,
0.08473867923021317,
0.160741925239563,
-0.5885212421417236,
-0.21231016516685486,
-0.13150158524513245,
-0.5280474424362183,
-0.16906003654003143,
0.5289890170097351,
-0.7667595744132996,
-0.195363849401474,
-0.30428174138069153,
0.5306001901626587,
-0.41439107060432434,
0.43377313017845154,
0.384122759103775,
-0.43062540888786316,
0.13206703960895538,
0.656004011631012,
-0.6562296748161316,
0.6581881046295166,
0.42360445857048035,
1.3768932819366455,
-0.5083615779876709,
-0.4563254415988922,
-0.31232476234436035,
0.12704256176948547,
-0.2209509015083313,
1.1979942321777344,
-0.4128451645374298,
-0.38680776953697205,
-0.19729533791542053,
0.3620312213897705,
-0.20572000741958618,
-0.6670120358467102,
0.6017142534255981,
-0.2829872965812683,
-0.16826370358467102,
-0.4830543100833893,
-0.4628859758377075,
-0.46797695755958557,
0.19766733050346375,
-0.889863908290863,
0.6276734471321106,
0.4166153073310852,
-0.6608235239982605,
0.4937207102775574,
-0.4222876727581024,
-0.27518951892852783,
-0.10951164364814758,
0.035861168056726456,
-0.444089412689209,
0.3552221357822418,
0.3523486852645874,
0.21619625389575958,
-0.3235982656478882,
-0.028555914759635925,
-0.41031119227409363,
-0.580085277557373,
0.3700316846370697,
0.03002636693418026,
0.43898752331733704,
0.04088321700692177,
-0.08489105850458145,
0.09387420862913132,
-0.4973624646663666,
-0.21312299370765686,
-0.1320958435535431,
0.028384234756231308,
-0.3978404998779297,
0.2543519139289856,
0.03263302147388458,
0.0456865057349205,
0.1699162721633911,
-0.7432471513748169,
0.05585242435336113,
-0.024063877761363983,
0.7685803771018982,
0.6944143176078796,
0.19968199729919434,
0.3839954137802124,
-0.5603001713752747,
0.6297982335090637,
0.06683387607336044,
0.6503289341926575,
-0.10059761255979538,
-0.30468958616256714,
-0.46873998641967773,
-0.3188270032405853,
0.3680896759033203,
0.58000648021698,
-0.4084131121635437,
0.08088099211454391,
-0.2604895532131195,
-0.4935995042324066,
-0.5903092622756958,
0.05948193743824959,
0.3687758445739746,
0.6568923592567444,
0.5671535730361938,
-0.7968016862869263,
-0.5716478228569031,
-1.1184136867523193,
-0.039985500276088715,
0.10074793547391891,
0.11781670898199081,
0.5591940879821777,
0.3401833772659302,
0.16525520384311676,
0.9716582894325256,
-0.8984479308128357,
-1.0292409658432007,
-0.168985977768898,
-0.19951526820659637,
0.2358827143907547,
0.3949124217033386,
0.7257543206214905,
-0.7465381622314453,
-0.4301324784755707,
-0.3169437348842621,
-0.4077532887458801,
-0.0581965334713459,
-0.14954057335853577,
0.1620827317237854,
-0.6344139575958252,
0.5941240191459656,
-0.4845193922519684,
0.6216816306114197,
0.424816370010376,
-0.17634335160255432,
0.791738748550415,
-0.32091042399406433,
0.5691266059875488,
-0.5958736538887024,
0.02030078135430813,
-0.04787004366517067,
-0.2709304690361023,
-0.03582586348056793,
-0.03807844594120979,
0.04697627201676369,
-0.28397467732429504,
-0.8386346697807312,
0.4626997411251068,
-0.6097508072853088,
-0.3815206289291382,
-0.29149580001831055,
0.441095769405365,
0.5300553441047668,
0.44122618436813354,
0.09575656056404114,
0.9664703607559204,
0.90787672996521,
-0.5802793502807617,
0.3720521330833435,
0.7454184293746948,
-0.9093384146690369,
0.8665014505386353,
-1.090656042098999,
-0.15374471247196198,
-0.22363662719726562,
0.22374071180820465,
-0.8799237608909607,
-0.4182031750679016,
0.1553792953491211,
-0.3063211143016815,
-0.0007681276183575392,
-0.07690378278493881,
-0.3017977774143219,
-0.39811211824417114,
-0.7795811891555786,
0.6083577871322632,
0.2107459008693695,
-0.5543289184570312,
0.13319160044193268,
0.3444358706474304,
0.0273000355809927,
-0.23941265046596527,
-0.7575576901435852,
0.059758078306913376,
-0.2506405711174011,
-0.24832406640052795,
0.6556671261787415,
0.0660160481929779,
-0.03396938368678093,
0.3143373727798462,
-0.06281550973653793,
-0.22374041378498077,
0.11102082580327988,
0.37964433431625366,
0.4135032296180725,
-0.02714637666940689,
0.2175837606191635,
0.34426507353782654,
0.08897853642702103,
-0.07232043147087097,
0.14672082662582397,
0.029161958023905754,
0.1231733039021492,
-0.10716607421636581,
-0.3321574330329895,
0.4527476131916046,
0.5772182941436768,
-0.18976737558841705,
0.5391165018081665,
0.13910654187202454,
-0.2872205972671509,
-0.08323695510625839,
-0.19702914357185364,
0.18346500396728516,
-0.3662942945957184,
0.4077109098434448,
-0.41201990842819214,
-0.7992166876792908,
0.8529462814331055,
0.2008449286222458,
-0.22655846178531647,
0.6254422068595886,
0.12225085496902466,
-0.2810749411582947,
1.0061960220336914,
0.5972667336463928,
0.06233157217502594,
0.5412745475769043,
-0.1549469381570816,
-0.12443938106298447,
-1.4768527746200562,
-0.30726686120033264,
-0.5960301160812378,
-0.4567520320415497,
-0.028673090040683746,
-0.4745631515979767,
0.4992630183696747,
0.4093613922595978,
0.014588103629648685,
0.7293146252632141,
-0.907429575920105,
0.6680150628089905,
0.3198409378528595,
0.586739182472229,
0.3726212680339813,
-0.2333313375711441,
0.23318128287792206,
-0.4431251883506775,
-0.6326679587364197,
-0.42916733026504517,
0.7413945198059082,
0.3421773910522461,
0.9716318845748901,
0.18962819874286652,
0.10927730798721313,
0.8499674201011658,
0.36276325583457947,
-0.7928484082221985,
0.2888016998767853,
-0.4973786175251007,
-0.5983269214630127,
0.17845799028873444,
-0.05475379526615143,
-0.7234077453613281,
0.013975094072520733,
-0.25277799367904663,
-0.87677001953125,
0.4316370487213135,
0.3429272770881653,
-0.5326363444328308,
0.2752504050731659,
-0.7463692426681519,
0.9430168271064758,
-0.17081895470619202,
-0.047666605561971664,
-0.2714405953884125,
-0.4939829707145691,
0.3978089988231659,
0.19417595863342285,
0.1259497106075287,
-0.33367180824279785,
-0.20314277708530426,
0.8946638107299805,
-0.4667767286300659,
0.9059126973152161,
0.013373027555644512,
0.478092223405838,
0.6182770133018494,
0.14710688591003418,
0.11479239165782928,
-0.06294693797826767,
0.14146651327610016,
0.15560659766197205,
0.3802238702774048,
-0.3577064573764801,
-0.9271543622016907,
0.4728524386882782,
-0.60107421875,
-0.5924303531646729,
-0.2016052007675171,
-0.33252498507499695,
-0.21064235270023346,
-0.08480977267026901,
0.5700372457504272,
0.6771395802497864,
-0.22376897931098938,
-0.02532678283751011,
0.23662640154361725,
-0.27982237935066223,
0.08455018699169159,
0.18618156015872955,
0.03389197215437889,
-0.5338749885559082,
0.6741111278533936,
0.1566081941127777,
0.29369527101516724,
0.3250591456890106,
0.11321078985929489,
-0.38181954622268677,
-0.5613690614700317,
-0.5774003863334656,
0.11772982031106949,
-0.8141590356826782,
-0.5850901007652283,
-0.29349493980407715,
-0.14630112051963806,
-0.09758400917053223,
-0.36095768213272095,
-0.20312032103538513,
-0.5294250249862671,
-0.6749687194824219,
-0.31017783284187317,
0.5808687806129456,
0.5992620587348938,
-0.16721270978450775,
0.46365711092948914,
-0.9220027327537537,
0.13980908691883087,
0.3045712411403656,
0.7114521265029907,
0.2705382704734802,
-0.9400782585144043,
-0.3333606719970703,
-0.2423536777496338,
-0.4594927728176117,
-1.0176810026168823,
0.09142155200242996,
0.5993524789810181,
0.3838081955909729,
0.2244838923215866,
0.1526837944984436,
0.8369949460029602,
-0.4815567135810852,
0.8552270531654358,
0.5071882009506226,
-1.3839048147201538,
0.6499360203742981,
0.04755614325404167,
0.24712538719177246,
0.7376605868339539,
0.2408495843410492,
-0.4579698145389557,
-0.42773279547691345,
-0.6047981977462769,
-0.5041375756263733,
0.5059599280357361,
-0.2045910507440567,
0.471845805644989,
-0.0675894170999527,
0.20806679129600525,
0.26666367053985596,
0.022943101823329926,
-0.38666319847106934,
0.25610241293907166,
-0.316021203994751,
-0.16715504229068756,
-0.0029395101591944695,
-0.3599127233028412,
-0.028943294659256935,
-0.38793477416038513,
0.2024141550064087,
-0.28289318084716797,
0.33799055218696594,
0.8318353891372681,
-0.3693229556083679,
0.038355641067028046,
0.24108244478702545,
0.7227608561515808,
0.7554959654808044,
-0.4879499077796936,
0.4204905033111572,
0.2802577614784241,
-0.6021468043327332,
-0.15496233105659485,
-0.11578294634819031,
-0.1740226298570633,
0.18585160374641418,
0.6739656329154968,
1.0274654626846313,
0.9039317965507507,
-0.893318235874176,
0.9897408485412598,
0.2266141176223755,
-0.4173745810985565,
0.016329338774085045,
0.1857762187719345,
-0.4716908037662506,
0.17211152613162994,
0.3588813245296478,
0.47223395109176636,
0.44044792652130127,
-0.6738466620445251,
0.4064290225505829,
0.18008165061473846,
-0.9868260025978088,
-0.5562602877616882,
1.0246442556381226,
0.12636062502861023,
-0.20460543036460876,
0.3200094699859619,
0.14492042362689972,
-0.8641457557678223,
0.5990532636642456,
0.26375290751457214,
0.699830949306488,
0.17054788768291473,
0.49635031819343567,
0.4463629722595215,
0.21768304705619812,
-0.23978191614151,
-0.06778257340192795,
-0.2419205754995346,
-0.6369770765304565,
-0.27186232805252075,
-0.2910386025905609,
-0.7486059069633484,
-0.4657813012599945,
-0.990570068359375,
0.1741480827331543,
-0.7313098311424255,
-0.3006837069988251,
0.030219227075576782,
-0.2914864122867584,
-0.6558533310890198,
0.3142630159854889,
-0.20048277080059052,
1.3653571605682373,
-0.9618080854415894,
0.44720160961151123,
0.37765124440193176,
-0.6750559210777283,
-0.8881098031997681,
-0.3224303126335144,
-0.375463604927063,
-0.531894862651825,
0.39128461480140686,
0.2299078404903412,
-0.02240804396569729,
-0.3577616214752197,
-0.8248280882835388,
-0.7147969603538513,
1.0892248153686523,
0.3553900420665741,
-0.35958075523376465,
-0.02479497157037258,
-0.2733810245990753,
0.5966043472290039,
-0.5567853450775146,
0.06658986955881119,
0.5059051513671875,
0.1483568549156189,
0.14514976739883423,
-1.0387767553329468,
0.005290525034070015,
0.16804145276546478,
-0.19440250098705292,
-0.09290166944265366,
-0.8964765667915344,
0.8967838883399963,
-0.5574842095375061,
-0.48649510741233826,
0.16930487751960754,
0.6218366026878357,
-0.07533036917448044,
0.37929823994636536,
0.42111149430274963,
0.28468361496925354,
0.439063161611557,
-0.023165611550211906,
1.1669977903366089,
0.10257422924041748,
0.6787202954292297,
1.2608028650283813,
-0.16002118587493896,
0.7691062688827515,
0.25979986786842346,
-0.22231081128120422,
0.6022927761077881,
0.4803411662578583,
-0.4160994589328766,
0.7059743404388428,
-0.14304444193840027,
-0.03286758437752724,
-0.11447054892778397,
-0.2774416506290436,
-0.04724865406751633,
0.5874625444412231,
-0.05836571380496025,
-0.7218417525291443,
-0.3771333694458008,
0.09684925526380539,
-0.12646496295928955,
0.528416097164154,
-0.6989330053329468,
0.4233103394508362,
0.20500338077545166,
-0.599830150604248,
0.4266064763069153,
-0.048145949840545654,
0.38481780886650085,
-0.20182843506336212,
-0.11879289150238037,
0.010452515445649624,
0.1376187801361084,
-0.322123646736145,
-1.2983176708221436,
0.7287489771842957,
0.1157577708363533,
-0.4640710949897766,
0.11375732719898224,
0.46061116456985474,
-0.14312906563282013,
-0.3647262752056122,
0.260351300239563,
0.13567185401916504,
0.2756633758544922,
-0.05352451652288437,
-0.8376995921134949,
0.301119863986969,
-0.09460796415805817,
0.5725331902503967,
-0.03814874216914177,
0.06129149720072746,
-0.29788079857826233,
0.6570132374763489,
0.22164419293403625,
0.28139421343803406,
0.028450340032577515,
-0.008588047698140144,
0.8092219233512878,
-0.654859721660614,
-0.7209169268608093,
-0.6563746929168701,
0.1492498219013214,
-0.246022030711174,
-0.5747345685958862,
0.606072187423706,
0.653140664100647,
0.525284469127655,
-0.4259440302848816,
0.5209980010986328,
-0.1842636615037918,
0.6655300855636597,
-0.6801894307136536,
0.4015856981277466,
-0.42357656359672546,
0.031081868335604668,
-0.4891824424266815,
-1.0701091289520264,
-0.35613977909088135,
0.40518513321876526,
-0.3963841199874878,
-0.5054774880409241,
0.7933011054992676,
0.5662286281585693,
-0.34881702065467834,
-0.17047865688800812,
0.21690215170383453,
-0.03308851644396782,
0.02618791162967682,
0.9904378056526184,
0.8468696475028992,
-0.6640961766242981,
0.7151280045509338,
0.010776274837553501,
-0.4258471429347992,
-0.1400783658027649,
-0.7674325704574585,
-0.7516850829124451,
-0.5819932818412781,
-0.48908647894859314,
-0.27645736932754517,
-0.03199082240462303,
0.5617945194244385,
0.8518937230110168,
-0.7838295698165894,
0.13139194250106812,
0.337187796831131,
0.3568646013736725,
-0.565728485584259,
-0.2550986707210541,
0.7725326418876648,
0.13948316872119904,
-0.5416474342346191,
-0.23159189522266388,
0.44058454036712646,
-0.024068767204880714,
-0.2049737125635147,
0.06852321326732635,
0.24320882558822632,
0.32188186049461365,
0.45151287317276,
0.5253413915634155,
-0.5002267360687256,
-0.9479162096977234,
-0.08654923737049103,
-0.04377149045467377,
0.49600642919540405,
0.889935314655304,
-0.6541945338249207,
0.45276403427124023,
0.3123968243598938,
0.31422799825668335,
0.46027708053588867,
0.2765788435935974,
0.3030477464199066,
-0.4911321699619293,
0.12923763692378998,
-0.035775505006313324,
0.29512375593185425,
0.6111027002334595,
-0.20102696120738983,
0.36621013283729553,
0.3717500865459442,
-0.3145279586315155,
-0.6634854674339294,
0.24236363172531128,
-1.6239275932312012,
-0.0642666220664978,
0.7569327354431152,
-0.3882814049720764,
-0.6360994577407837,
-0.12291703373193741,
-0.5636452436447144,
-0.21737608313560486,
-0.24751852452754974,
1.053337574005127,
0.5687729716300964,
0.019657505676150322,
-0.509800374507904,
-0.22824938595294952,
0.6824783682823181,
0.07662443816661835,
-0.5330082178115845,
-0.007146105635911226,
0.4132848083972931,
0.5466341376304626,
0.1228589192032814,
0.5100818872451782,
-0.35219746828079224,
0.7975467443466187,
-0.20140737295150757,
-0.20043453574180603,
-0.25065261125564575,
-0.24522432684898376,
-0.23023244738578796,
0.2874583303928375,
0.11627553403377533,
-0.6376805305480957
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08627v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08627v1
|
Time-MMD: A New Multi-Domain Multimodal Dataset for Time Series Analysis
| 2024-06-12T20:20:09 | 2024-06-12T20:20:09 |
Haoxin Liu, Shangqing Xu, Zhiyuan Zhao, Lingkai Kong, Harshavardhan Kamarthi, Aditya B. Sasanur, Megha Sharma, Jiaming Cui, Qingsong Wen, Chao Zhang, B. Aditya Prakash
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Time series data are ubiquitous across a wide range of real-world domains.
While real-world time series analysis (TSA) requires human experts to integrate
numerical series data with multimodal domain-specific knowledge, most existing
TSA models rely solely on numerical data, overlooking the significance of
information beyond numerical series. This oversight is due to the untapped
potential of textual series data and the absence of a comprehensive,
high-quality multimodal dataset. To overcome this obstacle, we introduce
Time-MMD, the first multi-domain, multimodal time series dataset covering 9
primary data domains. Time-MMD ensures fine-grained modality alignment,
eliminates data contamination, and provides high usability. Additionally, we
develop MM-TSFlib, the first multimodal time-series forecasting (TSF) library,
seamlessly pipelining multimodal TSF evaluations based on Time-MMD for in-depth
analyses. Extensive experiments conducted on Time-MMD through MM-TSFlib
demonstrate significant performance enhancements by extending unimodal TSF to
multimodality, evidenced by over 15% mean squared error reduction in general,
and up to 40% in domains with rich textual data. More importantly, our datasets
and library revolutionize broader applications, impacts, research topics to
advance TSA. The dataset and library are available at
https://github.com/AdityaLab/Time-MMD and
https://github.com/AdityaLab/MM-TSFlib.
|
[
-0.4459437131881714,
-0.6199634671211243,
0.2198609560728073,
0.44863033294677734,
-0.35652628540992737,
0.5033394694328308,
0.36740896105766296,
-0.16999779641628265,
0.22333206236362457,
0.08196832239627838,
-1.0112144947052002,
-0.3914317190647125,
-0.3960735499858856,
-0.1856352835893631,
-0.21132023632526398,
0.8475630879402161,
0.061161864548921585,
-0.0027618829626590014,
-0.17088481783866882,
-0.2544442415237427,
-0.15300673246383667,
-0.797497570514679,
-0.05546903237700462,
-0.06984968483448029,
0.45251262187957764,
0.227992981672287,
0.6369466781616211,
0.3615071475505829,
0.579979658126831,
0.20149901509284973,
0.6165086030960083,
0.7114258408546448,
-0.024350754916667938,
0.006858480162918568,
0.25344961881637573,
0.35059991478919983,
-0.7864763736724854,
-0.013896378688514233,
0.6007214784622192,
0.7239070534706116,
-0.2348410189151764,
0.37953388690948486,
-0.3128969669342041,
0.5309069752693176,
-0.5400002598762512,
0.39101642370224,
0.014066850766539574,
0.24469824135303497,
-0.5654695630073547,
-0.7392981648445129,
-0.245877206325531,
-0.07388679683208466,
0.3121773302555084,
-0.765740692615509,
0.3872217535972595,
0.17920884490013123,
0.5710110664367676,
0.26783016324043274,
-1.11039400100708,
0.3135361075401306,
-1.0872571468353271,
0.9520882964134216,
-0.47280287742614746,
0.5469527244567871,
-0.11493445187807083,
0.49539777636528015,
0.12846854329109192,
-0.40995219349861145,
-0.4092755615711212,
0.32916122674942017,
0.22987087070941925,
0.06286917626857758,
0.014477898366749287,
-0.3838931620121002,
0.20913827419281006,
0.13855214416980743,
-0.9355883002281189,
-0.20571327209472656,
-0.3480304777622223,
-0.1064116358757019,
0.2817774713039398,
0.4098425805568695,
0.11842319369316101,
-0.09960170090198517,
-0.6758953332901001,
-0.02091030776500702,
-0.2474290430545807,
-0.20508086681365967,
0.019359903410077095,
0.416593462228775,
-0.42043307423591614,
0.4516867697238922,
-0.1543203443288803,
0.19771608710289001,
-0.4537619650363922,
-0.3189569115638733,
0.5232126712799072,
-0.2921154201030731,
-0.3961835205554962,
-0.14875440299510956,
0.6064436435699463,
0.5177860260009766,
0.24550344049930573,
-0.1523401439189911,
0.08131605386734009,
0.08385453373193741,
0.018688147887587547,
-1.0031630992889404,
-0.1132194772362709,
0.2246856689453125,
-0.4635690450668335,
-0.42650482058525085,
0.0641319751739502,
-1.2809653282165527,
-0.3034631609916687,
-0.6195894479751587,
0.35696685314178467,
-0.2312641590833664,
-0.623093843460083,
-0.011394950561225414,
-0.26063525676727295,
0.005514764226973057,
0.21516349911689758,
-0.7511247396469116,
0.22114069759845734,
0.5433492660522461,
0.9356828927993774,
-0.13474434614181519,
-0.319295197725296,
-0.3164863586425781,
0.43750089406967163,
-0.15390644967556,
0.8458247780799866,
-0.5055952668190002,
-0.6890981197357178,
-0.2223162055015564,
-0.08223164081573486,
-0.09150613099336624,
-0.3143312335014343,
0.17888383567333221,
-0.6848177909851074,
0.07328842580318451,
0.0019567753188312054,
-0.18591216206550598,
-0.2118324339389801,
0.26298072934150696,
-0.7865211963653564,
0.8858681321144104,
0.05590927600860596,
-0.4940004348754883,
0.5792132616043091,
-1.0035488605499268,
-0.418704628944397,
-0.5389257669448853,
0.20336699485778809,
-0.3916352689266205,
-0.28473198413848877,
0.6466633677482605,
0.6245468854904175,
-0.49038612842559814,
0.4283117353916168,
-0.8550161123275757,
0.35937491059303284,
0.26668617129325867,
-0.8817896842956543,
0.45097002387046814,
0.6601302027702332,
0.1588234156370163,
-0.04519907012581825,
-0.8081496357917786,
0.12137238681316376,
0.03965833783149719,
0.21228370070457458,
-0.3605194091796875,
-0.0074673802591860294,
0.6278278827667236,
0.2927200198173523,
-0.07097296416759491,
-0.5602004528045654,
0.20096272230148315,
0.19758491218090057,
0.5195574164390564,
1.0588685274124146,
0.2134929746389389,
0.22227835655212402,
-0.6147719621658325,
0.7332648038864136,
0.5375953316688538,
0.482885479927063,
-0.4344305992126465,
-0.2779189646244049,
-0.21034054458141327,
-0.27347877621650696,
0.14654770493507385,
0.4149859547615051,
-0.802294909954071,
-0.3272091746330261,
-0.683163583278656,
-0.5915876626968384,
0.030170701444149017,
-0.12912864983081818,
0.04203033074736595,
0.2596244812011719,
0.3302387297153473,
-0.03783312067389488,
-0.6479455232620239,
-0.6445392966270447,
0.12520359456539154,
0.2443915754556656,
0.2718413770198822,
0.012041534297168255,
0.409527987241745,
-0.3103894293308258,
1.0863702297210693,
-0.8008749485015869,
-0.4053252339363098,
0.12131262570619583,
0.2787107229232788,
-0.025919921696186066,
0.46066221594810486,
0.8773739337921143,
-0.782242476940155,
-0.22082935273647308,
-0.0326947458088398,
-0.7955372929573059,
-0.06836345791816711,
-0.19757752120494843,
-0.18598102033138275,
0.08722745627164841,
0.1826116442680359,
-0.4634149968624115,
0.13475869596004486,
0.7664860486984253,
-0.7251464128494263,
0.6420806050300598,
0.029644761234521866,
0.3620067536830902,
-1.3682914972305298,
0.2682439386844635,
0.18835555016994476,
-0.17185992002487183,
-0.6176174879074097,
-0.34558528661727905,
0.017921816557645798,
-0.5963591933250427,
-0.37816110253334045,
0.7419403791427612,
-0.30163997411727905,
-0.17789298295974731,
0.35949215292930603,
-0.12692174315452576,
0.21840374171733856,
0.6690266728401184,
-0.31330159306526184,
0.7174831032752991,
0.11452009528875351,
-0.6566711664199829,
0.46388041973114014,
0.11304845660924911,
-0.32927414774894714,
0.5040673613548279,
-0.2878651022911072,
-0.034870002418756485,
-0.13329385221004486,
0.028264975175261497,
-0.7429164052009583,
-0.15971273183822632,
0.007333314511924982,
-0.28480395674705505,
0.19224639236927032,
-0.0038505306001752615,
-0.4584159851074219,
-0.11778860539197922,
-0.3330206871032715,
0.7791593074798584,
-0.07642555981874466,
-0.5685498118400574,
0.9022368788719177,
0.44903719425201416,
-0.14607425034046173,
-0.6355066299438477,
-0.5257189869880676,
-0.0569942481815815,
-0.1266881823539734,
-0.810214638710022,
0.2985793352127075,
-0.608739972114563,
-0.3109947443008423,
-0.04574451223015785,
-0.3361371159553528,
-0.46454596519470215,
0.09045138210058212,
0.2595035135746002,
0.616478681564331,
-0.2772284150123596,
0.1508648693561554,
0.06543873250484467,
-0.35912665724754333,
-0.07881848514080048,
-0.17954158782958984,
0.4766993820667267,
-0.08938188850879669,
-0.36356255412101746,
-0.49997586011886597,
0.4105755686759949,
1.0180386304855347,
-0.30662351846694946,
0.43616747856140137,
0.8141602277755737,
-0.4490218460559845,
-0.239981546998024,
-0.36523714661598206,
0.12160781770944595,
-0.4446890950202942,
0.06370196491479874,
-0.40314167737960815,
-0.45119744539260864,
0.20657560229301453,
0.006523479241877794,
0.18699194490909576,
0.39628151059150696,
0.16652067005634308,
-0.009972536005079746,
1.0502338409423828,
0.5255158543586731,
-0.14884446561336517,
0.4621230959892273,
-0.42316386103630066,
-0.14084236323833466,
-0.5680422782897949,
-0.39424216747283936,
-0.20753532648086548,
-0.38453227281570435,
-0.20835848152637482,
-0.4105953574180603,
0.6363922357559204,
-0.7048537135124207,
-0.25898459553718567,
-0.24103693664073944,
-0.04479687288403511,
0.2594014108181,
0.2009090632200241,
0.035981763154268265,
0.5494207143783569,
0.05703769251704216,
-0.02389390952885151,
-0.2890520989894867,
-0.306913822889328,
-0.2033693790435791,
1.4449869394302368,
0.1463799774646759,
1.0005544424057007,
0.2508452832698822,
-0.06743817776441574,
1.1489558219909668,
0.1851550042629242,
-0.5968207716941833,
0.35084521770477295,
-0.22754400968551636,
-0.5661407113075256,
0.05703992024064064,
-0.48487207293510437,
-0.5325281023979187,
0.3032217025756836,
-0.11438773572444916,
0.13359427452087402,
0.3002557158470154,
0.059977322816848755,
-0.5338879823684692,
0.5382688641548157,
-1.1239951848983765,
0.9385315775871277,
-0.320809006690979,
-0.1335712969303131,
-0.20192013680934906,
-0.4038715362548828,
0.34442368149757385,
-0.22034262120723724,
0.39549627900123596,
-0.566808819770813,
-0.11258489638566971,
0.740342378616333,
-0.4772626459598541,
0.631578266620636,
-0.41821756958961487,
0.06506741791963577,
-0.05917603150010109,
0.1337713897228241,
-0.04716604948043823,
0.15289616584777832,
0.06404604762792587,
0.18725156784057617,
0.45816969871520996,
-0.5280103087425232,
-0.5565674901008606,
0.7743756771087646,
-0.7991992831230164,
-0.028976542875170708,
-0.8182776570320129,
-0.5686870217323303,
-0.432880699634552,
0.25263649225234985,
-0.36975017189979553,
1.5224000215530396,
-0.3939514458179474,
0.16570346057415009,
0.4899120330810547,
0.20643214881420135,
0.7487929463386536,
0.5942625999450684,
-0.3663715720176697,
-0.39100369811058044,
1.0808262825012207,
0.2542349398136139,
0.1515365093946457,
0.7100120782852173,
0.012461883015930653,
-0.4133366346359253,
-0.11765962839126587,
-0.44288086891174316,
0.19631201028823853,
-0.4810340404510498,
-0.17519399523735046,
-0.4921252131462097,
-0.011891776695847511,
-0.4632289707660675,
0.14223520457744598,
-0.2853469252586365,
-0.6292415857315063,
-0.4060225188732147,
-0.01848197728395462,
0.282010018825531,
0.5304253697395325,
0.12864284217357635,
0.34217220544815063,
-1.0257272720336914,
0.5723438262939453,
0.1693960279226303,
0.38302117586135864,
-0.03308834508061409,
0.014180680736899376,
-0.06619292497634888,
-0.03588322922587395,
-0.5820798277854919,
-0.31362295150756836,
0.8170660734176636,
0.43018245697021484,
0.16069981455802917,
0.7834464907646179,
0.10124120116233826,
0.9516674876213074,
-0.5343639254570007,
0.7187350392341614,
-0.03500072658061981,
-0.7707930207252502,
0.12591460347175598,
-0.4287482798099518,
0.4467141330242157,
-0.31541958451271057,
0.28444841504096985,
-0.9837098717689514,
0.26838037371635437,
-0.39456626772880554,
-0.46901413798332214,
0.903070867061615,
-0.04335008189082146,
-0.27565157413482666,
0.23397508263587952,
-0.2007274627685547,
0.46898627281188965,
0.48238348960876465,
-0.13059397041797638,
-0.4402024745941162,
-0.5298957824707031,
-0.1895017772912979,
-0.4418182075023651,
-0.1564531922340393,
-0.08244725316762924,
0.057221680879592896,
0.5958105325698853,
-0.27687427401542664,
0.5835501551628113,
0.21012865006923676,
-0.16866642236709595,
-0.18295174837112427,
0.30251017212867737,
0.8934837579727173,
0.961667537689209,
-0.5348244309425354,
0.023595008999109268,
-0.21550461649894714,
-0.5082602500915527,
0.08536079525947571,
0.1413731724023819,
0.19427883625030518,
-0.0907534807920456,
0.16975270211696625,
0.530424177646637,
0.14684094488620758,
-0.6968986988067627,
0.23793070018291473,
-0.07216886430978775,
0.1194012388586998,
-0.5493146777153015,
-0.3933321237564087,
-0.3153742849826813,
0.32785218954086304,
0.7479725480079651,
0.6822993159294128,
0.005705847404897213,
-0.362918496131897,
0.23202355206012726,
0.28037336468696594,
0.02368437498807907,
-0.7218164801597595,
0.9986093044281006,
0.3922297954559326,
0.16966970264911652,
0.44489386677742004,
0.033499982208013535,
-0.1948932409286499,
0.6712517738342285,
0.1901969164609909,
0.710216760635376,
-0.19316822290420532,
0.3951427638530731,
0.0135642746463418,
0.31833362579345703,
0.2616998851299286,
0.3731341063976288,
0.028461838141083717,
-0.610373854637146,
-0.3798207938671112,
-0.5036190152168274,
-0.43804970383644104,
0.1439022272825241,
-0.4538700580596924,
0.22661051154136658,
-0.7732571363449097,
-0.460807740688324,
0.14939649403095245,
-0.00522861210629344,
-0.4958820641040802,
0.19465816020965576,
-0.04161200672388077,
0.801468014717102,
-0.6585161089897156,
0.7454107999801636,
0.2613249123096466,
-0.05337294563651085,
-0.03425447270274162,
-0.24604618549346924,
0.5455067753791809,
-0.6133715510368347,
0.45051538944244385,
0.12069715559482574,
-0.19940897822380066,
0.06776431202888489,
-0.24984736740589142,
-0.742459237575531,
1.3832001686096191,
0.010069399140775204,
-0.09264544397592545,
-0.11293918639421463,
0.23471878468990326,
0.1754346787929535,
-0.37143445014953613,
0.2023002952337265,
0.34296491742134094,
0.441947340965271,
0.013866037130355835,
-0.6577324271202087,
-0.2366192787885666,
-0.5685566067695618,
-0.02473154477775097,
0.6728811860084534,
-0.9906908273696899,
0.6604076027870178,
-0.42668843269348145,
-0.2091815024614334,
-0.05323720723390579,
0.7308399081230164,
-0.3000091016292572,
0.7613479495048523,
0.3882140815258026,
0.3583458960056305,
0.5333158373832703,
-0.38084349036216736,
0.7341921925544739,
-0.05818668380379677,
0.43291813135147095,
0.7513124346733093,
-0.359078586101532,
0.5507540106773376,
0.44579464197158813,
-0.18712370097637177,
0.2701290547847748,
0.5330833196640015,
-0.09744162857532501,
0.6010076403617859,
-0.7273730039596558,
-0.2726327180862427,
-0.2979760468006134,
-0.21314996480941772,
-0.4543244242668152,
0.12200547009706497,
0.5143007040023804,
0.2606120705604553,
-0.388290673494339,
0.33409619331359863,
-0.1329077035188675,
-0.29372620582580566,
-0.082534059882164,
0.14870305359363556,
-0.16103540360927582,
0.01952999271452427,
0.0948241651058197,
0.019999681040644646,
0.6188345551490784,
-0.9575625061988831,
0.06892699748277664,
-0.1959446519613266,
0.20370395481586456,
-0.11639915406703949,
-0.5388397574424744,
0.4110095500946045,
-0.136624276638031,
-0.42065081000328064,
-0.49006330966949463,
0.32041531801223755,
-0.193792462348938,
-0.3288072347640991,
0.05582726374268532,
0.5262506604194641,
-0.32192450761795044,
-0.03462120145559311,
-0.37631624937057495,
-0.1495024561882019,
-0.17702612280845642,
-0.13945575058460236,
0.18166284263134003,
0.4848066568374634,
-0.04596865922212601,
1.137226939201355,
0.9416764974594116,
-0.31199559569358826,
0.3153464198112488,
0.13281145691871643,
0.59422367811203,
-0.878426730632782,
-0.3968832790851593,
-0.5767226815223694,
0.44635850191116333,
0.18532976508140564,
-0.3745020031929016,
0.5056081414222717,
0.7815834879875183,
0.45934462547302246,
-0.36512666940689087,
0.7677186727523804,
-0.15896427631378174,
0.7291696667671204,
-0.5525455474853516,
0.5202821493148804,
-0.8507183790206909,
0.19506999850273132,
-0.19173088669776917,
-0.6745098829269409,
-0.3529185950756073,
-0.25666317343711853,
0.08447299897670746,
0.1588723063468933,
0.7536237239837646,
0.6199698448181152,
-0.43504762649536133,
0.343221515417099,
0.2675263583660126,
0.20404277741909027,
0.7584899067878723,
0.3257825970649719,
0.7429918646812439,
-0.41480696201324463,
0.8815891146659851,
-0.4954914450645447,
-0.24588564038276672,
-0.18868596851825714,
-0.9021803736686707,
-0.7998086810112,
-0.7885374426841736,
-0.029187558218836784,
0.007370025385171175,
-0.293547123670578,
1.3254948854446411,
0.715956449508667,
-0.734197199344635,
-0.3516708016395569,
0.7454695105552673,
-0.13973818719387054,
-0.489450067281723,
-0.31800833344459534,
0.3827030658721924,
-0.026963982731103897,
-0.8646597862243652,
0.39284804463386536,
0.2590405344963074,
0.2932077646255493,
-0.34765082597732544,
0.09502524882555008,
-0.24718543887138367,
-0.10252957791090012,
0.8902480602264404,
0.12853914499282837,
-0.309951514005661,
-0.004697693046182394,
0.30828553438186646,
0.18272165954113007,
-0.034521352499723434,
1.0261191129684448,
-0.6432411074638367,
0.6154820919036865,
0.3891279995441437,
0.48741579055786133,
0.3181305229663849,
0.029810449108481407,
0.515480101108551,
-0.9497055411338806,
0.0963873416185379,
-0.11590203642845154,
0.36916038393974304,
0.09412996470928192,
-0.06803995370864868,
0.4584592580795288,
0.8119439482688904,
-0.502842903137207,
-0.7629640698432922,
-0.15698373317718506,
-1.3993338346481323,
-0.05435480177402496,
0.8573991656303406,
0.3845289647579193,
-0.0646812692284584,
-0.28804895281791687,
-0.11657720059156418,
0.08707544952630997,
-0.9542880058288574,
0.6343870162963867,
0.896335780620575,
-0.027073301374912262,
0.19725821912288666,
-0.7431156039237976,
0.2822362184524536,
-0.023375563323497772,
-0.8819066882133484,
0.2940254211425781,
0.5131634473800659,
0.3327381908893585,
-0.008425920270383358,
0.46710771322250366,
-0.14161023497581482,
0.12724512815475464,
-0.10716267675161362,
-0.37510889768600464,
-0.5949837565422058,
-0.7838354110717773,
0.028682924807071686,
0.3015899956226349,
-0.4483097791671753,
-0.2248535007238388
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08619v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08619v1
|
Self-Supervised Speech Representations are More Phonetic than Semantic
| 2024-06-12T20:04:44 | 2024-06-12T20:04:44 |
Kwanghee Choi, Ankita Pasad, Tomohiko Nakamura, Satoru Fukayama, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, eess.AS
|
Self-supervised speech models (S3Ms) have become an effective backbone for
speech applications. Various analyses suggest that S3Ms encode linguistic
properties. In this work, we seek a more fine-grained analysis of the
word-level linguistic properties encoded in S3Ms. Specifically, we curate a
novel dataset of near homophone (phonetically similar) and synonym
(semantically similar) word pairs and measure the similarities between S3M word
representation pairs. Our study reveals that S3M representations consistently
and significantly exhibit more phonetic than semantic similarity. Further, we
question whether widely used intent classification datasets such as Fluent
Speech Commands and Snips Smartlights are adequate for measuring semantic
abilities. Our simple baseline, using only the word identity, surpasses
S3M-based models. This corroborates our findings and suggests that high scores
on these datasets do not necessarily guarantee the presence of semantic
content.
|
[
-0.22924767434597015,
-0.33268752694129944,
0.5404539704322815,
0.1482650339603424,
0.023226963356137276,
-0.16638632118701935,
-0.4293983280658722,
-0.45442864298820496,
0.45200905203819275,
0.6745960116386414,
-0.26357772946357727,
-0.603341281414032,
-0.726659893989563,
0.2127838134765625,
-0.608914852142334,
0.6952227354049683,
0.29835647344589233,
0.16844354569911957,
-0.17782525718212128,
-0.3444717228412628,
-0.2706844210624695,
-0.5719219446182251,
-0.11682214587926865,
-0.21852487325668335,
0.47783708572387695,
0.2892531156539917,
0.7461163997650146,
0.8953992128372192,
0.3767537772655487,
0.25207874178886414,
0.04424849525094032,
-0.23433056473731995,
-0.2824051082134247,
-0.001537466305308044,
-0.1950923055410385,
-0.37848129868507385,
-0.3388100862503052,
0.47075363993644714,
0.7058494687080383,
0.964674174785614,
-0.029034139588475227,
0.3041001558303833,
0.37823548913002014,
0.42068955302238464,
-0.29175272583961487,
0.3576451241970062,
-0.8819426894187927,
-0.06151720508933067,
-0.472025066614151,
-0.27165448665618896,
-0.21158817410469055,
-0.054984040558338165,
0.15821895003318787,
-0.4830380976200104,
0.2894309163093567,
0.008770894259214401,
0.7479251623153687,
0.2748735547065735,
-0.2883625030517578,
-0.5802428126335144,
-0.5236247777938843,
0.8671076893806458,
-0.7293625473976135,
0.7190634608268738,
0.504858136177063,
0.299475759267807,
-0.14727389812469482,
-0.521862268447876,
-0.6345306634902954,
-0.4187008738517761,
-0.04295026510953903,
0.20872525870800018,
-0.025481123477220535,
0.15281589329242706,
-0.09911201894283295,
0.40205422043800354,
-0.49504899978637695,
0.36333829164505005,
-0.2587131857872009,
-0.24546413123607635,
0.7800787091255188,
0.08618239313364029,
0.025462167337536812,
-0.6686447262763977,
-0.47942274808883667,
-0.2686083912849426,
-0.30662640929222107,
0.08204305917024612,
0.38013923168182373,
0.6730705499649048,
0.049071863293647766,
0.9102241396903992,
-0.3380505442619324,
0.687120795249939,
-0.235078826546669,
-0.4429861009120941,
0.3258756101131439,
-0.30144259333610535,
-0.09615179151296616,
0.4550044536590576,
0.8579109907150269,
0.3355600833892822,
0.3759520351886749,
-0.4876222014427185,
-0.007749116513878107,
0.0488567128777504,
0.13273786008358002,
-0.4009685814380646,
-0.1231466680765152,
0.22215335071086884,
-0.518407940864563,
0.00008824423275655136,
0.18631699681282043,
-0.1560739278793335,
-0.17709232866764069,
-0.4793233275413513,
0.6534420847892761,
-0.6128986477851868,
-0.0839846134185791,
0.3530444800853729,
-0.2698124349117279,
0.4695785343647003,
-0.1227838322520256,
-1.1256285905838013,
0.4625399708747864,
0.9587236046791077,
0.6617571711540222,
-0.42023712396621704,
-0.5034322142601013,
-0.12498030811548233,
0.3245963156223297,
-0.42259588837623596,
0.4483470022678375,
-0.5762672424316406,
-0.36712488532066345,
-0.13938455283641815,
-0.04309326410293579,
-0.05030341073870659,
-0.7145506143569946,
0.17720255255699158,
-0.2558363378047943,
0.10246212780475616,
-0.08054428547620773,
-1.134898066520691,
-0.06382337212562561,
-0.10157719254493713,
-0.4543258547782898,
0.9531962871551514,
0.15772731602191925,
-0.7466297745704651,
0.6149758100509644,
-0.26201990246772766,
-0.14632068574428558,
0.08978656679391861,
-0.5450157523155212,
-0.07096654921770096,
0.19018763303756714,
-0.08995257318019867,
0.9864725470542908,
-0.025650033727288246,
0.23689188063144684,
-0.48097819089889526,
-0.36500465869903564,
0.25328996777534485,
-0.15595079958438873,
0.4786074161529541,
0.16594091057777405,
-0.15724514424800873,
-0.011029403656721115,
-0.815986156463623,
-0.04132722318172455,
0.056433744728565216,
-0.027588140219449997,
-0.37465089559555054,
-0.08966916799545288,
-0.3853883147239685,
-0.014589479193091393,
0.561601996421814,
-0.8091856837272644,
-0.10773821920156479,
-0.38524186611175537,
0.23857569694519043,
0.617492139339447,
-0.36130303144454956,
0.5497788190841675,
-0.19621267914772034,
0.10173937678337097,
-0.12210814654827118,
-0.16473345458507538,
0.12113872170448303,
-0.5700078010559082,
-0.5284174680709839,
-0.36962929368019104,
0.3209775686264038,
0.36897045373916626,
-0.2500258982181549,
0.6291676163673401,
-0.6575132608413696,
-0.4155310392379761,
-0.7193489074707031,
0.2882266044616699,
0.2908950746059418,
0.4369548261165619,
0.5203439593315125,
-0.2418653815984726,
-0.1357739120721817,
-1.1983966827392578,
-0.7142483592033386,
-0.197383314371109,
-0.31540563702583313,
0.35201868414878845,
0.16568657755851746,
-0.2995661497116089,
1.186533808708191,
-0.15473313629627228,
-0.69001704454422,
-0.2837021052837372,
-0.008732098154723644,
0.08094464987516403,
0.27134549617767334,
0.5363304615020752,
-0.3533407151699066,
-0.08010030537843704,
-0.1761169284582138,
-0.7826668620109558,
-0.1337040662765503,
0.20302987098693848,
0.2692929208278656,
-0.04796589910984039,
0.6482570767402649,
-0.08836214244365692,
0.2332179993391037,
0.5321293473243713,
-0.3109736740589142,
0.24460595846176147,
-0.07574225962162018,
-0.04651404917240143,
-0.8135959506034851,
-0.30925244092941284,
-0.05332937464118004,
-0.04915910214185715,
-0.646972119808197,
-0.1622617393732071,
0.051076740026474,
-0.037798814475536346,
-0.5100686550140381,
0.6314563751220703,
-0.1423923671245575,
-0.57542884349823,
-0.24274206161499023,
0.4963156282901764,
-0.05432163551449776,
0.37137556076049805,
0.31392955780029297,
0.7019363045692444,
0.6629194617271423,
-0.549236536026001,
0.5235713124275208,
0.11663004010915756,
-0.30930209159851074,
0.4461928904056549,
-0.6107678413391113,
-0.09807852655649185,
-0.12682488560676575,
-0.018794022500514984,
-0.8973109722137451,
-0.5088549256324768,
-0.13034699857234955,
-0.5405446887016296,
0.11966542154550552,
0.020735077559947968,
-0.713817298412323,
-0.14610685408115387,
-0.19869589805603027,
0.31273800134658813,
0.3077497184276581,
-0.5400846600532532,
0.4064287841320038,
0.5680040121078491,
-0.05822257697582245,
0.024601522833108902,
-0.9463087320327759,
-0.017676714807748795,
-0.5378928780555725,
-0.7287315130233765,
0.5992603898048401,
0.5230947136878967,
0.004190824925899506,
0.05754157155752182,
-0.0513632632791996,
-0.00906513910740614,
-0.05879747495055199,
0.21704411506652832,
-0.14616207778453827,
-0.25950855016708374,
0.38141414523124695,
-0.2593201696872711,
-0.03646804019808769,
0.2617305815219879,
-0.3048032224178314,
0.35153570771217346,
-0.3405827581882477,
-0.22078464925289154,
-0.5570558309555054,
0.33195045590400696,
0.2100938856601715,
0.02783171646296978,
0.5459045767784119,
0.6002882122993469,
-0.28269925713539124,
0.09497559815645218,
-0.49703893065452576,
-0.2443942129611969,
-0.43595409393310547,
0.18757806718349457,
-0.7028209567070007,
-1.1284140348434448,
0.6086292862892151,
0.2095789611339569,
-0.2514328956604004,
0.43988943099975586,
0.1573779582977295,
-0.3766375482082367,
0.8932374119758606,
0.2484830915927887,
-0.029439305886626244,
0.27441468834877014,
-0.3348250985145569,
0.09572427719831467,
-0.9895018935203552,
-0.43642184138298035,
-0.38663357496261597,
-0.049466799944639206,
-0.9122114777565002,
-0.3662398159503937,
0.19109302759170532,
-0.03903154656291008,
-0.037132278084754944,
0.5325138568878174,
-0.37669992446899414,
-0.023691311478614807,
0.5951851010322571,
-0.07521025836467743,
-0.008329606615006924,
-0.041177719831466675,
0.07688263803720474,
-0.2785395085811615,
-0.8923937678337097,
-0.7334557771682739,
0.9289171099662781,
0.5346773266792297,
0.6975331902503967,
0.025747181847691536,
1.1586328744888306,
0.044145870953798294,
-0.30732080340385437,
-0.8936912417411804,
0.6863940954208374,
-0.42609500885009766,
-0.4202616214752197,
-0.5216725468635559,
-0.5309260487556458,
-1.1844112873077393,
0.12732097506523132,
-0.13322561979293823,
-0.7742130756378174,
0.04267634451389313,
-0.03390936926007271,
-0.3969062566757202,
0.1630532443523407,
-0.6392963528633118,
0.9172707796096802,
-0.18793387711048126,
-0.07812471687793732,
-0.08619344234466553,
-0.5269243717193604,
0.1860923320055008,
0.006666023749858141,
0.2695717215538025,
-0.5722298622131348,
-0.15097063779830933,
1.116017460823059,
-0.29936492443084717,
0.513308584690094,
-0.018185365945100784,
-0.31356340646743774,
0.2504926919937134,
0.13818883895874023,
-0.12362788617610931,
-0.17490489780902863,
-0.2847200930118561,
0.40833356976509094,
0.2781580984592438,
-0.5967398285865784,
-0.7232071161270142,
1.0901144742965698,
-0.6142040491104126,
-0.6395710706710815,
-0.3317849040031433,
-0.25861263275146484,
-0.45645833015441895,
0.1509227752685547,
0.08091619610786438,
0.6858718991279602,
-0.0333782397210598,
0.20284989476203918,
0.33163923025131226,
0.10612771660089493,
0.39130303263664246,
0.15123407542705536,
-0.2282649427652359,
-0.056869909167289734,
1.2108768224716187,
0.4234560430049896,
0.3478779196739197,
-0.11152897030115128,
0.44557324051856995,
-0.6728267669677734,
-0.5120363235473633,
-0.19497308135032654,
0.1951763927936554,
-0.7309118509292603,
-0.021093538030982018,
-0.6339689493179321,
-0.21250884234905243,
-0.6231687068939209,
0.1965617686510086,
-0.5310910940170288,
-0.5556197166442871,
-0.4734634757041931,
0.03243788704276085,
0.576893150806427,
0.8648214936256409,
-0.2549009621143341,
0.35883286595344543,
-0.5840221643447876,
0.7875058650970459,
0.6284650564193726,
0.6243306994438171,
-0.2810545861721039,
-0.7520053386688232,
-0.14031663537025452,
-0.0164705291390419,
0.11429095268249512,
-0.8218244910240173,
0.22086989879608154,
0.5111359357833862,
0.5886841416358948,
0.34102949500083923,
-0.1034291684627533,
0.6952242255210876,
-0.4033835232257843,
1.034198522567749,
-0.12170875817537308,
-0.9728390574455261,
0.791175127029419,
-0.3270011842250824,
0.24779438972473145,
0.714515209197998,
0.34871578216552734,
-0.1934724748134613,
-0.6686429977416992,
-0.8494575619697571,
-0.5384454131126404,
0.7122622132301331,
0.3808504343032837,
0.31063175201416016,
-0.43369361758232117,
0.3425379693508148,
0.08141536265611649,
-0.04861666262149811,
-0.3905460834503174,
-0.33864128589630127,
-0.51893150806427,
-0.3519655466079712,
-0.13545671105384827,
-0.13484543561935425,
0.12413881719112396,
-0.12697619199752808,
0.23092976212501526,
-0.07130149751901627,
0.31016969680786133,
0.2846618592739105,
0.10597541928291321,
0.6351177096366882,
0.2635621428489685,
0.12233881652355194,
0.11388254165649414,
-0.40024998784065247,
0.5982019305229187,
0.3090246021747589,
-0.3799200654029846,
0.007740816101431847,
0.028332239016890526,
0.4211711883544922,
0.022019898518919945,
0.5748305916786194,
0.5033605098724365,
0.43106716871261597,
-0.5102952718734741,
0.7811523079872131,
-0.0034827881027013063,
-0.02522778883576393,
-0.16599175333976746,
0.32171812653541565,
0.017178066074848175,
-0.059614457190036774,
0.06592028588056564,
-0.1954014003276825,
0.5802767276763916,
-0.8361570835113525,
0.27383214235305786,
0.3948037326335907,
-0.7662609815597534,
-0.12024324387311935,
0.3575921356678009,
0.10003982484340668,
-0.17336393892765045,
0.2441282719373703,
-0.3360822796821594,
-0.27347397804260254,
0.2908214032649994,
0.41277626156806946,
0.5948789119720459,
-0.2048514038324356,
-0.10778333246707916,
0.16595125198364258,
0.03635053336620331,
-0.07497231662273407,
0.3457064628601074,
-0.2819157540798187,
-0.7757357358932495,
-0.09646067023277283,
-0.6836674809455872,
-0.07153521478176117,
-0.009266224689781666,
-0.9039511680603027,
0.2315319925546646,
-0.1711643785238266,
-0.16381634771823883,
0.0530511699616909,
-0.11427677422761917,
-0.6938772201538086,
0.36566248536109924,
0.23687131702899933,
0.6194150447845459,
-0.5705579519271851,
0.9947464466094971,
0.3131028115749359,
0.06228870525956154,
-0.9652778506278992,
-0.14013485610485077,
-0.15362149477005005,
-0.7432835698127747,
0.67191481590271,
0.3740308880805969,
-0.5531339049339294,
0.07748352736234665,
-0.14458297193050385,
-0.8937230706214905,
1.0568721294403076,
0.36285367608070374,
-0.33825573325157166,
0.13352380692958832,
0.6207388043403625,
0.5116607546806335,
-0.5779551863670349,
-0.015905827283859253,
0.948095977306366,
0.1799456626176834,
-0.09367724508047104,
-1.1013603210449219,
-0.23696742951869965,
0.07319795340299606,
0.21302543580532074,
-0.29143190383911133,
-0.31493526697158813,
0.3364417552947998,
0.017507629469037056,
-0.4805218577384949,
-0.029369311407208443,
1.0200282335281372,
0.25061866641044617,
0.2654109299182892,
0.3555843234062195,
0.5480514168739319,
0.712850034236908,
-0.07203727215528488,
1.084633231163025,
-0.36283886432647705,
0.19750458002090454,
1.279619812965393,
-0.19470274448394775,
0.9658085107803345,
0.5191617608070374,
-0.026055656373500824,
0.26976144313812256,
0.47701793909072876,
0.08879666030406952,
0.5498772859573364,
0.27158206701278687,
0.030848532915115356,
-0.2794620990753174,
-0.23778261244297028,
-0.36993294954299927,
1.1027472019195557,
0.47806140780448914,
-0.27532267570495605,
0.02588840015232563,
0.15163001418113708,
-0.20745381712913513,
0.3853704035282135,
-0.30151277780532837,
1.0405957698822021,
0.2193327695131302,
-0.26969584822654724,
0.5501984357833862,
-0.2529422342777252,
0.7403564453125,
-0.3017582893371582,
0.24686364829540253,
0.1440691202878952,
-0.3023374676704407,
-0.212013840675354,
-1.1815357208251953,
0.3760111629962921,
-0.17885439097881317,
0.1942051351070404,
-0.21719315648078918,
0.5320373177528381,
-0.45432278513908386,
-0.35399603843688965,
0.6359552145004272,
0.33035433292388916,
0.4787849485874176,
0.11551608145236969,
-0.4482283890247345,
0.027696341276168823,
-0.40781983733177185,
0.08507965505123138,
-0.12921519577503204,
0.6842289566993713,
0.2039186954498291,
0.650713324546814,
0.2598259150981903,
0.432529091835022,
0.6122285723686218,
0.32777950167655945,
0.4838850200176239,
-0.8916671276092529,
-0.39065879583358765,
-0.6475096344947815,
-0.07508818805217743,
-0.08156584948301315,
-0.32542458176612854,
0.9593735337257385,
0.5840790271759033,
1.0959837436676025,
0.1534394472837448,
0.5766737461090088,
0.3591102361679077,
0.6815150380134583,
-0.7142463326454163,
0.3545156717300415,
-0.4994896948337555,
0.2445853352546692,
-0.30188655853271484,
-0.8934476375579834,
-0.36863675713539124,
0.807424783706665,
-0.3422168791294098,
0.02185419388115406,
0.24817566573619843,
0.8434637188911438,
-0.3765696585178375,
0.20952491462230682,
0.5680100917816162,
-0.06587963551282883,
-0.029741009697318077,
0.18883392214775085,
1.0573515892028809,
-0.49712324142456055,
0.176667720079422,
-0.26667067408561707,
-0.1446687877178192,
-0.31363198161125183,
-0.6837318539619446,
-0.9551294445991516,
-0.7957990765571594,
-0.2571849822998047,
-0.07861323654651642,
-0.21579013764858246,
0.848069965839386,
0.7757240533828735,
-0.5862407088279724,
-0.2890433073043823,
-0.012566746212542057,
-0.21454346179962158,
0.06064028665423393,
-0.17651599645614624,
0.3623998761177063,
-0.4681791365146637,
-0.3961748480796814,
0.6011990904808044,
0.21379929780960083,
0.29168644547462463,
-0.4233061373233795,
-0.1727159172296524,
0.30094465613365173,
0.23123636841773987,
0.5820667743682861,
-0.026701560243964195,
-1.2218574285507202,
-0.6058273911476135,
0.11224998533725739,
-0.35459309816360474,
0.056168507784605026,
0.5184427499771118,
-0.7694752216339111,
0.5289213061332703,
0.4732414484024048,
0.36181122064590454,
0.27995097637176514,
-0.3140866756439209,
0.35172146558761597,
-0.6468865871429443,
0.14771948754787445,
0.27267372608184814,
0.5448238849639893,
0.4868595004081726,
0.03245321661233902,
0.2570949196815491,
-0.20745308697223663,
-0.2860829532146454,
-0.573399543762207,
0.3063719868659973,
-1.27908194065094,
-0.08197994530200958,
1.323067307472229,
-0.1492495834827423,
-0.26902082562446594,
-0.1871979832649231,
0.006886384915560484,
0.33429601788520813,
-0.281657338142395,
0.6494284272193909,
0.5122402310371399,
-0.6018539667129517,
0.12228015810251236,
-0.5043315887451172,
0.7359976172447205,
0.512343168258667,
-0.3173772990703583,
0.09489226341247559,
0.005400583613663912,
0.1670965701341629,
0.4222451150417328,
0.39139479398727417,
-0.3419785499572754,
0.05022117495536804,
-0.16816994547843933,
-0.17935876548290253,
0.07641051709651947,
-0.4678216874599457,
-0.5786467790603638,
0.06446359306573868,
0.14257080852985382,
-0.3140355944633484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08607v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08607v1
|
Reversing the Forget-Retain Objectives: An Efficient LLM Unlearning Framework from Logit Difference
| 2024-06-12T19:26:35 | 2024-06-12T19:26:35 |
Jiabao Ji, Yujian Liu, Yang Zhang, Gaowen Liu, Ramana Rao Kompella, Sijia Liu, Shiyu Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate extensive capability in learning
from documents, LLM unlearning becomes an increasingly important research area
to address concerns of LLMs in terms of privacy, copyright, etc. A conventional
LLM unlearning task typically involves two goals: (1) The target LLM should
forget the knowledge in the specified forget documents, and (2) it should
retain the other knowledge that the LLM possesses, for which we assume access
to a small number of retain documents. To achieve both goals, a mainstream
class of LLM unlearning methods introduces an optimization framework with a
combination of two objectives - maximizing the prediction loss on the forget
documents while minimizing that on the retain documents, which suffers from two
challenges, degenerated output and catastrophic forgetting. In this paper, we
propose a novel unlearning framework called Unlearning from Logit Difference
(ULD), which introduces an assistant LLM that aims to achieve the opposite of
the unlearning goals: remembering the forget documents and forgetting the
retain knowledge. ULD then derives the unlearned LLM by computing the logit
difference between the target and the assistant LLMs. We show that such
reversed objectives would naturally resolve both aforementioned challenges
while significantly improving the training efficiency. Extensive experiments
demonstrate that our method efficiently achieves the intended forgetting while
preserving the LLM's overall capabilities, reducing training time by more than
threefold. Notably, our method loses 0% of model utility on the ToFU benchmark,
whereas baseline methods may sacrifice 17% of utility on average to achieve
comparable forget quality. Our code will be publicly available at
https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/ULD.
|
[
0.1458679586648941,
-0.5105470418930054,
0.4287966191768646,
0.04052693769335747,
-0.20884086191654205,
0.2702845335006714,
-0.2540087401866913,
-0.12057671695947647,
0.09259934723377228,
0.5592355132102966,
-0.5718420147895813,
-0.43936580419540405,
-0.5536766052246094,
-0.33011311292648315,
-0.4819304347038269,
0.7506183385848999,
-0.1709037870168686,
0.06714438647031784,
-0.3897980749607086,
-0.24483709037303925,
-0.5436826348304749,
-0.31025469303131104,
-0.8182454705238342,
-0.840665876865387,
0.3769816756248474,
0.5822991132736206,
0.16427823901176453,
0.473730206489563,
0.22476114332675934,
0.1715758740901947,
-0.19226820766925812,
0.12963923811912537,
-1.0495017766952515,
-0.13370415568351746,
-0.13573867082595825,
-0.5324592590332031,
-0.10682444274425507,
-0.3547121286392212,
0.8239625692367554,
0.617551863193512,
-0.46818405389785767,
0.049493059515953064,
0.2937639355659485,
1.1106791496276855,
-0.6512175798416138,
0.061661943793296814,
-0.7836926579475403,
0.1904274970293045,
0.08038870245218277,
-0.26172471046447754,
-0.5280349254608154,
-0.016334058716893196,
-0.20930981636047363,
-0.5613024830818176,
0.298810750246048,
-0.24038298428058624,
0.7299929261207581,
0.3609817326068878,
-0.12761396169662476,
-0.24508371949195862,
-0.719426155090332,
0.8688583970069885,
-0.6672624349594116,
0.7238876819610596,
0.32024314999580383,
-0.06992392987012863,
-0.24040617048740387,
-0.41819730401039124,
-0.41682612895965576,
0.19786299765110016,
0.12790969014167786,
0.35022643208503723,
-0.24339774250984192,
-0.10876746475696564,
-0.07801754772663116,
0.3142622113227844,
-0.6017829179763794,
0.4545978009700775,
-0.22474658489227295,
-0.1368282586336136,
0.46532589197158813,
-0.09350868314504623,
-0.07462078332901001,
0.12772901356220245,
-0.4043537974357605,
-0.04353945329785347,
-1.0326178073883057,
-0.07959680259227753,
0.19364741444587708,
-0.021072568371891975,
0.1378844827413559,
0.34727299213409424,
-0.2247878611087799,
0.04101155698299408,
0.05387420579791069,
-0.2883260250091553,
0.252564400434494,
0.3037869334220886,
-0.20374839007854462,
0.13386039435863495,
0.29893702268600464,
0.3683997690677643,
-0.03987113758921623,
-0.5571205019950867,
-0.46851128339767456,
-0.1876184344291687,
0.0039820596575737,
-0.5761072635650635,
-0.24718207120895386,
-0.04327358305454254,
-0.5403978228569031,
0.017946366220712662,
-0.1317368596792221,
-0.5241901874542236,
-0.37216299772262573,
-0.3075477182865143,
0.6474589109420776,
-0.486295223236084,
-0.2529815137386322,
0.12003909796476364,
-0.06286568939685822,
0.24637754261493683,
0.502025842666626,
-0.826210618019104,
0.42170578241348267,
0.603960394859314,
0.7764462828636169,
-0.3072507679462433,
-0.3830975294113159,
-0.5971174836158752,
0.2792557179927826,
-0.3015836477279663,
0.5399429798126221,
-0.23285627365112305,
-0.6962777972221375,
-0.10359907150268555,
-0.14394670724868774,
-0.23907826840877533,
-0.5989848971366882,
0.14679330587387085,
-0.5171216726303101,
0.26280149817466736,
-0.2587020993232727,
-0.7136110067367554,
-0.5233824849128723,
0.25316011905670166,
-0.5933902859687805,
1.2405437231063843,
0.09601056575775146,
-0.3699140250682831,
0.224110946059227,
-0.4741150140762329,
-0.29870423674583435,
-0.11186781525611877,
0.003923071548342705,
-0.7081159949302673,
0.18205150961875916,
-0.11133008450269699,
0.4053724706172943,
-0.5018633008003235,
0.5027896165847778,
-0.06554760783910751,
-0.5419036149978638,
-0.001243598759174347,
-0.7206085324287415,
0.7527569532394409,
0.026187755167484283,
-0.43029624223709106,
-0.1431090533733368,
-0.7661099433898926,
-0.23941607773303986,
0.23547115921974182,
-0.731113076210022,
-0.4368760585784912,
0.06153743714094162,
-0.1855984479188919,
-0.09739696979522705,
0.4166458547115326,
-0.49069955945014954,
0.16681647300720215,
-0.2825077474117279,
0.27225521206855774,
1.0098681449890137,
-0.047670628875494,
0.5699558854103088,
-0.5188239216804504,
0.20958822965621948,
-0.03626560792326927,
0.08050616085529327,
-0.18341048061847687,
-0.04892008751630783,
-0.9022017121315002,
-0.16001075506210327,
0.18451321125030518,
0.4249749779701233,
-0.31736546754837036,
0.282235711812973,
0.017045840620994568,
-0.322776198387146,
-0.5376274585723877,
0.7520488500595093,
0.7432873249053955,
0.6160494685173035,
0.38634926080703735,
-0.22623303532600403,
-0.5452739000320435,
-0.5225451588630676,
-0.25119665265083313,
-0.36950522661209106,
0.1595369577407837,
-0.048177264630794525,
0.43210598826408386,
-0.5502671599388123,
0.5514616370201111,
-0.4766973555088043,
-0.5935114622116089,
-0.1795458346605301,
0.027240583673119545,
0.14046965539455414,
0.4732257127761841,
0.17287375032901764,
-0.8672672510147095,
-0.36163222789764404,
-0.03352058306336403,
-0.8636004328727722,
0.021910762414336205,
-0.3883008360862732,
-0.024848073720932007,
0.6345490217208862,
0.7913029193878174,
-0.5431616902351379,
0.4489026665687561,
0.3332599401473999,
-0.010657777078449726,
0.5957116484642029,
-0.30417361855506897,
-0.0914977639913559,
-0.9813771843910217,
0.10318382829427719,
-0.5602059960365295,
-0.11859928071498871,
-0.43550777435302734,
-0.031364064663648605,
0.06284541636705399,
0.025184959173202515,
-0.40491247177124023,
0.7028337121009827,
-0.6564035415649414,
0.00501925777643919,
-0.059971295297145844,
0.018261540681123734,
0.12555646896362305,
0.7360469698905945,
0.004845491610467434,
0.43055489659309387,
0.35437679290771484,
-0.5347930788993835,
0.06688877195119858,
0.263313889503479,
0.04146036133170128,
0.32509446144104004,
-0.3820790648460388,
0.20246431231498718,
-0.24725571274757385,
0.006932982709258795,
-1.0498294830322266,
0.1379602551460266,
0.06487385183572769,
-0.2646176815032959,
0.5838979482650757,
0.08223903924226761,
-0.5176101922988892,
-0.149398535490036,
-0.4927155375480652,
0.21645499765872955,
0.7433513402938843,
-0.8326129913330078,
0.7113125920295715,
0.15667352080345154,
-0.011018983088433743,
-0.8196253180503845,
-0.6562130451202393,
0.007145796902477741,
-0.414089173078537,
-0.17970113456249237,
0.5314174294471741,
-0.11792229861021042,
-0.018461797386407852,
0.2260119915008545,
-0.4470283091068268,
-0.03368331864476204,
0.051162879914045334,
0.4040846824645996,
0.13433581590652466,
-0.09118633717298508,
0.5647594928741455,
0.13319431245326996,
-0.23917058110237122,
-0.10167355835437775,
-0.48941728472709656,
0.5193508863449097,
-0.057955317199230194,
-0.6262208819389343,
-0.3084014356136322,
0.37576085329055786,
0.2789338529109955,
0.02614341303706169,
0.6767252683639526,
0.6058124899864197,
-0.5876700282096863,
-0.23935310542583466,
-0.8387730717658997,
-0.1595829725265503,
-0.451384574174881,
0.452386736869812,
-0.1637982279062271,
-0.7412481904029846,
0.5220829844474792,
-0.37244731187820435,
0.47853514552116394,
0.35823601484298706,
0.3170992136001587,
-0.17228738963603973,
0.5118616819381714,
0.9763559103012085,
-0.26926782727241516,
0.49024155735969543,
-0.5462158918380737,
0.08703945577144623,
-0.8457627892494202,
-0.47027602791786194,
-0.1997700035572052,
-0.2805155813694,
-0.11358001828193665,
-0.19735068082809448,
0.09529569000005722,
0.7033247351646423,
-0.20094726979732513,
0.2700936496257782,
-0.35064131021499634,
0.6073601841926575,
0.6665067672729492,
0.0942329689860344,
0.6525656580924988,
-0.017672643065452576,
-0.2439144253730774,
0.19903253018856049,
-0.8782306909561157,
-0.5127055644989014,
1.2475626468658447,
0.1928357034921646,
0.8539801836013794,
0.20410215854644775,
1.3134994506835938,
0.30186402797698975,
0.3028935492038727,
-0.6088562607765198,
0.665694534778595,
-0.34312543272972107,
-0.2591148316860199,
-0.5618870258331299,
-0.4051682651042938,
-0.9165529012680054,
0.10166073590517044,
-0.01926831342279911,
-0.9307557940483093,
-0.026428693905472755,
0.42008471488952637,
-0.024288207292556763,
0.6407210230827332,
-0.746073305606842,
0.7605201005935669,
-0.19684168696403503,
-0.327279657125473,
-0.44263750314712524,
-0.4940092861652374,
0.28343841433525085,
-0.43544214963912964,
-0.04596075043082237,
-0.08275768905878067,
0.17552459239959717,
0.9711068868637085,
-0.3366045355796814,
1.0148874521255493,
-0.1920800805091858,
-0.07730734348297119,
0.23489978909492493,
0.21492648124694824,
0.5323613286018372,
0.08569711446762085,
-0.2030864953994751,
0.15190808475017548,
-0.16658920049667358,
-0.3403509557247162,
-0.5512619614601135,
0.7469666004180908,
-0.6872126460075378,
-0.6678121089935303,
-0.11297663301229477,
-0.40150365233421326,
0.11347445100545883,
0.5257411599159241,
0.3908161222934723,
0.40556007623672485,
-0.5402082800865173,
0.11791279166936874,
0.9373660087585449,
-0.21354511380195618,
0.7474477291107178,
0.6461944580078125,
-0.2637736201286316,
-0.016995113343000412,
1.1630947589874268,
0.13769970834255219,
0.38200122117996216,
0.9746628999710083,
0.1709500402212143,
-0.6153792142868042,
-0.5091116428375244,
-0.16081620752811432,
0.3867192268371582,
-0.9207196235656738,
-0.28360715508461,
-0.307448148727417,
-0.1127457544207573,
-0.25393733382225037,
-0.4533771276473999,
-0.5450888872146606,
-0.3705722689628601,
-0.6782613396644592,
0.002787048229947686,
0.2737991511821747,
0.6097148656845093,
-0.34896478056907654,
0.33517780900001526,
-0.5860897898674011,
0.32043278217315674,
0.24684150516986847,
0.3025990426540375,
0.15375185012817383,
-0.6655445694923401,
-0.1358368694782257,
0.048216864466667175,
-0.5497593879699707,
-0.4964120388031006,
0.35540032386779785,
0.3516484200954437,
0.6328497529029846,
0.5702711939811707,
0.11882278323173523,
0.6586766839027405,
-0.3237890601158142,
0.2520737051963806,
0.6195695400238037,
-0.8607765436172485,
0.24195048213005066,
-0.09852427244186401,
0.29835689067840576,
0.5136274695396423,
0.12929433584213257,
-0.6334567070007324,
-0.16511967778205872,
-0.6822695136070251,
-0.9035243391990662,
0.5654779672622681,
-0.12164553254842758,
-0.08445881307125092,
0.28521648049354553,
0.3043651580810547,
0.40622466802597046,
0.3149925470352173,
-0.6805422306060791,
-0.15312474966049194,
-0.029832011088728905,
-0.14792312681674957,
-0.35128727555274963,
-0.2863817512989044,
-0.03828468918800354,
-0.10863421112298965,
0.8648103475570679,
0.049445442855358124,
0.3559885025024414,
-0.01477145403623581,
-0.5400541424751282,
-0.11762367188930511,
0.34210312366485596,
0.34997645020484924,
0.5466403365135193,
-0.19382061064243317,
0.16901862621307373,
0.5026965141296387,
-0.33988380432128906,
0.2659679353237152,
-0.0018093049293383956,
-0.3537624478340149,
0.008462920784950256,
0.3043982684612274,
0.7177932262420654,
0.483485609292984,
-0.8044067621231079,
0.23173119127750397,
0.2569849193096161,
-0.44921186566352844,
-0.5981084108352661,
-0.02386319823563099,
0.4938099682331085,
0.21069017052650452,
0.4452444612979889,
-0.041859615594148636,
-0.03527919203042984,
-0.5000165104866028,
0.31936538219451904,
0.3919534385204315,
-0.237264484167099,
-0.057789284735918045,
0.6794215440750122,
0.09608762711286545,
-0.5105763673782349,
0.6759943962097168,
-0.2447444200515747,
-0.3489939570426941,
0.36260855197906494,
0.7329770922660828,
0.8822038769721985,
-0.3161737620830536,
0.34133923053741455,
-0.05234680324792862,
0.12549030780792236,
-0.40410229563713074,
-0.019769344478845596,
-0.0241728276014328,
-0.7616441249847412,
-0.07867630571126938,
-0.5082346200942993,
-0.2543960213661194,
0.26311933994293213,
-0.6435999274253845,
0.15638312697410583,
-0.5446218252182007,
0.2896776795387268,
-0.2504642605781555,
0.01596779190003872,
-0.5705963373184204,
0.04947400838136673,
-0.3880569040775299,
0.568474292755127,
-0.5632214546203613,
0.653118908405304,
0.4492582678794861,
-0.25376659631729126,
-0.6681877374649048,
-0.0909913182258606,
0.26026320457458496,
-1.0668721199035645,
0.500396728515625,
0.286959171295166,
-0.37552547454833984,
0.13647840917110443,
-0.13861124217510223,
-0.5574248433113098,
1.268309473991394,
0.5736129283905029,
-1.0498409271240234,
-0.24933506548404694,
-0.011188267730176449,
0.22576090693473816,
-0.16004915535449982,
-0.11050327867269516,
0.5761557221412659,
0.18102671205997467,
0.13961157202720642,
-0.6038952469825745,
-0.043396204710006714,
-0.10198421031236649,
-0.17826049029827118,
0.46366825699806213,
-0.7229198217391968,
0.7194936275482178,
-0.5915577411651611,
-0.2506345510482788,
-0.0025589079596102238,
0.3188490867614746,
0.07539458572864532,
0.538843035697937,
0.39432936906814575,
0.7247609496116638,
0.9322349429130554,
0.10539624094963074,
0.4565531015396118,
0.2483544647693634,
0.3705938756465912,
1.2362375259399414,
-0.21893347799777985,
0.8213037848472595,
0.6676496863365173,
-0.0031929765827953815,
0.1157464012503624,
0.4071142077445984,
0.13746292889118195,
0.5518378019332886,
0.0782037079334259,
-0.337378591299057,
-0.13052508234977722,
0.18179185688495636,
-0.21872276067733765,
0.40156280994415283,
0.1640828549861908,
-0.10079025477170944,
-0.3855534493923187,
-0.01927756704390049,
0.14333274960517883,
0.2970559597015381,
-0.3018389046192169,
0.9275146722793579,
0.16156654059886932,
-0.32579612731933594,
0.9177733659744263,
-0.019216107204556465,
0.5261595845222473,
-0.5064258575439453,
-0.14280521869659424,
-0.4240967929363251,
0.6829581260681152,
-0.21783782541751862,
-0.2853238880634308,
0.13852711021900177,
-0.20825235545635223,
-0.28193068504333496,
-0.32564157247543335,
0.536033034324646,
-0.6755355000495911,
-0.36952048540115356,
0.5667321681976318,
0.35214877128601074,
0.3359532356262207,
0.14197909832000732,
-0.8348562121391296,
-0.06094566732645035,
0.34475600719451904,
-0.17205557227134705,
0.4504542350769043,
0.2429935783147812,
-0.06629844754934311,
0.955830991268158,
0.3764261305332184,
0.031469665467739105,
-0.11264187842607498,
0.1283598393201828,
0.8086833953857422,
-0.5318724513053894,
-0.32600468397140503,
-0.7880839109420776,
0.3678201735019684,
0.13455656170845032,
-0.35541582107543945,
0.4861883223056793,
0.6651819944381714,
0.9322538375854492,
-0.007656519301235676,
0.6936312913894653,
0.2747722864151001,
0.6470789313316345,
-0.9510223269462585,
0.7467442154884338,
-0.7904965281486511,
0.5474786162376404,
-0.2956864535808563,
-1.0490376949310303,
-0.25919631123542786,
0.44498181343078613,
0.005723017267882824,
0.014292273670434952,
0.7419916987419128,
0.9365469813346863,
0.004204169847071171,
-0.24730674922466278,
0.5449785590171814,
0.03507048636674881,
0.3612165153026581,
0.9309120178222656,
0.6468458771705627,
-0.4288833439350128,
0.6032778024673462,
-0.11210620403289795,
-0.14004364609718323,
-0.299405038356781,
-0.732184112071991,
-0.9324666857719421,
-0.6902599930763245,
-0.3614436388015747,
0.02570197731256485,
0.5160214304924011,
0.716572642326355,
0.26051363348960876,
-0.6784708499908447,
-0.29890015721321106,
-0.4190789759159088,
0.4003738462924957,
-0.22200307250022888,
-0.17948082089424133,
0.514631986618042,
-0.2220374494791031,
-0.5118035674095154,
0.3779650926589966,
0.3260067403316498,
0.1729416400194168,
-0.12511706352233887,
-0.564093291759491,
-0.43119296431541443,
-0.1546962559223175,
0.42648571729660034,
0.7645065784454346,
-0.6411855220794678,
-0.08672474324703217,
-0.054431285709142685,
0.23454168438911438,
0.012549564242362976,
0.7837399244308472,
-0.7211509943008423,
0.3076164722442627,
0.0845368281006813,
0.9242280721664429,
0.7928394079208374,
-0.0954163521528244,
0.3485473692417145,
-0.7760779857635498,
0.08670656383037567,
0.006472415290772915,
0.3118423521518707,
0.37096256017684937,
-0.3886258602142334,
0.46403953433036804,
0.2601945102214813,
-0.35330551862716675,
-1.0027363300323486,
0.13154585659503937,
-0.6184943318367004,
-0.502870500087738,
1.0969842672348022,
-0.2770374119281769,
0.1040324792265892,
-0.11887834966182709,
-0.2013721913099289,
0.4231507480144501,
-0.5607717633247375,
0.9684605002403259,
0.388350248336792,
-0.06603977084159851,
-0.21439525485038757,
-0.14898447692394257,
0.3958180248737335,
0.7108103036880493,
-0.5840251445770264,
0.36650556325912476,
0.35747700929641724,
0.34166568517684937,
0.02282332442700863,
0.951582133769989,
-0.16170768439769745,
0.29027318954467773,
-0.11991970241069794,
0.21497680246829987,
-0.23704217374324799,
-0.7258060574531555,
-0.3733779489994049,
-0.13097144663333893,
0.06626173108816147,
-0.2993535101413727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08606v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08606v1
|
End-to-End Argument Mining as Augmented Natural Language Generation
| 2024-06-12T19:22:29 | 2024-06-12T19:22:29 |
Nilmadhab Das, Vishal Choudhary, V. Vijaya Saradhi, Ashish Anand
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Argument Mining (AM) is a crucial aspect of computational argumentation,
which deals with the identification and extraction of Argumentative Components
(ACs) and their corresponding Argumentative Relations (ARs). Most prior works
have solved these problems by dividing them into multiple subtasks. And the
available end-to-end setups are mostly based on the dependency parsing
approach. This work proposes a unified end-to-end framework based on a
generative paradigm, in which the argumentative structures are framed into
label-augmented text, called Augmented Natural Language (ANL). Additionally, we
explore the role of different types of markers in solving AM tasks. Through
different marker-based fine-tuning strategies, we present an extensive study by
integrating marker knowledge into our generative model. The proposed framework
achieves competitive results to the state-of-the-art (SoTA) model and
outperforms several baselines.
|
[
-0.6628493070602417,
-1.2348828315734863,
0.4224058985710144,
-0.23511338233947754,
-0.47381728887557983,
0.20020483434200287,
-0.12264924496412277,
-0.4762069284915924,
0.26843488216400146,
0.4416886568069458,
-0.539642333984375,
-0.5885321497917175,
-0.5729622840881348,
0.4364311993122101,
-0.26705533266067505,
1.1422779560089111,
-0.15349476039409637,
-0.28292155265808105,
-0.29347139596939087,
-0.28425195813179016,
-0.24236133694648743,
-0.8517078757286072,
-0.9522038698196411,
-0.24509099125862122,
0.26487818360328674,
0.5500085949897766,
0.6711201667785645,
0.9858220219612122,
-0.13593606650829315,
0.3201802670955658,
-0.24408619105815887,
0.560149073600769,
0.07702836394309998,
0.33636850118637085,
-0.3398156762123108,
-0.15985071659088135,
-0.4825499355792999,
-0.2157394140958786,
0.15238039195537567,
0.45483505725860596,
0.18304593861103058,
0.09726767987012863,
-0.31094682216644287,
0.4331054985523224,
-0.8416748642921448,
0.05299302935600281,
-0.539942741394043,
0.008750158362090588,
-0.35439977049827576,
-0.4509539306163788,
-0.3879237771034241,
-0.010019459761679173,
0.06144212186336517,
-0.7564313411712646,
0.2424544095993042,
0.27341488003730774,
1.0811039209365845,
0.08779515326023102,
-0.3499671220779419,
-0.7522990703582764,
-0.356044739484787,
0.4474984407424927,
-0.9337030649185181,
-0.009222906082868576,
0.114996537566185,
0.15078313648700714,
-0.3100941479206085,
-0.6528232097625732,
-0.5996423363685608,
0.020372219383716583,
0.010503930039703846,
0.15867692232131958,
-0.22974491119384766,
0.36776497960090637,
0.017995893955230713,
0.5648733973503113,
-0.0765230655670166,
0.19366411864757538,
0.02002798393368721,
-0.13942499458789825,
0.48784154653549194,
0.013893978670239449,
0.5336459279060364,
-0.3232156038284302,
-0.49507975578308105,
0.26287439465522766,
-0.5858174562454224,
-0.010512311942875385,
0.5358402132987976,
0.5648434162139893,
-0.08132326602935791,
0.7124465107917786,
-0.3542824685573578,
1.020213007926941,
0.2756664454936981,
0.42884397506713867,
-0.29093995690345764,
-0.17949385941028595,
-0.26776641607284546,
0.45960748195648193,
0.8535578846931458,
0.39165186882019043,
0.41802480816841125,
-0.01292307861149311,
0.09217019379138947,
0.24015997350215912,
0.18217472732067108,
-0.6291821002960205,
-0.3049266040325165,
0.023131683468818665,
-0.26877930760383606,
-0.21969293057918549,
-0.32480907440185547,
-0.8514137864112854,
-0.626714289188385,
-0.5634212493896484,
0.30224356055259705,
-0.410736620426178,
-0.17026540637016296,
0.14382979273796082,
-0.003449368756264448,
0.057917382568120956,
0.1863824874162674,
-1.1829413175582886,
0.3511946499347687,
0.7522866129875183,
0.8343241810798645,
-0.01123118493705988,
0.036383628845214844,
-0.7549496293067932,
0.26217278838157654,
-0.4314934313297272,
1.477838158607483,
-0.9365512132644653,
-0.3638860881328583,
0.3834695518016815,
-0.355642706155777,
0.07678782939910889,
-0.751756489276886,
0.9877792000770569,
-0.5149540901184082,
0.4620019197463989,
-0.2906140685081482,
-0.8719826340675354,
-0.41448917984962463,
0.5535798072814941,
-0.5129401087760925,
0.9819198250770569,
-0.0038344990462064743,
-0.5523486137390137,
0.6394467949867249,
-0.9679689407348633,
-0.6414802670478821,
0.3961467146873474,
-0.3698744773864746,
-0.49795103073120117,
0.1782597005367279,
0.37823963165283203,
0.4776623547077179,
-0.6905581951141357,
0.33294564485549927,
-0.06413430720567703,
0.0026845457032322884,
-0.14051848649978638,
-0.1286749541759491,
0.6377082467079163,
0.14032842218875885,
-0.22917285561561584,
0.45145082473754883,
-0.955085813999176,
-0.17646336555480957,
-0.22168955206871033,
-0.4487036466598511,
-0.4135599434375763,
0.2827208638191223,
-0.1187710165977478,
0.25788357853889465,
0.2899216115474701,
-0.7986366748809814,
0.10443955659866333,
-0.4636330008506775,
0.47295865416526794,
0.6653851270675659,
0.3989926278591156,
0.08177582919597626,
0.037190526723861694,
0.3427716791629791,
0.0821247547864914,
-0.1312011182308197,
-0.3192034363746643,
-0.6649938821792603,
-1.0451173782348633,
-0.25479623675346375,
0.2946167290210724,
0.46471935510635376,
-0.525803804397583,
0.6346988081932068,
-0.12852327525615692,
-0.010096121579408646,
-0.5907196998596191,
0.019794706255197525,
0.5384913086891174,
0.5273944139480591,
0.6530275344848633,
-0.24063856899738312,
-1.0086922645568848,
-0.8342163562774658,
-0.3969661295413971,
-0.4425223767757416,
0.032831549644470215,
0.13211959600448608,
0.23588235676288605,
-0.22207233309745789,
1.3020353317260742,
-0.3663642406463623,
-0.4123081564903259,
-0.1442333310842514,
0.451134592294693,
0.07774733752012253,
0.1541110724210739,
0.32198014855384827,
-0.5236448645591736,
-0.673041582107544,
0.517898678779602,
-0.8334439992904663,
-0.32201269268989563,
-0.3300378918647766,
-0.21012312173843384,
0.22433310747146606,
0.5399428606033325,
-0.4720150828361511,
0.411567360162735,
0.03438560664653778,
-0.7439751029014587,
0.6267307996749878,
-0.1417902410030365,
0.17682716250419617,
-1.2265584468841553,
-0.21387982368469238,
0.09110110998153687,
-0.041279979050159454,
-0.8205868005752563,
0.01149584911763668,
-0.39449575543403625,
0.06744911521673203,
-0.10705310851335526,
0.5179508924484253,
-0.270841121673584,
0.3944258689880371,
-0.5184839963912964,
-0.3108510971069336,
0.16393770277500153,
0.38912925124168396,
0.1826101690530777,
0.5807688236236572,
0.4713694155216217,
-0.4941568672657013,
0.5541641116142273,
0.23076267540454865,
0.03189588338136673,
0.7776123285293579,
-0.4018740653991699,
-0.01072628702968359,
-0.039509017020463943,
-0.13387992978096008,
-0.7470734119415283,
-0.1230928897857666,
0.18089598417282104,
-0.4648659825325012,
0.26349636912345886,
-0.45153599977493286,
-0.45155975222587585,
0.27486756443977356,
-0.09430069476366043,
0.12415605038404465,
0.04811953008174896,
-0.8880895972251892,
0.7695537805557251,
0.32293760776519775,
-0.2546880841255188,
-0.2351386845111847,
-0.1632649451494217,
0.6155335307121277,
-0.4683723747730255,
-0.4706454575061798,
0.5456694960594177,
0.04993981868028641,
-0.17163164913654327,
0.16525804996490479,
0.3077000677585602,
0.006644895300269127,
-0.23596525192260742,
0.202625572681427,
-0.10977990925312042,
-0.3309355676174164,
0.0554991252720356,
0.028600912541151047,
-0.4494868516921997,
0.14099404215812683,
-0.10506400465965271,
0.3911769390106201,
-0.05810004472732544,
-0.2602136433124542,
-0.09456991404294968,
0.9818546175956726,
0.5798276662826538,
-0.16429339349269867,
0.6566209197044373,
0.2089037150144577,
-0.5945138335227966,
-0.08581549674272537,
-0.6225487589836121,
0.13694870471954346,
-0.43473854660987854,
0.22808139026165009,
-0.48544836044311523,
-0.7983923554420471,
0.6136261820793152,
-0.500996470451355,
0.4361971318721771,
0.5460778474807739,
0.8913170099258423,
0.1962428241968155,
1.0613682270050049,
0.2707325518131256,
0.04906691983342171,
0.3043239414691925,
-0.007702184375375509,
0.5092288851737976,
-0.7526583671569824,
-0.24809995293617249,
-0.28474482893943787,
0.058434903621673584,
-0.17089232802391052,
-0.3420966863632202,
0.17878933250904083,
0.46796947717666626,
-0.39579176902770996,
0.23398305475711823,
-0.6088989973068237,
0.30758488178253174,
0.4536821246147156,
-0.42244043946266174,
0.3632732927799225,
0.1879892647266388,
-0.3138250708580017,
0.03524477407336235,
-0.5142762064933777,
-0.6645175218582153,
0.724225640296936,
0.21468260884284973,
0.04521511495113373,
0.13029834628105164,
0.6018152236938477,
0.4959534704685211,
0.44683870673179626,
-0.8113433718681335,
0.6301242709159851,
-0.3779881000518799,
-0.6719701886177063,
-0.03503856435418129,
0.005582061596214771,
-0.6460559964179993,
0.3460933566093445,
-0.5014171004295349,
-0.6337918639183044,
0.16478821635246277,
0.26847830414772034,
-0.30879729986190796,
0.5816367864608765,
-0.8741855621337891,
0.9510270357131958,
-0.09954653680324554,
-0.506931483745575,
0.24060800671577454,
-0.4160105884075165,
0.06482435762882233,
0.33087167143821716,
0.210647314786911,
-0.10185899585485458,
0.34862321615219116,
0.7944899201393127,
-0.8099949955940247,
0.7073646783828735,
-0.21862785518169403,
-0.0669177919626236,
0.8680451512336731,
-0.19358402490615845,
0.4364132881164551,
-0.000318925769533962,
-0.2849375009536743,
-0.19180262088775635,
-0.2422776222229004,
-0.30031970143318176,
-0.6361281871795654,
0.41634082794189453,
-0.44769302010536194,
-0.6035731434822083,
-0.404766708612442,
-0.31102463603019714,
-0.08107321709394455,
0.0018169874092563987,
0.5264615416526794,
0.41918885707855225,
-0.0002604805922601372,
-0.14409798383712769,
0.3387722969055176,
-0.019538456574082375,
0.5129323601722717,
0.40085917711257935,
0.21394918859004974,
-0.5095323324203491,
1.15150785446167,
-0.022510666400194168,
-0.22346101701259613,
0.2660661041736603,
0.45011958479881287,
-0.6043663620948792,
-0.7116394639015198,
-1.0631870031356812,
-0.2447800189256668,
-0.7139978408813477,
-0.5425873398780823,
-0.6246858239173889,
-0.1322702169418335,
-0.20077350735664368,
-0.3714239001274109,
-0.4251870810985565,
-0.256539911031723,
-0.47252336144447327,
-0.22150294482707977,
0.704339861869812,
0.5719456672668457,
0.05551924183964729,
0.17318128049373627,
-0.48398303985595703,
0.4102035462856293,
0.307332307100296,
0.5329462885856628,
-0.04150201380252838,
-0.21791574358940125,
-0.27741727232933044,
-0.05785559490323067,
-0.280940443277359,
-0.9805306792259216,
0.3312036991119385,
0.49759647250175476,
0.32920852303504944,
0.5610054135322571,
0.3296213746070862,
0.9796497821807861,
-0.6457527875900269,
0.8341413736343384,
0.34336382150650024,
-0.9015212059020996,
0.5311909914016724,
-0.27580833435058594,
0.08061669766902924,
0.5393170118331909,
-0.018467949703335762,
-0.38338789343833923,
-0.21286043524742126,
-0.502933919429779,
-1.2757004499435425,
0.3046584129333496,
0.07373639196157455,
-0.13132748007774353,
-0.41422539949417114,
0.4927438497543335,
0.13979490101337433,
-0.05147022008895874,
-0.7458444237709045,
-0.1409890353679657,
-0.1902076154947281,
-0.2530454099178314,
0.29871994256973267,
-0.43584689497947693,
-0.15638504922389984,
-0.19699180126190186,
0.6578815579414368,
-0.19049400091171265,
-0.07397832721471786,
0.06885781139135361,
-0.027605265378952026,
-0.229444682598114,
0.6596353054046631,
0.36716780066490173,
0.1276482492685318,
-0.07006167620420456,
0.3952537775039673,
0.3019792139530182,
-0.1462215930223465,
0.1443168818950653,
0.28409871459007263,
-0.2852415442466736,
0.0763322189450264,
0.42151105403900146,
0.8891984224319458,
-0.10455266386270523,
-0.6255660057067871,
0.04403623566031456,
0.11302674561738968,
-0.3375367820262909,
-0.22756585478782654,
-0.2541109025478363,
0.008951355703175068,
0.08420782536268234,
0.37985408306121826,
-0.09982788562774658,
0.39669662714004517,
-0.5807925462722778,
0.24528691172599792,
0.5496461391448975,
-0.4970332384109497,
-0.2937517464160919,
0.6077383756637573,
0.3228536546230316,
-0.4331367015838623,
0.12563568353652954,
-0.42733150720596313,
-0.7849082350730896,
0.24293044209480286,
0.7136205434799194,
0.8122439980506897,
-0.11267019808292389,
0.047683387994766235,
0.22140389680862427,
-0.11732447147369385,
0.46170052886009216,
0.23847390711307526,
-0.19768351316452026,
-0.5412551164627075,
-0.6949093341827393,
-0.8611569404602051,
-0.5223200917243958,
-0.025318533182144165,
-0.613679826259613,
0.19443130493164062,
-0.4183804392814636,
-0.007437348831444979,
0.1616254448890686,
0.16914358735084534,
-0.013998009264469147,
0.44494158029556274,
0.15629751980304718,
0.4264351427555084,
-1.0774141550064087,
0.3388247787952423,
1.244680643081665,
-0.12226781994104385,
-0.3002050817012787,
-0.3850344121456146,
-0.1403881460428238,
-0.18154014647006989,
0.3146418035030365,
0.10178431868553162,
-0.31215497851371765,
-0.13430173695087433,
-0.26829400658607483,
-0.3763870596885681,
0.5070238709449768,
0.38847851753234863,
0.16837087273597717,
0.27663856744766235,
0.38263610005378723,
0.8325350880622864,
-0.6620131731033325,
0.2814309000968933,
0.6161698698997498,
0.1841651201248169,
0.29606929421424866,
-0.30550074577331543,
0.2547323703765869,
-0.6434609293937683,
-0.10899051278829575,
0.333394318819046,
-0.25421226024627686,
0.7835681438446045,
-0.13592112064361572,
-0.38330623507499695,
-0.2235776036977768,
0.9365042448043823,
0.5126276016235352,
0.4758772850036621,
0.5172649621963501,
0.9296406507492065,
0.25783252716064453,
0.034523528069257736,
0.6939132213592529,
-0.3239923417568207,
0.1805325746536255,
1.0637166500091553,
-0.19834548234939575,
0.8362833857536316,
0.4264261722564697,
0.01847766898572445,
0.8847330808639526,
0.7990456223487854,
0.16719035804271698,
0.22247666120529175,
0.39321228861808777,
-0.8657594919204712,
-0.6541807055473328,
-0.7484222650527954,
-0.346001535654068,
0.33232906460762024,
0.7711095213890076,
-0.16645140945911407,
-0.49080002307891846,
-0.34262338280677795,
0.20862483978271484,
0.6092882752418518,
-0.12548066675662994,
0.9903393387794495,
-0.20396922528743744,
-0.6923635005950928,
0.6072816252708435,
0.17326320707798004,
0.607597291469574,
-0.2901766896247864,
-0.5151675343513489,
0.03738618642091751,
-0.07503537833690643,
-0.36581140756607056,
-0.6059913635253906,
0.1734057515859604,
0.39677733182907104,
-0.4846494793891907,
-0.16869236528873444,
0.6313015222549438,
-0.3622816503047943,
-0.429027795791626,
0.28186342120170593,
0.21519523859024048,
-0.15894900262355804,
0.11488484591245651,
-0.43994200229644775,
-0.13975700736045837,
-0.05593468248844147,
-0.3080098628997803,
0.31159237027168274,
0.5064864158630371,
-0.2731979489326477,
0.4973909854888916,
0.8640050292015076,
0.05565471202135086,
0.2967382073402405,
0.0500287190079689,
1.0847872495651245,
-0.42502880096435547,
-0.6223157644271851,
-1.1807242631912231,
0.6248903274536133,
-0.386603981256485,
-0.45545968413352966,
0.5571838021278381,
0.9151835441589355,
0.34658142924308777,
0.11639175564050674,
0.8324058651924133,
-0.1408122181892395,
0.6017282605171204,
-0.5283339023590088,
0.3063162565231323,
-0.22614632546901703,
0.23937931656837463,
-0.13284972310066223,
-0.6045986413955688,
-0.6314015984535217,
0.5989307165145874,
-0.12109310179948807,
-0.30822327733039856,
0.29903721809387207,
0.3762483298778534,
0.010231824591755867,
0.29880473017692566,
0.16506452858448029,
-0.07339958846569061,
0.708988606929779,
0.7256669998168945,
0.7106621861457825,
-0.37296074628829956,
0.4188094735145569,
-0.01584308221936226,
-0.2839761972427368,
-0.018959730863571167,
-1.1811516284942627,
-0.8880846500396729,
-0.5273777842521667,
-0.706437885761261,
-0.19495220482349396,
0.18692095577716827,
0.84760582447052,
0.5780937075614929,
-1.1728968620300293,
-0.1899574249982834,
-0.5980075597763062,
-0.01889314316213131,
0.050413455814123154,
-0.1912044733762741,
0.647950291633606,
-0.5497838258743286,
-0.47883158922195435,
0.41533440351486206,
0.5595942735671997,
-0.15665125846862793,
0.1530257910490036,
-0.11555914580821991,
-0.7989549040794373,
0.06775091588497162,
0.8406871557235718,
0.6906914114952087,
-0.813730776309967,
-0.4306897521018982,
-0.4376832842826843,
0.634567141532898,
0.22899460792541504,
0.8416373133659363,
-0.9133253693580627,
1.0497232675552368,
0.25899142026901245,
0.6857990026473999,
0.238775372505188,
0.45334509015083313,
0.7422351837158203,
-0.9947198629379272,
-0.054196495562791824,
0.09931006282567978,
0.3585122227668762,
0.5346508026123047,
-0.1541563868522644,
0.2888753414154053,
0.059205953031778336,
-0.383141428232193,
-0.8079425692558289,
0.44962701201438904,
-0.76053386926651,
-0.12575316429138184,
1.1238830089569092,
-0.35021358728408813,
0.24105645716190338,
-0.5979564785957336,
-0.42736825346946716,
0.6309807896614075,
-0.37793704867362976,
0.6990042328834534,
0.7487133741378784,
-0.5102438926696777,
-0.22618094086647034,
-0.35615599155426025,
0.7409800887107849,
0.5665330290794373,
-1.015344262123108,
0.42317065596580505,
0.4311807453632355,
-0.09923820197582245,
0.5331024527549744,
0.38607853651046753,
0.039563607424497604,
0.0006802408024668694,
-0.06970919668674469,
-0.021253731101751328,
-0.2182677537202835,
-0.0957363173365593,
-0.0849919393658638,
0.4193105697631836,
0.11045084148645401,
-0.32762131094932556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08598v1
|
Language Model Council: Benchmarking Foundation Models on Highly Subjective Tasks by Consensus
| 2024-06-12T19:05:43 | 2024-06-12T19:05:43 |
Justin Zhao, Flor Miriam Plaza-del-Arco, Amanda Cercas Curry
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid advancement of Large Language Models (LLMs) necessitates robust and
challenging benchmarks. Leaderboards like Chatbot Arena rank LLMs based on how
well their responses align with human preferences. However, many tasks such as
those related to emotional intelligence, creative writing, or persuasiveness,
are highly subjective and often lack majoritarian human agreement. Judges may
have irreconcilable disagreements about what constitutes a better response. To
address the challenge of ranking LLMs on highly subjective tasks, we propose a
novel benchmarking framework, the Language Model Council (LMC). The LMC
operates through a democratic process to: 1) formulate a test set through equal
participation, 2) administer the test among council members, and 3) evaluate
responses as a collective jury. We deploy a council of 20 newest LLMs on an
open-ended emotional intelligence task: responding to interpersonal dilemmas.
Our results show that the LMC produces rankings that are more separable,
robust, and less biased than those from any individual LLM judge, and is more
consistent with a human-established leaderboard compared to other benchmarks.
|
[
-0.6270379424095154,
-0.5011317133903503,
0.5465793609619141,
0.25588542222976685,
0.08620259910821915,
0.3260904550552368,
-0.4950377941131592,
-0.4395819306373596,
0.1274196058511734,
0.5976560115814209,
-0.39473873376846313,
-0.5462557077407837,
-0.7737131714820862,
0.0587582103908062,
-0.4466688930988312,
0.790703535079956,
0.13556697964668274,
0.1339191049337387,
-0.4766504168510437,
-0.4190042018890381,
-0.2225264608860016,
-0.7520712018013,
-0.2816677689552307,
-0.6488586664199829,
0.4881911277770996,
0.6575351357460022,
0.7858237028121948,
0.335301011800766,
0.7389835715293884,
0.3688175082206726,
-0.058980826288461685,
-0.0232976283878088,
-0.5890758037567139,
0.19557516276836395,
-0.22398146986961365,
-0.5107486248016357,
-0.6596637964248657,
0.31463927030563354,
0.2733927369117737,
0.9146075248718262,
-0.4319555163383484,
0.25194886326789856,
0.022655263543128967,
0.8600698113441467,
-0.6013247966766357,
0.23166592419147491,
-0.7701115012168884,
-0.041074253618717194,
0.019427834078669548,
0.06790373474359512,
-0.42083320021629333,
-0.5347035527229309,
-0.06992834806442261,
-0.12075350433588028,
-0.03635825961828232,
0.033274464309215546,
0.5978620648384094,
0.29053646326065063,
-0.4898209869861603,
-0.16802366077899933,
-0.4584970474243164,
0.6113386154174805,
-0.7517383098602295,
0.4116858243942261,
0.4873364269733429,
0.24901863932609558,
-0.06144284829497337,
-0.4629465639591217,
-0.543388843536377,
-0.43882182240486145,
0.2619175612926483,
0.11947030574083328,
-0.20701846480369568,
0.0037613266613334417,
-0.032611820846796036,
0.18481996655464172,
-0.35309866070747375,
0.2401752918958664,
0.04711286351084709,
0.044570401310920715,
0.5238436460494995,
0.36023762822151184,
-0.0295165553689003,
0.0070505146868526936,
0.0143961813300848,
-0.09903720766305923,
-0.4503876864910126,
0.27799713611602783,
0.3393961787223816,
0.44656145572662354,
0.0799657478928566,
0.7070262432098389,
-0.5456300377845764,
0.3082195818424225,
0.2952292263507843,
0.023704996332526207,
0.2855321168899536,
0.07944288849830627,
0.028184931725263596,
0.019856883212924004,
0.6551182866096497,
0.6892515420913696,
0.3181024193763733,
-0.20387627184391022,
-0.4361386001110077,
0.28013142943382263,
0.3404046297073364,
-0.7882302403450012,
-0.08618568629026413,
0.1660585105419159,
-0.48009809851646423,
-0.3993200361728668,
-0.11767688393592834,
-0.5948010683059692,
-0.5735960602760315,
-0.5688578486442566,
0.15354938805103302,
0.24367184937000275,
-0.3908126652240753,
-0.09124526381492615,
0.3634747266769409,
-0.048449281603097916,
0.2758841812610626,
-0.7959527969360352,
0.7279404401779175,
1.0284909009933472,
0.7112295627593994,
-0.39881446957588196,
-0.2397785782814026,
-0.49027886986732483,
-0.27793455123901367,
-0.4335780739784241,
0.9758403301239014,
-0.7268505096435547,
-0.32736918330192566,
-0.0277119018137455,
-0.04971429705619812,
0.2683682441711426,
-0.9840946793556213,
0.579741895198822,
-0.33324316143989563,
-0.027533315122127533,
-0.533317506313324,
-0.7503063082695007,
0.13968603312969208,
0.5692650675773621,
-0.4707579016685486,
1.1440130472183228,
-0.031219329684972763,
-0.3729792833328247,
0.23572206497192383,
-0.30865830183029175,
-0.08292289823293686,
0.0901094526052475,
-0.3049051761627197,
-0.13779525458812714,
0.15989582240581512,
-0.06474895030260086,
0.6714420318603516,
-0.5642962455749512,
0.6979539394378662,
-0.6333036422729492,
-0.3816542327404022,
0.42884984612464905,
-0.13266722857952118,
0.4063064157962799,
0.07892364263534546,
-0.46996232867240906,
0.3464307487010956,
-0.6155509948730469,
0.27264586091041565,
-0.17592985928058624,
-0.3584402799606323,
-0.2915545105934143,
0.1761755645275116,
-0.1050536185503006,
0.285600483417511,
0.18036116659641266,
-0.39104801416397095,
-0.024928657338023186,
-0.22914153337478638,
0.2969070076942444,
1.2272660732269287,
-0.34907859563827515,
0.35970547795295715,
-0.5442371964454651,
0.2719307839870453,
-0.11366511136293411,
0.030627381056547165,
0.606982409954071,
-0.5045586824417114,
-0.8710355758666992,
-0.13285653293132782,
0.12570708990097046,
0.42826730012893677,
-0.3089877665042877,
0.7258893251419067,
-0.28624823689460754,
-0.8579131960868835,
-0.6374848484992981,
0.14870679378509521,
0.2638222575187683,
0.4143824875354767,
0.15161694586277008,
-0.5948121547698975,
-0.1290615200996399,
-1.036262035369873,
-0.30661359429359436,
-0.572385847568512,
0.20425176620483398,
0.45412734150886536,
0.5253415107727051,
0.042290620505809784,
0.8401834964752197,
-0.1779286116361618,
-0.02002890035510063,
-0.2430141121149063,
0.28037068247795105,
0.558538556098938,
0.19818544387817383,
0.30070316791534424,
-0.6109766960144043,
-0.39039403200149536,
-0.1269579827785492,
-0.5910889506340027,
-0.5898728966712952,
0.40941739082336426,
-0.2624173164367676,
0.05840253084897995,
0.4834744930267334,
-0.30345362424850464,
0.05595925450325012,
0.6735910773277283,
-0.3571115732192993,
0.6435315608978271,
0.1547492891550064,
0.445990651845932,
-0.8048058152198792,
0.2412712424993515,
-0.15302777290344238,
-0.4015063941478729,
-0.48665037751197815,
0.2296457588672638,
-0.012780088931322098,
-0.030016936361789703,
-0.32429033517837524,
0.6801487803459167,
-0.17659732699394226,
-0.1415954977273941,
-0.348787784576416,
0.3188924193382263,
-0.4182557761669159,
0.7901141047477722,
0.039217375218868256,
0.44143667817115784,
0.2935883104801178,
-0.5672245621681213,
0.47700098156929016,
0.14895384013652802,
-0.5768287777900696,
0.8904847502708435,
-0.6887608170509338,
0.28130143880844116,
-0.06429599970579147,
0.07957646995782852,
-0.7128026485443115,
-0.01963365450501442,
-0.06768860667943954,
-0.16802649199962616,
-0.13552874326705933,
0.2702423632144928,
-0.4682909846305847,
-0.28416845202445984,
-0.12809917330741882,
0.3258727788925171,
0.3881613612174988,
-0.33872467279434204,
0.4526363015174866,
0.7048965096473694,
-0.32441645860671997,
-0.6025674343109131,
-0.5025445818901062,
0.1002325713634491,
0.11203983426094055,
-0.43538138270378113,
0.1707720011472702,
-0.5822460651397705,
-0.6799254417419434,
0.016571033746004105,
-0.17029651999473572,
-0.07606986910104752,
0.283336877822876,
0.5504023432731628,
-0.041935618966817856,
-0.10031002014875412,
0.1366143524646759,
-0.31960567831993103,
-0.13226710259914398,
0.0803571417927742,
0.2793141007423401,
0.6055577993392944,
-0.532818078994751,
-0.5892500877380371,
-0.25193312764167786,
0.38101160526275635,
0.6943187713623047,
-0.32939550280570984,
0.4730646312236786,
0.011003403924405575,
-0.4210829436779022,
-0.12441305071115494,
-0.846358060836792,
-0.17017775774002075,
-0.4870135486125946,
0.5621103048324585,
-0.27240145206451416,
-1.095829963684082,
0.527423083782196,
-0.08146891742944717,
0.24833069741725922,
0.07164356857538223,
1.05141019821167,
0.052045878022909164,
1.1246200799942017,
0.5637285709381104,
-0.34732937812805176,
0.340388685464859,
0.2063821256160736,
0.24919693171977997,
-0.4338986873626709,
-0.21506594121456146,
-0.8743042945861816,
-0.634458601474762,
-0.46488454937934875,
-0.31543248891830444,
0.36398521065711975,
-0.001200466533191502,
-0.42758095264434814,
0.08743910491466522,
-0.4921451807022095,
0.5833367109298706,
0.4733870327472687,
0.19278760254383087,
0.432135671377182,
-0.3330170810222626,
-0.25841304659843445,
-0.04943240061402321,
-0.2737123966217041,
-0.7779837250709534,
0.8576086759567261,
0.190353661775589,
0.6273247599601746,
0.32821691036224365,
0.6892310380935669,
0.32929882407188416,
0.7730180025100708,
-0.6810762286186218,
1.005182147026062,
-0.19829189777374268,
-0.6813578605651855,
-0.08806373178958893,
-0.45333680510520935,
-0.4303595721721649,
0.3578505218029022,
-0.2711104154586792,
-0.6652756929397583,
0.13048383593559265,
-0.1955752968788147,
-0.05651284381747246,
0.26671573519706726,
-0.2959413528442383,
0.8491086959838867,
-0.0801939070224762,
-0.2712447941303253,
-0.3144313097000122,
-0.44824135303497314,
0.23881684243679047,
-0.03822857886552811,
0.29706871509552,
-0.7499499917030334,
-0.03902176767587662,
0.7945106029510498,
-0.4120097756385803,
0.7655767798423767,
-0.06634218245744705,
0.01830885373055935,
0.1402626484632492,
0.2658897638320923,
0.4603414833545685,
-0.04490326717495918,
-0.5091816186904907,
-0.1015128567814827,
-0.20764490962028503,
-0.40705057978630066,
-0.5044375658035278,
0.8481045961380005,
-0.96857088804245,
-0.7144113779067993,
-0.38247767090797424,
-0.41190409660339355,
-0.5446117520332336,
0.1476542055606842,
-0.1840067058801651,
0.25399333238601685,
-0.515002429485321,
0.33076411485671997,
0.46490564942359924,
0.0803770199418068,
0.3396982252597809,
0.7910048365592957,
-0.20498615503311157,
-0.3232403099536896,
0.6399262547492981,
-0.08808672428131104,
0.37557125091552734,
0.26162707805633545,
0.05472222715616226,
-0.07999696582555771,
-0.5230628252029419,
0.05702831223607063,
0.03607342019677162,
-0.8095647692680359,
-0.19977225363254547,
-0.7187010645866394,
0.10099431127309799,
-0.38976719975471497,
-0.12950897216796875,
-0.6754447817802429,
-0.44016513228416443,
0.01248474232852459,
-0.169899582862854,
-0.033862125128507614,
0.7408044338226318,
0.04788066819310188,
-0.06772372871637344,
-0.533150315284729,
0.1961621642112732,
0.5470534563064575,
0.4049878418445587,
0.07203545421361923,
-0.4251634478569031,
-0.03337167575955391,
-0.12465634942054749,
-0.35310104489326477,
-0.6255481243133545,
0.061533935368061066,
0.030984172597527504,
0.7529005408287048,
0.2662244141101837,
0.19451004266738892,
0.5601691007614136,
-0.4090398848056793,
0.7572097182273865,
0.20556986331939697,
-1.0882166624069214,
0.23124893009662628,
-0.1673913449048996,
0.3808039128780365,
1.0343451499938965,
0.2260783612728119,
-0.8328436613082886,
-0.9944074153900146,
-0.31134361028671265,
-0.6234526634216309,
0.5122767090797424,
0.06956114619970322,
0.1592598706483841,
-0.18987250328063965,
0.2777857482433319,
0.12090016901493073,
0.4297610819339752,
-0.9069584012031555,
-0.1538572758436203,
0.006195504684001207,
-0.3575311601161957,
-0.028356479480862617,
-0.18514874577522278,
-0.2085166722536087,
-0.14658454060554504,
0.8170602321624756,
-0.23068948090076447,
0.0333436094224453,
0.08843616396188736,
0.020160049200057983,
-0.3386286199092865,
0.403974324464798,
0.3795979917049408,
0.5440495014190674,
-0.07382025569677353,
0.41376835107803345,
0.08252476900815964,
-0.12437769025564194,
0.3990929126739502,
-0.1182439997792244,
0.13680167496204376,
-0.36182501912117004,
0.5492215752601624,
0.5161828398704529,
0.2582429349422455,
-0.9395936131477356,
0.6605105996131897,
-0.18328243494033813,
-0.30443546175956726,
0.020213168114423752,
0.11342384666204453,
0.33943960070610046,
0.40189358592033386,
0.240685373544693,
0.17330756783485413,
0.023712053894996643,
-0.7809187769889832,
0.17190155386924744,
0.3370975852012634,
-0.6801203489303589,
-0.19367997348308563,
0.4470219016075134,
0.47842949628829956,
-0.39321503043174744,
0.5475144386291504,
-0.13479603826999664,
-0.6595780849456787,
0.6777271628379822,
0.131494402885437,
0.7452430725097656,
-0.254438579082489,
0.3106134235858917,
0.12049809843301773,
0.38725560903549194,
-0.39566537737846375,
0.3774908781051636,
0.054259903728961945,
-0.8185293078422546,
-0.07145985215902328,
-0.6028239130973816,
-0.8468733429908752,
-0.23604807257652283,
-0.6554973721504211,
0.2150260955095291,
-0.5293170809745789,
-0.268384724855423,
-0.19358251988887787,
0.2540874779224396,
-0.6797611117362976,
0.13910679519176483,
0.31908848881721497,
0.7948151230812073,
-0.6272609829902649,
0.5116519331932068,
0.5136968493461609,
-0.029962502419948578,
-0.6382720470428467,
-0.2583838105201721,
0.131005197763443,
-0.7583548426628113,
0.428043395280838,
0.30773279070854187,
-0.10753283649682999,
-0.28265008330345154,
-0.5930628180503845,
-0.6260358691215515,
0.789455235004425,
0.47106245160102844,
-0.8718175292015076,
0.088500015437603,
0.1604074090719223,
0.6369158625602722,
-0.5056723952293396,
0.4795181155204773,
0.29280754923820496,
0.652351438999176,
-0.2175537496805191,
-1.0562450885772705,
0.13724689185619354,
-0.5379312634468079,
-0.3568095266819,
0.04075322300195694,
-0.9751377701759338,
0.6989827752113342,
-0.09285873174667358,
-0.0038294654805213213,
0.39634397625923157,
0.6889770030975342,
0.3295176327228546,
0.28609392046928406,
0.7527346014976501,
0.5252885222434998,
0.9471115469932556,
-0.23534896969795227,
0.7612521648406982,
-0.3416374623775482,
0.2879311442375183,
1.2470529079437256,
-0.8599025011062622,
1.0499985218048096,
0.3534780442714691,
-0.08912332355976105,
0.4120985269546509,
0.62967848777771,
0.0746883675456047,
0.5694758296012878,
0.49868008494377136,
-0.21628756821155548,
-0.6725665926933289,
-0.5032479166984558,
-0.26949062943458557,
0.5310688614845276,
-0.16844922304153442,
-0.12968099117279053,
0.023714186623692513,
-0.08614015579223633,
-0.10155243426561356,
0.45418450236320496,
-0.3582729697227478,
0.764319658279419,
0.13932007551193237,
-0.7940904498100281,
0.2974788546562195,
0.0325954295694828,
0.5697894096374512,
-0.42037367820739746,
0.20505841076374054,
-0.3491452634334564,
0.26939454674720764,
-0.11690957844257355,
-0.7621330618858337,
-0.01673721708357334,
0.1432637721300125,
-0.25023531913757324,
-0.33345362544059753,
0.13489094376564026,
-0.3802606463432312,
-0.5835072994232178,
0.6087296605110168,
0.7039524912834167,
0.168861523270607,
-0.06994125247001648,
-0.8045318722724915,
0.19895663857460022,
-0.37997499108314514,
-0.4354727268218994,
0.29982757568359375,
0.5156896710395813,
-0.013153688050806522,
0.7425755858421326,
0.398067831993103,
-0.04194755479693413,
-0.30655959248542786,
0.4546336829662323,
0.9731400012969971,
-0.7160284519195557,
-0.573164701461792,
-0.703991711139679,
0.2396879941225052,
-0.16734613478183746,
-0.4788230061531067,
0.3270391821861267,
0.49524059891700745,
0.6917062997817993,
0.3964797258377075,
0.5063498020172119,
-0.08194618672132492,
0.41867247223854065,
-0.2728329598903656,
0.8226746916770935,
-0.6701174974441528,
0.21237444877624512,
-0.3626427948474884,
-1.0949844121932983,
-0.14559540152549744,
0.3305518329143524,
-0.15720152854919434,
0.1433188021183014,
0.7167547941207886,
1.033016324043274,
0.19290950894355774,
0.2158488631248474,
0.4430980384349823,
0.5109962821006775,
0.4630991816520691,
0.6674578189849854,
0.9746423959732056,
0.04911119118332863,
0.41198551654815674,
-0.24491055309772491,
-0.32702189683914185,
-0.07232458144426346,
-0.8658886551856995,
-1.130650281906128,
-0.5477426052093506,
-0.2807569205760956,
-0.1890878528356552,
0.1398468166589737,
1.30728280544281,
0.8495476245880127,
-0.8874560594558716,
-0.6364443898200989,
0.08911765366792679,
0.19217152893543243,
-0.2528155744075775,
-0.20960402488708496,
0.007040210999548435,
0.02971932664513588,
-0.7153957486152649,
0.3632635474205017,
0.19635866582393646,
-0.388352632522583,
-0.3560805320739746,
-0.2531586289405823,
-0.1653594672679901,
0.14373858273029327,
0.320042222738266,
-0.14642460644245148,
-0.9145296812057495,
-0.40066781640052795,
0.06377750635147095,
-0.5358144044876099,
0.06064676493406296,
0.8548932075500488,
-0.558977484703064,
0.24068915843963623,
0.4384652078151703,
0.49083608388900757,
0.18517106771469116,
-0.25048545002937317,
0.5288498997688293,
-0.37727171182632446,
-0.08628454804420471,
0.4573516249656677,
0.32460105419158936,
0.30280011892318726,
-0.05655370652675629,
0.6629416942596436,
0.13304570317268372,
-0.7584675550460815,
-1.0376461744308472,
0.06569971889257431,
-1.1014482975006104,
-0.2915326654911041,
0.8561674952507019,
0.0033084219321608543,
-0.19862136244773865,
0.10072874277830124,
-0.124998539686203,
-0.04250986874103546,
-0.614801824092865,
0.8626222014427185,
1.0442204475402832,
-0.042922813445329666,
-0.16640356183052063,
-0.3149429261684418,
0.15550947189331055,
0.5886078476905823,
-0.9261042475700378,
0.3192623555660248,
0.24594008922576904,
0.17416873574256897,
0.09603611379861832,
0.9358683824539185,
-0.10838505625724792,
0.21062201261520386,
-0.4199018180370331,
0.2928590178489685,
0.1215740516781807,
-0.2650836706161499,
-0.08416525274515152,
0.47917187213897705,
0.23792798817157745,
0.6277898550033569
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09455v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09455v1
|
Pandora: Towards General World Model with Natural Language Actions and Video States
| 2024-06-12T18:55:51 | 2024-06-12T18:55:51 |
Jiannan Xiang, Guangyi Liu, Yi Gu, Qiyue Gao, Yuting Ning, Yuheng Zha, Zeyu Feng, Tianhua Tao, Shibo Hao, Yemin Shi, Zhengzhong Liu, Eric P. Xing, Zhiting Hu
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
World models simulate future states of the world in response to different
actions. They facilitate interactive content creation and provides a foundation
for grounded, long-horizon reasoning. Current foundation models do not fully
meet the capabilities of general world models: large language models (LLMs) are
constrained by their reliance on language modality and their limited
understanding of the physical world, while video models lack interactive action
control over the world simulations. This paper makes a step towards building a
general world model by introducing Pandora, a hybrid autoregressive-diffusion
model that simulates world states by generating videos and allows real-time
control with free-text actions. Pandora achieves domain generality, video
consistency, and controllability through large-scale pretraining and
instruction tuning. Crucially, Pandora bypasses the cost of
training-from-scratch by integrating a pretrained LLM (7B) and a pretrained
video model, requiring only additional lightweight finetuning. We illustrate
extensive outputs by Pandora across diverse domains (indoor/outdoor,
natural/urban, human/robot, 2D/3D, etc.). The results indicate great potential
of building stronger general world models with larger-scale training.
|
[
-0.46900123357772827,
-1.2660489082336426,
0.6482805609703064,
0.08635780215263367,
-0.1648952066898346,
-0.17236030101776123,
-0.12391825020313263,
-0.3299427032470703,
0.2823190689086914,
0.5702073574066162,
-0.6858178377151489,
-0.21110622584819794,
-0.6018983125686646,
-0.3501625657081604,
-0.6499805450439453,
0.7156389951705933,
-0.16676880419254303,
-0.4246179461479187,
0.03432850539684296,
0.005070501938462257,
-0.196480855345726,
-0.33615678548812866,
-0.6244099736213684,
-0.44344398379325867,
0.24022504687309265,
-0.1526036113500595,
1.0375914573669434,
0.31563809514045715,
-0.04500396549701691,
0.29924890398979187,
0.11510675400495529,
0.1215132549405098,
-0.4372681975364685,
-0.06174945831298828,
-0.3761838674545288,
-0.17118127644062042,
-0.389715313911438,
0.14250728487968445,
0.6275336742401123,
0.5027875900268555,
-0.1266246885061264,
0.1724708378314972,
0.06412457674741745,
0.3434414565563202,
-0.5120635628700256,
0.13621026277542114,
-0.3132327198982239,
0.2116350680589676,
0.3111998736858368,
-0.014828725717961788,
0.01570165529847145,
-0.19074581563472748,
0.2900323271751404,
-1.0426640510559082,
0.20317097008228302,
0.18212629854679108,
0.6623942255973816,
0.4804556965827942,
-0.6458386182785034,
0.00939272902905941,
-1.1825191974639893,
0.7169656157493591,
-0.3661843538284302,
0.5589815974235535,
0.40468740463256836,
0.24025242030620575,
-0.4127008020877838,
-0.635081946849823,
-0.7837023735046387,
-0.078721784055233,
0.4410608112812042,
0.382293164730072,
-0.2384193390607834,
0.17662110924720764,
0.2716173529624939,
0.4383598566055298,
-0.565479576587677,
0.11330009996891022,
-0.08946151286363602,
-0.10522690415382385,
0.48809656500816345,
0.2223559319972992,
0.39938557147979736,
-0.11465154588222504,
-0.1680477261543274,
-0.09249994903802872,
-0.595483124256134,
0.2812853157520294,
0.3292331397533417,
-0.030689163133502007,
-0.5454351902008057,
0.46732500195503235,
-0.2567369341850281,
0.9081922173500061,
0.15647156536579132,
-0.3597387671470642,
-0.31594526767730713,
0.08236617594957352,
-0.6136259436607361,
-0.29046815633773804,
0.7079043388366699,
0.35575106739997864,
0.04309291020035744,
-0.3164346218109131,
0.13501675426959991,
0.4407561123371124,
0.39035284519195557,
-0.5969618558883667,
-0.27150094509124756,
0.43728405237197876,
-0.3696972131729126,
-0.06181817874312401,
-0.2249479442834854,
-0.4709266722202301,
-0.17208068072795868,
-0.9166510701179504,
0.8165289759635925,
-0.29178181290626526,
-0.6567860841751099,
0.5194915533065796,
0.04879912734031677,
0.2643662095069885,
0.6251932978630066,
-0.8460589051246643,
0.5981810688972473,
0.44138333201408386,
0.7471998333930969,
-0.20277976989746094,
-0.16628889739513397,
-0.673875093460083,
0.5674517154693604,
-0.4573977589607239,
0.4950038492679596,
-0.5480534434318542,
-0.3675727844238281,
0.1786128282546997,
0.031139299273490906,
0.12983331084251404,
-0.28648853302001953,
0.07465425878763199,
-0.8457525968551636,
0.4476255178451538,
0.19285085797309875,
-0.49722611904144287,
-0.37626245617866516,
0.3474322557449341,
-0.748869776725769,
0.9087012410163879,
-0.023534176871180534,
-0.48663586378097534,
0.374061644077301,
-0.7508834600448608,
-0.21145276725292206,
-0.1906406730413437,
-0.11476786434650421,
-0.16392061114311218,
0.12601418793201447,
0.14387905597686768,
0.37300020456314087,
-0.2585574984550476,
0.7111368775367737,
-0.36759284138679504,
-0.31209346652030945,
-0.08146104216575623,
-0.49920833110809326,
0.3869960904121399,
0.24615196883678436,
-0.45353788137435913,
0.03826341778039932,
-0.7647514939308167,
0.06761229783296585,
-0.13075312972068787,
-0.3027452230453491,
-0.29259875416755676,
0.252709299325943,
0.14396366477012634,
0.3411749601364136,
-0.08265621960163116,
-0.49035221338272095,
0.28450363874435425,
-0.2195645421743393,
0.4171759784221649,
0.5596999526023865,
-0.09699152410030365,
0.8436785340309143,
-0.215945765376091,
0.735639214515686,
-0.14355967938899994,
0.21306827664375305,
0.1153329610824585,
-0.4824579656124115,
-0.6079645156860352,
-0.25131022930145264,
0.2257252037525177,
0.4746030271053314,
-0.7092529535293579,
0.4044159948825836,
-0.288991779088974,
-0.18244145810604095,
-0.1873655915260315,
0.0910913422703743,
0.151838481426239,
0.12813353538513184,
0.3315960168838501,
-0.4741783142089844,
-0.5036848187446594,
-0.687822699546814,
0.1823425590991974,
0.12819823622703552,
-0.13218575716018677,
0.06735500693321228,
0.5599707961082458,
-0.26946312189102173,
1.3254345655441284,
-0.21200715005397797,
-0.014446141198277473,
-0.32004523277282715,
0.24024531245231628,
0.1335861086845398,
0.5070140361785889,
0.2925030291080475,
-1.0575852394104004,
-0.3586060404777527,
-0.15528380870819092,
-0.9239630103111267,
0.18125005066394806,
-0.16330276429653168,
-0.2554120421409607,
-0.23853784799575806,
0.3230958878993988,
-0.7005304098129272,
0.5827464461326599,
0.8962051272392273,
-0.08894453197717667,
0.44295668601989746,
-0.3797301650047302,
0.10221000015735626,
-1.0978877544403076,
-0.1091025248169899,
0.06972400844097137,
-0.35386383533477783,
-0.46462127566337585,
0.16774025559425354,
-0.11117089539766312,
-0.5291786193847656,
-0.4667324721813202,
0.8622223734855652,
-0.2589671015739441,
-0.2004009634256363,
-0.4936724603176117,
-0.1999824196100235,
-0.05157331004738808,
0.38246652483940125,
0.5886917114257812,
0.6129286289215088,
0.7193413376808167,
-1.165053367614746,
0.455281525850296,
0.1322111189365387,
-0.49888259172439575,
0.4140079915523529,
-0.6053255200386047,
-0.2497924566268921,
-0.19516971707344055,
0.7144110798835754,
-0.5055798888206482,
-0.6027365922927856,
0.038289424031972885,
-0.115390345454216,
0.02789292484521866,
-0.39453932642936707,
-0.6891613602638245,
-0.49749520421028137,
0.2691059708595276,
0.15238484740257263,
0.6983354687690735,
-0.631413459777832,
0.9737095236778259,
0.3467247188091278,
0.07410349696874619,
-0.19602276384830475,
-0.4474228024482727,
0.14767947793006897,
-0.4921036660671234,
-0.5992202758789062,
0.5113252401351929,
-0.3160426914691925,
-0.2374681681394577,
0.0014050793834030628,
-0.017776641994714737,
-0.21807058155536652,
0.13837257027626038,
0.5018361210823059,
-0.016059909015893936,
0.03639049455523491,
0.030438287183642387,
0.1344405561685562,
-0.21068015694618225,
0.12172496318817139,
-0.7998481392860413,
0.4632892310619354,
0.12745243310928345,
-0.37549227476119995,
-0.4677261412143707,
0.5451810359954834,
0.4596858024597168,
-0.15838415920734406,
0.39601245522499084,
0.4351304769515991,
-0.3600594997406006,
-0.3385038375854492,
-0.46819421648979187,
0.024941205978393555,
-0.5017929077148438,
0.24969658255577087,
-0.2560388743877411,
-1.015259861946106,
0.3809153139591217,
-0.34807872772216797,
0.32829299569129944,
0.02457571029663086,
0.5840692520141602,
-0.2120264619588852,
1.0715062618255615,
0.9436302185058594,
-0.012332930229604244,
0.5052134394645691,
-0.5020216107368469,
0.052821893244981766,
-0.6918566226959229,
0.14644429087638855,
0.07658889144659042,
-0.4596289396286011,
-0.38351163268089294,
-0.6609974503517151,
0.5375474095344543,
0.14109094440937042,
-0.6350981593132019,
0.06974966824054718,
-0.07734643667936325,
0.5630818009376526,
0.6979536414146423,
-0.08708947151899338,
0.3245820105075836,
0.24418413639068604,
-0.3402702808380127,
-0.08630863577127457,
-0.548667848110199,
-0.4839732050895691,
0.9961735606193542,
0.19023631513118744,
0.9953374862670898,
0.3126455545425415,
0.5982480049133301,
0.5194554924964905,
0.2714594304561615,
-0.4320284426212311,
0.43442314863204956,
-0.011386919766664505,
-0.6775811314582825,
-0.18082311749458313,
-0.14094789326190948,
-0.8779730200767517,
0.2962033450603485,
-0.33235228061676025,
-0.6155118346214294,
-0.20326344668865204,
0.40820547938346863,
-0.6236385107040405,
0.55295330286026,
-0.5100721716880798,
0.7175025343894958,
-0.1997399628162384,
-0.6367237567901611,
-0.3875425159931183,
-0.37784722447395325,
0.5251598358154297,
0.12458831071853638,
0.5774500370025635,
0.14268220961093903,
0.06882790476083755,
0.210944265127182,
-0.175839364528656,
1.0710821151733398,
-0.233737513422966,
-0.4176368713378906,
0.44279399514198303,
0.34593552350997925,
0.4095124304294586,
0.22092077136039734,
0.450928270816803,
-0.36483120918273926,
-0.4001960754394531,
-0.4089163839817047,
-0.6125181913375854,
0.713331937789917,
-1.0127530097961426,
-0.5071521401405334,
-0.30454590916633606,
-0.49208736419677734,
-0.44364506006240845,
-0.057589173316955566,
0.18103770911693573,
0.6579931378364563,
-0.4658776521682739,
0.03948722034692764,
1.0461612939834595,
-0.35999956727027893,
0.4743186831474304,
0.81473308801651,
-0.7099627256393433,
-0.4976368248462677,
0.7043411731719971,
-0.08057482540607452,
0.32338759303092957,
0.3954892158508301,
0.01893102005124092,
-0.37102439999580383,
-0.2939094007015228,
-0.47433894872665405,
-0.07560443878173828,
-0.20938847959041595,
0.21810860931873322,
-0.6466533541679382,
-0.12583617866039276,
-0.08610261231660843,
-0.2375738024711609,
-0.30811989307403564,
-0.3151862323284149,
0.01122136041522026,
-0.21607646346092224,
0.38044798374176025,
0.8194551467895508,
-0.41890737414360046,
0.6081395149230957,
-0.6674463748931885,
0.7959288954734802,
0.9258008599281311,
0.473833292722702,
0.09717567265033722,
-0.49074095487594604,
-0.3777710497379303,
0.051388129591941833,
-0.5525044798851013,
-0.40937158465385437,
0.3249201476573944,
0.2398286759853363,
0.4563487768173218,
0.3257591724395752,
-0.11031655222177505,
0.8277474641799927,
-0.739956796169281,
1.0358943939208984,
0.5091325640678406,
-0.7487830519676208,
0.5314078330993652,
-0.7385213971138,
0.38531479239463806,
-0.06838519871234894,
0.5044438242912292,
-0.6223611235618591,
-0.4847521483898163,
-0.7869107127189636,
-0.6629799008369446,
0.403481125831604,
-0.011955227702856064,
0.41939061880111694,
-0.027449041604995728,
0.13060514628887177,
0.16400907933712006,
0.055577948689460754,
-1.0523309707641602,
0.11758989095687866,
-0.4652900695800781,
-0.04940035566687584,
-0.16922275722026825,
0.12561795115470886,
-0.2382192760705948,
-0.18469737470149994,
0.6508127450942993,
-0.20480436086654663,
0.11317797750234604,
0.11209841817617416,
-0.300773561000824,
-0.25050291419029236,
0.25091883540153503,
0.24115340411663055,
0.3440040349960327,
-0.14388155937194824,
-0.043146904557943344,
-0.08060984313488007,
-0.3595784902572632,
0.4857640564441681,
-0.10328130424022675,
-0.435768723487854,
-0.386740505695343,
0.08202124387025833,
0.7788357138633728,
0.5472859740257263,
-0.47786232829093933,
0.2173672765493393,
-0.06885246932506561,
-0.5145788192749023,
-0.7203908562660217,
0.3586950898170471,
0.323195219039917,
0.390748530626297,
0.30498233437538147,
-0.04718661680817604,
-0.006391710136085749,
-0.4798746109008789,
0.03572971001267433,
0.31226229667663574,
-0.32397863268852234,
-0.5701093673706055,
1.1493425369262695,
0.3317985534667969,
-0.009164082817733288,
0.3782336115837097,
-0.3426178991794586,
-0.22302626073360443,
0.42258280515670776,
0.6445273756980896,
0.7848190069198608,
0.10168662667274475,
0.37481027841567993,
0.4762742221355438,
0.16774949431419373,
-0.3643420934677124,
0.33809542655944824,
-0.2117512971162796,
-0.7049742341041565,
-0.9714028835296631,
-0.797218918800354,
-0.5167875289916992,
0.5004335045814514,
-0.6082632541656494,
-0.08844093233346939,
-0.6652644872665405,
-0.21223044395446777,
-0.528471827507019,
0.013757739216089249,
-0.771416962146759,
0.6443808078765869,
0.5255354046821594,
0.8949349522590637,
-1.0487245321273804,
0.9726128578186035,
0.6766151785850525,
-0.28926920890808105,
-0.5344184637069702,
-0.07712758332490921,
0.08601072430610657,
-0.30352911353111267,
0.6922149658203125,
0.1775803416967392,
-0.12298973649740219,
0.08240202069282532,
-0.8337676525115967,
-1.1321136951446533,
0.9568230509757996,
0.1299774944782257,
-0.4893968105316162,
-0.21661832928657532,
0.0737043172121048,
0.5112865567207336,
-0.4111604690551758,
0.0689295306801796,
0.29775241017341614,
0.2557305097579956,
-0.102204829454422,
-0.9378694295883179,
-0.4564279019832611,
-0.1697850078344345,
0.15711744129657745,
0.1740763783454895,
-0.7047149538993835,
0.7104589939117432,
0.060337863862514496,
-0.06107022613286972,
0.09651640802621841,
1.0193591117858887,
0.26861703395843506,
0.13874143362045288,
0.7607319951057434,
1.1072502136230469,
0.4611576199531555,
0.06033023074269295,
1.0549920797348022,
-0.13218389451503754,
0.05749572440981865,
1.0331470966339111,
-0.2911842465400696,
0.7513994574546814,
0.11807756870985031,
-0.3276246190071106,
0.6683230400085449,
0.559836745262146,
0.36808234453201294,
0.7697508335113525,
0.12841162085533142,
-0.43882042169570923,
-0.7482866644859314,
0.10519237816333771,
-0.31832364201545715,
0.36035922169685364,
0.5287304520606995,
0.16519683599472046,
-0.33015280961990356,
0.26351943612098694,
-0.23162499070167542,
0.18556900322437286,
-0.4754101634025574,
0.5694504380226135,
0.05924004316329956,
-0.6430399417877197,
0.41345319151878357,
-0.0860595628619194,
0.8408662676811218,
-1.0063412189483643,
-0.0039002648554742336,
0.04328140243887901,
-0.005007816478610039,
0.05310033634305,
-0.4582338035106659,
0.1594773232936859,
0.22806759178638458,
-0.4086572527885437,
-0.41734862327575684,
0.25996634364128113,
-0.3487008810043335,
-0.325076699256897,
0.4195684492588043,
0.38299113512039185,
-0.07970890402793884,
-0.005065783858299255,
-0.6316095590591431,
-0.12013231217861176,
-0.11028683930635452,
-0.22234933078289032,
0.6972726583480835,
0.4112231731414795,
-0.18337981402873993,
0.7471966743469238,
0.8810970187187195,
0.0306207537651062,
0.23854321241378784,
-0.05340692028403282,
0.6718628406524658,
-0.7508078813552856,
-1.0164698362350464,
-0.13207100331783295,
0.570853590965271,
-0.061810217797756195,
-0.2635006904602051,
0.39292043447494507,
0.4953247606754303,
0.702560544013977,
-0.03590342774987221,
1.1615983247756958,
-0.2490878850221634,
0.6360868215560913,
-0.7328752279281616,
0.27787846326828003,
-0.682986319065094,
-0.1327093243598938,
-0.13982445001602173,
-1.066567063331604,
-0.07533067464828491,
0.6690463423728943,
-0.3903607726097107,
-0.2907831072807312,
0.32185059785842896,
0.438235342502594,
-0.6445164680480957,
0.07142531871795654,
0.3639301061630249,
0.1977904587984085,
0.48761507868766785,
0.5450248122215271,
0.977796196937561,
-0.21804286539554596,
0.37893784046173096,
-0.1214669719338417,
-0.33000418543815613,
0.09740658849477768,
-1.0556695461273193,
-0.713661253452301,
-0.3153935372829437,
-0.27985715866088867,
-0.18905624747276306,
-0.041206687688827515,
0.8904023766517639,
0.8724908232688904,
-0.6329962015151978,
-0.31613457202911377,
-0.19914114475250244,
-0.3476470112800598,
-0.22178758680820465,
-0.20343469083309174,
0.19945216178894043,
-0.11849591135978699,
-0.8751209378242493,
0.6230947971343994,
0.24970990419387817,
0.2922057509422302,
-0.4758186340332031,
-0.26792407035827637,
0.11277831345796585,
-0.03200724348425865,
0.7057002186775208,
0.6689844727516174,
-0.9681501984596252,
-0.3603939116001129,
-0.1896962672472,
0.23144415020942688,
-0.2611558437347412,
0.6727977991104126,
-1.1264307498931885,
0.4767906963825226,
-0.04553065076470375,
0.38219591975212097,
0.7256216406822205,
0.08942582458257675,
0.9622907638549805,
-0.5012312531471252,
0.41032838821411133,
-0.03206612914800644,
0.24891619384288788,
0.23575180768966675,
0.16083121299743652,
0.3694614768028259,
0.10958756506443024,
-0.49960535764694214,
-0.2501765787601471,
0.543510377407074,
-0.9040777087211609,
-0.21252532303333282,
1.108887791633606,
0.03286271542310715,
-0.18283315002918243,
-0.3003650903701782,
-0.06616757810115814,
0.027063487097620964,
-0.22073887288570404,
0.8089670538902283,
0.675280749797821,
0.14294295012950897,
0.029834341257810593,
-0.9940414428710938,
0.42116618156433105,
0.19053201377391815,
-0.55872642993927,
-0.052614763379096985,
0.8218753337860107,
0.4196814000606537,
0.026014991104602814,
0.7325839400291443,
0.15434016287326813,
0.33520612120628357,
-0.12721334397792816,
-0.030080972239375114,
0.04608692228794098,
-0.46090731024742126,
-0.1572510153055191,
0.09579034894704819,
-0.2385408580303192,
0.14699402451515198
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08587v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08587v1
|
CS-Bench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Large Language Models towards Computer Science Mastery
| 2024-06-12T18:47:28 | 2024-06-12T18:47:28 |
Xiaoshuai Song, Muxi Diao, Guanting Dong, Zhengyang Wang, Yujia Fu, Runqi Qiao, Zhexu Wang, Dayuan Fu, Huangxuan Wu, Bin Liang, Weihao Zeng, Yejie Wang, Zhuoma GongQue, Jianing Yu, Qiuna Tan, Weiran Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Computer Science (CS) stands as a testament to the intricacies of human
intelligence, profoundly advancing the development of artificial intelligence
and modern society. However, the current community of large language models
(LLMs) overly focuses on benchmarks for analyzing specific foundational skills
(e.g. mathematics and code generation), neglecting an all-round evaluation of
the computer science field. To bridge this gap, we introduce CS-Bench, the
first bilingual (Chinese-English) benchmark dedicated to evaluating the
performance of LLMs in computer science. CS-Bench comprises approximately 5K
meticulously curated test samples, covering 26 subfields across 4 key areas of
computer science, encompassing various task forms and divisions of knowledge
and reasoning. Utilizing CS-Bench, we conduct a comprehensive evaluation of
over 30 mainstream LLMs, revealing the relationship between CS performance and
model scales. We also quantitatively analyze the reasons for failures in
existing LLMs and highlight directions for improvements, including knowledge
supplementation and CS-specific reasoning. Further cross-capability experiments
show a high correlation between LLMs' capabilities in computer science and
their abilities in mathematics and coding. Moreover, expert LLMs specialized in
mathematics and coding also demonstrate strong performances in several CS
subfields. Looking ahead, we envision CS-Bench serving as a cornerstone for LLM
applications in the CS field and paving new avenues in assessing LLMs' diverse
reasoning capabilities. The CS-Bench data and evaluation code are available at
https://github.com/csbench/csbench.
|
[
-0.19105029106140137,
-0.5222356915473938,
0.5976034998893738,
0.7107290029525757,
0.14561548829078674,
0.5870355367660522,
-0.547573447227478,
-0.3539167046546936,
-0.15965408086776733,
0.18904736638069153,
-0.28617751598358154,
-0.569352924823761,
-0.5397279858589172,
-0.2425648272037506,
-0.7620157599449158,
0.4418826997280121,
0.06559615582227707,
0.4520927667617798,
-0.7395097613334656,
0.09300971776247025,
-0.39031195640563965,
-0.5249726176261902,
-0.5340741872787476,
-0.3245885670185089,
0.2520555555820465,
0.17939043045043945,
0.49958476424217224,
0.6494077444076538,
0.4771524965763092,
0.3333236575126648,
-0.024332208558917046,
-0.09520182013511658,
-0.5946033000946045,
-0.008578329347074032,
-0.28789082169532776,
-0.5734731554985046,
-0.531471848487854,
-0.14329670369625092,
0.8708845376968384,
1.1436567306518555,
0.13900631666183472,
0.2857227623462677,
0.25350451469421387,
0.6248165965080261,
-0.8744792342185974,
0.17305484414100647,
-0.5532580614089966,
-0.09845368564128876,
-0.4050629734992981,
0.005109474994242191,
-0.3978802263736725,
-0.41472408175468445,
-0.10899916291236877,
-0.536298930644989,
0.0871330201625824,
-0.2137167900800705,
0.5503778457641602,
0.1035454124212265,
-0.34542468190193176,
0.3207668364048004,
-0.49583151936531067,
1.1089333295822144,
-0.4389103353023529,
0.565256655216217,
0.2954462170600891,
0.6227109432220459,
-0.10452497005462646,
-0.67803555727005,
-0.31154054403305054,
-0.415176659822464,
0.40155860781669617,
0.21483507752418518,
-0.059102561324834824,
-0.2798670828342438,
0.1711631715297699,
0.30576565861701965,
-0.6116650700569153,
0.12112600356340408,
-0.37030941247940063,
-0.20408298075199127,
0.7390907406806946,
0.41345667839050293,
0.25518763065338135,
0.35872846841812134,
-0.13933223485946655,
-0.17340120673179626,
-0.7799031734466553,
0.3533262014389038,
0.04879787936806679,
0.3209763169288635,
-0.2197340577840805,
0.3445103168487549,
-0.3764917552471161,
0.5723229646682739,
-0.1972423642873764,
-0.18277737498283386,
0.2281440943479538,
-0.2944021224975586,
-0.10038403421640396,
-0.20231971144676208,
0.6922738552093506,
0.05053793638944626,
0.37715521454811096,
-0.31917789578437805,
0.12924572825431824,
0.22779665887355804,
0.11071165651082993,
-0.5986920595169067,
-0.03601475805044174,
-0.006268021650612354,
-0.3535171151161194,
-0.22570976614952087,
-0.051041919738054276,
-0.4383116364479065,
-0.7836005687713623,
-0.5910114645957947,
-0.15972918272018433,
-0.2856003940105438,
-0.39785462617874146,
-0.1632055789232254,
-0.0066682323813438416,
0.426753968000412,
0.30675309896469116,
-0.5227582454681396,
0.6468089818954468,
0.9898926019668579,
0.5674297213554382,
-0.6121274828910828,
-0.5476655960083008,
-0.2084134817123413,
-0.024801405146718025,
-0.5782139897346497,
0.7045660018920898,
-0.5539282560348511,
-0.35221734642982483,
-0.03548595681786537,
-0.15298619866371155,
0.2562163472175598,
-0.5203657150268555,
0.4544162154197693,
-0.2882773280143738,
-0.4968448579311371,
-0.7128449082374573,
-0.2954755127429962,
0.20367486774921417,
0.489245742559433,
-0.4941900074481964,
1.189113974571228,
0.1027475968003273,
-0.417226105928421,
0.15961024165153503,
-0.22242815792560577,
-0.5831981301307678,
0.20399680733680725,
-0.4829091429710388,
0.17372052371501923,
0.061906855553388596,
-0.07843192666769028,
0.1947951763868332,
-0.9168766140937805,
0.42740657925605774,
-0.7059995532035828,
-0.5375893712043762,
0.4568386971950531,
-0.277083158493042,
0.801485002040863,
0.09674226492643356,
-0.16428251564502716,
-0.11540389806032181,
-0.8506001830101013,
0.5764049887657166,
0.07908909767866135,
-0.29318228363990784,
-0.06232917681336403,
0.3610745370388031,
0.2541634142398834,
0.3082594573497772,
0.6026788353919983,
-0.5064465403556824,
-0.1231803297996521,
-0.29162856936454773,
0.41203686594963074,
0.8702263236045837,
-0.5786334276199341,
0.30134379863739014,
-0.1961655169725418,
0.5019598007202148,
-0.3272620737552643,
0.14196908473968506,
0.13251595199108124,
-0.02763727679848671,
-0.5834265947341919,
-0.32912614941596985,
0.3619626760482788,
0.7102910280227661,
-0.15566428005695343,
0.2741847038269043,
-0.32207727432250977,
-0.9877144694328308,
-0.24610207974910736,
0.3711441457271576,
0.54554283618927,
0.29197031259536743,
0.36258217692375183,
-0.19614891707897186,
-0.5340020656585693,
-1.0434026718139648,
-0.5872705578804016,
0.03577669709920883,
0.1355292797088623,
0.43698227405548096,
0.26643648743629456,
0.0281127467751503,
0.9928376078605652,
-0.3997073471546173,
0.06072356924414635,
-0.2880004048347473,
-0.0034754204098135233,
0.0743669718503952,
0.33241531252861023,
0.4958462417125702,
-0.6073217391967773,
-0.7135966420173645,
0.18752466142177582,
-0.8540589213371277,
-0.4265699088573456,
0.236398845911026,
-0.25033092498779297,
-0.014040501788258553,
0.695321798324585,
-0.21054868400096893,
0.30338019132614136,
0.5325326919555664,
0.02527991496026516,
0.9208608269691467,
0.1096685454249382,
0.12341731786727905,
-0.7638296484947205,
0.47251826524734497,
-0.044249776750802994,
-0.014528345316648483,
-0.25190022587776184,
0.15383315086364746,
0.2975865304470062,
-0.17541825771331787,
-0.3178563416004181,
0.4678821861743927,
-0.5586192607879639,
-0.35908886790275574,
-0.3696894645690918,
0.2587122619152069,
-0.22176925837993622,
0.27284762263298035,
-0.12955303490161896,
0.6408147811889648,
0.8770045638084412,
-0.4861626923084259,
0.35585424304008484,
-0.18985114991664886,
-0.39131274819374084,
0.6625118255615234,
-0.7307243347167969,
-0.1584019511938095,
0.2723289728164673,
0.2729739546775818,
-0.8559582233428955,
0.0027808689046651125,
-0.6652626395225525,
-0.4285498559474945,
0.10698459297418594,
0.12505850195884705,
-0.5938824415206909,
-0.6199407577514648,
-0.19664214551448822,
0.5569599270820618,
0.39136573672294617,
-0.2954115569591522,
0.5243748426437378,
0.49001646041870117,
-0.20254234969615936,
-0.8535781502723694,
-0.863798201084137,
0.22175024449825287,
0.41083064675331116,
-0.6740229725837708,
0.5563763976097107,
-0.28284314274787903,
-0.35409900546073914,
-0.10842100530862808,
-0.3140948712825775,
-0.4147395193576813,
0.26861658692359924,
0.21730954945087433,
0.27567750215530396,
-0.33033016324043274,
-0.07752200216054916,
-0.037113480269908905,
-0.04995432123541832,
0.344331830739975,
-0.03312213718891144,
0.5705220699310303,
-0.44241297245025635,
-0.6763023138046265,
-0.07771910727024078,
0.2025279849767685,
0.6715980172157288,
-0.42050257325172424,
0.35365504026412964,
0.27122336626052856,
-0.44933077692985535,
-0.2850102186203003,
-0.7159824967384338,
0.19410710036754608,
-0.41436338424682617,
0.5563769936561584,
-0.5065539479255676,
-0.7931520342826843,
0.5503808856010437,
-0.318027526140213,
-0.09515178948640823,
0.29931697249412537,
0.4781568646430969,
0.05153816565871239,
1.2275269031524658,
0.6627756357192993,
-0.5111314058303833,
0.2618946433067322,
-0.03226042166352272,
0.09994659572839737,
-0.5584465861320496,
0.015008071437478065,
-0.6878859400749207,
-0.22167570888996124,
-0.35019972920417786,
-0.411239355802536,
0.3719188868999481,
0.1386396884918213,
-0.5502179861068726,
0.33570829033851624,
-0.4218429625034332,
0.7834638953208923,
0.29455432295799255,
0.08545345813035965,
0.17819373309612274,
-0.3049371540546417,
-0.2507041096687317,
-0.14101161062717438,
-0.4073386788368225,
-0.21794810891151428,
1.1537883281707764,
0.09686095267534256,
0.551500141620636,
0.04444005712866783,
0.42373958230018616,
0.2277555912733078,
0.22352562844753265,
-0.4600229561328888,
0.8690730929374695,
-0.3496471643447876,
-0.43756231665611267,
-0.007325819693505764,
-0.3496614396572113,
-0.69713294506073,
0.20147272944450378,
-0.14948652684688568,
-0.7092331647872925,
-0.13003826141357422,
-0.01582799293100834,
-0.0628591850399971,
0.09436242282390594,
-0.4254905879497528,
0.9308164715766907,
-0.6437717080116272,
-0.8033110499382019,
-0.7511457204818726,
-0.3891356885433197,
0.4616333842277527,
-0.18927066028118134,
0.37677857279777527,
-0.03927484154701233,
-0.12261196225881577,
0.36027991771698,
-0.35608866810798645,
0.817822277545929,
-0.02135034091770649,
0.26361972093582153,
0.24054168164730072,
0.3301388621330261,
0.17301103472709656,
-0.13891398906707764,
-0.2087583988904953,
0.12636475265026093,
0.24608641862869263,
-0.6164245009422302,
-0.3328029215335846,
1.1289031505584717,
-0.957724928855896,
-0.5498979687690735,
-0.5160040855407715,
-0.5844456553459167,
-0.5176893472671509,
0.3307191729545593,
-0.22404484450817108,
0.1585615873336792,
-0.6649757027626038,
0.410325288772583,
0.5468207001686096,
-0.35806703567504883,
0.19488030672073364,
0.77046138048172,
-0.15173432230949402,
-0.2718956470489502,
0.9710500836372375,
0.14762602746486664,
0.22152474522590637,
0.39222291111946106,
0.14478877186775208,
-0.01867281086742878,
-0.5503923892974854,
-0.14892339706420898,
0.040645502507686615,
-0.834315836429596,
-0.10605355352163315,
-0.47515740990638733,
-0.46179401874542236,
-0.5675853490829468,
-0.4242900013923645,
-0.5576695799827576,
-0.28134265542030334,
0.13642683625221252,
0.21976755559444427,
-0.010966867208480835,
0.5064883232116699,
-0.000908776477444917,
-0.128155916929245,
-0.499801367521286,
0.161164790391922,
0.11163520812988281,
0.5410028696060181,
0.12165689468383789,
-0.3228415846824646,
-0.26500841975212097,
-0.1154552698135376,
-0.4777625799179077,
-0.6166682243347168,
0.09416849911212921,
-0.13553069531917572,
0.9579433798789978,
0.25758418440818787,
-0.30203408002853394,
0.7892972826957703,
-0.3399752676486969,
0.8493345379829407,
0.24974291026592255,
-1.2572848796844482,
0.3706079423427582,
-0.4801470637321472,
0.5774114727973938,
0.8122971057891846,
0.12425336241722107,
-0.5396363139152527,
-0.3200867772102356,
-0.32998862862586975,
-0.7224740982055664,
0.7100788354873657,
-0.31187549233436584,
-0.08234098553657532,
0.04910563305020332,
-0.09107176959514618,
0.021210607141256332,
0.12511882185935974,
-0.7930852770805359,
-0.08711408823728561,
-0.11233676224946976,
-0.14020919799804688,
0.0499286949634552,
0.06633029133081436,
0.025348085910081863,
-0.515609860420227,
0.7275410294532776,
-0.2656692564487457,
-0.13259324431419373,
-0.2162654548883438,
-0.3665851056575775,
-0.012628261931240559,
0.22833143174648285,
0.35217735171318054,
1.0995757579803467,
0.15832248330116272,
-0.02965002879500389,
0.5693047046661377,
-0.33073869347572327,
-0.3143579959869385,
0.16634860634803772,
0.11385133862495422,
-0.49480193853378296,
0.23634903132915497,
0.04358052462339401,
0.4986160695552826,
-1.0662628412246704,
0.6860218644142151,
0.23620101809501648,
-0.12605154514312744,
-0.5688632130622864,
-0.006776482332497835,
0.36513739824295044,
-0.002141235861927271,
0.48272308707237244,
-0.0512986034154892,
0.050395019352436066,
-0.6066042184829712,
-0.02531762607395649,
0.5679322481155396,
-0.29838401079177856,
-0.01646609418094158,
0.46933621168136597,
0.09625095874071121,
0.025581087917089462,
0.3912818133831024,
-0.01960313878953457,
-0.6460238099098206,
0.9041518568992615,
0.6040184497833252,
0.7519956231117249,
-0.14410671591758728,
-0.008106413297355175,
0.5842269659042358,
0.3442038297653198,
-0.19957494735717773,
0.35489529371261597,
-0.19145746529102325,
-0.3753557503223419,
-0.5148295164108276,
-0.5939143300056458,
-0.5346477031707764,
-0.03884768486022949,
-0.45599207282066345,
0.5389189124107361,
-0.7828865051269531,
0.11319086700677872,
0.03800880163908005,
0.14968420565128326,
-0.7282982468605042,
0.15608756244182587,
0.42748209834098816,
1.3024016618728638,
-0.6922274827957153,
0.8730205297470093,
0.576052188873291,
-0.34319642186164856,
-0.48662808537483215,
-0.41362762451171875,
0.07331094145774841,
-0.7585738897323608,
0.6752578020095825,
-0.054279476404190063,
-0.1887570172548294,
-0.31473299860954285,
-0.745141863822937,
-1.0504350662231445,
1.2384763956069946,
0.42488157749176025,
-0.6227713227272034,
0.299846351146698,
0.5066042542457581,
0.7513841390609741,
-0.2814226746559143,
0.5496777296066284,
0.656008243560791,
0.5838174819946289,
-0.21681088209152222,
-1.1173114776611328,
0.060783594846725464,
-0.5344616174697876,
-0.0595412515103817,
0.11864624917507172,
-0.9171079397201538,
1.0055004358291626,
0.09948761761188507,
0.028488485142588615,
0.2985641062259674,
0.5994284152984619,
0.47938069701194763,
0.29525646567344666,
0.3479830324649811,
0.4261188805103302,
0.7076601982116699,
-0.3052060902118683,
0.8677425384521484,
-0.6270760893821716,
-0.10807372629642487,
0.8800809979438782,
-0.6254881620407104,
0.9259595274925232,
0.11923647671937943,
-0.47215262055397034,
0.7250776290893555,
0.4611159861087799,
-0.23593978583812714,
0.14869478344917297,
0.7229324579238892,
-0.17765773832798004,
-0.6639801859855652,
-0.17216864228248596,
-0.5628333687782288,
0.37801527976989746,
0.43238145112991333,
-0.25639259815216064,
-0.18901392817497253,
-0.23606035113334656,
-0.11995425075292587,
0.6186243891716003,
-0.47228217124938965,
0.32163000106811523,
0.06489262729883194,
-0.8456205129623413,
0.6426032185554504,
0.03461531549692154,
0.4745083451271057,
-0.8379800319671631,
0.17724567651748657,
-0.06334927678108215,
0.4828745126724243,
-0.15147541463375092,
-0.7405256032943726,
0.05299285054206848,
0.20305679738521576,
-0.4535715878009796,
-0.10112623870372772,
0.6803744435310364,
-0.23950953781604767,
-0.598716139793396,
0.6325498819351196,
0.5829159617424011,
0.24387598037719727,
-0.09999113529920578,
-0.8643661141395569,
0.24667924642562866,
-0.29549360275268555,
0.15687713027000427,
0.6010068655014038,
0.2409711480140686,
-0.4917706251144409,
0.700614333152771,
0.7432165145874023,
0.09275393933057785,
-0.06143184006214142,
0.39438706636428833,
0.9743375182151794,
-0.7464404702186584,
-0.4258430302143097,
-0.6600065231323242,
0.2536139190196991,
-0.30403605103492737,
-0.3415071368217468,
0.6737770438194275,
0.9823007583618164,
0.6893167495727539,
0.15080948173999786,
1.1730859279632568,
-0.16413286328315735,
0.5157724022865295,
0.24212974309921265,
0.8186730742454529,
-0.5914556980133057,
0.044036589562892914,
-0.2876942455768585,
-0.8025851845741272,
-0.11488725244998932,
0.1845165193080902,
-0.5246871113777161,
0.12496455758810043,
0.8316792845726013,
0.7199974060058594,
-0.10526067763566971,
0.1297558695077896,
0.2781291604042053,
0.2745479345321655,
0.062150850892066956,
0.9299641847610474,
0.7813539505004883,
-0.17406843602657318,
0.8363504409790039,
-0.19246666133403778,
-0.5442553162574768,
-0.0024686253163963556,
-0.8517627120018005,
-0.9684463143348694,
-0.307481974363327,
-0.124019093811512,
-0.3476879298686981,
-0.026655081659555435,
0.6553533673286438,
0.6863044500350952,
-0.9108485579490662,
-0.7032393217086792,
-0.20443730056285858,
-0.08701207488775253,
-0.6571109890937805,
-0.2136121541261673,
0.21192723512649536,
-0.38327640295028687,
-0.5375543236732483,
0.7134091258049011,
0.09550154209136963,
-0.47088170051574707,
-0.562138020992279,
-0.1898556500673294,
-0.089166559278965,
0.06819842755794525,
0.6266965270042419,
0.6405594348907471,
-0.720159649848938,
0.1709011048078537,
0.40536752343177795,
-0.4918680787086487,
-0.3335934281349182,
0.8656823635101318,
-0.8816214799880981,
0.3432207405567169,
0.7123118042945862,
0.906581699848175,
0.5825672745704651,
-0.2883104979991913,
0.636102020740509,
-0.5321402549743652,
-0.15856891870498657,
0.19954676926136017,
0.44734424352645874,
0.37845367193222046,
-0.005340521223843098,
0.5593678951263428,
0.22816962003707886,
-0.5050909519195557,
-0.9927046298980713,
-0.11275255680084229,
-1.1878366470336914,
-0.5478382706642151,
0.9933045506477356,
0.08708655834197998,
-0.18110741674900055,
0.02876385860145092,
-0.03430318459868431,
0.1243581473827362,
-0.06269954144954681,
0.6888523697853088,
0.9738451242446899,
0.10513733327388763,
0.10233954340219498,
-0.5814443230628967,
0.1273571103811264,
0.7754114270210266,
-0.81084805727005,
0.38665497303009033,
0.404166579246521,
0.30401888489723206,
0.13147005438804626,
0.6355728507041931,
-0.2781156003475189,
0.812330961227417,
0.02811378799378872,
0.3321951925754547,
-0.03194066509604454,
-0.24506202340126038,
0.11260986328125,
0.26521217823028564,
0.06845815479755402,
0.36764296889305115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08582v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08582v1
|
Exploring Fact Memorization and Style Imitation in LLMs Using QLoRA: An Experimental Study and Quality Assessment Methods
| 2024-06-12T18:38:40 | 2024-06-12T18:38:40 |
Eugene Vyborov, Oleksiy Osypenko, Serge Sotnyk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
There are various methods for adapting LLMs to different domains. The most
common methods are prompting, finetuning, and RAG. In this work, we explore the
possibility of adapting a model using one of the PEFT methods - QLoRA. The
experiment aims to simulate human responses based on their interviews. The
simulation quality is assessed by comparing the quality of the style and the
quality of the generated facts.
|
[
-0.3063521087169647,
-1.1414554119110107,
0.7614211440086365,
0.17670980095863342,
-0.4067074656486511,
0.11961036175489426,
0.13997311890125275,
-0.3200419545173645,
0.20606032013893127,
0.41308945417404175,
-0.6702487468719482,
-0.3623345196247101,
0.08862520009279251,
-0.06167611852288246,
-0.3638118803501129,
0.9000453352928162,
-0.2403019815683365,
0.33894044160842896,
-0.006110134534537792,
-0.16083678603172302,
-0.5540882349014282,
-0.8559635281562805,
-0.8387095332145691,
-0.20583872497081757,
0.37780070304870605,
0.5526062250137329,
0.5798028111457825,
0.06373810768127441,
0.26066988706588745,
0.3215094208717346,
-0.15439282357692719,
0.48425087332725525,
-0.6696621775627136,
-0.21897576749324799,
-0.39788323640823364,
-0.9407762885093689,
-0.4597702622413635,
0.6334714889526367,
0.7340952157974243,
0.23533818125724792,
-0.13886061310768127,
0.511411726474762,
-0.014881972223520279,
0.6085557341575623,
-0.4763500392436981,
-0.008867545984685421,
-0.3068055808544159,
0.2940136790275574,
0.11651791632175446,
-0.5746058225631714,
-0.19854828715324402,
-0.6169270277023315,
0.30460265278816223,
-0.5405372381210327,
0.3119969666004181,
0.36959365010261536,
0.7337568998336792,
-0.23908868432044983,
-0.24888278543949127,
-0.5967415571212769,
-1.1077057123184204,
0.6176601052284241,
-0.8107526302337646,
0.4035662114620209,
0.17695587873458862,
0.4712197184562683,
-0.2426862120628357,
-0.8199296593666077,
-0.8952971696853638,
-0.18166357278823853,
-0.1768987476825714,
0.3157396614551544,
0.27341699600219727,
-0.0971602201461792,
0.24929434061050415,
0.34558048844337463,
-0.4246843755245209,
-0.18780818581581116,
-0.42499276995658875,
-0.06990288943052292,
0.8020327091217041,
0.1942686289548874,
0.4450218677520752,
0.06932778656482697,
-0.6179103255271912,
-0.3902583122253418,
-0.7818562388420105,
0.2496730089187622,
0.24774762988090515,
-0.15014179050922394,
0.10952267050743103,
0.3231549561023712,
0.00036203526542522013,
0.5080268979072571,
0.11033232510089874,
-0.6120875477790833,
0.03814733028411865,
-0.5950536131858826,
-0.5101943612098694,
0.2219351977109909,
0.2172529250383377,
0.6715982556343079,
0.03945880010724068,
0.026395151391625404,
-0.2443922907114029,
-0.3576993942260742,
0.20308279991149902,
-0.5540812015533447,
-0.24126259982585907,
0.16659873723983765,
-0.6404604315757751,
-0.10066854953765869,
0.05188021808862686,
-0.9932518601417542,
-0.3625352084636688,
-0.5340576767921448,
0.8637808561325073,
-0.3625160753726959,
-0.14041368663311005,
-0.05354975908994675,
-0.12134398519992828,
0.6912581324577332,
0.6926709413528442,
-0.5897524952888489,
0.44780582189559937,
0.4163815379142761,
0.781028687953949,
-0.4187154471874237,
-0.4174038767814636,
-0.17134211957454681,
-0.21153660118579865,
-0.5792853236198425,
0.9473071098327637,
0.15577685832977295,
-0.45282503962516785,
-0.18750709295272827,
0.07285765558481216,
-0.239153191447258,
-0.6788403987884521,
0.6378836035728455,
-0.8285489082336426,
0.3484278917312622,
-0.38280022144317627,
-0.7917494773864746,
-0.6404153108596802,
0.24536705017089844,
-0.6778883934020996,
0.9101337790489197,
0.5009123086929321,
-0.5004414916038513,
0.27493834495544434,
-0.5981643795967102,
0.16163378953933716,
-0.23985788226127625,
-0.03742484375834465,
-0.6195521950721741,
0.08553937077522278,
-0.20964112877845764,
0.23877917230129242,
-0.005277331918478012,
0.11439599841833115,
-0.09334459155797958,
-0.617314875125885,
0.9691299796104431,
-0.5159796476364136,
0.6182911396026611,
0.3569859564304352,
-0.17104651033878326,
0.38606497645378113,
-0.7551110982894897,
0.1833939254283905,
0.276105672121048,
-0.5076566934585571,
-0.2173609584569931,
-0.08067145943641663,
0.09838211536407471,
0.3886510133743286,
-0.05961388349533081,
-0.3302944600582123,
0.20327819883823395,
-0.2540358901023865,
0.13757525384426117,
0.6111390590667725,
0.6602076888084412,
0.2526492476463318,
-1.0373656749725342,
0.4558109641075134,
-0.13062015175819397,
0.2583247125148773,
0.33576443791389465,
-0.268698126077652,
-0.768943727016449,
0.005513579118996859,
0.32178738713264465,
0.63844895362854,
-0.672966480255127,
-0.17047753930091858,
0.23459689319133759,
-0.5533838868141174,
-0.339534193277359,
0.3414495289325714,
0.38234978914260864,
0.3448379635810852,
0.14740310609340668,
-0.40989720821380615,
-0.6263108849525452,
-0.6801275610923767,
-0.19159618020057678,
-0.22153227031230927,
0.018613308668136597,
0.12748660147190094,
0.30044811964035034,
0.21499106287956238,
1.1015092134475708,
-0.3840301036834717,
-0.18686740100383759,
-0.26125866174697876,
0.20076490938663483,
0.13379669189453125,
0.40560564398765564,
1.0430817604064941,
-1.0303966999053955,
-0.31374889612197876,
-0.49222689867019653,
-0.5388038158416748,
-0.1098189726471901,
-0.4120374321937561,
-0.259046345949173,
0.13167870044708252,
0.6418749094009399,
-0.1438552886247635,
0.5120400786399841,
0.598862886428833,
-0.5220431089401245,
1.0675175189971924,
-0.11431337147951126,
0.5262415409088135,
-0.8991783857345581,
0.01608271896839142,
-0.13013288378715515,
-0.3772730827331543,
-0.9727681279182434,
0.1116122454404831,
-0.17113660275936127,
0.16370151937007904,
-1.048359990119934,
0.533079981803894,
-0.5346496105194092,
-0.3942909836769104,
-0.42688295245170593,
0.014881521463394165,
0.19825078547000885,
0.6635546088218689,
0.006142411846667528,
1.2557352781295776,
-0.059038981795310974,
-0.8144063949584961,
0.24204759299755096,
0.05804281309247017,
-0.47792622447013855,
0.5688034296035767,
-0.5416224002838135,
0.2559746503829956,
-0.09712755680084229,
0.024741262197494507,
-1.3447272777557373,
0.053305484354496,
0.34332606196403503,
0.03357487544417381,
0.17692553997039795,
0.031187940388917923,
-0.6277953386306763,
-0.018322139978408813,
-0.6609660983085632,
0.24352964758872986,
0.8348700404167175,
-0.5443379878997803,
0.6891970038414001,
0.11976749449968338,
-0.20980633795261383,
0.06732476502656937,
-0.23815412819385529,
-0.0757904052734375,
-0.7360843420028687,
-0.1430693119764328,
0.4517836570739746,
-0.6395578384399414,
-0.6797599196434021,
-0.354086697101593,
-0.04871002212166786,
-0.23070688545703888,
0.4397122859954834,
0.11422982811927795,
0.42364418506622314,
-0.36341971158981323,
-0.20281001925468445,
-0.009514718316495419,
0.5943686366081238,
0.1392870545387268,
0.20148837566375732,
0.6289039850234985,
-0.12100089341402054,
-0.49510690569877625,
-0.843925416469574,
-0.041233740746974945,
0.43957042694091797,
0.2154051512479782,
0.45075929164886475,
0.55906081199646,
-0.09113343060016632,
-0.2113640457391739,
-0.6925998330116272,
-0.3104243278503418,
-0.4989026188850403,
0.03280015289783478,
-0.25792407989501953,
-0.5642406344413757,
0.4848833978176117,
-0.5050112009048462,
0.0786655992269516,
0.14054657518863678,
0.6764551997184753,
-0.5707302093505859,
0.5912089347839355,
0.5550271272659302,
0.26626867055892944,
0.7613087296485901,
-0.2713405191898346,
-0.2060893476009369,
-0.8214729428291321,
-0.06812688708305359,
-0.13854241371154785,
-0.3962695896625519,
-0.42332923412323,
-0.6834579706192017,
0.5994036197662354,
0.503024697303772,
0.02424636483192444,
-0.10203281044960022,
-0.08742529153823853,
0.4385024309158325,
0.7345858216285706,
0.4911401569843292,
0.49312520027160645,
0.05594661459326744,
0.15497374534606934,
0.14539644122123718,
-0.7406187057495117,
-0.666179895401001,
1.0591940879821777,
0.3722796142101288,
0.7656238675117493,
0.19507835805416107,
0.7511572241783142,
0.4842791259288788,
0.6238386631011963,
-0.7592359781265259,
0.46530401706695557,
0.2806090712547302,
-0.5085505843162537,
-0.5759689211845398,
-0.021044017747044563,
-0.6921363472938538,
0.30724212527275085,
-0.31651774048805237,
-0.7308286428451538,
0.4288550317287445,
0.24132394790649414,
-0.5913283228874207,
0.2006029635667801,
-0.6878955364227295,
0.3063644468784332,
-0.3433196246623993,
-0.38117384910583496,
-0.04284794628620148,
-0.2820081412792206,
0.4491747319698334,
-0.22566375136375427,
0.2823851704597473,
-0.05215275660157204,
0.3019287884235382,
1.191071629524231,
-0.0880199447274208,
1.1544541120529175,
-0.06790375709533691,
-0.3579089939594269,
0.9620422720909119,
0.4830196797847748,
0.31616875529289246,
0.014141282998025417,
-0.06961555033922195,
-0.26690438389778137,
0.33218008279800415,
-0.30477166175842285,
-1.0102757215499878,
0.4128510355949402,
-0.8560236096382141,
-0.8558664321899414,
-0.35929301381111145,
-0.6453284621238708,
-0.37167826294898987,
0.023029234260320663,
-0.2129894495010376,
0.15242715179920197,
-0.5228900909423828,
-0.3918325901031494,
0.7128462791442871,
-0.234843447804451,
0.2819121479988098,
0.9010099768638611,
-0.4184727966785431,
-0.22155095636844635,
0.8028687238693237,
0.4667321443557739,
0.41834455728530884,
0.13153067231178284,
0.46028485894203186,
-0.3860161304473877,
-0.7694084048271179,
-0.43619757890701294,
0.34281614422798157,
-0.7818349003791809,
0.07199085503816605,
-0.16925078630447388,
-0.3763391673564911,
-0.2442905455827713,
-0.10371565073728561,
-0.11972414702177048,
-0.5107705593109131,
-0.34619033336639404,
-0.1513902246952057,
0.4391805827617645,
0.8603405952453613,
0.17194391787052155,
0.2535279393196106,
-0.6137672662734985,
0.2930994927883148,
0.7888784408569336,
0.10822401195764542,
-0.01600194349884987,
-0.6417269110679626,
0.050640687346458435,
0.07720158249139786,
-0.481648325920105,
-1.1950865983963013,
0.4197939336299896,
0.14837615191936493,
0.8575598001480103,
0.35872480273246765,
-0.041450854390859604,
0.5116236805915833,
-0.3532322347164154,
0.8775398135185242,
-0.0990651398897171,
-0.8253670930862427,
0.40816831588745117,
0.018549922853708267,
-0.36551645398139954,
0.5110443830490112,
0.4728727638721466,
-0.40536195039749146,
0.0286086518317461,
-0.7114813327789307,
-0.24117125570774078,
0.5483183264732361,
0.2538132071495056,
-0.08087531477212906,
0.43687552213668823,
0.8151292204856873,
0.017666148021817207,
0.17540805041790009,
-0.3609246611595154,
-0.3355468213558197,
-0.30145499110221863,
0.08558541536331177,
-0.18549726903438568,
-0.6437833309173584,
-0.40290218591690063,
-0.24250447750091553,
0.49951088428497314,
-0.2255779504776001,
0.3686579763889313,
0.5950234532356262,
-0.1834908127784729,
0.059971485286951065,
0.31586235761642456,
0.9696651697158813,
1.038201093673706,
-0.45717543363571167,
0.3987434208393097,
0.6816941499710083,
-0.291660875082016,
0.5408191084861755,
-0.5400854349136353,
-0.20054137706756592,
0.05036132037639618,
0.23893249034881592,
0.5148215889930725,
0.19990874826908112,
-0.6940369606018066,
0.14388500154018402,
-0.04097629338502884,
-0.21067962050437927,
-0.2749330997467041,
0.5736619830131531,
0.18885749578475952,
0.381551593542099,
0.2884652018547058,
-0.5022504329681396,
0.3384023606777191,
-1.2370437383651733,
0.31950414180755615,
0.02291840687394142,
-0.18214255571365356,
-0.41933006048202515,
0.27311813831329346,
-0.1821700483560562,
-0.6109541654586792,
0.3374800384044647,
-0.4027693569660187,
-0.6887181997299194,
0.7794610857963562,
0.7743439078330994,
0.41569480299949646,
-0.45465603470802307,
0.2996275722980499,
0.29621952772140503,
-0.11227338761091232,
-0.2410433292388916,
0.817700207233429,
0.17604495584964752,
-0.7921167612075806,
-0.15494593977928162,
-0.6142802238464355,
-0.8303353190422058,
0.07890705019235611,
-0.6718889474868774,
0.06335195153951645,
-0.5472912788391113,
-0.05919468030333519,
-0.1751500368118286,
0.14775171875953674,
-0.655564546585083,
0.22997508943080902,
0.029341917484998703,
1.1052708625793457,
-1.1139541864395142,
0.9280117154121399,
0.6346620917320251,
-0.3849923014640808,
-1.0543537139892578,
0.06336198002099991,
0.1520189791917801,
-0.9251360893249512,
0.8532958626747131,
-0.533591628074646,
-0.15617744624614716,
0.060258135199546814,
-0.6548388600349426,
-0.9368597865104675,
1.5425209999084473,
0.05724748224020004,
-0.3106030523777008,
0.045930929481983185,
-0.003235650947317481,
0.7216367721557617,
-0.321927547454834,
0.030305808410048485,
0.9224424362182617,
0.5275872349739075,
-0.038128145039081573,
-0.9094302654266357,
0.04763909429311752,
0.028910499066114426,
0.11929356306791306,
-0.6059443354606628,
-0.9451175332069397,
1.0788248777389526,
-0.10049156844615936,
-0.45402976870536804,
0.1982351839542389,
0.8748263716697693,
0.7302040457725525,
0.7112652063369751,
0.5895253419876099,
-0.05489949509501457,
0.780159592628479,
0.325113981962204,
0.9433280229568481,
-0.1063007265329361,
0.5396771430969238,
1.1602120399475098,
-0.44941219687461853,
0.6359177231788635,
0.628465473651886,
-0.5589518547058105,
0.6881137490272522,
0.7160860300064087,
0.002333670621737838,
0.24287815392017365,
0.5022512674331665,
-0.023210370913147926,
0.10410895198583603,
-0.21299737691879272,
0.013666169717907906,
0.49762627482414246,
0.5103664994239807,
-0.19605109095573425,
-0.18884867429733276,
-0.02255817875266075,
0.1428396999835968,
0.11241628229618073,
-0.4494969844818115,
0.9130565524101257,
-0.015507392585277557,
-0.7077348828315735,
0.7545711994171143,
0.04805648699402809,
0.5414307713508606,
-0.3614324629306793,
-0.46060124039649963,
-0.3824279010295868,
-0.2171705961227417,
-0.10132385045289993,
-0.8442862033843994,
0.06951377540826797,
-0.4130149185657501,
0.006847833748906851,
-0.010734581388533115,
0.7175940275192261,
-0.43301713466644287,
-0.4406953752040863,
-0.07741470634937286,
0.7786635160446167,
0.3657386004924774,
0.19804860651493073,
-0.7315659523010254,
-0.04318942874670029,
-0.2198798954486847,
-0.41715624928474426,
0.6818550825119019,
0.2324122190475464,
-0.3880179822444916,
0.7027528285980225,
0.6292150020599365,
0.17352460324764252,
0.20358042418956757,
0.02552839368581772,
0.7662534117698669,
-0.5753923058509827,
-0.4522598385810852,
-0.7711794376373291,
-0.3020995557308197,
0.049178220331668854,
-0.09732706099748611,
1.1812047958374023,
0.3614729642868042,
0.672161877155304,
-0.3026125133037567,
0.4045531451702118,
0.4337116777896881,
0.45086559653282166,
-1.1152421236038208,
0.7060429453849792,
-0.19529680907726288,
0.07812478393316269,
-0.3916037082672119,
-0.7773582339286804,
-0.003361006733030081,
0.5959076285362244,
-0.02892015501856804,
-0.04138640686869621,
0.7621496319770813,
0.8534146547317505,
-0.05517829582095146,
0.043311942368745804,
0.43367132544517517,
0.2540687918663025,
0.33274078369140625,
0.31520169973373413,
1.0870676040649414,
-0.21121960878372192,
0.09846851974725723,
-0.49634552001953125,
-0.17016953229904175,
-0.5150802731513977,
-0.8405007123947144,
-0.9315178990364075,
-0.4797278344631195,
-0.3337962329387665,
-0.5097530484199524,
0.22361789643764496,
1.1668627262115479,
0.7753081321716309,
-0.8461402654647827,
-0.3902400732040405,
0.3685137927532196,
0.2516164481639862,
-0.6234679818153381,
-0.2752145826816559,
0.7616103887557983,
-0.06451494246721268,
-0.6800225973129272,
0.4665296971797943,
-0.1818554550409317,
0.7925806641578674,
-0.5113911032676697,
0.0448995977640152,
-0.2713576555252075,
0.4470774233341217,
0.6372110843658447,
0.2774440348148346,
-0.4838229715824127,
-0.5220040082931519,
-0.0957343578338623,
0.007380683906376362,
0.0982552319765091,
1.2417304515838623,
-0.6956892013549805,
0.2556614279747009,
0.6637991070747375,
0.2021874636411667,
0.33322909474372864,
0.40693649649620056,
0.42081862688064575,
-0.4487667381763458,
-0.1690172255039215,
0.03125480189919472,
0.2734108567237854,
-0.0014330806443467736,
-0.5299413204193115,
0.4079865515232086,
0.21079309284687042,
-0.5283913016319275,
-0.7105817198753357,
0.06657647341489792,
-1.0519689321517944,
-0.4885450601577759,
1.2336227893829346,
-0.4632320702075958,
-0.5897531509399414,
-0.32312464714050293,
-0.8034614324569702,
0.16330929100513458,
-0.0007027554675005376,
1.0557844638824463,
0.6119626760482788,
-0.7149519324302673,
-0.18397924304008484,
-0.6341778039932251,
0.7430748343467712,
0.102616086602211,
-0.8186368942260742,
-0.2117355614900589,
0.1857604682445526,
0.8626378178596497,
0.13702720403671265,
0.9409919381141663,
-0.1366717666387558,
0.5655237436294556,
-0.23538543283939362,
-0.021757002919912338,
-0.07018008083105087,
-0.30905693769454956,
-0.3159359395503998,
0.2615445554256439,
0.5338486433029175,
0.11899261921644211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10288v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10288v2
|
Mimicking User Data: On Mitigating Fine-Tuning Risks in Closed Large Language Models
| 2024-06-12T18:33:11 | 2024-07-01T10:17:58 |
Francisco Eiras, Aleksandar Petrov, Phillip H. S. Torr, M. Pawan Kumar, Adel Bibi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning large language models on small, high-quality datasets can enhance
their performance on specific downstream tasks. Recent research shows that
fine-tuning on benign, instruction-following data can inadvertently undo the
safety alignment process and increase a model's propensity to comply with
harmful queries. Although critical, understanding and mitigating safety risks
in well-defined tasks remains distinct from the instruction-following context
due to structural differences in the data. Our work addresses the gap in our
understanding of these risks across diverse types of data in closed models -
where providers control how user data is utilized in the fine-tuning process.
We demonstrate how malicious actors can subtly manipulate the structure of
almost any task-specific dataset to foster significantly more dangerous model
behaviors, while maintaining an appearance of innocuity and reasonable
downstream task performance. To address this issue, we propose a novel
mitigation strategy that mixes in safety data which mimics the task format and
prompting style of the user data, showing this is more effective than existing
baselines at re-establishing safety alignment while maintaining similar task
performance.
|
[
0.020939387381076813,
-0.8582510948181152,
0.22213946282863617,
-0.24756339192390442,
0.13264763355255127,
0.019101735204458237,
-0.10265583544969559,
-0.5315444469451904,
-0.17600026726722717,
1.0930914878845215,
-0.7169747948646545,
-0.4419808089733124,
-0.2726151645183563,
-0.4456513822078705,
-0.3292536735534668,
1.2400915622711182,
0.09743034839630127,
-0.3676244616508484,
-0.03467926010489464,
0.20555615425109863,
-0.6299573183059692,
-0.6757254004478455,
-0.8393998146057129,
-0.08181940019130707,
0.8269995450973511,
0.6748906970024109,
1.0113375186920166,
0.9638899564743042,
0.4114401340484619,
0.20777855813503265,
0.2471131980419159,
0.03731178119778633,
-0.9461763501167297,
0.32372772693634033,
-0.31969955563545227,
-0.582485556602478,
-0.46408891677856445,
-0.14885586500167847,
0.4334630072116852,
0.9007063508033752,
-0.15621702373027802,
0.0753249004483223,
0.5349962115287781,
0.7710078358650208,
-0.9019052982330322,
0.15630291402339935,
-0.7175315618515015,
-0.1408771127462387,
-0.5226103067398071,
-0.35426369309425354,
-0.6392108201980591,
-0.2998899817466736,
-0.09696313738822937,
-0.4486199915409088,
0.1385738104581833,
0.23093341290950775,
0.7142873406410217,
0.41488683223724365,
-0.35385099053382874,
0.016594257205724716,
-0.8174829483032227,
0.659920871257782,
-0.5936751365661621,
0.06966527551412582,
0.5359256863594055,
0.2825421094894409,
-0.45188406109809875,
-0.32102328538894653,
-0.26611748337745667,
0.005444918293505907,
-0.1888456642627716,
-0.3001940846443176,
-0.1895923763513565,
0.16756020486354828,
0.5412505865097046,
-0.013719161041080952,
-0.4857485294342041,
0.41324615478515625,
-0.5219205021858215,
-0.3919278085231781,
0.7451584339141846,
0.5090821981430054,
0.44689908623695374,
0.08959326148033142,
-0.266001433134079,
-0.37523791193962097,
-1.225481390953064,
0.30433371663093567,
0.9650724530220032,
0.7117756605148315,
0.032350149005651474,
0.4296826124191284,
-0.5162353515625,
0.5365245938301086,
-0.15844018757343292,
0.14583836495876312,
0.1898280382156372,
-0.3607044517993927,
-0.33805960416793823,
0.14595939218997955,
0.4730100929737091,
0.6246170401573181,
0.6075035333633423,
-0.23609615862369537,
-0.3409513235092163,
0.01281531248241663,
0.5803426504135132,
-0.49159371852874756,
-0.4160682260990143,
0.0682709589600563,
-0.2931077778339386,
-0.4846840500831604,
0.012910846620798111,
-0.784541666507721,
-0.4868689179420471,
-0.5048761367797852,
0.49216189980506897,
-0.24888531863689423,
-0.0548836886882782,
0.22585317492485046,
0.3175075352191925,
-0.07811456173658371,
0.12493878602981567,
-1.0281474590301514,
0.5445201992988586,
0.8156090974807739,
0.36255091428756714,
-0.023544782772660255,
-0.14765632152557373,
-0.8060141205787659,
0.6586867570877075,
-0.40859267115592957,
0.4074435532093048,
-0.6662686467170715,
-0.36730289459228516,
-0.02017737179994583,
0.10848628729581833,
-0.15806733071804047,
-0.45939382910728455,
0.5543168187141418,
-0.42129161953926086,
0.005121578462421894,
-0.49782946705818176,
-0.27203071117401123,
-0.1578165888786316,
0.1032378077507019,
-0.5483595728874207,
0.8453180193901062,
-0.07675226777791977,
-0.7963932156562805,
0.47186681628227234,
-0.36631107330322266,
-0.6736312508583069,
-0.3138291835784912,
-0.08681382238864899,
-0.5623555183410645,
-0.02693812921643257,
0.13062649965286255,
0.5778967142105103,
0.17089243233203888,
-0.20200450718402863,
-0.38617634773254395,
-0.4632604420185089,
-0.08387773483991623,
-0.2915123403072357,
0.6573270559310913,
0.11818013340234756,
-0.09855445474386215,
0.3433622121810913,
-0.5395554900169373,
0.05279499292373657,
-0.08251627534627914,
-0.07613727450370789,
-0.8416761159896851,
0.14527514576911926,
0.012370617128908634,
0.1854233294725418,
0.18159374594688416,
-0.32307589054107666,
0.19327861070632935,
-0.3679684102535248,
0.17836053669452667,
0.9546777009963989,
0.2118408977985382,
0.4768175482749939,
-0.642123281955719,
0.42663928866386414,
0.08394145220518112,
0.4766058623790741,
-0.13205166161060333,
-0.25790807604789734,
-0.46217796206474304,
-0.07052764296531677,
0.022794175893068314,
0.6751338839530945,
-0.505035400390625,
0.20531731843948364,
-0.15715670585632324,
-0.49029237031936646,
-0.5438218712806702,
0.20681974291801453,
0.6010437607765198,
0.7916533350944519,
0.25436151027679443,
-0.2938431203365326,
-0.44080424308776855,
-0.9686130285263062,
-0.49757447838783264,
0.09943954646587372,
-0.09336163848638535,
0.44331467151641846,
0.14434485137462616,
-0.2601613700389862,
0.4935934841632843,
-0.6714174747467041,
-0.23932775855064392,
0.04794822633266449,
0.07025934755802155,
0.08479395508766174,
1.0243757963180542,
0.474180668592453,
-0.7235555052757263,
-0.4392886757850647,
0.013052611611783504,
-0.38026630878448486,
-0.03307453542947769,
-0.4247545301914215,
-0.2222004383802414,
0.19344662129878998,
0.814109742641449,
-0.28323784470558167,
0.4711601734161377,
0.2540690302848816,
-0.3788645267486572,
0.543718695640564,
-0.17181648313999176,
0.2271626740694046,
-0.9925957322120667,
0.12484164535999298,
-0.26311853528022766,
-0.1572420746088028,
-0.871747612953186,
0.19355803728103638,
0.11222351342439651,
0.04708300158381462,
-0.3147566020488739,
0.20190083980560303,
-0.35204145312309265,
0.2134927213191986,
-0.1569976806640625,
-0.4249469041824341,
-0.38139092922210693,
0.3470168709754944,
-0.4451351761817932,
0.8099491000175476,
0.7846570611000061,
-0.6576376557350159,
-0.0999046340584755,
0.19700372219085693,
-0.26957154273986816,
0.4011949598789215,
-0.6545950174331665,
0.19880330562591553,
-0.189315065741539,
-0.25342410802841187,
-0.8361402750015259,
-0.6049601435661316,
0.2593909800052643,
-0.17571964859962463,
0.5468640923500061,
-0.42783573269844055,
-0.7500917315483093,
0.03562600165605545,
-0.4376853108406067,
0.3194139003753662,
0.6906387805938721,
-0.224191814661026,
0.1960541307926178,
0.3945375084877014,
-0.34293845295906067,
-0.5969293117523193,
-0.6865216493606567,
0.034735433757305145,
-0.4953089654445648,
-0.6154571771621704,
0.17533807456493378,
0.06703940778970718,
-0.06209084391593933,
-0.12840218842029572,
-0.2615661919116974,
0.014922437258064747,
0.4824143648147583,
0.5483357310295105,
0.3005269467830658,
-0.006845066789537668,
-0.04598147049546242,
0.39671680331230164,
-0.15489380061626434,
0.17846344411373138,
-0.03758241608738899,
0.30462539196014404,
0.2648806869983673,
-0.47616130113601685,
-0.4840486943721771,
0.4313104450702667,
0.4236994683742523,
-0.060903988778591156,
0.7947618961334229,
0.10857132822275162,
-0.6296306848526001,
-0.2083512544631958,
-0.3061152696609497,
-0.6690921187400818,
-0.5531129240989685,
0.1024787649512291,
-0.2438373863697052,
-0.7873451709747314,
0.5487227439880371,
0.0037865093909204006,
0.2327057272195816,
0.052627645432949066,
0.4551115930080414,
-0.45044389367103577,
1.0943259000778198,
0.864509105682373,
-0.2045663297176361,
0.529476523399353,
0.15925233066082,
0.21365655958652496,
-0.4829986095428467,
-0.2597739100456238,
-0.6627931594848633,
-0.447304904460907,
-0.6981649994850159,
-0.13703301548957825,
0.48401543498039246,
-0.01358562707901001,
-0.31868186593055725,
0.4928278625011444,
-0.20114241540431976,
0.6530409455299377,
0.5170716047286987,
0.37631940841674805,
0.2910708487033844,
0.1259361058473587,
-0.060830406844615936,
0.0107954116538167,
-0.4473687410354614,
-0.7055990099906921,
1.138839602470398,
0.30085045099258423,
1.2806438207626343,
0.015498080290853977,
0.6335055828094482,
0.2641482651233673,
-0.08157555013895035,
-0.2335277944803238,
0.4428442418575287,
-0.24900507926940918,
-0.5742354989051819,
-0.2938137948513031,
-0.4469989538192749,
-0.9399406909942627,
-0.08536870032548904,
-0.27668869495391846,
-1.1360641717910767,
0.07118260115385056,
0.6721633076667786,
-0.39981329441070557,
0.22294732928276062,
-0.8412399888038635,
0.9785547256469727,
0.1728712022304535,
-0.4408974349498749,
-0.3812057375907898,
-0.8497637510299683,
0.3080887496471405,
-0.06406835466623306,
0.054212190210819244,
-0.11116581410169601,
0.07093420624732971,
0.5292534232139587,
-0.1328955888748169,
1.2772390842437744,
-0.12744612991809845,
0.0659908801317215,
-0.06634144484996796,
0.318856418132782,
0.7813311219215393,
-0.13790322840213776,
-0.0015499434666708112,
-0.11244944483041763,
0.06615748256444931,
-0.5937291979789734,
-0.5024009346961975,
0.9767311215400696,
-0.3457736074924469,
-0.7552295327186584,
-0.11607631295919418,
-0.8011937141418457,
-0.445313423871994,
0.39592841267585754,
0.0566863976418972,
0.30905547738075256,
0.06823743879795074,
0.28693798184394836,
0.86549311876297,
-0.018327753990888596,
0.20456986129283905,
0.341936856508255,
0.4372005760669708,
0.271533340215683,
0.7869006395339966,
0.05650996044278145,
0.5193758606910706,
0.32944169640541077,
0.1171601414680481,
-0.08676330000162125,
-0.6631032824516296,
-0.24756096303462982,
-0.066933773458004,
-0.4681454300880432,
-0.21038778126239777,
-0.487554132938385,
-0.015197685919702053,
-0.3012765049934387,
-0.19994497299194336,
-0.2510789632797241,
-0.30820685625076294,
-0.4340885579586029,
-0.21676529943943024,
0.28619933128356934,
0.4931548833847046,
0.11804740130901337,
0.3542494773864746,
-0.7364371418952942,
-0.07668952643871307,
0.07029116153717041,
0.5472937822341919,
0.01474838051944971,
-0.21849308907985687,
-0.1694447100162506,
0.07556302100419998,
-0.230935201048851,
-0.6952934265136719,
0.22524313628673553,
0.05630398541688919,
0.6304174661636353,
0.4916945993900299,
0.3371787667274475,
0.591966450214386,
-0.7644092440605164,
0.5027801990509033,
-0.14910852909088135,
-0.6032910943031311,
0.5596804022789001,
-0.563629150390625,
-0.03919366002082825,
0.7495774030685425,
0.5451892018318176,
-0.4464911222457886,
-0.44611114263534546,
-0.3179924786090851,
-0.8045046925544739,
0.587731659412384,
0.3071431517601013,
0.45417410135269165,
0.28087490797042847,
0.36284321546554565,
0.151558518409729,
0.17388302087783813,
-0.2149115800857544,
-0.058220140635967255,
0.14142628014087677,
-0.3467426896095276,
0.001842027879320085,
-0.19542765617370605,
-0.4199240505695343,
0.05037699639797211,
0.4940869212150574,
-0.20145173370838165,
-0.2314259558916092,
-0.22646795213222504,
0.13181275129318237,
-0.32583585381507874,
0.35421010851860046,
0.4978320896625519,
0.31748712062835693,
-0.09185558557510376,
0.14839407801628113,
0.017503973096609116,
-0.5466156601905823,
-0.20025573670864105,
-0.017745019868016243,
-0.3754018247127533,
-0.7223413586616516,
0.2962678372859955,
0.5163187980651855,
0.5279239416122437,
-0.8306324481964111,
0.10136332362890244,
0.20360812544822693,
0.2193300426006317,
0.0913940966129303,
0.79048091173172,
-0.0737457275390625,
0.12259078025817871,
0.20057378709316254,
0.2661491930484772,
0.3878990709781647,
-0.6528028845787048,
0.4492940306663513,
0.43555948138237,
-0.4107092022895813,
-0.4767319858074188,
0.7531383633613586,
0.04618652164936066,
-0.1605323702096939,
0.559529721736908,
0.27082329988479614,
-0.14933159947395325,
0.6795021295547485,
0.3578794300556183,
0.6581071615219116,
-0.37731319665908813,
-0.25483861565589905,
0.27606311440467834,
0.5897504687309265,
-0.1424344927072525,
0.6584461331367493,
0.24667172133922577,
-0.5143104195594788,
-0.17108570039272308,
-0.27515846490859985,
-0.30218780040740967,
0.050686437636613846,
-0.9523419141769409,
0.2502286732196808,
-0.5021809339523315,
0.06859651207923889,
-0.03770725801587105,
-0.3731699585914612,
-0.5497366189956665,
0.11084583401679993,
-0.1345061957836151,
0.9301339387893677,
-1.0309630632400513,
0.8979222178459167,
0.4421183466911316,
-0.23181070387363434,
-0.7321017980575562,
0.38589200377464294,
0.2344711869955063,
-0.4857058823108673,
0.18695281445980072,
0.17662958800792694,
-0.061850544065237045,
-0.19122661650180817,
-0.5300343632698059,
-0.6075029969215393,
0.7840330600738525,
0.5357457995414734,
-0.7014941573143005,
-0.1567978709936142,
0.2059369534254074,
0.5262850522994995,
-0.1937856376171112,
-0.5367224812507629,
0.6898696422576904,
0.22232456505298615,
-0.20647624135017395,
-0.9376883506774902,
0.41869959235191345,
0.08528789132833481,
-0.16769933700561523,
0.3737053871154785,
-0.27916911244392395,
0.6489299535751343,
-0.4632910490036011,
-0.316466748714447,
-0.04119360074400902,
0.3334363102912903,
-0.006667444482445717,
0.4699194133281708,
0.6645186543464661,
0.29450854659080505,
0.7015761137008667,
0.06868746131658554,
1.037707805633545,
-0.01911795139312744,
0.07048915326595306,
1.3370996713638306,
-0.2472178339958191,
0.832029402256012,
0.6246628165245056,
0.16571474075317383,
0.22178922593593597,
0.5252368450164795,
0.1057586520910263,
0.755376935005188,
0.0522770993411541,
0.05181615427136421,
-0.2696288228034973,
-0.10090195387601852,
-0.0314471572637558,
0.322354793548584,
0.4251648485660553,
-0.31527233123779297,
-0.23396918177604675,
-0.07334107160568237,
0.1159721091389656,
0.40453723073005676,
-0.39423754811286926,
0.7464869618415833,
-0.11016660928726196,
-0.4799181818962097,
0.4032652974128723,
-0.2252091020345688,
0.3311842083930969,
-0.42651548981666565,
-0.15160727500915527,
-0.0008834682521410286,
0.14407357573509216,
-0.35633736848831177,
-0.971479058265686,
0.6667518019676208,
-0.09589505195617676,
-0.22616134583950043,
-0.303598016500473,
0.5496883392333984,
-0.45640531182289124,
-0.2035183161497116,
0.11080782115459442,
0.01451394148170948,
-0.04321347177028656,
-0.042569659650325775,
-0.47962507605552673,
0.06336978077888489,
-0.0767328068614006,
-0.18624332547187805,
0.5715183615684509,
0.1462268978357315,
-0.47100937366485596,
0.7524089217185974,
0.712612509727478,
-0.01715082675218582,
-0.0014761743368580937,
-0.022384807467460632,
1.1136698722839355,
-0.5240170955657959,
-0.700384795665741,
-0.7539182901382446,
0.5483365654945374,
-0.0715315043926239,
-0.08742310851812363,
0.6928662657737732,
0.4990561008453369,
1.075585126876831,
-0.34050852060317993,
0.4959096610546112,
0.20663277804851532,
0.5883640646934509,
-0.6814472675323486,
1.0915111303329468,
-0.4473806619644165,
0.2609916627407074,
-0.35739994049072266,
-0.3207058608531952,
-0.30066314339637756,
0.10634554177522659,
-0.2483660727739334,
-0.08728137612342834,
0.199216827750206,
1.199297547340393,
-0.36346346139907837,
-0.13679572939872742,
0.3608577251434326,
0.353657603263855,
0.31774404644966125,
0.5923706293106079,
0.4182263910770416,
-0.22686605155467987,
0.43904638290405273,
-0.321858286857605,
-0.274139940738678,
-0.31125229597091675,
-0.9421219229698181,
-1.0156970024108887,
-0.6223956346511841,
-0.2696106433868408,
-0.28646790981292725,
0.30945050716400146,
0.5682663917541504,
0.8985598087310791,
-1.0748578310012817,
0.0849999487400055,
-0.00009801550913834944,
0.051844287663698196,
-0.42761197686195374,
-0.20598861575126648,
0.22638516128063202,
-0.3011460304260254,
-0.5766318440437317,
0.38673871755599976,
0.09962911903858185,
0.1660921424627304,
-0.03841240704059601,
0.24613358080387115,
0.20430493354797363,
0.14500004053115845,
0.14428919553756714,
0.4425235092639923,
-0.5493946671485901,
-0.6401740908622742,
-0.15144310891628265,
-0.37167954444885254,
-0.24425680935382843,
0.8620133399963379,
-0.5105258226394653,
0.4758080840110779,
0.4715813398361206,
0.7062116265296936,
0.15297941863536835,
0.06581884622573853,
0.7055396437644958,
-1.121209979057312,
0.058677200227975845,
0.2395756095647812,
0.2360178828239441,
0.28734904527664185,
-1.1285780668258667,
0.37988007068634033,
-0.18645276129245758,
-0.42957261204719543,
-0.9511767625808716,
0.431809663772583,
-0.9983783960342407,
-0.17915283143520355,
0.819297730922699,
-0.09681009501218796,
-0.021337728947401047,
-0.22411878407001495,
-0.27734968066215515,
0.110069639980793,
-0.402249276638031,
1.1673026084899902,
0.4376267194747925,
-0.11113724857568741,
0.07400272786617279,
-0.7640990018844604,
0.906521201133728,
0.242355614900589,
-1.0063215494155884,
0.5016177892684937,
0.35713258385658264,
0.5999780893325806,
-0.26690977811813354,
0.07770548015832901,
-0.1623164564371109,
0.40316760540008545,
-0.29799145460128784,
-0.3575080335140228,
-0.18614454567432404,
-0.5787054300308228,
-0.2590702474117279,
0.16870057582855225,
-0.1331014633178711,
-0.2681639492511749
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09454v1
|
Advancing High Resolution Vision-Language Models in Biomedicine
| 2024-06-12T18:29:26 | 2024-06-12T18:29:26 |
Zekai Chen, Arda Pekis, Kevin Brown
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, q-bio.QM
|
Multi-modal learning has significantly advanced generative AI, especially in
vision-language modeling. Innovations like GPT-4V and open-source projects such
as LLaVA have enabled robust conversational agents capable of zero-shot task
completions. However, applying these technologies in the biomedical field
presents unique challenges. Recent initiatives like LLaVA-Med have started to
adapt instruction-tuning for biomedical contexts using large datasets such as
PMC-15M. Our research offers three key contributions: (i) we present a new
instruct dataset enriched with medical image-text pairs from Claude3-Opus and
LLaMA3 70B, (ii) we propose a novel image encoding strategy using hierarchical
representations to improve fine-grained biomedical visual comprehension, and
(iii) we develop the Llama3-Med model, which achieves state-of-the-art
zero-shot performance on biomedical visual question answering benchmarks, with
an average performance improvement of over 10% compared to previous methods.
These advancements provide more accurate and reliable tools for medical
professionals, bridging gaps in current multi-modal conversational assistants
and promoting further innovations in medical AI.
|
[
-0.0004516441549640149,
-0.8046939373016357,
0.905502200126648,
-0.2090880125761032,
-0.11418326199054718,
0.13431847095489502,
-0.03868454322218895,
-0.7141788601875305,
0.059272099286317825,
0.3603799641132355,
-0.3596056401729584,
-0.6124358773231506,
-0.60447096824646,
0.30101194977760315,
0.020746823400259018,
0.7660635709762573,
-0.04010025039315224,
0.6670230031013489,
-0.5332651138305664,
-0.34638845920562744,
-0.34868553280830383,
-0.3255450129508972,
-0.44729843735694885,
-0.3716318905353546,
0.722724437713623,
0.30937889218330383,
0.5625030398368835,
0.7865830659866333,
0.7514541745185852,
0.30722445249557495,
0.10077869147062302,
0.26923835277557373,
-0.1886340081691742,
0.10758617520332336,
0.02429720014333725,
-0.4558718204498291,
-0.6910879015922546,
-0.17551997303962708,
0.6507992148399353,
0.8365063667297363,
-0.11010400205850601,
-0.10747899115085602,
-0.11864769458770752,
0.5519479513168335,
-0.5168596506118774,
0.37963584065437317,
-0.5046332478523254,
0.06304223835468292,
-0.043385110795497894,
-0.40560099482536316,
-0.41244399547576904,
0.18526078760623932,
0.038441162556409836,
-0.7551919221878052,
0.12618575990200043,
-0.20369459688663483,
0.8504400253295898,
0.38484013080596924,
-0.42331036925315857,
0.011742593720555305,
-0.3306621313095093,
0.6080331802368164,
-0.5784730315208435,
0.3255169987678528,
0.3822541832923889,
0.23661786317825317,
-0.09256242960691452,
-0.6831316351890564,
-0.22546663880348206,
-0.16968609392642975,
0.2865278720855713,
0.43343386054039,
-0.19227391481399536,
0.5020930171012878,
-0.05158328264951706,
0.298506498336792,
-0.48204830288887024,
0.3170042932033539,
-0.6352785229682922,
-0.018365856260061264,
0.2227182388305664,
0.3041702210903168,
0.1846494823694229,
-0.07490094751119614,
-0.277246356010437,
-0.0047064791433513165,
-0.6132115125656128,
-0.2840746343135834,
-0.3957619369029999,
-0.13764315843582153,
-0.3210188150405884,
0.7080333828926086,
-0.23749378323554993,
0.9357701539993286,
-0.058719150722026825,
-0.30413129925727844,
0.49823397397994995,
-0.6785773634910583,
-0.4301036298274994,
-0.2338947206735611,
0.7125332951545715,
0.29072636365890503,
0.004875045269727707,
0.03810795769095421,
0.22121486067771912,
0.045844923704862595,
0.352748841047287,
-0.7522352337837219,
-0.06513221561908722,
0.29556193947792053,
-0.6059839129447937,
-0.3990614116191864,
-0.3281543552875519,
-0.7211276888847351,
-0.5212828516960144,
-0.3042134940624237,
0.5482655167579651,
-0.5921499729156494,
0.1647789180278778,
0.44748109579086304,
0.18799258768558502,
0.36067673563957214,
0.6794450879096985,
-0.7430793046951294,
-0.16037404537200928,
0.31536561250686646,
0.7270431518554688,
0.05747437849640846,
-0.33187630772590637,
-0.4151986837387085,
0.36045345664024353,
-0.39852383732795715,
0.8034207820892334,
-0.5813490152359009,
-0.31870946288108826,
-0.16798780858516693,
0.06828828901052475,
-0.18085190653800964,
-0.5893675684928894,
0.12997278571128845,
-0.14664341509342194,
0.18734094500541687,
-0.05101197957992554,
-0.18388821184635162,
-0.19468340277671814,
0.3563387095928192,
-0.3499331474304199,
0.5207635164260864,
0.1063191369175911,
-0.4520992338657379,
0.14517557621002197,
-0.8136221766471863,
-0.2997296154499054,
0.2706734836101532,
-0.4916153848171234,
-0.4874991476535797,
0.20057211816310883,
0.5353070497512817,
0.6467846035957336,
-0.5437270402908325,
0.35685232281684875,
-0.2893720865249634,
-0.21464276313781738,
0.41066887974739075,
-0.649743378162384,
0.6387264728546143,
-0.021288331598043442,
-0.07977422326803207,
0.30549943447113037,
-0.8210565447807312,
-0.2688513398170471,
0.1327996402978897,
-0.31524941325187683,
-0.035293836146593094,
-0.12867358326911926,
-0.18445563316345215,
0.049105770885944366,
0.15018422901630402,
-0.7211344838142395,
0.2321966290473938,
-0.4954811930656433,
0.5308858752250671,
0.6609699726104736,
0.11774718761444092,
0.24851162731647491,
-0.4449736475944519,
0.49017953872680664,
0.3100665509700775,
0.4833236038684845,
-0.47064581513404846,
-0.8062750697135925,
-0.6123634576797485,
-0.6023500561714172,
0.15879333019256592,
0.7274802923202515,
-1.0272942781448364,
-0.1955263912677765,
-0.08795730024576187,
-0.31313806772232056,
-0.8501534461975098,
0.014205124229192734,
0.4932900369167328,
0.7975872755050659,
0.6863237023353577,
-0.3578126132488251,
-0.262723445892334,
-1.0571757555007935,
0.2964770197868347,
-0.33630064129829407,
-0.12385521084070206,
0.7196009159088135,
0.38401558995246887,
-0.6223214864730835,
0.3438762426376343,
-0.407521516084671,
-0.24268053472042084,
-0.09340381622314453,
0.13670067489147186,
0.148147851228714,
0.449655145406723,
0.548890233039856,
-0.6075727939605713,
-0.11577907204627991,
0.2364884465932846,
-1.0900812149047852,
0.006356334779411554,
-0.18725387752056122,
0.0030224882066249847,
0.05638715624809265,
0.38076406717300415,
-0.4501281678676605,
0.37915921211242676,
0.64239501953125,
-0.13379792869091034,
0.30563342571258545,
-0.5516923666000366,
0.5420522689819336,
-1.375864863395691,
-0.061187513172626495,
0.09283959120512009,
-0.19886969029903412,
-0.6992996335029602,
0.06302761286497116,
0.0922507494688034,
-0.16619470715522766,
-0.6059723496437073,
0.3299330770969391,
-0.38590478897094727,
0.12395307421684265,
-0.05719522759318352,
-0.29758352041244507,
0.047748666256666183,
0.3680337965488434,
-0.04758339002728462,
0.7957242727279663,
0.8920191526412964,
-0.3422556221485138,
0.22171589732170105,
0.4146919250488281,
-0.18346329033374786,
0.6809139847755432,
-0.7215680480003357,
-0.039879992604255676,
-0.4209759533405304,
0.20958547294139862,
-0.614010751247406,
-0.7066165804862976,
0.29657188057899475,
-0.4787488579750061,
0.33609142899513245,
0.015095512382686138,
-0.3890378475189209,
-0.21779543161392212,
-0.21609941124916077,
0.7359312772750854,
0.4022796154022217,
-0.20352789759635925,
0.5346978902816772,
0.31736505031585693,
-0.11258742958307266,
-0.4965980052947998,
-0.9328511357307434,
0.2727913558483124,
0.08859112113714218,
-0.441063791513443,
0.379695862531662,
-0.1214088723063469,
-0.048286233097314835,
-0.22455577552318573,
0.1615622341632843,
-0.20890161395072937,
-0.1322203278541565,
0.2785525619983673,
0.6008018255233765,
-0.28687307238578796,
0.20622088015079498,
0.09893804043531418,
0.01527794823050499,
-0.17099739611148834,
-0.10660392045974731,
0.23297119140625,
-0.16130925714969635,
-0.5877618789672852,
-0.6787557005882263,
0.47231343388557434,
0.8601009845733643,
-0.32262176275253296,
0.6437656879425049,
0.63343346118927,
-0.2645702064037323,
0.4353412389755249,
-0.4876604974269867,
-0.22965815663337708,
-0.42219823598861694,
0.6154794096946716,
-0.12945233285427094,
-0.972631573677063,
0.1508243978023529,
-0.09221309423446655,
-0.2520594894886017,
0.17779400944709778,
0.8527474403381348,
-0.4160902202129364,
0.8789222836494446,
0.5931239128112793,
0.2642497420310974,
0.3836216926574707,
-0.18191596865653992,
-0.09636913985013962,
-0.8126704096794128,
-0.507191002368927,
-0.1227203980088234,
-0.10684976726770401,
-0.4022463262081146,
-0.9180497527122498,
1.077206015586853,
-0.22158943116664886,
-0.07874011248350143,
0.007521049585193396,
-0.46582305431365967,
0.3131706714630127,
0.46231982111930847,
0.6369208693504333,
0.15845312178134918,
0.0766194760799408,
-0.15792185068130493,
0.1889742910861969,
-0.7982587218284607,
-0.09559661149978638,
1.207278847694397,
0.390824556350708,
0.7768411636352539,
-0.07229656726121902,
0.5701510906219482,
0.06367720663547516,
0.1602822095155716,
-0.8032773733139038,
0.430652916431427,
-0.17286501824855804,
-0.5453201532363892,
-0.0007974590407684445,
-0.18302741646766663,
-1.0422528982162476,
0.06794315576553345,
-0.4192201495170593,
-0.556260347366333,
0.38091418147087097,
0.31525495648384094,
-0.5401739478111267,
0.3070236146450043,
-0.5012633800506592,
0.8891708254814148,
-0.18480615317821503,
-0.5110796093940735,
-0.2661941647529602,
-0.8683491349220276,
0.20029978454113007,
-0.0030522176530212164,
0.12023443728685379,
-0.05833948776125908,
-0.22732318937778473,
0.1765443980693817,
0.050896041095256805,
1.2380385398864746,
0.06088559329509735,
-0.15941321849822998,
0.03727884590625763,
-0.15513037145137787,
-0.002930659567937255,
0.0638752356171608,
0.15093453228473663,
0.4600863456726074,
0.17078307271003723,
-0.601779043674469,
-0.22163470089435577,
0.48900744318962097,
-0.6843454837799072,
-0.33586665987968445,
-0.3267698884010315,
-0.8107854723930359,
-0.330831378698349,
-0.06080236658453941,
0.2470037043094635,
0.7001378536224365,
0.009746943600475788,
0.451608806848526,
0.7755604982376099,
-0.6356025338172913,
0.2568175494670868,
0.35116294026374817,
0.16675223410129547,
-0.593177080154419,
0.792518138885498,
-0.22233238816261292,
0.3261846899986267,
0.6608842611312866,
0.0028103722725063562,
0.12425992637872696,
-0.6986582279205322,
-0.7279846668243408,
0.38245439529418945,
-0.5795272588729858,
-0.5650641322135925,
-0.6282622218132019,
-0.2292686551809311,
-0.3184877932071686,
-0.23898723721504211,
-0.2744012475013733,
-0.016432400792837143,
-0.5837545990943909,
0.18573015928268433,
0.35622289776802063,
0.6452150940895081,
-0.14927387237548828,
0.13245299458503723,
-0.9975804686546326,
0.625866711139679,
0.27106016874313354,
0.2687455415725708,
-0.343349426984787,
-0.30156198143959045,
-0.34913283586502075,
-0.06534135341644287,
-0.22735093533992767,
-1.070605754852295,
0.15513953566551208,
0.3857221007347107,
0.3892439305782318,
0.28657934069633484,
-0.5269396305084229,
0.6544405817985535,
-0.6216448545455933,
0.7918907403945923,
0.3336388170719147,
-0.48170334100723267,
0.7454360723495483,
-0.46883153915405273,
0.42834508419036865,
0.4586459696292877,
0.17174646258354187,
-0.3069840967655182,
-0.19418226182460785,
-0.2799493074417114,
-0.5671572685241699,
0.4315883219242096,
-0.008897298946976662,
-0.059550873935222626,
-0.051640503108501434,
0.4991517663002014,
0.20726017653942108,
0.09506301581859589,
-0.5338886976242065,
-0.043691541999578476,
-0.12656226754188538,
-0.5187852382659912,
-0.03861929103732109,
-0.1326942890882492,
-0.22669540345668793,
-0.4867832362651825,
0.31472617387771606,
-0.48054614663124084,
0.6608585715293884,
0.369869202375412,
0.002399980090558529,
0.09752947092056274,
0.33912479877471924,
0.6386884450912476,
0.4981832206249237,
0.06273424625396729,
-0.042730819433927536,
0.12569773197174072,
-0.5800849795341492,
0.19456373155117035,
0.1788250207901001,
-0.09014467149972916,
-0.37447574734687805,
0.5349124670028687,
0.8558835387229919,
0.1093401312828064,
-0.9005038738250732,
0.5407922863960266,
0.21501043438911438,
-0.4458933174610138,
0.05298399552702904,
-0.021789338439702988,
-0.1325194090604782,
0.44989848136901855,
0.05877774953842163,
0.36901798844337463,
0.33922865986824036,
-0.4223616421222687,
0.16226302087306976,
0.3555774390697479,
-0.5878108143806458,
-0.3034769892692566,
0.8555514216423035,
0.10592932254076004,
0.2728428244590759,
0.3512549102306366,
0.3387453556060791,
0.08865826576948166,
0.47912919521331787,
0.5528740882873535,
0.5051268339157104,
-0.14200375974178314,
0.3922150135040283,
0.17709550261497498,
0.044354841113090515,
0.0902024507522583,
0.4663175344467163,
-0.20945005118846893,
-0.7127736210823059,
-0.7765781283378601,
-0.5801403522491455,
-0.39174798130989075,
0.1265166997909546,
-0.4939725697040558,
0.019250351935625076,
-0.27266666293144226,
-0.0929439514875412,
0.2835581302642822,
-0.486860990524292,
-0.5308706164360046,
0.07329105585813522,
0.23479063808918,
0.5315374135971069,
-0.6854413747787476,
1.0736278295516968,
0.8181918859481812,
-0.5056197047233582,
-0.3251696228981018,
-0.21631480753421783,
0.15774402022361755,
-1.0905520915985107,
0.4379500150680542,
-0.058847494423389435,
-0.10400918871164322,
-0.07954565435647964,
-0.7091270089149475,
-0.49497389793395996,
1.1236979961395264,
0.4809097647666931,
-0.4488307535648346,
-0.1441889852285385,
0.09713626652956009,
0.6008527874946594,
-0.2422751784324646,
0.049489881843328476,
0.30730175971984863,
0.19784504175186157,
0.10951072722673416,
-0.9694252610206604,
-0.28112784028053284,
-0.2757364511489868,
-0.0788511261343956,
-0.04639585316181183,
-0.5300143361091614,
0.6964753866195679,
-0.38089266419410706,
0.1795954406261444,
0.3810429275035858,
0.3234211802482605,
0.3186352550983429,
0.4004545509815216,
0.00985200796276331,
0.4782488942146301,
0.46075543761253357,
-0.06857606768608093,
1.201693058013916,
-0.2503746449947357,
-0.05481483414769173,
0.6513993144035339,
-0.14049915969371796,
0.6526023149490356,
0.5132006406784058,
-0.09004035592079163,
0.3227279782295227,
0.5404671430587769,
-0.17532579600811005,
0.2702692151069641,
-0.19573813676834106,
-0.5581461191177368,
-0.31082117557525635,
-0.3745265603065491,
-0.38062161207199097,
0.7211801409721375,
0.5872995853424072,
-0.5407280325889587,
0.008371599018573761,
0.5029591917991638,
-0.18851295113563538,
-0.025996211916208267,
-0.33872419595718384,
0.9246293902397156,
-0.010258903726935387,
-0.2236650437116623,
0.5990555286407471,
-0.16677305102348328,
0.4815059304237366,
-0.41797491908073425,
-0.34426939487457275,
-0.1720840185880661,
0.17860552668571472,
0.05475408956408501,
-0.6278573274612427,
-0.05209105461835861,
-0.1385016143321991,
-0.1392560601234436,
-0.007237171288579702,
0.4646327793598175,
-0.4841032326221466,
-0.5565424561500549,
0.17613248527050018,
0.7172242999076843,
0.2331680804491043,
0.26195982098579407,
-0.7688742876052856,
0.10014273971319199,
-0.10574905574321747,
0.26540321111679077,
0.31880614161491394,
0.32790884375572205,
0.04428836703300476,
0.5931116938591003,
0.36219438910484314,
0.1531156450510025,
-0.14379972219467163,
0.1882515698671341,
0.8283025026321411,
-0.5345733165740967,
0.16200214624404907,
-0.6709204316139221,
0.3252107799053192,
0.13417670130729675,
-0.15423177182674408,
0.2194591611623764,
0.488051176071167,
0.6003032326698303,
-0.1988489031791687,
0.4763837456703186,
0.1876625418663025,
0.20405375957489014,
-0.6393949389457703,
0.5522059798240662,
-0.7920878529548645,
-0.0013695671223104,
-0.12023335695266724,
-0.41561010479927063,
-0.7977045774459839,
0.42179471254348755,
0.002398597775027156,
0.07712062448263168,
0.6598829030990601,
0.8929727673530579,
-0.16111226379871368,
-0.38489994406700134,
0.6907225847244263,
0.3075658977031708,
0.18164975941181183,
0.787774384021759,
0.5753562450408936,
-0.449552059173584,
0.34644898772239685,
-0.13939358294010162,
-0.443569540977478,
-0.279884397983551,
-0.5506730079650879,
-0.8510141372680664,
-0.5342806577682495,
-0.3266686201095581,
-0.2628817856311798,
0.2806140184402466,
0.8233809471130371,
0.8179808855056763,
-0.6621506214141846,
0.03371068835258484,
-0.05309627577662468,
-0.43204236030578613,
-0.22287005186080933,
-0.05206068232655525,
0.3486272692680359,
-0.36882415413856506,
-0.7086181044578552,
0.7929121851921082,
0.8870866298675537,
0.33842432498931885,
-0.21205182373523712,
-0.033634334802627563,
-0.2962929308414459,
0.016979288309812546,
0.8593679666519165,
0.4029434025287628,
-0.8928618431091309,
-0.03973380848765373,
0.17186295986175537,
-0.20359671115875244,
0.5367907881736755,
0.5738292336463928,
-0.8691068887710571,
0.7327550649642944,
0.2630080282688141,
0.8483747839927673,
0.4200918972492218,
-0.09359613060951233,
0.5380523204803467,
-0.46765026450157166,
0.19258587062358856,
0.31084614992141724,
0.3110520541667938,
0.49624866247177124,
-0.31216004490852356,
0.4497695863246918,
0.3353443443775177,
-0.54522305727005,
-0.4776412546634674,
0.24473069608211517,
-1.192995309829712,
-0.37697193026542664,
0.9866443276405334,
0.08678561449050903,
-0.3643544316291809,
-0.028737738728523254,
-0.420762300491333,
0.28876301646232605,
-0.1714770495891571,
0.6040340065956116,
0.16172955930233002,
-0.5278914570808411,
-0.4620802104473114,
-0.9005429744720459,
0.3155951201915741,
0.4790361225605011,
-1.100062608718872,
-0.3320288062095642,
0.7777936458587646,
0.03363139182329178,
-0.06577084213495255,
0.7708964943885803,
-0.5411959886550903,
0.5409173369407654,
0.007458920124918222,
0.12123995274305344,
-0.22879059612751007,
-0.6067112684249878,
-0.4391466975212097,
0.19511669874191284,
-0.021104060113430023,
-0.4038877785205841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08482v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08482v1
|
Words Worth a Thousand Pictures: Measuring and Understanding Perceptual Variability in Text-to-Image Generation
| 2024-06-12T17:59:27 | 2024-06-12T17:59:27 |
Raphael Tang, Xinyu Zhang, Lixinyu Xu, Yao Lu, Wenyan Li, Pontus Stenetorp, Jimmy Lin, Ferhan Ture
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Diffusion models are the state of the art in text-to-image generation, but
their perceptual variability remains understudied. In this paper, we examine
how prompts affect image variability in black-box diffusion-based models. We
propose W1KP, a human-calibrated measure of variability in a set of images,
bootstrapped from existing image-pair perceptual distances. Current datasets do
not cover recent diffusion models, thus we curate three test sets for
evaluation. Our best perceptual distance outperforms nine baselines by up to 18
points in accuracy, and our calibration matches graded human judgements 78% of
the time. Using W1KP, we study prompt reusability and show that Imagen prompts
can be reused for 10-50 random seeds before new images become too similar to
already generated images, while Stable Diffusion XL and DALL-E 3 can be reused
50-200 times. Lastly, we analyze 56 linguistic features of real prompts,
finding that the prompt's length, CLIP embedding norm, concreteness, and word
senses influence variability most. As far as we are aware, we are the first to
analyze diffusion variability from a visuolinguistic perspective. Our project
page is at http://w1kp.com
|
[
-0.5488026738166809,
-0.636326789855957,
0.7215491533279419,
0.5415998697280884,
-0.4804469048976898,
-0.3904017210006714,
-0.027562016621232033,
-0.3725455403327942,
0.012853001244366169,
0.20067450404167175,
-0.795793890953064,
-0.3350176513195038,
-0.8358922600746155,
0.47812023758888245,
-0.23221327364444733,
0.581139862537384,
-0.05653630942106247,
-0.054703276604413986,
-0.33637019991874695,
-0.3687020540237427,
-0.664733350276947,
0.24627552926540375,
-0.43020108342170715,
0.023642731830477715,
1.0101239681243896,
0.5222083330154419,
0.7575469017028809,
0.37538689374923706,
-0.026132704690098763,
0.25890323519706726,
-0.04781842976808548,
-0.008045014925301075,
-0.30092018842697144,
0.3737694323062897,
-0.17150035500526428,
-0.37480971217155457,
0.24186670780181885,
0.019682161509990692,
0.6866357922554016,
0.7701643705368042,
0.17411832511425018,
0.06697618216276169,
0.22066201269626617,
0.7382692098617554,
-0.5970689654350281,
-0.2596866488456726,
-0.3881189227104187,
0.36014264822006226,
-0.1793496012687683,
-0.10978328436613083,
-0.27150553464889526,
-0.22155128419399261,
0.4449160695075989,
-1.0082664489746094,
0.3859541714191437,
0.07405460625886917,
0.9214115142822266,
0.12412987649440765,
-0.30155616998672485,
-0.4172094464302063,
-0.538149356842041,
0.731618344783783,
-0.624803364276886,
0.17600813508033752,
0.38601037859916687,
0.362050861120224,
-0.13763317465782166,
-0.7884875535964966,
-0.9108968377113342,
-0.21163935959339142,
0.28277313709259033,
0.0678303986787796,
-0.5246770977973938,
-0.20244766771793365,
0.17162224650382996,
0.021636981517076492,
-0.36891821026802063,
0.002495245775207877,
-0.1455206274986267,
-0.24400334060192108,
0.41960346698760986,
0.2726151943206787,
0.24850313365459442,
-0.1086970791220665,
-0.3465960919857025,
-0.4311879575252533,
-0.427639901638031,
0.0691380724310875,
0.7749606966972351,
-0.10312998294830322,
-0.05462513118982315,
0.41889438033103943,
-0.06167638301849365,
0.6708149313926697,
0.32375767827033997,
-0.05345449969172478,
0.1437406688928604,
-0.2079228311777115,
-0.22633759677410126,
-0.27245667576789856,
1.0534063577651978,
0.5396125912666321,
0.31368428468704224,
-0.11342613399028778,
-0.14146685600280762,
-0.20538091659545898,
0.2011900097131729,
-0.9504016637802124,
-0.2042837291955948,
-0.07340504974126816,
-0.3083503544330597,
-0.43162256479263306,
-0.1388329416513443,
-0.875689685344696,
-0.7310696244239807,
-0.022963976487517357,
0.5320139527320862,
-0.5520408749580383,
-0.2004065215587616,
0.2849317491054535,
-0.7400425672531128,
-0.10177925229072571,
0.6181471943855286,
-0.7008225321769714,
-0.1951850801706314,
0.20728683471679688,
0.9007776379585266,
-0.28710243105888367,
-0.6405434012413025,
-0.10368620604276657,
-0.5139155983924866,
-0.7009859085083008,
1.1846917867660522,
-0.49931463599205017,
-0.710655927658081,
0.04423169419169426,
0.16245023906230927,
0.44472724199295044,
-0.5083015561103821,
0.36706119775772095,
-0.27893128991127014,
0.2692418694496155,
-0.7576403021812439,
-0.5539569854736328,
-0.10140110552310944,
0.06111789122223854,
-0.5990045070648193,
0.7101956605911255,
0.2896367013454437,
-0.8236984610557556,
0.7136276364326477,
-0.4331035315990448,
-0.013720480725169182,
0.5468662977218628,
-0.38980886340141296,
-0.16541290283203125,
0.35273656249046326,
-0.11095632612705231,
0.3349909484386444,
-0.09053795784711838,
-0.08456822484731674,
-0.1990574151277542,
-0.210222989320755,
0.4466700851917267,
-1.0144685506820679,
0.4678109884262085,
0.061642713844776154,
-0.23484006524085999,
-0.14341825246810913,
-0.876504123210907,
-0.14064136147499084,
0.2218787670135498,
-0.19225803017616272,
-0.3262731730937958,
-0.09572254121303558,
0.22107137739658356,
0.12989956140518188,
0.026331307366490364,
-0.7600064277648926,
0.08770366758108139,
-0.14557521045207977,
0.06593728810548782,
0.9242732524871826,
0.41625919938087463,
0.47683221101760864,
-0.2700337767601013,
0.8489485383033752,
0.41051602363586426,
-0.03309180215001106,
-0.8914193511009216,
-0.9783262014389038,
-0.34780704975128174,
-0.19682985544204712,
0.1443825364112854,
0.49654170870780945,
-0.7042256593704224,
0.10881756991147995,
-0.011883355677127838,
-0.549259603023529,
-0.49765658378601074,
-0.07086575776338577,
0.12325733155012131,
0.7622284293174744,
0.15906789898872375,
-0.5216166377067566,
0.17742787301540375,
-0.8966383934020996,
-0.3536209762096405,
0.1706773042678833,
-0.3709559738636017,
0.5324696898460388,
0.31554096937179565,
-0.3768649101257324,
0.9876100420951843,
-0.5466302037239075,
0.16113878786563873,
0.3412316143512726,
0.5239431262016296,
-0.10201576352119446,
0.3631395697593689,
0.36566317081451416,
-0.7008110880851746,
-0.5910797119140625,
-0.2502472996711731,
-0.5590254068374634,
-0.16258616745471954,
-0.2870132625102997,
-0.09472527354955673,
0.22467102110385895,
0.19622400403022766,
-0.521020770072937,
0.6895203590393066,
0.4985538721084595,
-0.8321399688720703,
1.0437519550323486,
-0.4363246560096741,
0.44007042050361633,
-1.0141204595565796,
-0.09700250625610352,
0.35286691784858704,
-0.12458602339029312,
-0.24792005121707916,
-0.26956987380981445,
0.0700497254729271,
-0.03710898011922836,
-0.5507997274398804,
0.8394256234169006,
-0.24623136222362518,
0.12582537531852722,
-0.3589373826980591,
0.03989654779434204,
0.3527447283267975,
0.08946609497070312,
-0.20869190990924835,
0.8615767359733582,
0.8245329856872559,
-0.6252362728118896,
0.6635896563529968,
0.14450138807296753,
-0.6534222960472107,
1.2082488536834717,
-0.6456241011619568,
0.12738414108753204,
-0.4066808521747589,
0.20483101904392242,
-1.612524390220642,
-0.22947083413600922,
0.24281714856624603,
-0.4585300385951996,
0.24538400769233704,
0.03038126416504383,
-0.5592666268348694,
-0.10963096469640732,
-0.18537889420986176,
0.6132964491844177,
0.5620602965354919,
-0.5368261337280273,
0.24790166318416595,
-0.17793746292591095,
-0.0686764270067215,
-0.6111046671867371,
-0.7489334940910339,
0.26462748646736145,
-0.14361342787742615,
-0.614909827709198,
0.18385928869247437,
-0.2615215480327606,
-0.0189939234405756,
-0.04199031740427017,
-0.13424430787563324,
0.019799819216132164,
-0.09541065990924835,
0.6588188409805298,
-0.004877548199146986,
-0.17370425164699554,
0.5159386992454529,
-0.005572258494794369,
-0.06445813924074173,
0.019247345626354218,
-0.549782931804657,
0.3241439163684845,
0.3073498010635376,
-0.31539836525917053,
-0.6300540566444397,
0.44429367780685425,
0.42033815383911133,
0.27613258361816406,
0.46034500002861023,
0.6716530323028564,
-0.20735067129135132,
-0.07311113178730011,
-0.46139633655548096,
0.028657039627432823,
-0.5510472059249878,
0.2555234134197235,
-0.39687058329582214,
-0.5369825959205627,
0.4268055260181427,
-0.2547261714935303,
0.06802433729171753,
0.4525313973426819,
0.318942129611969,
-0.5120559334754944,
0.6191472411155701,
0.6840936541557312,
0.39887315034866333,
0.6535237431526184,
0.04193001613020897,
-0.11149502545595169,
-0.5611560940742493,
-0.10803892463445663,
-0.24608847498893738,
-0.5350875854492188,
-0.5184451341629028,
-0.6165719032287598,
0.21418529748916626,
-0.09124407172203064,
-0.0863562598824501,
-0.0940207913517952,
-0.4317348897457123,
0.7363964915275574,
0.3328801393508911,
0.20757785439491272,
0.033177804201841354,
0.28119203448295593,
-0.30516576766967773,
-0.24254010617733002,
-0.4759773015975952,
-0.635235071182251,
0.9967449307441711,
0.18774162232875824,
0.7153019309043884,
-0.310177743434906,
0.40262097120285034,
0.4319820702075958,
0.03915154188871384,
-0.7718525528907776,
0.6399711966514587,
-0.18126706779003143,
0.02324645407497883,
-0.5251575112342834,
-0.24447494745254517,
-1.3860304355621338,
-0.06726861745119095,
-0.32903122901916504,
-0.5750421285629272,
0.33653074502944946,
0.2878742516040802,
-0.3022940754890442,
0.2253604531288147,
-0.6182863116264343,
0.8346832990646362,
0.10899682343006134,
-0.42363178730010986,
-0.04145550727844238,
-0.35271477699279785,
0.015782414004206657,
-0.12973061203956604,
-0.019993644207715988,
-0.08680962771177292,
-0.31660914421081543,
0.6169033050537109,
-0.160006582736969,
0.7063485980033875,
-0.15064071118831635,
-0.3645050525665283,
0.09998536109924316,
0.19733501970767975,
0.3431212306022644,
-0.13817737996578217,
0.05841003358364105,
0.25804781913757324,
-0.008938251994550228,
-0.7068531513214111,
-0.4763219952583313,
0.7993384599685669,
-0.5708736777305603,
-0.36220353841781616,
-0.14968955516815186,
-0.6856362223625183,
-0.09867390990257263,
-0.061462849378585815,
0.9093772768974304,
0.5052387118339539,
-0.3014519214630127,
-0.016285236924886703,
0.8008889555931091,
-0.781463086605072,
0.5758199691772461,
0.28085973858833313,
-0.07049290835857391,
-0.24398685991764069,
0.7304800152778625,
0.29583799839019775,
0.4350030720233917,
0.13449837267398834,
0.4904381036758423,
-0.25767481327056885,
-0.1746412068605423,
-0.7343148589134216,
0.13176843523979187,
-0.8769641518592834,
-0.018359756097197533,
-0.47377514839172363,
0.3921966850757599,
-0.2560437321662903,
-0.42140957713127136,
-0.21620553731918335,
-0.37796255946159363,
-0.6118329167366028,
0.023974081501364708,
0.43391361832618713,
0.8368300795555115,
0.14856074750423431,
0.35457831621170044,
-0.4905020296573639,
0.26296374201774597,
0.6385873556137085,
0.5934766530990601,
0.09889981895685196,
-0.8838464021682739,
-0.04720543324947357,
-0.10965191572904587,
-0.43869155645370483,
-1.2176008224487305,
0.3591931164264679,
-0.0031479657627642155,
0.306750625371933,
0.5789472460746765,
-0.23778115212917328,
0.7444568276405334,
-0.691639244556427,
1.3248344659805298,
0.6302679181098938,
-0.6892502307891846,
0.5726602077484131,
-0.11823484301567078,
0.8834165334701538,
0.29258012771606445,
0.546603262424469,
-0.7134521007537842,
-0.553008496761322,
-0.9147354960441589,
-0.7940998673439026,
0.3157791197299957,
-0.14124222099781036,
0.5203967094421387,
0.03840658441185951,
0.4329529404640198,
0.4397567808628082,
-0.01430484838783741,
-0.3315467834472656,
-0.41533246636390686,
-0.4296491742134094,
-0.13388676941394806,
-0.20068219304084778,
-0.3084326982498169,
0.022062262520194054,
-0.09062084555625916,
0.2596273720264435,
-0.05427994579076767,
0.14024148881435394,
0.3704051077365875,
0.13147303462028503,
-0.3303681015968323,
0.20797674357891083,
0.7983038425445557,
0.5453122854232788,
0.21771901845932007,
0.16707012057304382,
0.12014465779066086,
-0.7283071279525757,
0.16214792430400848,
-0.2805304527282715,
-0.14854861795902252,
0.5371341109275818,
0.3924468159675598,
0.9831988215446472,
0.07001250982284546,
-0.7488512396812439,
0.6380999088287354,
-0.22534126043319702,
-0.415564626455307,
-0.04540220648050308,
0.04567675292491913,
0.06172177568078041,
0.22969402372837067,
0.5375778675079346,
0.36381828784942627,
0.03200066089630127,
-0.25551608204841614,
0.13150280714035034,
0.37851762771606445,
-0.29999208450317383,
-0.5402994751930237,
0.3709245026111603,
0.05067267268896103,
-0.5770167708396912,
0.40388351678848267,
-0.5612363219261169,
-0.03127176687121391,
0.6465335488319397,
0.44784918427467346,
0.9107051491737366,
-0.22322691977024078,
0.4728458821773529,
0.5317416787147522,
0.1621444672346115,
-0.16308267414569855,
0.13769373297691345,
-0.19828428328037262,
-0.6982248425483704,
0.12368305027484894,
-0.4155283272266388,
-0.3941649794578552,
0.07021693885326385,
-0.38499459624290466,
0.19608841836452484,
-0.3826560378074646,
-0.24347949028015137,
0.33115139603614807,
-0.30669689178466797,
-0.9098264575004578,
0.16269703209400177,
0.2397010773420334,
0.8994830846786499,
-1.0961214303970337,
0.48558294773101807,
0.6027159690856934,
-0.28054994344711304,
-0.6581785678863525,
0.199980691075325,
0.003392645390704274,
-0.575558602809906,
0.6602604985237122,
0.19088777899742126,
0.15839700400829315,
-0.00642845593392849,
-0.9549473524093628,
-0.38600996136665344,
1.165129542350769,
0.3841133713722229,
-0.7161319255828857,
0.26925504207611084,
0.06687963008880615,
0.4765765368938446,
-0.37111422419548035,
0.14685072004795074,
0.2853315472602844,
0.38734695315361023,
0.3193594217300415,
-0.5538520216941833,
-0.0341227687895298,
0.054225288331508636,
0.29787904024124146,
0.05136294290423393,
-0.16284282505512238,
0.7006980776786804,
-0.4723183512687683,
-0.5330390334129333,
0.07914724200963974,
0.3823750615119934,
0.28058016300201416,
0.4826108515262604,
0.7112313508987427,
0.497867226600647,
0.7884554862976074,
0.19637949764728546,
1.0769373178482056,
0.08491954952478409,
0.04691940173506737,
0.8528696894645691,
0.0413023866713047,
0.7535343170166016,
0.7015020847320557,
-0.2631470859050751,
0.6044688820838928,
0.5048391222953796,
-0.16942228376865387,
0.4199961721897125,
0.36194637417793274,
-0.6274543404579163,
0.02652488276362419,
-0.0028816384728997946,
-0.10734368115663528,
-0.07366655766963959,
0.24956834316253662,
-0.4290984869003296,
-0.23775017261505127,
0.42886781692504883,
-0.17581115663051605,
-0.05197402834892273,
-0.07055620104074478,
0.6246832013130188,
-0.0031612261664122343,
-0.7273147702217102,
0.5516849756240845,
-0.2277141809463501,
0.9142784476280212,
-0.6241177916526794,
0.01313078124076128,
-0.42460107803344727,
-0.22064657509326935,
-0.1905527561903,
-1.251212477684021,
0.039181631058454514,
0.10694270581007004,
-0.43178534507751465,
-0.31787991523742676,
0.6111815571784973,
-0.41100043058395386,
-0.6636087894439697,
-0.096377894282341,
0.16680295765399933,
0.3487931191921234,
-0.22228795289993286,
-0.6268527507781982,
-0.08179949969053268,
-0.03222530707716942,
-0.4010807275772095,
0.4681187868118286,
1.1141425371170044,
0.22751259803771973,
0.4681384265422821,
0.4752970337867737,
0.14541462063789368,
0.30647870898246765,
0.10714270174503326,
0.4223181903362274,
-0.5587918162345886,
-0.32294002175331116,
-0.8486247658729553,
0.5349259972572327,
0.2237667292356491,
-0.7095889449119568,
0.621557354927063,
0.22401443123817444,
0.4963926374912262,
-0.48101335763931274,
0.6401691436767578,
0.1959226280450821,
-0.16423240303993225,
-0.11512715369462967,
0.6423242092132568,
-0.5774485468864441,
0.019624078646302223,
-0.2665650546550751,
-0.6020768880844116,
-0.0025257521774619818,
0.4551846385002136,
0.11397244036197662,
-0.3188803791999817,
0.5917120575904846,
1.0285775661468506,
0.06547512114048004,
-0.1426364630460739,
0.7172384858131409,
-0.042316604405641556,
0.19063736498355865,
0.27450743317604065,
0.7401512861251831,
-0.4500569701194763,
0.4678405821323395,
-0.11410056799650192,
-0.3009389042854309,
0.12127102166414261,
-1.161914587020874,
-0.266547292470932,
-1.0241916179656982,
-0.6338021755218506,
-0.3422616422176361,
-0.2969861924648285,
0.534989058971405,
0.7905803322792053,
-0.3465663194656372,
0.0851796418428421,
-0.3429385721683502,
-0.0511712022125721,
-0.15965482592582703,
-0.2583732604980469,
0.10203594714403152,
-0.5323949456214905,
-0.5780067443847656,
-0.005572398658841848,
0.600780189037323,
0.556061863899231,
-0.42946508526802063,
-0.04233706742525101,
0.1552935391664505,
0.39049166440963745,
0.5598675608634949,
0.2637244760990143,
-0.7878943681716919,
-0.10306291282176971,
-0.06482436507940292,
-0.24875283241271973,
0.114996537566185,
0.5041826367378235,
-0.7341841459274292,
0.8544080853462219,
0.625028133392334,
0.5019222497940063,
0.28616130352020264,
-0.10527513921260834,
0.41717463731765747,
-1.0270392894744873,
0.23925752937793732,
0.08364333212375641,
0.14293870329856873,
0.43478935956954956,
-0.3829842507839203,
-0.02251140959560871,
0.6664743423461914,
-0.5120922327041626,
-0.571671724319458,
0.37127095460891724,
-1.0656427145004272,
-0.37566226720809937,
1.4035851955413818,
-0.33360692858695984,
-0.03146868571639061,
0.09935867041349411,
-0.4222949743270874,
-0.13664507865905762,
-0.30823978781700134,
0.7373461127281189,
1.1426020860671997,
0.07871577888727188,
-0.45205143094062805,
-0.5419365167617798,
0.40934401750564575,
0.28070807456970215,
-0.666999340057373,
-0.055510569363832474,
0.6166731119155884,
0.6086944341659546,
0.35306769609451294,
0.6961162090301514,
0.16069434583187103,
0.3679248094558716,
0.34909963607788086,
-0.009347180835902691,
0.10953240841627121,
-0.02204435132443905,
-0.6134865880012512,
0.08287534862756729,
-0.0066904593259096146,
-0.48513248562812805
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08478v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08478v2
|
What If We Recaption Billions of Web Images with LLaMA-3?
| 2024-06-12T17:59:07 | 2024-06-18T11:47:26 |
Xianhang Li, Haoqin Tu, Mude Hui, Zeyu Wang, Bingchen Zhao, Junfei Xiao, Sucheng Ren, Jieru Mei, Qing Liu, Huangjie Zheng, Yuyin Zhou, Cihang Xie
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Web-crawled image-text pairs are inherently noisy. Prior studies demonstrate
that semantically aligning and enriching textual descriptions of these pairs
can significantly enhance model training across various vision-language tasks,
particularly text-to-image generation. However, large-scale investigations in
this area remain predominantly closed-source. Our paper aims to bridge this
community effort, leveraging the powerful and \textit{open-sourced} LLaMA-3, a
GPT-4 level LLM. Our recaptioning pipeline is simple: first, we fine-tune a
LLaMA-3-8B powered LLaVA-1.5 and then employ it to recaption 1.3 billion images
from the DataComp-1B dataset. Our empirical results confirm that this enhanced
dataset, Recap-DataComp-1B, offers substantial benefits in training advanced
vision-language models. For discriminative models like CLIP, we observe
enhanced zero-shot performance in cross-modal retrieval tasks. For generative
models like text-to-image Diffusion Transformers, the generated images exhibit
a significant improvement in alignment with users' text instructions,
especially in following complex queries. Our project page is
https://www.haqtu.me/Recap-Datacomp-1B/
|
[
-0.3472024202346802,
-0.3760111927986145,
0.5044389963150024,
0.17855434119701385,
-0.585181713104248,
-0.02774856425821781,
-0.061146438121795654,
-0.7986965775489807,
0.16597455739974976,
0.49500972032546997,
-0.2666065990924835,
-0.48218390345573425,
-0.6084540486335754,
0.2378360629081726,
-0.8351259231567383,
0.9066636562347412,
-0.06428708881139755,
-0.2610134184360504,
-0.1965295374393463,
0.07930607348680496,
-0.2207881659269333,
-0.13575699925422668,
-0.6321959495544434,
-0.07212381064891815,
0.6836523413658142,
0.24902033805847168,
0.7038810849189758,
0.6932453513145447,
0.8040879368782043,
0.19673922657966614,
0.19585664570331573,
0.23811709880828857,
-0.7007280588150024,
0.20644313097000122,
-0.154242604970932,
-0.49859684705734253,
-0.3561800420284271,
0.10346606373786926,
0.5556431412696838,
0.40353208780288696,
-0.3733419179916382,
0.28121697902679443,
0.08714659512042999,
0.825516402721405,
-0.8134361505508423,
0.04049566015601158,
-1.0529948472976685,
0.015502091497182846,
-0.34497809410095215,
-0.2673373520374298,
-0.30880117416381836,
-0.2853531539440155,
0.2578224837779999,
-0.9903298616409302,
0.4258602261543274,
-0.0372420996427536,
1.1864924430847168,
0.6221427321434021,
-0.03846149146556854,
0.029944734647870064,
-0.4041949212551117,
0.7948787808418274,
-0.5474830269813538,
0.30793532729148865,
0.45418456196784973,
0.4078880846500397,
0.021205060184001923,
-1.0049763917922974,
-0.8093575239181519,
0.38287433981895447,
0.056463126093149185,
0.3038081228733063,
-0.5915088653564453,
-0.16396529972553253,
0.061688050627708435,
0.5180143117904663,
-0.3901636302471161,
0.1917540580034256,
-0.5004644393920898,
0.1419234424829483,
0.5064505338668823,
0.07065427303314209,
0.19216127693653107,
0.07520657777786255,
-0.39796188473701477,
-0.19664078950881958,
-0.7202566266059875,
-0.5070917010307312,
0.36255955696105957,
0.012691148556768894,
-0.01691744662821293,
0.606168806552887,
-0.25211450457572937,
0.8314690589904785,
0.12828682363033295,
-0.18529599905014038,
0.3017234802246094,
-0.3906402289867401,
-0.21506528556346893,
-0.28180381655693054,
0.7501015663146973,
0.8380497097969055,
0.4052278995513916,
-0.348371297121048,
-0.09469829499721527,
0.16633892059326172,
0.5390774011611938,
-0.8883808851242065,
-0.26097536087036133,
0.13911043107509613,
-0.42077359557151794,
-0.49746307730674744,
-0.1507703959941864,
-1.0161385536193848,
-0.2829214632511139,
-0.17065133154392242,
0.3289644718170166,
-0.08086944371461868,
-0.3002226650714874,
0.39595574140548706,
-0.23812103271484375,
0.5137908458709717,
0.5705812573432922,
-1.0230807065963745,
0.37291401624679565,
0.5580776333808899,
0.966280996799469,
-0.5427400469779968,
-0.26101046800613403,
-0.2592333257198334,
0.32554247975349426,
-0.3520401120185852,
1.007806658744812,
-0.4948282241821289,
-0.1344904899597168,
0.103763148188591,
0.08058089017868042,
0.27630823850631714,
-0.6836488842964172,
0.1749573051929474,
-0.5664204955101013,
0.16886179149150848,
0.06956709176301956,
-0.24824494123458862,
-0.36309152841567993,
0.3447093069553375,
-0.9536226987838745,
1.0732015371322632,
-0.043959520757198334,
-0.7743681073188782,
0.27960240840911865,
-0.40668052434921265,
-0.3246047794818878,
-0.08812777698040009,
-0.1577867716550827,
-0.5835868120193481,
-0.00814190972596407,
0.5861459374427795,
0.5435181856155396,
-0.3799077868461609,
-0.062479399144649506,
-0.19769859313964844,
-0.42502304911613464,
0.21032074093818665,
-0.5490425229072571,
0.5268194675445557,
0.14145758748054504,
-0.2305312603712082,
-0.2900421917438507,
-0.8256367444992065,
-0.1431322693824768,
0.35976794362068176,
-0.32942232489585876,
-0.12440530955791473,
-0.027519244700670242,
-0.04881593957543373,
-0.2840597927570343,
0.33254626393318176,
-0.5346109867095947,
0.2558820843696594,
-0.2978498339653015,
0.2630358338356018,
0.7541660070419312,
-0.11791711300611496,
0.4456704258918762,
-0.39857426285743713,
0.5297753214836121,
-0.051936835050582886,
0.06230688840150833,
-0.5379345417022705,
-0.6037071943283081,
-0.7491516470909119,
-0.45514312386512756,
0.035666972398757935,
0.5387721657752991,
-0.8455284237861633,
-0.15149308741092682,
-0.49022582173347473,
-0.4606010615825653,
-0.6862914562225342,
0.22941267490386963,
0.3104882538318634,
0.5948238372802734,
0.5217427611351013,
-0.5001819133758545,
-0.5884208679199219,
-1.0807024240493774,
0.06446606665849686,
-0.1511639803647995,
-0.30366745591163635,
0.1980307251214981,
0.2971700429916382,
-0.1318013221025467,
0.8342963457107544,
-0.6898260712623596,
-0.42002367973327637,
-0.04931052401661873,
-0.022128479555249214,
0.14208827912807465,
0.26948824524879456,
0.5598402619361877,
-0.7791920304298401,
-0.35090872645378113,
-0.06007462739944458,
-0.8759485483169556,
-0.2351900339126587,
-0.11143051832914352,
-0.2280612289905548,
0.12990815937519073,
0.3238826394081116,
-0.6579443216323853,
0.4870811700820923,
0.6012078523635864,
0.2558559477329254,
0.35457727313041687,
0.1387621909379959,
0.12273605167865753,
-1.187145709991455,
0.22617925703525543,
0.15368208289146423,
-0.3040478825569153,
-0.3254951536655426,
0.2633477449417114,
-0.24679790437221527,
-0.01801677606999874,
-0.5314162969589233,
0.2969369888305664,
-0.4972245991230011,
-0.32876479625701904,
-0.37498682737350464,
0.2851068079471588,
0.20923282206058502,
0.540113091468811,
0.21772851049900055,
0.9551348686218262,
0.555707573890686,
-0.440657377243042,
0.30492547154426575,
0.5073560476303101,
-0.4964665472507477,
0.5323953628540039,
-0.6637868881225586,
0.3379262685775757,
-0.021568836644291878,
0.4648851752281189,
-1.071718692779541,
-0.3907676935195923,
0.268459290266037,
-0.4672328531742096,
0.1648489385843277,
-0.12000282853841782,
-0.5882272124290466,
-0.1810586005449295,
-0.5569570660591125,
0.718953549861908,
0.5403936505317688,
-0.9559782147407532,
0.41126808524131775,
0.4962703287601471,
-0.05916538089513779,
-0.6552926301956177,
-0.8923726677894592,
0.298448771238327,
-0.14976850152015686,
-0.4094109833240509,
0.5776487588882446,
0.27629783749580383,
-0.1066763773560524,
-0.1147828921675682,
0.09702455252408981,
-0.2056874930858612,
0.016446029767394066,
0.2666563391685486,
0.4551277160644531,
0.08265483379364014,
0.020547660067677498,
-0.253666490316391,
-0.08147367835044861,
-0.2063782513141632,
-0.21480607986450195,
0.3523513674736023,
-0.06188880652189255,
-0.31094714999198914,
-0.5797026753425598,
0.20682387053966522,
0.1865261048078537,
-0.017438393086194992,
0.20958741009235382,
0.5393259525299072,
-0.267206072807312,
0.20100566744804382,
-0.6053481101989746,
0.07907728105783463,
-0.5255691409111023,
0.292523056268692,
-0.06044882908463478,
-0.8083689212799072,
0.1011069044470787,
-0.04296156018972397,
0.35253557562828064,
0.24870942533016205,
0.5390552282333374,
-0.4208851158618927,
0.7132923603057861,
0.6924645900726318,
-0.0445835217833519,
0.5590660572052002,
-0.3376235067844391,
-0.0281238816678524,
-0.9332685470581055,
-0.20452938973903656,
-0.13177838921546936,
-0.5734665393829346,
-0.43710920214653015,
-0.6214119791984558,
0.22664692997932434,
-0.07574319839477539,
0.0029026013799011707,
0.3577468991279602,
-0.7170132398605347,
0.6688901782035828,
0.4875831604003906,
0.40441760420799255,
0.4132311940193176,
0.5965330004692078,
0.45263686776161194,
-0.09933178126811981,
-0.4327760636806488,
-0.5180887579917908,
1.2356036901474,
0.24628841876983643,
1.075689673423767,
0.13899539411067963,
0.6052013039588928,
0.13818871974945068,
0.20673872530460358,
-0.8294922113418579,
0.6963560581207275,
-0.30032309889793396,
-0.3225710988044739,
0.0322641022503376,
-0.03806450963020325,
-1.252129077911377,
0.17739543318748474,
-0.21250391006469727,
-0.610266923904419,
0.10784158855676651,
0.28260406851768494,
-0.15755155682563782,
0.4323005676269531,
-0.5374377965927124,
0.36776652932167053,
-0.0369989313185215,
-0.43156999349594116,
-0.26513659954071045,
-0.6039409041404724,
0.35588228702545166,
-0.13843251764774323,
-0.05513172969222069,
0.010673917829990387,
-0.49480798840522766,
0.5550756454467773,
-0.09667806327342987,
1.1521106958389282,
0.18781374394893646,
-0.4435437321662903,
0.41086670756340027,
0.12150780111551285,
0.2993842363357544,
-0.4568018913269043,
0.2237997055053711,
0.5855129361152649,
-0.23390382528305054,
-0.3987169563770294,
-0.6363922357559204,
0.42291349172592163,
-0.6682882905006409,
-0.7577013373374939,
-0.169250026345253,
-0.43553054332733154,
0.030496785417199135,
-0.051678020507097244,
0.21686802804470062,
0.35151776671409607,
0.09361283481121063,
0.10756278783082962,
0.4781090021133423,
-0.24895654618740082,
0.37186479568481445,
0.43810638785362244,
-0.4768761396408081,
-0.6687978506088257,
1.0809417963027954,
-0.2250736951828003,
0.3359578251838684,
0.491683691740036,
-0.3051702082157135,
-0.017886532470583916,
-0.6261472702026367,
-0.4429897367954254,
0.19915279746055603,
-0.7752237915992737,
-0.6276326775550842,
-0.4906759262084961,
-0.1320410519838333,
-0.07687140256166458,
-0.295304536819458,
-0.33426550030708313,
-0.7199304103851318,
-0.5784595608711243,
-0.1986052393913269,
0.4494357407093048,
0.7868375182151794,
-0.17839938402175903,
0.4833068251609802,
-0.5535884499549866,
0.6250706911087036,
0.33364537358283997,
0.26154500246047974,
0.16437463462352753,
-0.46161770820617676,
-0.1177339255809784,
-0.1310724914073944,
-0.5361613035202026,
-0.7047471404075623,
0.3014228343963623,
0.36645278334617615,
0.3311827778816223,
0.3145659863948822,
-0.41592472791671753,
0.9184496402740479,
-0.6127675771713257,
1.0760798454284668,
0.373325377702713,
-0.5005186796188354,
0.5953032374382019,
-0.291048139333725,
0.3320405185222626,
0.41698309779167175,
0.2942653000354767,
-0.1527947038412094,
-0.5571215152740479,
-0.3649422228336334,
-0.9963002800941467,
0.4050241708755493,
0.39633992314338684,
0.16455353796482086,
-0.214895099401474,
0.5542811751365662,
0.22223761677742004,
0.09303069859743118,
-0.7847439646720886,
0.01287877932190895,
-0.4563267230987549,
-0.46109944581985474,
0.4034600555896759,
-0.19700486958026886,
-0.11789411306381226,
-0.15920859575271606,
0.43900665640830994,
-0.26077383756637573,
0.31063365936279297,
0.26562756299972534,
-0.172099307179451,
-0.12549540400505066,
-0.10250674933195114,
0.31007951498031616,
0.37582927942276,
-0.011225945316255093,
0.34539464116096497,
0.026235276833176613,
-0.7951897978782654,
0.10862699151039124,
0.08758562058210373,
-0.24595318734645844,
-0.15888811647891998,
0.5871998071670532,
0.5864711999893188,
0.20611803233623505,
-0.7070224285125732,
0.5635433197021484,
0.005658094305545092,
-0.2757735252380371,
-0.11178083717823029,
-0.033747490495443344,
-0.22757624089717865,
0.35971975326538086,
0.5575340390205383,
0.042928602546453476,
0.2764333188533783,
-0.30932074785232544,
0.2736762464046478,
0.40453100204467773,
-0.09395639598369598,
-0.36128899455070496,
0.7027830481529236,
0.3247126638889313,
0.009095240384340286,
0.6534348130226135,
0.16155637800693512,
-0.4374036490917206,
0.5359227061271667,
0.6725479960441589,
0.7764525413513184,
0.28562790155410767,
0.10244371742010117,
0.5665605664253235,
0.2565203607082367,
-0.1989504098892212,
0.0878397524356842,
-0.20938590168952942,
-0.7587736248970032,
-0.44965192675590515,
-0.6731320023536682,
-0.3809780776500702,
-0.0597754567861557,
-0.6816762089729309,
0.20803023874759674,
-0.3016931116580963,
-0.13602867722511292,
-0.12495991587638855,
-0.318610817193985,
-0.6578779816627502,
0.06773468106985092,
0.3640919029712677,
0.8584713339805603,
-0.44786715507507324,
0.6651928424835205,
0.3978613018989563,
-0.6096705198287964,
-0.4405978322029114,
0.13116368651390076,
-0.13399337232112885,
-1.294374942779541,
0.691300094127655,
0.4232460558414459,
-0.3171387314796448,
0.24661785364151,
-1.0497206449508667,
-0.7656062841415405,
1.3705339431762695,
0.4850691556930542,
-0.6663641333580017,
0.000041068644350161776,
0.011847157962620258,
0.4751721918582916,
-0.2293904572725296,
0.04050575941801071,
0.4154098629951477,
0.2202146202325821,
0.27721107006073,
-0.8907744884490967,
0.12755286693572998,
-0.2141149491071701,
0.06022823974490166,
0.021543309092521667,
-0.690509557723999,
0.44551771879196167,
-0.44050341844558716,
-0.6019116044044495,
0.5315760970115662,
0.5891156196594238,
0.1804586499929428,
0.02878507226705551,
0.5427170991897583,
1.0413352251052856,
0.5834873914718628,
0.09684665501117706,
1.1805107593536377,
0.02858428657054901,
0.04501478374004364,
1.3194327354431152,
-0.1037355363368988,
1.22121262550354,
0.6962305307388306,
-0.2542570233345032,
0.611171305179596,
0.6669917702674866,
-0.35232824087142944,
0.8181833028793335,
-0.0883389413356781,
-0.28077584505081177,
-0.22036345303058624,
-0.25677627325057983,
-0.2543540596961975,
0.43240484595298767,
0.27336135506629944,
-0.2971670627593994,
-0.363398015499115,
-0.19850125908851624,
-0.20585209131240845,
-0.0005931050982326269,
-0.17333316802978516,
0.8539006114006042,
0.08521781116724014,
-0.5548592805862427,
0.6127463579177856,
-0.4646543264389038,
0.7607197165489197,
-0.24611730873584747,
-0.43569788336753845,
-0.23316945135593414,
-0.048835914582014084,
-0.3823944628238678,
-1.233210563659668,
0.3420666456222534,
0.33536428213119507,
-0.09779185056686401,
-0.13731810450553894,
0.7057842016220093,
-0.38917791843414307,
-0.3885359466075897,
0.13113030791282654,
0.1606602966785431,
0.470132440328598,
-0.014255493879318237,
-0.50380539894104,
0.2716076076030731,
-0.0209385734051466,
-0.07349291443824768,
0.2387964129447937,
0.2313496172428131,
0.27163439989089966,
0.7622063755989075,
0.7444620728492737,
-0.07617567479610443,
0.03903568908572197,
0.17606955766677856,
0.9882815480232239,
-0.4495176672935486,
0.09669076651334763,
-0.9579750299453735,
0.3238271474838257,
-0.047945547848939896,
-0.07603573799133301,
0.5147408843040466,
0.6590458750724792,
0.8224676847457886,
0.0924774557352066,
0.7711560726165771,
0.0681891217827797,
0.27443140745162964,
-0.6114652156829834,
0.39335623383522034,
-0.6758607029914856,
0.19725151360034943,
-0.15996526181697845,
-0.8233668208122253,
-0.47790151834487915,
0.6060916185379028,
0.14628730714321136,
-0.3409436047077179,
0.36966603994369507,
0.8446994423866272,
-0.08707637339830399,
-0.13185624778270721,
0.18901482224464417,
0.12719398736953735,
0.27448543906211853,
0.5386799573898315,
0.9006739854812622,
-0.666141927242279,
1.018980860710144,
-0.13261467218399048,
-0.1518535017967224,
0.010714870877563953,
-0.9559713006019592,
-0.6756108999252319,
-0.49477267265319824,
-0.3091757297515869,
-0.22035500407218933,
-0.05561814457178116,
0.3282051384449005,
0.5514824390411377,
-0.31457653641700745,
-0.04058874025940895,
-0.16197967529296875,
-0.12074477970600128,
-0.07594751566648483,
-0.17145676910877228,
0.15846772491931915,
-0.3200572431087494,
-0.741016685962677,
0.15565386414527893,
0.48834818601608276,
0.36679133772850037,
-0.370378315448761,
0.11257623881101608,
-0.1690942496061325,
-0.11848358809947968,
0.5836191177368164,
0.18639345467090607,
-0.8611282110214233,
-0.23442816734313965,
-0.12170399725437164,
-0.07041588425636292,
0.322933554649353,
0.4907533824443817,
-0.9298959970474243,
0.5334404706954956,
0.18291115760803223,
0.8010593056678772,
0.7493137121200562,
0.09516189247369766,
0.723639965057373,
-0.7587422728538513,
0.2559461295604706,
-0.050584133714437485,
0.28554365038871765,
0.6506835222244263,
-0.20659074187278748,
0.9731457233428955,
0.14377160370349884,
-0.4763069152832031,
-0.6909018754959106,
0.18042153120040894,
-1.353947639465332,
-0.08786573261022568,
1.232869029045105,
-0.12674479186534882,
-0.3300946056842804,
0.2257005125284195,
-0.3642384111881256,
0.18854141235351562,
-0.2559424340724945,
0.9176183938980103,
0.5339468121528625,
0.09361955523490906,
-0.317212849855423,
-0.5456440448760986,
0.24091745913028717,
0.1938590109348297,
-0.8617526888847351,
-0.05788736790418625,
0.4988439679145813,
0.19061978161334991,
0.16099804639816284,
0.727164626121521,
-0.24003829061985016,
0.3285767436027527,
0.04349562153220177,
0.05210909619927406,
0.07123010605573654,
-0.16720180213451385,
-0.07316675037145615,
-0.08550190925598145,
-0.20813269913196564,
-0.464910089969635
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08464v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08464v1
|
Magpie: Alignment Data Synthesis from Scratch by Prompting Aligned LLMs with Nothing
| 2024-06-12T17:52:30 | 2024-06-12T17:52:30 |
Zhangchen Xu, Fengqing Jiang, Luyao Niu, Yuntian Deng, Radha Poovendran, Yejin Choi, Bill Yuchen Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
High-quality instruction data is critical for aligning large language models
(LLMs). Although some models, such as Llama-3-Instruct, have open weights,
their alignment data remain private, which hinders the democratization of AI.
High human labor costs and a limited, predefined scope for prompting prevent
existing open-source data creation methods from scaling effectively,
potentially limiting the diversity and quality of public alignment datasets. Is
it possible to synthesize high-quality instruction data at scale by extracting
it directly from an aligned LLM? We present a self-synthesis method for
generating large-scale alignment data named Magpie. Our key observation is that
aligned LLMs like Llama-3-Instruct can generate a user query when we input only
the left-side templates up to the position reserved for user messages, thanks
to their auto-regressive nature. We use this method to prompt Llama-3-Instruct
and generate 4 million instructions along with their corresponding responses.
We perform a comprehensive analysis of the extracted data and select 300K
high-quality instances. To compare Magpie data with other public instruction
datasets, we fine-tune Llama-3-8B-Base with each dataset and evaluate the
performance of the fine-tuned models. Our results indicate that in some tasks,
models fine-tuned with Magpie perform comparably to the official
Llama-3-8B-Instruct, despite the latter being enhanced with 10 million data
points through supervised fine-tuning (SFT) and subsequent feedback learning.
We also show that using Magpie solely for SFT can surpass the performance of
previous public datasets utilized for both SFT and preference optimization,
such as direct preference optimization with UltraFeedback. This advantage is
evident on alignment benchmarks such as AlpacaEval, ArenaHard, and WildBench.
|
[
-0.210819274187088,
-0.5195438265800476,
0.4100860357284546,
0.2528206408023834,
0.16864027082920074,
0.004047031980007887,
-0.2526753544807434,
-0.1856338232755661,
0.1686004102230072,
0.5560887455940247,
-0.6329883337020874,
-0.5997249484062195,
-0.21971939504146576,
0.2114201933145523,
-0.5872536897659302,
0.9877979159355164,
0.11821518838405609,
0.004725406877696514,
-0.38042882084846497,
0.21170125901699066,
-0.5248889923095703,
-0.2938540279865265,
-0.0031240261159837246,
-0.21408365666866302,
0.2519284784793854,
0.9570934772491455,
0.8062682747840881,
1.0360240936279297,
0.44357725977897644,
0.20931224524974823,
0.16780705749988556,
0.5236483216285706,
-0.5832954049110413,
0.042429368942976,
-0.09607665240764618,
-0.5039863586425781,
-0.5721049308776855,
0.2844237983226776,
0.7781792879104614,
0.47916191816329956,
-0.18603147566318512,
0.43095266819000244,
0.08111035823822021,
0.917252242565155,
-0.7875913381576538,
-0.031642790883779526,
-0.6143670678138733,
0.2690177261829376,
-0.3339284360408783,
-0.09335566312074661,
-0.6587309241294861,
-0.5425602197647095,
-0.43327152729034424,
-0.6469711065292358,
0.18412484228610992,
0.07300940901041031,
0.7209269404411316,
0.3877062499523163,
-0.07074647396802902,
-0.3341916501522064,
-0.6970157623291016,
0.6032617688179016,
-0.6126879453659058,
0.3462989032268524,
0.3783618211746216,
0.1883215308189392,
-0.5256598591804504,
-0.590131402015686,
-0.6454657316207886,
0.01196514256298542,
-0.10609403997659683,
0.1686488687992096,
-0.2569049894809723,
-0.36519327759742737,
-0.04328911006450653,
0.44347065687179565,
-0.4850408434867859,
0.3074762225151062,
-0.44663962721824646,
-0.10855501890182495,
0.7646793127059937,
0.3075869679450989,
0.0717577338218689,
-0.17663413286209106,
-0.4357147216796875,
-0.2498077154159546,
-1.167618989944458,
-0.02101041004061699,
0.520024299621582,
0.44127240777015686,
0.2500200867652893,
0.8972212672233582,
-0.20992517471313477,
0.7847220301628113,
0.5299438834190369,
-0.11561010777950287,
0.22560429573059082,
-0.2527039647102356,
-0.18613994121551514,
0.17335283756256104,
1.1369444131851196,
0.4641713798046112,
-0.01403945405036211,
-0.045634642243385315,
-0.2831313908100128,
-0.2766420245170593,
0.15846635401248932,
-0.7154160141944885,
-0.2572791576385498,
0.21895183622837067,
-0.22372159361839294,
-0.3521542251110077,
0.1270718276500702,
-0.7780899405479431,
-0.45636260509490967,
-0.3581121265888214,
0.36911246180534363,
-0.31983688473701477,
0.06165153905749321,
0.05179522931575775,
0.5642051696777344,
0.3611694872379303,
0.22925662994384766,
-1.233831763267517,
0.16818048059940338,
0.7822908759117126,
0.7293960452079773,
-0.3370783030986786,
-0.5424025058746338,
-0.8244097828865051,
0.24899336695671082,
-0.6946036219596863,
0.7719904184341431,
-0.6352826952934265,
-0.3108935058116913,
-0.3166113495826721,
0.08492495864629745,
-0.13316680490970612,
-0.6360092759132385,
0.04255320504307747,
-0.2195572853088379,
0.41737842559814453,
-0.20802690088748932,
-0.6984702348709106,
0.07223376631736755,
0.06071935221552849,
-0.40284138917922974,
1.0718820095062256,
0.09629688411951065,
-0.5377117395401001,
0.02000625990331173,
-0.637445330619812,
-0.4201447069644928,
-0.10322386026382446,
-0.12593989074230194,
-0.48585349321365356,
0.02580135129392147,
0.6581758260726929,
0.5721477270126343,
-0.21323546767234802,
0.13187284767627716,
-0.0800953209400177,
-0.6128530502319336,
0.24528537690639496,
-0.15349507331848145,
0.6602554321289062,
0.2033035159111023,
-0.3412057161331177,
0.07080328464508057,
-0.7026207447052002,
0.06399986147880554,
0.17757567763328552,
-0.1256556659936905,
0.04389139264822006,
-0.004491768311709166,
-0.5576913356781006,
-0.1654791533946991,
0.5361871719360352,
-0.31038713455200195,
0.678612232208252,
-0.3408537805080414,
0.32866591215133667,
0.8447390794754028,
-0.12349002063274384,
0.5565037727355957,
-0.1010858416557312,
0.534174382686615,
-0.17559008300304413,
0.38684695959091187,
-0.07476187497377396,
-0.2976371645927429,
-0.6535086631774902,
-0.17763693630695343,
0.4122103750705719,
0.475477397441864,
-0.1764083206653595,
0.550713837146759,
-0.2592023015022278,
-0.5247623920440674,
-0.9749454259872437,
0.5255321264266968,
0.2915205955505371,
0.546880304813385,
0.41692066192626953,
-0.06375600397586823,
-0.22020277380943298,
-0.8950034379959106,
0.14630842208862305,
-0.06769299507141113,
-0.11111940443515778,
0.13074614107608795,
0.12919898331165314,
-0.18903109431266785,
0.8248236775398254,
-0.6870228052139282,
-0.4741053581237793,
0.029801566153764725,
0.011142512783408165,
0.3005332350730896,
0.5289232134819031,
0.3444962501525879,
-0.34332025051116943,
-0.343670129776001,
0.03786394000053406,
-0.5378584265708923,
-0.3306165933609009,
-0.13959474861621857,
-0.4864574074745178,
0.07671321928501129,
0.5307000875473022,
-0.5785219073295593,
0.0221988707780838,
0.6567582488059998,
-0.10155878216028214,
0.3785579204559326,
-0.11525293439626694,
0.07200665026903152,
-1.1319619417190552,
-0.12126722186803818,
-0.4720675051212311,
-0.01629168540239334,
-0.3868650496006012,
0.05625389143824577,
0.31726017594337463,
-0.09133129566907883,
-0.40563344955444336,
0.2559669315814972,
-0.5997617840766907,
-0.3714878261089325,
-0.2753685712814331,
0.11635248363018036,
0.08514866977930069,
0.3531774580478668,
-0.2562321722507477,
1.3196649551391602,
0.3787139356136322,
-0.30162909626960754,
0.3689800798892975,
0.5629384517669678,
-0.19159257411956787,
0.33705297112464905,
-0.5278504490852356,
0.30016741156578064,
0.04204215854406357,
0.05807249993085861,
-0.8574873805046082,
-0.5079915523529053,
0.5461218357086182,
-0.3537907302379608,
0.3027113974094391,
-0.16125676035881042,
-0.6186608672142029,
-0.2586480677127838,
-0.24071335792541504,
-0.02620837092399597,
0.4663788080215454,
-0.8607863783836365,
0.3055693507194519,
0.23971356451511383,
-0.052903078496456146,
-0.7088726758956909,
-0.4006093740463257,
0.07945225387811661,
-0.08377481997013092,
-0.27929967641830444,
0.11127224564552307,
-0.10485368221998215,
0.11214740574359894,
-0.07377270609140396,
-0.03672356158494949,
0.24982592463493347,
0.14640213549137115,
0.4341994524002075,
0.33485424518585205,
-0.1723065972328186,
0.25910043716430664,
0.274815171957016,
-0.05150609090924263,
0.024193288758397102,
-0.26499268412590027,
0.5087953209877014,
-0.39363858103752136,
-0.6143377423286438,
-0.6057003140449524,
0.05886831507086754,
0.6373040676116943,
-0.571136474609375,
0.5517134666442871,
0.5844788551330566,
-0.005348821636289358,
-0.13902340829372406,
-0.44170325994491577,
-0.11332549154758453,
-0.49688050150871277,
-0.04500778391957283,
0.012476703152060509,
-0.5949938893318176,
0.10146202147006989,
0.03970438241958618,
0.27934709191322327,
0.24535825848579407,
0.6427974700927734,
-0.08553912490606308,
1.1049612760543823,
0.3595716059207916,
-0.24266164004802704,
0.4397963285446167,
-0.17341206967830658,
0.04510524868965149,
-0.7767805457115173,
-0.3086729347705841,
-0.2952237129211426,
-0.3527003824710846,
-0.44077035784721375,
-0.3408558666706085,
0.3682304918766022,
0.04950498044490814,
-0.21317319571971893,
0.33159926533699036,
-0.975676953792572,
0.828427791595459,
0.7298539280891418,
0.13560469448566437,
0.2703523337841034,
0.07041771709918976,
0.2542937994003296,
0.13784709572792053,
-0.47580721974372864,
-0.6832612156867981,
1.330864429473877,
-0.01143049169331789,
0.9936352372169495,
-0.036459945142269135,
1.0981926918029785,
0.19060705602169037,
0.3847109377384186,
-0.767052173614502,
0.580544114112854,
-0.04551268741488457,
-0.34097620844841003,
-0.2586652934551239,
-0.34200870990753174,
-0.9683181643486023,
0.039328839629888535,
-0.4530872106552124,
-0.5219862461090088,
-0.04726151376962662,
0.3044348955154419,
-0.5148442983627319,
0.0668855682015419,
-0.9208754897117615,
0.6694151759147644,
-0.34022822976112366,
-0.44909679889678955,
0.21170081198215485,
-0.6439988017082214,
0.4082317054271698,
-0.22189722955226898,
0.046468861401081085,
-0.369760125875473,
-0.00100613699760288,
0.6280156373977661,
-0.328124076128006,
0.8263859748840332,
0.015202335081994534,
-0.20054614543914795,
0.2784065306186676,
0.2546868622303009,
0.506561815738678,
-0.008047734387218952,
-0.1726199835538864,
-0.02797812782227993,
-0.017461104318499565,
-0.27134352922439575,
-0.7212607860565186,
0.9170576333999634,
-0.9815120697021484,
-0.9466514587402344,
-0.03071754053235054,
-0.747937798500061,
-0.1636919528245926,
0.37343332171440125,
0.1421489715576172,
0.18384747207164764,
0.1637047976255417,
0.15077993273735046,
0.34886300563812256,
0.0077128163538873196,
0.2058461457490921,
0.48654723167419434,
-0.33292919397354126,
-0.4872083365917206,
1.0392189025878906,
0.13540641963481903,
0.12310997396707535,
0.2616879343986511,
0.3045556843280792,
-0.09252608567476273,
-0.4086346924304962,
-0.6578394770622253,
0.20757310092449188,
-0.5625721216201782,
-0.6643519997596741,
-0.33086302876472473,
-0.0826057493686676,
-0.35149434208869934,
-0.24437719583511353,
-0.7338384389877319,
-0.5496116280555725,
-0.6071196794509888,
-0.01717344857752323,
0.36365804076194763,
0.9668000936508179,
-0.19852586090564728,
0.41807401180267334,
-0.8231148719787598,
0.07762309908866882,
0.31445997953414917,
0.12745825946331024,
-0.09056760370731354,
-0.3339827358722687,
-0.22265799343585968,
0.2362615019083023,
-0.6418250203132629,
-0.7853918671607971,
0.4109039008617401,
0.23353375494480133,
0.28553855419158936,
0.5222693681716919,
0.20626294612884521,
0.9008104205131531,
-0.6898697018623352,
0.7850818634033203,
-0.05039004981517792,
-1.0348414182662964,
0.750537633895874,
-0.06775981932878494,
0.1826639324426651,
0.4705616235733032,
0.3811659514904022,
0.012023445218801498,
-0.6039800643920898,
-0.330839604139328,
-0.6129193902015686,
0.7147596478462219,
0.16293640434741974,
0.11240750551223755,
-0.09842317551374435,
0.5204522013664246,
0.32646170258522034,
0.07059986889362335,
-0.5272464156150818,
-0.09786968678236008,
-0.2579838037490845,
-0.4402848184108734,
-0.0001684559101704508,
-0.056390292942523956,
-0.43278491497039795,
-0.3354048430919647,
0.6418774724006653,
-0.2648056745529175,
0.3013729453086853,
0.0467902347445488,
0.007669289596378803,
-0.32869598269462585,
0.13432371616363525,
0.5972235202789307,
0.6867884397506714,
-0.04543115198612213,
0.05772536247968674,
0.028297962620854378,
-0.3467956781387329,
0.3866350054740906,
0.06214750558137894,
-0.17298731207847595,
-0.3666599988937378,
0.3147335648536682,
0.3760336935520172,
0.05371928960084915,
-0.4780676066875458,
0.6876697540283203,
0.12982164323329926,
-0.07129569351673126,
-0.16523084044456482,
0.42031294107437134,
0.19499750435352325,
0.4681728184223175,
0.3004211187362671,
-0.27896973490715027,
-0.05096530169248581,
-0.14024358987808228,
0.043938446789979935,
0.4536125361919403,
0.06133795529603958,
-0.34255966544151306,
0.8195458650588989,
-0.007505794521421194,
-0.13267682492733002,
0.8939889073371887,
-0.0581061914563179,
-0.14902974665164948,
0.3150146007537842,
0.7407737970352173,
0.3731570541858673,
-0.2916264533996582,
0.3071476221084595,
0.32850736379623413,
0.2571372091770172,
-0.1889357566833496,
0.08123037219047546,
-0.12098842859268188,
-0.615252673625946,
-0.39296817779541016,
-0.5104382038116455,
-0.6812848448753357,
-0.0033271026331931353,
-0.9390288591384888,
0.20592744648456573,
-0.5813440680503845,
-0.0220235176384449,
-0.14385874569416046,
-0.043643519282341,
-0.3248468041419983,
-0.08186125010251999,
0.15991967916488647,
0.6086350679397583,
-0.8641278147697449,
0.6799380779266357,
0.6532295346260071,
-0.2630244195461273,
-0.9878010749816895,
0.0918494164943695,
0.004150036722421646,
-1.1265043020248413,
0.4717400074005127,
0.30207282304763794,
-0.16346339881420135,
0.07207468897104263,
-1.0297510623931885,
-1.0163397789001465,
1.2027238607406616,
0.5791541337966919,
-0.6977478861808777,
-0.029786746948957443,
0.10077474266290665,
0.4162943959236145,
-0.411532998085022,
-0.1182503029704094,
0.5046316385269165,
0.3480159342288971,
0.1802142858505249,
-0.4751884639263153,
0.12280846387147903,
-0.02280476689338684,
-0.24087640643119812,
0.28256353735923767,
-0.8693260550498962,
0.6900072693824768,
-0.38357633352279663,
-0.18287540972232819,
0.057063568383455276,
0.9398182034492493,
0.24554558098316193,
0.08718244731426239,
0.23452681303024292,
0.38664481043815613,
0.9951848983764648,
0.04546437785029411,
0.6503812670707703,
-0.497213214635849,
0.37281933426856995,
1.1461435556411743,
-0.42064112424850464,
0.9575718641281128,
0.547452986240387,
-0.14119496941566467,
0.35810455679893494,
0.6356257200241089,
-0.3335261940956116,
0.40637680888175964,
-0.16522979736328125,
0.006684149615466595,
-0.4054299294948578,
0.11054115742444992,
-0.40486252307891846,
0.7149289846420288,
0.27206313610076904,
-0.26435935497283936,
-0.03186438977718353,
-0.0921192616224289,
0.056116193532943726,
0.016254128888249397,
-0.20178042352199554,
0.6938813924789429,
-0.2743597626686096,
-0.6933560967445374,
0.8839454054832458,
-0.41475608944892883,
0.2172013819217682,
-0.3548271954059601,
-0.12163715809583664,
-0.5498095750808716,
0.12070680409669876,
-0.48252588510513306,
-0.9355324506759644,
0.043286148458719254,
-0.045818544924259186,
-0.13168053328990936,
-0.1411420702934265,
0.19887308776378632,
-0.4781016409397125,
-0.5909470915794373,
-0.22129347920417786,
0.30650320649147034,
0.24516426026821136,
0.42860546708106995,
-0.46462276577949524,
0.10437437146902084,
0.05854494497179985,
-0.43430960178375244,
0.3869888484477997,
0.32490408420562744,
0.10266494005918503,
0.8473399877548218,
0.6950731873512268,
0.17363309860229492,
-0.11709732562303543,
-0.33938834071159363,
1.0328130722045898,
-0.4362400770187378,
-0.06774221360683441,
-0.7363359332084656,
0.09671766310930252,
0.10805147886276245,
-0.12630526721477509,
0.8529760837554932,
0.5199591517448425,
0.9408965110778809,
-0.03144611790776253,
0.4137725532054901,
0.09478411823511124,
0.40775030851364136,
-0.7113127112388611,
0.6909822225570679,
-0.6809404492378235,
0.2953066825866699,
-0.11141310632228851,
-0.9021774530410767,
-0.4120123088359833,
0.6647902727127075,
-0.4268501102924347,
-0.4455813765525818,
0.26969507336616516,
1.1374914646148682,
-0.1719079166650772,
0.0437416210770607,
0.20814824104309082,
0.06091880425810814,
0.24172767996788025,
0.4391392469406128,
0.8890909552574158,
-0.2567218840122223,
0.6423113346099854,
-0.294551283121109,
-0.13591262698173523,
-0.2762848436832428,
-0.7828916311264038,
-0.8092511892318726,
-0.5106747150421143,
-0.09571857005357742,
-0.2598555088043213,
0.042466241866350174,
1.2535508871078491,
0.4793182611465454,
-0.7236377596855164,
-0.17784208059310913,
0.14047271013259888,
0.2690460979938507,
-0.1785612404346466,
-0.22756674885749817,
0.5316784381866455,
-0.3224042057991028,
-0.7556656002998352,
0.759583055973053,
0.11402224004268646,
0.224845752120018,
-0.15975791215896606,
-0.037057362496852875,
0.13397647440433502,
-0.1412314772605896,
0.3321802318096161,
0.4054381847381592,
-0.5807893872261047,
-0.26922914385795593,
0.15165062248706818,
-0.15674443542957306,
0.3090362250804901,
0.49546539783477783,
-0.47414809465408325,
0.47740575671195984,
0.11107431352138519,
0.6472476720809937,
0.22581946849822998,
0.3006935119628906,
0.6258757710456848,
-0.645911693572998,
-0.07033423334360123,
-0.007255057338625193,
0.16059274971485138,
0.47441360354423523,
-0.5547227263450623,
0.5135024189949036,
-0.18808609247207642,
-0.7728502154350281,
-0.8396165370941162,
0.08406689018011093,
-0.577750563621521,
-0.07941155880689621,
1.106029748916626,
-0.1271643489599228,
-0.42168837785720825,
0.5970482230186462,
-0.2972640097141266,
0.14242836833000183,
-0.35864800214767456,
0.9117503762245178,
0.36422908306121826,
-0.43533211946487427,
-0.03036654368042946,
-0.20919424295425415,
0.2162473201751709,
0.28534314036369324,
-0.709524393081665,
0.340592622756958,
0.688992440700531,
0.3626006543636322,
0.06660587340593338,
0.23164154589176178,
-0.250884085893631,
0.27417516708374023,
-0.18703393638134003,
0.22730430960655212,
-0.5890487432479858,
-0.48571792244911194,
-0.12762558460235596,
0.10766223073005676,
0.04667744040489197,
-0.3069765865802765
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08447v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08447v1
|
The Impact of Initialization on LoRA Finetuning Dynamics
| 2024-06-12T17:38:20 | 2024-06-12T17:38:20 |
Soufiane Hayou, Nikhil Ghosh, Bin Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
In this paper, we study the role of initialization in Low Rank Adaptation
(LoRA) as originally introduced in Hu et al. (2021). Essentially, to start from
the pretrained model as initialization for finetuning, one can either
initialize B to zero and A to random (default initialization in PEFT package),
or vice-versa. In both cases, the product BA is equal to zero at
initialization, which makes finetuning starts from the pretrained model. These
two initialization schemes are seemingly similar. They should in-principle
yield the same performance and share the same optimal learning rate. We
demonstrate that this is an incorrect intuition and that the first scheme
(initializing B to zero and A to random) on average yields better performance
compared to the other scheme. Our theoretical analysis shows that the reason
behind this might be that the first initialization allows the use of larger
learning rates (without causing output instability) compared to the second
initialization, resulting in more efficient learning of the first scheme. We
validate our results with extensive experiments on LLMs.
|
[
-0.3094192445278168,
-0.8240821361541748,
0.40629681944847107,
-0.1395837962627411,
-0.4323495924472809,
-0.14223803579807281,
-0.14140398800373077,
-0.557339608669281,
0.044236134737730026,
0.258267879486084,
-0.4317292869091034,
0.044338494539260864,
-0.6651455163955688,
-0.018764734268188477,
-0.4192097783088684,
1.4862946271896362,
0.1946887969970703,
-0.11682844907045364,
0.37069645524024963,
-0.11109822988510132,
-0.3548896908760071,
-0.4157726466655731,
-1.0511200428009033,
-0.5951404571533203,
1.0090097188949585,
0.5198132395744324,
0.6228787302970886,
0.5269525647163391,
0.5340505242347717,
0.3024469017982483,
-0.2564971148967743,
-0.16507360339164734,
-1.2299778461456299,
-0.11390269547700882,
0.21108980476856232,
-0.812728762626648,
-0.2738371789455414,
0.12627948820590973,
0.7906327843666077,
0.9491152167320251,
-0.3316537141799927,
0.10909389704465866,
0.4963788390159607,
0.9331426620483398,
-0.5942476987838745,
-0.18698778748512268,
-0.7865262031555176,
0.023027688264846802,
-0.21882253885269165,
-0.5500812530517578,
-0.32777515053749084,
-0.46347981691360474,
0.2764604091644287,
-0.8538488745689392,
-0.06497225165367126,
-0.06343924254179001,
0.9761913418769836,
0.5179501175880432,
-0.25994545221328735,
0.0451669842004776,
-0.9399492740631104,
0.6021111607551575,
-0.4963834285736084,
0.30578386783599854,
-0.19375395774841309,
0.4776840806007385,
-0.25737276673316956,
-0.5494734048843384,
-0.302734911441803,
0.03398340940475464,
0.22949321568012238,
0.026872042566537857,
-0.2142152190208435,
0.02938668057322502,
0.5131588578224182,
0.44671735167503357,
0.029486967250704765,
0.7997058033943176,
-0.7429216504096985,
0.11877269297838211,
0.32269537448883057,
-0.008151719346642494,
-0.13519787788391113,
0.06598549336194992,
-0.5643458366394043,
-0.18016012012958527,
-0.8647666573524475,
0.5330435633659363,
0.640256941318512,
0.6661352515220642,
-0.5287025570869446,
0.5895342230796814,
-0.20607924461364746,
0.47716689109802246,
0.6864239573478699,
-0.15414509177207947,
0.3084263801574707,
0.13428986072540283,
-0.3846283555030823,
0.3277171552181244,
0.53426593542099,
0.35090798139572144,
0.41734278202056885,
-0.0775555893778801,
-0.13602115213871002,
-0.03728516399860382,
0.13861343264579773,
-0.8441762328147888,
0.005648165009915829,
0.10449571907520294,
-0.48704493045806885,
-0.6577714085578918,
0.22673609852790833,
-0.5268681049346924,
-0.5637356042861938,
-0.6060056090354919,
0.8790450096130371,
-0.38624709844589233,
0.0733058974146843,
0.12617245316505432,
0.1964898556470871,
1.0204145908355713,
0.45635876059532166,
-1.1481324434280396,
0.510173499584198,
0.7445754408836365,
0.6685629487037659,
-0.37892472743988037,
-0.3790055215358734,
-0.8180880546569824,
-0.12753057479858398,
-0.46714916825294495,
0.7553896307945251,
0.30311423540115356,
-0.20820768177509308,
-0.26775282621383667,
0.008556089363992214,
0.018747983500361443,
-0.42827656865119934,
0.23474667966365814,
-0.6009100079536438,
-0.09119295328855515,
-0.24407479166984558,
-0.12094271183013916,
-0.06478768587112427,
-0.361390620470047,
-0.62701016664505,
0.867007851600647,
-0.010846076533198357,
-0.5301414728164673,
0.815984308719635,
-0.8394283652305603,
-0.46992865204811096,
-0.14779366552829742,
-0.04158028960227966,
-0.32803401350975037,
0.5265375375747681,
-0.31607016921043396,
0.38894492387771606,
0.02140973135828972,
-0.4114246070384979,
-0.27794981002807617,
-0.8383594155311584,
0.20052257180213928,
-0.24916094541549683,
0.826200008392334,
0.22136707603931427,
-0.17611652612686157,
-0.11701083928346634,
-0.9874541163444519,
0.22348234057426453,
0.08447236567735672,
-0.6036070585250854,
-0.31299862265586853,
-0.07371862232685089,
-0.1969604194164276,
-0.2076517790555954,
0.20948341488838196,
-0.3716614246368408,
0.2175551950931549,
-0.902986466884613,
0.2904432415962219,
1.1022552251815796,
0.42204636335372925,
0.7689322829246521,
-0.3076547682285309,
0.20673178136348724,
0.16398322582244873,
0.1852245181798935,
-0.028067290782928467,
-0.2899848222732544,
-1.0216141939163208,
0.03511068969964981,
0.49815553426742554,
0.4589221477508545,
-0.3124135136604309,
0.0359494574368,
-0.1279737502336502,
-0.2746613025665283,
-0.30381399393081665,
0.2296862155199051,
0.4595797061920166,
0.14368925988674164,
0.1802845150232315,
-0.3783796727657318,
-0.6527231931686401,
-0.8860061168670654,
-0.005124272312968969,
0.036886975169181824,
0.2515113353729248,
-0.09002430737018585,
0.2857498228549957,
0.06927561014890671,
0.822832465171814,
-0.5109122395515442,
-0.13154226541519165,
-0.12897758185863495,
0.11347860097885132,
0.7589690089225769,
0.8065502047538757,
0.923190176486969,
-0.2523885667324066,
-0.649633526802063,
0.2978295683860779,
-0.5832985639572144,
0.0049901134334504604,
-0.036925867199897766,
-0.5761417150497437,
0.2849459648132324,
0.35251283645629883,
-0.30001989006996155,
0.4242377281188965,
0.5832829475402832,
-0.10343051701784134,
0.12275183945894241,
-0.31631961464881897,
-0.03629171475768089,
-0.8789647817611694,
-0.05580795556306839,
-0.11712615191936493,
0.004384912550449371,
-0.7729452848434448,
-0.02579706721007824,
-0.3724038302898407,
-0.12570418417453766,
-0.6930660009384155,
0.24181540310382843,
-0.25800836086273193,
-0.295224666595459,
-0.2634808421134949,
-0.054915547370910645,
-0.06413130462169647,
0.6157681345939636,
-0.5071516633033752,
0.929149329662323,
0.3005598187446594,
-0.9829591512680054,
-0.26996007561683655,
0.18342076241970062,
-0.39192110300064087,
0.5300328731536865,
-0.8263336420059204,
0.19360299408435822,
-0.11839506775140762,
-0.2480001002550125,
-0.5836480855941772,
-0.05451217666268349,
0.3272187411785126,
-0.185714453458786,
0.37516704201698303,
-0.474423348903656,
-0.15860098600387573,
-0.0570082850754261,
-0.34452196955680847,
0.2339922934770584,
0.8729621171951294,
-0.6281086206436157,
0.30781295895576477,
0.13496847450733185,
0.12160972505807877,
-0.5570790767669678,
-0.5062791109085083,
-0.5374851822853088,
-0.4589701294898987,
-0.29153943061828613,
0.15882034599781036,
-0.3547079563140869,
-0.171253964304924,
-0.4833899140357971,
-0.4294297993183136,
0.04928931966423988,
0.6316112875938416,
0.43752872943878174,
0.2542167901992798,
-0.310702919960022,
-0.2763465642929077,
0.2558864653110504,
-0.3024933934211731,
-0.15053784847259521,
-0.2058355212211609,
0.4855598509311676,
-0.09609155356884003,
-0.16743305325508118,
-0.7834654450416565,
-0.05681779235601425,
0.4472459554672241,
0.03796481341123581,
0.9140440821647644,
0.525536060333252,
-0.2708076238632202,
-0.028311148285865784,
-0.3656260371208191,
-0.10483298450708389,
-0.5535152554512024,
0.18947646021842957,
-0.5049979090690613,
-0.3752641975879669,
0.6268627047538757,
0.010736766271293163,
0.18436966836452484,
0.49575960636138916,
0.47895941138267517,
-0.5565030574798584,
0.5613291263580322,
1.2068127393722534,
0.31361904740333557,
0.8082471489906311,
-0.8007274866104126,
0.0875103622674942,
-0.8615068197250366,
-0.12280144542455673,
-0.40430575609207153,
-0.6454272866249084,
-0.8433172106742859,
-0.030576488003134727,
0.3433826267719269,
0.5905247330665588,
-0.4610142707824707,
0.06311581283807755,
-0.28246524930000305,
0.8562654852867126,
0.4971703886985779,
0.39935508370399475,
0.3172784745693207,
0.26356080174446106,
-0.08693081885576248,
0.004336388781666756,
-0.8919866681098938,
-0.2165486216545105,
1.5232242345809937,
0.30269762873649597,
0.9804365634918213,
0.1828117072582245,
1.1848324537277222,
0.22149018943309784,
0.25311100482940674,
-1.0179027318954468,
0.2536977529525757,
-0.37887558341026306,
0.030111491680145264,
-0.47694066166877747,
-0.12662871181964874,
-1.3605399131774902,
0.07075819373130798,
-0.5168030858039856,
-0.6120970845222473,
0.6784078478813171,
0.3302743136882782,
-1.0475058555603027,
-0.02114541456103325,
-0.8223382234573364,
0.6073065996170044,
-0.35058510303497314,
-0.5048437118530273,
-0.0661785677075386,
-0.4887818396091461,
0.34752389788627625,
-0.43834903836250305,
0.16233129799365997,
-0.027901260182261467,
0.09628874808549881,
1.2008696794509888,
-0.38576966524124146,
0.8695542216300964,
-0.47398504614830017,
-0.30387312173843384,
0.3578590154647827,
-0.1790897101163864,
0.46917328238487244,
-0.11626072973012924,
0.036126840859651566,
-0.0713757798075676,
0.03124469518661499,
-0.3665773272514343,
-0.5189958810806274,
0.8302609920501709,
-1.3450223207473755,
-0.5588225722312927,
-0.333732932806015,
-0.2673906087875366,
-0.04032621532678604,
0.35101625323295593,
0.2545350193977356,
0.3844027519226074,
-0.24952010810375214,
0.38319131731987,
0.7284759879112244,
0.11468721926212311,
0.35096725821495056,
0.6045389175415039,
-0.49778494238853455,
-0.2550770342350006,
0.7839674949645996,
0.28406602144241333,
0.5223962068557739,
0.06876766681671143,
0.2309814840555191,
0.33002227544784546,
-0.8031119108200073,
0.08042418956756592,
0.25131651759147644,
-0.7844738960266113,
-0.23573072254657745,
-0.0999651551246643,
-0.31094616651535034,
0.28668078780174255,
-0.3654417097568512,
-0.5334847569465637,
-0.5247664451599121,
-0.18779969215393066,
0.04391905665397644,
0.4284297525882721,
0.8029754161834717,
-0.39166778326034546,
0.8768293857574463,
-0.3332517147064209,
0.25878143310546875,
0.4742226302623749,
0.36401283740997314,
-0.12387733161449432,
-0.7993746995925903,
-0.671327531337738,
0.013292687013745308,
-0.3259553015232086,
-0.5310198068618774,
-0.24002046883106232,
0.47303447127342224,
0.704160213470459,
0.8680897951126099,
-0.13827599585056305,
0.6905807852745056,
-0.5660238265991211,
0.41450485587120056,
0.34023454785346985,
-0.5954787731170654,
0.48949578404426575,
-0.3907431662082672,
0.21583645045757294,
0.640674352645874,
0.2825520634651184,
0.007144525647163391,
0.1574563831090927,
-0.46693751215934753,
-0.620056688785553,
0.7599642276763916,
0.03308747336268425,
0.09414901584386826,
0.4883163273334503,
0.6641327142715454,
0.5770152807235718,
-0.05791551619768143,
-0.7058523893356323,
-0.3040009140968323,
-0.08986762166023254,
0.343843936920166,
-0.27272018790245056,
-0.4026968479156494,
-0.3383411765098572,
-0.2630777955055237,
0.39454853534698486,
-0.1867528110742569,
0.3503901958465576,
-0.1469718962907791,
-0.2696751058101654,
-0.578211784362793,
0.18081237375736237,
0.4867691099643707,
0.6061796545982361,
-0.47988250851631165,
-0.38516712188720703,
0.36404499411582947,
-0.35367217659950256,
0.20565485954284668,
-0.09532129764556885,
-0.40170153975486755,
-0.4579409658908844,
0.19214850664138794,
1.1372748613357544,
1.0196402072906494,
-0.15255185961723328,
0.1446126103401184,
0.34596094489097595,
-0.31310638785362244,
-0.016383754089474678,
0.4746667146682739,
-0.41031917929649353,
0.49809160828590393,
0.5450769066810608,
0.3055001199245453,
-0.1583440750837326,
-0.7103031277656555,
-0.120653435587883,
0.48239636421203613,
0.06104891747236252,
-0.3464024066925049,
0.6212524175643921,
0.17862151563167572,
-0.23444858193397522,
0.25199639797210693,
0.06283467262983322,
-0.19393551349639893,
0.6938831210136414,
0.4010894000530243,
0.697314977645874,
-0.22883978486061096,
-0.042423658072948456,
0.3224806487560272,
0.2037196308374405,
0.04472823441028595,
0.29038724303245544,
0.12518884241580963,
-0.759255051612854,
-0.4415290653705597,
-0.8644245266914368,
-0.381496787071228,
-0.019298484548926353,
-0.9049903154373169,
0.6524914503097534,
-0.8190951943397522,
-0.37236347794532776,
0.11309236288070679,
0.1038285419344902,
-0.8466862440109253,
-0.032788194715976715,
0.32231682538986206,
0.6426553726196289,
-0.8287737369537354,
0.6457732915878296,
0.5693828463554382,
-0.3555026054382324,
-0.7083353996276855,
-0.13581913709640503,
-0.2159447968006134,
-0.9532134532928467,
0.7365788221359253,
-0.02168898656964302,
-0.1967972368001938,
0.46647340059280396,
-0.5634380578994751,
-1.2429686784744263,
1.5805904865264893,
0.34281373023986816,
-0.5500137209892273,
-0.2527863085269928,
0.02877078391611576,
0.49678558111190796,
-0.4450177848339081,
-0.12998779118061066,
0.6956543922424316,
0.25627776980400085,
-0.002688690321519971,
-0.9900371432304382,
-0.384067177772522,
0.15643543004989624,
0.1353299468755722,
0.18558108806610107,
-0.684825599193573,
1.1289255619049072,
-0.6299904584884644,
-0.39258354902267456,
0.30126816034317017,
0.6214461922645569,
0.24703139066696167,
0.04274609684944153,
0.44997498393058777,
0.46754541993141174,
0.543319046497345,
-0.04727688059210777,
0.9609727263450623,
-0.48702606558799744,
0.3699854016304016,
1.117326021194458,
-0.17166386544704437,
1.0419367551803589,
0.8208827376365662,
-0.5955359935760498,
0.5375915169715881,
0.5796425938606262,
0.0035525669809430838,
0.7474268674850464,
0.11043016612529755,
0.2611828148365021,
0.07030849903821945,
0.17399707436561584,
-0.6919800043106079,
0.5402572154998779,
0.09186755865812302,
-0.03955189883708954,
-0.36258283257484436,
0.15075097978115082,
-0.12965068221092224,
-0.11860106140375137,
-0.7119616866111755,
0.730838418006897,
0.1108245700597763,
-0.2550273835659027,
1.0272630453109741,
-0.14747871458530426,
0.6267790198326111,
-0.7371856570243835,
0.19186171889305115,
-0.3739664554595947,
0.16925252974033356,
-0.40472647547721863,
-0.42550334334373474,
-0.018138989806175232,
-0.07300791889429092,
-0.3007103204727173,
-0.04736136645078659,
0.4835392236709595,
0.08428703248500824,
-0.1454208940267563,
0.1418725699186325,
0.6670141816139221,
0.17480356991291046,
0.5572535395622253,
-0.43925464153289795,
0.23868407309055328,
-0.23132450878620148,
-0.40813449025154114,
0.6568453311920166,
0.3143483102321625,
0.07728215306997299,
0.5639569759368896,
0.9104950428009033,
-0.17708224058151245,
0.39161214232444763,
-0.0822812095284462,
0.9389846324920654,
-0.2951066792011261,
-0.5906980037689209,
-0.6629794836044312,
0.5493784546852112,
0.3527573049068451,
-0.14818206429481506,
0.4650179147720337,
0.4828047752380371,
0.6026663184165955,
-0.10259335488080978,
0.35053202509880066,
0.017705775797367096,
0.12622714042663574,
-0.9702463150024414,
0.9509702324867249,
-0.4617328941822052,
0.3568539619445801,
-0.18837814033031464,
-1.3749867677688599,
0.15432628989219666,
0.6267131567001343,
-0.4544152021408081,
0.06362415850162506,
0.9888067245483398,
0.4566212594509125,
-0.21431496739387512,
-0.3580322265625,
0.4246090054512024,
0.6733653545379639,
-0.17703813314437866,
0.49782633781433105,
0.5873680710792542,
-0.6494235396385193,
0.363678514957428,
-0.3547542691230774,
-0.3051547110080719,
-0.2477836310863495,
-0.9406075477600098,
-0.7026284337043762,
-0.20716454088687897,
-0.13498519361019135,
-0.4230037033557892,
0.2832818031311035,
0.9131354093551636,
0.4489423334598541,
-0.7883142828941345,
-0.44365936517715454,
0.05211745202541351,
-0.10413626581430435,
-0.15735922753810883,
-0.17923825979232788,
0.1017208993434906,
-0.3880925476551056,
-0.6344141364097595,
0.43881192803382874,
-0.06729267537593842,
0.4610449969768524,
-0.2618144452571869,
-0.34270113706588745,
-0.3140687346458435,
0.12128177285194397,
0.5862377285957336,
0.789749264717102,
-0.43812891840934753,
-0.2749226987361908,
-0.5708609223365784,
0.03674826771020889,
0.3755069971084595,
0.6128238439559937,
-1.0701125860214233,
-0.14015761017799377,
-0.05381297692656517,
0.4670547544956207,
0.5462248921394348,
-0.11162292957305908,
0.5210389494895935,
-0.31855344772338867,
0.5869507193565369,
-0.46264687180519104,
0.18097944557666779,
-0.14019733667373657,
-0.3192996084690094,
0.664400577545166,
0.10183583945035934,
-0.4189088046550751,
-1.1719739437103271,
0.18032017350196838,
-1.243901014328003,
0.33840644359588623,
0.7337563037872314,
0.023527629673480988,
-0.22381530702114105,
0.5211491584777832,
-0.21177002787590027,
0.2869071662425995,
-0.3458079993724823,
0.6608553528785706,
0.277542382478714,
-0.2846725881099701,
-0.013357467949390411,
-0.5953094959259033,
0.5319738984107971,
0.33090347051620483,
-0.7269566655158997,
-0.37407127022743225,
0.04933832585811615,
0.5350760221481323,
-0.04447808489203453,
0.49469631910324097,
0.19026193022727966,
0.39040228724479675,
-0.2676582634449005,
-0.18359608948230743,
-0.1259852796792984,
-0.3159123361110687,
-0.7346319556236267,
0.11533704400062561,
0.5394695401191711,
-0.014820950105786324
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08446v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08446v1
|
OLMES: A Standard for Language Model Evaluations
| 2024-06-12T17:37:09 | 2024-06-12T17:37:09 |
Yuling Gu, Oyvind Tafjord, Bailey Kuehl, Dany Haddad, Jesse Dodge, Hannaneh Hajishirzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Progress in AI is often demonstrated by new models claiming improved
performance on tasks measuring model capabilities. Evaluating language models
in particular is challenging, as small changes to how a model is evaluated on a
task can lead to large changes in measured performance. There is no common
standard setup, so different models are evaluated on the same tasks in
different ways, leading to claims about which models perform best not being
reproducible. We propose OLMES, a completely documented, practical, open
standard for reproducible LLM evaluations. In developing this standard, we
identify and review the varying factors in evaluation practices adopted by the
community - such as details of prompt formatting, choice of in-context
examples, probability normalizations, and task formulation. In particular,
OLMES supports meaningful comparisons between smaller base models that require
the unnatural "cloze" formulation of multiple-choice questions against larger
models that can utilize the original formulation. OLMES includes
well-considered recommendations guided by results from existing literature as
well as new experiments investigating open questions.
|
[
-0.2363324761390686,
-0.5989801287651062,
0.7722806930541992,
0.018425682559609413,
-0.13211625814437866,
-0.3955218493938446,
-0.4410895109176636,
-0.3863432705402374,
-0.1569099724292755,
0.5465057492256165,
-0.2032800316810608,
-0.6053957939147949,
-0.6835717558860779,
0.3320690393447876,
-0.41187137365341187,
0.6618987321853638,
-0.35444799065589905,
0.23410604894161224,
-0.5042313933372498,
-0.4114425778388977,
-0.21634817123413086,
-0.11236005276441574,
-0.8292429447174072,
-0.28913867473602295,
0.5002062916755676,
0.27429476380348206,
0.6945151686668396,
0.5176976919174194,
0.6526003479957581,
0.3178112804889679,
-0.1747167557477951,
0.3832733929157257,
-0.40821772813796997,
0.21727824211120605,
-0.32579395174980164,
-0.2390359491109848,
-0.7520226836204529,
0.43233829736709595,
0.9102560877799988,
0.9603825211524963,
-0.17933836579322815,
0.3322423994541168,
0.13508640229701996,
0.6171548366546631,
-0.8426209092140198,
0.0467563159763813,
-0.234643816947937,
0.028057701885700226,
0.05734672024846077,
0.00034403856261633337,
-0.3272985816001892,
-0.5930452942848206,
0.0857362449169159,
-0.19024986028671265,
-0.2231685221195221,
-0.06320656090974808,
0.37553319334983826,
0.07590879499912262,
-0.5175023078918457,
-0.36642470955848694,
-0.7654781937599182,
0.943476140499115,
-1.0071086883544922,
0.5922388434410095,
0.22311267256736755,
0.6885448098182678,
-0.21508631110191345,
-0.8209763765335083,
-0.34449145197868347,
-0.8455486297607422,
0.005132035817950964,
-0.24060402810573578,
-0.3403557538986206,
0.0754542127251625,
0.2608974277973175,
0.48028457164764404,
-0.4035317003726959,
0.16179494559764862,
-0.5526221394538879,
0.0029720270540565252,
0.7842519879341125,
0.3345407247543335,
0.12365096062421799,
0.3684263527393341,
-0.23933370411396027,
0.24708111584186554,
-0.7641621232032776,
-0.05318160727620125,
0.38347163796424866,
0.21494756639003754,
0.06732534617185593,
0.5925229787826538,
-0.30965325236320496,
0.8126859068870544,
-0.37839409708976746,
-0.18469245731830597,
0.31654900312423706,
-0.29933449625968933,
-0.5577632784843445,
-0.6068634390830994,
0.7756876349449158,
0.46349838376045227,
0.07338612526655197,
-0.33391132950782776,
-0.5337395668029785,
-0.12269575893878937,
0.26600441336631775,
-0.6849725842475891,
0.16686254739761353,
0.14336632192134857,
-0.773003876209259,
-0.1816878765821457,
0.13416966795921326,
-0.6167934536933899,
-0.5593588352203369,
-0.4559643864631653,
0.5697144269943237,
-0.2034725695848465,
-0.05806775391101837,
0.14370638132095337,
-0.16516874730587006,
-0.19581303000450134,
0.4194841980934143,
-0.5323609113693237,
0.7188752293586731,
0.7420080304145813,
0.7676703929901123,
-0.28299680352211,
-0.46897193789482117,
-0.4946315884590149,
-0.45741719007492065,
-0.6207416653633118,
0.6331340670585632,
-0.47129026055336,
-0.36296626925468445,
-0.022035298869013786,
-0.010732226073741913,
0.057137612253427505,
-0.6338133215904236,
0.5724686980247498,
-0.22150994837284088,
0.23342657089233398,
-0.1442089080810547,
-0.7418332695960999,
-0.02384377457201481,
0.11340679973363876,
-0.5519184470176697,
0.9940420985221863,
0.028079936280846596,
-0.11907624453306198,
0.37886205315589905,
-1.0179311037063599,
-0.06593193113803864,
-0.21636825799942017,
-0.1391417235136032,
-0.1605997532606125,
0.44797608256340027,
-0.21043062210083008,
0.18901726603507996,
-0.5895822048187256,
0.12374120205640793,
-0.14439615607261658,
-0.3668348789215088,
0.2553926408290863,
-0.6130204796791077,
0.8647761344909668,
0.41413450241088867,
-0.16286219656467438,
0.48162105679512024,
-0.7152698040008545,
0.2839892506599426,
0.14773356914520264,
-0.24569512903690338,
-0.1542287915945053,
0.28445225954055786,
-0.468192994594574,
-0.21313416957855225,
0.2614537179470062,
-0.6249719262123108,
0.16647562384605408,
-0.3355863690376282,
0.6313263177871704,
0.7068067789077759,
-0.26256537437438965,
0.46794092655181885,
-0.5005189180374146,
0.5420282483100891,
-0.2548813819885254,
0.3347860872745514,
-0.3044341206550598,
-0.5074825882911682,
-0.7241322994232178,
-0.23881912231445312,
0.19769293069839478,
0.1371556967496872,
-0.026975644752383232,
0.3882018029689789,
0.08710258454084396,
-0.849174976348877,
-0.7521652579307556,
0.22063474357128143,
0.24560298025608063,
0.365335613489151,
0.23918595910072327,
-0.34212610125541687,
-0.48668015003204346,
-1.0972844362258911,
-0.18153026700019836,
-0.07454771548509598,
0.014515763148665428,
0.2218591421842575,
0.6977885961532593,
-0.06897980719804764,
1.0059027671813965,
-0.30449479818344116,
-0.05511721596121788,
-0.20605972409248352,
0.29020678997039795,
0.08948171138763428,
0.30741649866104126,
0.6184141039848328,
-0.2969931960105896,
-0.24616773426532745,
-0.20744498074054718,
-0.5891054272651672,
-0.23058269917964935,
0.4680742025375366,
-0.0009175845189020038,
0.2988456189632416,
0.6802623867988586,
-0.2367260754108429,
0.36248496174812317,
0.7871711254119873,
-0.28560999035835266,
0.7062312960624695,
-0.2987646758556366,
0.4947131872177124,
-0.535134494304657,
0.19149310886859894,
-0.24004454910755157,
-0.45252105593681335,
-0.4826660752296448,
0.34388303756713867,
0.02071937918663025,
-0.19057835638523102,
-0.477618008852005,
0.8867861032485962,
-0.31256693601608276,
-0.1379408985376358,
-0.2520769536495209,
0.42990556359291077,
0.13513435423374176,
-0.13546589016914368,
-0.20292341709136963,
0.8014901280403137,
0.6371235251426697,
-0.5958638191223145,
0.6030099391937256,
-0.09451182186603546,
-0.7222121953964233,
0.7273609042167664,
-0.8210283517837524,
0.5682841539382935,
-0.14941635727882385,
-0.10409408807754517,
-0.926864743232727,
0.24792805314064026,
0.3979025185108185,
-0.43949586153030396,
-0.019516214728355408,
0.06207495555281639,
-0.5356153249740601,
-0.2944263517856598,
-0.31948646903038025,
0.36345016956329346,
0.8037455677986145,
-0.5060833692550659,
0.45750099420547485,
0.21532928943634033,
0.1461990624666214,
-0.537540853023529,
-0.4968906342983246,
0.013820121996104717,
0.03055407665669918,
-0.8426867723464966,
-0.03789853677153587,
-0.4026050269603729,
-0.5650988221168518,
0.2638709545135498,
-0.23961150646209717,
-0.1518862247467041,
0.3777208924293518,
0.029763370752334595,
-0.11478018015623093,
-0.6738815307617188,
0.10560953617095947,
-0.2749696671962738,
-0.03849473595619202,
0.027069732546806335,
-0.2291502058506012,
0.23795047402381897,
-0.314273476600647,
-0.7290933132171631,
-0.22944222390651703,
0.40521085262298584,
0.5101483464241028,
-0.36449405550956726,
0.5610533356666565,
0.11921872943639755,
-0.5542536377906799,
-0.3830401301383972,
-0.43747803568840027,
0.0003842323203571141,
-0.42401182651519775,
0.39520084857940674,
-0.30149713158607483,
-0.9294955134391785,
0.21045397222042084,
-0.01093308161944151,
0.4108268618583679,
0.3437555432319641,
0.5940677523612976,
-0.25107648968696594,
1.1209006309509277,
0.6904116868972778,
0.22288964688777924,
0.12721730768680573,
0.16499090194702148,
0.4254208207130432,
-0.6485745310783386,
-0.047582242637872696,
-0.8779940009117126,
-0.34141579270362854,
-0.2216424196958542,
-0.6191133260726929,
0.23872002959251404,
0.34968867897987366,
-0.08986625075340271,
0.2600933313369751,
-0.21774961054325104,
0.69803386926651,
0.43355700373649597,
-0.13175255060195923,
0.5708034634590149,
-0.26790565252304077,
-0.046408168971538544,
0.21483591198921204,
-0.4654370844364166,
-1.2731187343597412,
1.1840765476226807,
0.5112307071685791,
0.6988004446029663,
0.17954100668430328,
0.6590701341629028,
0.47499793767929077,
0.6360136866569519,
-0.7150075435638428,
0.7452622652053833,
-0.22742094099521637,
-0.6762297749519348,
-0.5418395400047302,
-0.4916173815727234,
-1.1863043308258057,
0.3018456697463989,
0.03245997801423073,
-0.999726414680481,
-0.27457454800605774,
0.22008804976940155,
-0.4017787575721741,
0.25989484786987305,
-0.5941234230995178,
1.169795036315918,
-0.17177043855190277,
0.12668336927890778,
-0.3454561233520508,
-0.17330263555049896,
0.18624454736709595,
0.3325727880001068,
0.1992032527923584,
-0.3545387089252472,
-0.2031957507133484,
0.7060511708259583,
-0.38649290800094604,
0.7337915897369385,
0.05513421446084976,
-0.029656747356057167,
0.6061687469482422,
0.20425884425640106,
0.05232544243335724,
-0.18622778356075287,
-0.2527608275413513,
0.26008471846580505,
0.21667598187923431,
-0.31724813580513,
-0.7771660089492798,
0.7194678783416748,
-0.6556172966957092,
-0.7146148085594177,
-0.2891486883163452,
-0.4383617341518402,
-0.2446514070034027,
0.0872732624411583,
-0.1597488969564438,
0.2396310567855835,
-0.7922090291976929,
0.10188893973827362,
0.33820536732673645,
-0.15922147035598755,
0.09883379191160202,
0.6469789147377014,
-0.5315243005752563,
-0.29367974400520325,
0.7070837020874023,
0.09166140109300613,
0.4736950695514679,
-0.13802474737167358,
0.4488428235054016,
0.053852882236242294,
-0.5937746167182922,
-0.407857745885849,
0.16157212853431702,
-1.0116270780563354,
-0.011404149234294891,
-0.13970032334327698,
-0.2307283580303192,
-0.5375695824623108,
-0.059889085590839386,
-0.4287815988063812,
-0.358669638633728,
-0.03537271171808243,
-0.014480441808700562,
-0.06268750131130219,
1.1284037828445435,
-0.14801771938800812,
0.12661373615264893,
-0.7257549166679382,
0.21172304451465607,
0.2581687867641449,
0.7521722912788391,
-0.21120890974998474,
-0.6617986559867859,
-0.20588195323944092,
-0.0509260855615139,
-0.3697134554386139,
-0.9039668440818787,
-0.04544331878423691,
0.11062795668840408,
1.09255051612854,
0.1855323165655136,
-0.21496829390525818,
0.256926029920578,
-0.5374640822410583,
0.8448053598403931,
0.020638015121221542,
-1.038668155670166,
0.4349554777145386,
0.03815758600831032,
0.047818660736083984,
0.37208715081214905,
0.34772494435310364,
-0.697032630443573,
-0.325031042098999,
-0.5284116864204407,
-0.48421916365623474,
0.613652229309082,
0.20584416389465332,
0.18070240318775177,
-0.11327778548002243,
0.2060416340827942,
0.47062623500823975,
0.4920574724674225,
-0.6091859936714172,
-0.2363162636756897,
0.29042932391166687,
-0.28427577018737793,
-0.21443426609039307,
-0.36716359853744507,
-0.3384036719799042,
0.07853385806083679,
0.5041210055351257,
0.09630123525857925,
0.21706561744213104,
0.10191662609577179,
-0.16270388662815094,
-0.2267003059387207,
0.34174254536628723,
0.6430100202560425,
1.0692771673202515,
-0.1774204522371292,
0.18589994311332703,
0.09383060038089752,
0.13939286768436432,
0.03805868327617645,
-0.07475043833255768,
-0.226191908121109,
-0.010176783427596092,
0.3345123827457428,
0.7910324335098267,
-0.020381905138492584,
-0.9473772048950195,
0.40819454193115234,
0.18252119421958923,
-0.06388232111930847,
-0.27835944294929504,
0.23770883679389954,
-0.09138636291027069,
0.2784738540649414,
-0.06325051188468933,
0.20535017549991608,
0.11929360777139664,
-0.7341183423995972,
0.09466277807950974,
0.30118033289909363,
-0.41645050048828125,
-0.24981792271137238,
0.2797892987728119,
0.4067079424858093,
-0.6339250206947327,
0.37383508682250977,
-0.470318466424942,
-0.11245401203632355,
0.7846382260322571,
0.3327658474445343,
0.9589810967445374,
-0.5074246525764465,
0.1406296342611313,
0.3663285970687866,
0.7575757503509521,
-0.3031919598579407,
0.5494177937507629,
0.23092681169509888,
-0.5666327476501465,
-0.20957286655902863,
-0.41279879212379456,
-0.45403844118118286,
0.2739717364311218,
-0.4054676592350006,
0.6581997871398926,
-0.5333465933799744,
-0.17028485238552094,
-0.11370453238487244,
-0.47078296542167664,
-0.6892257928848267,
0.06464779376983643,
0.41553324460983276,
1.4864420890808105,
-0.7412101626396179,
0.5137657523155212,
0.893484890460968,
-0.40741997957229614,
-0.09122633188962936,
-0.3756961524486542,
0.10509645938873291,
-0.7399862408638,
0.5410673022270203,
-0.02084565907716751,
-0.2006605714559555,
-0.37306681275367737,
-0.5896576642990112,
-0.9823375940322876,
0.9766681790351868,
0.5408042669296265,
-0.379596471786499,
0.12826988101005554,
0.05333715304732323,
0.6324766874313354,
-0.8035752773284912,
0.6081892848014832,
0.7080549001693726,
0.5930886268615723,
-0.2954798936843872,
-1.2899384498596191,
-0.07616907358169556,
0.008794959634542465,
-0.12912170588970184,
0.1900257170200348,
-0.4623541533946991,
0.8265972137451172,
-0.30525466799736023,
-0.17877297103405,
0.6712068915367126,
0.5305909514427185,
0.11432589590549469,
0.5992252230644226,
0.5772596001625061,
0.33002299070358276,
0.7911781668663025,
-0.12286292016506195,
1.0664366483688354,
0.04654937610030174,
0.3322260081768036,
1.3086515665054321,
-0.4043254256248474,
0.9064009785652161,
0.3252716660499573,
-0.319667786359787,
0.23592719435691833,
0.3564075231552124,
0.028943214565515518,
0.2511724531650543,
0.5422041416168213,
0.17965461313724518,
-0.27767428755760193,
-0.011603317223489285,
-0.2048678994178772,
0.39197707176208496,
0.2208215594291687,
-0.639237642288208,
-0.5492998361587524,
-0.1211247369647026,
-0.02310212515294552,
0.3738691806793213,
-0.31774476170539856,
0.411292165517807,
0.1905563473701477,
-0.7422746419906616,
0.36474454402923584,
0.25695347785949707,
0.26460549235343933,
-0.6309313178062439,
-0.2023744434118271,
-0.20589835941791534,
0.040484219789505005,
-0.11528758704662323,
-0.887009859085083,
0.5794249773025513,
0.0962948203086853,
-0.06031141057610512,
-0.15490448474884033,
0.4710467755794525,
-0.41695764660835266,
-0.4315526485443115,
0.34402522444725037,
0.5179659724235535,
0.43972498178482056,
0.07188252359628677,
-0.5757452845573425,
0.35090121626853943,
-0.2741449177265167,
-0.4081135094165802,
0.19086244702339172,
0.30941975116729736,
0.05760341137647629,
0.664572536945343,
0.2139272391796112,
-0.0013163608964532614,
0.03325653821229935,
0.1474839597940445,
0.4537924528121948,
-0.4861629009246826,
-0.15732045471668243,
-0.7465575933456421,
0.7177922129631042,
-0.17084722220897675,
-0.4620307385921478,
0.668440580368042,
0.5012988448143005,
0.7818522453308105,
0.045722149312496185,
0.8711075186729431,
-0.11189065873622894,
0.6144166588783264,
-0.5679153203964233,
0.48375943303108215,
-0.7809925079345703,
0.21363011002540588,
0.11905007809400558,
-0.9629488587379456,
-0.06322460621595383,
0.7659158706665039,
-0.3403436243534088,
0.30554038286209106,
0.9468608498573303,
0.6400293707847595,
-0.019272267818450928,
-0.010963897220790386,
0.7034488916397095,
0.3934997022151947,
0.22822879254817963,
0.3955453038215637,
1.030165672302246,
-0.3595530688762665,
0.43627607822418213,
-0.12940004467964172,
-0.5150411128997803,
-0.22443430125713348,
-1.2266860008239746,
-0.9062419533729553,
-0.6522185206413269,
-0.6490335464477539,
-0.13996192812919617,
0.2171146720647812,
1.2394096851348877,
0.7108251452445984,
-0.7583373785018921,
-0.644436776638031,
0.3442329168319702,
0.17057868838310242,
-0.5057557821273804,
-0.10417104512453079,
0.010144603438675404,
-0.555431604385376,
-0.8963916301727295,
0.8528084754943848,
0.34361663460731506,
-0.1470063030719757,
-0.5695503354072571,
-0.1654944121837616,
0.20138829946517944,
0.4384506344795227,
0.481180876493454,
0.2359764724969864,
-0.8206143379211426,
-0.39477968215942383,
-0.048153460025787354,
-0.3235523998737335,
0.08714983612298965,
0.9793370962142944,
-0.466174453496933,
0.5436782240867615,
0.6126953959465027,
0.3980999290943146,
-0.15189401805400848,
-0.429267942905426,
0.731469452381134,
-0.37547722458839417,
-0.0877753272652626,
0.41271430253982544,
0.7450762391090393,
0.0315239243209362,
0.1786038875579834,
0.6340404152870178,
-0.010774624533951283,
-0.65030437707901,
-1.0431538820266724,
0.4200318455696106,
-0.6694134473800659,
-0.3240382969379425,
1.0316261053085327,
-0.4490986466407776,
-0.10482879728078842,
0.09117850661277771,
-0.24237191677093506,
-0.19144770503044128,
-0.25904709100723267,
0.5751334428787231,
0.8540441393852234,
-0.1279205083847046,
0.016317829489707947,
-0.793732225894928,
0.21382351219654083,
0.321333646774292,
-0.6232547760009766,
0.044319622218608856,
0.5062513947486877,
0.3721825182437897,
0.10044651478528976,
0.6606280207633972,
-0.29246291518211365,
0.28683990240097046,
-0.0956752598285675,
0.09242619574069977,
-0.22274306416511536,
-0.31066685914993286,
-0.40209898352622986,
0.10286419838666916,
0.6224245429039001,
-0.04164079204201698
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08434v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08434v1
|
TasTe: Teaching Large Language Models to Translate through Self-Reflection
| 2024-06-12T17:21:21 | 2024-06-12T17:21:21 |
Yutong Wang, Jiali Zeng, Xuebo Liu, Fandong Meng, Jie Zhou, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have exhibited remarkable performance in various
natural language processing tasks. Techniques like instruction tuning have
effectively enhanced the proficiency of LLMs in the downstream task of machine
translation. However, the existing approaches fail to yield satisfactory
translation outputs that match the quality of supervised neural machine
translation (NMT) systems. One plausible explanation for this discrepancy is
that the straightforward prompts employed in these methodologies are unable to
fully exploit the acquired instruction-following capabilities. To this end, we
propose the TasTe framework, which stands for translating through
self-reflection. The self-reflection process includes two stages of inference.
In the first stage, LLMs are instructed to generate preliminary translations
and conduct self-assessments on these translations simultaneously. In the
second stage, LLMs are tasked to refine these preliminary translations
according to the evaluation results. The evaluation results in four language
directions on the WMT22 benchmark reveal the effectiveness of our approach
compared to existing methods. Our work presents a promising approach to unleash
the potential of LLMs and enhance their capabilities in MT. The codes and
datasets are open-sourced at https://github.com/YutongWang1216/ReflectionLLMMT.
|
[
-0.15726158022880554,
-0.25274142622947693,
0.8722820281982422,
0.5235823392868042,
-0.2923058271408081,
0.011810055933892727,
-0.32599857449531555,
-0.028254548087716103,
0.18169452250003815,
0.9066035747528076,
-0.5448790192604065,
-0.4827713072299957,
-0.6257979869842529,
0.20935729146003723,
-0.5304701924324036,
0.8894323706626892,
-0.2778465151786804,
0.44750839471817017,
-0.09485451877117157,
0.003121668007224798,
-0.5435835123062134,
-0.2067306935787201,
-0.33900684118270874,
-0.47206634283065796,
0.6398109197616577,
0.4468010663986206,
0.07604806125164032,
0.6425501704216003,
0.054120562970638275,
0.29842445254325867,
0.15302720665931702,
0.23086558282375336,
-0.45878803730010986,
0.28721633553504944,
-0.29290691018104553,
-0.5945197343826294,
-0.12618938088417053,
0.22248995304107666,
0.41932207345962524,
0.5887963175773621,
-0.10318270325660706,
0.10412123054265976,
0.5039870142936707,
0.8544504046440125,
-0.36858490109443665,
0.1716509461402893,
-0.6778939366340637,
0.05147998780012131,
-0.11050039529800415,
-0.4458019435405731,
-0.8127647638320923,
-0.112601138651371,
-0.03227733448147774,
-0.30848830938339233,
-0.11763153970241547,
0.05270904675126076,
0.6379318237304688,
0.30917537212371826,
-0.6649556159973145,
-0.29754340648651123,
-0.4512992203235626,
0.8736112713813782,
-0.9718198180198669,
0.4725227653980255,
0.18808060884475708,
0.27746808528900146,
-0.22034472227096558,
-0.8370101451873779,
-0.3619808256626129,
-0.2041730284690857,
0.061188917607069016,
0.2310137003660202,
0.19464987516403198,
-0.13664229214191437,
-0.24838587641716003,
0.4839918613433838,
-0.4064376950263977,
0.15825209021568298,
-0.10680010169744492,
0.0016280197305604815,
0.4197065532207489,
0.14416123926639557,
0.21769502758979797,
-0.23756489157676697,
-0.5231027007102966,
-0.24326050281524658,
-0.697614312171936,
-0.319337397813797,
0.14183737337589264,
0.5110660791397095,
0.027767887338995934,
0.45392951369285583,
-0.3490462303161621,
0.5078667402267456,
0.06841186434030533,
-0.039946287870407104,
0.27194851636886597,
-0.12366677075624466,
-0.2057923972606659,
-0.04843629524111748,
1.006719946861267,
0.38491716980934143,
0.27135518193244934,
-0.29612353444099426,
-0.3746170103549957,
-0.2935628890991211,
0.3375568091869354,
-0.9713109135627747,
-0.20820604264736176,
-0.007535660173743963,
-0.44568198919296265,
-0.4254767894744873,
-0.12552745640277863,
-0.7306809425354004,
-0.2251044064760208,
-0.47339293360710144,
0.691428542137146,
-0.251446008682251,
-0.20440059900283813,
0.10122208297252655,
0.06339270621538162,
0.2617869973182678,
0.4415651857852936,
-1.1413042545318604,
0.33111804723739624,
0.6138454079627991,
0.8263118863105774,
-0.6251047253608704,
-0.4437806010246277,
-0.43217602372169495,
0.06554774940013885,
-0.620119571685791,
0.5139685273170471,
-0.27018657326698303,
-0.22366084158420563,
-0.08576960861682892,
0.01306155789643526,
0.07370264083147049,
-0.8390710353851318,
0.4072490334510803,
-0.6384109854698181,
0.27071595191955566,
-0.5843202471733093,
-0.5369836688041687,
-0.1654338836669922,
0.23424021899700165,
-0.16253556311130524,
0.9378998279571533,
0.22087375819683075,
-0.3601289987564087,
0.3101896047592163,
-0.43216753005981445,
-0.5090935230255127,
0.061204008758068085,
-0.19669358432292938,
0.055591028183698654,
0.4699016809463501,
0.35850226879119873,
0.5163314342498779,
-0.16352763772010803,
0.3774001896381378,
-0.11192751675844193,
-0.2354404181241989,
0.05489806458353996,
-0.6474065780639648,
0.4771483242511749,
0.30320873856544495,
-0.6132441759109497,
0.3439572751522064,
-0.43838703632354736,
0.13891752064228058,
0.23258215188980103,
-0.39203941822052,
-0.23136959969997406,
-0.032352108508348465,
-0.04315127804875374,
0.2694362998008728,
0.18312816321849823,
-0.36573097109794617,
0.28602370619773865,
-0.5797371864318848,
0.5303818583488464,
1.089383602142334,
-0.23558352887630463,
0.5446019172668457,
0.19263459742069244,
0.40667852759361267,
0.25633299350738525,
-0.03986344486474991,
-0.5447660088539124,
-0.23263533413410187,
-1.010653018951416,
0.1761898398399353,
0.3755515515804291,
0.2850022315979004,
-1.0417588949203491,
0.14525258541107178,
-0.2415568232536316,
-0.37069830298423767,
-0.7247863411903381,
0.5705257654190063,
0.5250120162963867,
0.550264298915863,
0.6652053594589233,
-0.4381798803806305,
-0.3163875639438629,
-0.9228405356407166,
-0.4397358298301697,
0.1397046595811844,
-0.13629324734210968,
0.1418859213590622,
0.4318397343158722,
-0.08224815875291824,
0.5882682800292969,
-0.3552235960960388,
-0.4850592315196991,
-0.19629156589508057,
0.03291255980730057,
0.2654142379760742,
0.4752315580844879,
0.38484886288642883,
-0.5170458555221558,
-0.7446660995483398,
0.15404854714870453,
-0.8349852561950684,
-0.19320105016231537,
0.1896209716796875,
-0.20706087350845337,
0.18343688547611237,
0.4688945412635803,
-0.0774739608168602,
0.06141125038266182,
0.8325915932655334,
-0.20364290475845337,
0.5998568534851074,
-0.053571246564388275,
0.3024789094924927,
-0.9828872680664062,
-0.2588854432106018,
-0.07333339005708694,
-0.30626559257507324,
-0.407739520072937,
0.1819092333316803,
0.17344240844249725,
0.20251061022281647,
-0.5983864068984985,
0.8322350382804871,
-0.6631500720977783,
-0.06581839919090271,
-0.6160788536071777,
-0.05690470337867737,
0.38016772270202637,
0.4195203185081482,
-0.11017303913831711,
0.9996601343154907,
0.27757179737091064,
-0.7643772959709167,
0.25449684262275696,
0.0931330993771553,
-0.444118469953537,
0.6298620700836182,
-0.4865696132183075,
0.23021380603313446,
0.20094327628612518,
0.10601820796728134,
-0.9694977402687073,
-0.19461379945278168,
0.4228426516056061,
-0.3943890631198883,
0.4987514317035675,
-0.3161483705043793,
-0.6366068124771118,
-0.24685777723789215,
0.050821010023355484,
0.08571842312812805,
0.45395627617836,
-0.9593513607978821,
0.7657510638237,
0.011361555196344852,
0.06345190107822418,
-0.4560201168060303,
-0.9143694043159485,
0.4233826994895935,
-0.20273342728614807,
-0.4116828143596649,
0.24135561287403107,
-0.1251245141029358,
0.12479130178689957,
-0.06404662877321243,
-0.11949154734611511,
0.26441577076911926,
0.08304698020219803,
0.05827607586979866,
-0.16957196593284607,
-0.33932605385780334,
-0.12514039874076843,
0.3189929127693176,
-0.061937324702739716,
0.3034432828426361,
-0.8182221055030823,
0.674872875213623,
-0.23451945185661316,
-0.3442966043949127,
-0.4333001673221588,
0.09856681525707245,
0.39729613065719604,
-0.3978084623813629,
0.5937539935112,
0.520268440246582,
0.07524119317531586,
-0.4975040555000305,
-0.5795741677284241,
-0.46335551142692566,
-0.5898162722587585,
0.2620776891708374,
-0.7278448939323425,
-0.8280802965164185,
0.4200468361377716,
-0.22672976553440094,
-0.12516605854034424,
0.33582836389541626,
0.5332647562026978,
-0.2517257630825043,
1.169022798538208,
0.3744209110736847,
0.11652804911136627,
0.33573275804519653,
-0.13545188307762146,
-0.05111280083656311,
-1.1704925298690796,
-0.19599291682243347,
-0.29774361848831177,
-0.2849905788898468,
-0.4709276258945465,
-0.4033122658729553,
0.23904114961624146,
-0.250357985496521,
0.020659875124692917,
0.32903560996055603,
-0.44678282737731934,
0.46851298213005066,
0.6542130708694458,
0.08572079241275787,
0.3113611340522766,
0.05500989407300949,
-0.6274018883705139,
-0.5189546346664429,
-0.4301358163356781,
-0.5424219965934753,
0.9376036524772644,
0.3356846570968628,
0.7404822707176208,
-0.029455211013555527,
0.8801256418228149,
0.10273072123527527,
0.5491397976875305,
-0.8899257183074951,
0.6556470394134521,
-0.2894783914089203,
-0.5544102787971497,
-0.16033735871315002,
-0.7094685435295105,
-0.6792835593223572,
0.616433322429657,
0.20789910852909088,
-0.42357051372528076,
-0.13229675590991974,
0.15871202945709229,
0.2958245277404785,
0.3159131109714508,
-0.8128184676170349,
1.1434634923934937,
-0.7174572348594666,
-0.6970590949058533,
0.056621748954057693,
-0.4632328152656555,
0.41957128047943115,
-0.027008449658751488,
0.12624862790107727,
-0.0611061155796051,
0.05566665902733803,
0.6655135154724121,
-0.11084706336259842,
0.9637308120727539,
-0.3859677314758301,
-0.5321806073188782,
0.07107274979352951,
0.5855847001075745,
0.2629558742046356,
-0.17761999368667603,
-0.20726552605628967,
0.03321857750415802,
0.03532681241631508,
-0.30069708824157715,
-0.9237922430038452,
0.9203421473503113,
-0.4047444462776184,
-0.7340729236602783,
-0.3395797312259674,
-0.26677241921424866,
-0.3371981382369995,
0.6511754989624023,
0.08650047332048416,
0.17855992913246155,
-0.22231975197792053,
-0.04665778949856758,
0.528629720211029,
-0.14669808745384216,
0.1792650669813156,
0.6184183359146118,
-0.8564332723617554,
-0.4614942669868469,
1.2074542045593262,
0.10178886353969574,
0.39207378029823303,
0.2893156409263611,
0.4595146179199219,
-0.46314623951911926,
-0.691752552986145,
-0.8121119737625122,
0.27064424753189087,
-0.8498408794403076,
-0.17758439481258392,
-0.4698196351528168,
0.06993061304092407,
-0.45308804512023926,
0.12331977486610413,
-0.7375388741493225,
0.02349521592259407,
-0.379866361618042,
0.007822408340871334,
-0.010510125197470188,
0.9949837327003479,
0.10575947910547256,
0.43458491563796997,
-0.6812068819999695,
0.04863351210951805,
0.15773794054985046,
0.519787609577179,
0.18247005343437195,
-0.9106799960136414,
-0.3151656687259674,
0.054739780724048615,
-0.4077054560184479,
-0.8602322340011597,
0.7300626635551453,
0.028831535950303078,
0.40606847405433655,
0.4758665859699249,
-0.06156209483742714,
0.5502303838729858,
-0.8719287514686584,
0.6209455132484436,
0.010705272667109966,
-1.0769941806793213,
0.5833734273910522,
-0.27943435311317444,
0.30950626730918884,
0.8458096981048584,
0.39659130573272705,
-0.6517600417137146,
-0.26964259147644043,
-0.25844821333885193,
-0.8397467136383057,
0.4874218702316284,
-0.22697784006595612,
0.49982813000679016,
-0.2085992991924286,
0.4089105427265167,
0.22673815488815308,
0.37229692935943604,
-0.7436091899871826,
-0.2149208039045334,
-0.34450945258140564,
-0.24480441212654114,
-0.27397865056991577,
-0.261916846036911,
-0.02360733039677143,
-0.2745153307914734,
0.7165296673774719,
-0.3684982359409332,
0.034813351929187775,
0.05612879619002342,
-0.06446192413568497,
0.07125738263130188,
0.2738562226295471,
0.47935792803764343,
0.5208949446678162,
-0.05472678691148758,
0.5792382955551147,
0.05703972280025482,
-0.0042027258314192295,
0.2637956738471985,
-0.4565385580062866,
-0.3084198534488678,
-0.25198110938072205,
0.14933419227600098,
0.7816370129585266,
0.4627774655818939,
-0.349598228931427,
0.4917716085910797,
-0.004551749676465988,
-0.11670299619436264,
-0.07578426599502563,
0.11520770192146301,
0.40132609009742737,
-0.006271555088460445,
0.2813829779624939,
-0.2177562266588211,
0.3609992265701294,
-0.6571727991104126,
0.27902671694755554,
0.2609468698501587,
-0.7889128923416138,
-0.34552377462387085,
0.7610179781913757,
0.20265857875347137,
-0.08429974317550659,
0.5617688298225403,
-0.32981014251708984,
-0.7071005702018738,
0.16502916812896729,
0.8460238575935364,
0.8519768714904785,
-0.4691711664199829,
0.19186878204345703,
0.3224382996559143,
0.2763109505176544,
-0.3035030663013458,
-0.026767781004309654,
-0.007443401962518692,
-0.5740199089050293,
-0.6628133654594421,
-0.833620548248291,
-0.2573978304862976,
-0.021706782281398773,
-0.7089781761169434,
0.1304692178964615,
-0.0987110361456871,
0.131166473031044,
-0.32955753803253174,
-0.24224473536014557,
-0.4564623534679413,
0.21567869186401367,
-0.03474711254239082,
0.8296059370040894,
-0.9194186329841614,
0.7623851299285889,
0.39233750104904175,
-0.27722668647766113,
-0.7739743590354919,
0.04364466667175293,
-0.04826148599386215,
-0.9173546433448792,
0.7952359318733215,
0.29082953929901123,
-0.16877931356430054,
0.3104933202266693,
-0.6481407284736633,
-0.6381286382675171,
0.6387346386909485,
0.42638999223709106,
-0.4298618733882904,
-0.039846207946538925,
0.16144424676895142,
0.498186856508255,
-0.3937366306781769,
0.21078582108020782,
0.513632595539093,
0.6985711455345154,
0.24144360423088074,
-0.7971189618110657,
0.16356219351291656,
-0.0672510489821434,
0.02116958610713482,
-0.07774653285741806,
-0.5676250457763672,
0.41567397117614746,
-0.17606332898139954,
-0.13033823668956757,
-0.0035957323852926493,
1.0097323656082153,
0.05016016587615013,
0.2048705369234085,
0.27700167894363403,
0.5058562755584717,
0.28674885630607605,
-0.09586741775274277,
0.9066830277442932,
0.018986238166689873,
0.20003929734230042,
1.3633475303649902,
-0.3881683647632599,
1.1192735433578491,
0.7373033165931702,
-0.06509537249803543,
0.4135838449001312,
0.5876363515853882,
-0.06432726234197617,
0.6508373022079468,
0.4175243377685547,
0.0715818852186203,
-0.16116154193878174,
-0.12271322309970856,
-0.2957022190093994,
0.662925660610199,
0.29268455505371094,
-0.6506991982460022,
-0.10442101955413818,
0.16673725843429565,
0.11170553416013718,
0.43936991691589355,
-0.038323774933815,
0.7185954451560974,
0.4224431812763214,
-0.8740883469581604,
0.4909147322177887,
0.1867300122976303,
0.7746261954307556,
-0.3721150755882263,
-0.2104487121105194,
-0.3737502694129944,
0.040677811950445175,
-0.1257455050945282,
-0.863218367099762,
0.11481554806232452,
-0.21025481820106506,
0.07384268194437027,
-0.7015820741653442,
0.34984254837036133,
-0.44520390033721924,
-0.36649665236473083,
0.7157158255577087,
0.5263146162033081,
0.29810842871665955,
-0.31306666135787964,
-0.5286636352539062,
0.26830437779426575,
0.07678989320993423,
-0.4745531976222992,
0.4044789671897888,
0.5848103761672974,
0.23836906254291534,
0.7716575264930725,
0.4929156005382538,
0.14760272204875946,
0.2000470757484436,
0.2410612553358078,
0.770564615726471,
-0.5088419914245605,
-0.2037157267332077,
-0.9875792264938354,
0.3742144703865051,
0.2693878710269928,
-0.18969964981079102,
1.0004533529281616,
0.7148903012275696,
0.9748530387878418,
-0.29001837968826294,
0.5719350576400757,
0.26137179136276245,
0.37205347418785095,
-0.8548467755317688,
0.8287267088890076,
-0.8490509986877441,
0.2763007581233978,
-0.20979849994182587,
-1.0202090740203857,
-0.1576234996318817,
0.5162434577941895,
-0.4142504036426544,
0.3858826756477356,
0.700356125831604,
0.6083651781082153,
-0.22252482175827026,
-0.3248118758201599,
0.639788806438446,
0.44769343733787537,
0.4820619821548462,
0.27937862277030945,
0.902247428894043,
-0.5189438462257385,
0.3380938768386841,
-0.21200621128082275,
-0.11427635699510574,
-0.2646281123161316,
-0.8945430517196655,
-0.8220744132995605,
-0.644117534160614,
-0.07421267777681351,
-0.4736204743385315,
0.04808041825890541,
0.7049137353897095,
0.8673973679542542,
-0.7611801624298096,
-0.35274478793144226,
-0.02797565422952175,
-0.12164507061243057,
-0.15305399894714355,
-0.23147578537464142,
0.1644071489572525,
-0.5618566870689392,
-0.856738805770874,
0.9497390985488892,
0.33504509925842285,
-0.04208853095769882,
-0.7130484580993652,
-0.24477365612983704,
0.07050331681966782,
-0.025683337822556496,
0.6834034323692322,
0.06078101694583893,
-0.8670181035995483,
-0.2195083051919937,
0.21798114478588104,
-0.18233729898929596,
0.3425556719303131,
0.4941160976886749,
-0.563041090965271,
0.6148686408996582,
0.20922847092151642,
0.7552990317344666,
0.8013797998428345,
-0.13919730484485626,
0.6614125967025757,
-0.581889808177948,
-0.34576883912086487,
0.11455955356359482,
0.2507537305355072,
0.47949838638305664,
-0.05918319523334503,
0.41567641496658325,
0.01922471635043621,
-0.5170410871505737,
-0.7703086137771606,
0.28544822335243225,
-0.8740191459655762,
-0.19231358170509338,
1.1154705286026,
-0.1329105645418167,
-0.48237526416778564,
0.3404555022716522,
-0.13354939222335815,
0.13346505165100098,
-0.23557882010936737,
0.723803699016571,
0.65831059217453,
0.0711524486541748,
-0.3166466951370239,
-0.8565465211868286,
0.2300512045621872,
0.6021203398704529,
-0.7329878807067871,
0.09086084365844727,
0.006685873959213495,
0.6230775713920593,
-0.05098409205675125,
0.6465944051742554,
-0.2955915033817291,
-0.2099841684103012,
-0.1823766529560089,
0.28914979100227356,
-0.05457410216331482,
-0.5891907215118408,
-0.4116089940071106,
-0.1443478912115097,
0.4982687830924988,
0.011037497781217098
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08426v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08426v2
|
Next-Generation Database Interfaces: A Survey of LLM-based Text-to-SQL
| 2024-06-12T17:13:17 | 2024-06-27T13:51:30 |
Zijin Hong, Zheng Yuan, Qinggang Zhang, Hao Chen, Junnan Dong, Feiran Huang, Xiao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.DB
|
Generating accurate SQL according to natural language questions (text-to-SQL)
is a long-standing challenge due to the complexities involved in user question
understanding, database schema comprehension, and SQL generation. Conventional
text-to-SQL systems, comprising human engineering and deep neural networks,
have made substantial progress. Subsequently, pre-trained language models
(PLMs) have been developed and utilized for text-to-SQL tasks, achieving
promising performance. As modern databases become more complex, the
corresponding user questions also grow more challenging, leading PLMs with
limited comprehension capabilities to produce incorrect SQL. This necessitates
more sophisticated and tailored optimization methods for PLMs, which, in turn,
restricts the applications of PLM-based systems. Most recently, large language
models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant capabilities in natural language
understanding as the model scale remains increasing. Therefore, integrating the
LLM-based implementation can bring unique opportunities, improvements, and
solutions to text-to-SQL research. In this survey, we present a comprehensive
review of LLM-based text-to-SQL. Specifically, we propose a brief overview of
the technical challenges and the evolutionary process of text-to-SQL. Then, we
provide a detailed introduction to the datasets and metrics designed to
evaluate text-to-SQL systems. After that, we present a systematic analysis of
recent advances in LLM-based text-to-SQL. Finally, we discuss the remaining
challenges in this field and propose expectations for future research
directions.
|
[
-0.5763753056526184,
-0.9532355070114136,
0.8760377168655396,
0.056232888251543045,
-0.09255650639533997,
0.18589642643928528,
-0.1150570809841156,
-0.5148319005966187,
-0.013304230757057667,
0.8546326756477356,
-0.9186776280403137,
-0.7009801268577576,
-0.15418721735477448,
0.515770673751831,
-0.5833346843719482,
0.7232691645622253,
0.03042835183441639,
-0.03300531953573227,
-0.7703741788864136,
0.06569728255271912,
-0.4382062256336212,
-0.8761584758758545,
-0.4390546679496765,
-0.20718367397785187,
0.18925362825393677,
0.4463057219982147,
0.40543630719184875,
0.19921739399433136,
0.4682115614414215,
0.22306965291500092,
-0.1814173012971878,
0.343716561794281,
-0.38531890511512756,
0.13754576444625854,
-0.13290677964687347,
-0.35899561643600464,
-0.4469892382621765,
-0.207537442445755,
0.5931913256645203,
0.9194619059562683,
-0.11261267960071564,
0.03489901125431061,
-0.1284695863723755,
0.9232792854309082,
-0.30070269107818604,
-0.14359036087989807,
-0.8651635646820068,
0.09992435574531555,
-0.3099760115146637,
-0.43141910433769226,
-0.5381895899772644,
-0.5870358347892761,
0.26624739170074463,
-0.3690117299556732,
0.08754292130470276,
0.2082233428955078,
0.5923931002616882,
-0.04153113812208176,
-0.6808338761329651,
-0.49261125922203064,
-0.5716331005096436,
0.7480217814445496,
-0.8233526945114136,
0.5938980579376221,
-0.10659773647785187,
0.3072572946548462,
-0.5892557501792908,
-0.6925505995750427,
-0.6012099385261536,
-0.35881009697914124,
-0.018022850155830383,
-0.09202534705400467,
0.33795198798179626,
-0.027694910764694214,
-0.09966866672039032,
0.39290139079093933,
-0.553013801574707,
0.37238380312919617,
0.1136706992983818,
0.13497604429721832,
0.6708923578262329,
0.43007633090019226,
0.24814186990261078,
-0.27235761284828186,
-0.35531580448150635,
0.48767173290252686,
-1.0612294673919678,
-0.38622477650642395,
0.2844465374946594,
0.3426995873451233,
0.14560630917549133,
0.7583270072937012,
-0.36240243911743164,
1.05235755443573,
-0.1212678998708725,
0.18565763533115387,
0.03860637545585632,
-0.6432519555091858,
-0.04737921059131622,
-0.19832316040992737,
0.9375134706497192,
0.4613416790962219,
0.31298860907554626,
-0.2643069326877594,
-0.263654500246048,
-0.4600410461425781,
-0.027381980791687965,
-0.5391098856925964,
0.04544512927532196,
0.39446109533309937,
-0.4804788827896118,
-0.39682960510253906,
-0.41937875747680664,
-0.8838194012641907,
-0.7065978646278381,
-0.48124995827674866,
0.2668531537055969,
-0.31334829330444336,
-0.39935600757598877,
-0.1841610074043274,
0.14166127145290375,
0.5096295475959778,
0.38331979513168335,
-0.903879702091217,
0.4874085783958435,
0.6548582315444946,
0.7356167435646057,
-0.6016358137130737,
0.08069044351577759,
-0.05807247385382652,
0.20156681537628174,
-0.21997907757759094,
1.0131405591964722,
-0.26458436250686646,
-0.655915379524231,
0.22145898640155792,
-0.14673802256584167,
0.07941558212041855,
-0.8469470143318176,
0.28852972388267517,
-0.5166349411010742,
0.5239199995994568,
-0.3234398066997528,
-0.8281068801879883,
0.20639055967330933,
0.3348962366580963,
-0.36565732955932617,
0.9767634868621826,
0.029476622119545937,
-0.5183241963386536,
0.306659460067749,
-0.6039538383483887,
-0.4804248809814453,
0.13685214519500732,
-0.33761167526245117,
-0.5411612391471863,
0.19952571392059326,
0.15183991193771362,
0.3966377079486847,
-0.7795451283454895,
0.2831212282180786,
-0.2754904627799988,
-0.3442506194114685,
0.36831432580947876,
-0.16477450728416443,
0.7813078761100769,
0.23718805611133575,
-0.02266846038401127,
-0.11298471689224243,
-0.9400327801704407,
0.2034153789281845,
0.1555420607328415,
-0.43456846475601196,
-0.015303969383239746,
0.33077818155288696,
-0.028484582901000977,
0.07825259119272232,
0.417239248752594,
-0.47317811846733093,
0.019613660871982574,
-0.5063381791114807,
0.5282937288284302,
0.49654895067214966,
0.2019294649362564,
0.44973689317703247,
0.017914438620209694,
0.39279064536094666,
-0.13150353729724884,
0.19673389196395874,
-0.25314241647720337,
-0.4629666805267334,
-0.5918862819671631,
0.314414918422699,
0.1037745475769043,
0.7362133860588074,
-0.706039547920227,
0.5700622797012329,
-0.24328520894050598,
-0.3411579132080078,
-0.046546414494514465,
0.13410426676273346,
-0.032655779272317886,
0.548595666885376,
0.3704303503036499,
-0.16345533728599548,
-0.678231954574585,
-0.8066866993904114,
-0.5037976503372192,
-0.30956146121025085,
-0.0334467776119709,
0.5969467759132385,
0.2233027070760727,
0.10534543544054031,
1.1914818286895752,
-0.28015783429145813,
-0.19053103029727936,
-0.31070923805236816,
-0.05432882532477379,
0.19292695820331573,
0.36467334628105164,
0.2416795939207077,
-0.5798139572143555,
-0.4343106746673584,
0.3270549178123474,
-0.8255200386047363,
-0.14583632349967957,
-0.12610651552677155,
0.028693661093711853,
0.6024127006530762,
0.6370089650154114,
-0.6130825877189636,
-0.1536915898323059,
0.339437872171402,
-0.09913504868745804,
0.5274312496185303,
-0.025266138836741447,
0.022913066670298576,
-1.1146069765090942,
0.00643473444506526,
0.02122313715517521,
0.0513569675385952,
-0.7502556443214417,
-0.19315575063228607,
0.08813702315092087,
-0.2587950825691223,
-0.4174351096153259,
0.531880259513855,
-0.8187679052352905,
-0.33991143107414246,
0.02775643579661846,
0.1079220399260521,
-0.1526545137166977,
0.16312997043132782,
0.13778375089168549,
0.82843017578125,
0.18485720455646515,
-0.7424224019050598,
0.49155017733573914,
0.5057003498077393,
-0.33459678292274475,
0.7724326252937317,
-0.47798067331314087,
0.24861301481723785,
-0.08822987973690033,
0.1495434194803238,
-0.9448807835578918,
-0.18822810053825378,
-0.04216901212930679,
-0.5250306725502014,
0.2424653172492981,
-0.06732398271560669,
-0.48484447598457336,
-0.48282837867736816,
-0.31959980726242065,
0.12222657352685928,
0.5787488222122192,
-0.5608133673667908,
0.729805052280426,
0.20928668975830078,
-0.43018922209739685,
-0.47425782680511475,
-0.9088623523712158,
0.6141592860221863,
-0.009311992675065994,
-0.6925058960914612,
0.36348995566368103,
0.09851176291704178,
-0.21971437335014343,
-0.20745757222175598,
0.15163204073905945,
-0.30458056926727295,
-0.07061056047677994,
-0.27507543563842773,
0.39952677488327026,
-0.25171852111816406,
0.1680886149406433,
0.21837453544139862,
0.12767237424850464,
0.3507576882839203,
-0.3581393361091614,
0.4210778772830963,
0.23509223759174347,
-0.2406851351261139,
-0.3075386881828308,
0.5195884704589844,
0.1874963492155075,
-0.3023931086063385,
0.7301914691925049,
0.22308526933193207,
-0.06457659602165222,
-0.183099627494812,
-0.8202774524688721,
-0.12537449598312378,
-0.4438929259777069,
0.6731954216957092,
-0.36862727999687195,
-1.0272282361984253,
0.28865504264831543,
-0.4624326825141907,
0.2592564523220062,
0.41393303871154785,
0.49933573603630066,
-0.37272268533706665,
0.894815981388092,
0.6637848615646362,
0.40957242250442505,
0.37400612235069275,
0.12353911995887756,
0.34768766164779663,
-0.6054365634918213,
-0.6174817681312561,
-0.7385739684104919,
0.17074169218540192,
-0.48609551787376404,
-0.18582874536514282,
0.1917204111814499,
-0.14859311282634735,
-0.1845487803220749,
0.15359866619110107,
-0.42853280901908875,
0.4172118902206421,
-0.038552239537239075,
-0.1298557072877884,
0.6389809846878052,
0.13147804141044617,
0.220207080245018,
-0.04355635866522789,
-0.515652596950531,
-0.46718379855155945,
1.1944013833999634,
0.19051559269428253,
0.728873074054718,
0.11857352405786514,
0.7656902074813843,
0.09107900410890579,
0.3766269087791443,
-0.5300323367118835,
0.8659253716468811,
-0.3157944083213806,
-0.6619695425033569,
-0.2582668662071228,
-0.6659174561500549,
-0.614790678024292,
-0.1030394658446312,
-0.3152318000793457,
-0.5714898705482483,
0.1688595563173294,
0.16240747272968292,
-0.09407804906368256,
0.20813345909118652,
-0.9475498795509338,
0.6939365863800049,
-0.47030964493751526,
-0.4695347249507904,
0.23411747813224792,
-0.6473473310470581,
0.5969737768173218,
-0.196555957198143,
0.13722072541713715,
-0.04315485432744026,
-0.4307079315185547,
0.46249380707740784,
-0.4524824023246765,
0.57013338804245,
-0.23547370731830597,
-0.3966050446033478,
0.42269816994667053,
-0.19303260743618011,
0.588184654712677,
-0.03623157739639282,
-0.3572835326194763,
-0.0036665971856564283,
-0.07243524491786957,
-0.22938375174999237,
-0.4695761501789093,
0.7610174417495728,
-0.2672768235206604,
-0.7114642858505249,
-0.10763023793697357,
-0.41591784358024597,
-0.7102884650230408,
0.10868897289037704,
0.18895737826824188,
0.34346404671669006,
-0.3578929007053375,
0.0717083215713501,
0.934434175491333,
-0.7006233930587769,
0.36194315552711487,
0.42227041721343994,
-0.5350883603096008,
-0.2276981621980667,
0.9426226019859314,
-0.025834424421191216,
0.4154035151004791,
0.681247889995575,
-0.3336208164691925,
-0.8842935562133789,
-1.0675967931747437,
-0.5046025514602661,
0.20699749886989594,
-0.3974493443965912,
-0.1137290820479393,
-0.6699936389923096,
-0.1866794228553772,
-0.3640143573284149,
0.053026020526885986,
-0.11600471287965775,
-0.31884515285491943,
-0.47756069898605347,
0.137274369597435,
0.374074250459671,
0.7820409536361694,
0.579744279384613,
0.270395427942276,
-0.8356054425239563,
0.14304868876934052,
0.14287428557872772,
0.6424256563186646,
-0.20703820884227753,
-0.32317113876342773,
-0.010186024941504002,
-0.3331816792488098,
-0.03450626879930496,
-0.979136049747467,
0.1277591437101364,
0.33471739292144775,
0.367118239402771,
-0.17376144230365753,
-0.17965276539325714,
0.3080619275569916,
-0.5636432766914368,
0.9185162782669067,
0.24898599088191986,
-0.7408992648124695,
0.5139682292938232,
-0.40283122658729553,
0.09507843106985092,
0.5934315919876099,
0.2711864709854126,
-0.39093977212905884,
-0.10606000572443008,
-0.1458989828824997,
-0.8436111807823181,
0.5267418622970581,
0.0857468843460083,
0.25160497426986694,
0.027258872985839844,
0.6824284195899963,
0.19084875285625458,
0.34448716044425964,
-0.7258439660072327,
-0.16952712833881378,
0.13464392721652985,
-0.4124824106693268,
0.09835980832576752,
-0.32095760107040405,
0.36978691816329956,
-0.06178044155240059,
0.4720717966556549,
-0.20345813035964966,
0.2361317127943039,
-0.043820567429065704,
-0.18328265845775604,
0.2179766595363617,
0.4953264892101288,
0.33969026803970337,
0.6877362132072449,
-0.27738386392593384,
-0.27795884013175964,
0.4317443072795868,
-0.2733575701713562,
0.12151799350976944,
0.20934760570526123,
-0.28610000014305115,
0.0497400239109993,
0.017433393746614456,
0.6048429608345032,
-0.2571256756782532,
-0.8420702219009399,
0.43674203753471375,
-0.10912518203258514,
-0.3890911042690277,
-0.3610415756702423,
-0.13042262196540833,
0.4129156172275543,
-0.22556550800800323,
0.3669038414955139,
-0.19329385459423065,
0.16867931187152863,
-0.5680555701255798,
0.016757547855377197,
0.7400190830230713,
-0.2401677519083023,
0.034959662705659866,
0.6845685243606567,
0.45707055926322937,
-0.4067244231700897,
0.5671286582946777,
0.14500662684440613,
-0.048484716564416885,
0.4123852849006653,
0.4279443621635437,
0.6253508925437927,
-0.28674232959747314,
-0.00002622313695610501,
0.2312093824148178,
0.262215256690979,
0.10388689488172531,
0.6569150686264038,
0.049290742725133896,
-0.4605347216129303,
-0.5770010352134705,
-0.5407225489616394,
-0.5116438269615173,
0.09628600627183914,
-0.16771098971366882,
0.42523816227912903,
-0.41445356607437134,
-0.08733265101909637,
-0.21333648264408112,
-0.07223290205001831,
-0.190237894654274,
0.27294328808784485,
-0.07977898418903351,
1.1574136018753052,
-0.5160008668899536,
0.6762532591819763,
0.7298139333724976,
-0.2838291525840759,
-0.2475440353155136,
-0.36104637384414673,
-0.20882892608642578,
-0.5172998309135437,
0.24772153794765472,
-0.09821940958499908,
0.17867784202098846,
0.24206110835075378,
-0.4995129704475403,
-0.5903265476226807,
0.9741731882095337,
0.37904608249664307,
-0.78113853931427,
-0.27337148785591125,
0.7491781711578369,
0.5417760610580444,
-0.282969206571579,
0.1998405009508133,
0.8292551040649414,
0.43663373589515686,
-0.08439894765615463,
-0.539287805557251,
-0.14749322831630707,
-0.13120609521865845,
0.3824026882648468,
0.5109175443649292,
-0.33111387491226196,
0.7139676213264465,
-0.12017803639173508,
-0.03717748820781708,
0.397372305393219,
0.8082183003425598,
0.3291964828968048,
0.2741895914077759,
0.4400536119937897,
0.3094549775123596,
0.45824116468429565,
-0.23413565754890442,
1.041256070137024,
-0.15427806973457336,
0.0665259063243866,
1.13139009475708,
-0.5253006815910339,
0.8302469253540039,
0.8078374862670898,
-0.4785161018371582,
0.48057156801223755,
0.6747050881385803,
0.04018412157893181,
0.1781526356935501,
0.40524497628211975,
-0.5236966013908386,
-0.08510978519916534,
-0.1668352484703064,
-0.48867249488830566,
-0.15433748066425323,
0.5529219508171082,
-0.2636464834213257,
-0.14731687307357788,
-0.22429484128952026,
-0.4124941825866699,
0.4113420248031616,
-0.09581881761550903,
1.0114388465881348,
0.09599427133798599,
-0.4752873182296753,
0.36056283116340637,
-0.06190355122089386,
0.8452100157737732,
-0.5768346190452576,
-0.08022130280733109,
-0.3814966082572937,
-0.15837174654006958,
-0.4096882939338684,
-0.9471744298934937,
0.18173164129257202,
0.14762108027935028,
0.0534449964761734,
-0.08963289856910706,
0.8270492553710938,
-0.4641434848308563,
-0.26772090792655945,
-0.0938011109828949,
0.7985430359840393,
0.11753890663385391,
-0.04089190810918808,
-0.4781675636768341,
0.10032056272029877,
0.06587293744087219,
-0.25795337557792664,
0.38258281350135803,
0.5236383080482483,
0.09675249457359314,
0.6751096844673157,
0.5200988054275513,
0.05528130754828453,
0.40733152627944946,
0.1366317868232727,
0.5125744342803955,
-0.7196900248527527,
-0.2399633526802063,
-0.6566275358200073,
0.34763914346694946,
-0.23007985949516296,
-0.2063484489917755,
0.4739048182964325,
0.6884438991546631,
0.40478479862213135,
-0.08009596914052963,
0.8325148820877075,
-0.033228375017642975,
0.8988587260246277,
-0.5976203083992004,
0.5660133957862854,
-0.7399341464042664,
0.5900964736938477,
-0.1800907403230667,
-1.055525302886963,
-0.20235587656497955,
-0.10064464807510376,
-0.13538065552711487,
0.2620915174484253,
0.7558667659759521,
0.7787436246871948,
0.33055582642555237,
0.2127096801996231,
0.033977389335632324,
0.1440456211566925,
0.3869687020778656,
0.5840409398078918,
1.0210950374603271,
-0.30322524905204773,
0.7541801929473877,
0.15838193893432617,
0.062459394335746765,
-0.10145661979913712,
-0.8786446452140808,
-0.6795337796211243,
-0.5729990005493164,
-0.1389719843864441,
-0.18966442346572876,
0.2643660008907318,
0.6796374320983887,
0.2548679709434509,
-0.8723738789558411,
-0.4924778938293457,
-0.7011107206344604,
0.1002383828163147,
0.2814382314682007,
-0.22080416977405548,
0.1829564869403839,
-0.5188936591148376,
-0.7148282527923584,
0.29757559299468994,
0.4321150779724121,
0.15423646569252014,
-0.30651795864105225,
-0.04730868712067604,
-0.3618875741958618,
0.042471978813409805,
0.7855217456817627,
0.3268531560897827,
-0.4677353799343109,
0.13004866242408752,
0.11459404230117798,
-0.21483762562274933,
0.08386679738759995,
0.7429994344711304,
-0.8602334260940552,
0.02317195199429989,
0.46946442127227783,
1.0768373012542725,
0.3744039535522461,
-0.20179906487464905,
0.8809637427330017,
-0.6986136436462402,
-0.2721117436885834,
0.31246355175971985,
0.00043554132571443915,
0.6163333654403687,
-0.4542544186115265,
0.43829837441444397,
0.2098407745361328,
-0.38470104336738586,
-0.8831353783607483,
0.3508528769016266,
-0.8024355173110962,
-0.28021037578582764,
0.9103618860244751,
0.32355308532714844,
-0.17936110496520996,
-0.4203430712223053,
-0.1831466406583786,
-0.07876479625701904,
-0.1239256039261818,
0.47072675824165344,
0.5579040050506592,
-0.3722946047782898,
-0.4706789255142212,
-0.42488908767700195,
0.640197217464447,
0.6916401386260986,
-1.4353581666946411,
0.2076183706521988,
0.5621609091758728,
0.15000003576278687,
-0.34389957785606384,
0.6594448089599609,
-0.45182111859321594,
0.1888304501771927,
-0.33374378085136414,
0.08275387436151505,
0.020707495510578156,
-0.04754455387592316,
-0.25213778018951416,
0.2873704135417938,
0.2863098084926605,
0.30131006240844727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08411v1
|
Tailoring Generative AI Chatbots for Multiethnic Communities in Disaster Preparedness Communication: Extending the CASA Paradigm
| 2024-06-12T16:57:28 | 2024-06-12T16:57:28 |
Xinyan Zhao, Yuan Sun, Wenlin Liu, Chau-Wai Wong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC, 68U15
|
This study is among the first to develop different prototypes of generative
AI (GenAI) chatbots powered by GPT 4 to communicate hurricane preparedness
information to diverse residents. Drawing from the Computers Are Social Actors
(CASA) paradigm and the literature on disaster vulnerability and cultural
tailoring, this study conducted a between-subjects experiment with 441 Black,
Hispanic, and Caucasian residents of Florida. A computational analysis of chat
logs (N = 7,848) shows that anthropomorphism and personalization are key
communication topics in GenAI chatbot-user interactions. SEM results (N = 441)
suggest that GenAI chatbots varying in tone formality and cultural tailoring
significantly predict bot perceptions and, subsequently, hurricane preparedness
outcomes. These results highlight the potential of using GenAI chatbots to
improve diverse communities' disaster preparedness.
|
[
-0.45411989092826843,
-0.9175963401794434,
0.28793931007385254,
0.5066927075386047,
-0.04858793690800667,
0.5196870565414429,
-0.1781667023897171,
-0.45509156584739685,
0.7570177316665649,
0.13115723431110382,
-0.5288639664649963,
-0.16398866474628448,
-0.18201959133148193,
0.37053361535072327,
-0.29488471150398254,
1.043687105178833,
0.582046627998352,
-0.20231418311595917,
0.03262394666671753,
0.0582616962492466,
-0.38047075271606445,
-0.6007338166236877,
-0.8361476063728333,
-0.008480630815029144,
0.5242517590522766,
0.5247766375541687,
1.1896393299102783,
0.21717403829097748,
0.5178893208503723,
0.4122728109359741,
0.17597585916519165,
-0.3530736565589905,
-0.4709325432777405,
0.12980690598487854,
-0.2354324907064438,
-0.34022319316864014,
-0.3659934997558594,
-0.4796679615974426,
0.15903258323669434,
0.2507633566856384,
-0.22953854501247406,
0.291206419467926,
0.04922068864107132,
0.42967328429222107,
-0.6094931364059448,
0.07415053993463516,
-0.7282396554946899,
0.05988076701760292,
-0.03727453947067261,
-0.608607828617096,
-0.1515994817018509,
-0.29130470752716064,
0.22134321928024292,
-0.5226718187332153,
0.7918742299079895,
0.07420819997787476,
0.23717710375785828,
0.3537403345108032,
-0.4942860007286072,
-0.013613827526569366,
-1.2091875076293945,
0.35631853342056274,
-0.6243053078651428,
-0.0026260176673531532,
0.37362024188041687,
0.4739757478237152,
-0.35743826627731323,
-0.4387911558151245,
-0.6475052237510681,
0.19405674934387207,
0.3545929789543152,
0.2676045298576355,
-0.037530045956373215,
0.24535396695137024,
0.06211819127202034,
0.4185273349285126,
-0.7797269821166992,
0.042345885187387466,
-0.41075998544692993,
-0.32400843501091003,
0.872221827507019,
0.3908251225948334,
0.462599515914917,
-0.25254666805267334,
-0.3502279818058014,
-0.15308000147342682,
-0.46620801091194153,
-0.025710146874189377,
0.4352931082248688,
0.3342769145965576,
-0.427107572555542,
0.1288667768239975,
-0.052124880254268646,
0.48987171053886414,
-0.3346627950668335,
-0.34966784715652466,
0.17234821617603302,
-0.4968792200088501,
-0.3744222819805145,
0.0885285809636116,
0.7529694437980652,
0.4355379641056061,
0.4559117555618286,
0.10324466228485107,
0.20288589596748352,
-0.023825544863939285,
0.5783519148826599,
-0.5478020310401917,
-0.3731279671192169,
0.06420349329710007,
-0.5552074313163757,
-0.5009307861328125,
0.08356176316738129,
-1.2131057977676392,
-0.7641753554344177,
0.0661705806851387,
-0.014100492931902409,
-0.026730701327323914,
-0.438394695520401,
-0.22032710909843445,
-0.18004895746707916,
0.1823105663061142,
0.32095983624458313,
-1.259425163269043,
0.12370102107524872,
0.31774452328681946,
0.8342536687850952,
0.42906123399734497,
-0.10438261926174164,
0.020989637821912766,
0.0633305013179779,
-0.04791157692670822,
0.7634226679801941,
-0.6813158988952637,
-0.7540867924690247,
0.047828275710344315,
-0.2937953770160675,
-0.00011332394205965102,
0.05127391591668129,
0.3562813699245453,
-0.21612679958343506,
0.03493927791714668,
-0.14390254020690918,
0.12136561423540115,
-0.22717440128326416,
0.19672144949436188,
-0.5234620571136475,
0.41707804799079895,
0.3779306709766388,
-0.6402149796485901,
0.3169204294681549,
-0.5415825247764587,
-0.6454501152038574,
0.24155129492282867,
-0.19117149710655212,
-0.5396822690963745,
0.13135455548763275,
0.413324236869812,
0.22144895792007446,
-0.2832932472229004,
0.04803910851478577,
-0.6450428366661072,
-0.3393300175666809,
0.14243893325328827,
-0.6251028180122375,
0.6751202344894409,
0.44239312410354614,
-0.5081595182418823,
0.4179920256137848,
-0.38476598262786865,
-0.08980219811201096,
0.2276020497083664,
-0.259951651096344,
0.03368512913584709,
0.20849131047725677,
0.30258581042289734,
0.3362962305545807,
-0.08962590247392654,
-0.2268303483724594,
0.08117634057998657,
-0.39134275913238525,
0.45936495065689087,
0.7848119735717773,
0.010675780475139618,
0.33202555775642395,
-0.5731725692749023,
1.0037946701049805,
-0.2137317657470703,
0.5076166987419128,
-0.12961728870868683,
-0.8712860941886902,
-0.7781196236610413,
0.03438999131321907,
-0.1933363527059555,
0.8400013446807861,
-0.7887435555458069,
0.46201014518737793,
-0.18193182349205017,
-0.46626970171928406,
-0.4082165062427521,
-0.25102168321609497,
0.05985449627041817,
0.3949373960494995,
0.19604435563087463,
-0.2563702464103699,
-0.8900726437568665,
-0.7278403639793396,
0.22680971026420593,
-0.49567872285842896,
-0.0997808501124382,
0.38103151321411133,
0.2647063732147217,
-0.08541656285524368,
0.6792406439781189,
-0.13686716556549072,
-0.22585926949977875,
-0.6427286863327026,
-0.15626868605613708,
-0.1325237900018692,
0.17872262001037598,
0.9455444812774658,
-0.9615014791488647,
-0.5389876961708069,
-0.004154644440859556,
-0.6351075172424316,
0.4943862855434418,
-0.38449805974960327,
0.17748084664344788,
-0.010874430648982525,
0.17759378254413605,
-0.010489022359251976,
0.7253067493438721,
0.7015398740768433,
-0.38011878728866577,
0.34844160079956055,
-0.3766994774341583,
0.41084620356559753,
-1.580788493156433,
-0.14636486768722534,
0.03636159375309944,
-0.028943076729774475,
-0.9146254658699036,
-0.13652732968330383,
-0.39554378390312195,
-0.5815660357475281,
-0.2757960259914398,
0.3843769431114197,
-0.3933076560497284,
-0.2171417772769928,
-0.3042128086090088,
0.011851897463202477,
-0.3974842429161072,
0.2507806420326233,
0.04856172949075699,
0.922987699508667,
0.5490246415138245,
-0.5937031507492065,
0.4061014950275421,
0.49342015385627747,
-0.08536294102668762,
0.455251544713974,
-0.8031483888626099,
0.31996622681617737,
-0.3545572757720947,
0.6793631911277771,
-0.9042344093322754,
-0.409466415643692,
0.19512933492660522,
-0.5075247883796692,
-0.20611141622066498,
-0.07736864686012268,
-0.08656254410743713,
-0.8994727730751038,
-0.3227460980415344,
0.42816710472106934,
0.5915221571922302,
0.03888062760233879,
0.6047329902648926,
0.5963253378868103,
-0.537589430809021,
-0.3413747549057007,
-0.7166439890861511,
0.36271607875823975,
-0.5077081322669983,
-0.6820401549339294,
0.04477215185761452,
-0.2996329069137573,
-0.1646624356508255,
-0.6047820448875427,
0.24615681171417236,
-0.20183110237121582,
0.53831946849823,
0.4323025047779083,
0.1980968415737152,
-0.20632724463939667,
-0.025916844606399536,
-0.12284477055072784,
0.09084869921207428,
0.08508706837892532,
0.08605595678091049,
0.9075732827186584,
-0.20340965688228607,
-0.2938014566898346,
-0.5883629322052002,
0.5716186165809631,
0.4397847354412079,
-0.15575090050697327,
1.0106433629989624,
0.4420299828052521,
-0.2297828644514084,
0.5224800705909729,
-0.5325711369514465,
-0.43871328234672546,
-0.4941599369049072,
-0.0429079569876194,
-0.32457852363586426,
-0.9152995347976685,
0.794482409954071,
0.23466908931732178,
0.09760003536939621,
0.1860705465078354,
0.6704592704772949,
-0.03561841696500778,
0.7830014228820801,
0.7958630919456482,
-0.4749334752559662,
0.6641805768013,
0.06612029671669006,
0.28656718134880066,
-0.44646313786506653,
-0.06630947440862656,
-0.7919970750808716,
-0.5506272315979004,
-0.8003987669944763,
-0.23247076570987701,
0.5939918160438538,
-0.4852425754070282,
-0.21694159507751465,
0.2969616949558258,
-0.5273617506027222,
0.40384557843208313,
0.48880794644355774,
0.2296619862318039,
0.2767488658428192,
0.10831619799137115,
0.5571318864822388,
0.05603631213307381,
-0.6826046705245972,
-0.4728281497955322,
1.2032051086425781,
0.13365738093852997,
0.5564892888069153,
0.4040008783340454,
0.7213409543037415,
0.6264225840568542,
0.5122023820877075,
-0.33607783913612366,
0.19634486734867096,
0.31396377086639404,
-0.7410642504692078,
-0.6265010237693787,
-0.2924948036670685,
-1.2108972072601318,
0.14153628051280975,
-0.4300439655780792,
-0.7893335223197937,
0.3446851074695587,
0.3481425344944,
-0.6874430179595947,
0.21285374462604523,
-0.4833870232105255,
0.5825201272964478,
0.023009583353996277,
0.6565158367156982,
-0.5667005181312561,
-1.0395758152008057,
0.1799481213092804,
-0.10633354634046555,
0.49942368268966675,
-0.2212393432855606,
0.3170945942401886,
0.21336503326892853,
-0.1589106023311615,
0.9607861638069153,
0.10425179451704025,
0.15058594942092896,
0.4409560263156891,
0.07844530791044235,
0.44123247265815735,
0.29602834582328796,
-0.2913070321083069,
-0.032979074865579605,
-0.2755172550678253,
-0.575003981590271,
-0.4501497447490692,
0.48912227153778076,
-0.985652506351471,
-0.701999843120575,
-0.20635025203227997,
-0.37177959084510803,
-0.13846251368522644,
-0.09046544134616852,
0.3760753273963928,
0.34026461839675903,
-0.7539962530136108,
0.06142545863986015,
0.5366255044937134,
-0.2500288188457489,
0.5020371675491333,
0.21826472878456116,
0.143609881401062,
-0.4735090434551239,
0.7917607426643372,
-0.4759101867675781,
0.21455836296081543,
0.45388782024383545,
0.21754597127437592,
0.09752975404262543,
-0.28940659761428833,
-0.43235450983047485,
-0.2197532206773758,
-0.42015203833580017,
-0.397134929895401,
-0.5653099417686462,
-0.399951696395874,
-0.6392564177513123,
-0.5900259017944336,
-0.035148922353982925,
-0.24238929152488708,
-0.2563953101634979,
-0.25893741846084595,
0.31528088450431824,
0.7045344710350037,
-0.04271438345313072,
0.25403979420661926,
-0.6538733839988708,
0.182373046875,
0.34577837586402893,
-0.1862269788980484,
0.016254503279924393,
-0.30162596702575684,
0.15809635818004608,
0.4134348928928375,
-0.35779687762260437,
-0.8810553550720215,
0.37221819162368774,
0.525534987449646,
0.4279308319091797,
0.6724398136138916,
0.36862680315971375,
0.6055399775505066,
-0.2439577877521515,
0.8681442141532898,
0.36186569929122925,
-0.5661658048629761,
1.083328127861023,
-0.5947580337524414,
0.19780762493610382,
0.6963866949081421,
0.266967236995697,
-0.6199712753295898,
-0.7419826984405518,
-0.7587868571281433,
-0.5073925256729126,
0.2156514972448349,
0.4050741493701935,
0.7747164964675903,
-0.21976733207702637,
-0.18435800075531006,
-0.00526251457631588,
0.09182380139827728,
-0.5674950480461121,
-0.42977291345596313,
-0.6325691938400269,
-0.045869193971157074,
-0.2967846691608429,
-0.3027360141277313,
-0.4048928916454315,
-0.24058115482330322,
0.05957859382033348,
-0.30858853459358215,
0.4263707399368286,
0.04632074013352394,
0.17114892601966858,
-0.05024193599820137,
0.5218287110328674,
1.0468591451644897,
0.8144106268882751,
0.17532837390899658,
-0.10238403081893921,
0.34498465061187744,
-0.4981890022754669,
0.26006025075912476,
0.039499398320913315,
-0.09136736392974854,
-0.09718506038188934,
0.46058326959609985,
0.7130661010742188,
0.2935788631439209,
-0.17658615112304688,
0.2906661629676819,
-0.42591094970703125,
-0.04024893790483475,
-0.44541308283805847,
0.37783190608024597,
-0.12714897096157074,
0.15133529901504517,
0.32949143648147583,
0.12935870885849,
0.4264807403087616,
-0.8134541511535645,
-0.18079565465450287,
0.3339642584323883,
-0.09814649075269699,
-0.4609566926956177,
0.8766802549362183,
0.9042809009552002,
-0.7103192210197449,
1.033976674079895,
0.17639265954494476,
-0.3229275047779083,
0.6738932132720947,
0.580766499042511,
1.008514165878296,
-0.6323482990264893,
0.5772728323936462,
0.3629528284072876,
0.2079228013753891,
0.21593855321407318,
0.3964916467666626,
-0.19213294982910156,
-0.888518214225769,
0.02054385282099247,
-0.5348207354545593,
-0.3033895194530487,
-0.0813736692070961,
-0.5141962170600891,
0.06192506477236748,
-0.7067404985427856,
-0.4435984492301941,
0.010523744858801365,
-0.46047189831733704,
-0.8519914746284485,
0.007066528312861919,
0.2233808934688568,
0.6145932674407959,
-0.8734601736068726,
0.4837404787540436,
0.803076982498169,
-0.6070052981376648,
-0.7635772824287415,
0.2563795745372772,
0.1733299046754837,
-0.6407323479652405,
-0.07528296858072281,
0.003031826810911298,
0.1783016324043274,
0.012833921238780022,
-0.2992279529571533,
-0.9357818365097046,
1.0804047584533691,
0.3388177156448364,
-0.5579507946968079,
-0.1414337456226349,
0.31161293387413025,
0.7742817997932434,
-0.25027382373809814,
0.38506725430488586,
0.40722060203552246,
0.520348310470581,
0.06121562793850899,
-1.426484227180481,
-0.16650155186653137,
-0.35265982151031494,
0.3507484197616577,
0.023058341816067696,
-0.8774502873420715,
0.319440633058548,
-0.6296812295913696,
-0.17275531589984894,
0.17730006575584412,
0.9158088564872742,
0.020517004653811455,
0.34885838627815247,
0.3763773441314697,
0.1776658296585083,
0.7442260384559631,
-0.12726794183254242,
1.1848833560943604,
-0.3713780343532562,
0.1536758542060852,
0.8861884474754333,
0.05815548449754715,
0.2840777635574341,
0.04894248768687248,
-0.30064550042152405,
0.7767140865325928,
0.7311627864837646,
0.23930403590202332,
0.2965655028820038,
0.18411517143249512,
-0.7564050555229187,
-0.1736292541027069,
-0.1308954954147339,
-0.5413115620613098,
0.6550465226173401,
0.4012725353240967,
-0.3593161702156067,
-0.14127163589000702,
0.2948567271232605,
-0.02021539770066738,
0.0840163454413414,
-0.13908439874649048,
0.9136245250701904,
0.05154119059443474,
-0.38051995635032654,
0.20641706883907318,
-0.20643532276153564,
0.4391109347343445,
-0.2416689097881317,
0.13731473684310913,
-0.4854588508605957,
-0.03148799389600754,
-0.25447919964790344,
-0.740504264831543,
0.47168824076652527,
-0.34570926427841187,
-0.29041218757629395,
-0.04647630453109741,
0.5460429787635803,
-0.13789696991443634,
-0.39968106150627136,
-0.13625390827655792,
0.4436771273612976,
0.22095386683940887,
-0.08789290487766266,
-0.6610677242279053,
0.0672382339835167,
-0.09022340923547745,
-0.09885994344949722,
0.4312363862991333,
0.12620694935321808,
-0.28395935893058777,
1.047830581665039,
0.6918898820877075,
-0.018144479021430016,
-0.1947389543056488,
0.47186657786369324,
0.757365345954895,
-0.6497657299041748,
-0.7149680256843567,
-0.8625155687332153,
0.4613379240036011,
-0.11880876868963242,
-0.5441349744796753,
0.7186101675033569,
0.33242276310920715,
0.4404727816581726,
-0.3010197877883911,
0.9124093055725098,
-0.3702043890953064,
-0.12642209231853485,
-0.023499807342886925,
0.6316079497337341,
0.04328859597444534,
-0.09061731398105621,
-0.5110595226287842,
-1.0978543758392334,
-0.15682707726955414,
0.6129980683326721,
0.11310916393995285,
0.27860671281814575,
0.2098170667886734,
0.6203789114952087,
0.3001953363418579,
0.12841638922691345,
0.3705136179924011,
-0.4751787781715393,
0.5397346019744873,
0.4942222535610199,
0.6094995141029358,
-0.09229603409767151,
0.4833630621433258,
-0.09382917732000351,
-0.32450100779533386,
-0.49907395243644714,
-0.48737311363220215,
-0.8942188620567322,
-0.684410810470581,
-0.10430844128131866,
-0.2271854430437088,
0.1436213105916977,
0.7494491338729858,
0.7711421251296997,
-0.8940994143486023,
-0.040648914873600006,
-0.0814312994480133,
0.2532722055912018,
-0.10035855323076248,
-0.31613293290138245,
-0.18976446986198425,
-0.09457410871982574,
-0.40751367807388306,
0.4154794216156006,
0.4643414616584778,
0.460519939661026,
-0.6414448618888855,
-0.03630774840712547,
0.17766833305358887,
0.12258317321538925,
0.5800081491470337,
0.6304657459259033,
-0.603434681892395,
-0.5676733255386353,
-0.27891451120376587,
-0.08625123649835587,
0.0971425473690033,
1.0465337038040161,
-0.7563311457633972,
0.49130988121032715,
0.43220192193984985,
0.44286462664604187,
0.05843270942568779,
0.22003404796123505,
0.9670134782791138,
-0.6730344891548157,
0.5738092660903931,
0.3588760495185852,
0.2172074019908905,
0.5162701606750488,
-0.7392366528511047,
0.6062472462654114,
0.09144748747348785,
-0.7738870978355408,
-0.42546388506889343,
0.26823675632476807,
-0.5569167733192444,
0.1203533187508583,
1.0417146682739258,
0.05254020541906357,
0.22946114838123322,
-0.44756078720092773,
-0.2197163701057434,
0.07645858824253082,
-0.5322633385658264,
1.2993634939193726,
0.5076785683631897,
-0.16223551332950592,
-0.3653203248977661,
-0.3305806815624237,
0.6299225091934204,
-0.02998373471200466,
-1.1277379989624023,
-0.3413233458995819,
0.3951478600502014,
0.23518602550029755,
0.2681165039539337,
0.9489046335220337,
0.44828855991363525,
0.4924233555793762,
-0.03275889903306961,
0.06113284081220627,
0.21201598644256592,
-0.4834310710430145,
-0.1116781011223793,
-0.05243939906358719,
-0.008258639834821224,
0.023750295862555504
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08407v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08407v2
|
MMWorld: Towards Multi-discipline Multi-faceted World Model Evaluation in Videos
| 2024-06-12T16:54:54 | 2024-06-13T09:37:50 |
Xuehai He, Weixi Feng, Kaizhi Zheng, Yujie Lu, Wanrong Zhu, Jiachen Li, Yue Fan, Jianfeng Wang, Linjie Li, Zhengyuan Yang, Kevin Lin, William Yang Wang, Lijuan Wang, Xin Eric Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Multimodal Language Language Models (MLLMs) demonstrate the emerging
abilities of "world models" -- interpreting and reasoning about complex
real-world dynamics. To assess these abilities, we posit videos are the ideal
medium, as they encapsulate rich representations of real-world dynamics and
causalities. To this end, we introduce MMWorld, a new benchmark for
multi-discipline, multi-faceted multimodal video understanding. MMWorld
distinguishes itself from previous video understanding benchmarks with two
unique advantages: (1) multi-discipline, covering various disciplines that
often require domain expertise for comprehensive understanding; (2)
multi-faceted reasoning, including explanation, counterfactual thinking, future
prediction, etc. MMWorld consists of a human-annotated dataset to evaluate
MLLMs with questions about the whole videos and a synthetic dataset to analyze
MLLMs within a single modality of perception. Together, MMWorld encompasses
1,910 videos across seven broad disciplines and 69 subdisciplines, complete
with 6,627 question-answer pairs and associated captions. The evaluation
includes 2 proprietary and 10 open-source MLLMs, which struggle on MMWorld
(e.g., GPT-4V performs the best with only 52.3\% accuracy), showing large room
for improvement. Further ablation studies reveal other interesting findings
such as models' different skill sets from humans. We hope MMWorld can serve as
an essential step towards world model evaluation in videos.
|
[
-0.6518265604972839,
-0.8805062174797058,
0.39348769187927246,
0.2835093140602112,
-0.054800357669591904,
0.23732632398605347,
-0.05268939584493637,
-0.3484629988670349,
-0.33251944184303284,
0.21213294565677643,
-0.981363832950592,
-0.3743666112422943,
-0.6566597819328308,
-0.04269569739699364,
-0.29749298095703125,
0.9331250786781311,
0.13844996690750122,
0.14108861982822418,
-0.6949853897094727,
-0.45018377900123596,
-0.08821800351142883,
-0.39401617646217346,
-0.11781773716211319,
-0.5568647980690002,
0.6031495928764343,
0.07758767157793045,
0.6812266111373901,
0.44601771235466003,
0.8862618207931519,
0.38285166025161743,
-0.05868731066584587,
0.34966784715652466,
-0.21635644137859344,
-0.07796861231327057,
-0.1817920207977295,
0.0906069427728653,
-0.5160568952560425,
0.30790507793426514,
0.4819986820220947,
0.8460814952850342,
-0.020826872438192368,
0.5200657248497009,
-0.033643849194049835,
0.5358323454856873,
-0.7469029426574707,
0.07990149408578873,
-0.3526698648929596,
0.37251681089401245,
0.28086477518081665,
-0.24392662942409515,
-0.20361635088920593,
0.1283184438943863,
0.5511312484741211,
-0.719851016998291,
0.19297495484352112,
0.06225260719656944,
0.3719620406627655,
0.31624433398246765,
-0.7223587036132812,
0.060859858989715576,
-0.8623266220092773,
0.739453136920929,
-0.10328376293182373,
0.813740074634552,
-0.031045332551002502,
0.7434748411178589,
-0.014879019930958748,
-0.4717334508895874,
-0.6156534552574158,
-0.18866534531116486,
0.6648863554000854,
0.5068494081497192,
-0.22467343509197235,
0.1345459371805191,
0.3739071190357208,
0.25373390316963196,
-0.839078962802887,
-0.018432876095175743,
-0.3224988281726837,
-0.33319318294525146,
0.5811190605163574,
0.22650402784347534,
0.2449856549501419,
-0.29407379031181335,
-0.2745078504085541,
-0.16508692502975464,
-0.39783981442451477,
0.20050989091396332,
0.3011563718318939,
-0.048954933881759644,
-0.3859795928001404,
0.5436304211616516,
-0.3125750720500946,
0.7674345970153809,
-0.49677950143814087,
-0.7842914462089539,
0.1821739822626114,
-0.1149815022945404,
-0.574284553527832,
-0.4973141849040985,
0.5686372518539429,
0.9338528513908386,
0.18495981395244598,
-0.13086141645908356,
0.2379472255706787,
0.21239341795444489,
0.15987318754196167,
-0.8654322028160095,
-0.283248633146286,
0.23358267545700073,
-0.6621912717819214,
-0.18881841003894806,
0.18630939722061157,
-0.8352080583572388,
-0.567656934261322,
-0.5024788975715637,
0.47509732842445374,
-0.17745403945446014,
-0.43204036355018616,
0.05036448314785957,
-0.34341731667518616,
0.006847909186035395,
0.5254889726638794,
-0.5794678926467896,
0.24114269018173218,
0.7300501465797424,
0.908935010433197,
0.02079922705888748,
-0.6893329620361328,
-0.5624207258224487,
0.192798912525177,
-0.03532915562391281,
0.9155185222625732,
-0.5180596113204956,
-0.16211484372615814,
-0.021080205217003822,
-0.0708995833992958,
0.16768334805965424,
-0.628950834274292,
0.4075263440608978,
-0.33148273825645447,
0.09010689705610275,
-0.21296483278274536,
-0.2737344801425934,
-0.3461916744709015,
0.5899825692176819,
-0.5850574970245361,
0.7800475358963013,
-0.21728980541229248,
-0.5479983687400818,
0.6328010559082031,
-0.7951570749282837,
-0.005875337403267622,
-0.28534364700317383,
0.0006027730414643884,
-0.14386801421642303,
0.010997445322573185,
0.2674831748008728,
0.40407851338386536,
-0.28405994176864624,
0.5994776487350464,
-0.7858698964118958,
-0.12034179270267487,
0.3953946828842163,
-0.8835052847862244,
0.5037692785263062,
0.2781127691268921,
0.09176269173622131,
0.1513778567314148,
-0.8097305297851562,
0.04804769903421402,
-0.19261865317821503,
-0.05060739815235138,
-0.14576344192028046,
0.0679224282503128,
0.14104922115802765,
0.7777539491653442,
-0.09144944697618484,
-0.5862352252006531,
0.07764846086502075,
0.11590413004159927,
0.5663893818855286,
0.776652991771698,
-0.0043153646402060986,
0.18740180134773254,
-0.2674463391304016,
0.532455563545227,
0.2505839169025421,
0.5207597613334656,
-0.20484761893749237,
-0.6039314270019531,
-0.3937154710292816,
-0.18486228585243225,
-0.12723226845264435,
0.4463304579257965,
-0.718119204044342,
-0.09956105053424835,
-0.32752373814582825,
-0.6873607039451599,
-0.5230417251586914,
0.07660726457834244,
0.3456740379333496,
0.4326770007610321,
0.38547012209892273,
-0.16869598627090454,
-0.7614052295684814,
-0.9392585754394531,
-0.20024336874485016,
-0.1980040967464447,
-0.16386526823043823,
0.523688554763794,
0.8214761018753052,
-0.28110066056251526,
0.9749349355697632,
-0.3913326859474182,
-0.09274764358997345,
-0.09521700441837311,
0.2696549594402313,
-0.07554944604635239,
0.2003626972436905,
0.23624643683433533,
-1.1687188148498535,
-0.31575334072113037,
0.09078183770179749,
-1.1509723663330078,
-0.10706213116645813,
-0.084767647087574,
0.033148135989904404,
-0.38652217388153076,
0.3470562994480133,
-0.40845516324043274,
0.09620849788188934,
0.8436275720596313,
-0.2689494490623474,
0.8412133455276489,
-0.3507084846496582,
0.34221726655960083,
-0.5769270062446594,
0.09571196138858795,
0.23224054276943207,
-0.17285233736038208,
-0.3889704644680023,
0.26321476697921753,
-0.07473556697368622,
-0.3920229375362396,
-0.7120988368988037,
0.6014341711997986,
-0.26440170407295227,
-0.5416200160980225,
0.020027311518788338,
0.4267936944961548,
0.10616788268089294,
0.4978506863117218,
-0.09453895688056946,
0.6394454836845398,
0.717396080493927,
-0.6012502312660217,
0.7072643041610718,
0.15260954201221466,
-0.5450625419616699,
0.8697095513343811,
-0.3586671054363251,
-0.20889385044574738,
-0.25395673513412476,
0.29923370480537415,
-0.560308039188385,
-0.2571134865283966,
-0.247205913066864,
-0.4146161377429962,
-0.4272768795490265,
-0.2651485502719879,
-0.3408341705799103,
-0.5343718528747559,
-0.2074705958366394,
0.13104811310768127,
0.29331931471824646,
-0.4831966161727905,
0.546813428401947,
0.5269734263420105,
0.17757783830165863,
-0.7678604125976562,
-0.39758020639419556,
0.2694573402404785,
-0.3710920512676239,
-0.6391263008117676,
0.2710474133491516,
-0.5573691129684448,
-0.5575180053710938,
-0.022491086274385452,
-0.33554506301879883,
-0.266365110874176,
0.3150383532047272,
0.45937860012054443,
0.09277837723493576,
-0.138575479388237,
-0.2012658715248108,
-0.034977830946445465,
-0.17368483543395996,
0.20622393488883972,
-0.36450809240341187,
0.1728125959634781,
-0.1429421603679657,
-0.5895524621009827,
-0.11131242662668228,
0.37863385677337646,
0.7998769879341125,
-0.32907387614250183,
0.5280879139900208,
0.8724048733711243,
-0.41395485401153564,
0.016870146617293358,
-0.5908964276313782,
0.23027291893959045,
-0.45745474100112915,
0.6321195960044861,
-0.6146771907806396,
-0.8837885856628418,
0.6419879794120789,
-0.23001356422901154,
0.09778688102960587,
0.34232378005981445,
0.6803175806999207,
-0.2722957134246826,
1.4361464977264404,
0.7640759944915771,
0.13833090662956238,
0.3647763431072235,
-0.4083646535873413,
0.06781786680221558,
-0.9172554016113281,
-0.6321460604667664,
-0.034261032938957214,
-0.17723070085048676,
-0.4255473017692566,
-0.6692882776260376,
0.791008710861206,
0.06460245698690414,
-0.2712327539920807,
-0.09824205935001373,
-0.1346403956413269,
0.6465787887573242,
0.04708640277385712,
-0.015038260258734226,
0.5177469253540039,
-0.010260005481541157,
-0.42266878485679626,
-0.3695163130760193,
-0.5451889634132385,
-0.6194018721580505,
0.9674901366233826,
0.39000803232192993,
0.5860407948493958,
0.43818897008895874,
0.11455310136079788,
0.4722675085067749,
0.6106102466583252,
-0.7791259288787842,
0.5786572098731995,
-0.24538417160511017,
-0.5219892859458923,
-0.06157342344522476,
-0.35435059666633606,
-0.5867531299591064,
0.8359000086784363,
-0.3852904736995697,
-0.5053405165672302,
-0.3965969681739807,
0.04218493029475212,
-0.3578835129737854,
0.44294655323028564,
-0.4834117293357849,
1.1560815572738647,
-0.14737266302108765,
-0.47072768211364746,
-0.3559580445289612,
-0.536504328250885,
0.5303858518600464,
0.20280809700489044,
0.7609745860099792,
-0.37184709310531616,
0.03972668945789337,
0.4630865752696991,
-0.13932985067367554,
0.5220287442207336,
-0.43572598695755005,
-0.020333239808678627,
0.2784675657749176,
0.06014774367213249,
-0.25605112314224243,
0.22254136204719543,
0.1933067888021469,
0.010742418467998505,
0.07954096049070358,
-0.14050205051898956,
-0.8613399267196655,
0.6699232459068298,
-0.8094043135643005,
-0.33162662386894226,
-0.2251248061656952,
-0.7161523103713989,
-0.30718719959259033,
0.09340822696685791,
-0.09851530939340591,
0.7641865015029907,
-0.6827950477600098,
0.23827946186065674,
0.6176917552947998,
-0.33354756236076355,
0.35296034812927246,
0.7551788687705994,
-0.5396440625190735,
-0.4910601079463959,
1.0725055932998657,
0.017281075939536095,
0.2466190606355667,
0.4554084539413452,
0.168060302734375,
-0.19736436009407043,
-0.3588046133518219,
-0.8217295408248901,
-0.20326246321201324,
-0.8839108347892761,
-0.16776162385940552,
-0.9780089259147644,
-0.10893028229475021,
-0.23876827955245972,
0.0704696774482727,
-0.3118775188922882,
-0.14812134206295013,
0.24397659301757812,
-0.15199247002601624,
0.0898643210530281,
0.6778295636177063,
-0.2522565722465515,
0.113583505153656,
-0.880814790725708,
0.4774194061756134,
0.5767999291419983,
0.46587419509887695,
0.021335532888770103,
-0.41756471991539,
-0.4029664397239685,
0.024290965870022774,
-0.6698870658874512,
-0.602764904499054,
0.35248100757598877,
0.3921511471271515,
0.7336032390594482,
0.41472122073173523,
-0.42301544547080994,
1.2741570472717285,
-0.9024327993392944,
0.7803546786308289,
0.06775937229394913,
-0.9736126065254211,
0.4067997932434082,
-0.3398085832595825,
0.27853184938430786,
0.2102392017841339,
0.361307293176651,
-0.9219127893447876,
-0.4131610095500946,
-0.638619601726532,
-0.43749600648880005,
0.2610767185688019,
-0.015001984313130379,
0.09984862804412842,
0.24488681554794312,
-0.011738256551325321,
0.2980002462863922,
0.2715781331062317,
-0.8673765659332275,
-0.19557525217533112,
-0.24732041358947754,
0.07188564538955688,
-0.1856437474489212,
0.011786812916398048,
-0.16629862785339355,
-0.2730569541454315,
0.3015958368778229,
-0.41702187061309814,
0.2392967790365219,
0.18053045868873596,
-0.5484422445297241,
-0.224158376455307,
0.16184820234775543,
0.6883465647697449,
0.8966386318206787,
-0.4063987731933594,
0.2964581549167633,
0.19149455428123474,
-0.4711768925189972,
0.3050827383995056,
-0.055563222616910934,
0.2265988141298294,
-0.15856917202472687,
0.6638908982276917,
0.6475975513458252,
0.35837119817733765,
-1.097094178199768,
0.5568034648895264,
0.04767274111509323,
-0.3366324305534363,
-0.22790932655334473,
-0.05043372884392738,
-0.0961809903383255,
0.3773552179336548,
0.4424273669719696,
0.41276243329048157,
0.459879994392395,
-0.6299627423286438,
0.41050752997398376,
0.47744014859199524,
-0.29969340562820435,
-0.5776452422142029,
0.7390419840812683,
0.23278287053108215,
-0.031709443777799606,
0.27125829458236694,
-0.36393097043037415,
-0.594894528388977,
0.6590880155563354,
0.40814971923828125,
0.6231899857521057,
0.033226244151592255,
0.4074973165988922,
0.4598633348941803,
0.33551904559135437,
-0.015114245936274529,
0.25095903873443604,
-0.09091947227716446,
-0.7584784030914307,
-0.6397786140441895,
-0.5611028671264648,
-0.8577698469161987,
0.037116918712854385,
-0.8298324942588806,
0.06993851065635681,
-0.38532793521881104,
0.07883989810943604,
0.1870410293340683,
-0.004856126848608255,
-0.7067212462425232,
0.37835314869880676,
0.4265950918197632,
0.8800086975097656,
-1.1719661951065063,
0.8096399307250977,
0.7242807745933533,
-0.2576824426651001,
-0.04074694588780403,
-0.22330744564533234,
0.3792751729488373,
-0.5499563813209534,
0.7301066517829895,
0.4764741063117981,
-0.14320063591003418,
-0.3187519609928131,
-0.4817673861980438,
-0.8773845434188843,
1.1351020336151123,
0.29242822527885437,
-0.27091681957244873,
0.13860377669334412,
-0.03185129538178444,
0.6436687707901001,
-0.481069415807724,
0.5540109872817993,
0.4601821303367615,
0.3420049250125885,
-0.032791249454021454,
-0.9943403005599976,
-0.6223984360694885,
-0.3924916088581085,
-0.1585703194141388,
0.07192203402519226,
-0.6473067402839661,
0.7883387207984924,
-0.3613571524620056,
0.11081960797309875,
-0.17598207294940948,
0.7356427311897278,
0.4656393826007843,
0.6822428703308105,
0.6227250695228577,
0.4744715690612793,
0.5723754167556763,
0.06440500915050507,
0.9467914700508118,
0.0137729337438941,
0.450213223695755,
0.7879804968833923,
-0.29673317074775696,
0.8185529708862305,
0.4166525900363922,
-0.46906551718711853,
0.6248852014541626,
0.6291268467903137,
-0.030452705919742584,
0.5798090100288391,
0.0826173648238182,
-0.10246089845895767,
-0.5391558408737183,
-0.3331568241119385,
-0.19242586195468903,
0.6694798469543457,
0.2820092439651489,
0.20746535062789917,
-0.20816446840763092,
0.49162858724594116,
-0.3766266405582428,
0.08469264954328537,
-0.2834330201148987,
0.6321440935134888,
-0.025287041440606117,
-0.5012233853340149,
0.14485128223896027,
0.03489941358566284,
0.6462001204490662,
-0.4755374491214752,
-0.11666643619537354,
-0.010878399945795536,
0.1524043083190918,
-0.23319502174854279,
-0.7068188786506653,
0.4067891240119934,
0.3309762477874756,
-0.41408100724220276,
-0.34003496170043945,
0.39514774084091187,
-0.4698994755744934,
-0.5142223834991455,
0.4240325391292572,
0.7257892489433289,
0.3475569188594818,
-0.13412261009216309,
-0.9986477494239807,
0.0891176089644432,
-0.23876039683818817,
-0.049477629363536835,
0.4456925392150879,
0.47461816668510437,
-0.15778687596321106,
1.1290643215179443,
0.6953124403953552,
-0.25974538922309875,
-0.05736616253852844,
0.37817299365997314,
0.6298823952674866,
-0.5585781335830688,
-0.368285596370697,
-0.9529706239700317,
0.6831949949264526,
-0.06634709984064102,
-0.355395644903183,
0.832892656326294,
0.7257794141769409,
0.9580865502357483,
-0.02527053840458393,
0.8292171359062195,
-0.1865958273410797,
0.2624526023864746,
-0.5497693419456482,
0.4142957031726837,
-0.8038674592971802,
-0.022123435512185097,
-0.5663512349128723,
-0.9636621475219727,
-0.35930413007736206,
0.6932576298713684,
-0.13337589800357819,
-0.0027645390946418047,
0.5809323191642761,
0.405093789100647,
-0.2674383223056793,
0.06561992317438126,
0.6052101850509644,
0.10177581757307053,
0.5244603753089905,
0.4142262637615204,
1.1302428245544434,
-0.36459237337112427,
0.6071722507476807,
-0.5419499278068542,
-0.3146986663341522,
-0.011381193064153194,
-1.1761391162872314,
-0.8731122016906738,
-0.5205658078193665,
-0.29255151748657227,
0.020218469202518463,
-0.21364058554172516,
1.0262694358825684,
0.8579131364822388,
-0.5406386852264404,
-0.39600545167922974,
0.4388270378112793,
0.05965277552604675,
-0.5935649275779724,
-0.146997332572937,
-0.027688903734087944,
0.298778772354126,
-0.7344376444816589,
0.5424627065658569,
0.7056070566177368,
-0.12206549942493439,
-0.8628578186035156,
-0.18219926953315735,
-0.021837465465068817,
-0.35480833053588867,
1.0607157945632935,
-0.09297818690538406,
-1.0314953327178955,
-0.2725684940814972,
0.15186551213264465,
0.13855788111686707,
-0.04888366907835007,
0.9373533725738525,
-0.6797558665275574,
0.6142091751098633,
0.23434332013130188,
0.3008098304271698,
0.3674353063106537,
-0.08596595376729965,
0.46400880813598633,
-0.5999654531478882,
0.475002646446228,
-0.039180975407361984,
0.3830752968788147,
0.5492236614227295,
0.12063263356685638,
0.5380451679229736,
0.48703914880752563,
-0.49223363399505615,
-0.9506192803382874,
0.17629292607307434,
-0.8676292896270752,
-0.2018052041530609,
0.703231155872345,
-0.2609190046787262,
-0.03828054666519165,
-0.051883261650800705,
-0.08255477994680405,
0.06887093931436539,
-0.02402452751994133,
0.5417520403862,
0.8651403784751892,
-0.12281620502471924,
-0.3305417597293854,
-1.3172616958618164,
0.18359597027301788,
0.315554678440094,
-0.8920620083808899,
0.13467109203338623,
0.6660318374633789,
0.2702064514160156,
0.055593572556972504,
0.3547910749912262,
0.05862230062484741,
0.36340266466140747,
0.0679975226521492,
-0.08063709735870361,
-0.2364020198583603,
-0.7459062933921814,
-0.42809411883354187,
0.1421566903591156,
-0.1825575828552246,
0.21250292658805847
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08402v1
|
Understanding Sounds, Missing the Questions: The Challenge of Object Hallucination in Large Audio-Language Models
| 2024-06-12T16:51:54 | 2024-06-12T16:51:54 |
Chun-Yi Kuan, Wei-Ping Huang, Hung-yi Lee
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Large audio-language models (LALMs) enhance traditional large language models
by integrating audio perception capabilities, allowing them to tackle
audio-related tasks. Previous research has primarily focused on assessing the
performance of LALMs across various tasks, yet overlooking their reliability,
particularly concerning issues like object hallucination. In our study, we
introduce methods to assess the extent of object hallucination of publicly
available LALMs. Our findings reveal that LALMs are comparable to specialized
audio captioning models in their understanding of audio content, but struggle
to answer discriminative questions, specifically those requiring the
identification of the presence of particular object sounds within an audio
clip. This limitation highlights a critical weakness in current LALMs: their
inadequate understanding of discriminative queries. Moreover, we explore the
potential of prompt engineering to enhance LALMs' performance on discriminative
questions.
|
[
-0.6710461974143982,
-0.7952327132225037,
0.6859583854675293,
0.303490549325943,
0.14940404891967773,
-0.023382293060421944,
-0.14865989983081818,
-0.6572441458702087,
-0.036549314856529236,
0.5478758215904236,
-0.7388189435005188,
-0.5073102712631226,
-0.4935306906700134,
0.38739800453186035,
-0.6609737873077393,
0.498119056224823,
0.34347736835479736,
0.04343488812446594,
-0.46621832251548767,
-0.15356853604316711,
-0.9735046029090881,
-0.43194928765296936,
-0.676867663860321,
0.11228375136852264,
0.2936306595802307,
0.2578410506248474,
0.6659002900123596,
0.4123852252960205,
0.4776371717453003,
0.190594881772995,
-0.4681018888950348,
0.1780622899532318,
-0.17086392641067505,
-0.0000949281093198806,
0.04834800586104393,
-0.45574694871902466,
-0.18748421967029572,
-0.1899172067642212,
0.42494162917137146,
1.161105990409851,
0.02132226526737213,
0.13313867151737213,
-0.1321374922990799,
0.7452443838119507,
-0.6611711382865906,
0.17197436094284058,
-0.7627571225166321,
0.5121158361434937,
0.2871522605419159,
-0.3188062608242035,
-0.49563339352607727,
-0.027413861826062202,
0.2571617662906647,
-0.3825959265232086,
0.48251429200172424,
0.05721297860145569,
0.7609930634498596,
0.6843425631523132,
0.013868153095245361,
-0.6284512281417847,
-1.0220879316329956,
0.7490682601928711,
-0.41743457317352295,
0.7606627941131592,
0.9565787315368652,
0.2200305312871933,
-0.0793270543217659,
-0.21321402490139008,
-0.4787400960922241,
-0.5080788731575012,
-0.13614477217197418,
-0.11662952601909637,
-0.08494968712329865,
-0.05844719335436821,
0.42355382442474365,
0.3697352409362793,
-0.7366582155227661,
-0.01759856939315796,
-0.6963668465614319,
-0.08117306232452393,
0.5615648031234741,
0.021203557029366493,
0.3502297103404999,
-0.2616645395755768,
-0.19069957733154297,
-0.18676719069480896,
-0.5365738868713379,
-0.09335224330425262,
0.2873586416244507,
0.340321809053421,
-0.024802295491099358,
0.49749496579170227,
0.058406781405210495,
0.6127666234970093,
-0.031077787280082703,
-0.029190372675657272,
0.2494436502456665,
-0.21271507441997528,
0.09521975368261337,
0.3467137813568115,
0.5326648354530334,
0.03016897663474083,
0.15263491868972778,
-0.235123410820961,
-0.39949122071266174,
-0.379639208316803,
0.18922655284404755,
-0.47879868745803833,
-0.2417251616716385,
0.7403385043144226,
-0.292193204164505,
0.27454519271850586,
0.10629323124885559,
-0.39647364616394043,
-0.5952938199043274,
-0.312225878238678,
0.5875244140625,
-0.18885356187820435,
-0.52395099401474,
0.31634944677352905,
-0.34298786520957947,
0.23955443501472473,
0.30102109909057617,
-1.0830045938491821,
0.3394506573677063,
0.7138270735740662,
0.8768959641456604,
-0.24935317039489746,
-0.24642696976661682,
-0.8338491320610046,
0.07226018607616425,
-0.5678170919418335,
0.7913598418235779,
-0.49784979224205017,
-0.7229756712913513,
-0.1587056666612625,
0.15121500194072723,
0.14894096553325653,
-1.171848177909851,
0.47252386808395386,
-0.23737968504428864,
-0.05636514350771904,
-0.5450661182403564,
-0.4072158634662628,
-0.34432074427604675,
-0.012348371557891369,
-0.8116230964660645,
0.8712295293807983,
-0.09593020379543304,
-0.4333840012550354,
0.23809757828712463,
-0.597790539264679,
-0.36198675632476807,
-0.08349660784006119,
-0.36915767192840576,
-0.28056803345680237,
0.3580580949783325,
0.3838884234428406,
0.6190036535263062,
0.032899465411901474,
0.19278696179389954,
-0.10025464743375778,
-0.7251333594322205,
0.4616704285144806,
-0.2684386372566223,
0.6216379404067993,
0.16940557956695557,
-0.29779452085494995,
0.13837236166000366,
-0.7456037402153015,
-0.5980184078216553,
0.09620288759469986,
0.17069889605045319,
-0.12168877571821213,
0.24859942495822906,
0.23532365262508392,
-0.22275690734386444,
0.03287968784570694,
-0.11593978106975555,
-0.3550577163696289,
-0.3476032614707947,
0.223706915974617,
0.5820999145507812,
-0.11737937480211258,
0.2636030912399292,
-0.38866859674453735,
0.5411767959594727,
-0.05097745358943939,
-0.02161242812871933,
-0.35384368896484375,
-0.42508500814437866,
-0.5745826959609985,
-0.10559142380952835,
-0.18774446845054626,
0.2916725277900696,
0.04770512133836746,
0.40427717566490173,
0.2321806401014328,
-0.3607690930366516,
-0.5319912433624268,
0.012263976037502289,
0.03900991380214691,
0.271797239780426,
0.5466711521148682,
0.04469595104455948,
-0.6772258877754211,
-0.8355593681335449,
0.07972948998212814,
-0.32521429657936096,
-0.2758176624774933,
0.43186911940574646,
0.3450683355331421,
-0.1045665293931961,
0.8996695876121521,
-0.35092830657958984,
-0.4268665313720703,
-0.12422704696655273,
0.19802097976207733,
0.1913263350725174,
0.31295323371887207,
0.3080568015575409,
-1.0218617916107178,
-0.013034481555223465,
-0.04722742736339569,
-0.849999725818634,
-0.14939279854297638,
-0.2254008948802948,
0.5646588206291199,
0.05733319744467735,
0.8026129007339478,
-0.9098526835441589,
0.2154160439968109,
0.3538651764392853,
-0.08772660046815872,
0.7979966998100281,
0.017736760899424553,
0.16545061767101288,
-0.4095362424850464,
0.03903506323695183,
-0.21812400221824646,
-0.04056929424405098,
-0.5936928987503052,
-0.15244993567466736,
-0.17839491367340088,
-0.503017008304596,
-0.5862799286842346,
0.5581050515174866,
-0.7544240355491638,
-0.583881676197052,
-0.46645110845565796,
0.5915866494178772,
-0.07787454128265381,
0.25090059638023376,
0.2760935425758362,
0.893347978591919,
0.7295905351638794,
-0.8219284415245056,
0.22374001145362854,
0.2497042566537857,
-0.339474081993103,
0.3896479606628418,
-0.878109872341156,
0.3227343261241913,
-0.511207640171051,
-0.15041902661323547,
-1.1374298334121704,
-0.283564031124115,
0.10457099974155426,
-0.5042896866798401,
0.12804341316223145,
-0.08262579143047333,
-0.3128751516342163,
-0.3217320144176483,
-0.049338363111019135,
0.6281140446662903,
0.5146920680999756,
-0.5101661682128906,
0.4653432369232178,
0.555594265460968,
-0.22394046187400818,
-0.5034949779510498,
-0.3630976676940918,
0.10207060724496841,
-0.41814473271369934,
-0.38167083263397217,
-0.19717344641685486,
-0.2566208839416504,
-0.5048943758010864,
-0.14933450520038605,
-0.37013301253318787,
-0.1676918864250183,
0.4068381190299988,
0.3460715413093567,
0.0625041052699089,
-0.35936012864112854,
0.35822156071662903,
-0.23020844161510468,
0.11005573719739914,
0.48252037167549133,
0.16222868859767914,
0.6146232485771179,
-0.06851503998041153,
-0.6394937038421631,
-0.6060394644737244,
0.42905986309051514,
0.6962098479270935,
-0.30249008536338806,
0.2418607771396637,
0.6934215426445007,
-0.5993459224700928,
-0.3575296401977539,
-0.7382086515426636,
-0.49068355560302734,
-0.4384177625179291,
0.7042403817176819,
-0.5209316611289978,
-0.7951294779777527,
0.5969573855400085,
0.3335588276386261,
-0.19240128993988037,
0.2153264731168747,
0.35810399055480957,
-0.08884268999099731,
1.1427958011627197,
0.24501678347587585,
0.11090771108865738,
0.10474679619073868,
-0.012714305892586708,
0.10255932062864304,
-0.6076468229293823,
-0.4958718419075012,
-0.8200644254684448,
-0.1027253046631813,
-0.07626649737358093,
-0.3000167906284332,
0.25123223662376404,
0.14009280502796173,
0.0641801580786705,
0.3315331041812897,
-0.5371482372283936,
0.6254967451095581,
0.3035880923271179,
-0.0015187490498647094,
0.5046250820159912,
-0.15815526247024536,
0.5615003705024719,
0.20651766657829285,
-0.4221962094306946,
-0.5111621618270874,
0.6986101269721985,
0.5365424752235413,
0.7151866555213928,
0.00812238734215498,
0.34434226155281067,
0.23049797117710114,
-0.4158376455307007,
-1.0380563735961914,
0.5994333028793335,
0.1414915770292282,
-0.6617907285690308,
-0.54860520362854,
-0.3286421298980713,
-0.9938483834266663,
0.14129780232906342,
-0.11042527854442596,
-0.8894268870353699,
0.19464483857154846,
-0.010658729821443558,
-0.5312813520431519,
0.06740698218345642,
-0.5403904914855957,
0.801165759563446,
-0.1927967369556427,
0.029942765831947327,
-0.20302283763885498,
-0.3361721634864807,
0.3229072093963623,
-0.19597677886486053,
0.5144001841545105,
-0.5297398567199707,
0.1613888144493103,
0.8903862833976746,
-0.10563549399375916,
0.599203884601593,
-0.1958196610212326,
-0.37023332715034485,
0.445313423871994,
0.25228244066238403,
0.1771116703748703,
0.22270409762859344,
0.1786840260028839,
0.1580973118543625,
0.1106056496500969,
-0.19159278273582458,
-0.7222773432731628,
0.5855692625045776,
-0.5275861620903015,
-0.9228857755661011,
-0.12201187014579773,
-0.8396885991096497,
-0.4682586193084717,
-0.054486196488142014,
-0.05002962425351143,
0.3618285357952118,
-0.08265847712755203,
0.26910069584846497,
0.9321984648704529,
-0.5412523746490479,
0.496867835521698,
0.17487142980098724,
-0.5268539786338806,
0.16982561349868774,
0.8620333075523376,
-0.12461632490158081,
0.10082748532295227,
0.33413267135620117,
0.19731616973876953,
-0.5637855529785156,
-0.7162092328071594,
-0.42691516876220703,
0.3002511262893677,
-0.674905002117157,
0.17558927834033966,
-0.9082193374633789,
-0.08132822066545486,
-0.25887197256088257,
0.13696645200252533,
-0.5820003747940063,
-0.13963979482650757,
-0.6750009059906006,
-0.32897934317588806,
0.41607406735420227,
0.9569723606109619,
0.01660335063934326,
-0.09913312643766403,
-0.9450107216835022,
0.654486894607544,
0.26827773451805115,
0.1619485467672348,
0.35266321897506714,
-0.5971462726593018,
-0.17890243232250214,
-0.01282727625221014,
0.04809368774294853,
-0.961520254611969,
0.058694805949926376,
-0.10318250954151154,
0.5147780179977417,
0.4671298861503601,
0.06811420619487762,
0.6165658235549927,
-0.5231010317802429,
0.9481273889541626,
0.12545418739318848,
-0.9155452847480774,
0.6203492283821106,
-0.19261591136455536,
0.28646865487098694,
0.2979555130004883,
0.6326042413711548,
-0.44870200753211975,
-0.6032263040542603,
-0.3925148546695709,
-0.648684561252594,
0.6085980534553528,
0.11636959761381149,
0.29316022992134094,
-0.20963655412197113,
-0.049907371401786804,
0.2850094437599182,
0.07021407783031464,
-0.5247724652290344,
-0.24313518404960632,
-0.04979391768574715,
0.14649544656276703,
-0.025355687364935875,
-0.11849430203437805,
0.0958629921078682,
-0.1863960474729538,
0.31938639283180237,
0.28712284564971924,
0.06535995006561279,
0.42299023270606995,
-0.2662164568901062,
-0.050913985818624496,
0.18153069913387299,
0.7818819880485535,
0.8687549829483032,
-0.4615894854068756,
0.30286267399787903,
0.25739848613739014,
-0.3777640759944916,
0.11185574531555176,
-0.24237553775310516,
0.1186395213007927,
0.46335485577583313,
0.35228654742240906,
0.9831865429878235,
0.13900218904018402,
-1.2816321849822998,
0.41220778226852417,
0.1157524511218071,
-0.2028438299894333,
-0.5678980350494385,
0.15426310896873474,
0.22725225985050201,
0.19090555608272552,
0.7608376145362854,
-0.04445398226380348,
0.3310868740081787,
-0.7794382572174072,
0.3586430549621582,
0.4329072833061218,
-0.784905731678009,
-0.320717990398407,
0.9109558463096619,
-0.29118868708610535,
-0.5829294919967651,
0.5000226497650146,
-0.0008958560065366328,
-0.295237272977829,
0.8524291515350342,
0.46440061926841736,
0.909292995929718,
0.007977629080414772,
0.16232003271579742,
0.3865705728530884,
0.43989795446395874,
-0.41065168380737305,
0.19011805951595306,
-0.1335872858762741,
-0.4475226104259491,
-0.3860068619251251,
-0.575664758682251,
-0.5639696717262268,
0.47756004333496094,
-0.6466978192329407,
0.39562758803367615,
-0.5626385807991028,
-0.005932339001446962,
-0.14935733377933502,
-0.5978168249130249,
-0.5760279893875122,
0.06641945987939835,
0.2160332351922989,
0.6903172731399536,
-0.7600627541542053,
0.004656607750803232,
0.5084744095802307,
-0.5545322299003601,
-0.7672823071479797,
-0.0598013736307621,
-0.2689100503921509,
-0.4009118974208832,
0.8099414706230164,
0.32017970085144043,
-0.18985433876514435,
-0.2235596776008606,
-0.43843740224838257,
-0.6204954385757446,
0.4793127179145813,
0.3507141172885895,
-0.45413738489151,
-0.0390455462038517,
0.22034436464309692,
0.2973538339138031,
0.04974132776260376,
0.42535191774368286,
0.5542963743209839,
0.5741735696792603,
0.07967101782560349,
-1.0997660160064697,
0.015334893018007278,
0.08400905132293701,
-0.33678627014160156,
-0.1246333122253418,
-0.3268726170063019,
0.6311336755752563,
-0.5087860822677612,
-0.26964694261550903,
0.05457264930009842,
0.8490850925445557,
0.33388662338256836,
0.546229898929596,
0.6503002047538757,
0.16885794699192047,
0.9851267337799072,
-0.04885007068514824,
0.7555109858512878,
0.19437570869922638,
0.2522399127483368,
1.081920862197876,
-0.1998724639415741,
0.9794662594795227,
0.5226235389709473,
-0.3569985330104828,
-0.03154244273900986,
0.6826114058494568,
-0.14947934448719025,
0.19268681108951569,
0.43299996852874756,
-0.2875959277153015,
-0.2387165129184723,
-0.24545681476593018,
-0.629423975944519,
0.5816699266433716,
0.2586142420768738,
0.1331486999988556,
0.1868503987789154,
0.46562767028808594,
-0.49218830466270447,
0.11425277590751648,
-0.27424994111061096,
0.8261257410049438,
0.22377648949623108,
-0.3348742127418518,
0.7408576607704163,
-0.48711445927619934,
0.47815436124801636,
-0.29826247692108154,
-0.22652363777160645,
-0.36267659068107605,
-0.4501771628856659,
-0.3447060286998749,
-0.4817180633544922,
0.5562496781349182,
-0.10551898926496506,
-0.3260152339935303,
0.12472284585237503,
0.2530274987220764,
-0.3523362874984741,
-0.36403289437294006,
0.3719522953033447,
0.4148121178150177,
0.6998756527900696,
-0.4069184362888336,
-0.26166802644729614,
0.4813758432865143,
-0.26995599269866943,
0.09226711839437485,
-0.032515496015548706,
0.4982866048812866,
0.197079598903656,
0.7293111681938171,
0.4909375309944153,
0.1937267929315567,
0.01864403858780861,
0.3095703721046448,
0.1777058094739914,
-0.7195432186126709,
-0.2379770576953888,
-0.8132491707801819,
0.21708334982395172,
0.29537972807884216,
-0.04588070884346962,
0.7078973054885864,
0.6725533604621887,
1.1569888591766357,
-0.5690263509750366,
0.5422067642211914,
0.3743993639945984,
0.5989527702331543,
-0.724689781665802,
0.8890458345413208,
-0.835470974445343,
0.5570040345191956,
-0.5565561056137085,
-1.2365752458572388,
-0.35907265543937683,
0.7536774277687073,
-0.031784966588020325,
-0.08256734162569046,
0.777433454990387,
1.1352729797363281,
-0.07410332560539246,
0.23567795753479004,
0.6555128693580627,
0.20455577969551086,
0.05574691295623779,
0.3167457580566406,
1.4367711544036865,
-0.37082475423812866,
0.6652835011482239,
-0.13932488858699799,
0.2500552535057068,
-0.10095489025115967,
-0.5474210977554321,
-1.1281124353408813,
-0.823350727558136,
-0.4317164421081543,
0.009178964421153069,
-0.025470376014709473,
1.0062857866287231,
0.700635552406311,
-1.0626457929611206,
-0.5290643572807312,
0.0708107054233551,
0.4241882860660553,
-0.1147828921675682,
-0.29396915435791016,
0.6315603852272034,
-0.4225330948829651,
-1.084645390510559,
0.8792628645896912,
0.22899246215820312,
0.06631047278642654,
-0.3745885193347931,
-0.09534719586372375,
0.1548565924167633,
-0.16756245493888855,
0.5524877309799194,
0.3518751561641693,
-0.9515066146850586,
-0.39318087697029114,
0.2592405676841736,
0.2417484074831009,
0.11950082331895828,
0.668632984161377,
-0.5754580497741699,
0.29545795917510986,
0.5051605105400085,
0.940417468547821,
0.2817091643810272,
-0.030929265543818474,
0.2378758043050766,
-0.4770607054233551,
0.29299890995025635,
0.31930097937583923,
0.2899715304374695,
0.45704177021980286,
-0.20466703176498413,
0.24195203185081482,
0.20831270515918732,
-0.3334599733352661,
-1.1410961151123047,
0.06716449558734894,
-1.2121171951293945,
-0.5315045714378357,
1.2015224695205688,
0.37039071321487427,
0.07231618463993073,
-0.42209482192993164,
-0.5647709369659424,
0.02913350611925125,
-0.21462760865688324,
0.8072548508644104,
0.7915506362915039,
0.030724506825208664,
-0.44690948724746704,
-0.8052811026573181,
0.6166216731071472,
0.6559855937957764,
-0.5543555021286011,
0.2810031473636627,
0.5570275783538818,
-0.15997348725795746,
0.31568098068237305,
0.6357783675193787,
-0.14815226197242737,
0.4831709563732147,
-0.0071809254586696625,
-0.10989256948232651,
-0.04334128275513649,
-0.7371972799301147,
-0.2616651952266693,
0.4185832440853119,
0.3718017339706421,
-0.19512757658958435
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08398v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08398v1
|
cPAPERS: A Dataset of Situated and Multimodal Interactive Conversations in Scientific Papers
| 2024-06-12T16:46:12 | 2024-06-12T16:46:12 |
Anirudh Sundar, Jin Xu, William Gay, Christopher Richardson, Larry Heck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
An emerging area of research in situated and multimodal interactive
conversations (SIMMC) includes interactions in scientific papers. Since
scientific papers are primarily composed of text, equations, figures, and
tables, SIMMC methods must be developed specifically for each component to
support the depth of inquiry and interactions required by research scientists.
This work introduces Conversational Papers (cPAPERS), a dataset of
conversational question-answer pairs from reviews of academic papers grounded
in these paper components and their associated references from scientific
documents available on arXiv. We present a data collection strategy to collect
these question-answer pairs from OpenReview and associate them with contextual
information from LaTeX source files. Additionally, we present a series of
baseline approaches utilizing Large Language Models (LLMs) in both zero-shot
and fine-tuned configurations to address the cPAPERS dataset.
|
[
-0.50245600938797,
-0.7696747183799744,
0.7063353061676025,
0.0888335332274437,
-0.216645747423172,
0.3089851438999176,
-0.2046283781528473,
-0.6765981316566467,
0.283439964056015,
0.4683416187763214,
-0.08694110065698624,
-0.2529750168323517,
-0.4540235102176666,
0.05736251547932625,
-0.20314566791057587,
1.291674017906189,
-0.09061194956302643,
0.2848758101463318,
-0.6854192018508911,
-0.3004452884197235,
0.13767559826374054,
-0.5608178377151489,
-0.3168675899505615,
0.09915629029273987,
1.0178320407867432,
0.46332019567489624,
0.5002481937408447,
0.24584922194480896,
0.5582148432731628,
0.3124394118785858,
-0.1592114418745041,
0.3651561141014099,
-0.4374690353870392,
0.2604067027568817,
-0.0867794081568718,
-0.2539205849170685,
-0.47743964195251465,
0.025650447234511375,
0.5194244980812073,
0.8022050857543945,
-0.014425089582800865,
0.24854068458080292,
0.3139324188232422,
0.05193858966231346,
-0.49345555901527405,
0.20759162306785583,
-0.25020742416381836,
0.010809437371790409,
-0.0484296940267086,
-0.6606611013412476,
-0.45995599031448364,
-0.46125882863998413,
0.04508625715970993,
-0.564109742641449,
0.2983156442642212,
0.06584352999925613,
0.4846949279308319,
-0.3226175904273987,
-0.6321371793746948,
-0.5722268223762512,
-0.6903470158576965,
0.814232349395752,
-0.3628934621810913,
0.19496601819992065,
0.4402145445346832,
0.027237383648753166,
-0.18128928542137146,
-0.8673484325408936,
-0.6025785207748413,
-0.28978753089904785,
-0.42103007435798645,
0.25580501556396484,
-0.2496512532234192,
-0.128020241856575,
0.12217389792203903,
0.07405124604701996,
-0.5279965400695801,
-0.4104742109775543,
-0.7974295020103455,
0.16462059319019318,
0.4907279312610626,
0.2695199251174927,
0.11546177417039871,
-0.28604966402053833,
-0.306930810213089,
-0.19504022598266602,
-0.04997938871383667,
0.031293757259845734,
0.1645439714193344,
0.26998767256736755,
-0.3196040987968445,
0.80097895860672,
0.2607880234718323,
0.8998551368713379,
0.005142382811754942,
-0.1617058366537094,
-0.0007058775518089533,
-0.7040395736694336,
0.03681633993983269,
-0.03428959846496582,
0.8009217977523804,
0.30408623814582825,
-0.05251818895339966,
0.08925552666187286,
0.3558812141418457,
-0.3911319673061371,
0.20140215754508972,
-0.6432102918624878,
-0.4344213306903839,
0.3399880826473236,
-0.38514527678489685,
-0.3265315890312195,
0.19633078575134277,
-1.1274052858352661,
-0.1662999838590622,
-0.6015791893005371,
-0.002865771995857358,
-0.18385620415210724,
-0.11559153348207474,
-0.29441818594932556,
-0.0690348669886589,
0.07951506227254868,
0.6668398380279541,
-0.391830176115036,
0.4227566719055176,
0.5445396304130554,
0.9971005916595459,
-0.15971513092517853,
-0.021887581795454025,
-0.45729678869247437,
0.45361393690109253,
-0.20764560997486115,
0.9159953594207764,
-0.6527771353721619,
-0.709930419921875,
-0.016923822462558746,
-0.04633966088294983,
-0.2820521593093872,
-0.19120292365550995,
0.6716869473457336,
-0.5590068101882935,
0.7593356370925903,
-0.33368054032325745,
-0.12943653762340546,
0.09769414365291595,
0.5383138656616211,
-0.3925381302833557,
0.8571149706840515,
-0.258902907371521,
-1.2403172254562378,
-0.0400361530482769,
-0.7836621403694153,
-0.23473423719406128,
0.17611590027809143,
-0.5737296938896179,
0.03507872298359871,
-0.11158435046672821,
0.08498318493366241,
0.39655059576034546,
-0.06969410181045532,
0.3427727222442627,
-0.26612505316734314,
0.12797188758850098,
0.7393497824668884,
-0.23092927038669586,
0.4665934443473816,
0.4570828080177307,
0.3407893478870392,
0.12271010875701904,
-0.7017147541046143,
0.20724137127399445,
-0.038186777383089066,
-0.4985831677913666,
-0.6246795654296875,
0.1105509102344513,
0.4124143123626709,
0.03179313242435455,
0.19387969374656677,
-0.764216959476471,
0.10173871368169785,
0.2921260595321655,
0.4150397777557373,
0.2742716073989868,
0.21939460933208466,
0.13270887732505798,
-0.5073105096817017,
0.5350898504257202,
0.0642140582203865,
0.02738771215081215,
-0.6034559607505798,
-0.38316774368286133,
-0.6648533344268799,
-0.1787714958190918,
0.1342380940914154,
0.24977141618728638,
-0.5433778166770935,
0.009333929978311062,
-0.18048961460590363,
-0.4552662670612335,
-0.17622943222522736,
-0.12310750782489777,
0.58788001537323,
0.8891896605491638,
0.42499014735221863,
-0.14597570896148682,
-0.5080991983413696,
-0.7810924649238586,
0.1210889145731926,
-0.26811620593070984,
-0.2021012008190155,
0.6428646445274353,
0.36555546522140503,
0.2765789330005646,
1.0128536224365234,
-0.7127102017402649,
0.058948058634996414,
-0.008147744461894035,
0.5335034132003784,
-0.18088360130786896,
0.5011367797851562,
0.46551713347435,
-0.9375768303871155,
-0.43831855058670044,
-0.052934013307094574,
-0.7402254343032837,
-0.0892874151468277,
0.05419686436653137,
0.06718899309635162,
0.039471954107284546,
0.8023825287818909,
-0.28150102496147156,
0.009628942236304283,
0.7543788552284241,
-0.0033804206177592278,
0.2825588285923004,
-0.19022239744663239,
0.5274006128311157,
-1.2356340885162354,
0.38074779510498047,
0.14673416316509247,
-0.07727067172527313,
-0.5712486505508423,
-0.337367981672287,
-0.18057361245155334,
-0.24624204635620117,
-0.45689019560813904,
0.5631795525550842,
-0.615717887878418,
0.09539825469255447,
0.05008896067738533,
0.5388751029968262,
0.2503766119480133,
0.2585155963897705,
0.5367963910102844,
0.8712754249572754,
0.07291816174983978,
-0.4176267385482788,
-0.2678580582141876,
0.7749078273773193,
-0.18337802588939667,
0.7615809440612793,
-0.7679952383041382,
0.37640610337257385,
-0.09393613040447235,
0.4914172887802124,
-1.0236992835998535,
-0.4548417627811432,
0.25860491394996643,
-0.3688156008720398,
0.06395814567804337,
-0.3184991180896759,
-0.37668150663375854,
0.02011803537607193,
-0.21832984685897827,
0.6442082524299622,
-0.0709473043680191,
-0.3777766525745392,
0.401365727186203,
0.6591671109199524,
-0.8579003810882568,
-0.3403444290161133,
-0.4415190517902374,
0.3309098482131958,
-0.023874975740909576,
-0.5039246678352356,
0.19924618303775787,
-0.23194560408592224,
-0.5600289106369019,
-0.17600588500499725,
0.23015008866786957,
-0.13867440819740295,
-0.6940645575523376,
0.25747331976890564,
0.21794846653938293,
-0.15936024487018585,
0.029376063495874405,
-0.15556856989860535,
0.15178453922271729,
0.011659236624836922,
0.30759286880493164,
0.4859856367111206,
-0.2336135357618332,
-0.5523315072059631,
0.12441299110651016,
0.5967063307762146,
0.5006104111671448,
0.008819732815027237,
0.4710101783275604,
0.1995728611946106,
-0.05618232861161232,
0.30322888493537903,
-0.6166298985481262,
0.06568078696727753,
-0.4306377172470093,
0.005366429220885038,
-0.21273793280124664,
-1.0851404666900635,
0.4849797189235687,
-0.01335509680211544,
0.011883236467838287,
-0.1602717638015747,
0.4177515208721161,
-0.37494757771492004,
0.9585675001144409,
0.49120083451271057,
0.5176591873168945,
0.394600510597229,
0.07669737190008163,
0.12693560123443604,
-1.0333905220031738,
-0.7717902660369873,
-0.897478461265564,
-0.14364734292030334,
-0.3408244550228119,
-0.8809464573860168,
0.7308758497238159,
0.007230401039123535,
-0.17910809814929962,
0.22855563461780548,
-0.5048505067825317,
0.4049049913883209,
0.4370223879814148,
0.13926921784877777,
0.5220497250556946,
-0.014585752971470356,
-0.13692356646060944,
-0.3226817548274994,
-0.8266106843948364,
-0.9129616618156433,
0.6254913806915283,
0.2000228613615036,
0.9227482080459595,
-0.07844848930835724,
0.12246190756559372,
-0.040317103266716,
0.23983646929264069,
-0.5402776598930359,
0.7047684788703918,
0.34777674078941345,
-0.322711318731308,
0.16641224920749664,
-0.3638865649700165,
-1.056167483329773,
0.31807953119277954,
-0.24898940324783325,
-0.7614080905914307,
0.3624812960624695,
0.12890690565109253,
-0.22928547859191895,
0.2982112765312195,
-0.24668587744235992,
0.45219799876213074,
-0.6581789255142212,
-0.7930030226707458,
-0.022843817248940468,
-0.8907297849655151,
0.41819900274276733,
-0.06899037957191467,
0.3607169985771179,
0.199039027094841,
0.0424148365855217,
0.8683107495307922,
-0.18341213464736938,
0.9001516699790955,
0.1504712700843811,
-0.054266929626464844,
0.5237333178520203,
0.17676974833011627,
0.028272811323404312,
0.16531501710414886,
-0.02011512964963913,
0.24276283383369446,
0.5418334603309631,
-0.1971062272787094,
-0.12514156103134155,
0.7684178948402405,
-0.6241636276245117,
-0.24702270328998566,
-0.8799158334732056,
-0.7093352675437927,
-0.33443573117256165,
0.05184096470475197,
-0.03793828934431076,
0.4633309245109558,
-0.5619677901268005,
0.44635406136512756,
0.6165324449539185,
-0.37886112928390503,
0.37924203276634216,
0.7143434286117554,
-0.08721357583999634,
-0.6334453225135803,
0.2108955979347229,
0.013761885464191437,
0.1679389625787735,
0.4015682637691498,
0.1220722496509552,
-0.1231713742017746,
-0.3440950810909271,
-0.07813854515552521,
0.20879246294498444,
-0.4623166620731354,
-0.2379285842180252,
-1.1307435035705566,
-0.21592609584331512,
-0.4880210757255554,
-0.3239746689796448,
0.09757562726736069,
-0.5142592787742615,
-0.3491451144218445,
0.03245483338832855,
0.4790011942386627,
0.7069909572601318,
-0.3489948511123657,
0.18036861717700958,
-1.083935022354126,
0.30518531799316406,
0.23878847062587738,
0.12740124762058258,
-0.05080074071884155,
-0.20677921175956726,
-0.1662466675043106,
0.21657954156398773,
-0.4221562147140503,
-0.80903160572052,
0.4160749316215515,
0.018133969977498055,
0.5628100037574768,
0.38819241523742676,
0.08161367475986481,
0.8042148947715759,
-0.34138166904449463,
0.9493600726127625,
0.31456419825553894,
-0.4693838655948639,
0.6308004856109619,
-0.8887147903442383,
0.05735669657588005,
0.6281725168228149,
0.6519388556480408,
-0.6296347379684448,
-0.030264537781476974,
-0.5374851822853088,
-0.6544018983840942,
0.7085695266723633,
0.12635912001132965,
0.19186119735240936,
-0.19523756206035614,
0.19432370364665985,
-0.06173352152109146,
0.4890575110912323,
-0.5348565578460693,
0.31616729497909546,
-0.02776467241346836,
0.015190348960459232,
-0.18020935356616974,
-0.3448265790939331,
-0.8555740714073181,
-0.060486502945423126,
0.21795064210891724,
-0.3728429973125458,
0.12954063713550568,
0.4273776113986969,
0.26709359884262085,
-0.34936022758483887,
0.4320772588253021,
0.7468910813331604,
0.7723263502120972,
-0.3379448652267456,
0.4668598771095276,
-0.03270022198557854,
-0.5454350709915161,
-0.2187507152557373,
-0.019789762794971466,
-0.004461959004402161,
-0.12508846819400787,
0.2623823583126068,
0.3718026280403137,
0.3283308148384094,
-0.736298680305481,
0.2512291967868805,
-0.2292783409357071,
-0.21916206181049347,
-0.3780827522277832,
-0.14884892106056213,
0.18436922132968903,
0.09731350839138031,
0.31481415033340454,
0.08910627663135529,
-0.011982533149421215,
-0.5872572064399719,
0.25521108508110046,
0.49368634819984436,
-0.6650881171226501,
-0.3646923303604126,
0.6490278840065002,
0.21389882266521454,
-0.32764601707458496,
0.36729347705841064,
0.4931795299053192,
-0.2167896330356598,
0.47366127371788025,
0.5407945513725281,
0.3975773751735687,
0.14655379951000214,
0.4020788073539734,
0.3114495873451233,
-0.035709843039512634,
0.12132248282432556,
0.2579197883605957,
-0.31286075711250305,
-0.5278867483139038,
-0.16579605638980865,
-0.43034330010414124,
-1.1254613399505615,
0.2650071680545807,
-0.8623602390289307,
0.30750393867492676,
-0.3367423117160797,
-0.09112946689128876,
0.18122677505016327,
-0.15234054625034332,
-0.23395518958568573,
-0.06793748587369919,
-0.08509205281734467,
0.8359512090682983,
-0.8200355768203735,
0.5591947436332703,
0.8698806762695312,
-0.5803850889205933,
-0.49709418416023254,
-0.04856519773602486,
0.050077252089977264,
-0.3684414029121399,
0.613889217376709,
-0.4251490831375122,
-0.2733571231365204,
-0.3209925889968872,
-1.1121760606765747,
-0.6898735165596008,
0.7960242629051208,
0.3267444372177124,
-0.35420113801956177,
0.2784218490123749,
0.25202909111976624,
0.9234981536865234,
-0.30836203694343567,
0.46504443883895874,
-0.05750282108783722,
0.5484442710876465,
0.5552330017089844,
-0.8712387681007385,
-0.2599675953388214,
-0.6215791702270508,
-0.32639557123184204,
0.08338461071252823,
-0.9741926193237305,
0.7508074045181274,
-0.11443540453910828,
0.06530441343784332,
0.018774494528770447,
0.517866849899292,
0.7748932838439941,
0.6497046947479248,
0.2594127357006073,
0.21454554796218872,
0.4428318440914154,
0.013917687349021435,
0.7586233615875244,
-0.3492749333381653,
-0.0564890094101429,
1.459090232849121,
-0.5467768907546997,
0.9714385867118835,
0.9181672930717468,
-0.026334313675761223,
0.4665891230106354,
0.43394947052001953,
-0.01787343993782997,
0.2975323796272278,
0.16833116114139557,
-0.5171660780906677,
-0.0685126855969429,
-0.5134567022323608,
-0.387967586517334,
0.2611217200756073,
0.5058272480964661,
-0.13133539259433746,
-0.2009294629096985,
0.060524832457304,
0.389797568321228,
0.2999557852745056,
0.10549342632293701,
0.9690962433815002,
0.16120506823062897,
-0.7797009944915771,
-0.16377268731594086,
-0.16615813970565796,
0.29863661527633667,
-0.7050765752792358,
-0.38182803988456726,
-0.085015207529068,
-0.000007112616003723815,
-0.2590482234954834,
-1.0907564163208008,
0.2350773811340332,
0.21448026597499847,
-0.07569506019353867,
-0.48946574330329895,
0.6523586511611938,
-0.575325071811676,
-0.5843552947044373,
0.11192752420902252,
0.5969764590263367,
0.3057951331138611,
0.5929493308067322,
-0.53916996717453,
0.11154424399137497,
-0.33504679799079895,
-0.2326878011226654,
0.6037245392799377,
0.33135324716567993,
-0.22164632380008698,
0.4354506731033325,
0.8150981664657593,
0.10548117011785507,
-0.09057941287755966,
-0.14616791903972626,
1.1390661001205444,
-0.37409645318984985,
-0.35622555017471313,
-0.01071056630462408,
0.5280587077140808,
-0.20469757914543152,
-0.37048447132110596,
0.7990068793296814,
0.889647901058197,
0.640109658241272,
0.019182875752449036,
0.9113336205482483,
-0.3800830543041229,
0.9506301283836365,
-0.2578127682209015,
0.5257794260978699,
-0.31790050864219666,
0.1531294584274292,
-0.4917616844177246,
-0.7504414319992065,
-0.2946476936340332,
0.7693751454353333,
-0.3664810061454773,
0.11974509060382843,
0.5159666538238525,
0.7567206025123596,
-0.5781012773513794,
0.18797630071640015,
-0.04890058562159538,
0.17161977291107178,
0.3208998739719391,
0.0645153671503067,
1.0202906131744385,
-0.34011152386665344,
0.6495216488838196,
-0.22020304203033447,
-0.19644607603549957,
-0.06086362153291702,
-1.328550100326538,
-0.8367649912834167,
-0.7798154354095459,
-0.6084358096122742,
-0.4670475423336029,
0.1306614726781845,
0.7282357215881348,
0.4920842945575714,
-0.8883691430091858,
-0.4314024746417999,
0.1539727747440338,
-0.3714821934700012,
0.29519355297088623,
-0.26017242670059204,
0.4988080859184265,
-0.059093937277793884,
-0.771587073802948,
0.6200896501541138,
0.11265357583761215,
0.18948063254356384,
-0.1822342425584793,
0.0620160736143589,
-0.43141794204711914,
0.3839060962200165,
0.46434909105300903,
0.5385659337043762,
-0.15841861069202423,
-0.279682993888855,
0.2136455476284027,
-0.10429736226797104,
0.22067947685718536,
1.226727843284607,
-0.6100091934204102,
0.45903024077415466,
0.6939369440078735,
-0.018269255757331848,
0.683830201625824,
0.5076305866241455,
0.4835754334926605,
-0.7971897125244141,
0.21286694705486298,
0.44194871187210083,
0.19974879920482635,
0.30055615305900574,
-0.07176124304533005,
0.4695591628551483,
-0.1658119261264801,
-0.8299301862716675,
-0.9170570969581604,
-0.11893254518508911,
-1.6070423126220703,
-0.26426228880882263,
1.0276623964309692,
-0.2139931172132492,
0.3000853359699249,
-0.4026321470737457,
-0.5762978792190552,
0.014775412157177925,
-0.2464698702096939,
0.7475544214248657,
0.38000190258026123,
-0.5842776894569397,
-0.4251803457736969,
-0.4988969564437866,
0.24365611374378204,
0.07628613710403442,
-1.0912474393844604,
0.05368592217564583,
0.7904043197631836,
0.09349033236503601,
0.6369406580924988,
0.8252668380737305,
-0.5691993832588196,
-0.28656846284866333,
-0.06819473952054977,
-0.09451586753129959,
-0.04471832513809204,
-0.3354850709438324,
-0.14442910254001617,
0.6717610359191895,
-0.14491944015026093,
0.05086083710193634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08391v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08391v1
|
Large Language Models Must Be Taught to Know What They Don't Know
| 2024-06-12T16:41:31 | 2024-06-12T16:41:31 |
Sanyam Kapoor, Nate Gruver, Manley Roberts, Katherine Collins, Arka Pal, Umang Bhatt, Adrian Weller, Samuel Dooley, Micah Goldblum, Andrew Gordon Wilson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
When using large language models (LLMs) in high-stakes applications, we need
to know when we can trust their predictions. Some works argue that prompting
high-performance LLMs is sufficient to produce calibrated uncertainties, while
others introduce sampling methods that can be prohibitively expensive. In this
work, we first argue that prompting on its own is insufficient to achieve good
calibration and then show that fine-tuning on a small dataset of correct and
incorrect answers can create an uncertainty estimate with good generalization
and small computational overhead. We show that a thousand graded examples are
sufficient to outperform baseline methods and that training through the
features of a model is necessary for good performance and tractable for large
open-source models when using LoRA. We also investigate the mechanisms that
enable reliable LLM uncertainty estimation, finding that many models can be
used as general-purpose uncertainty estimators, applicable not just to their
own uncertainties but also the uncertainty of other models. Lastly, we show
that uncertainty estimates inform human use of LLMs in human-AI collaborative
settings through a user study.
|
[
-0.29850131273269653,
-0.9069350361824036,
0.8352482914924622,
-0.10512189567089081,
0.264474093914032,
-0.04223480820655823,
-0.3684133291244507,
-0.4500025510787964,
-0.3059197664260864,
0.4994999170303345,
-0.38204944133758545,
-0.2744499444961548,
-0.6461957693099976,
-0.3832007348537445,
-0.34101054072380066,
0.7244938015937805,
0.029436634853482246,
-0.07837425172328949,
-0.18939249217510223,
0.028294455260038376,
-0.24571993947029114,
-0.25649943947792053,
-0.6628352999687195,
-0.64520663022995,
0.7823447585105896,
0.600294291973114,
0.9928444027900696,
0.5789565443992615,
0.12633638083934784,
0.21600623428821564,
-0.12134689837694168,
0.20017816126346588,
-0.4665067791938782,
0.06686604022979736,
-0.1716713309288025,
-0.9027341604232788,
-0.2225407212972641,
0.11107414215803146,
0.6150557994842529,
0.9473394155502319,
-0.31815245747566223,
0.24147051572799683,
0.08682853728532791,
0.7931828498840332,
-0.8188799619674683,
0.12445899099111557,
-0.6952403783798218,
-0.1584964096546173,
-0.11174428462982178,
0.10352674871683121,
-0.38718652725219727,
-0.4720538556575775,
0.20967994630336761,
-0.7941188216209412,
-0.13394203782081604,
0.19446827471256256,
0.6785956621170044,
0.5605869293212891,
-0.4146823287010193,
-0.33533549308776855,
-0.9596378803253174,
0.9823969006538391,
-0.6890267133712769,
0.1391693651676178,
0.9547333121299744,
0.24567005038261414,
-0.4794958531856537,
-0.3735469579696655,
-0.452822208404541,
-0.17937059700489044,
0.42112016677856445,
-0.22654208540916443,
0.07534172385931015,
0.18321076035499573,
0.3613192141056061,
0.28190144896507263,
-0.14338426291942596,
0.6790040135383606,
-0.25739413499832153,
-0.28673890233039856,
0.429151326417923,
-0.04979892820119858,
-0.06318981200456619,
0.1630242019891739,
-0.23783095180988312,
-0.2189437299966812,
-1.2055578231811523,
0.17529183626174927,
0.6160631775856018,
0.2505761682987213,
-0.17578449845314026,
0.4915789067745209,
0.02399478107690811,
0.7397757768630981,
0.10469204187393188,
-0.1563166230916977,
-0.1258939653635025,
0.08577582985162735,
-0.2496441900730133,
-0.34462666511535645,
0.8963883519172668,
0.07648129761219025,
0.7941716909408569,
-0.016748838126659393,
-0.24405106902122498,
-0.008085692301392555,
0.022978628054261208,
-0.44192975759506226,
0.075050950050354,
0.421613872051239,
0.21749496459960938,
-0.2595411539077759,
-0.0557781420648098,
-0.6893584132194519,
-0.6046123504638672,
-0.36776232719421387,
0.5907372236251831,
-0.17302897572517395,
-0.012659587897360325,
0.22437773644924164,
0.2618356943130493,
0.16214214265346527,
0.526669442653656,
-1.005448341369629,
0.18282988667488098,
0.6199274659156799,
0.2723533809185028,
0.11302744597196579,
-0.5254348516464233,
-0.7259804606437683,
0.14885251224040985,
-0.6924049258232117,
0.5811943411827087,
-0.36229807138442993,
-0.3203904330730438,
0.1291949599981308,
-0.32688868045806885,
0.09192897379398346,
-0.4902295768260956,
0.3698475658893585,
-0.4676263928413391,
0.15290704369544983,
-0.4392286241054535,
-0.6646055579185486,
-0.005739483516663313,
0.133605495095253,
-0.572497546672821,
1.1304569244384766,
0.22786696255207062,
-0.6039013862609863,
0.3532252311706543,
-0.23968704044818878,
-0.12548549473285675,
0.04837942495942116,
-0.22132734954357147,
-0.19781436026096344,
0.3634050786495209,
0.43283388018608093,
0.465376079082489,
-0.34391066431999207,
0.4773281216621399,
-0.2708282768726349,
-0.5192756056785583,
0.36655324697494507,
-0.6963357329368591,
0.582693338394165,
0.19846604764461517,
-0.023959174752235413,
-0.04588685557246208,
-0.29519179463386536,
0.11269132047891617,
-0.10533548146486282,
-0.5769162774085999,
-0.1243622824549675,
0.07332824915647507,
-0.26736339926719666,
0.01311767939478159,
0.3155553340911865,
-0.21788890659809113,
-0.00800007488578558,
-0.5071300268173218,
0.48286759853363037,
0.9988313317298889,
-0.0993480384349823,
0.4305900037288666,
-0.5919592976570129,
0.6001843810081482,
-0.14772365987300873,
0.05304572731256485,
-0.17729128897190094,
-0.38510581851005554,
-0.6832684278488159,
0.07228738814592361,
0.44835126399993896,
0.5457248687744141,
-0.5129784941673279,
0.4659471809864044,
-0.06658517569303513,
-0.5840330719947815,
-0.5076822638511658,
0.540759265422821,
0.3679817318916321,
0.4086587727069855,
0.044870924204587936,
0.04341699928045273,
-0.35950127243995667,
-0.4768141806125641,
-0.15419621765613556,
-0.5529701709747314,
-0.09587167948484421,
0.3830350935459137,
0.43278542160987854,
-0.00998371746391058,
0.9553059339523315,
-0.24158963561058044,
0.0029362270142883062,
-0.08231482654809952,
0.28461772203445435,
-0.0009036945411935449,
0.3572494685649872,
0.3641882836818695,
-0.5915359258651733,
-0.22404953837394714,
-0.19324660301208496,
-0.7445427775382996,
0.08780322968959808,
0.004478232003748417,
0.01652734912931919,
0.15732017159461975,
0.6392518281936646,
-0.6034972071647644,
0.3074834942817688,
0.8816096186637878,
0.09860462695360184,
0.5147680044174194,
-0.5763886570930481,
-0.13420186936855316,
-1.2020872831344604,
0.024336205795407295,
0.16842147707939148,
-0.3710474669933319,
-0.3382280468940735,
0.14201316237449646,
-0.0316651314496994,
0.06451939791440964,
-0.4367552697658539,
0.7754230499267578,
-0.39451345801353455,
-0.12130088359117508,
-0.36120277643203735,
0.38948556780815125,
0.0683557465672493,
0.1600721925497055,
-0.17268376052379608,
0.8911129832267761,
0.6036324501037598,
-0.6120584607124329,
0.26053136587142944,
-0.049069181084632874,
-0.8365302681922913,
0.6055892109870911,
-0.6342052817344666,
0.08802113682031631,
-0.1061062291264534,
0.2543741762638092,
-0.7484799027442932,
-0.5637211799621582,
-0.09395766258239746,
-0.46276190876960754,
0.3383755683898926,
-0.19424907863140106,
-0.5292624831199646,
-0.39123547077178955,
-0.029254872351884842,
0.18548522889614105,
0.7644160985946655,
-0.38672637939453125,
0.44231536984443665,
0.4216262400150299,
0.0024137566797435284,
-0.9272763133049011,
-0.7358430027961731,
0.06101656332612038,
-0.14039528369903564,
-0.27827638387680054,
-0.14442485570907593,
-0.23552308976650238,
-0.38734525442123413,
-0.2346460074186325,
-0.023534314706921577,
-0.29383477568626404,
0.5170978307723999,
0.609105110168457,
0.14632371068000793,
-0.2275485396385193,
0.4446404278278351,
-0.10182546824216843,
-0.04639572277665138,
0.1399868130683899,
-0.31054016947746277,
0.4215211570262909,
-0.013452517800033092,
-0.9356736540794373,
-0.4996849596500397,
-0.0009291282040067017,
0.5601304173469543,
0.0005425162380561233,
0.658649742603302,
0.49143701791763306,
-0.5970661044120789,
-0.3374043405056,
-0.8456414341926575,
-0.3019895851612091,
-0.48253631591796875,
0.2917172312736511,
-0.01926426775753498,
-1.0355875492095947,
0.5052527189254761,
-0.09551531076431274,
-0.02505272626876831,
0.25423964858055115,
0.6126155257225037,
-0.3233378231525421,
0.7496293187141418,
0.7336944937705994,
-0.4938598871231079,
0.3915632665157318,
0.10023476183414459,
-0.05718265101313591,
-0.5682118535041809,
0.14799411594867706,
-0.7836217880249023,
-0.06867120414972305,
-0.5089930891990662,
-0.5010641813278198,
0.23714350163936615,
0.22035808861255646,
-0.4387865662574768,
-0.1876203715801239,
0.019097914919257164,
0.8320622444152832,
0.7502263784408569,
0.1371035873889923,
0.2651253342628479,
0.12141657620668411,
0.019379474222660065,
0.089064821600914,
-0.4580707848072052,
-0.670397162437439,
1.0184109210968018,
0.4686793088912964,
1.3112956285476685,
-0.12794363498687744,
0.597446858882904,
0.07451069355010986,
0.1617404669523239,
-1.0488673448562622,
0.24807745218276978,
0.1326102912425995,
-0.8230335712432861,
-0.6251624226570129,
-0.49647101759910583,
-0.9533053040504456,
-0.16117432713508606,
-0.12395832687616348,
-0.8753527998924255,
0.04451212286949158,
0.5532712936401367,
-0.7133755087852478,
0.32398518919944763,
-0.7285292744636536,
0.38098907470703125,
0.01571568474173546,
-0.26611992716789246,
-0.03957570344209671,
-0.5757687091827393,
0.19563212990760803,
-0.3512403666973114,
0.47021278738975525,
-0.2551218569278717,
-0.01796989142894745,
0.556675910949707,
-0.28491687774658203,
1.2775297164916992,
-0.17415595054626465,
-0.4174019396305084,
0.5895905494689941,
0.2878912389278412,
0.6923965811729431,
0.039380837231874466,
-0.3338035047054291,
-0.0728580504655838,
0.028254657983779907,
-0.37576645612716675,
-0.6009414792060852,
0.6247226595878601,
-0.9082515835762024,
-0.7910367846488953,
-0.1664801985025406,
-0.7773780226707458,
-0.5888766646385193,
-0.025113994255661964,
0.3954212963581085,
0.2061033844947815,
0.034148264676332474,
0.35082098841667175,
0.8592402935028076,
-0.17280767858028412,
0.16660557687282562,
0.21410760283470154,
-0.1082817018032074,
-0.07226971536874771,
0.5584986209869385,
0.15580792725086212,
0.6502514481544495,
0.30047133564949036,
0.5216074585914612,
-0.055297162383794785,
-0.4939962327480316,
-0.32300081849098206,
0.2557279169559479,
-0.754090428352356,
-0.07560845464468002,
-0.028899269178509712,
-0.1259351223707199,
-0.20687127113342285,
-0.3157574236392975,
-0.46900442242622375,
-0.1716659814119339,
-0.4957623779773712,
-0.19107560813426971,
0.41257694363594055,
1.0445952415466309,
-0.15817825496196747,
0.6093006134033203,
-0.6840779185295105,
-0.08296620100736618,
0.46396875381469727,
0.34616416692733765,
0.11673162132501602,
-0.6951820254325867,
-0.2764877378940582,
0.447933554649353,
-0.10744193941354752,
-0.4360051453113556,
0.10871109366416931,
0.29478803277015686,
0.6333637833595276,
0.44968271255493164,
0.13026398420333862,
0.5099031925201416,
-0.24801358580589294,
0.8323121070861816,
-0.16108325123786926,
-0.9920330047607422,
0.5832412838935852,
-0.4779052734375,
0.35144779086112976,
0.6158991456031799,
0.5627732872962952,
-0.489707350730896,
-0.2756103277206421,
-0.3068475127220154,
-0.5965195894241333,
0.5503496527671814,
-0.2309202402830124,
0.35561853647232056,
0.2460019439458847,
0.5765154361724854,
-0.14004306495189667,
0.10452032834291458,
-0.7168678045272827,
-0.0729338675737381,
0.22014574706554413,
-0.45406877994537354,
-0.3703919053077698,
-0.4395560622215271,
-0.21174854040145874,
0.11592771112918854,
0.4910900294780731,
-0.3439808487892151,
-0.02737424336373806,
-0.1307183802127838,
-0.15927064418792725,
-0.5336620211601257,
0.32779186964035034,
0.5439558029174805,
0.8170290589332581,
-0.15232746303081512,
0.11445820331573486,
0.311185747385025,
-0.3968421220779419,
0.12658920884132385,
-0.26057252287864685,
-0.04703851789236069,
-0.6320575475692749,
0.5052598118782043,
0.7013887166976929,
0.28193867206573486,
-0.8000569939613342,
0.5902765989303589,
0.1554216891527176,
-0.18299883604049683,
-0.35158753395080566,
0.28107118606567383,
0.2668246924877167,
0.1873934417963028,
0.27613651752471924,
-0.12618809938430786,
-0.4500449597835541,
-0.3528129458427429,
-0.13734863698482513,
0.3810098469257355,
-0.5135151743888855,
-0.3272465765476227,
0.4299421012401581,
-0.09308627247810364,
-0.1702849119901657,
0.5229761004447937,
0.19536708295345306,
-0.2928924560546875,
0.5254561305046082,
0.29890939593315125,
0.4265194237232208,
-0.4544737935066223,
0.1402701437473297,
0.16360868513584137,
0.3842879831790924,
-0.7141367197036743,
0.24774253368377686,
0.06270461529493332,
-0.8712137937545776,
-0.7247100472450256,
-0.5073702335357666,
-0.8719007968902588,
0.18803951144218445,
-0.6302569508552551,
0.10373840481042862,
-0.5432671904563904,
-0.23334859311580658,
-0.24096931517124176,
-0.025601064786314964,
-0.6668738126754761,
0.1999836564064026,
0.05752287805080414,
0.8920933604240417,
-0.8834087252616882,
0.7031952142715454,
0.34595760703086853,
-0.26425841450691223,
-1.1350994110107422,
-0.08194795995950699,
0.01607845164835453,
-1.0208090543746948,
0.6233513355255127,
-0.09343660622835159,
-0.150980606675148,
-0.04429050162434578,
-0.9902004599571228,
-0.9831490516662598,
0.810397744178772,
0.7363743782043457,
-0.5394365787506104,
-0.44224217534065247,
0.16271789371967316,
0.4398174583911896,
-0.09508579224348068,
0.14842142164707184,
0.17626585066318512,
0.47403112053871155,
0.3252815008163452,
-0.8971834778785706,
-0.16080297529697418,
0.4934031665325165,
-0.11805867403745651,
0.004502500873059034,
-0.4235017001628876,
0.9776667356491089,
-0.5266602039337158,
0.04956686869263649,
0.17529042065143585,
0.44953539967536926,
0.2728593945503235,
0.11357084661722183,
0.4091765880584717,
0.4063383936882019,
1.0483022928237915,
-0.16947320103645325,
1.1055852174758911,
-0.1908925473690033,
0.19026058912277222,
1.3878917694091797,
-0.3757486939430237,
1.1967328786849976,
0.535098135471344,
-0.23475654423236847,
0.3296314775943756,
0.8063516616821289,
0.12557783722877502,
-0.0031967773102223873,
0.2712612748146057,
-0.15189115703105927,
-0.5788888335227966,
-0.11341116577386856,
-0.1740623116493225,
0.4632027745246887,
0.7789499759674072,
-0.35557422041893005,
-0.09977911412715912,
-0.04949932172894478,
0.20367813110351562,
0.09721077233552933,
-0.2556447684764862,
0.6072936058044434,
0.3798450827598572,
-1.0169198513031006,
0.5225515961647034,
-0.24341145157814026,
0.4802030920982361,
-0.5143544673919678,
0.387862890958786,
-0.09677915275096893,
0.1743200421333313,
-0.017217444255948067,
-0.8514458537101746,
-0.10252001136541367,
-0.17052990198135376,
-0.05536444112658501,
0.10006696730852127,
0.37233206629753113,
-0.25315845012664795,
-0.45461028814315796,
0.0516398549079895,
0.7707006335258484,
0.16348476707935333,
-0.21984410285949707,
-0.36430585384368896,
-0.04851875826716423,
-0.2227131873369217,
-0.44890493154525757,
0.3676389753818512,
0.5067646503448486,
-0.1107805073261261,
1.023891806602478,
0.5284423232078552,
0.34415146708488464,
-0.0734177976846695,
0.01960103213787079,
0.5031191110610962,
-0.38365596532821655,
-0.07023891806602478,
-0.8858321905136108,
0.25108250975608826,
0.39819589257240295,
-0.3110507130622864,
0.5732041001319885,
0.01802327111363411,
0.8595951795578003,
0.15716469287872314,
0.8495934009552002,
0.4770102798938751,
0.4822814464569092,
-0.6344248652458191,
0.6550602912902832,
-0.38455650210380554,
0.309186190366745,
-0.00008849737059790641,
-0.7304986715316772,
-0.2329394519329071,
0.5797086954116821,
-0.44804495573043823,
0.4213032126426697,
0.3808045983314514,
0.8479174375534058,
0.1550893932580948,
-0.13957466185092926,
0.5959691405296326,
0.13122454285621643,
0.27565979957580566,
0.5985724329948425,
0.8536917567253113,
-0.3716640770435333,
0.41132795810699463,
-0.1307131052017212,
-0.10059484094381332,
-0.21241554617881775,
-1.1737134456634521,
-0.8649078607559204,
-0.5099732279777527,
-0.23294022679328918,
-0.43096718192100525,
-0.06581674516201019,
1.0695329904556274,
0.9822492003440857,
-0.683448314666748,
-0.41317543387413025,
0.0008885016432031989,
0.25153404474258423,
0.1657174676656723,
-0.05966135114431381,
0.16807052493095398,
-0.41304025053977966,
-0.8643602728843689,
0.31825941801071167,
-0.15275169909000397,
0.47347384691238403,
-0.6256652474403381,
-0.07525847852230072,
-0.10782286524772644,
0.4229828715324402,
0.23131892085075378,
0.4979507029056549,
-0.8809641003608704,
-0.4330831468105316,
-0.22547787427902222,
-0.3064800500869751,
-0.024233514443039894,
0.44427618384361267,
-0.7391495704650879,
0.26965850591659546,
0.3108009397983551,
0.7782363295555115,
0.21267962455749512,
-0.040202587842941284,
0.6753595471382141,
-0.9037296175956726,
0.0028431222308427095,
0.03757433220744133,
0.40598440170288086,
0.48532143235206604,
-0.3539411723613739,
0.3672068119049072,
-0.11239267885684967,
-0.8677133917808533,
-0.9111555814743042,
0.42590978741645813,
-0.5889137387275696,
-0.008913062512874603,
1.150312066078186,
-0.2845323979854584,
-0.3845002055168152,
-0.056611157953739166,
-0.08121868968009949,
-0.002755584893748164,
-0.4211399257183075,
0.6125175952911377,
1.0529338121414185,
0.30566057562828064,
-0.13129177689552307,
-0.7689228653907776,
0.4399265646934509,
0.17270155251026154,
-0.8253019452095032,
0.30666038393974304,
0.4165705442428589,
0.28406158089637756,
0.07457774877548218,
0.2587997615337372,
0.2238772064447403,
0.07693877816200256,
-0.008376163430511951,
-0.015272585675120354,
0.024797936901450157,
-0.19629359245300293,
-0.41548311710357666,
0.055102523416280746,
0.7832105755805969,
0.30562302470207214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08380v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08380v1
|
Towards Unsupervised Speech Recognition Without Pronunciation Models
| 2024-06-12T16:30:58 | 2024-06-12T16:30:58 |
Junrui Ni, Liming Wang, Yang Zhang, Kaizhi Qian, Heting Gao, Mark Hasegawa-Johnson, Chang D. Yoo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Recent advancements in supervised automatic speech recognition (ASR) have
achieved remarkable performance, largely due to the growing availability of
large transcribed speech corpora. However, most languages lack sufficient
paired speech and text data to effectively train these systems. In this
article, we tackle the challenge of developing ASR systems without paired
speech and text corpora by proposing the removal of reliance on a phoneme
lexicon. We explore a new research direction: word-level unsupervised ASR.
Using a curated speech corpus containing only high-frequency English words, our
system achieves a word error rate of nearly 20% without parallel transcripts or
oracle word boundaries. Furthermore, we experimentally demonstrate that an
unsupervised speech recognizer can emerge from joint speech-to-speech and
text-to-text masked token-infilling. This innovative model surpasses the
performance of previous unsupervised ASR models trained with direct
distribution matching.
|
[
-0.2585049271583557,
-0.031952522695064545,
0.18074488639831543,
-0.1390179544687271,
-0.48248228430747986,
0.44452765583992004,
-0.30463314056396484,
-0.29933497309684753,
0.3147203326225281,
0.6986681818962097,
-0.2269628345966339,
-0.4220734238624573,
-0.5401025414466858,
0.08577290922403336,
-0.7941960692405701,
0.5048044919967651,
0.39088308811187744,
0.2689611613750458,
-0.28523650765419006,
-0.22605721652507782,
-0.3125735819339752,
-0.7122637033462524,
-0.5669729113578796,
-0.6104304790496826,
0.004949562717229128,
0.3852710723876953,
0.4957137107849121,
0.47290199995040894,
0.2061614841222763,
0.2972142994403839,
-0.35712480545043945,
0.2315986007452011,
0.10578509420156479,
-0.22331193089485168,
0.09489725530147552,
-0.27362000942230225,
-0.3150057792663574,
0.046467799693346024,
0.7494245767593384,
1.2731742858886719,
-0.2545749247074127,
-0.19578981399536133,
0.34485670924186707,
0.6267420649528503,
-0.4967133700847626,
0.09861760586500168,
-0.8361384272575378,
0.049969688057899475,
-0.3929060399532318,
-0.10624615848064423,
-0.3525547683238983,
0.0406365841627121,
0.1209997683763504,
-0.6290343999862671,
0.3522738814353943,
-0.058356981724500656,
0.4355035126209259,
0.324999064207077,
-0.36185139417648315,
-0.4244476854801178,
-0.8549529314041138,
0.4499254822731018,
-0.44708141684532166,
0.7069350481033325,
0.4423004388809204,
-0.09861251711845398,
-0.14466048777103424,
-0.5178858637809753,
-0.5151598453521729,
-0.017216363921761513,
0.05371967703104019,
0.21016627550125122,
-0.38189321756362915,
0.17756476998329163,
0.256234735250473,
0.35903242230415344,
-0.5604703426361084,
0.10325416177511215,
-0.5444085597991943,
-0.2683950662612915,
0.4225538671016693,
-0.20485731959342957,
0.1271917223930359,
-0.24920661747455597,
-0.24318957328796387,
-0.12859544157981873,
-0.4530462920665741,
0.4122377038002014,
0.11950432509183884,
0.5723429918289185,
0.05280815809965134,
0.7010546922683716,
-0.08212477713823318,
0.31029224395751953,
0.12610088288784027,
0.041420917958021164,
0.40005290508270264,
0.13729830086231232,
-0.1661228984594345,
0.5406962037086487,
0.8795090913772583,
-0.09535275399684906,
0.3267614543437958,
-0.5562546253204346,
-0.5346150994300842,
0.6309829950332642,
0.060072146356105804,
-0.5157302618026733,
-0.3738339841365814,
0.008713999763131142,
-0.31858187913894653,
-0.21737311780452728,
0.21162725985050201,
-0.5394449234008789,
-0.4355275332927704,
-0.21756316721439362,
0.6029530763626099,
-0.3748309314250946,
-0.3808399438858032,
0.11807998269796371,
-0.4116221070289612,
-0.04482732340693474,
0.005326703656464815,
-0.5256614089012146,
0.7060363292694092,
0.3633185625076294,
0.6508363485336304,
-0.2396935373544693,
0.09347354620695114,
-0.7333157658576965,
0.177473247051239,
-0.6866744160652161,
0.606313169002533,
-0.6628167033195496,
-0.8901048898696899,
-0.0001904918608488515,
0.09047606587409973,
0.08326435834169388,
-0.9183319807052612,
0.5871873497962952,
-0.3894450068473816,
0.07468246668577194,
0.02717472054064274,
-0.8940044045448303,
-0.09252024441957474,
-0.3951011896133423,
-0.4628327190876007,
0.7577517032623291,
-0.41699811816215515,
-0.6047624349594116,
0.23103143274784088,
-0.9626544117927551,
-0.5305805206298828,
0.42931726574897766,
-0.07325441390275955,
0.028763094916939735,
0.24867762625217438,
0.2879955470561981,
0.17358480393886566,
-0.11621709913015366,
0.35079318284988403,
0.016882749274373055,
-0.7137117385864258,
0.09038477391004562,
-0.6338204741477966,
0.8340003490447998,
0.22429011762142181,
-0.2489495575428009,
-0.1245226114988327,
-1.3032857179641724,
0.02507219836115837,
-0.13282367587089539,
-0.3097159266471863,
-0.6993399858474731,
0.019453244283795357,
0.17773789167404175,
-0.1358879655599594,
0.241904154419899,
-0.9731947183609009,
-0.3010217845439911,
-0.7226189970970154,
0.5949769616127014,
0.38260605931282043,
-0.4340534806251526,
0.9003872275352478,
-0.006887480616569519,
0.10375504195690155,
0.14146247506141663,
-0.18453048169612885,
0.02346109040081501,
-0.35825955867767334,
-0.8992888927459717,
-0.4627404808998108,
0.38476163148880005,
0.6211608648300171,
-0.7342190146446228,
0.6425260901451111,
-0.23473750054836273,
-0.2306937575340271,
-0.7445281147956848,
0.10419706255197525,
0.3754717707633972,
0.4447925388813019,
0.4821010231971741,
-0.5538696050643921,
-0.6777823567390442,
-0.6276336312294006,
-0.15464526414871216,
-0.1559986174106598,
-0.5252023935317993,
-0.04307623207569122,
-0.05689467862248421,
-0.2339441031217575,
0.9385322332382202,
-0.21680903434753418,
-0.4673795700073242,
-0.1238207072019577,
0.17166949808597565,
0.007091968320310116,
0.5229583978652954,
-0.27936503291130066,
-0.6667875051498413,
0.007373413071036339,
-0.2318146526813507,
-0.6631783246994019,
-0.15303722023963928,
0.5360357165336609,
0.45985543727874756,
0.3420066833496094,
1.0026129484176636,
-0.5487244725227356,
0.7078769207000732,
0.4332817494869232,
-0.1171586662530899,
-0.13235951960086823,
-0.42074042558670044,
-0.33199983835220337,
-0.9917354583740234,
0.2634996771812439,
-0.03835517540574074,
-0.2162720113992691,
-0.8371365070343018,
-0.40711432695388794,
0.2566002309322357,
-0.6849222183227539,
-0.23663009703159332,
0.5849971175193787,
-0.5339093208312988,
-0.36334383487701416,
-0.5033142566680908,
0.039501603692770004,
0.04017778858542442,
0.21921253204345703,
0.33252206444740295,
0.6951693892478943,
0.6700782775878906,
-0.6512572765350342,
0.24130597710609436,
0.5356892347335815,
-0.17357602715492249,
0.3782970607280731,
-0.6621118783950806,
0.22399146854877472,
-0.2637554407119751,
0.22042901813983917,
-0.8042614459991455,
-0.03966846689581871,
-0.014792061410844326,
-0.6082802414894104,
0.40401744842529297,
-0.1929134726524353,
-0.3096371293067932,
-0.5423471331596375,
0.019709520041942596,
0.2700050175189972,
0.747196614742279,
-0.659182608127594,
0.34749284386634827,
0.67658531665802,
-0.008963823318481445,
-0.2296762764453888,
-0.5675252676010132,
0.2055966854095459,
-0.14576926827430725,
-0.26419878005981445,
0.41442838311195374,
0.07051758468151093,
-0.12204232811927795,
-0.069195456802845,
-0.24286843836307526,
-0.5077431797981262,
-0.2859203815460205,
0.6774660348892212,
0.17331339418888092,
0.06751500815153122,
0.3767538070678711,
-0.324006050825119,
-0.14660073816776276,
-0.14923062920570374,
-0.33042943477630615,
0.3592586815357208,
0.1291522979736328,
-0.18848244845867157,
-0.7740229368209839,
0.5734656453132629,
0.6026005148887634,
-0.5083131790161133,
0.128691166639328,
0.47935548424720764,
-0.5935110449790955,
-0.007261275313794613,
-0.6191542148590088,
-0.19990843534469604,
-0.527845025062561,
-0.002276137238368392,
-0.3585655391216278,
-0.9378123879432678,
0.2571027874946594,
0.13454042375087738,
-0.22700229287147522,
0.13089564442634583,
-0.09606166929006577,
-0.13475395739078522,
0.7976497411727905,
0.7117052674293518,
-0.18670780956745148,
0.36056503653526306,
0.12026997655630112,
0.2355450689792633,
-0.5891171097755432,
-0.2862115800380707,
-0.40934011340141296,
0.12882737815380096,
-0.7621189951896667,
-0.3396689295768738,
0.6544884443283081,
-0.2186352163553238,
-0.15617965161800385,
0.3711862564086914,
-0.6516352891921997,
0.3118946850299835,
0.884247362613678,
0.19562475383281708,
0.47739899158477783,
0.1712038516998291,
-0.026755940169095993,
0.23432567715644836,
-0.6095384359359741,
-0.32601964473724365,
1.1544544696807861,
-0.01588807813823223,
0.5052444934844971,
-0.41070982813835144,
0.6753170490264893,
0.29802870750427246,
-0.26468539237976074,
-0.8060094118118286,
0.7283712029457092,
-0.6718186736106873,
-0.20963463187217712,
-0.5471864938735962,
-0.4450814127922058,
-1.1132327318191528,
0.20508037507534027,
-0.07076618075370789,
-0.4360930323600769,
0.19499026238918304,
-0.01733289286494255,
-0.5907070636749268,
0.3208390772342682,
-0.4914647340774536,
0.3875182271003723,
0.34474536776542664,
0.19898755848407745,
-0.05487828701734543,
-0.5078057646751404,
0.02988908812403679,
-0.17206543684005737,
0.4071418046951294,
0.02403166890144348,
0.12430346757173538,
0.9537407159805298,
-0.6194754838943481,
0.6556558012962341,
-0.4297364056110382,
0.14858421683311462,
0.3725566864013672,
-0.05497568100690842,
0.36509907245635986,
-0.3357534110546112,
0.014901267364621162,
0.29370811581611633,
0.10545779764652252,
-0.26218926906585693,
-0.222179114818573,
0.6233261823654175,
-0.681239664554596,
-0.4450102150440216,
-0.29268980026245117,
-0.5039358735084534,
-0.5267153382301331,
0.09606391936540604,
0.39222538471221924,
0.8231958150863647,
-0.29138967394828796,
0.20147719979286194,
0.5393027067184448,
-0.1309107393026352,
0.7463331818580627,
0.4280969202518463,
0.06900577247142792,
-0.4412623643875122,
1.0031650066375732,
0.3423534631729126,
-0.026436539366841316,
0.18411247432231903,
0.20784486830234528,
-0.6538296937942505,
-0.4704132378101349,
-0.3273935317993164,
0.054166894406080246,
-0.3703520596027374,
0.043424658477306366,
-0.7919362187385559,
-0.46972766518592834,
-0.5105923414230347,
0.01659531146287918,
-0.5458256006240845,
-0.38864368200302124,
-0.5314899682998657,
0.14804960787296295,
0.34567973017692566,
0.7314509153366089,
-0.38018015027046204,
0.328203946352005,
-0.7647402882575989,
0.3409368097782135,
0.5252141952514648,
0.12940563261508942,
-0.15486803650856018,
-0.7960554361343384,
0.18830086290836334,
0.15497224032878876,
0.07711709290742874,
-0.3961053490638733,
0.6239104866981506,
0.25785648822784424,
0.09684564173221588,
0.4037378430366516,
0.4133818447589874,
0.7891998291015625,
-0.8627840876579285,
0.4716480076313019,
0.4186164438724518,
-1.1857653856277466,
0.5370321869850159,
-0.2467106282711029,
0.22773605585098267,
0.27077001333236694,
0.06565184146165848,
-0.5173758268356323,
-0.3801323473453522,
-0.704960286617279,
-0.746575117111206,
0.45789116621017456,
0.033077556639909744,
0.13993142545223236,
0.15736828744411469,
0.0794619768857956,
0.010809691622853279,
0.41327545046806335,
-0.2821986675262451,
0.05664083734154701,
-0.39012792706489563,
-0.16083601117134094,
-0.3818442225456238,
-0.07901407033205032,
0.07093825191259384,
-0.30901533365249634,
0.48096153140068054,
0.14865872263908386,
0.05946563929319382,
0.2512790858745575,
-0.16326484084129333,
-0.2006208896636963,
0.36219024658203125,
0.017649458721280098,
0.1498376727104187,
-0.23456408083438873,
0.35566943883895874,
0.03177102655172348,
-0.4430012106895447,
0.3207707405090332,
0.27531659603118896,
-0.2971123158931732,
0.2733972668647766,
-0.0896124541759491,
0.5814911723136902,
0.2630811333656311,
-0.6393134593963623,
0.7990690469741821,
0.19180329144001007,
-0.19775618612766266,
-0.6129042506217957,
-0.21985623240470886,
0.057141635566949844,
0.13898266851902008,
0.5456680059432983,
0.14946818351745605,
0.2518113851547241,
-0.39080512523651123,
0.5435542464256287,
0.694962739944458,
-0.8093063831329346,
-0.282258540391922,
0.6323891282081604,
0.4082373082637787,
-0.4457244873046875,
0.42299211025238037,
-0.20251259207725525,
-0.18627595901489258,
0.36002784967422485,
0.4855351448059082,
0.6994315385818481,
-0.4521675109863281,
0.20404276251792908,
0.02495918609201908,
0.08774539083242416,
-0.4451445937156677,
0.060996513813734055,
-0.01988835074007511,
-0.8762702941894531,
0.012098453007638454,
-0.6340790390968323,
-0.5471605658531189,
0.35034602880477905,
-0.8506587147712708,
0.24348768591880798,
-0.5133339166641235,
0.10869508236646652,
0.29456770420074463,
-0.0506388284265995,
-0.4650264382362366,
0.2763424515724182,
0.2820028066635132,
0.6753018498420715,
-0.6599985361099243,
0.9634385704994202,
0.5733054876327515,
0.000825866125524044,
-0.7512799501419067,
-0.03390621766448021,
0.0694616287946701,
-0.724666178226471,
0.3360733985900879,
0.27920156717300415,
-0.3253384232521057,
0.29464563727378845,
-0.3090309798717499,
-0.7511422038078308,
0.705033540725708,
0.22267332673072815,
-0.5211926102638245,
-0.0013270950876176357,
0.07754774391651154,
0.43379905819892883,
-0.1582956612110138,
-0.19272218644618988,
0.3475932478904724,
0.024769624695181847,
0.5109348297119141,
-1.1385256052017212,
-0.27067816257476807,
-0.06182098761200905,
0.035833604633808136,
0.08108419924974442,
-0.30338767170906067,
0.7616147398948669,
0.03780941665172577,
-0.41046011447906494,
0.22815391421318054,
0.6083319187164307,
-0.13845250010490417,
0.42507755756378174,
0.6735011339187622,
0.522972583770752,
0.9099127054214478,
0.23576299846172333,
0.41929376125335693,
-0.08883532136678696,
-0.11102108657360077,
1.001887559890747,
-0.627675473690033,
1.1263307332992554,
0.38913172483444214,
-0.09943357110023499,
0.09032495319843292,
0.22632476687431335,
0.22717787325382233,
0.5793726444244385,
0.16591130197048187,
-0.7056554555892944,
-0.4136123061180115,
-0.46516987681388855,
-0.0979245975613594,
1.1117559671401978,
0.232575923204422,
-0.09413207322359085,
-0.20034180581569672,
0.3108389973640442,
-0.11500173062086105,
0.4606402814388275,
-0.6262964010238647,
0.8356589078903198,
0.16985908150672913,
-0.20416399836540222,
0.7050781846046448,
-0.2727922201156616,
1.13545560836792,
-0.4188339412212372,
0.250588595867157,
-0.06758420169353485,
0.07590881735086441,
-0.16717036068439484,
-0.19642947614192963,
0.39742904901504517,
0.20674511790275574,
-0.24464775621891022,
-0.1055944636464119,
0.8515519499778748,
-0.7502193450927734,
-0.7025076150894165,
0.34817883372306824,
0.7681945562362671,
0.4192131459712982,
-0.3688811659812927,
-0.06859403103590012,
-0.20243069529533386,
-0.2898337244987488,
0.17129410803318024,
0.33020907640457153,
0.6363452672958374,
0.023801712319254875,
0.5752928853034973,
0.8198496103286743,
0.14606621861457825,
-0.20262637734413147,
0.07568900287151337,
0.7957515716552734,
-0.6478174924850464,
-0.5519089102745056,
-0.5355575084686279,
-0.022365983575582504,
0.07878157496452332,
0.16373120248317719,
0.3954494595527649,
0.5836323499679565,
0.7103440165519714,
0.12230205535888672,
0.9032415151596069,
0.2853049635887146,
1.0106068849563599,
-0.11145205050706863,
0.7628574967384338,
-0.649559736251831,
0.03680694103240967,
-0.3609996438026428,
-0.4598100483417511,
-0.43992879986763,
0.5427312254905701,
0.02770121954381466,
-0.3451533317565918,
0.377439945936203,
1.0124313831329346,
0.01745358109474182,
0.3488854765892029,
0.8991379141807556,
-0.01934949867427349,
-0.0787513330578804,
0.34052422642707825,
0.7244809865951538,
-0.37434086203575134,
0.774730920791626,
-0.11178214848041534,
-0.3157266080379486,
0.04342879727482796,
-0.4165327250957489,
-0.9259579181671143,
-0.706695020198822,
-0.09690701961517334,
-0.17804978787899017,
0.15444114804267883,
1.106621503829956,
0.5587286353111267,
-0.8603519797325134,
-0.39271703362464905,
-0.2983330190181732,
-0.246907576918602,
0.08002645522356033,
-0.15562032163143158,
0.35906368494033813,
-0.18343421816825867,
-0.7539859414100647,
1.0004909038543701,
0.2774379849433899,
0.22614257037639618,
0.14474624395370483,
0.07686711847782135,
0.3071005642414093,
0.04837298393249512,
0.4665651321411133,
0.4414212107658386,
-0.6872345805168152,
-0.34521228075027466,
-0.05503350868821144,
0.07284437865018845,
0.2597781717777252,
0.70637446641922,
-0.9968509674072266,
0.2821717858314514,
-0.022781159728765488,
0.5251635909080505,
0.2723284065723419,
-0.14086337387561798,
0.5016582012176514,
-0.7358905076980591,
0.5400189161300659,
0.28835317492485046,
0.29590415954589844,
0.5561975836753845,
-0.0931999534368515,
0.32127872109413147,
0.48926228284835815,
-0.23140829801559448,
-0.9551954865455627,
0.09441836178302765,
-0.8398405909538269,
-0.061855416744947433,
1.1254701614379883,
-0.05399478226900101,
0.025389578193426132,
-0.335393488407135,
-0.00550970109179616,
0.5023455023765564,
-0.6575742959976196,
0.553049623966217,
0.3344216048717499,
0.0719134658575058,
-0.09529711306095123,
-0.2313358187675476,
0.5822378396987915,
0.3259238600730896,
-0.31355947256088257,
0.24044451117515564,
0.4388178586959839,
0.33350831270217896,
0.1573329120874405,
0.8372599482536316,
-0.15819057822227478,
-0.0806933343410492,
0.045120809227228165,
0.5142686367034912,
-0.15526516735553741,
-0.37108707427978516,
-0.6318808197975159,
0.3676277697086334,
-0.07661623507738113,
-0.7044845819473267
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08353v1
|
Speech Emotion Recognition with ASR Transcripts: A Comprehensive Study on Word Error Rate and Fusion Techniques
| 2024-06-12T15:59:25 | 2024-06-12T15:59:25 |
Yuanchao Li, Peter Bell, Catherine Lai
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD
|
Text data is commonly utilized as a primary input to enhance Speech Emotion
Recognition (SER) performance and reliability. However, the reliance on
human-transcribed text in most studies impedes the development of practical SER
systems, creating a gap between in-lab research and real-world scenarios where
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) serves as the text source. Hence, this study
benchmarks SER performance using ASR transcripts with varying Word Error Rates
(WERs) on well-known corpora: IEMOCAP, CMU-MOSI, and MSP-Podcast. Our
evaluation includes text-only and bimodal SER with diverse fusion techniques,
aiming for a comprehensive analysis that uncovers novel findings and challenges
faced by current SER research. Additionally, we propose a unified ASR
error-robust framework integrating ASR error correction and modality-gated
fusion, achieving lower WER and higher SER results compared to the
best-performing ASR transcript. This research is expected to provide insights
into SER with ASR assistance, especially for real-world applications.
|
[
-0.15716570615768433,
-0.24800503253936768,
0.01651099883019924,
0.10781800001859665,
-0.15081629157066345,
0.2560340464115143,
-0.037727829068899155,
-0.5278111100196838,
0.08049521595239639,
-0.001363937626592815,
-0.3309266269207001,
-0.3358789086341858,
-0.5462075471878052,
0.398223876953125,
-0.4775450527667999,
0.48579642176628113,
0.012123780325055122,
0.45118871331214905,
-0.21767444908618927,
-0.2512267231941223,
-0.1029307022690773,
-0.7043154835700989,
-0.6277210712432861,
-0.16686132550239563,
0.5037232637405396,
0.4043765962123871,
0.21588943898677826,
0.19664481282234192,
0.4868168234825134,
0.26446855068206787,
-0.17759761214256287,
0.08442003279924393,
-0.24657100439071655,
0.2734859883785248,
0.2094598412513733,
-0.05101789906620979,
-0.3580402731895447,
-0.21468862891197205,
0.7258327007293701,
0.35382163524627686,
-0.11683379113674164,
-0.0854717418551445,
0.0772966742515564,
0.6838052272796631,
-0.7876210808753967,
-0.17089614272117615,
-0.3437961935997009,
0.35568827390670776,
-0.22382986545562744,
-0.1400327980518341,
-0.20161113142967224,
-0.45729243755340576,
0.4613523483276367,
-0.11584825068712234,
0.12659773230552673,
0.19099445641040802,
0.597357988357544,
0.4756994843482971,
-0.4924885332584381,
-0.43908533453941345,
-0.7517346143722534,
0.3848082423210144,
-0.7614115476608276,
0.6281750202178955,
0.32027673721313477,
0.2345637083053589,
0.09922908991575241,
-0.4131515920162201,
-0.718962550163269,
0.05181695520877838,
-0.014568404294550419,
0.43110254406929016,
-0.4543699622154236,
0.23663724958896637,
0.2993853688240051,
0.5437525510787964,
-0.6509157419204712,
0.14839917421340942,
-0.29054996371269226,
-0.48322492837905884,
0.589230477809906,
0.1753470003604889,
0.4121358394622803,
-0.17961876094341278,
-0.1068025678396225,
-0.5253039598464966,
-0.29808545112609863,
0.3614150285720825,
0.36145877838134766,
0.29937440156936646,
-0.0724673718214035,
0.5331510305404663,
-0.17929285764694214,
0.2557939887046814,
-0.26399141550064087,
0.16035759449005127,
0.43100523948669434,
-0.08752036839723587,
-0.18515360355377197,
0.4234279692173004,
0.9936496019363403,
0.433361291885376,
-0.18816377222537994,
-0.12368642538785934,
-0.323941707611084,
0.5226181745529175,
0.23650085926055908,
-0.5200527906417847,
0.09659983962774277,
0.34288525581359863,
-0.32995104789733887,
0.2308812439441681,
0.16967439651489258,
-1.303409457206726,
-0.6198375225067139,
-0.017563065513968468,
0.7189973592758179,
-0.5674283504486084,
-0.13248540461063385,
0.08052588254213333,
-0.4767828583717346,
0.28185686469078064,
0.04527508094906807,
-0.41556501388549805,
0.4480871558189392,
0.37013670802116394,
0.7000292539596558,
-0.2941572666168213,
-0.17205710709095,
-0.7924438118934631,
-0.1628948450088501,
0.09213201701641083,
0.6148813962936401,
-0.38980042934417725,
-0.8640956282615662,
0.36366915702819824,
-0.22036044299602509,
-0.03365097567439079,
-0.4489273428916931,
1.0834214687347412,
-0.2668110430240631,
0.20380884408950806,
-0.3895081877708435,
-0.5691947340965271,
-0.1765594184398651,
-0.13472281396389008,
-0.5750579237937927,
0.717017412185669,
-0.24357391893863678,
-0.5664023160934448,
0.010576393455266953,
-0.8787577152252197,
-0.6345327496528625,
-0.229820117354393,
0.03631579875946045,
-0.35166746377944946,
0.2603711187839508,
-0.13243368268013,
0.24412399530410767,
-0.3250194489955902,
-0.19623328745365143,
0.05474918335676193,
-0.41386276483535767,
0.4867982864379883,
-0.4914953112602234,
0.30270493030548096,
0.3067389726638794,
-0.5608319044113159,
0.17129310965538025,
-1.136856198310852,
-0.16932524740695953,
-0.25611814856529236,
-0.0943731814622879,
-0.27231210470199585,
0.15623000264167786,
0.25251102447509766,
0.1513550728559494,
0.08122963458299637,
-0.7607443928718567,
-0.2552984952926636,
-0.2513749897480011,
0.14314423501491547,
0.40996357798576355,
-0.29007118940353394,
0.28648263216018677,
-0.08382466435432434,
0.4533591568470001,
0.025296341627836227,
-0.0843329131603241,
-0.051390327513217926,
-0.13071230053901672,
-0.8412086367607117,
-0.24371905624866486,
0.278899610042572,
0.7410866022109985,
-0.5297819375991821,
0.645932674407959,
0.05061306431889534,
-0.5865164995193481,
-0.9802659749984741,
-0.4104650020599365,
0.8117961883544922,
0.806370198726654,
0.3854979872703552,
-0.5805319547653198,
-0.8177948594093323,
-0.6490845084190369,
-0.24753090739250183,
-0.18137481808662415,
-0.16477496922016144,
0.348225474357605,
0.005059080198407173,
-0.6621134281158447,
0.794636607170105,
-0.2342555969953537,
-0.25952714681625366,
0.14647702872753143,
0.7299001812934875,
-0.20460733771324158,
0.39517128467559814,
-0.009828710928559303,
-0.8708107471466064,
-0.386829137802124,
-0.09236977994441986,
-0.4601709544658661,
-0.46177881956100464,
0.3570587933063507,
0.14959019422531128,
0.5298061370849609,
-0.02053239941596985,
-0.263655424118042,
0.6136119365692139,
0.6451497673988342,
-0.4394907057285309,
0.47831282019615173,
-0.2909906804561615,
0.700718104839325,
-0.7618923187255859,
0.19284573197364807,
0.19893933832645416,
0.14118877053260803,
-0.8893556594848633,
-0.592570424079895,
-0.010121585801243782,
-0.24974122643470764,
-0.2564562261104584,
0.25860846042633057,
-0.22787585854530334,
-0.5257568955421448,
-0.37551289796829224,
0.058791134506464005,
-0.2483380287885666,
0.20405736565589905,
0.11686143279075623,
0.8576768040657043,
0.40560534596443176,
-0.5420055389404297,
0.49199628829956055,
0.591903030872345,
-0.06499631702899933,
0.5792632102966309,
-0.6548783183097839,
0.20641183853149414,
-0.13331560790538788,
0.2137037217617035,
-1.1863256692886353,
-0.3742901086807251,
0.02875974029302597,
-0.5979951024055481,
0.41320523619651794,
0.38686448335647583,
-0.4322270452976227,
-0.2523239254951477,
-0.31279173493385315,
0.18701981008052826,
0.9161020517349243,
-0.27256399393081665,
0.8238635063171387,
0.4215262830257416,
-0.455853670835495,
-0.48253098130226135,
-0.5547159314155579,
0.009363333694636822,
-0.14078618586063385,
-0.4898344576358795,
0.322520911693573,
-0.06637749820947647,
-0.055384863168001175,
-0.11721255630254745,
-0.29291608929634094,
-0.07913801074028015,
-0.11673831939697266,
0.5661619305610657,
0.2721853256225586,
0.027015846222639084,
0.1036500558257103,
0.00016258886898867786,
-0.1309375911951065,
-0.10210005193948746,
0.3867723047733307,
0.4761427938938141,
-0.20952625572681427,
-0.3296578526496887,
-0.8289474248886108,
0.6297683119773865,
0.7481858730316162,
-0.2233179211616516,
0.34230735898017883,
0.8037809133529663,
-0.38744494318962097,
0.32579904794692993,
-0.792927622795105,
-0.08668208122253418,
-0.3992381989955902,
0.09583406150341034,
-0.24419336020946503,
-0.8862484693527222,
0.5848096013069153,
-0.019697831943631172,
-0.21980349719524384,
0.4588718116283417,
0.26355645060539246,
-0.33748674392700195,
1.1324920654296875,
0.461681067943573,
-0.3492967188358307,
0.4110075533390045,
0.2253572940826416,
0.08208833634853363,
-0.929357647895813,
-0.30247750878334045,
-0.9409840703010559,
-0.3883250057697296,
-0.5130743384361267,
-0.08744557201862335,
0.5338637828826904,
-0.3693876564502716,
-0.12971772253513336,
0.15521235764026642,
-0.4636169970035553,
-0.04732991382479668,
0.6295524835586548,
-0.05722846835851669,
0.15038365125656128,
-0.06253766268491745,
0.21824748814105988,
-0.19623233377933502,
-0.43016260862350464,
-0.2940618395805359,
0.5362406969070435,
0.1595311313867569,
0.6643641591072083,
0.13929340243339539,
0.490403950214386,
0.4849831461906433,
-0.22009500861167908,
-0.6684475541114807,
0.3878682255744934,
-0.47425153851509094,
-0.08887768536806107,
-0.2527652978897095,
-0.5587784647941589,
-0.6532849669456482,
-0.0382162369787693,
-0.2773655354976654,
-0.7344549298286438,
0.2681771516799927,
0.2853454053401947,
-0.47180965542793274,
-0.026842979714274406,
-0.7335934042930603,
0.6438736915588379,
-0.207981139421463,
-0.04451365768909454,
-0.07509184628725052,
-1.0193284749984741,
-0.019229717552661896,
0.008319472894072533,
0.156342014670372,
0.018096063286066055,
-0.08412034809589386,
0.7445454597473145,
-0.13261249661445618,
0.6049879789352417,
-0.19096964597702026,
0.06605204194784164,
0.056277550756931305,
-0.15074795484542847,
0.39780136942863464,
-0.5850468277931213,
-0.3776369094848633,
0.02210899442434311,
0.06150923669338226,
0.033216141164302826,
-0.4555613398551941,
0.3116101324558258,
-0.8777598738670349,
-0.018676534295082092,
-0.5613641738891602,
-0.37687015533447266,
-0.5622060298919678,
-0.2386048138141632,
0.6511378288269043,
0.7771766781806946,
-0.1494501531124115,
0.2122301310300827,
0.7279341220855713,
-0.2978021204471588,
0.3323231339454651,
0.5435779094696045,
0.0999237522482872,
-0.6631307601928711,
1.1705085039138794,
0.002572412136942148,
0.16626307368278503,
0.32434922456741333,
0.167761892080307,
-0.533754289150238,
-0.20148546993732452,
-0.1542954295873642,
-0.011558004654943943,
-0.4855109453201294,
-0.35494479537010193,
-0.8160406947135925,
-0.23710118234157562,
-0.6578836441040039,
-0.24578100442886353,
-0.3497146964073181,
-0.19944626092910767,
-0.45959052443504333,
0.18859687447547913,
0.5276169776916504,
0.23868714272975922,
-0.30246502161026,
0.18313352763652802,
-1.2912170886993408,
0.41110122203826904,
0.40515631437301636,
0.34420856833457947,
-0.20934432744979858,
-0.536698043346405,
0.14540207386016846,
0.19963762164115906,
0.03546519577503204,
-0.9724040031433105,
0.4054792821407318,
0.6319180130958557,
0.3147115409374237,
0.34753838181495667,
0.3381298780441284,
0.7300160527229309,
-0.4577152729034424,
0.9736762046813965,
0.3905637562274933,
-1.3336199522018433,
0.6235843896865845,
-0.13480016589164734,
0.28888601064682007,
0.6439009308815002,
0.5180946588516235,
-0.7835264801979065,
-0.11186546832323074,
-0.5035431385040283,
-0.9016218781471252,
0.6228989958763123,
0.22110506892204285,
-0.18230852484703064,
0.41345685720443726,
0.11374173313379288,
0.06040695309638977,
0.30781272053718567,
-0.2143385410308838,
-0.1949610710144043,
-0.17595620453357697,
-0.6824610233306885,
-0.12191268801689148,
-0.5012574195861816,
-0.0756562128663063,
-0.12366294860839844,
0.804541289806366,
0.06455138325691223,
0.4804029166698456,
0.41797199845314026,
-0.09065710008144379,
-0.3150009214878082,
0.462924063205719,
0.6070953011512756,
-0.15579992532730103,
-0.36685681343078613,
0.15386582911014557,
0.22311261296272278,
-0.4470776617527008,
0.21750067174434662,
0.35281506180763245,
0.16725745797157288,
0.13748912513256073,
-0.12110253423452377,
0.9028787016868591,
0.42234495282173157,
-1.163105845451355,
0.4285055100917816,
-0.3016054630279541,
0.007726515643298626,
-0.178070530295372,
-0.05403144657611847,
-0.20128926634788513,
0.43755030632019043,
0.5055711269378662,
-0.03751080483198166,
0.724229097366333,
-0.662471354007721,
0.17711277306079865,
0.20898860692977905,
-0.8296085596084595,
-0.28882384300231934,
0.5161619782447815,
0.4319989085197449,
-0.5224257707595825,
0.4162028729915619,
-0.3338789939880371,
-0.9155793786048889,
0.23604685068130493,
0.5239519476890564,
1.1516526937484741,
-0.5902161002159119,
0.009424050338566303,
0.16245698928833008,
-0.24639001488685608,
-0.187545508146286,
0.4993843734264374,
-0.039703674614429474,
-0.6002557873725891,
-0.15212416648864746,
-0.6603994965553284,
-0.9593784213066101,
-0.33966442942619324,
-0.9310732483863831,
0.16812869906425476,
-0.0946526974439621,
-0.13515308499336243,
-0.2348407357931137,
-0.15606412291526794,
-0.2356167584657669,
0.34359851479530334,
0.4905707836151123,
0.6853742003440857,
-0.6612705588340759,
0.3601306080818176,
0.836702287197113,
-0.17163875699043274,
-0.5804911851882935,
-0.10030589997768402,
0.4436952769756317,
-0.27095696330070496,
0.3399551808834076,
0.1294742375612259,
-0.6125299334526062,
0.08188106119632721,
-0.2627955973148346,
-0.5133435726165771,
1.074455738067627,
0.03921204432845116,
-0.5122386813163757,
0.14302659034729004,
-0.0052620540373027325,
0.6605531573295593,
-0.11073511093854904,
0.10135692358016968,
0.7977920770645142,
0.1749228686094284,
0.4936385452747345,
-1.0090500116348267,
-0.3183441758155823,
-0.4620676040649414,
-0.0797034204006195,
0.16308629512786865,
-0.49718227982521057,
0.3337991535663605,
0.3111811876296997,
-0.34658077359199524,
-0.034826405346393585,
0.6984477043151855,
0.3248592019081116,
0.7366012334823608,
0.5715847611427307,
0.46008774638175964,
0.7568681240081787,
-0.22152860462665558,
0.7870234847068787,
0.00032205155002884567,
0.015628959983587265,
0.8087216019630432,
-0.6822633147239685,
1.134860873222351,
0.24713954329490662,
-0.28518542647361755,
0.22516615688800812,
0.3553997278213501,
0.08678248524665833,
0.5423030257225037,
0.054440658539533615,
-0.49633660912513733,
0.2670830488204956,
-0.4590061604976654,
-0.3071650266647339,
0.589267909526825,
0.4562538266181946,
0.05555698275566101,
0.2164529263973236,
0.41436347365379333,
-0.14412641525268555,
-0.06545800715684891,
-0.3269105553627014,
1.0866003036499023,
0.07056666910648346,
-0.25385305285453796,
0.1377662867307663,
-0.44957536458969116,
1.1069211959838867,
-0.6731590032577515,
0.19800551235675812,
0.001589396269991994,
-0.03423935920000076,
-0.22081664204597473,
-0.3668626546859741,
0.3413269519805908,
0.6255435347557068,
-0.1370052695274353,
-0.06667685508728027,
1.0335731506347656,
-0.7243943214416504,
-0.15833471715450287,
0.2320622056722641,
0.09823210537433624,
0.18252567946910858,
-0.036274880170822144,
-0.2583179175853729,
0.6132044196128845,
-0.14520777761936188,
0.08591943979263306,
0.22562067210674286,
0.3655379116535187,
0.6527509093284607,
0.3729552626609802,
0.4173516035079956,
0.05782419070601463,
0.03588308393955231,
0.036317117512226105,
0.6100702285766602,
-0.8015891909599304,
-0.3740161955356598,
-0.5419859290122986,
0.9353178143501282,
-0.2835330069065094,
-0.25349777936935425,
0.5545927286148071,
0.32865941524505615,
0.309902548789978,
-0.019305963069200516,
0.7609465718269348,
-0.1302817314863205,
0.8195730447769165,
-0.38412708044052124,
0.7395097613334656,
-0.6686895489692688,
-0.13313019275665283,
-0.6929111480712891,
-0.5679134726524353,
-0.3037445545196533,
0.6275675892829895,
0.09072550386190414,
-0.4366004467010498,
0.5559145212173462,
0.45004943013191223,
0.4448126256465912,
0.42810139060020447,
0.4947762191295624,
0.12168674170970917,
0.21039387583732605,
0.4635792374610901,
0.8230814933776855,
-0.6841709613800049,
0.4545535147190094,
-0.1442255973815918,
-0.20463532209396362,
-0.5773921608924866,
-0.7168781757354736,
-0.12950266897678375,
-0.9290195107460022,
-0.44452884793281555,
-0.36276572942733765,
0.13446420431137085,
1.220071792602539,
0.13522909581661224,
-0.7445147633552551,
-0.2190784066915512,
0.21902477741241455,
-0.308619886636734,
-0.0521344393491745,
-0.15682353079319,
0.28028008341789246,
-0.25805985927581787,
-0.7464617490768433,
0.4375627338886261,
0.38893038034439087,
0.21685302257537842,
0.14406177401542664,
-0.2730768322944641,
0.019676808267831802,
0.11499901115894318,
0.610430121421814,
0.587561309337616,
-0.5843417644500732,
-0.3247956931591034,
0.05818727985024452,
-0.2433527261018753,
-0.06497769057750702,
0.7078468799591064,
-0.4479258358478546,
0.6183544993400574,
0.6171530485153198,
0.9942295551300049,
0.1168094202876091,
0.02935137413442135,
0.7421145439147949,
-0.6140578389167786,
-0.124422587454319,
0.4923008680343628,
0.4418694078922272,
0.4950568675994873,
-0.11948103457689285,
0.5114706754684448,
0.15343812108039856,
-0.7575076222419739,
-1.0922757387161255,
-0.023079054430127144,
-1.2948325872421265,
0.4183608889579773,
1.1293320655822754,
-0.1685883104801178,
-0.06431584805250168,
0.13805922865867615,
-0.5281496644020081,
0.6426815390586853,
-0.659361720085144,
0.8140173554420471,
0.7064504623413086,
-0.5013083815574646,
-0.25269877910614014,
-0.05075748637318611,
0.7221145033836365,
0.36446574330329895,
-0.9592251777648926,
-0.03260485827922821,
0.7700331211090088,
-0.32436028122901917,
0.35171520709991455,
0.45769596099853516,
0.014314101077616215,
0.467556357383728,
0.07136279344558716,
0.3514713644981384,
0.32433703541755676,
-0.09470760077238083,
-0.9322018027305603,
0.10547475516796112,
-0.23885652422904968,
-0.21779604256153107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08316v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08316v2
|
Is Programming by Example solved by LLMs?
| 2024-06-12T15:16:40 | 2024-06-13T12:59:06 |
Wen-Ding Li, Kevin Ellis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
Programming-by-Examples (PBE) aims to generate an algorithm from input-output
examples. Such systems are practically and theoretically important: from an
end-user perspective, they are deployed to millions of people, and from an AI
perspective, PBE corresponds to a very general form of few-shot inductive
inference. Given the success of Large Language Models (LLMs) in code-generation
tasks, we investigate here the extent to which LLMs can be said to have
`solved' PBE. We experiment on classic domains such as lists and strings, and
an uncommon graphics programming domain not well represented in typical
pretraining data. We find that pretrained models are not effective at PBE, but
that they can be fine-tuned for much higher performance, provided the test
problems are in-distribution. We analyze empirically what causes these models
to succeed and fail, and take steps toward understanding how to achieve better
out-of-distribution generalization. Collectively these results suggest that
LLMs make strong progress toward solving the typical suite of PBE tasks,
potentially increasing the flexibility and applicability of PBE systems, while
also identifying ways in which LLMs still fall short.
|
[
-0.38505467772483826,
-0.6594902276992798,
1.0341582298278809,
0.042527783662080765,
-0.16604262590408325,
0.04711242392659187,
-0.2979498505592346,
-0.12351305782794952,
-0.33620545268058777,
0.5629611015319824,
-0.6133274435997009,
-0.5379690527915955,
-0.6631984710693359,
0.07754761725664139,
-0.539486825466156,
0.9257122278213501,
-0.005122866481542587,
-0.1570052206516266,
-0.536833643913269,
0.12233961373567581,
-0.08469768613576889,
-0.46523138880729675,
-0.39296695590019226,
-0.398550420999527,
0.13835111260414124,
0.7027052640914917,
0.7525407075881958,
0.3880964517593384,
0.5163986086845398,
0.21450017392635345,
0.20522809028625488,
0.35284173488616943,
-0.6072251796722412,
-0.08368822932243347,
-0.03128638118505478,
-0.8202856183052063,
-0.05048563703894615,
0.00945958960801363,
0.5287906527519226,
1.1555678844451904,
-0.11892319470643997,
0.1298660933971405,
0.05529212951660156,
0.4656151235103607,
-0.5554980635643005,
-0.057281482964754105,
-0.6999566555023193,
-0.20609703660011292,
-0.10334823280572891,
-0.2405729442834854,
-0.6850114464759827,
-0.2085907906293869,
-0.14449350535869598,
-0.4704260528087616,
0.3173651695251465,
0.15541189908981323,
0.5666038393974304,
0.12515291571617126,
-0.38734790682792664,
-0.8009425401687622,
-1.0129578113555908,
0.948823094367981,
-0.9169490933418274,
-0.10589349269866943,
0.20046062767505646,
0.22432784736156464,
-0.9344908595085144,
-0.6056456565856934,
-0.5101895928382874,
-0.21274110674858093,
0.025980588048696518,
-0.03170410171151161,
-0.1574835628271103,
-0.08706789463758469,
0.5283918976783752,
0.3866310715675354,
-0.5935680270195007,
0.21980266273021698,
-0.3862370550632477,
0.3581920862197876,
0.6899121999740601,
0.16345952451229095,
0.34595581889152527,
0.1341599076986313,
-0.08601599186658859,
-0.04959914833307266,
-1.2231669425964355,
0.000718733062967658,
0.33844149112701416,
0.05215292051434517,
-0.04990909621119499,
0.573236346244812,
0.06565654277801514,
0.7677953243255615,
-0.3941534161567688,
-0.09513957798480988,
-0.07038995623588562,
-0.048321109265089035,
-0.2725750207901001,
-0.5081989169120789,
0.49064359068870544,
0.11337700486183167,
0.5584530830383301,
-0.24662721157073975,
-0.4336223900318146,
0.0033233354333788157,
0.2210664302110672,
-0.5895616412162781,
-0.4378809928894043,
0.1888873279094696,
-0.5999845862388611,
-0.18865060806274414,
0.002770725404843688,
-0.3579758405685425,
-0.47641029953956604,
-0.14575618505477905,
0.4233684539794922,
-0.28560546040534973,
-0.34014439582824707,
0.0920293852686882,
-0.16267581284046173,
0.3453076481819153,
0.24598361551761627,
-0.7326292395591736,
0.35352298617362976,
0.7369970083236694,
0.660150945186615,
-0.13150350749492645,
-0.17787447571754456,
-0.3697725236415863,
-0.04998910799622536,
-0.6533468961715698,
0.8281421065330505,
-0.6012714505195618,
-0.6553131341934204,
0.055586427450180054,
-0.29810044169425964,
0.09866710007190704,
-1.005164623260498,
0.15650436282157898,
-0.23904132843017578,
-0.1472967565059662,
-0.09642641246318817,
-1.035715937614441,
0.3113482594490051,
-0.17413222789764404,
-0.14611287415027618,
0.7823732495307922,
-0.03303122520446777,
-0.4279005825519562,
0.41824501752853394,
-0.5331980586051941,
-0.24891142547130585,
0.06615754961967468,
-0.43229740858078003,
-0.5385782122612,
0.7268177270889282,
0.04588216170668602,
0.6737868189811707,
-0.5202058553695679,
0.0852213054895401,
-0.43499955534935,
-0.7496748566627502,
0.31292176246643066,
-0.12825150787830353,
0.66214519739151,
0.23174168169498444,
-0.21213845908641815,
-0.04165487363934517,
-0.5636488199234009,
0.16132070124149323,
0.6053282618522644,
-0.16759008169174194,
-0.3988473117351532,
0.1722237467765808,
-0.19916784763336182,
0.14170213043689728,
-0.12768344581127167,
-0.28579163551330566,
0.5730380415916443,
-0.15552592277526855,
0.46073466539382935,
0.7149802446365356,
0.015867015346884727,
0.5130578875541687,
-0.2914429306983948,
0.5573033690452576,
-0.043698396533727646,
0.00024320014927070588,
-0.2527306079864502,
-0.6686462759971619,
-0.6104826927185059,
-0.36973628401756287,
0.19231043756008148,
0.2247190773487091,
-0.6161538362503052,
0.16632923483848572,
0.08782102167606354,
-0.5924983024597168,
-0.04902857542037964,
0.39418959617614746,
0.28015807271003723,
0.23365901410579681,
0.21081379055976868,
-0.21709436178207397,
-0.14424633979797363,
-0.960059642791748,
-0.19636647403240204,
-0.15833522379398346,
-0.14452002942562103,
0.4654013514518738,
0.6151313781738281,
-0.20898081362247467,
0.7783781886100769,
-0.5103800296783447,
0.15696817636489868,
-0.5500394105911255,
0.35856473445892334,
0.4458419680595398,
0.42272141575813293,
0.518800675868988,
-0.5878870487213135,
-0.18750669062137604,
-0.34700122475624084,
-0.8342013955116272,
-0.15260781347751617,
-0.33248642086982727,
-0.052098676562309265,
0.03346037492156029,
0.665117084980011,
-0.39513882994651794,
0.4588353931903839,
0.5342774987220764,
0.012585864402353764,
0.7303788661956787,
-0.5501549243927002,
-0.31421372294425964,
-0.6564680933952332,
-0.21048706769943237,
0.11624248325824738,
-0.23700299859046936,
-0.40813836455345154,
0.15102428197860718,
-0.0023339493200182915,
-0.2930186986923218,
-0.2930583655834198,
0.37849268317222595,
-0.5869168043136597,
-0.4796464443206787,
-0.47616422176361084,
-0.0707186758518219,
-0.39343759417533875,
0.35343408584594727,
0.10845865309238434,
0.789885938167572,
0.7586708664894104,
-0.9210644960403442,
0.21153660118579865,
-0.06514333188533783,
-0.7115837931632996,
0.17558398842811584,
-0.7430431842803955,
0.36905428767204285,
-0.3221762180328369,
0.1453031599521637,
-1.050118088722229,
-0.11655724048614502,
-0.014876138418912888,
-0.06765798479318619,
0.21887746453285217,
-0.11069304496049881,
-0.44649872183799744,
-0.4659017026424408,
-0.09355303645133972,
0.3097195327281952,
0.8513221740722656,
-0.6994388699531555,
0.1996740996837616,
0.027688371017575264,
-0.05682145804166794,
-0.4320560693740845,
-0.4416331946849823,
-0.040236636996269226,
-0.1442859023809433,
-0.358036607503891,
0.21680311858654022,
-0.11875651776790619,
-0.3784732222557068,
0.012118829414248466,
-0.19041192531585693,
0.04717663675546646,
0.36098942160606384,
0.20702822506427765,
0.08736885339021683,
-0.27451708912849426,
0.1278468519449234,
-0.012654784135520458,
0.09662298113107681,
0.02345404028892517,
-0.2764298915863037,
0.4166637063026428,
-0.0779835432767868,
-0.7531998157501221,
-0.14079715311527252,
0.5514890551567078,
0.27327316999435425,
-0.07658835500478745,
0.7187612652778625,
0.002151917200535536,
-0.3233128786087036,
-0.7941732406616211,
-0.3099043369293213,
-0.16143882274627686,
-0.43787896633148193,
0.46903619170188904,
-0.5573164820671082,
-0.5751608610153198,
0.2268877476453781,
-0.5744962692260742,
0.24314768612384796,
-0.12338490784168243,
0.5715243816375732,
-0.42827287316322327,
0.7820423245429993,
0.9052965641021729,
0.28634557127952576,
0.38956180214881897,
-0.519482433795929,
0.34187543392181396,
-0.5151327848434448,
0.06520615518093109,
-0.5158774256706238,
-0.28834059834480286,
-0.6523897051811218,
-0.3187287449836731,
0.4383079409599304,
0.436954528093338,
-0.10149935632944107,
0.2595662474632263,
-0.34141165018081665,
0.7676858901977539,
0.7834100723266602,
0.0631708949804306,
0.19903169572353363,
0.01882222294807434,
0.01664322055876255,
0.06963951885700226,
-0.8875167369842529,
-0.779606282711029,
1.494052767753601,
0.16038796305656433,
1.026082158088684,
0.11335062235593796,
1.224625825881958,
0.29370832443237305,
0.6644425988197327,
-0.5963409543037415,
0.59189373254776,
-0.22947995364665985,
-0.4101821184158325,
-0.22512944042682648,
-0.36154836416244507,
-0.9495434761047363,
0.005111993756145239,
-0.043836720287799835,
-0.6930187344551086,
0.20731781423091888,
0.3201660215854645,
-0.08945026248693466,
0.11930204927921295,
-0.9434847831726074,
1.0186882019042969,
-0.28878480195999146,
-0.2396550327539444,
-0.2787087559700012,
-0.3626219928264618,
0.49153807759284973,
0.062492091208696365,
0.3759152591228485,
-0.024313731119036674,
0.2024199515581131,
0.5559664368629456,
-0.5784282088279724,
0.71442711353302,
-0.21577589213848114,
-0.12161827087402344,
0.4464534819126129,
0.0008052309276536107,
0.6554553508758545,
-0.0287274532020092,
0.15242312848567963,
-0.11741480231285095,
-0.21031220257282257,
-0.7741764783859253,
-0.9033037424087524,
0.5233004689216614,
-0.7271348237991333,
-0.7275723814964294,
-0.29744216799736023,
-0.5182530283927917,
-0.4182421863079071,
-0.2374291867017746,
0.37549686431884766,
0.4402273893356323,
-0.016323894262313843,
0.155943363904953,
0.7169066667556763,
-0.43851619958877563,
0.4810183644294739,
0.2663481831550598,
-0.3875832259654999,
0.19327275454998016,
0.9509246945381165,
-0.08929754048585892,
0.4197556674480438,
0.09821058809757233,
-0.08536551892757416,
-0.07020418345928192,
-0.9120709896087646,
-0.4112204611301422,
0.3784458637237549,
-0.8587022423744202,
0.02550768479704857,
-0.2742181122303009,
0.016058046370744705,
-0.12361037731170654,
-0.4147246479988098,
-0.2346455454826355,
-0.19643375277519226,
-0.016294516623020172,
0.12953104078769684,
-0.2073310911655426,
1.1628391742706299,
0.07645829021930695,
0.436271995306015,
-0.46724793314933777,
0.3180167078971863,
0.33921387791633606,
0.08005345612764359,
-0.06767747551202774,
-0.4556411802768707,
-0.2763809859752655,
-0.16403231024742126,
-0.29539933800697327,
-0.8889431953430176,
0.1336136907339096,
0.18325863778591156,
0.6913354992866516,
0.2492389976978302,
-0.1473669707775116,
0.5174756050109863,
-0.44007349014282227,
0.6688690781593323,
0.04399728402495384,
-0.7472231984138489,
0.46661457419395447,
-0.13710416853427887,
0.09404579550027847,
0.14780594408512115,
0.5269383788108826,
-0.2609637975692749,
-0.5956490635871887,
-0.6184144616127014,
-0.8161187767982483,
0.5029106140136719,
0.31611549854278564,
0.1787043809890747,
-0.11924608051776886,
0.5583832263946533,
0.17054341733455658,
0.20842157304286957,
-0.5377842783927917,
-0.42554423213005066,
-0.01431717537343502,
-0.24156783521175385,
-0.24756984412670135,
-0.276449590921402,
0.24494889378547668,
0.04956863820552826,
0.7314884662628174,
-0.185028538107872,
0.4747881293296814,
-0.07189233601093292,
-0.3265981674194336,
0.10007643699645996,
0.3807659447193146,
0.5839176177978516,
0.9516801238059998,
-0.12541478872299194,
0.12512053549289703,
-0.2480788230895996,
-0.026486266404390335,
0.3365037739276886,
-0.18338124454021454,
-0.15057918429374695,
-0.16412298381328583,
0.39508089423179626,
0.4783533215522766,
0.044091932475566864,
-0.8863242268562317,
0.474046915769577,
0.056367043405771255,
-0.028330737724900246,
-0.380739688873291,
0.3329779803752899,
0.1837679147720337,
0.1971374750137329,
0.7041502594947815,
-0.07583215832710266,
0.04267898574471474,
-0.7726956009864807,
0.04770539700984955,
0.8237607479095459,
0.308322936296463,
-0.035735949873924255,
0.49800118803977966,
0.1157122403383255,
-0.2970792055130005,
0.6992201805114746,
-0.41702184081077576,
-0.31108543276786804,
0.9831547737121582,
0.9751061797142029,
0.5011714696884155,
0.20230236649513245,
0.15914739668369293,
0.02568562887609005,
0.3379374146461487,
-0.2781996726989746,
0.04066850244998932,
-0.1488925814628601,
-0.8024097681045532,
-0.5796910524368286,
-0.5370783805847168,
-0.6861573457717896,
0.22924195230007172,
-0.45464515686035156,
0.26361215114593506,
-0.48028624057769775,
0.046810802072286606,
0.026829276233911514,
-0.18843020498752594,
-0.8039036989212036,
0.2209705412387848,
0.4507513642311096,
0.7560509443283081,
-1.0231472253799438,
0.8170570731163025,
1.0338257551193237,
-0.40945133566856384,
-0.8136338591575623,
0.0905478224158287,
-0.3202480375766754,
-0.7115328907966614,
0.8136903643608093,
-0.0402480810880661,
0.04680727794766426,
0.04764363542199135,
-0.9271253943443298,
-0.5834217667579651,
0.7977033853530884,
0.5863921046257019,
-0.6078488826751709,
-0.14463207125663757,
0.14127415418624878,
0.2674519121646881,
-0.5543330907821655,
0.3746984004974365,
0.5527986884117126,
0.14773426949977875,
-0.23573844134807587,
-0.7744263410568237,
-0.15265008807182312,
-0.15922929346561432,
0.15137909352779388,
0.11877133697271347,
-0.32492995262145996,
0.759540855884552,
-0.552045464515686,
0.08531481772661209,
0.07932892441749573,
0.8192756772041321,
0.537237823009491,
0.3971037268638611,
0.2951841354370117,
0.4072801172733307,
0.7609020471572876,
0.047626130282878876,
1.4301948547363281,
0.050581272691488266,
0.3301815688610077,
1.0682225227355957,
-0.3659643232822418,
0.6356273889541626,
0.382052481174469,
-0.4995063841342926,
0.5962730646133423,
0.4997321367263794,
0.1492423266172409,
0.3843430280685425,
0.6185297966003418,
-0.2410038411617279,
-0.7078135013580322,
0.18325640261173248,
-0.29074370861053467,
0.25469326972961426,
0.4715700149536133,
-0.4991160035133362,
-0.28796353936195374,
0.07540909200906754,
-0.1585627645254135,
0.17494791746139526,
-0.4885706603527069,
0.4366777837276459,
0.34648728370666504,
-0.4939252436161041,
0.6354617476463318,
-0.007211032789200544,
0.7584487795829773,
-0.4618678390979767,
-0.18958145380020142,
-0.4421641230583191,
0.2108347862958908,
-0.19361944496631622,
-0.5185284614562988,
0.22062720358371735,
0.011152239516377449,
-0.15467557311058044,
-0.08004750311374664,
0.7071896195411682,
-0.08068249374628067,
-0.5719853043556213,
0.0042542037554085255,
0.8838415145874023,
0.5382462739944458,
0.006624297238886356,
-0.2969028055667877,
-0.10516031831502914,
-0.10387004166841507,
-0.2932688593864441,
0.5454875826835632,
0.41244983673095703,
-0.17499575018882751,
0.8712674975395203,
0.408302903175354,
0.09888745844364166,
0.28960639238357544,
-0.16661512851715088,
0.6422266364097595,
-0.6027258634567261,
-0.0640534833073616,
-0.8485010862350464,
0.22026096284389496,
-0.015534140169620514,
-0.15495260059833527,
0.7148788571357727,
0.4729842245578766,
1.0393821001052856,
-0.35333091020584106,
1.0033411979675293,
0.033058639615774155,
0.18713043630123138,
-0.517758309841156,
0.31139999628067017,
-0.6637817025184631,
0.24905326962471008,
-0.2524835765361786,
-1.0516600608825684,
-0.2876083254814148,
0.6894563436508179,
-0.6100778579711914,
0.11810363084077835,
0.7063640356063843,
0.8303138017654419,
-0.1599085032939911,
-0.26341962814331055,
0.6548141241073608,
0.03164137527346611,
0.3738687336444855,
0.8540781736373901,
0.9628416299819946,
-0.2033626139163971,
0.6152887940406799,
-0.23664596676826477,
-0.30952247977256775,
-0.22048144042491913,
-0.8851375579833984,
-0.8624417185783386,
-0.33187779784202576,
-0.5635726451873779,
-0.20821288228034973,
0.3571314811706543,
1.0632014274597168,
0.6549009680747986,
-0.8554195165634155,
-0.36424362659454346,
-0.4720465838909149,
0.2774086594581604,
-0.3145204782485962,
-0.13937748968601227,
0.06217282637953758,
-0.5633530616760254,
-0.7854527235031128,
0.4253804087638855,
0.19392956793308258,
0.10045135766267776,
-0.18274645507335663,
-0.08341605961322784,
0.20502988994121552,
0.19290763139724731,
0.36989644169807434,
0.4339975416660309,
-0.4751715362071991,
0.05665535479784012,
-0.09575114399194717,
-0.08685816824436188,
-0.13261398673057556,
1.243518352508545,
-0.8509127497673035,
-0.0065855346620082855,
0.1218278706073761,
0.7232653498649597,
0.5370821356773376,
0.02864607609808445,
0.5900493860244751,
-0.7387799620628357,
0.19168208539485931,
0.13850824534893036,
0.6038058996200562,
0.18242794275283813,
-0.04499756917357445,
0.41972610354423523,
0.31902316212654114,
-0.7479792833328247,
-0.9696942567825317,
0.5251142978668213,
-0.3442363440990448,
-0.49541234970092773,
1.1909788846969604,
-0.38336431980133057,
-0.29894423484802246,
-0.1474636048078537,
0.05523063614964485,
-0.007770617492496967,
-0.2450922131538391,
0.5921047329902649,
0.8018710017204285,
-0.4438215494155884,
-0.2104497253894806,
-0.5293599367141724,
0.3646301031112671,
0.7593738436698914,
-0.812550961971283,
0.059952087700366974,
0.5334393978118896,
0.3257107734680176,
0.07335541397333145,
0.8089250922203064,
0.16184274852275848,
0.34137415885925293,
0.04214784502983093,
0.03807651624083519,
-0.020010793581604958,
-0.3457862138748169,
-0.17610689997673035,
0.23851148784160614,
0.7565754652023315,
0.0870291218161583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08255v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08255v1
|
M3T: A New Benchmark Dataset for Multi-Modal Document-Level Machine Translation
| 2024-06-12T14:28:25 | 2024-06-12T14:28:25 |
Benjamin Hsu, Xiaoyu Liu, Huayang Li, Yoshinari Fujinuma, Maria Nadejde, Xing Niu, Yair Kittenplon, Ron Litman, Raghavendra Pappagari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Document translation poses a challenge for Neural Machine Translation (NMT)
systems. Most document-level NMT systems rely on meticulously curated
sentence-level parallel data, assuming flawless extraction of text from
documents along with their precise reading order. These systems also tend to
disregard additional visual cues such as the document layout, deeming it
irrelevant. However, real-world documents often possess intricate text layouts
that defy these assumptions. Extracting information from Optical Character
Recognition (OCR) or heuristic rules can result in errors, and the layout
(e.g., paragraphs, headers) may convey relationships between distant sections
of text. This complexity is particularly evident in widely used PDF documents,
which represent information visually. This paper addresses this gap by
introducing M3T, a novel benchmark dataset tailored to evaluate NMT systems on
the comprehensive task of translating semi-structured documents. This dataset
aims to bridge the evaluation gap in document-level NMT systems, acknowledging
the challenges posed by rich text layouts in real-world applications.
|
[
-0.27169492840766907,
-0.4416118264198303,
0.6771727204322815,
0.202680304646492,
-0.35275158286094666,
-0.06903952360153198,
0.0005826461128890514,
-0.15101297199726105,
-0.4360240399837494,
0.19633522629737854,
-0.586033046245575,
-0.521519124507904,
-0.7732481360435486,
0.39456596970558167,
-0.4239298403263092,
0.7686339020729065,
-0.32489830255508423,
0.12003432214260101,
-0.015049685724079609,
-0.17728696763515472,
-0.6001567840576172,
-0.2672071158885956,
-0.3966502249240875,
-0.06345104426145554,
0.5112234950065613,
0.20499208569526672,
0.85950767993927,
0.8367066383361816,
0.7864885330200195,
0.36586982011795044,
0.22621895372867584,
0.4984903037548065,
0.02453404664993286,
0.1811312437057495,
0.017017100006341934,
-0.22941085696220398,
-0.4795970618724823,
-0.2082141935825348,
0.9128878712654114,
0.6328494548797607,
0.19604913890361786,
-0.08732675015926361,
0.12742529809474945,
0.6697748303413391,
-0.36936914920806885,
0.42510703206062317,
-0.3399777114391327,
0.39062464237213135,
-0.3048197329044342,
-0.41239914298057556,
-0.3248997628688812,
-0.22020047903060913,
-0.07424972951412201,
-0.612065315246582,
0.19344502687454224,
0.23216335475444794,
0.7495130896568298,
0.3868551552295685,
-0.7726973295211792,
-0.09988739341497421,
-0.5734963417053223,
0.5726226568222046,
-0.6189343333244324,
0.7370439171791077,
0.13672110438346863,
0.4899962246417999,
-0.17350445687770844,
-0.5770726203918457,
-0.5367357730865479,
-0.07179009914398193,
-0.10552406311035156,
0.38720861077308655,
0.039177194237709045,
-0.20069429278373718,
0.3013620674610138,
0.435157835483551,
-0.7532853484153748,
-0.09025252610445023,
-0.2962372303009033,
-0.2110024243593216,
0.09276271611452103,
0.35498929023742676,
0.4058196246623993,
-0.2754707634449005,
-0.6781919002532959,
-0.45740097761154175,
-0.38430026173591614,
-0.3528791069984436,
0.1605561375617981,
0.19971077144145966,
-0.030316928401589394,
0.7328665256500244,
-0.056083474308252335,
0.7137765288352966,
-0.3167054057121277,
-0.16499833762645721,
0.4141063988208771,
-0.544275164604187,
-0.2881985306739807,
0.026677343994379044,
1.0028153657913208,
0.5965805053710938,
0.014179742895066738,
-0.2500700354576111,
-0.7119547128677368,
-0.2984815835952759,
0.26167112588882446,
-0.9314030408859253,
0.23314905166625977,
-0.1284024566411972,
-0.38496264815330505,
-0.12413380295038223,
0.10236982256174088,
-0.8366338014602661,
-0.5916275978088379,
-0.36541104316711426,
0.4430333971977234,
-0.6923893094062805,
-0.03642827272415161,
0.17060989141464233,
-0.24612370133399963,
0.1150486096739769,
0.5667572021484375,
-0.8082047700881958,
0.0837387964129448,
0.6720371842384338,
1.2685943841934204,
-0.21316254138946533,
-0.5428137183189392,
-0.37795141339302063,
0.3624216616153717,
-0.4002220332622528,
0.6953622102737427,
-0.18655410408973694,
-0.15564554929733276,
-0.2434569150209427,
-0.06157505139708519,
-0.44615107774734497,
-0.5939904451370239,
0.8575791716575623,
-0.40292197465896606,
0.28465554118156433,
-0.1411246657371521,
-0.30843880772590637,
-0.01406553853303194,
0.562447190284729,
-0.7055066823959351,
0.9409318566322327,
0.4864031672477722,
-0.7594292759895325,
0.3353572487831116,
-0.5506507158279419,
-0.6093875169754028,
-0.20248709619045258,
-0.5199490189552307,
-0.3545551896095276,
0.19911858439445496,
0.34669771790504456,
0.48568063974380493,
-0.5896438956260681,
0.029800718650221825,
0.005106236319988966,
-0.3507719337940216,
0.18709824979305267,
-0.8525476455688477,
0.40000301599502563,
0.34891095757484436,
-0.5130784511566162,
0.01671670563519001,
-0.8566786050796509,
-0.21528883278369904,
0.04374121502041817,
-0.5513361692428589,
-0.19302648305892944,
-0.2247340828180313,
0.4408256411552429,
0.6521696448326111,
0.21833184361457825,
-0.5299206376075745,
0.3075309097766876,
-0.09008766710758209,
0.43661192059516907,
0.6526577472686768,
-0.2126387059688568,
0.2770146131515503,
-0.35240715742111206,
0.38346800208091736,
0.1358286738395691,
0.02202637307345867,
-0.3441239893436432,
-0.4740999937057495,
-0.5232782363891602,
-0.3885878920555115,
0.21723265945911407,
0.5883288979530334,
-0.8941073417663574,
0.2868834137916565,
-0.6244943737983704,
-0.1858021765947342,
-0.4381208121776581,
0.02266508899629116,
0.44309037923812866,
0.7267670035362244,
0.4651798903942108,
-0.23038825392723083,
-0.2937399744987488,
-1.1287472248077393,
0.025610752403736115,
0.13750424981117249,
-0.2858758568763733,
0.17391327023506165,
0.32839053869247437,
-0.1221901997923851,
0.3580128252506256,
-0.2039027065038681,
-0.5173973441123962,
0.09576746821403503,
0.40948477387428284,
0.09978920221328735,
0.5949657559394836,
0.2245902270078659,
-0.9522604942321777,
-0.46583059430122375,
0.4351341128349304,
-0.9445109367370605,
-0.011864051222801208,
-0.5093908905982971,
-0.019810965284705162,
0.07422246038913727,
0.7940648794174194,
-0.48304513096809387,
0.17462268471717834,
0.5197974443435669,
-0.25090134143829346,
0.36669737100601196,
-0.4510824382305145,
0.4445176124572754,
-1.3238130807876587,
0.2509138286113739,
-0.08311644941568375,
-0.2585732340812683,
-0.22338590025901794,
0.003969891462475061,
0.5470878481864929,
-0.17989501357078552,
-0.31917187571525574,
0.3896462321281433,
-0.6933975219726562,
-0.4141480326652527,
-0.03438510745763779,
0.12844090163707733,
0.2720693349838257,
0.5149253010749817,
-0.046414852142333984,
1.0912203788757324,
0.04594971239566803,
-0.1681179702281952,
0.1598653644323349,
0.3312930166721344,
-0.4577559232711792,
1.0449782609939575,
-0.3622302711009979,
-0.018863650038838387,
0.15080924332141876,
0.038794927299022675,
-0.9149927496910095,
0.01784149929881096,
0.14399532973766327,
-0.34392476081848145,
0.4807138442993164,
-0.1097150444984436,
-1.0317533016204834,
0.03245497867465019,
-0.10651496797800064,
0.39893287420272827,
0.19868561625480652,
-0.18863032758235931,
0.5002031326293945,
0.03225395455956459,
0.01792985573410988,
-0.5389137864112854,
-0.7791394591331482,
0.447070449590683,
0.09638688713312149,
-0.7272600531578064,
0.3700026571750641,
0.13280656933784485,
0.22407273948192596,
-0.12084129452705383,
-0.3909975588321686,
0.021634671837091446,
0.10587342083454132,
0.16515569388866425,
0.063477523624897,
-0.5593664050102234,
-0.23445816338062286,
0.06224749982357025,
-0.42473602294921875,
-0.0731332078576088,
-0.4829231798648834,
0.48343175649642944,
-0.2537606954574585,
-0.490042507648468,
-0.4585939645767212,
0.43938106298446655,
0.9931530952453613,
-0.31278565526008606,
0.5363223552703857,
0.9550020694732666,
-0.37360841035842896,
0.039097532629966736,
-0.26066792011260986,
0.09798697382211685,
-0.42689377069473267,
0.5170950889587402,
-0.8717299103736877,
-0.49276003241539,
0.2696269154548645,
-0.1431424766778946,
0.04455023631453514,
0.5681198835372925,
0.4978645145893097,
-0.08301066607236862,
1.1799612045288086,
0.4841679632663727,
0.1606104075908661,
0.5187053680419922,
-0.09631940722465515,
0.0510864295065403,
-1.1404567956924438,
-0.28284600377082825,
-0.4123961627483368,
-0.4903147220611572,
-0.3869205117225647,
-0.548636257648468,
0.43220254778862,
0.17482928931713104,
-0.03076787292957306,
0.6098200678825378,
-0.36876147985458374,
0.28035661578178406,
0.4882155656814575,
-0.01722758822143078,
0.46172916889190674,
-0.14587292075157166,
-0.6294768452644348,
-0.2004268616437912,
-0.3944862484931946,
-0.5502268671989441,
0.9806205630302429,
0.06000804901123047,
0.4083589017391205,
0.4124194085597992,
0.443344384431839,
0.41146767139434814,
0.14209644496440887,
-0.6814370155334473,
0.4171336591243744,
-0.14037910103797913,
-0.4690839648246765,
-0.2944018244743347,
-0.647009015083313,
-0.9309481382369995,
0.5331176519393921,
-0.14870962500572205,
-0.4898584187030792,
0.24375545978546143,
-0.2908090054988861,
-0.07559993118047714,
0.37771376967430115,
-0.6657402515411377,
1.1586966514587402,
-0.3290950059890747,
-0.3997558057308197,
0.16983574628829956,
-0.7242777347564697,
0.07107850164175034,
-0.3315099775791168,
0.09315123409032822,
-0.18546715378761292,
-0.38889604806900024,
0.3868280351161957,
-0.4118620753288269,
0.38964006304740906,
0.12306994199752808,
-0.0546179823577404,
-0.34783971309661865,
0.3424513041973114,
0.4239797592163086,
-0.08539513498544693,
-0.3570164740085602,
-0.05329664424061775,
0.18387359380722046,
-0.4803391695022583,
-0.7277501225471497,
0.5629335045814514,
-0.6994954943656921,
-0.18988890945911407,
-0.5464789271354675,
-0.8983729481697083,
-0.3019871115684509,
0.8376673460006714,
0.18497633934020996,
0.5871754288673401,
-0.33756834268569946,
0.3751976788043976,
0.63164883852005,
-0.024188518524169922,
0.2612609565258026,
0.4074399173259735,
-0.09279388189315796,
-0.459567129611969,
1.0145726203918457,
0.13118058443069458,
0.26628029346466064,
0.8422225117683411,
0.04165607690811157,
-0.3226296007633209,
-1.0121045112609863,
-1.2125531435012817,
-0.22366783022880554,
-0.6791577935218811,
-0.21437087655067444,
-0.7809833884239197,
-0.030806463211774826,
-0.34833791851997375,
-0.21892550587654114,
-0.33694201707839966,
-0.443582683801651,
0.030602529644966125,
0.06686022877693176,
-0.19852301478385925,
0.7893622517585754,
0.07195437699556351,
0.23474857211112976,
-0.924120306968689,
0.4766821265220642,
0.052984993904829025,
0.40714967250823975,
-0.25765252113342285,
-0.42019927501678467,
-0.2502516210079193,
-0.3377592861652374,
-0.36542564630508423,
-0.8110498189926147,
0.3163802921772003,
-0.09378065913915634,
0.5973387360572815,
0.23782697319984436,
-0.10073346644639969,
0.4114837348461151,
-0.6320231556892395,
0.33929672837257385,
0.08383144438266754,
-0.655452311038971,
0.1970035880804062,
-0.7215655446052551,
0.5237098336219788,
0.7044561505317688,
0.27124589681625366,
-0.8592139482498169,
-0.14950412511825562,
-0.3610638976097107,
-0.9169480800628662,
0.7688384652137756,
0.43458420038223267,
-0.2243412882089615,
0.1683366596698761,
-0.011988780461251736,
0.1231895312666893,
0.32089129090309143,
-0.3686490058898926,
0.04067086800932884,
-0.24798458814620972,
-0.5647138357162476,
-0.21083612740039825,
0.1761556714773178,
-0.006062379106879234,
0.08939925581216812,
0.3748762905597687,
-0.2637859582901001,
0.2265034168958664,
0.24589285254478455,
-0.5198566913604736,
0.21615684032440186,
0.3310440182685852,
0.8640215396881104,
0.4452956020832062,
-0.5872215628623962,
0.3084200322628021,
-0.13163328170776367,
-0.5044222474098206,
0.03673170879483223,
0.30856725573539734,
-0.339181125164032,
0.019646797329187393,
0.3435584306716919,
0.6542100310325623,
0.3220519423484802,
-0.4203934669494629,
0.7449997663497925,
-0.2591077983379364,
-0.19092868268489838,
0.05598314478993416,
-0.3775947391986847,
0.062025733292102814,
0.18871596455574036,
0.2017839103937149,
0.520704984664917,
0.33184561133384705,
-0.45489391684532166,
0.3539752662181854,
0.13162735104560852,
-0.7081423997879028,
-0.1765138953924179,
0.6669001579284668,
0.1983274519443512,
-0.36118075251579285,
0.5974657535552979,
0.0007130631129257381,
-0.3301853835582733,
0.5155393481254578,
0.49308016896247864,
0.8821064829826355,
0.19480277597904205,
0.003986075520515442,
0.26030051708221436,
0.6716373562812805,
-0.1935747265815735,
0.00008680601604282856,
-0.29811492562294006,
-0.42034363746643066,
0.04423760622739792,
-0.6664705276489258,
-0.42653408646583557,
0.040818002074956894,
-0.43951117992401123,
0.23640203475952148,
-0.5334723591804504,
0.04381982237100601,
0.07146252691745758,
-0.1814095377922058,
-0.6891303062438965,
0.12131820619106293,
0.24050019681453705,
0.8980708122253418,
-0.6257442831993103,
1.0334813594818115,
0.4194934666156769,
-0.6302725672721863,
-0.3071756362915039,
-0.04637432098388672,
0.2952440679073334,
-0.7629971504211426,
0.31767624616622925,
0.4183182120323181,
-0.32478561997413635,
0.06393326073884964,
0.26434585452079773,
-0.5984071493148804,
1.2978324890136719,
0.43375709652900696,
-0.37099310755729675,
-0.07900431007146835,
0.5272204875946045,
0.4593644440174103,
-0.2419663965702057,
0.34564024209976196,
0.29234305024147034,
0.7442079782485962,
-0.13830606639385223,
-0.7829606533050537,
0.2584681510925293,
-0.49556559324264526,
0.14296986162662506,
0.28024470806121826,
-0.575008749961853,
0.8817040920257568,
0.20279985666275024,
-0.2090677171945572,
0.05734040215611458,
0.4456213414669037,
-0.10861949622631073,
0.18710049986839294,
0.4510391056537628,
0.4353042542934418,
0.5809767246246338,
-0.10130313038825989,
1.1343094110488892,
-0.19661518931388855,
-0.023980753496289253,
1.2326457500457764,
-0.18543541431427002,
0.7457579374313354,
0.5741093754768372,
0.11913952231407166,
0.02008216455578804,
0.6109322905540466,
-0.19798719882965088,
0.44447681307792664,
0.09432310611009598,
-0.028789663687348366,
-0.0821070447564125,
0.05999761074781418,
-0.5124267935752869,
0.20301595330238342,
0.29499298334121704,
-0.5385432839393616,
-0.45003384351730347,
-0.11545908451080322,
-0.007492826320230961,
0.1348314881324768,
0.10096298903226852,
0.807003378868103,
0.06633314490318298,
-0.47527629137039185,
0.4150875508785248,
0.30838465690612793,
0.6816881895065308,
-0.5133674144744873,
-0.0332411527633667,
-0.3852824568748474,
0.3941017985343933,
-0.1106807217001915,
-0.8361231088638306,
0.25530508160591125,
-0.19501926004886627,
-0.35376349091529846,
-0.603454053401947,
0.4691500663757324,
-0.19226154685020447,
-0.5340076088905334,
0.19275280833244324,
0.6882328391075134,
0.14718638360500336,
-0.3411855697631836,
-0.8817533850669861,
-0.046490538865327835,
-0.08814433962106705,
-0.35483917593955994,
0.4989224970340729,
1.059360146522522,
-0.26251110434532166,
0.38886743783950806,
0.6595237851142883,
-0.1760168820619583,
0.2657985985279083,
-0.0038695973344147205,
0.6780591607093811,
-0.669916033744812,
-0.3712333142757416,
-0.7032613754272461,
0.3253226578235626,
-0.1860680729150772,
-0.5315738320350647,
0.8059250712394714,
1.0537530183792114,
0.816641628742218,
0.03851315379142761,
0.6984059810638428,
0.10193105787038803,
0.08156935125589371,
-0.5772246718406677,
0.9242643117904663,
-0.7769571542739868,
0.16527311503887177,
-0.2337387502193451,
-1.0430386066436768,
-0.4317934811115265,
0.2875674068927765,
-0.16768908500671387,
-0.11795442551374435,
1.0799537897109985,
0.8287564516067505,
-0.5303499102592468,
-0.05533633381128311,
0.715842604637146,
-0.09232576191425323,
0.26851195096969604,
0.5162635445594788,
0.7674606442451477,
-0.7872998118400574,
0.8867394328117371,
-0.07923255860805511,
-0.09731901437044144,
-0.3483130633831024,
-0.8338575959205627,
-0.6385790705680847,
-0.800268292427063,
0.006482808850705624,
-0.24175426363945007,
0.02700161747634411,
0.7199959754943848,
0.6141153573989868,
-0.6540651321411133,
-0.11613253504037857,
0.024800650775432587,
0.06153597682714462,
-0.4535928964614868,
-0.11391720920801163,
0.523540735244751,
-0.2758046090602875,
-0.7825961709022522,
0.5734518766403198,
0.5976570844650269,
0.18864886462688446,
-0.0858449637889862,
-0.09140986949205399,
-0.31624895334243774,
-0.1619625687599182,
0.5186336040496826,
0.1132640689611435,
-0.3157438635826111,
0.0046729217283427715,
0.059664081782102585,
-0.704184353351593,
0.5719969868659973,
0.8804866075515747,
-0.2790546715259552,
0.43887433409690857,
0.7496495246887207,
0.9497848153114319,
0.5862836241722107,
-0.3664674162864685,
0.7937164902687073,
-0.6984331607818604,
0.0711725652217865,
0.13656942546367645,
0.46617886424064636,
0.5788963437080383,
-0.13231226801872253,
0.6755505204200745,
0.2998802661895752,
-0.21228985488414764,
-0.764282763004303,
0.059933483600616455,
-1.2239816188812256,
-0.18235088884830475,
0.8530654311180115,
-0.16663840413093567,
-0.4286792576313019,
-0.23169948160648346,
-0.434854656457901,
0.30284789204597473,
-0.400595486164093,
0.5975149273872375,
0.6481084823608398,
0.11342822760343552,
-0.2860826551914215,
-1.0217080116271973,
0.32798290252685547,
0.4259366989135742,
-0.8029149770736694,
-0.00759149482473731,
0.5698903203010559,
0.02789170853793621,
0.19611619412899017,
0.6446360349655151,
-0.4586217701435089,
0.22294092178344727,
0.23155243694782257,
0.021358339115977287,
-0.4854506254196167,
-0.3612089157104492,
-0.30496296286582947,
0.33076056838035583,
-0.11561037600040436,
-0.24022254347801208
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08246v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08246v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Web Scraping
| 2024-06-12T14:15:15 | 2024-06-12T14:15:15 |
Aman Ahluwalia, Suhrud Wani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) demonstrate remarkable capabilities in
replicating human tasks and boosting productivity. However, their direct
application for data extraction presents limitations due to a prioritisation of
fluency over factual accuracy and a restricted ability to manipulate specific
information. Therefore to overcome these limitations, this research leverages
the knowledge representation power of pre-trained LLMs and the targeted
information access enabled by RAG models, this research investigates a
general-purpose accurate data scraping recipe for RAG models designed for
language generation. To capture knowledge in a more modular and interpretable
way, we use pre trained language models with a latent knowledge retriever,
which allows the model to retrieve and attend over documents from a large
corpus. We utilised RAG model architecture and did an in-depth analysis of
their capabilities under three tasks: (i) Semantic Classification of HTML
elements, (ii) Chunking HTML text for effective understanding, and (iii)
comparing results from different LLMs and ranking algorithms. While previous
work has developed dedicated architectures and training procedures for HTML
understanding and extraction, we show that LLMs pre-trained on standard natural
language with an addition of effective chunking, searching and ranking
algorithms, can prove to be efficient data scraping tool to extract complex
data from unstructured text. Future research directions include addressing the
challenges of provenance tracking and dynamic knowledge updates within the
proposed RAG-based data extraction framework. By overcoming these limitations,
this approach holds the potential to revolutionise data extraction from vast
repositories of textual information.
|
[
-0.131119504570961,
-0.6526845693588257,
0.5820266604423523,
-0.02584691345691681,
-0.2531179189682007,
0.35715270042419434,
-0.22863103449344635,
-0.5613185167312622,
0.09392286837100983,
0.5403417944908142,
-0.13342922925949097,
-0.3308030664920807,
-0.6015690565109253,
0.008028426207602024,
-0.6884055733680725,
0.9661374688148499,
0.24632151424884796,
-0.00321201141923666,
-0.371404767036438,
0.4538239538669586,
-0.09193431586027145,
-0.3466683328151703,
-0.34389644861221313,
-0.2270989716053009,
0.667446494102478,
0.4008755385875702,
0.5521625280380249,
0.790359616279602,
0.4182920455932617,
0.3348499834537506,
-0.037650562822818756,
0.11643324047327042,
-0.6230591535568237,
0.1121436357498169,
-0.5308248996734619,
-0.46589311957359314,
-0.5466135740280151,
0.1429654210805893,
0.512650191783905,
0.6737627387046814,
-0.09846684336662292,
0.39091765880584717,
0.1151653379201889,
0.40751174092292786,
-0.466052770614624,
0.07322443276643753,
-1.1164904832839966,
-0.32276439666748047,
-0.47014087438583374,
-0.23907919228076935,
-0.5713266730308533,
-0.2587607800960541,
0.19608354568481445,
-0.43958088755607605,
0.10174677520990372,
-0.03754914924502373,
1.0732126235961914,
0.07532685995101929,
-0.23773372173309326,
-0.43424397706985474,
-0.4293264150619507,
1.0944584608078003,
-0.7285754680633545,
0.5254418849945068,
0.5248473286628723,
0.5098788142204285,
-0.18077267706394196,
-0.9645208120346069,
-0.5729950070381165,
-0.1093340665102005,
0.038828782737255096,
-0.07199215888977051,
-0.15624335408210754,
-0.5223881006240845,
0.09728392213582993,
0.36270996928215027,
-0.45122653245925903,
0.31220728158950806,
-0.27490583062171936,
0.0565226711332798,
0.4692148268222809,
0.08520784229040146,
0.5681565403938293,
-0.5243195295333862,
-0.46715614199638367,
-0.04453650489449501,
-0.5177199244499207,
0.02274024859070778,
0.40401604771614075,
0.3834761083126068,
-0.17596735060214996,
0.6546335220336914,
-0.0006545102805830538,
0.8002381920814514,
-0.109715536236763,
-0.6044833064079285,
0.13011954724788666,
-0.06432464718818665,
-0.017887841910123825,
-0.48022937774658203,
0.5127210021018982,
0.12007191777229309,
0.5442753434181213,
-0.5233196020126343,
-0.33374854922294617,
-0.3177143633365631,
0.6742711067199707,
-0.572813868522644,
-0.11289145052433014,
0.06567292660474777,
-0.531732439994812,
-0.4771324396133423,
0.2782793641090393,
-1.16891610622406,
-0.36646708846092224,
-0.4275892674922943,
0.2732260823249817,
-0.44579678773880005,
-0.39824172854423523,
0.052417971193790436,
-0.4659219980239868,
0.46620437502861023,
0.44731006026268005,
-0.6636865735054016,
0.31235548853874207,
0.7587812542915344,
0.6980079412460327,
-0.5364318490028381,
-0.09327246993780136,
-0.45863988995552063,
0.4438975751399994,
-0.10645011812448502,
0.7861149311065674,
-0.656679093837738,
-0.09944631904363632,
-0.13037075102329254,
-0.13319602608680725,
-0.014193287119269371,
-0.5816725492477417,
0.26398932933807373,
-1.003652811050415,
-0.02291058376431465,
0.16364385187625885,
-0.6556941270828247,
-0.23979532718658447,
0.3361733853816986,
-0.8118240833282471,
0.5833086371421814,
0.24321240186691284,
-0.9023929834365845,
0.12005195021629333,
-0.26042845845222473,
-0.6040956974029541,
0.1606191247701645,
-0.1206311583518982,
-0.30820122361183167,
0.12507551908493042,
0.09630273282527924,
0.6545801758766174,
-0.6023316383361816,
0.19128748774528503,
-0.2384496033191681,
0.05484980717301369,
0.3631408214569092,
-0.36313536763191223,
0.6356579065322876,
0.3567369282245636,
-0.12205956876277924,
-0.16146177053451538,
-0.9543449282646179,
0.23631902039051056,
0.5218280553817749,
-0.8217994570732117,
-0.4463125169277191,
0.028453078120946884,
0.07622816413640976,
0.057359084486961365,
0.4061622619628906,
-0.32717788219451904,
0.21295757591724396,
-0.3073701858520508,
0.15390723943710327,
0.789042592048645,
-0.2147386223077774,
0.5560482144355774,
-0.3542264699935913,
0.7223804593086243,
-0.33288004994392395,
-0.3084627091884613,
-0.02464364655315876,
-0.044178448617458344,
-0.6427710056304932,
-0.45657482743263245,
0.6533050537109375,
0.4077302813529968,
-0.9055017232894897,
0.4121774137020111,
-0.6799250245094299,
-0.6548632383346558,
-0.2427578717470169,
0.22645319998264313,
0.31317564845085144,
0.5279712080955505,
0.3735853135585785,
-0.19901083409786224,
-0.6010891795158386,
-0.5010457634925842,
-0.30817827582359314,
0.23131151497364044,
-0.2779279351234436,
0.17526918649673462,
0.38273027539253235,
-0.2303355187177658,
1.1751818656921387,
-0.5714251399040222,
-0.20108778774738312,
-0.7912068367004395,
0.19879241287708282,
0.3603026270866394,
0.3128751814365387,
0.22672361135482788,
-1.0234867334365845,
-0.47612714767456055,
0.13114789128303528,
-0.7263672947883606,
-0.1800866425037384,
0.10508044809103012,
0.02092285454273224,
0.013692619279026985,
0.3477098345756531,
-0.6258233785629272,
0.33471107482910156,
0.5267394781112671,
0.06778060644865036,
0.7790845036506653,
0.16520248353481293,
-0.2698039412498474,
-1.0769810676574707,
0.33607256412506104,
0.01993928663432598,
-0.6265888214111328,
-0.5456396341323853,
0.11139784008264542,
0.06909769028425217,
-0.06766834855079651,
-0.4658065140247345,
0.7407749891281128,
-0.7578722834587097,
-0.2940366864204407,
-0.39330920577049255,
0.0723356306552887,
0.17699815332889557,
0.2034677118062973,
0.0911816656589508,
0.6948749423027039,
0.24274924397468567,
-0.7333980798721313,
0.19173796474933624,
-0.031511787325143814,
-0.339770644903183,
0.12726441025733948,
-0.38132771849632263,
0.17057526111602783,
0.10613048076629639,
0.09447979927062988,
-0.4959072172641754,
-0.4034532606601715,
-0.13290950655937195,
-0.5358057618141174,
0.6355909109115601,
-0.27914443612098694,
-0.4937671720981598,
-0.29092323780059814,
-0.2382499873638153,
0.014627471566200256,
0.6082943677902222,
-0.5303544998168945,
0.8888238668441772,
0.8277080059051514,
-0.4185338616371155,
-0.5151834487915039,
-0.19330498576164246,
0.04972272738814354,
-0.2199626863002777,
-0.4161455035209656,
0.2795693576335907,
0.25038471817970276,
-0.613681435585022,
-0.15288089215755463,
-0.15866264700889587,
-0.28504785895347595,
0.20390869677066803,
0.0004448011750355363,
0.1615915447473526,
0.03024345636367798,
0.008719904348254204,
-0.33413001894950867,
-0.16369715332984924,
-0.03946676850318909,
-0.13403834402561188,
0.986291229724884,
0.28628596663475037,
-0.25191566348075867,
-0.1687755584716797,
0.030763985589146614,
0.44443318247795105,
-0.42056772112846375,
0.42221707105636597,
0.5443074703216553,
-0.30924931168556213,
-0.36564159393310547,
-0.639086127281189,
0.06812956929206848,
-0.45359987020492554,
0.2625679671764374,
-0.39843136072158813,
-0.5205983519554138,
0.22496262192726135,
-0.41264858841896057,
0.06960786879062653,
0.37370291352272034,
0.4352480173110962,
-0.29055067896842957,
0.7561966776847839,
0.7542104125022888,
-0.27564963698387146,
0.3384122848510742,
-0.3150305151939392,
-0.1591901183128357,
-0.6414950489997864,
-0.0967785194516182,
-0.800788938999176,
-0.04385281354188919,
-0.2360953390598297,
-0.6885502934455872,
0.020400457084178925,
0.2669646143913269,
0.04261641576886177,
0.04369639605283737,
-0.03452508524060249,
0.45222458243370056,
0.46982184052467346,
0.09250705689191818,
0.33572301268577576,
0.2831023335456848,
0.005772874224931002,
0.08780980855226517,
-0.4610142707824707,
-0.726270854473114,
1.1811925172805786,
0.3519529104232788,
1.0011210441589355,
0.11561434715986252,
0.3838005065917969,
0.28250065445899963,
0.11385130882263184,
-0.7839624881744385,
0.5252521634101868,
-0.37069109082221985,
-0.4965091049671173,
-0.2362598180770874,
-0.4949180483818054,
-1.112830400466919,
0.17624999582767487,
-0.21926167607307434,
-0.6230917572975159,
-0.2656116187572479,
-0.21461771428585052,
0.20955199003219604,
0.5113388299942017,
-0.3493672013282776,
0.400587260723114,
-0.3656936287879944,
-0.4218190014362335,
-0.14472708106040955,
-0.6962833404541016,
0.19733527302742004,
-0.42708829045295715,
0.6338322162628174,
0.009693070314824581,
0.04459846019744873,
0.7084752321243286,
-0.40916427969932556,
0.8496296405792236,
-0.09139635413885117,
-0.23463857173919678,
0.1976166069507599,
0.23782287538051605,
0.6070613861083984,
-0.284219890832901,
-0.16939878463745117,
0.2299012839794159,
-0.42898285388946533,
-0.2960140109062195,
-0.36622917652130127,
0.2732510268688202,
-0.6166127324104309,
-0.6167467832565308,
-0.3463904857635498,
-0.5490736961364746,
-0.18690423667430878,
0.4283922016620636,
-0.016757167875766754,
0.3912111222743988,
-0.08259449154138565,
0.3735424876213074,
0.5044986009597778,
-0.40178149938583374,
0.46343502402305603,
0.7108487486839294,
-0.4565289616584778,
-0.2493968904018402,
1.0893864631652832,
-0.0991724506020546,
0.25483930110931396,
0.6237824559211731,
0.19255781173706055,
-0.2650252878665924,
-0.6568554043769836,
-0.37621214985847473,
0.2038380354642868,
-0.515091061592102,
-0.5245605707168579,
-0.8695323467254639,
-0.21526797115802765,
-0.5776581764221191,
-0.11719658970832825,
-0.2679751515388489,
-0.3245641589164734,
-0.5112457275390625,
0.03456425294280052,
0.18509452044963837,
0.90422123670578,
-0.05377282202243805,
0.3417498469352722,
-1.043589472770691,
0.6257925629615784,
0.27824726700782776,
0.1095183789730072,
0.2701417803764343,
-0.4937441945075989,
-0.296465128660202,
-0.112544484436512,
-0.15156622231006622,
-0.894490122795105,
0.6579514741897583,
-0.011811156757175922,
0.5970206260681152,
0.4025520980358124,
-0.30384209752082825,
0.7456746697425842,
-0.6079171299934387,
0.6618809700012207,
0.09809757769107819,
-0.7627197504043579,
0.3378496766090393,
-0.5296391844749451,
0.1853935569524765,
0.25242674350738525,
0.6620288491249084,
-0.1360453963279724,
-0.2547285854816437,
-0.4996594190597534,
-0.9073198437690735,
0.6293056607246399,
-0.12453509867191315,
0.06927523761987686,
0.1078178808093071,
0.3161325454711914,
0.47954005002975464,
0.09872151166200638,
-0.8286795020103455,
0.18015412986278534,
0.12674099206924438,
-0.3198096752166748,
0.050939757376909256,
-0.35216590762138367,
0.2577790915966034,
-0.17361406981945038,
0.6810436844825745,
-0.03564584255218506,
-0.24626289308071136,
-0.24612340331077576,
-0.6634055972099304,
-0.020399626344442368,
0.3634829819202423,
-0.16051261126995087,
1.0464318990707397,
0.029646800830960274,
0.2991333603858948,
0.09121518582105637,
-0.6314203143119812,
-0.058842603117227554,
0.23614108562469482,
-0.09448733180761337,
-0.12350939214229584,
0.5243149399757385,
0.055497363209724426,
0.22464025020599365,
-0.9297649264335632,
0.5667228698730469,
-0.057029906660318375,
0.29790782928466797,
-0.313590943813324,
-0.019347622990608215,
0.23117101192474365,
0.29310980439186096,
0.5860393047332764,
-0.39625436067581177,
0.009598547592759132,
-0.31539586186408997,
0.5101921558380127,
0.6067690253257751,
0.021446948871016502,
-0.25635597109794617,
0.41869056224823,
-0.0175939928740263,
-0.2562565207481384,
0.5510378479957581,
0.019089821726083755,
-0.46134209632873535,
0.4439557194709778,
0.7573307156562805,
0.2883155345916748,
-0.1517239660024643,
0.14892089366912842,
0.041528139263391495,
-0.04707663133740425,
0.059855811297893524,
0.1666368991136551,
-0.019671456888318062,
-0.679898202419281,
-0.5212095975875854,
-1.2899136543273926,
-0.29892176389694214,
0.27051475644111633,
-0.7791444659233093,
0.4415638744831085,
-0.18840304017066956,
0.10238242894411087,
-0.019912198185920715,
0.03462858870625496,
-0.8112276196479797,
0.44265052676200867,
0.06517987698316574,
0.9042069911956787,
-0.3620881140232086,
0.9011445641517639,
0.7163127064704895,
-0.5181401968002319,
-0.9531439542770386,
0.0032267237547785044,
-0.052070967853069305,
-0.865407407283783,
0.7401523590087891,
0.20422276854515076,
-0.037780359387397766,
0.1790906935930252,
-0.7114360332489014,
-1.0283139944076538,
0.952560305595398,
0.21489280462265015,
-0.5049235224723816,
-0.26556581258773804,
0.15672285854816437,
0.3528384864330292,
-0.20355844497680664,
0.036008816212415695,
0.4464207887649536,
0.36240699887275696,
0.15647272765636444,
-0.9190853238105774,
-0.03356862813234329,
-0.19049550592899323,
-0.2979166805744171,
-0.009651522152125835,
-0.150037482380867,
1.0712261199951172,
-0.06703086942434311,
-0.26012396812438965,
0.08856838196516037,
0.6004777550697327,
0.31002798676490784,
0.03875001519918442,
0.7005833387374878,
0.7327548265457153,
0.6729792952537537,
0.2763884365558624,
1.0677599906921387,
-0.06875990331172943,
0.11011045426130295,
1.274700403213501,
-0.3464193642139435,
0.9571318626403809,
0.31833502650260925,
-0.23326456546783447,
0.6269398331642151,
0.2367163598537445,
0.06344791501760483,
0.41390594840049744,
0.3024522662162781,
0.021867480129003525,
-0.16041643917560577,
-0.1256357729434967,
-0.19247950613498688,
0.9679129123687744,
0.3758068084716797,
-0.47055286169052124,
-0.499015748500824,
-0.1021028384566307,
0.38282400369644165,
0.019480250775814056,
-0.43418508768081665,
1.145810604095459,
0.14052414894104004,
-0.3718523383140564,
0.2781793475151062,
0.03009723499417305,
0.5897060036659241,
-0.7425333261489868,
-0.2410159558057785,
0.11527711153030396,
0.061602331697940826,
-0.16219975054264069,
-0.6235786080360413,
0.13119764626026154,
0.5402393341064453,
-0.26269152760505676,
-0.3603499233722687,
1.2990628480911255,
-0.08978240191936493,
-0.3643052279949188,
0.3378448784351349,
0.8518694043159485,
0.4523676037788391,
-0.1602354347705841,
-0.4321775734424591,
0.12277460843324661,
0.08323881775140762,
-0.4440889358520508,
0.612263023853302,
0.5021915435791016,
0.249186173081398,
0.5654985904693604,
0.922512412071228,
0.41649386286735535,
0.08384925872087479,
0.03541037440299988,
1.1206424236297607,
-0.8666330575942993,
-0.49531078338623047,
-0.849632740020752,
0.5861690640449524,
-0.25537794828414917,
0.28928282856941223,
0.8147801160812378,
0.6360716819763184,
0.6892498135566711,
0.09372040629386902,
0.9955672025680542,
-0.08931660652160645,
0.9419451355934143,
-0.6889169216156006,
0.8726254105567932,
-0.7191692590713501,
0.12680532038211823,
-0.22802765667438507,
-0.9024002552032471,
-0.12731440365314484,
0.45267796516418457,
-0.24217768013477325,
-0.08172588050365448,
0.36834585666656494,
0.313649982213974,
-0.14959508180618286,
-0.02752271480858326,
0.1346411257982254,
0.4246096611022949,
0.45183148980140686,
0.03854959085583687,
0.7915765047073364,
0.25536760687828064,
0.5364978909492493,
-0.012870068661868572,
-0.3136838972568512,
-0.03313591331243515,
-0.9455614686012268,
-0.7830098867416382,
-0.36219388246536255,
0.30937135219573975,
-0.23151464760303497,
-0.07489676028490067,
0.5917807221412659,
0.5911356806755066,
-0.42691928148269653,
-0.28975799679756165,
0.16021940112113953,
0.1961819976568222,
0.2002047747373581,
-0.2881767153739929,
0.3701113164424896,
-0.6679011583328247,
-0.7651585936546326,
0.5601433515548706,
0.07624258100986481,
0.12491042912006378,
-0.19031894207000732,
0.2566475570201874,
-0.4981916546821594,
-0.150717630982399,
0.6393222808837891,
0.08802009373903275,
-0.41904395818710327,
-0.03726755455136299,
-0.1187526136636734,
-0.046546801924705505,
0.030181817710399628,
0.6320334672927856,
-0.8656692504882812,
0.25008079409599304,
0.46983686089515686,
0.8566556572914124,
0.45055824518203735,
0.3582170903682709,
0.5738473534584045,
-0.7734907865524292,
-0.08538633584976196,
0.19853092730045319,
0.2884926497936249,
0.3747338056564331,
-0.14982041716575623,
0.4816998839378357,
-0.016105597838759422,
-0.3901202082633972,
-0.7563942074775696,
0.20186178386211395,
-0.8696028590202332,
-0.7321615815162659,
1.37808096408844,
-0.2680395245552063,
-0.4208807647228241,
-0.293525755405426,
0.06272301822900772,
0.4039842486381531,
-0.1023109033703804,
0.6161187291145325,
0.37321901321411133,
0.17443084716796875,
0.11168418079614639,
-0.5300384163856506,
0.27277395129203796,
-0.02315249666571617,
-0.973025918006897,
0.0443289689719677,
0.5018413662910461,
0.48758041858673096,
0.22728192806243896,
0.5302379727363586,
-0.30962127447128296,
-0.14158008992671967,
-0.2203989326953888,
0.22375161945819855,
0.08717594295740128,
-0.5065710544586182,
-0.14030824601650238,
0.42422282695770264,
0.016574164852499962,
0.15283401310443878
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08223v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08223v1
|
Research Trends for the Interplay between Large Language Models and Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-06-12T13:52:38 | 2024-06-12T13:52:38 |
Hanieh Khorashadizadeh, Fatima Zahra Amara, Morteza Ezzabady, Frédéric Ieng, Sanju Tiwari, Nandana Mihindukulasooriya, Jinghua Groppe, Soror Sahri, Farah Benamara, Sven Groppe
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This survey investigates the synergistic relationship between Large Language
Models (LLMs) and Knowledge Graphs (KGs), which is crucial for advancing AI's
capabilities in understanding, reasoning, and language processing. It aims to
address gaps in current research by exploring areas such as KG Question
Answering, ontology generation, KG validation, and the enhancement of KG
accuracy and consistency through LLMs. The paper further examines the roles of
LLMs in generating descriptive texts and natural language queries for KGs.
Through a structured analysis that includes categorizing LLM-KG interactions,
examining methodologies, and investigating collaborative uses and potential
biases, this study seeks to provide new insights into the combined potential of
LLMs and KGs. It highlights the importance of their interaction for improving
AI applications and outlines future research directions.
|
[
-0.5822902917861938,
-0.8978479504585266,
0.7716505527496338,
-0.07969677448272705,
0.18900974094867706,
0.13726602494716644,
-0.17945927381515503,
-0.6537970304489136,
0.2688085734844208,
0.6682441830635071,
-0.2871273458003998,
-0.389841228723526,
-0.677872359752655,
0.10929430276155472,
-0.5168426632881165,
0.6640062928199768,
-0.06688496470451355,
0.11339499801397324,
-0.8916449546813965,
-0.13191403448581696,
-0.32906055450439453,
-0.6405746340751648,
-0.8678609728813171,
-0.6235826015472412,
0.7414314150810242,
0.0363607257604599,
0.9515435099601746,
0.3204430639743805,
0.5599075555801392,
0.39655590057373047,
0.016782816499471664,
0.27318549156188965,
-0.3281690776348114,
0.5990287661552429,
-0.08460645377635956,
-0.45420703291893005,
-0.5740203261375427,
0.0021614795550704002,
0.703484058380127,
0.8337888121604919,
0.12578228116035461,
0.021876616403460503,
0.00034317653626203537,
0.6860612630844116,
-0.3607947826385498,
0.5719927549362183,
-0.3374421000480652,
-0.1493319571018219,
-0.3330534100532532,
-0.08657348901033401,
-0.18050211668014526,
-0.42609354853630066,
0.22282016277313232,
-0.5415935516357422,
-0.2892671823501587,
0.3159893751144409,
0.5438913106918335,
0.1887938380241394,
-0.6462743878364563,
-0.48502877354621887,
-0.7217431664466858,
0.6617236137390137,
-0.8295077085494995,
0.5811182856559753,
0.4201693832874298,
0.3991553783416748,
-0.4832235872745514,
-0.9803804159164429,
-0.7888877391815186,
-0.3737510144710541,
-0.3171764314174652,
-0.03171727433800697,
-0.3343196511268616,
0.21997176110744476,
0.04310362786054611,
0.20803573727607727,
-0.3765459358692169,
0.5470434427261353,
-0.22781787812709808,
-0.2228834480047226,
0.7475148439407349,
0.5194358825683594,
0.6319308280944824,
-0.14640046656131744,
0.030215930193662643,
0.01987461932003498,
-0.7734889984130859,
-0.02890421450138092,
0.33431315422058105,
0.2625029683113098,
0.008425489999353886,
0.793305516242981,
-0.2346183806657791,
1.1415103673934937,
-0.5515416860580444,
-0.3420954644680023,
0.021531186997890472,
-0.4710930585861206,
-0.1584710031747818,
-0.1069309189915657,
1.1564478874206543,
0.5030454993247986,
0.45316681265830994,
-0.41780704259872437,
0.12126703560352325,
-0.027432460337877274,
0.008285258896648884,
-0.5551155209541321,
-0.17372511327266693,
0.03704482689499855,
-0.33086103200912476,
-0.24762079119682312,
-0.018875066190958023,
-0.6973890662193298,
-0.6144272685050964,
-0.494314968585968,
0.2103324830532074,
-0.2550043761730194,
-0.5109144449234009,
-0.18662989139556885,
-0.2709078788757324,
0.0017756717279553413,
0.24147257208824158,
-0.780984103679657,
0.3471645712852478,
0.7281193137168884,
0.4652113616466522,
-0.11637744307518005,
-0.3351232409477234,
0.02999197691679001,
0.5435293912887573,
-0.32231393456459045,
0.6085271239280701,
-0.5215882062911987,
-0.3850592374801636,
0.098210908472538,
-0.3279263973236084,
-0.1259669065475464,
-0.6235533952713013,
0.2721982002258301,
-0.8799120783805847,
0.19603373110294342,
-0.4267942011356354,
-0.7325263023376465,
-0.3698807954788208,
0.8580718636512756,
-0.6994848251342773,
1.066060185432434,
0.1270008385181427,
-0.9507367014884949,
0.016084348782896996,
-0.7157471179962158,
-0.4626786410808563,
0.037136323750019073,
-0.4629060924053192,
-0.2597227394580841,
-0.2697884440422058,
0.061276521533727646,
0.5470570921897888,
-0.8123040199279785,
0.39150184392929077,
-0.368744432926178,
0.0135397519916296,
0.4157341718673706,
-0.18009550869464874,
0.4887138605117798,
0.202641099691391,
0.1140209212899208,
0.10802072286605835,
-0.6720458269119263,
0.1644531488418579,
0.37136849761009216,
-0.39287951588630676,
-0.5455358624458313,
0.16633251309394836,
-0.46731361746788025,
0.13979914784431458,
0.44656768441200256,
-0.2190147042274475,
0.26172295212745667,
-0.173191100358963,
0.4441964030265808,
0.36030304431915283,
-0.10440149158239365,
0.4238716959953308,
-0.23507431149482727,
0.6093083620071411,
-0.1941276639699936,
-0.0626097172498703,
0.03872501105070114,
-0.5106795430183411,
-0.6383591890335083,
0.04949095472693443,
0.23345129191875458,
0.33950409293174744,
-0.897678792476654,
0.31867149472236633,
-0.31650346517562866,
-0.6565276384353638,
-0.3140641748905182,
0.13794483244419098,
0.3826383352279663,
0.5879129767417908,
0.15825961530208588,
-0.1552378535270691,
-0.5257502794265747,
-0.7603330016136169,
-0.20625083148479462,
-0.47941622138023376,
0.1989598423242569,
0.605156660079956,
0.17260681092739105,
-0.299449622631073,
1.2764040231704712,
-0.5334545373916626,
-0.08450707793235779,
-0.4932926297187805,
-0.04506124183535576,
0.0038118460215628147,
0.03964322432875633,
0.7563871145248413,
-0.9600117802619934,
-0.6226561665534973,
0.010872461833059788,
-0.9547813534736633,
-0.1067163422703743,
0.6948038339614868,
-0.018483290448784828,
0.09954440593719482,
0.8231032490730286,
-0.7165581583976746,
0.17131486535072327,
0.7944811582565308,
-0.2847978472709656,
0.5668761730194092,
0.07258500903844833,
0.26893991231918335,
-1.1925663948059082,
-0.027531705796718597,
-0.1925278902053833,
0.034432101994752884,
-0.869774580001831,
-0.08137988299131393,
-0.33469903469085693,
0.004138084594160318,
-0.1128760278224945,
0.7575225830078125,
-0.4029231667518616,
-0.27234041690826416,
-0.16768914461135864,
0.3887028992176056,
0.08660963922739029,
0.0023377377074211836,
-0.2028249204158783,
0.7196195125579834,
0.5693721175193787,
-0.6194771528244019,
0.6859354376792908,
0.34273412823677063,
-0.30788764357566833,
0.2485642433166504,
-0.5083972811698914,
-0.06115274131298065,
-0.03603299334645271,
0.21155478060245514,
-1.1261545419692993,
-0.3100431561470032,
0.18375584483146667,
-0.5263796448707581,
0.2217872589826584,
0.052230339497327805,
-0.9651135802268982,
-0.6440779566764832,
-0.09410952776670456,
0.3867620825767517,
0.35049930214881897,
-0.22088612616062164,
0.8045704960823059,
0.7206663489341736,
-0.32187706232070923,
-0.3933444917201996,
-0.6367626786231995,
0.10707627236843109,
-0.12180358171463013,
-0.8865043520927429,
0.04824149236083031,
0.1785193830728531,
-0.782963216304779,
0.207084059715271,
0.28223228454589844,
0.07029122859239578,
0.05348911136388779,
0.14651581645011902,
0.2733733057975769,
-0.2796351909637451,
0.3511888086795807,
-0.15638570487499237,
0.0495976097881794,
0.23945969343185425,
-0.26500797271728516,
0.8719936013221741,
0.2241296023130417,
-0.2770066559314728,
-0.13712184131145477,
0.04221658036112785,
0.6494831442832947,
-0.226325124502182,
1.1169724464416504,
0.5042975544929504,
-0.07297796756029129,
0.04857182875275612,
-0.5435695052146912,
-0.04324028268456459,
-0.47421273589134216,
0.47711026668548584,
-0.18086279928684235,
-1.2010163068771362,
0.4604959785938263,
-0.19906564056873322,
-0.245912104845047,
0.4012347161769867,
0.6424884796142578,
-0.0947323590517044,
1.025204062461853,
0.5872664451599121,
-0.4109193980693817,
0.355891615152359,
-0.11432614922523499,
0.5015019178390503,
-0.906386137008667,
-0.4065690338611603,
-0.6320408582687378,
-0.12397480756044388,
-0.6662388443946838,
-0.1558198630809784,
0.605779767036438,
0.2179306149482727,
-0.15643280744552612,
0.0015095004346221685,
-0.11547576636075974,
0.27397483587265015,
0.5709623098373413,
-0.38315385580062866,
0.3195670545101166,
-0.13724179565906525,
-0.14811944961547852,
0.0918937623500824,
-0.7998502850532532,
-0.43607503175735474,
1.0280998945236206,
0.026315663009881973,
0.6953780651092529,
0.24709570407867432,
0.3144007623195648,
0.1669769138097763,
0.2595714330673218,
-0.545608639717102,
0.8488062024116516,
-0.07926839590072632,
-0.5185689926147461,
-0.5100880265235901,
-0.5502907633781433,
-1.1016936302185059,
0.11884003132581711,
-0.22711867094039917,
-0.7734647393226624,
-0.6696117520332336,
0.1995050609111786,
0.06626880913972855,
0.45847785472869873,
-0.6050107479095459,
0.7594109773635864,
-0.18053950369358063,
-0.1696241796016693,
-0.21288186311721802,
-0.6725574731826782,
0.38958078622817993,
0.1574060469865799,
0.3067188262939453,
-0.12893283367156982,
0.2452244907617569,
0.8318145275115967,
-0.22180317342281342,
0.768610417842865,
0.0051626842468976974,
-0.38064032793045044,
0.5955091714859009,
0.10063393414020538,
0.536375105381012,
-0.30281805992126465,
-0.23803003132343292,
0.13716566562652588,
-0.15788938105106354,
-0.002342310966923833,
-0.6056186556816101,
0.8464846014976501,
-0.9213616847991943,
-0.7277436852455139,
-0.11840162426233292,
-1.0389257669448853,
-0.5950942039489746,
0.34491464495658875,
-0.1652204692363739,
0.34496504068374634,
-0.07756016403436661,
-0.04497847333550453,
0.336678683757782,
-0.20743638277053833,
0.3376166820526123,
0.4074968695640564,
-0.6369156241416931,
-0.2774166166782379,
0.7510814070701599,
0.29867637157440186,
0.50726717710495,
0.4182837903499603,
0.16834266483783722,
-0.24809259176254272,
-0.6957840323448181,
-0.15686246752738953,
0.3526509404182434,
-0.6658105850219727,
-0.14226782321929932,
-0.7251939177513123,
-0.4526122808456421,
-0.8844929933547974,
-0.03407161682844162,
-0.006896389182657003,
-0.4029391407966614,
-0.059104107320308685,
-0.04430381953716278,
0.5627267956733704,
1.1853941679000854,
0.2239602506160736,
0.3007557988166809,
-0.8969504237174988,
0.03378550335764885,
0.3885410726070404,
0.19169393181800842,
0.48314496874809265,
0.053484003990888596,
-0.2519838213920593,
-0.1258990615606308,
-0.17363198101520538,
-0.6476961970329285,
0.2717219889163971,
-0.4465581178665161,
0.7465389370918274,
0.3507196307182312,
-0.060576003044843674,
0.44257164001464844,
-0.33588650822639465,
0.9869738817214966,
0.26462817192077637,
-0.46565595269203186,
0.18597686290740967,
-0.5908228158950806,
0.0939062312245369,
0.17001965641975403,
0.5255890488624573,
-0.6647317409515381,
-0.4255771040916443,
-0.3919386565685272,
-0.7325854897499084,
0.7494389414787292,
0.22470951080322266,
-0.10666976124048233,
0.15584610402584076,
0.14618609845638275,
-0.19811350107192993,
0.4359799921512604,
-0.5021483302116394,
-0.38013795018196106,
0.3683537542819977,
-0.40134620666503906,
-0.12859483063220978,
-0.289547860622406,
-0.2785685062408447,
-0.2681920528411865,
0.5859439373016357,
-0.09279759228229523,
0.08676441758871078,
-0.22808223962783813,
0.21576333045959473,
-0.024535244330763817,
0.15138322114944458,
0.12320391833782196,
0.6389451026916504,
0.23949357867240906,
0.34073406457901,
0.05004402995109558,
-0.2697957754135132,
-0.21256966888904572,
0.21854904294013977,
-0.19295451045036316,
-0.4807716906070709,
0.4450643062591553,
0.6875497102737427,
-0.20613470673561096,
-0.7248828411102295,
0.23852570354938507,
0.09426488727331161,
-0.03286813199520111,
-0.255260705947876,
0.22604112327098846,
0.5831044316291809,
0.5251285433769226,
0.0451115258038044,
-0.25740036368370056,
-0.1742268204689026,
-0.633765697479248,
-0.2023288607597351,
0.7495127320289612,
-0.22154174745082855,
-0.18149057030677795,
0.4926990568637848,
0.13927717506885529,
-0.323417067527771,
0.760887861251831,
-0.1579710841178894,
-0.6567116379737854,
0.7692645788192749,
0.5435236692428589,
0.2580283582210541,
0.05197771266102791,
-0.007018722128123045,
0.04147104546427727,
0.018615076318383217,
0.17508848011493683,
0.1183108314871788,
-0.04614844173192978,
-1.0535873174667358,
-0.32058417797088623,
-0.6222246885299683,
-0.38134104013442993,
0.07489799708127975,
-0.2657518982887268,
0.19880802929401398,
-0.023863373324275017,
-0.20386789739131927,
0.030243275687098503,
0.04805833473801613,
-0.46504005789756775,
0.10941843688488007,
0.23438338935375214,
0.6590462923049927,
-0.6383090019226074,
0.9069631099700928,
0.7625948190689087,
-0.47186511754989624,
-0.979408323764801,
-0.09006139636039734,
-0.05001600459218025,
-0.8637463450431824,
0.8323491811752319,
-0.10372836142778397,
-0.11108915507793427,
0.16464829444885254,
-0.49417513608932495,
-1.049007534980774,
1.4056811332702637,
0.15143753588199615,
-0.3305170238018036,
-0.0951702818274498,
0.6344003677368164,
0.6157761216163635,
-0.2356662154197693,
0.09155186265707016,
0.6398383378982544,
0.6989874839782715,
0.12520559132099152,
-0.9977307319641113,
-0.04368925094604492,
0.002981695579364896,
-0.06314641237258911,
0.5757625102996826,
-0.9002264142036438,
0.7970951795578003,
0.0051051857881248,
0.07445798814296722,
0.2450108677148819,
0.6190815567970276,
0.2770082950592041,
0.42565304040908813,
0.3123815953731537,
0.7682308554649353,
0.5009344816207886,
-0.11730695515871048,
1.1203856468200684,
-0.35753533244132996,
0.10438072681427002,
0.8760350942611694,
-0.5646358132362366,
0.4146389067173004,
0.541417121887207,
-0.5662534832954407,
0.5354990363121033,
0.20652981102466583,
0.018792767077684402,
0.17959293723106384,
0.2585773468017578,
-0.2795749604701996,
-0.06708110123872757,
-0.40576791763305664,
-0.38301989436149597,
0.3250998556613922,
0.5927463173866272,
-0.44237467646598816,
-0.24318884313106537,
-0.11447697877883911,
0.35242483019828796,
0.0964672863483429,
-0.3630145192146301,
0.8398590087890625,
0.07212471216917038,
-0.8285942077636719,
-0.04647159203886986,
-0.054458145052194595,
0.4328753352165222,
-0.9049851894378662,
0.0432610809803009,
0.11710002273321152,
0.07862398773431778,
-0.07872092723846436,
-1.0680229663848877,
0.09771562367677689,
-0.18760834634304047,
-0.23657110333442688,
-0.023157598450779915,
1.0409265756607056,
-0.4734669029712677,
-0.27940136194229126,
0.6992340683937073,
0.8185492157936096,
-0.02133750356733799,
0.35756632685661316,
-0.46627092361450195,
0.17086680233478546,
-0.21931743621826172,
-0.3230549395084381,
0.539478600025177,
0.44163551926612854,
-0.19857649505138397,
0.8270310759544373,
0.602806568145752,
0.044115278869867325,
0.2571386396884918,
0.3050202429294586,
1.0775550603866577,
-0.5318425893783569,
-0.22610360383987427,
-0.8721882700920105,
0.18518248200416565,
-0.11428898572921753,
-0.005209691822528839,
1.104727029800415,
0.447462797164917,
0.7297766208648682,
0.24231532216072083,
0.992161214351654,
-0.3941616714000702,
0.5018913745880127,
-0.5933609008789062,
0.837216854095459,
-0.40222299098968506,
0.056267742067575455,
-0.2552028000354767,
-0.6260700225830078,
-0.34964776039123535,
-0.10049708187580109,
-0.47044575214385986,
0.2073158323764801,
0.3928840160369873,
0.7121527194976807,
0.19600810110569,
0.02119089663028717,
0.3461255729198456,
0.36918994784355164,
0.5001441240310669,
0.1638696938753128,
1.0327202081680298,
-0.06908190995454788,
0.5295153856277466,
0.10737344622612,
0.1802973598241806,
-0.05181204155087471,
-0.6250325441360474,
-1.0159202814102173,
-0.5004860758781433,
0.0008950060582719743,
-0.3864080011844635,
-0.07443410158157349,
0.6004692912101746,
0.3173983097076416,
-0.5151984095573425,
-0.414537638425827,
-0.11079798638820648,
0.20240670442581177,
0.22364574670791626,
-0.26451513171195984,
0.4096360206604004,
-0.3467406928539276,
-0.7569562196731567,
0.2703791558742523,
0.22625280916690826,
0.1314408779144287,
-0.6163619160652161,
-0.35795798897743225,
-0.31029969453811646,
0.05956662818789482,
0.7248838543891907,
0.2784366011619568,
-0.5600465536117554,
-0.00478761363774538,
-0.05723482742905617,
-0.07043621689081192,
-0.21145592629909515,
0.884604275226593,
-0.7850823998451233,
0.2722015082836151,
0.8056396245956421,
0.7215429544448853,
0.3265663981437683,
-0.2271958589553833,
0.6553202867507935,
-0.6286953687667847,
0.03409353643655777,
0.045563582330942154,
0.39235249161720276,
0.44577914476394653,
-0.15342065691947937,
0.5657120943069458,
0.1884644478559494,
-0.6886199116706848,
-0.6971422433853149,
0.41746029257774353,
-0.6841939687728882,
-0.314704030752182,
1.2768340110778809,
0.027941634878516197,
-0.06056077033281326,
-0.08291091024875641,
-0.07941469550132751,
0.4112817347049713,
0.016740866005420685,
0.5148534178733826,
0.9069544076919556,
-0.5882923007011414,
0.055072858929634094,
-0.4427649974822998,
0.3765330910682678,
0.12042273581027985,
-0.9446415305137634,
-0.051388930529356,
0.4296953082084656,
0.09673938155174255,
0.38269826769828796,
0.6602739691734314,
-0.11898885667324066,
-0.27140435576438904,
-0.13504774868488312,
0.002803241368383169,
-0.20793385803699493,
-0.2196611613035202,
0.2241840660572052,
0.2208244949579239,
0.3672981560230255,
0.19136738777160645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08218v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08218v1
|
Figuratively Speaking: Authorship Attribution via Multi-Task Figurative Language Modeling
| 2024-06-12T13:49:38 | 2024-06-12T13:49:38 |
Gregorios A Katsios, Ning Sa, Tomek Strzalkowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The identification of Figurative Language (FL) features in text is crucial
for various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, where understanding of the
author's intended meaning and its nuances is key for successful communication.
At the same time, the use of a specific blend of various FL forms most
accurately reflects a writer's style, rather than the use of any single
construct, such as just metaphors or irony. Thus, we postulate that FL features
could play an important role in Authorship Attribution (AA) tasks. We believe
that our is the first computational study of AA based on FL use. Accordingly,
we propose a Multi-task Figurative Language Model (MFLM) that learns to detect
multiple FL features in text at once. We demonstrate, through detailed
evaluation across multiple test sets, that the our model tends to perform
equally or outperform specialized binary models in FL detection. Subsequently,
we evaluate the predictive capability of joint FL features towards the AA task
on three datasets, observing improved AA performance through the integration of
MFLM embeddings.
|
[
-0.008061517961323261,
-0.7747274041175842,
0.753414511680603,
0.46646782755851746,
-0.20625239610671997,
0.09027360379695892,
-0.08860865980386734,
-0.9777333736419678,
0.3630072772502899,
0.536005973815918,
-0.5653106570243835,
-0.22502164542675018,
-0.922699511051178,
0.4905546307563782,
-0.6007187962532043,
0.713013768196106,
0.0516246035695076,
-0.3442462980747223,
-0.5554089546203613,
-0.051841799169778824,
-0.3681197762489319,
-0.6557442545890808,
-0.7077367305755615,
-0.16235092282295227,
0.8390730619430542,
0.20181973278522491,
0.8101410269737244,
0.7621714472770691,
0.2928146421909332,
0.3555305302143097,
0.32167768478393555,
0.0237753763794899,
-0.22470985352993011,
0.039582811295986176,
0.07793281972408295,
-0.5731216669082642,
-0.13208776712417603,
0.3023257255554199,
0.7339001893997192,
0.22660380601882935,
0.02670380100607872,
0.12595151364803314,
-0.16090698540210724,
0.32390645146369934,
-0.7223814129829407,
0.4167664349079132,
-0.6167917847633362,
-0.16135287284851074,
-0.39564016461372375,
-0.2979658544063568,
-0.623977780342102,
-0.29872554540634155,
0.018297679722309113,
-0.49530839920043945,
0.22125399112701416,
0.26611921191215515,
0.46849435567855835,
0.3250318169593811,
-0.6827973127365112,
-0.5228492021560669,
-0.3768368065357208,
1.065282940864563,
-0.5577857494354248,
0.20185969769954681,
0.28332194685935974,
0.08072652667760849,
0.10154333710670471,
-0.4216139614582062,
-0.6854708194732666,
-0.4400382936000824,
-0.5898377895355225,
-0.28143447637557983,
-0.17501048743724823,
-0.19747726619243622,
-0.18776559829711914,
0.1175316721200943,
-0.24817951023578644,
0.01300120446830988,
-0.1583377718925476,
-0.18057015538215637,
0.8088661432266235,
0.016350600868463516,
0.3282087743282318,
-0.16345708072185516,
-0.6536227464675903,
-0.15474720299243927,
-0.39740338921546936,
0.07249560207128525,
0.18453046679496765,
0.6142281293869019,
-0.25283607840538025,
0.6674697399139404,
0.4615687429904938,
0.7936390042304993,
-0.4906551241874695,
-0.37408238649368286,
0.26940208673477173,
-0.23507817089557648,
-0.015048624016344547,
0.43356257677078247,
0.929314136505127,
-0.3260590732097626,
0.5303754210472107,
-0.052859045565128326,
-0.2653979957103729,
0.10378824174404144,
0.5568671226501465,
-0.36290043592453003,
0.03743039444088936,
0.03406146168708801,
-0.3750256597995758,
-0.7405043840408325,
0.143799290060997,
-0.24670864641666412,
-0.8245345950126648,
-0.41860127449035645,
0.289484441280365,
-0.5551182627677917,
-0.412362277507782,
-0.10015390068292618,
-0.18615484237670898,
-0.16422654688358307,
0.3859965205192566,
-0.7324077486991882,
0.2524007558822632,
0.7710039019584656,
1.0011394023895264,
-0.23568566143512726,
-0.8132532238960266,
-0.665111780166626,
0.3162066638469696,
-0.2089749127626419,
0.6573030352592468,
-0.6448538303375244,
0.25645703077316284,
0.022652268409729004,
-0.26570481061935425,
-0.5459437370300293,
-0.07254179567098618,
0.3997962176799774,
-0.26100626587867737,
0.08798890560865402,
-0.17080846428871155,
-0.5578346848487854,
-0.2854563295841217,
0.004170299507677555,
-0.9565356969833374,
0.8161969184875488,
0.09676281362771988,
-0.7206903696060181,
0.33302396535873413,
-0.866300106048584,
-0.6600756049156189,
-0.18169423937797546,
-0.507563054561615,
-0.29987451434135437,
0.49756675958633423,
0.11083745211362839,
0.7655103802680969,
-0.4771147668361664,
0.2616764307022095,
-0.05141251161694527,
-0.2891783118247986,
0.5864514708518982,
-0.271944522857666,
1.0690960884094238,
0.11115752160549164,
-0.27418777346611023,
0.2523776888847351,
-0.5829819440841675,
-0.2554669678211212,
0.13723820447921753,
-0.15057659149169922,
-0.47173306345939636,
0.00019236656953580678,
0.6766729950904846,
0.356670081615448,
0.05332869291305542,
-0.646756649017334,
-0.2264644056558609,
-0.16426627337932587,
0.09681055694818497,
0.7222909927368164,
-0.24390056729316711,
-0.01621687225997448,
-0.559235692024231,
0.8141331672668457,
-0.17425905168056488,
-0.30304592847824097,
0.036261025816202164,
-0.687863826751709,
-0.20072419941425323,
-0.8812061548233032,
0.08592206984758377,
0.5906475186347961,
-0.5053802728652954,
0.4942878484725952,
-0.11903771013021469,
-0.5834632515907288,
-0.4761710464954376,
0.18464715778827667,
0.8301752209663391,
0.23631836473941803,
0.29521310329437256,
-0.11479931324720383,
-0.08501246571540833,
-0.8602781891822815,
-0.8086883425712585,
-0.38803136348724365,
0.0617484450340271,
0.14810067415237427,
0.6135317087173462,
0.3574047386646271,
0.9702589511871338,
-0.6411576867103577,
-0.8032641410827637,
-0.27924010157585144,
0.5617055296897888,
-0.18867333233356476,
0.5869188904762268,
0.9884002208709717,
-0.892067015171051,
-0.4940900206565857,
-0.23102690279483795,
-1.0299898386001587,
-0.10525892674922943,
-0.3914780020713806,
-0.047390203922986984,
0.22302545607089996,
0.6993411779403687,
-0.705344021320343,
0.39951035380363464,
0.44372889399528503,
-0.738377034664154,
0.8419793248176575,
0.14867594838142395,
0.3110101521015167,
-0.7715890407562256,
0.15354587137699127,
0.210312157869339,
-0.13188758492469788,
-0.6380550265312195,
0.1282760500907898,
0.03167964145541191,
-0.04728136956691742,
-0.5929944515228271,
0.627814531326294,
-0.6230117082595825,
0.08703864365816116,
-0.11112391948699951,
-0.16308537125587463,
-0.07807841151952744,
0.4714202284812927,
0.1855328232049942,
0.5521977543830872,
0.5573458671569824,
-0.32220596075057983,
0.2798287570476532,
0.20438574254512787,
-0.5614538192749023,
0.5196893215179443,
-0.5270742177963257,
-0.026693927124142647,
-0.19360370934009552,
0.07901470363140106,
-1.1964974403381348,
-0.09622243791818619,
0.07995163649320602,
-0.3201768696308136,
0.2964574992656708,
0.20138469338417053,
-0.9872534871101379,
0.03291274234652519,
-0.11169452965259552,
0.5098488926887512,
-0.05001566931605339,
-0.20710615813732147,
1.0334835052490234,
0.20232661068439484,
-0.24961301684379578,
-0.6075016260147095,
-0.7415026426315308,
0.08541569113731384,
-0.40277954936027527,
-0.756535530090332,
0.5385255217552185,
0.39847517013549805,
-0.15671516954898834,
-0.0969090685248375,
0.2083762288093567,
-0.1482904851436615,
0.1882551610469818,
0.14512348175048828,
-0.024846859276294708,
-0.11730502545833588,
0.2657821476459503,
0.020282402634620667,
-0.10156543552875519,
0.33042052388191223,
0.3422478139400482,
0.27102214097976685,
-0.13194657862186432,
-0.3008826971054077,
-0.515937864780426,
0.5144605040550232,
0.7574231624603271,
-0.3318217098712921,
1.2242556810379028,
0.9056214094161987,
-0.5940585136413574,
0.0728892907500267,
-0.5762441158294678,
-0.2708827555179596,
-0.39531123638153076,
0.23958303034305573,
-0.5102037787437439,
-0.7359578013420105,
0.5394258499145508,
0.38558512926101685,
0.037287212908267975,
0.4769868552684784,
0.2783704698085785,
0.09983653575181961,
0.6986889839172363,
1.036932349205017,
-0.20234443247318268,
0.5019606351852417,
0.19417637586593628,
0.1536065638065338,
-0.5115349888801575,
-0.08825724571943283,
-0.7124256491661072,
-0.3746972680091858,
-0.31354132294654846,
-0.3211376667022705,
0.4590469300746918,
-0.2358957827091217,
0.025644149631261826,
0.37666890025138855,
-0.35154473781585693,
0.3332653343677521,
0.6512507796287537,
0.09513060748577118,
0.4131641089916229,
0.0407901369035244,
0.10875347256660461,
-0.08541993796825409,
-0.34398359060287476,
-0.4838172197341919,
0.9052014946937561,
0.24342000484466553,
0.5537953972816467,
0.41340041160583496,
0.7657285332679749,
0.5139502286911011,
0.3324718177318573,
-0.48125672340393066,
0.4722541570663452,
-0.18349207937717438,
-0.8776618242263794,
-0.49551627039909363,
-0.09948259592056274,
-0.5761173963546753,
0.48647183179855347,
-0.5441299676895142,
-0.8367312550544739,
-0.026010803878307343,
0.3000306487083435,
-0.2131659984588623,
0.05062391608953476,
-0.6670352816581726,
1.1152290105819702,
-0.32887032628059387,
-0.23721148073673248,
-0.32156795263290405,
-0.8690698742866516,
0.5720088481903076,
-0.2982247769832611,
0.4122709333896637,
-0.18918302655220032,
-0.1904299557209015,
0.900090754032135,
-0.2512223720550537,
1.1117901802062988,
-0.10857899487018585,
-0.26060688495635986,
0.18669284880161285,
0.13934701681137085,
0.44896766543388367,
-0.11183826625347137,
-0.3007689416408539,
-0.06617290526628494,
-0.053580787032842636,
-0.3100382387638092,
-0.4371422529220581,
0.6365366578102112,
-0.5553413033485413,
-0.2573845386505127,
-0.8145374655723572,
-0.6509466171264648,
-0.15673470497131348,
0.24080830812454224,
0.15593361854553223,
0.31221097707748413,
-0.2026156336069107,
0.15313179790973663,
-0.03800126910209656,
-0.044323500245809555,
0.25358375906944275,
-0.041649457067251205,
-0.17077668011188507,
-0.04818706959486008,
0.9292792081832886,
-0.3066391050815582,
0.2579292953014374,
0.3551585078239441,
0.419737845659256,
-0.46726539731025696,
-0.2353391796350479,
-0.40985989570617676,
0.5235772132873535,
-0.7359892129898071,
-0.095918670296669,
-0.8519022464752197,
0.16080783307552338,
-0.30098211765289307,
-0.5095964074134827,
-0.3590570390224457,
-0.49509549140930176,
-0.5655942559242249,
0.09147109091281891,
0.6052151322364807,
0.6820995211601257,
0.28215739130973816,
0.5765257477760315,
-0.5260328054428101,
0.4323329031467438,
-0.08277836441993713,
-0.03309628367424011,
0.18928483128547668,
-0.24422456324100494,
-0.24205222725868225,
-0.12697668373584747,
-0.21846039593219757,
-0.9253200888633728,
0.396936297416687,
0.5273681282997131,
0.46563249826431274,
0.40773558616638184,
-0.1001163125038147,
0.5984095335006714,
-0.319773405790329,
0.7461721897125244,
0.3790052831172943,
-1.0689021348953247,
0.4139503836631775,
-0.31174618005752563,
0.13432113826274872,
0.6286329627037048,
0.48251771926879883,
-0.2950523793697357,
-0.8430616855621338,
-0.5115254521369934,
-0.5412488579750061,
0.9039114713668823,
0.5257198810577393,
-0.00202258606441319,
0.12150459736585617,
0.06280630081892014,
0.17350617051124573,
0.7543683648109436,
-0.9750913977622986,
-0.37597718834877014,
0.025276578962802887,
-0.2960430085659027,
-0.5077539682388306,
-0.14164267480373383,
-0.09075197577476501,
-0.39479562640190125,
0.5376207232475281,
-0.21332290768623352,
0.3975309729576111,
-0.1640326976776123,
-0.3170792758464813,
0.10228056460618973,
0.06703600287437439,
0.7123437523841858,
0.7457901835441589,
-0.06936061382293701,
0.2894042432308197,
-0.3663190007209778,
-0.33106568455696106,
0.04215081036090851,
0.24206097424030304,
0.2178637981414795,
0.09605089575052261,
0.9445815086364746,
0.5719619393348694,
0.2980973422527313,
-0.5316243767738342,
0.6871024370193481,
0.32362067699432373,
-0.07374880462884903,
-0.42720067501068115,
0.08058393746614456,
0.24471066892147064,
0.06571941077709198,
0.4776563346385956,
0.2784269452095032,
0.1921566277742386,
-0.6872656345367432,
0.1670243740081787,
0.47990018129348755,
-0.3413110077381134,
-0.05687745660543442,
0.7392732501029968,
-0.020966794341802597,
-0.046484336256980896,
0.5890999436378479,
-0.026739608496427536,
-0.6223626136779785,
0.7642134428024292,
0.7151718735694885,
0.9967296719551086,
-0.20711129903793335,
0.24274343252182007,
-0.021550247445702553,
0.41811543703079224,
0.10451170057058334,
0.29347097873687744,
0.10907381772994995,
-0.663114607334137,
-0.2556441128253937,
-0.7520990371704102,
-0.04642767086625099,
-0.242734894156456,
-0.324118047952652,
0.3479425311088562,
-0.29456010460853577,
-0.018219416961073875,
0.5324145555496216,
-0.42543748021125793,
-0.6225101947784424,
0.20010101795196533,
0.23886795341968536,
0.425390362739563,
-1.3652923107147217,
0.5565348267555237,
0.6874367594718933,
-0.36061790585517883,
-0.553960919380188,
-0.2576740086078644,
0.6423535943031311,
-0.6550096869468689,
0.49935004115104675,
0.5359992384910583,
-0.5860241055488586,
0.04442532733082771,
-0.4689977765083313,
-0.8067108392715454,
1.0084500312805176,
0.6560966968536377,
0.11835414916276932,
-0.09680117666721344,
0.2307329624891281,
0.49958348274230957,
-1.0516655445098877,
0.23607848584651947,
0.3916319012641907,
0.5121967196464539,
0.0178903229534626,
-0.9491085410118103,
0.44212806224823,
-0.17460031807422638,
0.013370895758271217,
0.10909552872180939,
-0.3862203061580658,
1.0450329780578613,
-0.32575666904449463,
-0.09246250241994858,
-0.20401252806186676,
0.8955880403518677,
0.511540949344635,
0.16498619318008423,
0.7712002992630005,
0.1426132172346115,
0.7284355163574219,
0.11806127429008484,
1.1539983749389648,
-0.030681585893034935,
0.015566578134894371,
1.1049277782440186,
-0.1057395190000534,
0.6968441605567932,
0.7393459677696228,
-0.09479987621307373,
0.6803609728813171,
0.1678902804851532,
0.11083455383777618,
0.38083314895629883,
0.334852010011673,
-0.33603253960609436,
-0.2414725124835968,
-0.22064782679080963,
-0.22468076646327972,
0.7929821014404297,
0.19432120025157928,
-0.8112927675247192,
0.011315654963254929,
0.21519885957241058,
0.2155655473470688,
0.29597586393356323,
0.09513044357299805,
0.48417767882347107,
0.14596378803253174,
-0.48593616485595703,
0.5340050458908081,
0.21390046179294586,
0.8582484126091003,
-0.6150798797607422,
-0.047553520649671555,
0.4098537266254425,
0.09032318741083145,
-0.3781808316707611,
-0.5454907417297363,
0.49392062425613403,
-0.1734635829925537,
-0.25585809350013733,
-0.4288407266139984,
0.5742945671081543,
-0.5820993781089783,
-0.9611383676528931,
0.170024111866951,
0.5914134979248047,
0.2528783082962036,
-0.6820592880249023,
-0.6598585247993469,
0.20487259328365326,
-0.15631090104579926,
-0.28481805324554443,
0.18024325370788574,
0.4426335394382477,
-0.18756115436553955,
0.7656566500663757,
0.6121143698692322,
-0.009716534055769444,
0.17262578010559082,
0.1383727490901947,
0.5183644890785217,
-0.7718296647071838,
-0.7696567177772522,
-0.9813998937606812,
0.649764895439148,
0.022327592596411705,
-0.426645427942276,
0.6104776859283447,
0.5686092376708984,
0.46080273389816284,
-0.5395047068595886,
0.8177254796028137,
-0.38914886116981506,
0.34581559896469116,
-0.5599108338356018,
1.0416561365127563,
-0.9509326815605164,
-0.038835830986499786,
-0.8755390644073486,
-0.810261070728302,
-0.4280463457107544,
0.7149181962013245,
0.18937404453754425,
0.25442346930503845,
1.0415223836898804,
0.5288271903991699,
-0.146124005317688,
0.28550344705581665,
0.04789363220334053,
-0.1336192786693573,
0.47406846284866333,
0.34938526153564453,
0.4898589551448822,
-0.3970756232738495,
0.28510966897010803,
-0.43993785977363586,
-0.3210749626159668,
-0.18053299188613892,
-1.3150067329406738,
-0.9941532015800476,
-0.9506691694259644,
-0.6093230247497559,
-0.028490398079156876,
-0.30992013216018677,
0.9349187612533569,
0.4213559329509735,
-0.71330326795578,
-0.48805832862854004,
0.06375627219676971,
0.12979337573051453,
-0.868132472038269,
-0.2584809958934784,
0.48783040046691895,
-0.2599092721939087,
-0.5574014782905579,
0.29978060722351074,
-0.12859217822551727,
-0.031213728711009026,
-0.2065577358007431,
0.22656390070915222,
-0.7665600180625916,
-0.04800114035606384,
0.7999093532562256,
-0.17558667063713074,
-1.0153512954711914,
-0.3212987184524536,
-0.13857868313789368,
-0.10425150394439697,
-0.1789252758026123,
1.0954430103302002,
-0.6276001930236816,
0.2907937467098236,
0.10904403775930405,
0.4394865036010742,
0.24323835968971252,
0.2072935849428177,
0.7464967370033264,
-1.079866886138916,
0.1140279695391655,
0.24350036680698395,
0.22367249429225922,
0.29334452748298645,
-0.7548756003379822,
0.4511125981807709,
0.1807175576686859,
-0.18510451912879944,
-0.8558316230773926,
0.06047658994793892,
-1.0466609001159668,
-0.24316731095314026,
0.8993501663208008,
-0.015513033606112003,
0.04196010157465935,
-0.24409538507461548,
0.01219111867249012,
0.22072730958461761,
-0.5345699191093445,
0.6638124585151672,
1.0212446451187134,
-0.5360206365585327,
-0.29091885685920715,
-0.37538278102874756,
0.7997538447380066,
0.4156227707862854,
-0.6528042554855347,
0.4191594123840332,
0.709692120552063,
-0.08051490038633347,
0.5708909630775452,
0.7635591626167297,
0.003672775812447071,
0.2111302614212036,
-0.04162709414958954,
0.004476381931453943,
-0.4278671443462372,
-0.8047017455101013,
-0.06995143741369247,
0.38590332865715027,
0.07985693216323853,
-0.056688759475946426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08215v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08215v1
|
SumHiS: Extractive Summarization Exploiting Hidden Structure
| 2024-06-12T13:44:58 | 2024-06-12T13:44:58 |
Tikhonov Pavel, Anastasiya Ianina, Valentin Malykh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extractive summarization is a task of highlighting the most important parts
of the text. We introduce a new approach to extractive summarization task using
hidden clustering structure of the text. Experimental results on CNN/DailyMail
demonstrate that our approach generates more accurate summaries than both
extractive and abstractive methods, achieving state-of-the-art results in terms
of ROUGE-2 metric exceeding the previous approaches by 10%. Additionally, we
show that hidden structure of the text could be interpreted as aspects.
|
[
-0.06853149086236954,
-0.704475998878479,
0.31846562027931213,
0.15367238223552704,
-0.4737014174461365,
0.5847154855728149,
0.16624854505062103,
-0.4130231738090515,
0.841831624507904,
0.28404802083969116,
-0.5124500393867493,
-0.541691243648529,
-0.8569996356964111,
-0.016971314325928688,
-0.7957836985588074,
1.2355122566223145,
0.24464502930641174,
-0.25471749901771545,
0.00650380365550518,
-0.07389882206916809,
-0.19743667542934418,
-0.3387402892112732,
-0.24179372191429138,
0.020646579563617706,
0.7105474472045898,
0.6532215476036072,
0.34636572003364563,
0.9395433664321899,
0.8605490326881409,
0.26585033535957336,
-0.48819980025291443,
0.018143536522984505,
-0.43500852584838867,
0.3125452399253845,
-0.21869291365146637,
-0.7230530977249146,
-0.5529941916465759,
0.05467386171221733,
0.48465535044670105,
0.6153074502944946,
0.1281186193227768,
0.3177713453769684,
0.04991612583398819,
1.093528389930725,
-0.7976056933403015,
0.2610788941383362,
-0.4088098108768463,
0.028357524424791336,
-0.24292650818824768,
-0.26054126024246216,
-0.0341208316385746,
-0.42763552069664,
0.050656720995903015,
-0.42902883887290955,
0.6480618119239807,
-0.1650565266609192,
0.9184487462043762,
0.13335400819778442,
-0.6442505121231079,
-0.08658337593078613,
-0.7223109006881714,
0.6828892230987549,
-0.6408456563949585,
-0.07050378620624542,
0.15378674864768982,
0.49600455164909363,
0.4002532958984375,
-0.874005138874054,
-0.3082176744937897,
0.215455561876297,
-0.4853154420852661,
0.6252116560935974,
-0.19754956662654877,
-0.170059934258461,
0.19439607858657837,
1.0288209915161133,
-0.2859756648540497,
-0.1549142450094223,
-0.5866850018501282,
-0.1258184164762497,
0.816303551197052,
0.08668848872184753,
0.24971725046634674,
-0.255899041891098,
-0.10250823944807053,
-0.08572950959205627,
-0.6310684680938721,
-0.03884608671069145,
0.19873550534248352,
0.20006269216537476,
-0.21214577555656433,
0.7524318099021912,
-0.5395467281341553,
0.10260269790887833,
0.10114286839962006,
-0.18816633522510529,
0.22919930517673492,
-0.4534582197666168,
-0.1490669548511505,
0.1193375289440155,
0.36010563373565674,
0.6953279972076416,
-0.03950376808643341,
-0.25479212403297424,
-0.025210898369550705,
-0.19706518948078156,
0.08843798190355301,
-0.859830915927887,
-0.2123885303735733,
0.29072678089141846,
-0.7842617630958557,
-0.9083442091941833,
0.35579603910446167,
-1.0823943614959717,
-0.1992735117673874,
0.10387264937162399,
0.2871361970901489,
0.0031438509467989206,
-0.3641808331012726,
-0.5479623079299927,
-0.8858472108840942,
0.16016872227191925,
0.47697192430496216,
-1.0446888208389282,
0.4478221833705902,
0.6505783200263977,
1.1260007619857788,
-0.7790725827217102,
-0.07969779521226883,
-0.5007960200309753,
0.4507827162742615,
-0.40687453746795654,
0.9763180613517761,
-0.4283555746078491,
-0.3698686361312866,
-0.3074779808521271,
0.1946527063846588,
0.25231942534446716,
-0.5341199040412903,
0.31990039348602295,
-0.4376663267612457,
0.2804575562477112,
-0.38720938563346863,
-0.32463571429252625,
-0.5198496580123901,
0.2062825858592987,
-0.9947707056999207,
1.15670645236969,
0.1762484461069107,
-0.7942839860916138,
0.2577052414417267,
-0.6857671737670898,
-0.752713143825531,
-0.14755584299564362,
-0.05936938896775246,
-0.38380134105682373,
0.5705881714820862,
0.5733274221420288,
0.47116991877555847,
0.2956678569316864,
-0.06982944160699844,
0.35746005177497864,
-0.39397430419921875,
0.1687106043100357,
-0.21621261537075043,
0.6520403027534485,
0.02036171406507492,
-0.7213645577430725,
0.581219494342804,
-0.8921374678611755,
-0.36078277230262756,
0.21462216973304749,
-0.10561195760965347,
-0.5102290511131287,
0.07807089388370514,
0.12625455856323242,
0.0937444344162941,
0.24729683995246887,
-0.4231400191783905,
0.06942258030176163,
-0.7352813482284546,
0.1804855465888977,
0.5402686595916748,
0.4184139668941498,
0.7916222214698792,
-0.32618626952171326,
0.5593795776367188,
-0.02079673483967781,
-0.06441590934991837,
-0.7117540836334229,
-0.38853514194488525,
-0.731671929359436,
-0.45274093747138977,
0.31140607595443726,
0.6334278583526611,
-0.3736967146396637,
0.42118820548057556,
-0.16444091498851776,
-0.7232244610786438,
-0.2616272568702698,
-0.2160959243774414,
0.48406562209129333,
0.30520614981651306,
0.20685479044914246,
-0.1439875215291977,
-0.3785179853439331,
-0.9433634877204895,
-0.3545459806919098,
0.29502299427986145,
-0.06177414208650589,
-0.13156658411026,
0.5970844626426697,
0.35864096879959106,
0.6226548552513123,
-0.8594027161598206,
-0.41499772667884827,
-0.857977569103241,
0.11218002438545227,
0.17574959993362427,
0.4704146385192871,
0.42224887013435364,
-1.1051841974258423,
-0.7011842131614685,
0.04722914844751358,
-0.7743999361991882,
0.12645110487937927,
-0.0751575231552124,
-0.012037872336804867,
-0.11139557510614395,
0.6815317869186401,
-0.5985456705093384,
0.7346045970916748,
0.2274826616048813,
-0.1744718998670578,
0.3737371563911438,
-0.16366274654865265,
0.08573507517576218,
-1.2690972089767456,
0.21952705085277557,
-0.33948835730552673,
-0.5327168703079224,
-0.570779025554657,
0.5685664415359497,
0.09727421402931213,
-0.14063706994056702,
-0.24473977088928223,
0.3825035095214844,
-0.844596803188324,
-0.2531525492668152,
-0.5439139008522034,
0.19992639124393463,
0.28835949301719666,
0.621153712272644,
-0.0478985570371151,
0.5499756336212158,
0.39378485083580017,
-0.4555303156375885,
0.21618890762329102,
0.044754158705472946,
-0.13529351353645325,
0.056558433920145035,
-0.7409173250198364,
-0.0931365117430687,
-0.27449509501457214,
0.13575421273708344,
-1.1348689794540405,
-0.5276869535446167,
-0.013047565706074238,
-0.38065388798713684,
0.4318213164806366,
0.172044575214386,
-0.21996860206127167,
-0.0726863220334053,
-0.8384425044059753,
0.23878781497478485,
0.42908674478530884,
-0.19143185019493103,
0.5924891233444214,
0.6936050653457642,
-0.5506436228752136,
-0.6940401792526245,
-0.5486963391304016,
0.08554129302501678,
-0.29919758439064026,
-0.03179830685257912,
0.7649003267288208,
0.2242773473262787,
-0.38885483145713806,
0.07292727380990982,
-0.44546639919281006,
-0.009585793130099773,
0.39064034819602966,
0.4808443784713745,
0.09902897477149963,
-0.09867148846387863,
-0.27619749307632446,
0.5420443415641785,
-0.34531158208847046,
-0.09612811356782913,
0.06749875843524933,
0.45287591218948364,
0.03461804613471031,
-0.1330358386039734,
-0.6737496852874756,
1.1067783832550049,
0.52459716796875,
-0.39672693610191345,
0.5474483966827393,
0.5798086524009705,
-0.4634987711906433,
0.04071923717856407,
-0.33654719591140747,
-0.36297494173049927,
-0.4137989580631256,
0.6464380621910095,
0.05704164505004883,
-0.7224215865135193,
0.7195152640342712,
-0.0384812168776989,
0.34043824672698975,
0.9627971649169922,
0.4116969406604767,
-0.2535846531391144,
1.2199991941452026,
1.1832196712493896,
-0.21085065603256226,
0.5557819604873657,
-0.27898746728897095,
0.07687235623598099,
-0.575641393661499,
-0.4244847893714905,
-0.5181695818901062,
-0.5046589374542236,
-0.4264387786388397,
-0.044351380318403244,
0.385915607213974,
0.23938767611980438,
0.6556309461593628,
0.32890212535858154,
-0.6525992751121521,
0.8378681540489197,
0.79115229845047,
0.25221192836761475,
0.5071892142295837,
0.24331127107143402,
0.4011874198913574,
-0.10255078971385956,
-0.2123897522687912,
-0.3840792775154114,
0.8216241598129272,
0.07396622747182846,
0.41359463334083557,
0.24254058301448822,
0.8705433011054993,
0.40819305181503296,
0.16202573478221893,
-1.0172407627105713,
0.4852668344974518,
-0.053370073437690735,
-0.3532666862010956,
-0.4778934419155121,
-0.19719889760017395,
-0.9889013767242432,
0.3642968535423279,
-0.22710451483726501,
-0.6248720288276672,
0.11485301703214645,
-0.04891365393996239,
-0.2565080523490906,
0.15902379155158997,
-0.6254022121429443,
0.40718594193458557,
0.17901553213596344,
0.126771479845047,
-0.4437902271747589,
-0.8777099847793579,
0.2632943391799927,
0.23073038458824158,
0.3221036195755005,
-0.011557023972272873,
-0.04829917103052139,
1.1014797687530518,
-0.2985103726387024,
0.816369891166687,
-0.07429373264312744,
0.0808083787560463,
0.13274003565311432,
0.008447648957371712,
0.5121817588806152,
-0.2367817461490631,
0.2966141104698181,
-0.026787178590893745,
-0.07468553632497787,
-0.5184360146522522,
-0.8111139535903931,
0.27442467212677,
-0.17614896595478058,
-0.7340467572212219,
-0.446178138256073,
-0.5981478095054626,
0.31800708174705505,
0.5300483107566833,
0.456512987613678,
0.6783088445663452,
-0.25790053606033325,
-0.0569177120923996,
0.42620986700057983,
0.12821416556835175,
0.8249323964118958,
0.16388146579265594,
-0.12828116118907928,
-0.32705453038215637,
1.0882723331451416,
0.00009014010720420629,
-0.00914833415299654,
1.033843755722046,
0.39178773760795593,
-0.046166930347681046,
-0.8396831154823303,
-0.3284362852573395,
0.19474247097969055,
-0.612370491027832,
-0.13297605514526367,
-0.8441480398178101,
-0.3631719946861267,
-0.5267234444618225,
-0.24688483774662018,
-0.30390679836273193,
-1.1411486864089966,
-0.04007568210363388,
-0.6060929894447327,
0.017299151048064232,
1.077425479888916,
0.0019447157392278314,
0.39064186811447144,
-1.1184635162353516,
0.3345327377319336,
0.42219480872154236,
-0.3050082325935364,
0.015063508413732052,
-0.1500375121831894,
-0.5076963305473328,
-0.44248420000076294,
-0.25834769010543823,
-1.30411696434021,
0.5438604950904846,
0.21479694545269012,
0.6123970746994019,
0.6983541250228882,
-0.12911802530288696,
0.4556635618209839,
-0.2916884124279022,
1.0148682594299316,
0.05332458019256592,
-0.8474763035774231,
0.943988561630249,
-0.4281443953514099,
0.289660781621933,
0.6002665162086487,
0.24993565678596497,
-0.20043684542179108,
-0.5968524217605591,
-0.7382827401161194,
-1.0255630016326904,
0.5035744905471802,
0.4784945845603943,
-0.00356729025952518,
0.1918450891971588,
0.30095863342285156,
0.18995700776576996,
0.3696143329143524,
-0.4824036657810211,
-0.46744516491889954,
-0.07939107716083527,
-0.202523335814476,
0.011420122347772121,
-0.6209298968315125,
-0.3419906795024872,
-0.1921568214893341,
0.34148362278938293,
0.07740716636180878,
0.18963374197483063,
0.295299232006073,
-0.3340226709842682,
0.18066641688346863,
0.17091204226016998,
0.7337443828582764,
0.8530711531639099,
-0.3128601610660553,
0.4640147089958191,
-0.03016597405076027,
-0.9499725103378296,
-0.2294352948665619,
-0.19447819888591766,
-0.23597809672355652,
0.19462037086486816,
0.8110743761062622,
0.36208024621009827,
0.21068958938121796,
-0.5103440880775452,
0.9501692652702332,
-0.036550626158714294,
0.032324474304914474,
-0.15709032118320465,
0.23264442384243011,
-0.21490557491779327,
0.41281822323799133,
0.842153012752533,
0.2792903184890747,
0.6316038966178894,
-0.7254242300987244,
0.20791761577129364,
0.26222145557403564,
-0.5522836446762085,
-0.6073744893074036,
0.5894573330879211,
0.18611963093280792,
-0.14365921914577484,
0.09349450469017029,
-0.11627919226884842,
-0.6355751156806946,
0.8740404844284058,
0.5098304152488708,
0.9144047498703003,
-0.2440529763698578,
0.32262155413627625,
0.32004082202911377,
0.19736085832118988,
0.14749184250831604,
0.2924903333187103,
-0.34354525804519653,
-0.06610870361328125,
-0.615095853805542,
-0.2750376760959625,
-0.4013269543647766,
-0.20231984555721283,
-1.0443689823150635,
-0.09320947527885437,
-0.09618230164051056,
0.4417739510536194,
0.19779783487319946,
0.010450106114149094,
0.2843776047229767,
0.17231744527816772,
-0.3112955689430237,
0.8892170786857605,
-0.7436798810958862,
0.42065390944480896,
0.4032284617424011,
-0.11049502342939377,
-0.5695264935493469,
0.027280591428279877,
0.1259230673313141,
-0.5571721196174622,
0.26000139117240906,
0.40281417965888977,
0.003195089055225253,
0.009673298336565495,
-0.6109631657600403,
-0.8807312250137329,
1.3319658041000366,
0.1515398621559143,
-0.22857525944709778,
-0.33589375019073486,
-0.33933019638061523,
0.2717105746269226,
-0.22542546689510345,
0.23448127508163452,
0.4568907618522644,
0.19221092760562897,
0.14081445336341858,
-0.5740228295326233,
0.21900010108947754,
-0.5954521894454956,
-0.42303916811943054,
0.22505614161491394,
-0.6533609628677368,
0.8471654057502747,
-0.5192617774009705,
-0.5829623937606812,
-0.1599375456571579,
0.9714397192001343,
-0.04922394081950188,
0.49532991647720337,
0.24844789505004883,
0.09460251033306122,
0.9064801335334778,
-0.0915263220667839,
1.126367449760437,
0.04704326391220093,
0.12297668308019638,
0.9995476603507996,
0.2647550404071808,
0.7153613567352295,
0.2917219400405884,
0.0934947282075882,
0.677596926689148,
0.4407861828804016,
-0.010386875830590725,
0.9268283843994141,
-0.3716452717781067,
0.012513602152466774,
0.23185843229293823,
0.07468850165605545,
-0.31568971276283264,
0.6323332190513611,
0.30173298716545105,
-0.35956600308418274,
-0.3482184410095215,
-0.2504104971885681,
0.3357306122779846,
0.1625099927186966,
-0.5646651983261108,
1.167786955833435,
-0.016524413600564003,
-0.48113253712654114,
-0.25253450870513916,
0.0994502529501915,
0.5317257642745972,
-0.4538249373435974,
-0.35865503549575806,
-0.37516868114471436,
-0.15420986711978912,
-0.5266697406768799,
-0.6356655359268188,
0.7269315719604492,
0.043035008013248444,
-0.5505707263946533,
-0.16839976608753204,
0.9633733034133911,
-0.26122263073921204,
-0.45659416913986206,
-0.08401259779930115,
0.6801139116287231,
0.3747884929180145,
-0.6311118006706238,
-0.15099699795246124,
-0.6006810069084167,
0.06676018983125687,
-0.18781684339046478,
0.3764194846153259,
0.2916092574596405,
-0.15790194272994995,
0.14081540703773499,
0.5702871680259705,
0.28151044249534607,
-0.06264153122901917,
0.14996400475502014,
0.9208118319511414,
-1.1346091032028198,
-1.022087574005127,
-1.2403085231781006,
0.5134050250053406,
-0.6671869158744812,
-0.17622894048690796,
1.099758267402649,
0.8992210626602173,
0.21643218398094177,
-0.026949021965265274,
0.6421583294868469,
-0.05578847602009773,
0.5707245469093323,
-0.4543158710002899,
0.9735270142555237,
-0.511579155921936,
0.08415218442678452,
-0.487434446811676,
-0.8887016773223877,
-0.3358798325061798,
0.26520615816116333,
0.2775631546974182,
-0.47266605496406555,
0.998663067817688,
0.5110546350479126,
0.1398940533399582,
0.16546569764614105,
0.12124785780906677,
0.09385543316602707,
0.22021135687828064,
-0.00048590029473416507,
0.7117284536361694,
-0.4345919191837311,
0.5643768310546875,
-0.512392520904541,
-0.68541020154953,
-0.14775004982948303,
-0.7707217335700989,
-1.141793131828308,
-0.7744749188423157,
-0.35818177461624146,
-0.12046816945075989,
-0.1568673551082611,
0.26860302686691284,
0.7620519399642944,
-1.0017905235290527,
0.05983398109674454,
-0.24883267283439636,
0.5589936375617981,
-0.7808587551116943,
-0.3464202582836151,
1.0507209300994873,
0.03764892369508743,
-0.876701295375824,
0.5604609251022339,
0.6130334138870239,
0.1759214997291565,
-0.1495482474565506,
0.70064777135849,
0.13035465776920319,
-0.2533392012119293,
0.7086651921272278,
0.008511599153280258,
-0.24803416430950165,
-0.02400047332048416,
0.11177906394004822,
-0.07964727282524109,
0.20981429517269135,
1.1120009422302246,
-0.4942329525947571,
-0.08459396660327911,
0.6316478848457336,
0.33693161606788635,
0.9679530262947083,
0.29355737566947937,
0.471804678440094,
-0.9907382130622864,
0.18542881309986115,
0.01981741562485695,
0.030137546360492706,
0.09384791553020477,
-0.6329429745674133,
0.37321341037750244,
0.2819669842720032,
-0.1709398329257965,
-0.7327739596366882,
0.14263983070850372,
-1.3144479990005493,
-0.2575613260269165,
0.856593668460846,
-0.09001991152763367,
-0.4928533136844635,
-0.2158861607313156,
-0.3576369285583496,
0.43981170654296875,
-0.4834907650947571,
0.9092003703117371,
0.2524248957633972,
-0.1078031063079834,
-0.2370261251926422,
-0.19525068998336792,
0.6934037804603577,
0.13447056710720062,
-1.0772309303283691,
-0.11519017815589905,
0.1512816846370697,
0.14015156030654907,
0.47336965799331665,
0.6534423232078552,
-0.30835139751434326,
0.09380607306957245,
0.17400704324245453,
-0.40821754932403564,
-0.24372465908527374,
-0.5875838994979858,
-0.2165006697177887,
0.7014280557632446,
-0.6335853934288025,
-0.32599925994873047
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.08207v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.08207v1
|
Transformer-based Model for ASR N-Best Rescoring and Rewriting
| 2024-06-12T13:39:44 | 2024-06-12T13:39:44 |
Iwen E. Kang, Christophe Van Gysel, Man-Hung Siu
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Voice assistants increasingly use on-device Automatic Speech Recognition
(ASR) to ensure speed and privacy. However, due to resource constraints on the
device, queries pertaining to complex information domains often require further
processing by a search engine. For such applications, we propose a novel
Transformer based model capable of rescoring and rewriting, by exploring full
context of the N-best hypotheses in parallel. We also propose a new
discriminative sequence training objective that can work well for both rescore
and rewrite tasks. We show that our Rescore+Rewrite model outperforms the
Rescore-only baseline, and achieves up to an average 8.6% relative Word Error
Rate (WER) reduction over the ASR system by itself.
|
[
-0.24304650723934174,
-0.36383602023124695,
0.2846989631652832,
-0.04283462464809418,
-0.08729125559329987,
0.1326366364955902,
-0.10656123608350754,
-0.1803624927997589,
0.2717728018760681,
0.6409493088722229,
-0.5610572695732117,
-0.1502155214548111,
-0.5335354208946228,
0.33139899373054504,
-0.8529567122459412,
0.5738324522972107,
0.18518544733524323,
-0.06639527529478073,
-0.23612193763256073,
-0.23578886687755585,
-0.5938634276390076,
-0.5395521521568298,
-0.9402350783348083,
-0.44452181458473206,
0.347867876291275,
0.5357663631439209,
0.49352750182151794,
0.7383085489273071,
0.5524513721466064,
0.34553271532058716,
-0.0814746543765068,
0.07381588965654373,
-0.2119554877281189,
0.4497424066066742,
0.0015462610172107816,
-0.6583356261253357,
-0.5121021270751953,
-0.24535855650901794,
0.7165836691856384,
0.4400878846645355,
-0.6224281191825867,
0.20781970024108887,
-0.15516184270381927,
0.5372879505157471,
-0.4557304084300995,
-0.1475183367729187,
-0.9031980037689209,
-0.053037870675325394,
0.12191147357225418,
-0.08157128840684891,
-0.5059460997581482,
-0.39019575715065,
0.17093893885612488,
-0.6067429184913635,
0.8720265030860901,
0.04350766912102699,
0.8057680130004883,
0.6740193963050842,
-0.24202877283096313,
-0.10343439131975174,
-1.0522942543029785,
0.6932210326194763,
-0.5049790740013123,
1.1348258256912231,
0.4017845392227173,
0.5454620718955994,
0.10135813057422638,
-0.9341624975204468,
-0.8408451080322266,
-0.18323269486427307,
0.12943841516971588,
-0.2905276119709015,
-0.587440550327301,
-0.22528362274169922,
0.27013692259788513,
0.5177044868469238,
-0.35891515016555786,
-0.0013450492406263947,
-0.3092493414878845,
-0.2626689076423645,
0.7060756683349609,
0.11521844565868378,
0.15666550397872925,
-0.016210952773690224,
-0.09832923114299774,
-0.19806623458862305,
-0.526452898979187,
-0.04074501991271973,
-0.024764306843280792,
0.31336525082588196,
0.20899233222007751,
0.3794068992137909,
-0.130135178565979,
0.5334661602973938,
0.47422856092453003,
-0.2708202600479126,
0.46423426270484924,
-0.17318351566791534,
-0.2909596264362335,
0.19918480515480042,
0.6211187839508057,
0.36764976382255554,
0.08669887483119965,
-0.5585930347442627,
-0.3787352740764618,
0.31269195675849915,
0.6754648685455322,
-0.5824889540672302,
0.04278605803847313,
0.11210045963525772,
-0.4929081201553345,
-0.12412049621343613,
-0.24729453027248383,
-0.4962397515773773,
-0.15698277950286865,
-0.47993919253349304,
0.28557726740837097,
-0.34059664607048035,
-0.07427582144737244,
0.1481834053993225,
-0.022885771468281746,
0.3560405969619751,
0.17341923713684082,
-0.6126402020454407,
0.5702120065689087,
0.6500945687294006,
0.8260791301727295,
-0.21310637891292572,
-0.3128238022327423,
-0.6630776524543762,
0.1251375675201416,
0.028929412364959717,
0.9817457795143127,
-0.5311653017997742,
-0.8140845894813538,
-0.228609099984169,
0.15023885667324066,
-0.30582067370414734,
-0.6836615204811096,
1.0648140907287598,
-0.49011123180389404,
0.16029252111911774,
-0.0786466971039772,
-0.7015955448150635,
-0.06385623663663864,
-0.013599607162177563,
-0.9721048474311829,
0.7697438597679138,
-0.29826605319976807,
-0.30760061740875244,
0.2120966911315918,
-0.6297047138214111,
-0.6866315007209778,
-0.41434022784233093,
0.08123795688152313,
-0.8148906826972961,
0.3447878062725067,
0.30045086145401,
0.14392854273319244,
-0.6453444361686707,
0.46469739079475403,
0.4187633693218231,
-0.3242630064487457,
0.08794393390417099,
-0.589525580406189,
0.3579234778881073,
0.23573337495326996,
-0.43488702178001404,
0.23862630128860474,
-0.8693206310272217,
-0.11116144061088562,
0.21095891296863556,
-0.39774808287620544,
0.07982704043388367,
-0.013062858954071999,
0.0006516223656944931,
-0.1840827614068985,
0.08385694772005081,
-0.9707651734352112,
0.07193679362535477,
-0.20369373261928558,
0.6510920524597168,
0.29530972242355347,
-0.25309574604034424,
0.5057804584503174,
-0.5244689583778381,
0.5024705529212952,
-0.36954596638679504,
0.2111978381872177,
-0.06061949580907822,
-0.4511650800704956,
-0.8212710022926331,
0.011388971470296383,
0.2805481255054474,
0.6562457084655762,
-0.7419167160987854,
0.30059292912483215,
-0.5139150619506836,
-0.6535903811454773,
-0.8781121969223022,
-0.1669023185968399,
0.8314332365989685,
0.6772216558456421,
0.4923253357410431,
-0.39513733983039856,
-0.6368816494941711,
-0.9517235159873962,
-0.3988686800003052,
-0.12190116196870804,
-0.16323937475681305,
0.3845852017402649,
-0.12075302004814148,
-0.41686737537384033,
0.8464983105659485,
-0.5952644944190979,
-0.5691400766372681,
-0.45914462208747864,
0.020374471321702003,
0.17649208009243011,
0.29513394832611084,
-0.024279765784740448,
-1.0304207801818848,
-0.357500821352005,
-0.26828593015670776,
-0.360630065202713,
-0.37061265110969543,
-0.009025785140693188,
0.24296969175338745,
0.1448553055524826,
0.6882287859916687,
-0.6553946733474731,
0.5034621357917786,
0.2152014821767807,
-0.024228723719716072,
0.3431623876094818,
-0.2569326162338257,
0.054531656205654144,
-1.0222935676574707,
-0.06152160093188286,
-0.033998042345047,
-0.2052595019340515,
-1.203360676765442,
-0.17587269842624664,
-0.10850772261619568,
-0.2728433907032013,
-0.25487664341926575,
0.07449506223201752,
-0.46077823638916016,
-0.28796324133872986,
-0.6387479305267334,
-0.05631691589951515,
0.18013431131839752,
0.2819560766220093,
0.19353222846984863,
0.8749408721923828,
0.3317789137363434,
-0.5204072594642639,
0.20570722222328186,
0.7262911200523376,
-0.0730833113193512,
0.40613529086112976,
-0.9285053014755249,
0.45594847202301025,
-0.18302612006664276,
0.4360246956348419,
-0.7949047088623047,
0.10417189449071884,
-0.4378512501716614,
-0.7063402533531189,
0.21436470746994019,
-0.003835707902908325,
-0.38378170132637024,
-0.32745543122291565,
0.04715287312865257,
0.3945292532444,
0.5143039226531982,
-0.5885444283485413,
1.0472674369812012,
0.5369725227355957,
0.04713517799973488,
-0.31851887702941895,
-0.45187070965766907,
0.19209681451320648,
-0.23666884005069733,
-0.5896112322807312,
0.9167500138282776,
0.2402012199163437,
0.14644300937652588,
-0.33232972025871277,
-0.2601644694805145,
-0.2367272973060608,
-0.17493204772472382,
0.19883298873901367,
-0.013315371237695217,
-0.21674539148807526,
-0.07613824307918549,
-0.26270416378974915,
-0.38326990604400635,
-0.04963250085711479,
0.10436520725488663,
0.5849058628082275,
-0.0022068240214139223,
-0.367177277803421,
-0.937322199344635,
0.5977445840835571,
0.8144473433494568,
-0.529958188533783,
0.38312652707099915,
0.4573434889316559,
-0.46252068877220154,
-0.10334127396345139,
-0.8017566800117493,
-0.3288511037826538,
-0.46052286028862,
0.226073756814003,
-0.4819788932800293,
-0.8810012340545654,
0.5417612791061401,
0.07261910289525986,
0.13597264885902405,
0.29444339871406555,
0.33720457553863525,
0.20337344706058502,
0.7964929342269897,
0.6332108378410339,
-0.3085252344608307,
0.5908823609352112,
-0.31877973675727844,
0.4516737759113312,
-1.0970598459243774,
-0.27911344170570374,
-0.6043915152549744,
-0.19767679274082184,
-0.3687300384044647,
-0.39420273900032043,
0.3567828834056854,
-0.26769769191741943,
-0.2160947173833847,
0.7365378737449646,
-0.7565870881080627,
0.3329969346523285,
0.8895591497421265,
0.18368205428123474,
0.33340513706207275,
-0.026437662541866302,
0.3711177110671997,
0.05742150545120239,
-0.6961436867713928,
-0.45241501927375793,
1.159165859222412,
0.2641294300556183,
0.687406599521637,
0.2586098909378052,
0.5702938437461853,
0.20131735503673553,
0.023875856772065163,
-0.6313623189926147,
0.5303678512573242,
-0.5707200169563293,
-0.3091810941696167,
-0.5978835225105286,
-0.19279824197292328,
-0.8996286988258362,
0.17183390259742737,
0.10354869812726974,
-0.34004926681518555,
0.310394287109375,
0.43605223298072815,
-0.44311094284057617,
0.36525824666023254,
-0.696127712726593,
0.5015602707862854,
-0.016512734815478325,
-0.11575117707252502,
0.008812007494270802,
-0.5959535837173462,
-0.0902104377746582,
0.1292031854391098,
-0.06510891765356064,
0.13640043139457703,
0.21198058128356934,
0.6215879917144775,
-0.4552558958530426,
0.7024889588356018,
-0.4424305856227875,
0.023121077567338943,
0.42023012042045593,
0.0011077441740781069,
0.4971323013305664,
-0.3510170578956604,
-0.2199483960866928,
0.16294172406196594,
-0.3358885943889618,
0.28113552927970886,
-0.718237042427063,
0.42937976121902466,
-0.6295468807220459,
-0.8070911765098572,
-0.12602759897708893,
-0.3476787805557251,
-0.14534321427345276,
0.05320463329553604,
0.3886289894580841,
0.5951811075210571,
-0.015077455900609493,
0.2550453245639801,
0.6047154068946838,
-0.1805962473154068,
0.17466220259666443,
0.5792496204376221,
0.14040619134902954,
-0.22315959632396698,
1.0026553869247437,
0.0896289050579071,
0.4016070067882538,
0.48007336258888245,
0.3021260201931,
-0.6640100479125977,
-0.5233628749847412,
-0.3656507432460785,
0.15974506735801697,
-0.4354981482028961,
-0.21506275236606598,
-0.7953043580055237,
-0.415124773979187,
-0.5631588697433472,
-0.14858226478099823,
-0.6281453371047974,
-0.25062254071235657,
-0.2515718340873718,
0.007490683812648058,
0.41061192750930786,
0.2937881350517273,
0.03121435083448887,
0.44260910153388977,
-0.6079937815666199,
0.7056874632835388,
0.4039252996444702,
0.43136531114578247,
0.09888007491827011,
-0.8279457092285156,
0.2122388780117035,
-0.22427326440811157,
-0.3527323007583618,
-0.5824169516563416,
0.5549134016036987,
0.6622823476791382,
0.5696044564247131,
-0.17331990599632263,
0.06515856087207794,
0.7525753378868103,
-1.0977380275726318,
0.5665432214736938,
-0.00964860338717699,
-0.9775159955024719,
0.54032963514328,
0.08190867304801941,
0.31828203797340393,
0.5887444615364075,
-0.0471019521355629,
-0.610592782497406,
-0.10538413375616074,
-0.5042646527290344,
-0.8849929571151733,
0.5302060842514038,
0.36281681060791016,
-0.09287925064563751,
0.12520113587379456,
0.34514492750167847,
-0.02574976161122322,
0.09163891524076462,
-0.22588853538036346,
-0.31425029039382935,
-0.4430713653564453,
-0.11737043410539627,
-0.19497333467006683,
-0.18000352382659912,
0.37565848231315613,
-0.20224744081497192,
0.536961555480957,
-0.013424452394247055,
0.7606334686279297,
0.5417846441268921,
-0.1405307650566101,
0.06321365386247635,
0.36353930830955505,
0.6069254279136658,
-0.03280907869338989,
-0.1372969150543213,
-0.014613950625061989,
0.3380599915981293,
-0.5862525701522827,
0.39022666215896606,
0.028879083693027496,
-0.14401769638061523,
0.3123990297317505,
0.17486347258090973,
0.9744147658348083,
0.33129388093948364,
-0.5577930808067322,
0.36874163150787354,
-0.4702560603618622,
-0.11264686286449432,
-0.5398887395858765,
0.0888279601931572,
0.07302267849445343,
0.16156388819217682,
0.24452389776706696,
-0.055073175579309464,
0.5111820697784424,
-0.2734779119491577,
0.5412057638168335,
0.1605706661939621,
-0.2752199172973633,
-0.25915753841400146,
0.9707136750221252,
0.1795983910560608,
-0.9181859493255615,
0.5286902785301208,
0.10831144452095032,
-0.631956160068512,
0.5492678284645081,
0.8260368704795837,
1.132165551185608,
-0.8949177265167236,
-0.06540272384881973,
0.3965412974357605,
0.0631871297955513,
-0.271237313747406,
0.33777257800102234,
-0.15252047777175903,
-0.8342044949531555,
-0.1802213340997696,
-0.6294200420379639,
-0.6107924580574036,
-0.04866498336195946,
-0.9828357100486755,
0.1040213406085968,
-0.25349152088165283,
-0.23430095613002777,
0.30726712942123413,
-0.5289449095726013,
-0.5232709050178528,
0.4460025131702423,
-0.057656124234199524,
0.6938909888267517,
-0.5231480002403259,
0.8883397579193115,
0.3804000914096832,
-0.10462692379951477,
-0.7925519347190857,
-0.004777902737259865,
0.05367051437497139,
-0.7498387694358826,
0.5975149273872375,
0.1921137273311615,
-0.6482018828392029,
0.040564946830272675,
0.0609881728887558,
-1.1331745386123657,
1.2334415912628174,
0.4279896914958954,
-0.8726978302001953,
-0.28700610995292664,
0.17172382771968842,
0.5488182902336121,
-0.45018789172172546,
-0.018277311697602272,
0.7692059874534607,
0.035872187465429306,
0.26294445991516113,
-1.4388734102249146,
-0.08289328217506409,
-0.37405869364738464,
0.12200929969549179,
0.14062607288360596,
-0.6836652159690857,
0.81656414270401,
-0.12721861898899078,
-0.29392048716545105,
-0.047004006803035736,
0.5440767407417297,
0.15955056250095367,
0.528071403503418,
0.7626178860664368,
0.6302966475486755,
0.5446088910102844,
0.05645253509283066,
0.9455175399780273,
-0.2857935428619385,
0.07707124203443527,
1.3902087211608887,
-0.5078172087669373,
1.1450775861740112,
0.25610998272895813,
-0.05984168127179146,
0.3701273798942566,
-0.09444932639598846,
0.12594200670719147,
0.5909968018531799,
0.29588833451271057,
-0.3871631622314453,
-0.03310096636414528,
-0.2976721525192261,
-0.11431329697370529,
0.7429176568984985,
0.04294714331626892,
-0.4330540597438812,
0.05000239238142967,
0.11132211238145828,
-0.04234364256262779,
0.31459033489227295,
-0.20526427030563354,
1.016355276107788,
0.04875612631440163,
-0.6069739460945129,
0.7276963591575623,
0.007002061232924461,
0.7559491991996765,
-0.17881065607070923,
0.09981859475374222,
-0.16661296784877777,
0.2934708297252655,
-0.22285237908363342,
-0.4184727668762207,
0.7726547122001648,
0.4592972993850708,
-0.58924400806427,
-0.3401128053665161,
0.6906319260597229,
-0.2884213328361511,
-0.5007767081260681,
0.17877067625522614,
0.199357807636261,
0.14830774068832397,
-0.19632840156555176,
-0.4544583261013031,
0.2190600037574768,
0.21593570709228516,
0.07235501706600189,
-0.0561092384159565,
0.21846327185630798,
-0.06748568266630173,
0.9742660522460938,
0.750075101852417,
-0.1210118979215622,
0.21977533400058746,
0.4900442063808441,
0.7900645732879639,
-0.68442702293396,
-0.6362171173095703,
-0.5135157704353333,
0.2941633462905884,
-0.12634634971618652,
-0.192927747964859,
0.5781161189079285,
0.6331606507301331,
0.6731178760528564,
0.09559059888124466,
0.7114651203155518,
0.25740405917167664,
1.0194357633590698,
-0.24341262876987457,
0.6418721079826355,
-0.39218762516975403,
0.1962001770734787,
-0.1569717526435852,
-0.7576499581336975,
-0.35628101229667664,
0.7705730199813843,
-0.16317902505397797,
-0.2141878455877304,
0.367268830537796,
0.7935709357261658,
-0.012755545787513256,
0.4170863926410675,
0.3691959083080292,
-0.14071057736873627,
0.6647937297821045,
0.5898328423500061,
0.3866296708583832,
-0.6970704793930054,
0.4853203594684601,
-0.18271483480930328,
-0.04997575655579567,
-0.09674275666475296,
-0.4823518693447113,
-0.5853002667427063,
-0.8237720727920532,
-0.32269996404647827,
-0.050438616424798965,
0.08821550011634827,
0.716240644454956,
0.48447778820991516,
-0.7396904230117798,
-0.2709672749042511,
-0.18051792681217194,
-0.18750351667404175,
-0.030140237882733345,
-0.12933021783828735,
0.4149283170700073,
0.016781242564320564,
-0.5612191557884216,
0.7731479406356812,
-0.021338339895009995,
-0.1467047780752182,
0.01145592238754034,
-0.04893532022833824,
0.020546847954392433,
-0.0004929663264192641,
0.5457566976547241,
0.41543111205101013,
-0.8804911971092224,
-0.41570940613746643,
0.2758837938308716,
0.31210553646087646,
0.1683657020330429,
0.9419185519218445,
-0.8045434951782227,
0.5111873745918274,
0.157412588596344,
0.9120588302612305,
0.3577730357646942,
0.22122842073440552,
0.739116907119751,
-0.5248157978057861,
-0.18926386535167694,
0.31047993898391724,
0.3389841318130493,
0.5805417895317078,
-0.3183536231517792,
0.32219865918159485,
0.005527770146727562,
-0.7579353451728821,
-1.0231833457946777,
0.25641316175460815,
-0.7658177018165588,
0.23467540740966797,
1.0075432062149048,
0.05070999637246132,
-0.16950082778930664,
-0.16003207862377167,
-0.26929426193237305,
0.5258684754371643,
-0.5140458345413208,
0.7275180816650391,
0.08800895512104034,
-0.4251529574394226,
-0.37451058626174927,
-0.1497105211019516,
0.37020835280418396,
0.31856846809387207,
-0.5987053513526917,
0.32396262884140015,
0.30706995725631714,
0.38075897097587585,
0.35317322611808777,
0.7047793865203857,
0.04417800158262253,
0.2911308705806732,
0.06970568001270294,
0.21247048676013947,
-0.1548282951116562,
-0.4893606901168823,
-0.5813416838645935,
0.24266912043094635,
-0.05669986084103584,
-0.5544334053993225
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.