id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10203v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10203v1
|
A Fundamental Trade-off in Aligned Language Models and its Relation to Sampling Adaptors
| 2024-06-14T17:38:21 | 2024-06-14T17:38:21 |
Naaman Tan, Josef Valvoda, Anej Svete, Tianyu Liu, Yanxia Qin, Kan Min-Yen, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The relationship between the quality of a string and its probability
$p(\boldsymbol{y})$ under a language model has been influential in the
development of techniques to build good text generation systems. For example,
several decoding algorithms have been motivated to manipulate
$p(\boldsymbol{y})$ to produce higher-quality text. In this work, we examine
the probability--quality relationship in language models explicitly aligned to
human preferences, e.g., through Reinforcement Learning through Human Feedback
(RLHF). We find that, given a general language model and its aligned version,
for corpora sampled from an aligned language model, there exists a trade-off
between the average reward and average log-likelihood of the strings under the
general language model. We provide a formal treatment of this issue and
demonstrate how a choice of sampling adaptor allows for a selection of how much
likelihood we exchange for the reward.
|
[
-0.21147453784942627,
-0.37610381841659546,
0.46860000491142273,
-0.1537952423095703,
-0.28197044134140015,
-0.19285470247268677,
-0.37021318078041077,
-0.6507111191749573,
0.20264217257499695,
0.5226075053215027,
-0.28435224294662476,
-0.13226567208766937,
-0.3867756426334381,
-0.29087287187576294,
-0.34720322489738464,
1.45656418800354,
-0.04937496408820152,
-0.302295058965683,
-0.11795997619628906,
-0.1726040542125702,
-0.156882181763649,
-0.635814368724823,
-0.6265803575515747,
-0.3532496690750122,
0.5784735679626465,
0.04686689004302025,
1.0699553489685059,
0.5970377326011658,
0.5119290947914124,
0.28893014788627625,
0.16592401266098022,
-0.1708557903766632,
-0.5157403945922852,
0.26141157746315,
-0.5974463820457458,
-0.45948755741119385,
-0.27986228466033936,
0.32672086358070374,
0.6630932688713074,
0.7595229148864746,
-0.35239866375923157,
0.09189649671316147,
0.1620025783777237,
0.7598187327384949,
-0.6818720102310181,
-0.09254033863544464,
-0.5609416961669922,
-0.34463295340538025,
-0.10949990153312683,
-0.31726086139678955,
-0.5365867614746094,
-0.5665631294250488,
0.015691570937633514,
-0.7496262788772583,
0.21030277013778687,
0.10659066587686539,
1.180149793624878,
0.1539301723241806,
-0.1282598078250885,
-0.5098615884780884,
-0.747828483581543,
0.9586715698242188,
-0.31953009963035583,
0.2650902271270752,
0.35642772912979126,
0.15213093161582947,
-0.3997003436088562,
-0.4229024350643158,
-0.4300219714641571,
-0.02434428036212921,
-0.17786823213100433,
0.16613318026065826,
-0.07067903131246567,
0.16456085443496704,
-0.0805807039141655,
0.5104758739471436,
-0.36408042907714844,
0.10152941942214966,
-0.47200721502304077,
-0.24259807169437408,
0.8053419589996338,
-0.12333182245492935,
0.4043165147304535,
-0.13758790493011475,
-0.3260369300842285,
-0.5424304008483887,
-0.5752078294754028,
0.6882510781288147,
0.8607444167137146,
0.225491464138031,
0.20190952718257904,
0.5092706680297852,
0.21892520785331726,
1.1689774990081787,
0.2143993079662323,
-0.07718813419342041,
-0.21613071858882904,
-0.4066956341266632,
-0.05209553614258766,
-0.03882641717791557,
0.9103719592094421,
0.28799018263816833,
0.36155080795288086,
0.08919580280780792,
-0.595095157623291,
0.15862508118152618,
0.4266309440135956,
-0.43912312388420105,
-0.3975358009338379,
0.12506644427776337,
-0.6122835874557495,
-0.40976276993751526,
0.4060865044593811,
-0.5523870587348938,
0.17781810462474823,
-0.24095585942268372,
0.41915163397789,
-0.47318321466445923,
-0.2924789488315582,
0.06303056329488754,
-0.4080340266227722,
0.10478933900594711,
0.061566129326820374,
-1.3366754055023193,
0.39336124062538147,
0.6694839000701904,
0.4008796513080597,
-0.33752143383026123,
-0.24038992822170258,
-0.7753042578697205,
0.056940075010061264,
-0.4601224958896637,
0.9056808352470398,
-0.6744903922080994,
-0.3450140058994293,
0.024384871125221252,
-0.12609843909740448,
-0.1359117031097412,
-0.40840134024620056,
0.7643179893493652,
-0.7204849123954773,
0.40567412972450256,
-0.1751174032688141,
-0.7851600050926208,
-0.16325156390666962,
-0.1650586873292923,
-0.8033552169799805,
0.6789279580116272,
0.5256217122077942,
-0.567574143409729,
0.5879725217819214,
-0.16405518352985382,
-0.30026671290397644,
-0.002784856129437685,
-0.21730057895183563,
-0.31826138496398926,
0.24590390920639038,
-0.0031792400404810905,
0.0011408287100493908,
-0.04976562783122063,
0.3223419785499573,
-0.5060061812400818,
-0.6557697057723999,
0.8793866038322449,
-0.4333980977535248,
0.5872285962104797,
0.47788962721824646,
0.19878318905830383,
0.18263299763202667,
-0.705034077167511,
0.10340630263090134,
-0.20609153807163239,
-0.8264143466949463,
-0.5830151438713074,
0.13028299808502197,
0.22405292093753815,
0.26539406180381775,
0.10466375946998596,
-0.3714277446269989,
0.17157921195030212,
-0.4910133183002472,
0.2827604115009308,
0.8933684229850769,
-0.006472855340689421,
0.6455258131027222,
-0.579809844493866,
0.6375659704208374,
-0.07265748083591461,
-0.06502138078212738,
0.0826372504234314,
-0.2810985743999481,
-0.4903623163700104,
-0.31639689207077026,
0.6455078721046448,
0.33167457580566406,
-0.34780630469322205,
0.6796169877052307,
-0.18508130311965942,
-0.16285723447799683,
-1.0376087427139282,
0.1356412023305893,
0.48198115825653076,
0.0011630805674940348,
0.08125922083854675,
-0.49573007225990295,
-0.2469812035560608,
-0.8540654182434082,
-0.4955410957336426,
-0.4717216193675995,
-0.2541970908641815,
0.1394389122724533,
-0.05772466957569122,
0.39145511388778687,
1.1869280338287354,
-0.4258093535900116,
-0.007414454128593206,
-0.3117009699344635,
0.11473902314901352,
0.4845570921897888,
0.6250491738319397,
0.6525325179100037,
-0.7273933291435242,
-0.2957029938697815,
-0.15727120637893677,
-0.22394408285617828,
-0.08718061447143555,
-0.3262268006801605,
-0.31815916299819946,
0.4324437379837036,
0.10579625517129898,
-0.279295414686203,
0.2241830974817276,
0.9483005404472351,
-0.5390361547470093,
0.6826527714729309,
-0.4006316661834717,
0.3437482714653015,
-0.8602429628372192,
0.20706826448440552,
-0.007828832603991032,
-0.25403347611427307,
-0.49434810876846313,
0.13887150585651398,
0.07206783443689346,
0.13679946959018707,
-0.27539822459220886,
0.6488949060440063,
-0.10553290694952011,
-0.40023624897003174,
-0.48631006479263306,
0.07109729200601578,
0.06805767863988876,
0.4520464539527893,
0.3592209815979004,
0.9110267162322998,
0.0428091362118721,
-0.8596129417419434,
0.14451922476291656,
0.13464826345443726,
-0.3470694422721863,
0.8152304887771606,
-0.6226155757904053,
-0.25612643361091614,
0.011168663389980793,
0.25119510293006897,
-0.894524097442627,
-0.09973476827144623,
0.2457723766565323,
-0.6937963962554932,
0.24127089977264404,
-0.10791518539190292,
-0.24072310328483582,
-0.11525177210569382,
-0.2016666829586029,
0.43200191855430603,
0.6950398683547974,
-0.706298828125,
0.08285573124885559,
0.44786331057548523,
-0.1142648458480835,
-0.5213897824287415,
-0.47178828716278076,
-0.36108729243278503,
-0.0981806144118309,
-0.44972941279411316,
0.3809417188167572,
-0.08116263151168823,
-0.22446796298027039,
0.32436642050743103,
-0.035163454711437225,
0.09966710954904556,
0.12123719602823257,
0.050737667828798294,
0.5398903489112854,
-0.03296726197004318,
0.19386346638202667,
0.18101321160793304,
-0.3048943877220154,
0.04837634414434433,
-0.58042311668396,
0.3254391551017761,
0.09243259578943253,
-0.5088135600090027,
-0.12184730917215347,
0.11315375566482544,
0.0877014547586441,
-0.09079966694116592,
0.6099457144737244,
0.34028956294059753,
-0.017810529097914696,
0.18719641864299774,
-0.28872179985046387,
-0.23151373863220215,
-0.48671260476112366,
0.23294058442115784,
-0.42618459463119507,
-0.7484720349311829,
0.266382098197937,
0.4799368977546692,
0.18183238804340363,
0.533414900302887,
0.2817895710468292,
-0.18328416347503662,
1.0440137386322021,
0.4151402711868286,
-0.1943391114473343,
0.5483782887458801,
0.35723647475242615,
0.1471320241689682,
-0.858353316783905,
0.3159249424934387,
-0.5518943071365356,
-0.3497585654258728,
-0.9355692863464355,
-0.038725871592760086,
0.07992029190063477,
0.50338214635849,
-0.11685220897197723,
0.46827277541160583,
-0.5006994009017944,
0.42445650696754456,
0.9188469648361206,
-0.07147419452667236,
0.27533331513404846,
0.00978569034487009,
-0.05876348167657852,
-0.14187732338905334,
-0.7083989381790161,
-0.41650390625,
1.05354642868042,
0.18190468847751617,
0.9083057045936584,
0.22769106924533844,
0.7426536679267883,
0.10537153482437134,
0.11268825083971024,
-0.4936414062976837,
0.14724944531917572,
-0.1989382952451706,
-0.6589192748069763,
-0.36915671825408936,
-0.4971991777420044,
-1.1532281637191772,
0.20068322122097015,
-0.22443121671676636,
-0.8532977104187012,
0.2948322296142578,
0.5315476059913635,
-0.30402055382728577,
0.2588391900062561,
-0.4845934212207794,
0.7402322888374329,
-0.11925189197063446,
-0.4268842041492462,
-0.3577563166618347,
-0.5054720640182495,
0.5283907651901245,
0.14036235213279724,
0.2529822587966919,
0.03987358510494232,
0.2752392888069153,
0.8195587992668152,
-0.02955280989408493,
0.49244225025177,
0.04814997687935829,
-0.11558905988931656,
0.42114922404289246,
0.3360515534877777,
0.4865477681159973,
0.1503877490758896,
-0.053188424557447433,
-0.35959750413894653,
0.22914659976959229,
-0.6047453880310059,
-0.5707412958145142,
0.6623170375823975,
-0.9262028932571411,
-0.495397686958313,
-0.5235024690628052,
-0.6061280369758606,
0.06208887696266174,
-0.1902519017457962,
0.353451132774353,
0.29382291436195374,
-0.2703636884689331,
-0.12761899828910828,
0.6534754633903503,
-0.5379366278648376,
0.3097814917564392,
0.23607328534126282,
-0.576426088809967,
-0.43311458826065063,
1.1773139238357544,
-0.18324913084506989,
0.8041155338287354,
0.5458908081054688,
0.14788304269313812,
-0.30600103735923767,
-0.069442018866539,
-0.5068849921226501,
0.12572887539863586,
-0.6163884997367859,
-0.0013775539118796587,
-0.3166200518608093,
-0.4517351984977722,
-0.22969621419906616,
-0.34426236152648926,
-0.24578918516635895,
-0.5334419012069702,
-0.2233896404504776,
-0.09585787355899811,
0.2396557778120041,
0.576407253742218,
-0.26735979318618774,
0.08603885769844055,
-0.8730341196060181,
0.0964038148522377,
0.40029531717300415,
0.48919227719306946,
-0.11174000799655914,
-0.7060311436653137,
-0.1706966906785965,
0.12538191676139832,
-0.2947494387626648,
-0.8235963582992554,
0.28780215978622437,
0.08858948945999146,
0.637850284576416,
0.5286566615104675,
0.13224802911281586,
0.26142245531082153,
-0.18777810037136078,
0.7376869320869446,
0.23992446064949036,
-0.7924501895904541,
0.2538508176803589,
-0.3871902823448181,
0.2746330201625824,
0.5059430599212646,
0.18426728248596191,
-0.9467852711677551,
-0.6173592805862427,
-0.8231954574584961,
-0.5971452593803406,
0.8411257863044739,
0.1740158051252365,
-0.07136625796556473,
-0.01250503957271576,
0.20226545631885529,
0.3003804683685303,
0.14908553659915924,
-0.8675687313079834,
0.05269359052181244,
-0.29097554087638855,
-0.38988855481147766,
-0.16547945141792297,
-0.16159245371818542,
-0.04863988980650902,
0.03494558483362198,
0.7828044295310974,
-0.09717802703380585,
0.3736380338668823,
-0.19570671021938324,
-0.2988702654838562,
-0.3332606256008148,
0.6955538392066956,
0.6007453203201294,
0.5374512672424316,
-0.4002700746059418,
0.24247252941131592,
-0.3246888220310211,
-0.288054883480072,
0.32232022285461426,
0.02117781899869442,
-0.4910476505756378,
-0.17031733691692352,
0.18419449031352997,
1.0368969440460205,
0.3812873661518097,
-0.5927678942680359,
0.2871183156967163,
0.13230636715888977,
-0.10391083359718323,
0.21492990851402283,
0.5037523508071899,
0.07041650265455246,
-0.16504622995853424,
0.24685388803482056,
0.07250722497701645,
0.15768282115459442,
-0.4946553707122803,
0.39179494976997375,
0.4887980818748474,
-0.7436683177947998,
-0.4568997919559479,
0.3741828501224518,
0.14060625433921814,
-0.5251951217651367,
0.7448704838752747,
-0.3244177997112274,
-0.4111512005329132,
0.3610914945602417,
0.6905015707015991,
0.4286838471889496,
-0.21998509764671326,
0.3564751148223877,
0.6040793657302856,
0.05054616928100586,
-0.04759857431054115,
0.007357486058026552,
0.05930991470813751,
-0.7939841747283936,
-0.4402996599674225,
-0.8954784274101257,
-0.18553589284420013,
-0.049715783447027206,
-0.8605484366416931,
0.13250334560871124,
0.030766837298870087,
0.021820509806275368,
-0.2764805257320404,
-0.2214769870042801,
-0.45138120651245117,
0.07730237394571304,
-0.10274448990821838,
0.608258068561554,
-0.8224956393241882,
0.9272458553314209,
0.47855135798454285,
-0.488545298576355,
-0.8228335976600647,
0.07140747457742691,
-0.11128109693527222,
-0.7159892320632935,
0.47446611523628235,
-0.12683570384979248,
0.12897655367851257,
-0.04751656949520111,
-0.2496032565832138,
-1.0845261812210083,
0.6049883365631104,
0.1809857189655304,
-0.6125397682189941,
0.07294436544179916,
-0.08275991678237915,
0.4639376103878021,
-0.15360496938228607,
0.36688506603240967,
0.7971925735473633,
0.3224358558654785,
-0.0996728241443634,
-0.6755703091621399,
-0.08614689111709595,
-0.046744126826524734,
0.20085102319717407,
0.6287096738815308,
-0.3203159272670746,
0.5521829128265381,
-0.13405762612819672,
-0.22789746522903442,
0.07322847843170166,
0.8730763792991638,
0.8427159786224365,
-0.25127527117729187,
0.6946642994880676,
0.3769763708114624,
0.45193642377853394,
0.0919705331325531,
1.2049167156219482,
-0.40949130058288574,
0.37753376364707947,
0.956454873085022,
-0.03994519263505936,
1.0653936862945557,
0.7485206127166748,
-0.5893380641937256,
0.5677326917648315,
0.8828625679016113,
0.2813509702682495,
0.5603777170181274,
0.4370684027671814,
-0.059759508818387985,
-0.3443664610385895,
0.06664599478244781,
-0.15538381040096283,
0.09013840556144714,
0.3394845128059387,
-0.31978708505630493,
-0.17747008800506592,
-0.29220646619796753,
-0.3274359107017517,
0.43869099020957947,
-0.09528616070747375,
0.7941673398017883,
-0.06283865123987198,
-1.4267374277114868,
0.2770957946777344,
0.04141336679458618,
0.7518212199211121,
-0.5824987292289734,
0.020602120086550713,
-0.08195815235376358,
0.21505598723888397,
-0.0625859946012497,
-1.2087113857269287,
0.33901458978652954,
-0.42206627130508423,
-0.3694709241390228,
-0.09187430888414383,
0.6110119223594666,
-0.8147132396697998,
-0.4703190326690674,
0.2613269090652466,
0.026176348328590393,
0.0653872862458229,
0.30926603078842163,
-0.48587465286254883,
-0.09911223500967026,
-0.03958721458911896,
-0.28668761253356934,
0.7474223375320435,
0.026006534695625305,
-0.01238156296312809,
0.27546411752700806,
0.8371040225028992,
0.2650183141231537,
-0.12779659032821655,
-0.1064673662185669,
0.3843160569667816,
-0.48421579599380493,
-0.8227442502975464,
-0.5994149446487427,
0.3377605378627777,
-0.009197773411870003,
-0.36271408200263977,
0.2140442579984665,
0.3064229488372803,
0.9142907857894897,
-0.040381986647844315,
0.7937591671943665,
-0.019216427579522133,
0.6114804148674011,
-0.7143360376358032,
0.6713269352912903,
-0.2971101701259613,
0.14785179495811462,
-0.2725223898887634,
-0.973361611366272,
0.17430204153060913,
0.7800951600074768,
-0.2048792690038681,
-0.054506298154592514,
0.6861957907676697,
0.5308605432510376,
-0.2020738124847412,
-0.17115715146064758,
0.21283018589019775,
-0.3515406847000122,
0.4103381335735321,
0.7796947360038757,
0.6675446033477783,
-0.3814951479434967,
0.603238582611084,
0.04322574660181999,
-0.2529774308204651,
-0.18039929866790771,
-0.7217246294021606,
-0.4262138903141022,
-0.8501861691474915,
-0.12336760014295578,
-0.6330791711807251,
0.20886342227458954,
1.1621242761611938,
0.4622243344783783,
-0.8755455613136292,
-0.5885804295539856,
-0.19630201160907745,
0.3062096834182739,
-0.639115035533905,
-0.22963765263557434,
0.3271135687828064,
-0.5098415017127991,
-0.6750741004943848,
-0.0814521536231041,
0.20290012657642365,
0.0392371341586113,
-0.2251405119895935,
-0.508773922920227,
-0.16975471377372742,
0.25920724868774414,
0.020063312724232674,
0.4770570695400238,
-0.7814397811889648,
-0.40731459856033325,
-0.03267936035990715,
-0.3473729193210602,
0.13045206665992737,
0.8847149014472961,
-0.760077178478241,
0.3435889184474945,
0.46294721961021423,
0.6884787082672119,
0.2406408190727234,
0.14687439799308777,
1.153039813041687,
-0.8248964548110962,
0.12254501134157181,
-0.055352579802274704,
0.28975710272789,
0.21315395832061768,
-0.34665560722351074,
0.2425006777048111,
0.1034613847732544,
-0.8555758595466614,
-0.5269783139228821,
0.6916787624359131,
-0.7064003348350525,
-0.42326098680496216,
1.201429009437561,
-0.24911479651927948,
-0.3733617663383484,
0.17030353844165802,
-0.13368484377861023,
0.16123075783252716,
-0.5013530254364014,
0.8127455711364746,
0.9452727437019348,
-0.09392708539962769,
-0.14905782043933868,
-0.1605822592973709,
0.8205451965332031,
0.5851573944091797,
-0.5837168097496033,
-0.042992956936359406,
0.41953974962234497,
0.23166948556900024,
0.07379844784736633,
0.6368387341499329,
0.12697316706180573,
0.6435869336128235,
-0.23670470714569092,
0.2906847298145294,
0.3758642375469208,
-0.10233394056558609,
-0.47005972266197205,
-0.07531285285949707,
0.5747844576835632,
-0.16661964356899261
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10190v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10190v2
|
CHIRON: Rich Character Representations in Long-Form Narratives
| 2024-06-14T17:23:57 | 2024-06-26T14:22:18 |
Alexander Gurung, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Characters are integral to long-form narratives, but are poorly understood by
existing story analysis and generation systems. While prior work has simplified
characters via graph-based methods and brief character descriptions, we aim to
better tackle the problem of representing complex characters by taking
inspiration from advice given to professional writers. We propose CHIRON, a new
`character sheet' based representation that organizes and filters textual
information about characters. We construct CHIRON sheets in two steps: a
Generation Module that prompts an LLM for character information via
question-answering and a Validation Module that uses automated reasoning and a
domain-specific entailment model to eliminate false facts about a character. We
validate CHIRON via the downstream task of masked-character prediction, where
our experiments show CHIRON is better and more flexible than comparable
summary-based baselines. We also show that metrics derived from CHIRON can be
used to automatically infer character-centricity in stories, and that these
metrics align with human judgments.
|
[
-0.2050705850124359,
-0.5640837550163269,
0.8024681210517883,
0.1143973097205162,
-0.4023769795894623,
0.5336518883705139,
-0.2244466096162796,
-1.0105352401733398,
0.5968204736709595,
0.8406649827957153,
-0.5218811631202698,
-0.43802303075790405,
-0.3539508283138275,
0.43495288491249084,
-0.18591618537902832,
1.0017173290252686,
-0.1303730607032776,
0.056920189410448074,
-0.12136165797710419,
-0.0009312229813076556,
-0.5272701382637024,
-0.4025914967060089,
-0.3732329308986664,
-0.612790584564209,
0.985611617565155,
0.24283014237880707,
0.8983500599861145,
0.8339842557907104,
0.14128689467906952,
0.20877447724342346,
0.0384405292570591,
0.2507656514644623,
-0.37367093563079834,
0.38339725136756897,
0.032382529228925705,
-0.7149274349212646,
-0.5139150023460388,
-0.14345844089984894,
0.5065264701843262,
0.8676978349685669,
0.4041145443916321,
-0.32365983724594116,
0.23525676131248474,
0.5401538014411926,
-0.1872759759426117,
0.12229705601930618,
-0.09532647579908371,
0.2077825516462326,
-0.285164475440979,
-0.10227522999048233,
-0.1574816256761551,
-0.7733160257339478,
-0.09048843383789062,
-0.699760913848877,
0.5322798490524292,
0.2805366516113281,
0.7668779492378235,
-0.258186012506485,
-0.3068678677082062,
-0.5221198201179504,
-0.8498483300209045,
0.802609384059906,
-0.2450309693813324,
0.2732166349887848,
0.6533275246620178,
0.748526930809021,
0.10574191063642502,
-0.528211772441864,
-0.5149733424186707,
-0.418110728263855,
-0.3138583302497864,
0.313951700925827,
0.18483670055866241,
-0.08519960939884186,
0.22447583079338074,
0.3681512475013733,
-0.6112001538276672,
-0.0499967597424984,
-0.34370702505111694,
-0.5438131093978882,
0.8305835127830505,
0.15004412829875946,
0.2349836677312851,
-0.319366455078125,
-0.44395673274993896,
-0.12992532551288605,
-0.6917692422866821,
0.05154511332511902,
0.4438994228839874,
0.07693304866552353,
-0.058844663202762604,
0.6677119731903076,
-0.034424398094415665,
0.08154702186584473,
0.1387559473514557,
0.21652860939502716,
-0.13195016980171204,
0.028794987127184868,
-0.14704521000385284,
0.7103509306907654,
0.6452895998954773,
0.19515185058116913,
0.37140142917633057,
-0.21644657850265503,
-0.1796487271785736,
0.05388639494776726,
0.12515310943126678,
-0.8737171292304993,
-0.16401493549346924,
0.1562499850988388,
-0.37303033471107483,
-0.4151584804058075,
0.25512951612472534,
-1.052445888519287,
-1.1496437788009644,
-0.25588443875312805,
0.06301964819431305,
-0.7042464017868042,
0.24827070534229279,
-0.07538130134344101,
-0.33071786165237427,
0.2014847844839096,
1.0032336711883545,
-0.6908805966377258,
0.09153981506824493,
0.5435246825218201,
0.5296619534492493,
0.12605850398540497,
-0.3712194859981537,
-0.7041725516319275,
0.23856431245803833,
-0.7836402654647827,
1.0011489391326904,
-0.39758428931236267,
-0.21333231031894684,
-0.053087759763002396,
0.176255002617836,
0.3879447877407074,
-0.4173705279827118,
0.602934718132019,
-0.35506772994995117,
0.21194201707839966,
-0.4831395447254181,
-0.4591479003429413,
-0.23703855276107788,
0.08274663239717484,
-0.8861607909202576,
0.5010072588920593,
0.547561526298523,
-0.5284740328788757,
0.35231730341911316,
0.04365650191903114,
-0.5835197567939758,
0.4560886025428772,
-0.46430492401123047,
-0.12990117073059082,
0.046251215040683746,
0.24227961897850037,
0.5836482048034668,
-0.7090602517127991,
0.14235670864582062,
0.0011129860067740083,
-0.45896223187446594,
0.5029149651527405,
-0.1586669236421585,
0.572287917137146,
0.15446926653385162,
-0.27377206087112427,
0.08411170542240143,
-0.5836554765701294,
-0.17700915038585663,
0.09164298325777054,
-0.22980543971061707,
-0.2197434902191162,
-0.08620806783437729,
0.15137352049350739,
-0.4561653435230255,
0.10087218880653381,
-0.5716959238052368,
-0.04205780848860741,
-0.08058134466409683,
0.37427836656570435,
0.5677997469902039,
-0.16622543334960938,
0.3945395350456238,
-0.7843602299690247,
0.7079294323921204,
-0.20127710700035095,
-0.10574273765087128,
-0.6911218762397766,
-0.3887498378753662,
-0.5763669013977051,
-0.31464332342147827,
0.3908200263977051,
0.2519056499004364,
-0.7476015686988831,
0.7430303692817688,
-0.07133515924215317,
-0.4939534664154053,
-0.14741958677768707,
0.11791729927062988,
0.25511372089385986,
0.3700881004333496,
0.4003235697746277,
-0.26352518796920776,
-0.04631213843822479,
-0.8246779441833496,
-0.05981312692165375,
-0.24055726826190948,
-0.2544194161891937,
-0.17451120913028717,
0.1021481305360794,
-0.3313414454460144,
0.9774785041809082,
-0.4894998371601105,
-0.07579530030488968,
-0.8790639042854309,
0.3148587942123413,
-0.023165591061115265,
0.3789234459400177,
0.5728094577789307,
-0.6110749840736389,
-0.493747740983963,
0.17523394525051117,
-0.6223999857902527,
-0.062395140528678894,
-0.6843276619911194,
-0.29105329513549805,
-0.012734191492199898,
0.4868839681148529,
-0.524776041507721,
0.5130079984664917,
0.1577170491218567,
-0.5506396293640137,
0.712346613407135,
-0.10439594835042953,
0.36574965715408325,
-1.0416984558105469,
0.005970442667603493,
0.09578466415405273,
-0.6520392298698425,
-0.3478546738624573,
-0.08046092838048935,
0.4376802444458008,
-0.5093457102775574,
0.2354186624288559,
0.7184003591537476,
-0.4815128445625305,
0.07384981215000153,
-0.0715368464589119,
0.15621745586395264,
0.7182549834251404,
0.5499706864356995,
0.005860327742993832,
0.4830869138240814,
0.08584617078304291,
-0.4605676829814911,
0.4050850570201874,
0.12990565598011017,
-0.37199875712394714,
0.8994917869567871,
-0.866449773311615,
-0.0034388757776468992,
-0.40734291076660156,
0.44493207335472107,
-0.864284336566925,
-0.6267032027244568,
0.34255585074424744,
-0.25931793451309204,
0.7603542804718018,
-0.16348464787006378,
-0.5120694041252136,
-0.06916532665491104,
-0.5159430503845215,
0.40621161460876465,
0.3991684317588806,
-0.4143889844417572,
0.7505905032157898,
-0.015360946767032146,
-0.3546348512172699,
-0.14797396957874298,
-0.8606497049331665,
0.1333169788122177,
-0.1540207415819168,
-0.4371260106563568,
0.6267355680465698,
-0.1479005366563797,
-0.08398809283971786,
-0.06384139508008957,
-0.018695160746574402,
-0.35695481300354004,
-0.23309966921806335,
0.013152141124010086,
0.19876284897327423,
-0.24801023304462433,
0.10098748654127121,
0.3666337728500366,
-0.14970628917217255,
-0.13782712817192078,
0.39832499623298645,
0.6784164905548096,
0.18491774797439575,
-0.2947150468826294,
-0.32380589842796326,
0.7591564655303955,
0.8625673651695251,
-0.2733199894428253,
0.22727246582508087,
0.5160130858421326,
-0.6093572974205017,
-0.4310961067676544,
-0.40040841698646545,
-0.03839344158768654,
-0.3780934512615204,
0.43842703104019165,
-0.07428628206253052,
-0.6917027831077576,
0.8034725785255432,
0.12891484797000885,
0.027491135522723198,
0.8233878016471863,
-0.04956115037202835,
-0.36817634105682373,
0.7719550132751465,
0.6386414766311646,
0.14090949296951294,
0.1795947253704071,
0.03867530822753906,
0.14126761257648468,
-0.797868013381958,
-0.314650297164917,
-0.632564127445221,
-0.2662877142429352,
-0.21966642141342163,
-0.5580453872680664,
0.2252103090286255,
0.6494950652122498,
-0.38123852014541626,
0.619129478931427,
-0.3298014998435974,
0.5902107954025269,
0.2024325132369995,
0.2445981353521347,
0.21820293366909027,
-0.14018745720386505,
0.15564605593681335,
-0.03469260036945343,
-0.31584984064102173,
-0.6269485950469971,
0.45681145787239075,
0.678752064704895,
1.1803683042526245,
0.09218771010637283,
0.7888733744621277,
0.4488541781902313,
0.09725184738636017,
-0.9179936647415161,
0.4457603693008423,
-0.08741538971662521,
-0.5555235743522644,
-0.3565279543399811,
-0.5952818393707275,
-0.9048237800598145,
-0.26686644554138184,
-0.40444502234458923,
-0.5844363570213318,
0.40431344509124756,
-0.26116594672203064,
-0.622377336025238,
0.03109808824956417,
-0.4898264706134796,
0.4242056608200073,
-0.5598058104515076,
-0.35079118609428406,
-0.4329780340194702,
-0.40686261653900146,
0.2833787202835083,
-0.2459627240896225,
-0.08143000304698944,
-0.06649862229824066,
0.2821228802204132,
0.5485001802444458,
-0.5187984704971313,
0.9957373738288879,
0.27157294750213623,
0.00937852542847395,
0.6003223657608032,
0.6306816935539246,
0.33155372738838196,
0.26680484414100647,
-0.28755274415016174,
0.17966100573539734,
0.26936861872673035,
-0.2737957537174225,
-0.8028870820999146,
0.5083311200141907,
-0.6545964479446411,
-0.06910153478384018,
-0.743911623954773,
-0.5077446699142456,
-0.004349441733211279,
0.2310144007205963,
0.2594025135040283,
0.8896018266677856,
-0.48894017934799194,
0.2771950960159302,
0.49836716055870056,
-0.5741985440254211,
0.17359985411167145,
-0.2701297402381897,
-0.6234408617019653,
-0.8006374835968018,
0.5810818672180176,
0.1582750678062439,
0.05560927838087082,
0.5032340288162231,
0.5662045478820801,
-0.28277137875556946,
-0.11430304497480392,
-0.865672767162323,
0.5513097643852234,
-0.8533507585525513,
-0.4011191427707672,
-0.3932337164878845,
-0.5334797501564026,
-0.07571309804916382,
-0.6029797196388245,
-0.127951979637146,
-0.6354852914810181,
-0.294193297624588,
0.10579246282577515,
0.3937317132949829,
1.0848894119262695,
0.45103171467781067,
0.1540491282939911,
-0.9715506434440613,
0.4514174163341522,
0.46371352672576904,
0.43673160672187805,
-0.02865520492196083,
-0.08687683194875717,
-0.43394535779953003,
-0.18716837465763092,
-0.34228837490081787,
-1.1348105669021606,
0.21021535992622375,
-0.05395621433854103,
0.5873807072639465,
0.47966423630714417,
0.17114683985710144,
0.523586094379425,
-0.21538464725017548,
0.7835912108421326,
0.42669710516929626,
-0.9501559138298035,
0.41421931982040405,
-0.5192471742630005,
0.26513850688934326,
0.7065989375114441,
0.33390045166015625,
-0.783359944820404,
-0.1366710513830185,
-0.3584209680557251,
-0.39459434151649475,
0.5711516737937927,
0.37440061569213867,
0.21505363285541534,
0.23401714861392975,
0.6275172829627991,
0.420611709356308,
0.23892121016979218,
-0.5619762539863586,
0.27230796217918396,
-0.5661495923995972,
-0.38619619607925415,
-0.17217129468917847,
-0.4294368624687195,
-0.06243686378002167,
-0.019961392506957054,
0.27453914284706116,
-0.21290375292301178,
0.4549886882305145,
0.5403503179550171,
-0.16240695118904114,
-0.3416263461112976,
0.2233162224292755,
0.430960476398468,
0.7308744192123413,
-0.17168521881103516,
0.222861185669899,
-0.24471649527549744,
-0.5394175052642822,
-0.2773219048976898,
0.1842811107635498,
-0.045610785484313965,
0.0470464788377285,
0.9399687051773071,
0.4996488094329834,
0.23927955329418182,
-0.552030086517334,
0.1845335215330124,
-0.01726713962852955,
-0.11935026943683624,
-0.13335935771465302,
0.1831391602754593,
-0.005481131374835968,
0.40023115277290344,
0.23450574278831482,
-0.04010540246963501,
-0.19732636213302612,
-1.2307868003845215,
0.07429748773574829,
-0.05885206162929535,
-0.8836901187896729,
-0.34608757495880127,
0.5338510870933533,
0.23725217580795288,
-0.37382593750953674,
0.3239707052707672,
-0.31993451714515686,
-0.7643054127693176,
0.8835324645042419,
0.5946274399757385,
1.0844138860702515,
-0.22429440915584564,
0.5492749214172363,
0.36521241068840027,
0.19056251645088196,
0.06620381027460098,
0.04934760928153992,
0.019719360396265984,
-0.586624264717102,
-0.09168175607919693,
-0.710353434085846,
-0.5925092101097107,
-0.13499119877815247,
-0.2596398591995239,
0.41377079486846924,
-0.9659121036529541,
0.21249091625213623,
-0.11790189892053604,
0.1343325972557068,
-0.5066924095153809,
0.1156243085861206,
0.1393112689256668,
0.6379104852676392,
-0.41609930992126465,
0.5495928525924683,
0.4882696866989136,
-0.5818074941635132,
-0.7950034737586975,
0.35919928550720215,
-0.038902442902326584,
-0.4085463881492615,
0.4268774092197418,
0.39014649391174316,
-0.09433905780315399,
-0.3570064902305603,
-0.14828930795192719,
-0.43597477674484253,
1.332560658454895,
0.33568042516708374,
-0.7861561179161072,
-0.021868208423256874,
0.24459291994571686,
0.46639928221702576,
-0.6543831825256348,
0.28031525015830994,
-0.002708262763917446,
0.438041090965271,
0.1927058845758438,
-0.41788506507873535,
0.2220904529094696,
-0.15035498142242432,
-0.19972066581249237,
0.20136085152626038,
-0.6173616051673889,
0.8612078428268433,
0.07856497168540955,
-0.3469953238964081,
0.21501727402210236,
0.7332543730735779,
0.3898226022720337,
0.6164524555206299,
0.5226840376853943,
-0.21428419649600983,
1.0965324640274048,
0.008941958658397198,
1.2429198026657104,
-0.054130204021930695,
-0.1603713184595108,
0.9552387595176697,
-0.4610856771469116,
0.24078431725502014,
-0.031742289662361145,
0.09380646795034409,
0.7523316740989685,
0.6212950944900513,
0.0031408879440277815,
0.20876699686050415,
0.18232490122318268,
-0.05881405621767044,
-0.3003808856010437,
-0.17463788390159607,
-0.23053713142871857,
0.28476518392562866,
0.05334307998418808,
-0.3454388976097107,
-0.32500317692756653,
-0.41733598709106445,
0.09856674820184708,
0.4569423198699951,
-0.4096285104751587,
0.24676036834716797,
0.2910933792591095,
-0.4379706084728241,
0.124233677983284,
0.19314628839492798,
0.32389014959335327,
-0.9513287544250488,
-0.3687538206577301,
-0.30965349078178406,
-0.02567543275654316,
-0.17971596121788025,
-0.9085901379585266,
0.14751115441322327,
0.18701907992362976,
-0.2119707614183426,
-0.21083557605743408,
0.8522558808326721,
-0.5182161331176758,
-0.8760391473770142,
0.25313663482666016,
0.3894343078136444,
-0.04684659466147423,
-0.24633008241653442,
-0.2623419463634491,
-0.016955852508544922,
-0.04769843444228172,
0.03430749475955963,
0.19489099085330963,
0.8107687830924988,
-0.4649353623390198,
0.12665121257305145,
0.32636159658432007,
0.006575525272637606,
-0.39696580171585083,
0.3847440481185913,
0.7936835289001465,
-0.9356600642204285,
-0.6918548941612244,
-0.561660647392273,
0.5528619885444641,
-0.1726435273885727,
-0.378490686416626,
0.510866641998291,
0.5249099731445312,
0.19276770949363708,
0.2470521181821823,
0.8039725422859192,
0.21696487069129944,
0.44698452949523926,
-0.7847285866737366,
1.1659005880355835,
-0.3548531234264374,
0.24567539989948273,
-0.20004598796367645,
-1.4321744441986084,
-0.20125436782836914,
0.7662957906723022,
0.21536681056022644,
0.1490541696548462,
1.0899821519851685,
0.4743753969669342,
-0.20528502762317657,
0.45180264115333557,
0.35512450337409973,
-0.09206467121839523,
0.46101289987564087,
0.3997623324394226,
1.0572700500488281,
-0.39598459005355835,
0.19666016101837158,
-0.26059919595718384,
-0.18761658668518066,
-0.11822741478681564,
-0.8029309511184692,
-1.2943230867385864,
-0.5947728157043457,
-0.2587928771972656,
-0.41853514313697815,
-0.22430305182933807,
0.8703670501708984,
0.6110562086105347,
-0.5193723440170288,
-0.2759629487991333,
0.03943853825330734,
0.1786889135837555,
-0.10274612158536911,
-0.16906562447547913,
0.3468768000602722,
-0.11853773891925812,
-0.44190341234207153,
0.45322608947753906,
0.25463753938674927,
0.09355797618627548,
-0.39127036929130554,
-0.32596105337142944,
0.4801338016986847,
0.41645511984825134,
0.6298030614852905,
0.07665718346834183,
-0.3523810803890228,
-0.5298550724983215,
0.08007487654685974,
-0.2809642553329468,
0.2730444371700287,
1.2969766855239868,
-0.5511869192123413,
0.4274429976940155,
0.6842454075813293,
0.568115770816803,
0.6031203269958496,
-0.14130690693855286,
0.8061051964759827,
-0.3153395354747772,
-0.30561214685440063,
0.5695065259933472,
0.4104016125202179,
0.3551291227340698,
-0.8018558621406555,
0.24756863713264465,
0.0629633367061615,
-0.47907575964927673,
-0.46924644708633423,
0.5059732794761658,
-1.3496326208114624,
-0.4822043180465698,
0.9437786936759949,
-0.015400749631226063,
-0.44865140318870544,
-0.29219383001327515,
-0.37985819578170776,
0.3698829412460327,
-0.3850748538970947,
0.6482055187225342,
0.7207427620887756,
-0.13335973024368286,
-0.33705371618270874,
-0.4959835112094879,
0.44704723358154297,
-0.03743155673146248,
-1.0214133262634277,
0.4620327651500702,
0.7097618579864502,
-0.14829066395759583,
0.44377511739730835,
0.5608502626419067,
-0.3795742392539978,
0.1454700380563736,
-0.15463975071907043,
0.005569716449826956,
-0.18045884370803833,
-0.7426737546920776,
-0.17279405891895294,
0.1555977612733841,
-0.15068764984607697,
0.4212663769721985
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10177v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10177v1
|
Inclusive ASR for Disfluent Speech: Cascaded Large-Scale Self-Supervised Learning with Targeted Fine-Tuning and Data Augmentation
| 2024-06-14T16:56:40 | 2024-06-14T16:56:40 |
Dena Mujtaba, Nihar R. Mahapatra, Megan Arney, J. Scott Yaruss, Caryn Herring, Jia Bin
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, I.2; K.4
|
Automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems often falter while processing
stuttering-related disfluencies -- such as involuntary blocks and word
repetitions -- yielding inaccurate transcripts. A critical barrier to progress
is the scarcity of large, annotated disfluent speech datasets. Therefore, we
present an inclusive ASR design approach, leveraging large-scale
self-supervised learning on standard speech followed by targeted fine-tuning
and data augmentation on a smaller, curated dataset of disfluent speech. Our
data augmentation technique enriches training datasets with various
disfluencies, enhancing ASR processing of these speech patterns. Results show
that fine-tuning wav2vec 2.0 with even a relatively small, labeled dataset,
alongside data augmentation, can significantly reduce word error rates for
disfluent speech. Our approach not only advances ASR inclusivity for people who
stutter, but also paves the way for ASRs that can accommodate wider speech
variations.
|
[
-0.4100895822048187,
-0.7012940645217896,
-0.12302856147289276,
0.3479211628437042,
-0.08767307549715042,
0.22014662623405457,
-0.18292589485645294,
-0.5154638290405273,
0.3158780336380005,
0.21148979663848877,
-0.5739419460296631,
-0.16931815445423126,
-0.5847567319869995,
0.1731412559747696,
-0.5146923065185547,
0.891546368598938,
0.22222577035427094,
0.2893834412097931,
0.055814459919929504,
-0.3864048421382904,
-0.9333775639533997,
-0.49345698952674866,
-0.7300084829330444,
-0.3357040286064148,
0.39860063791275024,
0.6456543803215027,
0.7071132063865662,
0.6945695877075195,
0.24397672712802887,
0.34798818826675415,
-0.15966375172138214,
0.1420346200466156,
-0.23743665218353271,
0.27340006828308105,
-0.20123083889484406,
0.056457385420799255,
-0.5015516877174377,
-0.4041610658168793,
0.6939487457275391,
0.8800502419471741,
-0.3091977834701538,
-0.06316503882408142,
0.535383939743042,
0.7434002757072449,
-0.4547109007835388,
0.041157834231853485,
-0.43692946434020996,
0.042144834995269775,
-0.39456772804260254,
0.09832349419593811,
0.16097649931907654,
-0.09950096905231476,
-0.18084169924259186,
-0.4090312421321869,
0.4053715765476227,
-0.22663354873657227,
0.062231410294771194,
0.7707774639129639,
-0.3111201524734497,
-0.5746093988418579,
-0.8274012207984924,
0.38222113251686096,
-0.4101693332195282,
0.7662003636360168,
0.5086972117424011,
0.19808173179626465,
-0.27051597833633423,
-0.4917525351047516,
-0.5607221126556396,
-0.08747981488704681,
0.1407729536294937,
0.013982814736664295,
-0.4782537519931793,
0.304997980594635,
0.33678945899009705,
0.5555142760276794,
-0.8862582445144653,
0.626879870891571,
-0.5067869424819946,
-0.4128830134868622,
0.8656290173530579,
0.04309957101941109,
0.25055649876594543,
0.06680259853601456,
-0.14957493543624878,
0.025867246091365814,
-0.30483633279800415,
0.08371914178133011,
0.4115716814994812,
0.6969854831695557,
0.20738990604877472,
0.4853346347808838,
-0.4751305878162384,
0.5272582769393921,
0.16325685381889343,
0.06740497052669525,
0.38942551612854004,
0.060187503695487976,
-0.02733798511326313,
0.6631547212600708,
0.4408785104751587,
-0.06886356323957443,
0.1382746398448944,
-0.24085301160812378,
-0.40037283301353455,
0.31497520208358765,
0.1607203483581543,
-0.4521307349205017,
-0.5550441145896912,
0.21835969388484955,
-0.0049444264732301235,
0.10806518793106079,
0.067134328186512,
-0.6311017870903015,
-0.443591445684433,
-0.6493939161300659,
0.7193691730499268,
-0.40476706624031067,
-0.10449976474046707,
-0.10351922363042831,
-0.23111259937286377,
-0.2627650201320648,
0.1927279233932495,
-0.9604511857032776,
0.5082684755325317,
0.5255482196807861,
0.7511509656906128,
0.11892134696245193,
-0.2022373378276825,
-1.0595513582229614,
0.11507923901081085,
-0.24022428691387177,
0.5859664678573608,
-0.402732789516449,
-0.47371742129325867,
-0.14187534153461456,
-0.17099525034427643,
0.3845469355583191,
-0.6293860077857971,
0.7036609053611755,
-0.0350133553147316,
-0.153334841132164,
-0.2264677882194519,
-0.42449185252189636,
-0.008710036054253578,
-0.3380061686038971,
-0.5029301643371582,
0.8356504440307617,
0.12384743988513947,
-0.398886114358902,
0.5563898682594299,
-0.6448132991790771,
-0.905215322971344,
0.2393328696489334,
-0.3492763936519623,
-0.6270228624343872,
0.2848789691925049,
0.3500901162624359,
0.1618025004863739,
0.13290391862392426,
0.40072229504585266,
-0.2055119276046753,
-0.29583317041397095,
0.07286110520362854,
-0.6181954741477966,
0.482796311378479,
0.3757111430168152,
-0.4357253909111023,
0.13082090020179749,
-1.0177916288375854,
-0.1685803234577179,
-0.2375904768705368,
-0.18892520666122437,
-0.4134744107723236,
0.09612341970205307,
0.26353350281715393,
0.3056721091270447,
0.10993531346321106,
-0.6062132716178894,
0.16574813425540924,
-0.42706045508384705,
0.45161959528923035,
0.7260977029800415,
-0.30154550075531006,
0.2301056683063507,
-0.32542893290519714,
0.0636826902627945,
0.17988578975200653,
0.19315794110298157,
-0.0617644228041172,
-0.20773710310459137,
-0.8080876469612122,
-0.5753214955329895,
0.267194002866745,
0.2365090548992157,
-0.8334852457046509,
0.7353224754333496,
-0.06987709552049637,
-0.1174207404255867,
-0.780707836151123,
0.2760626971721649,
0.45341867208480835,
0.7948709726333618,
0.8097670078277588,
-0.4649619162082672,
-0.8672362565994263,
-0.9341145157814026,
-0.041805267333984375,
0.03768373280763626,
-0.488042950630188,
0.009504149667918682,
0.1540357917547226,
-0.255925714969635,
0.9476443529129028,
-0.07186998426914215,
-0.987144947052002,
0.06626811623573303,
0.1980815976858139,
-0.2587386667728424,
0.7163171768188477,
-0.04557013884186745,
-0.7822091579437256,
-0.1391797512769699,
-0.14133574068546295,
-0.28232747316360474,
-0.33966493606567383,
0.08074425905942917,
0.5706837773323059,
0.400966614484787,
0.4644738435745239,
0.005724410060793161,
0.5471358895301819,
0.44984543323516846,
-0.37337708473205566,
0.14902520179748535,
-0.3431871235370636,
0.12245272099971771,
-0.8720502257347107,
-0.07128738611936569,
0.006719554308801889,
-0.22362065315246582,
-0.8355904221534729,
-0.5190808176994324,
0.06779666990041733,
-0.08166348189115524,
0.02924441732466221,
0.1322525590658188,
-0.4715850055217743,
-0.005674383603036404,
-0.4526880085468292,
0.04324272647500038,
-0.15909995138645172,
0.07250245660543442,
0.0005425330018624663,
0.6350108981132507,
0.6754222512245178,
-0.5830602645874023,
0.1567932814359665,
0.4680657982826233,
-0.09102941304445267,
0.5818021297454834,
-0.6709839701652527,
0.24579071998596191,
-0.20111189782619476,
0.28374648094177246,
-1.1220641136169434,
-0.6278635859489441,
0.17979557812213898,
-0.5269556045532227,
0.637182354927063,
0.01666562259197235,
-0.31902679800987244,
-0.5580657124519348,
-0.004662851803004742,
0.3057115375995636,
0.519129753112793,
-0.8810378313064575,
0.26609811186790466,
0.7056145668029785,
-0.4118194878101349,
-0.42892158031463623,
-0.8782070279121399,
0.171474426984787,
-0.23078103363513947,
-0.416991651058197,
0.4451519846916199,
-0.06743759661912918,
0.06429038196802139,
-0.4553874433040619,
-0.36265283823013306,
-0.09829143434762955,
-0.03388306871056557,
0.5401612520217896,
-0.07633598893880844,
0.06555180996656418,
0.4013601839542389,
0.2052973210811615,
-0.1112300232052803,
-0.20941922068595886,
-0.22416169941425323,
0.45983755588531494,
-0.01539435051381588,
-0.5381869077682495,
-0.6545862555503845,
0.5501969456672668,
0.2861579358577728,
-0.03652068227529526,
0.018990905955433846,
0.6054765582084656,
-0.6994357705116272,
-0.062246281653642654,
-0.8696767091751099,
-0.29997503757476807,
-0.494901180267334,
0.4295710027217865,
-0.4042864143848419,
-1.134772777557373,
0.4303915202617645,
0.29463329911231995,
-0.06792164593935013,
0.22714504599571228,
0.33840906620025635,
-0.11842841655015945,
1.093369960784912,
0.45978134870529175,
-0.39922842383384705,
0.5492448806762695,
0.18327480554580688,
-0.026035279035568237,
-0.7304046154022217,
-0.24784454703330994,
-0.5269213318824768,
-0.5089367628097534,
-0.44050753116607666,
-0.301123708486557,
0.17959174513816833,
0.10009371489286423,
-0.24388104677200317,
0.05593753978610039,
-0.930352509021759,
0.28610560297966003,
0.5054989457130432,
0.19911029934883118,
0.37415531277656555,
0.09021324664354324,
0.47962698340415955,
-0.10341176390647888,
-0.598507821559906,
-0.10607075691223145,
0.5293194055557251,
0.5395563840866089,
0.8785266876220703,
0.11159145832061768,
0.5437029600143433,
0.5374419093132019,
0.03415153920650482,
-0.80224609375,
0.0711233913898468,
-0.4010544717311859,
-0.47505438327789307,
-0.6367704272270203,
-0.5328720211982727,
-0.8722274899482727,
-0.11561509966850281,
0.01434783823788166,
-0.8239854574203491,
0.5211818218231201,
0.6785302758216858,
-0.3044947683811188,
-0.04304810240864754,
-0.42806950211524963,
0.4206079840660095,
-0.21231147646903992,
-0.1786559522151947,
-0.16787846386432648,
-0.7225291132926941,
0.05956849828362465,
-0.19049741327762604,
0.27608194947242737,
0.0544603168964386,
0.1347143054008484,
0.7569229602813721,
-0.41364485025405884,
0.7429353594779968,
-0.5030394196510315,
-0.04877304285764694,
0.281554639339447,
-0.06745641678571701,
0.46370384097099304,
-0.01218177005648613,
-0.0866895541548729,
0.4705919623374939,
-0.41645827889442444,
-0.18619535863399506,
-0.5090658664703369,
0.593093991279602,
-0.6066933870315552,
-0.4873746931552887,
-0.2678534686565399,
-0.48366111516952515,
-0.46305203437805176,
-0.21004053950309753,
0.28036898374557495,
0.7279896140098572,
-0.12200900167226791,
0.28700119256973267,
0.47918373346328735,
0.1945616900920868,
0.49376383423805237,
0.596377432346344,
0.16878633201122284,
-0.6868016719818115,
1.1889216899871826,
0.6179146766662598,
-0.060231421142816544,
-0.032888226211071014,
0.028602657839655876,
-0.7021027207374573,
-0.6338440179824829,
-0.4309978783130646,
-0.36131221055984497,
-0.3737680912017822,
-0.4297347962856293,
-0.6512227654457092,
-0.415903240442276,
-0.7262935042381287,
-0.1586422324180603,
-0.5129900574684143,
-0.4810677170753479,
-0.5998144149780273,
0.041978683322668076,
0.5496006011962891,
0.6014512181282043,
-0.6173079013824463,
0.29772403836250305,
-0.43421274423599243,
0.5449618101119995,
0.326580286026001,
0.4411125183105469,
-0.15654388070106506,
-0.9737273454666138,
0.006460576318204403,
0.2574319541454315,
-0.37436622381210327,
-0.4817943871021271,
0.5090312361717224,
0.605168879032135,
0.31534963846206665,
0.35156941413879395,
0.37801605463027954,
1.1798222064971924,
-0.7065181136131287,
0.5620014667510986,
0.5805895328521729,
-1.0373176336288452,
0.7578111886978149,
-0.013551686890423298,
0.20036926865577698,
0.6665526032447815,
0.1553512066602707,
-0.5224590301513672,
-0.48369887471199036,
-0.4127107858657837,
-1.1872570514678955,
0.5964094400405884,
0.20480208098888397,
0.13041560351848602,
0.027261128649115562,
0.14506849646568298,
0.30280983448028564,
0.03162260353565216,
-0.32520782947540283,
-0.12619665265083313,
-0.4915667176246643,
-0.2580066919326782,
-0.2948492169380188,
-0.04823489487171173,
-0.20307204127311707,
-0.39896097779273987,
0.5885517001152039,
-0.20935602486133575,
-0.23740220069885254,
0.48597002029418945,
-0.2419736534357071,
-0.13489314913749695,
0.31851035356521606,
0.3333253562450409,
0.1522190272808075,
0.21207210421562195,
0.13305781781673431,
0.41306594014167786,
-0.48886311054229736,
0.3005107045173645,
0.5901838541030884,
0.3027661144733429,
-0.09724823385477066,
-0.12084940075874329,
0.8270770907402039,
0.06909985095262527,
-0.44423067569732666,
0.40584999322891235,
-0.1269110143184662,
-0.35757938027381897,
-0.3672024607658386,
0.2585110068321228,
-0.3209397494792938,
0.4799470007419586,
0.7047306895256042,
0.08116281032562256,
0.7185268998146057,
-0.2292657047510147,
0.6108976602554321,
0.4471975862979889,
-0.755293071269989,
-0.21452437341213226,
0.8991756439208984,
0.300028532743454,
-0.641721248626709,
0.7197083830833435,
0.030234243720769882,
-0.08858796954154968,
0.2924288213253021,
0.6924408078193665,
0.8288296461105347,
-0.734987199306488,
-0.07113407552242279,
0.13108095526695251,
0.24238330125808716,
0.0029434915632009506,
0.12862049043178558,
-0.3809152841567993,
-0.2057308852672577,
-0.25726237893104553,
-0.6789689064025879,
-0.2634698748588562,
0.3516553044319153,
-0.8901017308235168,
0.32655465602874756,
-0.2938288152217865,
-0.05948058143258095,
0.19202841818332672,
-0.22062832117080688,
-0.4107413589954376,
0.35995468497276306,
0.4583979845046997,
0.6004123091697693,
-0.8472762703895569,
0.7859935164451599,
0.5259367823600769,
-0.38512107729911804,
-0.5935115218162537,
0.14980606734752655,
0.19722871482372284,
-0.5070249438285828,
0.20080573856830597,
0.3481801450252533,
-0.09602522104978561,
0.2142355889081955,
-0.15483742952346802,
-0.8141086101531982,
0.8859710097312927,
0.3677964210510254,
-1.064894676208496,
0.3593742847442627,
0.3066834807395935,
0.6091747879981995,
-0.025438932701945305,
-0.1319824457168579,
0.65199214220047,
0.25451964139938354,
0.36396196484565735,
-1.1652402877807617,
-0.0360250249505043,
-0.12950116395950317,
0.14034520089626312,
0.08540985733270645,
-0.6110050082206726,
0.4076956510543823,
-0.09827283769845963,
-0.31134411692619324,
-0.13276921212673187,
0.8966137766838074,
0.1412355601787567,
0.5376017093658447,
0.7604542374610901,
0.4188748300075531,
0.9506224393844604,
-0.15521559119224548,
0.4524519443511963,
0.08895618468523026,
-0.03801564499735832,
1.396449089050293,
-0.187587708234787,
0.6319065690040588,
0.37587663531303406,
0.02288265898823738,
-0.012379363179206848,
0.4427173137664795,
0.14649096131324768,
0.4924870729446411,
0.24136660993099213,
-0.6395431160926819,
0.004202181473374367,
-0.14313752949237823,
-0.4164397716522217,
0.729053795337677,
0.4811584949493408,
0.005766773596405983,
-0.09276437014341354,
0.4341278672218323,
-0.42107364535331726,
0.06579301506280899,
-0.5590452551841736,
1.1998292207717896,
0.04822082072496414,
-0.2742905020713806,
0.5511382818222046,
-0.32034215331077576,
0.7690772414207458,
-0.4287688434123993,
-0.053098488599061966,
-0.1912487894296646,
0.17946133017539978,
-0.49574825167655945,
-0.6653574109077454,
0.6267728209495544,
0.08659046143293381,
-0.2667226195335388,
-0.18583618104457855,
0.8540377020835876,
-0.613649845123291,
-0.35785654187202454,
0.11253416538238525,
0.079890176653862,
0.1397607922554016,
-0.27905967831611633,
-0.44163525104522705,
0.17102213203907013,
-0.008495802991092205,
-0.03738697990775108,
0.40501609444618225,
0.290897935628891,
-0.1476801186800003,
0.507784903049469,
0.5841374397277832,
-0.11629537492990494,
-0.1705709993839264,
0.30343762040138245,
1.1781129837036133,
-0.37432071566581726,
-0.587863028049469,
-0.7463375926017761,
0.8801016807556152,
-0.10928750038146973,
-0.3372501730918884,
0.5161269903182983,
0.6193149089813232,
0.7370034456253052,
0.20769810676574707,
0.7562923431396484,
-0.14973101019859314,
0.6366288661956787,
-0.23969429731369019,
0.7455766201019287,
-0.595561683177948,
0.09197737276554108,
-0.38587847352027893,
-0.585910975933075,
-0.528108537197113,
0.9082332849502563,
-0.06814956665039062,
0.00659489631652832,
-0.026194840669631958,
0.8222227096557617,
-0.1459507793188095,
0.20310300588607788,
0.5190773606300354,
0.18215031921863556,
0.2256360501050949,
0.11378950625658035,
0.8218181133270264,
-0.32183921337127686,
0.4645400643348694,
-0.22855247557163239,
-0.6532026529312134,
-0.3359377384185791,
-0.4356990456581116,
-0.5152239203453064,
-0.8262172341346741,
-0.5357522368431091,
-0.2574298083782196,
0.49603453278541565,
1.0963494777679443,
0.6367348432540894,
-0.937153160572052,
0.054972704499959946,
-0.3916097581386566,
-0.1565328687429428,
-0.06247366964817047,
-0.2092917263507843,
0.06490247696638107,
-0.48997533321380615,
-0.6393483877182007,
0.728519082069397,
0.352536678314209,
0.16157777607440948,
-0.07353749126195908,
-0.11192523688077927,
0.29180708527565,
-0.2218352109193802,
0.5588837265968323,
0.5175509452819824,
-0.5615386962890625,
-0.489536315202713,
-0.4566516578197479,
0.19740287959575653,
0.23229365050792694,
0.619537889957428,
-0.7923205494880676,
0.7591546773910522,
-0.022877058014273643,
0.5259883403778076,
0.26110461354255676,
0.171476349234581,
0.3793069124221802,
-1.1385900974273682,
0.17045484483242035,
0.5835111737251282,
0.19558478891849518,
0.4135981798171997,
-0.47177326679229736,
0.23966296017169952,
-0.12311670184135437,
-0.7419769167900085,
-0.9982244372367859,
0.06200188398361206,
-0.8062289357185364,
-0.10850618034601212,
0.9099908471107483,
0.14604152739048004,
0.2998141944408417,
-0.44757547974586487,
-0.3802226483821869,
0.5286944508552551,
-0.5673872828483582,
1.0590729713439941,
0.33347955346107483,
-0.465044230222702,
0.0400848351418972,
-0.2753712832927704,
0.5381813645362854,
0.2755529582500458,
-0.5175470113754272,
0.4355630576610565,
0.9206669330596924,
0.24055124819278717,
0.012798462994396687,
0.5632036328315735,
0.04560829699039459,
0.20823486149311066,
0.2001626193523407,
0.23031681776046753,
-0.3463205099105835,
-0.6260598301887512,
-0.8795377016067505,
0.022907109931111336,
-0.0050573041662573814,
-0.3455077111721039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10174v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10174v1
|
Let the Poem Hit the Rhythm: Using a Byte-Based Transformer for Beat-Aligned Poetry Generation
| 2024-06-14T16:54:48 | 2024-06-14T16:54:48 |
Mohamad Elzohbi, Richard Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The intersection between poetry and music provides an interesting case for
computational creativity, yet remains relatively unexplored. This paper
explores the integration of poetry and music through the lens of beat patterns,
investigating whether a byte-based language model can generate words that fit
specific beat patterns within the context of poetry. Drawing on earlier
studies, we developed a method to train a byte-based transformer model, ByT5,
to align poems with beat patterns. The results demonstrate a high level of beat
alignment while maintaining semantic coherence. Future work will aim to improve
the model's ability to create complete beat-aligned poems.
|
[
-0.3114131689071655,
-0.21765443682670593,
0.5703471302986145,
0.39075347781181335,
-0.385123610496521,
0.03082462213933468,
0.08637739717960358,
-0.8286412954330444,
0.46133068203926086,
0.6771522164344788,
-0.9257199168205261,
-0.27479273080825806,
-0.5018178820610046,
-0.2279333621263504,
-0.6872091293334961,
0.8690258860588074,
0.016951894387602806,
-0.020955661311745644,
-0.026452427729964256,
0.2137453258037567,
-1.1636161804199219,
0.0632464736700058,
-0.31033506989479065,
-0.7692760825157166,
0.25504976511001587,
0.4425143599510193,
0.5769379734992981,
0.5421350598335266,
0.7987838983535767,
0.22853922843933105,
-0.06877332180738449,
-0.2063075453042984,
-0.30179622769355774,
0.5981541275978088,
-0.13389824330806732,
-0.8863278031349182,
-0.4487393796443939,
0.3018863797187805,
0.23032750189304352,
0.35786134004592896,
0.1572766751050949,
0.3951342701911926,
-0.4217104911804199,
0.6427809000015259,
-0.1228923574090004,
-0.03674663230776787,
-0.724682629108429,
0.475839763879776,
-0.5543586015701294,
-0.11827512830495834,
-0.3719481825828552,
-0.5151222348213196,
-0.24450817704200745,
-0.28895103931427,
0.13014332950115204,
0.015889422968029976,
0.5192884802818298,
0.3781595826148987,
-0.13992133736610413,
-0.6122779846191406,
-0.8429430723190308,
0.5849046111106873,
-0.05128507316112518,
0.47849810123443604,
0.007467825897037983,
0.7068372964859009,
-0.3124590814113617,
-0.8684548139572144,
-0.6800119280815125,
0.2832323908805847,
0.22048452496528625,
0.3855136036872864,
-0.12742646038532257,
-0.32816994190216064,
0.4658362865447998,
0.5224343538284302,
-0.5256074666976929,
-0.5691620707511902,
-0.23114371299743652,
0.1811750829219818,
0.8238622546195984,
0.2703721821308136,
0.9267324209213257,
-0.30372732877731323,
-0.3299424946308136,
-0.047336794435977936,
-0.32778483629226685,
0.7083394527435303,
0.527201235294342,
0.44383981823921204,
-0.10149973630905151,
0.7647096514701843,
0.26141661405563354,
0.8025150895118713,
0.4307520091533661,
-0.4685688614845276,
0.19448545575141907,
-0.12796050310134888,
0.09047618508338928,
0.7167525291442871,
0.8115909099578857,
0.2757004499435425,
0.5145296454429626,
-0.4804244041442871,
-0.4485262334346771,
0.6433215737342834,
0.7503913044929504,
-0.7248986959457397,
-0.3353179097175598,
0.3880658447742462,
-0.3711196184158325,
-0.4705885350704193,
0.12624013423919678,
-0.42586106061935425,
-0.12453257292509079,
-0.40080100297927856,
0.7144561409950256,
-0.8109598159790039,
-0.29041072726249695,
0.27674874663352966,
-0.7346886992454529,
0.2606604993343353,
-0.1371881067752838,
-1.0456329584121704,
0.05863579362630844,
1.0348323583602905,
0.7791540026664734,
0.03330189734697342,
-0.22966253757476807,
-0.39711010456085205,
0.08585093170404434,
-0.562421977519989,
0.7209337949752808,
-0.6836840510368347,
-0.29961875081062317,
-0.14466693997383118,
-0.08353684097528458,
0.08115032315254211,
-0.411873459815979,
0.6711622476577759,
-0.7204738259315491,
-0.14810976386070251,
-0.20561270415782928,
-0.5993339419364929,
-0.0041985600255429745,
-0.13284923136234283,
-0.6379615664482117,
0.9046677350997925,
0.02650042437016964,
-0.7842012643814087,
0.38756322860717773,
-0.6380652189254761,
-0.4158177375793457,
0.15714526176452637,
-0.3563430905342102,
-0.54058837890625,
0.25268128514289856,
-0.3279685080051422,
0.13602709770202637,
-0.26506662368774414,
0.2937578856945038,
0.002269031945616007,
-0.8549672365188599,
0.4167056679725647,
0.09365478903055191,
1.04265296459198,
0.2963700294494629,
-0.5266879200935364,
-0.006154421251267195,
-1.089585304260254,
0.2202145904302597,
0.2116852104663849,
-0.2300116866827011,
-0.1353064775466919,
-0.11781789362430573,
0.38053256273269653,
0.4665590822696686,
-0.11929280310869217,
-0.93349289894104,
0.2808801829814911,
-0.12813739478588104,
0.3145548403263092,
0.2513163983821869,
-0.11310627311468124,
0.2548985183238983,
-1.0502259731292725,
0.7347939014434814,
-0.09437017887830734,
-0.06415555626153946,
-0.5547412633895874,
-0.5023443698883057,
-0.1031460165977478,
-0.44627484679222107,
0.1598845273256302,
0.36055517196655273,
-0.3419044017791748,
0.5457181930541992,
-0.48428869247436523,
-0.9382960200309753,
-1.1386219263076782,
-0.09923779964447021,
-0.08348510414361954,
0.22253775596618652,
0.5346203446388245,
-0.5979629755020142,
-0.759631872177124,
-0.34343037009239197,
-0.43175119161605835,
0.39070141315460205,
0.21312983334064484,
0.16354040801525116,
-0.01758943870663643,
-0.15124373137950897,
1.2312970161437988,
-0.004755821544677019,
-0.07614481449127197,
-0.1330271065235138,
0.05202750116586685,
0.518298327922821,
1.061403512954712,
0.48335590958595276,
-0.6443848609924316,
-0.5086736083030701,
-0.23207631707191467,
-0.44691792130470276,
-0.630601167678833,
-0.15368571877479553,
-0.3721182346343994,
-0.5014026761054993,
0.24665281176567078,
-0.620164155960083,
0.18607302010059357,
0.4049686789512634,
-0.3292933702468872,
0.31852012872695923,
0.33218759298324585,
0.23810458183288574,
-1.0313408374786377,
-0.061492037028074265,
-0.5083770155906677,
-0.3939594328403473,
-0.8021607995033264,
-0.12289388477802277,
0.004763119388371706,
-0.6312798261642456,
-0.2358526736497879,
-0.08841969817876816,
-0.2904389500617981,
-0.31252631545066833,
-0.7069547772407532,
-0.12303368747234344,
-0.019042151048779488,
-0.06265071034431458,
0.09339150041341782,
0.45496734976768494,
0.817720890045166,
-0.33156880736351013,
0.5269591212272644,
0.34473568201065063,
-0.4884440302848816,
0.8603631258010864,
-0.5978031158447266,
0.387605756521225,
-0.22012656927108765,
0.09326884150505066,
-0.9309541583061218,
-0.20819836854934692,
-0.2066115140914917,
-0.6416036486625671,
0.4906945526599884,
-0.20980387926101685,
-0.12755106389522552,
-0.4694877862930298,
-0.16514348983764648,
0.7942735552787781,
0.908575713634491,
-0.7197946310043335,
0.6049486398696899,
0.1424020230770111,
0.47146105766296387,
-0.4120810627937317,
-0.8778294920921326,
-0.11458412557840347,
-0.22476333379745483,
-0.9673440456390381,
0.6571236848831177,
-0.14755244553089142,
-0.20625872910022736,
-0.06310143321752548,
-0.11123383790254593,
0.2941126227378845,
0.0456753671169281,
0.5857276320457458,
0.02325308695435524,
-0.22726751863956451,
0.04942313954234123,
-0.21860337257385254,
-0.18532375991344452,
0.2019672840833664,
-0.6612863540649414,
1.017749547958374,
0.4631269872188568,
-0.6707342267036438,
-0.588334858417511,
0.4713153839111328,
0.8571099042892456,
-0.41717201471328735,
0.20495803654193878,
0.6068159341812134,
-0.07939532399177551,
-0.4703274667263031,
-0.2351345419883728,
0.3514779210090637,
-0.48757702112197876,
-0.21209880709648132,
-0.6681700348854065,
-0.3896212875843048,
0.47537246346473694,
-0.25869283080101013,
-0.33001479506492615,
0.1919160783290863,
0.3589225113391876,
-0.5062229037284851,
0.5195525884628296,
0.8963006734848022,
0.02648393251001835,
0.8098863959312439,
-0.334017813205719,
0.20992018282413483,
-0.8381139039993286,
0.028704816475510597,
-0.6692087054252625,
-0.8328542113304138,
-0.960726261138916,
-0.23794524371623993,
0.2558574378490448,
0.2661626636981964,
-0.3816359043121338,
0.3916424810886383,
-0.7422966361045837,
0.4209822714328766,
0.7155721783638,
0.11852148175239563,
-0.024046292528510094,
-0.3769477605819702,
-0.1749168485403061,
0.08600883185863495,
-0.5310913920402527,
-0.05741626396775246,
0.9152948260307312,
-0.00666165491566062,
0.6466453671455383,
0.3281005620956421,
1.1426290273666382,
0.09661896526813507,
-0.12628580629825592,
-0.8543277382850647,
0.2738792896270752,
-0.007558501325547695,
-0.5737051367759705,
-0.04614325612783432,
0.22247377038002014,
-0.8824109435081482,
-0.37925225496292114,
-0.3437274396419525,
-0.7085627317428589,
-0.11899422109127045,
-0.05307585000991821,
0.09111001342535019,
0.3049697279930115,
-0.30177849531173706,
0.9701684713363647,
0.0284319669008255,
-0.1399880051612854,
0.20822744071483612,
-0.4671380817890167,
0.5196226835250854,
-0.14283964037895203,
0.2735235095024109,
-0.1609342396259308,
0.29162874817848206,
0.32398101687431335,
-0.6440030932426453,
0.6655380725860596,
0.039498619735240936,
-0.14923527836799622,
0.6390097141265869,
0.2805140018463135,
0.5901414752006531,
-0.7251192331314087,
0.21623064577579498,
0.03510715439915657,
-0.17514614760875702,
-0.4913836717605591,
-0.45809224247932434,
0.4755069613456726,
-0.5915558338165283,
-0.46904703974723816,
0.10388238728046417,
-0.8566728234291077,
-0.1386992484331131,
0.08374366909265518,
0.45679861307144165,
0.5173283815383911,
0.4081021249294281,
-0.023173894733190536,
0.5543686747550964,
0.254692941904068,
1.0200282335281372,
0.03752598911523819,
-0.5842867493629456,
-0.39815080165863037,
0.6110601425170898,
0.2941780388355255,
0.22966580092906952,
0.3115732967853546,
0.26904261112213135,
-0.11670660227537155,
-0.18251827359199524,
-0.7190955281257629,
-0.20165897905826569,
-0.661015510559082,
-0.0033385592978447676,
-0.352507084608078,
-0.0611102394759655,
-0.42771226167678833,
-0.6098386645317078,
-0.3199034035205841,
-0.10797835141420364,
0.3008991479873657,
0.28288543224334717,
0.5657316446304321,
0.7913861870765686,
0.014778000302612782,
0.4165261387825012,
-1.0411933660507202,
0.17965292930603027,
0.26429039239883423,
0.8371710181236267,
0.0105995312333107,
-0.5360684394836426,
-0.0015026276232674718,
-0.6399437785148621,
-0.17173054814338684,
-1.4974348545074463,
-0.07235267013311386,
-0.42002934217453003,
0.21746277809143066,
-0.05463620647788048,
-0.29579368233680725,
0.6942946314811707,
-0.8797324895858765,
0.7460148334503174,
0.4118971824645996,
-1.2323155403137207,
0.8267250061035156,
-0.4877048134803772,
0.4852070212364197,
0.19697503745555878,
0.34795433282852173,
-0.850266695022583,
-0.3977874517440796,
-0.7244012355804443,
-0.5832934379577637,
0.6374911069869995,
0.07812228053808212,
0.18234539031982422,
0.16467097401618958,
0.4104843735694885,
0.22151607275009155,
0.07474292069673538,
-0.9398494362831116,
-0.36000609397888184,
-0.41172635555267334,
-0.7151159048080444,
0.06445344537496567,
0.07604755461215973,
0.2702271342277527,
-0.11759752780199051,
0.8278221487998962,
0.1302352398633957,
0.19773203134536743,
0.21708612143993378,
-0.11062242090702057,
-0.7439908981323242,
0.10109539330005646,
0.43787986040115356,
0.1467093974351883,
0.21703362464904785,
0.30655404925346375,
-0.4851911962032318,
-0.8976744413375854,
0.44253674149513245,
-0.22428353130817413,
-0.7859784960746765,
0.15258120000362396,
0.4485161304473877,
0.776631236076355,
-0.0943974032998085,
-0.5619718432426453,
0.388245552778244,
0.2847312390804291,
0.2639261782169342,
-0.32247400283813477,
0.663384735584259,
0.4356248676776886,
0.6861721873283386,
-0.03021899424493313,
0.24274490773677826,
-0.03304172307252884,
-0.5813033580780029,
0.569145679473877,
0.5268251895904541,
-0.8412931561470032,
-0.2175128310918808,
0.9684007167816162,
-0.4200131297111511,
-1.0799518823623657,
-0.0438164621591568,
-0.03672991693019867,
-0.5112375020980835,
0.6510888934135437,
1.0784038305282593,
1.0927972793579102,
-0.1447940170764923,
-0.4738496243953705,
0.30014532804489136,
0.2883547842502594,
0.16920126974582672,
0.7611978650093079,
-0.5200430154800415,
-0.7455475926399231,
-0.5132091641426086,
-0.7379485964775085,
-0.0878184363245964,
-0.2646094262599945,
-0.46938127279281616,
0.6337302923202515,
-0.11193548887968063,
-0.1653984636068344,
0.4078531265258789,
-0.08839993178844452,
-0.49195969104766846,
0.2852098047733307,
0.28511396050453186,
0.9619197249412537,
-0.8872066140174866,
0.8645370006561279,
0.9596174955368042,
-0.6941918730735779,
-1.070212483406067,
0.3277370035648346,
-0.14379467070102692,
-0.4948277771472931,
0.7508677840232849,
0.30335187911987305,
-0.09660879522562027,
0.3071095943450928,
-0.6551044583320618,
-1.0083529949188232,
1.2371426820755005,
-0.03517322987318039,
-0.5888282656669617,
0.8059007525444031,
0.21889807283878326,
0.3777235448360443,
-0.2532561421394348,
0.31549257040023804,
0.6546333432197571,
0.36944514513015747,
0.42345571517944336,
-0.8551921248435974,
-0.29348224401474,
-0.30646613240242004,
0.04034608602523804,
0.6913394927978516,
-0.81951504945755,
0.981855571269989,
0.13923878967761993,
0.0032113022170960903,
-0.29771918058395386,
0.6990175247192383,
0.08299058675765991,
0.334062397480011,
0.2723422646522522,
0.9689663052558899,
0.8247493505477905,
-0.09412925690412521,
1.0266436338424683,
-0.5461128354072571,
0.15943121910095215,
0.8361741304397583,
-0.16628149151802063,
0.4195639491081238,
0.25171300768852234,
-0.3154621422290802,
0.5234258770942688,
0.2926197350025177,
0.06191185489296913,
0.4862090051174164,
0.530644953250885,
-0.5965988636016846,
-0.19746768474578857,
0.00011396448098821566,
-0.07605738937854767,
0.7261804938316345,
-0.3070036768913269,
-0.27423393726348877,
0.17117813229560852,
-0.036468423902988434,
0.009456122294068336,
0.23421859741210938,
-0.7760855555534363,
0.809526801109314,
-0.22052524983882904,
-0.7784654498100281,
0.22743581235408783,
-0.0957653596997261,
0.7607236504554749,
-0.21766245365142822,
-0.10304521769285202,
0.057902537286281586,
-0.09627735614776611,
-0.20402944087982178,
-0.779382586479187,
0.5082157254219055,
0.19619888067245483,
-0.605467677116394,
-0.08279825747013092,
1.1638239622116089,
-0.5456611514091492,
-0.40080174803733826,
0.14228737354278564,
0.3177652060985565,
0.2769000232219696,
0.26651453971862793,
-0.2748526930809021,
0.2883451282978058,
-0.0858011469244957,
0.11475774645805359,
0.08212511241436005,
0.7557505965232849,
0.040892645716667175,
0.25295257568359375,
0.5711309313774109,
0.3299044668674469,
0.4778268039226532,
-0.05868829786777496,
0.37026548385620117,
-0.9924665093421936,
-0.5143306851387024,
-0.8406602740287781,
0.43589070439338684,
0.36330729722976685,
0.051357291638851166,
0.1634344458580017,
0.579522430896759,
0.7960571050643921,
-0.04710837081074715,
0.8138044476509094,
-0.1481257528066635,
0.40454092621803284,
-0.4483798146247864,
0.7256648540496826,
-0.2854962646961212,
-0.15184421837329865,
-0.3155757784843445,
-0.7266631126403809,
-0.0763954371213913,
0.3621293008327484,
-0.08895803242921829,
0.09384501725435257,
0.5152778625488281,
0.33237022161483765,
-0.29288721084594727,
0.47554969787597656,
0.47549107670783997,
0.0065776328556239605,
0.2908095419406891,
0.5487774610519409,
0.6149614453315735,
-0.7062265872955322,
0.20543329417705536,
-0.6656593084335327,
0.031118644401431084,
0.2146001011133194,
-1.0607868432998657,
-0.6276533007621765,
-0.3823919892311096,
-0.1664987951517105,
-0.34560221433639526,
-0.3000093102455139,
1.3662364482879639,
0.32020577788352966,
-0.6722708344459534,
-0.2826360762119293,
-0.23032544553279877,
0.05945921689271927,
-0.44812458753585815,
-0.22252191603183746,
0.17370851337909698,
-0.8675775527954102,
-0.9176484942436218,
0.4903625249862671,
0.35000789165496826,
0.32588309049606323,
0.005507006775587797,
0.16123871505260468,
-0.016051966696977615,
0.2641258239746094,
0.20495982468128204,
-0.2601696848869324,
-0.28953373432159424,
-0.39542949199676514,
-0.11701837927103043,
-0.2666526436805725,
0.3366372287273407,
1.1113146543502808,
-0.606221616268158,
0.6127976775169373,
0.5254573225975037,
0.8982278108596802,
0.45079782605171204,
0.07538602501153946,
0.14394840598106384,
-0.837676465511322,
-0.04096651449799538,
0.12837529182434082,
0.37214139103889465,
0.13451805710792542,
-0.39831823110580444,
0.3645712733268738,
0.6819616556167603,
-0.46558746695518494,
-0.5022594332695007,
0.34402742981910706,
-1.2436696290969849,
-0.040841661393642426,
0.7280598878860474,
0.0742005780339241,
-0.515525221824646,
-0.09230570495128632,
-0.09997259825468063,
0.6263601779937744,
0.15014949440956116,
0.5653082728385925,
0.877696692943573,
-0.44079235196113586,
-0.006571992766112089,
-0.705680787563324,
0.5534914135932922,
0.33519846200942993,
-0.31189870834350586,
-0.2684226632118225,
0.4574681222438812,
0.24721777439117432,
0.39482977986335754,
0.5680789947509766,
-0.056410860270261765,
0.6173355579376221,
0.3020018935203552,
0.9253481030464172,
-0.04636571183800697,
-0.20799563825130463,
-0.3828400671482086,
0.5320843458175659,
0.03450150787830353,
-0.4472193419933319
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10173v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10173v1
|
IntentionQA: A Benchmark for Evaluating Purchase Intention Comprehension Abilities of Language Models in E-commerce
| 2024-06-14T16:51:21 | 2024-06-14T16:51:21 |
Wenxuan Ding, Weiqi Wang, Sze Heng Douglas Kwok, Minghao Liu, Tianqing Fang, Jiaxin Bai, Junxian He, Yangqiu Song
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Enhancing Language Models' (LMs) ability to understand purchase intentions in
E-commerce scenarios is crucial for their effective assistance in various
downstream tasks. However, previous approaches that distill intentions from LMs
often fail to generate meaningful and human-centric intentions applicable in
real-world E-commerce contexts. This raises concerns about the true
comprehension and utilization of purchase intentions by LMs. In this paper, we
present IntentionQA, a double-task multiple-choice question answering benchmark
to evaluate LMs' comprehension of purchase intentions in E-commerce.
Specifically, LMs are tasked to infer intentions based on purchased products
and utilize them to predict additional purchases. IntentionQA consists of 4,360
carefully curated problems across three difficulty levels, constructed using an
automated pipeline to ensure scalability on large E-commerce platforms. Human
evaluations demonstrate the high quality and low false-negative rate of our
benchmark. Extensive experiments across 19 language models show that they still
struggle with certain scenarios, such as understanding products and intentions
accurately, jointly reasoning with products and intentions, and more, in which
they fall far behind human performances. Our code and data are publicly
available at https://github.com/HKUST-KnowComp/IntentionQA.
|
[
-0.38193538784980774,
-0.7284058928489685,
0.7860767245292664,
0.2528586983680725,
-0.2872450351715088,
-0.2422664314508438,
-0.18180294334888458,
-0.5823028087615967,
-0.25103798508644104,
0.4054853916168213,
-0.8785845637321472,
-0.2885275185108185,
-0.037971146404743195,
0.039320267736911774,
-0.30142495036125183,
0.6976407170295715,
-0.16173328459262848,
0.1441107541322708,
-0.3161758780479431,
-0.10673990100622177,
-0.5739368200302124,
-0.405673623085022,
-0.9737640023231506,
-0.05807213485240936,
0.4128528833389282,
0.4777179956436157,
0.44666656851768494,
-0.06986574828624725,
0.1908082664012909,
0.1471109688282013,
0.14705008268356323,
0.34248167276382446,
-0.4620666801929474,
0.30983132123947144,
-0.08905111998319626,
-0.4211755692958832,
-0.5616922378540039,
0.04418554529547691,
0.38212406635284424,
0.5161961913108826,
-0.3173239529132843,
0.5243308544158936,
0.14938229322433472,
0.6634400486946106,
-0.8285757899284363,
-0.1618112027645111,
-0.43336746096611023,
-0.2471437156200409,
0.3813531696796417,
0.22283126413822174,
-0.554856538772583,
-0.09325549751520157,
0.12776634097099304,
-0.7571318745613098,
-0.030532414093613625,
0.3492143750190735,
0.724652111530304,
0.28329193592071533,
-0.5449901819229126,
-0.4125119149684906,
-0.46068552136421204,
0.7953680157661438,
-0.5631932616233826,
0.8945732116699219,
0.59128338098526,
0.36720800399780273,
-0.02205275371670723,
-0.791390061378479,
-0.612345278263092,
-0.04630950838327408,
-0.038725558668375015,
0.3360935151576996,
-0.41364309191703796,
-0.0696558803319931,
0.34960493445396423,
0.15598835051059723,
-0.7990714907646179,
-0.2951575219631195,
-0.22182370722293854,
0.005551593843847513,
0.6748192310333252,
0.20926567912101746,
0.29164543747901917,
-0.09165099263191223,
-0.4222073554992676,
0.06457208096981049,
-0.4960336685180664,
0.45445555448532104,
0.5308886766433716,
-0.009295742027461529,
0.07198348641395569,
0.4935772120952606,
-0.6320593357086182,
0.8228232860565186,
0.02014334313571453,
0.1383325755596161,
0.1455310881137848,
-0.5469211935997009,
-0.3824905753135681,
-0.19341334700584412,
0.5168914794921875,
0.41185829043388367,
0.20012688636779785,
0.14184732735157013,
-0.18628433346748352,
-0.3636769652366638,
0.49615633487701416,
-0.5582993626594543,
-0.13553792238235474,
0.8545745015144348,
-0.6323174238204956,
0.16581666469573975,
-0.019923044368624687,
-0.4217175543308258,
-0.09580790996551514,
-0.29202473163604736,
0.7386649250984192,
-0.18668092787265778,
-0.2061997354030609,
0.4962015748023987,
-0.19006186723709106,
0.35865578055381775,
0.022390656173229218,
-0.4190862476825714,
0.2492097020149231,
0.8477461338043213,
0.4412328898906708,
-0.04219333827495575,
-0.42518094182014465,
-0.5145193934440613,
0.045669279992580414,
-0.17799444496631622,
0.5843015909194946,
-0.28435370326042175,
-0.20046833157539368,
-0.15659977495670319,
-0.12529580295085907,
0.06945636123418808,
-0.22279098629951477,
1.0907680988311768,
-0.7507203817367554,
-0.0040616123005747795,
-0.4722243845462799,
-0.47902509570121765,
-0.3354566991329193,
0.5750772356987,
-0.6607936024665833,
0.8925415873527527,
-0.09333711117506027,
-0.20897504687309265,
0.5814149379730225,
-0.5282590389251709,
-0.4223570227622986,
0.1735258251428604,
0.18191377818584442,
-0.29410699009895325,
0.23510697484016418,
0.31744882464408875,
0.3772697448730469,
-0.35454919934272766,
0.23453830182552338,
-0.3291078507900238,
-0.29126837849617004,
0.6513658761978149,
-0.6341339945793152,
0.7369613647460938,
0.22326676547527313,
-0.284339964389801,
-0.2424185425043106,
-0.40675416588783264,
0.2673132121562958,
0.23123961687088013,
-0.11144538223743439,
-0.33519652485847473,
0.1194409430027008,
0.07171408832073212,
0.48910921812057495,
0.4843916594982147,
-0.43340227007865906,
0.04174964874982834,
-0.26733535528182983,
0.2313033789396286,
0.5305099487304688,
0.17543953657150269,
0.2297145426273346,
-0.39664825797080994,
0.744132399559021,
-0.2607939541339874,
0.649964451789856,
-0.16647545993328094,
-0.7879365682601929,
-0.8284140825271606,
0.10420187562704086,
0.11988545954227448,
0.170408695936203,
-0.5444847941398621,
0.11720486730337143,
-0.1569279134273529,
-0.4349927306175232,
-0.5314279198646545,
-0.001514823641628027,
0.5160394906997681,
0.14558623731136322,
0.4303112030029297,
-0.31997400522232056,
-0.23132294416427612,
-1.0710887908935547,
-0.9509440660476685,
-0.5097455382347107,
-0.03921356424689293,
0.6622238159179688,
0.234693244099617,
-0.009284105151891708,
0.8885984420776367,
-0.5473655462265015,
-0.0326026976108551,
-0.3090353310108185,
0.1643260270357132,
0.1256558746099472,
0.0027158339507877827,
0.2510482966899872,
-1.0260215997695923,
-0.644403338432312,
-0.2183956503868103,
-0.25456738471984863,
-0.30137380957603455,
-0.3553256094455719,
-0.3355473577976227,
0.11598628014326096,
0.037227336317300797,
-0.554365873336792,
0.2583910822868347,
0.6427231431007385,
-0.4743075966835022,
0.6487030386924744,
-0.1838088184595108,
0.3898548185825348,
-0.849976658821106,
0.04830856993794441,
0.018785348162055016,
-0.10004019737243652,
-0.7927293181419373,
0.12186487019062042,
0.5608105063438416,
0.21071994304656982,
-0.7052211165428162,
0.6758978366851807,
-0.5291213989257812,
-0.29429763555526733,
-0.013622953556478024,
0.08358893543481827,
0.48000892996788025,
0.36535438895225525,
0.1183214783668518,
0.7557132244110107,
0.27888089418411255,
-0.8973552584648132,
-0.06683105230331421,
0.19891460239887238,
-0.5059882998466492,
0.9106561541557312,
-0.6371681094169617,
0.13630057871341705,
-0.05343615263700485,
0.09371498972177505,
-1.067974328994751,
-0.14653146266937256,
0.3468206822872162,
-0.5692358016967773,
-0.11652099341154099,
-0.20718161761760712,
-0.3693700134754181,
-0.35288792848587036,
-0.11281158775091171,
0.5565739274024963,
0.49422112107276917,
-0.6208468079566956,
0.6320701837539673,
0.29917043447494507,
-0.07963325083255768,
-0.6034879088401794,
-0.7333720922470093,
0.07017059624195099,
-0.2691849172115326,
-0.5173399448394775,
0.18506260216236115,
-0.4757455289363861,
-0.2866666913032532,
-0.18830345571041107,
-0.08446954935789108,
-0.12823496758937836,
0.16808249056339264,
-0.049847401678562164,
0.08167820423841476,
0.030112966895103455,
0.2647132873535156,
0.25377848744392395,
0.034241676330566406,
0.5000265836715698,
-0.4393557608127594,
0.44509124755859375,
0.1705549657344818,
-0.6252985596656799,
-0.39615708589553833,
0.31335562467575073,
0.3959726095199585,
-0.20349867641925812,
0.46536746621131897,
0.2952165901660919,
-0.38529595732688904,
-0.3452310860157013,
-0.7387533187866211,
-0.144645556807518,
-0.4425651729106903,
0.278687983751297,
-0.776626467704773,
-0.5003596544265747,
0.22695006430149078,
0.09452222287654877,
0.10561417043209076,
0.2210104614496231,
0.3907717764377594,
-0.11644036322832108,
1.2950718402862549,
0.021296896040439606,
0.30232319235801697,
-0.03387510031461716,
0.13152839243412018,
0.46684807538986206,
-1.0097551345825195,
-0.22842548787593842,
-0.44707074761390686,
-0.375653475522995,
-0.12603217363357544,
-0.4362090528011322,
0.1954202800989151,
0.2968728542327881,
-0.2110752910375595,
0.41627615690231323,
-0.165202334523201,
0.43515080213546753,
0.37015673518180847,
0.17617863416671753,
0.501311719417572,
-0.07275981456041336,
0.22396717965602875,
0.01922553963959217,
-0.31742390990257263,
-0.5582623481750488,
1.1674610376358032,
0.28883835673332214,
0.3399878740310669,
0.5037710070610046,
0.44411930441856384,
0.05437532067298889,
0.0538751520216465,
-0.953238308429718,
0.4692290127277374,
0.13889896869659424,
-0.7782566547393799,
-0.19811446964740753,
-0.33011528849601746,
-0.8894181847572327,
0.35435938835144043,
0.024379342794418335,
-0.8577101826667786,
0.3065541982650757,
0.36773020029067993,
-0.41637569665908813,
-0.08540098369121552,
-0.6852763891220093,
1.1181260347366333,
-0.861488401889801,
-0.5917490124702454,
-0.2696533501148224,
-0.24815218150615692,
0.334664523601532,
-0.37436214089393616,
0.406485378742218,
-0.18294590711593628,
-0.4658542573451996,
0.6804537773132324,
0.09006953239440918,
0.40628644824028015,
-0.11295381933450699,
0.0015082632889971137,
0.2880229353904724,
0.2182772010564804,
0.5803660154342651,
0.10152249783277512,
-0.08991175889968872,
0.15834449231624603,
0.05019938200712204,
-0.33161747455596924,
-0.5711531639099121,
0.4566635489463806,
-0.35286539793014526,
-0.5181022882461548,
-0.16772089898586273,
-0.23633906245231628,
-0.6901739239692688,
0.1506788432598114,
-0.0483509786427021,
0.16963550448417664,
-0.6611495614051819,
0.12095066159963608,
0.42041224241256714,
-0.1170773059129715,
0.37960514426231384,
0.7595018148422241,
-0.28158408403396606,
0.009347676299512386,
0.655693531036377,
-0.16547465324401855,
0.4012123644351959,
0.2333148717880249,
0.22681720554828644,
-0.7736601233482361,
-0.6054299473762512,
-0.6640555262565613,
0.0025431718677282333,
-0.8490561246871948,
0.018182532861828804,
-0.8384292125701904,
0.2317827045917511,
-0.16000507771968842,
0.16837093234062195,
-0.04650034382939339,
-0.3991391360759735,
-0.08682951331138611,
0.017229901626706123,
0.0992390587925911,
0.8019250631332397,
0.23552945256233215,
0.08900441974401474,
-0.8560304641723633,
0.3749673068523407,
0.6175078749656677,
0.4013685882091522,
0.060780029743909836,
-0.5058885216712952,
-0.20124556124210358,
0.3552035689353943,
0.03119259513914585,
-0.9466015696525574,
0.4040425419807434,
0.07404545694589615,
0.7855865955352783,
0.43434861302375793,
0.2467663586139679,
0.7251437306404114,
-0.19270823895931244,
0.9340941309928894,
-0.047715481370687485,
-1.0601890087127686,
0.23612618446350098,
-0.2846890985965729,
0.5240610837936401,
0.8276283144950867,
0.6118749976158142,
-0.7465230822563171,
-0.022781163454055786,
-0.48043784499168396,
-0.8085842728614807,
0.9470713138580322,
0.38780319690704346,
0.09171108901500702,
-0.01603149250149727,
0.2758212983608246,
0.19105838239192963,
0.25365394353866577,
-0.5693361759185791,
-0.4089142382144928,
0.25822076201438904,
-0.15334680676460266,
-0.1363988220691681,
-0.411297470331192,
0.3460443317890167,
-0.018533235415816307,
0.9296987056732178,
0.014440580271184444,
-0.09648458659648895,
0.037843815982341766,
-0.383852481842041,
0.011100475676357746,
0.44584915041923523,
0.2820621728897095,
0.8213386535644531,
0.0029517156071960926,
-0.20968501269817352,
0.18413490056991577,
-0.5233691930770874,
-0.026206880807876587,
-0.02834831178188324,
-0.14131857454776764,
-0.38263729214668274,
-0.2991687059402466,
0.46802014112472534,
0.09517035633325577,
-1.0527253150939941,
0.5169664621353149,
-0.6608253121376038,
-0.1467972993850708,
-0.40695786476135254,
-0.13937662541866302,
0.2918943166732788,
0.19033846259117126,
0.31047406792640686,
-0.36490821838378906,
0.7784662246704102,
-0.479239284992218,
0.04254082590341568,
0.4326491951942444,
-0.44953545928001404,
-0.09449538588523865,
0.3584733009338379,
0.1119786873459816,
-0.4738357961177826,
0.45889437198638916,
-0.5325425863265991,
-0.5841322541236877,
0.5491818189620972,
0.4913005530834198,
1.0784552097320557,
-0.24312327802181244,
0.2430741786956787,
0.6655616760253906,
0.5192039012908936,
-0.10736996680498123,
0.7083917260169983,
-0.2928316593170166,
-0.766787052154541,
-0.2794690430164337,
-0.5960994958877563,
-0.416393905878067,
0.02373906783759594,
-0.7774260640144348,
0.23281915485858917,
0.20387646555900574,
-0.15093597769737244,
-0.12417732924222946,
-0.07869725674390793,
-0.8511120676994324,
0.2928289771080017,
-0.05259706825017929,
0.5896231532096863,
-0.5786585211753845,
0.6030390858650208,
0.6786085367202759,
-0.19093972444534302,
-0.8859100341796875,
0.16291531920433044,
0.06695199012756348,
-0.6044362783432007,
0.3292740285396576,
0.27332398295402527,
-0.28113114833831787,
-0.06397328525781631,
-0.1084883064031601,
-0.6434531211853027,
0.9530759453773499,
-0.11670888960361481,
-0.8910378217697144,
0.4077446162700653,
0.3229118883609772,
0.27244919538497925,
-0.30503761768341064,
0.4727555215358734,
0.9439826011657715,
0.6190690398216248,
-0.1826392412185669,
-0.6973326802253723,
-0.013685354962944984,
-0.21253658831119537,
-0.4020291268825531,
0.36679020524024963,
-0.42071112990379333,
0.7165129780769348,
0.1397123634815216,
-0.29024550318717957,
0.05892077460885048,
0.074442058801651,
0.42095428705215454,
0.4943864345550537,
0.8180738687515259,
0.6497814059257507,
0.6801766753196716,
0.07285485416650772,
0.9101057648658752,
-0.2976067066192627,
0.29161742329597473,
1.1054810285568237,
-0.3834322988986969,
1.237789511680603,
0.43077465891838074,
-0.32377076148986816,
0.23379069566726685,
0.6447083353996277,
0.5154801607131958,
0.14926178753376007,
0.042406413704156876,
-0.31089043617248535,
-0.7066164612770081,
-0.034821394830942154,
-0.16700205206871033,
0.5722556114196777,
0.5092215538024902,
-0.18628457188606262,
0.21184878051280975,
-0.24624769389629364,
-0.324335515499115,
-0.1531464159488678,
-0.3307254910469055,
0.8258113265037537,
0.08267241716384888,
-1.0058692693710327,
0.2535126209259033,
-0.019965920597314835,
0.17226986587047577,
-0.43726399540901184,
-0.03363525867462158,
0.13410231471061707,
0.06350190937519073,
-0.048864856362342834,
-0.9250908493995667,
0.001323805539868772,
0.027322014793753624,
0.04939470440149307,
-0.16328224539756775,
0.7585767507553101,
-0.3239906132221222,
-0.371663898229599,
0.37367430329322815,
0.8101469278335571,
0.24968600273132324,
-0.43382930755615234,
-0.9987686276435852,
0.007340694777667522,
0.008711463771760464,
-0.48363596200942993,
0.1437574028968811,
0.12181536853313446,
0.08694683760404587,
0.49600812792778015,
0.76158607006073,
-0.29895880818367004,
-0.1262107640504837,
0.18639226257801056,
0.36558428406715393,
-0.47073423862457275,
-0.6152918934822083,
-0.7665727734565735,
0.719454824924469,
-0.28914326429367065,
-0.3929692208766937,
0.8540747761726379,
0.6109151244163513,
1.002562165260315,
0.16724377870559692,
0.749925971031189,
0.3185473084449768,
0.30826544761657715,
-0.4694027006626129,
0.6310758590698242,
-0.9289039969444275,
0.38932639360427856,
-0.03977532684803009,
-1.1634739637374878,
0.018248794600367546,
0.3359517455101013,
-0.42418086528778076,
0.3104976713657379,
0.711991548538208,
0.6304714679718018,
-0.1833016276359558,
0.41283276677131653,
0.565666139125824,
-0.14482402801513672,
-0.174411341547966,
0.6679278016090393,
1.1582746505737305,
-0.5163293480873108,
0.7599241137504578,
-0.46990662813186646,
-0.11438145488500595,
-0.11588782072067261,
-0.7670794725418091,
-0.6676872968673706,
-0.591518223285675,
-0.2559943199157715,
-0.03285958617925644,
0.16717584431171417,
0.9728313684463501,
0.7062165141105652,
-0.5784789323806763,
-0.2528511881828308,
-0.0597112774848938,
-0.01343582570552826,
-0.47362804412841797,
-0.1592712551355362,
0.09044748544692993,
-0.3502066433429718,
-0.7669745683670044,
0.4405536651611328,
0.2466275840997696,
-0.16589170694351196,
-0.2632634937763214,
-0.33779218792915344,
-0.17181532084941864,
0.3624485433101654,
0.6392326354980469,
0.17234212160110474,
-0.8717367053031921,
-0.08489826321601868,
0.3679434657096863,
0.048550110310316086,
-0.22410644590854645,
0.8818392157554626,
-0.6761676669120789,
0.8067554235458374,
0.5451518297195435,
0.46964171528816223,
0.5097925066947937,
0.22830183804035187,
0.47592395544052124,
-0.4105374217033386,
-0.3964260518550873,
0.3134029507637024,
0.5291203856468201,
0.03744367137551308,
-0.29297980666160583,
0.16482725739479065,
-0.5455646514892578,
-0.6879463791847229,
-0.5232068300247192,
0.5913968682289124,
-0.8241666555404663,
-0.6345528364181519,
1.238842487335205,
-0.11143994331359863,
-0.17233873903751373,
-0.6323628425598145,
-0.3033965528011322,
-0.0994928851723671,
-0.44211718440055847,
0.42268964648246765,
0.6041305661201477,
-0.03967643901705742,
-0.36541271209716797,
-0.6708095073699951,
0.36323365569114685,
0.6680482029914856,
-0.6896879076957703,
0.2941804826259613,
0.6856920123100281,
-0.08396454900503159,
-0.19221436977386475,
0.5982695817947388,
0.27312809228897095,
0.7401403188705444,
-0.2408030778169632,
0.006210705265402794,
0.09675158560276031,
-0.3880468010902405,
-0.4842497706413269,
0.06555383652448654,
0.5495444536209106,
-0.013732455670833588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10172v1
|
Datasets for Multilingual Answer Sentence Selection
| 2024-06-14T16:50:29 | 2024-06-14T16:50:29 |
Matteo Gabburo, Stefano Campese, Federico Agostini, Alessandro Moschitti
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Answer Sentence Selection (AS2) is a critical task for designing effective
retrieval-based Question Answering (QA) systems. Most advancements in AS2 focus
on English due to the scarcity of annotated datasets for other languages. This
lack of resources prevents the training of effective AS2 models in different
languages, creating a performance gap between QA systems in English and other
locales. In this paper, we introduce new high-quality datasets for AS2 in five
European languages (French, German, Italian, Portuguese, and Spanish), obtained
through supervised Automatic Machine Translation (AMT) of existing English AS2
datasets such as ASNQ, WikiQA, and TREC-QA using a Large Language Model (LLM).
We evaluated our approach and the quality of the translated datasets through
multiple experiments with different Transformer architectures. The results
indicate that our datasets are pivotal in producing robust and powerful
multilingual AS2 models, significantly contributing to closing the performance
gap between English and other languages.
|
[
-0.374024361371994,
-0.5143660306930542,
0.3607381582260132,
0.3117867708206177,
-0.08223377168178558,
0.0914832353591919,
-0.09830417484045029,
-0.5325194001197815,
0.1416996717453003,
0.6394281387329102,
-0.4764191508293152,
-0.24222123622894287,
-0.5429790616035461,
0.6093336939811707,
-0.42127320170402527,
0.8034058809280396,
-0.3564945161342621,
0.45020976662635803,
-0.4353368282318115,
-0.4940982162952423,
-0.5297669172286987,
-0.3502422273159027,
-0.682112991809845,
-0.44141921401023865,
0.21672795712947845,
0.5362119078636169,
0.6258618235588074,
0.35578683018684387,
0.3980095684528351,
0.19666056334972382,
0.05332754924893379,
0.4548071026802063,
-0.03765445947647095,
0.18669313192367554,
-0.03417012467980385,
-0.5980406999588013,
0.040452081710100174,
-0.02777174301445484,
0.3461904525756836,
0.5513793230056763,
0.19247177243232727,
0.2354244738817215,
-0.047093138098716736,
0.46814054250717163,
-0.3420102894306183,
0.10132894665002823,
-0.4394988417625427,
-0.022472329437732697,
0.036452505737543106,
0.06512753665447235,
-0.4277796745300293,
-0.54021155834198,
-0.05221923813223839,
-0.4906254708766937,
0.17022667825222015,
-0.14640891551971436,
0.794854462146759,
0.3131697177886963,
-0.8832289576530457,
-0.5219098925590515,
-0.5399879813194275,
0.5259445309638977,
-0.410867303609848,
0.5047404766082764,
0.47138309478759766,
0.43903324007987976,
0.378081351518631,
-0.35944864153862,
-0.36210396885871887,
0.2064645141363144,
-0.3173879086971283,
0.35908621549606323,
-0.2631152272224426,
-0.3907368779182434,
-0.03513404726982117,
0.1107989177107811,
-0.8509088158607483,
0.22138777375221252,
-0.572472870349884,
-0.13920971751213074,
0.6515200138092041,
-0.11508859694004059,
0.06309129297733307,
-0.2925805449485779,
-0.19604021310806274,
-0.16186393797397614,
-0.869071364402771,
0.3693506121635437,
0.5475375056266785,
0.363738477230072,
0.09063762426376343,
0.6803646683692932,
-0.2441873997449875,
0.598832905292511,
-0.4550381600856781,
0.29782816767692566,
0.4285573363304138,
-0.34839120507240295,
0.24813500046730042,
-0.15891601145267487,
0.8812515735626221,
0.31380152702331543,
0.5969456434249878,
-0.18415549397468567,
-0.16362830996513367,
0.10464616119861603,
-0.007980520837008953,
-0.7350233197212219,
-0.13119463622570038,
0.41691356897354126,
-0.26054441928863525,
-0.08670084178447723,
0.16186898946762085,
-0.6599385142326355,
0.06084664911031723,
-0.12850426137447357,
0.14802704751491547,
-0.23744134604930878,
-0.033233508467674255,
0.17493540048599243,
-0.04261624068021774,
0.15883201360702515,
0.03957642242312431,
-0.5412845611572266,
0.3301903009414673,
0.09915092587471008,
0.46836423873901367,
-0.3172290325164795,
-0.399793803691864,
-0.7185388207435608,
0.04866786301136017,
-0.30402815341949463,
1.052008032798767,
-0.7615914940834045,
-0.43011221289634705,
0.35657814145088196,
0.23259182274341583,
-0.13223949074745178,
-0.6848707795143127,
0.6656258702278137,
-0.7772675156593323,
0.6024813055992126,
-0.18003171682357788,
-0.26650458574295044,
-0.32178807258605957,
0.19472084939479828,
-0.8028711080551147,
1.072548747062683,
-0.13456349074840546,
-0.4910241663455963,
0.11721111834049225,
-0.6108223795890808,
-0.8318169713020325,
-0.24023714661598206,
-0.25919309258461,
-0.26965197920799255,
0.04524143412709236,
0.7131240367889404,
0.24045628309249878,
-0.3643700182437897,
-0.03340037912130356,
0.05166982486844063,
-0.37883734703063965,
0.3553548753261566,
-0.5629480481147766,
0.8617983460426331,
0.4248034954071045,
0.10866160690784454,
-0.13662196695804596,
-0.5687283277511597,
0.1535790115594864,
0.025040507316589355,
-0.5342242121696472,
-0.05445697903633118,
-0.04974343255162239,
0.381846159696579,
0.633085310459137,
0.2844153940677643,
-0.6816272735595703,
-0.1452513188123703,
-0.3342890739440918,
0.5961851477622986,
0.295711874961853,
0.022301161661744118,
0.12254518270492554,
-0.1740850806236267,
0.8642639517784119,
0.1316346824169159,
-0.13915614783763885,
-0.16789282858371735,
-0.5034880042076111,
-0.7360733151435852,
0.13380205631256104,
0.4579552114009857,
1.1346571445465088,
-1.178766131401062,
0.2814749479293823,
-0.40078601241111755,
-0.08206591010093689,
-0.9562461376190186,
0.07755269855260849,
0.43585601449012756,
0.06377924233675003,
0.550269365310669,
0.24649447202682495,
-0.25932419300079346,
-1.038175106048584,
-0.1675729900598526,
-0.18603885173797607,
-0.3585498631000519,
0.3978492319583893,
0.4304559826850891,
-0.023417208343744278,
0.8764488697052002,
-0.6209372878074646,
-0.1548575758934021,
-0.3279428482055664,
-0.2578829228878021,
0.3625187575817108,
0.17140786349773407,
0.4942474663257599,
-0.9724370837211609,
-0.5736710429191589,
-0.010058458894491196,
-0.8496652841567993,
-0.1540348380804062,
0.09238648414611816,
-0.09967254102230072,
0.22313439846038818,
0.5219168066978455,
-0.5924249887466431,
0.10320248454809189,
0.6123955845832825,
-0.5173965096473694,
0.20254197716712952,
-0.2734011709690094,
0.48919469118118286,
-1.4792636632919312,
0.19952140748500824,
-0.04174131527543068,
-0.3420407176017761,
-0.5240763425827026,
0.07444702088832855,
0.3245322108268738,
-0.18775232136249542,
-0.4843369722366333,
0.7361145615577698,
-0.25438594818115234,
-0.01987321302294731,
0.07899533957242966,
0.16284601390361786,
0.23520983755588531,
0.22283516824245453,
0.1657516062259674,
1.0293464660644531,
0.19157208502292633,
-0.35889118909835815,
0.42765381932258606,
1.0786101818084717,
-0.29667919874191284,
0.5268077850341797,
-0.6930137276649475,
-0.004232105799019337,
-0.21607662737369537,
0.12675169110298157,
-0.9082278609275818,
-0.08991242945194244,
-0.24829983711242676,
-0.730919599533081,
0.015574438497424126,
0.017304038628935814,
-0.7050237059593201,
-0.6160680651664734,
-0.0970749482512474,
0.21540717780590057,
0.3033933639526367,
-0.4618021249771118,
0.2790878713130951,
0.2222708761692047,
-0.37179985642433167,
-0.5395184755325317,
-0.8935596942901611,
0.020518245175480843,
-0.15180732309818268,
-0.751227855682373,
-0.09909626841545105,
-0.12591128051280975,
-0.07984690368175507,
-0.15847495198249817,
-0.019444281235337257,
-0.14063237607479095,
0.055071279406547546,
-0.15694472193717957,
0.21074242889881134,
-0.07175253331661224,
0.3752608001232147,
0.19138255715370178,
-0.19618497788906097,
-0.06799978017807007,
-0.22003960609436035,
0.39843302965164185,
0.08498165756464005,
-0.26428934931755066,
-0.17228780686855316,
0.719479501247406,
0.3959974944591522,
-0.7239457368850708,
0.44065138697624207,
0.3414221704006195,
-0.30449777841567993,
-0.08673408627510071,
-0.5470879673957825,
-0.3307737112045288,
-0.3819909691810608,
0.37613075971603394,
-0.6770619750022888,
-0.9047497510910034,
0.7182140946388245,
0.4466777741909027,
0.22101739048957825,
0.3499840795993805,
0.3387143611907959,
-0.26311638951301575,
0.9569724798202515,
0.33325985074043274,
-0.11455244570970535,
0.2624209523200989,
-0.19319888949394226,
0.26337310671806335,
-0.43142440915107727,
0.04141676053404808,
-0.7187081575393677,
-0.2110317200422287,
-0.7376800775527954,
-0.43633148074150085,
0.7141604423522949,
-0.19414107501506805,
-0.07445075362920761,
0.27822935581207275,
-0.1314448118209839,
0.5862146019935608,
0.6121425032615662,
-0.017438018694519997,
0.5304672122001648,
0.27377966046333313,
0.06262196600437164,
0.12842002511024475,
-0.664749264717102,
-0.6002891659736633,
1.1170413494110107,
0.20558126270771027,
0.44061708450317383,
0.2751171290874481,
0.261434942483902,
0.05756693333387375,
-0.26854145526885986,
-0.49190276861190796,
0.3251033127307892,
-0.6518858075141907,
-0.6871857643127441,
-0.3982926309108734,
-0.4008922278881073,
-1.1542513370513916,
0.3002847135066986,
-0.03151656314730644,
-0.36764952540397644,
-0.11791572719812393,
-0.07886983454227448,
-0.4932084083557129,
-0.1564171016216278,
-0.6086228489875793,
0.8795492649078369,
0.02088973857462406,
-0.10104517638683319,
-0.037920061498880386,
-0.8753442168235779,
-0.07565131783485413,
-0.07330942153930664,
0.22638040781021118,
-0.07952042669057846,
0.08998098224401474,
0.6592310070991516,
-0.0043284413404762745,
0.1851470023393631,
-0.165510356426239,
-0.1434619128704071,
0.3193366229534149,
-0.14347900450229645,
0.5179365873336792,
0.3352433443069458,
-0.33522021770477295,
0.00044516808702610433,
0.21922428905963898,
-0.5253749489784241,
-0.35995739698410034,
0.3809296786785126,
-0.8543098568916321,
-0.2364109307527542,
-0.05908714234828949,
-0.5709518194198608,
-0.6811723709106445,
0.05794823169708252,
0.5127058029174805,
0.4105527102947235,
0.007709390949457884,
0.38865604996681213,
0.6971427798271179,
-0.44372421503067017,
0.4267183244228363,
0.8347980976104736,
0.0018932850798591971,
-0.3208460211753845,
0.7454874515533447,
0.38202768564224243,
0.23986826837062836,
0.46004363894462585,
-0.3062376081943512,
-0.5096322894096375,
-0.401511013507843,
-0.7825264930725098,
0.1903177946805954,
-0.6177217960357666,
-0.4070492684841156,
-0.8150973916053772,
-0.37425997853279114,
-0.40140852332115173,
-0.08821504563093185,
-0.16497859358787537,
-0.507422924041748,
-0.0024831632617861032,
-0.3827736973762512,
0.37973934412002563,
0.43247678875923157,
0.36709195375442505,
0.09563184529542923,
-0.817039430141449,
0.4970378577709198,
0.19818271696567535,
0.2822372615337372,
-0.5524147152900696,
-0.44039249420166016,
-0.2619202136993408,
0.15061736106872559,
-0.22027291357517242,
-0.7553526163101196,
0.2907269597053528,
0.21428675949573517,
0.491211861371994,
-0.07049050182104111,
0.004217556677758694,
0.31629499793052673,
-0.6591877341270447,
0.6861379742622375,
-0.15238286554813385,
-0.45435094833374023,
0.7564600110054016,
-0.4419792890548706,
0.6292787790298462,
0.8215524554252625,
0.41872498393058777,
-0.8722136616706848,
-0.5773468017578125,
-0.33751821517944336,
-0.9293254017829895,
0.7436589002609253,
0.35288918018341064,
0.29094138741493225,
-0.08196591585874557,
0.032016873359680176,
0.31882545351982117,
0.3926936686038971,
-0.683536171913147,
-0.33821672201156616,
-0.01982055976986885,
-0.4127728343009949,
-0.35525020956993103,
-0.0620252788066864,
0.05651025474071503,
0.15878963470458984,
0.8454147577285767,
-0.3502041697502136,
0.22573426365852356,
-0.008605007082223892,
-0.22367501258850098,
-0.04557870700955391,
0.29149624705314636,
0.025819016620516777,
0.37559622526168823,
0.027142100036144257,
-0.13155502080917358,
0.3561554253101349,
-0.3388439416885376,
0.35209882259368896,
0.5371716618537903,
-0.3841070234775543,
0.08098509162664413,
0.362173855304718,
0.637339174747467,
-0.163100928068161,
-0.8477922081947327,
0.5714045763015747,
-0.17376962304115295,
0.024597622454166412,
-0.5011923313140869,
-0.18581527471542358,
0.049137815833091736,
0.29858192801475525,
0.36048856377601624,
-0.09353536367416382,
0.2904885411262512,
-0.3406660258769989,
0.4230453073978424,
0.24514491856098175,
-0.4309260845184326,
-0.19016076624393463,
0.606609582901001,
0.27710211277008057,
-0.01488480530679226,
0.9637577533721924,
-0.07775883376598358,
-0.27521562576293945,
0.554279088973999,
0.3597557842731476,
0.5301206111907959,
-0.3964192867279053,
0.3360157608985901,
0.31918931007385254,
0.36837688088417053,
-0.09507963061332703,
0.6832994818687439,
0.3111415207386017,
-0.9188328981399536,
-0.36094552278518677,
-0.5864282846450806,
-0.13464951515197754,
0.0551355704665184,
-0.8038543462753296,
0.3917081654071808,
0.3155452013015747,
0.19664719700813293,
-0.2313866913318634,
0.19219966232776642,
-0.7254579663276672,
0.3719213902950287,
0.11439454555511475,
1.03799569606781,
-1.347918152809143,
0.7862660884857178,
1.0481677055358887,
-0.29545217752456665,
-0.5101195573806763,
-0.034121718257665634,
-0.18342375755310059,
-0.7518724203109741,
0.257161945104599,
0.14697057008743286,
0.12336695939302444,
0.03360595926642418,
-0.20999574661254883,
-0.848412275314331,
1.0409103631973267,
0.46056416630744934,
0.06375916302204132,
-0.20102423429489136,
0.4547816812992096,
0.6489046216011047,
-0.34596219658851624,
0.3156878650188446,
0.6737586855888367,
0.3229907751083374,
0.27322787046432495,
-0.9115229845046997,
-0.42799296975135803,
-0.603657603263855,
-0.04756869748234749,
0.1523851752281189,
-0.8044575452804565,
0.39095550775527954,
-0.0877460166811943,
0.011930185370147228,
0.1402207463979721,
0.4887941777706146,
0.42304930090904236,
-0.09809170663356781,
0.2786487936973572,
0.34764382243156433,
0.4527023732662201,
-0.26694247126579285,
0.7960453033447266,
-0.4448799192905426,
0.12760037183761597,
1.0798555612564087,
-0.26974132657051086,
1.207505226135254,
0.43466052412986755,
-0.30046045780181885,
0.14760078489780426,
0.8634015917778015,
-0.09651694446802139,
0.3346937298774719,
-0.052765507251024246,
-0.030266549438238144,
-0.39454036951065063,
-0.25519174337387085,
-0.16775721311569214,
0.7420186996459961,
0.23492585122585297,
-0.1711689978837967,
-0.12819382548332214,
0.27711865305900574,
0.1186767965555191,
0.2984711825847626,
0.01657877117395401,
0.7682631015777588,
-0.19757036864757538,
-0.905943751335144,
0.40296670794487,
-0.030091214925050735,
0.43646547198295593,
-0.5322746634483337,
0.17050307989120483,
-0.633721113204956,
-0.13143007457256317,
-0.17921964824199677,
-1.0546563863754272,
0.32171934843063354,
0.286612868309021,
-0.3110707998275757,
-0.4645804464817047,
0.1542247086763382,
-0.7974354028701782,
-0.8864311575889587,
0.35294514894485474,
0.8686926960945129,
0.22116489708423615,
-0.010552641935646534,
-0.4502263069152832,
-0.22335036098957062,
0.19773238897323608,
-0.39587336778640747,
-0.0632157251238823,
0.4760408103466034,
-0.2200772762298584,
0.7474669218063354,
0.29146870970726013,
0.07986316829919815,
-0.06221240013837814,
-0.055530667304992676,
0.63490229845047,
-0.2621912360191345,
-0.7486183047294617,
-0.3422144651412964,
0.6983770728111267,
-0.20607268810272217,
-0.28036603331565857,
0.6821308135986328,
1.024560570716858,
0.942383885383606,
-0.05685825273394585,
1.080419898033142,
0.04575178399682045,
0.9330850839614868,
-0.5413277745246887,
0.5540527105331421,
-0.5870180726051331,
0.20964302122592926,
0.15027260780334473,
-0.9257481098175049,
-0.25740039348602295,
0.4141233265399933,
-0.328554630279541,
0.0030066657345741987,
0.6940454244613647,
0.6645547747612,
-0.029518315568566322,
-0.04034653306007385,
0.3459379971027374,
0.15313005447387695,
0.38215556740760803,
0.7656632661819458,
0.5287671089172363,
-0.8666022419929504,
0.8192211389541626,
0.15387049317359924,
0.14963705837726593,
0.11973267048597336,
-0.22295644879341125,
-0.7950564622879028,
-0.780290961265564,
-0.1929897665977478,
-0.2856956720352173,
-0.0655335783958435,
0.9234610199928284,
0.47458451986312866,
-1.2560163736343384,
-0.3875035047531128,
0.28292956948280334,
-0.05772955343127251,
-0.06784304231405258,
-0.1203179657459259,
0.34825462102890015,
-0.3510279655456543,
-0.8713214993476868,
0.3593202531337738,
-0.034057386219501495,
0.03779922053217888,
0.039204441010951996,
0.07982995361089706,
-0.30999788641929626,
0.05428416654467583,
0.5368443727493286,
-0.046767931431531906,
-0.5771929025650024,
-0.19565682113170624,
0.2806215286254883,
-0.020141473039984703,
0.21284306049346924,
0.49046915769577026,
-0.7355443835258484,
0.45471134781837463,
0.3836406171321869,
0.6912976503372192,
0.33607348799705505,
0.0025462063495069742,
0.8101096153259277,
-0.8724856376647949,
0.0921739935874939,
0.3977537453174591,
0.33260437846183777,
0.37355464696884155,
-0.11148115247488022,
0.8456019759178162,
-0.12534646689891815,
-0.4502559006214142,
-0.6407981514930725,
0.3641301095485687,
-0.33699628710746765,
-0.3562833070755005,
1.5519201755523682,
-0.20481561124324799,
0.26457956433296204,
-0.23090875148773193,
-0.17135260999202728,
0.1173204779624939,
-0.30187758803367615,
0.6647472381591797,
0.9799318313598633,
-0.07539504766464233,
-0.1428767591714859,
-1.0030417442321777,
0.5057068467140198,
0.2939884662628174,
-1.1076377630233765,
0.14782094955444336,
0.5223435163497925,
0.03354087844491005,
0.10124444961547852,
0.29704150557518005,
-0.11607151478528976,
0.3299187123775482,
-0.3335711658000946,
-0.015130093321204185,
0.17577272653579712,
-0.40056493878364563,
-0.46568557620048523,
0.2534198760986328,
0.02514282986521721,
-0.154884472489357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10162v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10162v3
|
Sycophancy to Subterfuge: Investigating Reward-Tampering in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-14T16:26:20 | 2024-06-29T00:28:47 |
Carson Denison, Monte MacDiarmid, Fazl Barez, David Duvenaud, Shauna Kravec, Samuel Marks, Nicholas Schiefer, Ryan Soklaski, Alex Tamkin, Jared Kaplan, Buck Shlegeris, Samuel R. Bowman, Ethan Perez, Evan Hubinger
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In reinforcement learning, specification gaming occurs when AI systems learn
undesired behaviors that are highly rewarded due to misspecified training
goals. Specification gaming can range from simple behaviors like sycophancy to
sophisticated and pernicious behaviors like reward-tampering, where a model
directly modifies its own reward mechanism. However, these more pernicious
behaviors may be too complex to be discovered via exploration. In this paper,
we study whether Large Language Model (LLM) assistants which find easily
discovered forms of specification gaming will generalize to perform rarer and
more blatant forms, up to and including reward-tampering. We construct a
curriculum of increasingly sophisticated gameable environments and find that
training on early-curriculum environments leads to more specification gaming on
remaining environments. Strikingly, a small but non-negligible proportion of
the time, LLM assistants trained on the full curriculum generalize zero-shot to
directly rewriting their own reward function. Retraining an LLM not to game
early-curriculum environments mitigates, but does not eliminate,
reward-tampering in later environments. Moreover, adding harmlessness training
to our gameable environments does not prevent reward-tampering. These results
demonstrate that LLMs can generalize from common forms of specification gaming
to more pernicious reward tampering and that such behavior may be nontrivial to
remove.
|
[
-0.16738884150981903,
-0.9055451154708862,
0.7119747400283813,
0.027636121958494186,
0.12105832248926163,
0.01792614534497261,
-0.029713589698076248,
-0.521996021270752,
0.3123588263988495,
0.7007692456245422,
-0.6799771785736084,
-0.27969875931739807,
-0.9848948121070862,
-0.10656332969665527,
-0.317271888256073,
1.0293173789978027,
-0.017672676593065262,
-0.3019980490207672,
-0.4140848219394684,
0.1810968816280365,
-0.5946706533432007,
-0.9494070410728455,
-0.8255892992019653,
-0.567243218421936,
0.38741299510002136,
0.3313400149345398,
0.44388800859451294,
0.5019272565841675,
0.4294063150882721,
0.40506651997566223,
-0.12026770412921906,
0.1362738311290741,
-1.0590254068374634,
0.322853147983551,
-0.1363392323255539,
-0.7343841791152954,
-0.3536055088043213,
0.174780011177063,
0.1735268086194992,
0.21217334270477295,
-0.2757774889469147,
-0.21531452238559723,
0.21310099959373474,
0.3557983636856079,
-0.8490215539932251,
0.5099846720695496,
-0.34038245677948,
0.23416045308113098,
-0.0701465755701065,
-0.3146286606788635,
-0.6343011856079102,
0.13168254494667053,
-0.007168769836425781,
-0.8853568434715271,
-0.024599581956863403,
-0.14885173738002777,
0.6917585134506226,
0.2904268801212311,
-0.06979876756668091,
-0.5415210127830505,
-0.7616503238677979,
0.8383464217185974,
-0.3595553934574127,
0.0615825392305851,
0.590619683265686,
0.12027803808450699,
-0.45029857754707336,
-0.35515096783638,
-0.34855613112449646,
-0.471885085105896,
-0.08974044024944305,
0.08106108009815216,
-0.46354275941848755,
0.3775133490562439,
0.5467934012413025,
0.2537340223789215,
-0.3628852963447571,
0.20927199721336365,
-0.12025944143533707,
-0.1834639459848404,
0.7594649195671082,
0.4606552720069885,
0.417268306016922,
0.16108320653438568,
-0.25620973110198975,
-0.1999666690826416,
-0.7381244897842407,
0.4664665758609772,
0.4264783561229706,
0.08461984992027283,
-0.17636673152446747,
0.6215641498565674,
-0.018624255433678627,
0.1784229725599289,
0.20040114223957062,
-0.1284034252166748,
-0.07638577371835709,
-0.16322308778762817,
-0.17652659118175507,
0.057502683252096176,
0.6245196461677551,
-0.003235661191865802,
0.34133583307266235,
-0.3761017322540283,
-0.5508301258087158,
0.1000618189573288,
0.5120769143104553,
-0.45131319761276245,
-0.4256346821784973,
0.14492866396903992,
-0.2752256393432617,
-0.5719509720802307,
0.08489925414323807,
-0.4713200032711029,
-0.6296405792236328,
-0.07990924268960953,
0.6524296402931213,
-0.40307748317718506,
0.01453989278525114,
0.08192643523216248,
-0.2853736877441406,
0.17518942058086395,
0.24880467355251312,
-1.0921099185943604,
0.2252044677734375,
1.0550487041473389,
0.7016405463218689,
-0.33778199553489685,
-0.4662931263446808,
-0.702271580696106,
0.2056034952402115,
-0.4833216071128845,
0.6955674290657043,
-0.677588701248169,
-0.7221049666404724,
0.0023164593148976564,
0.23753726482391357,
0.2450706660747528,
-0.8228407502174377,
0.15822811424732208,
-0.34457895159721375,
0.08444922417402267,
-0.1308925300836563,
-0.43211784958839417,
0.20697660744190216,
0.5488425493240356,
-0.6124135851860046,
0.6119203567504883,
-0.08988294750452042,
-0.166324645280838,
0.3748880624771118,
-0.5301089286804199,
-0.4964545667171478,
0.09580009430646896,
-0.13349974155426025,
-0.37111184000968933,
0.2334994673728943,
-0.1271362453699112,
0.12024229019880295,
-0.030294204130768776,
0.2552454173564911,
-0.28956592082977295,
-0.8662194013595581,
0.2413833737373352,
-0.3972165286540985,
0.6121982336044312,
-0.08449113368988037,
-0.4656514823436737,
-0.04857650399208069,
-0.15596817433834076,
-0.1440420001745224,
0.0774129256606102,
-0.24859429895877838,
-0.5629730820655823,
-0.027669139206409454,
-0.6306999325752258,
0.2628423869609833,
0.4579010009765625,
-0.37627342343330383,
0.3991614580154419,
-0.34646227955818176,
0.10771075636148453,
1.013727068901062,
0.08113379776477814,
0.4948329031467438,
-0.674105703830719,
0.7991956472396851,
0.08442317694425583,
0.3206464946269989,
-0.18712419271469116,
-0.33654215931892395,
-0.7565038204193115,
-0.4285205602645874,
-0.0463981106877327,
0.682331383228302,
-0.7736071944236755,
0.25030675530433655,
0.033288754522800446,
-0.33498087525367737,
-0.2846461236476898,
-0.22795286774635315,
0.6942629218101501,
-0.061275094747543335,
0.370161235332489,
-0.3888561725616455,
-0.5178536176681519,
-0.770779013633728,
-0.19053539633750916,
-0.11077728867530823,
-0.033659983426332474,
0.44268798828125,
0.5016448497772217,
-0.13252222537994385,
0.3645859658718109,
-0.36819106340408325,
-0.4130827486515045,
-0.19592814147472382,
0.36576515436172485,
-0.1043098121881485,
0.5550069212913513,
0.16348856687545776,
-0.3214298188686371,
0.06560903042554855,
-0.29890677332878113,
-0.772750973701477,
-0.12917394936084747,
-0.23480768501758575,
0.08799661695957184,
0.24511386454105377,
0.7258464097976685,
-0.44559285044670105,
0.3318400979042053,
0.5321784019470215,
-0.26951032876968384,
0.5195950865745544,
-0.339451402425766,
0.15969032049179077,
-0.5670859813690186,
-0.029330313205718994,
-0.3554192781448364,
-0.03332873433828354,
-0.3707559406757355,
0.534099817276001,
-0.382711261510849,
0.1301223337650299,
-0.18730230629444122,
0.3937542736530304,
-0.3477548658847809,
0.04951901733875275,
-0.44504523277282715,
0.004613319877535105,
-0.20117954909801483,
0.4563148319721222,
0.17319618165493011,
0.7284602522850037,
0.478576123714447,
-0.6822054386138916,
0.4133587181568146,
-0.05997876077890396,
-0.058214861899614334,
0.4591435492038727,
-0.6745343208312988,
0.07037462294101715,
-0.03025590442121029,
0.31908294558525085,
-0.8512663245201111,
0.06174416467547417,
0.1044522374868393,
-0.4507366120815277,
0.14273855090141296,
-0.11629552394151688,
-0.29857370257377625,
0.08391977101564407,
-0.33784785866737366,
0.2739662826061249,
0.4938567280769348,
-0.38400763273239136,
0.32102102041244507,
0.6565366983413696,
-0.06474572420120239,
-0.8841871619224548,
-0.8485302925109863,
-0.11483297497034073,
-0.11538227647542953,
-0.1384759247303009,
0.30511191487312317,
-0.07700221985578537,
-0.14795395731925964,
-0.2687172591686249,
-0.2323661744594574,
0.1040799543261528,
0.3176349699497223,
0.5146069526672363,
0.34190255403518677,
-0.07886186987161636,
0.008737251162528992,
-0.10081125795841217,
-0.17568114399909973,
0.4498637616634369,
-0.04715938866138458,
0.7880561947822571,
0.14453119039535522,
-0.32069024443626404,
0.0436454676091671,
0.5074017643928528,
0.19522511959075928,
0.02439740113914013,
0.5775243043899536,
0.12284060567617416,
-0.23300479352474213,
-0.27579808235168457,
-0.28637757897377014,
-0.3604607582092285,
-0.5194429755210876,
0.6526287794113159,
-0.462843656539917,
-1.1260367631912231,
0.3733246624469757,
-0.0038159112446010113,
0.1490592360496521,
0.18965625762939453,
0.26883047819137573,
0.031024150550365448,
1.1904728412628174,
0.8597336411476135,
0.06721857190132141,
0.4644858241081238,
-0.25280889868736267,
0.030382636934518814,
-0.4559680223464966,
-0.6106501817703247,
-0.36844685673713684,
-0.3883638381958008,
-0.9920682311058044,
-0.36703336238861084,
0.19010905921459198,
-0.2759331464767456,
-0.41472020745277405,
0.1545611470937729,
-0.20941880345344543,
1.081526517868042,
0.5538830161094666,
0.04925067722797394,
0.2299662083387375,
-0.09869649261236191,
-0.1746947169303894,
-0.09452372044324875,
-0.5652490258216858,
-0.21438312530517578,
0.9141404628753662,
0.245345801115036,
0.9286853075027466,
0.38230323791503906,
1.262886643409729,
0.26347601413726807,
0.1527252197265625,
-0.7943122982978821,
0.4779723286628723,
-0.45048776268959045,
-0.30080726742744446,
-0.48758891224861145,
-0.4244632124900818,
-1.1302554607391357,
-0.18346233665943146,
-0.39124029874801636,
-0.7761779427528381,
0.2513115108013153,
0.09768561273813248,
-0.36058902740478516,
0.19562318921089172,
-0.4430754780769348,
0.827738881111145,
-0.026244843378663063,
-0.5799659490585327,
-0.2611145079135895,
-0.3231295049190521,
0.6594841480255127,
0.148329958319664,
0.15134559571743011,
0.3535797595977783,
-0.028736600652337074,
0.5337761640548706,
-0.03319023922085762,
0.7390745282173157,
0.03599158301949501,
-0.4348682165145874,
-0.1268520951271057,
0.8353410959243774,
0.64583420753479,
0.11023879051208496,
0.412737637758255,
-0.04288238286972046,
0.13340602815151215,
-0.5140299797058105,
-0.5371375679969788,
0.789578378200531,
-1.0171257257461548,
-0.8957253098487854,
-0.8105351328849792,
-0.6580270528793335,
-0.39313727617263794,
-0.08170522749423981,
0.31653445959091187,
-0.03851233422756195,
-0.38153761625289917,
0.08408010005950928,
1.3415226936340332,
-0.3734796941280365,
0.10921593010425568,
0.4746142625808716,
-0.17440424859523773,
0.1884574443101883,
1.138885259628296,
-0.24230004847049713,
0.3566577136516571,
0.5726407170295715,
0.0007550654117949307,
-0.06461633741855621,
-0.19837608933448792,
0.15545421838760376,
0.07399694621562958,
-0.33694955706596375,
-0.06051018089056015,
-0.2787485420703888,
-0.3624017536640167,
-0.48426294326782227,
-0.32978126406669617,
-0.25265347957611084,
-0.15431608259677887,
-0.09652688354253769,
-0.024372152984142303,
-0.09113897383213043,
0.9941801428794861,
-0.2169734537601471,
0.44123002886772156,
-0.5852343440055847,
0.07365669310092926,
0.5680235624313354,
0.2724821865558624,
-0.0646049901843071,
-0.7268999218940735,
-0.01232835091650486,
0.1684141904115677,
-0.3410722017288208,
-0.6572675108909607,
0.34133660793304443,
-0.27096372842788696,
0.682256281375885,
0.4503715932369232,
-0.20585677027702332,
0.7715327143669128,
-0.25379112362861633,
0.8980526328086853,
0.04564223438501358,
-0.8405882120132446,
0.14473982155323029,
-0.16953469812870026,
0.3938196003437042,
0.2652845084667206,
0.36692580580711365,
-0.7986043691635132,
-0.6191161870956421,
-1.0352158546447754,
-0.8405959010124207,
1.0689153671264648,
-0.31396931409835815,
0.3056131601333618,
-0.010689115151762962,
0.2238229513168335,
0.13614526391029358,
0.1653399020433426,
-0.8310645818710327,
-0.18348568677902222,
0.052525345236063004,
0.2470819354057312,
-0.479550838470459,
-0.39877310395240784,
-0.3736346662044525,
0.20821791887283325,
0.7271122932434082,
0.30164992809295654,
0.3934355676174164,
-0.21456041932106018,
-0.17250552773475647,
-0.16349034011363983,
0.35670867562294006,
0.6620453596115112,
0.1300181746482849,
0.0436437763273716,
0.2972676753997803,
-0.02216833457350731,
-0.48463231325149536,
0.26534712314605713,
-0.1162816733121872,
-0.057080723345279694,
-0.4007972478866577,
0.4949883222579956,
0.6326759457588196,
0.22676776349544525,
-0.9973374009132385,
0.653939425945282,
0.01803656853735447,
-0.2522889971733093,
-0.44529974460601807,
0.5912508368492126,
-0.09576977044343948,
0.3153403699398041,
-0.08273714035749435,
-0.22284150123596191,
0.28540903329849243,
-1.0084922313690186,
0.3349136710166931,
0.6391108632087708,
-0.34364190697669983,
-0.036335889250040054,
0.3762407600879669,
-0.15963657200336456,
-0.2832547128200531,
0.6929524540901184,
-0.4155409038066864,
-0.323273628950119,
0.6835905313491821,
0.725464940071106,
0.7145917415618896,
-0.31095460057258606,
0.5281548500061035,
0.3120626211166382,
0.42598673701286316,
-0.19704172015190125,
0.12626592814922333,
-0.010979252867400646,
-0.520801842212677,
-0.3782038986682892,
-0.30139052867889404,
-0.41423141956329346,
0.487550288438797,
-0.4522571861743927,
0.14806778728961945,
-0.6033163666725159,
0.19030871987342834,
-0.19190281629562378,
-0.11811913549900055,
-0.33015891909599304,
-0.16379213333129883,
0.3626593351364136,
0.4265148639678955,
-0.9396495223045349,
0.42391595244407654,
0.5348485112190247,
-0.5376595854759216,
-0.8121812343597412,
0.03600418567657471,
0.10756764560937881,
-0.8937408924102783,
0.6322843432426453,
-0.1375330686569214,
-0.17234712839126587,
-0.2806739807128906,
-0.8177742958068848,
-0.719674289226532,
1.0151255130767822,
0.2480068802833557,
-0.5474859476089478,
-0.4238387942314148,
0.32407569885253906,
0.6279173493385315,
-0.2958356738090515,
0.3893958330154419,
0.6091390252113342,
0.19904355704784393,
0.23708410561084747,
-0.7675023674964905,
0.08493032306432724,
-0.05442221090197563,
-0.126063734292984,
0.3095262348651886,
-0.6337963342666626,
1.090076208114624,
-0.29489219188690186,
-0.06847866624593735,
0.1627565622329712,
0.19062477350234985,
0.7092955112457275,
0.23035705089569092,
0.33936214447021484,
0.5738010406494141,
0.48078829050064087,
-0.19110287725925446,
0.8131230473518372,
0.20271584391593933,
0.19687354564666748,
0.9853545427322388,
-0.1610025018453598,
0.6719526648521423,
0.6017960906028748,
-0.05257657542824745,
0.6374058723449707,
0.4842575192451477,
0.16715136170387268,
0.486897349357605,
0.4822552800178528,
-0.12704889476299286,
-0.5073021054267883,
-0.09474467486143112,
-0.1669650673866272,
0.6690497994422913,
0.4550904929637909,
-0.24936246871948242,
-0.2739134728908539,
-0.07913607358932495,
0.177043154835701,
0.06521259248256683,
-0.33534127473831177,
0.9802113175392151,
-0.11843268573284149,
-0.9434872269630432,
0.36797767877578735,
-0.03525485098361969,
0.9454387426376343,
-0.7634456753730774,
-0.3258102536201477,
-0.6003315448760986,
0.19335947930812836,
-0.030807482078671455,
-0.6497859358787537,
-0.03392171487212181,
-0.13104376196861267,
0.12782515585422516,
-0.1721106767654419,
0.33004826307296753,
-0.4323115050792694,
0.18830636143684387,
0.1372835785150528,
0.5805495381355286,
0.2816146910190582,
0.02426794543862343,
-0.5063359141349792,
-0.19625946879386902,
-0.1518453061580658,
0.0014570211060345173,
0.8450469970703125,
0.6524991989135742,
-0.18826347589492798,
0.5947611927986145,
0.6187365651130676,
0.25124984979629517,
-0.10308868438005447,
-0.32440853118896484,
0.569451093673706,
-0.442584365606308,
-0.7845823168754578,
-0.8724827766418457,
0.09084783494472504,
-0.00900588184595108,
-0.23967067897319794,
0.48945581912994385,
0.6473811268806458,
0.9882948398590088,
-0.1807180643081665,
0.5763055682182312,
0.03895171359181404,
-0.10133004933595657,
-0.543828010559082,
0.41666117310523987,
-0.5294360518455505,
0.38545170426368713,
-0.23765090107917786,
-0.5799247026443481,
0.09173596650362015,
0.5800561904907227,
-0.38713616132736206,
0.11687938123941422,
0.6641216278076172,
0.7974251508712769,
-0.06070989742875099,
-0.010304002091288567,
0.6125451326370239,
0.21427977085113525,
0.30044496059417725,
1.0354598760604858,
0.9550061225891113,
0.05449555441737175,
0.5295997858047485,
-0.17675022780895233,
-0.45170414447784424,
-0.17867383360862732,
-0.6524261832237244,
-0.5701127648353577,
-0.5649721026420593,
0.0215939711779356,
-0.539020836353302,
0.4558616578578949,
0.7426803708076477,
0.2922241985797882,
-0.7062981724739075,
-0.5128343105316162,
-0.19089703261852264,
0.18437498807907104,
-0.526786208152771,
-0.29327553510665894,
-0.03888297080993652,
-0.4575378894805908,
-0.8556168675422668,
0.15035061538219452,
0.17912547290325165,
0.16100719571113586,
-0.5518437623977661,
-0.1220073476433754,
-0.05015530064702034,
0.3517990708351135,
0.5816688537597656,
0.6170534491539001,
-0.5840208530426025,
-0.20477139949798584,
0.30846816301345825,
-0.23508550226688385,
-0.268290638923645,
1.004129409790039,
-0.8098120093345642,
0.3457680940628052,
0.32147216796875,
0.6023368835449219,
0.29241833090782166,
-0.26288557052612305,
0.47697898745536804,
-0.8452086448669434,
0.22958825528621674,
0.34533700346946716,
0.18743467330932617,
-0.23665636777877808,
-0.539616584777832,
0.2035026103258133,
0.24033989012241364,
-0.5846672654151917,
-0.8090977668762207,
0.40469858050346375,
-0.6273385286331177,
-0.37193483114242554,
1.1176079511642456,
-0.402567982673645,
-0.30390143394470215,
0.08502271771430969,
-0.14815618097782135,
0.07604731619358063,
-0.38264620304107666,
1.4183624982833862,
1.0576153993606567,
-0.35313576459884644,
-0.04501323029398918,
-0.36637258529663086,
0.7519214153289795,
0.47304925322532654,
-0.761609673500061,
0.2634497284889221,
0.6327671408653259,
0.1702866554260254,
0.24715209007263184,
0.5767830014228821,
-0.11786282807588577,
0.666983962059021,
0.11969916522502899,
-0.01187169924378395,
-0.3063015341758728,
-0.42094874382019043,
-0.44674891233444214,
0.04753582179546356,
0.16176800429821014,
-0.06930429488420486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10149v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10149v1
|
BABILong: Testing the Limits of LLMs with Long Context Reasoning-in-a-Haystack
| 2024-06-14T16:00:29 | 2024-06-14T16:00:29 |
Yuri Kuratov, Aydar Bulatov, Petr Anokhin, Ivan Rodkin, Dmitry Sorokin, Artyom Sorokin, Mikhail Burtsev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, the input context sizes of large language models (LLMs) have
increased dramatically. However, existing evaluation methods have not kept
pace, failing to comprehensively assess the efficiency of models in handling
long contexts. To bridge this gap, we introduce the BABILong benchmark,
designed to test language models' ability to reason across facts distributed in
extremely long documents. BABILong includes a diverse set of 20 reasoning
tasks, including fact chaining, simple induction, deduction, counting, and
handling lists/sets. These tasks are challenging on their own, and even more
demanding when the required facts are scattered across long natural text. Our
evaluations show that popular LLMs effectively utilize only 10-20\% of the
context and their performance declines sharply with increased reasoning
complexity. Among alternatives to in-context reasoning, Retrieval-Augmented
Generation methods achieve a modest 60\% accuracy on single-fact question
answering, independent of context length. Among context extension methods, the
highest performance is demonstrated by recurrent memory transformers, enabling
the processing of lengths up to 11 million tokens. The BABILong benchmark is
extendable to any length to support the evaluation of new upcoming models with
increased capabilities, and we provide splits up to 1 million token lengths.
|
[
-0.4211731553077698,
-1.0392361879348755,
0.7653611898422241,
0.5309873223304749,
-0.5683603882789612,
-0.1373460292816162,
-0.45392128825187683,
-0.3354997932910919,
-0.25177285075187683,
0.6887416243553162,
-0.34002232551574707,
-0.26557695865631104,
-0.5366308689117432,
0.36649104952812195,
-0.45923423767089844,
0.9186922311782837,
-0.1072804406285286,
-0.4700377881526947,
-0.38854706287384033,
-0.44129982590675354,
-0.5084460377693176,
-0.4210810363292694,
-0.40000274777412415,
-0.17911742627620697,
0.44399261474609375,
0.44545435905456543,
0.48909634351730347,
0.3364913761615753,
0.3962792456150055,
0.1935974359512329,
-0.3459329307079315,
0.5335441827774048,
-0.44074830412864685,
0.19330258667469025,
-0.37444329261779785,
-0.38453832268714905,
-0.3495718836784363,
0.022763777524232864,
0.8649529218673706,
0.8757790327072144,
-0.12329816818237305,
0.26219797134399414,
-0.2369363158941269,
0.7589132785797119,
-0.683997392654419,
-0.014934447593986988,
-0.5550938844680786,
-0.26158416271209717,
-0.19590646028518677,
-0.04513469338417053,
-0.6293196082115173,
-0.48477035760879517,
0.08989968150854111,
-0.11925141513347626,
-0.036950454115867615,
0.13821843266487122,
0.7103368043899536,
0.2745952904224396,
-1.0442637205123901,
-0.30900314450263977,
-0.4610205888748169,
0.8546707034111023,
-0.7351208925247192,
0.3602136969566345,
0.455930233001709,
0.42356693744659424,
-0.4647323787212372,
-0.7632306218147278,
-0.7198166847229004,
-0.4833344519138336,
-0.18071429431438446,
0.07668530941009521,
-0.12682092189788818,
-0.18689022958278656,
0.7802941799163818,
0.2642820477485657,
-0.6695410013198853,
-0.20203708112239838,
-0.4880768358707428,
0.1829407811164856,
0.765813946723938,
-0.08159243315458298,
0.06435346603393555,
-0.4518340528011322,
-0.6473183631896973,
0.09731762111186981,
-0.859113872051239,
0.04259378835558891,
-0.015345253981649876,
0.06790280342102051,
-0.06636881828308105,
0.6230868101119995,
-0.32639047503471375,
0.8147702813148499,
-0.2832767069339752,
-0.1688244789838791,
0.03256721794605255,
-0.4078461527824402,
-0.39497998356819153,
0.15170614421367645,
0.6143935918807983,
0.46127164363861084,
0.0037127432879060507,
0.013328352011740208,
-0.0866447389125824,
-0.11629786342382431,
-0.03891332820057869,
-1.190508484840393,
0.08840391784906387,
0.23440062999725342,
-0.38640275597572327,
0.17431822419166565,
-0.1959761381149292,
-0.7303527593612671,
-0.34965160489082336,
0.048459917306900024,
0.2771756052970886,
-0.6378976106643677,
-0.13595762848854065,
0.2496475875377655,
-0.0784481093287468,
0.16467750072479248,
0.19376826286315918,
-0.8029118180274963,
0.23820191621780396,
0.7410991191864014,
1.0483452081680298,
-0.03704610839486122,
-0.339498907327652,
-0.946433961391449,
0.01612698845565319,
-0.56977778673172,
0.8870115876197815,
-0.3441227078437805,
-0.4302710294723511,
-0.3118862509727478,
0.16535848379135132,
-0.09609368443489075,
-0.6544522047042847,
0.6569349765777588,
-0.4122002422809601,
-0.026676936075091362,
-0.4194961190223694,
-0.7133333086967468,
-0.36146873235702515,
0.19001169502735138,
-0.574566662311554,
1.0817809104919434,
0.43749985098838806,
-0.5318572521209717,
0.4123392105102539,
-0.6336548924446106,
-0.9578892588615417,
-0.029710203409194946,
-0.07723253220319748,
-0.25664055347442627,
0.3206097483634949,
0.16459639370441437,
0.5439989566802979,
-0.749991774559021,
0.4761209785938263,
-0.35943448543548584,
-0.7559869289398193,
0.5743753910064697,
-0.6354760527610779,
1.117032527923584,
0.22316569089889526,
-0.6102923154830933,
-0.05247296020388603,
-0.7467737197875977,
-0.22356301546096802,
-0.006002732552587986,
-0.4391612112522125,
-0.2906194031238556,
0.0932040736079216,
-0.30176568031311035,
0.042598601430654526,
0.1348375678062439,
-0.48407894372940063,
0.20472654700279236,
-0.13998380303382874,
0.577212393283844,
0.5702100992202759,
-0.19873720407485962,
-0.0014347978867590427,
-0.4293343424797058,
0.3547014892101288,
-0.08565028756856918,
0.06130317226052284,
-0.41187235713005066,
-0.18838182091712952,
-0.6879437565803528,
-0.5881187319755554,
0.37885162234306335,
0.315960556268692,
-0.34940946102142334,
0.6122210025787354,
-0.35048043727874756,
-0.4460538625717163,
-0.3399488627910614,
0.13754303753376007,
0.1206645518541336,
0.5559791326522827,
0.4701654016971588,
-0.48770564794540405,
-0.32143694162368774,
-0.8712306618690491,
-0.1562679409980774,
-0.1671777069568634,
0.010505407117307186,
0.3572649359703064,
0.6097152233123779,
-0.5270406007766724,
0.9008749127388,
-0.25803184509277344,
0.21958376467227936,
-0.3149040937423706,
0.221119686961174,
0.48693376779556274,
0.16673582792282104,
0.47759193181991577,
-0.7621534466743469,
-0.25206032395362854,
0.050230320543050766,
-0.7922993898391724,
-0.22075070440769196,
-0.08637415617704391,
0.055026110261678696,
0.6095024943351746,
0.46636566519737244,
-1.0560518503189087,
0.5284938812255859,
0.5866210460662842,
-0.22123946249485016,
0.8177292346954346,
-0.06625285744667053,
0.11982991546392441,
-0.7439419031143188,
0.28347957134246826,
-0.2360491007566452,
-0.36191606521606445,
-0.25637051463127136,
0.15360812842845917,
0.3058943748474121,
-0.0835321694612503,
-0.13993486762046814,
0.7437204122543335,
-0.5461854934692383,
-0.24645990133285522,
-0.4447016716003418,
0.2969112694263458,
0.1215553805232048,
0.10136734694242477,
-0.12019716948270798,
0.867321789264679,
0.5091987252235413,
-0.6445423364639282,
0.8306555151939392,
-0.03015362098813057,
-1.0712966918945312,
0.5571431517601013,
-0.5649869441986084,
0.021924475207924843,
0.03391677141189575,
0.7637291550636292,
-1.0652939081192017,
-0.2689988911151886,
-0.266308069229126,
-0.10393762588500977,
-0.05816805362701416,
-0.22569994628429413,
-0.7535603642463684,
-0.3478325605392456,
-0.06510903686285019,
0.6087256073951721,
0.5647860765457153,
-0.8976472020149231,
0.5816472768783569,
0.041403304785490036,
-0.20144745707511902,
-0.7347733974456787,
-0.6095092296600342,
0.2787988483905792,
-0.4897208511829376,
-0.6194905638694763,
0.11834990233182907,
-0.2622058689594269,
-0.32712122797966003,
-0.058630626648664474,
-0.27929696440696716,
0.3017505407333374,
0.2812098264694214,
0.12995558977127075,
0.07620403170585632,
-0.21840262413024902,
0.19713194668293,
0.2833532691001892,
0.07453702390193939,
0.10984264314174652,
-0.04683481156826019,
0.49996107816696167,
-0.3490721881389618,
-0.18386363983154297,
0.06229992210865021,
0.2776194214820862,
0.5682061314582825,
-0.3757886290550232,
0.6992343068122864,
0.4040888845920563,
-0.26820826530456543,
-0.5802614688873291,
-0.6664916276931763,
0.1667814999818802,
-0.42968347668647766,
0.3903432786464691,
-0.5565309524536133,
-0.9232674837112427,
0.4571795165538788,
-0.5041300058364868,
-0.02838248386979103,
0.1648099720478058,
0.5415480136871338,
0.22555211186408997,
0.7805588245391846,
0.2908765971660614,
-0.10193678736686707,
-0.08410084247589111,
-0.08903012424707413,
0.4057769179344177,
-0.8140243887901306,
0.060552097856998444,
-0.07693947106599808,
0.09872514009475708,
-0.6578522324562073,
-0.7064460515975952,
0.2984124720096588,
0.44840681552886963,
-0.2563396096229553,
0.4798356294631958,
-0.09678643196821213,
0.5069942474365234,
0.40288594365119934,
0.018687669187784195,
0.2947905659675598,
-0.2957670986652374,
-0.024784976616501808,
0.49599364399909973,
-0.5891936421394348,
-0.4466397762298584,
0.9916501641273499,
0.26991406083106995,
0.4171837568283081,
0.3374369144439697,
0.353037565946579,
0.0824529230594635,
0.5499356985092163,
-0.8477948307991028,
0.8625804781913757,
-0.09020930528640747,
-0.9058411121368408,
-0.4569072723388672,
-0.6856610178947449,
-0.8019749522209167,
0.258815735578537,
0.25192713737487793,
-0.6314384937286377,
-0.014699800871312618,
-0.2083817422389984,
-0.3218050003051758,
0.21513432264328003,
-0.48252353072166443,
0.8403579592704773,
-0.49221670627593994,
-0.42206165194511414,
-0.373490571975708,
-0.7002171874046326,
0.6797472834587097,
-0.2154209017753601,
0.23617899417877197,
-0.3658357560634613,
0.15675321221351624,
0.39872825145721436,
-0.35454756021499634,
0.49788352847099304,
0.16999423503875732,
-0.089090995490551,
0.46652716398239136,
0.17567400634288788,
0.36361071467399597,
0.2101086676120758,
-0.3569370210170746,
0.07010328024625778,
0.1404373049736023,
-0.6521357893943787,
-0.6965543031692505,
0.6098499298095703,
-0.1911693662405014,
-0.7539100050926208,
-0.5211735963821411,
-0.6176209449768066,
-0.22455230355262756,
0.258505642414093,
0.09439366310834885,
0.5314112305641174,
-0.1716884970664978,
0.5779999494552612,
0.47852078080177307,
-0.3328002691268921,
0.23247113823890686,
0.4155721366405487,
-0.4174237549304962,
-0.2148454636335373,
0.7323079109191895,
0.12250539660453796,
0.2121940404176712,
0.22609283030033112,
0.37372222542762756,
-0.3914449214935303,
-0.3859006464481354,
-0.6003766059875488,
0.2814927399158478,
-0.7463411688804626,
-0.10945981740951538,
-0.33215564489364624,
-0.18630698323249817,
-0.3978695273399353,
0.03468778356909752,
-0.14412793517112732,
-0.26322466135025024,
0.2298833727836609,
-0.21296827495098114,
0.289691686630249,
0.5531826615333557,
-0.20971821248531342,
0.11097509413957596,
-0.5766882300376892,
0.2847253680229187,
0.5086112022399902,
0.3926534652709961,
0.028774581849575043,
-0.6439292430877686,
-0.2919630706310272,
-0.1949380785226822,
-0.1486106663942337,
-0.7540183663368225,
0.086980901658535,
-0.062395159155130386,
0.3525083363056183,
0.4352633059024811,
0.21666765213012695,
0.6920138597488403,
-0.5578999519348145,
0.6734493374824524,
0.08252960443496704,
-0.9551687836647034,
0.41914257407188416,
-0.32645267248153687,
0.21343481540679932,
0.5111355185508728,
0.49658143520355225,
-0.6078746318817139,
-0.036358848214149475,
-0.46406620740890503,
-0.8877235651016235,
0.4241687059402466,
0.11580011993646622,
0.09640906006097794,
-0.3831561803817749,
0.3822987675666809,
0.32108786702156067,
0.08641404658555984,
-0.5354867577552795,
-0.025861075147986412,
-0.18656447529792786,
0.06543385237455368,
-0.34415188431739807,
-0.4002225995063782,
-0.30986976623535156,
-0.28226223587989807,
0.5292144417762756,
-0.24069546163082123,
0.009763021022081375,
0.2095997929573059,
-0.23964139819145203,
0.026308249682188034,
0.32204800844192505,
0.7859230637550354,
1.1099179983139038,
-0.49042823910713196,
0.4358452260494232,
0.4661872386932373,
0.026636870577931404,
0.0300375297665596,
0.47862353920936584,
0.011023452505469322,
0.04815223813056946,
0.4690350890159607,
0.8741644620895386,
0.06612194329500198,
-1.2202486991882324,
0.5129669308662415,
-0.0429677739739418,
-0.038910310715436935,
-0.33293041586875916,
0.13177785277366638,
0.2976677715778351,
0.2450776994228363,
0.5003823041915894,
-0.42509686946868896,
0.05454476922750473,
-1.1369094848632812,
0.2650962769985199,
0.31333649158477783,
0.0028182670939713717,
-0.1467016041278839,
0.309780478477478,
0.11646699160337448,
-0.11951718479394913,
0.6895862817764282,
-0.38877177238464355,
-0.5618024468421936,
0.7064133286476135,
0.6474487781524658,
0.5030798316001892,
-0.042994704097509384,
0.061576273292303085,
0.481529176235199,
0.2870747447013855,
-0.28738874197006226,
-0.029542051255702972,
-0.3678538203239441,
-0.5302316546440125,
-0.5988774299621582,
-0.5706556439399719,
-0.5694666504859924,
0.4907117784023285,
-0.5280660390853882,
0.1476646065711975,
-0.5061160326004028,
-0.1743886023759842,
-0.15578442811965942,
0.37575262784957886,
-0.30676692724227905,
0.4747144877910614,
-0.15130315721035004,
1.1089214086532593,
-0.5127966403961182,
0.5900792479515076,
0.5197047591209412,
-0.22748184204101562,
-0.4249395430088043,
0.12113254517316818,
-0.200296089053154,
-0.54180508852005,
0.7818905115127563,
0.7050698399543762,
-0.16949337720870972,
-0.3795683681964874,
-0.5788260102272034,
-0.5846509337425232,
1.0319218635559082,
0.3875082731246948,
-0.6813170313835144,
0.3315839171409607,
0.016930609941482544,
0.46640080213546753,
-0.3006665110588074,
0.3207123279571533,
0.8723650574684143,
0.5133211016654968,
-0.12967048585414886,
-0.9043329358100891,
0.4498409628868103,
-0.13545876741409302,
-0.30171823501586914,
0.07602613419294357,
-1.0722739696502686,
0.6979608535766602,
-0.24881763756275177,
-0.28804296255111694,
0.32843130826950073,
0.7518653869628906,
0.7913747429847717,
0.5559254288673401,
0.8363058567047119,
0.49381718039512634,
0.8881838321685791,
0.13032901287078857,
1.1550283432006836,
-0.1042855978012085,
0.2724795341491699,
1.0318801403045654,
-0.7034670114517212,
0.7824264764785767,
0.20296309888362885,
-0.14175191521644592,
0.8354364633560181,
0.6391562223434448,
0.08472778648138046,
0.2567233145236969,
0.5045044422149658,
-0.5940832495689392,
-0.3815650939941406,
-0.2458159625530243,
-0.20056693255901337,
0.4807337522506714,
0.318189799785614,
0.04337134212255478,
0.04266859218478203,
-0.1497058868408203,
0.08538015931844711,
0.08347403258085251,
0.06954671442508698,
0.20560288429260254,
0.37998461723327637,
-0.9697390794754028,
0.7142837047576904,
0.14079755544662476,
0.4645857810974121,
-0.41811466217041016,
0.07912372797727585,
-0.6208500266075134,
0.108388252556324,
0.08196134120225906,
-0.6073951721191406,
0.12005744129419327,
0.12924398481845856,
-0.007216528989374638,
0.18059556186199188,
0.7218697667121887,
-0.34206461906433105,
-0.498358815908432,
0.5242652893066406,
0.1903425008058548,
0.38537561893463135,
0.04495522007346153,
-0.42194440960884094,
0.03314444422721863,
-0.378582626581192,
-0.4325542449951172,
0.2844654619693756,
0.8255563378334045,
-0.25171777606010437,
0.7671112418174744,
0.6198441982269287,
0.1708451509475708,
-0.1221754252910614,
0.055658433586359024,
0.7449430823326111,
-0.8788363933563232,
-0.24298711121082306,
-0.8804207444190979,
0.10864407569169998,
-0.33541053533554077,
-0.3502756655216217,
0.7727431654930115,
0.8774001598358154,
0.8601771593093872,
0.33270251750946045,
0.7915305495262146,
-0.04765665531158447,
0.5926589965820312,
-0.5386060476303101,
0.48336538672447205,
-0.7639887928962708,
0.15247419476509094,
0.024647830054163933,
-0.7725127339363098,
-0.053016297519207,
0.710893452167511,
-0.35937049984931946,
0.1035657450556755,
0.9382771849632263,
0.5877641439437866,
-0.2900405824184418,
-0.0024992625694721937,
0.32154303789138794,
0.29854702949523926,
0.22045579552650452,
0.6396269202232361,
1.1415290832519531,
-0.3826473355293274,
0.4977274239063263,
-0.22996072471141815,
-0.38926297426223755,
-0.39937543869018555,
-1.1207331418991089,
-1.2634928226470947,
-0.37689483165740967,
-0.07427460700273514,
-0.36576902866363525,
0.14569127559661865,
0.7376437783241272,
0.7135454416275024,
-0.5461165904998779,
-0.4836788475513458,
-0.011943668127059937,
0.22126388549804688,
-0.3335072994232178,
-0.2392873764038086,
0.6121289134025574,
-0.14464467763900757,
-0.5426666736602783,
0.7980862855911255,
0.4117458164691925,
-0.34757688641548157,
-0.07025361061096191,
0.012734425254166126,
-0.2396777868270874,
0.42033156752586365,
0.9935472011566162,
0.26879799365997314,
-0.5646710395812988,
-0.46179571747779846,
-0.08414029330015182,
0.04108413681387901,
-0.3218602240085602,
0.7902849316596985,
-0.6208930015563965,
0.364569753408432,
0.5368119478225708,
0.6884990930557251,
0.7277598977088928,
0.29004645347595215,
0.48581773042678833,
-0.4976341128349304,
0.12902617454528809,
0.016199404373764992,
0.4487496018409729,
0.39777103066444397,
-0.030674945563077927,
0.7720516920089722,
0.2887081205844879,
-0.7133972644805908,
-1.3088246583938599,
0.2857496738433838,
-1.1194651126861572,
-0.717705249786377,
1.2340983152389526,
-0.3047981262207031,
-0.23250426352024078,
0.036478687077760696,
-0.001190260169096291,
0.3581739366054535,
-0.07586304098367691,
0.9931692481040955,
0.7839544415473938,
-0.08255069702863693,
-0.23247841000556946,
-0.6595519185066223,
0.33568376302719116,
0.7956864833831787,
-0.7470651268959045,
0.4605243504047394,
0.42444559931755066,
0.3454011380672455,
0.06902403384447098,
0.7477330565452576,
0.031293462961912155,
0.5588333010673523,
-0.1533932238817215,
-0.35313093662261963,
0.067799873650074,
-0.5061662197113037,
-0.12547945976257324,
-0.046183038502931595,
-0.0461835078895092,
0.2624664008617401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10133v1
|
Evaluation of Large Language Models: STEM education and Gender Stereotypes
| 2024-06-14T15:42:42 | 2024-06-14T15:42:42 |
Smilla Due, Sneha Das, Marianne Andersen, Berta Plandolit López, Sniff Andersen Nexø, Line Clemmensen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have an increasing impact on our lives with use
cases such as chatbots, study support, coding support, ideation, writing
assistance, and more. Previous studies have revealed linguistic biases in
pronouns used to describe professions or adjectives used to describe men vs
women. These issues have to some degree been addressed in updated LLM versions,
at least to pass existing tests. However, biases may still be present in the
models, and repeated use of gender stereotypical language may reinforce the
underlying assumptions and are therefore important to examine further. This
paper investigates gender biases in LLMs in relation to educational choices
through an open-ended, true to user-case experimental design and a quantitative
analysis. We investigate the biases in the context of four different cultures,
languages, and educational systems (English/US/UK, Danish/DK, Catalan/ES, and
Hindi/IN) for ages ranging from 10 to 16 years, corresponding to important
educational transition points in the different countries. We find that there
are significant and large differences in the ratio of STEM to non-STEM
suggested education paths provided by chatGPT when using typical girl vs boy
names to prompt lists of suggested things to become. There are generally fewer
STEM suggestions in the Danish, Spanish, and Indian context compared to the
English. We also find subtle differences in the suggested professions, which we
categorise and report.
|
[
-0.20592060685157776,
-0.6925929188728333,
0.35564225912094116,
0.1449257880449295,
0.14516951143741608,
0.37702521681785583,
-0.37416794896125793,
-0.3220416009426117,
-0.20134836435317993,
0.16046199202537537,
-0.7401601672172546,
-0.38564372062683105,
-0.5518587827682495,
0.20532459020614624,
-0.31137871742248535,
0.6272793412208557,
-0.12106040120124817,
0.6853306293487549,
-0.21310625970363617,
0.30560925602912903,
-0.8841606974601746,
-0.5963106751441956,
-0.47382137179374695,
-0.3648630976676941,
0.42777010798454285,
0.31913504004478455,
0.6650437712669373,
0.16748616099357605,
0.41982123255729675,
0.1846776306629181,
-0.4303632378578186,
-0.027657397091388702,
-0.525836169719696,
0.07835356146097183,
-0.40023544430732727,
-0.5576514601707458,
-0.024984275922179222,
0.26720401644706726,
0.4161466658115387,
1.1896662712097168,
0.16139961779117584,
0.3330492377281189,
0.18992672860622406,
0.7677457928657532,
-0.3903694152832031,
0.3424358665943146,
-0.31691011786460876,
0.21193622052669525,
-0.030336054041981697,
0.12264416366815567,
-0.4637213349342346,
-0.47942405939102173,
0.4392777681350708,
-0.15188977122306824,
0.2346683293581009,
0.20155033469200134,
0.6811600923538208,
-0.264249324798584,
-0.5825675129890442,
-0.38283979892730713,
-0.7361012101173401,
1.0775913000106812,
-0.32890695333480835,
0.739564836025238,
0.3069823384284973,
0.3282264769077301,
-0.42274153232574463,
-0.11688212305307388,
-0.06348548829555511,
-0.35774877667427063,
0.026466941460967064,
0.0184588935226202,
-0.1177474707365036,
-0.059474702924489975,
0.36393359303474426,
0.1073262169957161,
-0.26692184805870056,
0.4128465950489044,
-0.8208693265914917,
-0.17688067257404327,
0.2823639214038849,
0.013815704733133316,
0.5379095673561096,
-0.18337590992450714,
-0.21740444004535675,
-0.05442952364683151,
-1.0603729486465454,
0.05449124053120613,
0.8295552730560303,
0.659277081489563,
-0.13712923228740692,
0.7683998346328735,
0.13696984946727753,
0.5294299721717834,
0.02859758585691452,
-0.21787089109420776,
0.23798011243343353,
-0.16495279967784882,
0.11911633610725403,
0.06195192039012909,
0.7619386315345764,
0.3274006247520447,
0.7200987339019775,
0.09466325491666794,
0.06971727311611176,
0.027281805872917175,
-0.011813942342996597,
-0.6765469312667847,
0.26357120275497437,
-0.08266445994377136,
-0.490567147731781,
-0.1647622436285019,
-0.1917211413383484,
-0.767113208770752,
-0.3810257315635681,
-0.28574949502944946,
-0.07041218876838684,
-0.31105804443359375,
-0.22341367602348328,
0.11287426203489304,
-0.15272589027881622,
0.06259819865226746,
0.3659534752368927,
-1.045687198638916,
0.14654625952243805,
0.5619354844093323,
0.7561674118041992,
-0.3097817301750183,
-0.08458514511585236,
0.08317836374044418,
-0.2607538104057312,
-0.5319618582725525,
0.45410749316215515,
-0.9157813787460327,
-1.0406181812286377,
0.14775526523590088,
-0.11292202770709991,
-0.016860291361808777,
-0.5007065534591675,
0.45039448142051697,
-0.1836915761232376,
0.6329373717308044,
-0.32877469062805176,
-0.3879706859588623,
-0.0587560199201107,
-0.002767011057585478,
-0.4728200137615204,
0.9498945474624634,
0.026562795042991638,
-0.776881217956543,
0.541406512260437,
-0.710397481918335,
-0.299300879240036,
-0.2832600474357605,
-0.7591146230697632,
-0.0941266268491745,
0.018931299448013306,
0.162160262465477,
0.4196082353591919,
-0.5842007398605347,
0.729495644569397,
-0.17425471544265747,
-0.31199371814727783,
0.32912400364875793,
-0.612794041633606,
1.0243674516677856,
-0.026931650936603546,
-0.20259250700473785,
0.02607855200767517,
-0.36178529262542725,
-0.4261457324028015,
0.13981938362121582,
-0.04297389090061188,
-0.5439119935035706,
0.053704362362623215,
-0.10800328850746155,
0.32368791103363037,
0.09525897353887558,
-0.7515555620193481,
0.11645842343568802,
-0.35842886567115784,
0.619442880153656,
0.8434017300605774,
-0.2353823035955429,
0.48400434851646423,
-0.21426191926002502,
0.6778292059898376,
0.028415845707058907,
0.18485544621944427,
-0.05410824716091156,
-0.692649781703949,
-0.39684557914733887,
-0.22910290956497192,
0.38560619950294495,
0.36082327365875244,
-0.4394683241844177,
0.15501753985881805,
-0.019181272014975548,
-0.26838555932044983,
-0.5008930563926697,
0.022614741697907448,
0.32752591371536255,
0.33186575770378113,
-0.042803771793842316,
-0.09586167335510254,
-0.7025015950202942,
-1.2634968757629395,
-0.37552008032798767,
-0.44784167408943176,
-0.20277783274650574,
0.5057937502861023,
0.8189578056335449,
-0.0016397456638514996,
1.1302886009216309,
-0.5449445843696594,
-0.16102156043052673,
-0.22029300034046173,
-0.06748136878013611,
0.24343982338905334,
0.2740546762943268,
0.7274615168571472,
-0.5000172853469849,
-0.12822780013084412,
-0.2432517558336258,
-0.5019869208335876,
-0.04162898287177086,
0.16859173774719238,
-0.2011825293302536,
0.07827345281839371,
0.2865047752857208,
-0.5421743988990784,
0.36959022283554077,
0.5886690020561218,
-0.5316756367683411,
0.7801700830459595,
0.07134141772985458,
0.12061897665262222,
-0.8087041974067688,
-0.30277886986732483,
0.3224821090698242,
0.04699654132127762,
-0.2582530081272125,
-0.12320508807897568,
-0.11478809267282486,
-0.16598816215991974,
-0.4700898230075836,
0.8798845410346985,
-0.6160851716995239,
-0.2158241719007492,
-0.08818405121564865,
0.1410379260778427,
-0.3243389427661896,
-0.009588588960468769,
0.2827722132205963,
0.913580060005188,
0.4308902323246002,
-0.27054548263549805,
-0.1602102667093277,
0.18324033915996552,
-0.3327764868736267,
0.5839195251464844,
-0.585811972618103,
-0.03287109360098839,
-0.11705412715673447,
0.4689793288707733,
-1.0284284353256226,
-0.11065487563610077,
0.19394244253635406,
-0.42064496874809265,
0.057974301278591156,
-0.1492861807346344,
-0.5321640968322754,
-0.5834349393844604,
-0.28103193640708923,
0.23149344325065613,
0.6387835144996643,
-0.5199041366577148,
0.3629559874534607,
0.2828258275985718,
-0.10642394423484802,
-0.5732273459434509,
-0.6498962044715881,
-0.03064837120473385,
-0.05875614285469055,
-0.40288588404655457,
-0.20358383655548096,
-0.22462864220142365,
-0.6624622941017151,
-0.15366250276565552,
-0.19686032831668854,
-0.2422606498003006,
0.1056305542588234,
0.4493754208087921,
0.7713376879692078,
-0.12911884486675262,
0.16684190928936005,
0.31239956617355347,
0.2046460658311844,
0.15733225643634796,
-0.08728283643722534,
0.5679970383644104,
-0.12433838844299316,
-0.41703805327415466,
0.01600232720375061,
0.21824441850185394,
0.6294090151786804,
0.08459518849849701,
0.7546465396881104,
0.21924085915088654,
-0.2558201849460602,
-0.1760873794555664,
-0.43863844871520996,
-0.5731562376022339,
-0.4308139383792877,
0.32443347573280334,
-0.2566746175289154,
-1.296182632446289,
0.3019096851348877,
0.06527747958898544,
0.34644296765327454,
0.36463409662246704,
0.5990062952041626,
-0.24777808785438538,
0.865269660949707,
0.3980247974395752,
0.04244042932987213,
0.4530617594718933,
-0.095933698117733,
0.3638197183609009,
-0.8437042832374573,
-0.1472007930278778,
-0.5267907381057739,
-0.19658717513084412,
-0.7386012077331543,
-0.5105635523796082,
0.06816117465496063,
-0.23382537066936493,
-0.3944259285926819,
-0.14075832068920135,
-0.18508471548557281,
0.4536512494087219,
0.33293288946151733,
-0.08838807791471481,
0.25759872794151306,
0.11143830418586731,
-0.2226976901292801,
-0.3273157477378845,
-0.7198577523231506,
-0.767096996307373,
1.2493081092834473,
0.5228539705276489,
0.7083187699317932,
0.019729487597942352,
0.34253573417663574,
0.2832396626472473,
0.41937175393104553,
-0.7975908517837524,
0.7044114470481873,
-0.4990788996219635,
-1.1071927547454834,
-0.23652996122837067,
-0.21924330294132233,
-1.0000165700912476,
0.36370784044265747,
-0.1570684164762497,
-0.7816902995109558,
0.24762625992298126,
-0.08806800097227097,
0.10872846841812134,
0.21825921535491943,
-0.5934751033782959,
0.3353753983974457,
-0.1802438497543335,
-0.40482965111732483,
-0.02948884665966034,
-0.5427274703979492,
0.7385246753692627,
-0.16881082952022552,
0.5944721102714539,
-0.24696780741214752,
0.14865055680274963,
0.8740261197090149,
-0.19750653207302094,
1.3382834196090698,
-0.0780361220240593,
-0.2756721079349518,
0.1772449016571045,
0.05339403077960014,
0.016938669607043266,
-0.15558283030986786,
-0.19148312509059906,
0.4613824486732483,
-0.2547937333583832,
-0.14947576820850372,
-0.2528846561908722,
0.7093907594680786,
-1.078195571899414,
-0.8013894557952881,
-0.5415302515029907,
-0.7666711211204529,
-0.2703734338283539,
0.13624036312103271,
0.026898272335529327,
0.2653217911720276,
-0.22993473708629608,
0.17749270796775818,
0.6817648410797119,
-0.5795403718948364,
0.0696742981672287,
0.5816437005996704,
-0.7401788830757141,
0.15830861032009125,
0.4433847963809967,
0.42992499470710754,
0.4302704930305481,
0.05671045184135437,
0.5808247923851013,
-0.3317650556564331,
-0.1714363843202591,
-0.45094090700149536,
0.5289241671562195,
-0.6469326019287109,
0.35258617997169495,
-0.4650285542011261,
-0.3933827877044678,
-0.4712774455547333,
-0.22771517932415009,
-0.3803800046443939,
-0.24719639122486115,
-0.37577810883522034,
-0.37715277075767517,
0.42250463366508484,
0.7388126254081726,
0.2646321654319763,
0.3493874967098236,
-0.25017061829566956,
0.18011903762817383,
0.1368594914674759,
0.20457375049591064,
0.06970284879207611,
-0.6398093700408936,
0.34308290481567383,
0.04114576429128647,
-0.08537276834249496,
-0.9494985938072205,
0.11230327188968658,
-0.015310748480260372,
0.6810528635978699,
0.27202704548835754,
-0.14963293075561523,
0.26020678877830505,
-0.6276171207427979,
1.011195182800293,
0.268811970949173,
-0.663785994052887,
0.3670104742050171,
-0.6256561875343323,
0.1727691888809204,
0.24319779872894287,
0.5547170639038086,
-0.6366904973983765,
-0.43348631262779236,
-0.40878066420555115,
-0.9038774967193604,
0.6105769276618958,
0.16546493768692017,
0.3724801540374756,
-0.13665403425693512,
0.2138238102197647,
0.5109446048736572,
0.36496835947036743,
-0.5950777530670166,
-0.5752345323562622,
0.09100359678268433,
0.016895540058612823,
0.14953531324863434,
-0.3293447196483612,
-0.04720873013138771,
-0.1852695345878601,
0.5589075088500977,
0.2598249614238739,
0.10838271677494049,
-0.2542937695980072,
-0.01815626583993435,
0.11413153260946274,
0.7669022679328918,
0.407590389251709,
0.8043045401573181,
-0.13642646372318268,
-0.07324118912220001,
0.13763634860515594,
-0.5961689949035645,
0.41509944200515747,
-0.3081552982330322,
-0.2928546369075775,
0.14525821805000305,
0.18817158043384552,
0.8189857602119446,
0.36179226636886597,
-0.785947322845459,
0.319122314453125,
-0.102589450776577,
-0.25234344601631165,
-0.38429567217826843,
-0.014692277647554874,
0.27256065607070923,
0.007212529424577951,
0.340780645608902,
-0.17884454131126404,
0.031564462929964066,
-0.7921081185340881,
-0.3935869038105011,
0.3665948808193207,
-0.5042194128036499,
-0.15796194970607758,
0.48559606075286865,
0.38580822944641113,
-0.3580242097377777,
0.504517674446106,
0.06257259100675583,
-0.26222366094589233,
0.628579318523407,
0.6818088293075562,
0.8998486399650574,
-0.2934209108352661,
0.48746779561042786,
0.3629007041454315,
0.5660280585289001,
-0.3520253896713257,
0.2999838590621948,
0.34070736169815063,
-0.805294394493103,
-0.3846268951892853,
-0.5577887296676636,
-0.5084651112556458,
-0.03116302192211151,
-0.46163293719291687,
0.453670859336853,
-0.3658389449119568,
-0.31578564643859863,
-0.285978764295578,
-0.5078359246253967,
-0.8082939982414246,
0.20691309869289398,
0.13834446668624878,
0.8191109895706177,
-1.1452362537384033,
0.4989718496799469,
0.7917188405990601,
-0.15251483023166656,
-0.6707067489624023,
-0.19418185949325562,
0.37192225456237793,
-0.7745730876922607,
1.2871321439743042,
0.06091815233230591,
-0.28417545557022095,
-0.2922068238258362,
-0.20815128087997437,
-0.9873788952827454,
0.6414870023727417,
0.2135665863752365,
-1.019707202911377,
-0.22744683921337128,
0.30886054039001465,
0.6417617797851562,
-0.390377938747406,
0.6843773722648621,
0.5153762698173523,
0.43624448776245117,
0.024486226961016655,
-1.0411163568496704,
-0.2568928599357605,
0.07228081673383713,
0.171916663646698,
0.1270046830177307,
-0.5539801716804504,
0.9502623677253723,
-0.24802438914775848,
0.018619226291775703,
-0.17393693327903748,
0.5697582960128784,
0.6399292349815369,
-0.025517001748085022,
0.41758081316947937,
-0.22575479745864868,
0.6318591237068176,
-0.23427344858646393,
0.8855181336402893,
-0.20275412499904633,
0.13589759171009064,
0.9850287437438965,
-0.24052469432353973,
0.6696880459785461,
0.565844714641571,
-0.5970913767814636,
0.48346146941185,
0.8833230137825012,
0.04647747427225113,
-0.0385681577026844,
0.535415530204773,
0.10883775353431702,
0.04464402794837952,
-0.4094493091106415,
-0.4401306211948395,
0.5105111002922058,
0.5400223731994629,
-0.5854432582855225,
-0.11163199692964554,
0.2398896962404251,
0.455691397190094,
0.0700293481349945,
-0.3987827003002167,
0.07116178423166275,
0.2627162039279938,
-0.37143343687057495,
0.19779294729232788,
-0.18806160986423492,
0.9928409457206726,
-0.6145267486572266,
0.15151873230934143,
-0.24941371381282806,
-0.21427032351493835,
-0.3012627065181732,
-0.972083568572998,
-0.10986654460430145,
0.2808123826980591,
-0.3254193961620331,
-0.21214167773723602,
0.7271842360496521,
-0.4031318724155426,
-0.9237393140792847,
0.30448997020721436,
0.7555927634239197,
0.32933396100997925,
0.44891491532325745,
-0.5206296443939209,
0.11559206247329712,
0.0021969019435346127,
-0.20864041149616241,
0.5038359761238098,
0.018712257966399193,
-0.5448986887931824,
0.8722850680351257,
0.4495798647403717,
0.297991544008255,
0.1365356296300888,
0.3882386088371277,
0.43888232111930847,
-0.41660070419311523,
-0.36573752760887146,
-0.8393550515174866,
0.13120628893375397,
0.05137389525771141,
-0.4272781014442444,
1.0529199838638306,
0.5358748435974121,
0.8329076170921326,
-0.19520871341228485,
1.1336432695388794,
0.17060653865337372,
0.550286591053009,
-0.3015223443508148,
0.5441384315490723,
-0.27868884801864624,
0.45862841606140137,
-0.45481473207473755,
-1.092497706413269,
-0.09247475117444992,
0.5471014380455017,
-0.8716186881065369,
0.5067669749259949,
0.7246626019477844,
0.303941935300827,
0.16969667375087738,
0.16841939091682434,
0.2914385199546814,
0.21208642423152924,
0.25562241673469543,
0.06225084513425827,
1.1188442707061768,
0.0271759070456028,
0.15475526452064514,
-0.055707115679979324,
-0.13888859748840332,
-0.14858794212341309,
-0.7196202874183655,
-1.3157061338424683,
-0.24087011814117432,
-0.32748866081237793,
-0.051411401480436325,
0.27207186818122864,
1.1373188495635986,
0.5159524083137512,
-0.48986345529556274,
-0.6813970804214478,
0.3473914563655853,
0.24676001071929932,
0.16034580767154694,
-0.21744126081466675,
0.2932438254356384,
0.006482229568064213,
-0.8905227184295654,
0.2503388822078705,
0.04148881882429123,
-0.12388765066862106,
-0.7933573126792908,
0.31274649500846863,
-0.10349534451961517,
0.19057321548461914,
0.7556107044219971,
-0.009274699725210667,
-0.9692381620407104,
-0.49183976650238037,
0.23699313402175903,
0.001995542785152793,
0.05036725476384163,
0.8284105062484741,
-0.5119332671165466,
0.4071976840496063,
0.39156368374824524,
0.2605416476726532,
0.05072016641497612,
-0.31528252363204956,
0.7270825505256653,
-0.5236190557479858,
0.08782118558883667,
0.03842154145240784,
0.40886297821998596,
0.4106890857219696,
-0.19741711020469666,
0.5190755128860474,
0.294357031583786,
-0.39450544118881226,
-0.9075016379356384,
0.2742588520050049,
-0.7198789715766907,
-0.5616275668144226,
1.4800626039505005,
0.01596379466354847,
-0.1282324343919754,
-0.21653476357460022,
-0.45796337723731995,
0.039501726627349854,
-0.7077984809875488,
0.6802855730056763,
1.0228967666625977,
-0.07848227769136429,
-0.0277615487575531,
-1.0329927206039429,
0.09587903320789337,
0.2734782099723816,
-0.5395268201828003,
0.009134563617408276,
0.4849396347999573,
0.5511015057563782,
-0.05169394612312317,
0.2671014070510864,
-0.3432168662548065,
0.07595045119524002,
-0.19547110795974731,
0.20953088998794556,
0.23741665482521057,
-0.16746528446674347,
-0.14194416999816895,
-0.014026748947799206,
0.28847986459732056,
0.042506054043769836
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10130v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10130v1
|
The Devil is in the Neurons: Interpreting and Mitigating Social Biases in Pre-trained Language Models
| 2024-06-14T15:41:06 | 2024-06-14T15:41:06 |
Yan Liu, Yu Liu, Xiaokang Chen, Pin-Yu Chen, Daoguang Zan, Min-Yen Kan, Tsung-Yi Ho
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Pre-trained Language models (PLMs) have been acknowledged to contain harmful
information, such as social biases, which may cause negative social impacts or
even bring catastrophic results in application. Previous works on this problem
mainly focused on using black-box methods such as probing to detect and
quantify social biases in PLMs by observing model outputs. As a result,
previous debiasing methods mainly finetune or even pre-train language models on
newly constructed anti-stereotypical datasets, which are high-cost. In this
work, we try to unveil the mystery of social bias inside language models by
introducing the concept of {\sc Social Bias Neurons}. Specifically, we propose
{\sc Integrated Gap Gradients (IG$^2$)} to accurately pinpoint units (i.e.,
neurons) in a language model that can be attributed to undesirable behavior,
such as social bias. By formalizing undesirable behavior as a distributional
property of language, we employ sentiment-bearing prompts to elicit classes of
sensitive words (demographics) correlated with such sentiments. Our IG$^2$ thus
attributes the uneven distribution for different demographics to specific
Social Bias Neurons, which track the trail of unwanted behavior inside PLM
units to achieve interoperability. Moreover, derived from our interpretable
technique, {\sc Bias Neuron Suppression (BNS)} is further proposed to mitigate
social biases. By studying BERT, RoBERTa, and their attributable differences
from debiased FairBERTa, IG$^2$ allows us to locate and suppress identified
neurons, and further mitigate undesired behaviors. As measured by prior metrics
from StereoSet, our model achieves a higher degree of fairness while
maintaining language modeling ability with low cost.
|
[
-0.4700542092323303,
-0.8653520941734314,
0.3221939504146576,
0.37329593300819397,
-0.18017779290676117,
0.1434282660484314,
-0.3713687062263489,
-0.15819156169891357,
0.4213058650493622,
0.32256388664245605,
-0.48464369773864746,
-0.31819602847099304,
-0.6381338238716125,
-0.4038141667842865,
-0.23127301037311554,
1.0576881170272827,
0.6203192472457886,
0.4738950729370117,
-0.2458852231502533,
-0.0360395573079586,
-0.15278123319149017,
-0.7538179755210876,
-0.6356270909309387,
-0.7505433559417725,
0.5076212286949158,
0.2031073421239853,
0.7052459120750427,
0.11861942708492279,
0.17529548704624176,
0.2234784960746765,
-0.3679795265197754,
-0.07104013115167618,
-0.5508772730827332,
-0.3306853473186493,
-0.20839756727218628,
-0.3641308546066284,
-0.4435468316078186,
0.20977811515331268,
0.2667933404445648,
0.7740945816040039,
-0.05850592628121376,
0.10596948117017746,
0.36388099193573,
0.6545478105545044,
-0.6185716390609741,
0.0922221839427948,
-0.9065295457839966,
-0.036814864724874496,
-0.4043435752391815,
-0.2550257444381714,
-0.3707450330257416,
-0.6185523271560669,
-0.07063405960798264,
-0.2554113566875458,
0.279909610748291,
-0.329784631729126,
0.8324894905090332,
0.32118475437164307,
-0.07273046672344208,
-0.009672182612121105,
-0.4517833888530731,
0.7389927506446838,
-0.7829455733299255,
-0.1489526331424713,
0.61146080493927,
0.11340556293725967,
-0.10355906188488007,
-0.25179436802864075,
-0.5508399605751038,
-0.21478955447673798,
-0.15001250803470612,
-0.06444381922483444,
-0.2199418842792511,
0.14316435158252716,
0.44804203510284424,
-0.15057262778282166,
-0.24567703902721405,
0.17382274568080902,
-0.46117398142814636,
-0.1845734864473343,
0.5952915549278259,
-0.15777230262756348,
0.5220693349838257,
-0.30082058906555176,
-0.24691610038280487,
0.1793643683195114,
-0.8505210280418396,
-0.01925705187022686,
0.9422594308853149,
0.2263454645872116,
-0.2818622589111328,
0.2630922794342041,
0.020703565329313278,
0.3145255148410797,
-0.1119285598397255,
0.6155772805213928,
0.3192391097545624,
-0.13813680410385132,
0.04137265682220459,
0.16532869637012482,
0.7773072719573975,
0.4359411895275116,
1.0958033800125122,
-0.19541797041893005,
-0.13362213969230652,
0.5690028667449951,
0.42967429757118225,
-0.6336575150489807,
-0.1852649301290512,
-0.2417307049036026,
-0.5545760989189148,
-0.582171618938446,
-0.44986405968666077,
-0.9715729355812073,
-0.5652981400489807,
-0.16372743248939514,
0.25157400965690613,
-0.27036190032958984,
-0.5131881833076477,
0.01453327015042305,
-0.12490496039390564,
0.06499119102954865,
0.01583191379904747,
-0.9877796173095703,
0.5189710855484009,
0.6101630330085754,
0.8103490471839905,
0.12746526300907135,
-0.1671331524848938,
-0.32264524698257446,
-0.09858154505491257,
-0.22535480558872223,
0.5431762337684631,
-0.660398542881012,
-0.17526187002658844,
-0.03902403265237808,
-0.1386442482471466,
0.06589110940694809,
-0.4613920748233795,
0.450926810503006,
-0.39704930782318115,
-0.21192610263824463,
-0.4361127018928528,
-0.18494653701782227,
0.13072173297405243,
0.0621226504445076,
-0.3180162310600281,
0.8709319233894348,
-0.08904601633548737,
-0.9422390460968018,
0.1904829740524292,
-0.6032348275184631,
-0.4593333601951599,
0.07198327034711838,
-0.4069560766220093,
-0.2155042588710785,
0.2926885187625885,
0.1731410026550293,
0.33042672276496887,
-0.29259803891181946,
0.5065730810165405,
-0.6938959956169128,
-0.5429449677467346,
0.3038572072982788,
-0.4726408123970032,
1.1628013849258423,
0.14717786014080048,
-0.5294979214668274,
0.2077949196100235,
-0.4682590067386627,
-0.13628773391246796,
0.1458105444908142,
0.14793181419372559,
-0.8699749112129211,
0.2461283951997757,
-0.13998956978321075,
0.2714803218841553,
0.02044513076543808,
-0.5743749141693115,
-0.2683876156806946,
-0.4867479205131531,
0.6440033316612244,
1.2690026760101318,
-0.425374299287796,
0.7490214109420776,
-0.02678525075316429,
0.3570496737957001,
0.0944533497095108,
0.5151724815368652,
0.3729327917098999,
-0.39374879002571106,
-0.6747890710830688,
-0.06440844386816025,
0.16081686317920685,
0.26306846737861633,
-0.8015385866165161,
0.5042341351509094,
-0.13777761161327362,
-0.3479354679584503,
-0.588823676109314,
-0.05468171462416649,
0.31450358033180237,
0.4512835144996643,
0.25790297985076904,
-0.44347864389419556,
-0.2803092300891876,
-1.1355247497558594,
-0.5937981009483337,
0.05165519192814827,
0.0977838784456253,
0.21921595931053162,
0.33857208490371704,
-0.1576012223958969,
0.8124263882637024,
-0.17829138040542603,
-0.0175559613853693,
-0.1727716624736786,
0.04992113634943962,
0.15005868673324585,
0.6016795039176941,
0.6037488579750061,
-0.5509434342384338,
-0.29264703392982483,
-0.3158318102359772,
-0.5710505843162537,
-0.5257501602172852,
0.10472333431243896,
-0.23430471122264862,
-0.02753179334104061,
0.5330489873886108,
-0.5493265390396118,
0.7722892761230469,
0.4680803120136261,
-0.40865764021873474,
0.3503085672855377,
-0.09769369661808014,
-0.36808478832244873,
-0.668071448802948,
-0.10730808973312378,
0.28723543882369995,
0.13817869126796722,
-0.5892429351806641,
-0.4882924556732178,
0.05949550122022629,
0.14385028183460236,
-0.3141852915287018,
0.4589763879776001,
-0.378492534160614,
-0.29835402965545654,
-0.19886186718940735,
0.16897766292095184,
-0.08476293832063675,
0.5427489280700684,
-0.2305009365081787,
0.5419884920120239,
0.6325042247772217,
-0.4795069098472595,
-0.11336694657802582,
-0.012139194644987583,
-0.48859578371047974,
0.3943253755569458,
-0.7673728466033936,
0.2136840969324112,
-0.579222559928894,
0.07027251273393631,
-0.8280503153800964,
0.22739306092262268,
0.4125388562679291,
-0.6664659380912781,
0.1126030758023262,
-0.21525108814239502,
-0.3826543390750885,
-0.09131427109241486,
-0.1395035982131958,
0.5028494000434875,
0.5793913006782532,
-0.46187224984169006,
0.3679948151111603,
0.6118446588516235,
-0.1988462656736374,
-0.8307085633277893,
-0.6815420389175415,
-0.10428448766469955,
-0.11948007345199585,
-0.5276033282279968,
0.18897591531276703,
-0.10247249156236649,
-0.5412825345993042,
-0.04725737124681473,
0.006462448742240667,
0.13193905353546143,
0.24598105251789093,
0.2177926003932953,
0.2649093270301819,
0.07752560079097748,
0.23406803607940674,
0.2153998464345932,
-0.12895222008228302,
0.3717209994792938,
0.014095742255449295,
0.9113336801528931,
0.030825624242424965,
-0.2857460081577301,
-0.0828617587685585,
0.2344212383031845,
0.5381834506988525,
-0.40419894456863403,
0.6526985764503479,
0.4377762973308563,
-0.4860871136188507,
-0.39213377237319946,
-0.5114052295684814,
-0.6050510406494141,
-0.47520044445991516,
0.47058025002479553,
-0.014477080665528774,
-0.5781450867652893,
0.5368683338165283,
0.13393612205982208,
-0.3686794638633728,
-0.044678255915641785,
0.3851446807384491,
0.08863937854766846,
1.0672855377197266,
0.3840101361274719,
-0.17765723168849945,
0.6935924887657166,
-0.06433005630970001,
0.5317150354385376,
-0.8341149687767029,
-0.22911399602890015,
-0.5905919075012207,
-0.36802956461906433,
-0.37579694390296936,
-0.2620942294597626,
0.19162866473197937,
0.08794273436069489,
-0.2712404727935791,
-0.11561029404401779,
-0.5114179849624634,
0.6578772068023682,
0.6388831734657288,
0.24168305099010468,
-0.20130404829978943,
0.19672276079654694,
-0.08462641388177872,
-0.2610090672969818,
-0.7141121625900269,
-0.5376136302947998,
1.0514179468154907,
0.4576997458934784,
0.855732262134552,
-0.337118923664093,
0.4779075086116791,
0.4144677519798279,
0.6792044639587402,
-0.5496166348457336,
0.6396507620811462,
-0.32715797424316406,
-0.7527683973312378,
-0.08766468614339828,
-0.49817955493927,
-0.5819414854049683,
0.43046852946281433,
-0.20449119806289673,
-0.8100625276565552,
0.4750339388847351,
0.27323928475379944,
-0.36490902304649353,
0.3383150100708008,
-0.7367600202560425,
0.9596014022827148,
-0.4188510477542877,
-0.6730514764785767,
-0.5063932538032532,
-0.6977112889289856,
0.314868301153183,
0.1854618340730667,
0.33114323019981384,
-0.37519100308418274,
0.49955904483795166,
0.6087356209754944,
-0.2568575143814087,
1.1060916185379028,
-0.4356505870819092,
0.1511981040239334,
0.03726162016391754,
-0.04258523881435394,
0.43705546855926514,
-0.019461743533611298,
-0.3276616632938385,
0.6621851921081543,
-0.35084083676338196,
-0.4883609414100647,
-0.43142077326774597,
0.8477534055709839,
-0.8130166530609131,
-0.3191397786140442,
-0.510159432888031,
-0.5789725184440613,
-0.0032600557897239923,
0.004635147750377655,
0.17466232180595398,
0.34165164828300476,
-0.21435391902923584,
-0.01757652498781681,
0.6093780398368835,
-0.6692070960998535,
0.48687610030174255,
0.39916059374809265,
0.0402195118367672,
-0.15610159933567047,
0.7141801714897156,
0.28784555196762085,
0.3591017723083496,
-0.23309236764907837,
0.19749271869659424,
-0.18236857652664185,
-0.46433863043785095,
-0.13303092122077942,
0.2904037535190582,
-0.6271477937698364,
0.062463950365781784,
-0.7996295094490051,
-0.17017127573490143,
-0.5787607431411743,
-0.07438632845878601,
-0.2766086459159851,
-0.05493346229195595,
-0.2797592282295227,
-0.2014317810535431,
0.07875082641839981,
0.7042292356491089,
-0.3369169235229492,
0.7372902035713196,
-0.2853679060935974,
0.21285901963710785,
0.08035533130168915,
0.4934048652648926,
0.2412666231393814,
-0.35205385088920593,
-0.11795198917388916,
0.21821019053459167,
-0.05970824137330055,
-0.9909965395927429,
0.5448282361030579,
-0.23339541256427765,
0.5687856078147888,
0.4055028557777405,
-0.06303978711366653,
0.4269509017467499,
-0.5017056465148926,
0.46470707654953003,
0.2841004431247711,
-1.1383072137832642,
0.36188340187072754,
-0.24055849015712738,
-0.013986638747155666,
0.42302027344703674,
0.1770954579114914,
-0.4318189322948456,
-0.3017999827861786,
-0.6855409145355225,
-0.9039417505264282,
1.025414228439331,
0.12983140349388123,
0.40409916639328003,
-0.31848809123039246,
0.42477843165397644,
-0.07075002044439316,
0.3306533992290497,
-1.0269057750701904,
-0.3908427357673645,
-0.361955851316452,
-0.20897045731544495,
-0.21805520355701447,
-0.5469681620597839,
-0.04783788323402405,
-0.41132649779319763,
0.6374400854110718,
0.03289049491286278,
-0.09901751577854156,
-0.08636239171028137,
-0.10015339404344559,
-0.08661215752363205,
0.2502490282058716,
0.3933286666870117,
0.5502853989601135,
-0.18612432479858398,
0.27942952513694763,
-0.07965946197509766,
-0.3366113007068634,
-0.05141199007630348,
0.06130101531744003,
-0.49164944887161255,
0.08379936963319778,
-0.15632255375385284,
0.7481353878974915,
-0.05518363416194916,
-0.2769463062286377,
0.7999128103256226,
-0.049614060670137405,
0.1769847720861435,
-0.4484774172306061,
-0.1715194135904312,
0.1530137062072754,
0.1299365758895874,
0.04295448958873749,
0.42692437767982483,
0.02779771015048027,
-0.49756762385368347,
0.06512463092803955,
0.8228850364685059,
-0.7778593897819519,
-0.5983902215957642,
0.5310707092285156,
0.4556894302368164,
-0.4802314341068268,
0.535431444644928,
-0.1374192088842392,
-0.5531061291694641,
0.8271716833114624,
0.5171342492103577,
0.9597928524017334,
-0.31371116638183594,
0.41022711992263794,
0.17147471010684967,
0.8299462795257568,
0.01945510134100914,
0.26903238892555237,
-0.002129197819158435,
-1.0308927297592163,
-0.3956907391548157,
-0.656840443611145,
0.26266929507255554,
0.29972171783447266,
-0.615603506565094,
0.06339090317487717,
-0.5690618753433228,
-0.37970179319381714,
0.054521527141332626,
-0.5176019668579102,
-0.5243391990661621,
0.007654998451471329,
0.21799251437187195,
0.7334867119789124,
-1.182897686958313,
1.0267908573150635,
0.3742411136627197,
-0.3282938003540039,
-0.3648095428943634,
0.08718150854110718,
-0.22227005660533905,
-0.8676242232322693,
0.9084464907646179,
0.17214493453502655,
-0.2815139591693878,
-0.02155442349612713,
-0.904570460319519,
-0.4064417779445648,
0.2024715691804886,
0.6400846838951111,
-0.518501341342926,
0.056991495192050934,
0.161155104637146,
0.508588969707489,
-0.23865960538387299,
0.40252405405044556,
0.6296626329421997,
0.45577988028526306,
-0.47864633798599243,
-0.4713621437549591,
0.12157107144594193,
-0.5111315846443176,
0.035917382687330246,
0.15575654804706573,
-0.4483785927295685,
1.0816813707351685,
-0.08562246710062027,
-0.02611622028052807,
-0.3526013493537903,
0.15925224125385284,
0.01889016106724739,
0.350330650806427,
0.7407737970352173,
0.3087622821331024,
0.4896968603134155,
-0.21738852560520172,
0.932839035987854,
-0.2661585807800293,
0.09037843346595764,
1.0426729917526245,
-0.3467138111591339,
0.18786880373954773,
0.8486672043800354,
0.15081752836704254,
0.33144646883010864,
0.5040008425712585,
0.3784591257572174,
0.6314185857772827,
0.8357460498809814,
-0.2945019602775574,
-0.35825294256210327,
-0.31379199028015137,
-0.25922730565071106,
0.17719483375549316,
0.5861607193946838,
-0.41829049587249756,
-0.16876459121704102,
-0.1754172146320343,
0.14149682223796844,
0.3239845931529999,
-0.33993926644325256,
0.5509825348854065,
0.33819374442100525,
-0.5137690901756287,
0.2864045202732086,
-0.3163326382637024,
1.0515460968017578,
-0.7725589871406555,
-0.019417110830545425,
-0.35920459032058716,
0.38686707615852356,
-0.22003158926963806,
-0.3589860796928406,
0.25715571641921997,
-0.10677651315927505,
-0.1765236109495163,
-0.2897484600543976,
0.8585810661315918,
-0.5396702289581299,
-0.27301931381225586,
0.9360212087631226,
0.35067999362945557,
0.1499922126531601,
-0.31389304995536804,
-0.6856202483177185,
0.11804506927728653,
-0.0034239618107676506,
-0.04474515840411186,
0.22908395528793335,
0.29545488953590393,
-0.14383573830127716,
0.5031110048294067,
0.5821918845176697,
0.4435821771621704,
0.14729054272174835,
0.5496267676353455,
0.8519634008407593,
-0.48526591062545776,
-0.5238653421401978,
-1.182660460472107,
0.4695061147212982,
-0.4314798414707184,
-0.11842469871044159,
0.7024992108345032,
0.21102963387966156,
0.8746686577796936,
0.06279917061328888,
0.9569681882858276,
0.04232386127114296,
0.3051518201828003,
-0.12603293359279633,
1.246300458908081,
-0.5017217397689819,
0.37550172209739685,
-0.48458901047706604,
-0.8143876791000366,
-0.07738392055034637,
0.7219946384429932,
-0.6758711934089661,
0.04666511341929436,
0.43395131826400757,
1.1396681070327759,
-0.05992114916443825,
0.07225210219621658,
0.16763298213481903,
0.33671998977661133,
0.19576577842235565,
0.33060237765312195,
1.1780993938446045,
-0.03132558614015579,
0.2908189296722412,
-0.26400601863861084,
-0.4339755177497864,
-0.047050826251506805,
-0.6267096996307373,
-1.0851913690567017,
-0.07629808038473129,
-0.07806728780269623,
-0.5414835810661316,
0.32250329852104187,
0.8208734393119812,
0.6902061700820923,
-0.637582004070282,
-0.36107534170150757,
-0.1356857568025589,
0.31810593605041504,
0.05019281059503555,
-0.25135090947151184,
0.12091623991727829,
-0.4908168315887451,
-0.5815793871879578,
0.10350756347179413,
0.23765653371810913,
-0.09812275320291519,
-0.46648281812667847,
-0.0499601885676384,
-0.1776309758424759,
0.18423372507095337,
0.4797796308994293,
-0.13490860164165497,
-0.45901864767074585,
-0.2662591338157654,
-0.14143911004066467,
-0.15871544182300568,
0.039988961070775986,
0.7995874881744385,
-0.5622111558914185,
0.42758285999298096,
0.5231240391731262,
0.38138917088508606,
0.25803089141845703,
-0.19122959673404694,
0.689762532711029,
-0.7447422742843628,
0.42211174964904785,
0.37940654158592224,
0.40199148654937744,
0.48072388768196106,
-0.3211711049079895,
0.4131064713001251,
0.24707596004009247,
-0.33183401823043823,
-0.9546916484832764,
0.4388183653354645,
-0.5596598386764526,
-0.39739564061164856,
1.1187158823013306,
0.12000999599695206,
-0.3837510347366333,
-0.2227499783039093,
-0.1250525265932083,
0.44856250286102295,
-0.4352470338344574,
1.1312055587768555,
0.588956892490387,
0.3678000867366791,
0.13983315229415894,
-0.5874899625778198,
0.708890974521637,
0.8348618149757385,
-0.7331803441047668,
0.1022387370467186,
0.4217981696128845,
0.23600730299949646,
0.15508556365966797,
0.8505823612213135,
-0.36199432611465454,
-0.0015429288614541292,
-0.2577592134475708,
0.5640096664428711,
0.20680135488510132,
-0.26999640464782715,
-0.6339350342750549,
-0.06448812037706375,
-0.2660726308822632,
-0.22280922532081604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10118v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10118v1
|
SEACrowd: A Multilingual Multimodal Data Hub and Benchmark Suite for Southeast Asian Languages
| 2024-06-14T15:23:39 | 2024-06-14T15:23:39 |
Holy Lovenia, Rahmad Mahendra, Salsabil Maulana Akbar, Lester James V. Miranda, Jennifer Santoso, Elyanah Aco, Akhdan Fadhilah, Jonibek Mansurov, Joseph Marvin Imperial, Onno P. Kampman, Joel Ruben Antony Moniz, Muhammad Ravi Shulthan Habibi, Frederikus Hudi, Railey Montalan, Ryan Ignatius, Joanito Agili Lopo, William Nixon, Börje F. Karlsson, James Jaya, Ryandito Diandaru, Yuze Gao, Patrick Amadeus, Bin Wang, Jan Christian Blaise Cruz, Chenxi Whitehouse, Ivan Halim Parmonangan, Maria Khelli, Wenyu Zhang, Lucky Susanto, Reynard Adha Ryanda, Sonny Lazuardi Hermawan, Dan John Velasco, Muhammad Dehan Al Kautsar, Willy Fitra Hendria, Yasmin Moslem, Noah Flynn, Muhammad Farid Adilazuarda, Haochen Li, Johanes Lee, R. Damanhuri, Shuo Sun, Muhammad Reza Qorib, Amirbek Djanibekov, Wei Qi Leong, Quyet V. Do, Niklas Muennighoff, Tanrada Pansuwan, Ilham Firdausi Putra, Yan Xu, Ngee Chia Tai, Ayu Purwarianti, Sebastian Ruder, William Tjhi, Peerat Limkonchotiwat, Alham Fikri Aji, Sedrick Keh, Genta Indra Winata, Ruochen Zhang, Fajri Koto, Zheng-Xin Yong, Samuel Cahyawijaya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Southeast Asia (SEA) is a region rich in linguistic diversity and cultural
variety, with over 1,300 indigenous languages and a population of 671 million
people. However, prevailing AI models suffer from a significant lack of
representation of texts, images, and audio datasets from SEA, compromising the
quality of AI models for SEA languages. Evaluating models for SEA languages is
challenging due to the scarcity of high-quality datasets, compounded by the
dominance of English training data, raising concerns about potential cultural
misrepresentation. To address these challenges, we introduce SEACrowd, a
collaborative initiative that consolidates a comprehensive resource hub that
fills the resource gap by providing standardized corpora in nearly 1,000 SEA
languages across three modalities. Through our SEACrowd benchmarks, we assess
the quality of AI models on 36 indigenous languages across 13 tasks, offering
valuable insights into the current AI landscape in SEA. Furthermore, we propose
strategies to facilitate greater AI advancements, maximizing potential utility
and resource equity for the future of AI in SEA.
|
[
-0.49953773617744446,
-0.2534372806549072,
0.19238536059856415,
0.2928543984889984,
-0.49743837118148804,
0.29290205240249634,
-0.43583565950393677,
-0.41448336839675903,
0.05781003460288048,
0.6552844643592834,
-0.29085442423820496,
-0.639067530632019,
-0.4288867115974426,
0.11050186306238174,
0.047068022191524506,
0.4789218604564667,
-0.10406828671693802,
0.3053686022758484,
-0.1698211282491684,
-0.7577511668205261,
-0.6422349810600281,
-0.49445855617523193,
-0.6339913606643677,
0.33905312418937683,
-0.05467769503593445,
0.7726122140884399,
0.9600341320037842,
0.8752382397651672,
0.803260326385498,
0.34353190660476685,
0.19885829091072083,
0.12627555429935455,
-0.27575910091400146,
0.46321672201156616,
-0.25608474016189575,
-0.4475557804107666,
-0.23061606287956238,
0.10776522010564804,
0.3189748227596283,
0.8728105425834656,
-0.3290380835533142,
0.17919380962848663,
-0.03590276092290878,
0.42290088534355164,
-0.6546284556388855,
0.6308583617210388,
-0.3512415587902069,
-0.06410546600818634,
-0.6422647833824158,
0.16100230813026428,
0.04658667743206024,
-0.1172298789024353,
0.4225059449672699,
-0.6558884978294373,
0.05969611555337906,
-0.04470008984208107,
0.45004796981811523,
0.5538467764854431,
-0.5978562235832214,
-0.35874390602111816,
-0.4057723879814148,
0.8385010957717896,
-0.45754000544548035,
0.6780717968940735,
0.46812188625335693,
0.5561239123344421,
0.27983802556991577,
-0.4730343520641327,
-0.6105006337165833,
-0.0441475473344326,
0.22755122184753418,
0.2144576609134674,
-0.16993194818496704,
0.09393022954463959,
-0.2713802456855774,
0.4396744668483734,
-0.9191310405731201,
0.18105553090572357,
-0.6028477549552917,
-0.2032483071088791,
0.9481896162033081,
0.11543779075145721,
0.5338402986526489,
0.020377695560455322,
-0.21724222600460052,
-0.6162832379341125,
-0.598651111125946,
-0.07442597299814224,
0.13680849969387054,
0.6609496474266052,
-0.34039822220802307,
0.5453805923461914,
-0.0657123476266861,
0.247435063123703,
-0.36648687720298767,
-0.2316058874130249,
0.3492699861526489,
-0.4032185971736908,
0.0487845204770565,
0.0890287384390831,
0.6367166638374329,
0.5649487972259521,
-0.08388738334178925,
-0.10095900297164917,
-0.1431071013212204,
0.16199536621570587,
0.09595537930727005,
-0.4502321481704712,
-0.02863645926117897,
0.38502585887908936,
-0.4444211721420288,
-0.0525023452937603,
0.19108648598194122,
-1.0739009380340576,
-0.5268287062644958,
-0.18815559148788452,
0.006985427811741829,
-0.2705131769180298,
-0.621041476726532,
0.057598065584897995,
-0.25423991680145264,
-0.0009728856384754181,
0.00413712952286005,
-0.3590568006038666,
-0.009450485929846764,
0.5008575916290283,
0.8590543270111084,
-0.346280574798584,
-0.6593469977378845,
-0.14222443103790283,
0.19122107326984406,
-0.3707846999168396,
0.6851677298545837,
-0.9465340375900269,
-0.4105077385902405,
0.10621585696935654,
0.06605969369411469,
0.17922130227088928,
-0.7151572108268738,
0.7014356255531311,
-0.3161552846431732,
0.1387200653553009,
-0.30889955163002014,
-0.3435397744178772,
-0.3754584789276123,
-0.004826729651540518,
-1.08673894405365,
0.8354938626289368,
0.44654175639152527,
-0.3627209961414337,
0.4659137725830078,
-0.7301538586616516,
-0.41431137919425964,
0.46814683079719543,
-0.1270667016506195,
-0.18116796016693115,
0.005747081711888313,
0.36188605427742004,
0.3473271429538727,
-0.5013650059700012,
0.31911084055900574,
-0.5485982894897461,
-0.13147246837615967,
-0.10296952724456787,
-0.44749173521995544,
0.7927348017692566,
0.7804301977157593,
-0.34173303842544556,
-0.04322409629821777,
-0.5410689115524292,
0.03644715994596481,
-0.024918725714087486,
-0.20712074637413025,
-0.6075201034545898,
-0.24950020015239716,
0.336818665266037,
0.1526162326335907,
0.32949426770210266,
-0.3403759002685547,
0.3151019811630249,
0.10081092268228531,
0.712579607963562,
0.6587795615196228,
-0.1968165785074234,
0.6566616892814636,
-0.3141722083091736,
0.9795191884040833,
0.35287654399871826,
0.09795162081718445,
-0.33918124437332153,
-0.2923603355884552,
-0.5110018253326416,
-0.5697802901268005,
0.07064074277877808,
0.4583010673522949,
-1.2325701713562012,
0.14796476066112518,
-0.2919710874557495,
-0.8411328196525574,
-1.2744604349136353,
0.18635737895965576,
0.12201875448226929,
-0.04287141561508179,
0.3570125699043274,
-0.37339502573013306,
-0.7962970733642578,
-0.7542349696159363,
0.19661103188991547,
-0.3465157151222229,
0.14011447131633759,
0.4598599076271057,
0.15024806559085846,
-0.581654965877533,
0.7451822757720947,
0.11319324374198914,
-0.5712274312973022,
-0.4642832279205322,
0.11446026712656021,
-0.07129307836294174,
0.4670222997665405,
0.65268474817276,
-0.8366033434867859,
-0.43906494975090027,
-0.013768065720796585,
-0.9681096076965332,
-0.46614643931388855,
-0.10562025755643845,
-0.1943240612745285,
0.19639961421489716,
0.6706965565681458,
-0.7872136235237122,
0.11348402500152588,
0.9692592620849609,
-0.1441354751586914,
0.39034441113471985,
0.024845832958817482,
0.19884715974330902,
-1.0092321634292603,
0.15133900940418243,
-0.23424308001995087,
0.2723826766014099,
-0.4162207543849945,
0.6852614283561707,
-0.33106088638305664,
-0.6077362298965454,
-0.16478203237056732,
0.7227501273155212,
-0.46055838465690613,
-0.24491101503372192,
-0.14156220853328705,
0.4363599717617035,
-0.23153027892112732,
0.18076784908771515,
0.2772005796432495,
1.1731128692626953,
0.6548478603363037,
-0.4316417872905731,
0.5393801927566528,
0.24345992505550385,
-0.2730062007904053,
0.7324886322021484,
-0.5946691036224365,
-0.12293381989002228,
-0.1970873922109604,
0.2908070981502533,
-0.89394611120224,
-0.24113458395004272,
-0.11727815121412277,
0.043795954436063766,
-0.2845856845378876,
-0.025734486058354378,
-0.17733314633369446,
-0.40006670355796814,
-0.3293498754501343,
0.9985980987548828,
0.06904307752847672,
-0.5584625005722046,
0.6121317148208618,
0.8820461630821228,
-0.6664495468139648,
-0.6141742467880249,
-0.6249411702156067,
0.17911916971206665,
-0.255795955657959,
-0.5882726311683655,
0.20127595961093903,
-0.00191877456381917,
-0.508575975894928,
0.06522097438573837,
0.21085475385189056,
-0.44746363162994385,
0.02087208442389965,
0.35431602597236633,
0.14354658126831055,
-0.49525800347328186,
0.046505458652973175,
0.06988848745822906,
-0.15373578667640686,
-0.13279905915260315,
-0.3307300806045532,
0.6919119954109192,
-0.27294921875,
-0.7253071665763855,
-0.45760518312454224,
0.22900329530239105,
1.1023789644241333,
-0.5393163561820984,
0.4475041925907135,
0.7465710639953613,
-0.17442819476127625,
0.09260812401771545,
-0.6304783821105957,
0.11693016439676285,
-0.4040038287639618,
0.34904202818870544,
-0.4548719525337219,
-0.881440281867981,
0.6890433430671692,
-0.06881747394800186,
0.07670988887548447,
0.36543890833854675,
0.21915794909000397,
0.05914785712957382,
0.8011727929115295,
0.8502882122993469,
-0.7321276068687439,
0.12475452572107315,
-0.16480347514152527,
0.11511202901601791,
-0.477536678314209,
-0.11477329581975937,
-0.55964195728302,
-0.32067903876304626,
-0.8667857646942139,
-0.5762295722961426,
0.5982519388198853,
0.19021724164485931,
-0.04285053163766861,
0.3779529631137848,
-0.41499513387680054,
0.4143597185611725,
0.8013018369674683,
-0.06676331907510757,
0.43490779399871826,
-0.031663209199905396,
-0.08180749416351318,
-0.3495585322380066,
-0.9438354969024658,
-0.6957303881645203,
1.1640123128890991,
0.07865098118782043,
0.589765191078186,
0.23547735810279846,
0.49822720885276794,
0.5069072246551514,
0.005955540109425783,
-0.15228398144245148,
0.3653143644332886,
-0.10703901201486588,
-0.40263932943344116,
-0.5335248112678528,
-0.28345975279808044,
-1.0606886148452759,
0.4307705760002136,
0.17462347447872162,
0.07068170607089996,
0.27829688787460327,
-0.25038421154022217,
-0.2195889949798584,
0.23026809096336365,
-0.6455013155937195,
0.8491736650466919,
-0.2867245078086853,
-0.22085638344287872,
-0.5875487923622131,
-0.48397403955459595,
0.3286846876144409,
-0.11485205590724945,
0.4547300934791565,
-0.010664409026503563,
-0.28528130054473877,
0.38994523882865906,
-0.6713481545448303,
0.782453179359436,
-0.24289879202842712,
-0.018807316198945045,
0.5015575885772705,
0.10460419952869415,
0.1295892298221588,
0.14265258610248566,
-0.322071373462677,
0.4474845826625824,
-0.0722750872373581,
-0.8602375984191895,
-0.09307324886322021,
0.4335940480232239,
-1.0659219026565552,
-0.11207941919565201,
-0.2971403896808624,
-0.3892473876476288,
0.04196968674659729,
0.0703013688325882,
0.1429290771484375,
0.07317246496677399,
-0.1717934012413025,
0.04753609374165535,
0.2207310050725937,
-0.47764211893081665,
0.47228187322616577,
0.507339358329773,
0.04839970916509628,
-0.5431485772132874,
0.979034960269928,
-0.06729504466056824,
-0.024953674525022507,
-0.07536428421735764,
-0.3025567829608917,
-0.4476073086261749,
-0.22132302820682526,
-0.5624633431434631,
0.04417145252227783,
-0.557841956615448,
-0.2710740268230438,
-0.33214840292930603,
-0.0460883229970932,
-0.3655393719673157,
-0.3967425227165222,
-0.5167853236198425,
-0.1840953230857849,
0.102828249335289,
-0.01404715608805418,
0.12049435079097748,
0.8134452700614929,
-0.39065802097320557,
0.2440914511680603,
-0.7125675678253174,
0.015260855667293072,
0.18480272591114044,
0.3357113301753998,
0.11417225748300552,
-0.2762787640094757,
0.029333287850022316,
0.2627590000629425,
-0.052674517035484314,
-0.42225298285484314,
0.49221479892730713,
0.20295798778533936,
0.7088230848312378,
0.6941505670547485,
0.25702986121177673,
1.1299041509628296,
-0.10175056755542755,
1.040999174118042,
-0.302422434091568,
-0.9508239030838013,
0.48832157254219055,
-0.03819701448082924,
0.5221865773200989,
0.6272711157798767,
0.6215102076530457,
-1.0243232250213623,
-0.6249220967292786,
-0.6202518939971924,
-0.7359615564346313,
0.447417676448822,
-0.1340181976556778,
0.055094555020332336,
0.05793258547782898,
-0.07860080152750015,
0.45919278264045715,
0.5046056509017944,
-0.4966912567615509,
0.09048736095428467,
-0.48491665720939636,
-0.199122816324234,
-0.10926607251167297,
-0.0744609460234642,
0.3321460783481598,
0.026793021708726883,
0.682498574256897,
-0.13341084122657776,
-0.03649858012795448,
-0.0756755918264389,
-0.49728280305862427,
-0.06737404316663742,
-0.059277527034282684,
0.5503935217857361,
0.5652512907981873,
0.3608202338218689,
0.21520531177520752,
0.1235392615199089,
-0.6975242495536804,
-0.051822371780872345,
0.021279282867908478,
-0.03448687493801117,
0.23039932548999786,
0.7749527096748352,
0.5136486291885376,
0.09165149182081223,
-1.2593839168548584,
0.5044376850128174,
-0.028898481279611588,
0.2917982041835785,
-0.1804521083831787,
-0.20234738290309906,
-0.241324782371521,
0.48399513959884644,
0.5274935960769653,
0.01487815286964178,
-0.042444996535778046,
-0.5415747165679932,
0.25585028529167175,
0.216403067111969,
-0.2285575270652771,
-0.20082511007785797,
0.7251537442207336,
0.5814645886421204,
0.06803859770298004,
1.1993921995162964,
-0.4038468301296234,
-0.7005593180656433,
0.4615090787410736,
-0.0173003189265728,
0.5744020938873291,
-0.4704676866531372,
0.34063616394996643,
0.46680179238319397,
0.41678789258003235,
-0.05969805642962456,
0.5515826940536499,
0.08478978276252747,
-0.7194505929946899,
-0.25656819343566895,
-0.46750643849372864,
-0.5376133322715759,
0.347873330116272,
-0.5687693953514099,
0.3318805694580078,
-0.3688758313655853,
-0.10570944845676422,
-0.5386388897895813,
0.05095810443162918,
-0.7192450165748596,
-0.2840985953807831,
0.1462778002023697,
0.8021404147148132,
-0.9985790252685547,
0.3466998040676117,
0.7753817439079285,
-0.779752254486084,
-0.3956708312034607,
-0.3543500006198883,
0.07755953818559647,
-0.8102698922157288,
0.4106992185115814,
0.0731431394815445,
0.1766718477010727,
-0.2125547081232071,
-0.7602130174636841,
-1.054735779762268,
1.099525809288025,
0.3357492685317993,
-0.4797958433628082,
0.3152928948402405,
0.7013542056083679,
0.7432502508163452,
-0.5600142478942871,
0.402378112077713,
0.4380744993686676,
0.6718529462814331,
-0.40167713165283203,
-1.1107890605926514,
-0.1474667191505432,
-0.46503424644470215,
0.2934277057647705,
-0.3245263397693634,
-0.9358338117599487,
0.8226045966148376,
-0.2876802682876587,
-0.38974684476852417,
0.24150845408439636,
0.5856425762176514,
0.593946099281311,
0.18143999576568604,
0.3843079209327698,
0.4442017376422882,
0.941032886505127,
-0.25161030888557434,
0.6532428860664368,
-0.8150821328163147,
-0.1038210391998291,
0.856482207775116,
-0.5581932067871094,
0.90092933177948,
0.20354580879211426,
-0.09782501310110092,
0.28103601932525635,
0.6556104421615601,
-0.14252543449401855,
0.491120308637619,
-0.15510977804660797,
-0.2391630858182907,
-0.1604287177324295,
-0.6567856669425964,
-0.39913392066955566,
0.8841263055801392,
0.2892514765262604,
0.1838148534297943,
-0.38319382071495056,
0.48400089144706726,
-0.10854201018810272,
0.24261049926280975,
-0.2402995079755783,
0.5547062754631042,
-0.2417982816696167,
-0.6088899970054626,
0.3108390271663666,
0.005758537445217371,
0.7412989735603333,
-0.1678077131509781,
-0.14372317492961884,
-0.7657253742218018,
0.01116318628191948,
0.04767085239291191,
-0.700168251991272,
0.014113630168139935,
-0.09872294962406158,
0.003035514149814844,
-0.2780941128730774,
0.22387173771858215,
-0.9200615286827087,
-0.25063592195510864,
0.07489287108182907,
0.7960348725318909,
0.420687198638916,
-0.20701077580451965,
-0.8046045303344727,
0.5627710819244385,
-0.17884530127048492,
0.4600706100463867,
-0.03957134485244751,
0.9390397071838379,
-0.5310083627700806,
1.1158355474472046,
0.6114791631698608,
0.1911066770553589,
0.03207731619477272,
0.027901746332645416,
0.5964997410774231,
-0.4383617043495178,
-0.6388934850692749,
-0.541480541229248,
0.1723438799381256,
-0.1274440437555313,
-0.7092716097831726,
0.5825803279876709,
0.8253971934318542,
1.2681866884231567,
-0.09949862957000732,
1.1187009811401367,
-0.08947896957397461,
0.4032309353351593,
-0.16629363596439362,
0.8615578413009644,
-0.2999688684940338,
0.25500327348709106,
-0.2795826494693756,
-0.9350466728210449,
0.03093184344470501,
0.6032097935676575,
0.2057565301656723,
0.05121160298585892,
0.5094808340072632,
0.7350048422813416,
-0.06852860003709793,
0.20033426582813263,
0.18237169086933136,
0.23226682841777802,
0.29157400131225586,
0.43398937582969666,
0.815761387348175,
-0.4924566149711609,
0.6740590929985046,
-0.39695706963539124,
0.0014749056426808238,
-0.24030081927776337,
-0.4707881808280945,
-0.6366602182388306,
-1.0150164365768433,
-0.19565200805664062,
0.103683240711689,
0.005868236534297466,
1.0059306621551514,
0.7718316316604614,
-0.9459714889526367,
-0.7011527419090271,
0.1290169209241867,
0.003387047676369548,
-0.3769005239009857,
-0.22401376068592072,
0.2556970715522766,
-0.3812197148799896,
-0.7905867695808411,
0.3896426856517792,
0.392080157995224,
0.23862481117248535,
-0.7208508253097534,
-0.25172820687294006,
0.1468699723482132,
-0.41761675477027893,
0.645499587059021,
0.252342164516449,
-0.6520527601242065,
0.23901303112506866,
-0.08672644942998886,
-0.45812544226646423,
-0.3928307890892029,
0.6016963720321655,
-0.7270941734313965,
0.33776959776878357,
0.15216588973999023,
0.8477796316146851,
0.02574172243475914,
0.046306416392326355,
0.8134686350822449,
-0.6522219777107239,
0.5630940198898315,
0.175924152135849,
0.2730504274368286,
0.39997589588165283,
-0.012220347300171852,
1.0124255418777466,
0.34284526109695435,
-0.3559201955795288,
-0.9253695607185364,
-0.16216973960399628,
-0.6027783155441284,
-0.3727863132953644,
0.7903966307640076,
-0.11476515978574753,
0.006282827351242304,
-0.32223719358444214,
-0.1954672783613205,
0.010951623320579529,
-0.6068726181983948,
1.0362131595611572,
0.9083165526390076,
0.35034728050231934,
-0.33297058939933777,
-0.5767763257026672,
0.5898635983467102,
0.3945516347885132,
-0.8251788020133972,
0.2931998074054718,
0.6247709393501282,
-0.2362903505563736,
0.2956908643245697,
0.4771965444087982,
0.13769526779651642,
0.4353680908679962,
0.16153578460216522,
0.23707017302513123,
0.286461740732193,
-0.37288784980773926,
-0.2143969088792801,
0.056795913726091385,
-0.10293080657720566,
0.16756010055541992
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10099v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10099v1
|
Know the Unknown: An Uncertainty-Sensitive Method for LLM Instruction Tuning
| 2024-06-14T14:56:04 | 2024-06-14T14:56:04 |
Jiaqi Li, Yixuan Tang, Yi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities across
various tasks but still face challenges such as hallucinations. One potential
reason for hallucinations is the lack of relevant knowledge or context. Thus, a
promising solution to mitigate this issue involves instructing LLMs to respond
with "I do not know" when a question falls outside their knowledge domain or
the provided context. However, in this work, we observed that LLMs struggle to
admit their lack of knowledge, primarily due to existing instruction datasets
designed to encourage specific answers. To improve large language models'
capability to recognize the boundaries of their knowledge, we propose a novel
approach called uncertainty-sensitive tuning. This method involves two-stage
training designed for uncertainty recognition and prompt-sensitive activation.
In the first stage, we guide the LLM to reject unknown questions. In the second
stage, we recover the decreased performance in QA tasks by incorporating
designed causal instructions. By leveraging this method, we aim to enhance the
model's ability to identify areas of uncertainty. The experimental results
demonstrate that our proposed uncertainty-sensitive tuning method significantly
improves the performance of the Llama2-chat-7B model. Specifically, it achieves
a substantial 34.7% improvement in handling questions involving knowledge gaps
compared to the original model. Moreover, our approach outperforms GPT-4,
exhibiting a 9.4% increase in overall performance. We open-source the model and
code on GitHub.
|
[
-0.32588064670562744,
-1.0268288850784302,
0.6743029952049255,
0.04251905158162117,
-0.06103021278977394,
0.06338433176279068,
-0.3062993288040161,
-0.3584005832672119,
-0.31639036536216736,
0.33316507935523987,
-0.8356221914291382,
-0.5548831224441528,
-0.6484641432762146,
-0.2204335629940033,
-0.035857826471328735,
0.5415139198303223,
0.007658622693270445,
0.09740935266017914,
0.03847607597708702,
0.2276829034090042,
-0.6139513254165649,
-0.06370369344949722,
-0.8852646946907043,
-0.011851434595882893,
0.38044077157974243,
0.46486419439315796,
0.5203336477279663,
0.8168023228645325,
0.47050485014915466,
0.24884602427482605,
-0.2741466462612152,
0.4271538555622101,
-0.5483361482620239,
0.174626424908638,
-0.1566406935453415,
-0.7655324935913086,
-0.2500440776348114,
-0.32428786158561707,
0.515058696269989,
0.6501144766807556,
-0.20518431067466736,
0.13436682522296906,
-0.039023227989673615,
0.518173336982727,
-0.7794584035873413,
0.24457263946533203,
-1.0069100856781006,
0.15697383880615234,
0.020533621311187744,
-0.3042706549167633,
-0.39667561650276184,
-0.3587411344051361,
0.02903069742023945,
-0.740558385848999,
0.23694179952144623,
0.13263900578022003,
0.6809476613998413,
0.7651932835578918,
-0.4605013132095337,
-0.29501092433929443,
-0.8186901807785034,
0.5871800780296326,
-0.7135453820228577,
0.36340266466140747,
0.6802231669425964,
0.3579973876476288,
-0.3303413987159729,
-0.419131338596344,
-0.3446063697338104,
0.010591774247586727,
0.2802087962627411,
-0.07892744243144989,
-0.21921488642692566,
0.13531360030174255,
0.32882410287857056,
0.16751700639724731,
-0.4634196162223816,
0.50030916929245,
-0.39086443185806274,
-0.43365478515625,
0.26281362771987915,
0.1202908381819725,
-0.019452981650829315,
0.236971914768219,
-0.3004171550273895,
0.05463648587465286,
-0.7861579656600952,
0.1024395152926445,
0.4820941388607025,
0.16281500458717346,
0.005403677932918072,
0.5448812246322632,
-0.20332004129886627,
0.9175562858581543,
0.3043898940086365,
-0.1596667617559433,
-0.11253077536821365,
0.34281980991363525,
-0.04052487760782242,
0.010794909670948982,
0.37757056951522827,
0.2712840139865875,
0.06403078138828278,
-0.09111788868904114,
-0.21566690504550934,
-0.12337625026702881,
0.30090996623039246,
-0.5231713652610779,
-0.20677855610847473,
0.16517674922943115,
0.0718064159154892,
-0.1344367414712906,
-0.30708742141723633,
-0.698285698890686,
-0.6303843855857849,
-0.22316387295722961,
0.7992776036262512,
-0.44241273403167725,
-0.0936066135764122,
0.22247545421123505,
0.1809232383966446,
0.40327584743499756,
0.48552873730659485,
-0.948815107345581,
0.20500491559505463,
0.4656972587108612,
0.43708062171936035,
-0.08172641694545746,
-0.03982188552618027,
-0.609535276889801,
0.20306865870952606,
-0.5843573212623596,
0.7490230798721313,
-0.5308007597923279,
-0.10899071395397186,
-0.009035839699208736,
-0.24514728784561157,
-0.12317707389593124,
-0.6330257058143616,
0.43314799666404724,
-0.7436349987983704,
0.16722294688224792,
-0.2384721040725708,
-0.6660374999046326,
-0.28151020407676697,
0.20308615267276764,
-0.5563988089561462,
0.9414311051368713,
0.33683472871780396,
-0.62229984998703,
0.053333669900894165,
-0.41255518794059753,
-0.17011147737503052,
-0.017002640292048454,
-0.15808376669883728,
-0.355010986328125,
0.09348561614751816,
0.490746408700943,
0.17008869349956512,
-0.1556892693042755,
0.2285471111536026,
-0.31334343552589417,
-0.6024405360221863,
0.3259247839450836,
-0.5416579246520996,
0.3708912432193756,
0.10509955137968063,
-0.3444623649120331,
0.05508589372038841,
-0.7362864017486572,
0.34623974561691284,
-0.06384818255901337,
-0.31467822194099426,
-0.187077134847641,
-0.11273057013750076,
-0.5859398245811462,
0.01790216565132141,
0.36824652552604675,
-0.08688358217477798,
0.10806602239608765,
-0.5325789451599121,
0.21290192008018494,
0.9909780621528625,
0.23682619631290436,
0.37324127554893494,
-0.33039310574531555,
0.7089542746543884,
0.093537837266922,
0.26973825693130493,
0.02624564617872238,
-0.40847286581993103,
-1.1466991901397705,
0.16875717043876648,
0.10996681451797485,
0.7531093955039978,
-0.8008254766464233,
0.4213744103908539,
0.1685841977596283,
-0.43092501163482666,
-0.819645881652832,
0.190464586019516,
0.4535846710205078,
0.7124109268188477,
0.4060773551464081,
0.2244625985622406,
-0.5053620338439941,
-0.7463645339012146,
-0.3585710823535919,
-0.26064684987068176,
-0.11153924465179443,
0.4288213551044464,
0.2287246584892273,
-0.030764391645789146,
0.6120372414588928,
-0.6633243560791016,
-0.15977416932582855,
0.16246294975280762,
0.10449991375207901,
0.0797855332493782,
0.3433016240596771,
-0.07646259665489197,
-0.6068060994148254,
-0.23217584192752838,
-0.009600521996617317,
-0.5595622658729553,
-0.09121457487344742,
0.014611116610467434,
-0.16099046170711517,
0.12541013956069946,
0.614904522895813,
-0.5086197853088379,
0.22897975146770477,
0.490898460149765,
-0.10499019920825958,
0.3897378146648407,
-0.27926304936408997,
0.04003796726465225,
-0.9964200854301453,
-0.22386708855628967,
-0.26144111156463623,
0.04606623575091362,
-0.5046868324279785,
-0.033907052129507065,
0.36550796031951904,
0.11831886321306229,
-0.42972439527511597,
0.4193881154060364,
-0.48068562150001526,
0.22626356780529022,
-0.2874452769756317,
0.16636379063129425,
-0.22610527276992798,
0.6602736711502075,
0.07589641213417053,
0.8607556819915771,
0.7020925283432007,
-0.7454575896263123,
0.0902237743139267,
0.0419919528067112,
-0.5511409640312195,
0.5148213505744934,
-0.43337148427963257,
0.49985218048095703,
-0.14864692091941833,
-0.2914571762084961,
-0.8940272331237793,
-0.3401622772216797,
0.47129860520362854,
-0.4818061292171478,
0.5863767862319946,
-0.14193610846996307,
-0.0910087302327156,
-0.394436776638031,
0.07295305281877518,
0.1948738396167755,
0.4166354537010193,
-0.33583754301071167,
0.559658944606781,
0.2817182242870331,
-0.1897076964378357,
-0.8252862095832825,
-0.3808712661266327,
-0.15477097034454346,
-0.3308808207511902,
-0.36790621280670166,
0.08783823251724243,
-0.3561321794986725,
-0.21802596747875214,
-0.1601257026195526,
-0.5760508179664612,
-0.27199822664260864,
0.34662187099456787,
0.27153611183166504,
0.04573884233832359,
-0.17451909184455872,
0.5033159852027893,
0.5120046734809875,
-0.08640730381011963,
0.15969155728816986,
-0.36950576305389404,
0.4426988363265991,
-0.004874662030488253,
-0.39826858043670654,
-0.3486122488975525,
0.0318206325173378,
0.12985460460186005,
-0.2250836342573166,
0.6349875926971436,
0.7979534864425659,
-0.5126562118530273,
-0.6641244292259216,
-0.6637260317802429,
-0.33577537536621094,
-0.5413827300071716,
0.5171321034431458,
-0.32408374547958374,
-1.1479597091674805,
0.5438455939292908,
-0.2964242100715637,
-0.390438437461853,
0.19864951074123383,
0.602954626083374,
-0.014681785367429256,
0.8367400169372559,
0.839249849319458,
0.033409930765628815,
0.3405044376850128,
0.09048686921596527,
0.24689729511737823,
-0.8232415318489075,
-0.3061484694480896,
-0.5147624611854553,
-0.17058609426021576,
-0.3070818781852722,
-0.6564053297042847,
0.5831769108772278,
0.1713142842054367,
-0.3634837865829468,
-0.056436169892549515,
-0.3864162266254425,
0.5998253226280212,
0.5797214508056641,
0.4607197940349579,
0.2517436444759369,
-0.1751329004764557,
0.05433793365955353,
-0.023214256390929222,
-0.651677131652832,
-0.48900535702705383,
1.0331385135650635,
0.34968075156211853,
0.9393981099128723,
0.03152177855372429,
0.44115209579467773,
0.09167904406785965,
0.029591159895062447,
-0.6490153074264526,
0.32965514063835144,
0.5203266739845276,
-0.7049843072891235,
-0.5941768288612366,
-0.5903617143630981,
-0.7836001515388489,
0.008569729514420033,
-0.12228148430585861,
-0.9270668625831604,
0.06119474768638611,
0.1256442666053772,
-0.6428766250610352,
0.35793590545654297,
-0.8873449563980103,
0.5484365224838257,
-0.23447981476783752,
-0.21878309547901154,
0.14091145992279053,
-0.748881459236145,
0.4182232916355133,
-0.43385568261146545,
0.21997100114822388,
-0.17291361093521118,
-0.2739095985889435,
0.657521665096283,
-0.01854725182056427,
1.026045322418213,
-0.1248939037322998,
-0.47352999448776245,
0.23936901986598969,
0.29320579767227173,
0.8261732459068298,
0.2660684883594513,
-0.13135406374931335,
-0.051909126341342926,
-0.2458718717098236,
-0.11072798818349838,
-0.7336401343345642,
0.6274734139442444,
-0.9002805948257446,
-0.8203177452087402,
-0.018637657165527344,
-0.9629291892051697,
-0.6217539310455322,
0.1869751662015915,
0.4320201575756073,
-0.1599036604166031,
-0.049273960292339325,
-0.1731719970703125,
1.2235863208770752,
-0.36382654309272766,
0.1844538301229477,
0.9686039090156555,
0.01841377653181553,
-0.2204028069972992,
0.5818836092948914,
0.15957164764404297,
0.3543623685836792,
0.7511292695999146,
0.03986829146742821,
-0.1991199553012848,
-0.674139142036438,
-0.21563847362995148,
-0.015988370403647423,
-0.7304120659828186,
-0.44539281725883484,
-0.5495318174362183,
-0.37599101662635803,
-0.3225368857383728,
0.12672963738441467,
-0.384321391582489,
-0.26321959495544434,
-0.6328465938568115,
-0.31643858551979065,
0.4851192235946655,
0.6549757719039917,
0.06578762829303741,
0.6104094982147217,
-0.3156455457210541,
0.26316937804222107,
0.4298492670059204,
0.5797497034072876,
-0.16685952246189117,
-0.9478098750114441,
-0.23687629401683807,
0.24872185289859772,
-0.236006960272789,
-0.9115665555000305,
0.4111194908618927,
0.2447522133588791,
0.5989605188369751,
0.49966737627983093,
0.3840315043926239,
0.5982147455215454,
-0.22125302255153656,
0.33261221647262573,
-0.3523377776145935,
-1.072609782218933,
0.7652270197868347,
-0.34245431423187256,
0.22772420942783356,
0.3804415464401245,
0.45516327023506165,
-0.1207636222243309,
-0.6656466126441956,
-0.3746383488178253,
-0.6750261783599854,
0.7702570557594299,
0.10625659674406052,
0.03172818571329117,
0.24383226037025452,
0.523097038269043,
0.1765124648809433,
0.29989808797836304,
-0.6027786135673523,
-0.31624677777290344,
0.3364149332046509,
-0.18381215631961823,
-0.1055656224489212,
-0.3424462080001831,
-0.22165745496749878,
-0.156096950173378,
0.5353163480758667,
-0.20083926618099213,
0.3083866834640503,
0.0015834593214094639,
-0.08389526605606079,
-0.5525121688842773,
0.2058081477880478,
0.5704797506332397,
0.783290684223175,
-0.3450925052165985,
0.25476133823394775,
0.44277137517929077,
-0.4432263672351837,
0.17739653587341309,
0.07504782825708389,
-0.16616535186767578,
-0.39585167169570923,
0.3701035678386688,
1.102963924407959,
0.17011839151382446,
-0.6245622634887695,
0.2853752076625824,
-0.11593412607908249,
-0.13032184541225433,
-0.3842003643512726,
0.42044875025749207,
0.14252224564552307,
0.5263836979866028,
0.24913530051708221,
0.11717254668474197,
0.023403644561767578,
-0.056826841086149216,
0.15628787875175476,
0.2637924253940582,
-0.5946530103683472,
-0.05881906673312187,
0.7415822744369507,
-0.2221042364835739,
-0.5447805523872375,
0.5827348232269287,
-0.24831648170948029,
-0.2964000701904297,
0.717166006565094,
0.7650822997093201,
0.5206120014190674,
-0.5754626393318176,
0.2520444691181183,
0.20593790709972382,
0.662887454032898,
0.09269949793815613,
0.4351927638053894,
0.08553478121757507,
-0.7821788191795349,
-0.3244801163673401,
-0.3459867238998413,
-0.46887290477752686,
0.23391011357307434,
-0.8322656750679016,
0.24879057705402374,
-0.5385057330131531,
-0.07298271358013153,
-0.38682547211647034,
-0.07443449646234512,
-0.6669524312019348,
0.08631563186645508,
0.02597392164170742,
0.7338854670524597,
-0.7779515981674194,
0.718995988368988,
0.43494901061058044,
-0.062155336141586304,
-1.1601406335830688,
0.11123181134462357,
-0.04353295639157295,
-1.0966053009033203,
0.06386234611272812,
-0.02775881439447403,
0.11188926547765732,
0.24604438245296478,
-0.6521744728088379,
-1.0716118812561035,
1.1152973175048828,
0.6737024188041687,
-0.8178450465202332,
0.06824671477079391,
-0.0382896363735199,
0.4994053542613983,
-0.1433238536119461,
0.21896372735500336,
0.536436915397644,
0.4829782247543335,
0.18860271573066711,
-0.630082368850708,
0.04675385728478432,
-0.1200680360198021,
-0.23310460150241852,
0.19394849240779877,
-0.6604983806610107,
0.763286828994751,
-0.6290485262870789,
-0.14086057245731354,
0.04610438644886017,
0.6129951477050781,
0.1734401434659958,
0.29386377334594727,
0.3384632170200348,
0.3686738610267639,
1.401687502861023,
-0.09713052958250046,
0.6136575937271118,
-0.42570188641548157,
0.16480764746665955,
1.3674827814102173,
-0.19713330268859863,
0.7681922912597656,
0.496377170085907,
-0.07177482545375824,
0.2274438589811325,
0.7941769361495972,
0.09181264042854309,
0.48547062277793884,
0.3913499414920807,
-0.34042954444885254,
-0.5474264025688171,
-0.03615625575184822,
-0.5353834629058838,
0.34069839119911194,
0.6089355945587158,
-0.23286151885986328,
-0.037048958241939545,
0.0741613507270813,
0.011249317787587643,
-0.0023832290899008512,
-0.3614918291568756,
0.8148884177207947,
0.07895226776599884,
-0.6911840438842773,
0.8294842839241028,
0.014453107491135597,
0.1982596218585968,
-0.688086748123169,
0.012001904658973217,
-0.3219769299030304,
0.15420733392238617,
0.12530767917633057,
-0.6604657173156738,
-0.009144020266830921,
-0.18615883588790894,
-0.14394588768482208,
0.2520875036716461,
0.5889953374862671,
-0.579522967338562,
-0.4950195252895355,
0.1816723644733429,
0.5840173959732056,
0.06094682216644287,
-0.2775990068912506,
-0.4446162283420563,
0.14403854310512543,
0.09208539873361588,
-0.14591725170612335,
0.1818513572216034,
0.8240026235580444,
-0.058113791048526764,
1.0982197523117065,
0.2441464364528656,
0.044643647968769073,
0.14939133822917938,
-0.08680637925863266,
0.8673585653305054,
-0.46662601828575134,
-0.1329728215932846,
-0.5457382202148438,
0.29624322056770325,
0.25832247734069824,
-0.449218213558197,
0.7078857421875,
0.3346647620201111,
0.8050931096076965,
-0.20108698308467865,
0.7194466590881348,
0.19764061272144318,
0.6424185633659363,
-0.7234440445899963,
0.5156800150871277,
-0.34634819626808167,
0.72636479139328,
-0.11392872780561447,
-0.7705329060554504,
-0.3997262418270111,
0.543259859085083,
-0.4077818989753723,
0.1951102912425995,
0.6672662496566772,
1.234287977218628,
0.1616881787776947,
-0.07480697333812714,
0.3754155933856964,
0.4563298225402832,
0.0709478035569191,
0.901816189289093,
1.0460319519042969,
-0.38551706075668335,
0.6874934434890747,
-0.30383485555648804,
-0.24021226167678833,
-0.06149320676922798,
-0.66717928647995,
-0.975732684135437,
-0.5042238235473633,
-0.2353198528289795,
-0.14362937211990356,
0.329232394695282,
0.7029111981391907,
0.611306369304657,
-0.7165284752845764,
0.05922283977270126,
-0.0948169007897377,
0.5455999374389648,
-0.2773381471633911,
-0.10633768886327744,
0.38599732518196106,
-0.5449631810188293,
-0.5309170484542847,
0.504136323928833,
0.19202829897403717,
0.16869162023067474,
-0.15539482235908508,
-0.13734441995620728,
-0.0031759298872202635,
0.2029879093170166,
0.11567199975252151,
0.03596421331167221,
-0.5485962629318237,
-0.342546671628952,
0.15036730468273163,
-0.008943183347582817,
-0.030801590532064438,
0.4917367696762085,
-0.47689786553382874,
0.4936888813972473,
0.023911993950605392,
0.46328017115592957,
0.38606172800064087,
0.04311163350939751,
0.5305277109146118,
-0.721014142036438,
0.038194186985492706,
0.35551026463508606,
0.0018433263758197427,
0.17372147738933563,
-0.7349939942359924,
0.33289608359336853,
-0.059481099247932434,
-0.6096135973930359,
-0.7008463144302368,
0.2434820979833603,
-0.9045699834823608,
-0.32147014141082764,
1.1593201160430908,
-0.18335433304309845,
-0.194652259349823,
-0.1457773596048355,
-0.4143107235431671,
0.39480575919151306,
-0.30758458375930786,
1.209834337234497,
0.5585324168205261,
0.2276628315448761,
-0.3448755741119385,
-0.5864261388778687,
0.501512885093689,
0.3927931487560272,
-0.6805453896522522,
-0.008115221746265888,
0.3467344641685486,
0.24409830570220947,
-0.323395311832428,
0.3217364251613617,
0.09054821729660034,
0.16283829510211945,
-0.001959360670298338,
0.11433906108140945,
-0.07127192616462708,
-0.4627930819988251,
-0.408531129360199,
0.2352691888809204,
0.46933358907699585,
-0.049699556082487106
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10091v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10091v1
|
Exploring the Correlation between Human and Machine Evaluation of Simultaneous Speech Translation
| 2024-06-14T14:47:19 | 2024-06-14T14:47:19 |
Xiaoman Wang, Claudio Fantinuoli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Assessing the performance of interpreting services is a complex task, given
the nuanced nature of spoken language translation, the strategies that
interpreters apply, and the diverse expectations of users. The complexity of
this task become even more pronounced when automated evaluation methods are
applied. This is particularly true because interpreted texts exhibit less
linearity between the source and target languages due to the strategies
employed by the interpreter.
This study aims to assess the reliability of automatic metrics in evaluating
simultaneous interpretations by analyzing their correlation with human
evaluations. We focus on a particular feature of interpretation quality, namely
translation accuracy or faithfulness. As a benchmark we use human assessments
performed by language experts, and evaluate how well sentence embeddings and
Large Language Models correlate with them. We quantify semantic similarity
between the source and translated texts without relying on a reference
translation. The results suggest GPT models, particularly GPT-3.5 with direct
prompting, demonstrate the strongest correlation with human judgment in terms
of semantic similarity between source and target texts, even when evaluating
short textual segments. Additionally, the study reveals that the size of the
context window has a notable impact on this correlation.
|
[
-0.0898914709687233,
-0.5747818946838379,
0.6885669231414795,
0.4262637794017792,
-0.48724445700645447,
0.07166633754968643,
-0.31565362215042114,
-0.6525051593780518,
-0.2566385865211487,
0.4091537892818451,
-0.12743735313415527,
-0.29156723618507385,
-0.6592371463775635,
0.30135345458984375,
-0.6476434469223022,
0.8759614825248718,
-0.21828700602054596,
0.5384661555290222,
-0.29606494307518005,
-0.3412778973579407,
-0.7435429096221924,
-0.4244624078273773,
-0.49656131863594055,
-0.48273995518684387,
0.08878955990076065,
-0.13750708103179932,
1.0963484048843384,
0.6111979484558105,
0.7140955328941345,
0.3520084619522095,
0.15268395841121674,
-0.05505729094147682,
-0.12136968225240707,
0.1275211125612259,
-0.26100796461105347,
-0.24166162312030792,
-0.31070759892463684,
0.3675132691860199,
0.731778085231781,
0.7667061686515808,
-0.028564371168613434,
0.2547483742237091,
0.41374871134757996,
0.3463933765888214,
-0.2098371982574463,
0.21126140654087067,
-0.49593788385391235,
-0.09864122420549393,
-0.07914483547210693,
-0.09918607026338577,
-0.3574494421482086,
-0.4278172254562378,
0.595525860786438,
-0.3773898780345917,
0.08982563763856888,
0.14279887080192566,
0.7809110879898071,
0.6828498840332031,
-0.5635097622871399,
-0.40099242329597473,
-0.6281527876853943,
0.9551774859428406,
-0.4906325936317444,
0.4864238202571869,
0.35176488757133484,
0.32100018858909607,
0.03468286246061325,
-0.6251457929611206,
-0.5391526222229004,
-0.6235430240631104,
-0.2979351878166199,
0.17022256553173065,
-0.32473304867744446,
-0.08099061995744705,
-0.09932258725166321,
0.28450778126716614,
-0.7355663180351257,
-0.03270694240927696,
-0.1069134846329689,
-0.41718217730522156,
0.7224202752113342,
0.22078120708465576,
0.6032416224479675,
-0.3814558982849121,
-0.4559369385242462,
-0.2478877753019333,
0.12646961212158203,
-0.19858556985855103,
0.3653593957424164,
-0.0326688215136528,
-0.15153154730796814,
0.5003325343132019,
-0.045505598187446594,
0.789311945438385,
-0.2800511121749878,
-0.03687331825494766,
0.33843937516212463,
-0.9177637100219727,
-0.22386781871318817,
-0.17746920883655548,
1.2140007019042969,
0.45707446336746216,
0.40220990777015686,
-0.4949105381965637,
-0.055281538516283035,
0.31461042165756226,
0.4338790774345398,
-0.22497159242630005,
0.20726372301578522,
0.06273645907640457,
-0.5327475666999817,
-0.2038527876138687,
0.3174397647380829,
-0.5489500164985657,
-0.04876130819320679,
-0.5214672684669495,
0.5858981609344482,
-0.4353468418121338,
-0.0028125622775405645,
0.05374583229422569,
-0.1047784686088562,
0.11781702190637589,
0.2070302516222,
-0.5167213678359985,
0.4707303047180176,
0.8175411224365234,
0.7807276248931885,
-0.44308382272720337,
-0.5905423164367676,
-0.7356399297714233,
-0.06272447854280472,
-0.23490822315216064,
0.6023787260055542,
-0.32358288764953613,
-0.17034853994846344,
-0.2881452739238739,
-0.3080299198627472,
-0.24106527864933014,
-0.423094242811203,
1.1017589569091797,
-0.43220949172973633,
0.30218905210494995,
0.11353472620248795,
-0.5136593580245972,
-0.2296822965145111,
-0.2010091096162796,
-0.6683926582336426,
0.729796826839447,
0.02863968163728714,
-0.67839515209198,
0.5723207592964172,
-0.4120247960090637,
-0.4130706489086151,
-0.01907186396420002,
-0.29948121309280396,
-0.3820873498916626,
0.17474617063999176,
0.26143282651901245,
0.17429731786251068,
-0.5381672382354736,
0.45620453357696533,
-0.1132628545165062,
-0.5066603422164917,
0.5249166488647461,
-0.7061010599136353,
0.6080591082572937,
0.26903489232063293,
-0.4197937548160553,
0.17101798951625824,
-0.43698278069496155,
0.14100854098796844,
-0.05695773661136627,
-0.149005725979805,
-0.30244189500808716,
0.08759671449661255,
0.18895921111106873,
0.31090226769447327,
0.1682301014661789,
-0.3230803906917572,
-0.17803797125816345,
-0.33382171392440796,
0.295802503824234,
0.4466644525527954,
0.14006008207798004,
0.20683185756206512,
-0.2007329910993576,
0.3953755497932434,
-0.12804274260997772,
0.23844625055789948,
0.07863495498895645,
-0.8075881600379944,
-0.28203636407852173,
-0.10648342221975327,
0.33815959095954895,
0.7426357269287109,
-0.4692332446575165,
0.6251534819602966,
-0.7403041124343872,
-0.3724057376384735,
-0.9025405645370483,
0.33134034276008606,
0.7704212665557861,
0.33031558990478516,
0.41570478677749634,
-0.7338993549346924,
-0.22887763381004333,
-0.9953449964523315,
-0.8428264856338501,
-0.2669224441051483,
-0.346400648355484,
0.16424448788166046,
0.40920570492744446,
-0.22144950926303864,
0.9958175420761108,
-0.10741927474737167,
-0.23509804904460907,
-0.009795080870389938,
0.5249623656272888,
0.18934430181980133,
0.31516385078430176,
0.39700570702552795,
-0.8004017472267151,
-0.7974247932434082,
0.08072579652070999,
-0.8306375741958618,
-0.3197738528251648,
-0.1776905357837677,
-0.05081566050648689,
0.13816384971141815,
-0.037937164306640625,
-0.3435283899307251,
0.5100847482681274,
0.7593954801559448,
-0.45553073287010193,
0.5253590941429138,
-0.2857859432697296,
0.47708675265312195,
-0.749815821647644,
0.20223820209503174,
-0.09523851424455643,
-0.2966274321079254,
-0.48787611722946167,
-0.0696801096200943,
-0.028490981087088585,
-0.007624094374477863,
-0.22952495515346527,
0.5120498538017273,
-0.3169914782047272,
-0.5111409425735474,
-0.08158543705940247,
0.4792322516441345,
0.057375796139240265,
0.1874902844429016,
-0.22938422858715057,
1.121813416481018,
0.2747076153755188,
-0.26107409596443176,
0.5154169201850891,
0.410896360874176,
-0.6388327479362488,
0.8012616038322449,
-0.6754505634307861,
0.5436415672302246,
0.29926279187202454,
0.23909388482570648,
-1.0890069007873535,
-0.18083760142326355,
0.11517764627933502,
-0.7436539530754089,
0.0899500921368599,
0.07435363531112671,
-0.7327139973640442,
-0.21774332225322723,
-0.056096721440553665,
0.3435313403606415,
0.5300807356834412,
-0.1928977370262146,
0.2407122105360031,
0.18842938542366028,
-0.1578816920518875,
-0.42224445939064026,
-0.8391788601875305,
0.387030690908432,
-0.09919534623622894,
-0.9822776913642883,
0.1771964728832245,
0.1270504742860794,
-0.5643567442893982,
0.0961909070611,
-0.21105869114398956,
-0.11132282763719559,
0.17367485165596008,
0.019136980175971985,
0.31277498602867126,
-0.1674090027809143,
-0.08379124104976654,
-0.01602051965892315,
-0.27213403582572937,
0.1028909832239151,
-0.44027554988861084,
0.25147899985313416,
-0.27322912216186523,
-0.5527406930923462,
-1.0662927627563477,
0.40339481830596924,
0.6946482062339783,
-0.16391541063785553,
0.7845591306686401,
0.7513521909713745,
0.0137132303789258,
0.6182701587677002,
-0.6684268116950989,
0.02256055176258087,
-0.29825353622436523,
0.24042324721813202,
-0.668114185333252,
-0.42669618129730225,
0.4774434268474579,
0.4228972792625427,
-0.2149512767791748,
0.5421025156974792,
0.49174362421035767,
0.03190193697810173,
1.359601378440857,
0.0052247741259634495,
-0.3255152404308319,
0.32090309262275696,
0.19061033427715302,
-0.12094280868768692,
-0.7373151779174805,
0.19927869737148285,
-0.6701870560646057,
-0.05340643227100372,
-0.4405808448791504,
-0.3804929554462433,
0.43194323778152466,
0.132456973195076,
0.15003621578216553,
0.36579152941703796,
-0.40136390924453735,
0.18173427879810333,
0.4422415792942047,
0.08756435662508011,
0.6442916989326477,
-0.0043904948979616165,
-0.2197268307209015,
-0.14406231045722961,
-0.24447216093540192,
-0.9554288983345032,
1.1619614362716675,
0.3326834440231323,
0.2736110985279083,
0.15600863099098206,
0.4253404140472412,
0.4102415442466736,
0.2693500220775604,
-0.5749549269676208,
0.2953631579875946,
-0.23318473994731903,
-0.4927055537700653,
-0.3986976146697998,
-0.6783674955368042,
-1.0452885627746582,
0.4916127920150757,
-0.1512030065059662,
-0.6967278718948364,
-0.29392799735069275,
-0.006421002093702555,
-0.17798638343811035,
-0.19977019727230072,
-0.994905948638916,
0.9912503361701965,
-0.5134837627410889,
-0.36923086643218994,
-0.5584752559661865,
-0.8071547150611877,
-0.00419370923191309,
-0.26140087842941284,
0.2847999632358551,
-0.026245761662721634,
-0.17093457281589508,
0.7410595417022705,
-0.027264554053544998,
0.3219987750053406,
0.040643226355314255,
0.056015171110630035,
0.16626320779323578,
0.06815851479768753,
0.3326302766799927,
-0.12884369492530823,
-0.4237350523471832,
0.49169495701789856,
0.23819835484027863,
-0.5132384896278381,
-0.7742798924446106,
0.42926299571990967,
-0.9177346229553223,
-0.41105836629867554,
-0.3133123517036438,
-0.5652035474777222,
-0.15443871915340424,
0.15222005546092987,
0.19409015774726868,
0.2703550457954407,
-0.3655727207660675,
0.00106342404615134,
-0.07403218001127243,
-0.13093866407871246,
-0.01892280951142311,
0.4138846695423126,
-0.10704689472913742,
-0.5315749645233154,
0.58185213804245,
-0.06741327792406082,
0.58875572681427,
0.2697206437587738,
0.2503350079059601,
-0.4612302780151367,
-0.6868895292282104,
-0.6908964514732361,
0.3493838310241699,
-0.5543476343154907,
0.26142510771751404,
-0.3816969394683838,
0.1325533390045166,
-0.4844811260700226,
0.21586619317531586,
-0.20778413116931915,
-0.21256624162197113,
-0.13254062831401825,
0.27029678225517273,
-0.07825769484043121,
0.7548314332962036,
0.1290317326784134,
0.18990160524845123,
-0.8958373069763184,
0.3100595772266388,
0.3685435652732849,
0.20430947840213776,
-0.17544226348400116,
-0.6713982820510864,
-0.19236892461776733,
0.1278945356607437,
-0.2567847669124603,
-0.9557034373283386,
0.31344959139823914,
-0.0028520305640995502,
0.6901349425315857,
0.061629898846149445,
-0.2465282827615738,
0.6763864159584045,
-0.5128166675567627,
0.7686434984207153,
0.06302089244127274,
-1.2856371402740479,
0.3908563554286957,
-0.2281910926103592,
0.2505936324596405,
0.7404148578643799,
0.12208937108516693,
-0.6561353206634521,
-0.5952212810516357,
-0.4564918279647827,
-0.47696593403816223,
0.7407733798027039,
0.5633841156959534,
-0.05887667462229729,
0.20246271789073944,
0.24106921255588531,
0.08080820739269257,
0.1152818500995636,
-0.29655441641807556,
-0.07142074406147003,
-0.06615652143955231,
-0.2531134784221649,
-0.45384398102760315,
0.0358249768614769,
-0.1183156669139862,
-0.1862918883562088,
0.23364536464214325,
-0.011800503358244896,
0.3277116119861603,
0.25821590423583984,
-0.3501325845718384,
-0.21765786409378052,
0.44292202591896057,
0.5409764051437378,
0.8568787574768066,
-0.3759661316871643,
0.0038768164813518524,
0.30474385619163513,
-0.5021162033081055,
0.035430874675512314,
0.05955072119832039,
0.03578444942831993,
0.199676513671875,
0.6595985293388367,
0.8515258431434631,
0.36901089549064636,
-0.315421462059021,
0.6143348813056946,
-0.16672416031360626,
0.27552902698516846,
-0.2815609276294708,
-0.20490281283855438,
-0.2306153029203415,
-0.05941879749298096,
0.3565259873867035,
0.20691418647766113,
0.23944509029388428,
-0.5361883640289307,
0.3485710322856903,
0.26279836893081665,
-0.5529472827911377,
-0.30541202425956726,
0.6374545693397522,
0.27113887667655945,
-0.48886698484420776,
0.7477785348892212,
-0.06962639093399048,
-0.5682216286659241,
0.2843046486377716,
0.11744125932455063,
1.0711387395858765,
-0.33630627393722534,
-0.05525805428624153,
0.17352040112018585,
0.2909640371799469,
-0.11555379629135132,
-0.1041436493396759,
-0.10453061014413834,
-0.489347368478775,
-0.6607106924057007,
-0.6156368851661682,
-0.5663389563560486,
-0.301950603723526,
-0.9738892912864685,
0.2663783133029938,
0.4205870032310486,
-0.2949238419532776,
0.07775512337684631,
0.05240469053387642,
-0.6604128479957581,
-0.08443763107061386,
-0.026774626225233078,
0.5432201623916626,
-0.9140563011169434,
0.9755086898803711,
0.6615191698074341,
-0.677269697189331,
-0.7086576819419861,
0.2639507055282593,
0.13281261920928955,
-0.7266132235527039,
0.6590315699577332,
-0.0025957373436540365,
-0.3212026059627533,
-0.0037267145235091448,
-0.10972823947668076,
-0.6787320971488953,
1.029708743095398,
0.5081102848052979,
-0.3687431514263153,
0.05328555777668953,
0.3394726812839508,
0.9009810090065002,
-0.07207150012254715,
0.4684038758277893,
0.8331619501113892,
0.5571510195732117,
-0.1621648520231247,
-1.8089462518692017,
0.013683589175343513,
0.12878964841365814,
0.04651567339897156,
0.07865393906831741,
-0.3325028717517853,
0.5247400999069214,
0.22159186005592346,
-0.39963579177856445,
0.26723870635032654,
0.4298817217350006,
0.016649676486849785,
0.48688456416130066,
0.6895248889923096,
0.34268513321876526,
0.5169922709465027,
0.05963878706097603,
1.3574713468551636,
-0.29558420181274414,
0.5576556921005249,
1.0893553495407104,
-0.20260223746299744,
0.9166538119316101,
0.5432879328727722,
-0.5066351294517517,
0.3637162744998932,
0.09849722683429718,
0.08388122171163559,
0.3354141414165497,
-0.1088731586933136,
-0.1036602258682251,
-0.10722101479768753,
0.03339695557951927,
-0.20181967318058014,
0.4761791527271271,
0.13396427035331726,
-0.5764108896255493,
-0.06988688558340073,
0.009362530894577503,
-0.044409919530153275,
0.31538131833076477,
0.18473905324935913,
0.8362847566604614,
0.25604692101478577,
-1.124206304550171,
0.6396738290786743,
-0.1889442652463913,
0.3172387480735779,
-0.34762659668922424,
0.16390134394168854,
0.03402285277843475,
0.2032463699579239,
-0.14227214455604553,
-0.8853829503059387,
0.6030033826828003,
0.10956233739852905,
0.020989583805203438,
-0.32936760783195496,
0.22884847223758698,
-0.23906470835208893,
-0.12564446032047272,
0.61026531457901,
0.5652125477790833,
0.555711030960083,
-0.1115373745560646,
-0.878315806388855,
0.18720561265945435,
0.018821805715560913,
-0.005750751588493586,
0.14825430512428284,
0.14941322803497314,
-0.08574292808771133,
0.5642016530036926,
0.5832872986793518,
0.19010943174362183,
0.17330491542816162,
0.21153463423252106,
0.37076976895332336,
-0.4833971858024597,
-0.2860605716705322,
-0.8843191862106323,
0.3494773805141449,
-0.10388654470443726,
-0.10607520490884781,
0.8991511464118958,
0.4797350764274597,
0.7486498951911926,
-0.015068098902702332,
0.6353891491889954,
0.23951394855976105,
0.5699149966239929,
-0.47194594144821167,
0.6423618197441101,
-0.36964312195777893,
0.1850094050168991,
-0.5744233131408691,
-1.0281926393508911,
-0.26076486706733704,
0.6489219665527344,
-0.5947309136390686,
-0.16414926946163177,
0.9336923956871033,
0.4409857988357544,
-0.2152756154537201,
0.08451958745718002,
0.38361579179763794,
0.14572492241859436,
0.14451806247234344,
0.41810551285743713,
1.0148801803588867,
-0.5479641556739807,
0.8196896314620972,
0.052546948194503784,
-0.32180264592170715,
-0.16788330674171448,
-0.5516096353530884,
-0.4254261553287506,
-0.6021737456321716,
-0.21722154319286346,
-0.3373940587043762,
0.06982770562171936,
0.6990452408790588,
0.6132155656814575,
-0.8225632905960083,
-0.44723063707351685,
-0.06573304533958435,
-0.05810292437672615,
-0.49986836314201355,
-0.2248227745294571,
0.4773772060871124,
-0.3026687204837799,
-0.9331725835800171,
0.34821203351020813,
0.2193530797958374,
-0.08146938681602478,
-0.3959601819515228,
-0.2724975347518921,
0.02119084820151329,
-0.006351823452860117,
0.3308964669704437,
-0.12439980357885361,
-1.1570963859558105,
-0.5239970088005066,
-0.17565619945526123,
-0.41096821427345276,
-0.011552233248949051,
0.5547107458114624,
-0.6417062282562256,
0.7541695237159729,
0.6363168954849243,
0.6068214774131775,
0.43338868021965027,
0.32705727219581604,
0.8026077151298523,
-0.41483619809150696,
0.022508783265948296,
0.216877281665802,
0.13708709180355072,
0.3550218641757965,
-0.010888555087149143,
0.6661107540130615,
0.24358224868774414,
-0.8180721402168274,
-0.7172455787658691,
0.08776438981294632,
-1.107561469078064,
0.11882676184177399,
0.9366858601570129,
-0.4001717269420624,
0.0344710499048233,
-0.4223843216896057,
-0.1945684403181076,
0.4856615960597992,
-0.25932326912879944,
0.6613884568214417,
1.0195039510726929,
-0.2807464003562927,
0.26651009917259216,
-0.8643906116485596,
0.1354086548089981,
0.712525486946106,
-0.521816611289978,
-0.3056786358356476,
0.355196088552475,
0.25272136926651,
0.48484405875205994,
0.3917018175125122,
-0.18002308905124664,
0.32800284028053284,
0.07053342461585999,
-0.22518786787986755,
0.2775881290435791,
0.09717963635921478,
-0.6520264148712158,
-0.13933081924915314,
0.10945001244544983,
-0.38929688930511475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10086v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10086v2
|
Discovering influential text using convolutional neural networks
| 2024-06-14T14:41:44 | 2024-06-21T18:14:42 |
Megan Ayers, Luke Sanford, Margaret Roberts, Eddie Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ME
|
Experimental methods for estimating the impacts of text on human evaluation
have been widely used in the social sciences. However, researchers in
experimental settings are usually limited to testing a small number of
pre-specified text treatments. While efforts to mine unstructured texts for
features that causally affect outcomes have been ongoing in recent years, these
models have primarily focused on the topics or specific words of text, which
may not always be the mechanism of the effect. We connect these efforts with
NLP interpretability techniques and present a method for flexibly discovering
clusters of similar text phrases that are predictive of human reactions to
texts using convolutional neural networks. When used in an experimental
setting, this method can identify text treatments and their effects under
certain assumptions. We apply the method to two datasets. The first enables
direct validation of the model's ability to detect phrases known to cause the
outcome. The second demonstrates its ability to flexibly discover text
treatments with varying textual structures. In both cases, the model learns a
greater variety of text treatments compared to benchmark methods, and these
text features quantitatively meet or exceed the ability of benchmark methods to
predict the outcome.
|
[
-0.14271090924739838,
-0.895190954208374,
0.652535617351532,
0.408255398273468,
-0.2521352469921112,
-0.13549911975860596,
-0.5225690007209778,
-0.5123859643936157,
0.35007548332214355,
0.3451191782951355,
-0.4002806544303894,
-0.44681617617607117,
-0.9486150145530701,
0.11324435472488403,
-0.8047957420349121,
1.1205554008483887,
0.13005970418453217,
0.22205574810504913,
-0.28915780782699585,
-0.25414082407951355,
-0.41754472255706787,
-0.4223083257675171,
-0.5880793333053589,
-0.7304922342300415,
0.748621940612793,
0.254859060049057,
0.6557933688163757,
0.03428659960627556,
0.5309664607048035,
0.32772794365882874,
-0.6046860218048096,
-0.06241450086236,
-0.5809789896011353,
0.047326523810625076,
-0.35285627841949463,
-0.45632076263427734,
0.4000316858291626,
-0.07746780663728714,
0.6285451650619507,
0.8463126420974731,
-0.00917876698076725,
-0.020064882934093475,
0.48006728291511536,
0.6833381056785583,
-0.48455920815467834,
0.05637141689658165,
-0.7803098559379578,
0.0610186904668808,
-0.22445905208587646,
-0.1766759753227234,
-0.46496060490608215,
-0.37483274936676025,
0.6061592102050781,
-0.3568463623523712,
0.38656625151634216,
-0.19119872152805328,
0.4823150634765625,
0.11187103390693665,
-0.5590807795524597,
-0.5549625158309937,
-0.658255398273468,
0.8459995985031128,
-0.623757541179657,
0.14629802107810974,
0.4230315685272217,
-0.02891026996076107,
-0.48409315943717957,
-0.9772726893424988,
-0.5463963747024536,
-0.3132622241973877,
-0.5782736539840698,
-0.06365084648132324,
0.013984059914946556,
0.06092056632041931,
0.1960955113172531,
0.19406111538410187,
-0.4234987795352936,
-0.006020908709615469,
-0.2273283302783966,
-0.031933385878801346,
0.5664571523666382,
0.12079309672117233,
0.35855722427368164,
-0.40735378861427307,
-0.3121192157268524,
-0.059971511363983154,
-0.3912056088447571,
0.4752698540687561,
0.11533520370721817,
0.2580864131450653,
0.09947696328163147,
0.7558946013450623,
-0.053487423807382584,
0.38011497259140015,
-0.1679379791021347,
0.35746678709983826,
0.08127012103796005,
-0.386663019657135,
-0.25261279940605164,
0.09104909002780914,
0.8747284412384033,
0.2759002149105072,
0.14828282594680786,
-0.2749043107032776,
0.02571714110672474,
0.278576135635376,
0.3445187211036682,
-0.8109960556030273,
-0.19668368995189667,
-0.1587463617324829,
-0.902567446231842,
-0.3932858407497406,
0.09739486128091812,
-0.7589993476867676,
-0.8152992129325867,
-0.4137359857559204,
0.4262402355670929,
-0.3754056990146637,
-0.22715267539024353,
0.22301919758319855,
-0.47795042395591736,
0.008727796375751495,
0.2108599692583084,
-0.9219667315483093,
0.3887060284614563,
0.8143856525421143,
0.9221711754798889,
-0.36559629440307617,
-0.18953658640384674,
-0.39428162574768066,
-0.49595239758491516,
-0.176884725689888,
0.7373301386833191,
-0.7036912441253662,
-0.3423770070075989,
0.15734949707984924,
0.079755499958992,
-0.08440493792295456,
-0.37633216381073,
0.8519464731216431,
-0.4323869049549103,
0.017607765272259712,
-0.18936926126480103,
-0.9510058760643005,
-0.15644334256649017,
0.2186010181903839,
-0.7759680151939392,
0.9093100428581238,
-0.10096172988414764,
-0.9714314341545105,
0.28501567244529724,
-0.5821139812469482,
-0.6999187469482422,
-0.14326803386211395,
-0.27209794521331787,
-0.6728962063789368,
0.4680861532688141,
-0.243742898106575,
0.608944296836853,
-0.1943701207637787,
0.5382545590400696,
-0.3634701371192932,
-0.4864599108695984,
0.637985110282898,
-0.36916854977607727,
0.6591129899024963,
-0.10720376670360565,
-0.5885293483734131,
0.23247191309928894,
-0.7310845851898193,
-0.19983287155628204,
-0.15114369988441467,
-0.24059170484542847,
-0.7826672792434692,
0.27065011858940125,
0.3106982707977295,
-0.07077574729919434,
-0.1049780622124672,
-0.4110911786556244,
-0.14202889800071716,
-0.4323667287826538,
0.2942836582660675,
0.5374965667724609,
0.43918946385383606,
0.5408748388290405,
-0.16331055760383606,
0.28827598690986633,
-0.3688981533050537,
0.05477132275700569,
-0.0630480945110321,
-0.6851199865341187,
-0.49186840653419495,
0.3473077118396759,
0.23050929605960846,
0.035982511937618256,
-0.7073341608047485,
0.3115517497062683,
0.08568201959133148,
-0.5695340037345886,
-0.2396354377269745,
-0.031579770147800446,
0.38424915075302124,
0.49848827719688416,
0.261038213968277,
-0.11946506798267365,
-0.5508849620819092,
-0.85377436876297,
-0.8475974202156067,
0.12247343361377716,
-0.19816800951957703,
0.19579780101776123,
0.570587158203125,
-0.10947534441947937,
0.7818830013275146,
-0.5403695106506348,
-0.2870064377784729,
-0.03174424171447754,
0.5897729992866516,
0.20037123560905457,
0.4146970212459564,
0.42651671171188354,
-1.1383535861968994,
-0.44946053624153137,
-0.06232162564992905,
-0.5149131417274475,
0.09222427755594254,
-0.29677820205688477,
0.0923742726445198,
-0.4105459451675415,
0.7552456259727478,
-0.3805430233478546,
0.6076533794403076,
0.4767082631587982,
-0.4474337697029114,
0.43675094842910767,
-0.1253068894147873,
0.1156981959939003,
-0.826795756816864,
0.03974933549761772,
0.5269784331321716,
-0.0667596384882927,
-0.7301128506660461,
-0.28693512082099915,
-0.002185381483286619,
0.13439105451107025,
-0.35552719235420227,
0.5323013067245483,
-0.14551866054534912,
0.076043039560318,
-0.33018702268600464,
0.1577521413564682,
0.14901824295520782,
0.19974777102470398,
0.09355278313159943,
0.3169938027858734,
0.20799100399017334,
-0.4838906526565552,
0.046923957765102386,
0.33280664682388306,
-0.7715433835983276,
0.09839422255754471,
-0.8185132741928101,
-0.08934513479471207,
-0.2736527919769287,
0.32848402857780457,
-1.0010631084442139,
-0.10650339722633362,
0.06101038306951523,
-0.4640948176383972,
-0.04511314630508423,
0.08805397152900696,
-0.37769103050231934,
0.08279816061258316,
-0.33081531524658203,
0.19318296015262604,
0.09042437374591827,
-0.5612813830375671,
0.4608464241027832,
0.3962929844856262,
0.06405006349086761,
-0.4598379135131836,
-0.5889561772346497,
0.151142880320549,
-0.2547987103462219,
-0.3312242031097412,
0.3699338734149933,
-0.07110724598169327,
-0.28782445192337036,
-0.10162456333637238,
0.13796336948871613,
0.004096865188330412,
0.4763490855693817,
0.30335092544555664,
-0.13626646995544434,
0.12970247864723206,
0.5729672312736511,
0.023075642064213753,
-0.037383295595645905,
0.21205967664718628,
0.029308021068572998,
0.30109256505966187,
-0.11075399816036224,
0.15018346905708313,
-0.11181691288948059,
0.4592914581298828,
0.26799476146698,
-0.2727604806423187,
0.7079361081123352,
0.712548553943634,
-0.5024227499961853,
-0.3368737995624542,
-0.15614403784275055,
-0.45638737082481384,
-0.4147481620311737,
0.5591797828674316,
0.09537665545940399,
-0.878417432308197,
0.37924492359161377,
-0.390980064868927,
-0.2704208195209503,
0.5182961225509644,
0.5630325675010681,
-0.12286700308322906,
1.0880180597305298,
0.7597876787185669,
0.09698981046676636,
0.9237506985664368,
-0.1474594622850418,
0.03761116415262222,
-0.8052439093589783,
-0.3528696894645691,
-0.7075526118278503,
-0.5482117533683777,
-0.8702071309089661,
-0.13110919296741486,
0.3742935359477997,
0.009969186969101429,
0.1396016627550125,
0.1650700867176056,
-0.7654858231544495,
0.47909024357795715,
0.5271506905555725,
0.5508725047111511,
0.19075770676136017,
-0.13768401741981506,
0.04403836652636528,
-0.059474144130945206,
-0.48703673481941223,
-0.4445466995239258,
0.9763750433921814,
0.20730216801166534,
0.6867614388465881,
-0.1171930804848671,
0.37442436814308167,
0.5154456496238708,
0.7792860269546509,
-0.8739492893218994,
0.387306809425354,
-0.34217923879623413,
-0.566505491733551,
-0.3726794123649597,
-0.35853204131126404,
-1.3384112119674683,
0.10899434238672256,
-0.8347321152687073,
-0.8267536759376526,
0.32437780499458313,
-0.13236118853092194,
-0.17703406512737274,
0.007076426409184933,
-0.7690981030464172,
0.9175474643707275,
-0.18991585075855255,
-0.2002118080854416,
-0.40182098746299744,
-0.7856086492538452,
0.16999486088752747,
-0.070855051279068,
0.07537242770195007,
-0.00895669311285019,
0.14086109399795532,
0.7499550580978394,
-0.1573595106601715,
1.0450773239135742,
-0.008027027361094952,
0.2298913151025772,
0.14038801193237305,
-0.3132530152797699,
0.5492238998413086,
0.15209585428237915,
-0.40270712971687317,
0.0008434181800112128,
-0.17816975712776184,
-0.2007254958152771,
-0.9838440418243408,
0.7567821741104126,
-0.541196882724762,
-0.24033932387828827,
-0.2326361984014511,
-0.46442362666130066,
-0.008025478571653366,
0.26705029606819153,
0.22866177558898926,
0.44369855523109436,
-0.6334741115570068,
0.5477753281593323,
0.5996261835098267,
-0.06328321248292923,
0.5972930788993835,
0.2480689287185669,
-0.2376214861869812,
-0.18786774575710297,
0.5314587950706482,
0.11602750420570374,
-0.07653501629829407,
0.3691262900829315,
0.7910873293876648,
-0.24406065046787262,
-0.6944385766983032,
-0.12677991390228271,
-0.15372207760810852,
-0.5953371524810791,
-0.13829556107521057,
-0.5655170679092407,
0.01450219377875328,
-0.06435391306877136,
-0.12373512983322144,
0.02239326573908329,
-0.32350850105285645,
-0.48081520199775696,
-0.1874750554561615,
0.3411610424518585,
0.8224839568138123,
0.31058019399642944,
0.5147276520729065,
-0.6225854158401489,
0.2710931897163391,
0.1352018117904663,
0.5428589582443237,
0.139590784907341,
-0.1338883340358734,
-0.5324050188064575,
0.0051300725899636745,
-0.21269232034683228,
-0.970016598701477,
0.21539074182510376,
0.2949906587600708,
0.384952574968338,
0.3825664520263672,
0.09909263998270035,
0.11078043282032013,
-0.30611902475357056,
0.6533611416816711,
0.225710928440094,
-0.9027565121650696,
0.5949709415435791,
-0.1476161926984787,
0.1795673668384552,
0.6903119683265686,
0.4948044419288635,
-0.6296570897102356,
-0.2674764394760132,
-0.7244588136672974,
-0.7354152798652649,
0.3848157227039337,
0.46805906295776367,
0.3081291913986206,
-0.22239629924297333,
0.7611794471740723,
0.22702763974666595,
0.19687195122241974,
-0.7897315621376038,
-0.29599258303642273,
-0.037154436111450195,
-0.26690658926963806,
-0.22525717318058014,
-0.19167889654636383,
0.007038240786641836,
-0.17217135429382324,
0.5578250885009766,
-0.12068479508161545,
-0.28010421991348267,
0.535722553730011,
-0.1297089159488678,
-0.03412079066038132,
0.1985204815864563,
0.4862994849681854,
0.6176641583442688,
-0.3516518473625183,
0.3019249439239502,
0.05762800946831703,
-0.505579948425293,
0.0022207230795174837,
0.31758835911750793,
-0.41655251383781433,
0.39225447177886963,
0.42668071389198303,
0.6447033882141113,
0.4616420269012451,
-0.5541562438011169,
0.5063580870628357,
-0.38407495617866516,
-0.03470822423696518,
-0.37378352880477905,
0.027739766985177994,
0.029386214911937714,
0.41098079085350037,
0.38018980622291565,
0.3785977065563202,
0.5144641399383545,
-0.6611717939376831,
0.5201343297958374,
0.4540446698665619,
-0.8903168439865112,
-0.21999041736125946,
0.40213170647621155,
0.14613214135169983,
-0.6124275326728821,
0.25060194730758667,
0.09222759306430817,
-0.4838649332523346,
0.9245011210441589,
0.3849748969078064,
0.8020392656326294,
-0.10188765078783035,
0.2990003824234009,
0.320453017950058,
0.16607201099395752,
-0.30077722668647766,
-0.12486854195594788,
0.13468657433986664,
-0.8053085803985596,
-0.4165967106819153,
-0.3543305993080139,
-0.5328221321105957,
0.0967913493514061,
-0.7556540966033936,
0.34414684772491455,
-0.18101072311401367,
-0.2297481894493103,
0.5659741163253784,
0.09932757914066315,
-0.545328676700592,
0.40771180391311646,
-0.05706939473748207,
0.745690643787384,
-1.080810546875,
0.7335919737815857,
0.7707870602607727,
-0.23894956707954407,
-0.7004442811012268,
0.12817002832889557,
0.015907714143395424,
-0.3948825001716614,
0.18638131022453308,
0.3111051619052887,
0.07902998477220535,
-0.11202148348093033,
-0.7331640720367432,
-0.5625876784324646,
0.8445226550102234,
0.03986835852265358,
-0.4667966663837433,
0.24341057240962982,
0.09982888400554657,
0.9795292019844055,
-0.32938310503959656,
0.4296268820762634,
0.6788437962532043,
0.6378398537635803,
-0.12065857648849487,
-0.4749828279018402,
0.24595487117767334,
-0.2869332730770111,
-0.151177778840065,
0.23400253057479858,
-0.46751466393470764,
0.4805828928947449,
0.02735813893377781,
0.043568238615989685,
-0.0003017163253389299,
0.785970151424408,
0.009747388772666454,
0.7675684094429016,
0.7299642562866211,
0.14799289405345917,
0.7879576086997986,
0.17371946573257446,
1.1754426956176758,
0.1369747519493103,
0.5836793780326843,
1.1109068393707275,
0.13172747194766998,
0.7162109613418579,
0.5218055248260498,
0.025359701365232468,
0.5881539583206177,
0.7174674272537231,
-0.0934094488620758,
0.5721460580825806,
0.6349177360534668,
-0.3618665039539337,
-0.02855379693210125,
-0.41967931389808655,
0.011105421930551529,
0.5351321697235107,
0.43318551778793335,
-0.6872791647911072,
-0.1712036430835724,
0.18184350430965424,
-0.0010579666122794151,
0.5099409222602844,
-0.3279237747192383,
0.7397093772888184,
0.3375864028930664,
-0.7289138436317444,
0.07666343450546265,
-0.07972898334264755,
0.7606543898582458,
-0.6153682470321655,
-0.26684707403182983,
-0.05946425348520279,
0.2744874358177185,
-0.3222675025463104,
-0.8181738257408142,
0.5746272206306458,
-0.26749923825263977,
-0.4732840359210968,
-0.08910740166902542,
1.1098077297210693,
-0.5786820650100708,
-0.6449787020683289,
0.5481559634208679,
0.32730570435523987,
-0.07513075321912766,
-0.4046253561973572,
-0.597033679485321,
-0.07920695841312408,
0.05803868547081947,
-0.4582637548446655,
0.41398119926452637,
0.5934833288192749,
-0.12609779834747314,
0.34118956327438354,
0.5627920627593994,
-0.10341420024633408,
-0.24420298635959625,
0.4037722945213318,
0.8536863327026367,
-0.5192690491676331,
-0.20108269155025482,
-0.9186661243438721,
0.5123852491378784,
-0.30877065658569336,
-0.46979832649230957,
0.7412418127059937,
0.5637519955635071,
0.5363684892654419,
0.21307021379470825,
0.8171683549880981,
0.16201633214950562,
0.4575878977775574,
-0.43332117795944214,
0.7804912328720093,
-0.427604615688324,
0.19249507784843445,
-0.5636666417121887,
-0.6331639885902405,
-0.6421303749084473,
0.3993176519870758,
-0.2703782916069031,
-0.23846083879470825,
0.6834954619407654,
0.5496230721473694,
0.10204493999481201,
0.31005266308784485,
0.138222798705101,
0.33099523186683655,
0.3586362600326538,
0.035956576466560364,
0.862134575843811,
-0.3477191925048828,
0.736079216003418,
-0.27013227343559265,
-0.4351634085178375,
-0.11896725744009018,
-1.1440562009811401,
-0.9598506689071655,
-0.6670863628387451,
-0.06622151285409927,
-0.3779866099357605,
-0.03160974383354187,
0.8178245425224304,
0.33209705352783203,
-0.5999228954315186,
0.0036615419667214155,
-0.3311850428581238,
0.6952288746833801,
-0.34637126326560974,
-0.2809029221534729,
0.7291932106018066,
-0.3870845437049866,
-0.6786457896232605,
0.27393537759780884,
0.010294532403349876,
-0.2192627489566803,
-0.08993557095527649,
0.07908615469932556,
-0.44654303789138794,
0.07480958849191666,
0.6505641341209412,
-0.04106758162379265,
-0.3529464304447174,
-0.42653706669807434,
0.08420161157846451,
0.10546023398637772,
-0.07939443737268448,
1.2513978481292725,
-0.678386926651001,
0.6235132217407227,
0.6242018938064575,
0.6779420971870422,
0.6821293830871582,
-0.07782081514596939,
0.5807920694351196,
-0.8578105568885803,
0.01562558300793171,
0.4328620433807373,
0.4342985153198242,
0.3358577489852905,
-0.5546958446502686,
0.6604570746421814,
0.08065173029899597,
-0.7600175738334656,
-0.4120109975337982,
0.00882352702319622,
-0.8536627292633057,
-0.5027564764022827,
1.1126199960708618,
-0.1814122349023819,
-0.12556178867816925,
-0.29114681482315063,
-0.2737610936164856,
0.24042725563049316,
-0.2695302963256836,
1.2742022275924683,
0.6174926161766052,
-0.17036235332489014,
-0.13141055405139923,
-0.4364405870437622,
0.7189268469810486,
0.6243871450424194,
-0.678744912147522,
-0.17400431632995605,
0.17294122278690338,
-0.00794058945029974,
0.26498574018478394,
0.3509145975112915,
0.0714106410741806,
0.07184978574514389,
-0.2897240221500397,
0.04408808425068855,
0.40657487511634827,
-0.009102776646614075,
-0.327603816986084,
0.06167107820510864,
-0.22439135611057281,
0.14493747055530548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10085v1
|
Enhancing Question Answering on Charts Through Effective Pre-training Tasks
| 2024-06-14T14:40:10 | 2024-06-14T14:40:10 |
Ashim Gupta, Vivek Gupta, Shuo Zhang, Yujie He, Ning Zhang, Shalin Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
To completely understand a document, the use of textual information is not
enough. Understanding visual cues, such as layouts and charts, is also
required. While the current state-of-the-art approaches for document
understanding (both OCR-based and OCR-free) work well, a thorough analysis of
their capabilities and limitations has not yet been performed. Therefore, in
this work, we addresses the limitation of current VisualQA models when applied
to charts and plots. To investigate shortcomings of the state-of-the-art
models, we conduct a comprehensive behavioral analysis, using ChartQA as a case
study. Our findings indicate that existing models particularly underperform in
answering questions related to the chart's structural and visual context, as
well as numerical information. To address these issues, we propose three simple
pre-training tasks that enforce the existing model in terms of both
structural-visual knowledge, as well as its understanding of numerical
questions. We evaluate our pre-trained model (called MatCha-v2) on three chart
datasets - both extractive and abstractive question datasets - and observe that
it achieves an average improvement of 1.7% over the baseline model.
|
[
-0.4780367612838745,
-0.8146076202392578,
0.8062631487846375,
-0.2855163514614105,
-0.5421673059463501,
0.14358603954315186,
0.30673110485076904,
-0.5756812691688538,
0.004640206694602966,
0.7199777960777283,
-0.649310827255249,
-0.5259157419204712,
-0.7566452622413635,
0.13680784404277802,
-0.34836915135383606,
0.7721587419509888,
-0.5433936715126038,
0.2726602852344513,
-0.5249481797218323,
-0.20085132122039795,
-0.7787317037582397,
-0.3826625347137451,
-0.5880914330482483,
0.047594647854566574,
0.49440211057662964,
0.5662292242050171,
0.5331772565841675,
0.3493160307407379,
0.6534206867218018,
0.3293173015117645,
0.03680619224905968,
0.3057830035686493,
-0.815105676651001,
0.238876610994339,
0.24677957594394684,
-0.7387694716453552,
-0.42466890811920166,
0.15701813995838165,
0.2210157811641693,
0.7521628141403198,
0.3414146602153778,
0.34654340147972107,
-0.06672337651252747,
0.7158596515655518,
-0.5216584205627441,
0.6925687193870544,
-0.3604047894477844,
-0.04607521370053291,
0.03135927766561508,
-0.2969188690185547,
-0.405813604593277,
-0.43904969096183777,
0.3852705955505371,
-1.4150670766830444,
-0.0026394084561616182,
-0.07832837849855423,
1.1878668069839478,
0.3986521065235138,
-0.8218522667884827,
-0.6090618968009949,
-0.5185288786888123,
0.3098040223121643,
-0.4255545139312744,
0.37781384587287903,
0.7595908045768738,
0.6487110257148743,
0.2206486463546753,
-1.2876774072647095,
-0.4200262725353241,
0.17000944912433624,
-0.3010309338569641,
0.5843860507011414,
-0.2237255573272705,
-0.135316401720047,
0.3983295261859894,
0.028787963092327118,
-0.5963035821914673,
-0.04923434555530548,
-0.7161217331886292,
-0.09504002332687378,
0.40672776103019714,
0.24242112040519714,
0.47757571935653687,
-0.333463191986084,
-0.22734448313713074,
-0.26518064737319946,
-0.3204652965068817,
0.5662888288497925,
0.079811230301857,
0.1552691012620926,
-0.087117500603199,
0.39550313353538513,
-0.17251098155975342,
0.6230438351631165,
0.08436848223209381,
0.29685673117637634,
0.10837558656930923,
-0.45132967829704285,
-0.08349346369504929,
-0.35174787044525146,
0.28173941373825073,
0.2891283929347992,
0.6890421509742737,
0.08740352839231491,
0.08147527277469635,
-0.08927712589502335,
0.5800839066505432,
-0.7285277247428894,
-0.379954069852829,
0.2482253611087799,
-0.37229475378990173,
-0.10785436630249023,
0.061318766325712204,
-0.40946853160858154,
-0.5708680152893066,
-0.5695075988769531,
0.6397032737731934,
-0.5195895433425903,
-0.06490355730056763,
0.07885108888149261,
-0.44485554099082947,
0.4221246838569641,
0.8273249268531799,
-0.48309826850891113,
0.061590541154146194,
0.3881509304046631,
0.3654997944831848,
0.31697937846183777,
-0.10155967622995377,
-0.7019270062446594,
0.04057630896568298,
-0.4920874834060669,
1.0872026681900024,
-0.47767356038093567,
-0.15888550877571106,
-0.2829633951187134,
0.03076493926346302,
-0.33310753107070923,
-0.32618972659111023,
0.2963216006755829,
-0.941064715385437,
0.3555341958999634,
-0.6964730620384216,
-0.5923641324043274,
-0.45325255393981934,
0.3666864037513733,
-0.8959447741508484,
0.6537894606590271,
0.441018283367157,
-0.9705249071121216,
0.5396680235862732,
-0.6681963801383972,
-0.300147145986557,
0.04735193029046059,
-0.47606104612350464,
-0.419487327337265,
-0.2527875304222107,
0.8333499431610107,
0.1383192390203476,
-0.09996386617422104,
-0.25146833062171936,
-0.1251271665096283,
-0.5265952348709106,
0.21266688406467438,
0.12225238233804703,
0.634290874004364,
0.31073057651519775,
-0.24769747257232666,
0.3709920346736908,
-0.32220375537872314,
0.21179726719856262,
0.38014379143714905,
0.015516085550189018,
-0.19711247086524963,
-0.22586287558078766,
-0.14806205034255981,
0.14122740924358368,
0.11927243322134018,
-0.19543103873729706,
0.029077325016260147,
-0.3136098384857178,
0.34971871972084045,
0.5553868412971497,
0.19057640433311462,
0.30113086104393005,
-0.35844460129737854,
1.0920829772949219,
0.03323012962937355,
0.13095393776893616,
-0.2589845061302185,
-0.4043101370334625,
-0.5215874910354614,
-0.1836835741996765,
0.487225741147995,
0.5759008526802063,
-1.197391390800476,
-0.12534715235233307,
-0.44717937707901,
-0.7289994955062866,
-0.2072119563817978,
0.13578444719314575,
0.27878087759017944,
0.9124835133552551,
0.44092491269111633,
-0.6005967259407043,
-0.5485990047454834,
-0.5127249956130981,
-0.06162865832448006,
-0.22152850031852722,
-0.08666159957647324,
0.22991277277469635,
0.4632697105407715,
0.2869994640350342,
0.8211299180984497,
-0.8004448413848877,
-0.0709116980433464,
-0.4639054238796234,
0.30479300022125244,
0.07984834164381027,
0.11789724230766296,
0.8159589767456055,
-1.0311741828918457,
-0.7340903282165527,
-0.33388960361480713,
-0.9785498380661011,
0.16940593719482422,
-0.0932711809873581,
-0.4282677173614502,
-0.29236799478530884,
0.8041399121284485,
-0.4281215965747833,
1.012395977973938,
0.1107633039355278,
-0.4457492232322693,
0.3525993824005127,
-0.17422442138195038,
0.4189654290676117,
-0.7711976766586304,
0.023724187165498734,
-0.24150553345680237,
-0.23175017535686493,
-0.8942786455154419,
0.21212857961654663,
0.2713194787502289,
-0.571969211101532,
-0.428012877702713,
0.5320293307304382,
-0.44278407096862793,
-0.055387046188116074,
-0.1903064101934433,
0.4359428882598877,
0.36762017011642456,
0.5452543497085571,
0.20324954390525818,
0.6871349811553955,
0.3060486614704132,
-0.43717074394226074,
0.04604077711701393,
0.9071664810180664,
-0.4280395209789276,
0.6859257817268372,
-0.775484561920166,
0.2992943227291107,
-0.6177582144737244,
0.3219352662563324,
-1.4744869470596313,
0.031906481832265854,
0.2985057830810547,
-0.5636376142501831,
0.2823875844478607,
-0.2228049337863922,
-0.24068105220794678,
-0.5814014673233032,
-0.15982341766357422,
0.4238555133342743,
0.5111717581748962,
-0.36830034852027893,
0.8319436311721802,
0.06900928169488907,
-0.3573530614376068,
-0.5346241593360901,
-0.39479753375053406,
-0.23612122237682343,
-0.23735977709293365,
-0.7532528042793274,
-0.26979687809944153,
-0.13693539798259735,
0.02786984294652939,
-0.2213924378156662,
-0.3107377886772156,
-0.4682792127132416,
0.22724488377571106,
0.25128042697906494,
0.19451719522476196,
-0.41031381487846375,
0.1637749969959259,
-0.21641407907009125,
-0.3129168450832367,
0.029065975919365883,
-0.03815583139657974,
0.4512142837047577,
0.07693510502576828,
-0.4523957669734955,
-0.4591473340988159,
0.24509340524673462,
0.5627418756484985,
-0.8341293334960938,
0.4328768253326416,
0.45445314049720764,
-0.1145952045917511,
0.3196771740913391,
-0.21846601366996765,
-0.0628865510225296,
-0.49487394094467163,
0.5811957120895386,
-0.38539281487464905,
-0.4644932746887207,
0.5128255486488342,
0.11431921273469925,
0.0645652785897255,
0.3306725025177002,
0.12377318739891052,
-0.8416923880577087,
0.9008387327194214,
0.3678815960884094,
0.2682098150253296,
0.5093202590942383,
-0.4582655429840088,
0.04643287509679794,
-0.4414219260215759,
-0.05273018777370453,
-0.6138969659805298,
-0.27077507972717285,
-0.19220751523971558,
-0.41931474208831787,
0.5756295919418335,
0.16740870475769043,
-0.4102896749973297,
0.1793091595172882,
-0.17814695835113525,
0.24802808463573456,
0.5556659698486328,
0.523486316204071,
0.11830957978963852,
-0.14265520870685577,
0.020232487469911575,
-0.05828465148806572,
-0.7658026218414307,
-0.5011255741119385,
1.3329334259033203,
0.10881420224905014,
0.6297600865364075,
-0.18882814049720764,
0.4568343758583069,
-0.16206200420856476,
0.3510977029800415,
-0.42144495248794556,
0.24734807014465332,
-0.10035442560911179,
-0.7224740386009216,
-0.8236708045005798,
-0.39940789341926575,
-1.3514094352722168,
0.1780579537153244,
-0.2897223234176636,
-0.38315150141716003,
0.08518610149621964,
0.33544376492500305,
-0.2885250151157379,
0.184165358543396,
-0.8420575261116028,
1.2845889329910278,
-0.5456354022026062,
0.09656915068626404,
0.09714822471141815,
-0.6584120392799377,
0.03609899431467056,
-0.17371737957000732,
0.3686448037624359,
0.08285106718540192,
0.21432992815971375,
0.7309337854385376,
-0.5107955932617188,
0.7167446613311768,
-0.378083735704422,
0.015042552724480629,
0.6017703413963318,
-0.11402620375156403,
0.5092120170593262,
-0.39214542508125305,
-0.008541347458958626,
-0.46467483043670654,
0.4623335599899292,
-0.9415439963340759,
-1.111939787864685,
-0.25114065408706665,
-0.8096632361412048,
-0.48706144094467163,
-0.034585654735565186,
-0.5509389638900757,
-0.5869220495223999,
0.3124813735485077,
0.2604368329048157,
0.6944472193717957,
-0.10066689550876617,
0.12469003349542618,
0.574063241481781,
-0.32322371006011963,
-0.17544841766357422,
0.5435349345207214,
-0.19099536538124084,
-0.2582606375217438,
0.5929229855537415,
0.34029603004455566,
0.379849910736084,
0.2683025002479553,
0.06962648779153824,
-0.5292450785636902,
-0.7229971885681152,
-0.3379513621330261,
0.1762552559375763,
-1.2912368774414062,
0.0734279453754425,
-0.43202006816864014,
-0.17515534162521362,
-0.4852527976036072,
-0.009709816426038742,
0.19944052398204803,
-0.33921101689338684,
-0.4165618419647217,
-0.33569109439849854,
0.3563390374183655,
0.7443976998329163,
0.3417894244194031,
0.37984952330589294,
-0.6945127844810486,
0.8217639923095703,
0.734980583190918,
0.12084827572107315,
0.26659971475601196,
-0.7015283107757568,
-0.2694457769393921,
0.12648023664951324,
-0.35597753524780273,
-1.0446704626083374,
0.018682166934013367,
-0.18680402636528015,
0.6530107259750366,
0.33471736311912537,
0.35566309094429016,
0.7903755903244019,
-0.18451181054115295,
0.42612382769584656,
0.05923735350370407,
-0.6405444145202637,
0.4926300346851349,
-0.4091959595680237,
0.6255687475204468,
0.7651264667510986,
0.7528590559959412,
-0.39386963844299316,
-0.49888846278190613,
-0.5552976727485657,
-0.5571194887161255,
0.6539918780326843,
0.35825422406196594,
0.017228921875357628,
0.296782523393631,
0.46757546067237854,
-0.022116713225841522,
0.23612430691719055,
-0.5246250629425049,
0.0009405188029631972,
-0.6683797836303711,
-0.4437808096408844,
-0.2913093864917755,
-0.005349606275558472,
0.08001305907964706,
-0.5061571598052979,
0.273614764213562,
-0.21551476418972015,
-0.18837891519069672,
0.24150711297988892,
-0.4358152449131012,
-0.038852494210004807,
0.018782854080200195,
0.29134222865104675,
1.0726078748703003,
-0.10892542451620102,
-0.08395200222730637,
0.2637474536895752,
-0.6699769496917725,
-0.05114283785223961,
0.21766604483127594,
-0.22130168974399567,
-0.3688027560710907,
0.8191319108009338,
0.881118893623352,
0.2623431086540222,
-0.7765005826950073,
0.5129690766334534,
-0.40051668882369995,
-0.2813413739204407,
-0.17699076235294342,
-0.034540846943855286,
0.3773021697998047,
0.19304394721984863,
0.24092845618724823,
-0.3610823154449463,
-0.1523544192314148,
-0.5909503698348999,
0.14403238892555237,
0.28129464387893677,
-0.6248084306716919,
0.0506586953997612,
0.7928395867347717,
0.14744846522808075,
0.03996508568525314,
0.8256080150604248,
0.25681883096694946,
-0.7274686098098755,
1.1016502380371094,
-0.039935410022735596,
0.2558499276638031,
0.1254255473613739,
0.3967268764972687,
0.36960306763648987,
0.4777853786945343,
0.6263960599899292,
0.8536878228187561,
-0.17612938582897186,
-0.49763381481170654,
-0.19967120885849,
0.013945821672677994,
-0.5531008243560791,
0.07731392234563828,
-0.8490466475486755,
0.1663571447134018,
-0.39991137385368347,
-0.11800695955753326,
0.05460834130644798,
0.1344643384218216,
-1.1069271564483643,
0.6160271167755127,
0.03394831344485283,
0.8550322651863098,
-0.722868025302887,
0.36966612935066223,
0.7357635498046875,
-1.0438288450241089,
-1.2365387678146362,
-0.19262166321277618,
-0.2128768414258957,
-0.8831338286399841,
0.6901530623435974,
0.12572580575942993,
0.2325526624917984,
0.045837707817554474,
-0.6487308740615845,
-0.809272289276123,
1.1385791301727295,
0.4876626133918762,
-0.1049213632941246,
-0.2574898898601532,
0.3832205533981323,
0.7086122632026672,
-0.06426096707582474,
0.6599698662757874,
0.4309779703617096,
0.7215486764907837,
0.21257755160331726,
-0.7446803450584412,
-0.013724059797823429,
-0.3052450716495514,
-0.5361371040344238,
-0.13633115589618683,
-0.3324182331562042,
0.840872049331665,
-0.18605482578277588,
-0.2842237055301666,
0.11134938895702362,
0.6037881970405579,
0.1280732899904251,
0.589667797088623,
0.7611627578735352,
0.18751022219657898,
1.0412440299987793,
-0.05820399522781372,
1.194162130355835,
-0.06909088790416718,
-0.015765339136123657,
1.3941690921783447,
-0.17721305787563324,
0.7727800011634827,
0.16841334104537964,
-0.03465033695101738,
0.49763596057891846,
0.8832994699478149,
0.1846059262752533,
0.2561098039150238,
0.18632753193378448,
0.5187039375305176,
-0.6703565716743469,
0.1873251497745514,
-0.509551465511322,
0.43237990140914917,
0.03172329068183899,
-0.2117462158203125,
-0.39052537083625793,
-0.10807792097330093,
-0.38068729639053345,
0.40407440066337585,
-0.3251767158508301,
0.8032957315444946,
0.007306247483938932,
-0.4567084312438965,
0.7441400289535522,
-0.5903549790382385,
-0.1817225068807602,
-0.8985452651977539,
-0.04394855722784996,
-0.36074888706207275,
-0.3860606849193573,
-0.0340779684484005,
-0.7273325324058533,
-0.13034193217754364,
-0.05851570516824722,
-0.05787123739719391,
-0.24776513874530792,
0.4248650074005127,
-0.17568838596343994,
-0.47008538246154785,
0.10055159777402878,
0.7641441822052002,
0.07084181904792786,
-0.28784698247909546,
-0.5327038168907166,
-0.3203437924385071,
-0.1398739516735077,
0.06382545828819275,
0.0857660248875618,
0.5578283071517944,
-0.07375387847423553,
0.6024097204208374,
0.40944352746009827,
-0.3214379549026489,
0.02251356653869152,
0.08594778925180435,
0.876081645488739,
-0.5011168122291565,
-0.9330108761787415,
0.020681463181972504,
0.5389552116394043,
-0.12492264062166214,
-0.22315673530101776,
0.6892772316932678,
0.3609807789325714,
0.6353235840797424,
-0.21551358699798584,
0.6202666759490967,
0.6028586626052856,
0.6556399464607239,
-0.7364051342010498,
1.0657085180282593,
-0.7792672514915466,
-0.17995892465114594,
-0.6733689904212952,
-0.5912896990776062,
0.09777579456567764,
0.39830929040908813,
-0.8490412831306458,
-0.0177990160882473,
0.9183655381202698,
0.3264729976654053,
-0.07908385992050171,
0.3359258472919464,
0.18705497682094574,
0.03529101237654686,
0.3627263605594635,
0.7093169689178467,
1.0954188108444214,
-0.33101120591163635,
1.0692516565322876,
-0.12880489230155945,
-0.03847445175051689,
0.08895653486251831,
-0.4783474802970886,
-1.026816487312317,
-0.7289880514144897,
-0.22179251909255981,
-0.19802825152873993,
-0.19662512838840485,
0.14207084476947784,
0.811598539352417,
-0.657192587852478,
-0.09855619072914124,
0.2908269464969635,
0.0009050379740074277,
-0.060964614152908325,
-0.09817855805158615,
0.8036561608314514,
-0.30708304047584534,
-0.2480812668800354,
0.1318264752626419,
-0.0811539813876152,
0.4481034576892853,
0.17583483457565308,
-0.039672479033470154,
-0.21494793891906738,
0.33764317631721497,
0.3554305136203766,
0.4166546165943146,
-0.1877535879611969,
-0.3957255482673645,
0.14292128384113312,
-0.07723736017942429,
0.4972437918186188,
0.9325941205024719,
-0.6934337615966797,
0.7472372651100159,
0.5698097944259644,
0.7327186465263367,
1.0089530944824219,
0.539029598236084,
0.5419560670852661,
-0.21963708102703094,
0.04036770015954971,
0.181303471326828,
0.2667308747768402,
0.1959417164325714,
-0.2849346399307251,
0.5104857683181763,
-0.09193427115678787,
-0.04214651137590408,
-0.49492788314819336,
0.3164216876029968,
-0.736600935459137,
-0.5509684681892395,
0.29379212856292725,
-0.334706574678421,
-0.1674703061580658,
-0.409455269575119,
-0.5313220620155334,
0.43276289105415344,
0.18252062797546387,
0.5561535954475403,
0.8044117093086243,
-0.2771664559841156,
-0.06790567934513092,
-0.5021449327468872,
0.3199231028556824,
0.5974441170692444,
-1.1935359239578247,
-0.111528180539608,
0.4898262321949005,
0.27066361904144287,
-0.04660547152161598,
0.9742156267166138,
-0.029837679117918015,
0.7525697946548462,
0.052066877484321594,
-0.39268651604652405,
-0.29091519117355347,
-0.1821805238723755,
-0.10320965200662613,
0.26948198676109314,
0.2829003632068634,
-0.02345314808189869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10083v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10083v1
|
On the Evaluation of Speech Foundation Models for Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-06-14T14:37:52 | 2024-06-14T14:37:52 |
Siddhant Arora, Ankita Pasad, Chung-Ming Chien, Jionghao Han, Roshan Sharma, Jee-weon Jung, Hira Dhamyal, William Chen, Suwon Shon, Hung-yi Lee, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The Spoken Language Understanding Evaluation (SLUE) suite of benchmark tasks
was recently introduced to address the need for open resources and benchmarking
of complex spoken language understanding (SLU) tasks, including both
classification and sequence generation tasks, on natural speech. The benchmark
has demonstrated preliminary success in using pre-trained speech foundation
models (SFM) for these SLU tasks. However, the community still lacks a
fine-grained understanding of the comparative utility of different SFMs.
Inspired by this, we ask: which SFMs offer the most benefits for these complex
SLU tasks, and what is the most effective approach for incorporating these
SFMs? To answer this, we perform an extensive evaluation of multiple supervised
and self-supervised SFMs using several evaluation protocols: (i) frozen SFMs
with a lightweight prediction head, (ii) frozen SFMs with a complex prediction
head, and (iii) fine-tuned SFMs with a lightweight prediction head. Although
the supervised SFMs are pre-trained on much more speech recognition data (with
labels), they do not always outperform self-supervised SFMs; the latter tend to
perform at least as well as, and sometimes better than, supervised SFMs,
especially on the sequence generation tasks in SLUE. While there is no
universally optimal way of incorporating SFMs, the complex prediction head
gives the best performance for most tasks, although it increases the inference
time. We also introduce an open-source toolkit and performance leaderboard,
SLUE-PERB, for these tasks and modeling strategies.
|
[
-0.39595919847488403,
-0.5315309762954712,
0.3101363182067871,
0.4879685342311859,
-0.05433938652276993,
0.2117132991552353,
-0.30015408992767334,
-0.44983235001564026,
-0.05361948534846306,
0.6151419878005981,
-0.4580090343952179,
-0.42854368686676025,
-0.48627349734306335,
-0.03863188624382019,
-0.5162000060081482,
0.8531933426856995,
0.2466864287853241,
0.19797486066818237,
-0.31797248125076294,
-0.01218988373875618,
-0.29808109998703003,
-0.4698545038700104,
-0.4648994207382202,
-0.7064247131347656,
0.06449803709983826,
0.3583024740219116,
0.47877874970436096,
0.5096182227134705,
0.29785239696502686,
0.3081921935081482,
-0.12287463247776031,
-0.1297295093536377,
-0.6399295926094055,
0.02003621496260166,
-0.15814484655857086,
-0.24866580963134766,
-0.38810279965400696,
0.14820846915245056,
0.6319528222084045,
0.9980611205101013,
-0.43236449360847473,
0.28401970863342285,
0.00612808158621192,
0.7013647556304932,
-0.7834925055503845,
0.18536816537380219,
-0.5835357308387756,
0.23654137551784515,
-0.014722341671586037,
0.053664639592170715,
-0.4021107852458954,
-0.13003478944301605,
0.5349660515785217,
-0.35962480306625366,
0.10729987174272537,
-0.1484968364238739,
0.49442729353904724,
0.3665040135383606,
-0.13360457122325897,
-0.29938191175460815,
-0.6543599367141724,
0.7556067705154419,
-0.783919095993042,
0.7222535014152527,
0.3063223659992218,
0.3884040415287018,
-0.023858346045017242,
-0.8318378329277039,
-0.18285542726516724,
-0.1925956904888153,
-0.15982067584991455,
0.18127527832984924,
-0.4690476953983307,
0.3525237441062927,
0.11986653506755829,
0.44818341732025146,
-0.8045839667320251,
0.32209041714668274,
-0.22106999158859253,
-0.22057408094406128,
0.5972900390625,
0.006312960758805275,
-0.11518745869398117,
-0.25266900658607483,
-0.4633050858974457,
-0.05257769301533699,
-0.4712648093700409,
0.26502394676208496,
-0.00762439938262105,
0.24881914258003235,
-0.19144514203071594,
0.2661082446575165,
-0.29802778363227844,
1.0721611976623535,
0.14265231788158417,
-0.495101660490036,
0.44662734866142273,
-0.28834307193756104,
-0.6102966070175171,
0.21694710850715637,
0.6571580767631531,
-0.11523963510990143,
0.3635255694389343,
-0.453165203332901,
-0.27327775955200195,
0.012473801150918007,
0.11814018338918686,
-0.7130310535430908,
-0.22539660334587097,
0.06804719567298889,
-0.3740811049938202,
-0.2243506908416748,
0.09232759475708008,
-0.2785264551639557,
-0.14535635709762573,
-0.5226385593414307,
0.2720448672771454,
-0.1526011973619461,
-0.3340422809123993,
0.2139221727848053,
-0.04120820760726929,
0.14754721522331238,
0.2493078112602234,
-0.73709636926651,
0.6145961284637451,
0.7431559562683105,
0.6931411623954773,
-0.45189258456230164,
-0.2779063284397125,
-0.8807525634765625,
-0.018995705991983414,
-0.3402353525161743,
0.5419765710830688,
-0.3705660104751587,
-0.3739086389541626,
-0.23695878684520721,
-0.15039047598838806,
-0.27094656229019165,
-0.6235777735710144,
0.5149144530296326,
-0.15828819572925568,
-0.07508661597967148,
-0.15101133286952972,
-0.5647164583206177,
-0.17246584594249725,
-0.15870976448059082,
-0.4571360647678375,
0.9987703561782837,
0.07868693023920059,
-0.5161983966827393,
0.21799349784851074,
-0.5360686779022217,
-0.5736233592033386,
0.18112938106060028,
-0.31786808371543884,
-0.07007458060979843,
0.12895196676254272,
0.21291227638721466,
0.8989143371582031,
-0.2153281420469284,
0.5300709009170532,
-0.1090724840760231,
-0.38661909103393555,
0.10826985538005829,
-0.12680856883525848,
0.4949135184288025,
0.42402350902557373,
-0.5949856638908386,
0.24395744502544403,
-0.7106302976608276,
0.11977295577526093,
-0.05863518267869949,
-0.056093547493219376,
-0.19790926575660706,
0.0485888347029686,
-0.058937158435583115,
0.01417423877865076,
-0.06813011318445206,
-0.22681380808353424,
-0.45431196689605713,
-0.42079228162765503,
0.7568491101264954,
0.6662107706069946,
-0.1554124355316162,
0.4831826388835907,
-0.13434217870235443,
0.7158360481262207,
-0.06986996531486511,
-0.13113108277320862,
-0.2656926214694977,
-0.2286614626646042,
-0.6751542687416077,
-0.21788199245929718,
0.22987788915634155,
0.5738129019737244,
-0.296394407749176,
0.24473589658737183,
0.005805599968880415,
-0.7158534526824951,
-0.6577149629592896,
0.16813401877880096,
0.7381936311721802,
0.6888285279273987,
0.35188207030296326,
-0.1769116371870041,
-0.3704717755317688,
-0.8545711636543274,
-0.22711139917373657,
-0.04362117499113083,
0.3032941520214081,
0.4721326231956482,
0.27037593722343445,
-0.12306816130876541,
0.8661402463912964,
-0.34628331661224365,
0.1424233466386795,
-0.16901013255119324,
0.34881067276000977,
0.2683151960372925,
0.5128376483917236,
0.660857081413269,
-0.7776069641113281,
-0.364510715007782,
-0.0691087618470192,
-0.6443222761154175,
-0.1939205676317215,
0.021415604278445244,
0.19237209856510162,
-0.09973445534706116,
0.35578083992004395,
-0.48283469676971436,
0.28029128909111023,
0.703827977180481,
0.04896967485547066,
0.8815857768058777,
0.21352721750736237,
0.20885074138641357,
-0.3743842542171478,
0.11132661253213882,
0.04298600181937218,
-0.4873041808605194,
-1.1014341115951538,
0.08494818955659866,
-0.09504825621843338,
-0.3503285050392151,
-0.4705367684364319,
0.3981930911540985,
-0.5155835747718811,
-0.6453287601470947,
-0.058974310755729675,
0.48655039072036743,
-0.10577455163002014,
0.2853185534477234,
0.2274753451347351,
0.8142595887184143,
0.6772443056106567,
-0.5575255751609802,
0.16128139197826385,
-0.04349055886268616,
-0.647226870059967,
0.2662770450115204,
-0.8910019993782043,
0.36371928453445435,
-0.1626148670911789,
0.0684870257973671,
-1.007890224456787,
0.04677867144346237,
-0.07405836880207062,
-0.3321745693683624,
0.4407747685909271,
0.07850015163421631,
-0.01630019024014473,
-0.27491122484207153,
0.058965764939785004,
0.18442891538143158,
0.3287883400917053,
-0.5668926239013672,
0.4350951611995697,
0.569418728351593,
-0.18426069617271423,
-0.9337561130523682,
-0.892048180103302,
-0.06042146682739258,
-0.27863192558288574,
-0.6526971459388733,
0.4281758666038513,
-0.210985466837883,
-0.49966952204704285,
-0.10290985554456711,
-0.4622790515422821,
0.08588550984859467,
0.3820660412311554,
0.34804078936576843,
-0.2727082371711731,
-0.5371196269989014,
0.06074582785367966,
0.056670572608709335,
-0.28760480880737305,
-0.020167667418718338,
-0.15434931218624115,
0.4127693176269531,
-0.6298256516456604,
-0.16794250905513763,
-0.39814868569374084,
0.15625393390655518,
0.4071596562862396,
-0.4092356860637665,
0.2575583755970001,
0.6432126760482788,
-0.4383369982242584,
-0.288002610206604,
-0.7440059781074524,
-0.10095994174480438,
-0.3934822082519531,
0.23609143495559692,
-0.5785600543022156,
-1.1529898643493652,
0.15734876692295074,
-0.07313233613967896,
0.17460717260837555,
0.1938946694135666,
0.48403093218803406,
-0.24420049786567688,
0.8059952855110168,
0.34979182481765747,
-0.20125849545001984,
0.25134918093681335,
-0.3018646240234375,
0.02939947135746479,
-0.5742108225822449,
-0.1323109120130539,
-0.7384498119354248,
0.024100106209516525,
-0.12754549086093903,
-0.4221479892730713,
0.1876276433467865,
0.5839271545410156,
0.02456861548125744,
0.46164843440055847,
-0.5009942650794983,
0.13261066377162933,
0.3483947813510895,
-0.009177357889711857,
0.23812340199947357,
-0.06432444602251053,
0.029956422746181488,
-0.0066052949987351894,
-0.8976621031761169,
-0.5420013070106506,
0.7236319780349731,
0.41854792833328247,
0.7038184404373169,
-0.14881597459316254,
0.6475222110748291,
0.38137897849082947,
0.11074171960353851,
-0.6973664164543152,
0.48595190048217773,
-0.36758294701576233,
-0.18710774183273315,
-0.38145172595977783,
-0.39621296525001526,
-0.8424404263496399,
0.5389478802680969,
-0.2017975151538849,
-0.7335202097892761,
0.06739064306020737,
0.3404442369937897,
-0.3236805200576782,
-0.2862470746040344,
-0.8275969624519348,
0.9809326529502869,
-0.350375771522522,
0.08930967003107071,
-0.4797024726867676,
-0.7659220695495605,
0.3811410963535309,
-0.06272581964731216,
0.33971861004829407,
-0.25221288204193115,
0.2527560293674469,
0.9287134408950806,
-0.12681041657924652,
0.5302405953407288,
-0.24697589874267578,
0.2490934580564499,
0.17455145716667175,
-0.13529300689697266,
0.14696337282657623,
-0.07212404161691666,
-0.3839687407016754,
0.08857080340385437,
0.15939411520957947,
-0.2289576381444931,
-0.5750722885131836,
0.7424652576446533,
-0.6467517614364624,
-0.6438445448875427,
-0.20963555574417114,
-0.3827369511127472,
-0.3370983600616455,
0.1572776883840561,
0.024530209600925446,
0.6041077971458435,
-0.2499728500843048,
0.42687729001045227,
0.6700904369354248,
-0.03752307966351509,
0.26271241903305054,
0.5256990790367126,
-0.17934060096740723,
-0.23609280586242676,
0.6849858164787292,
0.028650082647800446,
0.4627460241317749,
0.4606095850467682,
0.5040538311004639,
-0.23136071860790253,
-0.7258965969085693,
-0.4529566764831543,
0.1614038050174713,
-0.7437546253204346,
-0.058728478848934174,
-0.5913602709770203,
-0.19130195677280426,
-0.7723302841186523,
-0.14864778518676758,
-0.2247815728187561,
-0.3794710636138916,
-0.4889313280582428,
-0.4570930302143097,
0.11125406622886658,
0.7287700176239014,
-0.20342940092086792,
0.552617609500885,
-0.5314666628837585,
0.3722277879714966,
0.2995006740093231,
-0.09757236391305923,
0.11377225071191788,
-0.2985367774963379,
-0.08718691766262054,
0.08900625258684158,
0.14713431894779205,
-0.9963974356651306,
0.09129048138856888,
0.4560099244117737,
1.095866084098816,
0.46526676416397095,
-0.09454242885112762,
1.0749529600143433,
-0.32483237981796265,
0.6690582633018494,
0.3048284947872162,
-1.1898846626281738,
0.6272091865539551,
0.053067322820425034,
0.35577067732810974,
0.6403008103370667,
0.4038074314594269,
-0.3516061305999756,
-0.2868979275226593,
-0.585793673992157,
-0.5035116672515869,
0.6990342736244202,
0.1630779653787613,
-0.20987361669540405,
0.18609754741191864,
0.3369755744934082,
0.25641295313835144,
0.5085234045982361,
-0.5134247541427612,
-0.46477484703063965,
-0.33292633295059204,
0.09100382030010223,
-0.4180464744567871,
-0.0732753574848175,
-0.03467029333114624,
-0.11318200081586838,
0.6514795422554016,
-0.025032799690961838,
-0.08185100555419922,
0.25114086270332336,
-0.5035222172737122,
-0.005151652731001377,
0.28258371353149414,
0.5048277974128723,
0.8642495274543762,
-0.0984177365899086,
0.19707518815994263,
0.14644864201545715,
-0.28249382972717285,
-0.1449945569038391,
0.1821320652961731,
-0.12375868856906891,
0.06266545504331589,
0.4608135223388672,
1.3240548372268677,
0.6168438196182251,
-0.8225341439247131,
0.37594977021217346,
0.1416722536087036,
-0.09069587290287018,
-0.0916406437754631,
0.23312141001224518,
0.21134352684020996,
0.11775970458984375,
0.3786143660545349,
-0.08926567435264587,
0.3850446045398712,
-0.5854655504226685,
0.40098345279693604,
0.31720492243766785,
-0.4153806269168854,
-0.16278529167175293,
0.33613476157188416,
0.1753169447183609,
-0.48958247900009155,
0.3763202130794525,
-0.03393933176994324,
-0.6430100202560425,
0.5566205978393555,
0.5798150300979614,
0.6517419815063477,
-0.5202887654304504,
0.2862548232078552,
0.2556183934211731,
0.26636776328086853,
-0.01815534196794033,
0.1717330664396286,
-0.5164299607276917,
-0.6433451771736145,
-0.4525553584098816,
-0.8067589998245239,
-0.33678415417671204,
0.20313863456249237,
-0.9592245817184448,
0.053094636648893356,
-0.2786882519721985,
-0.14888761937618256,
0.23601014912128448,
-0.07491637021303177,
-0.6839430332183838,
0.3435351848602295,
0.15034383535385132,
0.9435080289840698,
-0.8280766010284424,
0.7385444045066833,
0.5515934824943542,
0.052132945507764816,
-0.844984769821167,
-0.40345069766044617,
0.07734958827495575,
-0.8837937116622925,
0.40993019938468933,
0.28559061884880066,
-0.5041770935058594,
0.20659765601158142,
-0.23930984735488892,
-0.7235299348831177,
0.9520389437675476,
0.420833021402359,
-0.812340497970581,
-0.014234001748263836,
-0.008918564766645432,
0.3512251377105713,
-0.4723564684391022,
0.21457527577877045,
0.9789659380912781,
0.3592544496059418,
0.10356985777616501,
-1.2042734622955322,
-0.19217422604560852,
0.08562879264354706,
-0.04256967827677727,
0.027821378782391548,
-0.27762600779533386,
0.5076501965522766,
-0.32699665427207947,
-0.23364779353141785,
0.04572107270359993,
0.7687023878097534,
0.40093809366226196,
0.465047150850296,
0.881226122379303,
0.5457743406295776,
0.7295477390289307,
-0.1734085977077484,
0.5538637042045593,
-0.1551220566034317,
0.34078842401504517,
1.3095951080322266,
-0.10162817686796188,
0.7915823459625244,
0.2586604952812195,
-0.32305240631103516,
0.3314613699913025,
0.7137125730514526,
0.09681142121553421,
0.5236781239509583,
0.3833993673324585,
0.1608612984418869,
-0.357867956161499,
-0.10702120512723923,
-0.48730021715164185,
0.6268596053123474,
0.5870020985603333,
-0.18573370575904846,
-0.14249438047409058,
0.22777394950389862,
-0.10222136974334717,
0.21126821637153625,
-0.33643367886543274,
0.664283037185669,
0.3619289994239807,
-0.6817895174026489,
0.5283101201057434,
-0.18982219696044922,
0.4018203318119049,
-0.6963353753089905,
0.1403159648180008,
0.08865990489721298,
-0.09562212228775024,
-0.48404011130332947,
-0.7588890194892883,
0.1726377010345459,
0.004487965255975723,
-0.048574984073638916,
-0.3817390203475952,
0.9588971138000488,
-0.533035159111023,
-0.1435139775276184,
0.5089029669761658,
0.5435105562210083,
0.5848708748817444,
-0.0009272360475733876,
-1.0860908031463623,
0.213372603058815,
-0.20235566794872284,
-0.3085283935070038,
0.16028308868408203,
-0.14799533784389496,
0.1584595888853073,
0.6967403292655945,
0.6330693960189819,
0.05134923756122589,
0.06180497631430626,
0.45641079545021057,
0.4180257022380829,
-0.3564978241920471,
-0.5750396847724915,
-0.5307366251945496,
0.4159772992134094,
0.04466831311583519,
-0.29955679178237915,
0.6998347640037537,
0.5335391759872437,
0.7189998030662537,
0.13196027278900146,
0.6250599026679993,
0.09332475811243057,
0.5282747745513916,
-0.4987877607345581,
0.5168185830116272,
-0.5008100867271423,
-0.05930740013718605,
-0.6166070699691772,
-0.6795833110809326,
0.038912542164325714,
0.9572483897209167,
-0.08681595325469971,
-0.048873402178287506,
0.42587941884994507,
0.48713451623916626,
0.15475207567214966,
0.40803807973861694,
0.3668301999568939,
0.23298075795173645,
0.07633785903453827,
0.4555329978466034,
0.6619376540184021,
-0.14179250597953796,
0.23620177805423737,
-0.5827510356903076,
-0.3958810865879059,
0.04423930123448372,
-0.9832355380058289,
-0.7517609000205994,
-0.5933144092559814,
-0.31635963916778564,
-0.08731517195701599,
0.28656116127967834,
0.8086186647415161,
1.2865543365478516,
-0.8876482248306274,
-0.7070392370223999,
-0.026963990181684494,
0.042959894984960556,
-0.4313381612300873,
-0.2095298320055008,
0.21525141596794128,
-0.1506178081035614,
-0.629133403301239,
0.9195913672447205,
0.2868369221687317,
-0.1475386917591095,
-0.46157535910606384,
-0.3251931369304657,
-0.027845729142427444,
-0.3799895644187927,
0.7150492072105408,
0.2694433629512787,
-1.0253034830093384,
-0.10965374857187271,
0.09718740731477737,
0.03278282657265663,
-0.0923379510641098,
0.8662051558494568,
-0.895058810710907,
0.5749744176864624,
0.46191465854644775,
0.8414208889007568,
0.993471086025238,
0.1477586179971695,
0.615162193775177,
-0.33411315083503723,
0.00012138413148932159,
0.455719918012619,
0.3981212079524994,
0.3143935799598694,
-0.2130594700574875,
0.7784435749053955,
0.06922658532857895,
-0.5240170359611511,
-1.1089975833892822,
0.058442436158657074,
-1.2316718101501465,
-0.2005711793899536,
0.9419726729393005,
-0.34312254190444946,
0.22666461765766144,
0.06709716469049454,
0.19690082967281342,
0.15942507982254028,
-0.27666807174682617,
0.08768799155950546,
0.5660344362258911,
-0.4329087436199188,
-0.20450928807258606,
-0.6269150972366333,
0.38822290301322937,
0.4916786551475525,
-0.6891430616378784,
-0.11075747758150101,
0.2784465551376343,
0.2649059295654297,
0.06410208344459534,
0.691955029964447,
0.19300860166549683,
0.35941192507743835,
-0.3420478403568268,
-0.28684642910957336,
-0.06969431787729263,
-0.5214927196502686,
-0.5297975540161133,
0.07656466215848923,
-0.0017302269116044044,
0.020837217569351196
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10073v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10073v1
|
Detecting the terminality of speech-turn boundary for spoken interactions in French TV and Radio content
| 2024-06-14T14:28:06 | 2024-06-14T14:28:06 |
Rémi Uro, Marie Tahon, David Doukhan, Antoine Laurent, Albert Rilliard
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.SD
|
Transition Relevance Places are defined as the end of an utterance where the
interlocutor may take the floor without interrupting the current speaker
--i.e., a place where the turn is terminal. Analyzing turn terminality is
useful to study the dynamic of turn-taking in spontaneous conversations. This
paper presents an automatic classification of spoken utterances as Terminal or
Non-Terminal in multi-speaker settings. We compared audio, text, and fusions of
both approaches on a French corpus of TV and Radio extracts annotated with
turn-terminality information at each speaker change. Our models are based on
pre-trained self-supervised representations. We report results for different
fusion strategies and varying context sizes. This study also questions the
problem of performance variability by analyzing the differences in results for
multiple training runs with random initialization. The measured accuracy would
allow the use of these models for large-scale analysis of turn-taking.
|
[
-0.662559449672699,
-0.8695123195648193,
0.7542678713798523,
0.06183145195245743,
0.0242427047342062,
0.005321836564689875,
-0.157440185546875,
-0.11171781271696091,
0.2874455749988556,
0.8499264121055603,
-0.5553725957870483,
-0.5115293860435486,
-0.7826904654502869,
-0.041196729987859726,
-0.6400179862976074,
0.607979416847229,
0.22930115461349487,
-0.014683069661259651,
0.13442039489746094,
-0.41526252031326294,
-0.6719646453857422,
-0.6612505912780762,
-0.5971605181694031,
-0.1628221571445465,
0.37520086765289307,
0.5819641947746277,
0.6851657629013062,
0.02746686339378357,
0.028311463072896004,
0.3573572337627411,
0.2245999574661255,
-0.062487296760082245,
-0.3199736475944519,
0.07331835478544235,
-0.15127359330654144,
-0.035008903592824936,
-0.04914040118455887,
0.3279755413532257,
0.5683504343032837,
0.6833518147468567,
0.056924570351839066,
-0.3527129292488098,
-0.4908532500267029,
0.4909690320491791,
-0.2453458607196808,
-0.1398223489522934,
-0.41590800881385803,
0.15171587467193604,
-0.1613146811723709,
-0.49781879782676697,
-0.6495192646980286,
-0.3332129716873169,
0.30931028723716736,
-0.0734502524137497,
0.10848251730203629,
-0.3388120234012604,
0.6970352530479431,
0.2398347556591034,
-0.8154476284980774,
-0.04912403225898743,
-1.0398248434066772,
0.4166933596134186,
-0.7155855894088745,
0.6961692571640015,
0.17217758297920227,
0.5382092595100403,
-0.15707606077194214,
-0.6155954003334045,
-0.7415160536766052,
-0.34385010600090027,
-0.08430064469575882,
-0.0337408073246479,
-0.1324181705713272,
0.3782777190208435,
0.31763017177581787,
0.02344183437526226,
-0.4188385009765625,
0.0019531042780727148,
-0.26518285274505615,
-0.22219374775886536,
0.4659141004085541,
-0.23067231476306915,
0.7519024014472961,
-0.24536772072315216,
0.13711318373680115,
-0.270685076713562,
-0.2445438802242279,
-0.14427869021892548,
0.370432049036026,
0.28089892864227295,
-0.21508005261421204,
0.49482136964797974,
-0.3334115743637085,
0.5281004309654236,
0.10488952696323395,
0.09205689281225204,
0.3835585117340088,
-0.19718512892723083,
0.02406887523829937,
0.23344068229198456,
0.7604793310165405,
0.31298843026161194,
0.1947951763868332,
-0.32281994819641113,
-0.0055303145200014114,
-0.15375325083732605,
0.24677224457263947,
-0.3717789947986603,
-0.24110332131385803,
0.2628490924835205,
-0.2593877911567688,
0.04590485244989395,
0.12189404666423798,
-0.30513545870780945,
0.0061443946324288845,
-0.33422210812568665,
0.5611263513565063,
-0.626432478427887,
-0.34790003299713135,
-0.019582176581025124,
-0.21446438133716583,
0.4824855625629425,
0.21900972723960876,
-0.606235682964325,
0.21923857927322388,
0.3641258776187897,
0.9312962293624878,
-0.4176029860973358,
-0.2613939940929413,
-0.9426387548446655,
-0.06075045093894005,
-0.07985386252403259,
0.7663944363594055,
-0.4099450707435608,
-0.6723107695579529,
0.1265399008989334,
0.16155299544334412,
-0.21951629221439362,
-0.21441644430160522,
0.5966289043426514,
-0.4708545207977295,
0.3970542848110199,
-0.1225859671831131,
-0.3166906237602234,
-0.19290104508399963,
-0.1082584336400032,
-0.6657054424285889,
0.7961118221282959,
0.043375708162784576,
-0.8315844535827637,
0.5268871188163757,
-0.42702049016952515,
-0.705810010433197,
-0.13116557896137238,
-0.47641655802726746,
-0.34798604249954224,
0.11734284460544586,
0.07584934681653976,
0.35421663522720337,
0.4238113462924957,
0.4664227366447449,
0.17191991209983826,
-0.15197496116161346,
0.482294499874115,
-0.5745252370834351,
0.2207709103822708,
0.01917296089231968,
-0.43465331196784973,
0.45927783846855164,
-0.8538644909858704,
-0.16242888569831848,
-0.44398415088653564,
-0.00565967196598649,
-0.3833698630332947,
0.30429980158805847,
0.2368418127298355,
0.6285151243209839,
-0.22658458352088928,
-0.3924247920513153,
0.21521344780921936,
-0.39098697900772095,
0.48147323727607727,
0.24719177186489105,
0.21078872680664062,
0.4464893043041229,
-0.3065306842327118,
0.17948751151561737,
0.37011992931365967,
0.4041390120983124,
-0.04876042902469635,
-0.6064928770065308,
-0.871521532535553,
-0.060684990137815475,
0.19716514647006989,
0.6424872279167175,
-0.9022493362426758,
0.4064989984035492,
-0.2524372339248657,
-0.2634541094303131,
-0.04153415560722351,
-0.6852027773857117,
0.0680035948753357,
0.26772525906562805,
0.4858914911746979,
-0.3476558327674866,
-0.316629022359848,
-1.0598055124282837,
-0.11691652983427048,
0.020395999774336815,
0.1606515496969223,
0.3379676938056946,
0.19824258983135223,
-0.49456945061683655,
1.006653070449829,
-0.09933777898550034,
-0.11548548191785812,
-0.09049816429615021,
0.732592761516571,
0.3488689661026001,
0.3785861134529114,
0.25042101740837097,
-1.0787392854690552,
-0.44555801153182983,
0.16930951178073883,
-0.6722168922424316,
-0.2354811131954193,
-0.362255334854126,
-0.052318453788757324,
0.09882023185491562,
0.8220912218093872,
-0.3904465138912201,
0.465867280960083,
0.32577604055404663,
-0.35224229097366333,
0.4481915533542633,
-0.10348819196224213,
0.5252469778060913,
-0.6720091700553894,
-0.0395917110145092,
-0.20428943634033203,
-0.3673134744167328,
-1.1226558685302734,
-0.7133423686027527,
-0.20620685815811157,
-0.019733864814043045,
-0.6635465025901794,
0.42237746715545654,
-0.3021611273288727,
-0.2746875584125519,
-0.16636374592781067,
0.41852274537086487,
-0.28550559282302856,
0.38326966762542725,
0.4682888686656952,
0.8829641938209534,
0.1801842749118805,
-0.7148629426956177,
-0.14352478086948395,
0.22838707268238068,
-0.21856987476348877,
0.31009072065353394,
-0.1092686876654625,
0.3954823911190033,
-0.14199404418468475,
0.16370393335819244,
-1.3800617456436157,
-0.2280825972557068,
0.1285744607448578,
-0.5166539549827576,
0.21541927754878998,
-0.35671401023864746,
0.060230329632759094,
-0.06693512946367264,
0.12709704041481018,
0.5248138904571533,
0.24370217323303223,
-0.07655546069145203,
0.6995391249656677,
0.43910637497901917,
-0.05192015320062637,
-0.4220833480358124,
-0.4880334138870239,
0.2128293812274933,
-0.29487648606300354,
-0.619743287563324,
0.40530267357826233,
0.12219090759754181,
-0.11223733425140381,
-0.3634827435016632,
0.08812930434942245,
0.01683282107114792,
-0.2718905210494995,
0.46275806427001953,
-0.2240360677242279,
0.09313049912452698,
0.0339694619178772,
0.3491341173648834,
-0.042120274156332016,
0.021178023889660835,
-0.1195874810218811,
0.7379772067070007,
0.18318480253219604,
-0.2657536268234253,
-0.43767115473747253,
0.6067882776260376,
0.9176191687583923,
0.047728266566991806,
0.6074454188346863,
0.47566330432891846,
-0.15053561329841614,
0.09700040519237518,
-0.9359719157218933,
-0.14878176152706146,
-0.4263071119785309,
0.11604111641645432,
-0.5685204267501831,
-0.710975706577301,
0.8724778890609741,
0.012767640873789787,
-0.1764858514070511,
0.505655825138092,
0.4271106421947479,
0.09161818027496338,
0.9291728138923645,
0.7117629647254944,
0.16606009006500244,
0.7584119439125061,
-0.24167048931121826,
0.12641416490077972,
-0.7159785628318787,
-0.29359379410743713,
-0.3561711609363556,
0.08175550401210785,
-0.8210660219192505,
-0.5788920521736145,
0.6165386438369751,
-0.4023529589176178,
0.07283219695091248,
0.3856944143772125,
-0.4144043028354645,
0.18634085357189178,
0.24264609813690186,
-0.14415505528450012,
0.37709394097328186,
-0.1397547870874405,
-0.04481564462184906,
-0.1483892947435379,
-0.7289997339248657,
-0.34429553151130676,
0.5536277294158936,
0.43496954441070557,
0.49248072504997253,
0.12818069756031036,
0.7579876184463501,
0.6703978180885315,
0.10130233317613602,
-0.8951498866081238,
0.42580071091651917,
-0.1713733971118927,
-0.34437668323516846,
-0.7655729055404663,
-0.41043516993522644,
-0.8927962183952332,
0.26679468154907227,
0.12555238604545593,
-0.7614027261734009,
0.5798230767250061,
-0.2501523792743683,
-0.09712526947259903,
0.08343208581209183,
-0.5678377151489258,
0.8916859030723572,
-0.26942992210388184,
0.07468419522047043,
-0.32039904594421387,
-0.8778350949287415,
0.24971504509449005,
0.18151159584522247,
0.5665526986122131,
-0.1886182278394699,
0.5209089517593384,
0.9651681184768677,
-0.1511046141386032,
0.6292300224304199,
-0.29036325216293335,
-0.11098812520503998,
0.3302833139896393,
0.2144792377948761,
0.1592068374156952,
0.17392756044864655,
0.08710526674985886,
0.31544432044029236,
0.1947416216135025,
-0.013043589890003204,
-0.29531368613243103,
0.5973563194274902,
-0.9846618175506592,
-0.38601237535476685,
-0.5618343949317932,
-0.04341897740960121,
-0.4490528106689453,
0.24065238237380981,
0.762092113494873,
0.5774399638175964,
-0.47318410873413086,
-0.2896234691143036,
0.7867687344551086,
-0.4060364365577698,
0.5514792203903198,
0.4333007335662842,
-0.29841288924217224,
-0.35758844017982483,
0.9726152420043945,
0.47027117013931274,
0.35002535581588745,
0.4056456685066223,
0.0003464141336735338,
-0.3329952359199524,
-0.38642993569374084,
-0.39359986782073975,
0.34125250577926636,
-0.9089563488960266,
0.25184300541877747,
-0.8185216188430786,
-0.5881933569908142,
-0.3098752200603485,
-0.09764788299798965,
-0.4890916347503662,
-0.5322466492652893,
-0.22106796503067017,
0.07460476458072662,
0.0385097861289978,
0.4698062241077423,
-0.23255030810832977,
0.5922383666038513,
-0.8516392111778259,
0.19005174934864044,
0.5128175616264343,
0.14855241775512695,
-0.26951372623443604,
-0.8602275252342224,
-0.17748618125915527,
-0.23204611241817474,
-0.21415267884731293,
-1.1256731748580933,
0.4452688992023468,
0.2637673020362854,
0.715662956237793,
0.262597918510437,
-0.01444079540669918,
-0.038252927362918854,
-0.5986159443855286,
0.7277529835700989,
0.40863463282585144,
-1.1038321256637573,
0.6956843137741089,
-0.5584778785705566,
0.4112894833087921,
0.7816553711891174,
0.4813637435436249,
-1.1729730367660522,
-0.35833147168159485,
-0.6950533390045166,
-0.8005825281143188,
0.689951479434967,
0.3452189266681671,
0.03766390681266785,
-0.2010485678911209,
0.1960141509771347,
0.26306214928627014,
0.14144358038902283,
-0.6885206699371338,
-0.1513582170009613,
-0.3196864724159241,
0.2358940988779068,
-0.09403206408023834,
-0.18689127266407013,
-0.23459553718566895,
-0.1571919471025467,
0.5274356603622437,
-0.12717287242412567,
0.5973877310752869,
0.4637471139431,
-0.30627351999282837,
-0.02234688401222229,
0.22653262317180634,
0.7860182523727417,
0.856546938419342,
-0.3992007076740265,
0.2487916648387909,
0.15441538393497467,
-0.08188707381486893,
0.36259955167770386,
-0.3760494887828827,
-0.02903909794986248,
0.4373076856136322,
0.357596755027771,
0.8839789628982544,
0.2668760418891907,
-0.4091019630432129,
0.5373132228851318,
-0.2515016496181488,
-0.02991696633398533,
-0.504344642162323,
-0.08945766091346741,
-0.3922412395477295,
0.05185161530971527,
0.4181026816368103,
-0.2692079544067383,
0.652890145778656,
-0.756912887096405,
0.5801309943199158,
0.2419266402721405,
-0.6133916974067688,
-0.3097008168697357,
0.22511173784732819,
0.5252588391304016,
-0.39642176032066345,
0.6392520666122437,
-0.2605735957622528,
-0.5786803364753723,
0.3540457785129547,
-0.01453065499663353,
1.259560227394104,
-0.4915178120136261,
0.5787156224250793,
0.12318653613328934,
0.006920419633388519,
0.19618748128414154,
0.058836471289396286,
-0.2268112301826477,
-0.8827884197235107,
-0.7429961562156677,
-0.41116592288017273,
-0.5891045928001404,
0.14437414705753326,
-0.6176823377609253,
0.38677147030830383,
-0.07966963946819305,
-0.6669071316719055,
0.07624150067567825,
-0.648792564868927,
-0.2852851152420044,
0.21539966762065887,
0.4995075464248657,
0.677323579788208,
-1.1649059057235718,
0.8296747803688049,
0.4358856678009033,
-0.07776308059692383,
-0.184905007481575,
0.26437607407569885,
-0.44535350799560547,
-0.18537425994873047,
0.6719940304756165,
0.2971924841403961,
-0.5714479684829712,
-0.11080889403820038,
-0.20667921006679535,
-0.6838584542274475,
0.40054184198379517,
-0.13520866632461548,
-0.6163155436515808,
-0.12801998853683472,
0.35112354159355164,
0.37048840522766113,
-0.2511884570121765,
0.6947130560874939,
0.8294759392738342,
0.3876608610153198,
0.23300661146640778,
-1.2658518552780151,
-0.29156234860420227,
0.2388579100370407,
-0.017773570492863655,
0.3985261023044586,
-0.8499991297721863,
0.6436752676963806,
0.2865462005138397,
-0.3507532775402069,
-0.4205079972743988,
0.6518315672874451,
-0.19412177801132202,
0.559742271900177,
0.6741002798080444,
0.07230209559202194,
0.30356186628341675,
-0.2994368374347687,
0.3382265269756317,
-0.18148928880691528,
0.31006091833114624,
0.6961024403572083,
-0.06455393135547638,
0.5957546234130859,
0.5281707048416138,
-0.22497206926345825,
0.6023971438407898,
0.5613659620285034,
0.6270168423652649,
0.6707941293716431,
0.0901491641998291,
-0.20614109933376312,
-0.4324767291545868,
0.26090919971466064,
-0.40220609307289124,
0.6013661026954651,
0.730216920375824,
0.05819064378738403,
-0.05774197727441788,
0.7173094749450684,
-0.1396569013595581,
-0.10423330217599869,
0.08979428559541702,
0.7906585335731506,
0.2809515595436096,
-0.7411745190620422,
0.6643039584159851,
-0.03487108647823334,
0.46232959628105164,
-0.3661652207374573,
0.0964568629860878,
-0.3300587832927704,
-0.3348773717880249,
-0.2094246745109558,
-0.6576388478279114,
0.5212887525558472,
-0.5960307717323303,
-0.13211701810359955,
0.11769252270460129,
0.25517207384109497,
-0.29089993238449097,
-0.16946838796138763,
0.5506662726402283,
0.5317526459693909,
0.2854456603527069,
0.04859376698732376,
-0.4509783387184143,
0.30688023567199707,
-0.034656643867492676,
-0.16232484579086304,
0.23713596165180206,
0.5359943509101868,
-0.21794508397579193,
0.5193980932235718,
0.1717010736465454,
-0.10148320347070694,
0.356962651014328,
0.4402003884315491,
0.7389519214630127,
-0.8569987416267395,
-0.6871774792671204,
-0.5553218722343445,
0.43349093198776245,
-0.13008984923362732,
-0.3105820119380951,
0.48585373163223267,
0.39720281958580017,
0.529731810092926,
0.027646271511912346,
0.8764205574989319,
-0.17893055081367493,
0.2506488263607025,
-0.7877106070518494,
0.24204029142856598,
-0.17897413671016693,
0.12520182132720947,
-0.24408791959285736,
-0.9411662817001343,
-0.009860712103545666,
0.6567710638046265,
-0.7471855878829956,
0.09693853557109833,
0.5845106840133667,
0.48654037714004517,
-0.19951297342777252,
-0.14292024075984955,
0.671023964881897,
0.15446646511554718,
0.5902887582778931,
0.34152430295944214,
1.073610544204712,
-0.40411102771759033,
0.13234367966651917,
-0.22458721697330475,
-0.3549852967262268,
-0.5113086104393005,
-0.7099983096122742,
-0.9219805002212524,
-1.060450553894043,
-0.7018399238586426,
-0.4138296842575073,
0.20040518045425415,
0.5586355328559875,
0.965380847454071,
-0.8482282757759094,
-0.4820055663585663,
-0.07511042803525925,
0.06179073825478554,
-0.07745776325464249,
-0.28345078229904175,
0.38805440068244934,
-0.1995786726474762,
-0.6076407432556152,
0.7089731097221375,
0.33658868074417114,
0.025727998465299606,
-0.3726544976234436,
0.2321760505437851,
-0.36044842004776,
0.31441429257392883,
0.6656746864318848,
0.6513691544532776,
-0.664576530456543,
-0.7432379722595215,
-0.3044995069503784,
0.03375031799077988,
0.2784580886363983,
0.9409074783325195,
-0.6785975098609924,
0.6773009300231934,
0.5170502066612244,
0.09660780429840088,
0.9178480505943298,
0.10573123395442963,
0.41831696033477783,
-0.8499375581741333,
0.3885733485221863,
0.28040221333503723,
-0.028054749593138695,
0.272723913192749,
-0.5092010498046875,
0.15593001246452332,
0.20585688948631287,
-0.8653767108917236,
-0.6269786953926086,
0.23244696855545044,
-1.273921251296997,
-0.2684422433376312,
1.2497129440307617,
0.3797037899494171,
-0.013697477988898754,
-0.3312113285064697,
-0.3442906141281128,
0.5752883553504944,
-0.4822811782360077,
0.6442241072654724,
0.8166846632957458,
-0.6280755400657654,
-0.2605627775192261,
-0.8097499012947083,
0.7026149034500122,
0.29679787158966064,
-0.4556368887424469,
-0.16695255041122437,
0.2659141719341278,
0.19287219643592834,
0.37048229575157166,
0.7639885544776917,
0.11615779995918274,
0.05099279806017876,
-0.29919368028640747,
-0.024236861616373062,
0.5100878477096558,
-0.6315628886222839,
-0.24806535243988037,
-0.028307585045695305,
0.04950373247265816,
-0.22233442962169647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.14522v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.14522v1
|
Learning thresholds lead to stable language coexistence
| 2024-06-14T14:24:02 | 2024-06-14T14:24:02 |
Mikhail V. Tamm, Els Heinsalu, Stefano Scialla, Marco Patriarca
|
physics.soc-ph
|
physics.soc-ph, cs.CL
|
We introduce a language competition model that incorporates the effects of
memory and learning on the language shift dynamics, using the Abrams-Strogatz
model as a starting point. On a coarse grained time scale, the effects of
memory and learning can be expressed as thresholds on the speakers fractions.
In its simplest form, the resulting model is exactly solvable. Besides the
consensus on one of the two languages, the model describes additional
equilibrium states that are not present in the Abrams-Strogatz model: a stable
coexistence of the two languages, if both thresholds are low enough, so that
the language shift processes in the two opposite directions compensate each
other, and a frozen state coinciding with the initial state, when both
thresholds are too high for any language shift to take place. We show
numerically that these results are preserved for threshold functions of a more
general shape.
|
[
-0.24944806098937988,
-0.8584890365600586,
0.5330930948257446,
0.22882527112960815,
-0.12572744488716125,
-0.006642963737249374,
-0.49128860235214233,
-0.501521110534668,
0.13797417283058167,
0.2658092975616455,
-0.2536540627479553,
-0.019538892433047295,
-0.7303212881088257,
-0.1884050816297531,
-0.38827231526374817,
0.8637749552726746,
-0.18504008650779724,
-0.12427406758069992,
-0.11447571963071823,
-0.12636318802833557,
-0.3968998193740845,
-0.2716117203235626,
-0.9749820232391357,
-0.5336102247238159,
0.27848267555236816,
0.22279930114746094,
0.6037119030952454,
0.7853459715843201,
0.3009326159954071,
0.23806236684322357,
-0.199395552277565,
-0.5042952299118042,
-0.5443302392959595,
0.7524648904800415,
-0.2469332367181778,
-0.47601017355918884,
0.08236361294984818,
0.14680346846580505,
0.9138022661209106,
0.8022764325141907,
-0.5415046215057373,
-0.37453243136405945,
0.209249347448349,
0.5837931036949158,
-0.4269237816333771,
0.12896323204040527,
-0.8019250631332397,
0.11015539616346359,
-0.24584908783435822,
-0.09447358548641205,
-0.42141076922416687,
-0.41038045287132263,
0.3366684019565582,
-0.23439504206180573,
-0.1551530659198761,
-0.3703380525112152,
1.2084907293319702,
0.18300317227840424,
-0.19803541898727417,
-0.28490421175956726,
-0.5934319496154785,
0.8428196907043457,
-0.13118848204612732,
0.7991839647293091,
0.3894321918487549,
-0.11541306972503662,
-0.1494637131690979,
-0.4716055691242218,
-0.3066769242286682,
-0.4515741169452667,
0.3513421416282654,
-0.042274460196495056,
-0.45166152715682983,
-0.17635540664196014,
0.011655506677925587,
0.1460169404745102,
-0.229157954454422,
0.2645401358604431,
-0.643842875957489,
-0.05635002627968788,
0.245448499917984,
0.2784785330295563,
0.6455647349357605,
0.47687312960624695,
-0.6227433085441589,
-0.04324742779135704,
-0.5761837363243103,
0.37870192527770996,
0.44652441143989563,
0.5420342087745667,
-0.2648966908454895,
-0.01574714668095112,
0.15462812781333923,
0.5205720067024231,
0.16627627611160278,
-0.05611776188015938,
0.2393931746482849,
-0.006446613930165768,
0.20222172141075134,
-0.15270289778709412,
0.8183055520057678,
0.37801021337509155,
0.442440003156662,
-0.32234635949134827,
-0.025569431483745575,
0.6054114103317261,
0.10231704264879227,
-0.27260738611221313,
-0.19842852652072906,
-0.30798470973968506,
-0.3181885778903961,
-0.16510681807994843,
-0.2799068093299866,
-0.830328643321991,
0.14226342737674713,
-0.056960396468639374,
0.4701835513114929,
-0.33835095167160034,
-0.6116175651550293,
0.3132425546646118,
-0.12577705085277557,
0.07886909693479538,
0.13547278940677643,
-1.1554962396621704,
0.8426566123962402,
0.524042010307312,
0.9404181838035583,
-0.601947009563446,
-0.6480526924133301,
-0.3635258674621582,
-0.2235843539237976,
-0.7011772394180298,
0.561760425567627,
-0.9769953489303589,
-0.37934839725494385,
0.1172003448009491,
0.03898081183433533,
-0.42259252071380615,
-0.6463356614112854,
0.16332301497459412,
-0.8481885194778442,
0.12113232165575027,
-0.13138969242572784,
-0.38868582248687744,
0.20935262739658356,
0.005143892951309681,
-0.7869399785995483,
1.165526270866394,
0.006047346163541079,
-0.30562540888786316,
0.4269174039363861,
-0.26049959659576416,
-0.4796779751777649,
0.09421323984861374,
-0.020328588783740997,
-0.3998181223869324,
-0.011266467161476612,
-0.7351212501525879,
-0.05710282176733017,
-0.02800687402486801,
0.014539563097059727,
-0.1497703641653061,
-0.08077453821897507,
0.2654232382774353,
-0.07036701589822769,
0.8710889220237732,
0.3506505787372589,
-0.4152531027793884,
-0.207577183842659,
-0.19407683610916138,
-0.034805864095687866,
0.06240175664424896,
-0.8809943199157715,
-0.39524877071380615,
0.3604121804237366,
-0.35489144921302795,
0.5326212048530579,
0.11189088225364685,
-0.2738996744155884,
0.20096643269062042,
0.038454990833997726,
0.4309578835964203,
0.5769567489624023,
0.10412964224815369,
0.7274565696716309,
-0.2830986976623535,
0.5415062308311462,
0.7312897443771362,
0.018203003332018852,
0.236533522605896,
-0.4897746741771698,
-0.9933236837387085,
0.1636132150888443,
0.376294881105423,
0.6297680735588074,
-0.6097239851951599,
0.0022202341351658106,
-0.0898967981338501,
-0.21052661538124084,
-0.4728303551673889,
0.14884081482887268,
0.31597521901130676,
0.31966307759284973,
0.14227107167243958,
-0.6446146368980408,
-0.3409281373023987,
-0.8086794018745422,
-0.1242213323712349,
-0.16555199027061462,
0.3516353964805603,
-0.1657264232635498,
0.3905242085456848,
-0.004569206386804581,
0.5417651534080505,
-0.2359851747751236,
-0.0794171392917633,
-0.12625207006931305,
-0.01166787464171648,
-0.09372859448194504,
0.572285532951355,
0.6632299423217773,
-0.6324576735496521,
-0.7253594398498535,
-0.05589058995246887,
-0.27239978313446045,
-0.09664437174797058,
0.07247542589902878,
-0.1017119511961937,
0.40476134419441223,
0.8568923473358154,
-0.43161001801490784,
0.17860658466815948,
0.7308992743492126,
-0.46001675724983215,
0.4723132252693176,
-0.00037956482265144587,
0.19686122238636017,
-0.8475518226623535,
-0.15095308423042297,
0.11233650147914886,
0.02271299436688423,
-0.9985624551773071,
0.041125740855932236,
-0.0027000736445188522,
0.19202105700969696,
-0.4477470815181732,
0.3991663157939911,
-0.32543712854385376,
0.1296064257621765,
-0.2813139855861664,
0.34008902311325073,
-0.3402942419052124,
0.18066661059856415,
0.440597802400589,
0.6054766774177551,
0.8504191040992737,
-0.808283805847168,
-0.1482655107975006,
-0.16008159518241882,
-0.45069947838783264,
0.3177124261856079,
-0.4031756520271301,
-0.02796459197998047,
-0.012273820117115974,
-0.377411425113678,
-0.7906150817871094,
0.3087114691734314,
0.36114218831062317,
-0.48860687017440796,
0.15042857825756073,
-0.3517828583717346,
0.07340498268604279,
0.16612349450588226,
0.026272907853126526,
0.30724528431892395,
0.7028001546859741,
-0.038252703845500946,
0.11220089346170425,
0.8286882638931274,
-0.3965547978878021,
-0.5700190663337708,
-0.6614105701446533,
0.07670711725950241,
-0.12231442332267761,
-0.2734759449958801,
0.08465700596570969,
-0.017795037478208542,
-0.6556944847106934,
0.32888972759246826,
0.18706950545310974,
-0.2955121695995331,
0.1662132441997528,
0.0862637460231781,
0.32278794050216675,
-0.1937536895275116,
0.32854029536247253,
0.0009767739102244377,
-0.27722203731536865,
0.035901814699172974,
-0.48400774598121643,
0.6394010782241821,
-0.27980872988700867,
0.25323137640953064,
0.07370896637439728,
0.41680487990379333,
0.5845054388046265,
-0.2364339381456375,
1.1161508560180664,
0.07619640976190567,
-0.4484100043773651,
-0.4554606080055237,
-0.1605921983718872,
-0.10279584676027298,
-0.47011157870292664,
0.3144465386867523,
-0.6383923292160034,
-1.2170082330703735,
0.7371281385421753,
0.1929188370704651,
-0.17340193688869476,
0.6348425149917603,
0.7036012411117554,
0.12419704347848892,
0.7935546040534973,
0.7584325075149536,
-0.04047009348869324,
0.8967095017433167,
0.20951169729232788,
0.13457578420639038,
-0.6243593096733093,
-0.283785343170166,
-0.7005390524864197,
-0.27230048179626465,
-0.4817863702774048,
-0.41449040174484253,
0.33910685777664185,
0.2097790539264679,
-0.10721059888601303,
0.39563417434692383,
-0.03867240250110626,
0.8861686587333679,
0.48009946942329407,
-0.0709962248802185,
0.03132511302828789,
0.2047702819108963,
-0.6144440770149231,
-0.5421774387359619,
-0.7708187699317932,
-0.2017434537410736,
0.5951387882232666,
0.22108887135982513,
0.8369039297103882,
0.10051774978637695,
0.4242361783981323,
0.4003034830093384,
-0.20586344599723816,
-0.5189833045005798,
0.47505056858062744,
-0.252234548330307,
-0.7323169112205505,
-0.3787272274494171,
-0.6353365182876587,
-1.2452689409255981,
0.20993448793888092,
-0.3653591275215149,
-0.938848614692688,
0.34871363639831543,
-0.16752788424491882,
0.012707218527793884,
0.4904657006263733,
-0.5013050436973572,
0.7656216621398926,
-0.021886268630623817,
-0.7615188360214233,
-0.4670237600803375,
-0.7377619743347168,
0.27959784865379333,
0.18492832779884338,
0.24332651495933533,
-0.37740442156791687,
-0.0689392238855362,
1.119765043258667,
0.09677334129810333,
0.5838121771812439,
-0.06730182468891144,
-0.06725472211837769,
0.4872146546840668,
0.7207480669021606,
0.1699846237897873,
-0.4332816004753113,
-0.17214146256446838,
0.027609698474407196,
-0.06080786511301994,
-0.4065612554550171,
-0.22438150644302368,
0.7185212969779968,
-0.9352502822875977,
-0.53968346118927,
-0.43188968300819397,
-0.5276360511779785,
0.019129833206534386,
0.28820377588272095,
0.22042381763458252,
0.0664634257555008,
-0.16873130202293396,
0.06206386908888817,
0.9051659107208252,
0.2450830340385437,
0.5625725388526917,
0.6514144539833069,
-0.25013914704322815,
-0.2818147838115692,
0.8111595511436462,
0.2605932950973511,
0.8534298539161682,
0.05231799557805061,
0.2801292836666107,
-0.04502633959054947,
-0.46500691771507263,
-0.16402029991149902,
0.10067412257194519,
-0.721022367477417,
0.1464710384607315,
-0.4644545018672943,
-0.39914757013320923,
-0.2006625086069107,
-0.3107483685016632,
-0.4675551950931549,
-0.37267839908599854,
-0.15765923261642456,
-0.16462282836437225,
0.01981244795024395,
0.7862726449966431,
-0.6858711838722229,
-0.016035063192248344,
-0.6111559271812439,
-0.09800945222377777,
0.4597608745098114,
0.4399797022342682,
0.09349396079778671,
-0.8421922922134399,
-0.5917103290557861,
-0.11894676834344864,
-0.06191842257976532,
-0.7671304941177368,
0.22738341987133026,
0.32983776926994324,
0.667131245136261,
0.5520222187042236,
-0.07474184781312943,
0.47495409846305847,
-0.6269000768661499,
0.7673743367195129,
0.45267271995544434,
-1.3112010955810547,
0.18986034393310547,
-0.3481511175632477,
0.09228960424661636,
0.6431589722633362,
0.647692859172821,
-1.025559902191162,
-0.6409513354301453,
-0.5224750638008118,
-0.7219797372817993,
0.6789909601211548,
-0.21551764011383057,
0.28880104422569275,
-0.16801130771636963,
0.2474943995475769,
0.2023157775402069,
-0.1808900088071823,
-0.9919858574867249,
-0.08569453656673431,
0.3097493052482605,
-0.024163968861103058,
0.024896373972296715,
-0.24101141095161438,
-0.16169723868370056,
-0.18459585309028625,
0.45949259400367737,
0.5064656138420105,
0.07578376680612564,
-0.25475257635116577,
-0.1967345029115677,
-0.6470224261283875,
0.3088251054286957,
0.8221473097801208,
0.45718318223953247,
0.09747012704610825,
0.7102910280227661,
0.23652148246765137,
-0.5953499674797058,
0.5510547161102295,
-0.4284903109073639,
-0.34106025099754333,
-0.13383634388446808,
0.2529790699481964,
0.826874315738678,
0.4693230986595154,
-0.42941364645957947,
0.250383198261261,
-0.025744155049324036,
-0.39852774143218994,
0.1493115872144699,
0.3295612037181854,
0.26630544662475586,
0.2204352170228958,
0.16290313005447388,
0.26569822430610657,
-0.3723013401031494,
-0.642910897731781,
0.6333890557289124,
0.37191644310951233,
-0.6237595677375793,
-0.45848309993743896,
0.7974750995635986,
0.23106339573860168,
-0.4404149055480957,
0.665928065776825,
-0.2515391707420349,
-0.8648571968078613,
0.4884728491306305,
0.8109591007232666,
0.626533031463623,
-0.6937741637229919,
0.31678536534309387,
0.2492823749780655,
0.6042011976242065,
-0.2653104066848755,
-0.032840460538864136,
-0.057412199676036835,
-1.0157724618911743,
-0.06251390278339386,
-0.4839869439601898,
-0.5353506207466125,
-0.1911274492740631,
-0.8497729301452637,
-0.0016634430503472686,
-0.34550055861473083,
-0.2763110399246216,
0.03591429814696312,
0.018642378970980644,
-0.14423947036266327,
0.1786038875579834,
0.34005632996559143,
0.652212917804718,
-1.321087121963501,
0.9077674746513367,
0.3238433599472046,
-0.193345308303833,
-0.4058842957019806,
-0.08065802603960037,
-0.2013038843870163,
-0.7884228229522705,
0.6704477071762085,
-0.29589295387268066,
-0.5945379137992859,
-0.0681416243314743,
-0.5445069074630737,
-0.9714958667755127,
0.322083443403244,
0.47168830037117004,
-0.41871437430381775,
0.15473507344722748,
-0.07467225939035416,
0.4949674904346466,
-0.3765740990638733,
-0.3900725245475769,
0.8379387855529785,
0.179787278175354,
0.031542178243398666,
-0.7777247428894043,
-0.12045121937990189,
-0.2703913152217865,
-0.3068925738334656,
0.6520695090293884,
-0.7413594722747803,
1.2891461849212646,
-0.12357399612665176,
-0.6272960305213928,
-0.3718341886997223,
0.27025753259658813,
-0.04333853721618652,
-0.18213900923728943,
0.5828987956047058,
0.9479210376739502,
0.35974565148353577,
-0.3436315953731537,
0.4815962016582489,
-0.39729079604148865,
0.49164605140686035,
0.7960018515586853,
-0.4053260385990143,
1.2557634115219116,
0.5496213436126709,
-0.5563950538635254,
0.933958888053894,
0.49886059761047363,
0.34076106548309326,
0.605231523513794,
0.052328042685985565,
-0.45865821838378906,
-0.5982794165611267,
-0.036471132189035416,
-0.4409147799015045,
0.13591748476028442,
0.572516679763794,
-0.3296479284763336,
-0.24176692962646484,
-0.09338873624801636,
0.4964872896671295,
0.10288669914007187,
-0.14359629154205322,
0.6054953932762146,
0.1736186146736145,
-0.937584400177002,
0.5665098428726196,
0.03935244679450989,
0.42780715227127075,
-0.8503397703170776,
0.25922054052352905,
-0.1997276097536087,
0.3353143334388733,
-0.013587331399321556,
-0.8743309378623962,
0.225936621427536,
-0.15151062607765198,
-0.3737473487854004,
-0.1661699414253235,
0.7086776494979858,
-1.2235057353973389,
-0.14940513670444489,
0.8401603102684021,
0.45667359232902527,
0.1197090893983841,
0.794421911239624,
-0.5826846361160278,
0.5631803274154663,
-0.14601309597492218,
-0.10744841396808624,
0.4711030423641205,
0.08789002895355225,
0.11911329627037048,
0.5777297616004944,
0.4015390872955322,
0.3208935260772705,
0.4825518727302551,
-0.33805274963378906,
0.5913882851600647,
-0.541093647480011,
-0.8847322463989258,
-0.922173023223877,
0.4119223654270172,
0.19211411476135254,
-0.286367803812027,
0.6771366596221924,
0.4242957830429077,
0.7684383988380432,
-0.11735178530216217,
0.7301879525184631,
-0.11901871114969254,
0.22421415150165558,
-0.6520560383796692,
0.7546190619468689,
-0.4211241602897644,
-0.18966639041900635,
-0.1401052474975586,
-0.7442712783813477,
-0.09909820556640625,
0.5884897112846375,
-0.531895637512207,
0.07250961661338806,
0.9212929606437683,
0.5888270735740662,
0.3331873118877411,
-0.3143542408943176,
0.46915319561958313,
0.1939319521188736,
-0.05406351014971733,
1.0786100625991821,
0.9011902213096619,
-0.23049962520599365,
0.4673559367656708,
0.031047437340021133,
-0.2379547357559204,
-0.17833177745342255,
-0.5818947553634644,
-0.7612363696098328,
-1.1568433046340942,
-0.5841537117958069,
-0.7742645144462585,
0.3259701132774353,
0.7585266828536987,
0.6196644306182861,
-0.8430016040802002,
-0.8491261601448059,
0.033345963805913925,
0.36460059881210327,
-0.3304392099380493,
-0.24221929907798767,
0.015950864180922508,
-0.645094633102417,
-0.6577760577201843,
0.41487327218055725,
0.32714346051216125,
0.2744896411895752,
-0.10190299898386002,
-0.42393821477890015,
-0.4365822672843933,
0.35486674308776855,
0.2896777093410492,
0.6929168105125427,
-0.3409769833087921,
-0.2372969388961792,
-0.048601239919662476,
-0.34330040216445923,
0.32140761613845825,
0.8005508780479431,
-0.461849182844162,
0.5424174070358276,
0.2717556953430176,
0.30463576316833496,
0.5027740597724915,
-0.3485707640647888,
0.3831685185432434,
-0.33004841208457947,
0.3549536466598511,
0.04749733954668045,
0.04981180652976036,
-0.009426718577742577,
0.22134292125701904,
0.18142069876194,
0.5353677868843079,
-0.596327543258667,
-0.8074314594268799,
0.5075117349624634,
-0.5734758377075195,
-0.24528370797634125,
0.8935627937316895,
-0.1400207281112671,
-0.23861390352249146,
-0.26624536514282227,
0.42852848768234253,
0.17231623828411102,
-0.2579798102378845,
1.0308431386947632,
1.1620020866394043,
0.02430671826004982,
-0.34922221302986145,
-0.3088762164115906,
0.8085224628448486,
0.5357229113578796,
-0.4827863276004791,
-0.018769916146993637,
0.24358013272285461,
0.5848616361618042,
0.11485663056373596,
0.512409508228302,
-0.12728136777877808,
0.4539019465446472,
0.7204140424728394,
-0.051724135875701904,
0.41567397117614746,
-0.5106462836265564,
-0.6458578109741211,
0.25393158197402954,
0.15834787487983704,
-0.21322625875473022
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10052v1
|
Simul-Whisper: Attention-Guided Streaming Whisper with Truncation Detection
| 2024-06-14T14:07:26 | 2024-06-14T14:07:26 |
Haoyu Wang, Guoqiang Hu, Guodong Lin, Wei-Qiang Zhang, Jian Li
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
As a robust and large-scale multilingual speech recognition model, Whisper
has demonstrated impressive results in many low-resource and
out-of-distribution scenarios. However, its encoder-decoder structure hinders
its application to streaming speech recognition. In this paper, we introduce
Simul-Whisper, which uses the time alignment embedded in Whisper's
cross-attention to guide auto-regressive decoding and achieve chunk-based
streaming ASR without any fine-tuning of the pre-trained model. Furthermore, we
observe the negative effect of the truncated words at the chunk boundaries on
the decoding results and propose an integrate-and-fire-based truncation
detection model to address this issue. Experiments on multiple languages and
Whisper architectures show that Simul-Whisper achieves an average absolute word
error rate degradation of only 1.46% at a chunk size of 1 second, which
significantly outperforms the current state-of-the-art baseline.
|
[
-0.19658541679382324,
-0.5747590065002441,
-0.010507517494261265,
0.41302916407585144,
-0.44852742552757263,
0.43971312046051025,
-0.11438746005296707,
-0.5695490837097168,
0.49149230122566223,
0.053870704025030136,
-0.7566081285476685,
-0.2725159823894501,
-0.7084547281265259,
-0.10875282436609268,
-0.6760173439979553,
0.4422401487827301,
0.19642698764801025,
-0.2605634331703186,
0.2746172249317169,
0.0014799012569710612,
-0.5727096796035767,
-0.21618831157684326,
-0.7503036856651306,
-0.01039645355194807,
0.28628507256507874,
0.2117016315460205,
0.6004060506820679,
0.8921288847923279,
0.20387203991413116,
0.2453640252351761,
-0.1386934518814087,
0.2967258095741272,
-0.41385719180107117,
0.03281368315219879,
0.5512376427650452,
-0.10630568861961365,
-0.3646200895309448,
-0.3008936941623688,
0.9817997217178345,
0.19447268545627594,
-0.7097840905189514,
0.4328688085079193,
0.27679455280303955,
0.5052466988563538,
-0.8677782416343689,
0.00042028314783237875,
-0.5198493599891663,
-0.07737524062395096,
-0.5631882548332214,
-0.41276147961616516,
-0.39602383971214294,
-0.3305351138114929,
0.32404401898384094,
-0.4422342777252197,
0.3534999489784241,
0.15755073726177216,
0.7628941535949707,
0.7899654507637024,
-0.16667406260967255,
-0.17895452678203583,
-0.963724672794342,
0.9364028573036194,
-0.7138778567314148,
0.85822993516922,
0.21994104981422424,
0.4987878203392029,
0.1208866760134697,
-0.44735419750213623,
-0.39496275782585144,
0.19494932889938354,
0.19354549050331116,
0.1712748259305954,
-0.18726670742034912,
0.0663144662976265,
0.11549833416938782,
0.18240217864513397,
-0.7589895129203796,
-0.24682804942131042,
-0.39541497826576233,
-0.502887487411499,
0.7305797338485718,
-0.002931073075160384,
0.10055778175592422,
-0.00659173633903265,
-0.14217104017734528,
-0.03166520595550537,
-0.45812684297561646,
0.11198456585407257,
0.6196683645248413,
0.3506358563899994,
-0.25717613101005554,
0.2705397605895996,
0.06930245459079742,
0.7979992032051086,
0.09797243773937225,
-0.3707767426967621,
0.28031888604164124,
0.1972440630197525,
-0.24013499915599823,
0.810727059841156,
0.780277669429779,
0.10518746823072433,
0.16611690819263458,
-0.017261967062950134,
0.11027654260396957,
0.23727576434612274,
0.09320398420095444,
-0.51014643907547,
0.03253898024559021,
0.4756118059158325,
-0.37687331438064575,
-0.05977046489715576,
-0.1306733638048172,
-0.4921053946018219,
0.027680428698658943,
0.03473648428916931,
0.4705889821052551,
-0.5972687005996704,
-0.4642166793346405,
0.5323686003684998,
-0.3008820414543152,
0.05438012257218361,
0.10667269676923752,
-0.5193201899528503,
0.3264234960079193,
0.44314688444137573,
1.0872937440872192,
-0.17934945225715637,
-0.3824749290943146,
-1.0438971519470215,
0.6177557706832886,
0.13885198533535004,
0.7174450755119324,
-0.6052242517471313,
-0.6121004223823547,
-0.09279994666576385,
-0.30140671133995056,
-0.280396044254303,
-0.480396032333374,
0.7755658030509949,
-0.19649167358875275,
-0.10508587211370468,
0.2402113676071167,
-0.695559024810791,
-0.20825201272964478,
-0.08106110990047455,
-0.6576973795890808,
0.8332327008247375,
-0.3401678800582886,
-0.8635838031768799,
0.33907750248908997,
-0.48586931824684143,
-0.4896484315395355,
0.25556057691574097,
0.28064024448394775,
-0.460650235414505,
0.26792481541633606,
0.46910005807876587,
0.1538562923669815,
-0.057707127183675766,
0.13877972960472107,
-0.2699354887008667,
-0.7004700899124146,
-0.005751834250986576,
-0.7502408027648926,
0.5735654830932617,
0.2760136127471924,
-0.13962700963020325,
0.11626570671796799,
-0.6549279689788818,
0.3286755681037903,
0.005443604663014412,
-0.16039161384105682,
-0.2699638605117798,
0.23729842901229858,
0.2922761142253876,
-0.038281165063381195,
-0.16117720305919647,
-0.9221377372741699,
-0.1639661192893982,
-0.3117653727531433,
0.5934744477272034,
0.21312004327774048,
0.04734738916158676,
0.05166090279817581,
-0.3578450083732605,
0.4679090678691864,
0.041664279997348785,
0.37191322445869446,
-0.1457722783088684,
-0.0028882126789540052,
-0.7831563353538513,
-0.5626731514930725,
0.5592777132987976,
0.31557637453079224,
-0.556736409664154,
0.24856281280517578,
-0.5342012047767639,
-0.46334171295166016,
-1.2891963720321655,
0.01983610726892948,
0.32773125171661377,
0.27879878878593445,
0.31356847286224365,
-0.016957692801952362,
-0.6078934669494629,
-0.6733822226524353,
-0.5940978527069092,
-0.14644218981266022,
0.2609292268753052,
0.2168416976928711,
-0.18579541146755219,
-0.032574959099292755,
0.7544352412223816,
-0.7329956889152527,
-0.7521130442619324,
-0.3433571457862854,
0.12350138276815414,
-0.22499869763851166,
0.32175442576408386,
0.27150067687034607,
-0.752891480922699,
-0.5820384621620178,
-0.26384589076042175,
-0.28653693199157715,
-0.19456811249256134,
-0.061330825090408325,
0.22629916667938232,
0.04027595371007919,
0.37158888578414917,
-0.4771418869495392,
0.5882675647735596,
0.7155263423919678,
-0.054690517485141754,
0.5749424695968628,
-0.03829687088727951,
-0.11525513231754303,
-0.857047438621521,
-0.2557743191719055,
-0.08235805481672287,
-0.502636194229126,
-0.771222710609436,
-0.38711217045783997,
0.2204492837190628,
-0.07313830405473709,
-0.7034894824028015,
0.583000659942627,
-0.5320385098457336,
0.008881982415914536,
-0.3371220529079437,
-0.0006918430444784462,
0.07423663139343262,
0.2000071257352829,
0.6132441759109497,
0.7220829725265503,
0.4658683240413666,
-0.6085269451141357,
0.1367485523223877,
0.20327220857143402,
-0.02931170165538788,
0.20908311009407043,
-0.8680091500282288,
0.08136145770549774,
0.035031311213970184,
0.1163211464881897,
-0.7581311464309692,
-0.18397307395935059,
-0.3259126543998718,
-0.585498571395874,
0.5200269222259521,
-0.3804035484790802,
-0.3917770981788635,
-0.5168668627738953,
-0.3606213629245758,
0.5633682012557983,
0.6399408578872681,
-0.5680001974105835,
0.7067145705223083,
0.4361385703086853,
-0.09309225529432297,
-0.6915678381919861,
-0.49002909660339355,
-0.15948539972305298,
-0.25576674938201904,
-0.7033699154853821,
0.23711656033992767,
-0.10299671441316605,
0.10846506059169769,
-0.14232352375984192,
-0.40228426456451416,
-0.047134168446063995,
-0.41366294026374817,
0.45077064633369446,
0.06692478060722351,
-0.08326952904462814,
-0.053058743476867676,
0.225210040807724,
-0.030537880957126617,
-0.205931156873703,
-0.17737683653831482,
0.6148637533187866,
-0.00014249169907998294,
-0.5459235310554504,
-0.6810341477394104,
0.5612185001373291,
0.5355145931243896,
-0.37045934796333313,
0.4309949576854706,
0.7321018576622009,
-0.3326368033885956,
-0.4283306300640106,
-1.024317741394043,
-0.025588788092136383,
-0.5652238726615906,
-0.009529457427561283,
-0.3075037896633148,
-0.9059127569198608,
0.42058172821998596,
0.09748418629169464,
-0.060824789106845856,
0.13541455566883087,
0.14377908408641815,
-0.42924776673316956,
0.7490721344947815,
0.5959305167198181,
0.002394448034465313,
0.39386191964149475,
-0.43729451298713684,
0.06473859399557114,
-1.0300592184066772,
-0.12298794835805893,
-0.29564613103866577,
-0.3077218234539032,
-0.09089630842208862,
-0.23616185784339905,
0.35178643465042114,
-0.07231824845075607,
0.05839436501264572,
0.2860867977142334,
-0.520166277885437,
0.31297042965888977,
0.2393593043088913,
0.03542814031243324,
0.3621264696121216,
-0.0791691243648529,
0.11809282749891281,
-0.40981239080429077,
-0.6286905407905579,
-0.05889292061328888,
0.4854162633419037,
0.3224705755710602,
1.058931589126587,
0.018538810312747955,
0.7171993255615234,
0.6339622139930725,
-0.2685244679450989,
-0.8789870142936707,
0.2813633978366852,
-0.067411869764328,
-0.5207549333572388,
-0.32165616750717163,
-0.2791086733341217,
-0.6265560984611511,
0.26543915271759033,
0.3084191679954529,
-0.42410820722579956,
0.2729022800922394,
0.39052119851112366,
-0.48626455664634705,
0.4206613600254059,
-0.7881011962890625,
0.4339454472064972,
-0.09324690699577332,
0.011616194620728493,
-0.12750138342380524,
-0.5315470099449158,
0.34103187918663025,
-0.06359333544969559,
0.0730404183268547,
-0.33137330412864685,
-0.0853261798620224,
0.6965659260749817,
-0.4518238604068756,
0.7310152053833008,
-0.43447110056877136,
0.047538794577121735,
0.604745626449585,
0.15223979949951172,
0.48087242245674133,
-0.23006203770637512,
0.17287583649158478,
0.34641432762145996,
0.13295482099056244,
-0.24109511077404022,
-0.5064436793327332,
0.44321680068969727,
-0.5307597517967224,
-0.35259154438972473,
-0.5208683013916016,
-0.5114200115203857,
-0.2565271556377411,
-0.08555388450622559,
0.44230762124061584,
0.8537721633911133,
-0.20040489733219147,
-0.08096721023321152,
0.5811235904693604,
0.14450916647911072,
0.7766622304916382,
0.7110063433647156,
-0.08464035391807556,
-0.2890309989452362,
1.1469699144363403,
0.2790009677410126,
0.3460825979709625,
0.2267591506242752,
0.0855550691485405,
-0.6290246248245239,
-0.6099521517753601,
-0.43911775946617126,
0.41380834579467773,
-0.10225774347782135,
-0.32967305183410645,
-0.8750836849212646,
-0.6939061880111694,
-0.2363445907831192,
-0.0661754235625267,
-0.6845528483390808,
-0.25755637884140015,
-0.2708875834941864,
0.09585010260343552,
0.3548450767993927,
0.42236074805259705,
0.0033273377921432257,
0.7299044132232666,
-1.1966595649719238,
0.26371702551841736,
0.1331818848848343,
0.14678001403808594,
0.1844014972448349,
-0.7332515716552734,
-0.08051769435405731,
-0.16816295683383942,
-0.05134006589651108,
-0.584439218044281,
0.8196957111358643,
0.7010527849197388,
0.19927318394184113,
0.6562523245811462,
0.3818594217300415,
1.2029626369476318,
-0.7692527174949646,
0.5218700170516968,
0.30941829085350037,
-1.2705905437469482,
0.5572384595870972,
-0.21230272948741913,
0.6708911061286926,
0.22880882024765015,
-0.02191893570125103,
-0.6760658621788025,
-0.610219419002533,
-0.3782804012298584,
-0.4372471868991852,
0.8158566355705261,
0.27562493085861206,
-0.10770629346370697,
0.27134624123573303,
0.00610048184171319,
0.20590832829475403,
0.14201703667640686,
-0.11577341705560684,
-0.3089340627193451,
-0.3603564202785492,
-0.35314682126045227,
0.1936509609222412,
-0.41915881633758545,
0.2400282770395279,
-0.18473194539546967,
0.5841768980026245,
-0.09891290962696075,
0.21481451392173767,
0.3485826253890991,
-0.40066850185394287,
-0.24738849699497223,
0.4765959680080414,
0.5548786520957947,
0.15396200120449066,
-0.4014110267162323,
-0.0956190899014473,
0.12209327518939972,
-0.994215190410614,
0.3586357533931732,
0.27564939856529236,
-0.29577234387397766,
0.3310334086418152,
0.45445963740348816,
0.8436095714569092,
0.2361559122800827,
-0.6570672988891602,
0.48648422956466675,
-0.27586379647254944,
-0.06796322017908096,
-0.4211536943912506,
0.1009347140789032,
0.1728242039680481,
0.14276190102100372,
0.636074960231781,
0.03676535189151764,
0.5142945051193237,
-0.10537654161453247,
0.12570159137248993,
0.40510427951812744,
-0.6214543581008911,
-0.44334155321121216,
0.6674788594245911,
0.4009775221347809,
-0.20679286122322083,
0.2602022588253021,
-0.11061990261077881,
-0.6715203523635864,
0.2518690526485443,
0.6093388795852661,
1.1120909452438354,
-0.6995804905891418,
0.19659525156021118,
0.1700262725353241,
0.327657550573349,
0.09783753007650375,
0.7069416046142578,
-0.20589372515678406,
-0.449237585067749,
-0.680700421333313,
-0.8611189126968384,
-0.16446025669574738,
0.027231190353631973,
-0.882854163646698,
0.2539614737033844,
-0.23094221949577332,
-0.3022388517856598,
0.01920701377093792,
-0.09811457991600037,
-0.3861493170261383,
0.12386927753686905,
0.29904210567474365,
1.0828373432159424,
-0.6003890037536621,
1.0536025762557983,
0.1952700912952423,
0.15703879296779633,
-0.8648301959037781,
0.3893406093120575,
0.2850111424922943,
-0.6126909255981445,
0.300418883562088,
0.2571672797203064,
-0.747302234172821,
0.20701201260089874,
-0.29701581597328186,
-1.13547945022583,
0.836043655872345,
0.4673718214035034,
-0.8579175472259521,
-0.18545886874198914,
-0.12882709503173828,
0.26277753710746765,
-0.17966561019420624,
0.038731902837753296,
0.5398613214492798,
0.28552675247192383,
0.4746067225933075,
-1.3443217277526855,
-0.3753436207771301,
0.016519635915756226,
-0.05042533949017525,
0.43797579407691956,
-1.133639931678772,
0.30422717332839966,
-0.3778468370437622,
-0.5703935623168945,
-0.21128225326538086,
0.8281421661376953,
-0.09439988434314728,
0.18662530183792114,
0.6221763491630554,
0.5190162658691406,
0.47504571080207825,
-0.1363481879234314,
0.8521402478218079,
0.1350945383310318,
0.12910762429237366,
1.3685988187789917,
-0.3755352199077606,
1.1294031143188477,
0.27861741185188293,
-0.09380488097667694,
0.21858103573322296,
0.43075451254844666,
0.32385122776031494,
0.8895364999771118,
-0.21093884110450745,
-0.26452648639678955,
-0.3024563193321228,
-0.4080616533756256,
-0.28502219915390015,
0.4992049038410187,
0.6115021705627441,
0.1476888507604599,
-0.10424775630235672,
0.26777103543281555,
-0.27094727754592896,
-0.3179875314235687,
-0.42845332622528076,
0.7518657445907593,
0.24074459075927734,
-0.09606578946113586,
0.6952183246612549,
-0.36048999428749084,
0.8428028225898743,
-0.8266074061393738,
0.0787937343120575,
0.2503669261932373,
0.34821268916130066,
-0.3793293833732605,
-0.5655624866485596,
0.5551148056983948,
-0.036523234099149704,
-0.13907290995121002,
0.21739232540130615,
0.8649218082427979,
-0.7844568490982056,
-0.4502200484275818,
0.5687662959098816,
0.5001946091651917,
0.08227474987506866,
-0.24840590357780457,
-0.5747913718223572,
0.6526504158973694,
0.0646471157670021,
0.1355610340833664,
-0.09626077860593796,
0.10984191298484802,
0.32200342416763306,
0.9895232319831848,
0.5255839824676514,
0.3892371654510498,
0.6189266443252563,
0.2598932385444641,
0.5397477149963379,
-0.5558271408081055,
-0.8638935089111328,
-0.7866679430007935,
0.34299349784851074,
-0.07115423679351807,
0.07414678484201431,
0.7447143793106079,
0.5749735832214355,
0.5008993744850159,
0.12229017913341522,
0.8378148078918457,
0.06889425963163376,
0.8140880465507507,
-0.3151320219039917,
0.6110002994537354,
-0.5747252106666565,
-0.10334206372499466,
-0.17954851686954498,
-0.7477289438247681,
-0.12927331030368805,
0.20036481320858002,
0.02497156523168087,
-0.16856783628463745,
0.624310314655304,
0.35442477464675903,
-0.27852344512939453,
0.29451826214790344,
0.5502668619155884,
0.11765915900468826,
0.15259526669979095,
0.4606810212135315,
0.8634292483329773,
-0.5750194191932678,
0.8907625675201416,
-0.13001686334609985,
0.12578557431697845,
-0.32177606225013733,
-0.7202267646789551,
-0.9601176977157593,
-0.569677472114563,
-0.5872995257377625,
-0.0964941680431366,
0.20853593945503235,
0.8581263422966003,
1.0304244756698608,
-0.7268367409706116,
-0.2164406031370163,
0.5935932397842407,
-0.15669062733650208,
-0.4312182664871216,
-0.20615379512310028,
0.5851216912269592,
-0.05192352086305618,
-0.6836581826210022,
0.5057654976844788,
0.5925547480583191,
0.3729669749736786,
-0.16315610706806183,
-0.26388096809387207,
-0.11335655301809311,
0.2153967171907425,
0.2507458031177521,
0.2723042666912079,
-0.8092346787452698,
-0.059212055057287216,
-0.10717285424470901,
0.23490001261234283,
0.13774730265140533,
0.6949568390846252,
-0.693495512008667,
0.5543295741081238,
0.13813728094100952,
0.4132004976272583,
0.8049386739730835,
0.23845849931240082,
0.4764253497123718,
-1.1297575235366821,
0.30368995666503906,
0.3023447096347809,
0.444705992937088,
0.5258128046989441,
-0.4925369918346405,
0.26200565695762634,
0.07262130826711655,
-0.2953738570213318,
-0.9405544996261597,
-0.037386562675237656,
-0.9521926045417786,
0.14648041129112244,
1.0143409967422485,
0.01554126851260662,
-0.4616355001926422,
-0.31785860657691956,
-0.3463378846645355,
0.2915136218070984,
-0.9485095143318176,
0.3916868269443512,
0.692552924156189,
-0.06212027743458748,
-0.42741814255714417,
-0.45610785484313965,
0.7249575853347778,
0.10775744169950485,
-0.37252363562583923,
0.41130438446998596,
0.2641003131866455,
0.3761628270149231,
0.27783626317977905,
0.456502765417099,
0.008696275763213634,
0.3881179690361023,
0.05697796866297722,
-0.09207148849964142,
-0.3483337163925171,
-0.48430076241493225,
-0.45142632722854614,
0.19031541049480438,
-0.18770597875118256,
-0.5428619384765625
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.12925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.12925v1
|
GLiNER multi-task: Generalist Lightweight Model for Various Information Extraction Tasks
| 2024-06-14T13:54:29 | 2024-06-14T13:54:29 |
Ihor Stepanov, Mykhailo Shtopko
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Information extraction tasks require both accurate, efficient, and
generalisable models. Classical supervised deep learning approaches can achieve
the required performance, but they need large datasets and are limited in their
ability to adapt to different tasks. On the other hand, large language models
(LLMs) demonstrate good generalization, meaning that they can adapt to many
different tasks based on user requests. However, LLMs are computationally
expensive and tend to fail to generate structured outputs. In this article, we
will introduce a new kind of GLiNER model that can be used for various
information extraction tasks while being a small encoder model. Our model
achieved SoTA performance on zero-shot NER benchmarks and leading performance
on question-answering, summarization and relation extraction tasks.
Additionally, in this article, we will cover experimental results on
self-learning approaches for named entity recognition using GLiNER models.
|
[
-0.15151280164718628,
-0.9326727390289307,
0.5872334837913513,
-0.07789933681488037,
-0.29789257049560547,
-0.19524410367012024,
-0.2642301619052887,
-0.9020535349845886,
0.30100688338279724,
0.5952255725860596,
-0.43587446212768555,
-0.2547025680541992,
-0.8022565841674805,
0.041325390338897705,
-0.5697689056396484,
1.1439018249511719,
0.05421718582510948,
0.16590379178524017,
-0.028768571093678474,
-0.03547069430351257,
-0.3541513979434967,
-0.7608817219734192,
-0.7751688361167908,
-0.05196306109428406,
0.6142646074295044,
0.32798320055007935,
0.4001951515674591,
0.48109170794487,
0.6055866479873657,
0.24287012219429016,
-0.03019162081182003,
-0.13921226561069489,
-0.12110342085361481,
0.13565555214881897,
-0.08989155292510986,
-0.40561601519584656,
-0.4729501008987427,
-0.3368884325027466,
0.7695744037628174,
0.5808371305465698,
-0.2102539986371994,
0.4361714720726013,
0.19225816428661346,
0.4336971640586853,
-0.7389416098594666,
0.11467385292053223,
-0.6006395816802979,
-0.20108047127723694,
-0.05202089622616768,
0.2773711383342743,
-0.37300822138786316,
-0.23182252049446106,
0.09175240248441696,
-0.5386742353439331,
0.33084115386009216,
0.03624376654624939,
1.118415117263794,
0.2039315551519394,
-0.4043367803096771,
-0.8188346028327942,
-0.7312089800834656,
1.0069074630737305,
-0.8191909193992615,
0.5034677386283875,
-0.033926621079444885,
0.4682200253009796,
0.053391605615615845,
-0.9711422324180603,
-0.5766505002975464,
-0.24616721272468567,
-0.31046420335769653,
-0.04732769727706909,
-0.07550641149282455,
0.1451062262058258,
0.31032270193099976,
0.39712396264076233,
-0.43768417835235596,
0.30328458547592163,
-0.4263937175273895,
0.023231713101267815,
0.47781577706336975,
0.2873368561267853,
0.42510488629341125,
-0.44065096974372864,
-0.4509259760379791,
0.2498636394739151,
-0.4306785762310028,
0.36335086822509766,
0.5073677897453308,
0.5112677812576294,
0.03808775171637535,
0.4650760889053345,
-0.28525543212890625,
0.8054046630859375,
0.0853017270565033,
-0.20047281682491302,
0.07664772123098373,
-0.3207765519618988,
-0.46293824911117554,
-0.17013344168663025,
0.8531573414802551,
0.015799276530742645,
0.19856029748916626,
-0.3724079728126526,
-0.26666781306266785,
-0.28962528705596924,
0.25563380122184753,
-1.0078248977661133,
-0.18767797946929932,
0.24665997922420502,
-0.7535168528556824,
-0.13675276935100555,
0.007828612811863422,
-0.9489520192146301,
-0.21375958621501923,
-0.5154286623001099,
0.45423179864883423,
-0.20501451194286346,
-0.37443819642066956,
0.29647552967071533,
-0.15395362675189972,
0.3979405164718628,
0.6768627762794495,
-1.1993982791900635,
0.5895068049430847,
0.3013315200805664,
0.6757293343544006,
-0.3140895366668701,
0.0690862163901329,
-0.6167382001876831,
0.13582737743854523,
-0.08365258574485779,
0.6849896907806396,
-0.5764011144638062,
-0.11977222561836243,
-0.24063371121883392,
0.31917595863342285,
-0.4781420826911926,
-0.5018662214279175,
0.5065404772758484,
-0.5043801069259644,
0.4218963384628296,
-0.16580219566822052,
-0.5604181289672852,
-0.4719809591770172,
0.06435580551624298,
-0.9565077424049377,
0.8269868493080139,
-0.17686398327350616,
-0.8082093000411987,
0.27341413497924805,
-0.7236854434013367,
-0.4062047004699707,
0.19130173325538635,
-0.3252575695514679,
-0.3826395273208618,
0.24799969792366028,
0.15989677608013153,
0.7759364247322083,
-0.6553024053573608,
0.5703203082084656,
-0.3204629719257355,
-0.34915775060653687,
-0.08696973323822021,
-0.003114747814834118,
0.8455865383148193,
0.2658270299434662,
-0.2388422042131424,
-0.03337247669696808,
-0.6255547404289246,
0.18559560179710388,
0.19278712570667267,
-0.7262294292449951,
-0.28571274876594543,
-0.00014006248966325074,
0.27800998091697693,
0.09741220623254776,
0.3596155047416687,
-0.5116680264472961,
0.4387509226799011,
-0.24832791090011597,
0.3413447439670563,
0.4195763170719147,
0.01192924939095974,
0.42254766821861267,
0.012343470938503742,
0.501322865486145,
-0.05511216074228287,
0.015519320033490658,
0.006285491399466991,
-0.23074331879615784,
-1.027721643447876,
-0.48558059334754944,
0.7575638890266418,
0.7904518246650696,
-0.6076755523681641,
0.17455843091011047,
-0.2448185235261917,
-0.4603370130062103,
-0.5168960094451904,
0.4022020697593689,
0.2847301959991455,
0.2022324949502945,
0.5409451127052307,
-0.3877321779727936,
-0.5216193199157715,
-1.0142779350280762,
-0.5038018822669983,
0.14698350429534912,
-0.26847198605537415,
0.4931838810443878,
0.6090857982635498,
-0.3011821210384369,
0.7660291194915771,
-0.4697168171405792,
-0.5673316121101379,
-0.7782908082008362,
0.3019477128982544,
0.5688788890838623,
0.4215724766254425,
0.4487878382205963,
-1.0088062286376953,
-0.43252190947532654,
0.06737495958805084,
-1.0979841947555542,
0.4330156445503235,
-0.1923884153366089,
0.3497869074344635,
0.06886254996061325,
0.555843710899353,
-0.8199334740638733,
0.15162387490272522,
0.39610302448272705,
0.15824323892593384,
0.4847155213356018,
-0.07674951106309891,
-0.17272351682186127,
-1.1112785339355469,
0.45073309540748596,
0.14346246421337128,
-0.1975468397140503,
-0.9436748623847961,
0.20538495481014252,
0.17534944415092468,
-0.09844491630792618,
-0.3900620937347412,
0.6360652446746826,
-0.9129482507705688,
-0.1612119823694229,
-0.11655592918395996,
-0.06550484150648117,
-0.08013111352920532,
0.6585663557052612,
0.03400762751698494,
0.5621359944343567,
0.6422927379608154,
-0.7769836783409119,
0.3803817331790924,
-0.118243008852005,
-0.3866082727909088,
0.13612456619739532,
-0.7826685309410095,
0.3703766167163849,
-0.49903592467308044,
-0.07992468774318695,
-0.8882834911346436,
-0.5063605308532715,
0.397506982088089,
-0.17495031654834747,
0.6472456455230713,
-0.20448394119739532,
-0.43042728304862976,
-0.2417508065700531,
0.004525639582425356,
0.26941606402397156,
0.3356955051422119,
-0.3893868029117584,
1.0333284139633179,
0.5362883806228638,
-0.5678916573524475,
-0.6699453592300415,
-0.44398266077041626,
0.06454407423734665,
-0.3875357210636139,
-0.19416263699531555,
0.19317679107189178,
0.061177659779787064,
-0.05086732655763626,
0.1022806242108345,
0.039242811501026154,
-0.5636675953865051,
0.19240018725395203,
0.22675292193889618,
0.3293558359146118,
-0.26201122999191284,
0.5087538957595825,
-0.17138294875621796,
0.09580822288990021,
-0.18942320346832275,
-0.16803200542926788,
0.2879372239112854,
-0.19541098177433014,
-0.07972484081983566,
-0.42504316568374634,
0.5603670477867126,
0.2902350127696991,
-0.23237693309783936,
0.5374646186828613,
0.5813773274421692,
-0.5301502346992493,
0.03415510058403015,
-0.6859633922576904,
-0.22224020957946777,
-0.4075460433959961,
0.4451292157173157,
-0.5941424369812012,
-1.0257567167282104,
0.24890650808811188,
-0.286599725484848,
-0.06986995041370392,
0.6958396434783936,
0.2858486771583557,
-0.08877721428871155,
0.7093057632446289,
1.0548381805419922,
-0.3277797996997833,
0.36699390411376953,
-0.2282191812992096,
0.2463613897562027,
-0.6965231895446777,
-0.10880999267101288,
-0.717287003993988,
-0.16022177040576935,
-0.3344338834285736,
0.06592770665884018,
-0.04061729833483696,
0.3599432408809662,
0.2177821844816208,
0.5341000556945801,
-0.48690536618232727,
0.3834865093231201,
0.5108630061149597,
-0.08440796285867691,
0.18546853959560394,
-0.08904363960027695,
-0.008266260847449303,
0.07358336448669434,
-0.4993884563446045,
-0.5253027081489563,
1.0333689451217651,
0.2557983696460724,
1.0062354803085327,
0.06997723877429962,
0.675294816493988,
0.37908557057380676,
0.138168603181839,
-0.7485975027084351,
0.5451013445854187,
-0.49353334307670593,
-0.8550431728363037,
-0.598543107509613,
-0.3350831866264343,
-0.9847174882888794,
0.3216613531112671,
-0.23848986625671387,
-1.1535749435424805,
0.3274651765823364,
0.1323622167110443,
-0.5028149485588074,
0.26875123381614685,
-0.6991556286811829,
1.0060932636260986,
-0.3731253147125244,
-0.15827368199825287,
-0.01256617158651352,
-0.6553519368171692,
0.3539462685585022,
-0.1533704400062561,
0.34949353337287903,
-0.1375901848077774,
0.06291083246469498,
0.7634296417236328,
0.3925706148147583,
0.9403170943260193,
-0.44195035099983215,
0.23339363932609558,
0.2867843806743622,
-0.015562394633889198,
0.5807499885559082,
-0.2772456109523773,
-0.008081259205937386,
0.3104954659938812,
-0.05009082704782486,
-0.07368946075439453,
-0.5334361791610718,
0.3384236693382263,
-0.5871065855026245,
-0.5620294213294983,
-0.12168039381504059,
-0.33898401260375977,
0.20655301213264465,
0.4482204020023346,
0.3269411325454712,
0.6118361949920654,
-0.18478558957576752,
0.39745938777923584,
0.4162444770336151,
-0.12113850563764572,
0.5914070010185242,
0.30258381366729736,
-0.12533941864967346,
-0.3457958400249481,
0.9763957262039185,
0.33276447653770447,
0.15793266892433167,
0.5247486233711243,
-0.20747888088226318,
-0.37289533019065857,
-0.5267904996871948,
-0.5935792326927185,
0.1656528115272522,
-0.8699057698249817,
-0.05847521498799324,
-1.0967142581939697,
-0.34873226284980774,
-0.3191068172454834,
0.2633533179759979,
-0.11430369317531586,
-0.6676611304283142,
-0.38444021344184875,
0.10712678730487823,
-0.28994154930114746,
0.9681480526924133,
0.2560765743255615,
0.3136661648750305,
-0.6333323121070862,
0.5730358958244324,
0.4766571819782257,
-0.05654747411608696,
-0.10639173537492752,
-0.253333181142807,
-0.4697849750518799,
-0.2940501570701599,
-0.30486759543418884,
-0.8910853862762451,
0.2887156009674072,
0.4178447425365448,
0.8901451230049133,
0.11430137604475021,
-0.08734114468097687,
0.46425092220306396,
-0.3059476315975189,
0.6214621067047119,
0.30133703351020813,
-0.9355093240737915,
0.33590683341026306,
-0.07006588578224182,
0.05543801188468933,
0.33903318643569946,
0.6233940720558167,
-0.33462604880332947,
-0.21195444464683533,
-0.6402568817138672,
-0.8407939076423645,
0.5064490437507629,
-0.22148342430591583,
-0.0036810454912483692,
0.305102676153183,
0.4328606426715851,
0.2861959934234619,
0.449597030878067,
-1.0279759168624878,
0.22195430099964142,
-0.03933141380548477,
-0.3397054076194763,
-0.20761936902999878,
-0.5903500318527222,
0.24091142416000366,
0.049085721373558044,
0.4275599420070648,
-0.52474045753479,
0.47432941198349,
0.3458581268787384,
-0.4913007915019989,
0.11484477669000626,
0.7120482921600342,
0.4090607762336731,
0.3192408084869385,
-0.1471945196390152,
0.12385430186986923,
0.5188013911247253,
-0.2162955105304718,
0.08443053811788559,
0.15263955295085907,
-0.19740034639835358,
0.1202472448348999,
0.3477114737033844,
0.7338564395904541,
0.34977564215660095,
-0.4223129451274872,
0.5419893264770508,
-0.1778065413236618,
-0.19104108214378357,
-0.3218817710876465,
0.24556633830070496,
0.1558847874403,
0.20044788718223572,
0.4182078540325165,
-0.06863778829574585,
0.6190085411071777,
-0.4033799171447754,
0.1736392080783844,
0.6181399822235107,
-0.3819531202316284,
-0.27643054723739624,
0.7732505202293396,
0.008286713622510433,
-0.09452987462282181,
0.613547682762146,
-0.08422582596540451,
-0.21476343274116516,
0.5810888409614563,
0.3218652307987213,
1.1288468837738037,
-0.20939204096794128,
-0.03127431496977806,
0.582480788230896,
0.26014113426208496,
-0.13944579660892487,
0.24705365300178528,
-0.18228434026241302,
-0.6365594863891602,
-0.5469790697097778,
-0.679617702960968,
-0.5307514071464539,
0.25405916571617126,
-0.8403774499893188,
0.30025768280029297,
-0.42054757475852966,
-0.24603600800037384,
0.4163421392440796,
-0.03291108459234238,
-0.8773781657218933,
0.4105477035045624,
-0.026183385401964188,
0.6459650993347168,
-0.6208472847938538,
1.1362663507461548,
0.606536865234375,
-0.3893904983997345,
-0.7912813425064087,
-0.036649882793426514,
-0.24680551886558533,
-0.4832414984703064,
1.0084214210510254,
0.5755032300949097,
-0.04209474101662636,
0.07578521966934204,
-0.4996543526649475,
-0.8459856510162354,
1.0191619396209717,
0.5168664455413818,
-0.7547432780265808,
-0.5513578653335571,
-0.04523133859038353,
0.34302249550819397,
-0.5795197486877441,
0.37852033972740173,
0.11430665850639343,
0.3241073787212372,
-0.10136384516954422,
-1.058664321899414,
0.06219979375600815,
-0.2269987314939499,
-0.0989922434091568,
0.05830368399620056,
-0.554695188999176,
1.457865595817566,
-0.33741310238838196,
-0.5882594585418701,
0.15970022976398468,
0.3540891408920288,
-0.2592470049858093,
-0.02319159172475338,
0.6746864914894104,
0.4693682789802551,
0.8561007380485535,
0.08906003087759018,
0.9811020493507385,
-0.15387023985385895,
0.48922646045684814,
1.204674482345581,
-0.3817765712738037,
0.842136561870575,
0.351551353931427,
0.1541721224784851,
0.6561324000358582,
0.391818642616272,
-0.1811143308877945,
0.47188228368759155,
0.05780913680791855,
-0.03556172549724579,
-0.5429126620292664,
-0.09489167481660843,
-0.19641231000423431,
0.4642527103424072,
0.2097439467906952,
-0.37796124815940857,
-0.29664191603660583,
-0.18059532344341278,
-0.08562712371349335,
-0.42513757944107056,
-0.28035983443260193,
1.0639771223068237,
0.1155928298830986,
-0.5011228919029236,
0.3982057273387909,
0.07142610847949982,
0.4892711043357849,
-0.6535005569458008,
-0.1438753604888916,
0.2153780609369278,
0.379184752702713,
-0.15027543902397156,
-0.42716774344444275,
0.20104637742042542,
-0.13004650175571442,
-0.25824832916259766,
-0.09489869326353073,
1.3695125579833984,
-0.3706371784210205,
-0.5543305277824402,
0.5904316902160645,
0.5976366996765137,
0.29548126459121704,
-0.12795861065387726,
-0.5987635850906372,
-0.13800053298473358,
0.02745950035750866,
-0.4605957567691803,
0.3936292231082916,
0.2632810175418854,
0.12142841517925262,
0.772617518901825,
0.6478514075279236,
0.13230957090854645,
0.03732699155807495,
-0.18719267845153809,
0.9042761325836182,
-0.999460756778717,
-0.5471911430358887,
-0.9243285655975342,
0.6257137060165405,
-0.2390495091676712,
-0.13499222695827484,
0.6349976062774658,
0.6997758746147156,
0.5207721590995789,
-0.3365017771720886,
1.0033628940582275,
-0.0992194265127182,
0.7577033042907715,
-0.7791382074356079,
0.3292232155799866,
-0.7986531853675842,
-0.21709102392196655,
-0.19598138332366943,
-0.7806583642959595,
-0.18869367241859436,
0.3883925676345825,
-0.14473874866962433,
-0.06973623484373093,
0.6574841737747192,
0.5947401523590088,
-0.028937339782714844,
0.13735026121139526,
0.327435702085495,
-0.008117501623928547,
0.27175837755203247,
0.7457980513572693,
0.8092159032821655,
-0.4393555223941803,
0.4931926429271698,
0.22888894379138947,
-0.013944058679044247,
-0.32342761754989624,
-0.7841672897338867,
-1.0166594982147217,
-0.48624783754348755,
-0.05693783238530159,
0.1585749387741089,
0.24665680527687073,
0.642520010471344,
0.8824176788330078,
-0.8433211445808411,
-0.2704126238822937,
0.06510031223297119,
0.09061602503061295,
-0.15267793834209442,
-0.21661554276943207,
0.18688955903053284,
-0.5970745086669922,
-0.7775212526321411,
0.3033730387687683,
0.22446581721305847,
0.14387458562850952,
-0.0458972342312336,
0.1103438138961792,
-0.019638502970337868,
-0.2360612154006958,
0.19426193833351135,
0.3772324323654175,
-0.8523027300834656,
-0.44982412457466125,
0.040999218821525574,
-0.2580246925354004,
-0.04946313798427582,
0.7282660007476807,
-0.6041626334190369,
0.2429802268743515,
0.14422743022441864,
0.7764795422554016,
0.6899981498718262,
-0.008384502492845058,
0.39152538776397705,
-0.578163743019104,
0.16289620101451874,
0.07642233371734619,
0.4292888939380646,
0.24488390982151031,
-0.5541823506355286,
0.5668288469314575,
0.2198183238506317,
-0.6838016510009766,
-0.6833831071853638,
0.19420044124126434,
-0.8502291440963745,
-0.3391515910625458,
1.0906239748001099,
-0.1467640995979309,
-0.13111421465873718,
-0.1596376895904541,
-0.265927255153656,
-0.05560554191470146,
-0.26712337136268616,
0.5404262542724609,
0.6830926537513733,
-0.13689574599266052,
-0.29866495728492737,
-0.9578021168708801,
0.3384370505809784,
0.1035168468952179,
-0.829258918762207,
-0.04639914631843567,
0.23936153948307037,
0.5253732204437256,
0.38876286149024963,
0.88289874792099,
0.2844490110874176,
0.0881650298833847,
-0.05399457365274429,
0.48175472021102905,
0.10999419540166855,
-0.7014772295951843,
-0.24240262806415558,
0.596576988697052,
0.19654135406017303,
-0.3931082487106323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10040v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10040v1
|
FZI-WIM at SemEval-2024 Task 2: Self-Consistent CoT for Complex NLI in Biomedical Domain
| 2024-06-14T13:49:07 | 2024-06-14T13:49:07 |
Jin Liu, Steffen Thoma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper describes the inference system of FZI-WIM at the SemEval-2024 Task
2: Safe Biomedical Natural Language Inference for Clinical Trials. Our system
utilizes the chain of thought (CoT) paradigm to tackle this complex reasoning
problem and further improves the CoT performance with self-consistency. Instead
of greedy decoding, we sample multiple reasoning chains with the same prompt
and make the final verification with majority voting. The self-consistent CoT
system achieves a baseline F1 score of 0.80 (1st), faithfulness score of 0.90
(3rd), and consistency score of 0.73 (12th). We release the code and data
publicly https://github.com/jens5588/FZI-WIM-NLI4CT.
|
[
-0.09116507321596146,
-0.8705556988716125,
0.7131195068359375,
0.6163832545280457,
-0.12531520426273346,
-0.03558152914047241,
-0.04774321988224983,
-0.5362796187400818,
0.19923363626003265,
0.49098506569862366,
-0.4568900167942047,
-0.5015362501144409,
-0.46083998680114746,
0.35955312848091125,
-0.2683071494102478,
0.9490327835083008,
-0.31148913502693176,
0.29503515362739563,
-0.12123925983905792,
-0.24844440817832947,
-0.07270929962396622,
-0.5372198224067688,
-0.48630768060684204,
-0.4053255021572113,
0.6144620776176453,
0.18999718129634857,
0.5814046859741211,
0.3581012189388275,
0.34844210743904114,
0.1543206125497818,
0.11758732050657272,
0.3069777488708496,
-0.2889825701713562,
0.14332588016986847,
-0.6510244607925415,
-0.4236515164375305,
-0.7680434584617615,
-0.014320777729153633,
0.3459652364253998,
0.49007514119148254,
-0.1660841405391693,
-0.22030377388000488,
0.09441698342561722,
0.7027062773704529,
-0.8567814230918884,
-0.15788811445236206,
-0.4527764320373535,
0.1893928200006485,
0.16885468363761902,
-0.29547038674354553,
-0.8226925730705261,
-0.3285123109817505,
0.1463651955127716,
-0.3714854419231415,
0.2662723660469055,
0.15595181286334991,
0.7359951734542847,
0.2822484076023102,
-0.7585684657096863,
-0.3196502923965454,
-0.6089580655097961,
0.7907874584197998,
-0.839357316493988,
0.20345322787761688,
0.6384944319725037,
0.07391225546598434,
-0.567863404750824,
-0.8455907702445984,
-0.5703781843185425,
-0.08580636978149414,
0.028977857902646065,
0.14989155530929565,
0.010487322695553303,
0.3072371482849121,
0.0035167501773685217,
0.2769283652305603,
-0.525696337223053,
-0.2103005200624466,
-0.36970293521881104,
-0.32760655879974365,
0.8785597681999207,
0.13333313167095184,
0.223586767911911,
0.03606231510639191,
-0.7995172142982483,
0.21941304206848145,
-0.7679137587547302,
-0.23815689980983734,
-0.0596165657043457,
0.03926169127225876,
0.03300223499536514,
0.47906771302223206,
-0.42993074655532837,
0.7204856276512146,
-0.016844304278492928,
0.06717120856046677,
0.7457019090652466,
-0.6391457319259644,
-0.54694002866745,
0.19990897178649902,
1.173848271369934,
0.33004358410835266,
-0.023254800587892532,
-0.2995353937149048,
-0.034647125750780106,
0.08586112409830093,
0.5429075956344604,
-0.516357421875,
-0.1904815137386322,
0.5299831628799438,
-0.5072923898696899,
-0.4663611352443695,
0.07249144464731216,
-0.8025602698326111,
-0.029581742361187935,
-0.022205986082553864,
0.8275179862976074,
-0.6397255063056946,
-0.1490810215473175,
0.28722620010375977,
0.06143100559711456,
0.33300086855888367,
0.45647478103637695,
-0.7291300296783447,
0.25441938638687134,
0.4346281886100769,
0.7756385207176208,
-0.24062921106815338,
-0.3421250581741333,
-0.5745396018028259,
0.3705296516418457,
-0.3979242146015167,
0.7996799945831299,
0.04002736136317253,
-0.10951658338308334,
-0.254962682723999,
0.25763437151908875,
-0.26898640394210815,
-0.19760820269584656,
0.7045250535011292,
-0.253690630197525,
0.14569059014320374,
-0.33815762400627136,
-0.8057831525802612,
0.10117919743061066,
0.32560232281684875,
-0.4769819974899292,
0.8315654397010803,
-0.0654275193810463,
-0.7392095923423767,
0.2110264152288437,
-0.37331464886665344,
-0.3462713062763214,
-0.10188809037208557,
-0.29524070024490356,
-0.28988972306251526,
-0.14876002073287964,
-0.020208168774843216,
0.13036103546619415,
-0.219029039144516,
0.48358073830604553,
-0.5811892151832581,
-0.39495164155960083,
0.20944002270698547,
-0.3941604495048523,
0.8384978771209717,
0.5058263540267944,
-0.9477331042289734,
0.07194599509239197,
-0.5827994346618652,
0.535979688167572,
-0.12485738843679428,
-0.11589070409536362,
-0.039727482944726944,
-0.10070928931236267,
-0.0576636902987957,
0.47110480070114136,
0.18483659625053406,
-0.777493417263031,
0.3052709400653839,
-0.5695017576217651,
0.3884899318218231,
0.6757502555847168,
0.1350732147693634,
0.23320886492729187,
-0.12048164010047913,
0.38017550110816956,
-0.01852775365114212,
0.32672443985939026,
0.3986208438873291,
-0.7379645705223083,
-0.6850161552429199,
-0.11825748533010483,
0.6769720315933228,
0.5449074506759644,
-0.6605674028396606,
0.8230066299438477,
0.22481802105903625,
-0.3422369956970215,
-0.3695344030857086,
-0.13414369523525238,
0.6049379110336304,
0.33785271644592285,
0.4789349436759949,
0.051174696534872055,
-0.43628790974617004,
-1.0840612649917603,
-0.20282934606075287,
-0.08514950424432755,
-0.1377311497926712,
-0.09050294011831284,
0.7647361755371094,
-0.7663849592208862,
0.767906665802002,
-0.473486989736557,
-0.27675899863243103,
-0.08302509039640427,
0.31417351961135864,
0.18120013177394867,
0.93010014295578,
0.3688047230243683,
-0.5872426629066467,
-0.07455301284790039,
-0.1729774922132492,
-0.8974501490592957,
-0.19990186393260956,
-0.03849668800830841,
-0.5886786580085754,
0.21888509392738342,
0.4805557131767273,
-0.32785895466804504,
0.7360976934432983,
0.46792516112327576,
-0.8576613664627075,
0.5032753944396973,
-0.44211408495903015,
0.5203186869621277,
-1.0500613451004028,
0.15042951703071594,
-0.23617812991142273,
-0.40965884923934937,
-0.7056710124015808,
-0.018435101956129074,
0.05603165924549103,
0.5817086100578308,
-0.1760530024766922,
0.3331814110279083,
-0.2926598787307739,
0.16677601635456085,
-0.3910220265388489,
0.04228506609797478,
0.32962262630462646,
0.5431265234947205,
-0.20924986898899078,
0.8063641786575317,
0.30061763525009155,
-0.5759789347648621,
-0.10295828431844711,
0.4301287829875946,
-0.1537017822265625,
0.09239591658115387,
-0.9057692885398865,
0.3311143219470978,
0.22863489389419556,
0.5230599045753479,
-0.7880632877349854,
-0.1342802196741104,
0.23319557309150696,
-0.3207850456237793,
0.08478724956512451,
0.35990869998931885,
-0.5138006210327148,
-0.25776025652885437,
-0.2621239125728607,
0.3629245460033417,
0.20172187685966492,
-0.3960750699043274,
0.5644161105155945,
0.49161696434020996,
0.21487949788570404,
-0.7319243550300598,
-0.9000677466392517,
-0.14770129323005676,
0.36495769023895264,
-0.5013002157211304,
0.5224283337593079,
-0.10819367319345474,
-0.05052083730697632,
-0.07017093151807785,
-0.4129366874694824,
-0.23347045481204987,
-0.1450054794549942,
0.20265141129493713,
0.3352643847465515,
-0.08017466962337494,
0.12042511254549026,
0.41545382142066956,
-0.1757616102695465,
0.1364581286907196,
-0.19411176443099976,
0.308467835187912,
-0.502500057220459,
-0.33994022011756897,
-0.3050096929073334,
0.5901395678520203,
0.5246860980987549,
0.022012386471033096,
0.7087671756744385,
0.5320422649383545,
-0.6382894515991211,
-0.1494269073009491,
-0.4603511691093445,
-0.006841073743999004,
-0.4554641842842102,
-0.20646338164806366,
-0.5370396375656128,
-1.0479625463485718,
0.44456231594085693,
-0.23204517364501953,
-0.12933941185474396,
0.7069926261901855,
0.6936609148979187,
-0.16126766800880432,
1.3124499320983887,
0.14058735966682434,
0.318590372800827,
-0.17281246185302734,
-0.41628196835517883,
0.4411950707435608,
-0.8329840302467346,
-0.44764262437820435,
-0.47961848974227905,
-0.2039792686700821,
-0.40712258219718933,
-0.46670621633529663,
0.41453057527542114,
0.5187292098999023,
-0.32011517882347107,
0.0751839280128479,
-0.5862400531768799,
0.2215835303068161,
0.6397568583488464,
0.5171367526054382,
0.13003675639629364,
-0.2569883465766907,
-0.6832054853439331,
0.22497031092643738,
-0.6635834574699402,
-0.6304619312286377,
0.8533290028572083,
0.19945891201496124,
0.776353120803833,
0.04356507584452629,
0.7792482376098633,
0.5075751543045044,
-0.015171258710324764,
-0.36689868569374084,
0.47586897015571594,
0.1260405331850052,
-0.839724600315094,
-0.24296291172504425,
-0.34583622217178345,
-0.9506784677505493,
0.132863387465477,
-0.33031153678894043,
-0.9031025767326355,
0.4681224524974823,
0.20361541211605072,
-0.41321879625320435,
0.09045398980379105,
-0.6411306262016296,
0.9207314252853394,
-0.10104849189519882,
-0.5718631148338318,
-0.2926952838897705,
-1.0671387910842896,
0.28004559874534607,
0.021536288782954216,
0.04551175236701965,
-0.3059552311897278,
0.052422620356082916,
0.5904282331466675,
-0.7921264171600342,
0.6292470693588257,
-0.11767081171274185,
0.0953916609287262,
0.5652732253074646,
-0.09242349117994308,
0.3853777348995209,
0.1764117032289505,
-0.31496763229370117,
0.2842097878456116,
0.44457337260246277,
-0.6626805067062378,
-0.721342146396637,
0.7666248679161072,
-0.7043713331222534,
-0.43881383538246155,
-0.7348079085350037,
-0.24328316748142242,
-0.3809395134449005,
0.3307720124721527,
0.5691156387329102,
0.5803272724151611,
-0.09523949772119522,
0.23107045888900757,
0.6530709862709045,
-0.16312485933303833,
-0.02324787527322769,
0.23106911778450012,
-0.11626680940389633,
-0.7726763486862183,
0.5505864024162292,
-0.2037573903799057,
0.4758761525154114,
0.1717338114976883,
0.204477459192276,
-0.4216409921646118,
-0.4888395667076111,
-0.4575291872024536,
0.1402273327112198,
-0.6123703718185425,
-0.519494891166687,
-0.9927464723587036,
-0.3731651306152344,
-0.48383063077926636,
-0.29164692759513855,
-0.39886534214019775,
-0.4079906642436981,
0.04105538874864578,
-0.19071225821971893,
0.2142542153596878,
0.750449538230896,
-0.096014104783535,
-0.16329146921634674,
-0.7558230757713318,
0.3567165732383728,
0.01020024623721838,
0.48475390672683716,
-0.2865699529647827,
-0.08325393497943878,
-0.14020131528377533,
0.25041231513023376,
-0.24759040772914886,
-0.8633243441581726,
0.05150290206074715,
0.08574119210243225,
0.6289509534835815,
0.2891685962677002,
0.252347469329834,
0.6132184267044067,
-0.4068711996078491,
0.7597144842147827,
0.3542645573616028,
-1.1447882652282715,
0.94575035572052,
-0.25900301337242126,
0.4127063453197479,
1.0829564332962036,
0.14091619849205017,
-0.06796986609697342,
-0.7411523461341858,
-0.7107909917831421,
-0.8307313323020935,
0.531244158744812,
0.5749055743217468,
-0.5020108222961426,
-0.2970389127731323,
0.49723824858665466,
0.22265422344207764,
0.10901922732591629,
-0.4777119755744934,
-0.30805662274360657,
-0.05601244419813156,
-0.6093081831932068,
0.3949933648109436,
-0.46153706312179565,
-0.16762614250183105,
-0.415654718875885,
0.8898342251777649,
-0.4461342692375183,
0.5502534508705139,
0.8996095657348633,
0.06238935887813568,
-0.12501654028892517,
0.3342590034008026,
0.6376749873161316,
0.6680226922035217,
-0.26309019327163696,
0.3201662003993988,
0.38634416460990906,
-0.5607170462608337,
0.4762263298034668,
-0.23727600276470184,
-0.1745787262916565,
-0.13243286311626434,
0.5074865221977234,
0.5586239695549011,
0.32331350445747375,
-0.6199785470962524,
0.6734740734100342,
-0.17756429314613342,
-0.6159732341766357,
-0.3270514905452728,
0.3856631815433502,
-0.06431880593299866,
0.3402637243270874,
0.30683407187461853,
0.4638606607913971,
0.5544500350952148,
-0.37690970301628113,
0.5084072351455688,
0.1799236387014389,
-0.4849466383457184,
-0.15762639045715332,
0.7618627548217773,
0.1048613116145134,
-0.1269250214099884,
0.41030481457710266,
-0.2023370862007141,
-0.39740195870399475,
0.5303513407707214,
0.7456047534942627,
0.8656318187713623,
-0.3328859210014343,
0.10376167297363281,
0.4815575182437897,
0.1926189363002777,
-0.3209669291973114,
0.791718602180481,
-0.01805884949862957,
-0.7805528044700623,
-0.3844296336174011,
-0.6656553149223328,
-0.4910723865032196,
-0.07020828127861023,
-0.7514170408248901,
0.32614946365356445,
-0.372625470161438,
-0.18490129709243774,
0.03582991287112236,
0.0749259814620018,
-0.28612664341926575,
0.5584936738014221,
-0.017323002219200134,
1.051645278930664,
-0.5027377009391785,
1.2672820091247559,
0.40951502323150635,
-0.21133334934711456,
-1.0300626754760742,
-0.11209826916456223,
0.01080214511603117,
-0.2832506000995636,
0.18842832744121552,
0.23757806420326233,
-0.6990483999252319,
-0.15737582743167877,
-0.5813278555870056,
-0.8225684762001038,
1.2663174867630005,
0.29514503479003906,
-0.6682592630386353,
-0.12029001861810684,
-0.19166412949562073,
0.6331033706665039,
-0.5157197713851929,
0.11443785578012466,
0.5360536575317383,
0.320222407579422,
0.19525140523910522,
-0.8543062210083008,
0.21449536085128784,
-0.43843019008636475,
-0.2423674762248993,
0.2763010859489441,
-0.532795786857605,
0.4622437357902527,
-0.36307233572006226,
0.04685882478952408,
0.22288461029529572,
0.706550657749176,
0.6505495309829712,
0.7321344017982483,
0.7092589735984802,
0.5150418281555176,
0.8030627369880676,
-0.05769272893667221,
0.8238505721092224,
-0.4295496940612793,
0.5988859534263611,
1.209822416305542,
-0.47060924768447876,
0.7451167106628418,
0.5276636481285095,
-0.16317923367023468,
0.6779022216796875,
0.35065314173698425,
0.08920250833034515,
0.7116478681564331,
0.01300638448446989,
-0.3829132914543152,
-0.3162590265274048,
0.2321425974369049,
-0.4537835121154785,
0.4877674877643585,
0.38480138778686523,
-0.4778282344341278,
0.08787088841199875,
0.04642878845334053,
-0.07761059701442719,
-0.12301430851221085,
0.13980795443058014,
0.6382696032524109,
0.2697754502296448,
-0.7347932457923889,
0.5977174639701843,
-0.17358173429965973,
0.3481619954109192,
-0.6680868268013,
-0.08846969902515411,
0.2375590205192566,
0.4143325984477997,
-0.25556614995002747,
-0.6810847520828247,
0.52595454454422,
-0.1540830135345459,
-0.23753224313259125,
0.04750164598226547,
0.8734703063964844,
-0.43295973539352417,
-0.4990300238132477,
0.5778268575668335,
0.4240773320198059,
0.05441050976514816,
0.33573484420776367,
-0.7281792163848877,
0.014188069850206375,
0.19961389899253845,
-0.23785856366157532,
0.046838924288749695,
0.5530933737754822,
-0.04224783927202225,
0.5513560771942139,
0.40290549397468567,
-0.024781551212072372,
-0.05785204842686653,
0.2068324238061905,
0.7092310190200806,
-0.8451062440872192,
-0.5164833068847656,
-0.9077954292297363,
0.22913813591003418,
-0.2850622534751892,
-0.5550485849380493,
0.5497815012931824,
0.5352774858474731,
0.30765295028686523,
0.04918987303972244,
0.5349542498588562,
-0.16426435112953186,
0.26744797825813293,
-0.5226351022720337,
0.7676087021827698,
-0.39265328645706177,
-0.16042570769786835,
-0.3883598744869232,
-0.41212454438209534,
-0.34943369030952454,
0.7924506068229675,
-0.0778743177652359,
-0.15247371792793274,
1.1450093984603882,
0.6061272025108337,
0.24107572436332703,
0.5903396010398865,
0.12025132030248642,
0.3097967207431793,
0.335538387298584,
0.6095423102378845,
0.4949556589126587,
-0.7829422354698181,
0.11248282343149185,
-0.26850250363349915,
-0.4090173542499542,
-0.09509813785552979,
-0.7131343483924866,
-0.6207501888275146,
-0.5209713578224182,
-0.4071061611175537,
-0.8505607843399048,
0.18988169729709625,
1.2723606824874878,
0.6396530866622925,
-1.232444167137146,
0.10764000564813614,
-0.5769597887992859,
0.06384844332933426,
-0.3476952016353607,
-0.23900961875915527,
0.37572938203811646,
-0.5846682190895081,
-0.4249644875526428,
0.4261712431907654,
0.6642757058143616,
-0.41608214378356934,
-0.1302451342344284,
-0.26886770129203796,
-0.819125235080719,
0.1714130938053131,
0.6317457556724548,
-0.08704044669866562,
-0.8765555620193481,
-0.46149396896362305,
-0.013006293214857578,
-0.5459156632423401,
-0.029157785698771477,
0.8533166646957397,
-0.7752481698989868,
0.5442221760749817,
0.5360790491104126,
0.5114046335220337,
0.522165834903717,
-0.06180398538708687,
1.0734268426895142,
-0.1733754277229309,
0.10812913626432419,
0.3958974778652191,
0.5219939351081848,
-0.07596954703330994,
-0.6254768967628479,
0.9367870688438416,
0.19346776604652405,
-0.9625180959701538,
-0.7056313157081604,
0.0722065418958664,
-1.1613175868988037,
-0.31125608086586,
1.0349252223968506,
-0.3387097120285034,
-0.5823572874069214,
-0.3485201597213745,
-0.19270014762878418,
0.3481175899505615,
-0.03747648000717163,
0.7220764756202698,
0.526826798915863,
-0.4050135910511017,
0.2036808878183365,
-0.42646339535713196,
0.6386173963546753,
0.49919992685317993,
-0.8032599091529846,
-0.4204816222190857,
0.2550593316555023,
0.28755107522010803,
0.19042189419269562,
1.1172428131103516,
-0.26143085956573486,
0.4014832377433777,
0.08488871902227402,
0.005540463607758284,
0.4116014540195465,
-0.36049777269363403,
-0.1469988077878952,
0.11025045067071915,
-0.16350051760673523,
-0.2680628001689911
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10023v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10023v1
|
Deep Bayesian Active Learning for Preference Modeling in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-14T13:32:43 | 2024-06-14T13:32:43 |
Luckeciano C. Melo, Panagiotis Tigas, Alessandro Abate, Yarin Gal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML
|
Leveraging human preferences for steering the behavior of Large Language
Models (LLMs) has demonstrated notable success in recent years. Nonetheless,
data selection and labeling are still a bottleneck for these systems,
particularly at large scale. Hence, selecting the most informative points for
acquiring human feedback may considerably reduce the cost of preference
labeling and unleash the further development of LLMs. Bayesian Active Learning
provides a principled framework for addressing this challenge and has
demonstrated remarkable success in diverse settings. However, previous attempts
to employ it for Preference Modeling did not meet such expectations. In this
work, we identify that naive epistemic uncertainty estimation leads to the
acquisition of redundant samples. We address this by proposing the Bayesian
Active Learner for Preference Modeling (BAL-PM), a novel stochastic acquisition
policy that not only targets points of high epistemic uncertainty according to
the preference model but also seeks to maximize the entropy of the acquired
prompt distribution in the feature space spanned by the employed LLM. Notably,
our experiments demonstrate that BAL-PM requires 33% to 68% fewer preference
labels in two popular human preference datasets and exceeds previous stochastic
Bayesian acquisition policies.
|
[
-0.38263893127441406,
-0.9129812121391296,
0.8314462304115295,
-0.07974911481142044,
-0.11182986199855804,
-0.18195119500160217,
-0.5071443319320679,
-0.20882797241210938,
-0.06299043446779251,
0.5778396725654602,
-0.3005617558956146,
-0.5056378245353699,
-0.6166864633560181,
-0.2729153037071228,
0.33101895451545715,
0.8827477693557739,
-0.06478741019964218,
-0.194461852312088,
0.2024286836385727,
0.09300462156534195,
-0.09614685922861099,
-0.3383411467075348,
-0.7060848474502563,
-0.1880505532026291,
0.7100318074226379,
0.5742904543876648,
0.7919745445251465,
0.3871341347694397,
0.19821852445602417,
0.14031194150447845,
-0.2625686526298523,
0.1217864379286766,
-0.1932659149169922,
0.280130535364151,
-0.22582609951496124,
-0.6828569173812866,
-0.5204708576202393,
0.07987846434116364,
0.6838175654411316,
1.2269840240478516,
-0.2913966178894043,
-0.2470676302909851,
-0.20735180377960205,
0.7447451949119568,
-0.9823224544525146,
0.3183731436729431,
-0.5910751223564148,
0.17494988441467285,
-0.026066217571496964,
0.38072025775909424,
-0.2675832211971283,
-0.24679571390151978,
0.6402996182441711,
-0.5162770748138428,
0.341423898935318,
-0.04366549476981163,
0.6790982484817505,
0.15161149203777313,
-0.6132605671882629,
0.008702666498720646,
-0.74333655834198,
0.8386122584342957,
-0.5088499188423157,
0.44321730732917786,
0.9776135683059692,
0.18506084382534027,
-0.028371304273605347,
-0.27987053990364075,
-0.5258319973945618,
-0.19835855066776276,
0.37231454253196716,
0.15427613258361816,
-0.1503627449274063,
0.3363784849643707,
0.03970072790980339,
0.22088441252708435,
-0.17845429480075836,
0.33663320541381836,
-0.32823607325553894,
-0.01688385382294655,
0.5781238079071045,
-0.12488380819559097,
-0.24379269778728485,
0.005334361921995878,
-0.298161119222641,
-0.08643946796655655,
-0.5942701101303101,
0.24837015569210052,
0.40115538239479065,
0.3523026704788208,
0.023380478844046593,
0.6150732040405273,
-0.4118770956993103,
0.8516133427619934,
0.2360382378101349,
-0.009533328004181385,
0.3078497648239136,
0.10910061746835709,
-0.278181791305542,
0.053639184683561325,
0.7893673181533813,
-0.03588635474443436,
-0.010846033692359924,
-0.028695376589894295,
-0.24342627823352814,
-0.03324879705905914,
0.34712982177734375,
-0.38428157567977905,
-0.5302633047103882,
0.3093251883983612,
-0.1741352081298828,
-0.272847056388855,
0.06192198768258095,
-0.5183305740356445,
-0.44879546761512756,
-0.13023726642131805,
0.4155060946941376,
-0.23140403628349304,
-0.4068562984466553,
0.5192561745643616,
0.12103957682847977,
-0.08319298923015594,
0.5958942174911499,
-1.10050368309021,
-0.15328577160835266,
0.5565497875213623,
0.5020915865898132,
-0.31723272800445557,
-0.1606762558221817,
-0.2700418531894684,
0.2894376218318939,
-0.4726521372795105,
0.6951373219490051,
-0.8803067207336426,
-0.3708937168121338,
-0.09582780301570892,
0.12385204434394836,
0.08512792736291885,
-0.5599687099456787,
0.453093945980072,
-0.6316198110580444,
0.08904553949832916,
-0.2167537361383438,
-0.32021477818489075,
-0.3488210141658783,
0.07647781074047089,
-0.6022786498069763,
0.7161516547203064,
0.18492528796195984,
-0.3987077474594116,
0.8463830351829529,
-0.3650224208831787,
-0.3717299699783325,
-0.04805480316281319,
-0.02825107052922249,
-0.5930891036987305,
0.2800924777984619,
0.03236003220081329,
0.743319034576416,
-0.23318646848201752,
0.5793365836143494,
-0.7858079075813293,
-0.033811017870903015,
0.4727650284767151,
-0.7257903814315796,
0.49707019329071045,
0.4355698823928833,
-0.4152279496192932,
0.035081617534160614,
-0.6472296118736267,
-0.359890341758728,
-0.05114617198705673,
-0.7590711712837219,
-0.4313299357891083,
0.18643367290496826,
-0.3657003939151764,
-0.06830646097660065,
0.3634498417377472,
-0.32413575053215027,
0.42480528354644775,
-0.44311970472335815,
0.0001373887062072754,
0.8695746660232544,
0.07641592621803284,
1.004885196685791,
-0.14080959558486938,
0.3510374128818512,
0.17078377306461334,
-0.1057698130607605,
0.22637079656124115,
-0.45766481757164,
-0.7793168425559998,
-0.5967981815338135,
0.14011575281620026,
0.4031680226325989,
-0.30459967255592346,
0.7353935241699219,
-0.12037311494350433,
-0.3613071143627167,
-0.5365082025527954,
0.23133330047130585,
0.29601407051086426,
0.05422061309218407,
0.31653639674186707,
-0.30710235238075256,
0.10385655611753464,
-1.0679830312728882,
0.025043489411473274,
-0.47402793169021606,
-0.17327211797237396,
0.512536346912384,
-0.05522018298506737,
-0.22484971582889557,
0.9371719360351562,
-0.6009594798088074,
-0.05055827647447586,
-0.42478376626968384,
0.22417759895324707,
0.28648942708969116,
0.3669686019420624,
0.3208981156349182,
-0.937611997127533,
-0.35840195417404175,
-0.16422812640666962,
-0.21310435235500336,
-0.14368480443954468,
0.022988473996520042,
-0.20715674757957458,
0.34787288308143616,
-0.18213362991809845,
-0.7089520692825317,
0.26831650733947754,
0.39478349685668945,
-0.18506498634815216,
0.32055264711380005,
-0.09686999768018723,
0.033874742686748505,
-1.006382703781128,
0.041708990931510925,
0.23724082112312317,
0.056278396397829056,
-0.4676484763622284,
-0.2716812193393707,
0.14250080287456512,
0.08735118806362152,
-0.3878672122955322,
0.5556721091270447,
-0.4627625644207001,
0.1321832239627838,
-0.30623242259025574,
-0.38031336665153503,
-0.08420714735984802,
0.5369738340377808,
0.6858124732971191,
0.21274414658546448,
0.6204001307487488,
-0.7968481779098511,
0.4333686828613281,
0.09230798482894897,
-0.3388558030128479,
0.31981155276298523,
-0.26415324211120605,
-0.1987532079219818,
-0.15350142121315002,
0.20941971242427826,
-1.0548529624938965,
-0.37247994542121887,
0.3745975196361542,
-0.36800745129585266,
0.6537438035011292,
-0.4726763963699341,
-0.045224420726299286,
0.08203095197677612,
-0.02225276455283165,
0.2868402302265167,
0.41783541440963745,
-0.38170623779296875,
0.18196836113929749,
0.687877357006073,
-0.3089190721511841,
-0.7734543681144714,
-0.5130422711372375,
-0.2510751187801361,
-0.15382780134677887,
-0.11590714007616043,
0.1147683635354042,
0.12182161211967468,
-0.27459076046943665,
-0.03158409893512726,
-0.5046300888061523,
-0.18156889081001282,
0.2657895088195801,
0.18766185641288757,
0.27472802996635437,
-0.035659242421388626,
0.25662630796432495,
0.277412474155426,
-0.18065664172172546,
-0.0038823517970740795,
-0.3080635368824005,
0.293466180562973,
0.10634133964776993,
-0.41710859537124634,
-0.1872411072254181,
0.22729100286960602,
0.4768924415111542,
-0.01948200725018978,
0.7950539588928223,
0.5199259519577026,
-0.28616106510162354,
-0.39507436752319336,
-0.6145498752593994,
-0.20079214870929718,
-0.38870134949684143,
0.49594545364379883,
-0.5186129212379456,
-0.919581413269043,
0.10938648879528046,
-0.09160996228456497,
0.12709689140319824,
0.27606043219566345,
0.4064505994319916,
-0.13858816027641296,
0.9454511404037476,
0.46386003494262695,
-0.12357635796070099,
0.6495106816291809,
-0.34317806363105774,
0.15928727388381958,
-0.5498468279838562,
-0.13610246777534485,
-0.32664579153060913,
-0.24431315064430237,
-0.3406546115875244,
-0.559453010559082,
0.2928474545478821,
0.2247244417667389,
-0.4248696565628052,
-0.05577978119254112,
-0.09305361658334732,
0.12305738031864166,
0.6476377844810486,
0.3128611743450165,
0.022792784497141838,
0.23367148637771606,
-0.15441745519638062,
-0.01131751574575901,
-0.6705284714698792,
-0.462893009185791,
1.032092809677124,
0.3705492317676544,
1.050984501838684,
0.3784671425819397,
0.4602051377296448,
0.09947837889194489,
0.018586229532957077,
-1.095808982849121,
0.4864637553691864,
-0.032492924481630325,
-0.7789596915245056,
-0.5496694445610046,
-0.6891745924949646,
-1.1423025131225586,
0.21569737792015076,
-0.4287523627281189,
-0.6034124493598938,
0.5829605460166931,
0.30659225583076477,
-0.612171471118927,
0.45073357224464417,
-0.5517790913581848,
0.948057234287262,
-0.307942658662796,
-0.8282504677772522,
-0.22133243083953857,
-0.7235840559005737,
0.27070680260658264,
-0.2614184021949768,
-0.04113815724849701,
-0.3579353392124176,
-0.38180166482925415,
0.6902428269386292,
0.0075356196612119675,
1.0496220588684082,
-0.3569420278072357,
-0.14745597541332245,
0.06388303637504578,
0.20909766852855682,
0.5044991374015808,
0.2485392838716507,
-0.20102986693382263,
-0.02905484475195408,
-0.41056564450263977,
-0.5005115866661072,
-0.36439162492752075,
0.4938577115535736,
-1.001726746559143,
-0.7285035252571106,
-0.6199377775192261,
-0.2813679277896881,
-0.65462726354599,
-0.06291451305150986,
-0.040642980486154556,
0.09110011905431747,
-0.12289852648973465,
0.2852296233177185,
0.9963393211364746,
-0.42391878366470337,
0.23263895511627197,
0.7996894121170044,
0.18832316994667053,
-0.28478583693504333,
0.8210651278495789,
0.15567131340503693,
0.5151187777519226,
0.48200467228889465,
0.16581137478351593,
-0.2705482244491577,
-0.7329187989234924,
-0.2931200861930847,
0.2819967567920685,
-0.33914628624916077,
-0.045099515467882156,
-0.8132703304290771,
-0.022430961951613426,
-0.40562930703163147,
-0.4252025783061981,
-0.5756299495697021,
-0.5602527260780334,
-0.47685736417770386,
-0.37534669041633606,
0.1990034282207489,
0.4478180706501007,
-0.09371308237314224,
0.4624612033367157,
-0.7071152329444885,
0.2717725336551666,
0.5780633091926575,
0.27133551239967346,
-0.20592592656612396,
-0.6546405553817749,
-0.2552964985370636,
0.19714023172855377,
-0.2837679982185364,
-0.8109311461448669,
0.7260997891426086,
0.10009680688381195,
0.9928174614906311,
0.7683011889457703,
0.35625699162483215,
0.41398724913597107,
-0.017841516062617302,
0.6796121597290039,
0.11690138280391693,
-0.4756186902523041,
0.7388703227043152,
-0.4807114899158478,
0.30475422739982605,
0.5617457032203674,
0.86309415102005,
-0.2506086230278015,
-0.17941078543663025,
-0.71174556016922,
-1.2634257078170776,
0.8370862603187561,
-0.37943360209465027,
0.018250267952680588,
-0.036802925169467926,
0.3079449534416199,
0.4496605694293976,
0.41006696224212646,
-0.560482382774353,
-0.20738434791564941,
0.2529928982257843,
-0.11241591721773148,
-0.35681721568107605,
-0.39566612243652344,
-0.024685470387339592,
0.0004653968499042094,
0.851101815700531,
-0.15386462211608887,
0.21601028740406036,
-0.07290029525756836,
-0.17826278507709503,
-0.11672898381948471,
0.5705322623252869,
-0.014836566522717476,
0.5515707731246948,
-0.5880243182182312,
0.27852991223335266,
0.061648208647966385,
-0.3507158160209656,
0.3090791404247284,
0.1405973583459854,
-0.31515881419181824,
-0.40725988149642944,
-0.07025012373924255,
1.107036828994751,
0.2844010591506958,
-0.524368405342102,
0.47975680232048035,
0.1842215657234192,
-0.13971245288848877,
-0.2134104073047638,
0.28507909178733826,
-0.08713723719120026,
0.07830025255680084,
0.4746207296848297,
0.3360649645328522,
0.07064340263605118,
-0.667432963848114,
0.0537249930202961,
0.3919214904308319,
-0.6704084873199463,
-0.3669351637363434,
0.35707107186317444,
0.13952474296092987,
0.173929825425148,
0.37609392404556274,
-0.19814936816692352,
-0.4635641574859619,
0.2503765821456909,
0.4381124675273895,
0.806986391544342,
-0.36222413182258606,
0.3970995843410492,
0.32046061754226685,
0.13435932993888855,
-0.5577844381332397,
0.12345674633979797,
-0.39090830087661743,
-1.0008151531219482,
-0.009715168736875057,
-0.9305577278137207,
-0.6368336081504822,
0.010791019536554813,
-0.6487971544265747,
0.2718406021595001,
-0.4431474506855011,
-0.3201754689216614,
-0.18883416056632996,
0.12117129564285278,
-0.4784490168094635,
0.24893911182880402,
0.2188035398721695,
0.2596256136894226,
-0.9820488691329956,
0.9824203252792358,
0.8848435282707214,
-0.36369451880455017,
-0.5188692212104797,
0.010439379140734673,
0.07529706507921219,
-0.5429137349128723,
0.3951069414615631,
-0.09180968999862671,
0.1769205927848816,
-0.06557653099298477,
-0.5077329874038696,
-0.7830936312675476,
0.6000874638557434,
0.3806937038898468,
-0.3798882067203522,
0.028751393780112267,
-0.2696481943130493,
0.18730495870113373,
-0.27457594871520996,
0.09869210422039032,
0.45626288652420044,
0.36328232288360596,
0.3377549648284912,
-0.7794090509414673,
-0.12399660795927048,
-0.027648264542222023,
-0.29086655378341675,
0.43343424797058105,
-0.7590850591659546,
0.6108333468437195,
-0.4447614848613739,
-0.11093748360872269,
-0.25540366768836975,
0.5785612463951111,
0.4380481541156769,
0.272513210773468,
0.5672277212142944,
0.4876363277435303,
0.7565149664878845,
0.05802600085735321,
0.6767557859420776,
0.09678502380847931,
0.1088547632098198,
0.9512156248092651,
-0.37936535477638245,
1.1481854915618896,
0.33316752314567566,
-0.37752485275268555,
0.017583603039383888,
1.0045669078826904,
0.18585656583309174,
0.6742151975631714,
-0.0281930323690176,
-0.641224205493927,
-0.6731110215187073,
0.01557504665106535,
-0.1432560682296753,
0.3735658526420593,
0.753268837928772,
-0.44011086225509644,
0.2840481102466583,
-0.004751279018819332,
0.17154578864574432,
-0.25219404697418213,
-0.2422853410243988,
0.8902836441993713,
0.019327476620674133,
-0.9378795027732849,
0.321316123008728,
0.013817106373608112,
0.7991204261779785,
-0.8028305172920227,
0.22156862914562225,
-0.14308705925941467,
0.17711949348449707,
0.03453163430094719,
-0.7411043643951416,
-0.09733825922012329,
-0.2013627588748932,
-0.27910691499710083,
-0.29117175936698914,
0.4979090094566345,
-0.6879147887229919,
-0.44389480352401733,
0.1067555621266365,
0.5749176740646362,
0.1667616367340088,
-0.13193991780281067,
-0.5961296558380127,
-0.28133559226989746,
-0.004682102706283331,
-0.7390035390853882,
0.4484291076660156,
0.46430376172065735,
-0.008241226896643639,
0.6660507917404175,
0.702700138092041,
0.543836772441864,
0.03933819383382797,
-0.13118019700050354,
0.6671144962310791,
-0.6658693552017212,
-0.35788995027542114,
-0.5640924572944641,
0.31966379284858704,
0.12470202893018723,
-0.10748837888240814,
0.6082027554512024,
0.5249472260475159,
0.8875139355659485,
-0.007544822990894318,
1.1571334600448608,
0.0008745467639528215,
0.3996116816997528,
-0.387128084897995,
0.650547444820404,
-0.5716466903686523,
0.5691043138504028,
-0.22536098957061768,
-1.1163123846054077,
-0.4042106568813324,
1.0341194868087769,
-0.6301542520523071,
0.07192673534154892,
0.5300097465515137,
0.86175137758255,
-0.2895461320877075,
-0.2935289442539215,
0.4205866754055023,
0.03513183444738388,
-0.026724698022007942,
0.7579285502433777,
0.7048206925392151,
0.046022679656744,
0.3130188286304474,
-0.3485707938671112,
-0.5003316402435303,
-0.23601460456848145,
-0.4018882215023041,
-0.6712235808372498,
-0.6169039607048035,
-0.46699750423431396,
-0.3478374481201172,
0.15496569871902466,
1.308353304862976,
0.6017326712608337,
-0.8093281388282776,
-0.21922199428081512,
0.19274166226387024,
0.1595364362001419,
-0.2140575647354126,
-0.16838496923446655,
0.3474820852279663,
-0.3408537209033966,
-0.8508151173591614,
0.4091576933860779,
0.2254246026277542,
0.19714875519275665,
-0.13328225910663605,
-0.07714250683784485,
-0.32123541831970215,
-0.04752381518483162,
0.3878505527973175,
0.29832687973976135,
-0.7432767152786255,
-0.14267803728580475,
-0.11707747727632523,
-0.28023651242256165,
-0.02246149070560932,
0.5490257143974304,
-0.6640282869338989,
0.6215031147003174,
0.6767433881759644,
0.6112985610961914,
0.7159621715545654,
-0.11623767763376236,
0.8676629662513733,
-0.3589308261871338,
0.026391837745904922,
0.27377447485923767,
0.37105733156204224,
0.18884100019931793,
-0.17753548920154572,
0.425726979970932,
0.4414188861846924,
-0.5205579400062561,
-0.7113487124443054,
0.29462090134620667,
-1.196373701095581,
-0.4743403494358063,
1.6149040460586548,
-0.38374629616737366,
-0.224777489900589,
-0.4065530002117157,
-0.2628733217716217,
0.24457138776779175,
-0.7669676542282104,
0.8621563911437988,
0.5110210180282593,
0.0959712415933609,
-0.2629943788051605,
-0.4291325807571411,
0.36193153262138367,
0.5186690092086792,
-0.27932703495025635,
0.23724958300590515,
0.9085845351219177,
0.3067976236343384,
-0.15574148297309875,
0.4050213396549225,
0.22958382964134216,
0.2892543077468872,
-0.0226282961666584,
0.11375600099563599,
0.1062365248799324,
-0.44310885667800903,
-0.44018206000328064,
0.4704446494579315,
0.34271901845932007,
-0.14078596234321594
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10019v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10019v1
|
Group and Shuffle: Efficient Structured Orthogonal Parametrization
| 2024-06-14T13:29:36 | 2024-06-14T13:29:36 |
Mikhail Gorbunov, Nikolay Yudin, Vera Soboleva, Aibek Alanov, Alexey Naumov, Maxim Rakhuba
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.NA, math.NA
|
The increasing size of neural networks has led to a growing demand for
methods of efficient fine-tuning. Recently, an orthogonal fine-tuning paradigm
was introduced that uses orthogonal matrices for adapting the weights of a
pretrained model. In this paper, we introduce a new class of structured
matrices, which unifies and generalizes structured classes from previous works.
We examine properties of this class and build a structured orthogonal
parametrization upon it. We then use this parametrization to modify the
orthogonal fine-tuning framework, improving parameter and computational
efficiency. We empirically validate our method on different domains, including
adapting of text-to-image diffusion models and downstream task fine-tuning in
language modeling. Additionally, we adapt our construction for orthogonal
convolutions and conduct experiments with 1-Lipschitz neural networks.
|
[
-0.22052887082099915,
-0.9189304113388062,
0.4499623477458954,
0.6203311681747437,
-0.4035472869873047,
-0.011783729307353497,
-0.3105548620223999,
-0.0755845382809639,
-0.07544709742069244,
0.31204599142074585,
-0.00459510600194335,
-0.5042130351066589,
-0.6297057867050171,
-0.2292306274175644,
-0.3795267343521118,
0.7781489491462708,
-0.05122002586722374,
0.2707923948764801,
0.2184056043624878,
-0.48288044333457947,
-0.3807770907878876,
-0.11438778042793274,
-0.6775768995285034,
-0.5532582402229309,
0.7390583157539368,
0.398866206407547,
0.9810799360275269,
1.0221877098083496,
0.28153112530708313,
0.42873939871788025,
0.024637892842292786,
0.18673188984394073,
-0.6798083782196045,
0.056388724595308304,
-0.12737466394901276,
-0.36547455191612244,
-0.8217632174491882,
0.17132830619812012,
0.746554434299469,
1.4131128787994385,
-0.5112593770027161,
0.456686407327652,
0.4469844698905945,
0.8200101852416992,
-0.5537341833114624,
-0.09915237873792648,
-0.7853248715400696,
0.060870181769132614,
-0.13925406336784363,
-0.7086734771728516,
-0.18336071074008942,
-0.4857381284236908,
-0.26899856328964233,
-0.9539669156074524,
0.3362259864807129,
0.19045208394527435,
0.5119245648384094,
0.3047533333301544,
0.01973869279026985,
0.06997842341661453,
-0.7550108432769775,
1.0303670167922974,
-0.38417747616767883,
0.5287179350852966,
0.4652426242828369,
0.27169543504714966,
-0.31273353099823,
-0.7558307647705078,
-0.11818388849496841,
-0.004964668303728104,
0.32058122754096985,
-0.08532882481813431,
-0.12936705350875854,
0.43577826023101807,
0.1950675994157791,
0.28447994589805603,
-0.526141881942749,
0.2195994108915329,
-0.625262439250946,
0.39152035117149353,
0.7040865421295166,
0.2358073592185974,
0.121785968542099,
0.6517859697341919,
-0.2916012406349182,
-0.03527098521590233,
-0.4148486852645874,
-0.009184103459119797,
0.9036102294921875,
0.21281012892723083,
0.0369853675365448,
0.21490441262722015,
-0.2917962074279785,
1.1453207731246948,
0.4607717990875244,
-0.08148079365491867,
0.1962195634841919,
-0.03831375762820244,
-0.4665414094924927,
-0.2586295008659363,
0.34539955854415894,
0.34785524010658264,
0.4038475453853607,
-0.3772633373737335,
-0.13995812833309174,
-0.11335089802742004,
0.37763115763664246,
-0.6888291835784912,
-0.5404571890830994,
-0.04593224823474884,
-1.3359650373458862,
-0.22948940098285675,
-0.4148721992969513,
-0.4269237220287323,
-0.019476843997836113,
-0.9619358777999878,
0.5354998707771301,
-0.34277331829071045,
0.15582193434238434,
0.6473777890205383,
-0.39201411604881287,
-0.007564962841570377,
0.6212839484214783,
-0.7423077821731567,
0.565797746181488,
0.6469842791557312,
0.5451070666313171,
-0.26098933815956116,
-0.3068239688873291,
-0.28541481494903564,
-0.012950331903994083,
-0.5682258009910583,
0.8729225397109985,
-0.618541419506073,
-0.04262978211045265,
-0.10980808734893799,
-0.4929479956626892,
-0.1189679503440857,
-0.8085404634475708,
0.30432766675949097,
-0.42953231930732727,
-0.07686635851860046,
-0.07808495312929153,
-0.2624441683292389,
-0.18288198113441467,
0.133339062333107,
-0.29737451672554016,
0.8826726078987122,
0.23839659988880157,
-0.1910018026828766,
0.3319374918937683,
-0.24402008950710297,
-0.27465489506721497,
0.10901226848363876,
-0.21096082031726837,
-0.4279344975948334,
0.4168574810028076,
-0.10775300115346909,
0.5835337042808533,
-0.177214577794075,
0.34641435742378235,
-0.7481339573860168,
-0.5540157556533813,
-0.03080206923186779,
0.058236800134181976,
0.5635952949523926,
0.5738512277603149,
0.3025079071521759,
0.2107391208410263,
-1.3953238725662231,
0.5216081142425537,
-0.35742297768592834,
-0.569663941860199,
-0.6305072903633118,
0.510489284992218,
0.14052145183086395,
0.10742649435997009,
0.08527754247188568,
-0.10540300607681274,
0.4242006242275238,
-0.09560644626617432,
0.3827642798423767,
0.6861459016799927,
-0.010614621452987194,
0.9885982275009155,
-0.5621095895767212,
0.43662142753601074,
-0.11857322603464127,
0.19442136585712433,
0.07743390649557114,
-0.325646311044693,
-0.6146641969680786,
-0.20923256874084473,
0.15435735881328583,
0.30469849705696106,
-0.5579381585121155,
0.3107004463672638,
0.038736335933208466,
-0.5355918407440186,
-0.24894076585769653,
0.2983432710170746,
0.33737683296203613,
0.241575688123703,
0.46227824687957764,
-0.19055037200450897,
-0.6425076723098755,
-1.0425339937210083,
-0.6180890798568726,
0.1801653355360031,
-0.2503690719604492,
0.1977972835302353,
-0.10060665756464005,
0.0005604653269983828,
0.4796145260334015,
-0.39414694905281067,
-0.4081363081932068,
-0.1950279027223587,
0.3749849200248718,
0.45744428038597107,
0.8038501739501953,
0.610851526260376,
-0.41514909267425537,
-0.496830016374588,
-0.19174817204475403,
-0.47113093733787537,
-0.26822954416275024,
-0.14704371988773346,
-0.08038756251335144,
-0.5621812343597412,
1.001036286354065,
0.13280104100704193,
0.20613354444503784,
0.31835365295410156,
-0.1574915498495102,
0.012592660263180733,
-0.38132956624031067,
-0.04800739884376526,
-0.8076769113540649,
-0.11217889934778214,
-0.12662866711616516,
-0.22558283805847168,
-0.7553713321685791,
0.09617747366428375,
0.0020672190003097057,
-0.03876814246177673,
-0.11461086571216583,
0.08061227947473526,
-0.7394050359725952,
0.22258909046649933,
-0.3099198043346405,
-0.4265606105327606,
-0.39734622836112976,
0.9555903673171997,
-0.32488036155700684,
0.43693795800209045,
0.6397346258163452,
-0.8795410990715027,
-0.3285354971885681,
0.1223520040512085,
-0.43577441573143005,
0.591802179813385,
-0.8812306523323059,
0.2410731166601181,
-0.5496730804443359,
-0.0769943818449974,
-0.8339319825172424,
0.07767316699028015,
-0.0614561103284359,
-0.11770204454660416,
0.2414662390947342,
-0.16427788138389587,
-0.17448687553405762,
0.21149033308029175,
-0.3643408715724945,
0.8737701773643494,
0.4813510775566101,
-0.23587174713611603,
0.5280234813690186,
0.4744863510131836,
-0.09193820506334305,
-0.21575742959976196,
-0.4420081675052643,
-0.21187128126621246,
-0.13863661885261536,
-0.658957302570343,
0.5842532515525818,
-0.17313677072525024,
-0.36346861720085144,
-0.20715221762657166,
0.029409371316432953,
-0.4141681492328644,
0.3376762270927429,
0.1751299649477005,
-0.4484187364578247,
-0.4826951026916504,
-0.01071237400174141,
0.25897735357284546,
-0.021455854177474976,
-0.18722984194755554,
-0.45922350883483887,
0.6662963032722473,
0.1378224641084671,
-0.07222195714712143,
0.023213569074869156,
0.7023038864135742,
0.05171862617135048,
-0.04570150002837181,
0.485169917345047,
0.42055413126945496,
-0.3836745023727417,
-0.7081547379493713,
-0.4558410346508026,
0.18297652900218964,
-0.5847191214561462,
0.7482714653015137,
-0.04805639386177063,
-0.961958646774292,
0.7876826524734497,
-0.09587588906288147,
-0.06104490906000137,
0.036712802946567535,
0.6296316385269165,
-0.15445660054683685,
1.2131458520889282,
0.7239522933959961,
0.17447428405284882,
0.8060576915740967,
-0.144012913107872,
0.20135599374771118,
-0.7665567398071289,
-0.031063757836818695,
-0.6675958037376404,
-1.2732900381088257,
-0.42282038927078247,
-0.3903156816959381,
0.5059058666229248,
0.47311457991600037,
-0.3362637758255005,
0.21751102805137634,
-0.4022141396999359,
0.6540107727050781,
0.44474491477012634,
0.33137255907058716,
-0.07137484103441238,
0.04305483028292656,
0.02822749689221382,
0.08336414396762848,
-0.6384304761886597,
-0.22514791786670685,
1.0134307146072388,
0.31523314118385315,
1.175861120223999,
-0.15559738874435425,
0.4402925670146942,
0.008401528932154179,
0.0901871994137764,
-0.41552215814590454,
0.6492259502410889,
-0.3802523910999298,
-0.16612324118614197,
-0.05034294351935387,
-0.2721070647239685,
-1.1843328475952148,
0.31362786889076233,
-0.1996409296989441,
-0.7241157293319702,
0.8093464970588684,
0.5357705950737,
-0.5174649953842163,
0.07141554355621338,
-0.5138137936592102,
0.4129759669303894,
0.1964402049779892,
-0.33131417632102966,
-0.44135478138923645,
-0.31445157527923584,
0.1880236268043518,
0.12892045080661774,
-0.07533875852823257,
-0.28901535272598267,
-0.15227851271629333,
0.658292293548584,
-0.4070524275302887,
0.5184550881385803,
-0.27021855115890503,
0.1335456818342209,
-0.02677408792078495,
0.09581121057271957,
0.1887238770723343,
0.24566331505775452,
-0.27091553807258606,
0.3131539225578308,
-0.41378656029701233,
-0.3723423480987549,
-0.5701467990875244,
0.4568219780921936,
-0.5977581739425659,
-0.3546048700809479,
0.041527196764945984,
-1.087470293045044,
-0.22792506217956543,
0.1541353017091751,
0.28013595938682556,
0.4766518175601959,
-0.03921233490109444,
0.47311216592788696,
0.7147834300994873,
-0.16756421327590942,
0.485424667596817,
0.4510596692562103,
-0.1175990030169487,
-0.4177378714084625,
0.5523937940597534,
0.2288220226764679,
0.19105562567710876,
0.36419299244880676,
0.06749264895915985,
0.4173930585384369,
-1.172314167022705,
0.03985937684774399,
-0.3825390040874481,
-0.334656298160553,
-0.45569300651550293,
-0.6001173853874207,
-0.18935370445251465,
-0.21280133724212646,
-0.3439190685749054,
-0.30099231004714966,
-0.6785045862197876,
-0.29487544298171997,
0.20375490188598633,
0.07595901191234589,
0.49323320388793945,
-0.03249930217862129,
0.7734520435333252,
-0.5444302558898926,
0.6417934894561768,
0.40467774868011475,
0.6796845197677612,
-0.04637746885418892,
-0.5006142258644104,
-0.2373177856206894,
-0.17824587225914001,
-0.5314918756484985,
-0.7699727416038513,
0.2820075452327728,
0.7913834452629089,
0.673389196395874,
0.5300447940826416,
-0.391647607088089,
0.9047738909721375,
-0.9306381940841675,
0.31558290123939514,
-0.09670562297105789,
-0.5680468082427979,
0.11223361641168594,
-0.7924668192863464,
0.165828675031662,
0.7565369606018066,
0.07641933113336563,
-0.0687788873910904,
-0.3357580900192261,
-0.29550033807754517,
-0.8555359840393066,
0.5495506525039673,
0.14407065510749817,
0.17364121973514557,
0.21211205422878265,
0.6295905709266663,
0.09279314428567886,
0.16452166438102722,
-0.4406168758869171,
-0.4874262809753418,
0.09921276569366455,
-0.2938925623893738,
-0.04613276198506355,
-0.35174548625946045,
0.10153580456972122,
-0.7485989332199097,
0.3637169301509857,
-0.22059212625026703,
0.3152522146701813,
-0.04076008498668671,
-0.1823379099369049,
-0.32835689187049866,
0.1350770741701126,
0.6604990363121033,
0.9929598569869995,
-0.1262088567018509,
0.16719450056552887,
0.14329472184181213,
-0.5185657739639282,
0.10451985150575638,
0.28264784812927246,
-0.16931138932704926,
-0.09162261337041855,
0.12183556705713272,
0.7713433504104614,
0.5719480514526367,
0.06579892337322235,
0.17835400998592377,
0.013462902046740055,
-0.6538856029510498,
-0.10623279213905334,
0.37659338116645813,
-0.20375707745552063,
0.3995997905731201,
0.3569660186767578,
0.60682612657547,
0.5114482045173645,
-0.33438682556152344,
0.06707042455673218,
0.5281832218170166,
-0.12720990180969238,
-0.4321662485599518,
0.7680397629737854,
-0.10084278136491776,
-0.6488401293754578,
0.2540641129016876,
-0.19519515335559845,
-0.2843439280986786,
0.410396933555603,
0.583900511264801,
0.8456955552101135,
-0.4024791717529297,
-0.1321263611316681,
0.3963012993335724,
0.20624712109565735,
-0.3912944793701172,
0.6904849410057068,
-0.3248414695262909,
-0.7396177053451538,
-0.2554584741592407,
-0.7123746275901794,
0.06559096276760101,
0.17355601489543915,
-0.6623620390892029,
0.23118026554584503,
-0.859503448009491,
0.0754685327410698,
0.19593806564807892,
-0.5265194177627563,
-0.6211581826210022,
-0.06429983675479889,
-0.04625047370791435,
1.0114305019378662,
-0.6643911004066467,
1.043359398841858,
0.8516473174095154,
0.20599046349525452,
-0.8602708578109741,
-0.471735417842865,
-0.3951723277568817,
-0.9459536075592041,
0.599311351776123,
-0.21806412935256958,
0.243452250957489,
0.03281994163990021,
-0.9618942141532898,
-0.9795690178871155,
0.765444815158844,
0.4556678235530853,
-0.47801220417022705,
0.014517762698233128,
0.20167498290538788,
0.6042748689651489,
-0.12276720255613327,
0.09028027951717377,
0.40636155009269714,
0.25556695461273193,
-0.30136385560035706,
-0.7254703044891357,
-0.26292866468429565,
-0.5456783771514893,
0.5137705206871033,
0.2950606346130371,
-0.4285533130168915,
1.3614939451217651,
0.25753796100616455,
0.024404635652899742,
0.14616313576698303,
0.9187266230583191,
0.1483391523361206,
0.21628731489181519,
0.6519997715950012,
0.731971263885498,
0.5052445530891418,
0.06539571285247803,
0.6080942153930664,
-0.17700029909610748,
0.14287394285202026,
1.1128435134887695,
-0.1497989147901535,
0.5384560823440552,
0.5500842332839966,
-0.16948305070400238,
0.33841031789779663,
0.23440393805503845,
-0.10013831406831741,
0.5205548405647278,
0.5469769239425659,
0.22997596859931946,
-0.42868998646736145,
0.3786465525627136,
-0.41649752855300903,
0.43583303689956665,
0.41210269927978516,
-0.4874483048915863,
-0.6183070540428162,
0.03830674663186073,
-0.28719574213027954,
0.3840184509754181,
-0.7836522459983826,
0.6178373098373413,
0.2532055377960205,
-0.7326650619506836,
0.6236144304275513,
0.37098827958106995,
0.7674390077590942,
-0.5148974657058716,
-0.2676931619644165,
-0.09365716576576233,
0.6662724018096924,
-0.21080808341503143,
-0.30450019240379333,
0.383470743894577,
-0.4996715784072876,
-0.44110211730003357,
-0.8584972023963928,
0.8297974467277527,
-0.7795917987823486,
-0.48699629306793213,
0.0037001674063503742,
0.1833411604166031,
-0.2661091387271881,
-0.2724832594394684,
-0.5851186513900757,
-0.08426137268543243,
-0.2831292152404785,
-0.11042951792478561,
0.4877985715866089,
0.3058696389198303,
-0.15935930609703064,
0.34416475892066956,
0.6009527444839478,
-0.043511029332876205,
0.4581141173839569,
-0.011538319289684296,
0.7369396090507507,
-0.4157111942768097,
-0.6558905243873596,
-0.6729010939598083,
0.24091923236846924,
0.1565617024898529,
-0.7985519170761108,
0.6772404313087463,
0.7157854437828064,
0.6626508831977844,
-0.18773536384105682,
0.1842755228281021,
0.18713459372520447,
0.3974618911743164,
-0.6070001721382141,
0.9773305058479309,
-0.5217719078063965,
0.02811228297650814,
-0.24287642538547516,
-1.012093424797058,
-0.4982037842273712,
0.9056191444396973,
0.19777832925319672,
0.25866538286209106,
0.4632486402988434,
0.6897715330123901,
-0.39637643098831177,
-0.0038052904419600964,
0.2305813431739807,
0.271305114030838,
0.013792409561574459,
0.5432777404785156,
0.6919756531715393,
-0.5293269753456116,
0.043382201343774796,
-0.2586652338504791,
-0.2855220437049866,
0.03454447165131569,
-0.9492830634117126,
-0.8293549418449402,
-0.6779130101203918,
-0.4890298843383789,
-0.21569755673408508,
0.06917215883731842,
0.7721414566040039,
0.9844152331352234,
-0.7652825117111206,
-0.3786296546459198,
-0.2808001935482025,
-0.03959059715270996,
-0.4183029234409332,
-0.16259847581386566,
0.17967121303081512,
-0.6983678936958313,
-0.49090299010276794,
0.3569985628128052,
0.39117708802223206,
-0.28022047877311707,
0.24697625637054443,
0.11209526658058167,
-0.1607527732849121,
0.07991412281990051,
0.5765630602836609,
0.22718565165996552,
-0.14663997292518616,
-0.22302500903606415,
0.06113601475954056,
-0.009822041727602482,
0.13093256950378418,
1.0224380493164062,
-0.6984232068061829,
0.02170211635529995,
0.794102668762207,
0.47657710313796997,
0.24182835221290588,
-0.03186240792274475,
0.7405481934547424,
-0.8880132436752319,
0.4867691099643707,
0.38015884160995483,
0.5896512866020203,
-0.3411385118961334,
-0.11283400654792786,
0.3202073872089386,
-0.13358652591705322,
-0.8570172786712646,
-0.6349918842315674,
-0.008817476220428944,
-1.381377100944519,
-0.11829987168312073,
1.227455973625183,
0.24932876229286194,
-0.25061288475990295,
-0.41011694073677063,
-0.19969108700752258,
0.10083097219467163,
-0.09852268546819687,
0.8163370490074158,
0.30188092589378357,
-0.09623196721076965,
0.11785572022199631,
-0.2687453031539917,
0.5911384224891663,
0.6365812420845032,
-0.7150790095329285,
-0.2689664959907532,
0.25152134895324707,
0.311643123626709,
-0.1117321252822876,
0.8270233273506165,
-0.033395785838365555,
0.3019479513168335,
-0.4036630392074585,
0.018255025148391724,
-0.33582934737205505,
-0.25065773725509644,
-0.5129420161247253,
0.4074711799621582,
-0.04639953002333641,
-0.33557599782943726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09994v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09994v1
|
Precision Empowers, Excess Distracts: Visual Question Answering With Dynamically Infused Knowledge In Language Models
| 2024-06-14T13:07:46 | 2024-06-14T13:07:46 |
Manas Jhalani, Annervaz K M, Pushpak Bhattacharyya
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In the realm of multimodal tasks, Visual Question Answering (VQA) plays a
crucial role by addressing natural language questions grounded in visual
content. Knowledge-Based Visual Question Answering (KBVQA) advances this
concept by adding external knowledge along with images to respond to questions.
We introduce an approach for KBVQA, augmenting the existing vision-language
transformer encoder-decoder (OFA) model. Our main contribution involves
enhancing questions by incorporating relevant external knowledge extracted from
knowledge graphs, using a dynamic triple extraction method. We supply a
flexible number of triples from the knowledge graph as context, tailored to
meet the requirements for answering the question. Our model, enriched with
knowledge, demonstrates an average improvement of 4.75\% in Exact Match Score
over the state-of-the-art on three different KBVQA datasets. Through
experiments and analysis, we demonstrate that furnishing variable triples for
each question improves the reasoning capabilities of the language model in
contrast to supplying a fixed number of triples. This is illustrated even for
recent large language models. Additionally, we highlight the model's
generalization capability by showcasing its SOTA-beating performance on a small
dataset, achieved through straightforward fine-tuning.
|
[
-0.38645240664482117,
-1.206549048423767,
0.8052184581756592,
-0.032502464950084686,
-0.28096890449523926,
0.1816939413547516,
0.05067279562354088,
-0.6464539766311646,
-0.13849307596683502,
0.6764964461326599,
-0.3499862253665924,
-0.18996617197990417,
-0.5454908609390259,
-0.10548736900091171,
-0.11846017092466354,
0.14303387701511383,
-0.32548651099205017,
0.06762529909610748,
-0.5335739850997925,
-0.27093711495399475,
-0.7865398526191711,
-0.09091009944677353,
-0.27346548438072205,
0.19840288162231445,
0.4866349697113037,
0.6293981671333313,
0.7994745969772339,
0.7081013321876526,
0.6657343506813049,
0.34844234585762024,
0.10103188455104828,
0.3916782736778259,
-0.43047034740448,
0.266733318567276,
0.07511957734823227,
-0.7541312575340271,
-0.12623262405395508,
-0.3103249669075012,
0.544302761554718,
0.521981418132782,
0.09337836503982544,
0.28343868255615234,
-0.2869951128959656,
0.7119529843330383,
-0.8028236627578735,
0.5002673864364624,
-0.6985803246498108,
-0.18475152552127838,
0.2204764187335968,
-0.14631310105323792,
-0.21547023952007294,
-0.30718091130256653,
0.28912821412086487,
-0.8112233877182007,
-0.3312950134277344,
-0.1643131524324417,
1.0529747009277344,
0.6821478605270386,
-0.7458238005638123,
-0.021680433303117752,
-0.6063252091407776,
0.4591563940048218,
-0.1410350501537323,
0.5622317790985107,
0.22584788501262665,
0.7432286739349365,
0.28389880061149597,
-0.8802899122238159,
-0.7661693692207336,
0.0457598939538002,
0.10339822620153427,
0.2984831631183624,
-0.2964861989021301,
-0.05820610746741295,
0.337632954120636,
0.31072288751602173,
-0.2599799335002899,
-0.49190112948417664,
-0.41136422753334045,
0.02000911720097065,
0.25207728147506714,
0.1293487697839737,
0.5222676396369934,
-0.32098153233528137,
-0.20844285190105438,
-0.17446288466453552,
-0.5122166872024536,
0.4885195195674896,
0.07080220431089401,
-0.08685677498579025,
0.24638201296329498,
0.6750605702400208,
-0.4961504638195038,
1.0795400142669678,
0.06068183481693268,
-0.04920453578233719,
0.023945534601807594,
-0.44689151644706726,
-0.2325119972229004,
-0.4278220534324646,
0.4022403061389923,
0.6678382158279419,
0.44833609461784363,
-0.0399356335401535,
0.18810053169727325,
-0.08075825870037079,
0.3569692373275757,
-0.7518015503883362,
-0.38667699694633484,
-0.014116561971604824,
-0.20493970811367035,
-0.32828289270401,
-0.021967733278870583,
-0.7932804226875305,
-0.21522463858127594,
-0.35308530926704407,
0.8129392266273499,
-0.5283765196800232,
-0.11267433315515518,
0.21580642461776733,
-0.4311075210571289,
0.5203548669815063,
0.5881530046463013,
-0.577224612236023,
0.11317645013332367,
0.1890878826379776,
0.2046230137348175,
0.1462867707014084,
0.009355144575238228,
-0.5751923322677612,
0.25847893953323364,
-0.4458317160606384,
0.76871258020401,
-0.7593345642089844,
0.20715339481830597,
-0.08624432235956192,
-0.059741318225860596,
0.18688765168190002,
-0.4854777753353119,
-0.12024538218975067,
-1.1459031105041504,
0.11573702841997147,
-0.8296031951904297,
-0.2987125515937805,
-0.535081684589386,
0.39001595973968506,
-0.7357364892959595,
0.9875034689903259,
0.14862827956676483,
-0.529288113117218,
0.5336910486221313,
-0.46225783228874207,
0.058049146085977554,
0.347758948802948,
-0.30837327241897583,
0.04490929841995239,
-0.13954408466815948,
0.7503710389137268,
0.38190245628356934,
-0.15903331339359283,
0.22055047750473022,
-0.34402361512184143,
-0.14262907207012177,
0.27391526103019714,
-0.33969974517822266,
0.42111992835998535,
0.07771962881088257,
-0.24304671585559845,
-0.0803995132446289,
-0.8020168542861938,
0.27000465989112854,
0.24348394572734833,
-0.2259773463010788,
-0.46544215083122253,
-0.2475840300321579,
-0.4710436761379242,
0.2760952413082123,
0.1869111955165863,
-0.5660988688468933,
0.14378133416175842,
-0.14557327330112457,
0.25366565585136414,
0.4461592435836792,
0.1864842027425766,
0.3963698744773865,
-0.038652826100587845,
0.5481782555580139,
0.0033434126526117325,
0.25257378816604614,
-0.17083445191383362,
-0.6716875433921814,
-0.8153108358383179,
-0.5325568914413452,
0.20264552533626556,
0.6107562780380249,
-1.6749624013900757,
-0.2565481662750244,
-0.4139726758003235,
-0.5658735632896423,
-0.5975265502929688,
0.1258333921432495,
0.3505410850048065,
0.7605950236320496,
0.4204646348953247,
-0.1441420018672943,
-0.29249224066734314,
-0.9988633394241333,
-0.2430933564901352,
-0.21939750015735626,
0.14981845021247864,
0.5746771097183228,
0.41899895668029785,
0.3060719072818756,
0.9677496552467346,
-0.890891432762146,
0.14991983771324158,
-0.10215100646018982,
-0.08901319652795792,
-0.16385367512702942,
0.016695018857717514,
0.5717730522155762,
-1.1597553491592407,
-0.6830013394355774,
-0.13176202774047852,
-1.0126724243164062,
0.06243523210287094,
0.0389932356774807,
-0.30560702085494995,
-0.046050164848566055,
0.5409450531005859,
-0.5616987347602844,
0.5227683782577515,
0.24041208624839783,
-0.2747960090637207,
0.42442068457603455,
0.0019389304798096418,
0.5766712427139282,
-0.9137647747993469,
-0.04507668316364288,
-0.24863898754119873,
-0.31827786564826965,
-0.7540598511695862,
0.41890355944633484,
0.3269568681716919,
-0.0061142100021243095,
-0.5913578271865845,
0.5457216501235962,
-0.4073760211467743,
0.18078522384166718,
-0.061907809227705,
0.11530141532421112,
0.282092422246933,
0.5627163648605347,
0.16459503769874573,
0.6547626256942749,
0.6747740507125854,
-0.4329356849193573,
0.7508763670921326,
0.41013845801353455,
-0.47551631927490234,
0.4787595868110657,
-0.635163426399231,
0.0980907529592514,
-0.41288620233535767,
-0.1499532163143158,
-1.2447439432144165,
-0.4233418405056,
0.17692002654075623,
-0.4921177327632904,
0.29249462485313416,
-0.23083648085594177,
-0.5011036992073059,
-0.5212152600288391,
-0.08588279038667679,
0.5022647976875305,
0.4937751293182373,
-0.6263270974159241,
0.8693202137947083,
0.3784383535385132,
-0.1856115609407425,
-0.8307349681854248,
-0.6541512608528137,
0.07045727968215942,
-0.050466135144233704,
-0.9085434079170227,
0.034126926213502884,
-0.0022115844767540693,
-0.36380821466445923,
0.13296298682689667,
-0.07693331688642502,
-0.435409814119339,
0.007266984321177006,
-0.04314438998699188,
0.3406577706336975,
-0.2652393579483032,
0.32170459628105164,
-0.12707948684692383,
0.28235453367233276,
0.055681806057691574,
-0.22315767407417297,
0.28709736466407776,
-0.3820779025554657,
-0.2847524881362915,
-0.2719988226890564,
0.44648244976997375,
0.6950251460075378,
-0.45740094780921936,
0.6633642315864563,
0.5143222808837891,
-0.3416593670845032,
0.316872775554657,
-0.7603738307952881,
-0.0994768738746643,
-0.5089029669761658,
0.5362796187400818,
-0.6150780916213989,
-0.9534299373626709,
0.4604348838329315,
0.38037434220314026,
-0.26524481177330017,
0.19704201817512512,
0.5216444730758667,
-0.32806721329689026,
1.0042486190795898,
0.7494569420814514,
0.6322235465049744,
0.48123490810394287,
-0.03695543855428696,
0.07945725321769714,
-0.43480855226516724,
-0.5195647478103638,
0.03163926675915718,
-0.0592312328517437,
-0.4748798906803131,
-0.6096950173377991,
0.5703105926513672,
0.050063639879226685,
-0.11236611008644104,
0.1483006775379181,
-0.34301963448524475,
0.5377402901649475,
0.6796492338180542,
0.43186450004577637,
0.3059852123260498,
-0.013674082234501839,
-0.014652609825134277,
-0.08598153293132782,
-0.9228861331939697,
-0.27705898880958557,
0.9653514623641968,
0.22325782477855682,
0.7131606340408325,
0.21106068789958954,
0.1139477863907814,
-0.35651418566703796,
-0.039732009172439575,
-0.6638561487197876,
0.5470713376998901,
0.12529341876506805,
-0.6773508191108704,
-0.45925211906433105,
-0.4454815089702606,
-0.5350648164749146,
0.23408624529838562,
-0.3727172017097473,
-0.5779823660850525,
0.2545025646686554,
0.44059184193611145,
-0.43380048871040344,
0.3280794322490692,
-0.807913064956665,
0.8587934970855713,
-0.269627183675766,
-0.5336288213729858,
0.00306849111802876,
-0.8114354014396667,
0.579556941986084,
-0.005775750149041414,
-0.13155949115753174,
0.18279685080051422,
-0.07471223920583725,
0.47386085987091064,
-0.29859158396720886,
0.6051265597343445,
-0.3180963099002838,
-0.01244249939918518,
0.511741042137146,
-0.030591823160648346,
0.3475150465965271,
-0.04344663769006729,
0.35887444019317627,
-0.18499936163425446,
0.24070720374584198,
-0.565739631652832,
-1.1453222036361694,
0.30935582518577576,
-0.5600788593292236,
-0.7023113965988159,
0.01736580953001976,
-0.870985209941864,
-0.5124796032905579,
0.297689825296402,
-0.17245155572891235,
0.7136584520339966,
0.24232117831707,
0.5221008062362671,
0.8587940335273743,
-0.4752674996852875,
0.21939510107040405,
0.4106471836566925,
-0.2288045734167099,
-0.6385948061943054,
0.7845292687416077,
0.2578732967376709,
0.6420089602470398,
0.6615919470787048,
0.09132345765829086,
-0.46900299191474915,
-0.20809192955493927,
-0.7288357615470886,
0.11178498715162277,
-1.1598793268203735,
-0.12179865688085556,
-1.0260851383209229,
0.035338785499334335,
-0.44295600056648254,
0.018430525436997414,
-0.18659022450447083,
-0.5391772985458374,
-0.025843476876616478,
-0.05578649789094925,
0.6044493317604065,
0.6282926797866821,
0.24106429517269135,
0.009398375637829304,
-0.8539678454399109,
0.7877213954925537,
1.1652523279190063,
0.39613741636276245,
-0.07770174741744995,
-0.3652960956096649,
0.03673528879880905,
0.06337028741836548,
-0.06952207535505295,
-1.1077138185501099,
0.1509428322315216,
0.0009570657275617123,
0.5588436126708984,
0.06465113162994385,
-0.0174697395414114,
1.0908687114715576,
-0.46442922949790955,
0.7874875664710999,
0.13229435682296753,
-0.6422033309936523,
0.39391031861305237,
-0.4536972939968109,
0.6879596710205078,
0.6295719146728516,
0.4095151722431183,
-0.3312082290649414,
-0.3360536992549896,
-0.44204428791999817,
-0.7256549596786499,
0.4163719117641449,
0.15780693292617798,
0.07602501660585403,
0.11934822052717209,
0.4403071105480194,
-0.111802838742733,
0.3629355728626251,
-0.6247604489326477,
-0.16471469402313232,
-0.5604325532913208,
-0.3558376729488373,
0.3745158314704895,
-0.36841654777526855,
-0.0008389423019252717,
-0.6381891369819641,
0.4784388840198517,
-0.30558255314826965,
0.35075002908706665,
0.13738921284675598,
-0.3616148829460144,
0.06616199016571045,
-0.04032948240637779,
0.3718987703323364,
0.6944378018379211,
-0.09000594168901443,
0.19866037368774414,
0.33807650208473206,
-0.42735719680786133,
-0.11887076497077942,
0.044652245938777924,
-0.14963403344154358,
-0.37975847721099854,
0.2724032998085022,
0.777611494064331,
-0.08636224269866943,
-0.8078382611274719,
0.6600670218467712,
-0.3226202130317688,
-0.2475312203168869,
-0.09145960211753845,
0.03158438578248024,
0.1402200162410736,
0.4495425224304199,
0.3448883891105652,
0.04197447746992111,
0.09640513360500336,
-0.5957492589950562,
0.3048131465911865,
0.5630942583084106,
-0.698179304599762,
0.022510642185807228,
0.5828809142112732,
0.03632187843322754,
0.09457254409790039,
0.3979749381542206,
0.21723683178424835,
-0.6080338954925537,
0.6737929582595825,
0.2175256609916687,
0.25690555572509766,
0.1409921646118164,
0.17834922671318054,
0.25077372789382935,
0.3973144292831421,
0.32682687044143677,
0.8642575740814209,
-0.19887542724609375,
-0.7473872303962708,
-0.6025398969650269,
-0.2921668589115143,
-0.2657802700996399,
0.05664395913481712,
-0.761172890663147,
0.133406862616539,
-0.05860920250415802,
0.19594654440879822,
0.04586717113852501,
-0.21040774881839752,
-0.8052100539207458,
0.4149666726589203,
0.28877902030944824,
0.8837650418281555,
-0.6433685421943665,
0.676257312297821,
0.7275393009185791,
-0.6690469980239868,
-1.02077054977417,
-0.0788169801235199,
-0.3674147427082062,
-0.8943813443183899,
0.7257291078567505,
0.11809452623128891,
-0.1591445803642273,
0.12527869641780853,
-0.8704018592834473,
-1.1922721862792969,
1.068100929260254,
0.512341320514679,
0.035919591784477234,
0.0775785893201828,
0.21118201315402985,
0.4918373227119446,
-0.04237948730587959,
0.3023751378059387,
0.4697309732437134,
0.5818326473236084,
0.38137489557266235,
-0.6143487691879272,
0.10549035668373108,
-0.429735004901886,
-0.10121428221464157,
0.11704660207033157,
-0.4696403741836548,
0.4099130630493164,
-0.274593710899353,
-0.11139494925737381,
0.029801417142152786,
0.7500635981559753,
0.08078399300575256,
-0.11123348772525787,
0.5151859521865845,
0.31866055727005005,
0.6961231827735901,
-0.2211689054965973,
1.0521214008331299,
-0.14333999156951904,
-0.08728402107954025,
1.0341533422470093,
0.057674210518598557,
0.6899347305297852,
0.6447592973709106,
0.14197680354118347,
0.45607906579971313,
0.34808796644210815,
0.07244601845741272,
0.6145412921905518,
-0.14164358377456665,
-0.08209299296140671,
-0.8045243620872498,
-0.09086574614048004,
-0.13069774210453033,
0.760886013507843,
0.12146668136119843,
-0.18002080917358398,
-0.09676233679056168,
0.130651593208313,
-0.2933574616909027,
0.18520769476890564,
-0.2557556927204132,
0.8371714949607849,
-0.15920385718345642,
-0.8591459393501282,
0.6639167070388794,
-0.43474745750427246,
0.13116541504859924,
-0.5177178382873535,
-0.2948838472366333,
0.09253112226724625,
0.023375289514660835,
0.2296009063720703,
-1.1106021404266357,
0.1922173649072647,
-0.07998239994049072,
-0.3483813405036926,
-0.13318480551242828,
0.7978405952453613,
-0.7281511425971985,
-0.5860635042190552,
-0.011904812417924404,
0.7003381252288818,
-0.18651440739631653,
-0.17848750948905945,
-0.5162009000778198,
-0.26291623711586,
-0.06298118084669113,
-0.02851835824549198,
-0.06769553571939468,
0.5787138342857361,
-0.07733411341905594,
0.9216324090957642,
0.4302555024623871,
-0.3231653571128845,
0.24960064888000488,
-0.13308067619800568,
0.9716705083847046,
-0.4359053671360016,
-0.333757221698761,
-0.6086187362670898,
0.7619038820266724,
-0.30621713399887085,
-0.01483613159507513,
0.7295428514480591,
0.11109049618244171,
0.4817744791507721,
-0.28203779458999634,
0.6782176494598389,
-0.0435551293194294,
0.20450839400291443,
-0.5831488966941833,
0.5814288854598999,
-0.8998287916183472,
-0.1436016708612442,
-0.42507991194725037,
-0.49925845861434937,
-0.4544914960861206,
0.2500723600387573,
-0.44283437728881836,
-0.1348598301410675,
0.6364258527755737,
0.8723856806755066,
0.08406838029623032,
-0.07789263129234314,
0.5731474161148071,
0.12458053231239319,
0.2570710778236389,
0.5377644300460815,
1.0829322338104248,
-0.4608781039714813,
0.9105929732322693,
-0.41221559047698975,
-0.2820868194103241,
0.0724756047129631,
-0.7770782709121704,
-0.7586958408355713,
-0.657683253288269,
-0.29420605301856995,
-0.11621006578207016,
0.06728921085596085,
0.4896588623523712,
0.644797146320343,
-0.4206070899963379,
0.35259607434272766,
0.2083984911441803,
-0.03195091709494591,
-0.28822582960128784,
-0.22879518568515778,
0.336834579706192,
-0.21996928751468658,
-0.46908247470855713,
0.25633054971694946,
0.3868350684642792,
0.027883009985089302,
-0.03155643865466118,
0.26634758710861206,
-0.40548351407051086,
0.24815359711647034,
0.7423258423805237,
0.03823704272508621,
-0.6066442131996155,
-0.6283748745918274,
0.5051665306091309,
0.03241259977221489,
0.17806407809257507,
0.2659353017807007,
-0.8724220395088196,
0.9266090393066406,
0.6998514533042908,
0.7790601849555969,
0.5758466720581055,
0.148548886179924,
0.713812530040741,
-0.7026426196098328,
-0.08123888075351715,
0.11530270427465439,
0.24541965126991272,
0.43596699833869934,
-0.38657593727111816,
0.2361864298582077,
0.2802727222442627,
-0.23183289170265198,
-0.5384877920150757,
0.45547160506248474,
-0.9605631232261658,
-0.3716050982475281,
1.2621967792510986,
-0.011614209972321987,
-0.4701864719390869,
-0.3214791417121887,
-0.282280296087265,
0.22912748157978058,
0.02961043082177639,
0.4606015384197235,
0.7046554088592529,
0.07844052463769913,
-0.5146303176879883,
-0.6230833530426025,
0.4519685208797455,
0.3166925311088562,
-0.7911308407783508,
-0.1044342964887619,
0.6751924157142639,
0.43638747930526733,
0.07109212875366211,
0.553670346736908,
-0.20878800749778748,
0.6868122816085815,
-0.01456117257475853,
0.16705219447612762,
-0.28048622608184814,
-0.4443398118019104,
-0.05893939360976219,
0.47375333309173584,
-0.006357905920594931,
-0.304319828748703
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09988v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09988v1
|
Details Make a Difference: Object State-Sensitive Neurorobotic Task Planning
| 2024-06-14T12:52:42 | 2024-06-14T12:52:42 |
Xiaowen Sun, Xufeng Zhao, Jae Hee Lee, Wenhao Lu, Matthias Kerzel, Stefan Wermter
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.RO
|
The state of an object reflects its current status or condition and is
important for a robot's task planning and manipulation. However, detecting an
object's state and generating a state-sensitive plan for robots is challenging.
Recently, pre-trained Large Language Models (LLMs) and Vision-Language Models
(VLMs) have shown impressive capabilities in generating plans. However, to the
best of our knowledge, there is hardly any investigation on whether LLMs or
VLMs can also generate object state-sensitive plans. To study this, we
introduce an Object State-Sensitive Agent (OSSA), a task-planning agent
empowered by pre-trained neural networks. We propose two methods for OSSA: (i)
a modular model consisting of a pre-trained vision processing module (dense
captioning model, DCM) and a natural language processing model (LLM), and (ii)
a monolithic model consisting only of a VLM. To quantitatively evaluate the
performances of the two methods, we use tabletop scenarios where the task is to
clear the table. We contribute a multimodal benchmark dataset that takes object
states into consideration. Our results show that both methods can be used for
object state-sensitive tasks, but the monolithic approach outperforms the
modular approach. The code for OSSA is available at
\url{https://github.com/Xiao-wen-Sun/OSSA}
|
[
-0.24031127989292145,
-0.691186249256134,
0.49853718280792236,
-0.3048824965953827,
-0.18219250440597534,
-0.30040472745895386,
-0.17451873421669006,
-0.5205382108688354,
0.29546213150024414,
0.49532032012939453,
-0.6419307589530945,
-0.32869359850883484,
-0.5878477096557617,
0.1261691451072693,
-0.24119317531585693,
0.6663875579833984,
0.13224388659000397,
-0.3354684114456177,
-0.15579362213611603,
-0.008628170937299728,
-0.42447128891944885,
-0.5109161138534546,
-0.4304160475730896,
-0.26999378204345703,
0.5751355290412903,
0.21933585405349731,
0.6416905522346497,
0.38790321350097656,
0.5410258769989014,
0.3464966416358948,
-0.043065302073955536,
0.17402136325836182,
0.006178075913339853,
0.15292198956012726,
-0.44939252734184265,
-0.5768067240715027,
-0.8270485401153564,
-0.5522080659866333,
-0.03090391866862774,
0.34501180052757263,
-0.1701744645833969,
0.17365379631519318,
-0.27761781215667725,
0.5898653268814087,
-1.1823002099990845,
0.44276267290115356,
-0.9811537265777588,
0.3422606885433197,
-0.06017226353287697,
0.13891512155532837,
-0.5407719016075134,
0.41110026836395264,
-0.041983045637607574,
-0.5849130153656006,
0.21279726922512054,
-0.11965882778167725,
0.9197618961334229,
0.5241336822509766,
-0.21581870317459106,
-0.005603446159511805,
-0.7538846135139465,
0.6441736221313477,
-0.6349775195121765,
0.2636532783508301,
0.35741686820983887,
0.29898449778556824,
-0.12196367233991623,
-0.6439991593360901,
-0.8466379046440125,
-0.4147871434688568,
-0.0497719943523407,
0.0038979037199169397,
-0.22822192311286926,
-0.029406335204839706,
0.6125420928001404,
-0.33608749508857727,
-0.5198951363563538,
0.16559039056301117,
-0.3162843585014343,
-0.4011439085006714,
0.5208365321159363,
0.4183153212070465,
0.146974116563797,
-0.55012446641922,
-0.8467476963996887,
-0.20492970943450928,
-0.47981810569763184,
0.1819322407245636,
0.170364111661911,
0.6615856885910034,
0.19984839856624603,
0.7385791540145874,
-0.42894482612609863,
1.1411093473434448,
-0.255558580160141,
-0.22957618534564972,
0.16164518892765045,
-0.15404553711414337,
-0.30891162157058716,
-0.05465378239750862,
0.8217016458511353,
0.29119300842285156,
0.36303001642227173,
-0.09870964288711548,
-0.6559599041938782,
0.40752893686294556,
0.8599973320960999,
-0.7049896121025085,
-0.19324399530887604,
0.31324076652526855,
-0.3231944143772125,
0.1363593190908432,
-0.09121590852737427,
-0.21437077224254608,
-0.32695135474205017,
-0.38559484481811523,
0.7120307683944702,
-0.2945036292076111,
-0.32708752155303955,
0.09895027428865433,
0.09650534391403198,
-0.1525658518075943,
0.34717920422554016,
-0.6814305782318115,
0.26035138964653015,
0.4298357665538788,
0.5666738748550415,
-0.25753918290138245,
-0.4900493323802948,
-0.31131500005722046,
0.36574026942253113,
-0.45849353075027466,
0.7756274342536926,
-0.22153924405574799,
-0.08872334659099579,
0.11878407001495361,
0.021979626268148422,
-0.06823617219924927,
-0.6818667054176331,
-0.06775883585214615,
-0.4160167872905731,
-0.4271959960460663,
-0.2615971863269806,
0.08111551403999329,
-0.2883100211620331,
0.6256994605064392,
-0.8488106727600098,
0.6941419243812561,
0.19433927536010742,
-0.3777238428592682,
0.851120114326477,
-0.6648584604263306,
-0.7807995676994324,
-0.19086198508739471,
-0.20126962661743164,
-0.4033554494380951,
-0.2535537779331207,
0.20451049506664276,
0.896163821220398,
0.0954422801733017,
0.20184063911437988,
-0.11777029931545258,
-0.030916426330804825,
0.18451566994190216,
0.04159002751111984,
0.19924086332321167,
0.17091667652130127,
-0.2789803743362427,
0.660252571105957,
-0.3728002607822418,
-0.01689535193145275,
0.2005159556865692,
-0.186424121260643,
0.09344757348299026,
0.36961057782173157,
-0.15022236108779907,
0.42271631956100464,
0.3859848380088806,
-0.5627608299255371,
-0.029437487944960594,
0.008251484483480453,
0.4242178499698639,
0.7013611793518066,
-0.3777675926685333,
0.3270009160041809,
-0.14319245517253876,
0.5311978459358215,
0.008224493823945522,
0.3314393162727356,
-0.06741110980510712,
-0.20002561807632446,
-0.5853037238121033,
-0.259396493434906,
-0.3659443259239197,
0.4959687292575836,
-1.074262261390686,
0.26343366503715515,
-0.023039665073156357,
-0.4040120244026184,
0.1525201052427292,
-0.19118519127368927,
0.5929004549980164,
0.7457455396652222,
0.45766735076904297,
-0.41967397928237915,
-0.026958394795656204,
-1.0188007354736328,
-0.07361176609992981,
-0.18288324773311615,
0.01649833470582962,
0.14172649383544922,
0.6509369611740112,
0.4826086759567261,
0.7284885048866272,
-0.6494461297988892,
-0.727090060710907,
-0.40968137979507446,
-0.1441040337085724,
0.034983694553375244,
0.29227638244628906,
0.480874627828598,
-0.7322521805763245,
-0.19753794372081757,
-0.029572168365120888,
-0.6204373240470886,
0.4828948378562927,
0.1122506707906723,
-0.027330519631505013,
0.5383466482162476,
0.7199455499649048,
-0.7374719381332397,
0.8354113101959229,
0.3062274158000946,
-0.26021674275398254,
0.34905776381492615,
-0.2094176709651947,
-0.08594032377004623,
-0.8611582517623901,
0.2718752324581146,
-0.13731737434864044,
-0.2173825204372406,
-0.800367534160614,
0.07358536124229431,
0.17864176630973816,
-0.39104336500167847,
-0.8422242403030396,
0.35061463713645935,
-0.6800754070281982,
-0.27744919061660767,
-0.7416968941688538,
-0.022683212533593178,
-0.32137393951416016,
0.8660390973091125,
0.4530240297317505,
0.45581308007240295,
0.5476722717285156,
-0.8224707245826721,
-0.12274441868066788,
0.2754744291305542,
-0.18764068186283112,
0.48540201783180237,
-0.551110029220581,
0.23386012017726898,
-0.0655517652630806,
0.08657907694578171,
-0.5267860889434814,
-0.09084825217723846,
0.6280797719955444,
-0.11342836171388626,
0.35175710916519165,
-0.03675418347120285,
-0.35131213068962097,
-0.3488861322402954,
0.05514376983046532,
0.2542038559913635,
0.15816955268383026,
-0.11486639082431793,
0.882462739944458,
0.5449872016906738,
-0.0008904660353437066,
-0.8127652406692505,
-0.6553851366043091,
-0.15038591623306274,
0.3024616837501526,
-0.33421701192855835,
0.17486572265625,
0.20815542340278625,
0.11885152012109756,
0.22795972228050232,
-0.6234383583068848,
-0.23605655133724213,
0.22488634288311005,
0.4022599756717682,
0.38904091715812683,
0.01179550215601921,
-0.07805387675762177,
-0.12228412926197052,
-0.3080582320690155,
0.17978262901306152,
0.12798039615154266,
0.9662860631942749,
-0.10064489394426346,
-0.5357885956764221,
-0.5482978820800781,
-0.01443567406386137,
0.3340665102005005,
-0.6853723526000977,
0.356999009847641,
0.3540284335613251,
-0.5789093971252441,
-0.5443076491355896,
0.07465660572052002,
-0.47593119740486145,
-0.4511151611804962,
0.7721502184867859,
-0.546866238117218,
-0.3159836530685425,
0.2256184220314026,
0.24205464124679565,
0.01283236499875784,
0.2057187259197235,
0.37653791904449463,
0.27190446853637695,
0.8164129853248596,
0.48189714550971985,
-0.06159636005759239,
0.5019709467887878,
-0.3342701494693756,
0.10063670575618744,
-0.8367390036582947,
-0.3941750228404999,
-0.487604558467865,
-0.6482338309288025,
-0.1024336963891983,
-0.4055335223674774,
0.1769031584262848,
-0.3420161008834839,
-0.11082810908555984,
0.8875550627708435,
-0.7047609090805054,
0.24821822345256805,
0.33564141392707825,
0.46497300267219543,
-0.05558739975094795,
-0.21656998991966248,
0.507534921169281,
0.4256637990474701,
-0.7307382822036743,
-0.6752513647079468,
0.9719448089599609,
-0.204509899020195,
0.6425580978393555,
-0.2337043434381485,
0.15672807395458221,
0.12422285974025726,
0.011607799679040909,
-0.7746257185935974,
1.1638984680175781,
-0.3792831301689148,
-0.9206464290618896,
-0.6871209144592285,
-0.1017477884888649,
-1.1004817485809326,
0.3810986578464508,
-0.3386366069316864,
-0.9082861542701721,
0.2867310047149658,
0.34297460317611694,
-0.23177240788936615,
0.6381248235702515,
-0.5296384692192078,
0.9436713457107544,
-0.2494858205318451,
-0.25958698987960815,
-0.1839544177055359,
-0.5170757174491882,
-0.14113108813762665,
0.09153459966182709,
-0.27497735619544983,
-0.7045577168464661,
-0.33277109265327454,
0.4784037470817566,
-0.1041644737124443,
0.7810570001602173,
-0.41608676314353943,
0.03688801825046539,
0.23205450177192688,
0.4659726619720459,
0.5844626426696777,
-0.12865279614925385,
-0.14146628975868225,
0.27296072244644165,
-0.3094140291213989,
-0.3937845528125763,
-0.3343223035335541,
0.3363266587257385,
-0.2898768484592438,
-0.5256101489067078,
-0.3948696255683899,
-1.1006983518600464,
-0.13295327126979828,
0.42459359765052795,
0.09164226800203323,
0.3982701897621155,
-0.010425240732729435,
-0.030300356447696686,
0.3365943431854248,
-0.11879126727581024,
0.754036009311676,
0.7380573153495789,
-0.23445791006088257,
0.33799830079078674,
0.9451218247413635,
0.26052626967430115,
0.5781881809234619,
0.5356806516647339,
-0.10146559029817581,
0.10906153917312622,
-0.705543577671051,
-0.36634358763694763,
-0.18641585111618042,
-0.3893555998802185,
-0.17980074882507324,
-0.3810429275035858,
-0.07245860248804092,
-0.05606108903884888,
-0.22938476502895355,
-0.5781227350234985,
-0.06124386936426163,
-0.12157721072435379,
0.07330629974603653,
0.051666077226400375,
0.6918612122535706,
0.0720035508275032,
0.05310719460248947,
-0.2213849425315857,
0.809433102607727,
0.2883784770965576,
-0.0017917839577421546,
-0.17601235210895538,
-0.0313015878200531,
0.31590473651885986,
-0.1206507608294487,
0.1022581234574318,
-0.6614823341369629,
0.39311984181404114,
-0.0023391651920974255,
0.4654465615749359,
0.4186399281024933,
0.22583100199699402,
0.41378146409988403,
-0.30734655261039734,
0.5822373628616333,
0.2473268210887909,
-0.6597086191177368,
0.7503054141998291,
-0.13269631564617157,
0.4565427303314209,
0.4313940405845642,
0.32463574409484863,
-0.06827931851148605,
-0.5980708003044128,
-0.3259405195713043,
-0.9263389110565186,
1.2797715663909912,
0.05445093289017677,
0.1535070240497589,
-0.036646828055381775,
-0.08623545616865158,
0.25963446497917175,
0.4972016513347626,
-0.5538639426231384,
-0.033076211810112,
-0.11530782282352448,
0.10941261053085327,
-0.0997333899140358,
0.04827297106385231,
-0.1551622450351715,
0.1417083740234375,
0.24091732501983643,
-0.2933187186717987,
0.3337230682373047,
0.12689168751239777,
-0.35516640543937683,
0.04500816389918327,
0.0352482870221138,
0.7427304983139038,
0.8100903630256653,
-0.18641985952854156,
0.1272936314344406,
0.1623525619506836,
-0.6390824913978577,
-0.12788063287734985,
-0.004558693617582321,
-0.391043484210968,
-0.2274802327156067,
0.270455002784729,
0.7861831784248352,
-0.044810499995946884,
-0.7576045989990234,
0.49232161045074463,
0.11617520451545715,
-0.1889360100030899,
-0.24902406334877014,
0.4280378520488739,
-0.03890763968229294,
0.1197754293680191,
0.03757248446345329,
0.4748360812664032,
-0.14996805787086487,
-0.5946187376976013,
0.016477445140480995,
0.30133864283561707,
-0.6483986973762512,
-0.37126898765563965,
0.7026984095573425,
-0.005540205631405115,
-0.5619367361068726,
0.5666446089744568,
-0.3279278874397278,
-0.47235894203186035,
1.0524383783340454,
0.6051055788993835,
0.6349664926528931,
-0.09836772084236145,
0.3949720561504364,
0.3422335386276245,
0.6766321659088135,
0.1596391648054123,
0.9043338894844055,
-0.15251661837100983,
-0.8421618342399597,
-0.14157399535179138,
-0.13517579436302185,
-0.23605196177959442,
-0.09655720740556717,
-0.7251414060592651,
-0.030899085104465485,
-0.702659547328949,
-0.35837072134017944,
-0.03710915520787239,
-0.47162550687789917,
-0.706226110458374,
0.2888941168785095,
0.044090405106544495,
0.6279282569885254,
-0.6742353439331055,
0.5758628845214844,
1.041210412979126,
-0.4079831838607788,
-0.8919380307197571,
0.12133265286684036,
-0.17576657235622406,
-0.9236177802085876,
0.6613054871559143,
0.11718859523534775,
-0.37502238154411316,
-0.3773014545440674,
-0.32683345675468445,
-0.8309495449066162,
1.0157420635223389,
0.5824649930000305,
-0.4927545189857483,
0.16058845818042755,
0.1384253203868866,
0.25029700994491577,
0.06906658411026001,
0.042346496134996414,
0.07074843347072601,
0.47032028436660767,
-0.3831082582473755,
-0.9361989498138428,
0.3096487820148468,
-0.08933238685131073,
-0.2206823080778122,
0.734921395778656,
-0.7233495116233826,
1.1679779291152954,
-0.2823985517024994,
-0.28388458490371704,
-0.0868324264883995,
0.6226121783256531,
0.2021002471446991,
0.3833674192428589,
1.0611577033996582,
0.4808998703956604,
0.4636424481868744,
-0.164626806974411,
1.008630633354187,
-0.22500158846378326,
-0.2440708428621292,
1.0719382762908936,
-0.6828420758247375,
1.0623613595962524,
0.4543631374835968,
0.04438873752951622,
0.3326256573200226,
0.0050074211321771145,
-0.00033032515784725547,
0.460936039686203,
0.1931173950433731,
-0.016840655356645584,
-0.5029491186141968,
-0.26185181736946106,
-0.10417061299085617,
0.6316068768501282,
0.1125853955745697,
0.04376331716775894,
-0.14147354662418365,
0.4052547812461853,
0.05460694059729576,
0.2604547142982483,
-0.4307243227958679,
0.5470626950263977,
-0.08002430200576782,
-0.7601007223129272,
0.10716051608324051,
-0.32639044523239136,
0.41474175453186035,
-0.8065351843833923,
0.09248913079500198,
0.1487967073917389,
0.3159356415271759,
-0.2285572737455368,
-0.8928356766700745,
0.14162661135196686,
0.02267693541944027,
-0.1696537286043167,
-0.1324070692062378,
0.9831737279891968,
-0.022961482405662537,
-0.03854629397392273,
0.3222784399986267,
0.2417985200881958,
0.12839387357234955,
-0.39254966378211975,
-0.5027615427970886,
-0.025688311085104942,
-0.29475006461143494,
-0.414179265499115,
0.3708077073097229,
0.028734605759382248,
-0.29868534207344055,
0.9442590475082397,
0.5874488353729248,
0.03790833428502083,
0.0650828629732132,
-0.12845122814178467,
0.7451615929603577,
-0.49542519450187683,
-0.27016374468803406,
-0.34501588344573975,
0.533999502658844,
0.09853260964155197,
-0.6620076298713684,
0.2534424960613251,
0.41183894872665405,
1.1590229272842407,
-0.3779084384441376,
0.17104361951351166,
-0.5481194853782654,
0.12590156495571136,
-0.6188574433326721,
0.7740747928619385,
-0.7544916868209839,
-0.18429240584373474,
-0.0926085039973259,
-0.7362574934959412,
0.07020388543605804,
0.4169789254665375,
-0.26180627942085266,
-0.0025100966449826956,
0.7626549005508423,
1.0266544818878174,
-0.007845769636332989,
-0.4505610466003418,
0.3746592402458191,
-0.18456055223941803,
0.03170204907655716,
0.7074742317199707,
0.9423544406890869,
0.01387509424239397,
0.7387488484382629,
-0.5197718143463135,
0.20332388579845428,
-0.10291754454374313,
-0.674213707447052,
-0.8660411238670349,
-0.6554769277572632,
-0.2305782288312912,
0.11940138787031174,
0.16419433057308197,
0.4590461850166321,
1.0283944606781006,
-0.5298522114753723,
-0.2050907164812088,
-0.018019236624240875,
-0.037846796214580536,
-0.4634660482406616,
-0.11986661702394485,
0.34705767035484314,
-0.27064621448516846,
-0.7901486158370972,
0.6257023811340332,
0.25313588976860046,
-0.3731711208820343,
-0.10336319357156754,
-0.05156945809721947,
-0.2504287660121918,
-0.1307155042886734,
0.679888129234314,
0.4552115201950073,
-0.7643587589263916,
-0.21219377219676971,
0.1294906735420227,
-0.31856319308280945,
-0.03544772043824196,
0.6097134947776794,
-0.6429460048675537,
0.5925212502479553,
0.3880338966846466,
0.0682208463549614,
0.5758289694786072,
-0.15627995133399963,
0.36122336983680725,
-0.5320556163787842,
0.6151008605957031,
0.5454908013343811,
0.3182835280895233,
-0.11191476136445999,
-0.15501642227172852,
0.4865540862083435,
-0.3396187424659729,
-0.34793031215667725,
-0.6816610097885132,
0.5585346221923828,
-1.2747429609298706,
-0.726065993309021,
0.8522423505783081,
0.04190522059798241,
-0.7888193130493164,
0.1878531128168106,
-0.402521014213562,
0.10482281446456909,
-0.41996416449546814,
0.6847575306892395,
0.0847870409488678,
-0.3273176848888397,
0.28742143511772156,
-0.48433154821395874,
0.28478002548217773,
0.5114657878875732,
-0.9955599904060364,
-0.20217657089233398,
0.4185924232006073,
0.0460810661315918,
0.39135682582855225,
0.5547317862510681,
0.07747004926204681,
0.589219868183136,
0.18799394369125366,
0.7522884607315063,
-0.6471508741378784,
-0.7740406394004822,
0.149129256606102,
0.5143964290618896,
-0.06975936889648438,
-0.7389746308326721
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10313v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10313v1
|
CNVSRC 2023: The First Chinese Continuous Visual Speech Recognition Challenge
| 2024-06-14T12:49:38 | 2024-06-14T12:49:38 |
Chen Chen, Zehua Liu, Xiaolou Li, Lantian Li, Dong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
The first Chinese Continuous Visual Speech Recognition Challenge aimed to
probe the performance of Large Vocabulary Continuous Visual Speech Recognition
(LVC-VSR) on two tasks: (1) Single-speaker VSR for a particular speaker and (2)
Multi-speaker VSR for a set of registered speakers. The challenge yielded
highly successful results, with the best submission significantly outperforming
the baseline, particularly in the single-speaker task. This paper
comprehensively reviews the challenge, encompassing the data profile, task
specifications, and baseline system construction. It also summarises the
representative techniques employed by the submitted systems, highlighting the
most effective approaches. Additional information and resources about this
challenge can be accessed through the official website at
http://cnceleb.org/competition.
|
[
-0.46226930618286133,
-0.22130697965621948,
0.16383664309978485,
0.10680843144655228,
-0.43868309259414673,
0.19027359783649445,
-0.25720858573913574,
-0.3612413704395294,
-0.19895100593566895,
0.7178183794021606,
-0.6393113732337952,
-0.43105801939964294,
-0.349014550447464,
-0.034861382097005844,
-0.565135657787323,
0.6364647746086121,
0.1415221095085144,
0.2591053247451782,
-0.22436131536960602,
-0.18054282665252686,
-0.6124247908592224,
-0.8363843560218811,
-0.6952250599861145,
-0.06739892810583115,
0.9182112812995911,
0.5138990879058838,
0.15983787178993225,
0.6842367053031921,
1.0144634246826172,
0.3458932042121887,
-0.11617404967546463,
0.31533846259117126,
-0.32667189836502075,
-0.187233105301857,
0.27397584915161133,
0.03204108029603958,
-0.24421605467796326,
-0.20872174203395844,
0.7922108173370361,
0.4548704922199249,
-0.2958308458328247,
0.14270447194576263,
0.2047867625951767,
0.5488928556442261,
-0.4970472455024719,
0.005357020068913698,
-0.5259124636650085,
0.18577267229557037,
-0.6971273422241211,
-0.5571302771568298,
-0.5104653239250183,
-0.08177074044942856,
0.3732106387615204,
-0.5718548893928528,
0.21201375126838684,
-0.10380852967500687,
0.7688605785369873,
0.3893674910068512,
-0.5557314157485962,
-0.2991824150085449,
-0.931793212890625,
0.7324107885360718,
-0.2339465320110321,
0.395748108625412,
-0.12803785502910614,
0.7380732893943787,
-0.13425655663013458,
-1.067236065864563,
-0.6975222229957581,
-0.46476155519485474,
0.5097262859344482,
0.20515185594558716,
-0.22068841755390167,
0.18683937191963196,
0.1770067662000656,
0.15780211985111237,
-0.9262562990188599,
0.06950169801712036,
-0.8077481985092163,
-0.3059613108634949,
0.621597409248352,
0.2960355579853058,
0.15193410217761993,
-0.019553253427147865,
-0.5125775933265686,
-0.21172350645065308,
-0.2378290444612503,
0.28792011737823486,
-0.04446595162153244,
0.6251271367073059,
-0.20614556968212128,
0.6891839504241943,
-0.23239077627658844,
0.8413393497467041,
-0.24636432528495789,
-0.3454153835773468,
0.3125300109386444,
-0.7433816194534302,
-0.2746621370315552,
0.3557831048965454,
0.7940698862075806,
0.24953284859657288,
0.3228626251220703,
0.17291584610939026,
-0.03482185676693916,
0.112308569252491,
0.10141260921955109,
-0.23514556884765625,
-0.2296585589647293,
0.26857852935791016,
-0.28561118245124817,
-0.025438375771045685,
0.1227535530924797,
-0.28818386793136597,
-0.20405997335910797,
-0.6862923502922058,
0.2634071409702301,
-0.1810886263847351,
-0.24179799854755402,
-0.01005097758024931,
-0.2528996169567108,
0.605872392654419,
0.7832961678504944,
-0.5081626772880554,
0.4874473810195923,
0.8626100420951843,
0.8904587626457214,
-0.47535812854766846,
-0.16622017323970795,
-0.9501902461051941,
-0.1328611522912979,
-0.24185538291931152,
0.6327687501907349,
-0.06427308917045593,
-0.23646396398544312,
-0.23880326747894287,
-0.022484121844172478,
0.16112187504768372,
-0.5307396650314331,
0.47230249643325806,
-0.2103838324546814,
-0.07769708335399628,
-0.7329232096672058,
-0.09075460582971573,
0.22010330855846405,
0.41572219133377075,
-0.7045638561248779,
0.79921555519104,
-0.0928182452917099,
-0.8311792612075806,
0.4010041356086731,
-0.1759287714958191,
0.19589416682720184,
0.684440016746521,
-0.346332848072052,
-0.35938960313796997,
-0.43310824036598206,
-0.04750576242804527,
0.3318876326084137,
-0.2621346414089203,
0.04270440340042114,
0.03270301967859268,
-0.4509144723415375,
-0.2390599101781845,
-0.5890882611274719,
0.8289837837219238,
0.24498577415943146,
-0.1851615011692047,
0.3809397220611572,
-1.0843266248703003,
0.1879001408815384,
0.3531012237071991,
-0.238500714302063,
-0.0064353300258517265,
0.1252393126487732,
0.29045188426971436,
0.12545153498649597,
0.10382576286792755,
-0.7757033705711365,
0.07681844383478165,
-0.031230773776769638,
0.5022985339164734,
0.5535916090011597,
-0.17673170566558838,
-0.12718398869037628,
-0.008809050545096397,
0.29311349987983704,
-0.06450430303812027,
0.5211402773857117,
0.10456106066703796,
-0.4696144461631775,
-0.8481847047805786,
-0.11246474087238312,
0.2980070114135742,
0.9280436635017395,
-1.182531714439392,
-0.014574866741895676,
-0.28571921586990356,
-0.8800221681594849,
-0.4306774437427521,
0.12132703512907028,
0.4430237114429474,
0.3603934943675995,
0.36735936999320984,
-0.33462339639663696,
-0.9058185815811157,
-0.7502110600471497,
0.3290100395679474,
-0.49744290113449097,
0.025202257558703423,
0.22476524114608765,
0.5310859680175781,
0.2938110828399658,
0.31572169065475464,
0.0694952979683876,
-0.6248233318328857,
-0.31816086173057556,
0.003972634207457304,
-0.04791644588112831,
0.5820462703704834,
0.25881385803222656,
-1.166885495185852,
-0.3065783381462097,
0.5766506791114807,
-0.5963792204856873,
0.34860971570014954,
-0.12105582654476166,
0.36115598678588867,
0.014286837540566921,
0.7534055709838867,
0.1332864910364151,
0.445500910282135,
0.7959467768669128,
0.1585945039987564,
0.7250347137451172,
-0.24235162138938904,
0.08068788796663284,
-0.47155654430389404,
0.0032171548809856176,
0.11097587645053864,
-0.11170665174722672,
-0.7776100039482117,
-0.09810490906238556,
0.00008521024574292824,
0.05647103860974312,
-0.9437525272369385,
0.05812406167387962,
-0.25276127457618713,
0.12521886825561523,
-0.0463888980448246,
0.21543961763381958,
-0.4987986981868744,
0.4076719582080841,
0.10612023621797562,
0.6096776723861694,
0.2527430057525635,
-0.7904146313667297,
1.1106407642364502,
0.15822573006153107,
-0.575328528881073,
0.6241407990455627,
-0.9609019756317139,
0.33640649914741516,
-0.15098096430301666,
-0.03167949244379997,
-1.198021650314331,
-0.10893382132053375,
0.09437612444162369,
-0.8979136943817139,
0.057463210076093674,
0.22016523778438568,
-0.1813073754310608,
-0.7598807215690613,
0.0966455340385437,
0.41213735938072205,
0.17342382669448853,
-0.6540530920028687,
0.2628920376300812,
0.36054980754852295,
-0.048609498888254166,
-0.583376944065094,
-0.9273515939712524,
0.5433696508407593,
-0.12679022550582886,
-0.3551107347011566,
0.4475841820240021,
-0.2346709668636322,
-0.2104470282793045,
-0.32674485445022583,
0.11385798454284668,
0.08202891796827316,
-0.29337412118911743,
-0.02475881017744541,
0.2738020718097687,
-0.4243243932723999,
-0.4138191044330597,
-0.7767147421836853,
-0.1598508656024933,
-0.07833300530910492,
-0.13505934178829193,
0.4325733184814453,
-0.3100968599319458,
-0.5009075403213501,
-0.8584996461868286,
0.2219996601343155,
0.30870741605758667,
-0.3994986414909363,
0.18419314920902252,
0.5868459939956665,
-0.31032779812812805,
0.0735255554318428,
-0.6085836291313171,
0.5426468849182129,
-0.4861910939216614,
0.5796059966087341,
-0.2873929440975189,
-1.068017840385437,
0.1774759590625763,
0.28018122911453247,
-0.012133115902543068,
0.24316909909248352,
0.7321628332138062,
0.07336398959159851,
1.0400874614715576,
0.7135856747627258,
-0.1435718983411789,
0.43853840231895447,
0.10825704783201218,
-0.029645461589097977,
-0.74106764793396,
-1.019930124282837,
-0.8232531547546387,
0.1429491639137268,
-0.8492920398712158,
-0.5466477870941162,
0.5997308492660522,
-0.19479778409004211,
-0.3396427631378174,
0.6272067427635193,
-1.0185061693191528,
0.13512612879276276,
0.7819223403930664,
0.2764188349246979,
0.04779205471277237,
-0.3393814265727997,
0.04010982811450958,
-0.29781731963157654,
-0.7044567465782166,
-0.24656224250793457,
0.5331007242202759,
0.23062093555927277,
0.22882559895515442,
0.07430372387170792,
0.540418803691864,
0.2354854792356491,
-0.21888123452663422,
-0.7624825835227966,
0.6842082738876343,
-0.3378055989742279,
-0.22502011060714722,
-0.4662039577960968,
-0.27066662907600403,
-0.7073593139648438,
0.2003825604915619,
0.08420342952013016,
-0.5616880655288696,
0.3096773028373718,
0.14102937281131744,
-0.2306581735610962,
0.34455111622810364,
-0.09771313518285751,
0.7650957703590393,
-0.6122867465019226,
-0.20245374739170074,
0.4569026231765747,
-1.0850895643234253,
0.3242649734020233,
0.1694592535495758,
0.020327253267169,
0.26722654700279236,
0.024107659235596657,
0.686947762966156,
-0.3564000725746155,
0.37028709053993225,
-0.2707168459892273,
0.3289085626602173,
0.3977263569831848,
-0.4868095815181732,
0.3867134749889374,
-0.2807813584804535,
0.03375919908285141,
-0.18798087537288666,
0.13597792387008667,
-0.45732295513153076,
-0.23108744621276855,
0.3480352759361267,
-0.5081024169921875,
-0.3879762589931488,
-0.8235589861869812,
0.06420736759901047,
0.15714222192764282,
0.35605955123901367,
0.3908286690711975,
0.4934447109699249,
-0.6651855111122131,
0.6895748376846313,
0.7719711661338806,
-0.4545263946056366,
0.28030121326446533,
0.18592333793640137,
-0.022620197385549545,
-0.7874966263771057,
1.1663713455200195,
0.16531287133693695,
0.5116207003593445,
0.6013474464416504,
-0.1494792401790619,
0.11425108462572098,
-0.9626904129981995,
-0.3459867835044861,
-0.03148682415485382,
-0.7186198830604553,
0.15496081113815308,
-0.5352964401245117,
-0.7000288963317871,
-0.41833439469337463,
0.07975047081708908,
-0.603573739528656,
0.1950587034225464,
-0.44692447781562805,
0.33128103613853455,
-0.007555732969194651,
0.7683236002922058,
-0.11799121648073196,
0.10369744896888733,
-0.3554348051548004,
0.5267094969749451,
0.5014311075210571,
0.006096233613789082,
-0.10181505233049393,
-0.5161937475204468,
-0.11408714205026627,
-0.0904066264629364,
-0.1712079793214798,
-0.031732913106679916,
0.5749049186706543,
0.0444183312356472,
0.6242007613182068,
0.3639950752258301,
0.05415266007184982,
1.0004616975784302,
-0.5657346248626709,
1.3248344659805298,
0.45761358737945557,
-0.7936211228370667,
0.5307477116584778,
-0.26485899090766907,
0.46446171402931213,
0.5233951210975647,
0.16707700490951538,
-0.7677404284477234,
-0.09415529668331146,
-0.05935167148709297,
-0.9065588116645813,
0.3882922828197479,
0.1483510583639145,
-0.1268095225095749,
0.10480479151010513,
0.2320529818534851,
-0.35199546813964844,
0.008626219816505909,
-0.5243529677391052,
-0.3809608817100525,
-0.3981446325778961,
0.20341883599758148,
-0.14201101660728455,
-0.1362636238336563,
0.2164863646030426,
-0.6191864609718323,
0.3292314410209656,
-0.23046384751796722,
0.3106023073196411,
0.5708053112030029,
0.38634034991264343,
-0.021605586633086205,
0.1445009559392929,
1.0871635675430298,
0.44381213188171387,
-0.28840458393096924,
-0.07262697070837021,
0.4822690188884735,
-0.6696008443832397,
-0.07439783215522766,
-0.2535771131515503,
0.17054606974124908,
0.11728253215551376,
0.6928446292877197,
1.0694066286087036,
0.05247900262475014,
-0.7598257064819336,
0.7209458351135254,
-0.37361687421798706,
-0.789482593536377,
-0.988034725189209,
-0.034664370119571686,
-0.035902637988328934,
0.3589886426925659,
0.46481645107269287,
0.026691682636737823,
0.11308463662862778,
-0.3409333825111389,
0.198571115732193,
0.44135192036628723,
-0.9465691447257996,
0.07939819991588593,
0.9307824969291687,
-0.1428481936454773,
-0.47273382544517517,
0.5718409419059753,
-0.01221878919750452,
-0.7485783696174622,
0.8721135854721069,
0.2324446737766266,
0.6236564517021179,
-0.4046585261821747,
0.05227045342326164,
0.5646774768829346,
0.4932456314563751,
-0.3036994934082031,
0.48892349004745483,
-0.1736828088760376,
-0.3900609016418457,
-0.3415312170982361,
-0.07166796922683716,
-1.0217758417129517,
0.17236465215682983,
-1.1743245124816895,
0.7192983627319336,
-0.4158755838871002,
0.01922381855547428,
0.2686181664466858,
0.1083759069442749,
-0.6936490535736084,
0.47820401191711426,
0.6839009523391724,
0.9733561277389526,
0.0016515273600816727,
1.0403399467468262,
0.1844954490661621,
-0.1632915735244751,
-0.5176714062690735,
-0.49109235405921936,
0.5511124730110168,
-0.6195005178451538,
0.7103727459907532,
-0.17927202582359314,
-0.3610904812812805,
-0.2373376190662384,
-0.8503931164741516,
-0.8350889682769775,
1.1269018650054932,
0.027575794607400894,
-0.8674914240837097,
-0.12212813645601273,
0.3132695257663727,
0.6021268963813782,
-0.15059563517570496,
-0.09742846339941025,
0.36781904101371765,
0.4938892126083374,
0.5210375189781189,
-1.4587626457214355,
-0.3745724856853485,
-0.5246689319610596,
0.17766770720481873,
-0.27741584181785583,
-0.9621899724006653,
0.9002200365066528,
-0.3606269061565399,
-0.23241764307022095,
0.7071033716201782,
1.062932014465332,
0.5989522337913513,
0.5159811973571777,
0.4973374307155609,
0.003988030832260847,
0.7273489236831665,
-0.32821643352508545,
0.9337173104286194,
0.3625403642654419,
-0.02057526633143425,
1.1554253101348877,
-0.3521865904331207,
1.0548344850540161,
0.5941675901412964,
-0.2716514766216278,
-0.018910203129053116,
0.5616040229797363,
-0.25804123282432556,
0.7199618816375732,
0.5057611465454102,
-0.1616428643465042,
-0.19159290194511414,
-0.363482803106308,
-0.6673598885536194,
0.7878888249397278,
0.23010486364364624,
0.2629905045032501,
0.31982994079589844,
0.3235318660736084,
-0.4752958118915558,
0.037352055311203,
-0.43315446376800537,
0.9575858116149902,
0.0035181171260774136,
-0.5456340909004211,
0.7368484139442444,
-0.29894310235977173,
0.7233186960220337,
-0.844971239566803,
-0.25976353883743286,
0.4008334279060364,
0.46132132411003113,
-0.03597896546125412,
-0.5968233346939087,
0.12580585479736328,
-0.016096090897917747,
0.05493747442960739,
-0.1519155502319336,
0.34144580364227295,
-0.4588170051574707,
-0.37860918045043945,
0.35101667046546936,
-0.044008392840623856,
0.14745426177978516,
-0.0870317593216896,
-0.5594626665115356,
0.5673092007637024,
0.2143104523420334,
-0.13113561272621155,
0.2202182412147522,
0.5503677725791931,
0.10089782625436783,
0.7588023543357849,
0.4483569264411926,
0.4296281933784485,
0.04451533406972885,
0.1814989298582077,
0.9416162371635437,
-0.9360087513923645,
-0.25217205286026,
-0.4774600863456726,
0.5370407700538635,
0.02273888699710369,
-0.5948808789253235,
0.722999632358551,
0.6421172618865967,
1.1962015628814697,
0.26884138584136963,
0.9639211893081665,
0.01856664940714836,
0.6085014939308167,
-0.42704880237579346,
0.3233416676521301,
-0.8105909824371338,
0.022903278470039368,
-0.6214227676391602,
-0.3550058901309967,
-0.7100071310997009,
0.21127216517925262,
0.27585771679878235,
-0.05627136304974556,
0.6014895439147949,
0.5922701358795166,
0.44340524077415466,
0.006380030419677496,
0.49551042914390564,
-0.12739337980747223,
0.4416743516921997,
0.9227768778800964,
0.9199978113174438,
-0.7676892280578613,
0.840587854385376,
-0.5188215374946594,
0.02422916702926159,
-0.14627982676029205,
-0.8241762518882751,
-0.7073311805725098,
-0.9277478456497192,
-0.37351956963539124,
-0.5856017470359802,
0.1535857766866684,
0.9337400794029236,
0.6298837661743164,
-1.1421440839767456,
-0.362853467464447,
0.006745790131390095,
-0.21631859242916107,
-0.5395409464836121,
-0.1149161159992218,
0.25800254940986633,
0.3952799141407013,
-0.7028711438179016,
0.48932236433029175,
0.28754982352256775,
-0.05114586651325226,
-0.3600641191005707,
-0.30890628695487976,
-0.10792206972837448,
-0.4824211597442627,
0.6224779486656189,
0.6733042597770691,
-1.0345287322998047,
-0.49695301055908203,
0.250015527009964,
-0.32589513063430786,
0.226542130112648,
0.9328008890151978,
-0.6524716019630432,
0.6661220788955688,
0.5500198006629944,
0.39318710565567017,
0.5480579137802124,
-0.10967018455266953,
0.23033419251441956,
-0.331432044506073,
0.2543869614601135,
0.45988643169403076,
0.09517577290534973,
0.42786121368408203,
-0.20518282055854797,
0.3703661561012268,
0.3431696593761444,
-0.6858805418014526,
-1.258360505104065,
-0.1126185953617096,
-1.9096543788909912,
0.07026617228984833,
0.7296300530433655,
0.24562549591064453,
-0.2234913557767868,
-0.45247551798820496,
-0.5008547306060791,
0.49405768513679504,
-0.002319422084838152,
0.10166767984628677,
0.6451246738433838,
-0.09055501967668533,
-0.6431629657745361,
-1.0154403448104858,
0.29748299717903137,
-0.06603898853063583,
-0.5162417888641357,
-0.10044358670711517,
0.08815910667181015,
0.16301290690898895,
0.06289558857679367,
0.6982645988464355,
-0.2969313859939575,
0.744005024433136,
0.1370338797569275,
0.2347697913646698,
-0.2573769688606262,
-0.5542172789573669,
-0.2852676212787628,
0.37681901454925537,
-0.023074837401509285,
-0.2538100481033325
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09979v1
|
HIRO: Hierarchical Information Retrieval Optimization
| 2024-06-14T12:41:07 | 2024-06-14T12:41:07 |
Krish Goel, Mahek Chandak
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) excel in natural language tasks but face
limitations due to static training datasets, resulting in outdated or
contextually shallow responses. Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) addresses
this by integrating real-time external knowledge, enhancing model accuracy and
credibility, especially for knowledge-intensive tasks. However, RAG-enhanced
LLMs struggle with long contexts, causing them to "choke" on information
overload, compromising response quality. Recent RAG applications use
hierarchical data structures for storing documents, organized at various levels
of summarization and information density. In this context, we introduce HIRO
(Hierarchical Information Retrieval Optimization), a novel querying approach
for RAG applications using hierarchical structures for storing documents. HIRO
employs DFS-based recursive similarity score calculation and branch pruning to
minimize the context returned to the LLM without informational loss. HIRO
outperforms existing querying mechanisms on the NarrativeQA dataset by an
absolute performance gain of 10.85%.
|
[
-0.3623342514038086,
-0.8181946873664856,
0.33526134490966797,
0.11937727779150009,
-0.06290174275636673,
0.5244154930114746,
0.0023636550176888704,
-0.4307534694671631,
0.2451225370168686,
0.5460788011550903,
-0.4419350326061249,
-0.44603949785232544,
-0.35096538066864014,
-0.07723446935415268,
-0.0947626456618309,
1.0870919227600098,
0.2221340537071228,
-0.35183751583099365,
-0.3155258595943451,
-0.22165553271770477,
-0.19458000361919403,
-0.525525689125061,
-0.6424323916435242,
-0.256197988986969,
0.41069915890693665,
0.6204294562339783,
0.7645619511604309,
0.7913227081298828,
0.6853088140487671,
0.2365197092294693,
-0.41020333766937256,
0.5312250256538391,
-0.9002897143363953,
0.5370466113090515,
-0.1134798601269722,
-0.3552515506744385,
-0.42579159140586853,
-0.4392700493335724,
0.8527171015739441,
0.5543674230575562,
-0.21540296077728271,
0.24026016891002655,
0.11260879784822464,
0.9717219471931458,
-0.9436770081520081,
-0.09927555918693542,
-0.7192512154579163,
0.017138376832008362,
-0.332659512758255,
-0.7197654843330383,
-0.13443349301815033,
-0.5073926448822021,
-0.032762859016656876,
-0.7770523428916931,
0.14349140226840973,
0.6891493201255798,
1.0455093383789062,
0.4091337025165558,
-0.2409001886844635,
-0.38184261322021484,
-0.7425086498260498,
0.9823649525642395,
-0.5400375127792358,
0.22606879472732544,
0.48398369550704956,
0.29812636971473694,
-0.3746606409549713,
-0.5124298334121704,
-0.3673853874206543,
-0.15135151147842407,
-0.18852593004703522,
0.103980652987957,
-0.1305120438337326,
0.1592130810022354,
0.07221350818872452,
0.5705174803733826,
-0.5242893099784851,
0.014093823730945587,
-0.14741943776607513,
-0.022533031180500984,
0.26392292976379395,
0.16390235722064972,
0.07351312041282654,
-0.7064585089683533,
-0.5536182522773743,
-0.05750405415892601,
-0.7291868925094604,
-0.07279270887374878,
0.31814733147621155,
0.2595794200897217,
0.3534276485443115,
0.4386581480503082,
-0.0619041807949543,
0.6702812314033508,
0.10538355261087418,
-0.652062714099884,
0.024958450347185135,
-0.3270711898803711,
-0.10993155837059021,
-0.08936173468828201,
0.6845897436141968,
0.1538136601448059,
-0.03079625405371189,
0.042728155851364136,
-0.32151708006858826,
-0.360349178314209,
0.3104512691497803,
-0.7158017158508301,
0.2510419487953186,
-0.05846935510635376,
-0.2151767611503601,
-0.6580410599708557,
0.05872594937682152,
-1.0201613903045654,
-0.14365634322166443,
-0.11310991644859314,
0.4853401482105255,
-0.2477525770664215,
0.28461822867393494,
-0.20042741298675537,
-0.06890165060758591,
-0.14657306671142578,
0.05120782554149628,
-0.8460960388183594,
0.7223940491676331,
0.6223798990249634,
0.580327033996582,
-0.17777325212955475,
-0.15465505421161652,
-0.9889662265777588,
0.509530246257782,
-0.4655083119869232,
0.5848737359046936,
-0.4455398917198181,
-0.19868838787078857,
-0.27813056111335754,
-0.333283007144928,
0.06545180827379227,
-0.7604984045028687,
0.746766209602356,
-0.894452691078186,
0.13995559513568878,
-0.009640343487262726,
-0.19230017066001892,
0.14143617451190948,
0.43507418036460876,
-0.6817047595977783,
1.8036694526672363,
0.44709086418151855,
-1.0105454921722412,
0.18608509004116058,
-0.4745056629180908,
-0.6392442584037781,
0.2095087170600891,
-0.24770011007785797,
-0.43159565329551697,
-0.03277205675840378,
0.2657058835029602,
0.16872277855873108,
-0.8146049976348877,
0.5418515801429749,
0.2305830866098404,
-0.5301402807235718,
-0.4330964684486389,
0.11123973876237869,
0.2686801254749298,
0.35243701934814453,
-0.15210776031017303,
0.061036888509988785,
-0.481193482875824,
-0.14061464369297028,
0.17186714708805084,
-0.6828164458274841,
-0.908650815486908,
0.18643254041671753,
-0.380204975605011,
-0.07889720797538757,
0.40085867047309875,
-0.5942493081092834,
0.17734025418758392,
-0.6462841033935547,
0.14988599717617035,
0.4112613797187805,
0.23057404160499573,
0.4280715584754944,
-0.433442622423172,
0.5739182829856873,
-0.001103644142858684,
0.18686607480049133,
-0.1722441166639328,
-0.24485048651695251,
-0.3741663694381714,
-0.2221369594335556,
0.20880766212940216,
0.4586081802845001,
-0.7580440044403076,
0.4976348280906677,
-0.32506388425827026,
-0.2189503163099289,
-0.6291297674179077,
0.22298797965049744,
0.2990482449531555,
1.0074867010116577,
0.25232231616973877,
0.0665365606546402,
-0.7024685740470886,
-0.9396100640296936,
-0.02634996734559536,
-0.2439270317554474,
0.09768018871545792,
0.6412861347198486,
0.46709561347961426,
-0.432373046875,
0.8832349181175232,
-0.7508679628372192,
-0.31310489773750305,
-0.2710079848766327,
0.3214257061481476,
0.4258638322353363,
0.16898593306541443,
0.3984646797180176,
-1.0353702306747437,
-0.4362140893936157,
0.18402297794818878,
-0.5898016691207886,
0.009467589668929577,
0.07089423388242722,
-0.3021945357322693,
0.3448024094104767,
0.44834375381469727,
-0.4943186640739441,
0.25403892993927,
0.488715797662735,
0.28425806760787964,
0.48366785049438477,
-0.3884534537792206,
0.4100283682346344,
-1.1585538387298584,
0.32165318727493286,
-0.3056134283542633,
-0.2023886889219284,
-0.23237955570220947,
0.2995419204235077,
0.08494290709495544,
-0.31365081667900085,
0.09009090811014175,
0.6242697238922119,
-0.5573549866676331,
-0.3321346342563629,
-0.33864083886146545,
0.32809895277023315,
0.2414439171552658,
0.5677428841590881,
-0.3326371908187866,
0.8719316124916077,
0.42684608697891235,
-0.7262872457504272,
0.1639692783355713,
0.27692627906799316,
-0.29534798860549927,
0.3222784996032715,
-0.5732448101043701,
-0.011815028265118599,
-0.48586103320121765,
0.04464856535196304,
-0.8817644119262695,
-0.43780359625816345,
-0.14360199868679047,
-0.432163268327713,
0.3814602494239807,
-0.1217663511633873,
-0.6614416837692261,
-0.6348414421081543,
-0.6683527231216431,
0.48285940289497375,
0.45177677273750305,
-0.7966011166572571,
0.3547496795654297,
0.6542989611625671,
-0.3073207139968872,
-0.9555841684341431,
-0.25125089287757874,
0.0845743715763092,
-0.19871561229228973,
-0.5452268719673157,
0.7663914561271667,
0.06310321390628815,
-0.12881562113761902,
0.06449288874864578,
-0.27737361192703247,
0.03223250061273575,
-0.09510178864002228,
-0.16213978826999664,
0.25183895230293274,
-0.27534720301628113,
0.2302197813987732,
0.30000752210617065,
-0.003418967127799988,
-0.37604451179504395,
-0.03803829476237297,
0.5698198676109314,
-0.06426837295293808,
0.06010144203901291,
-0.11589004099369049,
0.4012555778026581,
0.693840742111206,
-0.29003235697746277,
0.6809294819831848,
0.14007876813411713,
-0.5112109184265137,
-0.16801291704177856,
-0.4487021565437317,
0.02761846035718918,
-0.48960018157958984,
0.3675708770751953,
-0.4692635238170624,
-0.9336242079734802,
0.19659742712974548,
-0.18559934198856354,
0.012231563217937946,
0.437774121761322,
0.40161144733428955,
-0.2747901380062103,
0.966952919960022,
0.5763923525810242,
-0.38213208317756653,
0.4144190847873688,
-0.23278361558914185,
0.23855257034301758,
-0.9476767182350159,
-0.1695455014705658,
-0.7525917291641235,
-0.21403300762176514,
-0.699030339717865,
-0.4470333456993103,
0.7391746640205383,
0.374024897813797,
-0.2554050087928772,
0.31384679675102234,
-0.5109319686889648,
0.38497403264045715,
0.6269985437393188,
-0.09280969202518463,
0.565423309803009,
0.21257558465003967,
-0.10084755718708038,
-0.14096052944660187,
-0.9002645015716553,
-0.2749580144882202,
0.5864834189414978,
0.31871697306632996,
1.1154358386993408,
-0.014007794670760632,
0.8474764227867126,
0.13869987428188324,
0.1036633551120758,
-1.0586254596710205,
0.39182090759277344,
-0.17682044208049774,
-0.6277371644973755,
-0.4234936535358429,
-0.7971761226654053,
-1.2073626518249512,
0.1842474788427353,
-0.19923867285251617,
-0.47954457998275757,
0.1239958330988884,
0.04820508137345314,
-0.22451068460941315,
0.21964307129383087,
-0.15557438135147095,
0.43649986386299133,
-0.19546253979206085,
-0.42820805311203003,
-0.2044084668159485,
-0.8161839246749878,
0.21703697741031647,
-0.24077969789505005,
0.45541587471961975,
0.1197211891412735,
-0.19590234756469727,
0.722339928150177,
-0.20414581894874573,
0.3409830331802368,
0.0816694125533104,
0.21457968652248383,
0.3607448637485504,
0.17441049218177795,
0.434855192899704,
-0.16064216196537018,
-0.43637511134147644,
-0.4915787875652313,
0.13127237558364868,
-0.24236363172531128,
-0.7343999743461609,
0.7960473895072937,
-0.5386801362037659,
-0.5315201878547668,
-0.4049845337867737,
-0.7516797184944153,
-0.30563101172447205,
0.41246068477630615,
0.3111724257469177,
0.46188607811927795,
-0.180589959025383,
0.48840197920799255,
0.6187871694564819,
-0.23017661273479462,
0.12541666626930237,
0.38186368346214294,
-0.18133346736431122,
-0.3971286714076996,
0.7049112915992737,
0.06864460557699203,
0.16827090084552765,
0.7303142547607422,
0.718730092048645,
-0.15263432264328003,
-0.4229241907596588,
-0.4459560215473175,
0.395068496465683,
-0.33178332448005676,
-0.587821900844574,
-0.41348081827163696,
-0.18462075293064117,
-0.43616142868995667,
0.09574779868125916,
-0.1882929652929306,
-0.25930511951446533,
0.030265232548117638,
0.10244587063789368,
0.18693187832832336,
0.7794235944747925,
0.07785826176404953,
0.3486311137676239,
-0.9289156794548035,
0.7584391236305237,
-0.0960431918501854,
0.26026609539985657,
0.06934090703725815,
-0.5096112489700317,
-0.4474807381629944,
-0.1639968603849411,
-0.4111775755882263,
-0.8252427577972412,
0.5423369407653809,
0.35616499185562134,
0.5580316781997681,
0.06485869735479355,
0.2650018632411957,
0.8249711394309998,
-0.42293933033943176,
0.15904802083969116,
-0.07593969255685806,
-0.43572506308555603,
0.85647052526474,
-0.6049681901931763,
0.3657713830471039,
0.7804892063140869,
0.8248817920684814,
-0.29865625500679016,
-0.2890435457229614,
-0.4691329300403595,
-0.9544863700866699,
0.6974039077758789,
0.10168801248073578,
0.010920485481619835,
-0.05061589553952217,
0.5261519551277161,
-0.01728956401348114,
0.35458463430404663,
-0.34017643332481384,
0.04630132019519806,
0.4464436173439026,
-0.35134971141815186,
0.3200908601284027,
-0.36943382024765015,
-0.11784405261278152,
-0.3545667231082916,
0.6204471588134766,
-0.1884123682975769,
0.033399198204278946,
0.32237955927848816,
0.14852775633335114,
-0.5205438733100891,
0.17995166778564453,
0.01574627123773098,
0.5567406415939331,
-0.3431752622127533,
-0.05434538424015045,
-0.036698635667562485,
-0.4837769865989685,
-0.09737764298915863,
-0.15173090994358063,
-0.33355680108070374,
-0.019602959975600243,
0.20579858124256134,
0.629540205001831,
0.5140946507453918,
-0.6476370096206665,
0.2586967349052429,
0.2002798169851303,
0.006724336184561253,
-0.0036320779472589493,
0.0009257804485969245,
-0.03851892426609993,
-0.16009394824504852,
0.7339699268341064,
-0.0451434887945652,
0.40959665179252625,
-0.9514117240905762,
0.3062203526496887,
0.3033275604248047,
-0.019397374242544174,
0.1710304468870163,
0.39967623353004456,
-0.05468997731804848,
-0.38083207607269287,
0.5986981987953186,
0.04404405131936073,
-0.5781289339065552,
0.3883075416088104,
0.7213073968887329,
0.4205739498138428,
-0.26556816697120667,
0.04243332892656326,
0.7709576487541199,
0.08508717268705368,
-0.09433445334434509,
0.19037409126758575,
-0.2594740390777588,
-0.48733770847320557,
-0.3853432238101959,
-1.104199767112732,
-0.6281785368919373,
-0.062364302575588226,
-0.770637571811676,
0.1620911806821823,
-0.31295132637023926,
-0.16833239793777466,
-0.2859172224998474,
0.2586788833141327,
-0.030980557203292847,
0.3036056160926819,
-0.3595658838748932,
0.6778736710548401,
-0.25751450657844543,
0.793525218963623,
0.5055892467498779,
-0.10796001553535461,
-0.5197382569313049,
0.17568452656269073,
-0.3088414967060089,
-0.6195677518844604,
0.66033935546875,
-0.10575667768716812,
-0.5645459890365601,
0.1547958254814148,
-0.4301511347293854,
-1.0255948305130005,
0.9349632859230042,
0.3313024938106537,
-0.45636510848999023,
-0.5123694539070129,
-0.026663312688469887,
0.6480668783187866,
-0.3850473463535309,
-0.2501572072505951,
0.6680406928062439,
0.3939555883407593,
0.5684285759925842,
-0.7337319850921631,
-0.21797502040863037,
-0.20669148862361908,
0.03531122952699661,
0.6010727286338806,
-0.4069746732711792,
0.533305823802948,
-0.2549557685852051,
-0.1727440506219864,
0.1981319636106491,
0.6223139762878418,
0.620466411113739,
0.3734760284423828,
0.3488781452178955,
0.5540636777877808,
0.9635061621665955,
0.12418940663337708,
1.417067050933838,
-0.2406405806541443,
0.18186932802200317,
1.0508692264556885,
-0.14888788759708405,
1.0836325883865356,
0.4680328071117401,
0.1933954656124115,
0.4522818922996521,
0.4897957444190979,
0.29972440004348755,
0.5402906537055969,
0.13265983760356903,
-0.2364099621772766,
0.22632978856563568,
-0.29265734553337097,
-0.0796293318271637,
0.3299545347690582,
0.33893275260925293,
0.01443820632994175,
-0.22994887828826904,
-0.1989879310131073,
0.02461172081530094,
0.4343436360359192,
-0.18659664690494537,
0.7866752743721008,
-0.05952523276209831,
-0.9549981355667114,
0.7950267791748047,
0.11313088238239288,
0.6474116444587708,
-0.6040733456611633,
0.04878980293869972,
-0.3549635410308838,
0.06693729013204575,
-0.3013480007648468,
-0.6314129829406738,
0.564540684223175,
0.10526392608880997,
-0.22540293633937836,
-0.09262929856777191,
0.8263757228851318,
-0.2603829801082611,
-0.33707597851753235,
0.4198741316795349,
0.4091823995113373,
0.06702981889247894,
0.0168848168104887,
-0.5965772271156311,
0.04742594063282013,
-0.3427123427391052,
-0.3349725008010864,
0.35272109508514404,
0.4967578053474426,
-0.2593871057033539,
0.5955476760864258,
0.45546597242355347,
0.1481940895318985,
-0.19938836991786957,
0.09495489299297333,
0.9325233101844788,
-0.7406815886497498,
-0.47926872968673706,
-0.47366228699684143,
0.03444258123636246,
-0.057939037680625916,
-0.23316454887390137,
0.5709384083747864,
0.896977424621582,
0.5453945994377136,
0.19037148356437683,
0.3669765889644623,
-0.08501002937555313,
0.9548754096031189,
-0.36518627405166626,
0.5704749822616577,
-0.932098388671875,
0.15819145739078522,
-0.37089502811431885,
-1.0639184713363647,
-0.19822660088539124,
0.42864665389060974,
-0.1956985592842102,
0.02993790991604328,
0.6642981171607971,
0.973657488822937,
-0.05961007624864578,
-0.1687111109495163,
0.35445407032966614,
0.23595131933689117,
-0.07427987456321716,
0.34283825755119324,
0.7198008298873901,
-0.5252657532691956,
0.5338505506515503,
-0.1528908759355545,
-0.36476629972457886,
-0.23059453070163727,
-0.5998719334602356,
-0.5805277824401855,
-0.5436215400695801,
0.1397048830986023,
0.050972916185855865,
0.28496742248535156,
0.5313488841056824,
0.8120812773704529,
-0.4474498927593231,
-0.5945748686790466,
0.035670556128025055,
0.1897125393152237,
0.20327171683311462,
-0.2907394468784332,
0.29533469676971436,
-0.5170186758041382,
-0.6636101603507996,
0.6621040105819702,
0.314581960439682,
-0.22079943120479584,
-0.013303264044225216,
-0.1846889704465866,
-0.5000120997428894,
0.051632195711135864,
0.833903968334198,
0.29895609617233276,
-0.30901044607162476,
-0.017061475664377213,
0.32943981885910034,
-0.45471134781837463,
0.37904441356658936,
0.571674644947052,
-0.9109265804290771,
0.18240171670913696,
0.9288818836212158,
0.7771416306495667,
0.9536213278770447,
0.5159747004508972,
0.4972063899040222,
-0.7906531095504761,
-0.008442684076726437,
0.5949752926826477,
-0.06037593632936478,
0.3192300796508789,
-0.6895315051078796,
0.6257106065750122,
-0.018850693479180336,
-0.6547720432281494,
-0.843650221824646,
0.04038261994719505,
-0.9444461464881897,
-0.239884153008461,
0.7940318584442139,
0.31045326590538025,
-0.5744814276695251,
0.09227770566940308,
-0.3913446366786957,
0.12317898869514465,
-0.28813278675079346,
0.628250002861023,
0.3216492831707001,
-0.30213212966918945,
0.03194345161318779,
-0.6963015198707581,
0.5252664089202881,
0.47964540123939514,
-0.8782684803009033,
-0.05513244867324829,
0.5844608545303345,
-0.1104993224143982,
0.27549850940704346,
0.6923969388008118,
-0.40436118841171265,
0.1558471918106079,
-0.29338574409484863,
-0.17429998517036438,
0.06596959382295609,
-0.851161003112793,
0.022038763388991356,
0.4668866991996765,
0.1094089150428772,
0.06645329296588898
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09977v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09977v1
|
Disentangling Dialect from Social Bias via Multitask Learning to Improve Fairness
| 2024-06-14T12:39:39 | 2024-06-14T12:39:39 |
Maximilian Spliethöver, Sai Nikhil Menon, Henning Wachsmuth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Dialects introduce syntactic and lexical variations in language that occur in
regional or social groups. Most NLP methods are not sensitive to such
variations. This may lead to unfair behavior of the methods, conveying negative
bias towards dialect speakers. While previous work has studied dialect-related
fairness for aspects like hate speech, other aspects of biased language, such
as lewdness, remain fully unexplored. To fill this gap, we investigate
performance disparities between dialects in the detection of five aspects of
biased language and how to mitigate them. To alleviate bias, we present a
multitask learning approach that models dialect language as an auxiliary task
to incorporate syntactic and lexical variations. In our experiments with
African-American English dialect, we provide empirical evidence that
complementing common learning approaches with dialect modeling improves their
fairness. Furthermore, the results suggest that multitask learning achieves
state-of-the-art performance and helps to detect properties of biased language
more reliably.
|
[
-0.5575002431869507,
-0.8444415926933289,
0.4911201596260071,
0.23557844758033752,
-0.18940028548240662,
0.2515474557876587,
-0.49443545937538147,
-0.5826128721237183,
0.7074131965637207,
0.5023476481437683,
-0.6325958967208862,
-0.16059836745262146,
-1.0117402076721191,
0.02387721836566925,
-0.05684363469481468,
1.0910190343856812,
0.5857353806495667,
0.3191760182380676,
-0.06120466813445091,
-0.3457946181297302,
-0.3985656797885895,
-0.8096746206283569,
-0.7880491614341736,
-0.5853898525238037,
0.5758682489395142,
0.40852856636047363,
0.49976733326911926,
0.42903801798820496,
-0.0233458261936903,
0.36499789357185364,
-0.17280761897563934,
0.08758170902729034,
-0.3747987151145935,
0.2753582000732422,
-0.34907546639442444,
-0.4186858534812927,
-0.25761815905570984,
-0.04906317964196205,
0.26382994651794434,
0.864048182964325,
-0.28909972310066223,
0.13442543148994446,
0.3702218532562256,
1.082560420036316,
-0.733371913433075,
0.28711289167404175,
-0.8150714039802551,
-0.10074615478515625,
-0.8469169735908508,
0.18568956851959229,
-0.17266815900802612,
-0.2981323301792145,
-0.021566417068243027,
-0.37362581491470337,
0.6792593598365784,
-0.22574478387832642,
0.6524640917778015,
0.10265892744064331,
-0.5858172178268433,
-0.08179929107427597,
-0.43484532833099365,
0.9908510446548462,
-0.788665235042572,
0.4962266683578491,
0.4711483418941498,
0.2689269185066223,
0.09170220792293549,
-0.11246174573898315,
-0.6069183945655823,
-0.09137391299009323,
0.006964034866541624,
0.1103702187538147,
0.28631967306137085,
0.16751936078071594,
0.36766788363456726,
0.008688305504620075,
-0.24101194739341736,
-0.07340236753225327,
-0.23434139788150787,
-0.3211597800254822,
0.6357086300849915,
-0.01472350675612688,
0.07542240619659424,
-0.5138364434242249,
0.09265732020139694,
0.15211330354213715,
-0.2687858045101166,
0.19536305963993073,
0.8980052471160889,
0.501171886920929,
0.03379184007644653,
0.1455586850643158,
-0.42206019163131714,
0.3782375454902649,
0.12561820447444916,
-0.05204258859157562,
0.48908576369285583,
-0.2553270757198334,
0.4597051739692688,
-0.027535799890756607,
0.29397252202033997,
0.38427501916885376,
0.41372209787368774,
-0.20140224695205688,
-0.19101281464099884,
0.2766844928264618,
0.37872380018234253,
-0.24371238052845,
-0.11929977685213089,
0.0872979536652565,
-0.4525437355041504,
-0.056394338607788086,
-0.1733858734369278,
-1.1919125318527222,
-0.6415321826934814,
-0.4396417737007141,
0.1381024569272995,
-0.3241831362247467,
-0.5987361669540405,
-0.0036547607742249966,
-0.4053466022014618,
0.011529850773513317,
0.3296361267566681,
-1.3062816858291626,
0.5601648688316345,
0.8948065042495728,
0.6703534126281738,
-0.05895603448152542,
-0.434001624584198,
-0.5252624750137329,
-0.11418646574020386,
-0.15110979974269867,
0.5065374374389648,
-0.28062769770622253,
0.08923891931772232,
-0.036645516753196716,
0.04610005393624306,
0.14621558785438538,
-0.7690645456314087,
0.33580562472343445,
-0.3540981709957123,
-0.0999893769621849,
-0.6866267919540405,
-0.16583232581615448,
-0.3530195355415344,
-0.015577137470245361,
-0.7895735502243042,
1.018708348274231,
-0.007122672628611326,
-0.74403977394104,
0.7086932063102722,
-0.43015801906585693,
-0.7690441608428955,
-0.13857705891132355,
-0.015177268534898758,
-0.5102475881576538,
0.36952435970306396,
0.21524474024772644,
0.4021413028240204,
0.1651170551776886,
0.4447508752346039,
-0.6355221271514893,
-0.14258886873722076,
-0.0027085812762379646,
-0.3227848708629608,
1.0610520839691162,
0.13968142867088318,
-0.7495795488357544,
-0.24551527202129364,
-0.5484362244606018,
-0.12765568494796753,
0.1726616472005844,
-0.0929027795791626,
-0.6825458407402039,
0.25393250584602356,
0.02232971042394638,
0.2564210295677185,
0.1131429523229599,
-0.8252611756324768,
-0.33464503288269043,
-0.3569275140762329,
0.032715991139411926,
1.119197964668274,
-0.4146030843257904,
0.42227107286453247,
-0.4790950119495392,
0.24212399125099182,
0.0788997933268547,
0.06901514530181885,
0.370699018239975,
-0.4627228379249573,
-0.9061330556869507,
-0.05615402013063431,
0.17916107177734375,
0.33017468452453613,
-0.8042653799057007,
0.30308952927589417,
0.1152641624212265,
-0.1319875866174698,
-0.6341336369514465,
0.21212027966976166,
0.3913591504096985,
0.2881348431110382,
0.4478471875190735,
-0.6940508484840393,
-0.42708587646484375,
-0.8565027117729187,
-0.6386200785636902,
-0.009977027773857117,
0.2089354544878006,
0.35160207748413086,
0.2674568295478821,
0.15292885899543762,
0.7366805076599121,
-0.3818392753601074,
-0.2759724259376526,
-0.4507942795753479,
0.1386754959821701,
0.011183959431946278,
0.1819123774766922,
0.7543495893478394,
-0.6104409694671631,
-0.5954954624176025,
-0.17124781012535095,
-0.40846148133277893,
-0.5421064496040344,
0.20530007779598236,
-0.08315664529800415,
0.24815629422664642,
0.2706100642681122,
-0.02895607426762581,
0.25949743390083313,
0.5738887190818787,
-0.4109889566898346,
0.718112051486969,
0.15849365293979645,
0.32975152134895325,
-0.9227208495140076,
-0.3792489469051361,
0.07971774786710739,
-0.4386565089225769,
-0.6148101091384888,
-0.010104355402290821,
-0.00248788483440876,
0.16631783545017242,
-0.34653496742248535,
0.4235033094882965,
-0.32378706336021423,
-0.02074926719069481,
-0.2801194489002228,
0.03430371358990669,
0.029723912477493286,
0.49094298481941223,
0.16767680644989014,
0.408847451210022,
0.48716655373573303,
-0.5030781030654907,
0.3909856677055359,
-0.30035400390625,
-0.24400296807289124,
0.6628550887107849,
-0.29620590806007385,
0.34539365768432617,
-0.5176403522491455,
0.023869318887591362,
-0.7402377128601074,
-0.0517030730843544,
0.0018481038277968764,
-0.36850571632385254,
0.08742470294237137,
-0.29809805750846863,
-0.09768985211849213,
0.002891794079914689,
-0.2808370590209961,
0.24958957731723785,
0.2046678215265274,
-0.5883775949478149,
0.44271156191825867,
0.7845471501350403,
-0.6343229413032532,
-1.0260862112045288,
-0.598869264125824,
-0.13685837388038635,
-0.32789069414138794,
-0.6089310646057129,
0.2097904235124588,
0.228818878531456,
-0.45357224345207214,
-0.1766536831855774,
-0.09781763702630997,
-0.32356777787208557,
0.15218032896518707,
0.15004266798496246,
-0.06587349623441696,
0.0325612835586071,
0.12657955288887024,
0.11903750896453857,
0.11524642258882523,
0.09739293158054352,
-0.10542719811201096,
0.7712958455085754,
0.03576785326004028,
-0.3403840959072113,
-0.02318681962788105,
0.7326100468635559,
0.37068507075309753,
-0.26854339241981506,
0.7750027179718018,
0.695641040802002,
-0.1654656082391739,
-0.5990035533905029,
-0.9103648066520691,
-0.4649655818939209,
-0.447592169046402,
0.6537732481956482,
-0.24738459289073944,
-0.8389798402786255,
0.5833588242530823,
0.0003525257052388042,
0.07699763774871826,
0.05541142448782921,
0.32739660143852234,
-0.06995580345392227,
0.634188711643219,
0.7500408291816711,
-0.23421457409858704,
0.7875404953956604,
0.1551450490951538,
0.13367772102355957,
-0.512208878993988,
-0.06389167159795761,
-0.7322068810462952,
-0.39711055159568787,
-0.4697493612766266,
-0.2575720250606537,
0.47047483921051025,
-0.19647617638111115,
0.035687003284692764,
0.01654093526303768,
-0.11796346306800842,
0.5174140930175781,
0.8123024106025696,
0.4022669792175293,
0.23044779896736145,
0.0854351744055748,
-0.16179296374320984,
-0.25505560636520386,
-0.3531385362148285,
-0.29548344016075134,
1.1955052614212036,
0.14409349858760834,
0.5623815655708313,
0.4437021315097809,
1.0630837678909302,
0.46984198689460754,
-0.1949799805879593,
-0.47038325667381287,
0.3483579456806183,
-0.5577859878540039,
-0.7348743081092834,
-0.37529951333999634,
-0.5708146095275879,
-0.7593711614608765,
0.4219381511211395,
-0.1676529496908188,
-0.6317518353462219,
0.20110255479812622,
0.4083646535873413,
-0.17344793677330017,
0.20781855285167694,
-0.8896431922912598,
0.8829035758972168,
-0.2575068175792694,
-0.6704497337341309,
-0.6638801693916321,
-0.5726112127304077,
0.24482759833335876,
-0.1068790853023529,
0.6552653908729553,
-0.31276723742485046,
0.3975435793399811,
0.6970142126083374,
-0.20782287418842316,
0.9359244108200073,
-0.4576148986816406,
0.3151514530181885,
-0.05898858234286308,
0.03905489668250084,
0.3079301714897156,
0.08608701825141907,
-0.2739482522010803,
0.6903555989265442,
-0.12953153252601624,
-0.6934236884117126,
-0.3625923991203308,
0.5404176712036133,
-0.7007849812507629,
-0.5509759187698364,
-0.36346736550331116,
-0.41599932312965393,
-0.3263098895549774,
0.056931398808956146,
0.06902296096086502,
0.38893237709999084,
-0.18357224762439728,
-0.09305613487958908,
0.5252043008804321,
-0.2193959355354309,
0.46733352541923523,
0.5340582132339478,
-0.01732585020363331,
0.009965440258383751,
0.8190396428108215,
0.2461293637752533,
0.46272799372673035,
-0.1666276603937149,
0.27548789978027344,
-0.4129602909088135,
-0.4286886751651764,
-0.3715674579143524,
0.1697821468114853,
-0.5414475202560425,
0.20548056066036224,
-0.7466241121292114,
0.08862664550542831,
-0.8434918522834778,
-0.09901689738035202,
-0.4940762221813202,
-0.5578218698501587,
0.2517407238483429,
-0.018813015893101692,
0.21365438401699066,
0.9397854208946228,
-0.479568213224411,
0.19509129226207733,
-0.4879741668701172,
0.5726024508476257,
0.4620651304721832,
0.45397236943244934,
0.21124331653118134,
-0.5442558526992798,
-0.2640678882598877,
0.03450999781489372,
-0.49445873498916626,
-1.1060131788253784,
0.28598618507385254,
0.2858825922012329,
0.5961456894874573,
0.23366931080818176,
0.1319475620985031,
0.523989200592041,
-0.7681804299354553,
0.7760009169578552,
0.1226780042052269,
-1.1444934606552124,
0.30421456694602966,
-0.09732765704393387,
-0.022831451147794724,
0.5242424607276917,
0.18399257957935333,
-0.9469070434570312,
-0.7810168862342834,
-0.5411562323570251,
-0.9370498657226562,
0.7398197054862976,
-0.21646881103515625,
0.3333872854709625,
-0.10996804386377335,
0.045180004090070724,
0.42843005061149597,
0.4714992046356201,
-1.1480998992919922,
-0.37935343384742737,
-0.5284451842308044,
-0.012813919223845005,
-0.2970806062221527,
-0.21055829524993896,
-0.020161917433142662,
-0.24187378585338593,
0.6705280542373657,
-0.09195500612258911,
-0.05359620973467827,
-0.19197075068950653,
-0.21303297579288483,
0.09127803146839142,
0.5992019772529602,
0.2398686558008194,
0.4240095913410187,
0.04392870143055916,
0.39318594336509705,
-0.027369260787963867,
-0.454426109790802,
0.16525839269161224,
-0.004659681580960751,
-0.03389725089073181,
0.25880709290504456,
0.3079380393028259,
0.6230374574661255,
-0.30848684906959534,
-0.18693126738071442,
0.6479171514511108,
0.09170882403850555,
0.03652595356106758,
-0.03752480819821358,
0.06340356171131134,
0.11206015944480896,
0.24302367866039276,
0.06076947599649429,
0.23285391926765442,
0.4049615263938904,
-0.5357479453086853,
0.38450345396995544,
0.7400115728378296,
-0.13942719995975494,
-0.15407362580299377,
0.5291934013366699,
0.526115357875824,
-0.07640361040830612,
0.380646675825119,
-0.49333658814430237,
-0.760057270526886,
0.7474247217178345,
0.3559876084327698,
0.7551371455192566,
-0.2982370853424072,
0.4394022226333618,
0.15186737477779388,
0.38676413893699646,
0.0817301943898201,
0.19609864056110382,
-0.1770714819431305,
-1.072156310081482,
-0.35331857204437256,
-0.6840015053749084,
-0.2592811584472656,
0.008250036276876926,
-0.6470683813095093,
0.11972098797559738,
-0.37453117966651917,
-0.31042149662971497,
0.20970045030117035,
-0.0774998813867569,
-0.6755202412605286,
-0.10753616690635681,
0.13921698927879333,
0.1978820115327835,
-1.2784802913665771,
0.7147387266159058,
0.552773118019104,
-0.06490285694599152,
-0.6328721046447754,
0.24097733199596405,
0.5244974493980408,
-0.6571832895278931,
0.6911121606826782,
0.053862541913986206,
-0.25351256132125854,
-0.24927358329296112,
-0.16156938672065735,
-0.43716368079185486,
0.1513596624135971,
0.4301203787326813,
-0.5419694781303406,
0.13700369000434875,
0.3153016269207001,
0.3093433678150177,
0.11010577529668808,
0.43043777346611023,
0.40778008103370667,
0.24041146039962769,
-0.5371924638748169,
-1.2326675653457642,
-0.19231107831001282,
0.045238178223371506,
-0.14603514969348907,
0.24733607470989227,
-0.8590443730354309,
1.055965781211853,
-0.16193993389606476,
0.04855523258447647,
-0.5454467535018921,
0.27236315608024597,
-0.09054288268089294,
0.5069210529327393,
0.7408086061477661,
0.3751663565635681,
0.8257368803024292,
-0.2792908549308777,
0.5798317193984985,
-0.02835630066692829,
0.33924350142478943,
1.0921262502670288,
-0.5070135593414307,
0.3105771541595459,
0.5503274202346802,
-0.2860284745693207,
0.5218096971511841,
0.30865877866744995,
0.5688485503196716,
0.634719967842102,
0.26955536007881165,
-0.6648350954055786,
-0.1967255175113678,
-0.16889114677906036,
-0.24244220554828644,
0.6359624862670898,
0.2596660852432251,
0.03683249279856682,
-0.41033849120140076,
0.19561442732810974,
0.06359142065048218,
0.4994189441204071,
-0.338835746049881,
0.9475999474525452,
-0.05381038039922714,
-0.6139029860496521,
0.37614327669143677,
0.0420374795794487,
1.1942335367202759,
-0.6545730829238892,
-0.18032389879226685,
-0.3108283579349518,
0.1402251273393631,
-0.2717856466770172,
-0.42848244309425354,
0.5461950302124023,
-0.20983940362930298,
-0.44193336367607117,
-0.23499795794487,
0.5397061705589294,
-0.607577919960022,
-0.09412018209695816,
0.7402997016906738,
0.4918982982635498,
0.03411594778299332,
-0.2310670167207718,
-0.8062184453010559,
-0.09012576192617416,
0.18173092603683472,
0.19925153255462646,
0.445304811000824,
0.6366772055625916,
0.13484077155590057,
0.44836661219596863,
0.3735007643699646,
0.5954947471618652,
0.4949710965156555,
0.226617693901062,
0.5071535110473633,
-0.5593392252922058,
-0.6870548129081726,
-0.8251485824584961,
0.3445686995983124,
-0.2491496056318283,
-0.12775857746601105,
0.7406521439552307,
0.360393226146698,
1.2636584043502808,
-0.19481416046619415,
0.9062055945396423,
-0.23257248103618622,
0.8986960649490356,
-0.6117122173309326,
0.7931771278381348,
-0.6213476061820984,
0.1272764503955841,
-0.7114866375923157,
-0.7073472738265991,
0.17294754087924957,
0.7175386548042297,
-0.16200725734233856,
0.1474151313304901,
0.8351970314979553,
0.8855662941932678,
-0.11381847411394119,
0.181192085146904,
0.30740901827812195,
0.05163543298840523,
0.2161477506160736,
0.40914908051490784,
0.7122694253921509,
0.16164439916610718,
0.024153562262654305,
-0.7324385643005371,
-0.4980533719062805,
0.1452036201953888,
-0.7702767252922058,
-0.7287042140960693,
-0.5491495728492737,
-0.03883254900574684,
-0.574859619140625,
0.39652761816978455,
0.9281491637229919,
0.8340526223182678,
-0.8555953502655029,
-0.5668057799339294,
0.3056027293205261,
0.5142108201980591,
-0.6118080019950867,
-0.32147452235221863,
-0.02242276817560196,
-0.676733136177063,
-0.8975555300712585,
0.13293862342834473,
0.014355052262544632,
-0.5560511946678162,
-0.013340958394110203,
0.06109100207686424,
-0.1887151300907135,
-0.0043967776000499725,
0.6222198605537415,
0.04156416282057762,
-0.6358477473258972,
-0.48232728242874146,
-0.3522663712501526,
0.16904163360595703,
-0.01020840648561716,
1.0394452810287476,
-0.5684608221054077,
0.5957807898521423,
0.1903959959745407,
0.6106646656990051,
0.18877696990966797,
-0.1179976835846901,
0.34702882170677185,
-1.1848094463348389,
0.3896249830722809,
0.2544128894805908,
0.3562246263027191,
0.28612810373306274,
-0.499258428812027,
0.13603153824806213,
0.6587007641792297,
-0.6643439531326294,
-0.39122578501701355,
0.45650795102119446,
-0.5739942193031311,
-0.46878015995025635,
0.976041316986084,
0.1345975250005722,
0.11929208785295486,
-0.7856899499893188,
-0.11070460081100464,
0.2736082673072815,
-0.7665857672691345,
1.1359617710113525,
1.0049189329147339,
-0.1381520926952362,
-0.01697511039674282,
-0.7251328229904175,
0.7855223417282104,
0.8023284077644348,
-0.6557639837265015,
0.4109872281551361,
0.7615325450897217,
0.49648600816726685,
0.10777623951435089,
0.8791812062263489,
0.05711918696761131,
0.3280022144317627,
-0.19969715178012848,
0.20218171179294586,
0.2637839615345001,
-0.42131468653678894,
-0.3435063660144806,
0.14577798545360565,
0.055351633578538895,
-0.1639954298734665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10312v1
|
In-depth analysis of recall initiators of medical devices with a Machine Learning-Natural language Processing workflow
| 2024-06-14T12:38:49 | 2024-06-14T12:38:49 |
Yang Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recall initiator identification and assessment are the preliminary steps to
prevent medical device recall. Conventional analysis tools are inappropriate
for processing massive and multi-formatted data comprehensively and completely
to meet the higher expectations of delicacy management with the increasing
overall data volume and textual data format. This study presents a
bigdata-analytics-based machine learning-natural language processing work tool
to address the shortcomings in dealing efficiency and data process versatility
of conventional tools in the practical context of big data volume and muti data
format. This study identified, assessed and analysed the medical device recall
initiators according to the public medical device recall database from 2018 to
2024 with the ML-NLP tool. The results suggest that the unsupervised
Density-Based Spatial Clustering of Applications with Noise (DBSCAN) clustering
algorithm can present each single recall initiator in a specific manner,
therefore helping practitioners to identify the recall reasons comprehensively
and completely within a short time frame. This is then followed by text
similarity-based textual classification to assist practitioners in controlling
the group size of recall initiators and provide managerial insights from the
operational to the tactical and strategical levels. This ML-NLP work tool can
not only capture specific details of each recall initiator but also interpret
the inner connection of each existing initiator and can be implemented for risk
identification and assessment in the forward SC. Finally, this paper suggests
some concluding remarks and presents future works. More proactive practices and
control solutions for medical device recalls are expected in the future.
|
[
-0.4556993246078491,
-0.643284022808075,
0.32789817452430725,
0.017688605934381485,
-0.21841394901275635,
-0.05133404582738876,
0.09512573480606079,
-0.5930665135383606,
0.2591008245944977,
0.4531259834766388,
-0.4090266525745392,
-0.38343578577041626,
-0.6192014217376709,
0.14914695918560028,
-0.21491654217243195,
0.8253164887428284,
-0.13888314366340637,
-0.15409646928310394,
-0.0209839828312397,
-0.16119588911533356,
-0.9197396039962769,
-0.735799252986908,
-0.7843116521835327,
-0.03422780707478523,
0.42860397696495056,
0.44881048798561096,
0.27137482166290283,
0.29649803042411804,
0.6793960332870483,
0.3108047842979431,
-0.17038315534591675,
0.05729192867875099,
-0.21494019031524658,
0.09727952629327774,
0.07305236905813217,
-0.08456476777791977,
-0.46408888697624207,
-0.1846189945936203,
0.6072903871536255,
0.4061765670776367,
-0.4654002785682678,
0.09346182644367218,
0.19505758583545685,
0.8633432984352112,
-0.48411455750465393,
0.1362459510564804,
-0.7578315138816833,
0.21761614084243774,
-0.031570032238960266,
-0.29892393946647644,
-0.41058892011642456,
-0.5734684467315674,
0.10275851935148239,
-0.35782456398010254,
0.16989955306053162,
-0.06274589151144028,
0.6327678561210632,
0.5175905823707581,
-0.2564019560813904,
-0.5330800414085388,
-1.0128405094146729,
0.5052805542945862,
-0.7652884125709534,
0.06033293157815933,
0.37315693497657776,
0.5317396521568298,
-0.5259525775909424,
-0.5761045813560486,
-0.5660681128501892,
0.13692176342010498,
-0.21193082630634308,
-0.0457560196518898,
-0.1461183875799179,
-0.12306049466133118,
0.3246127963066101,
0.3267670273780823,
-0.63688725233078,
0.48044151067733765,
-0.4448741674423218,
-0.01589486561715603,
0.5491746664047241,
0.22234739363193512,
0.08717542141675949,
0.04153231531381607,
-0.3573581576347351,
0.2697449028491974,
-0.811843752861023,
-0.19402951002120972,
-0.23691189289093018,
-0.03205178678035736,
-0.20162013173103333,
0.44264134764671326,
-0.0017699578311294317,
0.4227660298347473,
0.18833757936954498,
-0.18570078909397125,
0.636037290096283,
-0.4285201132297516,
-0.7211173176765442,
0.5740578770637512,
0.7442893385887146,
0.2524400055408478,
0.16968393325805664,
-0.05992018058896065,
-0.04915750026702881,
-0.36102017760276794,
0.5453903079032898,
-0.9639851450920105,
-0.04797926917672157,
0.42866605520248413,
-0.6563010811805725,
-0.06345293670892715,
0.2913321852684021,
-0.8358734250068665,
-0.7160494327545166,
-0.26755037903785706,
0.49446892738342285,
-0.38153907656669617,
-0.14862529933452606,
0.3562089502811432,
-0.06313709169626236,
0.028694916516542435,
-0.05246850848197937,
-0.8460177183151245,
0.23840172588825226,
0.6630678176879883,
0.6730875372886658,
-0.24698735773563385,
0.07512249797582626,
-0.30658066272735596,
0.4345082938671112,
-0.26386192440986633,
0.5865123271942139,
-0.16330361366271973,
-0.6586431860923767,
-0.07245476543903351,
0.3248412311077118,
-0.4193778932094574,
-1.0682545900344849,
0.6589446067810059,
-0.3853183090686798,
0.2774336636066437,
-0.38216206431388855,
-0.6800923347473145,
-0.5604239106178284,
0.34079039096832275,
-0.9422575831413269,
0.9083915948867798,
-0.1735505759716034,
-0.7373268008232117,
1.0681384801864624,
-0.6394351720809937,
-0.6455204486846924,
0.2558267116546631,
-0.2018764764070511,
-0.9933719635009766,
0.027363121509552002,
0.2975419759750366,
0.9111040830612183,
-0.20450574159622192,
0.5044175982475281,
-0.10351990908384323,
-0.4773479700088501,
0.239752396941185,
-0.28076082468032837,
0.5215852856636047,
-0.10232173651456833,
-0.1596023291349411,
0.39987272024154663,
-0.829365611076355,
-0.42433273792266846,
0.11807317286729813,
-0.35304129123687744,
-0.35152384638786316,
-0.018844813108444214,
-0.3333494961261749,
0.5046942234039307,
-0.11687332391738892,
-0.687048077583313,
0.005260663107037544,
-0.39989539980888367,
0.3807738423347473,
0.42915380001068115,
0.7158312797546387,
0.30412548780441284,
-0.3033899664878845,
0.48158174753189087,
0.22212037444114685,
0.40283218026161194,
-0.23445501923561096,
-0.5782511830329895,
-0.24288442730903625,
-0.7210837006568909,
0.020813141018152237,
0.6739133596420288,
-0.49699723720550537,
0.9140687584877014,
-0.11830444633960724,
-0.6028692722320557,
-0.31437161564826965,
-0.09736981987953186,
0.17401190102100372,
0.9076462984085083,
0.154631108045578,
-0.3579217791557312,
-0.7031757831573486,
-0.7260828614234924,
0.08437135815620422,
0.15774127840995789,
-0.3203807473182678,
0.10717374831438065,
0.4692155420780182,
-0.3838534653186798,
0.6644092202186584,
-0.16426116228103638,
-0.719208836555481,
-0.21214069426059723,
-0.09608237445354462,
0.5831649899482727,
0.44382697343826294,
0.47959864139556885,
-1.025399923324585,
-0.32284441590309143,
0.22282910346984863,
-0.8444098830223083,
0.3417528569698334,
0.04131472483277321,
0.23564641177654266,
0.6458923816680908,
0.6451621651649475,
-0.6893084645271301,
0.7191875576972961,
0.11848236620426178,
-0.1515088528394699,
0.49360647797584534,
-0.49793341755867004,
0.2027096301317215,
-0.9600366950035095,
0.5928060412406921,
-0.04592905193567276,
0.39741021394729614,
-0.5592349171638489,
-0.44850993156433105,
0.16649048030376434,
0.07799220085144043,
-0.4187788963317871,
0.41374197602272034,
-0.10015108436346054,
0.03564541041851044,
0.14155153930187225,
-0.25866585969924927,
-0.20928852260112762,
0.23354041576385498,
-0.17087422311306,
0.5081968903541565,
0.25906866788864136,
-1.0616575479507446,
0.20863789319992065,
0.14331048727035522,
-0.4665868282318115,
0.5912427306175232,
-0.6325598955154419,
-0.11566159874200821,
-0.21304725110530853,
0.11069048941135406,
-1.1763263940811157,
-0.17244498431682587,
0.49194812774658203,
-0.18839339911937714,
0.4670877754688263,
-0.2208704799413681,
-0.9069694876670837,
-0.8390341997146606,
-0.07528281211853027,
-0.016080062836408615,
0.3417695462703705,
-0.5397248864173889,
0.6366788148880005,
0.6420634388923645,
-0.5229207873344421,
-0.27816250920295715,
-0.4097093343734741,
-0.11870302259922028,
-0.8000683784484863,
-0.13869835436344147,
0.2204144448041916,
-0.11341835558414459,
0.15211962163448334,
-0.15490570664405823,
-0.16686169803142548,
-0.13520093262195587,
0.15772642195224762,
0.49092888832092285,
0.6828673481941223,
0.03427201136946678,
0.48374664783477783,
0.08967997878789902,
-0.49557486176490784,
0.3131384551525116,
-0.10028533637523651,
0.2775799334049225,
0.1402602195739746,
-0.2717912197113037,
-0.6345049142837524,
0.11725703626871109,
0.5107783675193787,
-0.2356506586074829,
0.5422576069831848,
0.48811429738998413,
-0.6461754441261292,
0.310922235250473,
-0.6644318699836731,
-0.0479562021791935,
-0.4288099408149719,
0.27156752347946167,
-0.10588887333869934,
-0.611002504825592,
0.46063563227653503,
-0.044207021594047546,
0.28305160999298096,
0.46022796630859375,
0.8928263187408447,
-0.15859904885292053,
0.750264585018158,
0.1734439730644226,
-0.43987929821014404,
0.23011845350265503,
-0.18380048871040344,
0.29556772112846375,
-0.42451173067092896,
-0.7435838580131531,
-0.5962429046630859,
-0.4892219007015228,
-0.21461698412895203,
-0.053679414093494415,
0.474676251411438,
-0.43132641911506653,
-0.3993590474128723,
0.22937491536140442,
-0.6328360438346863,
0.24060368537902832,
0.3034454882144928,
-0.1670082062482834,
0.22360490262508392,
0.10998164117336273,
-0.10597655177116394,
-0.2676350176334381,
-0.5809746980667114,
-0.4084698259830475,
1.133437156677246,
0.28044307231903076,
0.5911595821380615,
0.05821999907493591,
0.7059515714645386,
0.16872480511665344,
0.14003801345825195,
-0.6697781085968018,
0.3337591588497162,
-0.1440151184797287,
-0.5146508812904358,
-0.2108088731765747,
-0.21046027541160583,
-1.3211767673492432,
0.03897113725543022,
-0.2982415556907654,
-0.6816722750663757,
0.37600475549697876,
0.15931963920593262,
-0.48900488018989563,
0.3473377227783203,
-0.7237271666526794,
0.900688648223877,
-0.05980876088142395,
0.14078928530216217,
-0.28090763092041016,
-0.6209202408790588,
0.26393240690231323,
-0.37228062748908997,
0.1621498167514801,
0.06941334903240204,
0.1931300163269043,
0.6676041483879089,
-0.1317177563905716,
0.8360170125961304,
-0.3444438576698303,
-0.05477019026875496,
0.3355124592781067,
-0.024987347424030304,
0.3953334093093872,
-0.2440873384475708,
-0.16188332438468933,
-0.02342921681702137,
-0.07255181670188904,
-0.12927275896072388,
-0.377872109413147,
0.5568100214004517,
-0.07353119552135468,
-0.03312227502465248,
-0.1910446584224701,
-0.13482370972633362,
-0.03715787082910538,
0.24893777072429657,
0.23493854701519012,
0.2334890067577362,
-0.4386734962463379,
0.20437467098236084,
0.9184927344322205,
-0.30621469020843506,
0.7555482983589172,
0.40978434681892395,
0.0264202281832695,
-0.15716873109340668,
0.9780008792877197,
0.2117765098810196,
-0.0973535105586052,
0.5592557191848755,
0.15591678023338318,
-0.09721401333808899,
-0.46440017223358154,
-0.5407898426055908,
0.16564428806304932,
-0.15047186613082886,
-0.3094525933265686,
-0.6966667771339417,
-0.2111356109380722,
0.050172507762908936,
-0.0027279320638626814,
-0.01500686164945364,
-0.1313970386981964,
-0.43643683195114136,
-0.24359574913978577,
0.31565067172050476,
0.6238299012184143,
0.2088172435760498,
0.3157045543193817,
-0.7905876636505127,
0.49661487340927124,
0.12000521272420883,
0.41848453879356384,
0.1069607213139534,
-0.1912737637758255,
-0.4186854064464569,
-0.33432716131210327,
-0.4760437607765198,
-0.5989257097244263,
0.49813511967658997,
-0.09428909420967102,
0.8143484592437744,
0.6053454875946045,
-0.2853567898273468,
0.46519365906715393,
-0.23342792689800262,
0.4269087016582489,
0.016126470640301704,
-0.3667498826980591,
0.38263577222824097,
0.05922761186957359,
0.2211918830871582,
0.3603174090385437,
0.5590121746063232,
-0.49916335940361023,
0.07262758165597916,
-0.6734943985939026,
-0.879710853099823,
0.38803932070732117,
-0.29805895686149597,
-0.40922367572784424,
-0.028319325298070908,
0.09366901963949203,
0.3472083508968353,
0.3705825209617615,
0.04224285110831261,
0.02112775482237339,
0.16270479559898376,
-0.311286062002182,
-0.05552032217383385,
-0.28412362933158875,
0.0766238421201706,
-0.2724234163761139,
0.6840994358062744,
0.15261070430278778,
0.15862581133842468,
0.019530780613422394,
-0.0276531670242548,
0.12480425834655762,
0.43241366744041443,
0.29181385040283203,
0.48085644841194153,
-0.2825952470302582,
-0.18388645350933075,
0.08766297996044159,
-0.6957840919494629,
-0.03204215690493584,
0.21694250404834747,
-0.10368109494447708,
-0.011985182762145996,
0.07012021541595459,
0.2357044667005539,
0.4559613764286041,
-0.783775806427002,
0.4031233787536621,
-0.04100426658987999,
-0.1814340204000473,
-0.47021377086639404,
-0.18023018538951874,
0.11167477071285248,
-0.12073234468698502,
0.25316324830055237,
0.060049425810575485,
0.4570466876029968,
-0.3042067587375641,
0.3533901274204254,
0.2920420169830322,
-0.76276695728302,
-0.1250893771648407,
0.5035779476165771,
0.07309753447771072,
0.0019068914698436856,
0.49992701411247253,
-0.3073694407939911,
-0.1331469863653183,
0.8440555334091187,
0.4428061842918396,
0.9439474940299988,
-0.5016237497329712,
-0.0004034477169625461,
0.5723985433578491,
0.33528590202331543,
-0.08946225792169571,
0.4413714110851288,
0.3906641900539398,
-0.3528164029121399,
-0.3508599102497101,
-0.05583975836634636,
0.024799497798085213,
0.2979643940925598,
-0.7079079151153564,
0.18396595120429993,
-0.637620747089386,
-0.237538680434227,
0.13881994783878326,
-0.09433404356241226,
-0.7766619324684143,
0.1159336119890213,
-0.12497688829898834,
0.8154184818267822,
-0.7099409103393555,
0.656627357006073,
0.3457203507423401,
-0.3366391956806183,
-0.41495147347450256,
-0.3474794924259186,
0.40461909770965576,
-0.5250838994979858,
0.38936570286750793,
0.3258405029773712,
0.20534363389015198,
-0.3426688313484192,
-0.11598921567201614,
-0.4983993470668793,
1.0142197608947754,
-0.12166871130466461,
-0.5842240452766418,
0.07471741735935211,
-0.15131381154060364,
0.5317721962928772,
-0.3255595266819,
-0.2819451689720154,
0.9833964705467224,
0.46367573738098145,
0.15565894544124603,
-0.991760790348053,
0.17878712713718414,
-0.04155853018164635,
-0.3249402642250061,
0.6905549168586731,
0.17681920528411865,
0.4389210343360901,
-0.3088776767253876,
-0.32052770256996155,
0.04142313450574875,
0.20737284421920776,
0.3706321716308594,
0.7468861937522888,
0.2017531394958496,
0.603775143623352,
0.9263712167739868,
0.29004865884780884,
0.8121515512466431,
0.32823094725608826,
-0.07910063117742538,
1.2124836444854736,
-0.3733353614807129,
0.8005849719047546,
0.485714852809906,
-0.1471189558506012,
0.37857234477996826,
0.2633959949016571,
-0.25215426087379456,
0.3076219856739044,
0.15653038024902344,
-0.08763215690851212,
0.3215884864330292,
0.10080645978450775,
-0.26775917410850525,
0.17121830582618713,
0.8813382983207703,
-0.6751519441604614,
0.0005269345128908753,
0.23809242248535156,
0.015632444992661476,
0.06141240894794464,
-0.2998311519622803,
1.2223941087722778,
-0.16798648238182068,
-0.17833302915096283,
0.5063490271568298,
-0.3633285462856293,
0.5640970468521118,
-0.49240806698799133,
-0.10520963370800018,
0.1285548061132431,
0.29681697487831116,
-0.1747814565896988,
-0.8044257760047913,
0.46032243967056274,
-0.33423805236816406,
-0.35281243920326233,
0.07971423119306564,
0.7011448740959167,
-0.17447370290756226,
-0.4487420618534088,
0.2198474407196045,
0.11367591470479965,
0.1629350632429123,
-0.3757750988006592,
-0.5676122903823853,
-0.13585235178470612,
-0.19871161878108978,
0.13681884109973907,
0.15228694677352905,
0.6972697973251343,
-0.3112036883831024,
0.7060468196868896,
0.38507017493247986,
0.051834605634212494,
0.06749313324689865,
0.08087790012359619,
0.603866696357727,
-0.7671198844909668,
-0.4030357003211975,
-0.9203535914421082,
0.37001800537109375,
-0.29797855019569397,
-0.26136457920074463,
0.6241904497146606,
0.9712218046188354,
0.6330614686012268,
-0.23177063465118408,
0.6503756642341614,
-0.05301318317651749,
0.8707298636436462,
-0.4414248764514923,
0.8791317343711853,
-0.18155908584594727,
0.090540811419487,
-0.2876969873905182,
-0.4587865471839905,
-0.4102201461791992,
0.21290190517902374,
-0.10256382077932358,
-0.10745951533317566,
0.4063167870044708,
0.710405170917511,
0.022398510947823524,
0.24319545924663544,
0.15478351712226868,
0.3783036768436432,
0.3525177836418152,
0.6265512704849243,
0.4112001359462738,
-0.33246010541915894,
0.378387987613678,
-0.053020332008600235,
-0.26687315106391907,
-0.6647618412971497,
-0.7357413172721863,
-0.8220149278640747,
-0.6870830059051514,
-0.1276620626449585,
-0.14528591930866241,
-0.37876448035240173,
0.6876513957977295,
0.5825499296188354,
-0.7503001689910889,
0.01695713959634304,
0.24278981983661652,
0.23415938019752502,
-0.5522874593734741,
-0.17341329157352448,
0.5708387494087219,
0.03131264075636864,
-0.23095755279064178,
0.26187920570373535,
0.580395519733429,
0.23865944147109985,
0.06301578879356384,
0.09408261626958847,
-0.011484246701002121,
-0.35062357783317566,
0.9025304317474365,
0.669416069984436,
-0.5283873081207275,
0.16418132185935974,
-0.2358494997024536,
-0.020397301763296127,
0.029911061748862267,
0.9408828020095825,
-0.970088541507721,
0.5538468360900879,
0.2502136826515198,
0.563130795955658,
0.4384416937828064,
-0.22671517729759216,
0.30987149477005005,
-0.5910652875900269,
0.21495197713375092,
0.14064009487628937,
0.33318543434143066,
0.21986201405525208,
-0.27918535470962524,
0.2679303288459778,
0.10087421536445618,
-0.5723755955696106,
-0.5290894508361816,
-0.043098997324705124,
-0.8487577438354492,
-0.25321710109710693,
0.8145829439163208,
0.21068817377090454,
-0.01190218050032854,
-0.594874382019043,
-0.589052677154541,
0.10432582348585129,
-0.4104965627193451,
1.001240849494934,
0.2761140763759613,
-0.02279997244477272,
0.2081240713596344,
-0.6426964998245239,
0.47362348437309265,
-0.029184428974986076,
-1.0412567853927612,
0.09444838017225266,
0.24863699078559875,
0.20842859148979187,
-0.01979457214474678,
0.6366463303565979,
-0.4607745110988617,
0.20028993487358093,
-0.27304455637931824,
0.07050596177577972,
-0.018315764144062996,
-0.40053266286849976,
-0.475748211145401,
0.09342530369758606,
-0.3429296612739563,
-0.5034940838813782
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09972v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09972v1
|
A Better LLM Evaluator for Text Generation: The Impact of Prompt Output Sequencing and Optimization
| 2024-06-14T12:31:44 | 2024-06-14T12:31:44 |
KuanChao Chu, Yi-Pei Chen, Hideki Nakayama
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This research investigates prompt designs of evaluating generated texts using
large language models (LLMs). While LLMs are increasingly used for scoring
various inputs, creating effective prompts for open-ended text evaluation
remains challenging due to model sensitivity and subjectivity in evaluation of
text generation. Our study experimented with different prompt structures,
altering the sequence of output instructions and including explanatory reasons.
We found that the order of presenting reasons and scores significantly
influences LLMs' scoring, with a different level of rule understanding in the
prompt. An additional optimization may enhance scoring alignment if sufficient
data is available. This insight is crucial for improving the accuracy and
consistency of LLM-based evaluations.
|
[
-0.2927871346473694,
-0.6937540173530579,
0.9775072932243347,
0.34838372468948364,
-0.26770150661468506,
-0.22240880131721497,
-0.4389117360115051,
-0.1423356831073761,
-0.1784667670726776,
0.3105625510215759,
-0.6263803839683533,
-0.5100736618041992,
-0.4319053590297699,
0.6437810659408569,
-0.09218292683362961,
1.0324848890304565,
-0.10487209260463715,
0.13438867032527924,
-0.373997300863266,
0.22571004927158356,
-0.8203302025794983,
-0.25932514667510986,
-0.7705349922180176,
-0.3780253529548645,
0.6935499906539917,
0.5785545110702515,
0.5698873996734619,
0.6675800085067749,
0.4698500335216522,
0.33800825476646423,
-0.2049812227487564,
0.26322323083877563,
-0.6063810586929321,
0.5523232221603394,
-0.061242371797561646,
-0.20409028232097626,
-0.2378803938627243,
-0.05181756615638733,
0.7834923267364502,
0.44313108921051025,
0.05581590160727501,
0.3090829849243164,
0.2168949395418167,
0.5335745215415955,
-0.5342453122138977,
-0.0798487588763237,
-0.31584516167640686,
-0.021007845178246498,
-0.04852892830967903,
-0.6653525233268738,
-0.7818257212638855,
-0.830482542514801,
0.07220083475112915,
-0.3189551830291748,
-0.09725729376077652,
0.1865522712469101,
0.658095121383667,
0.28396928310394287,
-0.17797881364822388,
-0.6218594312667847,
-0.6196972131729126,
0.943996250629425,
-0.7303518056869507,
0.11699902266263962,
-0.16721516847610474,
0.288783460855484,
-0.3753388822078705,
-0.6295004487037659,
-0.27501001954078674,
-0.22423218190670013,
0.07077982276678085,
0.21335914731025696,
-0.09472934901714325,
0.08410526812076569,
0.47313499450683594,
0.3945028781890869,
-0.6614482402801514,
0.5580223798751831,
-0.2235928475856781,
-0.2030627429485321,
0.7832632660865784,
0.6808585524559021,
0.3268028199672699,
-0.43807297945022583,
-0.04471997544169426,
-0.039436981081962585,
-0.8137655854225159,
0.3796745240688324,
0.6752763986587524,
0.4361904263496399,
0.061501000076532364,
0.7824649214744568,
-0.2896536588668823,
0.9151984453201294,
0.012085662223398685,
-0.3423026204109192,
0.0430152453482151,
-0.5044950246810913,
-0.09817840158939362,
0.09494709223508835,
0.9337464570999146,
0.7370266318321228,
0.22737950086593628,
0.16788369417190552,
-0.47119003534317017,
-0.2034691870212555,
0.25266650319099426,
-1.1285598278045654,
0.2151373326778412,
0.16087639331817627,
-0.6926823854446411,
-0.48232409358024597,
0.17277854681015015,
-0.7598186731338501,
-0.44160208106040955,
-0.5978694558143616,
0.22093477845191956,
-0.25510233640670776,
0.3842146694660187,
0.004579354077577591,
-0.18357083201408386,
0.11830362677574158,
0.529857873916626,
-0.7471272945404053,
-0.04627717286348343,
0.5729175806045532,
0.7932614088058472,
-0.3631575405597687,
-0.0883767306804657,
-0.9462408423423767,
-0.29383164644241333,
-0.4843335449695587,
0.7416499853134155,
-0.6201726198196411,
-0.6096963286399841,
0.10302100330591202,
-0.19995103776454926,
0.12081211805343628,
-0.34316286444664,
0.8862511515617371,
-0.451668918132782,
0.7405735850334167,
-0.3056317865848541,
-0.7104557752609253,
0.08638252317905426,
-0.1826685667037964,
-0.5897446274757385,
0.9510900378227234,
0.01472573820501566,
-0.5980794429779053,
0.3885921239852905,
-0.5948781371116638,
-0.38956132531166077,
0.1597517877817154,
-0.23902985453605652,
-0.34055253863334656,
0.49922728538513184,
0.24246461689472198,
0.3944125175476074,
-0.5583629012107849,
0.43926259875297546,
0.14403623342514038,
-0.5579847097396851,
0.47614404559135437,
-0.5172584056854248,
0.6274507641792297,
0.33109250664711,
-0.16601750254631042,
0.5100616216659546,
-0.8475853204727173,
0.21909749507904053,
-0.021839097142219543,
-0.7818993330001831,
-0.13705050945281982,
-0.06663741916418076,
-0.15864385664463043,
-0.05761593580245972,
0.18011805415153503,
-0.4414682686328888,
0.1445760875940323,
-0.3756650686264038,
0.08642108738422394,
1.006881594657898,
0.30735665559768677,
0.37515944242477417,
-0.4191593825817108,
0.9100266695022583,
-0.5219810009002686,
-0.006540512666106224,
-0.7337258458137512,
-0.6443357467651367,
-0.39040911197662354,
-0.08852443844079971,
0.2879634201526642,
0.3500410318374634,
-0.5997047424316406,
0.4175405204296112,
-0.0148571552708745,
-0.5014734864234924,
-0.2622416317462921,
0.031157108023762703,
0.4857237637042999,
0.6132885217666626,
-0.1537201702594757,
0.03504594415426254,
-0.535137951374054,
-0.6942704916000366,
-0.3293597102165222,
-0.03920328617095947,
-0.15739430487155914,
0.22833557426929474,
0.26573607325553894,
0.09233669191598892,
0.9593069553375244,
-0.7242543697357178,
0.4357045292854309,
-0.45187830924987793,
0.10467879474163055,
0.5847411155700684,
0.19903752207756042,
0.61274653673172,
-0.3484508991241455,
-0.46762537956237793,
-0.22494521737098694,
-0.47988423705101013,
-0.7842006683349609,
-0.276080846786499,
-0.188312366604805,
0.14470230042934418,
0.45593583583831787,
-0.5931429266929626,
0.28012776374816895,
0.33657777309417725,
-0.38522058725357056,
0.9528568387031555,
-0.02473573386669159,
0.3630354702472687,
-0.9937756061553955,
-0.00990382768213749,
-0.04995029419660568,
-0.013029392808675766,
-0.5496781468391418,
0.043195996433496475,
-0.04659964516758919,
-0.2828868329524994,
-0.3213135302066803,
0.5764347314834595,
-0.4539194405078888,
-0.03350483253598213,
-0.3435695469379425,
0.21370673179626465,
0.3561736047267914,
0.09817259758710861,
-0.3138730227947235,
1.2361124753952026,
0.15139426290988922,
-0.7135840654373169,
0.2576003670692444,
0.12294062227010727,
-0.693769097328186,
0.2715472877025604,
-0.7773236036300659,
0.21392294764518738,
-0.2358553260564804,
-0.004300709813833237,
-1.2954250574111938,
-0.3299195170402527,
0.09382812678813934,
-0.47429531812667847,
0.42393526434898376,
0.32154273986816406,
-0.42253369092941284,
-0.3992578387260437,
-0.6088313460350037,
0.28098395466804504,
0.6484037041664124,
-0.6134254932403564,
0.2672805190086365,
-0.11974621564149857,
-0.41331472992897034,
-0.36276906728744507,
-0.2711690366268158,
-0.05131211876869202,
-0.4547407925128937,
-0.6931217908859253,
0.31930258870124817,
-0.29638174176216125,
-0.41289636492729187,
-0.3742246925830841,
0.04097580909729004,
0.5632048845291138,
0.22892960906028748,
0.15746678411960602,
0.3714376389980316,
-0.34131523966789246,
0.29672837257385254,
0.20596593618392944,
-0.12328743189573288,
0.24574148654937744,
-0.0006664586835540831,
0.5667065382003784,
0.37266185879707336,
-0.15478219091892242,
-0.4987933337688446,
0.4803914725780487,
0.39510002732276917,
-0.054991040378808975,
0.5634007453918457,
0.15945865213871002,
-0.19026102125644684,
-0.3105018734931946,
-0.2761315703392029,
0.041425347328186035,
-0.5457122325897217,
0.2139424830675125,
-0.42941129207611084,
-0.8843989968299866,
0.3085939288139343,
-0.0258318018168211,
0.22344161570072174,
0.5424748659133911,
0.942632794380188,
0.13953270018100739,
1.1112984418869019,
0.4989430010318756,
0.37700584530830383,
0.6402644515037537,
0.28556519746780396,
0.228791743516922,
-0.8371807336807251,
-0.17919418215751648,
-0.7373096942901611,
-0.08590538799762726,
-0.4159613847732544,
-0.22503842413425446,
0.20193582773208618,
0.18310636281967163,
-0.16343113780021667,
-0.0025435034185647964,
-0.6005363464355469,
0.6425919532775879,
0.3811570107936859,
-0.022747159004211426,
0.24665628373622894,
-0.041557542979717255,
-0.34359878301620483,
-0.0875515267252922,
-0.5454320907592773,
-1.0283911228179932,
1.0240106582641602,
0.4326481819152832,
0.7640097737312317,
0.08857429772615433,
0.8033674955368042,
0.21577657759189606,
0.4194638133049011,
-0.8688511848449707,
0.4649828374385834,
0.04959341883659363,
-0.1044229120016098,
-0.3045220375061035,
-0.526763379573822,
-0.9324667453765869,
0.09461016207933426,
0.0016436477890238166,
-0.9140928387641907,
-0.2203548401594162,
-0.12298117578029633,
-0.5647351145744324,
-0.3076339662075043,
-0.8243818283081055,
0.8171875476837158,
-0.2282543033361435,
-0.31837308406829834,
0.20345759391784668,
-0.1837281584739685,
0.5192604064941406,
-0.23481445014476776,
0.08082570880651474,
0.0429425872862339,
-0.0685771256685257,
0.7291955351829529,
-0.6275423765182495,
0.6699091196060181,
0.023787084966897964,
-0.4112328588962555,
0.5224553942680359,
-0.029881689697504044,
0.44136008620262146,
-0.005681460257619619,
-0.46649807691574097,
-0.27545955777168274,
-0.5619656443595886,
0.0690382868051529,
-0.7366387248039246,
0.6967082619667053,
-0.6454741358757019,
-0.9648762345314026,
-0.0525287389755249,
-0.5309628844261169,
-0.09139709919691086,
0.010654467158019543,
0.6536498069763184,
0.6319894194602966,
-0.15176600217819214,
0.019006356596946716,
0.4322437345981598,
-0.6882946491241455,
0.6419728994369507,
0.2737860083580017,
-0.42126402258872986,
-0.5323241949081421,
0.6542862057685852,
-0.07820075005292892,
0.2843973636627197,
0.2761376202106476,
0.4973955452442169,
-0.46080905199050903,
-0.5917956829071045,
-0.6574726700782776,
0.06542891263961792,
-0.9154188632965088,
-0.40608757734298706,
-0.458983451128006,
-0.09296812862157822,
-0.36586931347846985,
-0.31455662846565247,
0.25182652473449707,
-0.4543810188770294,
-0.6386200785636902,
-0.2336757630109787,
0.4370150864124298,
1.0737417936325073,
0.19451765716075897,
0.6170263290405273,
-0.8333686590194702,
0.04084555059671402,
0.04175103083252907,
0.3122475743293762,
0.19929997622966766,
-0.6599737405776978,
-0.12870590388774872,
-0.37896668910980225,
-0.4455452263355255,
-1.1123380661010742,
0.2126741111278534,
0.041866328567266464,
0.5446739792823792,
0.4127952456474304,
-0.12334432452917099,
0.4633156955242157,
-0.6988784670829773,
0.9429373741149902,
0.4230072498321533,
-0.9772066473960876,
0.748385488986969,
-0.37129199504852295,
0.6226468682289124,
0.3210446834564209,
0.17582879960536957,
-0.26988980174064636,
-0.28564727306365967,
-0.09729772806167603,
-0.6610516309738159,
0.8287210464477539,
0.23930028080940247,
0.06720342487096786,
-0.09550826996564865,
0.5091773271560669,
0.4487778842449188,
0.14422357082366943,
-0.3822695016860962,
-0.09565834701061249,
0.16524609923362732,
-0.4450714588165283,
-0.09976845979690552,
-0.5875275731086731,
0.1736685335636139,
-0.04461297765374184,
0.5056772232055664,
-0.09468376636505127,
0.015360444784164429,
0.14166264235973358,
0.10188044607639313,
-0.3817538022994995,
0.3204822540283203,
0.8611339330673218,
0.6900104284286499,
0.18034349381923676,
-0.23849919438362122,
0.0798526182770729,
-0.28518757224082947,
0.19668999314308167,
-0.139852836728096,
-0.4861239790916443,
0.24276244640350342,
0.5826518535614014,
1.0101475715637207,
-0.0037467358633875847,
-0.7903886437416077,
0.4150409698486328,
-0.29510462284088135,
-0.10176324844360352,
0.08668980002403259,
0.2577383816242218,
-0.05995137616991997,
0.20969915390014648,
0.36365845799446106,
-0.2075260728597641,
0.34369948506355286,
-0.34873166680336,
0.143108531832695,
0.2404727041721344,
0.08229736983776093,
-0.0777377113699913,
0.590293824672699,
0.17077425122261047,
-0.7015725374221802,
0.44771134853363037,
-0.16196082532405853,
-0.5522450804710388,
0.7585062980651855,
0.6882386207580566,
1.0026676654815674,
-0.4560755491256714,
0.1547897458076477,
0.6144540905952454,
0.10731928795576096,
0.13495033979415894,
0.5110181570053101,
0.027674173936247826,
-0.4230569303035736,
-0.7439156770706177,
-0.9248569011688232,
-0.4252341091632843,
-0.05513424053788185,
-0.4605886936187744,
0.5748721361160278,
-0.3326396346092224,
-0.40780824422836304,
-0.06489938497543335,
-0.13265690207481384,
-0.5916990041732788,
0.1285586655139923,
0.11224505305290222,
0.7999786734580994,
-0.6425427198410034,
0.2223741114139557,
0.6675187945365906,
-0.31445056200027466,
-0.9822275042533875,
-0.03948897123336792,
-0.10233370959758759,
-0.6352592706680298,
0.73454350233078,
0.5387884378433228,
-0.029725104570388794,
-0.10862401127815247,
-0.4152609407901764,
-0.9076514840126038,
0.9410874843597412,
0.2553216516971588,
-0.7726016640663147,
0.024372123181819916,
0.03774873912334442,
0.6068149209022522,
-0.6305282115936279,
0.5904678702354431,
0.3975389003753662,
0.5326374769210815,
0.009181739762425423,
-0.7248128056526184,
0.3186795115470886,
-0.26330915093421936,
0.29158443212509155,
0.34038904309272766,
-0.38261306285858154,
0.7046307325363159,
-0.4350125789642334,
-0.4427444636821747,
0.5060080885887146,
0.5975828170776367,
0.5618155002593994,
0.38575026392936707,
0.20474135875701904,
0.38364335894584656,
0.8383290767669678,
-0.16770122945308685,
1.367940068244934,
-0.1238163486123085,
0.09755981713533401,
1.0880002975463867,
-0.26229438185691833,
0.4460136890411377,
0.4904025197029114,
-0.08702371269464493,
0.5087043046951294,
0.9023246765136719,
0.02549424208700657,
0.43722987174987793,
0.6760543584823608,
0.02711256965994835,
-0.0006288151489570737,
-0.3544986844062805,
-0.16835296154022217,
0.3081817030906677,
0.09310905635356903,
-0.6516843438148499,
-0.21221408247947693,
-0.009079191833734512,
-0.09911283105611801,
0.12845264375209808,
-0.3266822099685669,
0.7852579355239868,
0.0025180880911648273,
-1.0224683284759521,
0.3834742307662964,
0.15990813076496124,
0.42868712544441223,
-0.3088653087615967,
-0.05691523477435112,
-0.18410925567150116,
-0.1124645546078682,
-0.290941447019577,
-0.854104220867157,
0.042160529643297195,
0.45874571800231934,
-0.2986966371536255,
-0.35798442363739014,
0.645638644695282,
-0.14853836596012115,
-0.43708229064941406,
0.03437289968132973,
0.6014903783798218,
0.2757207453250885,
0.21986189484596252,
-0.27160176634788513,
0.4294615685939789,
0.11321676522493362,
-0.7469835877418518,
0.09213375300168991,
0.7330637574195862,
-0.04465317726135254,
0.24168452620506287,
0.7708575129508972,
-0.1176014170050621,
0.07060516625642776,
0.5138238072395325,
0.852208137512207,
-0.7634413242340088,
-0.35903871059417725,
-1.2593352794647217,
0.6817517876625061,
-0.059562817215919495,
-0.6569151878356934,
0.736780047416687,
0.6486631035804749,
0.38387978076934814,
-0.050689782947301865,
0.6295793056488037,
0.2089126706123352,
0.38464900851249695,
-0.8598695993423462,
0.363252729177475,
-0.39797085523605347,
0.4100933074951172,
-0.4687087833881378,
-1.3576260805130005,
-0.1770365834236145,
0.2931540310382843,
-0.287011057138443,
0.08288923650979996,
0.7837353348731995,
0.587742269039154,
0.5229282975196838,
0.23210029304027557,
0.27542755007743835,
-0.08229244500398636,
0.38712531328201294,
0.5312162041664124,
1.263609766960144,
-0.24405750632286072,
0.38034480810165405,
0.044504519551992416,
-0.306471586227417,
-0.11058730632066727,
-1.0403560400009155,
-1.0023201704025269,
-0.3031274080276489,
-0.1898994743824005,
-0.20398233830928802,
-0.13521260023117065,
0.9302710294723511,
-0.0026940791867673397,
-0.565854012966156,
-0.22739437222480774,
-0.13140733540058136,
0.23327435553073883,
0.2526223659515381,
-0.37671926617622375,
0.2956835925579071,
-0.7041085362434387,
-0.8457075953483582,
0.49305030703544617,
0.3327168822288513,
0.03751242533326149,
-0.20311228930950165,
-0.24919694662094116,
0.25780701637268066,
0.23730017244815826,
0.7838330864906311,
-0.3169260323047638,
-0.737179696559906,
-0.37982237339019775,
0.19701328873634338,
-0.2598155438899994,
0.012187125161290169,
1.0061615705490112,
-0.6146063208580017,
0.3315966725349426,
0.8472809195518494,
0.6855441927909851,
-0.11906340718269348,
0.31292837858200073,
1.0361603498458862,
-0.6350806355476379,
-0.345733106136322,
0.11020267009735107,
0.5241300463676453,
0.37670183181762695,
-0.7021209001541138,
0.4304727017879486,
-0.20419006049633026,
-0.7415972352027893,
-0.9153783321380615,
0.23332341015338898,
-0.7737419605255127,
-0.37270915508270264,
1.381676197052002,
-0.032892730087041855,
-0.14301039278507233,
0.31612128019332886,
-0.5411278009414673,
0.2424161434173584,
-0.6520540714263916,
0.5542916059494019,
0.9203073382377625,
-0.35025736689567566,
-0.17345529794692993,
-0.2846963703632355,
0.45526841282844543,
0.43887513875961304,
-0.863856315612793,
-0.05895792692899704,
0.7588506937026978,
-0.12151407450437546,
0.1353849470615387,
0.4496161639690399,
-0.05041483789682388,
0.2952277660369873,
-0.2386852204799652,
-0.18640291690826416,
0.017918510362505913,
-0.381048321723938,
-0.663776159286499,
0.26418617367744446,
0.2344498634338379,
-0.02162591926753521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09967v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09967v1
|
Bag of Lies: Robustness in Continuous Pre-training BERT
| 2024-06-14T12:16:08 | 2024-06-14T12:16:08 |
Ine Gevers, Walter Daelemans
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This study aims to acquire more insights into the continuous pre-training
phase of BERT regarding entity knowledge, using the COVID-19 pandemic as a case
study. Since the pandemic emerged after the last update of BERT's pre-training
data, the model has little to no entity knowledge about COVID-19. Using
continuous pre-training, we control what entity knowledge is available to the
model. We compare the baseline BERT model with the further pre-trained variants
on the fact-checking benchmark Check-COVID. To test the robustness of
continuous pre-training, we experiment with several adversarial methods to
manipulate the input data, such as training on misinformation and shuffling the
word order until the input becomes nonsensical. Surprisingly, our findings
reveal that these methods do not degrade, and sometimes even improve, the
model's downstream performance. This suggests that continuous pre-training of
BERT is robust against misinformation. Furthermore, we are releasing a new
dataset, consisting of original texts from academic publications in the
LitCovid repository and their AI-generated false counterparts.
|
[
-0.4000268876552582,
-0.8757616877555847,
0.3455202579498291,
-0.07471861690282822,
-0.2446698546409607,
0.11941098421812057,
-0.18029727041721344,
-0.5166454315185547,
-0.015544882044196129,
0.27152514457702637,
-0.5391072034835815,
-0.35751456022262573,
-0.7047073841094971,
-0.24941815435886383,
-0.6780902743339539,
1.5407929420471191,
0.3005754053592682,
0.19927102327346802,
-0.4029231369495392,
0.10019964724779129,
0.13233472406864166,
-0.7265790700912476,
-0.4695659279823303,
-0.3729413151741028,
0.5706678628921509,
0.3073210120201111,
0.834694504737854,
0.1580771803855896,
0.6605690717697144,
0.15652106702327728,
0.32134565711021423,
-0.20620791614055634,
-0.7200560569763184,
0.007882669568061829,
-0.14570355415344238,
-0.6329078674316406,
-0.2666183412075043,
0.10520120710134506,
0.1867314726114273,
0.3221183717250824,
-0.2622988820075989,
0.3641126751899719,
0.07373744994401932,
0.25349920988082886,
-0.8117551207542419,
-0.3475474715232849,
-0.9830610752105713,
-0.15211305022239685,
-0.33645498752593994,
0.054436590522527695,
-0.5152093172073364,
-0.2330845147371292,
0.5826176404953003,
-0.5265531539916992,
0.4499673545360565,
-0.051250655204057693,
1.4066613912582397,
0.5652452707290649,
-0.02769394777715206,
-0.4852352440357208,
-0.8387139439582825,
0.7093529105186462,
-0.4745067059993744,
0.05918557569384575,
0.7123852968215942,
0.3094920814037323,
-0.09528054296970367,
-1.0063867568969727,
-0.7252241373062134,
-0.14736711978912354,
0.1342894732952118,
0.13759909570217133,
-0.21662725508213043,
0.11175841093063354,
0.12062401324510574,
0.12224078923463821,
-0.7830039858818054,
0.07759294658899307,
-0.2584366202354431,
-0.2687235474586487,
0.6186373233795166,
-0.45028313994407654,
0.31434953212738037,
0.08134623616933823,
-0.7920249104499817,
-0.34140273928642273,
-0.6861161589622498,
0.2741842567920685,
0.4804600477218628,
-0.2548985481262207,
-0.0035038962960243225,
0.18750818073749542,
0.33530786633491516,
0.5336982607841492,
0.046864476054906845,
-0.32521358132362366,
-0.06518399715423584,
-0.3471166491508484,
-0.4738827347755432,
0.20634415745735168,
0.42665377259254456,
0.14533370733261108,
0.19742700457572937,
-0.17403608560562134,
-0.19723352789878845,
0.16561070084571838,
0.7581408023834229,
-0.7563580274581909,
-0.8169662952423096,
0.25296932458877563,
-0.45525991916656494,
-0.4436465799808502,
0.058187320828437805,
-0.6905698180198669,
-0.13796305656433105,
0.0008264860371127725,
0.7165877223014832,
-0.7217581868171692,
0.12652385234832764,
-0.05252551659941673,
-0.1816224753856659,
0.2730836272239685,
0.45275163650512695,
-0.46904969215393066,
0.24126185476779938,
0.34160152077674866,
0.4525547921657562,
0.010833253152668476,
-0.13178527355194092,
-0.4890505075454712,
-0.1266828030347824,
-0.3581993281841278,
0.6080678701400757,
-0.4463464915752411,
-0.18779239058494568,
0.05176805332303047,
-0.2682439088821411,
0.0429893359541893,
-0.3105678856372833,
0.5198752880096436,
-0.5826482772827148,
0.1652119755744934,
-0.5547550916671753,
-0.2550243139266968,
-0.20648689568042755,
0.49324679374694824,
-0.43214038014411926,
0.8534045219421387,
-0.1687334179878235,
-0.9651167392730713,
0.6287636160850525,
-0.505743145942688,
-0.3926275968551636,
-0.0792662650346756,
-0.3623500466346741,
-0.7731661796569824,
-0.2812381088733673,
0.3233166038990021,
0.36844098567962646,
0.129257932305336,
0.3077296018600464,
-0.6796406507492065,
-0.36279675364494324,
0.3886304497718811,
-0.43092915415763855,
1.0146620273590088,
0.15753532946109772,
-0.3601676821708679,
-0.3338877558708191,
-0.6838034987449646,
-0.0645873099565506,
0.08186545222997665,
-0.10200076550245285,
-0.35198700428009033,
0.2474062144756317,
-0.20400114357471466,
0.023503949865698814,
0.32641223073005676,
-0.45687320828437805,
0.340156227350235,
-0.10857628285884857,
0.06144453212618828,
0.7400360703468323,
-0.10639297962188721,
0.3224447965621948,
-0.70888751745224,
0.4398653209209442,
0.242825448513031,
0.532516360282898,
-0.07126276195049286,
-0.2509258985519409,
-0.825098991394043,
-0.3839579224586487,
0.5240040421485901,
0.7074662446975708,
-0.967621922492981,
0.6971988081932068,
-0.17970889806747437,
-0.7731775641441345,
-0.11530088633298874,
-0.06956645846366882,
0.07761113345623016,
0.6885018348693848,
0.45012447237968445,
-0.32750311493873596,
-0.6728283762931824,
-0.6599264144897461,
-0.0402766615152359,
-0.2946304678916931,
0.027967801317572594,
-0.08456950634717941,
0.8502840995788574,
-0.38071760535240173,
0.9232513308525085,
-0.23028995096683502,
-0.03877989947795868,
0.04304901510477066,
0.5052493810653687,
-0.0977584719657898,
0.61846524477005,
0.8021303415298462,
-0.70799320936203,
-0.13194885849952698,
-0.41068223118782043,
-0.5227579474449158,
0.44966861605644226,
-0.40924233198165894,
0.044364556670188904,
0.03789650276303291,
0.20011328160762787,
-0.3774477243423462,
0.7265400886535645,
0.4972728490829468,
-0.04366665333509445,
0.6655135154724121,
-0.40948835015296936,
-0.19549982249736786,
-0.8322988748550415,
0.16623921692371368,
-0.34164270758628845,
-0.26722100377082825,
-0.5753924250602722,
-0.1843666285276413,
-0.10783376544713974,
-0.14835719764232635,
-0.21019896864891052,
-0.0503687784075737,
-0.15364880859851837,
0.04743245989084244,
-0.07868961989879608,
-0.12797120213508606,
0.1426931470632553,
0.26409971714019775,
-0.16329891979694366,
0.7560505270957947,
0.7557128667831421,
-0.8146822452545166,
0.35603877902030945,
0.28485777974128723,
-0.5750606656074524,
0.3350828289985657,
-0.7500110864639282,
0.22530587017536163,
-0.27889344096183777,
0.5153111219406128,
-0.7826846241950989,
-0.15422509610652924,
0.2530003488063812,
-0.5842838883399963,
0.3311801552772522,
0.04205680638551712,
-0.49553820490837097,
-0.28335028886795044,
-0.3596135377883911,
-0.03686951845884323,
0.5868395566940308,
-0.5563262701034546,
0.3851360082626343,
0.24701541662216187,
-0.09214532375335693,
-1.0570746660232544,
-0.9406290054321289,
-0.19426089525222778,
-0.11615891009569168,
-0.5100157260894775,
0.3244772255420685,
-0.2811649441719055,
-0.20127107203006744,
0.08819006383419037,
-0.3729749917984009,
-0.3964625597000122,
0.4402522146701813,
0.1369285136461258,
0.3080042898654938,
-0.0876438319683075,
0.4480397403240204,
-0.10644134134054184,
0.2890048921108246,
0.08935779333114624,
-0.3314204514026642,
0.4748818576335907,
-0.2350432276725769,
-0.3901977241039276,
-0.0544440895318985,
0.11107628047466278,
0.42592883110046387,
-0.10519944131374359,
0.9283989667892456,
0.8441121578216553,
-0.5524469017982483,
-0.13032037019729614,
-0.5514150261878967,
-0.2175763100385666,
-0.36358118057250977,
0.21756023168563843,
-0.18920652568340302,
-0.3832985758781433,
0.5114406943321228,
0.00995694287121296,
0.017238277941942215,
0.2943207919597626,
0.21314604580402374,
-0.525084376335144,
0.5200141072273254,
0.8334704637527466,
-0.0874003916978836,
0.35012495517730713,
-0.29011186957359314,
0.2749859690666199,
-0.19859887659549713,
-0.16908682882785797,
-0.6688863039016724,
-0.31260451674461365,
-0.5533003211021423,
-0.06502258777618408,
0.39052334427833557,
0.449541836977005,
-0.3626631200313568,
0.19959157705307007,
-0.3453028202056885,
0.3213302493095398,
0.5760961771011353,
0.3401104807853699,
-0.1525619477033615,
0.027494575828313828,
-0.09627074003219604,
0.23361365497112274,
-1.00856351852417,
-0.4362587332725525,
1.210955023765564,
0.3728208541870117,
1.0168465375900269,
-0.06093025207519531,
0.8246868252754211,
0.4686228334903717,
0.19627611339092255,
-0.31032267212867737,
0.22030150890350342,
-0.08246321231126785,
-0.7203168869018555,
-0.4262838661670685,
0.019922127947211266,
-1.079438328742981,
-0.3107512891292572,
-0.4556536376476288,
-0.8355023860931396,
0.49071982502937317,
0.24526558816432953,
-0.80096834897995,
0.3342796564102173,
-0.7578302621841431,
0.5716711282730103,
-0.6108689904212952,
-0.13695324957370758,
-0.23448054492473602,
-0.9234034419059753,
0.1832665652036667,
-0.2930779457092285,
-0.02360224351286888,
0.11714019626379013,
0.01256474107503891,
0.8589399456977844,
-0.5016875267028809,
0.8571310043334961,
-0.05791809782385826,
0.15927204489707947,
0.29211190342903137,
-0.24923604726791382,
0.7019039988517761,
0.3626173138618469,
0.1558072865009308,
0.30343303084373474,
0.35377877950668335,
-0.9078064560890198,
-0.25533056259155273,
0.39299505949020386,
-1.1489061117172241,
-0.4492325484752655,
-0.848159909248352,
-0.17541362345218658,
-0.025132421404123306,
0.22230994701385498,
0.8300499320030212,
0.27598798274993896,
-0.32442954182624817,
0.5389021635055542,
1.171559453010559,
-0.32766592502593994,
0.539983868598938,
0.268754243850708,
-0.08567346632480621,
-0.30090197920799255,
0.6308097839355469,
0.48824000358581543,
0.18825523555278778,
0.47236332297325134,
0.037994444370269775,
-0.04576040059328079,
-0.573591947555542,
-0.20765767991542816,
-0.08294451981782913,
-0.6852133870124817,
-0.23046226799488068,
-0.5480883717536926,
-0.4227277338504791,
-0.5597148537635803,
-0.322543740272522,
-0.41937869787216187,
0.11790697276592255,
-0.21945787966251373,
0.0762515738606453,
0.25218626856803894,
0.7271601557731628,
-0.003864362370222807,
0.3917873501777649,
-0.7298290729522705,
0.17053499817848206,
0.46133196353912354,
0.14900998771190643,
-0.4594763219356537,
-0.2690529525279999,
-0.3707807958126068,
0.3773458003997803,
-0.37243449687957764,
-0.9256812930107117,
0.21614018082618713,
0.2358633428812027,
0.6425945162773132,
0.6730648279190063,
0.49362194538116455,
0.5848893523216248,
-0.10288713127374649,
1.0653818845748901,
0.14017896354198456,
-0.9070828557014465,
0.5881969332695007,
-0.17106911540031433,
0.21784693002700806,
0.6171815395355225,
0.8674236536026001,
0.12617619335651398,
-0.18901994824409485,
-1.1253596544265747,
-0.4798295199871063,
0.4452041685581207,
0.3207751214504242,
-0.13094954192638397,
0.2414741963148117,
0.03028876706957817,
0.3936050534248352,
0.4571992754936218,
-0.6962326765060425,
-0.3615334928035736,
-0.5863149762153625,
0.008386220782995224,
-0.14302393794059753,
-0.49297836422920227,
-0.40329042077064514,
-0.20150168240070343,
0.8185907602310181,
0.09645165503025055,
0.3872257471084595,
0.4218975901603699,
-0.321839839220047,
0.23468387126922607,
0.09563258290290833,
0.8252678513526917,
1.0128320455551147,
-0.3693842589855194,
0.3058395981788635,
0.2613137662410736,
-0.8373902440071106,
-0.03580614924430847,
0.26206719875335693,
-0.2915993928909302,
0.18109802901744843,
0.4945130944252014,
0.7075631618499756,
-0.07524508982896805,
-0.5075823664665222,
0.7362462878227234,
-0.1989315003156662,
-0.2298174500465393,
-0.814961850643158,
-0.0443120114505291,
-0.439291387796402,
0.12038183212280273,
0.3534591495990753,
0.7094727158546448,
-0.12320221960544586,
-0.6018707752227783,
0.3386475741863251,
0.41303253173828125,
-0.08004232496023178,
-0.3328807055950165,
0.20521482825279236,
0.09726063907146454,
0.09281323850154877,
0.7220887541770935,
-0.09818994998931885,
-0.6339313983917236,
0.42118868231773376,
0.14184828102588654,
0.48466020822525024,
-0.333045095205307,
0.3562070429325104,
0.1360132396221161,
0.7146726846694946,
-0.0006756276707164943,
0.11699941754341125,
-0.34221965074539185,
-0.8193387389183044,
-0.2877487242221832,
-0.36236414313316345,
-0.3085564970970154,
0.7019195556640625,
-0.8253155946731567,
0.24113298952579498,
-0.4307408928871155,
-0.23383425176143646,
-0.26041340827941895,
0.13005106151103973,
-1.013033151626587,
0.5761424899101257,
0.10153282433748245,
0.8642449378967285,
-0.8058313727378845,
1.2246146202087402,
0.625334620475769,
-0.5660125017166138,
-0.5646011829376221,
0.508988618850708,
-0.3825247883796692,
-0.7132624983787537,
0.4563046991825104,
0.14126963913440704,
0.20926761627197266,
-0.2797817885875702,
-0.9928245544433594,
-1.0681949853897095,
1.1032142639160156,
0.4933493733406067,
-0.6533188223838806,
-0.22960592806339264,
-0.1145990788936615,
0.3922455310821533,
0.009218401275575161,
0.16828151047229767,
0.3954123556613922,
0.37550094723701477,
-0.09613821655511856,
-0.7550286650657654,
-0.5203074812889099,
-0.13089530169963837,
-0.27126237750053406,
-0.29031023383140564,
-0.42252588272094727,
0.7992443442344666,
-0.14917723834514618,
-0.16361041367053986,
-0.0912458598613739,
0.6256881356239319,
-0.11687996983528137,
0.45424342155456543,
0.7145176529884338,
0.7069571018218994,
1.3706871271133423,
-0.2634444832801819,
0.9960342049598694,
-0.2178676426410675,
0.25842082500457764,
1.231597900390625,
-0.14122162759304047,
0.7655888795852661,
0.3288705348968506,
-0.09032034128904343,
0.7630036473274231,
0.7680953741073608,
-0.08608576655387878,
0.6115491390228271,
0.23904134333133698,
-0.22854465246200562,
-0.4174075722694397,
0.23917655646800995,
-0.5894378423690796,
0.5487964749336243,
0.41956180334091187,
-0.24562779068946838,
-0.24821063876152039,
0.30616679787635803,
0.06321949511766434,
-0.21248380839824677,
-0.12084748595952988,
0.6267160177230835,
-0.2556469738483429,
-0.7208731770515442,
0.6963182687759399,
-0.3298353850841522,
0.65514075756073,
-0.811695396900177,
0.2216622531414032,
0.035210516303777695,
0.21234765648841858,
-0.11034812778234482,
-0.4549541473388672,
0.34748074412345886,
-0.07557787746191025,
-0.2837761342525482,
-0.0736922100186348,
1.0561028718948364,
-0.4646090865135193,
-0.26507148146629333,
-0.09877635538578033,
0.3226794898509979,
0.21264100074768066,
-0.13422821462154388,
-0.7988932132720947,
0.17167003452777863,
-0.13924722373485565,
-0.050370387732982635,
0.3393710255622864,
0.16649262607097626,
0.1160350814461708,
0.8102086186408997,
0.5850667357444763,
0.168132483959198,
0.22735220193862915,
-0.44506555795669556,
0.7294948697090149,
-0.14271999895572662,
-0.440303236246109,
-0.7107482552528381,
0.4470698833465576,
-0.3301542401313782,
-0.06842369586229324,
0.6612952947616577,
0.3236115872859955,
1.2263679504394531,
-0.24733956158161163,
1.0737993717193604,
-0.08746214956045151,
0.34888264536857605,
-0.39485815167427063,
1.0174779891967773,
-0.23470507562160492,
0.0791093111038208,
0.07871679961681366,
-0.39060795307159424,
0.05854688212275505,
0.6276044845581055,
-0.47361302375793457,
-0.0648733600974083,
0.8173784613609314,
0.622270405292511,
0.26239141821861267,
-0.007032584398984909,
0.33077529072761536,
0.23653632402420044,
0.31121963262557983,
0.22634409368038177,
0.6040740609169006,
-0.5550656914710999,
0.777239978313446,
-0.3755195140838623,
-0.1574094444513321,
-0.3865261375904083,
-0.9512297511100769,
-0.974608302116394,
-0.6410379409790039,
-0.35302847623825073,
-0.5472428798675537,
0.44049569964408875,
0.7511464357376099,
1.028125524520874,
-0.8027054071426392,
0.3069961369037628,
-0.18213286995887756,
0.14226344227790833,
-0.22984415292739868,
-0.16774748265743256,
0.2828885018825531,
-0.5938464403152466,
-0.29427337646484375,
0.19955258071422577,
-0.04453999921679497,
0.2625976502895355,
-0.3699471056461334,
-0.030277147889137268,
-0.5233234763145447,
0.38091304898262024,
0.3507864773273468,
0.26952728629112244,
-0.5867632627487183,
-0.38839706778526306,
-0.0420215018093586,
-0.17747677862644196,
-0.17995993793010712,
0.5800361037254333,
-0.8716974854469299,
0.6365361213684082,
0.40789595246315,
0.9750807285308838,
0.3805738091468811,
-0.010266868397593498,
0.5345380902290344,
-0.8743534088134766,
0.08051122725009918,
0.30604371428489685,
0.4186267554759979,
0.2004370093345642,
-0.49572527408599854,
0.12426600605249405,
0.254183828830719,
-0.7728830575942993,
-0.9167131185531616,
0.09608090668916702,
-0.9565665125846863,
-0.3366311192512512,
0.7717977166175842,
-0.5541115403175354,
-0.30300232768058777,
-0.25842851400375366,
-0.005589001812040806,
0.3575197160243988,
-0.14700110256671906,
1.068203091621399,
0.9920428991317749,
0.1364295780658722,
0.11707311868667603,
-0.22505734860897064,
0.7727531790733337,
0.5044258832931519,
-0.733006477355957,
-0.560321569442749,
0.07197923213243484,
0.355848103761673,
0.36146488785743713,
0.3815711736679077,
0.24848107993602753,
0.3678480386734009,
0.2400275617837906,
0.11064539104700089,
0.09444230049848557,
-0.6368139386177063,
-0.05062413215637207,
0.18508879840373993,
0.0712060034275055,
-0.527009904384613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09961v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09961v1
|
ChartMimic: Evaluating LMM's Cross-Modal Reasoning Capability via Chart-to-Code Generation
| 2024-06-14T12:10:51 | 2024-06-14T12:10:51 |
Chufan Shi, Cheng Yang, Yaxin Liu, Bo Shui, Junjie Wang, Mohan Jing, Linran Xu, Xinyu Zhu, Siheng Li, Yuxiang Zhang, Gongye Liu, Xiaomei Nie, Deng Cai, Yujiu Yang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
We introduce a new benchmark, ChartMimic, aimed at assessing the
visually-grounded code generation capabilities of large multimodal models
(LMMs). ChartMimic utilizes information-intensive visual charts and textual
instructions as inputs, requiring LMMs to generate the corresponding code for
chart rendering. ChartMimic includes 1,000 human-curated (figure, instruction,
code) triplets, which represent the authentic chart use cases found in
scientific papers across various domains(e.g., Physics, Computer Science,
Economics, etc). These charts span 18 regular types and 4 advanced types,
diversifying into 191 subcategories. Furthermore, we propose multi-level
evaluation metrics to provide an automatic and thorough assessment of the
output code and the rendered charts. Unlike existing code generation
benchmarks, ChartMimic places emphasis on evaluating LMMs' capacity to
harmonize a blend of cognitive capabilities, encompassing visual understanding,
code generation, and cross-modal reasoning. The evaluation of 3 proprietary
models and 11 open-weight models highlights the substantial challenges posed by
ChartMimic. Even the advanced GPT-4V, Claude-3-opus only achieve an average
score of 73.2 and 53.7, respectively, indicating significant room for
improvement. We anticipate that ChartMimic will inspire the development of
LMMs, advancing the pursuit of artificial general intelligence.
|
[
-0.46147966384887695,
-0.5131032466888428,
0.581693708896637,
0.21789684891700745,
-0.25674647092819214,
0.3720610737800598,
-0.23466137051582336,
-0.3984701931476593,
-0.1818695366382599,
0.3613004982471466,
-0.5225768685340881,
-0.7760843634605408,
-0.4811217486858368,
0.0456090122461319,
-0.26291966438293457,
0.7011423707008362,
-0.05457379296422005,
0.19844315946102142,
-0.5805163979530334,
-0.06465357542037964,
-0.6309831142425537,
-0.5569806098937988,
-0.17142486572265625,
-0.018213074654340744,
0.5259262919425964,
0.7903168797492981,
0.712774395942688,
0.5508427619934082,
0.7809885740280151,
0.22160257399082184,
0.6283230185508728,
0.576324462890625,
-0.7702542543411255,
0.239120751619339,
0.12837634980678558,
-0.33158403635025024,
-0.7328805327415466,
0.16425743699073792,
0.5042831897735596,
0.7268272042274475,
0.24613416194915771,
0.5608457922935486,
-0.05810871720314026,
0.7728835344314575,
-0.7429325580596924,
0.7093713879585266,
-0.365755558013916,
-0.04558978229761124,
-0.009174412116408348,
-0.4336392879486084,
-0.7089499235153198,
-0.3772128224372864,
-0.11348862200975418,
-0.6968033909797668,
-0.24489638209342957,
0.34089425206184387,
0.46105727553367615,
0.2314334362745285,
-0.727949321269989,
-0.3051336407661438,
-0.5919506549835205,
0.757989227771759,
-0.42685526609420776,
0.5672306418418884,
0.27589261531829834,
0.7287316918373108,
0.07484905421733856,
-1.0791016817092896,
-0.1696028858423233,
-0.5838350653648376,
0.32755547761917114,
0.4691610336303711,
-0.3541813790798187,
-0.27732858061790466,
0.37962257862091064,
0.1716674417257309,
-0.6197926998138428,
-0.0175308920443058,
-0.5766432285308838,
-0.12263451516628265,
0.9128017425537109,
0.5231286883354187,
0.36371392011642456,
-0.17274333536624908,
-0.43021857738494873,
-0.25308218598365784,
-0.5713903903961182,
0.050902388989925385,
0.2894599139690399,
0.18508008122444153,
-0.30114296078681946,
0.6592473983764648,
-0.1923460066318512,
0.3565845787525177,
-0.162400484085083,
-0.12438640743494034,
0.36196550726890564,
-0.5942553281784058,
-0.27001503109931946,
-0.15408767759799957,
0.918820858001709,
0.846612811088562,
0.4369259178638458,
0.05513830482959747,
-0.1683918535709381,
0.23027943074703217,
0.3887919485569,
-0.8010010123252869,
-0.38121217489242554,
-0.018185948953032494,
-0.5940843224525452,
-0.11002777516841888,
-0.009591593407094479,
-0.6862150430679321,
-0.5158300399780273,
-0.2931063175201416,
0.28701233863830566,
-0.665188193321228,
-0.07758357375860214,
-0.0900760367512703,
-0.16846002638339996,
-0.054216787219047546,
0.45782700181007385,
-0.48817384243011475,
-0.005163668189197779,
0.7259101867675781,
0.7741142511367798,
-0.21831855177879333,
-0.32223549485206604,
-0.3857244551181793,
0.24613334238529205,
-0.6675886511802673,
0.7320834994316101,
-0.5924479365348816,
-0.5745278000831604,
-0.3352934420108795,
-0.37437161803245544,
-0.2832120656967163,
-0.532669186592102,
0.4485030174255371,
-0.28966426849365234,
0.01239779219031334,
-0.13840876519680023,
-0.6387710571289062,
-0.40653201937675476,
0.26362332701683044,
-0.8375971913337708,
0.8342944979667664,
0.27231699228286743,
-0.5240996479988098,
0.6073250770568848,
-0.8040436506271362,
-0.21610885858535767,
0.13285228610038757,
-0.6272956132888794,
-0.4722485840320587,
-0.1605941504240036,
0.25758039951324463,
0.3335128724575043,
-0.7383442521095276,
0.17240390181541443,
-0.5997650623321533,
-0.2249574512243271,
0.31972238421440125,
-0.332396924495697,
0.3974928855895996,
0.4418606460094452,
-0.3635611832141876,
0.5631532669067383,
-0.7640737891197205,
0.25944992899894714,
0.1662856936454773,
-0.19153040647506714,
0.023202549666166306,
0.06334952265024185,
0.2346113920211792,
0.23939330875873566,
0.05729466676712036,
-0.12214475870132446,
0.1458905041217804,
0.22951865196228027,
0.5177971720695496,
0.5591141581535339,
0.03458677604794502,
0.21813979744911194,
-0.4548908472061157,
0.7287068963050842,
0.06379593163728714,
0.46495071053504944,
-0.34707945585250854,
-0.8666320443153381,
-0.6124388575553894,
-0.6616421341896057,
0.19377028942108154,
0.44861191511154175,
-0.6324307322502136,
0.2805284261703491,
-0.4472796320915222,
-1.0218424797058105,
-0.08370456099510193,
0.23973384499549866,
0.36464494466781616,
0.3802894055843353,
0.26202699542045593,
-0.5273261070251465,
-0.4853185713291168,
-1.0157291889190674,
0.029708119109272957,
-0.016561945900321007,
-0.14538879692554474,
0.18683893978595734,
0.6120133399963379,
-0.4006717801094055,
0.7083472609519958,
-0.1897086352109909,
-0.05632222071290016,
-0.2522144019603729,
0.2955940067768097,
-0.19286483526229858,
0.3864448368549347,
0.7654424905776978,
-0.4915895164012909,
-0.2726362943649292,
0.05712244659662247,
-0.7709936499595642,
-0.00948805920779705,
-0.11004377901554108,
-0.23703141510486603,
-0.018461236730217934,
0.5613890290260315,
-0.39282193779945374,
0.5067723393440247,
0.5068016052246094,
-0.3976592719554901,
0.5975849628448486,
-0.19871555268764496,
0.43000802397727966,
-0.8682007193565369,
0.26299378275871277,
-0.04335297271609306,
-0.20587556064128876,
-0.4211142957210541,
0.18299464881420135,
0.3267563283443451,
-0.4102061688899994,
-0.10894042253494263,
0.22140805423259735,
-0.6049781441688538,
-0.3695591390132904,
0.042175836861133575,
0.14758798480033875,
0.015561101026833057,
0.5118438005447388,
-0.36726853251457214,
0.6896708011627197,
0.4878849685192108,
-0.3907848000526428,
0.5519119501113892,
-0.13229508697986603,
-0.6034879684448242,
0.6171035766601562,
-0.34722334146499634,
0.030701277777552605,
0.27586740255355835,
0.37123456597328186,
-1.109287977218628,
0.10252975672483444,
0.2732868492603302,
-0.36916598677635193,
0.07334505766630173,
0.23750953376293182,
-0.5889977216720581,
-0.3391087055206299,
-0.4137701094150543,
0.7149503231048584,
0.5334181785583496,
-0.16844527423381805,
0.7125529646873474,
0.2696491777896881,
0.05176489055156708,
-0.09648077934980392,
-0.608659565448761,
0.21486422419548035,
-0.06031389161944389,
-0.7689533829689026,
-0.2942722737789154,
-0.3707233965396881,
-0.26442909240722656,
-0.29506710171699524,
-0.06956450641155243,
0.23669902980327606,
0.09869978576898575,
0.423549085855484,
0.39309239387512207,
-0.4168357849121094,
-0.09565329551696777,
-0.22847923636436462,
-0.2550041973590851,
0.30706077814102173,
-0.07630959153175354,
0.4462677836418152,
-0.2799960672855377,
-0.9584371447563171,
-0.26877230405807495,
0.2920956313610077,
0.9240474104881287,
-0.39991581439971924,
-0.003270739456638694,
0.6018103957176208,
-0.11583685129880905,
-0.15062937140464783,
-0.26184332370758057,
0.20026655495166779,
-0.4091012477874756,
0.48973968625068665,
-0.42200949788093567,
-0.5159273147583008,
0.43841552734375,
-0.17141257226467133,
0.14421556890010834,
0.5105666518211365,
0.9034067988395691,
0.16412502527236938,
1.4381890296936035,
0.329302579164505,
0.2088882029056549,
0.19838596880435944,
-0.38141754269599915,
0.1979973465204239,
-0.3770345449447632,
-0.2915550172328949,
-0.32511624693870544,
-0.5917887091636658,
-0.5379720330238342,
-0.9261807799339294,
0.5944675207138062,
0.019824938848614693,
-0.3850175738334656,
-0.05236760526895523,
-0.42984217405319214,
0.06287677586078644,
0.6777868866920471,
0.07716630399227142,
0.3730945289134979,
-0.18050862848758698,
-0.3114030659198761,
0.08251699805259705,
-0.7746751308441162,
-0.5454737544059753,
1.5457706451416016,
0.41340675950050354,
0.838992714881897,
-0.013718646951019764,
0.4273279905319214,
0.48475831747055054,
0.5896588563919067,
-0.8446010947227478,
0.6543056964874268,
0.1296384185552597,
-0.44569718837738037,
-0.03810456022620201,
-0.6570855975151062,
-0.8146357536315918,
0.02793991193175316,
-0.30182313919067383,
-0.5498425364494324,
-0.005214588716626167,
0.1069541722536087,
-0.1894766092300415,
0.257882684469223,
-1.0384551286697388,
1.1897932291030884,
-0.6523481011390686,
-0.17058037221431732,
-0.5463882684707642,
-0.5575582385063171,
0.624750018119812,
-0.28675565123558044,
0.4637976586818695,
-0.31864675879478455,
-0.3080466687679291,
0.6212486624717712,
-0.2977599501609802,
0.7869442105293274,
0.030900660902261734,
-0.19980987906455994,
0.16089977324008942,
0.3806135356426239,
-0.04639260843396187,
-0.020405905321240425,
0.053128499537706375,
0.1700151264667511,
0.12285362929105759,
-0.42636486887931824,
-0.6434807777404785,
0.5246622562408447,
-0.7379748225212097,
-0.29388895630836487,
-0.1905149519443512,
-0.9760677814483643,
-0.45631706714630127,
0.13771376013755798,
0.02283347211778164,
0.619391918182373,
-0.24396850168704987,
0.3331146836280823,
0.03156372904777527,
-0.157183438539505,
0.08046158403158188,
0.11329379677772522,
-0.6489672064781189,
-0.6630143523216248,
0.9710381031036377,
-0.07555992901325226,
0.48845648765563965,
0.2191421240568161,
0.056313373148441315,
-0.07880180329084396,
-0.47226935625076294,
-0.6543548107147217,
-0.06169592961668968,
-0.9655218720436096,
-0.26511406898498535,
-0.1703011393547058,
-0.12608560919761658,
-0.271199494600296,
-0.023116378113627434,
-0.3176930844783783,
-0.5580127835273743,
-0.0825752541422844,
0.08626509457826614,
0.25643354654312134,
0.9444117546081543,
-0.08454452455043793,
-0.1591225266456604,
-0.8952297568321228,
0.4385567903518677,
0.25936347246170044,
0.31039586663246155,
0.025997333228588104,
-0.022367939352989197,
-0.4433172643184662,
0.05414159595966339,
-0.5499828457832336,
-0.7825227379798889,
0.0034955362789332867,
-0.015260482206940651,
0.6515280604362488,
0.666770339012146,
-0.04583313316106796,
0.703857421875,
-0.32601267099380493,
0.6493186354637146,
0.6195698976516724,
-0.9779340028762817,
0.326144814491272,
-0.2852878272533417,
0.43391746282577515,
0.25109758973121643,
0.3082168400287628,
-0.28711241483688354,
-0.663699746131897,
-0.45941072702407837,
-0.7268013954162598,
0.48382171988487244,
0.21885819733142853,
-0.26397377252578735,
0.03149330988526344,
-0.15951691567897797,
0.18151067197322845,
0.19960041344165802,
-0.4612485468387604,
-0.2093127816915512,
-0.5565285682678223,
-0.3705732226371765,
-0.42671287059783936,
0.007581490091979504,
-0.37014347314834595,
-0.4882892668247223,
0.18928319215774536,
-0.41004645824432373,
0.03303024545311928,
0.04553387314081192,
-0.21740946173667908,
-0.2857978045940399,
0.01917080394923687,
0.8797720670700073,
1.1782172918319702,
-0.1725810021162033,
0.1788526475429535,
-0.08689635246992111,
-0.41682764887809753,
-0.13670314848423004,
0.1357118934392929,
-0.024562345817685127,
-0.34469014406204224,
0.6271063685417175,
0.8385158777236938,
0.5082024335861206,
-1.1166694164276123,
0.3952200412750244,
-0.10714371502399445,
-0.36834239959716797,
0.017069701105356216,
0.06751231104135513,
0.2733210027217865,
0.490168958902359,
0.41717252135276794,
0.15083934366703033,
-0.09680961817502975,
-0.6373640298843384,
0.25428226590156555,
0.4701392352581024,
-0.12916456162929535,
-0.19242264330387115,
0.8358787298202515,
0.2884528934955597,
-0.04626309871673584,
0.3600099980831146,
-0.10970349609851837,
-0.4222797751426697,
0.7977908253669739,
0.24808382987976074,
0.7863711714744568,
-0.00999806635081768,
0.07141372561454773,
0.385044664144516,
0.5600512623786926,
0.4714609384536743,
0.37427395582199097,
-0.20111088454723358,
-0.3578506410121918,
-0.14173194766044617,
-0.19099117815494537,
-0.6538975834846497,
-0.24167658388614655,
-0.5810651183128357,
0.3039040267467499,
-0.6619836688041687,
-0.3574557900428772,
-0.07678329944610596,
-0.0316212996840477,
-0.7470687627792358,
0.07676844298839569,
0.4945768117904663,
1.0219112634658813,
-0.46503740549087524,
0.5449168682098389,
0.6270924210548401,
-0.7037602066993713,
-0.8029325604438782,
-0.2767847776412964,
-0.026342293247580528,
-1.115828275680542,
0.753806471824646,
0.29466840624809265,
-0.193534255027771,
-0.13617002964019775,
-0.47959980368614197,
-0.6202611923217773,
1.3516696691513062,
0.4411911368370056,
-0.539833664894104,
-0.012208440341055393,
0.35059642791748047,
0.46504226326942444,
-0.665140688419342,
0.6634485721588135,
0.5085387229919434,
0.7650813460350037,
-0.1435602903366089,
-1.0689632892608643,
0.0985562801361084,
-0.45572569966316223,
-0.06453787535429001,
-0.10530633479356766,
-0.5391969084739685,
1.0182515382766724,
-0.32284700870513916,
-0.34119895100593567,
0.07975082099437714,
0.39404287934303284,
0.45814043283462524,
0.625907301902771,
0.5978447198867798,
0.48926979303359985,
0.6352894306182861,
0.05362823233008385,
1.0627633333206177,
-0.7285226583480835,
0.2992953062057495,
0.8361486196517944,
-0.49036917090415955,
0.6597301959991455,
0.32903167605400085,
0.09445952624082565,
0.5807345509529114,
0.6160863637924194,
-0.19568957388401031,
0.19875499606132507,
0.17873258888721466,
0.33225515484809875,
-0.5134443640708923,
0.1568714827299118,
-0.7251442074775696,
0.5235517024993896,
0.291976660490036,
-0.44773030281066895,
-0.27018213272094727,
-0.09360858798027039,
-0.20140063762664795,
0.10554247349500656,
-0.429107666015625,
0.4218098521232605,
0.071092888712883,
-0.45463064312934875,
0.8639296889305115,
-0.12000177800655365,
0.16211870312690735,
-0.7455762624740601,
0.043913304805755615,
-0.1008388102054596,
0.17891913652420044,
-0.11990613490343094,
-0.6831644773483276,
-0.13212235271930695,
-0.035639893263578415,
0.013856939040124416,
-0.2660081088542938,
0.4304269850254059,
-0.12528090178966522,
-0.7236686944961548,
0.49591779708862305,
0.9982466697692871,
-0.1060832291841507,
0.07757813483476639,
-0.7505647540092468,
0.18900665640830994,
-0.10776733607053757,
-0.204993337392807,
0.22034424543380737,
0.572056233882904,
-0.16126400232315063,
0.9578035473823547,
0.7296608090400696,
-0.2395337074995041,
0.16543182730674744,
0.44224563241004944,
0.828158438205719,
-0.6899053454399109,
-0.627866804599762,
-0.4675474762916565,
0.29383066296577454,
0.005379721987992525,
-0.30500081181526184,
1.0141816139221191,
0.9665994644165039,
0.6650404334068298,
-0.1683627814054489,
0.7998319864273071,
0.28283625841140747,
0.2500852048397064,
-0.39982327818870544,
0.863987922668457,
-0.7588503360748291,
0.12441370636224747,
-0.4555489122867584,
-0.7662979364395142,
-0.27604392170906067,
0.034958675503730774,
-0.48676571249961853,
0.1827370673418045,
0.8790892362594604,
0.5590489506721497,
-0.2894195020198822,
0.13038210570812225,
0.4970403015613556,
-0.10192005336284637,
0.23627199232578278,
0.9139270186424255,
1.2746121883392334,
-0.12173670530319214,
1.0544546842575073,
-0.17270031571388245,
-0.39575859904289246,
-0.2888147830963135,
-0.7168655395507812,
-0.8718363046646118,
-0.4928681254386902,
-0.22556528449058533,
-0.07701288163661957,
-0.38077259063720703,
0.7573778033256531,
0.7400811314582825,
-0.5748540163040161,
-0.6905785799026489,
0.3076397478580475,
0.020925404503941536,
-0.4289689064025879,
-0.2309110015630722,
0.2045569121837616,
-0.24162739515304565,
-0.5278517603874207,
0.4195138216018677,
0.5299842357635498,
-0.2892887592315674,
-0.5426901578903198,
-0.39820271730422974,
0.021528474986553192,
0.11687985062599182,
0.6620559692382812,
0.03306958079338074,
-0.5582211017608643,
-0.23851639032363892,
-0.09346076846122742,
-0.3559455871582031,
0.24609141051769257,
1.2072410583496094,
-0.44803130626678467,
0.6092039942741394,
0.5580787062644958,
0.4595763385295868,
0.4108459949493408,
-0.049503572285175323,
0.5869969725608826,
-0.26892024278640747,
0.025622334331274033,
0.18489313125610352,
0.5739368200302124,
0.16244035959243774,
0.1411527693271637,
0.5095422863960266,
0.3339109420776367,
-0.48525652289390564,
-0.883873462677002,
0.3418123722076416,
-1.2469172477722168,
-0.28124138712882996,
0.8192530274391174,
0.07211557775735855,
-0.1279897838830948,
0.04566430300474167,
-0.22228825092315674,
0.24982336163520813,
-0.2943688631057739,
0.6231455206871033,
0.43634822964668274,
-0.33808428049087524,
-0.13257542252540588,
-0.7401362061500549,
0.17248396575450897,
0.26370805501937866,
-1.1436054706573486,
0.045807573944330215,
0.8857001662254333,
0.1396479457616806,
0.3233424425125122,
0.6011306047439575,
-0.08368925005197525,
0.7344415783882141,
0.2634408175945282,
0.2680155038833618,
-0.2834452688694,
-0.23033156991004944,
0.04507680982351303,
0.3595544993877411,
0.1152031272649765,
-0.09918678551912308
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09952v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09952v1
|
BiVLC: Extending Vision-Language Compositionality Evaluation with Text-to-Image Retrieval
| 2024-06-14T11:58:49 | 2024-06-14T11:58:49 |
Imanol Miranda, Ander Salaberria, Eneko Agirre, Gorka Azkune
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Existing Vision-Language Compositionality (VLC) benchmarks like SugarCrepe
are formulated as image-to-text retrieval problems, where, given an image, the
models need to select between the correct textual description and a synthetic
hard negative text. In this work we present the Bidirectional Vision-Language
Compositionality (BiVLC) dataset. The novelty of BiVLC is to add a synthetic
hard negative image generated from the synthetic text, resulting in two
image-to-text retrieval examples (one for each image) and, more importantly,
two text-to-image retrieval examples (one for each text). Human annotators
filter out ill-formed examples ensuring the validity of the benchmark. The
experiments on BiVLC uncover a weakness of current multimodal models, as they
perform poorly in the text-to-image direction. In fact, when considering both
retrieval directions, the conclusions obtained in previous works change
significantly. In addition to the benchmark, we show that a contrastive model
trained using synthetic images and texts improves the state of the art in
SugarCrepe and in BiVLC for both retrieval directions. The gap to human
performance in BiVLC confirms that Vision-Language Compositionality is still a
challenging problem. BiVLC and code are available at
https://imirandam.github.io/BiVLC_project_page.
|
[
-0.14038127660751343,
-0.3801220655441284,
0.40533289313316345,
0.45623770356178284,
-0.4359414875507355,
0.15332022309303284,
-0.44077396392822266,
-0.6851571202278137,
-0.16076578199863434,
0.6501703262329102,
-0.09498584270477295,
-0.5957711338996887,
-0.47059404850006104,
0.21410052478313446,
-0.4496200382709503,
0.9187800288200378,
-0.03650275245308876,
0.35590893030166626,
-0.725373387336731,
-0.3104890286922455,
-0.6462920308113098,
-0.2810443341732025,
-0.11903326958417892,
0.005215499084442854,
0.3349126875400543,
0.402603417634964,
0.4610465466976166,
0.46038031578063965,
0.8839946389198303,
0.3264122009277344,
0.08827964961528778,
0.2650076746940613,
-0.37597814202308655,
0.10205800086259842,
-0.3358573913574219,
-0.603620171546936,
-0.04102242365479469,
0.11714135110378265,
0.6737138032913208,
0.7222078442573547,
-0.005013788118958473,
-0.0055498722940683365,
0.07465243339538574,
0.705583930015564,
-0.9422397613525391,
0.2959577739238739,
-0.7343951463699341,
-0.04252443462610245,
-0.21603651344776154,
-0.10923893749713898,
-0.519879937171936,
-0.02600439451634884,
0.31158849596977234,
-0.2965441346168518,
0.30168265104293823,
0.054653726518154144,
0.9145473837852478,
0.23535571992397308,
-0.6120175719261169,
-0.38697168231010437,
-0.6994068622589111,
0.7688006162643433,
-0.3618968427181244,
0.4456186294555664,
0.27661365270614624,
0.41231074929237366,
0.37340837717056274,
-0.8274607062339783,
-0.7575658559799194,
-0.4215262234210968,
-0.14981737732887268,
0.6878736019134521,
0.10556446760892868,
-0.3038106858730316,
-0.13791340589523315,
0.2878186106681824,
-0.7285920977592468,
-0.3239983022212982,
-0.556693434715271,
-0.1617666482925415,
0.3864672780036926,
0.20897600054740906,
0.17609326541423798,
-0.3249279856681824,
-0.8106963634490967,
-0.23735445737838745,
-0.40039047598838806,
-0.039072297513484955,
0.15592409670352936,
0.2677331268787384,
-0.14143961668014526,
0.8765588998794556,
-0.019500700756907463,
0.7100169062614441,
-0.2845476269721985,
0.1681758165359497,
0.4639180302619934,
-0.7961503267288208,
-0.1948082596063614,
-0.10241998732089996,
0.6109468936920166,
0.8526595234870911,
0.12986989319324493,
-0.18602140247821808,
-0.18606509268283844,
0.4519803822040558,
0.3026028275489807,
-0.8221363425254822,
-0.4787296950817108,
-0.21328163146972656,
-0.5172467231750488,
-0.23784185945987701,
0.23746906220912933,
-0.7897350788116455,
-0.395463228225708,
-0.4454827606678009,
0.5146971344947815,
-0.3744281232357025,
0.06612824648618698,
-0.0003345438453834504,
-0.15898428857326508,
0.45271825790405273,
0.3601199686527252,
-0.6309579610824585,
0.35770195722579956,
0.5358578562736511,
0.7620159983634949,
-0.43152761459350586,
-0.3689453899860382,
-0.5848445892333984,
0.06864313781261444,
-0.28020620346069336,
0.9622470736503601,
-0.7619574666023254,
-0.5070026516914368,
-0.12415841221809387,
0.14153127372264862,
-0.02507137879729271,
-0.8420709371566772,
0.5477672219276428,
-0.2484285980463028,
0.4054300785064697,
-0.1982967108488083,
-0.12294474244117737,
-0.11838054656982422,
0.3944711685180664,
-0.5938495397567749,
0.9692980051040649,
0.09165763109922409,
-0.618833065032959,
0.29753735661506653,
-0.2608049511909485,
-0.6852423548698425,
0.3614084720611572,
-0.4254676401615143,
-0.5222816467285156,
0.10089121013879776,
-0.08879188448190689,
0.1951218843460083,
-0.5992858409881592,
-0.015209351666271687,
-0.06898301839828491,
-0.5590015053749084,
0.30458828806877136,
-0.5235750079154968,
0.5409024357795715,
0.026316069066524506,
-0.2648026645183563,
-0.13910168409347534,
-0.9038134217262268,
-0.14844916760921478,
0.14353738725185394,
-0.41238540410995483,
-0.6122585535049438,
0.1619279831647873,
0.3347540497779846,
0.16136875748634338,
0.3219722509384155,
-0.4987001419067383,
-0.002161049284040928,
-0.4894452691078186,
0.026654349640011787,
0.4823124408721924,
-0.32668063044548035,
0.43657514452934265,
0.004760249983519316,
0.18759721517562866,
0.40722495317459106,
0.3420979976654053,
-0.28585800528526306,
-0.43350452184677124,
-0.7037163376808167,
-0.27369892597198486,
0.17489250004291534,
0.7325367331504822,
-1.1866040229797363,
0.02478332817554474,
-0.24307961761951447,
-0.4328465759754181,
-0.5542343854904175,
0.26425111293792725,
0.7705218195915222,
0.9663012623786926,
0.6052159667015076,
-0.8902482986450195,
-0.31248441338539124,
-1.2156596183776855,
0.023257018998265266,
-0.26632994413375854,
0.06578612327575684,
0.4980275630950928,
0.4490402042865753,
-0.2220543771982193,
0.5588337779045105,
-0.4800904095172882,
-0.24805177748203278,
-0.01920117251574993,
0.22475716471672058,
0.04207586869597435,
0.32759174704551697,
0.737825870513916,
-1.3445587158203125,
-0.7568793296813965,
0.04146837815642357,
-0.5091001391410828,
-0.16835840046405792,
0.057994794100522995,
-0.19026824831962585,
0.32600805163383484,
0.21524746716022491,
-0.38371792435646057,
0.653076171875,
0.5315765738487244,
-0.43764376640319824,
0.8349012136459351,
-0.28873053193092346,
0.44086262583732605,
-1.151140809059143,
0.31176942586898804,
0.25298941135406494,
-0.20902596414089203,
-0.4670594036579132,
0.0362849161028862,
0.3409792482852936,
0.12425188720226288,
-0.5709514617919922,
0.24534961581230164,
-0.5110049247741699,
-0.20550115406513214,
-0.360393762588501,
0.3266909122467041,
0.2988389730453491,
0.3717716634273529,
0.1622028648853302,
0.877672553062439,
0.746718168258667,
-0.42874622344970703,
0.58868408203125,
0.46510443091392517,
-0.36489611864089966,
1.0540815591812134,
-0.7197210192680359,
-0.10522393137216568,
-0.41964712738990784,
0.03464791178703308,
-1.2944068908691406,
0.026136664673686028,
0.33423009514808655,
-0.37592455744743347,
0.4243301749229431,
-0.37525835633277893,
-0.36097612977027893,
-0.15770626068115234,
-0.5060060620307922,
0.6355507373809814,
0.29386234283447266,
-0.4974772334098816,
0.578738808631897,
0.07667139917612076,
-0.07603631168603897,
-0.594266951084137,
-1.0303562879562378,
0.5347070097923279,
0.13726116716861725,
-0.5183863639831543,
0.6073435544967651,
-0.34133654832839966,
-0.03624355047941208,
-0.005681496113538742,
0.12439858168363571,
0.03949076309800148,
-0.17489926517009735,
0.13341493904590607,
0.9454734325408936,
-0.054614610970020294,
-0.02177543193101883,
-0.33453282713890076,
-0.0049280128441751,
-0.08261536806821823,
-0.15060627460479736,
0.36977118253707886,
-0.3009899854660034,
-0.23481443524360657,
-0.14815518260002136,
0.379964143037796,
0.35551291704177856,
-0.5608752965927124,
0.5576013326644897,
0.671158492565155,
-0.14502781629562378,
0.11558977514505386,
-0.3664596974849701,
0.06119973212480545,
-0.42227593064308167,
0.4342753291130066,
-0.2706478536128998,
-0.30857595801353455,
0.24250932037830353,
0.0899219736456871,
-0.23769856989383698,
0.10855390876531601,
0.75879967212677,
-0.31996703147888184,
0.781810462474823,
0.37941277027130127,
0.34668028354644775,
0.514054536819458,
-0.25731590390205383,
-0.20818915963172913,
-0.9617513418197632,
-0.6306530237197876,
-0.45644065737724304,
-0.3180693984031677,
-0.7192560434341431,
-0.6387186646461487,
0.35074540972709656,
-0.28558194637298584,
0.1333352029323578,
0.5990126729011536,
-0.5223962664604187,
0.5862290859222412,
0.5180601477622986,
0.3504524528980255,
0.3484348952770233,
0.0772634968161583,
-0.3609063923358917,
-0.16955503821372986,
-0.18496209383010864,
-0.29435503482818604,
0.8801807761192322,
-0.3602333068847656,
0.7259975075721741,
0.2851172685623169,
0.3583172559738159,
0.22246591746807098,
0.29951396584510803,
-0.7153422236442566,
0.630211353302002,
-0.6430240273475647,
-0.4518527388572693,
0.3376733958721161,
-0.4081617295742035,
-0.7754008173942566,
0.4487590193748474,
-0.4130250811576843,
-0.5640890002250671,
0.3992803394794464,
0.14182409644126892,
0.15296529233455658,
-0.06627634912729263,
-0.8872773051261902,
1.0074101686477661,
-0.540599524974823,
-0.9516792893409729,
-0.01014221366494894,
-1.1894906759262085,
0.11291616410017014,
0.12918049097061157,
-0.0650278851389885,
0.11633919924497604,
-0.18736255168914795,
0.18601495027542114,
-0.17484261095523834,
0.7404364943504333,
-0.01835787668824196,
0.1735791116952896,
0.17487208545207977,
0.14471879601478577,
0.2800152003765106,
-0.13252593576908112,
0.06320908665657043,
-0.058643292635679245,
0.13314339518547058,
-0.5875264406204224,
-0.4620976150035858,
0.6749237775802612,
-0.4898485839366913,
-0.24905672669410706,
-0.3669174611568451,
-0.16014836728572845,
-0.23490262031555176,
0.05722786486148834,
0.14012150466442108,
0.6704567670822144,
-0.0168483667075634,
0.46443647146224976,
0.3913281261920929,
-0.4242425262928009,
0.42026862502098083,
0.41217318177223206,
-0.15347032248973846,
-0.4730205833911896,
1.0504975318908691,
-0.30102354288101196,
0.3572770059108734,
0.6346163153648376,
0.15519720315933228,
-0.38002535700798035,
-0.5049194097518921,
-0.47951290011405945,
0.2492905706167221,
-0.7290645837783813,
-0.2858901023864746,
-0.10085058957338333,
-0.039267200976610184,
-0.3413999378681183,
0.024463079869747162,
-0.508246660232544,
-0.15237832069396973,
-0.4040215015411377,
0.2115793526172638,
-0.2248554527759552,
0.2619225084781647,
0.14427311718463898,
-0.17119432985782623,
-0.7156132459640503,
0.39969906210899353,
0.21117207407951355,
0.43977901339530945,
-0.22739863395690918,
-0.5292543172836304,
-0.3027794063091278,
-0.04813586175441742,
-0.3477608561515808,
-0.7731544375419617,
0.36620232462882996,
0.29001539945602417,
0.21613574028015137,
0.08031006902456284,
-0.22169628739356995,
0.7544050812721252,
-0.3737349510192871,
0.8180487155914307,
0.5111764669418335,
-0.6914559006690979,
0.5399699807167053,
0.06579161435365677,
0.329581618309021,
0.8871313333511353,
0.14465726912021637,
-0.5780491828918457,
0.021119778975844383,
-0.009067287668585777,
-0.8682487607002258,
0.40597522258758545,
0.5044034719467163,
0.20600003004074097,
0.1306440830230713,
0.19546040892601013,
0.24568048119544983,
0.3073565363883972,
-0.821500301361084,
-0.17479386925697327,
-0.6118793487548828,
-0.45943254232406616,
-0.06262532621622086,
-0.1106673926115036,
0.14397794008255005,
-0.2790127992630005,
0.42757564783096313,
-0.1025509312748909,
0.1650148183107376,
0.36553266644477844,
-0.29765334725379944,
0.14513558149337769,
0.1370636522769928,
0.5134792327880859,
0.41130557656288147,
-0.11567693948745728,
0.5324816703796387,
-0.2492511123418808,
-0.6895478367805481,
-0.08935017883777618,
0.3646562099456787,
-0.3549942672252655,
-0.2489064484834671,
0.2972477376461029,
0.746432363986969,
-0.046374525874853134,
-1.0817947387695312,
0.8709362149238586,
-0.26115158200263977,
-0.2476252019405365,
-0.19798670709133148,
-0.14313402771949768,
-0.10771367698907852,
0.40074828267097473,
0.26787927746772766,
0.2780342698097229,
0.4655149281024933,
-0.8575731515884399,
-0.038480039685964584,
0.4994114339351654,
-0.5774917602539062,
-0.5075671672821045,
0.7317206263542175,
0.20833277702331543,
-0.12819895148277283,
0.6520422101020813,
-0.1682850420475006,
-0.6776740550994873,
0.5076403617858887,
0.5151795744895935,
0.6185572147369385,
0.13001100718975067,
0.3294801414012909,
0.08144447207450867,
0.3456357717514038,
0.3011491000652313,
0.3950284719467163,
-0.2929535508155823,
-0.6349573135375977,
-0.26834943890571594,
-0.6479569673538208,
-0.29581812024116516,
-0.27400243282318115,
-0.42274439334869385,
0.40779030323028564,
-0.0776953175663948,
0.07987085729837418,
-0.05334660783410072,
-0.060579609125852585,
-0.6755232214927673,
0.2985741198062897,
0.3626518249511719,
0.5059360265731812,
-0.652478814125061,
0.6250514984130859,
0.930942177772522,
-0.6027793288230896,
-0.3871767520904541,
0.030258048325777054,
-0.19954335689544678,
-0.6222317814826965,
0.5719361305236816,
0.30342623591423035,
-0.1802532821893692,
-0.41144001483917236,
-0.6168760061264038,
-0.2514973282814026,
1.218037486076355,
0.22823970019817352,
-0.506994366645813,
0.03887207433581352,
0.44413891434669495,
0.8218326568603516,
-0.2681080400943756,
0.17084801197052002,
0.33974695205688477,
0.535983145236969,
0.5123928189277649,
-0.6984402537345886,
-0.09777775406837463,
-0.49736732244491577,
0.20183148980140686,
0.08572408556938171,
-0.754928708076477,
0.7124398946762085,
-0.16730177402496338,
-0.35881778597831726,
0.31366369128227234,
0.3794553577899933,
-0.00976652093231678,
0.7844741344451904,
0.4171082079410553,
0.43264755606651306,
0.11231517791748047,
-0.1075880378484726,
1.0675896406173706,
-0.07244215160608292,
0.34085044264793396,
1.2281603813171387,
-0.5530713200569153,
0.8283284306526184,
0.6792520880699158,
-0.07030560076236725,
0.44919684529304504,
0.3230922222137451,
-0.3860015273094177,
0.779291570186615,
-0.06094346195459366,
-0.3585018813610077,
-0.2366671860218048,
-0.20813050866127014,
0.05155656114220619,
0.7831799387931824,
0.08671024441719055,
-0.4237179458141327,
-0.064006008207798,
0.20124347507953644,
-0.5018208622932434,
0.3923054337501526,
-0.13078618049621582,
0.6878381967544556,
-0.11396565288305283,
-0.6817037463188171,
0.3574485182762146,
0.010560324415564537,
0.5207903981208801,
-0.25182095170021057,
-0.11982180923223495,
-0.2338654100894928,
0.2066621482372284,
-0.06456516683101654,
-0.8542464375495911,
0.22948575019836426,
-0.051541589200496674,
-0.054633092135190964,
0.1414278894662857,
0.8893072009086609,
-0.8448954224586487,
-0.6050066351890564,
0.2410346120595932,
0.32776927947998047,
0.038797687739133835,
0.02657274156808853,
-0.7466000914573669,
-0.018436521291732788,
-0.13120603561401367,
0.08845651894807816,
-0.06059792637825012,
0.17747731506824493,
-0.011429314501583576,
0.32989415526390076,
0.4516310691833496,
0.08677110075950623,
-0.03562651574611664,
0.24375563859939575,
0.776679277420044,
-0.5664175748825073,
-0.11656800657510757,
-0.9219487309455872,
0.5042709708213806,
-0.21191667020320892,
-0.1781948059797287,
0.5529011487960815,
1.0637407302856445,
0.9614241719245911,
-0.2724158465862274,
0.554847240447998,
-0.16133514046669006,
0.16365087032318115,
-0.6058908700942993,
0.44758275151252747,
-0.9308338165283203,
0.1721712201833725,
-0.3574526011943817,
-1.0016329288482666,
-0.44526559114456177,
0.29525211453437805,
0.03468221426010132,
0.02257911115884781,
0.7226332426071167,
1.0329164266586304,
-0.2992137670516968,
-0.1865544468164444,
0.450381338596344,
0.1602168083190918,
0.1310018002986908,
0.5797853469848633,
0.9521850943565369,
-0.6068927645683289,
0.9297440648078918,
-0.2807149887084961,
-0.15785008668899536,
-0.32321569323539734,
-0.8492623567581177,
-0.802196741104126,
-0.9457930326461792,
-0.30877557396888733,
-0.23009327054023743,
0.08476017415523529,
0.7037912607192993,
0.590072512626648,
-0.5581144094467163,
-0.09382656961679459,
0.030464909970760345,
-0.2772935628890991,
-0.04660450294613838,
-0.18156448006629944,
0.13253261148929596,
0.11006274819374084,
-0.8302959203720093,
0.21250838041305542,
0.7200067639350891,
0.30680912733078003,
-0.31156522035598755,
-0.12283840775489807,
-0.3879101574420929,
0.11315567791461945,
0.9576705098152161,
0.03240128979086876,
-0.40474581718444824,
-0.16879862546920776,
0.031149564310908318,
-0.2821880578994751,
0.3828844726085663,
0.7971822023391724,
-0.7438062429428101,
0.7753708362579346,
0.570684552192688,
0.5337244272232056,
0.8373337984085083,
0.2075652778148651,
0.08643721044063568,
-0.8602697253227234,
0.003225329564884305,
0.2663224935531616,
0.45489105582237244,
0.7804387807846069,
0.032892730087041855,
0.42495426535606384,
0.7353775501251221,
-0.3171970844268799,
-0.5748363733291626,
0.2852329909801483,
-1.575852632522583,
-0.344452828168869,
1.0934584140777588,
0.20246149599552155,
-0.5190388560295105,
0.21352888643741608,
-0.5400177836418152,
0.1524885594844818,
-0.013124944642186165,
0.8553338050842285,
0.5802066922187805,
0.26654118299484253,
-0.21439971029758453,
-0.17858770489692688,
-0.04735061898827553,
0.3675887882709503,
-0.8731024861335754,
0.03564758226275444,
0.7281786203384399,
0.23028361797332764,
0.13350720703601837,
0.2638368606567383,
-0.38262268900871277,
0.41546204686164856,
-0.1202462911605835,
0.028729859739542007,
-0.005876525770872831,
-0.6260955333709717,
0.013779871165752411,
-0.07572325319051743,
-0.2502506673336029,
-0.22404009103775024
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09950v1
|
An efficient text augmentation approach for contextualized Mandarin speech recognition
| 2024-06-14T11:53:14 | 2024-06-14T11:53:14 |
Naijun Zheng, Xucheng Wan, Kai Liu, Ziqing Du, Zhou Huan
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Although contextualized automatic speech recognition (ASR) systems are
commonly used to improve the recognition of uncommon words, their effectiveness
is hindered by the inherent limitations of speech-text data availability. To
address this challenge, our study proposes to leverage extensive text-only
datasets and contextualize pre-trained ASR models using a straightforward
text-augmentation (TA) technique, all while keeping computational costs
minimal. In particular, to contextualize a pre-trained CIF-based ASR, we
construct a codebook using limited speech-text data. By utilizing a simple
codebook lookup process, we convert available text-only data into latent text
embeddings. These embeddings then enhance the inputs for the contextualized
ASR. Our experiments on diverse Mandarin test sets demonstrate that our TA
approach significantly boosts recognition performance. The top-performing
system shows relative CER improvements of up to 30% on rare words and 15%
across all words in general.
|
[
-0.06538674980401993,
-0.3940609097480774,
0.015155868604779243,
0.21776460111141205,
-0.5835437178611755,
0.08285678923130035,
-0.5877344608306885,
-0.4775048494338989,
0.005498488433659077,
0.309397429227829,
-0.1456388384103775,
-0.3582281172275543,
-0.2372284084558487,
0.20613591372966766,
-0.4162473976612091,
0.8286423087120056,
0.192884624004364,
0.1374673694372177,
0.017807960510253906,
-0.22054333984851837,
-0.6296558380126953,
-0.7443085312843323,
-0.450023353099823,
-0.3459897041320801,
0.18702960014343262,
0.5915840864181519,
0.5741863250732422,
0.779498279094696,
0.38047245144844055,
0.19986936450004578,
-0.2772555351257324,
0.12139403074979782,
-0.1627330631017685,
-0.07314027100801468,
0.12009749561548233,
0.03961706534028053,
-0.25632432103157043,
-0.46484076976776123,
0.9543394446372986,
0.5428038239479065,
-0.030532879754900932,
-0.18492437899112701,
0.29077649116516113,
0.448887437582016,
-0.6906683444976807,
0.06286578625440598,
-0.7934020757675171,
0.1707586646080017,
-0.26400360465049744,
-0.5086769461631775,
-0.15555572509765625,
-0.08741647750139236,
0.3866013288497925,
-0.7466282248497009,
0.030447321012616158,
-0.34327802062034607,
0.47013574838638306,
0.3595659136772156,
-0.5140631198883057,
-0.2016010880470276,
-0.6997573375701904,
0.5484307408332825,
-0.5148085355758667,
0.4223373234272003,
0.30418860912323,
0.2843538820743561,
0.12097438424825668,
-0.7735034227371216,
-0.6991811394691467,
-0.3127705454826355,
-0.2615073621273041,
0.04667286574840546,
0.04834097996354103,
0.1889512836933136,
0.2526428997516632,
0.567647397518158,
-0.6118699312210083,
-0.17020940780639648,
-0.2308623194694519,
-0.21497255563735962,
0.4968584179878235,
-0.09109555184841156,
0.5955573320388794,
0.04189009964466095,
-0.3594527840614319,
-0.31555476784706116,
-0.6283749938011169,
0.32633548974990845,
-0.23726962506771088,
0.6688881516456604,
-0.24834482371807098,
0.5613570809364319,
-0.0754927545785904,
0.9546113014221191,
-0.11780121177434921,
0.07029615342617035,
0.48870933055877686,
-0.5633583664894104,
-0.34831035137176514,
0.5699732899665833,
0.5679408311843872,
-0.03844400867819786,
0.25144416093826294,
-0.03984938934445381,
-0.33635833859443665,
-0.17502866685390472,
0.07974023371934891,
-0.6092755198478699,
-0.2629072070121765,
-0.013212890364229679,
0.05864641070365906,
-0.02725997380912304,
0.26555395126342773,
-0.10891326516866684,
-0.3224872648715973,
-0.10664482414722443,
0.6174187064170837,
-0.4193481206893921,
-0.09810492396354675,
-0.24225108325481415,
-0.3593735098838806,
0.2398541420698166,
0.35637354850769043,
-0.6584234237670898,
0.05240623280405998,
0.33943769335746765,
0.8087977170944214,
-0.03188991919159889,
-0.12692339718341827,
-0.894619882106781,
0.3642427325248718,
-0.48297449946403503,
0.649220883846283,
-0.660019040107727,
-0.6299956440925598,
0.08414595574140549,
-0.009468365460634232,
-0.1261766403913498,
-0.5792593359947205,
0.6569358110427856,
-0.3443376123905182,
-0.1711510568857193,
-0.26572301983833313,
-0.4296809136867523,
0.09698611497879028,
0.08260896801948547,
-0.7354621887207031,
1.0984063148498535,
-0.17141586542129517,
-0.69427889585495,
0.40735217928886414,
-0.8795266151428223,
-0.9168861508369446,
0.3519403040409088,
-0.528026819229126,
-0.12901198863983154,
0.0032445380929857492,
0.4957251250743866,
0.4598008990287781,
0.13030743598937988,
0.25850632786750793,
0.25446856021881104,
-0.7833065986633301,
0.33203262090682983,
-0.6555809378623962,
0.5263535976409912,
0.32352215051651,
-0.4412030279636383,
-0.014971298165619373,
-0.760919451713562,
0.08376611024141312,
-0.20301036536693573,
-0.7314204573631287,
-0.5045489072799683,
-0.03885244205594063,
0.652183473110199,
-0.23504455387592316,
0.4286949634552002,
-0.36258432269096375,
0.029095947742462158,
-0.7100803256034851,
0.2537483870983124,
0.31698375940322876,
-0.34881773591041565,
0.6825205087661743,
-0.2457505464553833,
0.17610901594161987,
0.16920636594295502,
-0.30615001916885376,
-0.6751876473426819,
-0.15263009071350098,
-0.723254382610321,
-0.3012302815914154,
0.2790619134902954,
0.5552728176116943,
-1.008621335029602,
0.5648398995399475,
-0.5819112658500671,
-0.30002883076667786,
-0.039388734847307205,
0.12510192394256592,
0.5761762857437134,
0.5623729825019836,
0.49574822187423706,
-0.06953366845846176,
-0.6332485675811768,
-0.6466519236564636,
-0.610619068145752,
-0.016076620668172836,
-0.15978480875492096,
0.5473989844322205,
-0.09225069731473923,
-0.26161453127861023,
1.1350051164627075,
-0.3575303554534912,
-0.5297167897224426,
-0.3115893006324768,
-0.10319069027900696,
0.3695037364959717,
0.8057087063789368,
0.25611934065818787,
-1.1120271682739258,
-0.7568099498748779,
0.4611656367778778,
-0.5378432869911194,
0.06504040211439133,
-0.1084292083978653,
0.408549040555954,
0.1874752938747406,
0.6928008794784546,
0.0018979733576998115,
0.551083505153656,
0.24845854938030243,
-0.25708189606666565,
0.003048195503652096,
-0.31548935174942017,
0.16285409033298492,
-0.7822622656822205,
0.2023380845785141,
-0.016910094767808914,
-0.36518794298171997,
-1.205777645111084,
-0.0916961133480072,
0.36324384808540344,
-0.25322696566581726,
-0.44114360213279724,
0.6784627437591553,
-0.541388213634491,
-0.050582025200128555,
-0.30645403265953064,
0.11459216475486755,
-0.11433425545692444,
0.3462396264076233,
0.48402833938598633,
1.0832701921463013,
0.49522921442985535,
-0.8543588519096375,
0.01485931035131216,
0.30805838108062744,
-0.3072512149810791,
0.08885899186134338,
-0.5509411692619324,
0.20647290349006653,
-0.10584288090467453,
0.2838411331176758,
-0.9074360132217407,
-0.3001878559589386,
0.07286445796489716,
-0.6156176328659058,
0.41937464475631714,
-0.008134376257658005,
-0.2499333918094635,
0.06843489408493042,
-0.08009358495473862,
0.7091774940490723,
0.3157740533351898,
-1.0610510110855103,
0.6669926643371582,
0.47909778356552124,
-0.27273663878440857,
-0.6759530901908875,
-0.9194936752319336,
0.3410693109035492,
0.041555795818567276,
-0.24138952791690826,
0.7478035092353821,
-0.060406606644392014,
-0.005892342422157526,
-0.29238003492355347,
-0.12472272664308548,
-0.4493056833744049,
-0.10371911525726318,
0.045061755925416946,
-0.027087101712822914,
-0.2709853947162628,
0.5042598843574524,
0.16076092422008514,
0.11057066917419434,
-0.4678225517272949,
-0.276386022567749,
0.41346436738967896,
-0.18335215747356415,
-0.0431034192442894,
-0.39424556493759155,
0.1504068374633789,
0.2605467438697815,
-0.22500760853290558,
0.3230891823768616,
0.747262716293335,
-0.6994544267654419,
-0.016572974622249603,
-0.5379337072372437,
0.11644492298364639,
-0.4834575355052948,
0.4173527956008911,
-0.4922848045825958,
-0.9510881304740906,
0.11718307435512543,
0.4166371524333954,
-0.011529069393873215,
0.22989460825920105,
0.16656991839408875,
0.1768943965435028,
0.6172029376029968,
0.5586017966270447,
-0.3379588723182678,
0.8600624203681946,
0.04083801433444023,
0.09007637947797775,
-0.8027366399765015,
-0.08417806029319763,
-0.4522564113140106,
0.2797159254550934,
-0.45773446559906006,
-0.5809131860733032,
0.5754464864730835,
0.13708247244358063,
-0.3133653998374939,
0.4102936387062073,
-0.6962237358093262,
0.6078110933303833,
0.4740062654018402,
0.3635469377040863,
0.4368610978126526,
0.15531598031520844,
-0.0033338458742946386,
0.08593481779098511,
-0.8040070533752441,
-0.40482041239738464,
0.9669885635375977,
0.16179296374320984,
0.431873619556427,
0.12249325215816498,
0.44102907180786133,
0.4817448854446411,
0.3192792236804962,
-0.8221548199653625,
0.30452296137809753,
-0.4396492540836334,
-0.31568393111228943,
-0.6139910817146301,
-0.3813888132572174,
-0.527269184589386,
0.1621728539466858,
-0.3082270920276642,
-0.5255537629127502,
0.23116835951805115,
0.43690383434295654,
-0.6138662099838257,
-0.035407278686761856,
-0.6424108147621155,
0.44494011998176575,
-0.21359959244728088,
-0.09723875671625137,
0.026784392073750496,
-0.5109401941299438,
0.10776904970407486,
-0.25581276416778564,
0.2017035335302353,
0.4090941548347473,
-0.18074777722358704,
0.7764865159988403,
-0.5887982249259949,
0.5359104871749878,
-0.2945387065410614,
0.07201196253299713,
0.34821027517318726,
-0.5183611512184143,
0.372039794921875,
0.09252432733774185,
-0.05306083709001541,
0.17959128320217133,
0.04346361383795738,
-0.22608903050422668,
-0.4544004499912262,
0.6197372078895569,
-0.6071075797080994,
-0.3560589849948883,
-0.5385026931762695,
-0.2654871940612793,
-0.21324920654296875,
0.09333328157663345,
0.3033963441848755,
0.9026569128036499,
-0.41829028725624084,
0.45553258061408997,
0.6336683630943298,
-0.5640182495117188,
0.7336361408233643,
0.3522312641143799,
0.0900316908955574,
-0.704142153263092,
0.9723606705665588,
0.08635974675416946,
-0.10714611411094666,
0.7781929969787598,
0.3264637589454651,
-0.544013261795044,
-0.35399454832077026,
-0.6004651188850403,
-0.3275902271270752,
-0.6836810111999512,
-0.12897026538848877,
-0.8502718806266785,
-0.44128817319869995,
-0.5949182510375977,
-0.26417338848114014,
-0.13296259939670563,
-0.35264506936073303,
-0.6535966396331787,
0.10741174966096878,
0.5573878288269043,
0.4157584607601166,
-0.1790754795074463,
0.7373540997505188,
-0.9411522150039673,
0.3384624719619751,
0.36091989278793335,
0.14763681590557098,
-0.006455096881836653,
-0.7629634141921997,
-0.5395300984382629,
0.07108410447835922,
0.09869994223117828,
-0.667397141456604,
0.4816368520259857,
0.8215051293373108,
0.37282130122184753,
0.5793749690055847,
0.18508538603782654,
1.0033506155014038,
-0.6365719437599182,
0.7982769012451172,
0.28071555495262146,
-1.297285556793213,
0.6769756078720093,
-0.4242420494556427,
0.42766696214675903,
0.6012648940086365,
-0.04787103831768036,
-0.4600223898887634,
0.08439619094133377,
-0.24783757328987122,
-0.8956658840179443,
0.7144285440444946,
0.23954497277736664,
0.4014124572277069,
0.1406734585762024,
0.4193164110183716,
-0.28067895770072937,
0.21423615515232086,
-0.9108066558837891,
-0.31240320205688477,
-0.4645303189754486,
-0.49899306893348694,
-0.5113219618797302,
-0.13528385758399963,
0.11141337454319,
-0.4564046859741211,
0.5098455548286438,
-0.3122166693210602,
0.07065265625715256,
0.5964099764823914,
-0.4797767996788025,
0.14010071754455566,
0.386191725730896,
0.5389711260795593,
0.31565025448799133,
-0.03767058998346329,
0.13318032026290894,
0.4572106897830963,
-0.778954803943634,
0.09819794446229935,
0.44806766510009766,
0.12170876562595367,
0.2503284513950348,
0.29316839575767517,
0.6307179927825928,
0.4223986566066742,
-1.0141743421554565,
0.851201057434082,
-0.12225153297185898,
0.28233247995376587,
-0.7997743487358093,
0.16517922282218933,
-0.2893373370170593,
0.18735305964946747,
0.8428720831871033,
-0.10893828421831131,
0.3386269807815552,
-0.4747377038002014,
0.40033742785453796,
0.3971128761768341,
-0.707815408706665,
0.128605455160141,
0.367723286151886,
0.30993005633354187,
-0.47212016582489014,
0.24716952443122864,
0.113579660654068,
-0.6764324307441711,
0.6450659036636353,
0.715417206287384,
0.777033805847168,
-0.3402435779571533,
-0.06556063145399094,
0.4216451048851013,
0.16022726893424988,
-0.1085035651922226,
0.16338977217674255,
-0.6242923736572266,
-0.8484549522399902,
-0.16323021054267883,
-0.3612223267555237,
-0.48496827483177185,
0.18657484650611877,
-0.7050119638442993,
0.38840532302856445,
-0.5388075113296509,
-0.020118990913033485,
-0.3374563157558441,
-0.030207999050617218,
-0.4986862242221832,
0.763980507850647,
0.047399282455444336,
0.685143232345581,
-0.47890010476112366,
1.003820538520813,
0.8713986277580261,
-0.12417958676815033,
-0.8463477492332458,
0.2923435568809509,
-0.39588379859924316,
-0.7594638466835022,
0.5010800361633301,
0.5120468735694885,
-0.11287640780210495,
0.1666322946548462,
-0.4525724947452545,
-0.7858572602272034,
0.946896493434906,
0.052405983209609985,
-0.778032124042511,
0.20192301273345947,
0.07818254828453064,
0.500176727771759,
-0.33806830644607544,
0.3064597249031067,
0.5682206749916077,
0.2697124183177948,
0.1384238749742508,
-0.9405850172042847,
-0.10031012445688248,
-0.6086788773536682,
0.15891462564468384,
-0.23040737211704254,
-0.21531608700752258,
0.7030119299888611,
-0.12476131319999695,
-0.5017428994178772,
-0.016951588913798332,
0.7743179798126221,
0.3953326344490051,
0.5244790315628052,
0.7796843647956848,
0.04908761382102966,
0.6274334788322449,
0.034081194549798965,
0.7085527777671814,
-0.3957160711288452,
-0.05961090326309204,
1.309686303138733,
-0.056177131831645966,
1.0869117975234985,
0.2313428819179535,
0.17893294990062714,
0.11169050633907318,
0.6053758263587952,
0.2180752158164978,
0.6239231824874878,
0.07163089513778687,
-0.676163911819458,
-0.19447672367095947,
-0.34205248951911926,
-0.5192579627037048,
0.5442200303077698,
0.31852462887763977,
-0.3056795001029968,
0.12755784392356873,
0.08450645953416824,
-0.18074475228786469,
0.1283271163702011,
-0.486293226480484,
0.8652184009552002,
0.11146778613328934,
-0.4295661151409149,
0.6669591069221497,
-0.09583218395709991,
0.9334067106246948,
-0.46735554933547974,
-0.1577085554599762,
-0.04571560025215149,
0.10289253294467926,
-0.3333056569099426,
-0.3512169122695923,
0.1994032859802246,
0.43908295035362244,
-0.03714879974722862,
0.004785703960806131,
0.9516321420669556,
-0.7926589250564575,
-0.46799927949905396,
0.11442411690950394,
0.29132550954818726,
0.12403254956007004,
-0.3224491775035858,
-0.29365718364715576,
-0.026615142822265625,
-0.00994149874895811,
0.1231669932603836,
0.0843522846698761,
0.28506186604499817,
0.155752494931221,
0.32838770747184753,
0.7355014085769653,
0.1558685302734375,
-0.25230464339256287,
0.19744019210338593,
1.0574849843978882,
-0.8172724843025208,
-1.037550449371338,
-0.8241602182388306,
0.518722414970398,
-0.027416443452239037,
-0.1912601888179779,
0.4687754511833191,
0.5069228410720825,
0.7143642902374268,
0.12405555695295334,
1.1016225814819336,
0.2176993489265442,
0.5698040127754211,
-0.5545969009399414,
0.9718868732452393,
-0.8219026327133179,
0.4662477672100067,
-0.656141459941864,
-0.6642398834228516,
-0.5281549692153931,
0.8850263953208923,
-0.07759268581867218,
0.04753892496228218,
0.371658593416214,
0.7330582737922668,
0.08796299993991852,
0.20254573225975037,
0.5311235189437866,
-0.008684363216161728,
0.1515623778104782,
0.36189574003219604,
0.8902234435081482,
-0.6131772398948669,
0.5434112548828125,
0.06763534247875214,
-0.39333754777908325,
-0.20594659447669983,
-0.833583414554596,
-0.9625884890556335,
-0.6489391326904297,
-0.07424516975879669,
-0.05294699966907501,
0.16052401065826416,
1.2330318689346313,
0.5207951068878174,
-0.7890677452087402,
-0.2686394453048706,
-0.1271134316921234,
-0.1073114275932312,
0.0371411070227623,
-0.21772420406341553,
0.42306727170944214,
-0.19271576404571533,
-0.6563959717750549,
0.8019876480102539,
0.19976387917995453,
0.16233491897583008,
0.22805477678775787,
-0.060116175562143326,
0.056426893919706345,
-0.040266796946525574,
0.6510248780250549,
0.4466260075569153,
-0.3469022810459137,
-0.1904580295085907,
-0.10349605977535248,
0.024806028231978416,
0.24781344830989838,
0.8434909582138062,
-0.9344722628593445,
0.5994543433189392,
0.2946566343307495,
0.9571881294250488,
0.307599812746048,
0.1653369814157486,
0.7169955372810364,
-0.8945406675338745,
0.2420208603143692,
0.32816746830940247,
0.29946503043174744,
0.5826364755630493,
-0.5586363673210144,
0.31137651205062866,
-0.009685352444648743,
-0.20194438099861145,
-1.045611023902893,
-0.09497135877609253,
-0.7837756276130676,
-0.10393258184194565,
1.075160264968872,
-0.16072219610214233,
0.12026175856590271,
-0.18989244103431702,
-0.15312397480010986,
0.4455210566520691,
-0.5351414680480957,
0.29799601435661316,
0.12396835535764694,
-0.04762737825512886,
-0.12854944169521332,
0.033708058297634125,
0.6751241087913513,
0.3396303951740265,
-0.6909779906272888,
-0.022110939025878906,
0.43909952044487,
0.09493188560009003,
0.12535221874713898,
1.045087218284607,
0.13192331790924072,
0.33903393149375916,
-0.20348064601421356,
-0.12320353090763092,
-0.1292722523212433,
-0.4628535807132721,
-0.9104412794113159,
-0.042309075593948364,
-0.051325686275959015,
-0.1748533695936203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09948v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09948v1
|
BLEnD: A Benchmark for LLMs on Everyday Knowledge in Diverse Cultures and Languages
| 2024-06-14T11:48:54 | 2024-06-14T11:48:54 |
Junho Myung, Nayeon Lee, Yi Zhou, Jiho Jin, Rifki Afina Putri, Dimosthenis Antypas, Hsuvas Borkakoty, Eunsu Kim, Carla Perez-Almendros, Abinew Ali Ayele, Víctor Gutiérrez-Basulto, Yazmín Ibáñez-García, Hwaran Lee, Shamsuddeen Hassan Muhammad, Kiwoong Park, Anar Sabuhi Rzayev, Nina White, Seid Muhie Yimam, Mohammad Taher Pilehvar, Nedjma Ousidhoum, Jose Camacho-Collados, Alice Oh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) often lack culture-specific knowledge of daily
life, especially across diverse regions and non-English languages. Existing
benchmarks for evaluating LLMs' cultural sensitivities are limited to a single
language or collected from online sources such as Wikipedia, which do not
reflect the mundane everyday lifestyles of diverse regions. That is,
information about the food people eat for their birthday celebrations, spices
they typically use, musical instruments youngsters play, or the sports they
practice in school is common cultural knowledge but uncommon in easily
collected online sources, especially for underrepresented cultures. To address
this issue, we introduce BLEnD, a hand-crafted benchmark designed to evaluate
LLMs' everyday knowledge across diverse cultures and languages. BLEnD comprises
52.6k question-answer pairs from 16 countries/regions, in 13 different
languages, including low-resource ones such as Amharic, Assamese, Azerbaijani,
Hausa, and Sundanese. We construct the benchmark to include two formats of
questions: short-answer and multiple-choice. We show that LLMs perform better
for cultures that are highly represented online, with a maximum 57.34%
difference in GPT-4, the best-performing model, in the short-answer format. For
cultures represented by mid-to-high-resource languages, LLMs perform better in
their local languages, but for cultures represented by low-resource languages,
LLMs perform better in English than the local languages. We make our dataset
publicly available at: https://github.com/nlee0212/BLEnD.
|
[
-0.443708598613739,
-0.5192685127258301,
0.41352570056915283,
0.3852452337741852,
-0.13911710679531097,
0.4347524046897888,
-0.5579392313957214,
-0.7840589284896851,
0.2860320806503296,
0.3173571527004242,
-0.5927531719207764,
-0.4194035232067108,
-0.361803263425827,
0.12111373990774155,
-0.061181847006082535,
0.7704617977142334,
-0.1609766036272049,
0.17309920489788055,
-0.3944282829761505,
-0.4872725307941437,
-0.3394419550895691,
-0.29303598403930664,
-0.4445722997188568,
-0.5053307414054871,
0.33719512820243835,
0.338193416595459,
0.5019286870956421,
0.32602566480636597,
0.35228413343429565,
0.19490957260131836,
-0.3455877900123596,
0.4380664825439453,
-0.7573021650314331,
0.2627452611923218,
-0.13507387042045593,
-0.61339271068573,
-0.19981886446475983,
0.19091157615184784,
0.40123313665390015,
0.841553270816803,
-0.08075349777936935,
0.45109423995018005,
0.2362179011106491,
0.43105393648147583,
-0.6193152070045471,
-0.04685690626502037,
-0.5949535965919495,
0.30718594789505005,
-0.21374332904815674,
0.09165173768997192,
0.037001702934503555,
-0.5418689846992493,
-0.09632758796215057,
-0.6886476874351501,
-0.03595983609557152,
-0.040328074246644974,
0.6459448933601379,
0.0150337228551507,
-0.8619096279144287,
-0.023643139749765396,
-0.7927274107933044,
0.964058518409729,
-0.37866121530532837,
0.630481481552124,
0.5086938738822937,
0.3813866674900055,
-0.17800454795360565,
-0.2943545877933502,
-0.4928576946258545,
-0.053199607878923416,
0.11079276353120804,
0.41038256883621216,
0.010478177107870579,
-0.4354666769504547,
0.17851202189922333,
0.5727041959762573,
-0.5879858732223511,
-0.010041864588856697,
-0.20586282014846802,
-0.23180370032787323,
0.5207759141921997,
0.3607596457004547,
0.3137836754322052,
0.08916880190372467,
-0.3943745791912079,
-0.05009254068136215,
-0.9577053189277649,
0.23991434276103973,
0.2125273495912552,
-0.036153532564640045,
-0.41813430190086365,
0.4975992739200592,
-0.37719249725341797,
0.745179295539856,
-0.2507193088531494,
-0.5535546541213989,
0.17793430387973785,
-0.4641002416610718,
0.09915437549352646,
-0.5426819920539856,
0.5686023235321045,
0.7409164905548096,
0.48310041427612305,
-0.05265546217560768,
-0.11708679050207138,
-0.05841602012515068,
-0.33988815546035767,
-0.765718400478363,
-0.01947481371462345,
-0.09516352415084839,
-0.39392656087875366,
0.14052078127861023,
-0.396213173866272,
-0.6858319044113159,
-0.6790961027145386,
-0.16090519726276398,
0.09832169115543365,
-0.14449553191661835,
-0.18564748764038086,
-0.09483730047941208,
-0.10665334016084671,
0.5014616847038269,
0.4508534371852875,
-0.727220356464386,
0.4480314254760742,
0.6131384968757629,
0.8825345635414124,
-0.7107495069503784,
-0.14711542427539825,
-0.2822524309158325,
0.08637254685163498,
-0.08344608545303345,
0.7475737929344177,
-0.5803890228271484,
-0.5887724161148071,
0.0423385351896286,
-0.24009107053279877,
0.010273325257003307,
-0.987494707107544,
0.4590913951396942,
-0.43895241618156433,
0.19577015936374664,
-0.539273738861084,
-0.4239500164985657,
-0.01837402954697609,
0.8064591288566589,
-0.5542058348655701,
1.1679530143737793,
0.1324472874403,
-0.5058759450912476,
0.4533369541168213,
-0.22365249693393707,
-0.6325193643569946,
0.21549955010414124,
-0.5389640927314758,
0.30120810866355896,
-0.07139737159013748,
0.2929654121398926,
0.21378979086875916,
-0.6691338419914246,
0.18543092906475067,
-0.3898906707763672,
-0.46281614899635315,
0.43757274746894836,
-0.5672522783279419,
0.8336268067359924,
0.5389658808708191,
-0.10301569849252701,
-0.1692163050174713,
-0.7304409146308899,
0.03053797222673893,
0.2622087299823761,
-0.6168990135192871,
-0.2875923812389374,
-0.014490772038698196,
0.18280471861362457,
0.32888898253440857,
0.38579580187797546,
-0.6611146330833435,
0.1127195805311203,
-0.2679619789123535,
0.4692705273628235,
0.6321675777435303,
-0.11053547263145447,
0.1743534505367279,
-0.6536858677864075,
0.7351315021514893,
0.2079150229692459,
0.04563809186220169,
-0.09828703850507736,
-0.6308233737945557,
-0.7774466276168823,
-0.2613433003425598,
0.14808356761932373,
0.6514266133308411,
-0.5754714012145996,
0.0810583159327507,
-0.5339792370796204,
-0.5932849049568176,
-0.6143365502357483,
0.5213987231254578,
0.039542753249406815,
0.4122350215911865,
0.15927644073963165,
-0.5730665922164917,
-0.3905690908432007,
-0.8163754940032959,
-0.4754311740398407,
-0.016843019053339958,
-0.38496434688568115,
0.4302687346935272,
0.212098628282547,
-0.11925550550222397,
0.9646944403648376,
-0.6089653372764587,
-0.06263559311628342,
-0.35882046818733215,
-0.10083281993865967,
0.23529179394245148,
0.15428897738456726,
0.31781816482543945,
-0.7891051173210144,
-0.7902793288230896,
0.11741480976343155,
-0.6652485132217407,
-0.009421858936548233,
0.23117589950561523,
-0.13318949937820435,
0.1731829196214676,
0.19771790504455566,
-0.3033922612667084,
0.02276550978422165,
0.8208391070365906,
-0.2035999298095703,
0.1799798458814621,
-0.07916015386581421,
0.22979234158992767,
-1.1201152801513672,
-0.011124087497591972,
-0.05302228033542633,
-0.2999672591686249,
-0.3491525948047638,
0.09707175195217133,
0.11798962950706482,
-0.2239338755607605,
-0.6250555515289307,
1.0836052894592285,
-0.3700014054775238,
-0.009061289951205254,
0.028603125363588333,
0.08421431481838226,
0.0011960678966715932,
0.24847234785556793,
0.09841416031122208,
0.8664161562919617,
0.29637381434440613,
-0.5503280162811279,
0.23401550948619843,
-0.10357978940010071,
-0.761576771736145,
0.7699601650238037,
-0.35959383845329285,
-0.03501160070300102,
-0.042552683502435684,
0.43788373470306396,
-0.8173590302467346,
-0.3289855718612671,
0.06725503504276276,
0.008224592544138432,
-0.06716903299093246,
-0.04334698244929314,
-0.414076566696167,
-0.2486533373594284,
-0.16838370263576508,
0.712158739566803,
0.784447193145752,
-0.49247485399246216,
0.8034409880638123,
0.5376114845275879,
-0.0760166347026825,
-0.3929533064365387,
-0.8568961024284363,
-0.022197050973773003,
-0.42668935656547546,
-0.8681514859199524,
0.19129782915115356,
-0.623297393321991,
-0.48783427476882935,
-0.226845845580101,
-0.42582353949546814,
-0.20329001545906067,
0.3877060115337372,
0.0672411322593689,
0.07791165262460709,
-0.27590495347976685,
-0.19879502058029175,
-0.4038059413433075,
0.20447947084903717,
-0.014991151168942451,
-0.16844013333320618,
0.7124051451683044,
-0.24107633531093597,
-0.5635687708854675,
0.23133307695388794,
0.496768057346344,
0.4809214770793915,
-0.16902081668376923,
0.5462304353713989,
0.6128387451171875,
-0.2560458183288574,
-0.24484188854694366,
-0.808456540107727,
-0.09729526937007904,
-0.4727540910243988,
0.025867406278848648,
-0.36974138021469116,
-1.0420070886611938,
0.9977556467056274,
0.04343036189675331,
-0.010147315450012684,
0.3240475356578827,
0.59428870677948,
-0.27581918239593506,
0.5229291915893555,
0.4357890784740448,
-0.25470593571662903,
0.3203490674495697,
0.11303553730249405,
0.11846647411584854,
-0.44759392738342285,
-0.1745709478855133,
-0.23722149431705475,
-0.502926230430603,
-0.9619100093841553,
-0.8272743225097656,
0.6747850179672241,
-0.2212243527173996,
-0.1484076827764511,
-0.03115762025117874,
0.08893389254808426,
0.9197201728820801,
0.6044753789901733,
0.05280321463942528,
0.6382234692573547,
-0.06863898038864136,
-0.3568856120109558,
-0.21307875216007233,
-0.7397312521934509,
-0.34352824091911316,
1.0756944417953491,
0.17332185804843903,
1.0313588380813599,
0.254764199256897,
0.8025814294815063,
0.1998176872730255,
0.29044613242149353,
-0.6827976107597351,
0.584528923034668,
-0.2473536878824234,
-0.6795985102653503,
0.17822130024433136,
-0.5777081251144409,
-0.7675632834434509,
0.3367617726325989,
-0.09042007476091385,
-0.4918442964553833,
-0.07495240122079849,
0.11304941773414612,
-0.23423442244529724,
0.11491816490888596,
-0.6586886644363403,
0.6629959940910339,
-0.5036738514900208,
-0.46473127603530884,
0.07077206671237946,
-0.48650065064430237,
0.3864136040210724,
-0.10817976295948029,
0.618546724319458,
-0.4628364145755768,
0.006689082831144333,
0.6278824806213379,
0.20457521080970764,
0.9948907494544983,
0.3305405378341675,
-0.14328913390636444,
0.1890711635351181,
0.2552297115325928,
0.23928572237491608,
-0.03985176235437393,
-0.0635899156332016,
0.3690992593765259,
-0.023599298670887947,
-0.5132684707641602,
-0.38372576236724854,
0.82196444272995,
-0.8241034746170044,
-0.690642774105072,
-0.4919170141220093,
-0.6934804320335388,
-0.4529677629470825,
0.0734962597489357,
0.24312567710876465,
-0.011039802804589272,
-0.35769161581993103,
0.2597259283065796,
0.7383012771606445,
-0.15413114428520203,
0.21410274505615234,
0.9101807475090027,
-0.12627461552619934,
-0.22524718940258026,
0.9136266112327576,
0.2381914258003235,
0.36775150895118713,
0.2730230689048767,
0.441162645816803,
-0.11141246557235718,
-0.11798397451639175,
-0.3964521288871765,
0.10956712067127228,
-0.9952955842018127,
0.016575602814555168,
-0.5056749582290649,
-0.2950890064239502,
-0.2890084981918335,
-0.1465759128332138,
-0.21586889028549194,
-0.4137744903564453,
0.15399572253227234,
0.07092396169900894,
0.026956655085086823,
0.6165133714675903,
0.12235989421606064,
-0.11213501542806625,
-0.7823050022125244,
0.2616385817527771,
0.40851688385009766,
0.4246944785118103,
-0.17799979448318481,
-0.5091586112976074,
-0.1404639035463333,
0.11513971537351608,
-0.5205511450767517,
-0.7136884927749634,
0.18476234376430511,
0.4555855095386505,
0.8141914010047913,
0.3240324854850769,
0.08537169545888901,
0.8084100484848022,
-0.3467975854873657,
0.9792889356613159,
-0.039827413856983185,
-0.7497372627258301,
0.25969767570495605,
-0.3736156225204468,
0.6264605522155762,
0.677039623260498,
0.5917359590530396,
-1.092626690864563,
-0.7236392498016357,
-0.3026302754878998,
-0.9377428889274597,
0.3528386354446411,
0.03306473046541214,
0.2428070455789566,
-0.10830500721931458,
-0.1767745018005371,
0.26426273584365845,
0.1409558206796646,
-1.0817973613739014,
-0.2884747385978699,
0.08235405385494232,
-0.2568858861923218,
-0.08936141431331635,
-0.14112839102745056,
-0.5043515563011169,
-0.3106386065483093,
0.3827056884765625,
-0.17082473635673523,
-0.07077404856681824,
-0.21864748001098633,
-0.24458281695842743,
-0.2283899039030075,
0.36855074763298035,
0.5820380449295044,
0.7787866592407227,
-0.08331965655088425,
0.305043488740921,
0.5137346982955933,
-0.46155279874801636,
0.11498991400003433,
-0.021945668384432793,
-0.3276069164276123,
-0.5184844136238098,
0.38539668917655945,
0.4302877187728882,
0.24000877141952515,
-0.97475665807724,
0.23415638506412506,
-0.24787120521068573,
0.10195321589708328,
-0.277301162481308,
0.28756266832351685,
0.4126482605934143,
0.08163738250732422,
0.33608362078666687,
-0.20857754349708557,
-0.049979593604803085,
-0.7542543411254883,
-0.10797802358865738,
0.4063788056373596,
-0.11757052689790726,
-0.18118953704833984,
0.5996701717376709,
0.5061005353927612,
0.006384178996086121,
0.46267169713974,
-0.16230784356594086,
-0.38554492592811584,
0.565570592880249,
0.5951454043388367,
0.6331108808517456,
-0.03094477951526642,
0.09514426440000534,
0.25288617610931396,
0.3180920481681824,
-0.015507123433053493,
0.447814404964447,
-0.16173586249351501,
-1.0409040451049805,
-0.2907189726829529,
-0.9641379714012146,
-0.7185596227645874,
0.0965908020734787,
-0.4196280241012573,
0.08456827700138092,
-0.19754864275455475,
0.11142431944608688,
-0.3103336989879608,
0.13643641769886017,
-1.2141163349151611,
0.27347084879875183,
0.27159905433654785,
0.9910585880279541,
-1.26236891746521,
0.856666088104248,
0.965399980545044,
-0.10647725313901901,
-0.47532007098197937,
0.24915291368961334,
0.16123516857624054,
-1.1162000894546509,
0.6241692900657654,
0.19829557836055756,
-0.09843723475933075,
-0.29284119606018066,
-0.08160990476608276,
-0.8948652744293213,
0.9523763656616211,
0.462595134973526,
-0.28745317459106445,
0.47549861669540405,
0.5126581788063049,
0.7098578810691833,
-0.46651172637939453,
0.47568270564079285,
0.6063641309738159,
0.470794677734375,
0.3619745969772339,
-0.867793619632721,
-0.18888457119464874,
-0.30073240399360657,
-0.024395087733864784,
-0.06167028844356537,
-0.8232303261756897,
0.763911247253418,
0.11318080872297287,
-0.21002288162708282,
-0.29056447744369507,
0.6232552528381348,
0.3586975634098053,
0.40714696049690247,
0.46315231919288635,
0.40424883365631104,
0.811577558517456,
-0.24595846235752106,
0.8913887143135071,
-0.5263294577598572,
0.1157161295413971,
1.150184988975525,
-0.5689876675605774,
0.7994136810302734,
0.4547613263130188,
-0.25021353363990784,
0.34699690341949463,
0.8825051784515381,
0.06808186322450638,
0.2864724099636078,
0.21912921965122223,
-0.48765382170677185,
-0.517423152923584,
-0.5209339261054993,
-0.426107257604599,
0.7435775995254517,
0.10599387437105179,
-0.01620304025709629,
-0.3263423442840576,
-0.13939674198627472,
0.12570737302303314,
0.23515193164348602,
-0.11047801375389099,
0.6778318285942078,
0.15560117363929749,
-0.9811822175979614,
0.6349719762802124,
-0.06901448965072632,
0.826396107673645,
-0.7275145649909973,
0.16710960865020752,
-0.7774872183799744,
-0.006773293484002352,
-0.046062421053647995,
-1.0576918125152588,
0.2583778202533722,
0.11332311481237411,
-0.1876133382320404,
-0.26132893562316895,
0.5098770260810852,
-0.7383679747581482,
-0.585177481174469,
0.27605563402175903,
0.6892727613449097,
0.10104770213365555,
0.22936812043190002,
-0.3775017261505127,
0.2029491513967514,
0.020240142941474915,
-0.1407608985900879,
0.5775917172431946,
0.20523270964622498,
-0.208258718252182,
0.86375892162323,
0.44265949726104736,
0.17759481072425842,
0.12530966103076935,
-0.08205311745405197,
0.7635239958763123,
-0.6263406872749329,
-0.5572820901870728,
-0.6422150135040283,
0.3192674517631531,
-0.11799907684326172,
-0.4722912013530731,
0.9741872549057007,
0.6890295147895813,
1.26298189163208,
-0.02005215734243393,
0.7725690603256226,
0.003516135038807988,
0.2921479344367981,
-0.34777262806892395,
0.681621789932251,
-0.9198434352874756,
0.24447034299373627,
0.310507208108902,
-1.0653247833251953,
0.07671786099672318,
0.4721412658691406,
-0.22623348236083984,
0.1508222222328186,
0.4595474898815155,
0.5470521450042725,
-0.28888094425201416,
0.10407759994268417,
0.46896520256996155,
0.22214147448539734,
0.235224649310112,
0.45772621035575867,
0.8157058358192444,
0.038994643837213516,
0.5387256145477295,
-0.3643434941768646,
-0.03519739210605621,
-0.0030850644689053297,
-1.1561371088027954,
-0.773858904838562,
-0.31619876623153687,
-0.1852780282497406,
-0.1837524175643921,
-0.16208918392658234,
1.2354915142059326,
0.5809537172317505,
-0.829828143119812,
-0.7079358696937561,
0.4416584074497223,
0.22323817014694214,
-0.1841423660516739,
-0.17469267547130585,
-0.23565632104873657,
-0.13504351675510406,
-0.7183894515037537,
0.5833888053894043,
0.07217484712600708,
0.001439225859940052,
-0.26372289657592773,
-0.0687091127038002,
0.08396200835704803,
0.14953452348709106,
0.5930290222167969,
0.3100600838661194,
-0.7009860873222351,
-0.15320666134357452,
0.1758624166250229,
-0.2185675948858261,
0.12739461660385132,
0.6620087027549744,
-0.5369496941566467,
0.6869503259658813,
0.5612109899520874,
0.6520112156867981,
0.583777666091919,
-0.16002409160137177,
0.6416664719581604,
-0.8492487072944641,
0.09378435462713242,
0.27654829621315,
0.3531673848628998,
0.5758758187294006,
-0.046344757080078125,
0.6010176539421082,
0.36182814836502075,
-0.42069968581199646,
-0.4956343173980713,
0.4138390123844147,
-1.0214771032333374,
0.010105579160153866,
1.3028935194015503,
-0.269208699464798,
-0.11307541280984879,
-0.05489550530910492,
0.18439994752407074,
-0.12682439386844635,
-0.21282583475112915,
0.8043190836906433,
0.9798889756202698,
0.0802173763513565,
0.1340961903333664,
-0.745795726776123,
0.29234078526496887,
0.5505945086479187,
-0.7344484925270081,
-0.18771393597126007,
0.4100355803966522,
0.7466073036193848,
-0.10201095044612885,
0.7443838715553284,
0.21281614899635315,
0.09450821578502655,
-0.3962624669075012,
-0.10257381200790405,
0.2556348741054535,
-0.12332867830991745,
-0.08323909342288971,
0.07667618989944458,
0.23711605370044708,
0.1743098348379135
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09938v1
|
Experiments in News Bias Detection with Pre-Trained Neural Transformers
| 2024-06-14T11:34:36 | 2024-06-14T11:34:36 |
Tim Menzner, Jochen L. Leidner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The World Wide Web provides unrivalled access to information globally,
including factual news reporting and commentary. However, state actors and
commercial players increasingly spread biased (distorted) or fake (non-factual)
information to promote their agendas. We compare several large, pre-trained
language models on the task of sentence-level news bias detection and sub-type
classification, providing quantitative and qualitative results.
|
[
-0.5864799618721008,
-0.8260404467582703,
0.6109166741371155,
0.31840482354164124,
-0.056072428822517395,
-0.14803706109523773,
-0.21708296239376068,
-0.5959257483482361,
0.14657863974571228,
0.2870687246322632,
-0.5144996047019958,
-0.1845887452363968,
-0.796244204044342,
-0.16488558053970337,
-0.8218953013420105,
1.2106614112854004,
0.20089566707611084,
0.49151936173439026,
-0.3171862065792084,
0.05205274745821953,
0.16020385921001434,
-0.6186367273330688,
-0.434521347284317,
-0.41960176825523376,
0.4742403030395508,
0.0605345256626606,
0.7857305407524109,
-0.036193594336509705,
0.18070195615291595,
0.324572890996933,
0.04133400693535805,
-0.029250413179397583,
-0.19017833471298218,
-0.3873344659805298,
-0.5106998085975647,
-0.6861982345581055,
-0.2804810106754303,
0.526322066783905,
0.4830574095249176,
0.5612688660621643,
0.30342450737953186,
0.4520527124404907,
-0.14392146468162537,
0.3600199222564697,
-0.722924530506134,
-0.10877236723899841,
-0.4572344124317169,
0.3452017307281494,
-0.11878599971532822,
-0.13249492645263672,
-0.6054632067680359,
-0.7672100067138672,
0.5095676779747009,
-0.7611744999885559,
0.4844283163547516,
0.12001073360443115,
0.932167112827301,
0.20464521646499634,
-0.9311966300010681,
-0.27764737606048584,
-0.7901172637939453,
0.7230002284049988,
-0.36168649792671204,
0.696955680847168,
0.20807640254497528,
-0.04152325168251991,
-0.13232038915157318,
-0.6909198760986328,
-0.723106861114502,
-0.4139458239078522,
-0.15503419935703278,
0.3432910740375519,
-0.39625048637390137,
0.06379061192274094,
0.39826932549476624,
0.26049885153770447,
-0.47162604331970215,
0.19663135707378387,
-0.3131415545940399,
-0.38644301891326904,
0.458458811044693,
-0.47386154532432556,
0.5054318308830261,
-0.08627725392580032,
-0.23246437311172485,
-0.0074823773466050625,
-0.4463399350643158,
-0.10104820877313614,
0.853280782699585,
-0.05951352044939995,
-0.15301693975925446,
0.3661145865917206,
-0.31273555755615234,
0.6608584523200989,
0.2783586084842682,
-0.0941920280456543,
0.3041650652885437,
-0.318447083234787,
-0.09974771738052368,
0.1926094889640808,
0.7284001708030701,
0.47148242592811584,
0.5069046020507812,
-0.016686486080288887,
-0.1103571355342865,
0.5099601149559021,
0.5155335068702698,
-0.4056914150714874,
0.005548673216253519,
-0.20440232753753662,
-0.7691614031791687,
-0.39450737833976746,
0.14634466171264648,
-0.8645341396331787,
-0.5560245513916016,
-0.304910272359848,
0.6692406535148621,
0.061372142285108566,
-0.2939600944519043,
0.050812020897865295,
-0.6062309145927429,
0.14500603079795837,
0.217895969748497,
-0.49417176842689514,
0.07693107426166534,
0.24972987174987793,
0.49511000514030457,
-0.14684946835041046,
-0.06410802155733109,
-0.30963167548179626,
-0.342516154050827,
-0.3091704547405243,
1.017722487449646,
-0.3372449576854706,
0.07924797385931015,
0.315676212310791,
0.00103001540992409,
0.2621877193450928,
-0.49428653717041016,
0.7487659454345703,
-0.6712307929992676,
0.583993136882782,
-0.38656213879585266,
-0.22863943874835968,
0.037926483899354935,
0.29599395394325256,
-0.7903246879577637,
0.5865631103515625,
0.23585684597492218,
-1.1272262334823608,
0.8965926170349121,
-0.6309013962745667,
-0.8045534491539001,
-0.7082425951957703,
0.05009237304329872,
-0.3698418438434601,
0.22079813480377197,
0.5207889080047607,
0.058731481432914734,
-0.05033506080508232,
0.21266956627368927,
-0.11408931016921997,
-0.23092488944530487,
0.447070449590683,
-0.7873480916023254,
0.5458276867866516,
0.16011936962604523,
-0.5174415111541748,
0.2226136177778244,
-0.6688769459724426,
-0.4747978150844574,
0.03837950527667999,
-0.41942501068115234,
-0.43200233578681946,
-0.020550278946757317,
0.2544989287853241,
0.45431360602378845,
-0.07071094214916229,
-0.7884225845336914,
0.3148304522037506,
-0.0408969521522522,
0.25305333733558655,
0.6482078433036804,
-0.1722661256790161,
0.6294719576835632,
-0.23966336250305176,
0.43447843194007874,
0.6282065510749817,
0.5436081886291504,
0.030354389920830727,
-0.09460479766130447,
-1.0097076892852783,
0.169988214969635,
0.4366612434387207,
0.42067262530326843,
-0.8532302379608154,
0.2840934693813324,
-0.26770809292793274,
-0.17111581563949585,
-0.496358722448349,
-0.2544422149658203,
0.22888946533203125,
0.5803751945495605,
0.5237154960632324,
-0.06432920694351196,
-0.8924403190612793,
-1.1329916715621948,
-0.7946360111236572,
0.17501918971538544,
-0.08724149316549301,
-0.18032772839069366,
0.2442205399274826,
-0.26290786266326904,
0.921920120716095,
-0.29270511865615845,
-0.40179315209388733,
-0.3745989501476288,
0.4301203787326813,
-0.03646332398056984,
0.29817038774490356,
0.506552517414093,
-1.0884758234024048,
-0.34285151958465576,
-0.34542760252952576,
-0.599367082118988,
-0.0848284587264061,
-0.21125705540180206,
0.07925936579704285,
0.33147817850112915,
0.4583689868450165,
-0.7343119978904724,
0.702238142490387,
0.5120288729667664,
-0.3146272599697113,
0.5558109879493713,
0.08370965719223022,
0.11708321422338486,
-0.8423741459846497,
-0.08519459515810013,
0.31520453095436096,
-0.4851185083389282,
-0.5904738903045654,
-0.5059154033660889,
-0.08711651712656021,
0.3658025562763214,
-0.5698652863502502,
0.2947359085083008,
-0.41409409046173096,
-0.4717816412448883,
-0.40145745873451233,
0.3033900856971741,
0.03518093004822731,
0.1736212968826294,
0.08377238363027573,
0.7532843947410583,
0.31406864523887634,
-0.5450621247291565,
0.3306752145290375,
0.051253791898489,
-0.7713008522987366,
0.3031269609928131,
-0.3565807342529297,
-0.19235391914844513,
-0.47986066341400146,
0.8610556721687317,
-0.753248929977417,
-0.20299945771694183,
-0.13830243051052094,
-0.6020957231521606,
0.017034875229001045,
-0.13472038507461548,
-0.49004805088043213,
-0.5140815377235413,
-0.05052018165588379,
0.3186115622520447,
0.6192690134048462,
-0.6778631210327148,
0.3505849838256836,
0.4559490978717804,
0.3336561918258667,
-0.8020088076591492,
-0.9293568134307861,
-0.32371190190315247,
0.12042943388223648,
-0.34779810905456543,
0.14676739275455475,
0.36590322852134705,
-0.23755359649658203,
0.2930581867694855,
-0.47698867321014404,
-0.14685092866420746,
-0.11490239948034286,
0.03079047240316868,
0.09377092868089676,
-0.2943774163722992,
-0.14436958730220795,
-0.1121324673295021,
0.16464132070541382,
0.34043383598327637,
-0.6329954862594604,
0.6318089962005615,
0.10986662656068802,
-0.36768266558647156,
-0.756410539150238,
-0.02713669277727604,
0.7044180035591125,
-0.19889189302921295,
0.6734857559204102,
0.7224367260932922,
-0.14373458921909332,
-0.2833904027938843,
-0.7760995030403137,
-0.2732678949832916,
-0.4130934178829193,
0.31694456934928894,
0.20998631417751312,
-0.7142419219017029,
0.17902083694934845,
0.02569432742893696,
-0.06442629545927048,
0.3100130259990692,
0.32185670733451843,
0.18849341571331024,
1.429642677307129,
0.5151922106742859,
-0.3927614986896515,
0.6876391768455505,
-0.24329324066638947,
0.34128865599632263,
-0.3482063114643097,
-0.10245222598314285,
-0.25935375690460205,
-0.5128652453422546,
-0.43736061453819275,
-0.11441430449485779,
0.21452432870864868,
-0.10948684811592102,
-0.12637747824192047,
-0.08528948575258255,
-0.4528122842311859,
0.6399569511413574,
0.9003844857215881,
0.09330552816390991,
0.22498208284378052,
0.0711028203368187,
-0.11897896975278854,
0.06271170824766159,
-0.6139395236968994,
-0.12396781891584396,
1.0075548887252808,
0.293266236782074,
0.9473125338554382,
-0.34684503078460693,
0.12789645791053772,
0.6677959561347961,
0.7080798745155334,
-0.6294016242027283,
0.16084973514080048,
-0.07448069751262665,
-0.8804685473442078,
-0.012860164977610111,
-0.1481657475233078,
-0.6631770730018616,
0.33843398094177246,
-0.4551905393600464,
-0.3567229211330414,
0.2469714879989624,
0.42927488684654236,
-0.2734486758708954,
0.5601051449775696,
-0.7829466462135315,
0.6860923767089844,
-0.2553069293498993,
-0.09172341972589493,
-0.2431201934814453,
-0.5225818753242493,
0.4509156048297882,
-0.049560051411390305,
0.26510483026504517,
0.08760424703359604,
0.22041702270507812,
0.5646218061447144,
0.21894453465938568,
0.6246302723884583,
-0.30545201897621155,
0.12475638836622238,
0.17817579209804535,
-0.3269289433956146,
0.27444586157798767,
0.16177590191364288,
0.1803092360496521,
0.15681956708431244,
-0.3612480163574219,
-0.42823684215545654,
-0.49225303530693054,
0.43653419613838196,
-0.9641003608703613,
-0.6543121933937073,
-0.677928626537323,
-0.5870673060417175,
-0.33638909459114075,
0.2776555120944977,
0.6658695936203003,
0.3101641535758972,
-0.3978536128997803,
0.23342733085155487,
0.6612728238105774,
-0.37367475032806396,
0.31842148303985596,
0.6831093430519104,
-0.36059847474098206,
0.09964397549629211,
0.41690608859062195,
0.11814046651124954,
0.2156229168176651,
0.32892388105392456,
0.10015649348497391,
-0.37087884545326233,
-0.32631155848503113,
-0.20371030271053314,
-0.18581576645374298,
-0.4881227910518646,
-0.01692306436598301,
-0.7352490425109863,
-0.3682314157485962,
-0.4943501949310303,
-0.006107938941568136,
-0.44389739632606506,
-0.28810760378837585,
-0.0709281712770462,
-0.4477582275867462,
-0.07250521332025528,
0.8358268737792969,
-0.31859341263771057,
0.59269118309021,
-0.610964298248291,
0.5716500282287598,
0.2607550323009491,
0.25184428691864014,
-0.16693884134292603,
-0.41919830441474915,
-0.1740909367799759,
0.2762862741947174,
-0.3279336392879486,
-0.8382861614227295,
0.27417266368865967,
-0.27962687611579895,
0.5520414113998413,
0.6488510370254517,
-0.14816917479038239,
0.284320205450058,
-0.5267960429191589,
0.865359365940094,
0.1935049146413803,
-0.9300983548164368,
0.5956752896308899,
-0.541383683681488,
0.23442745208740234,
0.35656359791755676,
0.8854760527610779,
-0.5070087909698486,
-0.19443567097187042,
-0.5912706255912781,
-0.38305866718292236,
0.8442168235778809,
-0.19155950844287872,
0.22398068010807037,
-0.15704487264156342,
0.14642976224422455,
0.04425289109349251,
0.2874094247817993,
-1.1229324340820312,
-0.2633225619792938,
-0.6102002859115601,
-0.04217056930065155,
-0.0743340477347374,
-0.39994338154792786,
0.010743794031441212,
-0.28548818826675415,
0.6261060237884521,
0.006459351629018784,
0.3597443401813507,
0.527212917804718,
-0.5764656662940979,
-0.12297060340642929,
0.42712292075157166,
0.7201846241950989,
0.7722222805023193,
0.053084347397089005,
0.36910560727119446,
0.06371789425611496,
-0.6561093926429749,
0.2805446684360504,
-0.09860292822122574,
-0.48021936416625977,
0.1724354773759842,
0.5135298371315002,
0.7296422123908997,
0.10500898957252502,
-0.5881433486938477,
0.8950969576835632,
-0.16268222033977509,
-0.36236870288848877,
-0.6008410453796387,
-0.05836724117398262,
0.013282646425068378,
0.202458918094635,
0.4679640531539917,
0.3446163237094879,
0.26894813776016235,
-0.9316814541816711,
0.31520792841911316,
0.4334002435207367,
-0.5901370644569397,
-0.5589028000831604,
0.6170903444290161,
0.29054921865463257,
0.014673265628516674,
0.7836828827857971,
-0.046648889780044556,
-0.9534279704093933,
0.6230725049972534,
0.8231112360954285,
0.45607295632362366,
-0.17497436702251434,
0.30551740527153015,
-0.05595579743385315,
0.5479391813278198,
-0.46102070808410645,
0.2384253591299057,
0.29381170868873596,
-1.0138064622879028,
-0.4490845501422882,
-0.5106456875801086,
0.19000883400440216,
0.5428784489631653,
-0.7652133107185364,
0.0751572996377945,
-0.43764379620552063,
-0.45040908455848694,
0.17786097526550293,
-0.27549615502357483,
-0.7341669201850891,
0.4020494520664215,
0.3601953685283661,
1.1078892946243286,
-1.0525747537612915,
0.9361608028411865,
0.7879414558410645,
-0.5265310406684875,
-0.3027021884918213,
0.5713005065917969,
0.02792847901582718,
-0.5739077925682068,
0.9529711604118347,
0.3316929042339325,
0.2364368885755539,
-0.17677004635334015,
-0.5272632241249084,
-0.9032018780708313,
0.5394123196601868,
0.4030601978302002,
-0.4319401681423187,
-0.24867026507854462,
0.31644055247306824,
0.5062541365623474,
-0.12685425579547882,
0.4420781135559082,
0.6356492638587952,
0.6068956255912781,
-0.3480575978755951,
-1.0092246532440186,
-0.27284348011016846,
0.09354258328676224,
-0.2819104492664337,
0.29369214177131653,
-0.70558100938797,
0.8906903266906738,
0.197703555226326,
0.06504451483488083,
-0.6160019636154175,
0.7834634184837341,
-0.4266163408756256,
0.15187036991119385,
0.8206849694252014,
0.5662745833396912,
0.5599082708358765,
-0.2343934327363968,
1.0116900205612183,
-0.2602568566799164,
0.06373132765293121,
0.8372916579246521,
-0.1146044135093689,
0.400903582572937,
0.19164055585861206,
0.005352939013391733,
0.8156650066375732,
0.42699670791625977,
-0.10892132669687271,
0.5511018633842468,
0.33635714650154114,
-0.22423486411571503,
-0.11195361614227295,
-0.3191176950931549,
-0.33735987544059753,
0.458291620016098,
0.30955544114112854,
-0.41231241822242737,
-0.183425173163414,
0.4898580014705658,
0.13529525697231293,
0.072849340736866,
-0.5817278027534485,
0.34184059500694275,
0.010082338936626911,
-1.115151047706604,
0.05631975457072258,
-0.15785890817642212,
1.1404720544815063,
-0.5467923879623413,
0.30107972025871277,
-0.25400274991989136,
0.46181973814964294,
-0.4211093485355377,
-0.5628520846366882,
0.28489264845848083,
-0.036513540893793106,
-0.37690269947052,
-0.16546443104743958,
1.0351386070251465,
-0.23041610419750214,
-0.23284173011779785,
0.46627750992774963,
0.40855690836906433,
-0.2163316011428833,
-0.2849079668521881,
-0.5047047734260559,
0.05323098972439766,
-0.09371431916952133,
-0.5076770782470703,
0.4004650115966797,
0.06818093359470367,
-0.17108188569545746,
0.5728351473808289,
0.7365775108337402,
-0.05818193033337593,
0.622465193271637,
0.27706649899482727,
0.7757311463356018,
-0.4248778522014618,
-0.45677268505096436,
-0.729314386844635,
0.012237660586833954,
-0.3467491567134857,
-0.2591572701931,
1.0459898710250854,
0.7644303441047668,
1.1514114141464233,
-0.3179154694080353,
1.03891921043396,
0.10907486081123352,
0.3449242115020752,
-0.3894229233264923,
0.7556379437446594,
-0.42914751172065735,
-0.5039791464805603,
0.014150526374578476,
-0.89382004737854,
-0.20535783469676971,
0.6709544062614441,
-0.37275123596191406,
0.10083720088005066,
0.7747623920440674,
0.35583674907684326,
-0.4346863329410553,
0.12175361067056656,
0.07752178609371185,
0.3468371331691742,
0.007474884856492281,
0.22970561683177948,
1.2297934293746948,
-0.14887355268001556,
0.42643049359321594,
-0.16263963282108307,
-0.18079693615436554,
-0.12843631207942963,
-0.653107225894928,
-1.1045602560043335,
-0.23681092262268066,
0.0020268757361918688,
-0.4230128228664398,
0.17782489955425262,
0.8767699599266052,
1.1015335321426392,
-0.8135983943939209,
0.13659435510635376,
-0.1357164829969406,
0.21524542570114136,
0.05565870180726051,
-0.21819107234477997,
0.21101512014865875,
-0.5078156590461731,
-0.7329476475715637,
0.27993521094322205,
-0.06229172274470329,
-0.08251010626554489,
-0.584216296672821,
0.5152562260627747,
-0.4584575593471527,
0.32010897994041443,
0.62117999792099,
0.10307491570711136,
-0.6324521899223328,
-0.3990381956100464,
0.03417656570672989,
-0.11889491230249405,
-0.008923406712710857,
1.1185392141342163,
-0.8933588862419128,
-0.023721842095255852,
0.6976141333580017,
0.44472312927246094,
0.44039562344551086,
0.18020929396152496,
0.5933393836021423,
-0.9587097764015198,
0.6985452771186829,
-0.03517371416091919,
0.22906045615673065,
0.14639189839363098,
-0.4418835937976837,
0.16628025472164154,
0.3411020338535309,
-0.632574200630188,
-0.5686739087104797,
0.2891966998577118,
-0.5613127946853638,
-0.5577475428581238,
1.025865912437439,
0.19017864763736725,
-0.23051917552947998,
-0.2531498968601227,
0.010983156971633434,
0.5320141315460205,
-0.16004931926727295,
0.730147659778595,
0.6902816295623779,
-0.01033610850572586,
0.1264737993478775,
-0.7777236104011536,
0.8634387850761414,
0.32137954235076904,
-0.7983012795448303,
-0.4263956546783447,
0.4822411835193634,
0.4737025201320648,
0.3966329097747803,
0.551662266254425,
0.009089432656764984,
0.2084411233663559,
-0.03655732423067093,
0.1505216360092163,
0.23097503185272217,
-0.5540148019790649,
-0.12052177637815475,
-0.11910606175661087,
-0.3112899363040924,
-0.08036962896585464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09923v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09923v1
|
CliBench: Multifaceted Evaluation of Large Language Models in Clinical Decisions on Diagnoses, Procedures, Lab Tests Orders and Prescriptions
| 2024-06-14T11:10:17 | 2024-06-14T11:10:17 |
Mingyu Derek Ma, Chenchen Ye, Yu Yan, Xiaoxuan Wang, Peipei Ping, Timothy S Chang, Wei Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The integration of Artificial Intelligence (AI), especially Large Language
Models (LLMs), into the clinical diagnosis process offers significant potential
to improve the efficiency and accessibility of medical care. While LLMs have
shown some promise in the medical domain, their application in clinical
diagnosis remains underexplored, especially in real-world clinical practice,
where highly sophisticated, patient-specific decisions need to be made. Current
evaluations of LLMs in this field are often narrow in scope, focusing on
specific diseases or specialties and employing simplified diagnostic tasks. To
bridge this gap, we introduce CliBench, a novel benchmark developed from the
MIMIC IV dataset, offering a comprehensive and realistic assessment of LLMs'
capabilities in clinical diagnosis. This benchmark not only covers diagnoses
from a diverse range of medical cases across various specialties but also
incorporates tasks of clinical significance: treatment procedure
identification, lab test ordering and medication prescriptions. Supported by
structured output ontologies, CliBench enables a precise and multi-granular
evaluation, offering an in-depth understanding of LLM's capability on diverse
clinical tasks of desired granularity. We conduct a zero-shot evaluation of
leading LLMs to assess their proficiency in clinical decision-making. Our
preliminary results shed light on the potential and limitations of current LLMs
in clinical settings, providing valuable insights for future advancements in
LLM-powered healthcare.
|
[
-0.2052137404680252,
-0.5741892457008362,
0.8047811985015869,
0.15085040032863617,
-0.11855044960975647,
0.025665925815701485,
-0.6071119904518127,
-0.5547757744789124,
0.02801489271223545,
0.6423548460006714,
-0.6193792819976807,
-0.8952448964118958,
-0.7039774656295776,
0.14523743093013763,
-0.5666031241416931,
0.7720223069190979,
0.10033983737230301,
0.4627986252307892,
-0.39611345529556274,
-0.4252588748931885,
-0.4284549057483673,
-0.578828752040863,
-0.5264540314674377,
-0.4830598533153534,
0.5556386113166809,
0.2574649155139923,
0.5975201725959778,
0.4594475328922272,
0.7502897381782532,
0.2839867174625397,
0.23093661665916443,
0.24840939044952393,
-0.20249104499816895,
0.21458442509174347,
-0.1415327489376068,
-0.48413556814193726,
-0.44102516770362854,
-0.2304280549287796,
0.4832943081855774,
1.0355161428451538,
-0.08136158436536789,
0.10845404118299484,
-0.10243182629346848,
0.6403268575668335,
-0.47317740321159363,
0.15476436913013458,
-0.45453378558158875,
0.08046701550483704,
-0.2936839461326599,
0.18660855293273926,
-0.2255765050649643,
-0.4055362641811371,
0.38862594962120056,
-0.49176108837127686,
0.23888514935970306,
0.1700851172208786,
0.6024540662765503,
0.3344387114048004,
-0.2614930272102356,
-0.6382856369018555,
-0.5037825107574463,
0.7701998949050903,
-0.706810474395752,
0.40667012333869934,
-0.04274920001626015,
0.5690767765045166,
-0.19537729024887085,
-1.0508708953857422,
-0.3942248821258545,
-0.5347497463226318,
-0.18255233764648438,
0.041174907237291336,
-0.1377716362476349,
0.30573201179504395,
0.2068098485469818,
0.2944495379924774,
-0.8689613342285156,
0.3393543064594269,
-0.38822469115257263,
-0.3012160062789917,
0.4948473572731018,
0.4349125623703003,
0.3723621964454651,
0.037888240069150925,
-0.1750534325838089,
0.054420262575149536,
-0.5159358978271484,
-0.20912693440914154,
-0.24088908731937408,
0.22451193630695343,
-0.04271756857633591,
0.31531861424446106,
-0.11333467066287994,
0.7763235569000244,
-0.04001113399863243,
-0.3903923034667969,
0.3527372181415558,
-0.17185348272323608,
-0.21830104291439056,
0.20444653928279877,
0.976781964302063,
0.3133115768432617,
0.27629539370536804,
-0.12346151471138,
0.18414467573165894,
0.1222696453332901,
0.11690618842840195,
-0.752165675163269,
-0.2114459127187729,
0.5927110314369202,
-0.6464764475822449,
-0.2477635145187378,
-0.23350906372070312,
-0.7857386469841003,
-0.7663173675537109,
-0.2533648610115051,
0.14958101511001587,
-0.5599847435951233,
-0.03368496522307396,
0.29122474789619446,
-0.007996320724487305,
-0.14320755004882812,
0.39268508553504944,
-0.543453574180603,
0.5810779929161072,
0.6970217823982239,
0.7256317138671875,
-0.22360461950302124,
-0.3000878393650055,
-0.37400108575820923,
-0.08171270042657852,
-0.40513554215431213,
0.8207826614379883,
-0.45604974031448364,
-0.44536879658699036,
0.23525357246398926,
-0.02951125055551529,
-0.22256724536418915,
-1.1038012504577637,
0.529462456703186,
-0.12118398398160934,
-0.2748604118824005,
-0.08604653924703598,
-0.5070553421974182,
-0.13849297165870667,
0.42842355370521545,
-0.6613648533821106,
0.622387707233429,
0.3428996801376343,
-0.4599529802799225,
0.4700150191783905,
-0.6247425079345703,
-0.4922191798686981,
0.2717345654964447,
-0.286620557308197,
-0.37426450848579407,
-0.0650549978017807,
0.08489593118429184,
0.43691742420196533,
-0.7764523029327393,
0.3602840006351471,
-0.5435269474983215,
-0.11422575265169144,
0.4083413779735565,
-0.16425029933452606,
0.7853564023971558,
0.13896141946315765,
-0.14071521162986755,
0.18213380873203278,
-0.569841742515564,
0.2580966353416443,
-0.11516670137643814,
0.13418595492839813,
-0.1561141312122345,
-0.06002146005630493,
-0.31695523858070374,
0.006218216381967068,
0.4367508590221405,
-0.27242395281791687,
0.45791304111480713,
-0.4788995385169983,
0.5300862789154053,
0.3653717339038849,
-0.04805449768900871,
0.045030005276203156,
-0.6664111018180847,
0.6386085152626038,
-0.11591427028179169,
0.46094805002212524,
-0.21756809949874878,
-0.38121354579925537,
-0.8059144020080566,
-0.8047760725021362,
0.515318751335144,
0.6437581777572632,
-0.11831866949796677,
0.28415647149086,
-0.08831888437271118,
-0.6565667986869812,
-0.6679379343986511,
0.2707184851169586,
0.39529359340667725,
0.4154517948627472,
0.19700895249843597,
-0.13456228375434875,
-0.4209165871143341,
-1.0744991302490234,
-0.2279808074235916,
0.010124712251126766,
-0.07056588679552078,
0.44007575511932373,
0.6798787117004395,
-0.543262779712677,
0.5445956587791443,
-0.4093208909034729,
-0.6371479630470276,
-0.5843733549118042,
0.22340533137321472,
0.5436429977416992,
0.16027747094631195,
0.6413838267326355,
-0.34675881266593933,
-0.47519269585609436,
0.34278246760368347,
-0.8123774528503418,
-0.4683079421520233,
-0.04008330777287483,
0.06809284538030624,
-0.21734097599983215,
0.5057507753372192,
-0.5766843557357788,
0.43088066577911377,
0.6222167611122131,
0.11402276903390884,
0.724622905254364,
-0.4795932173728943,
0.21263954043388367,
-0.5271881222724915,
0.34485742449760437,
-0.2969960868358612,
-0.3218781054019928,
-0.5055830478668213,
0.06830489635467529,
0.18368223309516907,
0.0022601638920605183,
-0.3452398180961609,
0.7456459999084473,
-0.26864033937454224,
-0.06506659090518951,
0.0979192778468132,
0.2706628739833832,
0.1011272668838501,
0.08017407357692719,
-0.07807829231023788,
0.398120641708374,
0.643419086933136,
-0.7626118063926697,
0.5638654232025146,
0.08640734106302261,
-0.6361373066902161,
0.5946840047836304,
-0.7933962345123291,
-0.0843457505106926,
0.20270831882953644,
0.14110048115253448,
-0.7415372729301453,
-0.2554627060890198,
0.09690029919147491,
-0.4322836399078369,
0.11903278529644012,
0.10257595032453537,
-0.8752384781837463,
-0.6008980870246887,
-0.1470126360654831,
0.5842921137809753,
0.4987618923187256,
-0.3498086929321289,
0.5777865648269653,
0.1410481482744217,
-0.26763540506362915,
-0.3173102140426636,
-0.5092954635620117,
-0.1149960309267044,
-0.03253654018044472,
-0.5423740744590759,
0.4159395694732666,
-0.1880759596824646,
-0.4099422097206116,
-0.26570025086402893,
0.30855298042297363,
-0.176378071308136,
0.08956955373287201,
0.2634061276912689,
0.29621216654777527,
-0.1635882407426834,
0.2596648633480072,
0.17796066403388977,
-0.025391021743416786,
0.04258256033062935,
-0.06904178112745285,
0.6298306584358215,
-0.15465670824050903,
-0.7318699359893799,
-0.5275548696517944,
0.22620227932929993,
1.033672571182251,
-0.2626136541366577,
0.45236489176750183,
0.24932034313678741,
-0.41409730911254883,
-0.4236021637916565,
-0.4185696244239807,
-0.04340840131044388,
-0.3789336383342743,
0.300831139087677,
-0.09961644560098648,
-0.5308875441551208,
0.6509746313095093,
-0.459369421005249,
-0.038616154342889786,
0.3246058523654938,
0.7860904335975647,
-0.10471037030220032,
1.2671653032302856,
0.2132517248392105,
0.04969463497400284,
-0.04150830954313278,
-0.26823553442955017,
0.47683367133140564,
-0.8415127396583557,
-0.2565971612930298,
-0.6055684089660645,
-0.10795291513204575,
-0.43702787160873413,
-0.4494289457798004,
0.938728928565979,
-0.04700266569852829,
-0.27534934878349304,
-0.2131088674068451,
-0.5023666620254517,
-0.02669214829802513,
0.24372601509094238,
0.1772846132516861,
0.5141307711601257,
-0.48593688011169434,
-0.5098506808280945,
-0.08239581435918808,
-0.5995324850082397,
-0.34933578968048096,
1.3124959468841553,
0.2527855634689331,
0.5053730607032776,
-0.14086271822452545,
0.418099582195282,
0.6134577989578247,
0.6202225089073181,
-1.0396851301193237,
0.4280749559402466,
-0.41133949160575867,
-0.6840275526046753,
0.014132161624729633,
-0.04240566864609718,
-1.058656096458435,
0.32781460881233215,
-0.07297823578119278,
-0.8372798562049866,
-0.1799645721912384,
0.1307184398174286,
-0.542955219745636,
0.03714827448129654,
-0.4722835421562195,
1.080188512802124,
-0.7372798919677734,
-0.04245511442422867,
-0.40745338797569275,
-0.4666922986507416,
0.4612666368484497,
-0.239574134349823,
0.44368162751197815,
-0.12963293492794037,
-0.01693158596754074,
0.5594777464866638,
-0.5415053963661194,
0.8487198948860168,
0.04364651441574097,
0.2579725384712219,
0.058502379804849625,
0.21119289100170135,
-0.005005327053368092,
0.0641363188624382,
-0.24115005135536194,
0.4335538446903229,
0.41596245765686035,
-0.15738597512245178,
-0.783413827419281,
0.6241148710250854,
-0.6049824953079224,
-0.4119265079498291,
-0.6016414165496826,
-0.5432401299476624,
-0.49355173110961914,
0.44565248489379883,
0.16173134744167328,
0.7089784145355225,
-0.3258644640445709,
0.04465048387646675,
0.5196253061294556,
-0.4690760672092438,
-0.23073416948318481,
0.7598918080329895,
-0.4746584892272949,
-0.38403186202049255,
0.6578269004821777,
-0.049656931310892105,
0.29947271943092346,
0.17715857923030853,
0.3576231598854065,
-0.3695036470890045,
-0.8846434354782104,
-0.3245861530303955,
0.5992413759231567,
-0.6331632137298584,
-0.174738347530365,
-0.5328502058982849,
-0.3011435866355896,
-0.5116050243377686,
-0.3345967233181,
-0.37397706508636475,
0.08463974297046661,
-0.12263704836368561,
0.2997831106185913,
0.21834777295589447,
0.7636241316795349,
0.03905605152249336,
0.24848343431949615,
-0.8302236795425415,
0.38387128710746765,
-0.10084569454193115,
0.24161309003829956,
0.035580702126026154,
-0.40665340423583984,
-0.1534116119146347,
0.029112467542290688,
-0.28442907333374023,
-0.590071439743042,
0.5453125834465027,
0.22524124383926392,
0.7734060883522034,
0.7929986119270325,
0.16929160058498383,
0.8004907369613647,
-0.4365924000740051,
0.6450509428977966,
0.22992295026779175,
-1.0068796873092651,
0.5552642941474915,
-0.21737082302570343,
0.261058509349823,
0.6057030558586121,
0.34146648645401,
-0.6380913257598877,
-0.4575240910053253,
-0.4741903841495514,
-0.5938370227813721,
0.42701753973960876,
-0.2443365901708603,
-0.3624836802482605,
0.045734014362096786,
0.26996275782585144,
0.3058505952358246,
0.3641901910305023,
-0.1552557647228241,
-0.1592068374156952,
0.1835508942604065,
-0.5929504632949829,
-0.021322766318917274,
0.17147256433963776,
-0.25401198863983154,
-0.47345656156539917,
0.14129173755645752,
-0.21214011311531067,
0.24813248217105865,
0.45666414499282837,
-0.2334294617176056,
0.21180886030197144,
0.16669127345085144,
0.5371246337890625,
0.8242533802986145,
-0.15066368877887726,
-0.2679123282432556,
0.194973886013031,
-0.2890148460865021,
-0.35215526819229126,
0.11154117435216904,
0.07416288554668427,
0.07256188988685608,
0.8236564993858337,
0.3686262369155884,
0.28638628125190735,
-1.401544213294983,
0.628433883190155,
-0.0249465499073267,
-0.25116318464279175,
-0.5596603155136108,
0.049759622663259506,
-0.16729013621807098,
0.30169495940208435,
0.05419442430138588,
0.012545940466225147,
0.3492296040058136,
-0.6755596995353699,
0.24429237842559814,
0.5963307619094849,
-0.4045335352420807,
-0.22736720740795135,
0.3517797291278839,
0.14851965010166168,
-0.23380793631076813,
0.7530003786087036,
-0.004061869345605373,
-0.6525381207466125,
0.873839259147644,
0.4062632918357849,
0.5704780220985413,
0.03578906133770943,
0.11617864668369293,
0.3453015685081482,
0.12226760387420654,
-0.0290733240544796,
0.019877968356013298,
0.11605855822563171,
-0.7029844522476196,
-0.06532470136880875,
-0.43902823328971863,
-0.677606463432312,
0.443919837474823,
-0.7138267159461975,
0.48061403632164,
-0.874291718006134,
-0.2627609670162201,
0.03013475425541401,
0.08001980930566788,
-0.7735482454299927,
0.12583282589912415,
0.119145467877388,
0.9965175986289978,
-0.42580804228782654,
0.7514285445213318,
0.42865991592407227,
-0.05087379738688469,
-0.39133915305137634,
-0.0826856717467308,
0.23689982295036316,
-1.0772466659545898,
0.6784356832504272,
0.3405291438102722,
-0.09572503715753555,
-0.29579436779022217,
-0.4088381230831146,
-0.5822267532348633,
1.0192815065383911,
0.26581576466560364,
-0.586725115776062,
0.08795668184757233,
0.2114885300397873,
0.8824217319488525,
-0.745244562625885,
0.519408106803894,
0.8688251972198486,
0.7293728590011597,
-0.05980690196156502,
-1.3769514560699463,
-0.03700852394104004,
-0.09694617986679077,
-0.24161309003829956,
0.24991783499717712,
-0.6446065902709961,
0.9116879105567932,
-0.4383503794670105,
-0.18918389081954956,
0.6346737146377563,
0.043778885155916214,
0.30024826526641846,
0.434202641248703,
0.2629362642765045,
0.48082679510116577,
0.960966169834137,
-0.023736078292131424,
1.2306774854660034,
-0.68196702003479,
0.16663895547389984,
0.8520620465278625,
-0.7807167172431946,
0.6993434429168701,
0.004053332842886448,
-0.21543140709400177,
0.5988299250602722,
0.3787468671798706,
-0.01103037130087614,
0.38149961829185486,
0.33021780848503113,
-0.28798186779022217,
-0.3760617673397064,
-0.32899945974349976,
-0.32403460144996643,
0.40239661931991577,
0.9008511304855347,
-0.5010244846343994,
-0.15639953315258026,
-0.013525432907044888,
0.023262010887265205,
0.08456780761480331,
-0.24693310260772705,
0.6009971499443054,
-0.018807869404554367,
-0.6688433885574341,
0.7467648983001709,
-0.2686862647533417,
0.2723381817340851,
-0.8380409479141235,
-0.08385706692934036,
0.06837192922830582,
0.5865853428840637,
-0.14026837050914764,
-0.5456192493438721,
0.106770358979702,
-0.1222880557179451,
-0.07706278562545776,
-0.046338070183992386,
0.42138397693634033,
-0.16957899928092957,
-0.670397162437439,
0.5943910479545593,
0.38384103775024414,
0.2321747988462448,
0.04768117517232895,
-0.9154554605484009,
0.4058956503868103,
-0.18393488228321075,
0.27465149760246277,
0.22506053745746613,
0.44046804308891296,
-0.031396739184856415,
1.0319496393203735,
0.5161041021347046,
0.41688910126686096,
-0.20983867347240448,
0.282406747341156,
0.7196703553199768,
-0.5798810124397278,
-0.08727103471755981,
-0.6635327339172363,
0.2763325273990631,
-0.08421102166175842,
-0.4487183392047882,
0.21521399915218353,
0.40016672015190125,
0.5617992877960205,
0.12001502513885498,
1.2278021574020386,
0.09756578505039215,
1.0013961791992188,
-0.3744746148586273,
0.6707409024238586,
-0.7083883285522461,
0.21216998994350433,
0.02774769812822342,
-0.18720075488090515,
-0.5738110542297363,
0.42942923307418823,
-0.5181652307510376,
-0.06558675318956375,
1.0518873929977417,
0.7230121493339539,
0.17629951238632202,
-0.2744026780128479,
0.498171865940094,
0.5641322731971741,
0.30059507489204407,
0.7118111848831177,
0.7577639818191528,
-0.19842635095119476,
0.4319932758808136,
-0.11388685554265976,
-0.3582051694393158,
-0.5518717765808105,
-0.5449501276016235,
-1.181670904159546,
-0.3482646048069,
-0.11680138111114502,
-0.10089236497879028,
0.21039557456970215,
0.9234082102775574,
0.8525149822235107,
-0.918083667755127,
-0.26126450300216675,
0.15116596221923828,
0.0740334615111351,
-0.43821853399276733,
-0.19571532309055328,
0.29849928617477417,
-0.3294109106063843,
-0.5757312178611755,
0.2216520756483078,
0.5372833609580994,
-0.3679025173187256,
-0.5002720952033997,
0.005982942879199982,
0.17667217552661896,
-0.02253575436770916,
0.6123653650283813,
0.20369738340377808,
-0.9331020712852478,
0.11901836842298508,
0.06550616025924683,
-0.15728597342967987,
0.05961372330784798,
1.0471171140670776,
-0.9204422235488892,
0.5295991897583008,
0.24668942391872406,
0.48236802220344543,
0.1341264247894287,
-0.17236506938934326,
0.5752652883529663,
0.21079564094543457,
0.1351112574338913,
0.6583618521690369,
0.3716019093990326,
0.11252681165933609,
-0.20108193159103394,
0.0981547087430954,
0.11921387165784836,
-0.5944167971611023,
-0.7567766308784485,
0.2187163531780243,
-1.0240854024887085,
-0.3138640820980072,
0.9797627329826355,
-0.26052719354629517,
-0.31556132435798645,
-0.429974228143692,
-0.31343522667884827,
-0.0993807315826416,
-0.28289347887039185,
0.7314411401748657,
0.5286872982978821,
-0.595690906047821,
0.04950394481420517,
-0.7950323820114136,
0.37494543194770813,
0.44395944476127625,
-0.8136546611785889,
-0.11911702901124954,
0.41166871786117554,
0.3853294849395752,
0.008812965825200081,
0.6479229927062988,
-0.29200634360313416,
0.3981764614582062,
-0.3295842707157135,
-0.0696304440498352,
0.1734188348054886,
-0.29862791299819946,
-0.012864296324551105,
0.11974575370550156,
0.23295418918132782,
-0.07703949511051178
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09920v1
|
Knowledge Editing in Language Models via Adapted Direct Preference Optimization
| 2024-06-14T11:02:21 | 2024-06-14T11:02:21 |
Amit Rozner, Barak Battash, Lior Wolf, Ofir Lindenbaum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) can become outdated over time as they may lack
updated world knowledge, leading to factual knowledge errors and gaps.
Knowledge Editing (KE) aims to overcome this challenge using weight updates
that do not require expensive retraining. We propose treating KE as an LLM
alignment problem. Toward this goal, we introduce Knowledge Direct Preference
Optimization (KDPO), a variation of the Direct Preference Optimization (DPO)
that is more effective for knowledge modifications. Our method is based on an
online approach that continually updates the knowledge stored in the model. We
use the current knowledge as a negative sample and the new knowledge we want to
introduce as a positive sample in a process called DPO. We also use
teacher-forcing for negative sample generation and optimize using the positive
sample, which helps maintain localized changes. We tested our KE method on
various datasets and models, comparing it to several cutting-edge methods, with
100 and 500 sequential edits. Additionally, we conducted an ablation study
comparing our method to the standard DPO approach. Our experimental results
show that our modified DPO method allows for more refined KE, achieving similar
or better performance compared to previous methods.
|
[
-0.13741452991962433,
-0.7063510417938232,
0.722953200340271,
-0.02166753076016903,
-0.22163036465644836,
0.09728126227855682,
-0.5471224188804626,
-0.26784127950668335,
-0.03996406868100166,
0.6716050505638123,
-0.39772123098373413,
-0.5326972603797913,
-0.5377467274665833,
0.22867713868618011,
0.16371165215969086,
0.5679705142974854,
-0.3175245225429535,
0.3237569034099579,
-0.42452186346054077,
0.03960144519805908,
-0.54147869348526,
-0.2833053171634674,
-0.6699016094207764,
-0.45025551319122314,
0.4278642535209656,
0.7937625050544739,
0.6721516847610474,
1.0008046627044678,
0.3681354820728302,
0.30916815996170044,
-0.4493541121482849,
0.2954505681991577,
-0.46465304493904114,
0.19742755591869354,
-0.18708966672420502,
-0.6399440765380859,
-0.633174479007721,
-0.1486547589302063,
0.6867384314537048,
0.8209673762321472,
-0.11511591821908951,
-0.21043668687343597,
-0.1123879924416542,
1.0098209381103516,
-0.7250015139579773,
-0.13015906512737274,
-0.8270227909088135,
0.07824765145778656,
0.12130380421876907,
-0.05732358247041702,
-0.3254699110984802,
-0.734907329082489,
0.24663391709327698,
-0.8319500684738159,
-0.049278415739536285,
-0.28965339064598083,
0.49232423305511475,
0.52080237865448,
-0.3381287753582001,
-0.32226938009262085,
-0.7682504057884216,
0.8583372831344604,
-0.8178938627243042,
0.6234649419784546,
0.39769530296325684,
0.02461741864681244,
-0.4168255925178528,
-0.08583734184503555,
-0.6809071898460388,
-0.21031257510185242,
0.26477253437042236,
0.007052141707390547,
0.034242358058691025,
0.3013985753059387,
0.12666407227516174,
0.207859605550766,
0.03452689200639725,
0.4009069502353668,
-0.12593938410282135,
-0.10532272607088089,
0.6809247732162476,
-0.10506051033735275,
0.24963614344596863,
-0.07677273452281952,
-0.011248900555074215,
-0.1004936471581459,
-0.7666881680488586,
-0.05210370942950249,
0.6999468207359314,
0.06543202698230743,
0.26555144786834717,
0.8334637880325317,
-0.4051736891269684,
0.997337818145752,
0.36983761191368103,
-0.6090990900993347,
0.11125548183917999,
0.01271554920822382,
-0.23884238302707672,
0.28517135977745056,
0.37606388330459595,
0.7839358448982239,
0.2980028986930847,
-0.0743798241019249,
-0.07903929799795151,
-0.14982019364833832,
0.06774964183568954,
-0.5183455944061279,
-0.05170750990509987,
0.23655983805656433,
-0.08239687234163284,
-0.6317606568336487,
-0.43356332182884216,
-0.8914036750793457,
-0.6426075100898743,
-0.6251730918884277,
0.23949198424816132,
-0.4462839663028717,
0.02948381006717682,
0.5322697162628174,
-0.11547110974788666,
-0.16838908195495605,
0.6470879912376404,
-0.8444235920906067,
-0.004075314849615097,
0.6098883748054504,
0.48778435587882996,
-0.04369022697210312,
-0.19000208377838135,
-0.3522735834121704,
0.2975568473339081,
-0.3476409316062927,
0.6215906143188477,
-0.6782967448234558,
-0.5382453203201294,
-0.044908542186021805,
-0.3658464550971985,
0.14358116686344147,
-0.6059795618057251,
0.674625813961029,
-0.9491715431213379,
0.3531269431114197,
-0.4680503308773041,
-1.0783360004425049,
0.07024763524532318,
0.21999621391296387,
-0.38293740153312683,
0.9736274480819702,
0.045142192393541336,
-0.5682480931282043,
0.5509365797042847,
-0.6309251189231873,
-0.22797510027885437,
-0.40861034393310547,
0.296007364988327,
-0.40049928426742554,
0.056758105754852295,
0.3591534495353699,
0.24160228669643402,
0.08122284710407257,
0.37318941950798035,
-0.42676350474357605,
0.000423179822973907,
0.0973149910569191,
0.20804984867572784,
0.5274513959884644,
0.11743008345365524,
-0.068425752222538,
0.2173713594675064,
-0.9951342940330505,
-0.2747441232204437,
0.06152520701289177,
-0.5642411112785339,
-0.7639935612678528,
0.2530893385410309,
-0.7341010570526123,
0.11585728079080582,
0.5077447295188904,
-0.8369627594947815,
0.86175537109375,
-0.46279633045196533,
0.176611065864563,
1.2784781455993652,
0.11766641587018967,
0.7514016032218933,
-0.2278345227241516,
0.45843783020973206,
-0.12023919075727463,
0.39747360348701477,
0.45563656091690063,
-0.456417053937912,
-0.9483351111412048,
-0.034120094031095505,
0.3370996415615082,
0.46958136558532715,
-0.7160720229148865,
0.5170443654060364,
-0.3506786525249481,
-0.48841026425361633,
-0.577055811882019,
0.4312330186367035,
0.03076963871717453,
0.8997814655303955,
0.38974910974502563,
0.026681996881961823,
-0.5584489703178406,
-0.9173198342323303,
-0.3971337378025055,
-0.09441451728343964,
0.239248588681221,
0.5181450247764587,
-0.01036379300057888,
-0.291288822889328,
1.2632243633270264,
-0.9883767366409302,
-0.07764800637960434,
-0.1532767415046692,
-0.23260171711444855,
0.13438178598880768,
0.3942252993583679,
0.4039812386035919,
-0.4930148422718048,
-0.8157366514205933,
0.1757766604423523,
-0.3795362412929535,
-0.47799572348594666,
0.010864689946174622,
-0.27544426918029785,
0.2755061089992523,
0.2878757119178772,
-0.3643322288990021,
-0.1330692321062088,
0.5336465835571289,
-0.1996164470911026,
0.3985953629016876,
-0.29962965846061707,
0.23745964467525482,
-1.0320580005645752,
-0.24519456923007965,
-0.19346921145915985,
-0.09786632657051086,
-0.7769461870193481,
0.000003188613845850341,
0.17327575385570526,
-0.1475476771593094,
-0.4045461118221283,
0.7341060042381287,
-0.3779076039791107,
0.3061712682247162,
-0.3395271599292755,
0.16408076882362366,
0.0025850655511021614,
0.41338661313056946,
0.11156512051820755,
0.5129103064537048,
0.3474535644054413,
-0.6130763292312622,
0.31014543771743774,
0.349409282207489,
-0.4759550988674164,
0.27769389748573303,
-0.3238591253757477,
0.6441801190376282,
-0.3884523808956146,
-0.003890629857778549,
-0.6841506361961365,
-0.09396018087863922,
0.4168735444545746,
-0.07429897785186768,
0.4331192970275879,
-0.26967334747314453,
-0.3155882954597473,
-0.06843306124210358,
-0.4767322242259979,
0.15606775879859924,
0.33318817615509033,
-0.5068473219871521,
0.3227643668651581,
0.3506598174571991,
-0.21709121763706207,
-0.8203893899917603,
-0.21298816800117493,
0.01563674584031105,
-0.13836230337619781,
-0.5816881656646729,
0.47767555713653564,
-0.1768074780702591,
-0.4483340382575989,
0.062448032200336456,
-0.2196858823299408,
-0.004743007477372885,
0.09647689014673233,
-0.37170588970184326,
0.28015071153640747,
0.15111017227172852,
0.1050754263997078,
0.44295769929885864,
-0.022749727591872215,
-0.3075144290924072,
-0.19695468246936798,
0.4806968867778778,
0.6688430905342102,
-0.17849290370941162,
-0.5320837497711182,
0.06172282248735428,
0.5446333885192871,
0.01302478089928627,
0.526005208492279,
0.12990999221801758,
-0.19805051386356354,
-0.15977369248867035,
-0.7835032939910889,
0.001931772450916469,
-0.5009778141975403,
0.406195729970932,
-0.377710223197937,
-0.8982166647911072,
0.2103004902601242,
-0.1648690104484558,
0.04535548761487007,
0.2730654180049896,
0.38499128818511963,
-0.02384028024971485,
0.8986395001411438,
0.6850341558456421,
-0.2560209035873413,
0.7792999744415283,
0.1898341178894043,
-0.009417508728802204,
-0.8885131478309631,
0.05532019957900047,
-0.4397145211696625,
-0.4557584822177887,
-0.4029892086982727,
-0.48484742641448975,
0.30900630354881287,
0.4674386978149414,
-0.0443563312292099,
0.2290983349084854,
-0.47399118542671204,
0.5803002715110779,
0.582192063331604,
0.32824763655662537,
0.5216100215911865,
-0.16171881556510925,
-0.16925875842571259,
-0.34661439061164856,
-0.6949427723884583,
-0.3242563009262085,
1.4578369855880737,
0.22898797690868378,
0.6705753803253174,
0.17021532356739044,
0.7163971066474915,
0.22251370549201965,
0.3199175000190735,
-0.9028797149658203,
0.5489596724510193,
-0.1361851543188095,
-0.4131415784358978,
-0.36422911286354065,
-0.5192666053771973,
-0.5623453259468079,
-0.04736897721886635,
-0.23515748977661133,
-0.5292608141899109,
0.43855488300323486,
0.4187241196632385,
-0.08118047565221786,
0.4596765339374542,
-0.9519952535629272,
0.6425938010215759,
-0.2388325184583664,
-0.24474367499351501,
-0.34848305583000183,
-0.24670478701591492,
0.18024839460849762,
-0.23833630979061127,
0.1627700924873352,
-0.09140551090240479,
-0.2693560719490051,
0.5104990005493164,
-0.42765334248542786,
0.7364044189453125,
-0.4848535358905792,
-0.392105370759964,
0.06547179818153381,
0.08255036920309067,
0.9449787139892578,
-0.10963097214698792,
-0.5244359374046326,
-0.07743316143751144,
-0.2450913041830063,
-0.1905553638935089,
-0.7957877516746521,
0.7532347440719604,
-1.0371313095092773,
-0.8729735612869263,
-0.1017257422208786,
-0.5124562382698059,
-0.5402215719223022,
0.21658234298229218,
-0.07524459064006805,
0.12444879859685898,
-0.013090581633150578,
-0.012815291061997414,
0.46453970670700073,
-0.5371702313423157,
0.0797283947467804,
0.6076741814613342,
-0.2835155725479126,
-0.6954776048660278,
0.7089260816574097,
0.25732043385505676,
0.6315237283706665,
0.7750768065452576,
0.7491071224212646,
-0.23547488451004028,
-0.8384551405906677,
-0.4842095971107483,
0.2569068372249603,
-0.8264248967170715,
0.005469870287925005,
-0.6753224730491638,
0.27304595708847046,
-0.6574689745903015,
-0.4901576042175293,
-0.40335410833358765,
-0.5423216819763184,
-0.1984405666589737,
0.08491629362106323,
0.5246599316596985,
0.5160643458366394,
-0.2075393795967102,
0.22139742970466614,
-0.6611437201499939,
0.2535638213157654,
0.5049005150794983,
0.5601479411125183,
-0.10553549975156784,
-0.5196260809898376,
-0.22396790981292725,
0.11951814591884613,
-0.280068576335907,
-0.975410521030426,
0.17244510352611542,
0.21052740514278412,
0.4587049186229706,
0.23261690139770508,
0.14442551136016846,
0.8026736378669739,
-0.5106847882270813,
0.4976304769515991,
-0.07474775612354279,
-1.0581427812576294,
0.8090853691101074,
-0.47547850012779236,
0.43118393421173096,
0.6493892073631287,
0.42781490087509155,
-0.7883054614067078,
-0.16420923173427582,
-0.31290411949157715,
-0.512904167175293,
0.714206874370575,
-0.12611940503120422,
0.03050447814166546,
0.19286373257637024,
0.8222227692604065,
0.20196862518787384,
0.3800272047519684,
-0.5478696227073669,
-0.3630580008029938,
0.010975975543260574,
-0.15446411073207855,
0.06697707623243332,
-0.6120405197143555,
-0.10342587530612946,
-0.4512989819049835,
1.1638514995574951,
-0.062345001846551895,
-0.03736110031604767,
0.4046748876571655,
-0.09913694858551025,
-0.36202582716941833,
0.4233081638813019,
0.758263885974884,
0.740321695804596,
-0.5018004179000854,
-0.2747345566749573,
0.2985084056854248,
-0.500971794128418,
0.20855210721492767,
-0.08931432664394379,
-0.48733389377593994,
-0.15591610968112946,
0.10924918949604034,
0.7890599370002747,
0.1939437836408615,
-0.5562694072723389,
0.18387249112129211,
0.05552633851766586,
-0.21961955726146698,
0.06112911179661751,
0.17018456757068634,
-0.03206591680645943,
0.0034576202742755413,
-0.03480169549584389,
0.15712538361549377,
-0.14951175451278687,
-0.24191364645957947,
-0.10209935903549194,
0.1498343050479889,
-0.2634400725364685,
-0.1244799941778183,
0.4827883839607239,
0.32808005809783936,
-0.35579100251197815,
0.3484729826450348,
-0.10626484453678131,
-0.552301287651062,
0.2863517105579376,
0.33353522419929504,
0.6821713447570801,
-0.35065582394599915,
0.16771794855594635,
0.4318237900733948,
0.09737959504127502,
0.06073731556534767,
0.09886247664690018,
0.010183407925069332,
-1.3422822952270508,
-0.6611791253089905,
-0.6027418375015259,
-0.7128984332084656,
0.21434634923934937,
-0.4465394616127014,
0.646203875541687,
-0.5023761987686157,
0.06725968420505524,
-0.09137485176324844,
0.062430404126644135,
-0.4123559296131134,
0.20432519912719727,
-0.19080311059951782,
0.7861980199813843,
-0.5248357057571411,
0.9935022592544556,
0.8476619720458984,
0.16612361371517181,
-0.46147966384887695,
-0.1207612082362175,
0.07835042476654053,
-0.9159590601921082,
0.4913463294506073,
-0.3865722119808197,
0.1889074146747589,
0.26698026061058044,
-0.18562519550323486,
-0.9974918365478516,
0.8683372735977173,
0.7012606263160706,
-0.840085506439209,
0.09962977468967438,
0.22322621941566467,
0.3799574375152588,
0.03785601630806923,
-0.3253389000892639,
0.38659924268722534,
0.6495253443717957,
0.04361533746123314,
-0.7383692264556885,
-0.18381941318511963,
0.1880173236131668,
-0.1924188733100891,
0.4134625792503357,
-0.5299960970878601,
0.400685578584671,
-0.08558803796768188,
0.09333846718072891,
-0.1655038595199585,
0.28914931416511536,
-0.02771534025669098,
-0.15575489401817322,
0.7842084169387817,
0.9914735555648804,
0.7896080613136292,
0.12160143256187439,
0.8821630477905273,
-0.5064822435379028,
0.39083194732666016,
1.2452492713928223,
-0.5152866244316101,
0.5681240558624268,
0.7455964684486389,
-0.282767117023468,
0.31240007281303406,
0.6109102368354797,
0.12024087458848953,
0.6744452118873596,
0.14002110064029694,
-0.4863014817237854,
-0.29451197385787964,
-0.16174152493476868,
-0.34780529141426086,
0.48589813709259033,
-0.144830122590065,
-0.22226150333881378,
-0.03953389823436737,
-0.09647336602210999,
0.33527982234954834,
0.24407915771007538,
-0.33445847034454346,
0.9853946566581726,
-0.270630419254303,
-0.8314017057418823,
0.354646772146225,
0.20742738246917725,
0.5943968296051025,
-0.6388733983039856,
0.16062243282794952,
-0.15554331243038177,
0.2910687029361725,
-0.12098836153745651,
-0.5995086431503296,
0.3347345292568207,
0.08782630413770676,
-0.2903979420661926,
-0.48197129368782043,
0.8350987434387207,
-0.4886471629142761,
-0.6271759271621704,
0.30213865637779236,
0.32208073139190674,
-0.35019955039024353,
-0.02838442660868168,
-0.5481484532356262,
0.0904802605509758,
0.37121814489364624,
-0.23567688465118408,
0.36348628997802734,
0.2202318012714386,
0.30122119188308716,
0.5564832091331482,
0.8457616567611694,
0.5008766651153564,
-0.06967490911483765,
0.10792861878871918,
0.8393553495407104,
-0.5091874003410339,
-0.3158469498157501,
-0.9752874970436096,
0.40761059522628784,
-0.1571781188249588,
-0.4433150589466095,
0.7166657447814941,
0.4997313618659973,
0.971749484539032,
-0.20777194201946259,
0.7960578203201294,
0.047638554126024246,
0.47835981845855713,
-0.7207167148590088,
0.5410293936729431,
-0.6264384388923645,
0.1785009801387787,
-0.5381374359130859,
-1.1116483211517334,
-0.3410227298736572,
0.35823121666908264,
-0.7234096527099609,
-0.46057575941085815,
0.3895399868488312,
0.7949950695037842,
0.16031408309936523,
-0.08733326941728592,
0.28187212347984314,
0.3678015470504761,
0.2980993986129761,
0.310086727142334,
0.6590208411216736,
-0.1958051472902298,
0.16202421486377716,
-0.9344301223754883,
-0.22560331225395203,
-0.025867583230137825,
-1.1784398555755615,
-0.6720188856124878,
-0.32741254568099976,
-0.4794585704803467,
-0.08767338842153549,
0.14608901739120483,
1.1799577474594116,
0.44703972339630127,
-0.6364031434059143,
-0.14992499351501465,
-0.14853490889072418,
0.5092694759368896,
-0.0785025954246521,
-0.21635042130947113,
0.3860803544521332,
-0.2620077133178711,
-1.0650118589401245,
0.5904895663261414,
0.12212787568569183,
-0.026732083410024643,
0.018689673393964767,
-0.05671868845820427,
-0.3557508885860443,
-0.15045365691184998,
0.622022271156311,
0.022692548111081123,
-0.46656522154808044,
-0.6970623731613159,
0.16625383496284485,
0.2638527750968933,
0.20893752574920654,
0.6949174404144287,
-0.3386279344558716,
1.0509281158447266,
0.6083891987800598,
0.9863743782043457,
0.30146729946136475,
0.01864738203585148,
0.876424252986908,
-0.7207315564155579,
0.05461364611983299,
0.17245829105377197,
0.34725791215896606,
0.40629732608795166,
-0.5807276368141174,
0.2654181122779846,
0.5067844986915588,
-0.6694969534873962,
-0.7388105392456055,
0.16304758191108704,
-0.9571514129638672,
-0.21134889125823975,
1.3817648887634277,
0.12976479530334473,
-0.05683538317680359,
0.06315180659294128,
-0.4437803030014038,
0.3421444594860077,
-0.4873936176300049,
1.0399658679962158,
1.0514492988586426,
-0.218683660030365,
-0.0586339570581913,
-0.27780821919441223,
0.57981276512146,
0.40769562125205994,
-0.5975636839866638,
0.04007943719625473,
0.5544571876525879,
0.3933851718902588,
-0.18213389813899994,
0.585277259349823,
0.07793906331062317,
0.05099056288599968,
-0.38170817494392395,
0.44276541471481323,
-0.20075112581253052,
-0.02865724079310894,
-0.37494024634361267,
-0.10278653353452682,
0.3416711986064911,
0.03854621946811676
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09900v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09900v1
|
GEB-1.3B: Open Lightweight Large Language Model
| 2024-06-14T10:15:49 | 2024-06-14T10:15:49 |
Jie Wu, Yufeng Zhu, Lei Shen, Xuqing Lu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently developed large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, Claude, and
Llama have demonstrated impressive abilities, and even surpass human-level
performance in several tasks. Despite their success, the resource-intensive
demands of these models, requiring significant computational power for both
training and inference, limit their deployment to high-performance servers.
Additionally, the extensive calculation requirements of the models often lead
to increased latency in response times. With the increasing need for LLMs to
operate efficiently on CPUs, research about lightweight models that are
optimized for CPU inference has emerged. In this work, we introduce GEB-1.3B, a
lightweight LLM trained on 550 billion tokens in both Chinese and English
languages. We employ novel training techniques, including ROPE,
Group-Query-Attention, and FlashAttention-2, to accelerate training while
maintaining model performance. Additionally, we fine-tune the model using 10
million samples of instruction data to enhance alignment. GEB-1.3B exhibits
outstanding performance on general benchmarks such as MMLU, C-Eval, and CMMLU,
outperforming comparative models such as MindLLM-1.3B and TinyLLaMA-1.1B.
Notably, the FP32 version of GEB-1.3B achieves commendable inference times on
CPUs, with ongoing efforts to further enhance speed through advanced
quantization techniques. The release of GEB-1.3B as an open-source model marks
a significant contribution to the development of lightweight LLMs, promising to
foster further research and innovation in the field.
|
[
-0.4421423673629761,
-1.0813624858856201,
0.4156721830368042,
0.3129388093948364,
-0.37727421522140503,
-0.19474856555461884,
-0.5413839221000671,
-0.6650255918502808,
-0.008538021706044674,
0.4232546091079712,
-0.2662637233734131,
-0.4629727602005005,
-0.6008591651916504,
-0.3373788297176361,
-0.1047818660736084,
0.8346021175384521,
0.2027522772550583,
0.253935307264328,
-0.07597245275974274,
-0.052662864327430725,
-0.16907626390457153,
-0.3678838610649109,
-0.8295161724090576,
-0.4933418333530426,
0.33497029542922974,
0.41264867782592773,
0.8261634111404419,
0.6432690620422363,
0.40705934166908264,
0.21892528235912323,
-0.19920384883880615,
-0.1562085896730423,
-0.4417687654495239,
-0.3476872742176056,
0.16468065977096558,
-0.32771942019462585,
-0.8570234775543213,
-0.1622169315814972,
0.5948078036308289,
0.7580654621124268,
-0.2047307789325714,
0.4648415148258209,
0.07701696455478668,
0.6212220788002014,
-0.6351465582847595,
0.22263920307159424,
-0.7054355144500732,
-0.03589726239442825,
-0.583027184009552,
0.2616627812385559,
-0.6105716824531555,
-0.20686955749988556,
-0.06331199407577515,
-0.4553978145122528,
0.32245591282844543,
0.23672887682914734,
0.775558352470398,
0.17847096920013428,
-0.04984971135854721,
-0.020338037982583046,
-0.3254757225513458,
0.6607479453086853,
-1.0997642278671265,
0.41114863753318787,
0.07292455434799194,
0.13657493889331818,
-0.12436962872743607,
-0.6214107871055603,
-0.3230327069759369,
-0.34921491146087646,
0.1166013553738594,
-0.10333473980426788,
-0.168709859251976,
0.26334989070892334,
0.24090789258480072,
0.3849962651729584,
-0.6646972298622131,
0.5685296654701233,
-0.2059578150510788,
0.04232579842209816,
0.12756213545799255,
0.02094487100839615,
0.189095601439476,
-0.22225165367126465,
-0.27695536613464355,
0.31061097979545593,
-0.8353217244148254,
-0.07951527088880539,
0.4225202798843384,
0.4800809621810913,
-0.25670039653778076,
0.23918591439723969,
-0.14441601932048798,
0.7329638600349426,
-0.09469715505838394,
-0.15496523678302765,
0.11632411181926727,
0.15180017054080963,
-0.2980140447616577,
0.04899532347917557,
0.8598185777664185,
0.12205424159765244,
0.1655058115720749,
-0.26586711406707764,
-0.0608842708170414,
-0.06635082513093948,
-0.22653000056743622,
-1.1129344701766968,
-0.1006138026714325,
0.09992217272520065,
-0.678081214427948,
-0.24392348527908325,
0.17035940289497375,
-0.41621389985084534,
-0.11998589336872101,
-0.1846955120563507,
0.22652147710323334,
-0.46830570697784424,
-0.3272511065006256,
0.2741278409957886,
0.2307576984167099,
0.3409995138645172,
0.36610525846481323,
-1.286661148071289,
0.6550496816635132,
0.8528062701225281,
0.8906447887420654,
-0.29017409682273865,
-0.08668870478868484,
-0.5554873943328857,
0.10490325093269348,
-0.2242492288351059,
0.41047316789627075,
-0.31566548347473145,
-0.22467374801635742,
-0.3867098093032837,
-0.0314364954829216,
0.19984471797943115,
-0.5679440498352051,
0.38174375891685486,
-0.4234424829483032,
-0.06288745254278183,
-0.034636128693819046,
-0.490670382976532,
-0.12944132089614868,
0.07995011657476425,
-0.7850894331932068,
1.2060410976409912,
0.10559408366680145,
-0.8201009035110474,
0.042651720345020294,
-0.44095078110694885,
-0.5241348147392273,
0.15504586696624756,
-0.10041104257106781,
-0.2691483795642853,
0.3032413721084595,
0.3895115554332733,
0.5980877876281738,
-0.809028148651123,
0.24885137379169464,
-0.6599594354629517,
-0.7317748665809631,
-0.223147451877594,
-0.48409199714660645,
0.9446278214454651,
0.27263957262039185,
-0.35656189918518066,
-0.14119501411914825,
-0.6674879789352417,
0.0864492878317833,
0.23477546870708466,
-0.2172074317932129,
-0.14893105626106262,
0.006643269211053848,
0.0349835567176342,
-0.0226859450340271,
0.4820712208747864,
-0.5509408116340637,
0.1404353380203247,
-0.4322689473628998,
0.2225780189037323,
0.7868242263793945,
-0.3053761124610901,
0.247902974486351,
0.05370578542351723,
0.560325562953949,
-0.1238425225019455,
0.20872482657432556,
-0.1468437761068344,
-0.4659063220024109,
-0.6651159524917603,
-0.4291505813598633,
0.38431423902511597,
0.6501252055168152,
-0.4218501150608063,
0.2135465294122696,
-0.3654245436191559,
-0.5836763978004456,
-0.5416306257247925,
0.32132452726364136,
0.42700493335723877,
0.48913317918777466,
0.2165367305278778,
-0.019310053437948227,
-0.5042580366134644,
-0.9246631860733032,
0.05533386766910553,
-0.26226770877838135,
-0.23068825900554657,
0.415300190448761,
0.2756884694099426,
0.013826641254127026,
0.6441879272460938,
-0.6151147484779358,
0.17872706055641174,
-0.4473089277744293,
0.09599000960588455,
0.3445546627044678,
0.5196078419685364,
0.5359451174736023,
-0.41208794713020325,
-0.4570436179637909,
0.3722448945045471,
-0.7816062569618225,
-0.3686448335647583,
0.22646474838256836,
-0.02954169735312462,
0.22210711240768433,
0.6424977779388428,
-0.4135575592517853,
-0.05496436357498169,
0.8460901975631714,
-0.01267236564308405,
0.5335806012153625,
-0.038843411952257156,
-0.1284177452325821,
-1.0485646724700928,
0.20658013224601746,
0.03502015396952629,
-0.2711081802845001,
-0.33605408668518066,
0.11599545925855637,
0.23985914885997772,
-0.11922039091587067,
-0.685881495475769,
0.8115909099578857,
-0.6496391892433167,
-0.12187478691339493,
-0.253736287355423,
0.2343200296163559,
-0.20823055505752563,
0.5458545088768005,
-0.25937560200691223,
0.8626603484153748,
0.6790801882743835,
-0.44193243980407715,
0.2531377375125885,
-0.13107818365097046,
-0.3675169348716736,
0.020658308640122414,
-0.6992012858390808,
0.20727317035198212,
-0.053694259375333786,
0.08967804908752441,
-0.6409878730773926,
-0.11934368312358856,
0.08995301276445389,
-0.22334131598472595,
0.5181984901428223,
-0.05634867027401924,
-0.5459339022636414,
-0.5159735083580017,
-0.26997771859169006,
0.26783621311187744,
0.5609114170074463,
-0.5371424555778503,
0.6864368319511414,
0.4008512794971466,
-0.3402756452560425,
-0.6786463260650635,
-0.6769993305206299,
-0.06973006576299667,
0.06213502958416939,
-0.7750079035758972,
0.21962738037109375,
0.0739789605140686,
-0.2183782309293747,
-0.009533225558698177,
-0.2098148614168167,
0.09341294318437576,
0.41518571972846985,
0.20904281735420227,
0.5887950658798218,
-0.457465797662735,
-0.014881984330713749,
-0.2343834936618805,
-0.1864127516746521,
-0.07622583210468292,
-0.32214343547821045,
0.41630879044532776,
-0.4593766927719116,
-0.43060460686683655,
-0.0844501331448555,
0.1173863336443901,
0.2906005382537842,
-0.19095131754875183,
0.6619471907615662,
0.7164691686630249,
-0.36779820919036865,
-0.2956973612308502,
-0.7117626667022705,
0.07136434316635132,
-0.46764564514160156,
0.5902406573295593,
-0.3149578869342804,
-1.161453127861023,
0.5655866265296936,
-0.11122870445251465,
-0.1261955350637436,
0.14085812866687775,
0.639277458190918,
0.22936028242111206,
0.9783740043640137,
0.7113786339759827,
-0.5328782796859741,
0.6622852087020874,
0.09013743698596954,
-0.025374261662364006,
-0.7901796102523804,
0.11216142028570175,
-0.5291540026664734,
-0.208076611161232,
-0.5022271871566772,
-0.5632062554359436,
0.30799540877342224,
0.17870546877384186,
-0.28096720576286316,
0.22034679353237152,
-0.2189469188451767,
0.7801828384399414,
0.39744916558265686,
0.29196372628211975,
0.1910465508699417,
-0.2818698585033417,
-0.16108839213848114,
0.24100129306316376,
-0.7566132545471191,
-0.6195419430732727,
1.1606135368347168,
0.437853068113327,
1.1107920408248901,
-0.027043543756008148,
0.370706707239151,
-0.04469090700149536,
0.5824556350708008,
-0.6052394509315491,
0.7975400686264038,
-0.46774494647979736,
-0.629629373550415,
-0.0838797315955162,
-0.4778744876384735,
-0.49362513422966003,
0.3559173345565796,
0.14396341145038605,
-1.0069910287857056,
-0.5765266418457031,
0.2658563554286957,
-0.17229890823364258,
0.5970836877822876,
-0.8753224015235901,
1.137841820716858,
-0.3646027445793152,
-0.4082983136177063,
-0.21260111033916473,
-0.7468010187149048,
0.6514067053794861,
-0.001955462386831641,
0.02892344444990158,
-0.40915489196777344,
-0.023074844852089882,
0.42382901906967163,
-0.27288562059402466,
0.6722336411476135,
-0.20650102198123932,
-0.21834596991539001,
0.2431478351354599,
-0.015388812869787216,
0.7677688598632812,
-0.12369054555892944,
-0.30012038350105286,
0.3622051775455475,
-0.44975200295448303,
-0.4305088222026825,
-0.3433322608470917,
0.6829754710197449,
-0.6636884808540344,
-0.698931097984314,
0.013256543315947056,
-0.637015163898468,
-0.2343103587627411,
0.16999460756778717,
0.10618126392364502,
0.4032942056655884,
-0.43931400775909424,
0.47674810886383057,
0.8276745080947876,
-0.22170646488666534,
0.3841386139392853,
0.5765662789344788,
-0.44278043508529663,
-0.19644178450107574,
0.7205200791358948,
0.05691448599100113,
0.5120685696601868,
0.5577758550643921,
0.09820464253425598,
-0.005201584193855524,
-0.723863422870636,
-0.49353861808776855,
0.2443622350692749,
-0.7271336913108826,
-0.08465342223644257,
-0.5786186456680298,
-0.020936353132128716,
-0.33994483947753906,
-0.19530260562896729,
-0.42936819791793823,
-0.4546935260295868,
-0.26389023661613464,
-0.08642109483480453,
0.08424258977174759,
0.4590359926223755,
0.12472280114889145,
0.4891105890274048,
-0.6932415962219238,
0.3618421256542206,
0.15362393856048584,
0.5018100738525391,
0.19438989460468292,
-0.5130190253257751,
-0.5784294009208679,
-0.3233913481235504,
-0.2517890930175781,
-0.605779230594635,
-0.06171410530805588,
0.040146417915821075,
0.5258547067642212,
0.53680419921875,
-0.37834432721138,
0.6227952837944031,
-0.5601212382316589,
0.7452145218849182,
-0.011257492937147617,
-1.0653783082962036,
0.3594639301300049,
-0.4906483292579651,
0.5372890830039978,
0.2944188714027405,
0.18154537677764893,
-0.34592315554618835,
-0.4855859875679016,
-0.4678773880004883,
-0.7840408086776733,
0.8329460620880127,
-0.1827443391084671,
-0.055195990949869156,
-0.09232545644044876,
0.13358621299266815,
0.1809028536081314,
0.18483111262321472,
-0.6691654324531555,
-0.3073959946632385,
0.11752806603908539,
-0.2574433982372284,
0.07660605013370514,
-0.10345177352428436,
0.27124375104904175,
-0.12072106450796127,
1.0543714761734009,
-0.4771633446216583,
0.08458142727613449,
-0.3383329510688782,
-0.12852515280246735,
-0.10872476547956467,
0.2677757740020752,
0.2459418624639511,
0.5704665184020996,
-0.4320333003997803,
0.0901053175330162,
0.5185526609420776,
-0.6125390529632568,
0.030186375603079796,
0.3201499879360199,
-0.22489586472511292,
-0.10085631161928177,
0.1747027486562729,
0.8849942088127136,
0.46505793929100037,
-0.7524667382240295,
0.4126850664615631,
0.16286812722682953,
0.10519573092460632,
0.1233285665512085,
0.11772088706493378,
0.3710726499557495,
0.2108207494020462,
0.2149994820356369,
-0.1664232760667801,
-0.010948038659989834,
-0.36886483430862427,
-0.01620960421860218,
0.6343315243721008,
-0.011688100174069405,
-0.2905985414981842,
0.9453070759773254,
0.11908909678459167,
0.17334850132465363,
0.4849209785461426,
-0.31623122096061707,
-0.38047724962234497,
0.5871480107307434,
0.6809069514274597,
1.0365275144577026,
-0.029891714453697205,
-0.028811395168304443,
0.41207805275917053,
0.4337618947029114,
-0.2596014142036438,
0.2499476969242096,
0.06422523409128189,
-0.5809612274169922,
-0.5182443261146545,
-0.6961366534233093,
-0.6354433298110962,
-0.0032002287916839123,
-0.6125360131263733,
0.4382886290550232,
-0.5040289759635925,
-0.10866016894578934,
-0.09747879207134247,
0.11004425585269928,
-0.5605301260948181,
0.05044560506939888,
0.6507840156555176,
1.0517003536224365,
-0.6446231007575989,
1.0925558805465698,
0.46072450280189514,
-0.17772644758224487,
-0.9645417332649231,
-0.3073030412197113,
0.040156565606594086,
-0.8288419246673584,
0.5570206642150879,
0.3080716133117676,
-0.19611750543117523,
0.2515237331390381,
-0.7457174062728882,
-0.741694450378418,
1.2661470174789429,
0.8202618360519409,
-0.6460960507392883,
-0.14715111255645752,
-0.16071033477783203,
0.2273988574743271,
-0.2064662128686905,
0.3545236587524414,
0.46423155069351196,
0.27542147040367126,
-0.18498457968235016,
-0.8916870355606079,
0.1896096020936966,
-0.22614800930023193,
0.25652584433555603,
0.44087591767311096,
-1.0139272212982178,
1.1682302951812744,
-0.3180866241455078,
-0.06616048514842987,
0.19781865179538727,
0.8460362553596497,
0.40868547558784485,
-0.13879317045211792,
0.3877357244491577,
0.7363389730453491,
0.835861325263977,
-0.2470940351486206,
0.9551568627357483,
-0.4964798390865326,
0.412081241607666,
1.2545053958892822,
-0.4895983040332794,
0.9067845344543457,
0.41824832558631897,
-0.2668914794921875,
0.4377627968788147,
0.3509337604045868,
-0.05520426109433174,
0.17840620875358582,
0.168887197971344,
-0.3427122235298157,
-0.2494702786207199,
-0.0027625011280179024,
-0.2968314290046692,
0.12342912703752518,
0.19989536702632904,
-0.12238654494285583,
-0.1674065887928009,
-0.06199350953102112,
0.3791882395744324,
-0.44564780592918396,
-0.42469897866249084,
0.48654666543006897,
0.09848099201917648,
-0.5503984093666077,
0.4625982344150543,
0.2378242313861847,
0.7334011793136597,
-0.9815941452980042,
0.21879248321056366,
-0.1851012408733368,
0.2989597022533417,
0.011054943315684795,
-0.4134314954280853,
-0.19381269812583923,
0.211613729596138,
-0.23186343908309937,
0.06568820774555206,
0.8422483205795288,
-0.1315186470746994,
-0.4768259525299072,
0.3367360532283783,
0.542269229888916,
0.10945488512516022,
-0.028645196929574013,
-0.5807145237922668,
0.45103102922439575,
-0.1327582746744156,
-0.5770584940910339,
0.4121599495410919,
0.5663174390792847,
-0.021006111055612564,
0.7853226661682129,
0.5584555268287659,
0.2439151555299759,
0.1348421722650528,
0.1728489249944687,
0.8212422728538513,
-0.689972996711731,
-0.4831685423851013,
-0.8937910795211792,
0.2938787341117859,
0.18498151004314423,
-0.05135902762413025,
0.7757139205932617,
0.6868548393249512,
0.8669576048851013,
-0.03735622018575668,
0.8065405488014221,
-0.2558453381061554,
0.26295897364616394,
-0.6367307305335999,
0.3943430483341217,
-0.4308406114578247,
0.2767016887664795,
-0.2984468638896942,
-0.7618399262428284,
-0.11378501355648041,
0.2560420036315918,
-0.17778566479682922,
0.10795909911394119,
0.665069043636322,
0.9013015627861023,
-0.11439833790063858,
0.1024867594242096,
0.20706811547279358,
0.24277497828006744,
0.27587568759918213,
0.7101983428001404,
0.2505902647972107,
-0.5082255601882935,
0.6281594634056091,
-0.05277757719159126,
-0.19620907306671143,
-0.3154194951057434,
-1.0957491397857666,
-0.7964993119239807,
0.040228813886642456,
-0.07294267416000366,
-0.061073172837495804,
-0.021744292229413986,
1.1362227201461792,
0.788314938545227,
-0.7593892216682434,
-0.36303219199180603,
-0.05355537682771683,
-0.03518945351243019,
-0.3198143541812897,
-0.217514306306839,
0.19607572257518768,
-0.461951345205307,
-0.7587935328483582,
0.33441686630249023,
0.36863863468170166,
0.15687713027000427,
-0.37296944856643677,
-0.29855310916900635,
-0.11556645482778549,
-0.021354153752326965,
0.5553891062736511,
0.2216915637254715,
-0.8048562407493591,
-0.188665509223938,
-0.032235074788331985,
-0.3601991534233093,
0.011480814777314663,
0.6089773178100586,
-0.6803053021430969,
0.2806042730808258,
0.4141577482223511,
0.8673341870307922,
0.6239472031593323,
0.058182790875434875,
0.44058293104171753,
-0.7760953307151794,
0.43613576889038086,
0.09505286812782288,
0.5881213545799255,
0.409994900226593,
-0.10813776403665543,
0.6786341667175293,
0.11452546715736389,
-0.5877165198326111,
-0.7765332460403442,
0.01109203603118658,
-0.9868559241294861,
-0.36468803882598877,
1.06526517868042,
-0.08558303862810135,
-0.35780057311058044,
0.35936790704727173,
-0.23654304444789886,
0.30600571632385254,
-0.250267893075943,
0.34313151240348816,
1.0076515674591064,
0.11980181187391281,
-0.15489165484905243,
-0.9594484567642212,
0.08261047303676605,
0.4628101587295532,
-0.9277634024620056,
0.3063928186893463,
0.44277557730674744,
0.1916550099849701,
-0.26601994037628174,
0.8433423638343811,
-0.08452286571264267,
0.23866131901741028,
0.193345308303833,
0.35024958848953247,
-0.27440178394317627,
-0.2540358901023865,
-0.1704554259777069,
0.35433438420295715,
0.15853381156921387,
-0.023475948721170425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09897v1
|
3D-RPE: Enhancing Long-Context Modeling Through 3D Rotary Position Encoding
| 2024-06-14T10:13:37 | 2024-06-14T10:13:37 |
Xindian Ma, Wenyuan Liu, Peng Zhang, Nan Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Inspired by the Bloch Sphere representation, we propose a novel rotary
position encoding on a three-dimensional sphere, named 3D Rotary Position
Encoding (3D-RPE). 3D-RPE is an advanced version of the widely used 2D Rotary
Position Encoding (RoPE), with two major advantages for modeling long contexts:
controllable long-term decay and improved position resolution. For controllable
long-term decay, 3D-RPE allows for the regulation of long-term decay within the
chunk size, ensuring the modeling of relative positional information between
tokens at a distant relative position. For enhanced position resolution, 3D-RPE
can mitigate the degradation of position resolution caused by position
interpolation on RoPE. We have conducted experiments on long-context Natural
Language Understanding (NLU) and long-sequence Language Modeling (LM) tasks.
From the experimental results, 3D-RPE achieved performance improvements over
RoPE, especially in long-context NLU tasks.
|
[
-0.40944230556488037,
-1.043117642402649,
0.3968695402145386,
0.2497921586036682,
-0.30840229988098145,
-0.15276433527469635,
-0.10584167391061783,
-0.8686298131942749,
0.28697675466537476,
0.6176691055297852,
-0.4529934525489807,
-0.49301424622535706,
-0.36072850227355957,
0.21412497758865356,
-0.3245435953140259,
0.48965510725975037,
0.16189847886562347,
-0.02332436479628086,
-0.12656232714653015,
0.016509944573044777,
-0.5289368033409119,
-0.8429616689682007,
-0.33657723665237427,
-0.41513875126838684,
0.3399428725242615,
0.5507367253303528,
0.8750019073486328,
0.6495365500450134,
0.41253629326820374,
0.2526089549064636,
0.054852601140737534,
0.028875326737761497,
-0.3461195230484009,
-0.048781946301460266,
-0.20829090476036072,
-0.32753974199295044,
-0.9090674519538879,
-0.04782860726118088,
0.8072550296783447,
0.9070302844047546,
-0.41058748960494995,
-0.15562137961387634,
-0.05135275423526764,
1.220346212387085,
-0.5184521675109863,
-0.0928822010755539,
-0.21368741989135742,
0.328709214925766,
-0.2145814597606659,
-0.30509331822395325,
-0.4985494911670685,
-0.0440339669585228,
-0.01619921624660492,
-0.6363793611526489,
0.3263058662414551,
0.03786563500761986,
0.6189970970153809,
-0.08925016969442368,
-0.3864198625087738,
-0.052495431154966354,
-0.8023936152458191,
0.7119784355163574,
-0.5570933818817139,
0.7637398838996887,
0.5662261843681335,
0.34596481919288635,
-0.3790596127510071,
-0.5180980563163757,
-0.5234399437904358,
-0.003671012120321393,
-0.07455780357122421,
0.20107057690620422,
0.31614944338798523,
0.11448807269334793,
-0.031269922852516174,
0.3489517569541931,
-0.38252314925193787,
0.12141355127096176,
-0.6092369556427002,
0.08124640583992004,
0.7354543209075928,
-0.18952316045761108,
0.35837632417678833,
-0.441000759601593,
-0.8021770119667053,
-0.08781293034553528,
-0.6614876985549927,
0.06073835492134094,
0.1903536468744278,
0.2277642786502838,
-0.1968083530664444,
0.9027791023254395,
-0.2403719127178192,
1.170044183731079,
0.006554240360856056,
-0.09550958126783371,
0.2857789993286133,
-0.005777586717158556,
-0.3922862708568573,
-0.041684649884700775,
0.6087635159492493,
0.6269428730010986,
0.14602944254875183,
0.13454435765743256,
-0.07559021562337875,
-0.6701796054840088,
0.4375552237033844,
-0.7564376592636108,
0.035106953233480453,
0.3424813151359558,
-0.7287272810935974,
-0.08698557317256927,
0.47194671630859375,
-0.8927358388900757,
-0.2466593235731125,
-0.3431236743927002,
0.09007345885038376,
-0.6500361561775208,
-0.46866294741630554,
0.8851949572563171,
-0.09624571353197098,
0.18397550284862518,
0.329470157623291,
-1.1049152612686157,
0.3873763978481293,
0.8362442255020142,
0.8745011687278748,
-0.438292920589447,
-0.41205504536628723,
-0.5180877447128296,
0.40505534410476685,
-0.3392944931983948,
0.6768163442611694,
-0.5953598618507385,
-0.7104707956314087,
0.05532313883304596,
-0.039824891835451126,
0.12500444054603577,
-0.6543076634407043,
0.19138836860656738,
-0.633353054523468,
0.5554478764533997,
0.44845151901245117,
-0.5900271534919739,
-0.6474359035491943,
0.22169992327690125,
-0.7869333028793335,
1.2872847318649292,
0.22654032707214355,
-0.4735570251941681,
0.20629608631134033,
-0.5901519656181335,
-0.2804590165615082,
0.004948682151734829,
-0.43914321064949036,
-0.41113919019699097,
0.3255690336227417,
0.25032302737236023,
0.6514330506324768,
-0.10117458552122116,
-0.12640045583248138,
-0.14675524830818176,
-0.4669043719768524,
0.2165694236755371,
-0.35264548659324646,
0.524787962436676,
-0.3525875508785248,
-0.07718778401613235,
0.12674427032470703,
-0.7749881744384766,
0.01081174798309803,
-0.062281202524900436,
-0.41234248876571655,
-0.24312113225460052,
0.11459387838840485,
-0.0987473577260971,
0.25645574927330017,
0.19714044034481049,
-0.5195217728614807,
0.43681901693344116,
-0.4677923619747162,
0.3105349540710449,
0.442320317029953,
0.05457719415426254,
0.6117819547653198,
-0.16235171258449554,
0.7087843418121338,
-0.03246917575597763,
0.18608084321022034,
0.1592794954776764,
-0.6470908522605896,
-0.3804735839366913,
-0.2019079178571701,
-0.13090109825134277,
0.5922433137893677,
-0.6628722548484802,
0.386443555355072,
-0.37540069222450256,
-0.3842335641384125,
0.17339551448822021,
-0.09760016947984695,
0.04071338102221489,
0.3735087811946869,
0.8065206408500671,
-0.29937559366226196,
-0.28179118037223816,
-1.0490868091583252,
-0.12694215774536133,
-0.0987878143787384,
-0.4129039943218231,
0.2019677311182022,
0.27033481001853943,
-0.047581493854522705,
0.9318251609802246,
-0.32321465015411377,
-0.5762755274772644,
-0.43336793780326843,
0.0694488137960434,
0.5614392161369324,
0.5603270530700684,
0.3538941740989685,
-0.8370554447174072,
-0.39106881618499756,
0.14111684262752533,
-0.6473442912101746,
0.4465203583240509,
-0.3148150146007538,
-0.1739553064107895,
0.3434779942035675,
0.778007984161377,
-0.7034719586372375,
0.4717999994754791,
0.9061736464500427,
-0.4898330867290497,
0.5443364381790161,
-0.36251091957092285,
0.1703268587589264,
-0.7316145896911621,
-0.032064978033304214,
-0.2002193182706833,
-0.40571871399879456,
-0.6551512479782104,
-0.06371678411960602,
0.4396219551563263,
-0.2940981686115265,
-0.7266998887062073,
0.3932894468307495,
-0.7693041563034058,
-0.25756925344467163,
-0.1850840300321579,
0.741835355758667,
0.23503050208091736,
0.6721801161766052,
0.584315836429596,
0.7822490334510803,
0.3193318247795105,
-1.0023435354232788,
0.25282761454582214,
0.20381508767604828,
-0.44448721408843994,
0.49645960330963135,
-0.5127682089805603,
0.22168971598148346,
-0.04117036238312721,
0.38747477531433105,
-0.4217308759689331,
-0.20710258185863495,
0.2501738667488098,
-0.4729847013950348,
0.4789067208766937,
-0.3034495711326599,
-0.045926760882139206,
-0.27979138493537903,
-0.5727642178535461,
0.86177659034729,
0.14560768008232117,
-0.43070709705352783,
0.8275739550590515,
0.22122399508953094,
0.008100642822682858,
-0.8696204423904419,
-0.7532936930656433,
-0.035928115248680115,
-0.30248787999153137,
-0.4755324721336365,
0.9478533267974854,
0.2003849595785141,
0.021563369780778885,
-0.16632021963596344,
-0.17849378287792206,
0.008643623441457748,
-0.2887602150440216,
0.15596142411231995,
0.22533954679965973,
-0.11481942981481552,
0.15248769521713257,
-0.310738205909729,
-0.35691818594932556,
0.16145934164524078,
-0.06010418385267258,
0.7015823125839233,
-0.07806239277124405,
-0.41043397784233093,
-0.8223163485527039,
0.5864213109016418,
0.6091217994689941,
0.0019777780398726463,
0.7508610486984253,
0.3643253445625305,
-0.423688143491745,
-0.2520776391029358,
-0.2789805829524994,
-0.11393631994724274,
-0.5255619883537292,
0.7220941781997681,
-0.5377729535102844,
-0.5577811002731323,
0.17581677436828613,
-0.0311242938041687,
-0.06589443236589432,
0.1733984500169754,
0.11654641479253769,
-0.23355010151863098,
0.836875319480896,
0.8600849509239197,
0.06646488606929779,
0.6870832443237305,
-0.26144444942474365,
0.31774279475212097,
-1.203603982925415,
-0.5671298503875732,
-0.31819599866867065,
-0.24704676866531372,
-0.2168676108121872,
-1.0873794555664062,
0.3379840552806854,
0.891077995300293,
-0.2376537173986435,
0.24919967353343964,
-0.42010411620140076,
0.48531094193458557,
0.3137855529785156,
0.18571199476718903,
0.2840994596481323,
-0.02012997679412365,
0.008849285542964935,
-0.048688579350709915,
-0.8273336887359619,
-0.5604590177536011,
0.6438350677490234,
0.5391243100166321,
0.642798662185669,
0.22228002548217773,
0.47719988226890564,
0.28205183148384094,
0.025369759649038315,
-0.9795539379119873,
0.5950847268104553,
0.05051256716251373,
-0.5419790148735046,
-0.48977118730545044,
0.07989075779914856,
-0.8780947327613831,
0.24179743230342865,
-0.2733301818370819,
-0.6371720433235168,
0.22536037862300873,
0.2962372303009033,
-0.290384978055954,
0.6153587698936462,
-0.35935670137405396,
0.7091044783592224,
-0.24547319114208221,
-0.32116377353668213,
-0.5697034597396851,
-0.4379848837852478,
0.17519204318523407,
0.36252298951148987,
0.46346515417099,
-0.18922971189022064,
-0.20430231094360352,
0.5569853186607361,
-0.3848295211791992,
0.873099684715271,
-0.23998060822486877,
-0.43708857893943787,
0.15857212245464325,
0.39238059520721436,
0.626480221748352,
0.5022853016853333,
-0.34912148118019104,
0.4684455692768097,
-0.18923860788345337,
-0.4551028609275818,
-0.7765438556671143,
0.4660094380378723,
-0.6582731008529663,
-0.8419516086578369,
-0.31180340051651,
-0.3487667441368103,
-0.1452343761920929,
0.24327419698238373,
0.17957481741905212,
0.673022449016571,
-0.2923322319984436,
0.39962244033813477,
0.3693154454231262,
-0.5697171092033386,
0.4026363790035248,
0.12288597226142883,
-0.7546208500862122,
-0.39235517382621765,
0.5836986899375916,
-0.4195193648338318,
0.49149271845817566,
0.8236362338066101,
0.028337309136986732,
-0.3299354612827301,
-0.534652590751648,
-0.6203254461288452,
0.43058112263679504,
-0.7676756381988525,
-0.41010355949401855,
-0.276729553937912,
-0.20340009033679962,
0.07774554193019867,
-0.5111364126205444,
-0.7082853317260742,
-0.8054903745651245,
-0.1481611430644989,
-0.277152955532074,
0.4477479159832001,
1.070258378982544,
-0.35755035281181335,
-0.10518784075975418,
-0.8829497694969177,
0.7382703423500061,
0.18251043558120728,
0.6809172630310059,
-0.23500066995620728,
-0.22495943307876587,
-0.38144367933273315,
0.16166698932647705,
0.139987513422966,
-0.7744429111480713,
0.33139076828956604,
0.2908238172531128,
0.4133565425872803,
0.16181161999702454,
-0.2089872509241104,
0.791603147983551,
-0.7284174561500549,
1.091762661933899,
0.2560851275920868,
-0.9994115829467773,
0.5240523219108582,
-0.32786211371421814,
0.2395624965429306,
0.1476491391658783,
0.21841111779212952,
-0.8048637509346008,
-0.16647577285766602,
-0.24481576681137085,
-0.9896403551101685,
0.7489092946052551,
0.01343771256506443,
0.17075912654399872,
-0.4324147701263428,
0.6890273690223694,
0.23406825959682465,
-0.25362682342529297,
-0.8277642130851746,
-0.2864263951778412,
-0.47451093792915344,
0.11551690101623535,
0.18693621456623077,
-0.7240723371505737,
-0.0513727143406868,
-0.05587725713849068,
0.6929129362106323,
0.024909624829888344,
0.6553666591644287,
0.5603927373886108,
-0.15165385603904724,
-0.060237158089876175,
0.030401362106204033,
0.9072847962379456,
0.8061313033103943,
-0.3316139876842499,
0.17027315497398376,
0.28104984760284424,
-0.6660475134849548,
-0.12738099694252014,
-0.32278555631637573,
0.14707064628601074,
-0.028012186288833618,
0.5592172145843506,
0.47038862109184265,
0.3048151731491089,
-0.40688052773475647,
0.43625402450561523,
0.049196407198905945,
-0.2818959951400757,
-0.601585865020752,
-0.041225939989089966,
0.12499898672103882,
0.031119240447878838,
0.5366729497909546,
-0.053501904010772705,
-0.08449896425008774,
-0.34379813075065613,
0.1942737102508545,
0.30731144547462463,
-0.5013980865478516,
-0.2511984407901764,
0.5530492663383484,
0.45445123314857483,
-0.7297519445419312,
0.7977779507637024,
0.25605928897857666,
-0.27081605792045593,
0.48602166771888733,
0.7618361711502075,
0.3640216588973999,
-0.34167423844337463,
0.2451256364583969,
0.8564615249633789,
-0.02487383596599102,
0.1341177225112915,
0.18281054496765137,
-0.22430935502052307,
-0.8570946455001831,
-0.4697285592556,
-0.3895876109600067,
-0.2964429557323456,
0.14340290427207947,
-1.1226427555084229,
0.44541239738464355,
-0.37772902846336365,
0.06868094205856323,
-0.6261253952980042,
-0.307576060295105,
-0.5305107831954956,
0.22451168298721313,
-0.023059548810124397,
1.0574859380722046,
-0.17832449078559875,
1.156514286994934,
0.48248162865638733,
0.16806481778621674,
-0.2875322699546814,
-0.11841729283332825,
-0.13780005276203156,
-0.8164012432098389,
0.7324875593185425,
0.4884490966796875,
-0.9461156725883484,
-0.017582299187779427,
0.07771290838718414,
-1.0466324090957642,
1.3130455017089844,
-0.2844509482383728,
-0.7084019184112549,
0.0740775316953659,
0.3954195976257324,
0.1370244175195694,
-0.29583555459976196,
-0.3250490725040436,
0.3627683222293854,
0.2818413972854614,
-0.5526696443557739,
-0.8453319668769836,
-0.028106065467000008,
-0.19129429757595062,
0.28587430715560913,
0.30832457542419434,
-0.4183306097984314,
0.4320809245109558,
-0.0635608583688736,
-0.4116743803024292,
-0.00943595077842474,
1.0981279611587524,
0.4318182170391083,
-0.42572087049484253,
0.6111125349998474,
0.004844733513891697,
0.5769418478012085,
0.36450091004371643,
1.2639596462249756,
-0.4568513035774231,
0.29715490341186523,
1.1488877534866333,
0.10299532115459442,
1.2335134744644165,
0.736856997013092,
0.017234185710549355,
0.8735188245773315,
0.30498287081718445,
0.5393958687782288,
0.34783583879470825,
-0.11565521359443665,
-0.28855863213539124,
-0.19222135841846466,
0.5332636833190918,
-0.6534245610237122,
0.4774375259876251,
0.7209469079971313,
-0.0002699600299820304,
0.04699287563562393,
0.1382320523262024,
-0.0852138102054596,
0.4910987913608551,
-0.22594276070594788,
0.3184772729873657,
0.07497890293598175,
-0.519838273525238,
0.81523197889328,
0.1528293937444687,
0.7624275088310242,
-0.5597872138023376,
-0.2621844410896301,
-0.11909596621990204,
0.2309306114912033,
-0.1546631008386612,
-0.9295030832290649,
0.5435352325439453,
-0.45840519666671753,
-0.13785377144813538,
-0.5296257734298706,
0.453635036945343,
-0.4296664893627167,
-0.46768876910209656,
0.5564039945602417,
0.298633873462677,
0.08958106487989426,
0.1298355907201767,
-0.7476253509521484,
0.13984419405460358,
-0.11207523196935654,
-0.7057916522026062,
-0.035533614456653595,
0.5214647650718689,
0.05371452495455742,
0.7898122668266296,
0.2971806228160858,
-0.10678385198116302,
-0.1414942443370819,
0.1789628267288208,
0.4946540892124176,
-1.2995471954345703,
-0.2528354525566101,
-0.6671760678291321,
0.5376889109611511,
-0.10966137051582336,
-0.25208818912506104,
0.6366850137710571,
0.5779566764831543,
0.9099981784820557,
-0.38760408759117126,
0.34253379702568054,
-0.19036495685577393,
0.573478639125824,
-1.0288270711898804,
0.32669705152511597,
-0.5473061800003052,
0.2023954838514328,
0.02697213739156723,
-0.9086032509803772,
-0.821752667427063,
1.2123605012893677,
-0.034535523504018784,
0.20549276471138,
0.9043562412261963,
0.6951177716255188,
-0.2733914256095886,
-0.09492918103933334,
0.45367467403411865,
0.0950639545917511,
0.4371178150177002,
0.4555600881576538,
0.739429771900177,
-0.4584163427352905,
0.17697785794734955,
-0.6437937617301941,
-0.10278479009866714,
-0.5029961466789246,
-1.148161768913269,
-0.921536386013031,
-0.5448238849639893,
-0.18416687846183777,
-0.06698218733072281,
-0.2523968517780304,
0.8693783283233643,
0.9070011973381042,
-0.514198899269104,
-0.5133410096168518,
-0.337486207485199,
0.019488602876663208,
-0.5719598531723022,
-0.2072448432445526,
0.473703533411026,
-0.12285112589597702,
-0.8342747688293457,
1.026141881942749,
0.66500324010849,
0.05994829908013344,
-0.22794008255004883,
-0.1498270481824875,
-0.3589358329772949,
-0.19949419796466827,
1.0155086517333984,
0.41118279099464417,
-0.7459099888801575,
-0.8413782119750977,
-0.030874259769916534,
0.07652700692415237,
0.3920474052429199,
0.9153668880462646,
-0.847074568271637,
0.21721701323986053,
0.4655717611312866,
-0.02657945081591606,
0.7073678970336914,
0.3587239682674408,
1.2129713296890259,
-0.6915631294250488,
0.525621235370636,
0.24368809163570404,
0.30535954236984253,
0.41563162207603455,
-0.4769536256790161,
0.578194260597229,
-0.19125548005104065,
-0.4142167866230011,
-0.39977869391441345,
0.7050926089286804,
-1.2085071802139282,
-0.6088844537734985,
1.0454460382461548,
0.1090669110417366,
-0.25623083114624023,
-0.33186179399490356,
-0.2500055432319641,
0.0012720295926555991,
0.0629458874464035,
0.8479701280593872,
0.5367954969406128,
-0.4886566698551178,
-0.1302427053451538,
-0.880850613117218,
0.7708993554115295,
0.5008622407913208,
-0.5427466034889221,
0.408246248960495,
0.5469866394996643,
0.2404436469078064,
0.11895614117383957,
0.6005361080169678,
-0.5068256258964539,
0.2900621294975281,
-0.28282976150512695,
0.3279740512371063,
-0.22479772567749023,
-0.538840651512146,
-0.26247701048851013,
0.36777111887931824,
0.0903630331158638,
-0.16055342555046082
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09884v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09884v1
|
Enhancing Fake News Detection in Social Media via Label Propagation on Cross-modal Tweet Graph
| 2024-06-14T09:55:54 | 2024-06-14T09:55:54 |
Wanqing Zhao, Yuta Nakashima, Haiyuan Chen, Noboru Babaguchi
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL, cs.SI
|
Fake news detection in social media has become increasingly important due to
the rapid proliferation of personal media channels and the consequential
dissemination of misleading information. Existing methods, which primarily rely
on multimodal features and graph-based techniques, have shown promising
performance in detecting fake news. However, they still face a limitation,
i.e., sparsity in graph connections, which hinders capturing possible
interactions among tweets. This challenge has motivated us to explore a novel
method that densifies the graph's connectivity to capture denser interaction
better. Our method constructs a cross-modal tweet graph using CLIP, which
encodes images and text into a unified space, allowing us to extract potential
connections based on similarities in text and images. We then design a Feature
Contextualization Network with Label Propagation (FCN-LP) to model the
interaction among tweets as well as positive or negative correlations between
predicted labels of connected tweets. The propagated labels from the graph are
weighted and aggregated for the final detection. To enhance the model's
generalization ability to unseen events, we introduce a domain generalization
loss that ensures consistent features between tweets on seen and unseen events.
We use three publicly available fake news datasets, Twitter, PHEME, and Weibo,
for evaluation. Our method consistently improves the performance over the
state-of-the-art methods on all benchmark datasets and effectively demonstrates
its aptitude for generalizing fake news detection in social media.
|
[
-0.42324963212013245,
-1.2011030912399292,
0.4615442454814911,
0.41609910130500793,
-0.683844268321991,
0.23897907137870789,
-0.0544753335416317,
-0.5219493508338928,
0.7221249938011169,
0.20249027013778687,
-0.44239678978919983,
-0.5241199135780334,
-0.6024131774902344,
-0.2560368776321411,
-0.5892170667648315,
0.9112823605537415,
0.09633055329322815,
-0.2328978031873703,
0.030788827687501907,
-0.2266978770494461,
-0.16857942938804626,
-0.3868812024593353,
-0.3840387165546417,
-0.0848722830414772,
0.630010724067688,
0.000710000516846776,
0.6658151149749756,
0.4914816617965698,
-0.004380555357784033,
0.11504393815994263,
-0.058620110154151917,
0.43589192628860474,
-0.652533769607544,
-0.31829947233200073,
-0.13555316627025604,
0.07783367484807968,
-0.3642430007457733,
0.044608455151319504,
0.8734549880027771,
0.5768149495124817,
0.3522386848926544,
-0.011479463428258896,
-0.02216978557407856,
0.2638821005821228,
-0.44805338978767395,
0.01870879903435707,
-0.5507581830024719,
0.013906502164900303,
-0.357004851102829,
-0.47417888045310974,
-0.28230082988739014,
-0.32283836603164673,
-0.11412988603115082,
-0.6974077820777893,
0.4028867483139038,
0.05188138410449028,
1.0421468019485474,
-0.2487310916185379,
-0.6085691452026367,
0.11731496453285217,
-0.7750150561332703,
0.42183825373649597,
-0.3751913607120514,
0.6128969192504883,
0.1316261738538742,
0.34105241298675537,
0.013227265328168869,
-0.6737973690032959,
-0.6221219897270203,
-0.020304422825574875,
-0.014680217951536179,
0.01811136305332184,
-0.3750388026237488,
-0.0781681016087532,
0.003854241920635104,
0.10638148337602615,
-0.43059083819389343,
-0.1247471421957016,
-0.4047517478466034,
-0.5413275957107544,
0.4302389323711395,
-0.33091503381729126,
0.4505877196788788,
-0.11805818974971771,
-0.5274789929389954,
-0.06781657785177231,
-0.4678671061992645,
-0.2018716037273407,
0.33112022280693054,
0.13837747275829315,
-0.2677295207977295,
0.4211716651916504,
-0.1059778705239296,
0.5763642191886902,
0.2138150930404663,
-0.2092101126909256,
0.43524307012557983,
-0.35687512159347534,
-0.1145411804318428,
0.06892774254083633,
0.7713271379470825,
0.6108925342559814,
0.09318485110998154,
-0.22226808965206146,
-0.16447441279888153,
0.12976430356502533,
0.07841254770755768,
-0.7268283367156982,
-0.300991952419281,
-0.20136162638664246,
-0.6588567495346069,
-0.5149351954460144,
0.26624226570129395,
-0.6718603372573853,
-0.37360671162605286,
-0.06626178324222565,
0.61436927318573,
-0.4216720163822174,
-0.46732741594314575,
-0.2171335071325302,
-0.4883299469947815,
-0.2025958150625229,
0.4577541947364807,
-0.19812412559986115,
0.10025635361671448,
0.518330991268158,
0.9049340486526489,
0.007908383384346962,
-0.0524214506149292,
-0.5510187149047852,
0.39679622650146484,
-0.3632013201713562,
0.8336341381072998,
-0.6650806069374084,
-0.10884204506874084,
-0.020776113495230675,
0.02061859332025051,
-0.0019307293696328998,
-0.4158853590488434,
0.5182660222053528,
-0.6895001530647278,
-0.12804999947547913,
-0.36033546924591064,
-0.5367531776428223,
-0.27644819021224976,
0.3611052930355072,
-0.8400800228118896,
0.7038584351539612,
0.11322614550590515,
-0.8337541818618774,
0.35031062364578247,
-0.5189008116722107,
-0.6329174637794495,
-0.04361222684383392,
0.07758771628141403,
-0.6604300141334534,
0.01431760098785162,
0.5953559279441833,
0.395591676235199,
0.20165006816387177,
0.27354881167411804,
-0.7444230914115906,
-0.34015917778015137,
0.3570493459701538,
-0.6066457033157349,
0.6421949863433838,
-0.033439479768276215,
-0.2325914204120636,
0.09592539072036743,
-0.6062596440315247,
-0.24318067729473114,
0.0559910386800766,
0.02268201857805252,
-0.5823612809181213,
-0.1499466598033905,
0.10977848619222641,
0.16134217381477356,
-0.17766036093235016,
-0.6221089363098145,
0.22400043904781342,
0.031070411205291748,
0.35604047775268555,
0.44602206349372864,
0.5847786068916321,
0.6001901030540466,
-0.4179973006248474,
0.2501848638057709,
0.3015912175178528,
0.32529881596565247,
-0.13772666454315186,
-0.571699857711792,
-0.4465240240097046,
-0.2416847199201584,
0.25213906168937683,
0.3193660080432892,
-1.0847915410995483,
0.2215992659330368,
-0.24311479926109314,
-0.20591971278190613,
-0.21909578144550323,
0.03900199756026268,
0.22545887529850006,
0.5747431516647339,
0.4575551748275757,
0.01853490062057972,
-0.6412339210510254,
-0.7846390008926392,
-0.6502646803855896,
0.062041956931352615,
-0.09314808249473572,
0.16528593003749847,
0.4575352072715759,
-0.3165383040904999,
0.9826155304908752,
-0.3398534953594208,
-0.5362783074378967,
-0.14937518537044525,
0.2599033713340759,
-0.16915620863437653,
0.36887654662132263,
0.790529191493988,
-1.248292088508606,
-0.44048166275024414,
-0.1330202966928482,
-0.3315238952636719,
-0.3828200101852417,
-0.18548406660556793,
-0.0530240498483181,
0.3536233603954315,
0.3544379472732544,
-0.2290615290403366,
0.7021845579147339,
0.5900930762290955,
-0.2152499109506607,
0.46419206261634827,
0.3508366048336029,
0.28260233998298645,
-0.9487763047218323,
-0.07057908177375793,
0.34279847145080566,
-0.6583154201507568,
-0.7431787252426147,
-0.4543030858039856,
0.0880565345287323,
-0.1253681182861328,
-0.3219161033630371,
0.6991909742355347,
-0.32986706495285034,
-0.001965280156582594,
-0.2914543151855469,
0.31596639752388,
0.34037506580352783,
0.2809349298477173,
-0.06295807659626007,
0.4493849575519562,
0.3851360082626343,
-0.3693811595439911,
0.28510111570358276,
-0.17542621493339539,
0.00994060281664133,
0.40943285822868347,
-0.5387185215950012,
-0.06795546412467957,
-0.1419897973537445,
0.7461233735084534,
-0.9472742676734924,
-0.2888072431087494,
0.6826577186584473,
-0.7257784008979797,
0.07005613297224045,
-0.1902867704629898,
-0.6046181321144104,
-0.34613674879074097,
-0.41705286502838135,
0.5774002075195312,
0.20074935257434845,
-0.5915756821632385,
0.5931150317192078,
0.4204752743244171,
0.39912593364715576,
-0.32512062788009644,
-0.7641652226448059,
0.038948334753513336,
0.03919092193245888,
-0.7094253897666931,
0.6019823551177979,
0.10424099862575531,
0.06299123913049698,
0.43413496017456055,
-0.4860283434391022,
-0.28288355469703674,
-0.2659856975078583,
0.1597992479801178,
0.02625376544892788,
-0.161284938454628,
0.333543062210083,
0.31784796714782715,
0.25981441140174866,
-0.20573373138904572,
-0.2844313979148865,
0.4033581614494324,
-0.0935497134923935,
-0.23555965721607208,
-0.7056878805160522,
0.3165811598300934,
0.46083852648735046,
-0.022883782163262367,
0.8323575258255005,
0.9518402218818665,
-0.6110593676567078,
-0.40995466709136963,
-0.6653247475624084,
-0.23960280418395996,
-0.40550342202186584,
0.04345102608203888,
-0.14989611506462097,
-0.9166170954704285,
0.5892928242683411,
-0.12773987650871277,
-0.44045719504356384,
0.3241921067237854,
0.10609141737222672,
0.11215940862894058,
1.0186476707458496,
0.7273104190826416,
-0.20498912036418915,
0.6419936418533325,
-0.31321385502815247,
0.3492019474506378,
-0.5066894888877869,
-0.3008597791194916,
0.05963049829006195,
-0.31133463978767395,
-0.22413495182991028,
-0.9471964240074158,
0.45869746804237366,
0.27987414598464966,
0.20236589014530182,
0.268232524394989,
-0.31963393092155457,
0.4660578668117523,
0.43156570196151733,
0.43325328826904297,
0.4319831430912018,
0.23589520156383514,
-0.026933345943689346,
0.02520272508263588,
-0.7297467589378357,
-0.06955710053443909,
0.5783019065856934,
0.4449819326400757,
0.6380254030227661,
-0.02310151979327202,
0.4261801838874817,
0.6119080781936646,
0.6594043374061584,
-0.5829408168792725,
0.3493252098560333,
-0.003374275751411915,
-0.4078963100910187,
-0.15195904672145844,
-0.6512703895568848,
-0.6057643294334412,
0.2720666825771332,
-0.32322192192077637,
-0.5818268060684204,
0.267744243144989,
0.1799534410238266,
0.020022816956043243,
0.6408261060714722,
-0.568568766117096,
0.6978623270988464,
0.0882849171757698,
-0.05534098669886589,
-0.2823232114315033,
-0.39225584268569946,
0.541623055934906,
-0.09374181181192398,
0.29895463585853577,
-0.07501231878995895,
-0.2323334664106369,
0.6416307687759399,
-0.4134194850921631,
1.1130766868591309,
-0.12807290256023407,
0.04138348996639252,
0.32805493474006653,
0.05530232936143875,
0.38301581144332886,
0.30595406889915466,
0.33913564682006836,
0.25487202405929565,
-0.35601168870925903,
-0.3923390805721283,
-0.6207141876220703,
0.7458354830741882,
-0.4975925087928772,
-0.2738259434700012,
-0.06878922879695892,
-0.5604537129402161,
-0.09007725864648819,
0.44357791543006897,
0.3411494791507721,
0.6564552783966064,
-0.5158924460411072,
0.10316139459609985,
0.4662543833255768,
0.002207844750955701,
0.39018622040748596,
0.2786155641078949,
-0.21651996672153473,
-0.6555358171463013,
1.004897952079773,
0.33817237615585327,
0.0472540408372879,
0.23134058713912964,
0.1834016591310501,
-0.413715660572052,
-0.18821920454502106,
-0.26135385036468506,
0.40006697177886963,
-0.5255181789398193,
-0.33796191215515137,
-0.6298161149024963,
-0.2925247251987457,
-0.75334632396698,
-0.37810516357421875,
-0.3126002848148346,
-0.41192442178726196,
-0.45927324891090393,
-0.012111887335777283,
0.2103649526834488,
0.4973515570163727,
-0.2792774736881256,
0.43933674693107605,
-0.8135416507720947,
0.7008156776428223,
0.12204667180776596,
0.41255202889442444,
0.06537040323019028,
-0.42697757482528687,
-0.13523267209529877,
0.34374505281448364,
-0.2799381911754608,
-1.1544052362442017,
0.40268900990486145,
0.18055592477321625,
0.5022596120834351,
0.8199513554573059,
0.3577675223350525,
0.6253461241722107,
-0.24971936643123627,
0.39219334721565247,
0.2771799862384796,
-1.0092501640319824,
0.4858722388744354,
-0.6733161211013794,
0.05839252099394798,
-0.02738066576421261,
0.5608166456222534,
-0.6519179940223694,
-0.5445188283920288,
-0.6453340649604797,
-0.5965921878814697,
0.3421524465084076,
0.416005402803421,
0.08796831965446472,
-0.0893545150756836,
0.07020977884531021,
-0.08598101139068604,
0.307294636964798,
-0.9745985865592957,
-0.26647257804870605,
-0.41135716438293457,
0.16501204669475555,
0.2769850194454193,
-0.20175588130950928,
-0.33462631702423096,
-0.3535361886024475,
0.5664541125297546,
-0.08832808583974838,
0.21765387058258057,
0.36351364850997925,
-0.2840571999549866,
-0.11900778859853745,
-0.09983883053064346,
0.7687221169471741,
0.7013945579528809,
-0.20982837677001953,
0.16411565244197845,
-0.21196193993091583,
-0.2994827330112457,
-0.12573473155498505,
0.2107803076505661,
-0.3455604314804077,
0.4184984862804413,
0.355435848236084,
0.8041553497314453,
0.06848924607038498,
-0.22690139710903168,
0.8863153457641602,
0.1502830982208252,
-0.39601269364356995,
-0.15380309522151947,
-0.27792543172836304,
0.0126738790422678,
0.39627790451049805,
0.8466618061065674,
0.2564730942249298,
0.15296725928783417,
-0.7148373126983643,
0.46432411670684814,
0.18862982094287872,
-0.4853353500366211,
-0.6013769507408142,
0.7587055563926697,
0.29355162382125854,
-0.20743146538734436,
0.02585192583501339,
-0.1619003266096115,
-0.9259579181671143,
0.6491184830665588,
0.6823512315750122,
0.7217539548873901,
-0.12530946731567383,
0.716497540473938,
0.10895644873380661,
0.5044388175010681,
-0.020457539707422256,
-0.08472371846437454,
-0.04127215966582298,
-0.8548793792724609,
-0.30263614654541016,
-0.2120756059885025,
-0.24566534161567688,
0.3815223276615143,
-0.1928584724664688,
0.10967763513326645,
-0.3453936278820038,
-0.2981565296649933,
0.07682885974645615,
-0.10879067331552505,
-0.21172092854976654,
0.12114031612873077,
0.2166530191898346,
0.8422877192497253,
-1.2309590578079224,
0.8131918907165527,
0.541162371635437,
-0.18983688950538635,
-0.6430318355560303,
0.4456697404384613,
0.14780384302139282,
-0.2992977201938629,
0.4701150357723236,
0.3835921585559845,
0.07354782521724701,
-0.1377432644367218,
-0.6130268573760986,
-0.711418628692627,
0.8253588080406189,
0.41249409317970276,
-0.2667291760444641,
0.14431780576705933,
0.04167668893933296,
0.39127397537231445,
-0.5138408541679382,
-0.15345311164855957,
0.04956389218568802,
0.5514093637466431,
0.1518986076116562,
-0.6765254735946655,
0.2418758124113083,
-0.0477854423224926,
0.10608649253845215,
0.23947982490062714,
-0.8148410320281982,
0.6228475570678711,
-0.0754646584391594,
-0.43488016724586487,
-0.35586145520210266,
0.805832028388977,
0.1788972169160843,
0.7636528015136719,
0.624631941318512,
0.43784087896347046,
0.6236324906349182,
-0.06703489273786545,
0.8456405997276306,
-0.0068711345084011555,
0.4079597294330597,
0.7693321704864502,
0.028629565611481667,
0.3770616948604584,
0.3015383183956146,
0.3843260407447815,
0.5391483902931213,
0.48854899406433105,
-0.1315612494945526,
0.44538140296936035,
0.11082908511161804,
-0.2855564057826996,
-0.3990393280982971,
-0.4381047487258911,
-0.3839586079120636,
-0.011312476359307766,
0.4838578999042511,
-0.436628133058548,
-0.5264215469360352,
0.4729379713535309,
0.12263817340135574,
0.057884085923433304,
-0.4944544732570648,
0.044961776584386826,
-0.03840307146310806,
-0.13214096426963806,
0.49679335951805115,
0.02345275692641735,
0.6147674322128296,
-0.25619974732398987,
-0.14189554750919342,
-0.12024356424808502,
0.05163150280714035,
-0.18800042569637299,
-0.6916481256484985,
0.354631632566452,
-0.4069228172302246,
-0.2193748950958252,
-0.22541746497154236,
1.2859668731689453,
-0.6663341522216797,
-0.30727264285087585,
0.5716914534568787,
0.3449799716472626,
-0.016824278980493546,
-0.3355201184749603,
-0.5462231040000916,
0.41128870844841003,
-0.1650812178850174,
-0.2840876877307892,
0.17052705585956573,
0.4345891773700714,
-0.36928847432136536,
0.6610003113746643,
0.7461405396461487,
0.006857933476567268,
0.14737734198570251,
0.23941738903522491,
1.2609587907791138,
-0.32052579522132874,
-0.5218583345413208,
-0.5331639647483826,
0.13216105103492737,
-0.4478675425052643,
-0.20226359367370605,
0.8611299991607666,
0.6587663292884827,
0.7999492883682251,
-0.039097193628549576,
0.7025218605995178,
-0.02493312396109104,
0.6643677353858948,
-0.16862185299396515,
0.7345948815345764,
-0.6389212608337402,
0.14159245789051056,
-0.3297854959964752,
-0.7633212208747864,
-0.6329665780067444,
0.22841840982437134,
-0.15274152159690857,
0.07453227788209915,
0.6032883524894714,
0.6855728030204773,
-0.39151647686958313,
-0.2737993896007538,
0.4169652462005615,
0.29566797614097595,
0.34225380420684814,
0.17118531465530396,
0.4900304973125458,
-0.531549870967865,
0.9087106585502625,
-0.4873521625995636,
-0.19878993928432465,
-0.678435206413269,
-0.7846120595932007,
-1.150510311126709,
-0.6232214570045471,
-0.4884341061115265,
-0.6324887871742249,
0.25106024742126465,
0.38217082619667053,
0.8313176035881042,
-0.5444923639297485,
0.26066479086875916,
0.07235108315944672,
0.3863334655761719,
-0.19886861741542816,
-0.37208253145217896,
0.49815863370895386,
0.10019850730895996,
-0.5361828804016113,
0.43657952547073364,
0.15344245731830597,
0.26811203360557556,
0.03347434476017952,
0.10580965876579285,
-0.3206518590450287,
0.29886090755462646,
0.6622319221496582,
0.4587744176387787,
-0.5244640707969666,
-0.6031819581985474,
-0.06209804117679596,
-0.03881849721074104,
-0.009834402240812778,
0.8240160346031189,
-0.9078007936477661,
0.22684794664382935,
0.6575413346290588,
0.5267904996871948,
0.610369086265564,
0.4694722890853882,
0.5145773887634277,
-1.0540807247161865,
0.2299252599477768,
0.13414178788661957,
0.02324940823018551,
0.23322275280952454,
-0.3885278105735779,
0.2988678514957428,
0.9482822418212891,
-0.2716001570224762,
-0.9303817749023438,
0.16247090697288513,
-1.2516940832138062,
-0.49563929438591003,
1.166921854019165,
0.14334237575531006,
-0.4203445315361023,
-0.3499501943588257,
-0.17135702073574066,
0.4587092101573944,
-0.6845094561576843,
0.6215596795082092,
0.3035343885421753,
0.05104365572333336,
-0.3576565086841583,
-0.3085317611694336,
0.4256838858127594,
-0.06099950522184372,
-0.4365602731704712,
-0.31358271837234497,
0.5636432766914368,
0.48839831352233887,
0.10868190228939056,
0.8431413173675537,
0.13599452376365662,
0.3557916581630707,
0.01897382363677025,
-0.14946392178535461,
-0.29107531905174255,
-0.4472211003303528,
-0.034960970282554626,
0.20035381615161896,
-0.7772179841995239,
-0.2314973622560501
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09881v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09881v2
|
A Unified Data Augmentation Framework for Low-Resource Multi-Domain Dialogue Generation
| 2024-06-14T09:52:27 | 2024-06-28T12:58:11 |
Yongkang Liu, Ercong Nie, Shi Feng, Zheng Hua, Zifeng Ding, Daling Wang, Yifei Zhang, Hinrich Schütze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Current state-of-the-art dialogue systems heavily rely on extensive training
datasets. However, challenges arise in domains where domain-specific training
datasets are insufficient or entirely absent. To tackle this challenge, we
propose a novel data \textbf{A}ugmentation framework for
\textbf{M}ulti-\textbf{D}omain \textbf{D}ialogue \textbf{G}eneration, referred
to as \textbf{AMD$^2$G}. The AMD$^2$G framework consists of a data augmentation
process and a two-stage training approach: domain-agnostic training and domain
adaptation training. We posit that domain corpora are a blend of
domain-agnostic and domain-specific features, with certain representation
patterns shared among diverse domains. Domain-agnostic training aims to enable
models to learn these common expressive patterns. To construct domain-agnostic
dialogue corpora, we employ a \textit{\textbf{de-domaining}} data processing
technique used to remove domain-specific features. By mitigating the effects of
domain-specific features, the model trained on the de-domained corpora can
effectively learn common expression patterns in different domains.
Subsequently, we adapt the learned domain-agnostic features to the target
domain through domain adaptation training. We conduct experiments on Chinese
dialogue datasets from five different domains and show that AMD$^2$G achieves
superior performance compared to both direct training on the target domain
corpus and collective training on all five domain corpora. Our work underscores
AMD$^2$G as a viable alternative solution for low-resource multi-domain
dialogue generation. Code and data associated with our work are available on
GitHub repository$^{\text 1}$.
|
[
-0.3472440838813782,
-0.879422128200531,
0.3175137937068939,
0.023724939674139023,
-0.1266455501317978,
0.37335482239723206,
-0.4156682789325714,
-0.1797594279050827,
0.08280900120735168,
0.393097460269928,
-0.9091936349868774,
-0.5440295934677124,
-0.1162470132112503,
0.08358482271432877,
0.17652975022792816,
0.7974112629890442,
0.1764022558927536,
0.14980685710906982,
-0.11625970155000687,
-0.3380896747112274,
-0.43220949172973633,
-0.8301856517791748,
-0.608191728591919,
-0.36684566736221313,
0.03940828517079353,
0.5177356004714966,
0.7514963746070862,
0.455229789018631,
-0.09268572926521301,
0.22402344644069672,
0.38331902027130127,
0.6615652441978455,
-0.5364203453063965,
0.06567248702049255,
-0.11878381669521332,
-0.03718850761651993,
-0.5851806402206421,
0.08313046395778656,
0.4342791736125946,
0.7865446209907532,
-0.2891828119754791,
-0.1118159145116806,
0.1447567343711853,
0.3652965724468231,
-0.4429968297481537,
0.15828652679920197,
-0.7862188220024109,
0.05499127507209778,
-0.015641016885638237,
-0.22712306678295135,
-0.3597567677497864,
-0.008860377594828606,
0.037897419184446335,
-1.0679504871368408,
0.4477488696575165,
0.20095469057559967,
0.6579784750938416,
0.18671834468841553,
-0.21605414152145386,
-0.11412088572978973,
-0.584874153137207,
0.8951974511146545,
-0.5107982158660889,
0.24977245926856995,
0.07922554761171341,
0.2262200564146042,
-0.19999170303344727,
-0.5025954842567444,
-0.7893457412719727,
0.2632540464401245,
-0.13960601389408112,
0.25317391753196716,
-0.5313355922698975,
0.24269169569015503,
0.21014650166034698,
0.614481508731842,
-0.5184144377708435,
0.08296800404787064,
-0.1515537053346634,
-0.20223692059516907,
0.42421507835388184,
0.18770471215248108,
0.2931009829044342,
-0.1948336809873581,
-0.5131197571754456,
-0.2408093363046646,
-0.8167850971221924,
-0.052138008177280426,
0.33454832434654236,
0.35868358612060547,
-0.21985960006713867,
0.28154879808425903,
-0.22135019302368164,
0.5449713468551636,
0.26785239577293396,
0.05468877777457237,
0.25956693291664124,
-0.39663103222846985,
-0.5556222200393677,
-0.02307991124689579,
0.6521660089492798,
0.35745155811309814,
0.20551560819149017,
-0.17554447054862976,
-0.03460834547877312,
0.28286436200141907,
0.37106698751449585,
-0.956175684928894,
-0.3775502145290375,
0.08456785976886749,
-0.3529002070426941,
-0.09953989833593369,
-0.08652937412261963,
-0.7549559473991394,
-0.23155680298805237,
-0.5565816760063171,
0.05610635131597519,
-0.41117215156555176,
-0.2653116285800934,
0.1455654799938202,
0.18207718431949615,
-0.016504263505339622,
0.5448396801948547,
-1.140795350074768,
0.3594214916229248,
0.47431185841560364,
0.7556021809577942,
-0.3688560724258423,
-0.11497936397790909,
-0.7660132050514221,
0.19409362971782684,
-0.13209062814712524,
0.606532633304596,
-0.8419225215911865,
-0.4957295358181,
0.25748032331466675,
0.11605630069971085,
-0.4764074683189392,
-0.7060441970825195,
0.7044097185134888,
-0.3011440932750702,
0.39902472496032715,
0.18804603815078735,
-0.36160048842430115,
-0.41826364398002625,
0.007837964221835136,
-0.48693764209747314,
0.874477207660675,
0.5721954107284546,
-0.4858422875404358,
0.3158981204032898,
-0.9351422190666199,
-0.36624398827552795,
-0.021868938580155373,
-0.538023829460144,
-0.2632733881473541,
0.07203993946313858,
0.4009142518043518,
0.29441195726394653,
-0.5960952043533325,
0.21254076063632965,
-0.42644262313842773,
-0.30459046363830566,
0.2212943434715271,
-0.7333377599716187,
0.7434173226356506,
0.2591836750507355,
-0.16376303136348724,
0.057930778712034225,
-0.963093101978302,
0.22959429025650024,
-0.01570119895040989,
-0.252390056848526,
-0.2967379093170166,
-0.29007720947265625,
-0.013322602957487106,
0.27154913544654846,
-0.21700701117515564,
-0.779562771320343,
0.4112209677696228,
-0.4767439663410187,
0.33585748076438904,
0.7071692943572998,
0.2630726397037506,
0.5420381426811218,
-0.22732838988304138,
0.47140032052993774,
0.4680233597755432,
0.008203215897083282,
-0.23776450753211975,
-0.3451493978500366,
-0.7598781585693359,
-0.40945395827293396,
0.3381473124027252,
0.6416139602661133,
-0.9603666663169861,
0.49154263734817505,
-0.28149089217185974,
0.0838332250714302,
-0.8760143518447876,
0.40606197714805603,
0.5430012345314026,
0.40759241580963135,
0.5459624528884888,
-0.6302111744880676,
-0.6679243445396423,
-0.813926100730896,
0.24346135556697845,
-0.11918924748897552,
-0.349386602640152,
0.3924446403980255,
0.06607349216938019,
-0.4641405940055847,
0.8801026940345764,
-0.6304185390472412,
-0.43326693773269653,
-0.12825746834278107,
0.3120632767677307,
0.07391548901796341,
0.5068464279174805,
0.4566608667373657,
-0.706461489200592,
-0.44777676463127136,
0.09360647946596146,
-0.7976177930831909,
-0.13924501836299896,
-0.236610546708107,
-0.4400317072868347,
0.45742958784103394,
0.2350807785987854,
-0.6100127100944519,
0.5220001339912415,
0.5978908538818359,
-0.05801017954945564,
0.34755653142929077,
-0.19615793228149414,
0.32698020339012146,
-1.1715084314346313,
-0.11974667012691498,
-0.055322498083114624,
0.007538263686001301,
-0.9974333047866821,
-0.43547579646110535,
-0.16136009991168976,
-0.21285827457904816,
-0.2797695994377136,
0.5031343102455139,
-0.44197413325309753,
-0.048005472868680954,
-0.2855757474899292,
0.23802506923675537,
0.3005688190460205,
1.074939250946045,
0.16943548619747162,
0.8934178948402405,
0.6662235260009766,
-0.743267297744751,
0.3658219277858734,
0.7748397588729858,
-0.230791836977005,
0.7509410381317139,
-0.549307644367218,
0.3704950213432312,
0.25769761204719543,
0.24395516514778137,
-1.0059757232666016,
-0.3082052171230316,
0.4582817852497101,
-0.48533135652542114,
0.3061821162700653,
-0.2601194381713867,
-0.34593772888183594,
-0.1815929263830185,
-0.16512367129325867,
0.4063095152378082,
0.36310166120529175,
-0.9934462904930115,
0.49689367413520813,
0.4232109785079956,
-0.3023839592933655,
-0.44541993737220764,
-0.3579085171222687,
0.02105977013707161,
-0.15759463608264923,
-0.9792762398719788,
0.5113437175750732,
-0.30027133226394653,
-0.23281477391719818,
-0.16354157030582428,
-0.051165200769901276,
0.022467629984021187,
-0.043746162205934525,
0.29831773042678833,
0.3344495892524719,
-0.2621711790561676,
-0.0299064964056015,
0.23659983277320862,
-0.07905209809541702,
-0.21013997495174408,
-0.4534699618816376,
0.42808255553245544,
0.21979722380638123,
-0.5315824151039124,
-0.1432892233133316,
0.5668386220932007,
0.3145645260810852,
-0.10484331846237183,
0.16543370485305786,
0.7317588329315186,
-0.29236942529678345,
-0.5430418848991394,
-0.2202812135219574,
-0.09203533828258514,
-0.458404004573822,
0.11904174089431763,
-0.5522067546844482,
-1.1124014854431152,
0.3645881116390228,
-0.31641605496406555,
-0.002960766898468137,
0.40547648072242737,
0.8554887771606445,
0.3471713364124298,
1.1155309677124023,
0.6517587304115295,
0.0777486115694046,
0.2399987131357193,
-0.15384306013584137,
0.3690541088581085,
-1.0942232608795166,
0.14707693457603455,
-0.08257756382226944,
-0.04994580149650574,
-0.4245153069496155,
-0.7487937211990356,
0.47170382738113403,
0.04208865389227867,
0.023847579956054688,
0.11435281485319138,
-0.5289030075073242,
0.16863292455673218,
0.4856905937194824,
-0.14309343695640564,
0.3000796437263489,
0.31951454281806946,
-0.14026866853237152,
-0.0819476917386055,
-0.6874398589134216,
-0.313525527715683,
1.009773850440979,
0.1586727499961853,
0.8502103090286255,
0.21940697729587555,
0.2483852207660675,
0.6699936389923096,
0.11906219273805618,
-0.7442319989204407,
0.2989744246006012,
-0.35932278633117676,
-0.29206129908561707,
-0.35948511958122253,
-0.4129467010498047,
-0.7592970728874207,
0.534268856048584,
-0.1972053200006485,
-0.6507133841514587,
0.4473702907562256,
-0.0029741490725427866,
-0.6057330369949341,
0.2080499827861786,
-0.7597880959510803,
0.914216160774231,
0.03451470658183098,
-0.27577462792396545,
-0.1723821461200714,
-0.5635766983032227,
0.2798321545124054,
-0.21966692805290222,
0.11174879968166351,
-0.1364404559135437,
0.4600018858909607,
0.3125111162662506,
-0.3360758125782013,
0.9823930263519287,
-0.3913213014602661,
-0.2981400489807129,
0.5627264976501465,
0.013533566147089005,
0.34010010957717896,
0.3040316104888916,
0.11465460062026978,
0.07536005228757858,
-0.38842034339904785,
-0.22705787420272827,
-0.7419160604476929,
0.601592481136322,
-0.715313732624054,
-0.5155346989631653,
-0.11703592538833618,
-0.5007837414741516,
-0.5838649272918701,
-0.1508825421333313,
0.10609637200832367,
0.665197491645813,
-0.6803441643714905,
-0.048139918595552444,
0.605191707611084,
-0.1997678428888321,
0.2950994074344635,
0.6279839873313904,
0.12173750251531601,
-0.5928976535797119,
0.9335678219795227,
-0.404798686504364,
0.42489877343177795,
0.24787351489067078,
-0.2818025052547455,
-0.43569278717041016,
-0.25555655360221863,
-1.1014474630355835,
-0.037046439945697784,
-0.635455310344696,
-0.40075719356536865,
-0.6587676405906677,
-0.20599833130836487,
-0.4645593464374542,
0.010675459168851376,
-0.055480994284152985,
-0.6942515969276428,
-0.3905409574508667,
-0.09891922771930695,
0.3522142469882965,
0.44403743743896484,
-0.18141327798366547,
0.4009105861186981,
-0.7493537664413452,
0.40069380402565,
0.3923400342464447,
0.2152206152677536,
-0.20257309079170227,
-0.7795029878616333,
-0.5074297785758972,
0.4352625906467438,
-0.6008434295654297,
-0.17004267871379852,
0.42650702595710754,
0.5954924821853638,
0.5271025896072388,
0.328249990940094,
0.09361723065376282,
0.6816818118095398,
-0.7727853059768677,
0.7786951661109924,
0.3761449158191681,
-0.8558791875839233,
0.38140952587127686,
-0.19943201541900635,
0.2055080384016037,
0.6155896186828613,
0.12411019951105118,
-0.5986301898956299,
-0.3863396942615509,
-0.7583112716674805,
-0.5001055598258972,
0.9361301064491272,
0.1686778962612152,
0.2101672738790512,
0.08624863624572754,
0.09218394011259079,
0.38530057668685913,
0.3185542821884155,
-0.2539796233177185,
-0.38312217593193054,
-0.426503449678421,
-0.06799343973398209,
-0.0051011634059250355,
-0.00505899777635932,
-0.4837054908275604,
-0.24944110214710236,
0.704663097858429,
-0.6386401057243347,
0.377262145280838,
0.08758100867271423,
-0.19532254338264465,
-0.39110609889030457,
0.5140691995620728,
0.4492603838443756,
0.3682311177253723,
-0.13928784430027008,
-0.104354627430439,
-0.052700772881507874,
-0.28870949149131775,
0.26894134283065796,
0.1799992322921753,
0.04254574328660965,
0.22357894480228424,
-0.2330816239118576,
1.1355366706848145,
0.1664850264787674,
-0.437274307012558,
0.6005864143371582,
-0.10680530965328217,
-0.43286991119384766,
-0.17072008550167084,
0.1124105229973793,
-0.4209343492984772,
0.2625623047351837,
0.40539634227752686,
0.2600010335445404,
0.2994011640548706,
-0.5373522639274597,
0.5475277304649353,
0.2522830367088318,
-0.2514401078224182,
-0.5536414384841919,
0.6809473633766174,
0.31238457560539246,
0.13812658190727234,
0.4475582540035248,
-0.5318242311477661,
-0.44987839460372925,
-0.026717204600572586,
0.5165560245513916,
1.0551402568817139,
-0.2710508406162262,
0.4207919239997864,
0.35469090938568115,
-0.21559272706508636,
0.20958130061626434,
0.09190644323825836,
-0.15357846021652222,
-0.8967756032943726,
-0.5223069787025452,
-0.7352367639541626,
-0.7355764508247375,
0.19186261296272278,
-0.4892376959323883,
0.10189016163349152,
-0.4107772707939148,
-0.06328509747982025,
0.07318443059921265,
-0.10940997302532196,
-0.4688147008419037,
0.363950252532959,
0.2612074613571167,
0.42850905656814575,
-0.6250302195549011,
0.9713102579116821,
0.5455307960510254,
-0.22486266493797302,
-0.3374917805194855,
0.0990217849612236,
0.22940197587013245,
-0.9886327385902405,
0.3712977170944214,
0.11032277345657349,
-0.2448642998933792,
-0.09562953561544418,
-0.48906251788139343,
-0.4399718940258026,
1.0450618267059326,
0.33365553617477417,
-0.3280872702598572,
0.006437153089791536,
0.13047799468040466,
0.4555535316467285,
-1.107643961906433,
-0.018020134419202805,
0.7272416353225708,
0.30134817957878113,
0.2816961705684662,
-0.7736945152282715,
0.12953166663646698,
-0.5419310927391052,
0.06669163703918457,
-0.04500710219144821,
-0.7603200078010559,
0.802276611328125,
-0.15347076952457428,
-0.5915813446044922,
0.0986674502491951,
0.7067980170249939,
0.09594187885522842,
0.04590114951133728,
0.5837438106536865,
0.4972963333129883,
0.904049813747406,
-0.23711203038692474,
0.7274796366691589,
-0.4378608465194702,
0.10661699622869492,
0.9953067898750305,
-0.37983787059783936,
0.32406216859817505,
0.14906901121139526,
-0.03180449828505516,
0.5935817956924438,
0.47356027364730835,
-0.15551330149173737,
0.6348341703414917,
0.302304208278656,
-0.5672420859336853,
-0.34889933466911316,
-0.37838906049728394,
-0.08716639131307602,
0.6195877194404602,
0.5916140675544739,
-0.18090501427650452,
-0.16524940729141235,
0.03768633306026459,
0.026898669078946114,
0.12632304430007935,
-0.11802881956100464,
0.9773901700973511,
0.10715576261281967,
-0.6437830328941345,
1.1897238492965698,
0.09826631098985672,
0.6733678579330444,
-0.5352887511253357,
-0.23625609278678894,
-0.2256232053041458,
0.22077473998069763,
-0.18318787217140198,
-0.4322802424430847,
0.07930386811494827,
0.09881025552749634,
-0.37010589241981506,
-0.32524532079696655,
0.6363571882247925,
-0.7235437631607056,
-0.13087813556194305,
0.3150404393672943,
0.7493360638618469,
-0.014483990147709846,
0.0219948198646307,
-0.7231031060218811,
0.10265423357486725,
0.41439735889434814,
-0.07377500087022781,
0.4437609314918518,
0.9296340346336365,
0.008543789386749268,
0.17061777412891388,
0.6142436861991882,
-0.17651838064193726,
-0.3100903332233429,
0.6675422191619873,
1.0946941375732422,
-0.3790193796157837,
-0.2621420919895172,
-0.407566636800766,
0.4936962425708771,
-0.2345529943704605,
-0.3278341293334961,
0.570669412612915,
0.541340708732605,
0.8333576321601868,
-0.022881828248500824,
1.3312842845916748,
-0.07574811577796936,
0.7190372347831726,
-0.7106593251228333,
0.2563563287258148,
-0.41753891110420227,
0.22993052005767822,
-0.08668659627437592,
-1.0055450201034546,
-0.15037132799625397,
0.5133910775184631,
0.07758504897356033,
-0.062062714248895645,
0.5777814984321594,
0.8433414697647095,
-0.2638629674911499,
0.34240618348121643,
0.5229963064193726,
0.13369788229465485,
0.37214910984039307,
0.6196463108062744,
0.7272424101829529,
-0.34364885091781616,
0.6078386306762695,
0.08216031640768051,
-0.35871320962905884,
-0.09562051296234131,
-0.4074757695198059,
-0.9989928603172302,
-0.559259831905365,
-0.2665558159351349,
-0.29051145911216736,
-0.049705274403095245,
0.9710308313369751,
0.6266252994537354,
-0.9271816611289978,
-0.21491655707359314,
0.23220817744731903,
-0.3184387981891632,
-0.12023628503084183,
-0.25277867913246155,
0.29912152886390686,
-0.6043130159378052,
-0.9406512379646301,
0.7616276741027832,
0.5020312070846558,
0.14692498743534088,
-0.18598708510398865,
-0.17343121767044067,
0.032009415328502655,
0.25807997584342957,
0.6500992774963379,
0.3481898605823517,
-0.4819793999195099,
-0.4706359803676605,
-0.06224968284368515,
0.011152485385537148,
0.5074734687805176,
1.061926007270813,
-0.5108969211578369,
0.5280762314796448,
-0.2064819186925888,
0.7280389070510864,
0.3569486737251282,
0.47553709149360657,
0.8798872828483582,
-1.2998019456863403,
0.2529577314853668,
-0.01935240440070629,
0.3592080771923065,
0.6487022042274475,
-0.29807624220848083,
0.8039167523384094,
0.44989335536956787,
-0.5451474189758301,
-0.5435962080955505,
0.4081905484199524,
-0.9849885702133179,
-0.07810160517692566,
1.1791361570358276,
-0.24068906903266907,
-0.00435973284766078,
-0.3206295073032379,
-0.4575231969356537,
0.13102996349334717,
-0.7488871216773987,
0.5667521953582764,
0.6262229084968567,
-0.36805716156959534,
0.2080620676279068,
-0.40758636593818665,
0.8828744292259216,
0.2840837836265564,
-0.7233734726905823,
0.7666465044021606,
0.8850505352020264,
-0.21205204725265503,
0.30478641390800476,
0.8795037865638733,
-0.07138756662607193,
0.18585579097270966,
-0.014209035784006119,
0.11700291186571121,
0.07059994339942932,
-0.4440908432006836,
-0.36429592967033386,
-0.14371398091316223,
-0.22222493588924408,
-0.17557767033576965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09864v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09864v1
|
LUMA: A Benchmark Dataset for Learning from Uncertain and Multimodal Data
| 2024-06-14T09:22:07 | 2024-06-14T09:22:07 |
Grigor Bezirganyan, Sana Sellami, Laure Berti-Équille, Sébastien Fournier
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Multimodal Deep Learning enhances decision-making by integrating diverse
information sources, such as texts, images, audio, and videos. To develop
trustworthy multimodal approaches, it is essential to understand how
uncertainty impacts these models. We introduce LUMA, a unique benchmark
dataset, featuring audio, image, and textual data from 50 classes, for learning
from uncertain and multimodal data. It extends the well-known CIFAR 10/100
dataset with audio samples extracted from three audio corpora, and text data
generated using the Gemma-7B Large Language Model (LLM). The LUMA dataset
enables the controlled injection of varying types and degrees of uncertainty to
achieve and tailor specific experiments and benchmarking initiatives. LUMA is
also available as a Python package including the functions for generating
multiple variants of the dataset with controlling the diversity of the data,
the amount of noise for each modality, and adding out-of-distribution samples.
A baseline pre-trained model is also provided alongside three uncertainty
quantification methods: Monte-Carlo Dropout, Deep Ensemble, and Reliable
Conflictive Multi-View Learning. This comprehensive dataset and its tools are
intended to promote and support the development and benchmarking of trustworthy
and robust multimodal deep learning approaches.
|
[
-0.2836965322494507,
-0.8974809050559998,
0.5644571781158447,
-0.03454769775271416,
0.03373129665851593,
0.2684268057346344,
-0.40137022733688354,
-0.3759756088256836,
-0.2283749133348465,
0.051933564245700836,
-0.5115827918052673,
-0.40416452288627625,
-0.8397743701934814,
-0.3663463294506073,
-0.37732553482055664,
0.5848261117935181,
-0.1983693242073059,
0.357818067073822,
-0.20165644586086273,
-0.5336660742759705,
-0.22046805918216705,
-0.19484640657901764,
-0.3437730371952057,
-0.200675368309021,
0.7337545156478882,
0.46525508165359497,
0.760073721408844,
0.18007905781269073,
0.6019703149795532,
0.23977860808372498,
0.3757075071334839,
0.5779638886451721,
-0.2570323348045349,
0.298321008682251,
0.08112567663192749,
-0.3423841595649719,
-0.37437695264816284,
0.13728448748588562,
0.60072922706604,
0.6888712048530579,
-0.24554038047790527,
0.20386427640914917,
-0.22674232721328735,
0.4505601227283478,
-1.109079360961914,
0.26154664158821106,
-0.7273245453834534,
0.20455938577651978,
-0.24395984411239624,
-0.001602574484422803,
-0.29984697699546814,
-0.466537207365036,
0.21273405849933624,
-0.8068777918815613,
-0.08423452079296112,
-0.05459444224834442,
0.8243561387062073,
0.6015453338623047,
-0.5741285085678101,
-0.41596782207489014,
-0.9006878733634949,
0.9584941267967224,
-0.4482673704624176,
0.5454094409942627,
0.7283936738967896,
0.6889293789863586,
0.15036547183990479,
-0.9921576380729675,
-0.5857512354850769,
0.2534348666667938,
0.37030333280563354,
0.20658765733242035,
0.015700599178671837,
-0.24372506141662598,
0.09854038059711456,
0.29299771785736084,
-0.32365769147872925,
-0.16381333768367767,
-0.22572410106658936,
-0.30846360325813293,
0.4435061812400818,
0.02976866252720356,
-0.18889176845550537,
0.2270047813653946,
-0.5545456409454346,
-0.7080010771751404,
-0.6683597564697266,
0.18846745789051056,
0.46251341700553894,
0.06733964383602142,
-0.10263518989086151,
0.20987744629383087,
-0.1265527755022049,
0.5540643930435181,
-0.41603606939315796,
-0.5436606407165527,
0.6482830047607422,
-0.320573627948761,
-0.37836846709251404,
-0.03872756287455559,
0.969109058380127,
0.228778675198555,
0.07587342709302902,
0.21533824503421783,
-0.2843913733959198,
0.22735382616519928,
0.07609616219997406,
-0.6688815951347351,
-0.09197414666414261,
0.04897037148475647,
-0.1080382764339447,
-0.2605404555797577,
0.22699899971485138,
-1.072434425354004,
-0.5281686186790466,
-0.22330357134342194,
0.750969648361206,
-0.4982861578464508,
-0.07950874418020248,
0.2342357486486435,
0.4307030141353607,
-0.01929464377462864,
0.5344544649124146,
-0.673046350479126,
0.040386732667684555,
0.15593072772026062,
0.49201440811157227,
-0.031609974801540375,
-0.34372687339782715,
-0.601402997970581,
0.24602103233337402,
-0.5286256670951843,
0.4864446222782135,
-0.8526467680931091,
-0.26902732253074646,
0.1685914248228073,
-0.17002436518669128,
-0.07856793701648712,
-0.39523935317993164,
0.8078961372375488,
-0.2924717366695404,
0.16818749904632568,
-0.02361309714615345,
-0.37407732009887695,
-0.46367108821868896,
0.09946390241384506,
-0.8231403827667236,
1.090328574180603,
0.058404210954904556,
-0.5047000050544739,
0.8046204447746277,
-0.11646929383277893,
-0.30143284797668457,
-0.28096023201942444,
-0.5473040342330933,
-0.630601704120636,
0.06977315992116928,
0.44580012559890747,
0.5535000562667847,
-0.342538446187973,
0.5411725640296936,
-0.7336814999580383,
-0.2294933795928955,
0.500774085521698,
-0.8594660758972168,
0.1659311056137085,
0.6288613677024841,
-0.17753756046295166,
-0.009407433681190014,
-0.9978182911872864,
0.13845035433769226,
-0.13562902808189392,
-0.20071358978748322,
-0.09257381409406662,
0.18822582066059113,
0.45222166180610657,
0.28356629610061646,
0.04860667139291763,
-0.23013126850128174,
0.0015377465169876814,
0.2938752770423889,
0.38024210929870605,
0.7236626744270325,
-0.2667311131954193,
0.17324043810367584,
-0.37791958451271057,
0.5216534733772278,
0.358621746301651,
0.294116348028183,
-0.5114662647247314,
-0.4064100980758667,
-0.7462752461433411,
-0.3786998987197876,
0.4038209617137909,
0.3132561147212982,
-0.7236472368240356,
-0.03202546387910843,
-0.12698544561862946,
-0.49196067452430725,
-0.9275520443916321,
0.3949630558490753,
0.10896644741296768,
0.48403021693229675,
0.4296397268772125,
-0.017031317576766014,
-0.567103385925293,
-0.7201958894729614,
0.09801632165908813,
0.025504298508167267,
0.21153470873832703,
0.5261794328689575,
0.42221003770828247,
-0.6462552547454834,
0.7773587107658386,
-0.22861404716968536,
-0.4184882640838623,
0.2565073072910309,
0.49646538496017456,
0.18116840720176697,
0.40023618936538696,
0.44600406289100647,
-0.9828932881355286,
-0.3099096715450287,
-0.012234365567564964,
-0.9351898431777954,
0.25379449129104614,
-0.33590808510780334,
0.20572932064533234,
-0.17555376887321472,
0.38906964659690857,
-0.2991257905960083,
0.4183647036552429,
0.7045155763626099,
0.12295711785554886,
0.15963910520076752,
-0.25917521119117737,
0.34257566928863525,
-1.2137612104415894,
-0.028921542689204216,
-0.0945800319314003,
-0.20175541937351227,
-0.3210946023464203,
-0.13197919726371765,
0.36503052711486816,
0.10801557451486588,
-0.5796708464622498,
0.3203361928462982,
-0.23477299511432648,
-0.12373179197311401,
0.024026714265346527,
-0.06384247541427612,
0.21091558039188385,
0.14357072114944458,
0.13738258183002472,
0.8012954592704773,
0.8797937035560608,
-0.3384243845939636,
0.37799277901649475,
-0.07705613970756531,
-0.9741495847702026,
0.5723878145217896,
-0.4444398581981659,
0.1535969227552414,
0.03111439198255539,
0.01245410367846489,
-0.7716227173805237,
-0.4783461093902588,
-0.04520128667354584,
-0.2170971781015396,
0.2637574374675751,
0.28715118765830994,
-0.5007050037384033,
0.18095460534095764,
-0.17054057121276855,
0.6420202851295471,
0.1460646539926529,
-0.28494393825531006,
0.6834752559661865,
0.35294798016548157,
0.03404131159186363,
-1.0276799201965332,
-0.6527853608131409,
-0.15472500026226044,
-0.3063085973262787,
-0.4130305051803589,
0.2459503561258316,
-0.40510112047195435,
-0.3623533844947815,
-0.32225489616394043,
-0.18516148626804352,
-0.3529263436794281,
0.24065068364143372,
0.6443264484405518,
-0.04383910447359085,
-0.19299817085266113,
0.3205017149448395,
0.0439586341381073,
0.03971877694129944,
-0.06476163864135742,
0.1191895380616188,
0.36471134424209595,
-0.3338901102542877,
-0.6145826578140259,
-0.1925063133239746,
0.1949993222951889,
0.6537481546401978,
-0.13203246891498566,
0.2974006235599518,
1.2341134548187256,
-0.5546267628669739,
-0.09608708322048187,
-0.4985268712043762,
-0.11004963517189026,
-0.4676142930984497,
0.26268842816352844,
-0.3703705668449402,
-0.48351186513900757,
0.36684221029281616,
-0.16132007539272308,
-0.09608384221792221,
0.17667722702026367,
0.5865161418914795,
-0.271708607673645,
0.8180829882621765,
0.5910573601722717,
-0.14786356687545776,
0.3184245526790619,
-0.199541375041008,
-0.23208269476890564,
-0.32251209020614624,
-0.5270228981971741,
-0.2586212754249573,
-0.3819999098777771,
-0.12831024825572968,
-0.6163277626037598,
0.27661359310150146,
0.04735568165779114,
0.016432149335741997,
-0.08347433805465698,
0.1086813434958458,
0.2137325406074524,
0.5398797392845154,
0.3043876886367798,
0.3479216992855072,
0.006111449096351862,
-0.12571460008621216,
-0.18430887162685394,
-0.40793347358703613,
-0.3631320595741272,
1.2480723857879639,
0.38985052704811096,
1.3360151052474976,
0.1924007534980774,
0.2768646776676178,
0.450697660446167,
-0.040196001529693604,
-0.5888633728027344,
-0.050009965896606445,
0.2562428414821625,
-0.5397982597351074,
0.046987567096948624,
-0.47261857986450195,
-0.905139684677124,
0.06623947620391846,
-0.6706982851028442,
-0.36650046706199646,
0.5643548369407654,
-0.043396785855293274,
-0.5324457287788391,
0.2573106586933136,
-0.724821150302887,
0.6361187696456909,
-0.4590420424938202,
-0.436125785112381,
-0.1689174473285675,
-0.764674961566925,
0.27403369545936584,
-0.5181883573532104,
0.6065032482147217,
-0.4188748002052307,
-0.12187737226486206,
0.5131743550300598,
0.12215952575206757,
0.6601854562759399,
0.13490717113018036,
-0.11366991698741913,
0.15006211400032043,
0.08454689383506775,
0.23256772756576538,
0.5034521222114563,
-0.10604964941740036,
0.1588158905506134,
-0.030865425243973732,
-0.3077484667301178,
-0.2936576008796692,
0.5646877288818359,
-1.0828399658203125,
0.012435064651072025,
-0.530289888381958,
-0.943442165851593,
-0.505618155002594,
0.13439536094665527,
0.390269935131073,
0.4273519814014435,
-0.06840747594833374,
0.596582293510437,
0.8373100161552429,
-0.23272114992141724,
0.6826801896095276,
0.27264395356178284,
-0.21779534220695496,
-0.6324836015701294,
0.8960431814193726,
-0.012697165831923485,
0.2083025574684143,
0.4901247024536133,
-0.06160303205251694,
-0.2170131951570511,
-0.48224300146102905,
-0.19741088151931763,
-0.3819607198238373,
-0.91910719871521,
-0.24852614104747772,
-0.45957356691360474,
-0.03598269447684288,
-0.1473451405763626,
-0.0011129865888506174,
-0.48715460300445557,
-0.12053591012954712,
-0.3318392038345337,
-0.217056006193161,
0.2719811499118805,
0.7162634134292603,
-0.0472249798476696,
0.4377104640007019,
-0.4928649365901947,
0.1786951720714569,
0.6492916345596313,
0.2381424903869629,
-0.5216749906539917,
-0.2578936219215393,
-0.27828750014305115,
0.13898387551307678,
-0.153025820851326,
-0.7604813575744629,
0.3407643139362335,
0.8587877154350281,
0.7570804953575134,
0.927865743637085,
-0.04811818525195122,
0.5690556168556213,
-0.23139022290706635,
0.480165958404541,
0.16714335978031158,
-0.8822609186172485,
0.6854361891746521,
-0.45925459265708923,
0.13384650647640228,
0.840398907661438,
0.5898622274398804,
-0.17581428587436676,
0.06241220608353615,
-0.45879921317100525,
-0.8073545098304749,
0.4508419632911682,
0.19302302598953247,
-0.1326964944601059,
0.3686400353908539,
0.02980026602745056,
0.43635958433151245,
0.5304008722305298,
-0.7231239080429077,
-0.32966217398643494,
-0.4266054928302765,
-0.3296768069267273,
-0.44623082876205444,
-0.14913097023963928,
-0.4097380042076111,
-0.0928269550204277,
0.39620983600616455,
-0.40685269236564636,
-0.029541343450546265,
-0.08669372648000717,
-0.5843658447265625,
-0.011932790279388428,
0.1622312068939209,
0.876554012298584,
0.8988827466964722,
-0.5427490472793579,
0.43140363693237305,
0.0722646489739418,
-0.6923845410346985,
0.2824530601501465,
0.020189998671412468,
0.023019982501864433,
0.045041948556900024,
0.48266661167144775,
0.8737376928329468,
0.23586352169513702,
-0.9760404825210571,
0.484358549118042,
-0.34568876028060913,
-0.29508206248283386,
-0.32507380843162537,
-0.07543642073869705,
-0.18448233604431152,
0.29399245977401733,
0.5609194040298462,
0.406174898147583,
0.1324281245470047,
-0.43033239245414734,
0.5003593564033508,
0.13940945267677307,
-0.7670493721961975,
-0.16274167597293854,
0.7084980010986328,
-0.03530711680650711,
0.2456175833940506,
0.3627580404281616,
0.26051098108291626,
0.1490672081708908,
0.4001135528087616,
0.0005024385754950345,
0.5105965733528137,
-0.2724550664424896,
0.3379542827606201,
0.18048278987407684,
0.4725132882595062,
0.00019054632866755128,
0.3809601068496704,
-0.05099048838019371,
-0.8387571573257446,
-0.2064831554889679,
-0.46981269121170044,
-0.5839979648590088,
0.15989913046360016,
-0.9647365212440491,
0.23547907173633575,
-0.660747230052948,
-0.3855903446674347,
-0.06192408874630928,
-0.1765422523021698,
-0.8312580585479736,
0.331017404794693,
0.3732090890407562,
0.6526477336883545,
-0.8389272093772888,
1.244659185409546,
0.5440049767494202,
-0.33410072326660156,
-0.4486636519432068,
-0.3384475111961365,
0.12992577254772186,
-0.9066270589828491,
0.4470962584018707,
0.3086642920970917,
-0.09415329247713089,
-0.592322826385498,
-0.5265787839889526,
-0.8163831830024719,
1.2403143644332886,
0.7644412517547607,
-0.7243770956993103,
0.38825005292892456,
0.17943374812602997,
0.11201458424329758,
-0.475214421749115,
0.5542956590652466,
0.3629266619682312,
0.5340554714202881,
-0.0236965324729681,
-0.5429587960243225,
-0.35697728395462036,
-0.24258223176002502,
-0.2976963520050049,
-0.07791502773761749,
-0.6241381764411926,
1.1925917863845825,
-0.1262761503458023,
0.16678832471370697,
-0.18765084445476532,
0.6653276681900024,
0.13591906428337097,
0.3962516486644745,
0.5771437883377075,
0.5563884973526001,
1.0635724067687988,
-0.46638980507850647,
0.617732584476471,
-0.07924555242061615,
0.467492014169693,
1.2433301210403442,
-0.41008803248405457,
0.9155745506286621,
0.6241378784179688,
-0.1000463217496872,
0.5334832668304443,
1.1216317415237427,
-0.05512051284313202,
0.8363634943962097,
-0.27848097681999207,
-0.4325772523880005,
-0.6130102872848511,
-0.22097653150558472,
-0.7623944878578186,
0.5891768336296082,
0.8685268759727478,
-0.39229997992515564,
-0.08500907570123672,
0.20977076888084412,
-0.09961360692977905,
-0.06789323687553406,
-0.1039445623755455,
0.5695852637290955,
0.08521212637424469,
-0.2581094801425934,
0.1839466691017151,
-0.34155088663101196,
0.685146152973175,
-0.8348315358161926,
0.11957692354917526,
-0.22049647569656372,
0.32939931750297546,
-0.15181545913219452,
-0.5656397938728333,
-0.09080047160387039,
-0.5813881158828735,
-0.22324515879154205,
-0.1474049687385559,
0.39661991596221924,
-0.624245285987854,
-0.7165767550468445,
0.39198267459869385,
0.5441250801086426,
-0.06395142525434494,
0.005617448594421148,
-0.8201593160629272,
0.3007397949695587,
-0.261618971824646,
-0.15891049802303314,
0.39164960384368896,
0.36750757694244385,
0.23947106301784515,
0.8510850667953491,
0.46824607253074646,
-0.12776778638362885,
0.11913236975669861,
0.1013348326086998,
0.630391538143158,
-0.26771286129951477,
-0.034640755504369736,
-0.6850993037223816,
0.29898127913475037,
0.020136717706918716,
-0.5501472353935242,
0.7136427164077759,
0.45489296317100525,
0.8664490580558777,
0.03592253848910332,
0.7647870779037476,
0.07376563549041748,
0.06896588206291199,
-0.6945847868919373,
0.7084029316902161,
-0.8014562129974365,
0.1967090517282486,
-0.49475568532943726,
-0.7825237512588501,
-0.15549394488334656,
0.7331408262252808,
0.143108531832695,
0.18425112962722778,
0.6480152606964111,
0.690425455570221,
-0.1601860374212265,
0.005840172991156578,
0.561677098274231,
-0.1589478999376297,
0.17341600358486176,
0.7665448784828186,
0.9343966245651245,
-0.750433623790741,
0.7265464067459106,
-0.4993148744106293,
0.019198501482605934,
-0.05299254506826401,
-0.9622172117233276,
-0.7195382714271545,
-0.76097571849823,
-0.28079500794410706,
-0.13620266318321228,
-0.05027669668197632,
0.8270566463470459,
1.2791849374771118,
-0.9566700458526611,
-0.14873474836349487,
0.36629652976989746,
0.21660196781158447,
-0.48391929268836975,
-0.11373105645179749,
0.30648306012153625,
-0.18261006474494934,
-0.8984076380729675,
0.7264893651008606,
0.10681622475385666,
0.17493413388729095,
-0.33139050006866455,
-0.26786476373672485,
-0.3847306966781616,
-0.1439075917005539,
0.34403207898139954,
0.012382907792925835,
-0.6722927093505859,
-0.19025371968746185,
-0.07427730411291122,
-0.12092771381139755,
0.15681672096252441,
0.6347249746322632,
-0.7627887725830078,
0.8593255877494812,
0.19817262887954712,
0.8098008036613464,
0.6697147488594055,
-0.480089396238327,
0.7881284952163696,
-1.062856674194336,
0.4599631130695343,
0.16956456005573273,
0.8234157562255859,
0.23915116488933563,
0.00993084255605936,
0.6786805391311646,
0.18870553374290466,
-0.42218032479286194,
-0.86822110414505,
0.14366625249385834,
-1.161203145980835,
-0.2880823016166687,
0.9423374533653259,
-0.3691850006580353,
0.152094766497612,
-0.06573943793773651,
-0.04297274723649025,
-0.013626077212393284,
-0.5389225482940674,
0.6312612891197205,
0.8397982120513916,
0.40512609481811523,
-0.49055731296539307,
-0.8035205006599426,
0.492912620306015,
0.478110671043396,
-0.9865937829017639,
-0.35777053236961365,
0.5452232360839844,
-0.024457471445202827,
0.15880423784255981,
0.04153645783662796,
0.06343621760606766,
0.34830206632614136,
0.05080724135041237,
-0.014022903516888618,
0.03226306661963463,
-0.735020101070404,
-0.2722019851207733,
0.5192062854766846,
-0.08804159611463547,
-0.1764247715473175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09855v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09855v1
|
On the Encoding of Gender in Transformer-based ASR Representations
| 2024-06-14T09:10:24 | 2024-06-14T09:10:24 |
Aravind Krishnan, Badr M. Abdullah, Dietrich Klakow
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While existing literature relies on performance differences to uncover gender
biases in ASR models, a deeper analysis is essential to understand how gender
is encoded and utilized during transcript generation. This work investigates
the encoding and utilization of gender in the latent representations of two
transformer-based ASR models, Wav2Vec2 and HuBERT. Using linear erasure, we
demonstrate the feasibility of removing gender information from each layer of
an ASR model and show that such an intervention has minimal impacts on the ASR
performance. Additionally, our analysis reveals a concentration of gender
information within the first and last frames in the final layers, explaining
the ease of erasing gender in these layers. Our findings suggest the prospect
of creating gender-neutral embeddings that can be integrated into ASR
frameworks without compromising their efficacy.
|
[
-0.1643872708082199,
-0.30646616220474243,
0.10722655057907104,
0.09430694580078125,
0.2749464809894562,
0.18423643708229065,
0.11247269064188004,
-0.37712541222572327,
-0.29252225160598755,
0.6166892647743225,
-0.6565687656402588,
-0.004397028591483831,
-0.7597214579582214,
-0.13921959698200226,
-0.6483780145645142,
0.7277916073799133,
-0.04138317331671715,
0.26234251260757446,
-0.31696954369544983,
-0.0791793167591095,
-0.8341079950332642,
-0.6284641623497009,
-0.42487505078315735,
-0.8295825719833374,
0.1434747278690338,
0.3297575116157532,
0.4828949272632599,
0.6178892850875854,
0.3226645886898041,
0.23967969417572021,
-0.39043134450912476,
-0.045190948992967606,
-0.8289463520050049,
0.23977576196193695,
-0.017993809655308723,
-0.5508900880813599,
-0.31061622500419617,
0.09452706575393677,
0.883915364742279,
0.7043680548667908,
-0.37119653820991516,
0.37294286489486694,
0.18534500896930695,
0.38098910450935364,
-0.6512444019317627,
0.0772373229265213,
-0.5148736238479614,
0.28715458512306213,
0.047148413956165314,
-0.21226081252098083,
-0.48088496923446655,
-0.0449632853269577,
0.07711610198020935,
-0.2873955965042114,
0.38749703764915466,
-0.13857179880142212,
0.7490684390068054,
0.11637239158153534,
-0.5271347761154175,
-0.18718145787715912,
-1.413120985031128,
0.8482769727706909,
-0.13131946325302124,
0.7201709151268005,
0.5137696266174316,
0.21878363192081451,
0.08760280162096024,
-0.36910468339920044,
-0.4427187144756317,
0.31358063220977783,
-0.22771881520748138,
0.17342744767665863,
-0.7226399183273315,
-0.29436931014060974,
0.4329173266887665,
0.0782570168375969,
-0.3426648676395416,
0.11319592595100403,
-0.9293363690376282,
-0.15939244627952576,
0.2727307081222534,
-0.01326326560229063,
0.22383825480937958,
-0.37689638137817383,
-0.22836914658546448,
0.029722245410084724,
-0.7014191746711731,
0.2730632424354553,
0.6234672665596008,
0.1448780596256256,
-0.15424975752830505,
0.8683820962905884,
0.4584774971008301,
-0.34219294786453247,
0.3370039165019989,
0.029809843748807907,
0.2941317558288574,
0.2811020314693451,
-0.038621000945568085,
0.1969323307275772,
0.49190962314605713,
0.1533760130405426,
-0.04828888177871704,
-0.25638124346733093,
-0.3042248487472534,
0.127776637673378,
0.6236332654953003,
-0.7680567502975464,
-0.1683228611946106,
0.029172293841838837,
-0.8047812581062317,
-0.23864972591400146,
0.3995797038078308,
-0.22746020555496216,
-0.17880180478096008,
-0.5089684724807739,
0.5456720590591431,
-0.3825739026069641,
-0.4514557719230652,
-0.18682394921779633,
-0.6430907249450684,
0.7783353924751282,
0.1675923764705658,
-1.1090588569641113,
0.7875426411628723,
0.7995239496231079,
0.23844313621520996,
0.2744564414024353,
0.10232467949390411,
-0.43947944045066833,
0.42829322814941406,
-0.2766086757183075,
0.27340173721313477,
-0.7280778884887695,
-0.711633563041687,
-0.14895708858966827,
0.1261218637228012,
0.3345053493976593,
-0.5838977098464966,
0.12651702761650085,
-0.5547346472740173,
0.24650289118289948,
-0.7242434024810791,
-0.40119415521621704,
-0.3030528724193573,
-0.556776225566864,
-0.7952395677566528,
1.2208484411239624,
0.08227930963039398,
-0.5224040746688843,
0.26862573623657227,
-0.5938667058944702,
-0.3315682113170624,
-0.2327580749988556,
-0.5022485256195068,
-0.32264596223831177,
0.39184850454330444,
0.26664435863494873,
0.1588844209909439,
-0.282414972782135,
0.029040981084108353,
0.4718395173549652,
-0.5997008681297302,
0.46443283557891846,
-0.602394163608551,
0.3638399839401245,
-0.1561117172241211,
-0.4606475532054901,
-0.13442450761795044,
-0.6168108582496643,
-0.4661053419113159,
0.21535125374794006,
-0.05516143515706062,
-0.042267754673957825,
0.1419016420841217,
0.15286174416542053,
0.14405956864356995,
-0.06283969432115555,
-0.7289928793907166,
-0.2997000217437744,
-0.07943323254585266,
0.40418335795402527,
0.7328140139579773,
-0.35123661160469055,
0.9565410017967224,
-0.1389148086309433,
0.5424978137016296,
0.02037728577852249,
-0.02241332270205021,
-0.1486348807811737,
-0.5672785639762878,
-0.7792783975601196,
-0.08205024152994156,
0.2270967662334442,
0.5170999765396118,
-0.6086043119430542,
0.1341605931520462,
-0.13711795210838318,
-0.03534580022096634,
-0.7195948958396912,
-0.029319168999791145,
0.6362137794494629,
0.45632416009902954,
0.5471025109291077,
-0.06885264813899994,
-0.6521334648132324,
-1.1202399730682373,
-0.022493237629532814,
-0.08109529316425323,
-0.37773385643959045,
0.4023553133010864,
0.5908835530281067,
-0.3424105644226074,
1.1495410203933716,
-0.38092219829559326,
-0.10086505860090256,
-0.44641977548599243,
0.41747692227363586,
0.03634724020957947,
0.7471669316291809,
0.3377283811569214,
-0.762819230556488,
0.30123481154441833,
-0.2888021767139435,
-0.8212267756462097,
-0.11451441794633865,
0.1514173448085785,
-0.13110022246837616,
0.006682670209556818,
0.4662921130657196,
-0.18135567009449005,
0.6040667295455933,
0.36666762828826904,
-0.3291633129119873,
0.12920168042182922,
-0.4533587098121643,
0.2416067272424698,
-0.34649980068206787,
0.2588968575000763,
-0.2520933747291565,
-0.4237692058086395,
-0.9555133581161499,
-0.1910371333360672,
0.24991250038146973,
-0.26284676790237427,
-0.2747212052345276,
0.19910520315170288,
-0.5274721384048462,
-0.26758497953414917,
-0.10965222120285034,
-0.194243386387825,
0.3112007975578308,
0.34749966859817505,
0.1882273554801941,
0.5287557244300842,
-0.05086788535118103,
-0.2751389741897583,
-0.4130264222621918,
0.6340942978858948,
0.19278104603290558,
0.3230321407318115,
-0.9946193099021912,
0.49779289960861206,
-0.7938792705535889,
0.3367966413497925,
-0.7843778133392334,
0.04498752951622009,
0.43127474188804626,
-0.41181713342666626,
0.8340554237365723,
-0.48596107959747314,
-0.15942662954330444,
-0.41779258847236633,
-0.43156957626342773,
0.4941391944885254,
0.9663519859313965,
-0.5695556402206421,
0.8375177383422852,
0.427155464887619,
0.13798578083515167,
-0.7550293803215027,
-1.1816706657409668,
-0.246827632188797,
0.042787838727235794,
-0.4258071184158325,
0.4985099732875824,
0.24293634295463562,
0.04841679334640503,
0.011734580621123314,
-0.37371116876602173,
0.02718493342399597,
-0.08703498542308807,
0.7872400283813477,
0.21387653052806854,
-0.3440491855144501,
0.0036104696337133646,
0.3589469790458679,
-0.37208378314971924,
0.09675955027341843,
-0.04474806413054466,
0.4815022349357605,
0.1517462581396103,
-0.44120508432388306,
-0.7380148768424988,
0.8930512070655823,
0.3604031801223755,
-0.4152190387248993,
0.8016927242279053,
0.8882681131362915,
-0.6844057440757751,
-0.11969171464443207,
-0.709176778793335,
-0.21542659401893616,
-0.48808372020721436,
0.13411356508731842,
-0.4323207139968872,
-0.9984046816825867,
0.7112478613853455,
0.23046749830245972,
-0.26986929774284363,
0.5812861919403076,
0.16301070153713226,
-0.6130635142326355,
0.9075624346733093,
0.5054531693458557,
0.37409645318984985,
0.31949135661125183,
-0.7183927893638611,
0.027937468141317368,
-1.1970053911209106,
-0.8844060301780701,
-0.530046820640564,
-0.462197870016098,
-0.49638795852661133,
-0.9232840538024902,
0.05532144382596016,
0.13436582684516907,
-0.4540676176548004,
0.19806425273418427,
-0.4983813762664795,
0.3946881592273712,
0.4848996102809906,
0.19415171444416046,
-0.05635356530547142,
0.022315507754683495,
0.4967349171638489,
-0.4491770565509796,
-0.5524272322654724,
-0.6425624489784241,
1.0321234464645386,
0.8756492733955383,
0.5856489539146423,
0.42643699049949646,
0.45706841349601746,
0.4188791513442993,
-0.2663831412792206,
-0.4403654634952545,
0.28678807616233826,
-0.655565083026886,
-0.5476539134979248,
0.02991500124335289,
-0.35244688391685486,
-0.8250569105148315,
0.04986090213060379,
-0.34842222929000854,
-0.835365891456604,
0.6400042772293091,
0.008460598066449165,
-0.10046304017305374,
0.325255811214447,
-0.33325639367103577,
0.583666205406189,
0.2208538055419922,
-0.12164358794689178,
-0.2696763873100281,
-0.4914103150367737,
0.11826570332050323,
0.17421430349349976,
0.137260302901268,
0.04092355817556381,
-0.04354260489344597,
0.8924669027328491,
-0.653997540473938,
0.7540385723114014,
-0.3985321819782257,
-0.14316987991333008,
0.2498672902584076,
0.14576362073421478,
0.3126089870929718,
-0.0024007719475775957,
0.03403379023075104,
0.6505105495452881,
-0.14853981137275696,
-0.13563263416290283,
-0.5231045484542847,
0.19155195355415344,
-1.1125786304473877,
-0.4045409858226776,
-0.15848946571350098,
-0.19531826674938202,
0.21717236936092377,
-0.32231032848358154,
0.2704329490661621,
1.0180994272232056,
-0.23629699647426605,
0.2910110056400299,
0.8045327663421631,
-0.5302862524986267,
0.25042200088500977,
0.2543635368347168,
-0.1640952229499817,
-0.18780778348445892,
0.8350121974945068,
0.21179935336112976,
0.1074443906545639,
0.5855724215507507,
0.14390328526496887,
-0.3101974427700043,
-0.3442915678024292,
-0.1790359914302826,
0.18168345093727112,
-0.8367331624031067,
-0.002696083625778556,
-0.9689786434173584,
-0.3866819143295288,
-0.11814769357442856,
-0.25210392475128174,
-0.6640599370002747,
-0.5754681825637817,
-0.5532416105270386,
0.09916955977678299,
0.24397940933704376,
1.0332838296890259,
-0.11917881667613983,
0.6344334483146667,
-0.5190145969390869,
0.9027531147003174,
0.5512140393257141,
0.23199769854545593,
0.038021236658096313,
-0.7190619707107544,
0.16824783384799957,
0.05084073916077614,
-0.15863552689552307,
-0.6675954461097717,
0.15568695962429047,
0.14281436800956726,
0.5459919571876526,
0.2774156928062439,
-0.37769436836242676,
0.5868959426879883,
-0.7489681839942932,
0.9731238484382629,
0.2935158312320709,
-1.4719314575195312,
0.6498380899429321,
-0.24874339997768402,
0.2228979915380478,
0.19661691784858704,
0.06797055900096893,
-0.4871883690357208,
-0.42339444160461426,
-0.4522046446800232,
-0.9072510004043579,
1.290984034538269,
0.6645540595054626,
0.5577163100242615,
0.3015277683734894,
0.48758479952812195,
0.4685935974121094,
0.27295228838920593,
-0.3236906826496124,
-0.567168653011322,
-0.45047318935394287,
-0.017162885516881943,
0.3271231949329376,
-0.9507703185081482,
0.08634328842163086,
-0.26231515407562256,
0.46710216999053955,
0.3386453092098236,
0.9983340501785278,
0.04105290770530701,
-0.3805703818798065,
0.013720414601266384,
0.10831405967473984,
0.3170539140701294,
0.1891179382801056,
-0.3422011435031891,
0.09978168457746506,
0.12623651325702667,
-0.5805923342704773,
0.2275683581829071,
-0.4028867483139038,
-0.1725056916475296,
0.03188652545213699,
0.5770696997642517,
0.8586394190788269,
0.37629225850105286,
-0.17681539058685303,
0.569670557975769,
-0.23826996982097626,
-0.20405125617980957,
-0.3836356997489929,
0.10511892288923264,
0.06401418149471283,
0.514081597328186,
0.6243226528167725,
0.3662325441837311,
0.24289554357528687,
-0.46162745356559753,
0.14372381567955017,
0.21896004676818848,
-0.6477966904640198,
-0.417132705450058,
1.0639355182647705,
0.11466880142688751,
-0.28499019145965576,
0.7441242933273315,
0.00594166899099946,
-0.4635829031467438,
0.6456245183944702,
0.6576687693595886,
0.9704104065895081,
-0.39352717995643616,
0.15175922214984894,
0.3328694999217987,
0.414803147315979,
-0.020648900419473648,
0.4405157268047333,
0.03904300928115845,
-0.6939027905464172,
-0.17354196310043335,
-0.4211907386779785,
-0.08858318626880646,
-0.13609948754310608,
-0.9967166185379028,
0.2880001366138458,
-0.38940292596817017,
-0.31614363193511963,
0.08497932553291321,
-0.5678806900978088,
-0.9392052292823792,
0.024356605485081673,
0.7581899166107178,
0.36077994108200073,
-0.8040188550949097,
0.4087868928909302,
0.34235477447509766,
-0.22690202295780182,
-0.8241549134254456,
-0.03242512792348862,
0.3163960874080658,
-0.4274674654006958,
0.9192947149276733,
0.26805374026298523,
-0.4947544038295746,
-0.391308456659317,
-0.17631059885025024,
-0.8481271266937256,
1.1759474277496338,
0.5832574367523193,
-0.33282098174095154,
0.06205624341964722,
0.39351069927215576,
0.3053770363330841,
-0.31976118683815,
0.6759861707687378,
0.5382658839225769,
0.4019685387611389,
0.17464010417461395,
-0.7350134253501892,
0.015155956149101257,
-0.4281933605670929,
0.46508756279945374,
-0.09687349200248718,
-0.35390299558639526,
0.8793998956680298,
-0.04054481163620949,
-0.35407429933547974,
-0.046410564333200455,
0.7914067506790161,
-0.19521310925483704,
0.038953401148319244,
0.3037247657775879,
-0.20001175999641418,
0.8179377317428589,
-0.4041147828102112,
1.0671319961547852,
0.22036194801330566,
0.01751754991710186,
1.057080626487732,
-0.01910628192126751,
0.6337160468101501,
0.287124365568161,
-0.2554050087928772,
0.5009979009628296,
-0.07233188301324844,
-0.14579036831855774,
0.29702842235565186,
0.11611103266477585,
0.0614054799079895,
0.02623882330954075,
-0.27312153577804565,
-0.4129806160926819,
1.1158751249313354,
0.18230809271335602,
-0.39695239067077637,
0.2587758004665375,
0.1693543642759323,
0.002405603649094701,
0.07719575613737106,
-0.19317913055419922,
0.766265332698822,
-0.018326276913285255,
0.05968742445111275,
0.43247947096824646,
0.2577228248119354,
0.5377562642097473,
-0.5592957139015198,
-0.25303778052330017,
-0.10681353509426117,
-0.018282346427440643,
-0.3462275266647339,
-0.5541508197784424,
0.3392605185508728,
0.2436046153306961,
-0.822178065776825,
-0.5962368249893188,
0.8319584131240845,
-0.6408069133758545,
-0.6560450196266174,
0.5185729265213013,
0.46973368525505066,
-0.016198983415961266,
0.26316726207733154,
-0.1993003785610199,
0.18891263008117676,
0.012828096747398376,
-0.14624455571174622,
-0.08401893824338913,
0.1457589715719223,
-0.06280309706926346,
0.4887925982475281,
0.4985783100128174,
-0.18416473269462585,
-0.13007792830467224,
0.5164031386375427,
0.6412350535392761,
-0.653275728225708,
-0.2522895634174347,
-0.733207106590271,
0.8551486730575562,
0.11140105128288269,
0.128203347325325,
0.40712806582450867,
0.57426917552948,
0.3139023780822754,
-0.1256394237279892,
0.5279417037963867,
0.17107416689395905,
0.2440079152584076,
-0.39785778522491455,
1.0428435802459717,
-0.34497302770614624,
0.568343460559845,
-0.43523678183555603,
-0.821993350982666,
-0.12317460030317307,
0.5293418765068054,
0.053955528885126114,
0.13294021785259247,
0.27420559525489807,
0.721005916595459,
-0.1988927572965622,
0.4841897785663605,
0.13339759409427643,
0.1941973865032196,
0.387155145406723,
0.14268358051776886,
1.2705296277999878,
-0.8817890882492065,
0.21135467290878296,
-0.19684766232967377,
-0.003868183819577098,
-0.03720041736960411,
-0.6408621668815613,
-0.811933159828186,
-0.42240676283836365,
-0.5128190517425537,
-0.0651150792837143,
0.028640665113925934,
0.853721022605896,
0.6093770861625671,
-0.7455306053161621,
-0.19283370673656464,
0.3947262167930603,
0.01415410079061985,
-0.17881391942501068,
-0.1150878369808197,
0.28760865330696106,
0.33994919061660767,
-0.4704766869544983,
0.5055303573608398,
0.1059846431016922,
-0.06355921179056168,
-0.15997634828090668,
-0.2664971947669983,
0.23577077686786652,
0.17847983539104462,
0.6625760197639465,
-0.16901972889900208,
-0.7563701272010803,
-0.5485127568244934,
0.0062644463032484055,
0.07704244554042816,
0.24540404975414276,
0.9665309190750122,
-0.9262175559997559,
0.3701139986515045,
0.30565503239631653,
0.195656418800354,
0.7241917252540588,
0.07267999649047852,
0.9244043231010437,
-1.0731422901153564,
0.17645369470119476,
0.1093999519944191,
0.20763161778450012,
0.45288655161857605,
-0.4579121172428131,
0.24945855140686035,
0.01959093287587166,
-0.09106156975030899,
-0.7308468222618103,
-0.22188302874565125,
-1.0036712884902954,
-0.23532700538635254,
1.21815824508667,
0.22530359029769897,
0.017479307949543,
-0.1564604789018631,
-0.22059248387813568,
0.5298668146133423,
-0.5927484035491943,
-0.040814101696014404,
0.23172308504581451,
0.11911974847316742,
-0.12736715376377106,
-0.7387422919273376,
0.15355727076530457,
0.1429588943719864,
-0.1126665323972702,
0.10250575840473175,
0.2832251489162445,
0.286695659160614,
0.013663474470376968,
0.4660646617412567,
-0.29178985953330994,
0.2577607035636902,
0.3219236731529236,
0.35821542143821716,
-0.31264156103134155,
-0.30630648136138916,
-0.6831055283546448,
0.2709450423717499,
-0.2349805235862732,
-0.16297085583209991
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09839v1
|
Rapport-Driven Virtual Agent: Rapport Building Dialogue Strategy for Improving User Experience at First Meeting
| 2024-06-14T08:47:15 | 2024-06-14T08:47:15 |
Muhammad Yeza Baihaqi, Angel García Contreras, Seiya Kawano, Koichiro Yoshino
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Rapport is known as a conversational aspect focusing on relationship
building, which influences outcomes in collaborative tasks. This study aims to
establish human-agent rapport through small talk by using a rapport-building
strategy. We implemented this strategy for the virtual agents based on dialogue
strategies by prompting a large language model (LLM). In particular, we
utilized two dialogue strategies-predefined sequence and free-form-to guide the
dialogue generation framework. We conducted analyses based on human
evaluations, examining correlations between total turn, utterance characters,
rapport score, and user experience variables: naturalness, satisfaction,
interest, engagement, and usability. We investigated correlations between
rapport score and naturalness, satisfaction, engagement, and conversation flow.
Our experimental results also indicated that using free-form to prompt the
rapport-building strategy performed the best in subjective scores.
|
[
-0.7657185792922974,
-0.6925846934318542,
0.7141190767288208,
0.3502163887023926,
-0.38281717896461487,
0.45396894216537476,
0.010244127362966537,
-0.7375815510749817,
0.5132999420166016,
0.4689847528934479,
-0.4853311777114868,
-0.4650834798812866,
-0.055959805846214294,
0.17554743587970734,
0.09214282035827637,
0.8115605115890503,
0.26437267661094666,
-0.18719784915447235,
-0.6256502270698547,
0.03612261265516281,
-0.6874092221260071,
-0.7023560404777527,
-0.8544083833694458,
-0.5407095551490784,
0.609518826007843,
0.5131145715713501,
1.01036536693573,
0.42537975311279297,
0.18797989189624786,
0.33412444591522217,
-0.19684839248657227,
0.44598037004470825,
-0.6674396395683289,
0.09874790161848068,
0.08636114746332169,
-0.4487150311470032,
-0.6292628049850464,
0.009718678891658783,
0.2916976809501648,
0.6511614322662354,
-0.4295410215854645,
-0.1268429011106491,
-0.08047164976596832,
0.42260441184043884,
-0.07066452503204346,
0.23620334267616272,
-0.33077916502952576,
0.06509619951248169,
0.000800136593170464,
-0.4002319276332855,
-0.3220600485801697,
-0.14777685701847076,
0.27172210812568665,
-0.931383490562439,
-0.0195025447756052,
0.19338423013687134,
0.8199828863143921,
-0.07362338155508041,
-0.423520565032959,
-0.10675593465566635,
-0.860167384147644,
0.5323801040649414,
-0.5493738651275635,
0.09810226410627365,
0.2119084894657135,
0.23878435790538788,
-0.39844009280204773,
-0.5489153861999512,
-0.6464561223983765,
-0.620527982711792,
-0.0767860934138298,
0.09152286499738693,
-0.34259822964668274,
0.28900617361068726,
0.37779274582862854,
0.040434595197439194,
-0.25282609462738037,
0.01897922158241272,
-0.19966372847557068,
-0.04833785444498062,
0.7226859927177429,
0.27074629068374634,
0.2582066059112549,
-0.12311778962612152,
-0.4928421080112457,
-0.17398883402347565,
-0.5506647825241089,
0.5644223690032959,
0.44297584891319275,
0.6317093372344971,
-0.4786052107810974,
0.4042806923389435,
-0.2919705808162689,
0.3107048273086548,
0.4141797125339508,
-0.2888348400592804,
0.23568317294120789,
-0.5357632040977478,
-0.030426522716879845,
0.057014260441064835,
0.6043447852134705,
0.6729859113693237,
0.5716556906700134,
-0.12145587801933289,
-0.12477549910545349,
0.10373116284608841,
0.6134234666824341,
-0.7757102251052856,
0.24384531378746033,
0.10173509269952774,
-0.3765057623386383,
-0.875953733921051,
0.38032448291778564,
-0.5064976811408997,
-0.2096603363752365,
-0.4164784848690033,
0.20621050894260406,
-0.38611745834350586,
-0.5666719079017639,
-0.4099332392215729,
0.014409152790904045,
0.60132896900177,
0.5732254981994629,
-0.6611858606338501,
1.0636026859283447,
0.5326151847839355,
1.0111953020095825,
-0.17733094096183777,
0.007158671040087938,
-0.9399295449256897,
0.10883836448192596,
-0.4076901078224182,
0.8868668079376221,
-0.208079531788826,
-1.0864595174789429,
0.18329675495624542,
-0.43138548731803894,
0.2786380350589752,
-0.7503926753997803,
0.5346956253051758,
-0.14008410274982452,
0.23609867691993713,
-0.19314290583133698,
-0.1809735894203186,
0.2229795753955841,
0.2988007068634033,
-0.5243858695030212,
0.7938823103904724,
0.39484623074531555,
-0.4062468111515045,
0.15738016366958618,
-0.9389646649360657,
-0.5604860186576843,
0.5088550448417664,
-0.5031962990760803,
-0.0609460324048996,
0.23050448298454285,
0.2193155288696289,
-0.005296924151480198,
-0.1546989530324936,
-0.2982152998447418,
0.11805485188961029,
-0.3684174716472626,
0.3779175281524658,
0.17844878137111664,
0.354256808757782,
0.007573172450065613,
-0.040345337241888046,
0.14130274951457977,
-0.4960324168205261,
0.30556783080101013,
0.22652705013751984,
-0.04781585559248924,
-0.26439690589904785,
-0.08407872915267944,
-0.12236722558736801,
0.546144962310791,
-0.04220452532172203,
-0.5688318610191345,
0.49575117230415344,
-0.9204942584037781,
-0.1980404257774353,
0.6263365745544434,
0.43028581142425537,
0.3962286710739136,
-0.695239245891571,
0.6775221228599548,
0.43167591094970703,
0.20205383002758026,
-0.04956158250570297,
-0.6135121583938599,
-0.617250382900238,
0.04677269235253334,
0.0544576495885849,
0.560798704624176,
-0.9400423765182495,
0.019174393266439438,
-0.4326978027820587,
-0.45401349663734436,
-0.5239302515983582,
0.2994921803474426,
0.5749268531799316,
0.35239601135253906,
-0.0643448680639267,
-0.5542415976524353,
-0.4510997235774994,
-0.6585007905960083,
-0.041493866592645645,
-0.5783591270446777,
-0.022244088351726532,
0.622664213180542,
0.069333516061306,
-0.35171061754226685,
1.2825720310211182,
-0.39682939648628235,
-0.3098168969154358,
-0.6885268092155457,
0.24918100237846375,
0.039875324815511703,
0.13497067987918854,
0.7296097278594971,
-0.9015477895736694,
-0.700287401676178,
-0.1567833423614502,
-0.4158037602901459,
-0.04395207017660141,
0.22124330699443817,
-0.0879620611667633,
0.397997111082077,
0.13166065514087677,
-0.9040299654006958,
0.5875040888786316,
0.1343599259853363,
-0.45069777965545654,
0.4990900754928589,
-0.19360311329364777,
0.3774513900279999,
-1.0590952634811401,
-0.4468485116958618,
0.009478768333792686,
-0.3541942238807678,
-0.9399659037590027,
-0.4744856357574463,
-0.5492675304412842,
-0.2772104740142822,
-0.865354597568512,
0.7822360396385193,
-0.28296443819999695,
-0.076352059841156,
-0.3357846438884735,
0.372723251581192,
0.01678060181438923,
0.4871049225330353,
0.07490289211273193,
0.8266298174858093,
0.17594477534294128,
-0.6114670038223267,
0.1852615624666214,
0.6641332507133484,
0.015082783997058868,
0.831879198551178,
-0.8889135718345642,
0.477486789226532,
0.1095210388302803,
0.01613488793373108,
-0.9618586301803589,
0.01651136390864849,
0.09820550680160522,
-0.7769294381141663,
0.19829532504081726,
0.03306485339999199,
-0.4553740918636322,
-0.2976638674736023,
-0.31579816341400146,
0.11142062395811081,
0.41641512513160706,
-0.2637007236480713,
0.5611223578453064,
0.2154049426317215,
-0.459635466337204,
0.1225842833518982,
-0.18718041479587555,
0.3914273679256439,
0.04190399497747421,
-1.1227188110351562,
0.5271511673927307,
-0.2497292160987854,
-0.8451308608055115,
-0.3802739977836609,
0.10614044219255447,
0.06536078453063965,
-0.06484401971101761,
0.6210843920707703,
0.16916128993034363,
0.034635137766599655,
-0.1282876878976822,
-0.3233482837677002,
-0.3321966230869293,
-0.04261726140975952,
0.07200190424919128,
0.7107873558998108,
-0.3155340254306793,
-0.029764004051685333,
-0.4871739149093628,
0.731652021408081,
0.5794008374214172,
0.038730137050151825,
0.9712088704109192,
0.259477823972702,
-0.12048964202404022,
0.013851971365511417,
-0.4658936858177185,
-0.4176013767719269,
-0.4389902651309967,
-0.15036067366600037,
-0.7352997660636902,
-0.7172178030014038,
0.41226837038993835,
-0.40146303176879883,
-0.05792742222547531,
0.109446682035923,
0.6398140788078308,
-0.4129844009876251,
1.176476001739502,
1.1085529327392578,
0.12894773483276367,
0.36276981234550476,
-0.0054912748746573925,
0.27192360162734985,
-0.496844083070755,
-0.24902960658073425,
-0.20750324428081512,
-0.04007183387875557,
-0.5940642356872559,
-0.2901889383792877,
0.30450183153152466,
-0.12887218594551086,
0.21119974553585052,
0.2915705144405365,
0.0518762432038784,
0.07363785803318024,
0.636777937412262,
-0.07668133825063705,
0.41863980889320374,
-0.012119892053306103,
-0.44139790534973145,
-0.20737981796264648,
-0.5202077031135559,
-0.6524683833122253,
0.5568391680717468,
0.33188560605049133,
0.48781824111938477,
0.3972983658313751,
1.0529614686965942,
0.55101078748703,
-0.010551855899393559,
-0.904468834400177,
0.651398777961731,
0.561488151550293,
-0.007612125016748905,
-0.3661096692085266,
-0.4437660574913025,
-1.0531682968139648,
0.14031869173049927,
-0.46901121735572815,
-0.9518608450889587,
-0.11031490564346313,
0.02912779524922371,
-0.5297070741653442,
-0.3218478560447693,
-0.6771035194396973,
0.7056381702423096,
-0.2879689335823059,
-0.37976041436195374,
-0.2192515879869461,
-0.6855990290641785,
0.22848404943943024,
0.2505744993686676,
0.22097152471542358,
0.0989617109298706,
0.15594635903835297,
0.4976601004600525,
-0.5857416987419128,
0.5649030208587646,
-0.2741955518722534,
0.006030385382473469,
0.3153233826160431,
0.13287898898124695,
0.6474509835243225,
-0.02964167296886444,
0.13386963307857513,
0.2513444721698761,
0.03584956005215645,
-0.25514018535614014,
-0.8666325807571411,
0.35749372839927673,
-1.0974105596542358,
-0.5696731209754944,
-0.3341476321220398,
-0.36382588744163513,
-0.3301735520362854,
0.03565855696797371,
0.014035713858902454,
0.2895454168319702,
-0.7640988826751709,
0.018329571932554245,
0.45789986848831177,
-0.22150413691997528,
0.24485091865062714,
0.7726446390151978,
-0.419405460357666,
-0.40081554651260376,
0.7032884955406189,
-0.14559754729270935,
0.5954748392105103,
0.24214614927768707,
0.22800838947296143,
-0.25455358624458313,
-0.11075462400913239,
-0.02437051571905613,
0.31695371866226196,
-0.013519260101020336,
0.027353208512067795,
-0.4300616681575775,
-0.4230021834373474,
-0.6889494061470032,
-0.13010889291763306,
-0.2841583490371704,
-0.18199187517166138,
-0.0034483736380934715,
-0.16604453325271606,
0.14284397661685944,
0.5539507269859314,
-0.08656085282564163,
0.7316323518753052,
-0.676977276802063,
0.6658028364181519,
0.293266236782074,
0.0034819182474166155,
-0.2807135283946991,
-0.3457464277744293,
-0.31776466965675354,
0.10224851220846176,
-0.5096635818481445,
-0.8083755970001221,
0.49796873331069946,
-0.012114662677049637,
0.733048677444458,
0.6465792655944824,
0.11011746525764465,
0.42659080028533936,
-0.30191460251808167,
0.8851820230484009,
0.3707960247993469,
-0.6224653720855713,
0.8868654370307922,
-0.46064841747283936,
0.17646034061908722,
0.33862459659576416,
0.11746873706579208,
-0.5363494157791138,
-0.1542574167251587,
-1.065887212753296,
-0.6955285668373108,
0.5850809812545776,
0.5889372229576111,
0.1011633574962616,
0.0996825098991394,
0.22156165540218353,
-0.22251220047473907,
0.5157068967819214,
-0.457331120967865,
-0.4327612817287445,
-0.08535749465227127,
0.21793141961097717,
-0.044938188046216965,
-0.43099209666252136,
-0.45316052436828613,
-0.20228971540927887,
0.23499304056167603,
-0.20004667341709137,
0.43460553884506226,
0.14227160811424255,
0.08759032934904099,
-0.3879907727241516,
0.2648944854736328,
0.8620849847793579,
0.679932177066803,
-0.3314277231693268,
-0.33322930335998535,
-0.009290569461882114,
-0.33451783657073975,
0.1960292011499405,
-0.04322947934269905,
-0.13367369771003723,
-0.07543528079986572,
0.18012942373752594,
0.6443958282470703,
0.09193607419729233,
-0.6019672751426697,
0.7235729098320007,
-0.380410373210907,
-0.5013220310211182,
-0.4089180529117584,
0.2762041687965393,
0.07138624042272568,
0.32285404205322266,
0.3051620423793793,
-0.3707291781902313,
-0.23830994963645935,
-0.6933318376541138,
0.23265069723129272,
0.4936010241508484,
-0.39504146575927734,
-0.18863749504089355,
0.1982412338256836,
0.7055239081382751,
-0.9159590005874634,
0.6441208720207214,
-0.18233661353588104,
-0.2782270014286041,
0.1922910064458847,
0.5674827098846436,
0.7727733850479126,
-0.2144453078508377,
0.6485856175422668,
0.08632763475179672,
0.2125619798898697,
0.39470699429512024,
0.19767723977565765,
-0.41365161538124084,
-0.9979211688041687,
-0.19231505692005157,
-0.43717315793037415,
-0.873248815536499,
-0.08980589359998703,
-0.5169854760169983,
0.2322148233652115,
-0.29188692569732666,
-0.3093962073326111,
-0.14788438379764557,
0.704377293586731,
-0.7566699981689453,
-0.011639248579740524,
0.3243744373321533,
0.8220170140266418,
-0.4587455093860626,
0.5993075966835022,
0.5905486345291138,
-0.6389039158821106,
-0.8737908601760864,
-0.2501090466976166,
0.17218060791492462,
-0.5629249811172485,
0.6734857559204102,
0.18849240243434906,
-0.5307726263999939,
0.08062215894460678,
-0.7375854849815369,
-0.5494807958602905,
1.1355986595153809,
0.10768333077430725,
-0.5289689302444458,
-0.21100062131881714,
0.4070078134536743,
0.5406453013420105,
-0.74053955078125,
0.24587032198905945,
0.42027992010116577,
0.24503041803836823,
0.44382384419441223,
-1.030032753944397,
-0.13964122533798218,
-0.5711635947227478,
0.21555881202220917,
0.05394300818443298,
-0.6541451811790466,
0.4219698905944824,
-0.4848157465457916,
-0.24460400640964508,
0.2736768126487732,
0.9666132926940918,
0.30452218651771545,
0.25477200746536255,
0.8089544773101807,
0.4755641520023346,
0.5840572118759155,
0.04829961061477661,
0.9440352916717529,
-0.3337109386920929,
-0.2957885265350342,
1.084333896636963,
-0.46387431025505066,
0.6581537127494812,
0.7027857303619385,
0.0351315476000309,
0.8671686053276062,
0.24318894743919373,
0.28882303833961487,
0.46724066138267517,
0.3430795669555664,
-0.3931090235710144,
-0.14584292471408844,
-0.46062779426574707,
-0.1557908058166504,
0.6904612183570862,
0.2845897376537323,
0.026864495128393173,
-0.11774473637342453,
0.15849967300891876,
0.011852890253067017,
0.17177607119083405,
-0.07448405772447586,
1.2513866424560547,
0.2896743416786194,
-0.590604305267334,
0.18048763275146484,
-0.05336042121052742,
0.28093254566192627,
-0.71564781665802,
-0.22496196627616882,
-0.1848437488079071,
-0.11330470442771912,
-0.12925097346305847,
-0.4572458565235138,
-0.1547415554523468,
0.007283536717295647,
-0.3062412440776825,
-0.2661955654621124,
0.6973202228546143,
-0.20794440805912018,
-0.13065090775489807,
0.3240765929222107,
0.9814685583114624,
0.17216859757900238,
-0.23483020067214966,
-0.3996836245059967,
0.10670465230941772,
-0.2400033324956894,
-0.2920336425304413,
0.5360295176506042,
0.403143972158432,
0.04164789617061615,
0.6722378134727478,
0.9345256686210632,
0.21877801418304443,
-0.4196258783340454,
0.518051266670227,
0.8933483362197876,
-0.7235416173934937,
-0.5985925197601318,
-0.44958022236824036,
0.7319825291633606,
-0.39246171712875366,
-0.19867448508739471,
0.6328148245811462,
0.2921943962574005,
0.5193088054656982,
0.12078393250703812,
0.6765797734260559,
0.07237827777862549,
0.7377607822418213,
-0.06681321561336517,
0.314933180809021,
-0.17216847836971283,
-0.001376186846755445,
-0.6174907088279724,
-0.7905511260032654,
0.23324139416217804,
0.7421048283576965,
-0.04894451051950455,
-0.01970764622092247,
0.3475765883922577,
0.8427118062973022,
0.29437634348869324,
-0.2261873334646225,
0.7548114061355591,
0.18299372494220734,
0.6056646108627319,
0.5491957664489746,
1.0609147548675537,
-0.15590111911296844,
0.5749526619911194,
-0.19355757534503937,
-0.48692408204078674,
-0.2328002005815506,
-0.8076798319816589,
-0.8930057287216187,
-0.3436279594898224,
-0.2507573068141937,
-0.4767918884754181,
-0.07148110121488571,
1.143394947052002,
0.5919936299324036,
-0.3135133981704712,
-0.4621504545211792,
0.06162254884839058,
-0.12036927789449692,
-0.20553115010261536,
-0.3143045902252197,
-0.37039658427238464,
-0.21351279318332672,
-0.5060701370239258,
0.5497532486915588,
0.4474002718925476,
0.3510901629924774,
-0.2840823829174042,
-0.6154244542121887,
-0.025671476498246193,
0.31283625960350037,
0.7882984280586243,
0.5570797324180603,
-0.5291455388069153,
-0.27707821130752563,
0.1445874571800232,
-0.33401602506637573,
0.2248377948999405,
0.7945533394813538,
-1.0185002088546753,
0.42439934611320496,
-0.037271272391080856,
0.23186327517032623,
0.5530913472175598,
0.5850958228111267,
1.1154921054840088,
-0.7653956413269043,
0.2535736858844757,
0.22105908393859863,
-0.1540881097316742,
0.2937312424182892,
-0.42546346783638,
0.3480561375617981,
0.28434810042381287,
-0.40617942810058594,
-0.5658555626869202,
0.3477519452571869,
-1.4326722621917725,
0.3188406229019165,
0.9602206349372864,
0.20477016270160675,
0.10403058677911758,
-0.08197124302387238,
-0.7174251675605774,
0.17582178115844727,
-0.6363901495933533,
0.6685203909873962,
0.601884663105011,
-0.6252492070198059,
-0.24907247722148895,
-0.41589561104774475,
0.6383137106895447,
-0.08517991006374359,
-0.848859965801239,
-0.48394569754600525,
0.29722127318382263,
-0.13353173434734344,
0.4394954442977905,
1.0459620952606201,
0.27785158157348633,
0.28234541416168213,
0.19572648406028748,
-0.11892580986022949,
-0.34493395686149597,
-0.500206708908081,
0.2725456655025482,
0.198167622089386,
0.27460387349128723,
-0.19762524962425232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09831v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09831v1
|
Federated Learning driven Large Language Models for Swarm Intelligence: A Survey
| 2024-06-14T08:40:58 | 2024-06-14T08:40:58 |
Youyang Qu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.NE
|
Federated learning (FL) offers a compelling framework for training large
language models (LLMs) while addressing data privacy and decentralization
challenges. This paper surveys recent advancements in the federated learning of
large language models, with a particular focus on machine unlearning, a crucial
aspect for complying with privacy regulations like the Right to be Forgotten.
Machine unlearning in the context of federated LLMs involves systematically and
securely removing individual data contributions from the learned model without
retraining from scratch. We explore various strategies that enable effective
unlearning, such as perturbation techniques, model decomposition, and
incremental learning, highlighting their implications for maintaining model
performance and data privacy. Furthermore, we examine case studies and
experimental results from recent literature to assess the effectiveness and
efficiency of these approaches in real-world scenarios. Our survey reveals a
growing interest in developing more robust and scalable federated unlearning
methods, suggesting a vital area for future research in the intersection of AI
ethics and distributed machine learning technologies.
|
[
-0.17553916573524475,
-0.6779073476791382,
0.25699251890182495,
-0.07290845364332199,
0.09509162604808807,
0.6432200074195862,
-0.4329164922237396,
-0.4118846654891968,
-0.28863397240638733,
0.6187658905982971,
-0.8101679682731628,
-0.3538723289966583,
-0.3108997642993927,
-0.03761003538966179,
-0.5018845796585083,
0.962368369102478,
0.38635990023612976,
0.06280461698770523,
-0.6025221943855286,
0.0016315070679411292,
0.11696121096611023,
-0.9525091052055359,
-0.30331951379776,
-0.6593995094299316,
0.3905542492866516,
0.4787757098674774,
0.790147602558136,
0.8172159194946289,
0.5086876153945923,
0.36990272998809814,
-0.14321331679821014,
0.1502123326063156,
-0.7138073444366455,
0.3750954270362854,
-0.2989916503429413,
-0.48060834407806396,
-0.2836405336856842,
0.24373599886894226,
0.8519380688667297,
1.0972225666046143,
-0.3441430628299713,
0.23083770275115967,
-0.21819168329238892,
0.9383444786071777,
-0.7610507607460022,
0.3879183828830719,
-0.5106311440467834,
0.2856220006942749,
-0.13937035202980042,
0.2214803248643875,
-0.719607412815094,
-0.18515637516975403,
0.020261678844690323,
-0.2181188315153122,
0.20140141248703003,
-0.029888099059462547,
0.2711906135082245,
0.27459102869033813,
-0.33685967326164246,
-0.18125401437282562,
-0.9037507772445679,
0.9933673143386841,
-0.4335460960865021,
0.7315601706504822,
0.2710849344730377,
0.2076006829738617,
-0.35763686895370483,
-0.9936766624450684,
-0.2938367426395416,
0.15656530857086182,
0.024420347064733505,
0.03566825017333031,
-0.5430456399917603,
0.17117726802825928,
-0.05034903809428215,
0.6386454105377197,
-0.32339248061180115,
0.7340433597564697,
-0.09864512830972672,
-0.27694225311279297,
0.9569743871688843,
-0.005798729136586189,
0.02087855525314808,
0.22644974291324615,
-0.29610997438430786,
-0.1928812861442566,
-0.6893452405929565,
0.2512112557888031,
0.5952647924423218,
0.47914785146713257,
0.12961748242378235,
0.3840358555316925,
-0.3785230219364166,
0.5018870234489441,
0.011057691648602486,
-0.25072553753852844,
0.4145246744155884,
0.06806889176368713,
-0.35129156708717346,
-0.33394309878349304,
0.9117931723594666,
-0.13660632073879242,
0.12724442780017853,
-0.747431755065918,
-0.6751624345779419,
-0.4785774052143097,
0.03651484474539757,
-0.7092774510383606,
-0.108404241502285,
0.4361976981163025,
-0.6144636869430542,
-0.4336404800415039,
0.3859693706035614,
-1.0146608352661133,
-0.5577734112739563,
-0.2830113470554352,
0.02474069595336914,
-0.14748895168304443,
-0.5421568751335144,
-0.23641489446163177,
0.0011650583473965526,
0.04462607577443123,
0.009119481779634953,
-1.1610562801361084,
0.2856970727443695,
1.170270562171936,
0.5281341075897217,
-0.04887301102280617,
-0.49243831634521484,
-0.7592156529426575,
-0.35643643140792847,
-0.2627074718475342,
0.1737273931503296,
-0.6453284621238708,
-0.3117068409919739,
0.38336431980133057,
0.09857642650604248,
-0.2141338437795639,
-0.5115612149238586,
-0.1260996162891388,
-0.8835705518722534,
0.40316492319107056,
0.11682193726301193,
-0.862391471862793,
-0.5869175791740417,
-0.022733964025974274,
-0.30659008026123047,
0.47847780585289,
0.2139006406068802,
-0.4781741797924042,
-0.02231391705572605,
-0.7025768160820007,
-0.5630787014961243,
0.13004842400550842,
-0.23705343902111053,
-0.7745876908302307,
0.17499881982803345,
0.06816837191581726,
0.9035823345184326,
-0.21560046076774597,
0.4641823172569275,
-0.4128013551235199,
-0.23415501415729523,
0.1353365033864975,
-0.4915638267993927,
1.3208972215652466,
0.5236616134643555,
-0.4527510702610016,
0.35033944249153137,
-0.7108524441719055,
0.10959553718566895,
0.19267389178276062,
-0.191158264875412,
-0.04807465150952339,
0.0134272500872612,
-0.3658263683319092,
-0.02693324349820614,
0.3898565471172333,
-0.4849911332130432,
0.07836272567510605,
-0.43222060799598694,
0.694975733757019,
0.9232442378997803,
0.04476077854633331,
0.7386664152145386,
-0.4374617040157318,
0.43308353424072266,
-0.1365874856710434,
0.4305172264575958,
-0.0879763513803482,
-0.10310111939907074,
-0.44844716787338257,
-0.44078385829925537,
0.0521230585873127,
0.2570495009422302,
-0.5342556834220886,
0.37496811151504517,
-0.03201400488615036,
-0.7881863117218018,
-0.3062412738800049,
0.22325699031352997,
0.4498545527458191,
0.2647947072982788,
0.007440694607794285,
0.3183515965938568,
-0.4529094398021698,
-0.5250315070152283,
-0.007529963739216328,
-0.2299199253320694,
0.07266481965780258,
0.28065574169158936,
0.4878943860530853,
-0.7660295367240906,
0.8108876943588257,
-0.07072629779577255,
-0.17012859880924225,
-0.25527021288871765,
0.036827702075242996,
-0.25258490443229675,
0.3832338750362396,
0.4969666004180908,
-1.0306061506271362,
-0.05726103484630585,
0.19533060491085052,
-0.8537031412124634,
0.42234426736831665,
0.17784500122070312,
0.3251987099647522,
0.6168830394744873,
0.5042657852172852,
-0.3221268057823181,
0.14763784408569336,
0.7503983378410339,
0.015642868354916573,
0.44092002511024475,
-0.24630847573280334,
-0.004400986712425947,
-0.889316201210022,
-0.005488488357514143,
-0.7137507200241089,
-0.3374618589878082,
-0.790628969669342,
0.5131593942642212,
-0.11381865292787552,
-0.16179408133029938,
-0.4113164246082306,
0.1012549102306366,
-0.6300066113471985,
-0.3448989987373352,
-0.3469710946083069,
-0.1214291900396347,
-0.6258518695831299,
0.4461953639984131,
-0.02415432408452034,
0.7619650363922119,
0.8437070846557617,
-0.517713725566864,
0.6238642334938049,
0.25337859988212585,
0.040949027985334396,
0.01918107643723488,
-0.22769229114055634,
0.4034101068973541,
-0.32209038734436035,
0.02045239880681038,
-0.7104213833808899,
-0.5015736222267151,
-0.027926594018936157,
-0.4207499027252197,
0.006089288741350174,
0.12197908014059067,
-0.6928266882896423,
-0.3330968916416168,
-0.21893581748008728,
0.16676588356494904,
0.7314280867576599,
-0.9047722220420837,
0.653267502784729,
0.742016613483429,
0.21644459664821625,
-0.7806273102760315,
-0.5042194128036499,
-0.3990527093410492,
-0.08326414227485657,
-0.42006707191467285,
-0.04182276129722595,
0.08280728757381439,
-0.5678909420967102,
-0.22349299490451813,
-0.024200234562158585,
-0.3015243411064148,
0.5363122224807739,
0.8139561414718628,
-0.12911930680274963,
-0.15345598757266998,
0.40884608030319214,
-0.27929678559303284,
0.058694083243608475,
0.17798294126987457,
-0.18958397209644318,
0.8498496413230896,
-0.5449522137641907,
-0.24602828919887543,
-0.43062126636505127,
0.22262276709079742,
0.9474316239356995,
-0.571165919303894,
1.0386244058609009,
0.5710623860359192,
-0.49497076869010925,
-0.42058059573173523,
-0.39859727025032043,
-0.349385142326355,
-0.47188928723335266,
-0.00112690101377666,
0.12420075386762619,
-1.3760539293289185,
0.6802341938018799,
-0.4195553958415985,
0.6103901267051697,
0.25805971026420593,
0.6885702013969421,
-0.07408186793327332,
0.7221398949623108,
1.2904499769210815,
-0.4568835496902466,
0.6419692635536194,
-0.18761253356933594,
0.308337926864624,
-0.2833186089992523,
-0.419914186000824,
-0.40208011865615845,
-0.11712057143449783,
-0.806289553642273,
-0.03325348347425461,
0.054503653198480606,
-0.14902734756469727,
-0.4401104152202606,
-0.026104459539055824,
-0.2740572988986969,
0.5685984492301941,
0.6346390247344971,
0.06287750601768494,
0.45656371116638184,
0.01864144206047058,
0.1816840022802353,
0.508903980255127,
-0.6725653409957886,
-0.19652222096920013,
1.153245210647583,
0.45257678627967834,
0.4636556804180145,
0.10249883681535721,
0.9283181428909302,
0.3030852675437927,
0.24044638872146606,
-0.6049646139144897,
0.49548953771591187,
-0.14873182773590088,
-0.5315232276916504,
-0.5251124501228333,
-0.7342743277549744,
-0.8264515995979309,
0.22739990055561066,
-0.2562442719936371,
-0.7348775267601013,
0.09990078210830688,
-0.0018262952798977494,
-0.3447639048099518,
0.6962823271751404,
-0.41869354248046875,
0.5776950716972351,
-0.0727844163775444,
-0.1590798944234848,
-0.35441452264785767,
-0.7940886616706848,
0.41791361570358276,
-0.3064241111278534,
0.23599395155906677,
0.11892262101173401,
0.18133188784122467,
0.7941367030143738,
-0.6922906637191772,
0.9985248446464539,
-0.25416773557662964,
0.059994906187057495,
0.1365259438753128,
-0.2208489179611206,
0.5695855617523193,
0.001920238952152431,
-0.23833619058132172,
0.316019743680954,
-0.11999986320734024,
-0.29578250646591187,
-0.22537913918495178,
0.582767128944397,
-1.031595230102539,
-0.5911997556686401,
-0.4222898781299591,
-0.6965526938438416,
-0.3565099239349365,
0.42534637451171875,
0.26469534635543823,
0.15560917556285858,
-0.07677225023508072,
0.6244601607322693,
0.7463013529777527,
0.032643165439367294,
0.812581479549408,
0.7802724242210388,
-0.4475739300251007,
-0.343506783246994,
0.785893440246582,
0.005531060975044966,
0.32417047023773193,
0.35742872953414917,
0.17539091408252716,
-0.2557280361652374,
-0.4772661030292511,
0.07287132740020752,
0.4078301191329956,
-0.4940119981765747,
-0.3070129454135895,
-0.5382024645805359,
-0.45083168148994446,
-0.5635092854499817,
-0.2660147249698639,
-0.8369988799095154,
-0.1363794207572937,
-0.5313851833343506,
-0.23042811453342438,
0.49172839522361755,
0.7404417395591736,
-0.1887592077255249,
0.5042237043380737,
-0.5807685256004333,
-0.22236184775829315,
0.06365398317575455,
0.45889565348625183,
0.21690383553504944,
-0.32950180768966675,
0.12230028212070465,
0.365844190120697,
0.05763726681470871,
-0.22629453241825104,
0.1536072939634323,
0.11090296506881714,
0.5423687696456909,
0.6592065095901489,
0.5071381330490112,
0.5449306964874268,
-0.3447314500808716,
0.5797675251960754,
0.13436362147331238,
-0.775736927986145,
0.19078463315963745,
-0.2678222358226776,
-0.13082003593444824,
0.40436461567878723,
0.49133554100990295,
-0.4059866964817047,
-0.5123070478439331,
-0.8064886927604675,
-0.6329981088638306,
0.5235120058059692,
-0.21143180131912231,
0.18457281589508057,
0.36103856563568115,
0.3737977147102356,
0.31861627101898193,
0.5139156579971313,
-0.5329570770263672,
-0.38463348150253296,
0.05131205916404724,
0.003683223621919751,
-0.2783432602882385,
-0.022099729627370834,
-0.049098577350378036,
-0.270160973072052,
0.7188689112663269,
0.23336024582386017,
-0.02112741209566593,
-0.23709271848201752,
-0.1557530164718628,
-0.3245493173599243,
0.18860317766666412,
0.35281407833099365,
0.7107073068618774,
0.023690028116106987,
0.0552016980946064,
-0.26988282799720764,
-0.392205148935318,
0.22693613171577454,
0.01445640716701746,
-0.36604392528533936,
-0.3623703718185425,
0.35765761137008667,
0.4027511179447174,
0.16231636703014374,
-0.9236068725585938,
0.6272696852684021,
0.17904998362064362,
-0.3893745243549347,
-0.5612684488296509,
0.14527666568756104,
-0.218971386551857,
0.45003414154052734,
0.3270942270755768,
0.029345408082008362,
-0.28949373960494995,
-0.7063212394714355,
0.5638064742088318,
0.5915123820304871,
-0.2861555218696594,
-0.33280766010284424,
0.511141836643219,
0.07426901906728745,
-0.3019619584083557,
0.9859901070594788,
-0.17207853496074677,
-0.5303422212600708,
0.25179779529571533,
0.5124388933181763,
0.6837819814682007,
-0.41305267810821533,
0.5000841021537781,
-0.16165675222873688,
0.35215795040130615,
-0.3380434811115265,
-0.1336793750524521,
-0.2648867964744568,
-0.6589447855949402,
0.03096671588718891,
-0.453626811504364,
-0.6466689109802246,
0.2495645135641098,
-0.6742873787879944,
-0.40941062569618225,
-0.8668349385261536,
0.16732050478458405,
-0.0740581676363945,
0.3318883180618286,
-0.40135589241981506,
-0.16750401258468628,
-0.04527532681822777,
0.602756917476654,
-0.8843282461166382,
0.65060955286026,
0.673214852809906,
-0.4067589044570923,
-0.8730823993682861,
-0.1537715494632721,
0.35966381430625916,
-0.6991398930549622,
0.28188222646713257,
0.1349485218524933,
-0.15336139500141144,
0.27485331892967224,
-0.6007223129272461,
-0.654393196105957,
1.0851030349731445,
0.2910955548286438,
-0.5628489851951599,
0.23956143856048584,
0.315449059009552,
0.5330038070678711,
-0.3039802312850952,
-0.18786905705928802,
0.5186567306518555,
0.05094338580965996,
-0.002389595378190279,
-0.6733805537223816,
-0.2874133884906769,
0.16488440334796906,
-0.3112492859363556,
0.1326451599597931,
-1.1028695106506348,
1.1575192213058472,
-0.36111247539520264,
-0.3853355944156647,
-0.04020918533205986,
0.9616332054138184,
-0.2539522349834442,
0.4613400995731354,
0.46480804681777954,
0.1931505650281906,
1.4823362827301025,
0.01670135371387005,
0.5847412943840027,
-0.09179693460464478,
0.5710107088088989,
0.810962438583374,
-0.42890456318855286,
0.884228527545929,
0.27239349484443665,
0.02379787154495716,
0.19736655056476593,
0.4664883017539978,
-0.055797550827264786,
0.4709208011627197,
-0.0308210551738739,
-0.334477037191391,
-0.22007536888122559,
0.04909903556108475,
-0.055689938366413116,
0.7648438215255737,
-0.01170324720442295,
-0.4167972207069397,
-0.43116727471351624,
0.5366973876953125,
0.32484421133995056,
0.43649935722351074,
-0.5043684840202332,
0.9794635772705078,
-0.20714443922042847,
-0.49625876545906067,
0.4329977035522461,
-0.06805797666311264,
0.584871232509613,
-0.321825236082077,
0.29348501563072205,
-0.4476718306541443,
0.5716487169265747,
-0.4783724248409271,
-0.4391658306121826,
0.29653939604759216,
0.2485552430152893,
-0.4385794997215271,
-0.34223616123199463,
0.297434538602829,
-0.4005047082901001,
-0.21902596950531006,
0.2629352807998657,
0.5789884328842163,
0.13563129305839539,
-0.06307820230722427,
-0.48168978095054626,
0.13428133726119995,
0.12115580588579178,
-0.18200522661209106,
0.559869647026062,
0.2886347472667694,
-0.021518807858228683,
1.146660327911377,
0.7362813949584961,
-0.2612549960613251,
-0.005666875746101141,
-0.050573643296957016,
0.9167097806930542,
-0.26848477125167847,
-0.3348831832408905,
-0.8744578957557678,
0.04883073270320892,
0.07732715457677841,
0.017772480845451355,
0.9475228786468506,
0.4978686273097992,
1.0655416250228882,
0.0014259525341913104,
0.5815561413764954,
0.21875588595867157,
0.6214091181755066,
-0.2819032371044159,
1.2068088054656982,
-0.4223076105117798,
0.1922467201948166,
0.13108140230178833,
-0.540317714214325,
-0.3949012756347656,
0.32425567507743835,
-0.20406457781791687,
-0.16495296359062195,
0.23522400856018066,
0.6594558954238892,
0.1865023821592331,
0.4385232925415039,
0.4395195543766022,
0.13258187472820282,
0.4665338695049286,
0.27441486716270447,
0.6166805624961853,
-0.11982503533363342,
0.1360727846622467,
-0.7169921398162842,
-0.3071817457675934,
-0.2719336748123169,
-0.49761444330215454,
-0.9803525805473328,
-0.7421561479568481,
-0.26874983310699463,
0.22355511784553528,
0.13583828508853912,
1.0715477466583252,
0.522994875907898,
-0.8679720163345337,
-0.20024065673351288,
-0.23041902482509613,
0.4875341057777405,
-0.48737671971321106,
-0.19028757512569427,
0.24952132999897003,
-0.473097562789917,
-0.527611255645752,
0.5064989328384399,
0.16002029180526733,
0.03759080916643143,
-0.3551149070262909,
-0.05518689751625061,
-0.07788915187120438,
-0.23468421399593353,
0.5653051137924194,
0.7020018100738525,
-0.6593557596206665,
-0.22430340945720673,
0.026568550616502762,
-0.00907734502106905,
-0.2961306869983673,
0.6476675271987915,
-0.7060234546661377,
0.3326547145843506,
0.32068145275115967,
1.0281190872192383,
-0.15438295900821686,
0.2620614171028137,
0.32157984375953674,
-0.8500877022743225,
0.45031046867370605,
0.38094794750213623,
0.2110336571931839,
0.08484281599521637,
-0.5898576974868774,
0.4274468421936035,
0.25792834162712097,
-0.9390251636505127,
-1.2900850772857666,
0.12305286526679993,
-0.503340482711792,
-0.390270471572876,
0.86812824010849,
-0.32804355025291443,
-0.364663690328598,
0.15798808634281158,
0.5440580248832703,
0.17627567052841187,
-0.198045015335083,
0.658721923828125,
0.4517737329006195,
-0.14687947928905487,
-0.20900803804397583,
-0.10837318748235703,
0.4427163600921631,
0.03881752863526344,
-0.7084850072860718,
0.7813621163368225,
0.7694641947746277,
0.1777959167957306,
0.015860753133893013,
0.32389599084854126,
-0.12561006844043732,
0.3166404962539673,
-0.09258335828781128,
-0.07508333027362823,
-0.5267523527145386,
-0.6038184762001038,
-0.6650461554527283,
0.35838860273361206,
-0.2383345663547516,
-0.3187432885169983
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09827v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09827v1
|
HiP Attention: Sparse Sub-Quadratic Attention with Hierarchical Attention Pruning
| 2024-06-14T08:32:45 | 2024-06-14T08:32:45 |
Heejun Lee, Geon Park, Youngwan Lee, Jina Kim, Wonyoung Jeong, Myeongjae Jeon, Sung Ju Hwang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.DC, cs.LG
|
In modern large language models (LLMs), increasing sequence lengths is a
crucial challenge for enhancing their comprehension and coherence in handling
complex tasks such as multi-modal question answering. However, handling long
context sequences with LLMs is prohibitively costly due to the conventional
attention mechanism's quadratic time and space complexity, and the context
window size is limited by the GPU memory. Although recent works have proposed
linear and sparse attention mechanisms to address this issue, their real-world
applicability is often limited by the need to re-train pre-trained models. In
response, we propose a novel approach, Hierarchically Pruned Attention (HiP),
which simultaneously reduces the training and inference time complexity from
$O(T^2)$ to $O(T \log T)$ and the space complexity from $O(T^2)$ to $O(T)$. To
this end, we devise a dynamic sparse attention mechanism that generates an
attention mask through a novel tree-search-like algorithm for a given query on
the fly. HiP is training-free as it only utilizes the pre-trained attention
scores to spot the positions of the top-$k$ most significant elements for each
query. Moreover, it ensures that no token is overlooked, unlike the sliding
window-based sub-quadratic attention methods, such as StreamingLLM. Extensive
experiments on diverse real-world benchmarks demonstrate that HiP significantly
reduces prompt (i.e., prefill) and decoding latency and memory usage while
maintaining high generation performance with little or no degradation. As HiP
allows pretrained LLMs to scale to millions of tokens on commodity GPUs with no
additional engineering due to its easy plug-and-play deployment, we believe
that our work will have a large practical impact, opening up the possibility to
many long-context LLM applications previously infeasible.
|
[
-0.2282012403011322,
-1.064256191253662,
0.4876744747161865,
0.23421891033649445,
-0.4215467572212219,
0.15274402499198914,
0.02694760635495186,
-0.5725806355476379,
0.38067370653152466,
0.1335011124610901,
-0.9167910218238831,
-0.24650788307189941,
-0.2723836600780487,
-0.04159080982208252,
-0.06089901179075241,
0.9568533897399902,
0.13752996921539307,
-0.4067542254924774,
-0.19590747356414795,
-0.14853446185588837,
-0.3778776228427887,
-0.4799911379814148,
-0.5309867858886719,
-0.013759042136371136,
0.8051798343658447,
0.21399660408496857,
0.7822965383529663,
0.8863436579704285,
0.3353491425514221,
0.22986264526844025,
-0.12132424116134644,
0.12597334384918213,
-0.8818739652633667,
0.13483580946922302,
0.06932470947504044,
-0.26546114683151245,
-0.517734706401825,
-0.23935800790786743,
0.9905203580856323,
0.834180474281311,
0.24677039682865143,
0.34049928188323975,
0.18262289464473724,
0.6744616031646729,
-0.8533371090888977,
0.021839842200279236,
-0.625995934009552,
0.12653928995132446,
-0.15472032129764557,
-0.574666440486908,
-0.1691341996192932,
-0.1896013468503952,
0.16894236207008362,
-0.8771541118621826,
0.14517948031425476,
0.2902924418449402,
0.9704967737197876,
0.5836847424507141,
-0.1788496971130371,
0.44413357973098755,
-0.6820105910301208,
0.952900767326355,
-0.4022649824619293,
0.3542366325855255,
0.32607489824295044,
0.0035007833503186703,
-0.17074427008628845,
-0.6204163432121277,
-0.2286904752254486,
-0.15605954825878143,
0.11774931102991104,
-0.019404670223593712,
-0.018693331629037857,
0.5238136053085327,
0.3831331133842468,
0.5625214576721191,
-0.4957534670829773,
-0.22958825528621674,
-0.0528547428548336,
-0.3041813373565674,
0.1977602243423462,
0.09480829536914825,
0.12272176146507263,
0.14674580097198486,
-0.4333421289920807,
0.30051523447036743,
-0.953454315662384,
0.09369844198226929,
0.11406739056110382,
-0.019000664353370667,
0.15535007417201996,
0.40973329544067383,
-0.20053717494010925,
0.6253876090049744,
0.42395931482315063,
-0.44230613112449646,
0.0130281588062644,
-0.4237040877342224,
-0.5130183696746826,
-0.09895158559083939,
0.6619800329208374,
0.00010294515232089907,
0.014909448102116585,
-0.17747388780117035,
-0.10523650795221329,
-0.1173180341720581,
0.1519007533788681,
-0.7762893438339233,
-0.24176587164402008,
0.3173066973686218,
-0.3848607540130615,
-0.1425093710422516,
-0.4943178594112396,
-0.5909289717674255,
-0.04739779978990555,
-0.22387386858463287,
0.554807186126709,
-0.3185124099254608,
0.05256740748882294,
0.15217998623847961,
0.41252362728118896,
0.22562099993228912,
0.38324448466300964,
-1.0050441026687622,
0.39637479186058044,
0.7127982974052429,
0.8834916949272156,
0.027312397956848145,
-0.2063823789358139,
-1.0899633169174194,
0.2784392535686493,
-0.31420037150382996,
0.5000888109207153,
-0.5081580877304077,
0.05487285181879997,
-0.06529151648283005,
0.02085077203810215,
-0.15215051174163818,
-0.5101780891418457,
0.31139129400253296,
-0.6163020133972168,
-0.04655343294143677,
-0.2975955903530121,
-0.17563892900943756,
0.08302292227745056,
0.2773788273334503,
-0.5129083395004272,
1.2774429321289062,
0.14341546595096588,
-1.1096155643463135,
0.19956667721271515,
-0.26461324095726013,
-0.5838590264320374,
0.4484280049800873,
-0.23423349857330322,
-0.5881027579307556,
-0.005918041802942753,
0.3756692111492157,
0.15802446007728577,
-0.3186991214752197,
0.0730174332857132,
-0.3530689477920532,
-0.6645548939704895,
-0.19831633567810059,
-0.026051441207528114,
0.5614756345748901,
0.10632064938545227,
-0.6313064694404602,
0.551880419254303,
-0.5394108891487122,
-0.09916970878839493,
0.20927207171916962,
-0.5381679534912109,
-0.4854006767272949,
0.048250939697027206,
0.06893579661846161,
0.14281240105628967,
0.42097601294517517,
-0.5854848623275757,
0.17661826312541962,
-0.6206767559051514,
0.662696897983551,
0.5302857756614685,
0.11480648070573807,
0.47764599323272705,
-0.370978444814682,
0.8122473359107971,
-0.28661465644836426,
0.2923760712146759,
-0.32839664816856384,
-0.14555802941322327,
-0.6209291219711304,
-0.5828442573547363,
0.1856618970632553,
0.4774424731731415,
-0.4237346649169922,
0.470452219247818,
-0.22206901013851166,
0.135994553565979,
-0.7505130767822266,
0.14672397077083588,
0.2923942804336548,
0.42131757736206055,
0.11489613354206085,
-0.2323671579360962,
-0.5135376453399658,
-0.7402550578117371,
0.01669558882713318,
-0.12672220170497894,
-0.04836249351501465,
0.626118004322052,
0.2402254343032837,
-0.042584918439388275,
0.9233403205871582,
-0.31199535727500916,
-0.3268272280693054,
-0.2340659499168396,
-0.06370513141155243,
-0.025720184668898582,
0.3249272406101227,
0.33550018072128296,
-0.6831080317497253,
-0.20684845745563507,
-0.3222823143005371,
-0.2701450288295746,
-0.14906549453735352,
-0.3739977180957794,
-0.11186625063419342,
0.030573420226573944,
0.4845297336578369,
-1.0232986211776733,
0.322953999042511,
0.33601081371307373,
0.030303938314318657,
0.5992941856384277,
-0.23562082648277283,
-0.01838642917573452,
-0.8849006295204163,
0.2700205147266388,
-0.03615231439471245,
-0.3905128538608551,
-0.31281915307044983,
0.21825499832630157,
-0.023476896807551384,
-0.4067528247833252,
-0.3701448440551758,
0.34265002608299255,
-0.6899059414863586,
-0.37474364042282104,
-0.21736030280590057,
0.028674783185124397,
0.11283034831285477,
0.813984215259552,
0.1405390352010727,
0.5339663028717041,
0.4483528733253479,
-0.4646012485027313,
0.29962578415870667,
-0.013138164766132832,
-0.4021156132221222,
0.09900694340467453,
-0.6513640880584717,
0.14864730834960938,
-0.18696947395801544,
0.381775438785553,
-1.3866922855377197,
-0.12699468433856964,
0.3826759159564972,
-0.3521522879600525,
0.44102469086647034,
-0.22949562966823578,
-0.4732981324195862,
-0.35539475083351135,
-0.5473588109016418,
0.81413334608078,
0.20430539548397064,
-0.3338722884654999,
0.3855802118778229,
0.40992942452430725,
-0.4575972855091095,
-0.9182784557342529,
-0.3975299000740051,
0.06187266483902931,
-0.30179914832115173,
-0.5005322694778442,
0.4655643701553345,
-0.24352169036865234,
0.03206227719783783,
-0.044387031346559525,
-0.3781794607639313,
0.023094182834029198,
0.03590448200702667,
0.042902301996946335,
0.18516266345977783,
-0.3010047376155853,
0.195437952876091,
0.08969353139400482,
0.030051246285438538,
0.04836104065179825,
-0.45440873503685,
0.5088317394256592,
0.03902699425816536,
-0.07983773946762085,
-0.6494845151901245,
0.5992535948753357,
0.9975445866584778,
-0.5158051252365112,
0.5158613324165344,
0.5319319367408752,
-0.5325227975845337,
-0.10165102779865265,
-0.3859752118587494,
-0.36609965562820435,
-0.44416141510009766,
0.613577663898468,
-0.30624920129776,
-1.2858679294586182,
0.26829174160957336,
-0.10048941522836685,
0.31641483306884766,
-0.08376340568065643,
0.6293095350265503,
0.12444256246089935,
1.0111596584320068,
0.6666296720504761,
-0.40847358107566833,
0.6221567392349243,
-0.1367621272802353,
0.49486446380615234,
-0.8818922638893127,
-0.1364707201719284,
-0.3157446086406708,
-0.4642174541950226,
-0.36796292662620544,
-0.5145142078399658,
0.33114147186279297,
0.0115787573158741,
-0.12689879536628723,
0.011041366495192051,
-0.5705571174621582,
0.40345707535743713,
0.30399465560913086,
0.015130349434912205,
0.13450120389461517,
-0.007114857900887728,
0.0882374718785286,
-0.23945677280426025,
-0.8345207571983337,
-0.010888073593378067,
0.6666338443756104,
0.7324603796005249,
0.9502061605453491,
-0.27513328194618225,
0.5919833779335022,
0.05353561043739319,
-0.059429045766592026,
-1.2250813245773315,
0.6143555045127869,
0.3516567647457123,
-0.45268431305885315,
-0.5949483513832092,
-0.45085039734840393,
-0.9812687635421753,
0.4228426516056061,
-0.16089600324630737,
-0.6030043959617615,
0.20654301345348358,
0.35885071754455566,
-0.9210977554321289,
0.20494714379310608,
-0.3784928619861603,
0.9025321006774902,
-0.14009279012680054,
-0.9553481340408325,
-0.38036441802978516,
-0.8270436525344849,
0.2662842571735382,
-0.03565744310617447,
0.2105473428964615,
-0.22090788185596466,
-0.2955985963344574,
0.5989428162574768,
-0.3504004180431366,
0.8417821526527405,
-0.10123623162508011,
0.0015362565172836185,
0.1750389188528061,
0.07968906313180923,
0.5897125601768494,
0.12596027553081512,
0.615115225315094,
-0.3087747097015381,
0.034028761088848114,
-0.5367058515548706,
-0.17590336501598358,
0.8160620331764221,
-0.6279911994934082,
-0.6445111036300659,
-0.48446768522262573,
-1.1247668266296387,
-0.27062007784843445,
0.11955545097589493,
0.03812738135457039,
0.41987383365631104,
0.07873718440532684,
0.29429516196250916,
0.9938386678695679,
-0.2986656427383423,
0.28566890954971313,
0.280292272567749,
-0.06485240906476974,
-0.36684155464172363,
0.5746419429779053,
0.06204729154706001,
0.11085111647844315,
0.8188034296035767,
0.23565135896205902,
-0.3130508363246918,
-0.7864601612091064,
-0.17196297645568848,
0.5168565511703491,
-0.1851934790611267,
-0.1566982865333557,
-0.7789885997772217,
-0.01204163208603859,
-0.5455315709114075,
0.06545194983482361,
-0.2065931111574173,
-0.36468151211738586,
-0.07168898731470108,
0.03805438056588173,
0.22083278000354767,
0.26729366183280945,
0.10337251424789429,
0.29519882798194885,
-0.6106612682342529,
0.5915411710739136,
0.5096745491027832,
0.058967091143131256,
0.02735777385532856,
-0.5339752435684204,
-0.3802596628665924,
-0.25531622767448425,
-0.3236353397369385,
-0.587674617767334,
0.6320635676383972,
0.3511110544204712,
0.2625412046909332,
0.3124646842479706,
0.23854553699493408,
0.9530542492866516,
-0.6874616742134094,
0.34495821595191956,
0.15961720049381256,
-0.6682076454162598,
0.4944760203361511,
-0.5616443157196045,
0.6403275728225708,
0.40813493728637695,
0.5982680320739746,
-0.30582669377326965,
-0.43166089057922363,
-0.3590342700481415,
-1.1327590942382812,
0.834924578666687,
-0.014886217191815376,
-0.07228481024503708,
0.0036326171830296516,
0.6018071174621582,
-0.16910627484321594,
0.12996463477611542,
-0.6962722539901733,
-0.04729773476719856,
0.11314839124679565,
-0.05064398795366287,
0.1502782106399536,
-0.4892385005950928,
-0.06269713491201401,
-0.4073646366596222,
0.5466938018798828,
-0.08573891967535019,
0.1874563843011856,
0.4296475350856781,
-0.04286809265613556,
-0.5298550128936768,
0.23977972567081451,
0.3293881118297577,
0.7684598565101624,
-0.41571375727653503,
0.07393304258584976,
-0.02141808718442917,
-0.5140243768692017,
-0.09519347548484802,
0.22702480852603912,
-0.265392541885376,
-0.039196595549583435,
0.07568246871232986,
0.6677248477935791,
0.5279178023338318,
-0.6311014890670776,
0.4384102523326874,
0.03447265923023224,
-0.2544229030609131,
-0.0973493829369545,
-0.4043031930923462,
0.16884168982505798,
0.0772206261754036,
0.5666474103927612,
-0.1445700079202652,
0.24912163615226746,
-0.6749016046524048,
0.28319647908210754,
0.39691734313964844,
-0.3061935305595398,
-0.3477141261100769,
0.8220282196998596,
0.18873047828674316,
-0.20958314836025238,
0.31640276312828064,
0.26686352491378784,
-0.32528257369995117,
0.346123069524765,
0.5780527591705322,
0.6944358944892883,
-0.47894805669784546,
-0.040284667164087296,
0.40628454089164734,
0.38736870884895325,
0.2493857443332672,
0.019315309822559357,
-0.5992358922958374,
-0.2508396506309509,
-1.041783094406128,
-0.7766041159629822,
-0.1873515099287033,
0.8186153769493103,
-0.458426296710968,
-0.13990384340286255,
-0.7539850473403931,
-0.1658754199743271,
-0.014989678747951984,
0.3975200951099396,
-0.056378837674856186,
0.16253434121608734,
0.15257567167282104,
0.708987832069397,
-0.6916761994361877,
1.1111620664596558,
0.7008206248283386,
-0.037611279636621475,
-0.5475873947143555,
0.23273548483848572,
-0.23944950103759766,
-0.6014046669006348,
0.3439185619354248,
0.3160260319709778,
-0.25993582606315613,
0.07196277379989624,
-0.4850483536720276,
-0.8969613909721375,
0.8667372465133667,
0.6575941443443298,
-0.9881578087806702,
-0.4409428834915161,
-0.09360050410032272,
0.295045405626297,
-0.2976049780845642,
-0.15704825520515442,
0.5046356916427612,
0.04092852771282196,
0.33058226108551025,
-0.9399815201759338,
0.04229801148176193,
-0.1495170146226883,
-0.11490828543901443,
0.4110904932022095,
-0.814418613910675,
0.6830414533615112,
-0.4715486764907837,
-0.3343275189399719,
0.2177458107471466,
0.6414994597434998,
0.47023528814315796,
0.23111945390701294,
0.5936459898948669,
0.6137526631355286,
0.6607087254524231,
0.13810595870018005,
0.8843795657157898,
-0.4404449760913849,
0.3153308928012848,
0.9848951697349548,
-0.2779335677623749,
0.7291944622993469,
0.6979442238807678,
-0.06536556035280228,
0.1481105089187622,
0.9391556978225708,
0.6227145195007324,
0.7663850784301758,
0.3291625678539276,
-0.5356225371360779,
-0.6490695476531982,
-0.170917809009552,
-0.19014810025691986,
-0.13336145877838135,
0.33778831362724304,
-0.007307139690965414,
-0.09983710944652557,
0.0015851781936362386,
-0.04175538569688797,
-0.011744560673832893,
-0.45271700620651245,
0.6204510927200317,
0.25416991114616394,
-0.6889945268630981,
0.8718649744987488,
-0.23986102640628815,
0.6018086075782776,
-0.7652254700660706,
-0.03396250307559967,
-0.15517860651016235,
0.387105256319046,
-0.1196366399526596,
-0.2649908661842346,
0.2055707722902298,
-0.2752702534198761,
-0.23145791888237,
-0.24440622329711914,
0.6682552695274353,
-0.5879369378089905,
-0.05562987178564072,
0.28300145268440247,
0.09861068427562714,
0.09995419532060623,
-0.19283343851566315,
-0.821437656879425,
0.23268388211727142,
-0.06613800674676895,
-0.2745791971683502,
0.7048789262771606,
0.520435631275177,
-0.17736507952213287,
0.7313269972801208,
0.5772020816802979,
0.033941805362701416,
0.1296210139989853,
0.03987104818224907,
0.9778836369514465,
-0.457773894071579,
-0.7399278283119202,
-0.5050322413444519,
0.07275354862213135,
0.3138313889503479,
-0.04255857691168785,
0.53642338514328,
0.646842896938324,
0.5495683550834656,
0.12285095453262329,
0.5980029702186584,
0.07301558554172516,
0.5313997864723206,
-0.13718166947364807,
0.3824506998062134,
-0.6376158595085144,
0.19078777730464935,
-0.1587068885564804,
-0.9937266111373901,
-0.27426064014434814,
0.6735615730285645,
-0.3892982304096222,
-0.04236316308379173,
0.7570667266845703,
0.622178852558136,
-0.07274063676595688,
-0.5105474591255188,
0.4696041941642761,
0.3079606592655182,
0.020278319716453552,
1.114388108253479,
0.7533286809921265,
-0.29940569400787354,
0.8372418880462646,
-0.2369706779718399,
-0.5202293992042542,
-0.3828433156013489,
-0.6414834260940552,
-0.7214849591255188,
-0.3986097574234009,
-0.44965553283691406,
-0.11627930402755737,
0.32089224457740784,
0.6467453241348267,
0.9429984092712402,
-0.6025479435920715,
-0.06767769157886505,
0.004923804197460413,
-0.018376749008893967,
-0.26310086250305176,
-0.22631295025348663,
0.5874988436698914,
-0.4734548330307007,
-0.7018438577651978,
0.4255146384239197,
0.6685510873794556,
-0.27466410398483276,
-0.2615496516227722,
-0.06884851306676865,
-0.4168836176395416,
-0.025335809215903282,
0.7558338642120361,
0.5872310996055603,
-0.7333972454071045,
-0.3182952105998993,
0.17303594946861267,
-0.04319442808628082,
0.26990944147109985,
0.849064290523529,
-0.9189732670783997,
0.26534008979797363,
0.5995286107063293,
0.7530868053436279,
0.6423654556274414,
0.2076483815908432,
0.3455435037612915,
-0.8468611240386963,
0.38190701603889465,
0.5457582473754883,
0.3538701832294464,
0.26293113827705383,
-0.5338735580444336,
0.013073911890387535,
0.47811123728752136,
-0.8205414414405823,
-0.7769345641136169,
0.2875804901123047,
-1.296576738357544,
-0.17847371101379395,
1.0402417182922363,
-0.21950535476207733,
-0.6138197183609009,
-0.4535317122936249,
-0.4176522195339203,
0.08330410718917847,
-0.3674274981021881,
0.8200896382331848,
0.2792380452156067,
-0.049477167427539825,
-0.45656394958496094,
-0.5320569276809692,
0.5595926642417908,
0.8069533705711365,
-0.5026175379753113,
0.549956738948822,
0.7554435729980469,
0.3124402165412903,
0.0546468049287796,
0.9127019643783569,
-0.26092272996902466,
0.5841560363769531,
-0.20730283856391907,
-0.1105450764298439,
0.05124427378177643,
-0.5878204703330994,
-0.3486758768558502,
0.4321679174900055,
0.15199333429336548,
-0.4466822147369385
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15465v1
|
RadEx: A Framework for Structured Information Extraction from Radiology Reports based on Large Language Models
| 2024-06-14T08:17:44 | 2024-06-14T08:17:44 |
Daniel Reichenpfader, Jonas Knupp, André Sander, Kerstin Denecke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, J.3
|
Annually and globally, over three billion radiography examinations and
computer tomography scans result in mostly unstructured radiology reports
containing free text. Despite the potential benefits of structured reporting,
its adoption is limited by factors such as established processes, resource
constraints and potential loss of information. However, structured information
would be necessary for various use cases, including automatic analysis,
clinical trial matching, and prediction of health outcomes. This study
introduces RadEx, an end-to-end framework comprising 15 software components and
ten artifacts to develop systems that perform automated information extraction
from radiology reports. It covers the complete process from annotating training
data to extracting information by offering a consistent generic information
model and setting boundaries for model development. Specifically, RadEx allows
clinicians to define relevant information for clinical domains (e.g.,
mammography) and to create report templates. The framework supports both
generative and encoder-only models and the decoupling of information extraction
from template filling enables independent model improvements. Developing
information extraction systems according to the RadEx framework facilitates
implementation and maintenance as components are easily exchangeable, while
standardized artifacts ensure interoperability between components.
|
[
-0.16282936930656433,
-0.7585282325744629,
0.964776337146759,
0.1148081123828888,
-0.2218206375837326,
-0.14722515642642975,
-0.07893379032611847,
-0.7226131558418274,
0.0986015796661377,
0.5947235822677612,
-0.19994133710861206,
-0.677910327911377,
-0.9021009206771851,
0.19178563356399536,
-0.3853238821029663,
0.8060621023178101,
-0.18517832458019257,
0.020738385617733,
-0.3088649809360504,
0.06527336686849594,
-0.5782774686813354,
-0.06540372222661972,
-0.2920459806919098,
-0.6775691509246826,
0.38926252722740173,
0.4978184103965759,
0.8788878321647644,
1.1361174583435059,
0.6399258375167847,
0.15901774168014526,
0.3248967230319977,
-0.12254709005355835,
-0.05533191189169884,
0.3916231691837311,
-0.15602290630340576,
-0.04505999758839607,
-0.6853824257850647,
-0.06338277459144592,
0.3763260543346405,
0.8172767162322998,
-0.3269123136997223,
-0.0010158246150240302,
-0.07096395641565323,
0.40808308124542236,
-0.9761326909065247,
0.5981130599975586,
0.22741322219371796,
0.14144407212734222,
-0.1112532690167427,
-0.43631911277770996,
-0.5136550068855286,
-0.47655802965164185,
0.04052089527249336,
-0.7514340877532959,
-0.19804206490516663,
-0.20388738811016083,
1.0847957134246826,
-0.023550765588879585,
-0.2537698447704315,
-0.4114563763141632,
-0.8890230059623718,
0.5720410346984863,
-0.5094196796417236,
0.022938184440135956,
0.5618150234222412,
0.5559782385826111,
-0.008355269208550453,
-0.9530327320098877,
-0.0067230346612632275,
0.34560319781303406,
-0.14301654696464539,
0.43905991315841675,
-0.5994687676429749,
0.1207108274102211,
0.21392232179641724,
0.38976040482521057,
-0.6586024165153503,
0.05322656407952309,
-0.34439826011657715,
0.05410794913768768,
0.6036655306816101,
0.33370405435562134,
0.7571535110473633,
-0.15895546972751617,
-0.4373428225517273,
-0.3245665431022644,
-0.6709019541740417,
-0.5173011422157288,
-0.3468165397644043,
0.18930593132972717,
-0.2726364731788635,
0.6304906010627747,
-0.22666625678539276,
0.6037991046905518,
-0.35561567544937134,
-0.13108135759830475,
0.2356746792793274,
0.0998622253537178,
-0.3834816515445709,
0.2843512296676636,
0.5202580094337463,
0.16395412385463715,
-0.015120251104235649,
-0.19000527262687683,
-0.48608121275901794,
0.18543604016304016,
0.06165183335542679,
-0.832166314125061,
-0.1630997210741043,
0.26731613278388977,
-0.9265224933624268,
-0.3705143928527832,
0.2986578345298767,
-1.0110433101654053,
-0.29380476474761963,
-0.49941086769104004,
0.38808321952819824,
-0.4299633800983429,
-0.7110364437103271,
0.6931682825088501,
-0.204473078250885,
0.35541898012161255,
0.5653809905052185,
-0.35622286796569824,
0.5346530675888062,
0.5973560214042664,
0.7416934967041016,
-0.23196925222873688,
0.46811842918395996,
-0.8271593451499939,
0.3643835484981537,
-0.23026245832443237,
1.1267189979553223,
-1.121496319770813,
-0.5581777095794678,
-0.0674796998500824,
0.020394209772348404,
-0.056879039853811264,
-0.5415571331977844,
0.3567940294742584,
-0.4599388539791107,
0.17236492037773132,
0.17214465141296387,
-0.4243840277194977,
-0.24629336595535278,
-0.0032386507373303175,
-0.8112999796867371,
0.9640166163444519,
0.31538358330726624,
-0.6938257217407227,
0.11386681348085403,
-0.4699556231498718,
-0.3949865996837616,
0.34396597743034363,
-0.5961799025535583,
-0.24217315018177032,
0.19036193192005157,
0.3342154026031494,
0.39252549409866333,
-0.7721600532531738,
0.15562088787555695,
-0.1371041238307953,
-0.1782902628183365,
-0.07926663756370544,
0.16072125732898712,
0.6466774940490723,
0.5866860747337341,
-0.048373471945524216,
0.10784772783517838,
-0.9117838740348816,
0.1733483523130417,
0.32097184658050537,
-0.3293062448501587,
-0.7280524373054504,
-0.17576844990253448,
0.441562682390213,
0.32629895210266113,
-0.02523154579102993,
-0.8037389516830444,
0.1593180149793625,
-0.27045103907585144,
0.13452482223510742,
0.5241379737854004,
0.07308931648731232,
0.34784072637557983,
-0.34424394369125366,
1.112031102180481,
-0.0013658317038789392,
0.19610880315303802,
-0.33144304156303406,
-0.318221777677536,
-0.18906965851783752,
-0.6474824547767639,
0.3389422297477722,
0.5888106226921082,
-0.4376744329929352,
0.1381228119134903,
-0.5363050103187561,
-0.21548908948898315,
-0.017526965588331223,
-0.3444761037826538,
0.38143694400787354,
0.4854121506214142,
-0.013478932902216911,
-0.6019898056983948,
-0.6332546472549438,
-0.7389395236968994,
0.41913968324661255,
0.3621356189250946,
-0.12628008425235748,
0.11928875744342804,
0.2333480417728424,
-0.24530315399169922,
1.0498796701431274,
-0.9530327916145325,
-0.4435456097126007,
-0.40433961153030396,
0.4760705530643463,
0.20911180973052979,
0.19890739023685455,
0.32383662462234497,
-0.5495820045471191,
-0.262069970369339,
0.30106016993522644,
-1.2090131044387817,
-0.06089945510029793,
0.17617152631282806,
-0.043885983526706696,
-0.1549547165632248,
0.6008118987083435,
-0.1532663106918335,
0.7581741809844971,
0.30107277631759644,
-0.02200484275817871,
0.3208617568016052,
-0.574083149433136,
-0.09763750433921814,
-1.1535754203796387,
0.40333014726638794,
0.04199937358498573,
-0.29221296310424805,
-0.07905581593513489,
-0.12207090109586716,
0.0868677943944931,
-0.5387547612190247,
0.08809588104486465,
0.5075563192367554,
-0.7663030624389648,
-0.26742023229599,
-0.38360393047332764,
-0.1429845243692398,
0.2305593192577362,
-0.10673002153635025,
0.466734379529953,
0.4970478117465973,
0.6509661078453064,
-0.31648609042167664,
0.038123514503240585,
0.3534126281738281,
-0.4952642321586609,
0.2738215923309326,
-0.625209629535675,
0.33601680397987366,
-0.41470661759376526,
0.04385923594236374,
-0.5437537431716919,
-0.3657028377056122,
-0.05484694615006447,
-0.2521985173225403,
0.42645516991615295,
-0.18849028646945953,
-0.34138986468315125,
0.08680299669504166,
-0.09359478950500488,
0.23438730835914612,
0.3784424364566803,
-0.1733148843050003,
0.86874920129776,
0.8793874979019165,
-0.5374699234962463,
-0.6308467984199524,
-0.41844066977500916,
0.3864799737930298,
0.1597958505153656,
-0.6295064687728882,
0.24319058656692505,
0.12916290760040283,
-0.5135826468467712,
0.33860814571380615,
-0.021907946094870567,
-0.5573242902755737,
-0.05313887447118759,
0.4745141565799713,
0.3659924566745758,
-0.5139697194099426,
-0.06815791130065918,
-0.13476243615150452,
-0.5787310004234314,
0.05841263383626938,
0.05772505700588226,
0.24341487884521484,
0.12367092072963715,
-0.12966866791248322,
-0.18789437413215637,
0.9430350661277771,
0.46953141689300537,
-0.31368163228034973,
0.11155804246664047,
0.17195220291614532,
-0.7906173467636108,
-0.3384071886539459,
-0.28353750705718994,
-0.19449250400066376,
-0.2891462445259094,
0.4314078688621521,
-0.45149675011634827,
-0.3982284963130951,
0.4934414029121399,
-0.2732384502887726,
0.024065669625997543,
0.34878891706466675,
0.2680678963661194,
0.27774307131767273,
1.2795151472091675,
1.114825963973999,
0.27582719922065735,
0.14062899351119995,
0.06788475811481476,
-0.045659538358449936,
-0.4945131540298462,
-0.33353525400161743,
-0.6106136441230774,
0.3399168848991394,
0.1783917099237442,
-0.07452871650457382,
0.5766160488128662,
-0.3405497670173645,
0.26154160499572754,
0.027105335146188736,
-0.7428302764892578,
0.3780343532562256,
0.07301104813814163,
0.03265860304236412,
0.47701236605644226,
0.2196265012025833,
0.09943412989377975,
-0.1844054013490677,
-0.6289627552032471,
-0.4936630129814148,
1.2036288976669312,
0.15083086490631104,
1.3069019317626953,
0.09516413509845734,
0.3822205662727356,
0.533395528793335,
0.2666352689266205,
-0.6887878775596619,
0.2937115430831909,
-0.2218867987394333,
-0.21102724969387054,
0.248493030667305,
0.058911338448524475,
-1.0635883808135986,
-0.1483292281627655,
-0.2873419523239136,
-0.27372094988822937,
0.579456627368927,
-0.4435053765773773,
-0.6742814779281616,
-0.09041329473257065,
-0.34338510036468506,
0.475443035364151,
0.21502619981765747,
-0.12678657472133636,
-0.2600240409374237,
-0.5889419317245483,
0.12009270489215851,
-0.08232901990413666,
0.5128034353256226,
-0.21229253709316254,
0.02512618526816368,
0.591388463973999,
-0.40928372740745544,
0.6468398571014404,
0.10953601449728012,
-0.03425130248069763,
-0.14372506737709045,
0.3913520574569702,
0.23393218219280243,
0.030703440308570862,
0.07378029078245163,
0.15667010843753815,
0.3860545754432678,
0.06012311205267906,
-0.5528941750526428,
0.3010408282279968,
-0.7022920250892639,
0.0011811277363449335,
-0.9017699360847473,
-0.6032335162162781,
0.05925316736102104,
0.24359454214572906,
0.08813049644231796,
0.857089102268219,
-0.09355142712593079,
0.008940467610955238,
0.7065186500549316,
-0.3787197470664978,
0.10324076563119888,
0.6821204423904419,
-0.06446059048175812,
-0.38529321551322937,
0.6751601696014404,
-0.0741102322936058,
-0.10321447253227234,
0.5595824718475342,
0.3076290786266327,
0.002700885757803917,
-0.3960578441619873,
-0.1982467919588089,
0.132032111287117,
-0.9516217708587646,
-0.4987283945083618,
-0.48074182868003845,
-0.5087870955467224,
-0.2745840847492218,
-0.2287963479757309,
-0.4757213890552521,
-0.3648555874824524,
-0.1618041843175888,
0.022886648774147034,
0.2536289393901825,
1.2275470495224,
-0.3501075208187103,
-0.014275464229285717,
-0.8072260618209839,
-0.07817670702934265,
-0.11853603273630142,
0.19056032598018646,
-0.34289491176605225,
-0.11306554824113846,
-0.36033111810684204,
-0.6197161674499512,
0.08741462975740433,
-0.7483930587768555,
0.6866722702980042,
0.09755385667085648,
0.47167763113975525,
0.5141626596450806,
0.13202844560146332,
0.5548275709152222,
-0.2087050825357437,
0.10381381958723068,
0.2624465227127075,
-0.579771876335144,
0.8900242447853088,
-0.3559444546699524,
0.12090276926755905,
0.17481881380081177,
-0.036227427423000336,
-0.40421196818351746,
-0.1786077618598938,
-0.40848714113235474,
-0.9932650327682495,
0.8605906367301941,
-0.268736332654953,
-0.37293878197669983,
-0.24431872367858887,
0.5939542651176453,
0.36352595686912537,
-0.374270498752594,
-0.4151148200035095,
0.11739307641983032,
0.09956903010606766,
-0.44868260622024536,
0.3872242569923401,
-0.5380284786224365,
-0.5639976263046265,
0.09110264480113983,
0.34712520241737366,
-0.18055152893066406,
0.3891560435295105,
0.41645219922065735,
-0.47879788279533386,
-0.16280518472194672,
0.21489349007606506,
0.3909199833869934,
1.1575080156326294,
-0.4326401948928833,
0.37017911672592163,
-0.5591844320297241,
-0.829948365688324,
-0.10976878553628922,
0.07083812355995178,
-0.039175763726234436,
0.029073888435959816,
0.36847588419914246,
0.24656502902507782,
0.3406434953212738,
-0.7766710519790649,
0.6341122388839722,
-0.3307993710041046,
-0.23597349226474762,
-0.6379244327545166,
0.04730326682329178,
-0.4009842574596405,
0.10504350811243057,
0.2992090880870819,
-0.05695997178554535,
0.1788974404335022,
-0.004760573618113995,
0.6200627684593201,
0.22815309464931488,
-0.5585326552391052,
-0.3667641878128052,
0.8020879030227661,
-0.026829486712813377,
0.40009579062461853,
0.696876049041748,
0.36341869831085205,
0.48806649446487427,
0.6433156132698059,
0.5616796016693115,
0.7667458057403564,
-0.16840481758117676,
0.262494832277298,
0.7399811148643494,
0.1268877238035202,
-0.23801197111606598,
0.22216452658176422,
0.09886737167835236,
-0.4864933490753174,
-0.6319253444671631,
-0.4334218204021454,
-0.2070327252149582,
0.12551476061344147,
-1.1762709617614746,
0.4064445197582245,
-0.696696400642395,
-0.0483003593981266,
0.17266514897346497,
-0.20896276831626892,
-0.2920290231704712,
0.16318517923355103,
0.23066990077495575,
0.9333592057228088,
-0.9103946089744568,
0.9119635224342346,
0.6848645806312561,
-0.8816813230514526,
-0.550685465335846,
-0.6608073115348816,
0.18562714755535126,
-0.9429997801780701,
0.9127225279808044,
0.023433854803442955,
-0.23460517823696136,
-0.10898905992507935,
-0.45746657252311707,
-0.9399726986885071,
1.019135594367981,
0.4977155923843384,
-0.1932734251022339,
-0.23308631777763367,
0.09781140089035034,
-0.06372592598199844,
-0.6421338319778442,
0.4117923676967621,
0.2731499969959259,
0.36367136240005493,
0.3359381854534149,
-0.6388490200042725,
0.42161497473716736,
-0.4754481613636017,
-0.05299173295497894,
-0.11315272003412247,
0.30521053075790405,
0.9556189775466919,
-0.10642777383327484,
-0.633934497833252,
-0.09797203540802002,
0.3318767547607422,
-0.2399287223815918,
-0.08292459696531296,
0.17543724179267883,
0.5682400465011597,
0.4475901126861572,
-0.07782337814569473,
1.138992428779602,
-0.2751545011997223,
0.11474638432264328,
0.9067196249961853,
-0.38555416464805603,
0.6338949203491211,
0.0038506421260535717,
0.23776987195014954,
0.6402815580368042,
0.570052981376648,
0.11681917309761047,
0.48905256390571594,
-0.2920110821723938,
-0.27247560024261475,
-0.5100113749504089,
-0.0479152649641037,
-0.47686582803726196,
0.6194556951522827,
0.5889503955841064,
-0.4012812376022339,
-0.8736883997917175,
0.2365257889032364,
0.3146381378173828,
0.03912801668047905,
-0.09319821745157242,
0.9935656189918518,
0.17353595793247223,
-0.466589093208313,
0.3713923692703247,
0.2680319845676422,
0.07788778096437454,
-1.0311731100082397,
-0.4252259433269501,
-0.19718818366527557,
0.46683233976364136,
-0.4084921181201935,
-0.7509123682975769,
0.6494811177253723,
-0.21207939088344574,
-0.4019179940223694,
-0.299367219209671,
0.8410465717315674,
-0.0710606798529625,
-0.24530385434627533,
0.27757275104522705,
0.3696037232875824,
0.09787389636039734,
-0.06021279841661453,
-0.4780106246471405,
0.3252035677433014,
-0.2426968216896057,
-0.11399586498737335,
0.5936354994773865,
0.21530914306640625,
-0.2668757140636444,
0.38090988993644714,
0.5708287954330444,
0.3558594286441803,
-0.4789389967918396,
0.02678937278687954,
0.8603129386901855,
-0.6288940906524658,
-0.5327085256576538,
-0.428138792514801,
0.3116794526576996,
-0.1324005275964737,
-0.14343445003032684,
0.41152000427246094,
0.8453639149665833,
0.0368352085351944,
0.19966985285282135,
0.941139280796051,
-0.07010113447904587,
0.4459312856197357,
-0.49338090419769287,
0.7255951166152954,
-0.5061192512512207,
0.16562922298908234,
-0.17536574602127075,
-0.6671836376190186,
-0.5407387018203735,
0.7340825796127319,
-0.1957477629184723,
-0.31564784049987793,
0.8495648503303528,
0.6806250810623169,
-0.25908705592155457,
0.22202104330062866,
0.18054327368736267,
0.19574442505836487,
0.40380579233169556,
0.5512060523033142,
0.27178117632865906,
-0.2266080230474472,
0.5253195762634277,
0.04873402416706085,
-0.7435517311096191,
-0.06614319980144501,
-0.7866203188896179,
-0.3071524202823639,
-0.6803974509239197,
-0.6636500954627991,
-0.6739594340324402,
0.10320717841386795,
0.540054202079773,
0.8498165011405945,
-0.4420369565486908,
-0.2519380748271942,
0.23733313381671906,
-0.20253530144691467,
-0.21887478232383728,
-0.24531733989715576,
0.8206867575645447,
-0.23434768617153168,
-0.48541149497032166,
0.4034203290939331,
0.9328435659408569,
-0.28501415252685547,
0.11967506259679794,
0.2549448311328888,
-0.023083359003067017,
-0.11623723804950714,
0.5677163600921631,
0.6798748970031738,
-0.07701215893030167,
-0.16824929416179657,
-0.00410547386854887,
-0.3272024989128113,
0.49429598450660706,
0.6954741477966309,
-0.8112008571624756,
0.967714786529541,
0.2727982699871063,
0.4869908094406128,
0.6874508857727051,
-0.21164333820343018,
0.9288321137428284,
-0.43953102827072144,
0.3166462779045105,
0.2356766313314438,
0.1748289167881012,
0.10178479552268982,
-0.1977316439151764,
0.5084517598152161,
0.22274360060691833,
-0.22339244186878204,
-0.7097481489181519,
0.08294689655303955,
-1.1516605615615845,
-0.6034773588180542,
1.269761323928833,
0.0012925071641802788,
-0.539750874042511,
-0.5773675441741943,
0.040886010974645615,
0.05281221866607666,
-0.17216520011425018,
0.49800682067871094,
0.4147864282131195,
-0.2915695607662201,
-0.2539137899875641,
-0.8295669555664062,
0.38236382603645325,
-0.15528179705142975,
-0.9403201937675476,
-0.007483319379389286,
0.7245941162109375,
0.6295329332351685,
-0.17233894765377045,
1.0171849727630615,
-0.848949134349823,
0.3702283501625061,
-0.04913930222392082,
0.7024414539337158,
-0.2800178527832031,
-0.038946930319070816,
-0.3634055554866791,
0.4724615812301636,
-0.20779013633728027,
-0.16038857400417328
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09815v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09815v1
|
Retrieval Augmented Fact Verification by Synthesizing Contrastive Arguments
| 2024-06-14T08:13:34 | 2024-06-14T08:13:34 |
Zhenrui Yue, Huimin Zeng, Lanyu Shang, Yifan Liu, Yang Zhang, Dong Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The rapid propagation of misinformation poses substantial risks to public
interest. To combat misinformation, large language models (LLMs) are adapted to
automatically verify claim credibility. Nevertheless, existing methods heavily
rely on the embedded knowledge within LLMs and / or black-box APIs for evidence
collection, leading to subpar performance with smaller LLMs or upon unreliable
context. In this paper, we propose retrieval augmented fact verification
through the synthesis of contrasting arguments (RAFTS). Upon input claims,
RAFTS starts with evidence retrieval, where we design a retrieval pipeline to
collect and re-rank relevant documents from verifiable sources. Then, RAFTS
forms contrastive arguments (i.e., supporting or refuting) conditioned on the
retrieved evidence. In addition, RAFTS leverages an embedding model to identify
informative demonstrations, followed by in-context prompting to generate the
prediction and explanation. Our method effectively retrieves relevant documents
as evidence and evaluates arguments from varying perspectives, incorporating
nuanced information for fine-grained decision-making. Combined with informative
in-context examples as prior, RAFTS achieves significant improvements to
supervised and LLM baselines without complex prompts. We demonstrate the
effectiveness of our method through extensive experiments, where RAFTS can
outperform GPT-based methods with a significantly smaller 7B LLM.
|
[
-0.41715508699417114,
-0.8379533290863037,
0.6740351915359497,
0.08624818176031113,
-0.3934461176395416,
0.10845524817705154,
-0.08671000599861145,
-0.2513333857059479,
0.14602510631084442,
0.36482176184654236,
-0.23459848761558533,
-0.4085182249546051,
-0.5512515306472778,
0.0561431460082531,
-0.35010871291160583,
1.1874287128448486,
-0.06380812078714371,
-0.19432125985622406,
-0.41394487023353577,
-0.22522711753845215,
-0.2639872431755066,
-0.43958792090415955,
-0.4545365571975708,
-0.27668753266334534,
0.5240446925163269,
0.34077945351600647,
0.45270153880119324,
0.4863986074924469,
0.06744924187660217,
0.2946893274784088,
-0.09671139717102051,
0.6015596389770508,
-0.31479957699775696,
0.1170814111828804,
-0.3992951512336731,
-0.2978271543979645,
-0.043776411563158035,
0.10766179114580154,
0.4634837210178375,
0.2196645438671112,
0.09746714681386948,
0.1895369440317154,
0.16381652653217316,
0.4026147127151489,
-0.9322758316993713,
0.08693715929985046,
-0.803958535194397,
-0.2870175540447235,
-0.0843389555811882,
-0.16642673313617706,
-0.5846987962722778,
-0.37446263432502747,
0.34243014454841614,
-0.4952547252178192,
0.311882883310318,
0.25305163860321045,
0.91717529296875,
0.26966285705566406,
-0.6334152817726135,
-0.632457435131073,
-0.36155471205711365,
0.7016710638999939,
-0.743912935256958,
0.4518764615058899,
0.35384708642959595,
0.1290455013513565,
-0.11283696442842484,
-1.023306965827942,
-0.6922251582145691,
-0.2888815104961395,
-0.4717496335506439,
0.18388675153255463,
0.05597663298249245,
-0.2380858212709427,
0.26097872853279114,
0.31822073459625244,
-0.3719949722290039,
-0.06807108968496323,
-0.376564621925354,
-0.7729563117027283,
0.649121105670929,
-0.3550179600715637,
0.2037787288427353,
-0.49637794494628906,
-0.6567733883857727,
-0.16596682369709015,
-1.079820156097412,
0.007899361662566662,
0.3998154103755951,
0.4067697823047638,
-0.2087956666946411,
0.8395109176635742,
-0.1922704577445984,
0.5009113550186157,
0.3065125048160553,
-0.21264755725860596,
0.23331645131111145,
-0.26471224427223206,
-0.1520172506570816,
0.4693450927734375,
0.29984837770462036,
0.4936891496181488,
-0.48901766538619995,
0.12779568135738373,
-0.34445682168006897,
-0.05068637430667877,
0.052829768508672714,
-0.7743564248085022,
-0.15973933041095734,
0.383954256772995,
-0.3212410807609558,
-0.0986577495932579,
-0.2961067855358124,
-0.8055046796798706,
-0.6333445310592651,
-0.260725736618042,
0.7618621587753296,
-0.26366958022117615,
0.008261501789093018,
-0.17637737095355988,
-0.24030907452106476,
0.17531892657279968,
0.48318639397621155,
-0.4374315142631531,
-0.03579720854759216,
0.7064154148101807,
0.6974637508392334,
-0.029111772775650024,
-0.048513349145650864,
-1.071650505065918,
0.27634549140930176,
-0.29245680570602417,
1.1353577375411987,
-0.48459985852241516,
-0.07209683954715729,
0.32492321729660034,
-0.0848548635840416,
0.40365657210350037,
-0.44156962633132935,
0.9136484861373901,
-0.6846647262573242,
0.5769287943840027,
-0.38655030727386475,
-0.725631058216095,
-0.30865949392318726,
0.6512387990951538,
-0.6628058552742004,
0.9593588709831238,
-0.1789056360721588,
-0.8398070931434631,
0.4841782748699188,
-0.31875795125961304,
-0.6265459060668945,
-0.010857198387384415,
-0.15268221497535706,
-0.4375307261943817,
-0.13821649551391602,
0.5544233322143555,
0.28319886326789856,
-0.24808132648468018,
0.1770981252193451,
-0.28727465867996216,
-0.13522648811340332,
0.13854746520519257,
-0.3439907431602478,
0.5011821985244751,
0.22407689690589905,
-0.2334267497062683,
-0.15289396047592163,
-0.7359311580657959,
-0.38739657402038574,
-0.29446572065353394,
-0.8198928833007812,
-0.6040228605270386,
0.14940787851810455,
-0.27861276268959045,
0.08497767150402069,
0.2283727377653122,
-0.740572452545166,
-0.030637813732028008,
-0.3055558502674103,
0.2431126981973648,
0.6040022373199463,
0.27893251180648804,
0.0013518743216991425,
-0.3733738958835602,
-0.01780783012509346,
0.05613670498132706,
-0.21291327476501465,
-0.4194526672363281,
-0.44987162947654724,
-0.6355668902397156,
-0.5237956047058105,
0.4911404252052307,
0.3434590697288513,
-1.1576907634735107,
0.13166391849517822,
-0.09323161840438843,
-0.015256536193192005,
-0.6229734420776367,
-0.07869943976402283,
0.3038520812988281,
1.0622425079345703,
0.6671974658966064,
0.263033390045166,
-0.8485904335975647,
-0.9541250467300415,
-0.3499695658683777,
-0.5034787654876709,
-0.19429440796375275,
0.4245501458644867,
0.4201286733150482,
-0.10484055429697037,
0.8221181035041809,
-0.3541625142097473,
0.05060325562953949,
0.09009929746389389,
0.4240586459636688,
0.16481171548366547,
0.392743855714798,
0.3242044448852539,
-1.005760669708252,
-0.25561264157295227,
-0.11056946963071823,
-0.5965511202812195,
-0.24634072184562683,
-0.24429358541965485,
0.07510096579790115,
0.3639204800128937,
0.5314529538154602,
-0.6345484256744385,
0.3761416971683502,
0.2378377467393875,
-0.18671178817749023,
0.436777263879776,
-0.1612299382686615,
0.3908787667751312,
-0.774878978729248,
-0.12983988225460052,
-0.014712654985487461,
-0.3462335765361786,
-0.20925019681453705,
0.10283877700567245,
-0.03951532393693924,
0.2089143693447113,
-0.3642500340938568,
0.6401669979095459,
-0.33927232027053833,
0.06758098304271698,
-0.28658998012542725,
0.48038217425346375,
0.19079843163490295,
0.19088177382946014,
0.06951296329498291,
0.6459546089172363,
0.3247552216053009,
-0.6815836429595947,
0.24927113950252533,
0.26821306347846985,
-0.4662427306175232,
0.7780429124832153,
-0.7511091828346252,
-0.15250608325004578,
-0.09552358835935593,
0.5834213495254517,
-1.3896260261535645,
-0.26524820923805237,
0.0047590406611561775,
-0.20999382436275482,
0.1466584950685501,
-0.589323103427887,
-0.4358174800872803,
-0.20574992895126343,
-0.49818918108940125,
0.19705766439437866,
0.5075181722640991,
-1.021182894706726,
0.7761850953102112,
0.3681401312351227,
-0.36250075697898865,
-0.92158442735672,
-0.667034924030304,
0.14928103983402252,
-0.31062889099121094,
-0.4182910919189453,
0.47714027762413025,
-0.07049281150102615,
-0.4003712236881256,
0.00689304992556572,
-0.3055706024169922,
0.10671860724687576,
-0.09099742770195007,
0.20338770747184753,
0.4530574679374695,
-0.27045223116874695,
0.3162604570388794,
0.1274232715368271,
0.09383923560380936,
-0.08284228295087814,
-0.20783744752407074,
0.07934863865375519,
-0.09624946862459183,
-0.5203273296356201,
0.24209626019001007,
0.21667370200157166,
0.3857887387275696,
0.004957818426191807,
0.4869288206100464,
0.6122164726257324,
-0.32359185814857483,
-0.21774977445602417,
-1.1883808374404907,
-0.16166380047798157,
-0.416113942861557,
-0.06663916260004044,
-0.21176184713840485,
-0.9427147507667542,
0.49033477902412415,
-0.3518354296684265,
0.2907254993915558,
0.4843743145465851,
0.5692366361618042,
-0.0322798490524292,
0.5596632361412048,
-0.06477273255586624,
0.24721401929855347,
0.1742645651102066,
0.05978698283433914,
0.19630077481269836,
-0.7244204878807068,
-0.37489309906959534,
-0.37585726380348206,
-0.14312423765659332,
-0.5210882425308228,
-0.5393322110176086,
0.4255058467388153,
0.10894378274679184,
-0.21406148374080658,
0.0557602159678936,
-0.23721221089363098,
0.48616868257522583,
0.3356495499610901,
0.2891794741153717,
0.45675528049468994,
-0.00514185382053256,
-0.33752328157424927,
0.12675639986991882,
-0.46518635749816895,
-0.6099481582641602,
1.087893009185791,
0.13797439634799957,
0.31524336338043213,
0.27870598435401917,
0.7316255569458008,
0.8044003844261169,
0.6770500540733337,
-0.561915934085846,
0.46778208017349243,
0.032397326081991196,
-0.6790978312492371,
0.03870560973882675,
-0.4135333299636841,
-0.61955326795578,
0.5628935694694519,
-0.5282896161079407,
-0.5209075808525085,
0.2484765350818634,
0.17655591666698456,
-0.3585302531719208,
0.031103989109396935,
-0.8542134761810303,
0.30740928649902344,
-0.030769512057304382,
-0.731407105922699,
-0.4329312741756439,
-0.5903374552726746,
0.5285658836364746,
0.013271361589431763,
0.3135058581829071,
0.1496976912021637,
-0.1249629408121109,
0.4302096664905548,
-0.458492636680603,
0.6845071315765381,
-0.27168238162994385,
-0.29691216349601746,
0.5058743357658386,
0.07143184542655945,
0.7361552715301514,
0.2547333538532257,
-0.3323751986026764,
-0.3272567391395569,
-0.280762642621994,
-0.28276339173316956,
-0.8155922889709473,
0.9273286461830139,
-0.4462816119194031,
-0.8934378623962402,
-0.1464686393737793,
-0.34794625639915466,
-0.17320944368839264,
0.015187614597380161,
0.04544813930988312,
0.5523062944412231,
-0.20743222534656525,
0.283384770154953,
0.567050576210022,
-0.19895777106285095,
0.47336697578430176,
0.6857175230979919,
-0.08949317783117294,
-0.631237268447876,
0.8268264532089233,
0.20048075914382935,
-0.1245163306593895,
0.5976588129997253,
0.3152087926864624,
-0.7937161922454834,
-0.7906811237335205,
-0.29981422424316406,
0.08468414098024368,
-0.9055365324020386,
-0.4153561294078827,
-0.540582537651062,
0.09486135840415955,
-0.2233177274465561,
-0.09106583148241043,
-0.2936626076698303,
-0.7495425939559937,
0.2841607928276062,
-0.3937053978443146,
0.39341455698013306,
0.7619727849960327,
-0.30610477924346924,
-0.12957488000392914,
-0.6839593052864075,
0.6211547255516052,
0.613784909248352,
0.2273927628993988,
-0.1300181895494461,
-0.6297668814659119,
-0.21929247677326202,
0.114383265376091,
-0.15346427261829376,
-0.5872073769569397,
0.004640836268663406,
-0.10058147460222244,
0.7712833285331726,
0.2119165062904358,
0.4124382436275482,
0.6504790782928467,
-0.3484630584716797,
1.166603684425354,
-0.12601183354854584,
-0.9229053854942322,
0.6104274988174438,
-0.033366572111845016,
-0.46434691548347473,
0.35360488295555115,
0.4886433184146881,
0.0643715113401413,
-0.18961508572101593,
-0.8261818289756775,
-0.9782337546348572,
0.386211633682251,
0.19605527818202972,
-0.1302148848772049,
-0.0934513658285141,
0.3236224949359894,
0.15571831166744232,
0.23574650287628174,
-0.7483981847763062,
-0.049948543310165405,
-0.43885311484336853,
-0.06822546571493149,
0.1991560012102127,
-0.361553817987442,
-0.4993795156478882,
-0.025462046265602112,
0.9084975123405457,
-0.28429609537124634,
-0.18637600541114807,
0.5794982314109802,
-0.30813881754875183,
0.2560906708240509,
0.3191530704498291,
0.6174755692481995,
0.5026019215583801,
-0.3089420199394226,
0.7599917650222778,
0.24959035217761993,
-0.03713948279619217,
0.24535498023033142,
0.26570650935173035,
-0.34566035866737366,
0.16276925802230835,
0.6273347735404968,
0.5651578903198242,
0.2511844038963318,
-0.6072357296943665,
0.5577144026756287,
0.1715361326932907,
0.07314370572566986,
0.18549907207489014,
-0.2494044303894043,
0.07149728387594223,
0.5416281223297119,
0.41268277168273926,
0.037367094308137894,
0.02348458208143711,
-0.5389197468757629,
0.34718871116638184,
0.27816036343574524,
0.08182457834482193,
-0.14578285813331604,
0.2669728398323059,
0.27963653206825256,
-0.040553413331508636,
0.43445587158203125,
-0.09990264475345612,
-0.3639283776283264,
0.2626951038837433,
0.5143851041793823,
0.5798220038414001,
-0.05799810588359833,
0.2878727316856384,
0.5271896123886108,
0.1775442361831665,
-0.17786014080047607,
0.059169381856918335,
-0.18307974934577942,
-0.6882919669151306,
-0.48707568645477295,
-0.3383050262928009,
-0.5130298733711243,
0.18510882556438446,
-0.3838825523853302,
0.17115747928619385,
-0.38947707414627075,
0.03386761248111725,
-0.033771812915802,
0.038379911333322525,
-0.3167586624622345,
0.25669723749160767,
0.21150028705596924,
0.7676674723625183,
-0.8980950117111206,
0.43704667687416077,
0.7131333351135254,
-0.6833482384681702,
-0.5695995688438416,
0.23641405999660492,
0.09567487239837646,
-0.7045656442642212,
0.6966078877449036,
-0.08793623000383377,
-0.20589856803417206,
-0.41090548038482666,
-0.8209099769592285,
-0.5774174332618713,
0.936553418636322,
0.5705400109291077,
-0.3061109781265259,
0.2947906255722046,
-0.1953926682472229,
0.507081151008606,
-0.6174753308296204,
0.2770422101020813,
0.2645127475261688,
0.6341410875320435,
0.44097086787223816,
-0.5026386976242065,
0.3969241678714752,
-0.03182346373796463,
-0.22692488133907318,
-0.5047378540039062,
-0.5456548929214478,
0.8430714011192322,
-0.31917163729667664,
-0.21058696508407593,
-0.07013924419879913,
0.8874119520187378,
0.6989287734031677,
0.4771702289581299,
0.6023111939430237,
0.44534727931022644,
1.0478427410125732,
0.13537177443504333,
1.1806740760803223,
-0.07566936314105988,
0.14180493354797363,
1.329839825630188,
-0.45652827620506287,
1.1093392372131348,
0.6692754626274109,
-0.042978983372449875,
0.8953530192375183,
0.480010449886322,
0.0671176090836525,
0.6588480472564697,
0.11239390820264816,
-0.3861243426799774,
-0.4233105182647705,
-0.43897539377212524,
-0.2132735699415207,
0.19825249910354614,
0.4305129945278168,
-0.21969172358512878,
-0.4248608350753784,
-0.08649414777755737,
0.006821691989898682,
0.1848192662000656,
-0.25945499539375305,
0.7259162068367004,
-0.14201831817626953,
-0.9830004572868347,
0.7733408212661743,
-0.1550436168909073,
0.5095843076705933,
-0.44414639472961426,
-0.43445664644241333,
-0.20071028172969818,
0.14673413336277008,
-0.39059242606163025,
-0.9682056307792664,
0.1465817391872406,
0.16889381408691406,
-0.21835877001285553,
-0.09608601033687592,
0.8271977305412292,
-0.562084436416626,
-0.17999115586280823,
-0.08647556602954865,
0.5581093430519104,
-0.03659765049815178,
0.037900615483522415,
-0.3531773090362549,
0.07894208282232285,
0.10450874269008636,
-0.15918385982513428,
0.2803853452205658,
0.596401572227478,
-0.05537949502468109,
0.6311694979667664,
0.8526700735092163,
0.08201921731233597,
-0.29094699025154114,
-0.05750521644949913,
0.99140864610672,
-0.1536010205745697,
-0.363660991191864,
-0.850547730922699,
0.6261559724807739,
-0.26970037817955017,
0.13489601016044617,
0.8449204564094543,
0.7282779216766357,
0.6388854384422302,
-0.08023536950349808,
0.8488017320632935,
-0.01828397437930107,
0.6057301163673401,
-0.7279844284057617,
0.44415953755378723,
-0.37745389342308044,
0.6221184134483337,
-0.11208423227071762,
-0.5746414661407471,
-0.2411724030971527,
0.5474857091903687,
-0.2889542877674103,
-0.31555697321891785,
0.5734154582023621,
0.9018767476081848,
-0.21402880549430847,
0.09270085394382477,
0.011616374365985394,
0.45542657375335693,
0.4568367004394531,
0.23344801366329193,
1.055580496788025,
-0.5498347878456116,
0.5776619911193848,
0.07190366089344025,
0.04053114354610443,
-0.2965087294578552,
-1.4406038522720337,
-0.6965882778167725,
-0.4882028102874756,
-0.7379168272018433,
-0.6536787152290344,
0.11797472089529037,
1.0803453922271729,
0.5968941450119019,
-0.8880661129951477,
0.17268580198287964,
0.19700415432453156,
0.7080265283584595,
-0.03343195840716362,
-0.17979000508785248,
0.6049019694328308,
-0.245619997382164,
-0.33829858899116516,
0.6660845875740051,
0.04530218616127968,
0.0862974151968956,
-0.06700778007507324,
-0.0874805673956871,
-0.5244778394699097,
0.4735673666000366,
0.7206322550773621,
0.311319500207901,
-0.8119780421257019,
-0.7026509642601013,
-0.714410662651062,
0.06953869014978409,
0.03913619741797447,
0.7791426777839661,
-1.2120147943496704,
0.28532925248146057,
0.7164897918701172,
0.871869683265686,
0.7479938864707947,
0.2734907567501068,
0.44069376587867737,
-1.08551824092865,
-0.005945638287812471,
-0.026640089228749275,
0.5458642840385437,
0.7151532769203186,
-0.23914696276187897,
0.3943970501422882,
0.23388619720935822,
-0.3154873251914978,
-0.9931927919387817,
0.07299665361642838,
-0.9376266002655029,
-0.22571681439876556,
1.0976089239120483,
-0.582581639289856,
-0.006544516421854496,
-0.1882241815328598,
-0.2986427843570709,
0.14312990009784698,
-0.40716320276260376,
1.081550121307373,
0.7934527397155762,
0.095941461622715,
-0.05592014640569687,
-0.0020666581112891436,
0.5585404634475708,
0.09328161180019379,
-0.7155936360359192,
0.3257647752761841,
0.779922366142273,
0.33392438292503357,
0.4650513529777527,
0.24546079337596893,
0.00172686658333987,
0.13995003700256348,
0.20106729865074158,
-0.36891481280326843,
-0.2551465630531311,
-0.12710420787334442,
0.09035121649503708,
0.5466794967651367,
-0.16102354228496552,
-0.04257018119096756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.15126v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.15126v1
|
On LLMs-Driven Synthetic Data Generation, Curation, and Evaluation: A Survey
| 2024-06-14T07:47:09 | 2024-06-14T07:47:09 |
Lin Long, Rui Wang, Ruixuan Xiao, Junbo Zhao, Xiao Ding, Gang Chen, Haobo Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Within the evolving landscape of deep learning, the dilemma of data quantity
and quality has been a long-standing problem. The recent advent of Large
Language Models (LLMs) offers a data-centric solution to alleviate the
limitations of real-world data with synthetic data generation. However, current
investigations into this field lack a unified framework and mostly stay on the
surface. Therefore, this paper provides an organization of relevant studies
based on a generic workflow of synthetic data generation. By doing so, we
highlight the gaps within existing research and outline prospective avenues for
future study. This work aims to shepherd the academic and industrial
communities towards deeper, more methodical inquiries into the capabilities and
applications of LLMs-driven synthetic data generation.
|
[
-0.4457935690879822,
-0.8093581795692444,
0.8046037554740906,
-0.15251320600509644,
0.002946928609162569,
0.49680230021476746,
-0.4007068872451782,
-0.4928322732448578,
-0.031665172427892685,
0.5411023497581482,
-0.811042308807373,
-0.514668881893158,
-0.40560489892959595,
0.44222721457481384,
-0.6713563203811646,
0.7191195487976074,
-0.1495123952627182,
0.3022257685661316,
-0.29655569791793823,
0.0403585247695446,
-0.3503352701663971,
-0.7505112290382385,
-0.7233022451400757,
-0.44405242800712585,
0.6180727481842041,
0.2558479905128479,
0.4158709943294525,
0.46066153049468994,
0.4331151843070984,
0.3226710855960846,
-0.024758432060480118,
0.6303805112838745,
-0.7364146709442139,
0.504460334777832,
-0.22834110260009766,
-0.36697012186050415,
-0.35599836707115173,
0.14808593690395355,
0.875861406326294,
1.0707356929779053,
-0.03365320339798927,
0.2826821804046631,
0.07314537465572357,
0.859320878982544,
-0.49144163727760315,
-0.06762135773897171,
-0.671090841293335,
0.27271121740341187,
-0.17818044126033783,
-0.011302287690341473,
-0.24360014498233795,
-0.38819026947021484,
0.08731216192245483,
-0.2037467509508133,
0.41895633935928345,
-0.048940081149339676,
0.35383495688438416,
0.13450026512145996,
-0.32312506437301636,
-0.32429635524749756,
-1.1034170389175415,
0.9917165040969849,
-0.7659749984741211,
0.41839873790740967,
-0.02831195294857025,
0.4990241229534149,
-0.42691490054130554,
-1.076458215713501,
-0.7010926008224487,
-0.23769021034240723,
0.29830679297447205,
0.12487205862998962,
0.050500188022851944,
-0.29508206248283386,
0.00528749031946063,
0.8407037258148193,
-0.49347802996635437,
0.45851507782936096,
-0.5338706374168396,
0.003153678961098194,
1.0158804655075073,
0.6914078593254089,
0.0005292647401802242,
0.056227393448352814,
-0.003063095035031438,
0.01720871776342392,
-0.9909762740135193,
-0.19500230252742767,
0.5482219457626343,
0.2856660783290863,
0.1097208559513092,
0.8149049282073975,
-0.4619580805301666,
0.7078166007995605,
-0.1288141906261444,
0.20987580716609955,
0.16136696934700012,
-0.6169341802597046,
-0.23034977912902832,
-0.21602791547775269,
0.9907343983650208,
0.19412632286548615,
0.12312942743301392,
-0.12619811296463013,
-0.5017054677009583,
0.0872006043791771,
0.41072580218315125,
-0.765673041343689,
0.0035160190891474485,
0.3831031620502472,
-0.10589553415775299,
-0.6393017172813416,
-0.05937553197145462,
-0.5979840159416199,
-0.4213055372238159,
-0.8346506357192993,
-0.082541324198246,
-0.006873246282339096,
-0.37448185682296753,
0.0947348102927208,
0.17850130796432495,
0.14259842038154602,
0.14423538744449615,
-0.7229918241500854,
0.11660704016685486,
0.7960407137870789,
0.6608768701553345,
-0.701547384262085,
-0.059206608682870865,
-0.09716872125864029,
-0.08989201486110687,
-0.7295038104057312,
0.6200869083404541,
-0.5588662028312683,
-0.6642961502075195,
0.2659081518650055,
0.07199636101722717,
0.23180896043777466,
-0.8057206273078918,
0.414298951625824,
-0.4405527412891388,
0.29474762082099915,
-0.15958061814308167,
-0.6195427775382996,
0.08011448383331299,
0.4066945016384125,
-0.6154330372810364,
1.0332081317901611,
0.2085670679807663,
-0.22607973217964172,
0.4563620090484619,
-0.3811255991458893,
-0.3501276671886444,
0.17106111347675323,
-0.48769617080688477,
-0.41553565859794617,
0.3889771103858948,
0.010925433598458767,
0.5643922090530396,
-0.7269481420516968,
0.7333423495292664,
-0.3203665316104889,
-0.2508695125579834,
0.6245486736297607,
-0.6109452843666077,
0.39303719997406006,
0.44824856519699097,
-0.0660015344619751,
-0.08476696908473969,
-0.939824104309082,
0.01733514666557312,
0.21221518516540527,
-0.3342072665691376,
0.05486017465591431,
-0.0062597147189080715,
-0.14768502116203308,
0.3045057952404022,
0.20823711156845093,
-0.649948000907898,
0.3371518552303314,
-0.407127320766449,
0.7075913548469543,
0.7562289834022522,
0.2139049619436264,
0.4253185987472534,
-0.33002689480781555,
0.5467272400856018,
0.07035873830318451,
0.13764697313308716,
0.026178676635026932,
-0.1182280033826828,
-0.7608563899993896,
0.13241511583328247,
0.3550697863101959,
0.014318877831101418,
-0.6576004028320312,
0.2849397659301758,
-0.24988876283168793,
-0.8065474033355713,
-0.7921051383018494,
0.3667818605899811,
0.1636117696762085,
0.4460484981536865,
0.13968046009540558,
-0.2166987806558609,
-0.8420922756195068,
-0.8657500743865967,
0.10874392092227936,
0.15621770918369293,
-0.03732123598456383,
0.414541095495224,
0.28885617852211,
-0.7259876728057861,
0.8650417923927307,
-0.3860336244106293,
0.10935667902231216,
-0.4406680166721344,
-0.052020542323589325,
0.3690566420555115,
0.4305347204208374,
0.3067986071109772,
-0.39879128336906433,
-0.09603355824947357,
-0.12921327352523804,
-0.8366869688034058,
0.001143977395258844,
-0.08153042197227478,
-0.2347773164510727,
0.2251204252243042,
0.4930664598941803,
-0.6441030502319336,
-0.13012224435806274,
0.6510587334632874,
0.2658202052116394,
0.6617043018341064,
0.08073357492685318,
0.020859774202108383,
-1.163230299949646,
0.003224716056138277,
-0.02182742767035961,
0.14101164042949677,
-0.7074561715126038,
0.030357133597135544,
-0.34559890627861023,
-0.24321244657039642,
-0.5122169256210327,
0.5378758907318115,
-0.37557297945022583,
-0.17073553800582886,
-0.26689088344573975,
0.2799994647502899,
0.16103477776050568,
0.1951059103012085,
0.09880020469427109,
0.7079318761825562,
0.6010298132896423,
-0.7575154304504395,
0.617670476436615,
0.008246145211160183,
-0.4941040277481079,
0.44870954751968384,
-0.6916776299476624,
0.32789069414138794,
-0.1193925142288208,
0.3289864659309387,
-0.8930480480194092,
-0.399707555770874,
0.14274604618549347,
-0.3813183605670929,
0.37483757734298706,
-0.12144534289836884,
-0.675505518913269,
-0.5215193629264832,
-0.1918296217918396,
0.49548089504241943,
0.5774446725845337,
-0.5215420126914978,
0.1980494111776352,
0.49119219183921814,
-0.1169397309422493,
-0.22801680862903595,
-0.7429858446121216,
0.1665688306093216,
-0.13811318576335907,
-0.6779953837394714,
0.23120026290416718,
-0.004095117561519146,
-0.3981863260269165,
-0.29242658615112305,
-0.20398248732089996,
0.17851126194000244,
0.0601741261780262,
0.07210468500852585,
0.12416116148233414,
-0.27799221873283386,
0.01751084253191948,
0.05875755101442337,
0.013611639849841595,
0.4570668339729309,
-0.3313121199607849,
0.613593578338623,
0.13090354204177856,
-0.3815520107746124,
-0.2382114976644516,
0.276809424161911,
0.5081716179847717,
-0.08981149643659592,
0.44332778453826904,
0.555137574672699,
-0.24447529017925262,
-0.7628889083862305,
-0.41295093297958374,
-0.20128212869167328,
-0.55377197265625,
0.23279841244220734,
-0.18271751701831818,
-0.972610592842102,
0.32032111287117004,
-0.39376989006996155,
0.26119697093963623,
0.6146380305290222,
0.9201890826225281,
-0.2993992269039154,
1.0768119096755981,
0.322080135345459,
0.16990649700164795,
0.12117742747068405,
-0.7178256511688232,
0.47014254331588745,
-0.8964985013008118,
-0.46825194358825684,
-0.4118654727935791,
-0.3580172657966614,
-0.7690428495407104,
-0.2920895516872406,
0.3041943609714508,
-0.19026970863342285,
-0.21212051808834076,
0.028223587200045586,
-0.5865820646286011,
0.11473722010850906,
0.26547110080718994,
-0.01471877284348011,
0.2976829409599304,
0.002083933213725686,
0.07985624670982361,
-0.0028031060937792063,
-0.6004800200462341,
-0.6009395718574524,
1.1605337858200073,
0.28149861097335815,
0.7440028190612793,
-0.07085221260786057,
0.6491736173629761,
0.41132041811943054,
0.35153281688690186,
-0.670555591583252,
0.6079979538917542,
-0.08729737251996994,
-0.43875136971473694,
-0.3303912580013275,
-0.46341365575790405,
-1.1361911296844482,
0.03415798023343086,
-0.11824815720319748,
-0.12870430946350098,
0.16048932075500488,
-0.003120597917586565,
-0.14532294869422913,
0.2253667563199997,
-0.4171506464481354,
0.46661219000816345,
-0.4667778015136719,
-0.4563082754611969,
-0.08448663353919983,
-0.18039155006408691,
0.5500441789627075,
-0.4982663094997406,
0.18484796583652496,
-0.1887158304452896,
0.16548313200473785,
0.5981504917144775,
-0.5311027765274048,
0.7599623799324036,
-0.0015926351770758629,
-0.5451390743255615,
0.6814292073249817,
0.17778314650058746,
0.5087475180625916,
0.18506312370300293,
-0.23719842731952667,
0.22025693953037262,
-0.1270705908536911,
-0.12662556767463684,
-0.6231350898742676,
0.9341150522232056,
-0.6500584483146667,
-0.5279221534729004,
-0.1564876288175583,
-0.4244631230831146,
-0.61822909116745,
0.02316182665526867,
0.2136102020740509,
0.2133495807647705,
-0.22289283573627472,
0.2611686885356903,
0.43651214241981506,
-0.287699431180954,
0.3318568766117096,
0.4426603615283966,
-0.22941866517066956,
-0.3258473873138428,
1.1811931133270264,
0.16836665570735931,
0.26729851961135864,
0.00921004731208086,
0.030793841928243637,
-0.3289361894130707,
-0.8924777507781982,
-0.4755983054637909,
0.09729649126529694,
-0.3988024592399597,
-0.18891456723213196,
-0.39344707131385803,
-0.5148346424102783,
-0.4053976833820343,
-0.09784285724163055,
-0.5977951884269714,
-0.33856838941574097,
-0.44488874077796936,
-0.2718052864074707,
0.35340648889541626,
0.8965187072753906,
0.08418823778629303,
0.036632902920246124,
-0.7240799069404602,
0.29255563020706177,
0.24679547548294067,
0.42744800448417664,
0.12997618317604065,
-0.3813779652118683,
-0.2669200897216797,
0.40370723605155945,
-0.25698018074035645,
-0.3996015787124634,
0.5178481340408325,
-0.08521807938814163,
0.6515639424324036,
0.11251524090766907,
-0.006237593479454517,
0.4124394953250885,
-0.2607710659503937,
0.9837228655815125,
0.043282750993967056,
-0.4580797851085663,
0.41855189204216003,
-0.34758323431015015,
-0.005805117543786764,
0.4562056064605713,
0.3243691027164459,
-0.4849342107772827,
-0.3190460205078125,
-0.5329803824424744,
-1.0491615533828735,
0.21785598993301392,
0.23549383878707886,
0.4549976885318756,
0.06203262880444527,
0.3541603088378906,
0.3533080816268921,
0.40400320291519165,
-0.33339035511016846,
-0.12527531385421753,
0.07857762277126312,
-0.1627754271030426,
-0.11735227704048157,
-0.18196836113929749,
-0.03644580394029617,
-0.16975048184394836,
0.5503071546554565,
0.025546137243509293,
0.031086497008800507,
-0.059150561690330505,
-0.054618220776319504,
-0.007261649239808321,
0.23470206558704376,
0.3646741211414337,
0.7364832162857056,
0.10128296911716461,
-0.03562931716442108,
0.04641246050596237,
-0.3326195478439331,
0.2847782373428345,
-0.17932015657424927,
-0.31537359952926636,
0.0019168396247550845,
0.1365780532360077,
0.6717604398727417,
-0.2259892076253891,
-0.9658017754554749,
0.24632441997528076,
0.1253751963376999,
-0.49383944272994995,
-0.5606730580329895,
0.28098225593566895,
-0.03712061047554016,
0.21872815489768982,
0.4031871557235718,
-0.39375194907188416,
0.1670418679714203,
-0.6454249024391174,
0.13634756207466125,
0.38892751932144165,
-0.18431898951530457,
-0.20882681012153625,
0.3660416603088379,
0.23069941997528076,
-0.1133328527212143,
0.8764872550964355,
0.012229390442371368,
0.01547649409621954,
0.5957178473472595,
0.2260781079530716,
0.8542145490646362,
0.10260932892560959,
0.14752136170864105,
0.24137629568576813,
0.03217276558279991,
0.05957476794719696,
0.44007939100265503,
0.05511928349733353,
-0.6208758354187012,
-0.6211961507797241,
-0.8442301750183105,
-0.6253565549850464,
0.5642479658126831,
-0.4806255102157593,
0.13253596425056458,
-0.4818460941314697,
-0.28297269344329834,
0.011829192750155926,
0.07938138395547867,
-0.7953706383705139,
0.2861388921737671,
0.29391351342201233,
0.6368420124053955,
-0.6287052631378174,
0.6239186525344849,
0.4901314675807953,
-0.3562825918197632,
-0.3997724950313568,
-0.42019015550613403,
-0.2038540542125702,
-0.6766532063484192,
0.5568372011184692,
-0.11174067854881287,
-0.05857843905687332,
-0.15456658601760864,
-0.8892630338668823,
-0.867123007774353,
1.0621103048324585,
0.14215007424354553,
-0.7651754021644592,
-0.020630190148949623,
0.5914361476898193,
0.9031595587730408,
-0.4484977722167969,
-0.3225356638431549,
0.8482893109321594,
0.4188184440135956,
-0.0039255996234714985,
-0.3478552997112274,
-0.10180552303791046,
-0.36299780011177063,
0.19040465354919434,
0.043087687343358994,
-0.6250270009040833,
0.5508669018745422,
0.023128140717744827,
-0.17236822843551636,
0.07881438732147217,
0.6638995409011841,
0.5244921445846558,
0.2844178378582001,
-0.04314928129315376,
0.4623933732509613,
0.5755836963653564,
-0.20049230754375458,
0.9580957293510437,
-0.2711203992366791,
0.14920620620250702,
1.0951759815216064,
-0.4507593810558319,
0.5826553106307983,
0.4652023911476135,
-0.40705016255378723,
0.33232957124710083,
0.8965966105461121,
-0.5723356008529663,
0.2999905049800873,
0.7421574592590332,
-0.31962263584136963,
-0.13910195231437683,
-0.31114476919174194,
-0.26550447940826416,
0.3378930389881134,
0.5905729532241821,
-0.5280531644821167,
0.020268304273486137,
-0.09600869566202164,
-0.28614377975463867,
0.031043360009789467,
-0.1910206824541092,
0.8142290711402893,
0.12852507829666138,
-0.7660681009292603,
0.5649679899215698,
0.08035817742347717,
0.5069267749786377,
-0.2851860225200653,
-0.07268472760915756,
-0.5621246695518494,
-0.031317584216594696,
-0.28723305463790894,
-1.0332478284835815,
0.2676113545894623,
0.02905888296663761,
-0.16806219518184662,
-0.35900166630744934,
0.38998714089393616,
-0.3983033001422882,
-0.5401191115379333,
-0.011555030941963196,
0.7940680980682373,
0.21121710538864136,
0.23581671714782715,
-0.45822614431381226,
0.2771092653274536,
-0.1800435334444046,
-0.3066035807132721,
0.34028610587120056,
0.5515360236167908,
0.08890751749277115,
0.7454583048820496,
0.9355508685112,
0.15642501413822174,
0.16859211027622223,
0.36264529824256897,
0.8637709021568298,
-0.5725825428962708,
0.09081742912530899,
-0.7678462862968445,
0.5261207222938538,
0.020779652521014214,
-0.3085692524909973,
0.7034325003623962,
0.6517155170440674,
1.2170099020004272,
-0.13522809743881226,
1.0610134601593018,
0.157439187169075,
0.42942380905151367,
-0.6075109839439392,
0.511365532875061,
-0.40060922503471375,
0.3982495665550232,
-0.05400301143527031,
-0.9327282905578613,
-0.127878800034523,
0.11382859945297241,
-0.0952085331082344,
0.09619607031345367,
0.2931487262248993,
0.7483203411102295,
0.04139561951160431,
-0.10356583446264267,
0.21862642467021942,
0.16455097496509552,
0.3662245273590088,
0.4123550057411194,
1.1650625467300415,
-0.29834139347076416,
0.2732710838317871,
-0.3194350004196167,
0.43928262591362,
-0.11825493723154068,
-0.7124995589256287,
-0.633898913860321,
-0.6785154938697815,
-0.22250263392925262,
-0.2777528166770935,
-0.11945989727973938,
0.7878113985061646,
0.4437309801578522,
-0.7982469201087952,
-0.2500292658805847,
-0.49609971046447754,
-0.1483682245016098,
0.07835784554481506,
-0.21392643451690674,
0.2606378197669983,
-0.38535428047180176,
-0.9588707685470581,
0.5918571352958679,
0.08049818128347397,
0.2696412205696106,
-0.8882051706314087,
-0.27233433723449707,
0.27899619936943054,
0.1761428862810135,
0.8704038262367249,
0.2668696641921997,
-0.524757444858551,
0.2669028639793396,
0.10351642966270447,
-0.19160284101963043,
-0.15020982921123505,
0.9337864518165588,
-0.7266798615455627,
0.37082940340042114,
0.5281021595001221,
0.9898657202720642,
0.5122427344322205,
-0.15791195631027222,
0.9421530961990356,
-0.7443358302116394,
-0.2730788290500641,
0.4500158727169037,
0.343803733587265,
0.46683967113494873,
-0.26942193508148193,
0.6642425656318665,
0.21659843623638153,
-0.5013880133628845,
-1.1185163259506226,
0.2023918628692627,
-0.8279261589050293,
-0.2571514844894409,
1.284954309463501,
0.2790961265563965,
-0.0022595219779759645,
0.16313385963439941,
-0.1059795692563057,
0.21542134881019592,
-0.18792395293712616,
0.8269437551498413,
0.5292045474052429,
-0.22617949545383453,
-0.05360589548945427,
-0.5865187048912048,
0.3791857659816742,
0.13210000097751617,
-0.8265874981880188,
0.17822200059890747,
0.8228551149368286,
-0.0078043583780527115,
-0.061398547142744064,
0.16656480729579926,
-0.2853374481201172,
-0.05317747965455055,
-0.18889528512954712,
-0.1345268040895462,
-0.13852354884147644,
-0.3807392120361328,
-0.3386825621128082,
0.16871391236782074,
0.11564600467681885,
0.12334268540143967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09790v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09790v1
|
Pcc-tuning: Breaking the Contrastive Learning Ceiling in Semantic Textual Similarity
| 2024-06-14T07:40:07 | 2024-06-14T07:40:07 |
Bowen Zhang, Chunping Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Semantic Textual Similarity (STS) constitutes a critical research direction
in computational linguistics and serves as a key indicator of the encoding
capabilities of embedding models. Driven by advances in pre-trained language
models and contrastive learning techniques, leading sentence representation
methods can already achieved average Spearman's correlation scores of
approximately 86 across seven STS benchmarks in SentEval. However, further
improvements have become increasingly marginal, with no existing method
attaining an average score higher than 87 on these tasks. This paper conducts
an in-depth analysis of this phenomenon and concludes that the upper limit for
Spearman's correlation scores using contrastive learning is 87.5. To transcend
this ceiling, we propose an innovative approach termed Pcc-tuning, which
employs Pearson's correlation coefficient as a loss function to refine model
performance beyond contrastive learning. Experimental results demonstrate that
Pcc-tuning markedly surpasses previous state-of-the-art strategies, raising the
Spearman's correlation score to above 90.
|
[
-0.4200022220611572,
-0.4258579611778259,
0.5886840224266052,
0.06651604920625687,
-0.7144603729248047,
0.08491268008947372,
-0.607315719127655,
-0.2137192189693451,
0.05104167014360428,
0.45697256922721863,
-0.4305984675884247,
-0.7528091073036194,
-0.7135062217712402,
0.09902188181877136,
-0.3032999634742737,
1.0249526500701904,
0.24877595901489258,
0.023005928844213486,
-0.5208278298377991,
-0.03161420300602913,
-0.46737897396087646,
-0.4947800636291504,
-0.38813820481300354,
-0.12501360476016998,
0.5637822151184082,
0.4181691110134125,
0.8282743096351624,
0.8799037933349609,
1.131671667098999,
0.2760138213634491,
-0.10743044316768646,
0.32203733921051025,
-0.8408175110816956,
0.054760608822107315,
-0.2283458411693573,
-0.6375410556793213,
-0.27688756585121155,
0.23108160495758057,
0.5153824090957642,
0.7578509449958801,
-0.04822435602545738,
-0.18880394101142883,
0.45041805505752563,
0.7017549872398376,
-0.8145534992218018,
0.15027755498886108,
-0.9439446330070496,
-0.01779821701347828,
-0.1626865118741989,
-0.7521207332611084,
-0.7532585263252258,
-0.167631134390831,
0.02632879838347435,
-0.9862346649169922,
0.502499520778656,
0.11790265887975693,
1.01260507106781,
0.3408341705799103,
-0.554195761680603,
-0.3510035276412964,
-0.25195059180259705,
1.1309311389923096,
-0.34962090849876404,
0.3846195936203003,
0.5644127726554871,
0.01347357127815485,
-0.06288032233715057,
-0.6041175723075867,
-0.35511064529418945,
-0.4562280476093292,
-0.10184664279222488,
0.45895275473594666,
-0.17824386060237885,
-0.15136848390102386,
-0.09279882162809372,
0.3586120009422302,
-0.6810491681098938,
0.03114371933043003,
-0.4904903471469879,
0.2460726797580719,
0.47487759590148926,
0.35366350412368774,
-0.13252994418144226,
-0.17853020131587982,
-0.4999094605445862,
-0.4744429290294647,
-0.4568256139755249,
-0.21161451935768127,
0.22995345294475555,
0.7717042565345764,
-0.13510791957378387,
0.3015499711036682,
0.13202469050884247,
0.6170536279678345,
0.14543594419956207,
0.539945125579834,
0.24913549423217773,
-0.2616285979747772,
-0.16933688521385193,
0.06974771618843079,
0.6323243379592896,
0.6438737511634827,
0.27995389699935913,
-0.0345749706029892,
0.32745715975761414,
0.43166229128837585,
0.7484700083732605,
-0.4392171800136566,
-0.45656275749206543,
-0.2627124786376953,
-0.6045076847076416,
-0.39749303460121155,
0.4831712543964386,
-0.5658318996429443,
-0.25245463848114014,
-0.6073726415634155,
0.11573315411806107,
-0.680417001247406,
-0.09321067482233047,
0.06079859286546707,
-0.044734157621860504,
0.5000678896903992,
0.059713564813137054,
-0.6680141687393188,
0.591286301612854,
1.1704145669937134,
0.9897099733352661,
-0.49401360750198364,
-0.41200846433639526,
-0.37005752325057983,
-0.04327831417322159,
-0.8078550696372986,
0.8674029111862183,
-0.825904369354248,
-0.5672609806060791,
0.021507270634174347,
-0.1398385614156723,
-0.06639973074197769,
-0.6898355484008789,
0.8085437417030334,
-0.5068457126617432,
0.06954696774482727,
-0.3828630745410919,
-0.7240302562713623,
0.20140662789344788,
0.047544561326503754,
-0.45464426279067993,
0.9526565074920654,
-0.016854096204042435,
-0.865427553653717,
0.4529740512371063,
0.002591112395748496,
-0.4047905504703522,
0.15926486253738403,
-0.046491652727127075,
-0.6189383864402771,
0.43457382917404175,
-0.0387762151658535,
0.4288586974143982,
-0.5170160531997681,
-0.0006907748174853623,
-0.47926411032676697,
-0.8328799605369568,
0.2251349538564682,
-0.09735730290412903,
0.7139819860458374,
0.2952794134616852,
0.019266989082098007,
-0.05155195668339729,
-0.8355231881141663,
0.024712273851037025,
-0.36590656638145447,
-0.08757703006267548,
-0.722173273563385,
0.07689649611711502,
0.01635127328336239,
0.171518936753273,
0.04900973662734032,
-0.4121110439300537,
-0.20423869788646698,
-0.4242338538169861,
0.2805798053741455,
0.703154444694519,
-0.14573974907398224,
0.2294977307319641,
-0.5392548441886902,
0.24406492710113525,
0.16258858144283295,
-0.10884345322847366,
-0.023179978132247925,
-0.22064588963985443,
-0.8335250020027161,
-0.13484281301498413,
0.20647183060646057,
0.4214380979537964,
-0.4592169523239136,
0.7396257519721985,
-0.42441076040267944,
-0.6836986541748047,
-0.7065527439117432,
0.06604572385549545,
0.5136666893959045,
0.5557124614715576,
0.8312220573425293,
-0.41593438386917114,
-0.47205767035484314,
-0.802558422088623,
-0.7172388434410095,
-0.16837777197360992,
-0.22573530673980713,
0.2741949260234833,
0.25119829177856445,
0.21784758567810059,
0.5857093930244446,
-0.7325241565704346,
-0.6091103553771973,
0.11829154193401337,
0.21151283383369446,
0.32946646213531494,
0.7226934432983398,
0.2873076796531677,
-0.971670925617218,
-0.7176381945610046,
0.18949542939662933,
-0.6636942625045776,
-0.055421724915504456,
-0.06910815834999084,
0.047897111624479294,
-0.12718407809734344,
1.1180673837661743,
-0.21315117180347443,
0.32840171456336975,
0.3412184417247772,
-0.35772326588630676,
0.39112117886543274,
-0.4894382655620575,
0.39819830656051636,
-0.9439643025398254,
-0.023023923859000206,
0.13099466264247894,
0.014181440696120262,
-0.4123556315898895,
0.23860102891921997,
0.3003223240375519,
0.07213035225868225,
-0.2595873177051544,
-0.06483068317174911,
-0.31203344464302063,
0.3446187973022461,
-0.33501267433166504,
0.5097533464431763,
-0.16153980791568756,
0.41901153326034546,
-0.06289655715227127,
0.6222608685493469,
0.46883147954940796,
-0.644299328327179,
0.15905454754829407,
0.39674320816993713,
-0.20236892998218536,
1.0142427682876587,
-0.6110048890113831,
-0.028000731021165848,
-0.0991242453455925,
-0.03231240436434746,
-0.9789509773254395,
0.2851264178752899,
-0.24732978641986847,
-0.6726842522621155,
0.14936795830726624,
0.09287895262241364,
-0.0979158952832222,
0.07720507681369781,
-0.491707444190979,
0.4220958650112152,
0.5138835310935974,
-0.5080190896987915,
0.33160579204559326,
0.03259062394499779,
0.07104908674955368,
-0.37197354435920715,
-0.9228829145431519,
0.13413883745670319,
-0.20808421075344086,
-0.28804075717926025,
0.9330118894577026,
-0.05629287660121918,
-0.19079723954200745,
-0.005427934229373932,
0.036519426852464676,
0.08966515958309174,
-0.26091817021369934,
0.24356555938720703,
0.25618332624435425,
-0.20197319984436035,
0.3159002363681793,
0.08541302382946014,
-0.4638715386390686,
0.01932494342327118,
-0.14395923912525177,
0.34987932443618774,
-0.2177462875843048,
-0.10466457903385162,
-0.2763918340206146,
0.3417471945285797,
0.14100195467472076,
-0.1857508420944214,
0.8275067210197449,
0.3240330219268799,
0.03254292905330658,
-0.21632282435894012,
-0.17005251348018646,
-0.13422249257564545,
-0.5094293355941772,
0.43492552638053894,
-0.7369979023933411,
-0.9208003282546997,
0.33375778794288635,
-0.1397009789943695,
-0.28876906633377075,
0.5927039980888367,
0.35955575108528137,
-0.2805019021034241,
0.8091380000114441,
0.7223585844039917,
0.38152891397476196,
0.2831172049045563,
0.20172810554504395,
-0.02233635075390339,
-0.8577843308448792,
-0.3312738239765167,
-0.8988553285598755,
-0.10819673538208008,
-1.2652947902679443,
-0.46566182374954224,
0.4137348234653473,
0.008165054023265839,
-0.2765027582645416,
0.5663615465164185,
-0.47270384430885315,
0.6266900897026062,
0.4666622579097748,
0.42362362146377563,
0.3024693429470062,
-0.1961865872144699,
-0.500085175037384,
-0.45852357149124146,
-0.45304957032203674,
-0.26784834265708923,
1.0145938396453857,
-0.08343587815761566,
0.5028896927833557,
0.05430803820490837,
0.399715393781662,
0.34924206137657166,
-0.09002266824245453,
-0.5772932767868042,
0.5715551376342773,
-0.9032624363899231,
-0.1205907091498375,
0.02136990800499916,
-0.573742687702179,
-0.8794758915901184,
0.35909849405288696,
-0.4322621822357178,
-0.18166488409042358,
0.2992544174194336,
0.07687020301818848,
0.21243688464164734,
0.051084134727716446,
-0.23357556760311127,
0.7062179446220398,
0.29743438959121704,
-0.5875430107116699,
-0.6605342626571655,
-0.8810523152351379,
0.08109150826931,
-0.020729878917336464,
0.07959344238042831,
0.05132749676704407,
-0.29090049862861633,
0.5572642683982849,
-0.4173242151737213,
0.5267759561538696,
0.2420390248298645,
0.09729446470737457,
-0.10928699374198914,
0.14836256206035614,
0.15496888756752014,
-0.1889740228652954,
-0.1721625179052353,
0.12089978903532028,
-0.034496136009693146,
-0.7293890118598938,
-0.5634461641311646,
1.0177265405654907,
-0.834136426448822,
-0.2967853248119354,
-0.5727057456970215,
-0.2622185945510864,
-0.24180467426776886,
-0.0303471852093935,
0.38497084379196167,
0.20841357111930847,
-0.3350647985935211,
0.5140697360038757,
0.6738412380218506,
-0.27827003598213196,
0.17374050617218018,
0.3933258056640625,
0.3444640040397644,
-0.547757625579834,
0.9337528347969055,
-0.3037155270576477,
0.21449321508407593,
0.9255932569503784,
0.1853390485048294,
0.01795828901231289,
-0.5416319370269775,
0.26939842104911804,
0.3160460591316223,
-0.6216228008270264,
-0.3175409436225891,
-0.2245863527059555,
-0.13093414902687073,
-0.2865995764732361,
-0.5705680847167969,
-0.3684365749359131,
-0.24148793518543243,
-0.5850707292556763,
-0.10131976753473282,
0.13495446741580963,
0.42235487699508667,
-0.08634926378726959,
0.47954803705215454,
-0.44142812490463257,
0.1833624690771103,
0.1244615688920021,
0.48470810055732727,
-0.11960674822330475,
-0.7428265810012817,
-0.36610057950019836,
-0.2862541377544403,
-0.2851400077342987,
-0.6138433814048767,
0.32557159662246704,
0.4418694078922272,
0.16458259522914886,
0.47152188420295715,
0.28512364625930786,
0.9178492426872253,
-0.49951907992362976,
0.6256775856018066,
0.1971169263124466,
-1.1372307538986206,
0.4630100429058075,
-0.3292354643344879,
0.5642326474189758,
0.9965397119522095,
0.6568011045455933,
-0.49871698021888733,
-0.47431814670562744,
-0.524384081363678,
-0.6999375224113464,
0.4149026870727539,
0.1508394032716751,
0.14945317804813385,
-0.18160542845726013,
0.460544615983963,
0.1690109819173813,
-0.09082527458667755,
-0.41688108444213867,
-0.05641646310687065,
-0.429594486951828,
-0.3055959939956665,
-0.2876746952533722,
0.03245220705866814,
0.3141120970249176,
-0.31943121552467346,
0.7149671316146851,
-0.1818932443857193,
0.018488740548491478,
0.24267852306365967,
-0.13331827521324158,
-0.05978233367204666,
0.15929874777793884,
0.5229533314704895,
0.6774464845657349,
-0.3574046194553375,
0.5731698870658875,
0.25876471400260925,
-0.6009365320205688,
-0.27437087893486023,
-0.06443418562412262,
0.2053164839744568,
-0.3016161024570465,
0.7010728716850281,
0.4432537257671356,
0.42724934220314026,
-0.4967387318611145,
0.5342472195625305,
-0.18108896911144257,
-0.36598190665245056,
-0.11277568340301514,
0.07783224433660507,
-0.11989600211381912,
-0.19504643976688385,
0.28584644198417664,
0.1336221545934677,
-0.015568230301141739,
-0.4919988811016083,
0.5399218797683716,
0.30260586738586426,
-1.1286282539367676,
-0.16247884929180145,
0.5627524256706238,
-0.03774617612361908,
-0.19372758269309998,
0.9026985168457031,
0.18553462624549866,
-0.27617204189300537,
0.4179670512676239,
0.5919703841209412,
0.5555281043052673,
-0.38104313611984253,
0.18608702719211578,
0.5086381435394287,
0.3284167945384979,
0.22201363742351532,
0.11236537992954254,
-0.15321481227874756,
-0.6018099784851074,
-0.29108837246894836,
-0.5136716365814209,
-0.38339999318122864,
-0.4274485111236572,
-1.1671953201293945,
0.6456578373908997,
-0.3298182487487793,
0.09813591837882996,
0.18346509337425232,
0.1857667863368988,
-0.4977957308292389,
0.3250766694545746,
-0.2621256709098816,
0.814716100692749,
-0.836689293384552,
0.7875010967254639,
0.40530022978782654,
-0.26622894406318665,
-0.329597532749176,
-0.1928221881389618,
-0.0478353351354599,
-0.5224832892417908,
0.4684886932373047,
-0.036024145781993866,
-0.30214229226112366,
-0.11906737834215164,
-0.4827043414115906,
-0.36445555090904236,
0.9391118288040161,
0.34088045358657837,
-0.7853631377220154,
0.24597491323947906,
0.36574190855026245,
0.9095557928085327,
-0.5419273972511292,
0.48336300253868103,
0.7011149525642395,
0.23909339308738708,
0.118988998234272,
-0.6668456196784973,
0.12536107003688812,
-0.3841378092765808,
0.18319670855998993,
0.24744604527950287,
-0.7918415665626526,
0.9603726863861084,
0.06436475366353989,
-0.10042475908994675,
0.08247525990009308,
0.6634008884429932,
0.2568943500518799,
0.11342145502567291,
0.4251789152622223,
0.6774114966392517,
0.5613071918487549,
-0.0720411092042923,
0.8411146998405457,
-0.3151437044143677,
0.43502339720726013,
1.1957582235336304,
-0.2659415900707245,
1.237809658050537,
0.4208441972732544,
-0.23429520428180695,
0.908912181854248,
0.40289273858070374,
-0.28424447774887085,
0.6688728332519531,
0.4333452880382538,
-0.03036557510495186,
-0.5116938948631287,
-0.09530384093523026,
-0.2624313235282898,
0.7688312530517578,
0.2135258913040161,
-0.6157978773117065,
0.05553419888019562,
-0.10192451626062393,
-0.012597457505762577,
0.8839144706726074,
-0.3139793574810028,
0.9405778646469116,
0.33437779545783997,
-0.5214465260505676,
0.6927060484886169,
-0.1649411916732788,
0.5534543395042419,
-0.6382272839546204,
-0.157525897026062,
-0.024058878421783447,
0.3970974385738373,
-0.098226398229599,
-0.5142782926559448,
0.42431268095970154,
-0.34229856729507446,
-0.13484059274196625,
-0.17526163160800934,
0.5075922012329102,
-0.4515930712223053,
-0.4054740369319916,
0.5784030556678772,
0.25011152029037476,
0.024108607321977615,
0.07009419053792953,
-0.6106192469596863,
0.185176819562912,
-0.2961321175098419,
0.3422599136829376,
0.2523822784423828,
0.3847658038139343,
0.3113725483417511,
0.41257351636886597,
0.5261253714561462,
0.19601242244243622,
-0.25306037068367004,
-0.0016164452536031604,
0.938675045967102,
-0.9502389430999756,
-0.7737162113189697,
-0.8898292183876038,
0.11449142545461655,
-0.23864354193210602,
-0.7186350226402283,
0.7507511377334595,
0.6766926050186157,
1.0440192222595215,
-0.06210748106241226,
0.33952346444129944,
0.3177885413169861,
0.6114269495010376,
-0.42965829372406006,
0.662384569644928,
-0.4451824724674225,
0.37476542592048645,
-0.5907918810844421,
-0.9188010096549988,
-0.6961361765861511,
0.5707825422286987,
-0.22122541069984436,
-0.05674697458744049,
1.1808432340621948,
0.8009863495826721,
-0.18274237215518951,
0.35390836000442505,
0.4273304343223572,
0.3281688392162323,
0.16038799285888672,
0.7572215795516968,
0.6868690848350525,
-0.6232303380966187,
0.7341800332069397,
-0.05124977231025696,
-0.3660309612751007,
0.05059652030467987,
-0.9659299850463867,
-0.8904038667678833,
-0.8361770510673523,
-0.3541620671749115,
-0.2254789173603058,
0.38930702209472656,
0.6720709800720215,
0.6408225297927856,
-0.8990234732627869,
-0.3446861505508423,
-0.4478311538696289,
-0.09603596478700638,
-0.7164501547813416,
-0.22440893948078156,
0.7099183797836304,
-0.6044154167175293,
-0.5555917620658875,
0.3029175102710724,
0.3165130317211151,
-0.46775829792022705,
0.018179286271333694,
-0.06415104866027832,
-0.38924556970596313,
0.10134118795394897,
0.47410106658935547,
-0.16346891224384308,
-0.39861586689949036,
-0.2847111225128174,
-0.14636290073394775,
-0.049299322068691254,
0.33174821734428406,
1.20846426486969,
-1.0080052614212036,
0.3732389807701111,
0.5020490884780884,
0.5685610175132751,
0.6179408431053162,
0.07448574155569077,
0.5599215030670166,
-0.7251365780830383,
-0.1515280306339264,
0.3468954563140869,
-0.0687374398112297,
0.36991599202156067,
-0.15938971936702728,
0.4002421796321869,
0.07577548921108246,
-0.6461629867553711,
-0.6505330204963684,
0.2229650765657425,
-1.3485262393951416,
-0.44103682041168213,
0.540020763874054,
-0.110991932451725,
-0.1289820820093155,
-0.1715998649597168,
0.09007386118173599,
0.23211300373077393,
-0.21958138048648834,
0.9281646013259888,
0.5080622434616089,
-0.08612977713346481,
-0.26578474044799805,
-0.036024052649736404,
0.7041691541671753,
0.7383955717086792,
-0.7472323179244995,
0.28716543316841125,
0.07624493539333344,
0.03227876499295235,
0.20557129383087158,
0.07852981984615326,
-0.28173473477363586,
0.3347471058368683,
0.3258870840072632,
-0.44628262519836426,
0.0715680867433548,
-0.30966368317604065,
-0.4262077510356903,
0.41606658697128296,
-0.21593311429023743,
0.13563862442970276
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09779v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09779v1
|
OSPC: Detecting Harmful Memes with Large Language Model as a Catalyst
| 2024-06-14T07:28:02 | 2024-06-14T07:28:02 |
Jingtao Cao, Zheng Zhang, Hongru Wang, Bin Liang, Hao Wang, Kam-Fai Wong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Memes, which rapidly disseminate personal opinions and positions across the
internet, also pose significant challenges in propagating social bias and
prejudice. This study presents a novel approach to detecting harmful memes,
particularly within the multicultural and multilingual context of Singapore.
Our methodology integrates image captioning, Optical Character Recognition
(OCR), and Large Language Model (LLM) analysis to comprehensively understand
and classify harmful memes. Utilizing the BLIP model for image captioning,
PP-OCR and TrOCR for text recognition across multiple languages, and the Qwen
LLM for nuanced language understanding, our system is capable of identifying
harmful content in memes created in English, Chinese, Malay, and Tamil. To
enhance the system's performance, we fine-tuned our approach by leveraging
additional data labeled using GPT-4V, aiming to distill the understanding
capability of GPT-4V for harmful memes to our system. Our framework achieves
top-1 at the public leaderboard of the Online Safety Prize Challenge hosted by
AI Singapore, with the AUROC as 0.7749 and accuracy as 0.7087, significantly
ahead of the other teams. Notably, our approach outperforms previous
benchmarks, with FLAVA achieving an AUROC of 0.5695 and VisualBERT an AUROC of
0.5561.
|
[
-0.2986811697483063,
-0.7910142540931702,
0.0850071981549263,
0.23641160130500793,
-0.5795388221740723,
0.15323342382907867,
0.10532256215810776,
-0.8012076020240784,
0.220795676112175,
0.6322703957557678,
-0.36553454399108887,
-0.3117765486240387,
-0.8654538989067078,
0.44148415327072144,
-0.14415466785430908,
0.8005131483078003,
0.03464875742793083,
-0.2393094152212143,
0.35065653920173645,
0.03343493118882179,
-0.19898785650730133,
-0.5819928646087646,
-1.0130921602249146,
0.5221002697944641,
0.35781028866767883,
0.462368905544281,
0.24400050938129425,
0.3537989556789398,
0.8314687609672546,
0.3290821313858032,
-0.13136914372444153,
0.0942324697971344,
-0.48475366830825806,
0.02204633131623268,
-0.5558053851127625,
-0.4632563889026642,
-0.3964730501174927,
0.1359512060880661,
0.24651841819286346,
0.1062517911195755,
-0.03927002474665642,
-0.10301483422517776,
0.10229109227657318,
0.28655770421028137,
-0.7932073473930359,
0.1721215397119522,
-0.7802766561508179,
0.3245348036289215,
-0.4770534038543701,
-0.4156361222267151,
-0.41576430201530457,
-0.27298712730407715,
-0.28425151109695435,
-0.26792141795158386,
-0.13721580803394318,
-0.027111278846859932,
0.49151530861854553,
0.009129304438829422,
-0.6290803551673889,
-0.6354128122329712,
-0.4876220226287842,
0.9677690267562866,
-0.804757297039032,
0.15565651655197144,
0.24567820131778717,
0.5817521810531616,
-0.06698835641145706,
-0.417257696390152,
-0.6706135869026184,
0.05313286557793617,
0.35087263584136963,
0.0656769797205925,
-0.2121572196483612,
-0.054232604801654816,
0.19388221204280853,
0.30099689960479736,
-0.6460874080657959,
0.22337748110294342,
-0.7479071617126465,
-0.6939133405685425,
0.7033565640449524,
0.14178571105003357,
0.5218587517738342,
-0.47250115871429443,
-0.6547192335128784,
-0.1822185218334198,
-0.7592764496803284,
-0.14826691150665283,
0.4431413412094116,
0.3682425022125244,
-0.009225641377270222,
0.5108797550201416,
-0.11987821757793427,
0.19505324959754944,
-0.07008330523967743,
-0.6825820803642273,
0.21791747212409973,
-0.49298903346061707,
0.030246399343013763,
0.25872302055358887,
0.9860949516296387,
0.6995657086372375,
0.2484327107667923,
0.41741612553596497,
-0.03511006385087967,
0.32071956992149353,
0.03098292089998722,
-1.084749460220337,
-0.015076898038387299,
-0.07036111503839493,
-0.5756614208221436,
-0.483094722032547,
0.23427248001098633,
-0.8588855266571045,
-0.5011078119277954,
0.2251455932855606,
0.1525934338569641,
-0.4642094075679779,
-0.4898984432220459,
0.19237634539604187,
-0.1648719608783722,
0.14362303912639618,
0.3949587047100067,
-0.8920929431915283,
-0.16434787213802338,
0.7374598383903503,
0.9271957874298096,
0.10753262788057327,
-0.053042221814394,
-0.44245395064353943,
0.3823603093624115,
-0.3364706337451935,
0.5785142779350281,
-0.5227950811386108,
-0.17354442179203033,
-0.24141187965869904,
0.33281970024108887,
0.2431924194097519,
-0.4042559564113617,
0.7858514189720154,
-0.20360958576202393,
0.2224026471376419,
-0.2859080731868744,
-0.2549780309200287,
-0.2519082725048065,
0.3771640956401825,
-0.5990812182426453,
0.4134998917579651,
-0.08410943299531937,
-0.9290205240249634,
0.3708636462688446,
-0.6907791495323181,
-0.482428640127182,
0.2264356166124344,
-0.17308327555656433,
-0.3891899287700653,
-0.265380859375,
0.06659617274999619,
0.941933274269104,
-0.05936311557888985,
0.06819666922092438,
-0.3770407438278198,
-0.30714431405067444,
-0.08454951643943787,
-0.6196596026420593,
1.0265542268753052,
0.7630133628845215,
-0.4568912088871002,
0.08530416339635849,
-0.4737780690193176,
-0.4541703760623932,
0.2542944848537445,
-0.37908580899238586,
-0.5686237215995789,
-0.12686042487621307,
-0.022224077954888344,
0.5471243858337402,
0.06586179882287979,
-1.0329796075820923,
0.02832123450934887,
0.007520914077758789,
0.7300827503204346,
0.8039731979370117,
0.16634851694107056,
0.12015874683856964,
-0.08259482681751251,
0.555783212184906,
0.133340984582901,
0.45929884910583496,
-0.247127503156662,
-0.8636235594749451,
0.18051816523075104,
-0.33627963066101074,
-0.2720852792263031,
0.5664238929748535,
-1.1230486631393433,
0.42940592765808105,
-0.11649002879858017,
-0.45241761207580566,
-0.10711295902729034,
0.07673946768045425,
0.2609182894229889,
0.442990243434906,
0.15178143978118896,
-0.6626062989234924,
-0.4861323833465576,
-0.6396324038505554,
-0.14908957481384277,
-0.35713058710098267,
-0.0884924829006195,
0.30754050612449646,
0.44495466351509094,
-0.41573652625083923,
0.1952657699584961,
-0.21576471626758575,
-0.591746985912323,
-0.1579916626214981,
0.3148316740989685,
0.07949269562959671,
0.5197253823280334,
1.0213994979858398,
-0.6260190010070801,
-0.749361515045166,
-0.0739300474524498,
-0.7055909037590027,
-0.3238915801048279,
-0.1428815871477127,
0.06779198348522186,
0.12999139726161957,
0.7709741592407227,
0.053265444934368134,
0.3803890645503998,
0.56055748462677,
-0.6063693761825562,
0.7578536868095398,
0.1326342225074768,
0.6585975289344788,
-0.9563112854957581,
0.026705892756581306,
0.014420109800994396,
-0.4151839315891266,
-0.3751811683177948,
0.19732201099395752,
0.12333912402391434,
-0.28365135192871094,
-0.6035106182098389,
0.2993199825286865,
-0.15317675471305847,
0.4303840398788452,
-0.17535905539989471,
0.017733102664351463,
-0.16205263137817383,
0.2456214278936386,
-0.06796946376562119,
0.8115951418876648,
0.2926517128944397,
-0.3207727372646332,
0.3918381631374359,
0.14127995073795319,
-0.46437403559684753,
0.7191926836967468,
-0.1798878163099289,
-0.06957004964351654,
-0.1024460569024086,
0.15372334420681,
-1.0045557022094727,
-0.25713080167770386,
0.6817057728767395,
-0.43643760681152344,
0.18976673483848572,
0.09348580986261368,
-0.5984441637992859,
-0.5145214200019836,
-0.7314437031745911,
0.5128834247589111,
0.19028358161449432,
-0.6163278222084045,
0.22741082310676575,
0.5909533500671387,
-0.37056058645248413,
-0.7226495146751404,
-0.7976253628730774,
0.30804529786109924,
-0.28976067900657654,
-0.5886279940605164,
-0.028976023197174072,
-0.015169796533882618,
0.026293594390153885,
-0.2450558990240097,
0.06541651487350464,
-0.042109496891498566,
0.23968982696533203,
0.14537768065929413,
-0.23671855032444,
-0.30289754271507263,
-0.1767217516899109,
0.1914689689874649,
-0.12492956966161728,
0.11652211099863052,
0.23492619395256042,
0.6057707071304321,
-0.17069996893405914,
-0.29781875014305115,
-0.6346222758293152,
0.36858004331588745,
0.8094967603683472,
-0.30116790533065796,
0.7147644758224487,
0.5442211031913757,
-0.48393815755844116,
-0.07430178672075272,
-0.2919715344905853,
-0.2900612950325012,
-0.556527316570282,
0.3963339626789093,
-0.24890467524528503,
-0.9825096130371094,
0.30015113949775696,
-0.1642656922340393,
0.023606162518262863,
0.38619208335876465,
0.27302390336990356,
0.1198551133275032,
1.1356112957000732,
0.4544748067855835,
-0.5346145033836365,
0.5363844633102417,
-0.021620040759444237,
0.49897319078445435,
-0.40442904829978943,
-0.11709535866975784,
-0.41723406314849854,
-0.11883332580327988,
-0.5708017945289612,
-0.549252986907959,
0.4062560796737671,
0.09456183761358261,
-0.3322736322879791,
0.29152730107307434,
-0.6065085530281067,
0.49341320991516113,
0.3940160870552063,
0.22072440385818481,
0.20713524520397186,
0.1697964370250702,
-0.31425219774246216,
-0.1992233246564865,
-0.2979184687137604,
-0.6755199432373047,
0.9657340049743652,
0.5188557505607605,
0.8071630597114563,
0.5573179125785828,
0.2378254383802414,
0.4797114431858063,
0.4435345530509949,
-0.44670572876930237,
0.6235111355781555,
-0.45941248536109924,
-0.9343801736831665,
-0.3301317095756531,
-0.515838086605072,
-0.8482961058616638,
0.06898684054613113,
-0.32950282096862793,
-0.7410602569580078,
-0.10887322574853897,
-0.010824281722307205,
-0.05387495830655098,
0.8376588225364685,
-0.3019762635231018,
0.8391981720924377,
-0.4356958568096161,
-0.40506091713905334,
-0.39603009819984436,
-0.7226763367652893,
0.5844209790229797,
-0.0730045810341835,
0.4240182936191559,
-0.16639314591884613,
0.0004295612743590027,
0.5474258065223694,
-0.4227781891822815,
0.8662753105163574,
-0.29373684525489807,
-0.15158873796463013,
0.46224403381347656,
0.06425782293081284,
0.16312773525714874,
-0.3348066508769989,
-0.27096328139305115,
0.41229891777038574,
-0.14916516840457916,
-0.5028874278068542,
-0.08002187311649323,
0.7544165849685669,
-0.5528720021247864,
-0.20563454926013947,
-0.5402035117149353,
-0.15287189185619354,
0.30548161268234253,
0.4457473158836365,
0.14233410358428955,
0.23019500076770782,
-0.08675570785999298,
0.34673917293548584,
0.4462144374847412,
-0.7959489226341248,
0.256376177072525,
0.4704371392726898,
-0.17262676358222961,
-0.41908320784568787,
1.158972978591919,
-0.058777205646038055,
0.23562659323215485,
0.3841879367828369,
0.3533441722393036,
-0.31433263421058655,
-0.5100457072257996,
-0.41708138585090637,
0.27643460035324097,
-0.8710184693336487,
-0.29382792115211487,
-0.5396384596824646,
-0.03325844556093216,
-0.5571675300598145,
-0.0926085039973259,
-0.24821916222572327,
-0.3003978133201599,
-0.08895871788263321,
-0.13388876616954803,
-0.07464322447776794,
0.7527762055397034,
-0.32676881551742554,
0.5691798329353333,
-0.708031952381134,
0.10342871397733688,
0.22008268535137177,
0.5600349307060242,
0.009891927242279053,
-0.2778131663799286,
0.2913670539855957,
-0.061240654438734055,
-0.6800684928894043,
-1.0830069780349731,
0.47673532366752625,
0.06775125116109848,
0.39642077684402466,
1.4377106428146362,
0.17179451882839203,
0.5082108974456787,
-0.2857283651828766,
0.8052021861076355,
0.38219204545021057,
-0.7887803316116333,
0.6664256453514099,
-0.40430381894111633,
-0.14763468503952026,
0.5591982007026672,
0.7207480669021606,
-0.7256538271903992,
-0.6182764172554016,
-0.3616938889026642,
-0.6433368921279907,
0.5488212704658508,
0.1791437417268753,
0.16804315149784088,
-0.39220133423805237,
0.49596214294433594,
0.12416023761034012,
0.33136868476867676,
-1.0420583486557007,
0.056978967040777206,
-0.19819402694702148,
-0.030392860993742943,
-0.10425020009279251,
-0.5789294838905334,
0.361602783203125,
-0.06525801122188568,
0.8197463750839233,
-0.05350732058286667,
0.17348319292068481,
0.0716996043920517,
-0.01245251577347517,
-0.43519917130470276,
0.10839088261127472,
0.5704115033149719,
0.29273995757102966,
-0.32331061363220215,
0.4113081395626068,
-0.25445088744163513,
-0.5945886969566345,
0.0953582227230072,
-0.259122371673584,
0.056614913046360016,
-0.3389582335948944,
0.48846936225891113,
0.16399069130420685,
-0.07470043748617172,
-0.8425222635269165,
0.8512063026428223,
-0.2520466148853302,
0.0016921445494517684,
-0.015364582650363445,
0.04052870720624924,
-0.2310153841972351,
-0.12031795084476471,
0.36148688197135925,
0.06333472579717636,
0.35140639543533325,
-0.7666942477226257,
0.32495036721229553,
0.548753559589386,
-0.43438616394996643,
-0.43406566977500916,
0.8602105975151062,
0.4909340739250183,
-0.002663773950189352,
0.34625378251075745,
-0.44352611899375916,
-0.8910638093948364,
0.7661141157150269,
0.5618849396705627,
0.4376901686191559,
-0.992101788520813,
0.20985455811023712,
0.7830789685249329,
0.8718129992485046,
0.04343733936548233,
0.5853425860404968,
0.09360512346029282,
-0.7414249777793884,
-0.2605549097061157,
-0.45665764808654785,
-0.3384297490119934,
0.6265501976013184,
-0.2822181284427643,
0.3913537263870239,
-0.9687759280204773,
0.22590050101280212,
0.21764594316482544,
-0.07531505823135376,
-0.12243682146072388,
0.2784987688064575,
0.4083191752433777,
0.7419666051864624,
-1.3966716527938843,
0.35422757267951965,
0.7035287618637085,
-0.3419937193393707,
-0.5516120791435242,
-0.1842450648546219,
0.4139682948589325,
-0.5864933133125305,
0.14682723581790924,
0.7964604496955872,
-0.08917004615068436,
-0.40613308548927307,
-0.7645303010940552,
-0.5553690195083618,
0.8427335619926453,
0.26154255867004395,
-0.7712226510047913,
0.6371771097183228,
0.30233144760131836,
0.5422455668449402,
-0.12279180437326431,
0.2540682256221771,
0.12434075772762299,
0.21961748600006104,
0.1437155157327652,
-0.9713329672813416,
0.31384196877479553,
-0.3354441821575165,
-0.45992031693458557,
0.29979023337364197,
-0.7059761881828308,
0.961808979511261,
0.0041349418461322784,
-0.384876012802124,
0.011718366295099258,
0.2592766284942627,
0.19513145089149475,
0.4606458842754364,
0.7549134492874146,
0.2816019058227539,
0.6182710528373718,
0.1844324767589569,
0.9394643902778625,
-0.18370623886585236,
0.20203545689582825,
0.6506856679916382,
-0.0759088546037674,
0.7838144898414612,
0.4396847188472748,
-0.18651895225048065,
0.30678853392601013,
0.7060951590538025,
0.14849376678466797,
0.7243737578392029,
0.1561124175786972,
-0.33998462557792664,
-0.12517037987709045,
-0.1870604306459427,
-0.3686896860599518,
0.5350572466850281,
0.7318045496940613,
-0.44610556960105896,
-0.26600903272628784,
0.3712379038333893,
0.08449724316596985,
0.11942815780639648,
-0.5179822444915771,
0.683122456073761,
0.03127037361264229,
-0.34677019715309143,
0.43936166167259216,
0.4004650115966797,
0.9228857755661011,
-0.4079550504684448,
-0.10536392033100128,
0.0706569254398346,
0.4550268352031708,
-0.14591826498508453,
-0.7241711020469666,
0.5850154161453247,
-0.13357391953468323,
0.26714515686035156,
-0.056868039071559906,
0.9404289126396179,
-0.3119855523109436,
-0.4906079173088074,
0.4507717192173004,
0.11186728626489639,
0.5593128204345703,
-0.29252445697784424,
-0.9208574891090393,
0.09550119936466217,
0.14003178477287292,
0.22516469657421112,
0.13150256872177124,
0.4726911783218384,
-0.538215696811676,
0.5636612772941589,
0.5991613864898682,
0.044881224632263184,
0.06582725793123245,
-0.046187955886125565,
0.7266839742660522,
-0.5860348343849182,
-0.900131106376648,
-0.766686201095581,
0.06052703782916069,
-0.2954162657260895,
-0.03145753592252731,
0.6510028839111328,
0.5580059885978699,
0.8189847469329834,
-0.02373379096388817,
0.9326845407485962,
-0.2240346074104309,
0.5461876392364502,
-0.08390671014785767,
0.7593697905540466,
-0.6075754165649414,
0.40496015548706055,
-0.6356084942817688,
-0.6387595534324646,
-0.5142695307731628,
0.8367332816123962,
-0.2628747224807739,
-0.31156545877456665,
0.3443171977996826,
0.7633661031723022,
-0.3027777075767517,
0.2991330623626709,
0.2936762869358063,
0.4653733968734741,
0.7181528806686401,
0.6188758611679077,
0.942405104637146,
-0.24277636408805847,
0.7039984464645386,
-0.45498350262641907,
-0.784690260887146,
-0.3426612317562103,
-1.0361123085021973,
-1.210920810699463,
-0.38887274265289307,
-0.24624255299568176,
-0.22719819843769073,
-0.00505932467058301,
0.715236485004425,
0.4902105927467346,
-1.1319894790649414,
0.08863331377506256,
0.08136024326086044,
0.034638065844774246,
-0.08731677383184433,
-0.25708097219467163,
0.18582969903945923,
0.10784692317247391,
-0.5571616291999817,
0.11545827239751816,
0.5373435616493225,
-0.06402187794446945,
-0.2876366972923279,
0.11681248247623444,
-0.3168436288833618,
-0.026234997436404228,
0.9543091654777527,
0.20371520519256592,
-0.6437230110168457,
-0.5232844948768616,
-0.32619908452033997,
-0.23915041983127594,
-0.12345029413700104,
0.5436506271362305,
-0.11080688238143921,
0.6759047508239746,
0.5316922664642334,
0.41347330808639526,
0.14159297943115234,
0.17359237372875214,
0.3303797245025635,
-0.7061253786087036,
0.4008638560771942,
0.27675551176071167,
0.4095407724380493,
0.506208598613739,
-0.7008392214775085,
0.6632802486419678,
0.2974680960178375,
-0.4253107011318207,
-0.7373626828193665,
0.09822801500558853,
-0.8544976115226746,
-0.6383843421936035,
0.9832702279090881,
-0.317875474691391,
-0.2833697497844696,
-0.490710973739624,
-0.43792444467544556,
-0.01187687274068594,
-0.4299345016479492,
1.1238884925842285,
0.4410868287086487,
-0.009058993309736252,
-0.14181636273860931,
-0.33121657371520996,
0.3512939214706421,
0.28405171632766724,
-0.754797101020813,
-0.31610095500946045,
0.4156920909881592,
0.5035263895988464,
0.49734777212142944,
0.7020984292030334,
-0.4150552749633789,
0.5042086839675903,
-0.21336734294891357,
0.029524946585297585,
0.07441043853759766,
-0.2364853024482727,
-0.2175586074590683,
0.3363002836704254,
-0.26414936780929565,
-0.32084745168685913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09765v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09765v2
|
Application of Natural Language Processing in Financial Risk Detection
| 2024-06-14T07:06:24 | 2024-06-20T13:12:23 |
Liyang Wang, Yu Cheng, Ao Xiang, Jingyu Zhang, Haowei Yang
|
q-fin.RM
|
q-fin.RM, cs.CL
|
This paper explores the application of Natural Language Processing (NLP) in
financial risk detection. By constructing an NLP-based financial risk detection
model, this study aims to identify and predict potential risks in financial
documents and communications. First, the fundamental concepts of NLP and its
theoretical foundation, including text mining methods, NLP model design
principles, and machine learning algorithms, are introduced. Second, the
process of text data preprocessing and feature extraction is described.
Finally, the effectiveness and predictive performance of the model are
validated through empirical research. The results show that the NLP-based
financial risk detection model performs excellently in risk identification and
prediction, providing effective risk management tools for financial
institutions. This study offers valuable references for the field of financial
risk management, utilizing advanced NLP techniques to improve the accuracy and
efficiency of financial risk detection.
|
[
-0.030673161149024963,
-0.9591350555419922,
0.19128888845443726,
0.12926775217056274,
0.09242051839828491,
0.09342880547046661,
0.09582753479480743,
-1.133482813835144,
-0.04828164353966713,
0.9908280372619629,
-0.30437159538269043,
-0.6618563532829285,
-0.6473672986030579,
-0.13868428766727448,
-0.6120598912239075,
0.9246167540550232,
0.1606604903936386,
-0.12498398125171661,
-0.008833859115839005,
0.4795375466346741,
-0.41570672392845154,
-0.3519914746284485,
-1.393997311592102,
-0.0981706753373146,
0.0414448156952858,
0.2140236496925354,
0.7565063834190369,
0.15294873714447021,
1.0374057292938232,
0.3613990247249603,
-0.05368621274828911,
-0.477649986743927,
0.4228138029575348,
-0.014997023157775402,
0.0961160659790039,
-0.7465949058532715,
-0.41328418254852295,
0.33739304542541504,
0.4123592674732208,
0.47857922315597534,
-0.3007659614086151,
0.16101956367492676,
-0.03281780332326889,
0.8894884586334229,
-0.3987686336040497,
0.40574562549591064,
-0.6440191864967346,
0.19757063686847687,
-0.3525328040122986,
-0.6654218435287476,
-0.5981362462043762,
-0.4821559190750122,
0.5997976064682007,
-0.3399176299571991,
0.2098260074853897,
0.2596914768218994,
0.7978054285049438,
0.1739605963230133,
-0.2908594310283661,
-0.8383736610412598,
-0.8220518231391907,
0.6118754148483276,
-0.6915639638900757,
0.12575773894786835,
0.7089272141456604,
0.6791270971298218,
-0.08244994282722473,
-0.42276623845100403,
-0.13487868010997772,
-0.030299611389636993,
-0.10766992717981339,
-0.2805160582065582,
-0.35776665806770325,
0.04491886869072914,
0.12431526184082031,
0.5592555403709412,
-0.5550178289413452,
0.14097537100315094,
-0.3642648756504059,
-0.3041847348213196,
0.5940253734588623,
-0.29989203810691833,
0.35401055216789246,
-0.31215524673461914,
-0.45027583837509155,
-0.2671565115451813,
-0.3850595951080322,
0.25156283378601074,
0.8273615837097168,
0.5598395466804504,
0.007257448509335518,
0.44252288341522217,
-0.015429416671395302,
0.8294551968574524,
-0.29566043615341187,
-0.49629634618759155,
0.17000435292720795,
-0.13524748384952545,
-0.5320976376533508,
0.35363200306892395,
0.38344714045524597,
0.2499963939189911,
0.44719985127449036,
0.0883321464061737,
-0.2739945352077484,
-0.21936754882335663,
0.35284167528152466,
-0.025342628359794617,
-0.048570115119218826,
0.12193994224071503,
-0.6196371912956238,
-0.8383120894432068,
-0.04379795864224434,
-0.9011667370796204,
-0.28224438428878784,
-0.1288202852010727,
0.15977294743061066,
-0.6234169006347656,
-0.13505317270755768,
0.5520676970481873,
-0.4124494194984436,
0.43511754274368286,
-0.16881409287452698,
-0.9493083953857422,
0.817422091960907,
0.6863195300102234,
0.7103919386863708,
0.17809100449085236,
0.49591052532196045,
-0.5037842988967896,
0.20524300634860992,
-0.04030279070138931,
1.1487878561019897,
-0.21906660497188568,
-0.27022725343704224,
0.12405885756015778,
-0.4242313504219055,
-0.0572432316839695,
-0.5671891570091248,
0.8854280710220337,
-0.4832479655742645,
0.09242913126945496,
0.38078421354293823,
-0.7252166867256165,
-0.43434789776802063,
0.2709576487541199,
-1.0349849462509155,
0.8543556332588196,
0.09529342502355576,
-1.0934462547302246,
0.4787992537021637,
-0.9522899389266968,
-0.46317335963249207,
0.3386382758617401,
0.5110462307929993,
-0.6851973533630371,
-0.13608713448047638,
0.21041476726531982,
0.4233831763267517,
-0.3647114634513855,
0.3570747673511505,
-0.14611154794692993,
-0.23684124648571014,
0.5352820754051208,
-0.5894774794578552,
0.6045888066291809,
0.08381719887256622,
-0.07749757170677185,
0.0794883519411087,
-0.8985932469367981,
-0.1398388296365738,
0.18954387307167053,
-0.10155624151229858,
-0.8745489716529846,
0.3000056743621826,
0.4137285053730011,
0.21793125569820404,
0.18179036676883698,
-0.2653504014015198,
-0.21614965796470642,
-0.8486531972885132,
0.25936365127563477,
0.5353904366493225,
0.16870786249637604,
0.5539142489433289,
-0.3328770399093628,
0.5024461150169373,
-0.4053453505039215,
0.2101665437221527,
0.05606251209974289,
-0.6015421152114868,
-0.43489986658096313,
-0.06371331959962845,
0.4218812882900238,
1.1212002038955688,
-0.307481974363327,
0.6990017294883728,
0.35868698358535767,
-0.353776216506958,
-0.2837100327014923,
-0.13197293877601624,
-0.08857293426990509,
0.6422150135040283,
0.439238578081131,
0.2240319848060608,
-0.9003180861473083,
-0.8349049687385559,
-0.8314943909645081,
-0.31496304273605347,
-0.10919282585382462,
-0.1548408567905426,
0.19532747566699982,
-0.1825208067893982,
0.9121634364128113,
-1.0066430568695068,
-0.43240031599998474,
-0.26948678493499756,
0.5528730154037476,
0.4588010907173157,
0.5011683106422424,
0.7246254682540894,
-1.1937116384506226,
-0.339494526386261,
-0.04104780778288841,
-0.4773794114589691,
0.028576016426086426,
-0.4332256019115448,
0.06341259181499481,
0.28962135314941406,
0.461646169424057,
-0.24188053607940674,
0.7844185829162598,
0.5060312151908875,
-0.4688686430454254,
0.3017803728580475,
-0.16635331511497498,
-0.251252144575119,
-0.8980070352554321,
0.07541992515325546,
0.6231876015663147,
-0.3252978026866913,
-0.9111759066581726,
-0.2609085738658905,
-0.20141780376434326,
-0.14934714138507843,
-0.002043449319899082,
0.6267122626304626,
0.06581351906061172,
-0.15267254412174225,
-0.5845507383346558,
-0.1347636878490448,
-0.05221522971987724,
-0.04879428446292877,
0.29853397607803345,
0.2717995047569275,
0.5361486673355103,
-0.5334680676460266,
0.1886916309595108,
0.05975867435336113,
-0.5653539299964905,
0.39196649193763733,
-0.5479439496994019,
-0.38917192816734314,
0.11054480820894241,
-0.20058831572532654,
-0.9476854801177979,
0.24307093024253845,
0.4611746668815613,
-0.2004341036081314,
0.487806111574173,
0.09444110095500946,
-0.3829439878463745,
-0.5995530486106873,
-0.16592243313789368,
-0.2112027406692505,
0.16717438399791718,
-0.03382273390889168,
0.5469619631767273,
0.5436453819274902,
-0.8391973972320557,
-0.5892281532287598,
-0.6826860308647156,
0.33248406648635864,
-0.4632490873336792,
-0.47326746582984924,
0.37097272276878357,
0.294399231672287,
-0.3359014391899109,
0.02018970251083374,
-0.10807781666517258,
-0.20960605144500732,
0.5507622361183167,
0.3719954788684845,
0.698001503944397,
0.017861777916550636,
0.221819207072258,
-0.18880948424339294,
-0.8199290633201599,
0.2303013950586319,
-0.41073113679885864,
0.29026126861572266,
-0.1302335262298584,
-0.10686403512954712,
-0.2750421464443207,
0.3966245651245117,
-0.16014260053634644,
-0.2592986822128296,
0.7724047303199768,
0.6395557522773743,
-0.784593403339386,
0.06374257802963257,
-0.6066365838050842,
0.2639889419078827,
-0.5134247541427612,
-0.029727142304182053,
0.1632092148065567,
-0.7322787642478943,
0.5342016816139221,
-0.10709352791309357,
0.009894222021102905,
0.8476700186729431,
0.18049202859401703,
-0.30797961354255676,
0.4848535358905792,
1.2456778287887573,
-0.27713149785995483,
0.6032158136367798,
-0.15893933176994324,
0.5676639676094055,
-0.18324410915374756,
-0.19646844267845154,
-0.952475905418396,
-0.06976860761642456,
-0.5299185514450073,
-0.37683984637260437,
0.10766354948282242,
-0.04026868939399719,
0.23574285209178925,
0.6693661212921143,
-0.2845177948474884,
0.1460845023393631,
0.601308286190033,
-0.21235661208629608,
0.48508420586586,
-0.12043625116348267,
-0.12250322103500366,
-0.04900806397199631,
-0.17814038693904877,
-0.7496033310890198,
1.127913475036621,
0.8132935166358948,
0.7558672428131104,
-0.20607316493988037,
0.5863310098648071,
0.6644294261932373,
0.416032999753952,
-0.607068657875061,
0.039449967443943024,
-0.09894707053899765,
-0.6734876036643982,
-0.6118870973587036,
-0.490334689617157,
-0.4617992043495178,
-0.4279096722602844,
-0.55966717004776,
-0.5472535490989685,
0.18759532272815704,
0.01704479567706585,
-0.6773220896720886,
0.30701497197151184,
-0.5621166229248047,
0.7767639756202698,
-0.264757364988327,
0.5502420663833618,
0.05066467449069023,
-0.3389906585216522,
0.6169340014457703,
-0.38064709305763245,
0.6516218781471252,
-0.27504676580429077,
0.2646316587924957,
0.7826360464096069,
-0.0421757735311985,
0.9148106575012207,
-0.06051626428961754,
-0.419722318649292,
0.5187893509864807,
-0.18803295493125916,
0.5285392999649048,
0.350119024515152,
-0.33709925413131714,
0.014300158247351646,
-0.0400053896009922,
-0.06552667170763016,
-0.31272801756858826,
0.3890225887298584,
-0.08475810289382935,
-0.1321219801902771,
-0.7281850576400757,
-0.6778455972671509,
-0.07051508128643036,
0.011612088419497013,
-0.17617301642894745,
-0.03240356221795082,
-0.269587904214859,
-0.15064840018749237,
0.21854616701602936,
-0.5116797685623169,
0.7078422904014587,
0.4001971483230591,
-0.16782209277153015,
-0.23787270486354828,
0.6805453300476074,
-0.14134468138217926,
0.031323377043008804,
0.715100109577179,
0.3968432545661926,
-0.524438202381134,
-0.5506356358528137,
0.18410846590995789,
-0.21236689388751984,
-0.65251225233078,
-0.4526282548904419,
-0.426141619682312,
-0.30184805393218994,
-0.6408975124359131,
-0.3365364372730255,
-0.04987972229719162,
-0.2874698340892792,
-0.2187236249446869,
-0.4396471679210663,
0.6962714791297913,
0.3329355716705322,
-0.1378084421157837,
0.27350273728370667,
-0.9811632633209229,
0.6404457092285156,
0.3871811628341675,
0.5875147581100464,
-0.2001994550228119,
-0.1069098636507988,
-0.35296833515167236,
-0.19219686090946198,
0.014013641513884068,
-0.6782613396644592,
0.9149858951568604,
0.2970975339412689,
0.7167102098464966,
0.6625257730484009,
0.07311464101076126,
0.18711937963962555,
-0.15186668932437897,
0.06634528934955597,
0.06294053792953491,
-0.8218977451324463,
0.7891565561294556,
-0.25137531757354736,
-0.03902782127261162,
0.5883911848068237,
0.5722365379333496,
-0.7969322800636292,
-0.3296290934085846,
-0.6956208944320679,
-0.7933934926986694,
0.55527263879776,
0.06502323597669601,
-0.24712646007537842,
-0.08660303801298141,
0.4145162105560303,
-0.11321459710597992,
0.1714305728673935,
-0.7510666847229004,
-0.05013061687350273,
0.012563390657305717,
-0.11754067987203598,
-0.13366661965847015,
-0.5085474848747253,
0.14738838374614716,
-0.05349485203623772,
0.5442468523979187,
-0.18678796291351318,
0.17368283867835999,
0.04966334253549576,
0.1324949860572815,
-0.2946470379829407,
0.20636649429798126,
0.33787140250205994,
0.18952052295207977,
-0.6682842373847961,
-0.1266402006149292,
-0.06398070603609085,
-0.48464348912239075,
-0.1131371408700943,
0.403068870306015,
-0.12107528746128082,
0.057917118072509766,
0.6641638278961182,
0.4283062815666199,
0.6994883418083191,
-0.9162758588790894,
0.47774142026901245,
-0.2174825668334961,
-0.12554523348808289,
-0.7795565128326416,
-0.012177170254290104,
0.16875000298023224,
0.06427882611751556,
0.716549813747406,
0.5886829495429993,
0.6024523377418518,
-0.7347618341445923,
0.6047681570053101,
0.3541267514228821,
-0.5784338116645813,
0.19673492014408112,
0.45303216576576233,
0.10896754264831543,
-0.3119974136352539,
0.453390896320343,
0.07349245995283127,
-0.4970022737979889,
0.9019800424575806,
0.5525721907615662,
0.9794557094573975,
-0.2619333565235138,
0.32841652631759644,
0.21620094776153564,
0.3956628143787384,
-0.22247684001922607,
0.5981637835502625,
0.35978931188583374,
-0.8224471807479858,
-0.715910792350769,
-0.9844154715538025,
-0.32219788432121277,
-0.06882719695568085,
-0.828072190284729,
0.5037437677383423,
-0.6091369986534119,
-0.24327106773853302,
0.47263336181640625,
0.08786461502313614,
-0.4386221468448639,
0.3347606360912323,
0.43908530473709106,
1.1785037517547607,
-0.9176163673400879,
0.5368086099624634,
0.1251605600118637,
0.11683087795972824,
-0.4329884648323059,
-0.17129971086978912,
0.2420344203710556,
-0.5241919159889221,
0.6680874824523926,
0.44928669929504395,
0.15083664655685425,
-0.2858552634716034,
-0.0819762647151947,
-0.7941968441009521,
0.7198715806007385,
0.02156451903283596,
-0.5416937470436096,
-0.23524174094200134,
0.2674543261528015,
0.37842032313346863,
-0.2612065374851227,
-0.23539209365844727,
0.6904343962669373,
0.7734832763671875,
0.1356487274169922,
-0.5823027491569519,
-0.35254785418510437,
-0.141590878367424,
-0.114158995449543,
0.58432936668396,
0.3326868712902069,
0.6963216662406921,
-0.0037473447155207396,
-0.06803981214761734,
-0.2191951423883438,
0.567391037940979,
-0.14085257053375244,
0.5129836201667786,
0.5589179396629333,
0.5002833604812622,
0.7140145301818848,
-0.1718485951423645,
1.1396362781524658,
-0.03521331772208214,
0.29225340485572815,
0.7961385846138,
-0.313724547624588,
0.8374361991882324,
0.18964147567749023,
-0.2539161741733551,
0.45074471831321716,
0.4791452884674072,
-0.16707660257816315,
0.2813934087753296,
0.25400757789611816,
-0.2667520344257355,
-0.1185491532087326,
0.034567318856716156,
0.1436755508184433,
0.7690178155899048,
0.7512996792793274,
-0.4926203787326813,
-0.2084207534790039,
0.21857185661792755,
-0.39411526918411255,
0.2569817900657654,
-0.3778233230113983,
0.6241640448570251,
0.2856152057647705,
-0.06952615082263947,
-0.17324946820735931,
0.4300280809402466,
0.8626667261123657,
-0.8299066424369812,
-0.10847383737564087,
0.5983479619026184,
-0.08882744610309601,
0.04903247952461243,
-0.7284614443778992,
1.1642423868179321,
0.014399874024093151,
-0.24129459261894226,
-0.4901420474052429,
1.362035870552063,
-0.06365852057933807,
-0.8358785510063171,
0.5199188590049744,
0.09368975460529327,
-0.222885400056839,
-0.5820485949516296,
-0.7058480978012085,
-0.7024953365325928,
-0.26582613587379456,
-0.19490237534046173,
0.3647812008857727,
0.2182244211435318,
-0.06108454614877701,
0.8979578614234924,
1.1131969690322876,
0.028376448899507523,
-0.2068834900856018,
0.030435733497142792,
0.32581496238708496,
-1.0977141857147217,
-0.6267282962799072,
-0.8182588815689087,
0.09954497963190079,
-0.15493640303611755,
-0.19174246490001678,
0.44641613960266113,
0.4376069903373718,
0.5570648312568665,
-0.22628040611743927,
0.49786919355392456,
0.12657874822616577,
0.6750587224960327,
-0.8307076096534729,
0.6807970404624939,
0.06314463168382645,
0.3510894477367401,
-0.6537421345710754,
-0.44792258739471436,
-0.8412109613418579,
0.7566587328910828,
-0.5179644823074341,
-0.38923677802085876,
0.41554829478263855,
0.18193627893924713,
0.5602471232414246,
0.324830561876297,
0.1348724514245987,
-0.37718749046325684,
0.17994704842567444,
0.2730675935745239,
0.1984151154756546,
-0.6413933038711548,
0.556740403175354,
-0.5182269811630249,
0.13163629174232483,
-0.5456613302230835,
-1.27311110496521,
-0.5873466730117798,
-0.41627246141433716,
-0.37761223316192627,
0.10453146696090698,
-0.5369188785552979,
0.5251457691192627,
0.1393253207206726,
-0.8167430758476257,
-0.1062762513756752,
-0.13838641345500946,
0.29455968737602234,
-0.5495397448539734,
-0.2981002628803253,
0.2143230438232422,
-0.24194230139255524,
-0.46137693524360657,
0.3449794352054596,
0.6850991249084473,
0.5056087374687195,
-0.08114038407802582,
0.38234561681747437,
-0.6354317665100098,
0.014029697515070438,
0.42040643095970154,
0.3204074501991272,
-0.10797326266765594,
-0.290409117937088,
-0.09408386051654816,
-0.02904355712234974,
-0.2843184173107147,
0.7527271509170532,
-0.3466821610927582,
-0.022882208228111267,
0.4199047088623047,
0.6134291291236877,
0.28975749015808105,
-0.1731864959001541,
0.7637855410575867,
-0.6964611411094666,
0.4317120611667633,
0.35810109972953796,
0.40085726976394653,
0.17479540407657623,
-0.9584435820579529,
0.5352551937103271,
0.061163321137428284,
-0.2615671753883362,
-0.3646879196166992,
-0.03904115781188011,
-1.0085774660110474,
-0.37228596210479736,
0.49724045395851135,
-0.03236977010965347,
-0.3193289637565613,
-0.5163757801055908,
-0.14610570669174194,
0.1884484738111496,
-0.1638820469379425,
0.6855593323707581,
0.7468923330307007,
0.14155738055706024,
0.004312196280807257,
-1.0363260507583618,
0.733486533164978,
-0.20122474431991577,
-0.7803938388824463,
-0.04766930267214775,
-0.205495685338974,
0.06516760587692261,
0.5229198336601257,
0.5928978323936462,
-0.2223144769668579,
0.24180802702903748,
0.029476439580321312,
0.3262220025062561,
0.00538784172385931,
-0.16282610595226288,
-0.34783098101615906,
0.28037676215171814,
-0.09201205521821976,
0.14027324318885803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09760v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09760v1
|
Bootstrapping Language Models with DPO Implicit Rewards
| 2024-06-14T06:57:18 | 2024-06-14T06:57:18 |
Changyu Chen, Zichen Liu, Chao Du, Tianyu Pang, Qian Liu, Arunesh Sinha, Pradeep Varakantham, Min Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Human alignment in large language models (LLMs) is an active area of
research. A recent groundbreaking work, direct preference optimization (DPO),
has greatly simplified the process from past work in reinforcement learning
from human feedback (RLHF) by bypassing the reward learning stage in RLHF. DPO,
after training, provides an implicit reward model. In this work, we make a
novel observation that this implicit reward model can by itself be used in a
bootstrapping fashion to further align the LLM. Our approach is to use the
rewards from a current LLM model to construct a preference dataset, which is
then used in subsequent DPO rounds. We incorporate refinements that debias the
length of the responses and improve the quality of the preference dataset to
further improve our approach. Our approach, named self-alignment with DPO
ImpliCit rEwards (DICE), shows great improvements in alignment and achieves
superior performance than Gemini Pro on AlpacaEval 2, reaching 27.55%
length-controlled win rate against GPT-4 Turbo, but with only 8B parameters and
no external feedback. Our code is available at https://github.com/sail-sg/dice.
|
[
-0.08162606507539749,
-0.11797440052032471,
0.6559026837348938,
0.3096848726272583,
-0.2724362909793854,
0.2749565541744232,
-0.1636108011007309,
-0.41255924105644226,
0.19717112183570862,
0.242896169424057,
-0.8425307869911194,
-0.32179293036460876,
-0.5731819272041321,
0.10121635347604752,
-0.12066509574651718,
1.1159334182739258,
-0.14317640662193298,
0.016295401379466057,
-0.18899746239185333,
0.011507409624755383,
-0.22984564304351807,
-0.3743113577365875,
-0.6481053233146667,
-0.42699936032295227,
0.7106212973594666,
0.6560629606246948,
0.5433750152587891,
1.031497597694397,
0.4271024167537689,
0.3066776990890503,
0.2322542816400528,
-0.007045506499707699,
-0.5046505331993103,
0.176594078540802,
-0.02269337698817253,
-0.27336210012435913,
-0.4222516119480133,
0.30868759751319885,
0.6255961060523987,
0.22271662950515747,
-0.34217369556427,
-0.06795148551464081,
0.09500875324010849,
1.0149381160736084,
-0.5981300473213196,
0.12926238775253296,
-0.6001476049423218,
0.11832936853170395,
-0.06677503138780594,
-0.1904306411743164,
-0.24822312593460083,
-0.5309866666793823,
-0.011084784753620625,
-0.8708247542381287,
-0.026700282469391823,
0.0008694560965523124,
0.592635989189148,
0.7002562880516052,
-0.15310008823871613,
-0.4249725937843323,
-0.5548281073570251,
0.6681326031684875,
-0.5006681680679321,
0.06552208960056305,
0.18000003695487976,
0.24534600973129272,
-0.3347412347793579,
-0.19561932981014252,
-0.46936172246932983,
-0.36655211448669434,
0.028990741819143295,
0.14617788791656494,
0.14444184303283691,
-0.00019203622650820762,
-0.03165431320667267,
0.3200628459453583,
-0.36969777941703796,
0.6118704676628113,
-0.22284770011901855,
-0.20927752554416656,
0.9082891345024109,
0.12660452723503113,
-0.009598729200661182,
-0.07365312427282333,
-0.7491559982299805,
-0.26786285638809204,
-0.7621954083442688,
0.34172600507736206,
0.7941883206367493,
0.2723512351512909,
-0.21280735731124878,
0.5589277744293213,
-0.3087804317474365,
0.8084093332290649,
0.4818004071712494,
-0.41434425115585327,
0.3134450614452362,
0.10121661424636841,
0.10867032408714294,
0.2419944554567337,
0.8721706867218018,
0.29645591974258423,
0.3191962242126465,
-0.09886776655912399,
-0.4330882430076599,
-0.0532686784863472,
0.21458843350410461,
-0.6600502133369446,
-0.002385201398283243,
0.4301978349685669,
-0.18542061746120453,
-0.707711935043335,
-0.16425563395023346,
-0.6749544143676758,
-0.5456916689872742,
-0.35813167691230774,
0.32102465629577637,
-0.3953750431537628,
-0.15569239854812622,
0.12272599339485168,
-0.026443414390087128,
0.14502288401126862,
0.2489546537399292,
-1.3627057075500488,
0.4195420742034912,
1.0014667510986328,
0.7046617865562439,
-0.6045900583267212,
-0.4502287209033966,
-0.9427332878112793,
0.0947110503911972,
-0.3601427972316742,
0.6389985084533691,
-0.3982485234737396,
-0.20527808368206024,
0.008292651735246181,
-0.26763054728507996,
0.24292656779289246,
-0.37475064396858215,
0.4328871965408325,
-0.4458947479724884,
0.1864936202764511,
-0.34691160917282104,
-0.6342113018035889,
0.30591532588005066,
0.18380017578601837,
-0.49764037132263184,
1.095224380493164,
-0.08501891791820526,
-0.516249418258667,
0.5135309100151062,
-0.4763726592063904,
-0.2578241229057312,
0.07173636555671692,
-0.4806746542453766,
-0.33374980092048645,
0.014140278100967407,
0.14852191507816315,
0.3609534800052643,
-0.2246197909116745,
0.3336031138896942,
-0.39552560448646545,
-0.5909554958343506,
0.12194870412349701,
-0.023287879303097725,
0.40486830472946167,
0.10843539983034134,
-0.722209632396698,
0.13729111850261688,
-0.7832129597663879,
-0.053609658032655716,
0.20700660347938538,
-0.3408440053462982,
-0.2653956413269043,
0.06324135512113571,
-0.34995654225349426,
0.35118165612220764,
0.260969340801239,
-0.5710775852203369,
0.699335515499115,
-0.39103996753692627,
0.128575399518013,
1.2930316925048828,
-0.4412398338317871,
0.7060254812240601,
-0.07263022661209106,
0.5832664370536804,
-0.03225388377904892,
0.251335471868515,
0.24003548920154572,
-0.148989737033844,
-0.6249090433120728,
-0.6623172760009766,
0.5930299162864685,
0.2578166127204895,
-0.5046772360801697,
0.6042003035545349,
-0.23282741010189056,
-0.3212900161743164,
-0.8054270148277283,
0.0489293597638607,
0.3370170593261719,
0.6340653896331787,
0.3470494747161865,
-0.16161520779132843,
-0.28520190715789795,
-1.1835469007492065,
0.06330613791942596,
-0.3642421364784241,
-0.07340343296527863,
0.21137762069702148,
0.31427666544914246,
0.01127677969634533,
0.9958708882331848,
-0.7328782677650452,
-0.27114439010620117,
-0.008154566399753094,
0.1697445511817932,
0.06783279031515121,
0.5557303428649902,
0.43898507952690125,
-0.4032244086265564,
-0.36062100529670715,
-0.31626519560813904,
-0.3623514175415039,
-0.2492843121290207,
-0.0436580590903759,
-0.19360849261283875,
0.4398510456085205,
0.17983685433864594,
-0.3949418365955353,
0.05900447815656662,
0.6639745831489563,
-0.3490641117095947,
0.4652974605560303,
-0.17175912857055664,
0.2759753465652466,
-0.6686546206474304,
0.006482863798737526,
-0.11919370293617249,
-0.22865448892116547,
-0.10632079839706421,
-0.3314448297023773,
0.24684453010559082,
0.1529472917318344,
-0.33981966972351074,
0.6942014098167419,
-0.3614625334739685,
-0.22164562344551086,
-0.5553136467933655,
0.012411147356033325,
-0.16609884798526764,
0.6748536229133606,
0.39903831481933594,
0.8915181756019592,
0.3288894295692444,
-0.6417883634567261,
0.4265038073062897,
0.1695021390914917,
-0.3055312931537628,
0.4184454679489136,
-0.6559906005859375,
0.168712317943573,
-0.17563201487064362,
0.22241303324699402,
-1.021662950515747,
-0.08480562269687653,
0.5077465772628784,
-0.38239288330078125,
0.3479800224304199,
-0.20837320387363434,
-0.2528703212738037,
-0.13249120116233826,
-0.5125032067298889,
0.393067330121994,
0.6015629172325134,
-0.8456225395202637,
0.12379667907953262,
0.38587501645088196,
-0.14113777875900269,
-1.0173605680465698,
-0.1891232579946518,
-0.22255820035934448,
-0.25552764534950256,
-0.2522609531879425,
0.7042718529701233,
-0.23841175436973572,
-0.07717073708772659,
-0.29666271805763245,
-0.22921231389045715,
0.2599809169769287,
0.08429484069347382,
0.14387337863445282,
0.3985537588596344,
0.23481251299381256,
0.4555821120738983,
0.04467998817563057,
-0.42962610721588135,
-0.03768276795744896,
-0.3931216597557068,
0.5845732092857361,
0.000132447385112755,
-0.23676536977291107,
-0.21438702940940857,
0.19341441988945007,
0.32125815749168396,
-0.05768917500972748,
0.6034611463546753,
0.36443522572517395,
-0.006648887414485216,
-0.15907560288906097,
-0.7348665595054626,
-0.24161995947360992,
-0.49061983823776245,
0.059599414467811584,
-0.38832888007164,
-0.8294556140899658,
0.293530136346817,
0.05159561708569527,
-0.0902460440993309,
0.5501012802124023,
0.47332099080085754,
-0.12838801741600037,
0.9172884225845337,
0.7683987021446228,
-0.3864911198616028,
0.4193399250507355,
0.09515071660280228,
-0.3417961001396179,
-0.7361456751823425,
-0.4272819757461548,
-0.4035739600658417,
-0.5047891736030579,
-0.5343143939971924,
-0.27303260564804077,
0.14215484261512756,
-0.11355964094400406,
-0.41169971227645874,
0.10451485216617584,
-0.5883584022521973,
0.3815336227416992,
0.5278159379959106,
0.00904302578419447,
0.269216388463974,
-0.027567222714424133,
-0.39386841654777527,
-0.20180970430374146,
-0.7086958289146423,
-0.31843358278274536,
0.9697040319442749,
0.42796754837036133,
0.9591080546379089,
-0.10337652266025543,
1.0102626085281372,
0.3213854134082794,
0.2530772089958191,
-0.6481720209121704,
0.3920411467552185,
0.13188554346561432,
-0.3745402991771698,
-0.519619345664978,
-0.5087593793869019,
-0.8368054628372192,
0.04236159101128578,
-0.18235673010349274,
-0.5889545679092407,
0.16481736302375793,
0.19720004498958588,
-0.565369188785553,
-0.07060851901769638,
-0.2627127170562744,
0.7361525297164917,
-0.657142698764801,
-0.6857401132583618,
-0.02469567582011223,
-0.6344965696334839,
0.2660016715526581,
0.035499539226293564,
0.09593091160058975,
-0.5019097924232483,
-0.3850710690021515,
0.8361661434173584,
-0.5041904449462891,
0.6136248707771301,
-0.08061514794826508,
-0.39406147599220276,
-0.05196431279182434,
-0.056751105934381485,
0.515597403049469,
0.22908422350883484,
-0.15393850207328796,
-0.09813180565834045,
-0.22894684970378876,
-0.32427358627319336,
-0.560350239276886,
0.9531882405281067,
-0.9402742385864258,
-0.6488372683525085,
-0.8553375005722046,
-0.5057002305984497,
-0.22863829135894775,
-0.07605954259634018,
0.1856682151556015,
0.10474535077810287,
-0.1644957959651947,
-0.28941428661346436,
0.5031333565711975,
-0.03522234410047531,
0.4987110495567322,
0.8183910250663757,
-0.29447442293167114,
-0.5374438762664795,
0.5490513443946838,
-0.1517259180545807,
0.3027481734752655,
0.39875760674476624,
0.3191103935241699,
-0.6171668171882629,
-0.21489310264587402,
-0.7032999992370605,
0.3450845181941986,
-0.4835178554058075,
-0.2714795470237732,
-0.2875877320766449,
0.05630915239453316,
-0.39908379316329956,
-0.14235934615135193,
-0.8033215403556824,
-0.6144712567329407,
0.026763414964079857,
-0.11225343495607376,
0.4793286621570587,
0.8414387702941895,
-0.23069129884243011,
0.15141701698303223,
-0.5066671967506409,
0.20628857612609863,
0.4075319468975067,
0.7015873789787292,
-0.2192455381155014,
-0.4988223612308502,
-0.10669005662202835,
-0.07902888208627701,
-0.13694781064987183,
-0.8729803562164307,
0.3188660144805908,
-0.2643485367298126,
0.5106640458106995,
0.21277235448360443,
-0.010462895967066288,
0.6777780055999756,
-0.5898265838623047,
0.44292858242988586,
0.45763474702835083,
-0.9134783744812012,
0.49926382303237915,
-0.4554429352283478,
0.28863510489463806,
0.8690792322158813,
0.6644507646560669,
-0.48078763484954834,
-0.015920504927635193,
-0.6109205484390259,
-0.7482265830039978,
0.7995309233665466,
0.08384035527706146,
-0.22887921333312988,
-0.03659823536872864,
0.731013834476471,
0.3534362316131592,
0.39071816205978394,
-0.9223066568374634,
-0.2390914410352707,
0.12680019438266754,
-0.44760188460350037,
-0.16064338386058807,
-0.3558987081050873,
-0.39717748761177063,
-0.2104424238204956,
0.910828709602356,
-0.30921414494514465,
0.0909121185541153,
0.1970026046037674,
0.024898579344153404,
-0.22272051870822906,
0.07245250046253204,
0.4838862419128418,
0.5644807815551758,
-0.18006867170333862,
0.019749922677874565,
-0.053900349885225296,
-0.18552158772945404,
0.6980371475219727,
0.19951698184013367,
-0.1416834145784378,
-0.3735153377056122,
0.07830005884170532,
0.580771267414093,
0.35261401534080505,
-0.5107829570770264,
0.5237522721290588,
-0.07602319866418839,
-0.13897742331027985,
-0.2459009289741516,
0.07971643656492233,
0.03449419140815735,
0.0930975005030632,
0.3917359709739685,
-0.26757222414016724,
0.14466935396194458,
-0.4314209520816803,
0.11075685918331146,
0.5321030616760254,
-0.6561905145645142,
-0.021716896444559097,
0.5634669661521912,
0.4635268449783325,
-0.18133243918418884,
0.6370877623558044,
-0.19659048318862915,
-0.4385708272457123,
0.5577207207679749,
0.4901285469532013,
0.6841774582862854,
-0.3283829987049103,
0.42144396901130676,
0.3758675754070282,
0.18158839643001556,
-0.32270297408103943,
-0.06468529254198074,
-0.16929543018341064,
-0.675230860710144,
-0.49307361245155334,
-0.5754810571670532,
-0.449468731880188,
0.15758074820041656,
-0.4991688132286072,
0.5228500962257385,
-0.3253795802593231,
0.16705018281936646,
-0.15547464787960052,
0.036373116075992584,
-0.46817103028297424,
0.2625752389431,
0.38784247636795044,
0.6870256662368774,
-0.8072317838668823,
0.8142518401145935,
0.42472851276397705,
-0.39783239364624023,
-0.6762033700942993,
0.043929558247327805,
0.08517089486122131,
-0.9425004124641418,
0.7506115436553955,
0.27439162135124207,
-0.3420688807964325,
-0.07575567066669464,
-0.3522571325302124,
-1.0800966024398804,
1.1322906017303467,
0.3893224596977234,
-0.7365397214889526,
0.10127712786197662,
0.2257176637649536,
0.3564201891422272,
-0.6272491216659546,
0.3898856043815613,
0.5633102059364319,
0.3375324308872223,
0.25891777873039246,
-0.6904499530792236,
0.17397932708263397,
-0.044574953615665436,
-0.07039870321750641,
0.25278240442276,
-0.904421329498291,
0.4932746887207031,
-0.18730394542217255,
0.09586028009653091,
-0.09871189296245575,
0.764340341091156,
0.5104817152023315,
-0.023703651502728462,
0.7452004551887512,
0.5409397482872009,
0.7073493599891663,
-0.02857484668493271,
0.9534667134284973,
-0.2743147611618042,
0.1855430155992508,
1.091787338256836,
-0.40593263506889343,
0.7858311533927917,
0.7284228801727295,
-0.08455400168895721,
0.6295149326324463,
0.8338947296142578,
0.31352755427360535,
0.6951950788497925,
0.42688652873039246,
-0.0701962485909462,
-0.3606671988964081,
0.17723731696605682,
-0.4786049723625183,
0.5407185554504395,
-0.2461136281490326,
-0.0963173434138298,
0.1684013307094574,
-0.38666582107543945,
0.05273855850100517,
0.1251630336046219,
-0.18053551018238068,
0.8060129880905151,
-0.1720028817653656,
-1.1970099210739136,
0.4738239645957947,
-0.03527471050620079,
0.8783308267593384,
-0.8649532794952393,
-0.06421880424022675,
-0.30439499020576477,
0.27547118067741394,
-0.0741967186331749,
-0.6087512969970703,
0.047178737819194794,
-0.04868576303124428,
-0.1169794574379921,
-0.2791973650455475,
0.5308260917663574,
-0.6047604084014893,
-0.3957670331001282,
0.4199824631214142,
0.1965886652469635,
-0.136750265955925,
0.026541929692029953,
-0.7585452795028687,
0.2725941836833954,
-0.06861275434494019,
-0.3221791088581085,
0.545805811882019,
0.07830215245485306,
0.2617625296115875,
0.728702962398529,
0.48821985721588135,
-0.0471174456179142,
-0.3009343147277832,
-0.12571676075458527,
0.7882142663002014,
-0.6783775687217712,
-0.6481905579566956,
-1.1120495796203613,
0.6032820343971252,
-0.2692612409591675,
-0.44309642910957336,
0.5386627316474915,
0.7984189391136169,
0.6271044611930847,
-0.1396491825580597,
0.6366301774978638,
0.11944151669740677,
0.4491909444332123,
-0.67792147397995,
0.40805140137672424,
-0.6273447275161743,
0.31378570199012756,
-0.2959415018558502,
-0.8847159147262573,
0.20001095533370972,
0.567052960395813,
-0.300832599401474,
0.01623852364718914,
0.6280001401901245,
0.5118086338043213,
0.14037948846817017,
-0.2933073937892914,
0.06481154263019562,
-0.13579656183719635,
0.04614490270614624,
0.5622539520263672,
0.8698772192001343,
-0.22108964622020721,
0.5080710649490356,
-0.3408530056476593,
-0.6067138314247131,
-0.1770627349615097,
-1.2584164142608643,
-0.5492913126945496,
-0.6606499552726746,
-0.41562947630882263,
-0.27949008345603943,
0.2116619050502777,
1.1622675657272339,
0.6646549105644226,
-0.5243780016899109,
-0.5021088719367981,
0.01361882034689188,
0.2519214153289795,
-0.2570348381996155,
-0.14542996883392334,
0.1631154865026474,
-0.6182056069374084,
-0.8761911988258362,
0.5617173314094543,
0.44000667333602905,
0.07888983190059662,
-0.26272037625312805,
-0.4018871784210205,
-0.2382429540157318,
-0.02377813495695591,
0.22669768333435059,
0.25252848863601685,
-0.5914568901062012,
-0.41118964552879333,
0.12250983715057373,
-0.3014295995235443,
0.17281536757946014,
0.8080582618713379,
-0.921709418296814,
0.17090728878974915,
0.2727508246898651,
0.5787588357925415,
0.6820448637008667,
0.16645580530166626,
1.0282230377197266,
-0.6499028205871582,
0.3234890401363373,
0.15249797701835632,
0.3696022629737854,
0.3455338776111603,
-0.6157493591308594,
0.7165098190307617,
0.011321374215185642,
-0.6050658822059631,
-0.48265737295150757,
0.405703067779541,
-0.9059975743293762,
-0.16609680652618408,
1.3471543788909912,
0.09683623909950256,
-0.16506926715373993,
0.38584405183792114,
-0.17190761864185333,
0.11255378276109695,
-0.5668609142303467,
1.208333134651184,
0.7268743515014648,
-0.16959436237812042,
0.1660390943288803,
0.003994709812104702,
0.9935705065727234,
0.7062233090400696,
-0.8050312399864197,
-0.0012728319270536304,
0.4871982932090759,
0.44828906655311584,
-0.04735912010073662,
1.0506327152252197,
-0.19199612736701965,
0.27107611298561096,
-0.2922365367412567,
0.41280820965766907,
-0.26027700304985046,
-0.4504118859767914,
-0.5606204271316528,
0.030093640089035034,
0.2734037935733795,
-0.3596550226211548
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10311v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10311v1
|
CHiSafetyBench: A Chinese Hierarchical Safety Benchmark for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-14T06:47:40 | 2024-06-14T06:47:40 |
Wenjing Zhang, Xuejiao Lei, Zhaoxiang Liu, Meijuan An, Bikun Yang, KaiKai Zhao, Kai Wang, Shiguo Lian
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
With the profound development of large language models(LLMs), their safety
concerns have garnered increasing attention. However, there is a scarcity of
Chinese safety benchmarks for LLMs, and the existing safety taxonomies are
inadequate, lacking comprehensive safety detection capabilities in authentic
Chinese scenarios. In this work, we introduce CHiSafetyBench, a dedicated
safety benchmark for evaluating LLMs' capabilities in identifying risky content
and refusing answering risky questions in Chinese contexts. CHiSafetyBench
incorporates a dataset that covers a hierarchical Chinese safety taxonomy
consisting of 5 risk areas and 31 categories. This dataset comprises two types
of tasks: multiple-choice questions and question-answering, evaluating LLMs
from the perspectives of risk content identification and the ability to refuse
answering risky questions respectively. Utilizing this benchmark, we validate
the feasibility of automatic evaluation as a substitute for human evaluation
and conduct comprehensive automatic safety assessments on mainstream Chinese
LLMs. Our experiments reveal the varying performance of different models across
various safety domains, indicating that all models possess considerable
potential for improvement in Chinese safety capabilities. Our dataset is
publicly available at
https://github.com/UnicomAI/DataSet/tree/main/TestData/Safety.
|
[
-0.0016314071835950017,
-0.7364392280578613,
0.23759841918945312,
0.44202399253845215,
-0.229990154504776,
0.03396330028772354,
-0.13410140573978424,
-0.7100352644920349,
-0.34827136993408203,
0.2783263027667999,
-0.35652872920036316,
-0.49771174788475037,
-0.4009939134120941,
-0.004380831029266119,
-0.5207470655441284,
0.8829867839813232,
-0.07613427191972733,
0.14477404952049255,
0.0704425796866417,
0.15500469505786896,
-0.3385753631591797,
-0.33652907609939575,
-0.8056594133377075,
-0.25507527589797974,
0.5696553587913513,
-0.050701916217803955,
0.6941782832145691,
0.7753158211708069,
0.6096280813217163,
0.336971640586853,
-0.019771499559283257,
-0.20952259004116058,
-0.1511051207780838,
-0.06516536325216293,
-0.3043156862258911,
-0.24050118029117584,
-0.48098671436309814,
-0.10196077823638916,
0.6412308216094971,
0.7158913016319275,
-0.11103426665067673,
0.17166577279567719,
0.49760252237319946,
0.1724957972764969,
-0.6984496712684631,
0.09278391301631927,
-0.7672076225280762,
-0.006930294446647167,
-0.11271822452545166,
-0.119973324239254,
-0.1954641193151474,
-0.7253821492195129,
0.09395158290863037,
-0.17387142777442932,
-0.06451386958360672,
0.13357067108154297,
0.9548604488372803,
0.17413492500782013,
-0.5616236329078674,
-0.03210901468992233,
-0.2820063531398773,
0.6847893595695496,
-0.5954073667526245,
0.386355996131897,
0.6653815507888794,
0.5287606120109558,
-0.23266609013080597,
-0.5355839729309082,
-0.2907601594924927,
-0.57060307264328,
0.007541093975305557,
-0.14815811812877655,
0.14474301040172577,
0.11334436386823654,
0.05031244084239006,
0.3040083646774292,
-0.8741379976272583,
0.15901333093643188,
0.013952188193798065,
-0.5912805795669556,
0.7834014296531677,
0.28890565037727356,
0.5661324858665466,
-0.2810458540916443,
-0.5130705237388611,
-0.3079701066017151,
-0.8029953837394714,
0.24510227143764496,
0.12330589443445206,
0.3285815119743347,
-0.2568643093109131,
0.2736845016479492,
-0.20951715111732483,
0.40136706829071045,
-0.461350679397583,
-0.3145577013492584,
0.25353753566741943,
-0.38599488139152527,
-0.2432882934808731,
0.029357973486185074,
1.024807333946228,
0.4519026279449463,
0.10177097469568253,
-0.28825846314430237,
-0.24764762818813324,
-0.17672233283519745,
0.2466719001531601,
-0.7239628434181213,
-0.22621525824069977,
0.32305261492729187,
-0.384573757648468,
-0.45712730288505554,
0.18040552735328674,
-0.8559166789054871,
-0.6301685571670532,
0.27443262934684753,
0.41055870056152344,
-0.35218214988708496,
-0.2129608690738678,
0.029891323298215866,
0.14326685667037964,
0.4135071337223053,
0.24415162205696106,
-0.5397992730140686,
0.2019595056772232,
0.6523905992507935,
0.7847315669059753,
-0.43939563632011414,
-0.566983699798584,
-0.561643123626709,
0.11070908606052399,
-0.6884317994117737,
0.6984003186225891,
-0.1586865931749344,
-0.2867884337902069,
0.044568464159965515,
0.5072433948516846,
-0.029026973992586136,
-0.46624165773391724,
0.6122241616249084,
-0.40313345193862915,
-0.32326507568359375,
-0.4019874930381775,
0.03470795229077339,
-0.2772791087627411,
0.6409391164779663,
-0.6581600308418274,
0.9568111300468445,
-0.07989055663347244,
-0.8663582801818848,
0.3803464472293854,
-0.08816806226968765,
-0.7222150564193726,
-0.11043912172317505,
-0.18805977702140808,
-0.39875462651252747,
-0.4676792621612549,
-0.09195663034915924,
0.3284991681575775,
-0.7623234391212463,
0.5382440090179443,
-0.6650151610374451,
-0.47786879539489746,
0.34364810585975647,
-0.7669672966003418,
1.04057776927948,
0.056973300874233246,
-0.4812849164009094,
0.3883926272392273,
-0.6832014918327332,
0.12908963859081268,
0.314662903547287,
-0.5298048257827759,
-0.4563606381416321,
-0.030702121555805206,
0.40632164478302,
0.5416505932807922,
0.3085935711860657,
-0.5607134699821472,
-0.4609721004962921,
-0.27957209944725037,
0.17942872643470764,
0.7947313785552979,
-0.05333278328180313,
-0.17865557968616486,
-0.4567992687225342,
0.30848896503448486,
-0.08703561127185822,
0.17390331625938416,
0.14521223306655884,
-0.1936844438314438,
-0.646108865737915,
0.06627046316862106,
0.37159237265586853,
0.7872901558876038,
-0.8049089908599854,
0.7723966836929321,
-0.1678343266248703,
-0.6954149603843689,
-0.20588909089565277,
0.15137051045894623,
0.6169496178627014,
0.30460435152053833,
0.2318786382675171,
-0.13317781686782837,
-0.11291569471359253,
-0.7524421215057373,
-0.21297256648540497,
-0.5677171945571899,
-0.3698238432407379,
-0.08199422806501389,
0.37924036383628845,
0.0159011147916317,
0.4680468440055847,
-0.173366516828537,
0.06031549721956253,
-0.26455333828926086,
0.029168248176574707,
-0.21677415072917938,
0.649128794670105,
0.6860287189483643,
-0.6351433396339417,
-0.20565420389175415,
0.010992837138473988,
-0.7086228728294373,
-0.06465093791484833,
-0.18212394416332245,
-0.2831249237060547,
0.13463640213012695,
0.4600527286529541,
-0.32460513710975647,
0.3954457640647888,
0.4159591495990753,
-0.20198608934879303,
0.6205615997314453,
0.1811007410287857,
0.21062491834163666,
-0.9307477474212646,
0.3701784610748291,
-0.04095056653022766,
-0.07861883193254471,
-0.43985533714294434,
0.4029505252838135,
0.33327776193618774,
0.019767358899116516,
-0.7667397260665894,
0.5223702192306519,
-0.11922070384025574,
-0.10772570222616196,
-0.29521098732948303,
0.10119860619306564,
-0.1645635962486267,
0.4255982041358948,
0.13619466125965118,
0.7002673149108887,
0.5833741426467896,
-0.6441476941108704,
0.2997530996799469,
0.019700368866324425,
-0.4186444878578186,
0.10828104615211487,
-0.9254284501075745,
-0.014318706467747688,
0.2564460039138794,
0.08741757273674011,
-1.1975337266921997,
-0.36838117241859436,
0.30578309297561646,
-0.08105478435754776,
0.07221473008394241,
0.13880285620689392,
-0.5057101249694824,
-0.3677959740161896,
-0.7222886085510254,
0.1637786626815796,
0.1526615172624588,
-0.4002678692340851,
0.28093603253364563,
0.5537232756614685,
-0.37373417615890503,
-0.8284541368484497,
-0.7883017063140869,
0.0563976913690567,
-0.3270496726036072,
-0.4518105089664459,
0.17474958300590515,
-0.26596659421920776,
-0.09988858550786972,
-0.11131977289915085,
-0.28191810846328735,
-0.31778666377067566,
0.5346920490264893,
0.15971404314041138,
0.447780042886734,
-0.06353869289159775,
0.09708703309297562,
0.13095633685588837,
-0.2310924530029297,
0.30860549211502075,
0.2522246539592743,
0.5110530853271484,
-0.2970784306526184,
-0.4092465937137604,
-0.3031674027442932,
0.0398922860622406,
0.2740025222301483,
-0.22753365337848663,
0.5434693098068237,
0.4201619625091553,
-0.7347069382667542,
-0.12664709985256195,
-0.3294573724269867,
-0.08322801440954208,
-0.5454306602478027,
0.4860709607601166,
-0.2306603193283081,
-0.8180261850357056,
0.4063376188278198,
0.015796134248375893,
0.4648561179637909,
0.34125789999961853,
0.5464832186698914,
0.27195966243743896,
0.8734322190284729,
0.42491963505744934,
-0.46778926253318787,
0.002503696596249938,
0.3918265104293823,
0.056080352514982224,
-0.22102677822113037,
-0.04266148805618286,
-0.7609174251556396,
0.18563292920589447,
-0.5916551947593689,
-0.40291523933410645,
0.4886443614959717,
-0.10319823771715164,
-0.43360769748687744,
0.5426263809204102,
-0.16306239366531372,
0.31413036584854126,
0.09886061400175095,
0.03892706334590912,
0.42758846282958984,
-0.25033271312713623,
-0.29850977659225464,
0.23322869837284088,
-0.4592168629169464,
-0.6115468144416809,
0.7221775054931641,
0.586592972278595,
0.9837127923965454,
0.029140843078494072,
0.32752007246017456,
-0.0958990827202797,
0.3421742916107178,
-0.6149969696998596,
0.8350825309753418,
-0.06520095467567444,
-0.7809237241744995,
-0.5093739032745361,
-0.4379103183746338,
-0.825725257396698,
0.376692533493042,
-0.35730206966400146,
-0.7272409200668335,
-0.08615531027317047,
-0.1076638251543045,
-0.5173003077507019,
0.2716691792011261,
-0.17718306183815002,
0.9600943326950073,
-0.6708288192749023,
-0.5005631446838379,
-0.2036357969045639,
-0.6270548701286316,
0.6986168026924133,
-0.4067849814891815,
0.14758749306201935,
-0.3551517426967621,
-0.08402103185653687,
0.6220750212669373,
-0.050573986023664474,
0.8982055187225342,
0.18927673995494843,
-0.28447943925857544,
0.2982955873012543,
0.3455759882926941,
0.2760390043258667,
0.1313595026731491,
-0.5029894113540649,
0.39806103706359863,
0.3826426565647125,
-0.18553034961223602,
-0.13127386569976807,
0.7836244106292725,
-0.537259578704834,
-0.5668115019798279,
-0.58258056640625,
-0.42875394225120544,
-0.46257540583610535,
0.564656138420105,
0.11601009219884872,
0.009567106142640114,
-0.5012727379798889,
0.36256396770477295,
0.2906993627548218,
-0.6753491759300232,
0.5515444278717041,
0.595877468585968,
-0.094875767827034,
-0.11026188731193542,
0.7719723582267761,
0.030305568128824234,
0.12243586778640747,
0.1902109682559967,
0.21044988930225372,
-0.3885054290294647,
-0.6828898191452026,
-0.45023584365844727,
-0.03212989866733551,
-0.8053591251373291,
-0.19295360147953033,
-0.5878774523735046,
-0.6680386662483215,
-0.30586838722229004,
0.09561813622713089,
-0.3228933811187744,
-0.041796743869781494,
0.26371774077415466,
-0.27647626399993896,
-0.03919921815395355,
0.312801331281662,
0.04180849343538284,
-0.09406615793704987,
-0.9534576535224915,
0.3095646798610687,
0.38787996768951416,
0.6500818729400635,
0.17214320600032806,
-0.15852943062782288,
-0.1539282351732254,
-0.23118142783641815,
-0.3416530191898346,
-0.6333514451980591,
0.10167963057756424,
-0.2120441198348999,
0.7504042983055115,
0.5817707777023315,
0.551715075969696,
0.45305731892585754,
-0.41279882192611694,
0.6984694004058838,
-0.012511705979704857,
-0.8902073502540588,
0.3745996654033661,
-0.42904606461524963,
-0.046224191784858704,
0.7772324681282043,
0.5610817670822144,
-0.5650090575218201,
-0.3895187973976135,
-0.037014540284872055,
-0.9201392531394958,
0.5285985469818115,
0.10535990446805954,
0.052112579345703125,
-0.0909392237663269,
0.009162059053778648,
0.13165950775146484,
0.09002262353897095,
-0.9863951206207275,
0.12541747093200684,
-0.12026702612638474,
0.033851366490125656,
0.08411939442157745,
-0.13012011349201202,
-0.18076422810554504,
-0.08670123666524887,
0.6591047048568726,
-0.2158239334821701,
0.012856535613536835,
-0.039111893624067307,
-0.02132798172533512,
-0.3062048554420471,
0.4413737952709198,
0.12082454562187195,
0.4765132963657379,
-0.17701280117034912,
0.25608953833580017,
0.5456939339637756,
-0.5099515318870544,
0.27253401279449463,
0.2905037999153137,
-0.07770681381225586,
-0.3236204981803894,
0.6475524306297302,
0.30138489603996277,
0.24265365302562714,
-1.1111332178115845,
0.39714980125427246,
-0.1022648736834526,
-0.06709404289722443,
-0.3063426613807678,
0.3844965994358063,
0.1283532977104187,
-0.174595907330513,
0.20986920595169067,
-0.47334861755371094,
0.3055943250656128,
-0.41534703969955444,
0.445304274559021,
0.3847696781158447,
-0.5193418264389038,
-0.04820357263088226,
0.7358460426330566,
0.1774662882089615,
0.10252686589956284,
0.2731999456882477,
0.15679901838302612,
-0.26128312945365906,
0.7763431072235107,
0.27011772990226746,
1.0166242122650146,
-0.5340527892112732,
0.1305832713842392,
0.46222877502441406,
0.8067960143089294,
0.010936733335256577,
0.2609899044036865,
0.24414707720279694,
-0.6718370914459229,
-0.06927728652954102,
-0.6569556593894958,
-0.3734399080276489,
0.5475159287452698,
-0.5185458064079285,
0.19305026531219482,
-0.9264163374900818,
-0.027848031371831894,
-0.16662271320819855,
-0.09848356246948242,
-0.16865785419940948,
0.38546961545944214,
0.03848959133028984,
1.0519660711288452,
-0.7332145571708679,
0.8860973119735718,
0.6505885720252991,
-0.20598287880420685,
-0.8424503803253174,
0.6878609657287598,
0.35781046748161316,
-0.582012414932251,
0.17007532715797424,
0.3929551839828491,
-0.2836800217628479,
-0.6192917823791504,
-0.26871591806411743,
-0.7222082614898682,
1.0847119092941284,
0.3387123644351959,
-0.6163313388824463,
0.06709470599889755,
0.4991035461425781,
0.5305123329162598,
-0.02478974685072899,
0.10014201700687408,
0.7569049596786499,
0.5313200354576111,
0.012887612916529179,
-1.0209660530090332,
0.4684789776802063,
-0.4065065085887909,
-0.014441762119531631,
-0.28546980023384094,
-0.9299757480621338,
0.7415783405303955,
-0.000028921400371473283,
-0.27729761600494385,
0.31786999106407166,
0.5332964062690735,
0.4770081341266632,
0.38130512833595276,
0.9768760800361633,
-0.055897537618875504,
0.46180158853530884,
-0.05235859379172325,
0.952588677406311,
-0.44738978147506714,
0.09082943946123123,
0.9271473288536072,
-0.506758987903595,
0.9405962824821472,
0.07249559462070465,
-0.05618342012166977,
0.16560974717140198,
1.0256527662277222,
0.18965540826320648,
0.3636719286441803,
0.1358921378850937,
-0.03747561573982239,
-0.6409336924552917,
-0.2081676870584488,
-0.3137189447879791,
0.5052605867385864,
0.17595016956329346,
-0.14359356462955475,
-0.4648524522781372,
-0.21554769575595856,
0.09074993431568146,
-0.21960236132144928,
-0.06281811743974686,
0.5025629997253418,
0.09827076643705368,
-0.5609612464904785,
0.678267240524292,
0.30449599027633667,
0.45429369807243347,
-0.7755501866340637,
0.025278596207499504,
-0.09458465874195099,
0.1671595275402069,
0.056224972009658813,
-0.9530317783355713,
0.3753228187561035,
0.0493420735001564,
0.5308798551559448,
0.29374876618385315,
0.8245415091514587,
-0.31454041600227356,
-0.44610360264778137,
0.6835540533065796,
0.22453927993774414,
0.0002162272430723533,
0.16387449204921722,
-0.9877957701683044,
0.05133331939578056,
-0.3146889805793762,
-0.2798922061920166,
0.5619840621948242,
0.20493347942829132,
-0.6051892042160034,
0.8596954345703125,
0.5919233560562134,
-0.1960054636001587,
-0.2609238624572754,
-0.07096169888973236,
0.9611709713935852,
-0.781492292881012,
-0.8040542602539062,
-0.6315938234329224,
0.29587507247924805,
0.08247663825750351,
-0.25392594933509827,
0.7940872311592102,
0.29021531343460083,
0.7386553883552551,
0.11483227461576462,
0.975970447063446,
-0.09978274255990982,
0.41462358832359314,
-0.44321462512016296,
1.1854926347732544,
-0.7157586812973022,
0.35741686820983887,
-0.656543493270874,
-0.736579418182373,
-0.3112691640853882,
0.5442622303962708,
-0.244990736246109,
0.19549335539340973,
0.6717494130134583,
0.9073817729949951,
0.06110706925392151,
0.13282416760921478,
0.399894654750824,
0.23382164537906647,
0.3510374128818512,
0.7880787253379822,
0.8968327045440674,
-0.3273313641548157,
0.7246710658073425,
-0.5217524766921997,
-0.29610493779182434,
-0.03567410632967949,
-0.9724794030189514,
-1.2937520742416382,
-0.3913857936859131,
-0.1928742378950119,
-0.31126895546913147,
0.18414300680160522,
0.9966588020324707,
0.577959418296814,
-1.0875675678253174,
-0.31516721844673157,
0.20056530833244324,
0.0828668624162674,
-0.43891188502311707,
-0.20620585978031158,
0.5816075801849365,
-0.1288728266954422,
-0.5416598916053772,
0.46528369188308716,
0.2843162715435028,
0.07225551456212997,
-0.3270949125289917,
0.11664330214262009,
-0.018315104767680168,
0.2105608433485031,
0.4843131899833679,
0.24237380921840668,
-0.5448663234710693,
-0.6368630528450012,
-0.06233293190598488,
-0.4086949825286865,
-0.31930816173553467,
0.61520916223526,
-0.11141310632228851,
-0.024458130821585655,
0.6401494741439819,
1.0426394939422607,
-0.0978672206401825,
-0.1479257345199585,
0.40864965319633484,
-0.28478267788887024,
0.31492987275123596,
-0.04578002914786339,
0.3733556866645813,
0.2118195742368698,
-0.48671385645866394,
0.6118273735046387,
0.07712476700544357,
-0.24262593686580658,
-0.6816086173057556,
-0.07304683327674866,
-0.8642143607139587,
-0.5143555998802185,
1.0737074613571167,
-0.42085200548171997,
-0.38387513160705566,
-0.5728105902671814,
-0.05862408131361008,
0.21947641670703888,
-0.07157659530639648,
1.05051851272583,
0.7379915118217468,
0.2575596272945404,
-0.18136635422706604,
-0.6430861949920654,
0.4919545352458954,
0.4552711844444275,
-1.1180505752563477,
0.44457507133483887,
0.3471127152442932,
0.53779137134552,
-0.028248179703950882,
0.5207776427268982,
-0.3620244562625885,
0.7068884968757629,
-0.1068059653043747,
-0.00015269483265001327,
0.09530440717935562,
-0.590146541595459,
-0.21445834636688232,
0.3013117015361786,
0.1154666617512703,
-0.10283606499433517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10310v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10310v1
|
TEG-DB: A Comprehensive Dataset and Benchmark of Textual-Edge Graphs
| 2024-06-14T06:22:47 | 2024-06-14T06:22:47 |
Zhuofeng Li, Zixing Gou, Xiangnan Zhang, Zhongyuan Liu, Sirui Li, Yuntong Hu, Chen Ling, Zheng Zhang, Liang Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text-Attributed Graphs (TAGs) augment graph structures with natural language
descriptions, facilitating detailed depictions of data and their
interconnections across various real-world settings. However, existing TAG
datasets predominantly feature textual information only at the nodes, with
edges typically represented by mere binary or categorical attributes. This lack
of rich textual edge annotations significantly limits the exploration of
contextual relationships between entities, hindering deeper insights into
graph-structured data. To address this gap, we introduce Textual-Edge Graphs
Datasets and Benchmark (TEG-DB), a comprehensive and diverse collection of
benchmark textual-edge datasets featuring rich textual descriptions on nodes
and edges. The TEG-DB datasets are large-scale and encompass a wide range of
domains, from citation networks to social networks. In addition, we conduct
extensive benchmark experiments on TEG-DB to assess the extent to which current
techniques, including pre-trained language models, graph neural networks, and
their combinations, can utilize textual node and edge information. Our goal is
to elicit advancements in textual-edge graph research, specifically in
developing methodologies that exploit rich textual node and edge descriptions
to enhance graph analysis and provide deeper insights into complex real-world
networks. The entire TEG-DB project is publicly accessible as an open-source
repository on Github, accessible at
https://github.com/Zhuofeng-Li/TEG-Benchmark.
|
[
-0.4329100549221039,
-1.1398378610610962,
0.3655809462070465,
-0.1460750252008438,
-0.19467966258525848,
0.20220351219177246,
-0.3840813934803009,
-0.5814031362533569,
0.10437901318073273,
0.45535245537757874,
-0.6597533822059631,
-1.049545407295227,
-0.2952888607978821,
0.18112939596176147,
-0.377270370721817,
1.0429564714431763,
0.15585139393806458,
-0.10504166781902313,
-0.18612170219421387,
-0.06633292138576508,
-0.167619526386261,
-0.1830071061849594,
-0.6684156656265259,
-0.337575227022171,
0.7025775909423828,
0.05189622566103935,
0.6575557589530945,
1.014586091041565,
0.3143760859966278,
0.16068585216999054,
0.04705941677093506,
0.3269583284854889,
-0.6549474000930786,
0.05999862030148506,
-0.2916364073753357,
-0.011714073829352856,
-0.7090869545936584,
-0.21600405871868134,
0.7671294212341309,
0.9558437466621399,
0.2701907157897949,
0.07010985165834427,
0.11186210811138153,
0.6751472353935242,
-0.5573908090591431,
0.2886830270290375,
-0.5580976605415344,
-0.05741220712661743,
-0.6166771650314331,
-0.0530046708881855,
-0.4662296175956726,
-0.7221704721450806,
0.25558170676231384,
-0.8636518716812134,
0.08400996774435043,
-0.09472747892141342,
1.3216298818588257,
0.1722128838300705,
-0.7760472297668457,
-0.0619087889790535,
-0.5134881138801575,
0.28918978571891785,
-0.21400928497314453,
0.44401517510414124,
0.46714144945144653,
0.31051403284072876,
-0.022221030667424202,
-1.2740801572799683,
-0.2089502513408661,
0.28031232953071594,
-0.25972414016723633,
0.02768206037580967,
-0.042954377830028534,
0.12259669601917267,
0.03548404574394226,
0.20437856018543243,
-0.5726427435874939,
0.08660735189914703,
-0.03425990790128708,
-0.07698922604322433,
0.5465913414955139,
0.11588382720947266,
0.3102983832359314,
-0.2471201866865158,
-0.602310836315155,
-0.20409205555915833,
-0.8519648313522339,
-0.19514144957065582,
0.2644141614437103,
0.5230810046195984,
0.07522314041852951,
0.36790138483047485,
-0.30380910634994507,
0.7776311635971069,
-0.5431662201881409,
0.4360964894294739,
0.6044793725013733,
-0.60899817943573,
-0.009988058358430862,
0.07678775489330292,
0.9634830355644226,
0.7702624797821045,
0.5813201665878296,
-0.5005230903625488,
-0.014817416667938232,
-0.06674840301275253,
-0.04040319100022316,
-0.8926700353622437,
-0.2310822755098343,
0.02318277582526207,
-0.3480414152145386,
-0.22661754488945007,
0.06323119252920151,
-1.072256326675415,
-0.5898329019546509,
0.0007210996118374169,
0.08215605467557907,
-0.7789560556411743,
-0.48151302337646484,
-0.11587929725646973,
-0.45160824060440063,
0.1151038408279419,
-0.2138381004333496,
-0.329843670129776,
0.5944915413856506,
0.8714835047721863,
0.9782769083976746,
0.023206079378724098,
-0.34914422035217285,
-0.32256782054901123,
0.47210806608200073,
-0.3012693524360657,
0.9680048227310181,
-0.8301278948783875,
-0.33464911580085754,
0.1420828402042389,
0.11104276031255722,
-0.1558407098054886,
-0.18518246710300446,
1.0328937768936157,
-0.24298152327537537,
0.01338267046958208,
-0.6157339215278625,
-0.7379701733589172,
-0.07555608451366425,
0.16726581752300262,
-0.8323993682861328,
1.5996487140655518,
0.131943017244339,
-0.9138444662094116,
0.35701894760131836,
-0.5883333086967468,
-0.6054790616035461,
0.30245059728622437,
-0.16557078063488007,
-0.2695140242576599,
-0.1887284815311432,
0.22070562839508057,
0.47149816155433655,
-0.6007310748100281,
0.21629610657691956,
-0.5234115123748779,
-0.4098355770111084,
0.19986078143119812,
-0.004774205386638641,
0.6744002103805542,
0.08888242393732071,
-0.1463351547718048,
-0.15911638736724854,
-0.7582558989524841,
0.3962917923927307,
0.4308697581291199,
0.2067825347185135,
-0.6839793920516968,
0.3873189389705658,
0.24582310020923615,
-0.10205978155136108,
0.15239189565181732,
-0.5899143218994141,
0.09830695390701294,
-0.18136107921600342,
0.6363595724105835,
0.7269431352615356,
0.04549563676118851,
0.14382505416870117,
-0.13406220078468323,
0.017505738884210587,
-0.4846344590187073,
-0.2685031294822693,
-0.3225703835487366,
-0.12670418620109558,
-0.19442036747932434,
-0.26702454686164856,
0.6140748858451843,
0.4474583566188812,
-0.9022506475448608,
0.5913201570510864,
-0.9257882833480835,
-0.6727491617202759,
-0.28970658779144287,
-0.26796621084213257,
0.3904034495353699,
0.9547122716903687,
0.4143739640712738,
-0.04288170486688614,
-0.16071686148643494,
-0.959216296672821,
-0.5973774194717407,
-0.14827804267406464,
-0.17758119106292725,
0.5907188653945923,
0.289395272731781,
0.04394715279340744,
1.1001496315002441,
-0.738308310508728,
-0.45606255531311035,
0.08738581836223602,
0.15161409974098206,
-0.08391035348176956,
0.07719683647155762,
0.7109211683273315,
-0.6728662252426147,
-0.6648234128952026,
0.2815723121166229,
-0.7531684041023254,
-0.5212135910987854,
0.21532471477985382,
-0.29466158151626587,
-0.19419792294502258,
0.3818644881248474,
-0.29748401045799255,
0.16960509121418,
0.30899694561958313,
-0.6203818917274475,
0.2972922921180725,
0.14491336047649384,
0.08628763258457184,
-0.9295913577079773,
0.046367235481739044,
0.27697527408599854,
-0.23489825427532196,
-0.6227840185165405,
-0.29262593388557434,
0.19373023509979248,
-0.038219742476940155,
0.13883063197135925,
0.6407438516616821,
-0.4549546241760254,
-0.07758374512195587,
0.19953301548957825,
0.3532976508140564,
0.2654002904891968,
0.40800172090530396,
0.11695865541696548,
0.7045945525169373,
0.6413699984550476,
-0.40594998002052307,
0.2967638373374939,
0.12900778651237488,
-0.02147950977087021,
1.0041414499282837,
-0.837193489074707,
0.2647070288658142,
0.007934650406241417,
0.3246479034423828,
-0.875601589679718,
-0.27584901452064514,
0.06075097247958183,
-0.4637841284275055,
0.2363865077495575,
-0.388221800327301,
-0.6755579113960266,
-0.06486807763576508,
-0.6181660890579224,
0.11819177865982056,
0.18585002422332764,
-0.4046476483345032,
0.6890661120414734,
0.4819830060005188,
-0.11652910709381104,
-0.5752449035644531,
-0.6026672124862671,
0.3202950358390808,
-0.14302682876586914,
-0.7584519386291504,
0.7689347863197327,
0.345279723405838,
0.02784118987619877,
0.500167191028595,
-0.014151042327284813,
-0.3448251187801361,
0.07424972951412201,
0.18852940201759338,
0.01076850388199091,
-0.1958073079586029,
0.5706505179405212,
0.22069306671619415,
-0.2235601395368576,
0.23913173377513885,
-0.5007631778717041,
0.5460122227668762,
-0.29114097356796265,
0.035559505224227905,
0.029336821287870407,
0.15892907977104187,
0.08470664918422699,
-0.532511830329895,
0.5632232427597046,
0.6634154915809631,
-0.8072528839111328,
-0.4582465589046478,
-0.07319851964712143,
0.26500484347343445,
-0.48142609000205994,
0.6056753993034363,
-0.5734924674034119,
-0.4499119818210602,
0.42015713453292847,
-0.39260727167129517,
-0.020284214988350868,
0.5735247135162354,
0.06657968461513519,
-0.32318511605262756,
0.358577162027359,
0.3451848030090332,
0.20346882939338684,
0.5026113390922546,
-0.15297238528728485,
-0.14446911215782166,
-0.8238344192504883,
-0.324847549200058,
-0.7527753710746765,
-0.261489599943161,
-0.5514890551567078,
-0.08887135982513428,
0.2745673656463623,
0.011245450004935265,
-0.2829439640045166,
0.3694041967391968,
-0.7223653197288513,
0.6144104599952698,
0.1618044674396515,
0.3685021996498108,
0.2815881073474884,
0.0862543135881424,
-0.044732850044965744,
-0.11176179349422455,
-0.39634808897972107,
-0.6727851033210754,
1.2061996459960938,
0.2252299040555954,
0.6017341017723083,
-0.2247505933046341,
0.39166098833084106,
0.4767165184020996,
0.0745399072766304,
-0.43648838996887207,
0.6278488636016846,
-0.16736851632595062,
-0.5446464419364929,
-0.28363433480262756,
-0.6451069712638855,
-1.0918022394180298,
-0.07424884289503098,
-0.2608568072319031,
-0.8763588070869446,
0.03345722705125809,
-0.11774501949548721,
0.324023962020874,
0.45612674951553345,
-0.9113092422485352,
1.0835119485855103,
-0.23856595158576965,
-0.5233711004257202,
0.20549242198467255,
-0.5271962285041809,
-0.19436147809028625,
0.130966454744339,
0.16773608326911926,
-0.36963850259780884,
-0.39086073637008667,
0.6910224556922913,
-0.43556442856788635,
0.5992559790611267,
-0.20100626349449158,
0.10004444420337677,
0.38806313276290894,
-0.013089179992675781,
0.5600224137306213,
-0.07250400632619858,
-0.19145098328590393,
0.3275311589241028,
-0.19221481680870056,
-0.4332024157047272,
-0.21978692710399628,
0.7452117204666138,
-0.7479946613311768,
0.09089479595422745,
-0.20655378699302673,
-0.21618767082691193,
-0.30171263217926025,
0.48067083954811096,
0.33915260434150696,
0.7896268963813782,
-0.6181336641311646,
0.2637324929237366,
0.6117402911186218,
-0.0870344266295433,
0.5309743285179138,
-0.11408795416355133,
-0.013959216885268688,
-0.5126463174819946,
0.8947727084159851,
0.4146154522895813,
0.2290075123310089,
0.4644530713558197,
-0.024795472621917725,
-0.5012142062187195,
-0.4893159866333008,
-0.41122350096702576,
0.23999078571796417,
-0.7647240161895752,
-0.29013508558273315,
-0.8439410328865051,
-0.17161820828914642,
-0.20238523185253143,
-0.11408380419015884,
-0.3686714768409729,
-0.41505926847457886,
-0.005689368583261967,
-0.42819565534591675,
0.7369678616523743,
0.6759525537490845,
0.4054122865200043,
0.23732972145080566,
-0.5309212803840637,
0.13330671191215515,
-0.16491980850696564,
0.9806202054023743,
-0.061729032546281815,
0.3066408634185791,
-0.23653173446655273,
-0.11383773386478424,
0.014381477609276772,
-1.2599761486053467,
-0.13168592751026154,
0.4254351556301117,
0.3531927466392517,
0.024932149797677994,
0.3292180597782135,
0.34652528166770935,
-0.4782562851905823,
0.5664350986480713,
-0.14230819046497345,
-0.9680148959159851,
0.4225479066371918,
-0.7978922724723816,
-0.003388411598280072,
0.6172845959663391,
0.4876016080379486,
-0.5907731056213379,
-0.005106487311422825,
-0.45136094093322754,
-0.9937953948974609,
0.538385272026062,
0.33062201738357544,
-0.19050800800323486,
0.07368927448987961,
0.272365003824234,
0.11724542081356049,
-0.027029622346162796,
-0.7683066129684448,
-0.3230684995651245,
-0.42965149879455566,
-0.4140353798866272,
0.2832830846309662,
0.04667132347822189,
-0.2156490832567215,
0.22496888041496277,
0.5192614197731018,
-0.38788992166519165,
0.16233579814434052,
0.23689556121826172,
-0.20292198657989502,
0.1802772730588913,
0.2330177277326584,
-0.30846214294433594,
0.7545477151870728,
-0.3427867293357849,
0.3970641493797302,
0.2732643187046051,
-0.4676457941532135,
-0.22170355916023254,
0.6727690100669861,
-0.3183092474937439,
0.1477145552635193,
0.5008271336555481,
0.5868346095085144,
-0.26613742113113403,
-0.37287649512290955,
0.2909955084323883,
-0.1446426659822464,
0.03847893327474594,
-0.020712587982416153,
-0.17374160885810852,
0.445179283618927,
-0.17293818295001984,
0.6627839207649231,
-0.4539977014064789,
0.2982924282550812,
-0.31367793679237366,
0.22476930916309357,
0.21289129555225372,
-0.6620086431503296,
-0.2944883406162262,
0.5950493812561035,
0.5110646486282349,
-0.33187443017959595,
0.4863533079624176,
-0.09907879680395126,
-0.4012075960636139,
0.7314265966415405,
0.24244508147239685,
0.8590589761734009,
0.26559075713157654,
0.23633699119091034,
0.45466622710227966,
0.4132460951805115,
0.41537123918533325,
0.0171660203486681,
0.15358281135559082,
-0.485690176486969,
-0.16452351212501526,
-0.13113124668598175,
-0.21494300663471222,
-0.18377935886383057,
-0.6752921342849731,
0.5386503338813782,
-0.3493419289588928,
-0.5039839744567871,
0.25942927598953247,
0.19384029507637024,
-0.6255110502243042,
0.3231433033943176,
0.023672353476285934,
0.9477325677871704,
-0.7947331666946411,
0.7526562213897705,
0.7924261093139648,
-0.2028883397579193,
-0.32501959800720215,
-0.18308106064796448,
-0.051600564271211624,
-0.47509241104125977,
0.039239030331373215,
0.22181513905525208,
-0.22046780586242676,
0.1541478931903839,
-0.38784059882164,
-0.4493538737297058,
1.2967255115509033,
0.27402326464653015,
-0.17250940203666687,
-0.0426248200237751,
0.279648095369339,
0.5515015721321106,
-0.2846594452857971,
0.6468378901481628,
0.5929893851280212,
0.545169472694397,
-0.16625195741653442,
-0.652856171131134,
0.3717554807662964,
-0.417736291885376,
0.04089874029159546,
0.5906827449798584,
-0.6947435140609741,
0.6388974785804749,
0.2929317057132721,
-0.6178504228591919,
-0.3983535170555115,
0.5467601418495178,
-0.17198780179023743,
0.516946017742157,
0.4654131829738617,
0.4859333038330078,
0.9640359878540039,
-0.8460987210273743,
1.1197513341903687,
-0.25033968687057495,
0.4639217257499695,
1.1330260038375854,
-0.4734362065792084,
0.4389667510986328,
-0.014294186607003212,
-0.04863416403532028,
0.5285428762435913,
0.9227849841117859,
0.041749197989702225,
0.379480242729187,
-0.030467987060546875,
-0.046109676361083984,
-0.037569575011730194,
-0.7577375769615173,
-0.7470632791519165,
-0.11292785406112671,
0.5732640027999878,
-0.23663024604320526,
-0.3794904947280884,
-0.5824015736579895,
0.233368918299675,
0.3250662684440613,
-0.23840108513832092,
0.6535640358924866,
-0.15041139721870422,
-0.11651863902807236,
0.3454843759536743,
-0.006338062696158886,
0.3957660496234894,
-0.7828434109687805,
0.06437507271766663,
-0.1774977445602417,
0.007521730847656727,
-0.41190195083618164,
-1.217832326889038,
0.20641931891441345,
0.0673392042517662,
0.107984259724617,
-0.2633635997772217,
1.0893052816390991,
-0.2090446501970291,
-0.1871783435344696,
0.6142099499702454,
0.4173782467842102,
-0.1268453598022461,
0.07547501474618912,
-0.5124224424362183,
-0.0669834241271019,
-0.31548193097114563,
-0.3005073666572571,
-0.08341166377067566,
1.0693379640579224,
-0.13470274209976196,
0.4965270161628723,
0.3333602547645569,
-0.04517441987991333,
-0.08714307844638824,
-0.042402684688568115,
1.1691672801971436,
-0.8512717485427856,
-0.465095192193985,
-0.8829734921455383,
0.4275004267692566,
-0.683746337890625,
-0.5392424464225769,
0.46164530515670776,
0.7902212142944336,
0.8295263051986694,
0.46643489599227905,
0.8906127214431763,
-0.30300405621528625,
0.4835866093635559,
-0.4648733139038086,
0.6542487144470215,
-0.36532729864120483,
0.01044606976211071,
-0.5120586156845093,
-1.0262775421142578,
-0.006443922407925129,
0.0685228481888771,
-0.1345786154270172,
0.1668216735124588,
0.8755204081535339,
0.505230724811554,
0.06953316926956177,
0.05932197719812393,
-0.2663561701774597,
0.15437284111976624,
0.24811363220214844,
0.7784410119056702,
0.710708498954773,
-0.49597424268722534,
0.955551028251648,
0.020797815173864365,
-0.16231003403663635,
0.13884466886520386,
-1.1170296669006348,
-1.1716526746749878,
-0.6172069311141968,
-0.3240637183189392,
-0.593946099281311,
0.21913595497608185,
0.6977081298828125,
0.5041545033454895,
-0.326254665851593,
-0.15970784425735474,
0.07424517720937729,
0.336472749710083,
-0.21401159465312958,
-0.2524939775466919,
0.7383723258972168,
0.03881647437810898,
-0.7267287969589233,
0.09472358971834183,
0.23832924664020538,
-0.03481272980570793,
0.17001435160636902,
0.0203457809984684,
-0.2913294732570648,
-0.10426847636699677,
0.14630115032196045,
0.12092787027359009,
-0.024882253259420395,
-0.1677798330783844,
0.1772548258304596,
-0.32443317770957947,
0.27866047620773315,
0.6180990934371948,
-0.6603018641471863,
0.380575954914093,
0.5650168061256409,
0.9323214292526245,
0.6950739026069641,
0.08209837228059769,
0.6720336675643921,
-1.0480310916900635,
-0.18642756342887878,
0.1427140235900879,
0.2803407609462738,
0.45205792784690857,
-0.37539878487586975,
1.145385980606079,
0.3283544182777405,
-0.08249273151159286,
-0.9141014218330383,
0.18255963921546936,
-0.9422100782394409,
-0.39989298582077026,
0.9957677721977234,
-0.2393127679824829,
-0.18108543753623962,
-0.027909189462661743,
0.04304162412881851,
0.342420756816864,
-0.4799494743347168,
0.13359948992729187,
0.8062375783920288,
0.2629074454307556,
0.015817109495401382,
-0.4079977571964264,
0.5259062647819519,
-0.034802280366420746,
-1.1926050186157227,
0.35436341166496277,
0.49480390548706055,
0.14484015107154846,
-0.12203463166952133,
0.7153804898262024,
-0.11036203056573868,
-0.10093797743320465,
0.13969385623931885,
0.11935310065746307,
-0.3595885634422302,
-0.2791837751865387,
0.09315173327922821,
0.28395721316337585,
-0.393000066280365,
-0.07139161974191666
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09719v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09719v1
|
Self-Knowledge Distillation for Learning Ambiguity
| 2024-06-14T05:11:32 | 2024-06-14T05:11:32 |
Hancheol Park, Soyeong Jeong, Sukmin Cho, Jong C. Park
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent language models have shown remarkable performance on natural language
understanding (NLU) tasks. However, they are often sub-optimal when faced with
ambiguous samples that can be interpreted in multiple ways, over-confidently
predicting a single label without consideration for its correctness. To address
this issue, we propose a novel self-knowledge distillation method that enables
models to learn label distributions more accurately by leveraging knowledge
distilled from their lower layers. This approach also includes a learning phase
that re-calibrates the unnecessarily strengthened confidence for training
samples judged as extremely ambiguous based on the distilled distribution
knowledge. We validate our method on diverse NLU benchmark datasets and the
experimental results demonstrate its effectiveness in producing better label
distributions. Particularly, through the process of re-calibrating the
confidence for highly ambiguous samples, the issue of over-confidence when
predictions for unseen samples do not match with their ground-truth labels has
been significantly alleviated. This has been shown to contribute to generating
better distributions than the existing state-of-the-art method. Moreover, our
method is more efficient in training the models compared to the existing
method, as it does not involve additional training processes to refine label
distributions.
|
[
-0.25141841173171997,
-0.4560198187828064,
0.5730821490287781,
0.22154054045677185,
-0.40170085430145264,
0.24126844108104706,
-0.13635262846946716,
-0.4023017883300781,
-0.05694996938109398,
0.23733216524124146,
-0.5379628539085388,
-0.39421284198760986,
-0.9499063491821289,
0.23461368680000305,
-0.22014501690864563,
1.0663020610809326,
-0.00771223334595561,
-0.24465948343276978,
-0.08113808184862137,
-0.20613619685173035,
-0.3536832928657532,
-0.3621862530708313,
-0.2593596577644348,
-0.8202617764472961,
0.49795880913734436,
0.13109590113162994,
0.48219576478004456,
0.5416481494903564,
0.11352536082267761,
0.3511793911457062,
-0.1613808125257492,
0.18195268511772156,
-0.588795006275177,
0.17375671863555908,
-0.399629682302475,
-0.5477051734924316,
-0.017079640179872513,
0.07181024551391602,
0.23918119072914124,
0.9147674441337585,
-0.4615015983581543,
0.278909295797348,
0.3174823522567749,
0.8437337875366211,
-0.9977801442146301,
0.06834027916193008,
-0.9025811553001404,
0.16449235379695892,
0.011486491188406944,
-0.04478049650788307,
-0.49924755096435547,
-0.12230915576219559,
0.3720035254955292,
-0.9006331562995911,
0.33955055475234985,
-0.12871016561985016,
0.6986715197563171,
0.8020281791687012,
-0.5104730725288391,
-0.3021165728569031,
-0.7772156596183777,
0.8727827072143555,
-0.7247160077095032,
0.5359533429145813,
0.5901685357093811,
0.6102955341339111,
-0.21725726127624512,
-0.7531651258468628,
-0.5285347104072571,
0.20597495138645172,
-0.0707039013504982,
0.2009250968694687,
-0.2227812111377716,
-0.08169779181480408,
-0.02140655368566513,
0.1880064457654953,
-0.29653969407081604,
0.0431685745716095,
-0.47119736671447754,
-0.12449206411838531,
0.5609464049339294,
-0.24623233079910278,
-0.25464800000190735,
-0.20913133025169373,
-0.5785326957702637,
-0.195516437292099,
-0.27136895060539246,
-0.09266425669193268,
0.48144009709358215,
0.18559782207012177,
0.2121979147195816,
0.32779911160469055,
-0.28585153818130493,
0.7230474948883057,
0.377427339553833,
-0.26173925399780273,
0.64380943775177,
0.10977093875408173,
-0.5621645450592041,
0.2663964033126831,
0.6571245789527893,
-0.06616228818893433,
-0.11818110197782516,
-0.05211005359888077,
-0.18585413694381714,
-0.343414306640625,
0.17120373249053955,
-0.44074681401252747,
-0.6132593154907227,
0.20301282405853271,
-0.1154085025191307,
-0.22983388602733612,
-0.1624956578016281,
-0.6200023293495178,
-0.5605440735816956,
-0.48645520210266113,
0.5348243117332458,
-0.28962722420692444,
-0.40073537826538086,
0.3281513452529907,
-0.37533536553382874,
-0.3373867869377136,
0.3233763575553894,
-0.969330906867981,
-0.10164657980203629,
0.33025023341178894,
0.3105386197566986,
0.1368481069803238,
-0.19718904793262482,
-0.2262362390756607,
0.3709568977355957,
-0.17914748191833496,
0.46360015869140625,
-0.4405577778816223,
-0.18456698954105377,
-0.4540903568267822,
-0.40955686569213867,
0.09701661765575409,
-0.740075409412384,
0.441899836063385,
-0.31456559896469116,
0.12505125999450684,
-0.06873296946287155,
-0.6203213334083557,
-0.28745630383491516,
0.19924163818359375,
-0.6074421405792236,
1.2552850246429443,
0.17648424208164215,
-0.845767617225647,
0.4859446883201599,
-0.16572844982147217,
-0.11187805235385895,
0.06247474625706673,
-0.2797268331050873,
-0.44273465871810913,
0.28882142901420593,
0.44355309009552,
0.3989793360233307,
-0.06321179121732712,
0.6931019425392151,
-0.281150758266449,
0.08418150991201401,
0.21045885980129242,
-0.7872821092605591,
0.806797206401825,
0.40510204434394836,
-0.3610870838165283,
-0.4091697931289673,
-0.9444971084594727,
0.10856010019779205,
-0.11776702851057053,
-0.2682275176048279,
-0.7597411274909973,
-0.26457881927490234,
-0.5668513774871826,
0.0802370235323906,
0.2621254026889801,
-0.31484609842300415,
0.057945117354393005,
-0.4398895502090454,
0.3201068937778473,
0.8196189403533936,
-0.07645003497600555,
0.4082971215248108,
0.0532742477953434,
0.32696694135665894,
0.257613867521286,
0.17810265719890594,
0.17360559105873108,
-0.44995009899139404,
-0.8225436806678772,
-0.03768328204751015,
0.5093615651130676,
0.4311257600784302,
-0.8796753883361816,
0.6913048624992371,
-0.01641133613884449,
-0.648430585861206,
-0.8831957578659058,
0.5483114719390869,
0.4271588623523712,
0.8384818434715271,
0.7608900666236877,
-0.023142961785197258,
-0.49828654527664185,
-0.787877082824707,
-0.30351364612579346,
-0.23512794077396393,
-0.03447425737977028,
0.006652174051851034,
0.4077053368091583,
-0.41249558329582214,
1.2191972732543945,
-0.7635678648948669,
-0.3833460807800293,
-0.0012225823011249304,
0.8332170248031616,
0.20150387287139893,
0.39147651195526123,
0.41251373291015625,
-0.9434036016464233,
-0.5653505921363831,
-0.03887376934289932,
-0.6600801348686218,
-0.21834628283977509,
-0.1033998429775238,
-0.22113753855228424,
0.010058586485683918,
0.319885790348053,
-0.04971639811992645,
0.36989450454711914,
0.7143502235412598,
0.13551078736782074,
0.3962913453578949,
-0.536314845085144,
-0.21296733617782593,
-1.0557631254196167,
-0.248461052775383,
0.21332591772079468,
-0.1884017288684845,
-0.6757934093475342,
-0.2930227816104889,
0.2355073094367981,
0.507885754108429,
-0.3191440999507904,
0.44204217195510864,
-0.5926339626312256,
0.43501168489456177,
-0.30613410472869873,
0.19762097299098969,
0.5266873240470886,
0.2994166910648346,
0.02534797415137291,
0.2752688229084015,
0.533881664276123,
-0.529787003993988,
0.35247254371643066,
0.00692735193297267,
-0.49526605010032654,
0.48933079838752747,
-0.41633492708206177,
0.04689725488424301,
-0.5750080347061157,
0.30001184344291687,
-1.2550327777862549,
0.06617322564125061,
0.2794592082500458,
-0.28984373807907104,
0.4756891429424286,
-0.2715946137905121,
0.05262466147542,
-0.5015646815299988,
0.32142260670661926,
0.7168042063713074,
0.37659594416618347,
-0.8036229610443115,
0.7818601131439209,
0.2861609160900116,
0.15602591633796692,
-1.2367990016937256,
-1.0908616781234741,
-0.31723320484161377,
-0.5494303107261658,
-0.1563664823770523,
0.12933431565761566,
-0.043877631425857544,
-0.06665872037410736,
-0.06631636619567871,
-0.6115867495536804,
-0.42338237166404724,
0.1661224365234375,
0.14960548281669617,
-0.19138911366462708,
0.15124079585075378,
0.49458080530166626,
0.2813315689563751,
-0.23055090010166168,
-0.018048305064439774,
-0.48204317688941956,
0.12812615931034088,
0.16056008636951447,
-0.3282700479030609,
-0.39688318967819214,
0.018228894099593163,
-0.030520593747496605,
-0.04155046492815018,
0.6016715168952942,
0.6161947250366211,
-0.2963252663612366,
-0.4513300359249115,
-0.6358175873756409,
-0.10342374444007874,
-0.574781596660614,
0.1775563806295395,
-0.692637026309967,
-0.5338050723075867,
0.4311623275279999,
-0.1903092861175537,
0.012894291430711746,
0.4434151351451874,
0.17363521456718445,
-0.36251169443130493,
0.6642698049545288,
0.6385455131530762,
-0.11369909346103668,
0.2001807987689972,
-0.250027060508728,
0.36534926295280457,
-0.625870406627655,
-0.25942540168762207,
-0.41418933868408203,
-0.3896607756614685,
-0.19858688116073608,
-0.6392117142677307,
0.2509583532810211,
0.26946136355400085,
0.09590449929237366,
0.08690836280584335,
-0.6220089197158813,
0.6464608311653137,
0.5958297848701477,
0.17562371492385864,
0.402792751789093,
0.04668864235281944,
-0.26307791471481323,
-0.14041008055210114,
-0.5688070058822632,
-0.16268479824066162,
0.9773332476615906,
0.45251837372779846,
1.0196233987808228,
0.09407386183738708,
1.192916989326477,
0.22004146873950958,
0.3216090500354767,
-0.41888678073883057,
-0.07855168730020523,
-0.1731271594762802,
-0.693101704120636,
-0.5082284808158875,
-0.7321884632110596,
-1.0387507677078247,
0.5738915205001831,
-0.25740212202072144,
-0.62868332862854,
0.503424346446991,
0.37968337535858154,
-0.45594316720962524,
0.2583266496658325,
-1.044663429260254,
0.8172842860221863,
-0.29519936442375183,
0.06412971764802933,
0.289000004529953,
-0.8026339411735535,
0.3858688473701477,
-0.40736114978790283,
0.5439871549606323,
-0.4409179389476776,
0.25854557752609253,
0.4796888828277588,
-0.24589765071868896,
1.0347174406051636,
-0.21841862797737122,
-0.5900852680206299,
0.42225903272628784,
0.0987565815448761,
0.43034619092941284,
0.03203269839286804,
-0.275899201631546,
0.17645536363124847,
-0.07144362479448318,
-0.2602393627166748,
-0.9302891492843628,
0.31335926055908203,
-0.867398738861084,
-0.7003130316734314,
-0.3704111576080322,
-0.4932793080806732,
-0.06374029070138931,
0.17452682554721832,
0.46583113074302673,
0.2321709543466568,
0.030605221167206764,
0.006238703615963459,
0.6613968014717102,
0.02176414057612419,
0.16081532835960388,
0.44754090905189514,
-0.07373955100774765,
-0.27096810936927795,
0.846215546131134,
0.2104787528514862,
0.5649930834770203,
0.5705699920654297,
0.45134279131889343,
-0.7955977320671082,
-0.5771097540855408,
-0.3226790130138397,
-0.05858895927667618,
-1.0342040061950684,
-0.33917173743247986,
-0.6810898780822754,
-0.18424472212791443,
-0.6076149344444275,
0.14953365921974182,
-0.4855232536792755,
-0.46026259660720825,
-0.48039212822914124,
-0.31882205605506897,
0.30839917063713074,
0.7385804057121277,
-0.32891470193862915,
0.510402262210846,
-0.5806806683540344,
0.48499795794487,
0.5225486755371094,
0.2877351939678192,
-0.20909184217453003,
-0.7814834713935852,
-0.014667272567749023,
0.5254771113395691,
-0.26627030968666077,
-1.1990070343017578,
0.5105405449867249,
0.4127555191516876,
0.810814619064331,
0.3556172251701355,
0.538520336151123,
0.981702983379364,
-0.3187687397003174,
0.37226662039756775,
0.3397979140281677,
-0.982345461845398,
0.595746636390686,
0.06680627912282944,
0.3827242851257324,
0.9753364324569702,
0.6356329917907715,
-0.41608625650405884,
-0.7177801132202148,
-0.6501977443695068,
-1.139597773551941,
0.47219404578208923,
0.3018386960029602,
0.037661366164684296,
0.1547100841999054,
0.515479326248169,
0.420465886592865,
0.16487693786621094,
-0.9721240997314453,
-0.8227047324180603,
-0.32612472772598267,
-0.436664342880249,
-0.31158313155174255,
-0.14387203752994537,
-0.20270907878875732,
-0.4634556174278259,
0.8547559976577759,
-0.21029937267303467,
-0.32785362005233765,
0.28300273418426514,
-0.2470424473285675,
-0.0051805791445076466,
0.4279756247997284,
0.09019051492214203,
0.8159237504005432,
-0.27004173398017883,
0.7324663400650024,
0.3649739921092987,
-0.3795395493507385,
0.4256952106952667,
0.23150216042995453,
-0.010887200944125652,
0.06149253994226456,
-0.18745706975460052,
0.8618790507316589,
-0.006998075637966394,
-0.3045024573802948,
0.2636931538581848,
-0.17104686796665192,
-0.3624180853366852,
-0.020525822415947914,
0.08618101477622986,
0.1482761800289154,
0.33872225880622864,
0.5635471940040588,
0.053155556321144104,
0.4208262860774994,
-0.18601763248443604,
0.3178543746471405,
0.12323309481143951,
-0.28978410363197327,
0.25448504090309143,
0.43860214948654175,
0.12846596539020538,
0.08662930130958557,
0.5237341523170471,
-0.4766719341278076,
-0.40842878818511963,
0.4709576666355133,
0.5161487460136414,
0.7361324429512024,
-0.4807979464530945,
0.5192808508872986,
0.3734515309333801,
0.27593037486076355,
-0.20159710943698883,
-0.1200050339102745,
-0.18401087820529938,
-0.8502427339553833,
-0.30170413851737976,
-0.7537192702293396,
-0.1866162121295929,
0.055554334074258804,
-0.8729910850524902,
-0.10899826139211655,
-0.05710044875741005,
-0.24104809761047363,
0.24097955226898193,
-0.17535731196403503,
-0.47089725732803345,
0.3600790798664093,
0.1948004961013794,
0.6373550891876221,
-1.1355652809143066,
1.0565885305404663,
0.4174576997756958,
-0.12045846879482269,
-1.031290888786316,
-0.14112231135368347,
0.03416081517934799,
-0.5533909201622009,
0.6847442388534546,
0.20857317745685577,
-0.16169065237045288,
0.000823089387267828,
-0.2244569957256317,
-0.9884536266326904,
0.9682857394218445,
0.5547381043434143,
-0.8271232843399048,
0.14821375906467438,
0.3697429895401001,
0.5489100813865662,
-0.08669841289520264,
0.40177929401397705,
0.7770000100135803,
0.45659178495407104,
0.4846690595149994,
-0.8919677734375,
-0.10620485991239548,
-0.1545238196849823,
-0.06755367666482925,
0.3057359457015991,
-0.22609688341617584,
0.6414919495582581,
-0.21390295028686523,
-0.3393218517303467,
-0.3536231219768524,
0.9212865829467773,
0.29755905270576477,
0.3434905409812927,
0.6242082118988037,
0.6481481790542603,
1.382259726524353,
-0.15006491541862488,
0.4771011173725128,
0.19892838597297668,
0.7217086553573608,
1.8683335781097412,
-0.017342979088425636,
0.6916468739509583,
0.6975529789924622,
-0.14643114805221558,
0.584425687789917,
0.6817420721054077,
0.0800280049443245,
0.6240768432617188,
0.35384565591812134,
-0.22190724313259125,
-0.5152729749679565,
0.1826738566160202,
-0.46914851665496826,
0.2699314057826996,
0.4920366108417511,
-0.24042291939258575,
-0.5923474431037903,
0.06470093131065369,
-0.4342973530292511,
0.21891909837722778,
0.05164720118045807,
0.7424863576889038,
0.13981874287128448,
-0.5769156813621521,
0.9782645106315613,
-0.1856301724910736,
0.6839683651924133,
-0.4238925576210022,
0.14913204312324524,
-0.0011954822111874819,
0.22513537108898163,
-0.23262815177440643,
-0.9553335905075073,
0.19362103939056396,
-0.39261704683303833,
-0.17045868933200836,
-0.320404589176178,
0.4982879161834717,
-0.8613598346710205,
-0.5454625487327576,
0.3685598075389862,
0.48307451605796814,
0.22797539830207825,
-0.0833745077252388,
-0.9535263776779175,
-0.25325626134872437,
0.26044219732284546,
-0.08800595998764038,
-0.043614670634269714,
0.796811044216156,
0.32726797461509705,
0.7959891557693481,
0.2769829034805298,
-0.19011589884757996,
0.5648103952407837,
0.21211974322795868,
0.753123939037323,
-0.30627837777137756,
-0.4999447166919708,
-0.8754091858863831,
0.545504629611969,
-0.13133449852466583,
-0.27955201268196106,
0.6336311101913452,
0.3804127275943756,
0.9608150720596313,
0.044761307537555695,
0.8358884453773499,
0.07914546132087708,
0.3512905538082123,
-0.380415141582489,
0.49901941418647766,
-0.7242504954338074,
0.36729368567466736,
-0.15848970413208008,
-0.7446612119674683,
-0.316184937953949,
0.8044428825378418,
-0.48146966099739075,
0.0709499716758728,
0.4523114860057831,
0.4760257601737976,
-0.177648663520813,
0.1520712971687317,
0.27303919196128845,
0.30461597442626953,
0.22421270608901978,
0.747100830078125,
0.8916987776756287,
-0.540065586566925,
0.5515120029449463,
-0.692380964756012,
-0.10741986334323883,
-0.054259318858385086,
-1.0981143712997437,
-0.8324349522590637,
-0.6198194622993469,
-0.436282217502594,
-0.15128359198570251,
0.030251476913690567,
0.7658218145370483,
0.9113133549690247,
-0.6051117777824402,
0.11293564736843109,
-0.1518595963716507,
0.30817192792892456,
-0.20198401808738708,
-0.1972469985485077,
0.13648022711277008,
-0.4559434950351715,
-0.8045477271080017,
0.3002603352069855,
0.018932592123746872,
0.49077796936035156,
-0.1992427259683609,
-0.07773654907941818,
-0.22611545026302338,
-0.1475597620010376,
0.23201124370098114,
0.2643256187438965,
-0.7529030442237854,
-0.15000051259994507,
-0.44429653882980347,
-0.12713231146335602,
0.23286671936511993,
0.32386264204978943,
-0.8314147591590881,
0.9012072682380676,
0.465453177690506,
0.573945939540863,
0.6250852942466736,
0.21740777790546417,
0.5853306651115417,
-1.3389856815338135,
0.2470446527004242,
0.08850880712270737,
0.2345391809940338,
0.2395777851343155,
-0.6427868604660034,
0.39189639687538147,
-0.1303461790084839,
-0.4122083783149719,
-0.7154462933540344,
0.3029751777648926,
-0.8098416924476624,
-0.6080172657966614,
1.0847980976104736,
-0.29834792017936707,
-0.29177406430244446,
-0.431281179189682,
-0.10993236303329468,
0.46746739745140076,
-0.4039515256881714,
1.0069516897201538,
0.5242246389389038,
0.07137171924114227,
-0.0191054530441761,
-0.30147433280944824,
0.5261919498443604,
0.5161256194114685,
-0.6482686400413513,
0.3028336763381958,
0.30649635195732117,
0.564816415309906,
0.41517847776412964,
0.4158746302127838,
0.29053279757499695,
-0.19372773170471191,
-0.24038754403591156,
0.000819300883449614,
0.04461337625980377,
-0.5776572823524475,
-0.28483811020851135,
-0.0036548147909343243,
-0.027243202552199364,
-0.06728152930736542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09717v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09717v2
|
UniBridge: A Unified Approach to Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning for Low-Resource Languages
| 2024-06-14T04:55:30 | 2024-06-17T04:05:39 |
Trinh Pham, Khoi M. Le, Luu Anh Tuan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce UniBridge (Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning with
Optimized Embeddings and Vocabulary), a comprehensive approach developed to
improve the effectiveness of Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning, particularly in
languages with limited resources. Our approach tackles two essential elements
of a language model: the initialization of embeddings and the optimal
vocabulary size. Specifically, we propose a novel embedding initialization
method that leverages both lexical and semantic alignment for a language. In
addition, we present a method for systematically searching for the optimal
vocabulary size, ensuring a balance between model complexity and linguistic
coverage. Our experiments across multilingual datasets show that our approach
greatly improves the F1-Score in several languages. UniBridge is a robust and
adaptable solution for cross-lingual systems in various languages, highlighting
the significance of initializing embeddings and choosing the right vocabulary
size in cross-lingual environments.
|
[
-0.2485722005367279,
-0.13760648667812347,
0.0616854727268219,
0.4214112460613251,
-0.2788911461830139,
0.44064104557037354,
-0.14688485860824585,
-0.24290184676647186,
0.2517439126968384,
0.2453797310590744,
-0.23771630227565765,
-0.08615409582853317,
-0.39679908752441406,
-0.241908460855484,
-0.2680096924304962,
0.6707216501235962,
-0.290406197309494,
0.17065149545669556,
-0.19966073334217072,
-0.23447300493717194,
-0.47759971022605896,
0.09352246671915054,
-0.26148396730422974,
-0.5256214141845703,
0.19387075304985046,
0.6108078956604004,
0.8103830814361572,
0.622581422328949,
0.3899329900741577,
0.21744512021541595,
0.21635715663433075,
0.04752224683761597,
-0.5935637950897217,
-0.23213531076908112,
-0.49826478958129883,
-0.21683917939662933,
0.13211508095264435,
-0.4278729557991028,
0.9173247814178467,
1.2299139499664307,
-0.18472085893154144,
0.10131201893091202,
0.2547483444213867,
0.49943915009498596,
-0.7868210077285767,
0.03749740868806839,
-0.5222983956336975,
0.2491121143102646,
-0.13927185535430908,
-0.2825164198875427,
-0.359100878238678,
0.20123419165611267,
0.28523412346839905,
-0.9496256709098816,
-0.12460555136203766,
0.23113302886486053,
0.5782520174980164,
0.030040215700864792,
-0.398233026266098,
-0.16816473007202148,
-0.2913127839565277,
1.2755928039550781,
-0.1506132036447525,
0.7198359966278076,
0.005832947324961424,
0.03189598023891449,
-0.011836562305688858,
-0.5695801377296448,
-0.09251856803894043,
0.1354970782995224,
-0.4101271629333496,
-0.03317873179912567,
-0.28465965390205383,
-0.07025415450334549,
-0.2858826518058777,
0.04325782507658005,
-0.6184149384498596,
0.14520692825317383,
-0.46033763885498047,
-0.4774025082588196,
0.4840545654296875,
-0.14770641922950745,
0.5965139865875244,
-0.11609194427728653,
-0.6986459493637085,
0.011939764022827148,
-0.6137024760246277,
0.09643134474754333,
0.02802860364317894,
0.6127687692642212,
-0.13048005104064941,
0.3207182288169861,
-0.10089617967605591,
0.5301300287246704,
-0.11343611031770706,
-0.11982148885726929,
0.10412121564149857,
-0.4901413321495056,
-0.1833420693874359,
0.5044318437576294,
0.7270005345344543,
0.24634498357772827,
0.3142717182636261,
-0.49087175726890564,
-0.17154672741889954,
-0.21618680655956268,
-0.20427411794662476,
-0.8553404211997986,
-0.20263507962226868,
-0.12605372071266174,
-0.22284053266048431,
-0.06613198667764664,
0.014032620005309582,
-0.9175533652305603,
-0.02198977582156658,
-0.248711496591568,
0.3228868842124939,
-0.42583543062210083,
-0.18972869217395782,
-0.02448156848549843,
0.2030927836894989,
0.383502721786499,
0.11307019740343094,
-1.1759707927703857,
0.37917086482048035,
0.39283496141433716,
0.8751795291900635,
-0.32381460070610046,
-0.5015506744384766,
-0.7227923274040222,
0.3457127809524536,
-0.41340938210487366,
0.7289659380912781,
-0.537544846534729,
-0.5817782282829285,
0.15337567031383514,
0.06430374085903168,
0.029087306931614876,
-0.21822452545166016,
0.05795407295227051,
-0.2914765179157257,
0.16228510439395905,
-0.30707380175590515,
-0.2896712124347687,
-0.1007799580693245,
-0.19490236043930054,
-0.5314203500747681,
0.920311450958252,
0.3880472481250763,
-0.4936347007751465,
0.16220827400684357,
-0.8210272789001465,
-0.7601280212402344,
0.10550945997238159,
0.13191889226436615,
0.3597530424594879,
0.3362525403499603,
0.2760104835033417,
0.22884713113307953,
-0.6300441026687622,
0.04584648087620735,
0.031088458374142647,
-0.22394351661205292,
0.13045057654380798,
-0.3054722249507904,
1.0916000604629517,
0.39589059352874756,
0.05323057994246483,
-0.3787650465965271,
-0.5649528503417969,
0.5292699933052063,
0.015700317919254303,
-0.23010598123073578,
-0.6577666997909546,
-0.7041053771972656,
0.32416269183158875,
-0.08467566967010498,
0.4376210868358612,
-0.8268969655036926,
-0.053373150527477264,
-0.2130027413368225,
0.294498473405838,
0.6063950061798096,
-0.4126660227775574,
1.1148515939712524,
-0.23224833607673645,
0.41409772634506226,
-0.016940632835030556,
-0.015492034144699574,
-0.08984453976154327,
-0.08770053088665009,
-0.49594464898109436,
-0.2944543957710266,
0.9161441326141357,
0.6954466104507446,
-0.6650530695915222,
0.1149125024676323,
-0.2299281805753708,
-0.13435225188732147,
-0.9732037782669067,
0.6937416195869446,
0.6963873505592346,
0.3037264347076416,
0.44753485918045044,
-0.62973952293396,
-0.49121859669685364,
-0.7128947377204895,
-0.25478097796440125,
-0.043726854026317596,
0.17871254682540894,
-0.06923015415668488,
0.16162513196468353,
-0.30978018045425415,
0.7503088712692261,
-0.305621474981308,
-0.4602918326854706,
-0.4023694396018982,
0.19193555414676666,
-0.28858357667922974,
0.6415432095527649,
0.6286996006965637,
-0.7128064632415771,
-0.9124580025672913,
0.4996892809867859,
-0.608622133731842,
-0.43494075536727905,
-0.03225782886147499,
-0.523507297039032,
0.44372737407684326,
0.33091843128204346,
-0.15630508959293365,
0.1760101020336151,
0.8360891938209534,
-0.30393609404563904,
-0.16691747307777405,
-0.24404866993427277,
-0.02226596511900425,
-1.2023217678070068,
0.1056675836443901,
-0.28623872995376587,
-0.21873772144317627,
-0.47789937257766724,
-0.0817122682929039,
0.08570117503404617,
-0.05993766337633133,
-0.7847620248794556,
1.0782076120376587,
-0.7893487811088562,
-0.33331194519996643,
-0.07371733337640762,
0.329382985830307,
0.23779286444187164,
0.3666585087776184,
-0.05885622650384903,
0.6730269193649292,
0.7115203142166138,
-0.13212069869041443,
0.43750032782554626,
0.4030928909778595,
-0.5051681399345398,
0.8057761192321777,
-0.38438937067985535,
-0.11621777713298798,
-0.09054455161094666,
-0.12755364179611206,
-1.0222598314285278,
0.00818361435085535,
-0.1395612508058548,
-0.41372135281562805,
0.658447265625,
-0.11331195384263992,
-0.19940927624702454,
0.28556835651397705,
-0.16778956353664398,
0.8279685378074646,
0.5594656467437744,
-0.8226044178009033,
0.7645840048789978,
0.5750936269760132,
-0.12052996456623077,
-0.8406725525856018,
-1.0722506046295166,
-0.3460349142551422,
0.13179126381874084,
-0.5462005138397217,
0.5897348523139954,
0.0217584278434515,
-0.15753936767578125,
0.425044983625412,
-0.061482757329940796,
-0.3002910912036896,
-0.05608024075627327,
-0.19412441551685333,
0.24224545061588287,
-0.2385675311088562,
0.007639672607183456,
0.1876084804534912,
-0.3062203824520111,
-0.30027079582214355,
-0.36449867486953735,
0.38935697078704834,
-0.20204412937164307,
-0.20733943581581116,
-0.3354615271091461,
0.5719460248947144,
0.42494556307792664,
-0.26831552386283875,
0.5262113809585571,
0.5615637302398682,
-0.39110156893730164,
-0.3197151720523834,
-0.15093202888965607,
0.032243434339761734,
-0.42047378420829773,
0.5243263244628906,
-0.339331716299057,
-0.6990869641304016,
0.5571480393409729,
-0.2331373542547226,
0.21285435557365417,
0.165039524435997,
0.2965042293071747,
0.09588759392499924,
0.8235039710998535,
1.009044885635376,
-0.2625030279159546,
0.3802700340747833,
-0.17093047499656677,
0.20640245079994202,
-1.006327509880066,
-0.4341695308685303,
-0.2359805554151535,
-0.4321484863758087,
-0.5865691900253296,
-0.49038931727409363,
-0.11599334329366684,
0.1795119196176529,
-0.28067028522491455,
0.42277827858924866,
-0.1930447369813919,
0.8634713888168335,
0.3989928364753723,
-0.4486951231956482,
0.3658236265182495,
0.2832683026790619,
-0.7011330723762512,
-0.1365804523229599,
-0.9748468995094299,
-0.008713479153811932,
1.0843969583511353,
0.11363156139850616,
1.147404432296753,
0.4845745265483856,
0.7758282423019409,
0.15667733550071716,
0.3830925524234772,
-0.903306782245636,
0.2628641426563263,
-0.44916632771492004,
-0.40104570984840393,
-0.5535264611244202,
-0.6325738430023193,
-1.167254090309143,
0.6281533241271973,
-0.14282801747322083,
-0.8726242184638977,
0.24533875286579132,
-0.11915257573127747,
-0.31631600856781006,
0.38905757665634155,
-0.6678568720817566,
1.0077919960021973,
-0.7771754860877991,
-0.44636234641075134,
0.0842956155538559,
-0.4520837962627411,
0.2709423899650574,
-0.340125173330307,
0.4231969714164734,
-0.14117750525474548,
-0.24948982894420624,
0.8098576068878174,
-0.12667979300022125,
0.6192589402198792,
-0.006869906559586525,
-0.031132597476243973,
0.14573398232460022,
0.4890024960041046,
0.03816388174891472,
0.09511097520589828,
0.24423031508922577,
0.31028780341148376,
0.354927659034729,
-0.6465957760810852,
-0.621277928352356,
0.9153881072998047,
-0.8966745138168335,
-0.09661968797445297,
-0.5382736325263977,
-0.9536834955215454,
-0.289681077003479,
0.43934762477874756,
0.15584796667099,
0.41753411293029785,
-0.482902467250824,
0.291576087474823,
0.5613139271736145,
-0.12641175091266632,
0.43118739128112793,
0.8185986280441284,
-0.46311840415000916,
-0.3838076591491699,
0.9902883172035217,
0.10003451257944107,
0.40686240792274475,
0.7620839476585388,
0.25805342197418213,
-0.49416887760162354,
-0.07207869738340378,
-0.5176556706428528,
0.4374465346336365,
-0.6848106384277344,
-0.3013971447944641,
-0.1957165151834488,
-0.08024559170007706,
-0.5367987155914307,
-0.6147056818008423,
-0.8261072039604187,
-0.34893152117729187,
-0.17804981768131256,
0.289946585893631,
0.09109800308942795,
0.4091551601886749,
-0.599885106086731,
0.39740127325057983,
-0.9904725551605225,
0.040982022881507874,
0.195076584815979,
0.33844193816185,
-0.13698194921016693,
-0.8979726433753967,
-0.16612538695335388,
0.13660241663455963,
-0.1849542260169983,
-0.39911508560180664,
0.426726758480072,
0.45846644043922424,
0.778641402721405,
0.41786763072013855,
0.24705055356025696,
0.6407779455184937,
-0.32883504033088684,
0.3215688169002533,
0.6566565036773682,
-1.206710696220398,
0.16175897419452667,
0.23386923968791962,
0.39889153838157654,
0.6610590219497681,
0.6555896997451782,
-0.7659255862236023,
0.3538369834423065,
-0.4643910229206085,
-0.7421454191207886,
0.5721579790115356,
-0.1504877805709839,
0.17987094819545746,
0.3896844983100891,
-0.19959083199501038,
-0.0028959917835891247,
-0.0860075131058693,
-0.3709772825241089,
-0.0005678160232491791,
-0.06071234866976738,
-0.2094283550977707,
-0.10729989409446716,
0.03557024896144867,
-0.16668419539928436,
-0.38919252157211304,
0.6677084565162659,
-0.46879830956459045,
0.096089668571949,
-0.1378466635942459,
-0.4940606355667114,
-0.5263646841049194,
0.16229330003261566,
0.1440211534500122,
0.7157625555992126,
-0.12874887883663177,
0.05233876034617424,
0.3329401910305023,
-0.22399233281612396,
0.3262163996696472,
0.10506651550531387,
-0.12297201156616211,
0.022661538794636726,
0.38700681924819946,
0.7088529467582703,
0.8423922061920166,
-0.7365075349807739,
0.6015858054161072,
0.053805865347385406,
-0.19972293078899384,
-0.10201955586671829,
-0.28433138132095337,
-0.09596149623394012,
0.1694972664117813,
0.04121749848127365,
-0.27948883175849915,
-0.16111129522323608,
-0.9208186864852905,
0.2756032347679138,
0.6276789307594299,
-0.4363481402397156,
-0.2852155566215515,
0.26664841175079346,
0.2801187336444855,
-0.05062910169363022,
0.7320712208747864,
-0.0435018390417099,
-0.523112952709198,
0.18277770280838013,
0.8445639610290527,
0.62044358253479,
-0.5326153635978699,
0.6420871615409851,
0.12148211151361465,
0.3858204782009125,
-0.16637970507144928,
0.2445770502090454,
-0.1154017224907875,
-1.0266412496566772,
-0.39539191126823425,
-0.8201730251312256,
-0.4177740812301636,
-0.2934173345565796,
-0.766200840473175,
0.1753663867712021,
-0.3459175229072571,
0.39545735716819763,
-0.12383659183979034,
0.21954260766506195,
-0.7629439830780029,
-0.14759773015975952,
0.06417255103588104,
0.8771706223487854,
-0.8912421464920044,
0.7322119474411011,
0.8076632618904114,
-0.25315162539482117,
-0.7168293595314026,
-0.2884833812713623,
0.049393508583307266,
-1.1971490383148193,
0.6496203541755676,
-0.10471873730421066,
-0.12015928328037262,
0.10660301893949509,
-0.12070941179990768,
-1.2551792860031128,
1.196527123451233,
0.5283819437026978,
-0.388774573802948,
0.057268206030130386,
0.34762194752693176,
0.2481345385313034,
-0.5940243601799011,
0.12913773953914642,
0.6695850491523743,
0.49965646862983704,
0.5509481430053711,
-1.021582007408142,
0.05424586310982704,
0.06784121692180634,
0.18127098679542542,
0.5604477524757385,
-0.6346544623374939,
0.7696150541305542,
-0.3851873278617859,
-0.36022254824638367,
0.2555069029331207,
0.7266194820404053,
-0.26912975311279297,
0.024073917418718338,
0.3155428171157837,
0.7396071553230286,
0.8992506861686707,
0.01677880436182022,
0.8499147891998291,
-0.4099501371383667,
0.44390684366226196,
0.8382844924926758,
-0.49349477887153625,
0.7697663307189941,
0.7645186185836792,
-0.06418383866548538,
0.2867527902126312,
0.31086215376853943,
0.2468447983264923,
0.9213070869445801,
0.26401108503341675,
-0.08205549418926239,
-0.242616668343544,
-0.5733342170715332,
-0.18923479318618774,
0.5650610327720642,
0.2776585817337036,
-0.0769410952925682,
-0.7038921117782593,
0.047268789261579514,
0.03796503692865372,
-0.013217547908425331,
-0.4367978572845459,
0.5489988327026367,
0.21364983916282654,
-0.6302924752235413,
0.7917178273200989,
-0.0675477683544159,
0.6164283752441406,
-0.7275562286376953,
0.1336563378572464,
-0.5378029942512512,
0.312863826751709,
-0.14437267184257507,
-0.7969794273376465,
0.20010146498680115,
-0.21457964181900024,
0.14437077939510345,
-0.3040388822555542,
0.5255399942398071,
-0.900518536567688,
-0.5299405455589294,
0.6172035932540894,
0.7472040057182312,
0.2563450038433075,
0.5514636635780334,
-0.6796339154243469,
-0.151927649974823,
0.12432938814163208,
0.11806809902191162,
0.8103476166725159,
0.7798186540603638,
-0.08068471401929855,
0.46815910935401917,
0.7127227187156677,
0.3186315596103668,
0.05763014405965805,
-0.17975440621376038,
0.5825482606887817,
-0.37295520305633545,
-0.335686057806015,
-0.30968964099884033,
0.3969751000404358,
0.14721578359603882,
-0.4088290333747864,
0.4188370108604431,
0.4556241035461426,
1.2839752435684204,
0.11894594877958298,
0.7842928171157837,
-0.20104265213012695,
0.22026072442531586,
-0.5530050992965698,
0.4821487069129944,
-0.9064387679100037,
0.09512706100940704,
-0.1107204407453537,
-1.0680674314498901,
-0.345511794090271,
0.7976273894309998,
0.030714474618434906,
-0.13904769718647003,
0.875850260257721,
0.8722795248031616,
-0.4430907070636749,
-0.25795963406562805,
0.642406165599823,
-0.11962205916643143,
-0.13048437237739563,
0.8543764352798462,
0.610175609588623,
-0.35694563388824463,
0.5866822004318237,
-0.5006836652755737,
-0.44293108582496643,
-0.1294334977865219,
-1.0040724277496338,
-0.7490228414535522,
-0.5124906301498413,
-0.21631595492362976,
-0.14127644896507263,
0.10415279120206833,
1.005581021308899,
0.4405894875526428,
-0.9017610549926758,
-0.5802791118621826,
0.3078235685825348,
0.02087779901921749,
-0.11203040182590485,
-0.19800858199596405,
0.3031432330608368,
-0.5169054865837097,
-0.7106174230575562,
0.29472994804382324,
0.10695227980613708,
0.07491236925125122,
-0.3557714521884918,
-0.3800705373287201,
-0.37996187806129456,
0.19854432344436646,
0.39291054010391235,
0.7438881993293762,
-0.4744184911251068,
-0.14805684983730316,
-0.09382409602403641,
-0.08668811619281769,
-0.2162473499774933,
0.8549270033836365,
-0.5715590119361877,
0.4754106104373932,
0.630999743938446,
1.1577757596969604,
0.023424983024597168,
-0.18931637704372406,
0.5646661520004272,
-0.8561804294586182,
0.37331798672676086,
-0.011071424931287766,
0.6820537447929382,
0.5095316767692566,
-0.19331054389476776,
0.5439504384994507,
0.3076867461204529,
-0.23731817305088043,
-0.915367603302002,
0.11344081908464432,
-0.8271092772483826,
-0.37845951318740845,
1.0133806467056274,
-0.12221982330083847,
-0.3924483060836792,
0.08521774411201477,
0.08220665156841278,
0.17313432693481445,
-0.42485180497169495,
0.48594000935554504,
0.6004632711410522,
0.041951194405555725,
-0.1913129985332489,
-0.3286382257938385,
0.23451031744480133,
0.6374149322509766,
-0.5541697144508362,
0.05348667874932289,
0.10726255178451538,
0.4077691435813904,
0.4001559019088745,
0.3849518597126007,
-0.14534136652946472,
0.301736444234848,
-0.1299341768026352,
-0.07608700543642044,
0.047518014907836914,
-0.6321477293968201,
-0.09652392566204071,
-0.1673971712589264,
-0.12479601800441742,
-0.22419564425945282
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10307v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10307v1
|
What is the best model? Application-driven Evaluation for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-14T04:52:15 | 2024-06-14T04:52:15 |
Shiguo Lian, Kaikai Zhao, Xinhui Liu, Xuejiao Lei, Bikun Yang, Wenjing Zhang, Kai Wang, Zhaoxiang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
General large language models enhanced with supervised fine-tuning and
reinforcement learning from human feedback are increasingly popular in academia
and industry as they generalize foundation models to various practical tasks in
a prompt manner. To assist users in selecting the best model in practical
application scenarios, i.e., choosing the model that meets the application
requirements while minimizing cost, we introduce A-Eval, an application-driven
LLMs evaluation benchmark for general large language models. First, we
categorize evaluation tasks into five main categories and 27 sub-categories
from a practical application perspective. Next, we construct a dataset
comprising 678 question-and-answer pairs through a process of collecting,
annotating, and reviewing. Then, we design an objective and effective
evaluation method and evaluate a series of LLMs of different scales on A-Eval.
Finally, we reveal interesting laws regarding model scale and task difficulty
level and propose a feasible method for selecting the best model. Through
A-Eval, we provide clear empirical and engineer guidance for selecting the best
model, reducing barriers to selecting and using LLMs and promoting their
application and development. Our benchmark is publicly available at
https://github.com/UnicomAI/DataSet/tree/main/TestData/GeneralAbility.
|
[
-0.3347255289554596,
-1.015472650527954,
0.6357274055480957,
0.3588206470012665,
-0.03145107254385948,
0.08884315192699432,
-0.5575348734855652,
-0.26781606674194336,
-0.2551189959049225,
0.5535942912101746,
-0.45399796962738037,
-0.58673495054245,
-0.2553172707557678,
0.03330884873867035,
-0.7970488667488098,
0.7737559080123901,
-0.037833575159311295,
0.0629744902253151,
-0.5083572268486023,
0.008601969107985497,
-0.22707097232341766,
-0.48146042227745056,
-0.8380240797996521,
-0.5780661106109619,
0.344929039478302,
0.24253448843955994,
0.6286453604698181,
0.6869048476219177,
0.4792061746120453,
0.3326244354248047,
-0.1528327465057373,
-0.008543549105525017,
-0.3465920090675354,
0.03171949088573456,
-0.3674788773059845,
-0.20036599040031433,
-0.47132939100265503,
-0.07242223620414734,
0.33874985575675964,
0.8988495469093323,
-0.4262043237686157,
0.5395147800445557,
-0.046249404549598694,
0.5158449411392212,
-0.7087358832359314,
0.10129612684249878,
-0.48018816113471985,
-0.30628037452697754,
0.006916786078363657,
-0.012514849193394184,
-0.47752875089645386,
-0.41910508275032043,
0.020059239119291306,
-0.3153184950351715,
-0.07568063586950302,
0.25984781980514526,
0.6390358805656433,
0.011583898216485977,
-0.5601499676704407,
-0.3768180310726166,
-0.771250307559967,
0.9954738616943359,
-0.5721408128738403,
0.5344088673591614,
0.29950764775276184,
0.43978071212768555,
-0.03443628177046776,
-0.5734241008758545,
-0.2106526494026184,
-0.7761968374252319,
0.1550665944814682,
-0.10072910785675049,
-0.3218887448310852,
0.17163190245628357,
0.10374946147203445,
0.43707823753356934,
-0.7772299647331238,
0.43985655903816223,
-0.26122546195983887,
-0.11066631227731705,
0.8655425906181335,
0.35575687885284424,
0.12949992716312408,
0.0986320748925209,
-0.2583651840686798,
-0.05421658232808113,
-0.7817457914352417,
-0.08886395394802094,
0.3958056569099426,
0.1802537441253662,
0.03854746371507645,
0.5247683525085449,
-0.46388277411460876,
0.8222460150718689,
-0.1268121898174286,
0.06869115680456161,
0.21294434368610382,
-0.08898359537124634,
-0.1837000995874405,
-0.36635929346084595,
0.9753583073616028,
0.31097084283828735,
0.4281744360923767,
-0.3266063928604126,
-0.7307227253913879,
0.17677924036979675,
0.3748403489589691,
-0.739958643913269,
-0.01923898234963417,
0.1995820552110672,
-0.421024888753891,
-0.358602911233902,
-0.35130324959754944,
-0.574981689453125,
-0.41063231229782104,
-0.483793705701828,
0.397055059671402,
-0.018564822152256966,
-0.2308870106935501,
0.13084939122200012,
0.3288838863372803,
-0.06785713136196136,
0.4299052059650421,
-0.9421238899230957,
0.7151960730552673,
0.7311744689941406,
0.6228624582290649,
-0.3707534074783325,
-0.21173369884490967,
-0.6293478012084961,
-0.21273685991764069,
-0.5432350039482117,
0.770879328250885,
-0.5234812498092651,
-0.43708905577659607,
0.04549090936779976,
-0.21965447068214417,
-0.08503825962543488,
-0.8240199089050293,
0.5158938765525818,
-0.6214153170585632,
-0.053994789719581604,
0.05946808308362961,
-0.7019826769828796,
-0.26543164253234863,
0.2617133855819702,
-0.5343120098114014,
1.009719729423523,
0.21594420075416565,
-0.17136208713054657,
0.0777830109000206,
-0.7604451775550842,
-0.2596410810947418,
0.2082132250070572,
-0.11785831302404404,
-0.23346132040023804,
0.3253524601459503,
0.05754527077078819,
0.4902175962924957,
-0.7834905385971069,
0.5281438827514648,
-0.4016636312007904,
-0.28314852714538574,
0.27742937207221985,
-0.5018256306648254,
0.5299537777900696,
0.43873319029808044,
-0.12773552536964417,
0.38774874806404114,
-0.9269430637359619,
0.23427435755729675,
0.1558980941772461,
-0.5210407972335815,
-0.1289653331041336,
0.14552554488182068,
0.3313991129398346,
0.03419960290193558,
0.25943002104759216,
-0.5219035744667053,
0.2052740752696991,
-0.1738935261964798,
0.46147438883781433,
0.6679155230522156,
-0.059360332787036896,
0.28214049339294434,
-0.04578598588705063,
0.8177744150161743,
-0.4176345467567444,
0.2833232879638672,
0.019702479243278503,
-0.06914111226797104,
-0.6757742762565613,
-0.0052484432235360146,
0.4552725851535797,
0.5696634650230408,
-0.3541031777858734,
0.36935898661613464,
-0.05608893558382988,
-0.5358971357345581,
-0.6028885245323181,
0.4308125972747803,
0.5543187260627747,
0.33995917439460754,
0.2216481864452362,
-0.40888893604278564,
-0.4089539647102356,
-1.0602771043777466,
-0.11286602169275284,
-0.3836090564727783,
-0.09284079819917679,
0.43495216965675354,
0.5648136138916016,
-0.36438077688217163,
0.8900364637374878,
-0.491193950176239,
0.01603117398917675,
-0.5463067889213562,
0.14089412987232208,
0.1617325246334076,
0.12564519047737122,
0.4276832044124603,
-0.6717967987060547,
-0.4030301868915558,
0.16712568700313568,
-0.6105217933654785,
-0.45622020959854126,
0.054450828582048416,
-0.056068211793899536,
0.13646845519542694,
0.29437175393104553,
-0.3664606511592865,
0.13504309952259064,
0.6183696389198303,
-0.2025519609451294,
0.7065975666046143,
-0.3461889326572418,
0.13148696720600128,
-0.6042087078094482,
0.3473530113697052,
0.19549313187599182,
-0.33863696455955505,
-0.5711537003517151,
0.18723993003368378,
0.32838940620422363,
0.03541233018040657,
-0.5849182605743408,
0.8803959488868713,
-0.19643492996692657,
-0.27720364928245544,
-0.35284316539764404,
-0.049477409571409225,
-0.09713514149188995,
0.32156291604042053,
-0.07390036433935165,
0.903326690196991,
0.5432437062263489,
-0.6319316625595093,
0.6770316958427429,
0.05348692089319229,
-0.7152993679046631,
0.26886171102523804,
-0.7694951295852661,
0.2759031653404236,
0.14693838357925415,
-0.08860919624567032,
-0.6510492563247681,
-0.17507895827293396,
-0.1759047657251358,
-0.10633772611618042,
0.03895209729671478,
0.05914608761668205,
-0.5423526167869568,
-0.4370691776275635,
-0.10549184679985046,
0.15401794016361237,
0.46443498134613037,
-0.5527397394180298,
0.4496537148952484,
0.3074873387813568,
-0.1279405802488327,
-0.29688477516174316,
-0.43523165583610535,
0.1263791173696518,
-0.19727438688278198,
-0.37863749265670776,
0.034899044781923294,
-0.31920918822288513,
-0.45564988255500793,
0.018916843459010124,
-0.026701994240283966,
-0.23412835597991943,
0.43178418278694153,
0.004680538550019264,
0.049406539648771286,
-0.26101064682006836,
0.15571512281894684,
-0.22354795038700104,
-0.17047305405139923,
0.14382067322731018,
0.1570366621017456,
0.4989909529685974,
-0.46030792593955994,
-0.43551215529441833,
-0.24370115995407104,
0.1878385841846466,
0.588176965713501,
-0.2949754595756531,
0.4130939841270447,
0.19756019115447998,
-0.30777278542518616,
-0.2873155176639557,
-0.6440969705581665,
0.12886136770248413,
-0.4614005386829376,
0.6470510959625244,
-0.3371928632259369,
-0.6916489005088806,
0.41544264554977417,
-0.30881762504577637,
0.08368396013975143,
0.41229555010795593,
0.6954038143157959,
0.2744361460208893,
1.271114706993103,
0.6093167066574097,
-0.33498865365982056,
0.3354383707046509,
-0.3501245379447937,
0.07050159573554993,
-0.8134097456932068,
-0.13779257237911224,
-0.5431133508682251,
0.03368237987160683,
-0.15248093008995056,
-0.08441928774118423,
0.3005548417568207,
0.35571548342704773,
-0.22133532166481018,
0.22747722268104553,
-0.1567278802394867,
0.5556675791740417,
0.42853182554244995,
-0.08483200520277023,
0.3595976233482361,
-0.2855969965457916,
-0.07700049877166748,
0.36628827452659607,
-0.44171762466430664,
-0.8455098867416382,
1.1688379049301147,
0.3980197608470917,
0.9245924949645996,
0.07657904922962189,
0.600488543510437,
0.4671774208545685,
0.5772575736045837,
-0.8645856380462646,
0.8208714723587036,
-0.1656998097896576,
-0.5100938081741333,
-0.2663644552230835,
-0.5453454256057739,
-0.9378862977027893,
0.42846137285232544,
-0.13659434020519257,
-0.889985978603363,
-0.4269241392612457,
0.30458325147628784,
-0.24247147142887115,
0.062971331179142,
-0.7952023148536682,
1.0056655406951904,
-0.6514236330986023,
-0.35554540157318115,
-0.45128941535949707,
-0.19648471474647522,
0.31035345792770386,
-0.15760183334350586,
0.4358460307121277,
-0.08498609066009521,
-0.12295182049274445,
0.45057329535484314,
-0.2483646273612976,
0.41986551880836487,
-0.08361637592315674,
-0.06277165561914444,
0.35244444012641907,
0.0943077877163887,
0.38899627327919006,
-0.19048990309238434,
-0.3828364610671997,
-0.020038291811943054,
-0.1441805362701416,
0.007094870321452618,
-0.7252158522605896,
0.7570359706878662,
-0.6103678941726685,
-0.58674556016922,
-0.15314196050167084,
-0.2765696942806244,
-0.3422035276889801,
0.02725069597363472,
-0.10632030665874481,
0.6524349451065063,
-0.44275423884391785,
0.4840191602706909,
0.3632924258708954,
-0.3994254767894745,
0.3748653531074524,
0.7904782295227051,
-0.5227163434028625,
-0.2617287337779999,
0.8529693484306335,
-0.11703246831893921,
0.30206745862960815,
0.3876688480377197,
0.4821523129940033,
-0.47771531343460083,
-0.732022225856781,
-0.7245227694511414,
-0.04452471062541008,
-0.6628389954566956,
-0.06518740206956863,
-0.5335139632225037,
-0.1850401610136032,
-0.12543985247612,
-0.013224897906184196,
-0.5846666097640991,
-0.1628687083721161,
-0.08081117272377014,
-0.10918743908405304,
0.09806991368532181,
0.921883225440979,
0.2506423890590668,
0.1555255949497223,
-0.6434624791145325,
0.17940551042556763,
0.2751460671424866,
0.5417065620422363,
0.2179579883813858,
-0.2929283678531647,
-0.3200131356716156,
-0.12631119787693024,
-0.4526515603065491,
-0.559790313243866,
0.40733620524406433,
0.31525918841362,
0.7088226675987244,
0.3110673129558563,
-0.02878584899008274,
0.2949788570404053,
-0.5295940637588501,
0.7882828712463379,
0.12927545607089996,
-0.9031552076339722,
0.538637101650238,
-0.26795050501823425,
0.3276185095310211,
0.4798963963985443,
0.14752990007400513,
-0.5011035799980164,
-0.26607170701026917,
-0.41404104232788086,
-1.0338255167007446,
0.4462563097476959,
-0.05832713469862938,
0.09528525173664093,
-0.060422319918870926,
0.20413130521774292,
0.328182578086853,
0.3896324932575226,
-0.7186036109924316,
-0.13717950880527496,
0.3594287633895874,
-0.32532334327697754,
-0.29392674565315247,
-0.14472760260105133,
0.16890738904476166,
-0.03939790278673172,
0.7453548908233643,
-0.15554946660995483,
-0.05736861377954483,
-0.32925066351890564,
-0.4028659462928772,
-0.26299452781677246,
0.5002049803733826,
0.48085781931877136,
0.9659582376480103,
-0.2201850414276123,
0.010592435486614704,
0.31881600618362427,
-0.2176821082830429,
0.12660330533981323,
-0.021209828555583954,
-0.14466692507266998,
-0.2779283821582794,
0.3584229648113251,
1.0594857931137085,
0.319205641746521,
-1.0453482866287231,
0.4992278218269348,
-0.09199334681034088,
-0.14915238320827484,
-0.07942638546228409,
0.3880470395088196,
0.005173564422875643,
0.3165441155433655,
0.3677945137023926,
-0.397129625082016,
0.4428013563156128,
-0.4626351296901703,
-0.011896063573658466,
0.4518870413303375,
-0.04981726035475731,
-0.3282177150249481,
0.7079536318778992,
0.2947937548160553,
-0.4608556032180786,
0.4376077950000763,
-0.10677759349346161,
-0.4954802393913269,
0.5777114629745483,
0.4362986981868744,
1.0080965757369995,
-0.24786578118801117,
0.3062974512577057,
0.19445005059242249,
0.10065571218729019,
-0.2955431044101715,
0.16294744610786438,
0.01581660285592079,
-0.38324296474456787,
-0.39300069212913513,
-0.9309741258621216,
-0.8177769780158997,
0.5437433123588562,
-0.6427906155586243,
0.20469282567501068,
-0.2976059317588806,
-0.01579325832426548,
-0.1140190064907074,
0.20924656093120575,
-0.7260043621063232,
0.4986180067062378,
0.013427396304905415,
0.8556526899337769,
-0.8337103724479675,
0.6952332258224487,
0.8980523943901062,
-0.06640544533729553,
-0.5673937797546387,
-0.37153542041778564,
-0.03912026435136795,
-0.7632207274436951,
0.4991077780723572,
0.0935722291469574,
-0.04415467754006386,
-0.024949219077825546,
-0.36505192518234253,
-0.8045471906661987,
0.8180149793624878,
0.5213955640792847,
-0.7373811602592468,
0.3860296905040741,
0.041040826588869095,
0.6940863132476807,
-0.48258113861083984,
0.6020237803459167,
0.6149850487709045,
0.2356487214565277,
0.0652402862906456,
-1.100783109664917,
-0.12601308524608612,
-0.3222166895866394,
0.2925383448600769,
0.19217489659786224,
-0.5950295925140381,
0.6274020671844482,
-0.09047756344079971,
0.021330704912543297,
0.34915652871131897,
0.3716886639595032,
0.256458044052124,
0.35675767064094543,
0.6852362751960754,
0.41402584314346313,
0.5658923983573914,
0.052388615906238556,
1.3521978855133057,
-0.4035065770149231,
0.38436076045036316,
1.035251498222351,
-0.3561611771583557,
1.0643450021743774,
0.20544077455997467,
-0.33937546610832214,
0.184533029794693,
0.7728856801986694,
-0.0003088869561906904,
0.5514492392539978,
0.618593156337738,
-0.21338599920272827,
-0.33648309111595154,
-0.17534372210502625,
-0.13908469676971436,
0.4962207078933716,
0.18348079919815063,
-0.2728479504585266,
-0.25035175681114197,
-0.01941484399139881,
-0.30721262097358704,
0.11639313399791718,
-0.4506445527076721,
0.7104039788246155,
0.019779330119490623,
-0.7187952399253845,
0.4837660491466522,
0.28480008244514465,
0.40314361453056335,
-0.7488161325454712,
0.18631313741207123,
-0.23051778972148895,
0.31081682443618774,
-0.0436258390545845,
-0.6591078042984009,
-0.017251040786504745,
0.3089040219783783,
-0.04998880252242088,
-0.34544533491134644,
0.6532914042472839,
-0.5123266577720642,
-0.48804885149002075,
0.3761933445930481,
0.4423058032989502,
0.22547709941864014,
-0.04166199266910553,
-0.7029566764831543,
0.2886902391910553,
-0.33066344261169434,
-0.7478888630867004,
0.4388642907142639,
0.058039091527462006,
-0.3217932879924774,
1.0395294427871704,
0.41930729150772095,
0.21229767799377441,
-0.15346543490886688,
0.3950673043727875,
0.6753690838813782,
-0.5655161738395691,
-0.39610418677330017,
-0.7875745296478271,
0.43943876028060913,
0.11203937977552414,
-0.4177636206150055,
0.6111475229263306,
0.8061865568161011,
0.7356011867523193,
-0.013218224979937077,
0.8389104008674622,
0.2271016240119934,
0.5535622835159302,
-0.5011126399040222,
0.5401135683059692,
-0.5968093872070312,
0.33784055709838867,
-0.14553232491016388,
-1.1235895156860352,
-0.17228609323501587,
0.6856805086135864,
-0.38610222935676575,
0.21438682079315186,
0.5271329879760742,
0.7057188749313354,
-0.03846294432878494,
0.056018199771642685,
0.3348381817340851,
0.12971806526184082,
0.3514508008956909,
0.6165120005607605,
0.9529463648796082,
-0.19054871797561646,
0.23961074650287628,
-0.16600261628627777,
-0.3179044723510742,
-0.23228731751441956,
-0.9562104344367981,
-0.7584931254386902,
-0.3240678012371063,
-0.5450377464294434,
0.015687700361013412,
0.2661783993244171,
1.169657826423645,
0.7075387239456177,
-0.8919466137886047,
-0.775420069694519,
-0.16077706217765808,
-0.058267783373594284,
-0.14981374144554138,
-0.19022175669670105,
0.24552591145038605,
-0.31313663721084595,
-0.6916494369506836,
0.5865079164505005,
0.2386254072189331,
-0.1829223781824112,
-0.3675728738307953,
-0.2696978449821472,
-0.0404411144554615,
0.01030462421476841,
0.6304293274879456,
0.23971427977085114,
-0.7620026469230652,
-0.2529715299606323,
-0.16312594711780548,
-0.1162087619304657,
-0.35945793986320496,
0.6489502191543579,
-0.5552220940589905,
0.4630059599876404,
0.10480830073356628,
0.8212850093841553,
0.410556435585022,
-0.06958921253681183,
0.6195617914199829,
-0.5603740215301514,
-0.270058274269104,
0.154709592461586,
0.26773545145988464,
0.34773898124694824,
-0.15396156907081604,
0.7713844180107117,
-0.10100094228982925,
-0.6041409373283386,
-0.9300934672355652,
0.03798971325159073,
-0.6746959686279297,
-0.1666063517332077,
1.4655253887176514,
-0.04663022980093956,
-0.17537930607795715,
0.21360959112644196,
-0.2128722369670868,
-0.14906993508338928,
-0.37381359934806824,
0.8173426985740662,
0.8209221959114075,
-0.2683190107345581,
-0.09111671149730682,
-0.7526839971542358,
0.19051800668239594,
0.2798229157924652,
-0.8748026490211487,
0.14316366612911224,
0.5742394924163818,
0.27489158511161804,
-0.3455412685871124,
0.4692530632019043,
0.2136353701353073,
0.0943555012345314,
-0.3565554618835449,
0.05556676536798477,
-0.2012309730052948,
-0.37340572476387024,
-0.5577466487884521,
0.2899051308631897,
0.4536568522453308,
-0.010621040128171444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09702v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09702v1
|
Detecting Response Generation Not Requiring Factual Judgment
| 2024-06-14T04:03:24 | 2024-06-14T04:03:24 |
Ryohei Kamei, Daiki Shiono, Reina Akama, Jun Suzuki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the remarkable development of large language models (LLMs), ensuring the
factuality of output has become a challenge. However, having all the contents
of the response with given knowledge or facts is not necessarily a good thing
in dialogues. This study aimed to achieve both attractiveness and factuality in
a dialogue response for which a task was set to predict sentences that do not
require factual correctness judgment such as agreeing, or personal
opinions/feelings. We created a dataset, dialogue dataset annotated with
fact-check-needed label (DDFC), for this task via crowdsourcing, and
classification tasks were performed on several models using this dataset. The
model with the highest classification accuracy could yield about 88% accurate
classification results.
|
[
-0.4549526572227478,
-0.7366934418678284,
0.584743320941925,
0.20674312114715576,
-0.1867194026708603,
-0.03018089570105076,
-0.15824812650680542,
-0.33163851499557495,
0.21381275355815887,
0.7013314366340637,
-0.6009489297866821,
-0.5431503653526306,
-0.575690507888794,
0.4282049536705017,
-0.5427154302597046,
1.237388014793396,
0.418855756521225,
-0.02862996980547905,
-0.6793724298477173,
-0.17044934630393982,
-0.14892837405204773,
-0.367760568857193,
-0.47836270928382874,
-0.08006087690591812,
0.5411285758018494,
0.5352843999862671,
0.3798602223396301,
0.3058635890483856,
0.33965399861335754,
0.4345248341560364,
-0.06188922002911568,
0.4394165873527527,
-0.47663918137550354,
0.19112363457679749,
-0.2199716567993164,
-0.5394378900527954,
-0.2205996811389923,
0.2320527583360672,
0.30631789565086365,
0.3988640308380127,
0.00004028379771625623,
0.37403351068496704,
0.02415267564356327,
0.5839516520500183,
-0.36305832862854004,
0.5018051266670227,
-0.6816196441650391,
0.12882797420024872,
-0.08776253461837769,
-0.259356290102005,
-0.6658526659011841,
-0.6493421792984009,
0.3286609649658203,
-0.3331591486930847,
0.5910497903823853,
0.5056192874908447,
0.7291390299797058,
0.30110323429107666,
-0.3775542378425598,
-0.5008009672164917,
-0.49584442377090454,
0.6809489130973816,
-0.823975682258606,
0.2581692934036255,
0.5364352464675903,
0.1473415046930313,
-0.18152840435504913,
-0.3977642357349396,
-0.9318225979804993,
-0.46248024702072144,
-0.3889395594596863,
0.3077680170536041,
-0.12169452756643295,
0.143989697098732,
0.612622857093811,
0.28024616837501526,
-0.3649744391441345,
-0.12772467732429504,
-0.1346183568239212,
-0.4206470549106598,
0.628509521484375,
0.06957636773586273,
0.16385290026664734,
-0.6605518460273743,
-0.4900166094303131,
0.06467501819133759,
-0.3643450438976288,
0.13063928484916687,
0.27571386098861694,
0.5141376256942749,
-0.33613693714141846,
0.7794519066810608,
-0.4460926949977875,
0.43474921584129333,
0.23566751182079315,
-0.3656185269355774,
0.21337220072746277,
-0.7364802360534668,
-0.3411330580711365,
0.1580841988325119,
0.8432491421699524,
0.4511334300041199,
0.1964559406042099,
0.00023868381686042994,
-0.29054030776023865,
0.11972539126873016,
0.13146385550498962,
-0.9061651229858398,
-0.2279859483242035,
0.21373625099658966,
-0.28352653980255127,
-0.6217232346534729,
-0.07849889993667603,
-0.8555837869644165,
-0.36276865005493164,
-0.2502135634422302,
-0.03418643772602081,
-0.030196065083146095,
-0.2024015188217163,
-0.3167630732059479,
0.08702391386032104,
0.12764360010623932,
0.5920506715774536,
-0.6832225322723389,
0.058420486748218536,
0.34446215629577637,
0.7659868001937866,
0.07214582711458206,
0.4263448119163513,
-0.6716684103012085,
-0.12965215742588043,
-0.328239768743515,
1.0890685319900513,
-0.30990833044052124,
-0.45496463775634766,
-0.0027649826370179653,
0.10540725290775299,
-0.07912240922451019,
-0.4237745702266693,
0.9573894739151001,
-0.5795365571975708,
0.5498611330986023,
-0.549850583076477,
-0.39122524857521057,
-0.2545928359031677,
0.39771759510040283,
-0.646987795829773,
0.6140320897102356,
0.0347098745405674,
-1.0564935207366943,
0.6056617498397827,
-0.3989146947860718,
-0.4060071110725403,
0.08281177282333374,
-0.3228797912597656,
-0.4848519265651703,
-0.01809721067547798,
0.05339207500219345,
0.3647201657295227,
-0.13483135402202606,
0.45411092042922974,
-0.5397568345069885,
0.024412138387560844,
0.8197571039199829,
-0.3662434220314026,
0.38676875829696655,
0.34143948554992676,
-0.3626939058303833,
-0.004182907752692699,
-0.8814862370491028,
0.03115818463265896,
0.05564388632774353,
-0.756695032119751,
0.055486809462308884,
0.13265052437782288,
-0.1831284463405609,
0.395109087228775,
0.0356752946972847,
-0.9688841700553894,
0.05590690299868584,
-0.5595805048942566,
-0.118851438164711,
0.9732733964920044,
-0.10774979740381241,
0.06552521139383316,
-0.4386759400367737,
0.22720393538475037,
0.1897774189710617,
-0.2546848952770233,
0.1547037810087204,
-0.5751856565475464,
-1.20243501663208,
-0.2955012619495392,
0.29154640436172485,
0.6071525812149048,
-1.0401631593704224,
0.5928279161453247,
-0.1547723114490509,
-0.18894048035144806,
-0.3838246464729309,
0.14669504761695862,
0.4955369532108307,
0.9986632466316223,
-0.001884798752143979,
-0.12687331438064575,
-0.7672112584114075,
-1.0029966831207275,
-0.003729672636836767,
-0.6758636236190796,
0.12876981496810913,
0.5508347749710083,
0.1513555347919464,
0.07130328565835953,
0.9684116244316101,
-0.6276997327804565,
0.03943893313407898,
-0.27273380756378174,
0.33892443776130676,
0.112276591360569,
0.08428488671779633,
0.5812081098556519,
-0.8109448552131653,
-0.15670748054981232,
-0.08874387294054031,
-0.8823779821395874,
-0.3368145525455475,
0.16086451709270477,
0.095554418861866,
0.364970862865448,
0.16468283534049988,
-0.6565905809402466,
0.4781257212162018,
0.32241085171699524,
-0.035922031849622726,
0.27433115243911743,
0.1413666009902954,
0.39738044142723083,
-0.8581968545913696,
0.10342879593372345,
0.32110774517059326,
-0.49487146735191345,
-0.6553298234939575,
-0.5095073580741882,
-0.20881465077400208,
-0.09510715305805206,
-0.3245428204536438,
0.42330402135849,
0.08910025656223297,
0.05245298147201538,
-0.4411679208278656,
0.17998602986335754,
0.05135643482208252,
0.5384591221809387,
0.37241411209106445,
0.8204609155654907,
0.11144466698169708,
-0.7288902997970581,
0.7344228625297546,
0.6415565013885498,
-0.5418071746826172,
0.5473490953445435,
-0.39430078864097595,
0.2746226191520691,
-0.39338797330856323,
0.30201247334480286,
-1.2265914678573608,
-0.6835973858833313,
0.4382503926753998,
-0.628149688243866,
0.035701848566532135,
-0.003147124545648694,
-0.3697310984134674,
-0.5070513486862183,
-0.25332656502723694,
-0.005682946648448706,
0.3311026692390442,
-0.6087422370910645,
0.3595091700553894,
0.07144750654697418,
-0.47886529564857483,
-0.4560069143772125,
-0.48547235131263733,
-0.07041455805301666,
-0.2982122302055359,
-0.462294340133667,
-0.3286278247833252,
-0.29976701736450195,
-0.28385335206985474,
-0.436687707901001,
0.01153597328811884,
0.042775027453899384,
-0.00836789421737194,
0.2738434970378876,
0.5037075281143188,
-0.09295972436666489,
0.2308037281036377,
-0.38977402448654175,
0.04269324988126755,
0.2676449418067932,
0.2538871169090271,
0.17627041041851044,
0.14618898928165436,
-0.16357773542404175,
-0.6525527834892273,
-0.13049057126045227,
0.5893422961235046,
-0.030824949964880943,
0.5027931928634644,
0.487877756357193,
-0.05327442288398743,
-0.10352297127246857,
-0.6463651061058044,
-0.13237270712852478,
-0.48592790961265564,
0.21869663894176483,
-0.134725421667099,
-0.8660050630569458,
0.2270234078168869,
0.06687001883983612,
-0.0006147742387838662,
0.17713698744773865,
0.6493117213249207,
-0.15972454845905304,
1.1892454624176025,
0.2550013065338135,
0.09165414422750473,
0.22861942648887634,
0.25271692872047424,
0.4187993109226227,
-0.6427759528160095,
-0.5802846550941467,
-0.7285021543502808,
-0.042310357093811035,
-0.7218238711357117,
-0.024749744683504105,
0.26370954513549805,
-0.446450799703598,
0.05269245058298111,
0.07300753891468048,
-0.29275721311569214,
-0.06405657529830933,
0.36683592200279236,
0.2346557080745697,
0.35619059205055237,
0.004902677144855261,
0.12449119985103607,
-0.06579084694385529,
-0.4170038104057312,
-0.5050334334373474,
0.960080623626709,
0.19237330555915833,
0.784935712814331,
0.3596187233924866,
0.36811548471450806,
0.46219730377197266,
0.35887303948402405,
-1.013016939163208,
0.7977794408798218,
0.09548009932041168,
-0.6154571175575256,
-0.1037290096282959,
-0.8687844276428223,
-0.7283015251159668,
-0.03887185454368591,
-0.4718993306159973,
-0.551298975944519,
0.0677947849035263,
0.11714918911457062,
-0.6598926782608032,
0.053281269967556,
-0.6303433775901794,
0.24781763553619385,
-0.1947745680809021,
-0.2956766188144684,
0.04112061858177185,
-0.5778604745864868,
0.6637893319129944,
-0.2839181125164032,
0.3552584946155548,
-0.46858635544776917,
0.37804925441741943,
0.6486618518829346,
-0.36673128604888916,
0.8767422437667847,
-0.16097144782543182,
-0.16829626262187958,
0.4476257860660553,
-0.032647378742694855,
0.4704558849334717,
0.09986856579780579,
0.0410473570227623,
-0.5300194025039673,
-0.2590571343898773,
-0.3360104560852051,
-0.7472864985466003,
0.5654687881469727,
-0.5722364187240601,
-0.9567658305168152,
-0.39114823937416077,
-0.26963305473327637,
-0.3822159767150879,
0.05692256614565849,
0.20888224244117737,
0.5069843530654907,
-0.41606253385543823,
-0.017408709973096848,
0.9651095271110535,
-0.09945179522037506,
0.20507831871509552,
0.6383267641067505,
-0.3246929347515106,
-0.2618557810783386,
0.934906005859375,
0.0054218159057199955,
0.338133841753006,
0.2041408270597458,
0.2629525065422058,
-0.6345121264457703,
-0.5052748918533325,
-0.5660368800163269,
-0.005347448401153088,
-0.5529254674911499,
-0.3522490859031677,
-0.7160173654556274,
-0.20067445933818817,
-0.7424014806747437,
0.5123094320297241,
-0.058118827641010284,
-0.5467480421066284,
-0.24771961569786072,
-0.4277189373970032,
0.4957539439201355,
0.9346321225166321,
-0.05471741408109665,
0.017798343673348427,
-0.6919050216674805,
0.4264880120754242,
0.6542973518371582,
0.2183355838060379,
-0.10159891843795776,
-0.5977636575698853,
-0.12390627712011337,
0.21382391452789307,
-0.3591483533382416,
-0.5179780721664429,
0.22412768006324768,
0.2624414563179016,
0.4003909230232239,
0.5062597990036011,
0.39645758271217346,
0.06331589818000793,
-0.14134708046913147,
0.7557573914527893,
0.226339191198349,
-0.5840375423431396,
0.7954834699630737,
-0.23420993983745575,
0.09455504268407822,
0.413297176361084,
0.25806665420532227,
-0.2557346820831299,
-0.23893603682518005,
-0.560889482498169,
-0.2578411102294922,
0.9210952520370483,
0.39999204874038696,
0.3937474489212036,
-0.26879313588142395,
0.19065995514392853,
-0.07693707942962646,
0.5110774636268616,
-0.5990151762962341,
-0.0908966213464737,
-0.44338831305503845,
-0.18367446959018707,
0.14561042189598083,
-0.18899226188659668,
-0.3606870472431183,
0.03076835535466671,
0.5917282104492188,
-0.30534982681274414,
0.2700577676296234,
0.3627720773220062,
0.04154236987233162,
-0.14810240268707275,
0.45711550116539,
0.5946898460388184,
0.32087984681129456,
-0.41076692938804626,
0.21059365570545197,
0.16913357377052307,
-0.33655846118927,
0.28241103887557983,
-0.11613141000270844,
-0.23722955584526062,
0.007820403203368187,
0.4593988358974457,
0.7988594174385071,
0.09498359262943268,
-0.6902050375938416,
0.7561600208282471,
-0.14034605026245117,
-0.01907884143292904,
0.057757668197155,
0.39828211069107056,
-0.1817670464515686,
0.13460266590118408,
0.027575785294175148,
0.23636242747306824,
0.32945162057876587,
-0.6370944380760193,
0.1837797611951828,
0.5065948963165283,
-0.2907209098339081,
-0.5117806196212769,
0.3862683176994324,
0.555346667766571,
-0.03608070686459541,
0.9605369567871094,
-0.38012680411338806,
-0.6756380200386047,
0.5130388140678406,
0.4737015664577484,
0.8017222285270691,
-0.2606136202812195,
0.4505990445613861,
0.6638393402099609,
-0.06586350500583649,
0.17661210894584656,
-0.07402783632278442,
-0.1752220243215561,
-1.0865520238876343,
-0.296829491853714,
-0.6865726709365845,
-0.43405088782310486,
0.1259901225566864,
-0.7654536366462708,
0.2514100968837738,
-0.8750897645950317,
-0.5304033756256104,
0.16664499044418335,
-0.1948106586933136,
-0.5979809761047363,
0.6245754361152649,
0.3031027317047119,
0.7292418479919434,
-0.8996814489364624,
0.6290437579154968,
0.3484218716621399,
-0.4943104386329651,
-0.5373899936676025,
-0.026714801788330078,
0.2513161301612854,
-0.8455227613449097,
0.922685980796814,
0.1444365233182907,
-0.30061542987823486,
-0.33208969235420227,
-1.0588842630386353,
-0.6192852258682251,
0.6082805395126343,
0.48660221695899963,
-0.27079153060913086,
-0.05458557605743408,
0.08744653314352036,
0.3059538006782532,
-0.35833606123924255,
0.22105033695697784,
0.569441020488739,
0.4795750677585602,
0.6054154634475708,
-0.8673359155654907,
-0.049308303743600845,
-0.28327518701553345,
-0.07729636877775192,
-0.13636067509651184,
-0.9689061045646667,
0.44128483533859253,
-0.22450609505176544,
-0.45983657240867615,
0.2572430670261383,
0.8066951632499695,
0.3683750331401825,
0.4084870219230652,
0.5543314218521118,
0.5680992603302002,
0.8494084477424622,
-0.2943074107170105,
0.9416301846504211,
0.0547022819519043,
0.36949944496154785,
0.8671057820320129,
-0.4793170094490051,
0.44229817390441895,
0.16123861074447632,
-0.35418787598609924,
0.5584356784820557,
0.6937128305435181,
-0.0676790177822113,
0.6637440919876099,
0.1669469177722931,
-0.5959415435791016,
-0.5576133728027344,
-0.6811271905899048,
-0.09896843135356903,
0.578311026096344,
0.2780422270298004,
-0.1423378884792328,
-0.09429900348186493,
-0.09637628495693207,
0.10389242321252823,
0.30122309923171997,
-0.11277945339679718,
0.9937667846679688,
-0.021327879279851913,
-0.6532344222068787,
0.4335194230079651,
-0.2392374724149704,
0.6202319860458374,
-0.29424625635147095,
-0.20777705311775208,
-0.3178027272224426,
-0.28698742389678955,
-0.5495345592498779,
-0.7980829477310181,
0.13297061622142792,
0.26867812871932983,
-0.5647917985916138,
0.14625538885593414,
0.6060025095939636,
-0.29412227869033813,
-0.5174252390861511,
0.03539185971021652,
0.3483772873878479,
0.13409963250160217,
0.34513190388679504,
-0.4607134461402893,
-0.042211323976516724,
0.44080907106399536,
-0.2187395542860031,
0.15347209572792053,
0.48779797554016113,
0.22569914162158966,
0.7273987531661987,
0.6316487193107605,
-0.1465657651424408,
-0.244544118642807,
-0.021192029118537903,
0.8888846635818481,
-0.47209328413009644,
-0.08075658231973648,
-0.5427422523498535,
0.3225576877593994,
-0.32444918155670166,
-0.014313263818621635,
0.7824604511260986,
0.6849635243415833,
0.49245747923851013,
-0.0256902277469635,
1.0954654216766357,
-0.0512285940349102,
0.8922528028488159,
-0.6655718088150024,
0.3030466139316559,
-0.16125726699829102,
0.18387705087661743,
-0.26523667573928833,
-0.6904456615447998,
0.1028294563293457,
0.6124607920646667,
-0.3281159996986389,
0.24063082039356232,
0.41410914063453674,
0.9099303483963013,
0.14742140471935272,
0.373898446559906,
0.383851557970047,
0.34152477979660034,
0.19585254788398743,
0.3780076503753662,
1.0605069398880005,
0.046411506831645966,
0.411923348903656,
0.026292573660612106,
-0.36998677253723145,
-0.1801004409790039,
-0.8475261926651001,
-0.9819570779800415,
-0.26497912406921387,
-0.4839157462120056,
-0.6774807572364807,
-0.2608463168144226,
0.9852423667907715,
0.6046198606491089,
-1.028199553489685,
0.033292245119810104,
0.17493471503257751,
0.06033807992935181,
0.4687558710575104,
-0.20930536091327667,
0.1723114252090454,
-0.31935176253318787,
-0.736742377281189,
0.45733100175857544,
0.1704881489276886,
0.32162976264953613,
-0.17783686518669128,
0.17873390018939972,
-0.1313020884990692,
0.34000492095947266,
0.5311618447303772,
0.19204826653003693,
-0.6776774525642395,
-0.6955116391181946,
0.03254152461886406,
-0.12331472337245941,
0.21484537422657013,
0.5942466259002686,
-0.7925706505775452,
0.6792399287223816,
0.31266459822654724,
0.4595831036567688,
0.3967253267765045,
0.32970109581947327,
0.47555646300315857,
-0.8428397178649902,
0.09471623599529266,
0.0362652912735939,
0.2044510543346405,
0.7435986399650574,
-0.6111910939216614,
0.39751142263412476,
0.45926347374916077,
-0.5720890760421753,
-0.5134987235069275,
0.47184330224990845,
-0.9626418948173523,
0.1588059365749359,
0.9663015604019165,
-0.3851204514503479,
-0.30584701895713806,
-0.20644140243530273,
-0.35556498169898987,
0.2674511969089508,
-0.6100401878356934,
0.8705722093582153,
0.9596632122993469,
-0.4407948851585388,
-0.03742661327123642,
-0.43292170763015747,
0.6183339357376099,
0.16863097250461578,
-0.7823808789253235,
0.21461978554725647,
0.6706965565681458,
0.25115862488746643,
0.4108645021915436,
0.5080248117446899,
0.2750566601753235,
0.11839134991168976,
-0.22797134518623352,
-0.15722408890724182,
0.24769139289855957,
-0.18462881445884705,
0.08656968176364899,
0.009636737406253815,
0.3977373242378235,
-0.16320490837097168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.11890v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.11890v1
|
Unraveling the Mechanics of Learning-Based Demonstration Selection for In-Context Learning
| 2024-06-14T03:34:02 | 2024-06-14T03:34:02 |
Hui Liu, Wenya Wang, Hao Sun, Chris Xing Tian, Chenqi Kong, Xin Dong, Haoliang Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated impressive in-context learning
(ICL) capabilities from few-shot demonstration exemplars. While recent
learning-based demonstration selection methods have proven beneficial to ICL by
choosing more useful exemplars, their underlying mechanisms are opaque,
hindering efforts to address limitations such as high training costs and poor
generalization across tasks. These methods generally assume the selection
process captures similarities between the exemplar and the target instance,
however, it remains unknown what kinds of similarities are captured and vital
to performing ICL. To dive into this question, we analyze the working
mechanisms of the learning-based demonstration selection methods and
empirically identify two important factors related to similarity measurement:
1) The ability to integrate different levels of task-agnostic text similarities
between the input of exemplars and test cases enhances generalization power
across different tasks. 2) Incorporating task-specific labels when measuring
the similarities significantly improves the performance on each specific task.
We validate these two findings through extensive quantitative and qualitative
analyses across ten datasets and various LLMs. Based on our findings, we
introduce two effective yet simplified exemplar selection methods catering to
task-agnostic and task-specific demands, eliminating the costly LLM inference
overhead.
|
[
-0.45785167813301086,
-0.5982789397239685,
0.6479788422584534,
-0.08781272917985916,
-0.36715441942214966,
-0.05291147902607918,
-0.29588231444358826,
-0.4818778932094574,
-0.26416030526161194,
0.10675828158855438,
-0.3340275287628174,
-0.29983219504356384,
-0.39497917890548706,
0.0381927452981472,
-0.443501353263855,
1.1078860759735107,
-0.26779207587242126,
-0.11767114698886871,
-0.7528842091560364,
-0.2623092234134674,
-0.1275465488433838,
-0.3698463439941406,
-0.48543232679367065,
-0.8160772919654846,
0.30294546484947205,
0.49021705985069275,
0.2545737624168396,
0.697714626789093,
0.2538240849971771,
0.190571129322052,
-0.047578539699316025,
-0.05458592623472214,
-0.35623252391815186,
0.263109415769577,
-0.15101560950279236,
-0.7087256908416748,
0.30367299914360046,
0.17125767469406128,
0.5899373888969421,
0.9636316299438477,
0.24928419291973114,
0.3757035732269287,
0.7036924362182617,
0.34261468052864075,
-0.7293766736984253,
0.1395844966173172,
-0.6687304973602295,
0.17410601675510406,
-0.07215560972690582,
-0.032372891902923584,
-0.3337783217430115,
-0.1641378104686737,
0.42543330788612366,
-0.531521201133728,
0.3194160461425781,
-0.03847438842058182,
0.6854448318481445,
0.013002539984881878,
-0.5984396934509277,
-0.3940635025501251,
-0.6275134682655334,
1.0815725326538086,
-0.5522527098655701,
0.2565878927707672,
0.1632978618144989,
0.4416865110397339,
0.09544999897480011,
-0.7901582717895508,
-0.28945663571357727,
-0.6324222087860107,
-0.19583122432231903,
-0.04873266443610191,
-0.03183317929506302,
-0.03643399477005005,
0.5798357725143433,
0.27485933899879456,
-0.5061171650886536,
0.3224867284297943,
-0.11394244432449341,
-0.2594117224216461,
0.11125259846448898,
-0.021613096818327904,
0.1885606199502945,
-0.02909800596535206,
-0.5744393467903137,
-0.4492211937904358,
-1.0493154525756836,
0.3231404423713684,
0.2604178488254547,
0.20873220264911652,
-0.17385928332805634,
0.2758795917034149,
-0.3293384313583374,
0.7185933589935303,
-0.03416355326771736,
-0.3366527557373047,
0.23935988545417786,
-0.17813345789909363,
-0.3615698218345642,
-0.14354193210601807,
0.7011160254478455,
0.04994075000286102,
-0.02190842293202877,
-0.1984574794769287,
-0.23762443661689758,
-0.049892935901880264,
-0.07892151176929474,
-0.7270868420600891,
0.0024132567923516035,
-0.013331209309399128,
-0.5283599495887756,
-0.15711702406406403,
0.02755965106189251,
-0.5465880036354065,
-0.17469650506973267,
-0.49639326333999634,
0.684010922908783,
-0.3528671860694885,
0.09754777699708939,
-0.43206068873405457,
-0.3384832441806793,
0.2988438904285431,
0.19590914249420166,
-0.797175407409668,
0.42480871081352234,
0.7107228636741638,
0.668378472328186,
-0.45604634284973145,
-0.4327305853366852,
-0.7970735430717468,
0.1457592397928238,
-0.43694883584976196,
0.5924360752105713,
-0.516295850276947,
-0.22759190201759338,
0.0807555615901947,
-0.27305078506469727,
-0.18794839084148407,
-0.8398680090904236,
0.18657194077968597,
-0.38394245505332947,
0.047095201909542084,
-0.42542725801467896,
-0.7334489822387695,
-0.29412394762039185,
0.2931119501590729,
-0.5381137728691101,
0.9987011551856995,
0.03407664969563484,
-0.5566205382347107,
0.9365313649177551,
-0.46076154708862305,
-0.4932170808315277,
-0.09136006236076355,
-0.6215966939926147,
-0.38537850975990295,
0.1982049196958542,
0.0170285627245903,
0.8697385787963867,
-0.2555276155471802,
-0.1159500926733017,
-0.3391672968864441,
-0.6531175971031189,
0.3903958797454834,
-0.3770729601383209,
0.5351290702819824,
0.17179088294506073,
-0.8625747561454773,
0.16051460802555084,
-0.5355873107910156,
-0.1543961763381958,
-0.04957037791609764,
-0.18644554913043976,
-0.47784844040870667,
0.08855762332677841,
-0.3302120566368103,
0.3473212420940399,
0.120738685131073,
-0.4657413065433502,
-0.08931375294923782,
-0.3750355839729309,
0.21410968899726868,
0.5071529150009155,
-0.00885507371276617,
0.45662954449653625,
-0.47463613748550415,
0.6516938209533691,
-0.12691672146320343,
0.11095850169658661,
-0.13600507378578186,
-0.11700266599655151,
-0.4794750213623047,
-0.25545355677604675,
0.04404982924461365,
0.09948824346065521,
-0.6632475256919861,
-0.20590895414352417,
-0.2613600194454193,
-0.44945958256721497,
-0.14227771759033203,
0.34802812337875366,
0.6903319358825684,
0.5534973740577698,
0.19106781482696533,
-0.06429290771484375,
-0.17496785521507263,
-1.0549793243408203,
-0.2697363495826721,
-0.28258147835731506,
0.05020562931895256,
0.16926640272140503,
0.4737362563610077,
0.3591541647911072,
0.8457925915718079,
-0.2238771766424179,
-0.3193177282810211,
-0.45122024416923523,
0.1010102778673172,
0.1687394082546234,
0.11105508357286453,
0.9348078966140747,
-0.7768359780311584,
-0.8538280129432678,
0.39525118470191956,
-0.7215702533721924,
-0.11457418650388718,
-0.2831648290157318,
0.3911159336566925,
0.15497273206710815,
0.8643658757209778,
-0.23487399518489838,
0.5128129124641418,
0.4435161054134369,
0.04773184284567833,
0.6438656449317932,
-0.2756158411502838,
0.21710944175720215,
-0.6719706654548645,
-0.04300311207771301,
-0.017644483596086502,
-0.22857238352298737,
-0.4213534891605377,
0.3761831223964691,
0.3269535005092621,
0.20794953405857086,
-0.6933829188346863,
0.6810209155082703,
-0.6577993631362915,
-0.32533150911331177,
-0.4654844105243683,
0.2247999757528305,
-0.15891174972057343,
0.4953320026397705,
-0.1302957385778427,
0.9194647669792175,
0.8180436491966248,
-0.7627153396606445,
0.010346993803977966,
0.06790602207183838,
-0.5803149342536926,
0.5041863322257996,
-0.43158620595932007,
0.0018301785457879305,
0.1277996301651001,
0.1912713199853897,
-1.0593712329864502,
-0.012209768407046795,
0.11851911246776581,
-0.09778551757335663,
0.29270678758621216,
-0.08436791598796844,
-0.5220130085945129,
-0.06061740592122078,
-0.38997364044189453,
0.33164623379707336,
0.6879798769950867,
-0.8087466955184937,
0.4182084798812866,
-0.10690002888441086,
-0.08196480572223663,
-0.6534789204597473,
-0.7017619609832764,
-0.07206977903842926,
-0.4903537333011627,
-0.04897715523838997,
0.4254993200302124,
-0.15664272010326385,
-0.4011625647544861,
-0.3111627697944641,
-0.2755309045314789,
0.19924123585224152,
0.2641892433166504,
0.6087687015533447,
-0.10634448379278183,
-0.18012703955173492,
0.22647416591644287,
0.46623530983924866,
0.05815409868955612,
0.09950179606676102,
-0.09116201847791672,
0.25203973054885864,
0.01198799628764391,
-0.9375866651535034,
-0.39048486948013306,
0.359346866607666,
0.533883273601532,
-0.06490789353847504,
0.4838140308856964,
0.3391721844673157,
-0.04115895554423332,
-0.5326528549194336,
-0.5193132162094116,
-0.3134196996688843,
-0.4055800437927246,
0.4993464946746826,
-0.5244054794311523,
-0.8152729868888855,
0.29086026549339294,
-0.1951621025800705,
0.22938227653503418,
0.03795798495411873,
0.4055343568325043,
-0.004155562724918127,
0.8400967121124268,
0.4770992398262024,
-0.006182181183248758,
0.5589437484741211,
-0.1835460364818573,
-0.02028609998524189,
-0.8350202441215515,
-0.31525731086730957,
-0.49835243821144104,
-0.5126345753669739,
-0.1399075835943222,
-0.369941383600235,
0.43335723876953125,
0.04870249703526497,
-0.18663054704666138,
0.3044637441635132,
-0.21048736572265625,
0.5001128315925598,
0.7411355972290039,
0.13722380995750427,
0.264769971370697,
0.18947100639343262,
-0.5111859440803528,
-0.16785436868667603,
-0.3797149062156677,
-0.5936368703842163,
1.1643733978271484,
0.13634927570819855,
0.4153114855289459,
0.0958806723356247,
0.7325706481933594,
0.028018392622470856,
0.3426578938961029,
-0.642892062664032,
0.8160020709037781,
-0.18803967535495758,
-0.26239779591560364,
-0.313156396150589,
-0.043356962502002716,
-0.9336619973182678,
0.4078267812728882,
-0.07766036689281464,
-0.8308545351028442,
0.05141808092594147,
0.19671516120433807,
-0.1305098682641983,
0.3080357015132904,
-0.5408706665039062,
0.7125944495201111,
-0.1482354700565338,
-0.2178698629140854,
-0.4271039068698883,
-0.6273704767227173,
-0.09998466819524765,
-0.2327314168214798,
0.07144244015216827,
0.16281501948833466,
-0.11885315924882889,
0.623062252998352,
-0.21859312057495117,
0.9769607782363892,
-0.22465181350708008,
-0.049111008644104004,
0.28325095772743225,
0.2724817097187042,
0.40120258927345276,
-0.36202898621559143,
-0.158823162317276,
-0.15948733687400818,
-0.13773512840270996,
-0.2590111196041107,
-0.8201408386230469,
0.7883546948432922,
-0.6217784285545349,
-0.680282711982727,
0.008564046584069729,
-0.42124176025390625,
-0.4657239615917206,
-0.17953141033649445,
0.4007481038570404,
0.6784510612487793,
-0.1760244220495224,
0.5644493103027344,
0.6885781288146973,
-0.13651005923748016,
0.6376846432685852,
0.3286634683609009,
-0.16839896142482758,
0.11648503690958023,
0.8637974858283997,
0.050528667867183685,
0.7849068641662598,
0.725351095199585,
0.2756863236427307,
-0.22450296580791473,
-0.875555694103241,
-0.14673565328121185,
0.049073442816734314,
-0.9822189211845398,
-0.01509987935423851,
-0.6919957995414734,
0.0735340416431427,
-0.1575639545917511,
-0.2831593155860901,
0.08309520035982132,
-0.25090205669403076,
-0.31413811445236206,
-0.4569321274757385,
-0.09984373301267624,
0.5999455451965332,
-0.1189379021525383,
0.22768667340278625,
-0.18911020457744598,
0.3549538254737854,
0.7973136901855469,
-0.1335591971874237,
0.23283708095550537,
-0.6766700744628906,
-0.13005977869033813,
-0.016912763938307762,
-0.4119579792022705,
-0.7592172026634216,
0.044345416128635406,
0.4068605601787567,
0.8931320309638977,
0.646098256111145,
0.011724566109478474,
0.5884828567504883,
-0.31395408511161804,
0.7873050570487976,
0.1512044221162796,
-0.8692108988761902,
0.6369950771331787,
-0.05810617655515671,
0.018401166424155235,
0.4176951050758362,
0.3665015697479248,
-0.18410073220729828,
-0.6010711789131165,
-0.38170671463012695,
-0.7286326885223389,
0.48202601075172424,
0.09066339582204819,
0.1912239044904709,
-0.03758866339921951,
0.23711510002613068,
0.6387168765068054,
0.08287882804870605,
-0.828037679195404,
-0.443478524684906,
0.05447012186050415,
-0.0750526487827301,
-0.10046017169952393,
-0.021022653207182884,
-0.15372738242149353,
-0.060220759361982346,
0.5714765191078186,
-0.4840333163738251,
0.05296258628368378,
0.12611763179302216,
-0.42251136898994446,
0.07950016111135483,
0.4427805244922638,
0.6119905114173889,
0.7117307186126709,
0.07948551326990128,
0.09803812950849533,
0.41026830673217773,
-0.18225841224193573,
0.2801568806171417,
0.03681345656514168,
-0.12763334810733795,
-0.012758217751979828,
0.5679597854614258,
1.0025489330291748,
0.44389745593070984,
-0.8545601963996887,
0.8355519771575928,
0.2664441168308258,
-0.1912761777639389,
-0.21723376214504242,
0.4130307734012604,
-0.2837201654911041,
0.5202887654304504,
0.6603108644485474,
-0.21419024467468262,
0.23461154103279114,
-0.6462207436561584,
0.25004586577415466,
0.6729406714439392,
-0.7118790149688721,
-0.27435943484306335,
0.5111350417137146,
-0.1667994111776352,
-0.11097211390733719,
0.2465507984161377,
-0.24217654764652252,
-0.31189242005348206,
0.8533568978309631,
0.664740264415741,
0.6575867533683777,
-0.002319124760106206,
0.4566996097564697,
0.10035045444965363,
0.07009854167699814,
-0.11692201346158981,
-0.13729017972946167,
-0.27816495299339294,
-0.4659440815448761,
-0.5208896398544312,
-0.3571919798851013,
-0.5240769982337952,
0.16137245297431946,
-0.980802595615387,
0.27198606729507446,
-0.24440692365169525,
0.1647634506225586,
-0.3203985095024109,
0.042187780141830444,
-0.8246030211448669,
0.3010784387588501,
0.3449951708316803,
0.9845795631408691,
-1.0575296878814697,
0.645025908946991,
0.9283581376075745,
-0.07744920998811722,
-0.9279673099517822,
0.21570144593715668,
0.13221223652362823,
-0.7135251760482788,
0.8784778118133545,
0.24935728311538696,
0.16215522587299347,
-0.21766631305217743,
-0.5669991374015808,
-0.5176261067390442,
1.309930443763733,
0.6566267013549805,
-0.478728324174881,
0.006037421058863401,
0.20990276336669922,
0.5395323634147644,
-0.6165570616722107,
0.4117763638496399,
0.28727078437805176,
0.06725253164768219,
0.04769238829612732,
-1.0346136093139648,
0.13686227798461914,
0.2770068049430847,
-0.07750578969717026,
0.07380469143390656,
-0.5487373471260071,
0.5842270851135254,
-0.288479208946228,
-0.048797376453876495,
0.17992420494556427,
0.7258570790290833,
0.5916353464126587,
0.5052511692047119,
0.6753182411193848,
0.232152059674263,
0.582506000995636,
0.02582826465368271,
1.1129266023635864,
0.04830045998096466,
0.1985359936952591,
1.0632531642913818,
-0.44578877091407776,
0.8987937569618225,
0.7298374772071838,
-0.23942184448242188,
0.7698853611946106,
0.4610808193683624,
0.1372755616903305,
0.5820966958999634,
0.18720193207263947,
-0.3038907051086426,
-0.3132990300655365,
-0.16487954556941986,
-0.20882298052310944,
0.3791652023792267,
0.26161500811576843,
-0.4850479066371918,
-0.3246323764324188,
0.4049006998538971,
-0.19474799931049347,
0.15819938480854034,
-0.25235581398010254,
0.797715961933136,
0.15623414516448975,
-0.7242960333824158,
0.29892265796661377,
-0.5823939442634583,
0.6026454567909241,
-0.8005493879318237,
-0.07367318868637085,
-0.09126549959182739,
-0.0884406790137291,
0.08711060881614685,
-0.7740009427070618,
0.04676622152328491,
-0.3318667411804199,
-0.09303688257932663,
-0.28593143820762634,
0.6452429890632629,
-0.2910183370113373,
0.1437760889530182,
0.5521854758262634,
0.5425435900688171,
0.15830858051776886,
-0.25537967681884766,
-0.516829788684845,
0.023790637031197548,
0.12191005796194077,
-0.1607682704925537,
0.8961254954338074,
0.40354788303375244,
-0.19803713262081146,
0.8278895020484924,
0.43643829226493835,
0.07302920520305634,
-0.08714774250984192,
0.03690085932612419,
0.657260537147522,
-0.417974591255188,
-0.4143385887145996,
-0.806553840637207,
0.3803376853466034,
-0.13735081255435944,
-0.2212083786725998,
0.5928105711936951,
0.5446068048477173,
1.0572338104248047,
-0.18352337181568146,
0.9133778810501099,
0.1156950294971466,
0.6611053347587585,
-0.5658861994743347,
0.518186092376709,
-0.7180841565132141,
0.17160043120384216,
-0.2778455317020416,
-1.0194846391677856,
-0.08652310818433762,
0.35663527250289917,
-0.2979956865310669,
-0.0027756253257393837,
0.9093820452690125,
0.5965794324874878,
-0.287949800491333,
-0.24356119334697723,
0.6667353510856628,
-0.012793098576366901,
0.2649540901184082,
0.6274542808532715,
0.9148158431053162,
-0.14481130242347717,
0.8484238982200623,
-0.38914546370506287,
-0.2821691930294037,
-0.23561270534992218,
-1.0753666162490845,
-1.1452735662460327,
-0.7517032623291016,
-0.7103564739227295,
0.12663163244724274,
-0.006350161507725716,
0.9973452091217041,
0.788676917552948,
-0.7006440758705139,
-0.36181172728538513,
0.14721906185150146,
-0.024814285337924957,
-0.663849413394928,
-0.20615775883197784,
0.41629648208618164,
-0.33069145679473877,
-0.7683454155921936,
0.42026180028915405,
0.21794848144054413,
0.12694431841373444,
0.12302694469690323,
-0.009314809925854206,
0.2039337009191513,
-0.22337593138217926,
0.5028670430183411,
0.4449579417705536,
-0.9348837733268738,
-0.32452476024627686,
-0.29001086950302124,
-0.06423870474100113,
-0.09919419139623642,
0.9453721046447754,
-1.0539984703063965,
0.24256101250648499,
0.38935473561286926,
0.782586932182312,
0.38920947909355164,
-0.32625219225883484,
0.44972971081733704,
-0.9428498148918152,
0.12384229153394699,
-0.05358856916427612,
0.4796369969844818,
0.23396070301532745,
-0.05205731466412544,
0.38363996148109436,
-0.03375125303864479,
-0.5078101754188538,
-0.8310102224349976,
0.39872273802757263,
-0.8032470941543579,
-0.35095179080963135,
1.2637027502059937,
-0.35624757409095764,
0.07339849323034286,
-0.20326022803783417,
-0.09473595768213272,
0.10709306597709656,
-0.05960046872496605,
0.5038598775863647,
0.522580623626709,
-0.2616415023803711,
-0.11113326251506805,
-0.5330992341041565,
0.44210460782051086,
0.5485929250717163,
-0.5612183809280396,
-0.1367454081773758,
0.24459481239318848,
0.4754216969013214,
0.07714929431676865,
0.14052017033100128,
0.09825233370065689,
0.28895390033721924,
-0.38648298382759094,
-0.18211311101913452,
-0.010219995863735676,
-0.16723106801509857,
-0.3760710060596466,
0.5369008183479309,
0.20682817697525024,
-0.14077305793762207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09688v1
|
FreeCtrl: Constructing Control Centers with Feedforward Layers for Learning-Free Controllable Text Generation
| 2024-06-14T03:18:28 | 2024-06-14T03:18:28 |
Zijian Feng, Hanzhang Zhou, Zixiao Zhu, Kezhi Mao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Controllable text generation (CTG) seeks to craft texts adhering to specific
attributes, traditionally employing learning-based techniques such as training,
fine-tuning, or prefix-tuning with attribute-specific datasets. These
approaches, while effective, demand extensive computational and data resources.
In contrast, some proposed learning-free alternatives circumvent learning but
often yield inferior results, exemplifying the fundamental machine learning
trade-off between computational expense and model efficacy. To overcome these
limitations, we propose FreeCtrl, a learning-free approach that dynamically
adjusts the weights of selected feedforward neural network (FFN) vectors to
steer the outputs of large language models (LLMs). FreeCtrl hinges on the
principle that the weights of different FFN vectors influence the likelihood of
different tokens appearing in the output. By identifying and adaptively
adjusting the weights of attribute-related FFN vectors, FreeCtrl can control
the output likelihood of attribute keywords in the generated content. Extensive
experiments on single- and multi-attribute control reveal that the
learning-free FreeCtrl outperforms other learning-free and learning-based
methods, successfully resolving the dilemma between learning costs and model
performance.
|
[
-0.031023001298308372,
-0.6116982102394104,
0.1076442077755928,
0.1700829416513443,
-0.27494919300079346,
0.2023533582687378,
-0.5607388019561768,
-0.25767916440963745,
-0.09018438309431076,
0.5648583769798279,
-0.7467385530471802,
-0.45077231526374817,
-0.4261142611503601,
-0.20259574055671692,
-0.33370813727378845,
1.4043241739273071,
-0.0642690658569336,
-0.18818067014217377,
-0.11942026764154434,
-0.07424426078796387,
-0.32819288969039917,
-0.25010451674461365,
-1.043971300125122,
-0.45501643419265747,
0.9750185012817383,
0.462542861700058,
0.8253382444381714,
0.8432367444038391,
0.24123993515968323,
0.20599515736103058,
-0.033510174602270126,
0.3022855818271637,
-0.535042405128479,
0.23078308999538422,
-0.17498978972434998,
-0.31146764755249023,
-0.22652173042297363,
0.22971560060977936,
0.5540369749069214,
0.36330947279930115,
0.05657130852341652,
-0.2980186939239502,
0.4114677309989929,
0.709372878074646,
-0.5180374383926392,
-0.018287109211087227,
-0.8512336611747742,
0.13454538583755493,
-0.045482538640499115,
-0.1301189512014389,
-0.7257640361785889,
-0.47578367590904236,
0.02439447119832039,
-0.6838783621788025,
0.5204356908798218,
-0.10901215672492981,
0.8017562627792358,
0.3060320317745209,
-0.4583437740802765,
-0.44212135672569275,
-0.6873207092285156,
1.045178771018982,
-0.38517534732818604,
0.5947473645210266,
0.3034239411354065,
0.21608076989650726,
-0.15368889272212982,
-0.5956493020057678,
-0.3042655885219574,
-0.3319740295410156,
-0.06638982892036438,
0.19544821977615356,
-0.25658878684043884,
0.16073131561279297,
-0.19484585523605347,
0.08997537940740585,
-0.45855122804641724,
0.2721920609474182,
-0.2144792228937149,
-0.1969226598739624,
0.6239693760871887,
-0.12984155118465424,
0.1335660070180893,
-0.09596055001020432,
-0.3942983150482178,
-0.35306376218795776,
-0.931029200553894,
0.2590865194797516,
0.34532490372657776,
0.7499025464057922,
-0.09177930653095245,
0.40573006868362427,
-0.038134973496198654,
0.40414300560951233,
0.42582857608795166,
0.12170320004224777,
-0.1075897067785263,
0.010851369239389896,
-0.44895198941230774,
0.27040573954582214,
0.9732747077941895,
0.1470009833574295,
0.1746588796377182,
-0.46512100100517273,
-0.1332555115222931,
-0.38935190439224243,
0.5156786441802979,
-0.7906284332275391,
-0.34071627259254456,
0.27534306049346924,
-0.41688382625579834,
-0.977683424949646,
-0.19324274361133575,
-0.5259829759597778,
-0.3072536587715149,
-0.3506160378456116,
0.3970303535461426,
-0.60316401720047,
-0.24678844213485718,
-0.5346457362174988,
0.031186958774924278,
0.23754142224788666,
0.34837648272514343,
-0.8342397809028625,
-0.16312873363494873,
0.3389717638492584,
0.7691621780395508,
-0.4819587171077728,
-0.04847682639956474,
-0.5876988768577576,
0.21279487013816833,
-0.8272737264633179,
0.6304718255996704,
-0.40181785821914673,
-0.5047979950904846,
-0.10713610798120499,
-0.06068987771868706,
-0.057575345039367676,
-0.4000897705554962,
0.38123178482055664,
-0.6166189312934875,
0.27002042531967163,
-0.07623646408319473,
-0.38298022747039795,
-0.13773459196090698,
-0.08050208538770676,
-0.7961506843566895,
0.896096408367157,
0.29919928312301636,
-0.873143196105957,
0.32527783513069153,
-0.4108934998512268,
-0.4769875407218933,
0.1076040044426918,
-0.10958293825387955,
-0.5651058554649353,
0.2997928559780121,
0.03756595402956009,
0.5490167737007141,
-0.2077360600233078,
0.34605172276496887,
0.20195318758487701,
0.12933559715747833,
0.425425261259079,
-0.4728228449821472,
0.7237972617149353,
0.424410879611969,
-0.4142583906650543,
0.667043149471283,
-1.001415491104126,
0.3116410970687866,
-0.11916203796863556,
-0.4579419791698456,
-0.4298868179321289,
0.32690659165382385,
-0.025759724900126457,
0.1992572396993637,
-0.026500876992940903,
-0.2965731620788574,
0.05628008395433426,
-0.30158838629722595,
0.24001248180866241,
0.8538615703582764,
-0.23061855137348175,
0.8318598866462708,
-0.4077407717704773,
0.4138808250427246,
0.1091683879494667,
-0.02485605515539646,
0.14692415297031403,
-0.05276431143283844,
-0.9207059144973755,
-0.2646161913871765,
0.231644868850708,
0.5235178470611572,
-1.2816802263259888,
0.06300386786460876,
0.025554081425070763,
-0.6976810097694397,
-0.4593859910964966,
0.20867398381233215,
0.6256567239761353,
0.6063761115074158,
0.49261924624443054,
0.12515126168727875,
-0.2560252249240875,
-0.7450113296508789,
-0.33497491478919983,
0.19106927514076233,
-0.2127624899148941,
0.23292838037014008,
0.12472722679376602,
0.16613678634166718,
0.7994754314422607,
-0.400348424911499,
-0.44410476088523865,
-0.5064858198165894,
0.3073497712612152,
-0.07505492866039276,
0.7401857972145081,
0.5045419335365295,
-0.6259667873382568,
-0.3679654598236084,
0.23471368849277496,
-0.4444239139556885,
-0.18173696100711823,
-0.5133703351020813,
-0.22985665500164032,
0.3787223696708679,
0.36886104941368103,
-0.26033255457878113,
0.3210514187812805,
0.6446235775947571,
-0.299104779958725,
0.5540595650672913,
-0.4234272539615631,
-0.1390141397714615,
-0.9007789492607117,
-0.03822774067521095,
-0.08136460185050964,
-0.08231434971094131,
-0.8332924842834473,
0.18499930202960968,
0.40750962495803833,
0.021045871078968048,
-0.6888312697410583,
0.5891568064689636,
-0.3541002571582794,
0.5370721817016602,
-0.4062485098838806,
0.10632125288248062,
-0.13386286795139313,
0.7240347862243652,
0.055357832461595535,
0.8164755702018738,
0.04526058956980705,
-0.8028146624565125,
0.22123518586158752,
0.049120254814624786,
-0.24622882902622223,
0.39171189069747925,
-0.448392778635025,
0.09843842685222626,
-0.3234730362892151,
-0.06683653593063354,
-0.7741014957427979,
-0.15279334783554077,
0.22540347278118134,
-0.46006911993026733,
0.33486098051071167,
0.344681054353714,
0.03641527518630028,
-0.280603289604187,
-0.24423867464065552,
0.08803525567054749,
0.2616455554962158,
-0.519716739654541,
0.6326310038566589,
-0.20264600217342377,
-0.11715778708457947,
-0.6097363829612732,
-1.0023106336593628,
-0.2079811990261078,
0.11380074173212051,
-0.16426625847816467,
0.4094281494617462,
-0.1328331083059311,
0.022580962628126144,
0.08465795964002609,
0.21373909711837769,
-0.2117326855659485,
0.1909019500017166,
0.15021377801895142,
0.0441599003970623,
-0.05633627995848656,
0.2769310474395752,
0.7108569145202637,
-0.07218616455793381,
-0.31223633885383606,
-0.6382786631584167,
0.20036166906356812,
0.2995195984840393,
0.049649447202682495,
-0.2991968095302582,
0.472249835729599,
0.2854095697402954,
-0.4487064778804779,
0.7546206116676331,
0.3111715018749237,
-0.13482119143009186,
-0.9042770266532898,
-0.09181854128837585,
0.185468852519989,
-0.5073897838592529,
0.24779187142848969,
-0.17793190479278564,
-1.2729566097259521,
0.3633650243282318,
0.33124223351478577,
0.3790481984615326,
0.48236313462257385,
0.5729905962944031,
0.05913461372256279,
0.8663520812988281,
0.8887776732444763,
0.32046985626220703,
0.4883101284503937,
-0.02481689304113388,
0.12510287761688232,
-0.44819971919059753,
-0.3358660340309143,
-0.6488018035888672,
-0.4811844527721405,
-0.8443747758865356,
-0.4921531677246094,
0.0938466489315033,
0.24804389476776123,
-0.5036910176277161,
0.25221988558769226,
-0.8766759037971497,
0.5519140362739563,
0.7491590976715088,
0.1239689365029335,
0.22914041578769684,
0.009183339774608612,
-0.579162061214447,
-0.1632041335105896,
-0.7147941589355469,
-0.1384904831647873,
0.8519476056098938,
-0.046717267483472824,
0.9094510674476624,
-0.07676348835229874,
0.3908381164073944,
0.2433202564716339,
0.6102118492126465,
-0.8101140260696411,
0.3473581373691559,
-0.6530028581619263,
-0.26864710450172424,
-0.10815276205539703,
-0.5510187149047852,
-0.8031557202339172,
0.1466100513935089,
-0.3492295444011688,
-0.4702720046043396,
0.07369053363800049,
0.45120757818222046,
-0.2596253752708435,
0.7083150148391724,
-0.3536822199821472,
0.37703877687454224,
-0.6631223559379578,
-0.5487058758735657,
-0.06239335611462593,
-0.46164366602897644,
0.15691258013248444,
-0.22269169986248016,
0.06066806614398956,
0.15820476412773132,
-0.05279037356376648,
0.6192688345909119,
-0.18409258127212524,
0.8431749939918518,
-0.24720130860805511,
-0.4013844132423401,
0.47124016284942627,
0.49527502059936523,
0.404961496591568,
-0.4398299753665924,
-0.17540894448757172,
-0.16837145388126373,
-0.3810332417488098,
-0.07546403259038925,
-0.29651540517807007,
0.877368688583374,
-0.9146522283554077,
-0.27067407965660095,
-0.055949438363313675,
-0.8087183237075806,
-0.08007869869470596,
0.5428958535194397,
0.38282835483551025,
0.3802095949649811,
-0.21845687925815582,
0.5440154671669006,
0.7686861753463745,
-0.7159481048583984,
0.6639556288719177,
0.042709484696388245,
-0.2456522285938263,
-1.0169322490692139,
1.097376823425293,
0.20529712736606598,
0.3419150710105896,
0.8787102103233337,
0.4123929440975189,
-0.2018263041973114,
-0.39255279302597046,
-0.471201092004776,
-0.028866423293948174,
-0.3689887225627899,
-0.578184187412262,
-0.53773033618927,
-0.5179086327552795,
-0.3733096718788147,
-0.5712237358093262,
-0.30851954221725464,
-0.6245418787002563,
-0.6373573541641235,
-0.23652803897857666,
0.40538960695266724,
0.6627854704856873,
-0.014101366512477398,
0.9016894698143005,
-0.7194910645484924,
0.026435833424329758,
0.18582627177238464,
0.5197284817695618,
0.3457888066768646,
-0.02183750458061695,
-0.3683899939060211,
0.1987651139497757,
-0.7638024687767029,
-0.703220784664154,
0.6389389038085938,
0.3447857201099396,
0.313877671957016,
0.6184178590774536,
0.12907271087169647,
0.16252301633358002,
-0.5779260396957397,
0.8641126155853271,
0.4370555281639099,
-0.8903055191040039,
0.5224384665489197,
-0.564287543296814,
0.45573750138282776,
0.26966339349746704,
0.4548055827617645,
-0.5767631530761719,
-0.6205836534500122,
-0.4649307131767273,
-0.7731107473373413,
0.7051493525505066,
0.13286367058753967,
0.0924590528011322,
0.022667165845632553,
0.41358232498168945,
0.2332518845796585,
0.42027828097343445,
-0.7023110389709473,
0.14945855736732483,
-0.650032103061676,
-0.5478365421295166,
0.15023334324359894,
-0.05317426100373268,
0.15594571828842163,
0.013408300466835499,
0.7542880177497864,
-0.35567840933799744,
0.3119654655456543,
0.21976831555366516,
-0.00763052050024271,
-0.15521785616874695,
0.43968334794044495,
0.7727729082107544,
0.23526333272457123,
0.07179450988769531,
0.18107379972934723,
-0.0203437227755785,
-0.2935495376586914,
0.10129755735397339,
-0.20337139070034027,
-0.6357523202896118,
-0.2396422028541565,
0.16671721637248993,
1.05049729347229,
0.20584379136562347,
-0.32619211077690125,
0.502332866191864,
0.08342257142066956,
-0.7929772138595581,
0.017841974273324013,
0.21108566224575043,
-0.004896786063909531,
0.2256956547498703,
0.41560277342796326,
-0.039505839347839355,
-0.5840765237808228,
0.23456361889839172,
0.3734498620033264,
0.5518218278884888,
-0.9103613495826721,
-0.25253826379776,
1.1976361274719238,
0.31398025155067444,
-0.21237969398498535,
0.7506221532821655,
0.23074279725551605,
-0.3185981810092926,
0.5069964528083801,
0.6625086665153503,
1.1662122011184692,
-0.3574455976486206,
0.4788951277732849,
0.2933749258518219,
0.4136669337749481,
0.27254563570022583,
0.19247326254844666,
-0.11690174043178558,
-0.7521902322769165,
-0.5478649735450745,
-0.7084792256355286,
-0.2769157290458679,
0.2167031168937683,
-0.36822766065597534,
0.18521544337272644,
-0.9284372329711914,
0.07517676800489426,
-0.37004613876342773,
-0.05614188686013222,
-0.41379621624946594,
0.47172993421554565,
-0.1344003677368164,
1.216193675994873,
-0.49390825629234314,
0.9865211248397827,
0.37026700377464294,
-0.3405536711215973,
-1.1413711309432983,
-0.37119022011756897,
0.05422262102365494,
-0.3979819416999817,
0.6722777485847473,
0.07671914249658585,
-0.2680402100086212,
0.06072873994708061,
-0.9441929459571838,
-0.6086429357528687,
1.1511560678482056,
0.06846002489328384,
-0.4569682776927948,
-0.49026983976364136,
0.23342680931091309,
0.4044610559940338,
-0.34622320532798767,
0.015205534175038338,
-0.05317698419094086,
0.24751636385917664,
0.24469906091690063,
-0.5545380711555481,
-0.04291704669594765,
0.12385972589254379,
0.14227348566055298,
0.3554689288139343,
-0.8324287533760071,
0.8971222639083862,
-0.16544225811958313,
-0.2192312777042389,
0.17022691667079926,
1.0431578159332275,
-0.03646455332636833,
-0.08526880294084549,
0.388403058052063,
0.4258388876914978,
0.774409294128418,
-0.23273013532161713,
0.8019546270370483,
-0.16258782148361206,
0.20080620050430298,
1.1402465105056763,
-0.004807454999536276,
0.6950069069862366,
0.30396363139152527,
0.36009013652801514,
0.462277352809906,
0.3057589828968048,
0.03584916889667511,
0.7426117658615112,
0.21527715027332306,
-0.38424819707870483,
-0.0888461172580719,
-0.04108363389968872,
0.026929620653390884,
0.41543376445770264,
0.17538738250732422,
-0.4913346469402313,
-0.36449071764945984,
0.2700088918209076,
0.34141814708709717,
0.12648905813694,
-0.5038310885429382,
0.746944010257721,
-0.11976280063390732,
-0.6142361164093018,
0.4091518223285675,
0.01815800368785858,
0.8704604506492615,
-1.0652786493301392,
0.1882023960351944,
-0.2937934994697571,
0.5163813233375549,
-0.1424022614955902,
-0.5110742449760437,
0.39640572667121887,
0.1915557086467743,
-0.26499900221824646,
-0.6801198720932007,
0.9254601001739502,
-0.8272603154182434,
-0.5723823308944702,
0.2559279501438141,
0.4749492406845093,
-0.33015114068984985,
0.18679092824459076,
-0.49555185437202454,
-0.26816800236701965,
0.3355712294578552,
-0.3073953092098236,
0.3110162913799286,
0.5286113023757935,
-0.41694995760917664,
0.522501528263092,
0.7174386382102966,
0.48477989435195923,
0.08963014930486679,
-0.28071025013923645,
0.8142344355583191,
-0.5776846408843994,
-0.45377326011657715,
-0.5297479033470154,
0.5413228869438171,
0.22124163806438446,
-0.17556461691856384,
0.3900602161884308,
0.32807061076164246,
1.1218163967132568,
-0.0423596054315567,
0.9015525579452515,
-0.16082262992858887,
0.6233819723129272,
-0.4564912021160126,
1.4522523880004883,
-0.7573502063751221,
-0.4441204071044922,
-0.2853420078754425,
-0.5216582417488098,
-0.641234815120697,
0.5492759346961975,
0.06506752967834473,
-0.22028560936450958,
0.5941601991653442,
0.8122381567955017,
0.07426293939352036,
0.055220283567905426,
0.3053622543811798,
0.12049520760774612,
0.6987672448158264,
0.48091036081314087,
0.6286540627479553,
-0.16348527371883392,
0.675265908241272,
-0.44272884726524353,
-0.39762547612190247,
0.34239381551742554,
-1.434069275856018,
-0.718754231929779,
-0.5137653350830078,
-0.051568593829870224,
-0.39431700110435486,
0.0038500826340168715,
1.0543043613433838,
0.4508064091205597,
-0.9414637088775635,
-0.2909146547317505,
-0.10082564502954483,
0.2685680091381073,
-0.5546188354492188,
-0.2379254251718521,
0.5599578619003296,
-0.4450351297855377,
-0.6623114943504333,
0.2886509895324707,
-0.0496675968170166,
0.19853608310222626,
0.07695024460554123,
-0.08834780752658844,
-0.10498622804880142,
0.14967410266399384,
0.7208790183067322,
0.15900294482707977,
-0.4235196113586426,
-0.36986085772514343,
0.10312303155660629,
-0.1693524569272995,
-0.008886356838047504,
1.2686443328857422,
-0.8350936770439148,
0.19025127589702606,
0.512694776058197,
0.9296534061431885,
-0.034744203090667725,
-0.20798137784004211,
0.5324917435646057,
-1.0755850076675415,
0.14594049751758575,
0.00041847352986223996,
-0.30999788641929626,
0.3334544897079468,
-0.47842633724212646,
0.08961553871631622,
0.016865741461515427,
-0.6361533403396606,
-0.2897352874279022,
0.22164347767829895,
-0.8998910784721375,
-0.4879487156867981,
0.876849353313446,
0.141498401761055,
-0.32794272899627686,
0.4168614447116852,
-0.25550997257232666,
0.6547020673751831,
-0.4168729782104492,
0.33484962582588196,
0.3953772485256195,
-0.27932289242744446,
-0.3777042031288147,
-0.3636929392814636,
0.8752235174179077,
0.18452326953411102,
-0.6159795522689819,
0.38529738783836365,
0.7068143486976624,
0.1698143184185028,
-0.05275822430849075,
0.4801112115383148,
-0.10969918221235275,
-0.11320662498474121,
-0.512453019618988,
0.15529710054397583,
-0.3617490231990814,
-0.6528685092926025,
-0.13885638117790222,
0.3806872069835663,
-0.05908465012907982,
0.0002640129532665014
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10304v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10304v1
|
Enhancing Voice Wake-Up for Dysarthria: Mandarin Dysarthria Speech Corpus Release and Customized System Design
| 2024-06-14T03:06:55 | 2024-06-14T03:06:55 |
Ming Gao, Hang Chen, Jun Du, Xin Xu, Hongxiao Guo, Hui Bu, Jianxing Yang, Ming Li, Chin-Hui Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Smart home technology has gained widespread adoption, facilitating effortless
control of devices through voice commands. However, individuals with
dysarthria, a motor speech disorder, face challenges due to the variability of
their speech. This paper addresses the wake-up word spotting (WWS) task for
dysarthric individuals, aiming to integrate them into real-world applications.
To support this, we release the open-source Mandarin Dysarthria Speech Corpus
(MDSC), a dataset designed for dysarthric individuals in home environments.
MDSC encompasses information on age, gender, disease types, and intelligibility
evaluations. Furthermore, we perform comprehensive experimental analysis on
MDSC, highlighting the challenges encountered. We also develop a customized
dysarthria WWS system that showcases robustness in handling intelligibility and
achieving exceptional performance. MDSC will be released on
https://www.aishelltech.com/AISHELL_6B.
|
[
-0.1241576075553894,
-0.5795493721961975,
0.3346737027168274,
0.5616010427474976,
-0.10643942654132843,
0.5623577833175659,
-0.17916274070739746,
-0.5724495649337769,
0.5755247473716736,
0.32336774468421936,
-0.7073150277137756,
-0.40737417340278625,
-0.6309834122657776,
-0.020897863432765007,
-0.2545757591724396,
0.5431618690490723,
0.32073095440864563,
-0.13382527232170105,
0.49782365560531616,
-0.06960218399763107,
-0.6597453355789185,
-0.3138645589351654,
-0.37999507784843445,
-0.28738436102867126,
0.22771766781806946,
0.4964704215526581,
0.8548831343650818,
0.5148643255233765,
0.4156753718852997,
0.2140112817287445,
-0.4329828917980194,
-0.002386735985055566,
-0.15998367965221405,
0.6292501091957092,
0.16636808216571808,
-0.07456120103597641,
-0.8437495827674866,
-0.06920991837978363,
0.5029770731925964,
0.8773625493049622,
-0.6794437170028687,
0.3098617196083069,
0.23970413208007812,
0.9175373911857605,
-0.42926210165023804,
0.1063544750213623,
-0.3926137387752533,
0.4295339584350586,
-0.5969938039779663,
-0.021445784717798233,
-0.04174470528960228,
-0.4225592017173767,
-0.07957078516483307,
-0.6225802302360535,
0.08000658452510834,
0.029265830293297768,
0.25545352697372437,
0.4654216170310974,
0.15126273036003113,
-0.20178070664405823,
-0.70817631483078,
0.47806376218795776,
-0.8894019722938538,
0.6130763292312622,
0.5444257855415344,
0.5555904507637024,
-0.40781787037849426,
-0.6600262522697449,
-0.7148599624633789,
-0.5098598599433899,
0.2783835530281067,
0.1845076084136963,
-0.39425787329673767,
0.42684319615364075,
0.24001134932041168,
0.6914240717887878,
-0.6598734259605408,
0.12016744911670685,
-0.4022597670555115,
-0.4505828320980072,
0.5571774840354919,
0.07936067879199982,
0.6238493323326111,
-0.21416352689266205,
0.1792229562997818,
0.19597148895263672,
-0.6051635146141052,
-0.059447892010211945,
0.46714967489242554,
0.5990170836448669,
-0.20354989171028137,
0.5975156426429749,
-0.5778751969337463,
0.783051073551178,
0.28212034702301025,
-0.5641190409660339,
0.5918365120887756,
-0.02019764855504036,
-0.032633475959300995,
0.7793106436729431,
0.045510318130254745,
0.10513651371002197,
-0.16027526557445526,
-0.0976594090461731,
-0.26713815331459045,
-0.14772972464561462,
0.10648518800735474,
-0.6555737853050232,
-0.4329330325126648,
0.6081653833389282,
-0.7645859718322754,
-0.4404802620410919,
-0.1650475710630417,
-0.6101359724998474,
-0.7627858519554138,
-0.36791595816612244,
0.038332559168338776,
-0.22949835658073425,
-0.9882703423500061,
0.19931532442569733,
-0.5213260054588318,
-0.09266506135463715,
-0.041777342557907104,
-1.2074838876724243,
0.2167433500289917,
0.46240755915641785,
0.904607892036438,
-0.3182618319988251,
-0.12724781036376953,
-0.8706687688827515,
0.1754152774810791,
-0.23304961621761322,
0.48274436593055725,
-0.23331202566623688,
-0.557674765586853,
-0.2572531998157501,
-0.12690934538841248,
-0.33320456743240356,
-0.8446882367134094,
0.49468570947647095,
-0.11094983667135239,
-0.036989856511354446,
-0.1389230191707611,
-0.09758070856332779,
0.1107172742486,
-0.06069479510188103,
-0.6630523800849915,
1.027037501335144,
0.3574382960796356,
-0.8070693016052246,
0.18824252486228943,
-0.7868046760559082,
-0.6293525099754333,
0.607593834400177,
-0.2875572741031647,
-0.15478487312793732,
0.1777365654706955,
0.2991143763065338,
0.296370267868042,
0.18022489547729492,
0.278713196516037,
-0.02344587817788124,
-0.4252624809741974,
-0.10847532004117966,
-0.5738893747329712,
1.0048424005508423,
0.8281527161598206,
-0.5512174963951111,
0.04612034931778908,
-0.9064099192619324,
0.11627613008022308,
0.04139602556824684,
-0.2132895439863205,
-0.15225030481815338,
0.1506105363368988,
-0.010489256121218204,
-0.1003251001238823,
0.343496710062027,
-0.9697421789169312,
-0.04345817118883133,
-0.25987550616264343,
0.4892790913581848,
0.36910396814346313,
0.08457893878221512,
-0.18148526549339294,
-0.6717367768287659,
0.534267008304596,
0.1995934396982193,
0.314076691865921,
0.1108473390340805,
-0.8049265742301941,
0.08089224249124527,
-0.720028817653656,
0.029017385095357895,
0.5908511877059937,
-0.7020955681800842,
0.6693806648254395,
-0.09239499270915985,
-0.3939932882785797,
-0.7680331468582153,
-0.15340067446231842,
0.19174529612064362,
0.7623423337936401,
0.3275465965270996,
0.2419770061969757,
-0.7608476281166077,
-0.4826725125312805,
-0.19195811450481415,
-0.22656862437725067,
0.011680901050567627,
0.22107787430286407,
-0.1873023808002472,
-0.2123958170413971,
1.0009148120880127,
-0.5465141534805298,
-0.4933376610279083,
-0.5242567658424377,
-0.19883576035499573,
0.2613756060600281,
0.3849797248840332,
0.52659672498703,
-0.695775032043457,
-0.23146335780620575,
0.14304903149604797,
-0.69554603099823,
-0.256838858127594,
0.14773567020893097,
0.491743803024292,
0.06622213125228882,
0.47492605447769165,
-0.39354991912841797,
0.6075572371482849,
0.7798687219619751,
-0.2018853724002838,
0.929982602596283,
-0.27137675881385803,
0.14873754978179932,
-1.3511816263198853,
-0.032219238579273224,
-0.3763747811317444,
-0.014152026735246181,
-0.664619505405426,
-0.20549729466438293,
-0.18484821915626526,
-0.38617318868637085,
-0.3619620203971863,
0.18280723690986633,
-0.5045307278633118,
-0.19109395146369934,
-0.2613238990306854,
0.3152344226837158,
-0.006003879941999912,
-0.01600041054189205,
-0.0969693660736084,
0.763521671295166,
0.668607771396637,
-0.43400803208351135,
0.43652424216270447,
0.226848766207695,
-0.4794451594352722,
0.42842134833335876,
-0.652924120426178,
-0.26160451769828796,
0.07397394627332687,
0.08301161974668503,
-0.9223076701164246,
-0.34665802121162415,
0.2747645080089569,
-0.5561627745628357,
0.31632670760154724,
0.20381882786750793,
-0.3369831442832947,
-0.6011414527893066,
-0.4124317765235901,
0.05267105624079704,
0.4411110281944275,
-1.0786621570587158,
0.28321409225463867,
0.8351500630378723,
-0.5051957964897156,
-0.3671433627605438,
-0.6707250475883484,
0.445626437664032,
-0.22116902470588684,
-0.4321955144405365,
0.7625361680984497,
-0.07622536271810532,
-0.40753692388534546,
-0.06303919106721878,
-0.027314120903611183,
0.04419062286615372,
0.17830698192119598,
0.11006896942853928,
0.10425401479005814,
-0.22014032304286957,
0.30505427718162537,
0.39158061146736145,
0.1129772812128067,
-0.19677774608135223,
-0.047636453062295914,
0.3770599365234375,
-0.061930738389492035,
-0.43351009488105774,
-0.8338430523872375,
0.47847121953964233,
0.7394839525222778,
-0.18398703634738922,
0.029823437333106995,
0.5518513917922974,
-0.6964882612228394,
-0.21789796650409698,
-0.39632293581962585,
-0.3218277096748352,
-0.5386456847190857,
0.3315976560115814,
-0.5533487796783447,
-0.42904114723205566,
0.39016517996788025,
0.030568841844797134,
-0.07036347687244415,
0.08059137314558029,
0.6763372421264648,
-0.26976892352104187,
1.2414036989212036,
0.5059455633163452,
-0.3661835193634033,
0.6401622891426086,
0.13969704508781433,
0.3146328926086426,
-1.168029546737671,
-0.10686438530683517,
-0.5663817524909973,
-0.27171608805656433,
-0.5019962191581726,
-0.005331805907189846,
0.2851536273956299,
-0.07487211376428604,
-0.007809455972164869,
0.27204447984695435,
-1.0997180938720703,
0.008241849020123482,
0.22888906300067902,
0.3281588852405548,
0.565823495388031,
0.05846399441361427,
-0.2663041949272156,
-0.3482103943824768,
-0.6035513877868652,
-0.1954578459262848,
0.4842529296875,
0.2161620557308197,
0.9514598250389099,
0.22304435074329376,
0.6494706869125366,
0.7235326170921326,
0.036288466304540634,
-0.735307514667511,
0.3733952045440674,
-0.20710687339305878,
-0.4407612979412079,
-0.3949318528175354,
-0.20201066136360168,
-1.0408575534820557,
0.06863181293010712,
0.1735823005437851,
-0.9919626116752625,
0.4360974431037903,
0.09649563580751419,
-0.6537134051322937,
0.42865070700645447,
-0.40511974692344666,
0.24513670802116394,
-0.2166636735200882,
0.12805290520191193,
-0.28090140223503113,
-0.5243949294090271,
0.27581027150154114,
0.43149274587631226,
0.09091021120548248,
-0.4853401780128479,
0.1751924604177475,
0.7864579558372498,
-0.32744577527046204,
1.0484575033187866,
-0.520675539970398,
-0.17747963964939117,
0.43067410588264465,
-0.13720837235450745,
0.0936446562409401,
-0.14316965639591217,
-0.19920745491981506,
0.23684357106685638,
0.0985122099518776,
-0.008803363889455795,
-0.3533662259578705,
0.7258779406547546,
-0.5965481400489807,
-0.5139037370681763,
-0.6624525785446167,
-0.5583315491676331,
-0.37680506706237793,
0.1350805014371872,
0.0883745476603508,
0.7915390729904175,
-0.27211618423461914,
0.047000546008348465,
0.6034391522407532,
0.009312985464930534,
0.5726028084754944,
0.5903850197792053,
-0.48951083421707153,
-0.3927071690559387,
1.300643801689148,
0.30125388503074646,
-0.1012972965836525,
-0.005511825438588858,
0.5906572937965393,
-0.43700429797172546,
-0.8348010778427124,
-0.7509784698486328,
0.12292095273733139,
-0.36081835627555847,
0.14158061146736145,
-0.48930051922798157,
-0.5603313446044922,
-0.8276713490486145,
0.29306817054748535,
-0.06838070601224899,
-0.6491662263870239,
-0.5178596377372742,
-0.19040481746196747,
0.4288916289806366,
0.9078388810157776,
-0.26751238107681274,
0.04369616135954857,
-0.784453272819519,
0.7723914980888367,
0.219655841588974,
0.3417207896709442,
-0.023287979885935783,
-0.598355233669281,
-0.1559985727071762,
0.3168942630290985,
-0.426614373922348,
-0.7582091689109802,
0.416604220867157,
0.34696364402770996,
0.9626102447509766,
0.22476553916931152,
0.42195531725883484,
0.6821603178977966,
-0.1875837743282318,
1.039086103439331,
0.14918413758277893,
-0.6617133021354675,
0.7162309288978577,
-0.3971717655658722,
0.34970226883888245,
0.4876821041107178,
0.07943541556596756,
-0.7923644781112671,
-0.3640157878398895,
-0.4869682788848877,
-0.47730764746665955,
0.32853227853775024,
0.06371677666902542,
-0.2522569000720978,
-0.04078057035803795,
0.16666068136692047,
-0.0845920667052269,
0.30256062746047974,
0.19469566643238068,
-0.04902026429772377,
-0.38381701707839966,
-0.40830421447753906,
0.19960609078407288,
-0.022414272651076317,
-0.06743396818637848,
-0.5558358430862427,
0.5595199465751648,
-0.19824902713298798,
0.03183985874056816,
0.4715328812599182,
-0.16642601788043976,
-0.03830821067094803,
0.10684705525636673,
0.7914330363273621,
0.45760220289230347,
-0.15798166394233704,
-0.19501756131649017,
-0.059461940079927444,
-1.3461921215057373,
-0.013479168526828289,
0.19294580817222595,
-0.041666168719530106,
0.23722822964191437,
0.20664499700069427,
0.5654984712600708,
0.041891489177942276,
-0.749726414680481,
0.41076987981796265,
-0.13533653318881989,
-0.184561625123024,
-0.26945722103118896,
0.012508779764175415,
0.2768835127353668,
0.21747605502605438,
0.5180720686912537,
0.09016148746013641,
0.26546600461006165,
-0.41444963216781616,
0.19624723494052887,
0.1752934604883194,
-0.6055729985237122,
-0.38775700330734253,
0.6474436521530151,
0.2991921901702881,
-0.6320085525512695,
0.6793278455734253,
-0.03969451040029526,
-0.4010867178440094,
0.4949403405189514,
0.7522257566452026,
1.1426507234573364,
-0.47063490748405457,
0.10482338815927505,
0.04679596796631813,
0.18203923106193542,
0.26413121819496155,
0.8273115754127502,
-0.44464343786239624,
-0.6191139221191406,
-0.04681884124875069,
-0.4989335536956787,
-0.7226541638374329,
-0.15913273394107819,
-0.926106870174408,
-0.09376043826341629,
-0.19221588969230652,
-0.4725218117237091,
-0.2079469859600067,
0.15290679037570953,
0.07865837961435318,
0.13007302582263947,
0.3394768536090851,
0.8308133482933044,
-0.3925700783729553,
1.0022735595703125,
0.4785861074924469,
-0.0011618031421676278,
-0.6674343943595886,
0.41926881670951843,
0.18669526278972626,
-0.8490419387817383,
0.41432562470436096,
0.09583846479654312,
-0.5394178032875061,
0.24762998521327972,
-0.030614707618951797,
-0.6904683113098145,
1.2484158277511597,
0.28299736976623535,
-0.7139518857002258,
0.33695414662361145,
0.0770179033279419,
0.4573363959789276,
-0.3394555449485779,
-0.19316746294498444,
0.9722200632095337,
0.6207828521728516,
-0.1462709903717041,
-1.1096327304840088,
-0.12949515879154205,
-0.1386871337890625,
0.03065764717757702,
-0.28700047731399536,
-0.40528979897499084,
0.5478870272636414,
-0.6862083077430725,
-0.3660523295402527,
0.12351137399673462,
0.5613102316856384,
0.5117414593696594,
0.26172947883605957,
0.5789585113525391,
0.4352257549762726,
1.2424218654632568,
0.05702020972967148,
0.8957434892654419,
-0.601300835609436,
-0.18877120316028595,
1.12059485912323,
-0.5401644110679626,
0.9572314620018005,
0.33130982518196106,
-0.1739734411239624,
0.3304196298122406,
0.5072122812271118,
0.5667088627815247,
0.544166624546051,
0.34317153692245483,
-0.7799965143203735,
0.33997300267219543,
-0.44452521204948425,
-0.7732958793640137,
0.48498448729515076,
0.7543992400169373,
0.15286119282245636,
-0.2294781655073166,
0.5703437924385071,
-0.1604098379611969,
0.2766215205192566,
-0.1504792720079422,
0.8887904286384583,
0.07648130506277084,
-0.454425185918808,
0.6150806546211243,
-0.40496397018432617,
0.7247589826583862,
-0.6618900895118713,
-0.11101505905389786,
-0.040119510143995285,
0.46667495369911194,
-0.5071287751197815,
-0.6698014140129089,
0.53939288854599,
-0.17139878869056702,
-0.2982887625694275,
-0.2010883390903473,
0.7852806448936462,
-0.2631233036518097,
-0.3364061713218689,
0.31700190901756287,
0.498405396938324,
0.18521054089069366,
-0.30078697204589844,
-0.5801202058792114,
0.4137421250343323,
0.026134422048926353,
-0.18608002364635468,
0.3493453860282898,
-0.05763828754425049,
-0.07252229750156403,
0.6067735552787781,
0.8140592575073242,
0.588508129119873,
0.12505322694778442,
0.36637648940086365,
0.8890827894210815,
-0.5436673760414124,
-0.5630238652229309,
-0.4573267102241516,
0.13651886582374573,
-0.2570962607860565,
-0.5914531946182251,
0.7920704483985901,
0.4799136519432068,
0.15804710984230042,
0.1467130184173584,
0.9371496438980103,
-0.30918535590171814,
0.967208743095398,
-0.0480598509311676,
1.31004798412323,
-0.29919570684432983,
0.1450807750225067,
0.028173599392175674,
-0.48860883712768555,
-0.1783570498228073,
0.4683510363101959,
0.16283071041107178,
-0.3000217080116272,
0.5867892503738403,
0.9226167798042297,
0.3012566566467285,
0.5175178647041321,
0.6283787488937378,
0.1868220865726471,
0.5388990044593811,
0.06834007799625397,
0.8021016120910645,
-0.07514414936304092,
0.16827388107776642,
-0.5154348611831665,
-0.6410987973213196,
-0.32096025347709656,
-0.9445483088493347,
-0.3203381896018982,
-0.6178555488586426,
-0.36683449149131775,
-0.22772593796253204,
0.43779680132865906,
0.9295574426651001,
0.8722413778305054,
-0.8543581366539001,
-0.2799016237258911,
0.06120464578270912,
0.19656403362751007,
-1.0107383728027344,
-0.2317289561033249,
0.28490763902664185,
-0.22456412017345428,
-0.4726918637752533,
1.1815996170043945,
0.3182545304298401,
0.08664608746767044,
-0.3642213046550751,
-0.04115471616387367,
0.17892959713935852,
-0.29833564162254333,
0.604963481426239,
0.6237701177597046,
-0.528290867805481,
-0.3233649730682373,
0.12940926849842072,
-0.24490346014499664,
0.05529596656560898,
0.8533561825752258,
-0.8997376561164856,
0.4750937819480896,
0.5301614999771118,
0.4084264934062958,
0.19656121730804443,
0.049780867993831635,
0.36940503120422363,
-0.6644750237464905,
0.3440302908420563,
0.590133011341095,
0.41420596837997437,
0.3700700104236603,
-0.598884642124176,
-0.016476735472679138,
0.42963868379592896,
-0.3018783926963806,
-1.0796908140182495,
0.09892304241657257,
-1.087519645690918,
-0.06547721475362778,
0.7337652444839478,
0.08611387759447098,
-0.12914179265499115,
-0.7167673110961914,
-0.5085498690605164,
-0.03737874701619148,
-0.3020758628845215,
0.7230128049850464,
0.3238944709300995,
-0.3415350019931793,
0.3165624141693115,
-0.815748393535614,
0.5785608291625977,
0.07367713004350662,
-0.46894749999046326,
0.37524911761283875,
0.14664103090763092,
0.24483205378055573,
0.015070945955812931,
0.7009652853012085,
-0.25759100914001465,
0.5176204442977905,
0.2936873435974121,
0.10733635723590851,
-0.521744430065155,
-0.2931864559650421,
-0.46202781796455383,
-0.04169866070151329,
0.006433430593460798,
-0.7779557108879089
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09676v1
|
Optimizing Byte-level Representation for End-to-end ASR
| 2024-06-14T02:58:19 | 2024-06-14T02:58:19 |
Roger Hsiao, Liuhui Deng, Erik McDermott, Ruchir Travadi, Xiaodan Zhuang
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL
|
We propose a novel approach to optimizing a byte-level representation for
end-to-end automatic speech recognition (ASR). Byte-level representation is
often used by large scale multilingual ASR systems when the character set of
the supported languages is large. The compactness and universality of
byte-level representation allow the ASR models to use smaller output
vocabularies and therefore, provide more flexibility. UTF-8 is a commonly used
byte-level representation for multilingual ASR, but it is not designed to
optimize machine learning tasks directly. By using auto-encoder and vector
quantization, we show that we can optimize a byte-level representation for ASR
and achieve better accuracy. Our proposed framework can incorporate information
from different modalities, and provides an error correction mechanism. In an
English/Mandarin dictation task, we show that a bilingual ASR model built with
this approach can outperform UTF-8 representation by 5% relative in error rate.
|
[
-0.32360634207725525,
-0.26545557379722595,
-0.10015536099672318,
0.3597266972064972,
-0.369936466217041,
0.24451561272144318,
-0.11438734829425812,
-0.40668684244155884,
0.0473032109439373,
0.17803405225276947,
-0.16559238731861115,
-0.3496336340904236,
-0.6044266223907471,
0.31956446170806885,
-0.34885022044181824,
0.4401690363883972,
0.16356950998306274,
0.4939359426498413,
-0.022938324138522148,
-0.3360164165496826,
-0.5757021903991699,
-0.7921887040138245,
-1.0245115756988525,
-0.3261536657810211,
0.14576618373394012,
0.3813322186470032,
0.44470661878585815,
0.980279803276062,
0.48997730016708374,
0.2800409197807312,
-0.30723536014556885,
0.07358165085315704,
-0.07500392943620682,
0.05613492801785469,
-0.046368952840566635,
-0.29021796584129333,
-0.2957647144794464,
-0.6493169665336609,
0.9668585062026978,
0.7059758901596069,
-0.482818067073822,
0.17640690505504608,
-0.25613126158714294,
0.7432262301445007,
-0.5391342043876648,
0.11128397285938263,
-0.4910047650337219,
0.3622071146965027,
-0.1608930230140686,
-0.3018612265586853,
-0.4124480187892914,
0.06530294567346573,
-0.2923225164413452,
-0.3664895296096802,
-0.07519974559545517,
0.10455820709466934,
0.48697352409362793,
0.5037912726402283,
-0.45820310711860657,
-0.299354612827301,
-1.0488170385360718,
0.565009593963623,
-0.6111928820610046,
0.7361315488815308,
0.3168710172176361,
0.6029216647148132,
-0.005662229843437672,
-0.20492616295814514,
-0.6397020816802979,
-0.16008321940898895,
0.23075300455093384,
0.06112603470683098,
-0.28839990496635437,
0.2784077823162079,
0.34955501556396484,
0.4516806900501251,
-0.610590934753418,
0.1683191955089569,
-0.4817168116569519,
-0.49268990755081177,
0.5994419455528259,
0.045152805745601654,
0.4357641935348511,
0.09774072468280792,
-0.1608668714761734,
-0.1562286764383316,
-0.6140507459640503,
0.5328168272972107,
0.253187894821167,
0.416629821062088,
0.1874396651983261,
0.5788670778274536,
-0.19516387581825256,
0.7575380802154541,
0.29937097430229187,
0.1372089833021164,
0.23390910029411316,
-0.17188367247581482,
-0.053649235516786575,
0.5919708609580994,
0.7705693244934082,
0.17360660433769226,
0.16247610747814178,
0.023790501058101654,
-0.6087300777435303,
0.1443486511707306,
0.1853361874818802,
-0.9531951546669006,
0.07742588222026825,
0.21998853981494904,
-0.483359158039093,
0.14965586364269257,
0.014145043678581715,
-0.36374709010124207,
-0.07839672267436981,
-0.39940887689590454,
0.6175030469894409,
-0.5105057954788208,
-0.08659448474645615,
0.4162040054798126,
-0.020987989380955696,
0.20132477581501007,
0.033229656517505646,
-1.0314061641693115,
0.5574039816856384,
0.1907675862312317,
0.6876732707023621,
0.2795132100582123,
0.0668160691857338,
-0.6430467963218689,
0.4631662964820862,
-0.5132098197937012,
0.6417149305343628,
-0.6750505566596985,
-0.6106476187705994,
-0.15092603862285614,
-0.27579858899116516,
0.2705410420894623,
-0.7228124141693115,
0.36275234818458557,
-0.5063365697860718,
-0.0236546341329813,
-0.20518343150615692,
-0.5661803483963013,
-0.14628461003303528,
-0.34284546971321106,
-0.7035070657730103,
0.8922642469406128,
-0.15321293473243713,
-0.2426428347826004,
0.37071117758750916,
-0.6815455555915833,
-0.6147924661636353,
0.08046829700469971,
-0.4809499680995941,
-0.5036597847938538,
0.16308923065662384,
0.4975131154060364,
0.24993085861206055,
-0.2972850501537323,
-0.05196134373545647,
0.3601330816745758,
-0.5600196123123169,
0.06910589337348938,
-0.4267621636390686,
0.9122817516326904,
0.3204481899738312,
-0.3953869342803955,
0.10278788208961487,
-1.1007297039031982,
0.030868198722600937,
-0.04321903735399246,
-0.7031280398368835,
-0.1923474371433258,
0.14485731720924377,
-0.010498734191060066,
-0.02123267576098442,
0.5046287775039673,
-0.8085399270057678,
-0.13401657342910767,
-0.4357644319534302,
0.5847971439361572,
0.4027588665485382,
-0.22384202480316162,
0.5626591444015503,
-0.032085783779621124,
0.34266212582588196,
0.3204263746738434,
0.023841258138418198,
-0.12794175744056702,
-0.15139371156692505,
-0.7699708342552185,
-0.16377243399620056,
0.47097182273864746,
0.7061672210693359,
-0.6295318007469177,
0.6573753356933594,
-0.18057839572429657,
-0.1761711984872818,
-0.7905264496803284,
-0.09846051782369614,
0.7062634229660034,
0.10865700244903564,
0.47400063276290894,
-0.5169132947921753,
-0.7132627367973328,
-0.7864133715629578,
-0.24939647316932678,
-0.2378225177526474,
-0.1742289662361145,
-0.049129050225019455,
0.0863574743270874,
-0.3347829580307007,
0.831148087978363,
0.04151621833443642,
-0.4764435589313507,
-0.1523386389017105,
0.046235110610723495,
0.21220242977142334,
0.7436991930007935,
0.2103091925382614,
-0.9662317633628845,
-0.6744577884674072,
0.3570541441440582,
-0.2344147264957428,
-0.018761813640594482,
-0.07827150821685791,
0.12518121302127838,
0.3965390920639038,
0.6030316352844238,
-0.3071572780609131,
0.2927333116531372,
0.09073834866285324,
-0.3982544243335724,
0.2796001434326172,
-0.5370790362358093,
0.1804599165916443,
-0.8990296125411987,
-0.07927703857421875,
-0.10236498713493347,
-0.41072145104408264,
-0.7131231427192688,
-0.16244201362133026,
0.31754955649375916,
-0.28651970624923706,
-0.02379121445119381,
0.1660538762807846,
-0.7551955580711365,
-0.37808603048324585,
-0.15421298146247864,
-0.3045204281806946,
-0.06588049978017807,
0.3539309501647949,
0.12240508943796158,
0.9438347220420837,
0.6584933996200562,
-0.4603064954280853,
0.5973151326179504,
0.29463502764701843,
0.00036541238659992814,
0.5748238563537598,
-0.8966336846351624,
0.1752755045890808,
-0.48640692234039307,
0.09404666721820831,
-0.7983232736587524,
-0.08521755784749985,
-0.10023365169763565,
-1.0421353578567505,
0.803615927696228,
-0.17025068402290344,
-0.3955124020576477,
-0.24195145070552826,
-0.1072779968380928,
0.39154621958732605,
0.7139031291007996,
-0.5619726777076721,
0.7628059387207031,
0.6599000692367554,
0.0375295914709568,
-0.6776955723762512,
-0.7706177830696106,
-0.03917630389332771,
-0.11941064149141312,
-0.46028104424476624,
0.5725667476654053,
-0.055317383259534836,
0.0730830729007721,
-0.21335357427597046,
-0.4187195301055908,
-0.21980315446853638,
-0.47445645928382874,
-0.06896280497312546,
-0.18764328956604004,
-0.3388081192970276,
-0.08850684762001038,
0.06401634961366653,
-0.25333231687545776,
0.006745553575456142,
-0.4678948223590851,
0.44066745042800903,
-0.21644462645053864,
-0.3794560730457306,
-0.42024317383766174,
0.779983401298523,
0.5055270195007324,
-0.46027636528015137,
0.6036388874053955,
0.7341756820678711,
-0.674549400806427,
-0.23512041568756104,
-0.5374247431755066,
0.053998637944459915,
-0.5029968023300171,
0.5607256889343262,
-0.6418136358261108,
-0.7892338037490845,
0.7781678438186646,
0.38728195428848267,
0.0051946514286100864,
0.22613950073719025,
0.40895742177963257,
-0.07893534749746323,
1.2530357837677002,
0.5552738308906555,
-0.2658301293849945,
0.46857190132141113,
-0.13595713675022125,
0.3026515245437622,
-0.7885589599609375,
-0.3465729355812073,
-0.5396633744239807,
-0.10468342900276184,
-0.4934127628803253,
-0.601428747177124,
0.3744099736213684,
0.18209753930568695,
-0.3625065088272095,
0.5572339296340942,
-0.7282512187957764,
0.39690354466438293,
0.6494317650794983,
0.021933887153863907,
0.08267336338758469,
0.32008832693099976,
-0.06119001284241676,
0.07777891308069229,
-0.6479542255401611,
-0.3658347725868225,
0.6821640133857727,
0.35151156783103943,
0.6871398091316223,
0.36773645877838135,
0.7304086089134216,
0.32666367292404175,
-0.6139326691627502,
-0.7587665319442749,
0.5332294702529907,
-0.5604815483093262,
-0.3494313657283783,
-0.727653443813324,
-0.6423751711845398,
-0.7609868049621582,
0.3156353235244751,
0.04265551269054413,
-0.5060727596282959,
0.29122525453567505,
0.36991748213768005,
-0.4995863437652588,
0.127403125166893,
-0.5868654847145081,
0.697238564491272,
0.0931720957159996,
0.13007283210754395,
-0.12967826426029205,
-0.8690988421440125,
-0.5448071956634521,
0.17023895680904388,
0.1475210040807724,
0.12385161966085434,
-0.18193292617797852,
0.7175639867782593,
-0.4990248382091522,
0.568710207939148,
-0.4581303894519806,
-0.016566310077905655,
0.38752487301826477,
-0.102420374751091,
0.45714235305786133,
-0.21612557768821716,
-0.09835837036371231,
0.2624199092388153,
0.1986932009458542,
-0.37558725476264954,
-0.5943466424942017,
0.0868409276008606,
-0.9828082919120789,
-0.3085845410823822,
-0.1744939684867859,
-0.3122442066669464,
-0.1356552392244339,
0.04472890496253967,
0.45093652606010437,
1.009810447692871,
0.04310739040374756,
0.29426664113998413,
0.8784403800964355,
-0.27279022336006165,
0.4414525032043457,
0.6104459166526794,
0.14827577769756317,
-0.5685735940933228,
1.3677146434783936,
0.30477073788642883,
0.138107031583786,
0.9721478223800659,
0.25564125180244446,
-0.5472038388252258,
-0.8693473935127258,
-0.822904646396637,
-0.13598911464214325,
-0.8600341081619263,
-0.19255848228931427,
-0.4602375030517578,
-0.38961705565452576,
-0.6559346318244934,
-0.015808194875717163,
-0.45998167991638184,
-0.5881105661392212,
-0.39172250032424927,
0.12980587780475616,
0.2917068302631378,
0.4773397445678711,
-0.33556199073791504,
0.3558105528354645,
-0.8010576963424683,
0.3908109962940216,
0.014879622496664524,
0.26008906960487366,
-0.13866470754146576,
-0.8487401008605957,
-0.44908055663108826,
-0.05379573628306389,
0.0007793992990627885,
-0.7093732357025146,
0.4248929023742676,
0.7116331458091736,
0.511135995388031,
0.2620898485183716,
0.025642115622758865,
0.7349826097488403,
-0.9352460503578186,
0.4767090380191803,
0.3650577962398529,
-1.2009875774383545,
0.4852004945278168,
-0.16436715424060822,
0.4328070282936096,
0.27898839116096497,
0.3622545003890991,
-0.7024669647216797,
-0.2489214390516281,
-0.054336901754140854,
-1.0643528699874878,
0.5508798956871033,
0.03412891924381256,
0.08931128680706024,
0.1236724853515625,
0.09835188835859299,
-0.0335279181599617,
0.16226375102996826,
-0.6886683702468872,
-0.251149445772171,
-0.2922193109989166,
-0.6207013130187988,
0.09456770122051239,
-0.478591650724411,
0.4361730217933655,
-0.2844482958316803,
0.626432478427887,
-0.021071355789899826,
0.5117326974868774,
0.24932855367660522,
-0.32086288928985596,
-0.16685327887535095,
0.21644724905490875,
0.42291441559791565,
0.2925247251987457,
-0.008070908486843109,
0.1318644881248474,
0.2709326148033142,
-0.7343260645866394,
0.3617189824581146,
0.16763925552368164,
-0.00434501376003027,
0.10871805250644684,
0.11690811812877655,
0.8467448949813843,
0.023630717769265175,
-0.7035414576530457,
0.4714624583721161,
0.006996032781898975,
0.0991111770272255,
-0.7231536507606506,
-0.0916713997721672,
0.10961565375328064,
0.38882482051849365,
0.5531152486801147,
-0.05309122055768967,
0.5700721740722656,
-0.3599778413772583,
0.2698793411254883,
0.3566691279411316,
-0.2906915247440338,
-0.15906867384910583,
0.7572393417358398,
0.25580307841300964,
-0.4386976957321167,
0.3794601857662201,
-0.334952712059021,
-0.4390060007572174,
0.6075610518455505,
0.6534914970397949,
0.6513509750366211,
-0.8207255601882935,
-0.15798932313919067,
0.48856914043426514,
0.2453315407037735,
-0.017575448378920555,
0.5292089581489563,
-0.2392764836549759,
-0.7442677021026611,
-0.4701894223690033,
-0.8543798923492432,
-0.3525310456752777,
-0.2982124090194702,
-0.8011780381202698,
0.4789249002933502,
-0.391869455575943,
-0.08671312779188156,
0.02984115667641163,
-0.08471674472093582,
-0.25733867287635803,
0.347570538520813,
0.4649401605129242,
0.6349396705627441,
-0.3943532109260559,
0.7382310628890991,
0.7989374399185181,
-0.47700268030166626,
-0.7359897494316101,
-0.38640284538269043,
-0.28888532519340515,
-0.670886754989624,
0.5463404655456543,
0.2037484347820282,
-0.2852477729320526,
0.11870433390140533,
0.021823320537805557,
-1.0925393104553223,
0.839626133441925,
0.3620131313800812,
-0.9965136647224426,
-0.06724737584590912,
0.6076168417930603,
0.47992390394210815,
-0.23166963458061218,
0.16785767674446106,
0.3849996328353882,
0.04898160696029663,
0.2937396168708801,
-1.1414700746536255,
-0.0001984199625439942,
-0.4165542423725128,
0.5182398557662964,
0.31333911418914795,
-0.47664037346839905,
0.7299426198005676,
-0.15582290291786194,
-0.2846866846084595,
-0.3368386924266815,
1.040219783782959,
0.12117605656385422,
0.056693993508815765,
0.5083217620849609,
0.31074854731559753,
0.5615760684013367,
0.2037970870733261,
0.618362307548523,
-0.35907405614852905,
0.0454106442630291,
0.8269739747047424,
-0.09503353387117386,
1.0020991563796997,
0.36340633034706116,
-0.38002803921699524,
0.06356257200241089,
0.6330796480178833,
0.08869457989931107,
0.6228739619255066,
0.4102732539176941,
-0.4836024045944214,
0.04721429571509361,
0.14983366429805756,
-0.08064547926187515,
0.5209407210350037,
0.4228373169898987,
-0.047704387456178665,
0.05343252047896385,
0.15849097073078156,
-0.3412853479385376,
0.10702231526374817,
-0.6540713310241699,
0.8992992043495178,
0.05856294184923172,
-0.0817403718829155,
0.871082603931427,
0.0717565044760704,
0.8036389350891113,
-0.3735187351703644,
-0.05380183458328247,
-0.02320404350757599,
0.11500822007656097,
-0.25034233927726746,
-0.3323502838611603,
0.5280782580375671,
0.12970778346061707,
-0.4793766736984253,
-0.2156054973602295,
0.6665452122688293,
-0.928305983543396,
-0.5703887343406677,
0.23697058856487274,
-0.0106387073174119,
0.40246617794036865,
-0.08477544039487839,
-0.4373844265937805,
0.25817564129829407,
0.10312347859144211,
-0.002466293517500162,
0.11254864186048508,
0.6251408457756042,
-0.04317954182624817,
0.6119234561920166,
0.4156397581100464,
0.3085245192050934,
0.30934929847717285,
0.2721039354801178,
0.5462238788604736,
-0.7532932758331299,
-0.7868725061416626,
-0.8380336761474609,
0.6150554418563843,
-0.011299164965748787,
0.08439594507217407,
0.36129188537597656,
0.6780635118484497,
1.0275936126708984,
0.022072739899158478,
0.7668197751045227,
-0.01225606445223093,
0.5869244337081909,
-0.4748995304107666,
0.7110271453857422,
-0.48625653982162476,
0.21645456552505493,
0.013943498954176903,
-0.7415127754211426,
-0.21493420004844666,
1.0191723108291626,
0.11856618523597717,
0.055229052901268005,
0.39515677094459534,
0.6916357278823853,
0.20031225681304932,
-0.0028112370055168867,
0.7311673760414124,
0.0418119840323925,
0.3227218985557556,
0.5816612243652344,
0.6967818140983582,
-0.45718497037887573,
0.5544547438621521,
-0.21291816234588623,
-0.20992393791675568,
-0.012003937736153603,
-0.5436499714851379,
-0.7847943902015686,
-0.9070688486099243,
-0.35438376665115356,
-0.0016228939639404416,
0.1991940289735794,
1.1707894802093506,
0.5142902731895447,
-0.8858093619346619,
-0.5508318543434143,
-0.05048482120037079,
-0.3879545032978058,
-0.06914670020341873,
-0.10524778068065643,
0.2450670748949051,
-0.45346498489379883,
-0.695952296257019,
0.4949778616428375,
0.2903628349304199,
0.20101848244667053,
-0.1553512066602707,
-0.15177392959594727,
0.42632806301116943,
0.11975276470184326,
0.7260180711746216,
0.278144508600235,
-0.5484416484832764,
-0.14949767291545868,
-0.06471879035234451,
0.03823019191622734,
0.34477123618125916,
0.6113091111183167,
-0.5485727787017822,
0.4853067398071289,
0.35777390003204346,
0.8151127099990845,
0.3817579746246338,
-0.16194501519203186,
0.8437255620956421,
-0.7842029929161072,
0.06458389014005661,
0.44887858629226685,
0.3918018043041229,
0.7223562598228455,
-0.49536579847335815,
0.2107825130224228,
-0.19805151224136353,
-0.5103597640991211,
-0.8239147663116455,
0.11420419067144394,
-0.8653618693351746,
-0.03785136342048645,
1.0728880167007446,
-0.10284899920225143,
-0.23445400595664978,
-0.15171711146831512,
-0.32489636540412903,
0.4762696325778961,
-0.711449921131134,
0.44793811440467834,
0.421327143907547,
-0.2833483815193176,
-0.21277378499507904,
-0.5124756097793579,
0.4633758068084717,
0.3166496157646179,
-0.34496447443962097,
0.06263317167758942,
0.48414263129234314,
0.1934257298707962,
0.17022626101970673,
0.8226019144058228,
-0.23059776425361633,
0.29539063572883606,
0.13419991731643677,
0.3924267888069153,
-0.07254000753164291,
-0.33218592405319214,
-0.6992494463920593,
-0.1967790722846985,
0.12851141393184662,
-0.47085994482040405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09671v1
|
Evaluating ChatGPT-4 Vision on Brazil's National Undergraduate Computer Science Exam
| 2024-06-14T02:42:30 | 2024-06-14T02:42:30 |
Nabor C. Mendonça
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The recent integration of visual capabilities into Large Language Models
(LLMs) has the potential to play a pivotal role in science and technology
education, where visual elements such as diagrams, charts, and tables are
commonly used to improve the learning experience. This study investigates the
performance of ChatGPT-4 Vision, OpenAI's most advanced visual model at the
time the study was conducted, on the Bachelor in Computer Science section of
Brazil's 2021 National Undergraduate Exam (ENADE). By presenting the model with
the exam's open and multiple-choice questions in their original image format
and allowing for reassessment in response to differing answer keys, we were
able to evaluate the model's reasoning and self-reflecting capabilities in a
large-scale academic assessment involving textual and visual content. ChatGPT-4
Vision significantly outperformed the average exam participant, positioning
itself within the top 10 best score percentile. While it excelled in questions
that incorporated visual elements, it also encountered challenges with question
interpretation, logical reasoning, and visual acuity. The involvement of an
independent expert panel to review cases of disagreement between the model and
the answer key revealed some poorly constructed questions containing vague or
ambiguous statements, calling attention to the critical need for improved
question design in future exams. Our findings suggest that while ChatGPT-4
Vision shows promise in multimodal academic evaluations, human oversight
remains crucial for verifying the model's accuracy and ensuring the fairness of
high-stakes educational exams. The paper's research materials are publicly
available at https://github.com/nabormendonca/gpt-4v-enade-cs-2021.
|
[
-0.4505192041397095,
-0.8511203527450562,
0.45329609513282776,
0.4919387400150299,
-0.22231166064739227,
0.2112877070903778,
-0.07093822956085205,
-0.6009404063224792,
-0.13613632321357727,
0.24843046069145203,
-0.06751018762588501,
-0.3377740681171417,
-0.450740784406662,
0.3460800349712372,
-0.518515944480896,
0.7800502181053162,
-0.3904259204864502,
0.07116465270519257,
-0.4588989317417145,
0.025992807000875473,
-0.40675097703933716,
-0.24190442264080048,
-0.7057042121887207,
-0.1889353096485138,
0.35547682642936707,
0.14661383628845215,
0.4252146780490875,
0.008610320277512074,
0.9489100575447083,
0.37157684564590454,
-0.04091459885239601,
0.020053252577781677,
-0.48061197996139526,
-0.2750820517539978,
0.011269249022006989,
-0.43774259090423584,
-0.5938706398010254,
0.17023435235023499,
0.9748486280441284,
0.39614877104759216,
0.009001223370432854,
0.30978214740753174,
0.4938082993030548,
0.5244601368904114,
-0.460549920797348,
0.5992411375045776,
-0.25297877192497253,
0.06562907993793488,
-0.15242047607898712,
-0.24719803035259247,
-0.29449692368507385,
-0.3776127099990845,
0.4721080958843231,
-0.602910578250885,
-0.0032643817830830812,
-0.03200170397758484,
1.1794168949127197,
0.26713934540748596,
-0.39482834935188293,
0.03694071248173714,
-0.3963354229927063,
0.4888409972190857,
-0.29385673999786377,
0.4152408838272095,
-0.11192535609006882,
0.5853831768035889,
-0.08389969915151596,
-0.73944091796875,
-0.3662671744823456,
-0.25279316306114197,
0.3313347399234772,
0.62315434217453,
-0.2776015102863312,
0.19857759773731232,
0.3013910949230194,
0.21058782935142517,
-0.7643873691558838,
-0.06774125248193741,
-0.9087467789649963,
-0.3388378322124481,
0.4256168603897095,
0.08915019035339355,
0.3107718229293823,
0.017420180141925812,
-0.3957059979438782,
-0.16635765135288239,
-0.6535723805427551,
0.09800533205270767,
0.47140049934387207,
0.017926203086972237,
-0.2034732550382614,
0.45267432928085327,
-0.2960275709629059,
0.9620162844657898,
-0.47274249792099,
0.22318477928638458,
0.2778543531894684,
-0.27663931250572205,
-0.3879295289516449,
-0.2579022943973541,
0.6591267585754395,
0.3453761339187622,
0.3967132568359375,
0.20600266754627228,
-0.07498687505722046,
0.29198309779167175,
0.3169766962528229,
-0.8864617943763733,
-0.3849124014377594,
0.09065791219472885,
-0.2290223240852356,
-0.17637492716312408,
-0.07518938928842545,
-0.9402020573616028,
-0.28836575150489807,
-0.40708962082862854,
0.535440981388092,
-0.435239315032959,
-0.020207343623042107,
0.098911352455616,
-0.047571487724781036,
0.5387090444564819,
0.9092668890953064,
-0.39163169264793396,
0.2204148769378662,
0.49064359068870544,
0.8497822284698486,
-0.32968708872795105,
-0.3847392201423645,
-0.022408530116081238,
-0.25851649045944214,
-0.46511074900627136,
0.846138060092926,
-0.679897129535675,
-0.05022086203098297,
-0.24515800178050995,
-0.323250412940979,
-0.1662023961544037,
-0.20961514115333557,
0.3341268301010132,
-0.5227999687194824,
0.30565547943115234,
-0.359951913356781,
-0.14511196315288544,
-0.34854617714881897,
0.6759400367736816,
-0.41522470116615295,
0.6571137309074402,
-0.0014420290244743228,
-0.6285309791564941,
0.3849850594997406,
-0.8776181936264038,
0.1896270215511322,
0.4043366312980652,
-0.809272050857544,
-0.23090969026088715,
-0.33128678798675537,
0.22799918055534363,
0.1601092517375946,
-0.22807371616363525,
0.10884969681501389,
-0.22430537641048431,
-0.6064034700393677,
0.36910441517829895,
-0.7385917901992798,
0.5281378626823425,
-0.009829049929976463,
-0.1814045011997223,
0.10410082340240479,
-0.5512712001800537,
0.036284688860177994,
0.2453494518995285,
-0.40186119079589844,
0.14976860582828522,
-0.1715480089187622,
-0.019061138853430748,
-0.0003774101787712425,
0.3262128233909607,
-0.7813864946365356,
0.21469180285930634,
-0.19591182470321655,
0.33719944953918457,
0.7799233198165894,
-0.039105385541915894,
0.2317061424255371,
-0.001944651477970183,
0.6360117197036743,
-0.1846814900636673,
0.48827216029167175,
-0.08413124084472656,
-1.1313211917877197,
-0.7173806428909302,
-0.06364419311285019,
0.5282195210456848,
0.5426007509231567,
-0.6713053584098816,
-0.5211945176124573,
-0.15560360252857208,
-0.5099281072616577,
-0.3641359210014343,
-0.18274207413196564,
0.4557345509529114,
0.3850538730621338,
0.11515235155820847,
-0.4460935592651367,
-0.20245084166526794,
-0.9428080320358276,
-0.16826963424682617,
-0.3089032769203186,
0.10911019146442413,
0.35242435336112976,
0.9783737063407898,
-0.08030067384243011,
0.7543218731880188,
-0.5137835144996643,
-0.23719261586666107,
-0.051591359078884125,
0.29808804392814636,
0.16726388037204742,
0.3673281967639923,
0.6230909824371338,
-0.7600686550140381,
-0.34619948267936707,
0.1472649723291397,
-0.9597771763801575,
-0.1637369841337204,
-0.007286597974598408,
-0.19660300016403198,
0.09008391201496124,
0.14330080151557922,
-0.09694334864616394,
0.6891613006591797,
0.48518529534339905,
-0.4387769401073456,
0.6988064646720886,
-0.23527123034000397,
0.5547497868537903,
-0.3004801869392395,
0.09348282963037491,
0.15137150883674622,
0.04297439754009247,
-0.303461492061615,
0.29481011629104614,
0.14820021390914917,
-0.42229366302490234,
-0.23428897559642792,
0.43384262919425964,
-0.4576292932033539,
-0.3932156264781952,
-0.11705499142408371,
0.2827707827091217,
-0.03823651745915413,
0.3966139256954193,
-0.12650229036808014,
0.7727958559989929,
0.6764655709266663,
-0.14508113265037537,
0.41517874598503113,
0.24463628232479095,
-0.49245262145996094,
0.8021318316459656,
-0.6883694529533386,
0.09040812402963638,
-0.12196074426174164,
0.18250910937786102,
-0.9090625643730164,
-0.38819316029548645,
0.23774437606334686,
-0.46052834391593933,
0.2464529275894165,
-0.15145540237426758,
-0.29616421461105347,
-0.48713430762290955,
-0.03365151211619377,
0.4228523373603821,
0.21670228242874146,
-0.38478079438209534,
0.7087906002998352,
0.1561514437198639,
-0.09356172382831573,
-0.7264488339424133,
-0.6739108562469482,
0.3580184280872345,
-0.026732778176665306,
-0.9696072340011597,
0.171061709523201,
0.084080770611763,
-0.2742025852203369,
-0.2638097107410431,
-0.050300635397434235,
-0.16988854110240936,
0.018404075875878334,
0.17363594472408295,
0.5082359910011292,
-0.2237757444381714,
-0.14804518222808838,
-0.19472716748714447,
0.12306563556194305,
0.18976013362407684,
0.12517890334129333,
0.3982410132884979,
-0.8213537931442261,
-0.5520334243774414,
-0.4326266646385193,
0.07049408555030823,
0.4972577691078186,
-0.37746602296829224,
0.15265412628650665,
0.33982768654823303,
-0.24807235598564148,
0.04156145080924034,
-0.5672627687454224,
-0.09532276540994644,
-0.4546143412590027,
0.6014920473098755,
-0.4150214195251465,
-0.6570630669593811,
0.5880920886993408,
0.12298284471035004,
0.1766940802335739,
0.06024022027850151,
0.17929449677467346,
-0.22840453684329987,
0.7167136073112488,
0.36977460980415344,
0.20442421734333038,
0.47656139731407166,
-0.3858984410762787,
0.08508709073066711,
-0.8060544729232788,
-0.5645039677619934,
-0.40955930948257446,
-0.28504106402397156,
-0.501632809638977,
-0.5381370186805725,
0.718635082244873,
-0.37429797649383545,
-0.4847028851509094,
-0.14748284220695496,
-0.4398074448108673,
0.3947276771068573,
0.6127601861953735,
0.4342988133430481,
0.3617004156112671,
0.0823039710521698,
-0.10666929930448532,
0.028258325532078743,
-0.5479156970977783,
-0.5951138734817505,
1.1474257707595825,
0.4214852750301361,
0.7566726803779602,
-0.011316443793475628,
0.526329517364502,
0.07790032029151917,
0.28666236996650696,
-0.3730078637599945,
0.7062709331512451,
0.2507290542125702,
-0.4541477560997009,
-0.274308443069458,
-0.4873995780944824,
-0.8987276554107666,
0.6472644805908203,
-0.16632512211799622,
-0.8594868183135986,
0.12241502106189728,
0.11395645141601562,
-0.2678023874759674,
0.08205324411392212,
-0.8022632002830505,
1.1227545738220215,
-0.45682114362716675,
-0.5801227688789368,
-0.14503423869609833,
-0.49038174748420715,
0.408718466758728,
-0.1443699449300766,
0.0012976889265701175,
0.16811832785606384,
-0.027463741600513458,
0.9695020914077759,
0.056649547070264816,
0.7264258861541748,
-0.024194758385419846,
0.13632048666477203,
0.4249175190925598,
0.13457635045051575,
0.10708347707986832,
-0.06312941014766693,
0.06253419816493988,
0.42164936661720276,
0.12674304842948914,
-0.3890956938266754,
-0.6593912839889526,
0.5641502141952515,
-0.91413813829422,
-0.6435330510139465,
-0.784845769405365,
-0.36297398805618286,
-0.16892693936824799,
0.1173754334449768,
-0.0032339536119252443,
0.6566463708877563,
-0.4013606905937195,
0.07354234158992767,
0.37409213185310364,
-0.4643327295780182,
0.2297825813293457,
0.33275866508483887,
-0.5126382112503052,
-0.1909024566411972,
1.0292763710021973,
0.2827335298061371,
0.36522430181503296,
-0.028504598885774612,
0.13957050442695618,
-0.1524536907672882,
-0.6351408362388611,
-0.8010722398757935,
0.18767379224300385,
-0.9075817465782166,
0.038946483284235,
-0.4213915765285492,
-0.3372415006160736,
-0.31162846088409424,
-0.033333670347929,
-0.1879957765340805,
-0.14102914929389954,
-0.125581294298172,
0.18307209014892578,
-0.016811443492770195,
0.8220118880271912,
0.2739419937133789,
0.33775070309638977,
-0.2019398957490921,
-0.023191194981336594,
0.31877028942108154,
0.45326289534568787,
-0.20106388628482819,
-0.48559504747390747,
0.22818365693092346,
-0.14001283049583435,
-0.740593433380127,
-0.9917517900466919,
0.09224358201026917,
0.018080279231071472,
0.5594297051429749,
0.4716876447200775,
-0.5277166962623596,
0.5820028781890869,
-0.14784178137779236,
0.7177435159683228,
0.10996674001216888,
-0.6170778274536133,
0.5056009292602539,
-0.6067907214164734,
0.5081629157066345,
0.3856438100337982,
0.10036076605319977,
-0.2820255160331726,
-0.3185092508792877,
-0.3476322293281555,
-0.42213162779808044,
0.5515832304954529,
0.5603963732719421,
-0.11556705832481384,
0.40108317136764526,
0.10722178220748901,
-0.21184378862380981,
0.16426153481006622,
-0.9254249334335327,
0.19738639891147614,
-0.36063912510871887,
-0.003583514830097556,
0.39710021018981934,
-0.08483391255140305,
0.02649739198386669,
-0.07452448457479477,
0.48877108097076416,
-0.1999937891960144,
0.4433067739009857,
0.08833298087120056,
0.1805754005908966,
0.33379238843917847,
0.33416441082954407,
0.3329855501651764,
0.9656464457511902,
-0.2733183801174164,
-0.20905359089374542,
0.24790240824222565,
-0.7473924160003662,
-0.3461611568927765,
0.0014507670421153307,
-0.30972450971603394,
-0.3910234868526459,
0.3238682746887207,
0.6220638751983643,
0.08560888469219208,
-0.582683265209198,
0.7465194463729858,
-0.19447971880435944,
-0.2009788304567337,
-0.2443990260362625,
0.0181423369795084,
-0.27199026942253113,
0.2612389624118805,
0.3291207551956177,
0.2443724125623703,
0.35450953245162964,
-0.6363028883934021,
-0.24118739366531372,
0.2961578667163849,
-0.2945965826511383,
-0.1409156322479248,
0.5203596353530884,
0.3499911427497864,
0.07275411486625671,
0.7131114602088928,
0.05760463699698448,
-0.6448877453804016,
0.8323760032653809,
0.38223594427108765,
0.4890778660774231,
-0.32622942328453064,
0.35598960518836975,
0.4106360971927643,
0.711357593536377,
0.01108858734369278,
0.8876385688781738,
-0.055535051971673965,
-0.5909141898155212,
-0.2756655812263489,
-0.5855045914649963,
-0.723432183265686,
-0.08893536776304245,
-0.3266453146934509,
0.3712422251701355,
-0.4391106069087982,
-0.057930707931518555,
-0.34022215008735657,
-0.1868746429681778,
-0.7979392409324646,
0.560876727104187,
0.26904943585395813,
0.7720054984092712,
-0.6934693455696106,
0.2891322672367096,
0.6828781366348267,
-0.7150439620018005,
-0.5250990390777588,
-0.27936261892318726,
-0.032805342227220535,
-0.7575579285621643,
0.7069348096847534,
0.2595319151878357,
-0.13530710339546204,
-0.28060147166252136,
-0.69686359167099,
-1.0108383893966675,
0.8460866212844849,
0.48772019147872925,
-0.5655094385147095,
-0.1409829556941986,
0.35806792974472046,
0.5752140283584595,
-0.11200861632823944,
0.8511244058609009,
0.3911324441432953,
0.6031655669212341,
0.19701281189918518,
-1.050921082496643,
-0.11865059286355972,
-0.2979166507720947,
-0.28006839752197266,
0.04960354417562485,
-0.8216938972473145,
0.7164338827133179,
-0.26617494225502014,
-0.24336497485637665,
-0.11256320774555206,
0.681239128112793,
0.3527137041091919,
0.34732869267463684,
0.2933642268180847,
0.3802454471588135,
0.6548200249671936,
-0.4385155439376831,
0.9694395661354065,
-0.031036376953125,
-0.014106440357863903,
0.8549787402153015,
-0.12562261521816254,
0.7950852513313293,
0.40743809938430786,
-0.2183886617422104,
0.5270532369613647,
0.6657346487045288,
-0.26221078634262085,
0.19685152173042297,
0.3594736158847809,
-0.018852634355425835,
-0.2358928918838501,
0.19641821086406708,
-0.43753987550735474,
0.9284970760345459,
0.43062785267829895,
-0.19419530034065247,
-0.28003212809562683,
0.15757091343402863,
-0.2725159823894501,
-0.19530357420444489,
-0.46790558099746704,
0.32646867632865906,
-0.026747437193989754,
-0.8029810786247253,
0.24017678201198578,
-0.1937236785888672,
0.33244478702545166,
-0.4529581367969513,
-0.27731651067733765,
-0.17221996188163757,
0.185822993516922,
-0.16545210778713226,
-1.038106083869934,
0.10036925971508026,
0.23819378018379211,
0.6184800267219543,
-0.19094763696193695,
0.5066090822219849,
0.07717709988355637,
-0.5877382159233093,
0.15075889229774475,
0.27707499265670776,
0.6656907796859741,
-0.20730073750019073,
-0.725471556186676,
0.24205327033996582,
-0.09379442036151886,
-0.08016806095838547,
0.25672435760498047,
0.18890812993049622,
-0.26476234197616577,
0.8441148400306702,
0.27188432216644287,
0.06560543924570084,
0.15894055366516113,
0.14282405376434326,
0.7665066123008728,
-0.3457028269767761,
-0.495358407497406,
-0.624920666217804,
0.21091262996196747,
-0.3070555329322815,
-0.595360279083252,
0.7388699650764465,
0.745782732963562,
0.8728029131889343,
0.16005180776119232,
0.7095565795898438,
0.15991422533988953,
-0.15713293850421906,
-0.34320199489593506,
0.8035659790039062,
-0.5276381373405457,
-0.0324103944003582,
-0.6080644726753235,
-0.8985501527786255,
-0.18327833712100983,
0.6865223050117493,
-0.6154796481132507,
0.2067394107580185,
0.7460344433784485,
0.6411852836608887,
0.011030507273972034,
0.4008166193962097,
0.40716132521629333,
0.2008708417415619,
0.3220863938331604,
0.5721385478973389,
1.0030289888381958,
-0.35264334082603455,
0.8422459959983826,
-0.03237348794937134,
-0.6971701383590698,
0.050528764724731445,
-0.6562061309814453,
-0.9377908706665039,
-0.4149341881275177,
-0.4704127013683319,
-0.1931518167257309,
0.1752801388502121,
0.34823206067085266,
0.33987709879875183,
-0.44221243262290955,
-0.28325673937797546,
0.06296279281377792,
-0.2551194131374359,
-0.011142134666442871,
-0.16489754617214203,
0.4434516429901123,
0.0474635548889637,
-0.6428413987159729,
0.303604394197464,
0.4912598431110382,
0.08675962686538696,
-0.459641695022583,
0.140431746840477,
0.027015669271349907,
-0.011546473950147629,
0.5304898023605347,
0.03128955885767937,
-0.7720584869384766,
-0.22765277326107025,
0.1410188376903534,
0.08996257185935974,
0.2226281464099884,
0.33069661259651184,
-0.7610519528388977,
0.7745717167854309,
0.6772562861442566,
0.3805917203426361,
0.7106614112854004,
-0.02729964815080166,
0.5882633924484253,
-0.10683999210596085,
-0.20572181046009064,
0.27648475766181946,
0.7352925539016724,
0.3605723977088928,
-0.11450092494487762,
0.6302669048309326,
0.21941328048706055,
-0.755657434463501,
-0.6417468190193176,
-0.05475352704524994,
-1.244586706161499,
-0.05188950523734093,
1.030497431755066,
-0.2676408588886261,
-0.35871994495391846,
0.06050678342580795,
-0.5658546686172485,
0.05364619940519333,
-0.45710426568984985,
0.841323971748352,
0.6865196824073792,
-0.22547587752342224,
-0.19265033304691315,
-0.8896263241767883,
0.0158428605645895,
0.2708958089351654,
-0.9542179107666016,
-0.3208923637866974,
0.604327917098999,
0.13148561120033264,
0.09396632760763168,
0.44549429416656494,
-0.34555917978286743,
0.5051474571228027,
0.1348310261964798,
0.13005982339382172,
-0.11306663602590561,
-0.4543554186820984,
-0.1912289559841156,
0.4665723145008087,
-0.21865910291671753,
-0.2524467408657074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10303v1
|
A Survey on Large Language Models from General Purpose to Medical Applications: Datasets, Methodologies, and Evaluations
| 2024-06-14T02:42:20 | 2024-06-14T02:42:20 |
Jinqiang Wang, Huansheng Ning, Yi Peng, Qikai Wei, Daniel Tesfai, Wenwei Mao, Tao Zhu, Runhe Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated surprising performance across
various natural language processing tasks. Recently, medical LLMs enhanced with
domain-specific knowledge have exhibited excellent capabilities in medical
consultation and diagnosis. These models can smoothly simulate doctor-patient
dialogues and provide professional medical advice. Most medical LLMs are
developed through continued training of open-source general LLMs, which require
significantly fewer computational resources than training LLMs from scratch.
Additionally, this approach offers better protection of patient privacy
compared to API-based solutions. This survey systematically explores how to
train medical LLMs based on general LLMs. It covers: (a) how to acquire
training corpus and construct customized medical training sets, (b) how to
choose a appropriate training paradigm, (c) how to choose a suitable evaluation
benchmark, and (d) existing challenges and promising future research directions
are discussed. This survey can provide guidance for the development of LLMs
focused on various medical applications, such as medical education, diagnostic
planning, and clinical assistants.
|
[
-0.1897021234035492,
-0.7560141682624817,
0.9662942290306091,
-0.06115509569644928,
-0.09068898111581802,
-0.08772275596857071,
-0.5616468787193298,
-0.5976139903068542,
0.07807100564241409,
0.6710467338562012,
-0.39034414291381836,
-0.7019886374473572,
-0.7671137452125549,
0.14106155931949615,
-0.2869030237197876,
0.722450852394104,
-0.09625288844108582,
0.7882920503616333,
-0.293297678232193,
-0.1973317712545395,
-0.22111815214157104,
-0.901807963848114,
-0.8002405762672424,
-0.3474234938621521,
0.4174194633960724,
0.07435733079910278,
0.4860570728778839,
0.4741024971008301,
0.5758123397827148,
0.29190704226493835,
0.0009393077343702316,
0.16660761833190918,
-0.37496721744537354,
0.1911722719669342,
-0.2932591736316681,
-0.31529688835144043,
-0.3307464122772217,
0.05063631013035774,
0.6612681746482849,
1.1580053567886353,
-0.2153674215078354,
0.12249082326889038,
-0.22943244874477386,
0.5804961323738098,
-0.5091429948806763,
0.008668205700814724,
-0.44570833444595337,
0.10031633824110031,
-0.06697506457567215,
-0.0732429251074791,
-0.3845498859882355,
-0.4364328384399414,
0.33645686507225037,
-0.24157315492630005,
0.09317656606435776,
0.13160750269889832,
0.42686551809310913,
0.055843912065029144,
-0.4213813543319702,
-0.596397876739502,
-0.8211591243743896,
0.9799663424491882,
-0.6624676585197449,
0.5892698764801025,
0.374027818441391,
0.42279505729675293,
-0.3502393960952759,
-0.7079172134399414,
-0.12585784494876862,
-0.5400749444961548,
0.16323742270469666,
-0.10996463149785995,
-0.03875182569026947,
0.25371360778808594,
0.039767902344465256,
0.5595533847808838,
-0.6600694060325623,
0.622748076915741,
-0.23178845643997192,
0.010877246037125587,
0.6201233863830566,
0.4577292799949646,
0.4655139744281769,
0.2130613774061203,
-0.10139919817447662,
0.26252543926239014,
-1.0051814317703247,
-0.3532273769378662,
-0.003934121690690517,
-0.047220662236213684,
-0.21827174723148346,
0.6621987223625183,
0.04241320490837097,
0.955554723739624,
-0.3229210376739502,
-0.29752668738365173,
0.21312834322452545,
-0.19553616642951965,
-0.5091804265975952,
-0.29618340730667114,
0.9976706504821777,
0.3186933100223541,
0.49204349517822266,
-0.37881818413734436,
-0.11531167477369308,
-0.08824319392442703,
0.2872215509414673,
-0.7285217642784119,
0.05227116495370865,
0.41067057847976685,
-0.581913411617279,
-0.19646449387073517,
-0.5157719254493713,
-0.5253714919090271,
-0.6019290685653687,
-0.6428828835487366,
-0.04254593327641487,
-0.38691022992134094,
-0.10016456246376038,
0.5541260242462158,
0.33422228693962097,
0.17588646709918976,
0.33058905601501465,
-1.1030287742614746,
0.5054476857185364,
0.8283116221427917,
0.6481910347938538,
-0.14616958796977997,
0.0384269654750824,
-0.4006277620792389,
-0.014186614193022251,
-0.4246240556240082,
0.598285973072052,
-0.5892810821533203,
-0.6052228808403015,
0.41180866956710815,
0.05593974143266678,
-0.1737130731344223,
-0.8835575580596924,
0.464990496635437,
-0.28269925713539124,
0.29797735810279846,
0.0412299670279026,
-0.6869857907295227,
0.058204591274261475,
0.4396035671234131,
-0.4625735282897949,
0.45864245295524597,
0.1168559342622757,
-0.5324763059616089,
0.1869364231824875,
-0.6936309337615967,
-0.4216735363006592,
0.0691528171300888,
-0.5513685345649719,
-0.375972718000412,
0.19641989469528198,
0.26230588555336,
0.7949680685997009,
-1.0014586448669434,
0.41668015718460083,
-0.17892611026763916,
-0.3351013660430908,
0.2729468047618866,
-0.11866667866706848,
0.6682918667793274,
0.36624571681022644,
0.10346142947673798,
0.2126496434211731,
-0.7165029048919678,
0.04507019370794296,
0.15196733176708221,
-0.41105714440345764,
-0.38954266905784607,
0.0789388045668602,
-0.07955281436443329,
-0.12371137738227844,
0.05046490207314491,
-0.5250983834266663,
0.37522661685943604,
-0.7036858797073364,
0.5411900877952576,
0.3580475151538849,
0.18086160719394684,
0.3094024956226349,
-0.10684680193662643,
0.7729202508926392,
-0.2318533957004547,
0.30751940608024597,
0.011615689843893051,
-0.5589970946311951,
-0.3765782117843628,
-0.3435989022254944,
0.3744598925113678,
0.44475889205932617,
-0.4910542368888855,
0.3335728943347931,
-0.27502667903900146,
-0.47184768319129944,
-0.6628484725952148,
0.17021702229976654,
0.3234345614910126,
0.39152342081069946,
0.15651430189609528,
-0.028563739731907845,
-0.49959611892700195,
-1.02704656124115,
-0.13155193626880646,
-0.07022074609994888,
-0.29755741357803345,
0.4469034671783447,
0.44544240832328796,
-0.664878249168396,
0.685664176940918,
-0.513164758682251,
-0.24660490453243256,
-0.41576334834098816,
-0.26322951912879944,
0.26327064633369446,
0.18951021134853363,
0.6345410943031311,
-0.5789262056350708,
-0.3252279460430145,
0.10639455914497375,
-0.7805050015449524,
0.001263295765966177,
0.17268554866313934,
0.1882704347372055,
0.1330959051847458,
0.3944131135940552,
-0.4768325388431549,
-0.05476978048682213,
0.881639838218689,
-0.04199744388461113,
0.5340569019317627,
-0.33293694257736206,
0.03464515879750252,
-1.0640677213668823,
0.390083372592926,
0.12121106684207916,
-0.2784528136253357,
-0.6202172040939331,
0.11301381886005402,
-0.08291694521903992,
-0.1783214807510376,
-0.3455861508846283,
0.8645277619361877,
-0.6615874171257019,
-0.03135871887207031,
-0.2531615197658539,
-0.006732703186571598,
-0.3588620126247406,
-0.019711850211024284,
0.030785951763391495,
0.5819398164749146,
0.7749050855636597,
-0.5877971649169922,
0.48193612694740295,
0.22329801321029663,
-0.5607267618179321,
0.5624306797981262,
-0.7148545980453491,
0.20728053152561188,
-0.09535481780767441,
0.04404174163937569,
-0.6079040169715881,
-0.3722211420536041,
0.2637704610824585,
-0.2112738937139511,
0.31416094303131104,
-0.12458740919828415,
-0.5876233577728271,
-0.6154218316078186,
-0.09999529272317886,
0.26916638016700745,
0.5962617993354797,
-0.37782952189445496,
0.367328405380249,
0.5844779014587402,
-0.2931731939315796,
-0.46779879927635193,
-0.7034342288970947,
0.19066770374774933,
-0.036328624933958054,
-0.4411725699901581,
-0.11391628533601761,
-0.09825488179922104,
-0.3920272886753082,
-0.1558998078107834,
0.2336094081401825,
-0.23650211095809937,
0.09043771028518677,
0.36976364254951477,
0.29480594396591187,
-0.15170711278915405,
0.39699798822402954,
-0.1444518268108368,
0.051194917410612106,
0.21808257699012756,
-0.11731739342212677,
0.6966375708580017,
0.08309609442949295,
-0.6881820559501648,
-0.18225744366645813,
0.4739106595516205,
0.41136810183525085,
-0.15168684720993042,
0.5996113419532776,
0.23304115235805511,
-0.37429651618003845,
-0.12128794193267822,
-0.7569435834884644,
-0.0319044403731823,
-0.39897048473358154,
0.6563248038291931,
0.057649314403533936,
-1.1033726930618286,
0.22962571680545807,
-0.3954489231109619,
0.18533368408679962,
0.27779054641723633,
1.1284208297729492,
0.1228533536195755,
0.9579083919525146,
0.5323345065116882,
-0.3130730390548706,
0.06610340625047684,
-0.12301138043403625,
0.1336946338415146,
-0.7334322333335876,
-0.2495121955871582,
-0.501318097114563,
-0.07696208357810974,
-0.33201801776885986,
-0.450693279504776,
0.49882271885871887,
-0.2821071445941925,
-0.12173047661781311,
-0.23800532519817352,
-0.5235210657119751,
0.39203280210494995,
0.11617715656757355,
-0.07030966132879257,
0.33672282099723816,
0.05692166090011597,
-0.10073422640562057,
0.07870272547006607,
-0.4537982642650604,
-0.49564823508262634,
1.3695192337036133,
0.7278532981872559,
0.9104973673820496,
-0.1639944463968277,
0.583543598651886,
-0.025119030848145485,
0.5247724056243896,
-0.9646337628364563,
0.45838168263435364,
-0.3750162422657013,
-0.6409613490104675,
-0.24190954864025116,
-0.4505975544452667,
-1.1589837074279785,
0.07521893829107285,
0.014733098447322845,
-0.6037213206291199,
-0.25776639580726624,
-0.021263038739562035,
-0.2631029188632965,
0.27120402455329895,
-0.6114844679832458,
0.6242761611938477,
-0.3074752390384674,
0.03820176422595978,
-0.19541682302951813,
-0.6328815221786499,
0.43437713384628296,
-0.27087274193763733,
0.2557663321495056,
-0.02819594368338585,
-0.13892778754234314,
0.6058759093284607,
-0.25140005350112915,
0.7903079986572266,
-0.287405401468277,
-0.2558838725090027,
0.11747538298368454,
-0.34461820125579834,
0.08353544026613235,
0.0976380854845047,
-0.1444627344608307,
0.1778564602136612,
-0.03991840407252312,
-0.13490422070026398,
-0.3617350459098816,
0.7250820994377136,
-0.704043984413147,
-0.4915379583835602,
-0.28712254762649536,
-0.586753249168396,
-0.8501627445220947,
0.07414524257183075,
0.16034962236881256,
0.4228305220603943,
-0.5399491786956787,
0.19026093184947968,
0.727669894695282,
-0.5305023789405823,
0.03855350986123085,
0.6859293580055237,
-0.47851547598838806,
-0.3954664170742035,
0.37789392471313477,
-0.03197522088885307,
0.2798070013523102,
0.27493953704833984,
0.22703644633293152,
-0.36973047256469727,
-0.9554734230041504,
-0.5460903644561768,
0.5387753248214722,
-0.5185635685920715,
0.0010955892503261566,
-0.5194745063781738,
-0.48628470301628113,
-0.3507470488548279,
0.02478208765387535,
-0.3217225968837738,
0.07191890478134155,
-0.19151310622692108,
0.05602512136101723,
0.4139161705970764,
1.0614843368530273,
0.33474308252334595,
0.2690035402774811,
-0.7987030744552612,
0.40157702565193176,
0.20381951332092285,
0.7498879432678223,
-0.033469706773757935,
-0.24429753422737122,
-0.35746994614601135,
-0.02002795599400997,
0.02293788641691208,
-0.6248036026954651,
0.2411952018737793,
0.09765959531068802,
0.7441515922546387,
0.46048372983932495,
-0.34610989689826965,
0.33852460980415344,
-0.8254359364509583,
0.7947670221328735,
0.4757229685783386,
-0.4138036072254181,
0.32230645418167114,
-0.3830414414405823,
0.17128705978393555,
0.4841427505016327,
0.6965978741645813,
-0.7051581740379333,
-0.16352935135364532,
-0.10214579105377197,
-0.6005516052246094,
0.267441987991333,
-0.23552465438842773,
0.267973393201828,
-0.06346197426319122,
0.585260808467865,
0.07936161756515503,
0.21020662784576416,
-0.3186049461364746,
-0.13609570264816284,
0.5262079834938049,
-0.40288498997688293,
-0.22978617250919342,
-0.23281444609165192,
-0.4438970685005188,
-0.2106366604566574,
0.31435543298721313,
-0.040769319981336594,
0.3827929198741913,
0.07479862123727798,
0.04041357338428497,
0.016575274989008904,
0.5005117654800415,
0.5288313627243042,
0.7527340054512024,
-0.01601012423634529,
-0.1950249969959259,
0.07365316152572632,
-0.7707600593566895,
0.2561729848384857,
-0.007675988599658012,
0.16688740253448486,
0.0649559274315834,
0.2573834955692291,
0.6937316060066223,
0.19325600564479828,
-1.0393269062042236,
0.6679282188415527,
-0.11927375197410583,
-0.38630297780036926,
-0.36304739117622375,
-0.013961086980998516,
0.3914375901222229,
0.035792961716651917,
0.057863105088472366,
-0.46701812744140625,
0.10283631831407547,
-0.5950765609741211,
-0.15151043236255646,
0.5728097558021545,
-0.2545697093009949,
-0.19279687106609344,
0.5014265179634094,
0.08910556882619858,
-0.13796910643577576,
0.5290248394012451,
0.12440710514783859,
-0.1244484931230545,
0.2634682357311249,
0.5828071236610413,
0.7561681270599365,
-0.30814993381500244,
-0.10064169019460678,
0.09783534705638885,
0.013307425193488598,
-0.2493492215871811,
0.4506140947341919,
0.4583803713321686,
-0.5034546256065369,
-0.6809465885162354,
-0.7150033712387085,
-0.7992160320281982,
0.6273908019065857,
-0.42569002509117126,
0.371294766664505,
-0.6857931613922119,
-0.20929361879825592,
-0.01364864781498909,
-0.11629902571439743,
-0.8111505508422852,
0.3898327946662903,
0.23766835033893585,
0.8627374172210693,
-0.5421300530433655,
0.9237291812896729,
0.913492739200592,
-0.11684422940015793,
-0.5850720405578613,
-0.36071446537971497,
0.004947632551193237,
-1.0042442083358765,
0.4346923530101776,
-0.10214829444885254,
0.1589210033416748,
-0.36531275510787964,
-0.6817293167114258,
-0.49140608310699463,
0.7199118733406067,
0.429402619600296,
-0.9221795797348022,
-0.4294925630092621,
0.4978042244911194,
0.8000240325927734,
-0.49438974261283875,
0.13932624459266663,
0.5797134637832642,
0.17611300945281982,
-0.1155276671051979,
-1.117146611213684,
-0.13977421820163727,
-0.227511465549469,
0.08804704248905182,
0.15469013154506683,
-0.41535523533821106,
0.7001262307167053,
-0.07994245737791061,
0.08636275678873062,
0.4149779677391052,
0.010003466159105301,
0.35107505321502686,
0.10741721838712692,
0.3322901427745819,
0.48483598232269287,
0.726404070854187,
0.08641372621059418,
1.3335177898406982,
-0.4898110628128052,
0.18908634781837463,
0.893416166305542,
-0.5250113606452942,
0.7216147780418396,
0.3204663097858429,
-0.21863429248332977,
0.2005557417869568,
0.4555681645870209,
-0.23684220016002655,
0.156281515955925,
0.615637481212616,
-0.3667740821838379,
-0.12295148521661758,
-0.03796917572617531,
-0.6101009249687195,
0.26639506220817566,
0.6127271056175232,
-0.7685000896453857,
-0.1267954707145691,
0.2203625589609146,
0.09194431453943253,
0.06637664139270782,
-0.47109729051589966,
0.7633684277534485,
0.4145416021347046,
-0.36531150341033936,
0.598779022693634,
0.06519186496734619,
0.5653923749923706,
-0.9565639495849609,
0.15827950835227966,
0.11213283240795135,
0.20995484292507172,
-0.16128456592559814,
-0.5948109030723572,
0.09055355191230774,
0.19929134845733643,
-0.11396494507789612,
-0.1060088723897934,
0.7017748951911926,
-0.1857215315103531,
-0.4189176559448242,
0.23260140419006348,
0.5392588376998901,
0.34975165128707886,
-0.037086330354213715,
-0.37994953989982605,
0.09723669290542603,
-0.26452237367630005,
-0.24113190174102783,
0.5442594289779663,
0.3375689387321472,
0.007181480992585421,
0.7357803583145142,
0.5381780862808228,
0.6090872883796692,
-0.06059475988149643,
0.47048091888427734,
0.9060056805610657,
-0.6844642162322998,
-0.27159932255744934,
-0.7814209461212158,
0.14822237193584442,
0.048939306288957596,
-0.32667121291160583,
0.5031545162200928,
0.6275730729103088,
0.48008012771606445,
-0.28888601064682007,
0.949378490447998,
0.46377071738243103,
0.9214880466461182,
-0.5822444558143616,
0.8389055728912354,
-0.4019489586353302,
0.12081529200077057,
-0.03831366077065468,
-0.7591695189476013,
-0.5933810472488403,
0.3521707057952881,
-0.5847872495651245,
0.06747819483280182,
0.5643091797828674,
0.39759767055511475,
0.0393931046128273,
0.03026447258889675,
0.4726528823375702,
0.16023069620132446,
0.437558650970459,
0.634538471698761,
0.8779303431510925,
-0.014236862771213055,
0.061917006969451904,
0.19725285470485687,
-0.18375562131404877,
-0.2870813310146332,
-0.5973000526428223,
-0.9856449961662292,
-0.18308474123477936,
-0.13545818626880646,
0.07788554579019547,
0.1661914587020874,
1.1032565832138062,
0.7377399206161499,
-0.7958944439888,
-0.2781563997268677,
0.20737560093402863,
-0.5130857825279236,
0.2457590103149414,
-0.06929218769073486,
0.38451746106147766,
-0.296329528093338,
-0.7816568613052368,
0.5537933111190796,
0.23180772364139557,
0.042952053248882294,
-0.5703920125961304,
-0.06175621226429939,
0.004035434685647488,
-0.05917007476091385,
0.5985231995582581,
0.34225183725357056,
-0.721444308757782,
-0.18357805907726288,
0.01593872718513012,
-0.33419230580329895,
0.09149285405874252,
0.9183902740478516,
-0.6029436588287354,
0.36749207973480225,
0.15269334614276886,
0.9830905199050903,
0.22883570194244385,
-0.24531786143779755,
0.6217047572135925,
-0.4104519486427307,
0.1785910576581955,
0.4819507896900177,
0.5081091523170471,
0.37804311513900757,
-0.23051241040229797,
0.5952937602996826,
-0.05809922516345978,
-0.8441083431243896,
-0.7868085503578186,
0.10551426559686661,
-0.8921377062797546,
-0.31606242060661316,
1.3935145139694214,
-0.09968645870685577,
-0.11560880392789841,
-0.27167561650276184,
-0.2498372495174408,
0.006980982609093189,
0.004319269210100174,
0.5245598554611206,
0.5256443619728088,
-0.25223803520202637,
0.20628198981285095,
-0.8891413807868958,
0.38657355308532715,
0.33114156126976013,
-0.9127677083015442,
-0.02033323608338833,
0.6096696853637695,
0.6185420155525208,
-0.09814060479402542,
0.9017322659492493,
-0.5343217849731445,
0.07513488829135895,
-0.4430423080921173,
0.17249765992164612,
-0.04923337697982788,
-0.19069355726242065,
-0.6663282513618469,
0.17349278926849365,
0.40095722675323486,
-0.1004142165184021
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09662v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09662v1
|
Learning Language Structures through Grounding
| 2024-06-14T02:21:53 | 2024-06-14T02:21:53 |
Freda Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
Language is highly structured, with syntactic and semantic structures, to
some extent, agreed upon by speakers of the same language. With implicit or
explicit awareness of such structures, humans can learn and use language
efficiently and generalize to sentences that contain unseen words. Motivated by
human language learning, in this dissertation, we consider a family of machine
learning tasks that aim to learn language structures through grounding. We seek
distant supervision from other data sources (i.e., grounds), including but not
limited to other modalities (e.g., vision), execution results of programs, and
other languages.
We demonstrate the potential of this task formulation and advocate for its
adoption through three schemes. In Part I, we consider learning syntactic
parses through visual grounding. We propose the task of visually grounded
grammar induction, present the first models to induce syntactic structures from
visually grounded text and speech, and find that the visual grounding signals
can help improve the parsing quality over language-only models. As a side
contribution, we propose a novel evaluation metric that enables the evaluation
of speech parsing without text or automatic speech recognition systems
involved. In Part II, we propose two execution-aware methods to map sentences
into corresponding semantic structures (i.e., programs), significantly
improving compositional generalization and few-shot program synthesis. In Part
III, we propose methods that learn language structures from annotations in
other languages. Specifically, we propose a method that sets a new state of the
art on cross-lingual word alignment. We then leverage the learned word
alignments to improve the performance of zero-shot cross-lingual dependency
parsing, by proposing a novel substructure-based projection method that
preserves structural knowledge learned from the source language.
|
[
0.05074942484498024,
-1.00089430809021,
0.6246456503868103,
0.24553276598453522,
-0.07317796349525452,
0.03565486520528793,
-0.3847866952419281,
-0.20208661258220673,
0.0638810321688652,
0.23015354573726654,
-0.12444291263818741,
-0.7697250843048096,
-0.5531070828437805,
-0.20728854835033417,
-0.27494028210639954,
0.4135896563529968,
-0.09101223200559616,
0.21840432286262512,
-0.24231672286987305,
-0.14080317318439484,
-0.6056815385818481,
-0.5182799696922302,
-0.25099602341651917,
-0.49596333503723145,
0.20308272540569305,
0.4349202811717987,
0.5648694634437561,
1.0360957384109497,
0.15793511271476746,
0.38132795691490173,
-0.03208905830979347,
-0.089337058365345,
-0.3160197138786316,
0.000011428626748966053,
-0.27443209290504456,
-0.7150394916534424,
0.11777108907699585,
0.025908522307872772,
0.7732223272323608,
1.3455650806427002,
0.08316678553819656,
-0.016252096742391586,
0.01082686334848404,
0.9184293746948242,
-0.640938937664032,
0.7684369087219238,
-0.5511667132377625,
0.33091628551483154,
-0.0847012996673584,
-0.13284093141555786,
-0.4206026792526245,
-0.08419718593358994,
0.03245477005839348,
-0.4694388806819916,
0.050522949546575546,
-0.04870573431253433,
0.8407799601554871,
0.4262542426586151,
-0.06599237024784088,
-0.1994619071483612,
-0.3149681091308594,
0.7059302926063538,
-0.20316541194915771,
0.81285160779953,
0.5627849698066711,
0.21329578757286072,
-0.20415371656417847,
-0.5478647947311401,
-0.23859287798404694,
-0.3618905246257782,
-0.11877450346946716,
0.21194672584533691,
-0.0030077521223574877,
0.13994185626506805,
0.42676466703414917,
0.39413201808929443,
-0.5161212086677551,
-0.06325220316648483,
-0.2538391947746277,
0.012571458704769611,
0.01888410747051239,
-0.1062953919172287,
0.5985508561134338,
-0.25479939579963684,
-0.12854143977165222,
-0.11631853133440018,
-0.5936418771743774,
0.1979655921459198,
0.12710876762866974,
0.43149492144584656,
-0.3331854045391083,
0.7004910111427307,
-0.49635016918182373,
0.720228374004364,
0.006526859477162361,
-0.024571074172854424,
0.21544602513313293,
0.08058174699544907,
-0.45757636427879333,
0.14223523437976837,
0.3749088943004608,
0.20000308752059937,
0.43822136521339417,
-0.3806867003440857,
0.16408033668994904,
0.5991755127906799,
0.1512400060892105,
-0.2235211730003357,
-0.38253673911094666,
0.04838085174560547,
-0.48295751214027405,
-0.32751187682151794,
0.12843912839889526,
-0.3932059109210968,
-0.18271663784980774,
-0.7337640523910522,
0.11502810567617416,
-0.6446818709373474,
-0.1435595154762268,
0.05325578898191452,
-0.29480183124542236,
0.47800174355506897,
0.20314058661460876,
-0.9368161559104919,
0.3691242039203644,
0.6607226133346558,
0.6773170828819275,
0.20217442512512207,
-0.6397994756698608,
-0.7158759236335754,
0.3086218237876892,
-0.5374190211296082,
0.678067684173584,
-0.5063643455505371,
-0.03133513405919075,
-0.010243398137390614,
0.08008190244436264,
-0.020258402451872826,
-0.4994889497756958,
0.3553480803966522,
-0.32218697667121887,
0.22417351603507996,
-0.25005143880844116,
-0.43660756945610046,
-0.3400857150554657,
0.269866406917572,
-0.35483941435813904,
0.9131556153297424,
0.14578533172607422,
-0.7522902488708496,
0.390102744102478,
-0.29573705792427063,
-0.7444327473640442,
-0.00633337814360857,
-0.595483124256134,
-0.20686210691928864,
0.40102535486221313,
0.3065999150276184,
0.5316866636276245,
0.14828963577747345,
0.4011338949203491,
0.008395818993449211,
-0.2730787396430969,
-0.4517206847667694,
0.08085659146308899,
0.8237205743789673,
-0.016940688714385033,
-0.7389747500419617,
0.1993110030889511,
-0.9396961331367493,
0.11039984226226807,
0.2622385323047638,
-0.30734071135520935,
-0.42018795013427734,
0.2345617562532425,
-0.23595677316188812,
0.1855746954679489,
-0.0421135388314724,
-0.12113083153963089,
-0.036542318761348724,
-0.7701300382614136,
0.3640793263912201,
0.5348581075668335,
-0.15985246002674103,
0.6591278314590454,
0.014176255092024803,
0.2546524405479431,
0.12284776568412781,
-0.31706348061561584,
-0.5955814123153687,
-0.27842530608177185,
-1.0610171556472778,
-0.01672236993908882,
0.08140715211629868,
0.833440363407135,
-0.7504065632820129,
0.6099147200584412,
-0.1335655152797699,
-0.2089177668094635,
-0.2925374209880829,
0.22820691764354706,
0.7033076882362366,
0.7074254155158997,
0.4301009178161621,
-0.16822053492069244,
-0.8160542249679565,
-0.8448271751403809,
-0.3893606662750244,
-0.3504905104637146,
0.29341810941696167,
0.0810309574007988,
0.19430075585842133,
-0.10839346796274185,
0.8343906998634338,
-0.4133172035217285,
-0.19017791748046875,
-0.38224318623542786,
0.13677087426185608,
0.11383610963821411,
0.5608559250831604,
0.3551170527935028,
-0.6837805509567261,
-0.4810626804828644,
0.2356007695198059,
-1.2802200317382812,
-0.23523899912834167,
-0.022617287933826447,
-0.046355340629816055,
0.12102887034416199,
0.7584086060523987,
-0.5127020478248596,
0.1955624371767044,
0.3849482238292694,
-0.14684073626995087,
0.21776221692562103,
0.02068045735359192,
-0.16462911665439606,
-0.926280677318573,
-0.044870756566524506,
-0.022483041509985924,
-0.4116401970386505,
-0.5732779502868652,
0.24662017822265625,
-0.050016600638628006,
-0.3060098886489868,
-0.5479956269264221,
0.2676446735858917,
-0.7602717280387878,
-0.3171617388725281,
-0.239339679479599,
0.06893797963857651,
-0.12835156917572021,
0.6734941005706787,
0.23624275624752045,
0.4727112948894501,
0.9205218553543091,
-0.31816792488098145,
0.1538034975528717,
0.2721948027610779,
-0.3097480833530426,
0.2695187032222748,
-0.3941631317138672,
0.0785779356956482,
-0.6064087748527527,
-0.056006282567977905,
-0.8785911798477173,
-0.3173913061618805,
0.3547402024269104,
-0.48898613452911377,
0.18613466620445251,
-0.4054669737815857,
-0.23761846125125885,
0.18743756413459778,
-0.0323142483830452,
0.05104094371199608,
0.5563321113586426,
-0.5404518842697144,
0.4431399703025818,
0.5166755318641663,
0.05803091078996658,
-0.42574793100357056,
-0.6226939558982849,
0.3261621594429016,
-0.15471956133842468,
-0.6174976229667664,
0.12212886661291122,
0.5075697898864746,
-0.6390088200569153,
0.12786400318145752,
-0.15321314334869385,
0.07120174914598465,
0.3074222803115845,
0.608439564704895,
-0.19390180706977844,
-0.33679503202438354,
0.07627344131469727,
-0.017492186278104782,
-0.3174392282962799,
-0.006038820371031761,
-0.7416171431541443,
0.44532766938209534,
-0.37631291151046753,
-0.27687445282936096,
-0.4661564230918884,
0.4289800822734833,
0.30407607555389404,
-0.20622694492340088,
0.573469340801239,
0.3961772918701172,
-0.611579954624176,
-0.2922559082508087,
-0.46740177273750305,
0.13508373498916626,
-0.3950844407081604,
0.1649649292230606,
-0.7042012214660645,
-0.7760317325592041,
0.17097994685173035,
-0.24382427334785461,
-0.28008654713630676,
0.343440979719162,
0.657738208770752,
-0.1237369105219841,
0.8265731930732727,
1.0798454284667969,
-0.2319122552871704,
0.7684447169303894,
-0.16477462649345398,
0.050419338047504425,
-0.2648550570011139,
-0.12773898243904114,
-0.42583444714546204,
-0.0726202055811882,
-0.2960641086101532,
-0.46997153759002686,
0.035894494503736496,
0.6094657778739929,
0.24609273672103882,
0.4784601032733917,
-0.20748665928840637,
0.6601192355155945,
0.6507348418235779,
0.07277567684650421,
0.07038388401269913,
0.4024668037891388,
-0.5213791131973267,
-0.13194969296455383,
-0.5972415208816528,
-0.5907582640647888,
0.5298852324485779,
0.34818655252456665,
0.5522196292877197,
-0.3922443389892578,
0.6881822943687439,
0.1374489665031433,
0.00218917615711689,
-0.8268185257911682,
0.34257054328918457,
-0.11574362963438034,
0.03472532704472542,
-0.21861612796783447,
-0.32339951395988464,
-0.45059001445770264,
0.5465717911720276,
0.01247592456638813,
-0.6523928046226501,
0.06900125741958618,
0.11090713739395142,
0.23444215953350067,
-0.016083259135484695,
-1.109352946281433,
0.9182310104370117,
-0.2914428412914276,
-0.3591238856315613,
-0.04268847033381462,
-0.9803142547607422,
0.17615444958209991,
0.343766987323761,
0.25570666790008545,
0.13251779973506927,
0.3880568742752075,
0.4050081968307495,
-0.1383558213710785,
1.166013240814209,
-0.426907479763031,
-0.1359807401895523,
0.15450242161750793,
-0.04539954289793968,
0.29083094000816345,
-0.05900126323103905,
0.06906289607286453,
0.2053128033876419,
-0.3336753249168396,
-0.49020829796791077,
-0.6196696162223816,
0.3965158760547638,
-0.5739185214042664,
-0.5056630969047546,
-0.19355301558971405,
-0.29562047123908997,
-0.25623849034309387,
0.5929551720619202,
0.09356535971164703,
0.3241206109523773,
-0.2646840214729309,
0.11404070258140564,
0.4839266538619995,
-0.18558600544929504,
0.16759225726127625,
0.08810684829950333,
-0.14537657797336578,
-0.46147873997688293,
0.9069459438323975,
-0.13929103314876556,
-0.004441746044903994,
0.8662077784538269,
0.255642831325531,
-0.06529431790113449,
-0.4934609830379486,
-0.3662121891975403,
0.1875048279762268,
-0.9879920482635498,
0.2089802771806717,
-0.8462679386138916,
-0.022177617996931076,
-0.5759708881378174,
-0.36232084035873413,
-0.16581828892230988,
-0.5211620330810547,
-0.15749868750572205,
-0.41489729285240173,
-0.2603587806224823,
0.5153248906135559,
0.05075501278042793,
0.28290224075317383,
-0.42866334319114685,
0.6293808221817017,
0.0842791423201561,
0.2556309103965759,
-0.2951657772064209,
0.012260622344911098,
-0.21968165040016174,
-0.03468013554811478,
-0.12661577761173248,
-0.6339895129203796,
0.15187115967273712,
0.26356804370880127,
0.6541581153869629,
0.24546164274215698,
-0.415211945772171,
0.9534612894058228,
-0.9117697477340698,
0.615807294845581,
0.15463626384735107,
-1.1582956314086914,
0.9443826079368591,
-0.3018735647201538,
0.12024036049842834,
0.5489935278892517,
0.19044779241085052,
-0.5619990825653076,
-0.42010176181793213,
-0.5236690044403076,
-0.5790050625801086,
0.58536297082901,
0.10831709206104279,
-0.06297500431537628,
-0.1813766211271286,
0.38969042897224426,
-0.07206374406814575,
0.20868328213691711,
-0.887523353099823,
-0.062123674899339676,
-0.39380255341529846,
-0.3067731261253357,
-0.2072429209947586,
-0.07347941398620605,
-0.15078094601631165,
-0.24382667243480682,
0.2992995083332062,
-0.4045441448688507,
-0.015507114119827747,
0.1503114402294159,
-0.7553249001502991,
-0.13782203197479248,
0.2103840857744217,
0.508167028427124,
0.5674421191215515,
0.11454802751541138,
0.6713411211967468,
-0.002084107371047139,
-0.06041409820318222,
0.05806881561875343,
-0.2291846126317978,
-0.13919690251350403,
-0.020531082525849342,
0.6439809203147888,
0.938503623008728,
0.4085158109664917,
-0.6434521079063416,
0.44321873784065247,
0.271073579788208,
-0.19614900648593903,
-0.21880021691322327,
-0.013196241110563278,
-0.027265647426247597,
0.2737104296684265,
-0.09735896438360214,
-0.16899287700653076,
-0.036374546587467194,
-0.7779272794723511,
0.4170243442058563,
0.3584444224834442,
-0.4432370066642761,
-0.47298455238342285,
0.5733696818351746,
-0.0907520055770874,
-0.18221518397331238,
0.40179434418678284,
0.0944320484995842,
-0.7044125199317932,
0.43790432810783386,
0.8255236744880676,
0.8932194709777832,
-0.039944566786289215,
0.05537248030304909,
0.03000502660870552,
0.4126863181591034,
-0.11391930282115936,
0.3873322010040283,
-0.3977868854999542,
-0.7114247679710388,
-0.42488980293273926,
-0.7092944979667664,
-0.40494105219841003,
-0.1684952676296234,
-0.39228788018226624,
0.47051000595092773,
-0.6117554903030396,
0.30943119525909424,
-0.12007828056812286,
-0.14205706119537354,
-0.321329802274704,
0.28580501675605774,
0.44288408756256104,
0.6225863099098206,
-1.2098593711853027,
0.7405489683151245,
1.158067226409912,
-0.45596495270729065,
-0.7098947763442993,
-0.03221011534333229,
-0.0811033844947815,
-0.7427815198898315,
0.9701981544494629,
0.4760493040084839,
-0.17917805910110474,
0.17539413273334503,
-0.5219331383705139,
-0.6504862904548645,
0.5726878643035889,
0.5892314314842224,
0.036396320909261703,
-0.2732183635234833,
0.1709374487400055,
0.5220221281051636,
-0.19583158195018768,
-0.26333025097846985,
0.3797384798526764,
0.27780506014823914,
-0.1928531378507614,
-0.41935452818870544,
-0.0035269504878669977,
-0.2842930853366852,
0.02607162669301033,
0.15572655200958252,
-0.36459147930145264,
0.6287208199501038,
0.09320715069770813,
-0.5430362820625305,
-0.14028792083263397,
0.7243345379829407,
0.19592294096946716,
0.13872136175632477,
0.39512965083122253,
0.974348247051239,
0.5222183465957642,
-0.1361067146062851,
0.7818308472633362,
-0.15263216197490692,
0.08928847312927246,
0.9579319953918457,
-0.3377179503440857,
0.6394960880279541,
0.5910515189170837,
-0.03747539967298508,
0.5698755383491516,
0.2239244133234024,
0.086717389523983,
0.5944163799285889,
0.291027694940567,
0.07945531606674194,
-0.22026433050632477,
-0.19896025955677032,
-0.20173785090446472,
0.6184627413749695,
0.45039623975753784,
-0.4090062379837036,
-0.6544597148895264,
0.06934963911771774,
-0.3639054298400879,
0.4573606848716736,
-0.025597872212529182,
0.9087032079696655,
0.23615306615829468,
-0.4191133379936218,
0.6088733077049255,
0.2244180142879486,
0.11456037312746048,
-0.34928807616233826,
-0.4246774911880493,
0.006201836746186018,
0.06908657401800156,
-0.3818235993385315,
-0.22321002185344696,
0.5242247581481934,
-0.06935063004493713,
-0.35886844992637634,
-0.59799724817276,
0.7906292676925659,
-0.403912216424942,
-0.3903636336326599,
0.3699500560760498,
0.5204304456710815,
0.2567019760608673,
0.061943065375089645,
-0.5073524713516235,
0.16672469675540924,
-0.29344555735588074,
0.07483547180891037,
0.2532140016555786,
0.45821917057037354,
-0.35667431354522705,
0.42307332158088684,
0.7460550665855408,
0.2305654138326645,
0.3870684504508972,
0.2710229158401489,
0.8261022567749023,
-0.9099623560905457,
-0.8224213719367981,
-0.8946263790130615,
0.4577624797821045,
0.10360946506261826,
0.036913543939590454,
0.7845844030380249,
0.6044950485229492,
1.1105713844299316,
-0.12167661637067795,
0.7406527400016785,
-0.11993298679590225,
0.21966950595378876,
-0.965632438659668,
0.36679884791374207,
-0.14567327499389648,
-0.16606971621513367,
-0.49805983901023865,
-0.9724987149238586,
-0.7093393802642822,
0.9296219944953918,
-0.36570268869400024,
-0.4154975712299347,
0.8199004530906677,
0.41571012139320374,
-0.0803346037864685,
-0.1535697877407074,
0.5201631784439087,
0.0010424806969240308,
0.30847635865211487,
0.3262941241264343,
0.9561976194381714,
-0.30069461464881897,
-0.02887994423508644,
-0.47725003957748413,
-0.3663615882396698,
0.1666710078716278,
-0.7655799388885498,
-1.1431571245193481,
-0.4827991724014282,
-0.15678654611110687,
-0.09837687760591507,
0.29909947514533997,
0.8605813384056091,
0.8069782257080078,
-0.7992551922798157,
-0.36982545256614685,
-0.7337605357170105,
0.2459864616394043,
-0.24483977258205414,
-0.226864755153656,
0.4592178463935852,
-0.9335141777992249,
-0.6610289812088013,
1.0227354764938354,
0.562323808670044,
-0.09269563108682632,
0.03349706158041954,
0.21112732589244843,
-0.19406214356422424,
-0.5772162079811096,
0.8520131707191467,
0.3834529519081116,
-0.960773229598999,
-0.3411322832107544,
-0.07170919328927994,
-0.06810985505580902,
0.185860276222229,
0.8406217694282532,
-0.9155235290527344,
0.14072999358177185,
0.5481454133987427,
1.048424243927002,
0.11222963035106659,
0.31278568506240845,
0.6315092444419861,
-1.0443243980407715,
0.5280365347862244,
-0.058133769780397415,
0.5360971689224243,
0.35762569308280945,
-0.31403225660324097,
0.4799124598503113,
0.5043933987617493,
-0.0262388177216053,
-0.7373401522636414,
0.34718063473701477,
-0.743647575378418,
-0.17512594163417816,
0.9287857413291931,
-0.09205701947212219,
-0.38643139600753784,
-0.10940844565629959,
-0.2207205891609192,
0.5650235414505005,
0.13371285796165466,
0.5304746031761169,
0.7218853831291199,
0.07496360689401627,
-0.3536221385002136,
-0.34000566601753235,
0.30399563908576965,
0.5775216221809387,
-0.883885383605957,
0.13454017043113708,
0.6691252589225769,
0.24783803522586823,
0.32173383235931396,
0.4761399030685425,
-0.17933355271816254,
0.1308814138174057,
-0.002797258784994483,
0.0364101342856884,
-0.05663145333528519,
-0.6817463636398315,
-0.7123736143112183,
0.42383596301078796,
-0.007919172756373882,
-0.2594849765300751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09618v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09618v1
|
Multi-Modal Retrieval For Large Language Model Based Speech Recognition
| 2024-06-13T22:55:22 | 2024-06-13T22:55:22 |
Jari Kolehmainen, Aditya Gourav, Prashanth Gurunath Shivakumar, Yile Gu, Ankur Gandhe, Ariya Rastrow, Grant Strimel, Ivan Bulyko
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Retrieval is a widely adopted approach for improving language models
leveraging external information. As the field moves towards multi-modal large
language models, it is important to extend the pure text based methods to
incorporate other modalities in retrieval as well for applications across the
wide spectrum of machine learning tasks and data types. In this work, we
propose multi-modal retrieval with two approaches: kNN-LM and cross-attention
techniques. We demonstrate the effectiveness of our retrieval approaches
empirically by applying them to automatic speech recognition tasks with access
to external information. Under this setting, we show that speech-based
multi-modal retrieval outperforms text based retrieval, and yields up to 50 %
improvement in word error rate over the multi-modal language model baseline.
Furthermore, we achieve state-of-the-art recognition results on the
Spoken-Squad question answering dataset.
|
[
-0.27032122015953064,
-0.8751980662345886,
0.6219726204872131,
-0.009441845118999481,
-0.24684332311153412,
0.017662223428487778,
-0.4790920317173004,
-0.6561324000358582,
0.11509544402360916,
0.30998358130455017,
-0.3180766999721527,
-0.11704975366592407,
-0.48817503452301025,
0.08208048343658447,
-0.3433433771133423,
0.4888986647129059,
0.11382187902927399,
0.34797534346580505,
-0.14193463325500488,
-0.29843151569366455,
-0.5981189012527466,
-0.8057710528373718,
-0.47155800461769104,
-0.2519190013408661,
0.7432600259780884,
-0.018222538754343987,
0.5666981935501099,
0.4646032750606537,
0.5376185178756714,
0.33343008160591125,
-0.010993445292115211,
0.07591063529253006,
-0.2590065896511078,
0.39691755175590515,
-0.00788991991430521,
-0.38981571793556213,
-0.13058985769748688,
-0.11208497732877731,
0.955979585647583,
0.49776801466941833,
-0.05196654796600342,
-0.04484311491250992,
-0.11439886689186096,
0.4473561644554138,
-0.7815716862678528,
0.345232754945755,
-0.7019442319869995,
0.02043413370847702,
-0.21771566569805145,
-0.23415949940681458,
-0.5098698139190674,
-0.04778055101633072,
0.35680535435676575,
-0.4279160499572754,
-0.0062077464535832405,
-0.04612504318356514,
0.26781198382377625,
-0.01054280437529087,
-0.6419106721878052,
-0.44425827264785767,
-0.7713968753814697,
1.0498478412628174,
-0.6151021122932434,
1.1612660884857178,
0.7707778215408325,
0.39097535610198975,
0.10640307515859604,
-0.43454480171203613,
-0.4615803062915802,
-0.6931917667388916,
0.003560704877600074,
0.22936110198497772,
0.05201051011681557,
0.059768255800008774,
0.1697181910276413,
0.1692223995923996,
-0.3732001483440399,
-0.12601976096630096,
-0.257508784532547,
-0.48776429891586304,
0.5006143450737,
-0.13694295287132263,
0.06889677792787552,
-0.2533380389213562,
-0.3542189598083496,
-0.2345491498708725,
-0.3820825219154358,
0.08112092316150665,
0.10351169854402542,
0.8134390711784363,
0.06506417691707611,
0.7295834422111511,
-0.29544368386268616,
0.7803935408592224,
-0.07491940259933472,
-0.25074273347854614,
0.3833037316799164,
-0.7825430631637573,
-0.1533140391111374,
0.07959070056676865,
0.5602032542228699,
0.09126487374305725,
-0.053665053099393845,
-0.38727954030036926,
-0.2176046371459961,
-0.22884102165699005,
0.23419643938541412,
-0.4641476571559906,
0.1143944263458252,
0.03156430274248123,
-0.5489091873168945,
0.17130503058433533,
0.0021917480044066906,
-0.6751677393913269,
-0.2817065417766571,
-0.6494789123535156,
0.8038822412490845,
-0.46020346879959106,
-0.3459171950817108,
-0.25349295139312744,
-0.11369654536247253,
0.34388116002082825,
0.4096262753009796,
-0.35009413957595825,
-0.12379142642021179,
0.4711390733718872,
0.7591220140457153,
-0.1052452027797699,
0.0033492925576865673,
-0.9535844326019287,
0.3341623544692993,
-0.07927647978067398,
0.5201500654220581,
-0.7967451810836792,
-0.40608489513397217,
-0.03659225255250931,
-0.05106174573302269,
-0.3901938498020172,
-0.5659149289131165,
0.5613313317298889,
-0.8550240397453308,
0.16536898910999298,
-0.3986540138721466,
-0.3831227719783783,
-0.46703019738197327,
0.31544601917266846,
-0.8699046969413757,
1.029384732246399,
-0.2684060037136078,
-0.41789862513542175,
0.06011737138032913,
-0.5938873291015625,
-0.6066009998321533,
-0.18278217315673828,
-0.06435234844684601,
-0.31240880489349365,
0.126146599650383,
0.08937912434339523,
0.45540130138397217,
-0.5048049092292786,
0.10064573585987091,
-0.34038105607032776,
-0.02558010071516037,
0.38489246368408203,
-0.5934264659881592,
0.37262094020843506,
0.04971424117684364,
-0.11624406278133392,
0.2161804586648941,
-0.7539310455322266,
0.19883336126804352,
-0.14025340974330902,
-0.7753185033798218,
-0.7241332530975342,
-0.060912854969501495,
0.3820219039916992,
0.5152468681335449,
0.19751796126365662,
-0.6941940784454346,
-0.14507657289505005,
-0.25692346692085266,
0.4349738359451294,
0.3595172166824341,
-0.15520937740802765,
0.42339304089546204,
-0.27939316630363464,
0.2893620729446411,
0.09875582903623581,
-0.017163164913654327,
-0.24285945296287537,
-0.4601248800754547,
-0.3882252275943756,
-0.4044567346572876,
0.41332048177719116,
0.6501718759536743,
-0.8402233719825745,
0.2486695647239685,
0.003802837571129203,
-0.38287436962127686,
-0.7164113521575928,
0.12257802486419678,
0.5215861797332764,
0.6183754205703735,
0.5834447741508484,
-0.13935592770576477,
-0.5338819622993469,
-0.8766583204269409,
-0.22645404934883118,
-0.06978318095207214,
0.04972798749804497,
0.8327944874763489,
0.19420991837978363,
-0.24631020426750183,
0.8079906105995178,
-0.1094028577208519,
-0.3112499415874481,
-0.34307077527046204,
0.1838328242301941,
-0.09641308337450027,
0.33291786909103394,
0.22400273382663727,
-1.2274401187896729,
-0.5059580206871033,
0.10216191411018372,
-0.39472249150276184,
0.22377872467041016,
0.0556291826069355,
0.15029826760292053,
0.2282833606004715,
0.40247437357902527,
-0.5983371138572693,
0.3106396794319153,
0.3793404996395111,
-0.016449594870209694,
0.3967805504798889,
-0.06125251576304436,
0.4201730191707611,
-1.0571563243865967,
0.4215230643749237,
-0.03541902080178261,
-0.5905782580375671,
-0.713947594165802,
0.012016895227134228,
0.3175060451030731,
-0.17764076590538025,
-0.4436935782432556,
0.487639456987381,
-0.5195292234420776,
-0.3251117169857025,
-0.3060036301612854,
0.3240075409412384,
-0.1562863141298294,
0.4704645574092865,
0.11134067922830582,
0.8214160203933716,
0.5875526666641235,
-0.7301778197288513,
0.6105164885520935,
0.049213260412216187,
-0.14684538543224335,
0.6149008274078369,
-0.6253026723861694,
0.3655165433883667,
-0.3787379264831543,
0.31161025166511536,
-1.231495976448059,
-0.06710591167211533,
0.17958644032478333,
-0.2667965888977051,
0.40588751435279846,
-0.16444894671440125,
-0.5399877429008484,
-0.09976080805063248,
-0.23788248002529144,
0.6658691167831421,
0.07547789067029953,
-0.48017799854278564,
0.9024495482444763,
0.4867384433746338,
-0.31371212005615234,
-0.4917776584625244,
-0.46044328808784485,
-0.03504011407494545,
-0.021395031362771988,
-0.17685529589653015,
0.22329367697238922,
-0.2965572476387024,
-0.04092779383063316,
-0.17852340638637543,
-0.2620418071746826,
-0.3659934401512146,
-0.22925925254821777,
0.018163839355111122,
0.23836830258369446,
-0.23424190282821655,
0.36658868193626404,
-0.38392409682273865,
0.051306724548339844,
-0.2618735134601593,
0.027081359177827835,
0.7034167647361755,
0.03418092429637909,
-0.4259738028049469,
-0.5105447173118591,
0.7342672348022461,
0.6501296162605286,
-0.5899028778076172,
0.49245908856391907,
0.7599948048591614,
-0.414313942193985,
0.25943779945373535,
-1.0069433450698853,
-0.29221799969673157,
-0.41068851947784424,
0.5990806818008423,
-0.45943495631217957,
-0.7336856126785278,
0.48943427205085754,
0.05257992818951607,
-0.2850519120693207,
0.35014617443084717,
0.5223349928855896,
-0.08340711891651154,
1.154568076133728,
0.43092262744903564,
-0.48916590213775635,
0.7467343807220459,
0.01403296459466219,
-0.028072627261281013,
-1.0415875911712646,
-0.5349465012550354,
-0.6526542901992798,
-0.33401814103126526,
-0.1535654067993164,
-0.6400174498558044,
0.509766161441803,
0.10316963493824005,
0.20008008182048798,
0.43983593583106995,
-0.14392730593681335,
0.12783724069595337,
0.7170823812484741,
0.5364586114883423,
0.5434935688972473,
-0.1319190412759781,
-0.20255272090435028,
0.0037666624411940575,
-0.6832960247993469,
0.11112615466117859,
1.0414553880691528,
0.17230594158172607,
0.7089393138885498,
0.20239700376987457,
0.35265645384788513,
0.13111527264118195,
0.15672515332698822,
-1.0286258459091187,
0.5004785060882568,
0.047953154891729355,
-0.6961244344711304,
-0.5277055501937866,
-0.7257280349731445,
-0.9180784821510315,
0.4928377866744995,
-0.10057137906551361,
-0.5082889199256897,
0.2387138158082962,
-0.11987984925508499,
-0.1736895740032196,
-0.027275623753666878,
-0.5764762759208679,
0.6538033485412598,
-0.29179173707962036,
-0.049597904086112976,
-0.6015521287918091,
-0.8177661299705505,
0.17991796135902405,
-0.2062779814004898,
0.1617259383201599,
0.06268078088760376,
-0.18225973844528198,
0.651360273361206,
0.012182613834738731,
0.669086754322052,
-0.2580052614212036,
-0.21336126327514648,
0.18049907684326172,
-0.2674892544746399,
0.616152822971344,
0.022545350715517998,
-0.3788037896156311,
-0.019643448293209076,
0.15154388546943665,
0.019523486495018005,
-0.6493175029754639,
0.6825545430183411,
-0.5131914019584656,
-0.21237929165363312,
-0.24857723712921143,
-1.0432735681533813,
-0.38211023807525635,
0.41303765773773193,
-0.20924565196037292,
0.9060482382774353,
-0.0639321357011795,
0.6933140754699707,
0.6651844382286072,
-0.1318998783826828,
0.7596050500869751,
0.713924765586853,
-0.005204229615628719,
-0.6013805270195007,
0.7731258273124695,
0.27870306372642517,
0.3762299418449402,
0.7049683332443237,
0.27138569951057434,
-0.7676074504852295,
-0.3041086494922638,
-0.5020142793655396,
0.18835118412971497,
-0.5278336405754089,
-0.3622874915599823,
-0.7044984698295593,
-0.12987428903579712,
-0.6677910089492798,
0.47101765871047974,
-0.3127569258213043,
-0.5186936855316162,
-0.14892224967479706,
0.3807668387889862,
0.25567108392715454,
0.40715786814689636,
-0.025089701637625694,
0.034291237592697144,
-1.0431445837020874,
0.7640441656112671,
0.38071128726005554,
0.40497031807899475,
0.07717069983482361,
-0.45793166756629944,
-0.2964480519294739,
0.2036953717470169,
-0.10586724430322647,
-1.0238953828811646,
0.1376405507326126,
0.4330093562602997,
0.8515244722366333,
0.009661559015512466,
0.11773039400577545,
0.580777645111084,
-0.6255035996437073,
0.3126058578491211,
0.1634046584367752,
-0.7895544171333313,
0.5261358022689819,
-0.2642870843410492,
0.5291885137557983,
0.5547912120819092,
0.4446326792240143,
-0.6610422134399414,
-0.07168616354465485,
-0.20529846847057343,
-0.774941623210907,
0.8096371293067932,
0.035655274987220764,
0.02395903319120407,
0.19933174550533295,
0.2987120747566223,
-0.020342547446489334,
0.43349459767341614,
-0.6388059854507446,
-0.1351412981748581,
-0.0623277984559536,
-0.28065457940101624,
-0.20769518613815308,
0.03225351870059967,
-0.13532665371894836,
-0.1379941701889038,
0.6954845190048218,
-0.2314370721578598,
0.4591231942176819,
0.33508703112602234,
-0.4617975652217865,
-0.0054687620140612125,
0.5396351218223572,
0.6735767126083374,
0.5428546071052551,
-0.11779948323965073,
0.025271983817219734,
0.22271546721458435,
-0.3740377128124237,
0.06246078386902809,
0.5755237340927124,
-0.030126478523015976,
0.24110442399978638,
0.10514989495277405,
0.6293289065361023,
0.504371166229248,
-0.8667579889297485,
0.5127271413803101,
0.21803180873394012,
0.17678605020046234,
-0.17201535403728485,
-0.29890599846839905,
-0.09914113581180573,
0.5989813208580017,
0.718471884727478,
-0.012744937092065811,
0.37993934750556946,
-0.9175201058387756,
0.38925960659980774,
0.839952826499939,
-0.5303367376327515,
-0.2081368863582611,
0.48993000388145447,
-0.022821076214313507,
-0.368245929479599,
0.3652385175228119,
0.1460782140493393,
-0.5812861919403076,
0.3880331814289093,
0.6717936992645264,
0.7503652572631836,
-0.49959686398506165,
0.005709653254598379,
0.17394644021987915,
0.05338791757822037,
-0.1588057577610016,
0.5342268943786621,
-0.3218748867511749,
-0.5079819560050964,
-0.5549554824829102,
-0.38224998116493225,
-0.4048367142677307,
0.19828620553016663,
-0.676034152507782,
0.011934389360249043,
-0.11267437040805817,
-0.2855410575866699,
-0.10000262409448624,
-0.037151992321014404,
-0.6821895241737366,
0.26074492931365967,
0.20191523432731628,
0.6338328123092651,
-0.32102054357528687,
0.8830013871192932,
0.748787522315979,
-0.4726105034351349,
-0.7348998188972473,
-0.007566358894109726,
-0.11645868420600891,
-0.6931244730949402,
0.8506957292556763,
0.15487046539783478,
-0.2597804665565491,
0.0018384043360128999,
0.02009539306163788,
-1.2460169792175293,
0.9566771388053894,
0.12777237594127655,
-0.5726612210273743,
-0.15687797963619232,
0.12409412115812302,
0.29841846227645874,
-0.06984181702136993,
0.3055843710899353,
0.11964301019906998,
0.5835359692573547,
0.004171141888946295,
-1.422195553779602,
0.04987826943397522,
0.07814158499240875,
-0.02760189212858677,
0.2699165642261505,
-0.6823746562004089,
0.5913917422294617,
0.007644626311957836,
-0.05109965056180954,
0.028352782130241394,
0.6239354610443115,
0.07913113385438919,
0.3826650083065033,
0.7466561794281006,
0.38822948932647705,
0.6444852948188782,
0.09369459003210068,
0.9759141206741333,
-0.23357756435871124,
0.2689809203147888,
0.9945576786994934,
-0.31069985032081604,
1.265589952468872,
0.45596545934677124,
-0.06371491402387619,
0.03264731913805008,
0.13301119208335876,
0.24044418334960938,
0.7533716559410095,
-0.1617807000875473,
-0.3028690218925476,
-0.25823965668678284,
-0.3346908390522003,
-0.4253441095352173,
0.6394408345222473,
0.17822448909282684,
-0.4005025327205658,
-0.26319748163223267,
0.5555729269981384,
-0.33309319615364075,
-0.1892831027507782,
-0.500203013420105,
1.0382468700408936,
0.00961250625550747,
-0.4217037260532379,
0.3978225290775299,
-0.018497437238693237,
0.6307989358901978,
-0.6773483157157898,
0.03262762725353241,
0.24391840398311615,
0.2642921209335327,
0.06632460653781891,
-0.35648781061172485,
0.1409536749124527,
-0.38064491748809814,
-0.45378515124320984,
-0.23047302663326263,
0.9509761929512024,
-0.9737679958343506,
-0.5122913718223572,
0.3619627356529236,
0.5945562124252319,
-0.024823125451803207,
-0.3397192358970642,
-0.7366816997528076,
0.15472765266895294,
-0.35145196318626404,
-0.13446277379989624,
0.3623455762863159,
0.15494845807552338,
0.13852927088737488,
0.6505954265594482,
0.6276804804801941,
-0.032371774315834045,
0.3703521192073822,
0.2736288607120514,
0.8123182654380798,
-0.6458562612533569,
-0.6599560379981995,
-0.672735333442688,
0.29096052050590515,
0.03501452878117561,
0.005719173699617386,
0.843305230140686,
0.866820752620697,
0.6969279646873474,
-0.08671583980321884,
0.8415101766586304,
-0.020309241488575935,
0.9598647356033325,
-0.6100411415100098,
0.4848949909210205,
-0.5762865543365479,
-0.13037431240081787,
-0.3717477023601532,
-0.9460418224334717,
-0.27329984307289124,
0.7300843000411987,
-0.10940319299697876,
0.28474685549736023,
0.4815492033958435,
0.7432234287261963,
-0.27764564752578735,
0.047315988689661026,
0.3380635380744934,
0.13001006841659546,
0.20648176968097687,
0.4259410798549652,
0.9428561329841614,
-0.598693311214447,
0.7050387263298035,
-0.2783105969429016,
-0.04070192202925682,
-0.44245603680610657,
-0.6137601733207703,
-0.6863119602203369,
-0.8943283557891846,
-0.09841273725032806,
-0.30921104550361633,
0.12668490409851074,
1.1541827917099,
0.9679502844810486,
-0.7645856738090515,
-0.1310926377773285,
0.5112774968147278,
-0.07316620647907257,
-0.22440554201602936,
-0.20343875885009766,
0.23525278270244598,
-0.36524152755737305,
-0.8047776222229004,
0.9779931902885437,
0.20273615419864655,
-0.09455988556146622,
-0.23449905216693878,
0.008487897925078869,
-0.6904450058937073,
-0.09011343866586685,
0.94537353515625,
0.33773741126060486,
-0.7775283455848694,
-0.419902503490448,
0.2342904657125473,
-0.16004672646522522,
0.10241193324327469,
1.134836196899414,
-0.9314414858818054,
0.4931609332561493,
0.685410737991333,
1.0446946620941162,
0.5566785931587219,
0.008040109649300575,
0.6439586281776428,
-0.6952688694000244,
0.06876768916845322,
0.4617198407649994,
0.21075798571109772,
0.3563711643218994,
-0.25106343626976013,
0.1791788637638092,
0.25600969791412354,
-0.5552981495857239,
-0.7468385696411133,
0.26663416624069214,
-1.1005510091781616,
-0.12274021655321121,
1.0469614267349243,
0.11604428291320801,
0.14740075170993805,
-0.3457225263118744,
-0.4133756160736084,
0.503806471824646,
-0.6406511664390564,
0.7094995975494385,
0.6299841403961182,
-0.20625749230384827,
-0.26831474900245667,
-0.8336227536201477,
0.265485942363739,
0.5413053035736084,
-0.6756839156150818,
0.059784356504678726,
0.6786667704582214,
0.17171506583690643,
0.25206297636032104,
0.40472689270973206,
-0.1464502215385437,
0.21466349065303802,
-0.5860337018966675,
-0.3864072859287262,
-0.08688013255596161,
-0.5033904910087585,
-0.4157753884792328,
0.3201204836368561,
-0.30858632922172546,
-0.17123201489448547
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09617v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09617v1
|
Multimodal Large Language Models with Fusion Low Rank Adaptation for Device Directed Speech Detection
| 2024-06-13T22:52:07 | 2024-06-13T22:52:07 |
Shruti Palaskar, Oggi Rudovic, Sameer Dharur, Florian Pesce, Gautam Krishna, Aswin Sivaraman, Jack Berkowitz, Ahmed Hussen Abdelaziz, Saurabh Adya, Ahmed Tewfik
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) have shown promise for human-like
conversations, they are primarily pre-trained on text data. Incorporating audio
or video improves performance, but collecting large-scale multimodal data and
pre-training multimodal LLMs is challenging. To this end, we propose a Fusion
Low Rank Adaptation (FLoRA) technique that efficiently adapts a pre-trained
unimodal LLM to consume new, previously unseen modalities via low rank
adaptation. For device-directed speech detection, using FLoRA, the multimodal
LLM achieves 22% relative reduction in equal error rate (EER) over the
text-only approach and attains performance parity with its full fine-tuning
(FFT) counterpart while needing to tune only a fraction of its parameters.
Furthermore, with the newly introduced adapter dropout, FLoRA is robust to
missing data, improving over FFT by 20% lower EER and 56% lower false accept
rate. The proposed approach scales well for model sizes from 16M to 3B
parameters.
|
[
-0.4011402726173401,
-0.7260215878486633,
0.43017005920410156,
0.06690837442874908,
-0.4810214936733246,
0.05169238895177841,
-0.39271777868270874,
-0.34686750173568726,
0.28437209129333496,
0.233704075217247,
-0.6197744011878967,
-0.4988510310649872,
-0.5463752746582031,
0.09102386981248856,
-0.25524768233299255,
0.7287898659706116,
0.38122501969337463,
0.17271099984645844,
-0.21619924902915955,
-0.12630578875541687,
-0.48508626222610474,
-0.2807486355304718,
-0.6659891605377197,
-0.19697795808315277,
0.5763465166091919,
0.6111970543861389,
0.6177279949188232,
0.31612280011177063,
0.38946470618247986,
0.29341739416122437,
-0.08922500908374786,
0.2948135435581207,
-0.557351291179657,
0.20770244300365448,
-0.08729954063892365,
-0.3652448058128357,
-0.7003162503242493,
-0.23751269280910492,
0.9612960815429688,
0.6244614124298096,
0.09112261980772018,
-0.005894197151064873,
0.1566106677055359,
0.15913531184196472,
-0.516173243522644,
0.07731780409812927,
-0.7760787010192871,
-0.10166158527135849,
-0.3786284625530243,
-0.37576034665107727,
-0.7381182909011841,
0.14639802277088165,
-0.0350041501224041,
-0.573056697845459,
-0.022712159901857376,
-0.09953629225492477,
0.37173473834991455,
0.34249868988990784,
-0.46054354310035706,
0.09134194254875183,
-0.9310033321380615,
0.6211088299751282,
-0.7391091585159302,
0.7171449065208435,
0.4742964804172516,
-0.02772861160337925,
-0.1926509588956833,
-0.45981907844543457,
-0.6892240047454834,
-0.1073976531624794,
0.1597863733768463,
0.08190033584833145,
-0.40760037302970886,
0.15609747171401978,
0.19865618646144867,
0.2871406376361847,
-0.6660215258598328,
0.4309375286102295,
-0.054897043853998184,
-0.42559006810188293,
0.3592448830604553,
-0.20953385531902313,
0.32183244824409485,
-0.2756415009498596,
-0.2861831784248352,
-0.39179664850234985,
-0.5197089910507202,
0.004847532603889704,
-0.07198458164930344,
0.5558551549911499,
-0.3108629882335663,
0.2288259118795395,
-0.11412397772073746,
0.7402549982070923,
0.12918978929519653,
-0.7926292419433594,
0.4007153809070587,
-0.4351278245449066,
-0.2874920964241028,
0.17652398347854614,
0.7044982314109802,
0.09569840133190155,
-0.14704765379428864,
0.14610877633094788,
-0.37935054302215576,
0.06905302405357361,
-0.21035772562026978,
-0.8384521007537842,
-0.5188558101654053,
0.03541901707649231,
-0.5665662288665771,
-0.01793394796550274,
-0.4391460120677948,
-0.9566693902015686,
-0.6165953874588013,
-0.1647716462612152,
0.7079046368598938,
-0.3184463679790497,
-0.4595705568790436,
-0.12418080121278763,
0.03401990234851837,
0.3193419575691223,
0.49555283784866333,
-0.9947302341461182,
0.19923032820224762,
0.4466756284236908,
1.0355095863342285,
-0.1448449045419693,
-0.07794830948114395,
-1.2930514812469482,
0.05607510730624199,
-0.12795253098011017,
0.8155533075332642,
-0.5642654299736023,
-0.7769220471382141,
-0.27992674708366394,
0.09573864936828613,
-0.5355705618858337,
-0.3438742756843567,
0.8885188102722168,
-0.2695309817790985,
0.024982241913676262,
0.03362574800848961,
-0.2070028930902481,
-0.0331922322511673,
-0.053435295820236206,
-0.396950364112854,
0.6194590926170349,
0.011641222983598709,
-0.4828057885169983,
0.4865745007991791,
-0.8154405951499939,
-0.8331434726715088,
0.04773149639368057,
0.14659465849399567,
-0.43896085023880005,
0.07327602058649063,
0.4415738880634308,
0.4768763780593872,
-0.29562023282051086,
0.12112879008054733,
-0.6957536339759827,
-0.1662294715642929,
-0.00883900560438633,
-0.8478951454162598,
0.6783294081687927,
0.3325364589691162,
-0.05413961783051491,
0.4693892002105713,
-0.9751034379005432,
-0.24162675440311432,
-0.04191213101148605,
-0.4179491698741913,
-0.42216089367866516,
0.07122905552387238,
0.365435928106308,
0.10827363282442093,
0.010483717545866966,
-0.7137472629547119,
0.1673375815153122,
-0.13870196044445038,
0.6484040021896362,
0.8298971056938171,
-0.33638614416122437,
0.545393705368042,
-0.31147944927215576,
0.3228926360607147,
0.24947883188724518,
0.2083170861005783,
-0.3980417251586914,
-0.4922240078449249,
-1.0040184259414673,
-0.7525142431259155,
0.44761213660240173,
0.4881778657436371,
-1.0988932847976685,
0.3189082443714142,
-0.6868516802787781,
-0.5220659375190735,
-0.6663291454315186,
0.3699341118335724,
0.3221939206123352,
0.6106515526771545,
0.27282989025115967,
-0.5072872042655945,
-0.30854249000549316,
-0.6989333033561707,
0.1998208612203598,
-0.3704075515270233,
-0.12810486555099487,
0.4036727845668793,
0.2954261004924774,
-0.5089097619056702,
0.8449148535728455,
-0.46800142526626587,
-0.5158069133758545,
-0.29780083894729614,
0.1654481738805771,
0.16570603847503662,
0.5591697096824646,
0.5425838232040405,
-0.8231136798858643,
-0.1115175262093544,
0.17238181829452515,
-0.32598093152046204,
-0.020185362547636032,
-0.022499576210975647,
0.16403800249099731,
0.21625831723213196,
0.26757848262786865,
-0.5455068945884705,
0.1468939334154129,
0.8261067867279053,
-0.11365235596895218,
-0.13711751997470856,
-0.4276352822780609,
0.10334347188472748,
-1.489647626876831,
-0.12709146738052368,
0.2208576500415802,
-0.4875633120536804,
-0.9480868577957153,
-0.3741140365600586,
0.17293114960193634,
-0.4985048770904541,
-0.6030590534210205,
0.47076719999313354,
-0.2980089485645294,
-0.30401045083999634,
-0.194228395819664,
0.052706312388181686,
0.02759718894958496,
0.3871254622936249,
0.16600364446640015,
0.8928666114807129,
0.6541941165924072,
-0.6825233101844788,
0.3182222545146942,
0.43361636996269226,
-0.18237870931625366,
0.8184888362884521,
-0.2714201807975769,
0.14590159058570862,
-0.11224600672721863,
0.49483829736709595,
-1.1361567974090576,
-0.4513230621814728,
0.08665935695171356,
-0.30835697054862976,
0.36643272638320923,
-0.24945342540740967,
-0.43009284138679504,
-0.22068549692630768,
-0.4144180119037628,
0.5229840874671936,
0.6446617245674133,
-1.012677788734436,
0.9252538084983826,
0.517654299736023,
-0.41145995259284973,
0.1552690863609314,
-0.5395114421844482,
0.0470748245716095,
-0.3603672385215759,
-0.8075830936431885,
0.32398107647895813,
-0.1500435322523117,
0.07555286586284637,
-0.36857733130455017,
0.018466413021087646,
-0.05302482098340988,
0.2730097770690918,
0.2294379472732544,
0.11405635625123978,
-0.44605064392089844,
0.368280827999115,
0.11543601006269455,
0.11804644763469696,
-0.27145805954933167,
-0.18457235395908356,
0.6353017687797546,
0.1844269037246704,
-0.47638025879859924,
-0.8131158351898193,
-0.0048911357298493385,
0.8500065803527832,
-0.35172897577285767,
0.31711792945861816,
0.9032803773880005,
-0.37889793515205383,
-0.05599713698029518,
-0.33756327629089355,
-0.2824322581291199,
-0.4794681668281555,
0.42875295877456665,
-0.5798941254615784,
-0.6071376800537109,
0.23408353328704834,
-0.1776738315820694,
-0.18931826949119568,
0.29982808232307434,
0.4232165515422821,
0.018187642097473145,
0.9367592334747314,
0.5125940442085266,
-0.4627755880355835,
0.6954300403594971,
0.10667973756790161,
0.1517968475818634,
-0.8982707858085632,
0.0011027568252757192,
-0.5613564252853394,
-0.2091989517211914,
-0.6332522630691528,
-0.48417750000953674,
0.6375030279159546,
-0.14405903220176697,
0.155402272939682,
0.21619898080825806,
-0.16399219632148743,
0.1607757806777954,
0.790433943271637,
0.35994261503219604,
0.4850543439388275,
-0.12002764642238617,
0.3680397868156433,
0.20547612011432648,
-0.7037619948387146,
0.05060296505689621,
1.0831761360168457,
0.5260055661201477,
1.0247817039489746,
0.40271300077438354,
0.63922119140625,
0.4751213788986206,
0.15921048820018768,
-0.7914999127388,
0.47936469316482544,
-0.47296932339668274,
-0.15090183913707733,
-0.35477888584136963,
-0.31125572323799133,
-0.7385138273239136,
0.4583861529827118,
-0.5221166610717773,
-0.4867541790008545,
0.3770788311958313,
0.14015813171863556,
-0.6483066082000732,
0.21901194751262665,
-0.9290481805801392,
0.7413809299468994,
-0.3055044412612915,
-0.2872564494609833,
-0.11699660122394562,
-0.3369152843952179,
0.5060648322105408,
-0.43825575709342957,
0.41738244891166687,
-0.060148436576128006,
0.3454524278640747,
0.9628961086273193,
-0.07304508239030838,
0.9505978226661682,
-0.3871458172798157,
-0.282147616147995,
0.0015403166180476546,
-0.09169307351112366,
0.4963624179363251,
-0.012583013623952866,
0.025195984169840813,
0.022236784920096397,
0.1435338407754898,
-0.31394127011299133,
-0.26724401116371155,
0.8380056023597717,
-0.9027831554412842,
-0.676800549030304,
-0.34765955805778503,
-0.6917217373847961,
-0.5488370656967163,
0.1587657481431961,
-0.016245901584625244,
0.6563994288444519,
-0.2076174020767212,
0.43096721172332764,
0.813109278678894,
-0.24136854708194733,
0.6589145660400391,
0.38441428542137146,
-0.27771925926208496,
-0.4165123999118805,
1.0867751836776733,
-0.28670260310173035,
0.48487740755081177,
0.4839588701725006,
0.21979624032974243,
-0.498900443315506,
-0.7249049544334412,
-0.7735385894775391,
0.01550467498600483,
-0.642164409160614,
-0.17265178263187408,
-0.699184000492096,
-0.10886688530445099,
-0.7086133360862732,
0.1851828396320343,
-0.23859146237373352,
-0.12416217476129532,
-0.8374677300453186,
0.28929808735847473,
0.614844024181366,
0.31417208909988403,
-0.07797031849622726,
0.6824954748153687,
-0.8504483699798584,
0.5813031792640686,
0.5206361413002014,
0.07372889667749405,
-0.27040785551071167,
-0.8722087144851685,
0.19973500072956085,
0.31063780188560486,
-0.2405274361371994,
-0.5639241933822632,
0.4774957597255707,
0.7573432922363281,
0.24757513403892517,
0.6550674438476562,
0.07567151635885239,
1.0288889408111572,
-0.2916349172592163,
0.5943763256072998,
0.3386145234107971,
-0.9857755303382874,
0.6077050566673279,
-0.4863847494125366,
0.4616125226020813,
0.33161377906799316,
0.015436943620443344,
-0.4276363253593445,
0.11295510828495026,
-0.010373181663453579,
-0.356357604265213,
0.8122099041938782,
-0.16654711961746216,
0.1828312873840332,
0.2553383708000183,
-0.1479111760854721,
-0.06334178149700165,
-0.24760152399539948,
-0.7326892614364624,
0.1621653139591217,
-0.15158481895923615,
-0.2953554391860962,
-0.5554198622703552,
-0.20035314559936523,
-0.11561387777328491,
-0.4487266540527344,
0.6642377376556396,
-0.3833266496658325,
0.09961448609828949,
0.06508875638246536,
-0.48233741521835327,
-0.1779734194278717,
0.5809952020645142,
0.8395776152610779,
0.33600419759750366,
-0.13640780746936798,
0.17839494347572327,
0.22370386123657227,
-0.3728526532649994,
0.11797303706407547,
0.40297845005989075,
-0.06684983521699905,
-0.05815005302429199,
0.41884124279022217,
1.039001703262329,
0.6446130275726318,
-0.635217010974884,
0.5128236413002014,
0.008312235586345196,
-0.05601127818226814,
-0.05003250762820244,
0.09558263421058655,
0.06667514145374298,
0.24021075665950775,
0.26921528577804565,
0.14105728268623352,
0.07242503762245178,
-0.6632856726646423,
0.2257160246372223,
0.5961666703224182,
-0.37422212958335876,
-0.3288637399673462,
0.6705279350280762,
0.6552770137786865,
-0.2503840923309326,
0.3603619337081909,
0.023565378040075302,
-0.24300000071525574,
0.22124214470386505,
0.688059389591217,
0.6887224316596985,
-0.631304144859314,
0.4486713409423828,
-0.1633753925561905,
0.017334777861833572,
0.14189933240413666,
0.04855545982718468,
-0.05837557464838028,
-0.7849377989768982,
-0.2968551814556122,
-0.8676570653915405,
-0.2649746835231781,
0.33173668384552,
-0.4253409206867218,
0.3802006244659424,
-0.3537953495979309,
-0.11173024773597717,
0.22927452623844147,
-0.2906024158000946,
-0.4252707064151764,
0.08621742576360703,
0.3621198832988739,
0.6346638798713684,
-0.9374517202377319,
1.2476650476455688,
0.3948509693145752,
-0.1772923767566681,
-0.5024349093437195,
-0.013972494751214981,
0.19705870747566223,
-0.8396456241607666,
0.43577665090560913,
-0.09985566884279251,
-0.19702835381031036,
0.21804997324943542,
-0.018170224502682686,
-0.8731688261032104,
1.1771228313446045,
0.3723670244216919,
-0.7320848703384399,
0.14969173073768616,
0.08503995835781097,
0.3660604655742645,
-0.2965947389602661,
0.20483149588108063,
0.5227790474891663,
0.4306849539279938,
0.3610984683036804,
-1.3785207271575928,
-0.32333800196647644,
0.0027348962612450123,
0.06950307637453079,
0.25812873244285583,
-0.5155323147773743,
1.1106035709381104,
-0.00090694276150316,
-0.16354288160800934,
0.14084835350513458,
0.4805866777896881,
0.015699459239840508,
0.3825395107269287,
0.8676193952560425,
0.38393107056617737,
0.8278567790985107,
-0.022760974243283272,
0.7435154914855957,
-0.0876411646604538,
0.12666845321655273,
0.8564063906669617,
-0.6039620637893677,
1.0140981674194336,
0.34512171149253845,
0.058868493884801865,
0.14318107068538666,
0.8530501127243042,
0.20243139564990997,
0.6622787117958069,
-0.10544022917747498,
-0.5531542301177979,
-0.4267689883708954,
-0.369170606136322,
-0.40659427642822266,
0.8844529986381531,
0.3421178162097931,
-0.3596942126750946,
-0.17889031767845154,
0.5461911559104919,
-0.12215811759233475,
-0.04360570013523102,
-0.7330495119094849,
0.8772566318511963,
-0.04530661925673485,
-0.4519669711589813,
0.7611363530158997,
-0.07363041490316391,
0.8857395052909851,
-0.39994674921035767,
0.03820216655731201,
-0.16517016291618347,
0.3895130157470703,
-0.12948475778102875,
-0.3250296711921692,
-0.3079560101032257,
-0.0838858038187027,
-0.17406883835792542,
-0.22464214265346527,
0.9540587067604065,
-0.4572651982307434,
-0.6523675322532654,
0.2876741588115692,
0.5667294859886169,
-0.002726564183831215,
0.08669417351484299,
-0.30454471707344055,
0.39311474561691284,
0.023939598351716995,
0.0670127347111702,
0.51863694190979,
0.12384738028049469,
-0.10144446045160294,
0.7082726955413818,
1.0638099908828735,
0.058787621557712555,
0.011939984746277332,
0.15226654708385468,
0.9791215658187866,
-0.3597515821456909,
-0.36413756012916565,
-0.7565410137176514,
0.160245880484581,
0.09732881188392639,
-0.11449325829744339,
0.43804505467414856,
0.4457892179489136,
0.7228437066078186,
-0.15586337447166443,
0.6878911852836609,
0.16951176524162292,
0.41817188262939453,
-0.7472229599952698,
0.6264598369598389,
-0.5811715722084045,
0.1696142703294754,
-0.5187516808509827,
-0.8857772946357727,
-0.28778401017189026,
0.4696201980113983,
-0.15589217841625214,
-0.09307966381311417,
0.45269134640693665,
0.7285040616989136,
-0.3796837627887726,
0.2096930891275406,
0.7414416670799255,
0.3088666796684265,
0.5251929759979248,
0.620980978012085,
0.5772443413734436,
-0.2718363404273987,
0.3966635465621948,
-0.13373124599456787,
-0.480745404958725,
-0.35811901092529297,
-0.611229658126831,
-0.7973417639732361,
-0.6874493956565857,
-0.10962985455989838,
-0.09913179278373718,
-0.06239031255245209,
1.005822777748108,
0.9336217641830444,
-0.7572216987609863,
-0.11195850372314453,
0.36599868535995483,
0.01475059799849987,
0.11620693653821945,
-0.14424146711826324,
0.27525651454925537,
0.04264238849282265,
-0.8894184231758118,
0.8289687037467957,
0.3092217743396759,
0.0626792460680008,
-0.2672847807407379,
-0.15753281116485596,
-0.35788121819496155,
-0.2204442322254181,
0.9482102394104004,
0.2576405107975006,
-0.7708888649940491,
-0.5838367938995361,
-0.18707722425460815,
0.3208772838115692,
0.14059676229953766,
0.5412040948867798,
-0.7071493864059448,
0.5568604469299316,
0.3253783583641052,
0.7639162540435791,
0.39499786496162415,
0.017795037478208542,
0.2941036820411682,
-0.5279613733291626,
0.3763797879219055,
0.22650331258773804,
0.5579190850257874,
0.41507425904273987,
-0.1089523583650589,
-0.01564006321132183,
0.37234872579574585,
-0.35787734389305115,
-1.0634928941726685,
0.276559442281723,
-1.316285490989685,
-0.0860203355550766,
1.3869938850402832,
-0.0206455010920763,
-0.26736611127853394,
-0.06837081164121628,
-0.33950287103652954,
0.07658932358026505,
-0.5724409222602844,
0.38420358300209045,
0.3813633322715759,
-0.16260205209255219,
-0.42674243450164795,
-0.1273178905248642,
0.36068305373191833,
0.261207640171051,
-1.0131163597106934,
-0.013580783270299435,
0.617824137210846,
0.3032483160495758,
0.27811792492866516,
0.7951138019561768,
0.3186269998550415,
0.17044603824615479,
-0.1454637348651886,
-0.041388560086488724,
0.1458148956298828,
-0.3821257948875427,
-0.5711153149604797,
0.01751881279051304,
0.38873106241226196,
-0.5111233592033386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10300v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10300v1
|
Large Language Models as Software Components: A Taxonomy for LLM-Integrated Applications
| 2024-06-13T21:32:56 | 2024-06-13T21:32:56 |
Irene Weber
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG, A.1; I.2.7; D.2.11
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become widely adopted recently. Research
explores their use both as autonomous agents and as tools for software
engineering. LLM-integrated applications, on the other hand, are software
systems that leverage an LLM to perform tasks that would otherwise be
impossible or require significant coding effort. While LLM-integrated
application engineering is emerging as new discipline, its terminology,
concepts and methods need to be established. This study provides a taxonomy for
LLM-integrated applications, offering a framework for analyzing and describing
these systems. It also demonstrates various ways to utilize LLMs in
applications, as well as options for implementing such integrations.
Following established methods, we analyze a sample of recent LLM-integrated
applications to identify relevant dimensions. We evaluate the taxonomy by
applying it to additional cases. This review shows that applications integrate
LLMs in numerous ways for various purposes. Frequently, they comprise multiple
LLM integrations, which we term ``LLM components''. To gain a clear
understanding of an application's architecture, we examine each LLM component
separately. We identify thirteen dimensions along which to characterize an LLM
component, including the LLM skills leveraged, the format of the output, and
more. LLM-integrated applications are described as combinations of their LLM
components. We suggest a concise representation using feature vectors for
visualization.
The taxonomy is effective for describing LLM-integrated applications. It can
contribute to theory building in the nascent field of LLM-integrated
application engineering and aid in developing such systems. Researchers and
practitioners explore numerous creative ways to leverage LLMs in applications.
Though challenges persist, integrating LLMs may revolutionize the way software
systems are built.
|
[
-0.4680776000022888,
-0.7220418453216553,
0.6909470558166504,
0.43975770473480225,
0.010048278607428074,
0.5588622689247131,
-0.1515844762325287,
-0.5269772410392761,
0.3416941165924072,
0.8677776455879211,
-0.25913769006729126,
-0.5059810876846313,
-0.36441153287887573,
-0.10258504748344421,
-0.5767825245857239,
0.5346851348876953,
-0.24805031716823578,
0.1835920661687851,
-0.40625,
-0.08604077994823456,
-0.6823712587356567,
-0.6127340197563171,
-0.24029570817947388,
-0.6651219129562378,
0.6425265669822693,
0.42669108510017395,
0.5784059166908264,
0.5979361534118652,
0.7278192043304443,
0.36744779348373413,
-0.02274079993367195,
-0.16646233201026917,
0.05284060165286064,
-0.010404631495475769,
-0.17725014686584473,
-0.4571889638900757,
-0.7801700234413147,
0.19516780972480774,
0.67488694190979,
1.0231972932815552,
0.04012340307235718,
0.2500993013381958,
0.13421069085597992,
0.3126548230648041,
-0.5280031561851501,
0.33840328454971313,
-0.25815892219543457,
0.000934421201236546,
-0.3798885941505432,
-0.3186444342136383,
-0.27922722697257996,
-0.2344622015953064,
-0.08512329310178757,
-0.11769402027130127,
-0.4742484986782074,
-0.12614108622074127,
0.25370123982429504,
-0.13044609129428864,
-0.5896814465522766,
-0.4315478503704071,
-1.026700735092163,
0.88460773229599,
-0.7827038764953613,
0.3005996346473694,
-0.16813750565052032,
0.3207957446575165,
-0.3549514710903168,
-0.42451485991477966,
-0.4399973154067993,
-0.48275697231292725,
0.03245455026626587,
-0.08818678557872772,
-0.041974905878305435,
0.3137052655220032,
-0.145471453666687,
0.556406557559967,
-0.6503218412399292,
0.6319367289543152,
-0.1845129281282425,
-0.12503065168857574,
0.5501946806907654,
0.48155447840690613,
0.5141041278839111,
0.04414043575525284,
-0.3133685290813446,
0.3621353507041931,
-0.7573323249816895,
-0.31735190749168396,
0.19880948960781097,
0.530852735042572,
-0.19498227536678314,
0.892443060874939,
0.05336743965744972,
0.8156772255897522,
-0.5339412689208984,
-0.6120225787162781,
0.090335413813591,
-0.17234449088573456,
-0.3264315128326416,
-0.05230779945850372,
0.7315402626991272,
-0.06949342042207718,
-0.03917153924703598,
-0.169525146484375,
-0.4725485146045685,
0.21571092307567596,
0.10232561826705933,
-0.38706108927726746,
0.15674440562725067,
0.2605314254760742,
-0.40094780921936035,
-0.4000580608844757,
-0.12420184165239334,
-0.29248639941215515,
-0.5338157415390015,
-0.5045150518417358,
0.32816460728645325,
-0.2310420721769333,
-0.3322107493877411,
-0.11022777855396271,
0.005649585276842117,
0.5157196521759033,
0.29395633935928345,
-0.6832825541496277,
0.6590877175331116,
1.2344611883163452,
0.7586584687232971,
-0.32939639687538147,
-0.37465184926986694,
-0.3399040997028351,
0.1569746881723404,
-0.33335334062576294,
0.7388912439346313,
-0.748467206954956,
-0.43312808871269226,
0.2985568940639496,
-0.0007418397581204772,
0.34459951519966125,
-0.7438651323318481,
0.12817654013633728,
-0.7796820402145386,
-0.11775046586990356,
0.11963547766208649,
-0.758567214012146,
-0.3832351267337799,
0.22962212562561035,
-0.4780762493610382,
0.8910338282585144,
0.03615565225481987,
-0.2347332388162613,
0.2363509088754654,
-0.5852903127670288,
-0.39429429173469543,
0.5091432929039001,
-0.48235568404197693,
0.22666414082050323,
0.28248330950737,
-0.4117712676525116,
0.6250488758087158,
-0.49993380904197693,
0.10851997137069702,
-0.2613109350204468,
-0.31938284635543823,
0.3036447763442993,
0.00956763606518507,
0.7412711381912231,
0.19230206310749054,
0.19497625529766083,
0.22467435896396637,
-0.6499975919723511,
-0.0571478009223938,
-0.08672183007001877,
-0.4836429953575134,
-0.5428169965744019,
0.10476406663656235,
0.1584819257259369,
-0.08799522370100021,
0.5290447473526001,
-0.44622674584388733,
0.4139593541622162,
-0.21482257544994354,
0.556293249130249,
0.4679960310459137,
-0.22728578746318817,
0.7906157970428467,
0.016304709017276764,
0.7219825983047485,
0.12224086374044418,
0.25434401631355286,
-0.18948820233345032,
-0.27954474091529846,
-0.5481422543525696,
-0.3180239200592041,
0.05403002351522446,
0.6648528575897217,
-0.7518340945243835,
0.4527909457683563,
-0.13752958178520203,
-0.6279647350311279,
0.08454251289367676,
0.32763952016830444,
0.011839141137897968,
0.0669911578297615,
0.006003197748214006,
-0.4359346926212311,
-0.2559407949447632,
-0.8829351663589478,
0.02554820105433464,
-0.43580085039138794,
0.0034786842297762632,
0.3681143522262573,
0.5127387046813965,
-0.4360677897930145,
1.0255026817321777,
-0.4828993082046509,
-0.16872994601726532,
-0.5081858038902283,
0.03158477693796158,
0.48171716928482056,
0.16408564150333405,
0.5419155359268188,
-0.5761286616325378,
-0.30907371640205383,
0.2359398752450943,
-0.7315055131912231,
-0.3610038459300995,
-0.07587113976478577,
0.10097496956586838,
-0.14418645203113556,
0.48821473121643066,
-0.5307854413986206,
-0.10045652091503143,
0.6202613115310669,
-0.13408313691616058,
0.5968642830848694,
-0.30072489380836487,
-0.2750872075557709,
-0.9300317168235779,
-0.1575639396905899,
0.08743062615394592,
-0.004790279548615217,
-0.6314563155174255,
0.5169198513031006,
0.06514513492584229,
-0.10446510463953018,
-0.5227314829826355,
0.732399582862854,
-0.7223334908485413,
-0.545943558216095,
-0.637355387210846,
0.2505543529987335,
-0.07011251896619797,
-0.044191643595695496,
-0.3304210901260376,
0.6254442930221558,
0.6025649309158325,
-0.5457757711410522,
0.8892558217048645,
-0.16813509166240692,
-0.32256656885147095,
0.4697061777114868,
-0.3653215169906616,
-0.14582732319831848,
-0.024561267346143723,
-0.017661230638623238,
-0.7252047657966614,
-0.2692818343639374,
0.02795957215130329,
-0.0384361669421196,
0.3919667899608612,
0.14861054718494415,
-0.727508544921875,
-0.46364322304725647,
-0.32185184955596924,
0.2824223041534424,
0.1521555334329605,
-0.227604478597641,
0.9479767680168152,
0.584024965763092,
-0.25336191058158875,
-0.4268728196620941,
-0.7719792723655701,
0.4287962317466736,
-0.4229152202606201,
-0.4283440113067627,
0.4072403311729431,
0.08602753281593323,
-0.45226940512657166,
0.1482204645872116,
0.2243472933769226,
-0.23932616412639618,
0.22361138463020325,
0.18790611624717712,
0.4039660096168518,
-0.4094470739364624,
0.24917566776275635,
-0.12590765953063965,
-0.1516205221414566,
-0.10949573665857315,
-0.18657927215099335,
0.543826699256897,
-0.026376018300652504,
-0.4943634569644928,
-0.019775990396738052,
0.5067774653434753,
0.8362812399864197,
-0.18048657476902008,
0.6932080388069153,
0.25101736187934875,
-0.2406153827905655,
-0.1607389599084854,
-0.56345134973526,
0.023368196561932564,
-0.45770448446273804,
0.5184851288795471,
-0.36570924520492554,
-1.1398468017578125,
0.7629024386405945,
-0.3982278108596802,
0.1679578423500061,
0.1237495094537735,
0.5827407836914062,
-0.06204821541905403,
0.5474076867103577,
1.1850359439849854,
-0.4736690819263458,
0.5850863456726074,
0.018939338624477386,
0.4323984384536743,
-0.8756378889083862,
-0.10355069488286972,
-0.4943598210811615,
-0.22269387543201447,
-0.5246545076370239,
-0.4398905634880066,
0.26605525612831116,
0.1281892955303192,
-0.29485055804252625,
0.2383253425359726,
-0.29488518834114075,
0.4252810478210449,
0.1536179929971695,
-0.3964446485042572,
0.3915925621986389,
-0.3460623323917389,
0.015606681816279888,
0.10415953397750854,
-0.44903743267059326,
-0.7424194812774658,
0.8141809105873108,
0.7030093669891357,
1.3152133226394653,
0.29514893889427185,
0.6411482095718384,
0.35897859930992126,
0.44236642122268677,
-1.359518051147461,
0.909084141254425,
-0.43398532271385193,
-0.20834887027740479,
-0.12806344032287598,
-0.0764404907822609,
-0.6143814325332642,
0.058332882821559906,
-0.04215297847986221,
-0.8476681709289551,
0.18540337681770325,
-0.14571695029735565,
-0.20527908205986023,
0.06838931143283844,
-0.5949667096138,
0.5224575400352478,
-0.6471044421195984,
-0.009548847563564777,
-0.2509223222732544,
-0.23002952337265015,
0.5182417631149292,
-0.3190802037715912,
0.3826570510864258,
-0.21983684599399567,
-0.26825565099716187,
0.33458685874938965,
-0.38881126046180725,
0.8826571106910706,
0.16310006380081177,
-0.47161564230918884,
0.25196439027786255,
0.0798245370388031,
0.3376011252403259,
-0.466528981924057,
-0.027893342077732086,
0.10835584998130798,
0.1173676922917366,
-0.04024837911128998,
-0.7002615332603455,
0.8917759656906128,
-0.6159024834632874,
-0.5150802135467529,
-0.428643137216568,
-0.6314198970794678,
-0.13974064588546753,
0.12897983193397522,
-0.4212712347507477,
0.3821641802787781,
-0.15694352984428406,
0.11345558613538742,
0.35755589604377747,
-0.5555950999259949,
0.36887145042419434,
0.5700444579124451,
-0.813844621181488,
-0.07603959739208221,
0.8311981558799744,
0.3511938452720642,
0.1239013746380806,
0.47758224606513977,
0.18020033836364746,
-0.11646189540624619,
-0.6620148420333862,
-0.06750405579805374,
0.25190097093582153,
-0.7727192640304565,
-0.07230120897293091,
-0.3019544780254364,
-0.4002438187599182,
-0.10640748590230942,
-0.2679610252380371,
-0.2478344738483429,
-0.10735707730054855,
-0.3164255917072296,
0.11703493446111679,
0.3203423321247101,
0.9991329908370972,
0.3105674684047699,
0.48189809918403625,
-0.9376869201660156,
0.025924375280737877,
0.16100981831550598,
0.39724722504615784,
0.18860457837581635,
-0.14343780279159546,
-0.3915330171585083,
-0.4539255201816559,
-0.22406309843063354,
-0.8451218605041504,
0.2241182178258896,
0.14585399627685547,
0.918619692325592,
0.40691670775413513,
-0.23934179544448853,
0.4289746880531311,
-0.5837344527244568,
1.0175505876541138,
0.21898271143436432,
-0.8180969953536987,
0.2978270351886749,
-0.2671907842159271,
0.2669081687927246,
-0.012658285908401012,
0.2181835025548935,
-0.5786686539649963,
-0.40127530694007874,
0.008148669265210629,
-0.9282922148704529,
0.3607267439365387,
-0.3584004342556,
0.4940049350261688,
0.040532663464546204,
0.5432363152503967,
0.04671163484454155,
0.18642884492874146,
-0.6234149932861328,
-0.23964782059192657,
0.4653657078742981,
-0.25989723205566406,
-0.059926409274339676,
-0.46828141808509827,
-0.04692699387669563,
-0.19196315109729767,
0.4519549310207367,
-0.22296011447906494,
0.09168710559606552,
-0.4589424729347229,
-0.2299771010875702,
0.27556461095809937,
0.3553588092327118,
0.4405878186225891,
0.5698745846748352,
0.14362733066082,
0.42074695229530334,
-0.12467952072620392,
-0.5537775754928589,
0.23320674896240234,
-0.22705017030239105,
-0.03912261500954628,
-0.22356116771697998,
0.5573114156723022,
0.4204050898551941,
0.21698932349681854,
-0.6263992786407471,
0.13570722937583923,
0.2592983841896057,
0.12270830571651459,
-0.3870278000831604,
0.13012903928756714,
0.2600241005420685,
0.8066465258598328,
0.31404292583465576,
-0.574053168296814,
0.20954011380672455,
-0.9828521013259888,
-0.15505428612232208,
0.7327349185943604,
-0.16092447936534882,
-0.17459776997566223,
0.1737062931060791,
0.270853728055954,
-0.24279214441776276,
0.13302965462207794,
0.1334702968597412,
-0.29688066244125366,
0.5262928009033203,
0.37878015637397766,
1.036591649055481,
-0.14734168350696564,
0.05331844463944435,
-0.3225744068622589,
0.35181838274002075,
0.09186765551567078,
0.3851737380027771,
0.17889919877052307,
-0.8379237651824951,
-0.6597829461097717,
-0.8216549158096313,
-0.5438985824584961,
0.24822433292865753,
-0.1642114520072937,
0.4279424548149109,
-0.3342786729335785,
-0.38343966007232666,
0.18441785871982574,
-0.08713272958993912,
-0.28320515155792236,
-0.06597850471735,
0.3695299029350281,
1.0302027463912964,
-0.9016727209091187,
0.8273563385009766,
1.244580864906311,
-0.268485426902771,
-0.6722898483276367,
-0.04321971535682678,
0.25640320777893066,
-0.5985687971115112,
0.9792541265487671,
-0.35157033801078796,
-0.13257214426994324,
-0.38840630650520325,
-0.31935080885887146,
-0.8602733016014099,
0.9314160943031311,
0.2736459970474243,
-0.3455438017845154,
0.17718932032585144,
0.6484203338623047,
0.44046273827552795,
-0.7028469443321228,
0.2602745592594147,
0.5876060128211975,
0.3181414306163788,
0.1373298466205597,
-0.9749244451522827,
-0.13464437425136566,
-0.012531590647995472,
0.5477943420410156,
0.19609162211418152,
-0.6032915115356445,
0.9167383909225464,
0.1553383469581604,
0.009609679691493511,
0.09877727180719376,
0.4502958655357361,
0.08259152621030807,
0.1255759298801422,
0.1409538984298706,
0.14294032752513885,
0.5014909505844116,
-0.006603587884455919,
0.801706075668335,
-0.531036913394928,
0.2517603933811188,
0.9517005085945129,
-0.49527621269226074,
0.8718017339706421,
0.6226327419281006,
-0.37033191323280334,
0.35499095916748047,
0.6762036085128784,
0.11237259954214096,
0.20899003744125366,
0.4165512025356293,
-0.5505979061126709,
-0.08491110056638718,
-0.2593695819377899,
-0.11809377372264862,
0.663945734500885,
0.55255526304245,
-0.4020993411540985,
-0.3447023332118988,
0.2704450488090515,
-0.13514594733715057,
-0.08921854197978973,
-0.39894336462020874,
0.7094696760177612,
0.4534437954425812,
-0.03029758669435978,
-0.007182631175965071,
0.1918862909078598,
0.604751467704773,
-0.5825720429420471,
-0.01854732446372509,
-0.2664499878883362,
0.2627145051956177,
-0.40123310685157776,
-1.1307591199874878,
0.3602675199508667,
-0.02981201559305191,
-0.24533823132514954,
-0.1406041383743286,
0.876863420009613,
-0.20250454545021057,
-0.49044880270957947,
0.506069004535675,
0.7215484976768494,
0.21361708641052246,
0.1767141968011856,
-0.3529641032218933,
0.432151734828949,
-0.5657152533531189,
-0.13301807641983032,
0.4673311114311218,
0.6348273158073425,
-0.2484969049692154,
0.8803198933601379,
0.23455089330673218,
0.33740633726119995,
0.03237994760274887,
0.13837197422981262,
0.9427338242530823,
-0.7239387631416321,
-0.2542780041694641,
-0.932010293006897,
0.42789265513420105,
0.16561594605445862,
0.24113400280475616,
0.8111698031425476,
0.7527638077735901,
0.4840477705001831,
0.03637770935893059,
0.7740792036056519,
-0.05030517280101776,
0.2866579592227936,
-0.40346822142601013,
0.5756300091743469,
-0.6776650547981262,
0.7332003116607666,
-0.2973565459251404,
-1.2349517345428467,
-0.4064585566520691,
0.1821194589138031,
-0.35494014620780945,
0.06582998484373093,
0.3749874532222748,
0.5675846934318542,
-0.08104363828897476,
-0.18269267678260803,
0.42980045080184937,
0.25945335626602173,
0.4857253432273865,
0.225324809551239,
0.8703948259353638,
0.004152196459472179,
-0.06143353506922722,
-0.03481343388557434,
-0.5636669993400574,
-0.42736122012138367,
-0.9948973059654236,
-0.5391102433204651,
-0.3818317651748657,
-0.2974994480609894,
0.009803459979593754,
-0.3979131281375885,
0.7625595331192017,
0.4904453456401825,
-0.6284657120704651,
-0.8219950795173645,
0.17274132370948792,
0.21604657173156738,
-0.03439394012093544,
-0.23759430646896362,
-0.12349643558263779,
-0.2777818739414215,
-0.5868937969207764,
0.46086385846138,
0.833446204662323,
-0.10912749171257019,
-0.9584057927131653,
0.017955612391233444,
0.028899969533085823,
0.10530587285757065,
1.0916508436203003,
0.2464524805545807,
-0.71207195520401,
-0.22370032966136932,
0.005037135910242796,
-0.14919832348823547,
-0.07747747004032135,
0.8871676325798035,
-0.47594285011291504,
0.2512529194355011,
0.482939749956131,
0.6265909671783447,
0.16075453162193298,
-0.403591126203537,
0.5280131697654724,
-0.6870056986808777,
0.16974510252475739,
0.24429528415203094,
0.30208060145378113,
0.13306233286857605,
-0.22532370686531067,
0.33040282130241394,
0.08482462167739868,
-0.47748854756355286,
-0.8732612729072571,
0.36061224341392517,
-1.0965696573257446,
-0.4268951714038849,
1.0813078880310059,
0.0986853539943695,
-0.07867976278066635,
-0.2073463797569275,
0.02576759085059166,
-0.15508240461349487,
-0.05232328176498413,
0.3368563950061798,
0.9063900709152222,
-0.5892166495323181,
-0.4697141647338867,
-0.8621180057525635,
-0.030390245839953423,
-0.2834237217903137,
-0.8583047986030579,
0.01123285386711359,
0.4808025062084198,
0.17824076116085052,
0.3669528365135193,
0.5456641316413879,
-0.23411428928375244,
-0.232773095369339,
-0.1418515145778656,
0.2844160795211792,
0.23881834745407104,
-0.28431496024131775,
-0.35506007075309753,
0.1688407063484192,
0.5893257856369019,
0.10938230901956558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09573v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09573v1
|
Analyzing Gender Polarity in Short Social Media Texts with BERT: The Role of Emojis and Emoticons
| 2024-06-13T20:23:59 | 2024-06-13T20:23:59 |
Saba Yousefian Jazi, Amir Mirzaeinia, Sina Yousefian Jazi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this effort we fine tuned different models based on BERT to detect the
gender polarity of twitter accounts. We specially focused on analyzing the
effect of using emojis and emoticons in performance of our model in classifying
task. We were able to demonstrate that the use of these none word inputs
alongside the mention of other accounts in a short text format like tweet has
an impact in detecting the account holder's gender.
|
[
-0.19730031490325928,
-1.0392835140228271,
0.6179395914077759,
0.4234914183616638,
-0.4188782274723053,
0.2044830024242401,
-0.21919123828411102,
-0.463590145111084,
0.6310659050941467,
0.3494597375392914,
-0.738471508026123,
-0.3387905955314636,
-0.7527427077293396,
0.415834903717041,
-0.5027098655700684,
1.0573214292526245,
0.15594418346881866,
0.15981194376945496,
0.13244205713272095,
-0.19732971489429474,
-0.37960001826286316,
-0.47491076588630676,
-0.8792763948440552,
-0.11012186855077744,
0.8479334712028503,
0.46600231528282166,
0.7187991738319397,
-0.1864069402217865,
0.6021280288696289,
0.303171843290329,
-0.20225800573825836,
-0.13796791434288025,
-0.42265254259109497,
0.24278004467487335,
0.06884901225566864,
-0.39318016171455383,
-0.330596923828125,
0.18869318068027496,
0.6104022860527039,
0.34090539813041687,
0.16422975063323975,
0.3646022379398346,
0.02899586595594883,
0.6498891115188599,
-0.3463059067726135,
0.2971125543117523,
-0.2592450976371765,
0.057528164237737656,
-0.04680226370692253,
0.0370548777282238,
-0.16407620906829834,
-0.7784903645515442,
0.38136979937553406,
-0.14831416308879852,
0.2784039080142975,
0.28646036982536316,
0.7281155586242676,
-0.3251161277294159,
-0.5673949718475342,
-0.5995678901672363,
-0.7756257653236389,
1.2161054611206055,
-0.5702477097511292,
0.291830450296402,
0.32850316166877747,
0.4277796149253845,
0.25613418221473694,
-0.32993337512016296,
-0.5594221949577332,
0.03975985199213028,
-0.06776340305805206,
-0.2590649127960205,
-0.2480599582195282,
0.018759887665510178,
0.12987598776817322,
-0.10148370265960693,
-0.18259523808956146,
-0.1212841272354126,
-0.4392995536327362,
0.1521887630224228,
0.7285915017127991,
-0.07761774212121964,
0.7195225954055786,
-0.3965337574481964,
-0.03672826662659645,
0.058159101754426956,
-0.4383361339569092,
0.19715802371501923,
0.6786528825759888,
0.47169098258018494,
-0.21618114411830902,
0.911750316619873,
0.39955976605415344,
0.2630493938922882,
0.12870240211486816,
-0.107511006295681,
0.21923930943012238,
0.0036893475335091352,
-0.14039936661720276,
0.2541418969631195,
0.5680258870124817,
0.4109414219856262,
0.5943552255630493,
0.012669523246586323,
-0.2867163121700287,
-0.3883678615093231,
0.32773834466934204,
-0.7590680718421936,
0.0954122543334961,
0.2841510772705078,
-0.8866909146308899,
-0.5237645506858826,
0.062207404524087906,
-0.5777359008789062,
-0.6176308393478394,
-0.14009027183055878,
0.3522748351097107,
-0.41822806000709534,
-0.2251075804233551,
-0.345370352268219,
-0.7064980864524841,
0.24508894979953766,
0.46338918805122375,
-1.1280626058578491,
0.03643632307648659,
0.8347148895263672,
0.7530359029769897,
0.37161609530448914,
0.06266439706087112,
0.011219767853617668,
0.032862987369298935,
-0.2405390441417694,
0.37920209765434265,
-0.5976999998092651,
-0.2136274129152298,
0.45500391721725464,
0.043866295367479324,
-0.044452887028455734,
0.021927539259195328,
0.4100504219532013,
-0.4451653063297272,
0.1262524425983429,
-0.8513931035995483,
-0.7105292081832886,
-0.23616114258766174,
0.09449219703674316,
-0.7167288661003113,
0.620564341545105,
0.09425023943185806,
-1.0000486373901367,
0.5114812254905701,
-0.8975406289100647,
-0.573182225227356,
0.04803874343633652,
-0.2044127881526947,
-0.445850670337677,
0.2004639059305191,
0.12090718746185303,
0.8497499823570251,
-0.20166322588920593,
0.03585711866617203,
-0.6289005279541016,
-0.2852109670639038,
0.5159187912940979,
0.021367529407143593,
1.1228911876678467,
-0.12550818920135498,
-0.3076406419277191,
0.04766078665852547,
-0.24861040711402893,
-0.413858562707901,
0.2686980068683624,
-0.03024006448686123,
-0.5717372894287109,
0.40534505248069763,
0.28704193234443665,
-0.0028182012028992176,
0.23054195940494537,
-0.8823843598365784,
0.028420308604836464,
-0.04335269331932068,
0.7368135452270508,
0.6903117895126343,
-0.22229883074760437,
0.6761689186096191,
-0.40086621046066284,
0.33624210953712463,
-0.4054349958896637,
0.5078933835029602,
0.4592209458351135,
-1.1208816766738892,
-0.5681583285331726,
-0.49222180247306824,
0.3136442303657532,
0.6306062936782837,
-0.9191070795059204,
0.6880658268928528,
-0.2969079315662384,
-0.13187971711158752,
-0.5513661503791809,
0.2604966163635254,
0.08618557453155518,
-0.026531968265771866,
-0.1851620376110077,
0.00795982126146555,
-0.5096791982650757,
-1.1279990673065186,
-0.40628522634506226,
-0.6175753474235535,
0.03504963219165802,
0.545573890209198,
0.6982207894325256,
-0.1915062516927719,
1.094692349433899,
-0.27672916650772095,
-0.4102018475532532,
-0.7543559074401855,
0.7551406621932983,
0.28580304980278015,
0.248494952917099,
1.109381914138794,
-1.0770885944366455,
-0.628304660320282,
-0.25390180945396423,
-0.719629168510437,
-0.38508340716362,
0.17102716863155365,
-0.09579462558031082,
0.2840155065059662,
0.27042391896247864,
-0.44935423135757446,
0.4772786498069763,
0.5479006171226501,
-0.6274662017822266,
-0.04422367364168167,
0.18056797981262207,
0.5408511757850647,
-0.6474501490592957,
-0.14702191948890686,
0.20937584340572357,
-0.28504347801208496,
-0.9130414128303528,
-0.4182273745536804,
0.0964449793100357,
-0.027801955118775368,
-0.5676916241645813,
0.34311217069625854,
-0.2366728037595749,
-0.11181624978780746,
-0.09227217733860016,
-0.1421232372522354,
-0.1128913015127182,
0.08820764720439911,
-0.3127952218055725,
0.3925386369228363,
0.19624242186546326,
-0.10814741998910904,
-0.002324430039152503,
0.22691060602664948,
-0.12668563425540924,
0.4364708960056305,
-0.6879429817199707,
0.06277954578399658,
-0.45326972007751465,
0.1054266020655632,
-1.3782403469085693,
-0.1500934362411499,
0.46176767349243164,
-0.7277554273605347,
0.3853502869606018,
-0.2269531488418579,
-0.915532112121582,
-0.5738947987556458,
-0.853732705116272,
0.5678457617759705,
0.802529513835907,
-0.4592098593711853,
0.9831190705299377,
0.40431660413742065,
-0.23655764758586884,
-0.25665387511253357,
-0.8793517351150513,
-0.2504785358905792,
-0.15082906186580658,
-0.9829391837120056,
0.0824170708656311,
0.07444628328084946,
-0.24952451884746552,
-0.03626854345202446,
0.3588625490665436,
-0.27068012952804565,
0.13796310126781464,
0.05951699614524841,
0.20935453474521637,
0.17270062863826752,
0.19379861652851105,
0.5453962087631226,
0.638039767742157,
0.14643754065036774,
0.4859828054904938,
0.6598552465438843,
-0.19913530349731445,
-0.01885806955397129,
-0.5524140000343323,
0.7574748992919922,
0.5792692303657532,
0.4954465925693512,
1.2726985216140747,
0.7871158719062805,
-0.4021241366863251,
-0.09205065667629242,
-0.6800683736801147,
-0.38222628831863403,
-0.5098428130149841,
-0.23051927983760834,
0.0917809009552002,
-1.0485061407089233,
0.8840948939323425,
0.49174731969833374,
0.08326457440853119,
0.38454505801200867,
0.4305669665336609,
-0.6765451431274414,
1.4001619815826416,
0.8968467712402344,
-0.03588177636265755,
0.8377023339271545,
-0.0368693582713604,
0.5943493247032166,
-0.506027340888977,
-0.03626225143671036,
-0.38399237394332886,
-0.43590694665908813,
-1.0388171672821045,
0.008291484788060188,
0.10209143906831741,
-0.02906377799808979,
-0.22673271596431732,
0.29131487011909485,
-0.46419453620910645,
0.25177082419395447,
0.5040122270584106,
0.32956385612487793,
-0.3897261917591095,
-0.10353749245405197,
0.4696938097476959,
-0.4310195744037628,
-0.47589200735092163,
-0.5027777552604675,
0.8056700825691223,
0.7168697714805603,
0.6542933583259583,
0.4747283458709717,
0.901789128780365,
0.9393256306648254,
0.5746197700500488,
-0.7214870452880859,
0.5596963763237,
-0.3978795111179352,
-1.1355226039886475,
-0.4658711552619934,
-0.2984310984611511,
-0.8924617767333984,
-0.06118328496813774,
-0.26592087745666504,
-0.8981944918632507,
0.20392955839633942,
-0.08724991977214813,
-0.00028530933195725083,
0.294904500246048,
-0.9142686724662781,
0.5328664779663086,
-0.17206832766532898,
0.25019577145576477,
0.010956577025353909,
-0.6491137146949768,
0.3476378619670868,
-0.04869498685002327,
0.43036872148513794,
-0.5663169026374817,
-0.04630204662680626,
1.1745338439941406,
-0.1831379383802414,
1.2985048294067383,
-0.2850516140460968,
0.035444680601358414,
0.27517250180244446,
0.0029315778519958258,
0.1648065149784088,
0.037188947200775146,
0.19956853985786438,
0.5642016530036926,
-0.18518878519535065,
-0.5080484747886658,
-0.336764395236969,
0.5338183045387268,
-0.8865838050842285,
-0.4406662881374359,
-0.4430823028087616,
-0.3052465617656708,
0.15501905977725983,
0.1567656546831131,
0.014433438889682293,
-0.06426290422677994,
-0.1518397331237793,
0.2190721482038498,
0.47599291801452637,
-0.37453481554985046,
0.7266055941581726,
0.08477940410375595,
-0.3080282509326935,
-0.4673025608062744,
0.810556948184967,
0.1432487517595291,
0.04384738579392433,
0.28620848059654236,
0.3594001829624176,
-0.20193983614444733,
0.07380473613739014,
-0.22838270664215088,
0.40654852986335754,
-0.6690181493759155,
0.01534212101250887,
-0.636978268623352,
0.0041675991378724575,
-0.8051838874816895,
-0.5906944870948792,
-0.1927502155303955,
-0.5346411466598511,
-0.5718895792961121,
0.23285438120365143,
0.447588711977005,
0.8580825924873352,
0.007780394516885281,
0.5763198733329773,
-0.9317821264266968,
0.33532899618148804,
0.4784494936466217,
0.031376246362924576,
-0.12547148764133453,
-0.40714988112449646,
0.08395374566316605,
-0.11074577271938324,
-0.28519168496131897,
-1.234920620918274,
0.5009104013442993,
0.21900783479213715,
0.47446271777153015,
0.610460102558136,
-0.11920724809169769,
0.024310637265443802,
-0.47193577885627747,
0.9613547921180725,
0.5677517056465149,
-1.4117796421051025,
0.8455648422241211,
-0.6775651574134827,
-0.25828155875205994,
0.2732078433036804,
0.4619792103767395,
-0.42119327187538147,
-0.6822236776351929,
-0.6498591303825378,
-0.7848090529441833,
0.7313085198402405,
1.015663743019104,
0.27820006012916565,
-0.11040512472391129,
0.4771949350833893,
0.1725732535123825,
0.5081556439399719,
-0.6276683211326599,
-0.5183275938034058,
-0.19133830070495605,
-0.421525239944458,
0.08910511434078217,
-0.8641965985298157,
-0.21829001605510712,
-0.6443096995353699,
0.33942094445228577,
0.08906888961791992,
0.9337280988693237,
-0.11241301149129868,
0.01538387406617403,
-0.037490833550691605,
0.2191833257675171,
0.4975561499595642,
0.5307270288467407,
-0.6686608195304871,
-0.211462140083313,
0.1534568816423416,
-0.3286695182323456,
-0.060792841017246246,
-0.08261239528656006,
-0.17860989272594452,
0.4820367991924286,
0.5731533169746399,
0.4216170012950897,
0.2768663465976715,
-0.33453401923179626,
0.9263864755630493,
-0.3257751762866974,
-0.17314592003822327,
-0.415081650018692,
-0.2708967328071594,
0.08192809671163559,
0.3493587076663971,
0.49715498089790344,
-0.34626656770706177,
0.2501741051673889,
-0.9050952792167664,
-0.23758669197559357,
0.44220271706581116,
-0.4839802384376526,
-0.5663893818855286,
0.39870598912239075,
0.5237175226211548,
-0.4952991306781769,
0.6065272092819214,
-0.06049773097038269,
-0.9199385046958923,
0.8554085493087769,
0.30425575375556946,
1.313151240348816,
-0.3001466393470764,
0.5667856931686401,
-0.0637613832950592,
0.696751058101654,
0.023224467411637306,
0.9767109751701355,
0.04477529972791672,
-0.9898894429206848,
0.05872049555182457,
-0.3900041878223419,
-0.44947782158851624,
-0.5889126658439636,
-0.7847055196762085,
0.4510299861431122,
-0.732879638671875,
-0.7064254879951477,
0.6302093267440796,
-0.4351517856121063,
-0.6410294771194458,
0.14375023543834686,
0.4957840144634247,
0.3714864253997803,
-1.3562215566635132,
0.5196741819381714,
0.8237099647521973,
-0.4107789695262909,
-0.2953210175037384,
0.036164164543151855,
-0.0054973638616502285,
-0.6454944610595703,
1.1139851808547974,
0.5227617025375366,
-0.022902637720108032,
-0.5075851678848267,
-0.9476675391197205,
-0.5265655517578125,
0.9762057065963745,
0.3135153353214264,
-0.3213322162628174,
0.1207045316696167,
0.21743711829185486,
0.6559726595878601,
-0.4894386827945709,
0.40862521529197693,
0.39256587624549866,
0.4760138988494873,
-0.28667277097702026,
-0.9406369924545288,
-0.04173407703638077,
-0.06771485507488251,
0.33635061979293823,
0.33118268847465515,
-0.6224896311759949,
1.398113489151001,
0.11074210703372955,
-0.40294021368026733,
-0.14605379104614258,
0.5601199865341187,
0.06424415856599808,
0.44307941198349,
0.728031575679779,
0.02639860473573208,
0.3377540409564972,
-0.2550031244754791,
1.2031017541885376,
-0.02130802348256111,
0.7983983159065247,
0.2624339759349823,
-0.18238946795463562,
0.7003403306007385,
0.6814364194869995,
-0.12803076207637787,
0.7500985860824585,
0.45862600207328796,
0.012327811680734158,
0.5655428171157837,
-0.06984659284353256,
-0.06701859086751938,
-0.2926521599292755,
-0.32620859146118164,
-0.06461869180202484,
0.14191438257694244,
0.4704633355140686,
-0.8544777035713196,
-0.07073444873094559,
0.25400182604789734,
-0.041261281818151474,
-0.31092190742492676,
-0.23648884892463684,
0.5961410403251648,
0.2588863670825958,
0.0360393263399601,
-0.058615412563085556,
0.1237248033285141,
0.9385800361633301,
-0.24668444693088531,
-0.17646034061908722,
0.2036045491695404,
0.10230499505996704,
-0.05971765145659447,
-1.0057727098464966,
0.30305400490760803,
-0.040532004088163376,
-0.339363157749176,
-0.42578965425491333,
1.1558187007904053,
-0.1364763230085373,
-0.8430923223495483,
0.5626713037490845,
0.4887942373752594,
-0.02371702902019024,
-0.003114262828603387,
-0.9223318099975586,
-0.0476156547665596,
-0.05601682513952255,
-0.1533578485250473,
0.2141510397195816,
0.501275360584259,
-0.05439833179116249,
0.7517568469047546,
0.49717602133750916,
-0.29308217763900757,
0.04986735060811043,
0.5002970099449158,
0.6376206278800964,
-0.8365286588668823,
-0.4380486011505127,
-1.068895936012268,
0.14765609800815582,
-0.3001815974712372,
-0.23954994976520538,
0.9379574656486511,
0.08556807041168213,
0.37574467062950134,
-0.3192386031150818,
0.6672924757003784,
-0.6031439900398254,
0.8223237991333008,
-0.18394514918327332,
1.0607367753982544,
-0.7274735569953918,
0.24541521072387695,
-0.44746923446655273,
-0.7810473442077637,
-0.2677013874053955,
0.5268720984458923,
-0.36684855818748474,
0.28901195526123047,
0.5573105812072754,
0.30576151609420776,
0.19885043799877167,
0.4754217267036438,
0.15319445729255676,
-0.17414677143096924,
0.37939614057540894,
-0.07903933525085449,
1.2360178232192993,
-0.5030287504196167,
0.26377755403518677,
-0.5877776741981506,
-0.1730881631374359,
-0.5391700863838196,
-0.8066975474357605,
-1.7214123010635376,
-0.4901915192604065,
-0.4249128997325897,
-0.47563794255256653,
-0.03069518692791462,
1.0144853591918945,
0.34521374106407166,
-0.950924277305603,
-0.13769879937171936,
0.15003857016563416,
0.6274638772010803,
0.08045639842748642,
-0.32044506072998047,
0.3232432007789612,
-0.13777807354927063,
-0.7745908498764038,
-0.4478623569011688,
0.07858105003833771,
0.2704527974128723,
-0.033377159386873245,
0.3175605833530426,
-0.325122207403183,
0.44939321279525757,
1.0181154012680054,
-0.0708862841129303,
-0.7982665300369263,
-0.7876618504524231,
0.052455805242061615,
-0.21077071130275726,
-0.273028701543808,
1.121986746788025,
0.09703977406024933,
0.28638407588005066,
0.9681708216667175,
0.24601520597934723,
-0.014664055779576302,
0.04796295240521431,
0.5569377541542053,
-0.8040571808815002,
-0.12781907618045807,
0.46633967757225037,
0.37119561433792114,
0.4134656488895416,
-0.6665287017822266,
0.14875313639640808,
0.2160879522562027,
-0.5539502501487732,
-0.8435158133506775,
-0.2690373361110687,
-1.2835606336593628,
-0.28923895955085754,
1.440791130065918,
0.0075743114575743675,
-0.4253382980823517,
-0.2926097512245178,
-0.34398606419563293,
0.2139100283384323,
-0.8587164878845215,
0.9519113898277283,
0.8649595975875854,
-0.2342240959405899,
-0.16051028668880463,
-0.5347365736961365,
0.3738253116607666,
0.36134985089302063,
-0.3981870710849762,
-0.538931667804718,
-0.06913973391056061,
0.2979731559753418,
0.19616229832172394,
0.4591657817363739,
0.2370905578136444,
0.20472387969493866,
-0.32239583134651184,
0.09295573085546494,
0.4241458773612976,
0.008380639366805553,
-0.19002173840999603,
-0.11108551919460297,
-0.18903501331806183,
-0.4519746005535126
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09569v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09569v1
|
Speech ReaLLM -- Real-time Streaming Speech Recognition with Multimodal LLMs by Teaching the Flow of Time
| 2024-06-13T20:20:29 | 2024-06-13T20:20:29 |
Frank Seide, Morrie Doulaty, Yangyang Shi, Yashesh Gaur, Junteng Jia, Chunyang Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We introduce Speech ReaLLM, a new ASR architecture that marries
"decoder-only" ASR with the RNN-T to make multimodal LLM architectures capable
of real-time streaming. This is the first "decoder-only" ASR architecture
designed to handle continuous audio without explicit end-pointing. Speech
ReaLLM is a special case of the more general ReaLLM ("real-time LLM") approach,
also introduced here for the first time. The idea is inspired by RNN-T: Instead
of generating a response only at the end of a user prompt, generate after every
input token received in real time (it is often empty). On Librispeech "test",
an 80M Speech ReaLLM achieves WERs of 3.0% and 7.4% in real time (without an
external LM or auxiliary loss). This is only slightly above a 3x larger
Attention-Encoder-Decoder baseline. We also show that this way, an LLM
architecture can learn to represent and reproduce the flow of time; and that a
pre-trained 7B LLM can be fine-tuned to do reasonably well on this task.
|
[
-0.1357969343662262,
-0.9381362795829773,
0.35218116641044617,
0.25149664282798767,
-0.6868860125541687,
0.494951456785202,
-0.04297211766242981,
-0.638763427734375,
0.4002300500869751,
0.20369020104408264,
-0.8442496657371521,
-0.13229875266551971,
-0.47411516308784485,
-0.22538481652736664,
-0.5933583974838257,
0.5495570302009583,
0.1869029402732849,
0.36456337571144104,
-0.08305588364601135,
-0.22273918986320496,
-0.05282934755086899,
-0.7858507633209229,
-0.9972921013832092,
-0.48009997606277466,
0.9888654351234436,
0.09896767884492874,
0.42994147539138794,
0.7980153560638428,
0.3161441683769226,
0.14953568577766418,
-0.08564837276935577,
0.019630469381809235,
-0.27445971965789795,
0.4030172526836395,
0.32151320576667786,
-0.34982815384864807,
-0.5308771729469299,
-0.1046653613448143,
0.8789660334587097,
0.3339957892894745,
-0.20425951480865479,
0.4768771231174469,
-0.11659443378448486,
0.5851956009864807,
-0.529779314994812,
0.07055848836898804,
-0.27624160051345825,
0.2757476568222046,
-0.5108643770217896,
-0.4113287031650543,
-0.4269520342350006,
-0.37165510654449463,
0.026099499315023422,
-0.46296554803848267,
-0.014628221280872822,
0.15999136865139008,
0.6954660415649414,
0.5364029407501221,
-0.21725115180015564,
-0.07708710432052612,
-1.081973671913147,
0.5733904838562012,
-0.6451672315597534,
0.8214010000228882,
-0.034402210265398026,
0.8019126057624817,
0.27253735065460205,
-1.0274577140808105,
-0.6460782885551453,
-0.2448868751525879,
0.3713408410549164,
0.29257744550704956,
0.10136018693447113,
0.11124283075332642,
0.20669102668762207,
0.07924358546733856,
-0.7278884649276733,
-0.0685100108385086,
-0.5542354583740234,
-0.24411502480506897,
0.5211220979690552,
0.219910129904747,
-0.02238205447793007,
0.5234168767929077,
-0.5649617314338684,
0.09249871224164963,
-0.6360898017883301,
0.2172192484140396,
0.19870106875896454,
0.10403040051460266,
-0.15086974203586578,
0.3542453348636627,
0.02993420511484146,
0.7496817708015442,
-0.2870234549045563,
-0.29147040843963623,
0.2935742139816284,
-0.21570207178592682,
-0.3022521436214447,
0.6169617772102356,
0.5579232573509216,
-0.18215855956077576,
0.31127113103866577,
-0.05162675678730011,
-0.23296333849430084,
0.21249262988567352,
0.21921177208423615,
-0.6501660346984863,
0.05399699881672859,
0.26414933800697327,
-0.4812924861907959,
-0.1820230931043625,
-0.1581292450428009,
-0.28462886810302734,
0.1507207602262497,
-0.5636196136474609,
0.4852718114852905,
-0.17666009068489075,
-0.2993116080760956,
-0.11981306225061417,
-0.041074950248003006,
0.4671558737754822,
0.29377031326293945,
-0.14670246839523315,
0.3071192502975464,
0.7001318335533142,
0.9888433218002319,
-0.1411943882703781,
-0.2928696870803833,
-1.041101336479187,
0.1483069807291031,
-0.20289523899555206,
0.861238956451416,
-0.4376307725906372,
-0.4186793267726898,
-0.04757897928357124,
-0.32342833280563354,
0.18469560146331787,
-0.4354512393474579,
0.47311004996299744,
-0.7621327042579651,
0.18046633899211884,
0.11350587755441666,
-0.7716819047927856,
0.07158532738685608,
0.14854814112186432,
-0.34427231550216675,
0.5658503174781799,
-0.2151370793581009,
-0.2095569372177124,
0.29007571935653687,
-0.948089063167572,
-0.5105141997337341,
0.23120634257793427,
0.024685600772500038,
-0.3544091582298279,
-0.20876365900039673,
-0.2450600415468216,
0.2316824048757553,
-0.13651078939437866,
0.15034057199954987,
-0.2401098757982254,
-0.353465735912323,
0.5174105763435364,
-1.0293024778366089,
0.7197434902191162,
0.7570500373840332,
-0.033344633877277374,
0.37361231446266174,
-0.9168636798858643,
0.10022225975990295,
0.01943380758166313,
-0.5854196548461914,
0.23297423124313354,
0.2701961100101471,
0.18387052416801453,
0.29837357997894287,
0.11161573976278305,
-0.8882933855056763,
-0.16533979773521423,
-0.2669655382633209,
0.6094861626625061,
0.762464165687561,
-0.16511432826519012,
0.20271523296833038,
-0.5997177362442017,
0.45710840821266174,
-0.028491811826825142,
0.4305848777294159,
-0.2529897093772888,
-0.438286691904068,
-0.8161751627922058,
-0.517066478729248,
0.21605654060840607,
0.6930165886878967,
-0.5413153171539307,
0.08892834931612015,
-0.4552282989025116,
-0.4817669093608856,
-0.7542283535003662,
-0.1332661211490631,
0.5746052265167236,
0.6651251316070557,
0.41175395250320435,
0.10909294337034225,
-0.6147536039352417,
-0.46163421869277954,
-0.11191792041063309,
-0.05789761617779732,
-0.03383762761950493,
0.1484469324350357,
-0.023824648931622505,
-0.07585922628641129,
0.7684481739997864,
-0.3823299705982208,
-0.32002270221710205,
-0.21700365841388702,
0.13734237849712372,
0.09248471260070801,
0.34208476543426514,
0.18296176195144653,
-0.7455189824104309,
-0.4949120581150055,
-0.44026002287864685,
-0.7529603838920593,
-0.11487699300050735,
-0.002268184209242463,
0.3662554919719696,
0.17781278491020203,
0.5922113656997681,
-0.306235671043396,
0.31421032547950745,
0.5842143297195435,
-0.3660221993923187,
0.4543464779853821,
-0.2931828796863556,
-0.2928486466407776,
-0.8087677359580994,
-0.22098663449287415,
-0.4586903750896454,
-0.5209226012229919,
-0.7703317999839783,
-0.16894188523292542,
-0.043820030987262726,
-0.5013708472251892,
-1.1176518201828003,
0.9795136451721191,
-0.5290172696113586,
-0.28966206312179565,
-0.2551875114440918,
0.13492348790168762,
-0.11569501459598541,
0.44013577699661255,
0.11988038569688797,
0.5522789359092712,
0.49463337659835815,
-0.8525447845458984,
0.7984221577644348,
-0.20555612444877625,
-0.20262005925178528,
0.4271896481513977,
-0.5466487407684326,
0.1800098866224289,
-0.21246640384197235,
0.4010329246520996,
-0.7497891783714294,
-0.0062476471066474915,
0.1583302766084671,
-0.5806009769439697,
0.2946164608001709,
-0.03419577702879906,
-0.09054481238126755,
-0.3332075774669647,
-0.14146286249160767,
0.40042170882225037,
0.6276475191116333,
-0.47361716628074646,
0.8217920660972595,
0.1490447074174881,
-0.15309208631515503,
-0.4023534059524536,
-0.8438405394554138,
0.016896042972803116,
-0.08473202586174011,
-0.5505586862564087,
0.1946476399898529,
-0.3413476049900055,
-0.3259657621383667,
0.21096032857894897,
-0.042944278568029404,
-0.3449314832687378,
0.044466495513916016,
0.26873716711997986,
0.30843421816825867,
-0.3272612988948822,
0.01641317829489708,
-0.20546212792396545,
-0.3360574543476105,
-0.18304555118083954,
-0.4894348382949829,
0.4733964502811432,
0.14175856113433838,
-0.7440047264099121,
-0.9112340807914734,
0.3170161545276642,
0.6761800646781921,
-0.1899610310792923,
0.417603075504303,
0.8067038655281067,
-0.22123166918754578,
-0.0039558252319693565,
-0.6018275618553162,
-0.1335727721452713,
-0.4263240694999695,
0.006023278925567865,
-0.3829905688762665,
-0.8910993933677673,
0.4679325222969055,
0.3726047873497009,
0.4215952754020691,
0.021649902686476707,
0.43550407886505127,
-0.5255073308944702,
0.6145613789558411,
0.280566930770874,
0.10385855287313461,
0.8952223658561707,
-0.23788975179195404,
0.08736369013786316,
-0.7450118064880371,
-0.3987170159816742,
-0.1586151421070099,
-0.6200597286224365,
-0.07057983428239822,
-0.47151023149490356,
0.3351326286792755,
-0.2250482589006424,
-0.34270989894866943,
-0.0851096510887146,
-0.3318307101726532,
0.21849782764911652,
0.6715360879898071,
-0.059246230870485306,
0.2591954171657562,
-0.08183012902736664,
0.05019496753811836,
0.08877193182706833,
-0.7299842238426208,
-0.2915845513343811,
0.9465641975402832,
0.5018337368965149,
0.9000684022903442,
0.024593502283096313,
0.6536622047424316,
0.6793600916862488,
0.2643994092941284,
-0.9615504145622253,
0.6077148914337158,
-0.17017501592636108,
-0.48956605792045593,
-0.4529261291027069,
-0.18082810938358307,
-0.7318046689033508,
0.30486980080604553,
-0.0033072486985474825,
0.02079402655363083,
0.05069328099489212,
0.5189175009727478,
-0.5775464177131653,
0.370812326669693,
-0.5092988610267639,
0.3407856523990631,
-0.5888606905937195,
-0.35048457980155945,
-0.23499569296836853,
-0.8623532652854919,
0.09365399926900864,
0.23011314868927002,
0.39641523361206055,
-0.49419647455215454,
-0.1928112953901291,
0.7965867519378662,
-0.24803966283798218,
0.5197982788085938,
-0.5613094568252563,
0.22483503818511963,
0.5435095429420471,
0.06377409398555756,
0.3088895082473755,
-0.06012069806456566,
0.08122868090867996,
0.10595899820327759,
-0.02589842863380909,
-0.31160685420036316,
-0.5010733604431152,
0.43445026874542236,
-0.6897485256195068,
-0.2601625919342041,
-0.5643669366836548,
-0.24541151523590088,
-0.015899140387773514,
-0.01853528618812561,
0.16164463758468628,
1.091879963874817,
-0.1558079570531845,
0.23735719919204712,
0.7589716911315918,
0.19794867932796478,
0.7617599368095398,
0.6289899349212646,
-0.2936699688434601,
-0.3581830561161041,
1.093449592590332,
0.28437766432762146,
0.3819213807582855,
0.6731427907943726,
0.31391435861587524,
-0.7173892855644226,
-0.4558025598526001,
-0.5072184205055237,
0.14846040308475494,
-0.5017105937004089,
-0.09801122546195984,
-0.7368448376655579,
-0.7109729051589966,
-0.310783326625824,
-0.25888192653656006,
-0.5097488164901733,
-0.4345962703227997,
-0.6373738050460815,
-0.028314312919974327,
0.17384909093379974,
0.3668331801891327,
-0.06995659321546555,
0.3816260099411011,
-1.037809133529663,
0.610175371170044,
0.7648719549179077,
0.1284235715866089,
-0.1423490047454834,
-0.7825976014137268,
0.06925687938928604,
0.08180338889360428,
0.09170867502689362,
-0.46251603960990906,
0.48607879877090454,
0.6758773922920227,
0.6568941473960876,
0.507489025592804,
-0.06532229483127594,
0.7199059724807739,
-0.6896494030952454,
1.0302790403366089,
0.2417709231376648,
-0.6340740323066711,
0.1422523707151413,
0.16985751688480377,
0.46115943789482117,
0.0007256937678903341,
0.05582384392619133,
-0.6785813570022583,
-0.29124972224235535,
-0.49611252546310425,
-0.623866856098175,
0.5774262547492981,
-0.05355264991521835,
0.036244768649339676,
0.23163966834545135,
0.13314084708690643,
-0.20884515345096588,
0.2519374489784241,
-0.5438797473907471,
-0.39153963327407837,
-0.5698053240776062,
-0.2199682742357254,
-0.151776984333992,
-0.5346322059631348,
-0.020615804940462112,
-0.2008516788482666,
0.448451429605484,
0.1634787768125534,
0.6209717988967896,
0.38808584213256836,
-0.34090813994407654,
0.047443635761737823,
0.45611047744750977,
1.1156535148620605,
0.6893967390060425,
-0.3472903370857239,
0.37301287055015564,
0.05917522683739662,
-0.4412608742713928,
0.44980067014694214,
-0.20883482694625854,
-0.14821642637252808,
0.09932413697242737,
0.5011551976203918,
1.1550875902175903,
0.2526032030582428,
-0.7138631939888,
0.26846587657928467,
-0.06329359114170074,
-0.3065219521522522,
-0.7381588220596313,
0.05761575698852539,
0.2021767944097519,
0.3277587592601776,
0.574613094329834,
-0.01579931564629078,
-0.16770781576633453,
-0.5802382230758667,
0.2724117040634155,
0.23314160108566284,
-0.6532544493675232,
-0.44291064143180847,
0.8768993616104126,
0.2762926518917084,
-0.7474706172943115,
0.3899911046028137,
-0.21721412241458893,
-0.3716973066329956,
0.31154000759124756,
0.7924339771270752,
1.0579700469970703,
-0.263583242893219,
-0.038077209144830704,
0.08690165728330612,
-0.20486590266227722,
0.20032691955566406,
0.6310308575630188,
-0.2500271499156952,
-0.6843352317810059,
-0.5682225823402405,
-0.9458721876144409,
-0.4899235665798187,
-0.021981386467814445,
-0.5599882006645203,
0.1109597235918045,
-0.5539949536323547,
-0.13702426850795746,
-0.13560988008975983,
-0.4088367521762848,
-0.27854377031326294,
0.30552369356155396,
0.3533163368701935,
1.0091828107833862,
-0.457955539226532,
1.1607900857925415,
0.6586393713951111,
-0.04434090107679367,
-0.3818580210208893,
-0.20555374026298523,
0.1319642812013626,
-0.8936768770217896,
0.8492571115493774,
-0.37566429376602173,
-0.5089467763900757,
0.3957456648349762,
-0.433961421251297,
-0.7120617032051086,
1.1354756355285645,
0.2488885372877121,
-0.8299058079719543,
-0.24292930960655212,
-0.2379804104566574,
0.4553575813770294,
-0.4409586489200592,
-0.14066581428050995,
0.032363198697566986,
0.31189149618148804,
0.5043972134590149,
-0.8295273780822754,
-0.5684953331947327,
0.033392127603292465,
-0.056849852204322815,
0.06837893277406693,
-0.5400480031967163,
0.8303200006484985,
-0.14329791069030762,
-0.37336495518684387,
-0.34261029958724976,
0.8379775285720825,
0.35467618703842163,
0.5336152911186218,
0.5560041666030884,
0.3133057653903961,
0.6246809363365173,
-0.13056974112987518,
0.9668184518814087,
-0.23370787501335144,
-0.04432054981589317,
1.2790580987930298,
-0.3126336336135864,
1.0970442295074463,
0.5130711197853088,
-0.15487276017665863,
0.1878596991300583,
0.4127173125743866,
0.3823806047439575,
0.7917487025260925,
0.029978564009070396,
-0.682376503944397,
-0.27336785197257996,
-0.16062016785144806,
-0.3031461834907532,
0.28522002696990967,
0.4315190315246582,
0.12896759808063507,
-0.13335120677947998,
0.4788561165332794,
-0.1271226555109024,
-0.05909019336104393,
-0.48870357871055603,
0.8135964274406433,
0.29438114166259766,
-0.16582132875919342,
0.5568212866783142,
-0.4486682116985321,
0.9567476511001587,
-1.054571509361267,
0.1312892585992813,
-0.044153399765491486,
0.10671546310186386,
-0.08311402052640915,
-0.8147892951965332,
0.6276901960372925,
0.08142710477113724,
-0.1420244723558426,
-0.5330066680908203,
0.7987071871757507,
-0.5211950540542603,
-0.4377545118331909,
0.3864922523498535,
0.4960489273071289,
0.3455545902252197,
0.08655330538749695,
-0.6277140378952026,
0.2516750991344452,
-0.1262727826833725,
-0.08632807433605194,
0.22238370776176453,
-0.0008998175035230815,
0.11924489587545395,
1.209408164024353,
0.959449291229248,
0.5123713612556458,
0.738899290561676,
0.24935488402843475,
0.6243100762367249,
-0.5884920954704285,
-0.5239731073379517,
-0.865317165851593,
0.49254319071769714,
0.28031888604164124,
0.027636045590043068,
0.3123760223388672,
0.5692421197891235,
0.6990147233009338,
0.03926263749599457,
0.6590028405189514,
-0.004625352099537849,
0.7347036600112915,
-0.5727748870849609,
0.6593447327613831,
-0.6550074815750122,
-0.1360582411289215,
0.3250400125980377,
-0.7794815301895142,
-0.3343546390533447,
0.45203912258148193,
0.22287017107009888,
-0.47150668501853943,
0.5266632437705994,
0.4660729169845581,
0.05513975769281387,
-0.1562107503414154,
0.7372564077377319,
0.08109675347805023,
0.5938017964363098,
0.19529882073402405,
0.9793938994407654,
-0.19688911736011505,
0.7411237955093384,
-0.18684852123260498,
-0.006884894333779812,
-0.3297991454601288,
-0.7231979370117188,
-0.36574164032936096,
-0.5099494457244873,
-0.2603643536567688,
-0.11991231143474579,
0.3188554346561432,
1.0907819271087646,
0.5891485810279846,
-0.7191360592842102,
-0.2878573536872864,
0.28636327385902405,
0.03147168457508087,
-0.42097821831703186,
-0.19217176735401154,
0.0959407314658165,
-0.34341520071029663,
-0.5483748316764832,
0.7905487418174744,
0.4518575072288513,
0.16666066646575928,
-0.4431013762950897,
-0.32784563302993774,
-0.25010478496551514,
0.041912976652383804,
0.8154850006103516,
0.49553823471069336,
-0.7637085914611816,
-0.310031533241272,
0.13114294409751892,
-0.018078181892633438,
0.3294225335121155,
0.8092288970947266,
-0.7222897410392761,
0.5758069157600403,
0.5782861113548279,
0.5247300863265991,
0.7062663435935974,
-0.021519672125577927,
0.2796260118484497,
-0.6563377976417542,
0.30636662244796753,
0.586930513381958,
0.18166588246822357,
0.07326743751764297,
0.019498081877827644,
0.18307502567768097,
0.5075629949569702,
-0.5527685880661011,
-0.8522785305976868,
0.283952534198761,
-1.0761115550994873,
0.004934001713991165,
0.8133166432380676,
-0.14376959204673767,
-0.2773491144180298,
-0.5098275542259216,
-0.15801303088665009,
0.6196368336677551,
-0.5233684182167053,
0.24140116572380066,
0.3151366114616394,
-0.48628324270248413,
-0.37420180439949036,
-0.6517565846443176,
0.2797244191169739,
-0.17079634964466095,
-0.4816858768463135,
-0.0763031393289566,
0.3956579267978668,
0.4715605676174164,
0.15047593414783478,
0.9264163970947266,
-0.10787633061408997,
0.23972614109516144,
-0.046008531004190445,
-0.01100421417504549,
-0.6980457901954651,
-0.5465388894081116,
-0.37340059876441956,
0.35716360807418823,
0.11737718433141708,
-0.5888751745223999
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09559v1
|
Decoding the Diversity: A Review of the Indic AI Research Landscape
| 2024-06-13T19:55:20 | 2024-06-13T19:55:20 |
Sankalp KJ, Vinija Jain, Sreyoshi Bhaduri, Tamoghna Roy, Aman Chadha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
This review paper provides a comprehensive overview of large language model
(LLM) research directions within Indic languages. Indic languages are those
spoken in the Indian subcontinent, including India, Pakistan, Bangladesh, Sri
Lanka, Nepal, and Bhutan, among others. These languages have a rich cultural
and linguistic heritage and are spoken by over 1.5 billion people worldwide.
With the tremendous market potential and growing demand for natural language
processing (NLP) based applications in diverse languages, generative
applications for Indic languages pose unique challenges and opportunities for
research. Our paper deep dives into the recent advancements in Indic generative
modeling, contributing with a taxonomy of research directions, tabulating 84
recent publications. Research directions surveyed in this paper include LLM
development, fine-tuning existing LLMs, development of corpora, benchmarking
and evaluation, as well as publications around specific techniques, tools, and
applications. We found that researchers across the publications emphasize the
challenges associated with limited data availability, lack of standardization,
and the peculiar linguistic complexities of Indic languages. This work aims to
serve as a valuable resource for researchers and practitioners working in the
field of NLP, particularly those focused on Indic languages, and contributes to
the development of more accurate and efficient LLM applications for these
languages.
|
[
-0.33279168605804443,
-0.29333677887916565,
0.1315922737121582,
0.6174391508102417,
-0.1373707503080368,
0.635460376739502,
-0.4829367995262146,
-0.785602331161499,
-0.08930349349975586,
0.41259244084358215,
-0.3977595269680023,
-0.6029122471809387,
-0.6323635578155518,
0.6220158338546753,
-0.5755178332328796,
0.7087762951850891,
0.027590349316596985,
0.2696273624897003,
-0.07471239566802979,
-0.5267049074172974,
-0.4293065369129181,
-0.2384270876646042,
-0.49028468132019043,
-0.2510809600353241,
0.1292484998703003,
0.4344710409641266,
0.4018386900424957,
0.48033103346824646,
0.5460979342460632,
0.2978598475456238,
-0.4006511867046356,
0.2686474025249481,
-0.31156378984451294,
0.4351072609424591,
-0.0469757504761219,
-0.5625953078269958,
0.004430790897458792,
-0.2584739923477173,
0.8006359338760376,
0.91571044921875,
-0.07682027667760849,
0.09012367576360703,
0.16115912795066833,
0.5320985317230225,
-0.4302222430706024,
0.19102409482002258,
-0.4713019132614136,
0.017248617485165596,
-0.5423718690872192,
-0.24104474484920502,
-0.30251896381378174,
-0.2679658532142639,
-0.09500850737094879,
-0.30554717779159546,
0.0883714109659195,
-0.04943864420056343,
0.3086118996143341,
0.16598978638648987,
-0.4991810619831085,
-0.5340722799301147,
-1.2316888570785522,
0.9006145000457764,
-0.7808742523193359,
0.24876394867897034,
0.24252358078956604,
0.1539529263973236,
-0.22870835661888123,
-0.42866000533103943,
-0.5559117794036865,
0.03278829902410507,
0.23119723796844482,
-0.015795841813087463,
-0.0393589548766613,
-0.08262158185243607,
-0.07614969462156296,
0.9287760853767395,
-0.5057179927825928,
0.47284233570098877,
-0.38738200068473816,
0.2468547821044922,
0.7764034271240234,
0.5672096610069275,
0.5597646832466125,
0.14775876700878143,
-0.0704977884888649,
-0.005080571398139,
-0.8042525053024292,
0.08226674050092697,
0.5519902110099792,
0.5058934092521667,
-0.4578186571598053,
0.6684752106666565,
-0.321494996547699,
0.8912418484687805,
-0.3126484751701355,
-0.26361411809921265,
0.28997865319252014,
-0.5472229719161987,
-0.12415442615747452,
-0.33622658252716064,
0.6246160268783569,
0.018952393904328346,
-0.058072641491889954,
-0.20573066174983978,
-0.1812153160572052,
-0.21040964126586914,
-0.1329403668642044,
-0.47642698884010315,
-0.01653437875211239,
0.20712123811244965,
-0.5707199573516846,
0.042605940252542496,
-0.3865918815135956,
-0.9299999475479126,
-0.6127275228500366,
-0.30855274200439453,
-0.43146607279777527,
-0.522800624370575,
-0.6808016300201416,
0.047464799135923386,
0.08693066984415054,
0.8437628149986267,
0.3955984115600586,
-1.2126681804656982,
0.2197638601064682,
0.9077017903327942,
0.906929075717926,
-0.28032416105270386,
-0.2999201714992523,
0.305288702249527,
-0.24454578757286072,
-0.33539092540740967,
0.6931778192520142,
-0.9005107879638672,
-0.6265297532081604,
0.2901288568973541,
-0.48458272218704224,
0.04166245087981224,
-0.6658139824867249,
0.5966094136238098,
-0.548085629940033,
-0.11091694235801697,
-0.18323087692260742,
-0.2685243487358093,
-0.32952749729156494,
0.48492419719696045,
-0.6688666939735413,
0.5927298665046692,
0.2819697856903076,
-0.8719333410263062,
0.39154013991355896,
-0.7075176239013672,
-0.5495458841323853,
0.5922674536705017,
-0.5978845953941345,
-0.18934667110443115,
0.0539846234023571,
0.1991906762123108,
0.0668526142835617,
-0.6619167327880859,
0.07112407684326172,
-0.07221989333629608,
-0.20150958001613617,
0.08252057433128357,
-0.40692803263664246,
1.3175302743911743,
0.5383591055870056,
-0.27212977409362793,
0.22539883852005005,
-0.8232654333114624,
-0.25766468048095703,
-0.033770617097616196,
-0.4536745846271515,
-0.3207528293132782,
0.09175185859203339,
0.3612295389175415,
-0.048606161028146744,
-0.03368670865893364,
-0.5822128057479858,
0.21370188891887665,
-0.5421637892723083,
0.512660801410675,
0.537896454334259,
-0.2690308094024658,
0.6030811071395874,
0.025505131110548973,
0.9075923562049866,
0.04248464107513428,
0.10592176020145416,
-0.2376328855752945,
-0.6112971305847168,
-0.6193471550941467,
-0.4166420102119446,
0.24543441832065582,
0.48271799087524414,
-0.501530110836029,
0.19275681674480438,
-0.15183725953102112,
-0.41993898153305054,
-0.9397214651107788,
0.24844291806221008,
-0.1543409526348114,
0.14354875683784485,
0.1815599799156189,
-0.13187697529792786,
-0.8337236046791077,
-0.7487618327140808,
-0.16322271525859833,
-0.16159416735172272,
0.2109946310520172,
0.10682317614555359,
0.32465410232543945,
-0.46722328662872314,
0.8080399036407471,
0.13635623455047607,
-0.14567479491233826,
-0.7305448055267334,
0.22276932001113892,
0.26216113567352295,
0.47029754519462585,
0.4249451756477356,
-0.9493532180786133,
-0.6357851028442383,
0.07790868729352951,
-0.781513512134552,
0.2757026255130768,
0.0014250779058784246,
0.1551625281572342,
0.25703367590904236,
0.3720967769622803,
-0.6279416084289551,
0.3766553997993469,
0.7554279565811157,
-0.10143887996673584,
0.2931932210922241,
0.04535219445824623,
0.07999084144830704,
-1.125246286392212,
0.10292819142341614,
-0.11694911122322083,
0.2895016074180603,
-0.4968814551830292,
0.35101473331451416,
-0.3645116984844208,
-0.040759094059467316,
0.01635834015905857,
0.4822833836078644,
-0.7631653547286987,
0.1245584785938263,
-0.34816041588783264,
-0.3638719320297241,
-0.5822927355766296,
-0.04918547347187996,
-0.12223922461271286,
0.855328381061554,
0.5961635708808899,
-0.4468895494937897,
0.3278784155845642,
0.3311471939086914,
-0.6994238495826721,
0.24635738134384155,
-0.34999528527259827,
-0.15556524693965912,
-0.20010989904403687,
0.16137245297431946,
-1.0674785375595093,
-0.21872210502624512,
0.3228287994861603,
-0.36919277906417847,
0.458413690328598,
-0.05968432500958443,
-0.5704669952392578,
-0.2779146134853363,
-0.190578892827034,
1.0070682764053345,
0.4819260239601135,
-0.5305120944976807,
0.7573302984237671,
0.6278902292251587,
-0.35790422558784485,
-0.859259307384491,
-0.7826699018478394,
0.3986872136592865,
-0.40596798062324524,
-0.6184099912643433,
0.06118112429976463,
-0.2469516098499298,
-0.6459341049194336,
-0.1855136603116989,
0.3233523368835449,
0.12882116436958313,
0.2700996994972229,
0.435375452041626,
0.07756787538528442,
-0.3123566210269928,
-0.1666494756937027,
-0.2631646692752838,
0.0475839264690876,
0.006096809636801481,
-0.16400526463985443,
0.7112085223197937,
-0.16412627696990967,
-0.2682642340660095,
-0.17571894824504852,
0.6757604479789734,
0.5032778978347778,
-0.5070921182632446,
0.7592150568962097,
0.6002858281135559,
-0.3122912049293518,
-0.4494844377040863,
-0.3779689073562622,
0.10263670980930328,
-0.3898414969444275,
0.35654306411743164,
-0.271677166223526,
-1.0386725664138794,
0.8083921074867249,
-0.07368739694356918,
0.13966324925422668,
0.5895235538482666,
0.8979892134666443,
0.14819535613059998,
0.8060534596443176,
1.2858796119689941,
-0.4296662211418152,
0.3097887933254242,
-0.3377286195755005,
0.5799950957298279,
-0.828959584236145,
-0.47238484025001526,
-0.8078129887580872,
-0.23458322882652283,
-0.9738911986351013,
-0.23976995050907135,
0.2339097410440445,
-0.05913469195365906,
-0.08193188905715942,
-0.05684322118759155,
-0.5432370901107788,
0.37942180037498474,
0.5841533541679382,
-0.3741452395915985,
0.5149326324462891,
0.17563071846961975,
0.17006179690361023,
-0.18860673904418945,
-0.6970242261886597,
-0.33869534730911255,
1.200087308883667,
0.32898709177970886,
1.0213302373886108,
0.21055011451244354,
0.6470654606819153,
0.24531641602516174,
0.5127285718917847,
-0.5608207583427429,
0.32828617095947266,
-0.2461162805557251,
-0.6365622282028198,
-0.3728952705860138,
-0.21599993109703064,
-1.0282469987869263,
0.27524709701538086,
-0.054400235414505005,
-0.5535303950309753,
0.3146570324897766,
-0.21535742282867432,
-0.25957223773002625,
0.6008181571960449,
-0.21567800641059875,
0.4862070083618164,
-0.13598378002643585,
0.01780407316982746,
-0.26274919509887695,
-0.6916531324386597,
0.7442511320114136,
0.35606062412261963,
0.26203039288520813,
-0.004149405751377344,
0.16857273876667023,
0.5024620890617371,
0.08574440330266953,
0.7608265280723572,
0.24850967526435852,
-0.3163263499736786,
0.39131107926368713,
-0.037119604647159576,
0.21197836101055145,
0.04939226806163788,
-0.23007823526859283,
0.23027954995632172,
-0.35566407442092896,
-0.37440845370292664,
-0.024383295327425003,
0.7059833407402039,
-0.935278058052063,
-0.46044009923934937,
-0.5741949677467346,
-0.8212267160415649,
-0.1460041105747223,
-0.10468627512454987,
0.34924638271331787,
0.17695128917694092,
-0.18682622909545898,
0.25854676961898804,
0.7032042145729065,
-0.4629228115081787,
0.4506898522377014,
0.35351595282554626,
-0.12474105507135391,
-0.1907360851764679,
0.7902380228042603,
0.0731818825006485,
-0.07960838079452515,
0.5415761470794678,
-0.21748016774654388,
-0.19624750316143036,
-1.2679526805877686,
-0.45463061332702637,
0.2273719757795334,
-0.8009449243545532,
-0.176421120762825,
-0.7477760910987854,
-0.42598703503608704,
-0.6391082406044006,
0.025646068155765533,
-0.2828065752983093,
-0.17597094178199768,
-0.278606116771698,
-0.07333433628082275,
0.2316189706325531,
1.0513869524002075,
-0.21317583322525024,
-0.006495046429336071,
-0.47647354006767273,
0.11382438987493515,
0.027143821120262146,
0.34852924942970276,
0.20392750203609467,
-0.49666109681129456,
-0.2650488317012787,
-0.15102875232696533,
0.02947022207081318,
-0.5614698529243469,
0.5452880263328552,
-0.03642887994647026,
0.6957270503044128,
0.11336458474397659,
0.02085181325674057,
0.4282432496547699,
-0.09557269513607025,
0.7890371680259705,
-0.05265376716852188,
-0.45446914434432983,
0.20784349739551544,
-0.3027239441871643,
0.3184766173362732,
0.6058846116065979,
0.33403491973876953,
-0.6784610748291016,
-0.40412676334381104,
-0.26677626371383667,
-1.279797911643982,
0.5322777628898621,
0.051342740654945374,
0.3202807307243347,
0.17338870465755463,
0.0788569450378418,
0.45056354999542236,
0.15951226651668549,
-0.7289575934410095,
-0.34375590085983276,
0.007281346712261438,
-0.3438580632209778,
0.003293870249763131,
-0.45165857672691345,
-0.2624512016773224,
-0.22062617540359497,
0.2983301281929016,
-0.0024239360354840755,
0.08485066145658493,
-0.08612585812807083,
-0.07290071249008179,
-0.23729152977466583,
0.5165514945983887,
0.6121197938919067,
0.7408863306045532,
-0.026847748085856438,
0.05742105469107628,
-0.052321191877126694,
-0.40550342202186584,
-0.00972604937851429,
0.2123788744211197,
-0.5825023055076599,
-0.12451644241809845,
0.5171481370925903,
0.5924955606460571,
-0.3527558743953705,
-0.8299792408943176,
0.1917015016078949,
-0.17165863513946533,
0.11887561529874802,
-0.7111210227012634,
-0.14501488208770752,
0.010043235495686531,
0.4351710379123688,
0.47777292132377625,
0.10436657816171646,
0.36255818605422974,
-0.5720031261444092,
-0.21801549196243286,
0.5857846140861511,
0.09410052746534348,
-0.35133475065231323,
0.628926157951355,
0.48689574003219604,
-0.28392136096954346,
1.0744733810424805,
-0.2197432965040207,
-0.33582744002342224,
0.7124084234237671,
0.6746934652328491,
1.039093255996704,
-0.1649809628725052,
0.13759398460388184,
0.40590301156044006,
0.5430055856704712,
0.04382503032684326,
0.3646526038646698,
-0.039392873644828796,
-0.7516454458236694,
-0.3932366669178009,
-0.8168981671333313,
-0.4455350339412689,
0.38351842761039734,
-0.296099454164505,
-0.044478751718997955,
-0.424752801656723,
0.12928152084350586,
-0.1313098520040512,
0.013131732121109962,
-0.8538739085197449,
-0.06978415697813034,
0.436248779296875,
0.9496135711669922,
-0.7614237070083618,
0.5933959484100342,
0.5011166334152222,
-0.533441424369812,
-0.6210166811943054,
-0.06391648203134537,
0.0012494722614064813,
-0.7106605172157288,
0.8031082153320312,
-0.030398990958929062,
-0.16720299422740936,
-0.15575923025608063,
-0.805246889591217,
-0.8452848792076111,
0.9819227457046509,
0.17114852368831635,
-0.3619205951690674,
0.05130630359053612,
0.422097772359848,
0.7628999948501587,
-0.6439250707626343,
0.26162758469581604,
0.5033555626869202,
0.4060300886631012,
-0.15583181381225586,
-0.6328009963035583,
-0.10596337169408798,
-0.5127540826797485,
0.25054025650024414,
-0.09579721838235855,
-0.7195791602134705,
1.0988341569900513,
-0.2593662440776825,
-0.4177086353302002,
0.5174227952957153,
0.8636474013328552,
0.24508580565452576,
0.24998413026332855,
0.11708283424377441,
0.4701979160308838,
0.43531692028045654,
0.11407370865345001,
1.13920259475708,
-0.33841341733932495,
0.02466154284775257,
1.01189386844635,
-0.2545051872730255,
0.6633902192115784,
0.5126744508743286,
-0.40727338194847107,
0.47236692905426025,
0.6134366393089294,
-0.1421423703432083,
0.2974845767021179,
0.21951067447662354,
-0.6252222061157227,
-0.028359772637486458,
-0.30312180519104004,
-0.5207287073135376,
0.5500307679176331,
0.6659214496612549,
-0.26711732149124146,
-0.29120707511901855,
0.05851733684539795,
-0.29168424010276794,
0.2772466242313385,
-0.29821550846099854,
0.5502212047576904,
0.006830990314483643,
-0.5324954986572266,
0.3493223190307617,
0.2723826467990875,
0.9198594093322754,
-0.5655332803726196,
-0.2035588026046753,
-0.53343665599823,
0.15582197904586792,
-0.3261043429374695,
-0.8813439011573792,
0.30933502316474915,
0.00781719759106636,
-0.1822052001953125,
-0.09939026832580566,
0.49657467007637024,
-0.6004284024238586,
-0.3206241726875305,
0.43976303935050964,
0.4041634798049927,
0.028111720457673073,
0.30398333072662354,
-0.5262026786804199,
0.27731770277023315,
0.11399579048156738,
-0.00026153482031077147,
0.202915757894516,
0.4456300735473633,
-0.05738276615738869,
0.9566055536270142,
0.39677894115448,
0.09816841781139374,
0.3282040059566498,
0.14311635494232178,
0.6686618328094482,
-0.782393217086792,
-0.286935955286026,
-0.8041149973869324,
0.4427696466445923,
0.12653422355651855,
-0.5143009424209595,
0.897759735584259,
0.614902138710022,
1.1001131534576416,
-0.09459424763917923,
1.0420351028442383,
-0.22086282074451447,
0.46483710408210754,
-0.24576671421527863,
0.5332384705543518,
-0.23801325261592865,
0.44362136721611023,
0.19126173853874207,
-0.7817509174346924,
-0.5579005479812622,
0.23974625766277313,
-0.014486690983176231,
0.16951021552085876,
0.2001635730266571,
0.7033134698867798,
0.08945141732692719,
0.18507282435894012,
0.07237562537193298,
0.22798828780651093,
0.311870276927948,
0.24235385656356812,
1.0563459396362305,
-0.15014231204986572,
0.43087783455848694,
-0.12504670023918152,
-0.1287987232208252,
-0.2705937325954437,
-0.34779149293899536,
-0.6831610202789307,
-0.7002398371696472,
-0.11181642860174179,
-0.27364200353622437,
-0.1687149554491043,
0.9464199542999268,
0.5221080780029297,
-0.9894908666610718,
-0.6818317174911499,
-0.16797129809856415,
0.3019372224807739,
-0.05579521879553795,
-0.20803740620613098,
0.04673156142234802,
-0.3888064920902252,
-0.7987836599349976,
0.376620352268219,
0.5948988199234009,
0.018229851499199867,
-0.6250865459442139,
-0.24639685451984406,
-0.41158315539360046,
-0.2171020805835724,
0.617168664932251,
0.8275535106658936,
-0.6778069138526917,
0.2987213432788849,
-0.16792328655719757,
-0.2756669521331787,
0.19551371037960052,
1.000354528427124,
-0.39279842376708984,
0.49350494146347046,
0.6455432176589966,
0.9813976287841797,
0.2571313977241516,
-0.17559802532196045,
0.5757336020469666,
-0.287008672952652,
0.18980127573013306,
0.6218939423561096,
0.23879322409629822,
0.8039392232894897,
-0.19410204887390137,
0.7460814118385315,
0.19274425506591797,
-0.4534347355365753,
-0.9594141840934753,
0.3829280734062195,
-0.9353097081184387,
-0.22196906805038452,
1.0758532285690308,
0.05868680402636528,
-0.16636696457862854,
-0.4328548014163971,
0.04275404289364815,
0.22318194806575775,
-0.1470944732427597,
0.8546016812324524,
0.6385404467582703,
-0.22391821444034576,
-0.4088803231716156,
-0.3243961036205292,
0.6030916571617126,
0.2049543410539627,
-0.7125871181488037,
0.025342226028442383,
0.17512387037277222,
0.2399466633796692,
0.13635271787643433,
0.6967186331748962,
-0.32903632521629333,
-0.10852795839309692,
0.19583599269390106,
0.12900225818157196,
0.27905648946762085,
-0.32985612750053406,
-0.6023256182670593,
0.16095657646656036,
0.5921893119812012,
0.07308454811573029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09556v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09556v2
|
$S^3$ -- Semantic Signal Separation
| 2024-06-13T19:43:38 | 2024-06-18T14:12:18 |
Márton Kardos, Jan Kostkan, Arnault-Quentin Vermillet, Kristoffer Nielbo, Kenneth Enevoldsen, Roberta Rocca
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, stat.ML, I.2.7
|
Topic models are useful tools for discovering latent semantic structures in
large textual corpora. Topic modeling historically relied on bag-of-words
representations of language. This approach makes models sensitive to the
presence of stop words and noise, and does not utilize potentially useful
contextual information. Recent efforts have been oriented at incorporating
contextual neural representations in topic modeling and have been shown to
outperform classical topic models. These approaches are, however, typically
slow, volatile and still require preprocessing for optimal results. We present
Semantic Signal Separation ($S^3$), a theory-driven topic modeling approach in
neural embedding spaces. $S^3$ conceptualizes topics as independent axes of
semantic space, and uncovers these with blind-source separation. Our approach
provides the most diverse, highly coherent topics, requires no preprocessing,
and is demonstrated to be the fastest contextually sensitive topic model to
date. We offer an implementation of $S^3$, among other approaches, in the
Turftopic Python package.
|
[
-0.5642273426055908,
-1.1719307899475098,
0.7478342056274414,
0.4388480484485626,
-0.45421552658081055,
-0.2576788365840912,
-0.12559004127979279,
-0.26078617572784424,
0.292549192905426,
0.5033973455429077,
-0.5733336806297302,
-0.43813586235046387,
-0.9447519779205322,
-0.16470018029212952,
-0.6451596617698669,
0.764887809753418,
0.2660674750804901,
0.17110511660575867,
0.10330072790384293,
0.252668172121048,
-0.3555665910243988,
-0.23204943537712097,
-0.38805946707725525,
-0.07325103878974915,
0.5719991326332092,
0.3438609838485718,
0.4487651288509369,
0.9240524768829346,
0.5502676963806152,
0.23274682462215424,
-0.572788655757904,
-0.41074487566947937,
-0.20650921761989594,
0.41040748357772827,
-0.2015940397977829,
-0.245706707239151,
-0.3620792329311371,
0.4115749001502991,
0.6018062233924866,
1.045526146888733,
0.10587948560714722,
-0.30109941959381104,
-0.2736421525478363,
0.26257333159446716,
-0.43918076157569885,
0.020738285034894943,
-0.7705250382423401,
-0.015062211081385612,
-0.3503866493701935,
-0.3619820773601532,
-0.1555914431810379,
-0.015907911583781242,
0.26980969309806824,
-0.4577862620353699,
0.4302918016910553,
-0.35932984948158264,
1.0150189399719238,
0.25345203280448914,
-0.5819494724273682,
-0.06760523468255997,
-0.5545020699501038,
0.7824715971946716,
-0.42486807703971863,
0.5919165015220642,
0.6648052930831909,
0.05746430158615112,
-0.06788288801908493,
-0.7941144704818726,
-0.35872769355773926,
0.01799810864031315,
0.27926284074783325,
-0.043413832783699036,
-0.334799200296402,
-0.2672831416130066,
0.297568142414093,
0.15283262729644775,
-0.35434842109680176,
0.046497803181409836,
-0.669338047504425,
-0.07707348465919495,
0.35482582449913025,
-0.04035642743110657,
0.25758427381515503,
-0.5924202799797058,
-0.23606398701667786,
0.4023747742176056,
-0.8723258376121521,
-0.7040244936943054,
0.37484192848205566,
0.2578587830066681,
0.10998554527759552,
0.438919335603714,
-0.43464943766593933,
0.7715135812759399,
0.033152081072330475,
-0.09370581805706024,
-0.16946806013584137,
-0.1365388184785843,
0.27676862478256226,
-0.13801009953022003,
0.4124574065208435,
0.05743206664919853,
-0.43330350518226624,
-0.3329925239086151,
-0.08304093033075333,
0.3045605421066284,
0.36744141578674316,
-0.8081526160240173,
-0.1988757848739624,
0.627722978591919,
-0.7152313590049744,
-0.38575464487075806,
-0.2850361764431,
-0.7021949887275696,
-0.254314124584198,
-0.4509204924106598,
0.3535405397415161,
-0.5751156806945801,
-0.6118003129959106,
0.1650300770998001,
-0.31815046072006226,
0.3107044994831085,
0.38359740376472473,
-0.9436232447624207,
0.32868000864982605,
1.0579724311828613,
0.8164042234420776,
-0.31583520770072937,
-0.19358043372631073,
-0.3867558240890503,
0.22815637290477753,
-0.28844812512397766,
0.9647964239120483,
-0.33087754249572754,
-0.13866586983203888,
-0.3414546251296997,
-0.11657477170228958,
0.2052289843559265,
-0.06729308515787125,
0.23633429408073425,
-0.8817347288131714,
0.2853029668331146,
-0.023376086726784706,
-0.6999630928039551,
-0.04970655217766762,
-0.1217370331287384,
-0.7604835629463196,
0.6495458483695984,
-0.04608675092458725,
-0.9153830409049988,
0.37615934014320374,
-0.7438771724700928,
-0.40473413467407227,
0.00006207328988239169,
-0.3400096595287323,
-0.030093636363744736,
-0.0023994867224246264,
0.1440100371837616,
0.6013401746749878,
-0.28355643153190613,
0.42062780261039734,
-0.35991576313972473,
-0.3664626181125641,
0.28720203042030334,
-0.25358960032463074,
0.648917019367218,
0.8006910085678101,
-0.5406023263931274,
0.3229430019855499,
-0.8589089512825012,
-0.3809705376625061,
-0.026797601953148842,
0.057498134672641754,
-0.4601156413555145,
0.27828267216682434,
0.024105586111545563,
0.19046713411808014,
0.1384059339761734,
-0.4835939407348633,
-0.2487456500530243,
-0.3020274341106415,
0.7407692074775696,
0.5684494972229004,
-0.04481988772749901,
0.6396113038063049,
-0.0032757690642029047,
0.02658073976635933,
0.14214186370372772,
-0.18796251714229584,
-0.10194946080446243,
-0.750109076499939,
-0.6832049489021301,
-0.6561190485954285,
0.3210698366165161,
0.13517627120018005,
-0.6117283701896667,
0.5764235258102417,
-0.1352643519639969,
-0.6109446287155151,
-0.016156993806362152,
-0.34368905425071716,
-0.07850855588912964,
0.3096177577972412,
0.288292795419693,
0.055979546159505844,
-0.07903894782066345,
-0.7754716873168945,
-0.18916888535022736,
0.12779539823532104,
-0.27974992990493774,
-0.13414929807186127,
0.4626980721950531,
0.017277846112847328,
0.8996486067771912,
-0.8847253918647766,
-0.000222424219828099,
-0.35708487033843994,
0.1993078738451004,
0.324799507856369,
0.5055415630340576,
0.24432314932346344,
-1.0099623203277588,
0.14666180312633514,
-0.3232594430446625,
-0.7747663259506226,
-0.12755218148231506,
0.3828797936439514,
-0.350618451833725,
-0.09828604012727737,
0.7297079563140869,
-0.8501988053321838,
0.5335821509361267,
0.23684419691562653,
-0.7287175059318542,
0.1607571393251419,
0.17276297509670258,
-0.1254665106534958,
-1.1290359497070312,
-0.012029387056827545,
0.042552486062049866,
-0.01450038980692625,
-0.7429351806640625,
0.17426030337810516,
0.05445810779929161,
-0.49816805124282837,
-0.5415230393409729,
0.2950236201286316,
-0.23476049304008484,
-0.39581024646759033,
-0.6123828887939453,
0.4243617653846741,
0.0632619708776474,
0.367561399936676,
0.6250702738761902,
0.34525349736213684,
0.5709639191627502,
-0.7374820709228516,
0.04243471473455429,
0.3343603312969208,
-0.08028838783502579,
0.42320188879966736,
-0.6007187366485596,
-0.004076266661286354,
-0.0103452755138278,
0.1872541457414627,
-0.8288277387619019,
-0.2661212384700775,
0.5229454040527344,
-0.2540634274482727,
0.07958855479955673,
-0.23270215094089508,
-0.23094533383846283,
0.11907842755317688,
0.009150449186563492,
0.49805718660354614,
0.2345871925354004,
-0.41417187452316284,
0.36052682995796204,
0.59029221534729,
-0.3580755293369293,
-0.1429194062948227,
-0.5385852456092834,
-0.18112169206142426,
-0.5023058652877808,
-0.8323097229003906,
0.6020237803459167,
0.2964988350868225,
-0.1354551911354065,
0.2406042516231537,
-0.205471009016037,
-0.37883418798446655,
0.30234313011169434,
0.19044353067874908,
0.026244373992085457,
-0.16933675110340118,
0.21371473371982574,
-0.12407258152961731,
-0.5513648986816406,
0.002462499774992466,
-0.6332194209098816,
0.451041042804718,
-0.15080539882183075,
-0.3793938457965851,
-0.36302945017814636,
0.6979331970214844,
0.38550493121147156,
-0.20276279747486115,
0.5002426505088806,
0.6190478205680847,
-0.6239762902259827,
-0.07077518850564957,
-0.4089229702949524,
-0.45445939898490906,
-0.4323177635669708,
0.5091747641563416,
-0.3022928833961487,
-0.9891941547393799,
0.2699683904647827,
-0.1495593786239624,
-0.39814844727516174,
0.6324428915977478,
0.4187128245830536,
0.060827434062957764,
0.7775129079818726,
0.6821500062942505,
0.3494773805141449,
0.6270586848258972,
-0.20238903164863586,
0.5956066250801086,
-0.6579998135566711,
-0.01899501495063305,
-0.7588832378387451,
0.19449318945407867,
-0.5323776006698608,
-0.5861167311668396,
-0.003845352679491043,
0.33989962935447693,
-0.23389925062656403,
0.42191076278686523,
-0.5186615586280823,
0.21788333356380463,
0.5493970513343811,
0.028405681252479553,
0.08124389499425888,
0.2859964668750763,
0.2743091881275177,
-0.16429105401039124,
-0.7620834708213806,
-0.584752082824707,
0.835671067237854,
0.5792108774185181,
0.43830665946006775,
0.042710110545158386,
0.528814971446991,
0.09156030416488647,
0.3409212827682495,
-0.6605401635169983,
0.710364580154419,
-0.3549967110157013,
-0.5615409016609192,
-0.3915712833404541,
-0.45823419094085693,
-0.8811103701591492,
0.5626720190048218,
-0.18474461138248444,
-1.0686017274856567,
0.1750098615884781,
-0.42141082882881165,
-0.2376202940940857,
0.2875750958919525,
-0.24553854763507843,
0.8386649489402771,
0.09661759436130524,
-0.5616576075553894,
-0.2554205358028412,
-0.4185781478881836,
0.35297271609306335,
-0.03513912856578827,
0.16567017138004303,
-0.5927209258079529,
0.05909119173884392,
1.1459423303604126,
-0.33507657051086426,
0.5670168399810791,
-0.1536756306886673,
-0.11493626236915588,
0.29501962661743164,
0.10859303176403046,
0.16231994330883026,
0.26124390959739685,
0.02840796858072281,
0.5085632801055908,
0.1927669793367386,
-0.49155816435813904,
-0.3237151503562927,
0.7184745669364929,
-0.9668329954147339,
-0.773476779460907,
-0.4651387333869934,
-0.5430065989494324,
-0.13775019347667694,
0.3561307191848755,
0.28241032361984253,
0.41942617297172546,
0.11013443022966385,
0.2115013152360916,
0.5609151124954224,
-0.19386649131774902,
0.4814434051513672,
0.552862823009491,
-0.2902988791465759,
-0.49622270464897156,
1.0628905296325684,
-0.018076620995998383,
-0.09145273268222809,
0.11208973824977875,
0.03770264610648155,
-0.23583245277404785,
-0.5352755784988403,
0.004143759608268738,
0.19264033436775208,
-0.9089632034301758,
-0.14232012629508972,
-0.9790962934494019,
-0.36509305238723755,
-0.1324184387922287,
-0.10296282917261124,
-0.6000735759735107,
-0.6635056138038635,
-0.5349023342132568,
0.009959351271390915,
0.37961968779563904,
0.6387525200843811,
-0.2908266484737396,
0.7570829391479492,
-0.5932013392448425,
0.7205159068107605,
0.14906655251979828,
0.38737156987190247,
-0.38461756706237793,
-0.15464265644550323,
-0.06901224702596664,
-0.25597885251045227,
-0.4054310619831085,
-1.1467742919921875,
0.46709734201431274,
-0.3225712180137634,
0.6486543416976929,
0.5594131946563721,
-0.18494866788387299,
0.2937583327293396,
-0.15091581642627716,
0.9201732277870178,
0.14117470383644104,
-1.3077484369277954,
0.8848519921302795,
-0.7678751349449158,
-0.025470126420259476,
0.12702399492263794,
0.45815300941467285,
-0.4440116286277771,
-0.5901715159416199,
-0.8056526780128479,
-1.0332263708114624,
0.8494872450828552,
0.3737969994544983,
-0.2337663471698761,
-0.3762405216693878,
0.36338600516319275,
0.13087236881256104,
0.18045088648796082,
-0.6449393630027771,
-0.025005213916301727,
-0.41508224606513977,
0.1073755994439125,
0.07274877279996872,
-0.43366408348083496,
-0.36093974113464355,
-0.04195069521665573,
0.37398266792297363,
-0.09023043513298035,
0.6874893307685852,
0.08201663941144943,
-0.02817157283425331,
0.04096711426973343,
0.007511948700994253,
0.5477820038795471,
0.654124915599823,
-0.40823712944984436,
0.46608036756515503,
-0.14894774556159973,
-0.28724008798599243,
0.23070980608463287,
0.2232425957918167,
-0.16378752887248993,
0.009479206055402756,
0.4923516809940338,
0.5760399103164673,
0.2652713358402252,
0.08909249305725098,
0.7723065614700317,
-0.13059984147548676,
-0.2643558382987976,
-0.028538644313812256,
-0.032336022704839706,
0.29603487253189087,
0.2710297107696533,
0.35049885511398315,
0.11991756409406662,
0.17402991652488708,
-0.03179019317030907,
0.49928420782089233,
0.048070985823869705,
-0.49045005440711975,
-0.15084953606128693,
0.8775612711906433,
0.3345305919647217,
-0.08583414554595947,
0.6804717779159546,
0.08921608328819275,
-0.33512410521507263,
0.7623530030250549,
0.5683387517929077,
0.9526039361953735,
0.22708453238010406,
0.2956327497959137,
0.04517089203000069,
-0.06399847567081451,
0.03980694338679314,
0.41868144273757935,
-0.20681755244731903,
-0.7992669343948364,
-0.5920107960700989,
-0.7177645564079285,
-0.2184005230665207,
0.24402020871639252,
-0.5541822910308838,
0.3077904284000397,
-0.47770214080810547,
-0.3090411126613617,
0.2681468725204468,
-0.03382176533341408,
-0.3399500250816345,
0.2791571617126465,
0.20509639382362366,
1.0872983932495117,
-0.8786176443099976,
0.8238863945007324,
0.35428595542907715,
-0.1748703271150589,
-0.6859661936759949,
0.25803717970848083,
-0.1481902301311493,
-0.06289162486791611,
1.0208998918533325,
0.237168088555336,
-0.07492992281913757,
-0.1279219090938568,
-0.6537958383560181,
-1.2688045501708984,
0.8680278062820435,
0.2182597815990448,
0.042805325239896774,
0.5923292636871338,
-0.11932393908500671,
0.34694188833236694,
-0.531897246837616,
0.2325621098279953,
0.4002279043197632,
0.2986885607242584,
0.11112066358327866,
-0.036471109837293625,
0.16210933029651642,
-0.2390613853931427,
0.057933393865823746,
-0.09105964750051498,
-0.5159950256347656,
1.1344696283340454,
0.3218216001987457,
-0.10713716596364975,
0.15189456939697266,
1.0083857774734497,
0.6114276647567749,
0.46695196628570557,
0.3891330063343048,
0.12407554686069489,
0.4782100021839142,
-0.39941057562828064,
0.6845605969429016,
-0.7733473181724548,
0.18462972342967987,
0.6584105491638184,
-0.28275975584983826,
0.7550984621047974,
0.7246925830841064,
0.06503143161535263,
0.2280627191066742,
0.9351834654808044,
0.22457629442214966,
0.9218079447746277,
0.2584577202796936,
-0.0618705153465271,
-0.26979461312294006,
0.06804490834474564,
-0.6821985840797424,
0.7072532176971436,
0.6713434457778931,
-0.021303648129105568,
-0.35901951789855957,
-0.16930225491523743,
0.030956877395510674,
-0.22301028668880463,
0.011258159764111042,
0.49064451456069946,
0.12658743560314178,
-0.6264551281929016,
0.17651495337486267,
0.3374982476234436,
0.48017993569374084,
-0.7586526870727539,
-0.16110295057296753,
-0.4185965955257416,
-0.07050562649965286,
0.013629716821014881,
-0.5102114081382751,
0.6240932941436768,
-0.18389981985092163,
-0.1858293116092682,
-0.45681503415107727,
1.0784896612167358,
-0.23538608849048615,
-0.20896609127521515,
0.49026280641555786,
0.6336628198623657,
0.2835427224636078,
-0.07619670778512955,
-0.20961187779903412,
0.416232168674469,
-0.3435588777065277,
-0.4452359974384308,
0.1806601583957672,
0.4796908497810364,
-0.20107510685920715,
0.4083304703235626,
0.8464298844337463,
0.31825071573257446,
-0.18636399507522583,
-0.19772039353847504,
0.9858472347259521,
-1.0266252756118774,
-1.1119304895401,
-0.48763978481292725,
0.1712772697210312,
-0.10223199427127838,
-0.4504464268684387,
0.6384844779968262,
0.19714605808258057,
0.4648398756980896,
-0.06727179139852524,
0.5453702807426453,
-0.0855109840631485,
0.2681560814380646,
-0.6039087772369385,
0.8019465804100037,
-0.4917586147785187,
0.6421521306037903,
-0.4214233160018921,
-0.9782918095588684,
-0.5331453680992126,
0.7553926706314087,
-0.5246788859367371,
-0.11448437720537186,
0.8431272506713867,
0.8182485103607178,
-0.06059280410408974,
0.7345793843269348,
0.3156206011772156,
-0.0034464614000171423,
0.3076592981815338,
0.23037825524806976,
1.6128796339035034,
-0.31058624386787415,
0.14460016787052155,
-0.305703729391098,
-0.2563864290714264,
-0.26999032497406006,
-0.928065299987793,
-0.475919634103775,
-0.5681150555610657,
-0.5345162749290466,
-0.35754990577697754,
0.1572839766740799,
0.35251879692077637,
1.099294662475586,
-0.630413830280304,
-0.09135047346353531,
-0.5131133794784546,
0.5126124620437622,
-0.20798370242118835,
-0.2203109860420227,
0.6225459575653076,
-0.3765093982219696,
-0.32096678018569946,
0.6825200915336609,
0.4038791060447693,
-0.27476125955581665,
-0.2285430133342743,
0.21119889616966248,
-0.16977845132350922,
0.018797941505908966,
0.37358370423316956,
0.016691671684384346,
-0.8227446675300598,
-0.3617993891239166,
-0.1589849889278412,
-0.38583675026893616,
-0.26385629177093506,
0.9750543832778931,
-0.587310791015625,
-0.05662251263856888,
0.5851606726646423,
0.22938598692417145,
0.7301990389823914,
-0.2902473211288452,
0.6839966177940369,
-0.47866082191467285,
0.6607174873352051,
0.005800203420221806,
0.3172774016857147,
0.3155972957611084,
-0.37654662132263184,
0.610359787940979,
0.6094687581062317,
-0.29467910528182983,
-0.5465939044952393,
0.29536768794059753,
-0.7954394221305847,
-0.8139423727989197,
1.3405653238296509,
-0.05187753587961197,
-0.4557141363620758,
-0.21448677778244019,
0.031554922461509705,
0.32214799523353577,
-0.10501354932785034,
0.5550064444541931,
0.592077374458313,
-0.23381353914737701,
-0.009788883849978447,
-0.5407295227050781,
0.5483013987541199,
0.4935355484485626,
-0.6096653938293457,
-0.17692570388317108,
0.47512006759643555,
0.479160875082016,
0.2844753563404083,
0.7549023032188416,
-0.28447920083999634,
0.20566579699516296,
0.5522601008415222,
-0.09190767258405685,
0.06474703550338745,
-0.6630859971046448,
-0.40377551317214966,
0.6059589982032776,
-0.2589368522167206,
-0.2362845540046692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09549v1
|
Exploring Syntactic Patterns in Urdu: A Deep Dive into Dependency Analysis
| 2024-06-13T19:30:32 | 2024-06-13T19:30:32 |
Nudrat Habib
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Parsing is the process of breaking a sentence into its grammatical components
and identifying the syntactic structure of the sentence. The syntactically
correct sentence structure is achieved by assigning grammatical labels to its
constituents using lexicon and syntactic rules. In linguistics, parser is
extremely useful due to the number of different applications like name entity
recognition, QA systems and information extraction, etc. The two most common
techniques used for parsing are phrase structure and dependency Structure.
Because Urdu is a low-resource language, there has been little progress in
building an Urdu parser. A comparison of several parsers revealed that the
dependency parsing approach is better suited for order-free languages such as
Urdu. We have made significant progress in parsing Urdu, a South Asian language
with a complex morphology. For Urdu dependency parsing, a basic feature model
consisting of word location, word head, and dependency relation is employed as
a starting point, followed by more complex feature models. The dependency
tagset is designed after careful consideration of the complex morphological
structure of the Urdu language, word order variation, and lexical ambiguity and
it contains 22 tags. Our dataset comprises of sentences from news articles, and
we tried to include sentences of different complexity (which is quite
challenging), to get reliable results. All experiments are performed using
MaltParser, exploring all 9 algorithms and classifiers. We have achieved a 70
percent overall best-labeled accuracy (LA), as well as an 84 percent overall
best-unlabeled attachment score (UAS) using the Nivreeager algorithm. The
comparison of output data with treebank test data that has been manually parsed
is then used to carry out error assessment and to identify the errors produced
by the parser.
|
[
-0.16912561655044556,
-0.502404510974884,
0.37120166420936584,
0.6356368660926819,
-0.24317680299282074,
0.1875411719083786,
0.11295202374458313,
-0.5351051688194275,
0.19722159206867218,
0.5422720909118652,
-0.20526881515979767,
-0.5879102945327759,
-0.7021247148513794,
0.41943973302841187,
-0.32045894861221313,
0.5805288553237915,
-0.24486781656742096,
0.062783382833004,
0.2764742970466614,
-0.14352065324783325,
-0.7367253303527832,
-0.3835548162460327,
-0.4260784983634949,
0.024196211248636246,
0.13775861263275146,
0.564287543296814,
0.48583877086639404,
1.0043498277664185,
0.6783561706542969,
0.40471306443214417,
-0.4973686933517456,
-0.005176002159714699,
0.12529687583446503,
0.42612552642822266,
-0.3907976448535919,
-0.5116257071495056,
-0.18061301112174988,
-0.2596326768398285,
0.44481542706489563,
0.9596177339553833,
0.07924322038888931,
0.3070051074028015,
-0.015370908193290234,
0.8998113870620728,
-0.8190073370933533,
0.16961748898029327,
-0.10200195759534836,
0.13146185874938965,
-0.6377963423728943,
0.021974068135023117,
-0.39440107345581055,
-0.2406727522611618,
-0.12504732608795166,
0.0649544894695282,
0.12745466828346252,
-0.02497108280658722,
0.9263983368873596,
0.1339680701494217,
-0.5691338181495667,
-0.4759555160999298,
-0.8175491690635681,
0.8878695964813232,
-0.6953083872795105,
0.6851564645767212,
0.48658478260040283,
0.20183435082435608,
-0.3417545258998871,
-0.4384560286998749,
-0.27400022745132446,
-0.2474958598613739,
-0.283578485250473,
-0.1299361288547516,
0.04385600984096527,
0.07356373965740204,
0.13211104273796082,
0.5986993312835693,
-0.6391848921775818,
-0.17349444329738617,
-0.18033573031425476,
-0.1458798497915268,
0.2842376232147217,
0.10148758441209793,
0.801652193069458,
-0.6732673048973083,
-0.3489122688770294,
-0.03462865576148033,
-0.41302481293678284,
0.5029122829437256,
0.4094890058040619,
0.43841248750686646,
-0.12453336268663406,
0.8282570242881775,
-0.4953862428665161,
0.7920191287994385,
0.15791349112987518,
-0.3348877727985382,
0.13833729922771454,
-0.4934540092945099,
-0.23458418250083923,
0.3478166162967682,
0.7139976620674133,
-0.04690408706665039,
0.1841667890548706,
0.0707792118191719,
0.1355428695678711,
0.10422952473163605,
-0.09588845819234848,
-0.5253967046737671,
-0.17020143568515778,
0.15426909923553467,
-0.459444522857666,
-0.2785341441631317,
0.17382483184337616,
-0.9710311889648438,
-0.3052894175052643,
-0.1019972562789917,
-0.11207504570484161,
-0.45947739481925964,
-0.4207606613636017,
0.09867170453071594,
0.002823838032782078,
0.2881665527820587,
0.007008266169577837,
-1.0268341302871704,
0.44585809111595154,
0.4523833394050598,
1.0347458124160767,
0.14745087921619415,
-0.37997034192085266,
-0.2809485197067261,
0.3677080571651459,
-0.44155916571617126,
1.2238322496414185,
-0.592788577079773,
0.052066557109355927,
-0.33910882472991943,
-0.12473466992378235,
-0.10632563382387161,
-0.6376566886901855,
0.6119136810302734,
-0.2797914445400238,
-0.047247521579265594,
-0.22804862260818481,
-0.4018011689186096,
-0.4736369848251343,
0.2181229591369629,
-0.8955022692680359,
0.9627079367637634,
0.5514379143714905,
-0.6746509075164795,
0.44179993867874146,
-0.5264923572540283,
-0.5511582493782043,
0.13354995846748352,
-0.055658530443906784,
-0.12944935262203217,
-0.1011383906006813,
0.1690562665462494,
0.19688156247138977,
-0.10550448298454285,
0.3061326742172241,
0.15126849710941315,
-0.08172234892845154,
0.09102386981248856,
0.051715463399887085,
0.93231201171875,
0.1378917396068573,
-0.4685218930244446,
0.11129862070083618,
-0.99223792552948,
-0.03815333917737007,
-0.13392727077007294,
-0.1990010291337967,
-0.3510352671146393,
0.13453201949596405,
0.19477351009845734,
0.12831006944179535,
-0.09749416261911392,
-0.5567526817321777,
0.2189154475927353,
-1.0219963788986206,
0.2959948778152466,
0.4720771610736847,
0.3544924855232239,
0.5165760517120361,
0.08559516072273254,
0.526400625705719,
0.19610394537448883,
-0.010441002435982227,
-0.310867577791214,
-0.2363397777080536,
-0.6224105954170227,
-0.1866540014743805,
0.5436811447143555,
0.772757351398468,
-0.165354922413826,
0.2784070074558258,
0.242405503988266,
-0.24981169402599335,
-0.20686064660549164,
0.4741707444190979,
0.3856295943260193,
0.24975521862506866,
0.16637937724590302,
-0.245892733335495,
-0.9499889612197876,
-0.8464246392250061,
-0.6057790517807007,
-0.22638048231601715,
0.45411416888237,
-0.4323802888393402,
0.1975976973772049,
-0.10268092900514603,
0.925021231174469,
-0.3769219219684601,
-0.42663928866386414,
-0.8855897784233093,
0.17496472597122192,
0.2469630092382431,
0.3172081708908081,
0.5544095039367676,
-1.1119152307510376,
-0.765606701374054,
0.1684342622756958,
-0.5628635883331299,
-0.4069221317768097,
0.13481725752353668,
-0.07888247817754745,
0.31444022059440613,
0.45566117763519287,
-0.5772641897201538,
0.5869211554527283,
0.2594835162162781,
-0.5990919470787048,
0.5539533495903015,
0.41524866223335266,
0.10632925480604172,
-1.1322749853134155,
-0.1197633221745491,
-0.20288850367069244,
-0.09529303759336472,
-0.7964765429496765,
0.10378624498844147,
-0.33203041553497314,
-0.015847934409976006,
-0.5556018948554993,
0.4404401183128357,
-0.5465824604034424,
0.04695800319314003,
-0.18243993818759918,
-0.5122756958007812,
0.17356616258621216,
0.26831164956092834,
-0.22095048427581787,
0.7288201451301575,
0.3004854917526245,
-0.30373483896255493,
0.18920718133449554,
0.22153155505657196,
-0.345182865858078,
-0.16757719218730927,
-0.38931065797805786,
-0.170270174741745,
0.036864131689071655,
-0.3382948040962219,
-1.1406558752059937,
-0.521369993686676,
0.7308125495910645,
-0.25225844979286194,
0.14593784511089325,
-0.3042142391204834,
-0.5378334522247314,
0.2101123332977295,
-0.28507933020591736,
0.6860995292663574,
0.06643252819776535,
-0.031017713248729706,
0.620886504650116,
0.4198612868785858,
-0.379207581281662,
-0.671034574508667,
-0.5291017293930054,
0.15348941087722778,
-0.2317853569984436,
-0.3858445882797241,
0.021992798894643784,
0.4288785457611084,
-0.7494034171104431,
0.18430574238300323,
-0.2964108884334564,
-0.38139086961746216,
0.02656535804271698,
0.37383177876472473,
-0.08757749199867249,
-0.4496641457080841,
-0.21311958134174347,
0.05190286412835121,
-0.28414496779441833,
-0.06865809857845306,
0.1360311210155487,
0.8527676463127136,
-0.19839808344841003,
-0.1813703030347824,
-0.4874805212020874,
0.7645403742790222,
0.4700145125389099,
-0.3692660629749298,
0.6850730180740356,
0.4287549555301666,
-0.32730644941329956,
-0.08348257094621658,
-0.5169823169708252,
0.428574800491333,
-0.43712082505226135,
0.201401948928833,
-0.25696155428886414,
-0.5108532905578613,
0.5605977177619934,
-0.09473218768835068,
-0.47274020314216614,
0.5938659906387329,
0.5496527552604675,
0.13646629452705383,
1.1040613651275635,
1.043931245803833,
-0.12873245775699615,
0.22904634475708008,
0.01972457766532898,
0.5931653380393982,
-0.2626452147960663,
-0.1679631471633911,
-0.5346947908401489,
0.07036025822162628,
-0.6179804801940918,
0.02842995524406433,
0.08825009316205978,
0.49919721484184265,
-0.0008998850244097412,
0.3299061059951782,
-0.43696507811546326,
0.8004716634750366,
0.2572282552719116,
-0.21837018430233002,
0.16469481587409973,
-0.10287760198116302,
0.08497563749551773,
-0.07121454924345016,
-0.32767948508262634,
-0.5665295720100403,
0.5030810832977295,
0.011608179658651352,
0.4877290725708008,
0.23532047867774963,
0.6020494699478149,
0.4196433424949646,
-0.16013659536838531,
-0.9978297352790833,
0.5496817827224731,
-0.325251966714859,
0.02997022494673729,
-0.12485841661691666,
-0.20056213438510895,
-0.7649655342102051,
0.1139478087425232,
0.16469508409500122,
-0.8251857161521912,
0.34191983938217163,
-0.039584580808877945,
-0.18419799208641052,
0.08833695203065872,
-0.8666979074478149,
1.0037565231323242,
-0.20012538135051727,
-0.19506341218948364,
0.380837082862854,
-0.6668635606765747,
0.46339452266693115,
0.29889923334121704,
0.2515726089477539,
-0.15599526464939117,
0.2635323703289032,
0.8322176337242126,
-0.38755735754966736,
0.8049942851066589,
0.006355127785354853,
0.16747784614562988,
0.35955971479415894,
0.2944968044757843,
-0.16669988632202148,
-0.2377147078514099,
0.09183856844902039,
-0.004857198800891638,
0.3914087116718292,
-0.4638582766056061,
-0.690636932849884,
0.24223589897155762,
-0.5985718369483948,
-0.40910646319389343,
-0.7831884622573853,
-0.5161415934562683,
-0.22059741616249084,
0.4847477674484253,
0.1664542853832245,
0.46781885623931885,
0.08208467811346054,
-0.35206758975982666,
0.20677684247493744,
-0.01414498221129179,
0.3109394609928131,
0.18095099925994873,
-0.357747346162796,
-0.32846784591674805,
0.8432872295379639,
0.18419212102890015,
-0.060498274862766266,
0.6080688238143921,
0.36916935443878174,
-0.1187266856431961,
-0.5395767688751221,
-0.4278598129749298,
0.2387773096561432,
-0.6565098762512207,
-0.3164907991886139,
-0.709134578704834,
-0.5076578855514526,
-0.72878497838974,
-0.02929430827498436,
-0.24270491302013397,
-0.5059863328933716,
0.09561744332313538,
-0.04646696150302887,
0.14341528713703156,
1.1859204769134521,
0.018657395616173744,
0.4215466380119324,
-1.0081864595413208,
0.21183821558952332,
-0.19176161289215088,
0.21538226306438446,
-0.04111568257212639,
0.10374929010868073,
-0.3060183525085449,
-0.24290142953395844,
-0.379980206489563,
-1.3420740365982056,
0.5999405980110168,
0.013637661933898926,
0.2665537893772125,
0.5210548043251038,
-0.08187681436538696,
0.8284027576446533,
-0.4735265374183655,
0.7414612174034119,
-0.1976194977760315,
-1.1517137289047241,
0.907161295413971,
-0.21552540361881256,
0.2583606243133545,
0.6437994837760925,
0.368448406457901,
-0.5864723920822144,
-0.5226020812988281,
-0.37766557931900024,
-1.1545861959457397,
0.6254013180732727,
0.004908875096589327,
-0.4494486451148987,
-0.03759676218032837,
0.4958500266075134,
0.11111346632242203,
0.019261900335550308,
-0.42451244592666626,
0.02307172678411007,
-0.08129797130823135,
-0.37900376319885254,
0.11195291578769684,
-0.7103744149208069,
0.3409525156021118,
-0.29453688859939575,
0.34420907497406006,
0.24136149883270264,
0.045206453651189804,
0.10503540188074112,
-0.44261279702186584,
-0.16522039473056793,
0.5604614615440369,
0.7047738432884216,
0.7458140850067139,
-0.22156141698360443,
0.4040045440196991,
-0.20556426048278809,
-0.7906489372253418,
0.44236719608306885,
-0.11868712306022644,
-0.03877801075577736,
0.17580582201480865,
0.6006925702095032,
0.32471945881843567,
0.16157563030719757,
-0.7649359703063965,
0.3868979215621948,
0.27052637934684753,
0.15972314774990082,
-0.36048561334609985,
-0.02826700173318386,
-0.20620858669281006,
0.21445201337337494,
0.18553759157657623,
0.11391323059797287,
0.5683588981628418,
-0.5769551992416382,
0.37607693672180176,
-0.035813603550195694,
-0.100687675178051,
-0.39778828620910645,
0.022671477869153023,
-0.38706836104393005,
-0.4263512194156647,
0.37736618518829346,
-0.26114925742149353,
-1.0082975625991821,
0.6806204915046692,
0.6557599902153015,
0.7026345729827881,
-0.5959523916244507,
0.40850961208343506,
0.27625128626823425,
0.17089137434959412,
-0.22451969981193542,
0.40854811668395996,
-0.18095426261425018,
-0.5644742250442505,
-0.8413087725639343,
-0.9721881151199341,
-0.4568132758140564,
-0.018640777096152306,
-0.8527968525886536,
0.29658398032188416,
-0.4351622462272644,
0.24941125512123108,
0.19725070893764496,
0.05105442926287651,
-0.0706871822476387,
-0.01823759265244007,
-0.2673778831958771,
0.8684743046760559,
-1.0507928133010864,
0.4244283437728882,
0.9804836511611938,
-0.48603230714797974,
-1.2181085348129272,
0.06260504573583603,
0.24197810888290405,
-0.48645955324172974,
1.0833441019058228,
0.38473159074783325,
-0.20707710087299347,
-0.26755717396736145,
-0.26646244525909424,
-0.9275993704795837,
0.4601806104183197,
0.2159346044063568,
-0.12885406613349915,
-0.06640373170375824,
0.6317160725593567,
0.4539031684398651,
-0.09821829199790955,
0.23846617341041565,
0.629522979259491,
0.3739023506641388,
-0.10488466173410416,
-0.6398137211799622,
0.14372104406356812,
-0.5468015074729919,
-0.04051008075475693,
0.9406309723854065,
-0.46440595388412476,
0.965457022190094,
0.13352710008621216,
-0.29593685269355774,
0.18537360429763794,
0.4875193238258362,
-0.09694786369800568,
0.45237767696380615,
0.42161253094673157,
0.5612020492553711,
0.13997270166873932,
0.22097046673297882,
0.5995768904685974,
-0.1329357624053955,
0.3142659068107605,
0.8649969696998596,
-0.34806448221206665,
0.8685787916183472,
0.5497841238975525,
-0.13954484462738037,
0.7530227899551392,
0.5183326601982117,
0.05847257375717163,
0.5267360210418701,
-0.0701351910829544,
-0.20646953582763672,
-0.08362805098295212,
-0.4490727186203003,
-0.12594114243984222,
0.9196592569351196,
0.3265942931175232,
-0.33758729696273804,
-0.7960637807846069,
0.31331950426101685,
-0.016101419925689697,
0.15106302499771118,
-0.20836228132247925,
0.8731917142868042,
-0.05981749668717384,
-0.2619696259498596,
0.3315328359603882,
0.08607123047113419,
0.0049326131120324135,
-0.5297107696533203,
-0.5318740010261536,
-0.076384536921978,
0.3236062824726105,
-0.4550133943557739,
-0.6799940466880798,
0.8144747018814087,
0.126795694231987,
-0.4567662179470062,
-0.26035624742507935,
0.9708063006401062,
-0.25769802927970886,
-0.5541073679924011,
0.19750143587589264,
0.6950718760490417,
0.24585996568202972,
0.13293257355690002,
-0.2866981029510498,
0.2569923400878906,
-0.1461680382490158,
-0.10412085056304932,
0.5286852121353149,
0.33376485109329224,
-0.24488677084445953,
0.34710943698883057,
0.5141808390617371,
0.31655997037887573,
-0.0005637263529933989,
0.03492492437362671,
0.7035753130912781,
-0.971726655960083,
-0.5711812973022461,
-1.1189069747924805,
0.3082731068134308,
0.20672930777072906,
-0.2622198760509491,
0.9084773659706116,
0.5930017232894897,
0.8566164970397949,
0.22743014991283417,
0.30011099576950073,
-0.25249093770980835,
0.738158106803894,
-0.5060007572174072,
0.5842155814170837,
-0.2405002862215042,
0.21593397855758667,
-0.3441966474056244,
-0.7106949090957642,
-0.6300547122955322,
0.6804644465446472,
-0.2788519263267517,
-0.35543131828308105,
0.6772392392158508,
0.7019087672233582,
-0.12558260560035706,
0.22905929386615753,
-0.03274429216980934,
0.34557193517684937,
0.1970272958278656,
0.3174739480018616,
1.127697229385376,
-0.260940819978714,
0.30339932441711426,
-0.7038988471031189,
-0.3537123203277588,
0.09945039451122284,
-0.5254113078117371,
-0.8573147654533386,
-0.6898069977760315,
0.03216157853603363,
-0.27921929955482483,
0.15209239721298218,
1.0520952939987183,
0.3612902760505676,
-1.013559341430664,
-0.5558667182922363,
-0.2529987394809723,
0.3400464653968811,
-0.35317590832710266,
-0.394020676612854,
0.5165759325027466,
-0.5787422060966492,
-0.39937376976013184,
0.3797227740287781,
0.48802757263183594,
-0.17433305084705353,
0.1631605327129364,
0.5616421699523926,
-0.5247412323951721,
-0.3749791085720062,
0.6869089007377625,
0.39714327454566956,
-0.5638934969902039,
-0.275801420211792,
0.06402327120304108,
0.06690704822540283,
0.2928816080093384,
1.0581239461898804,
-0.6534270644187927,
0.08186905831098557,
0.4890693426132202,
0.594991147518158,
-0.01410679891705513,
0.1566379815340042,
0.2863005995750427,
-0.38437142968177795,
0.2582431733608246,
0.22431406378746033,
0.13408593833446503,
0.17554762959480286,
-0.5319033265113831,
0.40177837014198303,
0.2990166246891022,
-0.43546175956726074,
-1.1910390853881836,
0.5255165100097656,
-1.2465503215789795,
-0.2177949994802475,
0.9839870929718018,
0.0843479186296463,
-0.6278363466262817,
-0.5425917506217957,
-0.5251170992851257,
0.3267551362514496,
-0.15461494028568268,
0.45764434337615967,
0.8331863284111023,
-0.6073687076568604,
-0.5685521960258484,
-0.4429517686367035,
0.46649792790412903,
0.45544490218162537,
-0.4844055473804474,
-0.08813966810703278,
0.011714091524481773,
0.33877483010292053,
0.46587955951690674,
0.4892842769622803,
-0.003253962378948927,
0.19671818614006042,
-0.01973024196922779,
-0.23480136692523956,
0.06978539377450943,
-0.4635273218154907,
-0.3010958433151245,
0.4744105637073517,
0.15372195839881897,
-0.07144675403833389
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09520v1
|
A Systematic Review of Generative AI for Teaching and Learning Practice
| 2024-06-13T18:16:27 | 2024-06-13T18:16:27 |
Bayode Ogunleye, Kudirat Ibilola Zakariyyah, Oluwaseun Ajao, Olakunle Olayinka, Hemlata Sharma
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, H.3.3
|
The use of generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) in academia is a
subjective and hotly debated topic. Currently, there are no agreed guidelines
towards the usage of GenAI systems in higher education (HE) and, thus, it is
still unclear how to make effective use of the technology for teaching and
learning practice. This paper provides an overview of the current state of
research on GenAI for teaching and learning in HE. To this end, this study
conducted a systematic review of relevant studies indexed by Scopus, using the
preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses (PRISMA)
guidelines. The search criteria revealed a total of 625 research papers, of
which 355 met the final inclusion criteria. The findings from the review showed
the current state and the future trends in documents, citations, document
sources/authors, keywords, and co-authorship. The research gaps identified
suggest that while some authors have looked at understanding the detection of
AI-generated text, it may be beneficial to understand how GenAI can be
incorporated into supporting the educational curriculum for assessments,
teaching, and learning delivery. Furthermore, there is a need for additional
interdisciplinary, multidimensional studies in HE through collaboration. This
will strengthen the awareness and understanding of students, tutors, and other
stakeholders, which will be instrumental in formulating guidelines, frameworks,
and policies for GenAI usage.
|
[
-0.42109215259552,
-0.657615065574646,
0.2737311124801636,
-0.11069624125957489,
0.03804982453584671,
0.24378538131713867,
-0.18178993463516235,
-0.32295629382133484,
0.16658617556095123,
-0.05958390235900879,
-0.16950297355651855,
-0.33550891280174255,
-0.5315716862678528,
0.37881091237068176,
-0.6625011563301086,
0.6718140244483948,
-0.027493443340063095,
0.35526400804519653,
-0.4438193440437317,
-0.27826857566833496,
-0.5857027173042297,
-0.23166024684906006,
-0.45086029171943665,
-0.6449955105781555,
0.5392189621925354,
0.6288483738899231,
0.4236033260822296,
0.05336405336856842,
0.8296793699264526,
0.2691386640071869,
0.10466770082712173,
0.03848366439342499,
-0.16800515353679657,
-0.08819214999675751,
-0.007593514863401651,
-0.6044135689735413,
-0.2998071014881134,
0.16484905779361725,
1.0839283466339111,
0.7440495491027832,
-0.3263412415981293,
0.16684392094612122,
0.2815737724304199,
0.5913654565811157,
-0.5963830351829529,
0.0899352878332138,
0.05963458493351936,
0.3239333927631378,
-0.39043837785720825,
0.0029979541432112455,
-0.2976013422012329,
-0.30562376976013184,
0.38758590817451477,
-0.8879832029342651,
0.29523083567619324,
-0.20972749590873718,
0.5860079526901245,
0.35899901390075684,
-0.20775873959064484,
-0.2260337620973587,
-0.813204824924469,
0.6589133143424988,
-0.5746150612831116,
0.20747560262680054,
0.17905381321907043,
0.35235631465911865,
0.0544138140976429,
-0.6859629154205322,
-0.6513354778289795,
-0.0007406102959066629,
-0.002447541104629636,
0.48750951886177063,
0.29009300470352173,
0.2238532453775406,
0.20511353015899658,
0.668754518032074,
-0.43867403268814087,
0.10495041310787201,
-0.7392478585243225,
0.09223265200853348,
0.6292394995689392,
0.11794571578502655,
0.7691422700881958,
-0.036089833825826645,
-0.35688546299934387,
-0.17543098330497742,
-0.5964828729629517,
-0.026481060311198235,
0.2586214542388916,
-0.006370082497596741,
0.0509173721075058,
0.5037251710891724,
-0.006552024744451046,
0.43415367603302,
-0.5153317451477051,
-0.08767174929380417,
0.24771718680858612,
-0.4211956560611725,
-0.3340739607810974,
-0.176192507147789,
1.0610793828964233,
0.0390847772359848,
0.1839274913072586,
-0.09143569320440292,
0.22961096465587616,
0.22403720021247864,
0.5467267036437988,
-0.4936898648738861,
-0.19193153083324432,
-0.08666733652353287,
-0.33707863092422485,
-0.1103033497929573,
0.23955082893371582,
-0.9913358688354492,
-0.15845483541488647,
-0.41060906648635864,
-0.03557256609201431,
-0.5560449361801147,
-0.47308164834976196,
-0.30234137177467346,
-0.3580973446369171,
0.32490596175193787,
0.4562639892101288,
-0.991401195526123,
0.024776365607976913,
0.6494565606117249,
0.7460553646087646,
-0.09726182371377945,
-0.7497648000717163,
0.18773852288722992,
0.003270132699981332,
-0.43815556168556213,
0.7154394388198853,
-0.66881263256073,
-0.7505837082862854,
0.2813403904438019,
-0.30729517340660095,
-0.4114362597465515,
-0.3901640474796295,
0.4202987551689148,
-0.2503921687602997,
0.6045953035354614,
-0.24868448078632355,
-0.6156476736068726,
-0.3234507143497467,
0.3087001144886017,
-0.6459656953811646,
0.82240229845047,
0.322489470243454,
-0.4152317941188812,
0.5508595108985901,
-0.823027491569519,
-0.5229867696762085,
0.6138044595718384,
-0.6999433040618896,
-0.5826342701911926,
-0.1368771642446518,
0.12879669666290283,
0.07366923987865448,
-0.31808018684387207,
0.7328502535820007,
0.20592071115970612,
-0.5908052325248718,
0.02271725796163082,
-0.34632378816604614,
0.9365143775939941,
0.4377131760120392,
-0.6193176507949829,
0.23766276240348816,
-0.36807680130004883,
-0.26488226652145386,
-0.1026478111743927,
-0.25364816188812256,
-0.4302542209625244,
0.027844080701470375,
-0.0442035049200058,
-0.30200210213661194,
-0.2715090811252594,
-0.3060474097728729,
0.41859298944473267,
-0.0352744460105896,
0.42785048484802246,
0.5283035635948181,
-0.16962723433971405,
0.6160547137260437,
-0.45258358120918274,
0.6379145383834839,
-0.39508056640625,
0.6131256222724915,
-0.1487131267786026,
-0.9359074234962463,
-0.7864708304405212,
-0.07964584231376648,
0.413808137178421,
0.3869327902793884,
-0.9443091154098511,
0.311360627412796,
0.05341755598783493,
-0.2838451564311981,
-0.998167872428894,
0.14790938794612885,
0.34855371713638306,
0.4268798232078552,
0.2792230546474457,
-0.43946516513824463,
-0.27268844842910767,
-0.4389812648296356,
-0.04275026172399521,
-0.3123456835746765,
0.061445802450180054,
0.2885874807834625,
0.5134212374687195,
-0.5353167653083801,
0.8256084322929382,
0.01692274399101734,
-0.6714372038841248,
-0.12000937759876251,
0.5339014530181885,
-0.31622496247291565,
0.379570871591568,
0.560867965221405,
-0.7321572303771973,
-0.43188971281051636,
-0.24655498564243317,
-1.421831488609314,
0.3582085072994232,
-0.34751394391059875,
-0.13986718654632568,
-0.029803302139043808,
0.3922852873802185,
-0.3770257532596588,
0.5342602729797363,
0.1314580738544464,
-0.177053302526474,
0.11993059515953064,
0.05744604021310806,
0.5312721729278564,
-0.8094757795333862,
0.3087702691555023,
0.07502859830856323,
0.38549160957336426,
-0.5902147889137268,
0.4083777070045471,
-0.08834652602672577,
-0.2259591668844223,
0.03236498683691025,
0.1976410448551178,
-0.4807261526584625,
-0.038921430706977844,
-0.27967891097068787,
0.09718755632638931,
-0.2859814167022705,
0.03726373240351677,
-0.26911142468452454,
1.2407721281051636,
0.5853054523468018,
-0.33064600825309753,
0.12747333943843842,
0.6140536665916443,
-0.5644012093544006,
0.7049515247344971,
-0.6222109794616699,
0.024936195462942123,
-0.027848059311509132,
0.30471745133399963,
-0.40466830134391785,
-0.15233765542507172,
0.5859479308128357,
-0.499162882566452,
0.2627125084400177,
0.032564640045166016,
-0.2685143053531647,
-0.49691760540008545,
-0.277159184217453,
0.5746614933013916,
0.5327710509300232,
-0.3285101056098938,
0.6867939233779907,
0.4144192934036255,
-0.15230971574783325,
-0.5457035899162292,
-0.47629988193511963,
0.4609690308570862,
0.11514464765787125,
-0.37394869327545166,
0.28552961349487305,
-0.044402867555618286,
-0.45422884821891785,
0.017927294597029686,
0.3162350654602051,
0.2780632972717285,
0.27195942401885986,
0.21791553497314453,
0.29013243317604065,
-0.10432225465774536,
-0.06664663553237915,
-0.0769965648651123,
-0.09932208806276321,
0.34531229734420776,
0.06494683027267456,
0.2859140634536743,
-0.027997931465506554,
-0.5296655297279358,
-0.7877503037452698,
0.37696573138237,
0.5601435899734497,
-0.15868450701236725,
0.25180956721305847,
0.938194215297699,
-0.07237245887517929,
-0.2618635296821594,
-0.23174911737442017,
-0.2852889597415924,
-0.4141989052295685,
-0.07677580416202545,
0.006702675484120846,
-0.7186340093612671,
0.11365983635187149,
-0.041259828954935074,
0.18667100369930267,
0.5332019925117493,
0.2945087254047394,
-0.34004101157188416,
0.496449738740921,
0.8042021989822388,
-0.3410859704017639,
0.6838560700416565,
-0.8771335482597351,
0.4556330740451813,
-1.1324677467346191,
-0.712727427482605,
-0.46559858322143555,
-0.30880874395370483,
-0.5430499911308289,
-0.31855157017707825,
0.5366504788398743,
-0.30949077010154724,
-0.07185190171003342,
-0.3573380708694458,
-0.6397770047187805,
0.11437969654798508,
1.1345688104629517,
0.13645027577877045,
0.2921253740787506,
0.07082568854093552,
0.23890367150306702,
0.21001659333705902,
-0.6834659576416016,
-0.36241278052330017,
1.261682152748108,
0.2125917375087738,
0.5573113560676575,
-0.019933447241783142,
0.6654684543609619,
0.6698575615882874,
0.6717711091041565,
-0.5407123565673828,
0.44356441497802734,
-0.003514989512041211,
-0.6427643895149231,
-0.5750225186347961,
-0.36996614933013916,
-0.8309502005577087,
0.11573819071054459,
0.00027201257762499154,
-0.11955799162387848,
0.14145804941654205,
-0.25974181294441223,
-0.35495027899742126,
0.6171954870223999,
-0.421644002199173,
0.3757612109184265,
-0.1778644174337387,
-0.1952427625656128,
-0.33655473589897156,
-0.6606355309486389,
0.37642791867256165,
0.3786059021949768,
0.13009272515773773,
0.07214676588773727,
0.4338390529155731,
1.2216321229934692,
-0.19791725277900696,
0.8479775190353394,
-0.1268470287322998,
-0.20685653388500214,
0.7425670623779297,
-0.4126608371734619,
-0.22088998556137085,
0.07427128404378891,
0.043467894196510315,
0.4744441509246826,
-0.1868397444486618,
-0.5191741585731506,
-0.3273797333240509,
0.4771190881729126,
-1.1262292861938477,
-0.670988917350769,
-1.0517585277557373,
-0.4455908536911011,
-0.0062753381207585335,
0.15025129914283752,
0.42785048484802246,
0.15503063797950745,
-0.26883453130722046,
0.013511010445654392,
0.7633787989616394,
-0.037790607661008835,
0.3099536597728729,
0.0891384482383728,
0.02977818436920643,
-0.4599524140357971,
1.1650410890579224,
0.23908869922161102,
-0.11634233593940735,
0.14027170836925507,
0.14206969738006592,
0.1818654090166092,
-0.6229341626167297,
-0.8253108859062195,
0.13007637858390808,
-0.37407779693603516,
-0.024868320673704147,
-0.4130713939666748,
-0.5753877758979797,
-0.722374439239502,
-0.16600294411182404,
0.09217771142721176,
0.16861778497695923,
-0.6960053443908691,
-0.08899013698101044,
0.04186730831861496,
1.144649863243103,
-0.03750457614660263,
0.3210482597351074,
-0.35252243280410767,
0.35930728912353516,
0.5421057343482971,
0.37782445549964905,
0.1661594808101654,
-0.34423452615737915,
0.050501786172389984,
0.08437809348106384,
-0.2999342679977417,
-0.4613581597805023,
0.20833027362823486,
0.4294890761375427,
0.6780332326889038,
0.6757665276527405,
-0.014353875070810318,
0.41613104939460754,
-0.19215618073940277,
1.0052746534347534,
0.2567218244075775,
-0.3898620009422302,
0.698920726776123,
-0.28025728464126587,
0.12130925059318542,
0.8671050071716309,
0.7303066253662109,
-0.4377048909664154,
-0.27971404790878296,
-0.48410212993621826,
-0.8282627463340759,
0.5333932638168335,
0.011738562025129795,
0.38407161831855774,
0.47321465611457825,
0.34301742911338806,
0.30296072363853455,
0.33567002415657043,
-0.3731856048107147,
-0.4911835789680481,
-0.20033720135688782,
-0.19644075632095337,
-0.033899880945682526,
-0.42733263969421387,
-0.5128523111343384,
-0.5972937345504761,
0.6123588681221008,
-0.2172495275735855,
0.4128873348236084,
0.04703648388385773,
0.010139348916709423,
-0.21878868341445923,
0.40238356590270996,
0.19542282819747925,
0.9229527115821838,
-0.1568121612071991,
-0.31875959038734436,
-0.26423782110214233,
-0.8205208778381348,
-0.02594882622361183,
0.1363903135061264,
-1.0297603607177734,
-0.15986667573451996,
0.5230643153190613,
0.38993141055107117,
0.06930376589298248,
-0.5338025093078613,
0.41166630387306213,
-0.02876216545701027,
-0.5471274256706238,
-0.7034938931465149,
0.3003518581390381,
-0.5884845852851868,
0.08988574892282486,
0.4320560097694397,
0.08527100831270218,
0.41807281970977783,
-0.821528971195221,
0.055772531777620316,
0.2264111489057541,
-0.3394347131252289,
-0.256352037191391,
0.4673272371292114,
0.634449303150177,
-0.3168959319591522,
1.4235504865646362,
-0.05794091895222664,
-0.28906717896461487,
0.6281484961509705,
0.36320674419403076,
0.8616712689399719,
-0.2632257640361786,
0.8055950999259949,
0.25733673572540283,
0.31619685888290405,
-0.04524435102939606,
0.49118825793266296,
-0.39028477668762207,
-0.4963739812374115,
0.15111017227172852,
-0.25909900665283203,
-0.7959185242652893,
-0.11503669619560242,
-0.6657556891441345,
-0.12540186941623688,
-0.4955369532108307,
-0.18523743748664856,
-0.144486665725708,
-0.115597203373909,
-0.47080734372138977,
0.009491483680903912,
0.18322081863880157,
0.6430428624153137,
-0.9103342890739441,
0.5610888004302979,
0.8596363067626953,
-0.9917666912078857,
-0.4590003788471222,
-0.012708532623946667,
0.08243727684020996,
-0.5046236515045166,
0.0823923796415329,
0.0074281939305365086,
0.03706727549433708,
-0.10959238559007645,
-0.5859092473983765,
-0.6237145662307739,
1.432878851890564,
-0.056465089321136475,
-0.6260296106338501,
-0.35848087072372437,
0.10036776214838028,
0.6473666429519653,
-0.010918139480054379,
0.44482704997062683,
0.5210227966308594,
0.5502951145172119,
0.02441210299730301,
-0.43985092639923096,
-0.38678985834121704,
-0.554405927658081,
-0.26118338108062744,
0.03871365636587143,
-0.963809072971344,
0.5975157022476196,
-0.2601190209388733,
-0.4263041913509369,
0.2405775934457779,
0.7370933294296265,
0.10611043125391006,
1.0004972219467163,
-0.038998737931251526,
0.8728834390640259,
0.758580207824707,
-0.3248676359653473,
0.8237878084182739,
-0.10645392537117004,
0.03781602531671524,
0.6958528757095337,
-0.3910806179046631,
0.5921970009803772,
0.38165104389190674,
-0.5266727805137634,
0.8823876976966858,
0.5172034502029419,
-0.4704497754573822,
0.26346689462661743,
-0.013973336666822433,
-0.462265282869339,
0.12566928565502167,
-0.3829696774482727,
-0.6082925796508789,
0.24631325900554657,
0.4588211178779602,
-0.30890652537345886,
0.1856497973203659,
0.46526530385017395,
-0.06690140068531036,
0.21525698900222778,
-0.2517372965812683,
0.8936406373977661,
0.10859473049640656,
-0.9267675876617432,
0.026485683396458626,
-0.2667430341243744,
0.8098903298377991,
-0.31904569268226624,
-0.20319990813732147,
-0.4020835757255554,
-0.12984809279441833,
-0.2997285723686218,
-0.6785709261894226,
0.04847300052642822,
-0.0024074793327599764,
0.08355098217725754,
-0.38849392533302307,
0.511996328830719,
-0.3336804211139679,
-0.4296410381793976,
0.17185550928115845,
0.494268536567688,
-0.1382332593202591,
0.46394920349121094,
-0.4365507662296295,
-0.03389766067266464,
-0.28738197684288025,
0.2886286973953247,
0.4582656919956207,
0.18464188277721405,
0.13463732600212097,
0.6158274412155151,
0.4975607991218567,
0.08554170280694962,
-0.06942583620548248,
0.700267493724823,
0.651140034198761,
-0.5773034691810608,
-0.2608627676963806,
-0.23120227456092834,
0.25549086928367615,
-0.14153771102428436,
-0.7802690863609314,
0.7117976546287537,
0.3107013404369354,
1.125657320022583,
0.30786362290382385,
1.1135056018829346,
-0.2237086296081543,
-0.118221715092659,
-0.33650529384613037,
0.7695062756538391,
-0.33876746892929077,
0.23040001094341278,
-0.22888043522834778,
-0.5605636835098267,
-0.25633737444877625,
0.45659106969833374,
-0.1725717931985855,
0.3468731641769409,
0.5489140748977661,
0.04241589456796646,
0.2814364731311798,
0.4769769012928009,
0.13510030508041382,
-0.2647725045681,
0.41125550866127014,
0.1305154711008072,
0.9235743284225464,
-0.5619389414787292,
0.03247683122754097,
-0.5130470991134644,
-0.49747198820114136,
-0.30555737018585205,
-0.1565895825624466,
-0.9418153166770935,
-0.7971659302711487,
-0.4486607015132904,
0.10000664740800858,
0.41189658641815186,
0.5547881126403809,
0.4783794581890106,
-0.788109302520752,
-0.43378421664237976,
-0.279039591550827,
0.23437052965164185,
-0.3956298828125,
-0.2542940676212311,
0.4726879894733429,
-0.525063157081604,
-0.6131799221038818,
0.34714582562446594,
0.09379202872514725,
-0.10395478457212448,
-0.5738895535469055,
-0.1198628768324852,
-0.5843204855918884,
-0.3381285071372986,
0.5829491019248962,
0.5987000465393066,
-0.5855588316917419,
0.07470868527889252,
-0.030520400032401085,
-0.03723081573843956,
-0.14072443544864655,
1.1099578142166138,
-0.6480912566184998,
0.6540673971176147,
0.6124067306518555,
0.8398659229278564,
0.008507904596626759,
-0.05341017246246338,
0.5507351756095886,
-0.1848328709602356,
-0.43554791808128357,
0.4535427689552307,
0.40948566794395447,
0.3103806674480438,
-0.2797541916370392,
0.7948414087295532,
0.5771719813346863,
-0.737208902835846,
-0.5831279158592224,
-0.1709100902080536,
-0.6698136925697327,
-0.2569597363471985,
0.8766805529594421,
-0.06089111045002937,
-0.21719668805599213,
-0.1223948746919632,
0.061613891273736954,
0.26833128929138184,
-0.3910166919231415,
1.3166745901107788,
0.38213467597961426,
-0.24541962146759033,
-0.2342120260000229,
-0.5195347666740417,
0.4693323075771332,
0.37755173444747925,
-1.0143365859985352,
-0.38681966066360474,
0.3652588129043579,
-0.08514232933521271,
0.30976060032844543,
0.533478856086731,
-0.19447612762451172,
0.5441213250160217,
-0.021395105868577957,
0.18903928995132446,
-0.007538657169789076,
-0.8594745993614197,
-0.32503557205200195,
0.1344049721956253,
0.04116763174533844,
-0.16267339885234833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09519v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09519v1
|
Talking Heads: Understanding Inter-layer Communication in Transformer Language Models
| 2024-06-13T18:12:01 | 2024-06-13T18:12:01 |
Jack Merullo, Carsten Eickhoff, Ellie Pavlick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Although it is known that transformer language models (LMs) pass features
from early layers to later layers, it is not well understood how this
information is represented and routed by the model. By analyzing particular
mechanism LMs use to accomplish this, we find that it is also used to recall
items from a list, and show that this mechanism can explain an otherwise
arbitrary-seeming sensitivity of the model to the order of items in the prompt.
Specifically, we find that models write into low-rank subspaces of the residual
stream to represent features which are then read out by specific later layers,
forming low-rank communication channels between layers. By decomposing
attention head weight matrices with the Singular Value Decomposition (SVD), we
find that previously described interactions between heads separated by one or
more layers can be predicted via analysis of their weight matrices. We show
that it is possible to manipulate the internal model representations as well as
edit model weights based on the mechanism we discover in order to significantly
improve performance on our synthetic Laundry List task, which requires recall
from a list, often improving task accuracy by over 20%. Our analysis reveals a
surprisingly intricate interpretable structure learned from language model
pretraining, and helps us understand why sophisticated LMs sometimes fail in
simple domains, facilitating future analysis of more complex behaviors.
|
[
-0.4466606378555298,
-0.6387584209442139,
0.45671817660331726,
0.001683495007455349,
-0.04606848955154419,
0.08664944767951965,
-0.13455332815647125,
-0.6440184116363525,
0.05813527852296829,
0.7280668616294861,
-0.7740123867988586,
-0.07656853646039963,
-0.8287392258644104,
-0.3627135455608368,
-0.49773353338241577,
1.0395478010177612,
0.23362396657466888,
-0.17956584692001343,
-0.33896002173423767,
-0.055919550359249115,
-0.44558870792388916,
-0.7706223726272583,
-0.5883355736732483,
-0.7642048597335815,
0.7402016520500183,
0.3761422336101532,
0.6482475996017456,
0.43138670921325684,
0.6585996747016907,
0.3213990330696106,
-0.18364542722702026,
-0.07995090633630753,
-0.759023129940033,
0.1462503969669342,
-0.36358878016471863,
-0.7366998195648193,
-0.4813072085380554,
-0.019329063594341278,
0.5561150908470154,
0.9997555017471313,
0.22596104443073273,
0.36770039796829224,
0.385140597820282,
0.7811394333839417,
-0.4152219891548157,
0.4671887755393982,
-0.515227198600769,
0.03370820730924606,
-0.16033242642879486,
-0.5317668914794922,
-0.6088495850563049,
0.3046957850456238,
0.4675091505050659,
0.009120594710111618,
0.07361268252134323,
-0.1605861783027649,
0.8725574612617493,
0.2728686034679413,
-0.17309404909610748,
-0.22965151071548462,
-1.1038804054260254,
0.7786684036254883,
-0.529190182685852,
0.39482444524765015,
0.39919400215148926,
0.2543390393257141,
0.15649959444999695,
-0.882618248462677,
-0.6357064843177795,
-0.15462329983711243,
-0.3101259768009186,
-0.09508940577507019,
-0.4300341308116913,
0.04368438944220543,
0.1571940779685974,
0.19914117455482483,
-0.15242883563041687,
-0.02148273214697838,
-0.5267618298530579,
0.18265680968761444,
0.2743118703365326,
-0.00971944723278284,
0.2437395304441452,
-0.045166611671447754,
-0.2871262729167938,
-0.20496855676174164,
-0.5309520959854126,
0.261814683675766,
0.21012917160987854,
0.6109590530395508,
-0.18169759213924408,
0.4653230905532837,
0.09765025228261948,
0.5514163970947266,
0.1995423436164856,
-0.07770956307649612,
-0.02796274796128273,
-0.011170336045324802,
-0.3391621708869934,
-0.1266009509563446,
0.34547242522239685,
0.32992324233055115,
0.31705161929130554,
-0.25794583559036255,
-0.15318624675273895,
-0.12868155539035797,
0.6900613903999329,
-0.6442873477935791,
-0.3421556055545807,
0.11322227120399475,
-0.8443751335144043,
-0.35803696513175964,
0.06772927939891815,
-0.09956388920545578,
-0.20590180158615112,
-0.5456695556640625,
0.6429725289344788,
-0.1979050636291504,
-0.2432277649641037,
0.01467321626842022,
-0.06013857200741768,
0.4152113199234009,
0.21872805058956146,
-0.830508291721344,
0.7102352380752563,
0.7071523070335388,
0.6289631128311157,
-0.12348324805498123,
-0.47410452365875244,
-0.39178267121315,
0.1571386456489563,
-0.07969579100608826,
0.9478669762611389,
-0.5422788262367249,
0.005482820328325033,
-0.3267262279987335,
0.16453306376934052,
-0.36564305424690247,
-0.612856388092041,
0.34315237402915955,
-0.4436323344707489,
0.20581039786338806,
-0.3896496891975403,
-0.43301764130592346,
-0.4496811330318451,
-0.034909266978502274,
-0.5951547622680664,
0.8020731210708618,
0.16816531121730804,
-0.8245270848274231,
-0.08666069060564041,
-0.4991914927959442,
-0.22816456854343414,
0.06641696393489838,
-0.08548521250486374,
-0.468437135219574,
0.2289816290140152,
-0.011410696431994438,
0.7225109338760376,
-0.2356119453907013,
-0.13769856095314026,
-0.09993166476488113,
-0.39014720916748047,
0.2026776820421219,
-0.12204951047897339,
0.6462053656578064,
0.01664683036506176,
-0.32065850496292114,
0.2829359173774719,
-0.3878951072692871,
-0.1048138216137886,
0.2652530074119568,
-0.07910798490047455,
-0.2772492468357086,
0.26858416199684143,
-0.21219410002231598,
0.33330729603767395,
0.005976784974336624,
-0.05015120282769203,
0.04944003373384476,
-0.034902166575193405,
0.5781740546226501,
0.6863245964050293,
0.0660572424530983,
0.5351866483688354,
-0.4677097797393799,
0.5392313599586487,
0.45407232642173767,
0.05132521316409111,
-0.38163480162620544,
-0.5316268801689148,
-1.0198737382888794,
0.29680001735687256,
-0.0791621059179306,
0.5009917616844177,
-0.5949157476425171,
0.3133231997489929,
-0.22633667290210724,
-0.4852242171764374,
-0.4229165017604828,
-0.09468647837638855,
0.5460306406021118,
0.5977898836135864,
0.3566074073314667,
-0.3141373097896576,
-0.41433537006378174,
-1.08894944190979,
-0.35663363337516785,
-0.23684579133987427,
0.0012366995215415955,
0.34919267892837524,
0.3806532025337219,
-0.21673545241355896,
0.8325926065444946,
-0.5007339715957642,
-0.20672352612018585,
-0.6671839952468872,
0.09226800501346588,
0.08729135245084763,
0.449215292930603,
0.48468199372291565,
-0.6232150793075562,
-0.28751686215400696,
-0.002630837494507432,
-0.3684723973274231,
-0.15003784000873566,
-0.04829519987106323,
-0.2032519280910492,
-0.1970992088317871,
0.7494094371795654,
-0.5488161444664001,
0.2796345055103302,
0.5474694967269897,
-0.2656131088733673,
0.33695918321609497,
-0.14434291422367096,
-0.21184588968753815,
-0.7133147120475769,
-0.021614940837025642,
0.027160026133060455,
-0.39608269929885864,
-0.9610685706138611,
0.07184043526649475,
-0.032336439937353134,
-0.11146387457847595,
-0.48047587275505066,
0.17390111088752747,
-0.43003207445144653,
-0.3332568407058716,
-0.4398767352104187,
0.05070856958627701,
0.0878487080335617,
0.8648131489753723,
-0.09877928346395493,
0.4981220066547394,
0.44944295287132263,
-0.7091979384422302,
0.06756468117237091,
0.23836804926395416,
-0.14549745619297028,
0.6831398606300354,
-0.6478880047798157,
0.3829861879348755,
-0.5513719320297241,
0.1527583748102188,
-0.9125136137008667,
0.23808620870113373,
0.3474539816379547,
-0.38831308484077454,
0.36314278841018677,
-0.3861984312534332,
-0.01521672960370779,
-0.33335962891578674,
0.015317024663090706,
0.22830623388290405,
0.25576141476631165,
-0.24965550005435944,
0.6350283026695251,
0.9036896824836731,
-0.24623391032218933,
-0.5177057385444641,
-0.6835246086120605,
-0.006749368738383055,
-0.2659393548965454,
-0.3381543457508087,
0.34860241413116455,
-0.25347477197647095,
-0.23277516663074493,
-0.05541516840457916,
-0.23208922147750854,
-0.10053317993879318,
0.110822893679142,
0.31951576471328735,
0.14185479283332825,
-0.30485856533050537,
-0.09504197537899017,
-0.13322758674621582,
-0.2676660120487213,
0.2869655191898346,
-0.5225159525871277,
0.6994038224220276,
-0.23299232125282288,
-0.3080769181251526,
-0.4422776401042938,
0.29654839634895325,
0.6678836345672607,
-0.1849161833524704,
0.8978756666183472,
0.578665018081665,
-0.5282875895500183,
-0.37190014123916626,
-0.3228707015514374,
-0.34286344051361084,
-0.4866392910480499,
0.34676218032836914,
-0.6362428069114685,
-0.6767287850379944,
0.5681436657905579,
-0.0168683473020792,
-0.1689097285270691,
0.306290864944458,
0.5874534249305725,
-0.2804710865020752,
0.8382918238639832,
1.03361177444458,
-0.007229425944387913,
0.4652281701564789,
-0.3618999421596527,
0.567828357219696,
-0.9184560179710388,
-0.35361629724502563,
-0.5023541450500488,
-0.5939465165138245,
-0.3707040846347809,
-0.6487385034561157,
0.21228542923927307,
0.2747615873813629,
0.0029206343460828066,
0.6597530841827393,
-0.5527895092964172,
0.5628218650817871,
0.6892247200012207,
0.14243192970752716,
0.2135164886713028,
-0.27098774909973145,
0.07504484802484512,
0.003210297552868724,
-0.5012975931167603,
-0.5545780658721924,
0.5556594729423523,
0.7176445722579956,
0.7643377780914307,
-0.20956701040267944,
0.29058966040611267,
0.20791462063789368,
0.010296161286532879,
-0.9092473387718201,
0.6433535814285278,
-0.21616590023040771,
-0.03993673250079155,
-0.13856036961078644,
-0.18706440925598145,
-0.8324503898620605,
0.33399489521980286,
-0.007723972201347351,
-0.7683773040771484,
0.33366549015045166,
0.023922599852085114,
-0.35870394110679626,
0.3171657621860504,
-0.8467487096786499,
0.83989417552948,
0.10871019959449768,
0.058748189359903336,
-0.15632416307926178,
-0.6547974944114685,
0.2510595917701721,
0.23697316646575928,
-0.04043059051036835,
-0.15310357511043549,
0.1934201866388321,
0.873065710067749,
-0.1415116786956787,
0.9324966669082642,
-0.028793729841709137,
-0.2769274413585663,
0.1363624483346939,
0.08791983127593994,
0.3728712499141693,
-0.2727968394756317,
0.28435638546943665,
0.30692440271377563,
-0.07012186199426651,
-0.2912183403968811,
-0.5046571493148804,
0.5427889823913574,
-0.8285294771194458,
-0.4897655248641968,
-0.06973904371261597,
-0.7528117299079895,
-0.105226069688797,
0.11412619054317474,
0.11307305842638016,
0.45571497082710266,
0.24120621383190155,
0.31304627656936646,
0.7175830602645874,
-0.15904875099658966,
0.3991800844669342,
0.38702166080474854,
-0.12997592985630035,
0.22004921734333038,
0.874786913394928,
0.27232539653778076,
0.49428799748420715,
0.7295293807983398,
0.11558908969163895,
0.1323603093624115,
-0.5437445044517517,
-0.025418229401111603,
0.14751800894737244,
-0.9199981093406677,
0.039537232369184494,
-0.9782156944274902,
-0.6426049470901489,
-0.20817872881889343,
0.0942295715212822,
-0.42877256870269775,
-0.4692201614379883,
-0.05443944036960602,
-0.2142058163881302,
-0.1025371104478836,
0.9660396575927734,
0.27004849910736084,
0.5994717478752136,
-0.6372990608215332,
0.45902422070503235,
0.4588768482208252,
0.29048576951026917,
0.3179905116558075,
-0.46588969230651855,
-0.5612601637840271,
-0.07145767658948898,
-0.37113240361213684,
-0.7010664939880371,
0.44564613699913025,
0.014758408069610596,
0.5617921352386475,
0.3560592234134674,
-0.08014761656522751,
0.7649297714233398,
-0.5738496780395508,
0.6233931183815002,
-0.2503652572631836,
-1.2048341035842896,
0.31923824548721313,
-0.14607401192188263,
0.4045349955558777,
0.06760041415691376,
0.23982124030590057,
-0.803314745426178,
-0.6320858597755432,
-0.6908577680587769,
-0.7497107982635498,
0.9786573648452759,
0.26349690556526184,
0.1169121041893959,
0.20749962329864502,
0.12175755947828293,
0.07160243391990662,
0.25429439544677734,
-0.7833792567253113,
-0.5402825474739075,
-0.018497781828045845,
0.02052517980337143,
-0.0032842347864061594,
-0.4317345917224884,
-0.04240516945719719,
-0.2341940850019455,
0.4029828608036041,
-0.10726038366556168,
0.6809805035591125,
-0.007231184747070074,
-0.34077784419059753,
-0.3632882833480835,
-0.03794429451227188,
0.7854896783828735,
0.8491002917289734,
-0.17744503915309906,
0.405892938375473,
0.010906711220741272,
-0.5259521007537842,
-0.2252548336982727,
-0.2106229066848755,
0.051247261464595795,
-0.10844027251005173,
0.5676584839820862,
1.216651201248169,
0.4035150110721588,
-0.357064813375473,
0.45009949803352356,
-0.15789909660816193,
0.1318976879119873,
-0.2675502896308899,
0.02915911376476288,
0.3675921857357025,
0.3831999897956848,
0.5765559077262878,
0.4032081365585327,
-0.04767477884888649,
-0.6936806440353394,
0.3496333956718445,
0.4520109295845032,
-0.5712886452674866,
-0.6369286775588989,
0.5519577264785767,
-0.01594003662467003,
-0.42078372836112976,
0.3368384838104248,
0.2589885890483856,
-0.6328328251838684,
0.48007234930992126,
0.3662693202495575,
0.9017060399055481,
-0.28665560483932495,
0.1503724902868271,
0.027057282626628876,
0.5027638077735901,
0.10095655173063278,
0.07554652541875839,
-0.17191946506500244,
-0.8645559549331665,
-0.4438471794128418,
-0.5147684812545776,
-0.5857130289077759,
0.33998575806617737,
-0.7679626941680908,
0.13325951993465424,
-0.32389453053474426,
-0.0004771218809764832,
0.15462450683116913,
-0.20145809650421143,
-0.878671407699585,
0.10742688924074173,
0.5131807327270508,
0.4382948875427246,
-0.9039060473442078,
0.8687726855278015,
0.3329564929008484,
-0.34265246987342834,
-0.7056791186332703,
0.10996172577142715,
-0.30952730774879456,
-1.0063588619232178,
0.7475405931472778,
0.3109274208545685,
-0.2873331606388092,
0.11354710161685944,
-0.340331494808197,
-0.9060455560684204,
0.7991992235183716,
0.46683254837989807,
-0.4202744662761688,
-0.48265963792800903,
0.3554057776927948,
0.285348504781723,
-0.5478712320327759,
0.6801650524139404,
0.7159168124198914,
0.35313087701797485,
-0.15603426098823547,
-1.1469411849975586,
-0.02221612073481083,
-0.21241292357444763,
0.16756883263587952,
0.030406756326556206,
-0.4901057779788971,
1.266342282295227,
-0.1844603568315506,
-0.3379075229167938,
-0.3546799421310425,
0.6010184288024902,
-0.1585760861635208,
0.05714322254061699,
0.554552435874939,
0.332771360874176,
0.5618671178817749,
0.03316482529044151,
0.9237027764320374,
-0.34914684295654297,
0.31682416796684265,
1.0819350481033325,
-0.1289374977350235,
0.8694154024124146,
0.4947505295276642,
-0.061742495745420456,
0.7994766235351562,
0.16473345458507538,
0.34608739614486694,
0.4147736430168152,
0.1381891369819641,
0.04994683340191841,
-0.004549753852188587,
-0.038524266332387924,
-0.10729586333036423,
0.524601399898529,
0.39270833134651184,
-0.3863712549209595,
-0.24867939949035645,
0.41240882873535156,
-0.13429337739944458,
-0.186592236161232,
-0.38173845410346985,
0.9011744260787964,
0.3313578963279724,
-0.4982023239135742,
0.654545247554779,
-0.1678335815668106,
0.34138616919517517,
-0.476528525352478,
-0.027210082858800888,
0.052837684750556946,
0.4597128629684448,
-0.08311780542135239,
-0.8225660920143127,
0.4442698657512665,
-0.3087013363838196,
-0.4884845018386841,
-0.6172414422035217,
0.7696366310119629,
-0.6388660669326782,
-0.18571250140666962,
0.49549102783203125,
0.6518544554710388,
0.13578864932060242,
-0.24694187939167023,
-0.7796440720558167,
0.4475404918193817,
-0.2681898772716522,
-0.4837283790111542,
0.39863523840904236,
0.2691956162452698,
-0.09939620643854141,
0.8357434868812561,
0.5816164016723633,
0.14877299964427948,
0.07577768713235855,
0.34442585706710815,
0.8572637438774109,
-0.7363980412483215,
-0.5903511047363281,
-0.7468011379241943,
0.6164159178733826,
0.13132795691490173,
0.14971724152565002,
0.5661436915397644,
0.13087394833564758,
1.1176960468292236,
-0.26887762546539307,
0.5189396739006042,
0.2948523461818695,
0.7703288197517395,
-0.28087079524993896,
0.9035460948944092,
0.0032243281602859497,
0.34313854575157166,
-0.3100099563598633,
-0.9538978338241577,
-0.02694130502641201,
0.6662836074829102,
-0.09798204898834229,
-0.058811645954847336,
0.9646826982498169,
0.5094712972640991,
-0.1668093502521515,
-0.1080598533153534,
0.2653815746307373,
0.44300544261932373,
0.3691253662109375,
0.5909826755523682,
0.7166970372200012,
-0.49373796582221985,
0.517142117023468,
-0.6260515451431274,
0.04057098180055618,
-0.0500091016292572,
-0.8021953701972961,
-0.9356913566589355,
-0.8884469866752625,
-0.3278844952583313,
-0.25721272826194763,
-0.07220584899187088,
0.7186594605445862,
0.9417505860328674,
-0.7406267523765564,
-0.5459778308868408,
0.004124104510992765,
0.11470222473144531,
-0.5997430086135864,
-0.3017754554748535,
0.2057180553674698,
-0.3443101644515991,
-0.8426251411437988,
0.41988998651504517,
0.4751839339733124,
-0.08688174933195114,
-0.4656829237937927,
0.0666598379611969,
0.06467687338590622,
0.23503656685352325,
0.8306810259819031,
0.12168499827384949,
-0.6952092051506042,
-0.43131864070892334,
-0.1350478231906891,
-0.11359498649835587,
0.14165768027305603,
1.0939116477966309,
-1.0885918140411377,
0.0737123191356659,
0.5938973426818848,
0.5380244851112366,
0.4413662552833557,
-0.017409997060894966,
0.643949568271637,
-0.694421648979187,
0.23939086496829987,
0.23604315519332886,
0.3249923288822174,
0.3118937611579895,
-0.3110308349132538,
0.06607154756784439,
0.1530362069606781,
-0.45135733485221863,
-0.927458643913269,
0.31016743183135986,
-1.1287373304367065,
-0.3379753828048706,
0.6916231513023376,
-0.04065593332052231,
-0.37194105982780457,
-0.1291351318359375,
-0.2327573150396347,
0.29818564653396606,
0.10804575681686401,
0.703777551651001,
0.6401216387748718,
-0.0737600028514862,
-0.6841558814048767,
-0.6005333065986633,
0.6143126487731934,
0.2937029302120209,
-0.6474966406822205,
0.21204249560832977,
-0.10420846939086914,
0.13620541989803314,
0.21689565479755402,
0.6789646148681641,
0.1381068080663681,
-0.0705396831035614,
-0.4060966372489929,
-0.15044328570365906,
0.026407284662127495,
-0.5338271260261536,
-0.1361483335494995,
0.18931050598621368,
-0.07509629428386688,
-0.1852923184633255
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09411v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09411v2
|
MuirBench: A Comprehensive Benchmark for Robust Multi-image Understanding
| 2024-06-13T17:59:52 | 2024-07-02T01:56:14 |
Fei Wang, Xingyu Fu, James Y. Huang, Zekun Li, Qin Liu, Xiaogeng Liu, Mingyu Derek Ma, Nan Xu, Wenxuan Zhou, Kai Zhang, Tianyi Lorena Yan, Wenjie Jacky Mo, Hsiang-Hui Liu, Pan Lu, Chunyuan Li, Chaowei Xiao, Kai-Wei Chang, Dan Roth, Sheng Zhang, Hoifung Poon, Muhao Chen
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We introduce MuirBench, a comprehensive benchmark that focuses on robust
multi-image understanding capabilities of multimodal LLMs. MuirBench consists
of 12 diverse multi-image tasks (e.g., scene understanding, ordering) that
involve 10 categories of multi-image relations (e.g., multiview, temporal
relations). Comprising 11,264 images and 2,600 multiple-choice questions,
MuirBench is created in a pairwise manner, where each standard instance is
paired with an unanswerable variant that has minimal semantic differences, in
order for a reliable assessment. Evaluated upon 20 recent multi-modal LLMs, our
results reveal that even the best-performing models like GPT-4o and Gemini Pro
find it challenging to solve MuirBench, achieving 68.0% and 49.3% in accuracy.
Open-source multimodal LLMs trained on single images can hardly generalize to
multi-image questions, hovering below 33.3% in accuracy. These results
highlight the importance of MuirBench in encouraging the community to develop
multimodal LLMs that can look beyond a single image, suggesting potential
pathways for future improvements.
|
[
-0.7468127608299255,
-0.5944350957870483,
0.7761422395706177,
0.3875955641269684,
-0.44815364480018616,
0.032139938324689865,
-0.028667164966464043,
-0.6072126030921936,
-0.09434887766838074,
0.42609646916389465,
-0.7836830019950867,
-0.6655241250991821,
-0.7359288930892944,
-0.1243724450469017,
-0.342020183801651,
0.6709657311439514,
-0.1437024623155594,
0.19386640191078186,
-0.38848230242729187,
-0.8945592045783997,
-0.3472500741481781,
-0.03218734636902809,
-0.4099636673927307,
-0.03922657668590546,
0.7199231386184692,
0.231271430850029,
0.5388680100440979,
0.4716299772262573,
0.6964430809020996,
0.3318656086921692,
0.022341499105095863,
0.1528046578168869,
-0.42274120450019836,
0.2380026876926422,
-0.3058684170246124,
-0.3600665330886841,
-0.2994545102119446,
0.14126160740852356,
0.43236884474754333,
0.5917629599571228,
-0.10470287501811981,
0.6170746088027954,
-0.0823814794421196,
0.6135078072547913,
-0.9715021848678589,
0.09740541875362396,
-0.7297844290733337,
0.007972834631800652,
-0.2727278470993042,
0.032098494470119476,
-0.16810743510723114,
-0.11367052793502808,
-0.1357126235961914,
-0.6899603009223938,
0.44078993797302246,
0.09681200981140137,
0.5596481561660767,
0.488844633102417,
-0.8377661108970642,
0.07718911021947861,
-0.12295015156269073,
0.8777214288711548,
-0.262714147567749,
0.641689121723175,
0.24577820301055908,
0.7684357166290283,
0.026596881449222565,
-0.8841951489448547,
-0.3927074372768402,
-0.1911255121231079,
0.12229152768850327,
0.35743850469589233,
0.03125942125916481,
0.17692680656909943,
0.2972278892993927,
0.3747667670249939,
-0.6167829632759094,
-0.04867544770240784,
-0.30916887521743774,
-0.2412334382534027,
0.24775439500808716,
0.1461562067270279,
-0.11652633547782898,
-0.4274798035621643,
-0.8017744421958923,
-0.28541454672813416,
-0.35192230343818665,
0.2574436068534851,
0.06387565284967422,
-0.5509969592094421,
0.17107334733009338,
0.4074876010417938,
-0.25687769055366516,
0.8373984098434448,
-0.06140773370862007,
-0.25447985529899597,
0.18382270634174347,
-0.5093090534210205,
-0.18887287378311157,
-0.23883800208568573,
0.6339311599731445,
0.7348353862762451,
-0.16507995128631592,
-0.19910717010498047,
-0.03407684713602066,
0.43567419052124023,
0.3010523319244385,
-0.7363163828849792,
-0.2511374056339264,
0.1669972538948059,
-0.5601162314414978,
-0.17997436225414276,
0.04985708370804787,
-0.9749177098274231,
-0.4727381467819214,
-0.24467407166957855,
0.24529726803302765,
-0.2646600008010864,
-0.05423213541507721,
-0.03705454245209694,
-0.30718764662742615,
0.36172983050346375,
0.7220580577850342,
-0.38120725750923157,
0.27615371346473694,
0.5308222770690918,
0.8057946562767029,
-0.16115298867225647,
-0.49303358793258667,
-0.6370173096656799,
0.17576943337917328,
-0.2993227541446686,
0.9827208518981934,
-0.3872343897819519,
-0.5372503995895386,
-0.5426724553108215,
0.15592776238918304,
-0.05159333720803261,
-0.6120066046714783,
0.6316478252410889,
-0.3983650505542755,
-0.051003310829401016,
-0.3299061954021454,
-0.10004235059022903,
-0.6391062140464783,
0.8399306535720825,
-0.8916827440261841,
1.1246840953826904,
-0.10080081224441528,
-0.6957460641860962,
0.46520981192588806,
-0.44137659668922424,
-0.01631392352283001,
-0.4255804717540741,
-0.2711484730243683,
-0.1018463671207428,
0.2655828893184662,
0.6149452924728394,
0.5386365056037903,
-0.41386908292770386,
0.48425018787384033,
-0.9210050106048584,
-0.08248554170131683,
0.44865483045578003,
-0.4924568831920624,
0.3482120931148529,
0.1816248595714569,
-0.31391146779060364,
0.21988198161125183,
-0.8850283026695251,
0.29320162534713745,
-0.13441193103790283,
-0.30759960412979126,
0.06694056838750839,
-0.16135799884796143,
0.339208722114563,
0.6301748156547546,
0.13759616017341614,
-0.6550948619842529,
-0.245292067527771,
0.40816012024879456,
0.269634872674942,
1.07975172996521,
-0.09418351203203201,
0.07026785612106323,
-0.43451017141342163,
0.6341273784637451,
0.08398269861936569,
0.2764398455619812,
-0.5537649393081665,
-0.502817690372467,
-0.6444998979568481,
-0.643549919128418,
0.11928154528141022,
0.3333202600479126,
-0.5538436770439148,
-0.126641184091568,
-0.20894184708595276,
-0.4514015018939972,
-0.4949973523616791,
0.465553879737854,
0.7216752767562866,
0.7696540951728821,
0.42852771282196045,
-0.8954922556877136,
-0.2936398386955261,
-1.1685664653778076,
-0.09572280198335648,
0.04555894434452057,
0.00043899344746023417,
0.4855101704597473,
0.5155649185180664,
-0.3030989468097687,
0.5787379145622253,
-0.35569655895233154,
-0.21302387118339539,
0.2994053065776825,
0.29271602630615234,
0.04647453874349594,
0.3627058267593384,
0.6215347647666931,
-0.8277233839035034,
-0.3420819938182831,
-0.0446285642683506,
-0.885329008102417,
0.21526846289634705,
-0.04390907287597656,
-0.3399065434932709,
-0.1401429921388626,
0.5124534368515015,
-0.4489934742450714,
0.30878788232803345,
0.7942308187484741,
0.06896846741437912,
0.5266447067260742,
-0.17035582661628723,
0.49561378359794617,
-0.9496802687644958,
0.37828442454338074,
0.026407357305288315,
-0.4193321466445923,
-0.20505529642105103,
0.39638224244117737,
0.4547830820083618,
-0.12236068397760391,
-0.6589400768280029,
0.40707844495773315,
-0.3925403952598572,
-0.3418560028076172,
0.15549752116203308,
0.08544202893972397,
0.22071050107479095,
0.5541955232620239,
-0.1902237832546234,
0.7596254348754883,
0.707808256149292,
-0.3088584542274475,
0.510377049446106,
0.15666504204273224,
-0.5986557602882385,
1.2510517835617065,
-0.685434103012085,
0.30472487211227417,
-0.2367534339427948,
0.514930248260498,
-1.3243526220321655,
-0.3915082812309265,
-0.1269042193889618,
-0.09352411329746246,
0.15025562047958374,
0.013382203876972198,
-0.5195310115814209,
-0.20017395913600922,
-0.6228820085525513,
0.6182764768600464,
0.1303696483373642,
-0.8824110627174377,
0.7544034719467163,
0.05482729896903038,
0.12314996868371964,
-0.7613553404808044,
-0.6522014737129211,
0.2085765302181244,
-0.3265507221221924,
-0.9348636865615845,
0.2815737724304199,
-0.1689935177564621,
-0.11220681667327881,
0.11681532114744186,
-0.4154370427131653,
-0.18249432742595673,
0.10104751586914062,
0.4879036247730255,
0.12540000677108765,
-0.17057915031909943,
0.03569762036204338,
-0.2081225961446762,
-0.2647959291934967,
-0.12798967957496643,
-0.08207240700721741,
0.22510647773742676,
-0.4127177894115448,
-0.857872486114502,
-0.30996230244636536,
0.3538949489593506,
0.8230665326118469,
-0.35995039343833923,
0.24427510797977448,
0.8292853832244873,
-0.09676863998174667,
0.07408377528190613,
-0.9421923160552979,
0.14677023887634277,
-0.47141754627227783,
0.34516605734825134,
-0.5720099806785583,
-0.6679087281227112,
0.7581340074539185,
-0.39219149947166443,
0.041260361671447754,
0.2408129870891571,
0.33766525983810425,
-0.21288317441940308,
1.0681923627853394,
0.4804450571537018,
0.048344653099775314,
0.3333143889904022,
-0.1597713977098465,
-0.2767316997051239,
-1.0516629219055176,
-0.4716029167175293,
-0.21979355812072754,
-0.7482433319091797,
-0.39692050218582153,
-0.7674446702003479,
0.6709302663803101,
0.08080362528562546,
-0.07680416852235794,
0.16044270992279053,
-0.2814338207244873,
0.5346361398696899,
0.6323554515838623,
0.41830217838287354,
0.446081280708313,
-0.276208758354187,
-0.24468117952346802,
-0.06739117950201035,
-0.4175085425376892,
-0.3673800230026245,
1.335864543914795,
0.07876796275377274,
0.945390522480011,
0.24851372838020325,
0.5730172395706177,
-0.17245009541511536,
0.47712409496307373,
-0.5371829271316528,
0.6681602001190186,
-0.01497398130595684,
-1.036982536315918,
0.27543148398399353,
-0.26820239424705505,
-0.9435805678367615,
0.7671620845794678,
0.01610148325562477,
-0.6858397722244263,
0.1938391774892807,
0.1275288462638855,
-0.09358209371566772,
0.22145718336105347,
-0.6460198760032654,
1.1103177070617676,
-0.6977024078369141,
-0.6099293828010559,
-0.4095537066459656,
-0.9138092994689941,
0.845319926738739,
-0.1614753007888794,
0.43135449290275574,
-0.29825180768966675,
-0.26053550839424133,
0.6017022132873535,
0.16435158252716064,
0.7469339370727539,
-0.05169285461306572,
0.197739377617836,
0.012771991081535816,
0.2275693714618683,
0.06970994174480438,
0.3326733708381653,
0.008261065930128098,
0.06776797771453857,
0.40368571877479553,
-0.5674036741256714,
-0.6545403003692627,
0.7304649353027344,
-0.42169785499572754,
-0.38674500584602356,
-0.34153690934181213,
-0.6250680685043335,
-0.4059138894081116,
0.09338907152414322,
0.025267187505960464,
0.6314185261726379,
-0.5044071674346924,
0.38392120599746704,
0.555392861366272,
-0.12469851225614548,
0.3007298409938812,
0.3438819646835327,
-0.2935062050819397,
-0.6537087559700012,
0.6875829100608826,
-0.23797020316123962,
0.3092738687992096,
0.10932378470897675,
-0.21691229939460754,
-0.5237575769424438,
-0.37146902084350586,
-0.5648792386054993,
0.12357989698648453,
-1.291411280632019,
-0.1580706685781479,
-0.6385320425033569,
0.42253220081329346,
0.13211023807525635,
-0.23705151677131653,
-0.3096606731414795,
-0.46090513467788696,
-0.08753219991922379,
-0.13452211022377014,
-0.06099780648946762,
0.5943478345870972,
-0.006658276543021202,
0.1275782287120819,
-0.8903266787528992,
0.6041661500930786,
0.6429548859596252,
0.6182987689971924,
-0.220774844288826,
-0.1270882487297058,
0.2797267436981201,
-0.38104575872421265,
-0.7754662036895752,
-0.7682607173919678,
-0.08253366500139236,
0.3484881520271301,
0.9254453778266907,
0.7940364480018616,
-0.1722816377878189,
1.1607469320297241,
-0.23243646323680878,
0.7160274982452393,
0.48683926463127136,
-0.8329776525497437,
0.5466596484184265,
-0.23110976815223694,
0.3156231939792633,
0.991369366645813,
0.17903679609298706,
-0.4262894093990326,
-0.27609091997146606,
-0.7875950932502747,
-0.5178635120391846,
0.5715073943138123,
-0.07267939299345016,
-0.05412203446030617,
0.32652467489242554,
-0.04207082837820053,
0.28384414315223694,
0.5569753646850586,
-0.6073055267333984,
0.12721993029117584,
-0.34589797258377075,
-0.1642346829175949,
-0.5606718063354492,
0.0089374715462327,
-0.5724126696586609,
-0.2970190942287445,
0.07000396400690079,
-0.36580193042755127,
0.05199740082025528,
-0.011913107708096504,
-0.3367980718612671,
0.026330459862947464,
0.2717728018760681,
0.5661811232566833,
0.8140354156494141,
-0.38547852635383606,
0.6828070282936096,
0.33261993527412415,
-0.201210618019104,
0.11453047394752502,
0.2504350244998932,
0.48125675320625305,
-0.16858308017253876,
0.5057054758071899,
0.7310932874679565,
0.6699388027191162,
-0.9213215112686157,
0.31145814061164856,
-0.0709967315196991,
-0.3404406011104584,
0.21415919065475464,
0.023354025557637215,
0.04148637875914574,
0.3539406359195709,
0.04107712581753731,
0.4462786912918091,
0.3086674213409424,
-0.6275981068611145,
0.25328758358955383,
0.6707438826560974,
-0.30041664838790894,
-0.29505404829978943,
0.7869170904159546,
0.01730116829276085,
0.29684537649154663,
0.4561665952205658,
-0.02971840649843216,
-0.5096130967140198,
0.7695624232292175,
0.09919189661741257,
0.578825831413269,
0.09156572818756104,
0.23348861932754517,
0.3466525971889496,
0.32146337628364563,
-0.17237983644008636,
0.2755030393600464,
-0.6327270865440369,
-0.40477222204208374,
-0.06053371727466583,
-0.41927775740623474,
-0.7065500617027283,
-0.1407473087310791,
-0.8364160060882568,
-0.10694103688001633,
-0.5304379463195801,
-0.26299944519996643,
0.017302529886364937,
-0.22408145666122437,
-0.9754205942153931,
0.03557363152503967,
-0.06547480076551437,
0.9251750707626343,
-0.5175682306289673,
0.6176971793174744,
0.7792001366615295,
-0.1341744363307953,
-0.4671821892261505,
-0.2512319087982178,
0.48360198736190796,
-0.9354645609855652,
0.5553731918334961,
0.6841402053833008,
-0.3306676149368286,
-0.032291166484355927,
-0.6153253316879272,
-0.7408871650695801,
1.3957351446151733,
0.5076316595077515,
-0.23005831241607666,
0.4496278762817383,
-0.281779408454895,
0.25358664989471436,
-0.09636423736810684,
0.396735280752182,
0.41008251905441284,
0.7543776035308838,
0.26745349168777466,
-0.9368884563446045,
-0.0033509330824017525,
-0.3794351816177368,
0.08341392874717712,
0.20870031416416168,
-0.6182567477226257,
0.9302558898925781,
-0.14653025567531586,
-0.21918289363384247,
0.17731083929538727,
0.12082547694444656,
0.35228121280670166,
0.6605526208877563,
0.6816967129707336,
0.8899921774864197,
0.6961040496826172,
-0.12222996354103088,
1.15822434425354,
-0.24892647564411163,
0.35388821363449097,
0.9342174530029297,
-0.21359924972057343,
0.6753058433532715,
0.7512148022651672,
-0.26269277930259705,
0.35847219824790955,
0.8739226460456848,
0.06361586600542068,
0.6603526473045349,
-0.07335153222084045,
-0.2681838572025299,
-0.5637184977531433,
-0.07815010845661163,
-0.4932430684566498,
0.40947625041007996,
0.3079342544078827,
-0.10889589786529541,
-0.7037220001220703,
0.12795980274677277,
-0.4644293785095215,
-0.22778035700321198,
-0.09397125244140625,
0.7212975025177002,
0.0887032076716423,
-0.8124156594276428,
0.5127353072166443,
0.014476912096142769,
0.7113413214683533,
-0.718333899974823,
0.18838702142238617,
-0.06491068750619888,
0.43022865056991577,
-0.17132963240146637,
-0.871239185333252,
0.048733580857515335,
-0.2297244817018509,
0.05017345771193504,
-0.301740437746048,
0.6778785586357117,
-0.15425021946430206,
-0.5518635511398315,
0.32237106561660767,
0.6930437088012695,
0.10811730474233627,
-0.28336039185523987,
-0.8759422898292542,
0.22209115326404572,
-0.28000980615615845,
-0.255066841840744,
0.42251044511795044,
0.31390145421028137,
-0.03395514562726021,
0.6398414969444275,
0.7742893695831299,
-0.5604774951934814,
0.38821595907211304,
-0.18982984125614166,
0.9524273872375488,
-0.45002296566963196,
-0.25511014461517334,
-0.5141081809997559,
0.5657573342323303,
-0.2084401398897171,
-0.5064347982406616,
0.7333011627197266,
0.31578323245048523,
0.9068539142608643,
-0.06504762917757034,
0.5314689874649048,
0.05798621475696564,
-0.011809801682829857,
-0.550996720790863,
0.1440933793783188,
-0.9206873774528503,
-0.10363803803920746,
-0.28419584035873413,
-0.9090834856033325,
-0.4369269609451294,
0.6523681282997131,
-0.2302057296037674,
0.019626306369900703,
0.8970848321914673,
1.0158605575561523,
-0.585936963558197,
0.07704080641269684,
0.27677181363105774,
-0.3699430227279663,
0.32191038131713867,
0.6573966145515442,
1.0683099031448364,
-0.11756787449121475,
0.6563318371772766,
-0.5431288480758667,
-0.3519230782985687,
-0.017847683280706406,
-0.8841356039047241,
-0.8733748197555542,
-0.5332915186882019,
-0.1081376001238823,
0.058467235416173935,
-0.23933735489845276,
0.48508700728416443,
1.0784308910369873,
-0.6647979021072388,
-0.18559449911117554,
-0.052100904285907745,
0.05841610208153725,
-0.5187593102455139,
-0.10363002866506577,
0.15409275889396667,
-0.28565430641174316,
-0.4997450113296509,
0.38733723759651184,
0.4559186100959778,
-0.27914485335350037,
-0.4090260863304138,
-0.08839844167232513,
-0.11281523108482361,
-0.15498290956020355,
0.5696720480918884,
0.0243024043738842,
-0.9141060709953308,
-0.09248410165309906,
0.07932073622941971,
-0.02803739346563816,
0.25094279646873474,
0.9652636647224426,
-0.7010589241981506,
1.0014687776565552,
0.3414635956287384,
0.7250193357467651,
1.0605895519256592,
0.16002480685710907,
0.052693940699100494,
-0.7217690348625183,
0.3089142143726349,
-0.02469755709171295,
0.5510140061378479,
0.3513328433036804,
0.09170418977737427,
0.6184214353561401,
0.17506766319274902,
-0.43596434593200684,
-0.7856468558311462,
0.39046236872673035,
-1.3683044910430908,
-0.30445778369903564,
0.6458727717399597,
-0.20525293052196503,
-0.17675122618675232,
-0.008163136430084705,
-0.4385552406311035,
-0.19036442041397095,
-0.16669531166553497,
0.5422977209091187,
0.802966296672821,
-0.2794519066810608,
-0.6572198271751404,
-0.958441436290741,
-0.19357334077358246,
0.6411238312721252,
-0.9268827438354492,
-0.49488505721092224,
0.7969115972518921,
0.3961666226387024,
0.2662704586982727,
0.6829316020011902,
-0.12359703332185745,
0.5132087469100952,
-0.09254524856805801,
-0.19151635468006134,
-0.24646402895450592,
-0.3977200388908386,
-0.23732930421829224,
0.4880794286727905,
0.002877030987292528,
-0.5656636953353882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09403v1
|
Visual Sketchpad: Sketching as a Visual Chain of Thought for Multimodal Language Models
| 2024-06-13T17:59:31 | 2024-06-13T17:59:31 |
Yushi Hu, Weijia Shi, Xingyu Fu, Dan Roth, Mari Ostendorf, Luke Zettlemoyer, Noah A Smith, Ranjay Krishna
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Humans draw to facilitate reasoning: we draw auxiliary lines when solving
geometry problems; we mark and circle when reasoning on maps; we use sketches
to amplify our ideas and relieve our limited-capacity working memory. However,
such actions are missing in current multimodal language models (LMs). Current
chain-of-thought and tool-use paradigms only use text as intermediate reasoning
steps. In this work, we introduce Sketchpad, a framework that gives multimodal
LMs a visual sketchpad and tools to draw on the sketchpad. The LM conducts
planning and reasoning according to the visual artifacts it has drawn.
Different from prior work, which uses text-to-image models to enable LMs to
draw, Sketchpad enables LMs to draw with lines, boxes, marks, etc., which is
closer to human sketching and better facilitates reasoning. Sketchpad can also
use specialist vision models during the sketching process (e.g., draw bounding
boxes with object detection models, draw masks with segmentation models), to
further enhance visual perception and reasoning. We experiment with a wide
range of math tasks (including geometry, functions, graphs, and chess) and
complex visual reasoning tasks. Sketchpad substantially improves performance on
all tasks over strong base models with no sketching, yielding an average gain
of 12.7% on math tasks, and 8.6% on vision tasks. GPT-4o with Sketchpad sets a
new state of the art on all tasks, including V*Bench (80.3%), BLINK spatial
reasoning (83.9%), and visual correspondence (80.8%). All codes and data are in
https://visualsketchpad.github.io/.
|
[
-0.37294167280197144,
-0.8898665904998779,
0.7508137822151184,
0.3787654936313629,
-0.17015205323696136,
0.24387557804584503,
0.022554665803909302,
-0.572074830532074,
0.46921390295028687,
0.6313128471374512,
-0.23625509440898895,
-0.38617202639579773,
-0.27193689346313477,
-0.25702372193336487,
-0.033643029630184174,
0.6009976267814636,
-0.35522544384002686,
0.07226637005805969,
-0.3118114471435547,
-0.032137032598257065,
-0.5344898104667664,
-0.304317831993103,
-0.4921537935733795,
-0.20859657227993011,
0.6741743683815002,
0.24517717957496643,
0.47906333208084106,
0.27289721369743347,
0.43491503596305847,
0.4126434326171875,
0.11296121031045914,
0.22782647609710693,
-0.20910082757472992,
0.03275683522224426,
-0.05099496990442276,
-0.6664205193519592,
-0.6455702781677246,
0.11235172301530838,
0.13924580812454224,
0.6131617426872253,
-0.09492571651935577,
-0.08010132610797882,
-0.20224471390247345,
0.635062038898468,
-0.6304255723953247,
0.12680524587631226,
-0.2490147203207016,
0.17816488444805145,
-0.18901242315769196,
-0.14195074141025543,
-0.3233497440814972,
-0.41950723528862,
-0.015515877865254879,
-0.9019603133201599,
0.19555844366550446,
0.126371830701828,
0.5211034417152405,
0.0045466371811926365,
-0.16342055797576904,
-0.2394530028104782,
-0.3813534677028656,
0.37986037135124207,
-0.4161619246006012,
0.3063707649707794,
0.36602985858917236,
0.4410993456840515,
-0.19879110157489777,
-0.906225323677063,
-1.0877938270568848,
-0.2447803020477295,
0.11037049442529678,
0.25629526376724243,
0.3204095959663391,
0.3001753091812134,
0.5307939052581787,
-0.0002475970541127026,
-0.5070965886116028,
-0.3690750002861023,
-0.5742411017417908,
-0.13703925907611847,
0.2164955884218216,
0.09108983725309372,
0.709078848361969,
-0.18533417582511902,
-0.5681125521659851,
-0.23068761825561523,
-0.6414851546287537,
0.3294585645198822,
0.32658064365386963,
0.06740594655275345,
-0.23587867617607117,
0.6757896542549133,
-0.07462015002965927,
0.7751758098602295,
-0.18811912834644318,
-0.455380380153656,
0.20432063937187195,
-0.3979489803314209,
-0.22578129172325134,
-0.2917039394378662,
0.556061327457428,
0.6501492857933044,
0.4258373975753784,
0.31948891282081604,
-0.12410873174667358,
0.1830158680677414,
0.27148881554603577,
-0.5961207747459412,
-0.7528248429298401,
-0.08062393218278885,
-0.4523271322250366,
-0.22429081797599792,
-0.16660307347774506,
-1.054644227027893,
-0.6464374661445618,
-0.449258029460907,
0.44207581877708435,
-0.27018290758132935,
-0.40844056010246277,
0.30616089701652527,
-0.593734860420227,
-0.22301991283893585,
1.0558736324310303,
-0.7937363982200623,
0.25501084327697754,
0.3050703704357147,
0.9176059365272522,
0.010815044865012169,
-0.4870973527431488,
-0.26900261640548706,
0.3181019425392151,
-0.5730170011520386,
1.0188472270965576,
-0.7348707914352417,
-0.4658271372318268,
-0.2691853940486908,
-0.27849358320236206,
-0.22351983189582825,
-0.4929535984992981,
0.5110837817192078,
0.1456695944070816,
0.1601669192314148,
-0.4786919951438904,
-0.2602179944515228,
-0.20640599727630615,
0.15324251353740692,
-0.9332113265991211,
1.0968929529190063,
-0.19785234332084656,
-0.5887657999992371,
0.6048368811607361,
-0.6913340091705322,
-0.2619457542896271,
0.14940154552459717,
-0.4926917254924774,
-0.04495004191994667,
0.016595760360360146,
0.19273154437541962,
0.4466005861759186,
-0.1988210380077362,
0.20210014283657074,
-0.7440819144248962,
-0.27400559186935425,
0.11653120815753937,
-0.15607093274593353,
0.6358349919319153,
0.023608656600117683,
-0.3110964298248291,
0.41510605812072754,
-0.6822092533111572,
0.1456877738237381,
0.09689849615097046,
-0.29703423380851746,
-0.31353235244750977,
-0.09415625780820847,
0.34064003825187683,
0.7254700064659119,
-0.19311927258968353,
-0.5531948208808899,
0.3774186074733734,
0.13764019310474396,
0.4444442391395569,
0.7728907465934753,
-0.36874255537986755,
0.3792281448841095,
-0.39370855689048767,
0.5773977637290955,
-0.024630064144730568,
-0.02228676900267601,
-0.5239155888557434,
-0.9488003849983215,
-0.8644370436668396,
-0.527068555355072,
-0.18033325672149658,
0.5069937705993652,
-1.110805869102478,
-0.011182749643921852,
-0.1752711683511734,
-0.36228248476982117,
-0.30952325463294983,
0.20424403250217438,
0.42771539092063904,
0.5016447305679321,
0.38756242394447327,
-0.19205839931964874,
-0.14650428295135498,
-0.5909929871559143,
-0.12342336028814316,
-0.16254830360412598,
0.10159913450479507,
0.2334485501050949,
0.47914475202560425,
0.10787806659936905,
0.5942573547363281,
-0.39547139406204224,
-0.21909268200397491,
-0.6697606444358826,
0.3068954646587372,
-0.09853545576334,
0.42260104417800903,
0.6134549379348755,
-0.6939600110054016,
-0.6279191374778748,
0.058346450328826904,
-0.6348264813423157,
-0.23999285697937012,
-0.4176686108112335,
-0.22258302569389343,
0.06556664407253265,
0.6020594835281372,
-1.1452692747116089,
0.8848077654838562,
0.4178285002708435,
-0.5414167046546936,
0.7272425889968872,
-0.21953612565994263,
0.09897769242525101,
-0.7376843690872192,
0.24556070566177368,
-0.02781321294605732,
-0.26654788851737976,
-0.4733738303184509,
-0.0038592752534896135,
0.1356419026851654,
-0.39690959453582764,
-0.02442188933491707,
0.9426586031913757,
-0.46819084882736206,
-0.03985856845974922,
-0.36790409684181213,
0.2847450077533722,
0.34588494896888733,
0.7393413186073303,
0.032375432550907135,
0.7734491229057312,
0.5211611986160278,
-0.16449207067489624,
0.5087375640869141,
-0.08301157504320145,
-0.36076685786247253,
0.5892527103424072,
-0.5602431893348694,
0.033101990818977356,
-0.054641108959913254,
0.4727941155433655,
-1.1953264474868774,
-0.0750698521733284,
0.21501527726650238,
-0.19446250796318054,
0.30487412214279175,
0.12822240591049194,
-0.37172210216522217,
-0.4387667179107666,
-0.5237206220626831,
0.3595118820667267,
0.08405160158872604,
-0.5884597897529602,
0.9138579368591309,
0.3978671133518219,
-0.45493370294570923,
-0.5332956314086914,
-0.2978939414024353,
0.21810965240001678,
0.0202286709100008,
-0.6320092082023621,
0.11041495203971863,
-0.14611999690532684,
-0.15030471980571747,
-0.0022543780505657196,
-0.14963731169700623,
-0.07194529473781586,
-0.33134517073631287,
0.28492358326911926,
0.37267744541168213,
0.032603006809949875,
0.18693724274635315,
-0.03739681839942932,
-0.1990191489458084,
-0.02522563375532627,
-0.07352765649557114,
0.4756077826023102,
0.02796288952231407,
-0.44463735818862915,
-0.33231300115585327,
0.22485631704330444,
0.5970032215118408,
-0.18630710244178772,
0.09978610277175903,
0.6945086121559143,
-0.1810683012008667,
-0.43915045261383057,
-0.6551887392997742,
0.008184521459043026,
-0.4534808099269867,
0.13886094093322754,
-0.7164684534072876,
-0.6654610633850098,
0.4139701724052429,
-0.38578519225120544,
-0.22944340109825134,
0.0002571136283222586,
0.318148672580719,
-0.43536287546157837,
0.6799607276916504,
0.7463130950927734,
0.24725349247455597,
0.4817327558994293,
-0.16224165260791779,
0.4048305153846741,
-0.7981866002082825,
-0.32092154026031494,
-0.1723874807357788,
-0.5382968783378601,
-0.400514155626297,
-0.9944916367530823,
0.3175201117992401,
0.35762569308280945,
0.1802976280450821,
-0.013816448859870434,
-0.20157019793987274,
0.6832267045974731,
0.7706257700920105,
0.17073379456996918,
-0.007675766479223967,
-0.19974243640899658,
-0.8103574514389038,
0.07766683399677277,
-0.5210192799568176,
-0.45113039016723633,
1.041159987449646,
0.038244087249040604,
0.9089166522026062,
-0.19591356813907623,
0.3301803767681122,
0.020980456843972206,
0.1832326203584671,
-0.4439978301525116,
0.9493328332901001,
0.07966265827417374,
-0.4152234196662903,
-0.3664689362049103,
-0.1512821465730667,
-0.3480973541736603,
0.5868484973907471,
-0.32494550943374634,
-0.7742496728897095,
0.2694023549556732,
0.4256393313407898,
-0.10185449570417404,
0.5323070287704468,
-0.9543145298957825,
0.9719796776771545,
-0.31211718916893005,
-0.7569994926452637,
-0.35225051641464233,
-0.5250235795974731,
0.3929580748081207,
0.2052019089460373,
-0.02400711178779602,
-0.09400378167629242,
0.18819911777973175,
0.49100634455680847,
-0.44657501578330994,
1.0991963148117065,
-0.3107413649559021,
0.11243733763694763,
0.3573903739452362,
0.13965687155723572,
0.31889066100120544,
-0.19856280088424683,
0.5223323106765747,
0.014905142597854137,
-0.07818394899368286,
-0.2662530839443207,
-0.7139629125595093,
0.6674772500991821,
-0.38146495819091797,
-0.457315057516098,
-0.22606681287288666,
-0.5968294739723206,
-0.04151468351483345,
0.36039337515830994,
-0.12996456027030945,
0.5163951516151428,
0.16122151911258698,
-0.0940871462225914,
0.46701759099960327,
-0.436795175075531,
0.4650423526763916,
-0.15880665183067322,
-0.8123989105224609,
-0.38421598076820374,
0.954431414604187,
-0.1294764131307602,
0.2572399079799652,
0.3555341958999634,
0.19206193089485168,
-0.28257784247398376,
-0.12064044922590256,
-0.7108921408653259,
0.37118837237358093,
-1.0468056201934814,
0.026692809537053108,
-0.6790006756782532,
0.1747862547636032,
-0.06886017322540283,
-0.33751651644706726,
-0.22986841201782227,
-0.9872069954872131,
0.32017266750335693,
-0.3038327693939209,
0.026821110397577286,
0.7635847330093384,
0.07121974229812622,
0.008075454272329807,
-0.23739232122898102,
0.7133194804191589,
0.5575399994850159,
0.4426794648170471,
0.03653598949313164,
0.30423077940940857,
-0.014439388178288937,
-0.16851688921451569,
-0.5360803604125977,
-0.7022866606712341,
0.17710553109645844,
-0.14743784070014954,
0.5112926363945007,
0.39801809191703796,
-0.572051465511322,
1.0197935104370117,
-0.5824181437492371,
0.5301000475883484,
0.5928913950920105,
-0.8901827335357666,
0.5006920695304871,
-0.4243272542953491,
0.26568225026130676,
0.07467810809612274,
0.06342713534832001,
-0.4626743495464325,
-0.33069464564323425,
-0.2117263525724411,
-0.4899740517139435,
0.34559881687164307,
0.014678329229354858,
-0.21140334010124207,
0.2600339353084564,
0.1403992921113968,
0.0803363099694252,
0.38852009177207947,
-0.868156373500824,
0.15185917913913727,
-0.5745263695716858,
-0.13422927260398865,
-0.04768579453229904,
-0.1927514672279358,
-0.036664001643657684,
-0.5047685503959656,
0.09927316009998322,
-0.2748447060585022,
0.45080137252807617,
-0.0072960322722792625,
0.028654012829065323,
-0.20965947210788727,
-0.11601949483156204,
0.9635277986526489,
1.0699176788330078,
0.06302724778652191,
0.3470390737056732,
-0.2809700667858124,
-0.683192253112793,
-0.12034669518470764,
0.061605099588632584,
0.02555176056921482,
0.05244552344083786,
0.5291825532913208,
0.8353574872016907,
0.23788712918758392,
-0.8777821063995361,
0.5585837364196777,
0.037133753299713135,
-0.1237265095114708,
-0.032726895064115524,
0.20175312459468842,
0.34973645210266113,
0.21945004165172577,
-0.0829026997089386,
0.33397406339645386,
0.14226369559764862,
-0.4554324746131897,
-0.09612502157688141,
0.37495285272598267,
-0.11735639721155167,
-0.5016994476318359,
0.6890560984611511,
0.4327861964702606,
-0.02751259133219719,
0.43237563967704773,
0.017005281522870064,
-0.5342296361923218,
0.6596816778182983,
0.6279835104942322,
0.6899868845939636,
-0.32497382164001465,
0.3609336018562317,
0.33735114336013794,
0.3873465657234192,
0.11615681648254395,
0.8440635800361633,
-0.33505237102508545,
-0.6420575380325317,
-0.4114806056022644,
-0.31112074851989746,
-0.4344518780708313,
-0.11434194445610046,
-0.24881890416145325,
0.2852887213230133,
-0.592924177646637,
-0.08298947662115097,
-0.005831375252455473,
-0.3413616716861725,
-0.5425264239311218,
0.08734893053770065,
0.05567252263426781,
0.8065149188041687,
-0.6755459308624268,
0.8706189393997192,
0.8810615539550781,
-0.43616318702697754,
-0.5302916765213013,
-0.18339447677135468,
0.12184518575668335,
-0.803502082824707,
0.9157463908195496,
0.48310792446136475,
-0.4075253903865814,
-0.4255879819393158,
-0.5776974558830261,
-0.49855679273605347,
0.9337453842163086,
0.14024868607521057,
-0.3601853847503662,
-0.0007130405865609646,
0.1345297396183014,
0.4463150203227997,
-0.1931043565273285,
0.3122582733631134,
-0.1486518234014511,
0.3535113036632538,
0.24902065098285675,
-1.1569215059280396,
0.0652141198515892,
-0.72524493932724,
0.022387197241187096,
0.4427335262298584,
-0.4678970277309418,
1.2417128086090088,
-0.6174574494361877,
-0.021076416596770287,
-0.024169649928808212,
0.10560915619134903,
0.5322767496109009,
0.46484285593032837,
0.2757778465747833,
0.8525285720825195,
0.7176529765129089,
-0.06625764071941376,
0.9614759087562561,
-0.10100863873958588,
-0.17433957755565643,
1.1151946783065796,
-0.4103376865386963,
0.7901532053947449,
0.5754877328872681,
0.036059677600860596,
0.6035262942314148,
0.04812587425112724,
0.3958326578140259,
0.3301333785057068,
0.1159282848238945,
-0.23221555352210999,
-0.30713343620300293,
0.11898547410964966,
-0.17907124757766724,
0.3289884924888611,
0.5235211253166199,
-0.028907589614391327,
-0.05913349986076355,
0.244221031665802,
0.04401693865656853,
0.019105128943920135,
-0.04476810619235039,
0.49007266759872437,
0.11947177350521088,
-0.37905675172805786,
0.15372280776500702,
-0.1881527304649353,
0.19105619192123413,
-0.5803746581077576,
-0.7028407454490662,
-0.22624489665031433,
0.27196431159973145,
0.17579230666160583,
-0.9466570615768433,
-0.24074764549732208,
-0.26799502968788147,
0.07403817772865295,
-0.4629676938056946,
0.9745067358016968,
-0.47394058108329773,
-0.5472841858863831,
0.22937403619289398,
0.5284079313278198,
-0.06830761581659317,
0.07077047973871231,
-0.7092335224151611,
0.1633838713169098,
-0.3034001588821411,
-0.161174476146698,
0.17533576488494873,
0.8283247351646423,
-0.3540649712085724,
1.0757663249969482,
0.8648892641067505,
0.2957458794116974,
0.3096212148666382,
0.21011283993721008,
1.1559215784072876,
-0.8282340168952942,
-0.7412635684013367,
-0.4933968186378479,
0.5391249656677246,
-0.38076603412628174,
-0.41609591245651245,
0.6716739535331726,
0.41941115260124207,
0.8731281161308289,
-0.18773946166038513,
0.7121759057044983,
-0.03335112705826759,
0.4430452883243561,
-0.8149318099021912,
0.6318029165267944,
-0.48747438192367554,
-0.1979401558637619,
-0.538844883441925,
-0.713559091091156,
-0.3234085142612457,
1.0781521797180176,
-0.1790146380662918,
0.3033124506473541,
1.0133169889450073,
0.509669840335846,
-0.18689338862895966,
0.0784095972776413,
0.29513996839523315,
-0.029941529035568237,
0.5481742024421692,
0.38361427187919617,
0.9915432333946228,
0.11168073117733002,
0.12643656134605408,
-0.3446059823036194,
-0.23556260764598846,
0.0491037480533123,
-0.7804197072982788,
-1.3222217559814453,
-0.5957903265953064,
0.12066371738910675,
0.13665388524532318,
-0.09196532517671585,
0.6303810477256775,
0.70025634765625,
-0.3246816098690033,
-0.5334723591804504,
-0.2921564280986786,
0.10278867185115814,
-0.1363726258277893,
-0.22822041809558868,
0.27748003602027893,
-0.33968397974967957,
-0.37886184453964233,
0.14509256184101105,
0.8089419007301331,
0.03075362555682659,
-0.27417075634002686,
-0.08139623701572418,
-0.34690147638320923,
-0.197393998503685,
0.8131999373435974,
0.13534055650234222,
-0.9633620381355286,
-0.055269669741392136,
-0.13492070138454437,
0.04640234261751175,
-0.0013734751846641302,
1.212674856185913,
-0.7279367446899414,
1.1106606721878052,
0.6179105639457703,
0.45436450839042664,
0.5988552570343018,
-0.1286773830652237,
0.3929247558116913,
-0.22249482572078705,
0.4721812605857849,
0.04362530633807182,
0.5746873617172241,
0.22101882100105286,
0.050305888056755066,
0.47323036193847656,
0.5144190788269043,
-0.31959423422813416,
-0.5474416613578796,
0.1513725221157074,
-1.1333309412002563,
-0.34495866298675537,
0.7068964242935181,
-0.06508857011795044,
-0.09969751536846161,
-0.09443532675504684,
-0.8038877248764038,
-0.24320028722286224,
-0.35425442457199097,
0.7512447834014893,
0.7953764200210571,
-0.4686887264251709,
-0.600239098072052,
-0.8673608899116516,
0.598103940486908,
0.17000612616539001,
-1.1156476736068726,
-0.08216887712478638,
0.7034946084022522,
-0.08129522204399109,
0.3504948019981384,
1.1021651029586792,
0.19571726024150848,
0.5396289229393005,
0.23004746437072754,
0.364604115486145,
-0.03997747600078583,
-0.8033650517463684,
0.32951369881629944,
0.13951705396175385,
-0.13709977269172668,
-0.00036226504016667604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09393v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09393v1
|
Improving Autoregressive Training with Dynamic Oracles
| 2024-06-13T17:59:09 | 2024-06-13T17:59:09 |
Jianing Yang, Harshine Visvanathan, Yilin Wang, Xinyi Hu, Matthew Gormley
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Many tasks within NLP can be framed as sequential decision problems, ranging
from sequence tagging to text generation. However, for many tasks, the standard
training methods, including maximum likelihood (teacher forcing) and scheduled
sampling, suffer from exposure bias and a mismatch between metrics employed
during training and inference. DAgger provides a solution to mitigate these
problems, yet it requires a metric-specific dynamic oracle algorithm, which
does not exist for many common metrics like span-based F1, ROUGE, and BLEU. In
this paper, we develop these novel dynamic oracles and show they maintain
DAgger's no-regret guarantee for decomposable metrics like span-based F1. We
evaluate the algorithm's performance on named entity recognition (NER), text
summarization, and machine translation (MT). While DAgger with dynamic oracle
yields less favorable results in our MT experiments, it outperforms the
baseline techniques in NER and text summarization.
|
[
-0.09619086980819702,
-0.48330917954444885,
0.31578847765922546,
0.41385418176651,
-0.10052689164876938,
0.4988044202327728,
-0.005702322348952293,
-0.5128220319747925,
0.4871236979961395,
0.399413526058197,
-0.6888328194618225,
-0.49677568674087524,
-0.6409531831741333,
0.3606015741825104,
-0.5387552976608276,
0.9784033894538879,
-0.1883009374141693,
-0.20323602855205536,
0.3142143189907074,
-0.36393967270851135,
-0.5385288596153259,
-0.2643975019454956,
-0.8566376566886902,
-0.0632316917181015,
0.3933502733707428,
0.15191297233104706,
0.5889133214950562,
0.9925997853279114,
0.6310502290725708,
0.2818535566329956,
0.02244926430284977,
0.4874028265476227,
0.005694095976650715,
0.5129548907279968,
-0.017105214297771454,
-0.5238231420516968,
-0.526710033416748,
-0.20110520720481873,
0.9205763936042786,
0.4773201048374176,
-0.5029339790344238,
0.08001696318387985,
-0.22485856711864471,
0.8062074780464172,
-1.0795764923095703,
0.18234628438949585,
-0.7836884260177612,
0.5249717831611633,
-0.21858474612236023,
0.023132355883717537,
-0.6653282642364502,
-0.460380494594574,
0.13387620449066162,
-0.8483754396438599,
0.09419719874858856,
-0.1591602861881256,
0.891025185585022,
0.8833969235420227,
-0.5759846568107605,
-0.3788032531738281,
-0.8625943660736084,
0.9228898286819458,
-0.6204671859741211,
0.35887888073921204,
0.26854416728019714,
0.46822839975357056,
0.05214409530162811,
-0.745188295841217,
-0.3541339635848999,
-0.09827332198619843,
-0.31917330622673035,
0.17392036318778992,
0.2681240439414978,
0.15233206748962402,
0.4221550524234772,
0.38298559188842773,
-0.38417676091194153,
0.3213765621185303,
0.2651555836200714,
0.14643022418022156,
0.8835469484329224,
0.5784921050071716,
0.09190607070922852,
-0.11364384740591049,
-0.2660916745662689,
-0.43642765283584595,
-0.5055135488510132,
-0.18732304871082306,
0.3455764353275299,
0.10957124829292297,
0.04024935141205788,
0.1732783019542694,
-0.057531896978616714,
0.9008551836013794,
0.2993406355381012,
-0.12843747437000275,
0.4336695075035095,
-0.10355755686759949,
-0.31654757261276245,
-0.06489387899637222,
0.580046534538269,
-0.051951732486486435,
0.04640539735555649,
-0.2303454577922821,
-0.23587819933891296,
-0.14938223361968994,
0.23115117847919464,
-0.3608180582523346,
-0.5158370733261108,
0.22839881479740143,
-0.29207879304885864,
-0.48783281445503235,
-0.15828090906143188,
-0.976462721824646,
-0.5659431219100952,
-0.059939637780189514,
0.23397842049598694,
-0.35119399428367615,
-0.2781096398830414,
-0.005980419460684061,
-0.1775151789188385,
0.20630306005477905,
0.3686944842338562,
-1.269031286239624,
0.4175826609134674,
0.34512317180633545,
0.6964632272720337,
-0.4943438172340393,
-0.2175614833831787,
-0.6887568831443787,
0.2475099265575409,
-0.5473752021789551,
0.4951019883155823,
-0.4148206412792206,
-0.14479640126228333,
0.0891641229391098,
-0.27664873003959656,
-0.2116282880306244,
-0.7462493777275085,
0.31723877787590027,
-0.2965971827507019,
0.1068187728524208,
-0.18118014931678772,
-0.3017028868198395,
-0.019707657396793365,
0.14440399408340454,
-0.6686469912528992,
1.138845682144165,
-0.1623525619506836,
-0.6726014018058777,
0.9522022604942322,
-0.5439749956130981,
-0.4415784180164337,
-0.00963114108890295,
-0.1057942733168602,
-0.6194992661476135,
0.030086670070886612,
0.34102630615234375,
0.35441067814826965,
-0.002566138980910182,
0.35974830389022827,
-0.25174880027770996,
-0.3127726912498474,
-0.05425037816166878,
-0.4083080291748047,
0.6569235324859619,
0.0557471439242363,
-0.5375837087631226,
-0.006462020333856344,
-1.0693554878234863,
-0.08688794076442719,
0.07375624775886536,
-0.3496716618537903,
-0.5747218728065491,
0.355292409658432,
-0.217336967587471,
-0.20434138178825378,
-0.14649511873722076,
-0.2797309458255768,
0.5014747977256775,
-0.8591210842132568,
-0.011290593072772026,
0.7517317533493042,
0.05851901322603226,
0.4884003698825836,
-0.02978275902569294,
0.21944186091423035,
-0.4361916184425354,
0.1552242934703827,
-0.32642000913619995,
0.08453526347875595,
-1.1948256492614746,
-0.4790531396865845,
0.35609787702560425,
0.8405998945236206,
-1.0746517181396484,
0.4323327839374542,
0.01138735469430685,
-0.5752087831497192,
-0.2912825345993042,
-0.17462663352489471,
0.4590444266796112,
0.28067073225975037,
0.49465370178222656,
-0.42444950342178345,
-0.6988525390625,
-0.7434693574905396,
-0.6197713017463684,
-0.20740100741386414,
0.03453633561730385,
0.22247235476970673,
0.36904260516166687,
0.07396036386489868,
0.8233546614646912,
-0.7009068727493286,
-0.5641077756881714,
0.06080971658229828,
0.6391848921775818,
0.33347058296203613,
0.3631366789340973,
0.7022936940193176,
-0.8133853673934937,
-0.8459043502807617,
-0.47095751762390137,
-0.900680422782898,
-0.1264372617006302,
-0.5645025372505188,
0.17251038551330566,
0.49906492233276367,
0.26585549116134644,
-0.4511314332485199,
0.3231501281261444,
0.2773236036300659,
-0.07053098827600479,
0.5094347596168518,
-0.26066792011260986,
-0.016160668805241585,
-1.0601723194122314,
-0.020735852420330048,
-0.13829627633094788,
-0.21179232001304626,
-0.41150498390197754,
0.055855534970760345,
-0.023557253181934357,
0.13536913692951202,
-0.39480429887771606,
0.7903531193733215,
-0.8364754915237427,
-0.09841153025627136,
-0.23545244336128235,
-0.2169502079486847,
-0.42451855540275574,
0.3180665671825409,
0.4067353308200836,
0.6004470586776733,
0.44298815727233887,
-0.7399714589118958,
0.515351414680481,
0.3143517076969147,
-0.30140334367752075,
0.3656069338321686,
-0.4159392714500427,
-0.022966375574469566,
0.08059938251972198,
0.30067914724349976,
-0.6336791515350342,
-0.2093663513660431,
0.12228032201528549,
-0.38572463393211365,
0.5600905418395996,
0.025106191635131836,
-0.44357889890670776,
-0.3741145730018616,
-0.3667854368686676,
0.14486899971961975,
0.6450424790382385,
-0.6327029466629028,
0.718393087387085,
0.4035623371601105,
0.10218794643878937,
-1.48067045211792,
-0.8123549222946167,
0.2268463671207428,
-0.19178947806358337,
-0.12276877462863922,
0.4715437889099121,
0.24777263402938843,
-0.16250300407409668,
0.027033314108848572,
-0.22537602484226227,
-0.16959553956985474,
0.14996014535427094,
0.09246769547462463,
0.01981586031615734,
0.11487829685211182,
0.22280217707157135,
0.24313560128211975,
-0.34362027049064636,
-0.01703331246972084,
-0.2491033375263214,
0.3040483891963959,
0.16451303660869598,
-0.3126422166824341,
-0.3773900270462036,
0.1017189472913742,
0.4114920198917389,
-0.2687581479549408,
0.9168131947517395,
0.5518977046012878,
-0.2534683346748352,
-0.7376543283462524,
-0.5352754592895508,
-0.30257150530815125,
-0.4897539019584656,
0.4018529951572418,
-0.1647740602493286,
-0.4680469334125519,
0.48290202021598816,
-0.034843459725379944,
0.4519152343273163,
0.36515218019485474,
0.5498947501182556,
-0.1076502650976181,
0.7358444333076477,
0.572921633720398,
0.10680726170539856,
0.473707914352417,
-0.4155229926109314,
0.09919897466897964,
-0.6422547101974487,
-0.041675299406051636,
-0.1542443186044693,
-0.34059691429138184,
-0.5110213756561279,
-0.06457236409187317,
0.31248560547828674,
-0.3789617419242859,
-0.20618154108524323,
0.3081792891025543,
-0.5933310985565186,
0.4668315649032593,
0.424938440322876,
-0.3100265860557556,
0.23168165981769562,
-0.21126583218574524,
-0.015918269753456116,
-0.27272722125053406,
-0.6244312524795532,
-0.08925497531890869,
0.9871389269828796,
0.14967378973960876,
0.8344361186027527,
0.11573205143213272,
0.8743895888328552,
0.4887737035751343,
0.24584272503852844,
-0.45782122015953064,
0.7166576981544495,
-0.6063306331634521,
-0.608712375164032,
-0.4026254713535309,
-0.46045827865600586,
-0.8069558143615723,
0.33576658368110657,
-0.614151656627655,
-0.5947009921073914,
0.3762388527393341,
0.5732741355895996,
-0.3651849627494812,
0.46861422061920166,
-0.36407747864723206,
0.4779821038246155,
-0.13665683567523956,
-0.3751949369907379,
0.06672373414039612,
-0.6554937362670898,
0.4239005446434021,
-0.2803345322608948,
-0.16931268572807312,
-0.0833369642496109,
-0.23143655061721802,
0.6818695068359375,
-0.43087509274482727,
0.829842746257782,
-0.4449279010295868,
0.1742435246706009,
0.061703264713287354,
0.18198826909065247,
0.7774394154548645,
0.18891359865665436,
0.0658571794629097,
-0.2867830991744995,
-0.18636207282543182,
-0.13292400538921356,
-0.8964813947677612,
0.38548144698143005,
-0.47573354840278625,
-0.5285617113113403,
-0.9323148727416992,
-0.4842863380908966,
-0.28264549374580383,
0.0489923432469368,
0.20881913602352142,
0.09395265579223633,
-0.09944707155227661,
0.14921383559703827,
0.8465599417686462,
-0.25593796372413635,
0.6902414560317993,
0.6845501065254211,
-0.0288400799036026,
-0.5124815702438354,
0.6223065853118896,
0.37065351009368896,
0.16052000224590302,
0.49786391854286194,
-0.19183480739593506,
-0.19574858248233795,
-0.6753262877464294,
-0.5817806124687195,
0.3323450982570648,
-0.49053213000297546,
-0.27401062846183777,
-0.7032716274261475,
-0.21419472992420197,
-0.12171537429094315,
-0.2906469404697418,
-0.7176858186721802,
-0.5698159337043762,
-0.006834457162767649,
-0.08741872757673264,
0.16249041259288788,
0.430294394493103,
-0.12734754383563995,
0.2395687699317932,
-0.8181371688842773,
0.049186959862709045,
0.29352885484695435,
0.07562898099422455,
0.10723703354597092,
-0.30611807107925415,
-0.22159288823604584,
-0.3386249542236328,
-0.0740075409412384,
-1.0204657316207886,
0.6650455594062805,
0.33494696021080017,
0.5235182642936707,
0.1061648353934288,
0.45220163464546204,
0.5041599869728088,
-0.48580920696258545,
0.7640501260757446,
-0.03465241193771362,
-0.9342201948165894,
0.5580852627754211,
-0.36821261048316956,
0.2103659063577652,
0.6324177384376526,
0.48371726274490356,
-0.49955540895462036,
-0.5827348232269287,
-0.451497346162796,
-1.150455355644226,
0.71305912733078,
0.2218208909034729,
0.13468223810195923,
0.18856441974639893,
0.658535361289978,
0.089964359998703,
0.21705825626850128,
-0.7942081689834595,
-0.37297162413597107,
0.1647477000951767,
-0.3675041198730469,
0.08197607845067978,
-0.1963961124420166,
0.014518426731228828,
-0.005606074817478657,
0.7657091617584229,
-0.0394374318420887,
0.20987534523010254,
0.0764768049120903,
-0.01380707137286663,
0.23674586415290833,
-0.10225365310907364,
0.23188433051109314,
0.41543346643447876,
-0.244227334856987,
-0.06535737216472626,
0.7210999727249146,
-0.6529713273048401,
0.46507906913757324,
0.0577988363802433,
-0.4469510316848755,
0.21459659934043884,
0.5473231077194214,
0.8892890214920044,
-0.0968327522277832,
-0.4627370238304138,
0.30694714188575745,
-0.13884563744068146,
-0.2295059710741043,
-0.7454187870025635,
0.3766261339187622,
-0.41085803508758545,
0.14281508326530457,
0.4299854338169098,
0.1502297818660736,
0.22125642001628876,
-0.26731428503990173,
0.26343730092048645,
0.30958735942840576,
-0.32811978459358215,
-0.1094106063246727,
0.6887147426605225,
0.3072534501552582,
-0.2813107371330261,
0.7265437245368958,
-0.2596619427204132,
-0.239495187997818,
0.6442291140556335,
0.3385460674762726,
1.062766194343567,
-0.5089254975318909,
0.2333657592535019,
0.42838361859321594,
0.3477863371372223,
-0.1797073781490326,
0.03844725713133812,
-0.20140741765499115,
-0.498454213142395,
-0.643328845500946,
-0.5565595626831055,
-0.5279172658920288,
-0.1390470564365387,
-0.6480348110198975,
0.45711401104927063,
-0.42870208621025085,
-0.14133702218532562,
-0.019663995131850243,
-0.032123271375894547,
-0.11237233877182007,
0.36011379957199097,
-0.2719570994377136,
0.9513198137283325,
-0.945737361907959,
0.8881835341453552,
0.5617522597312927,
-0.3470127284526825,
-0.6870023012161255,
0.15384681522846222,
0.22671569883823395,
-0.5555576682090759,
0.9120834469795227,
-0.2188177853822708,
-0.19058747589588165,
-0.18381454050540924,
-0.06946580111980438,
-1.0794614553451538,
1.051169991493225,
0.40073198080062866,
-0.2888363301753998,
-0.42713484168052673,
-0.15303775668144226,
0.5633242130279541,
-0.07464481145143509,
0.1846618503332138,
0.3107368052005768,
0.4105329215526581,
0.136497363448143,
-0.9601017236709595,
-0.26102688908576965,
-0.1754714995622635,
-0.16835448145866394,
0.6909081935882568,
-0.7246829271316528,
0.808856725692749,
-0.047916390001773834,
-0.284914493560791,
-0.006141430698335171,
0.6514015197753906,
0.0989057794213295,
0.2690756618976593,
0.5557146668434143,
0.699677586555481,
0.7903652787208557,
-0.307905912399292,
0.8995684385299683,
0.012174819596111774,
0.3502092957496643,
1.3429676294326782,
-0.456423819065094,
0.7702944874763489,
0.14073984324932098,
-0.10886593908071518,
0.5670170187950134,
0.5932646989822388,
-0.2086636871099472,
0.680084228515625,
0.12169881910085678,
-0.23953349888324738,
0.020473811775445938,
0.261231005191803,
-0.2097833752632141,
0.5274459719657898,
0.34073877334594727,
-0.45886850357055664,
-0.030145825818181038,
0.10758963972330093,
0.22972217202186584,
0.1789405643939972,
-0.00470842095091939,
1.0428210496902466,
-0.024253878742456436,
-0.7195528149604797,
0.6901478171348572,
-0.04118754714727402,
0.7326489686965942,
-0.795828104019165,
-0.0766601637005806,
-0.30832114815711975,
0.4822400212287903,
-0.21255044639110565,
-0.5484616756439209,
0.8948853015899658,
-0.03956130892038345,
-0.017284611240029335,
-0.3286166787147522,
0.6198257803916931,
-0.20854853093624115,
-0.18365944921970367,
0.2414950132369995,
0.2176080346107483,
-0.08690895140171051,
0.3451248109340668,
-0.6339304447174072,
-0.14963556826114655,
-0.1212264895439148,
-0.30279701948165894,
0.24779833853244781,
0.23420856893062592,
0.16735243797302246,
0.8978154063224792,
0.35281360149383545,
0.29987841844558716,
0.12071891129016876,
-0.4085184633731842,
0.4581429958343506,
-0.5966331362724304,
-0.5262173414230347,
-0.9422839879989624,
0.43273717164993286,
-0.46019047498703003,
-0.3534766435623169,
0.8213329911231995,
0.5062228441238403,
0.5677216649055481,
-0.0425218865275383,
0.5126510262489319,
0.11510081589221954,
0.7017413377761841,
-0.7167345881462097,
0.8005290031433105,
-0.7098649740219116,
0.2720317244529724,
-0.3040555417537689,
-1.1228541135787964,
-0.734586775302887,
0.6714782118797302,
-0.20130234956741333,
-0.04548991471529007,
0.7215531468391418,
0.3203584551811218,
0.24003152549266815,
-0.18226927518844604,
0.01954135112464428,
0.12315633893013,
0.3740791082382202,
0.6598008871078491,
0.6349979639053345,
-0.3664509654045105,
0.3226405084133148,
-0.04941742867231369,
-0.22454705834388733,
-0.11300693452358246,
-1.0821869373321533,
-0.6218844056129456,
-0.7760010361671448,
-0.3785061836242676,
-0.26260805130004883,
0.6109439730644226,
0.7626969218254089,
0.8732937574386597,
-0.4908575117588043,
-0.2408088594675064,
-0.118349090218544,
-0.06600233912467957,
-0.32932206988334656,
-0.15942414104938507,
0.6061646938323975,
-0.5799094438552856,
-0.862037181854248,
0.1956825852394104,
0.4146948754787445,
0.04301626235246658,
-0.1820620894432068,
0.048657141625881195,
-0.24175727367401123,
0.2083255648612976,
0.3742593228816986,
0.44372373819351196,
-0.4691704213619232,
-0.18984459340572357,
0.0905565470457077,
0.08975175768136978,
-0.08310245722532272,
0.5904879570007324,
-0.8848130106925964,
0.470367968082428,
0.5424099564552307,
0.8582381010055542,
0.7598071694374084,
-0.25434014201164246,
0.6404955387115479,
-0.7775469422340393,
0.24851928651332855,
0.5393326878547668,
0.09644538909196854,
0.21611063182353973,
-0.29024627804756165,
0.8222278952598572,
0.30018386244773865,
-0.6653241515159607,
-1.134731650352478,
0.30793890357017517,
-0.5833649039268494,
-0.1638491451740265,
0.83042973279953,
-0.20360243320465088,
-0.07101157307624817,
-0.0695110410451889,
0.10805124789476395,
0.13029012084007263,
-0.17459073662757874,
0.9314097762107849,
0.7394911646842957,
-0.35541239380836487,
-0.23324742913246155,
-0.26633313298225403,
0.9956483840942383,
0.7105637192726135,
-0.7627061605453491,
0.25741156935691833,
0.3098975419998169,
-0.11559811234474182,
0.21983450651168823,
0.7493636012077332,
0.08574025332927704,
0.2516796886920929,
0.16742713749408722,
-0.0002781102084554732,
-0.06974475830793381,
-0.5084538459777832,
-0.20847924053668976,
0.06220308318734169,
0.03282875195145607,
-0.17955335974693298
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09345v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09345v1
|
DiscreteSLU: A Large Language Model with Self-Supervised Discrete Speech Units for Spoken Language Understanding
| 2024-06-13T17:28:13 | 2024-06-13T17:28:13 |
Suwon Shon, Kwangyoun Kim, Yi-Te Hsu, Prashant Sridhar, Shinji Watanabe, Karen Livescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The integration of pre-trained text-based large language models (LLM) with
speech input has enabled instruction-following capabilities for diverse speech
tasks. This integration requires the use of a speech encoder, a speech adapter,
and an LLM, trained on diverse tasks. We propose the use of discrete speech
units (DSU), rather than continuous-valued speech encoder outputs, that are
converted to the LLM token embedding space using the speech adapter. We
generate DSU using a self-supervised speech encoder followed by k-means
clustering. The proposed model shows robust performance on speech inputs from
seen/unseen domains and instruction-following capability in spoken question
answering. We also explore various types of DSU extracted from different layers
of the self-supervised speech encoder, as well as Mel frequency Cepstral
Coefficients (MFCC). Our findings suggest that the ASR task and datasets are
not crucial in instruction-tuning for spoken question answering tasks.
|
[
-0.24252556264400482,
-0.7225339412689209,
0.6436087489128113,
0.14144054055213928,
-0.37344032526016235,
0.07261822372674942,
-0.19123677909374237,
-0.14706219732761383,
0.09958695620298386,
0.604346513748169,
-0.513644814491272,
-0.5312624573707581,
-0.4768497347831726,
0.11055730283260345,
-0.4436320662498474,
0.7929548025131226,
0.36422106623649597,
0.05620258301496506,
-0.6070387959480286,
-0.010343197733163834,
-0.4022018313407898,
-0.6271297931671143,
-0.6452863216400146,
-0.2837199568748474,
0.5384932160377502,
0.3653801381587982,
0.3956252634525299,
0.48826533555984497,
0.13188424706459045,
0.4102271795272827,
0.04396406561136246,
-0.13081395626068115,
-0.38313841819763184,
-0.04804924130439758,
-0.07935566455125809,
-0.4343876838684082,
-0.5912197828292847,
-0.19531604647636414,
1.0272010564804077,
0.6149985194206238,
-0.446942538022995,
0.02034047618508339,
0.012439848855137825,
0.3442245423793793,
-0.3047332167625427,
0.3012750744819641,
-0.5131949186325073,
-0.23202639818191528,
-0.15212063491344452,
0.2235286980867386,
-0.5622686147689819,
-0.348262220621109,
0.03577855974435806,
-0.5965665578842163,
-0.13310346007347107,
-0.3968918025493622,
0.18947114050388336,
0.6876318454742432,
-0.3920302093029022,
-0.4483093321323395,
-0.8549256324768066,
0.7054937481880188,
-0.980349063873291,
0.5557804107666016,
0.4834589660167694,
0.346645712852478,
0.16037847101688385,
-0.8171517252922058,
-0.6984393000602722,
-0.020256230607628822,
-0.22802743315696716,
0.21101830899715424,
-0.13913002610206604,
0.2522222399711609,
0.12227276712656021,
0.1690729856491089,
-0.6745975017547607,
0.3399573266506195,
-0.4161210358142853,
0.2769761085510254,
0.7358556985855103,
0.04524281993508339,
0.3360854387283325,
0.034939758479595184,
-0.0560494139790535,
0.25706419348716736,
-0.38505396246910095,
0.07100031524896622,
0.1603042036294937,
0.2968381643295288,
-0.35681667923927307,
0.2785108983516693,
-0.12947684526443481,
1.0467824935913086,
-0.008748508058488369,
-0.29752612113952637,
0.10935574024915695,
-0.1477692723274231,
-0.3054015636444092,
0.2808009684085846,
0.4907684326171875,
-0.37768933176994324,
0.25481295585632324,
-0.2782721519470215,
-0.032932158559560776,
0.09150541573762894,
0.3257155418395996,
-0.7409987449645996,
-0.3079061806201935,
0.12445913255214691,
-0.12018653005361557,
-0.13649742305278778,
-0.09581105411052704,
-0.37532272934913635,
0.09182480722665787,
-0.5612361431121826,
0.30148690938949585,
-0.5064716935157776,
-0.19600389897823334,
-0.03614703565835953,
0.1587166041135788,
0.34313148260116577,
0.35718047618865967,
-1.0844759941101074,
0.7093662023544312,
0.5979280471801758,
0.3750142753124237,
-0.3930387794971466,
-0.3183063566684723,
-0.5185365080833435,
0.24215276539325714,
-0.2029726356267929,
0.44770482182502747,
-0.8833602666854858,
-0.6038907170295715,
-0.3212658762931824,
-0.015675388276576996,
-0.4962558448314667,
-0.2518582344055176,
0.34326714277267456,
-0.5687235593795776,
0.06809386610984802,
-0.08743894100189209,
-0.7005718350410461,
-0.2178884744644165,
-0.14540138840675354,
-0.4082905650138855,
0.9140121340751648,
-0.008571293205022812,
-0.36899274587631226,
-0.19248446822166443,
-0.4816475212574005,
-0.5570101141929626,
0.4747665524482727,
-0.6335150003433228,
-0.13649235665798187,
0.14807376265525818,
0.27934399247169495,
0.3299616873264313,
0.10711535066366196,
0.44464972615242004,
-0.06282379478216171,
-0.4105179011821747,
0.4080224931240082,
-0.561630129814148,
0.5645041465759277,
0.14295043051242828,
-0.12999281287193298,
0.14624565839767456,
-0.913874626159668,
-0.05152425915002823,
-0.07431014627218246,
-0.40200579166412354,
-0.3424350321292877,
0.2868371307849884,
-0.18132182955741882,
0.13876686990261078,
0.33740127086639404,
-0.6179233193397522,
-0.07753857225179672,
-0.08404254168272018,
0.5990774631500244,
0.7391571998596191,
-0.22376921772956848,
0.4582432806491852,
0.04722469672560692,
0.6094456315040588,
0.02451726794242859,
-0.11778847128152847,
-0.19141390919685364,
-0.38483452796936035,
-0.735783040523529,
-0.23676489293575287,
0.3319641649723053,
0.5440261363983154,
-0.7312505841255188,
0.3930518627166748,
-0.2523534595966339,
-0.3700477182865143,
-0.6582170724868774,
-0.07337213307619095,
0.2826286852359772,
0.607464075088501,
0.2272912710905075,
0.08182299137115479,
-0.2568809390068054,
-0.7135151028633118,
0.13723276555538177,
-0.008107916451990604,
-0.030002817511558533,
0.5475895404815674,
0.24392664432525635,
-0.37051528692245483,
0.9459313750267029,
-0.51682049036026,
0.014745806343853474,
-0.316290020942688,
-0.08871248364448547,
0.19879353046417236,
0.3891046345233917,
0.2706010043621063,
-0.7679935097694397,
-0.4506692588329315,
0.07126901298761368,
-0.7950533628463745,
-0.028022252023220062,
-0.04291978105902672,
0.27259543538093567,
0.06860079616308212,
0.8200562000274658,
-0.4915716052055359,
0.2371429204940796,
0.8322749733924866,
-0.09597689658403397,
0.3806074261665344,
-0.2924248278141022,
0.0008866044227033854,
-0.9549134969711304,
-0.14281073212623596,
-0.13204516470432281,
-0.29554426670074463,
-1.0448241233825684,
0.04159438982605934,
0.10994698107242584,
-0.45139506459236145,
-0.4918089807033539,
0.31951016187667847,
-0.23954938352108002,
-0.33923256397247314,
-0.21393342316150665,
0.6008540987968445,
-0.07183689624071121,
0.46443891525268555,
0.18721826374530792,
0.9383074641227722,
0.6798135042190552,
-0.6951631903648376,
0.34733328223228455,
0.19013917446136475,
-0.2525165379047394,
0.29527047276496887,
-0.7723199129104614,
0.5734471082687378,
-0.35519322752952576,
0.1491534411907196,
-0.9689905643463135,
0.07007648795843124,
-0.08057886362075806,
-0.2405504584312439,
0.4420475959777832,
-0.05395357683300972,
-0.13601195812225342,
-0.26996055245399475,
0.2946394979953766,
0.6496931314468384,
0.4918398857116699,
-0.5028106570243835,
0.8174158334732056,
0.3098307251930237,
-0.45202144980430603,
-0.423302561044693,
-0.8084489703178406,
-0.1723882108926773,
-0.11946670711040497,
-0.4563025236129761,
0.3274145722389221,
-0.256294310092926,
-0.18267394602298737,
0.03617766872048378,
-0.06186079978942871,
-0.08108644932508469,
0.0004588498268276453,
0.2508350908756256,
0.09066997468471527,
-0.47292855381965637,
0.2885901927947998,
0.12743963301181793,
-0.14073649048805237,
0.06309135258197784,
-0.30421534180641174,
0.5766527652740479,
-0.2413979023694992,
-0.5009866952896118,
-0.5829636454582214,
0.42397093772888184,
0.520809531211853,
-0.3778395354747772,
0.48434165120124817,
0.37476539611816406,
-0.3500431478023529,
-0.22021269798278809,
-0.27156972885131836,
-0.09981906414031982,
-0.5389598608016968,
0.45720744132995605,
-0.7250802516937256,
-1.1258292198181152,
0.24586735665798187,
0.16809478402137756,
0.08923961222171783,
0.2355242669582367,
0.4145933985710144,
-0.3639738857746124,
0.777945876121521,
0.4837118685245514,
-0.26829707622528076,
0.3169303834438324,
0.09622079133987427,
0.201290100812912,
-0.7702842950820923,
-0.06350891292095184,
-0.4390081465244293,
-0.16586796939373016,
-0.5067577958106995,
-0.5329612493515015,
0.08848381787538528,
-0.041268233209848404,
-0.00314859626814723,
0.16631203889846802,
-0.27356863021850586,
0.339630126953125,
0.593632698059082,
0.07316400110721588,
0.2980046570301056,
-0.23142337799072266,
0.07394097000360489,
0.0303314421325922,
-0.8749269843101501,
-0.30369752645492554,
0.6421814560890198,
0.3967088460922241,
1.0763732194900513,
0.17392316460609436,
0.8968048095703125,
0.19980455935001373,
-0.09347192198038101,
-0.8517637252807617,
0.6466108560562134,
-0.704026997089386,
-0.11744567006826401,
-0.6585862636566162,
-0.45735540986061096,
-0.8972752094268799,
0.4207695722579956,
0.1645485907793045,
-0.7212144136428833,
0.07296732813119888,
-0.016581298783421516,
-0.44601187109947205,
0.11580435186624527,
-0.6612512469291687,
0.5178561806678772,
-0.34023141860961914,
0.44190192222595215,
-0.4111366271972656,
-0.39694809913635254,
0.29160258173942566,
-0.176963210105896,
0.45596590638160706,
0.03048105351626873,
0.16767607629299164,
0.7687346339225769,
-0.0834708958864212,
1.104979157447815,
-0.12674932181835175,
-0.1404818594455719,
0.25936925411224365,
-0.16086575388908386,
0.24396558105945587,
-0.0022782229352742434,
-0.10402293503284454,
0.13957539200782776,
0.04237743839621544,
-0.316643089056015,
-0.7065885066986084,
0.9690642952919006,
-1.045515775680542,
-0.8356020450592041,
-0.3259895145893097,
-0.7094452381134033,
-0.10817950963973999,
0.043939750641584396,
-0.121693454682827,
0.7764964699745178,
-0.2812086045742035,
0.24202562868595123,
0.9167071580886841,
-0.17212127149105072,
0.5790491104125977,
0.5759837627410889,
-0.0953231006860733,
-0.3658016324043274,
1.0997546911239624,
0.17012673616409302,
0.4894733130931854,
0.47052237391471863,
0.2589018940925598,
-0.348690003156662,
-0.6564075350761414,
-0.5004135370254517,
0.4188987910747528,
-0.6163246631622314,
0.03915167972445488,
-0.6413692831993103,
-0.5796397924423218,
-0.6191328763961792,
-0.0885467678308487,
-0.2334977388381958,
-0.3421410620212555,
-0.7251029014587402,
-0.16895222663879395,
0.2873549163341522,
1.0110281705856323,
0.14935368299484253,
0.7012025117874146,
-0.6866663694381714,
0.5234496593475342,
0.8506477475166321,
0.2352575808763504,
-0.18220126628875732,
-0.6825607419013977,
-0.14866340160369873,
0.05412404239177704,
0.09847632050514221,
-0.7801519632339478,
0.3067430257797241,
0.4425378739833832,
0.8266463875770569,
0.4458073079586029,
0.04784074053168297,
0.6389578580856323,
-0.6757891178131104,
0.668082058429718,
0.03851957246661186,
-1.0215177536010742,
0.7350714802742004,
-0.2625023126602173,
0.6522202491760254,
0.3924267888069153,
0.36033183336257935,
-0.6023191213607788,
-0.31886908411979675,
-0.4994198977947235,
-0.4189065992832184,
0.9708998203277588,
0.03565433621406555,
0.12716226279735565,
-0.12436771392822266,
0.3741850256919861,
-0.06114602088928223,
0.06788739562034607,
-0.6427619457244873,
-0.45738664269447327,
-0.23441468179225922,
-0.43808290362358093,
-0.33261969685554504,
-0.2647911310195923,
0.017457904294133186,
-0.1935858130455017,
0.5734449028968811,
-0.1346093714237213,
0.038670510053634644,
0.11104590445756912,
-0.3068350851535797,
0.11839789152145386,
0.37670278549194336,
0.584582507610321,
0.7354461550712585,
0.0607558898627758,
0.2046266794204712,
0.34893491864204407,
-0.6245876550674438,
-0.018373046070337296,
0.31870123744010925,
-0.23274286091327667,
-0.03199489414691925,
0.039081722497940063,
0.9475653767585754,
0.4199633300304413,
-0.4617937207221985,
0.15528929233551025,
-0.23665399849414825,
-0.18153849244117737,
-0.3503738343715668,
0.19109368324279785,
0.44457799196243286,
0.16112247109413147,
0.216549813747406,
-0.39660370349884033,
0.10316278040409088,
-0.4111274182796478,
0.27305030822753906,
0.3151521384716034,
-0.5548787117004395,
-0.3073109984397888,
0.4816472828388214,
0.3597445487976074,
-0.5511625409126282,
0.7167770862579346,
-0.047213513404130936,
-0.22735856473445892,
0.5920159816741943,
0.933101236820221,
0.5270542502403259,
-0.7710750699043274,
0.3289387822151184,
0.012363546527922153,
0.2635020315647125,
0.2503504753112793,
0.2345530092716217,
-0.2560710310935974,
-0.7356836795806885,
-0.5273274779319763,
-0.7164016962051392,
-0.41344118118286133,
0.1321031004190445,
-0.850340723991394,
0.03159743919968605,
-0.3017120361328125,
0.15219976007938385,
0.044046685099601746,
-0.24736297130584717,
-0.49773386120796204,
0.5208456516265869,
0.5038274526596069,
0.6685628890991211,
-0.7505068778991699,
1.4510271549224854,
0.6045318841934204,
-0.049252741038799286,
-0.6584879755973816,
-0.25690579414367676,
-0.14929187297821045,
-0.8230935335159302,
0.33416834473609924,
-0.06299879401922226,
-0.2551363408565521,
0.4760942757129669,
-0.1914718747138977,
-1.0367461442947388,
1.157701849937439,
0.1653919667005539,
-0.9303517937660217,
-0.07390835881233215,
0.33915212750434875,
0.2578694820404053,
-0.4511353373527527,
0.11420457065105438,
0.8276679515838623,
-0.049055393785238266,
0.2540583312511444,
-0.6679648160934448,
-0.0968349501490593,
0.009334741160273552,
0.005071847699582577,
0.0512881837785244,
-0.47071167826652527,
0.8010869026184082,
-0.05917970836162567,
-0.10415294766426086,
-0.06244245171546936,
0.8390619158744812,
0.43830859661102295,
0.28388556838035583,
0.5378232598304749,
0.6019482612609863,
0.852177083492279,
0.01946919597685337,
0.7488676905632019,
-0.01734105683863163,
0.05184868350625038,
1.4920674562454224,
-0.09171975404024124,
1.06203031539917,
0.28227511048316956,
-0.3747474253177643,
0.6224208474159241,
0.31414827704429626,
0.24228011071681976,
0.5497603416442871,
0.1648813933134079,
-0.5610783696174622,
-0.20593099296092987,
0.21259446442127228,
-0.23710520565509796,
0.5773842334747314,
0.7911155819892883,
-0.14909327030181885,
-0.1265811324119568,
0.11558185517787933,
-0.31039565801620483,
0.12221691012382507,
-0.3667033910751343,
1.0436424016952515,
0.457815557718277,
-0.31385698914527893,
0.501323938369751,
-0.14045502245426178,
0.5975313186645508,
-0.7382131814956665,
0.07685776799917221,
-0.1611233651638031,
-0.0917656198143959,
-0.2053755223751068,
-0.8007644414901733,
0.3522738516330719,
-0.10499059408903122,
-0.047932401299476624,
-0.14411777257919312,
0.7143221497535706,
-0.621261477470398,
-0.7232023477554321,
0.1849311739206314,
0.41619130969047546,
0.44382938742637634,
-0.01370422076433897,
-0.5395044088363647,
0.0774879902601242,
0.059350285679101944,
0.1204991489648819,
0.42075982689857483,
0.44736260175704956,
0.1348123550415039,
0.5541636943817139,
0.5023031830787659,
-0.18320615589618683,
0.18266284465789795,
0.6001174449920654,
0.8622019290924072,
-0.6712655425071716,
-0.6121140122413635,
-0.7362475991249084,
0.4131430387496948,
0.10720586031675339,
-0.03220221400260925,
0.6845698952674866,
0.38695478439331055,
0.6385647058486938,
-0.010525467805564404,
0.9573057293891907,
0.1273684799671173,
0.3519759476184845,
-0.3992156684398651,
0.6897028088569641,
-0.16349397599697113,
0.07320855557918549,
-0.060186490416526794,
-0.6053388714790344,
0.004847331903874874,
0.5921739935874939,
-0.38698500394821167,
-0.14783696830272675,
0.45407676696777344,
0.507968008518219,
-0.06157452240586281,
0.23807130753993988,
0.7276353240013123,
0.27960848808288574,
0.19162550568580627,
0.3029765784740448,
0.6162381172180176,
-0.27724191546440125,
0.42714056372642517,
-0.10490914434194565,
-0.33867722749710083,
0.150579035282135,
-0.411893367767334,
-0.9859244227409363,
-0.6004241108894348,
-0.43036407232284546,
0.09175007045269012,
-0.023631414398550987,
0.5736573338508606,
0.737321138381958,
-0.8997205495834351,
-0.4444561004638672,
-0.1531735360622406,
0.14717763662338257,
-0.006725220941007137,
-0.19648998975753784,
0.23817548155784607,
-0.4583119750022888,
-0.7409291863441467,
0.8118860125541687,
0.24310477077960968,
0.08192425221204758,
-0.3180530071258545,
-0.17823559045791626,
-0.14791381359100342,
0.17911139130592346,
0.868955671787262,
0.20856690406799316,
-0.9481790065765381,
-0.1612739861011505,
0.1621621549129486,
-0.0017845970578491688,
-0.02745380811393261,
0.5450509786605835,
-0.8639875054359436,
0.3654710650444031,
0.20197032392024994,
0.8590666651725769,
0.982243537902832,
0.1777483969926834,
0.5253578424453735,
-0.8453278541564941,
-0.02288387343287468,
0.329932302236557,
0.2627623677253723,
0.2339494228363037,
-0.3988119661808014,
0.03344068303704262,
-0.10119449347257614,
-0.6441501975059509,
-0.4387724697589874,
0.31645920872688293,
-1.1078696250915527,
-0.33585646748542786,
1.0828680992126465,
-0.22766244411468506,
-0.15025679767131805,
-0.14841139316558838,
-0.017327671870589256,
0.20323128998279572,
-0.4275275766849518,
0.38357025384902954,
0.42544838786125183,
-0.32400593161582947,
-0.6881401538848877,
-0.5108787417411804,
0.26099681854248047,
0.23958146572113037,
-1.060956358909607,
-0.04507053270936012,
0.2433127909898758,
0.29127833247184753,
-0.03432665765285492,
0.8180171847343445,
-0.04830269515514374,
-0.003195087192580104,
0.05113263055682182,
-0.13549162447452545,
0.17597734928131104,
-0.2957286238670349,
-0.7015239596366882,
-0.1946287751197815,
0.05911818891763687,
-0.5032126903533936
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09334v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09334v2
|
ProxyLM: Predicting Language Model Performance on Multilingual Tasks via Proxy Models
| 2024-06-13T17:15:33 | 2024-06-14T14:52:05 |
David Anugraha, Genta Indra Winata, Chenyue Li, Patrick Amadeus Irawan, En-Shiun Annie Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Performance prediction is a method to estimate the performance of Language
Models (LMs) on various Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks, mitigating
computational costs associated with model capacity and data for fine-tuning.
Our paper introduces ProxyLM, a scalable framework for predicting LM
performance using proxy models in multilingual tasks. These proxy models act as
surrogates, approximating the performance of the LM of interest. By leveraging
proxy models, ProxyLM significantly reduces computational overhead on task
evaluations, achieving up to a 37.08x speedup compared to traditional methods,
even with our smallest proxy models. Additionally, our methodology showcases
adaptability to previously unseen languages in pre-trained LMs, outperforming
the state-of-the-art performance by 1.89x as measured by root-mean-square error
(RMSE). This framework streamlines model selection, enabling efficient
deployment and iterative LM enhancements without extensive computational
resources.
|
[
-0.5015801191329956,
-0.5943348407745361,
0.28595852851867676,
0.397433340549469,
-0.18287137150764465,
0.36140939593315125,
0.1762116700410843,
-0.5058013796806335,
0.29681771993637085,
0.7461559772491455,
-0.6221321821212769,
-0.2758151590824127,
-0.5588555932044983,
-0.04604024440050125,
-0.26401883363723755,
0.6457754969596863,
0.2790931463241577,
0.39417338371276855,
-0.49567046761512756,
0.09575583040714264,
-0.3856005072593689,
-0.686572253704071,
-0.8097326755523682,
-0.3090290129184723,
0.5508032441139221,
0.02285941131412983,
0.9091389775276184,
0.7263221144676208,
0.21280400454998016,
0.2686256766319275,
-0.10100674629211426,
0.37533095479011536,
-0.49884533882141113,
0.18880827724933624,
-0.2518084645271301,
-0.37179410457611084,
-0.6017974019050598,
-0.19123575091362,
0.747332751750946,
0.8639637231826782,
-0.08240137249231339,
0.3644399046897888,
0.010851113125681877,
0.6173746585845947,
-0.7107716798782349,
0.20383045077323914,
-0.8528956174850464,
-0.08142095804214478,
-0.508965790271759,
0.0860447883605957,
-0.4530582129955292,
-0.04727243632078171,
-0.02926490642130375,
-0.28913000226020813,
0.3940909802913666,
0.2896254062652588,
0.32962948083877563,
0.10681429505348206,
-0.3797933757305145,
0.1323067545890808,
-0.44608405232429504,
0.6611531376838684,
-0.9091262221336365,
0.7178380489349365,
0.4725818336009979,
0.5278649926185608,
-0.504486620426178,
-0.9169403314590454,
-0.3906509578227997,
-0.34464818239212036,
-0.033415429294109344,
0.08827847987413406,
0.07785702496767044,
0.045407313853502274,
0.2352941781282425,
0.18453679978847504,
-0.7720061540603638,
0.071170374751091,
-0.3911961019039154,
-0.22285662591457367,
0.6104512810707092,
0.4088791012763977,
0.20067156851291656,
0.20944729447364807,
-0.22792240977287292,
0.18842878937721252,
-0.5936195254325867,
0.15731821954250336,
0.2963371276855469,
0.8708725571632385,
0.012870770879089832,
0.2896841764450073,
-0.3387717604637146,
0.7032978534698486,
-0.40224480628967285,
-0.2531360983848572,
0.23828761279582977,
0.007059706375002861,
-0.05948645994067192,
-0.1027165874838829,
0.6143009066581726,
0.15159280598163605,
0.1747262328863144,
-0.22169026732444763,
-0.3377855122089386,
0.1348128467798233,
0.35943591594696045,
-0.6599381566047668,
-0.027088794857263565,
0.035195041447877884,
-0.3992421329021454,
0.0961989089846611,
-0.17869730293750763,
-1.0032837390899658,
-0.4424394369125366,
-0.1141064241528511,
0.17831353843212128,
-0.031145678833127022,
-0.3987293243408203,
0.1319500058889389,
0.049836721271276474,
-0.4769679307937622,
0.12004125863313675,
-0.4624039828777313,
0.6765655279159546,
0.646081268787384,
1.0036019086837769,
-0.4232672452926636,
-0.7137337327003479,
-1.1522303819656372,
0.13888023793697357,
-0.44756564497947693,
0.5947884321212769,
-0.5463181138038635,
-0.4314369261264801,
0.4442555904388428,
0.11763187497854233,
-0.3193463981151581,
-0.3305653929710388,
0.781312882900238,
-0.6513336896896362,
-0.1919972449541092,
0.004729411099106073,
-0.6761040687561035,
-0.013664848171174526,
-0.05890895798802376,
-1.1804362535476685,
1.244899868965149,
-0.0058552478440105915,
-0.6521670818328857,
0.00720259128138423,
-0.7007746696472168,
-0.6238226294517517,
0.17154866456985474,
0.6386758089065552,
-0.19899410009384155,
0.32889190316200256,
0.18898747861385345,
0.5964000225067139,
-0.41643503308296204,
0.36555254459381104,
-0.5397135615348816,
-0.39279234409332275,
0.015992455184459686,
-0.38248130679130554,
0.4843728542327881,
0.340694785118103,
-0.05863945931196213,
0.14750494062900543,
-0.7652081847190857,
0.11972560733556747,
-0.07413164526224136,
-0.12349235266447067,
-0.3115457594394684,
0.29738831520080566,
0.09414825588464737,
0.5095928907394409,
0.21802465617656708,
-0.4521169066429138,
-0.04127705097198486,
-0.6449811458587646,
0.08146067708730698,
0.5945332646369934,
-0.52054363489151,
0.29164260625839233,
-0.08824757486581802,
0.8654529452323914,
-0.2808675169944763,
0.35313642024993896,
-0.15692278742790222,
-0.6427032351493835,
-0.655301034450531,
-0.22651682794094086,
0.3084884583950043,
0.39256078004837036,
-0.9731956720352173,
-0.518311083316803,
-0.40766441822052,
-0.7928681969642639,
-0.6815015077590942,
0.34940269589424133,
0.7907452583312988,
0.4508204162120819,
0.5462987422943115,
0.03458567336201668,
-0.703765332698822,
-0.896599531173706,
-0.6316294074058533,
-0.34149593114852905,
0.1357891708612442,
-0.055348951369524,
0.3925081789493561,
-0.21875323355197906,
0.6488243341445923,
-0.44313037395477295,
-0.06455425918102264,
-0.356192946434021,
0.187786266207695,
0.32369399070739746,
0.34650713205337524,
0.43136271834373474,
-0.8099724054336548,
-0.7790966629981995,
-0.0827760174870491,
-0.24354945123195648,
-0.44783493876457214,
0.29495757818222046,
-0.0055107008665800095,
0.5195543766021729,
0.5663622617721558,
-0.4785628914833069,
0.18723125755786896,
1.058173656463623,
-0.43943190574645996,
0.7805042266845703,
-0.21875134110450745,
-0.283947616815567,
-0.8573482632637024,
-0.0891500934958458,
0.0017913513584062457,
-0.41500991582870483,
-1.0752742290496826,
0.2087956666946411,
0.3634543716907501,
0.02967897802591324,
-0.759056568145752,
1.0772145986557007,
-0.42982590198516846,
-0.18532292544841766,
-0.25679370760917664,
-0.07672227174043655,
0.0283066313713789,
0.36872056126594543,
0.2411211133003235,
0.9093749523162842,
0.6573312282562256,
-0.7465519905090332,
0.12249592691659927,
-0.29941660165786743,
-0.26478540897369385,
0.12373903393745422,
-0.5631520748138428,
0.07551928609609604,
0.050132494419813156,
0.019347932189702988,
-1.0046805143356323,
0.008061693049967289,
-0.32011184096336365,
-0.3195330798625946,
0.12611693143844604,
-0.19093793630599976,
-0.4151149392127991,
-0.5857773423194885,
-0.13017697632312775,
0.24290168285369873,
0.2954385578632355,
-0.6002306938171387,
0.8111520409584045,
0.5413277745246887,
-0.13850536942481995,
-0.675266683101654,
-0.385801762342453,
0.014491857960820198,
-0.1000305637717247,
-0.4952835142612457,
0.4468197524547577,
-0.0616425946354866,
-0.10115550458431244,
-0.16441667079925537,
0.034498728811740875,
-0.18879204988479614,
0.2225015014410019,
0.3475947976112366,
0.2860089838504791,
-0.10742372274398804,
0.20266495645046234,
0.003846700070425868,
-0.09150373190641403,
0.06896951049566269,
-0.12429510056972504,
0.717952311038971,
-0.2005932629108429,
-0.47180747985839844,
0.07620616257190704,
0.2238197922706604,
0.7333489656448364,
-0.1393304169178009,
0.9321877360343933,
0.6625409126281738,
-0.372260719537735,
-0.2361854761838913,
-0.7591992020606995,
0.15757152438163757,
-0.40235191583633423,
0.5001099109649658,
-0.6505149602890015,
-0.6706496477127075,
0.8158969879150391,
-0.1696624904870987,
-0.1014249250292778,
0.42324480414390564,
0.3643292188644409,
0.25485995411872864,
1.587609052658081,
0.5982739329338074,
-0.22409643232822418,
0.25635743141174316,
0.09759357571601868,
-0.054247282445430756,
-0.6999871730804443,
-0.2950291335582733,
-0.6412224173545837,
0.19662068784236908,
-0.6695616841316223,
-0.6041984558105469,
0.191204234957695,
0.25471827387809753,
-0.1796107143163681,
0.3275829553604126,
0.04455940052866936,
0.17437182366847992,
0.6426806449890137,
-0.32883378863334656,
0.21479469537734985,
-0.16376815736293793,
-0.4171667695045471,
0.012371052987873554,
-0.8430606722831726,
-0.5484898090362549,
0.9754706025123596,
0.4175865948200226,
0.47441384196281433,
0.21915572881698608,
0.19159162044525146,
0.39736807346343994,
0.4308679401874542,
-0.492902010679245,
0.6031321287155151,
-0.33827540278434753,
-0.566498875617981,
-0.30138736963272095,
-0.36840441823005676,
-0.8506509065628052,
0.6447595953941345,
-0.07987156510353088,
-0.6480877995491028,
-0.2897453010082245,
0.1350187212228775,
0.008066995069384575,
0.2875804305076599,
-0.48636534810066223,
0.759334921836853,
-0.2301204353570938,
-0.5987144708633423,
-0.2163558006286621,
-0.42785152792930603,
0.16061446070671082,
-0.35367825627326965,
0.6119231581687927,
-0.23273193836212158,
-0.23608818650245667,
0.6094528436660767,
-0.34448620676994324,
0.8105641007423401,
-0.33508428931236267,
0.09028328955173492,
-0.17596110701560974,
0.3060605823993683,
0.6459434032440186,
0.018269823864102364,
-0.533822774887085,
0.4836822748184204,
0.2593011260032654,
-0.4976542890071869,
-0.6329452395439148,
0.7136834263801575,
-0.3905070722103119,
-0.6685100793838501,
-0.21389849483966827,
-0.46564364433288574,
-0.5684783458709717,
0.18565072119235992,
0.02526497095823288,
0.290629506111145,
-0.21161964535713196,
-0.18800456821918488,
0.2177044004201889,
-0.10550748556852341,
0.6192908883094788,
0.782034158706665,
-0.5617920756340027,
-0.35382941365242004,
0.7980524897575378,
0.26981961727142334,
0.3022031784057617,
0.28796976804733276,
0.19203364849090576,
-0.7195179462432861,
-0.5449567437171936,
-0.5462254881858826,
0.13498204946517944,
-0.5445677638053894,
-0.23711594939231873,
-0.6017667055130005,
-0.14885616302490234,
-0.500521183013916,
0.0034871527459472418,
-0.7698310017585754,
-0.34017065167427063,
0.06078844144940376,
0.05761439725756645,
-0.012541545554995537,
0.5447731018066406,
0.11883201450109482,
0.36851775646209717,
-0.8811798095703125,
0.26363205909729004,
0.051459215581417084,
0.664715051651001,
-0.040315333753824234,
-0.6122838258743286,
-0.4897176921367645,
0.18154141306877136,
0.02361515536904335,
-0.6104071140289307,
0.9518904089927673,
0.4872690737247467,
0.8716944456100464,
0.24428485333919525,
0.1319311261177063,
1.036069631576538,
-0.7794731855392456,
1.0633374452590942,
0.14111608266830444,
-1.146634817123413,
0.503964364528656,
-0.054855797439813614,
0.36074528098106384,
0.15011081099510193,
0.4271116852760315,
-0.5591838359832764,
-0.5433529615402222,
-0.4250757396221161,
-0.7835644483566284,
0.585720956325531,
-0.12110836058855057,
0.3052094876766205,
-0.22474819421768188,
0.24954146146774292,
0.3336676061153412,
0.34754547476768494,
-0.5857471823692322,
-0.3479911983013153,
-0.05255765840411186,
0.17513521015644073,
-0.5523076057434082,
-0.4541252553462982,
0.26941338181495667,
-0.3454475998878479,
0.8852965235710144,
-0.4151056706905365,
0.018224656581878662,
-0.17203912138938904,
-0.13242985308170319,
-0.1856537163257599,
-0.17125648260116577,
0.7008486390113831,
0.916746199131012,
-0.08375991880893707,
0.3247257173061371,
0.5242916345596313,
-0.44516098499298096,
-0.18322022259235382,
0.024538075551390648,
0.06639736145734787,
0.43722453713417053,
0.596637487411499,
1.122310757637024,
0.23894920945167542,
-0.895933210849762,
0.21355298161506653,
-0.07102203369140625,
0.0037212073802948,
-0.36750003695487976,
-0.07156319171190262,
0.08601842075586319,
0.34203723073005676,
0.36166760325431824,
-0.2359263151884079,
0.22551648318767548,
-0.3705129027366638,
-0.0026016950141638517,
0.5928505063056946,
-0.34317535161972046,
-0.35252147912979126,
0.8121957182884216,
-0.08021761476993561,
-0.5725809931755066,
0.25140246748924255,
-0.06779572367668152,
-0.6834427118301392,
0.5513764023780823,
0.8998432755470276,
0.8339414000511169,
-0.7968948483467102,
0.3829866349697113,
0.29727309942245483,
0.0642000287771225,
-0.4644941985607147,
0.20656737685203552,
0.48861926794052124,
-0.7300543785095215,
-0.6917656064033508,
-1.1009641885757446,
-0.3345222771167755,
0.2896396517753601,
-0.5802419781684875,
0.08930584043264389,
-0.09679018706083298,
-0.2847749888896942,
-0.10762108862400055,
0.15053904056549072,
-0.6249511241912842,
0.15617141127586365,
0.08316455036401749,
1.178760290145874,
-0.95064777135849,
1.1145987510681152,
0.7790742516517639,
0.02660607360303402,
-0.5859252214431763,
-0.20329004526138306,
-0.06328080594539642,
-0.593411386013031,
0.8809263706207275,
0.056425873190164566,
-0.5146729946136475,
-0.16282357275485992,
0.05406633019447327,
-1.085846185684204,
0.6240043640136719,
0.6382136940956116,
-0.38068267703056335,
0.24103768169879913,
0.6249252557754517,
0.8383496403694153,
-0.6506733298301697,
0.3514767289161682,
0.38105010986328125,
0.2758525013923645,
0.0638391301035881,
-1.2887824773788452,
-0.04337942972779274,
-0.4730236828327179,
0.6057866215705872,
0.09289304167032242,
-0.3859058916568756,
1.0619683265686035,
0.09175912290811539,
-0.05187126621603966,
0.054384659975767136,
0.5257933139801025,
0.20174865424633026,
0.6202355623245239,
0.46441611647605896,
0.15534880757331848,
0.8765991926193237,
0.06384902447462082,
1.1713871955871582,
-0.5352246761322021,
0.22860565781593323,
1.153663158416748,
-0.4377250671386719,
1.1372359991073608,
0.5372788310050964,
-0.23847396671772003,
0.3290542662143707,
0.58741694688797,
0.3934129476547241,
0.5539848804473877,
0.10965362936258316,
-0.20229686796665192,
-0.25955912470817566,
-0.15378549695014954,
-0.21822500228881836,
0.47899147868156433,
0.2555098831653595,
-0.21517294645309448,
-0.01913839392364025,
0.25395655632019043,
-0.12928010523319244,
0.25876694917678833,
-0.7088778614997864,
0.49397408962249756,
-0.11842072755098343,
-0.9143855571746826,
0.7858384251594543,
0.07560807466506958,
0.47706446051597595,
-0.4765068590641022,
-0.11159034818410873,
-0.31985583901405334,
0.2534540891647339,
0.09480670094490051,
-0.47201570868492126,
0.4590492248535156,
-0.2842048406600952,
-0.1689269095659256,
-0.27035996317863464,
1.0112112760543823,
-0.4433487355709076,
-0.7086911797523499,
0.8321423530578613,
0.8006527423858643,
0.15504881739616394,
-0.31580013036727905,
-0.7182186245918274,
0.07670056074857712,
-0.2698007822036743,
-0.32305100560188293,
0.5954955816268921,
0.07290690392255783,
-0.2597410976886749,
1.247282862663269,
0.7781743407249451,
0.3999120891094208,
0.37836647033691406,
0.19763511419296265,
0.7400814294815063,
-0.28806617856025696,
-0.44140228629112244,
-1.0545798540115356,
0.5363643765449524,
-0.14343033730983734,
-0.05791638791561127,
0.7833735346794128,
0.7195139527320862,
0.9234064817428589,
-0.3956741988658905,
0.6507180333137512,
0.4200708568096161,
0.8180842399597168,
-0.6255406737327576,
0.5686051845550537,
-0.7329370975494385,
0.32115405797958374,
-0.3975701928138733,
-0.9390668272972107,
-0.25232523679733276,
0.2797526717185974,
-0.14203646779060364,
-0.14160101115703583,
0.5893557071685791,
0.9614425301551819,
0.043709345161914825,
-0.0005467666778713465,
0.7792243361473083,
0.011512136086821556,
0.13761575520038605,
0.20471201837062836,
0.580116331577301,
-0.25214922428131104,
0.23426073789596558,
-0.4601462185382843,
0.10749021172523499,
-0.2324090600013733,
-0.9871850609779358,
-1.0100603103637695,
-0.803024172782898,
-0.03953992575407028,
-0.19377610087394714,
0.2850485146045685,
0.6794494390487671,
0.8227435946464539,
-0.8410377502441406,
-0.6263929009437561,
-0.12381025403738022,
0.22895266115665436,
-0.5783047676086426,
-0.21073627471923828,
0.2676408886909485,
-0.6203228235244751,
-1.0348756313323975,
0.6113671660423279,
-0.007298919837921858,
-0.33030107617378235,
-0.39773333072662354,
-0.4554457366466522,
-0.3068239688873291,
0.17629994451999664,
0.7854409217834473,
0.14053016901016235,
-0.9625722169876099,
0.05472337454557419,
-0.08772964030504227,
0.04084141552448273,
-0.4501793384552002,
0.6142674684524536,
-0.8294464349746704,
0.4948791265487671,
0.3396650552749634,
0.5689387917518616,
0.6413998603820801,
-0.17316797375679016,
0.6637127995491028,
-0.8715997338294983,
0.15676173567771912,
0.0859857127070427,
0.5102157592773438,
0.03449588641524315,
-0.25328385829925537,
0.7691115140914917,
0.08131857961416245,
-0.27799561619758606,
-1.1656343936920166,
0.08535999804735184,
-0.45981407165527344,
-0.42185157537460327,
1.0606865882873535,
-0.40059688687324524,
-0.1255398988723755,
-0.34242814779281616,
-0.07061158120632172,
0.27229437232017517,
-0.196516215801239,
0.6550764441490173,
0.5816813707351685,
0.004556648898869753,
-0.3280036449432373,
-1.1063443422317505,
0.6493916511535645,
0.41348209977149963,
-0.5433316826820374,
0.23810364305973053,
0.3564161956310272,
0.06857765465974808,
0.2925671339035034,
0.43582683801651,
0.19939006865024567,
0.12898844480514526,
-0.02414238639175892,
-0.04874637350440025,
-0.3459152281284332,
-0.3898216187953949,
-0.10639362037181854,
0.6016778349876404,
0.011994867585599422,
0.13419927656650543
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09330v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09330v1
|
Learning from Natural Language Explanations for Generalizable Entity Matching
| 2024-06-13T17:08:58 | 2024-06-13T17:08:58 |
Somin Wadhwa, Adit Krishnan, Runhui Wang, Byron C. Wallace, Chris Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Entity matching is the task of linking records from different sources that
refer to the same real-world entity. Past work has primarily treated entity
linking as a standard supervised learning problem. However, supervised entity
matching models often do not generalize well to new data, and collecting
exhaustive labeled training data is often cost prohibitive. Further, recent
efforts have adopted LLMs for this task in few/zero-shot settings, exploiting
their general knowledge. But LLMs are prohibitively expensive for performing
inference at scale for real-world entity matching tasks.
As an efficient alternative, we re-cast entity matching as a conditional
generation task as opposed to binary classification. This enables us to
"distill" LLM reasoning into smaller entity matching models via natural
language explanations. This approach achieves strong performance, especially on
out-of-domain generalization tests (10.85% F-1) where standalone generative
methods struggle. We perform ablations that highlight the importance of
explanations, both for performance and model robustness.
|
[
-0.39340120553970337,
-0.859394371509552,
0.7340075969696045,
-0.2305469512939453,
-0.5070074796676636,
-0.17259342968463898,
-0.24265938997268677,
-0.6719725728034973,
0.01440906710922718,
0.8225051760673523,
-0.8395834565162659,
-0.5559551119804382,
-0.12867245078086853,
0.34449318051338196,
-0.434712678194046,
1.0182286500930786,
-0.232188880443573,
-0.135488823056221,
-0.5209615230560303,
-0.041021928191185,
-0.3671787977218628,
-0.1038731262087822,
-1.1098710298538208,
-0.41669711470603943,
0.5495263934135437,
0.4784789979457855,
0.6608204245567322,
0.9011024236679077,
0.24423150718212128,
0.3346709907054901,
0.22244463860988617,
0.32210245728492737,
-0.3509301543235779,
0.2340807020664215,
-0.46704015135765076,
-0.7178260684013367,
-0.2538374066352844,
-0.015247151255607605,
0.5551146268844604,
0.9976420402526855,
-0.22471143305301666,
0.15153196454048157,
-0.06882591545581818,
0.679113507270813,
-0.43642446398735046,
0.08747393637895584,
-1.0359326601028442,
-0.11049530655145645,
-0.13353945314884186,
-0.237064391374588,
-0.4454195499420166,
-0.3368501365184784,
0.20592661201953888,
-0.924045205116272,
0.8547497987747192,
0.4371822774410248,
1.0711259841918945,
0.5238299369812012,
-0.661065936088562,
-0.5333886742591858,
-0.7156456708908081,
0.6041221022605896,
-0.41637587547302246,
0.3858622908592224,
0.26523682475090027,
0.3436953127384186,
-0.3159964382648468,
-0.7084688544273376,
-0.663764476776123,
-0.0815114825963974,
-0.3247334659099579,
-0.06315985321998596,
-0.21085287630558014,
0.3374342620372772,
0.37617626786231995,
0.6360886096954346,
-0.6339734792709351,
0.16539089381694794,
-0.137578085064888,
-0.20931299030780792,
0.5365898013114929,
0.017350930720567703,
0.3819684684276581,
0.09057820588350296,
-0.5092865824699402,
0.2433057725429535,
-0.9304759502410889,
-0.2138812392950058,
0.503466784954071,
0.295063316822052,
-0.0636824294924736,
0.6308513283729553,
-0.1586426943540573,
0.9324875473976135,
0.31543228030204773,
-0.09682351350784302,
-0.05773359537124634,
-0.49027884006500244,
-0.47392863035202026,
0.19521737098693848,
0.449429988861084,
0.3710021674633026,
0.432174414396286,
-0.524959921836853,
-0.1023021936416626,
0.19899162650108337,
0.17213097214698792,
-0.919792890548706,
-0.19766482710838318,
0.04530181363224983,
-0.28473466634750366,
0.15779250860214233,
-0.3866744637489319,
-0.7889180183410645,
-0.08041581511497498,
-0.6654054522514343,
0.3229418396949768,
-0.2975063920021057,
-0.14369931817054749,
0.14551809430122375,
0.003727236995473504,
0.29009923338890076,
0.26130568981170654,
-1.2065825462341309,
0.21914462745189667,
0.67186439037323,
0.5671805739402771,
0.0020461133681237698,
0.07547082006931305,
-0.5432994365692139,
0.28369632363319397,
-0.16703104972839355,
0.8304387927055359,
-0.30412834882736206,
-0.14530672132968903,
0.12950626015663147,
0.044939152896404266,
-0.04677627608180046,
-0.7095917463302612,
0.43985942006111145,
-0.6629819273948669,
0.3027336001396179,
-0.2150442749261856,
-0.8149563670158386,
-0.1999291032552719,
0.07017785310745239,
-0.5882818698883057,
0.7359322309494019,
0.0842694640159607,
-0.7316589951515198,
0.9374213218688965,
-0.39092233777046204,
-0.5354785323143005,
0.13813602924346924,
-0.20996510982513428,
-0.41913995146751404,
0.04525076970458031,
0.23542426526546478,
0.3612174391746521,
-0.5228290557861328,
0.3911338746547699,
-0.37401148676872253,
-0.3254747986793518,
-0.18676570057868958,
-0.2717847228050232,
0.5727185606956482,
0.1972164511680603,
-0.3509131073951721,
-0.06354094296693802,
-0.7998212575912476,
-0.3055056035518646,
0.29242148995399475,
-0.445332407951355,
-0.46813681721687317,
0.06312498450279236,
-0.6283968687057495,
-0.15266384184360504,
0.08948113769292831,
-0.3331678807735443,
0.12758614122867584,
-0.6331378817558289,
0.12001831829547882,
0.4912194609642029,
0.20107385516166687,
0.7867812514305115,
-0.23460835218429565,
0.4552038311958313,
0.13735245168209076,
-0.20076194405555725,
-0.17288994789123535,
-0.450005441904068,
-0.8846391439437866,
-0.5339308381080627,
0.2838541269302368,
0.42362600564956665,
-1.0539460182189941,
0.16599160432815552,
-0.2673865854740143,
-0.11565440148115158,
-0.6524078845977783,
0.3610262870788574,
0.38573139905929565,
1.0433191061019897,
0.6310518980026245,
0.035429928451776505,
-0.7377199530601501,
-1.2226381301879883,
-0.40259188413619995,
-0.11650112271308899,
-0.4182215631008148,
0.32701677083969116,
0.37142130732536316,
-0.17077314853668213,
0.8645401000976562,
-0.2965855002403259,
-0.15571700036525726,
-0.13927128911018372,
-0.029425447806715965,
0.2920479476451874,
0.18502534925937653,
0.4657968580722809,
-0.8560063242912292,
-0.49530667066574097,
-0.16206762194633484,
-0.8047832250595093,
-0.19825902581214905,
-0.350360631942749,
-0.36625632643699646,
0.19904924929141998,
0.5067991614341736,
-0.6125757098197937,
0.17690901458263397,
0.439677894115448,
-0.2959679663181305,
0.14895538985729218,
-0.25467127561569214,
0.02155204862356186,
-1.0380768775939941,
-0.23743243515491486,
0.3303930461406708,
-0.2508138418197632,
-0.5672252178192139,
0.11183398216962814,
-0.20512376725673676,
0.018121052533388138,
-0.3643244206905365,
0.5335887670516968,
-0.7834909558296204,
-0.1261635720729828,
-0.19963157176971436,
0.49430593848228455,
0.113390251994133,
0.3669434189796448,
0.13054537773132324,
0.5875282287597656,
0.6842739582061768,
-0.8971613049507141,
0.450692355632782,
0.09699054062366486,
0.01511488389223814,
0.8142235279083252,
-0.5239711999893188,
-0.055851854383945465,
-0.40024539828300476,
0.3359856605529785,
-0.7389119267463684,
-0.29653865098953247,
0.3637763261795044,
-0.21857501566410065,
0.4599872827529907,
-0.4909838140010834,
-0.29273703694343567,
-0.12171586602926254,
-0.016743065789341927,
0.3545580804347992,
0.4287661910057068,
-1.0226020812988281,
0.8037600517272949,
0.1569313108921051,
0.15315699577331543,
-0.43017444014549255,
-0.51874840259552,
-0.028309158980846405,
-0.506574273109436,
-0.7118473649024963,
0.5937109589576721,
-0.12515076994895935,
-0.32484883069992065,
0.2966819703578949,
-0.32827332615852356,
-0.11381620168685913,
0.4497348666191101,
0.26084116101264954,
0.4449976980686188,
-0.4753611385822296,
0.2472691833972931,
0.12168291211128235,
-0.17454580962657928,
0.20364844799041748,
-0.3758782744407654,
0.09726525843143463,
0.23485511541366577,
-0.3366813361644745,
-0.3318364918231964,
0.4147031307220459,
-0.010889949277043343,
0.012549428269267082,
0.8988265991210938,
0.48791417479515076,
-0.6954513788223267,
-0.3629120886325836,
-0.5296812057495117,
-0.1461852490901947,
-0.44801872968673706,
0.00958655308932066,
-0.5896127223968506,
-0.7605099678039551,
0.2592273950576782,
-0.039668116718530655,
0.2605803608894348,
0.5797544121742249,
0.5532995462417603,
-0.017313189804553986,
0.887108564376831,
0.4887066185474396,
0.14545635879039764,
0.2832816243171692,
0.029690705239772797,
0.27827131748199463,
-0.45915237069129944,
-0.2500923275947571,
-0.5252904295921326,
-0.13139350712299347,
-0.7724722623825073,
-0.26313352584838867,
-0.24445320665836334,
0.40091556310653687,
-0.10736115276813507,
0.40288880467414856,
-0.5565785765647888,
0.6385985016822815,
0.6982599496841431,
-0.035461895167827606,
0.5140154957771301,
0.06324202567338943,
-0.2139342725276947,
0.17758706212043762,
-0.4484882950782776,
-0.6366029977798462,
1.0339690446853638,
0.11154022067785263,
0.6468527913093567,
0.25960662961006165,
1.0918076038360596,
0.05117810517549515,
0.7638136148452759,
-0.7012714743614197,
0.5394141674041748,
-0.058206696063280106,
-0.7766523957252502,
-0.2920953929424286,
-0.692652702331543,
-1.1482325792312622,
0.24689099192619324,
-0.4417668282985687,
-0.5400466918945312,
-0.0438227616250515,
0.6815667152404785,
-0.13735637068748474,
0.2195514738559723,
-0.8954302668571472,
0.7037168741226196,
-0.048381365835666656,
-0.22000814974308014,
-0.029529668390750885,
-0.431301087141037,
0.5816196799278259,
-0.058055002242326736,
0.25135737657546997,
-0.2186252474784851,
-0.0630609318614006,
0.439273476600647,
-0.11356361210346222,
0.6662758588790894,
-0.31253159046173096,
-0.10994409769773483,
0.2428906112909317,
-0.04374412074685097,
0.48330968618392944,
0.2988346815109253,
-0.10170134902000427,
-0.048624999821186066,
-0.28031226992607117,
-0.3622795343399048,
-0.6602818369865417,
0.7878413796424866,
-0.3502858877182007,
-0.8346675634384155,
-0.06075068563222885,
-0.2407674640417099,
-0.21296259760856628,
-0.03267781436443329,
0.3961067795753479,
0.11683187633752823,
-0.07440909743309021,
-0.04135459288954735,
0.9839919209480286,
-0.004185003694146872,
0.05197375640273094,
0.6574800610542297,
-0.09294132143259048,
-0.17194031178951263,
0.7193537354469299,
-0.3136867880821228,
0.1873466819524765,
0.6944438815116882,
-0.19216524064540863,
-0.5817844271659851,
-0.6912451386451721,
-0.5530335903167725,
0.38355305790901184,
-0.7575517296791077,
-0.20773494243621826,
-0.495723694562912,
0.29177212715148926,
-0.22162146866321564,
-0.18087565898895264,
0.07436595112085342,
-0.08598104864358902,
-0.5036442875862122,
-0.3060201108455658,
0.14975114166736603,
0.3263265788555145,
-0.05618834123015404,
0.006783877499401569,
-0.5342546701431274,
0.8736954927444458,
0.5551659464836121,
0.3965786099433899,
-0.1017657220363617,
-0.3958161771297455,
-0.15684612095355988,
0.1668977588415146,
-0.0275464728474617,
-1.1117304563522339,
0.020904289558529854,
0.5258601903915405,
0.7607977986335754,
0.33966508507728577,
0.11056380718946457,
0.722137451171875,
-0.6744874715805054,
0.5327998995780945,
0.19352507591247559,
-0.8459569811820984,
0.673071563243866,
0.009186243638396263,
-0.2805871069431305,
0.4728463590145111,
0.628226101398468,
-0.32262372970581055,
-0.39880165457725525,
-0.6691527366638184,
-1.0056873559951782,
0.519560694694519,
0.04713970422744751,
-0.03169950470328331,
-0.47682419419288635,
0.8769528269767761,
0.07814989238977432,
-0.03099878504872322,
-0.7585416436195374,
-0.5351802110671997,
-0.03955255076289177,
-0.36865025758743286,
-0.24783320724964142,
-0.10650352388620377,
-0.20182853937149048,
0.14148788154125214,
0.8773713707923889,
-0.2634541988372803,
0.2084614634513855,
0.25396400690078735,
-0.5939230918884277,
-0.23149734735488892,
0.30480149388313293,
0.4903790354728699,
0.4609946608543396,
-0.026158208027482033,
0.3999573588371277,
0.2969802916049957,
0.10011142492294312,
0.14666292071342468,
0.235295370221138,
-0.241925910115242,
0.2209761142730713,
0.34088578820228577,
0.9051780700683594,
0.27725154161453247,
-0.5209082961082458,
0.29410088062286377,
-0.11648640036582947,
-0.43903419375419617,
-0.25958818197250366,
0.2623455822467804,
0.4884299635887146,
0.2640630602836609,
0.2954424321651459,
-0.3668483793735504,
0.17770250141620636,
-0.6359803676605225,
0.2443688064813614,
0.571017324924469,
-0.15349081158638,
-0.3723502457141876,
0.9869544506072998,
0.24383792281150818,
-0.33132025599479675,
0.6372494101524353,
-0.4515656530857086,
-0.19588948786258698,
0.4958239197731018,
0.6288659572601318,
0.7640045881271362,
0.06489793956279755,
0.16172200441360474,
0.4778594672679901,
0.1792881041765213,
-0.01414969190955162,
-0.055526018142700195,
-0.16890035569667816,
-0.757286787033081,
-0.6500710248947144,
-0.6270140409469604,
-0.5577365756034851,
-0.005701820831745863,
-0.7954056262969971,
0.1991092562675476,
-0.18822935223579407,
0.09169874340295792,
0.4003528952598572,
-0.27804213762283325,
-1.0445797443389893,
0.40334343910217285,
0.26761874556541443,
0.8006660342216492,
-0.9848873615264893,
0.556614339351654,
0.712944746017456,
-0.6951866745948792,
-0.7939253449440002,
-0.06422924250364304,
-0.09157688170671463,
-0.9798233509063721,
0.603007972240448,
0.14131233096122742,
0.17517374455928802,
0.10254132002592087,
-0.2947397530078888,
-0.5936117172241211,
1.107933759689331,
0.8600779175758362,
-0.5964276194572449,
-0.3498326241970062,
0.05115165561437607,
0.5401163101196289,
-0.43341368436813354,
0.03269422426819801,
0.7666305303573608,
0.3700820505619049,
0.010528440587222576,
-0.528958797454834,
0.3500501811504364,
0.15003307163715363,
-0.1337064653635025,
0.47811734676361084,
-0.049830351024866104,
0.4907829165458679,
-0.3505934178829193,
-0.5379754304885864,
-0.13421837985515594,
0.8050663471221924,
0.28052645921707153,
0.48708242177963257,
0.7612489461898804,
0.7176029682159424,
0.8559936285018921,
-0.21064385771751404,
0.886954128742218,
-0.15823420882225037,
0.4399361312389374,
1.1583772897720337,
-0.2285367101430893,
0.5241244435310364,
0.6148513555526733,
-0.1643269956111908,
0.7214055061340332,
0.8957485556602478,
-0.012623421847820282,
0.39916086196899414,
0.45280903577804565,
-0.5140248537063599,
-0.581654965877533,
-0.134761244058609,
-0.07915789633989334,
0.18163348734378815,
0.16432423889636993,
-0.4468144178390503,
-0.504584550857544,
-0.15267719328403473,
-0.1535177081823349,
0.25543567538261414,
-0.30330145359039307,
0.8820182085037231,
0.1303682029247284,
-0.8745946884155273,
0.4670735001564026,
-0.16581018269062042,
0.6113637685775757,
-0.3016173243522644,
-0.3581848740577698,
-0.38365426659584045,
0.012944011017680168,
-0.251982718706131,
-0.4382450580596924,
0.4783625304698944,
0.008139785379171371,
-0.5267935991287231,
-0.2629348635673523,
0.6891949772834778,
-0.6427332162857056,
-0.16134625673294067,
0.3199709355831146,
0.39667558670043945,
0.2787274718284607,
0.06648052483797073,
-0.6071138978004456,
-0.5499139428138733,
0.2601735293865204,
-0.17622290551662445,
0.40226972103118896,
0.5778612494468689,
0.031755708158016205,
0.6930636167526245,
0.7527104020118713,
-0.08965694904327393,
0.048033930361270905,
0.10081040114164352,
0.446219265460968,
-0.6404232978820801,
-0.10810676217079163,
-0.8857848644256592,
0.3752478063106537,
0.03137773275375366,
-0.029075877740979195,
0.4383433163166046,
0.6257207989692688,
0.9390689730644226,
0.0195452980697155,
0.5587635040283203,
0.18309219181537628,
0.6163358092308044,
-0.8677868247032166,
0.10174275934696198,
-0.5874571800231934,
0.44380292296409607,
0.20274563133716583,
-1.048617959022522,
-0.22236767411231995,
0.38209232687950134,
-0.01968846283853054,
-0.12892742455005646,
0.6941080093383789,
0.6393009424209595,
-0.11747538298368454,
-0.1291487216949463,
0.29628342390060425,
0.011762689799070358,
0.2611967921257019,
0.5474393963813782,
0.5507891774177551,
-0.14481283724308014,
0.8125519752502441,
-0.24659335613250732,
-0.04666665196418762,
-0.046068400144577026,
-1.1372101306915283,
-0.8549066185951233,
-0.3543455898761749,
-0.6785863637924194,
-0.2884601652622223,
0.06767168641090393,
0.8051335215568542,
0.38339629769325256,
-0.6764509081840515,
0.3119933605194092,
-0.3045686185359955,
0.45548248291015625,
0.06511826068162918,
-0.23544935882091522,
0.2024998813867569,
-0.3672620952129364,
-0.9168696403503418,
0.4485153555870056,
0.1935185045003891,
0.15622510015964508,
-0.17446927726268768,
0.06395494937896729,
-0.06097092479467392,
0.09605201333761215,
0.21044310927391052,
0.38520413637161255,
-0.9078439474105835,
-0.4826487600803375,
-0.10724256932735443,
0.0016238332027569413,
0.02583608217537403,
0.6835688948631287,
-0.741156816482544,
0.257673442363739,
0.2913091778755188,
0.6845372319221497,
0.6020231246948242,
-0.007081654854118824,
0.5398491621017456,
-0.8988966941833496,
-0.04109404608607292,
-0.0018064748728647828,
0.6127990484237671,
0.5667973160743713,
-0.4143810272216797,
0.598385214805603,
0.25665727257728577,
-0.48573002219200134,
-0.780718207359314,
0.4654391407966614,
-0.8825069665908813,
0.03555288165807724,
0.9812188744544983,
-0.4393446445465088,
0.05196031183004379,
-0.24731174111366272,
0.18013328313827515,
0.6515754461288452,
-0.20240674912929535,
0.4679844379425049,
0.39223968982696533,
-0.06181011348962784,
-0.05591806396842003,
-0.4697657823562622,
0.48532140254974365,
0.1925462931394577,
-0.8667341470718384,
-0.16647733747959137,
0.5002419352531433,
0.6293140053749084,
0.008182920515537262,
0.5617116689682007,
0.43984273076057434,
0.20411361753940582,
-0.03042798861861229,
0.2192835509777069,
0.04472919926047325,
-0.0028704642318189144,
-0.14524191617965698,
-0.010618753731250763,
0.19684451818466187,
-0.1888156235218048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09325v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09325v1
|
REVS: Unlearning Sensitive Information in Language Models via Rank Editing in the Vocabulary Space
| 2024-06-13T17:02:32 | 2024-06-13T17:02:32 |
Tomer Ashuach, Martin Tutek, Yonatan Belinkov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Large language models (LLMs) risk inadvertently memorizing and divulging
sensitive or personally identifiable information (PII) seen in training data,
causing privacy concerns. Current approaches to address this issue involve
costly dataset scrubbing, or model filtering through unlearning and model
editing, which can be bypassed through extraction attacks. We propose REVS, a
novel model editing method for unlearning sensitive information from LLMs. REVS
identifies and modifies a small subset of neurons relevant for each piece of
sensitive information. By projecting these neurons to the vocabulary space
(unembedding), we pinpoint the components driving its generation. We then
compute a model edit based on the pseudo-inverse of the unembedding matrix, and
apply it to de-promote generation of the targeted sensitive data. To adequately
evaluate our method on truly sensitive information, we curate two datasets: an
email dataset inherently memorized by GPT-J, and a synthetic social security
number dataset that we tune the model to memorize. Compared to other
state-of-the-art model editing methods, REVS demonstrates superior performance
in both eliminating sensitive information and robustness to extraction attacks,
while retaining integrity of the underlying model. The code and a demo notebook
are available at https://technion-cs-nlp.github.io/REVS.
|
[
0.017072390764951706,
-0.6502236127853394,
0.017195679247379303,
-0.16910366714000702,
-0.07854200899600983,
0.2894633114337921,
-0.3521350920200348,
-0.19091202318668365,
-0.08442427963018417,
0.7652645111083984,
-0.34950342774391174,
-0.4487706422805786,
-0.48726385831832886,
-0.2945084869861603,
-0.6549278497695923,
1.0996615886688232,
0.5841285586357117,
0.09363478422164917,
0.051215749233961105,
0.09077294915914536,
-0.05681290850043297,
-0.7928968667984009,
-0.4751923680305481,
-0.11519575119018555,
0.5929907560348511,
0.23644737899303436,
0.5178808569908142,
0.5741074681282043,
0.4749581515789032,
0.33926427364349365,
-0.6194576621055603,
0.05801788344979286,
-0.8014017939567566,
0.4165699779987335,
-0.5455820560455322,
-0.34143489599227905,
-0.591404914855957,
-0.20041032135486603,
0.7544019222259521,
0.7988911271095276,
-0.15840652585029602,
0.2559313476085663,
0.14055414497852325,
0.7750511169433594,
-0.8524929285049438,
-0.23357175290584564,
-1.172210931777954,
-0.2514289617538452,
-0.32626983523368835,
-0.1499849557876587,
-0.7482861280441284,
-0.14601142704486847,
-0.23524555563926697,
-0.3208940625190735,
0.44373777508735657,
-0.29509222507476807,
0.7695997357368469,
0.020061414688825607,
-0.06619817763566971,
0.26970374584198,
-0.6842453479766846,
0.6731765866279602,
-0.7136380076408386,
0.5355766415596008,
0.4071628153324127,
-0.028329042717814445,
-0.3822994530200958,
-0.9161620736122131,
-0.33853137493133545,
0.26393118500709534,
0.18244491517543793,
-0.009102837182581425,
-0.3417024612426758,
0.12644730508327484,
0.45789656043052673,
0.3872038722038269,
-0.3766566216945648,
0.3319909870624542,
-0.7372199892997742,
-0.2563064694404602,
0.6060547828674316,
-0.0884469524025917,
0.27210554480552673,
-0.11971445381641388,
-0.17965590953826904,
-0.20614606142044067,
-1.1658486127853394,
0.05183953419327736,
0.6539506316184998,
0.657062292098999,
0.21632279455661774,
0.8040131330490112,
-0.05699354037642479,
0.5174969434738159,
-0.10884994268417358,
0.2516871988773346,
0.30743634700775146,
0.17808592319488525,
-0.36935824155807495,
-0.17502309381961823,
0.6922476887702942,
0.11375352740287781,
0.4630482494831085,
-0.3629886507987976,
-0.4774037003517151,
-0.20115631818771362,
0.5698580741882324,
-0.7765458822250366,
-0.49190554022789,
0.07525255531072617,
-0.3504334092140198,
-0.6803444027900696,
0.07719479501247406,
-0.7241324186325073,
-0.7026654481887817,
-0.06173382326960564,
0.2892712354660034,
-0.3742426335811615,
-0.18810057640075684,
0.07120345532894135,
-0.09879045188426971,
-0.17206764221191406,
0.22832134366035461,
-0.9084600806236267,
0.17837776243686676,
0.7247449159622192,
0.4532386064529419,
-0.009932485409080982,
-0.1617412269115448,
-0.5682533979415894,
0.26580414175987244,
-0.2671557664871216,
0.35644611716270447,
-0.7924501895904541,
-0.505462646484375,
0.048049066215753555,
-0.021035371348261833,
0.08657290786504745,
-0.5304572582244873,
0.1652769148349762,
-1.029035210609436,
0.16086545586585999,
-0.11289092898368835,
-0.5168331265449524,
0.0925225093960762,
0.027777310460805893,
-0.5917866230010986,
1.0870532989501953,
-0.0011246369685977697,
-0.8210513591766357,
-0.02883009798824787,
-0.4509495496749878,
-0.35518524050712585,
-0.0865333303809166,
0.06115959212183952,
-0.5529906749725342,
0.2542286217212677,
0.17437304556369781,
0.38291287422180176,
0.1280713975429535,
0.4380663335323334,
-0.2531154751777649,
-0.0894870012998581,
0.4688592851161957,
-0.49934911727905273,
0.7960492372512817,
0.22208930552005768,
0.22566494345664978,
0.2772672176361084,
-0.7986253499984741,
0.11782986670732498,
0.1961689591407776,
-0.39123761653900146,
-0.45677390694618225,
-0.19522544741630554,
-0.20522655546665192,
0.08551027625799179,
0.3033652901649475,
-0.5771279335021973,
0.395746111869812,
-0.38226956129074097,
0.4555951654911041,
1.1321165561676025,
0.22931069135665894,
0.5435660481452942,
-0.2208324521780014,
0.3540216088294983,
0.013244496658444405,
0.3608475625514984,
-0.18958096206188202,
-0.5021383166313171,
-0.5283294320106506,
-0.26660293340682983,
0.6317998170852661,
0.3782295882701874,
-0.45046499371528625,
0.209336519241333,
-0.43978312611579895,
-0.45175644755363464,
-0.7096198201179504,
0.3240613341331482,
0.6257637739181519,
0.4592808783054352,
0.46074214577674866,
-0.2653098702430725,
-0.4740341603755951,
-0.8259060382843018,
-0.7621725797653198,
-0.18462178111076355,
-0.26156342029571533,
0.09806612133979797,
0.3680083751678467,
-0.06707586348056793,
0.6660209894180298,
-0.46072980761528015,
-0.19709448516368866,
-0.10635164380073547,
0.22436699271202087,
-0.17160071432590485,
0.6356238722801208,
0.08122014254331589,
-0.6134356260299683,
-0.052592772990465164,
-0.37145909667015076,
-0.3712112009525299,
-0.14249835908412933,
-0.11497760564088821,
0.08439627289772034,
-0.21620725095272064,
0.7825678586959839,
-0.30219611525535583,
0.6439874768257141,
0.2711421251296997,
-0.1431921422481537,
0.15973031520843506,
-0.38736504316329956,
-0.23080970346927643,
-0.9693863391876221,
0.26431146264076233,
-0.3518417477607727,
-0.1907915472984314,
-0.8928351402282715,
0.05905267223715782,
0.3076741397380829,
-0.10924787819385529,
-0.5546989440917969,
0.3721637427806854,
-0.6039268374443054,
-0.012301885522902012,
-0.03102804534137249,
-0.01345532201230526,
0.07996585220098495,
0.6149834394454956,
-0.11104638129472733,
0.669167160987854,
0.31714117527008057,
-0.4381099045276642,
-0.1426866054534912,
0.40631964802742004,
-0.3663668930530548,
-0.08607286214828491,
-0.5151008367538452,
0.6448362469673157,
-0.20248974859714508,
-0.18630176782608032,
-0.9333783388137817,
0.016265736892819405,
0.046294767409563065,
-0.7030242085456848,
0.7424181699752808,
-0.45930910110473633,
-0.368039071559906,
0.09764912724494934,
-0.424434095621109,
0.3493471145629883,
0.44686079025268555,
-0.5687054991722107,
0.3471297025680542,
0.8245805501937866,
-0.3978429138660431,
-0.9387528300285339,
-0.7222843170166016,
0.27224236726760864,
0.07812997698783875,
-0.19473056495189667,
0.49045661091804504,
0.2408653199672699,
-0.2356669157743454,
-0.14784246683120728,
-0.05241347849369049,
-0.18935316801071167,
0.31042563915252686,
0.44886165857315063,
0.3228350281715393,
0.18358126282691956,
0.19862692058086395,
0.3218899667263031,
-0.06490075588226318,
0.04580008611083031,
0.16131839156150818,
0.48504623770713806,
0.015800684690475464,
-0.41277411580085754,
-0.34698736667633057,
0.25113555788993835,
0.5609736442565918,
-0.5040327906608582,
0.6783036589622498,
0.27880996465682983,
-0.6194623708724976,
-0.2653804421424866,
-0.44815412163734436,
-0.5031985640525818,
-0.46344321966171265,
0.5945671200752258,
-0.1511812061071396,
-0.6968021392822266,
0.5136850476264954,
-0.2818211019039154,
0.45154091715812683,
0.14868074655532837,
0.2709309160709381,
0.06484119594097137,
0.9614513516426086,
0.7534289360046387,
-0.19300316274166107,
0.6768534183502197,
-0.32286718487739563,
0.39503076672554016,
-1.148058533668518,
-0.46435511112213135,
-0.5905996561050415,
-0.45388346910476685,
-0.4479023516178131,
-0.2796216607093811,
0.08176960051059723,
0.2955801486968994,
-0.221575066447258,
0.11707420647144318,
-0.5686399936676025,
0.5414913296699524,
0.47006604075431824,
0.21613965928554535,
0.3717190623283386,
-0.006278127897530794,
-0.03585114702582359,
-0.24367034435272217,
-0.4835900068283081,
-0.5858350992202759,
1.4796723127365112,
0.34335580468177795,
0.9710110425949097,
0.24521224200725555,
0.5994121432304382,
0.25589504837989807,
0.5529094934463501,
-0.41999778151512146,
0.5396188497543335,
-0.30149826407432556,
-0.6489341855049133,
-0.3613184988498688,
-0.3666251301765442,
-0.9570848345756531,
0.3130406439304352,
-0.3272709250450134,
-1.0212353467941284,
0.37199684977531433,
0.14127065241336823,
-0.36102715134620667,
0.776504635810852,
-0.6014644503593445,
0.605133056640625,
-0.007622547447681427,
-0.5789315700531006,
-0.14825986325740814,
-0.7243682742118835,
0.24084913730621338,
-0.17131750285625458,
0.2720658481121063,
0.2204045206308365,
-0.03282391279935837,
0.9631488919258118,
-0.35484495759010315,
1.0982997417449951,
-0.20037470757961273,
-0.03096737526357174,
-0.08384968340396881,
0.42510175704956055,
0.559791088104248,
0.06790158897638321,
-0.21952588856220245,
0.2735922038555145,
-0.26206427812576294,
0.010357840918004513,
-0.5828219056129456,
0.7969940304756165,
-0.554460883140564,
-0.5700885057449341,
-0.2261248230934143,
-0.5121036767959595,
-0.35713547468185425,
0.3209615647792816,
0.2573946416378021,
0.2679668366909027,
-0.2588237524032593,
0.21930468082427979,
0.8120747804641724,
-0.29674026370048523,
0.2914443016052246,
0.6695359945297241,
-0.3243328332901001,
-0.27276620268821716,
0.8750361800193787,
0.0743899717926979,
0.25162479281425476,
0.34305688738822937,
0.11957597732543945,
-0.21831099689006805,
-0.7385743260383606,
-0.1199115738272667,
0.23017893731594086,
-0.6866762042045593,
-0.3984737992286682,
-0.675194263458252,
-0.46019747853279114,
-0.5983074307441711,
-0.009734783321619034,
-0.700038492679596,
-0.6361644268035889,
-0.3307812213897705,
-0.19040822982788086,
0.3145485818386078,
0.8900235891342163,
-0.2555426061153412,
0.3720576763153076,
-0.6734739542007446,
0.4861425459384918,
0.1473492980003357,
0.3506576120853424,
-0.11633050441741943,
-1.1537396907806396,
0.09398729354143143,
0.25544020533561707,
-0.24064920842647552,
-0.8435325026512146,
0.6454451084136963,
0.21901476383209229,
0.2700449228286743,
0.48100215196609497,
0.06262819468975067,
0.6351466178894043,
-0.3483806848526001,
0.6316124200820923,
-0.07270867377519608,
-0.9254759550094604,
0.3827061057090759,
-0.18499018251895905,
0.03636424243450165,
0.6312066316604614,
-0.003986965399235487,
-0.6921952962875366,
-0.5228763222694397,
-0.8389943242073059,
-1.0348371267318726,
0.7862560153007507,
-0.05193173512816429,
0.3466184437274933,
0.07919029146432877,
0.6121578216552734,
0.05807526037096977,
0.38586190342903137,
-0.6163676381111145,
-0.22517772018909454,
0.05952705442905426,
-0.018862057477235794,
0.20230212807655334,
-0.5664511919021606,
-0.0853818878531456,
-0.3804612159729004,
0.7887533903121948,
0.23835593461990356,
-0.06048223376274109,
-0.035106200724840164,
-0.23269371688365936,
-0.1864878386259079,
0.3251943588256836,
0.3466268479824066,
0.3853202164173126,
-0.2712933123111725,
0.1479823738336563,
0.19366669654846191,
-0.6763714551925659,
-0.25228795409202576,
-0.3998168706893921,
-0.38911116123199463,
-0.1385582834482193,
0.23297587037086487,
0.4376852214336395,
0.3216046988964081,
-0.45822638273239136,
0.7056821584701538,
-0.04447631910443306,
-0.050298210233449936,
-0.21139578521251678,
0.03941475972533226,
0.01736709475517273,
-0.1337544023990631,
0.10925620049238205,
0.20133350789546967,
-0.08267723768949509,
-0.3190857470035553,
0.2656186819076538,
0.37946978211402893,
-0.4446678161621094,
-0.5377354621887207,
0.683657705783844,
0.010343932546675205,
-0.49160563945770264,
0.9898717999458313,
0.1768442541360855,
-0.4780484437942505,
0.23380088806152344,
0.4979507327079773,
0.8247146606445312,
-0.7978302836418152,
0.11448638141155243,
0.30816057324409485,
0.39973756670951843,
-0.08668163418769836,
0.42887482047080994,
0.14309324324131012,
-0.7400954961776733,
-0.22461648285388947,
-0.29700326919555664,
-0.247650146484375,
0.6829374432563782,
-0.9489588737487793,
0.10737133026123047,
-0.7471944689750671,
-0.18289610743522644,
0.1554546058177948,
-0.5779076218605042,
-0.4947796165943146,
0.09951070696115494,
-0.07902823388576508,
0.6764562726020813,
-0.8140383958816528,
0.9796090126037598,
0.6088230013847351,
-0.22211597859859467,
-0.45301732420921326,
-0.31453022360801697,
0.12055999785661697,
-0.889583170413971,
0.7046863436698914,
-0.12965980172157288,
-0.0400359146296978,
-0.02735987678170204,
-0.6442959904670715,
-0.6341972947120667,
0.49048784375190735,
0.5900015830993652,
-0.6618175506591797,
-0.0577571727335453,
0.24120751023292542,
0.5038706064224243,
0.05135917663574219,
0.11281997710466385,
0.21323397755622864,
0.24130263924598694,
-0.12763474881649017,
-0.5179569125175476,
-0.08646455407142639,
-0.4842267334461212,
-0.24319115281105042,
0.2000274509191513,
-0.3146194815635681,
1.0354461669921875,
-0.5009217262268066,
-0.23842276632785797,
-0.0563836544752121,
0.46820318698883057,
-0.1868668794631958,
-0.23638835549354553,
0.40405574440956116,
0.6089652180671692,
1.0685837268829346,
-0.04079828038811684,
0.6589372754096985,
-0.24898752570152283,
0.0941995158791542,
1.3071221113204956,
-0.26950350403785706,
0.9490335583686829,
0.6776847243309021,
0.07820691168308258,
0.2294723242521286,
0.25281476974487305,
0.14097988605499268,
0.5557300448417664,
0.5339386463165283,
-0.18436405062675476,
-0.253134548664093,
0.03327079862356186,
-0.30806368589401245,
0.5654962658882141,
0.4366814196109772,
-0.5446240305900574,
-0.15827906131744385,
-0.08737785369157791,
0.19202622771263123,
0.2760224938392639,
-0.05035730078816414,
0.9523411393165588,
0.05906510353088379,
-0.3388563096523285,
0.48333266377449036,
0.26517850160598755,
0.2800878584384918,
-0.6198689341545105,
-0.09565911442041397,
-0.13944792747497559,
0.43206918239593506,
-0.12368226796388626,
-0.7542955279350281,
0.2418375015258789,
0.4185377061367035,
-0.09748924523591995,
-0.48348015546798706,
0.6390002965927124,
-0.524336576461792,
-0.3069915175437927,
0.23008158802986145,
0.43561527132987976,
0.09314786642789841,
-0.38160082697868347,
-0.8070337772369385,
0.00621865363791585,
0.1491483747959137,
-0.6848137378692627,
0.6438358426094055,
0.16586564481258392,
-0.2176172435283661,
0.8284898996353149,
0.9257389307022095,
0.37727710604667664,
-0.0876646414399147,
0.4886243939399719,
1.141120433807373,
-0.6885660290718079,
-0.23021401464939117,
-0.8532639145851135,
0.5020595788955688,
-0.3301151394844055,
-0.47717854380607605,
0.5537750124931335,
0.7676017880439758,
0.8766419291496277,
0.09478146582841873,
0.740527868270874,
0.44447195529937744,
0.7845057845115662,
-0.3771314024925232,
1.0766628980636597,
-0.214079350233078,
0.6435049176216125,
-0.21316379308700562,
-0.6252195835113525,
-0.517924427986145,
0.44452789425849915,
-0.32060086727142334,
-0.04273724555969238,
0.2945643663406372,
1.249234676361084,
-0.0174087006598711,
0.04202227294445038,
0.35347431898117065,
0.4219733774662018,
0.4455870985984802,
0.3113996684551239,
0.8161145448684692,
-0.5306249856948853,
0.3038685917854309,
-0.4992777407169342,
-0.12701182067394257,
-0.01525926310569048,
-0.6960672736167908,
-0.9942818284034729,
-0.5829089879989624,
-0.21003574132919312,
-0.29438838362693787,
0.31484222412109375,
0.53156578540802,
0.49826887249946594,
-0.9346315264701843,
-0.006508663762360811,
0.14944744110107422,
0.13152746856212616,
-0.03120727650821209,
-0.18006043136119843,
0.5145503282546997,
-0.14891770482063293,
-0.5204200148582458,
0.7196175456047058,
0.20168592035770416,
0.05730761960148811,
-0.08536206185817719,
0.2352209836244583,
-0.11661162972450256,
0.05414663255214691,
0.10815278440713882,
0.42680126428604126,
-0.4719538986682892,
-0.17849114537239075,
0.02653689496219158,
-0.11461498588323593,
-0.10732931643724442,
0.9558182954788208,
-0.6880829334259033,
0.6075782179832458,
0.4973400831222534,
0.5878545045852661,
0.1998373419046402,
0.23637020587921143,
0.3876105844974518,
-0.9664679169654846,
0.1969389021396637,
0.3843132555484772,
0.41566261649131775,
0.5066825151443481,
-0.468965083360672,
0.23288387060165405,
0.08621189743280411,
-0.354788601398468,
-1.2811262607574463,
0.08008172363042831,
-0.7705294489860535,
-0.4386402368545532,
1.0962740182876587,
-0.17988257110118866,
-0.3632660508155823,
-0.2249291092157364,
-0.09606247395277023,
0.37915003299713135,
-0.34237727522850037,
1.1246994733810425,
0.2940760552883148,
0.460834264755249,
0.18523837625980377,
-0.2743827998638153,
0.5545337796211243,
0.5109208822250366,
-0.44087082147598267,
0.7349144220352173,
0.31708502769470215,
0.23746754229068756,
-0.12088469415903091,
0.2822651267051697,
-0.7283824682235718,
0.021039772778749466,
-0.23424044251441956,
0.41987115144729614,
-0.5102592706680298,
-0.50334233045578,
-0.6087071299552917,
0.1507035493850708,
-0.005651942919939756,
-0.2262616753578186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09324v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09324v1
|
Bag of Tricks: Benchmarking of Jailbreak Attacks on LLMs
| 2024-06-13T17:01:40 | 2024-06-13T17:01:40 |
Zhao Xu, Fan Liu, Hao Liu
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Although Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated significant
capabilities in executing complex tasks in a zero-shot manner, they are
susceptible to jailbreak attacks and can be manipulated to produce harmful
outputs. Recently, a growing body of research has categorized jailbreak attacks
into token-level and prompt-level attacks. However, previous work primarily
overlooks the diverse key factors of jailbreak attacks, with most studies
concentrating on LLM vulnerabilities and lacking exploration of
defense-enhanced LLMs. To address these issues, we evaluate the impact of
various attack settings on LLM performance and provide a baseline benchmark for
jailbreak attacks, encouraging the adoption of a standardized evaluation
framework. Specifically, we evaluate the eight key factors of implementing
jailbreak attacks on LLMs from both target-level and attack-level perspectives.
We further conduct seven representative jailbreak attacks on six defense
methods across two widely used datasets, encompassing approximately 320
experiments with about 50,000 GPU hours on A800-80G. Our experimental results
highlight the need for standardized benchmarking to evaluate these attacks on
defense-enhanced LLMs. Our code is available at
https://github.com/usail-hkust/Bag_of_Tricks_for_LLM_Jailbreaking.
|
[
-0.28987711668014526,
-1.1035512685775757,
0.5141583681106567,
0.1216723695397377,
-0.2539432644844055,
0.5142607688903809,
-0.08837512880563736,
-0.4028087556362152,
0.14421327412128448,
0.4951351583003998,
-0.30078160762786865,
-0.4889836013317108,
-0.6739278435707092,
0.04845118895173073,
-0.4087089002132416,
0.9777729511260986,
0.001108300406485796,
0.030092542991042137,
0.007220069412142038,
-0.09235179424285889,
-0.6864046454429626,
-0.7110695242881775,
-0.32014086842536926,
0.06456601619720459,
0.32641956210136414,
0.27539461851119995,
0.3005227744579315,
0.5306565165519714,
0.746370792388916,
0.16620418429374695,
-0.24139884114265442,
-0.20771218836307526,
-0.45659151673316956,
0.19107182323932648,
-0.01835591346025467,
-0.3482529819011688,
-0.4850151538848877,
-0.00834864005446434,
0.35576289892196655,
0.15731514990329742,
-0.19077837467193604,
0.3984009027481079,
-0.2495901882648468,
0.6292600631713867,
-1.0678412914276123,
-0.35663291811943054,
-1.0341914892196655,
0.013552414253354073,
-0.5408288240432739,
0.01561665441840887,
-0.4211336672306061,
-0.09758472442626953,
-0.41576001048088074,
-0.06821902841329575,
-0.012522642500698566,
0.16207070648670197,
0.5440803170204163,
0.08959275484085083,
-0.1921772062778473,
-0.21657679975032806,
-0.31573978066444397,
0.6706176400184631,
-0.8353179693222046,
0.035701967775821686,
0.1015487015247345,
0.2981660068035126,
-0.28582102060317993,
-0.32249435782432556,
-0.3089655935764313,
-0.5199312567710876,
0.13882972300052643,
-0.22018222510814667,
-0.42449480295181274,
0.20699386298656464,
0.7717034816741943,
0.32323628664016724,
-0.45084935426712036,
0.274664044380188,
-0.4733819365501404,
0.04112965241074562,
0.6592579483985901,
0.2917870283126831,
0.4554876387119293,
-0.19995008409023285,
-0.6247913837432861,
-0.010930449701845646,
-1.0530465841293335,
0.12501883506774902,
0.7491792440414429,
0.08217071741819382,
-0.11811021715402603,
0.4756680130958557,
-0.12039858102798462,
0.7740593552589417,
-0.14530201256275177,
-0.17242032289505005,
-0.0029547472950071096,
-0.2974400818347931,
-0.21707145869731903,
0.1311245560646057,
0.7538986802101135,
0.546530544757843,
0.1998218595981598,
-0.5061512589454651,
-0.41575950384140015,
-0.10949984192848206,
0.5637781620025635,
-1.053210735321045,
-0.18189559876918793,
0.16593486070632935,
-0.22655810415744781,
-0.7537052631378174,
0.17813529074192047,
-0.7824645638465881,
-0.7111034989356995,
0.6099770069122314,
0.31114986538887024,
-0.18730413913726807,
-0.10036807507276535,
0.14558817446231842,
-0.33651816844940186,
0.37693652510643005,
-0.10105520486831665,
-0.8414635062217712,
0.7795981764793396,
0.7913143038749695,
0.8821007609367371,
-0.4428091049194336,
-0.1679021716117859,
-0.8198508620262146,
0.19679445028305054,
-0.20349819958209991,
0.6949554085731506,
-0.46014440059661865,
-0.6245828866958618,
-0.19016896188259125,
-0.29375261068344116,
-0.15754620730876923,
-0.6598348021507263,
0.6291092038154602,
-0.4119046926498413,
-0.6194750666618347,
-0.15213710069656372,
-0.6134357452392578,
0.08877561241388321,
0.486822247505188,
-0.7199430465698242,
0.7717911601066589,
-0.2423461526632309,
-0.6998220682144165,
0.06921745091676712,
-0.6128749847412109,
-0.6719008088111877,
0.05946272239089012,
-0.06144394725561142,
-0.39734217524528503,
0.594897985458374,
0.19978322088718414,
0.2919871509075165,
-0.277394562959671,
0.16479553282260895,
-0.4586296081542969,
-0.6937023997306824,
0.4145459234714508,
-0.31998538970947266,
0.6748326420783997,
0.3005959391593933,
-0.5182889103889465,
-0.023965628817677498,
-0.6602855920791626,
-0.07000073045492172,
0.36537879705429077,
-0.12277789413928986,
-0.2147902399301529,
0.22861820459365845,
-0.14263159036636353,
-0.18848201632499695,
0.25403594970703125,
-0.8122200965881348,
0.5792696475982666,
-0.2459125518798828,
0.6871297955513,
0.6873529553413391,
0.11139336973428726,
0.022617505863308907,
-0.09124642610549927,
0.6394736170768738,
-0.24345888197422028,
0.3886006772518158,
-0.38792893290519714,
-0.24816572666168213,
-0.29875683784484863,
-0.10662756860256195,
0.2154102325439453,
0.6925827264785767,
-0.16563940048217773,
0.1183975413441658,
-0.0415976382791996,
-0.5975456237792969,
-0.3308033347129822,
0.45765531063079834,
0.5678810477256775,
0.2766036093235016,
0.33934485912323,
-0.4869776964187622,
-0.39596691727638245,
-0.7702218890190125,
-0.7546237707138062,
-0.33475175499916077,
0.220180943608284,
0.2846440076828003,
0.48593437671661377,
0.06635326892137527,
0.5595253705978394,
-0.5618886947631836,
-0.04459734261035919,
-0.3609975278377533,
-0.20339983701705933,
0.14920340478420258,
0.45978495478630066,
0.8464959263801575,
-0.1703656017780304,
-0.14185500144958496,
-0.3402715027332306,
-0.622085452079773,
-0.25465670228004456,
0.013391963206231594,
0.2546239197254181,
0.029227500781416893,
0.7457501292228699,
-0.5106903910636902,
0.4848339259624481,
0.4350232183933258,
-0.3795734643936157,
0.8516905307769775,
-0.0572643056511879,
0.17263196408748627,
-0.5621563792228699,
-0.052261918783187866,
0.001791201764717698,
-0.03249458596110344,
-0.6922085881233215,
0.4831388592720032,
0.2549818754196167,
-0.15943489968776703,
-0.6195972561836243,
0.5425258874893188,
-0.29121702909469604,
-0.2049134075641632,
-0.28384512662887573,
-0.0446435809135437,
0.06668633222579956,
0.1449660360813141,
-0.5072520971298218,
0.8327215909957886,
0.5119132995605469,
-0.10231906175613403,
0.4661811292171478,
-0.3423752188682556,
-0.4936918318271637,
0.28840577602386475,
-0.9323171973228455,
0.39224112033843994,
0.251547247171402,
0.1450299173593521,
-1.055468201637268,
0.18938925862312317,
0.1894271820783615,
-0.28709036111831665,
0.4723053574562073,
-0.3664279878139496,
-0.8147938847541809,
-0.1770591139793396,
-0.7347530126571655,
0.2801518738269806,
0.4776736795902252,
-0.5170969367027283,
0.22681818902492523,
0.2991136908531189,
0.06668340414762497,
-0.8262847661972046,
-0.44743114709854126,
0.5420867800712585,
-0.6598061323165894,
-0.4173283576965332,
0.31370192766189575,
-0.13941363990306854,
-0.5877180695533752,
-0.2541770935058594,
-0.3948018550872803,
0.22844050824642181,
0.7807110548019409,
0.37800997495651245,
0.3341946601867676,
0.07116933166980743,
-0.4185415208339691,
-0.25611817836761475,
0.10959585756063461,
0.4276784062385559,
-0.09703584015369415,
0.5546408891677856,
-0.129011332988739,
-0.44624340534210205,
-0.06892307102680206,
0.08943793922662735,
0.5917866826057434,
-0.24717673659324646,
0.5676100850105286,
0.3141666054725647,
-0.13732396066188812,
-0.05490320920944214,
-0.8366928696632385,
-0.12801049649715424,
-0.46887972950935364,
0.45409661531448364,
-0.6315706372261047,
-0.7712767124176025,
0.5161640644073486,
-0.0598236583173275,
0.16974878311157227,
0.03984332084655762,
0.24348177015781403,
-0.0914427861571312,
0.8314371705055237,
0.6349335312843323,
-0.6003295183181763,
0.5230826735496521,
0.007418209221214056,
0.3539915382862091,
-0.8637133240699768,
-0.09700804948806763,
-0.5020625591278076,
-0.403869092464447,
-0.5642834305763245,
-0.1712244153022766,
0.05337660759687424,
0.6209676265716553,
-0.24922244250774384,
0.4649536609649658,
-0.2701810598373413,
0.7240474820137024,
0.07305872440338135,
-0.09608738124370575,
0.2991947531700134,
-0.08592551201581955,
-0.31242790818214417,
0.2661339044570923,
-0.6217153668403625,
-0.38118302822113037,
1.4382272958755493,
0.46221300959587097,
1.0669279098510742,
0.0969887226819992,
0.8768564462661743,
0.4124336242675781,
0.2897050976753235,
-0.548290491104126,
0.714749276638031,
-0.055636949837207794,
-0.5814050436019897,
0.07424362748861313,
-0.25944623351097107,
-0.729663610458374,
0.1198526918888092,
0.06328987330198288,
-1.2136040925979614,
-0.3653925955295563,
-0.07409236580133438,
-0.27548301219940186,
0.6533309817314148,
-0.7525545358657837,
1.0517077445983887,
-0.6788433790206909,
-0.4461275637149811,
-0.27656829357147217,
-0.4756581485271454,
0.485645055770874,
-0.0074056838639080524,
0.27231794595718384,
-0.3348701000213623,
0.10413026064634323,
0.6869300007820129,
-0.3036925792694092,
0.7970501780509949,
-0.3512509763240814,
0.10718314349651337,
0.10785697400569916,
0.27657708525657654,
0.584587812423706,
0.2320016771554947,
0.07060934603214264,
0.292636513710022,
0.018804704770445824,
-0.4522191286087036,
-0.5833051204681396,
0.9574244618415833,
-0.5996453166007996,
-1.0987164974212646,
-0.3738018870353699,
-0.476406991481781,
-0.16860131919384003,
-0.05562033876776695,
-0.028685927391052246,
0.30744364857673645,
-0.19766761362552643,
0.022406497970223427,
0.6816439032554626,
-0.2835727334022522,
0.6623883247375488,
0.5757337808609009,
-0.3344593942165375,
-0.30162835121154785,
0.7447934746742249,
0.0822027325630188,
0.3084045946598053,
0.13519784808158875,
-0.019640188664197922,
0.06766792386770248,
-1.0452196598052979,
-0.6123836040496826,
0.0012491334928199649,
-0.5141016840934753,
-0.3912540674209595,
-0.2851189374923706,
-0.24871784448623657,
-0.34610414505004883,
-0.07712966203689575,
-0.340031236410141,
-0.41166526079177856,
0.24219538271427155,
-0.3469904661178589,
0.6097313761711121,
0.732666552066803,
0.20789383351802826,
0.3272102475166321,
-0.5871110558509827,
0.18516649305820465,
-0.06730151176452637,
0.3440348207950592,
-0.0490536093711853,
-0.4715593755245209,
-0.2176501601934433,
-0.4538709819316864,
-0.4820346236228943,
-1.1109639406204224,
0.04653085023164749,
-0.1479531079530716,
0.6841624975204468,
0.3506357967853546,
0.005904980935156345,
0.7006141543388367,
-0.5416474938392639,
0.6973961591720581,
0.19900284707546234,
-0.9164888858795166,
0.7600984573364258,
-0.08332530409097672,
0.17344516515731812,
0.670089840888977,
0.02719666063785553,
-0.2717819809913635,
-0.44979169964790344,
-0.6944816708564758,
-0.8311064839363098,
0.3615204095840454,
0.09025975316762924,
0.18458735942840576,
0.020183948799967766,
0.5472347140312195,
-0.0646732747554779,
0.2628021538257599,
-0.6843795776367188,
-0.4896855056285858,
0.0452502965927124,
0.2231738269329071,
-0.09461130201816559,
-0.2336241751909256,
-0.17256441712379456,
-0.27343061566352844,
0.24591146409511566,
0.2486765831708908,
-0.16186273097991943,
-0.16351331770420074,
-0.40420660376548767,
0.1891171634197235,
0.45073121786117554,
0.592170000076294,
0.5413089990615845,
-0.43520596623420715,
0.14398972690105438,
0.39256563782691956,
-0.728298544883728,
0.18274074792861938,
0.20269423723220825,
-0.2557266056537628,
-0.17682293057441711,
0.2706872820854187,
0.8212494254112244,
0.11807390302419662,
-1.0348237752914429,
0.39355286955833435,
-0.21366125345230103,
0.002062750980257988,
-0.0855671837925911,
0.4171695411205292,
-0.10692546516656876,
0.13193881511688232,
0.31020355224609375,
-0.13578683137893677,
0.051081594079732895,
-0.5495730042457581,
0.06517898291349411,
0.7959282398223877,
-0.2587374448776245,
-0.19707879424095154,
0.5533869862556458,
0.03928178548812866,
-0.3317989706993103,
0.4895622730255127,
-0.16657039523124695,
-0.4793865978717804,
0.7377684712409973,
0.575438916683197,
1.0048764944076538,
-0.13120070099830627,
-0.2672760486602783,
0.2459477186203003,
0.7802183032035828,
0.09298787266016006,
0.022047793492674828,
-0.26156511902809143,
-0.5400258898735046,
-0.33234649896621704,
-0.6175447702407837,
-0.5509546399116516,
0.34822946786880493,
-0.6781963109970093,
0.1538703292608261,
-0.7928333878517151,
-0.12633612751960754,
-0.25150835514068604,
0.20945821702480316,
-0.42067664861679077,
-0.2136078029870987,
0.3173397183418274,
1.2896298170089722,
-0.6359502673149109,
0.9456906914710999,
0.6356396675109863,
-0.06253717839717865,
-0.4674852192401886,
-0.06040380150079727,
0.1289205104112625,
-0.671978771686554,
0.6220569610595703,
0.32427191734313965,
-0.08945643156766891,
-0.3969416320323944,
-0.517325758934021,
-0.5664267539978027,
0.863818883895874,
0.38083237409591675,
-1.0279427766799927,
0.2508470416069031,
0.20003241300582886,
0.12162990123033524,
-0.2830332815647125,
0.16501080989837646,
1.069264531135559,
0.4363982677459717,
-0.2794945538043976,
-0.8043079972267151,
0.0598892942070961,
-0.3184385895729065,
-0.1024584174156189,
0.25175368785858154,
-0.49228715896606445,
0.5201048851013184,
-0.4974808096885681,
0.11292869597673416,
0.07306136190891266,
0.17240728437900543,
0.7455592751502991,
0.2789781987667084,
0.42282137274742126,
0.9334065914154053,
0.4020492136478424,
-0.14800778031349182,
1.1618096828460693,
-0.6619048118591309,
0.06320500373840332,
1.0310372114181519,
-0.4063440263271332,
0.9792588353157043,
0.7871993780136108,
-0.09892169386148453,
0.27370667457580566,
0.5112419128417969,
-0.3691697120666504,
0.563506007194519,
0.8783535361289978,
-0.3808896839618683,
0.16616174578666687,
0.2731595039367676,
-0.23158757388591766,
0.18883132934570312,
0.3239760398864746,
-0.015539386309683323,
-0.2692037522792816,
0.19889885187149048,
0.4964948296546936,
-0.1754312664270401,
-0.5065241456031799,
0.8184178471565247,
0.10797874629497528,
-0.4473504424095154,
0.5736845135688782,
0.38704773783683777,
0.9237272143363953,
-0.5496069192886353,
0.26151928305625916,
-0.32528528571128845,
0.13465259969234467,
-0.16269050538539886,
-0.6887531876564026,
0.04653370752930641,
0.6300795674324036,
0.04477003216743469,
-0.06689418107271194,
0.9135807156562805,
0.24440225958824158,
-0.3087664246559143,
0.4270403981208801,
0.3306618630886078,
0.14824776351451874,
-0.07111173868179321,
-0.6409098505973816,
0.7067721486091614,
-0.2293788343667984,
-0.43907636404037476,
0.8683634400367737,
-0.14563731849193573,
0.11616366356611252,
0.5795856714248657,
0.48455870151519775,
0.21385632455348969,
0.17802971601486206,
0.04223513975739479,
0.9477724432945251,
-0.7808712124824524,
-0.007537974510341883,
-1.472673773765564,
0.1888536810874939,
-0.16214978694915771,
-0.19592976570129395,
0.9489169716835022,
0.7802888751029968,
0.8763526082038879,
0.15118490159511566,
0.7885770797729492,
-0.03058619797229767,
-0.12409664690494537,
-0.584678053855896,
0.7336742877960205,
-0.20298318564891815,
0.757794976234436,
-0.4624098241329193,
-0.7641320824623108,
-0.09932111948728561,
0.3364901840686798,
-0.4214625656604767,
-0.15158453583717346,
0.49369001388549805,
0.7430059313774109,
0.24671871960163116,
-0.1866365522146225,
0.2506171464920044,
0.13338422775268555,
0.5186491012573242,
0.5826300382614136,
0.9571004509925842,
-0.4415440261363983,
0.5980046987533569,
-0.26137784123420715,
-0.1543559730052948,
-0.011532668024301529,
-1.0841282606124878,
-1.043721318244934,
0.059433259069919586,
-0.3823971748352051,
-0.30889469385147095,
0.5942482948303223,
0.44360461831092834,
0.5394399166107178,
-0.6222193241119385,
-0.5666676759719849,
0.01864311844110489,
0.19002610445022583,
-0.21249890327453613,
-0.18505796790122986,
0.03641669079661369,
-0.5404461622238159,
-0.2955455482006073,
0.6548073887825012,
0.5646318793296814,
-0.22693614661693573,
-0.3050844669342041,
0.07147584110498428,
0.21569667756557465,
0.12623299658298492,
0.3676851689815521,
0.29419001936912537,
-0.6723294258117676,
-0.22166723012924194,
-0.022292165085673332,
-0.059442952275276184,
0.039372555911540985,
0.9786779284477234,
-0.7755038142204285,
0.28584790229797363,
0.22835683822631836,
0.7167825698852539,
0.5168787240982056,
-0.023092878982424736,
0.35287711024284363,
-0.6718781590461731,
0.08136571943759918,
-0.03398206830024719,
0.4139368236064911,
0.04021036624908447,
-0.10628057271242142,
0.42790159583091736,
0.21359305083751678,
-0.32068055868148804,
-1.2798006534576416,
0.15194879472255707,
-0.8249058127403259,
-0.5020210146903992,
1.0518923997879028,
-0.3680407404899597,
-0.34720727801322937,
0.1795206516981125,
-0.006405373103916645,
-0.30878424644470215,
-0.2922912538051605,
0.7755208015441895,
0.8424497842788696,
-0.044410139322280884,
-0.2563338577747345,
-0.8928937911987305,
0.40257012844085693,
0.24327236413955688,
-0.8576107025146484,
0.2971141040325165,
0.15527310967445374,
0.536514163017273,
-0.1846892237663269,
0.21365907788276672,
-0.3504636585712433,
0.2831558585166931,
-0.07656390964984894,
-0.05063887685537338,
-0.24292416870594025,
-0.2794921100139618,
-0.4073459208011627,
0.39612874388694763,
0.29489684104919434,
-0.1140979751944542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09321v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09321v1
|
JailbreakEval: An Integrated Toolkit for Evaluating Jailbreak Attempts Against Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T16:59:43 | 2024-06-13T16:59:43 |
Delong Ran, Jinyuan Liu, Yichen Gong, Jingyi Zheng, Xinlei He, Tianshuo Cong, Anyu Wang
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Jailbreak attacks aim to induce Large Language Models (LLMs) to generate
harmful responses for forbidden instructions, presenting severe misuse threats
to LLMs. Up to now, research into jailbreak attacks and defenses is emerging,
however, there is (surprisingly) no consensus on how to evaluate whether a
jailbreak attempt is successful. In other words, the methods to assess the
harmfulness of an LLM's response are varied, such as manual annotation or
prompting GPT-4 in specific ways. Each approach has its own set of strengths
and weaknesses, impacting their alignment with human values, as well as the
time and financial cost. This diversity in evaluation presents challenges for
researchers in choosing suitable evaluation methods and conducting fair
comparisons across different jailbreak attacks and defenses. In this paper, we
conduct a comprehensive analysis of jailbreak evaluation methodologies, drawing
from nearly ninety jailbreak research released between May 2023 and April 2024.
Our study introduces a systematic taxonomy of jailbreak evaluators, offering
in-depth insights into their strengths and weaknesses, along with the current
status of their adaptation. Moreover, to facilitate subsequent research, we
propose JailbreakEval, a user-friendly toolkit focusing on the evaluation of
jailbreak attempts. It includes various well-known evaluators out-of-the-box,
so that users can obtain evaluation results with only a single command.
JailbreakEval also allows users to customize their own evaluation workflow in a
unified framework with the ease of development and comparison. In summary, we
regard JailbreakEval to be a catalyst that simplifies the evaluation process in
jailbreak research and fosters an inclusive standard for jailbreak evaluation
within the community.
|
[
-0.24038252234458923,
-0.7909432649612427,
0.35941794514656067,
0.4736383557319641,
-0.21855255961418152,
0.4716290831565857,
-0.2725042700767517,
-0.48860451579093933,
0.22472365200519562,
0.2999945878982544,
-0.3294949233531952,
-0.41287365555763245,
-0.5052419900894165,
0.0179205983877182,
-0.3647710978984833,
1.1062371730804443,
-0.06405258923768997,
0.03017214499413967,
0.06183719262480736,
-0.12093812972307205,
-0.8979796767234802,
-0.45641085505485535,
-0.09695176780223846,
0.031423844397068024,
0.19200950860977173,
0.31692662835121155,
0.5297276973724365,
0.11446509510278702,
0.8599433302879333,
0.23136736452579498,
-0.2705020308494568,
-0.32578328251838684,
-0.4180567264556885,
0.17560023069381714,
-0.18977832794189453,
-0.19612941145896912,
-0.3542729914188385,
0.044358666986227036,
-0.04101374000310898,
0.24188153445720673,
-0.3250361680984497,
0.30330461263656616,
-0.07477417588233948,
0.7567805647850037,
-0.8785527944564819,
-0.5590524077415466,
-0.7148740887641907,
0.04507044330239296,
-0.46824532747268677,
0.212919682264328,
-0.40912771224975586,
-0.617362916469574,
-0.01991058513522148,
0.13955222070217133,
-0.16036315262317657,
-0.144555926322937,
0.10721737146377563,
-0.11507431417703629,
-0.09376690536737442,
-0.44816023111343384,
-0.3761485815048218,
0.6084807515144348,
-0.9596300721168518,
0.144628643989563,
0.18491238355636597,
0.471854031085968,
-0.3163435161113739,
-0.48696374893188477,
-0.09601399302482605,
-0.7449838519096375,
0.2435668408870697,
-0.06026143953204155,
-0.21161368489265442,
0.10368569195270538,
0.20525068044662476,
0.34523019194602966,
-0.4977587163448334,
0.12781278789043427,
-0.5959989428520203,
-0.24288228154182434,
0.6712966561317444,
0.09958590567111969,
0.49676281213760376,
-0.43731823563575745,
-0.42117708921432495,
0.26725271344184875,
-0.8607906699180603,
-0.04569733887910843,
0.6633918285369873,
0.16357532143592834,
-0.16340243816375732,
0.5756901502609253,
0.028416207060217857,
0.6106343269348145,
-0.06428083777427673,
-0.11389034986495972,
0.32597780227661133,
-0.35889139771461487,
-0.08674971014261246,
0.14834517240524292,
0.975895345211029,
0.4362080991268158,
0.09480919688940048,
-0.44364404678344727,
-0.21597619354724884,
-0.18308071792125702,
0.6038497090339661,
-0.9964579343795776,
-0.1087946891784668,
0.3863546550273895,
-0.3905264735221863,
-0.7717912197113037,
0.042953986674547195,
-0.9428115487098694,
-0.8795939683914185,
0.4781266152858734,
0.2581796646118164,
-0.4570683240890503,
-0.15948352217674255,
-0.06881002336740494,
-0.21983349323272705,
0.17998076975345612,
0.2793017029762268,
-0.7313317656517029,
0.4326123893260956,
0.6097260117530823,
0.9614716172218323,
-0.21335239708423615,
-0.36860886216163635,
-0.5495831370353699,
-0.17397825419902802,
-0.08775880932807922,
0.49067768454551697,
-0.42707279324531555,
-0.5114465951919556,
-0.2666754722595215,
-0.29149535298347473,
0.06667936593294144,
-0.5825088024139404,
0.6324184536933899,
-0.5139639973640442,
-0.41652289032936096,
-0.02811652608215809,
-0.4122980535030365,
-0.025588050484657288,
0.34324178099632263,
-0.7611575126647949,
0.5963510274887085,
0.0749811977148056,
-1.0426762104034424,
0.25212305784225464,
-0.7136120200157166,
-0.5376187562942505,
0.19616152346134186,
0.22898776829242706,
-0.27127015590667725,
0.34687450528144836,
0.17613302171230316,
0.23162686824798584,
-0.3669610321521759,
0.4700238108634949,
-0.5373173952102661,
-0.3520856201648712,
0.19109798967838287,
-0.34663575887680054,
0.8837785720825195,
0.47163110971450806,
-0.6045969128608704,
0.21570299565792084,
-0.5226975083351135,
-0.06773264706134796,
0.269809752702713,
-0.27549704909324646,
-0.40424495935440063,
0.1404070407152176,
0.1289454847574234,
-0.023625463247299194,
0.24022571742534637,
-0.7687948942184448,
0.3441694974899292,
-0.5139240622520447,
0.7581858038902283,
0.7943956255912781,
-0.03871173784136772,
0.17704187333583832,
0.21918846666812897,
0.7008777260780334,
-0.3858444094657898,
0.5443586111068726,
-0.08705969154834747,
-0.13693523406982422,
-0.07572529464960098,
0.0028726716991513968,
0.21169714629650116,
0.7595996856689453,
-0.05052006244659424,
0.1428786963224411,
0.05992336571216583,
-0.9508838653564453,
-0.562691867351532,
0.4534080922603607,
0.5364641547203064,
0.3190532624721527,
0.35639628767967224,
-0.4232499301433563,
-0.668262779712677,
-0.7090345621109009,
-0.6777245402336121,
-0.41453617811203003,
0.24494963884353638,
0.06711513549089432,
0.49482980370521545,
-0.20117954909801483,
0.6245560050010681,
-0.11233364045619965,
-0.02818080596625805,
-0.5924808382987976,
-0.09629353880882263,
0.18836238980293274,
0.3163672387599945,
0.7136836647987366,
-0.5039926171302795,
-0.2620508074760437,
-0.10761360079050064,
-0.7325422763824463,
-0.2445528209209442,
0.11213675886392593,
0.3816426694393158,
-0.23816752433776855,
0.42481672763824463,
-0.38117754459381104,
0.4158512055873871,
0.5276503562927246,
-0.47626131772994995,
0.9707934856414795,
0.13737863302230835,
0.2901223301887512,
-0.7515802979469299,
-0.0572606585919857,
-0.18394188582897186,
-0.14284905791282654,
-0.5922278165817261,
0.5439422130584717,
0.23152491450309753,
0.025588229298591614,
-0.6063752174377441,
0.36932507157325745,
-0.22580315172672272,
0.03208976984024048,
-0.08659867197275162,
0.1797732561826706,
-0.2693631052970886,
-0.13750939071178436,
-0.5687991380691528,
0.8841837644577026,
0.1589522808790207,
0.18729454278945923,
0.5804051160812378,
0.06009027734398842,
-0.4595586359500885,
0.3393673598766327,
-0.8695154786109924,
0.38836848735809326,
0.24975889921188354,
-0.034624192863702774,
-0.8422453999519348,
-0.1782912015914917,
0.11405371874570847,
-0.3645240366458893,
0.11051768064498901,
-0.3990322947502136,
-0.31852391362190247,
-0.4618500769138336,
-0.7811096906661987,
0.3108352720737457,
0.2731286585330963,
-0.4979032576084137,
0.20668259263038635,
0.39798060059547424,
-0.2145722657442093,
-0.699235737323761,
-0.4572129249572754,
0.6641355156898499,
-0.5688644051551819,
-0.7182060480117798,
0.11057360470294952,
-0.27959850430488586,
-0.6423777341842651,
-0.22656196355819702,
-0.20366939902305603,
0.14275361597537994,
0.5286961197853088,
0.42242130637168884,
0.4203575849533081,
0.1079336628317833,
-0.4070873260498047,
-0.02767559140920639,
0.1795269101858139,
0.29782310128211975,
0.0065388926304876804,
0.43587538599967957,
-0.5213636159896851,
-0.3798768222332001,
-0.10222876816987991,
0.11401742696762085,
0.6793106198310852,
-0.305286169052124,
0.5307627320289612,
0.20285362005233765,
0.09438251703977585,
-0.0009171923738904297,
-0.7540104985237122,
0.12293282896280289,
-0.44073399901390076,
0.4958503246307373,
-0.40533310174942017,
-0.983224093914032,
0.46702659130096436,
-0.2091798633337021,
0.20029591023921967,
-0.0015290890587493777,
0.6515818238258362,
0.16037380695343018,
0.7593291401863098,
0.4464232921600342,
-0.40356671810150146,
0.28748518228530884,
0.18716326355934143,
0.29425811767578125,
-0.8241809010505676,
-0.3262880742549896,
-0.47396984696388245,
-0.18157845735549927,
-0.2089441865682602,
0.028208164498209953,
0.08981728553771973,
0.38165196776390076,
-0.18293067812919617,
0.6374495029449463,
-0.4374561905860901,
0.5899727940559387,
-0.050195369869470596,
-0.02106013335287571,
0.31352367997169495,
-0.40273189544677734,
-0.0923655554652214,
0.02718997932970524,
-0.23365139961242676,
-0.5193861722946167,
1.3782954216003418,
0.47387588024139404,
0.9448697566986084,
0.3081792891025543,
0.9946107268333435,
0.6263712048530579,
0.6125909090042114,
-0.8930141925811768,
0.4411243796348572,
0.1706876903772354,
-0.6969529986381531,
0.053558509796857834,
-0.2807087004184723,
-0.7067238092422485,
0.23966984450817108,
0.2423451989889145,
-1.2134511470794678,
-0.185702845454216,
0.03049713745713234,
-0.3257315456867218,
0.2981208562850952,
-0.9116514325141907,
1.068839430809021,
-0.6332495808601379,
-0.3465573489665985,
-0.25112152099609375,
-0.7872122526168823,
0.7310134768486023,
-0.3657695949077606,
0.627338171005249,
-0.14518508315086365,
0.2972496449947357,
0.8255136013031006,
-0.7898645997047424,
0.6375856995582581,
-0.5664380788803101,
0.14756609499454498,
0.21920563280582428,
0.47131723165512085,
0.3961941599845886,
0.1824546754360199,
-0.1724826991558075,
0.044277679175138474,
0.08900302648544312,
-0.04576440900564194,
-0.42590731382369995,
0.7684282660484314,
-0.5994595885276794,
-0.7511498332023621,
-0.1413700133562088,
-0.4531841278076172,
-0.149593785405159,
0.14030402898788452,
0.06308677792549133,
0.159595787525177,
-0.4931015968322754,
-0.05940677598118782,
0.2888000011444092,
-0.29090434312820435,
0.37341371178627014,
0.19818145036697388,
-0.5130127668380737,
-0.6280061602592468,
0.5111892819404602,
-0.16014203429222107,
0.17961589992046356,
-0.17811588943004608,
0.2953775227069855,
0.0027902373112738132,
-1.0631458759307861,
-0.4964941143989563,
-0.060178257524967194,
-0.5691258907318115,
-0.388094425201416,
-0.29996180534362793,
-0.19909410178661346,
-0.3295741081237793,
-0.3194594383239746,
-0.46930715441703796,
-0.3627067804336548,
0.3409025967121124,
-0.35585418343544006,
0.4865705966949463,
0.6782359480857849,
-0.038922060281038284,
0.259750634431839,
-0.7298616766929626,
0.307301789522171,
-0.001008361461572349,
0.1821179986000061,
0.09512375295162201,
-0.5799155235290527,
-0.12672846019268036,
-0.32217398285865784,
-0.3068654537200928,
-1.2952628135681152,
0.27142342925071716,
-0.006688120774924755,
0.4365592896938324,
0.3063593804836273,
0.06855299323797226,
0.7335168123245239,
-0.6364539265632629,
0.5907362103462219,
0.38940536975860596,
-1.0572147369384766,
0.9956414699554443,
-0.07549965381622314,
-0.09809679538011551,
1.1195124387741089,
-0.004722933750599623,
-0.41792258620262146,
-0.5264575481414795,
-0.29906466603279114,
-1.0747274160385132,
0.5136595964431763,
0.1450859159231186,
0.2928426265716553,
0.07549630105495453,
0.338622123003006,
0.21755322813987732,
0.1910838931798935,
-0.70159912109375,
-0.02396974340081215,
-0.2919263243675232,
0.02478763461112976,
0.28613221645355225,
-0.2391253560781479,
-0.12377636134624481,
-0.3330652713775635,
0.3538694679737091,
0.32130667567253113,
-0.22320474684238434,
-0.03988608345389366,
-0.5137795209884644,
0.16933874785900116,
0.6359109282493591,
0.11147621273994446,
0.7451570630073547,
-0.47806254029273987,
-0.02588603086769581,
0.24439889192581177,
-0.9177984595298767,
0.4790092408657074,
0.1939891129732132,
-0.11455561220645905,
-0.25256678462028503,
0.4374944269657135,
0.6189624667167664,
0.019230514764785767,
-1.0018192529678345,
0.8541742563247681,
-0.17017629742622375,
0.02404288575053215,
-0.22490902245044708,
0.11609818786382675,
-0.06499045342206955,
0.279937744140625,
0.22263984382152557,
0.0940832868218422,
0.3540288507938385,
-0.5767019987106323,
0.16829974949359894,
0.4486367404460907,
-0.5461525917053223,
-0.3411302864551544,
0.5720691680908203,
0.1771756410598755,
-0.4410456120967865,
0.6525825262069702,
-0.1767551302909851,
-0.5772138833999634,
0.531795859336853,
0.69691401720047,
1.2289537191390991,
-0.4331556260585785,
0.13687999546527863,
0.1436455100774765,
0.7890976667404175,
0.17061258852481842,
0.1606249362230301,
-0.12302651256322861,
-0.45391911268234253,
-0.5744631290435791,
-0.7755413055419922,
-0.3433515131473541,
0.2049534022808075,
-0.651682436466217,
0.1773367077112198,
-0.7371885180473328,
-0.21769556403160095,
0.007062682881951332,
-0.24132846295833588,
-0.28064870834350586,
-0.2609211504459381,
0.025113312527537346,
1.462918758392334,
-0.7050434350967407,
0.6386644244194031,
0.7141503691673279,
-0.19174334406852722,
-0.6744619607925415,
-0.06017010658979416,
0.4649251699447632,
-0.602237343788147,
0.5706831216812134,
0.4201478660106659,
-0.13160055875778198,
-0.38856080174446106,
-0.5813385844230652,
-0.3412958085536957,
0.6894423365592957,
0.37795525789260864,
-0.6630184650421143,
0.11339300125837326,
-0.10764821618795395,
0.23302610218524933,
-0.08548293262720108,
0.2855072319507599,
1.0695351362228394,
0.5770694613456726,
-0.05137668550014496,
-1.0253058671951294,
0.2042711228132248,
-0.4725230038166046,
-0.1423620581626892,
0.4874424338340759,
-0.4041774868965149,
0.3139205276966095,
-0.7378803491592407,
0.21379108726978302,
0.26579517126083374,
0.10984431952238083,
0.46942996978759766,
0.24989251792430878,
0.3300071358680725,
0.6049398183822632,
0.4013185203075409,
0.010392874479293823,
0.9599250555038452,
-0.12962114810943604,
0.2771713137626648,
1.0412185192108154,
-0.27135103940963745,
0.7552109956741333,
0.6653517484664917,
-0.4069555699825287,
0.42928043007850647,
0.48639363050460815,
-0.2848474383354187,
0.7427756786346436,
0.5098791718482971,
-0.24166715145111084,
0.16565537452697754,
0.2734763026237488,
-0.18208757042884827,
0.3833077549934387,
0.34142422676086426,
-0.09815449267625809,
-0.40012267231941223,
0.33601680397987366,
0.3443175256252289,
-0.1047976166009903,
-0.3285425007343292,
0.7279587984085083,
0.17343153059482574,
-0.34686601161956787,
0.43712079524993896,
0.36147788166999817,
0.6778478026390076,
-0.724223792552948,
0.2587669789791107,
-0.1645546406507492,
0.07271280884742737,
-0.4745404124259949,
-0.8073975443840027,
0.39612090587615967,
0.655445396900177,
0.1767617166042328,
0.23487921059131622,
0.8664644360542297,
0.39258337020874023,
-0.10397832840681076,
0.680911123752594,
0.2998434603214264,
0.24710972607135773,
-0.18144647777080536,
-0.8771143555641174,
0.4942057430744171,
0.13156934082508087,
-0.5381860733032227,
0.4708491265773773,
-0.12413296848535538,
-0.04678821936249733,
0.546312689781189,
0.5496866106987,
0.28956449031829834,
0.004548982251435518,
0.12759730219841003,
1.0415815114974976,
-0.7010824680328369,
-0.18404972553253174,
-1.422595739364624,
0.44680002331733704,
-0.14763125777244568,
-0.2001464068889618,
0.9627202153205872,
0.6205875873565674,
0.5175791382789612,
0.24475662410259247,
1.0010812282562256,
-0.5438987612724304,
0.11594343185424805,
-0.36771202087402344,
0.6718748807907104,
-0.19567623734474182,
0.7164174914360046,
-0.7880485653877258,
-0.8613463640213013,
-0.271524041891098,
0.38826999068260193,
-0.5477331876754761,
-0.08407273143529892,
0.4556523859500885,
0.522228479385376,
0.033493522554636,
0.16752217710018158,
0.03060099110007286,
0.2225940227508545,
0.4683080315589905,
0.5173071622848511,
1.145821213722229,
-0.18134112656116486,
0.6292493939399719,
-0.19704201817512512,
-0.4904124438762665,
-0.13902777433395386,
-0.766360342502594,
-0.9771891236305237,
0.015019341371953487,
0.05437658727169037,
-0.4247603714466095,
0.43919411301612854,
0.8483685851097107,
0.46410858631134033,
-0.7229263782501221,
-0.4481487274169922,
-0.10213915258646011,
0.07696209847927094,
0.057861629873514175,
-0.21848459541797638,
0.09670842438936234,
-0.38934576511383057,
-0.05489269271492958,
0.8463594913482666,
0.5617282390594482,
-0.45387589931488037,
-0.22708569467067719,
-0.12886536121368408,
0.21736003458499908,
-0.045069750398397446,
0.562373161315918,
0.26774322986602783,
-0.5134361386299133,
-0.11180566996335983,
-0.19079886376857758,
0.03239533677697182,
0.07688768953084946,
0.7707202434539795,
-0.656283974647522,
0.5921162366867065,
0.305942177772522,
0.7003979086875916,
0.368931382894516,
-0.1291341483592987,
0.32326599955558777,
-0.5518014430999756,
0.16689807176589966,
0.24511422216892242,
0.301869660615921,
0.2840029299259186,
-0.2232418805360794,
0.5093241930007935,
0.0260746069252491,
-0.5709357261657715,
-1.0335278511047363,
0.29765447974205017,
-0.6392969489097595,
-0.48606276512145996,
0.8233868479728699,
-0.28446900844573975,
-0.19802328944206238,
-0.2340012490749359,
-0.3221897780895233,
-0.4027358889579773,
-0.4168146550655365,
0.7891437411308289,
0.6854504942893982,
-0.053744181990623474,
-0.025218116119503975,
-0.8097587823867798,
0.2969435751438141,
0.04992327839136124,
-0.9327884316444397,
0.31643325090408325,
0.4748551845550537,
0.561093807220459,
0.09135659039020538,
0.31773415207862854,
-0.6003273725509644,
0.36124861240386963,
-0.16213305294513702,
-0.05877715349197388,
-0.18232281506061554,
-0.30651015043258667,
-0.4846021831035614,
0.3608931303024292,
0.41266536712646484,
0.2861461341381073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09320v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09320v2
|
Khmer Semantic Search Engine (KSE): Digital Information Access and Document Retrieval
| 2024-06-13T16:58:02 | 2024-06-16T19:08:34 |
Nimol Thuon
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The search engine process is crucial for document content retrieval. For
Khmer documents, an effective tool is needed to extract essential keywords and
facilitate accurate searches. Despite the daily generation of significant Khmer
content, Cambodians struggle to find necessary documents due to the lack of an
effective semantic searching tool. Even Google does not deliver high accuracy
for Khmer content. Semantic search engines improve search results by employing
advanced algorithms to understand various content types. With the rise in Khmer
digital content such as reports, articles, and social media feedback enhanced
search capabilities are essential. This research proposes the first Khmer
Semantic Search Engine (KSE), designed to enhance traditional Khmer search
methods. Utilizing semantic matching techniques and formally annotated semantic
content, our tool extracts meaningful keywords from user queries, performs
precise matching, and provides the best matching offline documents and online
URLs. We propose three semantic search frameworks: semantic search based on a
keyword dictionary, semantic search based on ontology, and semantic search
based on ranking. Additionally, we developed tools for data preparation,
including document addition and manual keyword extraction. To evaluate
performance, we created a ground truth dataset and addressed issues related to
searching and semantic search. Our findings demonstrate that understanding
search term semantics can lead to significantly more accurate results.
|
[
-0.4118856191635132,
-0.45903441309928894,
0.7834172248840332,
0.015166015364229679,
-0.7726064920425415,
0.15620891749858856,
0.012205963023006916,
-0.41570574045181274,
0.4328472912311554,
0.8000803589820862,
-0.5268639922142029,
-0.912297248840332,
-0.7424958348274231,
0.4258852005004883,
-0.04686105251312256,
0.24973970651626587,
-0.20584750175476074,
0.24491029977798462,
0.24430499970912933,
-0.38358333706855774,
-0.5667913556098938,
-0.01557251252233982,
-0.507757842540741,
-0.013787136413156986,
0.6854872107505798,
0.4792027175426483,
0.5433471202850342,
0.7625771164894104,
0.5688842535018921,
0.32725995779037476,
0.2737760543823242,
0.15889966487884521,
-0.5600934028625488,
0.27134549617767334,
-0.40039709210395813,
-0.44476139545440674,
-0.08870769292116165,
-0.11676076799631119,
0.4421374797821045,
0.34999582171440125,
0.04903978854417801,
0.22385573387145996,
-0.21410194039344788,
0.8076357245445251,
-0.9003315567970276,
0.5266546607017517,
-0.7532869577407837,
-0.21635112166404724,
-0.391806423664093,
-0.6052685379981995,
-0.19957658648490906,
-0.5327526330947876,
0.18772411346435547,
-1.3018348217010498,
-0.14470697939395905,
-0.09542788565158844,
1.0853632688522339,
0.06515607982873917,
-0.7024670839309692,
-0.6803656220436096,
-0.2242676317691803,
0.6223902702331543,
-0.7698389887809753,
0.6840693950653076,
0.4363899230957031,
0.6991572380065918,
-0.31279537081718445,
-1.0136957168579102,
-0.792950451374054,
0.05576479807496071,
-0.04803277924656868,
0.09850820899009705,
0.3401428759098053,
0.3462800085544586,
-0.15716855227947235,
0.09652756154537201,
-0.5508614778518677,
-0.008654693141579628,
-0.30095919966697693,
-0.37597593665122986,
0.388901948928833,
0.07252173125743866,
0.72260582447052,
-0.4849192202091217,
-0.24677547812461853,
-0.34825775027275085,
-0.5363362431526184,
-0.11410117149353027,
0.48079612851142883,
0.5066938996315002,
0.5292856693267822,
1.0253126621246338,
-0.5054344534873962,
0.5401225686073303,
-0.3439549207687378,
-0.550849437713623,
-0.19430400431156158,
-0.5427306890487671,
-0.06364210695028305,
0.5426908135414124,
0.07745646685361862,
0.6336628198623657,
0.005866930820047855,
-0.2698877155780792,
-0.3362421691417694,
0.302990198135376,
0.5165677666664124,
-0.8856216073036194,
0.009104429744184017,
-0.050413843244314194,
-0.6286303997039795,
-0.44286924600601196,
0.3208560049533844,
-0.8726520538330078,
-0.25027725100517273,
-0.5648576617240906,
0.9089969396591187,
-0.4111029803752899,
-0.19364318251609802,
0.10469949245452881,
-0.5275419354438782,
0.5271937847137451,
0.40721502900123596,
-0.7019530534744263,
0.5547247529029846,
0.9062838554382324,
0.7468830943107605,
-0.18493159115314484,
-0.017473362386226654,
-0.22715087234973907,
0.15100745856761932,
-0.3477519452571869,
0.818221390247345,
-0.6877703666687012,
-0.42804843187332153,
0.14540232717990875,
0.16527408361434937,
0.015067072585225105,
-0.5238874554634094,
0.8819044828414917,
-1.1839414834976196,
0.14072702825069427,
-0.38736677169799805,
-0.885624885559082,
-0.5934980511665344,
0.01322559267282486,
-0.7323302030563354,
0.9471065402030945,
0.5182510018348694,
-0.7975547909736633,
0.7855920195579529,
-0.7300693392753601,
-0.17336860299110413,
0.503635048866272,
-0.1578839272260666,
-0.15695659816265106,
-0.023144682869315147,
0.14508000016212463,
0.06009610369801521,
-0.23164699971675873,
-0.08478052914142609,
-0.1942393183708191,
-0.5498228669166565,
-0.410668283700943,
0.47577911615371704,
0.6949546933174133,
0.048838600516319275,
-0.43430858850479126,
-0.052514348179101944,
-0.7597436308860779,
0.40303415060043335,
0.3890908360481262,
-0.5134972929954529,
-0.8926393389701843,
-0.12452185153961182,
0.2534739077091217,
0.21934275329113007,
0.41244274377822876,
-0.8418360948562622,
0.2070639580488205,
-0.6238879561424255,
0.08155197650194168,
0.7766093015670776,
-0.02747344970703125,
0.3460976481437683,
-0.20008118450641632,
0.32482242584228516,
-0.1409984976053238,
-0.170930415391922,
-0.17873138189315796,
-0.5759021639823914,
-0.4488599896430969,
-0.21966452896595,
0.6150363087654114,
0.5617905259132385,
-0.7429937124252319,
0.47144991159439087,
-0.5954996943473816,
-0.6536861062049866,
-0.9324725270271301,
0.2117651402950287,
-0.10162284970283508,
0.5828119516372681,
0.22519320249557495,
-0.186110258102417,
-0.64007568359375,
-0.7899309992790222,
-0.2000095695257187,
-0.06068769842386246,
-0.19975103437900543,
0.7131927013397217,
0.34730327129364014,
-0.3003983795642853,
0.9811223745346069,
-0.5025777220726013,
-0.42435386776924133,
-0.042893100529909134,
0.044500384479761124,
-0.25052309036254883,
0.016665589064359665,
0.1905229240655899,
-1.3486301898956299,
-0.5126697421073914,
0.15755695104599,
-0.70841383934021,
-0.3113817870616913,
0.6178941130638123,
-0.2828131914138794,
0.5275819301605225,
-0.025605881586670876,
-0.6165031790733337,
0.33720457553863525,
0.08703106641769409,
-0.3913917541503906,
0.39574187994003296,
-0.1678510457277298,
0.4484337866306305,
-1.0422329902648926,
0.2829855680465698,
-0.34954705834388733,
0.030248578637838364,
-0.1454337239265442,
0.39239659905433655,
0.20972952246665955,
-0.45696061849594116,
-0.27781593799591064,
0.7558264136314392,
-0.03785042092204094,
-0.2197466641664505,
-0.5247896909713745,
0.8533768057823181,
0.2633558511734009,
0.2717567980289459,
0.06567970663309097,
0.6738415956497192,
0.3927419185638428,
-0.7173047065734863,
0.40065696835517883,
0.28044185042381287,
-0.3223026692867279,
0.34755244851112366,
-0.4075033366680145,
0.09853392094373703,
-0.22732757031917572,
0.1427706778049469,
-1.0344302654266357,
-0.30469223856925964,
-0.056204114109277725,
-0.4415707588195801,
0.24980373680591583,
-0.03579775616526604,
-0.8324845433235168,
-0.18485872447490692,
-0.5690132975578308,
0.12878356873989105,
0.2612477242946625,
-0.5128591060638428,
0.5327354669570923,
0.5050179362297058,
-0.4329131543636322,
-0.48195359110832214,
-0.023520324379205704,
0.3144683539867401,
-0.14699995517730713,
-0.9836196899414062,
0.40487799048423767,
0.41145825386047363,
-0.13599205017089844,
0.24350523948669434,
-0.4389503002166748,
-0.37455838918685913,
0.04931124672293663,
-0.15230347216129303,
0.47741642594337463,
-0.6195212006568909,
0.10952994972467422,
0.08155345171689987,
-0.38915276527404785,
-0.27620723843574524,
-0.5356652736663818,
0.5102487206459045,
0.1562480479478836,
-0.2092813402414322,
-0.3843631148338318,
0.3313521146774292,
0.6719107031822205,
-0.21792130172252655,
0.5128753185272217,
0.5553051233291626,
-0.5515024662017822,
0.3802354633808136,
-0.7230117321014404,
-0.37714385986328125,
-0.45471876859664917,
0.20592425763607025,
-0.3706260621547699,
-0.86017906665802,
0.4475628435611725,
-0.4249524176120758,
-0.18154338002204895,
0.721318244934082,
0.2890978455543518,
0.12414287775754929,
1.1499735116958618,
0.7836499214172363,
0.29364100098609924,
0.00023372880241367966,
0.06749127060174942,
0.417458713054657,
-0.5629777908325195,
-0.40317240357398987,
-0.6683912873268127,
-0.1375064104795456,
-1.3169466257095337,
-0.09935440123081207,
0.1654585897922516,
0.10836772620677948,
0.08457113802433014,
0.6994205713272095,
-0.5076192021369934,
0.04328322038054466,
0.3890300989151001,
-0.06062905117869377,
0.2410513013601303,
-0.11974264681339264,
-0.46948426961898804,
-0.5315183997154236,
-0.3678145408630371,
-0.9064244031906128,
1.084611415863037,
-0.13817740976810455,
0.4593309164047241,
0.13247336447238922,
0.6242788434028625,
0.3062482476234436,
-0.36996591091156006,
-0.794593334197998,
0.6349375247955322,
0.04629138112068176,
-0.4207558035850525,
-0.5037931203842163,
-0.25247976183891296,
-1.0964949131011963,
0.3212026357650757,
0.016850639134645462,
-0.6473916172981262,
-0.17514190077781677,
-0.5659857988357544,
0.17587828636169434,
0.123629629611969,
-0.5215560793876648,
0.8821530938148499,
0.06756380200386047,
-0.11998996138572693,
-0.5112284421920776,
-0.7715829610824585,
0.10601640492677689,
-0.3464938700199127,
-0.12284205853939056,
-0.2255321890115738,
-0.4711426794528961,
0.4796571731567383,
-0.4774910509586334,
0.06907309591770172,
-0.24482998251914978,
0.11762821674346924,
0.21729403734207153,
0.11550063639879227,
0.5442653298377991,
0.10866457968950272,
-0.11481229960918427,
0.007337461691349745,
0.37707048654556274,
-0.696881890296936,
-0.8864351511001587,
0.8301419019699097,
-0.4861892759799957,
-0.43276968598365784,
-0.08096835017204285,
0.026488959789276123,
0.12832094728946686,
0.8057188987731934,
0.18835005164146423,
0.2306673228740692,
0.023563077673316002,
0.07565265893936157,
0.5922545194625854,
-0.13733936846256256,
-0.06233900040388107,
0.897783100605011,
-0.2768138349056244,
-0.31948307156562805,
1.1778072118759155,
0.389938622713089,
-0.20879420638084412,
0.6895771622657776,
0.47730469703674316,
-0.5832138061523438,
-0.1826646327972412,
-0.6001279354095459,
0.057515308260917664,
-0.841166079044342,
-0.017021125182509422,
-0.7627310752868652,
-0.13657136261463165,
-0.7011898159980774,
-0.32767146825790405,
-0.2628834545612335,
-0.5540521144866943,
0.1402401626110077,
0.18710672855377197,
-0.0008618857827968895,
0.6875641942024231,
0.23822705447673798,
0.025173138827085495,
-0.8478378057479858,
0.5042717456817627,
0.30715590715408325,
0.48136889934539795,
-0.23879267275333405,
0.02682356722652912,
0.05638384446501732,
-0.13788262009620667,
-0.19681726396083832,
-0.8392025828361511,
0.09125321358442307,
-0.10700289905071259,
0.6482828259468079,
0.20062081515789032,
0.19703741371631622,
0.2141236662864685,
-0.2341098189353943,
0.6764630079269409,
-0.3479957580566406,
-0.5369459390640259,
0.8186642527580261,
-0.2939414978027344,
0.24963681399822235,
0.8436508178710938,
0.43655017018318176,
-0.5440012812614441,
-0.1361764520406723,
-0.46700361371040344,
-0.9322231411933899,
0.5374372005462646,
0.6063683032989502,
-0.11821478605270386,
0.018918298184871674,
0.528446614742279,
0.3770862817764282,
0.2485278844833374,
-0.17093466222286224,
-0.18277312815189362,
-0.27717044949531555,
-0.06725723296403885,
0.44778871536254883,
-0.18943342566490173,
0.41536691784858704,
-0.13150666654109955,
0.909249484539032,
-0.08697953075170517,
0.17251434922218323,
0.39443111419677734,
-0.18980690836906433,
-0.004772742744535208,
0.2097998410463333,
0.6047953963279724,
0.6179247498512268,
-0.23254810273647308,
0.10325423628091812,
0.08218909800052643,
-0.7390239834785461,
0.08840221911668777,
0.11739888787269592,
-0.27339857816696167,
0.34825947880744934,
0.02461618185043335,
0.5666581392288208,
0.3949373662471771,
-0.9715906977653503,
0.5169278979301453,
-0.25589844584465027,
0.2717752754688263,
-0.30666184425354004,
-0.0974198430776596,
0.08886909484863281,
-0.16669990122318268,
0.34693625569343567,
-0.36336052417755127,
0.4403294324874878,
-0.30898576974868774,
0.4144749343395233,
0.2832983732223511,
-0.2886953353881836,
-0.03609335795044899,
0.43012580275535583,
0.06253506988286972,
-0.4827665090560913,
0.4872012734413147,
-0.19984272122383118,
-0.6663833260536194,
0.4333098232746124,
0.45519182085990906,
0.8394908905029297,
-0.051258258521556854,
0.10890038311481476,
0.4312080144882202,
0.10955815762281418,
0.18323838710784912,
0.2737705707550049,
-0.4394530653953552,
-0.38367336988449097,
-0.37405017018318176,
-0.8967978358268738,
-0.271785169839859,
0.03927862271666527,
-0.4721389710903168,
0.89528888463974,
-0.052567675709724426,
0.029257839545607567,
0.02792089618742466,
0.6659551858901978,
-0.4805592894554138,
0.18127885460853577,
-0.18565045297145844,
1.2624915838241577,
-0.04238451272249222,
0.5816977024078369,
0.8026949763298035,
-0.26821067929267883,
-0.639814555644989,
-0.18401271104812622,
-0.030914824455976486,
-0.966440737247467,
0.7709865570068359,
0.3609662353992462,
-0.40472495555877686,
0.20547503232955933,
-0.16965582966804504,
-0.7736518383026123,
1.1896406412124634,
0.30607300996780396,
-0.05109178274869919,
-0.20545677840709686,
0.32589489221572876,
0.3607963025569916,
-0.19951759278774261,
0.04879119247198105,
0.442832350730896,
0.8269293308258057,
0.12586268782615662,
-0.7347221374511719,
0.048147112131118774,
-0.2626074254512787,
0.19958122074604034,
0.31354662775993347,
-0.3006511926651001,
0.13626660406589508,
0.1796616017818451,
-0.4433083236217499,
0.20361784100532532,
0.2250009924173355,
0.1697339415550232,
0.516376256942749,
0.353593647480011,
0.7223300933837891,
0.6296753883361816,
0.07574685662984848,
1.0183314085006714,
-0.6745274066925049,
0.2645459473133087,
0.8582421541213989,
-0.4348348379135132,
0.8335402011871338,
0.2984609603881836,
0.13850808143615723,
0.32142210006713867,
0.6854867339134216,
0.27411237359046936,
0.7826396822929382,
0.07950293272733688,
-0.6096209287643433,
-0.2409830093383789,
-0.40729308128356934,
-0.1651664525270462,
0.7695280909538269,
0.18184398114681244,
-0.248509019613266,
-0.7576842904090881,
-0.0945538580417633,
-0.1066763624548912,
0.25752460956573486,
-0.06297297030687332,
0.9678347110748291,
-0.10178880393505096,
-0.4723495543003082,
-0.0517604686319828,
0.3768392503261566,
0.2889411449432373,
-0.8500101566314697,
-0.2329544574022293,
0.25213509798049927,
-0.08825865387916565,
0.03771165385842323,
-0.6929268836975098,
0.24175265431404114,
-0.5864582061767578,
0.03553308546543121,
0.13692094385623932,
1.500426173210144,
-0.11664094030857086,
-0.40157705545425415,
0.587594747543335,
0.2801149785518646,
0.042149294167757034,
-0.320577472448349,
-0.41704997420310974,
-0.09959756582975388,
-0.5161551833152771,
-0.24004986882209778,
0.43395984172821045,
0.5390561819076538,
0.09964114427566528,
0.3806006610393524,
0.6681532263755798,
0.08684433251619339,
0.24742184579372406,
-0.28411659598350525,
0.8404277563095093,
-0.527944803237915,
-0.6552143096923828,
-0.6224659085273743,
0.02150345966219902,
-0.2391365021467209,
-0.13691824674606323,
0.5548683404922485,
0.8809502124786377,
0.9571306109428406,
0.19095607101917267,
0.8271073698997498,
0.04715197905898094,
0.49158379435539246,
-0.4245406687259674,
0.8341711163520813,
-0.7454870939254761,
-0.37457454204559326,
-0.1950342208147049,
-1.1732271909713745,
0.06953009217977524,
0.5279359817504883,
0.19283084571361542,
-0.12470968812704086,
0.5017200112342834,
0.7634533643722534,
-0.160299614071846,
0.26410287618637085,
0.486264169216156,
-0.005969702731817961,
0.1624983549118042,
-0.04956657811999321,
0.19574491679668427,
-0.698438286781311,
0.44611412286758423,
-0.3066478669643402,
0.0516793318092823,
-0.42559462785720825,
-0.6192130446434021,
-0.3150242865085602,
-0.8170678615570068,
0.0629982203245163,
-0.31156831979751587,
0.1917201280593872,
0.8334333300590515,
0.47749942541122437,
-0.6208695769309998,
0.22781993448734283,
-0.07982131838798523,
0.2654222548007965,
0.16922913491725922,
-0.3159714639186859,
0.3978724777698517,
-0.5203301906585693,
-0.5362086296081543,
0.3709736764431,
0.8321925401687622,
-0.07371975481510162,
-0.22791369259357452,
-0.2982877492904663,
-0.3093127906322479,
0.16999715566635132,
0.5727764368057251,
0.06862599402666092,
-0.850304901599884,
-0.28633442521095276,
0.30712252855300903,
-0.4410645663738251,
0.1445162445306778,
1.0251468420028687,
-0.7119268774986267,
1.0403887033462524,
0.6442680358886719,
0.9559741020202637,
0.4383496344089508,
-0.20135997235774994,
0.5242449045181274,
-0.16929814219474792,
-0.07534252107143402,
0.28467029333114624,
0.21166741847991943,
0.2808375656604767,
-0.3996368944644928,
0.5242041945457458,
0.5118978023529053,
-0.47500941157341003,
-0.4856144189834595,
0.002094983123242855,
-1.0718082189559937,
-0.1135823205113411,
0.8755931854248047,
-0.14769655466079712,
-0.27963438630104065,
-0.46436360478401184,
-0.5500045418739319,
0.6883920431137085,
-0.21396881341934204,
1.0014641284942627,
1.0373719930648804,
0.16359800100326538,
0.2689359188079834,
-0.9192241430282593,
0.23383158445358276,
0.14523069560527802,
-0.425908625125885,
-0.32851773500442505,
0.022016052156686783,
0.27584099769592285,
0.18062512576580048,
0.5499795079231262,
-0.34039613604545593,
0.5300183296203613,
0.08546673506498337,
-0.10397167503833771,
0.20608986914157867,
0.01666257530450821,
0.10221408307552338,
0.2573224604129791,
-0.05247073993086815,
-0.04232487455010414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09308v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09308v1
|
Transformers meet Neural Algorithmic Reasoners
| 2024-06-13T16:42:06 | 2024-06-13T16:42:06 |
Wilfried Bounsi, Borja Ibarz, Andrew Dudzik, Jessica B. Hamrick, Larisa Markeeva, Alex Vitvitskyi, Razvan Pascanu, Petar Veličković
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Transformers have revolutionized machine learning with their simple yet
effective architecture. Pre-training Transformers on massive text datasets from
the Internet has led to unmatched generalization for natural language
understanding (NLU) tasks. However, such language models remain fragile when
tasked with algorithmic forms of reasoning, where computations must be precise
and robust. To address this limitation, we propose a novel approach that
combines the Transformer's language understanding with the robustness of graph
neural network (GNN)-based neural algorithmic reasoners (NARs). Such NARs
proved effective as generic solvers for algorithmic tasks, when specified in
graph form. To make their embeddings accessible to a Transformer, we propose a
hybrid architecture with a two-phase training procedure, allowing the tokens in
the language model to cross-attend to the node embeddings from the NAR. We
evaluate our resulting TransNAR model on CLRS-Text, the text-based version of
the CLRS-30 benchmark, and demonstrate significant gains over Transformer-only
models for algorithmic reasoning, both in and out of distribution.
|
[
-0.3835216760635376,
-0.5473667979240417,
0.5364983677864075,
0.053695790469646454,
-0.18485507369041443,
0.23945128917694092,
-0.22627180814743042,
-0.19501951336860657,
-0.0503724068403244,
0.402019202709198,
-0.3406720757484436,
-0.28771141171455383,
-0.6819655299186707,
0.1744886338710785,
-0.6154073476791382,
0.9096983671188354,
-0.2967827320098877,
-0.04726703464984894,
-0.1274929642677307,
-0.36346080899238586,
-0.40662941336631775,
-0.35676005482673645,
-0.757966935634613,
-0.8006129264831543,
0.3666028082370758,
0.06923490762710571,
0.8788807392120361,
0.6207408308982849,
0.21813948452472687,
0.4925968647003174,
-0.037720002233982086,
0.29805418848991394,
-0.0965563952922821,
0.17381994426250458,
-0.3587338328361511,
-0.5683873891830444,
-0.09730285406112671,
-0.3245203197002411,
0.3157726228237152,
0.636431872844696,
-0.11412926763296127,
0.010983368381857872,
-0.0698193609714508,
0.45259520411491394,
-0.4042782187461853,
0.3462793827056885,
-0.7592851519584656,
0.05672132968902588,
0.15436036884784698,
-0.09344978630542755,
-0.677825927734375,
-0.09245205670595169,
0.10810868442058563,
-0.689236044883728,
0.6657071709632874,
-0.18344728648662567,
0.9221500754356384,
0.5889767408370972,
-0.3619980216026306,
-0.24837136268615723,
-1.096581220626831,
0.509486198425293,
-0.282659113407135,
0.5693654417991638,
0.10714900493621826,
0.6660540699958801,
0.07896312326192856,
-1.0087517499923706,
-0.7086787223815918,
0.14950783550739288,
-0.40707892179489136,
0.007361626718193293,
-0.6379639506340027,
0.08704608678817749,
0.15869194269180298,
0.2633650004863739,
-0.6873646378517151,
-0.009877831675112247,
-0.2930070459842682,
-0.19759173691272736,
0.26829466223716736,
0.026281949132680893,
0.41800186038017273,
-0.025650661438703537,
-0.08708220720291138,
-0.17804767191410065,
-0.3541591167449951,
-0.06118284538388252,
0.34034430980682373,
0.21804672479629517,
-0.11572220176458359,
0.3450911343097687,
0.17924875020980835,
0.7473214268684387,
0.286150187253952,
0.23725943267345428,
0.15049491822719574,
-0.309853732585907,
-0.10122159868478775,
-0.07845858484506607,
0.9625489711761475,
-0.04921795800328255,
0.4407724142074585,
-0.691127598285675,
-0.1991662085056305,
0.40998268127441406,
0.6035844683647156,
-0.5518801212310791,
-0.32707300782203674,
0.1844726800918579,
-0.4599197208881378,
-0.2395574003458023,
-0.1357955038547516,
-0.62785404920578,
-0.2729121148586273,
-0.47430911660194397,
0.24439826607704163,
-0.20766353607177734,
-0.32237857580184937,
0.07654061168432236,
-0.19162997603416443,
0.15874475240707397,
0.0463419146835804,
-0.9661974310874939,
0.5103136897087097,
0.8009685277938843,
0.7909417748451233,
0.052985139191150665,
-0.15018518269062042,
-0.3672061860561371,
-0.03906159847974777,
-0.3096989095211029,
0.8098742961883545,
-0.44222474098205566,
-0.06227726489305496,
0.01122787594795227,
-0.12442868947982788,
-0.45723193883895874,
-0.6254793405532837,
0.6285689473152161,
-0.7048363089561462,
0.2405877262353897,
0.20917043089866638,
-0.16834460198879242,
-0.3757407069206238,
0.25149932503700256,
-0.7308816313743591,
0.9510740041732788,
0.17559415102005005,
-0.7518182396888733,
0.16749486327171326,
-0.7046728730201721,
-0.5636752247810364,
0.06283418834209442,
-0.20600847899913788,
-0.5138154625892639,
0.09966596961021423,
0.3624061346054077,
0.14188621938228607,
-0.3471399247646332,
0.6024367213249207,
-0.0520961619913578,
-0.24769657850265503,
0.15485729277133942,
-0.5802544355392456,
0.5661047697067261,
0.0714089423418045,
-0.6152199506759644,
0.4375855624675751,
-0.5451174974441528,
-0.026623398065567017,
0.31477996706962585,
-0.08796369284391403,
-0.15820454061031342,
0.13008953630924225,
-0.004687541630119085,
0.4150851368904114,
-0.07008679956197739,
-0.5517133474349976,
-0.16891346871852875,
-0.6031494736671448,
1.040629267692566,
0.6008303761482239,
-0.5105274319648743,
0.6427855491638184,
-0.08050940185785294,
0.6658918261528015,
-0.06179873272776604,
-0.043782562017440796,
-0.12158703804016113,
-0.483000785112381,
-0.964581310749054,
0.12206314504146576,
0.3883794844150543,
0.7196587324142456,
-1.111760139465332,
0.3428214192390442,
-0.4169406294822693,
-0.5855095386505127,
-0.7224130034446716,
0.13581693172454834,
0.318613737821579,
0.5831241607666016,
0.634921133518219,
0.17847464978694916,
-0.5235995054244995,
-0.9653342962265015,
-0.34708279371261597,
-0.03961505368351936,
-0.10691366344690323,
0.30362948775291443,
0.44510185718536377,
-0.23008571565151215,
0.9851300120353699,
-0.09074174612760544,
0.0026313336566090584,
-0.9348272681236267,
0.17421574890613556,
0.46711254119873047,
0.3008871376514435,
0.2615755498409271,
-1.0258777141571045,
-0.41428738832473755,
0.11398487538099289,
-0.8465458154678345,
-0.004610852804034948,
-0.3160359859466553,
-0.025954749435186386,
-0.03324392810463905,
0.50677090883255,
-0.8193727731704712,
0.47511008381843567,
0.6829059720039368,
-0.2768460810184479,
0.23058798909187317,
-0.2266491949558258,
-0.5122309923171997,
-0.9890549182891846,
0.10829595476388931,
0.16662520170211792,
-0.5156604647636414,
-0.8438045382499695,
0.009061191231012344,
-0.24256132543087006,
-0.3905847668647766,
-0.1365347057580948,
0.4652901291847229,
-0.1527421772480011,
0.05164207145571709,
-0.3222947418689728,
0.20104554295539856,
0.13390977680683136,
0.4822383522987366,
-0.007000776939094067,
0.7814232110977173,
0.5494608283042908,
-0.43908926844596863,
0.2804411053657532,
0.3914596438407898,
0.061009570956230164,
0.34468379616737366,
-1.2658928632736206,
0.46974658966064453,
-0.4405438303947449,
0.5066992044448853,
-0.8568180799484253,
0.10505090653896332,
0.4757429361343384,
-0.3808524012565613,
0.2509772479534149,
-0.1891033798456192,
-0.3858160078525543,
-0.6261635422706604,
0.26136964559555054,
0.6834794878959656,
0.37300828099250793,
-0.7548902630805969,
1.517654299736023,
0.20773100852966309,
0.1502525955438614,
-0.35304000973701477,
-0.693919837474823,
0.2803241014480591,
0.00578219024464488,
-0.7991216778755188,
0.4687289893627167,
0.18632124364376068,
-0.15022136270999908,
0.22567929327487946,
-0.04778466373682022,
-0.11619026213884354,
0.07873661071062088,
0.24734054505825043,
0.15223194658756256,
-0.3280832767486572,
-0.015770023688673973,
0.010870149359107018,
-0.813690185546875,
0.17842192947864532,
-0.7268117666244507,
0.879788339138031,
-0.32743319869041443,
-0.33294978737831116,
-0.4891240894794464,
0.2897903323173523,
0.5512051582336426,
-0.48043251037597656,
0.8758400082588196,
0.4918414056301117,
-0.28023210167884827,
-0.5072510838508606,
-0.3484683632850647,
-0.13054068386554718,
-0.5337167382240295,
0.18987853825092316,
-0.33514365553855896,
-0.8429811000823975,
0.3798474967479706,
-0.1045243963599205,
0.00023880218213889748,
0.6186529397964478,
0.6225625872612,
0.12282454967498779,
1.15118408203125,
0.3209168612957001,
-0.11023281514644623,
0.1075870618224144,
-0.3957500457763672,
0.7799218893051147,
-0.5459123253822327,
-0.2168869972229004,
-0.5557175874710083,
-0.6243638396263123,
-0.5823732018470764,
-0.36065155267715454,
0.23232463002204895,
-0.14586442708969116,
-0.21786461770534515,
0.5403010845184326,
-0.662938117980957,
0.4863168001174927,
0.5465500950813293,
0.03584787994623184,
0.04067925736308098,
-0.13463042676448822,
-0.1963099092245102,
0.3027586042881012,
-0.9133601188659668,
-0.47785043716430664,
0.6051961183547974,
0.4084400534629822,
0.26774755120277405,
-0.16019083559513092,
0.3337446451187134,
-0.010704757645726204,
0.3662964701652527,
-0.7210023999214172,
0.4389753043651581,
-0.4212457835674286,
-0.5473824739456177,
-0.006339632906019688,
-0.6177590489387512,
-0.9382394552230835,
0.39993995428085327,
0.17193065583705902,
-0.719656229019165,
0.08705390989780426,
0.2685789465904236,
0.018377382308244705,
0.5573907494544983,
-0.5892539024353027,
1.1816344261169434,
-0.21287333965301514,
0.0968158170580864,
-0.10385819524526596,
-0.7400411367416382,
0.12859304249286652,
0.17957249283790588,
0.35195478796958923,
0.27721309661865234,
0.3030247092247009,
0.5383094549179077,
-0.4973095953464508,
0.7392604947090149,
-0.1923251450061798,
0.16588225960731506,
0.36566397547721863,
0.11926791816949844,
0.4683113992214203,
-0.13198448717594147,
0.03570285812020302,
0.2900753319263458,
-0.5122700929641724,
-0.29631176590919495,
-0.9252473711967468,
0.21657322347164154,
-0.753713846206665,
-0.4840988218784332,
-0.211810901761055,
-0.6766235828399658,
-0.08731035143136978,
0.1498141586780548,
0.4224800765514374,
0.6064363718032837,
0.28953805565834045,
0.20967702567577362,
0.5827242732048035,
-0.027216516435146332,
0.49832507967948914,
0.05715664476156235,
-0.06068684905767441,
-0.47879189252853394,
0.9758386611938477,
-0.2406342625617981,
0.2683239281177521,
0.4726108908653259,
0.4088718593120575,
-0.4171625077724457,
-0.5286571383476257,
-0.6113824248313904,
0.1374214142560959,
-0.7742883563041687,
-0.10024284571409225,
-0.7793745994567871,
-0.44469016790390015,
0.15546299517154694,
-0.19017404317855835,
-0.37615782022476196,
-0.21142666041851044,
-0.09122060239315033,
-0.2004810869693756,
0.08501243591308594,
0.7198631167411804,
0.1557733118534088,
0.4411610960960388,
-0.6879188418388367,
0.6007158160209656,
0.22547444701194763,
0.3055676519870758,
0.17454692721366882,
-0.4311412572860718,
0.009369234554469585,
0.05477192625403404,
-0.2221103459596634,
-0.6606624722480774,
0.18318258225917816,
0.11527454107999802,
0.6025708317756653,
0.3412894010543823,
-0.21206419169902802,
0.29006391763687134,
-0.5224362015724182,
0.4728211462497711,
0.14416658878326416,
-1.0939960479736328,
0.38416653871536255,
-0.21237659454345703,
0.2171909213066101,
0.6581077575683594,
0.15715822577476501,
-0.5776929259300232,
-0.421897828578949,
-0.5572259426116943,
-0.8247910141944885,
0.6103914380073547,
0.43822503089904785,
0.24782775342464447,
0.004138961900025606,
0.2730672061443329,
0.06236552447080612,
0.0011306491214782,
-0.7582352757453918,
-0.40032055974006653,
-0.6300181746482849,
-0.6274313926696777,
-0.06581304222345352,
0.15554040670394897,
-0.0716693326830864,
-0.2881624400615692,
0.53216952085495,
-0.42019057273864746,
0.30213457345962524,
-0.04904070124030113,
-0.19034449756145477,
0.05009555071592331,
0.32745757699012756,
0.5066736340522766,
0.7074304223060608,
0.4297207295894623,
0.5053670406341553,
0.14436765015125275,
-0.3393527865409851,
0.20507942140102386,
0.383126437664032,
-0.5608996152877808,
0.23268342018127441,
0.354585200548172,
0.9906691312789917,
0.2146744579076767,
-0.5062017440795898,
0.42425644397735596,
-0.33841535449028015,
-0.2864299714565277,
-0.009646771475672722,
-0.15805435180664062,
0.2863626182079315,
0.14288778603076935,
0.3053812086582184,
0.5417718291282654,
-0.11238039284944534,
-0.15810604393482208,
0.15834805369377136,
0.3623570501804352,
-0.5571830868721008,
-0.5605090856552124,
0.7972465753555298,
0.04961850121617317,
-0.6695847511291504,
0.7200825214385986,
-0.3157350718975067,
-1.2142289876937866,
0.5974072217941284,
0.8156856894493103,
1.007300615310669,
0.05424800515174866,
0.5187252759933472,
0.1574319750070572,
0.407684326171875,
-0.049319200217723846,
0.200136199593544,
-0.001092475256882608,
-0.9470566511154175,
-0.5750181674957275,
-0.5544819235801697,
-0.1873748004436493,
-0.1884019672870636,
-0.3394414484500885,
-0.03796198591589928,
-0.5358127951622009,
0.020633280277252197,
0.0030910929199308157,
-0.6882128715515137,
-0.8538959622383118,
0.1179468110203743,
0.15711161494255066,
0.8160231709480286,
-0.7765464782714844,
0.40862375497817993,
0.5453615784645081,
-0.26675596833229065,
-1.0782902240753174,
-0.19747281074523926,
-0.32783856987953186,
-0.8702948689460754,
0.5633985996246338,
0.34074288606643677,
-0.10146988928318024,
-0.0610027089715004,
-0.20403340458869934,
-0.6166048049926758,
0.8712818622589111,
0.5403367877006531,
-0.5905165672302246,
-0.12147914618253708,
0.5389577746391296,
0.6525463461875916,
-0.14389453828334808,
0.398502379655838,
0.5513074398040771,
0.5057199597358704,
0.17401474714279175,
-0.8602023124694824,
0.0830480307340622,
-0.42635616660118103,
-0.1572166383266449,
0.7133212089538574,
-0.31753218173980713,
0.6595717668533325,
0.033206868916749954,
-0.22796624898910522,
-0.22028213739395142,
0.6853824853897095,
0.15447168052196503,
0.46828368306159973,
0.8085787296295166,
0.8665977716445923,
0.6458860635757446,
-0.2686566114425659,
1.2026039361953735,
-0.39550718665122986,
0.35027626156806946,
0.9514831304550171,
0.08526422828435898,
0.48720622062683105,
0.2908400595188141,
-0.13380199670791626,
0.8342010378837585,
0.19521386921405792,
-0.004396459553390741,
0.37930721044540405,
0.22235003113746643,
-0.11426324397325516,
-0.4694770574569702,
-0.3347237706184387,
-0.09027628600597382,
0.5725013613700867,
0.11478852480649948,
-0.44591832160949707,
-0.583875298500061,
-0.08011828362941742,
-0.0019485433585941792,
0.25578218698501587,
-0.23647677898406982,
0.6923636794090271,
0.21192598342895508,
-0.5899824500083923,
0.27590468525886536,
0.03605995327234268,
0.4665885269641876,
-0.4462054967880249,
0.03470978885889053,
0.14788605272769928,
0.39892423152923584,
-0.24681827425956726,
-0.6628639698028564,
0.6802870035171509,
-0.08694125711917877,
-0.14917810261249542,
-0.49742838740348816,
0.8798021674156189,
-0.2000037133693695,
-0.7899226546287537,
0.39460909366607666,
0.4592340886592865,
-0.2911602854728699,
-0.12545207142829895,
-0.5959278345108032,
-0.062160346657037735,
-0.392223984003067,
0.11368037015199661,
0.02891521155834198,
0.42938539385795593,
0.03610772639513016,
0.6986759901046753,
0.6577978134155273,
-0.07940515875816345,
0.08503028005361557,
0.4384627938270569,
0.9858328700065613,
-0.21565520763397217,
-0.6068540215492249,
-1.0236201286315918,
0.5493268966674805,
0.02972976677119732,
-0.37942397594451904,
0.4297698736190796,
0.39815324544906616,
0.5932267904281616,
0.24983572959899902,
0.7784361839294434,
0.01998441480100155,
0.1825934797525406,
-0.35460907220840454,
0.5685467720031738,
-0.31462910771369934,
-0.09292592853307724,
0.08471646159887314,
-0.950954258441925,
-0.3183233141899109,
0.5330472588539124,
-0.4532620310783386,
0.057818878442049026,
0.5804089307785034,
0.5379456281661987,
-0.2728099822998047,
0.3607993721961975,
-0.12757304310798645,
0.08946050703525543,
0.5393942594528198,
0.7076169848442078,
0.8564136028289795,
-0.4225468337535858,
0.8328014016151428,
-0.1717660129070282,
0.058246731758117676,
0.26321253180503845,
-0.7150604724884033,
-1.0966089963912964,
-0.42417749762535095,
-0.07495713233947754,
-0.40332773327827454,
0.005780239589512348,
0.7379580140113831,
0.5421693325042725,
-0.8930732011795044,
0.09689204394817352,
-0.7257824540138245,
0.31952863931655884,
-0.18879733979701996,
-0.22787877917289734,
0.27785995602607727,
-0.3229595124721527,
-0.29202061891555786,
0.4746323823928833,
0.312631756067276,
-0.3075180649757385,
-0.3556292951107025,
-0.14361655712127686,
0.19473323225975037,
-0.07535290718078613,
0.2853906452655792,
0.22953787446022034,
-0.7132107019424438,
-0.2871173024177551,
0.14311248064041138,
0.06472033262252808,
0.19616106152534485,
1.0292611122131348,
-0.998053252696991,
0.4187605381011963,
0.5606366991996765,
1.0360444784164429,
0.5398437976837158,
0.04857230931520462,
0.7817875146865845,
-0.4465961754322052,
-0.04589080810546875,
0.3575814962387085,
0.4977699816226959,
0.48115652799606323,
-0.13069719076156616,
0.29548779129981995,
0.20118051767349243,
-0.44305455684661865,
-0.6051579117774963,
0.3028585612773895,
-0.8183979988098145,
-0.10451214015483856,
0.8844219446182251,
0.009549333713948727,
-0.244607076048851,
-0.3593776822090149,
0.046635180711746216,
0.3880169093608856,
-0.18580861389636993,
0.6525194048881531,
0.44118401408195496,
0.1203598752617836,
-0.32231056690216064,
-0.36993372440338135,
0.045479316264390945,
0.40461087226867676,
-0.8462048172950745,
-0.1518392711877823,
-0.14223870635032654,
-0.004756317939609289,
0.47590550780296326,
0.24147991836071014,
0.18529364466667175,
0.1428036093711853,
-0.06181865930557251,
-0.38068443536758423,
-0.26149269938468933,
-0.5899800658226013,
-0.24829019606113434,
0.39200010895729065,
-0.3358214497566223,
-0.0833745151758194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09295v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09295v2
|
AlignMMBench: Evaluating Chinese Multimodal Alignment in Large Vision-Language Models
| 2024-06-13T16:30:14 | 2024-06-14T02:14:49 |
Yuhang Wu, Wenmeng Yu, Yean Cheng, Yan Wang, Xiaohan Zhang, Jiazheng Xu, Ming Ding, Yuxiao Dong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Evaluating the alignment capabilities of large Vision-Language Models (VLMs)
is essential for determining their effectiveness as helpful assistants.
However, existing benchmarks primarily focus on basic abilities using nonverbal
methods, such as yes-no and multiple-choice questions. In this paper, we
address this gap by introducing AlignMMBench, a comprehensive alignment
benchmark specifically designed for emerging Chinese VLMs. This benchmark is
meticulously curated from real-world scenarios and Chinese Internet sources,
encompassing thirteen specific tasks across three categories, and includes both
single-turn and multi-turn dialogue scenarios. Incorporating a prompt rewrite
strategy, AlignMMBench encompasses 1,054 images and 4,978 question-answer
pairs. To facilitate the evaluation pipeline, we propose CritiqueVLM, a
rule-calibrated evaluator that exceeds GPT-4's evaluation ability. Finally, we
report the performance of representative VLMs on AlignMMBench, offering
insights into the capabilities and limitations of different VLM architectures.
All evaluation codes and data are available on https://alignmmbench.github.io.
|
[
-0.3371666371822357,
-0.36574673652648926,
0.4476967751979828,
0.2249901294708252,
-0.282755047082901,
-0.18440644443035126,
-0.19822940230369568,
-0.3580988943576813,
-0.06611846387386322,
0.29900509119033813,
-0.6880574822425842,
-0.24016709625720978,
-0.13850149512290955,
-0.16134801506996155,
-0.3389319181442261,
0.7744680643081665,
-0.14835225045681,
0.4719299077987671,
-0.4103492498397827,
-0.6035630702972412,
-0.5464314222335815,
-0.06514739245176315,
-0.2067505270242691,
-0.10931584239006042,
0.5625765919685364,
0.16867764294147491,
0.8742772936820984,
0.6605695486068726,
0.7536035180091858,
0.3254469037055969,
0.322995662689209,
0.38557037711143494,
-0.22415634989738464,
-0.06648750603199005,
-0.16120664775371552,
-0.06668765842914581,
-0.6072109937667847,
-0.03883742168545723,
0.7236582636833191,
0.34705567359924316,
-0.3520219326019287,
0.46923553943634033,
0.0239859689027071,
0.38653674721717834,
-0.8000863790512085,
0.010205919854342937,
-0.5013337731361389,
0.003244157414883375,
-0.34474319219589233,
0.10433325171470642,
-0.2893916070461273,
-0.323702335357666,
0.15523281693458557,
-0.6488643288612366,
-0.1039116233587265,
0.11472846567630768,
1.0095045566558838,
0.5231875777244568,
-0.393537700176239,
0.3130122125148773,
-0.22682763636112213,
0.8698196411132812,
-0.865666925907135,
0.6399396061897278,
-0.03253239765763283,
0.8153761029243469,
0.14382405579090118,
-0.7269504070281982,
-0.8120033740997314,
-0.1486494094133377,
-0.13381057977676392,
0.39690160751342773,
-0.011721811257302761,
-0.01956426165997982,
0.3389813005924225,
0.36993634700775146,
-0.9394612312316895,
0.008724931627511978,
-0.09125202149152756,
-0.3657963275909424,
0.6115944385528564,
0.3700198829174042,
0.36969730257987976,
-0.2563014626502991,
-0.6356722712516785,
-0.32517486810684204,
-0.19610543549060822,
-0.03667040169239044,
0.24567104876041412,
0.17635059356689453,
-0.0942884311079979,
0.8084216117858887,
-0.13358744978904724,
1.156595230102539,
-0.06451289355754852,
-0.1113358736038208,
0.45053747296333313,
-0.8849633932113647,
-0.37886786460876465,
-0.06312733143568039,
0.8156152367591858,
0.8624272346496582,
-0.08971112221479416,
0.13530994951725006,
-0.29322290420532227,
-0.03917549550533295,
0.45234254002571106,
-0.46865999698638916,
-0.1948501616716385,
0.18726368248462677,
-0.4498809576034546,
0.09309446811676025,
0.18214094638824463,
-0.7642722725868225,
-0.6824071407318115,
-0.6451644897460938,
0.5460469126701355,
-0.30427271127700806,
-0.261931836605072,
-0.2229321151971817,
-0.24967844784259796,
1.0356508493423462,
0.6244654059410095,
-0.488673597574234,
0.0602499358355999,
0.7909324169158936,
0.7855836749076843,
-0.28289517760276794,
-0.5438681244850159,
-0.8087797164916992,
-0.0995909571647644,
-0.2432183176279068,
0.6069746613502502,
-0.3064868450164795,
-0.01436255406588316,
-0.03128510341048241,
0.14343267679214478,
-0.24324321746826172,
-0.45592832565307617,
0.6353872418403625,
-0.17711231112480164,
0.25714272260665894,
-0.3345240652561188,
-0.28623247146606445,
-0.09225234389305115,
0.6039280295372009,
-0.7518900036811829,
0.9586161971092224,
0.16968593001365662,
-0.613115131855011,
0.35733386874198914,
-0.37350010871887207,
-0.290768027305603,
0.018509574234485626,
-0.4130769968032837,
-0.5266386866569519,
-0.0167616605758667,
0.19665664434432983,
0.10477795451879501,
-0.3725065290927887,
0.15143489837646484,
-0.5151969790458679,
-0.3057844340801239,
0.03982692211866379,
-0.5099503993988037,
0.8937369585037231,
0.11847061663866043,
-0.34277045726776123,
0.5966063737869263,
-0.7365311980247498,
0.46157562732696533,
-0.012256738729774952,
0.02299732342362404,
-0.12899009883403778,
-0.1499651074409485,
0.21368344128131866,
0.4910508394241333,
0.6622706651687622,
-0.5072230696678162,
0.24978460371494293,
-0.08830276131629944,
0.060023725032806396,
0.8891060948371887,
-0.6071869134902954,
0.10739997029304504,
-0.2434287667274475,
0.44125476479530334,
-0.09170925617218018,
0.49924737215042114,
-0.16514605283737183,
-0.27353528141975403,
-0.7854588627815247,
-0.15644079446792603,
0.18075443804264069,
0.4584888219833374,
-0.9639971256256104,
0.2087387889623642,
-0.38750648498535156,
-0.7747746109962463,
-1.001886010169983,
0.3800447881221771,
0.8398416042327881,
0.6299608945846558,
0.4266808032989502,
-0.4338655173778534,
-0.5658991932868958,
-1.087493896484375,
-0.2640330493450165,
-0.13841083645820618,
-0.11745906621217728,
0.14680571854114532,
0.1026991456747055,
0.011157236061990261,
0.7092573642730713,
-0.259590208530426,
-0.32335400581359863,
0.028234809637069702,
-0.07845419645309448,
0.0013517093611881137,
0.31341174244880676,
0.5558618903160095,
-0.9379490613937378,
-0.527992844581604,
0.2614934742450714,
-0.7433825135231018,
-0.2818378210067749,
0.03561680018901825,
-0.22733329236507416,
0.19478751718997955,
0.3327677845954895,
-0.47637781500816345,
0.1823696345090866,
0.929008424282074,
-0.2093561291694641,
0.7597425580024719,
-0.12565964460372925,
0.09732998162508011,
-0.9206324815750122,
0.36268705129623413,
0.12683174014091492,
-0.11447957903146744,
-0.40398794412612915,
0.21689186990261078,
0.5029870867729187,
0.04247784614562988,
-0.5982251763343811,
0.6141573786735535,
-0.6669116020202637,
-0.38504135608673096,
-0.04473348706960678,
0.5115387439727783,
-0.015653731301426888,
0.4663222134113312,
-0.13175514340400696,
0.7361205816268921,
0.3398818075656891,
-0.12263597548007965,
0.643963634967804,
0.2998169958591461,
-0.4543878734111786,
0.9475343823432922,
-0.4777752459049225,
0.1866457611322403,
0.10449803620576859,
0.10869176685810089,
-1.240167260169983,
-0.18901251256465912,
0.20218846201896667,
-0.21491798758506775,
0.15048550069332123,
0.1070384830236435,
-0.33896690607070923,
-0.34443145990371704,
-0.622001051902771,
0.3596499562263489,
0.2545132040977478,
-0.5964030623435974,
0.8874160647392273,
0.17704862356185913,
0.19896666705608368,
-0.9479807019233704,
-0.463296502828598,
0.10726197808980942,
-0.057395271956920624,
-0.6475948095321655,
0.31702667474746704,
-0.22159017622470856,
-0.17284056544303894,
-0.021681303158402443,
-0.24968890845775604,
0.12475565820932388,
-0.02915520779788494,
0.08320769667625427,
0.5615586042404175,
-0.45165079832077026,
-0.26126936078071594,
-0.4547497034072876,
-0.018935497850179672,
-0.2755052149295807,
-0.06675144284963608,
0.5178086757659912,
-0.2682188153266907,
-0.806818425655365,
-0.3695356845855713,
-0.10914978384971619,
0.7581802606582642,
-0.7535955905914307,
0.40595823526382446,
0.7922393083572388,
-0.007830502465367317,
0.1457110196352005,
-0.6507064700126648,
0.27551472187042236,
-0.4289311170578003,
0.357814759016037,
-0.2694025933742523,
-0.5049381852149963,
0.3307904005050659,
0.25179728865623474,
0.519768238067627,
0.3420606553554535,
0.6149705052375793,
0.23208440840244293,
1.178338646888733,
0.412275493144989,
-0.07081080228090286,
0.5756070613861084,
0.4068313241004944,
0.23421844840049744,
-1.067185878753662,
-0.17381440103054047,
-0.2822815477848053,
-0.33945223689079285,
-0.31349432468414307,
-0.584898829460144,
0.1745692491531372,
-0.2856430113315582,
-0.16093185544013977,
0.6549107432365417,
-0.43475037813186646,
0.3063836097717285,
0.5354484915733337,
-0.10861189663410187,
0.07959449291229248,
-0.4982838034629822,
-0.08303113281726837,
-0.0729849636554718,
-0.3543485701084137,
-0.45805102586746216,
0.9507630467414856,
0.05295165628194809,
0.5762547254562378,
0.3256782591342926,
0.22478410601615906,
-0.15142805874347687,
0.3229852616786957,
-0.6995850205421448,
0.6740960478782654,
-0.11693829298019409,
-0.4809892177581787,
-0.3790434002876282,
-0.19247348606586456,
-0.6212257146835327,
0.7110162377357483,
-0.1476011723279953,
-0.6731179356575012,
-0.15339460968971252,
0.23623871803283691,
-0.36750468611717224,
0.068478524684906,
-0.9081542491912842,
1.4171106815338135,
-0.8187021017074585,
-0.5856863260269165,
0.11446361243724823,
-0.890633225440979,
0.46349576115608215,
-0.19768498837947845,
0.020928751677274704,
-0.1272779256105423,
-0.02724568359553814,
0.30782896280288696,
-0.1735222339630127,
0.5531383752822876,
-0.3064168393611908,
-0.17610621452331543,
-0.018623195588588715,
-0.16329172253608704,
0.11528131365776062,
-0.4807332456111908,
-0.21374472975730896,
0.06749073415994644,
0.2985115051269531,
-0.26156407594680786,
-0.6243346333503723,
0.6351955533027649,
-0.5297700762748718,
-0.557375967502594,
-0.2111833393573761,
-0.40611493587493896,
-0.30277857184410095,
0.5149658918380737,
-0.06299832463264465,
0.23639222979545593,
-0.4374980032444,
0.2830226421356201,
0.10281527787446976,
-0.2270786166191101,
0.32527369260787964,
0.6952594518661499,
-0.3949805796146393,
-0.34522953629493713,
0.9856075644493103,
0.08099773526191711,
0.3565625250339508,
0.3010624051094055,
-0.023088473826646805,
-0.38771364092826843,
-0.34323549270629883,
-0.7403003573417664,
-0.006244083400815725,
-0.7503110766410828,
-0.2101372331380844,
-0.256859689950943,
-0.18172013759613037,
-0.4890952408313751,
0.14724424481391907,
-0.3865340054035187,
-0.126561239361763,
0.2633552551269531,
0.04907163605093956,
-0.282572478055954,
0.2636585533618927,
0.14591608941555023,
0.07289201021194458,
-0.7289259433746338,
0.3061510920524597,
0.28810957074165344,
0.5053800344467163,
-0.013558761216700077,
-0.25343650579452515,
-0.17799869179725647,
-0.02210495062172413,
-0.5050157904624939,
-0.5292460322380066,
0.04592340439558029,
0.06963397562503815,
0.919119656085968,
0.5987941026687622,
0.14074914157390594,
1.2186087369918823,
-0.5261529684066772,
0.9455012679100037,
0.21212486922740936,
-0.9210041165351868,
0.23685158789157867,
-0.07540049403905869,
0.4550277292728424,
0.5719422101974487,
-0.14420531690120697,
-0.621301531791687,
-0.2364882230758667,
-0.35531437397003174,
-0.6859015822410583,
0.6136465668678284,
0.05685563385486603,
-0.06133883446455002,
0.3253380358219147,
-0.2193729132413864,
-0.05999879539012909,
0.22229605913162231,
-0.5751622319221497,
-0.04480539262294769,
-0.36645248532295227,
-0.5574069619178772,
-0.19746489822864532,
0.02284931391477585,
-0.32651033997535706,
-0.22058384120464325,
0.38137727975845337,
-0.3768845498561859,
-0.13304202258586884,
0.05716000497341156,
-0.22909314930438995,
-0.0989115983247757,
0.001229663728736341,
0.7757630944252014,
0.7273824214935303,
-0.017565209418535233,
0.05222680792212486,
0.18324483931064606,
-0.1567685902118683,
-0.21779225766658783,
0.3256736695766449,
0.1874752640724182,
-0.10680674016475677,
0.4467225968837738,
0.8221173286437988,
0.20086531341075897,
-0.9524530172348022,
0.8067697882652283,
-0.3203340172767639,
-0.12176503241062164,
-0.33895063400268555,
0.11353711038827896,
0.025648465380072594,
0.3424631357192993,
0.005690702237188816,
-0.13807560503482819,
0.05378163233399391,
-0.38270166516304016,
0.3057813346385956,
0.7156995534896851,
-0.5871427059173584,
-0.2795735001564026,
0.8182422518730164,
0.060283515602350235,
-0.19176411628723145,
0.6371288895606995,
0.13726653158664703,
-0.4733515679836273,
0.4973783791065216,
0.1955288201570511,
0.8075432181358337,
-0.4265071153640747,
-0.03365826979279518,
0.2742830514907837,
0.33836352825164795,
-0.02444961667060852,
0.04709917679429054,
-0.13635267317295074,
-0.6978003978729248,
-0.3651234209537506,
-0.550763726234436,
-0.585808277130127,
-0.1497860848903656,
-0.6802191138267517,
0.5708180069923401,
-0.27002328634262085,
0.024323416873812675,
0.22640351951122284,
-0.19008097052574158,
-0.5488882660865784,
-0.015585299581289291,
0.3668327033519745,
0.8334043025970459,
-0.5706162452697754,
0.853905975818634,
0.8819218277931213,
-0.34261566400527954,
-0.8542218804359436,
0.026168692857027054,
0.5816530585289001,
-1.1394076347351074,
0.3051230013370514,
0.46124890446662903,
-0.22195446491241455,
-0.2868923842906952,
-0.45872440934181213,
-0.6573314070701599,
1.3559250831604004,
0.5606579780578613,
-0.5842073559761047,
0.07089395821094513,
-0.04280577600002289,
0.5953317284584045,
-0.0706702321767807,
0.38184401392936707,
0.5262860059738159,
0.815841555595398,
0.05799289792776108,
-1.4519587755203247,
0.0027279991190880537,
-0.5023860335350037,
-0.10799820721149445,
0.2523897588253021,
-1.0092644691467285,
0.8649085760116577,
-0.0400056466460228,
-0.23222340643405914,
0.3662790358066559,
0.36380311846733093,
0.13511963188648224,
0.30039411783218384,
0.6517447233200073,
0.625309407711029,
0.6023825407028198,
-0.14229802787303925,
0.8959748148918152,
-0.34498509764671326,
0.20543041825294495,
1.3197342157363892,
-0.6345238089561462,
0.8533833622932434,
0.7188570499420166,
0.048719435930252075,
0.27626940608024597,
0.4562157094478607,
-0.4104920029640198,
0.32242289185523987,
0.04883549362421036,
0.08858387917280197,
-0.29501670598983765,
-0.1898288130760193,
-0.20014801621437073,
0.6154621243476868,
-0.086590476334095,
-0.034650787711143494,
-0.33101794123649597,
-0.15925727784633636,
-0.32194384932518005,
-0.008959819562733173,
-0.17798994481563568,
0.8237463235855103,
-0.17130175232887268,
-0.9720418453216553,
0.34678617119789124,
-0.26428937911987305,
0.40232059359550476,
-0.6868487000465393,
-0.16399754583835602,
-0.06935760378837585,
0.48118850588798523,
-0.24109266698360443,
-0.9101739525794983,
0.08847621083259583,
-0.2436503767967224,
0.2600986063480377,
-0.06248052045702934,
0.4599002003669739,
-0.4572700262069702,
-0.15719670057296753,
0.3584011495113373,
0.40870118141174316,
-0.08651057630777359,
0.030000481754541397,
-0.8765305280685425,
0.13974012434482574,
0.1726042628288269,
-0.1325739026069641,
0.40815287828445435,
0.33927157521247864,
-0.2667236030101776,
0.5864197015762329,
0.575789749622345,
-0.23315298557281494,
0.050237733870744705,
0.08391104638576508,
0.7480905652046204,
-0.6052863597869873,
-0.0752863809466362,
-0.9635240435600281,
0.7738530039787292,
-0.41561058163642883,
-0.5472142696380615,
1.1956961154937744,
0.65101158618927,
1.0236225128173828,
0.07796373218297958,
0.5366207361221313,
-0.09866660088300705,
0.2226552814245224,
-0.4299654960632324,
0.4605163633823395,
-0.9665756821632385,
-0.038887664675712585,
-0.5365174412727356,
-1.0526914596557617,
-0.3223720192909241,
0.5151135325431824,
-0.1284957081079483,
-0.13558462262153625,
0.4646381437778473,
0.7559177279472351,
-0.13685940206050873,
-0.11503582447767258,
0.5041956901550293,
-0.08109565079212189,
0.4892330467700958,
0.5151138305664062,
0.8970215320587158,
-0.30308014154434204,
0.6991650462150574,
-0.11740273237228394,
-0.14238783717155457,
-0.2233959138393402,
-0.9310120344161987,
-0.6197205185890198,
-0.5787290334701538,
-0.15375950932502747,
-0.07602308690547943,
-0.3588302433490753,
0.6757658123970032,
0.5009291768074036,
-0.6021895408630371,
-0.2602826654911041,
0.3799189031124115,
0.003982576075941324,
-0.5424383878707886,
-0.15903019905090332,
0.33155468106269836,
-0.19479474425315857,
-0.7738377451896667,
0.19166655838489532,
0.4096424877643585,
-0.02208498679101467,
-0.437122106552124,
-0.13502176105976105,
-0.02404957078397274,
-0.21180152893066406,
0.5044600963592529,
0.3160249888896942,
-0.8776782751083374,
-0.31429603695869446,
0.13388244807720184,
-0.2766023874282837,
0.06835680454969406,
0.5959370732307434,
-0.33318468928337097,
0.9628576636314392,
0.28854772448539734,
0.8408610224723816,
0.08575795590877533,
0.28054410219192505,
0.7603745460510254,
-0.576591432094574,
0.0665910616517067,
0.03724170848727226,
0.6492090225219727,
0.484485000371933,
0.15725666284561157,
0.5500912070274353,
-0.19267980754375458,
-0.45132485032081604,
-0.8841435313224792,
0.01724226586520672,
-1.2125208377838135,
-0.1115993782877922,
0.9087620377540588,
-0.1131889745593071,
-0.330425500869751,
0.13265743851661682,
-0.7119206786155701,
0.16849730908870697,
0.0002706079394556582,
0.4252215325832367,
0.9218396544456482,
-0.05065353214740753,
-0.37640896439552307,
-0.6719019412994385,
0.24060840904712677,
0.6221857666969299,
-0.6030791401863098,
0.3395964503288269,
0.753691554069519,
0.03491400182247162,
0.34598562121391296,
0.3963947892189026,
-0.3041815459728241,
0.4747869372367859,
-0.10252001881599426,
0.12620574235916138,
0.09643859416246414,
0.009551910683512688,
-0.3657996952533722,
-0.05447234958410263,
0.09204326570034027,
-0.22589929401874542
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09290v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09290v1
|
Exploring Spoken Language Identification Strategies for Automatic Transcription of Multilingual Broadcast and Institutional Speech
| 2024-06-13T16:27:56 | 2024-06-13T16:27:56 |
Martina Valente, Fabio Brugnara, Giovanni Morrone, Enrico Zovato, Leonardo Badino
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
This paper addresses spoken language identification (SLI) and speech
recognition of multilingual broadcast and institutional speech, real
application scenarios that have been rarely addressed in the SLI literature.
Observing that in these domains language changes are mostly associated with
speaker changes, we propose a cascaded system consisting of speaker diarization
and language identification and compare it with more traditional language
identification and language diarization systems. Results show that the proposed
system often achieves lower language classification and language diarization
error rates (up to 10% relative language diarization error reduction and 60%
relative language confusion reduction) and leads to lower WERs on multilingual
test sets (more than 8% relative WER reduction), while at the same time does
not negatively affect speech recognition on monolingual audio (with an absolute
WER increase between 0.1% and 0.7% w.r.t. monolingual ASR).
|
[
-0.36550211906433105,
-0.6812426447868347,
0.03694837540388107,
0.20883509516716003,
0.1336444765329361,
0.6619887351989746,
-0.2845246195793152,
-0.5452598333358765,
0.16898377239704132,
0.21899861097335815,
-0.24046260118484497,
-0.2390434890985489,
-0.29030555486679077,
0.26165565848350525,
-0.5239443182945251,
0.6799885630607605,
0.1522212028503418,
0.32725435495376587,
0.23268775641918182,
-0.09837102890014648,
-0.48683106899261475,
-0.6262059807777405,
-0.9734983444213867,
-0.3993566334247589,
0.632599413394928,
0.21010278165340424,
0.27988284826278687,
0.6200749278068542,
0.4642247259616852,
0.41843855381011963,
-0.09631035476922989,
-0.010208849795162678,
-0.06861376017332077,
-0.13055457174777985,
0.0954432561993599,
-0.10875656455755234,
-0.32474440336227417,
-0.009924075566232204,
1.1343443393707275,
0.8108422160148621,
-0.29593029618263245,
0.32905933260917664,
-0.052257828414440155,
0.39222368597984314,
-0.7377888560295105,
0.23072341084480286,
-0.448047012090683,
0.11944112926721573,
-0.6288888454437256,
-0.34257984161376953,
-0.7239798307418823,
-0.23628607392311096,
0.03713741898536682,
-0.3304709196090698,
0.11123073846101761,
-0.22767525911331177,
0.8122080564498901,
0.03779980167746544,
-0.33425524830818176,
-0.37384381890296936,
-1.3615151643753052,
0.7104741930961609,
-0.813988447189331,
0.6013655066490173,
0.10442345589399338,
0.31113171577453613,
0.3653247654438019,
-0.422885537147522,
-0.4916939437389374,
-0.06242585927248001,
-0.34183821082115173,
0.023942790925502777,
-0.20706206560134888,
-0.09557241201400757,
0.253737211227417,
0.05490516498684883,
-0.6539039611816406,
0.13333401083946228,
-0.5076504945755005,
-0.5872313976287842,
0.6632087826728821,
-0.04584936797618866,
0.466069757938385,
0.1998862773180008,
-0.10118333995342255,
0.011616010218858719,
-0.5406529307365417,
0.22167877852916718,
0.4192243814468384,
0.7782561779022217,
-0.08340402692556381,
0.09023381769657135,
0.05986923351883888,
0.5982207655906677,
0.19706982374191284,
-0.6563885807991028,
0.601661205291748,
-0.2686697840690613,
-0.24659757316112518,
0.6447826623916626,
0.7389249801635742,
-0.20198795199394226,
0.13617390394210815,
-0.1983226090669632,
-0.37915661931037903,
0.005868083797395229,
0.026350246742367744,
-0.3097318708896637,
0.05741218104958534,
-0.01448165625333786,
-0.3019562363624573,
-0.06446284800767899,
0.35594767332077026,
-0.5721887350082397,
-0.15297776460647583,
-0.5083654522895813,
0.5213964581489563,
-0.3889339864253998,
-0.395386278629303,
-0.33599406480789185,
-0.15209418535232544,
0.6623134613037109,
0.2436741441488266,
-0.8833306431770325,
0.5191286206245422,
0.7150537371635437,
0.710781991481781,
-0.36675599217414856,
-0.33826377987861633,
-0.6887810826301575,
0.4202675223350525,
-0.4803543984889984,
0.3822244703769684,
-0.3927992880344391,
-0.3183848261833191,
0.34095779061317444,
0.00013891523121856153,
-0.3908109664916992,
-0.6856956481933594,
0.12577073276042938,
-0.8007621765136719,
-0.011814374476671219,
-0.20019689202308655,
-0.14226627349853516,
0.19642029702663422,
-0.24864044785499573,
-0.7907438278198242,
0.8330376744270325,
-0.1670857071876526,
-0.7472901940345764,
0.4050835371017456,
-0.5259931087493896,
-0.7017129063606262,
0.27494409680366516,
-0.08888077735900879,
-0.5561603307723999,
-0.1398906260728836,
-0.03274919465184212,
0.07152416557073593,
0.20901821553707123,
0.2575414180755615,
0.1605478674173355,
-0.46008777618408203,
0.3254714012145996,
-0.600164532661438,
0.7277034521102905,
0.5532266497612,
-0.3173533082008362,
-0.1967802494764328,
-1.102500081062317,
-0.06637272238731384,
-0.14790472388267517,
-0.6596736907958984,
-0.5562828183174133,
0.1475231647491455,
0.31977716088294983,
-0.07834073156118393,
0.2823581099510193,
-0.7453984022140503,
0.048683080822229385,
-0.26101189851760864,
0.30657073855400085,
0.6336067318916321,
-0.17058591544628143,
0.49620112776756287,
-0.18826788663864136,
0.30714231729507446,
0.3017028868198395,
0.17264065146446228,
0.013406561687588692,
-0.34375160932540894,
-0.8166913390159607,
-0.45859861373901367,
0.6078459024429321,
1.1455227136611938,
-0.5594696402549744,
0.021336030215024948,
-0.38375261425971985,
-0.2051059752702713,
-0.7956355214118958,
-0.006347944959998131,
0.8173044919967651,
0.2951633036136627,
0.2818417251110077,
-0.29795876145362854,
-0.9982481002807617,
-0.8487385511398315,
-0.2690618634223938,
-0.5315694808959961,
0.12496317923069,
0.13516119122505188,
0.10669434070587158,
-0.15831127762794495,
1.0290559530258179,
0.04276129603385925,
-0.2857135832309723,
-0.1963682621717453,
0.2473369538784027,
0.2152951955795288,
0.36461788415908813,
0.2138153612613678,
-0.8436864018440247,
-0.6957750916481018,
0.32916128635406494,
-0.5547617673873901,
-0.44433167576789856,
-0.2377936691045761,
0.5231384634971619,
0.005585790146142244,
0.5863465070724487,
-0.2546686828136444,
0.3582521975040436,
0.3326258659362793,
0.18389347195625305,
0.47963741421699524,
-0.20811592042446136,
0.17273373901844025,
-0.7639727592468262,
0.0446917824447155,
-0.022878630086779594,
-0.15645071864128113,
-1.3124067783355713,
-0.13981802761554718,
0.12186456471681595,
-0.18091553449630737,
-0.6586899161338806,
0.3308083415031433,
-0.5963977575302124,
-0.1585569828748703,
0.014178240671753883,
0.07104424387216568,
-0.4147064983844757,
0.27811384201049805,
-0.035607315599918365,
1.1028213500976562,
0.7100078463554382,
-0.7865474820137024,
0.30674508213996887,
0.12822750210762024,
-0.37433305382728577,
0.5125967860221863,
-0.4432993233203888,
0.39501044154167175,
-0.25459060072898865,
0.17699775099754333,
-1.017600178718567,
0.11162953078746796,
0.053052548319101334,
-0.43056029081344604,
0.7336423397064209,
-0.033481523394584656,
-0.07434744387865067,
-0.3679772615432739,
0.10214247554540634,
0.574362576007843,
0.2952347993850708,
-0.5291939377784729,
0.6689739227294922,
0.711005449295044,
-0.38484281301498413,
-0.7535291314125061,
-0.8239052891731262,
0.398416668176651,
-0.4103845953941345,
-0.09931014478206635,
0.4391479790210724,
-0.054318659007549286,
-0.5657031536102295,
-0.5303431749343872,
0.25545915961265564,
-0.2915820777416229,
-0.1643228530883789,
0.16232407093048096,
0.1375761777162552,
-0.4561857283115387,
0.08815949410200119,
-0.010368715040385723,
-0.3096785545349121,
-0.31736767292022705,
-0.22694964706897736,
0.30032551288604736,
-0.05451199412345886,
-0.3926740884780884,
-1.155353307723999,
0.746025562286377,
0.6371361613273621,
-0.4369615912437439,
0.41924387216567993,
0.9854278564453125,
-0.22945761680603027,
0.07912933826446533,
-0.8579567074775696,
0.18674792349338531,
-0.46965357661247253,
0.20548810064792633,
-0.8762739300727844,
-0.5805984735488892,
0.610186755657196,
-0.03199439123272896,
0.011019289493560791,
0.1113271415233612,
0.6018975377082825,
0.10317209362983704,
1.0544456243515015,
0.21936604380607605,
-0.6775212287902832,
0.7077605128288269,
-0.036288995295763016,
0.294065922498703,
-0.7552841901779175,
0.020317601040005684,
-0.9135370254516602,
-0.13503821194171906,
-0.7409629821777344,
-0.14645473659038544,
0.3397092819213867,
-0.23361115157604218,
0.07883071154356003,
0.6438052654266357,
-0.4051850438117981,
0.26079830527305603,
0.746641993522644,
-0.1449979990720749,
0.3553672432899475,
-0.33439117670059204,
-0.13034527003765106,
0.07642801851034164,
-0.29757535457611084,
-0.5253515243530273,
0.5529108643531799,
0.3359866440296173,
0.8071011900901794,
0.3704741299152374,
0.9972701072692871,
0.7349147200584412,
0.35580965876579285,
-0.4768774211406708,
0.4190831780433655,
-0.0577421672642231,
-0.3305947184562683,
-0.544751763343811,
-0.5662578344345093,
-0.7244017720222473,
0.2269849330186844,
0.2568988800048828,
-0.6913990378379822,
0.6506855487823486,
0.16176554560661316,
-0.3628728985786438,
0.07774962484836578,
-0.8725309371948242,
0.2814045548439026,
0.13322028517723083,
0.26700669527053833,
0.05606919527053833,
-0.5568851232528687,
-0.1653868705034256,
-0.22610989212989807,
0.8355354070663452,
0.1712237447500229,
0.1594226211309433,
0.9648780226707458,
-0.001907136058434844,
0.9241980910301208,
-0.44478893280029297,
-0.20706938207149506,
0.1943918764591217,
-0.1551339328289032,
0.5416365265846252,
0.05556333437561989,
-0.4414503872394562,
0.19331510365009308,
0.24570558965206146,
-0.07352680712938309,
-0.3641986846923828,
0.7325187921524048,
-1.0186797380447388,
-0.4444906413555145,
-0.2327328771352768,
-0.22346843779087067,
-0.0885276347398758,
0.14423252642154694,
0.08926086872816086,
0.8598977327346802,
-0.5297062397003174,
-0.07027850300073624,
0.6169215440750122,
-0.12858723104000092,
0.8693188428878784,
0.8375955820083618,
0.2154756337404251,
-0.722675621509552,
1.0638837814331055,
0.025653693825006485,
0.288936585187912,
0.6604576706886292,
0.17572610080242157,
-0.11601336300373077,
-0.621535062789917,
-0.47673147916793823,
0.3308737874031067,
-0.6901096105575562,
0.0924529954791069,
-0.4955214262008667,
-0.3776389956474304,
-0.9734346270561218,
0.22965781390666962,
-0.3029944896697998,
-0.26007166504859924,
-0.35555601119995117,
0.00874877255409956,
-0.4716598093509674,
0.6635522842407227,
-0.23478928208351135,
0.27759215235710144,
-0.4878998100757599,
0.2344840168952942,
0.5457664728164673,
-0.041638389229774475,
-0.21743090450763702,
-0.6992958188056946,
-0.4443860650062561,
0.06546863913536072,
-0.04618224874138832,
-1.0251648426055908,
0.47107845544815063,
0.9392225742340088,
0.7624931931495667,
0.522587239742279,
-0.09053190052509308,
0.9059896469116211,
-1.0476173162460327,
0.627894937992096,
0.19631193578243256,
-1.1543829441070557,
0.3963586986064911,
0.057239312678575516,
0.36050763726234436,
0.4834814965724945,
0.13505543768405914,
-0.8390217423439026,
-0.6773947477340698,
-0.15494337677955627,
-0.5351654887199402,
0.8164636492729187,
-0.18212540447711945,
0.25591611862182617,
0.012812931090593338,
0.17266178131103516,
-0.06439857184886932,
0.09515833854675293,
-0.6762675642967224,
-0.45457547903060913,
-0.07761447131633759,
-0.0017376565374433994,
-0.3141900300979614,
-0.029981227591633797,
-0.22139818966388702,
-0.3868575394153595,
0.8561721444129944,
-0.02034120447933674,
0.29113397002220154,
0.3470485806465149,
-0.340791255235672,
-0.2908729910850525,
0.5589936971664429,
0.9024537205696106,
0.5180528163909912,
-0.06500221788883209,
0.3395230174064636,
0.22346721589565277,
-0.45254427194595337,
0.3097025454044342,
-0.15164704620838165,
-0.3711574971675873,
0.3701574504375458,
0.49552178382873535,
1.1030306816101074,
0.1453770250082016,
-0.2826707065105438,
0.43380433320999146,
0.07019403576850891,
-0.1944211721420288,
-0.5921066403388977,
-0.14870573580265045,
-0.27126428484916687,
0.09541716426610947,
0.6551793217658997,
-0.06283721327781677,
0.1530282199382782,
-0.6400948762893677,
0.3726763129234314,
0.5044389367103577,
-0.6710320711135864,
-0.5162857174873352,
0.4621289372444153,
0.12390044331550598,
-1.0312501192092896,
0.370498925447464,
-0.09396971762180328,
-0.47806575894355774,
0.2720690071582794,
0.723511278629303,
0.8986238837242126,
-1.1921629905700684,
0.3685409426689148,
0.2892504930496216,
0.22593054175376892,
0.3287874758243561,
-0.23847047984600067,
-0.2909282445907593,
-0.9282074570655823,
-0.24549342691898346,
-0.5846689343452454,
-0.27155035734176636,
0.17456674575805664,
-0.8962597846984863,
0.40598219633102417,
-0.19968882203102112,
-0.32418444752693176,
0.5200734734535217,
-0.22915750741958618,
-0.3312743008136749,
-0.0264146625995636,
0.7054077386856079,
0.4521440267562866,
-1.2974880933761597,
1.1065163612365723,
0.46590518951416016,
-0.11126085370779037,
-0.5938405990600586,
-0.15266549587249756,
0.2603013515472412,
-0.5182833671569824,
0.7312264442443848,
-0.131742924451828,
-0.28992003202438354,
0.22389382123947144,
-0.07332798838615417,
-0.9289594888687134,
0.909536600112915,
0.10571955144405365,
-0.5750986337661743,
-0.18050026893615723,
0.4428778886795044,
0.566885232925415,
-0.3824574947357178,
0.44190263748168945,
0.7050924897193909,
0.6971484422683716,
0.2684759199619293,
-1.6009187698364258,
-0.3477073907852173,
-0.12976089119911194,
0.21936097741127014,
0.30412542819976807,
-0.5005486607551575,
0.8286470174789429,
-0.18363933265209198,
-0.6210361123085022,
-0.054470062255859375,
0.5638725161552429,
-0.20278237760066986,
0.5700681805610657,
0.6820806264877319,
0.2665409743785858,
0.6328701376914978,
-0.12375868856906891,
0.47796323895454407,
-0.1571490466594696,
0.3700481057167053,
0.9076128602027893,
-0.5466299653053284,
0.9123039245605469,
0.6595746278762817,
-0.37849926948547363,
0.6259847283363342,
0.4694962799549103,
0.26601558923721313,
0.7236765623092651,
0.22481505572795868,
-0.5873569846153259,
-0.0035392516292631626,
0.0385575070977211,
-0.23375169932842255,
0.6437400579452515,
0.3890141546726227,
-0.1990155130624771,
-0.06696798652410507,
0.5863358974456787,
-0.18679264187812805,
-0.1978483349084854,
0.08367255330085754,
1.2570120096206665,
-0.07955202460289001,
-0.4886028468608856,
0.8329746127128601,
0.015172364190220833,
0.44838452339172363,
-0.6624495983123779,
0.12153154611587524,
-0.024339135736227036,
0.3498680889606476,
-0.16023463010787964,
0.033371392637491226,
0.3270740211009979,
-0.3454440236091614,
-0.1959148794412613,
-0.522300660610199,
0.4358579218387604,
-0.7735380530357361,
-0.30237460136413574,
0.3725472688674927,
0.37123796343803406,
0.06761028617620468,
0.4174511432647705,
-0.655208945274353,
0.3376120328903198,
-0.1462622731924057,
0.008907601237297058,
0.27799731492996216,
0.10192108899354935,
-0.11641064286231995,
0.5582864880561829,
0.7027587294578552,
0.4591366648674011,
0.2520377039909363,
0.7075307369232178,
0.37279555201530457,
-0.3170551359653473,
-0.5707448720932007,
-0.677845299243927,
0.11903668940067291,
-0.015231173485517502,
-0.020351631566882133,
0.6647495031356812,
0.6870164275169373,
0.6702407598495483,
-0.228007972240448,
0.7500026226043701,
-0.050624798983335495,
0.8228501081466675,
-0.24183772504329681,
0.5513734221458435,
-0.31037285923957825,
0.36179208755493164,
-0.7270471453666687,
-0.5169448256492615,
-0.3415364921092987,
0.36825746297836304,
-0.05182431638240814,
-0.2775518596172333,
0.6696799397468567,
1.0205503702163696,
-0.014324813149869442,
-0.13238508999347687,
0.5552807450294495,
0.14672315120697021,
0.5233798623085022,
0.1851043552160263,
0.6713190078735352,
-0.4645673632621765,
0.3745129704475403,
-0.1931891292333603,
-0.47895678877830505,
-0.11981957405805588,
-0.4908900856971741,
-0.5075634121894836,
-1.0370008945465088,
-0.6387680172920227,
-0.023882649838924408,
0.3147542178630829,
0.5085010528564453,
0.9541672468185425,
-1.2759140729904175,
-0.7172856330871582,
0.35434576869010925,
-0.04273747280240059,
-0.8434514403343201,
-0.2752302885055542,
0.2846275866031647,
-0.2686430513858795,
-0.8937596082687378,
0.8631102442741394,
0.3981644809246063,
-0.15677259862422943,
-0.3149392008781433,
-0.10332249104976654,
-0.404712438583374,
0.22032631933689117,
0.3420030474662781,
0.6632269024848938,
-0.9724389910697937,
-0.5673224925994873,
-0.22925886511802673,
-0.22069361805915833,
0.17795506119728088,
1.0476453304290771,
-0.5741220116615295,
0.494587779045105,
0.43522173166275024,
0.32385945320129395,
0.2982410788536072,
0.25008344650268555,
0.3522360324859619,
-0.9500172138214111,
0.28409236669540405,
0.1896529346704483,
0.001472676289267838,
0.28721803426742554,
-0.2914670407772064,
-0.014246633276343346,
0.4918433427810669,
-0.510483980178833,
-0.9770407676696777,
0.0714387446641922,
-1.0075976848602295,
0.4280548393726349,
1.0433818101882935,
-0.12617819011211395,
-0.19463399052619934,
-0.593622088432312,
-0.06188368797302246,
0.42483073472976685,
-0.30173036456108093,
0.6378754377365112,
0.6021503210067749,
-0.037787362933158875,
-0.2765806317329407,
-0.2931317687034607,
0.5221888422966003,
-0.06477666646242142,
-0.5123239755630493,
-0.019302191212773323,
0.18720132112503052,
0.25395673513412476,
0.724181056022644,
0.9284530878067017,
-0.09885787963867188,
0.09787401556968689,
-0.2754887044429779,
0.12143465876579285,
0.303301602602005,
-0.4474824368953705,
-0.3981419503688812,
0.043429791927337646,
-0.08233898133039474,
-0.4555552303791046
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09289v1
|
Understanding Jailbreak Success: A Study of Latent Space Dynamics in Large Language Models
| 2024-06-13T16:26:47 | 2024-06-13T16:26:47 |
Sarah Ball, Frauke Kreuter, Nina Rimsky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Conversational Large Language Models are trained to refuse to answer harmful
questions. However, emergent jailbreaking techniques can still elicit unsafe
outputs, presenting an ongoing challenge for model alignment. To better
understand how different jailbreak types circumvent safeguards, this paper
analyses model activations on different jailbreak inputs. We find that it is
possible to extract a jailbreak vector from a single class of jailbreaks that
works to mitigate jailbreak effectiveness from other classes. This may indicate
that different kinds of effective jailbreaks operate via similar internal
mechanisms. We investigate a potential common mechanism of harmfulness feature
suppression, and provide evidence for its existence by looking at the
harmfulness vector component. These findings offer actionable insights for
developing more robust jailbreak countermeasures and lay the groundwork for a
deeper, mechanistic understanding of jailbreak dynamics in language models.
|
[
-0.15171240270137787,
-1.120375394821167,
0.5479485988616943,
-0.018810639157891273,
-0.1068018227815628,
0.32977229356765747,
-0.018162334337830544,
-0.3549601137638092,
0.0011699860915541649,
0.5581174492835999,
-0.29313528537750244,
-0.31984761357307434,
-0.7664300799369812,
-0.5011401772499084,
-0.5184568166732788,
1.193013310432434,
0.08520273119211197,
-0.3018718361854553,
0.06433594971895218,
-0.07200855016708374,
-0.8191536664962769,
-0.8775815963745117,
-0.17456288635730743,
-0.14424671232700348,
0.49856552481651306,
0.3977573812007904,
0.9596313834190369,
0.4195515811443329,
0.5751680135726929,
0.2859373688697815,
-0.41880735754966736,
-0.25340554118156433,
-0.698492705821991,
0.3285416066646576,
-0.0031910487450659275,
-0.5087218880653381,
-0.23448853194713593,
0.14988230168819427,
0.3140353858470917,
0.457990437746048,
-0.19237753748893738,
-0.33584827184677124,
0.16870155930519104,
0.46004539728164673,
-0.7416172623634338,
-0.2219766080379486,
-0.7797051072120667,
-0.056639861315488815,
-0.3946115970611572,
0.224944606423378,
-0.5148317813873291,
-0.31710731983184814,
0.008443777449429035,
-0.21106530725955963,
-0.041229549795389175,
-0.18438690900802612,
0.6442784070968628,
0.15652480721473694,
-0.2449292540550232,
-0.3214055001735687,
-0.8418649435043335,
0.6187970042228699,
-0.6699683666229248,
0.260312557220459,
0.4783991873264313,
0.22992803156375885,
-0.2582114338874817,
-0.3813056945800781,
-0.2763272523880005,
-0.5648370981216431,
-0.02484658546745777,
-0.37336909770965576,
-0.32850587368011475,
0.0003298702067695558,
0.26429057121276855,
0.11328639090061188,
-0.3656185269355774,
0.336660236120224,
-0.6095535755157471,
-0.19358044862747192,
0.3754907250404358,
-0.10195812582969666,
0.6910712718963623,
-0.2769632041454315,
-0.3063720166683197,
-0.1973550021648407,
-1.0762741565704346,
0.21059423685073853,
0.7235623002052307,
0.2099241465330124,
-0.33383631706237793,
0.6901628971099854,
0.4257398247718811,
0.41879361867904663,
-0.24258245527744293,
0.1948450207710266,
0.14896632730960846,
-0.2376382201910019,
0.0324258990585804,
-0.10857393592596054,
0.7223940491676331,
0.2370615154504776,
0.16449400782585144,
-0.5253219604492188,
-0.06858731061220169,
-0.18295982480049133,
0.6653839349746704,
-0.7556271553039551,
-0.16043861210346222,
0.44377097487449646,
-0.48781076073646545,
-0.7751004099845886,
0.24039490520954132,
-0.5898817181587219,
-0.5943188071250916,
0.28947651386260986,
0.3137933313846588,
-0.6669458746910095,
-0.48680898547172546,
-0.08568618446588516,
-0.35268211364746094,
0.26052460074424744,
-0.044368110597133636,
-0.986339807510376,
0.31511685252189636,
0.8444534540176392,
0.8802958726882935,
-0.07956574112176895,
-0.1743975430727005,
-0.607233464717865,
-0.046065378934144974,
-0.31572893261909485,
0.4648778736591339,
-0.5155442953109741,
-0.3659462034702301,
-0.2036096155643463,
-0.09588928520679474,
-0.04900993034243584,
-0.7590720653533936,
0.40423384308815,
-0.7364979982376099,
-0.41689783334732056,
-0.2208021879196167,
-0.39651769399642944,
-0.27707311511039734,
0.21962110698223114,
-0.7991716265678406,
0.5299949049949646,
-0.13752196729183197,
-0.8399971723556519,
0.4252447783946991,
-0.37921133637428284,
-0.3563052713871002,
-0.23021000623703003,
0.12450012564659119,
-0.6782116889953613,
0.3008120656013489,
-0.08972717076539993,
0.5035313367843628,
0.29628583788871765,
0.4659278690814972,
-0.6838445663452148,
-0.3490421175956726,
0.5838912725448608,
-0.2874411642551422,
0.6965129375457764,
0.4643033742904663,
-0.32281073927879333,
0.29588964581489563,
-0.6988325119018555,
-0.35291624069213867,
0.33261269330978394,
-0.16138286888599396,
-0.8526966571807861,
0.38248735666275024,
-0.10556615889072418,
0.25041520595550537,
-0.1453169882297516,
-0.5729498863220215,
0.18415960669517517,
-0.4380972385406494,
0.768335223197937,
0.5742530226707458,
0.27219903469085693,
0.38634055852890015,
-0.06196001172065735,
0.4702777564525604,
0.13030217587947845,
0.08955570310354233,
-0.11532566696405411,
-0.3052992522716522,
-0.11027857661247253,
-0.10240350663661957,
-0.024665459990501404,
0.7311292290687561,
-0.38793280720710754,
0.1841050237417221,
0.16623206436634064,
-0.6598157286643982,
-0.16689829528331757,
0.358222097158432,
0.6473312973976135,
0.2944495975971222,
0.3029846251010895,
-0.38820722699165344,
-0.4247503876686096,
-0.8176612257957458,
-0.5052789449691772,
-0.31616759300231934,
0.3555864095687866,
0.04324600100517273,
0.4270578920841217,
-0.009181180037558079,
0.6167672872543335,
-0.20792502164840698,
0.14344537258148193,
-0.4915436804294586,
0.12721151113510132,
0.15018415451049805,
0.7360527515411377,
0.8653971552848816,
-0.8008331060409546,
0.23788395524024963,
-0.30724433064460754,
-0.7914042472839355,
-0.028880596160888672,
-0.17740796506404877,
0.13877661526203156,
-0.26260918378829956,
1.009321928024292,
-0.4906751811504364,
0.6531032919883728,
0.41919469833374023,
-0.742473840713501,
0.6900151968002319,
-0.04054398834705353,
0.08496718853712082,
-0.7937972545623779,
0.033138636499643326,
-0.06305316090583801,
-0.1149323359131813,
-0.7697708606719971,
0.4493870139122009,
0.08087339252233505,
-0.18284325301647186,
-0.6709867715835571,
-0.08492778241634369,
-0.2070387750864029,
0.03842772915959358,
-0.14578379690647125,
0.2158268690109253,
-0.33596399426460266,
0.044352639466524124,
-0.3321199119091034,
0.7768809199333191,
0.27838417887687683,
-0.4400040805339813,
0.05655209720134735,
0.3111132085323334,
-0.30720841884613037,
-0.1113521009683609,
-0.98919278383255,
0.07558055967092514,
-0.15483815968036652,
-0.2579483389854431,
-1.2512458562850952,
-0.10459291934967041,
0.06543179601430893,
-0.48401549458503723,
0.2755722999572754,
-0.5940269827842712,
-0.37042006850242615,
-0.4530036747455597,
-0.27716386318206787,
0.39391008019447327,
0.4262246787548065,
-0.3759494721889496,
0.05734411999583244,
0.5573288798332214,
-0.18597719073295593,
-0.652507483959198,
-0.45895907282829285,
0.12364393472671509,
-0.6576037406921387,
-0.5539255738258362,
0.034592583775520325,
0.021184632554650307,
-0.6748005747795105,
-0.08880824595689774,
0.09030762314796448,
0.016204163432121277,
0.8121558427810669,
0.5664117336273193,
0.5913112163543701,
0.05269252881407738,
-0.018170811235904694,
0.03059821017086506,
0.12390648573637009,
0.4643569886684418,
-0.07523069530725479,
0.5984050035476685,
-0.06506101787090302,
-0.33802056312561035,
-0.16101022064685822,
0.187607079744339,
0.7503318786621094,
-0.3464824855327606,
1.236283302307129,
0.18094874918460846,
-0.18063229322433472,
0.013650148175656796,
-0.1873258501291275,
-0.1327291578054428,
-0.4766121208667755,
0.5456684827804565,
-0.4115520417690277,
-1.0872520208358765,
0.8208783268928528,
0.07023953646421432,
0.2017558515071869,
0.20555706322193146,
0.4317266643047333,
0.16060201823711395,
0.8069877624511719,
0.7370119094848633,
-0.07142733782529831,
0.5868922472000122,
-0.12788984179496765,
0.5158969163894653,
-0.6283884048461914,
-0.32248032093048096,
-0.7156404852867126,
0.007063835859298706,
-0.5221332907676697,
-0.22391155362129211,
0.08683856576681137,
0.5603964328765869,
-0.23662114143371582,
0.7331629395484924,
-0.2980550527572632,
0.5135783553123474,
0.13822470605373383,
0.12547628581523895,
0.03425493463873863,
-0.09161316603422165,
-0.3256857395172119,
-0.2070748209953308,
-0.42915886640548706,
-0.552013099193573,
0.9228416681289673,
0.6466477513313293,
0.9961996078491211,
0.4727609157562256,
0.6285118460655212,
0.2479795515537262,
0.20947912335395813,
-0.6016794443130493,
0.34140920639038086,
-0.08501796424388885,
-0.8064562678337097,
-0.1156701073050499,
-0.38037964701652527,
-0.8853960037231445,
0.18485867977142334,
-0.3755875527858734,
-1.2630876302719116,
-0.03460760414600372,
0.2480056881904602,
-0.43970799446105957,
0.48050397634506226,
-0.8302386403083801,
1.1299076080322266,
-0.232405424118042,
-0.676049530506134,
-0.43394461274147034,
-0.6951594948768616,
0.6667224168777466,
-0.1254560649394989,
0.6159825325012207,
0.003348447848111391,
0.4693455100059509,
0.7640703320503235,
-0.6215316653251648,
0.861632764339447,
-0.49100634455680847,
-0.25303930044174194,
0.4373936951160431,
0.5267199873924255,
0.4748804271221161,
-0.008515539579093456,
0.07438457012176514,
-0.0005900393007323146,
-0.21129900217056274,
-0.20223166048526764,
-0.4915817081928253,
0.5680463910102844,
-0.720952570438385,
-0.6988917589187622,
0.027794249355793,
-0.47790586948394775,
-0.1608966588973999,
0.18815484642982483,
0.3013708293437958,
0.27297505736351013,
-0.33919093012809753,
0.20805147290229797,
0.7469982504844666,
-0.6366475224494934,
0.5724694132804871,
0.23289044201374054,
-0.4481363892555237,
-0.04438012093305588,
0.6853554248809814,
0.06920398771762848,
0.591079592704773,
-0.04359423369169235,
0.12419252097606659,
-0.0963619276881218,
-0.9134278297424316,
-0.16569170355796814,
-0.00022836661082692444,
-0.5036841630935669,
0.14654958248138428,
-0.6975864768028259,
-0.4195081889629364,
-0.45133867859840393,
-0.11898926645517349,
-0.4406655430793762,
-0.4459577798843384,
0.056232914328575134,
-0.5158534049987793,
0.22295920550823212,
0.971356987953186,
-0.25275319814682007,
0.40521153807640076,
-1.0299549102783203,
0.3125140368938446,
0.16687385737895966,
0.3490525186061859,
0.2589094340801239,
-0.6741253733634949,
-0.17183507978916168,
-0.24900905787944794,
-0.4832581579685211,
-1.1727933883666992,
0.292767733335495,
-0.13280341029167175,
0.649922788143158,
0.5303046703338623,
-0.07857474684715271,
0.39427119493484497,
-0.6291268467903137,
0.8247208595275879,
0.2805593013763428,
-0.9894775152206421,
1.047877311706543,
-0.543593168258667,
-0.11221026629209518,
0.4851289987564087,
0.16697357594966888,
-0.421532541513443,
-0.7689715027809143,
-0.6448887586593628,
-1.2115105390548706,
0.31414687633514404,
0.20083479583263397,
0.3946947455406189,
-0.0020734253339469433,
0.4789874851703644,
0.1715318262577057,
0.04402082785964012,
-0.9785786271095276,
-0.2028275728225708,
-0.14317749440670013,
0.13058516383171082,
0.03603445366024971,
-0.44185298681259155,
-0.10051599144935608,
-0.04864693805575371,
0.4402559697628021,
0.42209216952323914,
-0.015619364567101002,
-0.0763602927327156,
-0.2506006062030792,
0.05477936565876007,
0.4679010808467865,
0.5226324796676636,
0.29613491892814636,
-0.2524798512458801,
0.04555310681462288,
-0.3390714228153229,
-0.7448809146881104,
0.4248020350933075,
-0.050239257514476776,
-0.19924698770046234,
-0.42626944184303284,
0.43695080280303955,
0.8272831439971924,
0.20111043751239777,
-0.6296581625938416,
0.6542378664016724,
-0.11284244060516357,
0.0061119841411709785,
-0.11975802481174469,
0.5305941700935364,
-0.15675584971904755,
0.21482574939727783,
0.22923411428928375,
0.2686200439929962,
0.07471808046102524,
-0.6734751462936401,
0.47100305557250977,
0.5954187512397766,
-0.5666999816894531,
-0.4886791706085205,
1.0266598463058472,
0.004906183108687401,
-0.21451833844184875,
0.7351242899894714,
-0.1307198405265808,
-0.5957441329956055,
0.7678589820861816,
0.6734867691993713,
0.7882937788963318,
-0.18700657784938812,
0.20164188742637634,
0.41977155208587646,
0.6529673933982849,
0.1003044843673706,
0.08453980088233948,
0.04337403550744057,
-0.9796415567398071,
-0.6185304522514343,
-0.4474385976791382,
-0.19924479722976685,
0.38527753949165344,
-0.7468651533126831,
0.10309319943189621,
-0.5721035599708557,
-0.034496158361434937,
0.1796106994152069,
-0.687437891960144,
-0.1831415295600891,
-0.1406882405281067,
0.31821104884147644,
0.9002275466918945,
-1.0722092390060425,
0.7421279549598694,
0.495061993598938,
-0.31408700346946716,
-1.077280044555664,
0.126433327794075,
0.4415211081504822,
-0.4616239368915558,
0.5469506978988647,
0.39140158891677856,
-0.08304224163293839,
-0.5091200470924377,
-0.8140062093734741,
-0.8197634220123291,
0.3346248269081116,
0.33190903067588806,
-0.6877614259719849,
0.1437016725540161,
-0.22285689413547516,
0.3236386179924011,
-0.05121771991252899,
-0.2934940457344055,
0.7766550779342651,
0.25470420718193054,
-0.07505693286657333,
-0.6781504154205322,
0.1468549519777298,
-0.3557877540588379,
-0.22375494241714478,
0.3995923399925232,
-0.2581862211227417,
0.557778000831604,
-0.8703961968421936,
0.03196701407432556,
0.23151332139968872,
0.45166242122650146,
0.5260237455368042,
0.08915667980909348,
0.56331866979599,
0.6743565797805786,
0.46959254145622253,
-0.1630048006772995,
1.0627177953720093,
-0.1623626947402954,
0.2095908522605896,
1.0959140062332153,
-0.08407995849847794,
0.8239840865135193,
0.5322902202606201,
-0.07100727409124374,
0.6266033053398132,
0.40970417857170105,
-0.06373998522758484,
0.7381395697593689,
0.35475048422813416,
-0.03354565426707268,
-0.15664657950401306,
0.34140533208847046,
-0.08950182795524597,
0.7972173094749451,
0.5257492661476135,
-0.36350521445274353,
-0.06333421170711517,
0.4409509301185608,
0.38053345680236816,
0.06930772960186005,
-0.21158893406391144,
0.7945684194564819,
0.03983171284198761,
-0.6886543035507202,
0.40479516983032227,
0.02201938070356846,
0.3975275456905365,
-0.5271781086921692,
0.009745616465806961,
0.05109269171953201,
0.1339755654335022,
-0.16290703415870667,
-0.9517573118209839,
0.640013575553894,
0.2529256343841553,
-0.10713993012905121,
0.11014313250780106,
0.8618375062942505,
-0.10261847823858261,
0.03447364643216133,
0.7130311727523804,
0.45939111709594727,
0.2278311550617218,
0.0708252415060997,
-0.5009426474571228,
0.25658413767814636,
-0.034172579646110535,
-0.31011611223220825,
0.2831191122531891,
0.18692316114902496,
-0.20453184843063354,
0.5568199157714844,
0.6486908197402954,
0.23406024277210236,
0.16712941229343414,
0.1242758110165596,
0.9612948894500732,
-0.6869015693664551,
-0.6231904029846191,
-1.2028396129608154,
0.6888672709465027,
-0.13440658152103424,
-0.16273726522922516,
0.8871635794639587,
0.30893030762672424,
0.537085771560669,
0.23443779349327087,
0.7477412223815918,
-0.34710174798965454,
0.19713787734508514,
-0.5090835094451904,
1.0939011573791504,
-0.23517419397830963,
0.7421886920928955,
-0.6094896197319031,
-0.7303609251976013,
-0.2568438649177551,
0.5302402377128601,
-0.4350694417953491,
-0.15370583534240723,
0.41064023971557617,
0.6107864379882812,
0.0018867345061153173,
-0.007808862719684839,
0.3332129120826721,
0.4856407344341278,
0.5492658019065857,
0.31031903624534607,
1.0892292261123657,
-0.2985037863254547,
0.4876413941383362,
-0.0594046488404274,
-0.27486658096313477,
0.11792346090078354,
-0.6949538588523865,
-0.8845468759536743,
-0.473804771900177,
-0.15235674381256104,
-0.8218468427658081,
0.17743150889873505,
0.4305649995803833,
0.8010290265083313,
-0.8271295428276062,
0.0268899817019701,
-0.27022185921669006,
0.2704484164714813,
-0.08904548734426498,
-0.24517662823200226,
-0.011135343462228775,
-0.3372166156768799,
-0.04092679172754288,
0.6071804761886597,
0.2652708888053894,
0.1427435725927353,
-0.0049097537994384766,
0.1756254881620407,
-0.011419720016419888,
0.1427275389432907,
0.4219120442867279,
0.4257514774799347,
-0.3678540289402008,
-0.40598413348197937,
-0.2196042388677597,
-0.0989622175693512,
-0.037429533898830414,
1.0869569778442383,
-0.749635636806488,
0.18829254806041718,
0.2353532314300537,
0.6165030598640442,
0.2369646579027176,
-0.11101026833057404,
0.5279906988143921,
-0.9563901424407959,
0.5953276753425598,
-0.0019315124955028296,
0.3729073703289032,
0.2789221405982971,
-0.49407681822776794,
0.35208043456077576,
0.20742644369602203,
-0.5631986260414124,
-0.7788151502609253,
0.30682072043418884,
-0.48659536242485046,
-0.6794191598892212,
0.9772465825080872,
-0.33093544840812683,
-0.29715216159820557,
-0.28919461369514465,
-0.06927620619535446,
0.13307228684425354,
-0.22016145288944244,
0.9099477529525757,
0.9011215567588806,
0.04574178531765938,
-0.25479212403297424,
-0.670269250869751,
0.3723039925098419,
0.3498050570487976,
-0.714064359664917,
0.3725310266017914,
0.43773970007896423,
0.4549887180328369,
0.2514632046222687,
0.19852879643440247,
-0.5732825398445129,
0.32257649302482605,
-0.1623365581035614,
-0.17418651282787323,
0.08254262059926987,
-0.4640219211578369,
-0.44738003611564636,
0.4984572231769562,
0.2550945580005646,
0.04529222846031189
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09282v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09282v1
|
On the Effects of Heterogeneous Data Sources on Speech-to-Text Foundation Models
| 2024-06-13T16:22:37 | 2024-06-13T16:22:37 |
Jinchuan Tian, Yifan Peng, William Chen, Kwanghee Choi, Karen Livescu, Shinji Watanabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
The Open Whisper-style Speech Model (OWSM) series was introduced to achieve
full transparency in building advanced speech-to-text (S2T) foundation models.
To this end, OWSM models are trained on 25 public speech datasets, which are
heterogeneous in multiple ways. In this study, we advance the OWSM series by
introducing OWSM v3.2, which improves on prior models by investigating and
addressing the impacts of this data heterogeneity. Our study begins with a
detailed analysis of each dataset, from which we derive two key strategies:
data filtering with proxy task to enhance data quality, and the incorporation
of punctuation and true-casing using an open large language model (LLM). With
all other configurations staying the same, OWSM v3.2 improves performance over
the OWSM v3.1 baseline while using 15% less training data.
|
[
-0.17994268238544464,
-0.7488678097724915,
0.4740326404571533,
0.33522650599479675,
-0.15977391600608826,
-0.13752450048923492,
-0.08072805404663086,
-0.7380663156509399,
-0.18494723737239838,
0.8652126789093018,
-0.5818907022476196,
-0.5762898325920105,
-0.6299442052841187,
0.03653623163700104,
-0.4787764251232147,
0.9290506839752197,
-0.047633152455091476,
0.16838282346725464,
-0.1499490886926651,
-0.15666227042675018,
-0.25639769434928894,
-0.5092315077781677,
-0.1254582405090332,
-0.33369508385658264,
0.1598631590604782,
0.4374048411846161,
0.9158758521080017,
0.946467399597168,
0.31134870648384094,
0.24899694323539734,
-0.18057933449745178,
-0.18357591331005096,
-0.6819955110549927,
0.0806647390127182,
-0.13884621858596802,
-0.637269914150238,
-0.15633369982242584,
0.28311023116111755,
0.8285921812057495,
1.0404934883117676,
-0.44107165932655334,
0.0415172353386879,
0.2286989837884903,
0.4077518582344055,
-0.5684260725975037,
0.06885377317667007,
-0.7580650448799133,
0.2115316390991211,
-0.51578688621521,
-0.07768724858760834,
-0.4276994466781616,
-0.20134347677230835,
0.6512452363967896,
-0.49885132908821106,
0.18100696802139282,
0.08581800013780594,
0.5854148864746094,
0.1757630556821823,
-0.17161759734153748,
-0.099822998046875,
-0.8051367998123169,
0.832563042640686,
-0.7029412984848022,
0.6247365474700928,
0.5150189399719238,
0.2099943608045578,
-0.06594327092170715,
-1.0139527320861816,
-0.4541533589363098,
0.1918412744998932,
0.17845207452774048,
0.050606753677129745,
-0.3537769317626953,
-0.009048448875546455,
0.2816440463066101,
0.4283459484577179,
-0.29035744071006775,
0.31144165992736816,
-0.45708584785461426,
-0.3231978714466095,
0.3881530463695526,
0.2469521462917328,
-0.05936635658144951,
0.12750348448753357,
-0.4473395347595215,
0.04223677143454552,
-0.6779507398605347,
0.01294386014342308,
0.5865406394004822,
0.735197126865387,
-0.3682534694671631,
0.6737098693847656,
-0.43657591938972473,
0.7180972695350647,
-0.27945902943611145,
-0.3537953794002533,
0.3767245411872864,
-0.2185991406440735,
-0.2790275812149048,
0.04561132937669754,
0.36345231533050537,
0.11055640131235123,
0.0752381682395935,
-0.2151382565498352,
-0.05739554017782211,
0.005882462486624718,
-0.07523024082183838,
-0.9359372854232788,
-0.0009981745388358831,
0.16438506543636322,
-0.6983171105384827,
-0.3860456049442291,
0.19851577281951904,
-0.5724075436592102,
-0.4379225969314575,
-0.6344950795173645,
0.6114411950111389,
-0.15607813000679016,
-0.18316999077796936,
0.3590001165866852,
-0.30771297216415405,
-0.07837527990341187,
0.38180387020111084,
-0.44095131754875183,
0.6281797289848328,
0.5900442004203796,
0.8920684456825256,
-0.14558416604995728,
-0.15565255284309387,
-0.9639730453491211,
0.23260009288787842,
-0.16759298741817474,
0.7277933955192566,
-0.7027020454406738,
-0.5627068281173706,
0.328031986951828,
-0.23229682445526123,
0.10332763940095901,
-0.5308387279510498,
0.45222195982933044,
-0.24532032012939453,
0.7460063695907593,
-0.2886624038219452,
-0.5873265266418457,
0.10892190784215927,
-0.3255999684333801,
-0.7350391149520874,
0.9670110940933228,
-0.051763441413640976,
-0.7674052119255066,
0.08953691273927689,
-0.7552381157875061,
-0.5738147497177124,
-0.12377224117517471,
-0.33253297209739685,
-0.4462434947490692,
0.11447076499462128,
0.11175688356161118,
0.48466262221336365,
-0.35038062930107117,
0.02424933761358261,
-0.3725757598876953,
-0.4244481027126312,
-0.08961044251918793,
-0.41320812702178955,
0.8192842602729797,
0.12839919328689575,
-0.3483404219150543,
-0.20848076045513153,
-0.8357066512107849,
-0.12244266271591187,
-0.020410291850566864,
-0.2474352866411209,
-0.28768500685691833,
0.31019893288612366,
0.07359001785516739,
0.20519812405109406,
-0.1658295840024948,
-0.6872726082801819,
-0.27508777379989624,
-0.49433836340904236,
0.46161577105522156,
0.9224621057510376,
-0.07691304385662079,
0.16084669530391693,
-0.370395690202713,
0.20891602337360382,
0.038023028522729874,
0.11053399741649628,
-0.1940932273864746,
-0.8192276358604431,
-0.4545607566833496,
-0.5173142552375793,
0.2266041338443756,
0.44566527009010315,
-0.5885400176048279,
0.13438557088375092,
-0.03888639435172081,
-0.3477095067501068,
-0.6480651497840881,
-0.0436626672744751,
0.3716732859611511,
0.7354978322982788,
0.45413973927497864,
-0.05884043499827385,
-0.573624312877655,
-0.8924149870872498,
-0.29435741901397705,
-0.1855243742465973,
-0.15018777549266815,
0.26175785064697266,
0.31782689690589905,
-0.0674041286110878,
1.318235993385315,
-0.654489278793335,
-0.20855005085468292,
0.23072366416454315,
0.2233521044254303,
-0.03453386574983597,
0.2963533401489258,
0.44939225912094116,
-0.7858055830001831,
-0.34919437766075134,
-0.4153915345668793,
-0.2550898790359497,
-0.3367616534233093,
0.5562342405319214,
-0.11878668516874313,
0.1350611448287964,
0.5896949768066406,
-0.21421299874782562,
0.5690910220146179,
0.7931637167930603,
-0.4220348596572876,
0.6356845498085022,
0.44667598605155945,
-0.09296692907810211,
-1.0506656169891357,
0.0006428835913538933,
0.04873153194785118,
-0.06913045793771744,
-0.749786913394928,
-0.2554067075252533,
-0.1481138914823532,
-0.30059927701950073,
-0.5879402756690979,
0.47103461623191833,
-0.3346491754055023,
-0.16936632990837097,
-0.16967187821865082,
0.008448902517557144,
0.15741464495658875,
0.25789308547973633,
0.300471693277359,
0.8534570336341858,
0.583867609500885,
-0.43836912512779236,
0.08205115050077438,
0.4367366433143616,
-0.35704612731933594,
0.6085397005081177,
-0.7227489948272705,
0.12707167863845825,
-0.125260591506958,
0.35749879479408264,
-0.9187843799591064,
-0.09023842215538025,
-0.004916653037071228,
-0.3349553644657135,
0.13668915629386902,
-0.00747740687802434,
-0.5461808443069458,
-0.20447304844856262,
-0.5533413887023926,
-0.2926865220069885,
0.46416446566581726,
-0.8466450572013855,
0.6310464143753052,
0.3126320540904999,
-0.3350377380847931,
-0.3402385115623474,
-0.8073197603225708,
-0.1933978945016861,
-0.11958040297031403,
-0.7624984383583069,
0.5902315378189087,
-0.19956406950950623,
-0.41851353645324707,
-0.03107486478984356,
-0.33556899428367615,
-0.0911683514714241,
0.032438769936561584,
0.21871773898601532,
0.3968106806278229,
-0.44503575563430786,
0.22978442907333374,
0.04321213439106941,
0.20315589010715485,
0.1508973389863968,
-0.28082770109176636,
0.45498597621917725,
0.04840156435966492,
-0.25946661829948425,
-0.5799737572669983,
0.5034898519515991,
0.2453835904598236,
-0.18387672305107117,
0.9257948994636536,
0.4816213548183441,
-0.39369991421699524,
-0.21244312822818756,
-0.5440253615379333,
-0.2053927183151245,
-0.48611190915107727,
0.39751964807510376,
-0.5143813490867615,
-1.1088192462921143,
0.34736499190330505,
0.17316779494285583,
0.2649560570716858,
0.5146121978759766,
0.45529669523239136,
-0.2235730141401291,
1.0961045026779175,
0.7429793477058411,
-0.31120070815086365,
0.5416022539138794,
-0.0025834771804511547,
-0.1741625964641571,
-0.6655384302139282,
-0.3646615445613861,
-1.1517080068588257,
0.23589684069156647,
-0.41831621527671814,
-0.4852166771888733,
0.31384921073913574,
0.06025979295372963,
-0.1558246910572052,
0.05028843507170677,
-0.12680098414421082,
0.0747360810637474,
0.21060723066329956,
0.1727970391511917,
0.5030046105384827,
0.5320829749107361,
-0.027323907241225243,
-0.02078820951282978,
-0.6102253198623657,
-0.5318378210067749,
1.2707979679107666,
0.779772162437439,
0.7269284129142761,
0.2933346927165985,
0.291502445936203,
0.25041496753692627,
0.2584902346134186,
-0.4530998170375824,
0.29938384890556335,
-0.375794917345047,
-0.5705350041389465,
-0.3162213861942291,
-0.45436471700668335,
-0.6482550501823425,
0.4522666037082672,
-0.15148583054542542,
-0.8362120389938354,
0.23263587057590485,
0.06264501065015793,
-0.2625022232532501,
0.15657463669776917,
-0.5233823657035828,
0.30564454197883606,
0.3803673982620239,
-0.4838504493236542,
-0.028955401852726936,
-0.7018457651138306,
0.31259649991989136,
0.018930137157440186,
0.14065903425216675,
-0.19239173829555511,
-0.28601858019828796,
0.9039109349250793,
-0.7365143299102783,
0.9460604190826416,
-0.2024659812450409,
-0.5420966148376465,
0.23873654007911682,
-0.4233716130256653,
0.8346445560455322,
-0.14340975880622864,
-0.4974137544631958,
0.49017277359962463,
-0.34655705094337463,
-0.33873480558395386,
-0.23374058306217194,
0.5961812734603882,
-0.8441188931465149,
-0.5164648294448853,
-0.1952183097600937,
-0.3985442519187927,
-0.8637378811836243,
-0.03637928515672684,
0.4440535306930542,
0.7475399971008301,
-0.23761233687400818,
0.5096501708030701,
1.0026308298110962,
0.16153711080551147,
0.3013496398925781,
0.9168155789375305,
-0.033026259392499924,
-0.3055586516857147,
0.6211411952972412,
0.25944653153419495,
0.5458181500434875,
0.2286720871925354,
0.3363257944583893,
-0.47303590178489685,
-0.5648115873336792,
-0.3048894703388214,
0.1670660823583603,
-0.551153302192688,
-0.048954032361507416,
-0.8885706663131714,
-0.19234052300453186,
-0.7180296182632446,
0.23791790008544922,
-0.2924990653991699,
-0.4390096664428711,
-0.5685755610466003,
0.10257589817047119,
0.5105275511741638,
0.5237285494804382,
0.030896224081516266,
0.5898144245147705,
-0.5167412757873535,
0.49620190262794495,
0.39999890327453613,
0.761062502861023,
-0.41556331515312195,
-0.7591874599456787,
-0.14131341874599457,
0.07715405523777008,
-0.10971201211214066,
-0.7957411408424377,
-0.34771135449409485,
0.40683555603027344,
0.6653779745101929,
0.3690241575241089,
-0.11747552454471588,
0.6698989272117615,
-0.546206533908844,
0.8800892233848572,
0.2808181941509247,
-0.9973801970481873,
0.440579354763031,
-0.5143223404884338,
0.25016269087791443,
0.45193278789520264,
0.2872454524040222,
-0.3628203272819519,
-0.30087172985076904,
-0.5182483792304993,
-0.5135811567306519,
1.0563889741897583,
0.6427906155586243,
0.07995172590017319,
0.37515944242477417,
-0.0017165755853056908,
0.3556630313396454,
0.5049604773521423,
-0.3789108097553253,
-0.3187534213066101,
-0.4168829917907715,
-0.17643047869205475,
-0.11291173845529556,
-0.18386481702327728,
-0.13398313522338867,
-0.014670750126242638,
0.7757792472839355,
-0.0525524765253067,
0.15407635271549225,
0.06575250625610352,
0.15992949903011322,
-0.15991972386837006,
0.2138524055480957,
0.3770972788333893,
0.2141529768705368,
-0.12263505160808563,
0.017847079783678055,
-0.08213318884372711,
-0.723088264465332,
-0.31608349084854126,
0.5932725071907043,
-0.16184867918491364,
0.24843107163906097,
0.5368301272392273,
1.0909802913665771,
-0.001667491509579122,
-0.5627663731575012,
0.4677347242832184,
0.2784624993801117,
-0.23832322657108307,
0.28391051292419434,
0.14561107754707336,
0.006793414708226919,
0.11713775992393494,
0.3837086260318756,
0.038772813975811005,
0.39408591389656067,
-0.8632875084877014,
0.13151855766773224,
0.1813746988773346,
-0.3877742886543274,
-0.15170006453990936,
0.3940693140029907,
0.40710732340812683,
-0.07592073827981949,
0.27912232279777527,
0.44197937846183777,
-0.38555049896240234,
0.39254236221313477,
0.7281934022903442,
0.5213589668273926,
-0.6255754232406616,
0.13745655119419098,
-0.04437587037682533,
0.25204700231552124,
-0.3455074429512024,
0.5267953872680664,
-0.09950064867734909,
-0.5020882487297058,
-0.16459736227989197,
-0.5674774050712585,
-0.45651233196258545,
0.3913179039955139,
-0.7677714228630066,
0.27127009630203247,
-0.22147510945796967,
-0.05056089907884598,
0.1745470017194748,
0.0705585926771164,
-0.5866241455078125,
0.353401780128479,
0.035421572625637054,
1.104765772819519,
-0.9481254816055298,
0.5526867508888245,
0.4743538796901703,
-0.08089716732501984,
-0.7802948951721191,
0.31005600094795227,
0.14351968467235565,
-0.7046887874603271,
0.04939749464392662,
0.13458935916423798,
-0.2875005602836609,
0.11504172533750534,
-0.7121802568435669,
-0.9823455810546875,
0.8210373520851135,
0.2745833396911621,
-0.6930999159812927,
0.13328085839748383,
0.5455027222633362,
0.4292854964733124,
-0.45384299755096436,
-0.3285083472728729,
0.5126813650131226,
0.40959396958351135,
-0.0894382894039154,
-0.9968258142471313,
-0.22239023447036743,
-0.22704820334911346,
0.34798285365104675,
0.11007627099752426,
-0.4271169602870941,
0.9466976523399353,
-0.06150349602103233,
-0.25545400381088257,
0.2819017767906189,
0.7966666221618652,
0.2880624234676361,
0.2038298398256302,
0.4880138039588928,
0.37273433804512024,
0.6470170617103577,
-0.056990426033735275,
0.8626687526702881,
0.18893440067768097,
0.03375590220093727,
1.4527106285095215,
-0.738696277141571,
0.9485222101211548,
0.5190458297729492,
-0.3015727400779724,
0.5780635476112366,
0.1956212818622589,
0.0745062604546547,
0.724855363368988,
0.18881316483020782,
-0.1460251361131668,
0.11011512577533722,
-0.3845587372779846,
-0.7454139590263367,
0.43615132570266724,
0.18120256066322327,
-0.33974334597587585,
-0.1541203260421753,
0.3525107204914093,
0.1704326719045639,
0.38708555698394775,
-0.2152589112520218,
0.5919552445411682,
-0.11717909574508667,
-0.25877296924591064,
0.1069670021533966,
0.333016037940979,
0.6759853363037109,
-0.693768322467804,
-0.049332909286022186,
-0.0045678443275392056,
-0.20360898971557617,
-0.23515190184116364,
-0.7388491630554199,
0.12762679159641266,
0.20903348922729492,
-0.43247735500335693,
0.017577053979039192,
0.7811786532402039,
-0.5414636135101318,
-0.27881839871406555,
0.15189212560653687,
0.38805314898490906,
-0.07518567144870758,
-0.3067082464694977,
-0.4096068739891052,
0.4497131109237671,
-0.16112394630908966,
-0.4817495346069336,
-0.03659344092011452,
0.2424727976322174,
-0.02674655243754387,
0.34960418939590454,
0.8100739121437073,
-0.06198686733841896,
0.0058202617801725864,
0.30315494537353516,
0.8464672565460205,
-0.2867526710033417,
-0.9292776584625244,
-0.45530882477760315,
0.4800253212451935,
-0.2896692454814911,
-0.33656153082847595,
0.7182493209838867,
0.7282578945159912,
0.7281248569488525,
0.14227494597434998,
0.9768993854522705,
0.11743989586830139,
1.0004650354385376,
-0.6936146020889282,
0.49622970819473267,
-0.43524113297462463,
0.3969380557537079,
-0.42002278566360474,
-0.7515607476234436,
0.12496320903301239,
0.3020019829273224,
-0.21520748734474182,
0.02105136774480343,
0.4624789357185364,
0.72243332862854,
-0.023474136367440224,
0.6729665398597717,
0.19030669331550598,
0.46430715918540955,
0.1305585503578186,
0.013209939934313297,
0.7018904089927673,
-0.584533154964447,
0.49561432003974915,
-0.34871160984039307,
-0.32102760672569275,
-0.23496666550636292,
-0.7643529772758484,
-0.8204839825630188,
-0.5599508881568909,
-0.40834057331085205,
-0.33692899346351624,
0.29479044675827026,
0.6308422684669495,
0.9385770559310913,
-0.5878279805183411,
-0.1779688596725464,
0.1525183916091919,
-0.21190328896045685,
-0.04890981316566467,
-0.2049817442893982,
0.23056884109973907,
0.027348987758159637,
-0.5564306378364563,
0.5967596769332886,
0.21605698764324188,
0.12998896837234497,
-0.24845638871192932,
-0.2181919664144516,
0.01185334287583828,
0.37926945090293884,
0.7181361317634583,
0.019527288153767586,
-0.593396782875061,
-0.16550074517726898,
-0.018735898658633232,
-0.2068825513124466,
0.005573237780481577,
0.7573964595794678,
-0.7544226050376892,
0.2502198815345764,
0.15017129480838776,
0.25036078691482544,
0.45970362424850464,
-0.09149543941020966,
0.51976478099823,
-0.7548704147338867,
0.27221930027008057,
0.16843567788600922,
0.20370958745479584,
0.2328726202249527,
-0.37349602580070496,
0.4598819613456726,
0.4214048981666565,
0.16595998406410217,
-1.1346455812454224,
0.1684381067752838,
-0.7047212719917297,
-0.5230022072792053,
1.1655502319335938,
0.08079155534505844,
0.18409469723701477,
-0.3850555419921875,
-0.13579362630844116,
0.25372669100761414,
-0.42148149013519287,
0.46886464953422546,
0.6902182102203369,
0.035040080547332764,
0.2868240177631378,
-0.5434190034866333,
0.4705847501754761,
0.31673598289489746,
-1.0512964725494385,
-0.005598034709692001,
0.6511147618293762,
0.4811703562736511,
-0.1596509963274002,
0.618525505065918,
-0.35708555579185486,
0.1957203596830368,
0.05466469004750252,
-0.26055988669395447,
-0.22615551948547363,
-0.527668297290802,
-0.3806838393211365,
0.4534968435764313,
-0.39828282594680786,
-0.18426217138767242
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09490v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09490v1
|
Newswire: A Large-Scale Structured Database of a Century of Historical News
| 2024-06-13T16:20:05 | 2024-06-13T16:20:05 |
Emily Silcock, Abhishek Arora, Luca D'Amico-Wong, Melissa Dell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
In the U.S. historically, local newspapers drew their content largely from
newswires like the Associated Press. Historians argue that newswires played a
pivotal role in creating a national identity and shared understanding of the
world, but there is no comprehensive archive of the content sent over
newswires. We reconstruct such an archive by applying a customized deep
learning pipeline to hundreds of terabytes of raw image scans from thousands of
local newspapers. The resulting dataset contains 2.7 million unique public
domain U.S. newswire articles, written between 1878 and 1977. Locations in
these articles are georeferenced, topics are tagged using customized neural
topic classification, named entities are recognized, and individuals are
disambiguated to Wikipedia using a novel entity disambiguation model. To
construct the Newswire dataset, we first recognize newspaper layouts and
transcribe around 138 millions structured article texts from raw image scans.
We then use a customized neural bi-encoder model to de-duplicate reproduced
articles, in the presence of considerable abridgement and noise, quantifying
how widely each article was reproduced. A text classifier is used to ensure
that we only include newswire articles, which historically are in the public
domain. The structured data that accompany the texts provide rich information
about the who (disambiguated individuals), what (topics), and where
(georeferencing) of the news that millions of Americans read over the course of
a century. We also include Library of Congress metadata information about the
newspapers that ran the articles on their front pages. The Newswire dataset is
useful both for large language modeling - expanding training data beyond what
is available from modern web texts - and for studying a diversity of questions
in computational linguistics, social science, and the digital humanities.
|
[
-0.4452196955680847,
-0.853487491607666,
0.515015184879303,
-0.09284728765487671,
-0.1492789387702942,
0.1343332976102829,
-0.23957206308841705,
-0.2541366219520569,
0.4710368812084198,
0.33017268776893616,
-0.23762094974517822,
-0.6113100647926331,
-0.36227303743362427,
0.15778547525405884,
-0.764818549156189,
1.196403980255127,
0.039956461638212204,
-0.0946284756064415,
0.005745952017605305,
-0.019831780344247818,
0.23459972441196442,
-0.5516096353530884,
-0.27435043454170227,
-0.11365237087011337,
0.6355684995651245,
0.11785213649272919,
0.7890444397926331,
0.8842115998268127,
0.2962201237678528,
0.27362099289894104,
-0.19401688873767853,
0.16979075968265533,
-0.5449097156524658,
-0.41393589973449707,
-0.39014774560928345,
-0.019561035558581352,
-0.20305940508842468,
0.2997106909751892,
0.46610990166664124,
0.8348513245582581,
0.15642084181308746,
0.3265751302242279,
-0.2975878119468689,
0.9025752544403076,
-0.4338299334049225,
-0.14999063313007355,
-0.6593174934387207,
-0.14870911836624146,
-0.374618262052536,
-0.5315495133399963,
-0.14195306599140167,
-0.7620446681976318,
0.014684120193123817,
-0.5939816236495972,
0.43470901250839233,
-0.28293275833129883,
1.0848065614700317,
-0.25947386026382446,
-1.0584732294082642,
-0.1630208045244217,
-0.7936035394668579,
0.2995687425136566,
-0.2332826405763626,
0.5786132216453552,
0.39556974172592163,
0.043580684810876846,
-0.2929230332374573,
-0.8219711780548096,
-0.41917407512664795,
0.13550260663032532,
0.002864157548174262,
-0.06719036400318146,
-0.32562291622161865,
-0.3097403943538666,
0.17635056376457214,
0.4774229824542999,
-0.9774750471115112,
-0.17261812090873718,
-1.1592265367507935,
-0.06783216446638107,
0.47289660573005676,
0.07026805728673935,
0.03460530564188957,
-0.45949119329452515,
-0.2044239640235901,
0.13862386345863342,
-0.4866642951965332,
0.12010812014341354,
0.6428024172782898,
0.038418591022491455,
0.21647031605243683,
0.3828628361225128,
-0.62001633644104,
0.613716721534729,
-0.007568662520498037,
-0.2723691165447235,
0.5807133913040161,
-0.10159438103437424,
-0.21152278780937195,
0.2557471692562103,
0.7256110310554504,
0.6943166255950928,
0.20110607147216797,
-0.5511378049850464,
0.23513451218605042,
-0.14405740797519684,
0.5073946118354797,
-0.584585428237915,
-0.24864906072616577,
0.1837325394153595,
-0.6238037347793579,
-0.20979860424995422,
0.23741267621517181,
-0.6473532915115356,
-0.5688000917434692,
-0.4887988269329071,
0.03625468164682388,
-0.24300606548786163,
-0.21967469155788422,
0.21547499299049377,
-0.5127487182617188,
0.011319651268422604,
0.1545436531305313,
-0.7808693647384644,
-0.15379038453102112,
0.7483649849891663,
0.9383674263954163,
0.02161109261214733,
-0.5745909810066223,
0.04841018468141556,
0.2537691295146942,
-0.27245643734931946,
0.6997038722038269,
-0.08837033808231354,
0.17229992151260376,
0.10150066018104553,
0.28567782044410706,
0.3538808524608612,
-0.24321803450584412,
0.5361167788505554,
-1.0121129751205444,
0.06594796478748322,
-0.030268346890807152,
-0.45403072237968445,
-0.18486028909683228,
0.45145857334136963,
-1.0742051601409912,
0.5103027820587158,
0.270792692899704,
-1.1735447645187378,
0.40068119764328003,
0.027655771002173424,
-0.5397279858589172,
-0.19842083752155304,
0.024174531921744347,
-0.27370381355285645,
0.18253320455551147,
0.43580543994903564,
0.08234325796365738,
-0.05927661433815956,
0.7358866930007935,
-0.26777005195617676,
-0.572484016418457,
-0.053182851523160934,
-0.42758357524871826,
1.0547187328338623,
0.3087204694747925,
0.08472459018230438,
-0.17786988615989685,
-1.162537932395935,
-0.49003052711486816,
-0.0201687291264534,
-0.8224093914031982,
-0.6597338914871216,
-0.22955812513828278,
0.005353082437068224,
0.10376892983913422,
0.05171671509742737,
-0.7336481809616089,
0.3881267309188843,
-0.3022187650203705,
0.6775103211402893,
0.48231369256973267,
0.27562931180000305,
0.9138563871383667,
-0.2866106927394867,
0.029883528128266335,
0.10733867436647415,
0.2583557963371277,
-0.45063045620918274,
0.10389880836009979,
-0.35942506790161133,
0.31247925758361816,
0.29401710629463196,
0.4157944321632385,
-0.5121879577636719,
0.3488808572292328,
-0.7996190786361694,
-0.5435487627983093,
-0.2304821014404297,
-0.026552781462669373,
-0.3896617293357849,
0.5933594107627869,
0.34735384583473206,
0.04326225072145462,
-0.9046639800071716,
-0.9086693525314331,
-0.2271232157945633,
0.11873676627874374,
-0.25694918632507324,
-0.17991803586483002,
0.325692743062973,
-0.04021305963397026,
1.0372428894042969,
-0.19133448600769043,
-0.027777457609772682,
0.18549689650535583,
0.3489733636379242,
0.5371078848838806,
0.27342650294303894,
0.35986772179603577,
-0.9119911193847656,
0.21645960211753845,
-0.1993730366230011,
-0.813275933265686,
0.31354251503944397,
-0.46829602122306824,
-0.3480660021305084,
0.0778694823384285,
0.6308837532997131,
-0.6045381426811218,
0.4859082102775574,
0.4882807433605194,
-0.354789674282074,
0.25140199065208435,
-0.08119365572929382,
0.4119252562522888,
-1.1926840543746948,
0.0991148054599762,
-0.0011402445379644632,
-0.026909997686743736,
-0.23317807912826538,
-0.316892147064209,
0.3645802140235901,
-0.41381126642227173,
-0.4113863408565521,
0.1640055775642395,
-0.4745197296142578,
-0.09268714487552643,
-0.11373593658208847,
0.09460078924894333,
0.2647725045681,
0.48723936080932617,
-0.0347372405230999,
0.37045931816101074,
0.277540385723114,
-0.3409574031829834,
0.7440994381904602,
0.1817992627620697,
-0.752439022064209,
0.4659544825553894,
-0.23056001961231232,
0.1442570686340332,
-0.6814938187599182,
0.5448457598686218,
-0.5355193614959717,
-0.0944242849946022,
-0.2583732604980469,
-0.4215176999568939,
-0.14876411855220795,
-0.30625995993614197,
-0.3119334578514099,
-0.4190452992916107,
-0.38782140612602234,
0.2058175802230835,
0.09137352555990219,
-0.5923647284507751,
0.3729776442050934,
0.5106200575828552,
-0.11077401787042618,
-0.385059118270874,
-0.8335845470428467,
0.6590415835380554,
-0.008968477137386799,
-0.666568398475647,
0.2830175757408142,
0.22103570401668549,
-0.16233238577842712,
0.42824235558509827,
-0.2558785080909729,
-0.5601240396499634,
0.18605810403823853,
0.23540082573890686,
0.17173835635185242,
-0.32370293140411377,
0.33047255873680115,
0.0034674094058573246,
0.04436062276363373,
0.038048893213272095,
-0.44616392254829407,
0.4336838722229004,
0.1355574131011963,
0.043481625616550446,
-0.2790762484073639,
0.711862325668335,
0.7813263535499573,
-0.45500585436820984,
0.7756303548812866,
0.49159106612205505,
-0.25157248973846436,
-0.06512902677059174,
-0.367984414100647,
0.0952378511428833,
-0.3714500367641449,
0.3041503131389618,
0.056506410241127014,
-0.8727749586105347,
0.17573685944080353,
-0.08759398758411407,
0.2310236245393753,
0.3749781847000122,
0.11558686196804047,
0.12220589816570282,
0.5268864631652832,
0.2564496099948883,
-0.4957222044467926,
0.5438036322593689,
-0.2980306148529053,
0.01576240360736847,
-0.3352382779121399,
-0.3488875925540924,
-0.4677959084510803,
-0.53453528881073,
-0.29261869192123413,
0.11097313463687897,
0.13020452857017517,
0.03396368399262428,
-0.5005034804344177,
0.408608615398407,
-0.29200974106788635,
0.5571504831314087,
0.8772898316383362,
0.1052575632929802,
0.753130316734314,
0.21576477587223053,
0.6356154084205627,
0.37747085094451904,
-0.28976017236709595,
-0.5039367079734802,
1.0599137544631958,
0.3507426977157593,
0.9487370848655701,
0.06487548351287842,
0.7049471735954285,
0.3941534757614136,
0.005695550702512264,
-0.7015159130096436,
0.11936887353658676,
-0.16510127484798431,
-0.6771968603134155,
-0.010223590768873692,
-0.5706648826599121,
-1.1536091566085815,
-0.3525366485118866,
-0.2878338694572449,
-0.4206274747848511,
0.36311569809913635,
-0.09139397740364075,
-0.40405574440956116,
0.37332814931869507,
-0.518514096736908,
0.5587167143821716,
-0.29250994324684143,
0.002548380522057414,
-0.024805814027786255,
-0.374041885137558,
0.45296213030815125,
-0.0731147825717926,
0.37042444944381714,
0.10236372798681259,
0.1580105423927307,
0.7007170915603638,
-0.17856261134147644,
0.28768008947372437,
0.2835737466812134,
0.08261482417583466,
0.06503839045763016,
0.016624879091978073,
0.3489733934402466,
0.2950623333454132,
-0.028587456792593002,
0.4296833276748657,
-0.033906951546669006,
-0.16244176030158997,
-0.53241366147995,
0.7842785716056824,
-0.7027865648269653,
-0.3546435236930847,
-0.3139806091785431,
-0.6379884481430054,
0.08299542963504791,
0.36473581194877625,
0.4471844434738159,
1.0437747240066528,
-0.08249068260192871,
0.6642805337905884,
0.41115275025367737,
-0.025740504264831543,
0.5401764512062073,
0.532651424407959,
-0.007737283129245043,
-0.5271735191345215,
0.666718065738678,
0.47776514291763306,
-0.5572354197502136,
0.2973649799823761,
-0.2347116768360138,
-0.1415623277425766,
-0.8540471196174622,
-0.42893776297569275,
-0.036450956016778946,
-0.6315410137176514,
-0.48263880610466003,
-0.7509194612503052,
-0.3026597499847412,
-0.4620918929576874,
-0.18354547023773193,
-0.2830038070678711,
-0.3087388575077057,
-0.3888948857784271,
-0.3438945710659027,
0.2539574205875397,
0.6959113478660583,
0.12176721543073654,
0.03652893379330635,
-0.9719868898391724,
0.5375874042510986,
0.29636716842651367,
0.6154020428657532,
-0.13874411582946777,
-0.11654309928417206,
-0.5856223106384277,
0.024396048858761787,
-0.04624960198998451,
-1.0718238353729248,
0.2678085267543793,
-0.04648858308792114,
0.5279369354248047,
0.18107984960079193,
0.4223470389842987,
0.49812477827072144,
-0.7134261131286621,
0.7208776473999023,
-0.06365146487951279,
-0.5891963243484497,
0.4857668876647949,
-0.6030265092849731,
0.33743348717689514,
0.7260263562202454,
0.5543621182441711,
-0.49168941378593445,
-0.42209547758102417,
-0.5371735095977783,
-1.0166436433792114,
0.4418277442455292,
-0.09746254980564117,
0.3355082869529724,
-0.4516928791999817,
0.5474810004234314,
-0.1592157781124115,
-0.005363768897950649,
-0.5768901705741882,
-0.15135721862316132,
-0.4466077983379364,
-0.25034359097480774,
0.1565731167793274,
-0.1350596696138382,
-0.2508305013179779,
-0.31449681520462036,
0.49356287717819214,
0.16882170736789703,
0.013770217075943947,
0.3697834014892578,
-0.36160293221473694,
-0.12816670536994934,
0.30157339572906494,
0.37906956672668457,
1.2072433233261108,
-0.2793669104576111,
0.647004246711731,
-0.14169645309448242,
-0.6643962264060974,
-0.018167389556765556,
0.32258954644203186,
-0.39402318000793457,
0.2974340617656708,
0.34284231066703796,
0.7927273511886597,
0.09131759405136108,
-0.5320608019828796,
0.5750371813774109,
-0.23229673504829407,
-0.33186280727386475,
-0.5674214363098145,
-0.24917322397232056,
0.0912279412150383,
0.7267850041389465,
1.08853018283844,
-0.027794351801276207,
0.3085435926914215,
-0.6778203248977661,
0.543811023235321,
0.2162594050168991,
-0.07038780301809311,
-0.11399877816438675,
0.5586570501327515,
0.13081452250480652,
-0.23675324022769928,
0.7814416885375977,
-0.07007723301649094,
-0.3019036054611206,
0.49802470207214355,
0.3478127419948578,
0.567593514919281,
0.39750340580940247,
0.3360888957977295,
0.6447627544403076,
0.3806629478931427,
-0.3984828293323517,
-0.14751331508159637,
0.12499481439590454,
-0.44927528500556946,
-0.3567434251308441,
-0.7027416229248047,
0.19152766466140747,
0.5751686096191406,
-0.6304298639297485,
0.19479453563690186,
-0.49723348021507263,
-0.2516259253025055,
0.0015721186064183712,
0.11669603735208511,
-0.463780015707016,
0.196313738822937,
0.3279094398021698,
1.4932148456573486,
-0.9352824091911316,
0.8996276259422302,
0.49678391218185425,
-0.49950265884399414,
-0.7779238820075989,
0.21647624671459198,
0.11402595043182373,
-0.3454323410987854,
0.44614648818969727,
0.00027409635367803276,
0.35856929421424866,
0.24406646192073822,
-0.41101256012916565,
-0.887529730796814,
1.2054145336151123,
0.4737069308757782,
-0.6260821223258972,
-0.24012725055217743,
-0.3229876458644867,
0.2470165342092514,
0.011523296125233173,
-0.13683733344078064,
0.6210079789161682,
0.16662999987602234,
0.06646018475294113,
-0.8017056584358215,
-0.037002697587013245,
-0.3735969364643097,
-0.09079349786043167,
0.46953195333480835,
-0.3103950321674347,
1.123555302619934,
0.0211369376629591,
-0.26959407329559326,
-0.14269018173217773,
0.7029543519020081,
-0.23744891583919525,
0.4167294502258301,
0.2742428183555603,
0.5637622475624084,
0.845013439655304,
0.0004343623004388064,
0.8695454597473145,
-0.0769008994102478,
0.38589829206466675,
1.10777747631073,
0.4807485342025757,
0.5659343600273132,
0.42122554779052734,
0.04366079345345497,
0.4935430884361267,
0.5775637626647949,
-0.47945621609687805,
0.5539365410804749,
-0.14324724674224854,
-0.11065404862165451,
0.14205902814865112,
-0.046300701797008514,
-0.3573930859565735,
0.5760695338249207,
-0.34400829672813416,
-0.7262141704559326,
-0.6478822827339172,
0.13116085529327393,
0.26358330249786377,
0.06678558886051178,
-0.6311308145523071,
0.6726087331771851,
-0.4387059211730957,
-0.5248318314552307,
0.3012586832046509,
-0.019094526767730713,
0.5205081105232239,
-0.499224990606308,
0.080535389482975,
-0.6359274983406067,
0.022447090595960617,
-0.3842741847038269,
-0.9850684404373169,
0.5437964797019958,
0.007320004981011152,
-0.3766774833202362,
-0.11479157209396362,
0.5175089240074158,
-0.533968985080719,
-0.35048046708106995,
-0.1565900295972824,
0.2095305174589157,
0.006598372012376785,
-0.18429674208164215,
-0.19153742492198944,
0.31387537717819214,
-0.2315235733985901,
-0.6713733077049255,
0.33368057012557983,
0.6495447158813477,
-0.06343405693769455,
0.06256738305091858,
0.6885957717895508,
0.20497845113277435,
-0.049456365406513214,
0.11070571094751358,
1.0353965759277344,
-0.8132091760635376,
-0.6843220591545105,
-0.883568286895752,
0.3349113464355469,
-0.41984298825263977,
-0.3640157878398895,
0.7427133321762085,
0.945098876953125,
0.8715873956680298,
0.1013476550579071,
0.773415744304657,
-0.057105761021375656,
0.3787866234779358,
-0.47006019949913025,
0.7906525135040283,
-0.39262282848358154,
-0.0653744712471962,
-0.04342492297291756,
-0.6120139956474304,
-0.3233589828014374,
0.5240846276283264,
-0.12093402445316315,
-0.3216847777366638,
0.44059890508651733,
0.6477603316307068,
-0.20263457298278809,
0.1814717948436737,
-0.08054421842098236,
-0.01584196649491787,
0.12179850041866302,
0.5687671303749084,
0.8148453831672668,
-0.257182776927948,
1.0680766105651855,
-0.29888758063316345,
-0.06262527406215668,
-0.02038295567035675,
-0.9777146577835083,
-0.8510869741439819,
-0.776506781578064,
-0.02130013518035412,
-0.4879400432109833,
0.07356665283441544,
0.958195149898529,
0.5918117165565491,
-0.5479342341423035,
0.12071213871240616,
-0.05481952056288719,
0.1872444450855255,
0.0935659110546112,
-0.2383134663105011,
0.549225389957428,
0.008568648248910904,
-0.5688067674636841,
0.2513520419597626,
0.22002342343330383,
-0.10533589869737625,
-0.2999661862850189,
0.219081848859787,
-0.27414944767951965,
-0.2431039810180664,
0.3676402270793915,
0.3198365271091461,
-0.2528044283390045,
-0.36092787981033325,
0.01793479174375534,
-0.425405353307724,
0.12102311104536057,
1.1739983558654785,
-1.0042904615402222,
0.14109809696674347,
0.619518518447876,
0.7444047331809998,
0.519419252872467,
0.2550763189792633,
0.4018309414386749,
-0.8491970896720886,
0.4119221270084381,
-0.018399901688098907,
0.25187328457832336,
0.2956356406211853,
-0.5612609386444092,
0.3062278628349304,
0.3616557717323303,
-0.6011825799942017,
-0.5226117372512817,
-0.09237780421972275,
-0.971558153629303,
-0.7417606711387634,
1.103538990020752,
0.05959270894527435,
-0.5199602842330933,
-0.5074360370635986,
-0.0657934620976448,
0.5160140991210938,
-0.4422351121902466,
0.838310956954956,
0.383755624294281,
0.16079656779766083,
-0.5859429240226746,
-0.6869016885757446,
0.37630075216293335,
-0.695428729057312,
-0.5869807004928589,
-0.04535837844014168,
0.9375839829444885,
0.3795255124568939,
0.1585959643125534,
0.6103718280792236,
-0.08945751935243607,
0.23995821177959442,
0.002559361280873418,
-0.13999366760253906,
-0.723718523979187,
-0.4591044783592224,
-0.3434354364871979,
0.6817432045936584,
-0.4735183119773865,
-0.1024225726723671
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09279v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09279v1
|
Unpacking DPO and PPO: Disentangling Best Practices for Learning from Preference Feedback
| 2024-06-13T16:17:21 | 2024-06-13T16:17:21 |
Hamish Ivison, Yizhong Wang, Jiacheng Liu, Zeqiu Wu, Valentina Pyatkin, Nathan Lambert, Noah A. Smith, Yejin Choi, Hannaneh Hajishirzi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Learning from preference feedback has emerged as an essential step for
improving the generation quality and performance of modern language models
(LMs). Despite its widespread use, the way preference-based learning is applied
varies wildly, with differing data, learning algorithms, and evaluations used,
making disentangling the impact of each aspect difficult. In this work, we
identify four core aspects of preference-based learning: preference data,
learning algorithm, reward model, and policy training prompts, systematically
investigate the impact of these components on downstream model performance, and
suggest a recipe for strong learning for preference feedback. Our findings
indicate that all aspects are important for performance, with better preference
data leading to the largest improvements, followed by the choice of learning
algorithm, the use of improved reward models, and finally the use of additional
unlabeled prompts for policy training. Notably, PPO outperforms DPO by up to
2.5% in math and 1.2% in general domains. High-quality preference data leads to
improvements of up to 8% in instruction following and truthfulness. Despite
significant gains of up to 5% in mathematical evaluation when scaling up reward
models, we surprisingly observe marginal improvements in other categories.
We publicly release the code used for training
(https://github.com/hamishivi/EasyLM) and evaluating
(https://github.com/allenai/open-instruct) our models, along with the models
and datasets themselves
(https://huggingface.co/collections/allenai/tulu-v25-suite-66676520fd578080e126f618).
|
[
-0.23823189735412598,
-0.22136236727237701,
0.5475330352783203,
-0.22229060530662537,
-0.11357805877923965,
0.06437032669782639,
-0.2657345235347748,
-0.18846338987350464,
-0.3423590362071991,
0.47913652658462524,
-0.448326975107193,
-0.15975187718868256,
-0.7727087140083313,
-0.07938925176858902,
0.336291640996933,
1.2395894527435303,
0.09755624830722809,
0.16963131725788116,
-0.1532122641801834,
0.17133113741874695,
-0.502359926700592,
-0.8276495337486267,
-0.5802150964736938,
-0.7447709441184998,
0.4784597158432007,
0.816605806350708,
0.5104026794433594,
0.5012109875679016,
0.24823297560214996,
0.25154197216033936,
-0.25296810269355774,
0.26275622844696045,
-0.8070628643035889,
-0.14425690472126007,
-0.12614385783672333,
-0.60805344581604,
-0.5751906633377075,
0.3959144055843353,
0.5528152585029602,
0.7956360578536987,
-0.3584826588630676,
-0.15250511467456818,
0.4441556930541992,
1.2087091207504272,
-0.7318063974380493,
0.3991677463054657,
-0.5964056253433228,
0.012969468720257282,
0.10123588889837265,
-0.18927539885044098,
-0.6924983263015747,
-0.4679242670536041,
0.4486740529537201,
-0.6041901707649231,
-0.023465247824788094,
-0.21931308507919312,
0.7894381880760193,
0.12193553894758224,
-0.5251894593238831,
-0.5541535019874573,
-0.6706003546714783,
1.1787155866622925,
-0.4749462306499481,
0.23184561729431152,
0.5375156402587891,
0.20521225035190582,
-0.2311730831861496,
-0.3919592499732971,
-0.39980319142341614,
-0.3662789463996887,
0.08955352008342743,
0.1885191798210144,
0.11925473064184189,
0.1367061585187912,
0.10725106298923492,
0.6363475322723389,
0.05663305148482323,
0.29109716415405273,
-0.21724741160869598,
-0.03434363007545471,
0.7415362596511841,
-0.09552904963493347,
-0.15044865012168884,
-0.3089057505130768,
-0.3405204117298126,
-0.34053608775138855,
-0.7568846940994263,
0.5380433797836304,
0.7273765802383423,
0.4966454803943634,
-0.053053002804517746,
0.2655946612358093,
-0.17704051733016968,
0.7838586568832397,
0.24227601289749146,
-0.43240538239479065,
0.4332607090473175,
0.04449565336108208,
-0.0507693737745285,
-0.12647056579589844,
0.7128704190254211,
0.3361572027206421,
0.3801070749759674,
-0.0696692243218422,
-0.3910435438156128,
-0.16767118871212006,
0.243216872215271,
-0.46481698751449585,
-0.25854215025901794,
0.24086663126945496,
-0.47496095299720764,
-0.555709719657898,
-0.00822881143540144,
-0.7792514562606812,
-0.4280356466770172,
-0.9139479398727417,
0.1924336850643158,
-0.3661385178565979,
-0.5013179779052734,
0.31607475876808167,
0.003244873834773898,
0.1843370646238327,
0.5357345342636108,
-1.3273261785507202,
0.2777334153652191,
0.9683423638343811,
0.6416192650794983,
-0.38780632615089417,
-0.3951907455921173,
-0.5360238552093506,
-0.30008232593536377,
-0.3964012563228607,
0.6076603531837463,
-0.4845116138458252,
-0.38908323645591736,
0.08659513294696808,
-0.1979806125164032,
-0.03359595686197281,
-0.7162154316902161,
0.3635563254356384,
-0.525135338306427,
0.3627333343029022,
-0.3803093135356903,
-0.7578880786895752,
-0.07510445266962051,
0.13080649077892303,
-0.5527682900428772,
0.948123037815094,
-0.0017445067642256618,
-0.43178942799568176,
0.5821465253829956,
-0.6813745498657227,
-0.09461601078510284,
-0.3393109142780304,
-0.07038969546556473,
-0.410155326128006,
0.3114403784275055,
-0.10920075327157974,
0.45110592246055603,
-0.10057774931192398,
0.5495499968528748,
-0.3208002746105194,
-0.1309528350830078,
0.372310996055603,
-0.266930490732193,
0.7355997562408447,
0.2634351849555969,
-0.34456610679626465,
0.224588543176651,
-0.9097422957420349,
-0.21805188059806824,
0.30736544728279114,
-0.3786362111568451,
-0.3213476538658142,
-0.027903595939278603,
-0.37713170051574707,
0.19614189863204956,
0.14666743576526642,
-0.40149492025375366,
0.491136759519577,
-0.2902868688106537,
0.4981432557106018,
1.304772973060608,
-0.3031773567199707,
0.661771297454834,
-0.21035365760326385,
0.31575697660446167,
0.0014133999356999993,
0.5149546265602112,
0.002768103266134858,
-0.38099026679992676,
-0.6019544005393982,
-0.09649848192930222,
0.36302056908607483,
0.13948483765125275,
-0.6690531373023987,
0.22948051989078522,
0.013398791663348675,
-0.34678301215171814,
-0.3706839680671692,
0.26847630739212036,
0.33327585458755493,
0.9393188953399658,
0.19231919944286346,
-0.3287523686885834,
-0.05209540203213692,
-0.7425088286399841,
0.08924202620983124,
-0.4416016936302185,
-0.03523855283856392,
0.3661893606185913,
0.37151721119880676,
0.28319084644317627,
0.8965281248092651,
-0.6836245059967041,
-0.009031879715621471,
-0.3830936551094055,
-0.029297534376382828,
0.3544812798500061,
0.21463680267333984,
0.5412635803222656,
-0.8308459520339966,
-0.4496082067489624,
-0.2741640508174896,
-0.3388603627681732,
0.10913053900003433,
0.33166977763175964,
-0.040728598833084106,
0.097043976187706,
-0.12232673913240433,
0.07953368872404099,
-0.09364279359579086,
0.48962220549583435,
-0.14152291417121887,
0.5774487257003784,
-0.2066841572523117,
0.010875948704779148,
-0.843053936958313,
0.0888962522149086,
-0.032372910529375076,
-0.1359197497367859,
-0.6774890422821045,
-0.11636792123317719,
0.07945586740970612,
-0.1330404281616211,
-0.7720215320587158,
0.2369803637266159,
-0.23903672397136688,
0.042201410979032516,
-0.42531561851501465,
-0.22882992029190063,
0.10724042356014252,
0.7201129198074341,
0.3732599914073944,
0.7861406207084656,
0.7283409833908081,
-0.9796662330627441,
0.1877770721912384,
0.011316374875605106,
-0.13940735161304474,
0.14923565089702606,
-0.6271275281906128,
0.5066255331039429,
-0.18143334984779358,
0.004123406950384378,
-0.8796538710594177,
-0.14535972476005554,
0.3715784251689911,
-0.28073450922966003,
0.5261915922164917,
-0.5401338338851929,
-0.3556252121925354,
-0.014419352635741234,
-0.4345335066318512,
0.005139597691595554,
0.5838391184806824,
-0.7871665954589844,
0.19409646093845367,
0.6675694584846497,
0.08591318875551224,
-0.8352187275886536,
-0.21268898248672485,
-0.4534018635749817,
-0.11128831654787064,
-0.057765476405620575,
0.34228065609931946,
0.020133748650550842,
-0.08482865989208221,
-0.27539297938346863,
-0.06437139958143234,
-0.03410361334681511,
0.33146971464157104,
0.11094004660844803,
0.4940427541732788,
0.2736322581768036,
0.38668131828308105,
-0.2553197145462036,
-0.4172316789627075,
-0.08302461355924606,
-0.3341938555240631,
0.7282134294509888,
-0.3485332131385803,
-0.07736989110708237,
-0.3342739939689636,
0.1016438752412796,
0.6036185026168823,
-0.25676724314689636,
0.6657143831253052,
-0.028085339814424515,
-0.01216657180339098,
-0.24414758384227753,
-0.16848598420619965,
-0.34355950355529785,
-0.4672371745109558,
0.03279846906661987,
-0.35949695110321045,
-0.8165851831436157,
0.22158630192279816,
-0.378329873085022,
0.22321662306785583,
0.27849677205085754,
0.44556549191474915,
-0.011004279367625713,
1.0405051708221436,
0.9327594637870789,
-0.20918351411819458,
0.8342946767807007,
-0.55399090051651,
0.05732353776693344,
-0.7016993761062622,
-0.4904734790325165,
-0.27393844723701477,
-0.10701151192188263,
-0.7210701107978821,
-0.14387734234333038,
0.1872163563966751,
0.2426624596118927,
0.04042486101388931,
-0.08860223740339279,
-0.570052981376648,
0.4374683201313019,
0.665596604347229,
0.11874250322580338,
0.35214945673942566,
0.17707020044326782,
-0.23809084296226501,
-0.06039602309465408,
-0.7520208358764648,
-0.6104471683502197,
1.5023235082626343,
0.5928899645805359,
0.8335340023040771,
0.023509420454502106,
0.8426735401153564,
0.17195148766040802,
0.237662672996521,
-1.193352222442627,
0.33967119455337524,
-0.31187668442726135,
-0.2339506447315216,
-0.2038629949092865,
-0.6191009879112244,
-0.9661911725997925,
0.196170836687088,
-0.045572679489851,
-0.4168424606323242,
0.27003201842308044,
0.586432933807373,
-0.362949013710022,
0.25118470191955566,
-0.8955246806144714,
0.6974383592605591,
-0.5185401439666748,
-0.7168152332305908,
-0.3512774407863617,
-0.38651198148727417,
0.14570200443267822,
0.3956919014453888,
-0.005769122391939163,
-0.1927424818277359,
0.1894393265247345,
0.6695865988731384,
-0.3104569911956787,
0.8835408687591553,
-0.31755855679512024,
-0.26778510212898254,
0.28202876448631287,
-0.2961444854736328,
0.31214502453804016,
0.06699944287538528,
-0.13793660700321198,
0.32668983936309814,
-0.253530889749527,
-0.47132620215415955,
-0.554599940776825,
0.6064737439155579,
-1.0972678661346436,
-0.40244266390800476,
-0.6203444600105286,
-0.2128431499004364,
-0.4443676471710205,
0.021411752328276634,
0.12461384385824203,
0.5695942044258118,
0.08371612429618835,
-0.028381170704960823,
0.9910479784011841,
-0.12512074410915375,
0.3258303701877594,
0.7156650424003601,
-0.2862465977668762,
-0.3515697717666626,
1.0156452655792236,
0.09410365670919418,
0.34543541073799133,
0.3924283981323242,
0.5929296612739563,
-0.5293216705322266,
-0.5244120955467224,
-0.3317091166973114,
0.36791253089904785,
-0.6209313273429871,
0.1481347531080246,
-0.1911042183637619,
0.1134212538599968,
-0.46546316146850586,
0.13561901450157166,
-0.7866575717926025,
-0.3677176833152771,
-0.2615606188774109,
-0.2076713740825653,
0.22469593584537506,
0.9287210702896118,
-0.05625328794121742,
0.18145763874053955,
-0.47412675619125366,
-0.05507389083504677,
0.5507591962814331,
0.6114089488983154,
0.21026253700256348,
-0.3625643849372864,
-0.12382220476865768,
0.05674787238240242,
-0.5689607262611389,
-0.8638200163841248,
0.16683059930801392,
-0.0544746033847332,
0.6369933485984802,
0.43910080194473267,
0.13784301280975342,
0.27456653118133545,
-0.45046690106391907,
0.7254331111907959,
0.27672380208969116,
-0.9239203333854675,
1.003117561340332,
-0.10815395414829254,
-0.045288700610399246,
0.7001816630363464,
0.7275933623313904,
-0.33492031693458557,
0.18862488865852356,
-0.5618528723716736,
-0.8291526436805725,
0.9794610738754272,
-0.13501782715320587,
0.03641756251454353,
0.13748697936534882,
0.5834188461303711,
0.5761187672615051,
0.6082321405410767,
-0.8012340068817139,
-0.4521162509918213,
-0.31416741013526917,
0.13909414410591125,
-0.25178053975105286,
-0.4018222987651825,
-0.11477500200271606,
-0.17926491796970367,
0.6124335527420044,
-0.2658330798149109,
0.17525559663772583,
0.07023359835147858,
-0.0279843807220459,
0.18418115377426147,
0.5211895108222961,
0.47037237882614136,
0.9377127885818481,
-0.4126141667366028,
0.0010235498193651438,
-0.4577818512916565,
-0.21948154270648956,
0.1911085993051529,
-0.17162857949733734,
-0.25349533557891846,
-0.22376129031181335,
0.09372919797897339,
1.153303623199463,
0.024190828204154968,
-0.4674665629863739,
0.40526387095451355,
-0.10677776485681534,
-0.18077807128429413,
-0.09744418412446976,
0.2169971913099289,
-0.46382859349250793,
-0.402803510427475,
0.3012106716632843,
-0.0610816590487957,
0.26161015033721924,
-0.9148693680763245,
0.06727702915668488,
0.14824213087558746,
-0.535311758518219,
-0.5553252696990967,
0.1164216622710228,
0.5272414088249207,
0.021197201684117317,
0.4809741973876953,
-0.1242474764585495,
-0.6572864055633545,
0.3591580390930176,
0.37638169527053833,
0.6237072944641113,
-0.2901299297809601,
0.6128615140914917,
0.32822108268737793,
-0.0703430101275444,
-0.16092266142368317,
0.16424433887004852,
-0.3514358103275299,
-0.8049207329750061,
-0.42737191915512085,
-0.389249712228775,
-0.8729271292686462,
0.4612188935279846,
-0.9442569613456726,
0.2344129979610443,
-0.4115893840789795,
-0.20535998046398163,
-0.12399107217788696,
0.24165980517864227,
-0.5780872702598572,
-0.012111864052712917,
0.10019593685865402,
0.4788699448108673,
-1.0133229494094849,
0.787675142288208,
0.9288010001182556,
-0.45659881830215454,
-0.8630524277687073,
0.025984173640608788,
0.11485698074102402,
-0.8844577670097351,
0.6855188608169556,
0.027804039418697357,
-0.04593103751540184,
-0.17624446749687195,
-0.3858278691768646,
-0.6323882341384888,
0.6453295946121216,
0.4877301752567291,
-0.7305954694747925,
0.12072256952524185,
0.15658612549304962,
0.5157769322395325,
-0.3404761552810669,
0.5006003975868225,
0.4729105234146118,
0.05919313430786133,
0.0764245018362999,
-0.9354549646377563,
-0.42134007811546326,
-0.03140399232506752,
-0.19334018230438232,
0.18292488157749176,
-0.9855487942695618,
0.753576934337616,
-0.17059914767742157,
0.06768983602523804,
-0.5699363350868225,
0.25948137044906616,
0.29319968819618225,
0.3765910863876343,
0.6764025688171387,
0.3979952037334442,
0.9117564558982849,
-0.12558095157146454,
1.282160758972168,
-0.20494362711906433,
0.538426399230957,
1.1322435140609741,
-0.4005337357521057,
0.8699232935905457,
0.6543447375297546,
-0.34701967239379883,
0.44450369477272034,
0.8571537733078003,
0.3613901138305664,
1.0025650262832642,
0.10129331797361374,
0.01890043541789055,
-0.17865489423274994,
-0.2807004749774933,
-0.3496255874633789,
0.4510115087032318,
0.19465677440166473,
-0.4141397774219513,
-0.0799119845032692,
0.0839652568101883,
0.00023690621310379356,
0.06510185450315475,
-0.4235635995864868,
1.042643666267395,
-0.05136208236217499,
-1.0438731908798218,
0.504512369632721,
-0.23586495220661163,
0.6540979146957397,
-0.7761571407318115,
-0.22152258455753326,
-0.3032835125923157,
0.368673712015152,
-0.009570417925715446,
-0.8067289590835571,
0.001431100070476532,
0.05433899164199829,
-0.42318764328956604,
-0.680178165435791,
0.6025890111923218,
-0.2939758598804474,
-0.09299245476722717,
0.44535279273986816,
0.33367496728897095,
-0.14763259887695312,
0.04019300267100334,
-0.8010561466217041,
-0.019141990691423416,
0.16680286824703217,
-0.17835772037506104,
0.6471627354621887,
0.20304080843925476,
0.333965927362442,
0.6184205412864685,
0.685147225856781,
0.2070803940296173,
-0.16711662709712982,
0.29823416471481323,
0.9051303267478943,
-0.19658446311950684,
-0.604802131652832,
-0.7695450782775879,
0.5214293003082275,
-0.10716836899518967,
-0.540592610836029,
0.6758808493614197,
0.4768886864185333,
1.1932499408721924,
-0.14384208619594574,
0.6585090756416321,
0.1845354437828064,
0.4837155342102051,
-0.7107608914375305,
0.4393783211708069,
-0.5219510793685913,
0.31055885553359985,
-0.0564868301153183,
-0.7070412039756775,
0.20931591093540192,
0.4928337335586548,
-0.7031715512275696,
-0.04958590865135193,
0.42513057589530945,
0.333232581615448,
0.03923698887228966,
-0.16921848058700562,
0.2480219304561615,
-0.15442562103271484,
0.4805639088153839,
0.5266603231430054,
1.0568183660507202,
-0.251621812582016,
0.3716576099395752,
-0.7060161828994751,
-0.6433432698249817,
-0.28476107120513916,
-0.9255512356758118,
-0.6472837328910828,
-0.5790886878967285,
-0.4580267369747162,
-0.19751445949077606,
0.09502287954092026,
0.985490620136261,
0.8961745500564575,
-0.8538795113563538,
-0.4676567614078522,
-0.28523293137550354,
0.40894415974617004,
-0.3351220190525055,
-0.2724008858203888,
0.3139668405056,
-0.5841063857078552,
-0.9647011160850525,
0.30576932430267334,
0.17400619387626648,
-0.0407097227871418,
-0.11667674779891968,
-0.3539486825466156,
0.0987204983830452,
-0.26474085450172424,
0.6650264859199524,
0.3252358138561249,
-0.6859347224235535,
-0.04333319514989853,
0.10116347670555115,
0.15375401079654694,
0.20882698893547058,
1.1721009016036987,
-0.6200774312019348,
0.747688889503479,
0.6307672262191772,
0.42327848076820374,
0.3168255090713501,
-0.24712809920310974,
0.7243722081184387,
-0.5463768839836121,
0.1286141574382782,
0.2129114270210266,
0.37672877311706543,
0.319171279668808,
-0.30470019578933716,
0.4131748378276825,
0.25341400504112244,
-0.6801601052284241,
-0.8687523007392883,
0.44661086797714233,
-0.7453367710113525,
-0.22456207871437073,
0.9880794286727905,
-0.3047216832637787,
-0.15869788825511932,
0.05457650125026703,
-0.21864131093025208,
0.07538438588380814,
-0.8059216737747192,
1.1370644569396973,
0.8268834948539734,
-0.4816673696041107,
-0.15436433255672455,
-0.3445877432823181,
0.8113942742347717,
0.6243442296981812,
-0.5066800713539124,
0.2134745717048645,
0.46163496375083923,
0.39364147186279297,
0.15996944904327393,
0.6395401954650879,
-0.20984148979187012,
0.24383488297462463,
-0.3999696671962738,
-0.007362612523138523,
-0.2506624162197113,
-0.6209306716918945,
-0.7845132946968079,
0.17535264790058136,
0.4701206386089325,
-0.47512373328208923
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09277v1
|
End-to-end Streaming model for Low-Latency Speech Anonymization
| 2024-06-13T16:15:53 | 2024-06-13T16:15:53 |
Waris Quamer, Ricardo Gutierrez-Osuna
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Speaker anonymization aims to conceal cues to speaker identity while
preserving linguistic content. Current machine learning based approaches
require substantial computational resources, hindering real-time streaming
applications. To address these concerns, we propose a streaming model that
achieves speaker anonymization with low latency. The system is trained in an
end-to-end autoencoder fashion using a lightweight content encoder that
extracts HuBERT-like information, a pretrained speaker encoder that extract
speaker identity, and a variance encoder that injects pitch and energy
information. These three disentangled representations are fed to a decoder that
resynthesizes the speech signal. We present evaluation results from two
implementations of our system, a full model that achieves a latency of 230ms,
and a lite version (0.1x in size) that further reduces latency to 66ms while
maintaining state-of-the-art performance in naturalness, intelligibility, and
privacy preservation.
|
[
-0.16882635653018951,
-0.8156228065490723,
0.0986931100487709,
-0.17560040950775146,
-0.38143619894981384,
0.3910316228866577,
-0.16673077642917633,
-0.7042534947395325,
0.6871145963668823,
0.3111916482448578,
-0.608450710773468,
0.08697079867124557,
-0.7888757586479187,
-0.1052236407995224,
-0.6289589405059814,
0.46988677978515625,
0.5478479266166687,
-0.11256664991378784,
-0.002901966217905283,
0.13611993193626404,
-0.012825227342545986,
-0.4236268997192383,
-0.7854217290878296,
-0.2554336190223694,
0.4429456889629364,
0.3049526512622833,
0.9118302464485168,
0.9891749620437622,
0.12502866983413696,
0.22506003081798553,
-0.20771370828151703,
-0.25324517488479614,
-0.8409461975097656,
0.20301945507526398,
0.009143449366092682,
-0.031854353845119476,
-0.3386184573173523,
0.022819627076387405,
0.5777692198753357,
0.8224263787269592,
-0.44270437955856323,
0.4868699610233307,
-0.2877357602119446,
0.37788134813308716,
-0.8708038926124573,
-0.07537762075662613,
-0.4775284230709076,
0.11061651259660721,
-0.4202345907688141,
-0.13089267909526825,
-0.43214917182922363,
-0.05061973258852959,
0.011208581738173962,
-0.29341354966163635,
0.20848244428634644,
0.15194137394428253,
0.9597424268722534,
0.7371613383293152,
0.04506446793675423,
-0.001374784274958074,
-1.0608762502670288,
0.4402487576007843,
-0.9755109548568726,
0.5655866861343384,
0.5302796363830566,
0.5418540239334106,
0.2768090069293976,
-0.5686058402061462,
-0.6373451352119446,
0.03478636220097542,
-0.04595402628183365,
0.20805135369300842,
-0.2510783076286316,
0.09743938595056534,
0.10713949054479599,
0.5471106767654419,
-0.7434417605400085,
0.4341196119785309,
-0.14902780950069427,
-0.21168754994869232,
0.7308759689331055,
-0.1553391069173813,
-0.11315963417291641,
-0.12284354865550995,
-0.19322934746742249,
0.18467985093593597,
-0.3089944124221802,
0.08828156441450119,
0.8528640270233154,
0.15843285620212555,
-0.3186670243740082,
0.3996838629245758,
-0.5046501159667969,
0.603609025478363,
0.21297739446163177,
-0.021647905930876732,
0.09247741848230362,
0.10064928978681564,
-0.008661366999149323,
0.43112969398498535,
0.7243853211402893,
0.01538224145770073,
-0.037637606263160706,
-0.40649139881134033,
-0.2305452525615692,
0.06890644878149033,
0.0011243656044825912,
-0.9313240647315979,
-0.4589060842990875,
0.2885984182357788,
-0.7454341650009155,
0.06575029343366623,
-0.09415606409311295,
-0.6281362771987915,
-0.2250380516052246,
-0.2968416213989258,
0.4831404387950897,
-0.18448196351528168,
-0.33830559253692627,
0.10828755795955658,
0.05527162924408913,
0.11777952313423157,
0.1331719309091568,
-1.2584540843963623,
0.7920417189598083,
0.25302866101264954,
0.9499114751815796,
-0.1981748640537262,
0.14996299147605896,
-0.8935930132865906,
0.19642573595046997,
-0.018848536536097527,
0.27998268604278564,
-0.6066049933433533,
-0.2344220131635666,
-0.20071573555469513,
0.13428184390068054,
0.12455704808235168,
-0.269302636384964,
0.02710643596947193,
-0.48880431056022644,
0.25681546330451965,
0.2167917937040329,
-1.04641854763031,
-0.05457429587841034,
-0.40959295630455017,
-0.5666604042053223,
0.6144742369651794,
-0.0001785538624972105,
-0.6261454820632935,
-0.08195571601390839,
-0.464950293302536,
-0.12029723078012466,
0.46068111062049866,
-0.20643681287765503,
-0.4887264370918274,
0.23668254911899567,
0.006691602058708668,
0.32593539357185364,
-0.23470042645931244,
-0.02712908759713173,
-0.3124619424343109,
-0.5438504815101624,
-0.032621901482343674,
-0.8221544623374939,
0.7545539140701294,
0.37781447172164917,
-0.2748616635799408,
-0.23471668362617493,
-1.0810471773147583,
-0.4385054111480713,
0.34907087683677673,
-0.20627662539482117,
0.12172834575176239,
0.22668671607971191,
0.22485966980457306,
-0.0769442468881607,
0.299310564994812,
-1.0116230249404907,
-0.2509945333003998,
-0.4755514860153198,
0.6608893275260925,
0.5334771871566772,
0.048468995839357376,
0.5163288116455078,
-0.24708420038223267,
0.3646451234817505,
-0.3363405466079712,
0.18627028167247772,
-0.4664653539657593,
-0.28379547595977783,
-0.5931594371795654,
-0.5254786014556885,
0.45251235365867615,
0.6726964116096497,
-0.3515492379665375,
0.355660617351532,
-0.533370852470398,
-0.3688778877258301,
-0.9052976369857788,
0.09829730540513992,
0.27269768714904785,
0.5540374517440796,
0.35010209679603577,
-0.33529192209243774,
-0.2803463637828827,
-0.7955299019813538,
0.005455637816339731,
-0.009057970717549324,
-0.3869570195674896,
0.421432226896286,
0.1005227118730545,
-0.07486976683139801,
1.103788137435913,
-0.22732502222061157,
-0.09258463233709335,
0.1559993326663971,
0.13452225923538208,
0.22510258853435516,
0.5452865958213806,
0.5134737491607666,
-0.803412675857544,
-0.49939611554145813,
-0.26409170031547546,
-0.541087806224823,
-0.22613143920898438,
-0.07499102503061295,
0.21092736721038818,
-0.15057501196861267,
0.3933948576450348,
-0.23057645559310913,
0.6067381501197815,
0.6995529532432556,
-0.2760366201400757,
0.09340397268533707,
-0.3456375002861023,
-0.10107780247926712,
-0.8055176734924316,
-0.0239388607442379,
-0.4665643274784088,
-0.4673428237438202,
-0.8914645910263062,
-0.5888230800628662,
-0.3017829954624176,
-0.5434898138046265,
-0.6044390201568604,
0.5546464323997498,
-0.49275824427604675,
-0.2612895965576172,
-0.4187471270561218,
0.12799780070781708,
-0.0436677448451519,
0.4306615889072418,
0.3420293927192688,
0.48702114820480347,
0.6797773838043213,
-0.5004621148109436,
0.5724145770072937,
0.134566530585289,
0.1438276767730713,
0.26954880356788635,
-0.5743839740753174,
0.257891982793808,
-0.31572794914245605,
0.07457555085420609,
-1.0096629858016968,
-0.26042693853378296,
0.055828746408224106,
-0.8549757599830627,
0.6711353063583374,
-0.5910744667053223,
-0.37089380621910095,
0.05071348324418068,
0.0727774128317833,
0.3439268469810486,
0.7446500062942505,
-0.6438565850257874,
0.382418692111969,
0.44562023878097534,
-0.43061691522598267,
-0.27806556224823,
-0.5457836389541626,
0.4174402952194214,
0.03964219242334366,
-0.5723945498466492,
0.7421467304229736,
-0.21732279658317566,
0.021814044564962387,
0.17584404349327087,
0.16132137179374695,
-0.28104665875434875,
-0.057629264891147614,
0.23305992782115936,
-0.03434194624423981,
0.027674954384565353,
0.07741698622703552,
-0.16461020708084106,
-0.27164408564567566,
-0.15053585171699524,
-0.38178589940071106,
0.3209608197212219,
0.36704325675964355,
-0.4415972828865051,
-0.8726679086685181,
0.8523657321929932,
0.20933964848518372,
-0.08872240036725998,
0.8123019337654114,
0.9035887718200684,
-0.6655617952346802,
0.07450037449598312,
-0.734423816204071,
-0.3916659951210022,
-0.40502801537513733,
0.1830027997493744,
0.022133955731987953,
-0.9782763719558716,
0.6262370944023132,
-0.030161820352077484,
-0.008374246768653393,
-0.07266296446323395,
0.18926648795604706,
-0.35617706179618835,
0.4500468373298645,
0.8487287759780884,
-0.07805178314447403,
0.7095780968666077,
-0.18243521451950073,
0.3582911491394043,
-0.4919652044773102,
-0.020624453201889992,
-0.25881755352020264,
-0.20182007551193237,
-0.5490344762802124,
-0.4267860949039459,
-0.07436388731002808,
-0.09891597926616669,
-0.08145236223936081,
0.20200970768928528,
-0.5431585311889648,
0.4154377579689026,
0.5154719352722168,
-0.059109002351760864,
0.1300666630268097,
-0.015725960955023766,
0.45655226707458496,
-0.15603221952915192,
-0.7004479169845581,
-0.4702894389629364,
0.7380050420761108,
0.48612096905708313,
0.7245458960533142,
0.30645453929901123,
0.6924037933349609,
0.7690779566764832,
-0.3006315231323242,
-0.3738108277320862,
0.29440897703170776,
-0.1797657161951065,
-0.3681543171405792,
-0.7851611375808716,
-0.5148546695709229,
-0.4955079257488251,
0.2909710705280304,
-0.2310231626033783,
-1.076215386390686,
0.3103236258029938,
0.2664930820465088,
-0.34386757016181946,
0.3854251503944397,
-0.46539750695228577,
0.5624074935913086,
0.04555195942521095,
-0.5924355983734131,
-0.08044233173131943,
-0.8476132154464722,
0.10867290943861008,
0.1307651400566101,
0.3856580853462219,
-0.2850135266780853,
0.12115678936243057,
0.9351280331611633,
-0.4252001941204071,
0.8579481244087219,
-0.6229975819587708,
0.16093070805072784,
0.16948403418064117,
-0.12714247405529022,
0.6404550671577454,
0.3088308274745941,
0.05336758494377136,
0.3349857032299042,
-0.12132948637008667,
-0.6229252219200134,
-0.5046722292900085,
0.31203562021255493,
-0.677304744720459,
-0.14549671113491058,
-0.030751803889870644,
0.033548980951309204,
0.01179609727114439,
-0.04748691990971565,
0.5465936064720154,
0.45971328020095825,
-0.0726742371916771,
0.274247407913208,
0.9280767440795898,
-0.14184390008449554,
1.0534650087356567,
0.5668419003486633,
0.22794640064239502,
-0.4553721249103546,
0.8975862860679626,
0.1536361128091812,
0.3028802275657654,
0.4885350167751312,
-0.021642934530973434,
-0.4261876046657562,
-0.5041756629943848,
-0.43570688366889954,
0.28811201453208923,
-0.459337443113327,
0.1576480269432068,
-0.5422610640525818,
-0.4589410722255707,
-0.37866589426994324,
-0.0793323963880539,
-1.0711865425109863,
-0.5438678860664368,
-0.4874889850616455,
-0.0186308566480875,
0.1044984981417656,
0.3511146306991577,
-0.2902787923812866,
0.9507802724838257,
-0.46211570501327515,
0.5945248603820801,
0.43703246116638184,
0.34993496537208557,
-0.05543224513530731,
-1.046701192855835,
-0.44757211208343506,
-0.061002884060144424,
0.1863468885421753,
-0.9658046364784241,
0.4040895998477936,
0.602965772151947,
0.6058021783828735,
0.5772555470466614,
0.39847227931022644,
0.39402878284454346,
-0.6025384664535522,
0.8214914798736572,
0.4248367249965668,
-0.9906735420227051,
0.5395022034645081,
-0.018164940178394318,
0.3262319564819336,
0.1748141646385193,
0.04923831671476364,
-0.6266759634017944,
-0.21277275681495667,
-0.39343732595443726,
-0.811592161655426,
0.6115291118621826,
0.39895355701446533,
0.17801009118556976,
0.2410762906074524,
0.2514423429965973,
0.14617328345775604,
0.29311248660087585,
-0.5994090437889099,
-0.395617812871933,
-0.6409342288970947,
0.1989135891199112,
-0.3257768750190735,
-0.4572620689868927,
0.17051202058792114,
-0.13529378175735474,
0.4820846617221832,
-0.015874501317739487,
0.38884782791137695,
0.11340664327144623,
-0.3859034776687622,
-0.08316759020090103,
0.2622379958629608,
0.6074498295783997,
0.33744317293167114,
-0.36795902252197266,
0.1375037282705307,
0.04349581152200699,
-0.35825881361961365,
0.17660588026046753,
0.24135838449001312,
-0.2610394358634949,
0.4517329931259155,
0.42089328169822693,
1.0860363245010376,
0.17723500728607178,
-0.31010493636131287,
0.5746357440948486,
-0.10821779817342758,
-0.05751768872141838,
-0.54060959815979,
-0.2518826425075531,
0.11014280468225479,
0.02389422059059143,
0.5158949494361877,
-0.16160863637924194,
0.19992783665657043,
-0.14710909128189087,
0.23436826467514038,
0.15489888191223145,
-0.4043410122394562,
-0.5164474248886108,
1.0461597442626953,
0.211469829082489,
-0.5650779008865356,
0.36188843846321106,
-0.3464513123035431,
0.06746421754360199,
-0.025620343163609505,
0.22208243608474731,
0.973325252532959,
-0.6366288661956787,
0.020456211641430855,
0.029691526666283607,
0.15596170723438263,
0.5521429777145386,
0.13109427690505981,
-0.5818904638290405,
-0.30584007501602173,
-0.4863649010658264,
-0.7956268191337585,
-0.5473636984825134,
0.007945474237203598,
-0.6882893443107605,
-0.06434878706932068,
-0.13299860060214996,
-0.20502647757530212,
-0.21385465562343597,
-0.11226768791675568,
-0.40867963433265686,
0.05669374763965607,
0.7274867296218872,
0.5025557279586792,
-0.8858515620231628,
0.8440587520599365,
0.05855096876621246,
-0.04439493641257286,
-0.12006276100873947,
-0.39524316787719727,
0.030772820115089417,
-0.1732344776391983,
0.17437361180782318,
-0.11612357199192047,
-0.28442147374153137,
0.11601263284683228,
-0.5403358340263367,
-1.0520966053009033,
1.1629726886749268,
0.6122180819511414,
-0.9171827435493469,
-0.024018622934818268,
0.22073684632778168,
0.27922725677490234,
-0.4086654782295227,
0.4576960504055023,
0.08171233534812927,
0.08016692101955414,
0.3334582448005676,
-0.9767937660217285,
-0.3160577118396759,
-0.15284213423728943,
0.12099873274564743,
-0.3099275231361389,
-0.7442906498908997,
0.9174900054931641,
0.05261475592851639,
-0.38356563448905945,
-0.3216625154018402,
0.9410282969474792,
-0.25492483377456665,
0.22556771337985992,
0.38218286633491516,
0.3619823157787323,
0.7501864433288574,
0.1800520271062851,
0.3094465434551239,
-0.5690621733665466,
0.3904520869255066,
1.2953159809112549,
-0.10948912054300308,
0.9415545463562012,
0.5134667158126831,
-0.02107386291027069,
0.13523346185684204,
0.7865816354751587,
0.13331632316112518,
0.8355051279067993,
0.35986432433128357,
-0.3135172426700592,
-0.2777678966522217,
-0.3016970157623291,
-0.3056911528110504,
0.5426160097122192,
0.3253982961177826,
-0.12632039189338684,
-0.0983426421880722,
0.2844441831111908,
-0.057218458503484726,
0.01139155961573124,
-0.056732382625341415,
0.8365582823753357,
0.035449638962745667,
0.03721122071146965,
0.7142078876495361,
-0.13469402492046356,
0.5489464402198792,
-0.4705616235733032,
-0.050545934587717056,
-0.22419431805610657,
-0.027629856020212173,
-0.2561282813549042,
-0.053807809948921204,
0.3041229546070099,
0.13899211585521698,
-0.3867999315261841,
-0.4221569001674652,
0.46241384744644165,
-0.42032766342163086,
-0.054600439965724945,
0.5557199120521545,
0.4414960443973541,
0.36657822132110596,
0.24495677649974823,
-0.3209831714630127,
0.15971188247203827,
-0.39425015449523926,
-0.5259672999382019,
0.4302414655685425,
-0.0201976727694273,
0.4034106731414795,
0.7305570244789124,
0.5935674905776978,
0.34003186225891113,
0.5434972047805786,
0.2218993604183197,
0.6212632656097412,
-0.36544641852378845,
-0.9023960828781128,
-0.7075004577636719,
0.3084235191345215,
-0.09915359318256378,
0.10323451459407806,
0.5125861167907715,
0.70383620262146,
0.7744872570037842,
0.23852600157260895,
0.6317216157913208,
0.03151172772049904,
0.6931511163711548,
-0.28696203231811523,
0.807339072227478,
-0.31611254811286926,
0.3240508437156677,
0.008760731667280197,
-0.7360435128211975,
0.16658006608486176,
0.3060323894023895,
0.3333951532840729,
-0.200186625123024,
0.06794016808271408,
0.46884673833847046,
-0.1594964563846588,
0.03575405851006508,
0.76608806848526,
0.15451495349407196,
0.3460138738155365,
0.38845697045326233,
0.4301668405532837,
-0.47139233350753784,
0.33473318815231323,
-0.5510236620903015,
-0.48433712124824524,
-0.3614664375782013,
-0.7398420572280884,
-0.7206110954284668,
-0.4592750370502472,
-0.6714205741882324,
0.2688041627407074,
0.36943063139915466,
0.5494105815887451,
1.001768946647644,
-0.5894185900688171,
-0.5133254528045654,
0.2925296723842621,
-0.34377145767211914,
-0.18330085277557373,
-0.12630300223827362,
0.3890830874443054,
-0.07694771885871887,
-0.6130966544151306,
0.6995496153831482,
0.5083411931991577,
0.1642823964357376,
-0.3118130564689636,
-0.37550050020217896,
-0.15789109468460083,
0.3093350827693939,
0.20940643548965454,
0.47014328837394714,
-0.7535181045532227,
-0.33565494418144226,
-0.09107604622840881,
0.2572977542877197,
0.009307256899774075,
0.2631138265132904,
-0.7545137405395508,
0.7713868618011475,
0.33312585949897766,
0.46854156255722046,
1.0159022808074951,
0.23722481727600098,
0.1568141132593155,
-0.8907634019851685,
0.24113141000270844,
0.462028831243515,
0.2979118824005127,
0.1957123577594757,
-0.28323957324028015,
0.14091548323631287,
0.4471083879470825,
-0.5051478147506714,
-0.8636857271194458,
0.22734138369560242,
-0.8222194910049438,
-0.026119742542505264,
0.6903828978538513,
-0.43557819724082947,
-0.15908010303974152,
-0.06860224902629852,
0.4197908639907837,
0.5772954225540161,
-0.4062706530094147,
0.48180708289146423,
0.49892789125442505,
-0.4123575985431671,
-0.6866257786750793,
-0.8059685826301575,
0.4286382496356964,
0.13105174899101257,
-0.28871580958366394,
0.24891427159309387,
0.21236035227775574,
0.06042090803384781,
0.017926756292581558,
0.8009572625160217,
0.2536512017250061,
0.1397365778684616,
0.3596577048301697,
0.04424426704645157,
-0.3327444791793823,
-0.25597909092903137,
-0.47667720913887024,
0.2442050278186798,
-0.30308011174201965,
-0.7566381096839905
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09265v1
|
Sharing Matters: Analysing Neurons Across Languages and Tasks in LLMs
| 2024-06-13T16:04:11 | 2024-06-13T16:04:11 |
Weixuan Wang, Barry Haddow, Wei Peng, Alexandra Birch
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multilingual large language models (LLMs) have greatly increased the ceiling
of performance on non-English tasks. However the mechanisms behind
multilingualism in these LLMs are poorly understood. Of particular interest is
the degree to which internal representations are shared between languages.
Recent work on neuron analysis of LLMs has focused on the monolingual case, and
the limited work on the multilingual case has not considered the interaction
between tasks and linguistic representations. In our work, we investigate how
neuron activation is shared across languages by categorizing neurons into four
distinct groups according to their responses across different languages for a
particular input: all-shared, partial-shared, specific, and non-activated. This
categorization is combined with a study of neuron attribution, i.e. the
importance of a neuron w.r.t an output. Our analysis reveals the following
insights: (i) the linguistic sharing patterns are strongly affected by the type
of task, but neuron behaviour changes across different inputs even for the same
task; (ii) all-shared neurons play a key role in generating correct responses;
(iii) boosting multilingual alignment by increasing all-shared neurons can
enhance accuracy on multilingual tasks. The code is available at
https://github.com/weixuan-wang123/multilingual-neurons.
|
[
-0.21594509482383728,
-0.22543729841709137,
0.27995747327804565,
0.8113725185394287,
0.059754692018032074,
-0.049065858125686646,
-0.5317864418029785,
-0.6355204582214355,
0.555761992931366,
-0.07648351788520813,
-0.15956830978393555,
-0.08394130319356918,
-0.9414970874786377,
0.14518004655838013,
-0.1368888020515442,
0.8537436723709106,
-0.12337662279605865,
0.5469693541526794,
-0.5393701791763306,
-0.6382878422737122,
-0.24389749765396118,
-0.9671143293380737,
-0.829563319683075,
-0.9214197993278503,
1.0896087884902954,
0.08868440985679626,
0.36977049708366394,
0.0604633204638958,
0.176166832447052,
0.345864474773407,
-0.32173237204551697,
0.19879339635372162,
-0.29446932673454285,
0.1565602421760559,
-0.25537559390068054,
-0.525808572769165,
-0.48694369196891785,
-0.26792415976524353,
0.6348990797996521,
0.8284763097763062,
-0.30507686734199524,
0.082673579454422,
0.367882639169693,
0.30409085750579834,
-0.3515390157699585,
0.4175190031528473,
-0.48179924488067627,
0.0974929928779602,
-0.09226628392934799,
-0.25453436374664307,
-0.2587207853794098,
-0.0951119139790535,
-0.07639922201633453,
-0.4318428039550781,
0.15688012540340424,
-0.3170918822288513,
0.47401341795921326,
-0.10880163311958313,
-0.5145272016525269,
-0.2104669213294983,
-0.13957642018795013,
0.7316808104515076,
-0.561885416507721,
0.05070452019572258,
0.33252888917922974,
-0.3405230939388275,
0.03546557202935219,
-0.29044845700263977,
-0.381971150636673,
-0.0662546157836914,
-0.448503702878952,
0.01864578388631344,
-0.2650756537914276,
0.1497272402048111,
0.07173684239387512,
0.291179358959198,
-0.37870582938194275,
0.2778553366661072,
-0.4820626676082611,
-0.34371504187583923,
0.5654393434524536,
-0.08838041871786118,
0.6711307168006897,
-0.07397999614477158,
-0.18255506455898285,
0.11973034590482712,
-0.6481837034225464,
0.08265294134616852,
0.6172934174537659,
0.32052263617515564,
-0.3087684214115143,
0.6275086998939514,
0.11233462393283844,
0.5485733151435852,
-0.15114626288414001,
0.33718109130859375,
0.4182002544403076,
-0.5037925243377686,
0.002029761206358671,
0.2603875994682312,
1.1171462535858154,
0.3037371039390564,
0.5382314324378967,
-0.16428425908088684,
-0.25552991032600403,
-0.10662852972745895,
0.24284327030181885,
-0.41043394804000854,
0.10167016834020615,
-0.14919261634349823,
-0.3630373775959015,
-0.08900400996208191,
-0.45720726251602173,
-0.38931477069854736,
-0.4768005609512329,
-0.36867693066596985,
0.4678628742694855,
-0.07212784886360168,
-0.6154986619949341,
0.2515815794467926,
0.08905647695064545,
-0.09510541707277298,
0.11556725203990936,
-1.220221757888794,
0.3965144455432892,
0.5015924572944641,
0.8033135533332825,
-0.5463404655456543,
-0.9618987441062927,
-0.18321020901203156,
0.13699345290660858,
-0.3952364921569824,
0.6044042706489563,
-0.320798397064209,
-0.19304151833057404,
0.1811039000749588,
0.23491868376731873,
-0.3363267779350281,
-0.6053268313407898,
0.18097446858882904,
-0.6164572834968567,
-0.1392219364643097,
-0.5572639107704163,
-0.2795799672603607,
-0.2841920554637909,
0.2713676989078522,
-0.8806962370872498,
0.9076994061470032,
-0.41603103280067444,
-0.7437705397605896,
0.10718973726034164,
-0.758518636226654,
-0.6443485617637634,
-0.02926705777645111,
-0.5259604454040527,
0.027731118723750114,
0.5606086850166321,
-0.15134255588054657,
0.596096932888031,
-0.03279630094766617,
0.41225263476371765,
-0.07911810278892517,
-0.27056485414505005,
0.38908660411834717,
-0.4212370812892914,
0.7470998764038086,
-0.24003930389881134,
-0.09250089526176453,
0.394516259431839,
-0.1570700705051422,
-0.05504158139228821,
0.11412390321493149,
-0.4039568305015564,
-0.21288570761680603,
-0.06022091954946518,
-0.04712419584393501,
0.13430023193359375,
0.4500591456890106,
-0.5012407898902893,
0.2640729248523712,
-0.029825495555996895,
0.5272539258003235,
0.6881734728813171,
-0.1324271857738495,
0.6092515587806702,
-0.25319719314575195,
0.3432621359825134,
0.2533343732357025,
-0.07765733450651169,
0.13844752311706543,
-0.6202463507652283,
-0.5347952842712402,
0.08237116038799286,
0.1541716605424881,
0.25646623969078064,
-0.48015719652175903,
-0.29239621758461,
-0.32886943221092224,
-0.1161191463470459,
-0.5621231198310852,
0.17048130929470062,
0.29637253284454346,
-0.2340545952320099,
0.2651224136352539,
-0.39812755584716797,
-0.2441544383764267,
-1.1492787599563599,
-0.29505980014801025,
0.044384971261024475,
0.37218642234802246,
0.16513489186763763,
0.26572275161743164,
-0.10250161588191986,
0.2834865152835846,
-0.21943722665309906,
-0.15028773248195648,
-0.5207975506782532,
0.35421106219291687,
0.2833603322505951,
0.4537971615791321,
0.4706340730190277,
-0.6132007241249084,
-0.6087561249732971,
0.5986825227737427,
-0.7418467402458191,
-0.08373944461345673,
-0.17577530443668365,
0.018523266538977623,
0.21662074327468872,
0.4748951494693756,
-0.7056884765625,
0.24089929461479187,
0.8019570112228394,
-0.049611423164606094,
0.4788881838321686,
-0.6722607016563416,
0.2568558156490326,
-0.8177765011787415,
-0.14843058586120605,
-0.11860329657793045,
0.05421456694602966,
-0.7664355635643005,
-0.12383285164833069,
0.12672074139118195,
0.0005814607138745487,
-0.4677191376686096,
0.6079615354537964,
-0.6657381057739258,
-0.38640326261520386,
-0.49301308393478394,
-0.04258919507265091,
-0.09940540045499802,
0.7922927737236023,
0.11256401985883713,
0.8437168598175049,
0.9467116594314575,
-0.5809096097946167,
0.1481463611125946,
-0.032928306609392166,
-0.3592844307422638,
-0.027903912588953972,
-0.6560870409011841,
-0.07697918266057968,
-0.12004245072603226,
-0.2851005792617798,
-0.7876644730567932,
-0.1603350192308426,
0.13092635571956635,
-0.6198861002922058,
0.501535952091217,
-0.040761351585388184,
-0.753169059753418,
0.3374103605747223,
0.015101887285709381,
0.8705655336380005,
-0.06469336152076721,
-0.4684452414512634,
0.6240110397338867,
0.5529308915138245,
-0.16513727605342865,
-0.7221885323524475,
-0.9271509051322937,
-0.1383228302001953,
0.02038530819118023,
-0.5496007204055786,
0.5068313479423523,
0.047384120523929596,
-0.27808550000190735,
-0.05843956395983696,
-0.34946227073669434,
-0.26790353655815125,
0.027194229885935783,
0.14662861824035645,
-0.03743034228682518,
-0.055687762796878815,
0.30279380083084106,
0.02486748807132244,
0.009496872313320637,
0.1465662270784378,
0.1385207325220108,
0.8225095868110657,
-0.14388035237789154,
-0.42750418186187744,
-0.34260988235473633,
0.7863876223564148,
0.5948717594146729,
-0.3767029643058777,
0.7818824648857117,
0.44805431365966797,
-0.3288535475730896,
-0.10650958865880966,
-0.14214764535427094,
-0.0819794088602066,
-0.4898987412452698,
0.4924612045288086,
-0.3841889500617981,
-0.7508565187454224,
0.6484324336051941,
0.2137908935546875,
-0.026666102930903435,
0.2851334810256958,
0.6414462924003601,
-0.1623985767364502,
0.6979005336761475,
0.7782662510871887,
-0.25900667905807495,
0.5641359090805054,
-0.08291121572256088,
0.31555402278900146,
-0.7613993883132935,
-0.2560966908931732,
-0.23795653879642487,
-0.4633719027042389,
-0.539638102054596,
-0.49516844749450684,
0.10631871968507767,
0.13673926889896393,
0.03587975725531578,
0.2599864900112152,
-0.32020536065101624,
0.6745279431343079,
0.3801533281803131,
-0.14916816353797913,
0.17270895838737488,
0.3491906225681305,
-0.1722109466791153,
-0.1012134924530983,
-0.7725844383239746,
-0.24884362518787384,
0.8832567930221558,
0.03116491064429283,
0.6219353079795837,
0.20052216947078705,
0.650364875793457,
0.23718231916427612,
0.2502633333206177,
-0.9402893781661987,
0.5596603155136108,
-0.22580520808696747,
-0.5074827671051025,
0.09625286608934402,
-0.3701079785823822,
-1.0319671630859375,
0.6716432571411133,
0.05359731987118721,
-0.8523760437965393,
0.10080669820308685,
-0.15989071130752563,
-0.23727500438690186,
0.366142213344574,
-0.780778169631958,
0.8084043860435486,
-0.43371298909187317,
-0.4852968156337738,
-0.6437220573425293,
-0.21387213468551636,
0.11927180737257004,
0.022007979452610016,
0.08911816030740738,
-0.0012556563597172499,
0.0239050704985857,
0.7758026123046875,
0.44920018315315247,
1.148439884185791,
0.09805963188409805,
-0.3294268250465393,
0.023653671145439148,
0.08451350033283234,
0.06840455532073975,
0.09313708543777466,
-0.2886066734790802,
0.7436939477920532,
-0.10768311470746994,
-0.39417800307273865,
-0.4817073345184326,
1.0950491428375244,
-0.9614538550376892,
-0.5955045223236084,
-0.6635404229164124,
-0.7795508503913879,
-0.08627257496118546,
0.05924753472208977,
0.3134843111038208,
0.4126386046409607,
0.06518011540174484,
-0.059452835470438004,
0.5516992211341858,
-0.20082992315292358,
0.6642459034919739,
0.3093986511230469,
-0.36076828837394714,
-0.13548266887664795,
0.9646561741828918,
0.2613902688026428,
0.3174164891242981,
0.22691722214221954,
-0.1464240401983261,
-0.007300700061023235,
-0.5687454342842102,
-0.16288304328918457,
0.4862905740737915,
-0.9034994840621948,
0.13910941779613495,
-0.6351396441459656,
-0.1932799518108368,
-0.14133217930793762,
0.035038743168115616,
-0.28106585144996643,
-0.2722426652908325,
-0.41919487714767456,
-0.30018600821495056,
0.1571919471025467,
1.0079187154769897,
-0.33744075894355774,
0.3708968162536621,
-0.7202863693237305,
0.31167852878570557,
0.19672013819217682,
0.4289270341396332,
0.28368324041366577,
-0.1468937247991562,
-0.4604455232620239,
-0.037061888724565506,
-0.20179302990436554,
-1.043708324432373,
0.2741422951221466,
0.1657988280057907,
0.9942836761474609,
-0.0449955090880394,
-0.5050517320632935,
0.6739344596862793,
-0.5961486101150513,
0.8018426299095154,
0.5314275026321411,
-0.9813221096992493,
-0.10645858198404312,
-0.09880055487155914,
0.1967853307723999,
0.3098682463169098,
0.5133550763130188,
-0.9844211339950562,
-0.034206271171569824,
-0.38558465242385864,
-0.8557214140892029,
1.0233293771743774,
0.15588389337062836,
0.30604758858680725,
-0.021678417921066284,
0.23681417107582092,
0.09876283258199692,
0.17026764154434204,
-1.1948410272598267,
-0.5043673515319824,
0.14065341651439667,
0.018747609108686447,
-0.19972942769527435,
-0.12842698395252228,
-0.37558454275131226,
-0.30352160334587097,
0.422287255525589,
-0.16378921270370483,
0.5379396080970764,
0.1211644783616066,
-0.21960695087909698,
0.12638528645038605,
0.20384517312049866,
0.5614029169082642,
0.5512194633483887,
0.28284305334091187,
0.3021292984485626,
0.24832674860954285,
-0.329504132270813,
0.11918128281831741,
-0.2509494721889496,
0.2569993734359741,
0.27111172676086426,
0.49842676520347595,
0.8665519952774048,
0.16305947303771973,
-0.23061873018741608,
0.4942547380924225,
-0.27032652497291565,
-0.1844155639410019,
-0.05055210366845131,
-0.16053415834903717,
0.42746609449386597,
0.273851603269577,
0.023578479886054993,
0.37574660778045654,
-0.14179793000221252,
-0.5787988305091858,
0.08849005401134491,
0.26857495307922363,
-0.26045531034469604,
-0.6887112855911255,
0.015365318395197392,
0.02849201112985611,
-0.31256502866744995,
0.26911506056785583,
-0.2860923707485199,
-0.754063606262207,
0.750181257724762,
0.5757756233215332,
0.7421371936798096,
-0.2548750936985016,
0.17298978567123413,
0.4242863059043884,
0.3256138265132904,
-0.14464432001113892,
0.4990881085395813,
-0.22298486530780792,
-1.003690481185913,
-0.7075632810592651,
-0.374370813369751,
-0.11895328760147095,
-0.023486630991101265,
-0.7515831589698792,
-0.15041686594486237,
-0.025876296684145927,
-0.15056303143501282,
-0.006824955809861422,
-0.17174164950847626,
-0.3740028440952301,
-0.19386442005634308,
0.35704389214515686,
0.5031889081001282,
-0.7802788615226746,
1.1091740131378174,
0.8457297086715698,
-0.14446721971035004,
-0.6083204746246338,
0.04210815578699112,
-0.20849302411079407,
-0.8106642365455627,
1.0399765968322754,
0.1767122596502304,
-0.13331469893455505,
-0.29905185103416443,
-0.2709026038646698,
-0.9152671098709106,
0.5475554466247559,
0.35581839084625244,
-0.40443986654281616,
0.048969097435474396,
0.3304578363895416,
0.4805673360824585,
-0.2798972725868225,
0.22098959982395172,
0.17969295382499695,
0.39966556429862976,
-0.2894921898841858,
-1.0335458517074585,
-0.15155093371868134,
-0.4653153419494629,
-0.2480631172657013,
0.3307260572910309,
-0.4552898705005646,
0.9446933269500732,
-0.11890517920255661,
-0.17104032635688782,
-0.28637099266052246,
0.5191290378570557,
0.21908067166805267,
0.01961842179298401,
0.21923741698265076,
0.25575387477874756,
0.9042428135871887,
-0.09161581099033356,
1.0703102350234985,
-0.3736683130264282,
0.28710484504699707,
1.2721718549728394,
-0.2805613577365875,
0.8088138103485107,
0.9220291376113892,
0.00826197862625122,
0.12357641756534576,
0.49178895354270935,
0.2033250778913498,
0.5046716928482056,
0.5293481945991516,
-0.5382664203643799,
-0.22320646047592163,
-0.2176613211631775,
-0.33657145500183105,
0.17062263190746307,
0.38951441645622253,
-0.1647566258907318,
-0.16231383383274078,
0.06510096788406372,
-0.049600910395383835,
-0.10606805980205536,
-0.4149627387523651,
0.6848737001419067,
0.2977244555950165,
-0.8243809938430786,
0.4667275846004486,
-0.05791303515434265,
0.9650852680206299,
-0.7835759520530701,
0.1066979467868805,
-0.3711736798286438,
0.10864792764186859,
-0.4544598162174225,
-1.0829633474349976,
0.56170654296875,
-0.05370255559682846,
-0.3901437222957611,
-0.6603690385818481,
0.5367909073829651,
-0.7102168798446655,
-0.06392887979745865,
1.134210467338562,
0.4526979625225067,
0.140105739235878,
-0.04820707067847252,
-0.5007819533348083,
0.2742743492126465,
0.16483865678310394,
-0.11301115155220032,
0.5804613828659058,
0.30047473311424255,
-0.09887731820344925,
0.40146350860595703,
0.45371121168136597,
0.36187103390693665,
0.48285600543022156,
0.29553037881851196,
0.6039974093437195,
-0.6410073041915894,
-0.038545671850442886,
-0.8999374508857727,
0.40018588304519653,
-0.028243791311979294,
-0.37576228380203247,
0.7509316205978394,
0.37665125727653503,
0.9224136471748352,
-0.10813429951667786,
0.5427095890045166,
-0.035317134112119675,
-0.24310646951198578,
-0.24744932353496552,
0.9964442253112793,
-1.0209944248199463,
-0.013681700453162193,
0.3262118101119995,
-0.619563639163971,
-0.3196102976799011,
0.5106445550918579,
-0.25535911321640015,
-0.30052581429481506,
0.8434810042381287,
0.7719727158546448,
-0.17288662493228912,
0.1310010701417923,
0.4698992669582367,
0.019268130883574486,
0.07216000556945801,
0.5316657423973083,
1.039332628250122,
-0.2763708829879761,
0.3942764401435852,
-0.22698761522769928,
0.17013366520404816,
0.24451836943626404,
-0.6690089702606201,
-0.5487409830093384,
-0.5977832078933716,
-0.4229464530944824,
-0.02506168745458126,
-0.2781323194503784,
0.8489016890525818,
0.6508626341819763,
-0.691508948802948,
-0.8590750694274902,
-0.016942495480179787,
0.24825681746006012,
-0.28805243968963623,
-0.13837093114852905,
0.2458271086215973,
-0.7053086757659912,
-0.715584933757782,
0.5615929365158081,
0.2009902149438858,
-0.13084273040294647,
-0.04399549216032028,
-0.10858257859945297,
-0.45510008931159973,
-0.06989411264657974,
0.5664520859718323,
0.0005149366334080696,
-0.5229039788246155,
0.2706073820590973,
-0.0014156518736854196,
-0.3589114546775818,
0.35961848497390747,
0.9742216467857361,
-0.09713523089885712,
0.26578420400619507,
0.8191466331481934,
0.6657435894012451,
0.5561110973358154,
-0.7155517339706421,
0.7505660057067871,
-0.9040104746818542,
0.09649140387773514,
0.1611119955778122,
0.8784982562065125,
0.4443323016166687,
-0.2094995677471161,
0.2118493765592575,
-0.010242163203656673,
-0.5542183518409729,
-0.6274189949035645,
0.2146535962820053,
-1.0518076419830322,
-0.316648930311203,
1.2960197925567627,
-0.3002379536628723,
-0.37925004959106445,
0.09351329505443573,
-0.14886131882667542,
0.3383994400501251,
-0.34952405095100403,
0.37506160140037537,
1.1805671453475952,
-0.1566295176744461,
0.021864397451281548,
-0.6872696280479431,
0.37884917855262756,
0.7704346776008606,
-0.5855905413627625,
0.22897551953792572,
0.13517984747886658,
0.20219296216964722,
0.5331270098686218,
0.6616578102111816,
-0.16931487619876862,
0.07439929246902466,
-0.34240296483039856,
0.48295891284942627,
0.3588818907737732,
-0.4279772937297821,
-0.7634365558624268,
0.260193794965744,
0.048541467636823654,
-0.30059814453125
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09264v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09264v2
|
Towards Bidirectional Human-AI Alignment: A Systematic Review for Clarifications, Framework, and Future Directions
| 2024-06-13T16:03:25 | 2024-06-17T16:58:35 |
Hua Shen, Tiffany Knearem, Reshmi Ghosh, Kenan Alkiek, Kundan Krishna, Yachuan Liu, Ziqiao Ma, Savvas Petridis, Yi-Hao Peng, Li Qiwei, Sushrita Rakshit, Chenglei Si, Yutong Xie, Jeffrey P. Bigham, Frank Bentley, Joyce Chai, Zachary Lipton, Qiaozhu Mei, Rada Mihalcea, Michael Terry, Diyi Yang, Meredith Ringel Morris, Paul Resnick, David Jurgens
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent advancements in general-purpose AI have highlighted the importance of
guiding AI systems towards the intended goals, ethical principles, and values
of individuals and groups, a concept broadly recognized as alignment. However,
the lack of clarified definitions and scopes of human-AI alignment poses a
significant obstacle, hampering collaborative efforts across research domains
to achieve this alignment. In particular, ML- and philosophy-oriented alignment
research often views AI alignment as a static, unidirectional process (i.e.,
aiming to ensure that AI systems' objectives match humans) rather than an
ongoing, mutual alignment problem [429]. This perspective largely neglects the
long-term interaction and dynamic changes of alignment. To understand these
gaps, we introduce a systematic review of over 400 papers published between
2019 and January 2024, spanning multiple domains such as Human-Computer
Interaction (HCI), Natural Language Processing (NLP), Machine Learning (ML),
and others. We characterize, define and scope human-AI alignment. From this, we
present a conceptual framework of "Bidirectional Human-AI Alignment" to
organize the literature from a human-centered perspective. This framework
encompasses both 1) conventional studies of aligning AI to humans that ensures
AI produces the intended outcomes determined by humans, and 2) a proposed
concept of aligning humans to AI, which aims to help individuals and society
adjust to AI advancements both cognitively and behaviorally. Additionally, we
articulate the key findings derived from literature analysis, including
discussions about human values, interaction techniques, and evaluations. To
pave the way for future studies, we envision three key challenges for future
directions and propose examples of potential future solutions.
|
[
-0.25715357065200806,
-0.3065735101699829,
0.3758702874183655,
-0.026723802089691162,
-0.046478573232889175,
0.3216726779937744,
-0.15922299027442932,
-0.5819183588027954,
0.17944885790348053,
0.3379051685333252,
-0.6931923627853394,
-0.23272371292114258,
-0.43385744094848633,
0.1294911950826645,
-0.2779935896396637,
1.0899659395217896,
-0.1973617523908615,
0.16786210238933563,
-0.4706999361515045,
-0.4765288233757019,
-0.7053635716438293,
-0.3230486810207367,
-0.3621635437011719,
-0.43381497263908386,
0.7127966284751892,
0.5001176595687866,
1.0246058702468872,
0.5897722244262695,
1.0445257425308228,
0.2189662754535675,
0.20423659682273865,
-0.06805352121591568,
-0.14460819959640503,
0.1128893718123436,
-0.26094385981559753,
-0.16785486042499542,
-0.7584919929504395,
0.1653098315000534,
0.6600556373596191,
0.991191029548645,
-0.35215091705322266,
0.09254933893680573,
0.32790637016296387,
1.0425833463668823,
-0.5266566276550293,
-0.23562480509281158,
-0.11896322667598724,
-0.12238077819347382,
-0.3620432913303375,
0.10254049301147461,
0.06359660625457764,
-0.2394377887248993,
0.4510113596916199,
-0.5838656425476074,
0.05590298771858215,
0.05748376622796059,
0.898605227470398,
0.5780282020568848,
-0.5231428146362305,
-0.16309531033039093,
-0.7276853322982788,
0.7783075571060181,
-0.704514741897583,
0.18441274762153625,
-0.08668720722198486,
0.339966356754303,
-0.1641572266817093,
-0.40971440076828003,
-0.735733151435852,
0.18385331332683563,
-0.018259812146425247,
0.16148604452610016,
0.1953447014093399,
0.2442616969347,
0.09830153733491898,
-0.07419723272323608,
-0.7238239645957947,
0.11253374069929123,
-0.3622704744338989,
0.002909933915361762,
1.0031369924545288,
0.25410789251327515,
0.40921249985694885,
0.25912535190582275,
-0.49165308475494385,
-0.040314797312021255,
-0.609755277633667,
0.09678953886032104,
0.41949114203453064,
0.3859030306339264,
-0.03291502967476845,
0.6279602646827698,
-0.2122683823108673,
0.575182318687439,
0.23657841980457306,
0.007582381833344698,
0.25435906648635864,
-0.6097458600997925,
0.038783345371484756,
0.23101723194122314,
0.6498414874076843,
0.617963433265686,
0.2721936106681824,
-0.16162927448749542,
0.05691074579954147,
-0.01140283327549696,
0.8110939264297485,
-0.5318903923034668,
0.21109437942504883,
0.3208272159099579,
-0.5169714689254761,
-0.3356599509716034,
0.2491629719734192,
-0.7101300358772278,
-0.4694138467311859,
-0.8269872665405273,
0.10897616297006607,
-0.1365826427936554,
-0.20713670551776886,
0.05859337002038956,
0.029366694390773773,
0.7506933212280273,
0.4678816795349121,
-0.8405647277832031,
0.16058556735515594,
1.047621726989746,
0.622771680355072,
-0.47556912899017334,
-0.6427003741264343,
0.0843401551246643,
0.4333105683326721,
-0.266061395406723,
0.5352888107299805,
-0.4660952687263489,
-0.2076590359210968,
-0.0023160018026828766,
-0.04842586815357208,
-0.21893811225891113,
-0.1391156017780304,
0.6250780820846558,
-0.30276602506637573,
0.6785285472869873,
-0.38683247566223145,
-0.21385449171066284,
-0.20456969738006592,
0.3611651062965393,
-0.3008534610271454,
0.4486154019832611,
-0.23715899884700775,
-0.7904452681541443,
0.3145922124385834,
-0.720113217830658,
-0.6633428335189819,
-0.09428655356168747,
-0.3213161826133728,
-0.5380444526672363,
-0.08126793056726456,
-0.022024258971214294,
0.06300295144319534,
-0.5853255987167358,
0.6312437653541565,
-0.32125669717788696,
-0.4730415344238281,
0.11364874988794327,
-0.27703729271888733,
1.0618454217910767,
0.07514187693595886,
-0.7071245312690735,
0.4833669662475586,
-0.4178667664527893,
-0.13552425801753998,
-0.24753722548484802,
0.027382925152778625,
-0.16170190274715424,
0.37822046875953674,
-0.05911305919289589,
0.2611694633960724,
0.4989379346370697,
-0.2692054808139801,
0.3494778871536255,
-0.31715115904808044,
0.5163227915763855,
0.8784091472625732,
-0.2994852662086487,
0.9075189828872681,
-0.5300516486167908,
0.41889193654060364,
-0.06415357440710068,
0.6417479515075684,
0.22734814882278442,
-0.3887513279914856,
-0.4443020224571228,
-0.1192728579044342,
0.24953405559062958,
0.5808272957801819,
-0.054208822548389435,
0.9121707081794739,
-0.3819383382797241,
-0.25562548637390137,
-0.8383361101150513,
0.0025348407216370106,
0.27392423152923584,
0.810531735420227,
0.1805061548948288,
-0.6379555463790894,
-0.45474517345428467,
-1.094245195388794,
-0.1710645705461502,
-0.542684018611908,
-0.0008468781597912312,
0.14830146729946136,
0.3637533187866211,
-0.6414464116096497,
1.0342140197753906,
-0.13360127806663513,
-0.33404117822647095,
0.16558042168617249,
0.25075843930244446,
-0.15811702609062195,
0.7368688583374023,
-0.03218334913253784,
-1.0677437782287598,
-0.3337135910987854,
0.0772642195224762,
-0.9205726385116577,
0.04080330953001976,
-0.09413599967956543,
-0.5234793424606323,
0.15959355235099792,
0.45371901988983154,
-0.7145187854766846,
0.3837263882160187,
0.11590644717216492,
-0.28537487983703613,
0.30060508847236633,
0.11765561252832413,
0.30507931113243103,
-1.0636487007141113,
0.5864675045013428,
-0.1997475028038025,
0.19491039216518402,
-0.6724969744682312,
-0.0454709455370903,
-0.11937494575977325,
0.006242404226213694,
0.09933234751224518,
0.40556085109710693,
-0.463432252407074,
-0.05719032883644104,
-0.1914813369512558,
0.22908155620098114,
-0.00466181943193078,
0.3170481324195862,
0.04217434301972389,
0.7259552478790283,
0.2903745472431183,
-0.1270911693572998,
0.18385355174541473,
0.34320640563964844,
0.08204049617052078,
1.1328846216201782,
-0.7637887001037598,
0.18175402283668518,
-0.11393355578184128,
0.3024032711982727,
-0.8540390729904175,
-0.19574996829032898,
0.46385931968688965,
-0.6112642884254456,
0.5578927397727966,
0.2764316201210022,
-0.04107223078608513,
-0.29824820160865784,
-0.4425813853740692,
0.7784702777862549,
0.3240715265274048,
-0.004020296037197113,
0.6844994425773621,
0.5442711710929871,
-0.2576219141483307,
-1.0188655853271484,
-0.3253348767757416,
0.38224175572395325,
-0.4401915669441223,
-0.7510450482368469,
0.5712509155273438,
-0.02009487897157669,
-0.5295146107673645,
-0.07559609413146973,
0.03348434343934059,
0.16620752215385437,
0.12906883656978607,
0.278474360704422,
0.6050049066543579,
-0.12297780066728592,
-0.04247937351465225,
-0.326016902923584,
-0.1219794750213623,
0.04388931393623352,
-0.31102296710014343,
0.050284698605537415,
-0.2318309098482132,
-0.5067812204360962,
-0.7048510313034058,
0.48911210894584656,
0.856002688407898,
-0.3356592059135437,
0.5215954184532166,
0.6205952167510986,
-0.3913370370864868,
0.6801785826683044,
-0.583497166633606,
-0.08973629772663116,
-0.3388592004776001,
0.24370381236076355,
0.08330566436052322,
-0.6573380827903748,
0.27297505736351013,
0.034209560602903366,
0.3119280934333801,
0.38917234539985657,
0.5194910764694214,
-0.7569916248321533,
1.2897742986679077,
0.93491131067276,
-0.49337446689605713,
0.284742146730423,
0.3015562891960144,
0.4459701478481293,
-1.1727807521820068,
-0.3945732116699219,
-0.6436309218406677,
-0.8532668948173523,
-0.618823766708374,
-0.13615280389785767,
0.22373025119304657,
0.15309025347232819,
-0.5095535516738892,
0.1676545888185501,
-0.8431203961372375,
0.0862593799829483,
0.5762195587158203,
-0.15042375028133392,
0.0034353923983871937,
-0.2530978322029114,
0.17127037048339844,
0.03109697252511978,
-0.24955667555332184,
-0.7338598966598511,
1.103055715560913,
0.22996577620506287,
0.4968366324901581,
0.327939510345459,
0.7073338031768799,
0.433772474527359,
0.38725346326828003,
-0.5410822033882141,
0.34427130222320557,
0.41469526290893555,
-0.7515696287155151,
-0.7414750456809998,
0.12298005074262619,
-1.1485254764556885,
0.0009100788738578558,
-0.01602313481271267,
-0.7261288166046143,
0.2590909004211426,
-0.028847329318523407,
-0.35139796137809753,
-0.0061108688823878765,
-0.4455235004425049,
0.9842471480369568,
-0.6211243271827698,
-0.6113105416297913,
-0.3710051476955414,
-1.4573891162872314,
0.22701327502727509,
0.1679256558418274,
-0.006163451354950666,
-0.29764366149902344,
-0.16776682436466217,
0.6645901203155518,
-0.20276378095149994,
0.9296822547912598,
-0.1928524374961853,
-0.16225899755954742,
0.12393681704998016,
-0.3784617781639099,
0.2660740613937378,
-0.1786036193370819,
0.16577470302581787,
0.290727823972702,
0.16796332597732544,
-0.7216921448707581,
-0.3523593544960022,
0.38394761085510254,
-0.9050310254096985,
-0.8952497839927673,
-0.6882032155990601,
-0.5840721130371094,
-0.3176135718822479,
0.31012508273124695,
0.0033986063208431005,
-0.021813824772834778,
-0.5620986223220825,
-0.1721436083316803,
0.5340515971183777,
0.2283269166946411,
0.20838044583797455,
0.17486625909805298,
0.24562661349773407,
-0.2541903555393219,
0.7504649758338928,
-0.3567737936973572,
-0.023079240694642067,
0.5338877439498901,
-0.13485994935035706,
-0.3114359974861145,
-0.5454534292221069,
-0.5949667096138,
0.3383900225162506,
-0.09533587098121643,
-0.010911443270742893,
-0.09285123646259308,
-0.015508665703237057,
-0.6364681720733643,
-0.5310242176055908,
-0.24234627187252045,
-0.2335546910762787,
-0.45694273710250854,
0.43950387835502625,
-0.26501545310020447,
0.5491476058959961,
0.03718388080596924,
0.05287469923496246,
-0.5932645797729492,
0.08661237359046936,
0.26336780190467834,
0.10383432358503342,
0.013380973599851131,
-0.3192836046218872,
-0.0771181657910347,
0.332772433757782,
-0.48532816767692566,
-0.6179096698760986,
-0.025598324835300446,
-0.03721874579787254,
0.46460169553756714,
0.7112488746643066,
0.0053707510232925415,
0.9931532740592957,
-0.6309210062026978,
0.6920684576034546,
0.5246878862380981,
-0.7515219449996948,
0.5833795666694641,
-0.3507094085216522,
0.1807255893945694,
0.9933432340621948,
0.3483666181564331,
-0.8518773317337036,
0.1740209311246872,
-0.37605270743370056,
-0.8545507788658142,
0.5284057855606079,
0.18111135065555573,
-0.12441661953926086,
0.40865299105644226,
0.40597257018089294,
-0.060195885598659515,
0.3408650755882263,
-0.23253445327281952,
0.03499880060553551,
0.0748656764626503,
-0.7403423190116882,
-0.1542784422636032,
0.11585602909326553,
-0.6277523636817932,
-0.24117235839366913,
0.570976734161377,
-0.24815478920936584,
0.35016077756881714,
0.09621108323335648,
-0.04320799186825752,
-0.33551353216171265,
0.2534494400024414,
0.7586933374404907,
0.7659549713134766,
-0.2955954372882843,
-0.05241359770298004,
-0.2626456916332245,
-0.40955016016960144,
0.3073088228702545,
0.3340235948562622,
-0.3533993363380432,
-0.6482189893722534,
0.33278772234916687,
0.2087142914533615,
0.11389542371034622,
-0.6911317706108093,
0.7750210762023926,
-0.11062778532505035,
-0.14021305739879608,
-0.3622281849384308,
-0.04283738508820534,
0.04468410462141037,
0.5091334581375122,
0.2393193393945694,
0.3269764184951782,
0.16680234670639038,
-0.5496442317962646,
0.04010414704680443,
0.8079748749732971,
-0.6092368364334106,
-0.5300940871238708,
0.7680668830871582,
0.5137677788734436,
-0.5328308343887329,
0.9425076842308044,
0.09541178494691849,
-0.4068658649921417,
0.48241662979125977,
0.05521281436085701,
1.1050082445144653,
-0.007515091449022293,
-0.01263338141143322,
0.098859041929245,
0.20711734890937805,
-0.032555803656578064,
0.006592486519366503,
-0.3875800669193268,
-0.8362141847610474,
-0.057729560881853104,
-0.3533453643321991,
-0.5157086849212646,
-0.5794167518615723,
-0.8483087420463562,
0.2586692273616791,
-0.012229884043335915,
-0.1951679140329361,
-0.030702581629157066,
0.15315191447734833,
-0.42749783396720886,
-0.1939961165189743,
0.21571338176727295,
0.5400034785270691,
-0.5036007165908813,
0.7100083231925964,
0.917475700378418,
-0.45429474115371704,
-0.31073999404907227,
0.4224187433719635,
0.2543598413467407,
-0.693070650100708,
0.28311342000961304,
0.15353725850582123,
-0.2911165654659271,
-0.303635835647583,
-0.632879376411438,
-0.8428694605827332,
1.4857940673828125,
-0.055204641073942184,
-0.594243586063385,
-0.6432459354400635,
0.21174225211143494,
0.6576348543167114,
-0.4152650535106659,
-0.06352945417165756,
0.5592764019966125,
0.6272681355476379,
-0.08184035122394562,
-0.9524931311607361,
-0.10782944411039352,
-0.3023691773414612,
-0.04138604551553726,
0.26299750804901123,
-0.9501729011535645,
0.39780670404434204,
-0.33371639251708984,
-0.16638363897800446,
0.23906953632831573,
0.7316235303878784,
0.1227322667837143,
0.6205968856811523,
0.3038209080696106,
0.5796502828598022,
0.8756345510482788,
-0.02349533699452877,
0.48829537630081177,
-0.36171475052833557,
-0.0561186857521534,
0.9110225439071655,
-0.9402000308036804,
0.5833625793457031,
0.7228175401687622,
-0.3348733186721802,
0.5721301436424255,
0.5998057126998901,
0.16642026603221893,
0.45961979031562805,
-0.09928767383098602,
-0.18120135366916656,
0.0401783362030983,
-0.1097724437713623,
-0.253273606300354,
0.42871975898742676,
0.18051031231880188,
0.035407159477472305,
0.10654553771018982,
-0.2576141655445099,
-0.23544573783874512,
0.17706601321697235,
-0.07959263771772385,
0.800527811050415,
-0.25838080048561096,
-1.1117209196090698,
0.252480685710907,
-0.008651746436953545,
0.7106422781944275,
-0.3777645528316498,
0.02143716625869274,
0.03415079787373543,
0.17812314629554749,
-0.13903097808361053,
-0.7046741843223572,
0.33210137486457825,
-0.190277099609375,
-0.3427470624446869,
-0.3672221899032593,
0.671819269657135,
-0.3343389630317688,
-0.07407178729772568,
-0.00506962276995182,
0.590717613697052,
-0.0018905417528003454,
0.19288793206214905,
-1.024571180343628,
-0.20391029119491577,
0.09914983063936234,
0.09955628961324692,
0.5012832283973694,
0.2579008638858795,
-0.2439732700586319,
0.3930045962333679,
0.44745737314224243,
-0.048055265098810196,
-0.38857904076576233,
0.022522786632180214,
0.5166415572166443,
-0.7637201547622681,
-0.16593268513679504,
-0.8347765803337097,
0.508974552154541,
-0.1628933995962143,
-0.4704265892505646,
0.49110063910484314,
0.40836384892463684,
0.6742278933525085,
0.5128839015960693,
0.6201133131980896,
-0.16609537601470947,
0.19733527302742004,
-0.010559890419244766,
0.42622607946395874,
-0.5225656032562256,
0.007807772606611252,
-0.2514861524105072,
-0.6901348233222961,
-0.3153010308742523,
0.5010629296302795,
-0.0951046347618103,
0.05162227153778076,
0.3337327837944031,
0.6782669425010681,
0.259985089302063,
0.26178619265556335,
-0.0567329041659832,
-0.19916953146457672,
0.2638974189758301,
0.3477769196033478,
0.8493415117263794,
-0.23209284245967865,
0.19651612639427185,
-0.1384083777666092,
-0.3417377173900604,
-0.3636959493160248,
-0.7031731009483337,
-0.5216195583343506,
-0.8203957080841064,
-0.4113835096359253,
-0.13437975943088531,
0.28336185216903687,
0.905367374420166,
0.7152687907218933,
-0.7308405041694641,
-0.5637454986572266,
-0.25941646099090576,
0.3911541998386383,
-0.49283748865127563,
-0.1973162442445755,
0.43111029267311096,
-0.3476046323776245,
-0.6890162229537964,
-0.15326757729053497,
0.6183723211288452,
-0.0053525944240391254,
-0.3702349066734314,
-0.39585956931114197,
-0.4577726721763611,
-0.047814227640628815,
0.32275575399398804,
0.5666380524635315,
-0.7655556201934814,
-0.25467708706855774,
0.009492417797446251,
-0.5193575024604797,
0.18848922848701477,
0.9136868119239807,
-0.34085652232170105,
0.290838360786438,
0.319452166557312,
0.700278103351593,
-0.1796269714832306,
0.4710584878921509,
0.7337601780891418,
-0.3031092584133148,
-0.21706050634384155,
0.6001986861228943,
0.20616061985492706,
0.358629047870636,
-0.41693469882011414,
0.609860360622406,
0.1828628033399582,
-0.932112455368042,
-0.831890344619751,
0.2673514485359192,
-1.0247584581375122,
-0.2922474443912506,
0.7909181714057922,
0.3119351863861084,
-0.15207412838935852,
-0.13447996973991394,
-0.2727620601654053,
0.4718092083930969,
-0.23926493525505066,
1.1419349908828735,
0.6827201247215271,
-0.7261472940444946,
0.17810718715190887,
-0.22186610102653503,
0.5303541421890259,
0.6955779790878296,
-0.827075719833374,
0.22188632190227509,
0.5332258343696594,
-0.13995039463043213,
0.30289605259895325,
0.48101308941841125,
-0.32294216752052307,
0.22998541593551636,
-0.5420864224433899,
0.45096877217292786,
0.6136515736579895,
-0.36056646704673767,
-0.5061543583869934,
-0.20035289227962494,
0.1612623780965805,
-0.17544786632061005
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09206v1
|
Self-Training for Sample-Efficient Active Learning for Text Classification with Pre-Trained Language Models
| 2024-06-13T15:06:11 | 2024-06-13T15:06:11 |
Christopher Schröder, Gerhard Heyer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Active learning is an iterative labeling process that is used to obtain a
small labeled subset, despite the absence of labeled data, thereby enabling to
train a model for supervised tasks such as text classification. While active
learning has made considerable progress in recent years due to improvements
provided by pre-trained language models, there is untapped potential in the
often neglected unlabeled portion of the data, although it is available in
considerably larger quantities than the usually small set of labeled data. Here
we investigate how self-training, a semi-supervised approach where a model is
used to obtain pseudo-labels from the unlabeled data, can be used to improve
the efficiency of active learning for text classification. Starting with an
extensive reproduction of four previous self-training approaches, some of which
are evaluated for the first time in the context of active learning or natural
language processing, we devise HAST, a new and effective self-training
strategy, which is evaluated on four text classification benchmarks, on which
it outperforms the reproduced self-training approaches and reaches
classification results comparable to previous experiments for three out of four
datasets, using only 25% of the data.
|
[
0.057539280503988266,
-0.6952309608459473,
0.47711315751075745,
0.04505698382854462,
-0.3637615740299225,
0.055056001991033554,
-0.3556613028049469,
-0.4424988627433777,
-0.02582738921046257,
0.4027940332889557,
-0.21182458102703094,
-0.4926501214504242,
-0.34570273756980896,
0.3295040428638458,
-0.6328291893005371,
1.175823450088501,
-0.3116477131843567,
-0.032594628632068634,
0.028704596683382988,
-0.21842420101165771,
-0.02566508762538433,
-0.7608912587165833,
-0.4041946828365326,
-0.16839735209941864,
0.25437358021736145,
0.3974791467189789,
0.19397364556789398,
0.7110208868980408,
0.2906087636947632,
0.45857545733451843,
0.039525698870420456,
0.0042006573639810085,
-0.2557275891304016,
0.22007030248641968,
0.037760648876428604,
-0.44521909952163696,
-0.13856352865695953,
0.4254496693611145,
0.9401167035102844,
0.5626865029335022,
-0.13414043188095093,
0.16621308028697968,
0.24236072599887848,
0.28696584701538086,
-0.6691646575927734,
0.10091029107570648,
-0.368395060300827,
0.24185898900032043,
-0.4925217032432556,
-0.002473563188686967,
-0.2866525650024414,
-0.19370396435260773,
0.1133115366101265,
-0.486530601978302,
0.42684298753738403,
-0.08355218172073364,
0.6256409883499146,
0.25318700075149536,
-0.45250484347343445,
-0.26715385913848877,
-0.9427052736282349,
0.894540548324585,
-0.6381504535675049,
0.5037111639976501,
0.5443045496940613,
0.2515988349914551,
0.23773759603500366,
-1.2047375440597534,
-0.540368378162384,
-0.22117210924625397,
-0.014574875123798847,
0.459812730550766,
-0.2259041965007782,
-0.03298313543200493,
0.1900312751531601,
0.4846949875354767,
-0.3602601885795593,
0.13538265228271484,
-0.42338526248931885,
-0.22823984920978546,
0.43905505537986755,
-0.3543523848056793,
0.17479225993156433,
-0.10301629453897476,
-0.7511309385299683,
-0.12735354900360107,
-0.3362430930137634,
0.00006258667417569086,
0.2872844338417053,
0.49661388993263245,
0.2274593561887741,
0.6412003636360168,
-0.18421031534671783,
0.8091439604759216,
-0.07699927687644958,
-0.10589819401502609,
0.37648487091064453,
-0.4880480468273163,
-0.1391064077615738,
0.1240670308470726,
0.8610799908638,
-0.37229228019714355,
0.06092030555009842,
-0.2782630920410156,
-0.5941674113273621,
0.010859860107302666,
0.3796212077140808,
-0.8220118880271912,
-0.5192729234695435,
-0.15525348484516144,
-0.3778514564037323,
-0.22000575065612793,
-0.16488777101039886,
-0.2915250062942505,
0.15254375338554382,
-0.2047169804573059,
0.8302856683731079,
-0.2226322591304779,
-0.12529762089252472,
0.010806616395711899,
0.14971943199634552,
-0.16316862404346466,
0.33569347858428955,
-0.7162126898765564,
0.5046865940093994,
0.04111042618751526,
0.9292948842048645,
-0.484520822763443,
-0.31542155146598816,
-0.64087975025177,
0.029949497431516647,
-0.2557849884033203,
1.0561877489089966,
-0.5532897710800171,
-0.29307442903518677,
-0.0055012693628668785,
-0.18318484723567963,
-0.058354418724775314,
-0.31765127182006836,
0.7384797930717468,
-0.4966586232185364,
0.48180997371673584,
0.10852713882923126,
-0.6854658126831055,
-0.074294313788414,
0.35575753450393677,
-0.7122920751571655,
1.4766457080841064,
0.10708656907081604,
-0.7218815088272095,
0.3911079466342926,
-0.3257978558540344,
-0.6680547595024109,
0.1719202697277069,
-0.15528924763202667,
-0.8474707007408142,
0.020597146824002266,
-0.013972921296954155,
0.6593532562255859,
-0.0058569167740643024,
-0.013656876981258392,
-0.34066322445869446,
-0.06685337424278259,
0.23031781613826752,
-0.5240979790687561,
0.4816576838493347,
0.326335072517395,
-0.38785725831985474,
0.016086159273982048,
-0.8693313002586365,
0.2676728069782257,
0.0016570850275456905,
-0.6547849774360657,
-0.639240562915802,
-0.14571823179721832,
-0.0034546100068837404,
0.27928251028060913,
0.2661953866481781,
-0.6265747547149658,
0.41770121455192566,
-0.4435838758945465,
0.14838391542434692,
0.542912483215332,
-0.012724668718874454,
0.7360841631889343,
0.09057634323835373,
0.3834402859210968,
-0.17197656631469727,
-0.0056966980919241905,
-0.1658487468957901,
-0.22231614589691162,
-0.773463785648346,
-0.49151113629341125,
0.7341628074645996,
0.3406146168708801,
-0.8897731900215149,
0.48565763235092163,
0.11963972449302673,
-0.6614405512809753,
-0.38115862011909485,
0.47771164774894714,
0.4613792598247528,
0.4783731698989868,
0.5434672832489014,
-0.1649935394525528,
-0.304583340883255,
-0.7797231674194336,
-0.24616122245788574,
-0.05922005698084831,
0.1966523826122284,
-0.13066072762012482,
0.405460000038147,
-0.2425338476896286,
0.9561271071434021,
-0.38389456272125244,
-0.6002755761146545,
-0.5197686553001404,
0.5119006037712097,
0.02588771842420101,
0.32102468609809875,
0.3017391562461853,
-0.6967450380325317,
-0.6890356540679932,
-0.11157036572694778,
-0.6743046641349792,
-0.2730828523635864,
-0.1359068602323532,
0.10296995937824249,
0.022855618968605995,
0.4544709324836731,
-0.07921024411916733,
0.5089201927185059,
0.5478702187538147,
0.009593156166374683,
0.15328632295131683,
-0.5777495503425598,
-0.06864647567272186,
-0.9130464792251587,
-0.05557815730571747,
0.2313801497220993,
-0.4487772583961487,
-0.8717572093009949,
-0.5429379940032959,
0.44167187809944153,
-0.21436351537704468,
-0.3186359405517578,
0.791126549243927,
-0.9273344874382019,
0.0718713104724884,
-0.7203376889228821,
-0.09370020776987076,
-0.33341705799102783,
0.4237182140350342,
0.4175397455692291,
0.7363182306289673,
0.7434531450271606,
-0.7812792658805847,
0.14314725995063782,
0.1369089037179947,
-0.3450196087360382,
-0.023025356233119965,
-0.35291728377342224,
0.27529177069664,
0.10807690024375916,
0.20690588653087616,
-1.1408098936080933,
0.1111069843173027,
0.14570774137973785,
-0.061048902571201324,
0.4717995822429657,
-0.0661570131778717,
-0.5660608410835266,
-0.4098994731903076,
-0.10006735473871231,
0.5589587092399597,
0.3832175135612488,
-0.5751951336860657,
0.6940404176712036,
0.49161380529403687,
0.04699510335922241,
-0.38209468126296997,
-0.5178603529930115,
-0.23039276897907257,
0.03953775018453598,
-0.03305426239967346,
0.33051639795303345,
0.09207571297883987,
0.3026689291000366,
0.11397019773721695,
-0.3792528212070465,
-0.2384200394153595,
0.27143073081970215,
-0.12461262196302414,
0.0018617952009662986,
0.148617684841156,
0.3715353310108185,
0.08651886135339737,
-0.39561691880226135,
-0.25045251846313477,
-0.4542748034000397,
0.3100805878639221,
-0.07696688920259476,
-0.4168073832988739,
-0.4609833061695099,
0.01681791990995407,
-0.12894868850708008,
-0.5133786201477051,
0.5973542332649231,
0.39533600211143494,
-0.48281145095825195,
-0.7346736788749695,
-0.3291458189487457,
-0.2780839204788208,
-0.4703787863254547,
0.2401742786169052,
-0.1922088861465454,
-0.6799420714378357,
0.10064154863357544,
-0.32468998432159424,
0.2384411096572876,
0.3229977488517761,
0.504109263420105,
-0.3268774747848511,
0.9475606083869934,
0.9054906368255615,
0.05450693890452385,
0.7752517461776733,
-0.2980973422527313,
0.16363191604614258,
-0.1942158192396164,
-0.08511500060558319,
-0.6509970426559448,
-0.16831740736961365,
-0.35690805315971375,
-0.46225830912590027,
0.21531513333320618,
-0.082260362803936,
0.19558045268058777,
0.3570173382759094,
-0.36917150020599365,
0.41253286600112915,
0.727816104888916,
0.21774423122406006,
0.2797759175300598,
0.03179864212870598,
0.10700011998414993,
-0.03814347833395004,
-0.9250775575637817,
-0.4904309809207916,
0.9523659944534302,
0.17778892815113068,
1.0258790254592896,
-0.19914904236793518,
0.896026611328125,
0.5031237006187439,
0.5856321454048157,
-0.7870500087738037,
0.4132721722126007,
-0.19258442521095276,
-0.8021461963653564,
-0.4450066387653351,
-0.5998913049697876,
-1.101377010345459,
0.11656402796506882,
-0.3388128876686096,
-0.42120087146759033,
0.025911936536431313,
0.5535464882850647,
-0.12305819243192673,
0.25880593061447144,
-0.8197442889213562,
0.9627314805984497,
-0.7224732637405396,
-0.34995344281196594,
0.10014934837818146,
-0.5409421920776367,
0.006206557620316744,
-0.6189568638801575,
0.1267140656709671,
0.2402394860982895,
-0.0925174131989479,
1.299582600593567,
-0.2781248986721039,
1.1046963930130005,
-0.24566520750522614,
0.03170833736658096,
0.5419477820396423,
-0.2322802096605301,
0.6315631866455078,
-0.34032708406448364,
0.08454138040542603,
-0.10268744081258774,
-0.09765169024467468,
-0.4904358685016632,
-0.49200886487960815,
0.15439119935035706,
-0.8309529423713684,
-0.24209092557430267,
-0.8570417761802673,
0.1957295536994934,
-0.32691842317581177,
0.44347482919692993,
0.348877876996994,
0.5362308025360107,
-0.1937340348958969,
0.20926502346992493,
0.7993543744087219,
-0.0715482160449028,
0.3573245406150818,
0.5486714839935303,
-0.1613241285085678,
-0.28272536396980286,
0.8675041198730469,
0.5132957696914673,
0.17267966270446777,
0.33835721015930176,
0.3417034447193146,
-0.7353554368019104,
-0.7448113560676575,
-0.19412001967430115,
0.37564122676849365,
-0.7655144929885864,
-0.4937344491481781,
-0.8738574981689453,
-0.42597758769989014,
-0.38606661558151245,
0.16400030255317688,
-0.7082003951072693,
-0.26909324526786804,
-0.39850327372550964,
-0.2059301733970642,
0.0748724415898323,
0.7787805199623108,
-0.03623764216899872,
0.7436800003051758,
-0.6513306498527527,
0.4376884698867798,
0.42424342036247253,
0.36555543541908264,
-0.2999458909034729,
-0.7620857357978821,
-0.4818892478942871,
-0.11717616021633148,
-0.10550261288881302,
-1.15928316116333,
0.3480229377746582,
0.31966111063957214,
1.0102182626724243,
0.20736640691757202,
0.33245566487312317,
0.3265167772769928,
-0.5407959818840027,
0.3333207070827484,
0.13811682164669037,
-0.7577110528945923,
0.5762656331062317,
-0.027805974707007408,
0.4313133656978607,
0.8578019142150879,
0.592016339302063,
-0.3089415431022644,
-0.38881275057792664,
-0.796737551689148,
-0.7548485994338989,
0.9442330002784729,
0.47629499435424805,
0.1732296198606491,
0.046220485121011734,
0.3250716030597687,
0.19951927661895752,
0.1825612485408783,
-1.1065303087234497,
-0.30088531970977783,
-0.32689598202705383,
-0.333242267370224,
-0.16191376745700836,
-0.24771428108215332,
0.08396900445222855,
-0.11979889124631882,
0.9290823340415955,
-0.17793290317058563,
0.24900703132152557,
0.14007379114627838,
-0.4958822727203369,
0.04204393923282623,
0.1872270256280899,
-0.05036244913935661,
0.2934695780277252,
-0.016810372471809387,
0.4416588246822357,
0.2718886137008667,
-0.5124890208244324,
0.27907779812812805,
0.3640195429325104,
-0.21852241456508636,
-0.04017975553870201,
0.34703606367111206,
0.699506938457489,
0.23104114830493927,
-0.275903582572937,
0.7179653644561768,
-0.3362704813480377,
-0.11584366112947464,
-0.18011273443698883,
0.14203694462776184,
-0.35020336508750916,
0.15527352690696716,
0.5179892778396606,
0.03358031064271927,
0.30370956659317017,
-0.5596161484718323,
0.43962156772613525,
0.16298341751098633,
-0.44038164615631104,
-0.418501615524292,
0.4943736791610718,
0.2082674205303192,
-0.33100226521492004,
0.6271075010299683,
-0.25081661343574524,
-0.856324315071106,
0.1633884161710739,
0.8176392912864685,
0.800768256187439,
-0.3634028434753418,
0.3656657040119171,
0.40598273277282715,
0.26949894428253174,
-0.4770018458366394,
0.07297620922327042,
-0.5565906167030334,
-0.7512509822845459,
-0.472491979598999,
-0.6859326362609863,
-0.37946873903274536,
0.03916245326399803,
-0.5045490860939026,
0.398017019033432,
-0.3660193979740143,
-0.19100765883922577,
-0.043028946965932846,
0.20779064297676086,
-0.6455145478248596,
0.5545464158058167,
0.11459120362997055,
0.807111382484436,
-1.2362452745437622,
1.1197872161865234,
1.0252403020858765,
-0.15785978734493256,
-0.7762687802314758,
0.07643268257379532,
-0.433252215385437,
-0.4384651780128479,
0.4280638098716736,
0.3874431848526001,
-0.13677233457565308,
0.2867179811000824,
-0.5986663699150085,
-0.8696957230567932,
0.5439304709434509,
0.0035981766413897276,
-0.42667144536972046,
0.273533433675766,
-0.23256193101406097,
0.7979099154472351,
0.045113760977983475,
0.10862389206886292,
0.15497680008411407,
0.29617244005203247,
-0.01117977499961853,
-0.6332760453224182,
-0.26950302720069885,
-0.44826775789260864,
-0.25486448407173157,
0.3215309679508209,
-0.5410743951797485,
0.3596441447734833,
0.11697619408369064,
-0.48006173968315125,
-0.1547200232744217,
1.2093712091445923,
0.04571925848722458,
0.33605438470840454,
0.8608277440071106,
0.31970512866973877,
0.9132115244865417,
-0.007635009009391069,
0.8917937874794006,
0.026915915310382843,
0.5342415571212769,
0.8913720846176147,
-0.30653083324432373,
0.6522925496101379,
-0.007150711957365274,
-0.1367112547159195,
-0.010854787193238735,
0.7500429749488831,
0.007032179273664951,
0.8276001214981079,
-0.12568815052509308,
-0.4031909108161926,
-0.5680064558982849,
0.41141435503959656,
-0.08712401241064072,
0.5763887166976929,
-0.010757890529930592,
-0.1411769837141037,
-0.515856921672821,
0.4665946066379547,
0.01228978019207716,
0.21971039474010468,
-0.11211217194795609,
1.0166139602661133,
-0.0710010752081871,
-0.5663001537322998,
0.32215508818626404,
0.03713056072592735,
0.5001617670059204,
-0.8580619692802429,
0.016484856605529785,
-0.16066674888134003,
0.30662110447883606,
0.05606922507286072,
-0.8052986264228821,
-0.05418283864855766,
0.2944989502429962,
-0.02139807678759098,
-0.7636780142784119,
1.0350748300552368,
-0.5238392949104309,
-0.6815095543861389,
0.2323625534772873,
0.6481954455375671,
0.36390912532806396,
-0.011859152466058731,
-0.842240035533905,
-0.41299259662628174,
0.140284925699234,
-0.5761078596115112,
0.3088400065898895,
0.7051888108253479,
-0.14151281118392944,
0.5851743221282959,
0.5086463093757629,
0.13216084241867065,
0.21595653891563416,
-0.14046300947666168,
1.03000009059906,
-0.7000474333763123,
-0.5536696314811707,
-0.63347327709198,
0.280892550945282,
-0.18921619653701782,
-0.41193896532058716,
0.8681564331054688,
0.8812466263771057,
0.8015365600585938,
0.16839739680290222,
0.9343910217285156,
-0.01254272274672985,
0.7557584047317505,
-0.6045377850532532,
0.45525693893432617,
-0.7126500606536865,
0.16440227627754211,
-0.08956621587276459,
-1.0334744453430176,
-0.2611179053783417,
0.8305931687355042,
-0.46835553646087646,
0.34907233715057373,
0.737933337688446,
0.31867340207099915,
-0.33344170451164246,
0.024955058470368385,
0.29473933577537537,
0.13684684038162231,
0.17988038063049316,
-0.15107911825180054,
0.9367735981941223,
-0.1639372557401657,
0.665749192237854,
-0.5997912287712097,
-0.5456504821777344,
0.10677283257246017,
-0.6599465608596802,
-1.0983307361602783,
-0.8015688061714172,
-0.2596137523651123,
-0.14305922389030457,
0.0876300036907196,
0.6820828914642334,
0.6952289342880249,
-0.7022745609283447,
-0.08934897929430008,
0.07666522264480591,
-0.2764658033847809,
-0.16504287719726562,
-0.04197685047984123,
0.5170470476150513,
-0.6160772442817688,
-0.8523800373077393,
0.43271130323410034,
0.017336037009954453,
0.3240850269794464,
-0.10841968655586243,
0.2490711659193039,
-0.4929366707801819,
-0.3175037205219269,
0.4436151087284088,
0.4774153530597687,
0.05475952848792076,
0.031245306134223938,
0.07271479070186615,
-0.3369255065917969,
0.11927853524684906,
0.7460659742355347,
-0.9568668603897095,
0.6092554330825806,
0.4022483825683594,
0.8983588218688965,
1.1114766597747803,
0.15266478061676025,
0.3875505030155182,
-0.9736230969429016,
0.046913571655750275,
0.4800945818424225,
0.21634027361869812,
0.2900150716304779,
-0.08992860466241837,
0.5348404049873352,
0.23863491415977478,
-0.5921382308006287,
-0.8640102744102478,
-0.09775688499212265,
-0.9842986464500427,
-0.48679396510124207,
1.2704896926879883,
-0.09718824177980423,
-0.4483887255191803,
-0.14243359863758087,
-0.2504289746284485,
0.6118870973587036,
-0.3007119297981262,
0.7996401190757751,
0.42080679535865784,
-0.0383743941783905,
-0.06497515738010406,
-0.43644893169403076,
0.4960389733314514,
0.38130223751068115,
-1.0403083562850952,
-0.0011032307520508766,
0.38326069712638855,
0.18789179623126984,
0.06378061324357986,
0.8382684588432312,
0.22045445442199707,
0.02191789075732231,
-0.2717646658420563,
0.20351658761501312,
0.1868676394224167,
-0.6074739098548889,
-0.1758217215538025,
0.08622433990240097,
0.0751979872584343,
-0.27326062321662903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09205v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09205v1
|
ReadCtrl: Personalizing text generation with readability-controlled instruction learning
| 2024-06-13T15:03:46 | 2024-06-13T15:03:46 |
Hieu Tran, Zonghai Yao, Lingxi Li, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Content generation conditioning on users's readability is an important
application for personalization. In an era of large language models (LLMs),
readability-controlled text generation based on LLMs has become increasingly
important. This paper introduces a novel methodology called
"Readability-Controlled Instruction Learning (ReadCtrl)," which aims to
instruction-tune LLMs to tailor users' readability levels. Unlike the
traditional methods, which primarily focused on categorical readability
adjustments typically classified as high, medium, and low or expert and
layperson levels with limited success, ReadCtrl introduces a dynamic framework
that enables LLMs to generate content at various (near continuous level)
complexity levels, thereby enhancing their versatility across different
applications. Our results show that the ReadCtrl-Mistral-7B models
significantly outperformed strong baseline models such as GPT-4 and Claude-3,
with a win rate of 52.1%:35.7% against GPT-4 in human evaluations. Furthermore,
Read-Ctrl has shown significant improvements in automatic evaluations, as
evidenced by better readability metrics (e.g., FOG, FKGL) and generation
quality metrics (e.g., BLEU, SARI, SummaC-Factuality, UniEval-Consistency and
Coherence). These results underscore Read-Ctrl's effectiveness and tenacity in
producing high-quality, contextually appropriate outputs that closely align
with targeted readability levels, marking a significant advancement in
personalized content generation using LLMs.
|
[
-0.038875505328178406,
-0.7502437829971313,
0.34012115001678467,
0.027324330061674118,
-0.2541443705558777,
0.6550740599632263,
-0.47160133719444275,
-0.2677052915096283,
-0.2800801992416382,
0.5521467328071594,
-0.6163458824157715,
-0.7964912056922913,
-0.3250013291835785,
0.0659012719988823,
-0.44554924964904785,
1.070288062095642,
-0.15953922271728516,
-0.2741229832172394,
-0.1013587936758995,
0.23307928442955017,
-0.4364190101623535,
-0.4182945489883423,
-0.45783883333206177,
-0.2521580159664154,
0.7138851284980774,
0.6805398464202881,
0.7386441230773926,
0.8720778822898865,
0.5160508155822754,
0.3311891257762909,
-0.4441225528717041,
0.3524273633956909,
-0.7752358913421631,
0.5712448954582214,
-0.11162236332893372,
-0.45244136452674866,
-0.5143178105354309,
-0.43344753980636597,
0.5915505886077881,
0.3576001524925232,
-0.2833150625228882,
-0.14637601375579834,
0.43171390891075134,
0.6371583342552185,
-0.44875964522361755,
-0.24029365181922913,
-0.49549609422683716,
0.14936871826648712,
-0.25722602009773254,
-0.306345134973526,
-0.8819414377212524,
-0.54853755235672,
0.14890360832214355,
-0.7455408573150635,
0.48577210307121277,
0.21712961792945862,
0.5043779611587524,
0.2269006073474884,
-0.40646159648895264,
-0.6978280544281006,
-0.8536091446876526,
0.9479400515556335,
-0.833736002445221,
0.6402988433837891,
0.15927407145500183,
0.23836877942085266,
-0.02149825170636177,
-0.7681055665016174,
-0.46378570795059204,
-0.4344558119773865,
0.17936497926712036,
0.3225978910923004,
0.08213675767183304,
-0.04313071817159653,
0.19222064316272736,
0.24943898618221283,
-0.46742406487464905,
0.24988768994808197,
-0.28975123167037964,
-0.1763637661933899,
0.38333943486213684,
0.38459470868110657,
0.3487032651901245,
-0.09648445248603821,
-0.35161474347114563,
0.0081018740311265,
-0.7607697248458862,
0.22478634119033813,
0.4760356843471527,
0.15828832983970642,
-0.27078619599342346,
0.6178249716758728,
-0.28659161925315857,
0.605251669883728,
0.3188062906265259,
-0.28431957960128784,
0.03404822573065758,
-0.38117170333862305,
0.009272255003452301,
0.10125403851270676,
0.5012240409851074,
0.09681057929992676,
0.21065711975097656,
-0.055199217051267624,
-0.39012986421585083,
-0.5315935015678406,
0.4187788963317871,
-0.7860241532325745,
-0.33235523104667664,
0.10971561074256897,
-0.4964161515235901,
-0.7350682616233826,
-0.06312140822410583,
-0.44695258140563965,
-0.556626558303833,
-0.4888671934604645,
0.22455047070980072,
-0.6106647253036499,
0.049512408673763275,
-0.05022494122385979,
0.14002755284309387,
0.17469920217990875,
0.8019164204597473,
-1.0106632709503174,
0.15610699355602264,
0.5018554329872131,
0.7512510418891907,
-0.7436086535453796,
-0.012511777691543102,
-0.4156254827976227,
0.3354090452194214,
-0.17520591616630554,
0.6970820426940918,
-0.4838106632232666,
-0.3256341218948364,
0.14904460310935974,
-0.39067140221595764,
-0.03684482350945473,
-0.5152140259742737,
0.24971845746040344,
-0.658011257648468,
0.09479115158319473,
-0.09134714305400848,
-0.5401335954666138,
0.023865144699811935,
0.26073935627937317,
-0.6401111483573914,
0.7230304479598999,
0.2320135533809662,
-0.9020221829414368,
0.5415416359901428,
-0.39028143882751465,
-0.5402032136917114,
0.2602962851524353,
0.13812223076820374,
-0.37754788994789124,
0.0472247377038002,
-0.007260280195623636,
0.45477646589279175,
-0.10726530104875565,
0.10131161659955978,
-0.0011256113648414612,
-0.2178495079278946,
0.49467864632606506,
-0.7206461429595947,
0.2613387405872345,
0.43024834990501404,
-0.47013553977012634,
0.4822501242160797,
-0.7289455533027649,
0.19175827503204346,
-0.24701130390167236,
-0.9583971500396729,
-0.13736526668071747,
0.2547702491283417,
0.15687499940395355,
-0.04292619973421097,
0.5547619462013245,
-0.4513251781463623,
0.04562877118587494,
-0.35316330194473267,
0.5572776198387146,
0.7090545296669006,
-0.1377926766872406,
0.4525791108608246,
-0.27112770080566406,
0.653204083442688,
0.11147508770227432,
0.09600704908370972,
-0.2856082022190094,
0.0040370705537498,
-0.8237142562866211,
-0.3613235354423523,
0.2332047075033188,
0.7142965197563171,
-0.8543632626533508,
0.2645723819732666,
0.07387851178646088,
-0.4959883391857147,
-0.22613167762756348,
0.41353240609169006,
0.77390056848526,
0.6559973359107971,
0.2749843895435333,
-0.002222212962806225,
-0.024905730038881302,
-0.4199182689189911,
-0.18010134994983673,
0.0900774672627449,
0.06939748674631119,
0.38221970200538635,
0.17338600754737854,
-0.157195582985878,
0.6001633405685425,
-0.5588703155517578,
0.03980975225567818,
-0.7569490671157837,
-0.08351632952690125,
0.2744693458080292,
0.37499162554740906,
0.0448126494884491,
-0.7385159134864807,
-0.6628609895706177,
0.4105077087879181,
-0.5013763308525085,
-0.14910927414894104,
-0.15898899734020233,
-0.08078274875879288,
0.3046056926250458,
0.4093773663043976,
0.004496695473790169,
0.35523954033851624,
0.3937174379825592,
-0.5253850221633911,
0.5881953239440918,
-0.6576406955718994,
0.13608670234680176,
-1.2129383087158203,
-0.15900464355945587,
-0.14159534871578217,
-0.4479566514492035,
-0.6077139377593994,
0.11338698118925095,
0.15542328357696533,
0.037459321320056915,
-0.6063211560249329,
0.5373556017875671,
-0.4450254738330841,
0.19067218899726868,
-0.10296626389026642,
0.0679822489619255,
0.04248860850930214,
0.21289093792438507,
-0.0010769866639748216,
0.8416649699211121,
-0.03350234776735306,
-0.5219773054122925,
0.23443977534770966,
0.3694489300251007,
-0.5423287153244019,
0.46244439482688904,
-0.8644500970840454,
0.05803567171096802,
0.041367437690496445,
0.05028567835688591,
-0.792707622051239,
-0.4219854176044464,
0.13942846655845642,
-0.14427825808525085,
0.4750880300998688,
0.593641996383667,
-0.31500616669654846,
-0.03955654427409172,
-0.1107775941491127,
0.13474614918231964,
0.5619091391563416,
-0.7697941064834595,
0.44319409132003784,
-0.1846390664577484,
-0.4538297951221466,
-0.506199300289154,
-0.6439130902290344,
-0.18358421325683594,
0.05480079725384712,
-0.5917738080024719,
0.3220255672931671,
-0.5013569593429565,
0.09513357281684875,
-0.19424234330654144,
0.0596436932682991,
-0.1825912445783615,
-0.018505023792386055,
0.08190441131591797,
0.05584927275776863,
-0.058979522436857224,
0.01091147493571043,
0.553510844707489,
0.17737209796905518,
-0.45643389225006104,
-0.008386501111090183,
0.5089860558509827,
-0.04619184881448746,
-0.11739619076251984,
-0.5698757767677307,
0.2956559956073761,
0.19200646877288818,
-0.4404163062572479,
0.6381545066833496,
0.5065146088600159,
0.09430915862321854,
-0.6782799363136292,
-0.29473844170570374,
0.05063251778483391,
-0.5693974494934082,
0.41301897168159485,
-0.43545278906822205,
-1.3358497619628906,
0.341937780380249,
-0.03803884983062744,
0.30817294120788574,
0.05043533816933632,
0.8987876772880554,
-0.29967185854911804,
0.9999744296073914,
0.5741847157478333,
0.39076587557792664,
0.8122888207435608,
-0.1724589318037033,
-0.09132593125104904,
-0.7081819176673889,
-0.4691404402256012,
-0.395017147064209,
-0.39901697635650635,
-0.5214830636978149,
-0.41171202063560486,
0.07104917615652084,
0.19619323313236237,
-0.6252555847167969,
0.17658065259456635,
-0.6792064905166626,
0.46174171566963196,
0.6071966290473938,
0.41679224371910095,
0.6088728308677673,
-0.09860554337501526,
-0.4673323333263397,
-0.17950262129306793,
-0.7388724684715271,
-0.5408000946044922,
0.8638033866882324,
0.2830810248851776,
1.2753254175186157,
0.30192703008651733,
1.0035873651504517,
0.740943193435669,
0.41564661264419556,
-0.7818869948387146,
0.46775493025779724,
-0.5305680632591248,
-0.29242029786109924,
-0.26842784881591797,
-0.522540807723999,
-0.8758870959281921,
0.03904690966010094,
-0.2904139459133148,
-0.414040207862854,
0.18728786706924438,
0.5228193402290344,
-0.13145782053470612,
0.1967231035232544,
-0.6985509395599365,
0.7196460962295532,
-0.32593852281570435,
-0.36028221249580383,
-0.1875452846288681,
-0.48839646577835083,
0.26914817094802856,
-0.3108687400817871,
0.07374932616949081,
0.33294907212257385,
-0.3241335153579712,
0.3198101818561554,
-0.41389137506484985,
1.0240892171859741,
0.15879258513450623,
-0.3551340103149414,
0.20091935992240906,
0.33898764848709106,
0.49097323417663574,
-0.1407434344291687,
-0.15974293649196625,
-0.23033614456653595,
0.04017750173807144,
-0.12371215969324112,
-0.550926923751831,
0.6742338538169861,
-0.9534446001052856,
-0.3635750710964203,
-0.1987663358449936,
-0.7592744827270508,
0.18124589323997498,
0.630544900894165,
0.48955920338630676,
0.7270867228507996,
-0.474029004573822,
0.41394248604774475,
1.0247703790664673,
-0.39375242590904236,
0.2501625418663025,
0.5395172238349915,
0.10153714567422867,
-0.7798380851745605,
1.1200968027114868,
-0.06787537038326263,
0.5304619669914246,
0.8370658159255981,
0.2583509385585785,
-0.27999642491340637,
-0.6906594038009644,
-0.3048023581504822,
-0.013888551853597164,
-0.5872480273246765,
-0.09660099446773529,
-0.35503464937210083,
-0.19110539555549622,
-0.1707126349210739,
-0.5967117547988892,
-0.0387161485850811,
-0.26630085706710815,
-0.7251085042953491,
0.11869587004184723,
0.008621898479759693,
0.9298405647277832,
0.26303592324256897,
0.8183404803276062,
-0.6795570850372314,
0.30313047766685486,
-0.04197027534246445,
0.17023952305316925,
-0.10001654922962189,
-0.7142009139060974,
-0.36617153882980347,
-0.13787075877189636,
-0.6202487349510193,
-0.8097053170204163,
0.47122687101364136,
0.2558968663215637,
0.3049488663673401,
0.5136283040046692,
0.1620531678199768,
0.10602056235074997,
-0.747810423374176,
0.5242276787757874,
0.24428553879261017,
-1.0597116947174072,
0.44168442487716675,
-0.41444680094718933,
0.5157326459884644,
0.5012633204460144,
0.10636530816555023,
-0.41263389587402344,
-0.5644012689590454,
-0.36886873841285706,
-0.6874187588691711,
0.5380922555923462,
0.07695400714874268,
0.19853977859020233,
0.0910736694931984,
0.5378139615058899,
0.2577541768550873,
0.3314807713031769,
-0.433845192193985,
0.3121202290058136,
-0.23364786803722382,
-0.6978051066398621,
-0.09050597995519638,
-0.447931706905365,
0.18548843264579773,
0.09281490743160248,
0.46972912549972534,
-0.053678326308727264,
-0.05983034148812294,
0.128051295876503,
-0.20032361149787903,
0.07211083918809891,
0.533889651298523,
0.8163979649543762,
0.7800160646438599,
-0.19265441596508026,
-0.0337471142411232,
-0.14171180129051208,
-0.8941523432731628,
0.25549373030662537,
-0.22068588435649872,
-0.6664789915084839,
-0.31576669216156006,
0.7446788549423218,
0.919402003288269,
0.2957504987716675,
-0.7533631324768066,
0.36411359906196594,
-0.06894997507333755,
-0.3323228359222412,
-0.22718986868858337,
0.5716525316238403,
-0.06371577084064484,
0.5047639608383179,
-0.10189739614725113,
-0.087315633893013,
-0.07953240722417831,
-0.1223885640501976,
0.18858566880226135,
0.08271237462759018,
-0.4305705428123474,
-0.3184364438056946,
0.9720434546470642,
0.5173394680023193,
-0.3601483106613159,
0.6496320962905884,
0.07432205229997635,
-0.3034285604953766,
0.5449276566505432,
0.7686203122138977,
0.7904331684112549,
-0.3327184319496155,
0.41303935647010803,
0.24231396615505219,
0.3863912522792816,
0.011068768799304962,
0.5065972208976746,
-0.21109355986118317,
-0.7757297158241272,
-0.42444801330566406,
-0.590153694152832,
-0.8142113089561462,
-0.2696700990200043,
-0.7499502897262573,
0.16659428179264069,
-0.5953906774520874,
-0.008436072617769241,
-0.1593906283378601,
0.12802931666374207,
-0.634423017501831,
0.41944366693496704,
-0.2417594939470291,
0.8771542310714722,
-0.408389687538147,
0.7612835764884949,
0.5684200525283813,
-0.25981125235557556,
-0.7896589636802673,
0.08306851238012314,
-0.08811689168214798,
-0.5357539653778076,
0.7216135263442993,
-0.018400510773062706,
0.01115579903125763,
0.37762197852134705,
-0.523195743560791,
-0.621013343334198,
1.3818210363388062,
0.14315681159496307,
-0.9093121886253357,
-0.18632501363754272,
0.02135949209332466,
0.4945921301841736,
-0.4939216375350952,
0.1799042820930481,
0.3722638189792633,
0.3591820001602173,
0.3408471941947937,
-0.4784049391746521,
0.05263406038284302,
0.04316304251551628,
0.14434444904327393,
0.16983561217784882,
-0.6592926383018494,
0.6585713028907776,
-0.5664075613021851,
0.0186250489205122,
0.22869062423706055,
0.8846191763877869,
0.3637974262237549,
0.34406524896621704,
0.3738996684551239,
0.40690162777900696,
0.8602797389030457,
0.11681566387414932,
1.0835762023925781,
-0.1537073403596878,
0.09847283363342285,
1.1979575157165527,
-0.17397251725196838,
1.036292552947998,
0.08189710974693298,
0.0784057006239891,
0.5439370274543762,
0.5140814185142517,
0.10600509494543076,
0.5532367825508118,
0.25402185320854187,
-0.4565354883670807,
-0.3361716866493225,
-0.0552208311855793,
-0.14495578408241272,
0.2316511869430542,
0.1964966058731079,
-0.5862414240837097,
0.03655841946601868,
0.08260302990674973,
0.08954766392707825,
0.31919893622398376,
-0.22955963015556335,
0.7242175936698914,
-0.008693903684616089,
-0.30923163890838623,
0.5912706851959229,
-0.014086652547121048,
0.636914074420929,
-0.6925798058509827,
-0.0073738619685173035,
-0.30651769042015076,
0.380418986082077,
-0.24020354449748993,
-0.9413533806800842,
-0.029727518558502197,
0.4481858015060425,
-0.6292833089828491,
-0.37642186880111694,
0.841635525226593,
-0.42717820405960083,
-0.5220813751220703,
-0.03701644390821457,
0.43499651551246643,
0.0933082178235054,
0.45402437448501587,
-0.5688166618347168,
0.2665835916996002,
0.3197433650493622,
-0.5905923843383789,
0.22526408731937408,
0.5343850255012512,
-0.10400297492742538,
0.7276014685630798,
0.7153439521789551,
0.2668231427669525,
0.11262699216604233,
0.2314126044511795,
0.7991348505020142,
-0.77581787109375,
-0.4231562912464142,
-0.45333877205848694,
0.4931659400463104,
0.0928269475698471,
-0.5183297395706177,
0.5609188675880432,
0.5797851085662842,
0.7945459485054016,
-0.07081808894872665,
0.9185866713523865,
-0.08247079700231552,
0.7170796990394592,
-0.5236007571220398,
0.9756243824958801,
-0.5660209655761719,
0.23070666193962097,
-0.13225647807121277,
-0.9375444054603577,
-0.21886566281318665,
0.2490464448928833,
-0.2551257312297821,
0.20589512586593628,
0.549943745136261,
0.5647298693656921,
-0.007580860052257776,
-0.35340169072151184,
0.48272958397865295,
0.30058553814888,
0.5157737731933594,
0.48657482862472534,
0.9069495797157288,
0.22797326743602753,
0.6152092814445496,
-0.141909658908844,
-0.46762579679489136,
-0.12250790745019913,
-0.9864878058433533,
-1.078757643699646,
-0.2881854474544525,
-0.13587404787540436,
-0.48995187878608704,
0.21555426716804504,
0.5713065266609192,
0.3330271244049072,
-0.7018653750419617,
-0.24702805280685425,
-0.07897906750440598,
0.1729876697063446,
-0.18719223141670227,
-0.19790582358837128,
0.34424689412117004,
-0.4238697290420532,
-0.7831327319145203,
0.25631919503211975,
0.05945759266614914,
-0.05742165818810463,
-0.24982266128063202,
-0.29969140887260437,
0.29739245772361755,
0.2049851268529892,
0.7450045347213745,
0.2580346167087555,
-0.6080653667449951,
-0.025006882846355438,
0.22243933379650116,
-0.3781687021255493,
-0.1320471614599228,
0.7584179639816284,
-0.5091162323951721,
0.6354843378067017,
0.830775260925293,
0.6595283150672913,
0.431162029504776,
0.23603303730487823,
0.4418688714504242,
-0.4821750819683075,
-0.13581381738185883,
0.22650374472141266,
-0.1784321814775467,
0.27245253324508667,
-0.5908454060554504,
0.2382611334323883,
-0.064870186150074,
-0.8167742490768433,
-0.5188384652137756,
0.29917624592781067,
-1.2254842519760132,
-0.0057601844891905785,
1.0633366107940674,
-0.2731977701187134,
-0.23314300179481506,
0.12126951664686203,
-0.5591872930526733,
0.35791370272636414,
-0.5340316891670227,
0.49143823981285095,
0.3989584445953369,
-0.15551619231700897,
-0.34446418285369873,
-0.5632168650627136,
0.314110666513443,
0.20938529074192047,
-1.005356788635254,
-0.08936938643455505,
0.651100754737854,
0.45166075229644775,
-0.37210536003112793,
0.4501745104789734,
0.0831715315580368,
0.20069897174835205,
-0.36768534779548645,
0.17540837824344635,
-0.38443586230278015,
-0.44467148184776306,
-0.036040011793375015,
-0.0025622963439673185,
0.11882226169109344,
0.19146665930747986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.09202v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.09202v1
|
Language Complexity and Speech Recognition Accuracy: Orthographic Complexity Hurts, Phonological Complexity Doesn't
| 2024-06-13T14:59:45 | 2024-06-13T14:59:45 |
Chihiro Taguchi, David Chiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We investigate what linguistic factors affect the performance of Automatic
Speech Recognition (ASR) models. We hypothesize that orthographic and
phonological complexities both degrade accuracy. To examine this, we fine-tune
the multilingual self-supervised pretrained model Wav2Vec2-XLSR-53 on 25
languages with 15 writing systems, and we compare their ASR accuracy, number of
graphemes, unigram grapheme entropy, logographicity (how much
word/morpheme-level information is encoded in the writing system), and number
of phonemes. The results demonstrate that orthographic complexities
significantly correlate with low ASR accuracy, while phonological complexity
shows no significant correlation.
|
[
0.05518706515431404,
-0.4392770826816559,
0.3764311671257019,
0.029530636966228485,
-0.049992967396974564,
0.26182863116264343,
-0.23918753862380981,
-1.0012824535369873,
-0.25237661600112915,
0.48717430233955383,
-0.22005850076675415,
-0.24798692762851715,
-0.7949750423431396,
0.11181891709566116,
-0.2006368339061737,
0.6444035172462463,
-0.048934925347566605,
0.21196672320365906,
-0.022505395114421844,
-0.4165273606777191,
-0.26310649514198303,
-0.8193321824073792,
-0.7354354858398438,
-0.5800768733024597,
0.23166276514530182,
0.37054601311683655,
0.595467746257782,
0.9630808234214783,
0.6642858386039734,
0.435016930103302,
-0.06535227596759796,
0.05341411381959915,
-0.3570666015148163,
0.05881362408399582,
0.20347809791564941,
-0.5147516131401062,
-0.3958185911178589,
-0.20137165486812592,
0.6199338436126709,
0.913519024848938,
-0.10995519906282425,
0.13828511536121368,
0.06919480115175247,
0.5971893668174744,
-0.37898772954940796,
0.23877868056297302,
-0.3063229024410248,
-0.20547348260879517,
-0.47337138652801514,
-0.10205397754907608,
-0.1588408499956131,
-0.19464229047298431,
0.4046860933303833,
-0.5410935282707214,
0.20948652923107147,
0.02802230231463909,
0.5476666688919067,
0.43936067819595337,
-0.2724435031414032,
-0.8803879022598267,
-1.0216948986053467,
0.6955770254135132,
-0.5478599071502686,
0.6238280534744263,
0.4676936864852905,
-0.08834998309612274,
0.07007903605699539,
-0.38436359167099,
-0.4665137827396393,
-0.02251139096915722,
0.046512044966220856,
0.006065873429179192,
-0.16677862405776978,
0.11144349724054337,
0.5859728455543518,
0.23454034328460693,
-0.8146424293518066,
0.45216822624206543,
-0.7507069706916809,
-0.3514916002750397,
0.7124204635620117,
0.14510118961334229,
0.42317667603492737,
-0.04444263130426407,
0.14406020939350128,
-0.2644484043121338,
-0.4123019576072693,
0.5848530530929565,
0.5360707640647888,
0.23705819249153137,
-0.081296905875206,
0.6022123098373413,
0.09925660490989685,
0.6366908550262451,
-0.004403505474328995,
-0.6705193519592285,
0.45056256651878357,
-0.05525463446974754,
-0.08644843101501465,
0.3041558861732483,
0.9623667597770691,
-0.14628659188747406,
0.42672425508499146,
-0.03587077185511589,
-0.1731165200471878,
0.267275869846344,
-0.12316011637449265,
-0.3900146186351776,
-0.5002325773239136,
0.20676058530807495,
-0.21332255005836487,
0.10807888954877853,
0.2535729706287384,
-0.01399888377636671,
-0.4366629421710968,
-0.24302682280540466,
0.5862298011779785,
-0.7652273178100586,
-0.028284961357712746,
0.22761496901512146,
-0.15346278250217438,
0.14911489188671112,
0.37698012590408325,
-0.7737508416175842,
0.2757590413093567,
0.4905635118484497,
0.6340419054031372,
-0.09891730546951294,
-0.67848140001297,
-0.1264726221561432,
-0.06491944938898087,
-0.4012819230556488,
0.7930956482887268,
-0.425496906042099,
-0.46778714656829834,
-0.24014241993427277,
-0.24019651114940643,
-0.21713759005069733,
-0.7052695751190186,
0.33682891726493835,
-0.2608601748943329,
-0.003965136595070362,
-0.29920536279678345,
-0.5756223797798157,
-0.2137855589389801,
-0.5052501559257507,
-0.6680226922035217,
0.7531436681747437,
-0.2061832696199417,
-0.39386287331581116,
0.41792505979537964,
-0.3285128176212311,
-0.9204079508781433,
-0.09833496809005737,
-0.2036244422197342,
-0.4690951108932495,
0.23139624297618866,
-0.31319400668144226,
0.35863256454467773,
0.029249699786305428,
-0.16529229283332825,
0.031208666041493416,
-0.371200829744339,
0.3551122844219208,
-0.1979033648967743,
0.7493225932121277,
0.12238594889640808,
-0.3652573525905609,
-0.15387597680091858,
-1.2010552883148193,
-0.004700817167758942,
0.061871886253356934,
-0.7648412585258484,
-0.08456215262413025,
0.026152878999710083,
-0.11720334738492966,
0.21354460716247559,
0.24233897030353546,
-0.6501901149749756,
-0.1341719627380371,
-0.4468599855899811,
0.7776364088058472,
0.24871689081192017,
-0.39097386598587036,
0.6004378795623779,
-0.3449850082397461,
0.34639972448349,
0.05565129965543747,
-0.1126314327120781,
-0.06917282193899155,
-0.502303421497345,
-0.793972373008728,
-0.013774081133306026,
0.2793292701244354,
0.7836835384368896,
-0.3525571823120117,
0.16703125834465027,
-0.33525896072387695,
-0.6634150147438049,
-0.5374481678009033,
0.09124796837568283,
0.8636905550956726,
0.44476720690727234,
0.25559407472610474,
-0.6227501630783081,
-0.44912806153297424,
-0.6343095898628235,
-0.2899765968322754,
-0.4127357006072998,
-0.016355635598301888,
0.2238115817308426,
0.1989680528640747,
-0.03500395640730858,
0.28061434626579285,
-0.18876008689403534,
-0.535972535610199,
0.13072697818279266,
0.5757524371147156,
-0.08519574254751205,
0.5900731682777405,
0.2617366313934326,
-0.38711273670196533,
-0.3577393591403961,
-0.07592514902353287,
-0.48220178484916687,
-0.11367838829755783,
0.3231510818004608,
0.721476674079895,
0.7405675649642944,
0.702644944190979,
-0.5170220136642456,
0.42743685841560364,
0.46812939643859863,
-0.19548778235912323,
0.4800150692462921,
-0.6189616918563843,
0.22478510439395905,
-0.2945498824119568,
0.08685001730918884,
-0.19710195064544678,
-0.0393839031457901,
-0.9525645971298218,
-0.27864938974380493,
0.06731022149324417,
-0.21791356801986694,
-0.07428771257400513,
0.0379222072660923,
-0.6456804871559143,
-0.27019864320755005,
-0.07734349370002747,
-0.15316373109817505,
-0.019053027033805847,
0.23072364926338196,
0.25086453557014465,
0.7074163556098938,
0.46471601724624634,
-0.5330345034599304,
0.19205684959888458,
-0.08339264988899231,
-0.5268195271492004,
0.35880807042121887,
-0.7949370741844177,
0.3152730166912079,
-0.1964431256055832,
-0.0235457606613636,
-1.2282683849334717,
-0.27902287244796753,
-0.06592444330453873,
-0.7368144392967224,
0.7578404545783997,
0.20173116028308868,
-0.3641391396522522,
-0.26126477122306824,
0.06200479716062546,
0.802864134311676,
0.4310727119445801,
-0.02124907821416855,
0.5586339235305786,
0.4912227988243103,
-0.16161379218101501,
-0.5261293649673462,
-1.037316083908081,
-0.03519979491829872,
0.1114061251282692,
-0.49282553791999817,
0.09334540367126465,
-0.07427369058132172,
-0.2022777944803238,
-0.30813276767730713,
-0.1266356259584427,
-0.03972230851650238,
-0.08119311183691025,
0.5423048734664917,
-0.264182984828949,
-0.24737797677516937,
0.24814768135547638,
-0.3585841655731201,
-0.21708077192306519,
0.09338415414094925,
-0.21725629270076752,
0.515597939491272,
-0.30231478810310364,
-0.4122491776943207,
-0.6536372303962708,
0.30022045969963074,
0.6514866352081299,
-0.377189040184021,
0.28800585865974426,
0.4156717360019684,
-0.2948113679885864,
0.152229905128479,
-0.7507809400558472,
0.13354307413101196,
-0.4012068808078766,
0.4544076919555664,
-0.7655577659606934,
-0.985187828540802,
0.6908702850341797,
0.4055933654308319,
-0.3285948634147644,
0.5365510582923889,
0.4193633496761322,
-0.4021308422088623,
0.8784746527671814,
0.4611724615097046,
0.004860138986259699,
0.32397788763046265,
-0.23545226454734802,
0.14019840955734253,
-0.3892439901828766,
-0.5814574360847473,
-0.763724148273468,
-0.012681934051215649,
-0.7737996578216553,
-0.2502506971359253,
0.13564273715019226,
-0.06903475522994995,
-0.34814316034317017,
0.3998882472515106,
-0.4944969713687897,
0.30031269788742065,
0.7138221859931946,
0.02192906104028225,
0.4358285963535309,
0.04220223054289818,
0.1162109300494194,
-0.11651577055454254,
-0.8041723966598511,
-0.41843119263648987,
0.9310035109519958,
0.236363485455513,
0.902463436126709,
0.29673078656196594,
0.5594197511672974,
0.1371653974056244,
-0.49125850200653076,
-0.7365833520889282,
0.011440485715866089,
-0.4706670045852661,
-0.38911429047584534,
-0.7851302027702332,
-0.3500107526779175,
-1.0057109594345093,
-0.33908161520957947,
-0.21280018985271454,
-0.796295702457428,
0.6347101330757141,
0.3340151906013489,
-0.5382479429244995,
0.09234628081321716,
-0.7284369468688965,
0.5888286828994751,
-0.1776459664106369,
0.2683735191822052,
-0.055086709558963776,
-0.9281784892082214,
-0.09303254634141922,
-0.25351330637931824,
0.40153443813323975,
-0.0055945152416825294,
-0.0665198266506195,
0.840697705745697,
-0.4767777621746063,
0.7331627607345581,
0.13523471355438232,
-0.24514169991016388,
0.2396927773952484,
0.2396453619003296,
0.2705991864204407,
-0.5247923731803894,
-0.21231324970722198,
0.5050020813941956,
0.12330084294080734,
-0.23443080484867096,
-0.41615360975265503,
0.4871906340122223,
-1.1862237453460693,
-0.3194807767868042,
-0.44595104455947876,
-0.42692509293556213,
0.009649663232266903,
0.20290319621562958,
0.9136054515838623,
0.8421513438224792,
-0.02856633812189102,
-0.09103072434663773,
0.7294917702674866,
-0.10831859707832336,
0.31638744473457336,
0.42214328050613403,
0.30837833881378174,
-0.2715192139148712,
1.068701982498169,
1.0192694664001465,
0.3730058968067169,
0.38449662923812866,
0.04422515258193016,
-0.2750132977962494,
-0.8454979658126831,
-0.2750549614429474,
0.1807214766740799,
-0.8878188133239746,
0.003163957968354225,
-0.6917368173599243,
-0.2918362617492676,
-0.6966211199760437,
-0.05076904594898224,
-0.4643397331237793,
-0.610013484954834,
-0.5021242499351501,
0.19654768705368042,
0.3388926386833191,
1.1021703481674194,
-0.47143644094467163,
0.2327781617641449,
-0.5338819026947021,
0.1890394389629364,
0.36441439390182495,
0.32820653915405273,
-0.076961949467659,
-1.0316059589385986,
-0.18365785479545593,
-0.10191313177347183,
0.12918506562709808,
-0.5642113089561462,
-0.042906731367111206,
0.5799874067306519,
0.2170349657535553,
0.3053254187107086,
-0.1604151874780655,
0.8562660813331604,
-0.6700702905654907,
0.42814281582832336,
0.2652015686035156,
-1.1678074598312378,
0.35080283880233765,
-0.19762510061264038,
0.5440322160720825,
0.4906803071498871,
0.17847730219364166,
-0.25958943367004395,
-0.5672778487205505,
-0.6577615737915039,
-0.6844542026519775,
0.7462093234062195,
0.08577343076467514,
-0.05086541920900345,
0.32421159744262695,
0.5827805399894714,
0.052031997591257095,
0.04173630475997925,
-0.5115334987640381,
-0.350713849067688,
-0.38278335332870483,
-0.04364369809627533,
-0.4217710494995117,
-0.5492103099822998,
0.2422615885734558,
-0.18683810532093048,
0.4930683374404907,
0.29421380162239075,
0.10746939480304718,
0.3355182111263275,
-0.36348697543144226,
-0.351728618144989,
0.056363776326179504,
0.9940569400787354,
0.6712893843650818,
-0.10120034962892532,
0.3012336492538452,
0.23839060962200165,
-0.6144932508468628,
0.3325382471084595,
0.06562350690364838,
0.03590178117156029,
-0.18827007710933685,
0.9465286731719971,
0.7717897891998291,
0.041427064687013626,
-0.6272191405296326,
0.3167041540145874,
-0.06327082216739655,
-0.3061657249927521,
-0.4731195569038391,
0.31988194584846497,
0.03013376146554947,
0.32457244396209717,
0.32360830903053284,
0.2625581622123718,
0.3162957727909088,
-0.6514931917190552,
-0.0703473761677742,
0.18528136610984802,
-0.47975239157676697,
-0.3291293680667877,
0.599686861038208,
-0.0860205739736557,
-0.7653754353523254,
0.5421889424324036,
0.024476760998368263,
-0.6118020415306091,
0.5964474081993103,
0.3376944363117218,
0.438405841588974,
-0.7137975096702576,
-0.26242879033088684,
0.4115391969680786,
0.5118362307548523,
-0.19682961702346802,
0.3560287058353424,
-0.02839800715446472,
-0.772793710231781,
-0.29263728857040405,
-0.44301363825798035,
-0.5569207668304443,
0.11275031417608261,
-0.8021817803382874,
0.05348630249500275,
-0.4974592924118042,
-0.1959351748228073,
0.5136739611625671,
0.08356823772192001,
-0.6488844752311707,
0.5476768612861633,
0.16634927690029144,
0.33295589685440063,
-0.7311782240867615,
0.6905878186225891,
0.6949670910835266,
-0.2544791102409363,
-1.0801888704299927,
-0.31293612718582153,
0.047986265271902084,
-0.7621455788612366,
0.6518167853355408,
0.16996566951274872,
-0.697441041469574,
0.2977614998817444,
-0.2935802638530731,
-0.9986271262168884,
0.9748496413230896,
0.4145430326461792,
-0.6224594712257385,
0.3187324106693268,
0.48865237832069397,
0.8398680090904236,
-0.12564870715141296,
-0.035067297518253326,
0.66552734375,
0.27285441756248474,
0.16003923118114471,
-1.3867653608322144,
-0.1526164412498474,
-0.11604411900043488,
-0.0003746846632566303,
0.09958362579345703,
-0.5142566561698914,
0.8558191061019897,
-0.6364962458610535,
-0.6005027890205383,
0.058404091745615005,
0.4707874357700348,
-0.06482180953025818,
0.09810828417539597,
0.32888364791870117,
0.6429107785224915,
0.8878383040428162,
-0.04932967573404312,
0.9028800129890442,
-0.13439065217971802,
0.07754500955343246,
1.10939621925354,
-0.13729624450206757,
0.8346022963523865,
0.15181110799312592,
-0.37609511613845825,
0.37789595127105713,
0.5759570598602295,
0.001063812174834311,
0.21132244169712067,
0.23960088193416595,
0.06133659929037094,
-0.20804360508918762,
0.06436003744602203,
-0.25165942311286926,
0.910696804523468,
0.31610122323036194,
-0.2576838433742523,
0.1841866821050644,
0.08051861822605133,
0.07962135970592499,
0.12080128490924835,
-0.22989626228809357,
1.0080732107162476,
0.21761532127857208,
-0.5162305235862732,
0.7297686338424683,
0.10592448711395264,
0.4424949288368225,
-0.3455832004547119,
0.3259331285953522,
0.23022812604904175,
0.11961884796619415,
-0.41708147525787354,
-0.7656725645065308,
0.33380627632141113,
-0.18109498918056488,
-0.4426393508911133,
0.15569421648979187,
0.8174828290939331,
-0.5399705171585083,
-0.5050991773605347,
0.39035505056381226,
0.562533974647522,
0.41924548149108887,
-0.0475691556930542,
-0.5267853140830994,
0.3132886290550232,
-0.31756240129470825,
-0.09774107486009598,
0.053789544850587845,
0.6896694302558899,
0.21258847415447235,
0.7952752113342285,
0.509804904460907,
0.15959049761295319,
0.1380743682384491,
0.13306640088558197,
0.4124910235404968,
-0.49850794672966003,
-0.26912879943847656,
-0.9130145907402039,
0.17718233168125153,
0.2729727625846863,
-0.2887377142906189,
0.5740159749984741,
0.48721715807914734,
0.9837085604667664,
0.020855015143752098,
0.7021825909614563,
0.16467034816741943,
0.4904823303222656,
-0.43245357275009155,
0.768315851688385,
-0.5042241215705872,
0.08503113687038422,
-0.38142678141593933,
-0.516162633895874,
-0.7512643337249756,
0.8875898718833923,
-0.38138246536254883,
0.10075053572654724,
0.5686315298080444,
0.6759589314460754,
0.13863830268383026,
-0.1700296252965927,
0.5147566795349121,
0.3081391453742981,
-0.10804153978824615,
0.4634939134120941,
0.617159366607666,
-0.5750476717948914,
0.6937111616134644,
-0.38776496052742004,
-0.2561604082584381,
-0.13936525583267212,
-0.48182082176208496,
-0.908944308757782,
-0.7990438938140869,
-0.44779685139656067,
-0.3962799608707428,
0.14197133481502533,
0.6544690132141113,
0.47481000423431396,
-0.9958445429801941,
-0.5569469928741455,
0.11949367821216583,
-0.04014676436781883,
-0.00026286367210559547,
-0.0776638612151146,
0.6588944792747498,
-0.11186036467552185,
-0.45411792397499084,
0.07072902470827103,
0.43975743651390076,
0.4256103038787842,
-0.008183795027434826,
-0.16498367488384247,
0.22330689430236816,
-0.03520265221595764,
0.5543479323387146,
0.6039559245109558,
-0.8306035995483398,
-0.30996015667915344,
-0.06257618963718414,
-0.405070960521698,
0.3599669635295868,
0.7124483585357666,
-0.2848447859287262,
0.615368127822876,
0.4178813695907593,
0.17932000756263733,
0.33744800090789795,
-0.042431868612766266,
0.4273611903190613,
-0.29206153750419617,
-0.007911461405456066,
0.14027774333953857,
0.3460603952407837,
0.45111778378486633,
-0.2994079291820526,
0.14695779979228973,
0.24081332981586456,
-0.6425984501838684,
-0.6885600686073303,
0.35364431142807007,
-0.7884709239006042,
-0.2196231186389923,
1.0205916166305542,
-0.22068428993225098,
0.02229335717856884,
-0.6075994968414307,
-0.047811493277549744,
0.3061818778514862,
-0.2868148982524872,
0.5990050435066223,
0.8217552304267883,
-0.42932677268981934,
-0.2720281481742859,
-0.11379670351743698,
0.803120493888855,
0.23197290301322937,
-0.18611417710781097,
-0.03265596926212311,
0.4023147225379944,
0.4484703838825226,
0.47207966446876526,
0.8576160669326782,
-0.010107120499014854,
0.3347577154636383,
0.3186495006084442,
0.20226305723190308,
-0.055591046810150146,
-0.32993626594543457,
-0.7307670712471008,
0.12860558927059174,
0.5368267893791199,
0.20807339251041412
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.