id
stringlengths 33
33
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
33
| title
stringlengths 13
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 6
16.6k
| category_primary
stringclasses 60
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
132
| abstract
stringlengths 123
1.99k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07358v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07358v3
|
AI Sandbagging: Language Models can Strategically Underperform on Evaluations
| 2024-06-11T15:26:57 | 2024-06-14T22:24:40 |
Teun van der Weij, Felix Hofstätter, Ollie Jaffe, Samuel F. Brown, Francis Rhys Ward
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Trustworthy capability evaluations are crucial for ensuring the safety of AI
systems, and are becoming a key component of AI regulation. However, the
developers of an AI system, or the AI system itself, may have incentives for
evaluations to understate the AI's actual capability. These conflicting
interests lead to the problem of sandbagging $\unicode{x2013}$ which we define
as "strategic underperformance on an evaluation". In this paper we assess
sandbagging capabilities in contemporary language models (LMs). We prompt
frontier LMs, like GPT-4 and Claude 3 Opus, to selectively underperform on
dangerous capability evaluations, while maintaining performance on general
(harmless) capability evaluations. Moreover, we find that models can be
fine-tuned, on a synthetic dataset, to hide specific capabilities unless given
a password. This behaviour generalizes to high-quality, held-out benchmarks
such as WMDP. In addition, we show that both frontier and smaller models can be
prompted, or password-locked, to target specific scores on a capability
evaluation. Even more, we found that a capable password-locked model (Llama 3
70b) is reasonably able to emulate a less capable model (Llama 2 7b). Overall,
our results suggest that capability evaluations are vulnerable to sandbagging.
This vulnerability decreases the trustworthiness of evaluations, and thereby
undermines important safety decisions regarding the development and deployment
of advanced AI systems.
|
[
-0.21714231371879578,
-0.6024941205978394,
0.6011251211166382,
-0.048656534403562546,
-0.0579795204102993,
0.4061237573623657,
-0.16767680644989014,
-0.5133308172225952,
-0.33847859501838684,
0.6143796443939209,
-0.19173000752925873,
-0.30826371908187866,
-0.7662903070449829,
-0.3421950042247772,
-0.6635177731513977,
1.101198673248291,
-0.07312709838151932,
-0.2792190909385681,
-0.47527292370796204,
-0.1402156502008438,
-0.6029672622680664,
-0.8886097073554993,
-0.3859846591949463,
-0.5166099071502686,
0.061406459659338,
0.20071448385715485,
0.9645439386367798,
0.6042819619178772,
0.7254137992858887,
0.38609644770622253,
-0.02994384989142418,
-0.1404486894607544,
-0.4083157181739807,
-0.13584838807582855,
-0.19386808574199677,
-0.7025789022445679,
-0.5118727087974548,
0.21799086034297943,
0.7599811553955078,
0.48094844818115234,
-0.39924007654190063,
0.15192784368991852,
0.1430717408657074,
0.47068753838539124,
-0.7952768206596375,
-0.0004886451060883701,
-0.9232551455497742,
-0.3191472887992859,
-0.42920467257499695,
0.11887051910161972,
-0.20654341578483582,
-0.2974373698234558,
-0.08367069810628891,
-0.19515018165111542,
-0.16079294681549072,
0.14489999413490295,
1.0389518737792969,
0.3507526218891144,
0.009063588455319405,
-0.2795353829860687,
-0.8383976221084595,
1.007830023765564,
-0.6188151836395264,
0.005475745536386967,
0.853672981262207,
0.4322132170200348,
0.10971283167600632,
-0.594122588634491,
-0.41576340794563293,
-0.5399524569511414,
0.008569922298192978,
-0.17300263047218323,
-0.362230509519577,
0.26240333914756775,
0.32365888357162476,
0.41999271512031555,
-0.43532711267471313,
0.4882849156856537,
-0.6560477614402771,
-0.19454234838485718,
0.9379463195800781,
0.12203320860862732,
0.25981441140174866,
-0.055714286863803864,
-0.5855640769004822,
-0.1717698872089386,
-0.7021360397338867,
0.40868300199508667,
0.62022864818573,
0.14158673584461212,
-0.03988924250006676,
0.5063418745994568,
-0.13327401876449585,
0.34783780574798584,
-0.38988998532295227,
-0.13708139955997467,
0.1138027235865593,
-0.11762920767068863,
-0.24573493003845215,
-0.2786497175693512,
0.6600936055183411,
0.402670294046402,
0.4556930661201477,
-0.4164138436317444,
-0.8850222826004028,
0.3428378701210022,
0.5855749249458313,
-0.3384799361228943,
-0.18115369975566864,
0.37938961386680603,
-0.6967595219612122,
-0.7087547183036804,
0.24500229954719543,
-0.5848731398582458,
-0.48980769515037537,
0.0886642336845398,
0.5715965628623962,
-0.3535005450248718,
-0.2076573371887207,
-0.09379472583532333,
-0.32876744866371155,
0.14679455757141113,
-0.16672690212726593,
-0.8223057985305786,
0.7849923372268677,
0.7701625227928162,
0.7960593700408936,
-0.20693399012088776,
-0.30236542224884033,
-0.3153010904788971,
0.12636476755142212,
-0.19279919564723969,
0.7005236744880676,
-0.7873218059539795,
-0.6110449433326721,
-0.012810350395739079,
-0.3692845106124878,
-0.026416374370455742,
-0.757896900177002,
0.4208315908908844,
-0.475747674703598,
-0.2558548152446747,
-0.23173503577709198,
-0.38346749544143677,
-0.23928678035736084,
0.2536890506744385,
-0.42409414052963257,
0.662132978439331,
0.11794210225343704,
-0.20071814954280853,
0.25894689559936523,
-0.5910020470619202,
-0.17335546016693115,
0.10322286933660507,
-0.447316974401474,
-0.3914230763912201,
0.1740320324897766,
0.1850612461566925,
0.250408798456192,
-0.33656546473503113,
0.30382081866264343,
-0.4727534353733063,
-0.7278600335121155,
0.5259448885917664,
-0.6455134749412537,
0.5601497888565063,
0.15884456038475037,
-0.3168877363204956,
0.17520397901535034,
-0.5265792012214661,
0.3064165413379669,
0.17032328248023987,
-0.24699842929840088,
-0.23347432911396027,
0.0800132304430008,
-0.2992461025714874,
0.014732707291841507,
0.20382903516292572,
-0.20174472033977509,
0.12785059213638306,
-0.42176470160484314,
0.3341052234172821,
1.003724455833435,
-0.15813250839710236,
0.5438997149467468,
-0.8344272375106812,
0.851089358329773,
-0.3523680567741394,
0.28527718782424927,
0.025547761470079422,
-0.3908413350582123,
-0.654028594493866,
-0.2269376814365387,
0.6062873005867004,
0.9209977984428406,
-0.502589762210846,
0.29023537039756775,
-0.2632285952568054,
-0.7092629075050354,
-0.5226388573646545,
0.36107155680656433,
0.6113317608833313,
-0.16893449425697327,
0.2261805534362793,
-0.5839124321937561,
0.01023904699832201,
-1.034229040145874,
-0.2939371168613434,
-0.42366498708724976,
-0.06959246098995209,
0.3091124892234802,
0.493588387966156,
-0.09016284346580505,
0.7476111650466919,
-0.23577767610549927,
-0.4445553421974182,
-0.378506064414978,
0.15139997005462646,
-0.07349452376365662,
0.8338741064071655,
0.5874691009521484,
-0.6608375906944275,
0.1915961652994156,
-0.3415389358997345,
-0.5927176475524902,
-0.08242645114660263,
-0.2664652466773987,
0.3038204610347748,
0.11597615480422974,
0.6265038847923279,
-0.6705334186553955,
0.49143704771995544,
0.6123101115226746,
-0.04896792396903038,
0.5277799367904663,
-0.26479679346084595,
-0.03179330378770828,
-0.31311726570129395,
0.3086088001728058,
-0.3192231059074402,
0.04921167343854904,
-0.3043447732925415,
0.6437115669250488,
-0.027649682015180588,
-0.1406722366809845,
-0.261741578578949,
0.3020515739917755,
-0.22878523170948029,
-0.009993941523134708,
-0.2965136766433716,
0.14794036746025085,
-0.21964463591575623,
0.1509869396686554,
-0.27596932649612427,
0.5114257335662842,
0.5705859661102295,
-0.652510404586792,
0.31346026062965393,
-0.11625345051288605,
-0.5258587002754211,
0.27338823676109314,
-0.7762131690979004,
0.15130332112312317,
-0.029472528025507927,
0.36375346779823303,
-0.821101725101471,
-0.028916537761688232,
0.21584777534008026,
-0.22355884313583374,
0.3387395441532135,
-0.18284234404563904,
-0.5070651769638062,
-0.28376710414886475,
-0.48975253105163574,
0.5148739218711853,
0.7983959913253784,
-0.09599573165178299,
0.33312663435935974,
0.6321374773979187,
-0.1284467875957489,
-0.6239826083183289,
-0.8996703028678894,
0.020854955539107323,
-0.4283284842967987,
-0.41135337948799133,
0.4717045724391937,
0.11982308328151703,
-0.5651882290840149,
0.011518824845552444,
-0.06101857125759125,
-0.03373173624277115,
0.5896707773208618,
0.6699219346046448,
0.1472409963607788,
0.11015301197767258,
0.0613265223801136,
-0.07471724599599838,
-0.34023770689964294,
0.3092088997364044,
0.06694821268320084,
0.5056815147399902,
-0.2859860360622406,
-0.6646977066993713,
-0.10922486335039139,
0.3024139106273651,
0.39991313219070435,
-0.38768431544303894,
0.68039470911026,
0.5819475650787354,
-0.5483386516571045,
-0.25984781980514526,
-0.5293682813644409,
-0.33221375942230225,
-0.5344671607017517,
0.14155684411525726,
-0.27015939354896545,
-0.5863642692565918,
0.5422886610031128,
-0.22436225414276123,
0.029673565179109573,
0.26439064741134644,
0.23078225553035736,
-0.09588812291622162,
0.8579532504081726,
0.9366776943206787,
-0.26875221729278564,
0.2465880811214447,
-0.25560683012008667,
0.30186986923217773,
-0.5169640779495239,
-0.2684970200061798,
-0.5514701008796692,
-0.5409031510353088,
-0.7993670105934143,
-0.30046430230140686,
0.19574949145317078,
0.23731015622615814,
0.0629160925745964,
0.06951333582401276,
-0.2885392904281616,
0.7531810402870178,
0.6045864224433899,
-0.07022810727357864,
0.13745330274105072,
-0.16857661306858063,
-0.18896956741809845,
0.13123008608818054,
-0.7757391333580017,
-0.8067166805267334,
1.2168422937393188,
0.6222082376480103,
0.8698397874832153,
0.13533256947994232,
0.7357707619667053,
0.4700298607349396,
0.16309118270874023,
-0.41125690937042236,
0.6884407997131348,
0.017870808020234108,
-0.5546071529388428,
-0.1814834475517273,
-0.3518018424510956,
-0.825871467590332,
0.032167740166187286,
-0.3538282811641693,
-1.2426353693008423,
-0.07185722887516022,
0.054160766303539276,
-0.804251492023468,
0.3579201400279999,
-0.7104494571685791,
0.654779851436615,
-0.28529033064842224,
-0.13202816247940063,
-0.6158446073532104,
-0.48426616191864014,
0.5903929471969604,
-0.1351170688867569,
0.4583214521408081,
-0.32295843958854675,
-0.2023920863866806,
0.6224046349525452,
-0.148362398147583,
0.903126060962677,
-0.03455355763435364,
0.06578430533409119,
0.24109560251235962,
0.35425031185150146,
0.266189843416214,
0.13957571983337402,
-0.026096167042851448,
0.4237224757671356,
0.13952113687992096,
-0.4190719425678253,
-0.562548041343689,
0.9546231627464294,
-0.7326126098632812,
-0.9897106289863586,
-0.6368383765220642,
-0.37968772649765015,
-0.18497487902641296,
0.033831704407930374,
0.13778090476989746,
0.36616986989974976,
-0.1893811672925949,
0.098812535405159,
0.3549964427947998,
-0.2439093440771103,
0.7032226324081421,
0.2656727433204651,
-0.351106733083725,
-0.1433805525302887,
1.1406290531158447,
0.43087875843048096,
0.3933621644973755,
-0.06029028072953224,
0.0077146971598267555,
-0.08805014938116074,
-0.8299520015716553,
-0.32442933320999146,
-0.04576382413506508,
-0.6709786653518677,
-0.3846188485622406,
-0.25905242562294006,
-0.4881170094013214,
-0.08918941766023636,
-0.3176446855068207,
-0.3334819972515106,
-0.5861263275146484,
0.20684626698493958,
0.0498623289167881,
-0.03030601516366005,
1.023533582687378,
-0.20183171331882477,
0.42729976773262024,
-0.6924540996551514,
0.1239396333694458,
0.21584200859069824,
0.6716838479042053,
0.0021798883099108934,
-0.4369475841522217,
-0.13766756653785706,
-0.04044453054666519,
-0.47595223784446716,
-0.618240475654602,
0.0007494023884646595,
-0.027827253565192223,
0.8127426505088806,
0.42203769087791443,
0.20804505050182343,
0.43427425622940063,
-0.16277416050434113,
0.9007963538169861,
-0.37136203050613403,
-1.027752161026001,
0.41691142320632935,
-0.24572084844112396,
0.44521409273147583,
0.49250468611717224,
0.3537260890007019,
-0.12244176864624023,
-0.5400082468986511,
-0.966832160949707,
-0.9116342663764954,
0.6059131622314453,
0.3079202473163605,
0.2740788161754608,
0.3556593060493469,
0.12605024874210358,
-0.10508819669485092,
0.4418751895427704,
-0.8767789602279663,
-0.02018735557794571,
0.21307335793972015,
0.08787516504526138,
-0.06819257885217667,
-0.43239670991897583,
-0.3281297981739044,
0.029111046344041824,
0.6108208298683167,
0.07930053770542145,
0.01899566873908043,
-0.2994023561477661,
-0.06346723437309265,
-0.08445395529270172,
0.3144845962524414,
0.4332643449306488,
0.7502697110176086,
-0.07584986835718155,
-0.0678306594491005,
0.41481149196624756,
-0.2241286337375641,
-0.10937175899744034,
0.27806779742240906,
-0.2826971709728241,
-0.41491174697875977,
0.3954913914203644,
0.29627931118011475,
0.23296214640140533,
-0.8820810317993164,
0.57427579164505,
0.040433477610349655,
0.1286161094903946,
-0.4140225350856781,
0.3779619634151459,
-0.45384275913238525,
0.26966696977615356,
0.2699199616909027,
0.42049649357795715,
0.16256894171237946,
-0.5017931461334229,
0.1350679099559784,
0.734490156173706,
-0.278939425945282,
-0.015056539326906204,
0.4689503312110901,
0.17126019299030304,
-0.265316903591156,
0.6259310245513916,
-0.15350772440433502,
-0.6209263205528259,
0.4735448360443115,
0.24920818209648132,
0.7735334038734436,
-0.26968052983283997,
0.12871479988098145,
-0.031062554568052292,
0.9446493983268738,
0.002641550963744521,
0.11910245567560196,
-0.14082574844360352,
-0.605254590511322,
-0.08720226585865021,
-0.6398265957832336,
-0.37794312834739685,
0.2834281623363495,
-0.5610160231590271,
0.07282646000385284,
-0.7475965023040771,
-0.3908509612083435,
-0.4488884508609772,
-0.003330618143081665,
-0.6038700342178345,
0.09307942539453506,
0.4623803198337555,
0.7293084263801575,
-0.6823726892471313,
0.7267087697982788,
0.3155427575111389,
-0.32961469888687134,
-0.4311046004295349,
0.18844351172447205,
0.15529774129390717,
-0.8182841539382935,
0.16448929905891418,
0.3594370186328888,
-0.053199801594018936,
-0.27427664399147034,
-0.3605116009712219,
-1.0149656534194946,
1.0104373693466187,
0.333126962184906,
-0.416124552488327,
-0.09766454994678497,
0.2980796992778778,
0.34530115127563477,
-0.1413370966911316,
0.2462269514799118,
0.9175978302955627,
0.4971119165420532,
-0.5494006872177124,
-1.323548436164856,
0.16227231919765472,
-0.08548101037740707,
0.035385455936193466,
-0.013104371726512909,
-0.846306324005127,
0.747211217880249,
-0.3229915201663971,
-0.3485621511936188,
0.32547444105148315,
0.3978388011455536,
0.3489735424518585,
0.12997247278690338,
0.5350722670555115,
0.6185023784637451,
0.7957273721694946,
-0.23668812215328217,
1.3181108236312866,
-0.1453508585691452,
-0.09900616109371185,
0.672759473323822,
-0.08041843771934509,
1.097318410873413,
0.3623324930667877,
0.040249794721603394,
0.5459490418434143,
0.28894126415252686,
-0.1024334579706192,
0.5350131392478943,
0.5505249500274658,
-0.016463816165924072,
-0.3790888488292694,
-0.18380628526210785,
-0.304299533367157,
0.866699755191803,
0.45539212226867676,
-0.36261919140815735,
-0.06521783024072647,
-0.21874624490737915,
0.015942523255944252,
0.23673701286315918,
-0.3359251618385315,
0.6350072622299194,
0.29831159114837646,
-0.6684569120407104,
0.5561525225639343,
0.3076099455356598,
0.5062084197998047,
-0.7456949353218079,
0.015152296051383018,
0.1582646667957306,
0.33432483673095703,
-0.11214904487133026,
-0.6744542717933655,
0.2735106348991394,
0.06251396983861923,
0.1992434710264206,
-0.33467841148376465,
0.7000071406364441,
-0.13740406930446625,
-0.4645554721355438,
0.2839442193508148,
0.6319690942764282,
-0.004728448577225208,
-0.0798453614115715,
-0.8186081051826477,
0.6222985982894897,
-0.34640973806381226,
-0.08042710274457932,
0.5303812623023987,
-0.03365357592701912,
-0.28158724308013916,
1.0536870956420898,
0.6397441029548645,
0.11756697297096252,
-0.319448858499527,
-0.0846712738275528,
0.9411420822143555,
-0.47933217883110046,
-0.5125097036361694,
-1.123523473739624,
0.448661744594574,
-0.2009693831205368,
-0.31414610147476196,
0.6634494066238403,
0.2356204390525818,
0.9031561613082886,
0.2796308100223541,
0.8950225114822388,
0.08134181052446365,
-0.050570543855428696,
-0.6139826774597168,
1.1622661352157593,
-0.2588688135147095,
0.6114432215690613,
-0.1831582933664322,
-0.7371805310249329,
0.018084092065691948,
0.3212396502494812,
-0.37153396010398865,
0.3675498962402344,
0.4471554458141327,
0.722134530544281,
-0.0608302541077137,
-0.07744766771793365,
0.4358620047569275,
0.02830076403915882,
0.42334604263305664,
0.4894134998321533,
0.8770115971565247,
-0.3801563084125519,
0.7307698726654053,
-0.33995917439460754,
-0.35245925188064575,
-0.12091851979494095,
-0.8438894152641296,
-0.9203231930732727,
-0.5420313477516174,
-0.15521544218063354,
-0.32388660311698914,
0.22768211364746094,
0.5817462801933289,
0.7068122625350952,
-0.729225218296051,
-0.3662841320037842,
0.2676692008972168,
0.25753965973854065,
-0.2500806748867035,
-0.15539880096912384,
-0.14616847038269043,
-0.3395109176635742,
-0.36936721205711365,
0.5886948108673096,
0.1256023645401001,
0.22787831723690033,
-0.6283586621284485,
0.06753133237361908,
0.2253679782152176,
0.350890576839447,
0.027603471651673317,
0.24264656007289886,
-0.919518768787384,
-0.27635589241981506,
-0.5517640113830566,
-0.011166034266352654,
-0.4821716845035553,
0.6240242719650269,
-0.9641062617301941,
0.193639874458313,
0.08248430490493774,
0.6643245220184326,
0.06591393053531647,
0.165060892701149,
0.9124864935874939,
-0.6510544419288635,
0.2107345163822174,
0.37300699949264526,
0.24570485949516296,
0.3325692415237427,
-0.0643598735332489,
0.21909888088703156,
0.11030184477567673,
-0.6645004153251648,
-1.0637151002883911,
0.13416670262813568,
-0.44104012846946716,
-0.23351818323135376,
1.1149243116378784,
-0.1581813246011734,
-0.09780174493789673,
0.04041532054543495,
-0.040828194469213486,
-0.32112574577331543,
-0.33038535714149475,
1.1532461643218994,
0.8777621984481812,
0.17975282669067383,
0.1010451540350914,
-0.597086489200592,
0.831649661064148,
0.44628211855888367,
-0.47609075903892517,
-0.05813382565975189,
0.09276628494262695,
0.006159772165119648,
0.15674079954624176,
0.39995136857032776,
-0.010189901106059551,
0.4385219216346741,
0.2552514970302582,
-0.45715802907943726,
-0.13126325607299805,
-0.3927496671676636,
-0.50925612449646,
0.43426814675331116,
0.40390080213546753,
-0.1611964851617813
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07353v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07353v1
|
Toxic Memes: A Survey of Computational Perspectives on the Detection and Explanation of Meme Toxicities
| 2024-06-11T15:22:48 | 2024-06-11T15:22:48 |
Delfina Sol Martinez Pandiani, Erik Tjong Kim Sang, Davide Ceolin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.SI
|
Internet memes, channels for humor, social commentary, and cultural
expression, are increasingly used to spread toxic messages. Studies on the
computational analyses of toxic memes have significantly grown over the past
five years, and the only three surveys on computational toxic meme analysis
cover only work published until 2022, leading to inconsistent terminology and
unexplored trends. Our work fills this gap by surveying content-based
computational perspectives on toxic memes, and reviewing key developments until
early 2024. Employing the PRISMA methodology, we systematically extend the
previously considered papers, achieving a threefold result. First, we survey
119 new papers, analyzing 158 computational works focused on content-based
toxic meme analysis. We identify over 30 datasets used in toxic meme analysis
and examine their labeling systems. Second, after observing the existence of
unclear definitions of meme toxicity in computational works, we introduce a new
taxonomy for categorizing meme toxicity types. We also note an expansion in
computational tasks beyond the simple binary classification of memes as toxic
or non-toxic, indicating a shift towards achieving a nuanced comprehension of
toxicity. Third, we identify three content-based dimensions of meme toxicity
under automatic study: target, intent, and conveyance tactics. We develop a
framework illustrating the relationships between these dimensions and meme
toxicities. The survey analyzes key challenges and recent trends, such as
enhanced cross-modal reasoning, integrating expert and cultural knowledge, the
demand for automatic toxicity explanations, and handling meme toxicity in
low-resource languages. Also, it notes the rising use of Large Language Models
(LLMs) and generative AI for detecting and generating toxic memes. Finally, it
proposes pathways for advancing toxic meme detection and interpretation.
|
[
-0.34107503294944763,
-0.6468875408172607,
0.5622339248657227,
0.24153129756450653,
-0.14840716123580933,
0.23485243320465088,
0.30226534605026245,
-0.6131080985069275,
0.32354116439819336,
0.40829169750213623,
-0.6552081108093262,
-0.25021663308143616,
-0.8685659170150757,
0.2962460517883301,
-0.3610718250274658,
0.8106344938278198,
0.16854478418827057,
-0.2410210520029068,
-0.3432254493236542,
-0.08343595266342163,
-0.42600905895233154,
-0.45812085270881653,
-0.7614594101905823,
0.1286599338054657,
0.9996434450149536,
0.6404811143875122,
0.5398010611534119,
0.25899791717529297,
0.5313203930854797,
0.4010292887687683,
-0.15148165822029114,
-0.23635727167129517,
-0.4421447217464447,
0.17450231313705444,
-0.3264457881450653,
-0.3528384566307068,
-0.376287043094635,
0.39649340510368347,
0.21948519349098206,
0.4954165816307068,
0.2222817838191986,
0.14250198006629944,
-0.11919547617435455,
0.7038893103599548,
-0.9064878821372986,
-0.040212370455265045,
-0.3713427186012268,
0.24897822737693787,
-0.2456611543893814,
-0.4472251832485199,
-0.41914448142051697,
-0.29840996861457825,
0.19075767695903778,
-0.4266430735588074,
-0.43775826692581177,
-0.26247328519821167,
0.1684931516647339,
0.0462237186729908,
-0.9245094656944275,
-0.536608099937439,
-0.7144149541854858,
0.9373286366462708,
-0.6223800778388977,
0.21212613582611084,
-0.074913889169693,
0.3478543758392334,
-0.01457473449409008,
-0.7819666862487793,
-0.45355331897735596,
-0.23355644941329956,
0.2783878743648529,
0.13994240760803223,
-0.30611908435821533,
-0.23861534893512726,
0.01980730891227722,
0.2848951816558838,
-0.7550318241119385,
0.1597554236650467,
-0.6440065503120422,
-0.45157161355018616,
0.5736933946609497,
0.47697800397872925,
0.7989511489868164,
-0.30840614438056946,
-0.39372649788856506,
-0.12767337262630463,
-0.9180768132209778,
-0.1577003002166748,
0.39786240458488464,
-0.3355511724948883,
-0.2063332349061966,
0.44464653730392456,
-0.0036057967226952314,
0.5245857238769531,
-0.4131983816623688,
-0.01946461759507656,
0.07748018205165863,
-0.48393136262893677,
0.20094747841358185,
-0.21538172662258148,
0.9826628565788269,
0.4993484914302826,
0.20429694652557373,
0.037911053746938705,
0.424371600151062,
-0.02741982974112034,
0.4578167796134949,
-0.9286154508590698,
-0.4741804897785187,
0.2041710764169693,
-0.6375060081481934,
-0.6457991003990173,
-0.43047988414764404,
-0.9609605669975281,
-0.6345720887184143,
0.017537930980324745,
-0.07425229996442795,
-0.055177345871925354,
-0.5115568041801453,
-0.12727738916873932,
-0.33524471521377563,
-0.08567950874567032,
0.3500686585903168,
-0.7138539552688599,
-0.10569928586483002,
0.5030458569526672,
0.6508709788322449,
-0.07388762384653091,
-0.08484635502099991,
-0.04469618201255798,
-0.0513058677315712,
-0.37446358799934387,
1.1085100173950195,
-0.7533771991729736,
0.009077159687876701,
-0.15892408788204193,
0.0236845500767231,
0.12782713770866394,
-0.681637704372406,
0.5130815505981445,
-0.480684369802475,
0.28505951166152954,
-0.4966922700405121,
-0.09862034767866135,
-0.5372699499130249,
0.3227131962776184,
-0.6831312775611877,
0.25390368700027466,
0.23623354732990265,
-0.8218507170677185,
0.08971081674098969,
-0.6819359064102173,
-0.0016113066812977195,
0.049532774835824966,
0.16832903027534485,
0.04772747680544853,
-0.043660663068294525,
-0.501548707485199,
0.43206587433815,
-0.25781163573265076,
-0.03546001389622688,
-0.531470775604248,
-0.28178226947784424,
0.3915303349494934,
-0.1479717344045639,
0.9852743148803711,
0.9010943174362183,
-0.0244726724922657,
0.15031278133392334,
-0.2655071020126343,
-0.16669230163097382,
0.10459551215171814,
-0.2787310779094696,
-0.31914639472961426,
0.33329063653945923,
0.12287436425685883,
0.5020785331726074,
0.08471756428480148,
-0.6323074102401733,
-0.22870293259620667,
-0.2009422928094864,
0.7602078914642334,
0.5418599843978882,
0.3486228883266449,
0.43785813450813293,
-0.4604770541191101,
0.5290772914886475,
0.17706555128097534,
0.5756914615631104,
-0.08716713637113571,
-0.7041196823120117,
0.035677094012498856,
0.21977168321609497,
-0.14799615740776062,
0.6215673685073853,
-0.7622933387756348,
0.1368701159954071,
-0.16456115245819092,
-0.6018880009651184,
0.33796077966690063,
-0.21559415757656097,
0.04137613996863365,
0.35957178473472595,
0.3806571662425995,
-0.2593677341938019,
-0.32454144954681396,
-0.7414196729660034,
-0.3866007626056671,
-0.28233063220977783,
-0.1369614154100418,
0.5400258898735046,
0.18379876017570496,
-0.3582606911659241,
0.3170795440673828,
-0.4018200635910034,
-0.11451594531536102,
-0.013614608906209469,
0.43131023645401,
-0.08841796219348907,
0.35519081354141235,
0.8357579112052917,
-0.5255980491638184,
-0.6957036852836609,
-0.22956937551498413,
-0.69728684425354,
-0.5439736843109131,
-0.009226856753230095,
0.0672619566321373,
-0.39982330799102783,
0.6379424929618835,
0.2230064421892166,
-0.1972305029630661,
0.7788174152374268,
-0.3443261682987213,
0.5569255352020264,
0.2621653378009796,
0.49275141954421997,
-0.6187719702720642,
-0.12485566735267639,
0.033645786345005035,
-0.04267503321170807,
-0.6812540292739868,
0.15715733170509338,
-0.13501013815402985,
-0.1920594424009323,
-0.688572347164154,
0.4225328862667084,
-0.4003876745700836,
0.33010172843933105,
-0.3748181462287903,
0.11971211433410645,
-0.037611059844493866,
0.27050164341926575,
-0.3888402581214905,
0.644530177116394,
0.30057355761528015,
-0.3783927261829376,
0.43282419443130493,
-0.002676798962056637,
0.18207383155822754,
0.5994126200675964,
-0.3035237789154053,
0.024096518754959106,
-0.15475408732891083,
0.35064053535461426,
-0.9189698100090027,
-0.013501547276973724,
0.8526826500892639,
-0.585419774055481,
0.1931348592042923,
0.03942915424704552,
-0.48786795139312744,
-0.4844883382320404,
-0.508893609046936,
0.9156520366668701,
0.2382349818944931,
-0.06254832446575165,
0.4142048954963684,
0.778191864490509,
-0.33990952372550964,
-0.44493862986564636,
-0.4557371437549591,
0.47797662019729614,
-0.380827397108078,
-0.801731526851654,
-0.02446923591196537,
-0.412649542093277,
-0.3331403434276581,
-0.0369517058134079,
-0.13592839241027832,
-0.3617362678050995,
0.31719139218330383,
-0.07167060673236847,
-0.31385672092437744,
-0.10445929318666458,
-0.20511522889137268,
0.15658912062644958,
-0.15079520642757416,
0.5259863138198853,
0.22945021092891693,
0.3062486946582794,
-0.18141017854213715,
-0.149131178855896,
-0.09555919468402863,
0.5499445199966431,
0.6654394865036011,
-0.0908321961760521,
0.27929624915122986,
0.2129729986190796,
-0.18944333493709564,
-0.027103208005428314,
-0.30502063035964966,
-0.0573296919465065,
-0.48969510197639465,
0.2021798938512802,
0.05664168670773506,
-0.9158873558044434,
0.6202503442764282,
-0.45099398493766785,
-0.006451410241425037,
0.5737438201904297,
0.38254421949386597,
-0.2890940308570862,
0.9884108304977417,
0.4024503231048584,
-0.04158104956150055,
0.5158861875534058,
-0.20431844890117645,
0.42175933718681335,
-0.5777426958084106,
-0.2140066921710968,
-0.5437672138214111,
-0.43062251806259155,
-0.5690617561340332,
-0.6396340131759644,
0.7701563835144043,
-0.4945606589317322,
-0.29231369495391846,
-0.02380477637052536,
-0.5731996893882751,
0.4518946707248688,
0.1260993927717209,
-0.0196387842297554,
0.10623281449079514,
-0.24408529698848724,
-0.03063424676656723,
-0.252322793006897,
-0.32369422912597656,
-0.36925363540649414,
0.7897437810897827,
0.42860591411590576,
0.6889503002166748,
0.30769723653793335,
0.18963567912578583,
0.6086111068725586,
0.5356180667877197,
-0.5296644568443298,
0.41959241032600403,
-0.34700632095336914,
-1.0140966176986694,
-0.013605660758912563,
-0.3041369616985321,
-0.7674717307090759,
-0.0711943507194519,
-0.3016864061355591,
-0.5503561496734619,
0.05396980792284012,
-0.04282233119010925,
0.11411532014608383,
0.19422335922718048,
-0.5777844190597534,
0.9686144590377808,
-0.2700481414794922,
-0.4836450219154358,
-0.632930338382721,
-0.8600468039512634,
0.5415562987327576,
-0.10953585058450699,
0.3687210977077484,
-0.3957251012325287,
0.06837823241949081,
0.5737684369087219,
-0.21906185150146484,
0.7246412038803101,
-0.19146594405174255,
-0.21800337731838226,
0.8909779191017151,
0.32047250866889954,
-0.011431928724050522,
-0.16840970516204834,
-0.05644947662949562,
0.31610384583473206,
0.3416767716407776,
-0.5003635287284851,
-0.4073280692100525,
0.8189677596092224,
-0.33208873867988586,
-0.09252416342496872,
-0.4824916422367096,
-0.40045174956321716,
-0.05238417908549309,
0.2531243860721588,
0.06643886864185333,
0.13103057444095612,
-0.14511412382125854,
0.19645026326179504,
0.645534873008728,
-0.7083521485328674,
0.11055413633584976,
0.46788620948791504,
0.1108134463429451,
-0.2306463122367859,
1.4014614820480347,
0.10057000815868378,
0.14470387995243073,
0.27792543172836304,
0.5098617076873779,
-0.28406694531440735,
-0.6954261660575867,
-0.3047123849391937,
0.1418234407901764,
-0.7344697117805481,
-0.1696232706308365,
-0.4881274402141571,
-0.21036618947982788,
-0.15748804807662964,
-0.037190329283475876,
-0.29376551508903503,
-0.12254096567630768,
-0.3452453911304474,
0.07847117632627487,
0.08645284920930862,
1.0088996887207031,
-0.20781835913658142,
0.43575549125671387,
-1.022645354270935,
0.024247458204627037,
0.17920437455177307,
0.6038798093795776,
0.15342244505882263,
-0.07560708373785019,
0.12436096370220184,
0.21914325654506683,
-0.7457138299942017,
-1.6953333616256714,
0.20675671100616455,
-0.11415261030197144,
0.5732534527778625,
0.8711346983909607,
0.10727163404226303,
0.1700899600982666,
-0.17939633131027222,
0.8791028261184692,
0.08199333399534225,
-0.5756633281707764,
0.31822964549064636,
-0.7551906704902649,
-0.15052039921283722,
0.41435134410858154,
0.6653876304626465,
-1.0055426359176636,
-0.6829547882080078,
-0.3855617046356201,
-0.4585734009742737,
0.2919677793979645,
0.07563839852809906,
0.5198761820793152,
-0.342401385307312,
0.4508279263973236,
-0.07902675867080688,
-0.060907624661922455,
-0.745434582233429,
-0.3729384243488312,
-0.19300006330013275,
-0.04833897575736046,
0.13259586691856384,
-0.7414548397064209,
0.11141080409288406,
-0.12545743584632874,
0.45012176036834717,
-0.023765482008457184,
0.1257975548505783,
-0.1522943079471588,
-0.21176743507385254,
-0.3177201747894287,
0.0624254047870636,
0.5455508828163147,
0.6538894772529602,
-0.2894585132598877,
0.5345929265022278,
-0.13779272139072418,
-0.6120259761810303,
0.32404983043670654,
-0.42651721835136414,
-0.05547890067100525,
-0.558611273765564,
0.1110386773943901,
-0.12157589197158813,
0.22415952384471893,
-0.9476660490036011,
0.6328302025794983,
-0.031147653236985207,
-0.13477346301078796,
-0.3008100986480713,
0.001118560554459691,
0.2352455109357834,
0.1559656709432602,
0.009498142637312412,
0.05235345661640167,
0.7959901690483093,
-0.5430092811584473,
0.2737739682197571,
0.5881373286247253,
-0.4234936535358429,
-0.6065467596054077,
0.7577717304229736,
0.3996870815753937,
0.3198128342628479,
0.4266449511051178,
-0.2035079449415207,
-0.3990340530872345,
0.8078673481941223,
0.262494832277298,
0.5733311176300049,
-0.2768409252166748,
0.43541112542152405,
0.5253557562828064,
0.4715630114078522,
0.6087415814399719,
0.2656543552875519,
0.2252228707075119,
-0.41653531789779663,
-0.2698049247264862,
-0.4332166314125061,
-0.3887276351451874,
0.4830479025840759,
0.09781232476234436,
0.19551491737365723,
-0.5421969890594482,
0.14209973812103271,
0.34551945328712463,
0.03470027819275856,
-0.0694287046790123,
0.10211069136857986,
0.38738512992858887,
0.7956041097640991,
-1.308752179145813,
-0.09866355359554291,
0.6366521120071411,
-0.4796426594257355,
-0.37539902329444885,
-0.16518226265907288,
0.422444224357605,
-0.3533066511154175,
-0.005394397769123316,
0.125234454870224,
0.022933505475521088,
-0.09749703109264374,
-0.9493221640586853,
-0.879279613494873,
0.7040868997573853,
0.13620461523532867,
0.1865566223859787,
0.27441084384918213,
0.1583060771226883,
0.7709496021270752,
-0.05912886932492256,
0.55534827709198,
0.2731514573097229,
0.40608328580856323,
0.4950610399246216,
-0.33723175525665283,
0.12862081825733185,
-0.6643789410591125,
-0.3201012909412384,
-0.0772203728556633,
-0.5394278764724731,
0.7901106476783752,
-0.09211913496255875,
-0.29070615768432617,
-0.17532514035701752,
0.4881940484046936,
-0.05371486023068428,
0.7045191526412964,
0.5204460620880127,
0.24152827262878418,
0.19812875986099243,
0.28623706102371216,
0.8112083077430725,
-0.0517590269446373,
0.029708199203014374,
0.7005928754806519,
0.1451919823884964,
0.4853423535823822,
0.19181689620018005,
-0.26136213541030884,
0.8831796646118164,
1.1346395015716553,
-0.13600598275661469,
0.3245203495025635,
0.5093476176261902,
-0.36119750142097473,
-0.0677081048488617,
-0.29698431491851807,
-0.3530411720275879,
0.49131709337234497,
0.6029052138328552,
-0.2523457407951355,
-0.6819279193878174,
-0.035593464970588684,
0.2102825939655304,
-0.0020814323797822,
-0.1617368757724762,
0.8981127142906189,
0.0027518426068127155,
-0.5393980741500854,
0.5271934270858765,
0.16046585142612457,
0.32427823543548584,
-0.21033206582069397,
-0.28435829281806946,
-0.11411114037036896,
-0.09103554487228394,
-0.21169425547122955,
-0.9823440909385681,
0.793673574924469,
-0.2126471847295761,
0.04788636788725853,
-0.3383801579475403,
1.0373036861419678,
0.008054152131080627,
-0.08472006022930145,
0.4343545734882355,
0.7884471416473389,
0.5412956476211548,
-0.49888846278190613,
-0.82248455286026,
-0.1554260104894638,
-0.23941664397716522,
0.10385850071907043,
0.3993762731552124,
0.4294799566268921,
-0.41919925808906555,
0.7165138125419617,
0.5294765830039978,
-0.19553762674331665,
0.4589157998561859,
-0.0138693330809474,
0.9565735459327698,
-0.4206971228122711,
-0.2376287579536438,
-0.5741647481918335,
0.44732236862182617,
0.060857582837343216,
0.15226159989833832,
0.3701540231704712,
0.38951265811920166,
0.41663414239883423,
-0.06745897233486176,
0.7276644110679626,
-0.25012463331222534,
0.3991301953792572,
0.09917538613080978,
0.881121814250946,
-0.7387551069259644,
0.15542790293693542,
-0.25706207752227783,
-0.7331681847572327,
-0.24128517508506775,
0.26241469383239746,
-0.1905163824558258,
0.07431886345148087,
0.5665996074676514,
0.34190353751182556,
-0.09198781102895737,
0.1272643357515335,
-0.09330431371927261,
0.48287302255630493,
0.5895187258720398,
0.5459533333778381,
1.2684035301208496,
-0.0854853019118309,
0.5274554491043091,
-0.5780558586120605,
-0.5472224354743958,
-0.34984293580055237,
-1.1020692586898804,
-0.5209067463874817,
-0.665892481803894,
-0.1946297287940979,
-0.1828715056180954,
-0.3096242845058441,
0.23518012464046478,
0.36427462100982666,
-0.7246487140655518,
-0.042193587869405746,
0.02666456252336502,
0.6045787334442139,
-0.04194183275103569,
-0.26141223311424255,
-0.275979220867157,
-0.2174496352672577,
-0.4939654469490051,
0.16700170934200287,
0.4482673108577728,
-0.10965482145547867,
-0.24091051518917084,
0.2091096043586731,
-0.28280460834503174,
0.30662015080451965,
0.934014618396759,
0.4228467345237732,
-0.32435905933380127,
-0.3230738937854767,
0.15691854059696198,
-0.1846698671579361,
-0.15230655670166016,
0.7370745539665222,
-0.32226407527923584,
0.6168966293334961,
0.9838473200798035,
0.1459432989358902,
0.09002873301506042,
0.02290264703333378,
0.24835872650146484,
-0.2870227098464966,
-0.21284154057502747,
0.46624255180358887,
-0.0023818151094019413,
0.2096455693244934,
-0.6107284426689148,
0.5070464015007019,
0.2621716558933258,
-0.49393415451049805,
-0.5503155589103699,
0.1495347023010254,
-1.1690884828567505,
-0.5750717520713806,
0.9131788015365601,
0.1478746086359024,
-0.18686138093471527,
-0.39756208658218384,
-0.07202991098165512,
0.08762896806001663,
0.0125546520575881,
0.9463575482368469,
0.6662527322769165,
-0.33060330152511597,
-0.16381403803825378,
-0.8140356540679932,
0.49313655495643616,
0.08669032156467438,
-1.0746673345565796,
0.08038120716810226,
0.7962191700935364,
0.550449550151825,
0.38266614079475403,
0.8854314684867859,
-0.3651958703994751,
0.4552510678768158,
-0.29396846890449524,
-0.13961096107959747,
0.28176504373550415,
-0.5705736875534058,
0.035548899322748184,
0.10085354000329971,
-0.06960491091012955,
0.07290567457675934
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07348v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07348v3
|
DR-RAG: Applying Dynamic Document Relevance to Retrieval-Augmented Generation for Question-Answering
| 2024-06-11T15:15:33 | 2024-06-16T04:33:17 |
Zijian Hei, Weiling Liu, Wenjie Ou, Juyi Qiao, Junming Jiao, Guowen Song, Ting Tian, Yi Lin
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) has recently demonstrated the
performance of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the knowledge-intensive tasks
such as Question-Answering (QA). RAG expands the query context by incorporating
external knowledge bases to enhance the response accuracy. However, it would be
inefficient to access LLMs multiple times for each query and unreliable to
retrieve all the relevant documents by a single query. We have found that even
though there is low relevance between some critical documents and query, it is
possible to retrieve the remaining documents by combining parts of the
documents with the query. To mine the relevance, a two-stage retrieval
framework called Dynamic-Relevant Retrieval-Augmented Generation (DR-RAG) is
proposed to improve document retrieval recall and the accuracy of answers while
maintaining efficiency. Additionally, a compact classifier is applied to two
different selection strategies to determine the contribution of the retrieved
documents to answering the query and retrieve the relatively relevant
documents. Meanwhile, DR-RAG call the LLMs only once, which significantly
improves the efficiency of the experiment. The experimental results on
multi-hop QA datasets show that DR-RAG can significantly improve the accuracy
of the answers and achieve new progress in QA systems.
|
[
-0.2632692754268646,
-0.9558059573173523,
0.7315715551376343,
-0.17567326128482819,
-0.15827830135822296,
0.6351765990257263,
0.15044067800045013,
-0.3897726237773895,
0.3619484007358551,
0.45423072576522827,
-0.30618250370025635,
-0.08909301459789276,
-0.4133531153202057,
0.06651504337787628,
-0.5232799053192139,
0.6650875806808472,
-0.06350051611661911,
-0.1268005073070526,
-0.5366942882537842,
-0.2385258823633194,
-0.5443671941757202,
-0.22739507257938385,
-0.7621099352836609,
-0.18546293675899506,
0.7053744196891785,
0.28453195095062256,
0.5066416263580322,
0.564903974533081,
0.6985588073730469,
0.2816808819770813,
-0.35056304931640625,
0.5946267247200012,
-0.5258222818374634,
0.8393653035163879,
-0.2382364720106125,
-0.7092580795288086,
-0.5976637005805969,
-0.04944935068488121,
0.7713949084281921,
0.29385000467300415,
-0.24061621725559235,
0.3507528603076935,
-0.14607970416545868,
0.7201074957847595,
-0.49037808179855347,
-0.15150776505470276,
-0.7232001423835754,
-0.24331757426261902,
-0.16816945374011993,
-0.6088094711303711,
-0.26603153347969055,
-0.3701934516429901,
-0.05585293099284172,
-0.708020031452179,
0.29866716265678406,
0.011011985130608082,
0.8083164691925049,
0.44069263339042664,
-0.5276211500167847,
-0.5449748039245605,
-0.8214197158813477,
0.6157170534133911,
-0.5877262353897095,
0.2933907210826874,
0.277750164270401,
0.5636013746261597,
-0.3301149904727936,
-1.0798593759536743,
-0.7798052430152893,
-0.080580934882164,
-0.05400669947266579,
0.23821592330932617,
0.456031858921051,
-0.07603363692760468,
0.4044142961502075,
0.533989667892456,
-0.3898876905441284,
-0.17601454257965088,
-0.21900711953639984,
0.0320066399872303,
0.4732104539871216,
0.15945249795913696,
0.17457905411720276,
-0.2535925805568695,
-0.20867392420768738,
-0.2813695967197418,
-0.44138941168785095,
0.09781752526760101,
0.21739935874938965,
0.15135063230991364,
0.3180856704711914,
0.5570865273475647,
-0.09688246995210648,
0.7754867672920227,
0.38679638504981995,
-0.72547847032547,
0.2954539656639099,
-0.2514439523220062,
0.08790268003940582,
-0.37565937638282776,
0.32641300559043884,
-0.05204744264483452,
-0.15957051515579224,
-0.1118963211774826,
-0.3032726049423218,
-0.2984257638454437,
0.5495337247848511,
-0.8162249326705933,
0.1778380423784256,
0.3110310733318329,
-0.38882535696029663,
-0.5094459652900696,
-0.05297860875725746,
-0.9875211715698242,
-0.5506317615509033,
-0.16193249821662903,
0.4333551526069641,
-0.11200075596570969,
-0.41908925771713257,
-0.25748568773269653,
-0.35555753111839294,
0.2522600591182709,
0.42221224308013916,
-0.39124250411987305,
0.11373841762542725,
0.6918637752532959,
0.46241477131843567,
-0.14821302890777588,
-0.08824115246534348,
-0.8921086192131042,
0.2178218513727188,
-0.44897952675819397,
0.8678059577941895,
-0.7448492646217346,
-0.2877582311630249,
-0.038568638265132904,
-0.26014479994773865,
-0.157953143119812,
-0.6978437304496765,
0.6918054819107056,
-1.2527306079864502,
0.41946572065353394,
-0.2255786508321762,
-0.5033743381500244,
-0.06562987715005875,
0.5086719989776611,
-0.6728437542915344,
1.2538526058197021,
0.47328948974609375,
-0.836428165435791,
0.2500532567501068,
-0.39896920323371887,
-0.4243448078632355,
0.08988773822784424,
-0.42950788140296936,
-0.34516966342926025,
0.029535887762904167,
-0.03204074874520302,
0.06185207515954971,
-0.5869696140289307,
0.30078399181365967,
-0.005329107400029898,
-0.3497048020362854,
0.2543635666370392,
-0.2764650881290436,
0.2507639527320862,
0.3847983479499817,
-0.13353243470191956,
-0.16879911720752716,
-0.8977525234222412,
0.1289837807416916,
0.2798672914505005,
-0.827190637588501,
-0.4217705726623535,
-0.031081365421414375,
-0.32557082176208496,
0.31597214937210083,
0.3169367015361786,
-0.4711788296699524,
0.10996983200311661,
-0.39917102456092834,
-0.11050303280353546,
0.4255687892436981,
0.2529037296772003,
0.5219046473503113,
-0.6044521331787109,
0.9393474459648132,
-0.18595069646835327,
-0.22239932417869568,
-0.28101781010627747,
-0.4321921765804291,
-0.5981011390686035,
-0.2645235061645508,
0.5748981237411499,
0.6494140028953552,
-1.005611538887024,
0.031660474836826324,
-0.10414436459541321,
-0.3840107023715973,
-0.5729010105133057,
-0.032772429287433624,
0.40530925989151,
0.9391717314720154,
0.2528999149799347,
-0.17331135272979736,
-0.40520209074020386,
-0.4592709243297577,
-0.2730271816253662,
-0.2946617007255554,
0.014382177032530308,
0.8122289180755615,
0.07150322198867798,
-0.15889519453048706,
0.9088459610939026,
-0.576454758644104,
-0.04875247925519943,
-0.0928712785243988,
0.18645793199539185,
0.33528175950050354,
0.04950806871056557,
0.5566005706787109,
-1.2940402030944824,
-0.6153523325920105,
-0.17251262068748474,
-0.7104471325874329,
-0.20428305864334106,
-0.034316252917051315,
-0.13350729644298553,
0.18756820261478424,
0.41941291093826294,
-0.4995723068714142,
0.1986844837665558,
0.37202438712120056,
-0.1710231751203537,
0.49901023507118225,
-0.4130427837371826,
0.602946400642395,
-1.3443896770477295,
0.21576130390167236,
-0.5667456388473511,
-0.23824475705623627,
-0.5262934565544128,
0.3565073311328888,
0.18953777849674225,
-0.2247614711523056,
-0.13672159612178802,
0.8118049502372742,
-0.5214948654174805,
-0.03169684112071991,
-0.6325094699859619,
0.5197398662567139,
0.28607580065727234,
0.0852898508310318,
-0.3087255358695984,
1.1060409545898438,
0.16086755692958832,
-0.60830157995224,
0.3564884066581726,
0.2980775833129883,
-0.07155513018369675,
0.4335748553276062,
-0.40220171213150024,
0.24691227078437805,
-0.33666712045669556,
0.25018683075904846,
-0.9700126647949219,
-0.27253231406211853,
-0.09593968838453293,
-0.5364614129066467,
0.8392089605331421,
-0.14344754815101624,
-0.611478328704834,
-0.523369312286377,
-0.2160140722990036,
0.40712815523147583,
0.5054165124893188,
-0.4050689935684204,
0.8935843706130981,
0.6376821398735046,
-0.2696998715400696,
-0.7598777413368225,
-0.23154738545417786,
-0.05909079685807228,
-0.1460498571395874,
-0.5738362669944763,
0.31071433424949646,
-0.14991070330142975,
-0.13080576062202454,
0.021882662549614906,
-0.3643854558467865,
-0.1505548506975174,
0.20859335362911224,
-0.059163667261600494,
0.08754492551088333,
-0.026987431570887566,
0.3720604181289673,
0.24374070763587952,
-0.058995556086301804,
-0.19668252766132355,
0.01876968890428543,
0.583921492099762,
0.36421269178390503,
-0.2597159743309021,
0.15617235004901886,
0.5082702040672302,
0.6883400082588196,
-0.6059342622756958,
0.6724277138710022,
0.6220329403877258,
-0.19767005741596222,
-0.20367656648159027,
-0.7028852701187134,
-0.25667959451675415,
-0.4505518078804016,
0.292616605758667,
-0.7367731928825378,
-0.8915749788284302,
0.5383720397949219,
-0.3325966000556946,
0.09460888057947159,
0.5169962644577026,
0.4693446755409241,
-0.27184954285621643,
0.8402818441390991,
0.5323654413223267,
0.236925408244133,
0.436968594789505,
-0.16400469839572906,
0.2642941474914551,
-1.0424365997314453,
-0.24892184138298035,
-0.7134491205215454,
-0.1981264352798462,
-0.7516476511955261,
-0.7374063730239868,
0.5813541412353516,
0.23279346525669098,
0.09922818839550018,
0.039633944630622864,
-0.5106239318847656,
0.10550814867019653,
0.48842093348503113,
-0.044372934848070145,
0.29813551902770996,
-0.03989393264055252,
-0.3328429162502289,
0.19109363853931427,
-0.8351079225540161,
-0.4442828297615051,
1.0496461391448975,
0.21198241412639618,
0.8167442083358765,
0.1684395670890808,
0.6916317939758301,
0.21928897500038147,
0.09929638355970383,
-0.4960455596446991,
0.5937433838844299,
-0.13818639516830444,
-0.7843613624572754,
-0.23815789818763733,
-0.6094768047332764,
-0.9934945702552795,
0.34215012192726135,
-0.3425808846950531,
-0.1459169089794159,
0.20056217908859253,
0.046441007405519485,
-0.35911011695861816,
0.21181178092956543,
-0.43658018112182617,
0.3785513639450073,
-0.19006891548633575,
-0.3897416293621063,
-0.38851264119148254,
-0.6652297973632812,
0.18736080825328827,
-0.47830474376678467,
0.23986203968524933,
-0.043554749339818954,
-0.15096095204353333,
0.7499454617500305,
-0.09157629311084747,
0.34912562370300293,
-0.18223287165164948,
-0.1547035425901413,
0.4143540859222412,
0.06545960903167725,
0.7417706847190857,
0.15457314252853394,
-0.3541094660758972,
-0.5612848401069641,
0.16220521926879883,
-0.22435952723026276,
-0.7016472816467285,
0.7317613363265991,
-0.46049076318740845,
-0.8202417492866516,
-0.6274336576461792,
-0.8867314457893372,
-0.3605729639530182,
0.48320093750953674,
-0.20924854278564453,
0.6508002281188965,
0.035560786724090576,
0.14336100220680237,
0.9543184041976929,
-0.40197551250457764,
-0.000009899748874886427,
0.7600110173225403,
-0.31712472438812256,
-0.4267555773258209,
0.6630417704582214,
0.17795971035957336,
0.20295016467571259,
0.6793906092643738,
0.1971428245306015,
-0.2952287793159485,
-0.5721977949142456,
-0.5107898116111755,
0.4875430464744568,
-0.5582892298698425,
-0.3330739438533783,
-0.9500956535339355,
-0.192051500082016,
-0.635438084602356,
0.13179443776607513,
-0.11760954558849335,
-0.6070519089698792,
-0.2396075278520584,
0.14741447567939758,
0.2874692976474762,
0.6665794253349304,
0.10589122772216797,
-0.13242748379707336,
-1.05128014087677,
0.9031203389167786,
0.4550396502017975,
0.37938758730888367,
-0.09955286979675293,
-0.7642428278923035,
-0.17625164985656738,
-0.031837139278650284,
-0.3030302822589874,
-0.919721782207489,
0.17952251434326172,
0.19593816995620728,
0.8251928091049194,
-0.006306365132331848,
0.3091369867324829,
0.5022032856941223,
-0.6225765347480774,
0.47637805342674255,
-0.28865405917167664,
-0.1761924922466278,
0.634288489818573,
-0.4864581227302551,
0.24772781133651733,
0.61025071144104,
0.27729758620262146,
-0.3510853052139282,
-0.6197726130485535,
-0.6818583011627197,
-1.0407294034957886,
0.5955883860588074,
0.0073417783714830875,
0.04877888411283493,
-0.008333648554980755,
0.7860192060470581,
-0.0885213315486908,
0.46478959918022156,
0.07322762906551361,
-0.36398378014564514,
0.2840988337993622,
-0.18226927518844604,
0.22790463268756866,
-0.7758930325508118,
-0.21598245203495026,
0.08475178480148315,
0.724945068359375,
-0.10845186561346054,
0.3630761206150055,
0.250786691904068,
-0.00821605883538723,
-0.29612886905670166,
0.3102639317512512,
0.48714205622673035,
0.895575761795044,
-0.4481980800628662,
-0.06910094618797302,
0.1466239094734192,
-0.666360080242157,
0.19564871490001678,
0.45337527990341187,
-0.35118499398231506,
0.03764951229095459,
0.1469305008649826,
0.45778772234916687,
-0.1288304179906845,
-0.7128391861915588,
0.3011556565761566,
-0.25269272923469543,
0.05557871609926224,
-0.3521829843521118,
0.18673847615718842,
-0.029215214774012566,
0.44704920053482056,
0.7005073428153992,
-0.0878739133477211,
0.1415213793516159,
-0.657745897769928,
0.4738417863845825,
0.3813486695289612,
0.022885605692863464,
0.15892238914966583,
0.7822319269180298,
0.22523994743824005,
-0.4175738990306854,
0.36390647292137146,
-0.28639277815818787,
-0.5806080102920532,
0.6776599884033203,
0.483778715133667,
0.6128644943237305,
-0.2560911178588867,
0.12333317846059799,
0.4451887607574463,
-0.02926962450146675,
0.003924873657524586,
0.41830918192863464,
-0.04283023625612259,
-0.47743573784828186,
-0.5157753229141235,
-0.9299240708351135,
-0.5058274865150452,
-0.09969957172870636,
-0.6060518026351929,
0.06384750455617905,
0.035420142114162445,
-0.20780013501644135,
-0.22561848163604736,
0.3826899230480194,
-0.3864098787307739,
0.3936486542224884,
-0.2036399245262146,
0.9944902062416077,
-0.3296709358692169,
0.8224590420722961,
0.9534615278244019,
-0.38006484508514404,
-0.9609335660934448,
0.25498825311660767,
-0.29608821868896484,
-0.45974111557006836,
0.45312488079071045,
-0.15032866597175598,
-0.13206467032432556,
0.06226588413119316,
0.08734456449747086,
-1.0833938121795654,
1.3999391794204712,
0.15751995146274567,
-0.3880529999732971,
-0.14993466436862946,
-0.1008162647485733,
0.6731300354003906,
-0.2313893735408783,
0.37711769342422485,
0.3456134796142578,
0.36791592836380005,
0.3789496123790741,
-0.9921996593475342,
-0.09163758158683777,
-0.23880964517593384,
-0.08983226120471954,
0.4061550199985504,
-0.6803237199783325,
0.6813023090362549,
-0.1746625304222107,
-0.23096711933612823,
0.1777716726064682,
0.6647728085517883,
0.54305100440979,
0.5557978749275208,
0.5596498250961304,
0.6384769678115845,
1.0226516723632812,
-0.04230184480547905,
1.1762326955795288,
-0.3964058458805084,
0.18773910403251648,
1.2257014513015747,
-0.2726307809352875,
0.8171984553337097,
0.2940894663333893,
-0.06347721815109253,
0.48319077491760254,
0.3140568733215332,
0.40696990489959717,
0.5560828447341919,
0.03691757097840309,
-0.40591058135032654,
-0.014456499367952347,
-0.16896891593933105,
-0.446358859539032,
0.3497683107852936,
0.2552666962146759,
-0.28418493270874023,
-0.2326699197292328,
0.0036089459899812937,
-0.03433407470583916,
0.31784141063690186,
-0.0643138587474823,
0.9477785229682922,
0.017516832798719406,
-0.83014976978302,
0.6052398085594177,
-0.04291892051696777,
0.42082270979881287,
-0.5714887380599976,
-0.21353404223918915,
-0.42864277958869934,
0.15053381025791168,
-0.025546256452798843,
-0.7391070127487183,
0.29463276267051697,
0.12071170657873154,
-0.5689237117767334,
-0.2483251988887787,
1.1709750890731812,
-0.4890590012073517,
-0.3199610114097595,
0.19710902869701385,
0.6906070709228516,
0.045852214097976685,
0.07545537501573563,
-0.6987715363502502,
-0.16942404210567474,
-0.13230840861797333,
-0.38950398564338684,
0.495554119348526,
0.64537513256073,
0.09911399334669113,
0.6694286465644836,
0.6107156872749329,
0.188240647315979,
0.1356019228696823,
0.06419932842254639,
1.0831564664840698,
-0.5013537406921387,
-0.3489796221256256,
-0.08089201152324677,
0.3926355540752411,
-0.2107330858707428,
0.13360700011253357,
0.6834281086921692,
0.6194300651550293,
0.46276140213012695,
0.24560756981372833,
0.6358610987663269,
-0.4102061092853546,
1.3505736589431763,
-0.2808619439601898,
0.69575035572052,
-0.9544761180877686,
0.4049179255962372,
-0.07573302090167999,
-0.8028199672698975,
-0.07798907905817032,
0.2800121009349823,
-0.11693185567855835,
0.16210472583770752,
0.7447423338890076,
0.8614549040794373,
0.09022141993045807,
-0.5167443156242371,
0.34824132919311523,
0.20297931134700775,
0.5112353563308716,
0.0667092353105545,
0.6244038939476013,
-0.5509382486343384,
0.741058886051178,
-0.1371898651123047,
-0.27728328108787537,
-0.15397843718528748,
-0.6606765389442444,
-0.5680322051048279,
-0.6677325367927551,
-0.08430736511945724,
-0.5653672814369202,
0.1598103642463684,
0.48316967487335205,
0.33955618739128113,
-0.5915796756744385,
0.09882276505231857,
0.2439897060394287,
0.2096392959356308,
-0.11423967033624649,
-0.25842195749282837,
0.38516533374786377,
-0.7198276519775391,
-0.7437962889671326,
0.6604381203651428,
0.20096071064472198,
-0.20638608932495117,
-0.05884750559926033,
0.1161024197936058,
-0.5451966524124146,
0.2938334047794342,
0.5948270559310913,
0.20373521745204926,
-0.3137279152870178,
-0.10598091036081314,
0.2723056375980377,
-0.2611818313598633,
0.0750829204916954,
0.7968602180480957,
-0.9418372511863708,
0.6292994022369385,
0.9913310408592224,
1.0176790952682495,
0.6199726462364197,
0.32404205203056335,
0.4248834252357483,
-0.5961269736289978,
-0.04287238419055939,
0.4745957553386688,
0.009175451472401619,
0.22484663128852844,
-0.3920044004917145,
0.5999754071235657,
0.1806594431400299,
-0.9147275686264038,
-0.9008982181549072,
0.33330345153808594,
-0.9126916527748108,
-0.24521388113498688,
1.2917437553405762,
-0.05729246512055397,
-0.1426946520805359,
-0.18488407135009766,
-0.2785019278526306,
0.45701730251312256,
-0.3477994501590729,
0.7966569066047668,
0.27760010957717896,
-0.015703991055488586,
-0.1946248561143875,
-0.8246371150016785,
0.4620436728000641,
0.3382423520088196,
-0.8261386156082153,
-0.1779293417930603,
0.4714420735836029,
0.22583231329917908,
0.39299631118774414,
0.746998131275177,
-0.30998823046684265,
0.338510662317276,
-0.08406049758195877,
-0.29009073972702026,
-0.05273189768195152,
-0.3372487425804138,
-0.06553886085748672,
0.42883607745170593,
0.5047674775123596,
-0.12053374946117401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07330v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07330v1
|
CTC-based Non-autoregressive Textless Speech-to-Speech Translation
| 2024-06-11T15:00:33 | 2024-06-11T15:00:33 |
Qingkai Fang, Zhengrui Ma, Yan Zhou, Min Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7
|
Direct speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) has achieved impressive
translation quality, but it often faces the challenge of slow decoding due to
the considerable length of speech sequences. Recently, some research has turned
to non-autoregressive (NAR) models to expedite decoding, yet the translation
quality typically lags behind autoregressive (AR) models significantly. In this
paper, we investigate the performance of CTC-based NAR models in S2ST, as these
models have shown impressive results in machine translation. Experimental
results demonstrate that by combining pretraining, knowledge distillation, and
advanced NAR training techniques such as glancing training and non-monotonic
latent alignments, CTC-based NAR models achieve translation quality comparable
to the AR model, while preserving up to 26.81$\times$ decoding speedup.
|
[
0.042788758873939514,
-0.6799678802490234,
0.34660011529922485,
0.09515099972486496,
-0.7021864056587219,
0.3278547525405884,
-0.32195019721984863,
-0.3550615608692169,
-0.045761916786432266,
0.3365061283111572,
-0.250297874212265,
-0.3683612644672394,
-1.029639720916748,
0.36549878120422363,
-0.697414219379425,
0.8826080560684204,
0.09169290959835052,
0.07089457660913467,
0.1393297165632248,
-0.08487892895936966,
-0.4502835273742676,
-0.6158384084701538,
-0.7388485074043274,
-0.16699419915676117,
0.028063734993338585,
0.12498419731855392,
0.6892761588096619,
0.9400242567062378,
0.36566150188446045,
0.15719275176525116,
-0.3912351131439209,
0.13136574625968933,
-0.4449511766433716,
0.2022983580827713,
-0.011037260293960571,
-0.3764364421367645,
-0.36232200264930725,
-0.03782731667160988,
0.5340790152549744,
0.20843267440795898,
-0.23309072852134705,
-0.28219273686408997,
0.23387008905410767,
0.6408852934837341,
-0.3638175129890442,
0.15763694047927856,
-0.5457083582878113,
-0.16662120819091797,
0.010775655508041382,
-0.21130937337875366,
-0.5400688052177429,
-0.6470901966094971,
0.1342494636774063,
-0.23259684443473816,
0.3118565082550049,
-0.3047020733356476,
0.5850063562393188,
0.7637901902198792,
-0.8184201121330261,
-0.39905908703804016,
-0.8125780820846558,
0.6977798938751221,
-0.8138912320137024,
0.6097853183746338,
0.546515166759491,
0.20095610618591309,
-0.04434039816260338,
-0.516174852848053,
-0.39893415570259094,
-0.2417726069688797,
0.05205480381846428,
0.3203355669975281,
-0.24599307775497437,
-0.055331531912088394,
-0.047808144241571426,
0.3454982340335846,
-0.787478506565094,
0.11887148022651672,
0.02691388502717018,
-0.027927212417125702,
0.45253756642341614,
0.1534915417432785,
-0.17505639791488647,
-0.0887986570596695,
-0.4758501350879669,
-0.15277588367462158,
-0.22047290205955505,
0.020115310326218605,
-0.08251586556434631,
0.3467867374420166,
-0.4470512866973877,
0.38684511184692383,
-0.30625832080841064,
0.7086037397384644,
0.3902844488620758,
-0.13554109632968903,
0.196485698223114,
-0.595201313495636,
0.07182756066322327,
0.14715348184108734,
0.67179936170578,
-0.023248428478837013,
0.03934367373585701,
-0.4688865840435028,
-0.34929049015045166,
0.10015709698200226,
-0.123189277946949,
-0.5860488414764404,
-0.3782542943954468,
-0.045027684420347214,
-0.48464667797088623,
-0.31866469979286194,
-0.4111114740371704,
-0.48082733154296875,
-0.0010063196532428265,
-0.3440629541873932,
0.3437173664569855,
-0.38137030601501465,
-0.5863521695137024,
-0.11444408446550369,
0.2179078310728073,
0.22688360512256622,
0.3997650146484375,
-0.5565800666809082,
0.2460532784461975,
0.13238081336021423,
1.304874062538147,
-0.4988427460193634,
0.25133979320526123,
-0.5003103017807007,
-0.27450326085090637,
-0.49677208065986633,
0.8866310119628906,
-0.07636146247386932,
-0.6340799331665039,
-0.31385618448257446,
-0.3185584247112274,
-0.24092288315296173,
-0.31457003951072693,
0.2123895138502121,
-0.6605247259140015,
-0.2318163514137268,
-0.016738656908273697,
-0.4978090524673462,
0.08855752646923065,
-0.027841219678521156,
-0.5369519591331482,
0.8951320648193359,
-0.03257976844906807,
-0.662203311920166,
-0.0933421403169632,
-0.605522096157074,
-0.7318082451820374,
-0.17739161849021912,
0.20346787571907043,
-0.23010849952697754,
0.2146049439907074,
0.10395040363073349,
0.18743805587291718,
-0.3388235569000244,
0.3485618829727173,
0.21007974445819855,
-0.20169036090373993,
0.26070505380630493,
-0.6907986998558044,
0.636701226234436,
0.6996613144874573,
-0.47643741965293884,
-0.11960739642381668,
-0.6583160758018494,
0.2603072226047516,
0.20257914066314697,
-0.352522611618042,
-0.08121472597122192,
-0.17183075845241547,
0.04058654606342316,
0.6327106952667236,
0.2710218131542206,
-0.06946701556444168,
0.06197682395577431,
-0.4837794899940491,
0.7268049120903015,
0.3021554946899414,
-0.025166116654872894,
0.51239013671875,
-0.03975045308470726,
0.3698957860469818,
0.2141074538230896,
-0.09301209449768066,
0.09685197472572327,
-0.2823868691921234,
-0.9785135388374329,
-0.0657375305891037,
0.6020694375038147,
0.6843038201332092,
-1.2649472951889038,
0.2617543935775757,
-0.36811602115631104,
-0.694037914276123,
-0.24840332567691803,
-0.32541435956954956,
0.6694032549858093,
0.5918554067611694,
0.6854620575904846,
-0.3739274740219116,
-0.14697064459323883,
-0.7157009243965149,
-0.33663278818130493,
-0.14128345251083374,
0.15448108315467834,
-0.05741558596491814,
0.427796870470047,
0.1532600075006485,
0.7045823931694031,
-0.09464211016893387,
-0.1471167951822281,
-0.46407073736190796,
0.43625062704086304,
0.04354647919535637,
0.4321853220462799,
0.07651308178901672,
-0.537466287612915,
-0.44596776366233826,
-0.2535569369792938,
-0.4571775197982788,
-0.11303985863924026,
-0.0376933291554451,
0.07412089407444,
0.7109783291816711,
0.5565796494483948,
-0.20900486409664154,
0.9018428921699524,
0.8219322562217712,
-0.1940639466047287,
0.3802017569541931,
-0.31801220774650574,
0.2745662331581116,
-1.118141770362854,
0.3791833221912384,
-0.14187173545360565,
-0.48648953437805176,
-0.8406357169151306,
-0.4164554178714752,
0.22737345099449158,
-0.01507630106061697,
-0.7447286248207092,
0.30005109310150146,
-0.6057850122451782,
-0.05065474659204483,
-0.6786763072013855,
0.18320991098880768,
-0.08817131817340851,
0.35747143626213074,
0.5336260795593262,
1.1732603311538696,
0.18309374153614044,
-1.022297978401184,
-0.1477869600057602,
0.5736021399497986,
-0.2830643355846405,
0.262531042098999,
-0.6143901944160461,
0.45424872636795044,
0.1179257184267044,
0.4252936840057373,
-0.8099186420440674,
0.30020812153816223,
0.007681967690587044,
-0.713440477848053,
0.25938764214515686,
-0.24438945949077606,
-0.7494152188301086,
-0.021472478285431862,
0.3857007324695587,
0.5075416564941406,
0.5971093773841858,
-0.4145641624927521,
0.37151360511779785,
0.05777927488088608,
-0.09130671620368958,
-0.34654122591018677,
-0.976986289024353,
0.30316445231437683,
0.13200455904006958,
-0.3583970367908478,
0.33107098937034607,
-0.00581770995631814,
0.12141021341085434,
-0.17743739485740662,
-0.1024756133556366,
-0.3204279839992523,
-0.04680268093943596,
-0.06769035011529922,
0.024782255291938782,
-0.08700352907180786,
0.11406876146793365,
0.048327263444662094,
-0.43064582347869873,
-0.4569236934185028,
-0.39792534708976746,
0.5392207503318787,
-0.08693760633468628,
-0.03902759030461311,
-0.8200706243515015,
0.4083371162414551,
0.4657107889652252,
-0.3869066536426544,
0.6166345477104187,
0.13208706676959991,
-0.0751279890537262,
0.1565719097852707,
-0.7200338244438171,
-0.39276668429374695,
-0.3838253617286682,
0.43978965282440186,
-0.2836451232433319,
-0.7332148551940918,
0.27792981266975403,
-0.027951134368777275,
-0.2385333776473999,
0.3876945674419403,
0.5007060170173645,
0.18048901855945587,
0.947252631187439,
0.5187594294548035,
0.04656023159623146,
0.4652571380138397,
-0.2485387772321701,
0.135415181517601,
-0.6304608583450317,
-0.20615200698375702,
-0.5687390565872192,
-0.12875382602214813,
-0.4771675169467926,
-0.6017984747886658,
0.31105002760887146,
0.027938274666666985,
-0.07374576479196548,
0.7826943397521973,
-0.5182426571846008,
0.12046360969543457,
0.5440831780433655,
-0.04930485039949417,
0.5591841340065002,
0.04685840383172035,
-0.11338949203491211,
-0.03608793765306473,
-0.9498181939125061,
-0.3949749171733856,
0.9091430306434631,
0.07159065455198288,
0.6061398983001709,
0.08478584885597229,
0.3795311152935028,
0.32713979482650757,
-0.17393769323825836,
-0.5351051092147827,
0.34233319759368896,
-0.65708988904953,
-0.45061737298965454,
-0.028241097927093506,
-0.6174346208572388,
-0.7170229554176331,
0.011191476136446,
-0.08531317114830017,
-0.25404301285743713,
0.2788164019584656,
0.3266831636428833,
-0.25475019216537476,
0.42238643765449524,
-0.42591431736946106,
0.43043169379234314,
-0.6180141568183899,
-0.37787699699401855,
-0.11539045721292496,
-0.9187477827072144,
-0.05218318849802017,
0.09891784191131592,
-0.11628219485282898,
0.2453632950782776,
0.08733582496643066,
0.6929993033409119,
-0.24153009057044983,
0.4482211768627167,
-0.37213364243507385,
-0.09959806501865387,
0.43963393568992615,
0.40908434987068176,
0.8280472755432129,
-0.13884331285953522,
-0.15784358978271484,
0.6465574502944946,
-0.01973756030201912,
-0.22628922760486603,
-0.46470728516578674,
0.5701727867126465,
-0.8259763717651367,
-0.3183109760284424,
-0.48574212193489075,
-0.41113585233688354,
-0.2900765836238861,
0.07159505784511566,
0.5654111504554749,
0.3476167619228363,
-0.04285700246691704,
0.15043357014656067,
0.7575573921203613,
-0.031127404421567917,
0.5932635068893433,
0.6481682658195496,
0.3325882852077484,
-0.7555833458900452,
0.6351960301399231,
0.3818199038505554,
0.6972051858901978,
0.4255242943763733,
-0.25904330611228943,
-0.9523698687553406,
-0.8172668218612671,
-0.45061469078063965,
0.15998399257659912,
-0.4430641233921051,
-0.44830235838890076,
-0.9936387538909912,
-0.5296640992164612,
-0.5446880459785461,
-0.05622154101729393,
-0.8649812340736389,
-0.6362388134002686,
-0.5094187259674072,
0.13366129994392395,
0.504672110080719,
0.6191892623901367,
-0.2623392343521118,
0.6315826773643494,
-0.6661697030067444,
0.2787686884403229,
-0.09418056160211563,
0.15547214448451996,
-0.055998895317316055,
-1.104743242263794,
-0.47450992465019226,
0.22860340774059296,
-0.2620581388473511,
-0.6965720653533936,
0.697794497013092,
-0.05440610647201538,
0.0533742755651474,
0.061627890914678574,
0.28142955899238586,
0.8457878232002258,
-0.1747305542230606,
0.730994701385498,
0.3356744945049286,
-0.9835922122001648,
0.6019295454025269,
-0.13397108018398285,
0.6494876742362976,
0.6311604976654053,
-0.1489739865064621,
-0.49704107642173767,
-0.22757449746131897,
-0.3232387602329254,
-0.85813969373703,
0.6944292187690735,
0.6706804633140564,
-0.22493413090705872,
-0.08254057168960571,
0.36926713585853577,
0.06939024478197098,
0.19797463715076447,
-0.34756705164909363,
-0.2789004147052765,
-0.7391222715377808,
-0.09758538752794266,
-0.30929580330848694,
-0.2958988845348358,
0.5847979187965393,
0.1600014865398407,
0.7907427549362183,
0.16128991544246674,
0.38419991731643677,
0.5481507182121277,
-0.3436604142189026,
0.17184893786907196,
0.313841849565506,
0.8759310841560364,
-0.035726092755794525,
-0.05192519724369049,
0.02590227872133255,
0.3538878858089447,
-0.2806609570980072,
0.47994673252105713,
0.08268094062805176,
0.0007142809336073697,
0.05923483148217201,
0.045980580151081085,
0.7382017374038696,
-0.003958629444241524,
-0.09906818717718124,
0.5916042327880859,
-0.2252078503370285,
-0.29266124963760376,
-0.35384052991867065,
-0.10374946147203445,
-0.1044592633843422,
0.12706103920936584,
0.30879226326942444,
0.3051578104496002,
0.036285899579524994,
0.10558979958295822,
0.20571452379226685,
0.1334698349237442,
-0.6084970831871033,
-0.37266290187835693,
0.9752082824707031,
0.32320451736450195,
-0.21206577122211456,
0.8195720314979553,
0.07544383406639099,
-0.2602335810661316,
0.49940672516822815,
0.593945324420929,
0.7989089488983154,
-0.37968605756759644,
-0.18467561900615692,
0.5717092156410217,
0.188225656747818,
-0.4222061038017273,
0.08536060899496078,
-0.26584428548812866,
-0.13218830525875092,
-0.5070144534111023,
-0.3001978099346161,
-0.0708424299955368,
0.0850544348359108,
-0.6879439949989319,
0.2130744457244873,
-0.11902698874473572,
-0.42946192622184753,
-0.6058236360549927,
-0.04284292459487915,
-0.6605010628700256,
0.4604669213294983,
-0.0429316870868206,
0.9857770204544067,
-0.5118147134780884,
1.2285608053207397,
0.1628493070602417,
-0.33956241607666016,
-0.9414163827896118,
0.08477482199668884,
-0.06085631623864174,
-0.5359114408493042,
0.8308290839195251,
-0.06550118327140808,
-0.5951696038246155,
0.565649151802063,
-0.23853084444999695,
-1.071090817451477,
1.070164442062378,
0.31673663854599,
-0.7697604894638062,
-0.18712159991264343,
0.36240139603614807,
0.6125368475914001,
-0.17655429244041443,
0.2295708805322647,
0.27864861488342285,
0.3652290105819702,
0.15092289447784424,
-1.1934269666671753,
-0.23310218751430511,
-0.23896679282188416,
0.2856596112251282,
0.009565741755068302,
-0.890656054019928,
0.6501098275184631,
-0.13291484117507935,
-0.47891533374786377,
0.4180413484573364,
0.6219670176506042,
-0.09772741049528122,
0.3339601755142212,
0.31309881806373596,
0.534440279006958,
0.12836039066314697,
-0.005652963183820248,
0.7363365292549133,
-0.5047228336334229,
0.21974743902683258,
1.320204257965088,
-0.11618033796548843,
0.8511509895324707,
0.4702574610710144,
0.1606089025735855,
0.22490698099136353,
0.42301756143569946,
0.2651791572570801,
1.0216120481491089,
-0.11578628420829773,
-0.18608340620994568,
-0.4375309348106384,
-0.155721977353096,
-0.6923802495002747,
0.6749247908592224,
0.11795871704816818,
-0.5432022213935852,
-0.24672308564186096,
-0.048444315791130066,
-0.0459783598780632,
0.18822342157363892,
-0.05099278315901756,
1.0298117399215698,
0.20131978392601013,
-0.7030162215232849,
1.0273375511169434,
0.08837906271219254,
0.7634508609771729,
-0.5517731308937073,
0.01940220594406128,
-0.2799902856349945,
-0.0075133927166461945,
0.14142511785030365,
-0.3315918743610382,
0.4147958755493164,
0.23858371376991272,
-0.25770479440689087,
-0.3523194491863251,
0.4562876522541046,
-0.35507890582084656,
-0.19485501945018768,
0.34941041469573975,
0.7226039171218872,
0.3688380718231201,
-0.06191959232091904,
-0.5503208637237549,
-0.09005948901176453,
0.09404375404119492,
0.021635262295603752,
0.24852418899536133,
0.24038062989711761,
0.06119874492287636,
0.5598670244216919,
0.7497918605804443,
-0.04293840751051903,
-0.012046142481267452,
-0.24984048306941986,
0.48941943049430847,
-0.6755067706108093,
-0.6580324769020081,
-0.7827174067497253,
0.46107733249664307,
0.30503004789352417,
-0.20035485923290253,
0.4939849078655243,
0.5571945905685425,
0.6370956301689148,
-0.12440555542707443,
0.7332116961479187,
0.09919147938489914,
0.5730718970298767,
-0.592866063117981,
1.0690819025039673,
-0.41348451375961304,
-0.038816507905721664,
0.1557856798171997,
-0.5085130929946899,
-0.22267194092273712,
0.6478286385536194,
-0.3399467170238495,
0.08192109316587448,
0.7403029203414917,
0.7969682812690735,
0.16121068596839905,
0.006520009599626064,
0.5825187563896179,
0.19468680024147034,
0.32892945408821106,
0.6536343693733215,
0.7112058997154236,
-0.6474483013153076,
1.0145573616027832,
-0.13916191458702087,
-0.08507812768220901,
-0.31884273886680603,
-0.6995846629142761,
-0.7573185563087463,
-0.6768814325332642,
-0.4733930230140686,
-0.49565601348876953,
0.4812796413898468,
0.71119624376297,
0.8309193849563599,
-0.6716887354850769,
-0.0021767844446003437,
-0.44818413257598877,
-0.36281177401542664,
-0.18265561759471893,
-0.16726598143577576,
0.5082435607910156,
-0.18954776227474213,
-0.5843355655670166,
0.7065601944923401,
0.14475423097610474,
0.49367526173591614,
0.25729864835739136,
-0.1716335117816925,
-0.2712414860725403,
0.06062415987253189,
0.34923306107521057,
0.15389062464237213,
-0.7587400674819946,
0.02585640735924244,
0.21762849390506744,
-0.18675488233566284,
0.28162920475006104,
0.7922345399856567,
-0.9038057923316956,
0.4409373998641968,
0.3231336772441864,
0.36088797450065613,
0.5763065218925476,
0.19836929440498352,
0.3329488933086395,
-0.45493993163108826,
0.1811688095331192,
0.36604204773902893,
-0.153559148311615,
0.32639890909194946,
-0.2716394066810608,
0.31400448083877563,
0.09361785650253296,
-0.6760392785072327,
-0.5637984871864319,
0.19849610328674316,
-0.8427392840385437,
0.01748320460319519,
1.118654727935791,
-0.1472334861755371,
0.020593246445059776,
-0.3933599591255188,
0.04682406410574913,
0.8823689222335815,
-0.7564725279808044,
0.7577520608901978,
0.24772962927818298,
-0.204461008310318,
-0.025857094675302505,
-0.5024797320365906,
0.31554940342903137,
0.5787180662155151,
-0.5109174847602844,
0.22002625465393066,
0.3411930203437805,
0.39702707529067993,
-0.21508629620075226,
0.5237748622894287,
-0.4854731559753418,
0.1624118685722351,
0.031716056168079376,
-0.023602038621902466,
-0.4216136038303375,
-0.18217125535011292,
-0.5276141166687012,
-0.0692625641822815,
0.1418250948190689,
-0.1438877433538437
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07327v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07327v1
|
3D-Properties: Identifying Challenges in DPO and Charting a Path Forward
| 2024-06-11T14:59:24 | 2024-06-11T14:59:24 |
Yuzi Yan, Yibo Miao, Jialian Li, Yipin Zhang, Jian Xie, Zhijie Deng, Dong Yan
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Aligning large language models (LLMs) with human preference has recently
gained tremendous attention, with the canonical yet costly RLHF-PPO and the
simple and straightforward Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) as two
examples. Despite the efficiency, DPO has rarely be used in the
state-of-the-art production-level LLMs, implying its potential pathologies. In
this work, we revisit DPO with a comprehensive examination of its empirical
efficacy and a systematic comparison with RLHF-PPO. We identify the
\textbf{3D}-properties of DPO's learning outcomes: the \textbf{D}rastic drop in
the likelihood of rejected responses, the \textbf{D}egradation into LLM
unlearning, and the \textbf{D}ispersion effect on unseen responses through
experiments with both a carefully designed toy model and practical LLMs on
tasks including mathematical problem-solving and instruction following. These
findings inherently connect to some observations made by related works and we
additionally contribute a plausible theoretical explanation for them.
Accordingly, we propose easy regularization methods to mitigate the issues
caused by \textbf{3D}-properties, improving the training stability and final
performance of DPO. Our contributions also include an investigation into how
the distribution of the paired preference data impacts the effectiveness of
DPO. We hope this work could offer research directions to narrow the gap
between reward-free preference learning methods and reward-based ones.
|
[
-0.4142448902130127,
-0.5925156474113464,
0.6656937003135681,
0.06920816749334335,
-0.06120983138680458,
0.14816145598888397,
-0.22549857199192047,
-0.5415995121002197,
-0.0812322348356247,
0.5538333654403687,
-0.23631486296653748,
-0.18937146663665771,
-0.7016254663467407,
0.21168607473373413,
0.1637723296880722,
0.6343545913696289,
-0.09706640243530273,
-0.04520735889673233,
-0.3078521192073822,
0.2564387321472168,
-0.2156544029712677,
-0.6679155826568604,
-0.4525420367717743,
-0.514439582824707,
0.4570541977882385,
0.6668455004692078,
0.8274438381195068,
0.9235243797302246,
0.5534956455230713,
0.28739455342292786,
-0.2728630602359772,
-0.12079650163650513,
-0.6573486924171448,
-0.046043433248996735,
0.09016256034374237,
-0.3355048894882202,
-0.624254047870636,
0.32760146260261536,
0.6920128464698792,
1.0693024396896362,
-0.012307959608733654,
-0.28150853514671326,
0.36676424741744995,
1.188633680343628,
-0.7122155427932739,
0.10340466350317001,
-0.4496721625328064,
0.2532420754432678,
-0.0361628457903862,
-0.15015795826911926,
-0.29187092185020447,
-0.13700377941131592,
0.3994472324848175,
-0.7308014035224915,
0.2706177830696106,
-0.03376142308115959,
0.7275344133377075,
0.19513677060604095,
-0.45200446248054504,
-0.3600016236305237,
-0.8625833988189697,
1.0284662246704102,
-0.3868594467639923,
0.40022316575050354,
0.5336510539054871,
0.20168815553188324,
-0.32497021555900574,
-0.1913147270679474,
-0.5062103867530823,
-0.4860871136188507,
0.07554274797439575,
0.09953489154577255,
0.21973462402820587,
0.23511500656604767,
0.12769649922847748,
0.7821343541145325,
-0.21610955893993378,
0.49912068247795105,
-0.28260740637779236,
-0.06750496476888657,
0.7869025468826294,
0.05212647467851639,
0.09175123274326324,
-0.187627911567688,
-0.4460853934288025,
-0.2784247100353241,
-0.5780075788497925,
0.1694701462984085,
0.8193457722663879,
0.39915645122528076,
-0.09360342472791672,
0.7729120254516602,
-0.15428389608860016,
0.8149977922439575,
0.02070232853293419,
-0.38831090927124023,
0.13897886872291565,
-0.09666226804256439,
0.06795679777860641,
-0.10915753990411758,
0.7060455679893494,
0.23839688301086426,
0.4421175420284271,
-0.02824237570166588,
-0.17426900565624237,
-0.3134091794490814,
0.07856714725494385,
-0.5956529974937439,
-0.13102784752845764,
0.3015140891075134,
-0.444125771522522,
-0.43182098865509033,
-0.007970046252012253,
-0.8015294075012207,
-0.5522851943969727,
-0.5341331362724304,
0.22570402920246124,
-0.268465518951416,
-0.4915805160999298,
0.5475788712501526,
-0.06196356192231178,
0.07361974567174911,
0.239203080534935,
-1.4248249530792236,
0.45962727069854736,
0.8898499011993408,
0.7561236023902893,
-0.4186362028121948,
-0.3672139048576355,
-0.21166740357875824,
-0.11231750249862671,
-0.22051264345645905,
0.5525496602058411,
-0.5241027474403381,
-0.525524914264679,
-0.10828857123851776,
-0.6216669678688049,
0.04555315524339676,
-0.8534068465232849,
0.3377685546875,
-0.30458664894104004,
0.21258030831813812,
-0.3680255711078644,
-0.5705796480178833,
0.03486402705311775,
0.18502025306224823,
-0.7281566858291626,
0.7475128173828125,
0.13040609657764435,
-0.7109938263893127,
0.36182349920272827,
-0.4113970398902893,
-0.027010280638933182,
-0.2644532024860382,
-0.20046836137771606,
-0.28046953678131104,
0.3496575653553009,
-0.18816016614437103,
0.4805082380771637,
-0.29309025406837463,
0.2125675082206726,
-0.5675063729286194,
-0.4455970227718353,
0.2231690138578415,
-0.307036429643631,
0.7101084589958191,
0.13092361390590668,
-0.09587528556585312,
-0.1556662768125534,
-1.033588171005249,
-0.4180651903152466,
0.4156566560268402,
-0.42276906967163086,
-0.28050029277801514,
-0.03568743169307709,
-0.28583967685699463,
0.14127184450626373,
0.3697766065597534,
-0.5702340602874756,
0.3101309537887573,
-0.42518824338912964,
0.10173647105693817,
1.0246028900146484,
-0.3068849742412567,
0.5845586657524109,
-0.220330610871315,
0.5345034003257751,
-0.03166018798947334,
0.31387025117874146,
0.40944865345954895,
-0.38364216685295105,
-0.49102455377578735,
-0.44579482078552246,
0.17861732840538025,
0.3481311798095703,
-0.34045642614364624,
0.4259875416755676,
-0.09568831324577332,
-0.22923599183559418,
-0.15036165714263916,
0.292395681142807,
0.49151867628097534,
0.7660384774208069,
0.22348067164421082,
-0.10958248376846313,
-0.33219024538993835,
-1.18329918384552,
-0.11654655635356903,
-0.24287626147270203,
-0.14683109521865845,
0.2819765508174896,
0.21851846575737,
0.10997606068849564,
0.9062771201133728,
-0.7697489857673645,
-0.20110517740249634,
-0.22312135994434357,
-0.19588151574134827,
0.15920038521289825,
0.37333938479423523,
0.534423291683197,
-0.6457709670066833,
-0.4452265501022339,
-0.07652217894792557,
-0.482637882232666,
0.018381359055638313,
0.3531304597854614,
0.04137760028243065,
0.164839506149292,
0.08323930948972702,
-0.28631293773651123,
0.044562507420778275,
0.5399775505065918,
-0.05096519738435745,
0.5425388216972351,
-0.30335137248039246,
-0.008120245300233364,
-0.7930914163589478,
-0.10099612176418304,
0.1952463686466217,
0.2513883411884308,
-0.5329145789146423,
-0.32304999232292175,
-0.22693389654159546,
-0.37105005979537964,
-0.5731748342514038,
0.6696246862411499,
-0.41119030117988586,
-0.31025201082229614,
-0.24753201007843018,
0.3650228679180145,
0.12633945047855377,
0.6745821833610535,
0.34729287028312683,
0.5595697164535522,
0.4831748604774475,
-0.8741558194160461,
0.32158371806144714,
0.16515804827213287,
-0.10237256437540054,
0.45317602157592773,
-0.584075391292572,
0.28270891308784485,
-0.08120142668485641,
-0.1470620483160019,
-0.9351590275764465,
-0.11839911341667175,
0.30053988099098206,
-0.3203480541706085,
0.43546512722969055,
-0.16664756834506989,
-0.5997331738471985,
-0.19034209847450256,
-0.5784130096435547,
0.4155322313308716,
0.31357482075691223,
-0.5304850935935974,
0.30933961272239685,
0.4186224937438965,
0.01509525440633297,
-0.6984280347824097,
-0.10268200933933258,
-0.05292665585875511,
-0.31341850757598877,
-0.4219406843185425,
0.38882142305374146,
-0.19194139540195465,
-0.4811950623989105,
-0.18654067814350128,
-0.1722087562084198,
0.1229613646864891,
0.4110667407512665,
-0.11850384622812271,
0.2635069191455841,
0.15175503492355347,
-0.08413902670145035,
-0.17954504489898682,
-0.4039002060890198,
0.08451544493436813,
0.00790332816541195,
0.39175063371658325,
-0.16543905436992645,
-0.236647829413414,
-0.323583722114563,
0.17613574862480164,
0.4250582158565521,
0.08200958371162415,
0.48065251111984253,
0.026753023266792297,
-0.31667912006378174,
-0.14007893204689026,
-0.2925686538219452,
-0.23451566696166992,
-0.4942614734172821,
0.4201584756374359,
-0.4977032542228699,
-0.6858510375022888,
0.3462083637714386,
0.02429799735546112,
-0.046346891671419144,
0.1779472827911377,
0.2572621703147888,
-0.04601103439927101,
1.1319361925125122,
0.8642255663871765,
0.2300480157136917,
0.5335780382156372,
-0.3181663453578949,
0.26185545325279236,
-1.0085865259170532,
-0.4555865526199341,
-0.4257766604423523,
-0.42294272780418396,
-0.7424061298370361,
0.0038301204331219196,
0.23922696709632874,
0.4185449481010437,
-0.22550566494464874,
0.08394711464643478,
-0.4518636465072632,
0.2996116280555725,
0.46211281418800354,
0.15153872966766357,
0.4600827097892761,
0.105096235871315,
-0.09668577462434769,
-0.25075703859329224,
-0.548427939414978,
-0.6102874279022217,
1.1245354413986206,
0.47375205159187317,
0.681959867477417,
0.13984747231006622,
0.6899523735046387,
0.015103950165212154,
0.018507106229662895,
-1.0440270900726318,
0.5689510107040405,
-0.13423246145248413,
-0.25961586833000183,
-0.31126680970191956,
-0.45478498935699463,
-1.032328724861145,
0.3288303017616272,
-0.34935981035232544,
-0.7116875052452087,
0.31970179080963135,
0.4347843527793884,
-0.29444608092308044,
0.37702682614326477,
-0.6518962979316711,
0.7805812954902649,
-0.6636738181114197,
-0.6749939918518066,
-0.16375747323036194,
-0.41676050424575806,
0.4435591995716095,
0.015164997428655624,
-0.004214284010231495,
-0.4348166286945343,
-0.20021876692771912,
0.5639876127243042,
-0.2127677947282791,
0.6976210474967957,
-0.10667118430137634,
-0.38421177864074707,
-0.09134473651647568,
0.15038146078586578,
0.18887896835803986,
0.1486470252275467,
-0.3048916161060333,
0.14448769390583038,
-0.2605034410953522,
-0.508819580078125,
-0.7026443481445312,
0.8312305212020874,
-0.9830996990203857,
-0.9166460037231445,
-0.536147952079773,
-0.5750933289527893,
-0.5477060079574585,
0.18105573952198029,
-0.027057448402047157,
0.322023868560791,
-0.2262195497751236,
0.05530440807342529,
0.7687419056892395,
-0.3925897777080536,
0.27210357785224915,
0.5342288017272949,
-0.37300074100494385,
-0.5357741117477417,
0.9177071452140808,
0.012283510528504848,
0.48646584153175354,
0.49265778064727783,
0.7606325745582581,
-0.4434831440448761,
-0.6611319780349731,
-0.15587790310382843,
0.5169990062713623,
-0.6422060132026672,
0.10854502767324448,
-0.4667495787143707,
-0.003024723380804062,
-0.3384488523006439,
-0.28332075476646423,
-0.5885660648345947,
-0.40846365690231323,
-0.48080331087112427,
-0.20748066902160645,
0.24954231083393097,
0.7660565972328186,
-0.2595462501049042,
-0.11812867224216461,
-0.4905703663825989,
0.4354481101036072,
0.5180825591087341,
0.6534025073051453,
-0.02938155084848404,
-0.5556015968322754,
-0.16420240700244904,
0.1762738674879074,
-0.4662473201751709,
-0.5500393509864807,
0.07848314195871353,
-0.15549299120903015,
0.550973653793335,
0.42008015513420105,
0.07280462235212326,
0.33115023374557495,
-0.1638888120651245,
0.5710455775260925,
0.12283019721508026,
-0.8741154670715332,
0.6187581419944763,
-0.3820619285106659,
-0.13440565764904022,
0.5070815682411194,
0.5981675386428833,
-0.12014483660459518,
0.051777902990579605,
-0.6900360584259033,
-0.6667697429656982,
0.6824893951416016,
0.05400790274143219,
0.091084323823452,
-0.06293903291225433,
0.7246938943862915,
0.27544674277305603,
0.22108791768550873,
-0.5757035613059998,
-0.27243557572364807,
-0.13106374442577362,
0.06438292562961578,
-0.03376026451587677,
-0.5849651098251343,
-0.057297565042972565,
-0.11356387287378311,
0.4337007403373718,
-0.0032513246405869722,
-0.05983501300215721,
0.14486725628376007,
0.1911718249320984,
0.07734479010105133,
0.14793488383293152,
0.8585788011550903,
0.896079957485199,
-0.7076647877693176,
0.0711897686123848,
-0.27101221680641174,
-0.436942994594574,
0.26766493916511536,
0.005805752705782652,
0.008411788381636143,
-0.4761751890182495,
0.24714066088199615,
0.7592675685882568,
0.12289360910654068,
-0.5605411529541016,
0.41569262742996216,
0.11692433059215546,
-0.2858911454677582,
-0.1741487979888916,
0.07228220254182816,
-0.3086548447608948,
-0.20391704142093658,
0.304791659116745,
-0.11665143072605133,
0.10169755667448044,
-0.5333844423294067,
-0.049322981387376785,
0.36484494805336,
-0.5287555456161499,
-0.48503947257995605,
0.47058650851249695,
0.4950229823589325,
-0.35400837659835815,
0.64612877368927,
0.01672632433474064,
-0.3741830289363861,
0.598473846912384,
0.4855390787124634,
0.7643709182739258,
-0.008137775585055351,
0.1846596598625183,
0.2854127883911133,
0.06540326774120331,
-0.17905740439891815,
-0.045584820210933685,
-0.1728716790676117,
-1.0366802215576172,
-0.26392659544944763,
-0.4050182104110718,
-0.800254762172699,
0.2429647445678711,
-0.780205488204956,
0.4141440987586975,
-0.6204469799995422,
0.005502290092408657,
-0.2274736911058426,
0.3439694046974182,
-0.5157340168952942,
0.02468535117805004,
0.1247326135635376,
0.40195825695991516,
-0.8190938830375671,
0.5648349523544312,
0.6526986956596375,
-0.4222240447998047,
-0.44067519903182983,
0.0523698590695858,
0.16529019176959991,
-0.9147571325302124,
0.7730352878570557,
-0.022503085434436798,
-0.36076295375823975,
0.1664198786020279,
-0.16969183087348938,
-0.8985422253608704,
0.8736873865127563,
0.6560898423194885,
-0.542874276638031,
0.18259277939796448,
0.40243464708328247,
0.5461940765380859,
-0.19885040819644928,
0.08012868463993073,
0.5845842361450195,
0.361177921295166,
0.0340256430208683,
-0.8862897157669067,
-0.07577202469110489,
0.005555388517677784,
0.1659255474805832,
0.10551639646291733,
-0.7499948143959045,
0.5105252265930176,
-0.4793679416179657,
-0.16216039657592773,
-0.24459867179393768,
0.47361528873443604,
0.7015393376350403,
0.1356375813484192,
0.4921002686023712,
0.5400009751319885,
0.5432559847831726,
0.08596806228160858,
1.2678563594818115,
-0.2699909508228302,
0.34581124782562256,
0.8084350228309631,
-0.5540125966072083,
0.8060597777366638,
0.7556437849998474,
-0.3436848223209381,
0.21499589085578918,
0.6679691076278687,
0.3080250918865204,
0.4857865273952484,
0.661941647529602,
-0.12323915958404541,
-0.08678548783063889,
-0.1620035320520401,
-0.25664472579956055,
0.523969829082489,
0.15454797446727753,
0.06888231635093689,
0.14167311787605286,
0.01576945185661316,
0.09569096565246582,
0.5233948230743408,
-0.07034333795309067,
0.6585650444030762,
0.18250149488449097,
-0.5817112922668457,
0.5693279504776001,
-0.2939893305301666,
0.6460641026496887,
-0.49389469623565674,
-0.1488904058933258,
-0.4057336747646332,
0.4007439911365509,
-0.13803569972515106,
-0.8704361319541931,
0.2872104048728943,
-0.27216508984565735,
-0.2599145174026489,
-0.47038599848747253,
0.2610633373260498,
-0.2602311372756958,
-0.3098834156990051,
0.5290771126747131,
0.3613430857658386,
-0.049094557762145996,
0.012290951795876026,
-0.6575667858123779,
0.31839558482170105,
-0.12240526080131531,
-0.2399943321943283,
0.5578612089157104,
0.35087522864341736,
0.2857001721858978,
0.7061041593551636,
0.3973563015460968,
0.16752812266349792,
-0.3731633424758911,
0.09542380273342133,
0.5935933589935303,
-0.6145505309104919,
0.0012556277215480804,
-0.6911910772323608,
0.3673214912414551,
-0.03645119071006775,
-0.45811501145362854,
0.7617089748382568,
0.7146568894386292,
1.1264867782592773,
0.016172200441360474,
0.5934961438179016,
0.24213393032550812,
0.33922305703163147,
-0.7423319220542908,
0.23406146466732025,
-0.5856673121452332,
0.716325581073761,
-0.2741788327693939,
-1.1477077007293701,
-0.36205482482910156,
0.47800081968307495,
-0.3740481734275818,
0.2096215933561325,
0.7659177780151367,
0.5883446931838989,
0.02317233942449093,
-0.3318421244621277,
0.5036587119102478,
-0.1378186196088791,
0.29845863580703735,
0.4223974943161011,
0.9860361218452454,
-0.26654455065727234,
0.46567919850349426,
-0.8699702024459839,
-0.4222044348716736,
-0.21033048629760742,
-1.0063453912734985,
-0.8601175546646118,
-0.6431835889816284,
-0.4879412353038788,
-0.198510080575943,
-0.08150622993707657,
0.9046885967254639,
0.3977525234222412,
-0.4828711450099945,
-0.4921267032623291,
-0.17185088992118835,
0.36301910877227783,
-0.32341980934143066,
-0.2218293845653534,
0.45203521847724915,
-0.07964016497135162,
-0.9997168183326721,
0.3257308006286621,
0.34491828083992004,
0.4374699592590332,
-0.43611979484558105,
-0.15006472170352936,
0.009389318525791168,
-0.15316525101661682,
0.6610525250434875,
0.358368843793869,
-0.7780702114105225,
-0.2984432578086853,
0.23763976991176605,
-0.026167908683419228,
0.16503950953483582,
1.0841889381408691,
-0.409220814704895,
0.5255935192108154,
0.6034659147262573,
0.4768587648868561,
0.2966100573539734,
-0.0038215983659029007,
0.905834436416626,
-0.4415404498577118,
0.16677141189575195,
0.2535708546638489,
0.3907648026943207,
0.4729236960411072,
-0.4568866789340973,
0.4154820442199707,
0.3693506419658661,
-0.4748397767543793,
-0.832621693611145,
0.4112316071987152,
-0.8818331956863403,
-0.2501142919063568,
1.145761251449585,
0.13408370316028595,
-0.0304587259888649,
-0.18844959139823914,
-0.1025288999080658,
-0.07039900869131088,
-0.28984901309013367,
1.1177940368652344,
0.6204835772514343,
-0.5296574234962463,
-0.15947213768959045,
-0.5023226737976074,
0.6859586834907532,
0.5653325915336609,
-0.5838285088539124,
0.22603145241737366,
0.49001190066337585,
0.19845463335514069,
0.12477567791938782,
0.6319120526313782,
-0.26654052734375,
-0.05951324477791786,
-0.14813636243343353,
0.1992558240890503,
-0.334600031375885,
-0.3985140919685364,
-0.5716586112976074,
-0.07846666127443314,
0.49086472392082214,
-0.2890423536300659
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07310v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07310v1
|
MM-KWS: Multi-modal Prompts for Multilingual User-defined Keyword Spotting
| 2024-06-11T14:38:29 | 2024-06-11T14:38:29 |
Zhiqi Ai, Zhiyong Chen, Shugong Xu
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
In this paper, we propose MM-KWS, a novel approach to user-defined keyword
spotting leveraging multi-modal enrollments of text and speech templates.
Unlike previous methods that focus solely on either text or speech features,
MM-KWS extracts phoneme, text, and speech embeddings from both modalities.
These embeddings are then compared with the query speech embedding to detect
the target keywords. To ensure the applicability of MM-KWS across diverse
languages, we utilize a feature extractor incorporating several multilingual
pre-trained models. Subsequently, we validate its effectiveness on Mandarin and
English tasks. In addition, we have integrated advanced data augmentation tools
for hard case mining to enhance MM-KWS in distinguishing confusable words.
Experimental results on the LibriPhrase and WenetPhrase datasets demonstrate
that MM-KWS outperforms prior methods significantly.
|
[
-0.40845900774002075,
-0.5461342930793762,
0.5477652549743652,
0.15824943780899048,
-0.6007454991340637,
0.33887332677841187,
-0.12842567265033722,
-0.015602760948240757,
0.3470202684402466,
0.22257868945598602,
-0.722451388835907,
-0.7722296118736267,
-0.5353662371635437,
0.5222343802452087,
-0.12302534282207489,
0.6525065898895264,
0.3993768095970154,
0.13418835401535034,
0.19906872510910034,
-0.3034917712211609,
-0.491240918636322,
-0.7757371664047241,
-0.26372087001800537,
-0.026654401794075966,
0.796583354473114,
0.6464308500289917,
0.6585281491279602,
0.22039276361465454,
0.054658010601997375,
0.26048868894577026,
-0.02838563546538353,
0.34379708766937256,
0.18136657774448395,
0.2719985246658325,
0.11979959160089493,
-0.6011785864830017,
0.05204099789261818,
0.08197221904993057,
0.4274998605251312,
0.3968784213066101,
-0.13269728422164917,
-0.25265413522720337,
0.06689441949129105,
0.4713512361049652,
-0.8946718573570251,
0.13504210114479065,
-0.8293877243995667,
0.04164157807826996,
-0.6999143362045288,
-0.2136966437101364,
-0.18918371200561523,
-0.02984747104346752,
0.13656021654605865,
-0.5837090015411377,
0.18146058917045593,
-0.2934000492095947,
0.5458621978759766,
-0.24278105795383453,
-0.6668712496757507,
-0.6114920973777771,
-0.21149961650371552,
0.929664134979248,
-0.6870250701904297,
0.90724116563797,
0.544448733329773,
0.5071913003921509,
-0.08033637702465057,
-0.7336528897285461,
-0.9813737273216248,
-0.38719114661216736,
-0.06387368589639664,
0.19122575223445892,
0.14979493618011475,
0.2223537415266037,
0.05158693343400955,
0.17112524807453156,
-0.432835191488266,
0.05341269448399544,
-0.1562991887331009,
-0.7598432898521423,
0.37679892778396606,
0.006725205574184656,
0.15323445200920105,
-0.7835999131202698,
-0.07338462024927139,
-0.11818766593933105,
-0.697264552116394,
0.39104005694389343,
0.2538035213947296,
0.76243656873703,
-0.2586437463760376,
0.6112043857574463,
-0.40874621272087097,
0.5932729244232178,
-0.22244931757450104,
-0.6451930999755859,
0.48807984590530396,
-0.5835999250411987,
-0.15400899946689606,
-0.0037733064964413643,
0.8359272480010986,
0.1718806028366089,
0.04141272231936455,
-0.17763899266719818,
-0.08879946917295456,
-0.019287433475255966,
-0.2396620362997055,
-0.5652486085891724,
-0.3082229197025299,
0.18518592417240143,
-0.6306523084640503,
-0.5872613787651062,
-0.09007083624601364,
-0.8232073783874512,
-0.5215028524398804,
-0.09278395026922226,
0.4375160336494446,
-0.4313165545463562,
-0.2575584948062897,
-0.1733597218990326,
-0.6515592932701111,
0.18746989965438843,
0.09730017930269241,
-0.8832656741142273,
-0.40131810307502747,
0.5749229788780212,
0.8933867812156677,
-0.0028713953215628862,
-0.17544487118721008,
-0.6199966669082642,
0.12073951959609985,
-0.18062402307987213,
0.5651914477348328,
-0.8537821769714355,
-0.8159359693527222,
0.19813849031925201,
0.22914089262485504,
-0.24014899134635925,
-0.5745320320129395,
0.8660508394241333,
-0.35242360830307007,
0.4292267858982086,
-0.6526207327842712,
-0.42263713479042053,
-0.3573020100593567,
0.43910151720046997,
-0.5890617370605469,
0.9905378222465515,
0.04757625237107277,
-0.4618684947490692,
0.7196742296218872,
-0.7493724226951599,
-0.6030352115631104,
0.2238757163286209,
-0.47913965582847595,
-0.28407180309295654,
0.11150480806827545,
0.5179451107978821,
0.5313177108764648,
-0.07213104516267776,
0.026876265183091164,
-0.32033365964889526,
-0.06665084511041641,
0.33939915895462036,
-0.6342993378639221,
0.7165974378585815,
0.46519240736961365,
-0.12603187561035156,
0.11863695085048676,
-0.9166685938835144,
0.05410350114107132,
0.02159867435693741,
-0.5735273957252502,
-0.5974788665771484,
0.255395770072937,
0.2078041136264801,
0.37474191188812256,
0.22321657836437225,
-0.6833990216255188,
0.11524896323680878,
-0.18190453946590424,
0.48992276191711426,
0.5407331585884094,
-0.16870878636837006,
0.14249654114246368,
-0.013372901827096939,
0.622087299823761,
0.2911607325077057,
-0.0119120879098773,
-0.5504600405693054,
-0.5056730508804321,
-0.3655572831630707,
-0.6686334013938904,
0.48891037702560425,
0.6617973446846008,
-1.100962519645691,
0.5030122399330139,
-0.1424621045589447,
-0.34731170535087585,
-0.586903989315033,
0.1987459361553192,
0.16377465426921844,
0.3347242474555969,
0.18323002755641937,
0.014706841669976711,
-0.4279418885707855,
-0.8630993366241455,
-0.24874000251293182,
0.05491510033607483,
-0.30597302317619324,
0.5695251822471619,
0.24086646735668182,
-0.044816549867391586,
0.9334102272987366,
-0.44705691933631897,
-0.44086113572120667,
-0.3564830422401428,
0.3022806644439697,
0.19920310378074646,
0.13523000478744507,
0.5220562219619751,
-1.0143886804580688,
-0.640829861164093,
-0.10554144531488419,
-0.5683473348617554,
-0.19366396963596344,
0.0940505862236023,
0.3824375569820404,
0.007521775085479021,
0.8360610604286194,
-0.5275771021842957,
0.04028894752264023,
0.4265763461589813,
-0.3448132872581482,
0.7115657329559326,
-0.0430796854197979,
0.3372094929218292,
-1.448266863822937,
0.1711249053478241,
-0.16728682816028595,
-0.16781237721443176,
-0.657476007938385,
0.043432753533124924,
0.336810827255249,
-0.20503628253936768,
-0.4250844419002533,
0.2580989599227905,
-0.3299724757671356,
0.22777925431728363,
-0.4045613706111908,
0.20742098987102509,
-0.030732175335288048,
0.2806013226509094,
-0.11626150459051132,
1.0334410667419434,
0.5112218856811523,
-0.7614567279815674,
0.33015382289886475,
0.006373793352395296,
-0.39774399995803833,
0.7364155054092407,
-0.3036026954650879,
0.06797459721565247,
-0.06734147667884827,
0.07052154093980789,
-1.2708218097686768,
-0.1035674437880516,
0.10369790345430374,
-0.5226296186447144,
0.14568041265010834,
-0.33618223667144775,
-0.7275426387786865,
-0.5832232236862183,
-0.6423943042755127,
0.09973328560590744,
0.15321217477321625,
-0.46332812309265137,
0.580102801322937,
0.37280988693237305,
-0.2506549060344696,
-0.6327220797538757,
-0.17800399661064148,
0.32778990268707275,
-0.2729530930519104,
-0.3377506136894226,
0.31978821754455566,
0.09214051067829132,
0.13335008919239044,
-0.28338372707366943,
0.16048119962215424,
-0.20761024951934814,
0.33460375666618347,
-0.019641827791929245,
0.1347353756427765,
-0.16849686205387115,
0.2576008439064026,
0.3651886284351349,
-0.11404319852590561,
-0.25314173102378845,
-0.15753625333309174,
0.6920356750488281,
0.40228739380836487,
-0.3172142803668976,
-0.32826894521713257,
0.5103833675384521,
0.996722936630249,
-0.45216959714889526,
0.2881109416484833,
1.0413610935211182,
-0.32997745275497437,
0.34006941318511963,
-0.5539373159408569,
-0.27569815516471863,
-0.588405966758728,
0.49431857466697693,
-0.8043060898780823,
-0.8303757905960083,
0.4396073818206787,
-0.28900715708732605,
0.11473233997821808,
0.4115448296070099,
0.45651713013648987,
-0.2564084529876709,
1.5058766603469849,
0.6737477779388428,
-0.5737029910087585,
0.3973236083984375,
0.05474291369318962,
0.24002650380134583,
-0.665343701839447,
-0.12321925163269043,
-0.7158925533294678,
-0.27986404299736023,
-0.6049586534500122,
-0.22257018089294434,
0.5347539186477661,
0.3648682236671448,
0.36326655745506287,
0.13325126469135284,
-0.24314691126346588,
0.23465129733085632,
0.7339691519737244,
-0.030424216762185097,
0.12938641011714935,
-0.16035975515842438,
-0.7703213095664978,
-0.3907015025615692,
-0.4555681347846985,
-0.22594711184501648,
1.2089102268218994,
0.0053993165493011475,
0.4486652612686157,
0.17661720514297485,
0.5235831141471863,
0.4034532308578491,
0.008542004972696304,
-1.0439598560333252,
0.5237691402435303,
-0.3130265474319458,
-0.672823429107666,
-0.2116318941116333,
-0.043290875852108,
-1.0076571702957153,
0.43785589933395386,
-0.2664727568626404,
-0.7319613099098206,
0.15697941184043884,
-0.1750626266002655,
-0.42634472250938416,
0.09011175483465195,
-0.6156098246574402,
0.784716784954071,
-0.0635814443230629,
0.3455316126346588,
-0.43829357624053955,
-0.5185676217079163,
0.1709635853767395,
-0.07940090447664261,
0.41369614005088806,
-0.33343884348869324,
-0.23994578421115875,
0.8165026903152466,
-0.44210630655288696,
0.7327970266342163,
-0.5619397163391113,
-0.12300345301628113,
0.12447433173656464,
-0.12237295508384705,
0.4236237704753876,
-0.05008358880877495,
0.17066380381584167,
0.04708966240286827,
0.06839635223150253,
0.004499072674661875,
-0.49698692560195923,
0.5454860329627991,
-0.3178183138370514,
-0.30834317207336426,
-0.25632405281066895,
-0.6505853533744812,
-0.18366563320159912,
0.5263940691947937,
0.3856578767299652,
0.4666489064693451,
-0.10357969254255295,
0.34473082423210144,
0.2452668994665146,
-0.1739887148141861,
0.700130045413971,
0.8388242125511169,
-0.13652366399765015,
-0.6204062104225159,
1.1822649240493774,
0.13841767609119415,
-0.08596806973218918,
0.5273207426071167,
0.5256427526473999,
-0.6256728768348694,
-0.5943588018417358,
-0.5904279947280884,
0.07594083994626999,
-0.5503827929496765,
-0.18373459577560425,
-0.8736878633499146,
0.003824440762400627,
-0.5486177802085876,
-0.19997486472129822,
0.015319670550525188,
-0.35672980546951294,
-0.21567843854427338,
0.07686468958854675,
0.23295466601848602,
0.21744553744792938,
-0.28124740719795227,
0.565199613571167,
-1.0922811031341553,
0.5786136388778687,
0.46162474155426025,
-0.0722372829914093,
-0.2735445499420166,
-0.3002144396305084,
-0.28219839930534363,
0.10899384319782257,
-0.37922120094299316,
-1.0889238119125366,
0.43460842967033386,
0.4157598614692688,
0.6865838170051575,
0.8231604695320129,
-0.0243530310690403,
0.43011659383773804,
-0.4990012049674988,
1.0227725505828857,
0.17683453857898712,
-0.9075998067855835,
0.5518668293952942,
-0.3941802382469177,
0.4982157349586487,
0.758955717086792,
0.46667754650115967,
-1.01012122631073,
-0.4922456443309784,
-0.2798766493797302,
-0.667391300201416,
0.5056518912315369,
-0.0174274742603302,
0.09978786110877991,
-0.08347056061029434,
0.18104514479637146,
0.15739350020885468,
0.34568139910697937,
-0.5097677707672119,
-0.47878727316856384,
-0.08069707453250885,
-0.5617147088050842,
-0.22063958644866943,
-0.4957965910434723,
0.01393585093319416,
-0.20810475945472717,
0.3653746545314789,
-0.3273787796497345,
0.13359487056732178,
0.12031688541173935,
-0.31287574768066406,
0.37034037709236145,
0.586246907711029,
0.7102110981941223,
0.17298787832260132,
-0.2136431634426117,
0.19204382598400116,
0.0716981515288353,
-0.9058136343955994,
0.09786839038133621,
0.41406914591789246,
-0.17243321239948273,
0.5788144469261169,
0.05633867159485817,
0.3464955687522888,
0.37958192825317383,
-0.7453864216804504,
0.5135334730148315,
0.06033112853765488,
-0.27582409977912903,
0.01230481918901205,
-0.2628193199634552,
0.09609046578407288,
0.20526213943958282,
0.7693507671356201,
-0.2783704996109009,
0.3335944712162018,
-0.4740304946899414,
0.3636849820613861,
0.8405948877334595,
-0.41006553173065186,
-0.38779759407043457,
0.35020938515663147,
0.3007729947566986,
-0.4182111620903015,
0.31650254130363464,
-0.2542746663093567,
-0.9697405099868774,
0.2963688373565674,
0.4307851493358612,
1.0162954330444336,
-0.4220261871814728,
0.13503031432628632,
0.1094600185751915,
0.256635844707489,
0.4777701795101166,
0.7319930791854858,
-0.46958452463150024,
-0.7813641428947449,
-0.13379037380218506,
-0.29822808504104614,
-0.34651312232017517,
0.451296865940094,
-0.43132156133651733,
0.4780871868133545,
-0.20131716132164001,
-0.2484336644411087,
0.38229864835739136,
0.08749201893806458,
-0.4720684289932251,
0.09974303096532822,
0.3031090795993805,
0.7865861058235168,
-0.7519359588623047,
0.8892557621002197,
0.5532754063606262,
-0.09344272315502167,
-0.5689535737037659,
-0.13145367801189423,
0.4055573046207428,
-0.9970954656600952,
0.49304091930389404,
0.46522510051727295,
0.08157920092344284,
0.01438542827963829,
-0.35458654165267944,
-0.8013081550598145,
1.0913450717926025,
-0.15970830619335175,
-0.3911679685115814,
0.027974780648946762,
0.2100663185119629,
-0.030445003882050514,
-0.05097223445773125,
0.025806905701756477,
0.6029888391494751,
0.4805293381214142,
-0.12991046905517578,
-1.1676939725875854,
-0.2526857554912567,
0.06125663220882416,
-0.5762678384780884,
0.25156697630882263,
-0.19621345400810242,
0.8921259641647339,
-0.049555547535419464,
-0.2237943708896637,
0.10764624178409576,
0.5309364795684814,
0.4412246644496918,
0.30490630865097046,
0.9027822017669678,
0.47036945819854736,
0.8258442878723145,
-0.007519289385527372,
0.7051218748092651,
-0.34122878313064575,
0.09213988482952118,
0.6858731508255005,
-0.20999282598495483,
0.886448085308075,
0.3461623191833496,
-0.38245928287506104,
0.4700232148170471,
0.5067694783210754,
0.1632724404335022,
1.003707766532898,
-0.12822401523590088,
-0.6846708655357361,
-0.20929738879203796,
-0.19705002009868622,
-0.40192240476608276,
0.8973966240882874,
0.7726972103118896,
-0.3569568991661072,
-0.5518960356712341,
0.3674596846103668,
0.0971045047044754,
-0.31858372688293457,
-0.1334451586008072,
0.6533287167549133,
0.08394667506217957,
-0.3415449261665344,
0.24127131700515747,
0.2986798882484436,
1.2729436159133911,
-1.083627462387085,
0.011775420047342777,
-0.001648198813199997,
0.13387972116470337,
0.07789957523345947,
-0.5315051078796387,
-0.1365285962820053,
-0.13967841863632202,
-0.08684487640857697,
0.23581646382808685,
0.9005642533302307,
-0.5314167141914368,
-0.5027432441711426,
-0.0024338182993233204,
0.7704897522926331,
-0.023044075816869736,
-0.511111319065094,
-0.9043326377868652,
-0.29744434356689453,
0.04196367785334587,
0.08962522447109222,
0.24094176292419434,
0.47723841667175293,
0.2004113346338272,
0.49169206619262695,
0.92643803358078,
0.007298750802874565,
0.10509175807237625,
0.4601573646068573,
0.6480922102928162,
-0.7685085535049438,
-0.9541694521903992,
-0.9501878023147583,
0.20724108815193176,
-0.11154340207576752,
-0.2659812569618225,
1.0120878219604492,
0.7128549218177795,
0.5183113813400269,
0.013017592020332813,
1.0426528453826904,
0.07361238449811935,
0.8413763642311096,
-0.48904871940612793,
0.8579732775688171,
-0.6199413537979126,
-0.19322142004966736,
-0.4014703035354614,
-0.5949872136116028,
-0.12064526975154877,
0.457565575838089,
0.15323609113693237,
-0.18104369938373566,
0.5742996335029602,
0.8218244910240173,
-0.08509171009063721,
0.02977278269827366,
0.4770919382572174,
-0.306850790977478,
0.7257612347602844,
0.1991526484489441,
0.6993482112884521,
-0.336633563041687,
0.5524559617042542,
-0.3497794270515442,
-0.17954154312610626,
-0.3564399182796478,
-0.7638630867004395,
-0.6729504466056824,
-0.7830823659896851,
-0.026536183431744576,
-0.1442430019378662,
-0.29404759407043457,
0.8062942624092102,
0.6816952228546143,
-0.8789865970611572,
-0.14695197343826294,
0.24115651845932007,
0.30359509587287903,
-0.2233080267906189,
-0.31418341398239136,
0.39191561937332153,
-0.5522175431251526,
-0.6204788684844971,
0.9192687273025513,
0.2993220090866089,
0.2116570621728897,
-0.2501762807369232,
0.1624271273612976,
-0.4640525281429291,
-0.0235577579587698,
0.8545396327972412,
0.28313034772872925,
-0.6814225912094116,
-0.26441386342048645,
0.39779701828956604,
-0.1406237930059433,
-0.08487536758184433,
1.1965539455413818,
-0.8653795719146729,
0.7484614849090576,
0.43765130639076233,
0.4039408266544342,
0.09673810005187988,
-0.370708167552948,
0.6120823621749878,
-0.9985496401786804,
0.4940034747123718,
0.11280728876590729,
0.4924706220626831,
0.2019815444946289,
-0.07526540756225586,
0.07369790971279144,
0.6614606380462646,
-0.11981406062841415,
-0.7662391662597656,
0.18376509845256805,
-0.9790847897529602,
-0.3863619565963745,
0.9351969957351685,
0.09908588230609894,
0.1587129533290863,
-0.7921772003173828,
-0.33794093132019043,
0.041619181632995605,
-0.22875447571277618,
0.68980872631073,
0.8405777812004089,
0.30035075545310974,
-0.006131250411272049,
-0.48416846990585327,
0.6823172569274902,
0.4833090901374817,
-0.2944941520690918,
-0.0661318451166153,
0.42119303345680237,
0.2534984052181244,
0.33456194400787354,
0.7416861653327942,
-0.07150579988956451,
0.4026172161102295,
-0.09519469738006592,
-0.27950501441955566,
-0.1204434335231781,
-0.17566853761672974,
-0.33730190992355347,
0.1438145935535431,
0.0039067049510777,
-0.7222973704338074
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07302v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07302v1
|
BertaQA: How Much Do Language Models Know About Local Culture?
| 2024-06-11T14:30:34 | 2024-06-11T14:30:34 |
Julen Etxaniz, Gorka Azkune, Aitor Soroa, Oier Lopez de Lacalle, Mikel Artetxe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibit extensive knowledge about the world, but
most evaluations have been limited to global or anglocentric subjects. This
raises the question of how well these models perform on topics relevant to
other cultures, whose presence on the web is not that prominent. To address
this gap, we introduce BertaQA, a multiple-choice trivia dataset that is
parallel in English and Basque. The dataset consists of a local subset with
questions pertinent to the Basque culture, and a global subset with questions
of broader interest. We find that state-of-the-art LLMs struggle with local
cultural knowledge, even as they excel on global topics. However, we show that
continued pre-training in Basque significantly improves the models' performance
on Basque culture, even when queried in English. To our knowledge, this is the
first solid evidence of knowledge transfer from a low-resource to a
high-resource language. Our analysis sheds light on the complex interplay
between language and knowledge, and reveals that some prior findings do not
fully hold when reassessed on local topics. Our dataset and evaluation code are
available under open licenses at https://github.com/juletx/BertaQA.
|
[
-0.47879090905189514,
-0.5450704097747803,
0.6336719393730164,
0.3227711617946625,
-0.09635945409536362,
0.21247610449790955,
-0.5887202024459839,
-0.6786452531814575,
0.45225802063941956,
0.5095646977424622,
-0.43932172656059265,
-0.3778036832809448,
-0.5566987991333008,
-0.07222327589988708,
-0.23450863361358643,
1.0145578384399414,
-0.19876131415367126,
0.13510923087596893,
-0.4300285279750824,
-0.3998035192489624,
-0.302565336227417,
-0.664763331413269,
-0.5949123501777649,
-0.24797742068767548,
0.7390270829200745,
0.5008252263069153,
0.7563629150390625,
0.15044307708740234,
0.3101326823234558,
0.16666440665721893,
-0.20824061334133148,
0.10786580294370651,
-0.759770393371582,
0.17210441827774048,
-0.14858463406562805,
-0.7253178358078003,
0.1120709627866745,
-0.0856260135769844,
0.6236518621444702,
0.6350380778312683,
-0.058381035923957825,
0.4459962844848633,
-0.13543695211410522,
0.5261247754096985,
-0.2720238268375397,
0.08522754907608032,
-0.754554271697998,
-0.1443544179201126,
-0.4251936674118042,
0.07497049123048782,
0.025626305490732193,
-0.8422220349311829,
0.4314318597316742,
-0.46719422936439514,
0.15626133978366852,
-0.17899885773658752,
1.0330325365066528,
0.2637186050415039,
-0.664237916469574,
-0.190948486328125,
-0.7836887836456299,
0.8412748575210571,
-0.29367250204086304,
0.21845634281635284,
0.5425150990486145,
0.3193504810333252,
-0.21607482433319092,
-0.483643501996994,
-0.6261104345321655,
-0.006519237533211708,
0.13926562666893005,
-0.1684555560350418,
-0.2877306044101715,
-0.5752086639404297,
0.045804183930158615,
0.2634275257587433,
-0.4078976809978485,
0.1349451094865799,
-0.7043099999427795,
-0.03369783237576485,
0.45037373900413513,
-0.09085284918546677,
0.5306486487388611,
-0.22980624437332153,
-0.3276538550853729,
0.00772838992998004,
-0.9839368462562561,
0.42747893929481506,
0.2900395691394806,
0.10110490769147873,
-0.255607545375824,
0.09928838908672333,
-0.07646558433771133,
0.4035724699497223,
-0.4397982656955719,
-0.10234944522380829,
0.36080360412597656,
-0.03320443630218506,
0.259856253862381,
-0.27983495593070984,
0.6567182540893555,
0.08354466408491135,
0.6716977953910828,
-0.25432461500167847,
0.2097119390964508,
-0.14857171475887299,
0.06119972839951515,
-0.588269829750061,
-0.2269572913646698,
0.33182549476623535,
-0.23553963005542755,
-0.03916560485959053,
-0.2668580710887909,
-0.270693302154541,
-0.28200140595436096,
-0.08889728039503098,
0.3729259967803955,
-0.3888736665248871,
-0.11352498084306717,
0.01674528606235981,
-0.09425342828035355,
0.48329561948776245,
0.27996304631233215,
-0.8506101965904236,
0.10331161320209503,
0.658063530921936,
0.7204268574714661,
-0.278583288192749,
-0.445198655128479,
-0.03889324143528938,
-0.10380809754133224,
-0.4663630425930023,
0.7979900240898132,
-0.540224552154541,
-0.24254371225833893,
0.029388029128313065,
0.10244573652744293,
0.15340636670589447,
-0.39250555634498596,
0.683638870716095,
-0.7111718058586121,
0.34687408804893494,
-0.8032192587852478,
-0.21044719219207764,
-0.3402997553348541,
0.2264862060546875,
-0.8025330901145935,
1.0955321788787842,
-0.05842628329992294,
-0.7712675929069519,
0.402406245470047,
-0.2323053777217865,
-0.5576403141021729,
-0.052693866193294525,
-0.2644411027431488,
0.1377529501914978,
0.14429743587970734,
0.44326838850975037,
0.39888954162597656,
-0.5046247839927673,
0.4195718467235565,
-0.38325780630111694,
-0.3807869255542755,
0.288779616355896,
-0.3347892761230469,
0.9775086641311646,
0.29441675543785095,
0.062258750200271606,
-0.39095228910446167,
-0.6117541193962097,
-0.1986476182937622,
0.19803325831890106,
-0.4468161165714264,
-0.5994920134544373,
-0.07922685146331787,
-0.16162945330142975,
0.3614697754383087,
0.48344895243644714,
-0.7186001539230347,
0.23551498353481293,
-0.2735958993434906,
0.3696291446685791,
0.6845402121543884,
-0.16542552411556244,
0.4248255789279938,
-0.6094976663589478,
0.5775641798973083,
-0.29627400636672974,
0.18490445613861084,
0.1900816112756729,
-0.7651344537734985,
-0.7003845572471619,
-0.2489374577999115,
0.5012626647949219,
0.4698363244533539,
-0.9939022660255432,
-0.1954260915517807,
-0.4014010429382324,
-0.6022495627403259,
-0.7858301401138306,
0.26769036054611206,
-0.11349363625049591,
0.18948985636234283,
-0.03258943557739258,
-0.4363565742969513,
-0.350073903799057,
-1.0367763042449951,
-0.16531004011631012,
-0.1362636834383011,
-0.1854649782180786,
0.34561413526535034,
0.33938977122306824,
0.09696418792009354,
0.9723417162895203,
-0.15150584280490875,
-0.21803267300128937,
-0.13116276264190674,
0.4495895504951477,
0.6127275824546814,
0.18761874735355377,
0.9124941229820251,
-0.5821773409843445,
-0.5560465455055237,
0.019129320979118347,
-0.5695263147354126,
-0.11092184484004974,
0.11506707221269608,
-0.2374853640794754,
0.1565357744693756,
-0.0886201336979866,
-0.4132242202758789,
-0.049962934106588364,
0.8896435499191284,
-0.11470493674278259,
0.20117314159870148,
-0.2973983883857727,
0.14793194830417633,
-1.1675186157226562,
-0.10318540781736374,
-0.3166201710700989,
0.0005405402625910938,
-0.5784950852394104,
-0.06949328631162643,
-0.015258175320923328,
0.005095277447253466,
-0.5383860468864441,
0.9771811366081238,
-0.28434354066848755,
-0.17050041258335114,
-0.08490696549415588,
0.1477067917585373,
-0.0796576514840126,
0.5039710998535156,
0.4750329554080963,
0.8335155248641968,
0.5442695021629333,
-0.4198800027370453,
0.23108412325382233,
0.34898942708969116,
-0.81911700963974,
0.32927820086479187,
-0.41290542483329773,
0.2562161386013031,
-0.25686994194984436,
0.2508247494697571,
-0.7967051863670349,
-0.24607621133327484,
-0.17403237521648407,
-0.482280433177948,
-0.10522323101758957,
-0.2590394914150238,
-0.5184437036514282,
-0.274428129196167,
-0.19251854717731476,
0.4800141155719757,
0.5292065739631653,
-0.7172434329986572,
0.6187565326690674,
0.5250372886657715,
-0.7352822422981262,
-0.7856879830360413,
-0.5406532883644104,
0.06938078999519348,
-0.13113634288311005,
-0.9477037191390991,
0.16955727338790894,
-0.11788660287857056,
-0.4755616784095764,
-0.24728381633758545,
0.06481204181909561,
-0.48838749527931213,
0.25803354382514954,
-0.0038937481585890055,
0.13445213437080383,
-0.2369195818901062,
0.42626142501831055,
-0.09541496634483337,
0.427870512008667,
0.22179867327213287,
-0.13413232564926147,
0.47345858812332153,
-0.14974577724933624,
-0.16939161717891693,
-0.12110939621925354,
0.24736042320728302,
0.6371082067489624,
-0.2605803906917572,
0.8566485047340393,
0.7186644673347473,
-0.16072840988636017,
-0.3507801592350006,
-0.8609272837638855,
-0.01810413971543312,
-0.3663526475429535,
0.16634303331375122,
-0.38014137744903564,
-0.9450536966323853,
0.8919064998626709,
0.22966082394123077,
0.08987824618816376,
0.33668991923332214,
0.6497241258621216,
-0.5593769550323486,
0.4024217128753662,
0.6995143890380859,
-0.33675408363342285,
0.42605331540107727,
-0.18462781608104706,
0.10767176002264023,
-0.4078175127506256,
-0.09815502166748047,
-0.7217324376106262,
-0.43610575795173645,
-0.7062434554100037,
-0.6736438274383545,
0.5612362027168274,
-0.17830826342105865,
-0.2511586844921112,
0.0291445329785347,
0.21033906936645508,
0.7564138770103455,
0.8313705921173096,
-0.05512799695134163,
0.4084825813770294,
0.1194300726056099,
-0.031938157975673676,
-0.06888659298419952,
-1.0770219564437866,
-0.4799259305000305,
1.2989890575408936,
0.5078222155570984,
0.8124532103538513,
0.3716118633747101,
0.7122160196304321,
0.13177083432674408,
0.4055387079715729,
-0.5979728698730469,
0.16092032194137573,
-0.34459778666496277,
-0.8375840187072754,
-0.3583885133266449,
-0.3901063799858093,
-0.8159472346305847,
0.2377927154302597,
-0.2404121309518814,
-0.6256019473075867,
0.44997638463974,
-0.17607471346855164,
-0.4507323205471039,
0.47744518518447876,
-0.6546190977096558,
0.6416927576065063,
-0.5915191173553467,
-0.4321780204772949,
-0.08775809407234192,
-0.5531824231147766,
0.337511271238327,
-0.31675195693969727,
0.5622326731681824,
-0.17649920284748077,
0.27410563826560974,
0.9028679728507996,
0.16155141592025757,
0.8136535286903381,
0.18464557826519012,
-0.5451015830039978,
0.19691753387451172,
0.3022833466529846,
0.21900123357772827,
0.10946016758680344,
-0.13141347467899323,
0.4628826081752777,
0.4105280339717865,
-0.6324136853218079,
-0.43779855966567993,
0.7415408492088318,
-1.0100737810134888,
-0.5821419358253479,
-0.36441823840141296,
-0.8215444087982178,
-0.4687534272670746,
-0.046720076352357864,
0.026681117713451385,
0.22515253722667694,
-0.3089636564254761,
0.42117422819137573,
0.9434977173805237,
-0.49445056915283203,
0.3093114495277405,
0.7113097906112671,
-0.23189306259155273,
-0.04625776782631874,
0.8005573749542236,
0.24456559121608734,
0.18548759818077087,
0.27554038166999817,
0.061424341052770615,
-0.2037781924009323,
-0.2552624046802521,
-0.2562795877456665,
0.4372759163379669,
-0.7861350774765015,
0.12638534605503082,
-0.312845915555954,
-0.060279183089733124,
-0.26869839429855347,
-0.020413542166352272,
-0.2653225064277649,
-0.5052661299705505,
-0.00925788190215826,
-0.028945110738277435,
0.3186706602573395,
0.9494839906692505,
-0.19847479462623596,
0.07748255133628845,
-0.917504608631134,
0.18948407471179962,
0.6702654361724854,
0.36135199666023254,
-0.01595218852162361,
-0.5750164985656738,
-0.17492243647575378,
-0.0832422748208046,
0.10118184983730316,
-0.7895347476005554,
0.285569429397583,
-0.026059044525027275,
0.5971792936325073,
0.2552354037761688,
0.08210412412881851,
0.22875216603279114,
-0.30083492398262024,
0.7596969604492188,
-0.27764660120010376,
-0.6654683351516724,
0.2366759479045868,
-0.4887537658214569,
0.41725921630859375,
0.42950496077537537,
0.9673681855201721,
-0.7165951132774353,
-0.5497968792915344,
-0.5317952036857605,
-0.6377673745155334,
0.7124168872833252,
0.05854964256286621,
0.6031500697135925,
-0.09455717355012894,
0.11406969279050827,
0.26729774475097656,
0.15329712629318237,
-0.9408718943595886,
-0.011489072814583778,
0.17509280145168304,
0.15253391861915588,
0.04950713738799095,
-0.39362454414367676,
-0.27353715896606445,
-0.3008977472782135,
0.8579989075660706,
-0.04960693418979645,
0.05206552520394325,
-0.020374629646539688,
-0.1275566965341568,
-0.0629633367061615,
0.4095287024974823,
0.28125903010368347,
0.9657903909683228,
-0.4061623215675354,
-0.21276883780956268,
0.4601879417896271,
-0.36255717277526855,
-0.19421878457069397,
-0.012230386957526207,
-0.20945078134536743,
0.02674712799489498,
0.38498401641845703,
0.6856757998466492,
0.18043068051338196,
-0.5496609210968018,
0.4600015878677368,
-0.30021733045578003,
-0.12298011779785156,
-0.3932369351387024,
-0.35902929306030273,
0.17146538197994232,
0.35257434844970703,
0.4259404242038727,
-0.33213990926742554,
-0.39266878366470337,
-0.8457645177841187,
0.008683839812874794,
0.3627396523952484,
-0.11472824215888977,
-0.13597384095191956,
0.359870582818985,
0.3632679581642151,
0.15199407935142517,
0.48413097858428955,
0.1144666075706482,
-0.6867026090621948,
0.642230212688446,
0.16172707080841064,
0.48162180185317993,
-0.07618323713541031,
0.4446164667606354,
0.28421613574028015,
0.4086739718914032,
0.07708544284105301,
0.6912399530410767,
-0.1449950486421585,
-1.0874927043914795,
-0.543441891670227,
-0.9349581599235535,
-0.5645594000816345,
0.054688096046447754,
-0.5113608241081238,
0.12360172718763351,
-0.23666079342365265,
-0.14262111485004425,
-0.26765111088752747,
-0.015025148168206215,
-0.9465873837471008,
0.013580930419266224,
0.3878314197063446,
0.9484111070632935,
-1.1126410961151123,
1.1821783781051636,
0.6342195868492126,
-0.4557514786720276,
-0.5741353034973145,
0.07480443269014359,
-0.39106351137161255,
-0.8728399872779846,
0.9171846508979797,
-0.36779603362083435,
0.012837231159210205,
-0.35952332615852356,
-0.45041096210479736,
-1.1360200643539429,
0.8972926139831543,
0.4791591763496399,
-0.37161773443222046,
-0.06092590466141701,
0.04604853689670563,
0.781827986240387,
-0.20343871414661407,
0.2746375799179077,
0.6663945913314819,
0.3709934949874878,
0.14717012643814087,
-1.2229703664779663,
-0.3640943169593811,
0.06937278807163239,
-0.10192769020795822,
-0.05553017929196358,
-0.8735682368278503,
0.9211435317993164,
-0.25963765382766724,
-0.07559017837047577,
0.10827304422855377,
0.6434343457221985,
-0.11330971121788025,
-0.19811506569385529,
0.1198941096663475,
0.5386802554130554,
0.9982763528823853,
-0.3307502269744873,
1.0706396102905273,
-0.38393929600715637,
0.2220662385225296,
1.2730449438095093,
-0.3911280930042267,
1.1465644836425781,
0.5161228179931641,
-0.2868547737598419,
0.8146637082099915,
0.6672364473342896,
0.2526051998138428,
0.31662172079086304,
0.2027166783809662,
-0.15835599601268768,
-0.36684736609458923,
-0.34141746163368225,
-0.33975061774253845,
0.7385943531990051,
0.16915562748908997,
-0.1605638712644577,
-0.28676262497901917,
0.05085506662726402,
0.20901773869991302,
-0.034494925290346146,
-0.22771574556827545,
0.7163370847702026,
-0.044289711862802505,
-0.8174034357070923,
0.6866576671600342,
-0.328364759683609,
0.6184203624725342,
-0.7853184938430786,
0.09583449363708496,
-0.6465446949005127,
-0.3249146044254303,
0.060851551592350006,
-0.8915346264839172,
0.09648392349481583,
0.144359290599823,
-0.2733076214790344,
-0.27412599325180054,
0.47928375005722046,
-0.49498605728149414,
-0.3949127197265625,
0.33508622646331787,
0.8159543871879578,
0.23618429899215698,
0.13118188083171844,
-0.1849985420703888,
-0.0998745784163475,
-0.03563447669148445,
0.1363297700881958,
0.2860584259033203,
0.6009337902069092,
-0.30801641941070557,
0.8024028539657593,
0.591772198677063,
0.3519646227359772,
0.05951990932226181,
0.30023398995399475,
0.7085434198379517,
-0.46369457244873047,
-0.41980433464050293,
-0.33032846450805664,
0.015928000211715698,
0.12076074630022049,
-0.3223947584629059,
0.597077488899231,
0.16191533207893372,
1.1647557020187378,
-0.08872348070144653,
0.8355145454406738,
-0.09358739852905273,
0.625751256942749,
-0.5491034388542175,
0.9386906027793884,
-0.5457409620285034,
0.28498315811157227,
0.12300929427146912,
-0.8278602361679077,
0.033719103783369064,
0.39608678221702576,
-0.774147629737854,
-0.19586633145809174,
0.6288191676139832,
0.5659160017967224,
0.12132696062326431,
0.15437395870685577,
0.20308896899223328,
0.4982888996601105,
-0.009937748312950134,
0.687023937702179,
1.1447149515151978,
-0.04321734234690666,
0.5687453746795654,
-0.4307197034358978,
-0.2148323506116867,
0.23248712718486786,
-0.890079140663147,
-0.9230664372444153,
-0.6144798994064331,
0.08801574259996414,
-0.0031086469534784555,
0.033321406692266464,
0.9990130662918091,
0.5769535899162292,
-0.8675740957260132,
-0.4861890375614166,
0.7830756306648254,
0.3792456388473511,
0.07451225072145462,
-0.15364772081375122,
0.2853826880455017,
-0.3587528169155121,
-0.7678530216217041,
0.29411327838897705,
-0.1379823088645935,
-0.1727764904499054,
-0.3651018440723419,
0.09570448845624924,
-0.3544643521308899,
0.22499778866767883,
0.5296295881271362,
0.47341999411582947,
-0.7904859781265259,
-0.3255743980407715,
-0.09015735983848572,
0.09115426242351532,
0.04801473766565323,
0.6517899036407471,
-0.9184722304344177,
0.4858437180519104,
0.7218019366264343,
0.830949604511261,
0.5678666234016418,
-0.20778430998325348,
0.8291287422180176,
-0.9158703088760376,
-0.004808083642274141,
0.1777620166540146,
0.5446153283119202,
0.3737526535987854,
-0.10413863509893417,
0.39616307616233826,
-0.013794205151498318,
-0.4353691637516022,
-0.41125473380088806,
0.05395864322781563,
-0.5698705911636353,
-0.3716549575328827,
1.165534496307373,
-0.10894596576690674,
-0.32646799087524414,
-0.17892029881477356,
-0.1179017648100853,
-0.09347720444202423,
-0.2502075135707855,
1.1050570011138916,
1.1819279193878174,
0.11808747053146362,
0.062087178230285645,
-0.8158432841300964,
0.5810667872428894,
0.6091972589492798,
-0.5574139356613159,
-0.15782524645328522,
0.3847936987876892,
0.70721036195755,
0.21746206283569336,
0.7357364296913147,
0.04123225808143616,
0.3963939845561981,
-0.5755783915519714,
0.09341537952423096,
0.3658027946949005,
-0.5435282588005066,
-0.36665311455726624,
0.14123445749282837,
0.270577609539032,
0.057125676423311234
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07296v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07296v1
|
Instruct Large Language Models to Drive like Humans
| 2024-06-11T14:24:45 | 2024-06-11T14:24:45 |
Ruijun Zhang, Xianda Guo, Wenzhao Zheng, Chenming Zhang, Kurt Keutzer, Long Chen
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL
|
Motion planning in complex scenarios is the core challenge in autonomous
driving. Conventional methods apply predefined rules or learn from driving data
to plan the future trajectory. Recent methods seek the knowledge preserved in
large language models (LLMs) and apply them in the driving scenarios. Despite
the promising results, it is still unclear whether the LLM learns the
underlying human logic to drive. In this paper, we propose an InstructDriver
method to transform LLM into a motion planner with explicit instruction tuning
to align its behavior with humans. We derive driving instruction data based on
human logic (e.g., do not cause collisions) and traffic rules (e.g., proceed
only when green lights). We then employ an interpretable InstructChain module
to further reason the final planning reflecting the instructions. Our
InstructDriver allows the injection of human rules and learning from driving
data, enabling both interpretability and data scalability. Different from
existing methods that experimented on closed-loop or simulated settings, we
adopt the real-world closed-loop motion planning nuPlan benchmark for better
evaluation. InstructDriver demonstrates the effectiveness of the LLM planner in
a real-world closed-loop setting. Our code is publicly available at
https://github.com/bonbon-rj/InstructDriver.
|
[
-0.17227883636951447,
-0.5811439156532288,
0.8014696836471558,
0.0196610726416111,
-0.1609349399805069,
-0.06554852426052094,
-0.4191339313983917,
-0.3594713807106018,
-0.17304591834545135,
0.6316918134689331,
-0.9254837036132812,
-0.39567798376083374,
0.025734705850481987,
-0.2532772421836853,
-0.29900044202804565,
0.6741788387298584,
-0.10315746068954468,
0.16935038566589355,
-0.13839995861053467,
0.3107703924179077,
-0.4776577949523926,
-0.16755163669586182,
-0.3078811764717102,
-0.5134193897247314,
0.16142289340496063,
0.5436539649963379,
0.7813310027122498,
0.7882826924324036,
0.23568187654018402,
0.27586475014686584,
0.04639042541384697,
0.34721285104751587,
-0.36390841007232666,
-0.1998451203107834,
-0.5459141731262207,
-0.03548145666718483,
-0.2476523518562317,
-0.25442445278167725,
0.4859152138233185,
0.6443191170692444,
-0.4194055199623108,
-0.17383259534835815,
-0.16115522384643555,
0.4051492512226105,
-0.6571416854858398,
0.2940162718296051,
-0.4275166392326355,
0.03325232118368149,
-0.06791816651821136,
-0.2693811357021332,
-0.34792304039001465,
-0.750077486038208,
-0.04654233902692795,
-0.45277899503707886,
-0.008664491586387157,
0.2853212058544159,
0.5567814111709595,
0.45515984296798706,
-0.5273061990737915,
-0.322459876537323,
-1.0791041851043701,
0.5047085881233215,
-0.8384146690368652,
0.3400689363479614,
-0.001344990567304194,
0.5225738286972046,
-0.6385543942451477,
-0.19574543833732605,
-0.9714526534080505,
0.0007824780186638236,
-0.12098121643066406,
0.11355973780155182,
0.21498136222362518,
0.3622029721736908,
0.28197088837623596,
0.0722815990447998,
-0.768831729888916,
0.397175669670105,
-0.3192659020423889,
0.030380044132471085,
0.8506008982658386,
0.5192069411277771,
0.06379369646310806,
0.39970484375953674,
-0.4153116047382355,
-0.3494396507740021,
-0.8087447285652161,
0.2753535509109497,
0.2666388154029846,
0.19629117846488953,
-0.20884084701538086,
0.4972229599952698,
-0.3530891537666321,
0.8077784776687622,
0.23802287876605988,
-0.32057109475135803,
0.19658499956130981,
-0.1112823560833931,
-0.2298445701599121,
0.35864028334617615,
0.8374444842338562,
0.651408851146698,
0.5467472076416016,
-0.36055871844291687,
-0.426963746547699,
-0.046517010778188705,
0.4067237377166748,
-0.7912766337394714,
-0.24134773015975952,
-0.026272304356098175,
0.08570816367864609,
0.08235559612512589,
0.3397402763366699,
-0.8804433941841125,
-0.1933700144290924,
-0.7330730557441711,
0.5097544193267822,
-0.5707637071609497,
-0.12994851171970367,
0.6522406339645386,
0.28345927596092224,
0.8251644372940063,
0.2571885585784912,
-1.2219358682632446,
0.3535267114639282,
0.8945188522338867,
0.5760563015937805,
-0.01642238162457943,
-0.5531916618347168,
-0.5808767676353455,
0.6812355518341064,
-0.38045811653137207,
0.6986470222473145,
-0.23415479063987732,
-0.36092376708984375,
0.18830479681491852,
0.018046727403998375,
-0.10045299679040909,
-0.49567821621894836,
0.38808536529541016,
-0.35500916838645935,
0.07086391746997833,
0.14892517030239105,
-0.7416179776191711,
-0.4737319350242615,
0.03935045376420021,
-0.30440154671669006,
0.3947043716907501,
0.15428464114665985,
-0.08147177845239639,
0.4234677851200104,
-0.963771641254425,
-1.2423219680786133,
0.13357746601104736,
-0.2673293650150299,
-0.3345385789871216,
-0.1904989778995514,
0.25838926434516907,
0.7946988940238953,
-0.050862330943346024,
0.6311988234519958,
0.06880547851324081,
-0.42844703793525696,
0.21496500074863434,
-0.2279144823551178,
0.7233858108520508,
-0.2557770013809204,
-0.4779721200466156,
0.6916239857673645,
-0.47299012541770935,
0.04625771939754486,
-0.10123816132545471,
-0.3929542899131775,
0.13974009454250336,
0.11177698522806168,
-0.13931655883789062,
0.2856025695800781,
-0.03938809409737587,
-0.5387907028198242,
0.2812413275241852,
-0.7498723268508911,
0.46104946732521057,
1.0196032524108887,
0.04670286551117897,
0.6323975324630737,
-0.29567012190818787,
0.687366783618927,
-0.3013533651828766,
0.19881224632263184,
0.053010255098342896,
-0.39943835139274597,
-0.6392678618431091,
0.3425387144088745,
-0.4100514352321625,
0.6732643842697144,
-0.5929539799690247,
0.7086876630783081,
-0.45660659670829773,
-0.2812885642051697,
-0.4509950578212738,
0.03586171939969063,
0.4538489282131195,
0.4660842716693878,
0.34698471426963806,
0.2716394364833832,
-0.18385156989097595,
-0.5766410827636719,
0.026685960590839386,
0.00633156206458807,
-0.12436918169260025,
0.05755849555134773,
0.5060199499130249,
-0.46201205253601074,
0.9047333598136902,
-0.5645363330841064,
-0.17575474083423615,
-0.42382192611694336,
0.08706966042518616,
-0.008741069585084915,
0.6188389658927917,
0.3013363182544708,
-0.6606459021568298,
-0.31721654534339905,
0.18225610256195068,
-0.48075318336486816,
0.09405521303415298,
-0.4835294783115387,
-0.3987329602241516,
0.03927416354417801,
0.6626073718070984,
-0.3649534583091736,
0.5106076598167419,
0.43945345282554626,
-0.3429933190345764,
0.4658632278442383,
-0.5347759127616882,
-0.27096110582351685,
-0.6562703251838684,
-0.30771467089653015,
-0.08279482275247574,
-0.4386610984802246,
-0.31863832473754883,
0.024825263768434525,
0.12630990147590637,
0.030937641859054565,
-0.38046836853027344,
0.3608441650867462,
-0.1907912939786911,
-0.06711214780807495,
-0.3086034953594208,
-0.1266552209854126,
-0.4336279332637787,
0.6267011165618896,
0.10517672449350357,
1.0082494020462036,
0.5158984661102295,
-0.9697699546813965,
0.41088220477104187,
0.3172718286514282,
-0.7477245330810547,
0.298977255821228,
-0.4492107927799225,
0.2044166773557663,
-0.25601333379745483,
0.06416409462690353,
-0.5825565457344055,
-0.5991811752319336,
0.2574734091758728,
0.24922430515289307,
0.38859403133392334,
-0.10062671452760696,
-0.731281578540802,
-0.20578935742378235,
0.2053333967924118,
0.025841768831014633,
0.6847904324531555,
-0.7826586365699768,
0.7373759746551514,
0.5665723085403442,
0.2212279736995697,
0.2627369463443756,
-0.5449283123016357,
-0.046500593423843384,
-0.3656199276447296,
-0.680829644203186,
0.5764537453651428,
-0.346356600522995,
-0.32863175868988037,
-0.320537805557251,
0.2968936264514923,
0.012293746694922447,
0.0013728158082813025,
0.6052674055099487,
0.19026882946491241,
0.022595638409256935,
0.062435876578092575,
0.2750932276248932,
-0.34653785824775696,
0.3805042803287506,
-0.1690552830696106,
0.6869863271713257,
-0.011192905716598034,
-0.24118058383464813,
-0.9202759265899658,
0.20448200404644012,
0.6056991815567017,
-0.3230741322040558,
0.4072052836418152,
0.28892043232917786,
0.0860835388302803,
-0.3479585647583008,
-0.046507254242897034,
-0.4291040003299713,
-0.5632494688034058,
0.2479352504014969,
-0.234634667634964,
-0.5700764656066895,
-0.1402454674243927,
-0.5155097246170044,
0.23169374465942383,
0.04986487701535225,
0.6155102252960205,
-0.375516802072525,
0.9052053093910217,
0.8135039806365967,
0.07852967083454132,
0.4163774847984314,
-0.2144378274679184,
0.02406124211847782,
-0.5492329001426697,
-0.49869289994239807,
0.04762164130806923,
-0.35206639766693115,
-0.3660810887813568,
-0.28551170229911804,
0.5274569988250732,
-0.4555775225162506,
-0.6021801829338074,
0.2654171586036682,
-0.41024652123451233,
0.6616165041923523,
0.47599223256111145,
0.24127909541130066,
-0.04173537343740463,
-0.34141871333122253,
0.14761967957019806,
0.12896376848220825,
-0.6927505135536194,
-0.4438745081424713,
0.6402400135993958,
-0.07699421793222427,
0.9347294569015503,
0.12265635281801224,
0.5394601821899414,
-0.10769476741552353,
0.1641002744436264,
-0.8580990433692932,
0.7857989072799683,
-0.017690429463982582,
-0.28621792793273926,
-0.27429044246673584,
-0.42830055952072144,
-0.7769595980644226,
-0.12565940618515015,
-0.30350765585899353,
-0.5680035352706909,
0.033952053636312485,
0.26852449774742126,
-0.5848438739776611,
0.2849687933921814,
-0.5105688571929932,
0.9537879228591919,
-0.9277217984199524,
-0.22016039490699768,
-0.3593485653400421,
-0.8477531671524048,
0.3123069703578949,
0.11576145142316818,
0.23063720762729645,
-0.1458020806312561,
0.21570464968681335,
0.5890105962753296,
-0.5455896854400635,
0.8733168244361877,
-0.12145238369703293,
-0.05176568776369095,
0.10200849920511246,
0.12569278478622437,
0.643311619758606,
-0.2992686629295349,
-0.0365181639790535,
-0.2134644240140915,
-0.48686179518699646,
-0.012407570146024227,
-0.6948157548904419,
0.48168718814849854,
-0.5189771056175232,
-0.4358459413051605,
-0.14223064482212067,
-0.710722029209137,
-0.0561147965490818,
0.056577764451503754,
0.2268831431865692,
0.3594774007797241,
-0.08911450207233429,
-0.1984499990940094,
0.5818334221839905,
-0.08988181501626968,
0.646702766418457,
0.39973312616348267,
-0.4675569534301758,
-0.19389225542545319,
0.7671056389808655,
-0.20844747126102448,
0.49418821930885315,
0.6760129928588867,
0.5528083443641663,
-0.290802538394928,
-0.5193151831626892,
-0.7480459213256836,
0.13630256056785583,
-0.48629942536354065,
-0.02481519989669323,
-0.3001856207847595,
0.02285761572420597,
-0.24270479381084442,
-0.6032336354255676,
-0.43069249391555786,
-0.08208288252353668,
-0.16019511222839355,
-0.12566642463207245,
0.49666252732276917,
0.8366608023643494,
0.012390274554491043,
0.7404067516326904,
-0.3254493474960327,
0.052154865115880966,
0.44737061858177185,
0.058404043316841125,
-0.1202516257762909,
-0.35469502210617065,
-0.32273170351982117,
0.11388751864433289,
-0.2063712477684021,
-0.4681091904640198,
0.4550531804561615,
0.14749248325824738,
0.40063178539276123,
0.7359579205513,
0.3075661361217499,
1.014450192451477,
-0.6339021325111389,
0.21901023387908936,
0.051012396812438965,
-0.7594219446182251,
0.6512894630432129,
-0.11779157817363739,
0.5491697788238525,
0.731333315372467,
0.33718448877334595,
-0.23528948426246643,
-0.11378591507673264,
-0.10257143527269363,
-0.7903034687042236,
0.5409543514251709,
0.004046111833304167,
-0.0433373898267746,
0.3313370645046234,
0.5979227423667908,
0.15999658405780792,
0.03776867315173149,
-0.5524832606315613,
0.13582132756710052,
0.04153122752904892,
-0.2741902470588684,
-0.055130209773778915,
-0.029179835692048073,
0.1850295066833496,
-0.506956160068512,
0.5804059505462646,
-0.16238820552825928,
-0.07688751071691513,
-0.12811638414859772,
0.04925720766186714,
-0.10429105162620544,
0.08959037810564041,
0.8670641779899597,
0.6777926683425903,
-0.19905833899974823,
0.06019192188978195,
0.02184273861348629,
-0.3458805978298187,
0.2806229591369629,
-0.2756011188030243,
-0.535687267780304,
-0.4476805031299591,
0.259845495223999,
0.5251144766807556,
0.53050297498703,
-1.0239546298980713,
0.3403698205947876,
0.10746566206216812,
-0.00755086075514555,
-0.7100701332092285,
0.7140894532203674,
-0.09693345427513123,
0.3761620819568634,
-0.21226614713668823,
0.03353922814130783,
-0.13976016640663147,
-0.5793458223342896,
-0.013979322277009487,
0.1339104324579239,
-0.6886162161827087,
-0.5118883848190308,
0.8282746076583862,
0.23820729553699493,
-0.5035600066184998,
0.8014988303184509,
-0.6307482719421387,
-0.6149771809577942,
0.30854958295822144,
0.5956436395645142,
0.9006452560424805,
-0.16782428324222565,
-0.13341647386550903,
0.4735199213027954,
0.24432902038097382,
-0.15231281518936157,
0.559151828289032,
0.059460222721099854,
-0.8033353090286255,
-0.7014929056167603,
-0.44033199548721313,
-0.2787879705429077,
-0.19612616300582886,
-0.46915724873542786,
0.20846755802631378,
-0.6756005883216858,
0.30163243412971497,
0.01157492958009243,
-0.4099172055721283,
-0.3938405215740204,
0.07885410636663437,
-0.15222720801830292,
0.5576083660125732,
-0.47841042280197144,
0.9575160145759583,
0.7312853932380676,
-0.32751187682151794,
-0.8181818127632141,
0.3229779601097107,
0.16774402558803558,
-0.49783143401145935,
0.6470940113067627,
0.21701361238956451,
-0.6350652575492859,
-0.07683156430721283,
-0.8552253842353821,
-0.4119943380355835,
1.2000176906585693,
0.44633689522743225,
-0.9043845534324646,
-0.1264064908027649,
0.052506402134895325,
0.1824144423007965,
-0.5366847515106201,
-0.4474714994430542,
0.3936948776245117,
0.5346735119819641,
0.3252502381801605,
-0.7432445287704468,
0.0864546075463295,
0.31325358152389526,
-0.26062723994255066,
0.4523983895778656,
-0.44727298617362976,
0.690987229347229,
-0.5390501618385315,
-0.39724308252334595,
0.14015613496303558,
0.5450779795646667,
-0.012889832258224487,
0.08880040049552917,
0.5656154751777649,
0.4980393946170807,
0.6962920427322388,
0.2076258659362793,
1.0756887197494507,
-0.2591302692890167,
-0.09002473950386047,
1.3785974979400635,
-0.45495712757110596,
0.8023003935813904,
0.28600624203681946,
-0.11872173100709915,
0.6759767532348633,
0.20523160696029663,
0.11916442960500717,
0.7610893249511719,
0.10052761435508728,
-0.28482839465141296,
-0.5930846333503723,
0.050409041345119476,
0.23921732604503632,
0.8689201474189758,
0.28716564178466797,
-0.03415803611278534,
-0.06513109803199768,
0.07440188527107239,
0.2242312878370285,
0.43717172741889954,
-0.43119606375694275,
0.9883586168289185,
-0.28458186984062195,
-0.4864782989025116,
0.20075851678848267,
0.07258972525596619,
0.533648669719696,
-0.4735252559185028,
-0.19058111310005188,
0.1609601378440857,
0.5652735829353333,
-0.1561684012413025,
-1.1006860733032227,
0.3370291590690613,
-0.2715606093406677,
-0.08397545665502548,
-0.41282787919044495,
0.2230985313653946,
-0.44478118419647217,
-0.42756718397140503,
0.1572289764881134,
-0.024323947727680206,
0.27766314148902893,
-0.018816223368048668,
-0.16812089085578918,
-0.31813716888427734,
0.2887917160987854,
0.42232054471969604,
0.14280562102794647,
0.5202934145927429,
-0.048239052295684814,
0.9323477149009705,
0.5511347651481628,
-0.0947631224989891,
-0.046579424291849136,
-0.17387805879116058,
0.8401275277137756,
-1.017100214958191,
-0.6271210312843323,
-0.9952003359794617,
0.5408313274383545,
0.12817126512527466,
-0.3835819363594055,
0.5648725628852844,
0.7947710156440735,
0.9470677971839905,
-0.08924051374197006,
0.4242129325866699,
0.27322131395339966,
0.25763997435569763,
-1.0559937953948975,
0.6118560433387756,
-0.2468721568584442,
0.18166562914848328,
0.03590571880340576,
-0.5680721402168274,
-0.24334265291690826,
0.9010719060897827,
-0.4520975649356842,
-0.25619301199913025,
0.1191401258111,
1.0314881801605225,
-0.34469130635261536,
-0.044733915477991104,
0.3632221817970276,
0.12134523689746857,
0.4587188959121704,
0.7613712549209595,
0.8091283440589905,
0.12167483568191528,
0.36856499314308167,
-0.5795981287956238,
-0.17588622868061066,
-0.25157231092453003,
-0.7912900447845459,
-0.8620600700378418,
-0.38857486844062805,
-0.2686659097671509,
0.08007228374481201,
0.08077318966388702,
1.1721007823944092,
0.972933828830719,
-0.5826055407524109,
-0.6485487222671509,
-0.47522374987602234,
0.18376901745796204,
-0.20748551189899445,
-0.22717295587062836,
0.20365911722183228,
-0.046317532658576965,
-0.5336941480636597,
0.8113438487052917,
0.4660978615283966,
0.2946288287639618,
-0.4943581819534302,
-0.6315538883209229,
-0.138514444231987,
-0.334769606590271,
0.47834137082099915,
0.1736241728067398,
-0.5692868828773499,
-0.21896272897720337,
-0.2902979254722595,
0.04024529457092285,
0.04389588162302971,
0.939120888710022,
-0.8212139010429382,
0.4764030873775482,
0.00876462273299694,
0.320644348859787,
0.5739854574203491,
0.019911155104637146,
0.9060376882553101,
-0.29172483086586,
0.33173704147338867,
0.3534059226512909,
0.24367626011371613,
0.23516085743904114,
-0.3633652925491333,
0.543858528137207,
-0.2966000437736511,
-0.8317172527313232,
-0.18196363747119904,
0.5696130394935608,
-0.9784879088401794,
-0.19099931418895721,
1.0773440599441528,
0.14162062108516693,
-0.4046168923377991,
-0.2077384740114212,
-0.25492435693740845,
-0.05207514762878418,
-0.594379186630249,
0.7119848728179932,
-0.22929224371910095,
-0.417264461517334,
-0.3566834628582001,
-0.5579379796981812,
0.33936139941215515,
-0.23676466941833496,
-0.9479724764823914,
0.16987374424934387,
0.5560618042945862,
-0.10619670897722244,
-0.19415941834449768,
0.08903010189533234,
0.37360066175460815,
0.2914917767047882,
-0.24674884974956512,
0.25138360261917114,
-0.05212097615003586,
-0.2775246500968933,
-0.3165762722492218,
-0.24695450067520142,
-0.1986129879951477,
-0.06781534850597382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07291v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07291v1
|
Joint Learning of Context and Feedback Embeddings in Spoken Dialogue
| 2024-06-11T14:22:37 | 2024-06-11T14:22:37 |
Livia Qian, Gabriel Skantze
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Short feedback responses, such as backchannels, play an important role in
spoken dialogue. So far, most of the modeling of feedback responses has focused
on their timing, often neglecting how their lexical and prosodic form influence
their contextual appropriateness and conversational function. In this paper, we
investigate the possibility of embedding short dialogue contexts and feedback
responses in the same representation space using a contrastive learning
objective. In our evaluation, we primarily focus on how such embeddings can be
used as a context-feedback appropriateness metric and thus for feedback
response ranking in U.S. English dialogues. Our results show that the model
outperforms humans given the same ranking task and that the learned embeddings
carry information about the conversational function of feedback responses.
|
[
-0.3451122045516968,
-0.4548082649707794,
0.6355096697807312,
0.2016124129295349,
-0.29109328985214233,
0.07616283744573593,
-0.5399610996246338,
-0.2667512595653534,
0.45195406675338745,
0.25258132815361023,
-0.3627951443195343,
-0.2951871156692505,
-0.5390128493309021,
0.10560513287782669,
0.02791210450232029,
1.106653094291687,
0.17334239184856415,
0.5613076686859131,
-0.4648279845714569,
-0.5100983381271362,
-0.7059955596923828,
-0.6153954863548279,
-0.5321804881095886,
-0.3137376010417938,
0.7264731526374817,
0.42826950550079346,
0.49642589688301086,
0.0010054707527160645,
0.15620379149913788,
0.3589458763599396,
0.1671648919582367,
-0.276720255613327,
-0.46538397669792175,
0.32156145572662354,
-0.3862152397632599,
-0.49284136295318604,
0.014259075745940208,
0.20216451585292816,
0.8388881683349609,
0.9860793948173523,
-0.2037491798400879,
-0.09563782066106796,
0.7052392363548279,
0.29007595777511597,
-0.6286931037902832,
0.09202072769403458,
-0.0029241577722132206,
0.002660763217136264,
0.2997930347919464,
-0.414305180311203,
-0.4605481028556824,
-0.3079569935798645,
0.5277522802352905,
-0.543239951133728,
0.0007810579263605177,
0.16609705984592438,
0.3722682297229767,
0.19544759392738342,
-0.3075045347213745,
-0.553311288356781,
-0.7294332385063171,
0.9018123149871826,
-0.616516649723053,
0.5952295064926147,
0.16710752248764038,
0.3590875267982483,
0.10123765468597412,
-0.6006211042404175,
-0.3468118906021118,
-0.3216153383255005,
-0.4090571701526642,
0.3528297543525696,
0.1376483291387558,
0.004019127227365971,
-0.01788308471441269,
0.1047012060880661,
-0.14803899824619293,
0.05516272410750389,
-0.3772171139717102,
-0.1756933331489563,
0.36340218782424927,
0.25330159068107605,
-0.0038298601284623146,
-0.17817722260951996,
-0.24613095819950104,
-0.29739880561828613,
-0.48092469573020935,
0.44135573506355286,
0.16602212190628052,
0.5679768919944763,
-0.33966585993766785,
0.1554178148508072,
0.028434645384550095,
0.37135496735572815,
-0.010124564170837402,
-0.19405484199523926,
0.20904850959777832,
-0.26856687664985657,
-0.04251750558614731,
-0.1405995488166809,
0.5111057162284851,
0.5132227540016174,
-0.1503526270389557,
-0.23671816289424896,
-0.2312259078025818,
-0.020173242315649986,
0.3014228641986847,
-0.7102377414703369,
-0.1495593637228012,
-0.03591572865843773,
-0.4960690438747406,
0.01750902272760868,
0.2588112950325012,
-0.613990843296051,
0.01743999309837818,
-0.22454777359962463,
0.437288761138916,
-0.052102647721767426,
0.03495842590928078,
-0.23658961057662964,
-0.21940003335475922,
0.046005431562662125,
0.4501476585865021,
-0.7191591262817383,
0.6777212619781494,
0.5232648253440857,
0.6872721314430237,
-0.0774109736084938,
-0.313618540763855,
-0.714487612247467,
-0.006293291226029396,
-0.22913958132266998,
0.5325934290885925,
-0.8195995688438416,
-0.7803720235824585,
0.15637318789958954,
0.20191892981529236,
-0.024514108896255493,
-0.6148465871810913,
0.22284922003746033,
-0.3497849702835083,
0.45609280467033386,
-0.3871988356113434,
-0.47687384486198425,
-0.20739541947841644,
0.12732134759426117,
-0.5256913304328918,
0.39920082688331604,
0.16042868793010712,
-0.7947939038276672,
0.33594486117362976,
-0.3315311372280121,
-0.3013102412223816,
-0.0069951643235981464,
-0.34809058904647827,
-0.30816930532455444,
0.13800573348999023,
0.1450076699256897,
0.5825899243354797,
-0.08139178156852722,
-0.0275169238448143,
-0.3835829794406891,
-0.7499802112579346,
0.31450265645980835,
-0.21603237092494965,
0.36911460757255554,
0.05808187648653984,
-0.39713427424430847,
-0.0382617749273777,
-0.46288567781448364,
0.006168168969452381,
-0.07510512322187424,
-0.6003849506378174,
-0.6561442017555237,
-0.024082593619823456,
-0.20266538858413696,
0.061300527304410934,
-0.16437102854251862,
-0.6526755094528198,
-0.1493801474571228,
-0.3751351535320282,
0.4960176348686218,
0.5269834399223328,
0.24452699720859528,
0.5886054635047913,
-0.25409701466560364,
0.4442025125026703,
0.19017189741134644,
-0.2882465720176697,
-0.19376510381698608,
-0.2792780101299286,
-0.6479830145835876,
0.05089094489812851,
0.385454922914505,
0.4237489402294159,
-0.5306345224380493,
0.2343079000711441,
-0.21792195737361908,
-0.07754866033792496,
-0.5867640972137451,
0.09837860614061356,
0.8473082184791565,
0.31762373447418213,
0.28025710582733154,
-0.7121650576591492,
-0.45579320192337036,
-0.8683091998100281,
-0.09967417269945145,
-0.24357236921787262,
-0.19159509241580963,
0.8103107213973999,
0.4105893075466156,
-0.02725370042026043,
0.6756648421287537,
-0.3864148259162903,
-0.0924883782863617,
-0.19838428497314453,
0.08134382963180542,
-0.104746013879776,
0.37047499418258667,
0.5433521270751953,
-0.5640689730644226,
-0.2908702492713928,
-0.3741290271282196,
-0.3818430006504059,
-0.02890600450336933,
0.2108808010816574,
0.15221041440963745,
-0.021167634055018425,
0.5913143157958984,
-0.03637951985001564,
0.3108537793159485,
0.6858682036399841,
-0.2369375377893448,
0.11745445430278778,
-0.006376351695507765,
0.4651595950126648,
-1.3125780820846558,
-0.12731380760669708,
-0.3022632598876953,
-0.4715491235256195,
-0.24051648378372192,
-0.11279383301734924,
-0.1319894939661026,
-0.22499242424964905,
-0.5046498775482178,
0.4259554147720337,
-0.2566416263580322,
-0.39928531646728516,
-0.04253854602575302,
0.5610359311103821,
0.07889523357152939,
0.8275159597396851,
0.1337449848651886,
0.8194747567176819,
-0.016913508996367455,
-0.6816509366035461,
0.15839864313602448,
0.13740257918834686,
-0.24281586706638336,
0.7435388565063477,
-0.87333083152771,
0.20665201544761658,
-0.05040915310382843,
0.5879320502281189,
-1.235554575920105,
0.021303975954651833,
0.18472623825073242,
-0.5243384838104248,
0.29221299290657043,
-0.13672344386577606,
0.05145823583006859,
-0.2263241410255432,
-0.36209341883659363,
0.44734352827072144,
0.41694289445877075,
-0.6903353333473206,
0.1894475519657135,
0.44960421323776245,
-0.4731377363204956,
-0.5964267253875732,
-0.5166602730751038,
-0.6314968466758728,
-0.06325977295637131,
-0.2682209312915802,
0.39133918285369873,
-0.016643214970827103,
-0.14710429310798645,
0.11782021820545197,
0.06952793151140213,
0.2603455185890198,
-0.037119537591934204,
0.4940796196460724,
-0.31048285961151123,
-0.12295446544885635,
0.3336902856826782,
-0.23946262896060944,
0.0001309075450990349,
0.05527906492352486,
-0.105042465031147,
0.3847084939479828,
-0.10327048599720001,
-0.4278610944747925,
-0.28371357917785645,
0.6692729592323303,
0.2719608545303345,
0.15871337056159973,
0.5293554663658142,
0.3926088511943817,
-0.13248051702976227,
-0.16405415534973145,
-0.2679614722728729,
-0.5840182900428772,
-0.40504759550094604,
0.4224863350391388,
-0.327605277299881,
-1.3077679872512817,
0.6153512001037598,
-0.04721526801586151,
0.09711065143346786,
0.18780174851417542,
0.5313514471054077,
-0.38991281390190125,
1.044251561164856,
0.6293002367019653,
-0.038839586079120636,
0.5728014707565308,
-0.2781493067741394,
0.25292617082595825,
-1.0485163927078247,
-0.3531043529510498,
-0.703551709651947,
-0.41549578309059143,
-0.6801983714103699,
-0.36340653896331787,
0.22287346422672272,
0.16312812268733978,
-0.06469415873289108,
0.12009524554014206,
-0.14233635365962982,
0.25142037868499756,
0.4339450001716614,
0.29123327136039734,
-0.02834901213645935,
-0.23867183923721313,
-0.6513006091117859,
-0.3509988486766815,
-0.639685869216919,
-0.3526349663734436,
0.624643087387085,
0.45630979537963867,
0.9029718041419983,
0.2647983729839325,
0.9636694192886353,
0.035487428307533264,
0.23324422538280487,
-0.7649887204170227,
0.2712283134460449,
-0.13872812688350677,
-0.031303152441978455,
-0.2085174024105072,
-0.20530010759830475,
-0.9892055988311768,
0.33005282282829285,
0.02108357660472393,
-0.7995867133140564,
0.17072245478630066,
0.19406169652938843,
-0.5944326519966125,
-0.06720215827226639,
-0.7797098755836487,
0.6138218641281128,
0.19051195681095123,
-0.4050593674182892,
-0.5187691450119019,
-0.7499825954437256,
-0.11549249291419983,
0.6187942028045654,
0.191385880112648,
0.1725584864616394,
0.016952835023403168,
0.9597941040992737,
-0.5360385775566101,
1.055883526802063,
-0.46768462657928467,
0.19937528669834137,
0.2870619297027588,
-0.03679491579532623,
0.09365267306566238,
0.5281504988670349,
0.4179162085056305,
-0.2075454592704773,
-0.10039451718330383,
-0.351394385099411,
-1.1178830862045288,
0.8371556997299194,
-0.8503037095069885,
-0.9728793501853943,
-0.17097876965999603,
-0.13606204092502594,
-0.4392445385456085,
-0.27905070781707764,
0.11803705245256424,
0.6904993653297424,
-0.4147120416164398,
0.6358184814453125,
0.47504177689552307,
-0.17178969085216522,
0.5692290663719177,
0.5815231204032898,
-0.16149838268756866,
-0.44809314608573914,
0.6878860592842102,
-0.0931612178683281,
0.24172019958496094,
0.4921324849128723,
0.22184540331363678,
-0.370951771736145,
-0.1582818180322647,
-0.15364442765712738,
0.24765419960021973,
-0.9336118102073669,
-0.09141553193330765,
-0.5513920187950134,
-0.1934814304113388,
-0.29117435216903687,
-0.25948888063430786,
-0.39760226011276245,
-0.4167425334453583,
-0.11075896769762039,
-0.21568180620670319,
-0.09680573642253876,
1.1005107164382935,
-0.17101356387138367,
0.05296008288860321,
-0.8199093341827393,
-0.21734939515590668,
0.811362624168396,
0.40228623151779175,
0.2682723104953766,
-0.4792858958244324,
-0.5812745690345764,
0.06619807332754135,
-0.3903057277202606,
-0.9102699160575867,
0.054270826280117035,
0.24136744439601898,
0.8371240496635437,
0.1879972517490387,
-0.1327233761548996,
0.48279473185539246,
-0.5305541753768921,
1.1821808815002441,
0.05790512263774872,
-0.8244028687477112,
0.683433473110199,
0.14764030277729034,
0.5440835356712341,
0.6348132491111755,
0.5885871052742004,
-0.6396189332008362,
-0.44932156801223755,
-0.48158207535743713,
-0.7022499442100525,
0.4833569824695587,
-0.04396966099739075,
0.37727823853492737,
-0.1753995418548584,
0.11409872025251389,
0.13167713582515717,
0.2219846397638321,
-0.556995153427124,
-0.010326200164854527,
-0.3341100215911865,
0.27369949221611023,
-0.3707558810710907,
-0.2987044155597687,
-0.3856194317340851,
-0.18251805007457733,
0.3951733708381653,
-0.21094053983688354,
0.6254744529724121,
0.3371294140815735,
-0.24810262024402618,
0.10862824320793152,
0.5089224576950073,
0.7259185314178467,
0.4130178391933441,
-0.25256991386413574,
-0.01677451841533184,
0.26206305623054504,
-0.25302740931510925,
0.14177991449832916,
-0.14334215223789215,
0.3027299642562866,
0.14737828075885773,
0.5231093764305115,
0.817723274230957,
0.9279268383979797,
-0.25902995467185974,
0.8088240027427673,
-0.2722037732601166,
0.12077800929546356,
-0.07758575677871704,
0.008657151833176613,
0.08704126626253128,
0.42459943890571594,
0.1654229760169983,
-0.0690055638551712,
0.3587675392627716,
-0.7579057812690735,
0.32899633049964905,
0.3641800582408905,
-0.6659492254257202,
-0.3955085873603821,
0.2822636663913727,
0.7338688373565674,
-0.45401886105537415,
0.5007451176643372,
-0.0008003102266229689,
-0.9095678925514221,
0.2989450991153717,
0.6666334271430969,
0.7497031688690186,
-0.3495786786079407,
0.10428955405950546,
0.47263002395629883,
-0.3376038670539856,
0.5133568644523621,
0.25073909759521484,
-0.7036020159721375,
-0.6017236113548279,
-0.12366588413715363,
-0.5030097365379333,
-0.6243128180503845,
-0.1693774312734604,
-1.0258350372314453,
-0.021960750222206116,
-0.5793977379798889,
-0.2897011935710907,
-0.09771867096424103,
0.13298866152763367,
-0.8921621441841125,
0.3065595328807831,
-0.12904030084609985,
0.4116544723510742,
-0.8480374813079834,
0.565723717212677,
0.7162132263183594,
-0.4519667327404022,
-1.0079623460769653,
0.25533297657966614,
-0.019914306700229645,
-0.6347821354866028,
0.767189621925354,
0.3592779040336609,
-0.5352770090103149,
-0.35207659006118774,
-0.34717226028442383,
-0.7054272890090942,
1.0301079750061035,
0.13063202798366547,
-0.6601016521453857,
0.05449859797954559,
-0.36961469054222107,
0.6813077330589294,
-0.785767138004303,
0.5266970992088318,
0.5138231515884399,
-0.24396175146102905,
-0.03540525212883949,
-0.9244824051856995,
0.054656945168972015,
-0.28624510765075684,
0.3889344334602356,
0.02789817377924919,
-0.8639144897460938,
0.5412260293960571,
-0.2087249904870987,
-0.2425822764635086,
0.12887895107269287,
0.5148239135742188,
0.27410566806793213,
0.08248195052146912,
0.5372266173362732,
0.5817158222198486,
0.31192219257354736,
-0.23122800886631012,
1.2082270383834839,
-0.15907135605812073,
0.19900451600551605,
1.2053793668746948,
0.04057556763291359,
1.271855115890503,
0.6467651724815369,
-0.21944932639598846,
1.0911331176757812,
0.5250752568244934,
0.48631659150123596,
1.0761961936950684,
0.2905330955982208,
-0.025174016132950783,
0.043020639568567276,
-0.17294219136238098,
-0.5097254514694214,
0.47974351048469543,
0.6582011580467224,
-0.5076646208763123,
0.05729788914322853,
0.15373319387435913,
-0.2627076506614685,
0.22515858709812164,
-0.10379872471094131,
1.0000444650650024,
0.30266642570495605,
-0.9730269908905029,
0.4324585795402527,
-0.16119955480098724,
0.7396736145019531,
-0.30065229535102844,
-0.35087040066719055,
-0.3948621451854706,
0.002536891493946314,
-0.1269308477640152,
-0.7971355319023132,
0.17449359595775604,
-0.48793038725852966,
-0.28138282895088196,
-0.18566927313804626,
0.20124953985214233,
-0.6364774107933044,
0.20291075110435486,
0.7296270132064819,
0.23277734220027924,
0.005892208311706781,
0.7212144732475281,
-0.4024517834186554,
0.016217254102230072,
-0.1569540947675705,
-0.24015970528125763,
0.28002625703811646,
-0.00701905507594347,
0.059436652809381485,
0.44528958201408386,
0.20145735144615173,
-0.02507837302982807,
-0.22040313482284546,
0.4870600700378418,
0.8532211780548096,
-0.6338329315185547,
-0.989976704120636,
-0.42123711109161377,
0.582443118095398,
-0.09620679169893265,
-0.3591201901435852,
0.4447779953479767,
0.14129026234149933,
1.1609686613082886,
-0.026434535160660744,
0.600705087184906,
0.2475033849477768,
0.9374477863311768,
-0.6635313034057617,
0.34796223044395447,
-0.5591557621955872,
0.3258497416973114,
-0.3626612722873688,
-1.1361382007598877,
-0.03336058184504509,
0.6978908777236938,
-0.3286421000957489,
0.4010891616344452,
0.8825250864028931,
0.667148232460022,
0.0588226355612278,
0.14073795080184937,
0.5291947722434998,
0.0711078941822052,
0.10006580501794815,
0.7822064757347107,
1.0231032371520996,
-0.2950206995010376,
0.47903311252593994,
-0.37257707118988037,
-0.05983328819274902,
-0.41021010279655457,
-0.6241579055786133,
-1.0097180604934692,
-0.869734525680542,
-0.06728961318731308,
-0.400826632976532,
0.3272685706615448,
1.0056496858596802,
0.9756792187690735,
-1.0237675905227661,
-0.17533181607723236,
0.37544935941696167,
0.1028270423412323,
-0.011585298925638199,
-0.27204254269599915,
0.18951502442359924,
-0.39479655027389526,
-0.8642954230308533,
0.40011730790138245,
0.4004228413105011,
0.11479754000902176,
-0.33793461322784424,
-0.5427578687667847,
0.12476083636283875,
-0.03822270780801773,
0.44929713010787964,
0.25725042819976807,
-1.0228623151779175,
-0.7504976391792297,
-0.2686425447463989,
-0.3932746946811676,
0.006979167927056551,
1.2388386726379395,
-0.9298397302627563,
0.5329804420471191,
0.4679120182991028,
0.6113000512123108,
0.4515618085861206,
-0.05859195068478584,
1.0695531368255615,
-1.2805815935134888,
0.39574652910232544,
0.3877776265144348,
0.495398610830307,
0.687180757522583,
-0.21499252319335938,
0.2979074716567993,
0.13395798206329346,
-0.6388726830482483,
-0.4963817894458771,
0.18946200609207153,
-0.5521867275238037,
-0.17674095928668976,
0.7826911807060242,
-0.6533968448638916,
0.02828180231153965,
-0.004779617767781019,
-0.1607954353094101,
0.28185945749282837,
-0.5351694226264954,
0.49371233582496643,
0.7875600457191467,
-0.08640187233686447,
-0.41887205839157104,
0.00866946205496788,
0.6192336082458496,
0.7440903186798096,
-0.40928277373313904,
-0.5108754634857178,
0.3396570384502411,
0.4031296670436859,
0.44260337948799133,
0.6329790353775024,
0.08008160442113876,
0.5974895358085632,
0.1375674158334732,
-0.5724154114723206,
0.33736592531204224,
-0.5695701241493225,
-0.5395553708076477,
0.10680095851421356,
0.27867648005485535,
-0.29670509696006775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07289v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07289v1
|
Can We Achieve High-quality Direct Speech-to-Speech Translation without Parallel Speech Data?
| 2024-06-11T14:17:12 | 2024-06-11T14:17:12 |
Qingkai Fang, Shaolei Zhang, Zhengrui Ma, Min Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS, I.2.7
|
Recently proposed two-pass direct speech-to-speech translation (S2ST) models
decompose the task into speech-to-text translation (S2TT) and text-to-speech
(TTS) within an end-to-end model, yielding promising results. However, the
training of these models still relies on parallel speech data, which is
extremely challenging to collect. In contrast, S2TT and TTS have accumulated a
large amount of data and pretrained models, which have not been fully utilized
in the development of S2ST models. Inspired by this, in this paper, we first
introduce a composite S2ST model named ComSpeech, which can seamlessly
integrate any pretrained S2TT and TTS models into a direct S2ST model.
Furthermore, to eliminate the reliance on parallel speech data, we propose a
novel training method ComSpeech-ZS that solely utilizes S2TT and TTS data. It
aligns representations in the latent space through contrastive learning,
enabling the speech synthesis capability learned from the TTS data to
generalize to S2ST in a zero-shot manner. Experimental results on the CVSS
dataset show that when the parallel speech data is available, ComSpeech
surpasses previous two-pass models like UnitY and Translatotron 2 in both
translation quality and decoding speed. When there is no parallel speech data,
ComSpeech-ZS lags behind \name by only 0.7 ASR-BLEU and outperforms the
cascaded models.
|
[
-0.16581524908542633,
-0.39893838763237,
0.3779972791671753,
0.09891140460968018,
-0.6538535952568054,
0.1354053020477295,
-0.41598594188690186,
-0.110231913626194,
0.06436982750892639,
0.42553481459617615,
-0.7386648654937744,
-0.4121089279651642,
-0.8195011019706726,
-0.047338761389255524,
-0.5280786752700806,
0.8494613766670227,
0.08835065364837646,
0.500647783279419,
-0.0628008171916008,
-0.1196988970041275,
-0.32733944058418274,
-0.5028269290924072,
-0.5705507397651672,
-0.35253477096557617,
0.23555713891983032,
0.5554047226905823,
0.46190759539604187,
0.7862874269485474,
0.3477839231491089,
0.16620156168937683,
-0.16492106020450592,
0.07144279778003693,
-0.5148729681968689,
-0.004096840973943472,
-0.26431792974472046,
-0.4341703951358795,
-0.26443251967430115,
0.01689830794930458,
0.7869834899902344,
0.9169520139694214,
-0.23836107552051544,
-0.03913190960884094,
0.24670098721981049,
0.46207815408706665,
-0.23706279695034027,
0.11035260558128357,
-0.5596041679382324,
0.09948273748159409,
-0.3813855051994324,
0.03417299687862396,
-0.4773779809474945,
-0.271605908870697,
0.12409749627113342,
-0.3587207496166229,
0.36389169096946716,
-0.22410035133361816,
0.530585527420044,
0.35893377661705017,
-0.48026177287101746,
0.05665619298815727,
-0.8392099738121033,
0.8117114901542664,
-0.46356135606765747,
0.7496148347854614,
0.11384260654449463,
0.5044280886650085,
0.02247186005115509,
-0.8464123010635376,
-0.5592455267906189,
-0.18098211288452148,
0.0705457329750061,
0.434739351272583,
-0.1873379945755005,
-0.14371472597122192,
0.15072938799858093,
0.2669063210487366,
-0.8858503103256226,
0.23079964518547058,
-0.21995672583580017,
0.05301088094711304,
0.23244325816631317,
0.26680630445480347,
0.04176529869437218,
-0.051644764840602875,
-0.8164669275283813,
-0.3193381130695343,
-0.7492043972015381,
0.12938357889652252,
-0.10282453149557114,
0.49000293016433716,
-0.5296779274940491,
0.42386364936828613,
-0.17670325934886932,
0.39927536249160767,
0.01026204414665699,
0.14784079790115356,
0.3183134198188782,
-0.5804317593574524,
-0.05787793546915054,
-0.04825723171234131,
0.8889977335929871,
-0.044422294944524765,
0.1403566151857376,
-0.4526166319847107,
0.009500224143266678,
0.39802634716033936,
-0.15791703760623932,
-0.7431702613830566,
0.20153607428073883,
0.13620494306087494,
-0.16478101909160614,
0.11756531149148941,
-0.10810612142086029,
-0.49172669649124146,
-0.04993109405040741,
-0.6033445000648499,
0.20909136533737183,
-0.25035780668258667,
-0.3140878975391388,
-0.040878575295209885,
-0.11241337656974792,
0.09064988046884537,
0.3230930268764496,
-0.6501184701919556,
0.709467351436615,
0.5069505572319031,
0.7631589770317078,
-0.5388170480728149,
-0.46371614933013916,
-0.716054379940033,
0.36353951692581177,
-0.461099773645401,
0.8150587677955627,
-0.2264474779367447,
-0.381780743598938,
-0.22915831208229065,
-0.2811587452888489,
-0.1315244883298874,
-0.5092428922653198,
0.5693067312240601,
-0.03854236379265785,
-0.0685795396566391,
-0.2034524381160736,
-0.5230404734611511,
0.15683645009994507,
-0.3590274155139923,
-0.37541425228118896,
0.772778332233429,
-0.06055578216910362,
-0.6369847059249878,
-0.14887051284313202,
-0.1343526691198349,
-0.5491578578948975,
-0.17566953599452972,
-0.4838191866874695,
-0.3078662157058716,
0.223791241645813,
0.2809016704559326,
0.2774602174758911,
-0.7156984210014343,
0.4260493516921997,
-0.09740299731492996,
-0.5111668705940247,
0.03798261284828186,
-0.40037164092063904,
0.7569124698638916,
0.26312604546546936,
-0.4438726305961609,
-0.16347789764404297,
-0.6586847901344299,
-0.21666599810123444,
0.1813419908285141,
-0.10147815942764282,
0.08326084166765213,
0.03746692091226578,
0.021300183609128,
0.38608217239379883,
0.08047302812337875,
-0.6621886491775513,
-0.3084862530231476,
-0.42026516795158386,
0.3473533093929291,
0.5412043333053589,
-0.4544292986392975,
0.5205821990966797,
-0.15201829373836517,
0.1886906772851944,
0.1458430141210556,
-0.14995454251766205,
-0.15059104561805725,
-0.3079221248626709,
-0.9065282940864563,
-0.30586230754852295,
0.3064694404602051,
0.719257652759552,
-0.7449110746383667,
0.4600316882133484,
-0.7258737087249756,
-0.66080641746521,
-0.25200989842414856,
-0.31054383516311646,
0.33034709095954895,
0.7606388926506042,
0.5006102919578552,
-0.33113524317741394,
-0.4366002082824707,
-0.7105035185813904,
-0.19979849457740784,
0.14708426594734192,
-0.2610265016555786,
0.11443047225475311,
0.16072268784046173,
0.19791311025619507,
0.6560599207878113,
-0.3187349736690521,
-0.2929930090904236,
-0.4246520698070526,
0.09727712720632553,
0.06559767574071884,
0.6706963777542114,
0.2209615707397461,
-0.41772451996803284,
-0.5727784037590027,
-0.02385113388299942,
-0.796755850315094,
-0.010210266336798668,
0.042479258030653,
0.03423057124018669,
-0.23942048847675323,
0.4926711916923523,
-0.8081701993942261,
0.4426477551460266,
0.5986993908882141,
-0.015969354659318924,
0.27705419063568115,
-0.08249314874410629,
-0.01602838560938835,
-1.0284936428070068,
0.23356184363365173,
-0.09187901020050049,
-0.4223092198371887,
-0.9427031874656677,
-0.015092284418642521,
0.06673633307218552,
-0.6466766595840454,
-0.6117720603942871,
0.44147011637687683,
-0.2927972376346588,
-0.3261435627937317,
-0.2755817472934723,
0.2126905620098114,
-0.056235626339912415,
0.5804663896560669,
0.4514143466949463,
0.9682790637016296,
0.6456692218780518,
-0.3542960286140442,
0.2669273912906647,
0.7223020792007446,
-0.3211277723312378,
0.5504043102264404,
-0.7122195959091187,
0.36198553442955017,
-0.04212823510169983,
0.5931496024131775,
-0.8063172101974487,
-0.07108187675476074,
0.2710005044937134,
-0.6375827193260193,
0.24588638544082642,
0.1538413166999817,
-0.47282421588897705,
-0.14871348440647125,
0.052987515926361084,
0.26460057497024536,
0.7975207567214966,
-0.5638094544410706,
0.3777073919773102,
0.12833337485790253,
-0.605229914188385,
-0.2999749183654785,
-0.9790070652961731,
0.1576937437057495,
0.1711619347333908,
-0.6502723693847656,
0.5636919140815735,
0.12572386860847473,
0.4138265550136566,
-0.15150848031044006,
-0.33248937129974365,
-0.37155085802078247,
-0.3867046535015106,
-0.004228998441249132,
-0.043418921530246735,
-0.11137013882398605,
-0.08951708674430847,
0.20555515587329865,
-0.3832830488681793,
-0.33577960729599,
-0.15071140229701996,
0.5502433180809021,
0.3120308518409729,
-0.2411166876554489,
-1.0482474565505981,
0.8005994558334351,
0.5398939847946167,
-0.37999096512794495,
0.4366939961910248,
0.39065808057785034,
-0.20522169768810272,
-0.21662582457065582,
-0.4393323063850403,
-0.22494195401668549,
-0.41836604475975037,
0.43122851848602295,
-0.3834865987300873,
-0.7157194018363953,
0.240509033203125,
-0.16330459713935852,
-0.28722119331359863,
0.22875744104385376,
0.43752795457839966,
-0.042539291083812714,
0.9208048582077026,
0.3029506206512451,
0.2939024865627289,
0.5764351487159729,
-0.10978744924068451,
0.09087953716516495,
-0.6610835194587708,
-0.3625626564025879,
-0.640765905380249,
0.03829953446984291,
-0.4168456196784973,
-0.6405376195907593,
0.4946601688861847,
-0.048824891448020935,
-0.3556082546710968,
0.6835504770278931,
-0.23617549240589142,
0.11945190280675888,
0.6745930314064026,
0.4456847310066223,
0.17648008465766907,
0.5981689691543579,
0.06085493043065071,
-0.22467483580112457,
-0.759454607963562,
-0.16063642501831055,
0.9429126977920532,
0.2416805475950241,
0.5559284687042236,
-0.13513970375061035,
0.6031988859176636,
-0.03400725871324539,
-0.2428501546382904,
-0.5071242451667786,
0.5593259930610657,
-0.8537308573722839,
-0.13372758030891418,
-0.15644289553165436,
-0.5528338551521301,
-0.7963857650756836,
0.27745121717453003,
0.17094624042510986,
-0.3384162485599518,
0.21707579493522644,
0.07463828474283218,
-0.34724244475364685,
0.006227229256182909,
-0.5803629755973816,
0.5410894751548767,
-0.06535957753658295,
-0.47233352065086365,
-0.5113628506660461,
-0.8149935007095337,
-0.023347986862063408,
-0.06801211833953857,
0.15506738424301147,
-0.05457969382405281,
0.0429656058549881,
0.7305946946144104,
-0.483254611492157,
0.6528350114822388,
-0.2117728441953659,
0.12034447491168976,
0.32545799016952515,
-0.013706974685192108,
0.7517811059951782,
-0.3033525049686432,
-0.07286473363637924,
0.5264126062393188,
-0.32311388850212097,
-0.49356213212013245,
-0.5868597030639648,
0.618537425994873,
-0.7893245220184326,
-0.5342425107955933,
-0.37815526127815247,
-0.3880290687084198,
-0.5027592778205872,
0.059782952070236206,
0.38361993432044983,
0.3691330850124359,
-0.06747569143772125,
0.21934592723846436,
0.4573874771595001,
-0.0819801464676857,
0.28172338008880615,
0.4197462797164917,
0.5378416180610657,
-0.7640359401702881,
0.9908350110054016,
0.19007545709609985,
0.35243186354637146,
0.2312847375869751,
0.2084793597459793,
-0.5401543378829956,
-0.6337825655937195,
-0.3756372034549713,
0.4053208827972412,
-0.5024768114089966,
-0.1389477699995041,
-0.5811053514480591,
-0.32025212049484253,
-0.5664280652999878,
0.1166645884513855,
-0.7584367394447327,
-0.41048625111579895,
-0.31277328729629517,
0.070057213306427,
-0.1029236689209938,
0.40990149974823,
-0.3271997570991516,
0.6997934579849243,
-0.8271349668502808,
0.623003363609314,
0.2802904546260834,
0.12275602668523788,
-0.16969454288482666,
-0.7466670274734497,
-0.2686309516429901,
0.13264498114585876,
-0.11394188553094864,
-0.7131458520889282,
0.2685573995113373,
0.17400531470775604,
0.40056112408638,
-0.025157270953059196,
-0.12111232429742813,
0.7509734034538269,
-0.872378408908844,
0.8717391490936279,
0.624563455581665,
-1.0846326351165771,
0.5587993860244751,
-0.4574894607067108,
0.2092416137456894,
0.44973835349082947,
0.1213994100689888,
-0.4487956166267395,
-0.13902083039283752,
-0.32627686858177185,
-0.5929623246192932,
1.0799076557159424,
0.6727200150489807,
0.18496818840503693,
0.19193831086158752,
0.15657834708690643,
0.28802424669265747,
0.30686357617378235,
-0.4665653705596924,
-0.2294655591249466,
-0.41834136843681335,
-0.3556258976459503,
-0.28084397315979004,
-0.15854434669017792,
0.17279191315174103,
-0.2712033689022064,
0.396130234003067,
0.3841608464717865,
0.5053120255470276,
0.12841032445430756,
0.03994297608733177,
-0.006739649455994368,
0.12262412160634995,
0.3914000689983368,
0.14213964343070984,
-0.11651423573493958,
0.10144278407096863,
-0.05877065286040306,
-0.2846418619155884,
0.4646007716655731,
0.27243536710739136,
-0.03721766918897629,
0.21745255589485168,
0.07484450936317444,
1.120152473449707,
0.07428945600986481,
-0.39214518666267395,
0.9050190448760986,
0.22531627118587494,
-0.12912622094154358,
-0.19637052714824677,
-0.1675722599029541,
0.06377561390399933,
0.15930944681167603,
0.12896743416786194,
0.25249552726745605,
-0.055361319333314896,
-0.13860388100147247,
0.39743471145629883,
-0.018131643533706665,
-0.32615503668785095,
-0.467089980840683,
0.8569459915161133,
0.4206481873989105,
-0.03795094043016434,
0.4877364933490753,
0.26707330346107483,
-0.08976153284311295,
0.40195488929748535,
0.6095615029335022,
0.8921271562576294,
-0.6726365685462952,
0.08042411506175995,
0.3255203068256378,
0.020550940185785294,
-0.5227383375167847,
0.11577419191598892,
-0.2131533920764923,
-0.2360425591468811,
-0.47921448945999146,
-0.405113160610199,
-0.4547683894634247,
0.08906292915344238,
-0.6242980360984802,
0.47941577434539795,
-0.3186178207397461,
0.0353158563375473,
-0.1387745440006256,
-0.463870644569397,
-0.6928216218948364,
0.4853900969028473,
0.30286625027656555,
0.8666161298751831,
-0.8894715905189514,
1.0876507759094238,
0.16294614970684052,
-0.39712706208229065,
-0.613689661026001,
0.15239185094833374,
-0.27819377183914185,
-0.72929847240448,
0.784425675868988,
0.054943107068538666,
-0.29456791281700134,
0.49293336272239685,
-0.33078449964523315,
-0.9254559874534607,
0.8056257367134094,
0.8915461897850037,
-0.7825330495834351,
-0.23531153798103333,
0.6562893390655518,
0.39395013451576233,
-0.19022062420845032,
0.0815342366695404,
0.4600287973880768,
0.09786028414964676,
0.33514443039894104,
-0.9744012355804443,
-0.15850897133350372,
0.07200543582439423,
0.11719521880149841,
-0.278560996055603,
-0.8498241305351257,
1.0113043785095215,
0.21865251660346985,
-0.38014498353004456,
0.19991366565227509,
0.5753198862075806,
0.03960966691374779,
0.09586317837238312,
0.22056233882904053,
0.7000657916069031,
0.3407634496688843,
-0.14582084119319916,
0.8000621199607849,
0.010021248832345009,
0.3741891086101532,
1.3917882442474365,
-0.4128260016441345,
1.1012945175170898,
0.4825471341609955,
-0.21644601225852966,
0.2511983811855316,
0.33441418409347534,
0.10411690175533295,
0.9366099238395691,
-0.020416567102074623,
-0.36312732100486755,
-0.5713927745819092,
-0.28893670439720154,
-0.5448616147041321,
0.7202604413032532,
0.29469025135040283,
-0.07629570364952087,
-0.5835269093513489,
0.15437544882297516,
-0.21998558938503265,
0.3459911048412323,
0.02176113985478878,
0.5036768317222595,
0.3615516722202301,
-0.5384323596954346,
0.8055081963539124,
-0.11809884011745453,
0.48816803097724915,
-0.7748628854751587,
0.15068675577640533,
-0.5652084350585938,
0.10101592540740967,
0.11980201303958893,
-0.4981689155101776,
0.411889910697937,
0.17342956364154816,
0.028314465656876564,
-0.17562676966190338,
0.21992139518260956,
-0.5792842507362366,
-0.30368855595588684,
0.32945701479911804,
0.6997650861740112,
0.1471642702817917,
-0.18864862620830536,
-0.44622528553009033,
0.1675540655851364,
-0.03260178864002228,
-0.1061386987566948,
0.25151821970939636,
0.16834817826747894,
0.21070505678653717,
0.39924976229667664,
0.5980277061462402,
0.24483376741409302,
-0.06511693447828293,
-0.06922827661037445,
0.7101451754570007,
-0.6619880795478821,
-0.802491307258606,
-0.6246747374534607,
0.4697504937648773,
-0.014663033187389374,
0.15349723398685455,
0.5434181094169617,
0.5929331183433533,
0.8204427361488342,
-0.0730782225728035,
1.0011100769042969,
0.30140942335128784,
1.046515703201294,
-0.3540917932987213,
0.4683411419391632,
-0.4575158655643463,
-0.04282045736908913,
-0.005475588608533144,
-0.7252004146575928,
-0.25299641489982605,
0.36150309443473816,
-0.09469533711671829,
-0.2910025417804718,
0.849343478679657,
0.6696066856384277,
-0.22004403173923492,
0.004900163505226374,
0.4704398810863495,
0.04706161469221115,
0.1566839963197708,
0.7435387372970581,
0.7152546048164368,
-0.7021979093551636,
0.748094916343689,
-0.11532524228096008,
-0.29416608810424805,
-0.006314403377473354,
-0.40399011969566345,
-0.7448530793190002,
-0.43567124009132385,
-0.3139107823371887,
-0.19971291720867157,
0.25341665744781494,
0.7071540951728821,
0.7292409539222717,
-0.8282871246337891,
-0.5555972456932068,
-0.5998257398605347,
-0.37876999378204346,
-0.21164479851722717,
-0.019969459623098373,
0.4911196827888489,
-0.35572952032089233,
-0.9871730804443359,
0.862321138381958,
0.15312711894512177,
0.455541729927063,
0.2642616033554077,
-0.1075468435883522,
0.14217904210090637,
0.09994376450777054,
0.4409917891025543,
0.14305661618709564,
-0.6625086069107056,
0.029539987444877625,
-0.08133822679519653,
-0.17718559503555298,
0.38384655117988586,
0.7839330434799194,
-0.7225186228752136,
0.38451698422431946,
0.44014981389045715,
0.7440230846405029,
0.8467016220092773,
-0.13392332196235657,
0.5928868651390076,
-0.7688257098197937,
0.6543523669242859,
0.06972629576921463,
0.011502500623464584,
0.31157809495925903,
-0.04559745267033577,
0.2699121832847595,
0.6138474345207214,
-0.20939145982265472,
-0.7166265249252319,
0.3479870557785034,
-1.1496106386184692,
-0.15557187795639038,
1.097644329071045,
-0.28137391805648804,
0.0680769681930542,
0.16256994009017944,
-0.11583476513624191,
0.7806271910667419,
-0.41809582710266113,
0.343796044588089,
0.236504465341568,
-0.23018300533294678,
-0.1534544825553894,
-0.42272427678108215,
0.4152781069278717,
0.7452743649482727,
-0.6268969774246216,
0.3051474690437317,
0.39969828724861145,
0.3121557831764221,
-0.32435140013694763,
0.5080245733261108,
-0.1901138722896576,
0.3059979975223541,
0.4305862784385681,
-0.15218326449394226,
-0.2024940550327301,
-0.28944408893585205,
-0.383523553609848,
0.18938815593719482,
-0.29642996191978455,
-0.5565890073776245
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07288v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07288v1
|
Fine-tuning with HED-IT: The impact of human post-editing for dialogical language models
| 2024-06-11T14:16:14 | 2024-06-11T14:16:14 |
Daniela Occhipinti, Michele Marchi, Irene Mondella, Huiyuan Lai, Felice Dell'Orletta, Malvina Nissim, Marco Guerini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automatic methods for generating and gathering linguistic data have proven
effective for fine-tuning Language Models (LMs) in languages less resourced
than English. Still, while there has been emphasis on data quantity, less
attention has been given to its quality. In this work, we investigate the
impact of human intervention on machine-generated data when fine-tuning
dialogical models. In particular, we study (1) whether post-edited dialogues
exhibit higher perceived quality compared to the originals that were
automatically generated; (2) whether fine-tuning with post-edited dialogues
results in noticeable differences in the generated outputs; and (3) whether
post-edited dialogues influence the outcomes when considering the parameter
size of the LMs. To this end we created HED-IT, a large-scale dataset where
machine-generated dialogues are paired with the version post-edited by humans.
Using both the edited and unedited portions of HED-IT, we fine-tuned three
different sizes of an LM. Results from both human and automatic evaluation show
that the different quality of training data is clearly perceived and it has an
impact also on the models trained on such data. Additionally, our findings
indicate that larger models are less sensitive to data quality, whereas this
has a crucial impact on smaller models. These results enhance our comprehension
of the impact of human intervention on training data in the development of
high-quality LMs.
|
[
-0.5777607560157776,
-0.7193988561630249,
0.24115623533725739,
-0.35889220237731934,
-0.26902273297309875,
0.013707098551094532,
-0.5292174816131592,
-0.373005747795105,
-0.07868585735559464,
0.667620062828064,
-0.4070109724998474,
-0.4445717930793762,
-0.3490076959133148,
0.23187999427318573,
-0.12551279366016388,
1.010483980178833,
0.0894450768828392,
0.1705961972475052,
0.012722089886665344,
-0.10855855792760849,
-0.5765729546546936,
-0.650328516960144,
-0.6327317953109741,
-0.3202248513698578,
0.5385323166847229,
0.6212713718414307,
1.1353875398635864,
0.962474524974823,
0.5731425285339355,
0.3284316062927246,
-0.1804911345243454,
0.19673801958560944,
-0.7228769063949585,
-0.24197906255722046,
-0.4083274304866791,
-0.39247116446495056,
-0.4964352250099182,
0.17130346596240997,
0.7626590132713318,
0.9131459593772888,
-0.056894365698099136,
0.2382308840751648,
0.30914658308029175,
0.7737590074539185,
-0.3831843435764313,
0.1733219027519226,
-0.7736310362815857,
-0.16142819821834564,
-0.14475803077220917,
-0.47958070039749146,
-0.27998510003089905,
-0.09608887135982513,
0.15497708320617676,
-0.43429818749427795,
0.3944534659385681,
0.06373368948698044,
1.0480152368545532,
0.5941792130470276,
-0.20840181410312653,
-0.16046512126922607,
-0.8861777186393738,
0.6942244172096252,
-0.9692375063896179,
0.32848742604255676,
0.7413542866706848,
-0.016587214544415474,
-0.34672096371650696,
-0.21104241907596588,
-0.43197762966156006,
-0.1214856505393982,
-0.040684301406145096,
-0.20023076236248016,
0.11859943717718124,
0.2488052248954773,
0.5083076357841492,
0.38579535484313965,
-0.2638823390007019,
0.43930622935295105,
-0.6807332634925842,
-0.25016868114471436,
0.9629104733467102,
0.49000483751296997,
0.11751517653465271,
-0.3055078983306885,
0.4124976396560669,
-0.06254418194293976,
-0.8320701718330383,
0.10526113212108612,
0.6279106736183167,
0.4506547152996063,
0.19402767717838287,
0.706657350063324,
-0.4790343642234802,
0.7686923146247864,
0.17894737422466278,
-0.019829725846648216,
-0.0455339141190052,
-0.6332623958587646,
-0.18161633610725403,
-0.11093252152204514,
0.9102391004562378,
0.6013948321342468,
0.7467649579048157,
0.0842149555683136,
-0.3368806540966034,
0.07168521732091904,
0.43976348638534546,
-0.9244170188903809,
-0.375741183757782,
-0.11941418796777725,
-0.4362082779407501,
-0.34056374430656433,
-0.04447031021118164,
-0.3459249436855316,
-0.30991077423095703,
-0.7093005776405334,
0.43810033798217773,
-0.37786629796028137,
-0.16006410121917725,
0.3733963370323181,
0.16737036406993866,
-0.1795397847890854,
0.5239529609680176,
-0.825667142868042,
0.175028994679451,
0.5354176759719849,
0.5294907689094543,
0.02055727317929268,
-0.29619699716567993,
-0.7752079963684082,
-0.12096729129552841,
-0.6444101333618164,
0.6031253337860107,
-0.6851588487625122,
-0.5287184119224548,
-0.13838140666484833,
0.033212728798389435,
0.043540846556425095,
-0.8113397359848022,
0.6374873518943787,
-0.4944445490837097,
0.23323562741279602,
-0.29317525029182434,
-0.8529969453811646,
0.1154874935746193,
-0.09349075704813004,
-0.6427075862884521,
0.8147577047348022,
0.14586175978183746,
-0.6504862904548645,
0.6192929148674011,
-0.5695173740386963,
-0.4276047348976135,
-0.13667845726013184,
-0.027170462533831596,
-0.5574671030044556,
0.23269127309322357,
0.16614101827144623,
0.3940223157405853,
-0.45054757595062256,
0.3660437762737274,
-0.27767935395240784,
-0.32159629464149475,
0.4777263104915619,
-0.441191166639328,
0.5291950702667236,
0.19449596107006073,
-0.11051903665065765,
0.27374905347824097,
-0.8735384345054626,
0.27284950017929077,
-0.2497197538614273,
-0.5094013214111328,
-0.1871756762266159,
0.005219132173806429,
-0.043744124472141266,
0.26078084111213684,
-0.0309299323707819,
-0.4878689646720886,
0.31460362672805786,
-0.4464130699634552,
0.5539857149124146,
0.5960143208503723,
0.18659940361976624,
0.5469877123832703,
-0.34035778045654297,
0.3647429347038269,
-0.1342669427394867,
0.2363189309835434,
-0.13600295782089233,
-0.41974708437919617,
-0.6418961882591248,
-0.1977451592683792,
0.6443184018135071,
0.32366418838500977,
-0.5086504817008972,
0.566228449344635,
-0.14891910552978516,
-0.38491690158843994,
-0.9279899001121521,
0.43502458930015564,
0.3244413137435913,
0.25076547265052795,
0.1384744495153427,
-0.49487465620040894,
-0.5067076086997986,
-0.890322744846344,
-0.2735484540462494,
-0.09765966981649399,
-0.13807249069213867,
0.4427909553050995,
0.4800141155719757,
-0.3615119159221649,
1.0872126817703247,
-0.4199584126472473,
-0.26758408546447754,
-0.06529552489519119,
0.23270590603351593,
-0.09386073052883148,
0.7001195549964905,
0.31325969099998474,
-0.17857490479946136,
-0.5387890338897705,
-0.008613137528300285,
-0.36158233880996704,
-0.29778632521629333,
-0.128290057182312,
-0.14173655211925507,
0.21757617592811584,
0.42291969060897827,
-0.5176434516906738,
0.6524707674980164,
0.2796061933040619,
-0.26976272463798523,
0.6255557537078857,
-0.5607218146324158,
0.5070160627365112,
-0.9901177883148193,
-0.09230586141347885,
-0.10783299058675766,
-0.20529110729694366,
-0.6320154666900635,
-0.1488853394985199,
0.0581558495759964,
-0.13846229016780853,
-0.12689070403575897,
0.45510566234588623,
-0.32892459630966187,
-0.33365771174430847,
-0.27591225504875183,
0.0326266773045063,
-0.1168079599738121,
0.3739822804927826,
0.014886562712490559,
0.9952819347381592,
0.1924818605184555,
-0.5152384638786316,
-0.03623752295970917,
0.28656312823295593,
-0.6062409281730652,
0.535749077796936,
-0.7218896150588989,
0.2794414162635803,
0.039235182106494904,
-0.07095540314912796,
-0.7426161170005798,
-0.41254955530166626,
-0.16326595842838287,
-0.426725298166275,
0.20690670609474182,
-0.20673252642154694,
-0.7225303053855896,
-0.15140029788017273,
-0.31244757771492004,
0.15863239765167236,
0.35969313979148865,
-0.2400493025779724,
-0.07071017473936081,
0.3291630744934082,
-0.26974374055862427,
0.07052703201770782,
-0.1592404991388321,
0.36854925751686096,
-0.09527022391557693,
-0.7039819359779358,
0.1449774205684662,
-0.33173438906669617,
-0.34267890453338623,
-0.10998968780040741,
0.11660704016685486,
-0.2942799925804138,
0.27434030175209045,
0.10171674937009811,
0.29951831698417664,
-0.24539543688297272,
-0.09781266748905182,
0.18806613981723785,
-0.30273568630218506,
-0.23805318772792816,
-0.04581981897354126,
0.5257506370544434,
0.12394790351390839,
-0.25086280703544617,
-1.202474594116211,
0.21627163887023926,
0.6206870079040527,
-0.393298476934433,
0.7208433151245117,
0.5690082311630249,
-0.3670937418937683,
0.28018710017204285,
-0.37317967414855957,
-0.4659941494464874,
-0.4810868203639984,
0.20689746737480164,
-0.42464715242385864,
-0.8573304414749146,
0.3182617723941803,
-0.032384101301431656,
0.12487348914146423,
0.3912722170352936,
0.557631254196167,
-0.41603830456733704,
1.5161972045898438,
0.597378134727478,
-0.14327868819236755,
0.7575209736824036,
-0.29949256777763367,
-0.08159833401441574,
-0.8343412280082703,
0.37790244817733765,
-0.6993255615234375,
-0.32666489481925964,
-0.7055065631866455,
-0.29699960350990295,
0.3304975926876068,
0.5223574042320251,
-0.21097621321678162,
0.2510494291782379,
-0.21073754131793976,
0.46610525250434875,
0.504547119140625,
0.0937185063958168,
0.4858418405056,
-0.05549193546175957,
0.32023078203201294,
-0.3918120861053467,
-0.6997746229171753,
-0.8128290772438049,
1.1792867183685303,
0.23880931735038757,
0.7757673859596252,
-0.04249653220176697,
0.49653831124305725,
0.3543529510498047,
0.060016974806785583,
-0.5694646835327148,
0.24097979068756104,
-0.11572867631912231,
-0.460475355386734,
-0.4621922969818115,
-0.43016791343688965,
-0.9881640672683716,
-0.058497704565525055,
-0.3851269781589508,
-0.7219287157058716,
0.06246175244450569,
0.45939457416534424,
-0.5231085419654846,
-0.09260492771863937,
-0.8929709792137146,
0.9070957899093628,
-0.016697656363248825,
-0.461401104927063,
-0.7389252185821533,
-0.39466622471809387,
-0.014520378783345222,
-0.05000033229589462,
0.14529111981391907,
-0.014543304219841957,
0.34652793407440186,
0.7020388245582581,
-0.8479175567626953,
0.9281242489814758,
-0.07871720939874649,
-0.2767781913280487,
0.18907921016216278,
0.1442212015390396,
0.6691546440124512,
0.214807391166687,
-0.19428949058055878,
0.05373421683907509,
0.0475488044321537,
-0.5294691324234009,
-0.43791115283966064,
0.512590765953064,
-0.9491947293281555,
-0.6890676021575928,
0.20200923085212708,
-0.7559035420417786,
-0.29898181557655334,
0.15140923857688904,
0.2513265311717987,
0.7702029347419739,
-0.002522889291867614,
0.20124569535255432,
0.6169205904006958,
-0.3996187150478363,
0.14668208360671997,
0.5447758436203003,
-0.09528825432062149,
-0.319179505109787,
0.9310939908027649,
0.340368390083313,
0.7474738955497742,
-0.17865771055221558,
0.18842169642448425,
0.0191377904266119,
-0.6322702169418335,
-0.9219050407409668,
0.18108458817005157,
-0.31716448068618774,
-0.04625815525650978,
-0.5118889212608337,
-0.23408734798431396,
-0.27977868914604187,
-0.17749616503715515,
-0.5438085198402405,
-0.37462538480758667,
-0.5050290822982788,
0.04308914393186569,
0.5932850241661072,
0.8924939632415771,
-0.06107185035943985,
0.5518405437469482,
-0.8117643594741821,
0.24367211759090424,
0.12045358121395111,
0.5467139482498169,
-0.37380653619766235,
-0.8007234930992126,
-0.5771187543869019,
0.42005684971809387,
0.027533790096640587,
-0.5114130973815918,
0.3227289319038391,
0.4492647349834442,
0.16653795540332794,
0.29472681879997253,
0.010957798920571804,
0.7757244110107422,
-0.5688064694404602,
0.6591936349868774,
-0.35445794463157654,
-0.7485857009887695,
0.39731842279434204,
-0.5288558602333069,
0.501386284828186,
0.6235530972480774,
-0.01487668976187706,
-0.5188857316970825,
-0.4565170407295227,
-0.5400944352149963,
-0.37055206298828125,
1.0019391775131226,
0.1680646687746048,
0.10068655014038086,
0.28664737939834595,
0.6144697666168213,
0.2833271026611328,
0.35472381114959717,
0.037910304963588715,
-0.08215447515249252,
0.017448581755161285,
-0.09176156669855118,
-0.16316308081150055,
-0.392741322517395,
0.04043615236878395,
-0.5275431871414185,
0.48775047063827515,
-0.06828104704618454,
-0.04649031534790993,
-0.09531038254499435,
-0.4047800302505493,
-0.41770172119140625,
0.3194900155067444,
0.6718711256980896,
0.5553833842277527,
-0.1450466364622116,
-0.21923251450061798,
0.08032763004302979,
-0.23734956979751587,
-0.19234851002693176,
-0.21208173036575317,
-0.2933860123157501,
-0.007850971072912216,
0.468379408121109,
1.2067029476165771,
0.2043025642633438,
-0.673547625541687,
0.05525120720267296,
-0.021258264780044556,
-0.17485220730304718,
0.16319957375526428,
0.40248194336891174,
-0.1083449050784111,
0.16763320565223694,
-0.09622228890657425,
0.2819492220878601,
0.12177686393260956,
-0.5760535597801208,
0.23421652615070343,
0.3990079462528229,
-0.27330267429351807,
-0.604322612285614,
0.5556935667991638,
0.26079490780830383,
-0.7555848360061646,
0.5686362385749817,
-0.23138493299484253,
-0.5807850360870361,
0.37744849920272827,
0.1980365365743637,
0.5502275228500366,
-0.3217772841453552,
0.1696435958147049,
0.561186671257019,
0.3689354360103607,
0.06105131283402443,
0.28303563594818115,
-0.13790254294872284,
-0.7886579036712646,
-0.5846722722053528,
-0.45713767409324646,
-0.2798178195953369,
0.18026112020015717,
-0.7384970784187317,
0.30812355875968933,
-0.5042237639427185,
-0.1960868537425995,
0.15497857332229614,
0.11317835003137589,
-0.8770623207092285,
0.21243345737457275,
-0.25806906819343567,
0.6053669452667236,
-0.5883670449256897,
0.8826289772987366,
0.5259672403335571,
-0.3513082265853882,
-0.7404661178588867,
0.019101176410913467,
-0.011951472610235214,
-0.5207899212837219,
0.5245946049690247,
-0.095583975315094,
-0.02293563447892666,
0.40887251496315,
-0.34163686633110046,
-0.913088858127594,
0.5212753415107727,
0.4204140603542328,
-0.74550461769104,
0.4027100205421448,
0.500957190990448,
0.8597508072853088,
-0.08665022253990173,
0.16301681101322174,
0.9066202044487,
0.3745509684085846,
-0.3048347234725952,
-1.5397491455078125,
-0.395743191242218,
-0.16077791154384613,
0.08186224102973938,
0.24659773707389832,
-0.37893250584602356,
0.7159644961357117,
-0.4042496085166931,
-0.259428471326828,
0.1674094945192337,
0.2503863573074341,
-0.4399360120296478,
-0.22433948516845703,
0.6096793413162231,
0.32370978593826294,
0.7959966063499451,
-0.01445185299962759,
0.9919833540916443,
-0.4050850570201874,
0.3447003662586212,
1.1581699848175049,
-0.3487604856491089,
0.8206462264060974,
0.28931084275245667,
-0.13081485033035278,
0.0028950637206435204,
0.782842218875885,
0.40255382657051086,
0.38909777998924255,
0.19738030433654785,
-0.06188233569264412,
-0.3163946866989136,
-0.2152196317911148,
-0.23201577365398407,
0.37693658471107483,
0.44155654311180115,
-0.15592044591903687,
-0.004417493473738432,
0.22626440227031708,
0.004956528078764677,
0.2428750991821289,
-0.2495262771844864,
1.185266375541687,
-0.3096458315849304,
-0.5790002942085266,
0.9283975958824158,
0.06638150662183762,
0.5292918086051941,
0.028652969747781754,
0.10107055306434631,
-0.20718912780284882,
0.12913444638252258,
-0.29640617966651917,
-0.8127837181091309,
0.3892746865749359,
0.3079119026660919,
-0.43146538734436035,
-0.21514418721199036,
0.42765602469444275,
-0.6749737858772278,
-0.2973671853542328,
-0.11439762264490128,
0.4425555467605591,
0.15589800477027893,
-0.149180069565773,
-0.5419692993164062,
0.2887127995491028,
0.11543933302164078,
-0.2821555435657501,
0.2951759994029999,
0.4611194133758545,
-0.29692742228507996,
0.5171676874160767,
0.6366734504699707,
0.10865706205368042,
-0.03931320831179619,
0.38465866446495056,
0.7393564581871033,
-0.6752458810806274,
-0.12615977227687836,
-0.7047837376594543,
0.4495485723018646,
-0.11616912484169006,
-0.38385871052742004,
0.3546746075153351,
0.43918025493621826,
0.9483593702316284,
0.07028753310441971,
0.7944389581680298,
0.19613610208034515,
0.5280646085739136,
-0.5251494646072388,
0.6350298523902893,
-0.36990731954574585,
0.3366175591945648,
-0.35872411727905273,
-0.6779170036315918,
-0.09555520862340927,
0.5929178595542908,
-0.35526490211486816,
-0.0979299396276474,
0.45327216386795044,
1.076040267944336,
0.11866867542266846,
0.028528138995170593,
0.3705696761608124,
0.41544392704963684,
0.4504071772098541,
-0.05562432110309601,
0.7297804355621338,
-0.38604921102523804,
0.18176613748073578,
-0.32083219289779663,
-0.11234544217586517,
-0.3132598102092743,
-0.4713795483112335,
-1.0383388996124268,
-0.7425034642219543,
-0.37245500087738037,
-0.09858036041259766,
0.10505935549736023,
1.1828104257583618,
0.6092588305473328,
-0.7224946618080139,
-0.29652029275894165,
-0.03253697603940964,
-0.08530982583761215,
-0.004195499233901501,
-0.20810829102993011,
0.2168518453836441,
-0.43687859177589417,
-0.9072526097297668,
0.2525734305381775,
0.28477418422698975,
-0.13729572296142578,
-0.2258644849061966,
-0.20217224955558777,
0.04385225102305412,
0.036002494394779205,
0.7144392132759094,
0.03950871154665947,
-0.6685212254524231,
-0.7000579237937927,
0.02693871594965458,
-0.2088066041469574,
0.11140126734972,
0.918927788734436,
-0.6810221672058105,
0.5889793634414673,
0.30802255868911743,
0.7245425581932068,
0.3189969062805176,
-0.11022835969924927,
1.053173542022705,
-0.6535611748695374,
0.039493247866630554,
-0.173691064119339,
0.34017083048820496,
0.5161095261573792,
-0.3310188949108124,
0.4283274710178375,
0.058828603476285934,
-0.6284684538841248,
-0.9286673665046692,
0.15172551572322845,
-0.47817549109458923,
-0.018192369490861893,
1.1400185823440552,
0.13998085260391235,
0.1351219266653061,
-0.261730432510376,
-0.8943034410476685,
0.3126388192176819,
-0.4428698420524597,
1.0339159965515137,
0.8428306579589844,
-0.06936723738908768,
-0.02786678448319435,
-0.8109739422798157,
0.8124374151229858,
0.5190610885620117,
-0.9648462533950806,
0.37740853428840637,
0.7552958130836487,
0.2403126209974289,
-0.2586943805217743,
0.5283263325691223,
0.2253909409046173,
0.436087965965271,
-0.36136162281036377,
-0.00735465670004487,
0.11346279829740524,
-0.12989041209220886,
-0.2621425986289978,
-0.35580703616142273,
0.4919913411140442,
0.08229340612888336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07287v1
|
Bilingual Sexism Classification: Fine-Tuned XLM-RoBERTa and GPT-3.5 Few-Shot Learning
| 2024-06-11T14:15:33 | 2024-06-11T14:15:33 |
AmirMohammad Azadi, Baktash Ansari, Sina Zamani
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Sexism in online content is a pervasive issue that necessitates effective
classification techniques to mitigate its harmful impact. Online platforms
often have sexist comments and posts that create a hostile environment,
especially for women and minority groups. This content not only spreads harmful
stereotypes but also causes emotional harm. Reliable methods are essential to
find and remove sexist content, making online spaces safer and more welcoming.
Therefore, the sEXism Identification in Social neTworks (EXIST) challenge
addresses this issue at CLEF 2024. This study aims to improve sexism
identification in bilingual contexts (English and Spanish) by leveraging
natural language processing models. The tasks are to determine whether a text
is sexist and what the source intention behind it is. We fine-tuned the
XLM-RoBERTa model and separately used GPT-3.5 with few-shot learning prompts to
classify sexist content. The XLM-RoBERTa model exhibited robust performance in
handling complex linguistic structures, while GPT-3.5's few-shot learning
capability allowed for rapid adaptation to new data with minimal labeled
examples. Our approach using XLM-RoBERTa achieved 4th place in the soft-soft
evaluation of Task 1 (sexism identification). For Task 2 (source intention), we
achieved 2nd place in the soft-soft evaluation.
|
[
-0.23781083524227142,
-1.005761742591858,
0.41193872690200806,
0.5901901721954346,
-0.1436755508184433,
-0.11570949852466583,
-0.20927470922470093,
-0.6344072818756104,
-0.02764342725276947,
0.45288458466529846,
-0.7106446623802185,
-0.5390087366104126,
-0.7497133612632751,
0.5685616731643677,
-0.4935840368270874,
1.2422540187835693,
0.03028074838221073,
0.3048887550830841,
0.04761917516589165,
-0.05092128366231918,
-0.3926525115966797,
-0.3524589240550995,
-0.6141284704208374,
-0.027940882369875908,
0.564766526222229,
0.1833273321390152,
0.535422682762146,
0.4425155222415924,
0.5052803158760071,
0.3769415020942688,
-0.4328123927116394,
0.524998664855957,
-0.7545576095581055,
-0.15958285331726074,
-0.3155844211578369,
-0.4678255319595337,
-0.5650012493133545,
-0.11481549590826035,
0.5273242592811584,
0.6276327967643738,
0.06371351331472397,
0.3859061002731323,
0.1528138965368271,
0.493956983089447,
-0.4685707986354828,
0.2481391876935959,
-0.6635304689407349,
0.3333221971988678,
-0.44007110595703125,
-0.24782559275627136,
-0.37905430793762207,
-0.37856411933898926,
0.09918266534805298,
-0.3324199318885803,
0.37555578351020813,
-0.08269062638282776,
0.5975539684295654,
-0.14129173755645752,
-0.857572615146637,
-0.30607396364212036,
-0.7634282112121582,
0.8095476627349854,
-0.5174025297164917,
0.3810727894306183,
0.5380584597587585,
0.08390627056360245,
-0.10567371547222137,
-0.19848690927028656,
-0.5439465641975403,
0.28892281651496887,
-0.1228368803858757,
-0.09089887142181396,
-0.3348475694656372,
-0.2761625647544861,
0.3532845377922058,
-0.20534870028495789,
-0.8862653970718384,
0.08613111823797226,
-0.583501935005188,
-0.173696368932724,
0.5846112966537476,
0.11451707035303116,
0.6435801386833191,
-0.5624073147773743,
-0.4150664508342743,
0.3921627402305603,
-0.6329123377799988,
-0.1130000650882721,
0.911092221736908,
0.6571527719497681,
-0.3951844274997711,
0.3454727232456207,
0.16649770736694336,
0.24754862487316132,
-0.0872947946190834,
-0.1705375760793686,
0.4718555808067322,
-0.296746164560318,
-0.05733238160610199,
-0.11617989093065262,
0.8798946142196655,
0.05811154097318649,
0.20109833776950836,
0.022975564002990723,
-0.016881316900253296,
0.026398494839668274,
0.33854445815086365,
-0.5328914523124695,
0.07372840493917465,
-0.07520516961812973,
-0.3442303240299225,
-0.3255733847618103,
0.13890990614891052,
-0.6968651413917542,
-0.17519475519657135,
-0.3747583329677582,
0.19948585331439972,
-0.36179599165916443,
-0.36748170852661133,
-0.2473277598619461,
-0.21517719328403473,
0.10982431471347809,
0.4191204309463501,
-0.940788745880127,
0.4023303687572479,
0.7937642335891724,
0.7909950613975525,
-0.3638647794723511,
0.055623654276132584,
-0.3084772527217865,
0.07375440001487732,
-0.12516479194164276,
0.48629438877105713,
-0.4758898615837097,
-0.19553084671497345,
0.15754979848861694,
0.40234264731407166,
-0.22421498596668243,
-0.23785080015659332,
0.8267613053321838,
-0.6162824630737305,
0.555621325969696,
-0.37542322278022766,
-0.17654599249362946,
-0.2926802635192871,
0.4002646505832672,
-0.5639608502388,
0.7824952602386475,
-0.08010359853506088,
-0.9634868502616882,
0.30207541584968567,
-0.6569825410842896,
-0.45341387391090393,
0.07147302478551865,
0.05106576904654503,
-0.5818594098091125,
-0.2130993902683258,
0.04832635447382927,
0.3833983838558197,
-0.03153809532523155,
0.0006351832416839898,
-0.5473801493644714,
-0.15901078283786774,
0.17115290462970734,
-0.4483274221420288,
1.0575001239776611,
0.03284410014748573,
-0.4879933297634125,
0.17465339601039886,
-0.7295427322387695,
-0.0768033117055893,
0.17660361528396606,
-0.0056893667206168175,
-0.5161247253417969,
-0.05601527914404869,
0.3308207094669342,
0.12476100027561188,
0.11649585515260696,
-0.44191452860832214,
-0.1579769253730774,
-0.7141035795211792,
0.13664132356643677,
0.7517483234405518,
-0.17492027580738068,
0.44411447644233704,
0.008564061485230923,
0.6801749467849731,
-0.00431203655898571,
0.21360526978969574,
0.13831521570682526,
-0.6408542394638062,
-0.6389601230621338,
-0.2541959583759308,
0.18743398785591125,
0.8184006214141846,
-0.6396800875663757,
0.3711540102958679,
-0.21671128273010254,
-0.3272959887981415,
-0.01977836713194847,
0.6413013339042664,
0.6711938381195068,
0.052095551043748856,
0.44303098320961,
-0.18967218697071075,
-0.81834876537323,
-0.8916828036308289,
-0.24377183616161346,
-0.05101846531033516,
0.14489632844924927,
0.1750211864709854,
0.740178644657135,
-0.25775259733200073,
0.6024882197380066,
-0.24145421385765076,
-0.6326884031295776,
-0.4440360367298126,
0.4722028076648712,
0.18954996764659882,
0.3353610932826996,
0.7243919372558594,
-1.0989385843276978,
-0.6116390824317932,
0.1456492692232132,
-0.7608982920646667,
-0.12551136314868927,
0.49240750074386597,
-0.11452651023864746,
0.22920842468738556,
0.032007329165935516,
-0.3249298632144928,
0.2492918074131012,
0.32926100492477417,
-0.08681730180978775,
0.1719774752855301,
-0.10700452327728271,
0.12517710030078888,
-0.8338266015052795,
-0.20544789731502533,
0.44102203845977783,
-0.4249001443386078,
-0.6375787854194641,
0.007256003096699715,
0.06531822681427002,
0.09574004262685776,
-0.7536897659301758,
0.3466104567050934,
-0.363182008266449,
0.004488947335630655,
-0.3309578597545624,
0.018553799018263817,
-0.3732577860355377,
0.4538003206253052,
0.06462492048740387,
0.25569993257522583,
0.3063408434391022,
-0.3574013411998749,
0.1949777901172638,
0.21299701929092407,
0.11831413954496384,
0.461393266916275,
-0.3440052270889282,
0.5136486887931824,
-0.43750593066215515,
0.329721063375473,
-1.027916431427002,
-0.27026063203811646,
0.508332371711731,
-0.3634603023529053,
0.16285651922225952,
-0.5533674359321594,
-0.6502887606620789,
-0.30261579155921936,
-0.41673222184181213,
0.46543416380882263,
0.22114938497543335,
-0.4315374493598938,
0.4003419876098633,
0.4764268398284912,
-0.313170462846756,
-0.5875325798988342,
-0.4954659342765808,
-0.22678770124912262,
-0.17759615182876587,
-0.4899298846721649,
0.2772199213504791,
0.11128559708595276,
-0.11788344383239746,
-0.2746076285839081,
0.163254976272583,
-0.2900165915489197,
-0.037220604717731476,
0.2457134872674942,
0.3430687189102173,
-0.030191263183951378,
0.09733769297599792,
0.28708988428115845,
-0.0693439319729805,
0.06682227551937103,
0.14085324108600616,
0.467436283826828,
-0.2777427136898041,
-0.14764288067817688,
-0.25665953755378723,
0.485981285572052,
0.3053930997848511,
-0.06713948398828506,
0.8019958734512329,
1.1732218265533447,
-0.4757317900657654,
-0.5659610629081726,
-0.16194546222686768,
-0.039722200483083725,
-0.40522798895835876,
0.24360787868499756,
-0.19123385846614838,
-0.7836889028549194,
0.3704666793346405,
0.38890400528907776,
-0.14296016097068787,
0.3341318964958191,
0.5699480772018433,
-0.15876998007297516,
1.3800621032714844,
0.840275228023529,
0.04779234156012535,
0.3160022497177124,
-0.2459186613559723,
-0.018701495602726936,
-0.3688511252403259,
-0.12385517358779907,
-0.5785036087036133,
-0.3012773394584656,
-0.828952968120575,
-0.37698614597320557,
0.5034767389297485,
-0.4340820610523224,
-0.0032276781275868416,
0.6188814043998718,
-0.26348239183425903,
0.5754117965698242,
0.18332408368587494,
0.3992995321750641,
0.2051614671945572,
-0.04545344412326813,
-0.03697330132126808,
-0.47593677043914795,
-0.5175411701202393,
-0.587015688419342,
1.024037480354309,
0.5061658024787903,
0.369963139295578,
0.6575284004211426,
0.3585096597671509,
0.4989439845085144,
0.48636090755462646,
-0.44169580936431885,
0.680526852607727,
-0.42524024844169617,
-0.8820571899414062,
0.11916744709014893,
-0.6499559283256531,
-0.9985415935516357,
0.39951181411743164,
-0.43002936244010925,
-0.8778645396232605,
-0.028815487399697304,
0.10902430862188339,
-0.03327927365899086,
0.27322256565093994,
-0.4364059269428253,
0.8526691198348999,
-0.22054527699947357,
-0.5946769118309021,
-0.17523379623889923,
-0.621430516242981,
0.6876309514045715,
-0.22861212491989136,
0.6327864527702332,
-0.3163524568080902,
-0.04731936752796173,
0.595012366771698,
-0.24592998623847961,
1.3177316188812256,
-0.08077652007341385,
-0.3071661591529846,
-0.21292801201343536,
0.017017865553498268,
0.4000900387763977,
-0.02293987013399601,
-0.008154175244271755,
0.3979666233062744,
0.16948749125003815,
-0.28461700677871704,
-0.29555898904800415,
0.6216614246368408,
-0.802763819694519,
-0.26430073380470276,
-0.32732027769088745,
-0.32149550318717957,
-0.11074571311473846,
0.2701722979545593,
0.3028663098812103,
0.4198785424232483,
-0.2630537748336792,
0.08914914727210999,
0.5367358922958374,
-0.1781294196844101,
0.13679896295070648,
0.6136707663536072,
-0.36456432938575745,
-0.3015133738517761,
0.8464681506156921,
0.0810202956199646,
-0.05799234285950661,
0.42086055874824524,
0.09587635099887848,
-0.40693262219429016,
-0.5366785526275635,
-0.21355006098747253,
0.2934627830982208,
-0.8173959851264954,
-0.04556332901120186,
-0.7891901731491089,
-0.09903479367494583,
-0.6126222014427185,
0.09496646374464035,
-0.27672433853149414,
-0.031510282307863235,
-0.3618113696575165,
0.02999293804168701,
-0.06594018638134003,
0.5280587673187256,
0.17584238946437836,
0.2564775347709656,
-0.7204968929290771,
0.547182559967041,
0.2035880982875824,
0.05841326341032982,
-0.49273061752319336,
-0.6633402109146118,
0.2236056625843048,
0.05421755835413933,
-0.544866681098938,
-1.2408721446990967,
0.673323929309845,
0.19142010807991028,
0.42863795161247253,
0.5496231317520142,
0.03337109088897705,
0.5000114440917969,
-0.30948397517204285,
0.42056944966316223,
0.1783829629421234,
-0.9874408841133118,
0.8013594746589661,
-0.5675413608551025,
-0.08296588063240051,
0.22941149771213531,
0.9287300109863281,
-0.24873314797878265,
-0.3836369812488556,
-0.5799931883811951,
-0.7757304310798645,
0.8218151926994324,
0.5939736366271973,
0.478109747171402,
-0.29507914185523987,
0.10215556621551514,
0.37148386240005493,
0.14467604458332062,
-1.335745096206665,
-0.38046860694885254,
0.228281632065773,
-0.25188857316970825,
0.33491048216819763,
-0.26923656463623047,
-0.24138899147510529,
-0.3412950038909912,
0.7456109523773193,
-0.3098789155483246,
0.09025976806879044,
-0.15073713660240173,
-0.44705384969711304,
-0.30073249340057373,
0.4813172519207001,
0.563160240650177,
0.6815388202667236,
-0.16747985780239105,
0.31942471861839294,
0.43456152081489563,
-0.17896051704883575,
0.17959196865558624,
-0.059942640364170074,
-0.2983117997646332,
0.14371216297149658,
0.4800190329551697,
0.7735257744789124,
0.4764728844165802,
-0.5714349150657654,
0.8291049003601074,
-0.0890597328543663,
-0.21411475539207458,
-0.49693408608436584,
0.15195788443088531,
-0.30614057183265686,
0.3564260005950928,
0.1879672408103943,
0.2715703845024109,
0.13553188741207123,
-0.7394317388534546,
-0.061020635068416595,
0.5587047338485718,
-0.47721067070961,
-0.6126444935798645,
0.6395768523216248,
0.208559051156044,
-0.3388378918170929,
0.08277944475412369,
-0.5844947099685669,
-0.8406485319137573,
0.5267828106880188,
0.7054227590560913,
0.8287646174430847,
-0.08760751038789749,
0.5476524233818054,
0.5894597172737122,
0.34492331743240356,
0.08456671237945557,
0.2821502685546875,
-0.17311567068099976,
-1.1460442543029785,
-0.18121087551116943,
-0.5395091772079468,
-0.2583843469619751,
-0.03866308927536011,
-0.5512436032295227,
0.5843713283538818,
-0.6119993329048157,
-0.2712625563144684,
0.2556699812412262,
-0.13891324400901794,
-0.6801267862319946,
-0.21285295486450195,
0.5066997408866882,
0.2500810921192169,
-1.2085301876068115,
0.48383963108062744,
0.6846891641616821,
-0.2831951081752777,
-0.3443716764450073,
-0.2857670783996582,
0.7937753200531006,
-0.5144413113594055,
1.0366053581237793,
0.38275018334388733,
-0.1928412914276123,
-0.1767595261335373,
-0.4921974539756775,
-0.6032246351242065,
0.6269057393074036,
0.5177170634269714,
-0.36402657628059387,
0.05442586913704872,
0.27490362524986267,
0.7688641548156738,
-0.29524290561676025,
0.5524325966835022,
0.29943767189979553,
0.5522873997688293,
-0.02321302518248558,
-1.151168942451477,
-0.07612542062997818,
-0.45933499932289124,
0.00407595606520772,
0.21323350071907043,
-0.38608741760253906,
0.6865618824958801,
-0.10358622670173645,
-0.43271762132644653,
-0.014726681634783745,
0.5115953087806702,
0.23124365508556366,
0.4933699369430542,
0.7372454404830933,
0.16608604788780212,
0.5954049229621887,
-0.12459257990121841,
0.719746470451355,
0.25893622636795044,
0.4189217984676361,
0.9196687936782837,
-0.29301032423973083,
0.8323105573654175,
0.1967473179101944,
-0.48124679923057556,
0.5736358165740967,
0.301016241312027,
-0.0403701514005661,
0.13847263157367706,
-0.05564558878540993,
-0.14945240318775177,
-0.20718546211719513,
-0.09071511030197144,
-0.20831872522830963,
0.6342892646789551,
0.3338119089603424,
-0.5208109021186829,
-0.3032572865486145,
0.33169105648994446,
0.2410963624715805,
0.23073093593120575,
-0.10631504654884338,
0.7662662267684937,
-0.02107917331159115,
-0.3321441411972046,
0.25880226492881775,
0.324426531791687,
0.8093734979629517,
-0.5985836982727051,
0.03451127931475639,
0.08610033243894577,
0.2379113882780075,
-0.42633700370788574,
-0.4431988000869751,
0.24020344018936157,
0.3223542273044586,
-0.3321487307548523,
-0.45206204056739807,
0.7506953477859497,
-0.6838112473487854,
-0.796019434928894,
0.48783907294273376,
0.438457727432251,
0.08789589256048203,
0.06091105192899704,
-0.8551461696624756,
-0.06207624450325966,
0.032815031707286835,
0.1594674438238144,
0.3231663107872009,
0.3161141574382782,
-0.10992284119129181,
0.5837954878807068,
0.9727351665496826,
0.25562721490859985,
0.025080911815166473,
0.18078458309173584,
0.41479113698005676,
-0.5577488541603088,
-0.6484963893890381,
-0.8997863531112671,
0.0664030909538269,
-0.12535637617111206,
-0.366232693195343,
0.8894844055175781,
0.38243311643600464,
0.7470821738243103,
-0.05858013033866882,
0.4822694957256317,
-0.06193942204117775,
0.7319910526275635,
-0.4178156852722168,
0.5019043684005737,
-0.5669811367988586,
0.637137234210968,
-0.6617115139961243,
-0.8214960694313049,
-0.4523744285106659,
0.44870784878730774,
-0.6088352203369141,
0.1117880716919899,
0.5897724628448486,
0.8715628981590271,
-0.34432682394981384,
0.2894802987575531,
0.20559944212436676,
0.1574612706899643,
0.3532739579677582,
0.3111530840396881,
0.819892942905426,
-0.4997663199901581,
0.6156250834465027,
-0.3784175217151642,
-0.05653825402259827,
-0.1639246642589569,
-0.8872683644294739,
-0.8951362371444702,
-0.3927434980869293,
-0.5060186982154846,
-0.09643680602312088,
0.04692825302481651,
1.2339671850204468,
0.8308452367782593,
-0.6502050161361694,
-0.027057567611336708,
-0.028579264879226685,
0.40820544958114624,
-0.23993906378746033,
-0.2610391080379486,
0.09786844253540039,
-0.3260986804962158,
-0.9876005053520203,
0.19958269596099854,
0.3460368812084198,
-0.15729933977127075,
-0.22174584865570068,
-0.02471037581562996,
-0.15178072452545166,
-0.20517411828041077,
0.7522926330566406,
0.3148660659790039,
-0.6908988356590271,
-0.23467181622982025,
-0.19146403670310974,
-0.025814129039645195,
-0.10841857641935349,
0.49211224913597107,
-0.27427420020103455,
0.43106362223625183,
0.6194804310798645,
0.32102468609809875,
0.38521137833595276,
-0.00031944309012033045,
0.45844316482543945,
-0.953361988067627,
0.19641195237636566,
0.16046877205371857,
0.4588746726512909,
0.2617778778076172,
-0.3117254376411438,
0.37777289748191833,
0.6171420216560364,
-0.1559254676103592,
-0.9037237763404846,
0.015899747610092163,
-1.251815676689148,
-0.08154763281345367,
1.2637791633605957,
-0.1703776717185974,
-0.369728147983551,
-0.3371197283267975,
-0.342087060213089,
0.1285768300294876,
-0.0748564600944519,
0.5809833407402039,
0.4985884130001068,
0.04359631612896919,
-0.3422376811504364,
-0.6855294704437256,
0.2659004032611847,
0.42526975274086,
-1.0157582759857178,
-0.28088563680648804,
0.34790894389152527,
0.4576020836830139,
0.10685938596725464,
0.3581215739250183,
-0.3209545314311981,
0.40216127038002014,
-0.5411092042922974,
-0.2517782151699066,
0.2625353932380676,
-0.2684378921985626,
-0.13645054399967194,
0.590610146522522,
-0.5315554141998291,
0.04486560821533203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07277v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07277v1
|
Speaking Your Language: Spatial Relationships in Interpretable Emergent Communication
| 2024-06-11T14:04:25 | 2024-06-11T14:04:25 |
Olaf Lipinski, Adam J. Sobey, Federico Cerutti, Timothy J. Norman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MA
|
Effective communication requires the ability to refer to specific parts of an
observation in relation to others. While emergent communication literature
shows success in developing various language properties, no research has shown
the emergence of such positional references. This paper demonstrates how agents
can communicate about spatial relationships within their observations. The
results indicate that agents can develop a language capable of expressing the
relationships between parts of their observation, achieving over 90% accuracy
when trained in a referential game which requires such communication. Using a
collocation measure, we demonstrate how the agents create such references. This
analysis suggests that agents use a mixture of non-compositional and
compositional messages to convey spatial relationships. We also show that the
emergent language is interpretable by humans. The translation accuracy is
tested by communicating with the receiver agent, where the receiver achieves
over 78% accuracy using parts of this lexicon, confirming that the
interpretation of the emergent language was successful.
|
[
-0.25194013118743896,
-0.6848641037940979,
0.7834556698799133,
0.6173146367073059,
-0.0018129621166735888,
0.20236192643642426,
-0.36686745285987854,
-1.1029837131500244,
0.2660018503665924,
0.258342981338501,
-0.16311629116535187,
-0.3752172589302063,
-0.4704984724521637,
-0.0702301636338234,
-0.3155234158039093,
0.6725758910179138,
0.17028972506523132,
-0.05677437782287598,
-0.10721328109502792,
-0.4088493883609772,
-0.6321814656257629,
-0.5828747153282166,
-0.6525962948799133,
-0.6657023429870605,
0.36094236373901367,
0.29208195209503174,
1.1674981117248535,
0.8622134923934937,
0.5050824880599976,
0.4897294044494629,
-0.35326719284057617,
0.1598520278930664,
-0.3560679852962494,
0.35356298089027405,
-0.47116634249687195,
-0.8351365923881531,
0.18637186288833618,
-0.14479349553585052,
0.6326021552085876,
0.9696841239929199,
-0.2951129078865051,
-0.1126788780093193,
-0.21751752495765686,
0.44820070266723633,
-0.20326191186904907,
0.6034361124038696,
-0.5496233701705933,
0.2983332872390747,
-0.23002555966377258,
-0.4564579725265503,
-0.44088026881217957,
-0.24917080998420715,
0.31043294072151184,
-0.6846978664398193,
0.1939372420310974,
0.06933946162462234,
0.9869499206542969,
-0.08901537209749222,
-0.3892546594142914,
-0.4354065954685211,
-1.2787481546401978,
0.4604088366031647,
-0.29375213384628296,
0.42070433497428894,
0.5412827134132385,
0.46928727626800537,
-0.293433278799057,
-0.5908159017562866,
-0.502928614616394,
-0.2553386092185974,
-0.3888401687145233,
0.12327644973993301,
-0.15575018525123596,
-0.08959099650382996,
0.15251924097537994,
-0.1100536361336708,
-0.24163588881492615,
-0.49241435527801514,
-0.2823944687843323,
0.1418611854314804,
0.5156456828117371,
0.01065158098936081,
0.6560644507408142,
-0.08900440484285355,
-0.4706566333770752,
-0.029334232211112976,
-0.46468034386634827,
-0.09741663932800293,
0.23313027620315552,
0.6196550130844116,
-0.33138319849967957,
0.49147021770477295,
0.29873067140579224,
0.56251460313797,
0.319388210773468,
0.012922142632305622,
0.06592335551977158,
-0.5622177720069885,
0.18474629521369934,
-0.08219997584819794,
0.6331550478935242,
0.3450469970703125,
0.2809382975101471,
-0.4705697298049927,
0.046568986028432846,
-0.16960471868515015,
0.3758028447628021,
-0.07593965530395508,
-0.326285719871521,
-0.05288403481245041,
-0.20307797193527222,
-0.1276191771030426,
0.24733465909957886,
-0.44179248809814453,
-0.3861616253852844,
-0.0831092819571495,
0.10510241240262985,
-0.5403634905815125,
-0.4376150071620941,
-0.19890905916690826,
-0.11808925867080688,
0.4392991065979004,
0.23001070320606232,
-1.356803297996521,
0.4313756823539734,
0.4291745722293854,
0.9886574745178223,
0.32641658186912537,
-0.6863152980804443,
0.026916133239865303,
0.5632186532020569,
-0.5736091732978821,
1.217734456062317,
-0.3096005916595459,
-0.48487532138824463,
0.09640099853277206,
-0.20593398809432983,
-0.31199219822883606,
-0.6131230592727661,
0.21910503506660461,
-0.4874175786972046,
-0.0654778853058815,
-0.3319530189037323,
-0.1919236034154892,
0.22669726610183716,
-0.033428966999053955,
-0.6797357797622681,
0.7073200941085815,
0.13979317247867584,
-0.5763954520225525,
0.44799667596817017,
-0.7543396949768066,
-0.615403413772583,
0.5864807367324829,
-0.30111822485923767,
-0.053708724677562714,
0.04168282821774483,
-0.030559202656149864,
-0.03168851509690285,
0.39321649074554443,
0.090801902115345,
0.1379012167453766,
-0.02436775155365467,
0.6447712182998657,
0.07392904162406921,
0.4319681227207184,
0.4964437782764435,
-0.43218091130256653,
-0.019353821873664856,
-0.4773067235946655,
0.10458850115537643,
0.03979804366827011,
-0.49758246541023254,
-0.3911331593990326,
0.4540553689002991,
-0.11224097013473511,
0.10917830467224121,
0.23446539044380188,
-0.32439514994621277,
-0.18432296812534332,
-0.648034393787384,
0.27382034063339233,
0.45081329345703125,
0.1727481633424759,
0.9726270437240601,
-0.18991419672966003,
0.28247547149658203,
0.16894184052944183,
-0.13340650498867035,
-0.1358991265296936,
-0.5373391509056091,
-0.5690110921859741,
0.3005646765232086,
-0.2406373918056488,
0.4582787752151489,
-0.8495124578475952,
0.4544178545475006,
-0.3319956362247467,
-0.5247709155082703,
-0.17102111876010895,
0.04824896901845932,
0.2735389173030853,
0.340984046459198,
0.002929740585386753,
0.05431010201573372,
-0.6548630595207214,
-0.6568244695663452,
-0.16134804487228394,
-0.7231376767158508,
0.17215055227279663,
0.6944983005523682,
0.14998283982276917,
0.10250008851289749,
0.851477324962616,
-0.48173075914382935,
0.0040189349092543125,
-0.5082672834396362,
0.32965290546417236,
-0.06623782217502594,
0.270384281873703,
0.7765963077545166,
-0.7653109431266785,
-0.702704906463623,
0.4216075539588928,
-1.023447036743164,
-0.12701258063316345,
-0.12281130999326706,
-0.276580274105072,
-0.16410590708255768,
0.42745426297187805,
-0.4878954291343689,
0.03156867250800133,
0.7238438725471497,
-0.8995356559753418,
0.24547800421714783,
-0.34596118330955505,
0.03223119676113129,
-1.1100175380706787,
-0.2153991013765335,
0.017252758145332336,
-0.4479743540287018,
-0.7951446771621704,
0.2823385000228882,
-0.3681276738643646,
-0.18665854632854462,
-0.5388308763504028,
0.38960471749305725,
-0.7054299116134644,
-0.20809562504291534,
-0.1392851322889328,
0.39417535066604614,
-0.1697411984205246,
0.011904703453183174,
0.543464183807373,
0.7865583896636963,
0.3455313742160797,
-0.5013259053230286,
0.3977213203907013,
0.5936552882194519,
-0.48769906163215637,
0.8111106753349304,
-0.625956118106842,
-0.04833987355232239,
-0.11185593158006668,
0.061916667968034744,
-0.8522074818611145,
-0.08635263890028,
0.3565126955509186,
-0.47782373428344727,
0.0689530074596405,
-0.07807916402816772,
-0.31214872002601624,
-0.10191889107227325,
0.4281013011932373,
0.14107181131839752,
0.028552982956171036,
-0.35888829827308655,
0.3026963770389557,
0.4004743695259094,
-0.11995879560709,
-0.25492340326309204,
-0.8990090489387512,
0.16178098320960999,
-0.12441710382699966,
-0.7131597995758057,
-0.3051008880138397,
-0.05994581803679466,
-0.4551560878753662,
0.10606164485216141,
0.2682809829711914,
-0.4490155279636383,
0.11815465241670609,
0.27221575379371643,
-0.22078004479408264,
-0.3806595206260681,
0.18387733399868011,
-0.40636971592903137,
-0.05803839489817619,
0.2953130304813385,
-0.1286284625530243,
0.30171531438827515,
-0.19151487946510315,
-0.28491562604904175,
-0.1266646832227707,
0.6283425688743591,
0.5826730132102966,
0.15843382477760315,
1.169276475906372,
0.25766780972480774,
-0.2552264928817749,
-0.06030193716287613,
-0.0751795768737793,
-0.07565402239561081,
-0.45399320125579834,
0.3500266373157501,
-0.6568042635917664,
-0.3997705280780792,
0.6344935297966003,
-0.015773067250847816,
-0.37878182530403137,
0.12578938901424408,
0.04761901870369911,
-0.3105291426181793,
0.9037759304046631,
0.7005667090415955,
0.2267574816942215,
0.6983634829521179,
-0.09372441470623016,
0.3750375807285309,
-0.6883211731910706,
-0.5668432712554932,
-0.6299834251403809,
-0.27889373898506165,
-0.5832853317260742,
-0.5580786466598511,
0.2112593650817871,
0.06881444901227951,
-0.0902496799826622,
0.8189125657081604,
-0.1278710514307022,
0.5700615644454956,
0.3411167562007904,
0.0556352324783802,
0.35075560212135315,
0.04525220766663551,
-0.0830342099070549,
-0.4502781629562378,
-0.606922447681427,
-0.6760150194168091,
0.4504525363445282,
0.4717550277709961,
0.9719961881637573,
0.5796827077865601,
0.5952489972114563,
0.10131716728210449,
0.22862116992473602,
-0.7274814248085022,
0.4382326006889343,
0.3731671869754791,
-0.4900859296321869,
-0.48609188199043274,
-0.45421111583709717,
-1.2460826635360718,
0.424633264541626,
-0.4125058650970459,
-0.8668561577796936,
0.4161839187145233,
-0.23074693977832794,
-0.11900219321250916,
0.13624751567840576,
-0.8004201054573059,
0.6283934116363525,
-0.3039580285549164,
-0.043214716017246246,
0.05372220277786255,
-0.7060635089874268,
-0.1399107724428177,
0.20066817104816437,
0.2060401439666748,
-0.04089650511741638,
-0.18172550201416016,
0.568718433380127,
-0.28374144434928894,
0.9354131817817688,
0.029913457110524178,
-0.22684958577156067,
0.6148605346679688,
0.12219098210334778,
0.26538318395614624,
-0.03028644062578678,
0.03144865483045578,
0.20971886813640594,
0.06108107417821884,
-0.47060680389404297,
-0.8000580072402954,
0.430158406496048,
-1.0845526456832886,
-0.1909126490354538,
-0.569743275642395,
-0.7368345260620117,
-0.11987189203500748,
0.22087466716766357,
0.08349039405584335,
0.2239914834499359,
-0.6268319487571716,
-0.2298322468996048,
0.38840100169181824,
0.10725780576467514,
0.3948461711406708,
0.8838866949081421,
-0.12454261630773544,
-0.20119933784008026,
0.8998820781707764,
-0.050946593284606934,
0.395590215921402,
0.6745014786720276,
0.24185620248317719,
-0.49454668164253235,
-0.48804420232772827,
-0.25041693449020386,
0.44347336888313293,
-0.5879361629486084,
0.02221301756799221,
-0.49137207865715027,
-0.32029932737350464,
-0.3319428563117981,
-0.36650437116622925,
-0.3513401448726654,
-0.14451655745506287,
0.06511978805065155,
-0.2508094906806946,
-0.09993502497673035,
1.4063827991485596,
-0.4482285976409912,
0.5675966739654541,
-0.929548442363739,
-0.2018277943134308,
0.0731678232550621,
0.15109698474407196,
-0.15487946569919586,
-0.2229008674621582,
-0.621729850769043,
0.2933267652988434,
-0.15026989579200745,
-1.2009234428405762,
0.523848831653595,
0.11966400593519211,
0.6385295987129211,
0.6272648572921753,
-0.44065889716148376,
0.8636211156845093,
-0.490520179271698,
0.7040224671363831,
0.058415237814188004,
-0.9235563278198242,
0.7059576511383057,
-0.48495763540267944,
0.38897329568862915,
0.35398975014686584,
0.2001490741968155,
-0.597892701625824,
-0.6975686550140381,
-0.8906546831130981,
-0.7521722912788391,
0.5047377347946167,
0.2635226547718048,
0.23220163583755493,
-0.452810138463974,
0.21086902916431427,
-0.5021852254867554,
0.30778929591178894,
-0.7751501798629761,
-0.41274452209472656,
0.17125576734542847,
0.25620952248573303,
-0.45437127351760864,
-0.34207966923713684,
-0.4989789128303528,
-0.15803688764572144,
-0.04664164036512375,
0.04915602132678032,
0.5334091186523438,
0.19767524302005768,
-0.0050660413689911366,
-0.541387140750885,
0.28439003229141235,
0.827692449092865,
0.9422499537467957,
0.029808366671204567,
0.4344962537288666,
-0.1673339605331421,
-0.5542573928833008,
0.33754855394363403,
-0.21520093083381653,
-0.2443350851535797,
0.26691100001335144,
0.6600925326347351,
0.45663076639175415,
0.554180383682251,
-0.36965590715408325,
0.46030282974243164,
-0.05783993378281593,
0.07874790579080582,
-0.3386261463165283,
-0.3466026484966278,
0.3779720366001129,
0.36550644040107727,
0.13621021807193756,
0.3141476511955261,
-0.09919987618923187,
-0.9032264351844788,
0.2833465039730072,
0.36056584119796753,
-0.5579720139503479,
-0.7264798283576965,
0.6158864498138428,
0.5511476397514343,
-0.2695818543434143,
0.5500553250312805,
-0.34832024574279785,
-0.4231733977794647,
0.4321202039718628,
1.218363642692566,
0.6398797631263733,
-0.31576716899871826,
0.6423773169517517,
0.4323614239692688,
0.3923148214817047,
0.27888768911361694,
0.30795079469680786,
-0.2178315371274948,
-1.3230419158935547,
-0.3568982481956482,
-0.5878162980079651,
-0.42228543758392334,
-0.22803378105163574,
-0.6647093892097473,
-0.36844900250434875,
-0.16301663219928741,
-0.1692122220993042,
-0.05507352948188782,
0.0948340892791748,
-0.3213852047920227,
-0.08365922421216965,
0.15594778954982758,
0.7166157364845276,
-1.3266063928604126,
0.38528868556022644,
1.2310645580291748,
-0.5514053702354431,
-1.112431287765503,
-0.23906320333480835,
-0.24407453835010529,
-0.7682321071624756,
0.9460480213165283,
-0.5498320460319519,
-0.08647684007883072,
-0.04406890645623207,
-0.5449283123016357,
-1.0299500226974487,
0.8908441066741943,
0.35094788670539856,
-0.17182181775569916,
0.14758111536502838,
0.3261338174343109,
0.9384765625,
-0.5183224081993103,
0.5053570866584778,
0.43696510791778564,
0.5339611172676086,
0.4393293559551239,
-0.8866038918495178,
-0.03520313277840614,
-0.014875495806336403,
0.18706810474395752,
0.33654507994651794,
-0.6493057608604431,
0.5492064952850342,
-0.5457972288131714,
-0.8019334673881531,
0.2446940839290619,
1.0717244148254395,
-0.22747592628002167,
0.33377745747566223,
0.18066126108169556,
0.22998227179050446,
0.7518086433410645,
-0.16921482980251312,
0.9856539368629456,
-0.31978118419647217,
-0.03648659586906433,
1.2634215354919434,
-0.29994305968284607,
0.9744324684143066,
0.5516536831855774,
-0.18584392964839935,
0.8575795292854309,
0.2129553258419037,
0.3293515741825104,
0.38300076127052307,
0.11033130437135696,
-0.7692403197288513,
0.07631661742925644,
-0.42311036586761475,
-0.07584750652313232,
0.5433553457260132,
0.46873366832733154,
-0.37367209792137146,
-0.3186695873737335,
-0.2050883173942566,
-0.03029564768075943,
0.6545014381408691,
0.052775368094444275,
1.000844120979309,
0.05839632451534271,
-0.4331241846084595,
-0.010088891722261906,
-0.3318464457988739,
0.05626983195543289,
-0.6254048943519592,
-0.21019849181175232,
0.009692334569990635,
0.02302154153585434,
-0.44518807530403137,
-1.0932852029800415,
0.6183027029037476,
-0.543982982635498,
-0.20177820324897766,
-0.2149435430765152,
0.589966356754303,
-0.8446055054664612,
-0.1048891618847847,
0.20635415613651276,
1.0363349914550781,
0.5488497018814087,
0.26947706937789917,
-0.47941601276397705,
0.029828723520040512,
-0.1952994018793106,
0.17310099303722382,
0.17603334784507751,
0.6469079852104187,
-0.05108582228422165,
0.7377604246139526,
0.5710713863372803,
0.8823176026344299,
0.19408810138702393,
0.11949414014816284,
0.4530715048313141,
-0.7557386159896851,
-0.4329203963279724,
-0.4978272020816803,
0.20199744403362274,
-0.04758139327168465,
-0.09726648777723312,
0.8728107213973999,
0.4356256127357483,
0.6754899024963379,
-0.17980949580669403,
0.8064022660255432,
-0.3264631927013397,
0.17519932985305786,
-0.10220836848020554,
0.6636061668395996,
0.4839712381362915,
0.08927272260189056,
-0.06695128232240677,
-1.0486057996749878,
0.09477777034044266,
1.1474887132644653,
-0.30045169591903687,
0.04862280189990997,
0.9744524359703064,
0.4280499219894409,
0.13489440083503723,
-0.17016816139221191,
0.6357073187828064,
0.4046388566493988,
0.3235553801059723,
0.535536527633667,
1.1663135290145874,
-0.27806323766708374,
0.6175547242164612,
-0.34294435381889343,
-0.2103673815727234,
0.3178384602069855,
-0.7316197752952576,
-0.5885120034217834,
-0.740500807762146,
-0.25870323181152344,
-0.3576929271221161,
0.19707602262496948,
0.5134638547897339,
0.7863844633102417,
-0.4855501651763916,
-0.6532730460166931,
-0.13169044256210327,
0.21657207608222961,
-0.5353651642799377,
-0.3402096629142761,
-0.11650214344263077,
-0.40231460332870483,
-0.8975444436073303,
0.5576896071434021,
0.16699030995368958,
0.4342237114906311,
-0.3133155107498169,
-0.11940887570381165,
-0.3288894295692444,
0.08492501080036163,
0.7738960385322571,
0.8292003870010376,
-0.25100114941596985,
-0.6766312122344971,
-0.3962123692035675,
-0.2646186947822571,
0.030301697552204132,
0.926847517490387,
-0.4002569019794464,
0.7198284268379211,
0.374927818775177,
0.14749029278755188,
0.20967023074626923,
0.4202703535556793,
1.0134952068328857,
-0.7847546339035034,
0.3544260561466217,
0.18327617645263672,
0.06617416441440582,
0.5847266912460327,
-0.5612515807151794,
0.45980963110923767,
0.26720014214515686,
-0.6552262902259827,
-0.238870307803154,
0.382184773683548,
-0.7269221544265747,
0.3247503340244293,
1.1547825336456299,
-0.18930493295192719,
-0.3362666368484497,
-0.4005943834781647,
-0.24408915638923645,
0.0476510152220726,
-0.5186060070991516,
0.46538305282592773,
0.7107264399528503,
-0.43981632590293884,
-0.02122943103313446,
-0.3820874094963074,
0.4768832325935364,
0.037536825984716415,
-0.6385498642921448,
-0.28793230652809143,
0.2984410226345062,
0.3305812180042267,
0.6993194222450256,
0.8854941725730896,
0.007833197712898254,
-0.04143475741147995,
0.447943776845932,
-0.13261528313159943,
0.40029293298721313,
-0.21321332454681396,
-0.033256154507398605,
-0.09603448212146759,
0.6438080072402954,
-0.34563198685646057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07268v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07268v1
|
Advancing Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition via LLM-Based Reformulation and Box-Based Segmentation
| 2024-06-11T13:52:29 | 2024-06-11T13:52:29 |
Jinyuan Li, Ziyan Li, Han Li, Jianfei Yu, Rui Xia, Di Sun, Gang Pan
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Grounded Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (GMNER) task aims to identify
named entities, entity types and their corresponding visual regions. GMNER task
exhibits two challenging attributes: 1) The tenuous correlation between images
and text on social media contributes to a notable proportion of named entities
being ungroundable. 2) There exists a distinction between coarse-grained noun
phrases used in similar tasks (e.g., phrase localization) and fine-grained
named entities. In this paper, we propose RiVEG, a unified framework that
reformulates GMNER into a joint MNER-VE-VG task by leveraging large language
models (LLMs) as connecting bridges. This reformulation brings two benefits: 1)
It enables us to optimize the MNER module for optimal MNER performance and
eliminates the need to pre-extract region features using object detection
methods, thus naturally addressing the two major limitations of existing GMNER
methods. 2) The introduction of Entity Expansion Expression module and Visual
Entailment (VE) module unifies Visual Grounding (VG) and Entity Grounding (EG).
This endows the proposed framework with unlimited data and model scalability.
Furthermore, to address the potential ambiguity stemming from the
coarse-grained bounding box output in GMNER, we further construct the new
Segmented Multimodal Named Entity Recognition (SMNER) task and corresponding
Twitter-SMNER dataset aimed at generating fine-grained segmentation masks, and
experimentally demonstrate the feasibility and effectiveness of using box
prompt-based Segment Anything Model (SAM) to empower any GMNER model with the
ability to accomplish the SMNER task. Extensive experiments demonstrate that
RiVEG significantly outperforms SoTA methods on four datasets across the MNER,
GMNER, and SMNER tasks.
|
[
-0.5953665375709534,
-0.9377028346061707,
0.5441154837608337,
0.006575362756848335,
-0.28711843490600586,
0.05281505361199379,
-0.2913895547389984,
-0.27400892972946167,
0.04678932949900627,
0.5231119394302368,
-0.6541109085083008,
-0.5246027112007141,
-0.6805949807167053,
0.07131160795688629,
-0.12096282839775085,
0.8345940113067627,
-0.06807734072208405,
0.03570178896188736,
-0.3008471131324768,
-0.16178879141807556,
-0.6394221782684326,
-0.16107483208179474,
-0.6795713901519775,
-0.35230451822280884,
0.5132084488868713,
0.40749719738960266,
0.37526988983154297,
0.7754671573638916,
0.562842607498169,
0.3746502101421356,
-0.042976174503564835,
0.3609801232814789,
-0.5377673506736755,
0.24375396966934204,
-0.15369300544261932,
-0.19794142246246338,
-0.26623648405075073,
-0.124091736972332,
0.5379573702812195,
0.338029682636261,
-0.0007053244626149535,
0.009140992537140846,
-0.0709947794675827,
0.38614562153816223,
-0.5194829106330872,
0.29959723353385925,
-0.7727389931678772,
-0.003976556938141584,
-0.15246395766735077,
-0.359365314245224,
-0.33332380652427673,
0.12285003811120987,
-0.0975111722946167,
-0.6073019504547119,
0.3835224509239197,
0.058280687779188156,
1.1710519790649414,
0.3567889928817749,
-0.5220482349395752,
-0.21609199047088623,
-0.48690274357795715,
0.7612754106521606,
-0.33679431676864624,
0.7914685606956482,
-0.09924349188804626,
0.3617442846298218,
-0.35867542028427124,
-0.7999148964881897,
-0.31339016556739807,
-0.23517195880413055,
0.0057867467403411865,
0.029022153466939926,
-0.15128661692142487,
0.1574607491493225,
0.3299851715564728,
0.31359782814979553,
-0.19486074149608612,
-0.06933121383190155,
-0.4693767726421356,
-0.13736186921596527,
0.30167296528816223,
0.04911665618419647,
0.45318329334259033,
-0.48355525732040405,
-0.6871581077575684,
0.128970205783844,
-0.578819215297699,
0.30734312534332275,
-0.07974427938461304,
0.2352466881275177,
0.12644214928150177,
0.7072818875312805,
-0.28686708211898804,
0.49488458037376404,
0.3570300340652466,
-0.4857563078403473,
0.08915218710899353,
-0.04376143217086792,
-0.45874667167663574,
-0.11534231156110764,
0.8039292693138123,
0.7782905697822571,
0.23312346637248993,
-0.34349653124809265,
-0.3316916525363922,
0.008474192582070827,
0.22470971941947937,
-1.0740034580230713,
-0.3394038677215576,
-0.042579080909490585,
-0.37640661001205444,
-0.13563548028469086,
0.16963143646717072,
-0.8612613081932068,
-0.5203065276145935,
-0.5779271125793457,
0.28596919775009155,
-0.4837424159049988,
-0.10140007734298706,
-0.041492149233818054,
-0.044224292039871216,
0.32501164078712463,
0.5951530933380127,
-0.48824676871299744,
0.03496444225311279,
0.6647599339485168,
0.6893358826637268,
-0.025179844349622726,
0.015215856023132801,
-0.6898602843284607,
0.17774859070777893,
-0.08688933402299881,
0.8591983914375305,
-0.6370753049850464,
-0.3830517530441284,
-0.4033736288547516,
0.5943878293037415,
-0.11517001688480377,
-0.44753825664520264,
0.3884522616863251,
-0.5419155955314636,
-0.03328748047351837,
-0.14054933190345764,
-0.47561344504356384,
-0.25488415360450745,
0.5481843948364258,
-0.6023849248886108,
0.7431775331497192,
-0.19617792963981628,
-0.7526568174362183,
0.519989550113678,
-0.3759993612766266,
-0.08623859286308289,
0.22859418392181396,
-0.5954524874687195,
-0.4618152976036072,
0.17278873920440674,
0.5434454083442688,
0.8461610674858093,
-0.3209916055202484,
0.6325831413269043,
-0.24366870522499084,
-0.18032655119895935,
0.06948654353618622,
-0.3666980564594269,
0.253213495016098,
0.0069887530989944935,
-0.18078932166099548,
0.21096698939800262,
-0.8580271005630493,
0.2549375593662262,
0.11473237723112106,
-0.4206603765487671,
-0.30052506923675537,
-0.030800098553299904,
0.30860838294029236,
0.11492844671010971,
-0.057159941643476486,
-0.4139809310436249,
0.2166982740163803,
0.13874411582946777,
0.558999240398407,
0.6122803688049316,
0.2383061647415161,
0.6466941833496094,
-0.019016556441783905,
0.5324278473854065,
0.12864412367343903,
-0.17973829805850983,
-0.589903712272644,
-0.403502881526947,
-0.7922065854072571,
-0.8278164267539978,
0.5517101883888245,
0.5142847895622253,
-0.8606919050216675,
0.1820032149553299,
-0.6069738864898682,
-0.3626761734485626,
-0.5053815245628357,
-0.11324413120746613,
0.2848997414112091,
0.3774825632572174,
0.4014686644077301,
-0.03474780172109604,
-0.5688584446907043,
-1.0705903768539429,
-0.08080577850341797,
0.232269287109375,
-0.016191095113754272,
0.4859876334667206,
0.4796459376811981,
-0.6961780190467834,
1.1104289293289185,
-0.35350945591926575,
-0.46129360795021057,
-0.08884606510400772,
0.161719411611557,
0.00520992511883378,
0.5860582590103149,
0.2096509337425232,
-1.0775575637817383,
-0.36937546730041504,
0.2493399977684021,
-0.6928622126579285,
-0.0031143082305788994,
-0.19618792831897736,
0.11782697588205338,
-0.4148806929588318,
0.7430194616317749,
-0.6681213974952698,
0.3011362552642822,
0.33585068583488464,
-0.11986835300922394,
0.2797202467918396,
0.04759220778942108,
0.33822348713874817,
-1.1829830408096313,
-0.3002515733242035,
0.1819915771484375,
-0.5805560946464539,
-0.7153752446174622,
0.2159111350774765,
0.14771033823490143,
-0.28089436888694763,
-0.3907748758792877,
0.6318380236625671,
-0.8426024913787842,
0.11724629998207092,
-0.4004812240600586,
0.14486674964427948,
0.14079077541828156,
0.37402886152267456,
-0.15518519282341003,
0.8840681910514832,
0.6905494928359985,
-0.5795927047729492,
0.2512839734554291,
-0.07697903364896774,
-0.08884180337190628,
0.6722533106803894,
-0.7633235454559326,
-0.005461157765239477,
-0.5842962861061096,
0.13239002227783203,
-0.8307710289955139,
-0.45291614532470703,
0.4190363883972168,
-0.41005370020866394,
0.5282773375511169,
-0.6590142250061035,
-0.24426397681236267,
0.06165795028209686,
-0.09544722735881805,
0.42688775062561035,
0.37312883138656616,
-0.5168036222457886,
1.1860644817352295,
0.4315948188304901,
-0.039488568902015686,
-0.39022013545036316,
-0.5173378586769104,
0.18284329771995544,
-0.40586286783218384,
-0.6864433288574219,
0.5785024166107178,
0.2951231300830841,
-0.12193353474140167,
0.22672538459300995,
-0.4392045736312866,
-0.10787840187549591,
-0.08685684949159622,
0.6333250999450684,
0.10736791789531708,
-0.28927841782569885,
0.07216963917016983,
-0.13861961662769318,
-0.3654748797416687,
-0.14862792193889618,
-0.06423880159854889,
0.3847609758377075,
-0.238301083445549,
-0.3520753085613251,
-0.15024620294570923,
0.2222224920988083,
0.5781325697898865,
-0.4718500077724457,
0.5594769716262817,
0.9155749678611755,
-0.5209604501724243,
-0.05391407385468483,
-0.765017032623291,
0.047122519463300705,
-0.43385106325149536,
0.3017588257789612,
-0.8730685710906982,
-1.3416639566421509,
0.41392454504966736,
-0.4931033253669739,
-0.07459928840398788,
0.35678941011428833,
0.31224918365478516,
0.03677939623594284,
0.7602479457855225,
0.697211742401123,
0.15632708370685577,
0.4467692971229553,
-0.21843692660331726,
0.36335840821266174,
-1.119528889656067,
-0.35313665866851807,
-0.09290508925914764,
-0.17193414270877838,
-0.6665397882461548,
-0.8317589163780212,
0.13361519575119019,
0.48799312114715576,
0.3504393994808197,
0.275567889213562,
-0.5431973934173584,
0.6446804404258728,
0.21915557980537415,
0.0627644956111908,
0.06321363151073456,
0.0003963103808928281,
-0.15383611619472504,
-0.2560766339302063,
-0.3337279260158539,
-0.6212620735168457,
0.6890519261360168,
0.5055736303329468,
0.7794066071510315,
-0.2548983097076416,
0.7313444018363953,
0.21436916291713715,
0.39726537466049194,
-0.9577968120574951,
0.688875138759613,
0.08066659420728683,
-0.4464329481124878,
-0.11562075465917587,
-0.340290367603302,
-0.7637979984283447,
0.7428306937217712,
-0.19289273023605347,
-0.8592708110809326,
0.26058927178382874,
-0.0775919184088707,
-0.15157899260520935,
0.2770070433616638,
-0.6876465678215027,
0.8551607728004456,
-0.023193126544356346,
-0.12095233798027039,
0.2861934304237366,
-0.38831591606140137,
0.4459135830402374,
0.058364275842905045,
0.34025368094444275,
-0.40965527296066284,
0.03473817929625511,
0.5687064528465271,
0.0591023713350296,
0.6640599966049194,
-0.29663383960723877,
0.055161334574222565,
0.19391794502735138,
-0.18182243406772614,
0.5832223892211914,
0.39991894364356995,
0.5248511433601379,
0.10119321197271347,
-0.2892579734325409,
-0.0308538768440485,
-0.600045382976532,
0.7830971479415894,
-0.3454623222351074,
-0.6198589205741882,
-0.2751785218715668,
-0.396330863237381,
0.06378255039453506,
0.45856109261512756,
0.13105084002017975,
0.4476504325866699,
-0.2788624167442322,
0.6476607322692871,
0.8747631311416626,
0.039310306310653687,
0.12705187499523163,
0.233108788728714,
-0.4769304096698761,
-0.7805103659629822,
0.8310440182685852,
-0.030093127861618996,
-0.18708200752735138,
0.4995269477367401,
-0.24689540266990662,
-0.12928029894828796,
-0.34528160095214844,
-0.4754771888256073,
0.24067659676074982,
-0.8143556118011475,
-0.30695459246635437,
-1.1081784963607788,
-0.23323415219783783,
-0.1700500249862671,
-0.30752331018447876,
-0.3296157419681549,
0.03958971053361893,
-0.3549199104309082,
-0.10732585191726685,
0.18489447236061096,
0.3936302363872528,
0.25077149271965027,
0.39736586809158325,
-0.6753654479980469,
0.7610454559326172,
0.29648423194885254,
0.09417637437582016,
-0.3872234523296356,
-0.32724300026893616,
0.06832809746265411,
0.08528094738721848,
-0.015824278816580772,
-0.8847204446792603,
0.07121584564447403,
0.03765466809272766,
0.5226922035217285,
0.5735794901847839,
-0.24887917935848236,
1.168161153793335,
-1.00685453414917,
0.3471481502056122,
0.3040786683559418,
-0.6693983674049377,
0.2752266228199005,
-0.2986229360103607,
0.027629470452666283,
0.45062774419784546,
0.06817571073770523,
-0.6227816939353943,
-0.11450058966875076,
-0.44032666087150574,
-1.0032345056533813,
0.5674921274185181,
0.24681982398033142,
0.11799869686365128,
-0.08311652392148972,
0.20410674810409546,
-0.04581564664840698,
0.11985545605421066,
-0.9291257262229919,
-0.16416195034980774,
-0.06785037368535995,
-0.053455449640750885,
-0.04517288878560066,
-0.4472026824951172,
-0.07565361261367798,
-0.07116153836250305,
0.42237043380737305,
-0.13951388001441956,
0.3338761031627655,
0.13497738540172577,
-0.28632041811943054,
0.1453733742237091,
0.721531331539154,
0.4182671904563904,
0.3554627597332001,
-0.0764918178319931,
0.21131157875061035,
0.13564683496952057,
-0.19049672782421112,
0.3544984757900238,
0.2562573254108429,
-0.4429531693458557,
0.1640569567680359,
0.14953964948654175,
0.9568172693252563,
0.5506415963172913,
-0.5520951747894287,
0.431257039308548,
-0.087258480489254,
-0.1281612366437912,
-0.2815681993961334,
0.08145680278539658,
0.150150328874588,
0.5223039388656616,
0.29166027903556824,
0.29073217511177063,
0.08483067899942398,
-0.17726710438728333,
0.3904727101325989,
0.5880864262580872,
-0.48993971943855286,
-0.14734871685504913,
0.6496352553367615,
-0.03363708034157753,
-0.23143568634986877,
0.28770482540130615,
-0.4592367112636566,
-0.45224398374557495,
0.5070235133171082,
0.5128920674324036,
0.9116618633270264,
-0.008891323581337929,
0.12777549028396606,
0.24079622328281403,
0.38539430499076843,
-0.18277767300605774,
0.10770437866449356,
-0.06422066688537598,
-0.716068685054779,
-0.2939358353614807,
-0.5305044054985046,
0.040262091904878616,
0.2636743187904358,
-0.6024118661880493,
0.3544270396232605,
-0.4195382297039032,
-0.42450594902038574,
0.12745776772499084,
-0.4865727424621582,
-0.8356831073760986,
0.4816358983516693,
0.12656717002391815,
0.5701813101768494,
-0.5702181458473206,
0.44913071393966675,
1.2603706121444702,
-0.255892813205719,
-0.6664190292358398,
0.061618074774742126,
-0.015577024780213833,
-0.537659227848053,
0.7146546244621277,
0.7542782425880432,
-0.17661982774734497,
0.267147034406662,
-0.3334397077560425,
-0.9134098291397095,
1.3881795406341553,
0.017618363723158836,
-0.5605445504188538,
-0.14938730001449585,
-0.12461231648921967,
0.11724791675806046,
-0.610024631023407,
0.20602256059646606,
0.11963003128767014,
0.5773205757141113,
0.18080037832260132,
-0.49378716945648193,
0.00824787374585867,
-0.15089350938796997,
0.4324769675731659,
0.5082184672355652,
-0.43554842472076416,
0.7896869778633118,
-0.12644346058368683,
-0.6468573212623596,
-0.2494601309299469,
0.8684571385383606,
0.3889545202255249,
0.3558095693588257,
0.616383969783783,
0.7817584276199341,
0.6383911967277527,
-0.2871273458003998,
0.500749409198761,
-0.10713958740234375,
0.5306020975112915,
0.8961748480796814,
-0.2128673493862152,
0.47636204957962036,
0.6077025532722473,
0.047609005123376846,
0.09882386773824692,
0.2876121401786804,
-0.3076828420162201,
0.6779332756996155,
0.140572652220726,
-0.15407538414001465,
-0.37347450852394104,
-0.29406243562698364,
-0.1823248267173767,
0.48972293734550476,
0.28416240215301514,
-0.27106761932373047,
-0.6124733686447144,
0.4063345789909363,
0.23459547758102417,
-0.17924220860004425,
-0.35553160309791565,
0.6688244938850403,
0.06086839362978935,
-0.17473991215229034,
0.24805700778961182,
0.5030147433280945,
0.7634741067886353,
-0.23997078835964203,
-0.17835411429405212,
0.11472689360380173,
0.19714924693107605,
-0.08866902440786362,
-0.4997864067554474,
-0.01667408086359501,
0.10223795473575592,
-0.315067857503891,
-0.2568749785423279,
1.2268532514572144,
-0.5406039953231812,
-0.4902160167694092,
0.19518481194972992,
0.5514668822288513,
0.10583893209695816,
-0.21734975278377533,
-0.6549229621887207,
0.1785992681980133,
0.16034667193889618,
-0.3652113080024719,
0.11920850723981857,
0.881273627281189,
-0.13431844115257263,
0.8100069165229797,
0.7112869024276733,
-0.26192808151245117,
0.28999224305152893,
0.021580636501312256,
1.0456870794296265,
-0.7142907381057739,
-0.27837806940078735,
-0.96245276927948,
0.8621732592582703,
0.023204287514090538,
0.09614907950162888,
0.7303745746612549,
0.5208253860473633,
0.826103687286377,
-0.2751930356025696,
0.5468869209289551,
-0.3030250370502472,
0.1771199256181717,
-0.7273938059806824,
0.4275496006011963,
-0.6244208812713623,
-0.05734223872423172,
-0.2292705923318863,
-0.9601291418075562,
-0.17057397961616516,
0.5383816957473755,
-0.2209833562374115,
0.04864389821887016,
0.6091921925544739,
0.7590218782424927,
-0.5903850793838501,
-0.35796424746513367,
0.5010698437690735,
-0.05431477725505829,
0.5271382331848145,
0.13470526039600372,
0.8599129915237427,
-0.5434116721153259,
0.30624470114707947,
-0.18429948389530182,
-0.06934209167957306,
-0.2591368854045868,
-0.8783572316169739,
-1.1449304819107056,
-0.4689062237739563,
-0.4570119380950928,
-0.016590939834713936,
0.018514035269618034,
0.9947820901870728,
0.7888541221618652,
-0.7255491614341736,
0.29788514971733093,
-0.1041981652379036,
-0.013521367684006691,
0.12996700406074524,
-0.30763545632362366,
0.05463024601340294,
-0.277100145816803,
-0.6238046884536743,
0.6095358729362488,
0.45330679416656494,
0.009208611212670803,
0.04862241819500923,
0.11117954552173615,
0.020135991275310516,
-0.14719095826148987,
0.5459386110305786,
0.027183769270777702,
-1.1352258920669556,
-0.22203175723552704,
0.07651116698980331,
-0.05606646463274956,
0.11873655021190643,
0.8191375732421875,
-0.6391239166259766,
0.31868669390678406,
0.1623193919658661,
0.9750800132751465,
0.2561759054660797,
0.44301775097846985,
0.10165498405694962,
-0.830650269985199,
0.11935989558696747,
0.01576966792345047,
0.6722254157066345,
0.4286552369594574,
-0.3160504102706909,
0.3080472946166992,
0.3917916417121887,
-0.5139350295066833,
-0.7556255459785461,
0.32935231924057007,
-0.9395101070404053,
-0.03598373010754585,
1.1526339054107666,
-0.1596459448337555,
-0.3131345808506012,
0.12748390436172485,
-0.4470296800136566,
0.1106831282377243,
-0.5218473076820374,
0.2535666227340698,
0.6931476593017578,
0.1627788096666336,
-0.8346907496452332,
-0.630596399307251,
0.1945583075284958,
-0.13015203177928925,
-0.6851177215576172,
-0.17120559513568878,
0.7066494226455688,
0.5479742884635925,
0.23974426090717316,
0.6508845090866089,
0.024281147867441177,
-0.04304274916648865,
-0.1569492667913437,
0.3352079689502716,
-0.46898892521858215,
-0.6627343893051147,
-0.20052506029605865,
0.2789612114429474,
-0.2673938572406769,
-0.39830538630485535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07594v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07594v2
|
MLLMGuard: A Multi-dimensional Safety Evaluation Suite for Multimodal Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T13:41:33 | 2024-06-13T11:22:15 |
Tianle Gu, Zeyang Zhou, Kexin Huang, Dandan Liang, Yixu Wang, Haiquan Zhao, Yuanqi Yao, Xingge Qiao, Keqing Wang, Yujiu Yang, Yan Teng, Yu Qiao, Yingchun Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CR
|
Powered by remarkable advancements in Large Language Models (LLMs),
Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs) demonstrate impressive capabilities in
manifold tasks. However, the practical application scenarios of MLLMs are
intricate, exposing them to potential malicious instructions and thereby posing
safety risks. While current benchmarks do incorporate certain safety
considerations, they often lack comprehensive coverage and fail to exhibit the
necessary rigor and robustness. For instance, the common practice of employing
GPT-4V as both the evaluator and a model to be evaluated lacks credibility, as
it tends to exhibit a bias toward its own responses. In this paper, we present
MLLMGuard, a multidimensional safety evaluation suite for MLLMs, including a
bilingual image-text evaluation dataset, inference utilities, and a lightweight
evaluator. MLLMGuard's assessment comprehensively covers two languages (English
and Chinese) and five important safety dimensions (Privacy, Bias, Toxicity,
Truthfulness, and Legality), each with corresponding rich subtasks. Focusing on
these dimensions, our evaluation dataset is primarily sourced from platforms
such as social media, and it integrates text-based and image-based red teaming
techniques with meticulous annotation by human experts. This can prevent
inaccurate evaluation caused by data leakage when using open-source datasets
and ensures the quality and challenging nature of our benchmark. Additionally,
a fully automated lightweight evaluator termed GuardRank is developed, which
achieves significantly higher evaluation accuracy than GPT-4. Our evaluation
results across 13 advanced models indicate that MLLMs still have a substantial
journey ahead before they can be considered safe and responsible.
|
[
-0.3103794455528259,
-0.5549745559692383,
0.42330145835876465,
0.4481481909751892,
-0.1103651374578476,
0.40335822105407715,
0.05095186084508896,
-0.46723249554634094,
-0.4315698742866516,
0.4318797290325165,
-0.35582566261291504,
-0.5973585844039917,
-0.669583797454834,
-0.07897897809743881,
-0.06483720242977142,
1.1408956050872803,
-0.18308025598526,
0.03966444730758667,
-0.016968460753560066,
-0.27634957432746887,
-0.48200342059135437,
-0.6921497583389282,
-0.4757905900478363,
-0.05898134782910347,
0.7716913223266602,
-0.1436329483985901,
0.5584120154380798,
0.27411341667175293,
0.6956408023834229,
0.3028585612773895,
0.0034460676833987236,
0.33691638708114624,
-0.2693967819213867,
0.21430261433124542,
-0.046405062079429626,
0.10147680342197418,
-0.46776628494262695,
0.09512221068143845,
0.5360047221183777,
0.12616103887557983,
-0.013607905246317387,
0.23374983668327332,
0.12498218566179276,
0.6745070219039917,
-0.9726224541664124,
0.05218205228447914,
-0.5959203839302063,
0.2321418672800064,
-0.16099920868873596,
-0.13522054255008698,
-0.42181769013404846,
-0.18920311331748962,
0.18468092381954193,
-0.181706503033638,
-0.3175164461135864,
0.2027052342891693,
0.4234769642353058,
0.01774595119059086,
-0.6278687119483948,
0.029646078124642372,
-0.4495929181575775,
1.0027443170547485,
-0.5586653351783752,
0.4586191773414612,
0.4610322117805481,
0.6925516128540039,
0.11944228410720825,
-0.6307022571563721,
-0.1806737631559372,
-0.3364308774471283,
0.03853711485862732,
0.05674799531698227,
-0.04139197617769241,
0.17299118638038635,
0.1258617639541626,
-0.21614983677864075,
-0.846622109413147,
0.27608367800712585,
-0.33503279089927673,
-0.6002350449562073,
0.8705958127975464,
0.27549460530281067,
0.42898446321487427,
-0.09317575395107269,
-0.7881778478622437,
-0.25032517313957214,
-0.7569001913070679,
0.2960202693939209,
0.34277376532554626,
0.2581980526447296,
-0.3628421127796173,
0.3182910680770874,
0.05160590261220932,
0.5464224219322205,
-0.4791634678840637,
-0.5595626831054688,
0.5033737421035767,
-0.38039129972457886,
-0.32341888546943665,
0.0782744362950325,
1.0417351722717285,
0.8339346647262573,
0.13208068907260895,
-0.10290512442588806,
-0.2907089293003082,
-0.0669853538274765,
0.2669495642185211,
-0.9168092608451843,
-0.13338075578212738,
0.4972778558731079,
-0.644730806350708,
-0.43126949667930603,
-0.0336453877389431,
-1.0309231281280518,
-0.7183268070220947,
-0.1587686538696289,
0.4774955213069916,
-0.16553957760334015,
-0.25020965933799744,
0.1856309473514557,
-0.02067624218761921,
0.04454202204942703,
0.20310766994953156,
-0.5451947450637817,
0.04687346890568733,
0.595989465713501,
0.855789303779602,
-0.3723044693470001,
-0.5276272892951965,
-0.6953290700912476,
0.13362960517406464,
-0.08011232316493988,
0.5611812472343445,
-0.46566063165664673,
-0.24393104016780853,
0.17283156514167786,
0.026506466791033745,
-0.21895620226860046,
-0.07169758528470993,
0.7446833252906799,
-0.5390218496322632,
0.086473248898983,
0.018781399354338646,
-0.2586897313594818,
-0.061810508370399475,
0.6808350086212158,
-0.7697926163673401,
0.660528302192688,
-0.33957168459892273,
-1.1158007383346558,
0.3961448669433594,
-0.5180710554122925,
-0.30705931782722473,
-0.21547941863536835,
-0.015622521750628948,
-0.7728980183601379,
-0.41291508078575134,
0.43708309531211853,
0.5055119395256042,
-0.0021782503463327885,
0.055466193705797195,
-0.7013389468193054,
-0.24292956292629242,
0.17888808250427246,
-0.8744657039642334,
0.8867044448852539,
0.25366321206092834,
-0.40936189889907837,
0.4002106189727783,
-0.46338707208633423,
0.20830370485782623,
0.004812636878341436,
-0.5077996253967285,
-0.3657185137271881,
-0.14892594516277313,
0.3116651177406311,
0.49211385846138,
0.2879820466041565,
-0.6729537844657898,
-0.16712602972984314,
0.10474757105112076,
0.2174205482006073,
1.027922511100769,
0.05721161887049675,
0.14913630485534668,
-0.11816710233688354,
0.561836838722229,
-0.2368268519639969,
0.7668992877006531,
-0.2031739503145218,
-0.563580334186554,
-0.3099178373813629,
-0.41801655292510986,
0.06660569459199905,
0.6252482533454895,
-0.8262043595314026,
0.2508527636528015,
-0.22098088264465332,
-0.6098291277885437,
-0.3408111333847046,
0.2527799606323242,
0.8080157041549683,
-0.036052435636520386,
0.4343946576118469,
0.07340288907289505,
-0.4440500736236572,
-0.9119321703910828,
-0.35944491624832153,
-0.003755589248612523,
0.1766759753227234,
0.1963721215724945,
0.4001927673816681,
-0.3789789378643036,
0.3688059449195862,
-0.18194842338562012,
-0.15901577472686768,
-0.3212980329990387,
-0.18690712749958038,
-0.012849584221839905,
0.2921338379383087,
0.7063372135162354,
-0.7807860374450684,
-0.5867160558700562,
0.04936939850449562,
-0.8510805368423462,
0.12206821888685226,
-0.06675275415182114,
-0.30040714144706726,
0.2084835022687912,
0.3496699333190918,
-0.5781003832817078,
0.1782510131597519,
1.0972274541854858,
-0.44161978363990784,
0.8326838612556458,
-0.2673969268798828,
0.030004339292645454,
-0.7432891726493835,
0.17744122445583344,
0.06270618736743927,
-0.2206064611673355,
-0.7442253232002258,
0.2179504930973053,
0.23443320393562317,
0.03761380910873413,
-0.5953772664070129,
0.7716856002807617,
-0.3715072572231293,
0.0688360184431076,
0.0019757384434342384,
0.19406093657016754,
0.1487000435590744,
0.20708103477954865,
-0.18118833005428314,
0.5305064916610718,
0.5052017569541931,
-0.46591854095458984,
0.4670472741127014,
-0.04526328667998314,
-0.4526771605014801,
0.3808855712413788,
-0.5609051585197449,
0.21671880781650543,
0.08500708639621735,
0.31368187069892883,
-0.5142035484313965,
-0.027643078938126564,
0.01729809306561947,
0.06224769726395607,
0.34126678109169006,
-0.16585175693035126,
-0.6332623362541199,
-0.5973948240280151,
-0.881321132183075,
0.19987842440605164,
0.19223842024803162,
-0.5410999655723572,
0.5667036175727844,
0.7727315425872803,
-0.1654544174671173,
-1.0653069019317627,
-0.5180606842041016,
0.24545609951019287,
-0.5889277458190918,
-0.5822216868400574,
-0.005703992210328579,
-0.1717592179775238,
-0.3299717903137207,
-0.31237709522247314,
-0.08727430552244186,
-0.11088798940181732,
0.18576516211032867,
0.15988662838935852,
0.5489688515663147,
0.17747710645198822,
-0.003438103012740612,
-0.031195133924484253,
-0.10004689544439316,
0.0871991291642189,
0.07412782311439514,
0.46628859639167786,
-0.3588666319847107,
-0.6720896363258362,
-0.11932501941919327,
0.07032162696123123,
0.7458792924880981,
-0.47921285033226013,
0.6046815514564514,
0.7898464798927307,
-0.09980495274066925,
-0.13614772260189056,
-0.47181782126426697,
0.04499363526701927,
-0.4929623603820801,
0.34375739097595215,
-0.2380918711423874,
-0.941016435623169,
0.20431247353553772,
0.38612455129623413,
0.5441932678222656,
0.17260803282260895,
0.5571657419204712,
-0.08769848197698593,
1.1001689434051514,
0.29881608486175537,
-0.32675808668136597,
0.20799022912979126,
0.13611938059329987,
0.32317355275154114,
-0.6281754970550537,
-0.34411925077438354,
-0.22417612373828888,
-0.2092846930027008,
-0.5600250363349915,
-0.3394739329814911,
0.5730425715446472,
-0.32109639048576355,
-0.4268234670162201,
0.30015385150909424,
-0.36973968148231506,
0.422532320022583,
0.26589804887771606,
0.04051892086863518,
0.17724336683750153,
-0.011629939079284668,
-0.3376079797744751,
-0.15092159807682037,
-0.39226818084716797,
-0.6057447791099548,
1.265108346939087,
0.7767677903175354,
0.8892284035682678,
0.43245577812194824,
0.5021752715110779,
0.45133090019226074,
0.4185512363910675,
-0.31874969601631165,
0.4381932020187378,
-0.18385891616344452,
-0.8118686676025391,
-0.2723931670188904,
-0.5386109352111816,
-0.9795247316360474,
0.7895713448524475,
-0.420600950717926,
-0.7323826551437378,
-0.21251456439495087,
0.08176539093255997,
-0.3591950535774231,
0.3752574920654297,
-0.7596465945243835,
0.9362808465957642,
-0.8091866970062256,
-0.5433027744293213,
-0.13603785634040833,
-0.762589156627655,
0.969907283782959,
-0.3739449381828308,
0.43346431851387024,
-0.32321590185165405,
0.13975323736667633,
0.37859007716178894,
-0.21475538611412048,
0.8505699038505554,
-0.4334731698036194,
-0.1408943086862564,
0.02804979681968689,
0.08094913512468338,
0.5108283162117004,
-0.07556707412004471,
0.0008151669753715396,
0.14804579317569733,
0.1331566423177719,
-0.17271140217781067,
-0.4037199020385742,
0.7751853466033936,
-0.4069029688835144,
-0.32896915078163147,
-0.291236013174057,
-0.3733992576599121,
-0.38901016116142273,
0.17931731045246124,
-0.07754193991422653,
0.3409784734249115,
-0.1599808633327484,
0.26059719920158386,
0.5528209209442139,
-0.6679521799087524,
0.5793803334236145,
0.33718225359916687,
-0.5302736759185791,
-0.48241639137268066,
0.9202733635902405,
-0.09635957330465317,
0.26989006996154785,
0.22928038239479065,
0.26260948181152344,
-0.65803462266922,
-0.49989885091781616,
-0.6753962635993958,
-0.07328231632709503,
-0.7530533671379089,
-0.3087151050567627,
-0.7011252045631409,
-0.4426546096801758,
-0.07039692252874374,
0.11841325461864471,
-0.27571260929107666,
-0.1968500167131424,
0.6076050400733948,
-0.2560940384864807,
0.09809976816177368,
0.5785360336303711,
0.06158612668514252,
-0.2726591229438782,
-1.0706539154052734,
0.11695369333028793,
0.4975401759147644,
0.3549093008041382,
-0.0561707578599453,
-0.1723507195711136,
-0.23659026622772217,
-0.24087409675121307,
-0.2594633102416992,
-0.4261571764945984,
0.20435766875743866,
-0.06528058648109436,
1.016012191772461,
0.43287596106529236,
0.11144758760929108,
0.27383822202682495,
-0.7143601775169373,
0.6716060638427734,
0.28902408480644226,
-0.6769884824752808,
0.2500808835029602,
-0.33241739869117737,
0.06274592131376266,
0.4755275249481201,
0.10637132078409195,
-0.3414236009120941,
-0.21507444977760315,
-0.23771879076957703,
-0.8338000774383545,
0.19319093227386475,
0.30936509370803833,
0.17438821494579315,
0.2539098858833313,
-0.4541059136390686,
-0.11039165407419205,
0.1426486223936081,
-0.9713438153266907,
-0.06630633026361465,
-0.3620088994503021,
0.0009431046200916171,
0.002563254674896598,
-0.3230934143066406,
-0.44237181544303894,
0.14876246452331543,
0.5163295865058899,
-0.10124287009239197,
-0.01801631599664688,
-0.18923109769821167,
-0.20645545423030853,
0.41808295249938965,
0.39639386534690857,
0.8465657234191895,
0.39731836318969727,
-0.16822250187397003,
0.5203356742858887,
0.35181349515914917,
-0.5417428016662598,
0.22155502438545227,
0.27593299746513367,
0.05079340189695358,
-0.07147732377052307,
0.6568845510482788,
0.571854293346405,
0.13595551252365112,
-0.9009471535682678,
0.7767993211746216,
-0.1756429523229599,
0.000039879963878775015,
-0.06974957138299942,
-0.16826246678829193,
0.04656005650758743,
0.17432402074337006,
0.04055728390812874,
0.11038223654031754,
0.13132040202617645,
-0.2586002051830292,
0.2082574963569641,
0.5969634652137756,
-0.36804646253585815,
-0.11007967591285706,
0.4580034613609314,
0.315975546836853,
0.17116451263427734,
0.08769707381725311,
-0.06887432932853699,
-0.6479067206382751,
0.4321841895580292,
0.13857285678386688,
0.990121603012085,
-0.4311661720275879,
0.11550431698560715,
0.35642117261886597,
0.7342339754104614,
-0.04107058793306351,
-0.07859089225530624,
0.14180609583854675,
-0.6984453797340393,
-0.421857088804245,
-0.7844805717468262,
-0.2495087832212448,
0.19842292368412018,
-0.2966611981391907,
0.01817476563155651,
-0.7717245221138,
-0.32389596104621887,
-0.2340942621231079,
-0.2579365670681,
-0.4640261232852936,
0.05897108092904091,
0.3412512540817261,
0.9651613235473633,
-0.7112374305725098,
0.6658822298049927,
0.3919764757156372,
-0.13054847717285156,
-0.538882315158844,
0.04501447454094887,
0.42086154222488403,
-0.7654560804367065,
0.76583331823349,
0.5195543169975281,
-0.4426601231098175,
-0.7078490257263184,
-0.1398228108882904,
-0.6381292343139648,
0.9943356513977051,
0.3017039895057678,
-0.6040077805519104,
0.1359596848487854,
0.08427257090806961,
0.4813283085823059,
-0.2048666626214981,
0.010117468424141407,
0.49337315559387207,
0.7256847023963928,
-0.4075194001197815,
-1.1471338272094727,
0.07908865809440613,
-0.2957577705383301,
0.03692729398608208,
-0.21455912292003632,
-0.47291329503059387,
0.6588388085365295,
-0.2667042315006256,
-0.1277291178703308,
-0.10615726560354233,
-0.09130802005529404,
0.7441148161888123,
0.3174270987510681,
0.6379363536834717,
0.41213080286979675,
0.5384463667869568,
0.13564427196979523,
1.3984888792037964,
-0.25363853573799133,
0.3283795416355133,
1.1209447383880615,
-0.4200248420238495,
0.9341066479682922,
0.1763439029455185,
-0.1916361302137375,
0.2883068025112152,
0.45550575852394104,
-0.11875856667757034,
0.7006823420524597,
0.10827559232711792,
-0.5565834641456604,
-0.2806689441204071,
-0.0009787630988284945,
-0.20569412410259247,
0.4852235019207001,
0.21666520833969116,
-0.6363450884819031,
-0.31361883878707886,
0.006855433806777,
0.2041323333978653,
-0.19342142343521118,
-0.3291597366333008,
0.4541974663734436,
0.08275385200977325,
-0.3574604094028473,
0.37291058897972107,
0.04599757120013237,
0.5964512825012207,
-0.6067661643028259,
0.05370436608791351,
0.011683826334774494,
0.37212011218070984,
-0.26854678988456726,
-1.1498202085494995,
0.14230181276798248,
0.3140236437320709,
0.2804252505302429,
-0.42925339937210083,
0.8772112727165222,
-0.23276792466640472,
-0.4310571253299713,
0.6853455901145935,
0.3983669877052307,
0.014832734130322933,
0.004698748234659433,
-1.0193474292755127,
0.3240063488483429,
-0.04282437637448311,
-0.25246360898017883,
0.4726128876209259,
0.04638856276869774,
-0.28544527292251587,
0.9026008248329163,
0.8800560832023621,
-0.10151106864213943,
0.2840735614299774,
0.2950037121772766,
0.8610315918922424,
-0.19129438698291779,
-0.17479518055915833,
-1.1206153631210327,
0.8181570768356323,
-0.3419719636440277,
-0.12323050945997238,
1.0207935571670532,
0.634175717830658,
0.3936270475387573,
-0.027705276384949684,
0.9822663068771362,
0.2601356506347656,
0.3358241021633148,
-0.7974060773849487,
1.224518060684204,
-0.3091353476047516,
0.245211660861969,
-0.505498468875885,
-0.9837468862533569,
-0.49153968691825867,
0.5309355854988098,
-0.15440072119235992,
0.18379536271095276,
0.5385169982910156,
0.6490556001663208,
-0.01397689525038004,
-0.33231744170188904,
0.7458928823471069,
0.009632078930735588,
0.6690274477005005,
0.39168021082878113,
0.8453797101974487,
-0.1794058084487915,
0.7987953424453735,
-0.13105715811252594,
-0.12524423003196716,
-0.09618428349494934,
-0.9862557053565979,
-1.2997201681137085,
-0.16222713887691498,
0.11116263270378113,
-0.3806474506855011,
0.15166693925857544,
0.8065567016601562,
0.8114559650421143,
-0.6536100506782532,
0.09284856915473938,
0.3574366569519043,
0.021345041692256927,
0.005725453607738018,
-0.17558079957962036,
0.4224473536014557,
-0.25496727228164673,
-0.45131778717041016,
0.5649029612541199,
0.5385918021202087,
0.0155150992795825,
-0.7154884338378906,
-0.24668829143047333,
0.14065302908420563,
-0.2089860588312149,
0.9883806705474854,
0.10558726638555527,
-0.6918449997901917,
-0.3729518949985504,
-0.26642656326293945,
-0.36838939785957336,
-0.3094499409198761,
0.5807207822799683,
-0.18425790965557098,
0.6593224406242371,
0.35371169447898865,
0.8412392735481262,
0.26474252343177795,
-0.2559550702571869,
0.5114352703094482,
-0.6849002838134766,
0.11613108217716217,
0.08933374285697937,
0.743141770362854,
0.5490471720695496,
-0.10400188714265823,
0.4461295008659363,
-0.07028371840715408,
-0.4980906546115875,
-0.7960971593856812,
0.22204391658306122,
-0.7538058161735535,
-0.30189111828804016,
1.2120643854141235,
-0.5497373342514038,
0.10061509907245636,
-0.4265872538089752,
-0.17505748569965363,
-0.35932883620262146,
-0.2046157717704773,
0.7517653703689575,
0.6447222828865051,
0.0630352720618248,
-0.46550261974334717,
-0.9309813380241394,
0.5272416472434998,
-0.0022714436054229736,
-0.9930114150047302,
0.26091328263282776,
0.44912466406822205,
0.3816908597946167,
0.24828939139842987,
0.3255942463874817,
-0.26614609360694885,
0.19093872606754303,
-0.06442227959632874,
0.050955403596162796,
-0.15637382864952087,
-0.4301438331604004,
-0.2608209252357483,
0.14985907077789307,
0.042080748826265335,
-0.049937598407268524
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07259v1
|
Scientific Computing with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T13:39:07 | 2024-06-11T13:39:07 |
Christopher Culver, Peter Hicks, Mihailo Milenkovic, Sanjif Shanmugavelu, Tobias Becker
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We provide an overview of the emergence of large language models for
scientific computing applications. We highlight use cases that involve natural
language processing of scientific documents and specialized languages designed
to describe physical systems. For the former, chatbot style applications appear
in medicine, mathematics and physics and can be used iteratively with domain
experts for problem solving. We also review specialized languages within
molecular biology, the languages of molecules, proteins, and DNA where language
models are being used to predict properties and even create novel physical
systems at much faster rates than traditional computing methods.
|
[
-0.21885664761066437,
-1.0719903707504272,
0.8888460397720337,
0.27193978428840637,
0.1958232969045639,
0.4493931531906128,
-0.3421532213687897,
-0.762673020362854,
0.27626892924308777,
0.6243559718132019,
-0.24826601147651672,
-0.1463935375213623,
-0.5478670597076416,
0.17347516119480133,
-0.507601797580719,
0.5609732866287231,
0.12448888272047043,
0.35789722204208374,
-0.40964657068252563,
0.3157980144023895,
-0.09686854481697083,
-0.8487806916236877,
-0.6724522113800049,
-0.5745200514793396,
0.24887385964393616,
0.25097760558128357,
0.8029318451881409,
0.2813723683357239,
1.0091955661773682,
0.480619877576828,
-0.06364990025758743,
-0.17809399962425232,
-0.19426466524600983,
0.3061884343624115,
-0.4235367476940155,
-0.5093019604682922,
-0.36732420325279236,
-0.1900484263896942,
0.6711185574531555,
1.1570154428482056,
-0.05504307895898819,
-0.07823565602302551,
-0.6405554413795471,
0.5843950510025024,
-0.02275681681931019,
0.5880008935928345,
-0.36054563522338867,
0.13058936595916748,
-0.2764839828014374,
-0.3567246198654175,
-0.44516274333000183,
-0.24759583175182343,
0.22837910056114197,
-0.6040223240852356,
0.3334091901779175,
0.050239987671375275,
0.49320322275161743,
-0.16186819970607758,
-0.3216477036476135,
-0.5634409785270691,
-1.0427272319793701,
1.0217069387435913,
-0.740349531173706,
0.5473713874816895,
0.4898080825805664,
0.4879608452320099,
-0.7902262210845947,
-0.6498106122016907,
-0.6157805323600769,
-0.7809955477714539,
0.19670003652572632,
-0.11888688057661057,
-0.2306337207555771,
0.27820342779159546,
0.3321422040462494,
0.23635363578796387,
-0.7302019596099854,
0.2314714938402176,
-0.7832332253456116,
0.13904836773872375,
0.7797510027885437,
0.1870041936635971,
0.5369398593902588,
0.1620797961950302,
0.455187052488327,
-0.000671162037178874,
-0.5487603545188904,
-0.30977529287338257,
0.19142092764377594,
0.44024527072906494,
0.05555985867977142,
0.9192507266998291,
-0.04741111025214195,
0.9102677702903748,
-0.3266288936138153,
-0.36297550797462463,
0.12467031180858612,
-0.29026511311531067,
-0.2682192921638489,
-0.01725165918469429,
0.8328852653503418,
0.011545945890247822,
0.6319173574447632,
0.02129344269633293,
0.10007131844758987,
0.12121332436800003,
0.14536255598068237,
-0.7930126190185547,
-0.4489305019378662,
0.2504359781742096,
-0.2824719548225403,
-0.037842560559511185,
-0.4157833158969879,
-0.7285376191139221,
-0.5871424078941345,
-0.3083643913269043,
-0.08425544202327728,
-0.33826062083244324,
-0.29157188534736633,
0.2804514467716217,
-0.26161181926727295,
-0.22970730066299438,
0.4122823178768158,
-0.9797696471214294,
0.6985520124435425,
0.7194424867630005,
0.718965470790863,
-0.002576613100245595,
-0.18422868847846985,
-0.11274447292089462,
0.0851091668009758,
-0.3241129517555237,
0.601682722568512,
-0.9086888432502747,
-0.6503798365592957,
-0.16766059398651123,
-0.06127270683646202,
0.21972844004631042,
-0.4586578905582428,
0.23651017248630524,
-0.6418461203575134,
0.10377058386802673,
0.1068473681807518,
-0.598285436630249,
-0.22001144289970398,
-0.2080102264881134,
-0.7371480464935303,
0.6799867153167725,
-0.02731207385659218,
-0.4450548589229584,
0.03641144931316376,
-1.190149188041687,
-0.7371559739112854,
0.30251970887184143,
-0.05073123425245285,
-0.10237802565097809,
0.19330473244190216,
-0.35577502846717834,
0.560299277305603,
-0.6181589365005493,
0.40968942642211914,
-0.10409475862979889,
-0.00992013979703188,
0.4725952744483948,
0.09117881953716278,
0.609931468963623,
0.4427666962146759,
0.006768009625375271,
0.15724048018455505,
-0.7370775938034058,
-0.008585646748542786,
0.19192136824131012,
-0.11030459403991699,
-0.3233042359352112,
0.42977067828178406,
0.24138188362121582,
-0.0012397714890539646,
0.39293691515922546,
-0.8041305541992188,
0.4858531653881073,
-0.46568191051483154,
0.9788427948951721,
0.09457006305456161,
-0.1665671467781067,
0.4960707426071167,
0.09647677838802338,
0.49536025524139404,
-0.09009812027215958,
-0.2589695453643799,
-0.1746438443660736,
-0.8297423124313354,
-0.29182910919189453,
-0.30757203698158264,
0.2611142098903656,
0.4437502324581146,
-0.49947813153266907,
0.1571292281150818,
-0.04391563683748245,
-0.7065778970718384,
-0.20737937092781067,
0.0277023296803236,
0.10572740435600281,
0.2828340232372284,
0.22571343183517456,
-0.08219980448484421,
-0.6862185597419739,
-0.8541129231452942,
0.0166122168302536,
-0.35357028245925903,
-0.1990015208721161,
0.39452245831489563,
0.5651297569274902,
-0.44663217663764954,
0.7987490296363831,
-0.6329268217086792,
0.3440759479999542,
-0.17568853497505188,
0.3059433400630951,
0.4248846471309662,
0.42354685068130493,
0.3920540511608124,
-0.9477206468582153,
-0.43109792470932007,
0.4649578034877777,
-0.7880864143371582,
0.0702551007270813,
0.18425413966178894,
0.16037170588970184,
0.3114032447338104,
0.5335736870765686,
-0.7123051285743713,
0.21357040107250214,
0.6355312466621399,
-0.4165581166744232,
0.5979719161987305,
-0.47524887323379517,
0.238348588347435,
-0.8711346387863159,
0.08805232495069504,
0.27164626121520996,
-0.3215526044368744,
-0.8767974972724915,
0.20190036296844482,
-0.1981998085975647,
-0.38841918110847473,
-0.3142099678516388,
0.5767432451248169,
-0.5609320402145386,
-0.20772355794906616,
-0.6003193259239197,
-0.025368789210915565,
-0.13929182291030884,
-0.10017554461956024,
0.580008864402771,
0.5157128572463989,
0.7162320613861084,
-0.5731528997421265,
0.5889971852302551,
-0.0012825411977246404,
-0.2935786843299866,
0.1270226687192917,
-0.9815936088562012,
-0.04879644513130188,
-0.058934908360242844,
0.15209461748600006,
-0.6085764765739441,
-0.582344114780426,
-0.4021442234516144,
-0.3382692337036133,
0.2956940233707428,
0.14503560960292816,
-0.7791027426719666,
-0.8440894484519958,
0.16712039709091187,
0.4723816215991974,
0.49427497386932373,
-0.08746012300252914,
0.29718321561813354,
0.6751201748847961,
-0.47207847237586975,
-0.07223420590162277,
-0.5245015025138855,
0.2294120043516159,
0.1230664774775505,
-0.7044443488121033,
0.1520182341337204,
-0.3271046578884125,
-0.5006881356239319,
-0.11723683774471283,
0.48242926597595215,
-0.5463173389434814,
0.21874059736728668,
0.306763619184494,
0.2572237253189087,
-0.23865492641925812,
0.29087990522384644,
-0.08095540851354599,
0.20257346332073212,
-0.040475837886333466,
-0.12571920454502106,
0.7776405811309814,
-0.40504759550094604,
-0.24363163113594055,
-0.31527552008628845,
0.9143812656402588,
0.9877179265022278,
0.01370821613818407,
0.8671286106109619,
0.011903311125934124,
-0.5568506717681885,
0.30820703506469727,
-0.353988379240036,
-0.3342888653278351,
-0.4835791289806366,
0.7253047227859497,
-0.4533490240573883,
-1.1038371324539185,
0.4771580696105957,
0.08537345379590988,
-0.12835747003555298,
0.3800147473812103,
0.9268398880958557,
-0.11364183574914932,
1.1979981660842896,
0.9792426824569702,
0.01033865101635456,
0.5666834712028503,
0.13477973639965057,
0.5877633094787598,
-0.19020241498947144,
-0.19161826372146606,
-0.8542037010192871,
0.15603987872600555,
-0.6593109965324402,
-0.44277340173721313,
0.3216956555843353,
0.08378762751817703,
-0.5632518529891968,
0.5944437980651855,
-0.6100285053253174,
0.5063721537590027,
0.552558958530426,
-0.32541999220848083,
0.30575740337371826,
0.08950027823448181,
-0.010801801458001137,
-0.026713373139500618,
-0.7226701378822327,
-0.5630504488945007,
0.8341662287712097,
0.4690783619880676,
0.9277042746543884,
-0.21221618354320526,
0.36969709396362305,
0.2006731927394867,
0.23761926591396332,
-0.8562837243080139,
0.4644192159175873,
-0.24486801028251648,
-0.6376098394393921,
-0.4519542455673218,
-0.5966718196868896,
-1.1724369525909424,
-0.24548795819282532,
-0.2267238050699234,
-0.8863447308540344,
-0.049177225679159164,
-0.1338275671005249,
-0.01576937362551689,
0.19387294352054596,
-0.9396693110466003,
0.4927678108215332,
-0.1653440296649933,
-0.009272173047065735,
-0.5260810256004333,
-0.5179927349090576,
0.3257306218147278,
-0.2511189877986908,
0.37426745891571045,
0.07358364015817642,
0.3934859335422516,
0.7795894742012024,
-0.3909209668636322,
0.8559498190879822,
0.08699264377355576,
-0.06043914705514908,
0.3001328706741333,
0.3240908980369568,
0.11036136746406555,
-0.09648796170949936,
-0.2615293264389038,
0.3557446002960205,
0.4755345582962036,
-0.3428814113140106,
-0.2781747579574585,
0.8078545928001404,
-0.8542242050170898,
-0.5987554788589478,
-0.49861863255500793,
-0.7237522602081299,
-0.23425838351249695,
0.4185320734977722,
-0.15216773748397827,
0.0889275074005127,
-0.22763700783252716,
0.12927277386188507,
0.49990785121917725,
-0.3375626802444458,
0.42706313729286194,
0.8219169974327087,
-0.4637305438518524,
0.05436215549707413,
0.7996224761009216,
0.12105940282344818,
0.22794805467128754,
0.39677694439888,
0.3399391174316406,
-0.021110232919454575,
-0.544545590877533,
-0.06662092357873917,
0.44720450043678284,
-0.33739393949508667,
-0.0834038183093071,
-0.8058487772941589,
-0.4549122750759125,
-0.61654132604599,
-0.5157451033592224,
-0.4312659800052643,
-0.668083906173706,
-0.05234404280781746,
0.12579524517059326,
0.7740976214408875,
1.0814146995544434,
0.05701495334506035,
0.3259067237377167,
-0.9474857449531555,
0.43842169642448425,
0.023074978962540627,
0.3603039085865021,
-0.1856786608695984,
-0.036186959594488144,
-0.31425461173057556,
0.14519627392292023,
-0.09626062959432602,
-0.786839485168457,
0.7784727811813354,
0.3696512281894684,
0.682389497756958,
0.11411701142787933,
-0.5375927686691284,
0.25681349635124207,
-0.8080346584320068,
0.9281066060066223,
0.42472413182258606,
-0.8988905549049377,
0.5819266438484192,
-0.4133383333683014,
0.26676639914512634,
-0.0005311701097525656,
0.7253193259239197,
-0.7358953356742859,
-0.3265848159790039,
-0.3954046964645386,
-0.7052422165870667,
0.2321453094482422,
0.01856701262295246,
0.007253478746861219,
-0.17341776192188263,
0.2697511911392212,
0.0894661471247673,
0.3886432349681854,
-0.41019222140312195,
-0.02101247012615204,
0.012506484985351562,
-0.20291045308113098,
-0.2358912229537964,
-0.0965198501944542,
-0.3186720609664917,
-0.3342173397541046,
0.41201475262641907,
-0.23077857494354248,
0.3877089023590088,
0.06525151431560516,
0.12805548310279846,
-0.3586237132549286,
0.19280670583248138,
0.664743185043335,
0.7105929851531982,
0.11237011104822159,
-0.03138715401291847,
-0.40923967957496643,
-0.7162721157073975,
-0.05641861632466316,
0.043767936527729034,
0.13020029664039612,
-0.17977456748485565,
0.32793372869491577,
0.4284030795097351,
0.14701607823371887,
-1.12382173538208,
0.029899099841713905,
-0.034850332885980606,
-0.1465495079755783,
-0.22904857993125916,
-0.0005012248875573277,
0.4985368251800537,
0.2166215181350708,
0.23748797178268433,
-0.06059739366173744,
0.3097655475139618,
-0.9541443586349487,
-0.10635430365800858,
0.6083029508590698,
-0.005287919193506241,
-0.4652647376060486,
0.47166600823402405,
0.009847222827374935,
-0.5175130367279053,
0.6076387763023376,
0.12717396020889282,
-0.5785055756568909,
0.8827542662620544,
0.8680777549743652,
0.5395191311836243,
-0.34543997049331665,
0.31872621178627014,
0.2151019126176834,
-0.018109221011400223,
-0.15916773676872253,
0.5127583742141724,
0.1018143743276596,
-0.6463697552680969,
-0.6298080682754517,
-0.9319555759429932,
-0.7817017436027527,
-0.1336197853088379,
-0.07019313424825668,
0.22184351086616516,
-0.6918366551399231,
-0.2285020649433136,
0.7168532609939575,
0.24341028928756714,
-0.5653175115585327,
0.11002358049154282,
0.2440803050994873,
0.9423617124557495,
-0.766704797744751,
0.8526000380516052,
1.0006208419799805,
-0.05295993760228157,
-0.503174901008606,
-0.8578173518180847,
-0.15635910630226135,
-0.4442943036556244,
1.1889554262161255,
-0.30948495864868164,
-0.08018632233142853,
-0.3314366340637207,
-0.8462622165679932,
-1.0667108297348022,
0.5203543305397034,
0.2594822347164154,
-0.7106703519821167,
0.17583419382572174,
0.20364604890346527,
1.170060157775879,
-0.44773685932159424,
0.4848613142967224,
0.37392640113830566,
0.5345869660377502,
0.19760607182979584,
-1.3849011659622192,
-0.1968277245759964,
-0.45945289731025696,
-0.15958258509635925,
0.2621387243270874,
-0.5125092267990112,
1.070857286453247,
-0.14660997688770294,
0.03865226358175278,
0.24305306375026703,
0.5671125650405884,
0.3913613557815552,
0.30499938130378723,
-0.06745529919862747,
-0.06347085535526276,
1.0401233434677124,
0.025783410295844078,
1.1784405708312988,
-0.4552006423473358,
0.09309923648834229,
0.6622085571289062,
-0.5858619213104248,
0.7278626561164856,
0.39109140634536743,
-0.432816743850708,
0.624552845954895,
0.44980818033218384,
-0.041582733392715454,
0.06753519177436829,
0.5456142425537109,
-0.3557569682598114,
-0.007480578031390905,
-0.08862244337797165,
-0.29362350702285767,
0.3630298972129822,
0.9977065920829773,
-0.3635227084159851,
0.07852490991353989,
0.30269724130630493,
0.05315954238176346,
0.04141615331172943,
-0.4947620630264282,
0.4340837597846985,
0.11457260698080063,
-0.5220338702201843,
0.32835349440574646,
0.11046122759580612,
0.46802082657814026,
-0.6120942234992981,
-0.1676768809556961,
0.32296833395957947,
-0.03527567908167839,
-0.24935701489448547,
-0.9826886653900146,
0.33541950583457947,
0.02078147605061531,
-0.49967604875564575,
-0.13091956079006195,
0.8157492876052856,
-0.28729158639907837,
-0.7822384238243103,
0.04653715342283249,
0.30582955479621887,
0.44493699073791504,
0.15877506136894226,
-0.3843803107738495,
-0.18557415902614594,
-0.451023131608963,
-0.3017319440841675,
0.2444445937871933,
0.22491316497325897,
-0.6534637212753296,
1.0622559785842896,
0.7211881279945374,
0.2834520637989044,
0.27740636467933655,
-0.0004640675033442676,
0.8475123643875122,
-1.0642282962799072,
-0.5030097961425781,
-0.5520794987678528,
-0.19507576525211334,
-0.10364624857902527,
0.12408215552568436,
0.7626538276672363,
0.47126859426498413,
0.3482306897640228,
-0.3120183050632477,
0.9702028632164001,
-0.16774819791316986,
0.48731130361557007,
-0.23757345974445343,
0.7494089007377625,
-0.2648356556892395,
-0.14604270458221436,
-0.33627015352249146,
-0.7699885964393616,
-0.6210591793060303,
0.551018238067627,
-0.36152687668800354,
0.02823237143456936,
0.738743245601654,
0.5927971601486206,
0.13298431038856506,
0.3501450717449188,
0.44824981689453125,
0.5975810885429382,
0.6182311177253723,
0.5108814835548401,
0.6011154055595398,
0.10701687633991241,
-0.22998583316802979,
-0.09934578835964203,
-0.47767579555511475,
-0.39768165349960327,
-0.8350348472595215,
-0.8905916213989258,
-0.6389833092689514,
-0.3510930836200714,
-0.2776397168636322,
0.010901723988354206,
0.7117823958396912,
0.9118270874023438,
-1.032409906387329,
-0.4547995328903198,
-0.29080983996391296,
0.0004041663487441838,
0.057943426072597504,
-0.2948773503303528,
0.12576331198215485,
-0.1454947292804718,
-0.9137682318687439,
0.8032326102256775,
0.32129406929016113,
0.23180238902568817,
-0.5462163686752319,
0.18438103795051575,
-0.08458131551742554,
0.3477007746696472,
0.7491970658302307,
1.0183879137039185,
-0.34575480222702026,
-0.02496352605521679,
0.2645200788974762,
-0.17729824781417847,
-0.04109114408493042,
1.195957064628601,
-0.8145756125450134,
0.55467289686203,
0.6779873967170715,
0.4110592007637024,
0.6591197848320007,
-0.47134074568748474,
0.9253479242324829,
-0.10425110906362534,
0.20098507404327393,
0.517630398273468,
0.498735636472702,
0.42252981662750244,
-0.5037713050842285,
0.36606869101524353,
0.1649918407201767,
-0.847557008266449,
-0.9429084658622742,
0.2782936692237854,
-1.1600761413574219,
-0.44383060932159424,
0.9578382968902588,
0.09985853731632233,
-0.3922712802886963,
-0.14329223334789276,
-0.2101234346628189,
0.03712158650159836,
-0.3737623989582062,
0.7009353637695312,
0.8520053029060364,
-0.4646052122116089,
-0.025908542796969414,
-0.7915560603141785,
0.27513548731803894,
0.12258456647396088,
-0.7832143902778625,
-0.0726773664355278,
0.3836279511451721,
0.06819381564855576,
0.6605821251869202,
0.39475417137145996,
-0.3457561731338501,
0.14479891955852509,
0.04723849892616272,
0.29062145948410034,
0.10181546956300735,
-0.4048032760620117,
-0.09850149601697922,
0.2611698508262634,
0.1703374683856964,
0.5688881874084473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07257v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07257v1
|
Scholarly Question Answering using Large Language Models in the NFDI4DataScience Gateway
| 2024-06-11T13:36:19 | 2024-06-11T13:36:19 |
Hamed Babaei Giglou, Tilahun Abedissa Taffa, Rana Abdullah, Aida Usmanova, Ricardo Usbeck, Jennifer D'Souza, Sören Auer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper introduces a scholarly Question Answering (QA) system on top of
the NFDI4DataScience Gateway, employing a Retrieval Augmented Generation-based
(RAG) approach. The NFDI4DS Gateway, as a foundational framework, offers a
unified and intuitive interface for querying various scientific databases using
federated search. The RAG-based scholarly QA, powered by a Large Language Model
(LLM), facilitates dynamic interaction with search results, enhancing filtering
capabilities and fostering a conversational engagement with the Gateway search.
The effectiveness of both the Gateway and the scholarly QA system is
demonstrated through experimental analysis.
|
[
-0.677834153175354,
-0.7176606059074402,
0.9033766388893127,
0.12619663774967194,
-0.06045767664909363,
0.36331894993782043,
0.22921136021614075,
-0.5668727159500122,
0.6463238596916199,
0.6234669089317322,
-0.6630486249923706,
-0.3175738751888275,
-0.18474647402763367,
0.45279473066329956,
-0.2965157628059387,
0.9775711894035339,
0.17419716715812683,
0.37013423442840576,
-0.5270630717277527,
-0.21385450661182404,
-0.15431120991706848,
-0.2272813320159912,
-0.8107089400291443,
-0.20857225358486176,
0.7079005837440491,
0.17368996143341064,
0.8122525811195374,
0.3686022162437439,
0.9653247594833374,
0.22897689044475555,
-0.34098371863365173,
-0.0660783052444458,
-0.4298807382583618,
0.39690810441970825,
-0.5682440996170044,
-0.5132319927215576,
-0.5913180708885193,
-0.21541979908943176,
0.8655633330345154,
0.7707265615463257,
-0.0560125894844532,
0.3331925868988037,
-0.4808964133262634,
0.8122110962867737,
-0.5117147564888,
0.1743706613779068,
-0.4797690510749817,
-0.05035191401839256,
-0.41759544610977173,
-0.3960461914539337,
-0.3187517821788788,
-0.5005213618278503,
0.1482582688331604,
-0.8684846758842468,
0.19244416058063507,
-0.013761981390416622,
0.7414705157279968,
0.16071432828903198,
-0.5014861226081848,
-0.420300155878067,
-0.5999167561531067,
0.5429671406745911,
-0.5744539499282837,
0.656536340713501,
0.17359715700149536,
0.45453721284866333,
-0.27596211433410645,
-1.1774957180023193,
-0.7545396685600281,
-0.03683692589402199,
0.040114182978868484,
0.13979101181030273,
0.05472646653652191,
0.05243435129523277,
0.28504177927970886,
0.5075802206993103,
-0.6717338562011719,
-0.0807451531291008,
-0.28805091977119446,
0.037193816155195236,
0.41593319177627563,
0.2908480763435364,
0.2921626567840576,
-0.31306031346321106,
-0.1519130915403366,
0.19148831069469452,
-0.7928421497344971,
-0.13512858748435974,
-0.0006618195911869407,
0.09186214208602905,
0.39602017402648926,
0.43790656328201294,
-0.42647337913513184,
0.8857474327087402,
0.08271824568510056,
-0.06124388426542282,
0.19576427340507507,
-0.41429510712623596,
-0.06604723632335663,
-0.3780023157596588,
0.4625168442726135,
0.22237984836101532,
-0.3682670593261719,
-0.6097012162208557,
-0.2929547429084778,
-0.04833272099494934,
0.17773954570293427,
-0.912988007068634,
0.046654995530843735,
0.3262471556663513,
-0.36513030529022217,
-0.17418701946735382,
-0.07678402960300446,
-1.3733770847320557,
-0.4833858013153076,
-0.16844823956489563,
0.29363206028938293,
0.05139660835266113,
-0.40225210785865784,
0.008945195004343987,
-0.1351875364780426,
0.6191330552101135,
0.2654229998588562,
-0.7300517559051514,
0.5790959596633911,
0.8881761431694031,
0.9357156157493591,
-0.19991932809352875,
-0.00924557913094759,
-0.9007670879364014,
0.21768808364868164,
-0.3313790261745453,
0.7811896204948425,
-0.6330085396766663,
-0.5169722437858582,
0.019691724330186844,
0.24708807468414307,
0.1351628601551056,
-0.39748838543891907,
0.8177278637886047,
-1.6590514183044434,
0.39935460686683655,
-0.5233047604560852,
-0.5999961495399475,
-0.24031434953212738,
0.3196682333946228,
-1.0042383670806885,
0.7218621969223022,
0.17181573808193207,
-1.0331623554229736,
-0.14865398406982422,
-1.1067291498184204,
0.03144208714365959,
0.504806637763977,
0.06434120237827301,
0.08344391733407974,
-0.14098435640335083,
0.08423618972301483,
0.1572461575269699,
-0.6836097836494446,
0.6091870665550232,
-0.3492797315120697,
-0.2128968983888626,
0.2299475371837616,
-0.165635347366333,
1.021288514137268,
0.3631476163864136,
-0.0890708714723587,
-0.1360921710729599,
-0.5783172845840454,
0.07096145302057266,
0.09424475580453873,
-0.26214250922203064,
-0.5123350024223328,
-0.344073086977005,
-0.024642029777169228,
0.09283506870269775,
0.5378184914588928,
-0.8931989073753357,
0.3882904350757599,
-0.507969319820404,
0.24936696887016296,
0.4436655342578888,
0.26264527440071106,
0.6047767400741577,
-0.33569425344467163,
0.7568370699882507,
-0.20283859968185425,
0.013520818203687668,
-0.01575157791376114,
-0.5880501866340637,
-0.47146064043045044,
0.1490405797958374,
0.5455574989318848,
0.4824214577674866,
-1.4053181409835815,
-0.27654510736465454,
-0.5267263054847717,
-0.4438699781894684,
-0.3391571342945099,
-0.1842162013053894,
0.26805323362350464,
0.6807019114494324,
0.438439279794693,
-0.16362464427947998,
-0.37779226899147034,
-0.6233222484588623,
-0.07993850111961365,
-0.35577771067619324,
-0.16814781725406647,
0.4216863512992859,
0.42643165588378906,
-0.41591572761535645,
1.021924614906311,
-0.6803540587425232,
-0.07324019819498062,
0.1813899129629135,
0.09601357579231262,
0.37774667143821716,
0.07880634069442749,
0.41923168301582336,
-1.0651798248291016,
-0.32937559485435486,
-0.1677362322807312,
-0.8325276374816895,
-0.31690579652786255,
0.27046629786491394,
-0.38693109154701233,
0.21908719837665558,
0.6070442199707031,
-0.8792941570281982,
-0.054816052317619324,
0.5858646035194397,
-0.4566992521286011,
0.6123444437980652,
0.12812690436840057,
0.2691551744937897,
-1.2162951231002808,
0.3801060914993286,
-0.12223480641841888,
0.0564163401722908,
-0.8125273585319519,
0.6499860286712646,
0.12930627167224884,
-0.2047065794467926,
-0.16355876624584198,
0.8330284953117371,
-0.5994819402694702,
-0.4368475079536438,
-0.3866865038871765,
0.3945282995700836,
0.3643115162849426,
0.026930680498480797,
0.12337825447320938,
0.969176709651947,
0.38058000802993774,
-0.48200738430023193,
0.35921815037727356,
0.49881985783576965,
0.14292646944522858,
0.6846379637718201,
-0.7254607677459717,
0.060119155794382095,
-0.38882172107696533,
0.525115430355072,
-0.7988367080688477,
-0.3789261281490326,
-0.07436369359493256,
-0.4281524121761322,
0.27443811297416687,
-0.06121961772441864,
-0.30654117465019226,
-0.5631226301193237,
-0.15120144188404083,
0.5266292691230774,
0.2179328352212906,
-0.7463918924331665,
0.7639362215995789,
0.5727981925010681,
-0.4193308353424072,
-0.5496830940246582,
-0.36597001552581787,
0.5085181593894958,
-0.19016754627227783,
-0.9332129955291748,
0.6340882778167725,
-0.18820026516914368,
-0.4281903803348541,
0.010027317330241203,
0.21953114867210388,
-0.3424026072025299,
0.024683641269803047,
0.01713922619819641,
0.5438328981399536,
-0.3464867174625397,
0.35824036598205566,
-0.12073707580566406,
0.04760834947228432,
0.37620118260383606,
-0.08548527956008911,
0.4736865758895874,
-0.2355499565601349,
-0.12773531675338745,
-0.27855589985847473,
0.42123404145240784,
0.8405128121376038,
-0.5348772406578064,
0.6482230424880981,
0.3947344720363617,
-0.2591700553894043,
0.10190843045711517,
-0.5683043599128723,
-0.605602502822876,
-0.5108151435852051,
0.05331612750887871,
-0.4674387276172638,
-1.1601109504699707,
0.7054612636566162,
-0.10954979807138443,
0.24169312417507172,
0.5030664801597595,
0.29302555322647095,
0.04598819836974144,
0.615502655506134,
0.4736245572566986,
0.21319563686847687,
0.14465054869651794,
-0.09817200154066086,
0.21339185535907745,
-1.2002956867218018,
-0.1579829901456833,
-0.9087651371955872,
-0.05040346831083298,
-0.6911494135856628,
-0.501707911491394,
0.659338653087616,
0.01563609577715397,
-0.38681310415267944,
-0.10354448109865189,
-0.36934295296669006,
0.33099520206451416,
0.5410394072532654,
-0.24916839599609375,
0.680327832698822,
-0.16765697300434113,
0.04373050853610039,
-0.017852677032351494,
-0.6313881874084473,
-0.4239559471607208,
1.0242111682891846,
0.44044700264930725,
0.7579907178878784,
0.5612562894821167,
0.5449689030647278,
-0.07084862887859344,
0.5613808035850525,
-0.6435821056365967,
0.5839968919754028,
0.13981451094150543,
-0.9046853184700012,
-0.46513065695762634,
-0.6325377821922302,
-0.9577538371086121,
0.13095806539058685,
-0.18950417637825012,
-0.37040606141090393,
0.384687215089798,
-0.23876258730888367,
-0.3089240491390228,
0.3863788843154907,
-0.31923118233680725,
0.5872466564178467,
0.11105189472436905,
-0.45964255928993225,
0.13672615587711334,
-0.6459391713142395,
0.7465338706970215,
-0.16011826694011688,
0.13788534700870514,
0.25254544615745544,
-0.12532810866832733,
0.8393541574478149,
0.010706904344260693,
0.3759341537952423,
-0.32752546668052673,
-0.06444758176803589,
0.13803401589393616,
0.34282660484313965,
0.5608376860618591,
0.3591906726360321,
-0.2507144808769226,
0.08198436349630356,
0.3263579308986664,
-0.2576608657836914,
-0.697044312953949,
1.0641674995422363,
-0.600526750087738,
-0.8836299180984497,
-0.6294061541557312,
-0.6437755823135376,
-0.5350286960601807,
0.3409616947174072,
-0.25606927275657654,
0.5092517137527466,
-0.17517033219337463,
0.28950923681259155,
0.9171769022941589,
-0.3273928463459015,
0.44952863454818726,
0.9503774046897888,
-0.550023078918457,
-0.28050315380096436,
0.7265547513961792,
0.1089678630232811,
0.2689685523509979,
0.38950562477111816,
0.02555066905915737,
-0.7709373235702515,
-0.5227905511856079,
-0.7294055223464966,
0.6413076519966125,
-0.6017154455184937,
-0.32185134291648865,
-1.0977776050567627,
-0.26446521282196045,
-0.46931177377700806,
0.014990062452852726,
-0.010589228942990303,
-0.30986839532852173,
-0.3972458839416504,
0.10876566171646118,
0.49647894501686096,
0.6613813042640686,
0.15829262137413025,
0.06296566873788834,
-1.0884344577789307,
0.44193318486213684,
0.43108808994293213,
0.7204249501228333,
-0.05590762197971344,
-0.5088182687759399,
-0.053401947021484375,
0.047210533171892166,
-0.24042119085788727,
-1.0421887636184692,
0.19767192006111145,
0.10637567192316055,
0.5099747180938721,
0.14340955018997192,
0.17652665078639984,
0.25594639778137207,
-0.6787173748016357,
0.8611693978309631,
0.13950315117835999,
-0.7176595330238342,
0.13888102769851685,
-0.6823906898498535,
0.3563217222690582,
0.5691572427749634,
0.6884523034095764,
-0.7548909783363342,
-0.14934830367565155,
-0.49092066287994385,
-0.5305414795875549,
0.2621172070503235,
-0.24766889214515686,
0.06381082534790039,
-0.19151058793067932,
0.5266643166542053,
-0.1743452101945877,
0.08913423866033554,
-0.6672888994216919,
-0.11266288161277771,
-0.19054017961025238,
0.12969106435775757,
0.12402159720659256,
-0.34719330072402954,
-0.32359832525253296,
-0.016803067177534103,
0.8411653637886047,
-0.3972693979740143,
0.2680146396160126,
0.2977670729160309,
0.22641170024871826,
-0.1661141812801361,
0.24740175902843475,
0.2993433475494385,
0.8908140659332275,
-0.13127145171165466,
-0.08154024928808212,
-0.14509834349155426,
-0.6066119074821472,
0.256241112947464,
0.21206405758857727,
-0.6079862117767334,
0.10803510993719101,
-0.06354550272226334,
0.45091038942337036,
-0.32842886447906494,
-0.5418164134025574,
0.43766650557518005,
-0.28324568271636963,
-0.22014379501342773,
-0.3618246614933014,
-0.13459908962249756,
0.5470074415206909,
0.2556987404823303,
0.7510076761245728,
-0.45994794368743896,
0.6118538975715637,
-0.3151596486568451,
0.3606660068035126,
0.7933533787727356,
-0.29904863238334656,
-0.07584071159362793,
0.8188951015472412,
0.1889740377664566,
-0.22729399800300598,
0.4765576720237732,
-0.2707865834236145,
-0.34700581431388855,
0.5254627466201782,
0.5462626218795776,
0.6665055155754089,
-0.24290159344673157,
0.6831939220428467,
0.3838059902191162,
0.22031335532665253,
0.011335774324834347,
0.3374274969100952,
0.42481887340545654,
-0.5624943971633911,
-0.8506367802619934,
-1.1083588600158691,
-0.6496196985244751,
0.07478293776512146,
-0.6344817280769348,
-0.059877779334783554,
-0.3104928433895111,
-0.1627824902534485,
0.34340205788612366,
0.17975100874900818,
-0.323386013507843,
0.11965231597423553,
-0.34276291728019714,
1.0827668905258179,
-0.5536966919898987,
0.5459074974060059,
0.8313567042350769,
-0.4476850926876068,
-0.7290447950363159,
0.10455993562936783,
-0.2473754584789276,
-0.25161832571029663,
1.0371264219284058,
-0.19255314767360687,
-0.14820267260074615,
0.25072672963142395,
-0.3459371030330658,
-1.2401082515716553,
1.233506202697754,
0.09572994709014893,
-0.3216918408870697,
-0.06461980938911438,
-0.2088184803724289,
0.7812296152114868,
-0.14315082132816315,
0.33222073316574097,
0.5014314651489258,
0.5116848349571228,
0.5208475589752197,
-0.8525418639183044,
-0.014235389418900013,
-0.3494756519794464,
-0.006843940354883671,
0.371186226606369,
-0.6559224724769592,
0.830239474773407,
0.03839537128806114,
-0.2812144160270691,
0.1821466088294983,
0.8684530854225159,
0.30623242259025574,
0.5234389305114746,
0.34569019079208374,
0.5994650721549988,
0.7932150363922119,
-0.21811340749263763,
1.003605842590332,
-0.4088413417339325,
0.13097187876701355,
0.934868335723877,
-0.6109980344772339,
0.753548800945282,
0.6689040064811707,
-0.13778015971183777,
0.7251179814338684,
0.5448601245880127,
0.3905686140060425,
0.33700159192085266,
0.1560688465833664,
-0.8125532269477844,
0.23546795547008514,
-0.45403939485549927,
-0.4552588164806366,
0.37611123919487,
0.4437703788280487,
-0.06463674455881119,
-0.4486083984375,
0.021065130829811096,
-0.12381881475448608,
0.10249915719032288,
-0.49792778491973877,
0.7900011539459229,
-0.14575909078121185,
-0.9232208728790283,
0.5122837424278259,
0.21688075363636017,
0.4813828468322754,
-0.35379111766815186,
-0.03841879591345787,
-0.519511342048645,
-0.3473281264305115,
-0.24665148556232452,
-0.8000583648681641,
0.4373820126056671,
-0.12327829003334045,
-0.2601417303085327,
0.09750545769929886,
0.6177123188972473,
-0.3083760440349579,
-0.2893340289592743,
0.1345914602279663,
0.6993488073348999,
0.10749023407697678,
0.14042171835899353,
-0.5937030911445618,
-0.048251911997795105,
-0.24184760451316833,
-0.3597887456417084,
0.34773582220077515,
0.5109079480171204,
-0.26913881301879883,
0.8704915046691895,
0.8916918635368347,
0.04247613623738289,
-0.004264259710907936,
0.016559667885303497,
1.1696608066558838,
-0.5826680064201355,
-0.5913643836975098,
-0.19987010955810547,
-0.04589056596159935,
-0.2134118378162384,
0.16471794247627258,
0.7518141865730286,
0.39030155539512634,
0.4334632456302643,
-0.035079337656497955,
0.5259235501289368,
-0.20821808278560638,
1.015428900718689,
-0.32233139872550964,
0.49435216188430786,
-0.5361279249191284,
0.2687566578388214,
-0.2723022401332855,
-1.1967591047286987,
-0.4172266125679016,
0.3385925889015198,
-0.37063583731651306,
0.0735865905880928,
0.7673619985580444,
1.084788203239441,
-0.007274032570421696,
0.4531165063381195,
0.18060734868049622,
0.2799263000488281,
0.5578148365020752,
0.26718199253082275,
0.6168850660324097,
-0.297175794839859,
0.1674451231956482,
0.13028113543987274,
-0.2664896845817566,
-0.01974441483616829,
-0.8223046660423279,
-0.5345199704170227,
-0.6216564178466797,
0.007583096623420715,
-0.632050096988678,
0.00208797468803823,
0.45203790068626404,
-0.010423651896417141,
-0.5853529572486877,
-0.10614805668592453,
-0.10338546335697174,
-0.05859237536787987,
0.12486030161380768,
-0.370536208152771,
0.423591673374176,
-0.37925195693969727,
-0.8179410696029663,
0.3825235664844513,
0.335468053817749,
-0.1669265627861023,
-0.8916333913803101,
-0.12224879860877991,
-0.5908634066581726,
0.1608324944972992,
0.5000178217887878,
0.3827774226665497,
-0.4129459261894226,
-0.03566258028149605,
0.6553229689598083,
-0.22533166408538818,
-0.29449212551116943,
0.7548605799674988,
-0.8179856538772583,
0.4951901137828827,
0.6684627532958984,
1.3552653789520264,
0.43816640973091125,
0.09795859456062317,
0.4057832360267639,
-0.18206888437271118,
-0.3248315453529358,
0.6278202533721924,
0.03683597594499588,
0.4297312796115875,
-0.48368334770202637,
0.6701100468635559,
0.25395113229751587,
-1.053384780883789,
-0.8193157911300659,
0.2033528983592987,
-0.8114397525787354,
-0.29033163189888,
1.1596516370773315,
-0.0440293550491333,
-0.348877876996994,
-0.4997817277908325,
-0.05638802796602249,
-0.07337936758995056,
-0.09935437142848969,
0.7582843899726868,
0.6890007853507996,
0.08329366892576218,
-0.17339330911636353,
-0.9625064134597778,
0.6462949514389038,
0.3838948905467987,
-0.9083729386329651,
-0.09668570011854172,
0.9302487969398499,
0.23451565206050873,
0.4250541031360626,
0.9847576022148132,
-0.3375000059604645,
0.4550773501396179,
-0.36336323618888855,
0.04522136226296425,
0.12495066225528717,
-0.37957414984703064,
-0.2058304399251938,
0.513803243637085,
0.0372091680765152,
0.35471171140670776
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07243v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07243v2
|
MBBQ: A Dataset for Cross-Lingual Comparison of Stereotypes in Generative LLMs
| 2024-06-11T13:23:14 | 2024-06-18T15:33:33 |
Vera Neplenbroek, Arianna Bisazza, Raquel Fernández
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Generative large language models (LLMs) have been shown to exhibit harmful
biases and stereotypes. While safety fine-tuning typically takes place in
English, if at all, these models are being used by speakers of many different
languages. There is existing evidence that the performance of these models is
inconsistent across languages and that they discriminate based on demographic
factors of the user. Motivated by this, we investigate whether the social
stereotypes exhibited by LLMs differ as a function of the language used to
prompt them, while controlling for cultural differences and task accuracy. To
this end, we present MBBQ (Multilingual Bias Benchmark for Question-answering),
a carefully curated version of the English BBQ dataset extended to Dutch,
Spanish, and Turkish, which measures stereotypes commonly held across these
languages. We further complement MBBQ with a parallel control dataset to
measure task performance on the question-answering task independently of bias.
Our results based on several open-source and proprietary LLMs confirm that some
non-English languages suffer from bias more than English, even when controlling
for cultural shifts. Moreover, we observe significant cross-lingual differences
in bias behaviour for all except the most accurate models. With the release of
MBBQ, we hope to encourage further research on bias in multilingual settings.
The dataset and code are available at https://github.com/Veranep/MBBQ.
|
[
-0.4044637978076935,
-0.695534348487854,
0.1838836669921875,
0.6447927951812744,
0.044972583651542664,
0.25533682107925415,
-0.05850743129849434,
-0.33855098485946655,
0.14998342096805573,
0.5920463800430298,
-0.4808097183704376,
-0.8199493288993835,
-0.5359333753585815,
0.3559277653694153,
-0.01903357170522213,
0.7448222041130066,
-0.1106661781668663,
0.5334193706512451,
-0.5682850480079651,
-0.30716219544410706,
-0.4410475194454193,
-0.5977333188056946,
-0.5970962047576904,
-0.33217233419418335,
0.5785673260688782,
0.20745350420475006,
0.7793842554092407,
0.2902710735797882,
0.29585036635398865,
0.10347127914428711,
-0.1414901465177536,
0.29733824729919434,
-0.4111887216567993,
0.28289031982421875,
-0.4494468569755554,
-0.5423347353935242,
-0.08841363340616226,
-0.1610059291124344,
0.45220527052879333,
0.7502747774124146,
-0.03350486606359482,
0.28387534618377686,
0.04401644319295883,
0.7525355219841003,
-0.6158626079559326,
0.26484137773513794,
-0.5886019468307495,
-0.07394721359014511,
-0.15780207514762878,
-0.049439601600170135,
-0.437347412109375,
-0.7196964025497437,
-0.43606138229370117,
-0.16043171286582947,
0.23028860986232758,
0.3783654570579529,
0.8298776149749756,
0.12038766592741013,
-0.8629298210144043,
-0.17216181755065918,
-0.38144007325172424,
0.7189627885818481,
-0.5360928177833557,
0.5657852292060852,
0.4337526857852936,
0.15159879624843597,
-0.08931522816419601,
0.04542788118124008,
-0.30063945055007935,
-0.22096721827983856,
-0.17157763242721558,
0.16325974464416504,
0.03818925842642784,
-0.014853816479444504,
0.39714643359184265,
0.03263722360134125,
-0.8247692584991455,
0.23718959093093872,
-0.5320929288864136,
-0.39273884892463684,
0.5210487246513367,
0.3238566219806671,
0.3520861268043518,
-0.4951302111148834,
-0.15513764321804047,
0.058969851583242416,
-1.130539894104004,
0.33981853723526,
0.5455192923545837,
0.2924109697341919,
-0.21108631789684296,
0.5133059620857239,
-0.35438212752342224,
0.590514063835144,
-0.04012582451105118,
-0.2781239151954651,
0.4111887216567993,
-0.10257234424352646,
0.043176308274269104,
0.01975148543715477,
0.8328865170478821,
0.9766430854797363,
0.4480331540107727,
-0.11114122718572617,
-0.08289787173271179,
0.11739183217287064,
-0.07467866688966751,
-0.7797724604606628,
-0.17794561386108398,
0.2142343968153,
-0.3842967450618744,
-0.07906079292297363,
-0.30920737981796265,
-0.6236622333526611,
-0.4306342899799347,
0.06085651367902756,
0.05805616453289986,
-0.24857932329177856,
-0.2798439860343933,
-0.027439113706350327,
-0.04022049903869629,
0.31594106554985046,
-0.13616250455379486,
-0.8068434596061707,
0.026990126818418503,
0.5198338031768799,
0.7554548978805542,
-0.21183133125305176,
-0.21003448963165283,
-0.33544421195983887,
0.1938328891992569,
-0.589008629322052,
0.5810961723327637,
-0.6580280065536499,
-0.49560537934303284,
0.10221564024686813,
0.25606071949005127,
0.0271332748234272,
-0.8914086818695068,
0.35405391454696655,
-0.5161580443382263,
0.16996508836746216,
-0.7821001410484314,
-0.2325761765241623,
-0.07919635623693466,
0.30266931653022766,
-0.5112669467926025,
1.2629961967468262,
-0.0446433424949646,
-0.9985023140907288,
0.6604503393173218,
-0.13216282427310944,
-0.5676812529563904,
-0.10645965486764908,
-0.40704071521759033,
-0.19080379605293274,
-0.12122632563114166,
0.4837498366832733,
0.598380982875824,
-0.5440366864204407,
0.3865509033203125,
-0.6165438890457153,
-0.5351349711418152,
0.22313496470451355,
-0.1606857031583786,
1.2168902158737183,
0.1517074555158615,
-0.11112987250089645,
-0.2180311679840088,
-0.5372470617294312,
-0.09937829524278641,
0.11204244941473007,
-0.40420693159103394,
-0.6393706798553467,
-0.1322968602180481,
-0.19030719995498657,
0.542306661605835,
0.20695967972278595,
-0.6151465177536011,
-0.1436692327260971,
-0.1144331693649292,
0.07846008986234665,
0.7774193286895752,
-0.12158578634262085,
0.15904219448566437,
-0.5286937355995178,
0.7391390800476074,
0.20803402364253998,
0.0672312006354332,
0.10123489797115326,
-0.4680519998073578,
-0.4168815612792969,
-0.38126763701438904,
0.2947065830230713,
0.8718109130859375,
-1.0646530389785767,
0.21791690587997437,
-0.2004474699497223,
-0.37640348076820374,
-0.6231660842895508,
0.31508100032806396,
0.6815667152404785,
0.2752193510532379,
0.14811131358146667,
-0.25674715638160706,
-0.26172494888305664,
-1.2786201238632202,
-0.4682402014732361,
-0.3910576403141022,
-0.1719411462545395,
0.5343122482299805,
0.16084164381027222,
0.1270321011543274,
0.5623898506164551,
-0.21258854866027832,
0.08206339925527573,
-0.18704655766487122,
0.02528669498860836,
0.31160423159599304,
0.27638792991638184,
0.8934515714645386,
-0.515660285949707,
-0.6825380921363831,
-0.06899774074554443,
-0.8431161642074585,
-0.5476841330528259,
0.17676158249378204,
-0.4441063702106476,
0.3432633876800537,
0.5678505301475525,
-0.5174984335899353,
-0.10127655416727066,
0.8011361360549927,
-0.3387832045555115,
0.7085792422294617,
0.24021080136299133,
0.4326716661453247,
-1.107471227645874,
-0.25043195486068726,
0.19514141976833344,
-0.1287376582622528,
-0.30718865990638733,
0.053012408316135406,
0.3623192608356476,
0.2547110617160797,
-0.5344216227531433,
0.5814430117607117,
-0.39690542221069336,
-0.039078276604413986,
0.10518484562635422,
-0.02317052334547043,
0.1677621752023697,
0.28209060430526733,
-0.0013084643287584186,
0.8247690200805664,
0.7143046259880066,
-0.5817242860794067,
0.42500901222229004,
0.16567370295524597,
-0.6409014463424683,
0.822075366973877,
-0.6073077917098999,
0.047159433364868164,
-0.556522011756897,
0.07373693585395813,
-1.0416147708892822,
-0.05692342668771744,
0.249567911028862,
-0.39680761098861694,
0.1245746836066246,
-0.27915316820144653,
-0.836187481880188,
-0.3387581408023834,
-0.129189133644104,
0.29314473271369934,
0.5854141712188721,
-0.39394983649253845,
0.49873825907707214,
0.35456541180610657,
-0.420418381690979,
-0.91802579164505,
-0.7646216750144958,
-0.2788587510585785,
-0.28511881828308105,
-0.6089037656784058,
-0.01695382222533226,
-0.06759534776210785,
-0.41089728474617004,
-0.18957705795764923,
-0.16704335808753967,
0.04361140727996826,
-0.06447692215442657,
0.23073074221611023,
0.33928659558296204,
-0.11685217171907425,
0.08656040579080582,
0.5198851823806763,
0.42311790585517883,
0.48337289690971375,
-0.03010573983192444,
0.4424450099468231,
0.17770224809646606,
-0.18843910098075867,
0.3189943730831146,
0.39756426215171814,
0.44626715779304504,
-0.10076165199279785,
0.901620626449585,
0.583361804485321,
-0.07944130152463913,
-0.04198790341615677,
-0.7552118897438049,
-0.0598454475402832,
-0.4371863603591919,
0.3605470061302185,
-0.6141387820243835,
-1.057477355003357,
0.5994371175765991,
0.2988520562648773,
0.3036477267742157,
-0.0318015031516552,
0.7328841090202332,
-0.2214765101671219,
1.0983296632766724,
0.45417678356170654,
-0.05640080198645592,
0.1459590047597885,
0.5198328495025635,
-0.01323846634477377,
-0.5560327172279358,
-0.21055619418621063,
-0.5960221886634827,
-0.22234535217285156,
-0.8836854100227356,
-0.42296066880226135,
0.5166728496551514,
-0.03409064561128616,
-0.3534298539161682,
0.020422954112291336,
-0.03605356439948082,
0.5716206431388855,
0.4939807951450348,
0.1233137845993042,
0.30501291155815125,
-0.0005344687378965318,
-0.6607422232627869,
-0.19325153529644012,
-0.7671834826469421,
-0.45768600702285767,
1.0765219926834106,
0.15904219448566437,
0.8953497409820557,
0.1916925460100174,
0.4668450355529785,
0.2001606822013855,
0.502761960029602,
-0.261886328458786,
0.6118039488792419,
-0.3122681975364685,
-1.2276084423065186,
-0.0350010022521019,
-0.7448135018348694,
-0.7805565595626831,
0.5743887424468994,
-0.19314143061637878,
-0.6857640147209167,
0.2301495373249054,
0.3867122530937195,
-0.05502311885356903,
0.2445884346961975,
-0.6776062846183777,
0.9044293165206909,
-0.2699432969093323,
-0.45890364050865173,
0.05382833629846573,
-0.6481426358222961,
0.5904062986373901,
-0.07928790152072906,
0.4191848635673523,
-0.607682466506958,
0.16121353209018707,
0.5261498689651489,
0.17109732329845428,
0.7942452430725098,
-0.1879347264766693,
-0.18672271072864532,
-0.04230811446905136,
0.29995325207710266,
0.370900422334671,
0.11024654656648636,
-0.2763940989971161,
0.49485841393470764,
0.34304100275039673,
-0.8273512125015259,
-0.407229483127594,
0.611165463924408,
-0.705694317817688,
-0.8018146753311157,
-0.13107818365097046,
-0.75204998254776,
-0.49252477288246155,
0.015600834041833878,
0.2182205617427826,
0.18585941195487976,
-0.26130276918411255,
0.20963092148303986,
0.7310229539871216,
-0.8042799830436707,
-0.02487746812403202,
0.6783694624900818,
-0.7101452946662903,
-0.007271078880876303,
0.6646202802658081,
0.1315506249666214,
0.5013200640678406,
0.516952395439148,
-0.07217805832624435,
-0.3135257959365845,
-0.197145015001297,
-0.6542628407478333,
0.31153982877731323,
-0.830549955368042,
-0.05992439389228821,
-0.7784291505813599,
0.048165347427129745,
-0.6493604779243469,
-0.012472040019929409,
-0.17046652734279633,
-0.16122162342071533,
0.366046279668808,
-0.23368549346923828,
0.2234598845243454,
0.5743939280509949,
0.04691691696643829,
-0.10636378824710846,
-0.5958243012428284,
0.3204154372215271,
0.14176413416862488,
0.14237166941165924,
-0.2871880829334259,
-0.4057384133338928,
-0.24042506515979767,
-0.07934217900037766,
-0.04539802297949791,
-0.9970570206642151,
0.2862394154071808,
-0.21054092049598694,
0.5627872347831726,
0.1764930635690689,
0.23055221140384674,
0.22369994223117828,
-0.36168885231018066,
0.6313719153404236,
0.11001609265804291,
-0.5991642475128174,
0.10299897938966751,
-0.5141766667366028,
0.4505394697189331,
0.4287179410457611,
0.9574233889579773,
-0.8472574949264526,
-0.8303587436676025,
-0.054001856595277786,
-0.7644553184509277,
0.4572315216064453,
-0.08610870689153671,
0.1717654913663864,
-0.34792718291282654,
0.05319872125983238,
0.27670174837112427,
0.426074743270874,
-0.9713638424873352,
-0.5157182216644287,
-0.21446749567985535,
-0.19007115066051483,
-0.08195792138576508,
-0.3106713891029358,
-0.12161016464233398,
-0.16110637784004211,
0.5506212115287781,
-0.03246377408504486,
0.05862521007657051,
-0.22980952262878418,
-0.19660285115242004,
-0.026741428300738335,
0.44277921319007874,
-0.0009591869893483818,
0.6902300715446472,
-0.2706700265407562,
0.15196770429611206,
0.403281033039093,
-0.32595178484916687,
0.23011596500873566,
0.034893546253442764,
-0.5631897449493408,
0.13557222485542297,
-0.005467895418405533,
0.6073455810546875,
0.01004899200052023,
-0.7750577926635742,
0.3263351619243622,
-0.01148676872253418,
-0.20924335718154907,
-0.05863013491034508,
-0.047822654247283936,
0.31890976428985596,
0.25451770424842834,
0.09019913524389267,
-0.29823270440101624,
0.09457876533269882,
-0.5286539793014526,
-0.17882241308689117,
0.6325191259384155,
-0.20361855626106262,
0.05512628331780434,
0.5894119143486023,
0.36111512780189514,
0.13424265384674072,
0.5630213618278503,
-0.3808627128601074,
-0.3508016765117645,
0.60319584608078,
0.34492817521095276,
0.4106118679046631,
-0.19906628131866455,
0.4247446656227112,
0.39117431640625,
0.7840346097946167,
0.15751013159751892,
0.5030516982078552,
0.19252699613571167,
-1.1650469303131104,
-0.5083198547363281,
-0.6519122123718262,
-0.3694770038127899,
0.019446097314357758,
-0.8109467625617981,
0.18962015211582184,
-0.34703344106674194,
-0.12489524483680725,
-0.1190512478351593,
-0.3938540816307068,
-0.8391119241714478,
0.18615522980690002,
0.09469731152057648,
0.7252253890037537,
-1.141366958618164,
0.7641347050666809,
0.9582507610321045,
-0.10927707701921463,
-0.546191394329071,
0.0434052012860775,
0.11495881527662277,
-0.9081752300262451,
0.8075926303863525,
0.18028956651687622,
-0.05907105281949043,
-0.3210499584674835,
-0.32935068011283875,
-0.707096517086029,
0.6868571639060974,
0.4921710789203644,
-0.5273831486701965,
-0.11447836458683014,
0.40598589181900024,
0.32303258776664734,
-0.22922661900520325,
0.3375740051269531,
0.6628054976463318,
0.3699033558368683,
-0.15936604142189026,
-1.0198808908462524,
0.16485178470611572,
-0.11504048854112625,
0.07688138633966446,
0.12991587817668915,
-0.8009161353111267,
0.6572363972663879,
-0.028288355097174644,
-0.10443512350320816,
-0.33406978845596313,
0.38510778546333313,
0.5043674111366272,
0.23151817917823792,
0.507131814956665,
0.22831889986991882,
0.6308374404907227,
-0.26656416058540344,
0.9060899615287781,
-0.3829246461391449,
0.05919383093714714,
0.8454571962356567,
-0.5492437481880188,
0.43252915143966675,
0.2873055934906006,
-0.2978855073451996,
0.4078352749347687,
0.7316203713417053,
0.12178279459476471,
0.31579431891441345,
0.20233787596225739,
-0.16290272772312164,
-0.39052069187164307,
-0.30959397554397583,
-0.2736556828022003,
0.20230355858802795,
0.37764304876327515,
-0.35333409905433655,
0.04788803681731224,
0.011399448849260807,
0.28841906785964966,
0.0042423405684530735,
-0.4886225759983063,
0.4043305218219757,
0.15328945219516754,
-0.6625558733940125,
0.7551082968711853,
-0.046582337468862534,
1.010474681854248,
-0.4044969379901886,
0.32011184096336365,
-0.584223210811615,
-0.22279797494411469,
-0.20498093962669373,
-0.8070238828659058,
0.2748416066169739,
0.04623803123831749,
-0.41927146911621094,
-0.09580127894878387,
0.4032628834247589,
-0.5181955099105835,
-0.6242144703865051,
0.4779219627380371,
0.833095371723175,
0.3995613753795624,
0.14477910101413727,
-0.7647485733032227,
0.03222544863820076,
0.09952481836080551,
0.021809319034218788,
0.38451752066612244,
0.4098169505596161,
-0.205140620470047,
0.8012992739677429,
0.3128838539123535,
0.22538699209690094,
0.4396420121192932,
0.33403459191322327,
0.4403618574142456,
-0.6415073871612549,
-0.4049602150917053,
-0.7028793692588806,
0.2625124156475067,
-0.0118604376912117,
-0.2469470202922821,
0.9705309867858887,
0.5357586145401001,
1.3366156816482544,
-0.22721301019191742,
0.9169142246246338,
-0.1351037323474884,
0.7533895969390869,
-0.6831157803535461,
0.5110426545143127,
-0.7361131310462952,
0.13203322887420654,
-0.39080166816711426,
-0.9122457504272461,
0.025459948927164078,
0.3227134644985199,
-0.4219515919685364,
0.31320661306381226,
0.7652407288551331,
1.3004013299942017,
0.1356106847524643,
-0.28614088892936707,
0.6190372705459595,
0.3546896278858185,
-0.11948443949222565,
0.4962034821510315,
1.014827847480774,
0.10236833989620209,
0.6993800401687622,
-0.25444120168685913,
-0.07947970181703568,
-0.006375323515385389,
-0.7083984017372131,
-1.3811321258544922,
-0.34958383440971375,
-0.3813970983028412,
-0.5195839405059814,
0.4747280776500702,
1.1164984703063965,
0.594425618648529,
-0.8920649886131287,
-0.4754980504512787,
0.622586727142334,
0.3081566393375397,
-0.29566526412963867,
-0.25723952054977417,
-0.05121057480573654,
-0.08751966804265976,
-0.8506718873977661,
0.07308153063058853,
0.1362793743610382,
-0.21646706759929657,
-0.3223230540752411,
0.09012756496667862,
0.07431399822235107,
0.16512428224086761,
0.5531907677650452,
0.06575733423233032,
-0.7459157109260559,
-0.12731021642684937,
0.09197397530078888,
-0.2300487458705902,
0.07057570666074753,
0.7058721780776978,
-0.29378220438957214,
0.29636213183403015,
0.4295693337917328,
0.519346296787262,
0.22434112429618835,
-0.1616034358739853,
0.7523335218429565,
-0.9308204650878906,
0.06738340854644775,
-0.012413418851792812,
0.49297866225242615,
0.6037590503692627,
-0.3717498779296875,
0.324469655752182,
0.12416151165962219,
-0.5235016942024231,
-0.6743794679641724,
0.4574491083621979,
-0.5629185438156128,
-0.36845582723617554,
1.3722800016403198,
-0.12418550997972488,
-0.09055260568857193,
-0.4234735667705536,
-0.05396219342947006,
0.04183483496308327,
-0.48501062393188477,
0.8681349158287048,
0.9766796827316284,
0.0949997678399086,
-0.41437795758247375,
-0.7644815444946289,
0.4337642788887024,
0.6954106688499451,
-0.48253294825553894,
0.059478357434272766,
0.6269543766975403,
0.6410104036331177,
-0.18005354702472687,
0.6010928153991699,
-0.23235245048999786,
0.30677351355552673,
-0.22130799293518066,
0.3335939049720764,
0.2672664225101471,
-0.1385420858860016,
-0.017599618062376976,
0.043556541204452515,
0.18819937109947205,
0.1504482924938202
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07239v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07239v1
|
On the Hallucination in Simultaneous Machine Translation
| 2024-06-11T13:20:07 | 2024-06-11T13:20:07 |
Meizhi Zhong, Kehai Chen, Zhengshan Xue, Lemao Liu, Mingming Yang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It is widely known that hallucination is a critical issue in Simultaneous
Machine Translation (SiMT) due to the absence of source-side information. While
many efforts have been made to enhance performance for SiMT, few of them
attempt to understand and analyze hallucination in SiMT. Therefore, we conduct
a comprehensive analysis of hallucination in SiMT from two perspectives:
understanding the distribution of hallucination words and the target-side
context usage of them. Intensive experiments demonstrate some valuable findings
and particularly show that it is possible to alleviate hallucination by
decreasing the over usage of target-side information for SiMT.
|
[
-0.4921163022518158,
-0.8564972877502441,
0.6551529765129089,
0.562465488910675,
-0.4865525960922241,
-0.11053497344255447,
-0.20602327585220337,
-0.4473746120929718,
0.4232816696166992,
0.726161539554596,
-0.6110879778862,
-0.2358202189207077,
-0.7477135062217712,
0.29039496183395386,
-0.5784167647361755,
0.9575759172439575,
-0.2590664327144623,
0.43488001823425293,
-0.42138969898223877,
-0.2965650260448456,
-0.9676715135574341,
-0.8279491662979126,
-0.5199575424194336,
-0.18394304811954498,
0.2890324890613556,
0.2773183286190033,
0.8887954354286194,
0.5530188679695129,
0.7343159914016724,
0.2760177254676819,
0.2266254872083664,
-0.05935094133019447,
-0.5960773825645447,
0.45536357164382935,
-0.07797698676586151,
-0.29338738322257996,
-0.14915014803409576,
-0.26534783840179443,
0.7383150458335876,
0.7749356627464294,
0.2686653733253479,
-0.15808534622192383,
0.2169862985610962,
0.7747121453285217,
-0.25266551971435547,
-0.01681770756840706,
-0.3910972774028778,
0.31203943490982056,
-0.18962498009204865,
-0.6523659825325012,
-0.3814779818058014,
-0.12883642315864563,
-0.06164960563182831,
-0.25598135590553284,
0.4593427777290344,
-0.012417502701282501,
0.479960560798645,
0.8691856265068054,
-0.5354554653167725,
-0.4102058410644531,
-0.8199633359909058,
0.8712269067764282,
-0.07111461460590363,
0.459246426820755,
0.21649335324764252,
0.3884216547012329,
-0.2642616629600525,
-0.4110558032989502,
-0.3524666130542755,
-0.22532759606838226,
-0.2757055163383484,
0.19646960496902466,
0.2394537776708603,
0.09756611287593842,
0.37294909358024597,
0.2696618437767029,
-0.6209478974342346,
-0.41139891743659973,
-0.5407417416572571,
-0.23292522132396698,
0.6206380724906921,
0.007813370786607265,
0.6401264071464539,
-0.17035581171512604,
-0.5051034688949585,
-0.10574409365653992,
-0.27084848284721375,
-0.48730146884918213,
-0.016644837334752083,
0.1755295693874359,
0.2361011505126953,
0.7640479207038879,
0.08072736114263535,
0.29263442754745483,
-0.2750878930091858,
0.11293492466211319,
0.4255432188510895,
-0.5586565136909485,
-0.2792406678199768,
0.1854943484067917,
0.7277763485908508,
0.2273910641670227,
0.061362288892269135,
-0.635871171951294,
-0.30910518765449524,
0.11119721084833145,
0.5628170967102051,
-0.7175012230873108,
0.2405032217502594,
0.4532620906829834,
-0.48015114665031433,
-0.0021119248121976852,
0.2637813091278076,
-0.7036598324775696,
-0.34378084540367126,
-0.2821497619152069,
0.6480197310447693,
-0.45361608266830444,
-0.3088759481906891,
0.06445924192667007,
-0.388074666261673,
0.15070846676826477,
0.1642598956823349,
-0.46372973918914795,
0.6107231378555298,
0.6472724080085754,
1.0814626216888428,
-0.48642095923423767,
-0.7538561224937439,
-0.5026531219482422,
0.20195873081684113,
-0.18745926022529602,
0.649545431137085,
-0.22706238925457,
-0.26838964223861694,
-0.23245869576931,
-0.049555592238903046,
-0.45426636934280396,
-0.7798832058906555,
0.5832333564758301,
-0.14255590736865997,
-0.1471908837556839,
-0.67350172996521,
-0.4485657215118408,
-0.6324858069419861,
-0.21837320923805237,
-0.7640289664268494,
0.9596372842788696,
-0.09790658950805664,
-0.8268621563911438,
0.2282174527645111,
-0.5083873271942139,
-0.7636607885360718,
-0.09032082557678223,
-0.35996952652931213,
-0.14113998413085938,
0.7485741376876831,
-0.08314525336027145,
0.49063485860824585,
-0.019463377073407173,
0.40944796800613403,
0.14423133432865143,
-0.7691795229911804,
0.4425598680973053,
-0.1899622678756714,
0.7076112627983093,
0.3646639883518219,
-0.6602893471717834,
0.04288095235824585,
-0.28332778811454773,
-0.3770388066768646,
0.18513622879981995,
0.2624880373477936,
-0.45029085874557495,
0.11333245784044266,
0.12356734275817871,
0.5270769596099854,
0.14514321088790894,
-0.10182737559080124,
0.21008267998695374,
-0.004313511308282614,
-0.05683985352516174,
0.4785444140434265,
0.16349413990974426,
0.36681315302848816,
-0.2013445496559143,
0.5374813675880432,
0.1800415962934494,
0.11627068370580673,
0.4391815662384033,
-0.4865575134754181,
-0.8485553860664368,
-0.02498834766447544,
-0.08919336646795273,
0.6405395865440369,
-0.8524646759033203,
0.14637793600559235,
-0.04361320286989212,
0.03850942850112915,
-0.6367152333259583,
0.16879573464393616,
0.3651977479457855,
0.06523220241069794,
0.669704794883728,
-0.27319926023483276,
-0.6308900117874146,
-1.0475085973739624,
-0.4880921244621277,
0.2592886984348297,
0.2799986004829407,
0.07316409796476364,
0.512143075466156,
-0.38726669549942017,
0.42300814390182495,
-0.27908775210380554,
-0.5851871371269226,
-0.46220311522483826,
0.30537310242652893,
-0.14201073348522186,
0.4121769070625305,
0.4696081876754761,
-1.1673433780670166,
-0.4240800440311432,
-0.021376240998506546,
-1.1425764560699463,
-0.32593804597854614,
-0.586782693862915,
-0.36236563324928284,
0.205054372549057,
0.7448523640632629,
-0.5324932932853699,
0.6782548427581787,
0.48366138339042664,
-0.10911006480455399,
0.24565890431404114,
-0.13034147024154663,
0.34486979246139526,
-1.1362740993499756,
-0.1685193032026291,
-0.47043538093566895,
-0.057252172380685806,
-0.8625564575195312,
0.12144210189580917,
-0.015786243602633476,
0.18319030106067657,
-0.32791194319725037,
0.15875409543514252,
-0.5436714291572571,
-0.4503932297229767,
-0.46173471212387085,
0.22399590909481049,
-0.31335604190826416,
0.32665371894836426,
0.18547412753105164,
0.7164565324783325,
0.4814130663871765,
-0.545003354549408,
0.251252681016922,
0.048046935349702835,
0.0720200315117836,
0.24615876376628876,
-0.309431254863739,
0.07321734726428986,
-0.24629104137420654,
0.19393803179264069,
-0.9335280656814575,
-0.37430539727211,
0.6361190676689148,
-0.4568612575531006,
0.18465466797351837,
0.3223872184753418,
-0.5914058685302734,
-0.25271761417388916,
-0.18376272916793823,
0.6580432653427124,
0.39944249391555786,
-0.2831445634365082,
0.29899662733078003,
0.29151925444602966,
0.2125588357448578,
-0.5026044249534607,
-0.8543274402618408,
0.05087471753358841,
-0.2626960873603821,
-0.5872290134429932,
0.14562185108661652,
-0.19530099630355835,
-0.39168354868888855,
-0.06796363741159439,
-0.3235026001930237,
-0.03958914801478386,
0.11261060833930969,
0.4881325364112854,
-0.16063618659973145,
0.029830383136868477,
0.3837909400463104,
0.2942578196525574,
-0.21959051489830017,
0.25012192130088806,
-0.13615062832832336,
0.8089784979820251,
0.13300713896751404,
-0.3745378851890564,
-0.742004930973053,
0.8664019107818604,
0.691760778427124,
0.17225287854671478,
1.181058645248413,
0.7707906365394592,
-0.5298870801925659,
-0.0749133825302124,
-0.6407195925712585,
-0.40573182702064514,
-0.3328852653503418,
0.41388845443725586,
-0.8952993750572205,
-0.3679710626602173,
0.5997376441955566,
0.04425805062055588,
-0.3765581250190735,
0.6966749429702759,
0.5262799263000488,
0.16331137716770172,
1.2987675666809082,
0.6871383190155029,
0.12405171245336533,
0.14543919265270233,
-0.004931328818202019,
0.3978578448295593,
-0.6769922375679016,
-0.43673208355903625,
-0.5310952663421631,
-0.31825244426727295,
-0.6419932842254639,
-0.5107816457748413,
0.12237992137670517,
0.33592984080314636,
0.35949933528900146,
0.4196809232234955,
-0.4893767237663269,
0.33828413486480713,
0.3866603374481201,
0.08656877279281616,
0.3926834762096405,
0.0019091315334662795,
-0.022153913974761963,
-0.2681714594364166,
-0.32639309763908386,
-0.38719817996025085,
0.5659593343734741,
0.17465505003929138,
0.40869882702827454,
0.01737808808684349,
1.1662628650665283,
-0.11615145206451416,
-0.012075998820364475,
-0.8921352624893188,
0.6907621622085571,
-0.01611739955842495,
-0.5575814247131348,
-0.3416099548339844,
-0.6190934181213379,
-0.5799275040626526,
0.3689974844455719,
0.20141096413135529,
-0.6103060841560364,
-0.12320080399513245,
-0.18613670766353607,
0.00387342507019639,
0.04104626551270485,
-0.696528971195221,
0.9850612878799438,
-0.3173513114452362,
-0.11822587251663208,
-0.41992437839508057,
-0.6515224575996399,
0.5091108083724976,
-0.3415299654006958,
0.29148849844932556,
0.11231013387441635,
-0.09887231141328812,
0.7419277429580688,
-0.35756435990333557,
0.47151461243629456,
-0.07270987331867218,
0.040327224880456924,
-0.004659984260797501,
0.18543367087841034,
0.33792611956596375,
0.046981073915958405,
0.07004056125879288,
0.29837125539779663,
-0.0926666185259819,
-0.34658533334732056,
-0.753643274307251,
0.6909427642822266,
-0.6785894632339478,
-0.7374234795570374,
-0.655741274356842,
-0.9795114398002625,
0.09254948794841766,
0.07629258930683136,
0.6562991142272949,
-0.13396073877811432,
-0.0976850762963295,
0.1330387145280838,
0.5662173628807068,
-0.28446459770202637,
0.07533517479896545,
-0.19026371836662292,
-0.6340153813362122,
-0.0401989109814167,
0.9332861304283142,
0.422071635723114,
0.36775532364845276,
0.31582215428352356,
0.030155278742313385,
-0.2515738308429718,
-0.5928100347518921,
-0.2508562207221985,
0.55836021900177,
-0.7333537936210632,
0.20490002632141113,
-1.2039189338684082,
-0.5203183889389038,
-0.6689945459365845,
-0.2442987710237503,
-0.4747128188610077,
-0.4432775676250458,
-0.15278291702270508,
0.10884024202823639,
0.06296385079622269,
0.8804754614830017,
-0.15125003457069397,
0.2837603688240051,
-0.5934258699417114,
0.731087327003479,
-0.10253133624792099,
-0.02385692484676838,
-0.3056257367134094,
-0.4459468424320221,
-0.18058578670024872,
0.09554171562194824,
-0.008754037320613861,
-1.1716086864471436,
0.4113706648349762,
-0.34432390332221985,
0.5229133367538452,
0.4418070614337921,
0.09733384102582932,
1.0324766635894775,
-0.29163917899131775,
0.6128409504890442,
0.03728886693716049,
-1.1098710298538208,
0.4633902907371521,
0.18056592345237732,
0.10784854739904404,
0.5556044578552246,
0.6098936796188354,
-0.8059291243553162,
-0.7934542298316956,
-0.433424174785614,
-0.8199114203453064,
0.9083649516105652,
0.5805572867393494,
0.050930414348840714,
0.019102023914456367,
0.13232584297657013,
0.5152536630630493,
0.23649320006370544,
-0.7215670347213745,
-0.21460691094398499,
-0.1659107655286789,
0.04706064611673355,
-0.24609288573265076,
-0.3803677260875702,
0.005314668174833059,
-0.4350490868091583,
0.6879792809486389,
0.3681345582008362,
0.348372220993042,
0.07298304885625839,
-0.5211825370788574,
-0.3032686114311218,
-0.07062006741762161,
0.6620957255363464,
0.6154969930648804,
-0.38469555974006653,
0.2869516611099243,
0.1991109400987625,
-0.6698133945465088,
-0.03426554054021835,
-0.19026659429073334,
-0.20874418318271637,
0.35169604420661926,
0.277677446603775,
0.7404277920722961,
0.0036445234436541796,
-0.2826908528804779,
0.5103034377098083,
-0.04194111004471779,
-0.1517694890499115,
-0.25992581248283386,
-0.10875964909791946,
-0.06821411103010178,
0.23915012180805206,
0.3997047543525696,
0.1414904147386551,
0.4159161448478699,
-0.5373464226722717,
0.37206050753593445,
0.3998429775238037,
-0.4367981255054474,
-0.14390026032924652,
0.6125263571739197,
-0.026264751330018044,
-0.2387266606092453,
0.6620627045631409,
-0.25055766105651855,
-0.8437372446060181,
0.6223650574684143,
0.8714877963066101,
1.334263801574707,
-0.5315789580345154,
0.35526859760284424,
0.2628674805164337,
0.47975677251815796,
-0.38352689146995544,
0.30490580201148987,
-0.20680326223373413,
-0.40369462966918945,
-0.2878541946411133,
-0.5911909341812134,
-0.0881250724196434,
0.07495598495006561,
-0.855987012386322,
0.4328668713569641,
0.12003646790981293,
0.023758281022310257,
-0.16205719113349915,
-0.09897921979427338,
-0.5041871666908264,
-0.04461013525724411,
-0.12537464499473572,
0.3221403956413269,
-1.075605034828186,
0.8115136623382568,
0.554940938949585,
-0.5152451992034912,
-0.3560062050819397,
0.5383456349372864,
0.014098788611590862,
-0.6034830808639526,
0.6841574311256409,
0.5837381482124329,
-0.28485172986984253,
-0.03535204380750656,
-0.33004647493362427,
-0.6430893540382385,
0.83711177110672,
0.13096171617507935,
-0.26935696601867676,
0.08830492198467255,
0.45317769050598145,
0.47940975427627563,
-0.12546341121196747,
-0.1237516701221466,
0.6394041776657104,
0.6977867484092712,
0.2939237058162689,
-0.694793164730072,
0.3942851722240448,
0.18226951360702515,
0.11160221695899963,
0.420792818069458,
-0.6727161407470703,
0.7765127420425415,
-0.04952780157327652,
-0.6237049102783203,
-0.0677204579114914,
0.5024594068527222,
-0.15906192362308502,
0.4785888195037842,
0.3873983919620514,
0.21439144015312195,
0.38708922266960144,
0.012712927535176277,
0.9946814179420471,
0.011520587839186192,
0.24266424775123596,
0.9291343092918396,
-0.11264385282993317,
0.552198588848114,
1.0812541246414185,
0.1405259519815445,
-0.21631306409835815,
0.5266666412353516,
0.23776079714298248,
0.4846770763397217,
0.27230414748191833,
-0.16074056923389435,
-0.2008887529373169,
-0.17628072202205658,
-0.6843865513801575,
0.3801679015159607,
0.36305558681488037,
-0.47417593002319336,
-0.049965787678956985,
0.45581328868865967,
0.002073167823255062,
-0.13158299028873444,
0.13793756067752838,
0.6721178293228149,
0.3275556266307831,
-0.7564387917518616,
0.6274836659431458,
-0.1756828874349594,
0.048213690519332886,
-0.15188734233379364,
-0.16723407804965973,
-0.5307307839393616,
0.10481884330511093,
-0.2414957731962204,
-0.34836870431900024,
0.7749024033546448,
-0.31155115365982056,
-0.09084443002939224,
-0.36698004603385925,
0.47296634316444397,
-0.4493936002254486,
-0.4396076798439026,
0.8691853284835815,
0.6223682165145874,
0.8980666399002075,
-0.5369804501533508,
-0.4039478003978729,
0.48389673233032227,
0.16984497010707855,
-0.25531238317489624,
0.2181754857301712,
0.773140013217926,
-0.17356562614440918,
0.37871962785720825,
0.20744472742080688,
0.0896511897444725,
0.36135947704315186,
0.14782117307186127,
0.7721763253211975,
-0.9917188882827759,
-0.12950865924358368,
-1.0256574153900146,
0.24025790393352509,
-0.09528780728578568,
0.0027481387369334698,
0.9866790771484375,
0.6456021070480347,
0.8241789937019348,
-0.23904109001159668,
0.7770854830741882,
-0.09673811495304108,
0.08477072417736053,
-0.5707651376724243,
0.7455164194107056,
-0.8553829789161682,
0.19689428806304932,
-0.44119513034820557,
-1.5888288021087646,
-0.6397445201873779,
0.5641786456108093,
-0.13716138899326324,
-0.08419342339038849,
1.4406152963638306,
0.6315816640853882,
-0.156776562333107,
0.1308237910270691,
0.6264268755912781,
0.3779025077819824,
-0.2836741507053375,
0.5881641507148743,
0.9281919002532959,
-0.5782904624938965,
0.6855994462966919,
-0.5539078116416931,
-0.20609831809997559,
-0.5655419826507568,
-0.3832482397556305,
-1.0090237855911255,
-0.9259774088859558,
-0.2999791204929352,
-0.2844008505344391,
0.13597428798675537,
0.6139359474182129,
0.24088086187839508,
-0.8617127537727356,
-0.37570902705192566,
-0.20987090468406677,
0.3879018723964691,
-0.6261858940124512,
-0.2531568109989166,
0.37991204857826233,
-0.7312895059585571,
-0.9215061664581299,
0.23816047608852386,
0.5029303431510925,
0.13716080784797668,
-0.17470626533031464,
-0.150275319814682,
-0.16950730979442596,
-0.059654928743839264,
0.48634055256843567,
-0.1895906925201416,
-0.8347553014755249,
-0.11892860382795334,
0.09031977504491806,
-0.31234702467918396,
0.06753135472536087,
1.0009307861328125,
-0.4112051725387573,
0.48712417483329773,
0.7552189826965332,
0.6578090190887451,
0.37769070267677307,
0.1304086297750473,
0.4458388686180115,
-0.5247830748558044,
0.34432849287986755,
0.03842417150735855,
0.05595806986093521,
0.10848299413919449,
-0.5713103413581848,
0.636504590511322,
0.4318009912967682,
-0.48533138632774353,
-0.9635593295097351,
0.21108464896678925,
-1.0295740365982056,
-0.4185364246368408,
1.1885948181152344,
0.41811707615852356,
-0.22438552975654602,
-0.28646141290664673,
-0.508484423160553,
0.877116322517395,
0.00965908169746399,
0.9016959071159363,
1.1198205947875977,
-0.2206326425075531,
0.05894416198134422,
-1.2077335119247437,
0.5283862352371216,
0.726620614528656,
-0.7045092582702637,
-0.017499694600701332,
0.4110845923423767,
-0.3225770890712738,
0.32073068618774414,
0.5219897031784058,
-0.0276710893958807,
0.027541745454072952,
0.2738921046257019,
-0.02412431500852108,
0.33714911341667175,
-0.7463143467903137,
-0.29631316661834717,
0.09951689839363098,
-0.1885416954755783,
-0.433474600315094
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07232v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07232v2
|
DUAL-REFLECT: Enhancing Large Language Models for Reflective Translation through Dual Learning Feedback Mechanisms
| 2024-06-11T13:10:39 | 2024-06-21T16:49:33 |
Andong Chen, Lianzhang Lou, Kehai Chen, Xuefeng Bai, Yang Xiang, Muyun Yang, Tiejun Zhao, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recently, large language models (LLMs) enhanced by self-reflection have
achieved promising performance on machine translation. The key idea is guiding
LLMs to generate translation with human-like feedback. However, existing
self-reflection methods lack effective feedback information, limiting the
translation performance. To address this, we introduce a DUAL-REFLECT
framework, leveraging the dual learning of translation tasks to provide
effective feedback, thereby enhancing the models' self-reflective abilities and
improving translation performance. The application of this method across
various translation tasks has proven its effectiveness in improving translation
accuracy and eliminating ambiguities, especially in translation tasks with
low-resource language pairs.
|
[
-0.03184865787625313,
-0.44800108671188354,
0.43886926770210266,
0.4996727705001831,
-0.32159194350242615,
0.4169847071170807,
-0.5410491824150085,
-0.5117076635360718,
0.37533000111579895,
0.8506094217300415,
-0.4748920202255249,
-0.22617056965827942,
-0.6154902577400208,
0.07311161607503891,
-0.3201621174812317,
1.0819728374481201,
-0.13889780640602112,
0.6100820899009705,
-0.004120275378227234,
-0.22637970745563507,
-0.3997967839241028,
-0.46893325448036194,
-0.5248082876205444,
-0.34761518239974976,
0.7727628946304321,
0.3884848356246948,
0.4733099639415741,
0.04030435159802437,
0.5931992530822754,
0.29191696643829346,
0.3917088508605957,
0.5888983607292175,
-0.5974383354187012,
0.44690147042274475,
-0.2359849512577057,
-0.5910994410514832,
-0.4437854290008545,
0.20572209358215332,
1.1811946630477905,
0.4606756269931793,
-0.2362166792154312,
0.38150855898857117,
0.4516049325466156,
0.7239362001419067,
-0.5405095219612122,
0.09890047460794449,
-0.23134732246398926,
0.07923205196857452,
-0.12897348403930664,
-0.250548779964447,
-0.5591078996658325,
-0.05957124009728432,
-0.14680255949497223,
-0.3031768202781677,
0.11092720925807953,
-0.03213116526603699,
0.31853654980659485,
0.40112632513046265,
-0.8346752524375916,
-0.06838376820087433,
-1.0680996179580688,
0.9867135882377625,
-0.7261338233947754,
0.4155585467815399,
-0.04088424891233444,
0.2861323654651642,
-0.009692121297121048,
-0.6644094586372375,
-0.28250807523727417,
-0.3687255382537842,
-0.18774855136871338,
0.3922549784183502,
0.43322986364364624,
-0.008615548722445965,
0.05357459932565689,
0.5559862852096558,
-0.1070350930094719,
-0.006709298584610224,
-0.2170289009809494,
-0.05981617420911789,
0.9067875742912292,
0.14984801411628723,
0.4024409055709839,
0.09054360538721085,
-0.603810727596283,
-0.12906397879123688,
-0.7302885055541992,
-0.1754542887210846,
0.22009387612342834,
0.6704455018043518,
0.030468221753835678,
0.37765246629714966,
0.0037129721604287624,
0.3384598195552826,
-0.040134597569704056,
-0.04186169058084488,
0.14801128208637238,
-0.5691474080085754,
0.1324983835220337,
-0.20783454179763794,
0.8120889663696289,
0.3140667676925659,
-0.3018854558467865,
-0.422269344329834,
-0.6367121934890747,
0.0976182222366333,
0.5433602333068848,
-0.7415966987609863,
0.04498846083879471,
-0.23462042212486267,
-0.5343056917190552,
-0.30764538049697876,
0.17384053766727448,
-1.152336597442627,
-0.422555148601532,
-0.47788554430007935,
0.8094579577445984,
0.2741399109363556,
-0.7878724336624146,
0.07027269154787064,
0.029575686901807785,
0.17982593178749084,
0.661029577255249,
-0.7767776846885681,
0.7258597612380981,
0.43941476941108704,
0.9532227516174316,
-0.2341533899307251,
-0.41899532079696655,
-0.8160240054130554,
0.22187943756580353,
-0.25638532638549805,
0.5390383005142212,
-0.40703994035720825,
-0.46804264187812805,
0.08767726272344589,
-0.19836364686489105,
0.04453686997294426,
-0.5569537281990051,
0.4056871831417084,
-0.5182209610939026,
0.27640482783317566,
-0.5700703263282776,
-0.20271936058998108,
-0.34659796953201294,
-0.0024205856025218964,
-0.6919776201248169,
1.3574917316436768,
0.14976544678211212,
-0.42324548959732056,
0.2571452260017395,
-0.599092960357666,
-0.5172023773193359,
0.2216452807188034,
-0.09063753485679626,
-0.27617526054382324,
0.4692651331424713,
0.004962260369211435,
0.3140697777271271,
-0.5471310615539551,
0.1312168687582016,
-0.34617406129837036,
-0.2127683162689209,
-0.09535693377256393,
-0.32390204071998596,
0.37841710448265076,
0.02894802950322628,
-0.5839276909828186,
0.1780976504087448,
-0.5789536237716675,
0.03245437517762184,
0.2270694226026535,
-0.5973800420761108,
-0.3120175302028656,
0.007935352623462677,
0.1812993586063385,
0.5238466262817383,
0.4039383828639984,
-0.5401358604431152,
0.5212588906288147,
-0.32806196808815,
0.13155902922153473,
0.6047271490097046,
-0.2997332811355591,
0.571606457233429,
-0.2752680480480194,
0.7144507765769958,
-0.015407697297632694,
-0.12978997826576233,
0.16474826633930206,
-0.2367672473192215,
-0.7621678709983826,
-0.14266251027584076,
0.23732209205627441,
0.526883602142334,
-0.7171615362167358,
-0.0990879163146019,
-0.24670244753360748,
-0.29860827326774597,
-1.0287009477615356,
0.917698860168457,
0.8381460309028625,
0.31185516715049744,
0.5526599884033203,
-0.6871652007102966,
-0.6509416699409485,
-0.7142316699028015,
-0.5325374603271484,
0.077326200902462,
0.17871583998203278,
0.040590669959783554,
0.44546982645988464,
-0.22813256084918976,
0.3697322607040405,
-0.30653491616249084,
-0.5764819979667664,
-0.35693544149398804,
0.3154541552066803,
0.0842353031039238,
0.327889621257782,
0.5382847189903259,
-0.9564043879508972,
-0.8338801264762878,
-0.2498951256275177,
-0.6398502588272095,
-0.19477911293506622,
-0.0016604174161329865,
-0.2447023093700409,
0.3405926823616028,
0.3545168340206146,
-0.277446985244751,
0.24338150024414062,
0.8356714844703674,
-0.4051116704940796,
0.4606582522392273,
-0.46563196182250977,
0.3282330632209778,
-0.9098304510116577,
0.09949226677417755,
-0.08406881242990494,
-0.49483856558799744,
-0.5745552182197571,
0.15177913010120392,
0.25536343455314636,
0.48900938034057617,
-0.22124572098255157,
0.701319694519043,
-0.9150148630142212,
-0.11561361700296402,
-0.550239086151123,
0.19252972304821014,
0.10729362070560455,
0.3675630986690521,
0.058660827577114105,
0.8499456644058228,
0.1485462486743927,
-0.4267806112766266,
0.40299609303474426,
0.09307757019996643,
-0.2878795266151428,
0.4777444005012512,
-0.4602437913417816,
0.2529738247394562,
0.04765714332461357,
0.2557430565357208,
-1.1188615560531616,
-0.05531921237707138,
0.3448968827724457,
-0.09421594440937042,
0.8946343660354614,
-0.14338192343711853,
-0.7401978373527527,
-0.6106900572776794,
-0.440783828496933,
0.4519258439540863,
0.5101360082626343,
-0.8017538189888,
0.6560077667236328,
0.3490411043167114,
-0.0518074557185173,
-0.7136799693107605,
-0.7768914699554443,
0.23240195214748383,
0.080751433968544,
-0.5968985557556152,
0.18633481860160828,
-0.12660445272922516,
-0.09862615168094635,
-0.11427047103643417,
-0.040159113705158234,
0.3238050639629364,
0.07666687667369843,
0.20129378139972687,
0.20482733845710754,
-0.08048199862241745,
0.16837766766548157,
0.016798343509435654,
-0.1081676110625267,
0.060847848653793335,
-0.48766547441482544,
0.4041895568370819,
-0.30853700637817383,
-0.29398849606513977,
-0.24844935536384583,
0.6420816779136658,
0.5979084968566895,
-0.5286182165145874,
0.9258825182914734,
0.5981439352035522,
0.02267874963581562,
-0.5644262433052063,
-0.8988651633262634,
-0.4417146146297455,
-0.45524492859840393,
0.30391034483909607,
-0.4089987874031067,
-0.7801945805549622,
0.47030583024024963,
-0.1489255428314209,
0.1276860386133194,
0.4428929090499878,
0.890198290348053,
-0.10925228893756866,
1.3912830352783203,
0.7261327505111694,
0.005225962959229946,
0.3990286886692047,
-0.2972647547721863,
0.24129468202590942,
-1.188965082168579,
-0.21732039749622345,
-0.21588574349880219,
-0.5715636610984802,
-0.34981754422187805,
-0.5674521327018738,
0.27026593685150146,
-0.10989837348461151,
0.16469183564186096,
0.1385970115661621,
-0.6205575466156006,
0.033337194472551346,
0.9827568531036377,
0.24375943839550018,
0.46654999256134033,
-0.301537424325943,
-0.26097244024276733,
-0.19318437576293945,
-0.4716387093067169,
-0.5265830159187317,
1.115141749382019,
0.2805977761745453,
0.8111622333526611,
0.2523656189441681,
0.8446824550628662,
0.18041731417179108,
0.5169519186019897,
-0.5998433828353882,
0.4441210627555847,
-0.2902640402317047,
-0.7494111061096191,
-0.17467747628688812,
-0.6858261823654175,
-0.43516674637794495,
0.7750054001808167,
-0.04227561876177788,
-0.10395972430706024,
-0.2767121493816376,
0.3600408434867859,
-0.1614372730255127,
0.45424744486808777,
-0.6441652774810791,
0.7663959860801697,
-0.6882468461990356,
-0.6318966150283813,
-0.5350947976112366,
-0.741320788860321,
0.20729322731494904,
-0.08389217406511307,
0.3246665894985199,
0.04398149251937866,
-0.26302018761634827,
0.6425188183784485,
-0.15995067358016968,
1.2126384973526,
-0.6043680310249329,
-0.4577955901622772,
0.15180106461048126,
0.19035696983337402,
0.43580642342567444,
0.06672431528568268,
0.0851350650191307,
-0.02679644152522087,
0.06421302258968353,
-0.3596749007701874,
-0.7563946843147278,
0.6130174398422241,
-0.6621618270874023,
-0.7941193580627441,
-0.3866741955280304,
-0.5487814545631409,
-0.16798138618469238,
0.4292322099208832,
0.11153122037649155,
0.29927313327789307,
-0.13074903190135956,
-0.1448143869638443,
0.48469075560569763,
0.17232759296894073,
0.16831737756729126,
0.9381692409515381,
-0.6597872972488403,
-0.5881922841072083,
0.856016218662262,
0.32559967041015625,
0.353270560503006,
0.3980698883533478,
0.17358769476413727,
-0.34885987639427185,
-0.5339811444282532,
-0.502397358417511,
0.747931718826294,
-0.4198797643184662,
-0.2910204529762268,
-0.39269715547561646,
-0.11435454338788986,
-0.4759337306022644,
0.19050221145153046,
-0.6806235909461975,
-0.5571646690368652,
-0.09750726073980331,
0.0823049321770668,
-0.24665556848049164,
1.1980348825454712,
-0.37145984172821045,
0.03745485469698906,
-0.9662945866584778,
0.2679581642150879,
0.37376418709754944,
0.40229907631874084,
0.02917950227856636,
-0.7250494956970215,
-0.44685718417167664,
0.35391709208488464,
-0.31121957302093506,
-0.791534423828125,
0.3663627505302429,
0.24414794147014618,
0.46945637464523315,
0.24180302023887634,
0.01578006148338318,
0.2723729610443115,
-0.689658522605896,
0.652613639831543,
0.3013901114463806,
-0.8983361721038818,
0.5599780082702637,
-0.22104164958000183,
0.2729489207267761,
0.5386332273483276,
0.062437888234853745,
-0.7550023198127747,
-0.463443398475647,
-0.13630609214305878,
-0.7031976580619812,
0.7386667132377625,
-0.25091353058815,
0.33518457412719727,
0.3102184236049652,
0.5691353678703308,
0.17856353521347046,
0.4107533395290375,
-0.8823738098144531,
-0.08458860218524933,
-0.15097925066947937,
-0.1641479730606079,
-0.39243966341018677,
-0.6757744550704956,
-0.2744022011756897,
-0.24422557651996613,
0.8495961427688599,
-0.2182411253452301,
0.26362144947052,
0.11253386735916138,
-0.2158430963754654,
-0.5157594680786133,
0.07103398442268372,
0.6399574279785156,
0.18192355334758759,
0.012249165214598179,
0.4269563555717468,
0.298854261636734,
-0.43806105852127075,
0.27819663286209106,
-0.24332469701766968,
-0.2238280028104782,
-0.2006489783525467,
0.3825227916240692,
0.49088945984840393,
0.47649240493774414,
-0.2399643361568451,
0.5966257452964783,
-0.055908698588609695,
-0.16079844534397125,
-0.2313728779554367,
0.07593773305416107,
0.06231936812400818,
0.34890711307525635,
0.16830743849277496,
0.01824181154370308,
0.202264204621315,
-0.4784214496612549,
0.08495080471038818,
0.5957868695259094,
-0.5457525849342346,
-0.7444452047348022,
0.70611971616745,
0.45598822832107544,
-0.2663341760635376,
0.5181795954704285,
-0.05913142114877701,
-0.9085274934768677,
0.14670686423778534,
0.6622454524040222,
0.9416871070861816,
-0.7211312651634216,
0.1783841997385025,
0.45403432846069336,
0.14680905640125275,
-0.49104633927345276,
0.36277392506599426,
-0.386692613363266,
-0.5122735500335693,
-0.56004798412323,
-0.6422860622406006,
-0.31640082597732544,
-0.5354435443878174,
-1.0106462240219116,
0.2412831038236618,
-0.1712876558303833,
-0.20959877967834473,
-0.4332747161388397,
0.41788777709007263,
-0.4879099428653717,
0.015029259957373142,
0.22712616622447968,
0.8086537718772888,
-0.7358254194259644,
0.9852616786956787,
0.8874062299728394,
-0.6138349771499634,
-0.5504841804504395,
-0.20039920508861542,
0.09506339579820633,
-0.7455838918685913,
0.8318410515785217,
0.19005846977233887,
-0.7750717401504517,
-0.013538267463445663,
-0.47172459959983826,
-0.8874440789222717,
0.8535561561584473,
0.46857020258903503,
-0.5202403664588928,
-0.29312142729759216,
0.14562226831912994,
0.7942087054252625,
-0.24035881459712982,
0.14383183419704437,
0.1636914610862732,
0.5597980618476868,
0.13548903167247772,
-1.0276997089385986,
0.1892985701560974,
-0.3414863646030426,
0.06596913188695908,
0.5886674523353577,
-1.2186156511306763,
0.23003137111663818,
-0.2141008973121643,
-0.27289101481437683,
0.03356408327817917,
0.7487257122993469,
-0.36265334486961365,
0.09737605601549149,
0.4994109272956848,
0.5770589113235474,
0.5892840027809143,
0.06900780647993088,
0.9981931447982788,
-0.3121708333492279,
0.45099949836730957,
1.3658555746078491,
-0.43011075258255005,
0.9966937899589539,
0.6193642020225525,
-0.14182130992412567,
0.6391839981079102,
-0.01839405857026577,
-0.11223104596138,
0.7101387977600098,
0.07676645368337631,
-0.40889352560043335,
-0.5257784724235535,
-0.027881847694516182,
-0.27148330211639404,
0.40494999289512634,
0.37356507778167725,
-0.3608991503715515,
-0.03684481605887413,
0.009366407990455627,
0.008500340394675732,
0.41265982389450073,
-0.04094761237502098,
0.7285393476486206,
0.3717142939567566,
-1.0511115789413452,
0.22466282546520233,
0.00835694745182991,
0.7130893468856812,
-0.5859565138816833,
-0.27122217416763306,
-0.06664308905601501,
0.5204386115074158,
-0.19188079237937927,
-0.5848880410194397,
0.3550197184085846,
-0.37786492705345154,
-0.31550565361976624,
-0.8473185300827026,
0.48679444193840027,
-0.8456718921661377,
-0.37355339527130127,
1.0622388124465942,
0.4638284146785736,
-0.3814011514186859,
-0.07467762380838394,
-0.5447056889533997,
-0.05667508766055107,
-0.0018870033090934157,
-0.2971284091472626,
0.34126535058021545,
0.14394722878932953,
0.4166280925273895,
0.5656388998031616,
0.3498993217945099,
0.346376895904541,
0.23873618245124817,
0.05251180753111839,
0.653177797794342,
-0.5458410382270813,
-0.14567367732524872,
-0.768425703048706,
0.5254934430122375,
-0.1116504892706871,
-0.0245665293186903,
1.1692290306091309,
0.5423846244812012,
0.6857961416244507,
-0.06384746730327606,
0.7538805603981018,
0.12162796407938004,
0.9959657788276672,
-0.3975912928581238,
0.6990446448326111,
-0.9026482105255127,
0.2847675383090973,
-0.17382946610450745,
-0.9340999722480774,
-0.5375784039497375,
0.50490802526474,
-0.39320966601371765,
0.27575939893722534,
0.6682791113853455,
0.8927602171897888,
-0.03113630972802639,
-0.09043627232313156,
0.27701470255851746,
0.4305587112903595,
0.32864028215408325,
0.5388456583023071,
1.169357180595398,
-0.5274848937988281,
0.4750567376613617,
-0.32303810119628906,
-0.4160991311073303,
-0.28162720799446106,
-0.659722089767456,
-0.9731674194335938,
-0.759292483329773,
-0.3213796019554138,
-0.4665692448616028,
-0.018598593771457672,
0.8103737831115723,
0.9180718660354614,
-0.8800397515296936,
-0.44744977355003357,
0.1428087055683136,
-0.1311829686164856,
-0.3296394348144531,
-0.15086977183818817,
0.22630825638771057,
-0.6627231240272522,
-0.7222961783409119,
0.568546712398529,
0.4684179723262787,
-0.1505325734615326,
-0.6725146770477295,
-0.3622615337371826,
-0.20442689955234528,
0.0015063832979649305,
0.4293261468410492,
0.13662947714328766,
-0.7300989031791687,
-0.31311744451522827,
-0.11928411573171616,
-0.3325013220310211,
0.1428608000278473,
1.01033616065979,
-0.6207216382026672,
0.6672917604446411,
0.3211385905742645,
0.5094993710517883,
0.7586889266967773,
-0.1353730708360672,
0.9164489507675171,
-0.5315970778465271,
-0.07508653402328491,
0.25420427322387695,
0.19859305024147034,
0.3907555937767029,
-0.47695207595825195,
0.6962012648582458,
0.202243372797966,
-0.7101962566375732,
-0.8274039626121521,
0.2903541028499603,
-0.731423020362854,
-0.020464466884732246,
1.161881923675537,
-0.21895413100719452,
0.011707325465977192,
0.23329395055770874,
-0.38306424021720886,
0.35004380345344543,
-0.15821710228919983,
0.8576489686965942,
0.6533926725387573,
0.15556548535823822,
-0.10919630527496338,
-0.5903539061546326,
0.42896968126296997,
0.8397471308708191,
-0.4914325475692749,
0.03365883603692055,
0.3662348985671997,
0.318671315908432,
0.12706220149993896,
0.6305450201034546,
-0.1779250055551529,
0.27199310064315796,
-0.07039473950862885,
0.06186867505311966,
0.1941632330417633,
-0.5928324460983276,
-0.4278198182582855,
0.08321643620729446,
0.39244550466537476,
0.15256020426750183
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07231v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07231v1
|
Decipherment-Aware Multilingual Learning in Jointly Trained Language Models
| 2024-06-11T13:10:30 | 2024-06-11T13:10:30 |
Grandee Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The principle that governs unsupervised multilingual learning (UCL) in
jointly trained language models (mBERT as a popular example) is still being
debated. Many find it surprising that one can achieve UCL with multiple
monolingual corpora. In this work, we anchor UCL in the context of language
decipherment and show that the joint training methodology is a decipherment
process pivotal for UCL. In a controlled setting, we investigate the effect of
different decipherment settings on the multilingual learning performance and
consolidate the existing opinions on the contributing factors to
multilinguality. From an information-theoretic perspective we draw a limit to
the UCL performance and demonstrate the importance of token alignment in
challenging decipherment settings caused by differences in the data domain,
language order and tokenization granularity. Lastly, we apply lexical alignment
to mBERT and investigate the contribution of aligning different lexicon groups
to downstream performance.
|
[
-0.28690236806869507,
-0.4640895426273346,
0.2826398015022278,
0.02917669527232647,
-0.40207913517951965,
0.6403474807739258,
-0.33483657240867615,
-0.7192984819412231,
-0.15901514887809753,
0.44365841150283813,
-0.17684273421764374,
-0.5831013321876526,
-0.46978098154067993,
0.10167425870895386,
0.021860672160983086,
0.9251325130462646,
-0.0005547379842028022,
0.3594142198562622,
-0.19109171628952026,
-0.5416507124900818,
-0.3827575743198395,
-0.9221012592315674,
-0.44838735461235046,
-0.45719587802886963,
0.38970598578453064,
0.38692063093185425,
0.6428194642066956,
0.7321903705596924,
0.5703784227371216,
0.28937268257141113,
-0.12325852364301682,
0.09179964661598206,
-0.2752417325973511,
0.08464861661195755,
-0.20419372618198395,
-0.6296864151954651,
-0.05662614107131958,
-0.15948143601417542,
0.772845447063446,
1.3288260698318481,
-0.13115304708480835,
-0.017675697803497314,
0.34942325949668884,
0.8357879519462585,
-0.5169920921325684,
0.1601565182209015,
-0.6714515089988708,
0.05366351827979088,
-0.31095531582832336,
0.12073148787021637,
-0.6612820029258728,
-0.043226830661296844,
0.052935656160116196,
-0.6169506311416626,
0.36568737030029297,
0.08155396580696106,
0.4569317400455475,
0.11824126541614532,
-0.7876113653182983,
-0.1566278487443924,
-0.6828716993331909,
0.8319893479347229,
-0.3360136151313782,
1.1324591636657715,
0.3132772445678711,
0.20447413623332977,
0.22777359187602997,
-0.43704184889793396,
-0.19003790616989136,
-0.02378183603286743,
-0.22486700117588043,
0.20873312652111053,
0.1701050102710724,
0.1774449348449707,
0.11319643259048462,
0.20969246327877045,
-0.6276823282241821,
0.2604142427444458,
-0.3185437023639679,
-0.4315798580646515,
0.22811289131641388,
-0.03362167626619339,
0.07317201048135757,
0.08835937827825546,
-0.6629685759544373,
-0.02414843998849392,
-0.7088847160339355,
0.26341304183006287,
0.3142334818840027,
0.6836974024772644,
-0.2618635594844818,
0.4195367693901062,
0.2157794088125229,
0.5214216113090515,
-0.11345064640045166,
-0.19006705284118652,
0.3846687376499176,
-0.3621794581413269,
0.002568997209891677,
0.3183595538139343,
0.4991725981235504,
-0.10759540647268295,
0.19586582481861115,
-0.4395768344402313,
0.016574997454881668,
0.15402460098266602,
0.09237077087163925,
-0.6024650931358337,
-0.2127670794725418,
0.11878649145364761,
-0.28419017791748047,
0.07410918921232224,
0.2185257375240326,
-0.5603286623954773,
-0.2174723744392395,
-0.7305157780647278,
0.21187259256839752,
-0.660274863243103,
-0.7251647710800171,
0.03613660857081413,
-0.13716158270835876,
0.12087646126747131,
0.19373466074466705,
-1.2133952379226685,
0.24042993783950806,
0.7376237511634827,
0.4169086515903473,
-0.1454906165599823,
-0.7507040500640869,
-0.24359320104122162,
0.37592053413391113,
-0.3861863613128662,
0.521432638168335,
-0.533917248249054,
-0.19676455855369568,
-0.0352298729121685,
-0.11261750757694244,
-0.5362108945846558,
-0.3830726742744446,
0.04460762441158295,
-0.5749015808105469,
0.017331788316369057,
-0.3924125134944916,
-0.5879767537117004,
-0.14306174218654633,
0.07110989093780518,
-0.5249940156936646,
0.8489619493484497,
-0.056372854858636856,
-1.0578793287277222,
0.7575445771217346,
-0.6656780242919922,
-0.7047078013420105,
-0.041676126420497894,
-0.5113887190818787,
-0.03426365926861763,
0.24254465103149414,
0.07763850688934326,
0.14956429600715637,
0.274912565946579,
0.21813569962978363,
-0.04647837206721306,
-0.1722809225320816,
0.35766664147377014,
-0.713113009929657,
0.9635538458824158,
0.05018657445907593,
-0.26030996441841125,
-0.04127926006913185,
-0.9025540947914124,
0.05555934086441994,
-0.16146095097064972,
-0.5901240706443787,
-0.5606217384338379,
-0.18972527980804443,
-0.008467094041407108,
0.05070708692073822,
0.2599990665912628,
-0.34451475739479065,
0.0444064736366272,
-0.28511616587638855,
0.14031684398651123,
0.6382893323898315,
-0.24623538553714752,
0.4980381429195404,
0.17238211631774902,
0.3237020969390869,
0.4312577545642853,
0.15501995384693146,
0.08837778121232986,
-0.13999122381210327,
-0.5922743082046509,
-0.4268667697906494,
0.5645529627799988,
0.4580684006214142,
-0.8105710744857788,
-0.006260584574192762,
-0.051591455936431885,
0.024673795327544212,
-0.9834878444671631,
0.3818914592266083,
0.6894472241401672,
0.3438095450401306,
0.2996107041835785,
-0.1513158529996872,
-0.47996437549591064,
-0.9373694062232971,
-0.04584965109825134,
-0.32999131083488464,
0.13465778529644012,
-0.2486076056957245,
0.24617959558963776,
-0.030112246051430702,
0.5706655383110046,
-0.15842965245246887,
-0.07882540673017502,
-0.3849295377731323,
0.3304908573627472,
0.018931083381175995,
0.40614381432533264,
0.41878262162208557,
-0.9763308763504028,
-0.36064276099205017,
0.3578133285045624,
-0.7530396580696106,
0.13857215642929077,
0.005203917622566223,
-0.16821300983428955,
0.5021945834159851,
0.6921297311782837,
-0.14254148304462433,
0.20648273825645447,
0.6303055286407471,
-0.30978721380233765,
0.4319053888320923,
-0.6095372438430786,
0.09200987964868546,
-1.1801186800003052,
0.06747545301914215,
-0.42471206188201904,
-0.2233836054801941,
-0.6917048692703247,
0.3851972818374634,
0.35473743081092834,
0.3172371983528137,
-0.4091184139251709,
0.14186394214630127,
-0.8087763786315918,
-0.22801126539707184,
-0.22262144088745117,
0.2613542079925537,
0.16768741607666016,
0.47678253054618835,
0.27999481558799744,
0.8222037553787231,
0.6913959980010986,
-0.5725628733634949,
-0.21948736906051636,
0.40539637207984924,
-0.44974038004875183,
0.6117590069770813,
-0.13582810759544373,
0.030662359669804573,
-0.2093288004398346,
-0.3559941053390503,
-0.9197278022766113,
0.014192399568855762,
-0.2926814556121826,
-0.32995980978012085,
0.6479217410087585,
-0.16586685180664062,
-0.2881474196910858,
-0.052371881902217865,
-0.012704510241746902,
0.5536256432533264,
0.027905672788619995,
-0.8014103174209595,
0.3440549969673157,
0.5024904012680054,
0.2093035727739334,
-0.8470202088356018,
-0.911149263381958,
-0.07057206332683563,
-0.3280163109302521,
-0.2928465008735657,
0.016925359144806862,
-0.2525973320007324,
-0.37175193428993225,
-0.3949735760688782,
-0.0883062556385994,
-0.11243045330047607,
0.31852829456329346,
0.2400430142879486,
0.11055988818407059,
-0.10731066763401031,
0.24258029460906982,
-0.08779577910900116,
-0.19619068503379822,
-0.030420133844017982,
-0.010129246860742569,
0.5406592488288879,
-0.28457754850387573,
-0.5273011326789856,
0.008090442046523094,
0.5128297209739685,
0.6087826490402222,
-0.4742448925971985,
0.801734983921051,
0.7287614345550537,
-0.06272368133068085,
-0.003302798606455326,
-0.3349475562572479,
0.018735598772764206,
-0.4560704827308655,
0.1641494184732437,
-0.7755536437034607,
-0.9467661380767822,
0.7879812717437744,
-0.10548628121614456,
-0.038846585899591446,
0.23125062882900238,
0.44929221272468567,
0.04642156511545181,
1.035042405128479,
1.0253723859786987,
-0.18409530818462372,
0.3693940341472626,
-0.1979316622018814,
0.034100715070962906,
-0.98915034532547,
-0.34578737616539,
-0.4140640199184418,
-0.020702168345451355,
-0.7542914152145386,
-0.015030255541205406,
0.3579951524734497,
0.6541612148284912,
-0.15903335809707642,
0.3154563009738922,
-0.20386311411857605,
0.5494528412818909,
0.6798640489578247,
0.06563924998044968,
0.5470878481864929,
0.05824446305632591,
-1.0217700004577637,
-0.12095893919467926,
-0.6044328212738037,
-0.18771375715732574,
0.8384489417076111,
0.06115876883268356,
0.5802938938140869,
0.492828369140625,
0.7933498620986938,
-0.2047613263130188,
-0.001647917670197785,
-0.4611130356788635,
0.3484078347682953,
-0.1651620715856552,
-0.5915786623954773,
-0.10618729889392853,
-0.42436540126800537,
-1.1064993143081665,
0.6159565448760986,
-0.08255212008953094,
-0.8979537487030029,
0.18926535546779633,
-0.1636498123407364,
0.10652700066566467,
0.24080593883991241,
-0.7568562030792236,
0.9832792282104492,
-0.3191121518611908,
-0.22055299580097198,
-0.11334724724292755,
-1.0402038097381592,
0.038199156522750854,
-0.2836402356624603,
0.4644489288330078,
0.026732297614216805,
0.15719082951545715,
0.5478900671005249,
-0.25663501024246216,
0.8246838450431824,
-0.09132829308509827,
-0.10578417778015137,
0.026936577633023262,
0.08825194090604782,
0.008869001641869545,
0.04942290484905243,
-0.03714136779308319,
0.3948248028755188,
0.2660919725894928,
-0.362410306930542,
-0.17250627279281616,
0.43152472376823425,
-0.8418208360671997,
-0.46345680952072144,
-0.30503809452056885,
-0.806316614151001,
-0.3822989761829376,
0.3074813187122345,
0.30626872181892395,
0.5940949320793152,
-0.28913646936416626,
0.06069350987672806,
0.41002675890922546,
0.2277020364999771,
0.5664919018745422,
0.8840665221214294,
-0.4106949269771576,
-0.41251564025878906,
0.8474966287612915,
0.003226555185392499,
0.7048221826553345,
0.7221480011940002,
0.06619901955127716,
-0.5410452485084534,
-0.8228821754455566,
-0.5006422400474548,
0.21548354625701904,
-0.9106734991073608,
0.0318230465054512,
-0.31556540727615356,
-0.10142971575260162,
-0.5524020791053772,
-0.09956355392932892,
-0.2991737425327301,
-0.43784064054489136,
-0.1510745882987976,
-0.20690257847309113,
0.06347623467445374,
0.5675862431526184,
-0.5228012204170227,
0.19623377919197083,
-0.7632979154586792,
0.2167803794145584,
0.09666500240564346,
0.28832608461380005,
-0.3546518385410309,
-0.457715779542923,
-0.5859769582748413,
0.32085683941841125,
-0.05916814133524895,
-0.6041044592857361,
0.05211205780506134,
0.19336453080177307,
0.7806442975997925,
0.6531193256378174,
0.05878593027591705,
0.8309826850891113,
-0.5463072657585144,
0.4382037818431854,
0.12450125068426132,
-0.8595473766326904,
0.3325101137161255,
-0.13913199305534363,
0.6212497353553772,
1.0403261184692383,
0.4318370521068573,
-0.5151659250259399,
-0.6494625806808472,
-0.4197198450565338,
-0.7007493376731873,
0.49817320704460144,
-0.047271013259887695,
-0.23256734013557434,
-0.10003171116113663,
0.0007432446000166237,
0.3253853917121887,
0.41238507628440857,
-0.6566967368125916,
-0.3239500820636749,
0.1440998762845993,
-0.16124367713928223,
-0.08296200633049011,
-0.16712257266044617,
-0.20250488817691803,
-0.4307073652744293,
0.4287727177143097,
-0.2173348367214203,
0.14024721086025238,
-0.20292922854423523,
-0.40196549892425537,
-0.10049063712358475,
0.3603697121143341,
0.32046061754226685,
0.9919041395187378,
-0.17108669877052307,
0.4775860011577606,
-0.029871691018342972,
-0.618575394153595,
0.09698177874088287,
0.16338185966014862,
0.012884281575679779,
-0.10972250998020172,
0.6079463958740234,
0.8441210985183716,
0.3886265754699707,
-0.4151860177516937,
0.3434169888496399,
-0.10847209393978119,
-0.24938756227493286,
0.044971249997615814,
-0.22318091988563538,
0.013631217181682587,
0.4751325845718384,
0.20766718685626984,
0.1466728150844574,
0.003810035064816475,
-0.5945602059364319,
0.21316318213939667,
0.6064476370811462,
-0.2708384096622467,
-0.3928544521331787,
0.6457082629203796,
-0.16365382075309753,
0.10169682651758194,
0.6270164847373962,
-0.17521622776985168,
-0.641757607460022,
0.3709960877895355,
0.7834020256996155,
0.6517467498779297,
-0.6676223278045654,
0.2825869619846344,
0.05795743316411972,
0.4276888072490692,
0.020586451515555382,
0.35420283675193787,
-0.3782453238964081,
-1.0801894664764404,
-0.37576133012771606,
-0.73662269115448,
-0.5489892363548279,
-0.21081772446632385,
-1.0498195886611938,
0.06148720532655716,
-0.03470610827207565,
0.1958473026752472,
0.19834329187870026,
-0.09372341632843018,
-0.6529446244239807,
-0.01423597987741232,
0.12508811056613922,
0.501024067401886,
-0.9029681086540222,
1.1709195375442505,
0.7167483568191528,
-0.32328560948371887,
-0.898888349533081,
-0.19327448308467865,
-0.016891079023480415,
-0.9441767930984497,
0.6864038109779358,
0.38423508405685425,
-0.12150461971759796,
0.029170121997594833,
0.018075326457619667,
-0.7777197360992432,
0.9471485614776611,
0.5824573636054993,
-0.3266616761684418,
0.10002116858959198,
0.6893835067749023,
0.5997806191444397,
-0.17045971751213074,
0.1879158318042755,
0.5155755877494812,
0.26970943808555603,
0.2764473259449005,
-1.0420207977294922,
-0.38025712966918945,
0.11935864388942719,
-0.09026051312685013,
0.5418527126312256,
-0.5082899332046509,
0.7075690031051636,
-0.29994961619377136,
-0.4337332248687744,
-0.307280957698822,
0.5117126703262329,
0.05683845654129982,
0.38213303685188293,
0.3724374771118164,
0.5816347599029541,
1.0037888288497925,
-0.0078078568913042545,
0.7058719396591187,
-0.46228665113449097,
0.2560175359249115,
1.2071921825408936,
-0.32154545187950134,
1.0122002363204956,
0.5831363201141357,
-0.32710540294647217,
0.2095753401517868,
0.5742677450180054,
0.4304857850074768,
0.7158651351928711,
-0.13068196177482605,
-0.4857591688632965,
-0.3158096671104431,
-0.15367700159549713,
-0.36812421679496765,
0.7102975249290466,
0.3640938103199005,
-0.2515554428100586,
-0.4731162190437317,
0.5002012848854065,
-0.09054545313119888,
0.10701362043619156,
-0.3739698827266693,
0.9038167595863342,
0.038412224501371384,
-0.3088599741458893,
0.6807565093040466,
-0.2710959315299988,
0.37593910098075867,
-0.549406111240387,
0.11993135511875153,
-0.24066856503486633,
0.4385089874267578,
0.056130509823560715,
-0.6233641505241394,
0.39421817660331726,
-0.2917623519897461,
-0.1932084709405899,
-0.32474133372306824,
0.4430356025695801,
-0.9253831505775452,
-0.6084986329078674,
0.6284320950508118,
0.7736040949821472,
0.32774728536605835,
0.0995975062251091,
-0.8339912295341492,
0.09235772490501404,
0.1624131053686142,
-0.03771521896123886,
0.6181440949440002,
0.7140552997589111,
0.058584004640579224,
0.4664042890071869,
0.3764483332633972,
-0.12812571227550507,
0.06750795990228653,
0.38842204213142395,
0.7367379665374756,
-0.4406639635562897,
-0.38755035400390625,
-0.8549767732620239,
0.38236749172210693,
0.20028914511203766,
-0.1393027901649475,
0.9280299544334412,
0.7832387089729309,
1.2132205963134766,
0.07771620899438858,
0.5738102793693542,
0.24581947922706604,
0.5384688973426819,
-0.7315245270729065,
0.5695577263832092,
-0.3225972354412079,
0.2205665409564972,
-0.07693202793598175,
-0.7420510053634644,
-0.483045756816864,
0.5505136847496033,
-0.12237079441547394,
-0.06418010592460632,
0.9697386622428894,
0.6714432835578918,
-0.07860467582941055,
0.12376002222299576,
0.5568517446517944,
0.0731784924864769,
0.18168343603610992,
0.4273029565811157,
0.6867464780807495,
-0.16835471987724304,
0.4946434795856476,
-0.38626745343208313,
-0.039445798844099045,
0.23303814232349396,
-0.7160502672195435,
-1.129085898399353,
-0.8849102854728699,
-0.310705304145813,
-0.12448901683092117,
-0.01452573575079441,
0.7363319993019104,
0.4244239926338196,
-0.7651589512825012,
-0.43978846073150635,
-0.30517667531967163,
0.1576320379972458,
-0.36361613869667053,
-0.21650193631649017,
0.5576892495155334,
-0.43299248814582825,
-0.5822453498840332,
0.637017011642456,
0.28223344683647156,
0.13284067809581757,
-0.030636079609394073,
0.07272334396839142,
-0.48812347650527954,
-0.31743720173835754,
0.6405516862869263,
0.2914123833179474,
-0.5574913024902344,
-0.36860814690589905,
-0.23927989602088928,
-0.09565906971693039,
0.366286963224411,
0.7662327885627747,
-0.6369577050209045,
0.5517169237136841,
0.14532673358917236,
0.5792662501335144,
0.4034523665904999,
0.0009293599869124591,
0.3035385310649872,
-1.183184027671814,
0.3670235872268677,
-0.23395299911499023,
0.4648909270763397,
0.4408728778362274,
-0.17388823628425598,
0.514739453792572,
0.13832631707191467,
-0.6054458022117615,
-0.6092577576637268,
0.32592037320137024,
-0.9471237063407898,
-0.4760325253009796,
0.9702339172363281,
0.0044920118525624275,
-0.1603769063949585,
-0.33907681703567505,
-0.17368508875370026,
0.34408047795295715,
-0.10142974555492401,
0.474314421415329,
0.6912228465080261,
-0.14545273780822754,
-0.26669326424598694,
-0.4120640456676483,
0.3688548505306244,
0.3443918228149414,
-0.6658377051353455,
0.3797500729560852,
0.5078511238098145,
0.1782332807779312,
0.2990657091140747,
0.47748416662216187,
0.01480273250490427,
-0.07761577516794205,
0.0320403091609478,
0.13542935252189636,
-0.10309672355651855,
-0.5742015242576599,
-0.4044508635997772,
0.08356685191392899,
0.33003440499305725,
-0.3557673394680023
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07229v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07229v1
|
Improving Commonsense Bias Classification by Mitigating the Influence of Demographic Terms
| 2024-06-11T13:09:16 | 2024-06-11T13:09:16 |
JinKyu Lee, Jihie Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, 68T50, I.2.7; I.2.6
|
Understanding commonsense knowledge is crucial in the field of Natural
Language Processing (NLP). However, the presence of demographic terms in
commonsense knowledge poses a potential risk of compromising the performance of
NLP models. This study aims to investigate and propose methods for enhancing
the performance and effectiveness of a commonsense polarization classifier by
mitigating the influence of demographic terms. Three methods are introduced in
this paper: (1) hierarchical generalization of demographic terms (2)
threshold-based augmentation and (3) integration of hierarchical generalization
and threshold-based augmentation methods (IHTA). The first method involves
replacing demographic terms with more general ones based on a term hierarchy
ontology, aiming to mitigate the influence of specific terms. To address the
limited bias-related information, the second method measures the polarization
of demographic terms by comparing the changes in the model's predictions when
these terms are masked versus unmasked. This method augments commonsense
sentences containing terms with high polarization values by replacing their
predicates with synonyms generated by ChatGPT. The third method combines the
two approaches, starting with threshold-based augmentation followed by
hierarchical generalization. The experiments show that the first method
increases the accuracy over the baseline by 2.33%, and the second one by 0.96%
over standard augmentation methods. The IHTA techniques yielded an 8.82% and
9.96% higher accuracy than threshold-based and standard augmentation methods,
respectively.
|
[
-0.6997290253639221,
-0.4678434133529663,
-0.02085484378039837,
0.15639667212963104,
-0.24857918918132782,
-0.038617752492427826,
-0.31040945649147034,
-0.14843231439590454,
-0.00403549475595355,
0.7891935706138611,
-0.47030624747276306,
-0.5416356921195984,
-0.646432638168335,
0.09419871866703033,
0.3172781765460968,
1.06990647315979,
0.522991418838501,
0.18566791713237762,
-0.4387848377227783,
-0.30259355902671814,
-0.5454885959625244,
-0.6503638029098511,
-0.4327738583087921,
-0.38157159090042114,
0.30779045820236206,
0.42575958371162415,
0.8037943840026855,
0.6676281094551086,
0.3477892577648163,
0.238658145070076,
-0.6172926425933838,
0.11921830475330353,
-0.5179603695869446,
-0.17566105723381042,
-0.292682945728302,
-0.31965094804763794,
-0.3656996786594391,
0.19134747982025146,
0.5062189698219299,
0.6577852368354797,
-0.14271946251392365,
0.17985011637210846,
0.18625453114509583,
0.8025239706039429,
-0.8339741826057434,
0.36313503980636597,
-0.8182587623596191,
0.07885578274726868,
-0.4262917935848236,
-0.6021287441253662,
-0.30886968970298767,
-0.37329262495040894,
0.1884734183549881,
-0.6442261934280396,
0.4930327236652374,
0.11808742582798004,
0.4789271056652069,
0.22329922020435333,
-0.44669309258461,
-0.08148599416017532,
-0.352473646402359,
1.1632639169692993,
-0.9842684864997864,
0.3656723201274872,
0.7265204191207886,
0.07388169318437576,
0.11729205399751663,
-0.15669536590576172,
-0.5833139419555664,
-0.42001739144325256,
-0.3313097655773163,
0.1029779389500618,
-0.22465696930885315,
0.26972857117652893,
0.5766032934188843,
0.20957188308238983,
-0.43832746148109436,
0.3233349025249481,
-0.6912640333175659,
-0.30350422859191895,
0.5359072685241699,
-0.012053322046995163,
0.5134047865867615,
-0.484975129365921,
-0.49237897992134094,
-0.18734318017959595,
-0.6086976528167725,
-0.08216410875320435,
0.6578262448310852,
0.5191481113433838,
0.08014888316392899,
0.6801387667655945,
-0.4093421697616577,
0.5553179979324341,
0.329030305147171,
0.009777722880244255,
0.491534948348999,
-0.3899482786655426,
0.16527386009693146,
-0.08885731548070908,
0.37055835127830505,
0.5639780163764954,
0.19334620237350464,
-0.035799089819192886,
-0.14931200444698334,
0.23158995807170868,
0.0803728923201561,
-0.5801810026168823,
0.03903716430068016,
0.11670427024364471,
-0.48654457926750183,
-0.47234776616096497,
-0.1879849135875702,
-1.273397445678711,
-0.5964322686195374,
-0.5406205654144287,
0.12619750201702118,
-0.4972819685935974,
-0.4158645570278168,
-0.07630467414855957,
-0.3920134902000427,
0.27932026982307434,
0.35866788029670715,
-1.0519473552703857,
0.33198121190071106,
1.000256896018982,
0.7854021191596985,
-0.23906059563159943,
0.05241326987743378,
-0.41296079754829407,
-0.1018841490149498,
-0.02556764893233776,
0.6724885106086731,
-0.6193817853927612,
-0.20067128539085388,
0.19828645884990692,
-0.4495273232460022,
-0.14815039932727814,
-0.8454497456550598,
0.6088284254074097,
-0.7799378633499146,
0.5621373057365417,
-0.11749765276908875,
-0.5888915657997131,
-0.16121099889278412,
0.2958502471446991,
-0.5915447473526001,
0.8401950597763062,
-0.0584881529211998,
-1.0687124729156494,
0.53831547498703,
-0.6905806064605713,
-0.2811100482940674,
0.30415764451026917,
0.11249099671840668,
-0.5090538263320923,
-0.18769678473472595,
0.5257400870323181,
0.31594812870025635,
-0.05099184066057205,
0.4082660973072052,
-0.1555412858724594,
-0.01797937974333763,
0.10519200563430786,
-0.4311228096485138,
1.1203370094299316,
0.16567766666412354,
-0.28241080045700073,
0.013972700573503971,
-0.3999679982662201,
-0.27859580516815186,
-0.4054824113845825,
-0.08599083125591278,
-0.5751568078994751,
-0.01961941458284855,
0.08323603868484497,
0.06712571531534195,
0.1296640932559967,
-0.5706038475036621,
-0.0783449113368988,
-0.5634032487869263,
0.12466911226511002,
0.8386921882629395,
-0.0504121296107769,
0.8018608689308167,
-0.599652886390686,
0.4462195038795471,
0.19019480049610138,
0.360067218542099,
0.14947710931301117,
-0.7913310527801514,
-0.5972976088523865,
-0.25181838870048523,
0.23917777836322784,
0.7749474048614502,
-1.028515338897705,
0.7339922785758972,
-0.3516068160533905,
-0.49776071310043335,
-0.11537777632474899,
0.4468928575515747,
0.32599788904190063,
0.7303140759468079,
0.609972357749939,
-0.2401072382926941,
-0.5543375015258789,
-0.7293941378593445,
-0.42388129234313965,
-0.37946847081184387,
-0.04363444820046425,
0.1879187375307083,
0.23748746514320374,
-0.17879453301429749,
1.0534306764602661,
-0.5944161415100098,
-0.5846681594848633,
-0.135734423995018,
0.40046682953834534,
0.3855452537536621,
0.7315571904182434,
0.45155036449432373,
-1.0716458559036255,
-0.30113813281059265,
0.05068435147404671,
-0.2171231210231781,
-0.4793238639831543,
0.05564843863248825,
0.07215586304664612,
-0.05225478857755661,
0.5091936588287354,
-0.34574151039123535,
0.3433929681777954,
0.39490312337875366,
-0.3767582178115845,
0.6008408665657043,
0.1067262813448906,
0.05353628471493721,
-0.6549068689346313,
-0.21392092108726501,
0.5718449950218201,
-0.02810724638402462,
-0.9200356602668762,
0.06243874132633209,
0.07050562649965286,
-0.011838281527161598,
-0.6226212978363037,
0.5307175517082214,
-0.37706631422042847,
0.4440358579158783,
-0.023036353290081024,
0.17771533131599426,
-0.2380618304014206,
0.4413619935512543,
-0.034760732203722,
0.8221448063850403,
0.33440646529197693,
-0.61424320936203,
0.08285795897245407,
0.3104870617389679,
-0.1317959725856781,
0.7700528502464294,
-0.2866021990776062,
-0.09090030938386917,
-0.7631900906562805,
0.16892476379871368,
-0.9426982402801514,
0.16602778434753418,
0.43430209159851074,
-0.5258470773696899,
0.14912119507789612,
-0.38502979278564453,
-0.2029123604297638,
-0.19395314157009125,
-0.5846171379089355,
0.5154640078544617,
0.5855435729026794,
-0.5941970944404602,
0.6799493432044983,
0.3706328868865967,
-0.38130536675453186,
-0.7763406038284302,
-0.5252318382263184,
-0.03298186510801315,
-0.5810554623603821,
-0.5369811654090881,
0.3438989818096161,
0.13441666960716248,
-0.38141316175460815,
-0.12049043923616409,
0.1421750783920288,
-0.06504523009061813,
-0.20916244387626648,
-0.12085656821727753,
0.49666303396224976,
-0.02037314511835575,
0.44607245922088623,
0.21253342926502228,
-0.18461427092552185,
-0.14969708025455475,
-0.08854382485151291,
0.7403672933578491,
0.11071779578924179,
0.007660330273211002,
-0.4066927433013916,
0.04387585446238518,
0.456417977809906,
-0.2076200246810913,
0.7426761388778687,
0.6167296171188354,
-0.16608330607414246,
-0.17793259024620056,
-1.089619755744934,
-0.2585815489292145,
-0.46560579538345337,
0.2735557556152344,
0.11749446392059326,
-0.8924298882484436,
0.4794143736362457,
0.006381714716553688,
0.1486029475927353,
0.5774782299995422,
0.30648353695869446,
0.06830957531929016,
0.9064105153083801,
0.18971949815750122,
-0.07506194710731506,
0.758222222328186,
-0.12736451625823975,
0.031340911984443665,
-1.1965049505233765,
-0.053796544671058655,
-0.5794425010681152,
0.004606017377227545,
-0.9117572903633118,
-0.8649094104766846,
0.4409944415092468,
-0.19697314500808716,
-0.12297482043504715,
0.3613382875919342,
-0.5387537479400635,
0.3224373757839203,
0.4431241750717163,
0.45676228404045105,
0.24143333733081818,
0.22146058082580566,
0.3017195761203766,
-0.30067965388298035,
-0.6812103390693665,
-0.4115360379219055,
1.2302652597427368,
0.4785268306732178,
0.5529215931892395,
0.3228107690811157,
0.6245206594467163,
0.7286154627799988,
0.6900614500045776,
-0.6608932018280029,
0.585278332233429,
-0.7165802717208862,
-0.7482098340988159,
-0.388526052236557,
-0.8623995184898376,
-0.8119633793830872,
0.6993616223335266,
-0.5007473230361938,
-0.5238704681396484,
0.4152677655220032,
0.28281116485595703,
-0.12435851991176605,
0.28981128334999084,
-0.6042535901069641,
0.4410359859466553,
-0.038605187088251114,
-0.4271492660045624,
-0.4840991199016571,
-0.2920787036418915,
0.49701714515686035,
0.02380979247391224,
0.35682231187820435,
-0.29307931661605835,
-0.1465403288602829,
0.9500208497047424,
-0.36215800046920776,
1.2399425506591797,
-0.4732684791088104,
0.14114785194396973,
0.025334516540169716,
-0.38492247462272644,
0.4201107323169708,
-0.014687007293105125,
-0.18359699845314026,
0.47736620903015137,
-0.013682898133993149,
-0.5353255271911621,
-0.6345667839050293,
0.5115166902542114,
-0.7882312536239624,
-0.833480179309845,
-0.40284883975982666,
-0.5478213429450989,
-0.40135249495506287,
0.10423999279737473,
0.14950209856033325,
0.4042505919933319,
-0.1016346737742424,
0.12356922775506973,
0.7275938391685486,
-0.35702237486839294,
0.1396465003490448,
0.12247933447360992,
-0.06306388229131699,
-0.8505104184150696,
0.6880338788032532,
0.31360599398612976,
0.4733912944793701,
0.25574952363967896,
0.6941981911659241,
-0.4598921239376068,
-0.3904299736022949,
-0.41488543152809143,
0.19757845997810364,
-0.6684530377388,
-0.44076114892959595,
-0.7954497337341309,
-0.03893589973449707,
-0.8494812846183777,
-0.015409482643008232,
0.17306897044181824,
-0.5408902764320374,
-0.3856724500656128,
0.1398543417453766,
0.2947070300579071,
0.2243328094482422,
-0.08884106576442719,
0.561065137386322,
-0.6039881110191345,
0.43765532970428467,
0.5256102085113525,
0.13102596998214722,
0.06858779489994049,
-0.6561394333839417,
0.3386671245098114,
0.066339410841465,
-0.12374737858772278,
-0.9343636631965637,
0.41425997018814087,
0.17697076499462128,
0.7864904999732971,
0.574325680732727,
0.2571904957294464,
0.4940997064113617,
-0.06502506136894226,
0.6124975681304932,
0.5251016020774841,
-0.9431205987930298,
0.4018770456314087,
-0.4046914279460907,
0.26078739762306213,
0.6228284239768982,
0.2371254414319992,
-0.579910397529602,
-0.24604205787181854,
-0.5188959240913391,
-0.875023365020752,
0.5412818193435669,
0.2699666917324066,
0.4531551003456116,
0.05913737416267395,
0.1266600787639618,
0.21567417681217194,
0.20555606484413147,
-0.70972740650177,
-0.07392452657222748,
-0.1508110612630844,
-0.14287982881069183,
0.10230167955160141,
-0.34953242540359497,
-0.08373314142227173,
-0.29149293899536133,
0.8732109665870667,
-0.10221097618341446,
-0.3951129615306854,
0.03135828301310539,
-0.10570932179689407,
0.08371497690677643,
0.5543181896209717,
0.499882310628891,
0.5863772034645081,
-0.1774783879518509,
0.264981210231781,
0.5535810589790344,
-0.6671696305274963,
-0.03969765454530716,
0.09072364121675491,
-0.7117684483528137,
-0.016682898625731468,
0.3963686227798462,
0.5820765495300293,
-0.013952858746051788,
-0.354293555021286,
0.6642192602157593,
0.20978395640850067,
-0.03027767688035965,
-0.130393847823143,
-0.058251310139894485,
-0.28876879811286926,
-0.12186646461486816,
0.36153218150138855,
0.32095256447792053,
0.19806768000125885,
-0.3565366566181183,
0.23089489340782166,
0.5591970086097717,
-0.3034238815307617,
0.04686172679066658,
0.22510528564453125,
0.3342236876487732,
-0.07461941242218018,
0.5332719087600708,
-0.24431593716144562,
-0.7426038980484009,
0.6462778449058533,
0.5406245589256287,
0.8758213520050049,
-0.43073973059654236,
0.5348698496818542,
0.6511113047599792,
0.411825954914093,
-0.04392091557383537,
-0.08989346027374268,
-0.25534167885780334,
-1.086796760559082,
-0.5821434259414673,
-0.5228285789489746,
-0.3990597128868103,
-0.22088851034641266,
-0.7232000231742859,
0.3336251378059387,
-0.5284123420715332,
-0.4415384531021118,
-0.004588350187987089,
-0.09679242223501205,
-0.6522936224937439,
0.10227558016777039,
0.09160121530294418,
0.871554434299469,
-1.20170259475708,
0.17111855745315552,
0.7628050446510315,
-0.22342504560947418,
-0.14073331654071808,
0.11102690547704697,
0.12194428592920303,
-0.7450787425041199,
0.7906778454780579,
0.16054721176624298,
-0.004942172206938267,
-0.16985853016376495,
-0.45660173892974854,
-0.821343719959259,
0.6450431942939758,
-0.2632032632827759,
-0.5184100866317749,
0.2901884615421295,
0.27099892497062683,
0.5336036086082458,
-0.043398063629865646,
0.2027801275253296,
0.4218968451023102,
0.7441381812095642,
0.12166134268045425,
-0.8210961818695068,
0.03086702525615692,
-0.1595572680234909,
0.31774622201919556,
0.0721002146601677,
-0.40438616275787354,
0.5802575349807739,
0.019722117111086845,
-0.4088286757469177,
-0.23097366094589233,
0.6509338021278381,
0.4011629819869995,
0.5574229955673218,
1.0736228227615356,
0.581820547580719,
0.5805204510688782,
-0.032501015812158585,
0.46888601779937744,
-0.005453083198517561,
0.38558390736579895,
0.7539860010147095,
-0.1944989711046219,
0.6045047044754028,
0.648434042930603,
-0.30055373907089233,
0.34467461705207825,
0.18216274678707123,
0.03587378188967705,
0.41881901025772095,
0.4004519283771515,
-0.4185847043991089,
-0.09954797476530075,
-0.41622868180274963,
-0.22772979736328125,
0.34776753187179565,
0.4307927191257477,
-0.10959495604038239,
-0.2733496129512787,
0.3122829794883728,
0.3624291718006134,
0.42300236225128174,
-0.5620455741882324,
0.9411677718162537,
-0.18278425931930542,
-0.7011657953262329,
0.3883192837238312,
-0.08155104517936707,
1.3013972043991089,
-0.2728945314884186,
-0.09184557944536209,
-0.19072850048542023,
-0.05199003964662552,
-0.4696710705757141,
-0.6819742321968079,
0.30209365487098694,
-0.09713488817214966,
-0.03920848295092583,
-0.3240194320678711,
0.7804276347160339,
-0.4984784424304962,
-0.6256468296051025,
0.10748666524887085,
0.3248578906059265,
-0.21752344071865082,
0.006648222450166941,
-0.536588191986084,
-0.23959143459796906,
-0.02472236193716526,
0.13710319995880127,
0.10407322645187378,
0.09066461771726608,
-0.2560105323791504,
0.5254373550415039,
1.0187575817108154,
0.5216749906539917,
0.09099725633859634,
0.15774129331111908,
1.0064197778701782,
-0.4888456463813782,
-0.6968449950218201,
-0.6920557618141174,
0.3264961838722229,
-0.5588411688804626,
-0.43422481417655945,
0.7609536647796631,
0.40250134468078613,
0.857589066028595,
-0.1387573480606079,
0.6859708428382874,
-0.09211316704750061,
0.5325480103492737,
-0.5640549063682556,
0.6043675541877747,
-0.14907203614711761,
0.4348929226398468,
-0.299513041973114,
-1.0254631042480469,
-0.6192463636398315,
0.42491286993026733,
-0.865234375,
0.09365981072187424,
0.23286838829517365,
1.0866585969924927,
0.02050672098994255,
0.08928948640823364,
0.39453577995300293,
-0.009242590516805649,
0.22860515117645264,
-0.006739386823028326,
0.9822437763214111,
-0.02984720654785633,
0.25657573342323303,
-0.6023321151733398,
-0.7209050059318542,
-0.07767970114946365,
-0.7711325287818909,
-0.8921249508857727,
-0.43767595291137695,
-0.5242663025856018,
-0.2935808598995209,
0.20880268514156342,
0.8273940682411194,
0.6807265281677246,
-0.9423080086708069,
-0.1260986626148224,
0.10831573605537415,
0.13921980559825897,
-0.3004917502403259,
-0.3908660411834717,
0.21561984717845917,
-0.5271090269088745,
-0.6624440550804138,
-0.05995795875787735,
0.1587369740009308,
-0.41134682297706604,
-0.3276686668395996,
0.13076895475387573,
-0.135170117020607,
0.00305578438565135,
0.6276743412017822,
0.18518191576004028,
-0.7009231448173523,
-0.26902440190315247,
-0.18343494832515717,
0.17252951860427856,
0.03415254130959511,
0.9357381463050842,
-0.6462807655334473,
0.5426774024963379,
0.8446922898292542,
0.288566917181015,
0.08891401439905167,
0.6032821536064148,
0.315797358751297,
-0.6031901240348816,
0.11944996565580368,
0.6327460408210754,
0.15249888598918915,
0.6022591590881348,
-0.633755624294281,
0.4182184338569641,
0.25655508041381836,
-0.4096798300743103,
-0.4924125075340271,
0.25595298409461975,
-0.9777332544326782,
-0.14576852321624756,
1.349358320236206,
0.2126309722661972,
-0.0748208686709404,
-0.5391600131988525,
-0.3503327965736389,
0.20595595240592957,
-0.4896584153175354,
0.9556021690368652,
0.36316898465156555,
0.056464195251464844,
-0.3396294414997101,
-0.36111894249916077,
0.4002881348133087,
0.5569993853569031,
-0.7709781527519226,
0.22230906784534454,
0.514568030834198,
0.23288027942180634,
0.4444902241230011,
0.4608146846294403,
-0.40826985239982605,
0.20559892058372498,
-0.26007279753685,
0.1185346394777298,
0.07101267576217651,
0.386811226606369,
-0.32269570231437683,
0.1139218732714653,
-0.26125723123550415,
-0.0009695541812106967
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07222v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07222v1
|
Improving Autoformalization using Type Checking
| 2024-06-11T13:01:50 | 2024-06-11T13:01:50 |
Auguste Poiroux, Gail Weiss, Viktor Kunčak, Antoine Bosselut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large language models show promise for autoformalization, the task of
automatically translating natural language into formal languages. However,
current autoformalization methods remain limited. The last reported
state-of-the-art performance on the ProofNet formalization benchmark for the
Lean proof assistant, achieved using Codex for Lean 3, only showed successful
formalization of 16.1% of informal statements. Similarly, our evaluation of
GPT-4o for Lean 4 only produces successful translations 34.9% of the time. Our
analysis shows that the performance of these models is largely limited by their
inability to generate formal statements that successfully type-check (i.e., are
syntactically correct and consistent with types) - with a whopping 86.6% of
GPT-4o errors starting from a type-check failure. In this work, we propose a
method to fix this issue through decoding with type-check filtering, where we
initially sample a diverse set of candidate formalizations for an informal
statement, then use the Lean proof assistant to filter out candidates that do
not type-check. Using GPT-4o as a base model, and combining our method with
self-consistency, we obtain a +18.3% absolute increase in formalization
accuracy, and achieve a new state-of-the-art of 53.2% on ProofNet with Lean 4.
|
[
0.04746994376182556,
-0.2085736095905304,
0.5917738676071167,
0.3080131709575653,
-0.2660287916660309,
0.11979066580533981,
-0.10912363976240158,
-0.6427248120307922,
-0.04130158945918083,
0.3402438759803772,
-0.09506768733263016,
-0.5929152369499207,
-0.7085137367248535,
0.5155043005943298,
-0.5099663138389587,
0.8692460060119629,
-0.6544268727302551,
0.007869889959692955,
-0.022169267758727074,
0.13431744277477264,
-0.08757931739091873,
-0.2826027572154999,
-0.5768086314201355,
-0.25789281725883484,
-0.12516126036643982,
0.2770313620567322,
0.6727648973464966,
0.9473544359207153,
0.4239746928215027,
0.4368417263031006,
0.29696136713027954,
0.24090476334095,
-0.30636370182037354,
0.15408620238304138,
0.28014281392097473,
-0.5970305800437927,
-0.6574888825416565,
0.144896999001503,
0.6503505706787109,
0.12512421607971191,
-0.21533124148845673,
-0.033725887537002563,
-0.24182724952697754,
0.6679112315177917,
-0.6829087138175964,
0.5447466373443604,
-0.6694194674491882,
0.11722920089960098,
-0.19221246242523193,
0.017610013484954834,
-0.15175773203372955,
-0.6952053904533386,
-0.30432817339897156,
-0.5993214249610901,
0.32910218834877014,
0.0031918580643832684,
1.1108540296554565,
0.5427324771881104,
-0.263810932636261,
-0.302804559469223,
-0.7808394432067871,
0.30378901958465576,
-1.1579126119613647,
0.5545982718467712,
0.9601593017578125,
0.2477482259273529,
-0.05310509726405144,
-0.6160767078399658,
-0.6582666635513306,
-0.36929136514663696,
0.033804964274168015,
0.11042085289955139,
-0.1978527158498764,
0.2730483114719391,
0.2923148572444916,
0.6735059022903442,
-0.718235194683075,
0.15175999701023102,
-0.2084556221961975,
-0.5707380771636963,
0.5538225769996643,
-0.12939871847629547,
0.4156986474990845,
-0.003123087342828512,
0.04714694619178772,
-0.14122404158115387,
-0.4088515043258667,
0.07384897023439407,
0.44220539927482605,
-0.20876145362854004,
0.14294007420539856,
0.4583751857280731,
-0.6600648164749146,
0.8624244332313538,
0.4517345130443573,
-0.2722976505756378,
0.1489046961069107,
-0.7263339161872864,
-0.5665537714958191,
-0.12192006409168243,
0.7116109728813171,
0.08410456776618958,
0.15128342807292938,
-0.20717628300189972,
-0.639957845211029,
0.14980483055114746,
0.07287949323654175,
-0.8439130187034607,
-0.4463667571544647,
0.19775675237178802,
-0.3847118616104126,
-0.3414938151836395,
0.04899080470204353,
-0.2146715372800827,
-0.06734064221382141,
-0.42955607175827026,
0.44352611899375916,
-0.5571348667144775,
-0.064299076795578,
0.39690786600112915,
0.07489341497421265,
0.3303573727607727,
0.3537149727344513,
-0.963751494884491,
0.3240765631198883,
0.40462028980255127,
0.6962035894393921,
0.1257411688566208,
-0.18948370218276978,
-0.5570454001426697,
0.19485606253147125,
-0.6386276483535767,
0.7895067930221558,
-0.1321377158164978,
0.07799772918224335,
0.027143778279423714,
-0.19672292470932007,
-0.10279480367898941,
-0.5867619514465332,
0.5578123927116394,
-0.43819788098335266,
0.13769222795963287,
-0.02655656449496746,
-0.6582871675491333,
0.06607167422771454,
0.3296060860157013,
-0.6421515345573425,
1.091338872909546,
0.15131455659866333,
-0.28665390610694885,
0.7023537755012512,
-0.5264678597450256,
-0.6459662914276123,
0.06901449710130692,
-0.27956509590148926,
-0.5191741585731506,
0.06727591902017593,
0.3511388301849365,
0.2855032682418823,
-0.22672002017498016,
0.35789602994918823,
-0.2435111403465271,
-0.1741410344839096,
-0.08699680119752884,
-0.09021445363759995,
0.42548656463623047,
0.2991097569465637,
-0.988010585308075,
0.15092113614082336,
-0.9836887717247009,
0.31787267327308655,
-0.19683736562728882,
-0.38718727231025696,
-0.15130212903022766,
-0.1656460165977478,
-0.3698011040687561,
0.5013524889945984,
0.4057643711566925,
-0.4974302053451538,
0.11011307686567307,
-0.5116643905639648,
0.5098506808280945,
0.5561602115631104,
-0.3100419342517853,
0.3395383059978485,
-0.19863881170749664,
0.4754905700683594,
0.10731581598520279,
0.25078868865966797,
0.05701765418052673,
-0.3131287395954132,
-1.260391116142273,
-0.2558916509151459,
0.30122262239456177,
0.3197684586048126,
-0.8876398205757141,
0.582811176776886,
0.036265529692173004,
-0.4023314118385315,
-0.504425585269928,
0.3942487835884094,
0.40235641598701477,
0.43633338809013367,
0.5799049735069275,
-0.23215068876743317,
-0.6941416263580322,
-1.0071265697479248,
-0.3755306303501129,
-0.44108083844184875,
0.04548801854252815,
-0.35200566053390503,
0.3646128475666046,
-0.42558491230010986,
1.099858045578003,
-0.2979141175746918,
-0.2677695155143738,
-0.003212645649909973,
0.5080194473266602,
0.11737377941608429,
0.6795651912689209,
0.3432960510253906,
-0.5132488012313843,
-0.49538666009902954,
-0.06546367704868317,
-0.5245529413223267,
-0.22588638961315155,
-0.01176222413778305,
-0.005474879406392574,
0.3628583550453186,
0.590603232383728,
-0.3522331416606903,
0.5833225250244141,
0.6485974788665771,
-0.32767367362976074,
0.5928730964660645,
-0.40383094549179077,
0.2510228753089905,
-0.7547279000282288,
0.12084124982357025,
-0.058598969131708145,
-0.5974971652030945,
-0.4276399314403534,
-0.16577348113059998,
0.28516748547554016,
-0.1521473079919815,
0.1348809450864792,
0.1800977736711502,
-0.7079061269760132,
-0.007703746668994427,
-0.3175498843193054,
-0.3622395098209381,
0.29106277227401733,
0.0966753140091896,
-0.0022408145014196634,
0.6923695206642151,
0.48383665084838867,
-0.5422049760818481,
0.1983429193496704,
0.03828058019280434,
-0.12900860607624054,
0.43443500995635986,
-0.7431355714797974,
0.17338933050632477,
-0.05955442041158676,
0.6221811771392822,
-0.982944130897522,
-0.3865436911582947,
0.1526542603969574,
-0.16169165074825287,
0.5217579007148743,
-0.452818363904953,
-0.497344970703125,
-0.2900795042514801,
-0.061870403587818146,
0.302998811006546,
0.3338429033756256,
-0.3817601799964905,
0.6909587979316711,
0.1281302124261856,
0.13567805290222168,
-0.36757081747055054,
-0.6197037100791931,
0.29578882455825806,
0.20777638256549835,
-0.8920421004295349,
0.2919192612171173,
-0.2139323502779007,
-0.02965298481285572,
-0.2854652404785156,
-0.5318256616592407,
-0.512559711933136,
0.0691470056772232,
-0.09160522371530533,
0.27365079522132874,
-0.14710156619548798,
-0.12630386650562286,
-0.1786983609199524,
-0.07006755471229553,
0.05078548192977905,
-0.8132736682891846,
0.15775708854198456,
-0.4035875201225281,
-0.31366029381752014,
-0.6880245804786682,
0.1378975659608841,
0.7766917943954468,
-0.4486303925514221,
0.4685104191303253,
0.8114795088768005,
-0.3694329261779785,
-0.2426362782716751,
-0.8752042055130005,
-0.22819481790065765,
-0.5082674026489258,
0.07144176959991455,
-0.5073421001434326,
-0.7996132969856262,
0.4238452613353729,
0.19857050478458405,
0.0021922604646533728,
0.5402418971061707,
0.3108058273792267,
0.06943093240261078,
0.9657196402549744,
0.5088955760002136,
-0.06281328946352005,
0.34080663323402405,
-0.16008304059505463,
0.36202043294906616,
-0.30951666831970215,
-0.1651403307914734,
-0.6740531325340271,
0.02464519813656807,
-0.563404381275177,
-0.46939578652381897,
0.27932319045066833,
-0.050060298293828964,
0.02946861833333969,
0.554690957069397,
-0.3038274645805359,
0.1659809947013855,
0.36514991521835327,
-0.09068634361028671,
0.5501300096511841,
-0.1996118426322937,
-0.23816074430942535,
-0.0475146658718586,
-0.6377907991409302,
-0.2571706473827362,
0.8512716889381409,
0.4519520699977875,
0.8305249810218811,
0.015118847601115704,
0.9031710624694824,
0.25741076469421387,
0.3952052891254425,
-0.712922215461731,
0.3020670413970947,
-0.17701967060565948,
-0.4827231764793396,
-0.4019211530685425,
-0.7677063941955566,
-0.48751595616340637,
0.05278526991605759,
-0.1696367859840393,
-0.10044821351766586,
0.42491012811660767,
0.6305098533630371,
-0.1485508531332016,
0.08867378532886505,
-0.5957849025726318,
0.9090977311134338,
-0.22284045815467834,
-0.045499373227357864,
0.11697608232498169,
-0.36871659755706787,
0.5012590885162354,
-0.10180814564228058,
0.2840151786804199,
-0.07661624997854233,
0.21059884130954742,
0.5320753455162048,
-0.7303746342658997,
0.8407505750656128,
0.009233365766704082,
-0.5934170484542847,
0.09663139283657074,
0.2363540232181549,
1.0171926021575928,
-0.11592193692922592,
0.08931916952133179,
0.03314538672566414,
-0.057740695774555206,
-0.3216666877269745,
-0.7776207327842712,
0.38515669107437134,
-0.8071398735046387,
-0.23404526710510254,
-0.4694225490093231,
-0.1110382080078125,
-0.2776261866092682,
0.416510671377182,
0.5910393595695496,
0.43190309405326843,
-0.031127963215112686,
-0.08213382214307785,
0.7814869284629822,
0.4038437306880951,
0.40876221656799316,
0.7830567955970764,
0.12513458728790283,
-0.5163849592208862,
0.8041112422943115,
0.03748273849487305,
0.332600474357605,
0.3919234573841095,
0.20699502527713776,
-0.5131974816322327,
-0.8425807952880859,
-0.465786874294281,
0.2509132921695709,
-0.7489776015281677,
-0.3207472264766693,
-0.5580717325210571,
0.029403937980532646,
-1.0063079595565796,
0.14758072793483734,
-0.805546224117279,
-0.5096185207366943,
-0.09729631245136261,
0.1715768724679947,
-0.05793794244527817,
0.7342586517333984,
-0.15925996005535126,
-0.04614204168319702,
-0.5256891250610352,
0.4718360900878906,
0.5399332046508789,
0.7535412907600403,
-0.46689721941947937,
-0.627773642539978,
-0.312290757894516,
-0.26589107513427734,
0.0054301125928759575,
-0.7040092945098877,
0.22253313660621643,
0.3191147446632385,
0.37418222427368164,
0.41207176446914673,
0.015218804590404034,
0.7047228217124939,
-0.499882310628891,
0.3719051778316498,
0.14433039724826813,
-1.2928457260131836,
0.5164618492126465,
-0.2023753821849823,
0.3831154704093933,
0.8423940539360046,
0.18105056881904602,
-0.5851514339447021,
-0.6097418665885925,
-0.5559966564178467,
-0.8089279532432556,
0.3860633671283722,
0.4476570188999176,
-0.5835395455360413,
0.05116785317659378,
0.4215641915798187,
-0.12225402891635895,
0.20769470930099487,
-0.8601207137107849,
-0.10370458662509918,
-0.7505714297294617,
-0.2787020802497864,
0.030262378975749016,
-0.20495840907096863,
-0.032981131225824356,
0.03220250457525253,
0.9201397895812988,
-0.35961756110191345,
-0.019462458789348602,
0.48771485686302185,
-0.3145540952682495,
-0.16872163116931915,
0.29899778962135315,
0.7681000828742981,
0.6283707022666931,
-0.1259961724281311,
0.3446979820728302,
-0.2667582929134369,
-0.620602011680603,
0.34967368841171265,
0.3332762122154236,
-0.40413832664489746,
0.08861976116895676,
0.18069978058338165,
0.7240039110183716,
0.23061634600162506,
-0.11439955979585648,
0.3523428738117218,
-0.20438873767852783,
-0.2006668895483017,
-0.41933557391166687,
0.1926059126853943,
-0.39559680223464966,
-0.33341920375823975,
0.21228836476802826,
0.19319599866867065,
0.4772534966468811,
-0.35207995772361755,
0.1973358541727066,
0.17910417914390564,
-0.1871597021818161,
-0.23894549906253815,
0.5474236607551575,
0.2984490692615509,
0.037461698055267334,
0.2936677634716034,
-0.5346453189849854,
-0.5991876721382141,
0.4807789921760559,
0.6560121178627014,
1.1187224388122559,
-0.301543265581131,
0.25745251774787903,
0.5554810762405396,
0.6791017651557922,
-0.6282116174697876,
0.24230772256851196,
-0.15255999565124512,
-0.6037781834602356,
-0.8128902912139893,
-0.6737609505653381,
-0.3854641914367676,
0.29341769218444824,
-0.464912086725235,
0.1957637220621109,
-0.5078079104423523,
-0.07258763909339905,
-0.3181372880935669,
-0.19359953701496124,
-0.6520749926567078,
0.45842522382736206,
0.11486923694610596,
0.7110952138900757,
-0.8415815234184265,
0.6773993968963623,
0.7434269189834595,
-0.36316144466400146,
-1.1822848320007324,
0.042503874748945236,
-0.15003910660743713,
-0.5986707210540771,
0.6110487580299377,
0.01586512103676796,
-0.4030575752258301,
0.09180505573749542,
-0.480983167886734,
-1.2998871803283691,
0.9010900259017944,
0.2588541507720947,
-0.6310103535652161,
-0.06905888766050339,
0.08568928390741348,
0.45581692457199097,
-0.26201754808425903,
0.37118956446647644,
0.6454086303710938,
0.8367915153503418,
-0.007521333638578653,
-1.2346011400222778,
0.277824729681015,
-0.275636225938797,
0.15970124304294586,
0.08090399950742722,
-0.3905428946018219,
0.4872966408729553,
0.12255001068115234,
-0.17968934774398804,
-0.14846691489219666,
0.7746133804321289,
0.08853320777416229,
0.012264509685337543,
0.578576922416687,
0.6215010285377502,
0.7745272517204285,
0.04499277472496033,
0.9537560343742371,
-0.3724592924118042,
0.32428938150405884,
1.1924808025360107,
-0.21809321641921997,
0.41860681772232056,
0.09085363894701004,
-0.03571309894323349,
0.6557783484458923,
0.4061030149459839,
-0.03294643759727478,
-0.008722984232008457,
0.13479197025299072,
-0.11871162801980972,
-0.4638766050338745,
0.38532188534736633,
-0.32032400369644165,
0.8258629441261292,
0.03196333348751068,
-0.2630518674850464,
-0.19557558000087738,
-0.3993006944656372,
0.1375735104084015,
0.015682462602853775,
-0.06570280343294144,
0.5993273854255676,
-0.29986926913261414,
-0.9665607810020447,
0.9348710775375366,
0.2355893850326538,
0.5798986554145813,
-0.7178211212158203,
-0.03398653864860535,
-0.2962324023246765,
0.03502752259373665,
-0.3507346510887146,
-0.10497654229402542,
0.18068234622478485,
-0.1518801599740982,
-0.34505048394203186,
-0.2854812443256378,
0.7663418054580688,
-0.728510320186615,
-0.3283344805240631,
-0.09916041791439056,
0.3400692641735077,
0.12182562053203583,
-0.07424624264240265,
-0.5135343670845032,
0.13791000843048096,
-0.039486877620220184,
0.1899966597557068,
0.05122532323002815,
0.32638224959373474,
0.012382637709379196,
0.640415608882904,
0.7582096457481384,
0.15576715767383575,
0.13716717064380646,
0.2091602087020874,
0.675754189491272,
-0.43628838658332825,
-0.9345297813415527,
-0.6790462732315063,
0.21087566018104553,
-0.14004087448120117,
-0.33869659900665283,
0.7140010595321655,
0.6133010387420654,
0.6099609732627869,
-0.07710711658000946,
0.7773634791374207,
-0.02925342693924904,
0.05441049858927727,
-0.7208855152130127,
0.7736378312110901,
-0.28365081548690796,
0.06784195452928543,
-0.32271909713745117,
-0.7241712808609009,
-0.2697412371635437,
0.6786801815032959,
-0.2971029579639435,
0.12007995694875717,
0.823034405708313,
0.4975992441177368,
-0.04050568863749504,
-0.09698422253131866,
0.3972781002521515,
0.4042346775531769,
0.5350834727287292,
0.29679039120674133,
0.4733830392360687,
-0.5396652817726135,
0.777942419052124,
-0.17716355621814728,
-0.5038036108016968,
-0.19199687242507935,
-1.2134721279144287,
-0.6874194741249084,
-0.4262416660785675,
-0.5410192608833313,
-0.7026301622390747,
-0.04453837499022484,
0.6030296087265015,
1.0497511625289917,
-0.8376907110214233,
-0.24907296895980835,
-0.3692692220211029,
-0.05785610154271126,
-0.15154409408569336,
-0.192347452044487,
0.1969168484210968,
-0.8343676328659058,
-0.48972028493881226,
0.7418006658554077,
0.3932727873325348,
0.23571738600730896,
-0.3996463418006897,
0.0533791109919548,
0.0742134228348732,
-0.0732756108045578,
0.39342570304870605,
0.5478664636611938,
-0.5787836313247681,
-0.14277374744415283,
-0.0015281200176104903,
-0.296525776386261,
0.2022436261177063,
1.0341918468475342,
-0.5590357780456543,
0.5672094225883484,
0.3857213854789734,
0.5996939539909363,
0.6396849751472473,
-0.03275530785322189,
0.9151015877723694,
-0.4376033544540405,
-0.31196317076683044,
0.34128525853157043,
0.48986512422561646,
0.5028374791145325,
-0.5273987650871277,
0.3783763647079468,
0.38132160902023315,
-0.7054808139801025,
-0.3143623471260071,
0.4590041935443878,
-0.6131773591041565,
0.18671880662441254,
1.0829873085021973,
-0.20333760976791382,
-0.11535011231899261,
-0.4913415312767029,
0.1190497875213623,
0.3396672308444977,
-0.4194805920124054,
0.9697823524475098,
0.6913907527923584,
-0.19761814177036285,
0.13657385110855103,
-0.3431176543235779,
1.1049327850341797,
0.5696231722831726,
-0.9547155499458313,
-0.125820130109787,
0.6483640074729919,
0.7494485974311829,
0.15239396691322327,
0.8868907690048218,
-0.2206498235464096,
0.4966159462928772,
-0.31029772758483887,
0.2821408808231354,
-0.15227195620536804,
-0.0781935602426529,
-0.40866678953170776,
-0.13546720147132874,
0.13553276658058167,
0.11363101005554199
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07217v1
|
A Synthetic Dataset for Personal Attribute Inference
| 2024-06-11T12:50:53 | 2024-06-11T12:50:53 |
Hanna Yukhymenko, Robin Staab, Mark Vero, Martin Vechev
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, powerful Large Language Models (LLMs) have become easily accessible
to hundreds of millions of users worldwide. However, their strong capabilities
and vast world knowledge do not come without associated privacy risks. In this
work, we focus on the emerging privacy threat LLMs pose - the ability to
accurately infer personal information from online texts. Despite the growing
importance of LLM-based author profiling, research in this area has been
hampered by a lack of suitable public datasets, largely due to ethical and
privacy concerns associated with real personal data. In this work, we take two
steps to address this problem: (i) we construct a simulation framework for the
popular social media platform Reddit using LLM agents seeded with synthetic
personal profiles; (ii) using this framework, we generate SynthPAI, a diverse
synthetic dataset of over 7800 comments manually labeled for personal
attributes. We validate our dataset with a human study showing that humans
barely outperform random guessing on the task of distinguishing our synthetic
comments from real ones. Further, we verify that our dataset enables meaningful
personal attribute inference research by showing across 18 state-of-the-art
LLMs that our synthetic comments allow us to draw the same conclusions as
real-world data. Together, this indicates that our dataset and pipeline provide
a strong and privacy-preserving basis for future research toward understanding
and mitigating the inference-based privacy threats LLMs pose.
|
[
-0.29939350485801697,
-0.7675837874412537,
0.6974748969078064,
0.2931143343448639,
0.27712976932525635,
0.3207913637161255,
-0.2718983292579651,
-0.7759214639663696,
0.052551668137311935,
0.7484895586967468,
-0.894310712814331,
-0.43786442279815674,
-0.3008013069629669,
0.31705814599990845,
-0.5279532670974731,
0.9608483910560608,
0.4245602786540985,
-0.25545811653137207,
-0.5111956000328064,
0.17030119895935059,
0.11079694330692291,
-0.7349019050598145,
-0.3490197956562042,
-0.05880280211567879,
0.940659761428833,
0.12087777256965637,
0.5001558661460876,
0.6661485433578491,
0.22651316225528717,
0.40067750215530396,
-0.02506309747695923,
0.28190290927886963,
-0.5434513688087463,
0.28522342443466187,
-0.1886475682258606,
-0.46185725927352905,
-0.41810789704322815,
0.18317538499832153,
0.5513581037521362,
0.3743904232978821,
0.1577022224664688,
0.44900619983673096,
0.03035418875515461,
0.4036512076854706,
-0.76158207654953,
-0.03540373221039772,
-0.6214268207550049,
-0.11437036842107773,
-0.21320801973342896,
0.030346615239977837,
-0.5476317405700684,
-0.5832131505012512,
0.12250621616840363,
-0.5508883595466614,
0.3297353982925415,
0.2008993923664093,
0.7483798265457153,
-0.019123338162899017,
-0.3401704430580139,
0.11364258080720901,
-0.9171150922775269,
0.8037199974060059,
-0.6240389347076416,
0.1358608901500702,
0.5357000827789307,
0.44545459747314453,
-0.24295173585414886,
-0.7944208383560181,
-0.7857043743133545,
-0.1749701350927353,
-0.27970537543296814,
-0.32100269198417664,
0.011460983194410801,
-0.021980833262205124,
0.3489148020744324,
0.18698717653751373,
-0.42348968982696533,
0.2072136402130127,
-0.2848226726055145,
-0.2531926929950714,
1.0702545642852783,
0.1743331104516983,
0.059214428067207336,
-0.13783223927021027,
-0.22626261413097382,
-0.1538764387369156,
-0.7826212048530579,
-0.0843454897403717,
0.9611333012580872,
0.3218211233615875,
-0.2096865177154541,
0.61846923828125,
-0.2642602324485779,
0.450443834066391,
-0.13227418065071106,
-0.06568360328674316,
0.28234338760375977,
-0.2099180966615677,
-0.03865526616573334,
-0.058398183435201645,
1.0151067972183228,
0.40552493929862976,
0.6360608339309692,
-0.19284731149673462,
0.09327062964439392,
0.018650950863957405,
0.159736767411232,
-0.7092393636703491,
-0.15529483556747437,
0.46143627166748047,
-0.26040324568748474,
-0.5723876357078552,
0.2850496768951416,
-0.956860363483429,
-0.975724458694458,
-0.23458242416381836,
0.2355436384677887,
-0.02210046537220478,
-0.056599345058202744,
-0.2844867706298828,
0.11152056604623795,
-0.015753664076328278,
0.2729819118976593,
-0.7229678630828857,
0.5056893825531006,
0.7905265092849731,
0.6821978688240051,
-0.2716669738292694,
-0.32141661643981934,
-0.20116490125656128,
0.31379857659339905,
0.06050531938672066,
0.7143362164497375,
-0.5888018012046814,
-0.32953664660453796,
0.004077416844666004,
0.12985503673553467,
0.21260054409503937,
-0.499683678150177,
0.34398505091667175,
-0.5282505750656128,
0.34910252690315247,
-0.292953759431839,
-0.49540770053863525,
-0.006148494314402342,
0.28892335295677185,
-0.7985331416130066,
0.7469267249107361,
0.004744330886751413,
-0.7040911912918091,
-0.11960794031620026,
-0.5029929280281067,
-0.4177427589893341,
-0.03658551350235939,
-0.10886800289154053,
-0.5996116399765015,
0.003998287487775087,
0.14416350424289703,
0.6097629070281982,
-0.42634573578834534,
-0.021983133628964424,
-0.7096020579338074,
-0.24629293382167816,
0.8669993281364441,
-0.39444372057914734,
0.8016493916511536,
0.2738593518733978,
-0.09068165719509125,
-0.1721792072057724,
-0.9977251291275024,
0.09569308161735535,
0.12380576878786087,
-0.06866292655467987,
-0.2644517719745636,
-0.038824811577796936,
0.008480247110128403,
0.003264403436332941,
0.31653469800949097,
-1.0251072645187378,
-0.1887885481119156,
-0.4096762239933014,
0.43694549798965454,
1.0404918193817139,
0.2902384400367737,
0.45131394267082214,
-0.42517954111099243,
0.5037028789520264,
-0.13653630018234253,
-0.005983451381325722,
-0.029397932812571526,
-0.4987976551055908,
-0.18444901704788208,
-0.47793319821357727,
0.37666264176368713,
0.6220703125,
-0.17332743108272552,
0.4379373788833618,
-0.2399977147579193,
-0.23296485841274261,
-0.6077362298965454,
0.22713884711265564,
0.5533896684646606,
0.17772440612316132,
-0.14348237216472626,
0.12819138169288635,
-0.6829771399497986,
-1.1712573766708374,
-0.7701258063316345,
-0.1912778913974762,
-0.44848179817199707,
0.5034525394439697,
0.3565504848957062,
-0.32025691866874695,
1.0939009189605713,
-0.7376300096511841,
-0.17427796125411987,
-0.12066369503736496,
0.06503254920244217,
-0.10029115527868271,
0.4680348336696625,
0.3236674666404724,
-0.7823708057403564,
-0.5515644550323486,
-0.15070195496082306,
-0.6430197954177856,
-0.28923019766807556,
-0.30950573086738586,
-0.25917741656303406,
-0.053244754672050476,
0.11404971033334732,
-0.7367750406265259,
0.30587559938430786,
0.5767968893051147,
-0.19485977292060852,
0.266048401594162,
-0.0916554406285286,
-0.020332638174295425,
-1.2063090801239014,
0.04311337321996689,
0.41710376739501953,
-0.49014779925346375,
-0.6813225746154785,
-0.09026973694562912,
-0.174318328499794,
-0.06068117171525955,
-0.5022470355033875,
0.9133653044700623,
-0.25594964623451233,
-0.05095018446445465,
-0.07332693040370941,
-0.1517401784658432,
0.07556238025426865,
0.40643206238746643,
-0.2447473406791687,
0.8237996697425842,
0.16308008134365082,
-0.491877943277359,
0.22933721542358398,
0.23644821345806122,
-0.33945509791374207,
0.4453144967556,
-0.5260715484619141,
0.4509430527687073,
-0.2543852627277374,
0.2484375536441803,
-0.7451822757720947,
-0.7946317791938782,
0.2607434093952179,
-0.6376379132270813,
0.09219399839639664,
0.321205198764801,
-0.8195528388023376,
-0.1325952261686325,
-0.5695223212242126,
0.23216189444065094,
0.5322272777557373,
-0.5340763926506042,
0.9889392256736755,
0.7525685429573059,
-0.21129730343818665,
-0.4131228029727936,
-0.7517380118370056,
0.2545948326587677,
-0.3141114115715027,
-0.6326513886451721,
0.44475188851356506,
-0.02844691276550293,
-0.5364249348640442,
-0.024198608472943306,
0.3970077931880951,
-0.32190459966659546,
0.23827484250068665,
0.5651681423187256,
0.05411968380212784,
0.32117700576782227,
-0.15945374965667725,
-0.1424446702003479,
-0.042337048798799515,
0.36038726568222046,
0.23933659493923187,
0.20932190120220184,
-0.028660519048571587,
-0.16153748333454132,
-0.7538000345230103,
0.19618894159793854,
0.22847320139408112,
0.01141792256385088,
0.9904544949531555,
0.32930251955986023,
-0.4835408926010132,
-0.5989936590194702,
-0.667256236076355,
-0.390423446893692,
-0.5750353336334229,
0.21511423587799072,
-0.0017250522505491972,
-0.8488307595252991,
0.6316369771957397,
0.04734664037823677,
0.27864447236061096,
-0.016954438760876656,
0.7125263810157776,
-0.35590535402297974,
1.1030933856964111,
0.4191843569278717,
0.082906074821949,
0.28980493545532227,
-0.1568179875612259,
0.32282987236976624,
-0.7623593807220459,
-0.39669400453567505,
-0.3474215865135193,
-0.4155498445034027,
-0.9946560859680176,
-0.3736923336982727,
0.23606671392917633,
-0.7640697956085205,
-0.3275343179702759,
0.3207876980304718,
-0.26254868507385254,
0.691153883934021,
0.657689094543457,
0.543895423412323,
0.31639909744262695,
0.09234887361526489,
0.4300605356693268,
-0.11488530784845352,
-0.06453336030244827,
-0.7692362070083618,
1.160814642906189,
0.43659648299217224,
1.0437958240509033,
0.15875229239463806,
0.6382217407226562,
0.7150956988334656,
0.490180104970932,
-0.25186049938201904,
0.7835590839385986,
-0.029065217822790146,
-1.1103788614273071,
-0.12484671175479889,
-0.5595752000808716,
-0.6440632343292236,
0.16475354135036469,
-0.17247827351093292,
-1.0243513584136963,
0.15597711503505707,
0.3627800941467285,
-0.4364181458950043,
0.24623632431030273,
-0.8117268681526184,
0.6682349443435669,
-0.29284363985061646,
-0.9138509035110474,
0.11884687840938568,
-0.9849370121955872,
0.588606595993042,
-0.31991004943847656,
0.29981404542922974,
-0.36253103613853455,
-0.03217139467597008,
0.43234044313430786,
-0.33132052421569824,
1.3283520936965942,
0.05963217467069626,
0.05645826831459999,
0.3273857831954956,
0.17390576004981995,
0.6041162014007568,
0.11453740298748016,
-0.2542966604232788,
0.08035159856081009,
0.05162016302347183,
-0.14699961245059967,
-0.6622416973114014,
0.9344567060470581,
-0.7642505168914795,
-0.7233211994171143,
-0.4550705850124359,
-0.5104929208755493,
-0.4228985011577606,
-0.05693468824028969,
-0.022742463275790215,
-0.12174613028764725,
-0.3625713586807251,
0.3229120373725891,
0.40142491459846497,
-0.34735816717147827,
0.044632717967033386,
0.3754452168941498,
0.09193502366542816,
-0.5344008803367615,
1.051845908164978,
-0.08845948427915573,
0.15356750786304474,
0.2835635244846344,
0.3190384805202484,
-0.5005791783332825,
-0.09370864927768707,
-0.008359569124877453,
0.49268290400505066,
-0.7178430557250977,
-0.07954070717096329,
-0.6339078545570374,
-0.2544883191585541,
-0.3626992702484131,
0.007152028847485781,
-0.2685496509075165,
-0.33259737491607666,
-0.42261239886283875,
-0.22510042786598206,
0.40002110600471497,
0.7218469977378845,
0.08293287456035614,
0.2701188027858734,
-0.6629608273506165,
0.23132692277431488,
0.21081794798374176,
0.25413748621940613,
0.030763177201151848,
-0.3437066078186035,
-0.028879817575216293,
0.186076819896698,
-0.23952235281467438,
-0.6351802349090576,
0.4253036379814148,
0.31953349709510803,
0.4113842844963074,
0.21590286493301392,
0.3381747305393219,
0.5400044918060303,
-0.41554468870162964,
0.672154426574707,
-0.2754189670085907,
-0.5400277972221375,
0.1303810328245163,
-0.3441290557384491,
-0.28747817873954773,
0.6718024611473083,
0.27735915780067444,
-0.2940719723701477,
-0.531679093837738,
-0.6490095257759094,
-0.5428120493888855,
0.456022709608078,
0.5688402056694031,
0.5362377166748047,
0.05091891810297966,
0.5831915140151978,
0.13578127324581146,
0.45185089111328125,
-0.9943007230758667,
-0.2013961374759674,
0.2625865936279297,
-0.47097426652908325,
0.10352446138858795,
-0.24658310413360596,
-0.0647328570485115,
-0.23698313534259796,
0.6474672555923462,
0.004801393952220678,
0.2436080425977707,
-0.02544497884809971,
0.1279674917459488,
0.06868621706962585,
0.032051097601652145,
0.38877564668655396,
0.522553026676178,
-0.1812359243631363,
0.26235777139663696,
0.17538784444332123,
-0.2965364158153534,
0.24909797310829163,
0.06754624843597412,
-0.3289967477321625,
-0.2813456952571869,
0.2339053899049759,
0.468805193901062,
0.061479125171899796,
-0.8781476020812988,
0.5106123089790344,
-0.10277637839317322,
-0.12494747340679169,
-0.691810667514801,
0.09268733859062195,
0.3336012661457062,
0.20997901260852814,
0.10319993644952774,
-0.1562456339597702,
-0.11048571020364761,
-0.5202144384384155,
0.19533617794513702,
0.4375822842121124,
-0.06595420837402344,
-0.740276038646698,
0.8688070774078369,
0.3347134292125702,
-0.5934396982192993,
0.3189255893230438,
0.04436641186475754,
-0.26378604769706726,
0.5262487530708313,
0.3781563341617584,
0.9217500686645508,
-0.14814138412475586,
0.1926717311143875,
0.24657806754112244,
0.026864392682909966,
-0.06462463736534119,
0.1285461038351059,
0.017448151484131813,
-0.7505393624305725,
-0.11594022065401077,
-0.7045363187789917,
-0.48312196135520935,
0.38199618458747864,
-0.32908472418785095,
0.28855305910110474,
-0.796811580657959,
-0.31238195300102234,
0.030914517119526863,
-0.08110322058200836,
-0.4420408606529236,
0.032076943665742874,
0.2190934717655182,
0.5024158954620361,
-0.7776706218719482,
0.6792527437210083,
0.41719502210617065,
0.015428840182721615,
-0.31189101934432983,
0.1000271812081337,
0.42431753873825073,
-0.6457436084747314,
0.5953096747398376,
0.2527501881122589,
-0.20266087353229523,
0.1098235547542572,
-0.7542034983634949,
-0.6575745940208435,
1.0143533945083618,
0.6905179619789124,
-0.3870793879032135,
-0.11442668735980988,
0.5263693928718567,
0.7367274165153503,
-0.5335310101509094,
-0.1964242309331894,
0.4062561094760895,
0.3800157308578491,
0.19409719109535217,
-0.29052311182022095,
0.1646711677312851,
-0.07161857932806015,
0.2288990020751953,
-0.2544825077056885,
-0.6469649076461792,
0.8073766827583313,
-0.1824599802494049,
-0.2485857605934143,
0.268503338098526,
0.6386736035346985,
0.5353973507881165,
0.24360305070877075,
0.36408671736717224,
0.3740788400173187,
0.5845438838005066,
0.25430187582969666,
1.334144115447998,
-0.4325428903102875,
0.2635332942008972,
1.219194769859314,
-0.6610324382781982,
0.7394306659698486,
0.4027499854564667,
-0.2150551676750183,
0.5268934369087219,
0.6547462940216064,
-0.21366432309150696,
0.4525779187679291,
0.27395063638687134,
-0.7265878319740295,
-0.21846669912338257,
-0.2540355622768402,
-0.0023667700588703156,
0.3124479651451111,
0.2331012487411499,
-0.760223925113678,
0.0821889117360115,
-0.23328593373298645,
0.09898664802312851,
0.3912939727306366,
0.2215540111064911,
0.7786055207252502,
0.17206420004367828,
-0.511883020401001,
-0.05062362551689148,
0.13750575482845306,
0.41545429825782776,
-0.4466738998889923,
-0.10602805763483047,
-0.0303474273532629,
0.5564028024673462,
-0.21444247663021088,
-0.747869610786438,
0.12766872346401215,
0.21566128730773926,
0.08054167777299881,
-0.3614128530025482,
0.7323216199874878,
-0.341149240732193,
-0.7850504517555237,
0.04179949313402176,
0.34417957067489624,
0.01059114933013916,
-0.0723918080329895,
-0.5113688707351685,
-0.03435997664928436,
-0.08681628853082657,
-0.6065941452980042,
0.5271823406219482,
0.227500781416893,
0.024058962240815163,
0.8645333647727966,
0.8692278265953064,
0.19198240339756012,
-0.06995540857315063,
-0.0874062329530716,
0.9184147119522095,
-0.659589946269989,
-0.5912761688232422,
-1.1829957962036133,
0.464197039604187,
-0.48658472299575806,
-0.16838319599628448,
0.9681727886199951,
0.5256335735321045,
0.8089060187339783,
-0.14152635633945465,
0.9434105157852173,
0.05864641070365906,
1.017919898033142,
-0.30022600293159485,
0.8161445260047913,
-0.3052932620048523,
0.5946036577224731,
-0.020965883508324623,
-0.7578092813491821,
-0.28474554419517517,
0.5313611030578613,
-0.23154567182064056,
0.19475142657756805,
0.21776776015758514,
1.1929962635040283,
0.09224793314933777,
-0.1006418839097023,
0.1452070027589798,
0.3539321720600128,
0.4399465024471283,
0.1650773286819458,
0.820577085018158,
-0.22437088191509247,
0.28384894132614136,
-0.6761991381645203,
0.11111452430486679,
-0.02644439972937107,
-1.0754140615463257,
-1.2009342908859253,
-0.4029103219509125,
-0.24573898315429688,
-0.6146113872528076,
0.00837003719061613,
1.1306934356689453,
0.6857662796974182,
-0.869236171245575,
-0.24051418900489807,
-0.06492359191179276,
0.09422087669372559,
0.18219684064388275,
-0.2552326023578644,
-0.017303746193647385,
0.39352935552597046,
-0.8010992407798767,
0.09561050683259964,
-0.07805173099040985,
0.18215462565422058,
-0.6743878126144409,
-0.10885018855333328,
-0.1374158412218094,
0.2221851646900177,
0.4342942237854004,
0.4562264084815979,
-0.8389148712158203,
-0.4352951645851135,
-0.09902496635913849,
-0.1209721639752388,
-0.04051367938518524,
0.7958818674087524,
-0.7283306121826172,
0.3882194757461548,
0.4647536277770996,
0.7711429595947266,
0.36876213550567627,
0.6612628698348999,
0.8017521500587463,
-1.1048729419708252,
0.09864532202482224,
0.3338087201118469,
0.07321200519800186,
0.4840594530105591,
-0.7712697982788086,
0.3581700325012207,
0.2344972789287567,
-0.47390884160995483,
-1.10250985622406,
0.25169503688812256,
-0.6537389755249023,
-0.19517605006694794,
1.2309362888336182,
-0.1625528782606125,
-0.6418237090110779,
-0.005246311891824007,
-0.06817588955163956,
-0.11797178536653519,
-0.4792701303958893,
1.0303791761398315,
0.5555415153503418,
-0.08352208137512207,
-0.2925291061401367,
-0.6237325668334961,
0.6454223394393921,
-0.13984103500843048,
-0.967225968837738,
0.4503474831581116,
0.4046066701412201,
0.3303077518939972,
-0.024686893448233604,
0.3956681787967682,
-0.0130864717066288,
0.006534027401357889,
-0.20858605206012726,
-0.10709154605865479,
-0.2731865346431732,
-0.3146403133869171,
-0.1641652137041092,
0.19035248458385468,
-0.1430492103099823,
0.04901285842061043
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07212v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07212v2
|
Towards Human-AI Collaboration in Healthcare: Guided Deferral Systems with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T12:41:54 | 2024-07-03T14:49:15 |
Joshua Strong, Qianhui Men, Alison Noble
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.HC
|
Large language models (LLMs) present a valuable technology for various
applications in healthcare, but their tendency to hallucinate introduces
unacceptable uncertainty in critical decision-making situations. Human-AI
collaboration (HAIC) can mitigate this uncertainty by combining human and AI
strengths for better outcomes. This paper presents a novel guided deferral
system that provides intelligent guidance when AI defers cases to human
decision-makers. We leverage LLMs' verbalisation capabilities and internal
states to create this system, demonstrating that fine-tuning small-scale LLMs
with data from large-scale LLMs greatly enhances performance while maintaining
computational efficiency and data privacy. A pilot study showcases the
effectiveness of our proposed deferral system.
|
[
-0.24563786387443542,
-0.44887739419937134,
0.8680968284606934,
-0.1151478961110115,
-0.1389092057943344,
0.015771660953760147,
-0.1754196733236313,
-0.49549469351768494,
0.23562292754650116,
0.4176125228404999,
-0.8589634895324707,
-0.44866642355918884,
-0.38880109786987305,
0.2787260413169861,
-0.1401825249195099,
0.6059631705284119,
0.1510702669620514,
0.3900704085826874,
-0.34937623143196106,
-0.017495859414339066,
-0.6090526580810547,
-0.5962390899658203,
-0.8573415279388428,
-0.7542715072631836,
0.46412667632102966,
0.34958159923553467,
0.9438035488128662,
0.4871893525123596,
0.7452981472015381,
0.346162885427475,
-0.023311587050557137,
0.21455974876880646,
-0.12285128980875015,
0.3314753770828247,
-0.07818125933408737,
-0.3838346600532532,
-0.6819859147071838,
-0.5841840505599976,
0.5067330598831177,
0.7478569149971008,
-0.5706725716590881,
-0.2611640691757202,
-0.03317398577928543,
0.9693396091461182,
-0.3653380870819092,
0.3031871020793915,
-0.2481418251991272,
0.08265119791030884,
-0.06536515057086945,
0.2351250797510147,
-0.17727653682231903,
-0.4206272065639496,
0.32606256008148193,
-0.44984227418899536,
-0.039701372385025024,
0.09132640808820724,
0.34443265199661255,
1.0536600351333618,
0.06599212437868118,
-0.13834042847156525,
-0.9725033044815063,
0.31664639711380005,
-0.8063586354255676,
0.5246548056602478,
0.7212621569633484,
0.23782727122306824,
-0.43186014890670776,
-0.7755087018013,
-0.4261421859264374,
-0.16826525330543518,
-0.08851601928472519,
-0.08295261859893799,
-0.13561324775218964,
0.5122092366218567,
0.01110710296779871,
-0.013593370094895363,
-0.4973803758621216,
0.35825997591018677,
-0.4368734359741211,
-0.29871702194213867,
0.9754897952079773,
0.32119277119636536,
0.03525988385081291,
0.2057470679283142,
0.038826800882816315,
0.1377774178981781,
-0.44408294558525085,
-0.22663338482379913,
-0.30977100133895874,
0.371501624584198,
-0.12949636578559875,
0.3212871849536896,
-0.3141983151435852,
0.533025860786438,
0.03221609815955162,
-0.3741665184497833,
-0.058259010314941406,
0.06254845857620239,
-0.42258280515670776,
0.428237646818161,
0.7482554316520691,
0.09725120663642883,
0.28936678171157837,
-0.25351887941360474,
-0.24228091537952423,
0.42696455121040344,
0.5091886520385742,
-0.6524605751037598,
-0.34532827138900757,
0.17683105170726776,
-0.5641648769378662,
-0.14495381712913513,
0.08547163009643555,
-0.46177756786346436,
-0.6397926807403564,
-0.31226834654808044,
0.2942991256713867,
-0.4044566750526428,
0.017718596383929253,
0.23678170144557953,
0.2961203157901764,
0.10844776034355164,
0.40713298320770264,
-0.8425916433334351,
0.6585037112236023,
0.790453314781189,
0.6964849233627319,
0.1626921147108078,
-0.26098358631134033,
-0.67293781042099,
0.2788161039352417,
-0.30984529852867126,
0.475111722946167,
-0.5673987865447998,
-0.7668006420135498,
-0.24393555521965027,
-0.11948518455028534,
0.2156461477279663,
-0.6031752228736877,
0.5182368755340576,
-0.2323867380619049,
0.23880669474601746,
-0.1657804697751999,
-0.38695192337036133,
-0.18494832515716553,
0.03599986433982849,
-0.5037769675254822,
0.4740826189517975,
0.3119494915008545,
-0.471338152885437,
0.42425161600112915,
-0.7855201363563538,
-0.7273269891738892,
0.3520587682723999,
-0.4852977395057678,
-0.6698011755943298,
0.09275836497545242,
0.3962724804878235,
0.3970544636249542,
-0.3854043781757355,
0.3094816207885742,
-0.2699686586856842,
-0.5607711672782898,
0.05290273204445839,
-0.42735958099365234,
0.2684077024459839,
0.10954897105693817,
-0.30430740118026733,
0.44392266869544983,
-0.5018240809440613,
-0.11989124864339828,
-0.1722116768360138,
-0.3798862397670746,
-0.3627721071243286,
0.13178782165050507,
-0.21422064304351807,
0.1100359633564949,
0.08337482810020447,
-0.02037707343697548,
0.34013471007347107,
-0.4397038221359253,
0.6506686210632324,
0.9377971887588501,
-0.20439915359020233,
0.34199047088623047,
-0.6712294816970825,
0.5230712294578552,
-0.4519718885421753,
0.36035263538360596,
0.21086351573467255,
-0.6825589537620544,
-0.46845296025276184,
-0.3328283429145813,
0.41801688075065613,
0.4248175323009491,
-0.6998209357261658,
0.7147226333618164,
-0.2621234655380249,
0.02930406853556633,
-1.0758346319198608,
-0.04065767303109169,
0.1415446400642395,
0.7101221084594727,
0.2209375649690628,
-0.30522608757019043,
-0.3456342816352844,
-0.916009783744812,
0.25592800974845886,
-0.5014886260032654,
-0.31929078698158264,
0.2513788342475891,
0.333570271730423,
-0.7068882584571838,
0.5342935919761658,
-0.3708440661430359,
-0.7509129643440247,
-0.11666154116392136,
-0.16641272604465485,
-0.05877428874373436,
0.28070196509361267,
-0.0562048964202404,
-0.940219521522522,
-0.2760544419288635,
-0.05831792578101158,
-0.7179208993911743,
-0.004125506151467562,
0.04625959321856499,
-0.1612214744091034,
0.41283902525901794,
0.4969674050807953,
-0.2800268232822418,
0.8114579916000366,
0.5064853429794312,
-0.4856524169445038,
0.13836942613124847,
-0.6746594905853271,
0.11526205390691757,
-1.1640385389328003,
0.04797790199518204,
-0.1961984485387802,
-0.3795866370201111,
-0.6132540702819824,
-0.30789849162101746,
-0.12867476046085358,
0.052318308502435684,
-0.04993222653865814,
0.357407808303833,
-0.2741236388683319,
0.01677452027797699,
-0.20564647018909454,
-0.007788797374814749,
-0.12062948942184448,
0.23529565334320068,
0.20932550728321075,
0.568900465965271,
0.5602109432220459,
-0.682304859161377,
0.4789946377277374,
0.6684510111808777,
0.040294282138347626,
0.9277375936508179,
-0.6731978058815002,
0.18058067560195923,
-0.040878430008888245,
0.35390231013298035,
-0.339652955532074,
-0.66997891664505,
0.2744615972042084,
-0.23521922528743744,
0.16005589067935944,
0.14524643123149872,
-0.2630307376384735,
-0.6371451020240784,
-0.25331616401672363,
0.4106934070587158,
0.5215727090835571,
-0.2663075625896454,
0.7798771858215332,
0.4041539430618286,
-0.3113691210746765,
-0.07859321683645248,
-1.1484092473983765,
0.36950376629829407,
0.008091752417385578,
-0.662600576877594,
0.561454176902771,
-0.2727299928665161,
-0.5179645419120789,
0.020571686327457428,
0.13110075891017914,
-0.13888205587863922,
0.024952417239546776,
0.8143057823181152,
0.34377479553222656,
0.1309206336736679,
0.3104301393032074,
0.04698564484715462,
-0.03966870531439781,
0.09741942584514618,
-0.28465044498443604,
0.45260995626449585,
-0.08339443057775497,
-0.67649245262146,
-1.2383028268814087,
0.4269792139530182,
0.8933748006820679,
0.006653851363807917,
0.8018362522125244,
0.2805425226688385,
-0.7565463185310364,
0.02452804334461689,
-0.45219314098358154,
-0.4367898404598236,
-0.48029446601867676,
0.06123028323054314,
-0.05506829917430878,
-0.7891873717308044,
0.32433268427848816,
-0.028864672407507896,
-0.12032341957092285,
0.1483413130044937,
0.7555240988731384,
0.058670710772275925,
0.9208174347877502,
0.7934526205062866,
-0.6677302718162537,
0.13661949336528778,
0.08456628769636154,
0.10235510766506195,
-0.6306179165840149,
-0.5464726090431213,
-0.36883583664894104,
-0.43054160475730896,
-0.6107852458953857,
-0.2724999189376831,
0.8262243270874023,
-0.24045749008655548,
-0.31926262378692627,
-0.35338130593299866,
-0.8624230623245239,
0.02868221141397953,
0.7168006896972656,
0.5126968026161194,
0.4059064984321594,
-0.2973395884037018,
0.03079434670507908,
0.12582626938819885,
-0.7705146074295044,
-0.26645782589912415,
0.7484484910964966,
0.23286360502243042,
0.9306654930114746,
0.14644257724285126,
0.6773307919502258,
0.621495246887207,
0.12538374960422516,
-0.7728596329689026,
0.4771113991737366,
-0.10312654823064804,
-0.18808750808238983,
-0.5501883029937744,
-0.3686527907848358,
-1.0372626781463623,
-0.11509524285793304,
-0.40498313307762146,
-0.5864905714988708,
-0.16076263785362244,
-0.03168399631977081,
-0.9333481788635254,
0.2597962021827698,
-0.5971692204475403,
0.2647523581981659,
-0.29041334986686707,
-0.40579524636268616,
-0.4001465439796448,
-0.8164671659469604,
0.0386001281440258,
-0.19191499054431915,
0.2484293133020401,
0.19653861224651337,
-0.026895370334386826,
0.6192200183868408,
-0.761659562587738,
0.7450333833694458,
0.10440785437822342,
-0.11298831552267075,
-0.03842804953455925,
0.09203086048364639,
0.606321394443512,
0.24603290855884552,
-0.45600762963294983,
0.04308725520968437,
-0.3253098726272583,
-0.13800561428070068,
-0.4097961485385895,
0.7771255373954773,
-0.4781000018119812,
-0.6489003300666809,
-0.3651195764541626,
-0.6726422905921936,
-0.3972835838794708,
0.38032642006874084,
-0.0005107563338242471,
0.3024047613143921,
-0.18360836803913116,
-0.059994619339704514,
0.36522626876831055,
-0.02580738067626953,
0.42431390285491943,
0.4681932330131531,
0.09027053415775299,
-0.40298932790756226,
0.40461066365242004,
-0.05003276839852333,
-0.08182363957166672,
0.37137407064437866,
0.44198551774024963,
-0.3687531352043152,
-0.6022472381591797,
-0.3547889292240143,
0.2671140134334564,
-0.18146294355392456,
-0.2851049304008484,
-0.10527058690786362,
-0.38688960671424866,
-0.6333590149879456,
-0.569878876209259,
-0.015872279182076454,
0.06324916332960129,
-0.399160772562027,
0.1329406499862671,
0.5356606245040894,
1.3448615074157715,
-0.044310614466667175,
0.11434830725193024,
-0.9311554431915283,
0.5766959190368652,
0.40906596183776855,
0.6593131422996521,
-0.008434329181909561,
-0.3113853931427002,
-0.06886263936758041,
0.17497119307518005,
0.02356790564954281,
-0.5467022657394409,
0.4063715934753418,
-0.04524107277393341,
0.42688992619514465,
0.4989088177680969,
0.4337819814682007,
0.6821377277374268,
-0.4949554204940796,
0.5992024540901184,
0.22078262269496918,
-0.8740332126617432,
0.6807356476783752,
-0.23477984964847565,
0.43594759702682495,
0.7010356783866882,
0.10447855293750763,
-0.6484407782554626,
-0.06152823939919472,
-0.36802610754966736,
-0.7250186204910278,
0.7987028360366821,
0.09863319247961044,
-0.5219975709915161,
0.4276186227798462,
0.4496784806251526,
-0.15307636559009552,
0.2531443238258362,
-0.15335114300251007,
0.09541343152523041,
0.3754866123199463,
-0.4076671898365021,
0.28959769010543823,
0.09444635361433029,
-0.3174802362918854,
-0.31316429376602173,
0.6022000312805176,
-0.1493019461631775,
0.1098114401102066,
0.4965629577636719,
0.2680008113384247,
-0.4676963984966278,
0.07722564786672592,
0.6851442456245422,
0.4212762713432312,
0.09966816008090973,
-0.09677905589342117,
0.42181703448295593,
-0.36043962836265564,
-0.057249680161476135,
0.24691163003444672,
-0.16119852662086487,
-0.37499573826789856,
0.45146098732948303,
0.5893168449401855,
-0.16015106439590454,
-0.7110037803649902,
0.1053963378071785,
-0.4227985441684723,
-0.3190401792526245,
-0.22450309991836548,
0.15276339650154114,
0.12408667802810669,
0.5193232297897339,
0.14070884883403778,
0.09299299120903015,
-0.019755398854613304,
-0.27871835231781006,
0.3992525637149811,
0.4411633312702179,
-0.42564892768859863,
-0.2122327983379364,
0.8372930884361267,
0.36877986788749695,
-0.889794647693634,
0.6666585803031921,
0.013041640631854534,
-0.3929475247859955,
0.38378360867500305,
0.05242447927594185,
0.7916894555091858,
-0.45481833815574646,
0.07036519050598145,
-0.2533336579799652,
0.10984878987073898,
-0.5288522243499756,
0.16859811544418335,
-0.14776243269443512,
-0.2623145580291748,
-0.3400675356388092,
-0.2302647978067398,
-0.7056661248207092,
0.06644608080387115,
-0.5960756540298462,
0.3010764420032501,
-0.5407202243804932,
-0.22344839572906494,
-0.26020750403404236,
0.036255162209272385,
-0.5931844711303711,
0.041212648153305054,
0.523654580116272,
0.5277091860771179,
-0.19183094799518585,
0.8928417563438416,
0.6774706244468689,
-0.0318443737924099,
-1.0226582288742065,
0.35795554518699646,
0.22326606512069702,
-0.6407704949378967,
0.16539840400218964,
-0.03281685337424278,
-0.45456865429878235,
-0.2765582203865051,
-0.14972011744976044,
-0.41739168763160706,
1.2567248344421387,
0.3477405905723572,
-0.8722436428070068,
-0.30843958258628845,
0.30429086089134216,
0.8012401461601257,
-0.15519167482852936,
-0.11070629209280014,
0.7258954644203186,
0.6104170680046082,
0.08900011330842972,
-1.3404299020767212,
0.2617940306663513,
0.23567163944244385,
-0.17738905549049377,
0.22113078832626343,
-0.9187456369400024,
0.3673211336135864,
-0.3332936763763428,
0.07996053993701935,
0.12391938269138336,
0.3804715573787689,
-0.059809401631355286,
0.5318302512168884,
0.3926461637020111,
0.5159445405006409,
1.2491060495376587,
-0.05623031035065651,
0.8871802687644958,
-0.31829580664634705,
-0.13801857829093933,
0.8639834523200989,
-0.8039618730545044,
0.6196324229240417,
0.3434883654117584,
-0.3303152918815613,
0.5808905363082886,
0.29019325971603394,
0.28563880920410156,
0.30946481227874756,
0.27918046712875366,
-0.5731050968170166,
-0.03521490842103958,
-0.42278507351875305,
-0.26052209734916687,
0.4813479781150818,
0.5096757411956787,
-0.3032407760620117,
0.16686367988586426,
-0.05197041854262352,
-0.03837629035115242,
0.32644420862197876,
-0.437753289937973,
1.0139667987823486,
0.22308772802352905,
-0.7971295118331909,
0.7044464349746704,
-0.19589340686798096,
0.8822011351585388,
-0.6749346852302551,
-0.129700168967247,
-0.09350796043872833,
0.3726823329925537,
-0.394297331571579,
-0.551641047000885,
0.324500173330307,
-0.23862428963184357,
-0.32031112909317017,
-0.25404614210128784,
0.6699646711349487,
-0.41052237153053284,
-0.5926198363304138,
0.34814921021461487,
0.37467220425605774,
-0.12198101729154587,
-0.01838790625333786,
-0.6119462847709656,
0.1355830579996109,
0.013325899839401245,
0.13181498646736145,
0.2772064208984375,
0.3875458538532257,
-0.26232093572616577,
0.9983197450637817,
0.49264150857925415,
0.506013035774231,
-0.6055942177772522,
0.3136584758758545,
0.9293779730796814,
-0.6613189578056335,
-0.6612502336502075,
-0.9959424138069153,
0.15692093968391418,
0.15593671798706055,
0.0387483686208725,
0.1665460169315338,
0.029349301010370255,
0.3787813186645508,
0.3608566224575043,
0.8801023960113525,
0.18266399204730988,
0.410887211561203,
-0.27912694215774536,
0.8683825731277466,
-0.41534560918807983,
0.4078645706176758,
-0.07621077448129654,
-0.24801766872406006,
-0.639598548412323,
0.6158849000930786,
-0.08842330425977707,
-0.05623985826969147,
0.20197774469852448,
0.7570269703865051,
0.40744417905807495,
0.005215419456362724,
0.5462692975997925,
0.10501616448163986,
0.5054656863212585,
0.7004074454307556,
0.533344566822052,
-0.02164999023079872,
0.2432907074689865,
-0.3388815224170685,
-0.15891294181346893,
-0.2788478136062622,
-0.4621542990207672,
-0.8236390948295593,
-0.5217070579528809,
-0.07298379391431808,
-0.2216959148645401,
0.4080137610435486,
1.2882555723190308,
1.052570104598999,
-0.5934282541275024,
0.04649601876735687,
-0.33129167556762695,
0.1940581351518631,
-0.03908671438694,
-0.15413345396518707,
0.4324469268321991,
0.17582586407661438,
-0.6016908884048462,
0.5306559205055237,
0.4902615547180176,
0.19369558990001678,
-0.6004749536514282,
-0.48333367705345154,
0.004930775612592697,
0.009198293089866638,
0.29867008328437805,
0.1006869450211525,
-0.6600109338760376,
-0.0877179354429245,
-0.10847864300012589,
-0.039505571126937866,
-0.033035341650247574,
0.9342670440673828,
-1.1504650115966797,
0.3418571650981903,
0.20920050144195557,
0.7738761901855469,
-0.035475727170705795,
0.2619669735431671,
0.6713927388191223,
-0.3550185263156891,
0.3138227164745331,
0.7455184459686279,
0.34676793217658997,
0.4054608643054962,
-0.7476736307144165,
0.5768574476242065,
0.0338718444108963,
-0.8846482634544373,
-0.6432778239250183,
0.04470294341444969,
-0.4981195032596588,
-0.42800554633140564,
0.9525105953216553,
0.24519364535808563,
-0.005338295828551054,
-0.31856071949005127,
-0.3374229371547699,
0.19081224501132965,
-0.7105535864830017,
1.1080060005187988,
0.4266433119773865,
-0.4963873326778412,
0.25344786047935486,
-0.18762533366680145,
0.5745255351066589,
0.4311196506023407,
-0.8060505986213684,
0.048893917351961136,
0.5261631608009338,
-0.165154367685318,
0.0077524008229374886,
0.8139849901199341,
0.2483288049697876,
0.12894444167613983,
-0.3727530241012573,
-0.07028432190418243,
-0.09499938040971756,
-0.5162549614906311,
-0.624221682548523,
-0.2578798830509186,
0.3211157023906708,
-0.18430683016777039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07188v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07188v1
|
Merging Improves Self-Critique Against Jailbreak Attacks
| 2024-06-11T12:01:09 | 2024-06-11T12:01:09 |
Victor Gallego
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The robustness of large language models (LLMs) against adversarial
manipulations, such as jailbreak attacks, remains a significant challenge. In
this work, we propose an approach that enhances the self-critique capability of
the LLM and further fine-tunes it over sanitized synthetic data. This is done
with the addition of an external critic model that can be merged with the
original, thus bolstering self-critique capabilities and improving the
robustness of the LLMs response to adversarial prompts. Our results demonstrate
that the combination of merging and self-critique can reduce the attack success
rate of adversaries significantly, thus offering a promising defense mechanism
against jailbreak attacks. Code, data and models released at
https://github.com/vicgalle/merging-self-critique-jailbreaks .
|
[
-0.6374375224113464,
-0.6729527711868286,
0.4479557275772095,
-0.0028580401558429003,
-0.10759590566158295,
0.4148018956184387,
-0.4752454161643982,
-0.5363327264785767,
0.409747451543808,
0.7827582955360413,
-0.34341850876808167,
-0.18093715608119965,
-0.5391780138015747,
0.1743241399526596,
-0.7908892035484314,
1.4156254529953003,
-0.00374972028657794,
-0.06174776703119278,
0.03147455304861069,
-0.03518868610262871,
-0.400524765253067,
-0.6897649168968201,
-0.3412182629108429,
-0.006260991096496582,
0.42644989490509033,
0.10941410809755325,
0.6853833198547363,
0.534743070602417,
0.6361969709396362,
0.46072736382484436,
0.034741126000881195,
0.38641321659088135,
-0.4640166163444519,
0.5151668190956116,
-0.2927831709384918,
-0.3030063807964325,
-0.4668373167514801,
0.07859679311513901,
0.4292517304420471,
0.17048820853233337,
0.09999576956033707,
-0.22051870822906494,
0.2032853364944458,
0.8356848359107971,
-0.6053987741470337,
-0.3905680179595947,
-0.6531212329864502,
-0.013345728628337383,
0.024472128599882126,
0.11000251024961472,
-0.4790029525756836,
-0.40521472692489624,
-0.2500301003456116,
-0.06094416230916977,
0.16861799359321594,
-0.35534632205963135,
0.4393381178379059,
0.39680415391921997,
-0.221881702542305,
0.16272497177124023,
-0.7811140418052673,
0.3098054826259613,
-0.9112386107444763,
0.08710023760795593,
0.05310795456171036,
0.2963709831237793,
-0.5192130208015442,
-0.420337051153183,
-0.5694681406021118,
-0.6385627388954163,
-0.06805337220430374,
-0.07025720924139023,
-0.4957311749458313,
-0.030153460800647736,
0.08576326817274094,
0.442820280790329,
-0.3148704767227173,
0.15809319913387299,
-0.8745446801185608,
-0.3070715069770813,
0.973014235496521,
0.15408527851104736,
0.48749157786369324,
-0.06577475368976593,
-0.5325266718864441,
-0.21413186192512512,
-0.8371293544769287,
-0.20370103418827057,
0.8871334195137024,
0.39535051584243774,
0.0006979691097512841,
0.6353410482406616,
-0.11891879886388779,
0.6800138354301453,
0.11292549967765808,
0.1684863418340683,
0.10734293609857559,
-0.6111140251159668,
-0.16661415994167328,
-0.08456632494926453,
1.1337946653366089,
0.6670169234275818,
0.1425676941871643,
-0.37089812755584717,
-0.2308952808380127,
0.12788347899913788,
0.7372835278511047,
-0.7121741771697998,
-0.6551779508590698,
0.41614246368408203,
-0.2997656464576721,
-0.8072860240936279,
0.15350231528282166,
-0.8184655904769897,
-0.7904042601585388,
-0.17367102205753326,
0.14908930659294128,
-0.4746303856372833,
-0.13697372376918793,
-0.08397195488214493,
-0.2575239837169647,
-0.18790560960769653,
0.33471280336380005,
-0.732976496219635,
0.324956476688385,
0.6335265636444092,
0.7966819405555725,
-0.20589303970336914,
-0.42879441380500793,
-0.5449872612953186,
0.05742378532886505,
-0.35537946224212646,
0.6806625723838806,
-0.05128638818860054,
-0.5243703126907349,
-0.3431314527988434,
-0.26426100730895996,
0.05077502503991127,
-0.6320441365242004,
0.33508071303367615,
-0.6371636390686035,
0.06175187975168228,
0.0734744668006897,
-0.3547246754169464,
0.0386287197470665,
0.6509064435958862,
-1.0139524936676025,
0.8448046445846558,
0.08538077771663666,
-0.8828727006912231,
-0.07921018451452255,
-0.3420070707798004,
-0.5796760320663452,
-0.1426645666360855,
0.05719413608312607,
-0.5649478435516357,
0.18909192085266113,
0.3908957242965698,
0.3149069845676422,
-0.1080288514494896,
0.2776922881603241,
-0.7754901647567749,
-0.09882454574108124,
0.5560862421989441,
-0.20043662190437317,
0.6449187397956848,
0.5826888084411621,
-0.25417569279670715,
0.28672733902931213,
-0.480943500995636,
0.11749093979597092,
0.21359585225582123,
-0.2606840133666992,
-0.2991711497306824,
-0.16675792634487152,
-0.05412664636969566,
-0.012218758463859558,
0.3424668312072754,
-0.46687084436416626,
0.8930341601371765,
-0.568515419960022,
0.6459490656852722,
0.7126114368438721,
-0.13970153033733368,
0.44375061988830566,
-0.3122499883174896,
0.5315126776695251,
-0.17739495635032654,
0.19071948528289795,
-0.17238083481788635,
-0.06700699776411057,
-0.5718092918395996,
-0.3429725468158722,
0.4061104953289032,
0.5516735315322876,
-0.5335399508476257,
0.5068973898887634,
-0.18157263100147247,
-0.7392547726631165,
-0.6535042524337769,
0.6785242557525635,
0.48666995763778687,
0.1594494879245758,
0.5880317091941833,
-0.38583385944366455,
-0.9388537406921387,
-0.833368182182312,
-0.44866427779197693,
-0.36090537905693054,
0.23714666068553925,
-0.03465115651488304,
0.35836729407310486,
-0.44152382016181946,
0.8043922781944275,
-0.31520792841911316,
-0.2211088389158249,
-0.462619423866272,
-0.17678691446781158,
-0.006163677666336298,
0.6792301535606384,
0.6297873854637146,
-0.3191378116607666,
-0.42365387082099915,
-0.10476453602313995,
-0.6865418553352356,
-0.2789974510669708,
-0.09712309390306473,
0.24230362474918365,
-0.11605339497327805,
0.8792127370834351,
-0.533257782459259,
0.17100836336612701,
0.521798849105835,
-0.27258995175361633,
0.8164067268371582,
-0.16712361574172974,
0.32835653424263,
-1.281997561454773,
-0.36877840757369995,
-0.1303078979253769,
-0.23721492290496826,
-0.6250078082084656,
0.6635400652885437,
0.21086861193180084,
-0.13826099038124084,
-0.46538686752319336,
0.3497128188610077,
-0.4112186133861542,
0.2291048765182495,
-0.5829353928565979,
0.19631725549697876,
-0.12313968688249588,
-0.022719457745552063,
-0.7088910937309265,
0.8957033157348633,
0.4460025131702423,
-0.23655487596988678,
0.6955208778381348,
0.07807709276676178,
-0.1829087883234024,
0.19271399080753326,
-0.6322038173675537,
0.36410024762153625,
-0.023062242195010185,
0.38478490710258484,
-1.0510764122009277,
-0.1822267770767212,
0.20891636610031128,
-0.39048460125923157,
0.47481754422187805,
-0.45544999837875366,
-0.43510347604751587,
-0.4457228183746338,
-0.8308780789375305,
0.29198983311653137,
0.23943687975406647,
-0.8225827217102051,
0.5673494935035706,
0.2726025879383087,
-0.04409833997488022,
-0.526497483253479,
-0.7956416606903076,
0.5459923148155212,
-0.4122332036495209,
-0.801075279712677,
0.47297438979148865,
-0.23315565288066864,
-0.39782747626304626,
0.0759916603565216,
0.18382857739925385,
0.42625853419303894,
0.2190532237291336,
0.2234494984149933,
0.6201172471046448,
-0.02704177051782608,
-0.3340652287006378,
-0.13957510888576508,
0.010751603171229362,
0.08792614936828613,
-0.2653515338897705,
0.5402672290802002,
-0.1654413640499115,
-0.22665545344352722,
-0.3602912127971649,
0.18504241108894348,
0.8974032402038574,
-0.16142301261425018,
0.6905449628829956,
0.2785917818546295,
0.15419049561023712,
-0.2970598638057709,
-0.7641058564186096,
-0.14712493121623993,
-0.5083336234092712,
0.11380086094141006,
-0.31974804401397705,
-1.187353253364563,
0.5635892152786255,
0.12130068987607956,
-0.08626991510391235,
0.3003184199333191,
0.5395002961158752,
-0.028335953131318092,
0.8627731204032898,
0.39275869727134705,
-0.8359922766685486,
0.49923184514045715,
-0.39914292097091675,
0.4118878245353699,
-1.2222349643707275,
-0.09328136593103409,
-0.41236355900764465,
-0.250732421875,
-0.5977149605751038,
-0.16240164637565613,
0.005624535493552685,
0.1259123682975769,
-0.1639704406261444,
0.790040135383606,
-0.5797772407531738,
0.6330990791320801,
0.22745639085769653,
0.27820518612861633,
0.16126962006092072,
-0.17283181846141815,
-0.1594308316707611,
0.11604093015193939,
-0.31973597407341003,
-0.30522239208221436,
1.2008702754974365,
0.394208163022995,
1.049951195716858,
0.3639439046382904,
1.0992977619171143,
0.33857986330986023,
0.38900384306907654,
-0.49000823497772217,
0.6261937022209167,
-0.33345451951026917,
-0.48254603147506714,
-0.10507013648748398,
-0.5692423582077026,
-0.8106822967529297,
0.5505614876747131,
-0.2045319825410843,
-1.0847281217575073,
-0.14319398999214172,
0.14636528491973877,
-0.596666693687439,
0.501326322555542,
-0.7875328660011292,
0.7088034152984619,
-0.376030296087265,
-0.4236675798892975,
-0.2529415488243103,
-0.3499394953250885,
0.8386350274085999,
-0.21798314154148102,
0.38058915734291077,
-0.00011796816397691146,
0.39304137229919434,
0.5995475649833679,
-0.9144567847251892,
0.9830487966537476,
0.07978223264217377,
-0.23062513768672943,
0.3250245749950409,
0.47342267632484436,
0.7158294916152954,
0.028240108862519264,
0.16954682767391205,
-0.15059857070446014,
-0.15090475976467133,
0.15717358887195587,
-0.9148876070976257,
1.0157941579818726,
-0.7193917036056519,
-1.106734275817871,
-0.2680116593837738,
-0.5189597606658936,
-0.03391803056001663,
0.052317988127470016,
0.1390000283718109,
0.25163888931274414,
-0.0058364649303257465,
0.13275210559368134,
0.19444280862808228,
0.16674040257930756,
0.3598892092704773,
0.544573962688446,
-0.40874436497688293,
-0.9440672397613525,
0.4673159718513489,
-0.0874164029955864,
0.3295254707336426,
-0.30234116315841675,
0.16672660410404205,
-0.3136037588119507,
-0.6417719721794128,
-0.32168155908584595,
0.10178670287132263,
-0.7074676752090454,
-0.5807394981384277,
-0.6046415567398071,
-0.4302788972854614,
-0.6337709426879883,
-0.10840252786874771,
-0.5131371021270752,
-0.4429579973220825,
0.04614774137735367,
-0.23646299540996552,
0.555853545665741,
0.7411072254180908,
-0.23848401010036469,
0.40295228362083435,
-1.013553261756897,
0.32191967964172363,
0.15097211301326752,
0.17824788391590118,
0.05304846167564392,
-0.8332445621490479,
-0.18613198399543762,
-0.1935608834028244,
-0.27293404936790466,
-1.2080271244049072,
0.5342234969139099,
-0.18207751214504242,
0.4091465175151825,
0.13922230899333954,
0.18782494962215424,
0.9022113680839539,
-0.36654430627822876,
0.5981647968292236,
0.29854077100753784,
-0.9439713954925537,
0.7998742461204529,
-0.27861887216567993,
0.029771968722343445,
0.8595643639564514,
-0.14371971786022186,
-0.08752261102199554,
-0.9628270268440247,
-0.4967426061630249,
-0.8981388807296753,
0.2914857268333435,
0.30065637826919556,
0.19119617342948914,
0.12460938096046448,
0.26801440119743347,
-0.3360123932361603,
-0.04952673614025116,
-0.903648853302002,
-0.18068110942840576,
-0.12344202399253845,
-0.19193579256534576,
-0.09163510054349899,
-0.10578086972236633,
-0.5119490623474121,
-0.3499981760978699,
0.5688819289207458,
0.06819711625576019,
-0.2758546769618988,
0.10212194919586182,
-0.056309085339307785,
0.02984127402305603,
0.4703080356121063,
0.14670497179031372,
-0.04181972146034241,
0.07065422832965851,
0.4224173128604889,
0.26091286540031433,
-0.2945441007614136,
0.4371180236339569,
0.15807408094406128,
-0.3034273684024811,
-0.5329196453094482,
0.5180798768997192,
0.5269719362258911,
0.05957818776369095,
-0.6222192645072937,
0.40478283166885376,
-0.30389633774757385,
-0.03564433753490448,
-0.04267870634794235,
0.5252009630203247,
-0.33469486236572266,
0.5250217318534851,
0.03549381345510483,
0.3746887147426605,
0.19224771857261658,
-0.7280508279800415,
0.37059858441352844,
0.7022216320037842,
-0.004736787173897028,
-0.1866670697927475,
0.7184398174285889,
0.06870639324188232,
-0.15638086199760437,
0.5875255465507507,
-0.02719457633793354,
-1.1290779113769531,
0.4939890205860138,
0.7920750975608826,
1.0261343717575073,
-0.40134820342063904,
-0.17372682690620422,
0.2852832078933716,
0.6458067297935486,
-0.16739822924137115,
-0.04670300707221031,
-0.2873162031173706,
-0.8294342756271362,
-0.47898828983306885,
-0.29407575726509094,
-0.25119441747665405,
0.24070310592651367,
-0.555137038230896,
0.15062034130096436,
-0.6444796323776245,
-0.38436201214790344,
-0.06074503809213638,
-0.03663314878940582,
-0.1823314130306244,
0.20336855947971344,
0.16195693612098694,
0.7803519368171692,
-0.7435656189918518,
0.9759242534637451,
0.5089720487594604,
-0.42103567719459534,
-0.7839810848236084,
-0.1301420032978058,
0.057862959802150726,
-0.2551213800907135,
0.4514428377151489,
0.429494708776474,
-0.19654066860675812,
-0.4867786765098572,
-0.4328365623950958,
-1.022877812385559,
0.5461334586143494,
0.5381444692611694,
-0.7355228662490845,
0.40716245770454407,
-0.3245846629142761,
0.6547110080718994,
-0.276258647441864,
-0.03482050448656082,
0.9202561974525452,
0.4167040288448334,
-0.1338639259338379,
-0.9505532383918762,
0.34757933020591736,
-0.6371275782585144,
-0.22616752982139587,
0.5707652568817139,
-0.5046160221099854,
0.7067542672157288,
-0.5866609811782837,
-0.1276058703660965,
0.24961014091968536,
0.6696083545684814,
0.23748423159122467,
-0.005960894748568535,
0.5761444568634033,
0.8575578927993774,
0.5307851433753967,
-0.04761195927858353,
1.1044901609420776,
-0.5435482263565063,
0.2776568830013275,
1.5148159265518188,
-0.3303505778312683,
0.769679844379425,
0.4912640154361725,
-0.17408685386180878,
0.5843335390090942,
0.24092374742031097,
-0.5065704584121704,
0.541815996170044,
0.2137279510498047,
-0.12594586610794067,
-0.070467509329319,
0.4413773715496063,
-0.4557667672634125,
0.4930274188518524,
-0.034647051244974136,
-0.3390442728996277,
-0.05921190604567528,
0.02295241318643093,
0.1978893280029297,
0.26651379466056824,
-0.13247351348400116,
0.9711244106292725,
-0.09201233088970184,
-0.964335024356842,
0.5689655542373657,
0.30731481313705444,
0.6512221097946167,
-0.48260498046875,
0.36436253786087036,
-0.07124939560890198,
0.3539547622203827,
-0.4139358401298523,
-0.8534219264984131,
0.5394792556762695,
0.21643298864364624,
0.02797374501824379,
-0.040337469428777695,
0.7829110026359558,
-0.4275371730327606,
-0.15130063891410828,
0.7197132110595703,
0.00588975939899683,
-0.12861640751361847,
-0.04490550234913826,
-0.5288704633712769,
0.44574302434921265,
0.12704230844974518,
-0.014779213815927505,
0.4865342080593109,
-0.2026159167289734,
0.18322156369686127,
0.7238329648971558,
0.9758265614509583,
0.24555964767932892,
-0.042769819498062134,
0.1572497934103012,
1.342939019203186,
-0.678922712802887,
-0.728425145149231,
-1.4856160879135132,
0.39662739634513855,
-0.3363403081893921,
0.03472829610109329,
1.1132155656814575,
0.6675691604614258,
0.8386333584785461,
-0.005395601037889719,
1.0783027410507202,
-0.012095721438527107,
0.20110109448432922,
-0.6298871040344238,
0.7681980729103088,
-0.24842800199985504,
0.5833579301834106,
-0.2505047023296356,
-0.6642036437988281,
-0.17558784782886505,
0.4556367099285126,
-0.3544916808605194,
-0.027423551306128502,
0.4801085591316223,
0.8237592577934265,
0.06818487495183945,
-0.21850617229938507,
0.09215276688337326,
0.2797859013080597,
0.47554269433021545,
0.4446585476398468,
1.1125118732452393,
-0.5140433311462402,
0.5596089363098145,
-0.32122328877449036,
-0.04216605797410011,
-0.16696661710739136,
-0.787979781627655,
-1.2281956672668457,
-0.280168354511261,
-0.2945900559425354,
-0.9211710691452026,
0.13989552855491638,
0.8947295546531677,
0.5947704315185547,
-0.8543596863746643,
-0.07619024813175201,
0.08834894001483917,
-0.019510187208652496,
0.10132874548435211,
-0.1886311173439026,
0.12220854312181473,
-0.44206729531288147,
-0.4159435033798218,
1.1278011798858643,
0.3615269064903259,
0.20632819831371307,
-0.5682593584060669,
-0.009079448878765106,
0.35725533962249756,
0.29794397950172424,
0.3384993374347687,
0.3213527798652649,
-0.767906665802002,
-0.05855070799589157,
-0.4037366509437561,
-0.2609790563583374,
-0.05526561290025711,
1.043209195137024,
-0.8272460699081421,
0.798148512840271,
0.40291857719421387,
0.7690216302871704,
0.2978006601333618,
0.37061429023742676,
0.7939783930778503,
-0.7188524603843689,
0.1734912395477295,
-0.1652596890926361,
0.7085880637168884,
0.5350465774536133,
-0.5523958206176758,
0.4493749439716339,
0.04820422828197479,
-0.29091325402259827,
-1.06409752368927,
0.3750539720058441,
-0.7525648474693298,
-0.46001556515693665,
1.0301483869552612,
-0.12222493439912796,
-0.2393437623977661,
0.23858381807804108,
-0.3160877525806427,
0.12220428138971329,
-0.16080302000045776,
1.1038302183151245,
0.6088241934776306,
0.17120274901390076,
-0.0240172166377306,
0.10036076605319977,
0.44653788208961487,
0.3033551275730133,
-0.9337140321731567,
0.29404667019844055,
0.3698243200778961,
0.3964415490627289,
0.2033671885728836,
0.3104243874549866,
-0.28317856788635254,
0.32076746225357056,
-0.18238332867622375,
-0.17460475862026215,
-0.4270763695240021,
-0.5679624080657959,
-0.7144755125045776,
0.294284850358963,
0.03602457419037819,
0.04338017478585243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07168v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07168v1
|
Teaching Language Models to Self-Improve by Learning from Language Feedback
| 2024-06-11T11:20:05 | 2024-06-11T11:20:05 |
Chi Hu, Yimin Hu, Hang Cao, Tong Xiao, Jingbo Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Aligning Large Language Models (LLMs) with human intentions and values is
crucial yet challenging. Current methods primarily rely on human preferences,
which are costly and insufficient in capturing nuanced feedback expressed in
natural language. In this paper, we present Self-Refinement Tuning (SRT), a
method that leverages model feedback for alignment, thereby reducing reliance
on human annotations. SRT uses a base language model (e.g., Tulu2) to generate
initial responses, which are critiqued and refined by a more advanced model
(e.g., GPT-4-Turbo). This process enables the base model to self-evaluate and
improve its outputs, facilitating continuous learning. SRT further optimizes
the model by learning from its self-generated feedback and refinements,
creating a feedback loop that promotes model improvement. Our empirical
evaluations demonstrate that SRT significantly outperforms strong baselines
across diverse tasks and model sizes. When applied to a 70B parameter model,
SRT increases the win rate from 9.6\% to 25.8\% on the AlpacaEval 2.0
benchmark, surpassing well-established systems such as GPT-4-0314, Claude 2,
and Gemini. Our analysis highlights the crucial role of language feedback in
the success of SRT, suggesting potential for further exploration in this
direction.
|
[
-0.21880656480789185,
-0.4298225939273834,
0.3353651463985443,
-0.007806479465216398,
-0.32693660259246826,
0.09645527601242065,
-0.49494293332099915,
-0.22793859243392944,
-0.0003370179038029164,
0.48110339045524597,
-0.7851176261901855,
-0.20165280997753143,
-0.35554268956184387,
0.012749909423291683,
0.014985310845077038,
1.3428118228912354,
0.049158886075019836,
0.11249395459890366,
0.13819800317287445,
-0.044153328984975815,
-0.6365531086921692,
-0.399813175201416,
-0.7999457716941833,
-0.5343762636184692,
0.7107514142990112,
0.63264000415802,
0.5668596029281616,
0.9209224581718445,
0.5246204733848572,
0.26848188042640686,
0.38554146885871887,
0.3071158528327942,
-0.6753794550895691,
0.31869813799858093,
-0.40475189685821533,
-0.40151146054267883,
-0.20981334149837494,
0.1612762212753296,
0.556228756904602,
0.19413478672504425,
-0.5389835238456726,
0.27108946442604065,
0.2817344665527344,
0.8439843058586121,
-0.38188526034355164,
0.11397527903318405,
-0.686102032661438,
-0.19755122065544128,
-0.2561454176902771,
-0.33474764227867126,
-0.4119207561016083,
-0.43086278438568115,
-0.03180621936917305,
-0.4927517771720886,
0.3577280342578888,
-0.06444521248340607,
0.9920029640197754,
0.6552943587303162,
-0.19848375022411346,
-0.20555628836154938,
-0.6117984056472778,
0.7259023189544678,
-0.9371196031570435,
0.42421841621398926,
0.176537424325943,
0.2665075361728668,
-0.19750681519508362,
-0.5008419156074524,
-0.28068166971206665,
-0.4634305536746979,
-0.0582970529794693,
0.20701593160629272,
0.15588481724262238,
-0.10818234831094742,
-0.04405008256435394,
0.26897135376930237,
-0.5079308748245239,
0.36153677105903625,
-0.38628360629081726,
-0.16900420188903809,
0.6495662331581116,
-0.07094177603721619,
0.04940129816532135,
-0.05087001621723175,
-0.19247734546661377,
-0.14834633469581604,
-0.804326057434082,
0.013765919953584671,
0.506171464920044,
0.6469110250473022,
0.009496522136032581,
0.3797389268875122,
-0.13474056124687195,
0.6381572484970093,
0.45800673961639404,
-0.1859908401966095,
-0.013830441981554031,
-0.24719738960266113,
-0.11017349362373352,
-0.1514931619167328,
0.7226295471191406,
0.34602439403533936,
0.3607695698738098,
-0.1338222175836563,
-0.3825073838233948,
0.06259278208017349,
0.5560683608055115,
-0.667243242263794,
-0.372729629278183,
-0.24457624554634094,
-0.2180720865726471,
-0.40443986654281616,
-0.11705818772315979,
-0.6270899176597595,
-0.10276828706264496,
-0.5926623344421387,
0.4506720304489136,
-0.3641558289527893,
-0.25927820801734924,
0.02313990890979767,
0.2618013620376587,
0.2516850233078003,
0.35676488280296326,
-1.2202726602554321,
0.1868942230939865,
0.5880311131477356,
0.6195396184921265,
-0.03111591376364231,
-0.3499335050582886,
-0.4851970076560974,
0.1249479427933693,
-0.416865736246109,
0.9274230599403381,
-0.3368516266345978,
-0.26872187852859497,
-0.2728614807128906,
-0.07758595049381256,
-0.03489510715007782,
-0.46296778321266174,
0.3969229757785797,
-0.4342532157897949,
0.4139021039009094,
-0.2893724739551544,
-0.5507099032402039,
0.03993525356054306,
0.17746195197105408,
-0.3838629424571991,
1.2866930961608887,
0.031732600182294846,
-0.4906236529350281,
0.24469973146915436,
-0.5737138986587524,
-0.3133307099342346,
0.0735972672700882,
-0.26537859439849854,
-0.5925512313842773,
0.3049183487892151,
0.19846630096435547,
0.19606554508209229,
-0.1569923758506775,
0.2134091705083847,
-0.21529552340507507,
-0.20045602321624756,
-0.047525323927402496,
-0.16177475452423096,
-0.006482159253209829,
0.251057893037796,
-0.6200306415557861,
0.2633694112300873,
-0.5030263662338257,
0.3580038845539093,
0.13925306499004364,
-0.498244971036911,
-0.06469572335481644,
-0.18284045159816742,
-0.28294694423675537,
0.17157313227653503,
0.15838021039962769,
-0.3162996470928192,
0.5705424547195435,
-0.47150900959968567,
0.4300859868526459,
1.0467101335525513,
-0.2633683979511261,
0.3270155191421509,
-0.3251967132091522,
0.6217884421348572,
-0.35849395394325256,
0.07395372539758682,
-0.13763119280338287,
-0.2043655663728714,
-0.9866494536399841,
0.02751409448683262,
0.5566529631614685,
0.13533520698547363,
-0.3657362461090088,
0.3513694405555725,
-0.2750110924243927,
-0.5883269906044006,
-1.0280163288116455,
0.4771767556667328,
0.4944645166397095,
0.7956556081771851,
0.3941609263420105,
-0.32688745856285095,
-0.44397875666618347,
-1.1055394411087036,
-0.2275175154209137,
-0.21633438766002655,
0.13278518617153168,
0.15577587485313416,
0.2316526174545288,
-0.061930518597364426,
0.8841931819915771,
-0.2914014756679535,
-0.25999656319618225,
-0.2109699249267578,
0.35822391510009766,
-0.16755516827106476,
0.5975202918052673,
0.2773594260215759,
-0.25786134600639343,
-0.4911850392818451,
0.1530761420726776,
-0.4525080621242523,
-0.4212418496608734,
0.09368786960840225,
-0.164734348654747,
0.42196664214134216,
0.4242865741252899,
-0.1825788915157318,
0.16172204911708832,
0.7252939939498901,
-0.20536474883556366,
0.5789975523948669,
-0.3351825177669525,
0.13160617649555206,
-0.8719528913497925,
0.026166701689362526,
-0.0412360243499279,
-0.37775713205337524,
-0.3721972703933716,
0.09057088941335678,
0.2865239679813385,
0.2748330533504486,
-0.08636952936649323,
0.48628342151641846,
-0.3813832104206085,
0.10774490237236023,
-0.6266821622848511,
0.259353369474411,
0.029228098690509796,
0.5031638145446777,
0.15205711126327515,
0.8844650983810425,
0.08814524114131927,
-0.4636540710926056,
0.2181168645620346,
-0.06413569301366806,
-0.25951117277145386,
0.289707750082016,
-0.6309211254119873,
0.4213952422142029,
-0.18048201501369476,
0.2537457346916199,
-0.9362099170684814,
-0.08719561249017715,
0.08322222530841827,
-0.4708922803401947,
0.48116156458854675,
-0.3971385657787323,
-0.20215950906276703,
-0.14326070249080658,
-0.03181849420070648,
0.14623157680034637,
0.4945876896381378,
-0.5484897494316101,
0.5090222358703613,
0.1972847878932953,
-0.2181950807571411,
-0.7170742750167847,
-0.4419485926628113,
-0.10896974056959152,
-0.08642886579036713,
-0.5056419372558594,
0.1693558543920517,
-0.10714593529701233,
0.12427461892366409,
-0.14786814153194427,
-0.2663772404193878,
0.4029051959514618,
0.06705304235219955,
0.06306546181440353,
0.15062296390533447,
-0.13105855882167816,
0.500012218952179,
-0.14590607583522797,
-0.368133008480072,
-0.2695764899253845,
-0.4908991754055023,
0.6571269035339355,
-0.4370085299015045,
-0.4233734905719757,
-0.5437755584716797,
-0.05009514093399048,
0.35258400440216064,
-0.4665025770664215,
0.46442610025405884,
0.5077531337738037,
0.10475266724824905,
-0.28109118342399597,
-0.8400056958198547,
-0.46250423789024353,
-0.4815421998500824,
0.358597069978714,
-0.498201459646225,
-1.0776638984680176,
0.3196641504764557,
-0.02529904618859291,
0.21094782650470734,
0.5155532956123352,
0.7767935991287231,
-0.1898764967918396,
1.0933592319488525,
0.7836849093437195,
-0.0938485786318779,
0.5336711406707764,
-0.25535210967063904,
0.09147860109806061,
-0.9080586433410645,
-0.20723497867584229,
-0.5216744542121887,
-0.358087956905365,
-0.5522760152816772,
-0.2119985818862915,
-0.06819222867488861,
0.13514871895313263,
-0.38640475273132324,
0.3726232945919037,
-0.6599725484848022,
0.5443478226661682,
0.6297815442085266,
0.08584289252758026,
0.2385094314813614,
-0.14984413981437683,
-0.23759886622428894,
-0.37436848878860474,
-0.6590145230293274,
-0.5911614298820496,
0.9588066339492798,
0.4879642128944397,
1.1731029748916626,
0.2286238968372345,
0.8586480617523193,
0.11653488129377365,
0.8704257607460022,
-0.668181836605072,
0.17454732954502106,
-0.036600708961486816,
-0.4879263937473297,
-0.41116732358932495,
-0.589072048664093,
-0.8346207141876221,
0.3184954524040222,
0.13119730353355408,
-0.4178069829940796,
-0.10366197675466537,
0.5198715925216675,
-0.49753516912460327,
0.05708002671599388,
-0.8168700337409973,
1.0084724426269531,
-0.6232234835624695,
-0.5112652778625488,
-0.36082926392555237,
-0.4678816795349121,
0.22286324203014374,
-0.03661895543336868,
0.19995728135108948,
-0.36373424530029297,
-0.003149345749989152,
0.5603868961334229,
-0.4049646556377411,
0.8947585225105286,
-0.0768948569893837,
-0.3883199095726013,
0.037611592561006546,
0.3557976484298706,
0.5709192752838135,
0.049986064434051514,
-0.12904316186904907,
-0.24708333611488342,
-0.007980825379490852,
-0.31824302673339844,
-0.8557671308517456,
0.8783321976661682,
-0.9225073456764221,
-0.8447742462158203,
-0.2727029025554657,
-0.3729103207588196,
-0.24348197877407074,
0.1772661656141281,
0.18075746297836304,
0.3082480728626251,
0.07620888203382492,
0.06544892489910126,
0.3763580918312073,
0.13330380618572235,
0.18610139191150665,
0.8811148405075073,
-0.43584564328193665,
-0.4224863350391388,
0.7735255360603333,
0.05435890331864357,
0.6168221235275269,
0.12187647074460983,
0.4265842139720917,
-0.631557285785675,
-0.2996959686279297,
-0.5179402828216553,
0.49806854128837585,
-0.7242960333824158,
-0.5245559811592102,
-0.23072506487369537,
-0.08175940811634064,
-0.6337682008743286,
-0.003340083407238126,
-0.6491973400115967,
-0.34418293833732605,
-0.01388748548924923,
-0.19744855165481567,
0.2563115656375885,
0.9003220796585083,
-0.280251145362854,
0.5142641663551331,
-0.5120575428009033,
-0.020632190629839897,
0.4511715769767761,
0.609889805316925,
0.07644525170326233,
-0.9987528920173645,
-0.34951329231262207,
0.1511603593826294,
-0.3360290825366974,
-0.61750328540802,
0.45952969789505005,
0.3473469018936157,
0.4783609211444855,
0.18273790180683136,
-0.24738681316375732,
1.0114918947219849,
-0.41759181022644043,
0.49843651056289673,
0.07469460368156433,
-0.8494002223014832,
0.8479036688804626,
-0.3748313784599304,
0.5289943814277649,
0.7764284610748291,
0.027349410578608513,
-0.7791087031364441,
-0.3604942262172699,
-0.5421972870826721,
-0.5730825066566467,
0.7634615898132324,
-0.017511483281850815,
0.08951741456985474,
0.0011410006554797292,
0.7894750237464905,
0.034798622131347656,
0.11993387341499329,
-1.1940242052078247,
-0.06509556621313095,
-0.3972257077693939,
-0.39211273193359375,
0.040635496377944946,
-0.13545911014080048,
-0.09539828449487686,
-0.23266449570655823,
1.1784310340881348,
-0.4588510990142822,
-0.22877910733222961,
0.11303965002298355,
-0.08350115269422531,
-0.49733689427375793,
0.16743625700473785,
0.5368688702583313,
0.5452587008476257,
-0.0478261299431324,
0.18482625484466553,
0.09377464652061462,
-0.051712021231651306,
0.2236461639404297,
-0.1752900630235672,
-0.211404949426651,
-0.2916603684425354,
0.25590503215789795,
0.7186634540557861,
0.4172377288341522,
-0.43218567967414856,
0.1760912537574768,
-0.234541118144989,
0.0800386518239975,
-0.029211504384875298,
0.19386549293994904,
0.12601153552532196,
0.061425309628248215,
0.14879529178142548,
-0.07776786386966705,
-0.19696658849716187,
-0.446461021900177,
0.29091331362724304,
0.5355048179626465,
-0.5606364011764526,
-0.2967386841773987,
0.4838096499443054,
0.31869378685951233,
-0.33588331937789917,
0.6623173356056213,
-0.018174264580011368,
-0.5410740971565247,
0.36960846185684204,
0.7302191853523254,
0.7017942667007446,
-0.6534590721130371,
0.10895385593175888,
0.5825027823448181,
0.42933306097984314,
-0.2860606908798218,
-0.03583090752363205,
0.034614186733961105,
-0.7813246846199036,
-0.699578046798706,
-0.8438957929611206,
-0.31729114055633545,
0.3011994957923889,
-0.6120842695236206,
0.34711068868637085,
-0.45571550726890564,
-0.2533026933670044,
0.0020524910651147366,
0.07403045147657394,
-0.4529370665550232,
0.18822945654392242,
-0.0004466695827431977,
0.6412450671195984,
-0.6226616501808167,
1.012695074081421,
0.5678649544715881,
-0.49733757972717285,
-1.1285443305969238,
-0.1097550019621849,
0.03884877637028694,
-1.1040672063827515,
0.8016424179077148,
0.2348874807357788,
-0.37671971321105957,
0.3023308515548706,
-0.546328604221344,
-1.2023091316223145,
0.7849751710891724,
0.554677426815033,
-0.8368279337882996,
0.05126619338989258,
-0.03454522415995598,
0.6560761332511902,
-0.4417993724346161,
0.2865537703037262,
0.5703659057617188,
0.4633542001247406,
0.0688057690858841,
-1.0269631147384644,
-0.11144272238016129,
-0.15417256951332092,
0.10960079729557037,
0.37544751167297363,
-0.9394142627716064,
0.43047499656677246,
-0.30524566769599915,
-0.274975448846817,
-0.006055167410522699,
0.7585663199424744,
0.27164432406425476,
-0.4347877502441406,
0.5220013856887817,
0.8298950791358948,
0.6042762994766235,
-0.17925865948200226,
0.8742103576660156,
-0.4016034007072449,
0.5917293429374695,
1.5071234703063965,
-0.12364854663610458,
0.7700803279876709,
0.3375169038772583,
0.08151119202375412,
0.6810782551765442,
0.712256669998169,
-0.051155444234609604,
0.5455054640769958,
0.34239858388900757,
-0.03229241073131561,
-0.6145334839820862,
0.07366146147251129,
-0.3901154696941376,
0.4857079088687897,
0.13593092560768127,
-0.1905064731836319,
-0.32743334770202637,
-0.24278366565704346,
0.019046304747462273,
0.272921621799469,
-0.10983868688344955,
0.879628598690033,
0.022945204749703407,
-1.0739251375198364,
0.5406200885772705,
0.08081953227519989,
0.5753717422485352,
-0.8053249716758728,
-0.02609243616461754,
-0.3906517028808594,
0.44248807430267334,
-0.1914917230606079,
-0.5370355844497681,
0.15789830684661865,
-0.0790361613035202,
-0.17532989382743835,
-0.24690364301204681,
0.42477133870124817,
-0.6980650424957275,
-0.5219006538391113,
0.3573242723941803,
0.15183709561824799,
-0.17408469319343567,
0.1585334986448288,
-0.795218288898468,
0.136119082570076,
0.16515876352787018,
-0.2258531004190445,
0.3619297444820404,
0.20440660417079926,
0.06276564300060272,
1.0234110355377197,
0.607949435710907,
0.10783877223730087,
-0.11447251588106155,
0.3847375810146332,
0.676771342754364,
-0.5994770526885986,
-0.38335466384887695,
-0.9506015777587891,
0.4306730329990387,
0.04843764752149582,
-0.31713539361953735,
0.7846759557723999,
0.5391930937767029,
0.9599312543869019,
0.07692286372184753,
0.8655018210411072,
0.10771273821592331,
0.7719296813011169,
-0.4304724335670471,
0.4772535562515259,
-0.466594398021698,
0.3201501965522766,
0.17307564616203308,
-0.7200051546096802,
-0.06847889721393585,
0.8073229193687439,
-0.360925555229187,
0.24179629981517792,
0.41016167402267456,
0.9310139417648315,
0.019255395978689194,
-0.21368232369422913,
0.20489221811294556,
0.1793954074382782,
0.487834632396698,
0.19133754074573517,
0.7840725183486938,
-0.31897449493408203,
0.5151384472846985,
-0.3826085329055786,
-0.36071300506591797,
-0.16984480619430542,
-0.8809623122215271,
-0.6061410903930664,
-0.38638603687286377,
-0.3711945712566376,
-0.4080647826194763,
0.23277714848518372,
1.0772672891616821,
0.9615339040756226,
-0.8002831935882568,
-0.4617677330970764,
0.03970460221171379,
-0.06384450197219849,
-0.1349048614501953,
-0.24139049649238586,
0.2742806375026703,
-1.0558216571807861,
-0.5830620527267456,
0.4182649552822113,
0.35074323415756226,
0.08118261396884918,
-0.4149753153324127,
-0.284736692905426,
-0.0387142114341259,
0.027320995926856995,
0.25154951214790344,
0.39428994059562683,
-1.000401258468628,
-0.5239285826683044,
-0.009121808223426342,
-0.1844463050365448,
0.1511012315750122,
0.8273558616638184,
-0.8338611721992493,
0.5000482201576233,
0.012674405239522457,
0.4842851459980011,
0.5927903652191162,
0.29739910364151,
0.8908393383026123,
-0.8765916228294373,
-0.15429691970348358,
0.10694820433855057,
0.333675354719162,
0.5417500138282776,
-0.302765429019928,
0.5989631414413452,
0.06615078449249268,
-0.8557094931602478,
-0.6674306392669678,
0.36865609884262085,
-0.5804510116577148,
-0.05569649487733841,
0.9412106275558472,
0.04480333626270294,
-0.053218137472867966,
0.1752055436372757,
-0.38189685344696045,
0.26401668787002563,
-0.45861467719078064,
1.2862634658813477,
0.6383928060531616,
-0.2793348729610443,
-0.4534416198730469,
-0.26090896129608154,
0.7654409408569336,
0.6422224044799805,
-0.6955295205116272,
0.48136278986930847,
0.3644682765007019,
0.5837095379829407,
0.056889697909355164,
0.677483320236206,
-0.14259250462055206,
0.15578074753284454,
-0.5780609250068665,
0.37482938170433044,
-0.005797514691948891,
-0.22202257812023163,
-0.4646326005458832,
-0.18157199025154114,
0.4928602874279022,
0.3002307415008545
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07162v1
|
EmoBox: Multilingual Multi-corpus Speech Emotion Recognition Toolkit and Benchmark
| 2024-06-11T11:12:51 | 2024-06-11T11:12:51 |
Ziyang Ma, Mingjie Chen, Hezhao Zhang, Zhisheng Zheng, Wenxi Chen, Xiquan Li, Jiaxin Ye, Xie Chen, Thomas Hain
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MM, eess.AS
|
Speech emotion recognition (SER) is an important part of human-computer
interaction, receiving extensive attention from both industry and academia.
However, the current research field of SER has long suffered from the following
problems: 1) There are few reasonable and universal splits of the datasets,
making comparing different models and methods difficult. 2) No commonly used
benchmark covers numerous corpus and languages for researchers to refer to,
making reproduction a burden. In this paper, we propose EmoBox, an
out-of-the-box multilingual multi-corpus speech emotion recognition toolkit,
along with a benchmark for both intra-corpus and cross-corpus settings. For
intra-corpus settings, we carefully designed the data partitioning for
different datasets. For cross-corpus settings, we employ a foundation SER
model, emotion2vec, to mitigate annotation errors and obtain a test set that is
fully balanced in speakers and emotions distributions. Based on EmoBox, we
present the intra-corpus SER results of 10 pre-trained speech models on 32
emotion datasets with 14 languages, and the cross-corpus SER results on 4
datasets with the fully balanced test sets. To the best of our knowledge, this
is the largest SER benchmark, across language scopes and quantity scales. We
hope that our toolkit and benchmark can facilitate the research of SER in the
community.
|
[
-0.518964946269989,
-0.33727896213531494,
0.07065319269895554,
0.3223433494567871,
-0.21392662823200226,
0.10670148581266403,
-0.1148882508277893,
-0.49102261662483215,
0.2880411744117737,
0.06729553639888763,
-0.3028492033481598,
-0.48496362566947937,
-0.3978102505207062,
0.34021642804145813,
-0.3063470423221588,
0.6093189716339111,
-0.09511015564203262,
0.22460860013961792,
-0.1562456637620926,
-0.5786296725273132,
-0.08512411266565323,
-0.6086273193359375,
-0.5398826599121094,
-0.18095336854457855,
0.5578208565711975,
0.3476007282733917,
0.3271320164203644,
-0.002827264368534088,
0.13125449419021606,
0.2250041514635086,
-0.09331343322992325,
0.10965686291456223,
-0.19605866074562073,
0.3864792585372925,
0.14897920191287994,
-0.32640835642814636,
-0.2544294595718384,
-0.3699946105480194,
0.6488007307052612,
0.31050634384155273,
-0.19700953364372253,
-0.099555604159832,
-0.21640995144844055,
0.53535395860672,
-0.7994667887687683,
-0.11288812011480331,
-0.33693066239356995,
0.40343600511550903,
-0.16868485510349274,
0.07430947571992874,
-0.16849598288536072,
-0.310619056224823,
0.10406848788261414,
-0.08662407100200653,
-0.17448794841766357,
0.24893243610858917,
0.3202628493309021,
0.27587220072746277,
-0.5335797071456909,
-0.19627925753593445,
-0.21305914223194122,
0.6336493492126465,
-0.8204264044761658,
0.87540203332901,
0.3666885793209076,
0.23681573569774628,
0.19704937934875488,
-0.32000553607940674,
-0.3858177661895752,
-0.05258755758404732,
0.29792293906211853,
0.43984806537628174,
-0.39493897557258606,
-0.17144672572612762,
0.2199542224407196,
0.05934678390622139,
-0.6668434143066406,
0.16329693794250488,
-0.01713499054312706,
-0.30502375960350037,
0.43319591879844666,
0.03526778146624565,
0.3357682228088379,
0.14605601131916046,
-0.06684763729572296,
-0.2922903299331665,
-0.4725632965564728,
0.23952651023864746,
0.482230007648468,
0.293911337852478,
-0.2756190299987793,
0.3281724750995636,
-0.1562282145023346,
0.3105716407299042,
-0.4641290307044983,
0.12057491391897202,
0.7758720517158508,
0.19619649648666382,
-0.07006596773862839,
0.46194568276405334,
0.7592647075653076,
0.33168429136276245,
0.12290912121534348,
-0.14073683321475983,
-0.16631215810775757,
0.1906832903623581,
0.30680182576179504,
-0.8257260918617249,
0.12984804809093475,
0.6615315079689026,
-0.32706418633461,
0.10595465451478958,
-0.40820834040641785,
-1.4207336902618408,
-0.660882294178009,
-0.22374390065670013,
0.24607276916503906,
-0.3107437491416931,
-0.5750550031661987,
-0.22145940363407135,
-0.012388319708406925,
-0.08549875766038895,
0.2229904979467392,
-0.5634080171585083,
0.3294714391231537,
0.6391071677207947,
0.8649688959121704,
-0.04225089028477669,
-0.20544826984405518,
-0.7157114148139954,
-0.3251703083515167,
-0.11495678126811981,
0.6202302575111389,
-0.7638520002365112,
-0.4567491412162781,
0.39228004217147827,
0.07864606380462646,
0.1903975009918213,
-0.44358721375465393,
0.6559619903564453,
-0.07167672365903854,
-0.06380001455545425,
-0.08601254969835281,
-0.6319658160209656,
-0.14464323222637177,
0.20920823514461517,
-0.5765040516853333,
1.0032330751419067,
-0.17867113649845123,
-0.6434463858604431,
-0.01049674954265356,
-0.4337863028049469,
-0.4358671009540558,
-0.12703897058963776,
-0.13334333896636963,
-0.5753916501998901,
0.447091668844223,
-0.009743532165884972,
0.20955771207809448,
-0.5122156143188477,
-0.22199223935604095,
-0.7310730218887329,
-0.03894943743944168,
0.45537325739860535,
-0.2744238078594208,
0.5130775570869446,
0.39145711064338684,
-0.35357198119163513,
-0.15328161418437958,
-1.1546434164047241,
0.1958991140127182,
-0.21129581332206726,
0.19150173664093018,
-0.5184268355369568,
0.04181886091828346,
0.38271382451057434,
0.38511893153190613,
-0.021930193528532982,
-1.092850923538208,
-0.217439666390419,
-0.2942730784416199,
0.31466004252433777,
0.28261512517929077,
-0.45882448554039,
0.037402402609586716,
0.12002657353878021,
0.738176703453064,
0.0074585615657269955,
0.10843583196401596,
-0.15807503461837769,
-0.4103623628616333,
-0.46997180581092834,
-0.3795919418334961,
0.15078148245811462,
0.5100163817405701,
-0.06698577105998993,
0.2844165861606598,
0.17630301415920258,
-0.6893236637115479,
-1.1151129007339478,
-0.2368595004081726,
0.5840030908584595,
0.4289844036102295,
0.3762322962284088,
-0.20443323254585266,
-0.5070577263832092,
-0.720669686794281,
-0.10426030308008194,
0.014965582638978958,
0.12844805419445038,
0.5699758529663086,
0.2568063735961914,
-0.5451165437698364,
0.8488205075263977,
-0.03659149631857872,
-0.02573120780289173,
0.24632248282432556,
0.658708930015564,
-0.15667927265167236,
0.35471320152282715,
0.5251774787902832,
-0.923114538192749,
-0.4386961758136749,
0.2826354503631592,
-0.5606465935707092,
-0.6086731553077698,
0.3504904806613922,
-0.11956672370433807,
0.45396023988723755,
0.01204169075936079,
0.010260731913149357,
0.5615820288658142,
0.7984365820884705,
-0.05765152722597122,
0.33600670099258423,
-0.08626294881105423,
0.41488248109817505,
-1.0863280296325684,
0.1372136026620865,
-0.19253414869308472,
-0.12464798241853714,
-0.6178917288780212,
-0.5030645132064819,
0.4207655191421509,
-0.44244134426116943,
-0.5878241658210754,
0.7046305537223816,
-0.15705260634422302,
-0.4589853286743164,
-0.3421190083026886,
0.1219729408621788,
-0.07148079574108124,
0.3522237539291382,
0.2502180337905884,
0.45124250650405884,
0.5922996997833252,
-0.4246616065502167,
0.7605469226837158,
0.38526007533073425,
-0.13100522756576538,
1.0182716846466064,
-0.5720113515853882,
0.2746563255786896,
0.12416421622037888,
-0.03380300849676132,
-1.003843903541565,
-0.058557767421007156,
-0.13959293067455292,
-0.49169212579727173,
0.08101795613765717,
0.015914298593997955,
-0.43941500782966614,
-0.13772423565387726,
-0.19236977398395538,
0.5540350675582886,
0.6382637619972229,
-0.7257044315338135,
0.9629800915718079,
0.5296277403831482,
-0.4972020983695984,
-0.6373283863067627,
-0.839963436126709,
-0.06873886287212372,
-0.3552688956260681,
-0.603959858417511,
0.14866545796394348,
-0.2104393094778061,
-0.09644889086484909,
-0.12639878690242767,
-0.027031857520341873,
-0.17238731682300568,
-0.14922162890434265,
0.6282092928886414,
-0.261860728263855,
0.11961851269006729,
0.4881531298160553,
0.17292937636375427,
0.024535808712244034,
-0.0463416650891304,
0.3774791359901428,
0.3264519274234772,
-0.28655514121055603,
-0.22898072004318237,
-0.23912666738033295,
0.6646313071250916,
0.6300026178359985,
-0.4352123439311981,
0.4543897211551666,
0.8633751273155212,
-0.39340347051620483,
-0.29090243577957153,
-0.6431236267089844,
0.2020920068025589,
-0.3271345794200897,
0.3881935179233551,
-0.6678835153579712,
-0.7811107039451599,
0.864748477935791,
-0.49209484457969666,
0.043647848069667816,
0.02476666495203972,
0.6977578401565552,
-0.08165077120065689,
1.1492940187454224,
0.37243393063545227,
-0.17155420780181885,
0.5026858448982239,
0.35429513454437256,
0.03547724708914757,
-1.0165603160858154,
-0.08950363844633102,
-0.872245728969574,
-0.19327138364315033,
-0.5115397572517395,
0.13789312541484833,
0.4363083243370056,
-0.23589274287223816,
-0.1990307718515396,
0.0889473557472229,
-0.3158392608165741,
-0.07631806284189224,
0.5157228112220764,
-0.13166067004203796,
-0.2599565386772156,
0.08332695066928864,
-0.2377074658870697,
-0.10671387612819672,
-0.2641221582889557,
-0.19329483807086945,
0.9804002046585083,
0.16647270321846008,
0.8710080981254578,
0.13777650892734528,
0.8374431133270264,
0.28519487380981445,
0.11944779008626938,
-0.6185880899429321,
0.17304560542106628,
-0.12604141235351562,
-0.5061647891998291,
-0.09652779996395111,
-0.5588372349739075,
-0.907260000705719,
0.34281444549560547,
-0.048417653888463974,
-0.886420488357544,
0.41712120175361633,
0.08895030617713928,
-0.3201017379760742,
0.05531226471066475,
-0.6886173486709595,
1.0739439725875854,
-0.5402741432189941,
-0.5025985240936279,
-0.24484385550022125,
-0.750808596611023,
-0.16453267633914948,
-0.3313606381416321,
0.48700112104415894,
-0.38809284567832947,
-0.04985827952623367,
0.7249574661254883,
-0.42759275436401367,
0.5718534588813782,
-0.08647680282592773,
-0.11390858888626099,
0.1387140303850174,
0.029246468096971512,
0.3397045433521271,
-0.04304930940270424,
-0.4518280625343323,
0.19239592552185059,
0.267554372549057,
-0.15682442486286163,
-0.4532144069671631,
0.4421222507953644,
-0.9121867418289185,
0.1447674185037613,
-0.5337478518486023,
-0.3619201183319092,
-0.4548798203468323,
-0.007042813114821911,
0.25898557901382446,
0.7458765506744385,
-0.4430481493473053,
0.42176949977874756,
0.36099597811698914,
-0.6402219533920288,
0.25489869713783264,
0.9038413166999817,
-0.19555258750915527,
-0.8971897959709167,
0.8507981300354004,
-0.019611703231930733,
0.20015566051006317,
0.45386388897895813,
0.20676490664482117,
-0.576543390750885,
0.0778372660279274,
-0.22857828438282013,
-0.013592823408544064,
-0.612902045249939,
-0.2740899622440338,
-0.6419516205787659,
0.24546726047992706,
-0.7298054695129395,
-0.1279352605342865,
-0.6824859380722046,
-0.07195840030908585,
-0.033279839903116226,
0.13174082338809967,
0.5436630249023438,
0.17629383504390717,
-0.4733237326145172,
0.15442244708538055,
-1.0206782817840576,
0.33996081352233887,
0.21760596334934235,
0.355284184217453,
-0.23211020231246948,
-0.45615559816360474,
-0.23663222789764404,
0.06967964768409729,
0.002538790227845311,
-1.0479943752288818,
0.7170666456222534,
0.3980724513530731,
0.3914830982685089,
0.5596840381622314,
0.344913125038147,
0.4971208870410919,
-0.580734133720398,
0.4644339084625244,
0.3192956745624542,
-1.295778512954712,
0.6292252540588379,
0.036621227860450745,
0.16743598878383636,
0.4725683033466339,
0.458528071641922,
-0.9403665661811829,
-0.1949443370103836,
-0.553378701210022,
-0.8731664419174194,
0.7094653844833374,
0.19391565024852753,
-0.18372072279453278,
0.2844521999359131,
-0.059470340609550476,
0.37755584716796875,
0.5261839032173157,
-0.5099886059761047,
-0.04559271037578583,
-0.3156617283821106,
-0.6979371309280396,
-0.10145214945077896,
-0.3130747079849243,
-0.2030690461397171,
0.08762303739786148,
0.6160134077072144,
0.016548315063118935,
0.41161802411079407,
0.031362876296043396,
-0.17474153637886047,
-0.1718241274356842,
0.5636733770370483,
0.23104971647262573,
0.07302720099687576,
-0.5983830690383911,
0.231184184551239,
0.1140461415052414,
-0.22069589793682098,
0.24764589965343475,
0.3324774205684662,
0.1640763133764267,
0.05712256580591202,
0.09341124445199966,
1.0398752689361572,
0.40663865208625793,
-1.176858901977539,
0.25207558274269104,
-0.09195700287818909,
0.1457187384366989,
-0.2878565192222595,
-0.3074522316455841,
-0.046364981681108475,
0.4766051769256592,
0.06386791169643402,
-0.28450295329093933,
0.43986180424690247,
-0.6452739834785461,
0.09940526634454727,
0.10423040390014648,
-0.3186545670032501,
-0.3117625117301941,
0.3614114224910736,
0.4779846668243408,
-0.4774370491504669,
0.5221049189567566,
-0.3713560104370117,
-0.7493313550949097,
0.7706013321876526,
0.5200424194335938,
1.0990058183670044,
-0.5380173921585083,
0.17756925523281097,
0.2957310676574707,
0.11342403292655945,
-0.026830235496163368,
0.5601323246955872,
-0.10485897213220596,
-0.7049805521965027,
0.17992986738681793,
-0.5748687982559204,
-1.0637151002883911,
-0.3855942487716675,
-0.9140745997428894,
0.10129830241203308,
-0.0751977264881134,
-0.2987951934337616,
-0.14541618525981903,
0.012958768755197525,
-0.611480712890625,
0.3824065327644348,
0.6910648345947266,
0.43996676802635193,
-0.7554422616958618,
0.666365921497345,
0.7856820821762085,
-0.17614048719406128,
-0.354846328496933,
-0.5379747152328491,
0.2774307131767273,
-0.6489556431770325,
0.44625574350357056,
0.45833295583724976,
-0.29579293727874756,
-0.06184273958206177,
-0.24562308192253113,
-0.606140673160553,
0.692129909992218,
0.3023342490196228,
-0.7690857648849487,
0.7306363582611084,
0.19719579815864563,
0.6733883619308472,
-0.47763070464134216,
0.6835548281669617,
0.45958876609802246,
0.38362106680870056,
-0.06399857997894287,
-0.9312188029289246,
-0.22298158705234528,
-0.5419304370880127,
-0.24369379878044128,
0.29966649413108826,
-0.8352609872817993,
0.7630168199539185,
0.24597793817520142,
-0.07408171147108078,
-0.027559718117117882,
0.3227112293243408,
0.2524692714214325,
0.6940277814865112,
0.586798369884491,
0.7386022806167603,
0.8503575325012207,
-0.16291865706443787,
0.6608337163925171,
-0.2896149158477783,
0.19332532584667206,
1.055525302886963,
-0.9713628888130188,
1.1117724180221558,
0.04547400400042534,
-0.42179301381111145,
0.2875691056251526,
0.7287342548370361,
-0.12350259721279144,
0.5290575623512268,
0.15645954012870789,
-0.2476576566696167,
-0.029373550787568092,
-0.4912831783294678,
-0.6695367097854614,
0.2965080142021179,
0.4362088441848755,
0.10817449539899826,
0.13066966831684113,
0.4699289798736572,
-0.118617482483387,
-0.3346659243106842,
-0.27727168798446655,
0.7006219625473022,
0.22160737216472626,
-0.21880750358104706,
0.34275975823402405,
-0.4107920527458191,
0.6879042983055115,
-0.7299528121948242,
0.3459005057811737,
-0.23929698765277863,
0.24645207822322845,
-0.28911346197128296,
-0.49867379665374756,
0.09315897524356842,
0.4196881353855133,
0.1466967761516571,
-0.03936142101883888,
0.4573698341846466,
-0.785693883895874,
-0.4139133095741272,
0.911967396736145,
0.14511021971702576,
0.5840732455253601,
-0.4089418947696686,
-0.7276659607887268,
0.5920965671539307,
-0.19753412902355194,
-0.19876903295516968,
0.2381996512413025,
0.8561930656433105,
0.4320898950099945,
0.5965802073478699,
0.13590870797634125,
0.022521577775478363,
0.31744661927223206,
0.4822447597980499,
0.40060529112815857,
-0.7478153705596924,
-0.6775094270706177,
-0.5309066772460938,
0.5463405251502991,
-0.11123568564653397,
-0.5580480098724365,
0.5551672577857971,
0.5637912154197693,
0.550233006477356,
0.039355017244815826,
0.8141096234321594,
-0.030233263969421387,
0.7107146978378296,
-0.11620151996612549,
0.3078864812850952,
-1.1939001083374023,
-0.5263769030570984,
-0.6712475419044495,
-0.6496757864952087,
-0.0677667185664177,
0.49409398436546326,
0.07719303667545319,
-0.09866897761821747,
0.720924437046051,
0.6430971026420593,
0.2944214344024658,
0.3446328938007355,
0.42756888270378113,
0.20333826541900635,
0.199821338057518,
0.7531034350395203,
0.7957983613014221,
-0.41144853830337524,
0.4806671738624573,
-0.47069478034973145,
-0.22792166471481323,
-0.5487837791442871,
-0.8222479224205017,
-0.6824721097946167,
-0.5371198058128357,
-0.5369934439659119,
-0.1723647266626358,
0.09716319292783737,
1.1284613609313965,
0.5927858352661133,
-0.9449859857559204,
-0.35544097423553467,
0.17243285477161407,
-0.15290042757987976,
-0.23562927544116974,
-0.07788962870836258,
0.24217692017555237,
-0.2656276226043701,
-0.9295110106468201,
0.28745126724243164,
0.4593546986579895,
0.07908181101083755,
0.14349433779716492,
-0.25588172674179077,
-0.04775301739573479,
-0.08370755612850189,
0.48470544815063477,
0.5547208189964294,
-0.5955795645713806,
0.011664923280477524,
-0.2802298069000244,
0.10324003547430038,
0.020032720640301704,
0.49516186118125916,
-0.36518594622612,
1.0203557014465332,
0.5334010124206543,
1.0407217741012573,
0.37681296467781067,
-0.21234595775604248,
0.6159659624099731,
-0.7259661555290222,
0.39787113666534424,
0.3720347285270691,
0.6197860240936279,
0.39435967803001404,
-0.08499112725257874,
0.8080034852027893,
-0.05582747608423233,
-0.661707878112793,
-1.1257524490356445,
0.02268166095018387,
-1.1068435907363892,
0.06132815033197403,
0.9486539363861084,
-0.3507680594921112,
-0.10653143376111984,
0.20681478083133698,
-0.282787948846817,
0.5889256000518799,
-0.7291228175163269,
0.6270097494125366,
0.9342798590660095,
-0.22747685015201569,
-0.2952161729335785,
-0.31096625328063965,
0.23600205779075623,
0.7708411812782288,
-1.1355432271957397,
0.1672763079404831,
0.5172386765480042,
-0.1234511062502861,
0.22153092920780182,
0.2862436771392822,
0.0247905645519495,
0.2557029128074646,
0.23656529188156128,
0.7051913738250732,
0.1965915411710739,
-0.2703447937965393,
-0.5670585632324219,
0.19050680100917816,
-0.44281014800071716,
-0.14096477627754211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07155v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07155v1
|
Scaling Large-Language-Model-based Multi-Agent Collaboration
| 2024-06-11T11:02:04 | 2024-06-11T11:02:04 |
Chen Qian, Zihao Xie, Yifei Wang, Wei Liu, Yufan Dang, Zhuoyun Du, Weize Chen, Cheng Yang, Zhiyuan Liu, Maosong Sun
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.MA, cs.NI, cs.SI
|
Pioneering advancements in large language model-powered agents have
underscored the design pattern of multi-agent collaboration, demonstrating that
collective intelligence can surpass the capabilities of each individual.
Inspired by the neural scaling law, which posits that increasing neurons leads
to emergent abilities, this study investigates whether a similar principle
applies to increasing agents in multi-agent collaboration. Technically, we
propose multi-agent collaboration networks (MacNet), which utilize directed
acyclic graphs to organize agents and streamline their interactive reasoning
via topological ordering, with solutions derived from their dialogues.
Extensive experiments show that MacNet consistently outperforms baseline
models, enabling effective agent collaboration across various network
topologies and supporting cooperation among more than a thousand agents.
Notably, we observed a small-world collaboration phenomenon, where topologies
resembling small-world properties achieved superior performance. Additionally,
we identified a collaborative scaling law, indicating that normalized solution
quality follows a logistic growth pattern as scaling agents, with collaborative
emergence occurring much earlier than previously observed instances of neural
emergence. The code and data will be available at
https://github.com/OpenBMB/ChatDev.
|
[
-0.5713303685188293,
-0.6397465467453003,
0.6810674071311951,
0.4005039930343628,
0.2956855893135071,
0.25432252883911133,
-0.3910033106803894,
-0.6440805792808533,
0.6010013222694397,
0.5770602822303772,
-0.5033677816390991,
-0.03503116965293884,
-0.6105659604072571,
-0.021524155512452126,
0.045134037733078,
0.9718407988548279,
0.595885694026947,
-0.17277586460113525,
-0.3830777108669281,
-0.3545089662075043,
-0.24087579548358917,
-0.4713796079158783,
-0.8452844023704529,
-0.5745477676391602,
0.8761011958122253,
0.579060971736908,
1.1872715950012207,
0.924083948135376,
0.792491614818573,
0.4914039373397827,
-0.19725680351257324,
0.5029149055480957,
-0.3346296548843384,
0.3184349238872528,
0.0661536157131195,
-0.1388167142868042,
-1.0297620296478271,
-0.030573830008506775,
0.5118510127067566,
0.858924925327301,
-0.43043622374534607,
-0.029739603400230408,
0.005789400078356266,
0.45299163460731506,
-0.1224789172410965,
0.25187766551971436,
-0.5750575065612793,
-0.2622844874858856,
0.2758091688156128,
-0.053503911942243576,
-0.5983115434646606,
-0.05924917384982109,
0.08794159442186356,
-0.7196304202079773,
0.06489703804254532,
0.14722974598407745,
0.43606114387512207,
0.07574311643838882,
-0.3037801682949066,
-0.24472597241401672,
-0.6071122288703918,
0.460214227437973,
-0.5729930400848389,
-0.09267981350421906,
-0.03313783183693886,
0.4160711467266083,
-0.3556627929210663,
-1.0572420358657837,
-0.48798754811286926,
-0.45028558373451233,
0.05694662034511566,
-0.11068229377269745,
-0.33587953448295593,
0.26895901560783386,
0.2845616638660431,
-0.04736074060201645,
-0.44596850872039795,
0.14563153684139252,
-0.25080257654190063,
0.04053516313433647,
0.5681592226028442,
0.16679109632968903,
0.6434915065765381,
0.42880144715309143,
-0.13400253653526306,
-0.15473084151744843,
-0.24981068074703217,
-0.025844281539320946,
0.12939730286598206,
0.7732841372489929,
-0.15127001702785492,
0.48480650782585144,
-0.09107859432697296,
0.3075794577598572,
-0.0564759187400341,
0.21429194509983063,
0.3822524845600128,
-0.6377463340759277,
0.015636395663022995,
0.00008023072587093338,
0.8262189030647278,
0.20116876065731049,
0.3975885808467865,
-0.24244274199008942,
0.0032401185017079115,
-0.1914406567811966,
0.3967793583869934,
-0.8497304320335388,
-0.47187525033950806,
-0.04901253804564476,
-0.36970940232276917,
-0.23090681433677673,
0.010881655849516392,
-0.33071455359458923,
-0.6902981400489807,
-0.2168285995721817,
0.4547431468963623,
0.03748644143342972,
-0.7795710563659668,
-0.2169104367494583,
-0.26327940821647644,
-0.07527290284633636,
0.5383490324020386,
-0.8572671413421631,
0.7168688774108887,
0.8483383655548096,
1.1574435234069824,
0.2902301549911499,
-0.825187087059021,
-0.5417373776435852,
-0.13514594733715057,
-0.4420028030872345,
0.5176441073417664,
-0.144138902425766,
0.00038959606899879873,
-0.36068761348724365,
-0.017731042578816414,
0.10818387567996979,
-0.4519210457801819,
-0.17959623038768768,
-0.37780463695526123,
-0.431618869304657,
-0.1912716031074524,
-0.013351745903491974,
0.1281728744506836,
0.34197762608528137,
-0.8677651882171631,
0.5047470331192017,
-0.2640444338321686,
-0.5102829933166504,
0.16545428335666656,
-0.9722300171852112,
-0.3744848072528839,
0.2799043357372284,
-0.1833227127790451,
-0.29946044087409973,
-0.03466721624135971,
-0.085793636739254,
0.45760777592658997,
-0.4374765455722809,
0.10778269171714783,
-0.5072253346443176,
0.0031669139862060547,
0.27885302901268005,
-0.22990447282791138,
1.013164758682251,
0.03578968718647957,
-0.18780022859573364,
0.40341466665267944,
-0.5028242468833923,
0.259722501039505,
0.14216791093349457,
-0.11033641546964645,
-0.15077131986618042,
-0.03407216817140579,
-0.3100566864013672,
0.5235032439231873,
0.3016892969608307,
-0.507426381111145,
0.37882304191589355,
-0.18273533880710602,
0.59259432554245,
0.6821860671043396,
0.16162708401679993,
0.56569904088974,
-0.5230402946472168,
0.19554628431797028,
-0.05810723081231117,
0.3257741332054138,
0.1358197033405304,
-0.8026421070098877,
-0.3930056095123291,
-0.3368670642375946,
-0.21463549137115479,
0.07291597127914429,
-0.7509050369262695,
0.14496390521526337,
-0.5580777525901794,
-0.6193283200263977,
-0.08612779527902603,
0.1611919105052948,
0.17951050400733948,
0.11079895496368408,
0.3249465227127075,
-0.4894925057888031,
-0.15995056927204132,
-0.7747186422348022,
0.2617487907409668,
-0.29369616508483887,
0.0828852578997612,
0.6385698318481445,
0.3914383351802826,
-0.2521861493587494,
0.8860815167427063,
-0.35193946957588196,
-0.045495111495256424,
-0.22304852306842804,
0.30291903018951416,
0.3212191164493561,
0.4848448932170868,
0.4676172137260437,
-0.8891722559928894,
-0.5412527322769165,
0.42739763855934143,
-0.5736633539199829,
0.1688777357339859,
0.1652543991804123,
-0.32345059514045715,
-0.09833978116512299,
0.5514537692070007,
-0.6832168102264404,
0.009469660930335522,
0.6056468486785889,
-0.4114103317260742,
0.6122754216194153,
-0.6165803670883179,
-0.05440661311149597,
-1.2904144525527954,
-0.20775191485881805,
-0.29919055104255676,
-0.055285338312387466,
-0.9093317985534668,
0.12289295345544815,
-0.18966707587242126,
-0.07260042428970337,
-0.2896292507648468,
0.14781296253204346,
-0.6210699081420898,
-0.2027653455734253,
-0.3778088688850403,
0.3517717719078064,
-0.08351292461156845,
0.5920174717903137,
-0.09377142041921616,
0.5344331860542297,
0.6760594844818115,
-0.4761451482772827,
0.5207266807556152,
-0.03283790126442909,
0.09003428369760513,
0.2957601547241211,
-0.7711994647979736,
0.2679647207260132,
0.2222311943769455,
0.2697388529777527,
-0.8047141432762146,
-0.19948481023311615,
-0.21122446656227112,
-0.6141312122344971,
0.023355701938271523,
-0.020499905571341515,
-0.9076892733573914,
-0.2746930718421936,
-0.17489396035671234,
0.6415056586265564,
0.014921247959136963,
-0.6187959313392639,
0.760524332523346,
0.32870393991470337,
0.026586923748254776,
-0.5948476195335388,
-0.6340349316596985,
0.43883994221687317,
0.1769677996635437,
-1.0307950973510742,
-0.0787225216627121,
-0.43242231011390686,
-0.5963119268417358,
-0.040759339928627014,
0.22773431241512299,
-0.3490559160709381,
0.13427811861038208,
0.3063293397426605,
-0.0018843034049496055,
-0.3729986250400543,
0.19858883321285248,
-0.11512450873851776,
0.36335769295692444,
0.1710042655467987,
-0.5091279745101929,
0.5974404811859131,
-0.5270076990127563,
0.06346609443426132,
0.006697899661958218,
0.3078865706920624,
1.1231491565704346,
-0.3691171109676361,
1.14388906955719,
0.294954389333725,
-0.2890265882015228,
-0.3581846058368683,
-0.31524375081062317,
-0.33183321356773376,
-0.506694495677948,
0.3288426399230957,
-0.2920939326286316,
-0.7582910656929016,
0.7899501919746399,
-0.21660159528255463,
0.16827912628650665,
0.29531586170196533,
0.5986678004264832,
0.2430235594511032,
1.1268699169158936,
0.7154136300086975,
0.16080328822135925,
0.48095160722732544,
-0.38520944118499756,
0.07823404669761658,
-0.8015847206115723,
-0.06708814948797226,
-0.45155835151672363,
-0.2084590196609497,
-0.9006366729736328,
-0.49070343375205994,
0.4332628846168518,
-0.2701107859611511,
-0.4331633448600769,
0.547915518283844,
-0.5229578018188477,
0.5450122356414795,
0.42197132110595703,
0.023307839408516884,
0.31681281328201294,
-0.13322119414806366,
-0.3338351249694824,
0.5325847864151001,
-0.8679844737052917,
0.022054731845855713,
0.815156877040863,
0.24409954249858856,
0.439659982919693,
0.642336905002594,
0.7194238305091858,
0.21662665903568268,
0.24804659187793732,
-0.7920897006988525,
0.5966833829879761,
0.07722064107656479,
-0.6492988467216492,
-0.8658020496368408,
-0.8188329935073853,
-1.2277143001556396,
0.4889841079711914,
-0.281955361366272,
-0.7663407921791077,
0.31551727652549744,
-0.3708840310573578,
-0.23931019008159637,
0.3658597469329834,
-0.6880492568016052,
0.6671962738037109,
0.003196695586666465,
-0.344603031873703,
-0.44139277935028076,
-0.8854288458824158,
-0.027498189359903336,
0.09150463342666626,
0.32100710272789,
-0.09275845438241959,
-0.03502412885427475,
0.49785926938056946,
-0.7487892508506775,
0.6776560544967651,
0.04482792690396309,
-0.03048521652817726,
0.5561546683311462,
0.18428754806518555,
0.4145870804786682,
0.09504111111164093,
0.10047874599695206,
0.1378738135099411,
-0.4063177704811096,
-0.4980025589466095,
-0.8617742657661438,
0.7946353554725647,
-1.03026282787323,
-0.3734056353569031,
-0.0728197917342186,
-0.9382854104042053,
-0.024951210245490074,
0.39407119154930115,
-0.12629735469818115,
0.7561460733413696,
-0.13873957097530365,
0.47285380959510803,
0.28033000230789185,
0.3288849890232086,
0.7523478269577026,
0.4653320908546448,
-0.057888470590114594,
-0.5902036428451538,
0.9217252731323242,
0.42613545060157776,
0.7602128386497498,
0.13884903490543365,
0.24961282312870026,
0.17234116792678833,
-0.38956376910209656,
-0.3192705512046814,
0.29888662695884705,
-0.4900527000427246,
-0.07228385657072067,
-0.5556321144104004,
-0.3538857698440552,
-0.4976375102996826,
-0.23789435625076294,
-0.4550849497318268,
-0.4947004020214081,
0.08013621717691422,
0.14805437624454498,
0.2240968644618988,
0.9570485353469849,
-0.3085471987724304,
0.13386107981204987,
-0.5926955938339233,
-0.12321373075246811,
0.4864179193973541,
0.2975885272026062,
0.461193710565567,
-0.049423061311244965,
-0.6670089960098267,
0.05506005138158798,
-0.2998153865337372,
-0.6687009930610657,
0.24332548677921295,
0.0003781165578402579,
0.49034830927848816,
0.2952093183994293,
0.055875975638628006,
0.18727591633796692,
-0.44469335675239563,
0.44676950573921204,
0.45546674728393555,
-0.6092665195465088,
0.20301634073257446,
-0.6734779477119446,
0.4135928452014923,
0.23556776344776154,
0.02572394721210003,
-0.524445116519928,
-0.5796681046485901,
-0.9378302097320557,
-0.8284669518470764,
0.7297778129577637,
0.48434978723526,
0.16251248121261597,
0.06860712915658951,
0.3486298620700836,
-0.35448989272117615,
0.2767527401447296,
-0.8166902661323547,
-0.31526294350624084,
0.010953436605632305,
0.06810427457094193,
-0.22105327248573303,
0.32812392711639404,
-0.20820586383342743,
-0.09253361076116562,
0.3161165118217468,
-0.4646419584751129,
0.20288996398448944,
0.15926764905452728,
0.1999543309211731,
-0.11412514746189117,
0.16742359101772308,
0.6174137592315674,
0.7979337573051453,
0.03331847861409187,
0.26932623982429504,
-0.09062539786100388,
-0.6359695196151733,
0.26936379075050354,
0.024992685765028,
0.3207595944404602,
-0.4758777320384979,
0.47316256165504456,
0.4812626242637634,
-0.32950183749198914,
-0.30038487911224365,
0.46918895840644836,
-0.38042202591896057,
-0.5340108871459961,
-0.02324727736413479,
0.15940406918525696,
0.2683260440826416,
0.720542311668396,
0.35992854833602905,
0.38742029666900635,
0.06205500662326813,
-0.8417975306510925,
0.13641837239265442,
0.38504132628440857,
-0.41978734731674194,
-0.1453585922718048,
0.11763317137956619,
0.13336986303329468,
-0.7065475583076477,
0.6391050219535828,
-0.30829063057899475,
-0.3955030143260956,
1.1947764158248901,
0.529694139957428,
0.7333758473396301,
-0.030321868136525154,
0.27190297842025757,
0.14737629890441895,
0.6808387041091919,
-0.21340154111385345,
-0.18020854890346527,
-0.3105044662952423,
-0.9957492351531982,
-0.36881521344184875,
-0.09010574966669083,
-0.5326123833656311,
-0.39836186170578003,
-0.4295836389064789,
0.0038825978990644217,
-0.7041171789169312,
-0.4133698046207428,
0.21898682415485382,
0.3355940878391266,
-0.30431294441223145,
-0.049226921051740646,
-0.14905834197998047,
0.4524907171726227,
-0.5377123355865479,
0.8737649917602539,
0.7935537695884705,
-0.5309038758277893,
-1.0128767490386963,
0.014546132646501064,
0.026949472725391388,
-0.37719523906707764,
0.350180447101593,
0.20175199210643768,
-0.40895169973373413,
0.16635288298130035,
-0.7329412698745728,
-0.9155207872390747,
1.4024981260299683,
0.3142690062522888,
-0.3476574122905731,
-0.06574875861406326,
-0.18648092448711395,
0.934291660785675,
-0.7456539273262024,
0.5310520529747009,
0.04368949681520462,
0.15342755615711212,
0.2971866726875305,
-1.0959727764129639,
0.1806441992521286,
-0.5118666887283325,
-0.19332671165466309,
0.4848380386829376,
-0.8330267071723938,
1.0541296005249023,
-0.4190419614315033,
0.07419193536043167,
-0.009109986945986748,
0.5993199944496155,
0.1120699867606163,
0.32687005400657654,
0.7020930051803589,
0.31915080547332764,
0.9054480195045471,
0.2518434524536133,
0.7292780876159668,
-0.19498534500598907,
0.3358902633190155,
1.2064952850341797,
-0.14465045928955078,
0.6770908832550049,
0.1595812737941742,
0.19989119470119476,
0.7065412998199463,
0.08395298570394516,
0.13196329772472382,
-0.029162166640162468,
0.32946813106536865,
-0.15005038678646088,
-0.16753838956356049,
-0.4725852608680725,
-0.06031874567270279,
0.3705475330352783,
0.2398887425661087,
-0.3224658966064453,
0.2170386165380478,
0.016392242163419724,
-0.08709351718425751,
-0.0581689327955246,
-0.4798727333545685,
1.0431928634643555,
0.05403441563248634,
-0.5150479674339294,
0.30979886651039124,
-0.40628576278686523,
0.330323725938797,
-0.30148112773895264,
-0.01497044786810875,
-0.00391827616840601,
0.10031186789274216,
-0.08979523926973343,
-0.6832791566848755,
-0.0715324655175209,
-0.4822811782360077,
-0.34973716735839844,
0.024211952462792397,
0.5343277454376221,
-0.38831207156181335,
-0.15052194893360138,
0.8864905834197998,
0.8904642462730408,
0.14542897045612335,
0.08002731949090958,
-0.4454907774925232,
-0.32221922278404236,
-0.5815960168838501,
-0.03171948343515396,
0.3759239912033081,
0.737816333770752,
-0.08165178447961807,
0.7312409281730652,
0.548926055431366,
0.17492270469665527,
-0.07030465453863144,
0.2692268490791321,
0.9577766060829163,
-0.17893987894058228,
-0.5347639322280884,
-0.7979984879493713,
0.23308591544628143,
-0.48699626326560974,
0.056713543832302094,
0.6370590329170227,
0.20836913585662842,
0.402321994304657,
0.4962692856788635,
0.2211114913225174,
-0.10349298268556595,
-0.15438519418239594,
0.12018793821334839,
1.0387780666351318,
-0.651215136051178,
-0.006690706126391888,
-0.4025169014930725,
-0.9728359580039978,
-0.3939376175403595,
0.13067679107189178,
0.06820622831583023,
0.2852199673652649,
0.7128927111625671,
0.8545092940330505,
0.058847010135650635,
-0.11854279041290283,
0.5523509979248047,
0.467888206243515,
0.48995086550712585,
0.3980668783187866,
0.6091219186782837,
0.10936108976602554,
0.8632301688194275,
-0.09737804532051086,
-0.5410749912261963,
-0.005570600274950266,
-0.5600962042808533,
-0.923949658870697,
-0.6286290884017944,
-0.1877373456954956,
-0.48730137944221497,
-0.05577857419848442,
1.248672366142273,
0.903979480266571,
-0.22170856595039368,
-0.6029359102249146,
-0.4925874173641205,
0.2016974538564682,
-0.5995854735374451,
-0.20232371985912323,
0.0017688249936327338,
-0.28382450342178345,
-0.3720807433128357,
0.37023958563804626,
0.3031347990036011,
-0.0225521270185709,
-0.37308022379875183,
-0.344839870929718,
-0.43417635560035706,
0.4034287929534912,
0.536655604839325,
0.23883838951587677,
-0.3251446485519409,
-0.08156555145978928,
-0.026857595890760422,
-0.3948969542980194,
0.1829962581396103,
0.928544819355011,
-0.2853720784187317,
0.5591034889221191,
0.4711597263813019,
0.4675021171569824,
0.35309866070747375,
-0.2289830595254898,
0.5731722712516785,
-0.8044754862785339,
0.026260679587721825,
0.11576209962368011,
0.22006112337112427,
0.10953278839588165,
-0.4030410349369049,
0.5207787752151489,
0.12751147150993347,
-0.9809834957122803,
-0.7003922462463379,
0.09288166463375092,
-0.8661656975746155,
-0.20554575324058533,
0.8985235095024109,
-0.19315722584724426,
-0.16564643383026123,
-0.04550411179661751,
-0.18454673886299133,
0.3130555748939514,
-0.607248067855835,
0.470473974943161,
0.6334472298622131,
-0.4185711443424225,
-0.18908752501010895,
-0.3486977219581604,
0.16232441365718842,
0.24479997158050537,
-0.8276596665382385,
0.183033749461174,
0.3880150318145752,
-0.2960078716278076,
0.8547019958496094,
0.7255022525787354,
0.3575792908668518,
0.41907232999801636,
0.370588093996048,
0.027049819007515907,
-0.2455919086933136,
-0.94547438621521,
-0.28216487169265747,
0.3730688989162445,
0.4487294852733612,
0.10289106518030167
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07138v1
|
Never Miss A Beat: An Efficient Recipe for Context Window Extension of Large Language Models with Consistent "Middle" Enhancement
| 2024-06-11T10:35:49 | 2024-06-11T10:35:49 |
Tong Wu, Yanpeng Zhao, Zilong Zheng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, many methods have been developed to extend the context length of
pre-trained large language models (LLMs), but they often require fine-tuning at
the target length ($\gg4K$) and struggle to effectively utilize information
from the middle part of the context. To address these issues, we propose
$\textbf{C}$ontinuity-$\textbf{R}$elativity ind$\textbf{E}$xing with
g$\textbf{A}$ussian $\textbf{M}$iddle (CREAM), which interpolates positional
encodings by manipulating position indices. Apart from being simple, CREAM is
training-efficient: it only requires fine-tuning at the pre-trained context
window (eg, Llama 2-4K) and can extend LLMs to a much longer target context
length (eg, 256K). To ensure that the model focuses more on the information in
the middle, we introduce a truncated Gaussian to encourage sampling from the
middle part of the context during fine-tuning, thus alleviating the
``Lost-in-the-Middle'' problem faced by long-context LLMs. Experimental results
show that CREAM successfully extends LLMs to the target length for both Base
and Chat versions of $\texttt{Llama2-7B}$ with ``Never Miss A Beat''. Our code
will be publicly available soon.
|
[
-0.3111855387687683,
-0.8167995810508728,
0.5937379002571106,
0.4055529832839966,
-0.38061463832855225,
0.1490936279296875,
-0.6273338794708252,
-0.4635145366191864,
0.27717483043670654,
0.4158417582511902,
-0.8892588019371033,
-0.7322097420692444,
-0.6279401183128357,
-0.14773422479629517,
-0.5199536681175232,
0.9083721041679382,
0.3098609745502472,
-0.3320601284503937,
0.005297806579619646,
-0.08848533779382706,
-0.2895490527153015,
-0.4743136465549469,
-0.38800713419914246,
0.02549123205244541,
0.463128000497818,
0.793546736240387,
0.4789465665817261,
0.8598609566688538,
0.3755212128162384,
0.18372616171836853,
-0.10510128736495972,
0.36890822649002075,
-0.6849125027656555,
0.2963058650493622,
0.11242231726646423,
-0.4035811126232147,
-0.6646680235862732,
0.08951695263385773,
0.5331836342811584,
0.6862756013870239,
-0.16379502415657043,
0.11041305959224701,
0.13287484645843506,
0.5234094858169556,
-0.8275861144065857,
0.06031864136457443,
-0.825141191482544,
-0.14852719008922577,
-0.5566926002502441,
-0.36419618129730225,
-0.3084743618965149,
-0.05845487117767334,
-0.13753171265125275,
-0.5954527854919434,
0.11587561666965485,
0.14786233007907867,
0.7788729667663574,
0.2682427167892456,
-0.41360190510749817,
-0.15535257756710052,
-0.686744749546051,
0.8332914113998413,
-0.574211835861206,
0.5142769813537598,
0.34541037678718567,
0.5556809902191162,
-0.4147047698497772,
-0.6169904470443726,
-0.5815601348876953,
-0.3278627097606659,
0.033592402935028076,
-0.004977272357791662,
-0.16721923649311066,
0.07662708312273026,
0.2947004735469818,
0.2777790427207947,
-0.1930064707994461,
0.05159791186451912,
-0.040525346994400024,
-0.14737655222415924,
0.4625893235206604,
0.06276538968086243,
0.3401491641998291,
0.5163283944129944,
-0.34428271651268005,
-0.0910244882106781,
-1.0901447534561157,
0.05120784789323807,
0.3216916024684906,
0.2858549952507019,
-0.2814789414405823,
0.3551322817802429,
-0.19123810529708862,
0.9651737809181213,
0.3313748836517334,
-0.1421331763267517,
0.1697661131620407,
-0.26400226354599,
-0.14357200264930725,
0.0020677479915320873,
0.4245828688144684,
0.430431991815567,
0.03911812976002693,
-0.1739663928747177,
-0.2406487613916397,
0.002825362840667367,
-0.015644298866391182,
-0.998548686504364,
-0.07844912260770798,
0.07293953746557236,
0.07867854833602905,
-0.0866682380437851,
-0.06799496710300446,
-0.3666870594024658,
-0.006009835749864578,
-0.3188042938709259,
0.16271016001701355,
-0.41317445039749146,
-0.09371769428253174,
-0.05017091706395149,
0.1994122862815857,
0.2963298559188843,
0.28412535786628723,
-1.0507657527923584,
0.2645440697669983,
0.8883395195007324,
0.8955928087234497,
-0.2370179146528244,
-0.27204304933547974,
-1.0206611156463623,
0.28390616178512573,
-0.406198114156723,
0.6445441842079163,
-0.6996658444404602,
-0.30895164608955383,
0.08934406191110611,
0.18762727081775665,
0.04373360425233841,
-0.5490610599517822,
0.5528044104576111,
-0.48300763964653015,
0.09307458996772766,
-0.21179504692554474,
-0.5455012917518616,
-0.056581173092126846,
0.30317988991737366,
-0.2932610809803009,
0.8220903873443604,
0.17394620180130005,
-0.3151858150959015,
0.4538523852825165,
-0.5936228632926941,
-0.5817937850952148,
-0.18427836894989014,
-0.15637557208538055,
-0.4813897907733917,
0.3587528467178345,
0.43340441584587097,
0.4618821144104004,
-0.2077334076166153,
-0.0272352397441864,
-0.6740682721138,
-0.6872087121009827,
0.20728813111782074,
-0.36728599667549133,
0.5519989132881165,
-0.0577811598777771,
-0.346337229013443,
0.023235807195305824,
-0.9481876492500305,
0.0243646502494812,
-0.05504370108246803,
-0.3835281729698181,
-0.3186163306236267,
-0.4368608295917511,
0.39197948575019836,
0.16241931915283203,
0.17359748482704163,
-0.5388732552528381,
0.18750466406345367,
-0.2789981961250305,
0.29001426696777344,
0.6924993991851807,
-0.12461983412504196,
0.5003295540809631,
-0.3697279393672943,
0.649477481842041,
-0.11968816071748734,
0.19628705084323883,
-0.4257616400718689,
-0.11448122560977936,
-0.7203096747398376,
-0.5382528305053711,
0.28342893719673157,
0.3938232362270355,
-0.3120647668838501,
0.568652331829071,
-0.47697916626930237,
-0.31820806860923767,
-0.3263460099697113,
0.047654636204242706,
0.4359513223171234,
0.4785915017127991,
0.3614993989467621,
-0.2403927445411682,
-0.5308863520622253,
-0.826901912689209,
-0.42310407757759094,
0.3031079173088074,
-0.07091891765594482,
0.3969375193119049,
0.047175440937280655,
-0.30581289529800415,
1.0977009534835815,
-0.2985742390155792,
-0.3127274811267853,
-0.08979475498199463,
-0.45434635877609253,
0.5112507939338684,
0.5227236747741699,
0.589613139629364,
-0.4903775155544281,
-0.6448923349380493,
-0.008000512607395649,
-0.4024086594581604,
-0.5362992882728577,
0.3027306795120239,
-0.3302040696144104,
0.13514335453510284,
0.5540881752967834,
-0.544310986995697,
0.3020319938659668,
0.7822668552398682,
-0.3767300546169281,
0.5902601480484009,
0.0017400727374479175,
0.1971825361251831,
-1.0368424654006958,
-0.06080581620335579,
-0.0817837193608284,
-0.5386995673179626,
-0.8156627416610718,
-0.2128596156835556,
0.3818758726119995,
0.10995118319988251,
-0.41369158029556274,
0.7429518699645996,
-0.633675754070282,
0.01601281948387623,
-0.6562367081642151,
0.3161832392215729,
-0.05415846407413483,
0.4999421238899231,
-0.4464642107486725,
0.9146488308906555,
0.37098100781440735,
-0.6596322059631348,
-0.01599743217229843,
-0.026876045390963554,
-0.22956831753253937,
0.7548319697380066,
-0.5454167127609253,
0.43731606006622314,
-0.00872278306633234,
0.30524110794067383,
-0.7213413119316101,
-0.32195979356765747,
0.1288750320672989,
-0.5384343862533569,
0.7161543965339661,
-0.5495545268058777,
-0.24878349900245667,
-0.1394469290971756,
-0.22506898641586304,
0.3361477553844452,
0.41619837284088135,
-0.8184614777565002,
0.4462369978427887,
0.5445894002914429,
0.01110747829079628,
-0.8396283984184265,
-0.7138868570327759,
0.3132227957248688,
-0.40933603048324585,
-0.6100063323974609,
0.513342022895813,
-0.30219903588294983,
-0.00960921123623848,
-0.23466935753822327,
-0.29702332615852356,
0.082522913813591,
0.11943560838699341,
0.1335296481847763,
0.24591492116451263,
-0.05295369029045105,
0.10508360713720322,
0.2625049650669098,
-0.2413926124572754,
-0.1728363335132599,
-0.5456277132034302,
0.7114693522453308,
-0.21935410797595978,
-0.3057277202606201,
-0.25439634919166565,
0.2096596509218216,
0.7464654445648193,
-0.018115362152457237,
0.3688618242740631,
0.5868362188339233,
-0.47199586033821106,
-0.3066982924938202,
-0.6171912550926208,
-0.4571082293987274,
-0.5015920996665955,
0.5612667202949524,
-0.5226653218269348,
-1.0133607387542725,
0.5074429512023926,
0.08100737631320953,
-0.13898295164108276,
0.047453511506319046,
0.5021472573280334,
-0.015834838151931763,
0.7453919649124146,
0.8675264120101929,
-0.22639553248882294,
0.7213442921638489,
-0.12959106266498566,
0.14739297330379486,
-0.9448462128639221,
0.12825283408164978,
-0.30926138162612915,
-0.2195419818162918,
-0.3942185044288635,
-0.33224934339523315,
0.5793359875679016,
0.28268593549728394,
-0.11116457730531693,
0.30815690755844116,
-0.0917612612247467,
0.6788814663887024,
0.5155640244483948,
0.1571509689092636,
0.2273116409778595,
0.15312767028808594,
-0.03923960030078888,
-0.12512223422527313,
-0.6807606816291809,
-0.265266090631485,
1.0829837322235107,
0.27371934056282043,
0.6205361485481262,
0.26475825905799866,
0.5214918851852417,
0.10476166754961014,
0.350631982088089,
-0.6238459944725037,
0.4566328525543213,
-0.1828218698501587,
-0.4198538661003113,
-0.29870685935020447,
-0.19900335371494293,
-0.8333490490913391,
0.17492282390594482,
-0.1782187968492508,
-0.7304263710975647,
0.049125127494335175,
0.46339359879493713,
-0.39866822957992554,
0.12636210024356842,
-0.3495098650455475,
0.6914556622505188,
-0.06642965227365494,
-0.5542534589767456,
-0.07331341505050659,
-0.6199671626091003,
0.3341568112373352,
0.04246797040104866,
0.2518742084503174,
-0.43696728348731995,
-0.16079583764076233,
0.5928809642791748,
-0.6935505270957947,
0.7334087491035461,
-0.16278691589832306,
-0.08740022033452988,
0.09075959771871567,
0.07702270150184631,
0.7399372458457947,
0.039888594299554825,
0.4229762554168701,
0.17223253846168518,
-0.3336106240749359,
-0.6263773441314697,
-0.7583186030387878,
0.8379426002502441,
-0.2643713653087616,
-0.7560821175575256,
-0.135747030377388,
-0.5659473538398743,
-0.5260765552520752,
0.1824069321155548,
0.2355886697769165,
0.6334889531135559,
0.08123581111431122,
0.4205729067325592,
0.4902285635471344,
0.12481518089771271,
0.5585858225822449,
0.46498334407806396,
-0.24822025001049042,
-0.44804123044013977,
0.4653499722480774,
0.03565850853919983,
0.4122483730316162,
0.32361483573913574,
0.2697535753250122,
-0.4607846736907959,
-0.48134753108024597,
-0.6740001440048218,
0.13576725125312805,
-0.5780918002128601,
-0.07139817625284195,
-0.852570116519928,
0.060793425887823105,
-0.30232349038124084,
-0.1934388428926468,
-0.49640002846717834,
-0.42600250244140625,
-0.1243024617433548,
-0.031183188781142235,
0.5571494102478027,
0.21002255380153656,
-0.239432230591774,
0.7090621590614319,
-0.8536854386329651,
-0.20422443747520447,
0.2890091836452484,
0.36075544357299805,
-0.06595859676599503,
-0.8171247243881226,
-0.4715779721736908,
-0.061609916388988495,
-0.05234281346201897,
-0.7267131209373474,
0.2964412569999695,
0.23175902664661407,
0.3694179654121399,
0.40185150504112244,
-0.1076587662100792,
0.8273360729217529,
-0.447180837392807,
0.4558117985725403,
0.24623434245586395,
-0.9272180795669556,
0.4298311769962311,
-0.6193637251853943,
0.4586206078529358,
0.6447006464004517,
0.03684457018971443,
-0.6762793064117432,
-0.39331769943237305,
-0.3647049069404602,
-0.9570391774177551,
0.40221723914146423,
0.023345183581113815,
0.26670771837234497,
-0.03037426434457302,
0.2972319424152374,
0.10645891726016998,
0.3226357698440552,
-0.4585360586643219,
-0.3494337499141693,
0.24698929488658905,
-0.33369818329811096,
-0.11121192574501038,
-0.3003939092159271,
-0.10075577348470688,
-0.10570001602172852,
0.8039690256118774,
-0.23938621580600739,
-0.07389403879642487,
0.1454460322856903,
-0.3045390844345093,
-0.08376018702983856,
0.2990294098854065,
0.5390661954879761,
0.747438907623291,
-0.26681625843048096,
0.011480224318802357,
0.20225055515766144,
-0.6295599341392517,
0.1972433179616928,
0.18495449423789978,
-0.2913568317890167,
-0.11643756181001663,
0.35731860995292664,
0.8661009669303894,
0.40491676330566406,
-0.5596190094947815,
0.7000547647476196,
0.003997194580733776,
0.3967767357826233,
-0.4035254418849945,
0.19322910904884338,
-0.011108068749308586,
0.3582193851470947,
0.48239126801490784,
-0.07925307005643845,
0.04151048883795738,
-0.6375641822814941,
0.3901119828224182,
0.3357125520706177,
-0.7772343754768372,
-0.20675842463970184,
0.6859422922134399,
-0.09839197993278503,
-0.3671821653842926,
0.35843321681022644,
-0.10472742468118668,
-0.6352914571762085,
0.44535383582115173,
0.8198569416999817,
0.8350863456726074,
-0.13686516880989075,
-0.39232775568962097,
0.18846844136714935,
0.15344224870204926,
0.14209511876106262,
-0.0015323508996516466,
-0.13656921684741974,
-0.6148056387901306,
-0.5105888843536377,
-0.45778971910476685,
-0.3417968153953552,
-0.06458504498004913,
-0.4171627163887024,
0.46130436658859253,
-0.4128411114215851,
-0.2287723869085312,
-0.4623704254627228,
0.022312650457024574,
-0.6882855892181396,
0.20328839123249054,
-0.022673800587654114,
0.978609561920166,
-0.6371736526489258,
1.0042780637741089,
0.44904619455337524,
-0.09434881806373596,
-0.5963878035545349,
0.250471830368042,
-0.015000496059656143,
-0.6597185730934143,
0.18216198682785034,
0.3908868432044983,
-0.2908444404602051,
-0.05803520232439041,
-0.7663770318031311,
-0.8804425001144409,
1.1443605422973633,
0.24428553879261017,
-1.1088601350784302,
0.27592167258262634,
-0.1758008599281311,
0.26823192834854126,
-0.7540568709373474,
0.31564095616340637,
0.9839808344841003,
0.3268449008464813,
0.17796045541763306,
-0.953093945980072,
0.08438118547201157,
-0.2427695244550705,
-0.08754512667655945,
0.040176570415496826,
-0.7552396655082703,
0.7973877787590027,
-0.36114877462387085,
-0.2678654193878174,
-0.035894691944122314,
0.7512727975845337,
0.5635960102081299,
0.41284021735191345,
0.7431615591049194,
0.5041048526763916,
0.8048380613327026,
-0.2339896410703659,
1.0984951257705688,
-0.6474754810333252,
0.3685469329357147,
1.3611479997634888,
-0.028300952166318893,
0.5350531339645386,
0.42966294288635254,
-0.08418816328048706,
0.2820255756378174,
0.5818507075309753,
0.3519974648952484,
0.6780829429626465,
0.21225133538246155,
-0.3794524073600769,
-0.2081049382686615,
0.023410340771079063,
-0.4460326135158539,
0.47301414608955383,
0.4741745591163635,
-0.02349945902824402,
0.035677939653396606,
0.003542957827448845,
0.602743923664093,
0.2342335283756256,
-0.2876809239387512,
0.36098289489746094,
0.22410574555397034,
-0.47463056445121765,
0.7600311040878296,
-0.04134553670883179,
0.9332121014595032,
-0.4983404874801636,
0.17393049597740173,
-0.5470951795578003,
0.0822359174489975,
0.14075163006782532,
-0.41974061727523804,
0.14735060930252075,
-0.26476526260375977,
-0.22307570278644562,
0.26922985911369324,
0.6523828506469727,
-0.7498776316642761,
-0.34305381774902344,
0.30389904975891113,
0.28519895672798157,
-0.04831467568874359,
-0.222259059548378,
-0.35536378622055054,
0.31342676281929016,
-0.21421194076538086,
-0.22389066219329834,
0.10591305792331696,
0.35745149850845337,
-0.05123113468289375,
0.6064925789833069,
0.8030650615692139,
0.17966020107269287,
0.21572326123714447,
0.11215933412313461,
0.8725757002830505,
-0.8187597393989563,
-0.7227100133895874,
-0.9404619336128235,
0.1961117535829544,
-0.3350721299648285,
-0.27928608655929565,
0.6482427716255188,
0.6228153109550476,
0.8372490406036377,
-0.06120974197983742,
0.8157007098197937,
0.16971251368522644,
0.6170868873596191,
-0.6627707481384277,
0.6696473360061646,
-0.6775482892990112,
0.37697839736938477,
-0.21202526986598969,
-1.1774333715438843,
-0.6136584877967834,
0.27173981070518494,
-0.2698625326156616,
0.14032378792762756,
0.5330214500427246,
1.0128058195114136,
-0.3825939893722534,
-0.17564569413661957,
0.4909563362598419,
0.38427481055259705,
0.4546179175376892,
0.6657117605209351,
0.7076388001441956,
-0.37682485580444336,
0.36391299962997437,
-0.2952880263328552,
-0.5733480453491211,
-0.587678849697113,
-0.9944769740104675,
-0.6993502974510193,
-0.39106306433677673,
-0.09689320623874664,
-0.6815304160118103,
0.28663116693496704,
1.2102429866790771,
1.1139705181121826,
-0.7611262202262878,
-0.11778777092695236,
0.2906678318977356,
-0.015793578699231148,
-0.10357552766799927,
-0.1463438868522644,
0.5210210680961609,
-0.42646318674087524,
-1.04791259765625,
0.7045041918754578,
0.64951092004776,
0.30021271109580994,
-0.03779385983943939,
-0.03946738317608833,
0.040094662457704544,
0.07714542001485825,
0.6271740794181824,
0.2417207658290863,
-0.43470221757888794,
-0.4405406713485718,
0.056092847138643265,
-0.05476667732000351,
0.1760139763355255,
0.813666045665741,
-0.4617513418197632,
0.27143174409866333,
0.10313725471496582,
0.7034871578216553,
0.6765559911727905,
-0.11511913686990738,
0.5679365396499634,
-0.9102743268013,
0.3830450773239136,
0.05810336396098137,
0.46586793661117554,
0.4600487947463989,
-0.3071615993976593,
0.5077293515205383,
0.24218624830245972,
-0.4188878834247589,
-0.778701663017273,
0.31450924277305603,
-1.0290930271148682,
-0.029201507568359375,
1.1872748136520386,
-0.07636021077632904,
-0.558940589427948,
0.17866820096969604,
-0.0743212178349495,
0.2287827432155609,
-0.4479895830154419,
0.8378061652183533,
0.5238004326820374,
0.12440414726734161,
-0.16605116426944733,
-0.4896029531955719,
0.535917341709137,
0.41160041093826294,
-0.5419314503669739,
0.13083285093307495,
0.5629904270172119,
0.49004173278808594,
-0.2579730451107025,
0.7936214804649353,
-0.24226051568984985,
0.2624158263206482,
-0.19585323333740234,
-0.09638205170631409,
-0.253840833902359,
-0.6414892673492432,
-0.24416464567184448,
-0.02114289440214634,
0.0030028719920665026,
-0.4482889771461487
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07133v1
|
Translating speech with just images
| 2024-06-11T10:29:24 | 2024-06-11T10:29:24 |
Dan Oneata, Herman Kamper
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.CL, cs.SD
|
Visually grounded speech models link speech to images. We extend this
connection by linking images to text via an existing image captioning system,
and as a result gain the ability to map speech audio directly to text. This
approach can be used for speech translation with just images by having the
audio in a different language from the generated captions. We investigate such
a system on a real low-resource language, Yor\`ub\'a, and propose a
Yor\`ub\'a-to-English speech translation model that leverages pretrained
components in order to be able to learn in the low-resource regime. To limit
overfitting, we find that it is essential to use a decoding scheme that
produces diverse image captions for training. Results show that the predicted
translations capture the main semantics of the spoken audio, albeit in a
simpler and shorter form.
|
[
-0.16860362887382507,
-0.4738385081291199,
0.5176509618759155,
-0.13517454266548157,
-0.7817990183830261,
-0.1802128255367279,
-0.3602178990840912,
-0.7225103974342346,
0.2141619771718979,
0.7471342086791992,
-0.46647176146507263,
-0.2296229898929596,
-0.5308998823165894,
0.02371121384203434,
-0.4694065451622009,
0.7829919457435608,
0.36496955156326294,
0.15159104764461517,
0.014120304025709629,
-0.37201324105262756,
-0.6799960136413574,
-0.1551557332277298,
-0.4650398790836334,
-0.3803997039794922,
0.3442523181438446,
0.38262930512428284,
0.9049622416496277,
0.9929975867271423,
0.3412681818008423,
0.3196497857570648,
0.04664072021842003,
-0.15275780856609344,
-0.33375784754753113,
0.029038891196250916,
-0.09491115808486938,
-0.5510602593421936,
-0.028721880167722702,
0.09854347258806229,
0.6052216291427612,
0.7760316729545593,
0.04530856013298035,
0.2056063562631607,
-0.28413641452789307,
0.48978909850120544,
-0.4484076499938965,
0.3383277952671051,
-0.7625683546066284,
0.008639662526547909,
-0.01640654169023037,
-0.3002515733242035,
-0.4249604046344757,
-0.07459317147731781,
0.14872997999191284,
-0.62176114320755,
-0.08738719671964645,
0.2395915538072586,
1.0362581014633179,
0.5941428542137146,
-0.2996629774570465,
0.0018824681174010038,
-0.8234360814094543,
0.8172532916069031,
-0.49262315034866333,
0.49945202469825745,
0.26093539595603943,
0.4313897490501404,
0.2978784143924713,
-0.8868061900138855,
-0.5919026136398315,
-0.1971461921930313,
-0.18239431083202362,
0.2579948306083679,
-0.2822900414466858,
0.11371135711669922,
0.2192925363779068,
0.259312242269516,
-0.18355581164360046,
-0.036353886127471924,
-0.685145914554596,
-0.05450625717639923,
0.47835320234298706,
-0.2161889225244522,
0.6132887005805969,
-0.35137587785720825,
-0.29867491126060486,
-0.47837668657302856,
-0.5335003733634949,
-0.030622893944382668,
-0.10169576853513718,
0.40953534841537476,
-0.33819398283958435,
0.7703840136528015,
0.2459913194179535,
0.8558518290519714,
-0.14259271323680878,
-0.3391134738922119,
0.21459418535232544,
-0.015893826261162758,
-0.30655303597450256,
0.4415556788444519,
0.8178133964538574,
0.3408649265766144,
0.3407723009586334,
-0.2550691068172455,
-0.26301106810569763,
0.35868576169013977,
0.17459172010421753,
-0.75009685754776,
-0.1522742509841919,
-0.24761846661567688,
-0.4333830773830414,
0.01528905052691698,
-0.34648042917251587,
-0.591273307800293,
-0.05565612390637398,
-0.37773293256759644,
0.43972763419151306,
-0.393949419260025,
-0.09579479694366455,
0.011661037802696228,
-0.10341119766235352,
0.1729818433523178,
0.10330162942409515,
-0.5121070146560669,
0.2736566960811615,
-0.03343823552131653,
0.6953616142272949,
0.15854424238204956,
-0.2568245232105255,
-0.7642859816551208,
0.3520902991294861,
-0.5806437730789185,
0.8801034092903137,
-0.31133097410202026,
-0.347898930311203,
0.25235676765441895,
-0.007217451464384794,
0.05134141072630882,
-0.10495368391275406,
0.6069164872169495,
-0.5296164751052856,
0.262261301279068,
-0.028559202328324318,
-0.25483593344688416,
-0.2320426106452942,
-0.25867971777915955,
-0.657585084438324,
0.5279691815376282,
-0.148634135723114,
-0.5335208177566528,
0.25828853249549866,
-0.737022340297699,
-0.7655300498008728,
0.2628761827945709,
-0.41813021898269653,
-0.23208478093147278,
0.3099132180213928,
0.27304360270500183,
0.3951982259750366,
-0.38174542784690857,
0.032887041568756104,
0.17772400379180908,
-0.331911563873291,
0.15249627828598022,
-0.4039166569709778,
0.5667773485183716,
0.4438280463218689,
-0.2372203916311264,
-0.08779099583625793,
-0.7389535903930664,
0.19722990691661835,
0.5273531079292297,
-0.2660141885280609,
-0.31699323654174805,
0.02909817174077034,
0.5612999796867371,
0.013798083178699017,
0.019539641216397285,
-0.6378251910209656,
-0.08676452934741974,
-0.6118722558021545,
0.8020800352096558,
0.26877689361572266,
-0.24951030313968658,
0.7774626016616821,
-0.19269247353076935,
0.3345543146133423,
-0.14072482287883759,
-0.2705163061618805,
-0.7130643725395203,
-0.6173959970474243,
-0.6283122301101685,
-0.4483712315559387,
0.21411798894405365,
0.6551663279533386,
-0.6810051202774048,
0.3064171075820923,
-0.6016193628311157,
-0.13093507289886475,
-1.0970548391342163,
0.08475784212350845,
0.6387943625450134,
0.7424774765968323,
0.665651798248291,
-0.41872256994247437,
-0.36785611510276794,
-0.9023020267486572,
0.10188625007867813,
-0.2779287099838257,
-0.05804182216525078,
0.3898572623729706,
0.11769397556781769,
-0.10968684405088425,
0.5965749621391296,
-0.30566468834877014,
-0.6992958784103394,
-0.2697575092315674,
0.16634593904018402,
0.0894317626953125,
0.6661010384559631,
0.7454351782798767,
-0.8724387288093567,
-0.4257696568965912,
0.18546037375926971,
-0.48224127292633057,
-0.034814294427633286,
-0.26977935433387756,
-0.02615887112915516,
0.1109081357717514,
0.7276217937469482,
-0.534804105758667,
0.4157679080963135,
0.599071204662323,
-0.050819337368011475,
-0.11307631433010101,
-0.25376343727111816,
0.277092844247818,
-1.0742251873016357,
0.003953454550355673,
-0.07392969727516174,
-0.601942777633667,
-0.3851679563522339,
0.13989700376987457,
-0.04785982519388199,
-0.7024381756782532,
-0.5977413058280945,
0.5207717418670654,
-0.6457207202911377,
-0.2874561548233032,
-0.3332385718822479,
0.042209163308143616,
0.05738985165953636,
0.3831004798412323,
0.395154744386673,
0.8510152697563171,
0.8822660446166992,
-0.28391608595848083,
0.4772473871707916,
0.5419168472290039,
-0.21980319917201996,
0.8579544425010681,
-0.7342695593833923,
0.30578476190567017,
-0.3461433947086334,
-0.021887624636292458,
-1.191895604133606,
-0.38838866353034973,
0.10334692895412445,
-0.3877851665019989,
0.7842544317245483,
-0.37798383831977844,
-0.2659890949726105,
-0.17901282012462616,
0.22299641370773315,
0.4788951873779297,
0.9355390071868896,
-0.7230667471885681,
0.5001847147941589,
0.45364809036254883,
-0.17999795079231262,
-0.13826201856136322,
-1.0011290311813354,
0.4212784171104431,
-0.13000819087028503,
-0.5713711977005005,
0.5164206027984619,
0.17187495529651642,
0.12588566541671753,
0.4250093400478363,
0.014186427928507328,
-0.41302525997161865,
-0.23952367901802063,
0.32460349798202515,
0.20793573558330536,
-0.5276699066162109,
0.14646391570568085,
-0.08842398971319199,
-0.005806958302855492,
-0.2127871960401535,
-0.5167337656021118,
0.19601388275623322,
-0.1380123645067215,
-0.3712874948978424,
-0.8515275120735168,
0.6823160648345947,
0.6476694941520691,
-0.2864731252193451,
0.44967079162597656,
0.40337005257606506,
-0.24990658462047577,
0.15459460020065308,
-0.5197926759719849,
-0.1056075319647789,
-0.43432092666625977,
0.4463754892349243,
-0.41032636165618896,
-0.5115480422973633,
0.3038642704486847,
-0.09230682998895645,
-0.05948600545525551,
0.2707735300064087,
0.12965506315231323,
-0.6034296154975891,
0.9394886493682861,
0.880454957485199,
-0.1780110001564026,
0.5724954605102539,
-0.2575911581516266,
0.09064051508903503,
-0.3523677587509155,
-0.008462700061500072,
-0.6125609874725342,
-0.30667048692703247,
-0.6839485168457031,
-0.220835343003273,
0.21968582272529602,
-0.126778706908226,
-0.050573334097862244,
0.6699195504188538,
-0.45481133460998535,
0.7873687148094177,
0.7781724333763123,
0.04376452416181564,
0.16199542582035065,
0.35596635937690735,
0.12949135899543762,
-0.3601122200489044,
-0.7009382843971252,
-0.46833285689353943,
0.7122558951377869,
0.19264601171016693,
0.8996442556381226,
-0.1844751238822937,
0.6644982695579529,
0.120774045586586,
0.09292002767324448,
-1.0320860147476196,
0.387332558631897,
-0.32609930634498596,
-0.496388703584671,
-0.4328749179840088,
-0.2952771782875061,
-0.943672776222229,
0.15176589787006378,
-0.5243799686431885,
-0.4358702301979065,
0.020410124212503433,
0.26057010889053345,
0.03677845373749733,
0.30459660291671753,
-0.6589122414588928,
0.7692012190818787,
-0.4945892095565796,
-0.21937617659568787,
-0.23790714144706726,
-0.8459887504577637,
0.020289752632379532,
0.12713205814361572,
0.4971809387207031,
0.16315029561519623,
0.11146233230829239,
0.6269423961639404,
-0.02611313946545124,
0.7850819230079651,
0.0021514487452805042,
0.19084858894348145,
0.4014531373977661,
0.05995110422372818,
0.09194912016391754,
-0.35893556475639343,
0.3065122961997986,
0.22845514118671417,
0.1534155309200287,
-0.6477430462837219,
-0.3636249005794525,
0.37064555287361145,
-0.8347554206848145,
-0.5442315936088562,
-0.3492012321949005,
-0.41987454891204834,
-0.1515127718448639,
0.444425106048584,
0.4241403341293335,
0.3864605128765106,
-0.23646746575832367,
0.2662985324859619,
0.3972604274749756,
-0.21956773102283478,
0.43820351362228394,
0.19113539159297943,
-0.09061478823423386,
-0.38916048407554626,
0.7219568490982056,
-0.05794701725244522,
0.16901396214962006,
0.23309668898582458,
0.27361708879470825,
-0.6390093564987183,
-0.3359295427799225,
-0.7293393015861511,
0.38028380274772644,
-0.7887422442436218,
-0.2481909841299057,
-0.275706946849823,
-0.0893104299902916,
-0.47169744968414307,
-0.3556590676307678,
-0.6689152121543884,
-0.2614804208278656,
-0.3385654091835022,
-0.006959080696105957,
0.1584353893995285,
0.6006246209144592,
-0.09345600754022598,
0.6484342813491821,
-0.8936253190040588,
0.7557217478752136,
0.6506684422492981,
0.18996287882328033,
-0.43610021471977234,
-0.9045248627662659,
-0.17110766470432281,
0.07568153738975525,
-0.2221585065126419,
-1.1258082389831543,
0.47634145617485046,
0.7597593069076538,
0.6087181568145752,
0.324098140001297,
0.046169739216566086,
0.8927937150001526,
-1.0256710052490234,
0.6085322499275208,
0.8399445414543152,
-0.9240860342979431,
0.732563853263855,
-0.11223792284727097,
0.2225341647863388,
0.42684563994407654,
0.24820533394813538,
-0.3812086284160614,
-0.3514443635940552,
-0.5365024209022522,
-0.58296799659729,
0.5405253767967224,
0.09444629400968552,
0.7689653038978577,
0.08967063575983047,
0.16443702578544617,
-0.3839011490345001,
0.10629358887672424,
-0.9386687874794006,
-0.19448447227478027,
-0.7146960496902466,
-0.12540288269519806,
-0.21258126199245453,
-0.18703097105026245,
-0.45722535252571106,
-0.288606196641922,
0.4042569100856781,
-0.08117183297872543,
0.1803852617740631,
0.19885115325450897,
-0.3389091193675995,
-0.481944739818573,
0.5927592515945435,
0.2589350938796997,
0.16007663309574127,
-0.1657337099313736,
0.18382993340492249,
-0.1967543363571167,
-0.3485547602176666,
0.3335687816143036,
-0.05242731794714928,
-0.2516954839229584,
0.18853366374969482,
0.43866389989852905,
1.0896987915039062,
0.5063397288322449,
-0.5976530313491821,
0.6716412305831909,
0.20820815861225128,
-0.0844893828034401,
-0.028787029907107353,
-0.16672956943511963,
0.15159957110881805,
0.2214524745941162,
0.37841200828552246,
0.3013382852077484,
-0.053236499428749084,
-0.8047369122505188,
0.17137588560581207,
0.3309512436389923,
-0.6109089255332947,
-0.21027331054210663,
0.9024507999420166,
0.3076304495334625,
-0.3059559464454651,
0.3671478033065796,
-0.12590546905994415,
-0.31443753838539124,
0.3465706706047058,
0.9651332497596741,
0.7895956635475159,
-0.05084558576345444,
0.1623239517211914,
0.3382580578327179,
0.47400766611099243,
-0.13415950536727905,
0.2651558816432953,
-0.09110565483570099,
-0.45600539445877075,
-0.6855283975601196,
-0.4573006331920624,
-0.27657413482666016,
0.11649537831544876,
-0.85822594165802,
0.2049458920955658,
-0.19023576378822327,
-0.17771382629871368,
0.05493529140949249,
-0.5489251613616943,
-0.8640432357788086,
0.40432918071746826,
0.64012211561203,
0.49029093980789185,
-0.9999910593032837,
0.7910263538360596,
1.1718876361846924,
-0.6427410840988159,
-0.7950587272644043,
-0.20806501805782318,
-0.30377593636512756,
-0.9000842571258545,
0.8605220317840576,
0.046225473284721375,
-0.2415737807750702,
0.3788289725780487,
-0.9211297631263733,
-0.6168599128723145,
0.7360811233520508,
0.7645465731620789,
-0.4663343131542206,
0.14335016906261444,
0.00009476631385041401,
0.4617379307746887,
-0.46908053755760193,
-0.1844143569469452,
0.13137392699718475,
0.27309611439704895,
0.46798989176750183,
-0.8654448390007019,
-0.23544737696647644,
-0.03449995070695877,
0.15339919924736023,
-0.21426640450954437,
-0.11306975781917572,
0.5597273707389832,
-0.4457467794418335,
-0.6686210036277771,
0.0866447389125824,
0.9006139039993286,
-0.1985705941915512,
0.206547349691391,
0.4259549379348755,
0.5178502798080444,
0.3395999073982239,
0.0849955752491951,
0.9521085619926453,
-0.1317581981420517,
0.02429436892271042,
1.0821149349212646,
-0.026588207110762596,
1.002554178237915,
0.7597777843475342,
-0.011343258433043957,
0.16300000250339508,
0.20647373795509338,
0.11940725892782211,
1.0331443548202515,
0.05402103811502457,
-0.031147824600338936,
-0.5706711411476135,
-0.6383624076843262,
-0.37364691495895386,
0.6532652378082275,
0.016440430656075478,
-0.2422565370798111,
-0.2743037939071655,
0.16266392171382904,
-0.44364291429519653,
0.6732298731803894,
-0.46849924325942993,
0.745366632938385,
0.25081971287727356,
-0.2846810817718506,
0.8202477097511292,
-0.16785554587841034,
0.616847813129425,
-0.38285908102989197,
-0.08967293053865433,
0.06300957500934601,
-0.47264131903648376,
-0.05535350367426872,
-0.6271488070487976,
0.159281924366951,
0.21621963381767273,
-0.05726902559399605,
-0.3835175335407257,
0.7416004538536072,
-0.6067237854003906,
-0.551375687122345,
0.2990266978740692,
0.5514841079711914,
0.34904584288597107,
0.18428528308868408,
-0.5972141027450562,
-0.07152823358774185,
-0.050864093005657196,
-0.11359096318483353,
0.11193360388278961,
0.34241533279418945,
0.11598897725343704,
0.49225807189941406,
0.5815765261650085,
0.41889438033103943,
0.23802968859672546,
0.14340415596961975,
0.6542484760284424,
-0.5723618268966675,
-0.703752338886261,
-0.4243326485157013,
0.4666019082069397,
0.2277689427137375,
0.060045115649700165,
0.11771070212125778,
0.20820015668869019,
0.8390585780143738,
-0.39125216007232666,
0.8083692789077759,
0.10329554975032806,
0.18716514110565186,
-0.6777272820472717,
0.8452975749969482,
-0.7816638350486755,
-0.295185387134552,
-0.2359990030527115,
-0.9732881188392639,
-0.27807536721229553,
1.0512079000473022,
0.03722953051328659,
-0.5225425362586975,
0.5268007516860962,
0.485933393239975,
-0.46727100014686584,
-0.26859280467033386,
1.0035096406936646,
0.04414279758930206,
-0.11655279994010925,
0.19199445843696594,
0.6916869282722473,
-0.6996910572052002,
0.8232157230377197,
-0.2739337682723999,
0.06176413968205452,
0.1058318167924881,
-1.0344288349151611,
-0.780644416809082,
-0.7450063824653625,
-0.5921749472618103,
-0.16292764246463776,
0.0023113444913178682,
0.7631835341453552,
0.9738889932632446,
-0.719797670841217,
-0.22424286603927612,
0.14383940398693085,
-0.3283769488334656,
0.1126692146062851,
-0.027840690687298775,
0.25110337138175964,
-0.3108639121055603,
-0.8147802352905273,
0.6262368559837341,
0.21394842863082886,
0.47345802187919617,
-0.03652786836028099,
-0.15559738874435425,
0.0065926676616072655,
0.10109423846006393,
0.40451446175575256,
0.6133109331130981,
-0.7665742635726929,
-0.36175838112831116,
-0.08845687657594681,
-0.24176447093486786,
0.2601189613342285,
0.5157550573348999,
-0.6021661758422852,
0.5602078437805176,
0.2443508803844452,
0.899986207485199,
0.743921160697937,
-0.10896597802639008,
0.38422536849975586,
-0.835017204284668,
0.7665257453918457,
0.20040519535541534,
0.47410011291503906,
0.5318090319633484,
-0.02599087357521057,
0.21981851756572723,
0.23257984220981598,
-0.1105041429400444,
-0.7156389951705933,
0.3028734624385834,
-1.2543472051620483,
-0.12791600823402405,
0.9372266530990601,
-0.2965669333934784,
-0.32960233092308044,
0.17669911682605743,
-0.32995036244392395,
0.4756567180156708,
-0.36520105600357056,
0.5373635292053223,
0.34302499890327454,
0.37146300077438354,
-0.5196292400360107,
-0.5811487436294556,
0.2676369547843933,
0.3956727087497711,
-0.4184613823890686,
-0.3717743754386902,
0.8361648917198181,
0.11130495369434357,
0.4489292502403259,
0.7150786519050598,
-0.12201566994190216,
0.3698726296424866,
-0.09932173788547516,
0.28611433506011963,
-0.09549994021654129,
-0.228529691696167,
-0.3538627326488495,
-0.06782253086566925,
0.14320410788059235,
-0.6753119826316833
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07115v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07115v1
|
Advancing Tool-Augmented Large Language Models: Integrating Insights from Errors in Inference Trees
| 2024-06-11T10:00:18 | 2024-06-11T10:00:18 |
Sijia Chen, Yibo Wang, Yi-Feng Wu, Qing-Guo Chen, Zhao Xu, Weihua Luo, Kaifu Zhang, Lijun Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Tool-augmented large language models (LLMs) leverage tools, often in the form
of APIs, to enhance their reasoning capabilities on complex tasks, thus taking
on the role of intelligent agents interacting with the real world. The recently
introduced ToolLLaMA model by Qin et al. [2024] utilizes the depth-first
search-based decision tree (DFSDT) method for reasoning with $16000+$
real-world APIs, which effectively improves the planning and inferencing
performance of tool-augmented LLMs compared to traditional chain reasoning
approaches. However, their approach only employs successful paths from decision
trees (also called inference trees) for supervised fine-tuning (SFT) during
training, which does not fully exploit the advantages of the tree of thought.
In this study, we propose an inference trajectory optimization framework based
on the preference data extracted from decision trees to address this
limitation. We first introduce a novel method for constructing preference data
from the tree of thought, capitalizing on the failed explorations previously
overlooked in the trees. Specifically, we generate an effective step-wise
preference dataset, named ToolPreference, for tool use based on the ToolBench
dataset. In the subsequent training phase, we first fine-tune the LLM with
tool-usage expert trajectories and then use these step-wise preference pairs
for direct preference optimization (DPO) to update the policy of the LLM,
resulting in our ToolPrefer-LLaMA (TP-LLaMA) model. Our experiments demonstrate
that by obtaining insights from errors in inference trees, TP-LLaMA
significantly outperforms the baselines across almost all test scenarios by a
large margin and exhibits better generalization capabilities with unseen APIs.
At the same time, TP-LLaMA has also demonstrated superior reasoning efficiency
compared to the baselines, making it more suitable for complex tool-usage
reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.15038667619228363,
-0.7939453125,
0.9969529509544373,
-0.0854429230093956,
-0.17536699771881104,
0.32228776812553406,
-0.2679698169231415,
-0.35836678743362427,
0.06771448254585266,
0.5296783447265625,
-0.7024502158164978,
-0.585703432559967,
-0.5383116602897644,
-0.18636293709278107,
-0.26392728090286255,
0.6184382438659668,
-0.11972523480653763,
-0.17298035323619843,
-0.16345877945423126,
0.12141893059015274,
-0.4547146260738373,
-0.34751707315444946,
-0.6372798681259155,
-0.16663825511932373,
0.5201760530471802,
0.4907282590866089,
0.7373971939086914,
0.7289309501647949,
0.30857735872268677,
0.23575705289840698,
-0.3102594017982483,
0.5260315537452698,
-0.37258511781692505,
-0.01708681508898735,
-0.19353103637695312,
-0.5262424945831299,
-0.5890390872955322,
-0.04202328249812126,
0.3854510188102722,
0.8568186163902283,
-0.06682895123958588,
0.0804457888007164,
0.1377156525850296,
0.317324697971344,
-0.5924177765846252,
0.2967787981033325,
-0.7247975468635559,
0.024787401780486107,
-0.05653851479291916,
-0.4633163511753082,
-0.4862053692340851,
-0.5034919381141663,
0.31695717573165894,
-0.6506412625312805,
0.06250680983066559,
0.012891941703855991,
0.5673514008522034,
0.7005739212036133,
-0.4364170432090759,
-0.2418348789215088,
-0.7266259789466858,
0.9464190006256104,
-0.8862394094467163,
0.3445407450199127,
0.34255626797676086,
0.28569257259368896,
-0.5929211378097534,
-0.36973074078559875,
-0.2009735107421875,
-0.164730504155159,
0.04033249616622925,
-0.09028681367635727,
-0.007987206801772118,
0.32198649644851685,
0.25860047340393066,
0.11282716691493988,
-0.27882182598114014,
0.399024099111557,
0.06521423906087875,
-0.1019873395562172,
0.7179031372070312,
0.14505738019943237,
-0.2771405577659607,
0.013019959442317486,
0.148006871342659,
-0.30799829959869385,
-0.7034270167350769,
0.28456491231918335,
0.19444090127944946,
0.44871222972869873,
0.08763387799263,
0.478646457195282,
-0.2601541578769684,
0.8365564346313477,
0.19322559237480164,
-0.5172114372253418,
0.16270290315151215,
-0.16295646131038666,
-0.38836202025413513,
0.11055204272270203,
0.45853298902511597,
0.39030373096466064,
0.25020137429237366,
-0.31777796149253845,
-0.11675279587507248,
0.03521168977022171,
-0.07190845906734467,
-0.873421311378479,
-0.17672882974147797,
0.4792617857456207,
-0.0807461217045784,
-0.4030115008354187,
-0.26099273562431335,
-0.5340510010719299,
-0.48250076174736023,
-0.3965573310852051,
0.06775549799203873,
-0.36223697662353516,
-0.41651347279548645,
0.36037957668304443,
0.1298801153898239,
0.07941807806491852,
0.7227983474731445,
-0.6305834054946899,
0.010100732557475567,
0.7095545530319214,
0.823940634727478,
-0.1408722996711731,
-0.16846823692321777,
-0.6648436188697815,
0.11946110427379608,
-0.677026629447937,
0.7773117423057556,
-0.7228280305862427,
-0.5230243802070618,
-0.18577341735363007,
-0.13643445074558258,
0.060715723782777786,
-0.399239718914032,
0.6494680047035217,
-0.42719337344169617,
-0.012777174822986126,
-0.33144763112068176,
-0.5232317447662354,
-0.49645429849624634,
0.3866537809371948,
-0.397517591714859,
1.2090210914611816,
0.06407549977302551,
-0.6136686205863953,
0.7383537888526917,
-0.8856655955314636,
-0.4174325466156006,
-0.1952802985906601,
-0.11069035530090332,
-0.2709939181804657,
-0.06380942463874817,
0.49928152561187744,
0.5781750082969666,
-0.40599679946899414,
0.6588088870048523,
-0.628130316734314,
-0.3337915241718292,
-0.16571858525276184,
-0.3818776309490204,
1.0100444555282593,
0.04272986948490143,
-0.3762494921684265,
0.2500554025173187,
-0.5031161904335022,
0.00033018141402862966,
0.1961888074874878,
-0.41559216380119324,
-0.3243142068386078,
0.491481214761734,
-0.3200801908969879,
0.07872208207845688,
0.11731249839067459,
-0.638670802116394,
0.4586547315120697,
-0.6027137041091919,
0.4517069160938263,
1.006752371788025,
-0.04088133946061134,
0.319735586643219,
0.04326828941702843,
0.5435438752174377,
0.1397995501756668,
0.12940412759780884,
-0.015890439972281456,
-0.19253332912921906,
-0.6405846476554871,
0.11472517251968384,
0.2218678891658783,
0.48041942715644836,
-0.510913074016571,
0.5753391981124878,
-0.3310306668281555,
-0.524029552936554,
-0.42602166533470154,
0.09833460301160812,
0.08440838009119034,
0.6178238987922668,
0.2264939844608307,
0.01330725196748972,
-0.5160220861434937,
-0.6137567162513733,
-0.1364423781633377,
-0.3787435293197632,
0.2958528697490692,
0.4842783808708191,
0.22175393998622894,
-0.13860616087913513,
1.2400903701782227,
-0.5843229293823242,
0.15222211182117462,
-0.23530972003936768,
-0.2984234392642975,
0.43804478645324707,
0.40592947602272034,
0.5653356909751892,
-0.594510555267334,
-0.33737462759017944,
0.19711615145206451,
-0.4478182792663574,
-0.08794888108968735,
-0.13272269070148468,
-0.1631077229976654,
0.06380512565374374,
0.3250981569290161,
-0.49869227409362793,
0.33321863412857056,
0.4279498755931854,
-0.31680887937545776,
0.5134437680244446,
-0.05244908481836319,
-0.03841681033372879,
-0.955903172492981,
-0.15927860140800476,
0.10310179740190506,
-0.27746155858039856,
-0.26188626885414124,
-0.18323248624801636,
-0.09701431542634964,
0.3604128658771515,
-0.3075745701789856,
0.5002009272575378,
-0.2710171639919281,
-0.2750612795352936,
-0.20131272077560425,
-0.033402055501937866,
0.032413046807050705,
0.5971741080284119,
0.008720507845282555,
0.8723868727684021,
0.6430299282073975,
-0.5135830640792847,
0.2221161425113678,
0.1597937047481537,
-0.16340814530849457,
0.4105827808380127,
-0.3911236822605133,
0.15334543585777283,
-0.009898069314658642,
0.3278238773345947,
-0.73822420835495,
-0.2074808031320572,
0.08109153062105179,
-0.17003311216831207,
0.12606975436210632,
-0.3272325098514557,
-0.7699944376945496,
-0.3484024107456207,
-0.278306245803833,
0.08230572938919067,
0.3308902382850647,
-0.8434084057807922,
0.6828460097312927,
0.3584422469139099,
0.13543248176574707,
-0.6728049516677856,
-0.44735488295555115,
0.10267438739538193,
-0.4405878186225891,
-0.5196560025215149,
0.09916271269321442,
-0.03909101337194443,
-0.2638776898384094,
-0.17090627551078796,
-0.2803255319595337,
0.1873246431350708,
0.44574373960494995,
0.2227879911661148,
0.16976222395896912,
-0.19161321222782135,
0.21397188305854797,
0.35415858030319214,
-0.017989695072174072,
0.17624786496162415,
-0.3264312744140625,
0.4170823097229004,
-0.04431265592575073,
-0.604216992855072,
-0.2709004878997803,
0.012847312726080418,
0.512572169303894,
-0.2737589478492737,
0.31836238503456116,
0.24164074659347534,
-0.11578203737735748,
-0.21396976709365845,
-0.667941153049469,
-0.28711557388305664,
-0.45676127076148987,
0.47774600982666016,
-0.4866161048412323,
-0.8511050939559937,
0.16273292899131775,
-0.5431123375892639,
0.6096760034561157,
0.24510879814624786,
0.3049027919769287,
-0.13753724098205566,
1.4529657363891602,
0.5509852170944214,
-0.1519896239042282,
0.4305300712585449,
-0.4385997951030731,
0.20639464259147644,
-0.7679161429405212,
0.03746615722775459,
-0.39384838938713074,
-0.25178825855255127,
-0.4855674207210541,
-0.3997410833835602,
0.37430882453918457,
0.13786692917346954,
-0.4664803445339203,
0.13881775736808777,
-0.5304663777351379,
0.4352913200855255,
0.6730765700340271,
0.166532963514328,
0.4803004562854767,
0.019951041787862778,
-0.17539872229099274,
0.11486636102199554,
-0.8266884684562683,
-0.5950555205345154,
1.196868896484375,
0.32588014006614685,
0.5700975656509399,
-0.1500300168991089,
0.6081026196479797,
0.08926784992218018,
0.17711284756660461,
-1.076227068901062,
0.6894027590751648,
0.023162681609392166,
-0.2932185232639313,
-0.2554878890514374,
-0.18905271589756012,
-0.8316073417663574,
0.2506837844848633,
0.004952508490532637,
-0.8278982043266296,
0.20789703726768494,
0.38411664962768555,
-0.4356360137462616,
0.5397859215736389,
-0.8537664413452148,
0.8396162390708923,
-0.5447792410850525,
-0.4192189872264862,
-0.2734304368495941,
-0.5513902902603149,
0.24826642870903015,
-0.09212186187505722,
0.008804009296000004,
-0.1921578347682953,
-0.0584537498652935,
0.6846206188201904,
-0.39619746804237366,
0.8987692594528198,
-0.3597080409526825,
-0.17735235393047333,
0.2125583291053772,
0.2977050244808197,
0.9234195947647095,
-0.17267842590808868,
-0.3325437903404236,
-0.03502091020345688,
0.04978587478399277,
-0.23224425315856934,
-0.5531037449836731,
0.5734647512435913,
-0.6926919221878052,
-0.8273824453353882,
-0.3094455897808075,
-0.7835674285888672,
-0.5763143301010132,
0.22874514758586884,
-0.26639774441719055,
0.2798396050930023,
-0.04352966323494911,
0.08235713094472885,
0.3698157072067261,
-0.10245020687580109,
0.4745270013809204,
0.3110775053501129,
-0.3955872058868408,
0.18923696875572205,
0.6207457780838013,
0.09493913501501083,
0.20515038073062897,
0.25484317541122437,
0.47136634588241577,
-0.3006685972213745,
-0.9995262026786804,
-0.469666987657547,
0.12594889104366302,
-0.5652951002120972,
-0.1781560480594635,
-0.6933497786521912,
0.10496330261230469,
-0.07349399477243423,
-0.22812248766422272,
-0.3382149040699005,
-0.2413843870162964,
-0.20501680672168732,
-0.4888792932033539,
0.7399465441703796,
0.5890548825263977,
-0.0063046677969396114,
0.4779888987541199,
-0.4462251663208008,
-0.27292776107788086,
0.051443297415971756,
0.21630795300006866,
0.09308454394340515,
-0.2583194375038147,
-0.23413953185081482,
0.28681764006614685,
-0.3517422080039978,
-0.6154041886329651,
0.2679451107978821,
-0.05459418147802353,
0.4203650653362274,
0.374481737613678,
0.0528615303337574,
1.0126137733459473,
-0.1479436606168747,
0.490035742521286,
-0.2805986702442169,
-0.6352224946022034,
0.7916966676712036,
-0.416730672121048,
0.17144866287708282,
0.4991728961467743,
0.004977307748049498,
-0.21274127066135406,
-0.28254246711730957,
-0.6812347769737244,
-0.5807822942733765,
0.893246054649353,
-0.1554555743932724,
-0.20759761333465576,
0.21608032286167145,
0.3190183639526367,
0.12020029872655869,
0.14117267727851868,
-0.346344530582428,
0.18952696025371552,
0.056546323001384735,
-0.17510779201984406,
-0.10732206702232361,
0.0014795124297961593,
-0.0101272938773036,
-0.49866002798080444,
0.7191388607025146,
-0.5195661783218384,
-0.3195401430130005,
0.0181528702378273,
-0.005807746201753616,
-0.17776590585708618,
0.125342458486557,
0.12830626964569092,
0.7801620960235596,
-0.46963152289390564,
0.12044543772935867,
0.3595520555973053,
-0.31399720907211304,
0.11700233817100525,
0.10094496607780457,
-0.13302958011627197,
-0.11850780993700027,
0.21982240676879883,
0.881401538848877,
0.07579924166202545,
-0.8626144528388977,
0.202809140086174,
0.33937153220176697,
-0.04905211552977562,
-0.18920071423053741,
0.2097911238670349,
0.3288642168045044,
0.39918607473373413,
0.16807711124420166,
0.14167916774749756,
0.22634193301200867,
-0.2891082167625427,
-0.14772215485572815,
0.6501702666282654,
-0.2663021385669708,
-0.1553923636674881,
0.4287637770175934,
0.22770006954669952,
-0.13675342500209808,
0.3125438392162323,
-0.12134125083684921,
-0.3893483877182007,
0.6248226165771484,
0.21898765861988068,
0.8018350601196289,
-0.034729376435279846,
0.1124936193227768,
0.3466155230998993,
0.3120718002319336,
-0.1333482712507248,
0.06301762163639069,
-0.22407299280166626,
-0.7243658304214478,
-0.8467373251914978,
-0.5566266775131226,
-0.46930792927742004,
-0.03260460123419762,
-0.22574514150619507,
0.2583869993686676,
-0.4267328977584839,
-0.10578183829784393,
-0.14529171586036682,
0.12954914569854736,
-0.6880599856376648,
0.14809735119342804,
-0.3102618157863617,
0.9751784801483154,
-0.6778876185417175,
0.9721707701683044,
0.5866255164146423,
-0.05432243272662163,
-1.0620330572128296,
0.023027172312140465,
0.11017636954784393,
-0.8846356868743896,
0.5469390749931335,
0.11714969575405121,
-0.34834760427474976,
0.20269908010959625,
-0.4641186594963074,
-0.9998900294303894,
1.0959111452102661,
0.6652204990386963,
-0.7803857922554016,
-0.20481762290000916,
0.08169738948345184,
0.29221218824386597,
-0.4105603098869324,
0.25375691056251526,
1.094027042388916,
0.5678921937942505,
0.3172677755355835,
-0.9035091400146484,
-0.013426383957266808,
0.17738857865333557,
-0.0770137682557106,
0.39683252573013306,
-0.35505107045173645,
0.5070331692695618,
-0.3999725878238678,
-0.12376230210065842,
-0.22039224207401276,
0.2834140360355377,
0.40792545676231384,
0.0660313069820404,
0.7506468892097473,
0.6211448907852173,
0.6695283055305481,
-0.09220279008150101,
1.1582075357437134,
-0.15757901966571808,
0.28780052065849304,
1.2103623151779175,
-0.22401957213878632,
0.8047078251838684,
0.64545077085495,
-0.4121995270252228,
0.3296491503715515,
1.1939924955368042,
0.26708465814590454,
0.42433270812034607,
-0.00427783140912652,
0.019213208928704262,
-0.5272661447525024,
-0.2768488824367523,
-0.0933176577091217,
0.4516744315624237,
0.47145193815231323,
-0.25654804706573486,
-0.33267152309417725,
-0.1654629111289978,
0.19794754683971405,
-0.09784472733736038,
-0.24655647575855255,
0.7808557152748108,
-0.15242189168930054,
-0.7351904511451721,
0.49958881735801697,
-0.1850024312734604,
0.6476518511772156,
-0.3365929126739502,
-0.13592983782291412,
-0.0566391795873642,
0.22000284492969513,
-0.2740766108036041,
-0.9544227719306946,
0.11672297865152359,
0.029674392193555832,
0.15190136432647705,
-0.15109564363956451,
0.4193299412727356,
-0.12334056198596954,
-0.654236912727356,
0.3888917565345764,
0.5798984169960022,
0.12156884372234344,
-0.1575690507888794,
-0.7756766080856323,
-0.0003055865236092359,
0.18033576011657715,
-0.3231973946094513,
0.02881428971886635,
0.32336536049842834,
-0.23195436596870422,
0.6459251046180725,
0.7498206496238708,
0.16396521031856537,
-0.17402197420597076,
-0.07332704216241837,
0.8993499875068665,
-0.45614203810691833,
-0.48168644309043884,
-0.9295527338981628,
0.5320006012916565,
-0.17437630891799927,
-0.14361679553985596,
0.6122668981552124,
0.5771639943122864,
0.778276264667511,
0.31959646940231323,
0.8764925003051758,
-0.032367076724767685,
0.8084662556648254,
-0.55148845911026,
0.18045644462108612,
-0.656550407409668,
0.4373812675476074,
-0.23724286258220673,
-1.0640960931777954,
-0.14127106964588165,
0.5073848366737366,
-0.7098528146743774,
0.10882546007633209,
0.4889615476131439,
0.9306080937385559,
-0.42023608088493347,
-0.053898248821496964,
0.0366254597902298,
0.34040820598602295,
0.5958566069602966,
0.6646681427955627,
0.5540812015533447,
-0.04827700927853584,
0.44131696224212646,
-0.33924874663352966,
-0.24866165220737457,
-0.34687426686286926,
-0.9700221419334412,
-0.8315282464027405,
-0.4111555516719818,
-0.22655414044857025,
-0.1977497935295105,
0.04368247091770172,
1.1882590055465698,
0.7765198349952698,
-0.6396822929382324,
-0.37161368131637573,
-0.4440118670463562,
0.23375630378723145,
-0.16518138349056244,
-0.20940561592578888,
0.5477163195610046,
-0.20247556269168854,
-0.8075085878372192,
0.4799520671367645,
0.3443572521209717,
0.006147729232907295,
-0.4483407735824585,
-0.23649495840072632,
-0.27768248319625854,
-0.09852515161037445,
0.6857370734214783,
0.1262403428554535,
-1.0678496360778809,
-0.46463361382484436,
-0.01735270768404007,
0.23830851912498474,
0.3160342574119568,
0.612644374370575,
-0.8860418200492859,
0.5513786673545837,
0.22072842717170715,
0.7885228395462036,
0.6529906392097473,
-0.12812499701976776,
0.6680164933204651,
-0.4809211492538452,
0.14512225985527039,
0.3671172559261322,
0.5177524089813232,
0.442109614610672,
-0.3069939613342285,
0.8182971477508545,
-0.06395798921585083,
-0.35899269580841064,
-0.9824569821357727,
0.21668538451194763,
-0.9865990281105042,
-0.2880098819732666,
1.1323010921478271,
0.026366975158452988,
-0.14757150411605835,
-0.12098117917776108,
-0.6796063780784607,
0.19506092369556427,
-0.5301768779754639,
0.6063807010650635,
0.6726930737495422,
-0.33636710047721863,
-0.24746915698051453,
-0.5713499784469604,
0.5237947106361389,
0.45431798696517944,
-0.917738676071167,
0.25343120098114014,
0.5533919334411621,
0.12574326992034912,
0.07147982716560364,
0.3368527889251709,
0.19976171851158142,
0.1773296743631363,
-0.23271137475967407,
-0.2782108783721924,
-0.18251512944698334,
-0.1744682341814041,
0.04718561843037605,
-0.013961456716060638,
0.5648036003112793,
-0.10051864385604858
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07589v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07589v1
|
Tag and correct: high precision post-editing approach to correction of speech recognition errors
| 2024-06-11T09:52:33 | 2024-06-11T09:52:33 |
Tomasz Ziętkiewicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents a new approach to the problem of correcting speech
recognition errors by means of post-editing. It consists of using a neural
sequence tagger that learns how to correct an ASR (Automatic Speech
Recognition) hypothesis word by word and a corrector module that applies
corrections returned by the tagger. The proposed solution is applicable to any
ASR system, regardless of its architecture, and provides high-precision control
over errors being corrected. This is especially crucial in production
environments, where avoiding the introduction of new mistakes by the error
correction model may be more important than the net gain in overall results.
The results show that the performance of the proposed error correction models
is comparable with previous approaches while requiring much smaller resources
to train, which makes it suitable for industrial applications, where both
inference latency and training times are critical factors that limit the use of
other techniques.
|
[
0.005560743156820536,
-0.4416889250278473,
-0.02426326274871826,
0.04426895081996918,
0.16010265052318573,
0.17239689826965332,
-0.3512404263019562,
-0.48718154430389404,
0.15416641533374786,
0.3136896789073944,
-0.04683494195342064,
-0.2509550154209137,
-0.7075977921485901,
-0.03129110485315323,
-0.25267335772514343,
0.5871257185935974,
-0.18166185915470123,
0.2314053624868393,
0.14307048916816711,
-0.16063274443149567,
-0.6697052121162415,
-0.7082480788230896,
-1.0037354230880737,
-0.39874398708343506,
0.5896508693695068,
0.3449080288410187,
0.6061922907829285,
1.1578075885772705,
0.8125795722007751,
0.31844571232795715,
-0.40195155143737793,
0.24005085229873657,
0.05485736206173897,
-0.3792102336883545,
-0.3860871493816376,
-0.42843636870384216,
-0.9724383354187012,
-0.18969106674194336,
0.8466642498970032,
0.6114514470100403,
-0.3255418837070465,
0.09699180722236633,
0.011009304784238338,
0.4207172691822052,
-0.5919638276100159,
-0.1238795816898346,
-0.7271275520324707,
-0.013064593076705933,
-0.24063389003276825,
-0.2909236252307892,
-0.4666889011859894,
-0.3795243203639984,
-0.1376284658908844,
-0.6358435750007629,
0.40518346428871155,
-0.18433202803134918,
0.8528537154197693,
0.5628034472465515,
0.184634730219841,
-0.12184814363718033,
-1.2714036703109741,
0.6368986964225769,
-0.8261783123016357,
0.4450327157974243,
0.21050472557544708,
0.22239260375499725,
-0.13918784260749817,
-0.6867931485176086,
-0.6196396946907043,
0.3623903691768646,
0.18005871772766113,
0.07930996268987656,
-0.27996841073036194,
0.2640179395675659,
0.6633564233779907,
-0.14973527193069458,
-0.3012557327747345,
0.34170153737068176,
-0.26239168643951416,
-0.3360004425048828,
0.7022382616996765,
-0.19123904407024384,
0.10498762875795364,
0.12810294330120087,
-0.02812785841524601,
-0.23584403097629547,
-0.6322574019432068,
0.1052098348736763,
0.2342006415128708,
0.3683907985687256,
0.36665570735931396,
0.522995114326477,
-0.17356908321380615,
0.9087656140327454,
0.0840810239315033,
-0.38507238030433655,
0.28250283002853394,
0.07182960957288742,
-0.4055968225002289,
0.5776352882385254,
0.43053460121154785,
0.45310354232788086,
0.12886933982372284,
0.039212729781866074,
-0.6112656593322754,
0.4590693414211273,
0.2966591417789459,
-0.23782432079315186,
-0.31714358925819397,
-0.07327147573232651,
-0.19846321642398834,
-0.03669526427984238,
-0.12350552529096603,
-0.506269633769989,
-0.3057462275028229,
-0.42680907249450684,
0.9183580279350281,
-0.16789960861206055,
-0.028520315885543823,
0.39469876885414124,
-0.21135224401950836,
0.0937357246875763,
0.5475981831550598,
-0.5616291165351868,
0.10446526855230331,
0.5057465434074402,
0.8184010982513428,
0.3222050070762634,
-0.269378125667572,
-0.7493460774421692,
0.33740970492362976,
-0.6369954347610474,
1.0930297374725342,
-0.28644880652427673,
-0.5269590020179749,
-0.02674584649503231,
-0.1961526721715927,
-0.11160855740308762,
-0.8070828318595886,
0.7036667466163635,
-0.5994238257408142,
-0.3494010865688324,
-0.4744167625904083,
-0.5625054240226746,
-0.08639322966337204,
-0.027733713388442993,
-0.37156569957733154,
0.8639578223228455,
-0.4205489158630371,
-0.5833455324172974,
0.4398517906665802,
-0.852306067943573,
-0.46796706318855286,
-0.018843920901417732,
0.09809428453445435,
-0.3626490533351898,
-0.051879871636629105,
0.015706485137343407,
0.19512291252613068,
0.24638265371322632,
0.11665854603052139,
0.1982719451189041,
-0.32027608156204224,
0.21238283812999725,
-0.06409340351819992,
0.49995043873786926,
0.09570025652647018,
-0.20756548643112183,
0.49935758113861084,
-0.976653516292572,
-0.04962005838751793,
-0.18097631633281708,
-0.7587124705314636,
-0.1789962202310562,
0.2901690900325775,
-0.16493003070354462,
0.14896808564662933,
0.07737057656049728,
-0.8048035502433777,
0.0401720255613327,
-0.39954277873039246,
0.562824010848999,
0.6867856383323669,
-0.1690874844789505,
0.5117061734199524,
-0.5649740695953369,
0.18837140500545502,
-0.21308325231075287,
0.11498275399208069,
0.01887247897684574,
-0.2873438596725464,
-0.9973199963569641,
-0.023005744442343712,
0.8404223918914795,
1.025534749031067,
-0.7559897303581238,
0.5551202297210693,
-0.21795397996902466,
-0.6802279949188232,
-0.6574961543083191,
-0.05136122182011604,
0.5441449284553528,
0.8421593308448792,
0.34490764141082764,
-0.6170722842216492,
-0.9253624081611633,
-0.2604825794696808,
-0.44048741459846497,
-0.2026178389787674,
-0.07009609788656235,
0.091891348361969,
0.18145804107189178,
-0.35778549313545227,
0.8551929593086243,
-0.42727532982826233,
-0.33364760875701904,
0.2974364161491394,
0.37964117527008057,
0.21577662229537964,
0.9963405728340149,
-0.03155280649662018,
-0.38817301392555237,
-0.11544325202703476,
0.037591785192489624,
-0.42142602801322937,
0.01501417625695467,
-0.05273756384849548,
-0.10159076005220413,
0.44656553864479065,
0.6972842216491699,
-0.6531153321266174,
0.6686508059501648,
0.15526656806468964,
0.2537633776664734,
0.6658972501754761,
-0.48560628294944763,
0.08622527867555618,
-0.8691279292106628,
0.1027829721570015,
0.12073305994272232,
-0.1498192697763443,
-0.822460412979126,
-0.3405954837799072,
0.21637605130672455,
0.08892375975847244,
-0.4355200529098511,
0.11045964807271957,
-0.2746155261993408,
-0.19801552593708038,
-0.2821003198623657,
-0.15575434267520905,
-0.06274081021547318,
0.11886021494865417,
0.06830201297998428,
0.7418652176856995,
0.2676420211791992,
-0.6452916264533997,
0.6853919625282288,
0.6251408457756042,
-0.24025380611419678,
0.49706122279167175,
-0.8201263546943665,
0.2522289752960205,
-0.31968581676483154,
0.14238889515399933,
-1.11695396900177,
-0.35687050223350525,
0.10965797305107117,
-1.0343056917190552,
0.5553366541862488,
-0.19814886152744293,
-0.5183875560760498,
-0.44638094305992126,
0.14593948423862457,
0.18454991281032562,
0.6151647567749023,
-0.4320235252380371,
0.31464698910713196,
0.4849172830581665,
-0.31913089752197266,
-0.7319743037223816,
-0.8478164076805115,
0.013694056309759617,
0.0878179594874382,
-0.44140520691871643,
0.43805739283561707,
0.03955504670739174,
-0.15778137743473053,
-0.25677481293678284,
-0.316092848777771,
-0.21609841287136078,
-0.08889901638031006,
-0.04727713763713837,
0.24161683022975922,
-0.35977259278297424,
0.34018728137016296,
-0.28221777081489563,
-0.3766825199127197,
-0.13748671114444733,
-0.18555335700511932,
0.48179182410240173,
0.23697532713413239,
-0.10434404015541077,
-0.8277495503425598,
0.22319422662258148,
0.23825013637542725,
-0.709202229976654,
0.213734969496727,
0.4659620225429535,
-1.0009406805038452,
0.14987416565418243,
-0.6821110844612122,
0.002290520817041397,
-0.4827483892440796,
0.33723047375679016,
-0.18850679695606232,
-0.36446550488471985,
0.5451827049255371,
-0.015924770385026932,
-0.003228098154067993,
0.2941712439060211,
0.15105898678302765,
-0.4863438606262207,
0.9981613159179688,
0.5172569155693054,
0.08397304266691208,
0.5675119161605835,
-0.17914944887161255,
0.345743864774704,
-0.8745028376579285,
-0.1433842033147812,
-0.8628960251808167,
-0.35944774746894836,
-0.14051900804042816,
-0.5589310526847839,
0.2363155335187912,
0.4436875581741333,
-0.28525295853614807,
0.4258960783481598,
-0.6784408688545227,
0.482224702835083,
0.9413511753082275,
0.12686268985271454,
0.1361912488937378,
-0.028794080018997192,
0.24424736201763153,
-0.04656854644417763,
-0.7992474436759949,
-0.5375801920890808,
0.5340081453323364,
0.23959094285964966,
0.7627820372581482,
0.01258584950119257,
0.47185632586479187,
0.16619981825351715,
0.10846676677465439,
-1.0828523635864258,
0.22326667606830597,
-0.29788073897361755,
-0.46639499068260193,
-0.3492600619792938,
-0.024718934670090675,
-0.5445412993431091,
-0.375235915184021,
-0.396371454000473,
-0.6345314979553223,
0.4364793002605438,
0.8135161995887756,
-0.9735603928565979,
0.7455922961235046,
-0.8567244410514832,
0.9141235947608948,
0.10199952870607376,
0.039114080369472504,
0.03648354485630989,
-0.9447224140167236,
-0.22378408908843994,
0.09021972864866257,
0.06959816068410873,
0.005561897065490484,
0.07150348275899887,
1.0965937376022339,
-0.3333999216556549,
0.6719426512718201,
-0.5112778544425964,
0.0366312675178051,
0.27702438831329346,
-0.059873517602682114,
0.6056379675865173,
-0.5636531710624695,
-0.34805217385292053,
0.03774946928024292,
-0.17652751505374908,
-0.06766755133867264,
-0.4601990878582001,
0.14614392817020416,
-0.6547874212265015,
-0.2585679292678833,
-0.5063119530677795,
-0.46442553400993347,
-0.2057395577430725,
0.20161215960979462,
0.461787611246109,
0.808330237865448,
0.13300837576389313,
0.10696402192115784,
0.7479737401008606,
-0.26724663376808167,
0.7192044258117676,
0.3404625356197357,
0.37305936217308044,
-0.6674103736877441,
0.7298645973205566,
0.7506303191184998,
0.16864484548568726,
0.4152041971683502,
-0.05818578600883484,
-0.347976952791214,
-0.8442152142524719,
-0.5275389552116394,
0.17513100802898407,
-0.6586652994155884,
-0.5947099328041077,
-0.6941134333610535,
-0.4129070043563843,
-0.7827558517456055,
-0.42974603176116943,
-0.5231927037239075,
-0.2197151929140091,
-0.3814096450805664,
0.06167158856987953,
0.5986528992652893,
0.6680812239646912,
-0.51042640209198,
1.0588515996932983,
-1.082166075706482,
0.1615709364414215,
0.11248263716697693,
0.5675697922706604,
-0.3164828419685364,
-0.697641909122467,
-0.22683991491794586,
0.24137991666793823,
-0.2039734274148941,
-0.7977978587150574,
0.3983144760131836,
0.4452188014984131,
0.24358732998371124,
-0.0054759979248046875,
-0.16574834287166595,
1.0838366746902466,
-0.8293306827545166,
0.5399938821792603,
0.16362996399402618,
-1.4025582075119019,
0.8426963686943054,
-0.390551894903183,
0.2317293882369995,
0.17267315089702606,
0.25765460729599,
-1.0311588048934937,
0.22576303780078888,
-0.6682731509208679,
-0.6477039456367493,
0.7830784916877747,
-0.2162817120552063,
-0.11658880859613419,
0.24378667771816254,
0.6890594363212585,
-0.36313462257385254,
0.1923675686120987,
-0.11574169993400574,
-0.003432661294937134,
-0.08550525456666946,
-0.1347254365682602,
-0.44028744101524353,
-0.40322890877723694,
0.041958387941122055,
-0.5118528008460999,
1.0207712650299072,
0.0027548223733901978,
0.43383216857910156,
0.655888020992279,
-0.1151309609413147,
-0.4608698785305023,
0.17513249814510345,
0.6407619118690491,
0.8437671661376953,
-0.25074952840805054,
0.06236957013607025,
0.5187222361564636,
-0.32841941714286804,
0.17691569030284882,
0.024889305233955383,
-0.04441414400935173,
0.24441073834896088,
0.014945611357688904,
0.728921115398407,
-0.15595360100269318,
-0.5261884927749634,
0.5574111342430115,
0.17863507568836212,
-0.10750341415405273,
-0.3199627101421356,
-0.054856330156326294,
-0.07410266995429993,
0.26785925030708313,
0.05222046375274658,
1.1305049657821655,
0.19518816471099854,
-0.07957569509744644,
0.5137901902198792,
-0.06297603994607925,
-0.34323838353157043,
-0.2527613639831543,
0.8352593779563904,
0.09895741939544678,
-0.9367272257804871,
0.161126509308815,
-0.35890039801597595,
-0.5649554133415222,
0.5556114315986633,
0.5960644483566284,
0.5266187787055969,
-1.0451687574386597,
0.0007982340757735074,
0.5434686541557312,
0.3396742641925812,
-0.4450450837612152,
0.4976333677768707,
0.40506741404533386,
-1.0242408514022827,
-0.9109378457069397,
-0.5353601574897766,
-0.7015742659568787,
-0.17638550698757172,
-0.8012143969535828,
0.45067402720451355,
-0.8954775333404541,
-0.2989351749420166,
0.4742220938205719,
-0.4760625660419464,
-0.2859970033168793,
0.573219895362854,
-0.020684147253632545,
0.7508072257041931,
-0.5291049480438232,
1.0262254476547241,
0.9637722373008728,
0.002246895106509328,
-1.0153943300247192,
-0.3225315809249878,
0.017182976007461548,
-0.5912029147148132,
0.39849984645843506,
-0.06291867792606354,
-0.1839572638273239,
0.20831610262393951,
-0.3165137469768524,
-0.8978455066680908,
0.5718662142753601,
0.37262484431266785,
-0.764568567276001,
-0.029791058972477913,
-0.01315001118928194,
0.4833128750324249,
0.20036059617996216,
-0.27557745575904846,
0.8113990426063538,
0.06184482201933861,
0.25184598565101624,
-1.2768727540969849,
-0.39781907200813293,
-0.2462645322084427,
0.20734156668186188,
0.3262629508972168,
-0.3956165611743927,
0.7875332832336426,
-0.06500731408596039,
0.018443280830979347,
0.047302041202783585,
0.5819215178489685,
-0.030804747715592384,
0.14524777233600616,
0.4824564456939697,
0.762620747089386,
0.9300222396850586,
-0.27417847514152527,
0.4775887727737427,
0.04544935002923012,
0.26407909393310547,
1.3128347396850586,
-0.39365264773368835,
1.2671297788619995,
0.25962474942207336,
-0.22512002289295197,
-0.04120737314224243,
0.6448476314544678,
0.04412633553147316,
0.22075366973876953,
0.30667591094970703,
-0.3763551712036133,
0.030132532119750977,
-0.3182036578655243,
-0.3549206256866455,
0.7456695437431335,
0.38920700550079346,
-0.07040949910879135,
0.18774794042110443,
-0.04721493646502495,
0.15568391978740692,
0.1779336929321289,
-0.5606805682182312,
0.9265672564506531,
-0.3395579755306244,
-0.41939035058021545,
0.6402963399887085,
0.2192392498254776,
0.9873566031455994,
-0.2563173472881317,
-0.07132000476121902,
0.2886393666267395,
0.5607587099075317,
-0.3722861707210541,
-0.44931474328041077,
1.0143135786056519,
0.24257485568523407,
-0.39088311791419983,
-0.28883811831474304,
0.9261683821678162,
-0.4507279098033905,
-0.4388883411884308,
0.0376143604516983,
0.038883987814188004,
-0.01964092254638672,
-0.2316664606332779,
-0.239924356341362,
0.2189614623785019,
-0.07381465286016464,
0.5836591720581055,
-0.6628475189208984,
0.10205056518316269,
0.2935846149921417,
0.14026987552642822,
0.562958300113678,
0.39944005012512207,
0.6376253366470337,
-0.156993106007576,
0.32359838485717773,
-0.6751237511634827,
-0.48297783732414246,
-0.5388942360877991,
0.7488577961921692,
0.03923724964261055,
-0.1665857881307602,
0.40335211157798767,
0.40882012248039246,
1.2439967393875122,
-0.07184012979269028,
0.9131366610527039,
0.0664481446146965,
0.9282174706459045,
-0.40841808915138245,
0.6257041692733765,
-0.252789169549942,
-0.030934037640690804,
-0.5204290747642517,
-0.7499081492424011,
-0.9676240086555481,
0.9979656338691711,
-0.28639742732048035,
-0.284368634223938,
0.36286434531211853,
1.0956262350082397,
0.13577669858932495,
0.06405303627252579,
0.19315893948078156,
0.42241716384887695,
0.19669818878173828,
0.3284856379032135,
0.7768593430519104,
-0.8342085480690002,
0.18186186254024506,
-0.3421948254108429,
-0.39279448986053467,
-0.1517261564731598,
-0.6669231057167053,
-0.19835452735424042,
-0.37501904368400574,
-0.6350975632667542,
-0.4827137887477875,
0.32379475235939026,
1.310492992401123,
0.6716856956481934,
-0.9739066958427429,
-0.4112778604030609,
0.04076080396771431,
-0.16934625804424286,
-0.31300896406173706,
-0.06534017622470856,
0.10811742395162582,
-0.3095400035381317,
-0.7142515182495117,
0.3006288707256317,
0.07656171172857285,
0.3150801360607147,
0.6493856310844421,
-0.00007762262976029888,
-0.3569094240665436,
0.05360643193125725,
0.49256420135498047,
0.3475264608860016,
-0.5623227953910828,
-0.7310109734535217,
-0.13396671414375305,
0.14001871645450592,
0.6187728643417358,
0.5833650231361389,
-0.3028268814086914,
0.7206778526306152,
0.6899116635322571,
0.9012837409973145,
0.17338250577449799,
-0.16401444375514984,
0.5297248959541321,
-1.0360794067382812,
0.1803259402513504,
0.2548598051071167,
0.497612863779068,
0.6265081763267517,
-0.29474762082099915,
0.2597670257091522,
0.5800389051437378,
-0.7263014912605286,
-0.8535706400871277,
0.025619158521294594,
-1.0269169807434082,
0.34309181571006775,
0.8376405239105225,
-0.21533863246440887,
-0.23320996761322021,
0.0337715744972229,
-0.6498576998710632,
1.063264012336731,
-0.216738760471344,
0.49936309456825256,
0.5847572684288025,
-0.09494534134864807,
0.0327141135931015,
-0.3594816029071808,
0.693105936050415,
0.3411574065685272,
-0.6171215772628784,
-0.028856081888079643,
0.48643791675567627,
0.3467157781124115,
0.4377423822879791,
0.4690702259540558,
-0.2090403288602829,
0.4674675762653351,
0.09714365005493164,
0.8028700947761536,
0.349882036447525,
-0.5459415316581726,
-0.8284947872161865,
-0.2410343438386917,
0.4198298156261444,
-0.7018360495567322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07096v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07096v1
|
Fast Context-Biasing for CTC and Transducer ASR models with CTC-based Word Spotter
| 2024-06-11T09:37:52 | 2024-06-11T09:37:52 |
Andrei Andrusenko, Aleksandr Laptev, Vladimir Bataev, Vitaly Lavrukhin, Boris Ginsburg
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD
|
Accurate recognition of rare and new words remains a pressing problem for
contextualized Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) systems. Most context-biasing
methods involve modification of the ASR model or the beam-search decoding
algorithm, complicating model reuse and slowing down inference. This work
presents a new approach to fast context-biasing with CTC-based Word Spotter
(CTC-WS) for CTC and Transducer (RNN-T) ASR models. The proposed method matches
CTC log-probabilities against a compact context graph to detect potential
context-biasing candidates. The valid candidates then replace their greedy
recognition counterparts in corresponding frame intervals. A Hybrid
Transducer-CTC model enables the CTC-WS application for the Transducer model.
The results demonstrate a significant acceleration of the context-biasing
recognition with a simultaneous improvement in F-score and WER compared to
baseline methods. The proposed method is publicly available in the NVIDIA NeMo
toolkit.
|
[
-0.41585347056388855,
-0.6509554982185364,
0.3169235587120056,
0.08916269242763519,
-0.6222805380821228,
0.01745450124144554,
-0.1441660076379776,
-0.29629218578338623,
0.3389676511287689,
0.2677445113658905,
-0.24816761910915375,
-0.36602410674095154,
-0.7330994606018066,
0.06174306198954582,
-0.5323525071144104,
0.3721388876438141,
0.061769381165504456,
0.23469220101833344,
0.1707463562488556,
-0.503355085849762,
-0.7805083990097046,
-0.3632164001464844,
-0.5156999826431274,
-0.2801227867603302,
0.3113674223423004,
-0.05608544871211052,
0.3884149193763733,
0.6385470032691956,
0.048914507031440735,
0.25985509157180786,
-0.7171539068222046,
0.05543762817978859,
0.1041136309504509,
0.23993976414203644,
-0.1714933067560196,
0.16854526102542877,
-0.11476964503526688,
-0.12155497819185257,
0.5918240547180176,
0.4305056929588318,
-0.00010356964048696682,
-0.14512233436107635,
0.12090844660997391,
0.10429951548576355,
-1.139771580696106,
0.002191455801948905,
-0.6766417026519775,
-0.057560887187719345,
-0.2634393274784088,
-0.7830604910850525,
-0.4380273222923279,
-0.3408222794532776,
0.47002553939819336,
-0.45086178183555603,
0.5570772290229797,
-0.2818109095096588,
0.45544353127479553,
0.2256620228290558,
-0.7794552445411682,
-0.2681136131286621,
-0.738172173500061,
0.8353283405303955,
-0.563306987285614,
0.6917737126350403,
0.23584915697574615,
0.28063100576400757,
0.06278245151042938,
-0.3521518409252167,
-0.4833938777446747,
-0.3158159852027893,
-0.09775897860527039,
0.056969791650772095,
-0.06832326948642731,
-0.07786684483289719,
0.3346547484397888,
0.17266137897968292,
-0.43386730551719666,
-0.16236914694309235,
-0.1267113834619522,
-0.7364718914031982,
0.3399815559387207,
-0.0016490695998072624,
0.021946556866168976,
0.05770449340343475,
-0.30289819836616516,
-0.16952788829803467,
-0.5950391292572021,
-0.14839637279510498,
-0.13875964283943176,
0.4305039644241333,
-0.08340476453304291,
0.2804596424102783,
-0.2087155431509018,
1.0502991676330566,
0.14154388010501862,
0.15261390805244446,
0.36733123660087585,
-0.36208951473236084,
0.13018323481082916,
0.33197951316833496,
0.5407295227050781,
0.1569925844669342,
-0.1099381372332573,
0.016043012961745262,
-0.38806745409965515,
0.4963819682598114,
0.02588406577706337,
-0.522826075553894,
0.2168237268924713,
-0.023510845378041267,
-0.3531137704849243,
-0.06426344066858292,
0.09041842818260193,
-0.43792128562927246,
-0.3402230739593506,
-0.03673503175377846,
0.561862051486969,
-0.2963919937610626,
-0.09250157326459885,
-0.12210828810930252,
-0.45681652426719666,
0.4210928678512573,
0.23869983851909637,
-0.45350685715675354,
-0.010419799014925957,
0.41866058111190796,
1.0252615213394165,
-0.2605845332145691,
0.12682969868183136,
-0.9539733529090881,
0.2716418206691742,
-0.12726956605911255,
1.0223757028579712,
-0.5827635526657104,
-0.8035631775856018,
0.13029587268829346,
-0.09330746531486511,
-0.06673381477594376,
-0.5594515204429626,
0.6528674364089966,
-0.6311613917350769,
0.214487686753273,
-0.19288891553878784,
-0.6333787441253662,
0.08354049921035767,
0.2552095949649811,
-0.7875969409942627,
0.8792771100997925,
-0.1433391273021698,
-0.9451109170913696,
0.5819002985954285,
-0.7275105118751526,
-0.7739002704620361,
0.17442892491817474,
-0.020475978031754494,
-0.18761982023715973,
0.2742781639099121,
0.40613853931427,
0.18302562832832336,
-0.09985775500535965,
0.2248576432466507,
-0.32587921619415283,
-0.771599292755127,
0.18256700038909912,
-0.5540182590484619,
0.7135298848152161,
0.30609437823295593,
-0.5174757242202759,
0.15839006006717682,
-0.5427420139312744,
0.11089476943016052,
-0.15955795347690582,
-0.6120783686637878,
-0.7616811394691467,
0.23464126884937286,
0.5021202564239502,
0.30212196707725525,
0.20104144513607025,
-0.8071365356445312,
-0.14084041118621826,
-0.31600645184516907,
0.6731956005096436,
0.4586220681667328,
-0.27743273973464966,
0.35653433203697205,
0.033410750329494476,
0.21022124588489532,
0.08218421041965485,
-0.05990627408027649,
0.04969792440533638,
-0.3223714530467987,
-0.5771008133888245,
-0.25962910056114197,
0.357614129781723,
0.46663373708724976,
-0.897858202457428,
0.5521515011787415,
-0.18344096839427948,
-0.2886272966861725,
-0.2430320680141449,
-0.4543409049510956,
0.5473118424415588,
0.5962427258491516,
0.5403257012367249,
-0.4121520519256592,
-0.5112172365188599,
-0.5831493735313416,
-0.7586444020271301,
0.4388199746608734,
-0.325930655002594,
0.5377860069274902,
0.1395197957754135,
-0.23384487628936768,
1.0628068447113037,
-0.42018941044807434,
-0.526158332824707,
-0.3783586919307709,
-0.004526742734014988,
-0.052232977002859116,
0.5100607872009277,
0.09806405007839203,
-0.8853498697280884,
-0.46960288286209106,
-0.18132923543453217,
-0.14681261777877808,
-0.25526776909828186,
0.5488522052764893,
0.26380467414855957,
0.25492310523986816,
0.5935571193695068,
-0.208720400929451,
0.6743348240852356,
0.4296039640903473,
-0.7199272513389587,
0.14027059078216553,
-0.059886541217565536,
-0.12065073847770691,
-0.9298405051231384,
0.1650129109621048,
0.19051259756088257,
-0.28693148493766785,
-0.7910454869270325,
-0.2864232063293457,
0.23650577664375305,
0.15640392899513245,
-0.6321751475334167,
0.8892192244529724,
-0.3584473729133606,
-0.06216316670179367,
-0.5580157041549683,
0.24306124448776245,
-0.059527479112148285,
0.07187850028276443,
0.566131055355072,
0.6890105605125427,
0.4380825161933899,
-0.7343610525131226,
-0.2246134877204895,
0.30246755480766296,
-0.19922509789466858,
0.3011656403541565,
-0.6556336283683777,
0.4489426016807556,
0.03037680871784687,
0.8544855117797852,
-0.5205304026603699,
0.22442911565303802,
-0.15714532136917114,
-0.3204449415206909,
0.08472201228141785,
-0.31832385063171387,
-0.24356390535831451,
-0.3664889931678772,
-0.13727013766765594,
0.9302652478218079,
0.16022789478302002,
-0.6676130890846252,
0.831673264503479,
0.4818769693374634,
0.2587074041366577,
-0.5065152049064636,
-0.5825372934341431,
-0.16666927933692932,
-0.08125477284193039,
-0.3313876688480377,
0.7448747158050537,
0.10676033049821854,
0.17466789484024048,
-0.22144261002540588,
-0.4149729907512665,
-0.2516217529773712,
-0.12017440795898438,
0.2226266711950302,
0.2938646972179413,
0.01125689409673214,
-0.2935241758823395,
0.004547359887510538,
-0.5363024473190308,
-0.31699419021606445,
-0.6447522044181824,
0.7697781324386597,
0.1884828358888626,
-0.04260166361927986,
-0.44235551357269287,
0.28629621863365173,
0.5108522176742554,
-0.3613171875476837,
0.39448651671409607,
0.5655234456062317,
-0.49744999408721924,
-0.06336403638124466,
-0.8439379930496216,
-0.4050423800945282,
-0.478985071182251,
0.29190927743911743,
-0.11725939810276031,
-1.0755716562271118,
0.33329567313194275,
0.2609623372554779,
-0.11877857893705368,
0.2575373351573944,
0.5832743644714355,
0.3236881494522095,
1.1769788265228271,
0.4591419994831085,
-0.36173906922340393,
0.9076616764068604,
-0.22780205309391022,
0.16621507704257965,
-0.9252824783325195,
-0.006664886139333248,
-0.5823109745979309,
-0.32838234305381775,
-0.544094979763031,
-0.5277864336967468,
0.49770355224609375,
-0.6400499939918518,
0.080967478454113,
0.43580886721611023,
-0.6582032442092896,
0.3160030245780945,
0.6742749810218811,
0.027702419087290764,
0.33113157749176025,
-0.08134946972131729,
-0.3430815041065216,
0.14734023809432983,
-0.6175855994224548,
-0.16334004700183868,
1.0084822177886963,
-0.06858167052268982,
0.378747820854187,
-0.2718355357646942,
0.33050525188446045,
0.2942184805870056,
0.4117361307144165,
-0.6196730732917786,
0.464023232460022,
-0.47310173511505127,
-0.9677361845970154,
-0.08149874210357666,
-0.46026530861854553,
-0.5531340837478638,
0.5101991295814514,
0.06996755301952362,
-0.5489954948425293,
0.41175100207328796,
0.5862030386924744,
-0.4659465253353119,
0.2941696345806122,
-0.4538460671901703,
0.7042689919471741,
0.09671436995267868,
-0.3603975474834442,
-0.28817522525787354,
-0.46823251247406006,
-0.013561097905039787,
0.37870049476623535,
0.05164385214447975,
-0.02085677720606327,
0.06584746390581131,
0.80145663022995,
-0.46715065836906433,
0.25782668590545654,
-0.8307031989097595,
0.04592549428343773,
0.44410404562950134,
0.06788074970245361,
0.6211310029029846,
-0.10037098079919815,
-0.1483277678489685,
0.3043051064014435,
-0.02901156060397625,
-0.2589722275733948,
-0.30075573921203613,
0.6045243740081787,
-0.30411413311958313,
-0.1982422024011612,
-0.5499475598335266,
-0.6354362368583679,
-0.2989082932472229,
0.07696975767612457,
0.6288270354270935,
0.665821373462677,
-0.22665081918239594,
0.15577355027198792,
0.38917386531829834,
-0.15800584852695465,
0.5777758359909058,
0.7308967709541321,
0.5176891684532166,
-0.4222724139690399,
0.8127959966659546,
0.12468747049570084,
0.05204857885837555,
0.4977111518383026,
0.34140971302986145,
-0.44929757714271545,
-0.49960920214653015,
-0.05978694185614586,
-0.03657892346382141,
-0.16586631536483765,
-0.16431698203086853,
-0.8143861889839172,
-0.31002309918403625,
-0.21065667271614075,
-0.5120024681091309,
-0.42886441946029663,
-0.12357106804847717,
-0.15482677519321442,
0.17385904490947723,
0.18554122745990753,
0.25418180227279663,
0.16639713943004608,
0.507665753364563,
-0.5219038724899292,
0.19038063287734985,
0.3156724274158478,
0.23387761414051056,
-0.16201633214950562,
-0.7138739824295044,
-0.03807654231786728,
0.06137687340378761,
-0.25495997071266174,
-0.6883786916732788,
0.6106215119361877,
0.060126256197690964,
0.09621031582355499,
0.4213602542877197,
-0.03379145637154579,
0.573943018913269,
-0.266052782535553,
0.3964935839176178,
-0.04945258051156998,
-1.2795665264129639,
0.5116364359855652,
-0.33891063928604126,
0.5876087546348572,
0.5208332538604736,
-0.2308482527732849,
-0.7160043120384216,
-0.2993149161338806,
-0.2957509458065033,
-0.9779670238494873,
0.8364385962486267,
0.036646097898483276,
-0.10974247008562088,
0.05684350058436394,
-0.05399290844798088,
-0.10595136880874634,
0.08699364215135574,
-0.5346070528030396,
-0.011022479273378849,
-0.38999223709106445,
-0.15176278352737427,
-0.18256007134914398,
-0.40951186418533325,
0.045734159648418427,
-0.27143290638923645,
0.6420446634292603,
-0.38601282238960266,
0.30929502844810486,
0.34936627745628357,
-0.478009968996048,
0.18889372050762177,
0.39051854610443115,
0.6182450652122498,
0.17611247301101685,
-0.23106707632541656,
0.15737375617027283,
0.40062376856803894,
-0.64823979139328,
0.10951272398233414,
0.3578769862651825,
-0.5608466267585754,
0.3487374186515808,
0.15427246689796448,
0.7004161477088928,
0.3807925879955292,
-0.5597996115684509,
0.697887122631073,
-0.10659970343112946,
-0.02733631432056427,
-0.35757142305374146,
0.04290297254920006,
-0.09233567863702774,
0.02403913624584675,
0.5318030714988708,
0.1163887158036232,
0.17428907752037048,
-0.0738479420542717,
0.13020984828472137,
0.7249718308448792,
-0.7898855209350586,
-0.3070582151412964,
0.6991091966629028,
0.3027145564556122,
-0.23976394534111023,
0.5183704495429993,
-0.14577746391296387,
-0.6676760911941528,
0.5569787621498108,
0.6137209534645081,
1.1108931303024292,
-0.484466016292572,
-0.1381787806749344,
0.3382147550582886,
-0.20807109773159027,
-0.12308617681264877,
0.438864529132843,
-0.38700515031814575,
-0.8703949451446533,
-0.2248528003692627,
-0.3109746277332306,
-0.23525385558605194,
-0.00317350379191339,
-0.6755197048187256,
0.45663613080978394,
-0.4365684390068054,
-0.37775447964668274,
-0.10456306487321854,
-0.11105181276798248,
-0.6809495687484741,
0.266624391078949,
0.3085578680038452,
0.9572222232818604,
-0.6894534230232239,
1.1455944776535034,
0.5173364281654358,
0.2815135717391968,
-0.8164032101631165,
0.2398187667131424,
0.15298892557621002,
-0.48803776502609253,
0.4300540089607239,
0.5009534358978271,
-0.25404098629951477,
0.009680100716650486,
-0.23316995799541473,
-1.0054242610931396,
1.2713980674743652,
0.09476764500141144,
-0.6466618180274963,
0.10109662264585495,
-0.20423251390457153,
0.36093828082084656,
-0.4491751790046692,
0.49183833599090576,
0.4965369999408722,
0.407482773065567,
0.09905324876308441,
-0.9322108626365662,
0.11929983645677567,
-0.14415764808654785,
0.19286540150642395,
0.18050672113895416,
-0.44736427068710327,
0.7999018430709839,
0.08491760492324829,
-0.20275522768497467,
-0.21904289722442627,
0.5350521802902222,
0.718099057674408,
0.5614778399467468,
0.9866904616355896,
0.29029232263565063,
0.12896935641765594,
-0.12267559766769409,
0.6582558155059814,
-0.34142500162124634,
0.3149722218513489,
0.9633678793907166,
-0.5939993858337402,
0.6914625763893127,
0.4006422758102417,
0.1545630693435669,
0.4307946562767029,
0.21871715784072876,
0.14045144617557526,
0.817704439163208,
0.10479237884283066,
-0.5335392355918884,
-0.12626919150352478,
-0.38088810443878174,
-0.4507327079772949,
0.5274226665496826,
0.3300059139728546,
-0.34613698720932007,
-0.16635951399803162,
-0.06478569656610489,
-0.06745322048664093,
-0.22583921253681183,
-0.324753075838089,
0.562473475933075,
0.052223365753889084,
-0.491528183221817,
0.37604063749313354,
0.1221940889954567,
1.2639847993850708,
-0.5813257098197937,
0.24782469868659973,
-0.16839736700057983,
0.24434342980384827,
-0.02587137371301651,
0.012244461104273796,
0.2686280608177185,
0.15796637535095215,
-0.27700841426849365,
-0.2728101313114166,
0.8354179859161377,
-0.43482670187950134,
-0.43066734075546265,
0.5480347275733948,
0.3003478944301605,
-0.38856521248817444,
-0.4215274155139923,
-0.23490749299526215,
0.1652102768421173,
-0.14892476797103882,
-0.06894134730100632,
0.16107086837291718,
-0.06704024225473404,
-0.3664475679397583,
0.5692856907844543,
0.5544717907905579,
0.01646912470459938,
0.1397291123867035,
0.23102766275405884,
0.7936670780181885,
-0.8229283094406128,
-0.9427407383918762,
-0.7260727286338806,
0.26688992977142334,
0.03424008563160896,
-0.3662876486778259,
0.5802676677703857,
0.6523470282554626,
0.6902562975883484,
0.07581620663404465,
0.7228701114654541,
-0.2991642653942108,
0.7268383502960205,
-0.23376043140888214,
0.772567093372345,
-0.43949005007743835,
0.13451708853244781,
-0.5073267221450806,
-0.8293043375015259,
-0.2873641848564148,
0.5850110054016113,
-0.45464736223220825,
0.17456385493278503,
0.6629366278648376,
0.90899258852005,
-0.14922498166561127,
0.18675830960273743,
0.17209890484809875,
0.11087328940629959,
0.3087931275367737,
0.5468843579292297,
0.9020460844039917,
-0.4168887734413147,
0.5560517311096191,
-0.17731043696403503,
-0.10387767106294632,
-0.3862956166267395,
-0.65347820520401,
-0.4973653256893158,
-0.6243053078651428,
-0.4013230502605438,
-0.35921788215637207,
0.14479368925094604,
0.8616975545883179,
0.8726686239242554,
-1.083103060722351,
-0.07215385138988495,
-0.04014383628964424,
0.12390755116939545,
-0.3875516653060913,
-0.26905277371406555,
0.3550839424133301,
0.31298092007637024,
-0.5711328983306885,
0.7544211149215698,
0.19267667829990387,
-0.1486755907535553,
-0.0061799599789083,
-0.010658039711415768,
-0.15434375405311584,
-0.0031315493397414684,
0.4306395947933197,
0.3202899098396301,
-0.676234781742096,
-0.4181908071041107,
-0.060721445828676224,
0.053269460797309875,
-0.040446873754262924,
1.3771406412124634,
-1.2578446865081787,
0.3776353597640991,
0.4386328160762787,
0.19297735393047333,
0.5688093900680542,
-0.08954931795597076,
0.6263999342918396,
-0.6513006091117859,
0.497892826795578,
0.335927814245224,
0.3802310526371002,
0.38323232531547546,
-0.01281630527228117,
0.08656281232833862,
0.4584580063819885,
-0.1270536482334137,
-0.8671373724937439,
0.06342674791812897,
-0.9060215950012207,
-0.09932082146406174,
1.028364896774292,
0.25110679864883423,
-0.01998327486217022,
-0.32140782475471497,
-0.07421044260263443,
0.409469336271286,
-0.6105142831802368,
0.6874034404754639,
0.16550332307815552,
0.23670291900634766,
0.36179211735725403,
-0.2171960175037384,
0.35422012209892273,
0.5185871720314026,
-0.30065032839775085,
0.009395214729011059,
0.554287850856781,
0.6813031435012817,
-0.014858570881187916,
0.6929674744606018,
-0.03473952040076256,
0.18349158763885498,
-0.13161256909370422,
0.007839417085051537,
-0.12667407095432281,
-0.07016408443450928,
-0.5667729377746582,
0.291169136762619,
-0.4384255111217499,
-0.3649735748767853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10267v1
|
Unused information in token probability distribution of generative LLM: improving LLM reading comprehension through calculation of expected values
| 2024-06-11T09:24:18 | 2024-06-11T09:24:18 |
Krystian Zawistowski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
LLM text decoding is key component for perceived LLM quality. We demonstrate
two experiments showing that decoding methods could be improved by manipulation
of token probabilities. First, we test few LLM on SummEval summary scoring
dataset, to measure reading comprehension. We compare scores from greedy
decoding to expected values over the next token distribution. We scale logits
by large temperature to increase the entropy of scores. This allows strong
improvement of performance on SummEval (in terms of correlations to human
judgement). We see improvement from 6-8% to 13-28% for 7B Mistral and from
20%-46% to 37%-56% for Mixtral, beating GPT 4 0314 result on two metrics. Part
of the gain seems related to positional bias. Secondly, we use
probability-based tree sampling algorithm, to examine all most probable
generations for given prompt.
|
[
-0.0721656084060669,
-0.46397995948791504,
0.4684962332248688,
0.18061572313308716,
-0.7181011438369751,
0.0481763519346714,
0.04937385395169258,
-0.5194543600082397,
0.18251825869083405,
0.2953709661960602,
-0.2986828684806824,
-0.6421325206756592,
-0.5434751510620117,
0.1657320261001587,
-0.34925124049186707,
0.6818140149116516,
0.1820223331451416,
0.26224157214164734,
-0.4023447632789612,
0.09263072907924652,
-0.37839752435684204,
-0.7039386630058289,
-0.7537124752998352,
-0.47720035910606384,
0.36014360189437866,
0.3162774443626404,
0.46799182891845703,
0.6341333389282227,
0.4727862775325775,
0.17113465070724487,
-0.45942190289497375,
0.06523524224758148,
-0.6073969602584839,
0.11006832867860794,
0.059649523347616196,
-0.9361021518707275,
-0.43982547521591187,
-0.10718237608671188,
0.5083357095718384,
0.4938967525959015,
-0.24149921536445618,
-0.04478835687041283,
0.28171807527542114,
0.7623006701469421,
-0.5291037559509277,
0.31851810216903687,
-0.5544265508651733,
0.25171205401420593,
-0.1957809031009674,
-0.836740255355835,
-0.729839026927948,
-0.14606167376041412,
-0.20619426667690277,
-0.5878342390060425,
0.48441144824028015,
0.18883007764816284,
0.4165569245815277,
0.3082672357559204,
-0.4373258352279663,
-0.30926910042762756,
-0.3632016181945801,
0.7691358923912048,
-0.6747366189956665,
0.30910706520080566,
0.7468287348747253,
-0.2287556231021881,
-0.12640982866287231,
-0.552697479724884,
-0.36004307866096497,
-0.14037229120731354,
0.10028395801782608,
0.4820035696029663,
-0.26141348481178284,
0.31326812505722046,
0.10739244520664215,
0.575934648513794,
-0.2950974702835083,
0.06648200005292892,
-0.21520043909549713,
-0.4612957239151001,
0.5793141722679138,
0.4411173164844513,
0.20522332191467285,
-0.2879496216773987,
-0.2042723298072815,
-0.5076118111610413,
-0.663496196269989,
0.2644749879837036,
0.6779360175132751,
-0.13567985594272614,
0.18163089454174042,
0.8007234930992126,
-0.1780642718076706,
0.6564992070198059,
-0.0594148263335228,
-0.20660100877285004,
0.3950888514518738,
-0.7459802627563477,
-0.218264639377594,
0.0557858906686306,
0.1946651041507721,
0.5172567367553711,
0.21202512085437775,
-0.13291920721530914,
-0.2569940388202667,
-0.19567790627479553,
0.012443223036825657,
-0.5730155110359192,
-0.2736029624938965,
0.16470961272716522,
-0.7576538920402527,
-0.425244003534317,
0.1780991107225418,
-0.6067520976066589,
-0.4765291213989258,
-0.2345113903284073,
0.10557347536087036,
-0.7277859449386597,
-0.18609187006950378,
0.20864887535572052,
-0.7497608065605164,
0.5066941976547241,
0.4356256127357483,
-1.2322295904159546,
-0.042405400425195694,
0.6065261960029602,
0.8564659357070923,
-0.3988562226295471,
-0.0846681147813797,
-0.2314527928829193,
-0.04910872504115105,
-0.3689862787723541,
0.8235018849372864,
-0.2897481322288513,
-0.4163462817668915,
-0.2667006254196167,
-0.34770798683166504,
-0.1796312779188156,
-0.6711010932922363,
0.6455727219581604,
-0.6635487079620361,
0.008326214738190174,
-0.23087383806705475,
-0.6551406383514404,
-0.03712236508727074,
0.23253385722637177,
-0.8385224938392639,
0.8899596929550171,
0.3253099024295807,
-1.062687873840332,
0.6140378713607788,
-0.2778361141681671,
-0.373206228017807,
0.03243512287735939,
0.22073769569396973,
-0.04067103564739227,
0.39178454875946045,
0.46404919028282166,
0.3172748386859894,
0.14139117300510406,
-0.023639585822820663,
0.08247154951095581,
-0.5854577422142029,
0.5645034909248352,
-1.0525394678115845,
0.9602577090263367,
0.45127084851264954,
-0.25358450412750244,
-0.05714403837919235,
-0.6229060292243958,
0.08288530260324478,
-0.20900903642177582,
-0.7415891885757446,
-0.2956092059612274,
-0.026091303676366806,
-0.0009276219643652439,
-0.3295132517814636,
-0.033103808760643005,
-0.3140955865383148,
0.20126588642597198,
-0.6728084683418274,
0.2711544930934906,
0.8480759263038635,
0.2987692654132843,
0.5100909471511841,
-0.41061779856681824,
0.7123177647590637,
0.4485189914703369,
-0.015083308331668377,
-0.2896922826766968,
-0.5467466711997986,
-0.7529320120811462,
-0.35612088441848755,
0.5184445381164551,
0.7198565006256104,
-0.9196176528930664,
0.3618756830692291,
0.02531293034553528,
-0.22099468111991882,
-0.5713245868682861,
0.09315553307533264,
0.12582573294639587,
0.3968906104564667,
0.22480268776416779,
-0.1886812299489975,
-0.4143083095550537,
-0.401937872171402,
-0.23065043985843658,
-0.4411771893501282,
-0.19001363217830658,
0.06436873227357864,
0.1304590255022049,
-0.11374900490045547,
0.9393184185028076,
-0.5584205389022827,
-0.05796238034963608,
-0.45606619119644165,
-0.08406875282526016,
0.4565613567829132,
0.36824825406074524,
0.26840803027153015,
-0.6900836229324341,
-0.07916595786809921,
-0.25715965032577515,
-0.7072897553443909,
-0.10493229329586029,
-0.07160067558288574,
-0.07372407615184784,
0.35322681069374084,
0.5521472096443176,
-0.5333698987960815,
0.5282270908355713,
0.41821491718292236,
-0.7555528283119202,
0.6639655828475952,
-0.3247583210468292,
0.3438994884490967,
-1.086883544921875,
-0.25437092781066895,
-0.1313980221748352,
-0.35660669207572937,
-0.4359096586704254,
0.25811636447906494,
0.012343757785856724,
0.32455524802207947,
-0.4489710032939911,
0.36545267701148987,
-0.6227213740348816,
0.04745020717382431,
-0.17584757506847382,
-0.08979357779026031,
-0.08442838490009308,
0.16751191020011902,
-0.23588572442531586,
1.0529667139053345,
0.3165200352668762,
-0.5504409074783325,
0.4224611818790436,
0.08069591224193573,
-0.653684139251709,
0.32328054308891296,
-0.5585576295852661,
-0.11735140532255173,
-0.4012748599052429,
0.3156924247741699,
-1.1949175596237183,
-0.12804603576660156,
0.23272541165351868,
-0.6357647776603699,
0.27641528844833374,
0.25874167680740356,
-0.7329721450805664,
-0.12523287534713745,
-0.40951085090637207,
0.4674030542373657,
0.809960663318634,
-0.5332980155944824,
0.4040321707725525,
0.11950645595788956,
-0.03640737757086754,
-0.7059996724128723,
-0.7620424628257751,
0.1562526375055313,
-0.4464065432548523,
-0.3811055123806,
0.22137710452079773,
-0.1777081936597824,
-0.3956011235713959,
0.07856498658657074,
-0.026058265939354897,
0.25570011138916016,
0.09358469396829605,
0.1589524894952774,
0.0963418111205101,
-0.05004800483584404,
0.21085241436958313,
0.06457584351301193,
-0.3464323580265045,
0.1094621866941452,
-0.35128548741340637,
0.6249209642410278,
0.117810919880867,
-0.31836751103401184,
-0.2844313085079193,
0.09155289083719254,
0.19932183623313904,
0.15744706988334656,
0.7265718579292297,
0.5832141637802124,
-0.19811156392097473,
-0.033188216388225555,
-0.43727582693099976,
-0.261427104473114,
-0.4307851791381836,
0.2824926972389221,
-0.4637066125869751,
-0.853874146938324,
0.7397750616073608,
0.13067947328090668,
-0.17344574630260468,
0.5283269882202148,
0.4420745372772217,
-0.3622671365737915,
1.0058774948120117,
0.6017439961433411,
-0.13447211682796478,
0.6072747707366943,
-0.3327311873435974,
-0.03735184669494629,
-0.7668138742446899,
-0.37897995114326477,
-0.1934223175048828,
-0.31915727257728577,
-0.37068888545036316,
-0.5446256995201111,
0.4433099031448364,
0.4349876642227173,
0.34451594948768616,
-0.0532296821475029,
-0.4133262634277344,
0.66029953956604,
0.9448326230049133,
0.5321733355522156,
0.5474206805229187,
0.30308836698532104,
-0.4149075150489807,
0.030079839751124382,
-0.7752825617790222,
-0.3146692216396332,
1.3885148763656616,
0.4132961928844452,
0.786421537399292,
0.12122511118650436,
0.8986226320266724,
0.5853185057640076,
0.35752028226852417,
-0.7704998254776001,
0.4258820414543152,
0.09664949029684067,
-0.46849778294563293,
-0.5642858147621155,
-0.6651216149330139,
-1.184611201286316,
0.31567299365997314,
-0.040198914706707,
-0.6374788284301758,
0.08528865873813629,
0.15136317908763885,
-0.021596577018499374,
0.2434484362602234,
-0.7503847479820251,
0.4089144170284271,
0.03311587870121002,
-0.010173890739679337,
-0.25086745619773865,
-0.5319181084632874,
0.5004640817642212,
-0.0006379790138453245,
0.0165586955845356,
0.06542396545410156,
0.02389414608478546,
0.7998590469360352,
-0.36715683341026306,
0.8229203224182129,
-0.148232564330101,
-0.13643698394298553,
0.5589338541030884,
-0.24160116910934448,
0.4498252868652344,
0.12449062615633011,
-0.48933836817741394,
0.06930509954690933,
0.1931183636188507,
-0.6720253229141235,
-0.5742402672767639,
0.23692357540130615,
-1.046372413635254,
-0.714440643787384,
-0.6136888265609741,
-0.6247531175613403,
-0.07913561165332794,
-0.15786778926849365,
0.7759100198745728,
0.45449382066726685,
-0.18792980909347534,
0.3093193769454956,
0.8266599178314209,
-0.188386932015419,
0.6160186529159546,
-0.04028625786304474,
0.2513662874698639,
-0.671463131904602,
0.6437338590621948,
0.008067016489803791,
0.3216874599456787,
0.6158836483955383,
0.25056347250938416,
-0.6878980398178101,
-0.7017441391944885,
-0.3451909124851227,
-0.08941435068845749,
-1.0128271579742432,
-0.4359971284866333,
-0.5483203530311584,
-0.28571435809135437,
-0.4723217487335205,
0.032933562994003296,
0.415986567735672,
-0.4567309021949768,
-0.7790259122848511,
-0.6214897632598877,
0.3773656189441681,
0.5787767767906189,
-0.1509183645248413,
0.4807744324207306,
-0.5040237903594971,
0.08196647465229034,
0.06348666548728943,
0.1298447698354721,
0.23349200189113617,
-0.7781912088394165,
-0.0871451124548912,
-0.03474593907594681,
-0.22332049906253815,
-1.0812917947769165,
0.5111947655677795,
-0.05515044182538986,
0.7735556960105896,
0.6385634541511536,
0.15546683967113495,
0.6812670826911926,
-0.12914618849754333,
0.8339004516601562,
0.30295857787132263,
-0.8975859880447388,
0.3263910710811615,
-0.12125413119792938,
0.3962689936161041,
0.6188828349113464,
-0.04863912984728813,
-0.3847050964832306,
-0.5823419690132141,
-0.8100362420082092,
-0.8138075470924377,
0.6552654504776001,
0.12870429456233978,
0.41650286316871643,
-0.09626349806785583,
0.5369351506233215,
0.21755024790763855,
0.025994645431637764,
-0.7143626809120178,
-0.34413400292396545,
-0.1725338101387024,
-0.5299027562141418,
-0.5435056090354919,
-0.6410990357398987,
0.06217600777745247,
-0.5410807728767395,
0.426192969083786,
0.04302094504237175,
0.4499616324901581,
0.2636846899986267,
-0.17585380375385284,
0.14015573263168335,
0.27145716547966003,
0.760527491569519,
0.7521259188652039,
-0.2661288380622864,
0.6258379220962524,
0.34661850333213806,
-0.7850641012191772,
0.33819618821144104,
-0.2895805537700653,
-0.266421377658844,
0.03143284097313881,
0.8087698817253113,
0.6873198747634888,
-0.08403163403272629,
-0.6735063791275024,
0.41844701766967773,
-0.04072542116045952,
-0.3780941069126129,
-0.2377784699201584,
0.3649080693721771,
0.16368499398231506,
0.21025067567825317,
0.7507112622261047,
0.00015463899762835354,
0.2350366860628128,
-0.5446107983589172,
0.3544456958770752,
0.2674752175807953,
-0.09716819226741791,
-0.11360541731119156,
0.6378230452537537,
0.08676007390022278,
-0.17426122725009918,
0.7568809390068054,
-0.4533275067806244,
-0.33252716064453125,
0.782801628112793,
0.9538602828979492,
0.5712430477142334,
0.01254168339073658,
0.32794392108917236,
0.3167630434036255,
0.4326082468032837,
-0.133528470993042,
0.3380906581878662,
-0.2837913930416107,
-0.8612363338470459,
-0.3938010036945343,
-0.6569799780845642,
-0.28772780299186707,
-0.16490188241004944,
-0.46793892979621887,
-0.03635212406516075,
-0.08717859536409378,
-0.12194976210594177,
-0.4756452739238739,
-0.015543371438980103,
-0.6381697058677673,
0.06563302874565125,
-0.22650626301765442,
1.1066819429397583,
-0.8258265256881714,
0.5514302253723145,
0.39025652408599854,
-0.2395213544368744,
-0.8970485329627991,
0.13648095726966858,
-0.2752157747745514,
-1.0550107955932617,
0.6087298393249512,
0.007887167856097221,
0.19262336194515228,
0.4353417158126831,
-0.46877092123031616,
-0.8636978268623352,
1.3819067478179932,
0.32620328664779663,
-0.3685702383518219,
0.13111694157123566,
0.03349432349205017,
0.6006044149398804,
-0.08830666542053223,
0.5220289826393127,
0.6938340663909912,
0.3122021555900574,
0.4019666314125061,
-0.3489777743816376,
-0.14053639769554138,
-0.1610383689403534,
-0.12257975339889526,
0.11629468947649002,
-0.39351919293403625,
0.4943169355392456,
-0.4864449203014374,
-0.38903605937957764,
0.008163318037986755,
0.7503183484077454,
0.6073943972587585,
0.768359899520874,
0.5179828405380249,
0.7875674366950989,
0.9828302264213562,
-0.0015270269941538572,
1.2203046083450317,
-0.1962367594242096,
0.21742017567157745,
0.44971492886543274,
0.2877028286457062,
0.9298347234725952,
0.6895583271980286,
-0.3938457667827606,
0.1792908012866974,
1.1331568956375122,
0.2655251920223236,
0.6887661218643188,
0.5201296210289001,
-0.5020315051078796,
-0.10889800637960434,
0.0018786466680467129,
-0.3643512427806854,
0.2516978979110718,
0.382855623960495,
-0.4976750612258911,
-0.006462037563323975,
0.15482771396636963,
-0.14102019369602203,
-0.16786067187786102,
-0.3890872895717621,
0.8811798691749573,
0.2643982172012329,
-0.6036588549613953,
0.43684449791908264,
0.18609769642353058,
0.7935386300086975,
-0.1780380755662918,
0.08017221838235855,
-0.6251437067985535,
0.0718967616558075,
-0.30991965532302856,
-0.9259491562843323,
0.04990437999367714,
-0.13504630327224731,
-0.22544556856155396,
-0.2976953089237213,
0.7461820244789124,
-0.2582601308822632,
-0.6473826169967651,
-0.04871707037091255,
0.6521971225738525,
0.5277542471885681,
0.06660879403352737,
-0.2895957827568054,
-0.04751848056912422,
0.1502569615840912,
-0.41739189624786377,
0.1400231420993805,
0.5776209831237793,
0.12200570851564407,
0.5789499282836914,
0.7649872303009033,
0.33612415194511414,
0.3278488218784332,
0.3002471327781677,
0.5974574089050293,
-0.7994192242622375,
-0.6714116930961609,
-1.0972490310668945,
0.25118428468704224,
0.03888402506709099,
-0.4181767702102661,
0.688641369342804,
0.5249402523040771,
0.7883503437042236,
-0.16672413051128387,
0.5066772699356079,
0.27830633521080017,
-0.021045317873358727,
-0.9843630790710449,
0.46210145950317383,
-0.23279406130313873,
0.253527969121933,
-0.11836391687393188,
-1.104110598564148,
-0.342037558555603,
0.44580456614494324,
0.03398376330733299,
0.021108366549015045,
0.8358210921287537,
0.5031710863113403,
0.186692476272583,
-0.14064185321331024,
0.5331957936286926,
-0.2855076491832733,
0.20131731033325195,
0.6689015030860901,
1.0313658714294434,
-0.39288511872291565,
0.4255183935165405,
0.1589725911617279,
-0.39053016901016235,
-0.4152766168117523,
-0.6934984922409058,
-0.7644328474998474,
-0.5499756336212158,
-0.07544788718223572,
-0.4160957634449005,
0.040483493357896805,
0.6302099227905273,
0.4488671123981476,
-0.5810337066650391,
0.07493070513010025,
-0.2695407271385193,
0.3391379117965698,
-0.5058041214942932,
-0.30652764439582825,
0.3550986051559448,
-0.4547107517719269,
-0.5528112053871155,
0.13198353350162506,
0.14469926059246063,
0.3069187104701996,
0.04871566966176033,
-0.23407946527004242,
0.3408900797367096,
0.1132531687617302,
0.7024951577186584,
-0.18573838472366333,
-0.6969534754753113,
-0.20412153005599976,
0.25776514410972595,
-0.2793773412704468,
0.06214834377169609,
0.8693901300430298,
-0.6269313097000122,
0.3465048372745514,
0.8735805153846741,
0.7065753936767578,
0.5462344884872437,
0.6187183260917664,
0.33474022150039673,
-0.7253301739692688,
0.10731745511293411,
0.22988508641719818,
0.3364628255367279,
0.1518957018852234,
-0.6923679113388062,
0.551864743232727,
0.47031325101852417,
-0.4357282817363739,
-0.6908183693885803,
0.12635838985443115,
-1.1418147087097168,
-0.2698464095592499,
1.4676804542541504,
0.10069046914577484,
-0.21010425686836243,
-0.10790915042161942,
-0.29173925518989563,
0.2793242037296295,
-0.3519026041030884,
0.7221603989601135,
1.0204699039459229,
-0.42382118105888367,
-0.5269967317581177,
-0.4700024127960205,
0.41725954413414,
0.5938242673873901,
-0.7946873903274536,
-0.151978999376297,
0.3499610126018524,
0.31517133116722107,
-0.18188968300819397,
1.0326088666915894,
-0.1470569372177124,
0.1499699503183365,
0.30361035466194153,
-0.0708753690123558,
-0.04892633110284805,
-0.12101349234580994,
-0.530086100101471,
0.23468554019927979,
0.2819107472896576,
-0.2977181077003479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07081v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07081v1
|
Efficiently Exploring Large Language Models for Document-Level Machine Translation with In-context Learning
| 2024-06-11T09:11:17 | 2024-06-11T09:11:17 |
Menglong Cui, Jiangcun Du, Shaolin Zhu, Deyi Xiong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) exhibit outstanding performance in machine
translation via in-context learning. In contrast to sentence-level translation,
document-level translation (DOCMT) by LLMs based on in-context learning faces
two major challenges: firstly, document translations generated by LLMs are
often incoherent; secondly, the length of demonstration for in-context learning
is usually limited. To address these issues, we propose a Context-Aware
Prompting method (CAP), which enables LLMs to generate more accurate, cohesive,
and coherent translations via in-context learning. CAP takes into account
multi-level attention, selects the most relevant sentences to the current one
as context, and then generates a summary from these collected sentences.
Subsequently, sentences most similar to the summary are retrieved from the
datastore as demonstrations, which effectively guide LLMs in generating
cohesive and coherent translations. We conduct extensive experiments across
various DOCMT tasks, and the results demonstrate the effectiveness of our
approach, particularly in zero pronoun translation (ZPT) and literary
translation tasks.
|
[
-0.3056599199771881,
-0.8826802968978882,
0.6827072501182556,
0.16798466444015503,
-0.3289314806461334,
-0.060285765677690506,
-0.5680488348007202,
-0.08864839375019073,
-0.29365265369415283,
0.27477550506591797,
-0.7109970450401306,
-0.6394182443618774,
-0.5222733020782471,
0.42625299096107483,
-0.5177231431007385,
0.8299555778503418,
-0.2811465859413147,
0.029120570048689842,
-0.47996577620506287,
0.13095572590827942,
-0.833907961845398,
-0.28570953011512756,
-0.7289655208587646,
-0.31704288721084595,
0.4144689738750458,
0.7627276182174683,
0.15258686244487762,
0.33068370819091797,
0.08485054224729538,
0.18067671358585358,
-0.01599215157330036,
0.683161199092865,
-0.4631187319755554,
0.36103111505508423,
-0.056959159672260284,
-0.330728679895401,
-0.2908225655555725,
-0.08125529438257217,
0.7979725003242493,
0.8416038155555725,
0.28176626563072205,
0.007989821955561638,
0.3193373680114746,
0.32074493169784546,
-0.2973092496395111,
0.25166329741477966,
-0.7634915709495544,
0.1068129763007164,
0.024319922551512718,
-0.40190720558166504,
-0.7648479342460632,
-0.051344990730285645,
0.17988221347332,
-0.7327768206596375,
0.37696531414985657,
0.22042830288410187,
0.6578176021575928,
0.1819484680891037,
-0.5919426679611206,
-0.37385293841362,
-0.36257264018058777,
0.7966211438179016,
-0.5369324088096619,
0.4237191677093506,
0.3660939633846283,
0.17063069343566895,
-0.460788756608963,
-0.5860816240310669,
-0.7243820428848267,
-0.2657555341720581,
-0.13361194729804993,
0.24158194661140442,
0.04062848165631294,
-0.1212194487452507,
0.2731700539588928,
0.3172747492790222,
-0.5419934988021851,
0.20958003401756287,
-0.0268641859292984,
-0.003008482279255986,
0.17393995821475983,
0.135745108127594,
0.29716917872428894,
-0.22870321571826935,
-0.49422895908355713,
-0.21228855848312378,
-0.8119164109230042,
0.11487746983766556,
-0.07993730157613754,
0.461642861366272,
-0.1763654202222824,
0.38866254687309265,
-0.14930754899978638,
0.8642008900642395,
0.2515409290790558,
-0.14717130362987518,
0.22822396457195282,
-0.3734873831272125,
-0.23295946419239044,
0.02164383977651596,
0.8093108534812927,
0.26109737157821655,
0.015364675782620907,
-0.2692752480506897,
-0.31770917773246765,
-0.4292885959148407,
0.05388429015874863,
-0.8098403215408325,
0.29808324575424194,
0.407424658536911,
-0.15324190258979797,
-0.1315687745809555,
-0.1633162498474121,
-0.46710526943206787,
-0.1860426813364029,
-0.3703020513057709,
0.424245685338974,
-0.6161264777183533,
0.11709938943386078,
0.07526767253875732,
0.03870539367198944,
0.374996542930603,
0.6169129014015198,
-0.8901061415672302,
-0.00038215951644815505,
0.62937992811203,
0.8639704585075378,
-0.20028056204319,
-0.424518883228302,
-1.0426265001296997,
0.3112412691116333,
-0.573081910610199,
0.5297995209693909,
-0.2859569489955902,
-0.31003496050834656,
0.16489407420158386,
0.07658123970031738,
-0.21505892276763916,
-0.557803213596344,
0.5528427958488464,
-0.44721874594688416,
0.42674171924591064,
-0.3774271607398987,
-0.7290704250335693,
-0.10678429901599884,
0.5835918188095093,
-0.20815928280353546,
1.1196184158325195,
0.23071442544460297,
-0.4933285713195801,
0.4282906651496887,
-0.7659590840339661,
-0.7086009383201599,
0.14682911336421967,
-0.24311703443527222,
-0.2795639932155609,
0.1563541442155838,
0.715411365032196,
0.9445781111717224,
-0.23989026248455048,
0.43572553992271423,
0.1332775503396988,
-0.3012752830982208,
0.11057332158088684,
-0.424735963344574,
0.5524081587791443,
0.17478615045547485,
-0.28244295716285706,
0.23478466272354126,
-0.3460146188735962,
-0.3837195634841919,
0.2191500961780548,
-0.23852753639221191,
-0.19435863196849823,
-0.3076399266719818,
-0.06587103754281998,
0.34832245111465454,
0.384763240814209,
-0.44083642959594727,
0.33578333258628845,
-0.44273725152015686,
0.5365452170372009,
0.4846592843532562,
0.07496491819620132,
0.6708971858024597,
-0.08978426456451416,
0.5910476446151733,
-0.06025415658950806,
-0.08445081114768982,
-0.861800491809845,
-0.33555349707603455,
-0.49598586559295654,
-0.45919930934906006,
0.05248747020959854,
0.434789776802063,
-0.8427234292030334,
0.49966785311698914,
-0.4361979067325592,
-0.05847261846065521,
-0.350354939699173,
0.229468435049057,
0.45492446422576904,
1.1548532247543335,
0.4650914967060089,
-0.037858448922634125,
-0.04127814620733261,
-0.5772374272346497,
-0.1399799883365631,
-0.008469725959002972,
-0.1733175367116928,
0.4536535441875458,
0.41439780592918396,
-0.21971838176250458,
0.9018025398254395,
-0.20861804485321045,
-0.3763360381126404,
-0.41182923316955566,
0.1842363029718399,
0.2449408769607544,
0.38290974497795105,
0.21654672920703888,
-0.7071499824523926,
-0.6740033030509949,
0.33620065450668335,
-0.8277519345283508,
-0.28012165427207947,
-0.41030535101890564,
-0.12020698934793472,
0.14636436104774475,
0.8733689188957214,
-0.5528507828712463,
-0.010576890781521797,
0.3157045841217041,
0.03971319645643234,
0.2882069945335388,
-0.5561957955360413,
0.11974015831947327,
-1.4329649209976196,
0.32627731561660767,
-0.19438335299491882,
-0.6318073272705078,
-0.6487539410591125,
0.1719820201396942,
0.5855750441551208,
-0.2635985314846039,
-0.5522244572639465,
0.7946450710296631,
-0.656215250492096,
-0.03854409605264664,
-0.14635682106018066,
0.5456984043121338,
0.24728015065193176,
0.4059249460697174,
-0.06207313761115074,
0.9438942670822144,
0.49724698066711426,
-0.6800996661186218,
0.08079998195171356,
0.5572314262390137,
-0.387744277715683,
0.6945405006408691,
-0.3079628050327301,
0.10827022045850754,
-0.18540117144584656,
0.5682875514030457,
-1.0823832750320435,
-0.6212001442909241,
0.13665050268173218,
-0.4420803189277649,
0.6206977963447571,
-0.07555396854877472,
-0.7105357050895691,
-0.24670593440532684,
0.012196335010230541,
0.2558032274246216,
0.3141585886478424,
-0.780119776725769,
0.2713777422904968,
0.057478904724121094,
-0.2951919734477997,
-0.5488367080688477,
-0.5232563614845276,
0.42917850613594055,
-0.31849801540374756,
-0.5149943232536316,
0.4066184461116791,
-0.07362984120845795,
0.13003486394882202,
-0.48417869210243225,
-0.030177608132362366,
0.16040629148483276,
0.1444801688194275,
-0.013692885637283325,
0.19182105362415314,
0.07378198951482773,
0.23847419023513794,
0.455348402261734,
-0.017155494540929794,
-0.09141162782907486,
-0.5137909054756165,
0.689237654209137,
-0.0941186398267746,
-0.1594262570142746,
-0.5632156133651733,
0.5081589818000793,
0.6735890507698059,
-0.3015972375869751,
0.5635918378829956,
0.5907737612724304,
-0.3817492127418518,
-0.4177842140197754,
-0.2676124572753906,
-0.31717395782470703,
-0.416552871465683,
0.38068392872810364,
-0.5819802284240723,
-0.984684407711029,
0.44066137075424194,
-0.33488455414772034,
0.07637961208820343,
0.25091731548309326,
0.6554424166679382,
-0.13991770148277283,
1.0236419439315796,
0.4609204828739166,
-0.11358491331338882,
0.6577939391136169,
-0.37237176299095154,
0.165963813662529,
-1.0122326612472534,
-0.19268499314785004,
-0.32836243510246277,
-0.11020059883594513,
-0.031085724011063576,
-0.5569055676460266,
0.6404730081558228,
0.29612913727760315,
-0.03525606542825699,
0.5500386953353882,
-0.2573871910572052,
0.46690550446510315,
0.3386531472206116,
-0.011550008319318295,
0.2825421690940857,
0.26296404004096985,
-0.4180859923362732,
0.06238172948360443,
-0.7804372906684875,
-0.4589991569519043,
0.7961240410804749,
0.2662535011768341,
0.35780903697013855,
-0.13903476297855377,
0.7027086019515991,
0.05632179602980614,
0.36634406447410583,
-0.9146414399147034,
0.3981519639492035,
0.012909915298223495,
-0.291877418756485,
-0.41827821731567383,
-0.5177239179611206,
-1.0386898517608643,
0.20347680151462555,
-0.05002289265394211,
-0.5301665663719177,
0.09010957181453705,
0.13070270419120789,
-0.21797969937324524,
-0.07460195571184158,
-0.5448240041732788,
1.0581388473510742,
-0.2533195912837982,
-0.29783323407173157,
-0.10529689490795135,
-0.7031876444816589,
0.07209480553865433,
-0.288372665643692,
0.27051281929016113,
0.11293110996484756,
-0.28087276220321655,
0.1231318935751915,
-0.269374281167984,
0.8640239834785461,
-0.16480065882205963,
-0.5893094539642334,
0.10808838158845901,
0.22892269492149353,
0.8290980458259583,
0.08810719102621078,
-0.1267700046300888,
-0.1078491061925888,
-0.4692818224430084,
-0.3927244246006012,
-0.5806740522384644,
0.6904646158218384,
-0.5100293755531311,
-0.4374167025089264,
-0.018649151548743248,
-1.0069514513015747,
-0.3749645948410034,
0.40443500876426697,
0.4954034090042114,
0.5523586273193359,
-0.2933237552642822,
0.18607383966445923,
0.8808989524841309,
-0.348443865776062,
0.49109166860580444,
0.5750138759613037,
-0.20928631722927094,
-0.2449323832988739,
0.7798790335655212,
-0.07397869229316711,
0.3869320750236511,
0.8277573585510254,
0.2455107867717743,
-0.4820992648601532,
-0.5090652108192444,
-1.0423336029052734,
0.05472814664244652,
-0.6402645111083984,
-0.19075971841812134,
-0.8285910487174988,
0.22193603217601776,
-0.4351574182510376,
-0.5539858341217041,
-0.07543370127677917,
-0.11199533939361572,
-0.22338028252124786,
0.07130520045757294,
0.20918789505958557,
0.4819289445877075,
0.34264177083969116,
0.3314191997051239,
-0.7408629655838013,
0.16439270973205566,
0.2130977064371109,
-0.07167266309261322,
-0.04672045633196831,
-0.8108504414558411,
-0.3110497295856476,
-0.1464315503835678,
-0.2829767167568207,
-0.7939541935920715,
0.4715782701969147,
0.22018983960151672,
0.4650435447692871,
0.41582658886909485,
0.15957136452198029,
0.6569187045097351,
-0.6437856554985046,
0.7848106026649475,
0.1667703092098236,
-1.082953929901123,
0.610866129398346,
-0.7711870074272156,
0.5322721600532532,
0.45811763405799866,
0.3843933641910553,
-0.8077837824821472,
-0.5744974613189697,
-0.25306791067123413,
-1.024259090423584,
0.6585134267807007,
0.016514118760824203,
0.3733757436275482,
-0.294826865196228,
0.42986470460891724,
0.3317972719669342,
0.2870814800262451,
-0.44622087478637695,
0.1579028218984604,
0.13176515698432922,
-0.27952590584754944,
-0.20899562537670135,
0.13373102247714996,
0.00018359428213443607,
-0.00984138622879982,
0.5797374248504639,
-0.6215022802352905,
-0.010203910991549492,
0.4709945321083069,
-0.5737720131874084,
-0.09458664059638977,
0.3676636517047882,
0.7304466366767883,
0.60463947057724,
-0.1475459784269333,
0.11188848316669464,
0.5796050429344177,
-0.025762105360627174,
0.038987208157777786,
-0.001365657546557486,
-0.2727108299732208,
-0.011480645276606083,
0.37061989307403564,
0.7480490803718567,
0.33562716841697693,
-0.724062442779541,
0.8641634583473206,
-0.07194822281599045,
-0.02723202295601368,
-0.11819043010473251,
-0.2992022633552551,
0.13743962347507477,
0.0848827138543129,
0.3050267994403839,
-0.18089574575424194,
-0.014631018973886967,
-0.39265498518943787,
0.0433904305100441,
0.4170681834220886,
-0.4911123514175415,
0.006000821478664875,
0.6622855067253113,
0.13456442952156067,
-0.12083017081022263,
0.552465558052063,
-0.179290771484375,
-0.4426284432411194,
0.3610135614871979,
0.7904829382896423,
0.8376255035400391,
-0.030850179493427277,
0.18726597726345062,
0.4365088641643524,
0.17934831976890564,
-0.27126583456993103,
-0.012850183993577957,
-0.5508471131324768,
-0.39237818121910095,
-0.5981862545013428,
-0.3466043770313263,
-0.550763726234436,
0.1608770340681076,
-0.5755952596664429,
0.27414101362228394,
-0.06503847241401672,
0.16859634220600128,
-0.3718566596508026,
-0.14550556242465973,
-0.5371915102005005,
0.07144017517566681,
0.19972191751003265,
1.0275367498397827,
-0.7292688488960266,
0.9034700393676758,
0.6127983927726746,
-0.42205387353897095,
-0.6019108891487122,
0.1883278340101242,
-0.2803841233253479,
-0.6324506402015686,
0.46648749709129333,
0.3598834276199341,
-0.18229122459888458,
0.22724640369415283,
-0.6741998791694641,
-0.41700106859207153,
1.1344876289367676,
0.7001091837882996,
-0.6275438666343689,
0.10250099003314972,
0.141431987285614,
0.3871248960494995,
-0.5664467811584473,
0.005091325845569372,
0.13865989446640015,
0.33848997950553894,
-0.08911202102899551,
-0.829248309135437,
0.15949440002441406,
-0.04562309756875038,
0.042189452797174454,
0.08842206001281738,
-0.6181690096855164,
0.7339559197425842,
-0.05637798458337784,
-0.24059012532234192,
0.07418292760848999,
0.7024279832839966,
0.1704753339290619,
0.3289209306240082,
0.5351674556732178,
0.29800617694854736,
1.0120596885681152,
0.1698669046163559,
1.1845998764038086,
-0.346639484167099,
0.18942879140377045,
1.2089914083480835,
-0.25527480244636536,
0.9524238705635071,
0.6112855076789856,
0.3734886050224304,
0.29442599415779114,
0.7252178192138672,
0.3091455399990082,
0.29693838953971863,
0.08247071504592896,
-0.5115405321121216,
-0.3355984389781952,
-0.24085818231105804,
-0.284016489982605,
0.18655240535736084,
0.40951114892959595,
-0.41551968455314636,
-0.24972805380821228,
0.260905385017395,
0.22933880984783173,
0.15421894192695618,
-0.2714959979057312,
0.7941941022872925,
0.23918722569942474,
-0.9800540804862976,
0.782333493232727,
0.0361337848007679,
0.5007693767547607,
-0.5656203031539917,
-0.06150360777974129,
-0.4333147406578064,
0.12850306928157806,
0.03190591186285019,
-0.6380332112312317,
0.03389196842908859,
0.23656001687049866,
-0.3780340552330017,
-0.7670860886573792,
0.5008763074874878,
-0.7486608028411865,
-0.21373184025287628,
0.3180486559867859,
0.6101205945014954,
0.34616637229919434,
-0.20841093361377716,
-0.37019482254981995,
-0.18250925838947296,
-0.21784795820713043,
-0.0790589451789856,
0.4705282747745514,
0.7066493034362793,
-0.31586843729019165,
0.5596248507499695,
0.6423195600509644,
-0.2586525082588196,
-0.07142898440361023,
0.09887174516916275,
0.6901368498802185,
-0.38762882351875305,
-0.5673375129699707,
-0.661045253276825,
0.366821825504303,
-0.055436886847019196,
-0.2356562465429306,
0.8869103193283081,
0.6312127113342285,
1.0464071035385132,
-0.1787433624267578,
0.7902757525444031,
0.1621401011943817,
0.2774827778339386,
-0.48044493794441223,
0.7556695342063904,
-0.742518961429596,
0.11582279950380325,
-0.2173449546098709,
-0.8083042502403259,
-0.3274441063404083,
0.5491485595703125,
-0.39514806866645813,
-0.24888195097446442,
0.7007015347480774,
0.8304674625396729,
-0.2706032693386078,
-0.23959140479564667,
0.5158553123474121,
0.1004302129149437,
0.33821672201156616,
0.6159252524375916,
0.7464590072631836,
-0.46081826090812683,
0.571537435054779,
0.22806674242019653,
-0.317476361989975,
-0.28941798210144043,
-1.0471407175064087,
-0.9653453826904297,
-0.609885036945343,
-0.13237646222114563,
-0.23589777946472168,
-0.18182829022407532,
1.1087620258331299,
0.779752790927887,
-0.7479318976402283,
-0.336084246635437,
-0.27969083189964294,
0.031930454075336456,
-0.31362247467041016,
-0.14745983481407166,
0.4049068093299866,
-0.9572745561599731,
-1.057464361190796,
1.0255961418151855,
0.28630080819129944,
-0.12612216174602509,
-0.17089244723320007,
-0.2881012260913849,
-0.052235860377550125,
-0.009762901812791824,
0.7806835174560547,
0.09131042659282684,
-0.6865010857582092,
-0.06519661098718643,
0.04016084596514702,
-0.3363053798675537,
0.0396285243332386,
0.7809558510780334,
-0.6601817011833191,
0.7210817337036133,
0.6931616067886353,
0.8678868412971497,
0.5219376683235168,
-0.16624410450458527,
0.7924342155456543,
-1.046354055404663,
0.1136559545993805,
-0.014520327560603619,
0.33502888679504395,
0.6002764701843262,
-0.44461649656295776,
0.3060324788093567,
0.03752056509256363,
-0.44810038805007935,
-0.8175116181373596,
0.2906125485897064,
-0.9403857588768005,
-0.21627791225910187,
1.042993426322937,
-0.40703481435775757,
-0.1815355122089386,
-0.0354720838367939,
-0.42638248205184937,
0.45810842514038086,
-0.4640357494354248,
0.5522427558898926,
0.43087148666381836,
0.07215254753828049,
-0.11589176952838898,
-0.7465425729751587,
0.3584316372871399,
0.5713489055633545,
-0.7669996619224548,
0.21248503029346466,
0.42837637662887573,
0.12897199392318726,
-0.09276565909385681,
0.4091770350933075,
-0.08628828823566437,
0.193900465965271,
-0.3639257252216339,
-0.02959110029041767,
-0.1947227269411087,
-0.4732409715652466,
-0.5689888596534729,
0.1598757654428482,
-0.0527920126914978,
-0.01770595833659172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07080v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07080v1
|
DARA: Decomposition-Alignment-Reasoning Autonomous Language Agent for Question Answering over Knowledge Graphs
| 2024-06-11T09:09:37 | 2024-06-11T09:09:37 |
Haishuo Fang, Xiaodan Zhu, Iryna Gurevych
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Answering Questions over Knowledge Graphs (KGQA) is key to well-functioning
autonomous language agents in various real-life applications. To improve the
neural-symbolic reasoning capabilities of language agents powered by Large
Language Models (LLMs) in KGQA, we propose the DecompositionAlignment-Reasoning
Agent (DARA) framework. DARA effectively parses questions into formal queries
through a dual mechanism: high-level iterative task decomposition and low-level
task grounding. Importantly, DARA can be efficiently trained with a small
number of high-quality reasoning trajectories. Our experimental results
demonstrate that DARA fine-tuned on LLMs (e.g. Llama-2-7B, Mistral) outperforms
both in-context learning-based agents with GPT-4 and alternative fine-tuned
agents, across different benchmarks in zero-shot evaluation, making such models
more accessible for real-life applications. We also show that DARA attains
performance comparable to state-of-the-art enumerating-and-ranking-based
methods for KGQA.
|
[
-0.3229372203350067,
-0.8683027625083923,
0.9034199714660645,
-0.08135562390089035,
0.02132812887430191,
0.2067653238773346,
-0.023096943274140358,
-0.10517142713069916,
0.09053054451942444,
0.5347737073898315,
-0.4557029604911804,
-0.6819145083427429,
-0.48284226655960083,
0.08531454205513,
-0.21305063366889954,
0.5503261089324951,
0.0011829982977360487,
-0.07226113975048065,
-0.527667760848999,
-0.31997641921043396,
-0.4331127405166626,
-0.21314357221126556,
-0.9513978362083435,
-0.6050266027450562,
0.6416353583335876,
0.11056926101446152,
0.9292814135551453,
0.7866342067718506,
0.13465826213359833,
0.41500362753868103,
-0.11308388411998749,
0.3941923677921295,
-0.3772573471069336,
0.5539419651031494,
-0.30582088232040405,
-0.5066002011299133,
-0.4809868633747101,
-0.1300024390220642,
0.47631531953811646,
0.5938075184822083,
-0.045386333018541336,
0.1443922370672226,
-0.3915786147117615,
0.6296036839485168,
-0.6504697203636169,
0.36776748299598694,
-0.558732807636261,
-0.3935380280017853,
0.3568977117538452,
0.10529372841119766,
-0.41579288244247437,
-0.48190581798553467,
0.034566085785627365,
-0.7957248687744141,
-0.3621216416358948,
-0.22886797785758972,
0.817043125629425,
0.8482526540756226,
-0.7816187739372253,
-0.2605748176574707,
-0.443231999874115,
0.5673587322235107,
-0.6447038054466248,
0.4138074815273285,
0.27863097190856934,
0.7567811012268066,
-0.18980064988136292,
-0.7243289947509766,
-0.6890660524368286,
-0.11615433543920517,
-0.13853074610233307,
-0.06385008245706558,
-0.10386049002408981,
0.2258225530385971,
0.06145196408033371,
-0.07760421931743622,
-0.7157954573631287,
0.024309150874614716,
0.1342608481645584,
-0.023551365360617638,
0.475630521774292,
0.2566128075122833,
0.3949226140975952,
-0.1361924409866333,
-0.038505103439092636,
-0.2859879434108734,
-0.6485228538513184,
-0.0013390774838626385,
0.23839442431926727,
0.31424814462661743,
0.1583855003118515,
0.4261227250099182,
-0.5248457789421082,
0.8640730381011963,
0.037801582366228104,
-0.2800757586956024,
-0.08287425339221954,
-0.07930497080087662,
-0.21461661159992218,
-0.29697033762931824,
0.5402628779411316,
0.18531334400177002,
0.1945144087076187,
-0.6074190139770508,
-0.25897350907325745,
0.1702539622783661,
0.12549279630184174,
-0.8160004615783691,
-0.38947001099586487,
0.4245901107788086,
-0.21362446248531342,
-0.13016262650489807,
-0.4351239502429962,
-0.24593335390090942,
-0.45342469215393066,
-0.5752131938934326,
0.622748613357544,
-0.44719648361206055,
-0.16411013901233673,
0.06741419434547424,
-0.1643102467060089,
0.41357696056365967,
0.46207714080810547,
-0.5394076704978943,
0.26759472489356995,
0.7794859409332275,
0.34955620765686035,
0.08196716755628586,
-0.24223639070987701,
-0.547722339630127,
0.27425482869148254,
-0.4112824499607086,
0.9276635646820068,
-0.5968858599662781,
0.15277883410453796,
-0.2342987358570099,
-0.1143905445933342,
-0.35225751996040344,
-0.691494345664978,
0.3122580051422119,
-1.024674892425537,
0.0042053284123539925,
-0.524394690990448,
-0.4953271150588989,
-0.3763091266155243,
0.8154934048652649,
-0.4600158631801605,
0.7851368188858032,
0.32329756021499634,
-0.2683033347129822,
0.1766490787267685,
-0.6741788387298584,
-0.3792082667350769,
-0.12729907035827637,
-0.1084173321723938,
-0.2233566790819168,
-0.6143196821212769,
0.489889919757843,
0.370381236076355,
-0.42170313000679016,
0.4388613998889923,
-0.14496152102947235,
-0.030558038502931595,
0.18380454182624817,
-0.08213712275028229,
0.9141845703125,
0.3135243356227875,
-0.2315189093351364,
0.17665132880210876,
-0.7620612382888794,
0.3200085461139679,
0.13318569958209991,
-0.11729609966278076,
-0.32524389028549194,
-0.0155140096321702,
-0.6371449828147888,
0.3419698476791382,
0.28596073389053345,
-0.3732491731643677,
0.3050083816051483,
-0.6032803058624268,
0.2619096338748932,
0.7217192053794861,
0.07449305802583694,
0.6425055265426636,
-0.39172127842903137,
0.7228224277496338,
-0.05508910119533539,
0.045580022037029266,
0.28257879614830017,
-0.2921086251735687,
-0.8129903078079224,
-0.3364178240299225,
0.2398003786802292,
0.5656150579452515,
-1.1554771661758423,
0.18599309027194977,
-0.25549331307411194,
-0.5471410155296326,
-0.4384259581565857,
-0.03108443133533001,
0.5925561189651489,
0.65291827917099,
0.2710758447647095,
0.2538636028766632,
-0.20508478581905365,
-0.6600466370582581,
-0.13506542146205902,
-0.2740454375743866,
0.19274041056632996,
0.400590717792511,
0.4435766339302063,
-0.34639039635658264,
1.0622456073760986,
-0.5333424210548401,
-0.021908100694417953,
-0.18733568489551544,
0.1720481961965561,
0.0597558431327343,
0.148828387260437,
0.7216873168945312,
-0.6927520036697388,
-0.6549564599990845,
0.17299188673496246,
-0.9083797931671143,
-0.2671951949596405,
0.13156826794147491,
-0.3073875308036804,
0.20189447700977325,
0.274711936712265,
-1.050392746925354,
0.347547322511673,
0.2196674346923828,
-0.5221059918403625,
0.4972204864025116,
0.0171258132904768,
0.15671567618846893,
-1.0381461381912231,
0.02425227500498295,
-0.5567079186439514,
-0.2700621783733368,
-0.5986779928207397,
0.32014229893684387,
-0.21770034730434418,
-0.09641896188259125,
-0.10443272441625595,
0.8494253158569336,
-0.37995633482933044,
-0.2848798632621765,
-0.46149101853370667,
0.41330480575561523,
0.03640935570001602,
0.6019414067268372,
-0.12127631902694702,
0.7629782557487488,
0.6137346625328064,
-0.6443771123886108,
0.4666695296764374,
0.5302243232727051,
0.023245923221111298,
0.381277859210968,
-0.5970499515533447,
0.33681556582450867,
-0.3724047839641571,
0.2802654206752777,
-1.0363709926605225,
-0.13079951703548431,
0.309771329164505,
-0.49899041652679443,
0.06300850212574005,
-0.20136865973472595,
-0.5691656470298767,
0.03265588358044624,
-0.05118098482489586,
0.6775578260421753,
0.4326689839363098,
-0.6154546737670898,
0.9316699504852295,
0.3339611291885376,
-0.04543645679950714,
-0.9122424125671387,
-0.08606048673391342,
-0.03868267685174942,
-0.027426110580563545,
-0.845776379108429,
0.11964365839958191,
0.010904618538916111,
-0.5890727043151855,
0.26801615953445435,
-0.03849351033568382,
-0.10956139117479324,
0.19718286395072937,
0.17492733895778656,
-0.18176013231277466,
-0.19822075963020325,
0.17328926920890808,
0.21565650403499603,
-0.28768691420555115,
0.010553251951932907,
-0.3311162292957306,
0.6274666786193848,
-0.016239872202277184,
-0.2743310332298279,
-0.25659698247909546,
0.19265151023864746,
0.7214499115943909,
-0.29238027334213257,
0.7997402548789978,
0.3095770478248596,
-0.21758577227592468,
-0.5422729849815369,
-0.3091656565666199,
-0.07605599611997604,
-0.44066259264945984,
0.09950803220272064,
-0.47160178422927856,
-0.7545921802520752,
0.74888676404953,
-0.12740154564380646,
-0.139719620347023,
0.2215729057788849,
0.5722481608390808,
0.005003673955798149,
1.0971814393997192,
0.37652072310447693,
-0.1604675054550171,
-0.060827307403087616,
-0.3735671639442444,
0.31965091824531555,
-0.45268407464027405,
-0.1789032518863678,
-0.7005791664123535,
-0.2828923165798187,
-0.32521888613700867,
-0.4629206955432892,
0.6246562600135803,
-0.12263299524784088,
-0.6845468282699585,
0.2884138226509094,
-0.47171688079833984,
0.7185024619102478,
0.5279353260993958,
-0.07334627956151962,
0.29198795557022095,
-0.34338560700416565,
0.0009958501905202866,
0.5847474932670593,
-0.655097246170044,
-0.41419389843940735,
0.9686159491539001,
0.12789089977741241,
0.705069363117218,
0.2768886685371399,
0.6704867482185364,
0.039636045694351196,
0.08772555738687515,
-0.8878158926963806,
0.8204813599586487,
-0.07101525366306305,
-0.4214685559272766,
-0.6497877240180969,
-0.5551245212554932,
-0.8464170694351196,
0.4115641713142395,
0.3348316252231598,
-0.6187198162078857,
-0.011126844212412834,
-0.07613427937030792,
-0.1476718634366989,
0.1319977343082428,
-0.595750093460083,
0.9029287099838257,
-0.04850119352340698,
0.06112038344144821,
-0.1437641829252243,
-0.7852967977523804,
0.265841543674469,
0.32239192724227905,
-0.13219612836837769,
-0.25990092754364014,
0.05603495240211487,
0.4536983370780945,
-0.7604362368583679,
0.7513198256492615,
-0.6231001019477844,
-0.42084914445877075,
0.41381028294563293,
0.32846832275390625,
0.7637348175048828,
-0.011027476750314236,
-0.03142460063099861,
-0.2633194029331207,
0.3436945378780365,
-0.3603133261203766,
-1.2285312414169312,
0.5515406727790833,
-1.1138980388641357,
-0.6441356539726257,
-0.24178364872932434,
-1.0025309324264526,
-0.4673011600971222,
0.16900360584259033,
-0.2588740289211273,
0.505587637424469,
0.27948814630508423,
-0.09810299426317215,
0.5362346172332764,
-0.08166718482971191,
0.209720179438591,
0.6006891131401062,
-0.09668058156967163,
-0.6083160042762756,
0.807963490486145,
0.19195574522018433,
0.34449076652526855,
0.6723517179489136,
0.0045258463360369205,
-0.5618492364883423,
-0.5814982056617737,
-0.43541476130485535,
0.43237704038619995,
-1.055371880531311,
-0.42731136083602905,
-0.5788490176200867,
-0.2647758424282074,
-0.6361203789710999,
-0.2153029441833496,
-0.227779820561409,
-0.6333253979682922,
0.023691153153777122,
-0.04014841839671135,
0.1769753396511078,
0.6015344858169556,
0.211908221244812,
0.32423365116119385,
-0.4566486179828644,
0.7071832418441772,
0.7059869170188904,
0.11465416848659515,
-0.02042471431195736,
-0.3849128484725952,
0.11866186559200287,
0.013185737654566765,
-0.12635311484336853,
-0.7304675579071045,
0.2566518485546112,
0.002676449017599225,
0.6328712701797485,
0.1288900077342987,
0.3408694565296173,
0.7524722218513489,
-0.12956611812114716,
0.5786614418029785,
-0.31588777899742126,
-0.7670530676841736,
0.36584198474884033,
-0.5809951424598694,
0.4149058759212494,
0.5048901438713074,
0.23709972202777863,
-0.3548128306865692,
-0.41009271144866943,
-0.22693045437335968,
-0.4946611225605011,
0.8372847437858582,
0.30942800641059875,
-0.25196176767349243,
-0.03337733820080757,
0.47164732217788696,
-0.028879866003990173,
0.08201313763856888,
-0.7541869878768921,
-0.4422151446342468,
-0.08178969472646713,
-0.3568434715270996,
0.24109099805355072,
-0.17507824301719666,
-0.32135137915611267,
-0.2679179608821869,
0.9780574440956116,
-0.5904878377914429,
0.2563612461090088,
-0.04043157026171684,
-0.2653804123401642,
-0.0018037180416285992,
0.1631491631269455,
0.30473873019218445,
0.7606568336486816,
-0.08564390242099762,
0.23021775484085083,
-0.029950788244605064,
-0.07906369864940643,
0.5061003565788269,
0.17925511300563812,
-0.47291886806488037,
-0.365545392036438,
0.20600031316280365,
0.48809969425201416,
-0.18032340705394745,
-0.7828406691551208,
0.4196905195713043,
-0.13293428719043732,
-0.21740172803401947,
-0.07526856660842896,
0.027289172634482384,
0.098781056702137,
0.6698354482650757,
0.09659645706415176,
-0.22600245475769043,
-0.03484535217285156,
-0.36638641357421875,
0.13254830241203308,
0.6332695484161377,
0.01356441155076027,
-0.20899128913879395,
0.5701543092727661,
0.0765312910079956,
-0.07460697740316391,
0.5118232369422913,
-0.6314998269081116,
-0.49962982535362244,
0.8567503094673157,
0.6067994236946106,
0.9630379676818848,
-0.021917114034295082,
0.6468474864959717,
0.17228367924690247,
0.19928394258022308,
0.2763962745666504,
0.3722582161426544,
-0.3806908428668976,
-1.0378059148788452,
-0.575786828994751,
-0.5997892022132874,
-0.33100131154060364,
-0.0996016189455986,
-0.28567489981651306,
-0.13518522679805756,
-0.3739505708217621,
0.0836038738489151,
-0.16491830348968506,
-0.014807122759521008,
-0.26237067580223083,
0.22121120989322662,
-0.02749793604016304,
0.6462516188621521,
-0.5379660725593567,
0.8424816131591797,
0.928638219833374,
-0.5109250545501709,
-1.1265615224838257,
-0.040668465197086334,
-0.266759991645813,
-0.8576960563659668,
0.9368072152137756,
-0.03511481732130051,
-0.377177357673645,
0.13316203653812408,
-0.5800299048423767,
-1.0805166959762573,
1.446662425994873,
0.9457123279571533,
0.1815526783466339,
-0.19760261476039886,
0.476908802986145,
0.4881267845630646,
-0.08193130791187286,
0.22815948724746704,
0.6770094633102417,
0.5349311232566833,
0.24349139630794525,
-0.9156709313392639,
0.18916605412960052,
-0.0783759206533432,
-0.20325465500354767,
0.33652353286743164,
-0.8503251075744629,
0.795055627822876,
0.11663931608200073,
-0.2162490338087082,
0.36428236961364746,
0.46305131912231445,
0.2998237609863281,
0.4383682906627655,
0.46765658259391785,
0.9832092523574829,
0.7540234923362732,
-0.13473647832870483,
0.7687415480613708,
-0.30485856533050537,
0.19146399199962616,
1.0275030136108398,
-0.45213088393211365,
0.3528948426246643,
0.20227019488811493,
-0.16253942251205444,
0.7524638175964355,
0.33815857768058777,
0.6612421274185181,
0.6085399389266968,
-0.01744178496301174,
-0.3212797939777374,
-0.5576679706573486,
-0.16252298653125763,
-0.025303546339273453,
0.6445028781890869,
0.15243743360042572,
-0.046682536602020264,
-0.5949015617370605,
-0.09216677397489548,
-0.03542052581906319,
0.23831386864185333,
-0.2801409661769867,
1.0172357559204102,
-0.06945519894361496,
-1.0341321229934692,
0.948880136013031,
0.0013841880718246102,
-0.10927292704582214,
-0.600970983505249,
-0.13882407546043396,
-0.3926379680633545,
0.15547797083854675,
-0.09163428097963333,
-0.6246216297149658,
0.192645862698555,
-0.2130785882472992,
-0.10280850529670715,
-0.1931532770395279,
0.9110939502716064,
-0.35479074716567993,
0.037008870393037796,
0.36103323101997375,
0.661627471446991,
-0.017200220376253128,
-0.2864924669265747,
-0.7163935303688049,
-0.2764662504196167,
-0.25322818756103516,
-0.15460330247879028,
0.3600941300392151,
0.7148080468177795,
-0.16195401549339294,
1.0953681468963623,
0.3590491712093353,
-0.3989095687866211,
-0.034569721668958664,
0.26832136511802673,
1.0412274599075317,
-0.5911895632743835,
-0.36364784836769104,
-0.5063762068748474,
0.3708173632621765,
0.12502311170101166,
0.05896279960870743,
0.6869512796401978,
0.3200545310974121,
0.568098247051239,
0.02357061207294464,
0.5376549363136292,
-0.13792192935943604,
0.4427548944950104,
-0.5624960660934448,
0.8041056990623474,
-0.3716772496700287,
0.12243033945560455,
-0.14263896644115448,
-0.7549954056739807,
-0.3112605810165405,
0.38748103380203247,
-0.4173240065574646,
0.05929502844810486,
0.5947272777557373,
0.9937729239463806,
0.2835896611213684,
-0.347023606300354,
0.47179698944091797,
0.16254933178424835,
0.48535579442977905,
0.5776121020317078,
1.024286150932312,
-0.37020984292030334,
0.6123928427696228,
-0.2940524220466614,
0.09094700962305069,
0.2924325168132782,
-0.49743884801864624,
-0.980107307434082,
-0.6875775456428528,
-0.21838171780109406,
-0.0667833685874939,
0.08803106844425201,
0.6822437644004822,
0.6860179901123047,
-0.6730438470840454,
0.02449645660817623,
-0.11280468106269836,
0.46865513920783997,
-0.34746024012565613,
-0.24342776834964752,
0.4873095154762268,
-0.6614980697631836,
-0.6093729138374329,
0.674911379814148,
0.3062278628349304,
-0.3263263404369354,
-0.2048078179359436,
-0.3359043598175049,
-0.2629140019416809,
0.0025795898400247097,
0.7368358969688416,
0.23945151269435883,
-0.7553610801696777,
-0.5100948810577393,
0.09051072597503662,
-0.04586321488022804,
-0.14459815621376038,
0.49320581555366516,
-1.1131292581558228,
0.457698255777359,
0.6671963930130005,
1.120845079421997,
0.24206526577472687,
0.37332960963249207,
0.4817080795764923,
-0.8721200823783875,
-0.044772129505872726,
0.45594322681427,
0.10029081255197525,
-0.043231844902038574,
-0.34511154890060425,
0.6032899618148804,
0.1640712469816208,
-0.89166259765625,
-0.7953548431396484,
0.2641376852989197,
-1.07346773147583,
-0.37158674001693726,
1.3335310220718384,
-0.059766992926597595,
-0.4086121618747711,
-0.19834691286087036,
-0.3052538335323334,
0.2738954722881317,
-0.301020085811615,
0.6328012347221375,
0.4207388460636139,
-0.3741225004196167,
-0.13211683928966522,
-0.10007336735725403,
0.4552345275878906,
0.5110587477684021,
-1.0708447694778442,
0.15261675417423248,
0.8070516586303711,
0.27183860540390015,
0.14507870376110077,
0.805826723575592,
-0.0118478462100029,
0.5426070690155029,
0.011592965573072433,
-0.09052523970603943,
-0.29657095670700073,
-0.5374947190284729,
-0.11630761623382568,
0.40914449095726013,
0.27406081557273865,
-0.180917426943779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07070v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07070v1
|
HalluDial: A Large-Scale Benchmark for Automatic Dialogue-Level Hallucination Evaluation
| 2024-06-11T08:56:18 | 2024-06-11T08:56:18 |
Wen Luo, Tianshu Shen, Wei Li, Guangyue Peng, Richeng Xuan, Houfeng Wang, Xi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have significantly advanced the field of Natural
Language Processing (NLP), achieving remarkable performance across diverse
tasks and enabling widespread real-world applications. However, LLMs are prone
to hallucination, generating content that either conflicts with established
knowledge or is unfaithful to the original sources. Existing hallucination
benchmarks primarily focus on sentence- or passage-level hallucination
detection, neglecting dialogue-level evaluation, hallucination localization,
and rationale provision. They also predominantly target factuality
hallucinations while underestimating faithfulness hallucinations, often relying
on labor-intensive or non-specialized evaluators. To address these limitations,
we propose HalluDial, the first comprehensive large-scale benchmark for
automatic dialogue-level hallucination evaluation. HalluDial encompasses both
spontaneous and induced hallucination scenarios, covering factuality and
faithfulness hallucinations. The benchmark includes 4,094 dialogues with a
total of 146,856 samples. Leveraging HalluDial, we conduct a comprehensive
meta-evaluation of LLMs' hallucination evaluation capabilities in
information-seeking dialogues and introduce a specialized judge language model,
HalluJudge. The high data quality of HalluDial enables HalluJudge to achieve
superior or competitive performance in hallucination evaluation, facilitating
the automatic assessment of dialogue-level hallucinations in LLMs and providing
valuable insights into this phenomenon. The dataset and the code are available
at https://github.com/FlagOpen/HalluDial.
|
[
-0.40470194816589355,
-0.8276225328445435,
0.4775559902191162,
0.5742248296737671,
-0.2780775725841522,
-0.031072085723280907,
-0.359585702419281,
-0.4928935766220093,
0.34865835309028625,
0.5806954503059387,
-0.4122154712677002,
-0.7230490446090698,
-0.5513913035392761,
0.22573985159397125,
-0.6703640222549438,
0.6215216517448425,
0.27997103333473206,
0.19640298187732697,
-0.192830428481102,
-0.12883052229881287,
-0.7298528552055359,
-0.5003823637962341,
-0.3226100206375122,
-0.12870866060256958,
0.2429317981004715,
0.08292899280786514,
0.6627098917961121,
0.18982554972171783,
0.48976483941078186,
0.27370408177375793,
0.11648093163967133,
0.13761422038078308,
-0.5558463335037231,
0.5427680611610413,
-0.0805707797408104,
-0.19456243515014648,
-0.34525707364082336,
0.023139623925089836,
0.4612932503223419,
0.7339703440666199,
-0.36973512172698975,
0.08893806487321854,
-0.054885439574718475,
0.5777483582496643,
-0.5846755504608154,
0.08854302018880844,
-0.9524656534194946,
0.2655206322669983,
0.09323619306087494,
-0.41155773401260376,
-0.4143398404121399,
-0.9328675866127014,
0.13399997353553772,
-0.2596127688884735,
0.16936147212982178,
0.17954732477664948,
0.5296453833580017,
0.720920741558075,
-0.04562370479106903,
-0.5163676738739014,
-0.5813185572624207,
0.5816918611526489,
-0.6378790736198425,
0.8771471977233887,
0.5531259179115295,
0.4390092194080353,
-0.23194003105163574,
-0.6511005759239197,
-0.42157745361328125,
-0.6854641437530518,
0.016658153384923935,
-0.0029223160818219185,
-0.15801642835140228,
-0.009316783398389816,
0.2726650536060333,
0.45681142807006836,
-0.784589946269989,
-0.21004369854927063,
-0.15671318769454956,
-0.32992464303970337,
0.500349760055542,
0.13575126230716705,
0.04066763073205948,
-0.4302068054676056,
-0.14595846831798553,
-0.04338747262954712,
-0.17965613305568695,
-0.4481082558631897,
0.19150564074516296,
0.02864573895931244,
0.24165251851081848,
0.5582761168479919,
-0.28403741121292114,
0.3792682886123657,
-0.07665105164051056,
0.034535836428403854,
0.3376821279525757,
-0.06756876409053802,
-0.30391544103622437,
0.45106035470962524,
0.8942711353302002,
0.48781028389930725,
0.1701185554265976,
-0.5904772281646729,
-0.20395013689994812,
0.1661497801542282,
0.5265892744064331,
-0.9515265822410583,
-0.44825494289398193,
0.4974738657474518,
-0.35185638070106506,
-0.22400452196598053,
-0.11987727880477905,
-1.1809414625167847,
-0.8290842175483704,
-0.274943470954895,
0.39584580063819885,
-0.4831889569759369,
-0.06517470628023148,
0.20272761583328247,
0.02925739251077175,
0.13843795657157898,
0.26889097690582275,
-0.6094340682029724,
0.5452128052711487,
0.8205403089523315,
0.9871214032173157,
-0.5187739133834839,
-0.3388528823852539,
-0.9249628186225891,
-0.23987068235874176,
-0.3907661437988281,
0.8726455569267273,
-0.6075699329376221,
-0.24196867644786835,
0.06465302407741547,
0.012834024615585804,
-0.09167961031198502,
-1.0094339847564697,
0.9067526459693909,
-0.29668450355529785,
0.003317252267152071,
-0.1807209849357605,
-0.39730340242385864,
-0.25234654545783997,
0.2790287137031555,
-0.7393825650215149,
1.0522511005401611,
-0.061399538069963455,
-0.5336596965789795,
0.4449200928211212,
-0.20589186251163483,
-0.2767271101474762,
0.08879964798688889,
-0.35484927892684937,
-0.3197168707847595,
0.23111195862293243,
0.022981388494372368,
0.38276904821395874,
-0.5165744423866272,
0.7404788136482239,
-0.2770925760269165,
-0.5707197785377502,
0.2836267054080963,
-0.6755837798118591,
0.5128649473190308,
-0.06590501219034195,
-0.6322667002677917,
0.1879391223192215,
-0.8135184049606323,
-0.08240216970443726,
-0.08549182116985321,
0.06784064322710037,
-0.15824788808822632,
-0.06771165132522583,
0.023644590750336647,
0.1421813666820526,
0.01805942878127098,
-0.33172520995140076,
0.002085912972688675,
-0.45994073152542114,
0.012169787660241127,
0.7242687344551086,
0.015500662848353386,
-0.02873789332807064,
-0.4279959201812744,
0.43163537979125977,
-0.22557561099529266,
0.10879900306463242,
0.20486636459827423,
-0.3131338357925415,
-0.8561896681785583,
-0.39374011754989624,
0.15158525109291077,
0.43363136053085327,
-0.34377148747444153,
0.7827378511428833,
-0.31260424852371216,
-0.5644855499267578,
-0.6456583142280579,
0.033383723348379135,
0.230830118060112,
0.31611111760139465,
0.44263017177581787,
-0.43042346835136414,
-0.6588292121887207,
-0.863929271697998,
-0.1894841194152832,
-0.21998538076877594,
0.06484280526638031,
0.24614490568637848,
0.4533407688140869,
-0.5217164158821106,
0.6229718327522278,
-0.2109815925359726,
-0.6460633277893066,
-0.02798016555607319,
0.3930932879447937,
0.16674023866653442,
0.1570461541414261,
0.08378704637289047,
-0.34495308995246887,
-0.1419803351163864,
-0.11850612610578537,
-1.0450412034988403,
-0.5018519759178162,
-0.28036677837371826,
-0.24142257869243622,
0.31555137038230896,
0.4884490966796875,
-0.6620153188705444,
0.39274004101753235,
0.6300801634788513,
-0.2645243704319,
0.8359737396240234,
0.06637633591890335,
0.3511018455028534,
-0.6450557112693787,
0.10103420913219452,
-0.36136776208877563,
-0.1996263563632965,
-0.4540177285671234,
-0.1297939419746399,
-0.2639895975589752,
0.12666161358356476,
-0.031592004001140594,
0.44447532296180725,
-0.16907016932964325,
-0.3787219226360321,
-0.023389989510178566,
0.4389074742794037,
-0.21395795047283173,
0.5636955499649048,
0.25139859318733215,
0.6176297664642334,
0.2595110833644867,
-0.38968318700790405,
0.5400776267051697,
0.29429692029953003,
-0.5426744818687439,
0.48783376812934875,
-0.6327786445617676,
0.2296266406774521,
0.13523396849632263,
0.255575031042099,
-0.9620795845985413,
-0.2555861473083496,
0.33049696683883667,
-0.2483600378036499,
-0.19210287928581238,
0.03722887858748436,
-0.5134523510932922,
0.06370402872562408,
-0.39554083347320557,
0.44550418853759766,
0.34727782011032104,
-0.6457722187042236,
0.6628668308258057,
0.3046890199184418,
-0.1538146585226059,
-0.465658962726593,
-0.15906181931495667,
0.43772202730178833,
-0.13677743077278137,
-0.5244829058647156,
0.17952071130275726,
-0.2521856725215912,
-0.3969739079475403,
-0.4218606948852539,
-0.3720949590206146,
0.1518103927373886,
-0.04053797572851181,
0.5798059701919556,
0.1595163196325302,
-0.018084943294525146,
0.08809477090835571,
-0.0832267701625824,
-0.11546933650970459,
0.47097092866897583,
-0.12158755958080292,
1.0778521299362183,
-0.19276933372020721,
-0.46307551860809326,
-0.5419979691505432,
0.02395283244550228,
0.6920472979545593,
0.1236223578453064,
0.4115246832370758,
0.6174231767654419,
-0.532292902469635,
-0.2742183804512024,
-1.1246099472045898,
-0.3221122622489929,
-0.35875192284584045,
0.3438570201396942,
-0.4669693410396576,
-0.5330433249473572,
0.38809627294540405,
-0.006736954674124718,
0.027179589495062828,
0.22593963146209717,
0.5581285953521729,
0.32650327682495117,
0.8639001250267029,
-0.039368096739053726,
-0.24885797500610352,
-0.00035467708948999643,
-0.010435588657855988,
0.25065702199935913,
-0.7494789361953735,
-0.41491106152534485,
-0.509782612323761,
-0.03313520923256874,
-0.4273841977119446,
-0.5717089772224426,
0.19707942008972168,
0.0638166293501854,
0.11848422884941101,
0.2029106765985489,
-0.6551398634910583,
0.294077605009079,
0.3159894347190857,
-0.050340816378593445,
0.7162213325500488,
-0.06403494626283646,
-0.10899139940738678,
-0.27240678668022156,
-0.3337970972061157,
-0.5822650790214539,
0.9393846392631531,
0.395119309425354,
0.6944047808647156,
0.0862780436873436,
0.6930161714553833,
0.6202825903892517,
0.1881415694952011,
-0.9078183174133301,
0.7904531359672546,
0.29614633321762085,
-0.3665873408317566,
-0.37997421622276306,
-0.5138979554176331,
-0.771508514881134,
0.4214121103286743,
-0.12244053184986115,
-0.8576197028160095,
0.17765673995018005,
-0.12681731581687927,
-0.12447226792573929,
-0.019603179767727852,
-0.2442276030778885,
0.8374027013778687,
-0.24932914972305298,
-0.4692247211933136,
-0.3944014608860016,
-0.3264079689979553,
0.5292147397994995,
-0.27603861689567566,
0.07538694143295288,
-0.1917712688446045,
0.3329191207885742,
0.7093982696533203,
-0.2251763492822647,
0.5983831882476807,
-0.18266206979751587,
-0.2628878653049469,
-0.14221754670143127,
0.592751681804657,
0.4930368661880493,
0.38180282711982727,
-0.14386144280433655,
0.46465814113616943,
0.06994957476854324,
0.10478831082582474,
-0.6515352725982666,
0.7295627593994141,
-0.4832015037536621,
-0.572039008140564,
-0.6008049845695496,
-0.4611520767211914,
-0.2820693552494049,
-0.04299718514084816,
0.1305002123117447,
0.3508381247520447,
-0.5606852173805237,
0.2769288718700409,
0.8272724747657776,
-0.3160819411277771,
0.11233214288949966,
0.24492470920085907,
-0.6737208962440491,
-0.4513155221939087,
0.9876660704612732,
-0.22913603484630585,
-0.011256563477218151,
0.11645569652318954,
0.10861006379127502,
-0.38290679454803467,
-0.7077023983001709,
-0.25312718749046326,
0.2895772457122803,
-0.639599084854126,
-0.09890655428171158,
-1.1627637147903442,
-0.4205435812473297,
-0.4752298593521118,
-0.0010661195265129209,
-0.44218844175338745,
-0.2991398274898529,
0.06413310766220093,
0.11598460376262665,
0.09266936033964157,
0.5074352622032166,
0.006079597864300013,
-0.3216593563556671,
-0.4729689061641693,
0.8284764289855957,
0.42553117871284485,
0.4094398021697998,
-0.057821184396743774,
-0.6673374176025391,
0.11355797201395035,
-0.14540638029575348,
-0.09729640185832977,
-0.6394646763801575,
0.45036378502845764,
0.04752156138420105,
0.5329076647758484,
0.46535518765449524,
0.28595519065856934,
0.7245094776153564,
-0.3411893844604492,
0.5918145775794983,
0.022643625736236572,
-1.014367699623108,
0.3376454710960388,
-0.04316899925470352,
0.1877932846546173,
0.9861690998077393,
0.25611642003059387,
-0.7269551753997803,
-0.7581154108047485,
-0.24291740357875824,
-0.617514967918396,
0.46569913625717163,
0.49903374910354614,
-0.15358573198318481,
-0.10878698527812958,
-0.06532451510429382,
0.4248494803905487,
0.3546271324157715,
-0.8184611797332764,
0.1668580025434494,
-0.3465365469455719,
-0.09166347235441208,
0.04503806680440903,
-0.26662278175354004,
-0.2049442082643509,
-0.36824703216552734,
0.7371130585670471,
-0.0006600828492082655,
0.33437827229499817,
0.3557209074497223,
-0.5385196805000305,
-0.04638012871146202,
0.15962907671928406,
0.6029248237609863,
0.5832809805870056,
-0.680822491645813,
0.2099059671163559,
0.2781676650047302,
-0.5994056463241577,
0.0346994586288929,
0.3036831021308899,
0.09737331420183182,
0.3608902096748352,
0.3774445354938507,
0.6507011651992798,
0.18693742156028748,
-1.1242263317108154,
0.5829828381538391,
-0.3473324477672577,
-0.22152036428451538,
-0.6457170248031616,
0.07851439714431763,
-0.19869787991046906,
0.3304627239704132,
0.3422129452228546,
-0.11574294418096542,
0.5429144501686096,
-0.6960784792900085,
0.3206638693809509,
0.5401418209075928,
-0.620714008808136,
-0.13201473653316498,
0.6817117929458618,
0.13385628163814545,
-0.49998554587364197,
0.6683456897735596,
-0.2803804278373718,
-0.570746123790741,
0.23023591935634613,
0.2984943687915802,
1.3192464113235474,
-0.17476113140583038,
0.33091720938682556,
0.459952175617218,
0.4674535393714905,
-0.09131729602813721,
0.13659265637397766,
-0.2680028975009918,
-0.5062042474746704,
-0.06914371252059937,
-0.9238730072975159,
-0.4620373845100403,
0.43798598647117615,
-0.6018714308738708,
0.20744362473487854,
-0.4767756760120392,
-0.08292791992425919,
-0.1537255346775055,
-0.07798182219266891,
-0.38808131217956543,
0.032204896211624146,
0.025490177795290947,
0.7311757802963257,
-0.46699783205986023,
0.5370787382125854,
0.04239659756422043,
-0.1320035755634308,
-0.046778354793787,
0.33942607045173645,
0.054012563079595566,
-0.5413795113563538,
0.5356066226959229,
0.5032901763916016,
-0.4592247009277344,
-0.26302120089530945,
-0.1508328765630722,
-0.3412027359008789,
0.8850628733634949,
0.2164716124534607,
-0.7350346446037292,
-0.06196009740233421,
0.3862035274505615,
0.543298602104187,
-0.3278629183769226,
0.40419504046440125,
0.9694497585296631,
0.5213932394981384,
0.14049741625785828,
-0.7783312797546387,
0.32516005635261536,
-0.32049092650413513,
-0.25687548518180847,
0.02888525277376175,
-0.44728174805641174,
0.28610262274742126,
0.20142334699630737,
-0.11447212845087051,
0.27124103903770447,
0.44826462864875793,
0.38631048798561096,
0.378150999546051,
0.6931960582733154,
0.4840700924396515,
0.8376500606536865,
-0.1596069037914276,
0.5819743275642395,
-0.4483788311481476,
-0.09366684406995773,
1.327986717224121,
-0.5696384906768799,
0.7121806740760803,
0.3893071711063385,
0.22226746380329132,
0.2998555898666382,
0.3234094977378845,
-0.20094649493694305,
0.4206036627292633,
0.37002962827682495,
-0.2809115946292877,
-0.16475144028663635,
-0.24835249781608582,
-0.43909648060798645,
0.4686095714569092,
0.29341191053390503,
-0.21162617206573486,
0.12772704660892487,
0.039056017994880676,
-0.25286275148391724,
-0.082132488489151,
0.25876912474632263,
0.9625696539878845,
-0.04918272793292999,
-0.849224328994751,
0.9407431483268738,
-0.3607425391674042,
0.45258790254592896,
-0.3822873830795288,
-0.1912863403558731,
-0.4045998156070709,
-0.034896086901426315,
-0.20924440026283264,
-0.26090681552886963,
0.28981366753578186,
0.005501888692378998,
0.18767185509204865,
0.027632536366581917,
0.4492507874965668,
-0.346329003572464,
-0.2900952100753784,
0.6368706822395325,
0.30229759216308594,
0.5271970629692078,
-0.36346784234046936,
-0.4789229929447174,
0.5497824549674988,
-0.07168105989694595,
-0.11118427664041519,
-0.05429426208138466,
0.5111039280891418,
0.07866895198822021,
0.6173363924026489,
0.48896658420562744,
0.1476026475429535,
0.026258569210767746,
0.5917895436286926,
0.7553984522819519,
-0.8445852994918823,
-0.03708888962864876,
-0.7081494331359863,
0.1964513659477234,
-0.3662620782852173,
-0.3879520297050476,
0.7229699492454529,
0.8575712442398071,
0.6160795092582703,
0.16314099729061127,
0.6347236037254333,
0.1566176414489746,
0.3098936975002289,
-0.6275588870048523,
0.639014482498169,
-0.44058892130851746,
0.43491843342781067,
-0.6006539463996887,
-1.5014084577560425,
-0.18288959562778473,
0.8879733681678772,
-0.1856074333190918,
-0.10036978125572205,
0.9555172324180603,
1.0615284442901611,
-0.03790045529603958,
0.42258507013320923,
0.55164635181427,
0.4822569489479065,
0.13667450845241547,
0.3738633990287781,
1.2117620706558228,
-0.36261653900146484,
0.5422561168670654,
-0.19852282106876373,
-0.22443802654743195,
-0.46512532234191895,
-0.5615843534469604,
-1.2523329257965088,
-0.5796793699264526,
-0.28243377804756165,
-0.36552783846855164,
0.27052730321884155,
1.1547185182571411,
0.5494428873062134,
-0.8260132074356079,
-0.4165685772895813,
-0.29458141326904297,
-0.012349184602499008,
-0.09174004942178726,
-0.2607499063014984,
0.11753317713737488,
-0.40517282485961914,
-0.6853690147399902,
0.5513693690299988,
0.5006000995635986,
-0.24275632202625275,
-0.580736517906189,
-0.19361643493175507,
-0.03209991380572319,
0.24664852023124695,
0.6467786431312561,
-0.13324137032032013,
-0.8472791910171509,
-0.12648895382881165,
-0.002313116332516074,
-0.09401527047157288,
0.13146604597568512,
0.7789265513420105,
-0.7829110622406006,
0.540870189666748,
0.3359513282775879,
0.6519924998283386,
0.4665035605430603,
-0.056235093623399734,
0.427914023399353,
-0.22476865351200104,
0.06740334630012512,
0.50601726770401,
0.0940014123916626,
0.2270965874195099,
-0.20573222637176514,
0.6722450256347656,
0.10561522096395493,
-0.6161153316497803,
-1.211989164352417,
-0.07891179621219635,
-1.0191813707351685,
-0.14821650087833405,
1.0682843923568726,
0.31016644835472107,
0.04403601214289665,
-0.36527153849601746,
-0.36217111349105835,
0.1346239447593689,
-0.506627082824707,
1.504388451576233,
0.8199154734611511,
0.07299543172121048,
-0.0414654016494751,
-0.7041884660720825,
0.6891086101531982,
0.6147592663764954,
-1.0968730449676514,
0.502331018447876,
0.7677809596061707,
-0.27882570028305054,
0.18009847402572632,
0.5291874408721924,
-0.05847587063908577,
0.26158639788627625,
0.03263929486274719,
0.04812418296933174,
0.28954508900642395,
-0.737730085849762,
-0.38025587797164917,
0.2373102307319641,
-0.055529385805130005,
0.22243598103523254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07060v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07060v1
|
Reading Miscue Detection in Primary School through Automatic Speech Recognition
| 2024-06-11T08:41:21 | 2024-06-11T08:41:21 |
Lingyun Gao, Cristian Tejedor-Garcia, Helmer Strik, Catia Cucchiarini
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Automatic reading diagnosis systems can benefit both teachers for more
efficient scoring of reading exercises and students for accessing reading
exercises with feedback more easily. However, there are limited studies on
Automatic Speech Recognition (ASR) for child speech in languages other than
English, and limited research on ASR-based reading diagnosis systems. This
study investigates how efficiently state-of-the-art (SOTA) pretrained ASR
models recognize Dutch native children speech and manage to detect reading
miscues. We found that Hubert Large finetuned on Dutch speech achieves SOTA
phoneme-level child speech recognition (PER at 23.1\%), while Whisper (Faster
Whisper Large-v2) achieves SOTA word-level performance (WER at 9.8\%). Our
findings suggest that Wav2Vec2 Large and Whisper are the two best ASR models
for reading miscue detection. Specifically, Wav2Vec2 Large shows the highest
recall at 0.83, whereas Whisper exhibits the highest precision at 0.52 and an
F1 score of 0.52.
|
[
-0.3299029767513275,
-0.4426935613155365,
0.19501525163650513,
0.13642531633377075,
-0.21681444346904755,
-0.19130346179008484,
-0.05988183617591858,
-0.906295895576477,
-0.16930119693279266,
0.3488367199897766,
-0.4165927469730377,
-0.3084834814071655,
-0.8676463961601257,
0.39587002992630005,
-0.8270443081855774,
0.5678412914276123,
-0.062247131019830704,
0.15261255204677582,
0.15027789771556854,
0.028787145391106606,
-0.6210637092590332,
-0.4112884998321533,
-0.9625071883201599,
-0.44757384061813354,
0.36858493089675903,
0.9342418909072876,
0.3952796757221222,
0.4960636794567108,
0.4952125549316406,
0.36426037549972534,
-0.18279896676540375,
0.012548407539725304,
-0.2692037522792816,
0.35112547874450684,
-0.11093045026063919,
-0.2209058254957199,
-0.13685548305511475,
-0.08191613107919693,
0.5543956756591797,
0.492641806602478,
-0.12990261614322662,
-0.13083872199058533,
0.4039102792739868,
0.7854298949241638,
-0.6204726696014404,
0.0388728566467762,
-0.17465081810951233,
0.04373354837298393,
-0.31409186124801636,
0.0157894566655159,
-0.5274593830108643,
-0.4277065098285675,
0.6710224151611328,
-0.776792049407959,
0.4377717673778534,
-0.011999828740954399,
0.8812404870986938,
0.12120745331048965,
-0.4832491874694824,
-0.9324097037315369,
-0.7626367807388306,
0.7189689874649048,
-0.3172512352466583,
0.66999751329422,
0.8570606708526611,
0.5097262263298035,
0.16489334404468536,
-0.5026079416275024,
-0.7581354975700378,
-0.1867796927690506,
-0.09305121004581451,
0.23807980120182037,
-0.6271088123321533,
-0.05300864204764366,
0.08189556747674942,
0.2592601776123047,
-1.0226320028305054,
0.2520090639591217,
-0.44826045632362366,
-0.33497199416160583,
0.5613726377487183,
0.04689238220453262,
0.1698545664548874,
-0.24083618819713593,
-0.11290465295314789,
-0.20192591845989227,
-0.3389577269554138,
0.25212740898132324,
0.3414405882358551,
0.4028235971927643,
0.09274119883775711,
0.3022194802761078,
0.07896794378757477,
0.7007793188095093,
0.14386719465255737,
-0.275231271982193,
0.1774187982082367,
-0.23904608190059662,
0.0745895504951477,
0.44164350628852844,
0.6705953478813171,
-0.05794958397746086,
0.6527966260910034,
0.07815805822610855,
-0.3268736004829407,
0.4148454964160919,
-0.06503695249557495,
-0.5226988196372986,
-0.37650054693222046,
-0.20785176753997803,
-0.47836384177207947,
-0.0037621986120939255,
-0.1398494690656662,
-0.33104580640792847,
-0.407578706741333,
-0.48468831181526184,
0.7693361043930054,
-0.8216173052787781,
-0.2181490957736969,
0.49030470848083496,
-0.23732750117778778,
0.1258903592824936,
0.395702064037323,
-0.8707777261734009,
0.42196568846702576,
0.32299914956092834,
0.6023501753807068,
-0.20676375925540924,
-0.0860668495297432,
-0.40897268056869507,
0.006022923160344362,
-0.2531611919403076,
1.1182087659835815,
-0.3881668746471405,
-0.617235541343689,
0.03282710909843445,
-0.023367686197161674,
-0.3662422001361847,
-0.7555307149887085,
0.6537313461303711,
-0.32930585741996765,
0.19882123172283173,
-0.2782333791255951,
-0.4958145320415497,
-0.1722751408815384,
0.12255033105611801,
-0.4638320505619049,
1.0629016160964966,
-0.14362749457359314,
-0.7552732229232788,
0.4479694068431854,
-0.355612576007843,
-0.652067244052887,
-0.1857658475637436,
0.29548966884613037,
-0.4643138349056244,
-0.17765195667743683,
0.21679048240184784,
0.31026533246040344,
-0.06708503514528275,
0.02338228188455105,
0.35538923740386963,
-0.6203216910362244,
-0.11013531684875488,
-0.7763968706130981,
0.7810185551643372,
0.2717941105365753,
-0.18021677434444427,
-0.2019779235124588,
-0.7992243766784668,
-0.10314450412988663,
0.031600382179021835,
-0.5351006388664246,
-0.3918532729148865,
-0.027139123529195786,
0.10059429705142975,
-0.09987515211105347,
-0.0029274211265146732,
-0.6022295355796814,
0.04572414606809616,
-0.3561647832393646,
0.19401583075523376,
0.24148571491241455,
-0.09572423249483109,
0.049447767436504364,
-0.4082694351673126,
0.3478868901729584,
0.22718900442123413,
0.049244705587625504,
-0.13638940453529358,
-0.7144469618797302,
-0.9469411373138428,
-0.25940537452697754,
0.4322353005409241,
1.0601102113723755,
-0.9022713899612427,
0.6982279419898987,
0.08705789595842361,
-0.4771561622619629,
-0.4557877480983734,
-0.16477879881858826,
0.6903806924819946,
0.6432742476463318,
0.3963250517845154,
-0.14541329443454742,
-0.6413251161575317,
-0.631359875202179,
-0.4570719003677368,
-0.2515829801559448,
-0.031330376863479614,
0.27083051204681396,
0.3897090554237366,
-0.3396696448326111,
0.601274847984314,
-0.22048069536685944,
-0.5815741419792175,
-0.20120574533939362,
0.06419490277767181,
0.16855621337890625,
0.6092291474342346,
0.3552325367927551,
-0.6022493243217468,
-0.8619359135627747,
-0.028421012684702873,
-0.4469689428806305,
-0.27816614508628845,
0.35789451003074646,
0.28983429074287415,
0.18486952781677246,
0.6213910579681396,
-0.1552194505929947,
0.7654757499694824,
0.41535916924476624,
-0.6899503469467163,
0.6392239928245544,
-0.3363395631313324,
0.2089652717113495,
-0.6469240784645081,
-0.08662388473749161,
0.0761779397726059,
-0.5215612649917603,
-0.7574228644371033,
-0.4299922287464142,
0.21268342435359955,
0.003290161257609725,
-0.06547123193740845,
0.21674109995365143,
-0.45099908113479614,
-0.057193733751773834,
-0.2515028715133667,
0.21975941956043243,
-0.09692702442407608,
-0.24300852417945862,
0.25380080938339233,
0.7672268152236938,
0.6844050884246826,
-0.6705079674720764,
0.09089073538780212,
0.4231261610984802,
-0.3803485929965973,
0.4458295404911041,
-0.6462306380271912,
0.06861148774623871,
-0.03396335616707802,
0.1060740202665329,
-1.1532129049301147,
0.07802681624889374,
0.1722404509782791,
-0.643617570400238,
0.6737047433853149,
0.21087682247161865,
-0.540557861328125,
-0.7193285226821899,
0.13453352451324463,
0.17896373569965363,
0.1710854470729828,
-0.772319495677948,
0.5141720771789551,
0.3796795904636383,
-0.4410565495491028,
-0.6202890872955322,
-0.763035237789154,
-0.22559596598148346,
0.23958590626716614,
-0.5979242920875549,
-0.06156736612319946,
0.12202765792608261,
0.06456200033426285,
-0.16965194046497345,
-0.2982374131679535,
-0.4264356791973114,
-0.13404908776283264,
0.11182255297899246,
0.1663394421339035,
-0.6083247661590576,
0.2698275148868561,
0.14530064165592194,
-0.6459417939186096,
-0.3923543393611908,
0.04445194825530052,
0.5104976892471313,
-0.17955626547336578,
-0.2828080654144287,
-0.8723927140235901,
0.524279773235321,
0.35793885588645935,
-0.02270442619919777,
0.21438118815422058,
0.3252565264701843,
-0.4751892387866974,
-0.14980341494083405,
-0.543827474117279,
-0.243412584066391,
-0.5754664540290833,
-0.014466595835983753,
-0.401426762342453,
-0.6946163177490234,
0.28705132007598877,
0.23763132095336914,
-0.18239209055900574,
0.34626510739326477,
0.2606044411659241,
-0.4159267246723175,
0.8922432661056519,
0.5328782796859741,
-0.21188557147979736,
0.6458950638771057,
-0.28327569365501404,
0.32244399189949036,
-0.46926313638687134,
-0.016163870692253113,
-0.8684116005897522,
-0.26871946454048157,
-0.2599746584892273,
-0.21486139297485352,
0.3814704418182373,
0.16077332198619843,
-0.19976931810379028,
0.4485708177089691,
-0.7945419549942017,
0.6677958965301514,
0.7640611529350281,
-0.04660395160317421,
0.6784160137176514,
-0.0009114722488448024,
-0.23489625751972198,
-0.2727566063404083,
-0.5392283201217651,
-0.6454576849937439,
0.9608647227287292,
0.12311667203903198,
0.47241517901420593,
0.1380271017551422,
0.6810411810874939,
0.28983813524246216,
0.2847176194190979,
-1.0613956451416016,
0.32459285855293274,
-0.6962752342224121,
-0.7390937209129333,
-0.5361801385879517,
-0.20707523822784424,
-1.442908763885498,
0.32317429780960083,
-0.2188580185174942,
-0.5905227661132812,
0.7041674852371216,
0.19918569922447205,
-0.4215511083602905,
0.04158966243267059,
-0.8852007389068604,
0.7153798341751099,
0.23696859180927277,
0.2083251178264618,
-0.12430635094642639,
-0.6461888551712036,
0.23935547471046448,
0.034487105906009674,
0.048409853130578995,
0.16964003443717957,
0.24572966992855072,
0.784638524055481,
-0.366828054189682,
0.5147725939750671,
-0.3373261094093323,
-0.013515891507267952,
0.5870556235313416,
0.05610296130180359,
0.40142276883125305,
-0.3317982256412506,
-0.13799315690994263,
0.08021030575037003,
0.22336751222610474,
-0.1881188005208969,
-0.12863121926784515,
0.4019073247909546,
-0.9246653914451599,
-0.2763490378856659,
-0.9608533978462219,
-0.27366387844085693,
-0.40885791182518005,
0.18786410987377167,
0.6470009684562683,
0.47464999556541443,
0.06956885755062103,
0.1442393809556961,
0.8132590651512146,
-0.1260768175125122,
0.4639228582382202,
1.3054848909378052,
0.037308864295482635,
-0.0955805629491806,
1.0424531698226929,
0.5741438269615173,
-0.014121860265731812,
-0.0824848935008049,
0.3713497817516327,
-0.36535221338272095,
-0.6119409203529358,
-0.23732884228229523,
0.2593366503715515,
-0.5818905830383301,
-0.31952202320098877,
-0.7957119345664978,
-0.5070736408233643,
-0.4231361448764801,
-0.3317195475101471,
-0.25291821360588074,
-0.2977600693702698,
-0.6148281693458557,
-0.12676426768302917,
0.33303460478782654,
0.7658547163009644,
-0.5326266288757324,
0.6383820176124573,
-0.7272859811782837,
0.6040481328964233,
0.46443337202072144,
0.10324657708406448,
0.008165708743035793,
-0.9190962314605713,
0.08702688664197922,
-0.3355114758014679,
-0.49601447582244873,
-0.7792567014694214,
0.4924110472202301,
0.3357557952404022,
0.21993951499462128,
0.6722425222396851,
0.06927583366632462,
0.825448751449585,
-0.6660839915275574,
0.5519378185272217,
0.33006346225738525,
-1.0496375560760498,
0.7070277333259583,
-0.06676053255796432,
0.09780994057655334,
0.5844160914421082,
0.3671756684780121,
-0.7375154495239258,
-0.3652578294277191,
-0.35988348722457886,
-0.5671598315238953,
1.010183572769165,
-0.10301408171653748,
-0.1740790456533432,
0.1293765902519226,
0.12297840416431427,
0.3052840530872345,
-0.2562512457370758,
-0.3083352744579315,
-0.3297753632068634,
-0.077355295419693,
-0.5261907577514648,
-0.21592390537261963,
-0.4191167950630188,
0.32459336519241333,
-0.6934634447097778,
0.6370174288749695,
0.1796601116657257,
0.1764223873615265,
0.3627840280532837,
-0.22544166445732117,
-0.2578049302101135,
0.10969706624746323,
0.38567429780960083,
0.15725216269493103,
0.1435411423444748,
-0.024702830240130424,
-0.014475774951279163,
-1.1875810623168945,
0.398677259683609,
0.3114759624004364,
-0.08850594609975815,
0.33021047711372375,
0.6067641973495483,
0.4739648401737213,
0.25092458724975586,
-0.5969709157943726,
0.9357078671455383,
-0.265420138835907,
-0.48937323689460754,
-0.33321046829223633,
0.28384584188461304,
0.03712519630789757,
0.42892569303512573,
0.3470865786075592,
0.25199759006500244,
0.45383957028388977,
-0.3480541706085205,
0.30345621705055237,
0.044819075614213943,
-0.4828941822052002,
-0.15151001513004303,
0.28228557109832764,
0.19422633945941925,
-0.49766063690185547,
0.5775936841964722,
-0.09026182442903519,
-0.583477258682251,
0.5139539837837219,
0.9347856640815735,
0.5561237335205078,
-0.7821497321128845,
0.13487191498279572,
0.33504149317741394,
0.474895715713501,
-0.2135397046804428,
0.8074148297309875,
-0.17758363485336304,
-1.038813591003418,
-0.008917923085391521,
-0.4419777989387512,
-0.42704957723617554,
0.031042002141475677,
-0.9991043210029602,
0.3700415790081024,
-0.35851922631263733,
0.005052682012319565,
0.25908446311950684,
0.2005908340215683,
-0.5993244051933289,
0.4253295958042145,
0.2786533832550049,
0.8047524094581604,
-0.9943232536315918,
1.018014907836914,
0.46642979979515076,
-0.07193759828805923,
-0.8433988094329834,
0.03444954752922058,
0.14508284628391266,
-0.8359631299972534,
0.5276104807853699,
0.3257957994937897,
-0.32177722454071045,
0.2202669382095337,
-0.22849097847938538,
-0.9623659253120422,
0.8120945692062378,
0.18658967316150665,
-1.048582911491394,
0.05315777286887169,
-0.07506818324327469,
0.5531554222106934,
0.07293245196342468,
0.1416410505771637,
1.0094128847122192,
0.5501717329025269,
0.28058576583862305,
-1.3005858659744263,
-0.5732181072235107,
0.09281158447265625,
-0.2900533676147461,
0.13123169541358948,
-0.37507978081703186,
0.6406229138374329,
-0.13648712635040283,
-0.4630794823169708,
0.1392773985862732,
0.6533269286155701,
0.49057236313819885,
0.8452875018119812,
0.5996107459068298,
0.5600892305374146,
1.103481411933899,
-0.12149050831794739,
0.8591898083686829,
-0.07261668145656586,
0.08969057351350784,
0.7984350323677063,
-0.1096096858382225,
1.1342122554779053,
0.12014858424663544,
-0.23286089301109314,
0.2961701452732086,
0.5939347147941589,
0.3900502324104309,
0.5584946274757385,
-0.0521307997405529,
-0.28394022583961487,
-0.21859464049339294,
0.18001395463943481,
-0.3784886300563812,
0.5083587169647217,
0.7171371579170227,
-0.2459488809108734,
-0.17182570695877075,
0.44032973051071167,
-0.14580805599689484,
0.20714856684207916,
-0.5224459171295166,
0.9262178540229797,
0.1882282793521881,
-0.3847810626029968,
0.9217737913131714,
-0.22566242516040802,
0.8387423753738403,
-0.5043503642082214,
0.16500727832317352,
0.07087810337543488,
0.42607802152633667,
-0.08898463100194931,
-0.7155271768569946,
0.44157570600509644,
0.31945809721946716,
-0.4729858636856079,
-0.14673292636871338,
0.9369966983795166,
-0.46099627017974854,
-0.4970300495624542,
0.3142533004283905,
0.38472360372543335,
0.4132702052593231,
0.03268308937549591,
-0.6083104610443115,
-0.01458220649510622,
-0.165743887424469,
-0.22310508787631989,
-0.07714813202619553,
0.6181885004043579,
0.03632931783795357,
0.6638630628585815,
0.49801430106163025,
0.154709130525589,
0.2632448971271515,
0.14586032927036285,
0.49408209323883057,
-0.522368848323822,
-0.6634445190429688,
-0.3116037845611572,
0.23316113650798798,
0.17447203397750854,
-0.6244367361068726,
0.5888012051582336,
0.4684144854545593,
0.5745834112167358,
0.016522260382771492,
0.6239138245582581,
0.31114041805267334,
1.2203999757766724,
-0.20527052879333496,
0.8168114423751831,
-0.4374428987503052,
-0.1692890226840973,
-0.20516802370548248,
-0.6622858047485352,
-0.6016055941581726,
1.264281988143921,
-0.552031397819519,
-0.29871508479118347,
0.7894774079322815,
0.6658115983009338,
-0.1536683887243271,
0.6022002696990967,
0.33600640296936035,
0.26738977432250977,
0.06931104511022568,
0.48498713970184326,
0.9092352986335754,
-0.635608434677124,
0.596211850643158,
0.17687585949897766,
-0.3073696494102478,
-0.5490062832832336,
-0.16613256931304932,
-0.6837912201881409,
-0.37274467945098877,
-0.254218727350235,
-0.2549005150794983,
0.25803712010383606,
0.6659561395645142,
0.6007478833198547,
-1.226631999015808,
-0.06815054267644882,
-0.15650397539138794,
0.0484711192548275,
-0.2630060613155365,
-0.23597119748592377,
0.35926300287246704,
-0.15040333569049835,
-0.6533254384994507,
0.5900783538818359,
0.15062841773033142,
0.1654784083366394,
0.12900139391422272,
-0.09463747590780258,
-0.04552067071199417,
0.2185731828212738,
0.6309590935707092,
0.49720707535743713,
-0.4673110246658325,
-0.35564011335372925,
-0.24875351786613464,
-0.49452805519104004,
0.05267147719860077,
0.5788089632987976,
-0.7381404638290405,
0.6236147284507751,
0.4626457691192627,
0.4223880469799042,
0.5798160433769226,
-0.08376623690128326,
0.22569790482521057,
-0.38595736026763916,
0.2467309534549713,
0.690840482711792,
0.19459472596645355,
0.2747131288051605,
-0.14198794960975647,
0.22528284788131714,
0.33345526456832886,
-0.6537351012229919,
-0.9307307004928589,
0.056943729519844055,
-0.7181604504585266,
-0.0839252695441246,
0.9551202058792114,
-0.15513913333415985,
-0.17076069116592407,
-0.7581658363342285,
-0.4939989149570465,
0.1741391122341156,
-0.3929137885570526,
0.5333198308944702,
0.7363362312316895,
-0.1144237220287323,
0.025932269170880318,
-0.4298458695411682,
0.33918726444244385,
0.3818659484386444,
-0.2610039710998535,
-0.05607212334871292,
0.3920193612575531,
0.424697607755661,
0.19078019261360168,
0.6977730393409729,
0.029620962217450142,
0.6065918207168579,
0.2821316421031952,
-0.09271544963121414,
0.04955318197607994,
-0.6309951543807983,
-0.47836145758628845,
0.004705430008471012,
-0.2755418121814728,
-0.38173913955688477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07057v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07057v1
|
Benchmarking Trustworthiness of Multimodal Large Language Models: A Comprehensive Study
| 2024-06-11T08:38:13 | 2024-06-11T08:38:13 |
Yichi Zhang, Yao Huang, Yitong Sun, Chang Liu, Zhe Zhao, Zhengwei Fang, Yifan Wang, Huanran Chen, Xiao Yang, Xingxing Wei, Hang Su, Yinpeng Dong, Jun Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
Despite the superior capabilities of Multimodal Large Language Models (MLLMs)
across diverse tasks, they still face significant trustworthiness challenges.
Yet, current literature on the assessment of trustworthy MLLMs remains limited,
lacking a holistic evaluation to offer thorough insights into future
improvements. In this work, we establish MultiTrust, the first comprehensive
and unified benchmark on the trustworthiness of MLLMs across five primary
aspects: truthfulness, safety, robustness, fairness, and privacy. Our benchmark
employs a rigorous evaluation strategy that addresses both multimodal risks and
cross-modal impacts, encompassing 32 diverse tasks with self-curated datasets.
Extensive experiments with 21 modern MLLMs reveal some previously unexplored
trustworthiness issues and risks, highlighting the complexities introduced by
the multimodality and underscoring the necessity for advanced methodologies to
enhance their reliability. For instance, typical proprietary models still
struggle with the perception of visually confusing images and are vulnerable to
multimodal jailbreaking and adversarial attacks; MLLMs are more inclined to
disclose privacy in text and reveal ideological and cultural biases even when
paired with irrelevant images in inference, indicating that the multimodality
amplifies the internal risks from base LLMs. Additionally, we release a
scalable toolbox for standardized trustworthiness research, aiming to
facilitate future advancements in this important field. Code and resources are
publicly available at: https://multi-trust.github.io/.
|
[
-0.27873337268829346,
-0.47395768761634827,
0.5846952199935913,
0.3897722661495209,
0.04120313376188278,
0.14633150398731232,
-0.21401526033878326,
-0.5619503855705261,
-0.40686535835266113,
0.19581721723079681,
-0.33490413427352905,
-0.38258233666419983,
-0.7972500920295715,
-0.11608657985925674,
-0.38703304529190063,
0.8454680442810059,
-0.008563078008592129,
0.2031521201133728,
-0.5035574436187744,
-0.5620390772819519,
-0.13660269975662231,
-0.6973146200180054,
-0.3755268156528473,
-0.2711535692214966,
0.7390455603599548,
-0.09136714041233063,
0.7718023061752319,
0.3620477616786957,
0.7588131427764893,
0.3118908405303955,
0.013048268854618073,
0.18421854078769684,
-0.39777666330337524,
0.34898242354393005,
-0.21267524361610413,
-0.017124393954873085,
-0.4264124929904938,
0.23537343740463257,
0.6024925112724304,
0.38343891501426697,
-0.07895471155643463,
0.4437817633152008,
0.2670087218284607,
0.5314878225326538,
-0.9183014631271362,
0.2531256377696991,
-0.6252555847167969,
-0.07901003211736679,
-0.22052277624607086,
-0.08270417898893356,
-0.5208261013031006,
-0.4137148857116699,
0.11591050028800964,
-0.38265085220336914,
-0.2731238007545471,
0.18107885122299194,
0.6480107307434082,
0.1566791832447052,
-0.7904744744300842,
-0.07204172760248184,
-0.4181983768939972,
0.8513236045837402,
-0.5117210149765015,
0.7941803932189941,
0.3820650577545166,
0.32695695757865906,
0.03134984150528908,
-0.9174582958221436,
-0.3906286954879761,
-0.5971161127090454,
-0.12248535454273224,
-0.02925904653966427,
-0.23954734206199646,
-0.17008402943611145,
0.2842165529727936,
0.08996186405420303,
-0.6950036883354187,
-0.05131983757019043,
-0.022640112787485123,
-0.7117181420326233,
0.47829025983810425,
0.10992775112390518,
0.2326618731021881,
0.13286392390727997,
-0.7640399932861328,
-0.2518939673900604,
-0.5722730159759521,
0.17712196707725525,
0.4618963599205017,
0.002847079187631607,
-0.3092067241668701,
0.4644330143928528,
-0.12559174001216888,
0.2077236771583557,
-0.33625131845474243,
-0.43384820222854614,
0.5130687355995178,
-0.7992278337478638,
-0.15933328866958618,
-0.3065885603427887,
0.984979510307312,
0.6327452659606934,
0.2525959610939026,
-0.30135247111320496,
-0.02476368471980095,
0.1364586502313614,
0.20550814270973206,
-0.647186815738678,
-0.10779949277639389,
0.261398047208786,
-0.647178590297699,
-0.3740276098251343,
0.07575701922178268,
-0.8288991451263428,
-0.7463383078575134,
-0.15415415167808533,
0.5069006085395813,
-0.42648476362228394,
-0.3575618267059326,
-0.20846104621887207,
0.009960426017642021,
0.08622632920742035,
0.1926136314868927,
-0.3379155099391937,
0.036140892654657364,
0.5632873773574829,
0.8273187875747681,
-0.3799000680446625,
-0.7868092656135559,
-0.5592604875564575,
0.16645824909210205,
-0.15753640234470367,
0.43616217374801636,
-0.5196601748466492,
-0.1864088773727417,
0.0332195870578289,
-0.0740378275513649,
-0.04871852695941925,
-0.21461981534957886,
0.7785233855247498,
-0.4081265926361084,
-0.05155692994594574,
-0.09709828346967697,
-0.37897711992263794,
-0.12604065239429474,
0.6911831498146057,
-0.8875492215156555,
0.8971650004386902,
-0.26656684279441833,
-0.7066904902458191,
0.37547025084495544,
-0.5232924818992615,
-0.31466054916381836,
-0.3890397846698761,
-0.060335345566272736,
-0.44092845916748047,
-0.025797661393880844,
0.037630267441272736,
0.6064619421958923,
-0.1593298763036728,
0.40410587191581726,
-0.940811038017273,
-0.01896142028272152,
0.6908011436462402,
-0.9815822839736938,
0.7378941774368286,
0.24753981828689575,
-0.2570432126522064,
0.29631978273391724,
-0.7725991606712341,
0.33100923895835876,
0.0773858055472374,
-0.2012728601694107,
-0.25084567070007324,
-0.34052443504333496,
0.4810185432434082,
0.48747706413269043,
0.4874768853187561,
-0.5273434519767761,
-0.2970139980316162,
0.21131069958209991,
0.3134351372718811,
0.9073612093925476,
-0.273571252822876,
0.20892362296581268,
-0.3383164703845978,
0.231349915266037,
0.2568059265613556,
0.7282212972640991,
-0.25547924637794495,
-0.40703916549682617,
-0.30331167578697205,
-0.309826523065567,
0.25577208399772644,
0.2850290536880493,
-0.40948379039764404,
0.12848114967346191,
-0.2710585296154022,
-0.579463005065918,
-0.3918645679950714,
0.12376781553030014,
0.7220627069473267,
0.07085581868886948,
0.35423514246940613,
-0.49648094177246094,
-0.26433464884757996,
-1.1420831680297852,
-0.4701062738895416,
0.03725288808345795,
0.34663599729537964,
0.25490617752075195,
0.5862995386123657,
-0.3798961639404297,
0.5738306045532227,
-0.1400371640920639,
-0.2045983225107193,
0.25012946128845215,
0.15758360922336578,
-0.2729114890098572,
0.4975856840610504,
0.5123822689056396,
-0.848685085773468,
-0.5169323682785034,
-0.02589540183544159,
-0.6384218335151672,
0.315026193857193,
0.09813667088747025,
0.07177606970071793,
0.26081788539886475,
0.321466326713562,
-0.6165031790733337,
0.10345429182052612,
1.2199407815933228,
-0.42299342155456543,
0.6469458937644958,
-0.3231012523174286,
0.27251484990119934,
-1.0206834077835083,
0.4058867394924164,
-0.03227777034044266,
-0.4290657639503479,
-0.5445737242698669,
0.30420348048210144,
0.32696107029914856,
0.059120554476976395,
-0.5287204384803772,
0.5596975684165955,
-0.47745898365974426,
-0.13986364006996155,
0.15506267547607422,
-0.07476197928190231,
0.06347820162773132,
0.3055252432823181,
-0.4616170823574066,
0.7622496485710144,
0.6740894913673401,
-0.2884753942489624,
0.3412439525127411,
-0.07087277621030807,
-0.3748001456260681,
0.6889117360115051,
-0.5226011276245117,
0.20461997389793396,
0.06423567980527878,
0.31687361001968384,
-0.8145120143890381,
0.06048097461462021,
0.12279660999774933,
-0.4037383198738098,
0.17752283811569214,
0.0643530935049057,
-0.7049180865287781,
0.16136586666107178,
-0.5117029547691345,
0.4018234610557556,
0.19003210961818695,
-0.42373019456863403,
0.7794995903968811,
0.4364089369773865,
0.004193930421024561,
-0.8869807124137878,
-0.45729854702949524,
0.2755799889564514,
-0.15353062748908997,
-0.5768491625785828,
0.0692492201924324,
-0.40811121463775635,
-0.34552818536758423,
-0.040609344840049744,
-0.18341809511184692,
-0.3320859372615814,
0.2340712547302246,
0.4822671711444855,
0.18199506402015686,
0.07395069301128387,
-0.05975319817662239,
-0.18897123634815216,
-0.2528083920478821,
0.10640043765306473,
0.07634063065052032,
0.41843071579933167,
-0.5422801375389099,
-0.6390361189842224,
-0.2514913082122803,
0.3009258210659027,
0.9943384528160095,
-0.6081351041793823,
0.784883975982666,
1.0290027856826782,
-0.2613705098628998,
0.032319288700819016,
-0.7676473259925842,
-0.15834619104862213,
-0.4511639177799225,
0.2834443151950836,
-0.4076899290084839,
-1.0216082334518433,
0.40808743238449097,
-0.048976656049489975,
0.09193383157253265,
0.21866460144519806,
0.5624102354049683,
0.11510288715362549,
0.878063976764679,
0.4393880069255829,
-0.23093675076961517,
0.08872727304697037,
0.2771861255168915,
0.028277695178985596,
-0.5797777771949768,
-0.3945923447608948,
-0.4682752192020416,
-0.022978637367486954,
-0.6892932653427124,
-0.5375646948814392,
0.41486695408821106,
-0.32414355874061584,
-0.21369661390781403,
0.03544154763221741,
0.0558113269507885,
0.3585626184940338,
0.4878287613391876,
0.087490014731884,
0.6731432676315308,
-0.17981788516044617,
-0.3467957377433777,
-0.007843006402254105,
-0.2832093834877014,
-0.6071269512176514,
1.4236036539077759,
0.6402000784873962,
0.8697370886802673,
0.3371430039405823,
0.4489206075668335,
0.2012287676334381,
0.29684174060821533,
-0.27702733874320984,
0.3715393543243408,
-0.14474250376224518,
-0.966566801071167,
-0.287985235452652,
-0.39895036816596985,
-0.6905661821365356,
0.48588839173316956,
-0.6043184995651245,
-0.5964887142181396,
-0.05880647152662277,
0.24662503600120544,
-0.15895742177963257,
0.12682510912418365,
-0.6434114575386047,
0.9823877215385437,
-0.45969048142433167,
-0.674957275390625,
-0.34466227889060974,
-0.8602140545845032,
0.49601081013679504,
-0.23945966362953186,
0.34513720870018005,
-0.28107622265815735,
-0.09294086694717407,
0.2632969617843628,
0.2593473494052887,
0.733323872089386,
0.04420729726552963,
-0.09063257277011871,
-0.34238359332084656,
0.1857711672782898,
0.5049777030944824,
0.13444431126117706,
0.07966016978025436,
0.6112380623817444,
0.35790443420410156,
-0.22220879793167114,
-0.4362758696079254,
1.0016309022903442,
-0.6191036105155945,
-0.1712397187948227,
-0.6179112195968628,
-0.6163628101348877,
-0.6300779581069946,
0.46080687642097473,
-0.13986502587795258,
0.4656379818916321,
-0.48093336820602417,
0.6447716355323792,
0.7784960269927979,
-0.12269166857004166,
0.45776787400245667,
0.4551907479763031,
-0.19759783148765564,
-0.39605513215065,
0.8209646344184875,
-0.22370503842830658,
0.3361157178878784,
0.25116580724716187,
0.09823300689458847,
-0.5128310322761536,
-0.5591901540756226,
-0.2997826039791107,
-0.09416680783033371,
-0.7263393402099609,
-0.007621834520250559,
-0.5521158576011658,
-0.1157146468758583,
-0.3685494661331177,
0.32285794615745544,
-0.7332640886306763,
-0.09779510647058487,
0.20230253040790558,
0.044700104743242264,
0.020016837865114212,
0.5803031921386719,
0.10085803270339966,
-0.293276846408844,
-0.9820823073387146,
0.22869546711444855,
0.3558944761753082,
0.8659292459487915,
-0.012374243699014187,
-0.11073265969753265,
-0.19912128150463104,
-0.10075359791517258,
-0.20632675290107727,
-0.390088826417923,
-0.12157835811376572,
0.08909648656845093,
0.9037101864814758,
0.4243219494819641,
-0.05420954152941704,
0.5525610446929932,
-0.6555524468421936,
0.6838446855545044,
0.3777070939540863,
-0.9434561729431152,
-0.13188712298870087,
-0.1538238376379013,
0.034057870507240295,
0.7015722393989563,
0.40273115038871765,
-0.3424607813358307,
-0.2926492691040039,
-0.47272399067878723,
-0.687497615814209,
0.10897355526685715,
0.36456629633903503,
0.08046580106019974,
0.3778389096260071,
-0.2513388395309448,
0.34808725118637085,
0.34782227873802185,
-0.9896116256713867,
-0.4829663038253784,
-0.31551551818847656,
-0.10273082554340363,
-0.42507413029670715,
-0.3049705922603607,
-0.6032007932662964,
0.028051219880580902,
0.5360968112945557,
-0.16945217549800873,
0.026916971430182457,
-0.03295851871371269,
-0.18197645246982574,
0.12735812366008759,
0.6332754492759705,
0.8134474158287048,
0.8667558431625366,
-0.0930154025554657,
0.4573044180870056,
0.09490766376256943,
-0.48201608657836914,
0.1458059400320053,
0.27610155940055847,
0.1392495334148407,
-0.17635869979858398,
0.4367746114730835,
0.5165992379188538,
0.27343541383743286,
-0.7388356328010559,
0.754522442817688,
-0.30312657356262207,
-0.17898499965667725,
-0.2778894007205963,
-0.1890677809715271,
0.17293313145637512,
0.4219481348991394,
0.07468835264444351,
0.2265206277370453,
0.16033123433589935,
-0.5722365975379944,
0.22734789550304413,
0.7231851816177368,
-0.3614477217197418,
-0.13833776116371155,
0.529791533946991,
0.13211126625537872,
0.2729562520980835,
0.1650443822145462,
0.1764407753944397,
-0.22364531457424164,
0.12928850948810577,
0.2982076108455658,
0.8309240937232971,
-0.08197662234306335,
0.1700425148010254,
0.09192738682031631,
0.7503169775009155,
-0.2454042136669159,
0.04008295014500618,
0.12881869077682495,
-0.7507591247558594,
-0.1618339717388153,
-0.4684031307697296,
-0.5673474669456482,
0.05928247794508934,
-0.7618862986564636,
-0.3637351393699646,
-0.39945298433303833,
-0.26399725675582886,
-0.18718461692333221,
-0.11278261989355087,
-0.6790206432342529,
0.1295880675315857,
0.28342127799987793,
0.8078321218490601,
-0.5556421875953674,
0.8740760684013367,
0.690325915813446,
-0.12353944778442383,
-0.6225861310958862,
-0.03289908915758133,
0.20436285436153412,
-0.7750385403633118,
0.37584978342056274,
0.2598786950111389,
-0.4368252754211426,
-0.3659551441669464,
-0.2946886122226715,
-0.8218315243721008,
1.3102819919586182,
0.49353212118148804,
-0.6569238305091858,
0.3049680292606354,
0.18886733055114746,
0.4143408238887787,
-0.23035359382629395,
0.25324559211730957,
0.2389237880706787,
0.7538511157035828,
-0.22836759686470032,
-1.2500946521759033,
0.21060720086097717,
-0.24115225672721863,
0.019206879660487175,
-0.10678016394376755,
-0.7686907052993774,
0.8574371337890625,
-0.06864160299301147,
0.022164644673466682,
0.0497513972222805,
0.25111624598503113,
0.37017622590065,
0.5274549722671509,
0.6226770877838135,
0.6069384217262268,
0.6762656569480896,
0.028604336082935333,
1.044735312461853,
-0.5557653307914734,
0.4105765223503113,
1.2152341604232788,
-0.5141733884811401,
0.912749707698822,
0.5911962389945984,
0.005871511064469814,
0.2705409526824951,
0.20178712904453278,
0.024341536685824394,
0.4613960385322571,
-0.18169188499450684,
-0.1545814722776413,
-0.3742941617965698,
-0.18818998336791992,
-0.5092172622680664,
0.5421018004417419,
-0.101882703602314,
-0.5383633375167847,
-0.11115969717502594,
-0.014768987894058228,
0.1013314351439476,
-0.03537413105368614,
-0.191363126039505,
0.5551645755767822,
0.11146390438079834,
-0.4194693863391876,
0.0721716582775116,
-0.13929082453250885,
0.7595289945602417,
-0.9033944606781006,
0.16188476979732513,
0.034676443785429,
0.34469476342201233,
-0.12646794319152832,
-0.861330509185791,
0.033835336565971375,
-0.1309140920639038,
-0.021105479449033737,
-0.4382365345954895,
0.6545864939689636,
-0.41369301080703735,
-0.2338777780532837,
0.5512998700141907,
0.7082894444465637,
-0.3117043673992157,
-0.21816961467266083,
-0.8564665913581848,
0.49474358558654785,
-0.3779267370700836,
-0.29179656505584717,
0.7321285605430603,
0.16239286959171295,
0.13883022964000702,
0.9113714694976807,
0.8686637878417969,
-0.17990261316299438,
0.15767669677734375,
0.12679678201675415,
0.7979854941368103,
-0.47356945276260376,
-0.20587602257728577,
-1.011572241783142,
0.6252813935279846,
-0.24438832700252533,
-0.46857234835624695,
1.2755831480026245,
0.6551597714424133,
0.8623261451721191,
-0.02746625430881977,
0.8076208829879761,
0.19441281259059906,
0.1640486866235733,
-0.5190839767456055,
1.0497393608093262,
-0.6079673171043396,
-0.1145675927400589,
-0.460881769657135,
-0.7539234757423401,
-0.2525850236415863,
0.32701900601387024,
0.18579630553722382,
0.06890175491571426,
1.0124571323394775,
0.7837552428245544,
-0.06610933691263199,
-0.06133471801877022,
0.6233633160591125,
0.1651090383529663,
0.2565959393978119,
0.38167494535446167,
0.8607215881347656,
-0.2288368195295334,
0.8505833745002747,
-0.5010886192321777,
-0.1076526790857315,
0.10033538937568665,
-1.1557896137237549,
-0.9674580693244934,
-0.6369983553886414,
-0.10086996853351593,
-0.41867175698280334,
0.11456447094678879,
0.8487612009048462,
0.8302434682846069,
-0.7121644020080566,
-0.10021135956048965,
0.5191266536712646,
0.0604531429708004,
-0.3323603868484497,
-0.1562216579914093,
0.1359281837940216,
0.05464501678943634,
-0.4242976903915405,
0.28349289298057556,
0.4175795912742615,
-0.03639256954193115,
-0.6223313808441162,
-0.2096376121044159,
0.02919013798236847,
-0.05585932359099388,
0.8654374480247498,
-0.10697843134403229,
-0.8268691301345825,
-0.33228740096092224,
0.059040963649749756,
-0.4202544093132019,
-0.21092906594276428,
0.7780391573905945,
-0.16739210486412048,
0.5222106575965881,
0.1465192586183548,
0.6651787757873535,
0.12413861602544785,
-0.23715418577194214,
0.33684244751930237,
-0.4726863503456116,
-0.06802669167518616,
0.14392653107643127,
0.5823596119880676,
0.2934209406375885,
-0.04761342704296112,
0.2658047676086426,
-0.009659727104008198,
-0.5431711077690125,
-0.8914819955825806,
0.27209043502807617,
-1.1758911609649658,
-0.13846638798713684,
1.025833010673523,
-0.45161721110343933,
0.06011010333895683,
-0.20950201153755188,
-0.004470309242606163,
-0.08966511487960815,
-0.4169928729534149,
0.6053980588912964,
0.882064163684845,
0.16904957592487335,
-0.28782567381858826,
-0.4936334192752838,
0.3264295756816864,
0.280601441860199,
-0.8696703314781189,
0.2911011278629303,
0.5898880958557129,
0.39214763045310974,
0.271984338760376,
0.4136102795600891,
-0.3132396340370178,
0.26154378056526184,
0.001389558776281774,
-0.10162980854511261,
-0.45036381483078003,
-0.5743217468261719,
-0.36328116059303284,
0.6221672296524048,
0.19927048683166504,
-0.008260225877165794
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07056v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07056v1
|
Effectively Compress KV Heads for LLM
| 2024-06-11T08:37:33 | 2024-06-11T08:37:33 |
Hao Yu, Zelan Yang, Shen Li, Yong Li, Jianxin Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of pre-trained large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized
various natural language processing tasks. These models predominantly employ an
auto-regressive decoding mechanism that utilizes Key-Value (KV) caches to
eliminate redundant calculations for previous tokens. Nevertheless, as context
lengths and batch sizes increase, the linear expansion in memory footprint of
KV caches becomes a key bottleneck of LLM deployment, which decreases
generation speeds significantly. To mitigate this issue, previous techniques
like multi-query attention (MQA) and grouped-query attention (GQA) have been
developed, in order to reduce KV heads to accelerate inference with comparable
accuracy to multi-head attention (MHA). Despite their effectiveness, existing
strategies for compressing MHA often overlook the intrinsic properties of the
KV caches. In this work, we explore the low-rank characteristics of the KV
caches and propose a novel approach for compressing KV heads. In particular, we
carefully optimize the MHA-to-GQA transformation to minimize compression error,
and to remain compatible with rotary position embeddings (RoPE), we also
introduce specialized strategies for key caches with RoPE. We demonstrate that
our method can compress half or even three-quarters of KV heads while
maintaining performance comparable to the original LLMs, which presents a
promising direction for more efficient LLM deployment in resource-constrained
environments.
|
[
-0.425134539604187,
-0.346489280462265,
0.4098299443721771,
0.2839711904525757,
-0.678290605545044,
0.08217442035675049,
-0.488696813583374,
-0.2588464021682739,
0.3455851376056671,
0.5029436349868774,
-0.6429277658462524,
-0.628494918346405,
-0.675716757774353,
0.04677514359354973,
-0.11122697591781616,
0.564329981803894,
0.24701718986034393,
-0.4373338520526886,
-0.17448417842388153,
-0.3108927607536316,
-0.6666684746742249,
-0.726954996585846,
-0.4631424844264984,
-0.08927476406097412,
0.4508039653301239,
0.38913941383361816,
0.5049188733100891,
0.886293351650238,
0.565784752368927,
0.24736033380031586,
-0.1649671196937561,
0.33952412009239197,
-0.718052327632904,
0.4884640574455261,
0.20619793236255646,
-0.49806684255599976,
-0.5964974761009216,
-0.14566117525100708,
0.7355446219444275,
0.3679203987121582,
-0.11529398709535599,
0.28872960805892944,
0.10200710594654083,
0.9340716600418091,
-0.9791845083236694,
0.43244338035583496,
-0.9053734540939331,
-0.018292339518666267,
-0.24450476467609406,
-0.46673378348350525,
-0.6687162518501282,
-0.307670921087265,
-0.06397508829832077,
-0.5024552941322327,
0.15102730691432953,
0.008546444587409496,
0.8364419341087341,
0.6817461252212524,
-0.24142052233219147,
0.19565841555595398,
-0.41027212142944336,
1.1260919570922852,
-0.5765987634658813,
0.5770277380943298,
0.29757994413375854,
0.24345636367797852,
-0.19228173792362213,
-0.4718833863735199,
-0.39374881982803345,
0.08477283269166946,
0.019425075501203537,
-0.10572376102209091,
0.031287629157304764,
0.1844632774591446,
0.026514442637562752,
0.43960854411125183,
-0.5098172426223755,
0.1605314165353775,
-0.05085839703679085,
-0.21184074878692627,
0.34475019574165344,
0.04322674497961998,
0.006957436446100473,
-0.15019413828849792,
-0.11014841496944427,
-0.5504851937294006,
-0.9990977048873901,
0.11846724897623062,
0.16753824055194855,
0.4893661141395569,
0.15132977068424225,
0.4175751805305481,
-0.6161798238754272,
0.8257803916931152,
0.31770041584968567,
-0.3515223562717438,
0.1850639283657074,
-0.4102712571620941,
-0.3950325846672058,
-0.08690034598112106,
0.4869751036167145,
0.4223439395427704,
0.45965254306793213,
-0.20411640405654907,
-0.022630490362644196,
0.08757192641496658,
0.5044189095497131,
-0.8463853001594543,
-0.14711330831050873,
0.16281576454639435,
-0.5576648712158203,
-0.44170066714286804,
-0.3873448371887207,
-0.7233548760414124,
0.012199221178889275,
-0.23897609114646912,
0.3225392997264862,
0.11114005744457245,
0.21390961110591888,
0.20897088944911957,
0.09741233289241791,
0.3949053883552551,
0.33972159028053284,
-1.0508500337600708,
0.1541021466255188,
0.3197796940803528,
0.7967507243156433,
-0.22092851996421814,
0.16101516783237457,
-0.8544371128082275,
0.3127841353416443,
0.052385907620191574,
0.6408886909484863,
-0.31310904026031494,
-0.2520677447319031,
0.10621288418769836,
-0.0742403045296669,
0.08279116451740265,
-0.5857545733451843,
0.5464474558830261,
-0.8484200239181519,
-0.4497075378894806,
-0.2621312141418457,
-0.08338402956724167,
0.010725018568336964,
0.45913293957710266,
-0.724485456943512,
0.7974859476089478,
0.18239690363407135,
-0.5165930986404419,
0.158960223197937,
-0.07983528822660446,
-0.41441667079925537,
-0.2695288062095642,
-0.30540698766708374,
-0.4442378282546997,
0.30369332432746887,
0.6885834336280823,
0.6101001501083374,
-0.45589399337768555,
-0.20706701278686523,
-0.13682058453559875,
-0.35471677780151367,
-0.046470534056425095,
-0.26255735754966736,
0.49339133501052856,
-0.007915259338915348,
-0.07685918360948563,
-0.15899978578090668,
-0.2898091971874237,
0.3124764561653137,
0.004697172436863184,
-0.541736900806427,
-0.2364044487476349,
-0.21373313665390015,
-0.19460353255271912,
0.26154786348342896,
0.24783535301685333,
-0.17231927812099457,
0.5695209503173828,
-0.4026462435722351,
0.3114051818847656,
0.6160784959793091,
0.11238119006156921,
0.42016157507896423,
-0.213062584400177,
0.49750298261642456,
0.05411636084318161,
0.09072389453649521,
-0.027597950771450996,
-0.19684700667858124,
-1.04974365234375,
-0.2468997687101364,
0.22373533248901367,
0.29763785004615784,
-0.7461619973182678,
0.5103104710578918,
-0.7427542209625244,
-0.3722526729106903,
-0.7096200585365295,
0.24547338485717773,
0.3791574537754059,
0.31964823603630066,
0.5190070867538452,
-0.3206867277622223,
-0.32305753231048584,
-1.0100116729736328,
-0.23959776759147644,
-0.13334862887859344,
0.06635759770870209,
0.445421427488327,
0.08998337388038635,
-0.038213323801755905,
0.891679048538208,
-0.6952618360519409,
-0.48046454787254333,
-0.04709063842892647,
0.36871466040611267,
0.2931247055530548,
0.5149972438812256,
0.09051095694303513,
-0.6472036242485046,
-0.5281307697296143,
-0.2568630874156952,
-0.42991504073143005,
-0.17756499350070953,
-0.1541050225496292,
-0.10135158151388168,
0.13367439806461334,
0.4064040780067444,
-0.9718335270881653,
0.4511399567127228,
0.5580893754959106,
0.23979510366916656,
0.6869505047798157,
-0.10033021122217178,
0.20623044669628143,
-0.6591039896011353,
-0.012936411425471306,
-0.24945394694805145,
-0.3866541087627411,
-0.399554967880249,
0.24639759957790375,
0.16031377017498016,
0.15667451918125153,
-0.5853012800216675,
0.2826398015022278,
-0.8238807916641235,
0.07330257445573807,
-0.28693416714668274,
0.06944921612739563,
-0.013898253440856934,
0.9108496904373169,
-0.031270965933799744,
0.8566916584968567,
0.2068607062101364,
-0.8259384632110596,
0.027983753010630608,
0.4023704528808594,
-0.22856006026268005,
0.3862845003604889,
-0.5371514558792114,
0.43708983063697815,
-0.13708966970443726,
0.5160189867019653,
-0.743370771408081,
-0.016166897490620613,
0.04541235417127609,
-0.38471129536628723,
0.583105206489563,
-0.42563533782958984,
-0.6024910807609558,
-0.1539992243051529,
-0.6316302418708801,
0.8295721411705017,
0.6335912942886353,
-0.40413808822631836,
0.3854138255119324,
0.5244306325912476,
-0.11071668565273285,
-0.8468442559242249,
-0.8037531971931458,
0.059997107833623886,
-0.39614608883857727,
-0.4462471604347229,
0.6786541938781738,
-0.11444226652383804,
0.03939581289887428,
-0.1769808828830719,
-0.49370136857032776,
-0.14009998738765717,
-0.12046569585800171,
-0.0499044731259346,
-0.024165494367480278,
-0.1931561827659607,
0.23652490973472595,
0.10749062895774841,
-0.2785900831222534,
-0.14757230877876282,
-0.3592137098312378,
0.6531388759613037,
0.027437077835202217,
-0.06915631890296936,
-0.2776392698287964,
0.2422352433204651,
0.9389761090278625,
-0.18488451838493347,
0.7271149158477783,
0.37622377276420593,
-0.32578912377357483,
-0.1612493097782135,
-0.760956883430481,
-0.3247879147529602,
-0.478956937789917,
0.1911037117242813,
-0.22591227293014526,
-0.8855361938476562,
0.35392987728118896,
-0.16212929785251617,
-0.038467779755592346,
0.2838359773159027,
0.7185127139091492,
0.09239354729652405,
0.6648029685020447,
0.5261455178260803,
-0.4805815517902374,
0.22250057756900787,
-0.38935551047325134,
0.2893289029598236,
-1.1953179836273193,
0.13369052112102509,
-0.5450965762138367,
-0.4278721213340759,
-0.4634435474872589,
-0.943376362323761,
0.5399779081344604,
0.1808040589094162,
0.09032364189624786,
0.36048606038093567,
-0.5793675780296326,
0.4642535150051117,
0.27568474411964417,
0.10830982774496078,
0.3940495550632477,
-0.028358643874526024,
-0.0469072163105011,
-0.13619403541088104,
-0.7091820240020752,
-0.26757901906967163,
1.1541378498077393,
0.18723736703395844,
0.8713512420654297,
0.08276546001434326,
0.6266517639160156,
0.1288439929485321,
0.044721659272909164,
-0.9521701335906982,
0.4687943756580353,
-0.14342696964740753,
-0.28396809101104736,
-0.39089128375053406,
-0.21282163262367249,
-0.9751274585723877,
0.40037062764167786,
0.021407218649983406,
-0.860568106174469,
0.09255649149417877,
0.2594141960144043,
-0.6058099269866943,
0.03187364339828491,
-0.2971039414405823,
0.6436479687690735,
0.10609223693609238,
-0.25636032223701477,
-0.43490511178970337,
-0.8459025621414185,
0.3731193542480469,
-0.041971977800130844,
0.043754901736974716,
-0.022673863917589188,
-0.07618381083011627,
0.567923903465271,
-0.4270065426826477,
0.7254402041435242,
-0.02429167367517948,
-0.07979469001293182,
0.15756073594093323,
-0.19191113114356995,
0.9435439109802246,
0.05496065691113472,
0.29277166724205017,
-0.01909850351512432,
-0.35702812671661377,
-0.26391738653182983,
-0.853326678276062,
0.8334988355636597,
-0.5815779566764832,
-0.6524641513824463,
-0.10955337435007095,
-0.6630430221557617,
-0.38200318813323975,
-0.1374935507774353,
0.14902539551258087,
0.3430011570453644,
0.1601349264383316,
0.45635339617729187,
1.008503794670105,
-0.1411413550376892,
0.5084684491157532,
0.17213375866413116,
0.0949421226978302,
-0.3496462106704712,
0.7437815070152283,
0.3180895149707794,
0.43005403876304626,
0.5822013020515442,
-0.06721928715705872,
-0.26750075817108154,
-0.6115974187850952,
-0.3342777490615845,
0.2241561859846115,
-0.7643735408782959,
-0.6367382407188416,
-0.7831759452819824,
-0.24853776395320892,
-0.3811957538127899,
-0.2764352560043335,
-0.6493895053863525,
-0.5043801665306091,
-0.17953404784202576,
0.28274452686309814,
0.24032548069953918,
0.0937233567237854,
0.11322532594203949,
0.7545702457427979,
-0.8210052251815796,
0.6371903419494629,
0.5224050879478455,
0.12061511725187302,
0.15659554302692413,
-0.38409358263015747,
-0.5918494462966919,
-0.16466625034809113,
-0.2270364761352539,
-0.7391406297683716,
0.684078574180603,
0.14844483137130737,
0.3916293978691101,
0.32005929946899414,
0.3336467146873474,
0.903392493724823,
-0.4766433835029602,
0.62771075963974,
-0.11146321892738342,
-0.7905063033103943,
0.35316216945648193,
-0.22003711760044098,
0.6760644912719727,
0.8364750742912292,
0.11237175017595291,
-0.4058234989643097,
-0.5318600535392761,
-0.49952733516693115,
-1.1063820123672485,
0.3510364592075348,
0.3450809121131897,
-0.03614531829953194,
0.08156938850879669,
0.3627670109272003,
-0.02117958664894104,
0.4062258303165436,
-0.6923352479934692,
-0.37845149636268616,
0.2813448905944824,
-0.18245121836662292,
0.02010369300842285,
-0.33010992407798767,
0.1705874800682068,
-0.2669144570827484,
0.5262113809585571,
-0.22261276841163635,
0.521064043045044,
0.13295838236808777,
-0.5864126086235046,
0.002310779644176364,
0.1982295960187912,
0.5408041477203369,
0.20980164408683777,
-0.36559560894966125,
0.3184078633785248,
0.17858964204788208,
-0.5303992033004761,
0.40797677636146545,
-0.27793315052986145,
0.036157794296741486,
0.07862167060375214,
0.12593887746334076,
0.40392476320266724,
0.4316433370113373,
-0.44152361154556274,
0.351918488740921,
-0.1383848488330841,
0.20478013157844543,
-0.11932025104761124,
-0.11497915536165237,
0.08176924288272858,
0.15828749537467957,
0.3511897623538971,
-0.13031470775604248,
0.1004803255200386,
-0.2254655808210373,
0.11232637614011765,
0.45795542001724243,
-0.08205777406692505,
-0.10508435219526291,
0.38688942790031433,
0.315807044506073,
-0.01651665009558201,
0.690883457660675,
0.009675434790551662,
-0.650831937789917,
0.33987244963645935,
0.20518159866333008,
1.0392948389053345,
-0.14275501668453217,
-0.24709491431713104,
0.31531164050102234,
0.543482780456543,
-0.12250643968582153,
0.08801411837339401,
-0.40958771109580994,
-0.7142066359519958,
-0.755821704864502,
-0.6127299666404724,
-0.19989079236984253,
0.3198040723800659,
-0.7284212708473206,
0.2756771445274353,
-0.16851304471492767,
-0.1778477281332016,
-0.4324166476726532,
0.05592896416783333,
-0.9144692420959473,
0.24702872335910797,
0.09257837384939194,
0.7243828177452087,
-0.6538684368133545,
1.1375292539596558,
0.06212102621793747,
-0.2516295313835144,
-0.506405770778656,
0.2008868008852005,
0.01308208517730236,
-0.7533130049705505,
0.8047052025794983,
0.44331544637680054,
-0.36204782128334045,
0.20701292157173157,
-0.3127155900001526,
-1.0849699974060059,
1.0200958251953125,
0.3367677628993988,
-0.5697567462921143,
-0.17507202923297882,
0.0817335993051529,
0.15453696250915527,
-0.27894094586372375,
0.030612412840127945,
0.5500018000602722,
0.5165552496910095,
-0.16225600242614746,
-0.9491308927536011,
0.1223815381526947,
0.0013356419513002038,
0.05657992511987686,
0.2311236560344696,
-0.7824592590332031,
0.6502256393432617,
0.16032420098781586,
-0.21416258811950684,
-0.15389730036258698,
0.7029314637184143,
0.3361344039440155,
-0.3438243865966797,
0.5695986151695251,
0.8184045553207397,
0.7186234593391418,
0.2322673201560974,
0.8475061655044556,
-0.3794616162776947,
0.38320913910865784,
1.0127525329589844,
0.036412563174963,
0.9032012224197388,
0.979684591293335,
0.05323285236954689,
0.2823270261287689,
0.5262764692306519,
0.372455358505249,
0.9257185459136963,
0.5052250027656555,
-0.2328815460205078,
-0.3266848027706146,
-0.133326455950737,
-0.36256131529808044,
0.5413271188735962,
0.3145047128200531,
-0.22675523161888123,
-0.22298891842365265,
-0.08782997727394104,
-0.06564905494451523,
-0.3792423903942108,
-0.24325934052467346,
0.49330955743789673,
0.18493375182151794,
-0.6521064043045044,
0.9673072695732117,
-0.060702845454216,
0.7087673544883728,
-0.39501699805259705,
0.03792998567223549,
-0.1187964454293251,
0.05107688903808594,
0.16292798519134521,
-0.2465386539697647,
0.24718910455703735,
-0.13028278946876526,
-0.3800187408924103,
-0.5298061370849609,
0.7445305585861206,
-0.4547237455844879,
-0.056382350623607635,
0.033897873014211655,
0.49434027075767517,
0.22038811445236206,
-0.3899102210998535,
-0.13619087636470795,
0.4184596836566925,
-0.18121810257434845,
-0.42183709144592285,
0.4962092936038971,
0.26441988348960876,
0.08655959367752075,
0.8061549067497253,
0.540698230266571,
0.1803019940853119,
0.11309215426445007,
-0.2125292867422104,
1.1326500177383423,
-0.7619977593421936,
-0.5227532982826233,
-0.8659460544586182,
0.5684342980384827,
0.016983380541205406,
-0.1977340131998062,
0.5393999218940735,
0.27505549788475037,
0.5894366502761841,
-0.266182005405426,
0.5861096382141113,
0.321958065032959,
0.0707276314496994,
-0.837594747543335,
0.7994511127471924,
-0.4293302893638611,
0.1819620132446289,
-0.1182209849357605,
-0.9728842377662659,
-0.3932364583015442,
0.6757564544677734,
0.15020136535167694,
-0.12172774225473404,
0.8298020362854004,
0.6657387614250183,
0.06050722301006317,
-0.6097252368927002,
0.4264315962791443,
0.12694872915744781,
0.2822726368904114,
0.8686001300811768,
0.44881194829940796,
-0.45987844467163086,
0.6760470867156982,
-0.1904735565185547,
0.05184537544846535,
-0.5946829319000244,
-1.1006934642791748,
-0.7556121945381165,
-0.3184182941913605,
-0.5015664100646973,
-0.14028400182724,
0.002659338526427746,
0.8461020588874817,
1.0609254837036133,
-0.5995664000511169,
-0.19763237237930298,
-0.0402439646422863,
0.1096348911523819,
-0.23660743236541748,
-0.19338065385818481,
0.4000636637210846,
-0.535712480545044,
-0.6122864484786987,
0.5001292824745178,
0.5010169148445129,
-0.08568678051233292,
-0.46924811601638794,
-0.006987804546952248,
-0.2308579534292221,
0.0581267811357975,
0.6054827570915222,
0.10760806500911713,
-0.8295345902442932,
-0.40337246656417847,
-0.029310019686818123,
-0.23564369976520538,
0.2736169099807739,
0.8200495839118958,
-1.2914546728134155,
0.47633346915245056,
0.4891709089279175,
0.902498722076416,
0.7177041172981262,
-0.0666021779179573,
0.7799301147460938,
-1.1197843551635742,
0.270508736371994,
0.2979297339916229,
0.16534468531608582,
0.19890564680099487,
-0.5996475219726562,
0.4941297769546509,
0.07937023043632507,
-0.5844775438308716,
-0.8239743709564209,
0.11023762822151184,
-1.2560733556747437,
0.04636077210307121,
1.0619847774505615,
-0.09143068641424179,
-0.2262381911277771,
-0.04045748710632324,
-0.04728759452700615,
0.4313444197177887,
-0.40455278754234314,
0.9286465644836426,
0.9009386897087097,
-0.000632377399597317,
-0.29403063654899597,
-0.7022507786750793,
0.640121340751648,
0.49224212765693665,
-0.709243655204773,
0.33434951305389404,
0.15607042610645294,
-0.2495502531528473,
0.11070861667394638,
0.4278290271759033,
0.06496506184339523,
0.2239883989095688,
-0.18695122003555298,
0.09224331378936768,
0.07845504581928253,
-0.3631732761859894,
-0.5183530449867249,
0.24698252975940704,
0.06709730625152588,
-0.5545361638069153
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07054v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07054v1
|
CoEvol: Constructing Better Responses for Instruction Finetuning through Multi-Agent Cooperation
| 2024-06-11T08:35:37 | 2024-06-11T08:35:37 |
Renhao Li, Minghuan Tan, Derek F. Wong, Min Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, instruction fine-tuning (IFT) on large language models
(LLMs) has garnered considerable attention to enhance model performance on
unseen tasks. Attempts have been made on automatic construction and effective
selection for IFT data. However, we posit that previous methods have not fully
harnessed the potential of LLMs for enhancing data quality. The responses
within IFT data could be further enhanced by leveraging the capabilities of
LLMs themselves. In this paper, we propose CoEvol, an LLM-based multi-agent
cooperation framework for the improvement of responses to instructions. To
effectively refine the responses, we develop an iterative framework following a
debate-advise-edit-judge paradigm. A two-stage multi-agent debate strategy is
further devised to ensure the diversity and reliability of editing suggestions
within the framework. Empirically, models equipped with CoEvol outperform
competitive baselines evaluated by MT-Bench and AlpacaEval, demonstrating its
effectiveness in enhancing instruction-following capabilities for LLMs.
|
[
-0.5154695510864258,
-0.7940904498100281,
0.29773399233818054,
0.17104491591453552,
-0.0842069685459137,
0.3445599377155304,
-0.5176551938056946,
-0.18841861188411713,
-0.17423461377620697,
0.5448090434074402,
-0.6384771466255188,
-0.6884190440177917,
-0.7566657662391663,
0.06698401272296906,
-0.24810615181922913,
1.0094642639160156,
0.01032692939043045,
0.2934539318084717,
-0.3056234121322632,
-0.2447407841682434,
-0.5948319435119629,
-0.35436299443244934,
-0.8059017658233643,
-0.5533342957496643,
0.4279897212982178,
0.7817540764808655,
0.7557517290115356,
0.5262658596038818,
0.3156379461288452,
0.4612029194831848,
0.09445033967494965,
0.7732064723968506,
-0.49004065990448,
0.2615557014942169,
-0.32608065009117126,
-0.4380573630332947,
-0.638297438621521,
0.09485450387001038,
0.6604418754577637,
0.555253267288208,
-0.2704315781593323,
-0.0971677377820015,
0.6335518956184387,
0.6672914028167725,
-0.49923381209373474,
0.2626377046108246,
-0.5375990867614746,
-0.080904021859169,
0.30405113101005554,
-0.36808475852012634,
-0.6757395267486572,
-0.36399850249290466,
0.0910138338804245,
-0.5132296085357666,
0.186079204082489,
-0.006547394208610058,
0.47378939390182495,
0.4095003306865692,
-0.026642052456736565,
-0.4489072263240814,
-0.6220716238021851,
0.6049246191978455,
-0.7463680505752563,
0.34070029854774475,
0.3918675184249878,
-0.02108192630112171,
-0.4339284598827362,
-0.661945104598999,
-0.24032515287399292,
-0.38739481568336487,
0.10778238624334335,
0.12196214497089386,
-0.10564600676298141,
0.17599420249462128,
-0.0687294751405716,
0.014249242842197418,
-0.08444267511367798,
0.25575464963912964,
0.0265776626765728,
-0.04428669810295105,
0.6096985936164856,
0.41403728723526,
0.06734622269868851,
0.5288428068161011,
-0.26250767707824707,
-0.12209754437208176,
-0.605982780456543,
0.1578245908021927,
0.4729171693325043,
0.48341959714889526,
-0.0818432942032814,
0.6725611090660095,
0.018279606476426125,
0.576302170753479,
0.5939127802848816,
0.20404760539531708,
-0.17507541179656982,
-0.3960673213005066,
-0.11763360351324081,
-0.0633561983704567,
0.6171467900276184,
0.46172618865966797,
0.007580101024359465,
-0.284523069858551,
-0.33037668466567993,
-0.07254137098789215,
0.24245987832546234,
-0.831634521484375,
-0.24337168037891388,
0.16472025215625763,
-0.2801891565322876,
-0.02375643141567707,
0.07377661019563675,
-0.6843756437301636,
-0.4417714774608612,
-0.7929787039756775,
0.3019200563430786,
-0.5393070578575134,
0.09411206096410751,
0.16006003320217133,
0.12253277748823166,
0.1785248965024948,
0.6209475994110107,
-0.6807658076286316,
0.49126580357551575,
0.9381632804870605,
0.6044707894325256,
-0.19534261524677277,
-0.6187452673912048,
-1.0382299423217773,
-0.04874223470687866,
-0.4531642198562622,
1.0409256219863892,
-0.8849455714225769,
-0.45654377341270447,
-0.0415574349462986,
0.1603870689868927,
0.014995255507528782,
-0.5119050145149231,
0.29862627387046814,
-0.4540834426879883,
0.11007647961378098,
-0.2858816087245941,
-0.9769157767295837,
0.2298940122127533,
0.33990758657455444,
-0.7444958686828613,
0.7287333607673645,
-0.015070350840687752,
-0.5499384999275208,
0.060830309987068176,
-0.5807222127914429,
-0.34953150153160095,
-0.04474063962697983,
-0.21669335663318634,
-0.5608478784561157,
-0.21695831418037415,
0.25641459226608276,
0.38968947529792786,
-0.4590303599834442,
0.07744155079126358,
-0.30080941319465637,
-0.526020884513855,
0.1420341283082962,
-0.5470882654190063,
0.4811907112598419,
0.0639401450753212,
-0.4309249520301819,
0.4991908073425293,
-0.4759625792503357,
0.13138769567012787,
-0.269216924905777,
-0.6013064980506897,
-0.11685149371623993,
0.08752549439668655,
-0.365094393491745,
-0.013102123513817787,
0.0355718694627285,
-0.23662088811397552,
0.5866988301277161,
-0.30426299571990967,
0.1484602391719818,
1.0476069450378418,
-0.1458716243505478,
0.6306357383728027,
-0.5625137090682983,
0.5287399291992188,
-0.07848659157752991,
0.3218192458152771,
0.1589793860912323,
-0.18299905955791473,
-0.7910279631614685,
-0.09501814842224121,
0.18718747794628143,
0.36553218960762024,
-1.2111274003982544,
0.11077672988176346,
0.05297992751002312,
-0.37187570333480835,
-0.9576689004898071,
0.3215089738368988,
0.6151967644691467,
0.05723479762673378,
0.4717175364494324,
-0.21398742496967316,
-0.42893412709236145,
-0.41233310103416443,
-0.020208468660712242,
0.09389112144708633,
0.2950156629085541,
0.3410753011703491,
0.17319338023662567,
-0.20818205177783966,
0.4503476917743683,
-0.22916585206985474,
-0.06704620271921158,
-0.09045707434415817,
0.24619315564632416,
-0.16137012839317322,
0.27161258459091187,
0.3016207814216614,
-0.39118680357933044,
-0.7404123544692993,
0.02871655486524105,
-0.3408671021461487,
-0.05716881528496742,
0.05930763855576515,
-0.24025508761405945,
0.49418866634368896,
0.44542407989501953,
-0.29119449853897095,
0.2741227149963379,
0.5359377861022949,
-0.43817266821861267,
0.6983966827392578,
-0.51039719581604,
0.4501207172870636,
-0.962120532989502,
-0.4627659022808075,
-0.12007228285074234,
-0.11280954629182816,
-0.43147021532058716,
0.1500415951013565,
-0.09902466088533401,
0.27828410267829895,
-0.36997678875923157,
0.40093672275543213,
-0.566647469997406,
-0.1725393831729889,
-0.6513065099716187,
0.20124246180057526,
-0.05118411406874657,
0.5011871457099915,
-0.04021494835615158,
1.1705313920974731,
0.5686477422714233,
-0.5306668281555176,
0.6392742991447449,
0.2858816385269165,
-0.03515423461794853,
0.7566638588905334,
-0.5739961266517639,
0.3726605772972107,
-0.007226757239550352,
0.18780328333377838,
-0.7815712690353394,
0.01241861842572689,
0.18396945297718048,
-0.2513780891895294,
0.23832572996616364,
-0.29759281873703003,
-0.3995681405067444,
-0.09803179651498795,
-0.5507623553276062,
0.0017203433671966195,
0.10019220411777496,
-0.8071185350418091,
0.5826746821403503,
0.11567986011505127,
-0.1892048865556717,
-0.8766195178031921,
-0.33412548899650574,
0.043216522783041,
0.2890423834323883,
-0.5906524062156677,
0.2585853040218353,
-0.6042877435684204,
-0.28730452060699463,
0.2955247759819031,
-0.04775889962911606,
-0.13277004659175873,
0.016317514702677727,
0.16429635882377625,
0.31134033203125,
-0.3235395550727844,
0.27553924918174744,
0.14373113214969635,
-0.037827782332897186,
-0.1199086382985115,
-0.26792144775390625,
0.6291467547416687,
-0.39339667558670044,
-0.40959250926971436,
-0.3296755850315094,
0.476311594247818,
0.41531580686569214,
-0.33196890354156494,
0.7165079116821289,
0.5466569662094116,
0.11487311869859695,
-0.5530452132225037,
-0.38352638483047485,
-0.2695270776748657,
-0.5220016837120056,
0.1122073382139206,
-0.29220864176750183,
-1.0310542583465576,
0.24610544741153717,
-0.28530043363571167,
0.25951507687568665,
0.030826685950160027,
0.7478251457214355,
-0.08093053102493286,
0.8817983269691467,
0.5867570638656616,
-0.005833568517118692,
0.5834550857543945,
-0.40835005044937134,
-0.2895064949989319,
-0.7537346482276917,
-0.3480377495288849,
-0.611113965511322,
-0.04478833079338074,
-0.4565182030200958,
-0.5052900910377502,
0.046760592609643936,
-0.23205870389938354,
-0.2462838590145111,
0.19244563579559326,
-0.5885782837867737,
0.7649807929992676,
0.6291015148162842,
0.2899165153503418,
0.24749982357025146,
-0.10195703059434891,
-0.1831655651330948,
0.34016427397727966,
-0.8004413843154907,
-0.5640910863876343,
0.7760860919952393,
-0.10468319803476334,
1.2062699794769287,
0.1317615807056427,
0.7390440702438354,
0.4401826858520508,
0.17216342687606812,
-0.5271742939949036,
0.5119189620018005,
-0.47400686144828796,
-0.051140353083610535,
-0.38746872544288635,
-0.28365322947502136,
-1.1355156898498535,
0.30294927954673767,
-0.39686983823776245,
-0.37254902720451355,
-0.01975412666797638,
0.09331197291612625,
-0.48549991846084595,
0.30546510219573975,
-0.7682380080223083,
0.6254822611808777,
-0.11464402824640274,
-0.81064373254776,
-0.30509239435195923,
-0.5111868381500244,
-0.05488038808107376,
0.3132625222206116,
0.0500413216650486,
0.051966261118650436,
-0.10047556459903717,
0.31254300475120544,
-0.5640790462493896,
0.8576309084892273,
-0.011590181849896908,
-0.43570515513420105,
0.6182122230529785,
0.02509917877614498,
0.6842539310455322,
0.01008235290646553,
-0.31456127762794495,
-0.368926078081131,
-0.04192860797047615,
-0.33937808871269226,
-0.7796393036842346,
0.8276093602180481,
-1.1128482818603516,
-0.732348620891571,
0.08282103389501572,
-0.8333667516708374,
-0.19206377863883972,
-0.1708407998085022,
0.03112875670194626,
0.678508460521698,
-0.1167057603597641,
0.24040035903453827,
0.6274313926696777,
-0.0662139430642128,
0.44051823019981384,
0.7145559787750244,
0.2450178563594818,
-0.3265414535999298,
0.7723988890647888,
0.1998344510793686,
0.3827385902404785,
0.1894356906414032,
0.11690628528594971,
-0.23359936475753784,
-0.44681763648986816,
-0.17875438928604126,
-0.1826801598072052,
-0.764373779296875,
-0.3965964913368225,
-0.49097245931625366,
-0.3800658583641052,
-0.4373895227909088,
-0.28689974546432495,
-0.5104796290397644,
0.03105761855840683,
-0.3263067603111267,
0.07276564091444016,
0.3569104075431824,
0.7627658843994141,
-0.20653551816940308,
0.42773744463920593,
-0.7362838387489319,
0.1358860582113266,
0.3657446801662445,
0.5720318555831909,
0.11121222376823425,
-0.46513721346855164,
-0.32664939761161804,
0.24685709178447723,
-0.37245985865592957,
-0.5584763884544373,
0.17611463367938995,
0.2174813598394394,
0.6839691400527954,
-0.11309780180454254,
0.24952085316181183,
0.6385862231254578,
-0.5483236312866211,
0.5768006443977356,
-0.14332528412342072,
-1.0292870998382568,
0.3488858938217163,
0.08413024991750717,
0.24566853046417236,
0.3395046889781952,
0.030405713245272636,
-0.2723716199398041,
-0.8050431609153748,
-0.563422679901123,
-0.6487569808959961,
0.9626287221908569,
0.12971632182598114,
0.06766075640916824,
0.14107565581798553,
0.3461013734340668,
0.2907651960849762,
0.01165310014039278,
-0.25565364956855774,
-0.17348012328147888,
-0.08484259247779846,
-0.26757872104644775,
0.034688327461481094,
-0.045045122504234314,
-0.1774793267250061,
-0.21476994454860687,
0.741584062576294,
-0.2575444281101227,
0.25094467401504517,
0.013611966744065285,
-0.0218060165643692,
-0.22385989129543304,
0.5905622839927673,
0.6377633810043335,
0.41899293661117554,
0.17595073580741882,
0.28971734642982483,
0.32223451137542725,
-0.20472857356071472,
0.3730933368206024,
0.2248547524213791,
0.14993372559547424,
-0.2749406695365906,
0.534030556678772,
0.8146988153457642,
0.06510800123214722,
-0.34467753767967224,
0.40923503041267395,
-0.356305330991745,
-0.18633829057216644,
0.2382461428642273,
0.541007936000824,
0.09156311303377151,
0.8568516373634338,
-0.11059024930000305,
0.117576465010643,
0.08621480315923691,
-0.5136765241622925,
0.5766211152076721,
0.3669597804546356,
-0.2544724941253662,
-0.13096129894256592,
0.2644210457801819,
0.2791749835014343,
-0.6198399662971497,
0.42139261960983276,
-0.22461192309856415,
-0.31112194061279297,
0.869331955909729,
0.5719843506813049,
0.6142610311508179,
-0.4803096055984497,
0.3936227858066559,
0.1895373910665512,
0.24776308238506317,
-0.10491012781858444,
0.26172691583633423,
0.0734202191233635,
-0.6894383430480957,
-0.47752323746681213,
-0.049315135926008224,
-0.738078773021698,
-0.13487274944782257,
-0.5458006262779236,
0.21919429302215576,
-0.56729656457901,
-0.05185624212026596,
0.05611710995435715,
0.37531358003616333,
-0.6420376300811768,
-0.15406280755996704,
-0.07557127624750137,
0.5392670631408691,
-0.4489900469779968,
1.1117066144943237,
0.6652424931526184,
-0.4673510193824768,
-1.0508501529693604,
-0.03887619450688362,
-0.1286921501159668,
-0.6562398672103882,
0.27171072363853455,
-0.11566539108753204,
-0.6013929843902588,
0.030702317133545876,
-0.9987245202064514,
-0.43488481640815735,
1.0571751594543457,
0.6438539028167725,
-0.819183349609375,
0.12628747522830963,
0.031948547810316086,
0.6108719706535339,
-0.5337013602256775,
0.3074514865875244,
0.49387362599372864,
0.39954131841659546,
0.3098950982093811,
-0.5306738615036011,
-0.0888638123869896,
-0.08826365321874619,
-0.2495764195919037,
0.021656101569533348,
-0.8085627555847168,
0.8774036169052124,
-0.49159979820251465,
-0.01947210170328617,
0.2407035529613495,
0.6844483017921448,
0.06202951818704605,
0.37798070907592773,
0.39404425024986267,
0.10078515112400055,
0.841316819190979,
0.10379073768854141,
0.9384158849716187,
-0.33048704266548157,
0.39633557200431824,
1.7817124128341675,
-0.24613970518112183,
0.6536993384361267,
0.18545491993427277,
0.03101089410483837,
0.36124348640441895,
0.4885566830635071,
-0.13207316398620605,
0.4159736931324005,
0.06701989471912384,
-0.3103589415550232,
-0.44070273637771606,
-0.3395245373249054,
-0.1575949490070343,
0.2859201729297638,
0.33510786294937134,
-0.030797747895121574,
-0.26115259528160095,
0.05572059750556946,
-0.0642453134059906,
0.46848058700561523,
-0.3448507487773895,
1.0166971683502197,
-0.10866103321313858,
-0.8305383324623108,
0.5480030179023743,
0.046047668904066086,
0.5781024694442749,
-0.3035967946052551,
-0.48894473910331726,
-0.5147408843040466,
0.26930001378059387,
-0.07506357878446579,
-1.128166675567627,
0.07436177879571915,
0.10542582720518112,
-0.12397646903991699,
0.16563554108142853,
0.6897492408752441,
-1.110180139541626,
-0.0737379863858223,
0.5577813386917114,
0.4216371476650238,
-0.11439245194196701,
0.33022135496139526,
-0.9561381936073303,
0.26125696301460266,
-0.2389034777879715,
0.07707926630973816,
0.12771038711071014,
0.675160825252533,
0.16570842266082764,
0.7063918709754944,
0.3850232660770416,
-0.11374753713607788,
0.041882582008838654,
0.23111753165721893,
1.1108604669570923,
-0.14683645963668823,
0.02319432608783245,
-0.9142267107963562,
0.44298356771469116,
-0.07451097667217255,
0.04208144545555115,
0.5836004018783569,
0.2041998952627182,
0.8980962038040161,
0.06895136088132858,
0.5872294902801514,
0.19651353359222412,
0.05122089758515358,
-0.6086980700492859,
0.5432389974594116,
-0.4215752184391022,
0.3388727903366089,
-0.16782346367835999,
-0.7980030179023743,
-0.09375902265310287,
0.4219644069671631,
-0.11861158162355423,
-0.014745681546628475,
0.6257928013801575,
0.9646412134170532,
-0.010274386033415794,
0.040525466203689575,
0.4737708568572998,
0.17814522981643677,
0.4152357578277588,
0.6407669186592102,
1.007004737854004,
-0.25252771377563477,
0.5578721761703491,
-0.12270224094390869,
-0.09683172404766083,
-0.1570533812046051,
-0.5293179154396057,
-1.1083085536956787,
-0.5370265245437622,
-0.3657380938529968,
-0.3581664264202118,
0.5270071029663086,
1.5914119482040405,
0.5588675141334534,
-0.6553405523300171,
-0.29018428921699524,
0.0727948397397995,
0.4183579385280609,
-0.34237563610076904,
-0.10133171826601028,
0.4444485604763031,
-0.7569029331207275,
-0.8024391531944275,
0.42299535870552063,
0.12832577526569366,
-0.020590750500559807,
-0.07826673239469528,
-0.5882415175437927,
-0.29975539445877075,
0.4824099540710449,
0.7753229737281799,
-0.001861760625615716,
-0.673284113407135,
-0.5427483916282654,
-0.12932857871055603,
-0.43354201316833496,
0.15897461771965027,
0.7157391309738159,
-0.2218230664730072,
0.5785702466964722,
0.14654436707496643,
0.9427746534347534,
0.0686962828040123,
-0.13705766201019287,
0.5248384475708008,
-0.8315434455871582,
0.04805697500705719,
0.10046762228012085,
0.21935760974884033,
0.2623653709888458,
-0.38107791543006897,
0.5968322157859802,
-0.13487115502357483,
-0.7327444553375244,
-0.29329508543014526,
-0.06819675862789154,
-0.7586086392402649,
-0.4086839258670807,
1.3264379501342773,
-0.4194263219833374,
-0.16487689316272736,
-0.025241203606128693,
-0.7103963494300842,
0.45533010363578796,
-0.6278167963027954,
0.7946946620941162,
0.8513575196266174,
-0.08630452305078506,
-0.3810598850250244,
-0.11884765326976776,
0.3804255425930023,
0.27385029196739197,
-1.1317931413650513,
0.28620436787605286,
0.6582867503166199,
0.12716758251190186,
-0.2574809789657593,
0.5671045780181885,
0.1289341300725937,
0.4143785238265991,
0.115901418030262,
0.05043630301952362,
-0.3051392138004303,
-0.6893847584724426,
-0.18152831494808197,
0.12659375369548798,
0.3595011234283447,
-0.16109424829483032
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07588v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07588v2
|
AIM: Let Any Multi-modal Large Language Models Embrace Efficient In-Context Learning
| 2024-06-11T08:12:43 | 2024-06-30T18:19:25 |
Jun Gao, Qian Qiao, Ziqiang Cao, Zili Wang, Wenjie Li
|
cs.MM
|
cs.MM, cs.CL
|
In-context learning (ICL) facilitates Large Language Models (LLMs) exhibiting
emergent ability on downstream tasks without updating billions of parameters.
However, in the area of multi-modal Large Language Models (MLLMs), two problems
hinder the application of multi-modal ICL: (1) Most primary MLLMs are only
trained on single-image datasets, making them unable to read multi-modal
demonstrations. (2) With the demonstrations increasing, thousands of visual
tokens highly challenge hardware and degrade ICL performance. During
preliminary explorations, we discovered that the inner LLM tends to focus more
on the linguistic modality within multi-modal demonstrations to generate
responses. Therefore, we propose a general and light-weighted framework
\textbf{AIM} to tackle the mentioned problems through \textbf{A}ggregating
\textbf{I}mage information of \textbf{M}ultimodal demonstrations to the dense
latent space of the corresponding linguistic part. Specifically, AIM first uses
the frozen backbone MLLM to read each image-text demonstration and extracts the
vector representations on top of the text. These vectors naturally fuse the
information of the image-text pair, and AIM transforms them into fused virtual
tokens acceptable for the inner LLM via a trainable projection layer.
Ultimately, these fused tokens function as variants of multi-modal
demonstrations, fed into the MLLM to direct its response to the current query
as usual. Because these fused tokens stem from the textual component of the
image-text pair, a multi-modal demonstration is nearly reduced to a pure
textual demonstration, thus seamlessly applying to any MLLMs. With its de facto
MLLM frozen, AIM is parameter-efficient and we train it on public multi-modal
web corpora which have nothing to do with downstream test tasks.
|
[
-0.3941580057144165,
-0.817096471786499,
0.3683302402496338,
0.229074627161026,
-0.5551432371139526,
-0.17409352958202362,
-0.6223890781402588,
-0.30381515622138977,
-0.15878506004810333,
0.03394559025764465,
-0.39802929759025574,
-0.3794504404067993,
-0.3545745313167572,
0.01597035676240921,
-0.40284278988838196,
0.9734336733818054,
-0.0007057898328639567,
0.1380227953195572,
-0.3066457509994507,
-0.23483005166053772,
-0.22529537975788116,
-0.5352362990379333,
-0.5290063619613647,
-0.12072765082120895,
0.5095717310905457,
0.38658612966537476,
0.4263119697570801,
0.2794227600097656,
0.2098831683397293,
0.28974834084510803,
0.12067237496376038,
0.34942826628685,
-0.5809683203697205,
0.18285411596298218,
0.10584704577922821,
-0.19092898070812225,
-0.051523275673389435,
-0.07362721860408783,
0.9832220077514648,
0.49793288111686707,
0.14118054509162903,
0.06317582726478577,
0.2881678640842438,
0.24251767992973328,
-0.6471337080001831,
0.33748090267181396,
-0.9652169346809387,
-0.17711178958415985,
-0.12580931186676025,
-0.12192722409963608,
-0.6067929267883301,
0.30905860662460327,
0.019433103501796722,
-0.47956252098083496,
-0.11452321708202362,
0.2698182165622711,
0.7409290075302124,
0.22050191462039948,
-0.6839312314987183,
-0.27011120319366455,
-0.5716813206672668,
0.9585621356964111,
-0.6448917388916016,
0.5309635996818542,
0.3049881160259247,
0.2624688446521759,
-0.005491879768669605,
-0.5913852453231812,
-0.6929510831832886,
-0.5110217332839966,
-0.2219349890947342,
-0.040690433233976364,
-0.021635178476572037,
0.03987114876508713,
0.22006036341190338,
0.12499446421861649,
-0.4347105026245117,
0.15272320806980133,
-0.09764085710048676,
-0.1637388914823532,
0.3246470093727112,
0.15465131402015686,
0.14044128358364105,
-0.17453978955745697,
-0.7170896530151367,
-0.06400402635335922,
-0.7083702683448792,
0.2586926519870758,
0.04456988722085953,
0.3574139475822449,
-0.33012980222702026,
0.5260297060012817,
0.10507555305957794,
0.7042230367660522,
0.22866377234458923,
-0.4393025040626526,
0.2806232273578644,
-0.4197423458099365,
-0.460050106048584,
-0.221588134765625,
0.888453483581543,
0.21772165596485138,
-0.1278291493654251,
-0.22598035633563995,
-0.30958059430122375,
-0.18380671739578247,
0.028917349874973297,
-0.9318146705627441,
0.17737184464931488,
0.23111726343631744,
-0.5068574547767639,
0.10935752838850021,
-0.013117944821715355,
-0.672911524772644,
-0.09790436923503876,
-0.5586551427841187,
0.7524614930152893,
-0.6348689794540405,
-0.23511123657226562,
-0.09301748126745224,
0.1886015236377716,
0.2886304259300232,
0.44969332218170166,
-0.6985095739364624,
0.09404149651527405,
0.5686120986938477,
0.7700768113136292,
-0.20782886445522308,
-0.41651925444602966,
-0.6528351902961731,
0.310328871011734,
-0.11911820620298386,
0.43359723687171936,
-0.5458828210830688,
-0.04715103656053543,
0.03769366443157196,
0.02786864899098873,
-0.4181506931781769,
-0.3252858817577362,
0.12920963764190674,
-0.5649669766426086,
0.44388270378112793,
-0.18958953022956848,
-0.49033883213996887,
-0.2392134666442871,
0.47939950227737427,
-0.44950753450393677,
0.702393651008606,
-0.1356225460767746,
-0.8800309896469116,
0.5465582013130188,
-0.7899978160858154,
-0.5143362283706665,
-0.08536741137504578,
-0.36466512084007263,
-0.2721984088420868,
-0.03816546872258186,
0.24169814586639404,
0.7105887532234192,
-0.43256545066833496,
0.36761730909347534,
-0.23462632298469543,
-0.45836248993873596,
0.38512730598449707,
-0.7891162633895874,
0.5166566371917725,
0.11130068451166153,
-0.6786497235298157,
0.3030308783054352,
-0.6668990254402161,
-0.04203678295016289,
-0.1481131613254547,
-0.6276870369911194,
-0.33173495531082153,
0.1015593633055687,
0.3854316174983978,
0.37498369812965393,
0.014783179387450218,
-0.46741002798080444,
0.1997992992401123,
-0.39636656641960144,
0.23872071504592896,
0.8189403414726257,
-0.23963342607021332,
0.4385012984275818,
-0.10330801457166672,
0.44613444805145264,
0.22169271111488342,
0.21755169332027435,
-0.539655327796936,
-0.31631022691726685,
-0.7158669829368591,
-0.804598867893219,
0.16008682548999786,
0.34146714210510254,
-0.9870348572731018,
0.1485104262828827,
-0.2180691361427307,
-0.14621232450008392,
-0.4528605341911316,
0.26836976408958435,
0.6987589597702026,
0.5542988777160645,
0.3812659978866577,
0.06203467398881912,
-0.17808838188648224,
-1.0145279169082642,
0.05719974264502525,
-0.09014227986335754,
-0.0498570017516613,
0.38022780418395996,
0.38090944290161133,
-0.00005729599797632545,
0.7790902256965637,
0.019937699660658836,
-0.23793314397335052,
-0.18840838968753815,
0.1292700320482254,
0.06960350275039673,
0.3674379885196686,
0.6260799169540405,
-1.1701358556747437,
-0.5930363535881042,
0.04449404031038284,
-0.7624098062515259,
0.14957651495933533,
-0.18789227306842804,
0.09649143368005753,
0.3154603838920593,
0.6360616683959961,
-0.6667534708976746,
0.24571357667446136,
0.6358051300048828,
-0.26417410373687744,
0.43755853176116943,
-0.08977257460355759,
0.32733795046806335,
-1.2158869504928589,
0.12068988382816315,
-0.13224539160728455,
-0.1412622183561325,
-0.4875754117965698,
0.22857320308685303,
0.27906689047813416,
-0.06534029543399811,
-0.6574430465698242,
0.6821990609169006,
-0.6650807857513428,
0.00478561595082283,
-0.2556731402873993,
0.04870683699846268,
-0.06228579208254814,
0.6879501938819885,
-0.2649838626384735,
0.8379275798797607,
0.8397163152694702,
-0.7148626446723938,
0.10830753296613693,
-0.004384276922792196,
-0.281667560338974,
0.709244966506958,
-0.3893790543079376,
0.02560437098145485,
-0.4310092031955719,
0.24067817628383636,
-1.0596904754638672,
-0.2727745771408081,
0.30030879378318787,
-0.0665726587176323,
0.5977418422698975,
-0.0955994501709938,
-0.5276831984519958,
-0.11768525838851929,
-0.27323606610298157,
0.5514954924583435,
0.26787763833999634,
-0.6496431231498718,
0.8423987627029419,
0.09400305151939392,
0.2210671454668045,
-0.7269876599311829,
-0.6159468293190002,
0.21160201728343964,
-0.36643797159194946,
-0.5747537612915039,
0.3074546754360199,
-0.44455206394195557,
-0.3415241539478302,
-0.04015816003084183,
0.33954593539237976,
0.02934545837342739,
-0.03287964686751366,
0.32128438353538513,
0.03808962181210518,
-0.38464513421058655,
0.5594295859336853,
-0.0440032035112381,
0.11317241936922073,
-0.22137074172496796,
-0.1968833953142166,
0.5988718867301941,
-0.29353365302085876,
-0.7545135617256165,
-0.410409152507782,
0.5989362001419067,
1.0003825426101685,
-0.22455880045890808,
0.82222980260849,
0.7643966674804688,
-0.30103546380996704,
-0.025855574756860733,
-0.5694109201431274,
-0.1473131775856018,
-0.45333242416381836,
0.4598841965198517,
-0.477720707654953,
-0.8402679562568665,
0.29304108023643494,
0.1379544734954834,
0.2504141926765442,
0.20923633873462677,
0.7510913610458374,
0.13701333105564117,
1.2013148069381714,
0.6099979281425476,
-0.09704607725143433,
0.5327581763267517,
-0.18761451542377472,
0.06155187636613846,
-0.908068060874939,
-0.36873793601989746,
-0.19607260823249817,
-0.42142584919929504,
0.11057981848716736,
-0.5723851919174194,
0.6673680543899536,
0.26312321424484253,
-0.183731347322464,
0.04279998317360878,
-0.1352255493402481,
0.26924213767051697,
0.4717411994934082,
0.21787069737911224,
0.22638574242591858,
0.14301803708076477,
-0.4329705536365509,
-0.0712021067738533,
-0.6979435086250305,
-0.33956390619277954,
0.9797638058662415,
0.17622530460357666,
0.8799768686294556,
0.1845652461051941,
0.27245214581489563,
-0.053922902792692184,
0.4706946015357971,
-0.8797627091407776,
0.5387421250343323,
-0.05470169708132744,
-0.5286250710487366,
-0.25991374254226685,
-0.2656324505805969,
-0.7859233617782593,
0.6258765459060669,
-0.20805883407592773,
-0.5898537039756775,
0.03371288627386093,
0.3056528568267822,
0.018585234880447388,
0.4573459327220917,
-0.7590029239654541,
0.770768404006958,
-0.48551344871520996,
-0.4923921823501587,
-0.21578052639961243,
-0.687466561794281,
0.43986472487449646,
-0.12872210144996643,
0.45000573992729187,
0.11569765955209732,
-0.1710149198770523,
0.359727680683136,
-0.09882864356040955,
1.0964536666870117,
-0.26113176345825195,
-0.13691405951976776,
0.10278282314538956,
0.12325098365545273,
0.29987916350364685,
0.11572100222110748,
-0.08903606981039047,
-0.22856944799423218,
-0.37355899810791016,
-0.2918684482574463,
-0.5330073833465576,
0.6261358857154846,
-0.508172869682312,
-0.40520164370536804,
0.028778010979294777,
-0.7107852101325989,
-0.31577470898628235,
-0.0008620602311566472,
0.22030462324619293,
1.0158120393753052,
-0.08776690065860748,
0.5710705518722534,
0.47018861770629883,
-0.054775167256593704,
0.8060124516487122,
0.5173571109771729,
-0.2590571939945221,
-0.42071500420570374,
0.7061532735824585,
-0.12134508788585663,
0.5297248959541321,
0.5350068211555481,
0.2043205350637436,
-0.3690425753593445,
-0.4796942472457886,
-0.6828664541244507,
0.0901331827044487,
-0.8734158873558044,
-0.28643810749053955,
-0.8445668816566467,
0.11130766570568085,
-0.2670482099056244,
-0.17149578034877777,
-0.2498144656419754,
-0.045853953808546066,
-0.5332279801368713,
0.21386420726776123,
0.19724135100841522,
0.5393304824829102,
-0.01126864179968834,
0.1625724881887436,
-0.5502304434776306,
0.3392014503479004,
0.500092089176178,
0.06679283082485199,
0.22866064310073853,
-0.5627635717391968,
-0.2812536358833313,
0.17516440153121948,
-0.15533244609832764,
-0.61458820104599,
0.22586806118488312,
0.6394972801208496,
0.6424955129623413,
0.7646089196205139,
-0.05133362114429474,
0.8496048450469971,
-0.531073808670044,
0.8598690032958984,
0.3902643918991089,
-0.9192100167274475,
0.21627438068389893,
-0.31559741497039795,
0.38272175192832947,
0.35455939173698425,
0.5168682336807251,
-0.39465397596359253,
-0.46565714478492737,
-0.2892489731311798,
-0.9561604261398315,
0.4777770936489105,
-0.09645094722509384,
0.3558843731880188,
-0.1103496104478836,
0.18272356688976288,
0.21191944181919098,
0.42145490646362305,
-1.0625661611557007,
-0.12775304913520813,
-0.24699310958385468,
-0.2507023811340332,
-0.1250080019235611,
-0.2430696040391922,
-0.27804017066955566,
-0.37606608867645264,
0.5112138390541077,
-0.7359040379524231,
0.18747885525226593,
0.0910947322845459,
-0.4219171106815338,
-0.09281396120786667,
0.31380322575569153,
0.7438069581985474,
0.8018118143081665,
0.10545899718999863,
0.4271872639656067,
0.10222265124320984,
-0.044215332716703415,
0.0907382220029831,
0.03521689772605896,
-0.20482438802719116,
-0.1355506032705307,
0.50173419713974,
0.9791576862335205,
0.7153211832046509,
-0.8101574778556824,
0.8424244523048401,
0.012597374618053436,
-0.13122084736824036,
-0.10310442000627518,
-0.39160972833633423,
-0.04864073172211647,
0.45400291681289673,
0.6650696396827698,
-0.04267438128590584,
-0.06799601763486862,
-0.6859452724456787,
0.3659909963607788,
0.8087297677993774,
-0.4112342298030853,
-0.38305890560150146,
0.644098699092865,
-0.14496970176696777,
-0.18544898927211761,
0.3919345438480377,
-0.28401756286621094,
-0.6617986559867859,
0.2926308512687683,
0.8296458721160889,
0.6644489765167236,
0.06731369346380234,
0.17117804288864136,
0.18168413639068604,
0.15957500040531158,
0.12245859950780869,
0.028080003336071968,
-0.13995566964149475,
-0.5628036856651306,
-0.5891333222389221,
-0.5946282744407654,
-0.09225630015134811,
0.16970273852348328,
-0.2985004186630249,
0.38254067301750183,
-0.33000442385673523,
0.037568818777799606,
-0.3336428999900818,
-0.46493983268737793,
-0.66889888048172,
0.0728888064622879,
0.28108304738998413,
0.6536672115325928,
-0.6848896145820618,
0.7372735142707825,
0.6342177391052246,
-0.3628096282482147,
-0.7573839426040649,
0.11023280769586563,
-0.04520222544670105,
-0.7758485674858093,
0.9164506793022156,
0.33404168486595154,
-0.20254480838775635,
-0.08201052993535995,
-0.7746317386627197,
-0.8253490924835205,
0.9749524593353271,
0.6290306448936462,
-0.2441062182188034,
-0.06789957731962204,
-0.2076379805803299,
0.32797664403915405,
-0.6456338763237,
0.30921030044555664,
-0.24036486446857452,
0.564527690410614,
0.1595100611448288,
-1.1361503601074219,
0.08184170722961426,
-0.10896707326173782,
-0.29329997301101685,
0.0005402659298852086,
-0.8111791610717773,
1.1222738027572632,
-0.1436399668455124,
-0.24535879492759705,
0.03831753507256508,
0.5622970461845398,
0.07367967814207077,
0.200071319937706,
0.8232118487358093,
0.3620017468929291,
0.4317990243434906,
0.1390010565519333,
1.1155784130096436,
-0.23505719006061554,
0.2294905036687851,
0.9020234942436218,
-0.24253709614276886,
0.9709420800209045,
0.7320243120193481,
0.22807222604751587,
0.370670884847641,
0.3244350850582123,
0.1965581625699997,
0.5420666933059692,
0.0913204699754715,
-0.4402288794517517,
-0.46655529737472534,
-0.14389555156230927,
-0.28139352798461914,
0.7260442972183228,
0.32644104957580566,
-0.3092598021030426,
-0.3640836179256439,
0.6145799160003662,
-0.00687214033678174,
0.01138152927160263,
-0.2994805872440338,
0.7049865126609802,
-0.00043467601062729955,
-0.45203912258148193,
0.741525411605835,
-0.11417007446289062,
0.958734393119812,
-0.7080057859420776,
-0.033801235258579254,
0.16691622138023376,
0.11251523345708847,
0.04218839108943939,
-0.2977067232131958,
-0.052530910819768906,
-0.2604138255119324,
-0.14899028837680817,
-0.2724912166595459,
0.5560240745544434,
-0.7694725394248962,
-0.43126899003982544,
0.47656184434890747,
0.47201359272003174,
0.1266121119260788,
-0.15600083768367767,
-0.7091745734214783,
0.1422935277223587,
-0.2681537866592407,
-0.39051908254623413,
0.5875453948974609,
0.45446038246154785,
0.021368999034166336,
0.6938959360122681,
0.6006888747215271,
-0.30559879541397095,
0.16120028495788574,
0.09964560717344284,
1.146701455116272,
-0.2711520791053772,
-0.40006914734840393,
-0.8184657096862793,
0.6591486930847168,
0.05652911588549614,
-0.2774569094181061,
0.6592645645141602,
0.5583786368370056,
0.692051351070404,
-0.05506573244929314,
0.5455480813980103,
-0.21504442393779755,
0.25443899631500244,
-0.8990921378135681,
0.6152580976486206,
-1.0156316757202148,
0.006274397950619459,
-0.20709286630153656,
-0.7432999014854431,
-0.2851572632789612,
0.39053526520729065,
0.0654730498790741,
0.04889119789004326,
0.8102554678916931,
0.7269411087036133,
-0.36643391847610474,
-0.31445592641830444,
0.631699800491333,
0.21219517290592194,
0.3808024227619171,
0.5385968685150146,
0.8328911066055298,
-0.3293605148792267,
0.6248624920845032,
-0.20255795121192932,
-0.1923556923866272,
-0.25326740741729736,
-0.9775480031967163,
-1.068610429763794,
-0.8636625409126282,
-0.08635016530752182,
-0.14104127883911133,
-0.13241420686244965,
1.218755841255188,
0.9978960156440735,
-0.7028500437736511,
-0.24020737409591675,
0.3439626693725586,
-0.04193831980228424,
-0.12366170436143875,
-0.2827649712562561,
0.4324896037578583,
-0.46821677684783936,
-0.7846764326095581,
0.6880952715873718,
0.3645666539669037,
0.042966898530721664,
-0.5193593502044678,
-0.06576201319694519,
-0.3608733117580414,
-0.2873101830482483,
1.0170809030532837,
0.1336079090833664,
-0.9047948122024536,
-0.49000468850135803,
-0.03038150444626808,
-0.07486041635274887,
0.047961149364709854,
1.0001991987228394,
-0.7767019867897034,
0.361669659614563,
0.04446164518594742,
0.7966607809066772,
0.373655766248703,
-0.19521354138851166,
0.4590003192424774,
-0.8036866188049316,
0.5048601627349854,
0.21900294721126556,
0.4236251413822174,
0.39834409952163696,
-0.19531717896461487,
0.028251389041543007,
0.17075525224208832,
-0.3056083023548126,
-0.7062011361122131,
0.33874499797821045,
-1.0100340843200684,
-0.3977124094963074,
1.3050779104232788,
-0.09083065390586853,
-0.22330385446548462,
-0.15704314410686493,
-0.3804129362106323,
-0.004406924359500408,
-0.30173495411872864,
0.5868021249771118,
0.48015549778938293,
0.01245268527418375,
-0.2955700755119324,
-0.4361494779586792,
0.32980602979660034,
0.34929823875427246,
-0.6585221886634827,
0.09955298900604248,
0.6887929439544678,
0.12185026705265045,
0.055806368589401245,
0.5727038383483887,
-0.02801399677991867,
0.053936414420604706,
-0.2566893696784973,
-0.016000298783183098,
-0.21825675666332245,
-0.572770357131958,
-0.488307386636734,
0.6232681274414062,
0.02480224519968033,
-0.0689743235707283
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07036v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07036v1
|
Paying More Attention to Source Context: Mitigating Unfaithful Translations from Large Language Model
| 2024-06-11T07:49:04 | 2024-06-11T07:49:04 |
Hongbin Zhang, Kehai Chen, Xuefeng Bai, Yang Xiang, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have showcased impressive multilingual machine
translation ability. However, unlike encoder-decoder style models, decoder-only
LLMs lack an explicit alignment between source and target contexts. Analyzing
contribution scores during generation processes revealed that LLMs can be
biased towards previously generated tokens over corresponding source tokens,
leading to unfaithful translations. To address this issue, we propose to
encourage LLMs to pay more attention to the source context from both source and
target perspectives in zeroshot prompting: 1) adjust source context attention
weights; 2) suppress irrelevant target prefix influence; Additionally, we
propose 3) avoiding over-reliance on the target prefix in instruction tuning.
Experimental results from both human-collected unfaithfulness test sets
focusing on LLM-generated unfaithful translations and general test sets, verify
our methods' effectiveness across multiple language pairs. Further human
evaluation shows our method's efficacy in reducing hallucinatory translations
and facilitating faithful translation generation.
|
[
-0.11708931624889374,
-0.7207072377204895,
0.6363678574562073,
0.24280765652656555,
-0.5128484964370728,
-0.1443641036748886,
-0.2788235545158386,
-0.2595047652721405,
-0.14964406192302704,
0.7920500636100769,
-0.6861945986747742,
-0.29951468110084534,
-0.6338085532188416,
0.18779638409614563,
-0.44100239872932434,
1.1165380477905273,
-0.1993531882762909,
0.29068806767463684,
-0.04695172235369682,
-0.09024035185575485,
-0.6638912558555603,
-0.47671088576316833,
-0.5323508977890015,
-0.2589450478553772,
0.7088502645492554,
0.3469473719596863,
0.6123959422111511,
0.6384638547897339,
0.4661363959312439,
0.17860375344753265,
0.009877373464405537,
0.2740841805934906,
-0.628106951713562,
0.3587076961994171,
-0.4648120105266571,
-0.41017377376556396,
-0.2711917459964752,
-0.025591140612959862,
0.5618173480033875,
0.4072549045085907,
0.15901905298233032,
0.4170708656311035,
0.1660180538892746,
0.39080190658569336,
-0.9163249731063843,
-0.08415070921182632,
-0.7620577216148376,
0.02193940430879593,
-0.28168225288391113,
-0.4284701943397522,
-0.9172719717025757,
0.1652553677558899,
-0.40029922127723694,
-0.3534108102321625,
0.3326452374458313,
-0.12100319564342499,
0.5350244045257568,
0.629468560218811,
-0.6353164315223694,
0.06284159421920776,
-0.659240186214447,
0.9551884531974792,
-0.6776553392410278,
0.3199223279953003,
0.24600636959075928,
-0.03080848790705204,
-0.46693819761276245,
-0.11960536986589432,
-0.46471723914146423,
0.04187113419175148,
0.015690486878156662,
-0.030215540900826454,
-0.1736588031053543,
-0.07595769315958023,
0.26926112174987793,
-0.13042476773262024,
-0.20114031434059143,
0.06660425662994385,
-0.0965193510055542,
-0.3602420389652252,
0.5565981864929199,
0.051780927926301956,
0.3293248414993286,
-0.05052187666296959,
-0.28479817509651184,
-0.2580018937587738,
-1.0741177797317505,
-0.12994833290576935,
0.022660313174128532,
0.49044981598854065,
0.0222577303647995,
0.678010106086731,
0.07978503406047821,
0.7374178767204285,
0.3123072385787964,
-0.06526307761669159,
0.12070639431476593,
-0.44793978333473206,
-0.2982957363128662,
0.46345293521881104,
0.4501785933971405,
0.5876190066337585,
0.27453726530075073,
-0.21509802341461182,
-0.050176020711660385,
0.0747150406241417,
0.5011640787124634,
-0.8555765151977539,
0.3828935921192169,
0.14804859459400177,
-0.08774936944246292,
-0.28739237785339355,
-0.11656463891267776,
-0.5843566656112671,
-0.14413738250732422,
-0.3223665654659271,
0.26454439759254456,
-0.31023144721984863,
0.060601118952035904,
-0.05574449896812439,
0.038002073764801025,
0.4935670793056488,
0.3225594758987427,
-0.7511731386184692,
-0.22169817984104156,
0.635118842124939,
0.7611579298973083,
-0.061156004667282104,
-0.4640457332134247,
-1.0411553382873535,
0.6371120810508728,
-0.5591774582862854,
0.577691912651062,
-0.5190567374229431,
-0.17351694405078888,
0.05163265019655228,
0.10126826167106628,
0.09988012164831161,
-0.2137157917022705,
0.6576372981071472,
-0.5879293084144592,
0.20245924592018127,
-0.48615750670433044,
-0.4314276874065399,
-0.08146689087152481,
0.12035708874464035,
-0.26628363132476807,
0.7490015625953674,
0.12840799987316132,
-0.4917246401309967,
0.37377336621284485,
-0.5198178887367249,
-0.6547353863716125,
0.02992614358663559,
-0.12270091474056244,
-0.2668639123439789,
0.5368255376815796,
0.4684337079524994,
0.4726530611515045,
-0.05541442707180977,
0.3351041078567505,
-0.13038748502731323,
-0.3646206259727478,
0.17757819592952728,
-0.6457210183143616,
0.7287559509277344,
0.27867570519447327,
-0.6121250987052917,
0.14732439815998077,
-0.12400534003973007,
-0.06106284633278847,
0.1833023577928543,
-0.16164569556713104,
-0.4850251078605652,
-0.24991019070148468,
0.10875088721513748,
0.4724089205265045,
-0.10271697491407394,
-0.5860487818717957,
0.07672849297523499,
-0.4470229148864746,
0.346479207277298,
0.7457748055458069,
0.12911488115787506,
0.3857296407222748,
-0.04961574450135231,
0.3743107318878174,
0.25932350754737854,
-0.0113728828728199,
-0.5101967453956604,
-0.35142648220062256,
-0.6241751909255981,
-0.1308271437883377,
-0.003740099025890231,
0.32491767406463623,
-0.786279559135437,
0.4097342789173126,
-0.2438354641199112,
0.002807478653267026,
-0.6512149572372437,
0.42935967445373535,
0.7975283861160278,
0.6071394681930542,
0.4493228793144226,
-0.33588916063308716,
-0.31389710307121277,
-0.6939133405685425,
-0.44174474477767944,
0.126468688249588,
-0.1580272912979126,
0.12484097480773926,
0.35886529088020325,
-0.23631519079208374,
0.7385292053222656,
-0.18614821135997772,
-0.5058071613311768,
-0.1400453895330429,
0.0011477363295853138,
-0.026661457493901253,
0.33621710538864136,
0.5348307490348816,
-0.6900062561035156,
-0.4870383143424988,
-0.11212108284235,
-0.615692675113678,
-0.22561399638652802,
-0.33760663866996765,
-0.3997661769390106,
0.4007963538169861,
0.705277144908905,
-0.5986886024475098,
0.24977664649486542,
0.4026457369327545,
-0.5789611339569092,
0.09544295072555542,
-0.1083756759762764,
0.10263993591070175,
-1.2734445333480835,
0.14205040037631989,
-0.19354651868343353,
-0.37723270058631897,
-0.6522723436355591,
0.5158167481422424,
0.32543081045150757,
0.09126029163599014,
-0.833343505859375,
0.6316449046134949,
-0.6996302604675293,
-0.021795235574245453,
-0.27753838896751404,
0.281444251537323,
0.15414024889469147,
0.4313061535358429,
-0.1254812628030777,
0.8513240218162537,
0.2719838321208954,
-0.34379899501800537,
0.2601868808269501,
0.4498291015625,
-0.015979204326868057,
0.7925857901573181,
-0.4809616208076477,
0.23987995088100433,
-0.2167835682630539,
0.35332491993904114,
-0.79462069272995,
-0.400840163230896,
0.33233559131622314,
-0.5311770439147949,
0.7279126048088074,
0.00438256561756134,
-0.4420187771320343,
-0.02365039847791195,
-0.43805548548698425,
0.3860328495502472,
0.387497216463089,
-0.5000841021537781,
0.2401735484600067,
0.052244797348976135,
0.07805022597312927,
-0.7480422854423523,
-0.9393860101699829,
0.41991323232650757,
-0.13153740763664246,
-0.34130945801734924,
0.2121872454881668,
-0.05535419285297394,
-0.08306524157524109,
-0.07909349352121353,
-0.18639162182807922,
0.08694981783628464,
-0.009272282011806965,
0.07903629541397095,
0.3291853368282318,
-0.18631187081336975,
0.011565281078219414,
0.1178244948387146,
-0.005398713052272797,
0.15782885253429413,
-0.33936694264411926,
0.44537079334259033,
0.3835090100765228,
-0.5118125677108765,
-0.23121699690818787,
0.6088069081306458,
0.8420737981796265,
-0.264508992433548,
0.8254175782203674,
0.5673525333404541,
-0.14308112859725952,
-0.19787918031215668,
-0.5953060984611511,
-0.40010589361190796,
-0.40119242668151855,
0.42199817299842834,
-0.2216261923313141,
-0.975820779800415,
0.3341250717639923,
0.10301646590232849,
0.1181206926703453,
0.22355666756629944,
0.8955321311950684,
0.20136207342147827,
1.163991928100586,
0.5948426127433777,
-0.41418564319610596,
0.3795088827610016,
0.21145248413085938,
0.35287633538246155,
-1.112531065940857,
0.016906851902604103,
-0.34521812200546265,
-0.3394733667373657,
-0.38030123710632324,
-0.5989042520523071,
0.2559170424938202,
0.20540179312229156,
-0.13503806293010712,
0.3500334322452545,
-0.6237752437591553,
0.7184396982192993,
0.3640958368778229,
-0.015908032655715942,
0.1739199310541153,
0.20699457824230194,
-0.14361783862113953,
-0.2353285849094391,
-0.5083072185516357,
-0.34284207224845886,
1.2092187404632568,
0.2527192234992981,
0.5017197132110596,
0.2886745035648346,
0.556016206741333,
0.0408111996948719,
0.4493105411529541,
-0.6670923829078674,
0.25353026390075684,
-0.07845304161310196,
-0.7839834690093994,
-0.3970027267932892,
-0.41233620047569275,
-0.7640997171401978,
0.27132049202919006,
0.3004508316516876,
-0.7141260504722595,
0.11420197039842606,
0.10390768200159073,
-0.3873851001262665,
0.16641581058502197,
-0.5408653616905212,
0.8055728077888489,
-0.3219537138938904,
-0.7181324362754822,
-0.03386798873543739,
-0.524620771408081,
0.48491543531417847,
-0.3063969612121582,
0.11366734653711319,
0.05723929777741432,
-0.18892227113246918,
0.14512716233730316,
-0.08549310266971588,
1.0370591878890991,
-0.08011302351951599,
-0.5655412673950195,
0.02973540872335434,
0.3436048626899719,
0.6887052655220032,
0.10620729625225067,
0.006801356561481953,
0.2084323912858963,
-0.39564114809036255,
-0.5460281372070312,
-0.4271489381790161,
0.7961017489433289,
-0.7180524468421936,
-0.6664959192276001,
-0.2486662119626999,
-0.7570662498474121,
-0.2027512490749359,
0.3933202922344208,
0.6625452637672424,
0.11200243979692459,
-0.0778733491897583,
0.17346373200416565,
0.8627378940582275,
-0.015148196369409561,
0.507695198059082,
0.7470952272415161,
0.010390257462859154,
-0.17143145203590393,
0.700393795967102,
-0.23281586170196533,
0.43530526757240295,
0.3198873996734619,
-0.15809239447116852,
-0.37555351853370667,
-0.3349635601043701,
-0.9141996502876282,
0.30951228737831116,
-0.6429148316383362,
-0.479129433631897,
-0.36391517519950867,
-0.11024590581655502,
-0.676218569278717,
-0.4009818136692047,
-0.44513869285583496,
0.09308568388223648,
-0.36234334111213684,
0.08544578403234482,
0.19716161489486694,
0.3735954463481903,
0.05916782096028328,
0.20823757350444794,
-0.8355814218521118,
0.2582504153251648,
0.11425285786390305,
0.11090221256017685,
-0.12833966314792633,
-0.9260183572769165,
0.05017862468957901,
0.14894118905067444,
-0.32469379901885986,
-0.9321034550666809,
0.5465384721755981,
0.1075296550989151,
0.4311796724796295,
0.4966885447502136,
0.21373900771141052,
0.7225782871246338,
-0.6511272192001343,
0.7098062038421631,
0.24328088760375977,
-1.1076940298080444,
0.6081440448760986,
-0.43747037649154663,
0.6573022603988647,
0.5703651309013367,
0.23806962370872498,
-0.7141866087913513,
-0.6751494407653809,
-0.27667132019996643,
-0.7709687352180481,
0.871630847454071,
0.1984594762325287,
0.6151461601257324,
0.024695776402950287,
0.599072277545929,
-0.15913841128349304,
0.2891470789909363,
-0.8272742033004761,
-0.07044346630573273,
-0.1520051807165146,
-0.08983061462640762,
-0.37169256806373596,
-0.41400331258773804,
-0.33017104864120483,
-0.1601446121931076,
0.5902886390686035,
-0.3204386830329895,
0.08882952481508255,
0.38358697295188904,
-0.22880195081233978,
-0.7866642475128174,
0.36484694480895996,
0.9812119007110596,
0.38966670632362366,
-0.01354364212602377,
0.2826283276081085,
0.11445052921772003,
-0.4489510655403137,
0.3701586425304413,
-0.3774866759777069,
-0.6261584162712097,
0.02359549142420292,
0.5040602684020996,
0.6993134021759033,
0.3883169889450073,
-0.47467732429504395,
0.6071842312812805,
0.11070140451192856,
-0.007327414583414793,
-0.14956770837306976,
0.11936327815055847,
0.1532365381717682,
0.04666781798005104,
0.19659370183944702,
-0.04248702898621559,
-0.19981034100055695,
-0.5543748140335083,
0.1878938525915146,
0.5168089270591736,
-0.5952745676040649,
-0.1889086812734604,
0.696313202381134,
0.2319478839635849,
-0.3533646762371063,
0.5507559180259705,
-0.23613335192203522,
-0.49806609749794006,
0.29875606298446655,
0.8618766069412231,
0.9643312692642212,
-0.6414719223976135,
0.14573070406913757,
0.3151102066040039,
0.48037320375442505,
-0.15717639029026031,
-0.06166943162679672,
-0.17649930715560913,
-0.6758856773376465,
-0.7601139545440674,
-0.49296844005584717,
-0.2378040850162506,
0.3571571111679077,
-0.717193603515625,
0.35595226287841797,
-0.08462414145469666,
0.1982693374156952,
-0.17399515211582184,
-0.35818323493003845,
-0.3130844831466675,
-0.14305084943771362,
0.23188884556293488,
0.6312064528465271,
-0.7932359576225281,
0.9181777834892273,
0.6193488240242004,
-0.4887385666370392,
-0.6900294423103333,
0.24824675917625427,
0.17393004894256592,
-0.7390493750572205,
0.5758366584777832,
0.13619327545166016,
-0.2442304491996765,
0.06017206981778145,
-0.6821618676185608,
-0.880686342716217,
0.7035095691680908,
0.8080881834030151,
-0.7516377568244934,
0.03793244808912277,
0.2799190878868103,
0.36756646633148193,
-0.3624994158744812,
0.1151876375079155,
0.4468947947025299,
0.4558066725730896,
0.20912809669971466,
-0.7041469812393188,
0.3763909339904785,
-0.1735491007566452,
-0.008923955261707306,
0.38190531730651855,
-0.6115574836730957,
0.7085187435150146,
-0.2688366174697876,
-0.289185494184494,
-0.23169350624084473,
0.2512732148170471,
0.25016942620277405,
0.09457999467849731,
0.17997051775455475,
0.406374990940094,
0.19604434072971344,
0.20120352506637573,
0.9858861565589905,
-0.3010989725589752,
0.06423146277666092,
1.424343466758728,
-0.5347131490707397,
0.8527585864067078,
0.9889312982559204,
0.2389596551656723,
0.10714633762836456,
0.3583657741546631,
-0.19906014204025269,
0.6494227051734924,
0.13171018660068512,
-0.2751947343349457,
-0.3267742097377777,
-0.39204686880111694,
-0.2894541919231415,
0.5714918971061707,
0.07810486853122711,
-0.57389235496521,
-0.5520031452178955,
0.01506456732749939,
0.3450263440608978,
0.24612581729888916,
-0.19963467121124268,
0.7271373271942139,
0.15941080451011658,
-0.8773097991943359,
0.7394134998321533,
0.19881273806095123,
0.6144124269485474,
-0.4953410029411316,
-0.1015106663107872,
-0.4531192481517792,
0.27497681975364685,
-0.03958699852228165,
-0.4878063499927521,
0.3774464428424835,
0.28496241569519043,
-0.27449336647987366,
-0.46336156129837036,
0.4143121838569641,
-0.44393256306648254,
-0.50602126121521,
0.4313129782676697,
0.39262568950653076,
0.17813552916049957,
-0.38379546999931335,
-0.4198035001754761,
0.11102253198623657,
0.2591889500617981,
-0.37434840202331543,
0.6043052673339844,
0.5122600197792053,
-0.28302115201950073,
0.3499458134174347,
0.8170359134674072,
0.13676020503044128,
-0.0416543073952198,
0.0874200165271759,
0.7204296588897705,
-0.5877068638801575,
-0.29306674003601074,
-1.0881571769714355,
0.3379238247871399,
-0.021021073684096336,
-0.35162976384162903,
1.0635393857955933,
0.26695072650909424,
1.0655038356781006,
-0.016098514199256897,
0.4547683596611023,
0.28657224774360657,
0.04847013205289841,
-0.33974432945251465,
0.691278338432312,
-0.5023982524871826,
0.1646522730588913,
-0.3160300850868225,
-1.0756174325942993,
-0.4663707911968231,
0.391835480928421,
-0.025640005245804787,
-0.14044754207134247,
0.6022323369979858,
0.766639769077301,
-0.029010217636823654,
-0.38491836190223694,
0.6433029770851135,
0.12431176006793976,
0.2762660086154938,
0.8044254183769226,
0.6395902633666992,
-0.36352044343948364,
0.5802590847015381,
-0.05279577895998955,
-0.1123628243803978,
-0.38290297985076904,
-1.0650594234466553,
-0.8505990505218506,
-0.19639800488948822,
-0.17545025050640106,
-0.13725346326828003,
0.005955880042165518,
0.7257721424102783,
0.6734873652458191,
-0.9140611886978149,
-0.01187023427337408,
-0.2728840112686157,
0.04343293234705925,
-0.18928168714046478,
-0.1640283763408661,
0.12430813908576965,
-0.6033316850662231,
-0.7301121950149536,
0.5690352320671082,
0.4804306924343109,
-0.04313026741147041,
-0.6060571074485779,
-0.14485587179660797,
-0.10075794905424118,
0.1907283216714859,
0.6566569209098816,
-0.07408078759908676,
-1.0223580598831177,
-0.4663412570953369,
0.17308728396892548,
-0.3568858206272125,
-0.01859348453581333,
0.8814165592193604,
-0.4108181297779083,
0.3195013403892517,
0.28399431705474854,
0.5968735814094543,
0.19809499382972717,
-0.01881534978747368,
0.7877777218818665,
-1.0274714231491089,
0.30947890877723694,
0.1816227287054062,
0.18264710903167725,
0.3828407824039459,
-0.845329225063324,
0.42254284024238586,
-0.004626932553946972,
-0.37584853172302246,
-1.050425410270691,
0.3109775483608246,
-0.6034970283508301,
-0.5058243274688721,
1.2054330110549927,
-0.2166237086057663,
-0.42601776123046875,
-0.1006900891661644,
-0.1925036907196045,
0.4934301972389221,
-0.4491919279098511,
0.7523452043533325,
0.7780939340591431,
0.09274514019489288,
-0.17665861546993256,
-0.7028208374977112,
0.3836950361728668,
0.8565567135810852,
-0.5487346053123474,
0.4100748896598816,
0.5502907037734985,
0.09860680997371674,
0.2592819333076477,
0.26675379276275635,
-0.23795664310455322,
0.3437904715538025,
-0.17281118035316467,
0.2045198678970337,
-0.11836683750152588,
-0.3407779633998871,
-0.6957162022590637,
-0.0783797949552536,
0.035539768636226654,
-0.017912937328219414
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07034v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07034v1
|
Improving Multi-hop Logical Reasoning in Knowledge Graphs with Context-Aware Query Representation Learning
| 2024-06-11T07:48:20 | 2024-06-11T07:48:20 |
Jeonghoon Kim, Heesoo Jung, Hyeju Jang, Hogun Park
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Multi-hop logical reasoning on knowledge graphs is a pivotal task in natural
language processing, with numerous approaches aiming to answer First-Order
Logic (FOL) queries. Recent geometry (e.g., box, cone) and probability (e.g.,
beta distribution)-based methodologies have effectively addressed complex FOL
queries. However, a common challenge across these methods lies in determining
accurate geometric bounds or probability parameters for these queries. The
challenge arises because existing methods rely on linear sequential operations
within their computation graphs, overlooking the logical structure of the query
and the relation-induced information that can be gleaned from the relations of
the query, which we call the context of the query. To address the problem, we
propose a model-agnostic methodology that enhances the effectiveness of
existing multi-hop logical reasoning approaches by fully integrating the
context of the FOL query graph. Our approach distinctively discerns (1) the
structural context inherent to the query structure and (2) the relation-induced
context unique to each node in the query graph as delineated in the
corresponding knowledge graph. This dual-context paradigm helps nodes within a
query graph attain refined internal representations throughout the multi-hop
reasoning steps. Through experiments on two datasets, our method consistently
enhances the three multi-hop reasoning foundation models, achieving performance
improvements of up to 19.5%. Our code is available at
https://github.com/kjh9503/caqr.
|
[
-0.27521103620529175,
-0.9937803745269775,
0.7441868782043457,
-0.03301719203591347,
-0.11995109170675278,
-0.008256649598479271,
-0.05222482606768608,
-0.4129212200641632,
0.03872479498386383,
0.5492812395095825,
-0.6068337559700012,
-0.5597450137138367,
-0.45524513721466064,
-0.08042474091053009,
0.04203639179468155,
0.471455842256546,
0.12360168248414993,
-0.06878234446048737,
-0.4406774640083313,
-0.4797864854335785,
-0.5406704545021057,
-0.5699276924133301,
-0.5896793007850647,
-0.07205399870872498,
0.4114786684513092,
0.0650317370891571,
0.6153632402420044,
0.40107646584510803,
0.27679887413978577,
0.19917267560958862,
-0.1386939287185669,
0.538776695728302,
-0.33613622188568115,
0.4049043357372284,
-0.22800874710083008,
-0.3534468412399292,
-0.31107622385025024,
-0.14578433334827423,
0.672743022441864,
0.9243285655975342,
0.006560881156474352,
-0.07148427516222,
-0.07595576345920563,
0.7637448310852051,
-0.8345192074775696,
0.6721025705337524,
-0.7270380258560181,
0.009495485574007034,
-0.07028073072433472,
-0.33014243841171265,
-0.7156988978385925,
-0.4109525978565216,
0.14161767065525055,
-0.8899846076965332,
-0.07414991408586502,
0.09150779992341995,
0.4428173899650574,
0.336305171251297,
-0.9157233238220215,
-0.22358238697052002,
-0.4940667152404785,
0.4728669822216034,
-0.42262616753578186,
0.9011227488517761,
0.20218203961849213,
0.6472962498664856,
-0.5030514597892761,
-0.7647951245307922,
-0.4438202679157257,
-0.11030205339193344,
-0.2297312468290329,
-0.0666004866361618,
-0.1258600801229477,
0.10598618537187576,
0.4376883804798126,
0.09120377153158188,
-0.38662683963775635,
-0.45396676659584045,
-0.07316519320011139,
-0.42628538608551025,
0.5481646656990051,
0.049364350736141205,
-0.013212000019848347,
-0.05547412857413292,
-0.32955023646354675,
-0.14582321047782898,
-0.5614057779312134,
0.3860132098197937,
0.15488219261169434,
0.5748580694198608,
0.4030418395996094,
0.4611639976501465,
-0.5856995582580566,
1.2069975137710571,
-0.1504785567522049,
-0.16496127843856812,
0.26709774136543274,
-0.5275253057479858,
-0.10346801578998566,
-0.10547679662704468,
0.6467265486717224,
0.14940890669822693,
0.27751368284225464,
-0.19110427796840668,
0.056185171008110046,
0.0665009468793869,
0.09080509841442108,
-0.7186484336853027,
-0.12626001238822937,
0.1474592685699463,
-0.12967608869075775,
-0.008511161431670189,
0.10238661617040634,
-0.42275339365005493,
-0.4188133478164673,
-0.28018447756767273,
0.3170224726200104,
-0.7391977310180664,
-0.19788719713687897,
0.23424194753170013,
-0.15059837698936462,
0.19787825644016266,
0.4694196283817291,
-0.4211593270301819,
0.31360769271850586,
0.480158269405365,
0.5624444484710693,
0.4717373549938202,
-0.13378866016864777,
-0.9150019884109497,
0.4934001863002777,
-0.27816298604011536,
0.7071319222450256,
-0.6552324891090393,
-0.17561697959899902,
-0.2648523449897766,
-0.20086830854415894,
-0.3228248953819275,
-0.2549471855163574,
0.6511974930763245,
-0.9246537089347839,
0.0429857037961483,
-0.5454199910163879,
-0.8183725476264954,
-0.29804134368896484,
0.4168051481246948,
-0.5504111647605896,
0.9637888073921204,
0.022278403863310814,
-0.9597052335739136,
0.3724053204059601,
-0.7370580434799194,
-0.5866299867630005,
-0.1342604011297226,
-0.37130993604660034,
-0.01724204421043396,
-0.08158589899539948,
0.4755116403102875,
0.16622194647789001,
-0.1548718512058258,
0.14330966770648956,
-0.5439416766166687,
-0.06918364018201828,
0.0021416929084807634,
-0.07544239610433578,
0.954755425453186,
0.0534910149872303,
-0.11189930140972137,
0.14967790246009827,
-0.6366018652915955,
0.3168235719203949,
0.2205510288476944,
-0.14158464968204498,
-0.6114411354064941,
0.21188263595104218,
-0.5836746692657471,
0.4089089632034302,
-0.13126380741596222,
-0.3994572162628174,
0.35428717732429504,
-0.5126419067382812,
0.3422098457813263,
0.5031523704528809,
0.09942198544740677,
0.46029728651046753,
-0.009754749946296215,
0.2801515460014343,
0.2315891683101654,
0.267280638217926,
-0.18003812432289124,
-0.7802248001098633,
-0.2464289367198944,
-0.11768792569637299,
0.04423414543271065,
0.49842560291290283,
-0.776732861995697,
0.324762761592865,
-0.20551523566246033,
-0.272494912147522,
-0.08684813976287842,
-0.11915584653615952,
0.14215342700481415,
1.1794542074203491,
0.5444263815879822,
0.073398657143116,
-0.20140327513217926,
-0.6378302574157715,
-0.575162947177887,
-0.32422903180122375,
0.16551457345485687,
0.4039370119571686,
0.3699275553226471,
-0.28307586908340454,
1.2811788320541382,
-0.7711570858955383,
-0.3212859332561493,
-0.009634144604206085,
-0.03738643229007721,
0.2193857878446579,
0.28545036911964417,
0.6280032992362976,
-0.9091657996177673,
-0.2570946514606476,
-0.1501731276512146,
-0.7688508629798889,
0.10745278745889664,
0.14561378955841064,
-0.5407062768936157,
-0.024307791143655777,
0.35597267746925354,
-0.6667677760124207,
0.7347888350486755,
0.06602171808481216,
-0.6946000456809998,
0.6576301455497742,
-0.0700567439198494,
0.15228721499443054,
-0.8391245603561401,
-0.12534889578819275,
-0.05992230772972107,
-0.2224724441766739,
-0.6161351799964905,
0.1549089252948761,
0.22406314313411713,
0.09693584591150284,
-0.18811091780662537,
0.6554296016693115,
-0.3714819848537445,
-0.03374418243765831,
0.12462791800498962,
0.21254324913024902,
0.36335238814353943,
0.3259965479373932,
0.10669070482254028,
0.5181861519813538,
0.5964943170547485,
-0.6953020095825195,
0.15631809830665588,
0.36711904406547546,
-0.07731188088655472,
0.4342469274997711,
-0.4929610788822174,
0.06614517420530319,
-0.18133461475372314,
0.6707659363746643,
-0.9944649338722229,
-0.12242976576089859,
0.44519051909446716,
-0.5784972906112671,
0.04327848553657532,
-0.43464794754981995,
-0.6242037415504456,
-0.33230894804000854,
-0.08421765267848969,
0.6482384204864502,
-0.021337086334824562,
-0.5114828944206238,
0.7326230406761169,
0.21622240543365479,
0.37586867809295654,
-0.7583085894584656,
-0.5046129822731018,
-0.32746097445487976,
0.06546592712402344,
-1.043972373008728,
0.3660076856613159,
0.04297501593828201,
-0.18546722829341888,
0.12690523266792297,
-0.4190780222415924,
-0.14970886707305908,
-0.03627312183380127,
-0.16001491248607635,
-0.033779844641685486,
-0.1797431856393814,
0.30703386664390564,
0.3240886628627777,
-0.06617993861436844,
0.2185104489326477,
-0.9016868472099304,
0.4105985760688782,
-0.2676698863506317,
-0.7137410044670105,
-0.31282249093055725,
0.1389748752117157,
0.5875917077064514,
-0.5664740204811096,
0.8752388954162598,
0.4612535834312439,
-0.5921817421913147,
-0.22506490349769592,
-0.3897932469844818,
-0.34941837191581726,
-0.37501534819602966,
0.03462444245815277,
-0.6323956847190857,
-0.8043550848960876,
0.5948805809020996,
-0.12113097310066223,
-0.23122525215148926,
0.36360830068588257,
0.08558419346809387,
0.14297015964984894,
1.0082792043685913,
0.3484293520450592,
0.19717109203338623,
0.2569402754306793,
-0.40921005606651306,
0.42328229546546936,
-0.7503674030303955,
-0.43159574270248413,
-0.3535816967487335,
0.0754917711019516,
-0.31369298696517944,
-0.6019728779792786,
0.6780664920806885,
0.4092298150062561,
-0.268455445766449,
-0.02754382975399494,
-0.2568390965461731,
0.3081783056259155,
0.6280314326286316,
0.19730670750141144,
0.5589185357093811,
0.06079362705349922,
-0.6490857601165771,
0.10059266537427902,
-0.820292592048645,
-0.1345771700143814,
0.9680709838867188,
0.0060994792729616165,
0.45217689871788025,
0.31291571259498596,
0.611300528049469,
0.06682312488555908,
-0.016029376536607742,
-0.8820440769195557,
0.4103953540325165,
0.2744532525539398,
-0.5969381332397461,
-0.3063536584377289,
-0.8699384927749634,
-0.7458582520484924,
0.6350089907646179,
-0.13689710199832916,
-0.9964650273323059,
0.14958351850509644,
0.28884464502334595,
-0.2676485776901245,
0.3718129098415375,
-0.5980340838432312,
1.104608416557312,
-0.2899220883846283,
-0.5194863677024841,
0.000036762394302058965,
-0.8022493720054626,
0.49040767550468445,
0.3130877614021301,
0.4682355523109436,
-0.08829136937856674,
0.2952471971511841,
0.3425563871860504,
-0.7301133871078491,
0.35506847500801086,
-0.6019790768623352,
0.1176612451672554,
0.5213500261306763,
0.17144589126110077,
0.6283966302871704,
0.3457503616809845,
-0.1325419545173645,
-0.11123771220445633,
0.12619373202323914,
-0.3944942057132721,
-0.9380314946174622,
0.28153884410858154,
-0.41217508912086487,
-0.48947545886039734,
-0.3739790618419647,
-0.701485812664032,
-0.5795840620994568,
0.45565521717071533,
-0.015463713556528091,
0.8223515748977661,
0.10863315314054489,
0.11700855940580368,
0.6392412781715393,
-0.11103526502847672,
-0.06747659295797348,
0.05477501079440117,
-0.4419265389442444,
-0.3252832591533661,
0.3949126601219177,
0.11202132701873779,
0.22743067145347595,
0.5842060446739197,
0.3528120517730713,
-0.8487808108329773,
-0.37946680188179016,
-0.3893226981163025,
0.13386881351470947,
-0.9149519205093384,
-0.26732802391052246,
-0.80279940366745,
-0.03185252472758293,
-0.7612578272819519,
0.11792442202568054,
-0.24065881967544556,
-0.559639036655426,
0.20148798823356628,
-0.0026053371839225292,
0.4254670739173889,
0.2925025522708893,
0.15255281329154968,
0.21849094331264496,
-0.6731235384941101,
0.3597831130027771,
0.3138889968395233,
0.4118114411830902,
0.06716154515743256,
-0.20579558610916138,
0.05608432739973068,
0.18896034359931946,
-0.17330874502658844,
-1.13771390914917,
0.04977064207196236,
0.1585640162229538,
0.7298427224159241,
0.43877431750297546,
0.3188709020614624,
0.7052136063575745,
-0.40086209774017334,
0.3247171640396118,
0.0244448259472847,
-0.7351257801055908,
0.9920399785041809,
-0.45767921209335327,
0.1699644923210144,
0.6650347709655762,
0.20642299950122833,
-0.3240548372268677,
-0.1601574569940567,
-0.4425487518310547,
-0.8867796659469604,
0.6663909554481506,
0.32655107975006104,
-0.30677351355552673,
-0.039830178022384644,
0.5066737532615662,
-0.21547281742095947,
0.18449178338050842,
-0.5818403363227844,
-0.3781331777572632,
-0.3450794219970703,
-0.09322398155927658,
0.34867581725120544,
0.11239634454250336,
-0.10971324890851974,
-0.597957193851471,
0.4566424489021301,
-0.5495961904525757,
0.187404066324234,
0.2415362298488617,
-0.31469252705574036,
0.2999251186847687,
0.19855552911758423,
0.12592990696430206,
0.9778537750244141,
-0.32300251722335815,
0.1560058742761612,
-0.09450390189886093,
-0.24858546257019043,
-0.012304186820983887,
0.5554720759391785,
-0.2370263636112213,
-0.16806215047836304,
0.3983629643917084,
0.5367565155029297,
0.12914472818374634,
-0.5170681476593018,
0.6542261838912964,
-0.33634328842163086,
0.03431341052055359,
-0.07927067577838898,
0.13423460721969604,
0.12025311589241028,
0.3598003685474396,
0.5477966666221619,
0.16752220690250397,
0.37246841192245483,
-0.4137353003025055,
0.4110057055950165,
0.5874490141868591,
-0.24577175080776215,
0.010517071932554245,
0.919314444065094,
-0.10715930163860321,
0.08721423149108887,
0.8093821406364441,
-0.5594437122344971,
-0.58921217918396,
0.4928099811077118,
0.5107353925704956,
0.43105000257492065,
0.02037382312119007,
0.2150818258523941,
0.6414899230003357,
0.2638888657093048,
0.1838570386171341,
0.3287695646286011,
-0.3703342080116272,
-1.0114271640777588,
-0.4140407145023346,
-0.6230407357215881,
-0.2557702958583832,
-0.36473506689071655,
-0.6490894556045532,
0.16605234146118164,
-0.31208109855651855,
-0.20117254555225372,
-0.13360558450222015,
0.033825796097517014,
-0.6454704999923706,
0.09792762994766235,
-0.13378064334392548,
1.2042295932769775,
-0.5557870268821716,
0.932482123374939,
0.8797221183776855,
-0.5022999048233032,
-0.8557127118110657,
0.02626645937561989,
0.16843487322330475,
-0.34670138359069824,
0.46934378147125244,
0.27260565757751465,
-0.37339478731155396,
-0.025462670251727104,
-0.13338817656040192,
-0.8781769275665283,
1.2469983100891113,
0.48141908645629883,
-0.3021447956562042,
0.07616512477397919,
0.12765425443649292,
0.31239330768585205,
-0.44046318531036377,
0.31977224349975586,
0.4739595055580139,
0.45334726572036743,
0.38499531149864197,
-0.4627455174922943,
0.14442424476146698,
-0.15113948285579681,
-0.04468657448887825,
0.1851198673248291,
-0.45912840962409973,
0.567670464515686,
-0.33510249853134155,
-0.06874494254589081,
-0.42163506150245667,
0.7756443619728088,
0.9335863590240479,
0.5023426413536072,
0.7657114863395691,
0.6492772698402405,
1.2249274253845215,
-0.16736508905887604,
1.1512465476989746,
-0.4245149493217468,
0.3667612671852112,
1.225882649421692,
-0.23250670731067657,
0.5763040781021118,
0.39768001437187195,
-0.10831789672374725,
0.6117427349090576,
0.56749427318573,
0.7099636197090149,
0.4892306923866272,
0.08236896246671677,
-0.12568411231040955,
-0.35197192430496216,
-0.029426872730255127,
-0.5241861343383789,
0.3892624080181122,
0.5229275822639465,
-0.03480564057826996,
-0.33770957589149475,
-0.36783573031425476,
0.023845843970775604,
0.06907124072313309,
-0.13013969361782074,
0.4318108856678009,
-0.1255687028169632,
-0.5200124979019165,
0.34024715423583984,
-0.1349707841873169,
0.15571971237659454,
-0.6261172294616699,
-0.10341326892375946,
-0.20718297362327576,
0.15265345573425293,
-0.0870153158903122,
-0.5547738075256348,
0.3837750554084778,
-0.3930644392967224,
-0.24635934829711914,
0.006022230722010136,
0.86540687084198,
-0.19836896657943726,
-0.5328269004821777,
0.7379149794578552,
0.7761057615280151,
-0.32747018337249756,
-0.34841129183769226,
-0.6803862452507019,
-0.12219322472810745,
-0.2470625936985016,
-0.29411524534225464,
0.006496767047792673,
0.7094325423240662,
-0.23834219574928284,
0.6625714898109436,
0.6285763382911682,
-0.08031532168388367,
0.32428693771362305,
0.3361356258392334,
0.9564302563667297,
-0.4968580901622772,
-0.6975934505462646,
-0.6691470146179199,
0.5076083540916443,
-0.19084706902503967,
-0.0681929662823677,
0.592648446559906,
0.5050848722457886,
0.8541696667671204,
0.18355457484722137,
0.6885049343109131,
-0.31712719798088074,
0.1474114954471588,
-0.5291937589645386,
0.4209674000740051,
-0.5301536321640015,
0.3206596374511719,
-0.35726746916770935,
-0.9070731997489929,
-0.5704684853553772,
0.634951651096344,
-0.4523445665836334,
0.15182755887508392,
0.6523703336715698,
0.6938166618347168,
-0.32348722219467163,
0.15060891211032867,
-0.018357282504439354,
0.15690980851650238,
0.46094831824302673,
0.4827384948730469,
0.9361029267311096,
-0.4059273600578308,
0.5829377770423889,
-0.49011191725730896,
-0.3432765305042267,
-0.01022128015756607,
-0.9324137568473816,
-0.5835899114608765,
-0.43717220425605774,
-0.21555200219154358,
-0.3392266631126404,
0.026664651930332184,
0.758476734161377,
0.8478890061378479,
-0.7130110263824463,
-0.005567139480262995,
-0.23418451845645905,
0.514997661113739,
-0.44894295930862427,
-0.29372718930244446,
0.4877294600009918,
-0.5744736194610596,
-0.21707065403461456,
0.5405355095863342,
0.3333987891674042,
-0.4526563286781311,
0.12260329723358154,
-0.16571930050849915,
-0.6146067976951599,
-0.13196663558483124,
0.9719947576522827,
0.08656562864780426,
-0.6907703280448914,
-0.5414425134658813,
0.04880818724632263,
0.2975209355354309,
0.12851926684379578,
0.7197131514549255,
-0.9162343144416809,
0.6758980751037598,
0.5936351418495178,
0.776646614074707,
0.5300634503364563,
0.21513217687606812,
0.37722909450531006,
-1.002711534500122,
0.10141059756278992,
0.19259919226169586,
0.4769301116466522,
0.14103011786937714,
-0.4030963182449341,
0.751842737197876,
0.6324803233146667,
-0.2499886155128479,
-0.6252654790878296,
0.4889579117298126,
-0.8703117966651917,
-0.3549761474132538,
0.8717867732048035,
-0.057968150824308395,
-0.15994474291801453,
-0.031883444637060165,
0.04137231037020683,
0.3057461082935333,
-0.3770004212856293,
0.24863755702972412,
0.44351112842559814,
-0.7181745171546936,
0.020419910550117493,
-0.607223629951477,
0.2845042645931244,
0.0612044595181942,
-0.7219660878181458,
-0.08468125015497208,
0.8664405345916748,
0.21580496430397034,
0.05237679183483124,
0.8371539115905762,
-0.13412640988826752,
0.08623056858778,
-0.12025831639766693,
-0.3491729497909546,
-0.1667899489402771,
-0.5907443165779114,
0.06581937521696091,
0.37531790137290955,
-0.05341045558452606,
-0.06274548172950745
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10266v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10266v1
|
COVID-19 Twitter Sentiment Classification Using Hybrid Deep Learning Model Based on Grid Search Methodology
| 2024-06-11T07:48:06 | 2024-06-11T07:48:06 |
Jitendra Tembhurne, Anant Agrawal, Kirtan Lakhotia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SI
|
In the contemporary era, social media platforms amass an extensive volume of
social data contributed by their users. In order to promptly grasp the opinions
and emotional inclinations of individuals regarding a product or event, it
becomes imperative to perform sentiment analysis on the user-generated content.
Microblog comments often encompass both lengthy and concise text entries,
presenting a complex scenario. This complexity is particularly pronounced in
extensive textual content due to its rich content and intricate word
interrelations compared to shorter text entries. Sentiment analysis of public
opinion shared on social networking websites such as Facebook or Twitter has
evolved and found diverse applications. However, several challenges remain to
be tackled in this field. The hybrid methodologies have emerged as promising
models for mitigating sentiment analysis errors, particularly when dealing with
progressively intricate training data. In this article, to investigate the
hesitancy of COVID-19 vaccination, we propose eight different hybrid deep
learning models for sentiment classification with an aim of improving overall
accuracy of the model. The sentiment prediction is achieved using embedding,
deep learning model and grid search algorithm on Twitter COVID-19 dataset.
According to the study, public sentiment towards COVID-19 immunization appears
to be improving with time, as evidenced by the gradual decline in vaccine
reluctance. Through extensive evaluation, proposed model reported an increased
accuracy of 98.86%, outperforming other models. Specifically, the combination
of BERT, CNN and GS yield the highest accuracy, while the combination of GloVe,
BiLSTM, CNN and GS follows closely behind with an accuracy of 98.17%. In
addition, increase in accuracy in the range of 2.11% to 14.46% is reported by
the proposed model in comparisons with existing works.
|
[
-0.31424736976623535,
-0.6387750506401062,
-0.019307127222418785,
0.18938329815864563,
-0.3993404805660248,
0.8580721616744995,
-0.3167116940021515,
-0.39149945974349976,
0.170499786734581,
-0.3146662414073944,
-0.38773736357688904,
-0.7403479218482971,
-0.6381914019584656,
-0.09992586821317673,
-0.28016117215156555,
1.1201554536819458,
0.057595498859882355,
0.2251996248960495,
-0.3060592710971832,
0.037850961089134216,
0.0917215421795845,
-0.5455613732337952,
-0.5948389768600464,
-0.5082236528396606,
0.436542809009552,
0.23381468653678894,
0.44477155804634094,
-0.3968368470668793,
0.4396257996559143,
0.2281423658132553,
-0.2865537106990814,
0.41378623247146606,
-0.43500858545303345,
-0.2006974220275879,
-0.06943491101264954,
-0.1370115429162979,
-0.30321842432022095,
0.08883503079414368,
0.18763841688632965,
0.13453106582164764,
-0.16319973766803741,
0.14604704082012177,
0.11240697652101517,
0.16819189488887787,
-0.5467952489852905,
-0.17456510663032532,
-0.6266089677810669,
0.19249327480793,
-0.013057724572718143,
-0.11142322421073914,
-0.24636627733707428,
-0.1475335657596588,
0.2904044985771179,
-0.2906395196914673,
0.3940066397190094,
-0.23263926804065704,
0.7190969586372375,
-0.14755235612392426,
-0.3378657400608063,
0.09540800750255585,
-0.7291705012321472,
0.9075804948806763,
-0.8737567663192749,
0.02548714354634285,
0.15476852655410767,
0.3957795202732086,
0.10841235518455505,
-0.4827364981174469,
-0.6619808077812195,
-0.09314006567001343,
0.34215477108955383,
0.3976280391216278,
-0.12638716399669647,
0.076407290995121,
-0.20345869660377502,
0.5041130781173706,
-0.6840461492538452,
0.2646321952342987,
-0.3297458291053772,
-0.26107242703437805,
0.9389992952346802,
0.2529773414134979,
0.35808005928993225,
-0.4406687319278717,
-0.46979936957359314,
-0.07704975455999374,
-0.09959910064935684,
0.4219604730606079,
0.06958349794149399,
0.2938021123409271,
-0.5251646637916565,
0.15118207037448883,
-0.3246491551399231,
0.3566403090953827,
0.1699914038181305,
-0.08628716319799423,
0.4416166841983795,
-0.3396179974079132,
-0.4516780376434326,
-0.10461321473121643,
1.088366150856018,
0.3977099061012268,
0.00485905772075057,
0.1284036934375763,
-0.11129139363765717,
0.3405981957912445,
0.3198307454586029,
-0.5855575203895569,
-0.14293837547302246,
0.2831157147884369,
-0.5833341479301453,
-0.5319141745567322,
0.178060844540596,
-0.938317596912384,
-0.8603249788284302,
-0.18198296427726746,
0.09480565786361694,
-0.4086945354938507,
-0.32760751247406006,
0.18775583803653717,
-0.14510583877563477,
0.15839162468910217,
0.8607111573219299,
-0.342049241065979,
0.17253510653972626,
0.8419826030731201,
0.9776327610015869,
-0.15376578271389008,
0.12078358978033066,
-0.31628236174583435,
-0.33478641510009766,
-0.1640198975801468,
0.597651481628418,
-0.6810906529426575,
-0.2908894419670105,
-0.06094042584300041,
-0.45912376046180725,
-0.24748846888542175,
-0.24194346368312836,
0.4646264314651489,
-0.5210005044937134,
0.22543063759803772,
-0.05354594811797142,
-0.6402717232704163,
-0.3807503581047058,
0.5472880005836487,
-0.28389522433280945,
0.7697853446006775,
-0.16168829798698425,
-0.9986647963523865,
0.27137476205825806,
-0.34836363792419434,
-0.34766432642936707,
0.2815401256084442,
-0.34103211760520935,
-0.8984253406524658,
0.22075292468070984,
0.4166560471057892,
0.8421279788017273,
-0.37799760699272156,
0.40909987688064575,
-0.9502411484718323,
-0.15031681954860687,
0.09074024856090546,
-0.08397959917783737,
0.9057663083076477,
0.11026638001203537,
-0.44508397579193115,
0.12688171863555908,
-0.5277981758117676,
-0.23398509621620178,
0.01595930941402912,
-0.0573803074657917,
-0.3493543267250061,
-0.09679189324378967,
0.19345524907112122,
0.46378031373023987,
0.07368310540914536,
-0.8223280310630798,
0.01099971029907465,
-0.40641263127326965,
0.3748321533203125,
0.6285039186477661,
0.1803276538848877,
0.43975043296813965,
-0.03548836708068848,
0.7103955745697021,
0.43650105595588684,
0.5019249320030212,
0.4981924891471863,
-0.7327730059623718,
-0.4725709855556488,
-0.1991482824087143,
0.07051055878400803,
0.651340126991272,
-0.7666860818862915,
0.5204492807388306,
-0.25635451078414917,
-0.8902392387390137,
-0.5439468026161194,
0.10591751337051392,
0.07907631248235703,
0.44198521971702576,
0.22514905035495758,
-0.034330084919929504,
-0.7459869384765625,
-0.63843834400177,
-0.27878284454345703,
0.04168994352221489,
0.592290997505188,
0.11453854292631149,
0.5214187502861023,
-0.5135145783424377,
0.4529326260089874,
-0.25004079937934875,
-0.06907720118761063,
-0.3382851779460907,
0.44801440834999084,
0.13721317052841187,
0.18973508477210999,
0.4158877432346344,
-0.9559974074363708,
-0.6750805974006653,
0.5246357917785645,
-0.6630488038063049,
0.4408971667289734,
-0.011111687868833542,
0.38670796155929565,
0.009573154151439667,
0.28484395146369934,
-0.4257577955722809,
0.7526151537895203,
0.4009830951690674,
-0.04373132064938545,
0.23894254863262177,
0.2121644765138626,
-0.09145906567573547,
-1.4461640119552612,
0.04600061476230621,
0.4936586320400238,
-0.22639961540699005,
-0.6131250262260437,
-0.0009839509148150682,
-0.09273304790258408,
-0.11228016018867493,
-0.37899816036224365,
0.29606881737709045,
0.08145932108163834,
0.4522341191768646,
-0.24564911425113678,
-0.47912290692329407,
0.06752311438322067,
-0.0167978648096323,
-0.15557725727558136,
0.56520676612854,
0.47455063462257385,
-0.27928170561790466,
0.7228489518165588,
0.07254242151975632,
-0.2771068811416626,
0.07186086475849152,
-0.37573620676994324,
0.09263744950294495,
-0.18549983203411102,
0.595591127872467,
-1.0564613342285156,
-0.07666227966547012,
0.3069921135902405,
-0.7353144288063049,
0.20123618841171265,
0.4061439633369446,
-0.37606966495513916,
-0.7415938973426819,
-0.6903778314590454,
0.25000253319740295,
0.41285866498947144,
-0.3578602075576782,
0.5066202878952026,
0.319911926984787,
0.05246391519904137,
-0.653924822807312,
-0.5535769462585449,
0.13154156506061554,
-0.13705383241176605,
-0.5311915278434753,
0.25276991724967957,
0.06294175982475281,
-0.16705675423145294,
-0.048796772956848145,
0.08460121601819992,
0.02923772856593132,
0.06552789360284805,
0.2676493227481842,
0.1080840528011322,
-0.020850803703069687,
0.2551444172859192,
0.1583932489156723,
0.08674857765436172,
-0.17546355724334717,
0.0312016811221838,
0.6449952721595764,
-0.42303332686424255,
-0.0427221804857254,
-0.8025742173194885,
0.40615519881248474,
0.6373082399368286,
-0.15648794174194336,
0.7417617440223694,
1.2259941101074219,
-0.6861401796340942,
-0.31957268714904785,
-0.6124679446220398,
-0.051189735531806946,
-0.39547199010849,
0.35681894421577454,
-0.0676419734954834,
-0.8757309317588806,
0.48142001032829285,
-0.04139265790581703,
-0.507623553276062,
0.6565706133842468,
0.7500516176223755,
-0.2731359601020813,
0.9646769165992737,
0.4741937816143036,
-0.5192355513572693,
0.391598105430603,
-0.4570934772491455,
0.46511685848236084,
-0.5248394012451172,
-0.5650104284286499,
-0.279723584651947,
-0.3835746943950653,
-0.5921367406845093,
-0.3619174659252167,
0.4290025234222412,
-0.3363491892814636,
-0.08499796688556671,
0.04866132512688637,
-0.49531328678131104,
-0.07946252077817917,
0.615269660949707,
0.6487711071968079,
-0.19538699090480804,
0.35983625054359436,
-0.1849391758441925,
0.008401287719607353,
-0.9072753190994263,
-0.08427519351243973,
0.8614438772201538,
0.4666716754436493,
0.7944878339767456,
-0.2469431310892105,
0.9365179538726807,
0.5344892144203186,
0.07081951200962067,
-0.625119149684906,
0.42337334156036377,
-0.5672585368156433,
-0.36121150851249695,
-0.0351608507335186,
-0.30134573578834534,
-0.6449434161186218,
-0.19331979751586914,
-0.474989116191864,
-0.6423524022102356,
0.5217823386192322,
-0.06279495358467102,
-0.8217338919639587,
0.44104939699172974,
-0.5980728268623352,
0.6159352660179138,
-0.10197551548480988,
-0.3611353039741516,
-0.6406087875366211,
-0.6527378559112549,
0.2858178913593292,
0.1064138188958168,
-0.03218792751431465,
-0.06195759400725365,
0.06620819121599197,
0.6085171699523926,
-0.5289708375930786,
1.195475459098816,
-0.0705849826335907,
0.2305831015110016,
0.3223015069961548,
-0.3558667004108429,
0.36223718523979187,
0.26619961857795715,
-0.20548182725906372,
0.1708160787820816,
-0.20987200736999512,
-0.47107893228530884,
-0.23802761733531952,
0.7039333581924438,
-1.1800169944763184,
-0.43035638332366943,
-0.6117316484451294,
-0.32146674394607544,
-0.08902405947446823,
-0.14458957314491272,
0.5650458931922913,
0.30020102858543396,
-0.26996350288391113,
0.3000757098197937,
0.5671389102935791,
-0.4718622863292694,
0.47477927803993225,
-0.2062235176563263,
-0.08737190067768097,
-0.7098137736320496,
0.9927533864974976,
0.25296837091445923,
-0.09819284826517105,
0.5613508224487305,
0.5217283368110657,
-0.15883146226406097,
-0.5921656489372253,
-0.19127844274044037,
0.04481600597500801,
-0.4406884014606476,
-0.5292629599571228,
-0.708216667175293,
-0.4957616627216339,
-0.7189414501190186,
-0.1999332457780838,
-0.08490888774394989,
0.021005520597100258,
-0.6157389283180237,
-0.21539360284805298,
0.5928484797477722,
0.7264445424079895,
0.01803465373814106,
0.2029021829366684,
-0.7043127417564392,
0.2420995533466339,
0.4378165304660797,
0.2110416293144226,
0.26806461811065674,
-0.19616436958312988,
-0.31722089648246765,
0.14184881746768951,
-0.4403437077999115,
-0.6503376960754395,
0.5215880870819092,
0.28900328278541565,
0.21319061517715454,
0.5107659101486206,
0.09979793429374695,
0.6601479053497314,
0.1438506543636322,
0.7835972905158997,
0.5657709836959839,
-0.8728138208389282,
0.46046167612075806,
-0.516773521900177,
0.060748178511857986,
0.4789310097694397,
0.2858489155769348,
-0.3751857578754425,
-0.10812332481145859,
-0.6335890293121338,
-0.5596044659614563,
0.43495774269104004,
-0.15826676785945892,
0.1376977562904358,
0.12475226819515228,
0.22483612596988678,
0.4237496554851532,
0.1779155135154724,
-0.407267689704895,
0.039262451231479645,
-0.24733775854110718,
-0.2762986421585083,
-0.3511284589767456,
-0.3299329876899719,
0.05485210567712784,
-0.8246910572052002,
0.6515480875968933,
0.09391970187425613,
0.2801881730556488,
0.137691929936409,
0.0716664046049118,
-0.3040575385093689,
0.14549873769283295,
0.5846698880195618,
0.45621171593666077,
-0.2783972918987274,
0.03584074601531029,
0.17291641235351562,
-0.36319494247436523,
0.14772607386112213,
0.1924128234386444,
-0.28142789006233215,
0.10198617726564407,
0.2512083947658539,
0.8669297695159912,
-0.24532106518745422,
-0.3099072575569153,
0.8762803673744202,
0.05241679027676582,
-0.1779014766216278,
-0.39677169919013977,
-0.1815589815378189,
0.12926702201366425,
0.2514083683490753,
0.2705301344394684,
0.3575313091278076,
0.4591595530509949,
-0.3841167688369751,
0.061944007873535156,
0.705954909324646,
-0.27299121022224426,
-0.5293331146240234,
0.3206094205379486,
0.35633325576782227,
-0.0631524994969368,
0.40064510703086853,
-0.262417733669281,
-0.7153119444847107,
0.6098425984382629,
0.22479960322380066,
1.181968092918396,
-0.47358834743499756,
0.7205556035041809,
0.2061440646648407,
0.20452852547168732,
0.0922091007232666,
0.5441789031028748,
0.2246890664100647,
-0.6971472501754761,
-0.4388716518878937,
-0.5065429210662842,
-0.31823456287384033,
0.4037465453147888,
-0.6658616662025452,
0.32962989807128906,
-0.7745930552482605,
-0.4039992392063141,
0.14126695692539215,
0.23366084694862366,
-0.9114577770233154,
0.5285793542861938,
0.6878727078437805,
0.9148775935173035,
-1.1901006698608398,
0.628517210483551,
0.993686318397522,
-0.23790979385375977,
-0.43096640706062317,
0.09316176921129227,
-0.04671873524785042,
-0.6904422640800476,
0.3177468776702881,
0.3514929413795471,
0.020817281678318977,
-0.2932897210121155,
-0.6742749810218811,
-0.35274308919906616,
0.9448181390762329,
-0.06243543699383736,
-0.6264381408691406,
0.08194470405578613,
0.20284661650657654,
0.774507999420166,
-0.30480480194091797,
-0.11558620631694794,
0.023540260270237923,
0.11847605556249619,
-0.06833145767450333,
-0.7732443809509277,
-0.07936641573905945,
-0.484880268573761,
0.07209810614585876,
-0.028652865439653397,
-0.8997179269790649,
0.8717085123062134,
0.03462614119052887,
0.0915161594748497,
-0.2232097089290619,
0.6503198146820068,
-0.019229689612984657,
1.1053500175476074,
0.3194607198238373,
0.7288613319396973,
0.6990782022476196,
0.2379712164402008,
1.0074771642684937,
0.1484941691160202,
0.6320285201072693,
0.7658748030662537,
-0.23479875922203064,
0.931268036365509,
0.4146207273006439,
-0.18893297016620636,
0.5620588660240173,
0.905909538269043,
0.05950494110584259,
0.5038143992424011,
0.07680351287126541,
-0.5579494833946228,
-0.5884591937065125,
-0.21641942858695984,
-0.4347192049026489,
0.4301443099975586,
0.6438782215118408,
-0.3717679977416992,
-0.3011242747306824,
0.35187381505966187,
-0.18271522223949432,
0.07151969522237778,
-0.538453996181488,
0.7995359301567078,
0.34515613317489624,
-0.2810610830783844,
0.3823622465133667,
-0.10970430821180344,
0.8935940861701965,
-0.11877814680337906,
0.26578399538993835,
0.1034671813249588,
0.37407851219177246,
-0.4335935711860657,
-0.48207876086235046,
0.16091227531433105,
-0.22951027750968933,
-0.21042490005493164,
0.04497310519218445,
1.131857991218567,
-0.1736910492181778,
-0.9427953958511353,
0.47958308458328247,
0.6074072122573853,
-0.38639676570892334,
-0.21265706419944763,
-1.1997158527374268,
0.03514114022254944,
-0.029473155736923218,
-0.23477347195148468,
0.24258656799793243,
0.16663391888141632,
-0.06375132501125336,
0.45736876130104065,
0.43701761960983276,
0.02950943075120449,
0.21587277948856354,
0.002066916087642312,
0.9481227993965149,
-0.4690183103084564,
-0.6407511234283447,
-1.0705101490020752,
0.36778342723846436,
-0.47763127088546753,
-0.18707433342933655,
0.709649920463562,
0.44087013602256775,
0.6998761892318726,
-0.2745739221572876,
1.2711124420166016,
0.19035327434539795,
0.6022035479545593,
0.008349142037332058,
0.5986990928649902,
-0.5121511816978455,
-0.12920832633972168,
-0.20592138171195984,
-0.3152772784233093,
-0.5678808689117432,
0.36768871545791626,
-0.8318491578102112,
0.0020113466307520866,
0.3655467629432678,
0.6786291599273682,
-0.11662878841161728,
0.08789493143558502,
0.2346082329750061,
0.0863138809800148,
0.15720117092132568,
0.44978824257850647,
0.9292201399803162,
-0.3361362814903259,
0.13977789878845215,
-0.6572965383529663,
-0.17402279376983643,
-0.9213806390762329,
-0.6524091958999634,
-1.0588096380233765,
-0.5341471433639526,
-0.4825611412525177,
-0.7181839346885681,
0.22734877467155457,
1.4424071311950684,
0.7534332275390625,
-1.0832245349884033,
-0.049025967717170715,
-0.29635798931121826,
-0.1059432402253151,
-0.1371157318353653,
-0.24810606241226196,
0.49381136894226074,
-0.17360469698905945,
-0.38089719414711,
0.019562531262636185,
0.32532650232315063,
-0.10987550765275955,
-0.09936115145683289,
-0.006969383917748928,
-0.4266780614852905,
-0.01753813773393631,
0.6429417133331299,
0.20045305788516998,
-0.8550572395324707,
-0.13929808139801025,
0.021241195499897003,
-0.33304083347320557,
0.0014593966770917177,
0.5291250348091125,
-0.6375150084495544,
0.753145694732666,
0.8010491132736206,
0.9189547300338745,
0.4856588840484619,
-0.01974223554134369,
0.43087536096572876,
-0.5350194573402405,
-0.049666907638311386,
0.4223627746105194,
0.28132179379463196,
0.5650137066841125,
-0.49770641326904297,
0.020167706534266472,
0.5665243864059448,
-0.23493127524852753,
-0.5777511596679688,
0.016821525990962982,
-1.2460426092147827,
-0.18937274813652039,
1.300356149673462,
0.08501270413398743,
-0.2719542384147644,
0.01739516109228134,
-0.20647168159484863,
0.5327014327049255,
-0.6462517380714417,
1.0138646364212036,
0.35921400785446167,
0.1115705668926239,
-0.3162170648574829,
-0.0527840219438076,
0.30946385860443115,
0.30496346950531006,
-0.5553635358810425,
-0.6029379963874817,
-0.1760941594839096,
0.029398981481790543,
0.047581661492586136,
0.40192076563835144,
0.30101844668388367,
0.49806296825408936,
-0.1903856098651886,
0.13555890321731567,
-0.0492834746837616,
-0.05498350411653519,
-0.5962747931480408,
0.3188480734825134,
-0.188868448138237,
-0.469371497631073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10265v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10265v1
|
Improving Language Models for Emotion Analysis: Insights from Cognitive Science
| 2024-06-11T07:42:13 | 2024-06-11T07:42:13 |
Constant Bonard, Gustave Cortal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We propose leveraging cognitive science research on emotions and
communication to improve language models for emotion analysis. First, we
present the main emotion theories in psychology and cognitive science. Then, we
introduce the main methods of emotion annotation in natural language processing
and their connections to psychological theories. We also present the two main
types of analyses of emotional communication in cognitive pragmatics. Finally,
based on the cognitive science research presented, we propose directions for
improving language models for emotion analysis. We suggest that these research
efforts pave the way for constructing new annotation schemes and a possible
benchmark for emotional understanding, considering different facets of human
emotion and communication.
|
[
-0.4131917953491211,
-0.8290225267410278,
0.5626832246780396,
0.3003312945365906,
-0.18358652293682098,
0.07288302481174469,
-0.8999188542366028,
-1.0075974464416504,
0.15806500613689423,
0.36489197611808777,
-0.4277452230453491,
-0.2825629413127899,
-0.597571849822998,
0.10197344422340393,
-0.17676305770874023,
0.7135903239250183,
0.009046186693012714,
0.38558319211006165,
-0.2613053619861603,
-0.31395307183265686,
-0.28494617342948914,
-0.8268376588821411,
-1.0527095794677734,
-0.4561893045902252,
0.4863409399986267,
0.35097306966781616,
0.7038159966468811,
0.059740666300058365,
0.8096171021461487,
0.338736355304718,
-0.16161100566387177,
-0.18167562782764435,
-0.2453356236219406,
0.14255815744400024,
0.10523746907711029,
-0.5538375377655029,
-0.5029131174087524,
0.3244752883911133,
0.4242289960384369,
0.7615269422531128,
-0.25994396209716797,
-0.1401815116405487,
-0.23721054196357727,
0.6801263689994812,
-0.6138424277305603,
0.5831229090690613,
-0.16539010405540466,
-0.003214108059182763,
-0.19136475026607513,
-0.14053992927074432,
-0.5805001258850098,
-0.5653105974197388,
0.47986844182014465,
-0.5329997539520264,
0.12395307421684265,
0.08954938501119614,
0.7986087799072266,
-0.022248156368732452,
-0.5583622455596924,
-0.5838937759399414,
-0.7413082122802734,
0.8190858364105225,
-0.7577908039093018,
0.30605512857437134,
0.5899213552474976,
0.22145119309425354,
0.24847529828548431,
-0.448306679725647,
-0.5258824825286865,
-0.696414589881897,
-0.07066679745912552,
0.19874334335327148,
-0.2997327446937561,
0.33737704157829285,
0.07054878771305084,
0.33107343316078186,
-0.3012903034687042,
-0.035080716013908386,
-0.3401128053665161,
-0.19340935349464417,
1.1823067665100098,
0.11161918193101883,
0.45580554008483887,
0.13401848077774048,
0.21342717111110687,
-0.2735961675643921,
-0.2682529091835022,
-0.07235087454319,
0.38883545994758606,
0.04530332237482071,
-0.04340125620365143,
0.3244028091430664,
-0.32036855816841125,
0.564007043838501,
-0.06230081990361214,
0.3377068340778351,
0.24319468438625336,
-0.14655384421348572,
-0.11537647247314453,
0.010906513780355453,
0.6505382657051086,
0.5903201699256897,
0.5629220604896545,
0.02576391212642193,
0.27810361981391907,
0.5479234457015991,
0.3461196720600128,
-0.6137089133262634,
-0.6688083410263062,
0.30056244134902954,
-0.49845415353775024,
-0.29069679975509644,
-0.24513955414295197,
-0.9344981908798218,
-0.6535701155662537,
-0.38900282979011536,
-0.06667149811983109,
-0.7146672010421753,
-0.7863443493843079,
0.1690436601638794,
-0.11252304166555405,
0.034588880836963654,
0.35569238662719727,
-0.957622766494751,
0.4810182750225067,
0.7745141386985779,
0.47500282526016235,
0.19272969663143158,
-0.1311335414648056,
0.23452304303646088,
-0.2519196569919586,
-0.2860482931137085,
0.9611198902130127,
-0.9715242981910706,
-0.2602655589580536,
0.32238927483558655,
-0.24823567271232605,
-0.012043330818414688,
-0.3732949495315552,
0.7434419393539429,
-0.18885521590709686,
0.43662357330322266,
-0.47250229120254517,
-0.675542950630188,
-0.5674644112586975,
0.038416799157857895,
-0.7477794289588928,
1.103344202041626,
-0.05846012383699417,
-0.6212018728256226,
0.0363023467361927,
-1.210744857788086,
-0.4416927099227905,
0.13046735525131226,
0.23548154532909393,
-0.08783958852291107,
0.8371551632881165,
-0.005141995381563902,
0.23302888870239258,
-0.4854520559310913,
0.37637636065483093,
-0.3587277829647064,
0.00771378492936492,
0.5614325404167175,
0.13134127855300903,
0.5461235642433167,
0.3820360004901886,
-0.1518029421567917,
0.13956743478775024,
-0.812183678150177,
0.0624314546585083,
0.10653416812419891,
-0.1875375658273697,
-0.4456278681755066,
0.27882662415504456,
0.10859306156635284,
0.016856223344802856,
0.31001749634742737,
-0.630678653717041,
0.13417492806911469,
-0.3693779408931732,
0.6175124049186707,
0.32273727655410767,
-0.015731623396277428,
0.7260761260986328,
0.19756154716014862,
0.5391939282417297,
-0.1505647897720337,
0.269849568605423,
-0.05356559157371521,
-0.4898209273815155,
-0.8116007447242737,
-0.03822820633649826,
0.05176084488630295,
0.4219318926334381,
-0.3403569161891937,
0.06757859140634537,
0.06071830913424492,
-0.6475796699523926,
-0.90926194190979,
-0.38909417390823364,
0.45140340924263,
0.5361313223838806,
0.4207913279533386,
-0.4896986484527588,
-0.7514938712120056,
-0.7589952945709229,
-0.709190845489502,
-0.5724753141403198,
0.2601112127304077,
0.02139282040297985,
0.1849386990070343,
0.09389056265354156,
0.995742917060852,
-0.5084171295166016,
0.3221294581890106,
-0.14117111265659332,
0.8905640840530396,
-0.40937143564224243,
0.2938205897808075,
0.44963720440864563,
-0.8455844521522522,
-0.3255687355995178,
0.08067330718040466,
-0.7216366529464722,
-0.37355998158454895,
0.17878103256225586,
-0.05085260421037674,
0.25037533044815063,
0.2874131202697754,
-0.43367981910705566,
0.4842528700828552,
0.3492397964000702,
-0.3939788341522217,
0.4359605312347412,
0.03246588259935379,
0.40145495533943176,
-0.4101434350013733,
-0.24583962559700012,
0.34016621112823486,
0.21088135242462158,
-1.1351953744888306,
-0.08810409903526306,
0.1575116068124771,
-0.05554306507110596,
-0.4252840578556061,
0.4482138752937317,
-0.7053998708724976,
0.3442107141017914,
-0.6464557647705078,
0.07983182370662689,
-0.09136050939559937,
0.21165122091770172,
0.4579853415489197,
0.05702139437198639,
0.5900865197181702,
-0.3630124628543854,
0.46661683917045593,
0.05448560789227486,
-0.24336589872837067,
0.7676376700401306,
-0.3316113352775574,
0.14046816527843475,
-0.48005107045173645,
0.25006434321403503,
-0.9568691253662109,
-0.234836608171463,
0.2759469747543335,
-0.6291190385818481,
0.3561191260814667,
0.04723389446735382,
-0.27075091004371643,
-0.40509191155433655,
-0.317066490650177,
0.06382786482572556,
0.5107400417327881,
-0.08067279309034348,
0.6711524724960327,
0.2909308075904846,
-0.33394867181777954,
-0.1882506161928177,
-0.6030495762825012,
0.23914320766925812,
-0.29625043272972107,
-0.8467634916305542,
0.04205196723341942,
-0.21475273370742798,
-0.6890948414802551,
0.040624745190143585,
0.06662566214799881,
-0.47860071063041687,
0.2281849980354309,
0.20427455008029938,
0.19724994897842407,
-0.2825170159339905,
0.48519203066825867,
-0.3039422333240509,
-0.25025784969329834,
0.4030258059501648,
0.0040961564518511295,
0.2695794403553009,
-0.24402278661727905,
0.0726848617196083,
-0.6391807794570923,
0.44378384947776794,
0.14702846109867096,
-0.4527314603328705,
0.8369420170783997,
0.8453568816184998,
-0.5371524095535278,
0.17107227444648743,
-0.9084428548812866,
-0.4036203622817993,
-0.398571640253067,
0.5667495131492615,
-0.20588895678520203,
-1.038797378540039,
0.26515546441078186,
-0.16172264516353607,
-0.25696730613708496,
0.42203763127326965,
0.4915751516819,
-0.34271010756492615,
1.1604658365249634,
1.0892354249954224,
0.058512020856142044,
1.0151513814926147,
0.15312804281711578,
0.5122132301330566,
-0.7798880338668823,
0.013074956834316254,
-0.6892399191856384,
-0.06722184270620346,
-0.3830747604370117,
-0.07121244072914124,
-0.23726792633533478,
0.16646745800971985,
0.032096829265356064,
0.23623588681221008,
-0.5812447667121887,
0.2619832754135132,
0.18235445022583008,
-0.2437443733215332,
-0.0021742216777056456,
-0.1251075267791748,
0.3271544873714447,
-0.3763993978500366,
-0.3722039461135864,
-0.6873897314071655,
0.7493565082550049,
0.526084303855896,
0.6945496797561646,
-0.052386488765478134,
0.5371407866477966,
-0.05178730934858322,
0.9382972121238708,
-0.6731253266334534,
0.5457972884178162,
0.2305021733045578,
-0.7260611653327942,
-0.08062442392110825,
-0.32294854521751404,
-0.6932555437088013,
0.2867133915424347,
-0.2052510529756546,
-1.2757487297058105,
0.23913216590881348,
0.15243561565876007,
-0.04583114758133888,
-0.18172258138656616,
-1.0858094692230225,
0.8433356285095215,
-0.24859127402305603,
0.009299619123339653,
-0.46763965487480164,
-0.596287727355957,
0.626270592212677,
0.27828046679496765,
0.4334205389022827,
-0.3080745041370392,
0.18489381670951843,
1.0141891241073608,
-0.3708461821079254,
1.0262651443481445,
-0.17928573489189148,
-0.20664112269878387,
0.6340739727020264,
0.087657630443573,
0.19472305476665497,
-0.07715360075235367,
-0.3840324878692627,
0.08786285668611526,
0.02151206135749817,
-0.3447364866733551,
-0.78806072473526,
0.41834756731987,
-0.5452835559844971,
-0.47815191745758057,
-0.437965989112854,
-0.6721321940422058,
-0.15317031741142273,
-0.4192225933074951,
-0.02560899406671524,
0.06960807740688324,
-0.177731454372406,
-0.18652842938899994,
0.42056652903556824,
-0.016443490982055664,
0.47974076867103577,
0.7541546821594238,
0.08713816851377487,
-0.23670172691345215,
0.8391249179840088,
0.06596405059099197,
0.24779826402664185,
0.2359730452299118,
0.2732114791870117,
-0.18772220611572266,
-0.4351661503314972,
0.4073367714881897,
0.4021158218383789,
-0.8977042436599731,
0.15153051912784576,
-0.6284561157226562,
0.2589617371559143,
-0.7462728023529053,
-0.15583644807338715,
-0.5236672163009644,
-0.4059256315231323,
-0.14083252847194672,
-0.32909438014030457,
0.8650468587875366,
0.9037752747535706,
-0.26418498158454895,
0.6911584734916687,
-0.7275734543800354,
-0.1331547349691391,
-0.16026990115642548,
0.20191529393196106,
0.16298802196979523,
-0.3709394931793213,
-0.3905036747455597,
-0.020977601408958435,
-0.29316291213035583,
-1.321990728378296,
0.5115224719047546,
0.24447694420814514,
0.19221217930316925,
0.37770676612854004,
-0.13306204974651337,
0.7279992699623108,
-0.22869651019573212,
0.8878807425498962,
0.3142715096473694,
-1.3153457641601562,
0.7673004269599915,
-0.014059014618396759,
-0.015697695314884186,
0.41436558961868286,
0.38792312145233154,
-0.841245174407959,
-0.352085679769516,
-0.9011362195014954,
-0.7893958687782288,
0.7049005627632141,
0.21116672456264496,
0.02251366339623928,
-0.21184572577476501,
0.5081281065940857,
-0.29828909039497375,
0.025974087417125702,
-0.5873944163322449,
-0.015509638004004955,
-0.08872967213392258,
-0.7351399660110474,
-0.25096362829208374,
-0.4054098427295685,
-0.18357910215854645,
-0.2418716847896576,
0.5401426553726196,
-0.13205021619796753,
0.4074958264827728,
0.14037944376468658,
-0.2794727087020874,
-0.2891206741333008,
0.21838289499282837,
0.5174962878227234,
0.5214500427246094,
-0.16760824620723724,
0.14543023705482483,
0.17418628931045532,
-0.5206945538520813,
-0.07652150839567184,
0.044793739914894104,
0.43958011269569397,
-0.04158487543463707,
0.6445997953414917,
0.8248255252838135,
0.2997886538505554,
-0.6813994646072388,
0.21270868182182312,
-0.24490928649902344,
0.16158635914325714,
-0.24375340342521667,
-0.11886518448591232,
0.5558047294616699,
0.2993752360343933,
0.2223730981349945,
-0.3427838385105133,
0.17947202920913696,
-0.8531110286712646,
-0.08614632487297058,
0.23641926050186157,
-0.5485301613807678,
-0.7038875818252563,
0.2460928112268448,
0.33591240644454956,
-0.47157955169677734,
0.5875475406646729,
-0.1690182387828827,
-0.7096483707427979,
0.7404396533966064,
0.42533811926841736,
0.7854391932487488,
-0.560332179069519,
0.26890289783477783,
0.30765336751937866,
0.3466370105743408,
-0.17487774789333344,
0.6334570050239563,
-0.002447394421324134,
-0.5926715135574341,
-0.5265682935714722,
-0.4232468903064728,
-0.7528157830238342,
-0.41189900040626526,
-0.8384566903114319,
0.23685021698474884,
-0.26016154885292053,
-0.21450665593147278,
0.27004945278167725,
0.36628633737564087,
-0.682750403881073,
0.5323480367660522,
0.5521581172943115,
0.7556735277175903,
-1.0328456163406372,
0.8612208366394043,
1.073775053024292,
-0.6526864767074585,
-0.5534881353378296,
-0.4268028438091278,
0.15643543004989624,
-0.4479575455188751,
0.8339324593544006,
0.1491597443819046,
0.045962851494550705,
-0.21836823225021362,
-0.896225094795227,
-0.8370878100395203,
0.8744996786117554,
0.07612716406583786,
-0.48616456985473633,
0.34050270915031433,
-0.2690202593803406,
0.9488483667373657,
-0.6605122089385986,
0.8881790041923523,
0.815385103225708,
0.8238921761512756,
-0.28656116127967834,
-0.6760894656181335,
-0.024444669485092163,
-0.34554216265678406,
0.0030693518929183483,
0.3469736576080322,
-0.5572466850280762,
0.856712281703949,
0.042849183082580566,
-0.4315665662288666,
0.056283388286828995,
1.018985390663147,
-0.12566888332366943,
0.47260963916778564,
0.33694422245025635,
0.39040082693099976,
0.8830475211143494,
-0.24005404114723206,
1.2717573642730713,
-0.1822487711906433,
0.6447306871414185,
0.9852045178413391,
-0.47056955099105835,
0.8467139005661011,
0.417205274105072,
-0.3415948748588562,
0.5856906175613403,
0.7681536078453064,
0.24907752871513367,
0.14651688933372498,
0.4856201112270355,
-0.3400673270225525,
-0.1440224051475525,
-0.26849719882011414,
-0.12426638603210449,
0.2291927933692932,
0.8451809883117676,
-0.053951021283864975,
0.047630831599235535,
0.2546711564064026,
0.400916188955307,
0.026282047852873802,
-0.03177804872393608,
0.6323120594024658,
0.05679075047373772,
-0.4243120849132538,
0.21969933807849884,
0.044794417917728424,
0.6737813353538513,
-0.3973086476325989,
0.14679762721061707,
-0.13943380117416382,
-0.18206611275672913,
-0.25125065445899963,
-0.6265577077865601,
0.4195796549320221,
0.12194576114416122,
0.05426015704870224,
0.12140177190303802,
0.9908024072647095,
-0.5993945598602295,
-0.20596976578235626,
0.5632948279380798,
0.11899608373641968,
0.34318578243255615,
-0.2523060441017151,
-0.5248082876205444,
0.4428656995296478,
-0.1705220639705658,
-0.5186594128608704,
0.05234549939632416,
0.3607041537761688,
-0.16935193538665771,
0.5398272275924683,
0.5379559993743896,
-0.00014850212028250098,
0.32197335362434387,
0.21525344252586365,
0.47762858867645264,
-1.1931599378585815,
-0.12086968868970871,
-0.8983632922172546,
0.7111218571662903,
-0.3638962507247925,
-0.3236035704612732,
0.48895227909088135,
-0.11863262951374054,
0.4999341666698456,
-0.007018099073320627,
0.7842827439308167,
-0.29251861572265625,
0.13495168089866638,
-0.2784199118614197,
0.36499857902526855,
-0.16254447400569916,
-0.29023516178131104,
-0.33575311303138733,
-0.8788999915122986,
-0.49834707379341125,
0.8053494095802307,
-0.6805722713470459,
0.044086456298828125,
1.1225643157958984,
0.4824991226196289,
0.31860458850860596,
0.6264612674713135,
-0.0011920765973627567,
0.5587310791015625,
0.3733493983745575,
0.6064162850379944,
1.1855049133300781,
-0.3053832948207855,
0.15249302983283997,
-0.6340193748474121,
-0.3679216504096985,
-0.38227975368499756,
-0.9947727918624878,
-0.6466147303581238,
-0.5950688123703003,
-0.9457523822784424,
-0.22305196523666382,
0.08807122707366943,
0.5989371538162231,
0.6553574800491333,
-0.6338208913803101,
-0.25110113620758057,
0.04272444546222687,
-0.039906956255435944,
-0.31630271673202515,
-0.3012171685695648,
0.1331787258386612,
-0.5872839093208313,
-0.7582920789718628,
0.33923473954200745,
0.4101421535015106,
-0.20223750174045563,
-0.07461612671613693,
-0.17480531334877014,
-0.26655974984169006,
0.41872575879096985,
0.6076743006706238,
0.4546642005443573,
-0.7831655144691467,
-0.597707211971283,
-0.3669963479042053,
0.02143724448978901,
0.1392909735441208,
1.050678014755249,
-0.3056011199951172,
0.4459490180015564,
0.47441983222961426,
0.3914225697517395,
0.27762657403945923,
-0.17417998611927032,
0.5641079545021057,
-0.399353951215744,
0.18277773261070251,
0.33414509892463684,
0.468679815530777,
0.6707291603088379,
-0.31997281312942505,
0.7179592251777649,
0.008469919674098492,
-0.4669027030467987,
-0.8581138253211975,
0.40867719054222107,
-1.024726152420044,
-0.15513774752616882,
0.7469039559364319,
-0.30693089962005615,
-0.50611412525177,
0.14580103754997253,
-0.36190637946128845,
0.5129360556602478,
-0.34110546112060547,
0.7713802456855774,
1.3218276500701904,
-0.489446759223938,
-0.5196025967597961,
-0.6629641056060791,
0.4943641126155853,
0.9365971088409424,
-1.0289783477783203,
0.29774385690689087,
0.4046629071235657,
0.09788061678409576,
0.45342567563056946,
0.6080748438835144,
-0.14419686794281006,
0.2390279918909073,
-0.1036691963672638,
0.6910130977630615,
0.4317522644996643,
-0.047508932650089264,
-0.7168560028076172,
0.0030041197314858437,
0.09774171561002731,
0.10638145357370377
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07017v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07017v1
|
MoreauPruner: Robust Pruning of Large Language Models against Weight Perturbations
| 2024-06-11T07:19:04 | 2024-06-11T07:19:04 |
Zixiao Wang, Jingwei Zhang, Wenqian Zhao, Farzan Farnia, Bei Yu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Few-shot gradient methods have been extensively utilized in existing model
pruning methods, where the model weights are regarded as static values and the
effects of potential weight perturbations are not considered. However, the
widely used large language models (LLMs) have several billion model parameters,
which could increase the fragility of few-shot gradient pruning. In this work,
we experimentally show that one-shot gradient pruning algorithms could lead to
unstable results under perturbations to model weights. And the minor error of
switching between data formats bfloat16 and float16 could result in drastically
different outcomes. To address such instabilities, we leverage optimization
analysis and propose an LLM structural pruning method, called MoreauPruner,
with provable robustness against weight perturbations. In MoreauPruner, the
model weight importance is estimated based on the neural network's Moreau
envelope, which can be flexibly combined with $\ell_1$-norm regularization
techniques to induce the sparsity required in the pruning task. We extensively
evaluate the MoreauPruner algorithm on several well-known LLMs, including
LLaMA-7B, LLaMA-13B, LLaMA3-8B, and Vicuna-7B. Our numerical results suggest
the robustness of MoreauPruner against weight perturbations, and indicate the
MoreauPruner's successful accuracy-based scores in comparison to several
existing pruning methods. We have released the code in
\url{https://github.com/ShiningSord/MoreauPruner}.
|
[
-0.315106064081192,
-0.9539055228233337,
0.18068824708461761,
0.4551571011543274,
-0.25586867332458496,
-0.051833298057317734,
-0.3422620892524719,
-0.22585773468017578,
0.18240059912204742,
0.19401109218597412,
-0.6778452396392822,
-0.3163573741912842,
-0.5935783982276917,
-0.012629170902073383,
-0.45990312099456787,
0.8565629124641418,
0.18631692230701447,
0.0560675710439682,
0.06425005197525024,
-0.23183897137641907,
-0.47861289978027344,
-0.7507343888282776,
-0.6537120342254639,
-0.3092338442802429,
0.5833297967910767,
0.2622111439704895,
0.7164381146430969,
0.610743522644043,
0.7619289755821228,
0.32094690203666687,
-0.5146665573120117,
-0.12170617282390594,
-0.6901221871376038,
0.08438794314861298,
0.46278631687164307,
-0.712302565574646,
-0.5606029629707336,
-0.34558895230293274,
0.7686806321144104,
0.4480223059654236,
-0.3824675679206848,
0.27110710740089417,
0.0916883647441864,
0.5828053951263428,
-0.4221881628036499,
-0.0640263631939888,
-0.6965458393096924,
0.023278558626770973,
-0.5854570269584656,
-0.12446431070566177,
-0.05698259547352791,
-0.28020477294921875,
-0.3301299214363098,
-0.3445436656475067,
-0.07231951504945755,
-0.10707836598157883,
1.2159056663513184,
0.47311311960220337,
-0.07861445844173431,
0.4890608489513397,
-0.6963799595832825,
0.9073516130447388,
-1.02744722366333,
0.3286658227443695,
0.2842058837413788,
0.3192595839500427,
-0.13162267208099365,
-0.4107358753681183,
-0.4366367757320404,
-0.42504429817199707,
0.1437474936246872,
0.07760565727949142,
0.01529612671583891,
0.053128790110349655,
0.20974136888980865,
0.2993016541004181,
-0.5025911927223206,
0.41482973098754883,
-0.22721776366233826,
-0.36789780855178833,
0.5457550287246704,
0.12310939282178879,
0.0560307539999485,
-0.17289617657661438,
-0.28216779232025146,
-0.4647538363933563,
-0.915425717830658,
0.14301052689552307,
0.7570431232452393,
0.18038144707679749,
0.1310659795999527,
0.5584856271743774,
0.17606304585933685,
0.6726953983306885,
0.040927864611148834,
-0.4811328053474426,
0.23500753939151764,
-0.21780192852020264,
-0.1296049803495407,
-0.0011574358213692904,
0.5217440128326416,
0.3423835039138794,
0.43345996737480164,
0.22585411369800568,
-0.2891167998313904,
0.017247609794139862,
-0.0962500274181366,
-0.8114039897918701,
-0.4044893980026245,
0.292428582906723,
-0.5942803621292114,
-0.27413442730903625,
-0.07589469105005264,
-0.5494964718818665,
-0.16293270885944366,
-0.03405877202749252,
0.04024699702858925,
-0.4649621844291687,
-0.34562787413597107,
0.016989249736070633,
0.11777108907699585,
0.27474483847618103,
0.30027908086776733,
-0.5645905137062073,
0.4495859444141388,
0.8662863969802856,
0.9602586627006531,
-0.21630175411701202,
-0.3171280026435852,
-0.689141035079956,
-0.08707819879055023,
-0.23637311160564423,
0.49351611733436584,
-0.5827298760414124,
-0.16515465080738068,
-0.12080062925815582,
-0.034716904163360596,
-0.00731227220967412,
-0.46591055393218994,
0.7096213102340698,
-0.5599818229675293,
-0.25554460287094116,
-0.24166032671928406,
-0.4625714421272278,
-0.38770049810409546,
0.712702751159668,
-0.8502218723297119,
0.9913923740386963,
0.09231231361627579,
-0.773210346698761,
0.2200177162885666,
-0.1870439201593399,
-0.6197494864463806,
-0.016642091795802116,
-0.11870899796485901,
-0.9366423487663269,
0.27663567662239075,
0.18865594267845154,
0.31756138801574707,
-0.17843157052993774,
0.483553409576416,
-0.39068299531936646,
-0.22664739191532135,
0.09272664040327072,
-0.8058342337608337,
1.0466047525405884,
-0.1112256646156311,
0.03626004233956337,
0.25972750782966614,
-0.6605919003486633,
-0.10597886890172958,
0.229458287358284,
-0.6897016167640686,
-0.2062978595495224,
-0.0963388979434967,
0.4197429418563843,
0.14447394013404846,
0.045141808688640594,
-0.5999094247817993,
0.3293323814868927,
-0.6103057265281677,
0.5268369913101196,
0.7214940786361694,
0.07649721950292587,
0.23618978261947632,
-0.560397744178772,
0.677238941192627,
-0.2904760539531708,
0.05395191162824631,
-0.19013482332229614,
-0.3225937783718109,
-0.6492233872413635,
-0.3833112120628357,
0.5484750866889954,
0.6369317173957825,
-0.049428340047597885,
0.46278059482574463,
-0.32788699865341187,
-0.4366924464702606,
-0.24270333349704742,
0.47029930353164673,
0.2971479594707489,
0.35276830196380615,
0.34331992268562317,
-0.44407781958580017,
-0.5366136431694031,
-0.6161393523216248,
-0.20138759911060333,
-0.11874015629291534,
-0.10652074217796326,
0.21203802525997162,
0.508847177028656,
0.11305630952119827,
0.6986293196678162,
-0.40202587842941284,
-0.6500884294509888,
-0.23350660502910614,
-0.09012367576360703,
0.25249361991882324,
0.7693621516227722,
0.6588800549507141,
-0.7717103958129883,
-0.23828314244747162,
-0.1002570390701294,
-0.2906828224658966,
0.25412482023239136,
-0.4124927520751953,
0.1425904929637909,
-0.2081054300069809,
0.4390254318714142,
-0.7269623875617981,
0.033337414264678955,
0.6136612892150879,
0.3666480779647827,
0.6544190049171448,
0.06510818004608154,
-0.4432738423347473,
-0.7728931307792664,
-0.09586965292692184,
0.3930909037590027,
-0.3297659456729889,
-0.37142664194107056,
0.13410958647727966,
-0.06175801903009415,
0.03301423043012619,
-0.4326484501361847,
0.422985702753067,
-0.5424467325210571,
0.021706338971853256,
0.03132914751768112,
-0.2142046093940735,
0.0644954964518547,
0.5973476767539978,
0.057261884212493896,
0.31496137380599976,
0.6160920858383179,
-0.46532952785491943,
0.5294955968856812,
0.22968725860118866,
-0.39652174711227417,
0.16742199659347534,
-0.8624303340911865,
-0.004098714329302311,
-0.24606743454933167,
0.29748639464378357,
-0.928152322769165,
-0.22053839266300201,
0.1493903547525406,
-0.26644426584243774,
0.7116239666938782,
-0.3695365786552429,
-0.4609438478946686,
-0.19106152653694153,
-0.8233223557472229,
0.3318013846874237,
0.19690947234630585,
-0.30523645877838135,
0.4066656529903412,
0.29593539237976074,
-0.6228362917900085,
-0.4001867473125458,
-0.9989330172538757,
0.07131540775299072,
-0.4606894850730896,
-0.6950033903121948,
0.25275617837905884,
-0.13788484036922455,
-0.256203293800354,
-0.22796648740768433,
-0.383974552154541,
-0.15437212586402893,
0.3005746006965637,
0.1281248927116394,
0.32417532801628113,
-0.2939879596233368,
-0.09202678501605988,
0.161374032497406,
-0.2387988120317459,
-0.014198258519172668,
-0.10810864716768265,
0.7008273005485535,
-0.13735756278038025,
-0.7428092360496521,
-0.4128626585006714,
0.0651935413479805,
0.3683001399040222,
-0.5471498370170593,
0.5838338732719421,
0.6529743671417236,
-0.3596101403236389,
0.16636984050273895,
-0.6005072593688965,
-0.38133329153060913,
-0.4949507415294647,
0.6847673058509827,
-0.2330137938261032,
-0.9225633144378662,
0.4653932750225067,
-0.25120478868484497,
0.4805939495563507,
0.2511056959629059,
0.5196248888969421,
-0.022606810554862022,
1.0535420179367065,
0.7849153876304626,
-0.5449023246765137,
0.7246805429458618,
-0.3944597840309143,
-0.13923484086990356,
-0.8238256573677063,
0.06699685752391815,
-0.5672072172164917,
-0.6459143757820129,
-0.3392077386379242,
-0.22944952547550201,
0.20831464231014252,
0.04580223932862282,
-0.09730013459920883,
0.40330857038497925,
-0.48516255617141724,
0.40559202432632446,
0.3842560350894928,
-0.16193413734436035,
0.21876703202724457,
0.35687288641929626,
0.07802394032478333,
-0.11934051662683487,
-0.8577285408973694,
-0.3885836899280548,
0.7929793000221252,
0.6522663235664368,
0.9994102716445923,
0.12884332239627838,
0.5198479294776917,
-0.26068779826164246,
0.5133851170539856,
-0.8708257675170898,
0.34106507897377014,
0.0537148155272007,
-0.6993803381919861,
-0.5396870970726013,
-0.49501416087150574,
-0.8135747313499451,
0.33526113629341125,
-0.15067893266677856,
-0.8901952505111694,
0.3771609663963318,
0.42912301421165466,
-0.5861130356788635,
0.14662116765975952,
-0.40777257084846497,
0.5860652327537537,
-0.6270447969436646,
-0.25207871198654175,
-0.09869935363531113,
-0.6640345454216003,
0.5099862217903137,
-0.07795439660549164,
0.1450423300266266,
-0.12272660434246063,
-0.10146895051002502,
0.6961519718170166,
-0.4566156268119812,
0.8770968317985535,
-0.0640392079949379,
-0.3185192346572876,
0.18798178434371948,
0.3844427168369293,
0.8857365846633911,
0.22767286002635956,
-0.33434510231018066,
0.16935843229293823,
-0.06287599354982376,
-0.25626009702682495,
-0.35970863699913025,
0.8080378174781799,
-0.5103747248649597,
-0.633825421333313,
-0.0700823962688446,
-0.49139028787612915,
-0.1140424981713295,
0.2149958610534668,
0.4516731798648834,
0.5302315354347229,
0.1051763966679573,
0.4739970564842224,
0.39461344480514526,
0.04020251706242561,
0.6218569874763489,
0.19661305844783783,
0.015428053215146065,
-0.3637229800224304,
1.2118369340896606,
0.5077316164970398,
-0.047173891216516495,
0.5772989392280579,
0.23415158689022064,
0.14150722324848175,
-0.9719520211219788,
-0.14240556955337524,
0.06138136237859726,
-0.3434767723083496,
-0.5682044625282288,
-0.3092053532600403,
-0.14128050208091736,
-0.036371879279613495,
-0.03612736985087395,
-0.4401707053184509,
-0.5842512249946594,
-0.0300652626901865,
-0.28321439027786255,
0.35072416067123413,
0.2284964621067047,
0.2474592924118042,
0.6439775228500366,
-1.0229946374893188,
-0.005090642720460892,
0.04689496010541916,
0.27864447236061096,
0.11583679914474487,
-0.48179757595062256,
0.060805078595876694,
-0.11054681986570358,
-0.29608455300331116,
-0.8764059543609619,
0.5638756155967712,
0.5128553509712219,
0.5260438323020935,
0.7808555960655212,
-0.06989557296037674,
0.6767632365226746,
-0.34637442231178284,
0.41000375151634216,
0.13416118919849396,
-0.5370837450027466,
0.10798188298940659,
-0.2202928215265274,
0.43368494510650635,
0.7215259671211243,
0.31138983368873596,
-0.36748623847961426,
-0.3613772392272949,
-0.4432699978351593,
-1.0189223289489746,
0.468462735414505,
0.3114320635795593,
0.25399598479270935,
0.2642596662044525,
0.3835729658603668,
-0.04405437037348747,
0.33517760038375854,
-0.839466392993927,
-0.25185978412628174,
-0.18856951594352722,
-0.06630344688892365,
0.02167692966759205,
-0.4733520448207855,
-0.236906498670578,
-0.20724816620349884,
0.6232348084449768,
-0.09993773698806763,
-0.30470454692840576,
-0.0025274045765399933,
-0.34897172451019287,
-0.10848499834537506,
0.1401975154876709,
0.43342921137809753,
0.48727861046791077,
-0.06709761917591095,
-0.14366762340068817,
0.31148216128349304,
-0.47882238030433655,
0.008515284396708012,
0.28775715827941895,
-0.4224630892276764,
-0.05261904373764992,
0.6747180819511414,
0.6223472952842712,
0.08046861737966537,
-0.5753036737442017,
0.5002907514572144,
-0.019297033548355103,
-0.2597433030605316,
-0.18294525146484375,
-0.1984236091375351,
0.06070809066295624,
0.04496690258383751,
0.39256009459495544,
0.3002360165119171,
-0.06747003644704819,
-0.10821468383073807,
0.010498722083866596,
0.7660513520240784,
-0.32930636405944824,
-0.42889708280563354,
0.49225860834121704,
0.30993741750717163,
-0.40808093547821045,
0.5166172981262207,
-0.03266548365354538,
-0.6223617792129517,
0.5938133597373962,
0.32927948236465454,
0.46992331743240356,
-0.22174802422523499,
-0.060123227536678314,
0.290432333946228,
0.8066661953926086,
-0.34197062253952026,
0.13827641308307648,
-0.12629468739032745,
-0.7571703195571899,
-0.9123410582542419,
-0.6312848925590515,
-0.051857542246580124,
0.30047690868377686,
-0.39872485399246216,
0.08849175274372101,
-0.7878677845001221,
-0.4344733953475952,
-0.2114689201116562,
0.07720470428466797,
-0.18512210249900818,
0.026716753840446472,
-0.07731907069683075,
1.006192684173584,
-0.8494333028793335,
0.6977550387382507,
0.8486085534095764,
-0.29042789340019226,
-0.8907290101051331,
0.03759582340717316,
0.35491943359375,
-0.43457549810409546,
0.2964773178100586,
0.11777209490537643,
-0.013192781247198582,
0.14305426180362701,
-0.615019679069519,
-1.1535556316375732,
0.8324832320213318,
0.9356141686439514,
-1.1594533920288086,
-0.1115998849272728,
-0.35428673028945923,
0.24327558279037476,
0.22019851207733154,
0.03977873921394348,
0.43727174401283264,
0.8015044331550598,
0.0359591543674469,
-0.7838271856307983,
-0.05515091493725777,
-0.2586001753807068,
-0.03108314797282219,
0.2779844403266907,
-1.0053365230560303,
0.820631206035614,
-0.07993752509355545,
-0.16085946559906006,
0.14836068451404572,
0.5960883498191833,
0.32701119780540466,
-0.22093205153942108,
0.5687733888626099,
0.48548197746276855,
0.8036661744117737,
0.0700143575668335,
1.0542728900909424,
-0.41335105895996094,
0.42594876885414124,
1.2175276279449463,
-0.2961200475692749,
0.7109367847442627,
0.6381142139434814,
-0.36117231845855713,
0.1701553910970688,
0.5298950672149658,
-0.29347893595695496,
0.09563547372817993,
0.34979814291000366,
0.1384737342596054,
-0.36029815673828125,
0.09834032505750656,
-0.3061414361000061,
0.2794855535030365,
0.1281379759311676,
0.1768212765455246,
-0.2584708034992218,
-0.02238553576171398,
0.20264574885368347,
-0.12065355479717255,
-0.16427451372146606,
0.47026342153549194,
0.2746546268463135,
-0.3453676700592041,
0.7088416814804077,
0.18057402968406677,
0.9255184531211853,
-0.7158654928207397,
0.009433504194021225,
-0.22397036850452423,
0.318233847618103,
-0.5147911310195923,
-0.3434985280036926,
0.13540762662887573,
-0.20840853452682495,
0.16420887410640717,
-0.21986545622348785,
0.8945475220680237,
-0.22026313841342926,
-0.8392899632453918,
0.10857699811458588,
0.3424112796783447,
-0.09964212775230408,
-0.18539758026599884,
-0.6706915497779846,
0.4672415554523468,
-0.1167425587773323,
-0.7280123233795166,
0.5201842188835144,
0.029919186607003212,
-0.22568625211715698,
0.9578001499176025,
0.6978529095649719,
0.37847456336021423,
0.11152777075767517,
0.13873134553432465,
1.008462905883789,
-0.2125849574804306,
-0.13163477182388306,
-1.0015918016433716,
0.3110353350639343,
-0.003966233693063259,
-0.36451366543769836,
1.0767028331756592,
0.5865405797958374,
0.735601007938385,
0.2894120216369629,
0.36451098322868347,
0.1347033530473709,
0.13987937569618225,
-0.386522501707077,
0.5222278237342834,
-0.4852094054222107,
0.4886036515235901,
-0.4430113136768341,
-1.1951024532318115,
-0.4900991916656494,
0.8052976727485657,
-0.09347276389598846,
0.19832594692707062,
0.3462027907371521,
0.8914440274238586,
0.014044818468391895,
-0.4208274781703949,
0.16469094157218933,
0.3543994426727295,
0.21715377271175385,
0.20470675826072693,
0.5107221603393555,
-0.05475371703505516,
0.9045690298080444,
-0.22428828477859497,
-0.13137611746788025,
-0.19656623899936676,
-0.9557929635047913,
-0.6071140766143799,
-0.12235195189714432,
-0.4161589741706848,
-0.03398619592189789,
0.05144285410642624,
0.7364960312843323,
0.9809467196464539,
-0.766196608543396,
-0.21942290663719177,
-0.2577100992202759,
0.1609799712896347,
-0.5108150839805603,
-0.21945025026798248,
0.2648061513900757,
0.14172659814357758,
-0.4848378002643585,
0.520739734172821,
0.2930891513824463,
0.010203943587839603,
-0.4442826509475708,
-0.11413471400737762,
-0.2535770833492279,
-0.09443022310733795,
0.31652751564979553,
0.4606003761291504,
-0.4154578149318695,
0.021264728158712387,
-0.12208624184131622,
0.23316723108291626,
0.15845902264118195,
0.6935665607452393,
-0.6805014610290527,
-0.10534895956516266,
0.4767160415649414,
0.7686135768890381,
0.6741786599159241,
0.38549354672431946,
0.6019286513328552,
-1.0680546760559082,
0.3230123519897461,
0.34357115626335144,
0.4735358655452728,
0.48480910062789917,
-0.30021747946739197,
0.08839011192321777,
0.002259682398289442,
-0.25186920166015625,
-0.9804049730300903,
0.3778429925441742,
-0.6519681811332703,
-0.234879732131958,
1.1186208724975586,
-0.14093993604183197,
-0.4201030135154724,
0.15542404353618622,
-0.43718913197517395,
-0.015563974156975746,
-0.5808480381965637,
0.41869720816612244,
0.6150807738304138,
0.06516245007514954,
-0.5031935572624207,
-0.32734283804893494,
0.35254645347595215,
0.6573827266693115,
-0.5791298151016235,
0.01845642738044262,
0.3727056086063385,
0.31946125626564026,
0.23947663605213165,
0.4339583218097687,
-0.02118511125445366,
0.12329203635454178,
-0.13996072113513947,
-0.27867648005485535,
-0.28708067536354065,
-0.3139991760253906,
-0.5851330161094666,
0.4430244266986847,
0.41541868448257446,
0.12100838124752045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07016v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07016v2
|
Delving into ChatGPT usage in academic writing through excess vocabulary
| 2024-06-11T07:16:34 | 2024-07-03T09:53:27 |
Dmitry Kobak, Rita González-Márquez, Emőke-Ágnes Horvát, Jan Lause
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.DL, cs.SI
|
Recent large language models (LLMs) can generate and revise text with
human-level performance, and have been widely commercialized in systems like
ChatGPT. These models come with clear limitations: they can produce inaccurate
information, reinforce existing biases, and be easily misused. Yet, many
scientists have been using them to assist their scholarly writing. How
wide-spread is LLM usage in the academic literature currently? To answer this
question, we use an unbiased, large-scale approach, free from any assumptions
on academic LLM usage. We study vocabulary changes in 14 million PubMed
abstracts from 2010-2024, and show how the appearance of LLMs led to an abrupt
increase in the frequency of certain style words. Our analysis based on excess
words usage suggests that at least 10% of 2024 abstracts were processed with
LLMs. This lower bound differed across disciplines, countries, and journals,
and was as high as 30% for some PubMed sub-corpora. We show that the appearance
of LLM-based writing assistants has had an unprecedented impact in the
scientific literature, surpassing the effect of major world events such as the
Covid pandemic.
|
[
-0.16512249410152435,
-0.6593102812767029,
0.666295051574707,
0.12647435069084167,
-0.1428234726190567,
0.23037651181221008,
-0.2578944265842438,
-0.870612382888794,
0.25596049427986145,
0.507127046585083,
0.04100752994418144,
-0.4010888636112213,
-0.9512291550636292,
0.36854368448257446,
-0.5924655199050903,
1.332776427268982,
-0.056323353201150894,
0.25774526596069336,
-0.4382915794849396,
-0.051405005156993866,
0.08108684420585632,
-0.5659410357475281,
-0.2363874465227127,
-0.5950091481208801,
0.7700731754302979,
0.19744034111499786,
0.5510983467102051,
0.36503905057907104,
0.8499162793159485,
0.21861864626407623,
-0.17686544358730316,
0.16448183357715607,
-0.7397106885910034,
-0.0016170345479622483,
0.02937069535255432,
-0.5508430600166321,
-0.677314043045044,
-0.008088549599051476,
0.8221791982650757,
0.8993290066719055,
-0.0631452277302742,
-0.07040385901927948,
0.215070441365242,
0.7113929986953735,
-0.43530261516571045,
0.03104889579117298,
-0.7105779051780701,
-0.11849594861268997,
-0.4357752799987793,
-0.315216600894928,
-0.41100186109542847,
-0.10763385891914368,
0.4612713158130646,
-0.6871193647384644,
0.014577186666429043,
0.07567667216062546,
0.695283055305481,
-0.039589058607816696,
-0.11043120175600052,
-0.4546392858028412,
-0.6007111072540283,
0.6379557847976685,
-0.5315563082695007,
0.16857372224330902,
0.18538600206375122,
-0.21474869549274445,
-0.47707700729370117,
-0.9079450368881226,
-0.34143105149269104,
-0.29181107878685,
0.024937255308032036,
0.11214450001716614,
-0.32348906993865967,
0.24720343947410583,
0.13676981627941132,
0.1948041021823883,
-0.41444867849349976,
0.023015743121504784,
-0.7411721348762512,
0.12502896785736084,
0.4568102955818176,
0.13203392922878265,
0.5505732893943787,
0.12972500920295715,
-0.25900667905807495,
0.32694369554519653,
-1.0512036085128784,
-0.4099031388759613,
0.0894513875246048,
0.07012239843606949,
0.2078051120042801,
0.9057336449623108,
0.27543604373931885,
0.3986421525478363,
-0.4838048815727234,
0.2153925597667694,
-0.1503392606973648,
-0.2627374529838562,
-0.2818588316440582,
0.07490448653697968,
0.9287311434745789,
0.7000964283943176,
0.4833855628967285,
-0.16373145580291748,
0.17412340641021729,
0.018381785601377487,
0.29395389556884766,
-0.5866998434066772,
-0.35583508014678955,
-0.018504861742258072,
0.07751421630382538,
-0.09971315413713455,
-0.35010936856269836,
-0.6319936513900757,
-0.797601580619812,
0.026822075247764587,
0.1342291384935379,
-0.5356994271278381,
0.10018180310726166,
0.20757357776165009,
-0.35812440514564514,
0.08497955650091171,
0.3659180700778961,
-0.6083250641822815,
0.3833620250225067,
0.7126136422157288,
1.2368838787078857,
-0.44225791096687317,
-0.351471483707428,
-0.0001039392373058945,
0.07299493253231049,
-0.5601006746292114,
1.0539666414260864,
-0.4172336459159851,
-0.7391909956932068,
0.05295661464333534,
-0.2174563854932785,
-0.021414384245872498,
-0.3942919373512268,
0.37874555587768555,
-0.4885390102863312,
0.14433114230632782,
-0.2079819291830063,
-0.6857158541679382,
0.02790207602083683,
-0.1258404552936554,
-0.36427855491638184,
0.7908395528793335,
-0.08334527909755707,
-0.7388544678688049,
0.38177385926246643,
-0.6383740901947021,
-0.3321634829044342,
0.2393617182970047,
-0.05417375639081001,
-0.33885207772254944,
0.11883935332298279,
-0.13683216273784637,
0.5265122056007385,
-0.16186216473579407,
0.2738669216632843,
-0.10743129253387451,
-0.48836225271224976,
0.529499351978302,
-0.27958551049232483,
0.3922269940376282,
0.24425263702869415,
0.1986236572265625,
-0.3027711510658264,
-0.5280355215072632,
-0.4271370768547058,
-0.1017872542142868,
-0.3849247097969055,
-0.6814791560173035,
0.03563889116048813,
0.08856374025344849,
-0.1680091917514801,
0.1449594646692276,
-0.6933236718177795,
0.3062080144882202,
-0.5169489979743958,
0.7540878653526306,
0.379572331905365,
0.26372087001800537,
0.37255099415779114,
-0.7176446914672852,
0.4199226200580597,
-0.4739103317260742,
-0.3962707817554474,
-0.05247563123703003,
-0.6129909753799438,
-0.4047396779060364,
-0.48216482996940613,
0.09897533804178238,
0.2622075080871582,
-0.25586748123168945,
0.011307241395115852,
-0.28270766139030457,
-0.6878030896186829,
-0.46713563799858093,
0.06406853348016739,
0.11337316781282425,
0.3544379472732544,
0.4367642104625702,
-0.034768246114254,
-0.5913357138633728,
-0.7919277548789978,
-0.6721969842910767,
0.020580308511853218,
-0.027245832607150078,
0.2082444429397583,
0.6304071545600891,
-0.21065129339694977,
0.7058928608894348,
-0.49377861618995667,
-0.2559709846973419,
-0.3314310312271118,
0.2820567786693573,
-0.027271244674921036,
0.2528023421764374,
0.08948945254087448,
-0.3188423812389374,
-0.5171797871589661,
-0.12977072596549988,
-0.5250945687294006,
-0.445504367351532,
-0.31995946168899536,
-0.10774552822113037,
0.21588034927845,
0.7346111536026001,
-0.46709951758384705,
0.06369486451148987,
0.6739485263824463,
-0.25313714146614075,
0.6448156833648682,
-0.3375813364982605,
-0.17250141501426697,
-0.8902455568313599,
0.23525284230709076,
0.34660789370536804,
-0.11402370780706406,
-0.6218241453170776,
-0.09472981840372086,
-0.0845162570476532,
0.12664106488227844,
-0.15272505581378937,
0.6273220181465149,
-0.7031170725822449,
0.19196093082427979,
-0.448742538690567,
0.45206740498542786,
0.0847538486123085,
-0.18336859345436096,
0.025634732097387314,
0.8767715692520142,
0.2039947658777237,
-0.37317657470703125,
-0.07252491265535355,
0.08735033869743347,
-0.5625879168510437,
0.1934925615787506,
-0.7756171822547913,
-0.1706344187259674,
-0.23021385073661804,
0.5355371236801147,
-1.3074396848678589,
-0.2823297381401062,
-0.09735476225614548,
-0.21632897853851318,
0.359547883272171,
0.09907019138336182,
-0.35864561796188354,
-0.0795702338218689,
-0.30887871980667114,
-0.05676945298910141,
0.4671877920627594,
-0.22094950079917908,
0.3977304995059967,
0.5672838687896729,
-0.5480837225914001,
-0.5272391438484192,
-0.823809027671814,
0.48965775966644287,
-0.04099231958389282,
-0.4822639226913452,
0.3891522288322449,
0.06485313177108765,
-0.6680594086647034,
-0.17573748528957367,
-0.05865190178155899,
0.021727008745074272,
-0.03840600326657295,
0.31483063101768494,
0.5491335988044739,
0.11264622211456299,
0.34100809693336487,
-0.10720928758382797,
0.40896862745285034,
0.20256049931049347,
-0.01172318309545517,
0.6104902029037476,
-0.15046752989292145,
-0.17693603038787842,
-0.0959220603108406,
0.2920149862766266,
0.7548261880874634,
0.17253756523132324,
0.594928503036499,
0.17626778781414032,
0.052638038992881775,
-0.05636957287788391,
-0.5384019017219543,
-0.07807702571153641,
-0.4076896607875824,
0.8167272806167603,
0.18813559412956238,
-0.7604906558990479,
0.4305378794670105,
-0.059983011335134506,
0.35170549154281616,
0.4383663833141327,
0.4296935796737671,
-0.19460982084274292,
0.45597806572914124,
0.4340706765651703,
0.14202803373336792,
0.4250546991825104,
-0.23451732099056244,
0.06950864940881729,
-1.1656156778335571,
-0.2017420083284378,
-0.4972861707210541,
-0.1580507606267929,
-0.7686405777931213,
-0.5372180342674255,
0.4909884035587311,
-0.10693572461605072,
0.043268486857414246,
-0.08298428356647491,
-0.5674287676811218,
0.5426971912384033,
0.38083747029304504,
0.01807309500873089,
0.569990873336792,
-0.0069840229116380215,
0.09911883622407913,
-0.11548315733671188,
-0.6782317757606506,
-0.6806401610374451,
1.224757432937622,
0.5164552927017212,
0.8219689726829529,
-0.18766441941261292,
0.40252840518951416,
0.19898532330989838,
0.6228407025337219,
-0.9784531593322754,
0.5228712558746338,
-0.3542923331260681,
-0.5250148773193359,
-0.3491482734680176,
-0.05174732580780983,
-0.9611244797706604,
0.2433193176984787,
-0.18196210265159607,
-0.5503949522972107,
0.06365621834993362,
-0.017569785937666893,
-0.26730093359947205,
0.2927457392215729,
-0.6267975568771362,
0.2215575873851776,
0.00015700074436608702,
-0.5126250386238098,
-0.12407287955284119,
-0.4736754596233368,
0.32068362832069397,
-0.21821942925453186,
0.3246781826019287,
-0.2568732500076294,
-0.40374839305877686,
0.8827848434448242,
-0.2782908082008362,
1.0209643840789795,
0.21074822545051575,
-0.2042754739522934,
0.2980441153049469,
0.05401991307735443,
0.5147800445556641,
0.11488379538059235,
-0.0401763953268528,
0.5383256077766418,
0.10976802557706833,
-0.3412455916404724,
-0.05224600434303284,
0.7446853518486023,
-0.8051863312721252,
-0.5986670851707458,
-0.8526356816291809,
-0.785941481590271,
-0.23772281408309937,
-0.030620282515883446,
0.6447871923446655,
0.3360544741153717,
-0.5014790296554565,
0.20421451330184937,
0.5645202398300171,
-0.23408155143260956,
0.26966774463653564,
0.4900444447994232,
-0.26023009419441223,
-0.15075959265232086,
0.6354894042015076,
0.4699479937553406,
0.42587536573410034,
0.154502734541893,
0.3103211224079132,
-0.14361804723739624,
-0.642857015132904,
-0.23187391459941864,
0.5012941956520081,
-0.43540993332862854,
0.15903538465499878,
-0.9957044720649719,
-0.23588481545448303,
-0.4334588050842285,
-0.5353116393089294,
-0.1341722011566162,
-0.3697071373462677,
-0.3955651819705963,
0.06742209941148758,
0.7463757991790771,
0.8588472008705139,
-0.002086928579956293,
0.44042113423347473,
-0.6207476854324341,
-0.11790581047534943,
-0.06629312038421631,
0.40488889813423157,
-0.18618430197238922,
-0.6792332530021667,
-0.0607340969145298,
-0.21911966800689697,
-0.06681309640407562,
-0.7678319811820984,
0.548351526260376,
0.4575136601924896,
0.32065457105636597,
0.158601775765419,
-0.2953246831893921,
0.2862783968448639,
-0.7177636027336121,
0.9846779108047485,
0.10165984183549881,
-0.4640389382839203,
-0.11860779672861099,
-0.7721019387245178,
0.6659121513366699,
0.37944740056991577,
0.7076645493507385,
-1.1186059713363647,
-0.8189984560012817,
-0.42481374740600586,
-1.1460472345352173,
0.3468865752220154,
-0.14551076292991638,
0.39609625935554504,
-0.12017430365085602,
0.30777743458747864,
0.20684795081615448,
0.04432158172130585,
-0.5921512842178345,
-0.10602586716413498,
0.17260237038135529,
-0.013167533092200756,
-0.19791348278522491,
-0.39044395089149475,
-0.24261172115802765,
-0.11923101544380188,
0.698383092880249,
0.06929094344377518,
0.2517591118812561,
0.4508339464664459,
0.029223959892988205,
0.0013648634776473045,
0.5089020729064941,
0.7122524380683899,
0.7410060167312622,
-0.16019144654273987,
0.16028283536434174,
0.23481808602809906,
-0.9770882725715637,
-0.2377566546201706,
0.10021641850471497,
-0.17081382870674133,
0.12858542799949646,
0.4648829400539398,
0.26116517186164856,
0.2239207625389099,
-0.8327234983444214,
0.22772054374217987,
0.21001650393009186,
-0.4589169919490814,
-0.465364545583725,
0.06305663287639618,
0.37771666049957275,
-0.03387783467769623,
0.3752814531326294,
0.15476654469966888,
0.17784659564495087,
-0.6094443798065186,
0.002487585414201021,
0.580970823764801,
-0.25283846259117126,
-0.21928581595420837,
0.35822999477386475,
0.052035048604011536,
0.06276776641607285,
0.14080768823623657,
0.18549254536628723,
-0.29037636518478394,
0.3580828607082367,
0.6786013841629028,
0.5380317568778992,
0.05112406983971596,
0.14077207446098328,
0.033018819987773895,
0.19434556365013123,
-0.26484963297843933,
0.1505129486322403,
0.5037881731987,
-0.5523954629898071,
-0.6182319521903992,
-0.666933536529541,
-0.5940335988998413,
0.4180087447166443,
-0.22414124011993408,
0.2635471820831299,
-0.3540135324001312,
-0.19006755948066711,
0.4089046120643616,
-0.10800333321094513,
-0.3035752475261688,
-0.21884672343730927,
-0.04149685427546501,
0.6850546598434448,
-0.679861307144165,
0.5136323571205139,
0.9717140793800354,
-0.05014700070023537,
-0.33441630005836487,
-0.1678134948015213,
0.26095902919769287,
-0.8288708329200745,
0.5257436037063599,
-0.15487593412399292,
-0.1671638935804367,
-0.017963433638215065,
-0.7731516361236572,
-0.9292517304420471,
0.6172143816947937,
-0.1675095111131668,
-0.8145166635513306,
-0.2354736030101776,
0.1104246973991394,
1.058661699295044,
-0.19521211087703705,
0.20089268684387207,
0.5399692058563232,
0.2824532091617584,
0.2100435197353363,
-0.8221036791801453,
-0.21600115299224854,
-0.11977917701005936,
-0.17371678352355957,
0.32442814111709595,
-0.5765909552574158,
0.7677304148674011,
-0.2207312136888504,
-0.14371369779109955,
-0.0433097667992115,
0.32823053002357483,
0.09768117964267731,
0.2694745361804962,
-0.14035245776176453,
0.0497545525431633,
0.9001052379608154,
0.09321194142103195,
0.9125773310661316,
-0.3006550073623657,
-0.1309330016374588,
1.0137957334518433,
-0.35354068875312805,
0.8485417366027832,
0.6481682062149048,
-0.23023489117622375,
0.3862997889518738,
0.2586396038532257,
-0.255928635597229,
0.0546569749712944,
0.5162200927734375,
-0.4808732867240906,
0.08062050491571426,
-0.3310307562351227,
-0.38067230582237244,
0.4535572826862335,
0.820112407207489,
-0.7101128101348877,
-0.17561504244804382,
0.09700821340084076,
0.5167337656021118,
0.13826093077659607,
-0.34585317969322205,
0.7656959891319275,
0.4105999767780304,
-0.636043906211853,
0.5395975708961487,
-0.17310714721679688,
0.8345277905464172,
-0.5983938574790955,
0.08614140003919601,
-0.1670549511909485,
0.01919739693403244,
-0.2667848467826843,
-0.9836384654045105,
0.3155312240123749,
0.33015498518943787,
-0.019256524741649628,
-0.09074437618255615,
0.811528742313385,
-0.4400346577167511,
-0.4435942769050598,
-0.00014553107030224055,
0.7629423141479492,
0.48890554904937744,
0.024212079122662544,
-0.03871139883995056,
-0.1357288956642151,
-0.146121084690094,
-0.24012428522109985,
0.5979953408241272,
0.3152725398540497,
0.03484193980693817,
0.6291108131408691,
0.4649883210659027,
0.7853922843933105,
0.035313669592142105,
-0.16314972937107086,
0.7584308981895447,
-0.27439358830451965,
0.00012376176891848445,
-1.0014195442199707,
-0.010382533073425293,
-0.1316940188407898,
-0.4630143642425537,
0.8405907154083252,
0.5128829479217529,
0.44135573506355286,
0.12957364320755005,
1.0925134420394897,
0.24153943359851837,
0.533255398273468,
-0.306496262550354,
0.975586473941803,
-0.4980693459510803,
0.3108086884021759,
-0.47158893942832947,
-0.5431892275810242,
-0.574518084526062,
0.2848148047924042,
-0.7191081643104553,
-0.10929881781339645,
0.7069365382194519,
0.5164608955383301,
0.37920597195625305,
0.14750778675079346,
0.30851659178733826,
0.2825436294078827,
0.30578818917274475,
0.1608959436416626,
0.8183491826057434,
-0.0073732915334403515,
0.5793715715408325,
0.05188414454460144,
-0.31259432435035706,
-0.3703806400299072,
-0.9662443399429321,
-0.7636697292327881,
-0.3662872910499573,
-0.21281184256076813,
-0.3764103949069977,
0.4210655689239502,
0.9992008209228516,
0.17239558696746826,
-0.5717566609382629,
-0.23397451639175415,
-0.12352925539016724,
-0.26329851150512695,
0.09675687551498413,
-0.2030497044324875,
0.46646586060523987,
-0.3985532224178314,
-0.7198511362075806,
0.22027412056922913,
0.3670230507850647,
0.17869190871715546,
-0.23638981580734253,
0.4228465259075165,
-0.4101257622241974,
0.42841771245002747,
0.6657244563102722,
0.3189780116081238,
-0.46763959527015686,
0.07936453819274902,
0.3395223617553711,
-0.4107368290424347,
0.27486345171928406,
0.6762407422065735,
-0.30081412196159363,
0.40060940384864807,
0.6322574019432068,
0.38796621561050415,
0.1514395922422409,
0.017415128648281097,
0.7991538047790527,
-0.6958081722259521,
-0.3805813789367676,
0.4814438819885254,
0.3748208284378052,
0.46311789751052856,
-0.3783625364303589,
0.4039362668991089,
0.2709134817123413,
-0.9997258186340332,
-0.8340744376182556,
-0.3165496289730072,
-0.6627628207206726,
-0.6226436495780945,
1.4224050045013428,
0.12397352606058121,
-0.21555200219154358,
-0.3700856566429138,
-0.2770179510116577,
0.15441879630088806,
-0.7116836905479431,
1.054992914199829,
1.0587983131408691,
-0.5028923153877258,
0.03828509896993637,
-0.8310677409172058,
0.7138636112213135,
0.42418092489242554,
-0.7658472657203674,
0.4055468738079071,
0.5977537035942078,
0.2786730229854584,
0.23353326320648193,
0.7554540038108826,
-0.19879020750522614,
0.10049979388713837,
-0.019843164831399918,
0.11738739907741547,
0.04253647103905678,
-0.14698447287082672,
-0.22823841869831085,
0.07104508578777313,
0.33408647775650024,
0.5017123818397522
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07012v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07012v2
|
Bridging Language Gaps in Audio-Text Retrieval
| 2024-06-11T07:12:12 | 2024-06-17T02:24:22 |
Zhiyong Yan, Heinrich Dinkel, Yongqing Wang, Jizhong Liu, Junbo Zhang, Yujun Wang, Bin Wang
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
Audio-text retrieval is a challenging task, requiring the search for an audio
clip or a text caption within a database. The predominant focus of existing
research on English descriptions poses a limitation on the applicability of
such models, given the abundance of non-English content in real-world data. To
address these linguistic disparities, we propose a language enhancement (LE),
using a multilingual text encoder (SONAR) to encode the text data with
language-specific information. Additionally, we optimize the audio encoder
through the application of consistent ensemble distillation (CED), enhancing
support for variable-length audio-text retrieval. Our methodology excels in
English audio-text retrieval, demonstrating state-of-the-art (SOTA) performance
on commonly used datasets such as AudioCaps and Clotho. Simultaneously, the
approach exhibits proficiency in retrieving content in seven other languages
with only 10% of additional language-enhanced training data, yielding promising
results. The source code is publicly available
https://github.com/zyyan4/ml-clap.
|
[
-0.47872206568717957,
-0.489000529050827,
0.4046420753002167,
0.4457199275493622,
-0.35681331157684326,
0.4033908545970917,
-0.3875633776187897,
-0.8014100193977356,
0.3686924874782562,
0.2706276774406433,
-0.2839929163455963,
-0.519325852394104,
-0.7657586336135864,
0.31991642713546753,
-0.4613649845123291,
0.7094536423683167,
0.33771878480911255,
0.037854474037885666,
0.06185144931077957,
-0.31679511070251465,
-0.5994032025337219,
-0.43454697728157043,
-0.6045343279838562,
-0.13166597485542297,
0.3583970069885254,
0.39711856842041016,
0.518642008304596,
0.5274384021759033,
0.4826716184616089,
0.17688614130020142,
-0.21809987723827362,
0.2970675528049469,
-0.2728436589241028,
0.3815743029117584,
0.10754726082086563,
-0.23973475396633148,
-0.43343037366867065,
-0.2686837911605835,
0.6596407890319824,
0.5456167459487915,
-0.12798359990119934,
-0.1293598860502243,
0.33545923233032227,
0.7260204553604126,
-0.8020972013473511,
0.1043272539973259,
-0.6019203066825867,
0.033225588500499725,
-0.44821885228157043,
-0.44215744733810425,
-0.22498749196529388,
-0.028144070878624916,
0.1777920126914978,
-0.5030887126922607,
0.02559899352490902,
-0.16659456491470337,
0.8368960022926331,
0.40094563364982605,
-0.2758336365222931,
-0.4401625096797943,
-0.7485084533691406,
0.7722616791725159,
-0.41844815015792847,
0.7542254328727722,
0.7697887420654297,
0.2875898480415344,
0.2484210878610611,
-0.4757395088672638,
-0.35907870531082153,
-0.021239427849650383,
0.06408900022506714,
0.32045990228652954,
-0.011116870678961277,
-0.09527123719453812,
-0.1655908077955246,
0.6685687899589539,
-0.621864914894104,
0.10362560302019119,
-0.39965158700942993,
-0.25086140632629395,
0.7925220727920532,
-0.27727264165878296,
0.3741320073604584,
0.11698798835277557,
-0.2225496619939804,
-0.16275368630886078,
-0.6371700763702393,
-0.15924952924251556,
0.38253751397132874,
0.5587318539619446,
-0.1619068831205368,
0.4651578664779663,
0.1321042776107788,
0.4233885109424591,
-0.23363487422466278,
-0.08808518201112747,
0.5250537395477295,
-0.19961152970790863,
0.23158681392669678,
0.5469413995742798,
0.5871319770812988,
0.24341674149036407,
0.025681467726826668,
-0.03978266194462776,
-0.4499315321445465,
-0.05027877539396286,
-0.26487383246421814,
-0.5296897888183594,
-0.07859217375516891,
0.23274599015712738,
-0.1744823008775711,
0.14463913440704346,
0.26922544836997986,
-0.9373378753662109,
-0.3987657427787781,
-0.022417182102799416,
0.47015658020973206,
-0.3489918112754822,
-0.3008553683757782,
0.331307590007782,
-0.4844458997249603,
-0.13739292323589325,
-0.21020370721817017,
-0.8089074492454529,
0.2646036148071289,
0.5141263008117676,
0.8767740726470947,
-0.15748141705989838,
-0.18048237264156342,
-0.802595317363739,
0.32994988560676575,
-0.05967477709054947,
0.5167519450187683,
-0.7994387745857239,
-0.6044962406158447,
0.1798093169927597,
-0.017142683267593384,
0.17490865290164948,
-0.7965147495269775,
0.8399508595466614,
-0.37609192728996277,
0.22114825248718262,
-0.0038914207834750414,
-0.6121217012405396,
0.07666641473770142,
-0.1847064197063446,
-0.9786320924758911,
1.1971551179885864,
-0.24230247735977173,
-0.7364568710327148,
0.29295802116394043,
-0.45342564582824707,
-0.6997187733650208,
0.05181735381484032,
-0.36304420232772827,
-0.3196089565753937,
0.009642370976507664,
0.6727380156517029,
0.24732856452465057,
-0.254134863615036,
0.03598878160119057,
0.1408465951681137,
-0.7443463206291199,
0.07248955219984055,
-0.6710237860679626,
0.5286955833435059,
0.35372331738471985,
-0.31891483068466187,
-0.46013331413269043,
-0.7371176481246948,
-0.4078812599182129,
-0.005324604921042919,
-0.6276435256004333,
-0.6971210837364197,
0.08132387697696686,
0.4409463107585907,
-0.246946319937706,
0.3576110899448395,
-0.5528424382209778,
-0.15578028559684753,
-0.43788114190101624,
0.2835130989551544,
0.4153363108634949,
-0.06161736324429512,
0.5964450836181641,
-0.31321102380752563,
0.6023968458175659,
-0.15792912244796753,
-0.26354941725730896,
-0.606799304485321,
-0.44029706716537476,
-0.2413383275270462,
-0.653014063835144,
0.49808475375175476,
0.7357913255691528,
-0.7512073516845703,
0.4717837870121002,
-0.16108940541744232,
-0.3031628131866455,
-1.2073707580566406,
0.10642791539430618,
0.478339821100235,
0.24564053118228912,
0.6669771075248718,
-0.3090706467628479,
-0.8574761152267456,
-0.7745938897132874,
-0.1996244341135025,
0.020225809887051582,
-0.3798052668571472,
0.33022046089172363,
-0.13891516625881195,
-0.28523579239845276,
0.785410463809967,
-0.3024767339229584,
-0.6341336965560913,
-0.27036887407302856,
0.10044901818037033,
0.4515567123889923,
0.4484066367149353,
0.3809017241001129,
-1.0051136016845703,
-0.6581351161003113,
0.13011333346366882,
-0.5081414580345154,
-0.5394641757011414,
-0.07995031774044037,
0.04984433576464653,
0.15113453567028046,
0.6041920185089111,
-0.3876694440841675,
0.1065940260887146,
0.7003671526908875,
0.0488661490380764,
0.30928346514701843,
-0.13747985661029816,
0.4399462044239044,
-0.9784297347068787,
-0.05125316604971886,
-0.047170985490083694,
-0.2947663962841034,
-0.43194618821144104,
-0.04403531178832054,
-0.015681767836213112,
0.06922321021556854,
-0.3072100877761841,
0.5600228309631348,
-0.6100583672523499,
-0.06050770729780197,
-0.4237915277481079,
0.6080865859985352,
0.0587875135242939,
0.04133760929107666,
0.1538899838924408,
0.8671735525131226,
0.830674946308136,
-0.6934870481491089,
0.02490662783384323,
0.23097611963748932,
-0.25886791944503784,
0.49340173602104187,
-0.5427500009536743,
0.20154957473278046,
-0.34219449758529663,
0.11066575348377228,
-0.7024109959602356,
-0.04846674203872681,
-0.35471904277801514,
-0.5414119958877563,
0.5871205925941467,
-0.36817115545272827,
-0.3536195456981659,
-0.20416764914989471,
-0.36735010147094727,
0.4948281943798065,
0.573646605014801,
-0.7545704245567322,
0.27032414078712463,
0.882464587688446,
-0.4362625181674957,
-0.8211984634399414,
-0.7118971347808838,
0.18794207274913788,
-0.3579292595386505,
-0.2864380478858948,
0.6042419075965881,
-0.1526680588722229,
-0.27616050839424133,
-0.26314079761505127,
-0.4194245934486389,
-0.35503581166267395,
0.005597642157226801,
-0.2184322327375412,
0.22095000743865967,
-0.15910249948501587,
0.3880845010280609,
0.31058844923973083,
-0.07386678457260132,
-0.27437615394592285,
-0.34155938029289246,
0.5622707605361938,
0.039588384330272675,
-0.19723501801490784,
-0.2828233242034912,
0.5138740539550781,
0.3711281418800354,
-0.3780733048915863,
0.3352168798446655,
0.7159832715988159,
-0.346660315990448,
-0.09496551752090454,
-0.471037894487381,
-0.3630642890930176,
-0.48916399478912354,
0.5183961391448975,
-0.49979305267333984,
-1.1430163383483887,
0.39702197909355164,
0.10610023140907288,
-0.05385218560695648,
0.3089914619922638,
0.19394551217556,
-0.38538774847984314,
1.0552819967269897,
0.6317288875579834,
-0.35378730297088623,
0.35440248250961304,
-0.0516035370528698,
0.029954571276903152,
-0.6455215811729431,
-0.09525049477815628,
-0.7745378017425537,
-0.12802445888519287,
-0.6364666819572449,
-0.36698246002197266,
0.3263535797595978,
0.17440934479236603,
0.21043874323368073,
0.48666560649871826,
-0.5657626986503601,
0.6781705617904663,
0.3034469485282898,
-0.041313547641038895,
0.45774132013320923,
0.1541312336921692,
-0.04800516366958618,
-0.3880092203617096,
-0.5979616641998291,
-0.3920557498931885,
0.7961781024932861,
0.39432379603385925,
0.5434764623641968,
0.2753557562828064,
0.8304802179336548,
0.3529227674007416,
-0.32900726795196533,
-0.5046670436859131,
0.2557655870914459,
-0.38667091727256775,
-0.4918818175792694,
-0.3570590019226074,
-0.4479844570159912,
-1.2726011276245117,
0.40511706471443176,
-0.18236692249774933,
-0.5672399997711182,
0.16098612546920776,
-0.03733905404806137,
-0.06058502942323685,
-0.03610718250274658,
-0.3913673162460327,
0.3833758533000946,
-0.1841256022453308,
-0.3042638599872589,
-0.20637503266334534,
-0.37931492924690247,
-0.07820308953523636,
-0.399038165807724,
0.8227325081825256,
-0.13896748423576355,
-0.147756427526474,
0.46221837401390076,
-0.18839986622333527,
0.38070064783096313,
-0.26364701986312866,
-0.42752277851104736,
0.30149027705192566,
-0.12803126871585846,
0.2859305441379547,
0.16502907872200012,
-0.08615361899137497,
0.14091341197490692,
-0.05555756390094757,
-0.38909170031547546,
-0.4101213216781616,
0.5875962972640991,
-0.4813949763774872,
-0.3093629479408264,
-0.03119450993835926,
-0.3813440799713135,
-0.30290842056274414,
-0.050246987491846085,
0.26599207520484924,
0.3990701138973236,
-0.13378740847110748,
0.38614848256111145,
0.619121789932251,
-0.4142882823944092,
0.7536138296127319,
0.6476094722747803,
-0.2846035659313202,
-0.32643067836761475,
1.0225259065628052,
-0.027354108169674873,
-0.006182615179568529,
0.7300792932510376,
0.13013848662376404,
-0.5116297006607056,
-0.3684101402759552,
-0.4424835741519928,
-0.003776741912588477,
-0.3927174508571625,
-0.07472028583288193,
-0.6342059373855591,
-0.08430153876543045,
-0.28130048513412476,
-0.041956912726163864,
-0.5654558539390564,
-0.551560640335083,
-0.058863021433353424,
-0.2665959596633911,
0.4513091742992401,
0.3215942978858948,
-0.332107275724411,
0.11903918534517288,
-1.248500108718872,
0.2792474925518036,
0.030410446226596832,
0.2011127769947052,
-0.3074789047241211,
-0.7272124290466309,
-0.6974968314170837,
-0.009195848368108273,
0.046046074479818344,
-0.9980444312095642,
0.5398606657981873,
0.6887082457542419,
0.6773973107337952,
0.07906726002693176,
0.2183321714401245,
0.6857175230979919,
-0.6837505102157593,
0.6959240436553955,
0.11173027008771896,
-0.9319462180137634,
0.8121663331985474,
-0.30196651816368103,
0.4081721603870392,
0.5870810151100159,
0.43703266978263855,
-0.4443035423755646,
-0.7949851751327515,
-0.24996213614940643,
-1.4009358882904053,
0.2988823354244232,
0.5253745913505554,
0.3500882387161255,
-0.19619043171405792,
0.018891744315624237,
0.24840642511844635,
0.08258162438869476,
-0.48481717705726624,
-0.28702080249786377,
-0.0459795817732811,
-0.36613765358924866,
-0.1996566504240036,
-0.02040659636259079,
0.14320962131023407,
-0.10900123417377472,
0.7521374821662903,
0.025844227522611618,
0.13060607016086578,
0.5170766115188599,
-0.40942221879959106,
0.27164357900619507,
0.5520215630531311,
0.2777319848537445,
0.15731677412986755,
-0.16625355184078217,
0.3663421869277954,
0.24645695090293884,
-0.8428279757499695,
0.07127148658037186,
0.3883688449859619,
0.18180039525032043,
0.3950960338115692,
0.34580546617507935,
0.4479057788848877,
0.2974279224872589,
-1.0988856554031372,
0.3847798705101013,
-0.07191402465105057,
0.08644615113735199,
-0.25066840648651123,
-0.26880401372909546,
0.024365326389670372,
0.3067109286785126,
0.9291503429412842,
-0.3010684847831726,
0.5943865180015564,
-0.4589079022407532,
0.6454660892486572,
0.04468076303601265,
-0.6318686008453369,
-0.08264125883579254,
0.826210618019104,
0.23272119462490082,
-0.3759015202522278,
0.4002991020679474,
-0.10614337772130966,
-0.22956667840480804,
0.5862078666687012,
0.541586697101593,
0.8052769899368286,
-0.3953079879283905,
-0.06234721839427948,
0.2971610128879547,
0.408783495426178,
-0.09092672169208527,
0.5196705460548401,
-0.12338530272245407,
-0.5938873887062073,
-0.6650969982147217,
-0.6493548154830933,
-0.24581694602966309,
0.013158057816326618,
-0.8082057237625122,
0.32974135875701904,
0.07201895117759705,
-0.2365395724773407,
-0.23743024468421936,
-0.24883513152599335,
-0.4282870888710022,
-0.026269664987921715,
0.32986822724342346,
0.8349815607070923,
-0.7076116800308228,
0.801891028881073,
0.5643509030342102,
-0.43952301144599915,
-0.5624621510505676,
0.09152144938707352,
0.03608211874961853,
-0.3162086308002472,
0.287080317735672,
0.22361856698989868,
-0.16404257714748383,
-0.14332106709480286,
-0.15393826365470886,
-0.5966046452522278,
0.8838576674461365,
0.47003060579299927,
-1.0789039134979248,
0.4612487256526947,
0.1517389416694641,
0.6310507655143738,
-0.3309668302536011,
0.2763577401638031,
0.6927928328514099,
0.4873875379562378,
-0.17749305069446564,
-1.3114535808563232,
-0.41395315527915955,
-0.40778547525405884,
-0.25183403491973877,
0.08666665107011795,
-0.24082839488983154,
0.44900983572006226,
0.07672525942325592,
-0.16767702996730804,
-0.051568128168582916,
0.6298484206199646,
0.580015242099762,
0.49635976552963257,
0.42257025837898254,
0.2688935697078705,
1.0018823146820068,
-0.1148901954293251,
0.9672680497169495,
-0.4938107430934906,
0.1625155359506607,
1.24812912940979,
-0.19683828949928284,
1.1055479049682617,
0.5747959613800049,
-0.08115261793136597,
0.3445488512516022,
0.5118454694747925,
0.21080946922302246,
0.6878289580345154,
-0.000653151364531368,
-0.6308446526527405,
-0.018972227349877357,
-0.32834044098854065,
-0.3981715738773346,
0.6511209011077881,
0.34310638904571533,
-0.20072564482688904,
0.19048622250556946,
0.3141394257545471,
-0.06336724758148193,
0.5740359425544739,
-0.22142434120178223,
0.6426973342895508,
0.19656188786029816,
-0.18338464200496674,
0.3926476836204529,
-0.19234460592269897,
1.0623996257781982,
-0.23869207501411438,
-0.25597554445266724,
-0.30620595812797546,
-0.06409140676259995,
-0.1766497641801834,
-0.6677521467208862,
0.41427916288375854,
0.08787603676319122,
-0.2380540519952774,
-0.22921237349510193,
0.5830007791519165,
-0.9023463129997253,
-0.2326010763645172,
0.7774718999862671,
0.5450770258903503,
0.4499856233596802,
-0.10127295553684235,
-0.4880602955818176,
0.22688299417495728,
-0.04555480182170868,
0.18007628619670868,
0.13869719207286835,
0.432930588722229,
0.08048207312822342,
0.27544480562210083,
0.40305477380752563,
0.14387883245944977,
0.07747150957584381,
0.6512745022773743,
0.5582137107849121,
-0.3615206778049469,
-0.6045269966125488,
-0.8309323787689209,
0.5362792611122131,
-0.1500011384487152,
0.25294095277786255,
0.7057636976242065,
1.0917754173278809,
1.070499062538147,
-0.05939529836177826,
0.9912779927253723,
0.07092992216348648,
0.6625030636787415,
-0.6079069375991821,
0.8288045525550842,
-0.6761470437049866,
0.8180406093597412,
-0.3887786269187927,
-1.1617951393127441,
-0.2426251471042633,
0.6159488558769226,
0.2972983419895172,
-0.11269277334213257,
0.5442537069320679,
0.8932868242263794,
-0.1349949687719345,
-0.05813572183251381,
0.3872728645801544,
0.12643559277057648,
0.141209676861763,
0.32508569955825806,
0.8966421484947205,
-0.6691126823425293,
0.763726532459259,
0.021428672596812248,
-0.18510548770427704,
0.07732902467250824,
-0.5804840922355652,
-0.48654428124427795,
-0.7357544302940369,
-0.3631742298603058,
-0.10610654950141907,
0.3489401042461395,
0.7906677722930908,
0.6104753017425537,
-0.7121421694755554,
-0.3441442847251892,
0.18939252197742462,
0.05048854276537895,
-0.22598037123680115,
-0.25311344861984253,
0.24922287464141846,
-0.3991950452327728,
-1.1972116231918335,
1.0455522537231445,
0.43076106905937195,
-0.0200596172362566,
0.03672241419553757,
-0.44493424892425537,
-0.132229745388031,
0.10035721957683563,
0.5734682083129883,
0.25623688101768494,
-0.31256699562072754,
-0.12541791796684265,
0.06100688502192497,
-0.012214401736855507,
0.10931801050901413,
0.6347836256027222,
-0.7233197093009949,
0.49777719378471375,
0.3956068456172943,
0.7845958471298218,
0.680598795413971,
-0.40550774335861206,
0.6919288635253906,
-1.3197606801986694,
0.38126492500305176,
0.3396006226539612,
0.4617891013622284,
0.539697527885437,
-0.29358339309692383,
0.6670437455177307,
0.000946897896938026,
-0.39420169591903687,
-0.8371082544326782,
-0.02124328911304474,
-0.7482821941375732,
-0.3285602927207947,
1.0012739896774292,
-0.06880118697881699,
0.18414445221424103,
-0.38216298818588257,
-0.428297758102417,
0.20825712382793427,
-0.5739326477050781,
0.7451241612434387,
0.5058867931365967,
0.24062928557395935,
-0.4636439383029938,
-0.7086699604988098,
0.4676937758922577,
0.5284702181816101,
-0.3300851583480835,
-0.14324219524860382,
0.47996219992637634,
-0.15440163016319275,
0.171611949801445,
0.770910382270813,
-0.3787461221218109,
0.2780817449092865,
-0.051273148506879807,
0.16328886151313782,
0.15431781113147736,
-0.39820972084999084,
-0.4894092082977295,
0.009584142826497555,
0.029656607657670975,
-0.3228473663330078
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07007v1
|
Crayon: Customized On-Device LLM via Instant Adapter Blending and Edge-Server Hybrid Inference
| 2024-06-11T07:00:08 | 2024-06-11T07:00:08 |
Jihwan Bang, Juntae Lee, Kyuhong Shim, Seunghan Yang, Simyung Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The customization of large language models (LLMs) for user-specified tasks
gets important. However, maintaining all the customized LLMs on cloud servers
incurs substantial memory and computational overheads, and uploading user data
can also lead to privacy concerns. On-device LLMs can offer a promising
solution by mitigating these issues. Yet, the performance of on-device LLMs is
inherently constrained by the limitations of small-scaled models. To overcome
these restrictions, we first propose Crayon, a novel approach for on-device LLM
customization. Crayon begins by constructing a pool of diverse base adapters,
and then we instantly blend them into a customized adapter without extra
training. In addition, we develop a device-server hybrid inference strategy,
which deftly allocates more demanding queries or non-customized tasks to a
larger, more capable LLM on a server. This ensures optimal performance without
sacrificing the benefits of on-device customization. We carefully craft a novel
benchmark from multiple question-answer datasets, and show the efficacy of our
method in the LLM customization.
|
[
-0.4658748507499695,
-0.9515188932418823,
0.4957841634750366,
0.05802091956138611,
-0.17742928862571716,
0.41674479842185974,
-0.4299744665622711,
-0.45363685488700867,
0.3999148905277252,
0.6540486812591553,
-0.6128162741661072,
-0.40981656312942505,
-0.3287179172039032,
-0.21777379512786865,
-0.23539908230304718,
0.6364657282829285,
0.22402292490005493,
-0.2988028824329376,
-0.2617207467556,
-0.14685282111167908,
-0.22665375471115112,
-0.1003563404083252,
-0.46553024649620056,
-0.19825968146324158,
0.3646116256713867,
0.8082393407821655,
0.7905243635177612,
1.1051322221755981,
0.2570081353187561,
0.33864206075668335,
0.045886095613241196,
0.3685561716556549,
-0.5232275128364563,
0.21356122195720673,
-0.0005881590186618268,
-0.6172140836715698,
-0.4359198212623596,
-0.20639418065547943,
0.1759219914674759,
0.6293960809707642,
-0.2322644740343094,
0.1342698484659195,
0.026863807812333107,
0.4312647879123688,
-0.6917626857757568,
-0.23534147441387177,
-1.0908397436141968,
0.23423153162002563,
-0.17495223879814148,
-0.03332944214344025,
-0.3266203999519348,
-0.3888111412525177,
0.1346500962972641,
-0.775539755821228,
0.6777055263519287,
-0.01816100999712944,
0.5670714974403381,
0.14417338371276855,
-0.43102025985717773,
0.03588973730802536,
-0.9013624787330627,
0.8399782776832581,
-0.6970047354698181,
0.5337145328521729,
0.24342463910579681,
0.4625737965106964,
-0.09134304523468018,
-1.1048892736434937,
-0.7238423228263855,
0.029066747054457664,
0.19013658165931702,
0.07631800323724747,
0.24402959644794464,
0.09231814742088318,
-0.021295076236128807,
0.34386715292930603,
-0.41347798705101013,
0.216501384973526,
0.0907660499215126,
-0.2681352198123932,
0.4955749213695526,
0.2709122896194458,
0.5387279987335205,
0.3216295838356018,
-0.2102753072977066,
0.27935826778411865,
-0.9050390720367432,
-0.0017829586286097765,
0.23037220537662506,
0.2117343693971634,
-0.001496636657975614,
0.5345520377159119,
-0.31218597292900085,
0.766464352607727,
0.3299754858016968,
-0.24632468819618225,
-0.055458858609199524,
-0.33914321660995483,
-0.12246100604534149,
0.26890403032302856,
0.7400557398796082,
0.5190480351448059,
0.005915451794862747,
-0.35239338874816895,
-0.0603543184697628,
-0.1981155276298523,
0.07258597016334534,
-1.035689353942871,
-0.5600934624671936,
0.29914745688438416,
-0.28021910786628723,
-0.07900140434503555,
-0.36536508798599243,
-1.1990994215011597,
-0.8395810127258301,
-0.10429508984088898,
-0.045086514204740524,
-0.1422256976366043,
0.034300703555345535,
-0.07335655391216278,
0.2153739333152771,
0.1246187686920166,
0.3447037935256958,
-1.2809284925460815,
0.4986811578273773,
0.6097228527069092,
1.0058950185775757,
-0.5056569576263428,
-0.10068411380052567,
-0.3203974664211273,
0.2667953073978424,
-0.1476198136806488,
0.8407958745956421,
-0.6126667261123657,
-0.5444878339767456,
0.007977710105478764,
-0.1034427285194397,
-0.33484330773353577,
-0.7504664659500122,
0.1903623789548874,
-0.6629601120948792,
0.1184338703751564,
-0.09612520784139633,
-0.6002039313316345,
0.1189604327082634,
0.03186958283185959,
-0.5253943204879761,
0.8470184803009033,
0.0893380418419838,
-0.45359450578689575,
0.25353163480758667,
-0.3801965117454529,
-0.667782723903656,
0.29729998111724854,
-0.30071476101875305,
-0.48016342520713806,
-0.012408273294568062,
0.2921251952648163,
0.19962045550346375,
-0.4953077435493469,
-0.11746916174888611,
-0.6056203842163086,
-0.2846742868423462,
0.24705171585083008,
-0.004742769990116358,
0.8400817513465881,
0.26842567324638367,
-0.4051397442817688,
0.0688050240278244,
-0.6913918852806091,
0.4105609953403473,
0.035902220755815506,
-0.47848498821258545,
0.048255402594804764,
0.016312558203935623,
0.09412439167499542,
-0.07763713598251343,
0.5914795398712158,
-0.8352600336074829,
-0.02273174375295639,
-0.06022155284881592,
0.8950484991073608,
0.6665167212486267,
-0.24348238110542297,
0.7282987833023071,
-0.33904415369033813,
0.6186349987983704,
-0.34965288639068604,
0.21513178944587708,
-0.24801698327064514,
-0.6354299187660217,
-0.9563730359077454,
-0.5497812032699585,
0.26369673013687134,
0.7840358018875122,
-0.5472978949546814,
0.36539381742477417,
-0.341179221868515,
-0.4975062310695648,
-0.5401426553726196,
0.4843255281448364,
0.12201470881700516,
0.7577487826347351,
0.21735882759094238,
-0.29445645213127136,
-0.505830705165863,
-0.8489097356796265,
-0.46591421961784363,
0.0847267359495163,
-0.1960732340812683,
0.7724972367286682,
-0.10866061598062515,
-0.29295533895492554,
1.2115775346755981,
-0.493225634098053,
-0.3922056257724762,
-0.4651711583137512,
-0.318559467792511,
0.02695060521364212,
0.32647567987442017,
0.33937373757362366,
-0.7643240094184875,
-0.7581171989440918,
0.2780487835407257,
-0.37237104773521423,
-0.4537188410758972,
-0.20476089417934418,
0.08952226489782333,
-0.013805530965328217,
0.44073665142059326,
-0.5498409271240234,
0.1521952748298645,
0.6023828983306885,
-0.16175208985805511,
0.4300277829170227,
-0.5097827315330505,
0.156219020485878,
-0.7987064123153687,
-0.46050411462783813,
0.05822599679231644,
-0.2989948093891144,
-0.6968296766281128,
-0.04999357461929321,
0.3010793924331665,
-0.15952575206756592,
-0.621604323387146,
0.6543602347373962,
-0.42060983180999756,
0.026115035638213158,
-0.2554135322570801,
0.27106282114982605,
0.15284094214439392,
0.3225628137588501,
-0.16714440286159515,
0.8888115286827087,
0.4190332293510437,
-0.5909181833267212,
0.3827997148036957,
0.00789837446063757,
-0.19441387057304382,
0.5117002129554749,
-0.6722390055656433,
0.28068092465400696,
0.1332719326019287,
0.11764755100011826,
-1.1182563304901123,
-0.17491403222084045,
-0.053586386144161224,
0.006423255428671837,
-0.14754916727542877,
-0.24420224130153656,
-0.5537648797035217,
-0.08776339143514633,
-0.38708359003067017,
0.4233240485191345,
0.8818327188491821,
-0.8872116208076477,
1.2094082832336426,
0.5484850406646729,
-0.18760377168655396,
0.022393522784113884,
-0.9869211912155151,
0.20140579342842102,
-0.4223070442676544,
-0.8198646306991577,
0.8568647503852844,
-0.4119226634502411,
0.040382057428359985,
-0.132208913564682,
-0.020833062008023262,
-0.4244483411312103,
0.03472427651286125,
0.3324177861213684,
0.19831092655658722,
-0.554209291934967,
-0.3374616503715515,
0.1602286547422409,
0.16023239493370056,
-0.29640716314315796,
-0.06755023449659348,
0.5174635052680969,
0.039710432291030884,
-0.4733172357082367,
-0.524151623249054,
0.06785494834184647,
0.434690922498703,
-0.21819770336151123,
0.43344417214393616,
0.42862406373023987,
-0.2654772102832794,
-0.6835278868675232,
-0.6620896458625793,
-0.25092989206314087,
-0.6466874480247498,
0.38337939977645874,
-0.3225768208503723,
-0.892950713634491,
0.703010618686676,
-0.2744186818599701,
0.00849702674895525,
-0.2160615622997284,
0.5882190465927124,
-0.133535698056221,
1.022847056388855,
0.4896700978279114,
0.03775961324572563,
0.9055794477462769,
-0.11327702552080154,
0.3538907766342163,
-0.8499301075935364,
-0.2805030643939972,
-0.23599129915237427,
-0.4906381666660309,
-0.5481466054916382,
-0.39824178814888,
0.20735260844230652,
-0.002385791391134262,
-0.3008820414543152,
0.25801995396614075,
-0.4297647476196289,
0.832440197467804,
0.5157386064529419,
0.5008114576339722,
0.44591307640075684,
0.19376088678836823,
-0.12480609118938446,
-0.28960779309272766,
-0.8075954914093018,
-0.37124598026275635,
1.0517748594284058,
0.11074035614728928,
0.7751995921134949,
0.13533319532871246,
0.5345121622085571,
0.29704201221466064,
0.30326536297798157,
-0.6151026487350464,
0.9221748113632202,
-0.3500458896160126,
-0.38877296447753906,
-0.006711791735142469,
-0.29666388034820557,
-0.9403955340385437,
0.594489336013794,
-0.10488323122262955,
-0.9401022791862488,
0.1709413379430771,
0.4207291901111603,
-0.3428523540496826,
0.49145910143852234,
-0.8843654990196228,
0.7747030854225159,
-0.4711463749408722,
-0.47125503420829773,
-0.15913860499858856,
-0.16804474592208862,
0.34313079714775085,
-0.025624211877584457,
0.13620586693286896,
-0.12681004405021667,
-0.5887515544891357,
0.513862133026123,
-0.6100208163261414,
1.0140832662582397,
-0.03205304592847824,
0.34663552045822144,
0.4755796492099762,
0.41525399684906006,
0.47279754281044006,
-0.03186483681201935,
-0.16720661520957947,
-0.024671202525496483,
-0.3199661374092102,
-0.43732982873916626,
-0.6654321551322937,
1.1168798208236694,
-0.6471387147903442,
-0.6585416197776794,
-0.050858091562986374,
-0.7950952649116516,
-0.39797553420066833,
0.48761484026908875,
0.20102284848690033,
0.2774266302585602,
-0.10465355962514877,
0.13593630492687225,
0.8268218040466309,
-0.3017656207084656,
0.5139215588569641,
0.5947723388671875,
-0.24128687381744385,
-0.6057732105255127,
1.0908927917480469,
0.07013188302516937,
0.39077720046043396,
0.06752806901931763,
0.4092252552509308,
-0.26742565631866455,
-0.6789408922195435,
-0.9761238694190979,
0.20236489176750183,
-0.6930556297302246,
0.22916045784950256,
-0.7157851457595825,
0.05418940633535385,
-0.1879730224609375,
-0.41477838158607483,
-0.4610181152820587,
-0.4410226345062256,
-0.4810943603515625,
0.12478000670671463,
0.4247400760650635,
0.3702206611633301,
0.34577852487564087,
0.8503229022026062,
-0.525507926940918,
0.3964376747608185,
0.35621267557144165,
0.4265666902065277,
0.05768303573131561,
-0.711618959903717,
-0.09338449686765671,
0.13625741004943848,
-0.44178149104118347,
-0.5856975317001343,
0.12189719080924988,
0.645154595375061,
0.5592970252037048,
0.5055249929428101,
0.02045956626534462,
0.7824723124504089,
-0.5914291143417358,
0.7507563829421997,
0.1271853893995285,
-0.7468054294586182,
0.25892266631126404,
-0.23814506828784943,
0.1802651435136795,
0.49182361364364624,
0.08456261456012726,
-0.45230481028556824,
-0.25180724263191223,
-0.4477453827857971,
-0.9953226447105408,
0.49046289920806885,
-0.21291467547416687,
0.3208754062652588,
0.28023144602775574,
0.36385881900787354,
-0.023762911558151245,
0.17460288107395172,
-0.4758076071739197,
-0.35940611362457275,
-0.07451029121875763,
-0.42464563250541687,
0.06925533711910248,
0.026275647804141045,
-0.10071705281734467,
-0.2437213957309723,
0.2799730896949768,
-0.08525218814611435,
0.08790445327758789,
-0.11617711931467056,
-0.39882683753967285,
-0.009856685064733028,
-0.15769878029823303,
0.37665432691574097,
0.5628921389579773,
0.08371052891016006,
0.2586125135421753,
0.40328142046928406,
-0.514299213886261,
0.033331431448459625,
0.06507482379674911,
-0.5161500573158264,
-0.182998389005661,
0.20357641577720642,
0.5301093459129333,
0.043537687510252,
-0.8162890076637268,
0.28825893998146057,
-0.133597731590271,
0.2564196288585663,
-0.12233931571245193,
0.5027258992195129,
0.3759137690067291,
0.1387549191713333,
0.1739536076784134,
-0.054336901754140854,
-0.0156065933406353,
-0.34593403339385986,
0.11131106317043304,
0.44368624687194824,
-0.36021196842193604,
-0.30206364393234253,
0.8269181847572327,
0.1719478964805603,
-0.6828200221061707,
0.39906859397888184,
0.021382901817560196,
-0.5066022276878357,
0.8920473456382751,
0.8347504734992981,
0.8315104842185974,
-0.32654035091400146,
0.2703962028026581,
-0.09885391592979431,
0.2394244223833084,
0.08482874184846878,
0.1791936457157135,
-0.06323204189538956,
-0.8240711092948914,
0.03010396845638752,
-0.1794593185186386,
-0.5933047533035278,
0.092259980738163,
-0.081917904317379,
0.19371524453163147,
-0.8922570943832397,
-0.13282938301563263,
-0.2207985371351242,
-0.29556360840797424,
-0.6924208402633667,
0.1897052675485611,
-0.005569320172071457,
0.7049367427825928,
-0.5901948809623718,
0.7821623682975769,
0.5560863614082336,
-0.028539296239614487,
-0.3595737814903259,
-0.19891615211963654,
-0.0009735060739330947,
-0.8850878477096558,
0.19193197786808014,
0.023827338591217995,
-0.1330331265926361,
0.06211119517683983,
-0.046143967658281326,
-0.6583718061447144,
1.1665397882461548,
0.5187267661094666,
-0.5193836688995361,
0.2888334393501282,
0.7807297110557556,
0.4629990756511688,
-0.6183006763458252,
0.4911963939666748,
0.5964869856834412,
0.27453604340553284,
-0.17381086945533752,
-0.6857607960700989,
0.13158312439918518,
-0.057617902755737305,
0.24848990142345428,
-0.04644618555903435,
-0.6226191520690918,
0.9217493534088135,
-0.44340935349464417,
-0.1828676164150238,
-0.05392942950129509,
0.5771569609642029,
0.3338111937046051,
0.35311225056648254,
0.5808103680610657,
0.3937549293041229,
0.8176677823066711,
0.0839940682053566,
1.002666711807251,
-0.629281759262085,
0.0922853946685791,
1.1783181428909302,
-0.47496095299720764,
0.6282358765602112,
0.3925993740558624,
-0.18007294833660126,
0.2739301919937134,
0.9018383026123047,
0.14991648495197296,
0.6360868215560913,
0.2698359489440918,
-0.7130064368247986,
-0.3168903589248657,
-0.27870166301727295,
-0.05548069626092911,
-0.18101438879966736,
0.3249952495098114,
-0.2624252140522003,
-0.17130166292190552,
-0.05079853534698486,
-0.13999050855636597,
0.2341705858707428,
-0.19763566553592682,
0.6367156505584717,
0.11419989168643951,
-0.407514750957489,
0.440182626247406,
0.14258208870887756,
0.8665183782577515,
-0.3128768503665924,
0.15072347223758698,
-0.43756720423698425,
0.39848634600639343,
-0.4627934992313385,
-0.538321316242218,
-0.12104560434818268,
-0.18976937234401703,
-0.05526214465498924,
-0.18179123103618622,
0.7969467639923096,
-0.5276999473571777,
-0.519198477268219,
0.28284773230552673,
0.44353801012039185,
-0.15837344527244568,
0.19007325172424316,
-0.7216482162475586,
0.17278027534484863,
0.0899011567234993,
-0.3803686499595642,
0.5544379353523254,
0.5318419933319092,
0.06205553561449051,
1.0990698337554932,
0.7898165583610535,
0.3252709209918976,
0.6545855402946472,
-0.06969711929559708,
0.8411710262298584,
-0.3551274538040161,
-0.6220008134841919,
-0.8730522394180298,
0.3063865303993225,
-0.023759527131915092,
-0.28897908329963684,
0.7160546183586121,
0.8798106908798218,
0.74358731508255,
-0.1014205813407898,
1.020400047302246,
-0.0765785500407219,
0.23779946565628052,
-0.2109202742576599,
0.7123005390167236,
-0.47827449440956116,
0.48789846897125244,
0.20015458762645721,
-0.9500796794891357,
-0.2711515724658966,
0.45248836278915405,
-0.3430822789669037,
0.1850200742483139,
0.43092384934425354,
1.1695855855941772,
-0.7277619242668152,
0.17544183135032654,
0.22567735612392426,
-0.12078863382339478,
0.4858049154281616,
0.3505476713180542,
0.5054454207420349,
-0.23490025103092194,
0.6838440299034119,
-0.6876357197761536,
-0.2690679430961609,
-0.3890360891819,
-1.0470519065856934,
-0.8638814687728882,
-0.275417685508728,
-0.49048203229904175,
-0.3519386649131775,
-0.04953278973698616,
0.7701096534729004,
0.8465861082077026,
-0.8545849323272705,
-0.5718573331832886,
-0.12939943373203278,
0.2611989974975586,
-0.011791342869400978,
-0.1817149966955185,
0.3418053388595581,
0.029346391558647156,
-0.7212269306182861,
0.4493137001991272,
-0.007761996239423752,
-0.005932333879172802,
-0.01301833800971508,
-0.11975623667240143,
0.2780694365501404,
0.18600496649742126,
0.47010645270347595,
0.44790685176849365,
-0.6444407105445862,
-0.08643699437379837,
0.0629628598690033,
-0.21595264971256256,
0.35314005613327026,
1.0585129261016846,
-0.7119432091712952,
0.5454106330871582,
0.43977469205856323,
1.1873774528503418,
0.6441130638122559,
-0.07098526507616043,
0.28510263562202454,
-0.37238773703575134,
0.06092594191431999,
0.19286894798278809,
0.478989839553833,
0.39180511236190796,
-0.33375266194343567,
0.04263465479016304,
0.16246317327022552,
-0.5472301840782166,
-0.8231915235519409,
0.5226631164550781,
-0.9048712253570557,
-0.06899780035018921,
1.0274543762207031,
-0.17997421324253082,
-0.4577994644641876,
-0.23209308087825775,
-0.047878995537757874,
0.0009109628153964877,
-0.40052133798599243,
0.834193766117096,
0.2317444384098053,
-0.43316739797592163,
-0.44881942868232727,
-0.48860466480255127,
0.2337212860584259,
0.49493029713630676,
-0.8449501991271973,
0.012411216273903847,
0.23565196990966797,
0.7157213091850281,
-0.20259211957454681,
0.6272379159927368,
0.19773463904857635,
0.13882392644882202,
-0.1739199012517929,
0.16746537387371063,
-0.21910148859024048,
-0.0908730998635292,
-0.006029187701642513,
0.1306459605693817,
0.09952295571565628,
-0.3180740773677826
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07001v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07001v1
|
Mitigating Boundary Ambiguity and Inherent Bias for Text Classification in the Era of Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T06:53:19 | 2024-06-11T06:53:19 |
Zhenyi Lu, Jie Tian, Wei Wei, Xiaoye Qu, Yu Cheng, Wenfeng xie, Dangyang Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Text classification is a crucial task encountered frequently in practical
scenarios, yet it is still under-explored in the era of large language models
(LLMs). This study shows that LLMs are vulnerable to changes in the number and
arrangement of options in text classification. Our extensive empirical analyses
reveal that the key bottleneck arises from ambiguous decision boundaries and
inherent biases towards specific tokens and positions. To mitigate these
issues, we make the first attempt and propose a novel two-stage classification
framework for LLMs. Our approach is grounded in the empirical observation that
pairwise comparisons can effectively alleviate boundary ambiguity and inherent
bias. Specifically, we begin with a self-reduction technique to efficiently
narrow down numerous options, which contributes to reduced decision space and a
faster comparison process. Subsequently, pairwise contrastive comparisons are
employed in a chain-of-thought manner to draw out nuances and distinguish
confusable options, thus refining the ambiguous decision boundary. Extensive
experiments on four datasets (Banking77, HWU64, LIU54, and Clinic150) verify
the effectiveness of our framework. Furthermore, benefitting from our
framework, various LLMs can achieve consistent improvements. Our code and data
are available in \url{https://github.com/Chuge0335/PC-CoT}.
|
[
-0.29003289341926575,
-0.7153986096382141,
0.5912867188453674,
0.37378937005996704,
-0.24379873275756836,
0.26710250973701477,
-0.33976995944976807,
-0.6883607506752014,
-0.38072341680526733,
0.7864024043083191,
-0.25762075185775757,
-0.45334741473197937,
-0.651907205581665,
0.07225670665502548,
-0.2201666235923767,
0.9730133414268494,
-0.18577691912651062,
-0.004783620126545429,
-0.2770128548145294,
-0.19157972931861877,
-0.5580299496650696,
-0.6585184931755066,
-0.7940992712974548,
-0.5679410099983215,
0.3548676073551178,
0.2865763306617737,
0.3916046917438507,
0.5162243247032166,
0.5910505652427673,
0.31001991033554077,
-0.2746124565601349,
0.38476821780204773,
-0.22056452929973602,
0.3251420557498932,
-0.09585803002119064,
-0.4731682538986206,
-0.2821482717990875,
-0.09645666927099228,
0.6741499900817871,
0.6305199265480042,
0.08509810268878937,
0.06806009262800217,
0.2965027093887329,
0.6647415161132812,
-0.6399996280670166,
-0.09556660056114197,
-0.653404951095581,
0.14862683415412903,
-0.5040695071220398,
-0.19141077995300293,
-0.799968957901001,
0.1439364105463028,
0.12704278528690338,
-0.13092690706253052,
0.23691850900650024,
0.044303130358457565,
0.45981815457344055,
0.32374680042266846,
-0.6671192646026611,
-0.11599210649728775,
-0.5962198376655579,
0.8069671988487244,
-0.503037691116333,
0.5785503387451172,
0.2454693615436554,
0.15810231864452362,
-0.17737841606140137,
-0.6168084144592285,
-0.32379046082496643,
0.14874157309532166,
0.01738814264535904,
-0.08520984649658203,
-0.15697520971298218,
0.23640578985214233,
0.13912273943424225,
0.16089266538619995,
-0.5523597598075867,
0.6955671310424805,
-0.3011011481285095,
-0.4169977903366089,
0.5612986087799072,
-0.052971988916397095,
0.11553168296813965,
-0.15072515606880188,
-0.6859245896339417,
0.02854543924331665,
-0.6558822393417358,
-0.009150531142950058,
0.2791944742202759,
0.3313039541244507,
-0.0692373588681221,
0.33973443508148193,
-0.015296578407287598,
0.6210887432098389,
0.17999546229839325,
-0.0792977511882782,
0.3253716826438904,
0.009121368639171124,
-0.28563857078552246,
0.22993206977844238,
0.7766562700271606,
0.43912485241889954,
-0.1823078840970993,
-0.07357358932495117,
-0.21200504899024963,
0.11509140580892563,
0.17580196261405945,
-0.6505939960479736,
0.04736438766121864,
0.4187878966331482,
-0.520704984664917,
-0.35558000206947327,
0.052293069660663605,
-0.9265396595001221,
-0.6752634048461914,
-0.21377593278884888,
0.011739705689251423,
0.00395422987639904,
-0.11391811817884445,
0.08054593205451965,
0.051448021084070206,
0.3388344943523407,
0.40714141726493835,
-0.735634982585907,
0.49526649713516235,
0.8908103108406067,
0.8948578238487244,
-0.4828357696533203,
-0.08036395907402039,
-0.46338093280792236,
0.15556693077087402,
-0.22116081416606903,
0.7891588807106018,
-0.5919164419174194,
-0.3771628141403198,
-0.06032557785511017,
-0.3298393487930298,
0.09905974566936493,
-0.6214544773101807,
0.762397050857544,
-0.4884546101093292,
0.36167168617248535,
-0.14615803956985474,
-0.5269306898117065,
0.10573865473270416,
0.21913892030715942,
-0.5596270561218262,
1.1595302820205688,
-0.19075600802898407,
-1.027113437652588,
0.2580990791320801,
-0.3771730065345764,
-0.4319700002670288,
0.017620474100112915,
-0.3050537109375,
-0.7027291059494019,
-0.0021132496185600758,
0.04383783042430878,
0.43337783217430115,
-0.36303454637527466,
0.3718006908893585,
-0.35578811168670654,
-0.29606398940086365,
0.36218416690826416,
-0.6260730028152466,
0.8305233716964722,
0.35035133361816406,
-0.46339452266693115,
0.06260044872760773,
-0.5875051021575928,
-0.061224281787872314,
-0.178554967045784,
-0.19945724308490753,
-0.5401623249053955,
-0.04113711416721344,
0.18818563222885132,
0.3566300570964813,
0.3541527986526489,
-0.3532453775405884,
0.26041942834854126,
-0.3663395643234253,
0.4575657248497009,
0.8834589719772339,
-0.21349535882472992,
0.6903455853462219,
-0.16325582563877106,
0.4134907126426697,
0.004271676763892174,
0.15811355412006378,
0.19734178483486176,
-0.4784325361251831,
-0.7393989562988281,
-0.19061750173568726,
0.4926854372024536,
0.5952718257904053,
-0.49890661239624023,
0.6894667148590088,
0.05598746985197067,
-0.23845942318439484,
-0.27522730827331543,
0.10261967778205872,
0.5026957392692566,
0.2690315246582031,
0.3865286409854889,
-0.23478733003139496,
-0.6031168699264526,
-0.863089382648468,
-0.2004350870847702,
-0.22746627032756805,
0.12837177515029907,
0.08925395458936691,
0.18167226016521454,
-0.4014030992984772,
0.8857020735740662,
-0.5334935188293457,
-0.19245101511478424,
-0.1658615618944168,
0.1396058350801468,
0.006506612058728933,
0.500018835067749,
0.4466065764427185,
-1.0306572914123535,
-0.21941104531288147,
0.10367696732282639,
-0.4462432861328125,
-0.41625237464904785,
-0.35493004322052,
-0.24855545163154602,
0.3769257366657257,
0.7164960503578186,
-0.4743386507034302,
0.5811008810997009,
0.4231360852718353,
-0.27717527747154236,
0.31220918893814087,
-0.24528606235980988,
-0.2038886696100235,
-0.8266298770904541,
-0.13675808906555176,
0.06510020792484283,
-0.3134097456932068,
-0.723023533821106,
-0.08135957270860672,
0.22717714309692383,
0.3431340456008911,
-0.024621102958917618,
0.7916498184204102,
-0.3638033866882324,
-0.018766624853014946,
-0.5080817937850952,
0.07612383365631104,
-0.03148341923952103,
0.2872893512248993,
0.011667471379041672,
0.5202216506004333,
0.38305023312568665,
-0.6621573567390442,
-0.12870603799819946,
0.19597478210926056,
-0.09608975052833557,
0.42126429080963135,
-0.24823349714279175,
0.21460595726966858,
-0.14526796340942383,
0.5584805607795715,
-0.9346997141838074,
0.17581012845039368,
0.554504930973053,
-0.2520532011985779,
0.4554382860660553,
0.11496024578809738,
-0.2971102297306061,
-0.3939812481403351,
-0.3868778645992279,
0.6700201630592346,
0.2861620783805847,
-0.6179450750350952,
0.45592695474624634,
0.377654105424881,
-0.25721344351768494,
-0.7959846258163452,
-0.717168390750885,
0.13514167070388794,
-0.38497626781463623,
-0.10019621253013611,
0.6126988530158997,
-0.21277301013469696,
-0.34128549695014954,
-0.3095461130142212,
-0.43847501277923584,
-0.182760551571846,
0.11032320559024811,
0.1839756965637207,
0.31654947996139526,
0.35880836844444275,
0.44909560680389404,
0.3633687198162079,
-0.1774551272392273,
0.01670621521770954,
-0.511989176273346,
0.5037527084350586,
-0.06751469522714615,
-0.1282704472541809,
-0.08581426739692688,
0.3194788992404938,
0.47590816020965576,
-0.3490142524242401,
0.46805539727211,
0.5684551000595093,
-0.39344796538352966,
-0.4567996561527252,
-0.8067024946212769,
0.12227220088243484,
-0.4853050410747528,
0.28397631645202637,
-0.4152277708053589,
-1.1056677103042603,
0.5366175174713135,
-0.052535366266965866,
0.05565766990184784,
0.5356563329696655,
0.5578442811965942,
0.18429893255233765,
0.7197291254997253,
0.5963313579559326,
-0.016250766813755035,
0.5055358409881592,
-0.014979807659983635,
0.34862151741981506,
-0.9011919498443604,
-0.23742039501667023,
-0.6434149742126465,
-0.10311847180128098,
-0.9469547271728516,
-0.4917190372943878,
0.27180519700050354,
-0.07198108732700348,
-0.07545844465494156,
0.023225605487823486,
-0.4253304600715637,
0.5568398237228394,
0.21711274981498718,
0.33412933349609375,
0.2245025932788849,
-0.10105511546134949,
-0.22818292677402496,
0.042954105883836746,
-0.6682301163673401,
-0.582324743270874,
1.1001805067062378,
0.5858628749847412,
0.46098455786705017,
0.08717027306556702,
0.8381083607673645,
0.38748905062675476,
0.33355286717414856,
-0.5784735083580017,
0.49664151668548584,
-0.33586937189102173,
-0.5309351086616516,
-0.2222331315279007,
-0.7013225555419922,
-0.885352611541748,
0.49526792764663696,
-0.320675253868103,
-0.784034788608551,
0.32746145129203796,
0.08939220011234283,
-0.2999119162559509,
0.38750165700912476,
-0.5613930225372314,
0.7436444759368896,
-0.48044463992118835,
-0.7225209474563599,
-0.10608014464378357,
-0.7948291301727295,
0.31506624817848206,
-0.45588621497154236,
0.41493839025497437,
0.013630661182105541,
-0.15602657198905945,
0.6663150787353516,
-0.38546091318130493,
0.9122915267944336,
-0.04076705500483513,
-0.4162921905517578,
0.2722063958644867,
-0.034548308700323105,
0.38596510887145996,
-0.06285204738378525,
-0.20824763178825378,
0.2782548666000366,
-0.08390968292951584,
-0.45840179920196533,
-0.4963613748550415,
0.6200032830238342,
-0.6630224585533142,
-0.4500299096107483,
-0.5536465644836426,
-0.3128732442855835,
-0.31385791301727295,
0.35782507061958313,
0.3500401973724365,
0.43938833475112915,
-0.13893848657608032,
-0.02882734313607216,
0.6628400683403015,
-0.22988754510879517,
0.4738093614578247,
0.17438727617263794,
-0.24395950138568878,
-0.31264543533325195,
0.4962129592895508,
0.10261067003011703,
0.19005483388900757,
0.5687541961669922,
0.22774873673915863,
-0.5857906341552734,
-0.8891236186027527,
-0.1577221155166626,
0.14495979249477386,
-0.6881387233734131,
-0.32449281215667725,
-0.5761922001838684,
-0.1678197681903839,
-0.5198813676834106,
-0.15146774053573608,
-0.1348617821931839,
-0.23419708013534546,
-0.3330172896385193,
-0.1532280445098877,
0.06893637776374817,
0.8247687816619873,
-0.028034739196300507,
0.4750908613204956,
-0.5729480385780334,
0.09112969785928726,
0.17447619140148163,
0.6449359655380249,
0.02137777954339981,
-0.5611679553985596,
-0.11045832186937332,
-0.30561259388923645,
-0.3425542116165161,
-0.8628574013710022,
0.22031328082084656,
-0.0338306687772274,
0.6700364351272583,
0.4669059216976166,
0.27665042877197266,
0.47251230478286743,
-0.5181766748428345,
0.3472835123538971,
0.3240842819213867,
-1.1108477115631104,
0.2502669394016266,
-0.20484422147274017,
0.20854373276233673,
0.688506007194519,
0.10096602886915207,
-0.6179326772689819,
-0.24656574428081512,
-0.5788428783416748,
-1.0006282329559326,
0.5451942086219788,
0.22371967136859894,
-0.17807215452194214,
0.1877104938030243,
0.5378435254096985,
0.37950974702835083,
0.2535291910171509,
-0.8982083797454834,
-0.22651784121990204,
0.22333107888698578,
-0.2767898738384247,
0.025444308295845985,
-0.40754494071006775,
0.1864994764328003,
-0.2544099986553192,
0.5713374018669128,
-0.06820640712976456,
0.08073707669973373,
0.26116976141929626,
-0.17541173100471497,
0.00569094717502594,
0.44388139247894287,
0.504953145980835,
0.6465294361114502,
-0.1486411839723587,
0.4557441473007202,
0.48482832312583923,
-0.3554500341415405,
0.15537887811660767,
0.13727505505084991,
-0.10295136272907257,
-0.12527912855148315,
0.38655608892440796,
0.6318531036376953,
0.18234437704086304,
-0.4945009648799896,
0.44775649905204773,
-0.10216597467660904,
-0.08948475867509842,
-0.1395271122455597,
-0.196542888879776,
-0.3525891900062561,
0.2815376818180084,
0.3158879578113556,
0.21454866230487823,
0.40356913208961487,
-0.2632544934749603,
0.236528217792511,
0.40705791115760803,
-0.2306419014930725,
0.11729124933481216,
0.30270668864250183,
0.4925280213356018,
-0.2034977674484253,
0.31062278151512146,
-0.4162529408931732,
-0.7761542797088623,
0.5311375856399536,
0.5652751326560974,
0.9921551942825317,
-0.3191109001636505,
0.24991223216056824,
-0.02980779856443405,
0.3066430687904358,
-0.18433867394924164,
-0.1289311945438385,
-0.18943767249584198,
-0.7818388938903809,
-0.3913542330265045,
-0.5280810594558716,
-0.5294158458709717,
0.08711867779493332,
-0.6195042133331299,
0.31951355934143066,
-0.7062544226646423,
-0.2608743906021118,
-0.009302239865064621,
0.09659656882286072,
-0.4959104359149933,
0.009991521947085857,
0.5195014476776123,
0.7927157878875732,
-0.8559679388999939,
0.630577802658081,
0.6687839031219482,
0.18419981002807617,
-0.21327589452266693,
0.16747546195983887,
-0.009146667085587978,
-0.5371571183204651,
0.37026017904281616,
0.586015522480011,
-0.30282601714134216,
-0.2932869493961334,
-0.45724132657051086,
-0.46027645468711853,
0.7171646356582642,
0.037493746727705,
-0.9815555214881897,
0.09168195724487305,
0.08189378678798676,
0.5512784123420715,
-0.3129171133041382,
0.22574472427368164,
0.5942211151123047,
0.5078932046890259,
0.020190460607409477,
-1.0751982927322388,
0.048144444823265076,
-0.1361469328403473,
0.11255104094743729,
0.5327824950218201,
-0.7750279903411865,
0.6977247595787048,
-0.10095910727977753,
-0.1647036373615265,
0.004453008994460106,
0.4427294135093689,
0.1882147192955017,
0.6591746211051941,
0.721455454826355,
0.48404937982559204,
1.1556881666183472,
-0.12681034207344055,
0.7186005711555481,
-0.10233857482671738,
0.43573883175849915,
1.0987623929977417,
-0.50759357213974,
0.802709698677063,
0.5019806027412415,
-0.30079662799835205,
0.41749995946884155,
0.9616778492927551,
0.12456616014242172,
0.2693127393722534,
0.39380350708961487,
-0.33123624324798584,
-0.4666650593280792,
-0.08163817971944809,
-0.34141167998313904,
0.6018474698066711,
0.34110191464424133,
-0.18444092571735382,
-0.07616598904132843,
-0.020934808999300003,
0.12999281287193298,
0.20379669964313507,
-0.3063060939311981,
0.6356375217437744,
0.14544975757598877,
-0.42080140113830566,
0.16458402574062347,
0.16994556784629822,
0.9222555160522461,
-0.36854785680770874,
0.06390074640512466,
-0.12790387868881226,
0.27498188614845276,
-0.3077327311038971,
-0.6463290452957153,
-0.045316584408283234,
-0.003546264488250017,
-0.20131312310695648,
-0.46250051259994507,
0.8351906538009644,
-0.5411685109138489,
-0.5155913829803467,
0.48778036236763,
0.35329368710517883,
-0.04874315857887268,
0.011271510273218155,
-0.7112939357757568,
0.3192991018295288,
0.0663449689745903,
0.048984602093696594,
0.1990678310394287,
0.4785240590572357,
-0.29738858342170715,
0.45540735125541687,
0.3753218948841095,
-0.01457195170223713,
-0.23539035022258759,
-0.04622567445039749,
0.8084076642990112,
-0.6821610331535339,
-0.7842566967010498,
-1.0336055755615234,
0.18445870280265808,
-0.24175211787223816,
-0.37287700176239014,
0.5202217102050781,
0.620294451713562,
0.8729559183120728,
0.2997420132160187,
0.916077733039856,
0.26723170280456543,
0.2795310318470001,
-0.6638420820236206,
0.44264504313468933,
-0.39210227131843567,
0.5681746006011963,
-0.2730696201324463,
-0.9159064888954163,
-0.6080387830734253,
0.6096858382225037,
-0.5266438722610474,
0.08627445250749588,
0.7388461232185364,
0.431484580039978,
0.15640556812286377,
-0.05559748411178589,
-0.07955612242221832,
0.22460143268108368,
0.27913516759872437,
0.4943968951702118,
0.8274661302566528,
-0.36750051379203796,
0.4171837270259857,
-0.09210725128650665,
-0.4197812080383301,
-0.3023958206176758,
-0.9213539958000183,
-0.9775025844573975,
-0.48703309893608093,
-0.36592933535575867,
-0.3352149426937103,
0.12570461630821228,
1.1614210605621338,
0.5718814730644226,
-0.7627490162849426,
-0.2965490221977234,
-0.07539139688014984,
0.4756637215614319,
0.12356027960777283,
-0.1800137162208557,
0.28569474816322327,
-0.2744866609573364,
-0.6024420261383057,
0.11946172267198563,
0.34100472927093506,
0.20201775431632996,
-0.16333505511283875,
-0.10420092195272446,
-0.06325486302375793,
-0.1476435363292694,
0.6024237871170044,
0.17404282093048096,
-0.7322136759757996,
-0.23197773098945618,
-0.15232601761817932,
-0.1291203796863556,
0.07410808652639389,
0.9662940502166748,
-0.5802103281021118,
0.4417009651660919,
0.37317347526550293,
0.9190657138824463,
0.37740272283554077,
-0.09164652228355408,
0.4405251145362854,
-0.7288640737533569,
0.0823240801692009,
0.11715246737003326,
0.24162496626377106,
0.3531011641025543,
-0.5388830900192261,
0.3916766941547394,
0.0809619277715683,
-0.5632968544960022,
-0.9176862239837646,
0.2626977562904358,
-1.162631869316101,
-0.5726673603057861,
1.2170710563659668,
0.23114851117134094,
-0.0632869303226471,
-0.15410079061985016,
-0.47596538066864014,
0.26140767335891724,
-0.3347943425178528,
0.7640370726585388,
0.7723144292831421,
-0.14056582748889923,
-0.05647895112633705,
-0.22367776930332184,
0.42437246441841125,
0.48749250173568726,
-0.8421700596809387,
0.25936535000801086,
0.48585426807403564,
0.047856807708740234,
0.016907164826989174,
0.5604466199874878,
0.022403491660952568,
0.046218957751989365,
-0.3393835127353668,
0.08199400454759598,
0.24791942536830902,
-0.4828742742538452,
-0.6801478862762451,
0.07697832584381104,
0.1543380618095398,
-0.06273731589317322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10264v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10264v1
|
Large Language Model-empowered multimodal strain sensory system for shape recognition, monitoring, and human interaction of tensegrity
| 2024-06-11T06:26:04 | 2024-06-11T06:26:04 |
Zebing Mao, Ryota Kobayashi, Hiroyuki Nabae, Koichi Suzumori
|
cs.RO
|
cs.RO, cs.CL
|
A tensegrity-based system is a promising approach for dynamic exploration of
uneven and unpredictable environments, particularly, space exploration.
However, implementing such systems presents challenges in terms of intelligent
aspects: state recognition, wireless monitoring, human interaction, and smart
analyzing and advising function. Here, we introduce a 6-strut tensegrity
integrate with 24 multimodal strain sensors by leveraging both deep learning
model and large language models to realize smart tensegrity. Using conductive
flexible tendons assisted by long short-term memory model, the tensegrity
achieves the self-shape reconstruction without extern sensors. Through
integrating the flask server and gpt-3.5-turbo model, the tensegrity
autonomously enables to send data to iPhone for wireless monitoring and
provides data analysis, explanation, prediction, and suggestions to human for
decision making. Finally, human interaction system of the tensegrity helps
human obtain necessary information of tensegrity from the aspect of human
language. Overall, this intelligent tensegrity-based system with self-sensing
tendons showcases potential for future exploration, making it a versatile tool
for real-world applications.
|
[
-0.15286551415920258,
-0.5931473970413208,
0.7028062343597412,
0.12336791306734085,
-0.14158456027507782,
0.055512361228466034,
-0.20118938386440277,
-0.654187798500061,
0.8228757381439209,
-0.22444581985473633,
-0.6981480121612549,
-0.21854794025421143,
-0.2990461587905884,
-0.2280569076538086,
-0.06412061303853989,
0.662284791469574,
-0.021032556891441345,
-0.30199429392814636,
0.1856759786605835,
-0.44134411215782166,
-0.13085079193115234,
-0.5915182828903198,
-0.11921213567256927,
-0.21320568025112152,
0.314314603805542,
0.1370217204093933,
0.9439291954040527,
0.01753878779709339,
0.32622456550598145,
0.5533361434936523,
-0.011160850524902344,
0.07946056127548218,
-0.08554685860872269,
0.3006456196308136,
0.08180171251296997,
-0.03905054181814194,
-0.6740311980247498,
-0.008054543286561966,
0.5545827150344849,
0.28184038400650024,
-0.3319161534309387,
0.18648774921894073,
-0.16456280648708344,
0.29548749327659607,
-0.26317963004112244,
0.021347420290112495,
0.04686032235622406,
0.30792832374572754,
-0.18545302748680115,
0.23186063766479492,
0.18779243528842926,
-0.17979303002357483,
-0.26373207569122314,
-0.4146338999271393,
-0.016919149085879326,
0.17895381152629852,
0.6870406270027161,
0.16590093076229095,
-0.5119056701660156,
0.14871615171432495,
-0.755648136138916,
0.4739820659160614,
-0.803451418876648,
1.00808846950531,
0.2424849271774292,
0.48061513900756836,
-0.1835641860961914,
-0.971534788608551,
-0.767572820186615,
-0.17562264204025269,
0.05082784593105316,
0.2537054717540741,
0.265654981136322,
-0.06940484046936035,
-0.013449005782604218,
0.29264986515045166,
-0.7977355718612671,
0.21515774726867676,
-0.5267099142074585,
-0.50416499376297,
0.5695067048072815,
0.20989200472831726,
0.35187843441963196,
-0.3114401400089264,
-0.6637369394302368,
-0.11673840135335922,
-0.2672734558582306,
0.37735435366630554,
0.27234816551208496,
0.21129439771175385,
-0.38310423493385315,
0.36378470063209534,
-0.15112747251987457,
0.5468529462814331,
-0.11939334124326706,
0.010761982761323452,
0.5360383987426758,
-0.05756494030356407,
-0.4436664283275604,
-0.33297228813171387,
1.1134259700775146,
-0.13454462587833405,
-0.17926517128944397,
-0.25559288263320923,
-0.6062433123588562,
-0.2017095685005188,
0.2530515491962433,
-0.5767160058021545,
-0.21453876793384552,
0.2773471772670746,
-0.5646591782569885,
-0.14961594343185425,
0.06910918653011322,
-1.0464781522750854,
-0.660513162612915,
-0.24990738928318024,
0.2809361219406128,
-0.6451374888420105,
-0.7957547903060913,
0.5422129034996033,
0.062200337648391724,
0.22466972470283508,
0.2892535924911499,
-0.8991193175315857,
0.19830553233623505,
0.43674784898757935,
1.137316346168518,
0.0991748794913292,
-0.34195441007614136,
-0.1503407061100006,
-0.052186645567417145,
0.25946044921875,
0.8182329535484314,
-0.38569867610931396,
-0.546274721622467,
-0.3924950063228607,
0.10445991158485413,
-0.26564982533454895,
-0.1308135688304901,
0.5677198171615601,
-0.31847238540649414,
0.09922262281179428,
0.4147160053253174,
-0.28823286294937134,
-0.3632871210575104,
0.6538006663322449,
-0.6568267941474915,
0.950738251209259,
0.13149306178092957,
-0.40201252698898315,
0.4178270399570465,
-0.6884700655937195,
-0.28387364745140076,
0.44159719347953796,
-0.2616276144981384,
-0.43505144119262695,
0.3009274899959564,
0.08545233309268951,
0.6543613076210022,
0.07049205899238586,
0.20696891844272614,
-0.552299976348877,
-0.10083534568548203,
0.34636440873146057,
-0.4264916181564331,
0.3125615417957306,
0.329907089471817,
-0.41863593459129333,
0.38018444180488586,
-0.7320145964622498,
0.21478058397769928,
0.2534020245075226,
-0.5542195439338684,
-0.17535336315631866,
0.2641493082046509,
0.28686684370040894,
0.15439844131469727,
0.09706765413284302,
-0.6056995391845703,
0.6679893732070923,
-0.16556209325790405,
0.4491932988166809,
0.5609711408615112,
-0.2790386378765106,
0.40158742666244507,
0.05580820143222809,
0.5836355686187744,
-0.1410813331604004,
0.5572615265846252,
0.17591749131679535,
-0.10719151049852371,
-0.6942691802978516,
-0.443884015083313,
-0.06538278609514236,
0.3869338929653168,
-0.6653072834014893,
0.24145327508449554,
-0.500330924987793,
-0.6545207500457764,
-0.18698039650917053,
-0.07170507311820984,
-0.20607368648052216,
0.042813558131456375,
0.31599435210227966,
0.020769231021404266,
-0.2358938753604889,
-0.35309192538261414,
-0.31023842096328735,
-0.29104170203208923,
-0.1840713769197464,
0.1477196216583252,
0.2984154522418976,
-0.45201200246810913,
0.710544764995575,
-0.46012574434280396,
-0.3942617177963257,
-0.16414175927639008,
0.3138178288936615,
0.40600860118865967,
0.46502962708473206,
0.7792487740516663,
-0.9195817112922668,
0.3025975823402405,
-0.011183559894561768,
-0.6525918841362,
0.1827610731124878,
-0.22934719920158386,
0.18704739212989807,
-0.258225679397583,
0.38538774847984314,
-0.8991643190383911,
0.19870205223560333,
0.875804603099823,
-0.8480812311172485,
0.6787933111190796,
-0.18805694580078125,
0.22682389616966248,
-1.0914909839630127,
0.06449338793754578,
0.24884375929832458,
-0.2655532658100128,
-0.46905845403671265,
0.07065633684396744,
0.4194071590900421,
-0.3754613995552063,
-0.3766134977340698,
0.5415860414505005,
-0.5673743486404419,
0.10936898738145828,
-0.04356065392494202,
-0.3021758496761322,
-0.014736414887011051,
0.5037446022033691,
-0.2300443947315216,
0.613074779510498,
0.3982159197330475,
-0.4493969976902008,
0.716876208782196,
-0.10990593582391739,
-0.3921090066432953,
0.04483659565448761,
-0.6331394910812378,
0.13369864225387573,
0.038717929273843765,
-0.000034322398278163746,
-0.6120652556419373,
-0.5070666670799255,
0.32895034551620483,
-0.48321691155433655,
0.3838910460472107,
-0.17493745684623718,
-0.2299274355173111,
-0.6739394664764404,
-0.25074732303619385,
0.5654569268226624,
0.5184919834136963,
-0.5405449271202087,
1.2620562314987183,
0.38648319244384766,
-0.29370009899139404,
-0.018889756873250008,
-0.5455663800239563,
0.12839531898498535,
-0.44637054204940796,
-0.5037617683410645,
-0.13604626059532166,
-0.14007046818733215,
-0.18809397518634796,
-0.5500828623771667,
-0.209694966673851,
-0.15558135509490967,
-0.005733775906264782,
0.7423157095909119,
0.20242203772068024,
-0.013132215477526188,
0.49041423201560974,
-0.06365112960338593,
0.29798924922943115,
0.06493312865495682,
-0.46108004450798035,
0.47041717171669006,
-0.6935140490531921,
-0.5497482419013977,
-0.5589805841445923,
0.11251115053892136,
1.216972827911377,
-0.386887788772583,
0.14767323434352875,
0.7076952457427979,
-0.3763951361179352,
-0.009663794189691544,
-0.6357024908065796,
-0.24790820479393005,
-0.6760056614875793,
0.04527169466018677,
-0.513823390007019,
-0.9298993349075317,
0.3996403217315674,
-0.4679706394672394,
-0.2692530155181885,
0.41867291927337646,
0.19760985672473907,
-0.23134654760360718,
0.784324586391449,
0.49369046092033386,
-0.37874722480773926,
0.43309953808784485,
0.03451418876647949,
0.2661278247833252,
-0.5074321627616882,
-0.6284708976745605,
-0.29996153712272644,
-0.7295997142791748,
-0.053202416747808456,
-0.39482197165489197,
0.4637915790081024,
-0.20046494901180267,
-0.22308985888957977,
0.13014529645442963,
-0.4763062596321106,
-0.06487004458904266,
0.4242406189441681,
0.34620293974876404,
-0.2377767115831375,
-0.2403939962387085,
-0.29563453793525696,
-0.2517574727535248,
-0.527593731880188,
-0.14083853363990784,
0.3123294413089752,
0.3553527295589447,
1.3293533325195312,
0.4048619270324707,
0.2466457188129425,
0.5196182131767273,
-0.03960743919014931,
-1.0381349325180054,
0.6008359789848328,
0.3400304317474365,
-0.2851143181324005,
-0.2626829147338867,
-0.3799346685409546,
-0.6846976280212402,
0.1720861792564392,
-0.4336288273334503,
-0.7994236946105957,
0.41879358887672424,
0.2880713641643524,
-0.728834331035614,
0.5871266722679138,
-1.0179028511047363,
0.4969904124736786,
-0.8224005103111267,
-0.30225810408592224,
0.009400107897818089,
-0.6042648553848267,
0.14617745578289032,
0.16275446116924286,
0.30250588059425354,
-0.07056649774312973,
0.2344733327627182,
0.660234808921814,
-0.2208864539861679,
1.2112585306167603,
-0.5355373620986938,
-0.05952276289463043,
0.39842912554740906,
0.26550745964050293,
0.46731138229370117,
0.3274635374546051,
0.0567733570933342,
0.1992706060409546,
-0.24485746026039124,
0.0693606436252594,
-0.4934602677822113,
0.6966474056243896,
-0.7236012816429138,
-0.47131597995758057,
-0.5541308522224426,
-0.4804942011833191,
-0.320259690284729,
0.30187922716140747,
-0.337348997592926,
0.26104414463043213,
-0.31834277510643005,
0.11536329984664917,
0.3483666181564331,
-0.037305716425180435,
0.707518994808197,
0.47884026169776917,
-0.1693277806043625,
-0.2210279405117035,
0.8765110373497009,
-0.054911114275455475,
-0.4165721833705902,
-0.006249172613024712,
0.19938968122005463,
-0.3775743246078491,
-0.42879241704940796,
-0.46476006507873535,
0.15514585375785828,
0.11531972140073776,
-0.6128770709037781,
-0.7687690854072571,
-0.06918056309223175,
-0.8462839126586914,
0.003699678461998701,
-0.5925958156585693,
-0.2920264005661011,
-0.19822388887405396,
-0.45922085642814636,
0.6923785209655762,
0.6070183515548706,
-0.1800529509782791,
0.33607953786849976,
-1.1815897226333618,
0.3555281162261963,
0.6055870652198792,
0.5110664367675781,
-0.30961641669273376,
-0.29863372445106506,
-0.188582643866539,
0.13110829889774323,
-0.15222686529159546,
-0.5498824119567871,
0.5522989630699158,
0.33187931776046753,
0.23900064826011658,
0.7605999112129211,
-0.13523729145526886,
0.5208927392959595,
-0.25460243225097656,
0.7929481267929077,
0.4908119738101959,
-0.9239408373832703,
0.4075523316860199,
-0.5084111094474792,
0.5919517874717712,
0.1377795934677124,
0.2616962492465973,
-0.7239745259284973,
-0.15089638531208038,
-0.44868412613868713,
-0.8523464202880859,
0.26247698068618774,
-0.1294868439435959,
-0.07588429003953934,
0.2727193236351013,
0.28892871737480164,
0.12703530490398407,
-0.18285664916038513,
-0.7308719754219055,
0.666983425617218,
-0.4465970993041992,
-0.3250376284122467,
0.3179575502872467,
-0.10866740345954895,
-0.07060365378856659,
-0.18327616155147552,
0.2954367995262146,
-0.444349080324173,
0.3897565007209778,
0.18162882328033447,
-0.13469840586185455,
0.24164113402366638,
0.3606718182563782,
0.6893617510795593,
0.12837868928909302,
-0.10543516278266907,
0.07659410685300827,
0.28016138076782227,
-0.8494272232055664,
0.025989139452576637,
0.31138062477111816,
0.306924432516098,
-0.12093095481395721,
0.16089537739753723,
0.722736120223999,
0.03984437510371208,
-0.6772943735122681,
0.44917726516723633,
-0.12716467678546906,
-0.010744843631982803,
-0.503288745880127,
0.16963711380958557,
0.13185369968414307,
0.8525822758674622,
0.5146891474723816,
0.2372385859489441,
0.09131608158349991,
-0.08311009407043457,
-0.03186316415667534,
0.24299070239067078,
-0.49209022521972656,
-0.8780261278152466,
0.8683099150657654,
0.2013857066631317,
-0.12790338695049286,
0.5557056069374084,
-0.017480168491601944,
-0.5206844806671143,
0.663814127445221,
0.33779481053352356,
0.4621395766735077,
-0.8208828568458557,
0.03851443901658058,
0.23284168541431427,
0.3105751574039459,
-0.12575720250606537,
0.7087873816490173,
-0.14325709640979767,
-0.7542994022369385,
-0.22602629661560059,
-0.6309677362442017,
-0.017803331837058067,
-0.025592751801013947,
-0.4328565001487732,
0.008929423056542873,
-0.5397261381149292,
-0.40211036801338196,
-0.39692169427871704,
-0.43968915939331055,
-0.6557202935218811,
0.762576162815094,
0.2800379693508148,
0.8102415800094604,
-0.7047995328903198,
0.7762804627418518,
0.8881531357765198,
-0.078543521463871,
-0.7604555487632751,
-0.281587690114975,
0.2671094834804535,
-0.8163672089576721,
0.48619648814201355,
0.08779451996088028,
-0.5858043432235718,
-0.2522958815097809,
-0.5801149606704712,
-0.6633740067481995,
1.2681173086166382,
-0.008741750381886959,
-0.5518786907196045,
0.020885560661554337,
-0.2089797854423523,
0.4432663321495056,
0.192491352558136,
0.01929233968257904,
0.009665685705840588,
0.6891926527023315,
-0.13951751589775085,
-0.8141714334487915,
0.0325903482735157,
-0.4863443374633789,
-0.2567525804042816,
0.6003090143203735,
-1.1056716442108154,
0.6484358310699463,
-0.303480863571167,
-0.38651254773139954,
0.020790504291653633,
1.1397662162780762,
-0.07096602767705917,
0.1348913013935089,
0.618884265422821,
0.5077470541000366,
0.7816494107246399,
-0.16270504891872406,
0.7152645587921143,
-0.10611911118030548,
0.49274593591690063,
0.9459941983222961,
-0.3393665552139282,
0.583394467830658,
0.6284418106079102,
0.008829372003674507,
0.2325299084186554,
0.5102691650390625,
0.007836815901100636,
0.2893718481063843,
0.023524653166532516,
-0.6171218752861023,
-0.22159415483474731,
0.14758485555648804,
-0.47887536883354187,
0.8045024275779724,
0.9058949947357178,
0.05025354027748108,
0.08205004036426544,
0.6109222173690796,
0.07711669057607651,
-0.34147149324417114,
-0.25184035301208496,
0.384237676858902,
-0.06838370859622955,
-0.34834080934524536,
0.2174726128578186,
-0.0670141726732254,
0.8806172609329224,
-1.0723389387130737,
0.16127145290374756,
-0.5466243624687195,
0.12331967055797577,
-0.18880194425582886,
-0.6580823063850403,
0.1257089227437973,
-0.14510710537433624,
0.06020893529057503,
-0.44666776061058044,
1.1212055683135986,
-0.017567606642842293,
-0.455698698759079,
0.18487747013568878,
0.667457640171051,
-0.055564116686582565,
-0.0807637944817543,
-0.2418208122253418,
0.03759008273482323,
-0.2786250412464142,
-0.7570369839668274,
0.25977540016174316,
0.7158289551734924,
0.12660852074623108,
1.019714117050171,
0.45585009455680847,
0.10914459824562073,
0.09677146375179291,
0.08563654124736786,
1.2074323892593384,
-1.0518625974655151,
-0.4353392422199249,
-0.3779950737953186,
0.5090292096138,
-0.02567007951438427,
-0.36274006962776184,
0.445487380027771,
0.372384250164032,
0.2734708786010742,
-0.05975906923413277,
0.6139329671859741,
-0.5532697439193726,
0.1652928590774536,
-0.4722806215286255,
1.1880909204483032,
-0.6536182165145874,
-0.2502439022064209,
0.3092055916786194,
-0.3802323043346405,
-0.5112277865409851,
0.499347060918808,
0.0017132810316979885,
0.21228371560573578,
0.547398567199707,
0.6118975281715393,
-0.6993553638458252,
0.11367624253034592,
0.40964728593826294,
0.4116668701171875,
0.4264470040798187,
0.2170618623495102,
0.6549697518348694,
-0.1506912261247635,
0.35669633746147156,
0.277312695980072,
-0.22298896312713623,
-0.20755024254322052,
-0.5426624417304993,
-0.42348045110702515,
-0.5754483342170715,
0.029396528378129005,
-0.2809000611305237,
-0.0679662749171257,
0.899033784866333,
0.9022277593612671,
-0.6141107082366943,
-0.038463056087493896,
0.2033594399690628,
-0.4622047543525696,
-0.20228345692157745,
-0.27654412388801575,
0.23041106760501862,
-0.20031072199344635,
-0.5531755089759827,
1.1552902460098267,
0.44439569115638733,
0.5061668753623962,
-0.1579897254705429,
0.05906582996249199,
-0.13519226014614105,
-0.4395378828048706,
0.6976878643035889,
0.8220183253288269,
-0.23073413968086243,
-0.664846658706665,
0.13423515856266022,
0.03553393483161926,
-0.016165148466825485,
0.9999074935913086,
-1.0435503721237183,
0.4702243208885193,
0.40223824977874756,
0.5934941172599792,
0.41443929076194763,
-0.2148740142583847,
0.5284842252731323,
-0.6583284735679626,
0.6382048726081848,
0.4126444160938263,
0.7757106423377991,
0.24177202582359314,
-0.46147724986076355,
0.4859349727630615,
0.34345316886901855,
-0.5436553359031677,
-0.07120959460735321,
0.3361522853374481,
-1.112547755241394,
-0.3121284544467926,
1.1151764392852783,
-0.19817227125167847,
-0.2392384558916092,
-0.03517983481287956,
-0.241926372051239,
0.16051869094371796,
-0.3251969814300537,
0.9699894189834595,
0.3973572552204132,
-0.1956588178873062,
-0.2731284201145172,
-0.3424605131149292,
0.13296623528003693,
0.39986899495124817,
-0.8385019302368164,
-0.33864888548851013,
0.7830371856689453,
0.02476409822702408,
0.22806479036808014,
0.23527483642101288,
0.16318275034427643,
-0.04267137497663498,
-0.03392971679568291,
0.45343661308288574,
-0.19698913395404816,
-0.30732429027557373,
-0.1897214651107788,
0.34859445691108704,
-0.158546581864357,
-0.39844417572021484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06964v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06964v1
|
Missingness-resilient Video-enhanced Multimodal Disfluency Detection
| 2024-06-11T05:47:16 | 2024-06-11T05:47:16 |
Payal Mohapatra, Shamika Likhite, Subrata Biswas, Bashima Islam, Qi Zhu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.MM, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Most existing speech disfluency detection techniques only rely upon acoustic
data. In this work, we present a practical multimodal disfluency detection
approach that leverages available video data together with audio. We curate an
audiovisual dataset and propose a novel fusion technique with unified
weight-sharing modality-agnostic encoders to learn the temporal and semantic
context. Our resilient design accommodates real-world scenarios where the video
modality may sometimes be missing during inference. We also present alternative
fusion strategies when both modalities are assured to be complete. In
experiments across five disfluency-detection tasks, our unified multimodal
approach significantly outperforms Audio-only unimodal methods, yielding an
average absolute improvement of 10% (i.e., 10 percentage point increase) when
both video and audio modalities are always available, and 7% even when video
modality is missing in half of the samples.
|
[
-0.3809523582458496,
-0.6317723989486694,
0.35485392808914185,
0.29459166526794434,
-0.12719076871871948,
0.11188922077417374,
0.11054040491580963,
-0.24060121178627014,
0.4699707627296448,
-0.07719742506742477,
-0.9070889353752136,
0.03577212244272232,
-0.6929754018783569,
-0.04731503501534462,
-0.42345187067985535,
0.686687171459198,
0.2281726747751236,
0.19026708602905273,
-0.3350505530834198,
-0.504081666469574,
-0.7074689269065857,
-0.18089602887630463,
-0.22760465741157532,
-0.29123085737228394,
0.3808201253414154,
0.42748257517814636,
0.7066110372543335,
0.393563449382782,
0.3276562988758087,
0.42554908990859985,
-0.010560213588178158,
0.24425077438354492,
-0.08391699939966202,
0.26896584033966064,
-0.062105339020490646,
0.12965954840183258,
-0.39595314860343933,
-0.24626131355762482,
0.7635471820831299,
0.620204508304596,
-0.45686379075050354,
-0.14954720437526703,
-0.0407625287771225,
0.4829917848110199,
-0.8461812138557434,
0.004250389523804188,
-0.8294364213943481,
0.29029208421707153,
-0.3130246102809906,
-0.007382996380329132,
-0.21810248494148254,
0.24703101813793182,
-0.083500437438488,
-0.5459789633750916,
0.07294630259275436,
-0.31356099247932434,
0.34246793389320374,
0.699358344078064,
-0.6029306054115295,
0.04618246853351593,
-0.7450549602508545,
0.61897873878479,
-0.4607582092285156,
0.9423629641532898,
0.5880373120307922,
0.5259228348731995,
-0.1069595068693161,
-0.5844910740852356,
-1.119016170501709,
-0.06136782839894295,
0.1229107454419136,
0.24496717751026154,
-0.3617224395275116,
0.14583884179592133,
0.3116466701030731,
0.49899160861968994,
-0.7138413190841675,
0.10839642584323883,
-0.09304182976484299,
-0.5938795804977417,
0.2973574995994568,
-0.00878373347222805,
0.6228905916213989,
-0.3737584054470062,
-0.37897613644599915,
-0.4544755518436432,
-0.08877775073051453,
-0.17422810196876526,
0.24556216597557068,
0.067960225045681,
-0.23200923204421997,
0.30703774094581604,
-0.14026084542274475,
0.6206690073013306,
-0.18533095717430115,
-0.6087051033973694,
0.6526329517364502,
-0.6732548475265503,
-0.3522900342941284,
0.30914729833602905,
0.4087587893009186,
0.1310557872056961,
-0.3189085125923157,
-0.026221515610814095,
-0.26423537731170654,
0.43918824195861816,
0.04497984051704407,
-0.17625409364700317,
-0.34099942445755005,
0.08681779354810715,
-0.2149955928325653,
0.126742884516716,
-0.14624276757240295,
-0.7198948860168457,
-0.5339904427528381,
-0.334492027759552,
0.8168848156929016,
-0.6050243377685547,
-0.7931118607521057,
0.033142220228910446,
-0.5501466989517212,
0.0034955411683768034,
0.044394735246896744,
-1.050106406211853,
-0.058676812797784805,
0.2936241626739502,
0.8605934977531433,
0.09605301916599274,
-0.22880582511425018,
-0.6585639715194702,
0.35641995072364807,
0.04213716462254524,
0.6532159447669983,
-0.4654267430305481,
-0.21330536901950836,
-0.12509407103061676,
0.12542180716991425,
-0.05410163477063179,
-0.4751187860965729,
0.7610856294631958,
0.10497880727052689,
0.173786923289299,
-0.20500490069389343,
-0.19046729803085327,
-0.13199514150619507,
0.19765375554561615,
-1.0419600009918213,
0.7722097635269165,
0.21425022184848785,
-0.4942185580730438,
0.7367814779281616,
-0.2707308232784271,
-0.48020750284194946,
-0.11152264475822449,
-0.2052219957113266,
-0.69051194190979,
-0.05275662988424301,
0.3272436857223511,
0.15943872928619385,
0.19305287301540375,
0.2799299657344818,
-0.5770861506462097,
-0.15434281527996063,
0.2515658140182495,
-1.1101552248001099,
0.5482592582702637,
0.05863146856427193,
-0.1995021253824234,
-0.20985092222690582,
-1.2675760984420776,
-0.25078460574150085,
-0.09011553972959518,
-0.3043835759162903,
-0.3589693307876587,
0.020743995904922485,
0.2883862853050232,
0.34112977981567383,
-0.28117701411247253,
-0.9463573694229126,
-0.20186558365821838,
-0.12497878074645996,
0.44845977425575256,
0.743430495262146,
-0.18799421191215515,
0.27008214592933655,
-0.33413538336753845,
0.06655769795179367,
0.3737075924873352,
0.16366401314735413,
-0.1437448412179947,
-0.05063741281628609,
-0.6080899834632874,
-0.8153226375579834,
-0.08160898089408875,
0.45547598600387573,
-1.2297892570495605,
0.13170470297336578,
-0.09061968326568604,
-0.3096367418766022,
-0.7330620884895325,
0.10719244927167892,
0.6182133555412292,
0.8291566967964172,
0.4812614917755127,
-0.3155587315559387,
-0.8463930487632751,
-0.9359749555587769,
-0.0013976938789710402,
-0.16829082369804382,
-0.05850240960717201,
0.06690625846385956,
0.24322938919067383,
-0.2817085087299347,
0.7498205304145813,
-0.3542821705341339,
-0.7230271697044373,
-0.0033530285581946373,
0.11545184999704361,
-0.11411216109991074,
0.4791510999202728,
0.5611935257911682,
-1.1856436729431152,
-0.008988674730062485,
-0.11914344877004623,
-0.8422405123710632,
0.03626818209886551,
-0.1012098491191864,
0.5298505425453186,
0.4317111670970917,
0.36058101058006287,
-0.22281770408153534,
0.4250272512435913,
0.7931695580482483,
-0.20678390562534332,
0.1579703986644745,
-0.30052947998046875,
0.41764628887176514,
-1.0581295490264893,
-0.27067241072654724,
-0.11031288653612137,
-0.3056972324848175,
-0.6809709072113037,
-0.6020122766494751,
-0.12866224348545074,
-0.32578349113464355,
-0.6138246655464172,
-0.00018277764320373535,
-0.4430846571922302,
-0.23343251645565033,
-0.15089905261993408,
0.25973206758499146,
0.020905161276459694,
0.486082524061203,
-0.1026066392660141,
0.5844496488571167,
0.5243171453475952,
-0.4882085919380188,
0.6134554147720337,
0.34049665927886963,
-0.14353905618190765,
0.8321344256401062,
-0.5914412140846252,
-0.009524831548333168,
-0.41400429606437683,
0.22429810464382172,
-1.3839606046676636,
-0.6476011276245117,
0.17096395790576935,
-0.4777814447879791,
0.1643693894147873,
-0.2388751059770584,
-0.21223317086696625,
-0.08461519330739975,
-0.24482636153697968,
0.5511085391044617,
0.14135588705539703,
-0.6154345870018005,
0.6731145977973938,
0.6403898000717163,
-0.22198957204818726,
-0.5574164986610413,
-0.9563362002372742,
0.022939249873161316,
-0.2556855082511902,
-0.7637147307395935,
0.5844674110412598,
-0.2613747715950012,
-0.016220252960920334,
0.0008247561636380851,
-0.4001705050468445,
-0.44669997692108154,
0.05917513370513916,
0.530504584312439,
0.13344623148441315,
0.15917284786701202,
0.5005444288253784,
0.1543375849723816,
-0.12289206683635712,
-0.5092054605484009,
0.25457823276519775,
0.3674483001232147,
-0.06535446643829346,
-0.9003753066062927,
-0.6318548917770386,
0.6191138029098511,
0.7294305562973022,
-0.0577140711247921,
0.3352476954460144,
0.890343427658081,
-0.7085081934928894,
0.2153848111629486,
-0.8137758374214172,
-0.28037145733833313,
-0.49907782673835754,
0.5474485754966736,
-0.15407811105251312,
-0.6838368773460388,
0.3198135197162628,
0.16483989357948303,
-0.0620819516479969,
0.003563864855095744,
0.39958643913269043,
-0.1271369308233261,
0.9468355178833008,
0.5516670346260071,
-0.18031862378120422,
0.834542989730835,
0.19241951406002045,
-0.006933984346687794,
-0.47515127062797546,
-0.4816356897354126,
-0.05666148290038109,
-0.2953437268733978,
-0.2536594569683075,
-0.1881115585565567,
0.674400269985199,
-0.2723621428012848,
0.04559730738401413,
0.3376133143901825,
-0.3944033682346344,
0.40062156319618225,
0.23554284870624542,
0.4910360276699066,
0.4235883951187134,
0.18015427887439728,
0.21757613122463226,
-0.38822680711746216,
-0.4068295955657959,
0.07045062631368637,
0.5553099513053894,
0.20712119340896606,
0.6279398202896118,
0.6025283932685852,
0.37104058265686035,
0.6364263296127319,
-0.35644370317459106,
-0.5742700099945068,
0.3005612790584564,
-0.07194531708955765,
-0.3185480535030365,
-0.37375107407569885,
-0.366555392742157,
-0.7777864933013916,
0.39478451013565063,
-0.570734441280365,
-0.35371530055999756,
0.3216494023799896,
0.3531936705112457,
-0.27223727107048035,
0.20896488428115845,
-0.685897171497345,
0.577843427658081,
-0.08774671703577042,
-0.29515913128852844,
-0.37212300300598145,
-0.5355650186538696,
0.34461861848831177,
-0.05437515676021576,
0.4269501566886902,
-0.10061512887477875,
0.2108767032623291,
0.7522099614143372,
-0.3470850884914398,
0.6206966042518616,
-0.3049974739551544,
0.028657017275691032,
0.12107446789741516,
-0.07570681720972061,
0.06696441024541855,
0.17046409845352173,
0.3769671320915222,
-0.09841696172952652,
-0.07637795805931091,
-0.26767879724502563,
-0.7511112689971924,
0.582162618637085,
-0.4679233133792877,
-0.40922749042510986,
-0.46521902084350586,
-0.6789649724960327,
-0.4770793616771698,
0.16373340785503387,
-0.1928068846464157,
0.753052830696106,
-0.16051837801933289,
0.4327559769153595,
0.8038137555122375,
-0.07527274638414383,
1.1777634620666504,
0.5615407824516296,
0.3115570843219757,
-0.76960289478302,
1.1630280017852783,
0.06171196326613426,
0.36442771553993225,
0.1569456160068512,
-0.05812940374016762,
-0.25747549533843994,
-0.20729848742485046,
-0.4037640690803528,
-0.04527696222066879,
-0.6581830978393555,
-0.1877625733613968,
-0.5983741283416748,
-0.04726419225335121,
-0.5691210031509399,
0.18479840457439423,
-0.5842165350914001,
-0.5362135767936707,
-0.009647726081311703,
-0.4337182343006134,
0.3710441291332245,
0.1945504993200302,
-0.5531243085861206,
0.04407350718975067,
-0.8818235993385315,
0.6870704293251038,
0.8542608022689819,
0.10657770931720734,
-0.175657257437706,
-0.43603813648223877,
0.20762237906455994,
0.3172030448913574,
-0.49342110753059387,
-0.8184062242507935,
0.34499436616897583,
0.5839716792106628,
0.6751089096069336,
0.2684726417064667,
0.07856987416744232,
0.9048160314559937,
-0.2949151396751404,
0.7530664205551147,
0.6693080067634583,
-0.8650133609771729,
0.5815090537071228,
-0.06270197033882141,
0.10919725149869919,
0.5296233892440796,
0.306143194437027,
-0.669251561164856,
0.09798718988895416,
-0.42477014660835266,
-0.77516770362854,
0.5061739087104797,
0.18533110618591309,
-0.06590753048658371,
0.13456392288208008,
-0.2911825478076935,
0.0891050323843956,
0.064518503844738,
-0.6635487675666809,
-0.1419449895620346,
-0.6295390725135803,
-0.06706580519676208,
-0.01700044982135296,
0.005623255856335163,
-0.3177419602870941,
-0.3412330746650696,
0.41078099608421326,
-0.10258597880601883,
0.24445736408233643,
0.4710424840450287,
-0.3773404657840729,
0.1324452906847,
0.3585291802883148,
0.7650938630104065,
0.5206838250160217,
-0.24925251305103302,
0.18322648108005524,
0.2642098665237427,
-0.5029918551445007,
0.3504803776741028,
0.14287863671779633,
0.4448045492172241,
0.4289452135562897,
0.4077353775501251,
0.927402675151825,
0.45563173294067383,
-0.9807936549186707,
0.7422316074371338,
-0.1221221312880516,
-0.21244372427463531,
-0.4873226583003998,
-0.3176282048225403,
-0.013922538608312607,
0.48885291814804077,
0.5715696215629578,
0.08444122970104218,
0.3326481878757477,
-0.7836614847183228,
0.8269813060760498,
0.46533477306365967,
-0.6471050381660461,
-0.30644911527633667,
0.5696175694465637,
0.23713064193725586,
-0.2035771906375885,
0.5974926948547363,
0.22343532741069794,
-0.20095601677894592,
0.34483736753463745,
0.565433919429779,
0.6831061244010925,
-0.39895427227020264,
0.27566391229629517,
-0.19927889108657837,
0.01731238327920437,
0.06481394171714783,
0.3247585892677307,
-0.22046564519405365,
-0.7765814661979675,
-0.15978798270225525,
-0.27000024914741516,
-0.2786025106906891,
0.0730302482843399,
-0.7623056173324585,
0.11232604831457138,
-0.324367493391037,
-0.18331462144851685,
0.12648239731788635,
-0.581930935382843,
-0.2387302964925766,
0.17699456214904785,
0.23816247284412384,
0.3883492648601532,
-1.2161996364593506,
0.6858099102973938,
0.37204286456108093,
-0.6847894787788391,
-0.47549140453338623,
-0.1309719979763031,
0.5214768648147583,
-0.8444039821624756,
0.45434486865997314,
-0.054790835827589035,
-0.21886171400547028,
-0.32371410727500916,
-0.05026621371507645,
-0.6339808106422424,
1.3686566352844238,
0.9033384323120117,
-0.5473479628562927,
0.13592498004436493,
0.059758029878139496,
0.2499343454837799,
0.20388098061084747,
0.20988203585147858,
0.5357480049133301,
0.35522329807281494,
0.4412001967430115,
-1.177785873413086,
-0.29157188534736633,
-0.0502341166138649,
-0.28977102041244507,
0.2395356148481369,
-0.47660887241363525,
0.6552832126617432,
0.16193901002407074,
-0.38370281457901,
-0.46687155961990356,
0.6571577787399292,
0.17214742302894592,
0.6967384219169617,
0.8291716575622559,
0.8468358516693115,
0.8223952651023865,
-0.009139793924987316,
0.6641424298286438,
0.18690398335456848,
0.1621064990758896,
0.8532058000564575,
0.03444301709532738,
0.6487647294998169,
0.7243121862411499,
-0.031031442806124687,
0.31504255533218384,
0.20370931923389435,
0.23111426830291748,
0.785936713218689,
-0.2645641267299652,
-0.6926093697547913,
-0.48520427942276,
-0.5207506418228149,
-0.5777671933174133,
0.9255236983299255,
0.09981594979763031,
0.0614059716463089,
-0.3763980269432068,
0.6457184553146362,
0.002049332018941641,
0.2411731481552124,
-0.3440515697002411,
0.938179612159729,
-0.07066135853528976,
-0.31456154584884644,
0.6711030006408691,
-0.5298876762390137,
0.8406537771224976,
-0.5674228072166443,
-0.32919397950172424,
-0.3666337728500366,
0.41235530376434326,
-0.3450391888618469,
-0.5929260849952698,
0.4915914237499237,
-0.3829349875450134,
-0.45631542801856995,
-0.3073870539665222,
0.7267255783081055,
-0.7418678402900696,
-0.2875361144542694,
0.3175325095653534,
0.26102766394615173,
-0.19067800045013428,
-0.009160224348306656,
-0.31410813331604004,
0.3457357883453369,
-0.17587873339653015,
0.2512497305870056,
0.6697824597358704,
0.3210817575454712,
0.07882921397686005,
0.6778793334960938,
0.5263388752937317,
-0.24388758838176727,
-0.11384034901857376,
0.10448140650987625,
1.030253291130066,
-0.28914135694503784,
-0.1709432303905487,
-0.9439937472343445,
0.4844144880771637,
-0.34303995966911316,
-0.16888035833835602,
0.6436928510665894,
0.2052662968635559,
0.9109523892402649,
-0.11342030763626099,
0.5876224637031555,
-0.23642374575138092,
0.32527974247932434,
-0.6311984658241272,
0.6280231475830078,
-0.7356292605400085,
-0.04327148199081421,
-0.7203559279441833,
-0.5162311792373657,
-0.2485659420490265,
0.5301710367202759,
0.4691998064517975,
-0.2919957637786865,
0.5100832581520081,
0.8307002186775208,
-0.19028016924858093,
-0.04619985818862915,
0.5527166128158569,
-0.07973366975784302,
0.4263533353805542,
0.7717528939247131,
0.5410474538803101,
-0.5478122234344482,
0.7966715693473816,
-0.2212887555360794,
-0.5886038541793823,
0.11503768712282181,
-0.9853507280349731,
-0.466673880815506,
-0.9633687734603882,
-0.2762138545513153,
-0.08829761296510696,
0.10306140780448914,
0.7849960923194885,
0.6809852719306946,
-0.4693947434425354,
0.27378320693969727,
0.21974174678325653,
0.18911214172840118,
-0.4602755904197693,
-0.19308508932590485,
0.11779073625802994,
0.13850237429141998,
-0.6289497017860413,
0.9540983438491821,
0.4104444682598114,
0.18829011917114258,
-0.16637486219406128,
0.09782065451145172,
-0.35674309730529785,
-0.22396522760391235,
0.6620003581047058,
0.4431357979774475,
-0.616788923740387,
-0.6999152302742004,
-0.3201461732387543,
0.31802570819854736,
-0.07217274606227875,
0.7743876576423645,
-0.8421909809112549,
0.8118922710418701,
0.6295481324195862,
0.7361831068992615,
0.1261395514011383,
-0.1489306092262268,
0.4468236565589905,
-1.0879536867141724,
0.6262910962104797,
0.26643627882003784,
0.7631452083587646,
0.44831550121307373,
-0.02272380143404007,
0.29637446999549866,
0.8854063749313354,
-0.369655579328537,
-1.1017310619354248,
0.2964448034763336,
-1.3051881790161133,
-0.263566792011261,
0.9148126244544983,
-0.04621707275509834,
0.07721497118473053,
-0.2690170109272003,
-0.2578878700733185,
0.3922511637210846,
-0.4304666817188263,
0.7480259537696838,
0.5681361556053162,
-0.025337370112538338,
-0.3527013063430786,
-0.19156788289546967,
0.3702804744243622,
0.4238055944442749,
-0.45340585708618164,
0.10194632411003113,
0.7390726208686829,
0.34503331780433655,
0.26229870319366455,
0.5134358406066895,
-0.06676628440618515,
0.4887441098690033,
0.30620425939559937,
-0.16938498616218567,
-0.6233484148979187,
-0.45832520723342896,
-0.5030488967895508,
0.13756772875785828,
-0.45799970626831055,
-0.5308937430381775
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06962v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06962v1
|
Evolving Subnetwork Training for Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T05:44:56 | 2024-06-11T05:44:56 |
Hanqi Li, Lu Chen, Da Ma, Zijian Wu, Su Zhu, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models have ushered in a new era of artificial intelligence
research. However, their substantial training costs hinder further development
and widespread adoption. In this paper, inspired by the redundancy in the
parameters of large language models, we propose a novel training paradigm:
Evolving Subnetwork Training (EST). EST samples subnetworks from the layers of
the large language model and from commonly used modules within each layer,
Multi-Head Attention (MHA) and Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP). By gradually
increasing the size of the subnetworks during the training process, EST can
save the cost of training. We apply EST to train GPT2 model and TinyLlama
model, resulting in 26.7\% FLOPs saving for GPT2 and 25.0\% for TinyLlama
without an increase in loss on the pre-training dataset. Moreover, EST leads to
performance improvements in downstream tasks, indicating that it benefits
generalization. Additionally, we provide intuitive theoretical studies based on
training dynamics and Dropout theory to ensure the feasibility of EST. Our code
is available at https://github.com/OpenDFM/EST.
|
[
-0.4078804850578308,
-0.7798091173171997,
0.23569628596305847,
-0.0067972457036376,
-0.18658006191253662,
-0.02163088321685791,
-0.5624985098838806,
-0.5189154744148254,
0.1866162270307541,
0.26065579056739807,
-0.6275714039802551,
-0.09890127182006836,
-0.5710593461990356,
-0.16202688217163086,
-0.3035372197628021,
0.9311007857322693,
0.13510385155677795,
-0.11719705909490585,
0.0046879299916327,
-0.16045790910720825,
-0.42982718348503113,
-0.21963118016719818,
-1.1198011636734009,
-0.6359952092170715,
0.6192237734794617,
0.4765336513519287,
0.5028111338615417,
0.53031325340271,
0.24622300267219543,
0.28163760900497437,
0.04605039209127426,
0.3896442651748657,
-0.6585550308227539,
-0.16299360990524292,
-0.17927247285842896,
-0.455973356962204,
-0.4378223121166229,
-0.1471235603094101,
0.7217472791671753,
0.7103544473648071,
-0.23835530877113342,
0.24705736339092255,
-0.010824810713529587,
0.6298296451568604,
-0.48294514417648315,
0.1595420092344284,
-0.9473857283592224,
0.2215239554643631,
-0.23493672907352448,
-0.0823231041431427,
-0.41032785177230835,
0.04735036566853523,
0.3484354019165039,
-0.4790533483028412,
0.11845511198043823,
-0.1374254673719406,
0.6815728545188904,
0.2586178779602051,
-0.008383854292333126,
0.2734951972961426,
-0.6422403454780579,
0.6902795433998108,
-0.5942661166191101,
0.5774977803230286,
0.13845694065093994,
0.23954014480113983,
-0.07616772502660751,
-0.6360547542572021,
-0.3839244544506073,
-0.4017111361026764,
0.2662835419178009,
0.022783521562814713,
-0.3895290195941925,
-0.04929595813155174,
-0.004244622308760881,
0.017917921766638756,
-0.4275621175765991,
0.4618549942970276,
-0.501132607460022,
0.18085017800331116,
0.5056985020637512,
0.007240770384669304,
0.2743680477142334,
0.48590755462646484,
-0.2473042756319046,
0.05575179681181908,
-0.7817186713218689,
-0.22817866504192352,
0.2136773318052292,
0.6524551510810852,
-0.2880167067050934,
0.12758919596672058,
-0.13354423642158508,
0.3134024143218994,
0.13759100437164307,
0.09687530994415283,
0.518159806728363,
-0.02830713801085949,
-0.38935333490371704,
-0.045761480927467346,
0.5785279273986816,
-0.15264296531677246,
0.5728605389595032,
-0.08488348126411438,
0.04968749359250069,
-0.3605964779853821,
0.4277700185775757,
-0.4389626681804657,
-0.5283993482589722,
0.08377650380134583,
-0.3031103014945984,
-0.21852104365825653,
-0.36649784445762634,
-0.45870327949523926,
-0.2882196009159088,
-0.48923152685165405,
0.14442522823810577,
-0.5968298316001892,
-0.47719311714172363,
0.07587279379367828,
0.14546604454517365,
0.07343053817749023,
0.49036717414855957,
-1.1167964935302734,
0.06585603207349777,
0.7226104140281677,
0.9412523508071899,
0.01994279772043228,
-0.6884657740592957,
-0.5802492499351501,
-0.060850005596876144,
-0.33016878366470337,
0.7417256236076355,
-0.4581962525844574,
-0.009836460463702679,
-0.01386419590562582,
-0.20038408041000366,
-0.5034806728363037,
-0.4541882574558258,
0.02950975112617016,
-0.6583098769187927,
0.04288912191987038,
0.18272626399993896,
-0.13687975704669952,
-0.07827676832675934,
0.2953801453113556,
-0.6329993009567261,
1.0146222114562988,
0.19892658293247223,
-0.6468438506126404,
0.24605783820152283,
-0.9093893766403198,
-0.38871365785598755,
0.20548611879348755,
-0.13650771975517273,
-0.6433702111244202,
0.2848740518093109,
0.22289277613162994,
0.2542888820171356,
-0.3704415559768677,
0.04518933221697807,
-0.3081476390361786,
-0.23216594755649567,
-0.02798311971127987,
-0.24839511513710022,
0.764143168926239,
0.07133101671934128,
-0.41609519720077515,
-0.09056385606527328,
-0.5891273617744446,
0.1634380966424942,
0.0037422075401991606,
-0.6796954870223999,
-0.2662697434425354,
-0.02984137460589409,
-0.03323904424905777,
0.1487041711807251,
0.21821145713329315,
-0.4110996425151825,
0.20529481768608093,
-0.5272072553634644,
0.6540977358818054,
0.8142628073692322,
-0.04206044599413872,
0.47425365447998047,
-0.15208926796913147,
0.4685271680355072,
0.03458208590745926,
0.21795012056827545,
0.17778930068016052,
-0.32500046491622925,
-1.0405515432357788,
-0.16374856233596802,
0.5473101139068604,
0.48482075333595276,
-0.7362813949584961,
0.38567835092544556,
-0.5214763879776001,
-0.5578143000602722,
-0.3412879407405853,
0.11257205903530121,
0.39387795329093933,
-0.008690315298736095,
0.540104866027832,
-0.19675949215888977,
-0.6919459700584412,
-1.0049054622650146,
-0.0150296026840806,
-0.2395039200782776,
0.024826548993587494,
0.08374638855457306,
0.5679643750190735,
-0.4545714855194092,
0.9240711331367493,
-0.1485610008239746,
-0.143147274851799,
-0.6579899191856384,
0.2594611346721649,
-0.05276738107204437,
0.6978411674499512,
0.5578835010528564,
-0.5232900381088257,
-0.3805636763572693,
0.2830369770526886,
-0.33575859665870667,
-0.025125324726104736,
-0.22065280377864838,
-0.18710024654865265,
0.1742999404668808,
0.46546608209609985,
-0.6733338236808777,
-0.00813231896609068,
0.5670046806335449,
0.10705308616161346,
0.42686665058135986,
-0.14829279482364655,
-0.2522212564945221,
-1.0794597864151,
-0.012414278462529182,
0.06585778295993805,
0.024836160242557526,
-0.6326897144317627,
0.2165900468826294,
0.022662149742245674,
0.03640858083963394,
-0.4802594780921936,
0.5320770144462585,
-0.6851624250411987,
-0.0365447960793972,
-0.2308218777179718,
-0.07549262046813965,
-0.36717015504837036,
0.6976408958435059,
-0.1139996126294136,
0.5235129594802856,
0.4674200713634491,
-0.5183050632476807,
0.2929994463920593,
0.09104353189468384,
-0.19104447960853577,
0.1384333223104477,
-0.5274410843849182,
0.47566521167755127,
-0.14676082134246826,
0.20144079625606537,
-0.5454072952270508,
-0.03442859277129173,
-0.009253844618797302,
-0.3447195589542389,
0.5823593735694885,
-0.2966073751449585,
-0.18907499313354492,
-0.31119295954704285,
-0.29593515396118164,
0.28831416368484497,
0.4273526966571808,
-0.5692543387413025,
0.7349877953529358,
0.4295331537723541,
-0.12299101799726486,
-0.627000629901886,
-1.0028048753738403,
0.13094410300254822,
-0.09201357513666153,
-0.589523434638977,
0.05025491863489151,
0.09853842109441757,
0.011983362957835197,
0.04331189766526222,
-0.08506821095943451,
-0.02024558186531067,
0.11062084883451462,
-0.02459479682147503,
-0.08330587297677994,
-0.5071228742599487,
0.3457207977771759,
0.16100843250751495,
-0.19745564460754395,
-0.13299860060214996,
-0.9705677628517151,
0.8165557980537415,
-0.09456884860992432,
-0.2237982153892517,
-0.42678460478782654,
0.2964237630367279,
0.4649321734905243,
-0.44767916202545166,
0.8310658931732178,
0.5964837670326233,
-0.4455799162387848,
-0.5740347504615784,
-0.47377267479896545,
-0.10003137588500977,
-0.41742005944252014,
1.0515176057815552,
-0.42854225635528564,
-1.0084792375564575,
0.2950992286205292,
-0.11014960706233978,
0.15740445256233215,
0.3630543351173401,
0.5742244124412537,
0.30915501713752747,
0.8199201226234436,
0.8683292269706726,
-0.25472837686538696,
0.8536719083786011,
-0.35331034660339355,
0.08834667503833771,
-0.8574305176734924,
-0.13808651268482208,
-0.3997933566570282,
-0.5092849135398865,
-0.3869447708129883,
-0.5574702024459839,
0.3809242844581604,
-0.07060703635215759,
-0.5158952474594116,
0.26802146434783936,
-0.2280893623828888,
0.7072007656097412,
0.6470166444778442,
0.17283447086811066,
-0.0443766787648201,
0.25606095790863037,
-0.0007658899994567037,
0.2642795443534851,
-0.9934918880462646,
-0.20082254707813263,
1.077256202697754,
0.6113126277923584,
0.7516863942146301,
0.10700558871030807,
0.6605551242828369,
0.4017845690250397,
0.306406706571579,
-0.698540210723877,
0.5195189118385315,
-0.3042263090610504,
-0.32129600644111633,
-0.5456240773200989,
-0.591255247592926,
-0.9413978457450867,
0.28909027576446533,
-0.18565626442432404,
-0.8035959005355835,
0.21093712747097015,
0.3583848476409912,
-0.39888420701026917,
0.3732888996601105,
-0.7372266054153442,
0.8364628553390503,
-0.2477475255727768,
-0.12958171963691711,
-0.32809314131736755,
-0.5930067300796509,
0.14137932658195496,
-0.245712548494339,
-0.04241716116666794,
0.033445168286561966,
-0.04311234503984451,
0.682725191116333,
-0.19494208693504333,
0.9099709391593933,
-0.2477680742740631,
0.04154185578227043,
0.17422769963741302,
-0.04617252200841904,
0.6902575492858887,
-0.0049088443629443645,
-0.04533132165670395,
0.3717018663883209,
-0.5569642782211304,
-0.47440025210380554,
-0.5182694792747498,
0.5494813323020935,
-0.9860110282897949,
-0.27727121114730835,
-0.09592477232217789,
-0.5647056698799133,
-0.48250940442085266,
0.16113154590129852,
0.2300674021244049,
0.5028435587882996,
-0.02130841091275215,
0.31221315264701843,
0.7962255477905273,
-0.13327325880527496,
0.23850630223751068,
0.26867952942848206,
0.21202901005744934,
-0.3195120096206665,
0.6588727235794067,
0.1416161060333252,
0.4403112530708313,
0.5967066884040833,
0.35318562388420105,
-0.09010674059391022,
-1.035581111907959,
-0.4140342175960541,
0.10640813410282135,
-0.5430582761764526,
-0.18018214404582977,
-0.7620656490325928,
-0.3122555613517761,
-0.3873383402824402,
0.04138869047164917,
-0.613772451877594,
-0.34570956230163574,
-0.09329869598150253,
-0.14376257359981537,
0.23853522539138794,
0.5223548412322998,
-0.2375071495771408,
0.2560596168041229,
-0.8392835855484009,
-0.3009766936302185,
0.5053491592407227,
0.11244632303714752,
0.37705352902412415,
-0.7121476531028748,
-0.7273759245872498,
0.14873601496219635,
0.0017262541223317385,
-0.46645551919937134,
0.22707806527614594,
0.5067225098609924,
0.6663116812705994,
0.2451448142528534,
-0.18101714551448822,
0.5170515179634094,
-0.752348780632019,
0.6877128481864929,
0.351107656955719,
-0.8370389342308044,
0.3431609570980072,
-0.5093545317649841,
0.5188922882080078,
0.6090413331985474,
0.11055917292833328,
-0.5176753997802734,
-0.3409911096096039,
-0.5460555553436279,
-1.0066076517105103,
0.9221020340919495,
-0.0038059439975768328,
0.2802615165710449,
0.13295996189117432,
0.29243913292884827,
0.05830938741564751,
0.09621822088956833,
-0.7217580080032349,
0.07403771579265594,
-0.053526341915130615,
-0.4104899764060974,
0.04023590311408043,
-0.15861128270626068,
-0.16965538263320923,
-0.2342425137758255,
0.9120423793792725,
-0.3335181772708893,
0.4722459018230438,
-0.21153973042964935,
-0.21405206620693207,
-0.06538301706314087,
0.24394433200359344,
0.6612491607666016,
0.7782116532325745,
0.13076747953891754,
0.19899553060531616,
0.490736722946167,
-0.6107877492904663,
-0.029367592185735703,
-0.025149649009108543,
-0.14381657540798187,
-0.3136290907859802,
0.5136779546737671,
1.0129523277282715,
0.2021954506635666,
-0.5460057854652405,
0.14834782481193542,
0.13483285903930664,
-0.40246161818504333,
-0.39822882413864136,
0.1680821180343628,
0.16491733491420746,
0.6544994711875916,
0.37953704595565796,
0.07756724953651428,
-0.1842777580022812,
-0.5375344753265381,
0.01742401346564293,
0.2530512511730194,
-0.3047514259815216,
-0.2409898191690445,
0.38861289620399475,
0.26562175154685974,
-0.333524227142334,
0.593400239944458,
-0.1516188085079193,
-0.6561610698699951,
0.6836456060409546,
0.648838460445404,
1.1018567085266113,
-0.02694903314113617,
0.23409968614578247,
0.022130001336336136,
0.6492408514022827,
-0.13594450056552887,
-0.1009620726108551,
0.16843393445014954,
-0.7665355205535889,
-0.4799503684043884,
-0.7131326198577881,
-0.44281280040740967,
0.5175834894180298,
-0.13195763528347015,
0.1169862374663353,
-0.44030076265335083,
0.1262424737215042,
-0.0492563396692276,
-0.12279170006513596,
-0.47580641508102417,
0.28978002071380615,
0.3955502510070801,
0.8211883902549744,
-0.685849666595459,
0.9205917716026306,
0.9576408863067627,
-0.27856603264808655,
-0.9431782960891724,
0.08250979334115982,
-0.006813558284193277,
-0.9054675102233887,
0.6412972807884216,
0.08372460305690765,
-0.18837010860443115,
0.06648040562868118,
-0.46078601479530334,
-1.1428494453430176,
0.9258723855018616,
0.46815139055252075,
-0.6142504215240479,
-0.2009388506412506,
0.03916997089982033,
0.6481566429138184,
-0.5614186525344849,
0.2174728363752365,
0.6155880689620972,
0.14471127092838287,
-0.10289517790079117,
-0.9301627278327942,
-0.08687996864318848,
-0.5127089619636536,
0.24406829476356506,
0.5295026302337646,
-0.7975956201553345,
1.2572450637817383,
-0.16793467104434967,
-0.16881144046783447,
0.06300874054431915,
0.5471930503845215,
-0.05942632257938385,
0.15836656093597412,
0.6069672107696533,
0.7056897282600403,
0.5754772424697876,
-0.04980546981096268,
0.6751254200935364,
-0.031234076246619225,
0.5700699687004089,
1.2952297925949097,
0.022777140140533447,
0.8902594447135925,
0.20236879587173462,
-0.13656948506832123,
0.537375807762146,
0.6811667680740356,
0.088160440325737,
0.36679625511169434,
0.26363232731819153,
-0.0016413554549217224,
-0.28104913234710693,
0.27391812205314636,
-0.4274492859840393,
0.49345824122428894,
0.14675061404705048,
-0.2922802269458771,
-0.31174302101135254,
0.22291503846645355,
0.08892746269702911,
-0.2216380387544632,
-0.32857659459114075,
0.6118223071098328,
-0.024157129228115082,
-0.48213648796081543,
0.6304303407669067,
0.07060300558805466,
0.5819123387336731,
-0.7550967335700989,
0.23172204196453094,
-0.4592987596988678,
0.4384725093841553,
-0.10025358200073242,
-0.15491995215415955,
0.005675219930708408,
-0.027367038652300835,
-0.220687597990036,
-0.0559910424053669,
0.4828895330429077,
-0.5266552567481995,
-0.26891425251960754,
0.32378917932510376,
0.5505257248878479,
0.005032596178352833,
-0.032424453645944595,
-0.8292121887207031,
-0.06513437628746033,
-0.05731203407049179,
-0.2774209976196289,
0.48081478476524353,
0.45455023646354675,
-0.024493379518389702,
0.4581987261772156,
0.6066997647285461,
0.22773291170597076,
0.2232150286436081,
0.36712050437927246,
0.9110860824584961,
-0.30423039197921753,
-0.7533552050590515,
-0.799077570438385,
0.38900497555732727,
-0.24244463443756104,
-0.5599263906478882,
0.41731807589530945,
0.3543092906475067,
0.9186920523643494,
-0.13110481202602386,
0.8290872573852539,
-0.0496978834271431,
0.4092324674129486,
-0.8054055571556091,
0.7109225988388062,
-0.6217777729034424,
0.1955139935016632,
-0.14617624878883362,
-1.014561414718628,
-0.08807027339935303,
0.5386520028114319,
-0.4175998866558075,
0.2563842236995697,
0.8229231238365173,
0.5954580903053284,
-0.24019530415534973,
0.04567365720868111,
0.0709526538848877,
0.3322034776210785,
0.2721558213233948,
0.9303845763206482,
0.8310542702674866,
-0.12880562245845795,
0.38881993293762207,
-0.0425897054374218,
-0.3391604423522949,
-0.29858219623565674,
-0.653678297996521,
-0.9537598490715027,
-0.3523068428039551,
-0.4604402780532837,
-0.02961202897131443,
0.3793213367462158,
1.1816020011901855,
0.98231440782547,
-0.7079293727874756,
-0.09447845071554184,
-0.3167622983455658,
-0.26454687118530273,
-0.32719483971595764,
-0.19543953239917755,
0.23158711194992065,
-0.48362696170806885,
-0.6732518672943115,
0.5227200984954834,
0.3811766505241394,
0.05484364181756973,
-0.3548736870288849,
-0.03450147435069084,
-0.5291534662246704,
0.10123056918382645,
0.5429978966712952,
0.521111011505127,
-0.3267362713813782,
-0.6039571166038513,
-0.3245140016078949,
0.18718715012073517,
-0.03857294097542763,
0.7270597219467163,
-0.4172671139240265,
0.12800732254981995,
0.3988240957260132,
1.1356520652770996,
0.466711163520813,
-0.21136540174484253,
0.5124700665473938,
-0.976966381072998,
0.2336016744375229,
0.2508220374584198,
0.3497980833053589,
0.3105325400829315,
-0.291390985250473,
0.6710220575332642,
0.2914683520793915,
-0.5200976133346558,
-0.8234918117523193,
0.35660725831985474,
-0.7921063899993896,
-0.15954984724521637,
1.1181660890579224,
-0.029410338029265404,
-0.12783803045749664,
-0.09925903379917145,
0.04327860847115517,
0.0815170630812645,
-0.40795832872390747,
0.8979542851448059,
0.3743584156036377,
-0.1780446320772171,
-0.29206547141075134,
-0.3854829967021942,
0.27628758549690247,
0.47872328758239746,
-0.9643551707267761,
0.07452691346406937,
0.3743807077407837,
0.19212238490581512,
0.4103871285915375,
0.6099131107330322,
0.2856637239456177,
0.36415553092956543,
0.22195585072040558,
0.018964136019349098,
-0.3361317217350006,
-0.6902651786804199,
-0.3253493309020996,
0.29654255509376526,
0.03051317110657692,
-0.34757551550865173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06950v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06950v1
|
A Probabilistic Framework for LLM Hallucination Detection via Belief Tree Propagation
| 2024-06-11T05:21:37 | 2024-06-11T05:21:37 |
Bairu Hou, Yang Zhang, Jacob Andreas, Shiyu Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper focuses on the task of hallucination detection, which aims to
determine the truthfulness of LLM-generated statements. To address this
problem, a popular class of methods utilize the LLM's self-consistencies in its
beliefs in a set of logically related augmented statements generated by the
LLM, which does not require external knowledge databases and can work with both
white-box and black-box LLMs. However, in many existing approaches, the
augmented statements tend to be very monotone and unstructured, which makes it
difficult to integrate meaningful information from the LLM beliefs in these
statements. Also, many methods work with the binarized version of the LLM's
belief, instead of the continuous version, which significantly loses
information. To overcome these limitations, in this paper, we propose Belief
Tree Propagation (BTProp), a probabilistic framework for LLM hallucination
detection. BTProp introduces a belief tree of logically related statements by
recursively decomposing a parent statement into child statements with three
decomposition strategies, and builds a hidden Markov tree model to integrate
the LLM's belief scores in these statements in a principled way. Experiment
results show that our method improves baselines by 3%-9% (evaluated by AUROC
and AUC-PR) on multiple hallucination detection benchmarks. Code is available
at https://github.com/UCSB-NLP-Chang/BTProp.
|
[
-0.28330203890800476,
-0.9161279797554016,
0.8502526879310608,
0.3732535243034363,
-0.3781265914440155,
-0.03009197674691677,
0.0030245401430875063,
-0.542416512966156,
0.41231003403663635,
0.4386153817176819,
-0.7637444138526917,
-0.788345992565155,
-0.35859739780426025,
0.14693152904510498,
-0.2829938232898712,
0.6296412348747253,
0.20931720733642578,
0.0035122449044138193,
-0.14857257902622223,
0.3329460918903351,
-0.434240460395813,
-0.423423707485199,
-0.24521538615226746,
-0.3125530183315277,
0.17111307382583618,
0.07838795334100723,
0.5505648851394653,
0.6148757338523865,
0.1844439059495926,
0.18795454502105713,
-0.32496461272239685,
0.40493616461753845,
-0.11477240175008774,
0.2522144019603729,
-0.05014966428279877,
-0.5574137568473816,
-0.400835245847702,
-0.2522856295108795,
0.6680859327316284,
0.5904554128646851,
-0.27410757541656494,
-0.20019273459911346,
0.0596933588385582,
0.3565845489501953,
-0.43924206495285034,
0.18979166448116302,
-0.94471675157547,
0.5001431107521057,
0.10055408626794815,
-0.6100462079048157,
-0.6264119744300842,
-0.634844183921814,
-0.21096618473529816,
-0.12912984192371368,
0.41913899779319763,
0.07996999472379684,
0.27449682354927063,
0.3111002743244171,
-0.2361697554588318,
-0.2624530792236328,
-0.6547458171844482,
0.4806056618690491,
-0.628292977809906,
0.494162380695343,
0.43465831875801086,
0.18043288588523865,
-0.6225884556770325,
-0.20479780435562134,
-0.7473776936531067,
-0.4101710319519043,
-0.11414384096860886,
0.07166730612516403,
0.03505314886569977,
0.24095343053340912,
0.15017615258693695,
0.2700210511684418,
-0.6199666857719421,
-0.14932624995708466,
0.19179712235927582,
-0.365891695022583,
0.22852009534835815,
-0.22479724884033203,
-0.0695730671286583,
-0.47388631105422974,
-0.3390074372291565,
0.08484739810228348,
-0.6965839862823486,
-0.5253755450248718,
0.34282776713371277,
0.04242836683988571,
0.2938304543495178,
0.6633237600326538,
-0.14229820668697357,
0.5899801850318909,
0.1694268137216568,
-0.5414795875549316,
0.17632831633090973,
-0.3030545115470886,
-0.30941757559776306,
0.6328588128089905,
0.38284119963645935,
0.2475503832101822,
0.15810197591781616,
-0.28982681035995483,
-0.3177148401737213,
0.47196483612060547,
0.025338776409626007,
-0.7187811732292175,
-0.39182165265083313,
0.3589463531970978,
-0.6278914213180542,
-0.43186360597610474,
-0.23521481454372406,
-0.5663380026817322,
-0.6402633190155029,
-0.06529821455478668,
0.49272260069847107,
-0.6503766775131226,
-0.438196063041687,
0.32371261715888977,
0.1763806939125061,
-0.07124006003141403,
0.2629011571407318,
-0.726239025592804,
0.12125398963689804,
0.6306912302970886,
0.635990560054779,
-0.30508315563201904,
-0.005093220621347427,
-0.512914776802063,
0.3818935453891754,
-0.41026100516319275,
0.8490689396858215,
-0.3488912880420685,
-0.4797026813030243,
-0.06301341950893402,
0.08679318428039551,
0.06726156920194626,
-0.8620461225509644,
0.704416811466217,
-0.22636890411376953,
-0.0017427557613700628,
-0.01055467501282692,
-0.6547487378120422,
-0.36197030544281006,
0.19917264580726624,
-0.3903474807739258,
0.6524873971939087,
0.10035920888185501,
-0.8880735039710999,
0.37262916564941406,
-0.3264077305793762,
-0.42233848571777344,
0.10155101120471954,
-0.42986825108528137,
-0.5817663669586182,
0.28637203574180603,
0.23689834773540497,
0.5661624670028687,
0.3682089149951935,
0.552480936050415,
-0.2834065854549408,
-0.40183955430984497,
0.2506111264228821,
-0.6846389770507812,
0.6428434252738953,
0.12003391981124878,
-0.5452105402946472,
0.01357434131205082,
-0.7787986397743225,
-0.16917383670806885,
0.012876416556537151,
-0.18430940806865692,
-0.08903812617063522,
0.25903773307800293,
-0.4505707919597626,
-0.09232686460018158,
0.10160212218761444,
-0.5712978839874268,
0.45745232701301575,
-0.46847638487815857,
-0.32020583748817444,
0.8369978666305542,
0.41730639338493347,
-0.07626229524612427,
-0.29729488492012024,
0.30753135681152344,
0.3223625421524048,
0.22435030341148376,
-0.11362142860889435,
-0.6083498597145081,
-0.537398636341095,
-0.10886441916227341,
-0.16049246490001678,
0.4944310188293457,
-0.590663492679596,
1.011959433555603,
0.05675323307514191,
-0.1422787755727768,
-0.4529784917831421,
-0.005925548728555441,
0.3304697871208191,
0.9326301217079163,
0.6454253792762756,
0.1140657439827919,
-0.8238049745559692,
-0.9311935305595398,
0.05598307028412819,
-0.6079494953155518,
-0.01572605036199093,
-0.09875530749559402,
0.5010845065116882,
-0.556152880191803,
0.8027150630950928,
-0.5489363670349121,
-0.5640913844108582,
0.0030679279007017612,
0.14355772733688354,
0.31064876914024353,
0.5632370114326477,
0.18330863118171692,
-0.6912334561347961,
0.006816311273723841,
-0.03922127187252045,
-0.8809143304824829,
-0.17085148394107819,
-0.28949403762817383,
0.09232574701309204,
0.4770137071609497,
0.0035466665867716074,
-0.589446485042572,
0.8222254514694214,
0.5537954568862915,
-0.3645811080932617,
1.0039880275726318,
-0.1344948559999466,
0.037966471165418625,
-1.0397255420684814,
-0.5206572413444519,
-0.19545632600784302,
-0.3733407258987427,
-0.2762947678565979,
-0.04137345030903816,
-0.20169566571712494,
0.5745346546173096,
-0.19046646356582642,
-0.0882941409945488,
-0.24328292906284332,
-0.36366036534309387,
-0.338569700717926,
-0.03135686367750168,
-0.2609752118587494,
0.34266406297683716,
0.5235915780067444,
0.6451317667961121,
0.6028243899345398,
-0.4817635118961334,
0.28178778290748596,
0.2496536374092102,
-0.3092743456363678,
0.5427636504173279,
-0.2942470610141754,
-0.14428232610225677,
-0.028426913544535637,
0.33138182759284973,
-0.8487071394920349,
0.10145915299654007,
0.5753787159919739,
-0.49320104718208313,
0.16662271320819855,
-0.10130312293767929,
-0.7320510149002075,
-0.1699863225221634,
-0.27557483315467834,
0.05394976586103439,
0.531169593334198,
-0.9065343737602234,
0.6057170629501343,
-0.022291915491223335,
0.2794053852558136,
-0.5487675666809082,
-0.6487215161323547,
0.040227122604846954,
-0.13948646187782288,
-0.6702216863632202,
0.5971308946609497,
-0.27385595440864563,
-0.20170889794826508,
0.06803233176469803,
-0.6521209478378296,
0.41711539030075073,
0.10245518386363983,
0.4493981599807739,
0.16847209632396698,
-0.22016459703445435,
0.21590350568294525,
0.1679076850414276,
-0.18777990341186523,
0.3061840236186981,
-0.6309647560119629,
0.5324673056602478,
-0.2256610095500946,
-0.730118989944458,
-0.6877336502075195,
0.16080066561698914,
-0.015544355846941471,
0.44596269726753235,
0.7150146961212158,
0.4429793059825897,
-0.6803367733955383,
-0.46266576647758484,
-0.6120104789733887,
-0.4539981782436371,
-0.4439803659915924,
0.11952483654022217,
-0.6951207518577576,
-0.6225164532661438,
0.26083728671073914,
-0.3932130038738251,
-0.24085120856761932,
0.18049710988998413,
0.5083856582641602,
-0.2820051908493042,
1.0821125507354736,
0.46032026410102844,
0.23717550933361053,
0.009876941330730915,
-0.2141554355621338,
0.21326278150081635,
-0.7282251715660095,
-0.47590890526771545,
-0.17547179758548737,
0.06812424212694168,
-0.7227433323860168,
-0.679229199886322,
0.3277948200702667,
0.36771485209465027,
0.23133239150047302,
0.2274618148803711,
-0.8963013887405396,
0.3126698136329651,
0.4392431676387787,
0.3087279498577118,
0.7513456344604492,
0.15755301713943481,
-0.2612575590610504,
0.052585799247026443,
-0.3097127079963684,
-0.6406036019325256,
0.8626641631126404,
0.38376253843307495,
0.5698074102401733,
0.13003472983837128,
1.0682785511016846,
0.4911969006061554,
0.40561649203300476,
-0.7359938621520996,
0.882783830165863,
0.2625586986541748,
-0.4064369797706604,
-0.2952810227870941,
-0.45217758417129517,
-0.6890362501144409,
0.3190447688102722,
-0.2780475616455078,
-1.0185002088546753,
0.25955691933631897,
0.15622596442699432,
-0.06479277461767197,
0.499959796667099,
-0.44133561849594116,
0.5172582864761353,
-0.16483274102210999,
-0.19443219900131226,
-0.37129223346710205,
-0.41973811388015747,
0.5661805272102356,
-0.367178350687027,
-0.009883478283882141,
0.046702153980731964,
0.24178384244441986,
0.756725549697876,
-0.38070210814476013,
0.8081947565078735,
-0.3969520032405853,
-0.15141074359416962,
0.2552834153175354,
0.48246002197265625,
0.8123899102210999,
0.3511921167373657,
0.010147659108042717,
-0.041813746094703674,
0.0905836969614029,
-0.0174405537545681,
-0.6221332550048828,
0.6378050446510315,
-0.5220842361450195,
-0.9273063540458679,
-0.43934622406959534,
-0.42656150460243225,
-0.24433238804340363,
-0.03788293898105621,
0.014808918349444866,
0.015865908935666084,
0.012648156844079494,
0.13548028469085693,
0.9490777850151062,
-0.21601684391498566,
0.212515190243721,
0.1714109182357788,
-0.6590800285339355,
-0.32844725251197815,
0.7887674570083618,
-0.034762486815452576,
0.06129874661564827,
0.42445674538612366,
0.2609567642211914,
-0.6510600447654724,
-0.9961920380592346,
0.16262894868850708,
0.46732470393180847,
-0.8217207789421082,
-0.20099598169326782,
-0.630158543586731,
-0.26576173305511475,
-0.39430302381515503,
-0.04593445360660553,
-0.07632032036781311,
-0.38846129179000854,
-0.04451052099466324,
-0.5605015158653259,
0.3236579895019531,
0.42791318893432617,
-0.29691368341445923,
0.41319528222084045,
-0.2784307897090912,
0.7976285815238953,
0.3746461868286133,
0.20859019458293915,
-0.22460366785526276,
-0.459504634141922,
0.18275238573551178,
0.1086314395070076,
-0.3839496970176697,
-1.087863802909851,
0.504817545413971,
-0.23479507863521576,
0.5079002976417542,
0.7777978181838989,
0.2097388207912445,
0.7473483085632324,
-0.22738327085971832,
0.311791330575943,
0.2638518512248993,
-0.7695120573043823,
0.8564082384109497,
-0.05872007831931114,
-0.36102309823036194,
0.3744286298751831,
0.3765406608581543,
-0.22847267985343933,
-0.5419958829879761,
-0.7414081692695618,
-0.19430865347385406,
0.4205029308795929,
0.286896675825119,
-0.374738872051239,
-0.10177905857563019,
0.21518290042877197,
0.21914927661418915,
0.2596414089202881,
-0.9802897572517395,
-0.3116512894630432,
-0.10900215059518814,
-0.05989369750022888,
0.11777648329734802,
-0.4153801500797272,
-0.21126139163970947,
-0.3902125954627991,
0.6781980395317078,
-0.15519402921199799,
0.335165798664093,
0.41389229893684387,
0.009345848113298416,
-0.1676095426082611,
0.029677478596568108,
0.3297882080078125,
0.6108198165893555,
-0.8297747373580933,
0.6577362418174744,
0.08640404045581818,
-0.36090087890625,
0.2664567530155182,
-0.04093673825263977,
-0.47572723031044006,
0.2219814509153366,
0.4663589596748352,
0.4857693910598755,
-0.1889321208000183,
-0.4192877411842346,
0.44100886583328247,
0.16034619510173798,
-0.4066215455532074,
-0.5956106185913086,
0.02902282029390335,
0.2667803466320038,
0.38605937361717224,
0.5233048796653748,
0.11037565767765045,
0.16730988025665283,
-0.6782354116439819,
0.6281709671020508,
0.46110954880714417,
-0.10405144840478897,
-0.3584553599357605,
0.7337709069252014,
-0.2656918466091156,
-0.519159734249115,
0.4196062684059143,
-0.4654272496700287,
-0.6663573980331421,
0.37654051184654236,
0.9711095690727234,
0.9427374005317688,
-0.37920454144477844,
0.5130462050437927,
0.11797783523797989,
0.36100664734840393,
-0.04934440925717354,
0.4257560074329376,
-0.265219509601593,
-0.8885079622268677,
-0.5158625841140747,
-0.8730195164680481,
-0.32037296891212463,
0.2058171033859253,
-0.08866333216428757,
0.10582803189754486,
-0.29025644063949585,
0.04719969257712364,
-0.17640601098537445,
0.10035637766122818,
-0.2148546576499939,
0.25156646966934204,
0.23484937846660614,
0.6505753397941589,
-0.902213990688324,
1.1094691753387451,
0.08688363432884216,
-0.23184671998023987,
-0.6862412691116333,
0.40313518047332764,
-0.031318653374910355,
-0.8635744452476501,
0.6387444138526917,
0.3478478193283081,
-0.2879600524902344,
-0.09539850801229477,
-0.4359992444515228,
-0.4146304428577423,
1.0221282243728638,
0.2616702914237976,
-0.5806342363357544,
0.050543736666440964,
0.11827995628118515,
0.4508028030395508,
-0.5119972825050354,
-0.05487220734357834,
0.5300363302230835,
0.6409425139427185,
0.5079324841499329,
-0.38314247131347656,
0.36098554730415344,
0.3978908658027649,
-0.14196418225765228,
-0.18318168818950653,
-0.08078274875879288,
0.2907346189022064,
-0.3323060870170593,
-0.3097224235534668,
-0.1445963978767395,
0.8734989166259766,
0.8988654017448425,
0.5235269069671631,
0.6745174527168274,
0.48186901211738586,
0.9214206337928772,
0.06432278454303741,
0.7028165459632874,
-0.37594208121299744,
0.05065839737653732,
1.0852158069610596,
-0.10377159714698792,
0.7292549014091492,
0.7501618266105652,
-0.2378903478384018,
0.5303387641906738,
0.709947943687439,
-0.07598069310188293,
0.5219743251800537,
0.46609261631965637,
-0.5305776596069336,
-0.40494346618652344,
-0.41224899888038635,
-0.4459426999092102,
0.05312170833349228,
0.5177945494651794,
-0.30293333530426025,
-0.05902964994311333,
-0.11240778863430023,
-0.11544518917798996,
0.06390772759914398,
-0.05286872014403343,
0.39052748680114746,
0.09065782278776169,
-0.6016727089881897,
0.7479276657104492,
-0.14427165687084198,
0.7646023631095886,
-0.3479478657245636,
-0.42204126715660095,
-0.33989524841308594,
0.1700461506843567,
-0.5905861854553223,
-0.8251854181289673,
0.45035332441329956,
-0.34335488080978394,
0.10772360861301422,
-0.24367907643318176,
0.7329687476158142,
-0.36044055223464966,
-0.5126441717147827,
0.45283013582229614,
0.5150505304336548,
0.5292376279830933,
-0.18148019909858704,
-0.2601928114891052,
-0.03573247790336609,
0.25369834899902344,
-0.26188284158706665,
0.18827740848064423,
0.5869595408439636,
0.0070986379869282246,
0.8577467203140259,
0.7459088563919067,
0.5399370193481445,
0.04555148258805275,
0.14930006861686707,
0.7911984324455261,
-0.4521206021308899,
-0.15038138628005981,
-0.8572899103164673,
0.042329154908657074,
-0.01974751241505146,
0.32580941915512085,
0.7956519722938538,
0.6160631775856018,
0.6213072538375854,
-0.05415675416588783,
0.5663729906082153,
0.23672054708003998,
0.38255301117897034,
-0.611346960067749,
0.33188119530677795,
-0.28294190764427185,
0.5841284394264221,
-0.31230464577674866,
-1.122107744216919,
-0.4408509433269501,
0.9502658843994141,
-0.049295760691165924,
-0.13721652328968048,
0.8490484356880188,
1.0641677379608154,
0.12092489749193192,
0.05223453789949417,
0.5040526390075684,
0.4203488528728485,
0.2043629288673401,
0.5793974995613098,
0.9989363551139832,
-0.071645088493824,
0.45545223355293274,
-0.3846287429332733,
-0.2670906186103821,
-0.2837561070919037,
-0.915115475654602,
-0.7348431944847107,
-0.5394549369812012,
-0.6531167030334473,
-0.4479162395000458,
0.0943518802523613,
0.7372980713844299,
0.5875293612480164,
-0.7220749258995056,
-0.02303234487771988,
-0.47180092334747314,
0.636874258518219,
-0.48666587471961975,
-0.2687828540802002,
0.6604411602020264,
-0.0799080953001976,
-0.31923946738243103,
0.6573543548583984,
0.41653284430503845,
0.24363301694393158,
-0.47653478384017944,
-0.1795703023672104,
-0.21261893212795258,
-0.10228077322244644,
0.5492912530899048,
-0.13181789219379425,
-0.9461051225662231,
-0.5580074787139893,
-0.1330007016658783,
0.2951880097389221,
0.16466708481311798,
0.33410951495170593,
-1.155510425567627,
0.4789541959762573,
0.3092617988586426,
0.44854384660720825,
0.5285290479660034,
0.23020832240581512,
0.11033502966165543,
-0.8266828060150146,
-0.08573034405708313,
0.41457638144493103,
0.3700719475746155,
0.14309397339820862,
-0.5643255114555359,
0.8252958655357361,
0.7945530414581299,
-0.391337126493454,
-1.0785797834396362,
0.30839142203330994,
-1.0913478136062622,
-0.5145788788795471,
1.1155565977096558,
0.10723616182804108,
-0.12393978238105774,
-0.2889676094055176,
-0.22709299623966217,
0.24665947258472443,
-0.11136762797832489,
0.9954881072044373,
0.38976404070854187,
-0.5144994258880615,
-0.12912261486053467,
-0.32669249176979065,
0.5084331631660461,
0.2125755250453949,
-0.6973770260810852,
0.13048963248729706,
0.574604332447052,
0.12862879037857056,
0.3960850238800049,
0.7224984169006348,
0.12946462631225586,
-0.03193606808781624,
0.1284707933664322,
0.20136843621730804,
-0.12144605815410614,
-0.4750443994998932,
-0.1732303351163864,
0.38940688967704773,
0.06508663296699524,
-0.26365360617637634
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06938v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06938v1
|
Post-Hoc Answer Attribution for Grounded and Trustworthy Long Document Comprehension: Task, Insights, and Challenges
| 2024-06-11T04:31:54 | 2024-06-11T04:31:54 |
Abhilasha Sancheti, Koustava Goswami, Balaji Vasan Srinivasan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Attributing answer text to its source document for information-seeking
questions is crucial for building trustworthy, reliable, and accountable
systems. We formulate a new task of post-hoc answer attribution for long
document comprehension (LDC). Owing to the lack of long-form abstractive and
information-seeking LDC datasets, we refactor existing datasets to assess the
strengths and weaknesses of existing retrieval-based and proposed answer
decomposition and textual entailment-based optimal selection attribution
systems for this task. We throw light on the limitations of existing datasets
and the need for datasets to assess the actual performance of systems on this
task.
|
[
-0.4018043279647827,
-0.6305311918258667,
0.9897270202636719,
-0.025755535811185837,
-0.465570867061615,
-0.12762975692749023,
0.06088868901133537,
-0.5689716339111328,
0.3097468614578247,
0.4952341616153717,
-0.7311134338378906,
-0.17643104493618011,
-0.5109046697616577,
0.2799204885959625,
-0.3751738667488098,
1.0877745151519775,
-0.3798845708370209,
-0.3524039387702942,
-0.9325109124183655,
-0.25987663865089417,
-0.3351324498653412,
-0.520810067653656,
-0.6269733309745789,
-0.3704359531402588,
0.5762379765510559,
0.49590569734573364,
0.31336989998817444,
0.40551337599754333,
0.5416125059127808,
0.12299653142690659,
-0.24337194859981537,
0.16851095855236053,
-0.6471535563468933,
0.2680642902851105,
-0.45953235030174255,
-0.2219100296497345,
-0.39087459444999695,
0.22558723390102386,
0.5548243522644043,
0.6505207419395447,
-0.1978609561920166,
0.5421174168586731,
0.10115629434585571,
0.7672635316848755,
-0.9815051555633545,
0.14225663244724274,
-0.6206669211387634,
-0.24434176087379456,
0.02842126414179802,
-0.49459680914878845,
-0.508028507232666,
-0.714185893535614,
0.13285735249519348,
-1.0008878707885742,
0.1569698601961136,
0.0015705983387306333,
0.4364003539085388,
0.34715548157691956,
-0.6691672205924988,
-0.7461420893669128,
-0.548171877861023,
0.7952075600624084,
-0.23183706402778625,
0.23166397213935852,
0.9355396628379822,
0.12448789179325104,
0.2751776874065399,
-0.5200027227401733,
-0.22963039577007294,
0.019563984125852585,
-0.18905134499073029,
0.277055025100708,
0.17227362096309662,
-0.19180083274841309,
0.1773197501897812,
0.34595435857772827,
-0.5228996872901917,
-0.05095737427473068,
-0.5088019967079163,
-0.24542471766471863,
0.6138233542442322,
0.016766397282481194,
-0.3359602689743042,
-0.29606905579566956,
-0.42021381855010986,
0.026057207956910133,
-0.7473668456077576,
0.16197235882282257,
0.34663912653923035,
-0.11293996125459671,
0.24320539832115173,
0.7519050240516663,
-0.3980415463447571,
0.6591863036155701,
-0.04649604484438896,
0.2519778609275818,
0.09458185732364655,
-0.7156351208686829,
0.10913360863924026,
0.40758463740348816,
0.26154106855392456,
0.43730852007865906,
0.12347953021526337,
-0.0781097561120987,
-0.47848260402679443,
-0.09055513143539429,
0.34734854102134705,
-0.6872671246528625,
-0.02877463772892952,
0.24710892140865326,
-0.6741892695426941,
-0.4699622392654419,
0.19703997671604156,
-0.5797457098960876,
-0.40575215220451355,
-0.5013558268547058,
0.23479235172271729,
-0.19672143459320068,
-0.13431128859519958,
-0.0773267149925232,
-0.3840154707431793,
0.541589617729187,
0.5732693076133728,
-0.5942727327346802,
0.41975995898246765,
0.6044572591781616,
0.7300518751144409,
-0.2981652021408081,
-0.043478045612573624,
-0.7106677293777466,
0.26989009976387024,
-0.5237785577774048,
1.0034236907958984,
-0.378741592168808,
-0.4339727759361267,
0.06674319505691528,
0.16731862723827362,
0.11969482153654099,
-0.6776192784309387,
0.9304589629173279,
-0.7921965718269348,
0.20518803596496582,
-0.6960225701332092,
-0.619432270526886,
0.2325444519519806,
0.41935136914253235,
-0.873690128326416,
0.989456832408905,
0.19978658854961395,
-1.099067211151123,
0.34322965145111084,
-0.704520046710968,
-0.578711748123169,
-0.18663497269153595,
-0.04613868147134781,
-0.06436678767204285,
0.0739932432770729,
0.33749377727508545,
0.4177408516407013,
-0.5193065404891968,
0.12604646384716034,
-0.300680011510849,
-0.32963553071022034,
0.38309144973754883,
-0.2624456584453583,
0.9572126865386963,
0.3505290746688843,
0.0005021868273615837,
0.022025160491466522,
-0.8175732493400574,
0.14518822729587555,
0.2264685034751892,
-0.505928635597229,
-0.4352538585662842,
0.31307661533355713,
-0.2128489911556244,
-0.059720639139413834,
0.3808198869228363,
-0.7416999936103821,
-0.3091268539428711,
-0.17886917293071747,
0.3060795068740845,
1.083784818649292,
0.0014430523151531816,
0.43592941761016846,
-0.514123797416687,
0.6199563145637512,
-0.230089470744133,
0.03972887992858887,
-0.08776405453681946,
-0.16998401284217834,
-0.2151833474636078,
-0.008629035204648972,
-0.07786529511213303,
0.5800219774246216,
-1.0513179302215576,
0.41412219405174255,
-0.41590020060539246,
-0.29718661308288574,
-0.46570271253585815,
-0.04870842397212982,
0.2793128192424774,
0.9039943814277649,
0.5097451210021973,
-0.0014669967349618673,
-0.2914324998855591,
-0.8643022775650024,
-0.09887435287237167,
-0.2926008999347687,
-0.4007379114627838,
0.38522326946258545,
0.5376573801040649,
0.11753436177968979,
0.925070583820343,
-0.8040640950202942,
0.011356484144926071,
0.005325627513229847,
-0.0959315076470375,
0.10446007549762726,
0.26551109552383423,
0.37717190384864807,
-0.8822808265686035,
-0.23652568459510803,
-0.18778479099273682,
-0.9010342955589294,
-0.040270522236824036,
0.15999387204647064,
-0.04373212158679962,
0.148451566696167,
0.7538152933120728,
-0.6652187705039978,
0.37111830711364746,
0.3262331783771515,
-0.27737948298454285,
0.9242036938667297,
-0.07451026141643524,
0.4229620695114136,
-0.8546388745307922,
0.511110782623291,
-0.46721455454826355,
-0.24293836951255798,
-0.10357391834259033,
0.08345021307468414,
0.15542109310626984,
-0.19148969650268555,
-0.3418833315372467,
0.5832733511924744,
-0.3270609676837921,
-0.10002255439758301,
-0.0966733992099762,
0.41867566108703613,
0.11809036880731583,
0.18423917889595032,
-0.011352071538567543,
0.5162116289138794,
0.35641101002693176,
-0.5486944317817688,
0.945235013961792,
0.36208802461624146,
-0.5738202929496765,
0.8389779925346375,
-0.8346244096755981,
0.2956406772136688,
-0.5210582613945007,
0.6011285185813904,
-0.9845126271247864,
-0.41729938983917236,
0.13869604468345642,
-0.5436754822731018,
0.0024581204634159803,
0.10418103635311127,
-0.4973345100879669,
-0.3776131272315979,
-0.5695393681526184,
0.6294989585876465,
0.31332454085350037,
-0.6476492285728455,
0.21513807773590088,
0.05595056340098381,
-0.2852436304092407,
-0.6673486232757568,
-0.6287783980369568,
-0.30262425541877747,
-0.11773056536912918,
-0.4864058494567871,
0.26147785782814026,
-0.1233898475766182,
-0.2806119918823242,
0.0030058231204748154,
-0.306747704744339,
-0.12408389151096344,
0.05321928486227989,
0.05650802329182625,
0.10533027350902557,
-0.2241280972957611,
0.30285659432411194,
0.05900295823812485,
-0.38970157504081726,
0.38540926575660706,
0.0020810049027204514,
0.14614659547805786,
0.15071256458759308,
-0.5408207178115845,
-0.2729719281196594,
0.8557281494140625,
0.45923930406570435,
-0.3794174790382385,
0.9256555438041687,
0.1359332650899887,
-0.4660347104072571,
-0.08944980055093765,
-0.40462446212768555,
-0.46807047724723816,
-0.4509964883327484,
0.15866176784038544,
-0.2549629509449005,
-0.8618465662002563,
0.6908624172210693,
0.10371038317680359,
-0.0029657301492989063,
0.5492836833000183,
0.09395520389080048,
-0.24172578752040863,
0.3741251528263092,
0.24754035472869873,
-0.018630042672157288,
0.17223891615867615,
0.10207828134298325,
-0.01814369112253189,
-0.7313177585601807,
-0.2411404252052307,
-0.7666263580322266,
-0.008816637098789215,
-0.24262882769107819,
-0.218324676156044,
-0.06817232817411423,
0.04128503054380417,
-0.07429912686347961,
0.0298074372112751,
-0.5311171412467957,
0.46370580792427063,
0.44609448313713074,
0.37333789467811584,
0.2976498305797577,
-0.12815065681934357,
0.2808879315853119,
0.21553286910057068,
-0.24714824557304382,
-0.3837549686431885,
1.0892212390899658,
0.21902373433113098,
0.7033939957618713,
0.014347393997013569,
0.4509035646915436,
0.2908810079097748,
0.21603180468082428,
-0.7717328667640686,
0.5620868802070618,
0.12465671449899673,
-0.8584829568862915,
-0.6701244711875916,
-0.45703309774398804,
-0.7379976511001587,
-0.15932415425777435,
0.07083006948232651,
-0.49398913979530334,
0.0344993881881237,
0.14475657045841217,
-0.12579227983951569,
0.007807827088981867,
-0.4858244061470032,
0.7412238121032715,
0.18879170715808868,
-0.1656617373228073,
-0.12607283890247345,
-0.8522422909736633,
0.08220914751291275,
-0.35636356472969055,
0.10881078243255615,
0.021403994411230087,
-0.007086360827088356,
1.1049587726593018,
-0.31593024730682373,
0.34421947598457336,
-0.23838721215724945,
-0.26152071356773376,
0.6734459400177002,
-0.07749778777360916,
0.8830075263977051,
0.1058688685297966,
-0.6242445111274719,
-0.38869333267211914,
0.26491060853004456,
-0.5869426131248474,
-0.6309763789176941,
0.5755653977394104,
-0.48324787616729736,
-0.4742140471935272,
-0.23841416835784912,
0.10644256323575974,
-0.17227928340435028,
0.28288552165031433,
0.4651087820529938,
0.4899480640888214,
-0.360272616147995,
0.7258750796318054,
0.8191335201263428,
0.05213721841573715,
0.08325537294149399,
0.25262704491615295,
0.0829324796795845,
-0.20085260272026062,
0.706601619720459,
0.038335446268320084,
0.2613126337528229,
0.3773931860923767,
0.03883077949285507,
-0.4023714065551758,
-0.7307753562927246,
-0.18437625467777252,
0.17747247219085693,
-1.0815870761871338,
-0.2468453347682953,
-0.25206801295280457,
-0.20090891420841217,
-0.4723745584487915,
-0.6024485230445862,
-0.3785706162452698,
-0.2350025773048401,
-0.6325315237045288,
-0.6039804816246033,
0.22541522979736328,
0.6414742469787598,
0.15790726244449615,
0.05734918266534805,
-0.5514597296714783,
0.49023061990737915,
0.3248312473297119,
0.5138869285583496,
-0.277778685092926,
-0.49202150106430054,
-0.2967280447483063,
0.21779382228851318,
-0.1868380755186081,
-0.94877690076828,
-0.24821670353412628,
0.06746820360422134,
0.7142102122306824,
0.21324139833450317,
0.608643114566803,
0.4144327938556671,
-0.18649454414844513,
0.7580711841583252,
0.05212468281388283,
-0.6140857338905334,
0.8840036988258362,
-0.4649636447429657,
0.29516687989234924,
0.7925131916999817,
0.6924445629119873,
-0.32841888070106506,
-0.2092912346124649,
-0.37878817319869995,
-0.942824125289917,
0.8936684131622314,
0.27100056409835815,
-0.18938231468200684,
0.04115383327007294,
0.703334391117096,
0.10426181554794312,
0.14350929856300354,
-0.5100794434547424,
-0.03792668133974075,
-0.26768210530281067,
-0.15094883739948273,
-0.39400559663772583,
-0.42204567790031433,
-0.3207504451274872,
0.018496200442314148,
0.5669927597045898,
-0.26315775513648987,
0.2844584286212921,
0.47609660029411316,
-0.1756618320941925,
-0.24421364068984985,
0.19858592748641968,
0.46555840969085693,
0.9503525495529175,
-0.3594770133495331,
0.3349320888519287,
0.1835954487323761,
-0.3720046579837799,
0.22629228234291077,
0.1078265830874443,
0.09180823713541031,
-0.19626285135746002,
0.6716521978378296,
0.49607524275779724,
-0.15237073600292206,
-0.6504039168357849,
0.5955691933631897,
0.1206854060292244,
-0.44773703813552856,
-0.4536212682723999,
-0.18889784812927246,
0.17320391535758972,
-0.21335366368293762,
0.6360575556755066,
-0.07103578746318817,
0.2445935755968094,
-0.3952864110469818,
0.44522783160209656,
0.20998676121234894,
-0.5465796589851379,
-0.08019090443849564,
0.36164191365242004,
0.08259985595941544,
0.0028227863367646933,
0.9255436062812805,
0.132036030292511,
-0.15036767721176147,
0.6961653232574463,
0.4290190637111664,
0.610832154750824,
-0.37196704745292664,
0.36423325538635254,
0.3477785289287567,
0.24420161545276642,
-0.038945093750953674,
0.04405460134148598,
-0.19360089302062988,
-0.5565313696861267,
-0.338647723197937,
-0.4401131272315979,
-0.18661253154277802,
-0.021591821685433388,
-1.0248881578445435,
0.08766428381204605,
-0.3489310145378113,
0.04317917674779892,
-0.16234850883483887,
-0.14545857906341553,
-0.44299083948135376,
0.2740795612335205,
-0.08969585597515106,
0.8176373839378357,
-0.7775754332542419,
0.6279079914093018,
0.6381791830062866,
-0.06487860530614853,
-0.5152411460876465,
-0.1889592409133911,
-0.11558974534273148,
-0.534403920173645,
0.4775744378566742,
0.14091216027736664,
-0.36071667075157166,
-0.14772748947143555,
-0.6621476411819458,
-0.8484606146812439,
1.208253026008606,
0.5108960866928101,
0.2096836268901825,
-0.17740146815776825,
-0.07529836148023605,
0.3766866624355316,
-0.1537320613861084,
0.13198600709438324,
0.3837885856628418,
0.46879610419273376,
0.24781300127506256,
-0.9304898977279663,
0.31161439418792725,
-0.18757224082946777,
-0.3567996621131897,
-0.01363085675984621,
-0.3651382327079773,
0.664658784866333,
0.005493752658367157,
-0.2145567238330841,
-0.1779155731201172,
0.5611757040023804,
0.3544866144657135,
0.5604496598243713,
0.5693366527557373,
0.26515740156173706,
0.7492387890815735,
0.05803265422582626,
1.0344793796539307,
0.34739071130752563,
0.3674679696559906,
1.2606194019317627,
-0.22179651260375977,
1.044132947921753,
0.762575089931488,
-0.19052457809448242,
0.3878971040248871,
0.9419626593589783,
0.3547913432121277,
0.7059651017189026,
0.2858301103115082,
-0.3468524217605591,
-0.1968795508146286,
-0.29621729254722595,
-0.36915212869644165,
0.36647844314575195,
0.36061206459999084,
-0.4132889211177826,
-0.18410466611385345,
-0.0707710012793541,
-0.32983285188674927,
0.045614298433065414,
-0.16473060846328735,
0.9016702175140381,
-0.011848370544612408,
-0.8245207071304321,
0.5530758500099182,
-0.1680273860692978,
0.26319146156311035,
-0.6891173124313354,
0.06281869858503342,
-0.1351429969072342,
0.06392811238765717,
-0.30092281103134155,
-1.1379908323287964,
0.5933705568313599,
-0.2467583864927292,
-0.36015644669532776,
-0.4699254035949707,
0.902066707611084,
-0.14905205368995667,
-0.1814035177230835,
0.3584289848804474,
0.1837625652551651,
0.13135968148708344,
-0.42125654220581055,
-0.34745165705680847,
-0.1125166192650795,
0.014883342199027538,
-0.6880425810813904,
0.12474296987056732,
0.5545644760131836,
0.10212833434343338,
0.7518948912620544,
0.671374499797821,
-0.20471253991127014,
-0.18658089637756348,
-0.58808434009552,
1.0218802690505981,
-0.5434363484382629,
-0.7089337110519409,
-0.4503931999206543,
0.5328779220581055,
-0.2358693927526474,
-0.08552607148885727,
0.5647833943367004,
0.6117238402366638,
0.6937380433082581,
-0.08137503266334534,
0.747002124786377,
-0.05870497599244118,
0.7989324331283569,
-0.6476070284843445,
0.7567753791809082,
-0.7227551341056824,
0.05533761531114578,
-0.1805744469165802,
-0.9320323467254639,
-0.04093119129538536,
0.49382859468460083,
-0.23902791738510132,
-0.08306708186864853,
1.0097651481628418,
0.5304217338562012,
-0.03797776624560356,
0.09072820842266083,
0.10564441233873367,
-0.2244005650281906,
0.40283331274986267,
0.48556873202323914,
0.7966360449790955,
-0.3024839460849762,
0.668831467628479,
0.02304234355688095,
-0.3497450351715088,
-0.40530234575271606,
-0.8960909843444824,
-0.513347864151001,
-0.8538829684257507,
-0.19601845741271973,
-0.30230027437210083,
0.07311441749334335,
0.5027905106544495,
0.35178104043006897,
-0.82300865650177,
0.01226835511624813,
0.0985163003206253,
0.3754108250141144,
-0.0013235446531325579,
-0.24958482384681702,
0.6718060374259949,
-0.03954702243208885,
-0.007497215177863836,
0.2446364015340805,
-0.09399724751710892,
0.007441220339387655,
0.1384076625108719,
-0.11716947704553604,
-0.1930796205997467,
0.03705310449004173,
0.7933447360992432,
0.20473912358283997,
-0.5075027346611023,
-0.6092561483383179,
0.22934672236442566,
-0.14085915684700012,
-0.06585267931222916,
1.2013357877731323,
-0.503918468952179,
0.43509185314178467,
0.5708595514297485,
0.6996477246284485,
0.2914426028728485,
0.31089314818382263,
0.47583723068237305,
-0.7235326766967773,
0.08670848608016968,
0.46492472290992737,
0.06603420525789261,
0.16848531365394592,
-0.45371806621551514,
0.3601851761341095,
0.12118213623762131,
-0.7454210519790649,
-0.6912207007408142,
0.2144172042608261,
-1.0344918966293335,
-0.42892757058143616,
1.2033400535583496,
-0.330400675535202,
-0.08154191821813583,
-0.4127205014228821,
-0.22293049097061157,
0.1982688158750534,
-0.32027965784072876,
0.45086777210235596,
1.028145670890808,
-0.0315094068646431,
-0.10709361732006073,
-0.41313523054122925,
0.6559774279594421,
0.30367881059646606,
-0.9798991680145264,
0.5437390208244324,
0.7036741971969604,
-0.023492608219385147,
0.1337074339389801,
1.0644201040267944,
-0.11211151629686356,
0.186168372631073,
0.11629554629325867,
-0.4292603135108948,
0.02393903210759163,
-0.3391556441783905,
0.008888320066034794,
0.29949474334716797,
0.13616304099559784,
-0.19502602517604828
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06937v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06937v1
|
A Non-autoregressive Generation Framework for End-to-End Simultaneous Speech-to-Any Translation
| 2024-06-11T04:25:48 | 2024-06-11T04:25:48 |
Zhengrui Ma, Qingkai Fang, Shaolei Zhang, Shoutao Guo, Yang Feng, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Simultaneous translation models play a crucial role in facilitating
communication. However, existing research primarily focuses on text-to-text or
speech-to-text models, necessitating additional cascade components to achieve
speech-to-speech translation. These pipeline methods suffer from error
propagation and accumulate delays in each cascade component, resulting in
reduced synchronization between the speaker and listener. To overcome these
challenges, we propose a novel non-autoregressive generation framework for
simultaneous speech translation (NAST-S2X), which integrates speech-to-text and
speech-to-speech tasks into a unified end-to-end framework. We develop a
non-autoregressive decoder capable of concurrently generating multiple text or
acoustic unit tokens upon receiving fixed-length speech chunks. The decoder can
generate blank or repeated tokens and employ CTC decoding to dynamically adjust
its latency. Experimental results show that NAST-S2X outperforms
state-of-the-art models in both speech-to-text and speech-to-speech tasks. It
achieves high-quality simultaneous interpretation within a delay of less than 3
seconds and provides a 28 times decoding speedup in offline generation.
|
[
-0.10466646403074265,
-0.5275247693061829,
0.12468875199556351,
0.5779178738594055,
-0.7043747305870056,
0.12609803676605225,
-0.20679661631584167,
-0.375146746635437,
0.325486421585083,
0.35723939538002014,
-0.6173579096794128,
-0.13710343837738037,
-0.5845922827720642,
0.35478341579437256,
-0.7557345032691956,
0.9926251173019409,
0.05794307589530945,
-0.16827991604804993,
-0.02444477006793022,
-0.13442973792552948,
-0.602506160736084,
-0.28876084089279175,
-0.7054623961448669,
-0.08331456780433655,
-0.1173604279756546,
0.33892565965652466,
0.5435413718223572,
0.7307758927345276,
-0.0034959944896399975,
0.16593268513679504,
0.07696804404258728,
0.23924191296100616,
-0.40153399109840393,
0.47205427289009094,
-0.09727797657251358,
-0.10521932691335678,
-0.4606736898422241,
-0.4297908544540405,
0.8566082119941711,
0.36586230993270874,
-0.1584530919790268,
0.07257528603076935,
-0.06364341825246811,
0.42747437953948975,
-0.48790132999420166,
0.26353704929351807,
-0.5599528551101685,
-0.00679723359644413,
-0.23772265017032623,
-0.3189728856086731,
-0.4219878017902374,
-0.21748360991477966,
-0.13546793162822723,
-0.30999723076820374,
-0.010505130514502525,
-0.021688692271709442,
0.39911916851997375,
0.653679609298706,
-0.6818941831588745,
-0.061189182102680206,
-0.5000069737434387,
0.5870040655136108,
-0.765410840511322,
0.6333328485488892,
0.016233578324317932,
0.11345082521438599,
-0.18369023501873016,
-0.744805097579956,
-0.6363298296928406,
0.059092842042446136,
0.21614256501197815,
0.47994691133499146,
-0.2929976284503937,
-0.04059997573494911,
-0.2543456554412842,
0.3730469048023224,
-0.7492620348930359,
0.05298139527440071,
0.23291389644145966,
0.011168735101819038,
0.6121924519538879,
0.02957364358007908,
0.18787448108196259,
-0.34335893392562866,
-0.4610659182071686,
0.1376798450946808,
-0.39196261763572693,
-0.09759381413459778,
0.1260225921869278,
0.40981540083885193,
-0.3470693528652191,
0.38149046897888184,
-0.12673057615756989,
0.49484556913375854,
0.3005627989768982,
0.10713952034711838,
0.22511768341064453,
-0.7072457075119019,
-0.20860029757022858,
0.23563005030155182,
0.973199725151062,
0.2048317939043045,
-0.33231937885284424,
-0.6525415778160095,
-0.31183677911758423,
0.020338861271739006,
-0.048526421189308167,
-0.58710116147995,
0.10794331133365631,
0.22204117476940155,
-0.4574258327484131,
-0.4137020409107208,
-0.3128584623336792,
-0.741759717464447,
0.2940642833709717,
0.1324402093887329,
0.38785499334335327,
0.004766977392137051,
-0.5781294107437134,
0.050824958831071854,
-0.04441780596971512,
0.08525767177343369,
-0.06648269295692444,
-0.7696565985679626,
0.5102108716964722,
0.17091765999794006,
1.0069026947021484,
-0.42324212193489075,
-0.12867605686187744,
-0.8293816447257996,
0.08553413301706314,
-0.5981717705726624,
0.6535736918449402,
-0.02972324937582016,
-0.5626257061958313,
-0.22591282427310944,
-0.2656000852584839,
-0.022855818271636963,
-0.07089243084192276,
0.4890904128551483,
-0.29567477107048035,
0.20869435369968414,
0.07295866310596466,
-0.29828447103500366,
0.1819264143705368,
-0.39602112770080566,
-0.3274781107902527,
1.0591413974761963,
0.20562776923179626,
-0.674445629119873,
0.054264649748802185,
-0.781096875667572,
-0.6886895298957825,
0.11317136138677597,
-0.3458344638347626,
-0.5593185424804688,
0.31472107768058777,
0.11438432335853577,
0.13503868877887726,
-0.7333468794822693,
0.629939079284668,
0.1323433816432953,
-0.08651436120271683,
0.04658365249633789,
-0.7214733362197876,
0.5784951448440552,
0.3591167628765106,
-0.6548985838890076,
-0.03659217804670334,
-0.8838209509849548,
0.22870424389839172,
0.32445695996284485,
-0.2588348984718323,
0.21512426435947418,
0.0371091291308403,
0.4995761811733246,
0.6533362865447998,
0.317707896232605,
-0.633265495300293,
-0.07885942608118057,
-0.36069777607917786,
0.566910445690155,
0.501314103603363,
0.07758896052837372,
0.44783952832221985,
-0.3307086229324341,
0.23067179322242737,
-0.05471163988113403,
-0.11389689147472382,
-0.6305912137031555,
-0.6424865126609802,
-0.7749391794204712,
-0.00455732736736536,
0.06870490312576294,
0.576169490814209,
-0.8769130706787109,
0.5123838186264038,
-0.3674650192260742,
-0.3076011836528778,
-0.3620856702327728,
-0.1512591540813446,
0.6175068616867065,
0.486245334148407,
0.4939551055431366,
-0.47586357593536377,
-0.5771950483322144,
-0.5745671987533569,
-0.20819644629955292,
-0.18168972432613373,
0.07065393775701523,
0.09483140707015991,
0.15722472965717316,
0.018863657489418983,
1.0068527460098267,
0.08206493407487869,
-0.2837676703929901,
-0.08033500611782074,
0.4902457296848297,
-0.05543329939246178,
0.4753308892250061,
0.2369263917207718,
-0.6605557799339294,
-0.4820317029953003,
-0.023475734516978264,
-0.541485071182251,
-0.49854716658592224,
-0.3663291037082672,
-0.09034696221351624,
0.5519025325775146,
0.41913148760795593,
-0.2229434847831726,
0.5014280676841736,
0.6634408831596375,
-0.2667330801486969,
0.36736437678337097,
-0.3539162278175354,
-0.03941057249903679,
-1.345970869064331,
0.32190167903900146,
-0.47158175706863403,
-0.5853726267814636,
-0.752597451210022,
-0.1320195347070694,
0.012190400622785091,
-0.14882966876029968,
-0.4339753985404968,
0.302640825510025,
-0.5361322164535522,
-0.3389972746372223,
-0.6225396394729614,
0.3721922039985657,
-0.026888972148299217,
0.38469579815864563,
0.2606271207332611,
1.0048327445983887,
0.4274681508541107,
-0.4193962812423706,
0.15591895580291748,
0.5043242573738098,
0.025904575362801552,
0.4801967442035675,
-0.4420544505119324,
0.44842833280563354,
-0.10283161699771881,
0.56625896692276,
-0.8451118469238281,
0.017945706844329834,
0.019630510360002518,
-0.7868019342422485,
0.25633591413497925,
-0.0023599877022206783,
-0.6254752278327942,
-0.03846783563494682,
0.19623488187789917,
0.49282240867614746,
0.513270378112793,
-0.5413814783096313,
0.35906028747558594,
0.2900240123271942,
-0.3767561614513397,
-0.38572996854782104,
-0.8652626276016235,
0.5433744192123413,
0.2546413838863373,
-0.7164359092712402,
0.5173258781433105,
-0.05880914255976677,
0.2846183180809021,
-0.03671935945749283,
-0.27577444911003113,
-0.09345611184835434,
-0.25515469908714294,
0.13774770498275757,
0.04415373504161835,
-0.2678976058959961,
-0.03143749013543129,
0.27870291471481323,
-0.5009487271308899,
-0.27491289377212524,
-0.9733765721321106,
0.3240475058555603,
0.3176351487636566,
-0.14150641858577728,
-0.6029775738716125,
1.0628186464309692,
0.6212958097457886,
-0.3378292918205261,
0.4416658580303192,
0.4094698131084442,
-0.15967458486557007,
-0.15365120768547058,
-0.40426105260849,
-0.12007376551628113,
-0.3901212513446808,
0.457423597574234,
-0.33564454317092896,
-0.7283611297607422,
0.17623670399188995,
0.0618964321911335,
0.3883456587791443,
0.2733871340751648,
0.6712465286254883,
0.2613610625267029,
0.8825163245201111,
0.5137377381324768,
0.15360935032367706,
0.37102609872817993,
0.06115878373384476,
0.3446063697338104,
-0.7015721201896667,
-0.15046755969524384,
-0.19953177869319916,
-0.0574202761054039,
-0.4044409692287445,
-0.6156627535820007,
0.18950605392456055,
0.05759988725185394,
0.047936346381902695,
0.5471958518028259,
-0.4031488001346588,
-0.0005963545991107821,
0.3388933837413788,
-0.5588170886039734,
0.3786342740058899,
0.051035456359386444,
-0.20214372873306274,
-0.0024057242553681135,
-0.7780716419219971,
-0.22035372257232666,
0.894927442073822,
0.009279166348278522,
0.1953279674053192,
0.2871003746986389,
0.6069329380989075,
0.15212848782539368,
-0.15385837852954865,
-0.34902480244636536,
0.2921943664550781,
-0.4889746308326721,
-0.42839694023132324,
-0.15478701889514923,
-0.5749132633209229,
-0.5999788641929626,
0.33642643690109253,
-0.04962698742747307,
-0.6457945704460144,
0.15214642882347107,
0.08357220143079758,
-0.22115646302700043,
0.3296995759010315,
-0.4095715582370758,
0.5389431715011597,
-0.2742482125759125,
-0.48857396841049194,
0.23957334458827972,
-0.9192884564399719,
0.1376965194940567,
-0.33468326926231384,
0.26425468921661377,
0.04032149165868759,
-0.0603795051574707,
0.5330198407173157,
-0.27941814064979553,
0.5301947593688965,
-0.14046941697597504,
-0.1442064642906189,
0.19936040043830872,
0.06391879916191101,
0.7608323693275452,
0.20869332551956177,
0.0016701238928362727,
0.2280135303735733,
-0.08834057301282883,
-0.2896396517753601,
-0.490710973739624,
0.5841888189315796,
-0.5803446173667908,
-0.13386383652687073,
-0.3233177661895752,
-0.6210059523582458,
-0.1489521563053131,
0.2296133190393448,
0.5916631817817688,
0.43599259853363037,
-0.03510986641049385,
0.01447305828332901,
0.29551345109939575,
0.012134387157857418,
0.6848993301391602,
0.5980514287948608,
-0.09693806618452072,
-0.693044900894165,
1.0224528312683105,
0.11795967817306519,
0.6322213411331177,
0.4198854863643646,
-0.24095472693443298,
-0.7222607135772705,
-0.471432626247406,
-0.6701313853263855,
0.1632920801639557,
-0.29684779047966003,
-0.17952555418014526,
-0.8938058614730835,
-0.3272359371185303,
-0.6812050938606262,
-0.150323286652565,
-0.8474849462509155,
-0.6951599717140198,
-0.42806413769721985,
0.2365599274635315,
0.2118593156337738,
0.5970441699028015,
-0.6056442260742188,
0.5816919207572937,
-0.6414080858230591,
0.6282638311386108,
0.10107376426458359,
0.1402510404586792,
-0.07891212403774261,
-0.6712660789489746,
-0.2743796706199646,
0.023441269993782043,
-0.24236752092838287,
-0.930698573589325,
0.5949935913085938,
0.26748180389404297,
0.17263665795326233,
0.2774755656719208,
0.3243023157119751,
0.7994388341903687,
-0.6043729186058044,
0.6822498440742493,
0.5816600918769836,
-1.177026629447937,
0.36541905999183655,
-0.2525871694087982,
0.4242066740989685,
0.19930577278137207,
-0.3915441036224365,
-1.0474437475204468,
-0.4347180426120758,
-0.39747387170791626,
-1.2425824403762817,
1.0266859531402588,
0.8709045648574829,
-0.07477479428052902,
-0.1491708904504776,
0.10989481210708618,
0.16832971572875977,
0.27408894896507263,
-0.5486912131309509,
-0.48755109310150146,
-0.7156360149383545,
0.05627379193902016,
-0.1658860146999359,
-0.15848690271377563,
0.3646774888038635,
0.41783469915390015,
0.7400598526000977,
-0.056077297776937485,
0.6513745784759521,
0.2507961690425873,
-0.1396327018737793,
-0.3961085379123688,
0.47780561447143555,
0.634064793586731,
-0.08964338898658752,
-0.16074173152446747,
0.016688089817762375,
0.2328909933567047,
-0.12430032342672348,
0.3117498457431793,
0.28436845541000366,
-0.0806274265050888,
0.3501804769039154,
-0.06202511861920357,
1.018399953842163,
0.38823202252388,
-0.23957706987857819,
0.600974977016449,
-0.2757621705532074,
-0.3237215280532837,
-0.3693922162055969,
-0.5281451940536499,
0.02190461754798889,
-0.0028718227986246347,
0.4937933087348938,
0.3547026515007019,
-0.018528949469327927,
-0.04502417519688606,
0.5997351408004761,
0.02356136403977871,
-0.22977402806282043,
-0.42270123958587646,
1.0986931324005127,
0.4712514579296112,
-0.3463389277458191,
0.40235620737075806,
-0.40807124972343445,
-0.13141529262065887,
0.3057608902454376,
0.9316345453262329,
1.2119808197021484,
-0.3833440840244293,
0.1938088983297348,
0.17691278457641602,
0.03963877260684967,
-0.039179496467113495,
0.39316362142562866,
-0.5803660154342651,
-0.21216823160648346,
-0.5341933369636536,
-0.6654006838798523,
-0.15384775400161743,
0.020823748782277107,
-0.692244827747345,
0.12521304190158844,
0.04418559744954109,
-0.23687919974327087,
-0.40714338421821594,
-0.34093132615089417,
-0.11900176852941513,
0.24083858728408813,
0.14259526133537292,
0.6549347639083862,
-0.6306917667388916,
0.907996654510498,
0.22497352957725525,
-0.37113863229751587,
-0.6066262125968933,
0.1358906328678131,
0.026322675868868828,
-0.49027711153030396,
0.5110636949539185,
-0.1531834751367569,
-0.5235570073127747,
0.49176323413848877,
0.03966087847948074,
-1.1849433183670044,
1.0284043550491333,
0.29602691531181335,
-0.5435208678245544,
-0.46611183881759644,
0.3325579762458801,
0.2202528566122055,
-0.34680524468421936,
0.1893233358860016,
0.31778445839881897,
0.20369403064250946,
0.39898228645324707,
-1.1711069345474243,
-0.05075109004974365,
-0.33851075172424316,
0.2889097332954407,
0.25582849979400635,
-0.8207707405090332,
0.8178354501724243,
0.05541529506444931,
-0.5802804827690125,
0.34687742590904236,
0.7816568613052368,
0.06944923102855682,
0.12589243054389954,
0.2598373293876648,
0.34730637073516846,
0.12803205847740173,
-0.013732319697737694,
0.5236997008323669,
-0.7217243313789368,
0.227178692817688,
1.4475041627883911,
-0.1850505769252777,
0.8885346055030823,
0.5811072587966919,
0.19675055146217346,
-0.03399283438920975,
0.3012053966522217,
0.30297398567199707,
0.8205580711364746,
-0.009026417508721352,
-0.519818902015686,
-0.31892240047454834,
-0.16092759370803833,
-0.625550389289856,
0.630896806716919,
0.3134051263332367,
-0.35388609766960144,
-0.5720611810684204,
0.015026199631392956,
-0.001560377306304872,
0.004918974824249744,
0.2028544843196869,
0.68028324842453,
0.1613527089357376,
-0.7623960375785828,
0.7276232242584229,
0.3568693697452545,
0.698042631149292,
-0.4977014362812042,
0.20685043931007385,
-0.16503658890724182,
0.017040546983480453,
-0.05034395679831505,
-0.30828726291656494,
0.5587436556816101,
0.19745297729969025,
-0.09210819005966187,
-0.5499776601791382,
0.22123868763446808,
-0.5531905889511108,
-0.16314470767974854,
0.36031031608581543,
0.5143299698829651,
0.2578681409358978,
0.20628853142261505,
-0.5574678778648376,
0.14615297317504883,
0.08486691117286682,
0.04118262603878975,
0.08306073397397995,
0.32572832703590393,
0.06858415901660919,
0.27045130729675293,
0.8675678372383118,
0.04215048998594284,
0.4061063528060913,
0.013287404552102089,
0.506232500076294,
-0.3525870144367218,
-0.8789075016975403,
-0.47793304920196533,
0.47707420587539673,
0.1861880123615265,
-0.3264870345592499,
0.628596305847168,
0.6202952861785889,
0.5005918145179749,
0.2344886213541031,
1.052767038345337,
-0.14038214087486267,
0.38382968306541443,
-0.23977264761924744,
0.854465126991272,
-0.7010276317596436,
-0.11377743631601334,
-0.1543758064508438,
-0.4867597222328186,
-0.31975919008255005,
0.45378348231315613,
0.1772831231355667,
-0.08735713362693787,
0.6870142817497253,
0.5401414036750793,
0.2179911732673645,
0.44217896461486816,
0.6810985207557678,
0.18636392056941986,
0.3616473376750946,
0.6242632269859314,
0.44881173968315125,
-0.8096122145652771,
0.8770841360092163,
0.027438415214419365,
-0.2548099756240845,
-0.12088636308908463,
-0.7358071804046631,
-0.5081182718276978,
-0.7235767841339111,
-0.31510481238365173,
-0.26486337184906006,
0.43527087569236755,
0.8369594812393188,
0.7492083311080933,
-0.48122987151145935,
-0.41752761602401733,
-0.6273542046546936,
-0.453199177980423,
-0.11465378105640411,
-0.1205274686217308,
0.13942384719848633,
-0.5645327568054199,
-0.7714827656745911,
0.7684217691421509,
0.7126279473304749,
0.16975826025009155,
-0.0804525837302208,
-0.31496360898017883,
-0.19755272567272186,
0.31794434785842896,
0.38139981031417847,
0.4465879201889038,
-0.6684326529502869,
0.12711453437805176,
0.08960746973752975,
0.17468924820423126,
0.26624879240989685,
0.7448713779449463,
-0.5798723697662354,
0.7776758074760437,
0.33620938658714294,
0.5005670189857483,
0.5823454260826111,
-0.2699499726295471,
0.6739954352378845,
-0.9687649011611938,
0.17256951332092285,
0.16803747415542603,
0.14567559957504272,
0.23752139508724213,
-0.2315690666437149,
-0.0508229099214077,
0.2387276440858841,
-0.5920819640159607,
-0.7878630757331848,
0.4584940969944,
-0.7415120005607605,
0.09294527769088745,
0.9243601560592651,
-0.1812485158443451,
-0.1272483915090561,
-0.407679945230484,
0.09064336121082306,
0.8254789113998413,
-0.8091036677360535,
0.4466235339641571,
0.254546582698822,
-0.20446854829788208,
-0.24372097849845886,
-0.4033493399620056,
0.2943818271160126,
0.6305327415466309,
-0.6165460348129272,
0.3154711127281189,
0.23084524273872375,
0.07718516141176224,
-0.04681850224733353,
0.9025086760520935,
-0.3172079622745514,
0.40484896302223206,
0.2444540411233902,
0.0033027385361492634,
-0.2149098962545395,
-0.07978279143571854,
-0.29112550616264343,
-0.06590288877487183,
-0.2744413912296295,
-0.4983717203140259
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06910v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06910v2
|
Agent-SiMT: Agent-assisted Simultaneous Machine Translation with Large Language Models
| 2024-06-11T03:09:20 | 2024-06-12T15:05:40 |
Shoutao Guo, Shaolei Zhang, Zhengrui Ma, Min Zhang, Yang Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Simultaneous Machine Translation (SiMT) generates target translations while
reading the source sentence. It relies on a policy to determine the optimal
timing for reading sentences and generating translations. Existing SiMT methods
generally adopt the traditional Transformer architecture, which concurrently
determines the policy and generates translations. While they excel at
determining policies, their translation performance is suboptimal. Conversely,
Large Language Models (LLMs), trained on extensive corpora, possess superior
generation capabilities, but it is difficult for them to acquire translation
policy through the training methods of SiMT. Therefore, we introduce
Agent-SiMT, a framework combining the strengths of LLMs and traditional SiMT
methods. Agent-SiMT contains the policy-decision agent and the translation
agent. The policy-decision agent is managed by a SiMT model, which determines
the translation policy using partial source sentence and translation. The
translation agent, leveraging an LLM, generates translation based on the
partial source sentence. The two agents collaborate to accomplish SiMT.
Experiments demonstrate that Agent-SiMT attains state-of-the-art performance.
|
[
-0.3295837938785553,
-0.7683022618293762,
0.6514245271682739,
0.46006399393081665,
-0.3736773431301117,
0.4103357791900635,
-0.22670377790927887,
-0.13930194079875946,
0.05402865260839462,
0.6147245168685913,
-0.6335218548774719,
-0.1350342184305191,
-0.39022907614707947,
0.4280547499656677,
-0.1258171796798706,
1.0469363927841187,
-0.383991539478302,
0.35945791006088257,
-0.2602887749671936,
0.1773463934659958,
-0.5540974736213684,
-0.26595306396484375,
-0.7391878366470337,
-0.4855181872844696,
0.3023053705692291,
0.2883170545101166,
1.2835274934768677,
0.8930152058601379,
0.6397668719291687,
0.3499588966369629,
0.31331488490104675,
0.4364670515060425,
-0.18284925818443298,
0.24170273542404175,
-0.12748204171657562,
-0.3699333071708679,
-0.5611134171485901,
-0.26391279697418213,
0.7530544996261597,
0.24599097669124603,
-0.007352479267865419,
-0.2037287801504135,
-0.19591446220874786,
0.3078366219997406,
-0.11205148696899414,
0.18283706903457642,
-0.4419790804386139,
-0.09043075144290924,
-0.023508647456765175,
-0.42282846570014954,
-0.4845200777053833,
-0.24628987908363342,
-0.20474113523960114,
-0.46012356877326965,
0.11203008890151978,
0.22267402708530426,
0.6555529832839966,
0.5133853554725647,
-0.9393616318702698,
-0.263288289308548,
-0.8764716982841492,
0.6385972499847412,
-0.2904548645019531,
0.25466522574424744,
0.09318487346172333,
0.5372768044471741,
-0.28362011909484863,
-0.644245445728302,
-0.6456533074378967,
-0.6686851978302002,
0.008210888132452965,
0.29263395071029663,
0.1490255743265152,
0.21198102831840515,
0.24867600202560425,
0.1855628788471222,
-0.7546603679656982,
-0.1926337331533432,
-0.04249516874551773,
0.020061424002051353,
0.7378891706466675,
0.12647749483585358,
0.4823341965675354,
0.017242426052689552,
-0.8389946818351746,
-0.20454443991184235,
-0.4432452619075775,
-0.4323422908782959,
0.21558615565299988,
0.18104097247123718,
0.23657162487506866,
0.7608697414398193,
-0.05668168142437935,
0.21102090179920197,
-0.25044915080070496,
-0.24552881717681885,
0.2997739017009735,
-0.34821048378944397,
-0.08895833790302277,
0.15236783027648926,
0.9255874156951904,
-0.05405742675065994,
0.21384654939174652,
-0.4568668305873871,
-0.6350517868995667,
0.06849535554647446,
0.2971479594707489,
-0.6956831216812134,
0.597819983959198,
0.1493254452943802,
-0.07902137190103531,
-0.21174277365207672,
0.18455207347869873,
-0.29107901453971863,
-0.0013774087419733405,
-0.5875861048698425,
0.5399373173713684,
-0.48965051770210266,
-0.3146985173225403,
0.14635492861270905,
-0.11342912167310715,
0.34235846996307373,
0.30456894636154175,
-0.3594528138637543,
0.5550531148910522,
0.645283579826355,
1.0267564058303833,
-0.38327550888061523,
-0.6161249279975891,
-0.5903691649436951,
0.5189931988716125,
-0.3611483573913574,
0.6278309226036072,
-0.2843884527683258,
-0.32777589559555054,
-0.05233307555317879,
-0.1470390111207962,
-0.24763095378875732,
-0.2664439380168915,
0.4573307931423187,
-0.56163090467453,
-0.33384090662002563,
-0.11603988707065582,
-0.5932552814483643,
0.06327372789382935,
0.20987512171268463,
-0.6747664213180542,
0.9373824000358582,
0.06877104192972183,
-0.46010535955429077,
0.051497682929039,
-1.0007226467132568,
-0.5326073169708252,
0.18445712327957153,
-0.19949686527252197,
-0.24608275294303894,
0.0025999131612479687,
0.11771277338266373,
0.31556665897369385,
-0.6104507446289062,
0.5517812371253967,
-0.015019616112112999,
-0.2764333486557007,
0.3625693917274475,
-0.7027518153190613,
0.6127140522003174,
0.601860523223877,
-0.28719303011894226,
0.08288835734128952,
-0.34101399779319763,
-0.2695293724536896,
0.3853234052658081,
-0.26541489362716675,
-0.01078963652253151,
-0.048008013516664505,
0.2586246132850647,
0.46972376108169556,
0.48033201694488525,
-0.4590460956096649,
0.5617358684539795,
0.0018896450055763125,
0.26677966117858887,
0.454889714717865,
0.024749189615249634,
0.5368791818618774,
-0.5113028287887573,
0.8013048768043518,
-0.08366111665964127,
0.16312219202518463,
-0.15533307194709778,
-0.07622447609901428,
-0.6624495983123779,
-0.4363219439983368,
0.20226861536502838,
0.7688944935798645,
-1.349194049835205,
0.11766088008880615,
-0.4642929136753082,
-0.3595118224620819,
-0.5682005882263184,
0.1487550586462021,
0.2532815933227539,
-0.27106305956840515,
0.3043791949748993,
-0.14978528022766113,
-0.10828971117734909,
-0.8331288695335388,
-0.33233901858329773,
0.013126997277140617,
0.2596862018108368,
0.05135542154312134,
0.4178732931613922,
-0.18988311290740967,
0.8446517586708069,
-0.4260369539260864,
-0.2844904363155365,
-0.5707732439041138,
0.29243022203445435,
-0.1837056577205658,
0.34819263219833374,
0.41900819540023804,
-1.05693781375885,
-0.6825376152992249,
0.3672432601451874,
-0.8409283757209778,
-0.230120450258255,
-0.45279666781425476,
-0.2754184305667877,
0.22541217505931854,
0.6904593706130981,
-0.8983897566795349,
0.19345510005950928,
0.4366443157196045,
-0.05421045422554016,
0.4445618987083435,
-0.4698368310928345,
0.129652202129364,
-1.438254952430725,
-0.23141829669475555,
-0.49794939160346985,
-0.7279557585716248,
-0.5156412720680237,
0.2733158767223358,
-0.007322687190026045,
-0.06919123232364655,
-0.4932144284248352,
0.4315800964832306,
-0.7945887446403503,
-0.32727447152137756,
-0.491294264793396,
0.02459227852523327,
-0.2214488834142685,
0.27429425716400146,
0.137470081448555,
1.0055606365203857,
0.3382302522659302,
-0.2659275233745575,
0.4763340651988983,
0.187969371676445,
0.18606606125831604,
0.4499987065792084,
-0.38030123710632324,
0.28849077224731445,
0.022916873916983604,
0.42273154854774475,
-0.5633871555328369,
-0.27002593874931335,
0.13119035959243774,
-0.18953049182891846,
0.36845192313194275,
0.23950211703777313,
-0.8080337643623352,
-0.33664029836654663,
0.062027979642152786,
0.4388229250907898,
0.41896679997444153,
-0.2784801423549652,
0.8249040842056274,
0.09012491255998611,
-0.23421137034893036,
-0.5438836812973022,
-0.5381933450698853,
0.20528319478034973,
0.1502804458141327,
-0.7668927907943726,
0.14032000303268433,
0.03842875361442566,
-0.1835397630929947,
0.11828277260065079,
-0.02567017450928688,
-0.12011289596557617,
-0.10996313393115997,
0.11871859431266785,
0.1645488440990448,
-0.3473045825958252,
0.13393534719944,
0.3044995367527008,
-0.22320431470870972,
-0.23692059516906738,
-0.3306615352630615,
0.6430502533912659,
-0.20597699284553528,
-0.537888765335083,
-0.2409343421459198,
0.5761838555335999,
0.8293150067329407,
-0.45468205213546753,
0.9003344178199768,
0.6883522868156433,
0.13799980282783508,
-0.5406708717346191,
-0.35660433769226074,
-0.05805235356092453,
-0.41532936692237854,
0.36880266666412354,
-0.8223658800125122,
-0.545701265335083,
0.2610930800437927,
-0.48431137204170227,
0.12884686887264252,
0.3140171766281128,
0.7461726069450378,
0.30013328790664673,
1.1358674764633179,
0.5385707020759583,
0.2332683801651001,
0.6007387638092041,
-0.0779728889465332,
0.10794145613908768,
-0.37084701657295227,
0.06687033176422119,
-0.2811968922615051,
0.012576717883348465,
-0.5348424911499023,
-0.5906698107719421,
0.3934573531150818,
-0.10163617879152298,
-0.08417379856109619,
0.46400558948516846,
-0.09102591127157211,
0.44696077704429626,
0.5851790308952332,
0.004246141295880079,
0.5946242213249207,
-0.05135561525821686,
-0.327597975730896,
0.41027066111564636,
-0.6389825344085693,
-0.7176332473754883,
0.9275161027908325,
0.22196868062019348,
0.6267634034156799,
0.16210786998271942,
0.8453300595283508,
0.3718941807746887,
0.17875686287879944,
-0.7736480236053467,
0.6547433733940125,
0.0257366094738245,
-0.5958482027053833,
-0.29391399025917053,
-0.6134287714958191,
-0.7811839580535889,
0.5358741283416748,
-0.0734032541513443,
-0.04467662051320076,
-0.22703427076339722,
-0.07852346450090408,
0.14512492716312408,
0.12653443217277527,
-0.659528374671936,
0.8523745536804199,
-0.5455324053764343,
-0.22322224080562592,
-0.1880599558353424,
-0.7333546280860901,
0.2656223475933075,
-0.38939595222473145,
-0.04562906175851822,
-0.013489702716469765,
-0.4249763488769531,
-0.0013740991707891226,
-0.4816245138645172,
0.4049926996231079,
0.07065211236476898,
0.06605979800224304,
0.21910694241523743,
0.2951194941997528,
0.7280015349388123,
-0.10599200427532196,
-0.0019466477679088712,
0.021573688834905624,
-0.06575410813093185,
-0.4238583743572235,
-0.5484014749526978,
0.3508427143096924,
-0.9315782189369202,
-0.49989888072013855,
-0.6491286754608154,
-1.0866925716400146,
-0.0064943041652441025,
0.35322797298431396,
0.07679587602615356,
0.026763176545500755,
-0.609057605266571,
0.056085359305143356,
0.26488903164863586,
-0.14105698466300964,
0.26161351799964905,
0.7573704719543457,
-0.4138099253177643,
-0.2640179693698883,
1.0142531394958496,
0.16139563918113708,
0.6778948307037354,
0.5288973450660706,
-0.10071958601474762,
-0.22929419577121735,
-0.31759798526763916,
-0.5652279853820801,
0.3539838194847107,
-0.3829859495162964,
-0.23970669507980347,
-0.7008893489837646,
-0.5599782466888428,
-0.41448453068733215,
-0.1607484072446823,
-0.47048524022102356,
-0.1409294754266739,
0.20858073234558105,
0.14742247760295868,
0.15461690723896027,
0.7935964465141296,
-0.12110797315835953,
0.6122073531150818,
-0.6060348749160767,
0.5821897387504578,
0.16496707499027252,
-0.10776423662900925,
-0.5549375414848328,
-0.06010876223444939,
-0.12988361716270447,
0.15297801792621613,
-0.5337858200073242,
-1.0539594888687134,
0.4366048276424408,
0.04424943029880524,
0.39777371287345886,
0.05788176879286766,
0.06446892768144608,
0.2493690848350525,
-0.7116896510124207,
0.5027506947517395,
-0.0697154775261879,
-0.9362061619758606,
0.19931729137897491,
-0.40992096066474915,
0.3671102821826935,
0.2854063808917999,
0.2167050838470459,
-0.59308260679245,
-0.6930603981018066,
-0.43095019459724426,
-0.7162418961524963,
1.1004362106323242,
0.5930597186088562,
0.012706375680863857,
-0.10841868072748184,
0.04944577440619469,
0.052009567618370056,
0.3903573453426361,
-0.49545374512672424,
-0.11412779241800308,
-0.02084595151245594,
-0.30890360474586487,
-0.2756327986717224,
0.027416184544563293,
0.19412510097026825,
0.13098858296871185,
0.905555784702301,
-0.26899775862693787,
0.2713266611099243,
0.18412025272846222,
-0.45167437195777893,
-0.2720118761062622,
0.37289902567863464,
0.5640715956687927,
0.48530155420303345,
-0.15980218350887299,
0.06988298147916794,
0.0620679073035717,
-0.50860995054245,
0.3786800503730774,
0.19304987788200378,
-0.5471243858337402,
0.25099191069602966,
0.16747547686100006,
1.0016965866088867,
-0.038974542170763016,
-0.4259515106678009,
0.7713131308555603,
-0.1260523498058319,
-0.26074734330177307,
-0.4272576570510864,
-0.02783203311264515,
0.09912242740392685,
0.4326952397823334,
0.18080224096775055,
0.21312053501605988,
-0.031568512320518494,
-0.30606958270072937,
0.37218719720840454,
0.34301692247390747,
-0.03441455960273743,
-0.08513612300157547,
0.5825834274291992,
0.09407355636358261,
-0.4611288905143738,
0.21242405474185944,
-0.21869246661663055,
-0.4957175552845001,
0.7930993437767029,
0.8664795160293579,
1.1492983102798462,
-0.5386217832565308,
0.6816253662109375,
-0.0837964341044426,
0.488285094499588,
-0.5514518618583679,
0.15556257963180542,
0.019687823951244354,
-0.605365514755249,
-0.47790366411209106,
-0.6527732014656067,
-0.3595435619354248,
-0.13541337847709656,
-0.5473390817642212,
0.44269728660583496,
0.07382561266422272,
-0.1105223223567009,
-0.12227769941091537,
-0.003945454489439726,
-0.7372233867645264,
-0.24080580472946167,
-0.11481567472219467,
0.8049989938735962,
-0.9398291707038879,
1.0181208848953247,
0.8785766959190369,
-0.7091259956359863,
-0.8587092757225037,
0.2387239634990692,
-0.0906577855348587,
-0.7983687520027161,
0.41044628620147705,
-0.07771746069192886,
-0.26068174839019775,
0.3642585575580597,
-0.4685935080051422,
-0.6414331793785095,
1.223404049873352,
0.9454196095466614,
-0.5017669200897217,
-0.1312054842710495,
0.6137046813964844,
0.44863253831863403,
-0.42104876041412354,
0.22193217277526855,
0.5584642291069031,
0.5439755916595459,
0.32665595412254333,
-1.1172761917114258,
-0.03679422661662102,
0.1460937261581421,
0.1804838925600052,
0.3307671844959259,
-0.852099597454071,
0.8858309388160706,
0.05029016360640526,
-0.17465560138225555,
0.15902096033096313,
0.6376516222953796,
0.0698406770825386,
0.3090735077857971,
0.47228267788887024,
0.13617011904716492,
0.3956509232521057,
0.038942378014326096,
1.3774887323379517,
-0.23641416430473328,
0.36863887310028076,
1.0430806875228882,
-0.42218050360679626,
0.6726836562156677,
0.4545947015285492,
0.1340831220149994,
-0.05566181614995003,
0.3137558400630951,
0.12145739048719406,
0.26287156343460083,
-0.026781003922224045,
-0.40548908710479736,
-0.48551198840141296,
-0.4292404055595398,
-0.34033283591270447,
0.48028069734573364,
0.006879292894154787,
-0.4037633538246155,
-0.3402709364891052,
0.2690747082233429,
0.15425358712673187,
0.012756426818668842,
-0.07631536573171616,
0.9112429022789001,
0.3192692697048187,
-0.9062482118606567,
0.3000149428844452,
0.035745296627283096,
0.05072927474975586,
-0.7278590202331543,
-0.12815405428409576,
-0.22068996727466583,
0.3294338583946228,
0.25329574942588806,
-0.5014159679412842,
-0.014351452700793743,
-0.047974079847335815,
-0.08628330379724503,
-0.4857405424118042,
0.5613200068473816,
-0.936703622341156,
-0.5289963483810425,
0.3507486879825592,
0.9807214140892029,
0.4424772560596466,
-0.10208815336227417,
-0.8367767930030823,
0.11126653850078583,
-0.2204529196023941,
-0.3699847161769867,
0.1622699648141861,
0.8301002979278564,
-0.3440154492855072,
0.6154265999794006,
0.5068951845169067,
0.2676965296268463,
0.15425720810890198,
0.06439264118671417,
0.6656836867332458,
-0.4324893653392792,
-0.5257557034492493,
-0.769788384437561,
0.04705837741494179,
0.004630488809198141,
0.14829641580581665,
0.568879246711731,
0.5353091359138489,
0.6644122004508972,
-0.14809858798980713,
0.8538985252380371,
-0.06695521622896194,
0.05210128799080849,
-0.5488781332969666,
0.6083073019981384,
-0.7972894310951233,
0.1069871336221695,
-0.13959477841854095,
-1.3812742233276367,
-0.1120201125741005,
0.29988038539886475,
-0.25164249539375305,
0.1414184272289276,
1.0836600065231323,
0.9300509691238403,
-0.21028754115104675,
-0.07280005514621735,
0.5979824662208557,
0.1590185910463333,
0.3382105827331543,
0.48960116505622864,
0.8896044492721558,
-0.340457022190094,
0.7528379559516907,
0.07146554440259933,
-0.10382693260908127,
-0.14529335498809814,
-0.6608375310897827,
-0.8393243551254272,
-0.5023417472839355,
-0.03271033242344856,
-0.05375228077173233,
0.2529756724834442,
1.3925089836120605,
0.4828352630138397,
-0.4207858145236969,
-0.344041109085083,
-0.20805324614048004,
0.09674602001905441,
-0.5142607092857361,
-0.17145146429538727,
0.24092502892017365,
-0.6417542695999146,
-0.9411375522613525,
0.3610306978225708,
0.23778076469898224,
0.06927584111690521,
-0.2562742233276367,
-0.47377121448516846,
-0.29024380445480347,
0.40910181403160095,
0.4154379963874817,
-0.021582745015621185,
-0.5902893543243408,
0.17410887777805328,
-0.09958738833665848,
-0.5355645418167114,
-0.032244957983493805,
0.9137346744537354,
-0.26066696643829346,
0.39379340410232544,
0.44586628675460815,
0.8399035930633545,
0.6143249869346619,
0.18028007447719574,
0.885069727897644,
-0.6403173804283142,
0.19902440905570984,
0.15572288632392883,
0.055225104093551636,
0.17351414263248444,
-0.37611058354377747,
0.6593661904335022,
0.20194588601589203,
-0.6531888842582703,
-0.75425124168396,
0.3045806288719177,
-0.9808524250984192,
-0.2708636224269867,
1.4068059921264648,
-0.014119384810328484,
-0.4326677620410919,
-0.09308117628097534,
-0.7137089967727661,
0.6282495260238647,
-0.565072774887085,
0.11867964267730713,
0.4741966426372528,
0.17635607719421387,
-0.09559007734060287,
-0.9949148893356323,
0.3189678192138672,
0.23382987082004547,
-0.7828145623207092,
-0.20489875972270966,
0.4461866021156311,
-0.0033102440647780895,
0.029815666377544403,
0.7296739220619202,
0.020418806001544,
0.25681617856025696,
0.3398602604866028,
0.29705438017845154,
-0.4381836950778961,
-0.6209315061569214,
-0.09673018008470535,
0.09689754992723465,
0.1128498837351799,
-0.20621466636657715
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06907v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06907v1
|
SignMusketeers: An Efficient Multi-Stream Approach for Sign Language Translation at Scale
| 2024-06-11T03:00:41 | 2024-06-11T03:00:41 |
Shester Gueuwou, Xiaodan Du, Greg Shakhnarovich, Karen Livescu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
A persistent challenge in sign language video processing, including the task
of sign language to written language translation, is how we learn
representations of sign language in an effective and efficient way that can
preserve the important attributes of these languages, while remaining invariant
to irrelevant visual differences. Informed by the nature and linguistics of
signed languages, our proposed method focuses on just the most relevant parts
in a signing video: the face, hands and body posture of the signer. However,
instead of using pose estimation coordinates from off-the-shelf pose tracking
models, which have inconsistent performance for hands and faces, we propose to
learn the complex handshapes and rich facial expressions of sign languages in a
self-supervised fashion. Our approach is based on learning from individual
frames (rather than video sequences) and is therefore much more efficient than
prior work on sign language pre-training. Compared to a recent model that
established a new state of the art in sign language translation on the How2Sign
dataset, our approach yields similar translation performance, using less than
3\% of the compute.
|
[
0.009881810285151005,
-0.06740988790988922,
0.2880689799785614,
0.15674692392349243,
-0.3873298168182373,
0.11560382694005966,
-0.05686567351222038,
-0.28325554728507996,
0.4351203143596649,
0.3678123354911804,
-0.5301734805107117,
-0.39320510625839233,
-1.2469772100448608,
0.0287762563675642,
-0.3519037961959839,
0.8512586951255798,
-0.32519978284835815,
0.3884434401988983,
0.2668706774711609,
-0.4495919346809387,
0.0770488753914833,
-0.02517661452293396,
-0.5993772745132446,
-0.2318759262561798,
0.04729013890028,
0.306771457195282,
0.5807547569274902,
0.5471506118774414,
0.5888580679893494,
0.3544263243675232,
0.20624488592147827,
0.1700780838727951,
-0.34525150060653687,
0.18613483011722565,
0.14653410017490387,
-0.09959202259778976,
-0.2809952199459076,
0.008870251476764679,
0.7301155924797058,
0.6807482838630676,
0.11599824577569962,
0.42343348264694214,
-0.24845649302005768,
0.5874361991882324,
-0.5310043096542358,
0.09835070371627808,
-0.12999488413333893,
0.1692613661289215,
-0.42648938298225403,
0.08078082650899887,
-0.3946020305156708,
-0.28095635771751404,
-0.4082862138748169,
-0.6777001619338989,
0.37806257605552673,
-0.2400936484336853,
0.247612863779068,
0.600466251373291,
-0.6841559410095215,
-0.05075336620211601,
-0.6363583207130432,
0.568881630897522,
-0.7171112895011902,
0.7567929029464722,
0.29655131697654724,
0.46462514996528625,
-0.15577468276023865,
-0.5995462536811829,
-0.4925404191017151,
0.2255466729402542,
-0.05514286458492279,
0.17920419573783875,
0.21743625402450562,
0.12627416849136353,
0.30538031458854675,
0.4108588993549347,
-0.849449098110199,
-0.0750175341963768,
-0.41519075632095337,
-0.31232431530952454,
0.8969994783401489,
-0.0007931222207844257,
0.3964381814002991,
-0.14973832666873932,
-0.5146949887275696,
-0.553506076335907,
-0.38597550988197327,
0.1506861299276352,
0.04128872603178024,
0.46857163310050964,
-0.26648765802383423,
0.46146848797798157,
-0.14569853246212006,
0.6781173944473267,
0.20548731088638306,
-0.5793675184249878,
0.20002084970474243,
-0.03346635401248932,
0.038399260491132736,
-0.18184979259967804,
0.833620011806488,
0.15015187859535217,
0.11238239705562592,
-0.08324489742517471,
-0.2590249180793762,
-0.12565872073173523,
-0.1081530824303627,
-0.9030240178108215,
-0.387264609336853,
-0.0005474223289638758,
-0.46745404601097107,
0.11365137249231339,
0.1148938313126564,
-0.3299292027950287,
-0.5883148908615112,
-0.3661421537399292,
0.5645487904548645,
-0.331726610660553,
-0.6883466839790344,
-0.09432867169380188,
-0.11249533295631409,
0.26014095544815063,
0.4738786518573761,
-0.9020116329193115,
0.2340165674686432,
0.377956360578537,
0.8572043776512146,
-0.2555704116821289,
-0.23897941410541534,
-0.7005089521408081,
0.23330099880695343,
-0.22983241081237793,
0.27639779448509216,
-0.20203596353530884,
-0.15934373438358307,
-0.1973925083875656,
-0.06949682533740997,
-0.2184198647737503,
-0.2221471518278122,
0.029594875872135162,
-0.43333831429481506,
-0.07043816149234772,
-0.0014815437607467175,
-0.7033682465553284,
-0.10535161942243576,
-0.10127604007720947,
-0.7327804565429688,
0.9281010627746582,
0.005380443297326565,
-0.05588969960808754,
0.540320873260498,
-0.4030322730541229,
-0.7491468787193298,
0.1628476232290268,
-0.10854820162057877,
-0.5424029231071472,
0.2804841697216034,
0.13132530450820923,
0.8360421061515808,
0.2611365020275116,
-0.053101878613233566,
0.028870409354567528,
0.0837830975651741,
0.15403993427753448,
0.08435916155576706,
0.7895745635032654,
0.253579318523407,
-0.4979512393474579,
-0.0004995521157979965,
-0.6301974654197693,
-0.05070110782980919,
-0.014745885506272316,
-0.1183580607175827,
-0.22167806327342987,
-0.1056448444724083,
0.10275222361087799,
0.5283336043357849,
0.10574793070554733,
-0.6234576106071472,
0.08883190155029297,
0.002749846549704671,
0.19155731797218323,
0.5219412446022034,
-0.21776747703552246,
0.5132708549499512,
0.44612377882003784,
0.6940754055976868,
0.003542638150975108,
0.25676393508911133,
-0.25225406885147095,
-0.5198999643325806,
-0.515072762966156,
-0.3124462068080902,
-0.2765800952911377,
0.03172687068581581,
-0.7409415245056152,
0.05209760740399361,
-0.31709495186805725,
-0.5377341508865356,
-0.5305570960044861,
0.5884228348731995,
0.8860599398612976,
0.08933857828378677,
0.5499613881111145,
-0.6635900735855103,
-0.15495018661022186,
-0.512112557888031,
-0.4864780902862549,
-0.26965609192848206,
0.1760297566652298,
-0.4962172508239746,
0.2891005575656891,
0.43964582681655884,
0.3637511730194092,
-0.4821026027202606,
-0.6424668431282043,
-0.08269393444061279,
0.19663658738136292,
0.10867446660995483,
0.5770236253738403,
0.5338916778564453,
-1.0072548389434814,
-0.8291640281677246,
0.07820925116539001,
-0.6147541999816895,
0.3053714334964752,
-0.39714884757995605,
0.11262892186641693,
-0.1353747695684433,
0.8838486671447754,
-0.3945052921772003,
0.1427628993988037,
1.0630391836166382,
-0.5020532608032227,
0.10593601316213608,
-0.22490046918392181,
0.30078020691871643,
-1.0462361574172974,
-0.06863116472959518,
0.11407148838043213,
-0.7378683686256409,
-0.8085751533508301,
0.14908245205879211,
0.22904212772846222,
-0.3823096752166748,
-0.49933382868766785,
0.4094649851322174,
-1.116168737411499,
-0.1315712183713913,
-0.36327043175697327,
0.275942862033844,
-0.33876147866249084,
0.44493386149406433,
0.1909465193748474,
0.6498733758926392,
0.71394944190979,
-0.5149534344673157,
0.3008750379085541,
0.4804331660270691,
-0.12965841591358185,
0.9097847938537598,
-0.23480971157550812,
0.20120251178741455,
-0.20197927951812744,
0.16395965218544006,
-1.3135350942611694,
-0.45486322045326233,
0.13576410710811615,
-0.5788887143135071,
0.9273031949996948,
-0.16213643550872803,
0.02014980837702751,
-0.3686581552028656,
0.013720530085265636,
0.4627543091773987,
0.40445250272750854,
-0.6571258306503296,
0.8509683609008789,
0.6172372102737427,
0.20003974437713623,
-0.4718483090400696,
-0.6563512086868286,
0.16137723624706268,
-0.18034598231315613,
-0.4371079206466675,
0.0953863188624382,
0.1679132878780365,
0.13055767118930817,
-0.3749326467514038,
-0.42603230476379395,
-0.1714494228363037,
-0.007096195127815008,
0.23597493767738342,
-0.26848623156547546,
-0.21900904178619385,
0.1169702559709549,
-0.07661662995815277,
-0.33354800939559937,
0.0049698990769684315,
-0.407918781042099,
-0.03293101489543915,
0.02677857130765915,
-0.36320778727531433,
-0.7602983713150024,
0.26451414823532104,
0.6491241455078125,
-0.24936746060848236,
0.6070423722267151,
0.590537965297699,
-0.2218872457742691,
-0.19765491783618927,
-0.37750402092933655,
-0.28850483894348145,
-0.4557788372039795,
0.33097192645072937,
-0.596652626991272,
-0.7590563893318176,
0.37974420189857483,
-0.2627720236778259,
0.17241773009300232,
0.258560448884964,
0.35666635632514954,
-0.19613686203956604,
0.7844109535217285,
0.5391875505447388,
0.20179802179336548,
0.5798235535621643,
-0.03474721312522888,
0.2080622911453247,
-0.5833579301834106,
-0.15130986273288727,
-0.21601133048534393,
-0.5499482750892639,
-0.21316388249397278,
-0.6868346929550171,
0.39092323184013367,
0.05444813519716263,
0.07471396028995514,
1.2730212211608887,
-0.4831151068210602,
0.43273890018463135,
0.1639278680086136,
0.14444565773010254,
0.43468546867370605,
-0.26800021529197693,
0.29897579550743103,
-0.3194313049316406,
-0.4313836097717285,
-0.3583534061908722,
1.1252681016921997,
0.05394108593463898,
0.6024360060691833,
0.5942800641059875,
0.7925398945808411,
0.14007799327373505,
0.5594653487205505,
-0.5527767539024353,
0.5543085932731628,
-0.34210455417633057,
-0.8461964130401611,
-0.5819917321205139,
-0.36141401529312134,
-0.7016786932945251,
0.6950892210006714,
-0.2532392144203186,
-0.3164995610713959,
0.0012583110947161913,
0.573363184928894,
0.09719628840684891,
0.34298649430274963,
-0.7368412017822266,
1.0685707330703735,
-0.5055522918701172,
-0.26888641715049744,
-0.2995956540107727,
-1.1095771789550781,
0.41016483306884766,
-0.1894892156124115,
0.2683396339416504,
-0.2307879775762558,
-0.058482781052589417,
0.726631760597229,
-0.5250882506370544,
1.0426936149597168,
-0.4199563264846802,
-0.24312978982925415,
0.020262550562620163,
0.2549695670604706,
0.3929789066314697,
-0.24382783472537994,
0.11928144842386246,
0.01951305754482746,
-0.03229815140366554,
-0.49426040053367615,
-0.5935565233230591,
0.3580203652381897,
-0.730528712272644,
-0.3467566967010498,
-0.2551494538784027,
-0.1476965993642807,
-0.15777815878391266,
0.2290697693824768,
0.16915760934352875,
0.17379727959632874,
-0.4851522147655487,
-0.045245904475450516,
0.5392788052558899,
0.44481444358825684,
0.5332466959953308,
0.3744610548019409,
-0.18533460795879364,
-0.4310135543346405,
0.7469196319580078,
0.0159068014472723,
0.6627869606018066,
0.5751398205757141,
0.07624652236700058,
-0.40168124437332153,
-0.5161510109901428,
-0.8003556132316589,
0.4711313843727112,
-0.814236044883728,
-0.2691211402416229,
-0.28561845421791077,
0.37416765093803406,
-0.644881010055542,
-0.17884878814220428,
-0.7795860767364502,
-0.7424606084823608,
0.061456020921468735,
-0.06774498522281647,
0.3448382616043091,
0.4859301447868347,
-0.21667584776878357,
0.602324366569519,
-0.5609712600708008,
0.6040599942207336,
0.44171732664108276,
0.18134674429893494,
-0.3201466202735901,
-0.6414928436279297,
-0.27580153942108154,
-0.2816418707370758,
-0.2899312674999237,
-0.9022976756095886,
0.053944531828165054,
0.6236896514892578,
0.48332759737968445,
0.6457899212837219,
0.09273047000169754,
0.8819355964660645,
-0.3953639268875122,
0.6405131816864014,
0.9337894320487976,
-1.0137921571731567,
0.3202703893184662,
-0.11881425976753235,
0.4315382242202759,
0.7483537197113037,
0.537013828754425,
-0.7971972823143005,
-0.43166765570640564,
-0.3971877992153168,
-0.6095835566520691,
0.6509914398193359,
0.3250385522842407,
0.21174143254756927,
0.18294934928417206,
0.16563642024993896,
0.12014062702655792,
0.011303761973977089,
-0.7509265542030334,
-0.2660701274871826,
-0.5367825031280518,
-0.3144398331642151,
-0.3073892891407013,
0.4278513193130493,
0.045330628752708435,
-0.30378562211990356,
0.7409852147102356,
-0.44706299901008606,
-0.213624507188797,
-0.011343616060912609,
-0.6905332207679749,
-0.33931705355644226,
-0.23030143976211548,
0.5328600406646729,
0.38022932410240173,
0.3153543770313263,
0.4462972581386566,
0.09315229952335358,
-0.7133912444114685,
0.40329626202583313,
-0.16480782628059387,
-0.03968855366110802,
0.06328629702329636,
0.3881605863571167,
0.8834623694419861,
0.3573858141899109,
-0.4261409044265747,
0.8483895659446716,
0.3099116086959839,
-0.09541640430688858,
-0.3896820843219757,
-0.13863174617290497,
0.13824690878391266,
0.2655269205570221,
0.04019622132182121,
0.19135716557502747,
0.021302055567502975,
-0.23069261014461517,
0.0830124244093895,
0.24767841398715973,
-0.43279367685317993,
-0.6164731979370117,
1.055959939956665,
0.4106028079986572,
-0.3015446066856384,
0.4608888328075409,
0.11750563234090805,
-0.4232425391674042,
0.2929672598838806,
0.3820348381996155,
1.0099455118179321,
-0.9450244903564453,
0.45589953660964966,
0.777209460735321,
0.2385263741016388,
-0.31791651248931885,
0.07123181223869324,
-0.4901357591152191,
-0.5898953080177307,
-0.6495979428291321,
-0.4639512002468109,
-0.22209110856056213,
-0.3497404158115387,
-0.5325959920883179,
0.25307953357696533,
-0.28572970628738403,
-0.24873808026313782,
0.018822571262717247,
-0.5531379580497742,
-0.487101674079895,
0.3386158347129822,
0.5060818791389465,
0.5274468660354614,
-1.3084633350372314,
0.6214936971664429,
0.7254914045333862,
-0.5346153974533081,
-0.6516481041908264,
-0.250954806804657,
0.3572847545146942,
-0.609552264213562,
0.6241976022720337,
0.06315914541482925,
-0.5083782076835632,
0.20590175688266754,
-0.34517866373062134,
-1.0657888650894165,
0.8179908990859985,
0.3786795139312744,
-0.24637964367866516,
0.17755994200706482,
0.28321361541748047,
0.48693400621414185,
-0.11277753114700317,
0.004285173490643501,
0.38892459869384766,
0.5009052753448486,
0.3156164586544037,
-0.8421406745910645,
0.14526565372943878,
-0.09334948658943176,
0.14136935770511627,
0.5092085599899292,
-0.8299523591995239,
0.25566208362579346,
-0.2569372355937958,
-0.2778395414352417,
-0.10713940858840942,
0.9755365252494812,
0.005612019449472427,
-0.02044268324971199,
0.43158382177352905,
0.39191967248916626,
0.5646678805351257,
0.00047480958164669573,
0.7887886762619019,
-0.10601099580526352,
0.30858516693115234,
0.9438803195953369,
-0.022302933037281036,
0.7491937875747681,
0.7637434601783752,
-0.29870012402534485,
0.2147320806980133,
0.338180273771286,
0.23038221895694733,
0.3337680399417877,
0.12007828056812286,
-0.2396795153617859,
-0.7694975733757019,
0.48696133494377136,
0.08222339302301407,
0.5613951086997986,
0.09448982775211334,
-0.2603524327278137,
-0.23621833324432373,
0.3295878767967224,
0.16347834467887878,
0.5210021734237671,
-0.2054339200258255,
0.718841552734375,
0.3690548837184906,
-0.5507252812385559,
0.43765947222709656,
-0.2933296859264374,
0.3445446491241455,
-0.7224399447441101,
0.10963042825460434,
-0.22742211818695068,
0.44549041986465454,
-0.25312304496765137,
-0.6429905295372009,
0.3421555161476135,
-0.1057753637433052,
0.1643734723329544,
-0.9032558798789978,
0.347743958234787,
-0.46337246894836426,
-0.4274078905582428,
0.2072596549987793,
0.2921394407749176,
0.8012806177139282,
0.172806516289711,
-0.524787962436676,
-0.0772724524140358,
-0.0917181521654129,
-0.383594274520874,
0.11863254010677338,
0.3731059432029724,
-0.21738776564598083,
0.40348440408706665,
0.39404186606407166,
-0.02869930863380432,
0.4316886067390442,
0.01924080401659012,
0.43670666217803955,
-0.49822762608528137,
-0.3593090772628784,
-0.4142826795578003,
0.7263215780258179,
-0.20893260836601257,
-0.7036617994308472,
0.9049336314201355,
0.6031655073165894,
0.912214994430542,
-0.3592708706855774,
0.3521077036857605,
-0.14665961265563965,
0.26187455654144287,
-0.528888463973999,
0.6786208748817444,
-0.6313121914863586,
-0.5476022958755493,
-0.5268586277961731,
-0.8865809440612793,
-0.7268502116203308,
0.6613706350326538,
-0.0794118344783783,
-0.16042713820934296,
0.5696577429771423,
0.5897875428199768,
-0.24459178745746613,
-0.13478496670722961,
0.47447189688682556,
-0.14080466330051422,
0.21661631762981415,
0.521273136138916,
0.30705976486206055,
-0.9200286269187927,
0.5780561566352844,
-0.008393265306949615,
-0.3097134232521057,
-0.14948900043964386,
-0.7846575379371643,
-0.7891148328781128,
-0.954900860786438,
-0.8535094857215881,
-0.011672467924654484,
-0.2515774667263031,
0.6632940173149109,
1.0331231355667114,
-0.9330453872680664,
-0.5761247873306274,
0.1413109302520752,
-0.34832972288131714,
-0.7263202667236328,
-0.008585076779127121,
0.41843941807746887,
-0.2255559265613556,
-0.7655045986175537,
0.5892015099525452,
0.2140674740076065,
0.06931859254837036,
-0.4089904725551605,
-0.486842542886734,
-0.12505359947681427,
-0.3617061674594879,
0.5688698291778564,
0.7223156094551086,
-0.5756410956382751,
-0.1721610724925995,
-0.05605163052678108,
-0.13365168869495392,
0.06061018258333206,
1.0000025033950806,
-0.4024394750595093,
0.747002899646759,
0.5456763505935669,
0.5696185231208801,
1.289203405380249,
0.09216398000717163,
0.3965756893157959,
-0.8351339101791382,
0.2293144166469574,
-0.02514069341123104,
0.22651241719722748,
0.7446073293685913,
-0.10853651911020279,
0.5244202017784119,
0.2811637818813324,
-0.10570035129785538,
-0.379869282245636,
0.5030227899551392,
-0.9767922163009644,
-0.23332591354846954,
0.8124072551727295,
-0.20243942737579346,
-0.14704552292823792,
-0.12049158662557602,
0.1807761937379837,
0.491656094789505,
-0.011146808974444866,
0.5723574161529541,
0.3655843436717987,
-0.33033886551856995,
-0.5212472677230835,
-0.2253223955631256,
0.5512700080871582,
0.3102806806564331,
-0.424609512090683,
0.16563795506954193,
0.625443696975708,
0.309231162071228,
0.33659854531288147,
0.7540638446807861,
-0.32363981008529663,
0.2346893846988678,
-0.04708867520093918,
0.44308218359947205,
-0.02001870423555374,
-0.24580249190330505,
-0.3646315336227417,
0.040152862668037415,
0.1083570271730423,
-0.3450096845626831
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06887v1
|
PLUM: Preference Learning Plus Test Cases Yields Better Code Language Models
| 2024-06-11T02:07:18 | 2024-06-11T02:07:18 |
Dylan Zhang, Shizhe Diao, Xueyan Zou, Hao Peng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.PL, cs.SE
|
Instruction-finetuned code language models (LMs) have shown promise in
various programming tasks. They are trained, using a language modeling
objective, on natural language instructions and gold code snippet pairs. Recent
evidence suggests that these models, never exposed to incorrect solutions
during training, often struggle to distinguish between correct and incorrect
solutions. This observation raises our inquiry: Can preference learning, which
trains models to prefer correct solutions over incorrect ones, help push the
boundaries of code LMs even further? We propose PLUM, a novel
\textbf{p}reference \textbf{l}earning framework a\textbf{u}gmented with test
cases tailored for code L\textbf{M}s.PLUM aims to investigate the key success
factors and potential benefits of preference learning in code LMs, which remain
elusive despite its success in aligning LMs with human values. PLUM consists of
three stages: (1) Generating test cases for natural language instructions, (2)
sampling candidate solutions from the policy and evaluating them against the
test cases to create a preference dataset, which is then used to (3) train the
policy with a preference learning algorithm. Experiments demonstrate that PLUM
substantially improves the performance of existing code LMs on established code
generation benchmarks such as HumanEval (+) and MBPP (+), even for the
state-of-the-art open-source language model CodeQwen-1.5-7B-Chat. PLUM
complements the supervised fine-tuning (SFT) stage, demonstrating synergistic
effects.
|
[
-0.18574059009552002,
-0.23519782721996307,
0.2821333706378937,
0.07277605682611465,
0.10054820775985718,
0.06421063095331192,
-0.34694942831993103,
-0.1387949138879776,
-0.11670760810375214,
0.5109300017356873,
-0.09524481743574142,
-0.31064268946647644,
-0.4075196087360382,
-0.015126538462936878,
-0.01604381762444973,
1.1831847429275513,
0.20860375463962555,
0.21633115410804749,
-0.21873974800109863,
-0.06729358434677124,
-0.4891146421432495,
-0.7033202052116394,
-0.46557602286338806,
-0.3909854590892792,
0.2677978575229645,
0.6900850534439087,
0.7714465260505676,
0.4406612813472748,
0.3014127314090729,
0.18832999467849731,
0.20058971643447876,
0.039307497441768646,
-0.3816295862197876,
0.01706981100142002,
0.10174257308244705,
-0.9464068412780762,
-0.26214107871055603,
0.03865773603320122,
0.2523534297943115,
0.5898599028587341,
-0.12043768167495728,
-0.09044322371482849,
0.10886957496404648,
1.0766605138778687,
-0.640755832195282,
0.45527011156082153,
-0.7769027948379517,
-0.08022162318229675,
-0.008967248722910881,
-0.5457987189292908,
-0.7061288952827454,
-0.5904120206832886,
-0.020281750708818436,
-0.18615853786468506,
0.14450137317180634,
-0.06938046216964722,
0.7344701290130615,
0.1641775369644165,
-0.46091318130493164,
-0.34511876106262207,
-0.5098667144775391,
0.9717829823493958,
-0.6291160583496094,
0.38618654012680054,
0.4289943277835846,
0.28371870517730713,
-0.1076875701546669,
-0.290616512298584,
-0.010332481935620308,
-0.5416439771652222,
-0.0023204477038234472,
0.09780973196029663,
0.07994823157787323,
-0.07741886377334595,
0.3325033187866211,
0.39638280868530273,
-0.4524482488632202,
0.06480125337839127,
-0.38745176792144775,
-0.32655128836631775,
0.5930431485176086,
0.01245814748108387,
0.20858658850193024,
-0.19411902129650116,
-0.04729444533586502,
-0.00042038652463816106,
-0.8727492094039917,
0.48475009202957153,
0.3446338474750519,
0.4438493549823761,
-0.14456982910633087,
0.454897403717041,
-0.15191145241260529,
0.5410030484199524,
-0.11966393887996674,
-0.09098805487155914,
0.4488030970096588,
0.25417807698249817,
-0.08497755229473114,
0.026852384209632874,
0.4939252436161041,
0.42712336778640747,
0.6435419321060181,
-0.13861387968063354,
-0.20793062448501587,
0.4872716963291168,
0.34525877237319946,
-0.8262057304382324,
-0.5844697952270508,
0.2220965027809143,
-0.3621200621128082,
-0.5352538228034973,
-0.12013855576515198,
-0.39276278018951416,
-0.5724231600761414,
-0.4204632341861725,
0.13754989206790924,
-0.50682133436203,
-0.45783862471580505,
0.3968956768512726,
0.013113853521645069,
0.4306494891643524,
0.09933901578187943,
-0.9352303147315979,
0.09211593866348267,
0.8181028962135315,
0.6001940965652466,
-0.28951629996299744,
-0.05334281921386719,
-0.7709494233131409,
-0.39549851417541504,
-0.5790358185768127,
0.5755721926689148,
-0.5756622552871704,
-0.6083400845527649,
0.10330841690301895,
-0.19639183580875397,
0.019661299884319305,
-0.6917384266853333,
0.4262585937976837,
-0.5246567130088806,
0.0798928514122963,
-0.1687825322151184,
-0.727350115776062,
0.29889529943466187,
0.31116801500320435,
-0.3776397407054901,
0.8309462070465088,
0.20035548508167267,
-0.6107189059257507,
0.40769076347351074,
-0.7693384289741516,
-0.4295319616794586,
-0.015000012703239918,
-0.39892563223838806,
-0.4425736367702484,
0.13579392433166504,
0.000472034327685833,
0.46813228726387024,
0.01860785484313965,
0.3262172341346741,
-0.37947526574134827,
-0.4576471149921417,
0.42350393533706665,
-0.34801197052001953,
0.8362325429916382,
0.2803530991077423,
-0.4237443804740906,
0.18151842057704926,
-0.3922954797744751,
0.16189773380756378,
0.3123690187931061,
-0.45560118556022644,
-0.4297178387641907,
0.03332637995481491,
-0.31763243675231934,
-0.08698853850364685,
0.09056048095226288,
-0.281179815530777,
0.33797651529312134,
-0.5621345043182373,
0.42813390493392944,
0.7118518352508545,
-0.18045838177204132,
0.8728702068328857,
-0.3963780701160431,
0.5790961384773254,
0.03475489094853401,
0.3000034987926483,
-0.3848440945148468,
-0.5864325761795044,
-0.8694986701011658,
0.051000840961933136,
0.417492151260376,
0.481817364692688,
-0.45408621430397034,
0.04307159036397934,
0.06357543915510178,
-0.3174203038215637,
-0.44090405106544495,
0.07234838604927063,
0.5347281694412231,
0.4124932885169983,
0.30831852555274963,
-0.4081483483314514,
-0.4726940393447876,
-0.8376437425613403,
-0.3304555416107178,
-0.21018876135349274,
0.01672469824552536,
0.7104049921035767,
0.14601799845695496,
-0.3512701988220215,
1.2684450149536133,
-0.6853088736534119,
-0.011663265526294708,
-0.3014139235019684,
-0.05443194508552551,
0.35524269938468933,
0.41202571988105774,
0.726773738861084,
-1.1078732013702393,
-0.502539873123169,
-0.06601504981517792,
-0.326191782951355,
-0.11927085369825363,
0.11512249708175659,
-0.029017247259616852,
0.48407676815986633,
0.27441102266311646,
-0.06615828722715378,
0.18509012460708618,
0.4859069883823395,
-0.10696396976709366,
1.0207033157348633,
-0.12319856882095337,
0.13124042749404907,
-0.9608029127120972,
-0.19299812614917755,
0.11003828793764114,
-0.4071970582008362,
-0.37679189443588257,
0.25568175315856934,
0.4898179769515991,
-0.2225813865661621,
-0.6175138354301453,
0.41492775082588196,
-0.40141940116882324,
-0.18624772131443024,
-0.27570217847824097,
-0.2571900188922882,
-0.06222992762923241,
0.716853678226471,
0.17120952904224396,
1.0704365968704224,
0.6183661222457886,
-0.8291982412338257,
-0.04578762128949165,
-0.10034510493278503,
-0.24175944924354553,
0.21325214207172394,
-0.537412703037262,
0.27307626605033875,
0.13389705121517181,
-0.18700122833251953,
-0.7396649122238159,
0.05813050642609596,
0.12392544746398926,
-0.49099382758140564,
0.304580956697464,
-0.5369376540184021,
-0.05789141356945038,
-0.21578344702720642,
-0.2048804759979248,
0.24376046657562256,
0.8209071159362793,
-0.4900686740875244,
0.1796538084745407,
0.4176202714443207,
-0.04299316182732582,
-0.5685078501701355,
-0.36266377568244934,
-0.15768615901470184,
-0.19561856985092163,
0.003989121876657009,
0.11143095791339874,
-0.36661386489868164,
-0.24956592917442322,
-0.2164239138364792,
-0.2711203098297119,
-0.18438801169395447,
0.2862618565559387,
0.3128484785556793,
0.42284291982650757,
-0.19125153124332428,
0.15998575091362,
-0.09309995919466019,
-0.4047805666923523,
0.08982542157173157,
-0.3861777186393738,
0.5135742425918579,
-0.699167013168335,
-0.2922765910625458,
0.11504162847995758,
0.053769756108522415,
0.4288383722305298,
-0.411684513092041,
0.39591914415359497,
0.1761060208082199,
-0.10939491540193558,
-0.2613089680671692,
-0.30096352100372314,
-0.1803882122039795,
-0.48701420426368713,
0.29286229610443115,
-0.5459599494934082,
-0.9321780204772949,
0.040304966270923615,
-0.2366107851266861,
0.32210245728492737,
0.06821194291114807,
0.3971571922302246,
-0.053540728986263275,
1.1822296380996704,
0.7734876871109009,
-0.5604217052459717,
0.5631709098815918,
-0.3568279445171356,
0.2202368825674057,
-0.45533236861228943,
0.08807127177715302,
-0.7290810346603394,
0.05399598926305771,
-0.5522135496139526,
-0.3243502080440521,
0.3590205907821655,
0.14890038967132568,
-0.23838376998901367,
0.2778586745262146,
-0.4608701765537262,
0.8186206817626953,
0.6191617846488953,
0.19938533008098602,
0.25922510027885437,
-0.06939122080802917,
-0.3635910451412201,
-0.26444193720817566,
-0.7363061308860779,
-0.5522668361663818,
1.2944586277008057,
0.3823793828487396,
0.7049795389175415,
0.013685719110071659,
0.8521923422813416,
0.37427785992622375,
0.6271035671234131,
-0.9825094938278198,
0.35418546199798584,
0.007449486292898655,
-0.37654656171798706,
-0.018540341407060623,
-0.6572247743606567,
-0.756812334060669,
-0.08331205695867538,
-0.11222978681325912,
-0.3644184172153473,
-0.13051168620586395,
0.4446876645088196,
-0.19384616613388062,
0.05847993493080139,
-1.0209394693374634,
0.9701697826385498,
-0.5341793894767761,
-0.443604975938797,
-0.09905163943767548,
-0.4760698080062866,
0.23376122117042542,
0.22362862527370453,
0.2396511435508728,
0.11207341402769089,
0.11914673447608948,
0.529098629951477,
-0.10621373355388641,
0.8097081184387207,
-0.19533662497997284,
-0.14532941579818726,
0.13592757284641266,
0.45942044258117676,
0.3728513717651367,
0.2102164924144745,
-0.22714035212993622,
0.12162723392248154,
-0.10035286098718643,
-0.45574408769607544,
-0.5527937412261963,
0.6366820931434631,
-0.6590370535850525,
-0.5022587776184082,
-0.3536197543144226,
-0.4486885666847229,
-0.5072697997093201,
0.3344178795814514,
0.17946042120456696,
0.7196477651596069,
0.07527091354131699,
0.2148514688014984,
0.799292802810669,
-0.23074455559253693,
0.23151889443397522,
0.5549390912055969,
-0.4884464740753174,
-0.06469398736953735,
0.954742968082428,
-0.3625185191631317,
0.2629619240760803,
0.347579687833786,
0.44864678382873535,
-0.2634992301464081,
-0.5173786282539368,
-0.32237711548805237,
0.10772298276424408,
-0.4370265305042267,
-0.2584899365901947,
-0.5197396278381348,
-0.15600311756134033,
-0.35238540172576904,
-0.1907072216272354,
-0.5984479784965515,
-0.11897475272417068,
-0.10126948356628418,
0.04964646324515343,
0.23594191670417786,
0.4056709408760071,
0.31207048892974854,
-0.08492233604192734,
-0.8663962483406067,
0.20883949100971222,
0.2972577214241028,
0.6211904287338257,
-0.30313172936439514,
-0.34573227167129517,
-0.28964242339134216,
0.319514662027359,
-0.38612908124923706,
-0.9109756946563721,
0.28436121344566345,
-0.07831085473299026,
0.33227482438087463,
0.36247551441192627,
0.260420560836792,
0.4816923141479492,
-0.5157849192619324,
0.5393436551094055,
0.09436637908220291,
-0.8489052653312683,
0.6378445029258728,
-0.34812110662460327,
0.16884875297546387,
0.6103919744491577,
0.49782103300094604,
-0.5444381833076477,
-0.28998297452926636,
-0.6333416104316711,
-0.5588576793670654,
0.5099008679389954,
0.05698661506175995,
0.15146169066429138,
-0.06753900647163391,
0.3846952021121979,
0.2614828944206238,
0.36395883560180664,
-0.7963946461677551,
-0.3692284822463989,
0.05311239883303642,
-0.028041673824191093,
-0.16656827926635742,
-0.25527557730674744,
0.13799388706684113,
-0.08322403579950333,
0.6812008023262024,
-0.448765367269516,
0.29633980989456177,
-0.10328636318445206,
-0.15137448906898499,
0.23309165239334106,
0.5574985146522522,
0.2242102175951004,
0.47107696533203125,
-0.23583555221557617,
-0.06308049708604813,
-0.20021730661392212,
-0.13163569569587708,
0.018221337348222733,
-0.301662802696228,
-0.23810064792633057,
-0.21601548790931702,
-0.061530400067567825,
0.6821324825286865,
0.3614278733730316,
-0.8028284907341003,
0.6913740634918213,
-0.15599797666072845,
-0.18698112666606903,
-0.18096929788589478,
0.5109643340110779,
0.032733820378780365,
0.04209176078438759,
0.1939421445131302,
0.44534870982170105,
0.24351905286312103,
-0.5859220027923584,
0.39402255415916443,
0.4437471330165863,
-0.4922843873500824,
0.07197444140911102,
0.31737107038497925,
0.4073581099510193,
-0.5529447793960571,
0.41832080483436584,
-0.44563159346580505,
-0.8458396196365356,
0.7188960909843445,
0.7169469594955444,
0.5554479360580444,
0.02649959921836853,
0.4497506022453308,
0.20651698112487793,
0.07871315628290176,
-0.09390994161367416,
0.12151435762643814,
-0.33816179633140564,
-0.8798867464065552,
-0.3526374399662018,
-0.45711857080459595,
-0.742394745349884,
-0.016781097277998924,
-0.625134289264679,
0.44336333870887756,
-0.24144232273101807,
0.06408250331878662,
-0.5768796801567078,
0.04584893956780434,
-0.5564893484115601,
0.1033547967672348,
0.1722232550382614,
0.8811141848564148,
-0.7658019661903381,
0.8419860601425171,
0.7759721279144287,
-0.1874072104692459,
-1.1040433645248413,
0.06258123368024826,
-0.14548204839229584,
-0.6859849095344543,
0.3982875645160675,
0.398616224527359,
-0.06765664368867874,
0.023798804730176926,
-0.3949262797832489,
-0.45378613471984863,
0.5205054879188538,
0.6087839603424072,
-0.7288944125175476,
0.099603570997715,
-0.032785121351480484,
0.3154466152191162,
-0.3881863057613373,
0.48995962738990784,
0.6193706393241882,
0.025499774143099785,
-0.274554967880249,
-0.7948930263519287,
-0.42481446266174316,
-0.45792052149772644,
-0.1764676421880722,
0.408554345369339,
-0.5690374970436096,
0.4699748456478119,
-0.6129233241081238,
-0.0049208905547857285,
0.0073617263697087765,
0.3786661624908447,
0.4806418716907501,
0.4040580689907074,
0.5906786918640137,
0.19637291133403778,
0.6443726420402527,
-0.08631440997123718,
1.1024436950683594,
-0.36959898471832275,
0.5906275510787964,
1.0771420001983643,
-0.4132867753505707,
0.8438364267349243,
0.32359179854393005,
-0.3582446575164795,
0.4714241623878479,
0.5719114542007446,
0.40526083111763,
0.47952863574028015,
0.12997932732105255,
0.23846986889839172,
-0.3267132043838501,
0.053429245948791504,
-0.6442830562591553,
0.32592883706092834,
0.1411239355802536,
-0.14836791157722473,
0.09589521586894989,
-0.020628882572054863,
0.0168522447347641,
0.30206629633903503,
-0.25569820404052734,
0.5210690498352051,
0.08877669274806976,
-0.7296482920646667,
0.5750676989555359,
-0.08648710697889328,
0.8369372487068176,
-0.5911334753036499,
-0.0527973398566246,
-0.41742369532585144,
0.3476391136646271,
-0.22252227365970612,
-0.5890333652496338,
0.1609645038843155,
0.1650504767894745,
-0.16998030245304108,
-0.31943756341934204,
0.7451233267784119,
-0.3322812616825104,
-0.20459887385368347,
0.21396398544311523,
0.26383593678474426,
-0.009946983307600021,
-0.11446148157119751,
-0.9638688564300537,
-0.12341386824846268,
0.1938188374042511,
-0.0783529132604599,
0.3895089626312256,
0.07195676118135452,
0.17690476775169373,
0.7773430943489075,
0.660359263420105,
0.19423066079616547,
-0.03663777559995651,
0.3087792992591858,
0.6159657835960388,
-0.5112872123718262,
-0.8390262722969055,
-0.6885144114494324,
0.503440797328949,
-0.05294010415673256,
-0.15385790169239044,
0.7436749935150146,
0.8301653861999512,
1.0935416221618652,
-0.2823154628276825,
0.9183463454246521,
0.07375471293926239,
0.39473021030426025,
-0.6260907053947449,
0.44383078813552856,
-0.5144760012626648,
0.3848056197166443,
-0.28580158948898315,
-0.8845181465148926,
-0.36496299505233765,
0.5892401337623596,
-0.6138399243354797,
0.15936236083507538,
0.6589480638504028,
1.0157678127288818,
-0.1237972229719162,
0.11113918572664261,
0.2931857407093048,
-0.05050678178668022,
0.36588191986083984,
0.9504409432411194,
0.7964438199996948,
-0.34338077902793884,
0.5542563796043396,
-0.3569723963737488,
-0.47250357270240784,
-0.4399358034133911,
-0.8478266596794128,
-0.7974169850349426,
-0.41236612200737,
-0.42180195450782776,
-0.4573172926902771,
0.0458541139960289,
1.1352684497833252,
0.7740013599395752,
-0.821884036064148,
-0.4094253480434418,
-0.46333879232406616,
0.17908291518688202,
-0.36788812279701233,
-0.2826080322265625,
-0.019815392792224884,
-0.6563384532928467,
-0.5894805788993835,
0.3126702904701233,
0.24638596177101135,
-0.17990952730178833,
0.03487377241253853,
-0.6317737698554993,
0.3433680236339569,
-0.17032058537006378,
0.41371992230415344,
0.3985839784145355,
-0.25245973467826843,
-0.053417183458805084,
0.23365415632724762,
-0.29619553685188293,
0.21615846455097198,
1.2758069038391113,
-0.8302333950996399,
0.39309725165367126,
0.16796892881393433,
0.8949123620986938,
0.2449840009212494,
-0.2811037302017212,
0.5271312594413757,
-0.49935269355773926,
0.09664709866046906,
0.2913544774055481,
0.5538974404335022,
0.14973944425582886,
-0.40043383836746216,
0.49802908301353455,
0.13607317209243774,
-0.6548671722412109,
-0.7562808394432068,
0.4931301772594452,
-0.7330690622329712,
-0.22159512341022491,
1.3728771209716797,
0.014019756577908993,
-0.1618913859128952,
-0.08086077868938446,
-0.5353677868843079,
0.08635157346725464,
-0.49655768275260925,
0.8072348237037659,
0.21291999518871307,
-0.15425604581832886,
0.0014233473921194673,
-0.3936876356601715,
0.5511333346366882,
0.8485070466995239,
-0.6325653195381165,
0.15264764428138733,
0.49723729491233826,
0.39752885699272156,
0.0122932568192482,
0.7663904428482056,
-0.26067084074020386,
0.6430085897445679,
-0.4119235575199127,
-0.06776190549135208,
-0.26702117919921875,
-0.5975448489189148,
-0.4409133791923523,
0.10980600118637085,
0.5272284150123596,
-0.2812212109565735
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06878v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06878v1
|
Modeling language contact with the Iterated Learning Model
| 2024-06-11T01:43:23 | 2024-06-11T01:43:23 |
Seth Bullock, Conor Houghton
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Contact between languages has the potential to transmit vocabulary and other
language features; however, this does not always happen. Here, an iterated
learning model is used to examine, in a simple way, the resistance of languages
to change during language contact. Iterated learning models are agent-based
models of language change, they demonstrate that languages that are expressive
and compositional arise spontaneously as a consequence of a language
transmission bottleneck. A recently introduced type of iterated learning model,
the Semi-Supervised ILM is used to simulate language contact. These simulations
do not include many of the complex factors involved in language contact and do
not model a population of speakers; nonetheless the model demonstrates that the
dynamics which lead languages in the model to spontaneously become expressive
and compositional, also cause a language to maintain its core traits even after
mixing with another language.
|
[
-0.08295105397701263,
-0.6863430738449097,
0.3873434364795685,
0.24220150709152222,
0.055093914270401,
0.39561429619789124,
-0.27333664894104004,
-0.7330330610275269,
-0.00774703873321414,
0.6626182198524475,
-0.5402587652206421,
-0.3031820058822632,
-0.2791014015674591,
0.036906104534864426,
-0.5853055715560913,
0.8514747619628906,
-0.17156869173049927,
-0.14639389514923096,
-0.19311819970607758,
-0.14289702475070953,
-0.19517238438129425,
-0.5848477482795715,
-0.7330469489097595,
-0.6894681453704834,
0.2608680725097656,
0.3428483009338379,
0.5266439914703369,
0.5182633399963379,
0.3785504698753357,
0.43800997734069824,
-0.058549270033836365,
-0.26971158385276794,
-0.4553945064544678,
-0.05949632078409195,
-0.45346781611442566,
-0.8783278465270996,
0.1129525750875473,
0.1465490609407425,
0.8755479454994202,
1.1414839029312134,
-0.26686951518058777,
-0.10668258368968964,
-0.14303681254386902,
0.8818200826644897,
-0.20927214622497559,
0.34630316495895386,
-0.37362444400787354,
-0.01914566569030285,
-0.27303841710090637,
-0.2710096836090088,
-0.6821163296699524,
-0.14584609866142273,
0.3305458128452301,
-0.13298431038856506,
0.13955309987068176,
-0.19303834438323975,
0.6688273549079895,
-0.22003431618213654,
-0.47311875224113464,
-0.20882432162761688,
-1.1982141733169556,
0.6616582870483398,
-0.6528152227401733,
0.345685750246048,
0.4489120841026306,
0.26408466696739197,
-0.06833013892173767,
-0.6428307890892029,
-0.47280973196029663,
-0.9156442284584045,
0.08856485038995743,
0.004713950678706169,
0.031096670776605606,
0.08445379883050919,
0.1037607342004776,
0.24788130819797516,
-0.22980262339115143,
0.04889572784304619,
-0.5659590363502502,
0.15231075882911682,
0.7545524835586548,
0.264772891998291,
0.5910095572471619,
0.2944052815437317,
-0.6387649774551392,
-0.17293314635753632,
-0.7017543315887451,
0.24507944285869598,
0.5368494391441345,
0.579612672328949,
-0.2942868173122406,
0.511591374874115,
0.07635242491960526,
1.0867669582366943,
0.067779541015625,
-0.4131736159324646,
0.18339715898036957,
-0.267263799905777,
0.023762546479701996,
-0.029530785977840424,
0.705177366733551,
0.15609095990657806,
0.30696606636047363,
-0.4202171266078949,
-0.27866652607917786,
0.025194460526108742,
0.35926201939582825,
-0.40931233763694763,
-0.07428169995546341,
-0.013806463219225407,
-0.36611777544021606,
-0.3011307418346405,
0.05097667872905731,
-0.3539256155490875,
0.1517280638217926,
-0.3848508298397064,
0.5108806490898132,
-0.6058834791183472,
-0.8220086097717285,
-0.014942816458642483,
0.09836570918560028,
-0.042201872915029526,
0.2716522514820099,
-0.9176425933837891,
0.654977560043335,
0.3718882203102112,
0.9238235354423523,
-0.3533419370651245,
-0.7729382514953613,
-0.04998779296875,
-0.01021952647715807,
-0.6142293214797974,
0.8797175884246826,
-0.8147363662719727,
-0.350276917219162,
0.2355017066001892,
0.11798430234193802,
-0.7429535984992981,
-0.8099092245101929,
-0.22621363401412964,
-0.6755115985870361,
0.13316594064235687,
0.038540489971637726,
-0.7734753489494324,
-0.4876081943511963,
0.13185040652751923,
-0.8462343811988831,
1.0406094789505005,
0.4544298052787781,
-0.5730318427085876,
0.14808019995689392,
-0.46473178267478943,
-0.45025309920310974,
0.08509761095046997,
0.09984137862920761,
-0.3828109800815582,
0.12368187308311462,
-0.8775162696838379,
0.17571216821670532,
-0.21705028414726257,
0.25207293033599854,
-0.34059593081474304,
-0.1329975724220276,
0.31693512201309204,
-0.007040938828140497,
0.77748042345047,
0.16929830610752106,
-0.22241313755512238,
0.23840835690498352,
-0.9101061224937439,
-0.2257091999053955,
0.14869064092636108,
-0.6266166567802429,
-0.38625574111938477,
0.19441936910152435,
0.024020565673708916,
0.5890113115310669,
0.11891798675060272,
-0.203473761677742,
0.5478968024253845,
-0.45232874155044556,
0.2704569697380066,
0.418605238199234,
0.16860663890838623,
0.798126757144928,
-0.6925972700119019,
0.4944645166397095,
0.43477028608322144,
-0.07887272536754608,
-0.014363308437168598,
-0.1344773769378662,
-0.8593621850013733,
0.05288511514663696,
0.2117626965045929,
0.5232734084129333,
-1.0288677215576172,
-0.07020500302314758,
0.09795808792114258,
-0.5093325972557068,
-0.5004751086235046,
0.37168964743614197,
0.29811087250709534,
0.3357677757740021,
0.05993673577904701,
-0.39486661553382874,
-0.30686426162719727,
-0.4995335042476654,
-0.14037087559700012,
-0.5599089860916138,
0.39791035652160645,
-0.09776635468006134,
0.35544276237487793,
-0.07425601035356522,
0.6095291376113892,
0.28057724237442017,
-0.20865224301815033,
-0.6196838617324829,
0.2357795089483261,
-0.1848088502883911,
0.40814635157585144,
0.6421407461166382,
-0.6902130246162415,
-0.7773625254631042,
0.23146399855613708,
-0.5858399271965027,
-0.09577000141143799,
-0.17033201456069946,
0.22989194095134735,
0.39595580101013184,
0.7083297967910767,
-0.24979236721992493,
0.4733477234840393,
0.6391343474388123,
-0.2639334797859192,
0.35478755831718445,
-0.23137405514717102,
-0.02284875325858593,
-1.1829299926757812,
-0.029404083266854286,
0.08232706785202026,
-0.1295497566461563,
-1.1481627225875854,
-0.009179837070405483,
-0.1382090151309967,
0.159590944647789,
-0.7527151107788086,
0.7237005233764648,
-0.7034388780593872,
-0.26781797409057617,
-0.42468827962875366,
-0.10301854461431503,
-0.49575239419937134,
0.27726495265960693,
0.37150636315345764,
0.6065032482147217,
0.8245383501052856,
-0.9062772989273071,
0.260949045419693,
-0.1485266238451004,
-0.22863738238811493,
0.35997265577316284,
-0.3118010461330414,
0.16373847424983978,
0.011961568146944046,
-0.2825067937374115,
-1.0016415119171143,
-0.02486901544034481,
0.03991621732711792,
-0.14492982625961304,
0.4602009952068329,
-0.1275753676891327,
-0.557531476020813,
-0.15767014026641846,
-0.17754560708999634,
0.35915225744247437,
0.09868468344211578,
-0.39254650473594666,
0.7642704844474792,
0.059147682040929794,
-0.004471536260098219,
-0.34861132502555847,
-0.33550959825515747,
0.11701499670743942,
-0.1526840627193451,
-0.6052808165550232,
0.18461549282073975,
-0.13041117787361145,
-0.6306387782096863,
0.1375252604484558,
0.2763030529022217,
-0.10033391416072845,
0.3774896562099457,
0.19965848326683044,
0.2313806712627411,
-0.06914757937192917,
0.2510295510292053,
-0.3570350706577301,
-0.018569232895970345,
-0.07077379524707794,
-0.11160484701395035,
0.7258170247077942,
-0.09012962132692337,
-0.5108424425125122,
-0.4894045293331146,
0.448143869638443,
0.575472354888916,
-0.2820114493370056,
1.1197657585144043,
0.050084374845027924,
-0.3148459196090698,
-0.2814432382583618,
-0.333556205034256,
-0.24374522268772125,
-0.4332844316959381,
0.2667970061302185,
-0.6950950026512146,
-0.7787545323371887,
0.7606024742126465,
-0.35795366764068604,
-0.05621114745736122,
0.45570430159568787,
0.7965903878211975,
-0.07328157871961594,
0.8288412094116211,
1.2711782455444336,
-0.20471985638141632,
0.8953766226768494,
-0.12479159981012344,
0.11374062299728394,
-0.4837908148765564,
-0.4018228054046631,
-0.556442141532898,
-0.044719524681568146,
-0.8572056889533997,
-0.29117676615715027,
-0.05571313202381134,
0.28277620673179626,
0.09121325612068176,
0.44871947169303894,
0.11813031882047653,
0.16181187331676483,
0.6227878332138062,
0.012696943245828152,
0.4657176434993744,
-0.039937857538461685,
-0.4505472779273987,
0.2569195330142975,
-0.7438718676567078,
-0.4876041114330292,
0.7294678092002869,
0.19672897458076477,
1.1370865106582642,
0.27010148763656616,
0.6291896104812622,
0.3178827166557312,
0.4524534344673157,
-0.5907294154167175,
0.4493309259414673,
0.1726362705230713,
-0.5350316762924194,
-0.1233077123761177,
-0.28579431772232056,
-0.8728960752487183,
-0.006316736340522766,
-0.11032228916883469,
-1.1946319341659546,
0.2792203724384308,
0.07708737999200821,
0.30915072560310364,
0.48376694321632385,
-0.4910261332988739,
0.4684235155582428,
-0.08795638382434845,
-0.5075525045394897,
-0.15884527564048767,
-0.6457394361495972,
0.24360187351703644,
-0.13002906739711761,
-0.0274400282651186,
0.028854938223958015,
0.26350152492523193,
0.5994313955307007,
-0.5766659379005432,
1.3104772567749023,
0.10905857384204865,
-0.2750305235385895,
0.5807051658630371,
0.3687439262866974,
0.3749805986881256,
-0.46138328313827515,
-0.1787017434835434,
0.024059752002358437,
-0.06311501562595367,
-0.426098495721817,
-0.20164892077445984,
0.3856835961341858,
-0.9748802185058594,
-0.5571436285972595,
-0.3528346121311188,
-0.6025530099868774,
-0.05400800332427025,
0.0790446475148201,
0.2763844430446625,
-0.007377177011221647,
-0.2386397272348404,
-0.13133010268211365,
0.446657657623291,
0.10334218293428421,
0.6533690094947815,
0.9357174634933472,
-0.48725372552871704,
0.21894624829292297,
0.8553767800331116,
0.2885608673095703,
0.8710610270500183,
0.3394307494163513,
0.03850230574607849,
-0.04679892584681511,
-0.3281143605709076,
-0.21608947217464447,
0.38306355476379395,
-0.5948755145072937,
0.2624076008796692,
-0.6424078941345215,
-0.5422742366790771,
-0.12687177956104279,
0.09046965837478638,
-0.5199035406112671,
-0.12448655813932419,
-0.3140311539173126,
-0.21881103515625,
0.32186952233314514,
1.0204704999923706,
-0.3858684301376343,
0.3190258741378784,
-0.711890459060669,
-0.02631276659667492,
0.25097596645355225,
0.31440410017967224,
-0.017928168177604675,
-0.6633949279785156,
-0.3537862002849579,
-0.15027369558811188,
-0.20047076046466827,
-1.1582409143447876,
0.4116952121257782,
0.39733362197875977,
0.6208038926124573,
0.6164630651473999,
-0.04309992119669914,
0.32458558678627014,
-0.5101156830787659,
0.4491439759731293,
0.04738856852054596,
-0.8810632824897766,
0.2999309003353119,
-0.23231549561023712,
0.06689297407865524,
0.2936796545982361,
0.47492286562919617,
-0.7574688792228699,
-0.5831679701805115,
-0.7307282090187073,
-0.6853858232498169,
0.8011894226074219,
-0.23187275230884552,
0.17442263662815094,
-0.03097575716674328,
0.28090164065361023,
0.15643668174743652,
0.2566714286804199,
-0.7805815935134888,
-0.3121308982372284,
0.12869234383106232,
-0.0007505178800784051,
-0.22462913393974304,
-0.31356048583984375,
-0.14842744171619415,
-0.05419576168060303,
0.5550358891487122,
-0.15994147956371307,
0.3247321844100952,
-0.21379609405994415,
-0.3193437457084656,
-0.5711389183998108,
0.07136935740709305,
0.7958147525787354,
0.7183937430381775,
0.0013573665637522936,
0.2096293717622757,
-0.0397767536342144,
-0.1723095178604126,
0.4238194227218628,
0.12579330801963806,
-0.19867751002311707,
0.11787492036819458,
0.5541680455207825,
1.1471362113952637,
-0.03642572835087776,
-0.5774849057197571,
0.409435898065567,
0.1825065016746521,
-0.35486456751823425,
-0.23703889548778534,
0.1644597351551056,
0.4077250361442566,
0.3247610628604889,
0.347313791513443,
0.030456870794296265,
-0.08294586092233658,
-1.0191047191619873,
0.3453001379966736,
0.282833069562912,
-0.5632903575897217,
-0.6929673552513123,
0.40157464146614075,
-0.0540507435798645,
-0.5719666481018066,
0.5196541547775269,
0.057312969118356705,
-0.758066713809967,
0.7224334478378296,
0.7937109470367432,
0.6375659108161926,
-0.901358425617218,
0.36555787920951843,
0.25769954919815063,
0.437796026468277,
-0.29954925179481506,
0.24565967917442322,
-0.13559675216674805,
-0.9488677382469177,
-0.37288060784339905,
-0.24281901121139526,
-0.6280560493469238,
0.0733860582113266,
-0.8159472942352295,
0.1448277235031128,
-0.21606728434562683,
0.03731304034590721,
-0.007640793453902006,
-0.08116136491298676,
-0.6407697796821594,
0.22144897282123566,
0.057394176721572876,
0.9775295257568359,
-1.3731493949890137,
1.010669469833374,
0.9511940479278564,
-0.49676233530044556,
-0.9442687630653381,
0.006257146596908569,
-0.04559880867600441,
-0.7399700880050659,
0.78462153673172,
0.24359755218029022,
0.05348343029618263,
0.10672729462385178,
-0.43366357684135437,
-0.7333945035934448,
0.64045649766922,
0.33678534626960754,
-0.5041165947914124,
0.0523662231862545,
0.35797277092933655,
0.6643549799919128,
-0.4913228750228882,
0.3417221009731293,
0.4255932867527008,
0.08482429385185242,
0.2452981024980545,
-0.9121349453926086,
-0.20506598055362701,
-0.33945968747138977,
0.27210938930511475,
0.2651861906051636,
-1.0088900327682495,
1.054411768913269,
-0.43610498309135437,
-0.3810478448867798,
0.04679005220532417,
0.48185995221138,
-0.09046301245689392,
0.16021175682544708,
0.5426247119903564,
0.5171834826469421,
0.5234982967376709,
-0.05433354899287224,
0.8284431099891663,
-0.5787835717201233,
0.51495760679245,
1.208109736442566,
-0.6793086528778076,
0.9366894960403442,
0.44337424635887146,
-0.2395724505186081,
0.5914669036865234,
0.7710208892822266,
0.2516966462135315,
0.6281378269195557,
0.31207403540611267,
-0.7139376997947693,
-0.11599158495664597,
-0.07696282863616943,
-0.18968245387077332,
0.6026082634925842,
0.3391837179660797,
-0.4059154689311981,
-0.4536845088005066,
0.5552762746810913,
-0.04359426349401474,
0.1903401017189026,
-0.1265740543603897,
1.2678231000900269,
-0.010199988260865211,
-0.6643772125244141,
0.47040507197380066,
-0.14355038106441498,
0.23386822640895844,
-0.5514729022979736,
-0.21599048376083374,
-0.296522319316864,
0.13366131484508514,
-0.15687346458435059,
-0.690472424030304,
0.34414225816726685,
-0.24609874188899994,
-0.24345451593399048,
-0.0003847346524707973,
0.9102898240089417,
-0.8755787014961243,
-0.41276946663856506,
0.8675041794776917,
0.7595919966697693,
0.12680713832378387,
0.3974374830722809,
-0.6743006110191345,
0.11579691618680954,
0.024656672030687332,
-0.5377575159072876,
0.6257553100585938,
0.49274590611457825,
-0.3998916745185852,
1.1083683967590332,
0.46070268750190735,
0.07517505437135696,
0.3983668386936188,
0.25435715913772583,
0.9060903191566467,
-0.5588740110397339,
-0.16564857959747314,
-0.7314005494117737,
0.49306797981262207,
0.22495785355567932,
0.14805488288402557,
0.5084112286567688,
0.18855957686901093,
0.9664469361305237,
-0.13295972347259521,
0.7428493499755859,
-0.05612586811184883,
0.514854371547699,
-0.3882286548614502,
0.4177965521812439,
-0.4404502213001251,
0.22220677137374878,
0.014779778197407722,
-0.8572940230369568,
0.07140772044658661,
0.5783256888389587,
-0.1712813377380371,
0.2983000576496124,
0.7421387434005737,
0.5356250405311584,
0.26023247838020325,
-0.30424487590789795,
0.605089008808136,
0.37726783752441406,
0.137869194149971,
0.4383755922317505,
0.810016393661499,
-0.1330195814371109,
0.04696062207221985,
-0.5401453971862793,
-0.17307515442371368,
-0.32420891523361206,
-0.7153223156929016,
-1.1043676137924194,
-1.0212347507476807,
-0.5348255634307861,
-0.5684587955474854,
0.11782895773649216,
0.9034972190856934,
0.5712515711784363,
-0.6853892803192139,
-0.628763735294342,
-0.2881407141685486,
-0.10492626577615738,
-0.47108590602874756,
-0.3124159574508667,
0.08458488434553146,
-0.6083175539970398,
-0.8700281977653503,
0.29398754239082336,
0.35635095834732056,
0.27569517493247986,
-0.40075981616973877,
0.14171968400478363,
-0.6101140975952148,
0.067545086145401,
0.5124433040618896,
0.7578095197677612,
-0.4120294451713562,
-0.14000891149044037,
-0.22562864422798157,
-0.27907705307006836,
0.19220301508903503,
0.5806886553764343,
-0.6621845364570618,
0.7759094834327698,
0.20564278960227966,
0.6067256331443787,
0.6023823618888855,
-0.26971665024757385,
0.7349003553390503,
-0.6096835136413574,
0.32137078046798706,
-0.061069101095199585,
0.19040752947330475,
0.3943629860877991,
-0.27514615654945374,
0.4744041860103607,
0.4760129153728485,
-0.2714657783508301,
-0.6032116413116455,
0.21514232456684113,
-0.8409102559089661,
-0.07155317813158035,
1.11013925075531,
-0.2922968864440918,
-0.31192687153816223,
-0.12932218611240387,
-0.054425712674856186,
0.324843168258667,
-0.06640605628490448,
0.9403111338615417,
0.8686222434043884,
-0.12148993462324142,
-0.657381534576416,
-0.5720657110214233,
0.532626211643219,
0.14061619341373444,
-0.834179162979126,
-0.19541749358177185,
-0.006789743434637785,
0.6300485730171204,
0.22844576835632324,
0.6333266496658325,
0.06904594600200653,
0.2876245975494385,
-0.13505420088768005,
0.36112430691719055,
0.47081369161605835,
-0.5146278738975525,
-0.1643386036157608,
-0.036087729036808014,
0.4912590980529785,
-0.0951162725687027
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10261v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10261v1
|
FoodSky: A Food-oriented Large Language Model that Passes the Chef and Dietetic Examination
| 2024-06-11T01:27:00 | 2024-06-11T01:27:00 |
Pengfei Zhou, Weiqing Min, Chaoran Fu, Ying Jin, Mingyu Huang, Xiangyang Li, Shuhuan Mei, Shuqiang Jiang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Food is foundational to human life, serving not only as a source of
nourishment but also as a cornerstone of cultural identity and social
interaction. As the complexity of global dietary needs and preferences grows,
food intelligence is needed to enable food perception and reasoning for various
tasks, ranging from recipe generation and dietary recommendation to
diet-disease correlation discovery and understanding. Towards this goal, for
powerful capabilities across various domains and tasks in Large Language Models
(LLMs), we introduce Food-oriented LLM FoodSky to comprehend food data through
perception and reasoning. Considering the complexity and typicality of Chinese
cuisine, we first construct one comprehensive Chinese food corpus FoodEarth
from various authoritative sources, which can be leveraged by FoodSky to
achieve deep understanding of food-related data. We then propose Topic-based
Selective State Space Model (TS3M) and the Hierarchical Topic Retrieval
Augmented Generation (HTRAG) mechanism to enhance FoodSky in capturing
fine-grained food semantics and generating context-aware food-relevant text,
respectively. Our extensive evaluations demonstrate that FoodSky significantly
outperforms general-purpose LLMs in both chef and dietetic examinations, with
an accuracy of 67.2% and 66.4% on the Chinese National Chef Exam and the
National Dietetic Exam, respectively. FoodSky not only promises to enhance
culinary creativity and promote healthier eating patterns, but also sets a new
standard for domain-specific LLMs that address complex real-world issues in the
food domain. An online demonstration of FoodSky is available at
http://222.92.101.211:8200.
|
[
0.05352000519633293,
-0.9739958643913269,
0.6675311326980591,
-0.11268796026706696,
0.11955130845308304,
-0.24286237359046936,
-0.33338460326194763,
-0.2349555790424347,
0.35261017084121704,
0.5288938879966736,
-0.522478461265564,
-0.6283554434776306,
-0.5793294906616211,
0.1297476440668106,
-0.6148974299430847,
0.7463228702545166,
0.023582344874739647,
0.1277153640985489,
-0.3345045745372772,
0.11139838397502899,
0.009033728390932083,
-0.11332178860902786,
-0.4377356171607971,
-0.16395266354084015,
0.5990069508552551,
0.633239209651947,
0.6501607894897461,
0.6847743391990662,
0.4329582452774048,
0.2726604640483856,
-0.20394273102283478,
0.26412609219551086,
-0.4246968626976013,
0.25342899560928345,
-0.33626559376716614,
-0.4411933422088623,
-0.38114261627197266,
-0.10183192789554596,
0.14819791913032532,
0.9897711873054504,
-0.24773599207401276,
0.12563665211200714,
-0.13065430521965027,
0.8552812337875366,
-0.44927358627319336,
0.26532745361328125,
-0.5137107968330383,
0.22848515212535858,
-0.04366312548518181,
0.03592871502041817,
-0.19275034964084625,
-0.3086014688014984,
0.2593754529953003,
-1.1471115350723267,
-0.2940838038921356,
-0.0748681128025055,
0.7748508453369141,
0.21387532353401184,
-0.6912088990211487,
-0.22108852863311768,
-0.6479386687278748,
0.8644681572914124,
-0.8680595755577087,
0.6777390837669373,
0.5186102986335754,
0.15600673854351044,
-0.4232299029827118,
-0.8693287968635559,
-0.813252329826355,
-0.39604195952415466,
0.2718508839607239,
0.28877946734428406,
0.33212780952453613,
-0.3090279698371887,
0.20059579610824585,
0.4445023834705353,
-0.5560910701751709,
-0.11215425282716751,
-0.24956554174423218,
0.09224197268486023,
0.48532459139823914,
0.36701858043670654,
0.8356087803840637,
-0.43638718128204346,
-0.5971728563308716,
0.01977110095322132,
-0.6171320676803589,
-0.06748799979686737,
-0.029295243322849274,
0.2762330174446106,
0.008395375683903694,
0.6051677465438843,
-0.5203107595443726,
0.7146925926208496,
-0.2769162952899933,
-0.37457185983657837,
0.13075676560401917,
-0.28302448987960815,
-0.10317555069923401,
0.15834574401378632,
0.492783784866333,
0.6606712341308594,
0.04306095466017723,
0.07465657591819763,
-0.14779675006866455,
-0.03855247423052788,
0.16678324341773987,
-0.7101390957832336,
-0.3714072108268738,
0.4582322835922241,
-0.27106383442878723,
-0.25543612241744995,
0.1418386995792389,
-0.5248942971229553,
-0.7197949290275574,
-0.4412553906440735,
0.24166613817214966,
-0.5008964538574219,
-0.5421753525733948,
0.23101148009300232,
-0.37310591340065,
0.7014332413673401,
0.3018530607223511,
-1.1126365661621094,
0.4464626908302307,
1.0864959955215454,
0.5413424968719482,
-0.16880977153778076,
-0.3659461736679077,
-0.3193565905094147,
0.5238819718360901,
-0.4704764187335968,
0.6270967125892639,
-0.6188713908195496,
-0.11353503167629242,
-0.40705761313438416,
0.17174410820007324,
0.12545718252658844,
-0.5218510031700134,
0.5014200806617737,
-0.2498682588338852,
-0.24791590869426727,
-0.8840836882591248,
-0.6654432415962219,
-0.17423802614212036,
0.6207901835441589,
-0.5943529009819031,
0.9070075154304504,
0.18688686192035675,
-0.7497417330741882,
0.6328222155570984,
-0.4531537592411041,
-0.9004356265068054,
0.39742016792297363,
-0.2530062198638916,
-0.02304139733314514,
-0.14931456744670868,
0.12052085995674133,
0.5770261287689209,
-0.4323347508907318,
0.4535391926765442,
-0.5893178582191467,
-0.23031270503997803,
0.26159119606018066,
-0.20279674232006073,
0.31050899624824524,
0.40988755226135254,
-0.004935466218739748,
0.3403063714504242,
-0.42739585041999817,
-0.1246400699019432,
0.5699818730354309,
-0.33213818073272705,
-0.5695802569389343,
0.47185468673706055,
0.1919376105070114,
-0.24466395378112793,
0.16896192729473114,
-0.4084928333759308,
0.17461742460727692,
-0.6386247277259827,
0.941416323184967,
0.5944413542747498,
-0.08129066973924637,
0.5028305053710938,
-0.25429263710975647,
0.03929485008120537,
0.15662556886672974,
0.24519266188144684,
-0.13615922629833221,
-0.6580647230148315,
-0.46680912375450134,
0.06242729350924492,
0.14097502827644348,
0.7329168915748596,
-0.7806971669197083,
0.4411362409591675,
-0.23657673597335815,
-0.48784101009368896,
0.04354718700051308,
0.027503497898578644,
-0.19427841901779175,
0.8552330732345581,
0.12091459333896637,
-0.005213784519582987,
-0.20777587592601776,
-0.7934380173683167,
-0.288875550031662,
0.31465983390808105,
-0.18473565578460693,
-0.006633103359490633,
0.4041365087032318,
-0.17661365866661072,
0.5950362086296082,
-0.849583625793457,
0.06118442863225937,
-0.7679441571235657,
-0.32129400968551636,
0.40181106328964233,
0.2635055184364319,
0.2581978440284729,
-0.8681886792182922,
-0.6474579572677612,
0.45708543062210083,
-0.644966185092926,
0.3472060263156891,
0.3333815336227417,
-0.23198392987251282,
-0.14179347455501556,
0.30446138978004456,
-0.6054412126541138,
0.22791577875614166,
0.28386950492858887,
-0.5552483797073364,
0.3862658143043518,
0.10580720752477646,
0.21158504486083984,
-1.3386539220809937,
-0.009556393139064312,
0.10586988180875778,
0.039535291492938995,
-0.5569449067115784,
0.2249031364917755,
0.16416029632091522,
-0.7074341177940369,
-0.45010465383529663,
0.8465754985809326,
-0.18237817287445068,
-0.07335072755813599,
-0.19768661260604858,
-0.07130900025367737,
0.30009883642196655,
0.4917049705982208,
0.0957174301147461,
0.4204419255256653,
0.6726927757263184,
-0.5933589935302734,
0.5885400176048279,
-0.060023561120033264,
-0.6399006247520447,
0.6053952574729919,
-0.3833440840244293,
-0.14867350459098816,
-0.04875384271144867,
0.20742341876029968,
-1.2184913158416748,
-0.46581050753593445,
0.5865637063980103,
-0.16808539628982544,
0.15460185706615448,
0.28785163164138794,
-0.6270108819007874,
-0.3248855173587799,
-0.13571113348007202,
0.08090780675411224,
0.16980479657649994,
-0.4836428463459015,
0.8485713601112366,
0.455644428730011,
0.02815364859998226,
-0.40233683586120605,
-0.6949981451034546,
-0.040577616542577744,
-0.025726279243826866,
-0.6464107632637024,
-0.04699772223830223,
-0.02790505811572075,
-0.2502897381782532,
0.12877951562404633,
-0.6585298180580139,
-0.07512630522251129,
0.3694491982460022,
0.036976203322410583,
0.06262002885341644,
-0.4326742887496948,
-0.04657936468720436,
0.00031482448684982955,
0.05971653759479523,
0.11171271651983261,
-0.5143004655838013,
0.35729917883872986,
-0.154067263007164,
0.15156374871730804,
-0.32585710287094116,
0.32762467861175537,
0.696133017539978,
-0.3307199776172638,
0.5450446605682373,
0.7435607314109802,
-0.5027527213096619,
-0.40917766094207764,
-0.06241125985980034,
-0.367176353931427,
-0.4841001331806183,
0.67585688829422,
-0.4583898186683655,
-0.34948107600212097,
0.3523634672164917,
-0.06759568303823471,
0.13256876170635223,
0.33216097950935364,
0.15600425004959106,
-0.22495612502098083,
0.619659423828125,
0.030647780746221542,
-0.11497184634208679,
0.2545826733112335,
-0.04308590292930603,
0.13089783489704132,
-0.7544946670532227,
-0.15812033414840698,
-0.21076788008213043,
-0.2696681320667267,
-0.403043270111084,
-0.44039028882980347,
0.40221527218818665,
-0.6090929508209229,
-0.3194775879383087,
0.10846690088510513,
-0.3803766667842865,
0.7148779034614563,
0.40262672305107117,
0.4668816924095154,
0.12098687142133713,
-0.039203014224767685,
-0.18645071983337402,
0.05550109222531319,
-0.6658674478530884,
-0.17244571447372437,
0.8021020889282227,
0.3828505873680115,
1.0417805910110474,
0.15364784002304077,
0.33515292406082153,
0.14961476624011993,
0.19712257385253906,
-1.237563133239746,
0.6374577879905701,
-0.7733160257339478,
-0.6693800091743469,
-0.6152385473251343,
-0.618450403213501,
-0.5239555835723877,
0.11108890175819397,
0.027951030060648918,
-0.635565996170044,
-0.3695298433303833,
0.12315376102924347,
-0.3804399073123932,
0.44311416149139404,
-1.0994397401809692,
1.0138087272644043,
-0.6307874321937561,
-0.6127651333808899,
0.321245402097702,
-0.5383008718490601,
0.40463438630104065,
0.4008670449256897,
0.14686040580272675,
-0.36349058151245117,
0.04360179230570793,
0.8941147923469543,
-0.28517159819602966,
0.7811681032180786,
-0.17083340883255005,
-0.3504956066608429,
0.014052622951567173,
0.42863985896110535,
0.33089038729667664,
0.18582871556282043,
-0.10237576812505722,
0.07763386517763138,
0.23862658441066742,
-0.16443483531475067,
-0.9889193773269653,
0.9667429327964783,
-0.6947078108787537,
-0.5633716583251953,
-0.4538411498069763,
-0.3638542890548706,
-0.3490372896194458,
0.5775333046913147,
-0.22608372569084167,
0.2772095501422882,
-0.02362421527504921,
0.01554697286337614,
0.813252866268158,
-0.4489978849887848,
-0.35372355580329895,
0.47982320189476013,
-0.31492578983306885,
-0.27376431226730347,
1.3006891012191772,
-0.07155434787273407,
-0.016588496044278145,
0.7791823148727417,
0.8169721961021423,
-0.21001693606376648,
0.02355373278260231,
-0.17993204295635223,
0.09778513014316559,
-0.9411120414733887,
-0.1435251235961914,
-0.46770524978637695,
-0.19632181525230408,
-0.26796770095825195,
-0.1302025467157364,
-0.7181649208068848,
-0.21614162623882294,
-0.3011000156402588,
-0.24388004839420319,
0.30582767724990845,
0.6976353526115417,
0.24428120255470276,
-0.16203823685646057,
-0.46466419100761414,
0.7312301993370056,
0.28412023186683655,
0.43272894620895386,
0.3212396800518036,
-0.24961300194263458,
-0.06763390451669693,
-0.19541002810001373,
-0.11348354816436768,
-0.946662962436676,
0.3122461438179016,
0.05001543462276459,
0.5012466311454773,
0.7671863436698914,
-0.09226813167333603,
0.3410240709781647,
-0.3895862400531769,
0.7201751470565796,
0.2605583071708679,
-0.976944088935852,
0.6056491136550903,
-0.4805590510368347,
0.7752342224121094,
0.4695374369621277,
0.5425248146057129,
-1.1181384325027466,
-0.2062191665172577,
0.15149381756782532,
-1.104089617729187,
0.6223281025886536,
-0.33079978823661804,
-0.020039990544319153,
-0.1929432451725006,
0.3111751973628998,
0.38428428769111633,
-0.09240227937698364,
-0.6961347460746765,
-0.15838557481765747,
-0.593786895275116,
-0.26868581771850586,
0.2812911868095398,
-0.2661420404911041,
-0.0681290328502655,
-0.5907199382781982,
0.6643106937408447,
-0.04754404351115227,
0.10007649660110474,
0.16921675205230713,
0.2751029133796692,
-0.16439229249954224,
0.442349910736084,
0.5013380646705627,
0.7405304908752441,
-0.3789311945438385,
0.24817223846912384,
0.04158255457878113,
-0.6004812717437744,
0.04274635761976242,
-0.16023710370063782,
0.08065561205148697,
-0.5945776700973511,
0.3113197684288025,
0.4874507784843445,
0.4179699122905731,
-0.5398073792457581,
0.36635422706604004,
-0.25925901532173157,
-0.38561883568763733,
-0.3489321768283844,
0.24555882811546326,
0.47108304500579834,
0.014562081545591354,
0.3514648377895355,
-0.2852310836315155,
0.41620758175849915,
-0.6442690491676331,
0.26377072930336,
0.17114034295082092,
-0.16492216289043427,
-0.2689831852912903,
0.525757372379303,
0.5086362957954407,
0.23970456421375275,
1.1219407320022583,
-0.23491550981998444,
-0.5561315417289734,
0.7963336706161499,
0.49904027581214905,
0.5397605299949646,
-0.2530125379562378,
0.25630295276641846,
0.5737159848213196,
0.29156094789505005,
-0.16016997396945953,
0.7256120443344116,
-0.2517963945865631,
-0.9301403760910034,
-0.21106122434139252,
-0.7592623233795166,
-0.392212837934494,
0.5816231966018677,
-0.5144128203392029,
0.08051936328411102,
-0.6312939524650574,
0.1559496968984604,
0.13649703562259674,
-0.032522205263376236,
-0.5591006278991699,
0.2523983418941498,
0.5272780060768127,
1.0583046674728394,
-0.7226960062980652,
0.7544287443161011,
0.8528990745544434,
0.001157568534836173,
-0.8070995211601257,
0.42851120233535767,
0.14019614458084106,
-0.8602771759033203,
0.6773101687431335,
0.22182418406009674,
0.09760686755180359,
-0.35473698377609253,
-0.7030031681060791,
-0.9393261075019836,
0.8362134099006653,
0.027144096791744232,
-0.6968816518783569,
-0.07071472704410553,
0.13593000173568726,
0.24609257280826569,
0.12475927919149399,
0.0872805193066597,
0.4029291868209839,
0.8771212100982666,
0.2938537001609802,
-0.38666921854019165,
0.23245787620544434,
-0.11488457024097443,
-0.04257438704371452,
0.15163594484329224,
-0.7791000604629517,
0.671532154083252,
-0.44331860542297363,
-0.28961893916130066,
0.009554157964885235,
0.7379717230796814,
0.3147719204425812,
0.46666374802589417,
0.39739471673965454,
0.5568837523460388,
0.5615247488021851,
-0.2421836256980896,
1.0012061595916748,
-0.19075629115104675,
0.14274254441261292,
1.0165021419525146,
-0.771599531173706,
0.7191744446754456,
0.545555055141449,
-0.1161077544093132,
0.035293109714984894,
0.938503623008728,
-0.07036750018596649,
0.7228140830993652,
0.47385093569755554,
0.059922996908426285,
-0.27408766746520996,
-0.16372734308242798,
-0.2426852434873581,
0.7985370755195618,
0.6666065454483032,
-0.280988872051239,
-0.10150831192731857,
-0.005281710997223854,
-0.06309620290994644,
0.038059718906879425,
-0.08541816473007202,
0.6635662317276001,
0.30741387605667114,
-0.3846568167209625,
0.10789845883846283,
0.19032566249370575,
0.28467920422554016,
-0.7891114354133606,
-0.33596187829971313,
-0.45252910256385803,
-0.07409030944108963,
-0.23353315889835358,
-1.0201032161712646,
0.16360259056091309,
-0.466714084148407,
-0.04399294778704643,
-0.017297523096203804,
0.6552547812461853,
-0.311049222946167,
-0.5583125352859497,
0.215016171336174,
0.26574522256851196,
-0.041768305003643036,
0.04685113951563835,
-0.6780073642730713,
0.37488895654678345,
-0.30938783288002014,
-0.3485584259033203,
-0.09878819435834885,
0.5588666200637817,
0.42892053723335266,
0.42391252517700195,
0.41456127166748047,
0.054938800632953644,
-0.4157710373401642,
-0.012985131703317165,
0.7965532541275024,
-0.8677582144737244,
-0.946305513381958,
-0.7116472125053406,
0.14855556190013885,
0.21278293430805206,
-0.06848537176847458,
0.5557421445846558,
0.4856926202774048,
1.0099610090255737,
-0.3924720585346222,
0.7722305059432983,
-0.10392534732818604,
0.3746609389781952,
-0.7028916478157043,
0.9577178359031677,
-1.1564644575119019,
0.19035276770591736,
-0.11045430600643158,
-0.6049210429191589,
-0.08795800805091858,
0.4700073301792145,
-0.7259082794189453,
0.039321593940258026,
0.629122257232666,
0.5404262542724609,
-0.3893950581550598,
0.09069042652845383,
0.592521071434021,
0.3804112672805786,
0.029901448637247086,
0.716693639755249,
1.1973463296890259,
-0.1338896006345749,
0.019276440143585205,
-0.12087012827396393,
-0.030325114727020264,
-0.03765023499727249,
-0.47564083337783813,
-0.6491467356681824,
-0.7578374743461609,
-0.05626027286052704,
0.10139869898557663,
0.0887436717748642,
0.8408171534538269,
0.8761165142059326,
-0.5805984735488892,
-0.3717505931854248,
0.1024845764040947,
0.37031447887420654,
-0.4454837143421173,
-0.37462079524993896,
0.24988673627376556,
0.015169685706496239,
-0.43304964900016785,
0.4936152398586273,
0.41176217794418335,
-0.5471968054771423,
-0.25167661905288696,
0.014703776687383652,
-0.26591357588768005,
0.14693203568458557,
0.8035780787467957,
0.2834866940975189,
-0.8525251746177673,
0.1511465162038803,
-0.0155564546585083,
-0.06485302001237869,
0.10505715757608414,
0.6488834023475647,
-0.06998143345117569,
0.5022411346435547,
0.3904555141925812,
0.7473176121711731,
0.18426069617271423,
-0.2760775685310364,
0.4004937708377838,
-0.6168166995048523,
-0.14154529571533203,
-0.010656505823135376,
0.28614896535873413,
0.4314931333065033,
-0.6943656206130981,
0.24510221183300018,
0.24747544527053833,
-0.2968953549861908,
-0.3595940172672272,
0.24139805138111115,
-1.0294657945632935,
-0.6989994049072266,
1.442466139793396,
0.07860065251588821,
-0.9293621778488159,
0.3674890398979187,
0.13555635511875153,
0.3318738341331482,
-0.6141293048858643,
0.6535124182701111,
0.5786309838294983,
-0.014412042684853077,
-0.17838217318058014,
-0.64313143491745,
0.4170909821987152,
0.24749428033828735,
-1.2320928573608398,
0.1555318832397461,
0.20937694609165192,
0.7644978165626526,
0.022103337571024895,
0.35851773619651794,
0.08008162677288055,
0.305035799741745,
-0.03846464678645134,
-0.025354493409395218,
0.09570365399122238,
-0.5757389664649963,
0.31355714797973633,
-0.02645309641957283,
0.115786112844944,
0.025375062599778175
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10260v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10260v1
|
Flextron: Many-in-One Flexible Large Language Model
| 2024-06-11T01:16:10 | 2024-06-11T01:16:10 |
Ruisi Cai, Saurav Muralidharan, Greg Heinrich, Hongxu Yin, Zhangyang Wang, Jan Kautz, Pavlo Molchanov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Training modern LLMs is extremely resource intensive, and customizing them
for various deployment scenarios characterized by limited compute and memory
resources through repeated training is impractical. In this paper, we introduce
Flextron, a network architecture and post-training model optimization framework
supporting flexible model deployment. The Flextron architecture utilizes a
nested elastic structure to rapidly adapt to specific user-defined latency and
accuracy targets during inference with no additional fine-tuning required. It
is also input-adaptive, and can automatically route tokens through its
sub-networks for improved performance and efficiency. We present a
sample-efficient training method and associated routing algorithms for
systematically transforming an existing trained LLM into a Flextron model. We
evaluate Flextron on the GPT-3 and LLama-2 family of LLMs, and demonstrate
superior performance over multiple end-to-end trained variants and other
state-of-the-art elastic networks, all with a single pretraining run that
consumes a mere 7.63% tokens compared to original pretraining.
|
[
-0.44276368618011475,
-0.6009857654571533,
0.45771849155426025,
-0.014517143368721008,
-0.2972353398799896,
0.09840438514947891,
-0.5664930939674377,
-0.23480331897735596,
0.05341699719429016,
0.5659603476524353,
-0.6431598663330078,
-0.10800494998693466,
-0.3560449481010437,
0.12151484191417694,
-0.3452345132827759,
0.9448724985122681,
-0.22454620897769928,
-0.06749410182237625,
0.2533171474933624,
-0.3669547140598297,
-0.03856099396944046,
-0.24704991281032562,
-0.5312642455101013,
-0.5644845366477966,
0.5340172052383423,
0.3757905960083008,
0.8647804260253906,
0.7002008557319641,
0.04801540449261665,
0.5048595070838928,
-0.26953718066215515,
0.28414490818977356,
-0.5666060447692871,
-0.041994012892246246,
-0.2350427359342575,
-0.5011539459228516,
-0.5483463406562805,
-0.24929697811603546,
0.7822702527046204,
0.7198995351791382,
-0.47500455379486084,
0.2792034149169922,
-0.2818939983844757,
0.3289943039417267,
-0.36770394444465637,
-0.49378108978271484,
-0.6873553395271301,
0.08237000554800034,
-0.10963714867830276,
0.07775501161813736,
-0.2182367891073227,
-0.2765827476978302,
0.28793805837631226,
-0.9325616955757141,
0.19215717911720276,
0.11276716738939285,
0.6137859225273132,
0.2607779800891876,
-0.4140257239341736,
0.24981482326984406,
-0.7816622853279114,
0.648468017578125,
-0.5861603617668152,
0.5856700539588928,
-0.39702582359313965,
0.7102714776992798,
-0.28381606936454773,
-1.0821592807769775,
-0.6310487985610962,
-0.009040763601660728,
0.28698405623435974,
0.12250537425279617,
0.25553926825523376,
0.21530546247959137,
-0.15189938247203827,
0.02426437847316265,
-0.6827195286750793,
0.44506171345710754,
-0.2076185941696167,
0.2987144887447357,
0.2827761769294739,
0.09375368058681488,
0.027112694457173347,
0.380471408367157,
-0.5599904656410217,
-0.11352181434631348,
-0.8410283923149109,
-0.21886982023715973,
0.596118152141571,
0.5622237324714661,
-0.1864999532699585,
0.2972043752670288,
0.0013354086549952626,
0.3979175090789795,
-0.08829350769519806,
0.012059834785759449,
0.4692874252796173,
-0.16283173859119415,
-0.45134952664375305,
-0.023451317101716995,
0.7464215755462646,
-0.34157225489616394,
0.298967570066452,
-0.2664516866207123,
-0.4356158673763275,
0.015724511817097664,
0.6340729594230652,
-0.6133525371551514,
0.1420009732246399,
0.20943300426006317,
-0.35744521021842957,
-0.06253755837678909,
-0.19360986351966858,
-0.6424460411071777,
-0.3000822067260742,
-0.3371559679508209,
0.21648384630680084,
-0.2251083254814148,
-0.7345211505889893,
0.41576406359672546,
0.04844304546713829,
0.19557297229766846,
0.501628041267395,
-0.9374094605445862,
0.6178625226020813,
0.743923008441925,
0.6787245273590088,
-0.2169710397720337,
-0.6255369186401367,
-0.2099112719297409,
0.0465208925306797,
-0.11234687268733978,
0.8081218004226685,
-0.19782207906246185,
-0.2040204256772995,
-0.07930704206228256,
0.15055392682552338,
-0.46924617886543274,
-0.5414690971374512,
0.19850526750087738,
-0.6530299782752991,
0.06791610270738602,
0.5509521961212158,
-0.385220468044281,
-0.3686378300189972,
0.5164708495140076,
-0.7077162861824036,
0.7438793182373047,
0.6438832879066467,
-0.5321758985519409,
-0.014350119978189468,
-0.7599596977233887,
-0.46115928888320923,
0.1987120807170868,
-0.24111609160900116,
-0.5636395812034607,
0.028540663421154022,
-0.014674808830022812,
0.332945317029953,
-0.7310255169868469,
0.11116396635770798,
-0.16380621492862701,
-0.46308082342147827,
0.10820717364549637,
-0.15176786482334137,
0.5329993963241577,
0.1957034170627594,
-0.6038275957107544,
0.5471153855323792,
-0.6601219177246094,
0.003209427697584033,
0.2895645201206207,
-0.6236674189567566,
0.26090162992477417,
0.03739335760474205,
0.34499141573905945,
0.0208707507699728,
0.005343484692275524,
-0.5380372405052185,
0.3696425259113312,
-0.6547079086303711,
0.5062426328659058,
0.8947821855545044,
-0.44801095128059387,
0.4981028139591217,
-0.3230724334716797,
0.8984832167625427,
-0.18443745374679565,
0.4388250410556793,
-0.0007953596068546176,
-0.010317136533558369,
-0.6158296465873718,
-0.26134252548217773,
0.04165559262037277,
0.5027010440826416,
-0.6535901427268982,
0.10266685485839844,
-0.5097366571426392,
-0.530075192451477,
-0.35400038957595825,
0.41318392753601074,
0.17640803754329681,
0.6359276175498962,
0.3984176218509674,
0.055470507591962814,
-0.38097015023231506,
-0.8300747871398926,
-0.07145953923463821,
0.10646114498376846,
-0.006108192726969719,
0.3074588477611542,
0.2767268717288971,
-0.7886248826980591,
0.6368568539619446,
-0.21363039314746857,
0.02604464255273342,
-0.802490770816803,
-0.145090252161026,
0.4709619879722595,
0.22757741808891296,
0.4321115016937256,
-0.8423417210578918,
-0.2621729373931885,
0.35639750957489014,
-0.3403468728065491,
0.10233628749847412,
-0.12104786187410355,
0.14492125809192657,
0.12238755822181702,
0.23318704962730408,
-0.4904884099960327,
-0.09875794500112534,
0.7883036136627197,
-0.055678509175777435,
0.6677648425102234,
-0.1349247694015503,
-0.3458470404148102,
-0.9288464784622192,
-0.11316143721342087,
-0.19547811150550842,
-0.3791813850402832,
-0.41590604186058044,
-0.03231021389365196,
-0.2193177044391632,
-0.040919896215200424,
-0.8808877468109131,
0.6211659908294678,
-0.3397912383079529,
-0.07037143409252167,
-0.1726173758506775,
-0.017281880602240562,
0.02582799270749092,
0.5172387957572937,
-0.2769211232662201,
0.8689520955085754,
0.5645856857299805,
-0.4601491391658783,
0.5261396765708923,
0.12520906329154968,
-0.16461911797523499,
0.27723944187164307,
-0.7036818265914917,
0.16696937382221222,
-0.20564544200897217,
0.27753180265426636,
-1.0120561122894287,
-0.15053783357143402,
0.006681851111352444,
0.2537437975406647,
0.1820726990699768,
-0.017134882509708405,
-0.4809207022190094,
-0.40132391452789307,
-0.2410345822572708,
0.6692148447036743,
0.40986937284469604,
-0.8258277773857117,
1.0060349702835083,
0.33508744835853577,
0.22580569982528687,
-0.2465883046388626,
-0.6759473085403442,
-0.2909686863422394,
-0.27637115120887756,
-0.7410594820976257,
0.3441838324069977,
0.1474483460187912,
0.2731589674949646,
-0.11643268913030624,
-0.18743881583213806,
-0.12530533969402313,
0.3535209596157074,
0.08776367455720901,
-0.0510692223906517,
-0.5892179608345032,
0.18015101552009583,
-0.11347563564777374,
-0.10864237695932388,
-0.3051305115222931,
-0.4376246929168701,
0.6977391242980957,
-0.6398649215698242,
-0.2653449773788452,
-0.3088400959968567,
0.23631183803081512,
0.6781944036483765,
-0.12077054381370544,
0.6734063029289246,
0.627434492111206,
-0.06605914235115051,
-0.6501269340515137,
-0.5403770208358765,
-0.1340571641921997,
-0.6272096633911133,
0.5239275097846985,
-0.29577338695526123,
-0.9666017889976501,
0.38482025265693665,
-0.93929523229599,
0.08367881178855896,
0.256086140871048,
0.48743221163749695,
-0.02596462331712246,
0.6368608474731445,
0.6824437975883484,
0.21928371489048004,
0.7393700480461121,
-0.5056537389755249,
-0.06245394051074982,
-0.9642559885978699,
-0.1283620148897171,
-0.21717585623264313,
-0.33278805017471313,
-0.7428017854690552,
-0.30255916714668274,
0.5430049896240234,
-0.21122249960899353,
-0.8879987001419067,
0.6397364735603333,
-0.5528185963630676,
0.35177069902420044,
0.3918651342391968,
0.27757591009140015,
-0.06195922940969467,
-0.1417374461889267,
-0.16423094272613525,
0.5427256226539612,
-1.234532356262207,
-0.47619515657424927,
1.180755376815796,
0.47966623306274414,
0.7669579386711121,
0.3340998589992523,
0.3903215229511261,
-0.324310302734375,
0.5958778262138367,
-0.4959685206413269,
0.5962141156196594,
-0.25977033376693726,
-0.3983152508735657,
-0.44813692569732666,
-0.6772286891937256,
-1.1042109727859497,
0.3704190254211426,
-0.2370997965335846,
-0.7127730846405029,
-0.13589920103549957,
0.09426185488700867,
-0.3011115789413452,
0.47237929701805115,
-0.7568807601928711,
0.9961339235305786,
-0.816771924495697,
-0.3849903345108032,
-0.2226639837026596,
-0.7279015183448792,
0.2593230903148651,
-0.21258343756198883,
0.10897915810346603,
-0.2017202377319336,
-0.22607554495334625,
0.4556392431259155,
-0.5507022142410278,
0.6158068776130676,
-0.03069089911878109,
0.3360050916671753,
0.22969739139080048,
-0.11195722222328186,
0.47851645946502686,
0.00949067622423172,
-0.5475522875785828,
0.10732723772525787,
-0.34499943256378174,
-0.13903085887432098,
-0.5339514017105103,
0.38007980585098267,
-1.2421272993087769,
-0.3110068142414093,
-0.024723907932639122,
-0.4470716118812561,
-0.11232879757881165,
0.36020466685295105,
0.12602806091308594,
0.27412140369415283,
-0.27314293384552,
0.24352850019931793,
0.48139461874961853,
-0.47754549980163574,
0.5616385340690613,
0.27084803581237793,
0.10701417177915573,
-0.5010734796524048,
0.4083312749862671,
0.004531797952950001,
0.30702856183052063,
0.3864688575267792,
0.45972803235054016,
-0.6415743827819824,
-0.57509845495224,
-0.5834107995033264,
0.3830872178077698,
-0.45269158482551575,
-0.3692691922187805,
-0.37427252531051636,
-0.23871567845344543,
-0.18426810204982758,
-0.4907911419868469,
-1.0827828645706177,
-0.23437617719173431,
-0.5490255951881409,
-0.05357551947236061,
0.4256705641746521,
0.5797809958457947,
0.5007089376449585,
1.289783239364624,
-0.47664421796798706,
0.31049609184265137,
0.30588498711586,
0.9374359846115112,
-0.10151926428079605,
-0.5354436039924622,
-0.30378207564353943,
-0.3251960277557373,
-0.436559796333313,
-0.5438287258148193,
0.18083755671977997,
0.36376115679740906,
0.724816083908081,
0.236724391579628,
-0.22045530378818512,
0.4469000995159149,
-0.7623555064201355,
0.4282413125038147,
0.40021103620529175,
-0.810391366481781,
0.13833683729171753,
-0.5243032574653625,
0.5212112069129944,
0.6847939491271973,
0.31845149397850037,
-0.25338464975357056,
0.10018856823444366,
-0.631720781326294,
-1.021413803100586,
0.6148954033851624,
-0.25297778844833374,
0.23517544567584991,
0.2114628404378891,
0.47750356793403625,
0.040684182196855545,
0.4437486231327057,
-0.7368133664131165,
-0.028545508161187172,
-0.45226460695266724,
-0.24203918874263763,
0.1532798409461975,
0.07924043387174606,
-0.27007973194122314,
-0.18965066969394684,
0.41893965005874634,
-0.44871625304222107,
0.20401741564273834,
-0.10172243416309357,
-0.06481184810400009,
0.03377668559551239,
0.26474687457084656,
0.6836122870445251,
0.9261351823806763,
-0.11168057471513748,
0.07892065495252609,
0.46878713369369507,
-0.1659235954284668,
0.5033367872238159,
0.1554417461156845,
0.17217746376991272,
-0.2032236009836197,
0.07489465177059174,
1.046616554260254,
0.4069039523601532,
-0.7688874006271362,
0.5721169114112854,
0.06876309216022491,
-0.27591055631637573,
-0.3262968361377716,
0.31401360034942627,
0.16751356422901154,
0.6593265533447266,
0.05208788439631462,
-0.09000719338655472,
-0.18631532788276672,
-0.28250789642333984,
0.2826356887817383,
0.19898293912410736,
0.16139094531536102,
-0.4724547863006592,
0.9027219414710999,
0.2047971934080124,
-0.529995858669281,
0.4522656500339508,
-0.009053105488419533,
-0.7980628609657288,
0.5662063956260681,
0.6562010645866394,
1.1114922761917114,
-0.33815479278564453,
0.24245062470436096,
-0.049412161111831665,
0.3494699001312256,
-0.45964130759239197,
0.2645050883293152,
0.280529260635376,
-0.7476097345352173,
-0.3427070379257202,
-0.6189475655555725,
-0.6167999505996704,
0.009234010241925716,
0.08978989720344543,
0.4357408881187439,
-0.8353033065795898,
-0.21293975412845612,
-0.4818032383918762,
-0.18197089433670044,
-0.9819263219833374,
0.21108980476856232,
0.1229671984910965,
1.0172587633132935,
-0.5400182604789734,
0.78457111120224,
0.7976414561271667,
0.13164110481739044,
-1.1192529201507568,
-0.6631225347518921,
-0.05690159276127815,
-0.6101771593093872,
0.3295927941799164,
0.21015839278697968,
-0.40935322642326355,
-0.019386256113648415,
-0.125321164727211,
-0.8171051740646362,
1.2957029342651367,
0.6770293116569519,
-0.5592961311340332,
0.08975909650325775,
0.35951805114746094,
0.5986225008964539,
-0.5417787432670593,
0.5522619485855103,
0.2783939838409424,
0.3227165937423706,
0.07836611568927765,
-0.9715282320976257,
0.03440197557210922,
0.050074487924575806,
0.2578383982181549,
0.12801186740398407,
-0.9926980137825012,
1.0735790729522705,
0.11727304011583328,
-0.06670986115932465,
-0.1639207899570465,
0.406723290681839,
0.20193064212799072,
-0.15197576582431793,
0.8966294527053833,
0.4123219847679138,
0.7886258363723755,
0.2084566056728363,
0.9237504601478577,
-0.1518266797065735,
0.11799479275941849,
1.1364754438400269,
-0.4027734696865082,
0.6654382348060608,
0.39585626125335693,
0.17850276827812195,
0.46133965253829956,
0.5208846926689148,
0.056335143744945526,
0.3894799053668976,
0.6857910752296448,
-0.29406964778900146,
-0.09622572362422943,
0.05398273468017578,
-0.30192655324935913,
0.6493569016456604,
0.24149417877197266,
-0.2051478624343872,
-0.3986888527870178,
0.08849364519119263,
-0.0737517699599266,
-0.054795507341623306,
-0.37712565064430237,
0.5939569473266602,
-0.0153611795976758,
-0.3765844702720642,
0.8249197006225586,
0.101250059902668,
0.6680957674980164,
-0.8191696405410767,
0.40494656562805176,
-0.20901641249656677,
0.42256319522857666,
-0.18919898569583893,
-0.3131033182144165,
0.32063406705856323,
-0.1906660944223404,
0.16360464692115784,
-0.5316013693809509,
0.3345814347267151,
-0.2052122950553894,
-0.3348592221736908,
0.4992176294326782,
0.5478489398956299,
-0.04764316603541374,
0.07959806174039841,
-0.5752856731414795,
0.198387011885643,
-0.4797663390636444,
-0.8333507776260376,
0.1835242658853531,
0.5464134216308594,
0.06265844404697418,
0.8975879549980164,
0.5703714489936829,
0.23919939994812012,
0.2775246500968933,
0.18401721119880676,
1.228471040725708,
-0.406951367855072,
-0.5638740062713623,
-0.5775711536407471,
0.5112289190292358,
0.27869677543640137,
-0.5690332055091858,
0.16598309576511383,
0.41470858454704285,
0.7601383328437805,
0.07948782294988632,
0.5028814673423767,
0.48752811551094055,
0.29945698380470276,
-0.30994805693626404,
0.6218141913414001,
-0.8142106533050537,
0.4943907558917999,
-0.022994734346866608,
-0.9125124216079712,
-0.2936285436153412,
0.5542911887168884,
-0.13514040410518646,
-0.06839077174663544,
0.4335958957672119,
0.7456724643707275,
-0.6145665645599365,
-0.032665468752384186,
0.07453437894582748,
0.03627529740333557,
0.41820424795150757,
0.6527665853500366,
0.5816562175750732,
-0.3229524493217468,
0.5891463160514832,
0.13370725512504578,
-0.1193801537156105,
-0.47508761286735535,
-0.9833154082298279,
-0.7215869426727295,
-0.09716016799211502,
-0.20796668529510498,
-0.057690590620040894,
0.025447994470596313,
1.1182003021240234,
0.9683248400688171,
-0.3820330798625946,
-0.5939913988113403,
-0.4384230673313141,
0.3979748487472534,
-0.22400504350662231,
-0.1244635209441185,
0.21610362827777863,
-0.3602408170700073,
-0.4024944603443146,
0.6140598654747009,
0.14142753183841705,
0.18674568831920624,
-0.21202582120895386,
-0.11151669174432755,
-0.2664956748485565,
0.0964389443397522,
0.4688531160354614,
0.48015373945236206,
-0.35829171538352966,
-0.4695763885974884,
0.12528030574321747,
-0.0616510733962059,
0.28047826886177063,
0.6634137034416199,
-0.7612771391868591,
0.2839101552963257,
0.3750651478767395,
1.2415529489517212,
0.7408446669578552,
-0.1227196455001831,
0.6991708278656006,
-0.6624146699905396,
0.5611344575881958,
0.45722848176956177,
0.3513130843639374,
0.3252963125705719,
-0.13024233281612396,
0.5623171925544739,
0.1689191311597824,
-0.5757818222045898,
-0.8537368178367615,
0.37500694394111633,
-0.9480772614479065,
-0.3584607243537903,
1.0818312168121338,
-0.04964834824204445,
-0.3939909338951111,
-0.1473877727985382,
0.19580326974391937,
0.3761471211910248,
-0.06180253624916077,
0.5015814304351807,
0.026317628100514412,
-0.18313656747341156,
-0.3898792862892151,
-0.5107261538505554,
0.07269246131181717,
0.4406798183917999,
-0.8918476700782776,
-0.17644307017326355,
-0.04012821242213249,
0.4296034276485443,
-0.042285848408937454,
0.5293651819229126,
0.35219821333885193,
0.1322379857301712,
-0.04920944198966026,
0.049904607236385345,
-0.38920000195503235,
-0.6499027609825134,
-0.19631028175354004,
0.30679410696029663,
-0.20960237085819244,
-0.3251514136791229
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06870v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06870v3
|
What's in an embedding? Would a rose by any embedding smell as sweet?
| 2024-06-11T01:10:40 | 2024-06-15T06:35:33 |
Venkat Venkatasubramanian
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are often criticized for lacking true
"understanding" and the ability to "reason" with their knowledge, being seen
merely as autocomplete systems. We believe that this assessment might be
missing a nuanced insight. We suggest that LLMs do develop a kind of empirical
"understanding" that is "geometry"-like, which seems adequate for a range of
applications in NLP, computer vision, coding assistance, etc. However, this
"geometric" understanding, built from incomplete and noisy data, makes them
unreliable, difficult to generalize, and lacking in inference capabilities and
explanations, similar to the challenges faced by heuristics-based expert
systems decades ago.
To overcome these limitations, we suggest that LLMs should be integrated with
an "algebraic" representation of knowledge that includes symbolic AI elements
used in expert systems. This integration aims to create large knowledge models
(LKMs) that not only possess "deep" knowledge grounded in first principles, but
also have the ability to reason and explain, mimicking human expert
capabilities. To harness the full potential of generative AI safely and
effectively, a paradigm shift is needed from LLM to more comprehensive LKM.
|
[
-0.24063821136951447,
-0.8408929705619812,
0.8860159516334534,
0.17253319919109344,
-0.1073102355003357,
0.20720307528972626,
-0.14188151061534882,
-0.3835671544075012,
0.23228222131729126,
0.2887857258319855,
-0.27791258692741394,
-0.5016456842422485,
-0.8996796607971191,
0.036186929792165756,
-0.5732148885726929,
0.6526073217391968,
-0.2562110722064972,
0.10368973761796951,
-0.6074467897415161,
0.07328752428293228,
-0.31098809838294983,
-0.3071742355823517,
-0.44970232248306274,
-0.38947781920433044,
0.33046114444732666,
0.1044546365737915,
0.9056174159049988,
0.8805555105209351,
0.2947860062122345,
0.30187898874282837,
-0.08298420161008835,
0.061077699065208435,
-0.3120132386684418,
0.05779531970620155,
0.17283493280410767,
-0.7569246292114258,
-0.40155550837516785,
0.16354729235172272,
0.5540784597396851,
1.060328483581543,
-0.03483498468995094,
-0.26552483439445496,
0.19970837235450745,
0.5714951157569885,
-0.4602762758731842,
0.48656463623046875,
-0.6055921912193298,
0.5257010459899902,
0.1477091759443283,
0.07278591394424438,
-0.2601546049118042,
-0.39035579562187195,
0.22126585245132446,
-0.58686763048172,
-0.20989610254764557,
0.17027778923511505,
0.66275954246521,
0.5602061748504639,
-0.43211641907691956,
-0.5184388160705566,
-0.6848060488700867,
0.7488142251968384,
-0.7512354254722595,
0.48876455426216125,
0.4333719313144684,
0.21193179488182068,
-0.28498387336730957,
-0.30598869919776917,
-0.36994093656539917,
-0.5879982113838196,
-0.2061820775270462,
0.010327800177037716,
-0.2866258919239044,
0.11774960160255432,
0.22495423257350922,
0.4365415573120117,
-0.46342989802360535,
0.24019765853881836,
-0.2021797001361847,
0.019437529146671295,
0.5169655084609985,
0.020769143477082253,
0.37485364079475403,
-0.054724711924791336,
-0.23609018325805664,
0.1515674740076065,
-0.9712843298912048,
-0.22553344070911407,
0.17787136137485504,
0.18852010369300842,
-0.19655455648899078,
0.7286278009414673,
0.17796030640602112,
0.6002824902534485,
-0.24936306476593018,
0.029896175488829613,
0.029239779338240623,
0.14171338081359863,
-0.4415060579776764,
0.05048539489507675,
0.7635070085525513,
-0.041492097079753876,
0.5066993832588196,
-0.34013062715530396,
-0.2131304293870926,
0.11907190829515457,
0.23054085671901703,
-0.6483228802680969,
-0.3756656050682068,
0.24452687799930573,
-0.42979317903518677,
-0.29108384251594543,
0.027383407577872276,
-0.3308965265750885,
-0.4252488911151886,
-0.524219274520874,
0.2336416244506836,
-0.49455583095550537,
-0.2784906029701233,
0.1401386708021164,
-0.05707735940814018,
0.14357143640518188,
0.5063030123710632,
-0.7742776274681091,
0.11272003501653671,
0.9834735989570618,
0.7262721061706543,
0.16454161703586578,
-0.22552675008773804,
-0.10926742851734161,
0.19910824298858643,
-0.6946302056312561,
0.6968507766723633,
-0.9287458062171936,
-0.5374324321746826,
0.2907620668411255,
-0.12581700086593628,
0.14072449505329132,
-0.4414823651313782,
0.2611522078514099,
-0.47158393263816833,
0.09605958312749863,
-0.4571414589881897,
-0.9053410291671753,
-0.34554505348205566,
0.23313620686531067,
-0.41681766510009766,
0.6588401794433594,
-0.048569455742836,
-0.41421422362327576,
0.3494839072227478,
-0.6170682907104492,
-0.17245975136756897,
0.19224640727043152,
-0.672138512134552,
-0.11884176731109619,
0.3535331189632416,
0.2481604516506195,
0.6269171237945557,
-0.3148895502090454,
0.0533863790333271,
-0.5406498908996582,
-0.2554769814014435,
0.32828861474990845,
-0.2879987359046936,
0.5881056189537048,
0.2591305077075958,
-0.22321152687072754,
-0.23707856237888336,
-0.3885570764541626,
-0.15831255912780762,
0.2325841188430786,
-0.2861163020133972,
-0.5221412777900696,
0.1850854903459549,
-0.2530409097671509,
-0.042145274579524994,
0.3306915760040283,
-0.562778651714325,
0.37731459736824036,
-0.4824075996875763,
0.38966548442840576,
0.9682853817939758,
-0.4439656436443329,
0.6957605481147766,
-0.25666776299476624,
0.6095908284187317,
0.2115481048822403,
-0.12271597236394882,
-0.09817741811275482,
-0.5125890374183655,
-0.9517680406570435,
-0.1449805498123169,
0.14190112054347992,
0.413339227437973,
-0.4659844934940338,
0.633497953414917,
-0.31630638241767883,
-0.2734585106372833,
-0.6263711452484131,
0.5029336810112,
0.35379570722579956,
0.12289853394031525,
0.2258860468864441,
0.10253042727708817,
-0.3126831650733948,
-1.0213884115219116,
-0.26044216752052307,
-0.0570409893989563,
-0.02905254065990448,
0.3241942226886749,
0.5452736616134644,
-0.2802472710609436,
0.834749162197113,
-0.40033990144729614,
-0.3438658118247986,
-0.13156172633171082,
-0.20607297122478485,
0.18291598558425903,
0.4644274115562439,
0.5395141243934631,
-0.3952174484729767,
-0.29878342151641846,
0.019978953525424004,
-1.248945713043213,
0.16180793941020966,
0.01917262002825737,
-0.10828955471515656,
-0.09876082092523575,
0.5825533866882324,
-0.7431440949440002,
0.37372973561286926,
0.4994615912437439,
-0.4193583130836487,
0.14716346561908722,
-0.2962428033351898,
-0.11583371460437775,
-1.018786072731018,
-0.4440377652645111,
0.14264392852783203,
-0.06337302178144455,
-0.4478587806224823,
0.08850640058517456,
-0.04184770956635475,
-0.14236846566200256,
-0.10014301538467407,
0.44924816489219666,
-0.6859877705574036,
-0.17702719569206238,
-0.31432685256004333,
0.27338501811027527,
-0.027135953307151794,
0.16762568056583405,
-0.09660791605710983,
0.68122798204422,
0.6920552849769592,
-0.5771481394767761,
0.3535460829734802,
0.40877363085746765,
-0.36430788040161133,
0.5691590905189514,
-0.6563799381256104,
0.16096939146518707,
-0.2274850308895111,
0.1717362403869629,
-0.6944014430046082,
-0.20385226607322693,
0.16112464666366577,
-0.46117278933525085,
0.3898527920246124,
-0.24444784224033356,
-0.4946131408214569,
-0.21095068752765656,
-0.16898958384990692,
0.4486946165561676,
0.7486876249313354,
-0.5397990345954895,
0.7966347336769104,
0.4308367371559143,
-0.20405958592891693,
-0.4219675064086914,
-0.8904110789299011,
0.27019500732421875,
-0.08572090417146683,
-0.5536907315254211,
0.1643938571214676,
0.26976045966148376,
-0.450176864862442,
0.4951574504375458,
0.3005591332912445,
0.22757849097251892,
0.17248490452766418,
0.2601277828216553,
0.06656813621520996,
-0.5426231622695923,
0.46117350459098816,
0.17648276686668396,
-0.19809727370738983,
0.356749951839447,
-0.32827329635620117,
0.34785398840904236,
-0.20798231661319733,
-0.9166697263717651,
-0.6009089946746826,
0.5378859639167786,
0.8305443525314331,
-0.18338356912136078,
0.6794767379760742,
0.22938624024391174,
-0.6695718765258789,
-0.417391300201416,
-0.4949589669704437,
-0.11368085443973541,
-0.4176103472709656,
0.5292474627494812,
-0.41421324014663696,
-0.9837034940719604,
0.3803422749042511,
-0.1165245920419693,
0.15854158997535706,
0.6408607363700867,
0.43546873331069946,
-0.5159083008766174,
1.1532561779022217,
0.6638864278793335,
-0.2742942273616791,
0.223805770277977,
-0.3710472881793976,
0.4935702085494995,
-0.8246358633041382,
-0.32643353939056396,
-0.5149063467979431,
-0.4602676331996918,
-0.5173993706703186,
-0.3472094237804413,
0.19576209783554077,
0.12889842689037323,
-0.5147233009338379,
-0.09156996011734009,
-0.40128183364868164,
0.33811140060424805,
0.4442228078842163,
0.005523042753338814,
0.18472009897232056,
0.1398186981678009,
0.06887533515691757,
0.055394165217876434,
-0.73298180103302,
-0.7421831488609314,
1.016228437423706,
0.6929635405540466,
1.1535825729370117,
0.12880679965019226,
0.5773624777793884,
0.2866356670856476,
0.27130651473999023,
-1.0016958713531494,
0.4052203595638275,
-0.42660465836524963,
-0.15927928686141968,
-0.129656583070755,
-0.2862815856933594,
-0.8811596035957336,
0.05972018837928772,
-0.2917562425136566,
-0.5492801666259766,
0.1716856062412262,
0.1932026892900467,
-0.48882076144218445,
0.6825922727584839,
-0.4503973722457886,
0.5516848564147949,
-0.3570469617843628,
0.10661875456571579,
-0.3593287467956543,
-0.021317632868885994,
0.5110020637512207,
0.06802517175674438,
0.36887022852897644,
-0.15202826261520386,
-0.17949028313159943,
0.8220996260643005,
-0.4273085296154022,
0.9201381802558899,
-0.2193925529718399,
-0.23813222348690033,
0.08208635449409485,
0.33888790011405945,
0.530227780342102,
-0.24710702896118164,
0.10698824375867844,
-0.017450004816055298,
-0.08632193505764008,
-0.49590003490448,
-0.9249275922775269,
0.8986903429031372,
-1.039961576461792,
-0.8787112832069397,
-0.3199685513973236,
-0.5852820873260498,
-0.23950079083442688,
-0.40473806858062744,
-0.28392910957336426,
0.3649728000164032,
-0.03456077352166176,
0.3654819428920746,
0.7480872869491577,
-0.3340219557285309,
0.14857734739780426,
0.08244236558675766,
-0.45118507742881775,
-0.19819338619709015,
0.7212904095649719,
0.008506816811859608,
0.03620370849967003,
0.2234354317188263,
0.2134057581424713,
-0.32435110211372375,
-0.5873892903327942,
-0.46883371472358704,
0.46839603781700134,
-0.8762162327766418,
-0.05233340710401535,
-0.7362977862358093,
-0.31426820158958435,
-0.31444382667541504,
-0.34254294633865356,
-0.45812365412712097,
-0.17382584512233734,
-0.5340911746025085,
-0.2752399444580078,
0.7017943859100342,
1.559139370918274,
0.020781811326742172,
0.2951850891113281,
-0.9947019815444946,
-0.08075916022062302,
0.2965245842933655,
0.31150951981544495,
0.24236524105072021,
-0.5874194502830505,
-0.3770936131477356,
0.18782711029052734,
0.013421619310975075,
-0.775111734867096,
0.25534942746162415,
0.156459242105484,
0.7534852027893066,
0.7267845869064331,
-0.2953084111213684,
0.6199831366539001,
-0.5328158140182495,
0.735100507736206,
0.07664307951927185,
-0.7733323574066162,
0.4744362533092499,
-0.11288531869649887,
-0.0663597583770752,
0.2632034420967102,
0.6275261044502258,
-0.34455379843711853,
-0.45657840371131897,
-0.5119503140449524,
-0.4683019518852234,
0.2421453893184662,
-0.06960874050855637,
0.5072190165519714,
-0.09998663514852524,
0.5668752789497375,
0.04698846489191055,
0.08771492540836334,
-0.5143313407897949,
-0.17963014543056488,
-0.008243238553404808,
-0.3243284523487091,
-0.10098431259393692,
-0.4836055338382721,
-0.21191532909870148,
-0.23323191702365875,
0.4802694022655487,
0.12859699130058289,
0.48790252208709717,
0.01921079307794571,
-0.25386759638786316,
-0.024384189397096634,
0.169190913438797,
0.33541586995124817,
0.6644994020462036,
0.02890927903354168,
0.30439329147338867,
0.08756570518016815,
-0.11094709485769272,
0.024361463263630867,
-0.056420087814331055,
0.013088054955005646,
-0.13945837318897247,
0.5780906081199646,
0.7551619410514832,
0.14168789982795715,
-0.3353528082370758,
0.44578060507774353,
0.21769681572914124,
-0.17750504612922668,
-0.4826134741306305,
0.0585453100502491,
0.26111993193626404,
0.3536429703235626,
0.3504888415336609,
-0.11237598210573196,
-0.21045416593551636,
-0.831525444984436,
0.12672127783298492,
0.7669066786766052,
-0.5144273638725281,
-0.2678624391555786,
0.47854354977607727,
0.2892119586467743,
-0.4005492329597473,
0.7519018650054932,
-0.040023140609264374,
-0.7225158214569092,
0.5543293952941895,
0.3411628007888794,
1.032416820526123,
-0.12749283015727997,
0.015949614346027374,
0.04841301590204239,
0.4548293650150299,
0.12527629733085632,
0.11281052231788635,
0.11554697155952454,
-0.9927619695663452,
-0.45977845788002014,
-0.7292245626449585,
-0.22170047461986542,
-0.00042901988490484655,
-0.2884334623813629,
-0.0028257868252694607,
-0.6814287304878235,
0.11727464944124222,
-0.3745028078556061,
-0.31449010968208313,
-0.7856513261795044,
0.11801355332136154,
0.13828366994857788,
0.9819817543029785,
-1.1797103881835938,
0.621330738067627,
0.6501883864402771,
-0.5437381863594055,
-0.6800364851951599,
-0.1252559870481491,
-0.04897390678524971,
-1.0179667472839355,
0.9034247994422913,
-0.006893927697092295,
0.02805996872484684,
-0.1262015849351883,
-0.49679553508758545,
-0.83828204870224,
0.9675764441490173,
0.35131776332855225,
-0.5186910629272461,
-0.1161850169301033,
0.1510467529296875,
0.45646554231643677,
-0.7254924774169922,
0.32743197679519653,
0.5486257076263428,
0.47575855255126953,
0.036199793219566345,
-0.7313852310180664,
0.12674345076084137,
-0.17400963604450226,
0.13614340126514435,
0.04235689342021942,
-0.345815509557724,
0.9326767921447754,
-0.16980789601802826,
-0.16039085388183594,
0.04788748547434807,
0.7047846913337708,
0.022205280140042305,
-0.13030482828617096,
0.3144817352294922,
0.9967265725135803,
0.6676416993141174,
-0.20452453196048737,
1.328086256980896,
-0.3618102967739105,
0.12363709509372711,
0.7907699942588806,
0.019387507811188698,
0.9820594787597656,
0.3852096199989319,
-0.5062480568885803,
0.5662744045257568,
0.8257464170455933,
0.10080064088106155,
0.3069826364517212,
0.29284170269966125,
-0.24504682421684265,
-0.5881137847900391,
-0.049401454627513885,
-0.611391007900238,
0.49394795298576355,
0.7336345314979553,
-0.5722360610961914,
-0.2673228085041046,
-0.06131047382950783,
-0.060172297060489655,
0.05205479636788368,
-0.2406851351261139,
0.9431738257408142,
0.5185041427612305,
-0.2377462089061737,
0.42782366275787354,
-0.18858839571475983,
0.592123806476593,
-0.3876101076602936,
-0.3122607171535492,
-0.20477215945720673,
0.05554605647921562,
-0.26883256435394287,
-0.9933265447616577,
0.22262205183506012,
-0.1434991955757141,
0.06080511212348938,
-0.30370789766311646,
0.38921740651130676,
-0.3799225091934204,
-0.729669451713562,
0.3661267161369324,
0.9161719083786011,
0.3672415316104889,
0.060983508825302124,
-0.8014976978302002,
0.09908084571361542,
-0.08315172791481018,
-0.1225450411438942,
0.18721903860569,
0.6395924687385559,
0.2982799708843231,
0.7960415482521057,
0.6755428314208984,
0.24676454067230225,
-0.10328339785337448,
0.11875002086162567,
0.9579461812973022,
-0.6105849146842957,
-0.1906617283821106,
-1.0185396671295166,
0.4189036190509796,
0.10361797362565994,
0.0560062900185585,
0.6111390590667725,
0.42823436856269836,
0.5618988275527954,
0.039953768253326416,
1.0092042684555054,
0.20394591987133026,
0.2014225721359253,
-0.7506814002990723,
0.9199509620666504,
-0.8272007703781128,
0.464885950088501,
-0.1516614854335785,
-1.0877214670181274,
-0.34474289417266846,
0.9188402891159058,
-0.4644390046596527,
0.2901654839515686,
0.6158328652381897,
0.5994543433189392,
-0.1953028440475464,
0.09115646034479141,
0.5869564414024353,
0.685939610004425,
0.44281205534935,
0.5674497485160828,
1.2166131734848022,
-0.10710220783948898,
0.14877425134181976,
0.04243617504835129,
-0.3356493413448334,
-0.15700937807559967,
-0.8009559512138367,
-1.0350956916809082,
-0.5473295450210571,
-0.3005276322364807,
-0.17573395371437073,
0.0039098807610571384,
1.121738314628601,
0.46115055680274963,
-0.8645009398460388,
-0.1493212729692459,
-0.166865736246109,
0.1481388807296753,
0.46798667311668396,
-0.14795881509780884,
0.47336769104003906,
-0.6216290593147278,
-0.7502773404121399,
0.43804237246513367,
0.47742122411727905,
0.31845131516456604,
-0.8275737762451172,
-0.03852098435163498,
0.06867802143096924,
-0.016601648181676865,
0.7050592303276062,
0.013187834061682224,
-1.0243947505950928,
-0.4409703314304352,
-0.05262475088238716,
0.07417690008878708,
0.07111694663763046,
0.6393725872039795,
-0.6917686462402344,
0.32442304491996765,
0.3524291515350342,
1.0391262769699097,
0.08514583855867386,
-0.26006537675857544,
0.7891181707382202,
-0.17880186438560486,
0.05277833342552185,
0.347625195980072,
0.7592703700065613,
0.3755849301815033,
-0.30396583676338196,
0.17497976124286652,
0.09709089249372482,
-0.5012518167495728,
-0.6232883930206299,
0.2898074984550476,
-0.7169085144996643,
-0.30296653509140015,
1.1418647766113281,
-0.32077842950820923,
-0.24989986419677734,
-0.03903813287615776,
0.04822414740920067,
-0.05562174320220947,
-0.4110565781593323,
0.7738327980041504,
0.7248961329460144,
-0.11185035109519958,
-0.29973462224006653,
-0.5856412053108215,
0.5843867659568787,
0.4662189483642578,
-0.7368819117546082,
-0.06729231774806976,
0.4240127205848694,
0.16382856667041779,
0.1948307752609253,
0.20898279547691345,
-0.07589612156152725,
0.023737838491797447,
-0.03508026525378227,
-0.12495698034763336,
-0.10345041751861572,
-0.3272615075111389,
-0.3177405297756195,
0.06273020058870316,
0.4204445779323578,
-0.08549261093139648
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06852v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06852v2
|
A Survey of Backdoor Attacks and Defenses on Large Language Models: Implications for Security Measures
| 2024-06-10T23:54:21 | 2024-06-13T08:52:44 |
Shuai Zhao, Meihuizi Jia, Zhongliang Guo, Leilei Gan, Jie Fu, Yichao Feng, Fengjun Pan, Luu Anh Tuan
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The large language models (LLMs), which bridge the gap between human language
understanding and complex problem-solving, achieve state-of-the-art performance
on several NLP tasks, particularly in few-shot and zero-shot settings. Despite
the demonstrable efficacy of LMMs, due to constraints on computational
resources, users have to engage with open-source language models or outsource
the entire training process to third-party platforms. However, research has
demonstrated that language models are susceptible to potential security
vulnerabilities, particularly in backdoor attacks. Backdoor attacks are
designed to introduce targeted vulnerabilities into language models by
poisoning training samples or model weights, allowing attackers to manipulate
model responses through malicious triggers. While existing surveys on backdoor
attacks provide a comprehensive overview, they lack an in-depth examination of
backdoor attacks specifically targeting LLMs. To bridge this gap and grasp the
latest trends in the field, this paper presents a novel perspective on backdoor
attacks for LLMs by focusing on fine-tuning methods. Specifically, we
systematically classify backdoor attacks into three categories: full-parameter
fine-tuning, parameter-efficient fine-tuning, and attacks without fine-tuning.
Based on insights from a substantial review, we also discuss crucial issues for
future research on backdoor attacks, such as further exploring attack
algorithms that do not require fine-tuning, or developing more covert attack
algorithms.
|
[
-0.3917936086654663,
-0.9342073798179626,
0.44744497537612915,
-0.21833838522434235,
0.027463246136903763,
0.0530858151614666,
-0.11347535252571106,
-0.5226737856864929,
-0.3991268277168274,
0.8660116195678711,
-0.617260754108429,
-0.5668357610702515,
-0.599145233631134,
-0.10820116102695465,
-0.4818389415740967,
1.0512977838516235,
0.3491151034832001,
-0.015167438425123692,
0.271800696849823,
0.009937533177435398,
-0.5803744196891785,
-0.7181766033172607,
-0.5031298995018005,
-0.043227292597293854,
0.619014322757721,
0.11103087663650513,
0.8489519953727722,
0.23132221400737762,
0.5804204940795898,
0.25905710458755493,
-0.07839660346508026,
-0.4100915193557739,
-0.5575713515281677,
0.25311365723609924,
-0.49914485216140747,
-0.5090073347091675,
-0.4724730849266052,
-0.10081417113542557,
0.4843220114707947,
0.5342996716499329,
-0.09671075642108917,
0.40014418959617615,
-0.04354873672127724,
0.6602118015289307,
-0.9016434550285339,
-0.35163918137550354,
-1.1864328384399414,
0.07202122360467911,
-0.46331512928009033,
-0.12917253375053406,
-0.42313534021377563,
-0.19805453717708588,
-0.24169231951236725,
0.19393640756607056,
0.11807548999786377,
0.14441032707691193,
0.5884565711021423,
0.1363261342048645,
-0.17913098633289337,
-0.22668227553367615,
-0.3881544768810272,
0.7960048317909241,
-1.052140474319458,
0.5077415108680725,
0.35219019651412964,
0.35715770721435547,
-0.5346130132675171,
-0.24218279123306274,
-0.295864462852478,
-0.3798984885215759,
0.04000093415379524,
-0.38331443071365356,
-0.6036770343780518,
0.1238742247223854,
0.3973791301250458,
0.463056355714798,
-0.6839012503623962,
0.7991045713424683,
-0.33959686756134033,
-0.24273699522018433,
0.7791807651519775,
0.44199979305267334,
0.40841200947761536,
0.018166985362768173,
-0.010027003474533558,
0.01167619414627552,
-1.1589369773864746,
0.021797997877001762,
0.7182964086532593,
0.5208232998847961,
-0.22405287623405457,
0.6317996978759766,
-0.08165986090898514,
0.8683490753173828,
-0.22448484599590302,
0.07557036727666855,
-0.29950830340385437,
-0.2131570726633072,
-0.34627825021743774,
-0.23823657631874084,
0.6777968406677246,
0.3187658488750458,
0.30516281723976135,
-0.3450854420661926,
-0.4905534088611603,
-0.1840769499540329,
0.3434547483921051,
-0.840624213218689,
0.1003538966178894,
0.5129531621932983,
-0.33710750937461853,
-0.5648939609527588,
-0.11170529574155807,
-0.922410786151886,
-0.4580603837966919,
0.3136880695819855,
0.3562776446342468,
-0.16106347739696503,
-0.021744633093476295,
0.19003884494304657,
0.011121830902993679,
0.37253138422966003,
0.17252503335475922,
-0.9125431180000305,
0.3819138705730438,
1.1276062726974487,
0.7832797169685364,
0.0366351455450058,
-0.2636106014251709,
-0.6735881567001343,
0.16620054841041565,
-0.35618793964385986,
0.22070199251174927,
-0.3828131854534149,
-0.3765428364276886,
0.21647699177265167,
-0.12504127621650696,
0.08225587010383606,
-0.33361005783081055,
0.14007316529750824,
-0.8500632643699646,
-0.07140865921974182,
0.1151522547006607,
-0.32380205392837524,
-0.10001925379037857,
0.6786479949951172,
-0.5409867167472839,
0.5202503800392151,
-0.293296217918396,
-0.840996503829956,
-0.17756684124469757,
-0.3080027103424072,
-0.4516303837299347,
-0.15050369501113892,
-0.06947734951972961,
-0.36378180980682373,
0.5152158141136169,
0.17843005061149597,
0.8178625106811523,
-0.3596140444278717,
-0.07098947465419769,
-0.5215865969657898,
-0.18220335245132446,
0.4464518129825592,
-0.41789186000823975,
0.7892769575119019,
0.29098841547966003,
-0.18155822157859802,
0.09983834624290466,
-0.8173530101776123,
-0.014635925181210041,
0.2116004377603531,
-0.008258405141532421,
-0.3952180743217468,
-0.11090958118438721,
-0.41641169786453247,
0.15435375273227692,
0.3753659725189209,
-0.5997379422187805,
0.1607632339000702,
-0.9916710257530212,
0.4772028625011444,
0.744017481803894,
0.2210247665643692,
0.2545376121997833,
-0.09493475407361984,
0.6248171925544739,
-0.31066176295280457,
0.45107516646385193,
-0.45840978622436523,
-0.47625696659088135,
-0.23725858330726624,
-0.13365934789180756,
0.18285271525382996,
0.5943238139152527,
-0.14888927340507507,
0.3215886950492859,
0.17521637678146362,
-0.7922391295433044,
-0.33290159702301025,
0.18093366920948029,
0.5580664277076721,
-0.00859822891652584,
0.1468799114227295,
-0.06724642217159271,
-0.20612011849880219,
-0.7965158224105835,
-0.6675423979759216,
0.011640832759439945,
-0.08891105651855469,
0.2041075974702835,
0.7363077402114868,
-0.30794036388397217,
0.5019009709358215,
-0.5738794803619385,
-0.21670669317245483,
-0.053913459181785583,
-0.2118229866027832,
0.21531736850738525,
0.61202073097229,
0.5654830932617188,
-0.28542134165763855,
-0.1322176605463028,
0.07717646658420563,
-0.504721999168396,
0.007313997019082308,
0.08139347285032272,
0.25229743123054504,
0.13772599399089813,
0.6999702453613281,
-0.6750795841217041,
0.4173767864704132,
0.8906121850013733,
-0.13551302254199982,
0.4876614511013031,
0.016407368704676628,
-0.3191611170768738,
-0.9542344212532043,
-0.08275362849235535,
-0.11795895546674728,
0.07261626422405243,
-0.7509395480155945,
0.8592097163200378,
0.019384531304240227,
-0.423943430185318,
-0.4313085377216339,
0.6836807131767273,
-0.40468114614486694,
-0.24468588829040527,
-0.07140959799289703,
-0.0744110643863678,
-0.24526888132095337,
0.46113190054893494,
-0.555289626121521,
0.5542551875114441,
0.6649606227874756,
-0.3727506697177887,
0.4972451627254486,
-0.2118408977985382,
-0.264719694852829,
0.23758918046951294,
-0.6785144209861755,
0.5186886787414551,
0.32654330134391785,
0.262739896774292,
-1.0874557495117188,
-0.15856236219406128,
0.43350034952163696,
-0.5730699896812439,
0.6242621541023254,
-0.2442220002412796,
-0.577019453048706,
-0.1505923718214035,
-0.6601031422615051,
0.267248272895813,
0.29228779673576355,
-0.27781760692596436,
0.5310736894607544,
0.22851017117500305,
-0.15082402527332306,
-0.6950034499168396,
-0.7101076245307922,
0.32850176095962524,
-0.1766391396522522,
-0.8037526607513428,
-0.10533523559570312,
0.1398797333240509,
-0.5482835173606873,
-0.41558536887168884,
-0.012911674566566944,
-0.015354800969362259,
0.611285924911499,
0.29584839940071106,
0.0022768713533878326,
-0.31977003812789917,
-0.1934419721364975,
-0.08605525642633438,
0.05251353606581688,
0.26448914408683777,
-0.33210307359695435,
0.6310854554176331,
-0.10807201266288757,
-0.6562567353248596,
-0.5199750065803528,
0.5515431761741638,
0.6394543647766113,
-0.3719000518321991,
0.8519589304924011,
0.38405126333236694,
-0.4260517656803131,
-0.21264393627643585,
-0.7888453006744385,
-0.5020721554756165,
-0.46306073665618896,
0.5975698232650757,
-0.44305965304374695,
-1.1341325044631958,
0.6151466369628906,
0.10556839406490326,
0.48084136843681335,
0.2711218297481537,
0.7683880925178528,
0.0734061449766159,
1.0818915367126465,
0.7753449082374573,
-0.18257322907447815,
0.21593192219734192,
0.027965357527136803,
0.3020307123661041,
-0.6805755496025085,
-0.1652536690235138,
-0.8942458629608154,
-0.10879287868738174,
-0.7589851021766663,
-0.00967929046601057,
-0.06156959384679794,
0.03029060736298561,
-0.3129015862941742,
0.1875515729188919,
-0.11581643670797348,
0.3080185651779175,
0.27441054582595825,
-0.07973307371139526,
0.3961764872074127,
-0.18622899055480957,
-0.0247187502682209,
0.1406375914812088,
-0.5459392070770264,
-0.36650586128234863,
1.1528311967849731,
0.8196760416030884,
1.2012062072753906,
0.3240490257740021,
0.6808249354362488,
0.1351238191127777,
0.04983493685722351,
-0.7210051417350769,
0.6348190307617188,
0.02718869224190712,
-0.8843746185302734,
-0.4613698422908783,
-0.2861761152744293,
-0.9937981367111206,
0.14754147827625275,
-0.11464471369981766,
-1.0359350442886353,
0.020273936912417412,
0.15378302335739136,
-0.5993270874023438,
0.5683691501617432,
-0.5487614870071411,
0.7823038697242737,
-0.37969449162483215,
-0.2557404339313507,
-0.31562289595603943,
-0.7053498029708862,
0.5210195779800415,
-0.4651007056236267,
0.2742041349411011,
-0.08460751175880432,
0.09789257496595383,
0.47124943137168884,
-0.4117549955844879,
1.1385260820388794,
-0.0925661027431488,
-0.7108705639839172,
-0.2160816639661789,
0.3859143555164337,
0.7853976488113403,
0.18094593286514282,
0.1087452620267868,
0.5302679538726807,
0.030805125832557678,
-0.34235310554504395,
-0.5027399063110352,
0.7850899696350098,
-0.6043220162391663,
-1.20884370803833,
-0.3389730155467987,
-0.3775222897529602,
-0.40998855233192444,
0.11956179141998291,
0.2649261951446533,
0.21542933583259583,
-0.02469828352332115,
0.2596021294593811,
0.7405898571014404,
-0.6424632668495178,
0.335948646068573,
0.6923662424087524,
-0.2437848150730133,
-0.1925610452890396,
0.6478524208068848,
-0.037342529743909836,
0.4616011381149292,
0.49210506677627563,
0.24325433373451233,
0.1307411789894104,
-1.0372296571731567,
-0.26303237676620483,
0.2684910297393799,
-0.34441688656806946,
-0.4920629858970642,
-0.5361164808273315,
-0.361070454120636,
-0.6119101643562317,
-0.05302615091204643,
-0.6052464842796326,
-0.1831607073545456,
-0.09010172635316849,
0.07310304045677185,
0.37007662653923035,
0.6411223411560059,
0.12023430317640305,
0.3557148873806,
-0.9344345331192017,
0.18309777975082397,
0.37346765398979187,
0.33843183517456055,
0.3036326467990875,
-0.6768603920936584,
-0.43548664450645447,
-0.10920783877372742,
-0.21265359222888947,
-0.8637385964393616,
0.26154136657714844,
-0.15981268882751465,
0.36199265718460083,
0.27096596360206604,
-0.12606194615364075,
0.2887415587902069,
-0.7041523456573486,
0.8152831792831421,
0.11989494413137436,
-0.7638742327690125,
0.4806436598300934,
-0.43196651339530945,
0.1827803999185562,
0.3126283288002014,
0.14531822502613068,
-0.5031414031982422,
-0.5937795639038086,
-0.3678545653820038,
-0.7330114841461182,
0.4805243909358978,
0.17064914107322693,
0.49245700240135193,
0.4044167995452881,
0.32448869943618774,
0.10596831142902374,
0.38738682866096497,
-0.5373854041099548,
-0.009950919076800346,
-0.05400335043668747,
0.1675471067428589,
-0.02948254533112049,
-0.2433016449213028,
-0.2488262802362442,
-0.0009973901323974133,
0.5002186894416809,
0.1510750651359558,
-0.29235437512397766,
-0.3796941339969635,
-0.06557265669107437,
-0.16087599098682404,
0.6109548807144165,
0.7171124219894409,
0.4756219685077667,
-0.153095081448555,
-0.07034526765346527,
0.49098390340805054,
-0.4533084034919739,
-0.009129570797085762,
0.05849229916930199,
-0.07932864129543304,
-0.3123619854450226,
0.4403134286403656,
0.6040109395980835,
0.2735362946987152,
-0.5762898325920105,
0.563092052936554,
-0.06385751068592072,
0.10453945398330688,
-0.2974725365638733,
0.21885128319263458,
-0.11313317716121674,
0.4932163953781128,
0.26319581270217896,
-0.10437119007110596,
-0.12313271313905716,
-0.6625607013702393,
-0.09694927930831909,
0.973726749420166,
-0.2723388671875,
-0.4696291983127594,
0.25925779342651367,
0.056445568799972534,
-0.626986563205719,
0.4582517445087433,
0.38855451345443726,
-0.4285350441932678,
0.35890233516693115,
0.47928550839424133,
1.008436679840088,
-0.412996381521225,
-0.4043025076389313,
-0.07646499574184418,
0.8389197587966919,
0.07406683266162872,
-0.021979093551635742,
-0.021403871476650238,
-0.7008039355278015,
-0.22965110838413239,
-0.653089702129364,
-0.5615350604057312,
0.6147403120994568,
-0.5441623330116272,
0.1361553817987442,
-0.9417869448661804,
-0.0462978295981884,
-0.19527380168437958,
-0.04400866851210594,
-0.4071911573410034,
0.04763393476605415,
0.39142733812332153,
1.1328363418579102,
-0.5299403667449951,
0.6797415614128113,
0.3151576519012451,
-0.1100982055068016,
-0.5706084966659546,
0.1083931252360344,
0.10340194404125214,
-0.7817690372467041,
0.5315352082252502,
-0.0478256456553936,
-0.3155699372291565,
-0.16216182708740234,
-0.6880426406860352,
-0.6907405853271484,
0.5741062164306641,
0.4609256982803345,
-0.8916683793067932,
-0.3412138819694519,
0.09356963634490967,
0.46751868724823,
-0.010565679520368576,
-0.38634273409843445,
0.5960159301757812,
0.3678317964076996,
-0.3184340298175812,
-0.7440210580825806,
0.12028466165065765,
-0.02884303778409958,
0.0935758501291275,
0.26947110891342163,
-0.6812451481819153,
0.8860718607902527,
-0.1300947666168213,
-0.04281461611390114,
0.2464594841003418,
0.5241960287094116,
0.47363710403442383,
0.33509787917137146,
0.17360809445381165,
0.5529966354370117,
0.3713137209415436,
0.1241615042090416,
1.0228105783462524,
-0.39019134640693665,
0.10013395547866821,
1.1157480478286743,
-0.33810731768608093,
0.9295201897621155,
0.45693448185920715,
-0.04914099723100662,
0.049112606793642044,
0.45321324467658997,
-0.33896878361701965,
0.2674800157546997,
0.5387184619903564,
0.1431545466184616,
0.04910700395703316,
0.37589243054389954,
-0.6338879466056824,
0.542708694934845,
0.5129019021987915,
-0.2942502498626709,
-0.37243691086769104,
0.0700337141752243,
0.3192003667354584,
-0.002547317184507847,
-0.601787805557251,
0.7423881888389587,
0.46208885312080383,
-0.4003751277923584,
0.5025290250778198,
0.46716779470443726,
0.8470653295516968,
-0.7792535424232483,
0.17429542541503906,
-0.19152235984802246,
0.15786470472812653,
-0.3611566722393036,
-0.7971890568733215,
0.22599317133426666,
0.2793324291706085,
0.14639391005039215,
-0.041596461087465286,
0.7102179527282715,
0.05427524447441101,
-0.1843549907207489,
0.34128889441490173,
0.32837527990341187,
-0.033928509801626205,
-0.3566891551017761,
-0.6444616913795471,
0.33474740386009216,
-0.21439248323440552,
-0.41507866978645325,
0.6401623487472534,
0.39016255736351013,
0.030300065875053406,
0.6947053670883179,
0.7152611613273621,
0.3469310402870178,
0.17588353157043457,
0.12835074961185455,
0.7998765110969543,
-0.7905968427658081,
-0.4386095404624939,
-1.4237923622131348,
0.06863780319690704,
0.09215893596410751,
-0.2376660704612732,
1.121034860610962,
0.45777636766433716,
0.9468740224838257,
0.09522778540849686,
0.5064424872398376,
0.5910225510597229,
0.4415396749973297,
-0.7884969115257263,
0.9665517210960388,
-0.4870135188102722,
0.5759764909744263,
-0.5474033951759338,
-0.6196290850639343,
-0.43593519926071167,
0.05790216475725174,
-0.34230008721351624,
0.06906946748495102,
0.26599839329719543,
1.0843762159347534,
0.18241970241069794,
-0.030550234019756317,
0.5983309149742126,
0.5108795762062073,
0.45628395676612854,
0.43285733461380005,
1.0671589374542236,
-0.20918893814086914,
0.48701032996177673,
0.00036147539503872395,
0.00369819113984704,
-0.3779315650463104,
-0.755034327507019,
-1.2725571393966675,
-0.16889609396457672,
-0.03547568991780281,
-0.361491858959198,
0.3875109851360321,
0.5464322566986084,
0.42406657338142395,
-0.9690880179405212,
-0.26418063044548035,
0.1559627801179886,
0.1944276988506317,
0.0925268605351448,
-0.1286349892616272,
0.09997764974832535,
-0.2815518379211426,
-0.26184237003326416,
0.35905060172080994,
0.48459458351135254,
-0.16337817907333374,
-0.8866270780563354,
0.226849764585495,
-0.03918658196926117,
0.24266697466373444,
0.4406592845916748,
0.5295687317848206,
-0.7979893684387207,
-0.32571941614151,
-0.250847727060318,
-0.32318341732025146,
-0.18235784769058228,
0.785460352897644,
-0.37522462010383606,
-0.021381909027695656,
0.4175899922847748,
0.950756847858429,
0.14735600352287292,
-0.318823903799057,
0.6042752861976624,
-0.8048529624938965,
0.26012128591537476,
0.2951163351535797,
0.25631994009017944,
0.2693687081336975,
-0.49317845702171326,
0.1390792280435562,
-0.014407132752239704,
-0.37118223309516907,
-1.290017008781433,
0.6675387620925903,
-0.5746186375617981,
-0.5611628293991089,
0.9733902812004089,
-0.026896407827734947,
-0.38233211636543274,
-0.13060928881168365,
-0.00705736642703414,
-0.04822516441345215,
-0.28567859530448914,
0.8221268653869629,
0.6722909212112427,
0.35976842045783997,
-0.04070093110203743,
-0.7440782785415649,
0.4576975405216217,
0.12673358619213104,
-0.6141049265861511,
0.2932548522949219,
0.2821810245513916,
0.2622430622577667,
0.06769327074289322,
0.08769611269235611,
-0.3014717102050781,
0.13388469815254211,
-0.17925989627838135,
-0.32061126828193665,
-0.09109354764223099,
-0.3348526060581207,
-0.7559364438056946,
0.5200801491737366,
0.11319279670715332,
0.000963295460678637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06840v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06840v2
|
Silent Signals, Loud Impact: LLMs for Word-Sense Disambiguation of Coded Dog Whistles
| 2024-06-10T23:09:19 | 2024-06-18T19:11:11 |
Julia Kruk, Michela Marchini, Rijul Magu, Caleb Ziems, David Muchlinski, Diyi Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, J.4; K.4.1; K.4.2
|
A dog whistle is a form of coded communication that carries a secondary
meaning to specific audiences and is often weaponized for racial and
socioeconomic discrimination. Dog whistling historically originated from United
States politics, but in recent years has taken root in social media as a means
of evading hate speech detection systems and maintaining plausible deniability.
In this paper, we present an approach for word-sense disambiguation of dog
whistles from standard speech using Large Language Models (LLMs), and leverage
this technique to create a dataset of 16,550 high-confidence coded examples of
dog whistles used in formal and informal communication. Silent Signals is the
largest dataset of disambiguated dog whistle usage, created for applications in
hate speech detection, neology, and political science.
The dataset can be found at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/SALT-NLP/silent_signals.
|
[
-0.4176503121852875,
-0.5612426996231079,
0.46265020966529846,
0.3875168561935425,
-0.39391475915908813,
-0.02466450445353985,
-0.32212764024734497,
-0.5247196555137634,
0.2838746905326843,
0.2832193076610565,
-0.482121080160141,
-0.752331018447876,
-0.9287204146385193,
-0.1261206865310669,
-0.5139153599739075,
0.9909303784370422,
0.5498443245887756,
0.16916105151176453,
0.41465458273887634,
-0.15494117140769958,
-0.17925149202346802,
-0.49256807565689087,
-0.41923049092292786,
-0.45137879252433777,
0.8159538507461548,
0.07211659848690033,
0.6177386045455933,
0.34587064385414124,
0.48479482531547546,
0.19325432181358337,
-0.24366559088230133,
-0.13118880987167358,
-0.567171037197113,
0.07569152116775513,
-0.006664680782705545,
-0.4385969936847687,
-0.1920192986726761,
0.5096393823623657,
0.3283877670764923,
0.48535028100013733,
-0.2968156933784485,
0.3160139322280884,
-0.15421800315380096,
0.14715254306793213,
-0.5017322897911072,
0.37264320254325867,
-1.116707444190979,
-0.2176830917596817,
-0.29590049386024475,
-0.23820897936820984,
-0.16651207208633423,
-0.47305139899253845,
-0.13190874457359314,
-0.13155698776245117,
-0.14155158400535583,
-0.19114869832992554,
0.7737714052200317,
0.346260130405426,
-0.4973742365837097,
-0.701973021030426,
-0.8541277647018433,
0.9360308647155762,
-0.6316472291946411,
0.389250248670578,
0.5685620903968811,
0.05339992046356201,
-0.25717324018478394,
-0.8259738683700562,
-0.6924529671669006,
-0.1638084053993225,
0.018424706533551216,
0.30234673619270325,
-0.5870699286460876,
0.07536771893501282,
0.44740790128707886,
0.11637890338897705,
-0.11015355587005615,
0.17939947545528412,
-0.5321964025497437,
0.027396269142627716,
0.8267109990119934,
0.21563658118247986,
0.04422115162014961,
-0.14916636049747467,
-0.09267571568489075,
0.006149296648800373,
-0.4202929437160492,
-0.005008107516914606,
0.5196461081504822,
0.47300583124160767,
-0.43597015738487244,
0.2404232621192932,
-0.07235811650753021,
0.5355536937713623,
0.13491326570510864,
-0.605609655380249,
0.15120233595371246,
0.10464321076869965,
0.08853425830602646,
0.28018105030059814,
0.7144332528114319,
0.4532822370529175,
0.4238986074924469,
-0.08586937934160233,
-0.2039635181427002,
0.6673371195793152,
-0.09197022765874863,
-0.6656617522239685,
-0.1884986311197281,
0.15220898389816284,
-0.5774508714675903,
-0.6191073656082153,
-0.11680573225021362,
-0.6308181881904602,
-0.7286328077316284,
-0.2520754039287567,
0.40032628178596497,
-0.09441375732421875,
-0.33014053106307983,
0.34441471099853516,
-0.6838592886924744,
0.7227404713630676,
-0.11228977143764496,
-0.7386797666549683,
0.1599375605583191,
0.8270920515060425,
0.7888420224189758,
0.2399267703294754,
-0.1015811562538147,
-0.40076249837875366,
0.17774300277233124,
-0.17724639177322388,
0.5924308896064758,
-0.7153156399726868,
-0.43824273347854614,
0.08112192153930664,
-0.12210105359554291,
0.39924851059913635,
-0.6387131810188293,
0.7261229157447815,
-0.5154238343238831,
-0.1242961511015892,
0.007231088820844889,
-0.22479912638664246,
-0.1668555736541748,
-0.28082534670829773,
-0.19095472991466522,
0.9352590441703796,
-0.22635731101036072,
-0.5864180326461792,
0.5204498171806335,
-0.4114922881126404,
-0.796059250831604,
0.21749138832092285,
-0.29361045360565186,
-0.29116588830947876,
0.18096263706684113,
-0.1022568941116333,
0.6072088479995728,
-0.13880661129951477,
0.19267435371875763,
-0.5016703009605408,
-0.5640513300895691,
0.20767487585544586,
-0.4335533678531647,
0.9341002702713013,
0.2807602882385254,
-0.5057507157325745,
-0.01218794658780098,
-0.9348535537719727,
0.03555121272802353,
0.15837280452251434,
-0.34630492329597473,
-0.6343531608581543,
0.30251652002334595,
-0.22663791477680206,
0.2169494479894638,
0.029613938182592392,
-0.5950652956962585,
-0.2063177227973938,
-0.05141376331448555,
0.49391651153564453,
0.6823121309280396,
0.08221280574798584,
-0.12096097320318222,
-0.41282230615615845,
0.32961469888687134,
-0.2736077606678009,
0.37636566162109375,
0.12342821061611176,
-0.5681647062301636,
-0.3604053258895874,
-0.6488763689994812,
0.06889160722494125,
0.4613950550556183,
-0.11445385217666626,
0.4314786195755005,
-0.13347317278385162,
-0.6331466436386108,
-0.7025443315505981,
-0.09360908716917038,
0.017834194004535675,
0.26670557260513306,
0.07708164304494858,
0.05003614351153374,
-0.7210060358047485,
-0.7603369355201721,
-0.32324132323265076,
-0.4623519480228424,
-0.2854677140712738,
-0.0001744211040204391,
0.45491594076156616,
-0.07552023231983185,
0.8206745982170105,
-0.4222101867198944,
-0.3123566508293152,
-0.18642063438892365,
0.440056711435318,
0.3392668068408966,
-0.19679223001003265,
0.2128787338733673,
-0.6642880439758301,
-0.41969069838523865,
-0.41174978017807007,
-0.7189232707023621,
-0.5642783045768738,
-0.043059397488832474,
0.00449690455570817,
-0.3979889452457428,
0.6244332790374756,
-0.22305525839328766,
0.37085938453674316,
0.7107340693473816,
-0.06756699085235596,
0.6393066048622131,
0.6114183664321899,
0.058876655995845795,
-0.7844132781028748,
-0.29222342371940613,
0.008494136855006218,
-0.03981580585241318,
-0.7444194555282593,
-0.34606993198394775,
-0.2059589922428131,
0.000053937586926622316,
-0.7737756371498108,
0.37323620915412903,
-0.5862504839897156,
-0.010143714025616646,
-0.5161178112030029,
0.36625978350639343,
-0.2758590877056122,
0.15334463119506836,
0.021377841010689735,
0.49477487802505493,
0.7614230513572693,
-0.8221046328544617,
0.6715877056121826,
0.3524934649467468,
-0.3392159640789032,
0.7868499159812927,
-0.591559886932373,
0.21165141463279724,
-0.22166010737419128,
0.18413665890693665,
-0.603222131729126,
-0.15922875702381134,
0.29299208521842957,
-0.5925720930099487,
-0.09465854614973068,
-0.361039400100708,
-0.5544969439506531,
-0.3925805985927582,
-0.41260579228401184,
0.050691235810518265,
0.8979744911193848,
-0.7886739373207092,
0.028738252818584442,
0.9432681798934937,
0.09530483931303024,
-0.32939329743385315,
-0.6894740462303162,
0.2541300356388092,
-0.5861905217170715,
-0.629104495048523,
0.07527989149093628,
0.07118487358093262,
-0.6946722269058228,
-0.2644047141075134,
-0.09094924479722977,
0.1526426076889038,
-0.03512385115027428,
0.5741942524909973,
-0.09109701961278915,
0.045264072716236115,
0.3862404525279999,
-0.22644361853599548,
0.1462710052728653,
0.30650457739830017,
0.14301815629005432,
0.7012850642204285,
-0.0908302590250969,
-0.31691309809684753,
-0.4558503031730652,
0.4807984232902527,
0.6819769740104675,
0.08767526596784592,
0.6597446799278259,
0.7811585664749146,
-0.31614404916763306,
-0.4632435739040375,
-0.47458910942077637,
-0.4602755606174469,
-0.5610324144363403,
0.12289382517337799,
-0.3500368595123291,
-0.7757201790809631,
0.543899655342102,
-0.2995099127292633,
-0.13802511990070343,
-0.055385321378707886,
0.526777446269989,
-0.22419598698616028,
1.0311108827590942,
0.47729113698005676,
-0.2818391025066376,
0.5013097524642944,
0.36807289719581604,
0.37127894163131714,
-0.5709086656570435,
-0.09963489323854446,
-0.6731566190719604,
-0.1900881975889206,
-0.6292482018470764,
-0.338113933801651,
0.378436416387558,
0.11732397228479385,
-0.16428162157535553,
-0.11375223100185394,
-0.6142327189445496,
0.4081646502017975,
0.4687172472476959,
-0.015129095874726772,
0.41161152720451355,
0.13814787566661835,
0.40490543842315674,
-0.20032645761966705,
-0.4303448796272278,
-0.5582879185676575,
0.8453889489173889,
0.5997772216796875,
1.1270151138305664,
0.20883257687091827,
0.5598412752151489,
0.4942527115345001,
0.29137682914733887,
-1.3338388204574585,
0.8123320937156677,
-0.02535730041563511,
-0.49680837988853455,
-0.3514661192893982,
-0.25659462809562683,
-1.2333110570907593,
0.11350059509277344,
-0.13838663697242737,
-0.7412712574005127,
-0.02989203855395317,
-0.19529324769973755,
0.09042606502771378,
0.20312125980854034,
-0.22054065763950348,
0.24605542421340942,
-0.2477673590183258,
-0.0020058860536664724,
-0.22125360369682312,
-0.12362927198410034,
0.6624062657356262,
-0.16829314827919006,
0.36602783203125,
-0.5191386938095093,
-0.1619444638490677,
1.0249773263931274,
-0.3222275376319885,
1.3219729661941528,
-0.10201378911733627,
-0.42990466952323914,
0.47246503829956055,
-0.3030325174331665,
0.9104662537574768,
-0.3502402901649475,
-0.250718355178833,
0.5447741150856018,
-0.054355375468730927,
-0.2271880805492401,
-0.26704519987106323,
0.3657771646976471,
-0.28172582387924194,
-0.5070540904998779,
-0.49031469225883484,
-0.20031856000423431,
-0.18134430050849915,
-0.006540754809975624,
0.20548568665981293,
0.29818129539489746,
-0.06147168204188347,
0.14609383046627045,
0.4599768817424774,
-0.15720370411872864,
0.3728099763393402,
1.120168685913086,
-0.1642453968524933,
-0.1837078481912613,
0.8044712543487549,
0.06832174211740494,
0.11991728097200394,
-0.3383132219314575,
0.11287517100572586,
-0.4715644121170044,
-0.6973585486412048,
0.13542844355106354,
0.42363473773002625,
-0.6682342290878296,
0.012492802925407887,
-0.4209137260913849,
-0.262692928314209,
-0.38023024797439575,
-0.08988688141107559,
-0.08421292901039124,
0.1735912263393402,
0.03283895552158356,
0.02805035375058651,
0.6291815042495728,
0.9151325225830078,
-0.6291120052337646,
0.6417709589004517,
-0.58369380235672,
0.5332962274551392,
0.3813086450099945,
0.6232792735099792,
-0.24800384044647217,
-0.7525312900543213,
-0.21559970080852509,
-0.17964324355125427,
0.06317756325006485,
-1.485216736793518,
0.2690572440624237,
0.0440526083111763,
0.5885890126228333,
0.3934493660926819,
0.5919342637062073,
0.668531596660614,
-0.22711095213890076,
0.7081490755081177,
0.5252996683120728,
-0.9116330742835999,
0.6473690867424011,
-0.7951443195343018,
0.25632232427597046,
0.27812740206718445,
0.47517073154449463,
-1.0460420846939087,
-0.836014449596405,
-0.4877678155899048,
-0.8432245254516602,
0.4339928925037384,
-0.14767533540725708,
0.4320998191833496,
-0.4009148180484772,
-0.018541600555181503,
0.05562270060181618,
0.2840939164161682,
-0.6499914526939392,
-0.49221596121788025,
0.12346285581588745,
-0.17049671709537506,
0.2330755889415741,
-0.3288576304912567,
-0.425946444272995,
-0.22520481050014496,
0.7717366218566895,
-0.08263673633337021,
0.23533941805362701,
-0.23381556570529938,
-0.0966477245092392,
0.043536849319934845,
0.4087054133415222,
0.4650687873363495,
0.3377988338470459,
-0.2853540778160095,
0.38389357924461365,
0.265569269657135,
-0.7712799906730652,
0.11435278505086899,
-0.3890962302684784,
-0.2801060974597931,
0.3502991795539856,
0.27622294425964355,
0.7303527593612671,
0.0122116319835186,
-0.5935307741165161,
0.5211471319198608,
-0.012747394852340221,
-0.3578433394432068,
-0.6066051125526428,
-0.1595507562160492,
0.21375617384910583,
0.2505311071872711,
0.3797241747379303,
-0.39327365159988403,
0.10244281589984894,
-0.7438052892684937,
0.45492345094680786,
0.7728661298751831,
-0.5123357772827148,
-0.24807846546173096,
0.5145882368087769,
0.27523273229599,
-0.1853371262550354,
0.2461104393005371,
-0.3907787799835205,
-0.4695769250392914,
0.2913174629211426,
0.5258597731590271,
0.788410484790802,
0.10363977402448654,
0.4354167580604553,
0.27867549657821655,
0.4575789272785187,
0.02799348346889019,
0.3761604130268097,
0.023487668484449387,
-0.6976463794708252,
-0.3421054780483246,
-0.90241938829422,
-0.30787912011146545,
0.8632525205612183,
-0.7022804617881775,
0.47568410634994507,
-0.5773934125900269,
-0.43102920055389404,
0.19161994755268097,
-0.24898172914981842,
-0.32749924063682556,
0.025057192891836166,
0.6047585606575012,
0.6585683226585388,
-0.9979573488235474,
0.7051265239715576,
0.3894864320755005,
-0.2859131693840027,
-0.8745671510696411,
0.4075307846069336,
0.17001298069953918,
-1.0270862579345703,
0.690382719039917,
-0.16013959050178528,
-0.6278203725814819,
0.016375726088881493,
-0.8874425888061523,
-0.7923537492752075,
0.5327820181846619,
0.1306016892194748,
-0.529878556728363,
0.5229170918464661,
0.2725062668323517,
0.5074793696403503,
-0.03334181755781174,
0.20489680767059326,
0.8922449946403503,
0.6989258527755737,
0.032334230840206146,
-1.0445630550384521,
0.21441999077796936,
-0.019800962880253792,
-0.46571409702301025,
0.06344155222177505,
-0.9896400570869446,
0.40804794430732727,
0.02288934402167797,
-0.50456303358078,
-0.37434956431388855,
0.4525555968284607,
0.2034105509519577,
0.4881210923194885,
0.4003809988498688,
0.18889397382736206,
0.9268301129341125,
-0.09054552763700485,
0.5893312096595764,
-0.33965083956718445,
0.06965429335832596,
1.1086370944976807,
-0.26815861463546753,
0.8133615851402283,
0.3498927354812622,
-0.4357115924358368,
0.25414496660232544,
0.38680499792099,
-0.2621690034866333,
0.3626963794231415,
0.7114056944847107,
-0.8864527344703674,
-0.14263899624347687,
-0.46904557943344116,
-0.3921560049057007,
0.8685331344604492,
0.5678638219833374,
-0.1757948249578476,
-0.22766883671283722,
-0.037770554423332214,
0.23570404946804047,
-0.06644752621650696,
-0.5709066390991211,
0.8307164311408997,
0.3825496733188629,
-0.15745973587036133,
0.9105801582336426,
-0.030777044594287872,
1.3122797012329102,
-0.6043007969856262,
0.12453242391347885,
-0.054027870297431946,
-0.18139728903770447,
-0.39967456459999084,
-0.829329788684845,
0.49225902557373047,
0.289242684841156,
-0.16695767641067505,
-0.11725582182407379,
0.91327965259552,
-0.29866087436676025,
-0.07546837627887726,
0.5768935084342957,
0.40879639983177185,
0.7897866368293762,
-0.18780569732189178,
-0.6158010363578796,
0.4456765353679657,
-0.046080708503723145,
-0.1002035066485405,
0.28260108828544617,
0.28747525811195374,
0.11191851645708084,
0.5961965322494507,
0.6457050442695618,
0.4392034113407135,
0.5000632405281067,
0.35787054896354675,
0.5304816961288452,
-0.7958722710609436,
-0.42986419796943665,
-0.6603561043739319,
0.16464491188526154,
-0.10886573046445847,
-0.05171281471848488,
0.7967624068260193,
0.3252759277820587,
0.6404421329498291,
0.015966780483722687,
1.2974281311035156,
-0.014407583512365818,
0.5634750723838806,
-0.31407347321510315,
0.7718245387077332,
-0.26212015748023987,
0.2833462655544281,
-0.09961222857236862,
-0.604185163974762,
-0.09534107893705368,
0.5400798320770264,
-0.6303241848945618,
-0.0753355398774147,
0.48267626762390137,
1.186139702796936,
0.09442690014839172,
0.10661019384860992,
0.7911859154701233,
0.40391892194747925,
0.05807424336671829,
0.06762051582336426,
1.151592493057251,
-0.23203827440738678,
1.0709753036499023,
0.07644613832235336,
-0.20580637454986572,
-0.0353718064725399,
-0.690812349319458,
-0.8179379105567932,
-0.4927458167076111,
-0.6700595021247864,
-0.47693538665771484,
0.1315004825592041,
0.5950591564178467,
0.870603084564209,
-0.5058946013450623,
-0.2080557942390442,
0.36257725954055786,
0.0729433000087738,
-0.01663598231971264,
-0.310494601726532,
0.08164384216070175,
-0.26567572355270386,
-0.8340780735015869,
0.6195266246795654,
0.17851878702640533,
0.08708808571100235,
-0.041500650346279144,
-0.1600079983472824,
0.22866828739643097,
0.5211415886878967,
0.7636265158653259,
0.5232165455818176,
-0.7239969968795776,
-0.411818265914917,
-0.5055777430534363,
-0.28812623023986816,
-0.1987306773662567,
0.4765985906124115,
-0.6277881860733032,
-0.1386108547449112,
0.3432532250881195,
0.06468620896339417,
0.38161396980285645,
-0.07479401677846909,
0.2050854116678238,
-0.8287519216537476,
0.332010954618454,
0.10838065296411514,
-0.07263597100973129,
0.20897133648395538,
-0.12686055898666382,
0.37578341364860535,
0.5191539525985718,
-0.3066254258155823,
-1.1056718826293945,
0.5279898643493652,
-1.1691253185272217,
-0.31827813386917114,
1.5925893783569336,
0.23871339857578278,
-0.27227914333343506,
-0.5803819894790649,
-0.042109061032533646,
0.4130501449108124,
-0.6826504468917847,
0.928089439868927,
0.6115246415138245,
-0.19636750221252441,
-0.3771974444389343,
-0.6848472356796265,
0.7187713384628296,
0.17609061300754547,
-0.5029431581497192,
0.06575655937194824,
0.49181193113327026,
0.3632561266422272,
-0.036753375083208084,
0.8454411029815674,
-0.07264113426208496,
0.021088307723402977,
0.6194179058074951,
0.3363370895385742,
0.16293150186538696,
0.03615329787135124,
-0.4739561378955841,
0.29964131116867065,
-0.044028349220752716,
-0.5461344122886658
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06839v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06839v1
|
EAVE: Efficient Product Attribute Value Extraction via Lightweight Sparse-layer Interaction
| 2024-06-10T23:06:38 | 2024-06-10T23:06:38 |
Li Yang, Qifan Wang, Jianfeng Chi, Jiahao Liu, Jingang Wang, Fuli Feng, Zenglin Xu, Yi Fang, Lifu Huang, Dongfang Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Product attribute value extraction involves identifying the specific values
associated with various attributes from a product profile. While existing
methods often prioritize the development of effective models to improve
extraction performance, there has been limited emphasis on extraction
efficiency. However, in real-world scenarios, products are typically associated
with multiple attributes, necessitating multiple extractions to obtain all
corresponding values. In this work, we propose an Efficient product Attribute
Value Extraction (EAVE) approach via lightweight sparse-layer interaction.
Specifically, we employ a heavy encoder to separately encode the product
context and attribute. The resulting non-interacting heavy representations of
the context can be cached and reused for all attributes. Additionally, we
introduce a light encoder to jointly encode the context and the attribute,
facilitating lightweight interactions between them. To enrich the interaction
within the lightweight encoder, we design a sparse-layer interaction module to
fuse the non-interacting heavy representation into the lightweight encoder.
Comprehensive evaluation on two benchmarks demonstrate that our method achieves
significant efficiency gains with neutral or marginal loss in performance when
the context is long and number of attributes is large. Our code is available
\href{https://anonymous.4open.science/r/EAVE-EA18}{here}.
|
[
-0.2391611635684967,
-0.9138559103012085,
0.29598504304885864,
0.48956534266471863,
-0.05911320820450783,
-0.15253663063049316,
-0.3226003348827362,
-1.1205302476882935,
0.2124188393354416,
0.15079085528850555,
-0.6621478199958801,
-0.242294579744339,
-0.44016775488853455,
-0.2819763720035553,
-0.13214831054210663,
0.8736798167228699,
0.02850392647087574,
-0.33770352602005005,
-0.3851466178894043,
-0.5717878937721252,
-0.4081224799156189,
-0.11103729903697968,
-0.46685791015625,
-0.0820513665676117,
0.5139399766921997,
0.23073115944862366,
0.5976355671882629,
0.23802411556243896,
0.3443615138530731,
0.430925577878952,
0.019511567428708076,
0.4459244906902313,
-0.5532981753349304,
0.4367924630641937,
0.07881864160299301,
0.300178587436676,
-0.8009433150291443,
0.052271146327257156,
0.317007839679718,
0.6358441710472107,
0.19325871765613556,
0.5531561374664307,
0.31849879026412964,
0.2973087728023529,
-0.9807109236717224,
0.23867590725421906,
-0.4439835548400879,
-0.20488253235816956,
0.02913805842399597,
-0.0887947827577591,
-0.31473544239997864,
0.22319550812244415,
-0.10490332543849945,
-0.7665256261825562,
0.02717643417418003,
0.2410408854484558,
1.213314175605774,
0.11378274112939835,
-0.27243277430534363,
0.2847204804420471,
-0.7951866984367371,
1.221114158630371,
-0.503391444683075,
0.7025738954544067,
0.2512966990470886,
0.04797791689634323,
0.03294852748513222,
-0.5892576575279236,
-0.5488553047180176,
-0.11361201107501984,
-0.20072303712368011,
0.07555197924375534,
-0.2354610413312912,
0.013975419104099274,
0.18279847502708435,
0.2707972526550293,
-0.18733137845993042,
0.024944782257080078,
-0.21093039214611053,
-0.046795230358839035,
0.6271254420280457,
0.10378994047641754,
0.08467831462621689,
-0.28251615166664124,
-0.7455873489379883,
0.013846505433321,
-0.49564656615257263,
0.3772621154785156,
0.09664849191904068,
0.024615881964564323,
0.07188060134649277,
0.4538325071334839,
-0.3806583881378174,
0.537653923034668,
0.299966424703598,
-0.5076156258583069,
0.6260908842086792,
-0.42499566078186035,
-0.26147475838661194,
-0.14945141971111298,
0.7812914848327637,
0.1653010994195938,
-0.6218043565750122,
-0.4662855565547943,
-0.707028865814209,
-0.4300415515899658,
-0.03228265792131424,
-1.0785309076309204,
0.027130048722028732,
0.21170927584171295,
-0.968468427658081,
-0.21584945917129517,
0.22821328043937683,
-0.8992380499839783,
-0.08156245201826096,
-0.0691457986831665,
1.0413707494735718,
-0.2760169208049774,
-0.2041943073272705,
0.21103434264659882,
-0.34657663106918335,
0.6471999287605286,
0.49546825885772705,
-0.7531076669692993,
0.5625176429748535,
0.5478945374488831,
0.6883941292762756,
-0.2084878534078598,
0.04705445095896721,
-0.9095484614372253,
0.6010023355484009,
0.2722373306751251,
0.6181034445762634,
-0.45969852805137634,
-0.14927667379379272,
-0.4051056206226349,
0.25677570700645447,
0.38071995973587036,
-0.4702232778072357,
0.39359089732170105,
-0.5768882632255554,
-0.40631940960884094,
-0.2960880696773529,
-0.2639118731021881,
0.021120505407452583,
0.14184686541557312,
-1.075126051902771,
1.223329782485962,
0.21432603895664215,
-0.46203160285949707,
0.5351501107215881,
-0.4859740734100342,
-0.7013689875602722,
0.5263314843177795,
-0.21009306609630585,
-0.6846333146095276,
0.23443305492401123,
0.4198545515537262,
0.6517100930213928,
-0.5298092365264893,
-0.2681688070297241,
-0.5958899259567261,
-0.3529685139656067,
0.3466634452342987,
-0.48094385862350464,
0.5860856771469116,
0.1843518167734146,
-0.5323829650878906,
-0.22237913310527802,
-0.9062702655792236,
0.05843191593885422,
0.19462071359157562,
-0.22342343628406525,
-0.48280444741249084,
-0.17772725224494934,
0.6448487043380737,
0.10492733865976334,
0.6908290386199951,
-0.9130447506904602,
0.056758664548397064,
0.20315223932266235,
0.13175523281097412,
0.7783547639846802,
0.23114939033985138,
0.6344704031944275,
0.08833255618810654,
0.2761199176311493,
-0.27867063879966736,
0.29156017303466797,
0.20205727219581604,
-0.22989141941070557,
-0.6309874653816223,
-0.8127516508102417,
0.131023570895195,
0.08588752895593643,
-0.7377277612686157,
0.5289130210876465,
-0.009051415137946606,
-0.2724597752094269,
-0.389807790517807,
0.7212120890617371,
0.2484889179468155,
0.5934582948684692,
0.4390118718147278,
-0.13556280732154846,
-0.08399876952171326,
-0.8711769580841064,
0.05275406315922737,
0.18542054295539856,
-0.3163414001464844,
0.7773750424385071,
0.2773128151893616,
-0.16640639305114746,
1.0090771913528442,
-0.9449228048324585,
-0.44003695249557495,
-0.4449669122695923,
0.6736941933631897,
0.09551411122083664,
0.7485930323600769,
0.6993566155433655,
-0.9160686135292053,
-0.2381509393453598,
0.11639653891324997,
-0.673051655292511,
-0.45659753680229187,
-0.2952789068222046,
-0.2810879051685333,
-0.07650613784790039,
0.27115654945373535,
-0.7932384610176086,
0.4078507125377655,
0.26475149393081665,
-0.07321936637163162,
0.17963145673274994,
-0.17337515950202942,
0.35104066133499146,
-0.771416425704956,
0.248641699552536,
0.172773078083992,
-0.14728346467018127,
-0.4542289078235626,
-0.16685481369495392,
0.20923644304275513,
-0.07522781938314438,
-0.6989142298698425,
0.4699644148349762,
-0.722163736820221,
-0.1708545833826065,
0.07297954708337784,
-0.2153700590133667,
0.5336637496948242,
0.5356656908988953,
0.09239597618579865,
0.6383997201919556,
0.24322587251663208,
-0.5182632803916931,
0.4480381906032562,
0.008944446220993996,
-0.3107123076915741,
0.7294614911079407,
-0.7564150094985962,
0.040638990700244904,
-0.2292727828025818,
-0.04203971102833748,
-0.6972693800926208,
0.1875060349702835,
0.045206934213638306,
-0.1282505840063095,
0.4450947344303131,
-0.0847940593957901,
-0.37334907054901123,
0.1597287952899933,
-0.6497641801834106,
0.6085727214813232,
0.5482577681541443,
-0.7006860375404358,
1.0170080661773682,
0.4080841541290283,
-0.09061203896999359,
-0.5923547744750977,
-0.6850759983062744,
-0.1682150661945343,
-0.29993459582328796,
-0.7362836003303528,
0.5568088293075562,
-0.08232203125953674,
-0.013949696905910969,
0.4033688008785248,
-0.3895018994808197,
-0.26779434084892273,
0.09646055102348328,
0.30160757899284363,
0.4883491098880768,
-0.19500958919525146,
0.08163108676671982,
0.003090560669079423,
-0.32322701811790466,
-0.14763230085372925,
-0.08514264971017838,
-0.00026532457559369504,
-0.050602782517671585,
-0.03580206632614136,
-0.20607520639896393,
0.6737832427024841,
0.35251355171203613,
-0.37332355976104736,
0.8525015115737915,
0.8377543091773987,
-0.6521286368370056,
-0.7509518265724182,
-0.7862101197242737,
-0.0193619467318058,
-0.5874209403991699,
0.47981172800064087,
-0.4296923875808716,
-0.5749902725219727,
0.5227249264717102,
-0.1287728250026703,
-0.22541850805282593,
0.3676888942718506,
0.18219512701034546,
-0.2678370475769043,
1.268742322921753,
0.8749282956123352,
-0.04777361825108528,
0.7123013734817505,
-0.6103600263595581,
0.3471590578556061,
-0.868914783000946,
-0.5810175538063049,
-0.4195757210254669,
-0.5613039135932922,
-0.09151118993759155,
-0.4416023790836334,
0.43616676330566406,
0.09218597412109375,
0.08731948584318161,
0.6710249185562134,
-0.30308032035827637,
0.32633742690086365,
0.20400241017341614,
0.5029664039611816,
0.044346027076244354,
-0.09235838800668716,
0.5624746084213257,
-0.2028283178806305,
-0.4506300389766693,
0.08030330389738083,
0.6084584593772888,
0.30494633316993713,
1.3952895402908325,
0.06388029456138611,
0.613391637802124,
0.08766923099756241,
0.15068449079990387,
-0.8420378565788269,
0.5232488512992859,
-0.12201762199401855,
-0.12903614342212677,
-0.1016559973359108,
-0.7341017723083496,
-0.5939891934394836,
-0.05225084722042084,
-0.6881870627403259,
-0.7811006307601929,
0.8021883368492126,
-0.0417480543255806,
-0.47999832034111023,
0.04918636754155159,
-0.6596231460571289,
1.0843217372894287,
-0.747603178024292,
-1.0078846216201782,
-0.14142917096614838,
-0.4480690062046051,
0.13643576204776764,
0.0723351240158081,
-0.019084153696894646,
-0.05364520475268364,
-0.2933765947818756,
0.8155158162117004,
-0.5332903861999512,
0.35075631737709045,
-0.18895694613456726,
0.042432304471731186,
0.08775579929351807,
-0.1909981518983841,
0.4580346941947937,
0.1770995408296585,
0.1246807649731636,
0.10335751622915268,
-0.25203317403793335,
-0.33743125200271606,
-0.984997570514679,
0.7827017903327942,
-0.7227751016616821,
-0.046418942511081696,
-0.2563518285751343,
-0.5131449103355408,
-0.20165154337882996,
0.018505841493606567,
-0.03851519525051117,
0.5000832676887512,
-0.23795023560523987,
0.5414528250694275,
0.7875844240188599,
-0.4608357548713684,
0.5592734813690186,
0.3385629653930664,
0.43666693568229675,
-0.4021938145160675,
1.2682925462722778,
0.24831773340702057,
0.3182923495769501,
0.39851319789886475,
0.009248116984963417,
-0.02590402215719223,
-0.1333327293395996,
-0.17665185034275055,
-0.06463861465454102,
-0.6665799021720886,
-0.7430837750434875,
-0.7611526250839233,
-0.29667821526527405,
-0.21712662279605865,
-0.3858839273452759,
-0.42123037576675415,
-0.4497816562652588,
-0.04967111349105835,
0.026752270758152008,
0.5800305604934692,
0.7038903832435608,
-0.10944464802742004,
0.08840439468622208,
-0.8123349547386169,
0.5823739767074585,
0.737233579158783,
0.19714036583900452,
0.11336300522089005,
0.09093201160430908,
-0.5144716501235962,
-0.29680073261260986,
-0.15244612097740173,
-0.8973885178565979,
0.31481772661209106,
0.35102325677871704,
0.7239376306533813,
0.6828576922416687,
0.15204177796840668,
1.0267210006713867,
-0.1920255571603775,
0.6378944516181946,
0.08405940234661102,
-1.0396147966384888,
0.19445165991783142,
0.2525084614753723,
0.02236419916152954,
0.6650132536888123,
0.1352357566356659,
-0.17725472152233124,
-0.09972570836544037,
-0.5121611952781677,
-1.3799107074737549,
0.7677118182182312,
0.07137837260961533,
-0.06253433227539062,
0.22852005064487457,
0.09796573221683502,
0.08907774090766907,
0.26557645201683044,
-0.695103645324707,
-0.04164818301796913,
-0.07499786466360092,
-0.22991299629211426,
0.39557451009750366,
-0.273681640625,
0.11739052087068558,
-0.3580079972743988,
0.5719676613807678,
-0.04836200922727585,
0.15124307572841644,
0.027804959565401077,
-0.4891546964645386,
-0.1695057451725006,
0.031126201152801514,
-0.19095230102539062,
0.19598816335201263,
-0.48434823751449585,
0.3708660900592804,
0.31708627939224243,
-0.3863544464111328,
-0.1521080881357193,
0.30517154932022095,
-0.06326986849308014,
-0.2742539048194885,
0.4035375714302063,
0.461154043674469,
0.5101483464241028,
-0.5373696088790894,
0.9994266629219055,
-0.07040800899267197,
0.09877230226993561,
0.19035422801971436,
-0.4063962399959564,
-0.22753401100635529,
0.2998628318309784,
0.5419945120811462,
0.04717344045639038,
0.5700950622558594,
-0.36414456367492676,
0.43187257647514343,
0.7293511033058167,
0.014474205672740936,
-0.15752540528774261,
0.7959598302841187,
0.4368568956851959,
0.22624407708644867,
0.3888843059539795,
-0.3212480843067169,
-0.3587193489074707,
0.6546444296836853,
0.5859203934669495,
1.0761420726776123,
0.244398295879364,
0.15818850696086884,
0.16167739033699036,
0.3046846389770508,
0.2564411461353302,
0.03473532572388649,
-0.6771090030670166,
-0.5398178100585938,
-0.4974689185619354,
-0.7556145787239075,
-0.14725978672504425,
0.2542487382888794,
-0.4944848418235779,
0.3164485692977905,
-0.2771191895008087,
0.08696286380290985,
0.028073137626051903,
0.13115742802619934,
-0.9202221632003784,
0.04406562075018883,
0.09644638001918793,
0.5584313273429871,
-1.1868951320648193,
0.5896036624908447,
0.24754703044891357,
-0.8481659293174744,
-0.8019589781761169,
-0.2517893612384796,
-0.050707750022411346,
-0.5392792224884033,
0.9340081214904785,
0.44118839502334595,
-0.48156315088272095,
-0.5741055607795715,
-0.7181193828582764,
-0.7725497484207153,
1.4274871349334717,
0.3456469774246216,
-0.08944552391767502,
0.3138953149318695,
-0.04763088747859001,
0.12222526967525482,
-0.4703788757324219,
0.32673412561416626,
0.2477349489927292,
0.5101021528244019,
0.37411990761756897,
-0.34188783168792725,
0.3959818184375763,
-0.47850504517555237,
0.16337288916110992,
0.04127535596489906,
-0.6440956592559814,
0.7455751895904541,
0.2836238741874695,
-0.19240568578243256,
0.11481795459985733,
0.9182299971580505,
-0.2512301206588745,
0.1712237447500229,
0.7091400027275085,
0.5917198657989502,
0.28981155157089233,
0.08411605656147003,
0.5374851226806641,
-0.32048776745796204,
0.38392308354377747,
0.6476281881332397,
-0.37591564655303955,
0.8767727017402649,
0.41879409551620483,
0.236238494515419,
0.2019970715045929,
0.12051373720169067,
0.026422355324029922,
0.8147289752960205,
-0.4336816668510437,
-0.5790393948554993,
-0.298279345035553,
-0.17287017405033112,
-0.1532747596502304,
0.3313194811344147,
0.22022917866706848,
-0.10991464555263519,
-0.0017793903825804591,
0.034507956355810165,
-0.04866752028465271,
-0.40124690532684326,
-0.28853023052215576,
0.9085448980331421,
-0.10202997922897339,
-0.05256637558341026,
0.24992185831069946,
0.10008426010608673,
0.7670124769210815,
-0.7458386421203613,
-0.549040675163269,
0.03347143903374672,
0.27548453211784363,
-0.5440647602081299,
-0.5109295845031738,
-0.027882304042577744,
-0.20106856524944305,
-0.08277570456266403,
-0.552240252494812,
1.1724482774734497,
-0.7687520980834961,
-0.5725337266921997,
0.44390395283699036,
0.394326776266098,
-0.3609578013420105,
0.28443193435668945,
-0.5332214832305908,
0.39610740542411804,
-0.5654746294021606,
-0.6451041102409363,
0.3987810015678406,
0.5239350199699402,
0.14589199423789978,
0.22704152762889862,
0.6542923450469971,
0.24008607864379883,
-0.17077967524528503,
-0.13745611906051636,
1.069990873336792,
-0.5315498113632202,
-0.23226377367973328,
-0.44507208466529846,
0.7677345871925354,
-0.6156631708145142,
-0.15480022132396698,
0.8104093670845032,
0.5720637440681458,
0.5466765761375427,
0.11098262667655945,
0.4921955466270447,
-0.43368956446647644,
-0.30497780442237854,
-0.49400776624679565,
0.7845966815948486,
-0.7149332165718079,
0.35246503353118896,
-0.6715958714485168,
-1.0514302253723145,
-0.06577078253030777,
0.7777459025382996,
0.11426366865634918,
0.16481003165245056,
0.5334375500679016,
0.9121990203857422,
-0.36726608872413635,
-0.3068496882915497,
0.2384711354970932,
0.2229645848274231,
0.17596429586410522,
0.6690199375152588,
0.43896326422691345,
-0.48184964060783386,
0.4232216477394104,
-0.4266294240951538,
-0.6759131550788879,
0.05725583806633949,
-1.122756838798523,
-0.35574543476104736,
-0.3299502432346344,
-0.2524053752422333,
-0.2530665695667267,
-0.15799996256828308,
0.9056311249732971,
1.0066735744476318,
-0.4902868866920471,
-0.12278860807418823,
0.43106532096862793,
0.013017418794333935,
-0.7057331204414368,
-0.3147595524787903,
0.3582000732421875,
-0.18803246319293976,
-0.5803000926971436,
0.48222869634628296,
0.5337666869163513,
-0.285691499710083,
-0.15743188560009003,
-0.26573050022125244,
-0.01018864568322897,
0.12972114980220795,
0.6440085768699646,
0.2833426296710968,
-0.09598582983016968,
-0.628165602684021,
-0.1475002020597458,
0.1996348351240158,
-0.04331355541944504,
0.7214632630348206,
-0.9537097811698914,
0.2787579298019409,
0.771290123462677,
0.9429939389228821,
0.8927226066589355,
0.0440157875418663,
0.41434991359710693,
-1.0248360633850098,
0.347027063369751,
0.03848577290773392,
0.5078113079071045,
0.2857242822647095,
-0.6128441691398621,
0.1068427562713623,
0.2744389474391937,
-0.5102264881134033,
-0.653766930103302,
0.18876340985298157,
-1.4249788522720337,
-0.15117521584033966,
1.0567225217819214,
-0.15765467286109924,
-0.5921295881271362,
0.16563449800014496,
-0.2460181713104248,
-0.14471444487571716,
-0.6360726356506348,
0.35467877984046936,
0.12671072781085968,
-0.19236020743846893,
-0.3488272726535797,
-0.3740461468696594,
0.431698203086853,
0.19337503612041473,
-0.7485173344612122,
0.004211894236505032,
0.5868775844573975,
0.19275572896003723,
0.008724259212613106,
0.49531275033950806,
-0.12517762184143066,
0.33085691928863525,
0.09304714947938919,
0.1357545405626297,
-0.21120081841945648,
-0.3480042517185211,
-0.31084057688713074,
0.29821616411209106,
0.09255974739789963,
-0.3028858006000519
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06809v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06809v1
|
AGB-DE: A Corpus for the Automated Legal Assessment of Clauses in German Consumer Contracts
| 2024-06-10T21:27:13 | 2024-06-10T21:27:13 |
Daniel Braun, Florian Matthes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Legal tasks and datasets are often used as benchmarks for the capabilities of
language models. However, openly available annotated datasets are rare. In this
paper, we introduce AGB-DE, a corpus of 3,764 clauses from German consumer
contracts that have been annotated and legally assessed by legal experts.
Together with the data, we present a first baseline for the task of detecting
potentially void clauses, comparing the performance of an SVM baseline with
three fine-tuned open language models and the performance of GPT-3.5. Our
results show the challenging nature of the task, with no approach exceeding an
F1-score of 0.54. While the fine-tuned models often performed better with
regard to precision, GPT-3.5 outperformed the other approaches with regard to
recall. An analysis of the errors indicates that one of the main challenges
could be the correct interpretation of complex clauses, rather than the
decision boundaries of what is permissible and what is not.
|
[
-0.5638828277587891,
-0.8002027273178101,
0.603537917137146,
-0.251287579536438,
-0.2286115139722824,
-0.2214541733264923,
0.022400226444005966,
-0.7292845845222473,
-0.17307573556900024,
0.7737147808074951,
-0.08408727496862411,
-0.6260184645652771,
-0.6811845302581787,
0.09869564324617386,
-0.5011215806007385,
0.8615134954452515,
-0.051363568753004074,
-0.3187786638736725,
-0.29200291633605957,
-0.2680143117904663,
-0.46670207381248474,
-0.6343477368354797,
-0.17330509424209595,
-0.0729832872748375,
-0.08926969021558762,
0.25845474004745483,
0.9717422723770142,
0.5203168392181396,
0.3070400357246399,
0.2776736915111542,
-0.27314260601997375,
-0.09814195334911346,
-0.050935808569192886,
-0.04746006801724434,
-0.36122098565101624,
-0.17658725380897522,
-0.6232345104217529,
0.23694360256195068,
0.27255699038505554,
0.6598441004753113,
-0.07184752821922302,
0.2590622305870056,
-0.20650669932365417,
0.8478155136108398,
-0.9497121572494507,
0.2752917408943176,
-0.4937884211540222,
-0.2567744553089142,
-0.011836230754852295,
0.1675073802471161,
-0.5251969695091248,
-0.35086217522621155,
0.041673801839351654,
-0.35829925537109375,
0.46037232875823975,
-0.15658311545848846,
1.469799280166626,
0.7239586114883423,
-0.7002367377281189,
-0.7164531946182251,
-0.7299023270606995,
0.2297641783952713,
-0.5264219045639038,
0.44061920046806335,
0.678794264793396,
0.1752646565437317,
-0.22174802422523499,
-0.6502874493598938,
-0.4006935656070709,
-0.7622581720352173,
-0.31933367252349854,
0.38142165541648865,
-0.6775767207145691,
0.046435508877038956,
0.3226672410964966,
0.1886160969734192,
-0.4307261109352112,
0.12102515995502472,
-0.5593482255935669,
-0.3452550172805786,
0.5689687132835388,
-0.012634088285267353,
-0.01174416858702898,
-0.41768452525138855,
-0.19589382410049438,
0.2502525746822357,
-0.5219748020172119,
0.25656628608703613,
0.6789503693580627,
0.09428034722805023,
-0.10413301736116409,
0.7371368408203125,
-0.4048861563205719,
0.8693521618843079,
-0.10636331140995026,
0.34521976113319397,
0.3574026823043823,
-0.017870444804430008,
-0.17515316605567932,
-0.04296721890568733,
0.23121318221092224,
0.14703668653964996,
0.29730820655822754,
-0.21014143526554108,
-0.3578896224498749,
0.20417547225952148,
0.5527126789093018,
-0.29357272386550903,
-0.23238548636436462,
0.49558982253074646,
-0.3363933563232422,
0.09534527361392975,
0.5476083159446716,
-0.2640053629875183,
-0.1776803731918335,
-0.6111325025558472,
-0.12381460517644882,
-0.3781701922416687,
0.12151801586151123,
0.2914840579032898,
-0.011043901555240154,
0.3600700795650482,
0.11566868424415588,
-0.5745839476585388,
0.4971284866333008,
0.7192754745483398,
0.20615661144256592,
0.11079540848731995,
0.023826733231544495,
-0.6001995205879211,
0.17285233736038208,
-0.5344586372375488,
1.1690020561218262,
-0.5860768556594849,
-0.1460351198911667,
0.07838273793458939,
0.06463407725095749,
0.10760973393917084,
-0.6683103442192078,
1.0342038869857788,
-0.40213537216186523,
0.26381316781044006,
0.02318074367940426,
-0.6535152196884155,
-0.5484278202056885,
0.3054550290107727,
-0.7396566867828369,
0.8115269541740417,
0.6539324522018433,
-0.3351770043373108,
0.730272650718689,
-0.46029195189476013,
-0.5183115005493164,
0.4168844223022461,
-0.30070412158966064,
-0.3459635376930237,
0.3787819445133209,
0.19955523312091827,
0.5161172747612,
-0.3573097288608551,
0.43318960070610046,
-0.43988436460494995,
-0.32942768931388855,
0.3581351935863495,
-0.2908601760864258,
0.7580814361572266,
0.4352034032344818,
-0.4034035801887512,
-0.06308450549840927,
-0.9109158515930176,
-0.011710177175700665,
-0.21300388872623444,
-0.5457491278648376,
-0.28918859362602234,
-0.0620763897895813,
-0.13837681710720062,
0.25032007694244385,
0.044899050146341324,
-0.27983084321022034,
-0.03501642122864723,
-0.32948052883148193,
0.2684309482574463,
0.6688477396965027,
-0.15580803155899048,
0.11503932625055313,
-0.20371899008750916,
0.8570958375930786,
-0.2318248152732849,
0.20909056067466736,
-0.020692234858870506,
-0.3005654215812683,
-0.8118841052055359,
-0.5786212086677551,
0.720101535320282,
0.6937873959541321,
-0.31728073954582214,
0.898049533367157,
-0.23541387915611267,
-0.47553232312202454,
-0.7207499742507935,
-0.1645752191543579,
0.3689854145050049,
0.1890946328639984,
0.2783341109752655,
-0.08033427596092224,
-0.21509741246700287,
-1.2760913372039795,
-0.20236995816230774,
-0.29224562644958496,
-0.06492500007152557,
0.6106281876564026,
0.6705340147018433,
-0.33869415521621704,
1.015354037284851,
-0.4409337341785431,
-0.7282160520553589,
0.03646468743681908,
0.25119906663894653,
0.44907429814338684,
0.1813402622938156,
0.6969249844551086,
-0.6986631751060486,
-0.6031108498573303,
0.2145802080631256,
-0.7895187139511108,
-0.5176875591278076,
-0.0185177531093359,
0.39348384737968445,
0.7174190878868103,
0.6323058009147644,
-0.48538875579833984,
0.3875461518764496,
0.26254212856292725,
-0.9585748314857483,
0.5328523516654968,
-0.584873616695404,
0.08013929426670074,
-0.40891650319099426,
0.3878675103187561,
-0.1714407503604889,
-0.47756507992744446,
-0.518427848815918,
0.11723672598600388,
0.4224819242954254,
0.23128321766853333,
-0.7980608344078064,
0.5903227925300598,
-0.5060054063796997,
-0.09539204835891724,
-0.3201770484447479,
-0.19925175607204437,
-0.06086904555559158,
0.1885562539100647,
-0.23560580611228943,
0.701943576335907,
0.27770817279815674,
-0.8158749938011169,
0.13909688591957092,
0.5787204504013062,
-0.3202548325061798,
0.6153451204299927,
-0.37647730112075806,
0.09521474689245224,
-0.31564468145370483,
0.10784813016653061,
-0.7788838148117065,
-0.24766850471496582,
0.3222767412662506,
-0.37792330980300903,
0.05053582787513733,
-0.2498706430196762,
-0.6392799019813538,
-0.4963538348674774,
0.13891293108463287,
0.021619996055960655,
0.4423047602176666,
-0.24292604625225067,
0.9404348134994507,
0.7219592928886414,
-0.2141360342502594,
-0.6228019595146179,
-0.35191673040390015,
-0.04752472788095474,
-0.3577708899974823,
-0.43051087856292725,
0.1670069843530655,
0.39434465765953064,
-0.22151120007038116,
0.3482414484024048,
-0.4081900715827942,
-0.15222203731536865,
0.4424150884151459,
0.3568471372127533,
0.20213134586811066,
0.14329589903354645,
-0.12438128143548965,
-0.05663946643471718,
-0.5078350901603699,
0.055501051247119904,
-0.05574518069624901,
0.42761731147766113,
-0.4922909140586853,
-0.33536356687545776,
0.03797468915581703,
0.18818844854831696,
0.38722774386405945,
0.07128888368606567,
-0.21594597399234772,
0.21950238943099976,
-0.46818599104881287,
-0.11227617412805557,
-0.8089076280593872,
0.5344055891036987,
-0.38753730058670044,
-0.1373191773891449,
-0.7775382399559021,
-0.8171550035476685,
0.785402238368988,
0.011035268194973469,
-0.26149192452430725,
0.7319841980934143,
0.5328455567359924,
0.029995035380125046,
0.5877194404602051,
0.45487672090530396,
0.11637189239263535,
-0.060090914368629456,
0.002415223978459835,
-0.09977854043245316,
-0.2605517506599426,
-0.37166622281074524,
-0.8963371515274048,
0.12186241149902344,
-0.40050503611564636,
-0.1521514654159546,
0.1966347098350525,
0.21487022936344147,
-0.024928690865635872,
0.5798649787902832,
-0.3581744432449341,
0.6780152916908264,
0.5888242721557617,
-0.11305007338523865,
0.27266648411750793,
-0.38076600432395935,
-0.2691986858844757,
0.3450990319252014,
-0.2761906087398529,
-0.7660756707191467,
0.7558904886245728,
0.30953308939933777,
0.35896381735801697,
0.19788026809692383,
0.35724708437919617,
0.7223555445671082,
0.12857407331466675,
-0.6306766271591187,
0.6071152091026306,
-0.5207276940345764,
-0.8891388177871704,
-0.10969192534685135,
-0.27004677057266235,
-1.2691352367401123,
0.39273861050605774,
-0.16911332309246063,
-0.7153250575065613,
0.258791983127594,
-0.010723858140408993,
-0.540860652923584,
-0.4002380669116974,
-0.831510066986084,
0.9428069591522217,
-0.14559580385684967,
-0.26942551136016846,
0.005845751613378525,
-0.4809916615486145,
0.21138574182987213,
-0.2842335104942322,
0.2682298719882965,
-0.6113029718399048,
-0.042431656271219254,
0.5021452307701111,
-0.13028883934020996,
0.4883231520652771,
-0.33885514736175537,
-0.07575331628322601,
0.6177049279212952,
0.20752786099910736,
0.5285096168518066,
0.052609190344810486,
0.027854008600115776,
0.02610837109386921,
0.13748739659786224,
-0.40211552381515503,
-0.0830947533249855,
0.2907622754573822,
-0.3472553789615631,
-0.3459758758544922,
-0.7877355217933655,
-0.35169366002082825,
-0.23205140233039856,
0.4382418096065521,
-0.05775430053472519,
-0.14967335760593414,
-0.46755799651145935,
0.280962198972702,
0.08531598746776581,
-0.30681589245796204,
0.25867563486099243,
0.9785014986991882,
0.07210801541805267,
-0.31992092728614807,
0.5273087620735168,
0.16687236726284027,
-0.16334861516952515,
-0.19783902168273926,
-0.0692424401640892,
-0.7045190930366516,
-0.6069912314414978,
-0.22670133411884308,
0.07342083752155304,
-1.123443365097046,
-0.3193362355232239,
-0.8605870008468628,
0.10958468168973923,
-0.4926004707813263,
-0.1374000608921051,
-0.4047277867794037,
-0.39745232462882996,
-0.17343325912952423,
-0.4451616406440735,
-0.04191863164305687,
0.5700469017028809,
-0.16308137774467468,
0.07721121609210968,
-1.0028940439224243,
0.7585267424583435,
-0.09530942142009735,
0.7712863087654114,
-0.7484096884727478,
-0.278751403093338,
-0.05523090437054634,
-0.41069382429122925,
-0.08133348822593689,
-0.6167638897895813,
0.3624036908149719,
-0.10693664848804474,
0.8737964034080505,
0.2585434019565582,
0.19333910942077637,
0.5905314683914185,
-0.25890833139419556,
0.6382952928543091,
-0.04744170606136322,
-1.2739696502685547,
0.22195738554000854,
-0.3846317529678345,
0.27962440252304077,
0.8879144787788391,
0.28658565878868103,
-0.23923952877521515,
-0.6951588988304138,
-1.05781090259552,
-1.1932188272476196,
0.8420975208282471,
0.2542756497859955,
0.04419612139463425,
-0.19609813392162323,
0.3057793080806732,
0.5044829845428467,
0.2488299459218979,
-0.5790050625801086,
0.03751322254538536,
0.196626678109169,
0.15225039422512054,
0.15656989812850952,
-0.3936058282852173,
0.09894629567861557,
-0.22928419709205627,
0.744576096534729,
-0.07159353792667389,
0.06201934441924095,
0.07873393595218658,
-0.38057222962379456,
0.13413308560848236,
0.48950865864753723,
0.5065765976905823,
0.8116729259490967,
-0.34172385931015015,
0.07959558069705963,
0.036472707986831665,
-0.24939456582069397,
0.3610786199569702,
0.5127748847007751,
-0.537396252155304,
0.15107740461826324,
0.2404625117778778,
0.8037093281745911,
-0.07142557948827744,
-0.88485187292099,
0.4479893743991852,
0.10892818868160248,
-0.5908940434455872,
-0.9312384128570557,
-0.04256980121135712,
-0.15434476733207703,
0.27367472648620605,
0.10443402826786041,
-0.07064907997846603,
0.4275398850440979,
-0.2548283040523529,
0.6968774795532227,
0.2526010274887085,
-0.6315529346466064,
0.02449948340654373,
0.7689586877822876,
-0.041063737124204636,
0.09751543402671814,
0.7278560996055603,
-0.39335504174232483,
-0.37072351574897766,
0.5494977235794067,
-0.0016903555952012539,
0.9406934380531311,
-0.024456389248371124,
0.4114105999469757,
0.15844815969467163,
0.4439883828163147,
-0.11541730910539627,
0.4557547867298126,
0.286710262298584,
-0.4774130582809448,
-0.45442119240760803,
-0.4141826331615448,
-0.21835769712924957,
0.30511152744293213,
-0.6446115374565125,
0.5702306032180786,
-0.1164630800485611,
-0.19895096123218536,
0.2768045961856842,
-0.20083118975162506,
-0.923590898513794,
0.17488835752010345,
0.28066879510879517,
0.6126374006271362,
-0.8035086989402771,
0.7758949398994446,
0.5908498764038086,
-0.5581188797950745,
-0.44008445739746094,
-0.1424814760684967,
-0.1458282768726349,
-0.46828630566596985,
0.46890753507614136,
0.24747531116008759,
0.1291998028755188,
-0.18857575953006744,
-0.18357253074645996,
-0.6079639196395874,
0.7768983840942383,
0.6636732220649719,
-0.23035073280334473,
0.1073499396443367,
0.5351375937461853,
0.6437513828277588,
-0.08552376925945282,
0.28581714630126953,
1.0417931079864502,
0.814861536026001,
-0.10399974882602692,
-0.9190974235534668,
0.18934471905231476,
-0.22375831007957458,
-0.35287752747535706,
0.13541468977928162,
-0.29345253109931946,
0.8859893679618835,
0.19706040620803833,
-0.47825029492378235,
-0.08927140384912491,
0.5323357582092285,
-0.005210962612181902,
0.24580249190330505,
0.8034883141517639,
0.6789290308952332,
0.8530043363571167,
-0.18749496340751648,
1.2188808917999268,
-0.1877909153699875,
0.4810316860675812,
1.1394118070602417,
-0.4796098470687866,
0.542671799659729,
0.25657427310943604,
-0.04142310842871666,
0.09383842349052429,
0.44730427861213684,
-0.6413021087646484,
0.38505545258522034,
0.5620986819267273,
0.2333991825580597,
-0.36356568336486816,
-0.033787477761507034,
-0.1816461682319641,
0.6836525201797485,
0.3720063269138336,
-0.09532732516527176,
-0.45651760697364807,
0.0016153051983565092,
-0.18145132064819336,
0.23999564349651337,
-0.09812391549348831,
1.0718899965286255,
-0.07117142528295517,
-0.9055017232894897,
0.8013570308685303,
0.027554070577025414,
0.14155523478984833,
-0.3421977460384369,
-0.04268692061305046,
-0.18930746614933014,
0.38888686895370483,
-0.08726911246776581,
-0.7448316812515259,
0.6338347792625427,
0.16436219215393066,
0.11992276459932327,
-0.1801910251379013,
0.7683522701263428,
0.039660580456256866,
-0.3572904169559479,
0.5967433452606201,
0.6904890537261963,
0.3163587152957916,
-0.32671037316322327,
-0.730850338935852,
-0.1363113671541214,
-0.15761306881904602,
-0.46934953331947327,
0.019093656912446022,
0.39613282680511475,
-0.2532227635383606,
0.5663893818855286,
0.3774324059486389,
-0.1311315894126892,
0.13610278069972992,
-0.114201620221138,
0.6760396957397461,
-0.9716652035713196,
-0.6817184686660767,
-0.6084240674972534,
0.762001633644104,
0.0639800950884819,
-0.1602293699979782,
0.4101572036743164,
0.8664968013763428,
1.0187883377075195,
-0.28007370233535767,
1.0572432279586792,
-0.2565568685531616,
0.6993054151535034,
-0.7876406311988831,
0.4110299050807953,
-0.38371846079826355,
0.2976454198360443,
-0.008408132009208202,
-1.040783166885376,
-0.4914471209049225,
0.4866379201412201,
-0.08590120077133179,
-0.1875322163105011,
0.9063394665718079,
0.35921189188957214,
-0.17890839278697968,
0.028505876660346985,
0.313505083322525,
0.2306193858385086,
0.4940465986728668,
0.33523136377334595,
0.8823779821395874,
-0.2931855022907257,
0.782076895236969,
-0.0963037759065628,
-0.1038973405957222,
-0.24945293366909027,
-0.8181917071342468,
-0.7577886581420898,
-0.48878350853919983,
-0.395060658454895,
-0.6468492150306702,
-0.05018509924411774,
0.7698820233345032,
0.34636029601097107,
-0.9720664024353027,
-0.18116021156311035,
-0.11651340872049332,
-0.4025841951370239,
-0.520420491695404,
-0.1188657209277153,
0.49626702070236206,
-0.5721726417541504,
-0.7541224360466003,
0.3999490737915039,
-0.05805578455328941,
0.22699198126792908,
0.22986653447151184,
0.06613220274448395,
-0.06819908320903778,
0.0757732018828392,
0.49816641211509705,
0.22876884043216705,
-0.9091370701789856,
-0.5377676486968994,
-0.40187329053878784,
-0.26608335971832275,
0.019005708396434784,
0.7680611610412598,
-0.7041994333267212,
0.2629334628582001,
0.42482230067253113,
0.6234100461006165,
0.6562774777412415,
0.19795815646648407,
0.5273044109344482,
-0.6306513547897339,
0.3191394507884979,
0.530943751335144,
0.552839994430542,
-0.07223403453826904,
-0.19790410995483398,
1.01047945022583,
-0.09704891592264175,
-0.3211890459060669,
-0.679107129573822,
0.08495722711086273,
-1.3313689231872559,
-0.8286156058311462,
1.30076265335083,
-0.19949807226657867,
-0.07478989660739899,
-0.716299831867218,
-0.1921916902065277,
0.09290295839309692,
-0.28329047560691833,
0.9789032936096191,
0.9984086155891418,
0.15542909502983093,
0.3040105104446411,
-1.0881497859954834,
0.4410695731639862,
0.41916701197624207,
-0.9274990558624268,
0.3502662181854248,
1.008124589920044,
-0.031951893121004105,
0.1766667664051056,
0.8491296172142029,
-0.1740572154521942,
0.35276949405670166,
-0.04936792328953743,
-0.0023406450636684895,
-0.41802743077278137,
-0.3660274147987366,
-0.3640790581703186,
0.6518779397010803,
-0.03656701371073723,
-0.08735258877277374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.07835v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.07835v2
|
SciRIFF: A Resource to Enhance Language Model Instruction-Following over Scientific Literature
| 2024-06-10T21:22:08 | 2024-06-18T23:43:34 |
David Wadden, Kejian Shi, Jacob Morrison, Aakanksha Naik, Shruti Singh, Nitzan Barzilay, Kyle Lo, Tom Hope, Luca Soldaini, Shannon Zejiang Shen, Doug Downey, Hannaneh Hajishirzi, Arman Cohan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present SciRIFF (Scientific Resource for Instruction-Following and
Finetuning), a dataset of 137K instruction-following demonstrations for 54
tasks covering five essential scientific literature understanding capabilities:
information extraction, summarization, question answering, claim verification,
and classification. SciRIFF demonstrations are notable for their long input
contexts, detailed task specifications, and complex structured outputs. While
instruction-following resources are available in specific domains such as
clinical medicine and chemistry, SciRIFF is the first dataset focused on
extracting and synthesizing information from research literature across a wide
range of scientific fields. To demonstrate the utility of SciRIFF, we develop a
sample-efficient strategy to adapt a general instruction-following model for
science by performing additional finetuning on a mix of general-domain and
SciRIFF demonstrations. In evaluations on nine held-out scientific tasks, our
model -- called SciTulu -- improves over a strong LLM baseline by 28.1% and
6.5% at the 7B and 70B scales respectively, while maintaining general
instruction-following performance within 2% of the baseline. We are optimistic
that SciRIFF will facilitate the development and evaluation of LLMs to help
researchers navigate the ever-growing body of scientific literature. We release
our dataset, model checkpoints, and data processing and evaluation code to
enable further research.
|
[
0.16366125643253326,
-0.35009071230888367,
0.3181346654891968,
0.40630707144737244,
-0.01049988716840744,
0.0398087315261364,
-0.1639275848865509,
-0.17266646027565002,
0.06328477710485458,
0.5130807757377625,
-0.46740877628326416,
-0.6121135354042053,
-0.41613131761550903,
0.14068195223808289,
-0.5826361775398254,
1.2753126621246338,
-0.05366731435060501,
0.5011999607086182,
-0.5839608311653137,
0.27739471197128296,
-0.1293046772480011,
-0.019008560106158257,
-0.3137485980987549,
-0.45769789814949036,
0.862151563167572,
0.7216280102729797,
0.33823665976524353,
0.6141884922981262,
0.6592896580696106,
0.1515234261751175,
0.014798684976994991,
0.053221654146909714,
-0.6313511729240417,
0.16563624143600464,
-0.4125917851924896,
-0.4203478991985321,
-0.3590054512023926,
-0.02131819538772106,
0.8397601842880249,
0.8520190715789795,
-0.05368778854608536,
0.1638699173927307,
0.3166979253292084,
0.5343872904777527,
-0.5969905853271484,
0.2798278033733368,
0.01416915375739336,
0.07251377403736115,
0.006067534442991018,
-0.3590407371520996,
-0.7457079291343689,
-0.39843320846557617,
0.20843277871608734,
-0.8572234511375427,
0.3196646273136139,
0.15837587416172028,
0.639190673828125,
0.04675666242837906,
-0.2595047652721405,
-0.3753185570240021,
-0.4886568486690521,
0.7506322860717773,
-0.32432717084884644,
0.4911978244781494,
0.6276984810829163,
0.06784598529338837,
-0.22048541903495789,
-1.0706684589385986,
-0.14439290761947632,
-0.5216836333274841,
-0.11410408467054367,
0.22410151362419128,
-0.12428826838731766,
0.10898944735527039,
0.4379211962223053,
0.018585143610835075,
-0.6462874412536621,
-0.005546104162931442,
-0.9075559973716736,
-0.21217584609985352,
0.3776650130748749,
0.17578117549419403,
0.34381186962127686,
-0.2292206883430481,
-0.1949189305305481,
-0.3501042127609253,
-0.8903626799583435,
-0.11801016330718994,
-0.07004649192094803,
-0.07867903262376785,
0.039019420742988586,
0.608797550201416,
-0.20942869782447815,
0.4490056335926056,
-0.20727407932281494,
-0.033500730991363525,
0.11802852153778076,
-0.6751828193664551,
-0.24090026319026947,
0.27599138021469116,
0.5328193306922913,
0.3414858281612396,
-0.24228383600711823,
-0.043252065777778625,
0.26581528782844543,
-0.29582443833351135,
0.0448172427713871,
-1.4360649585723877,
-0.5576249361038208,
-0.16578547656536102,
-0.2531735301017761,
-0.1180589571595192,
-0.11934199184179306,
-0.8424373865127563,
-0.5422640442848206,
-0.19963207840919495,
0.1811995804309845,
-0.6445634365081787,
0.003018854418769479,
0.008355109952390194,
-0.06631381809711456,
0.09808260947465897,
0.3897862434387207,
-0.830462634563446,
0.47922787070274353,
0.7541679739952087,
1.0857692956924438,
-0.2657730281352997,
-0.2607575058937073,
-0.6353282928466797,
0.2652939260005951,
-0.25843894481658936,
0.9003081321716309,
-0.7446227669715881,
-0.7618943452835083,
-0.3734605610370636,
0.26313045620918274,
-0.0177280455827713,
-0.10677651315927505,
0.6081673502922058,
-0.3807043135166168,
0.29174163937568665,
-0.33307260274887085,
-0.6209293007850647,
-0.3085744082927704,
-0.31844764947891235,
-0.71458500623703,
0.7044498324394226,
-0.024549590423703194,
-0.6647690534591675,
0.15879753232002258,
-0.9648342728614807,
-0.4070078432559967,
0.2785085141658783,
0.0513022281229496,
0.03820525109767914,
-0.0364803671836853,
0.015243040397763252,
0.35434770584106445,
-0.42875421047210693,
0.12517543137073517,
-0.2976495623588562,
-0.59242844581604,
0.052024926990270615,
-0.31988877058029175,
0.7015956044197083,
0.44440600275993347,
0.01872478798031807,
0.15499328076839447,
-0.7243784070014954,
0.1258314996957779,
-0.1988949179649353,
-0.06224891543388367,
-0.6213607788085938,
0.0416012778878212,
0.003728179493919015,
-0.37247154116630554,
0.056606125086545944,
-0.5383296012878418,
0.32839521765708923,
-0.1691538244485855,
0.47817161679267883,
0.3515181243419647,
0.15266153216362,
0.7039228677749634,
-0.2952492833137512,
0.7983471155166626,
-0.38390395045280457,
-0.011532621458172798,
-0.6492652297019958,
-0.22092463076114655,
-0.688962459564209,
-0.39335355162620544,
0.5666514039039612,
0.47136229276657104,
-0.5339983701705933,
-0.04413951188325882,
-0.1513768434524536,
-0.6217538714408875,
-0.5636746287345886,
0.22688435018062592,
0.36034566164016724,
0.8338350653648376,
0.39440250396728516,
-0.11059655249118805,
-0.6290872693061829,
-0.5686185359954834,
0.11919649690389633,
0.05107085779309273,
-0.02516859956085682,
-0.006709578912705183,
0.6266496181488037,
-0.07836149632930756,
0.6729775667190552,
-0.6078981757164001,
0.05250795930624008,
-0.1522139459848404,
0.4593018889427185,
0.24410340189933777,
0.43974751234054565,
0.37939804792404175,
-0.49723491072654724,
-0.44967857003211975,
0.13404981791973114,
-0.7032137513160706,
-0.36739733815193176,
-0.047307949513196945,
-0.37336474657058716,
0.1741485446691513,
0.6208386421203613,
-0.3148109018802643,
0.24252144992351532,
0.3537442088127136,
-0.4992034137248993,
0.7477330565452576,
-0.23525887727737427,
0.4044461250305176,
-0.8295181393623352,
0.3243587911128998,
0.09499216824769974,
0.1315346211194992,
-0.7557428479194641,
-0.002995068673044443,
0.4234379529953003,
-0.08924784511327744,
-0.4403497874736786,
0.5070938467979431,
-0.5273226499557495,
-0.0021946190390735865,
-0.33505141735076904,
-0.10684987902641296,
0.4242289364337921,
-0.04079677537083626,
0.13836711645126343,
1.064901351928711,
0.6693891286849976,
-0.41963064670562744,
-0.0035872270818799734,
0.06366479396820068,
-0.4619876444339752,
0.24753166735172272,
-0.8140658736228943,
-0.01819716952741146,
-0.09238025546073914,
0.19970089197158813,
-0.532596230506897,
-0.35632070899009705,
0.290689080953598,
-0.08907146751880646,
0.34998422861099243,
-0.24274909496307373,
-0.4783633053302765,
-0.11826936900615692,
-0.3117794692516327,
-0.07671058923006058,
0.731525182723999,
-0.2755773067474365,
0.555571973323822,
-0.14339932799339294,
-0.6218264698982239,
-0.8147490620613098,
-0.5312432646751404,
-0.12794718146324158,
0.011533922515809536,
-0.3232795000076294,
0.3911448121070862,
-0.218636155128479,
-0.09012676030397415,
0.103902667760849,
-0.1471165120601654,
-0.0779261589050293,
0.0076224845834076405,
0.3125365078449249,
0.556131899356842,
-0.13312126696109772,
0.22044318914413452,
0.33721044659614563,
0.0717613622546196,
0.2714780867099762,
-0.07511282712221146,
0.24447068572044373,
-0.141635000705719,
-0.5388320088386536,
-0.26830410957336426,
0.25313854217529297,
0.285704642534256,
-0.03245721757411957,
0.39717257022857666,
0.5301986336708069,
-0.24037258327007294,
-0.19708172976970673,
-0.12484386563301086,
-0.411446750164032,
-0.4828040599822998,
0.705033004283905,
-0.10336266458034515,
-0.6234757900238037,
0.1720120906829834,
0.08921556174755096,
0.2933744788169861,
0.26035043597221375,
0.18467682600021362,
-0.5162746906280518,
0.8876426815986633,
0.7635557055473328,
0.22348004579544067,
0.5640029311180115,
-0.3548991084098816,
0.0004244625451974571,
-0.7454506158828735,
-0.5321870446205139,
-0.5982853770256042,
-0.05556637793779373,
-0.24511229991912842,
-0.682277500629425,
0.37124910950660706,
0.29914528131484985,
-0.2004709541797638,
0.16076065599918365,
-0.5359365344047546,
0.7016985416412354,
0.585579514503479,
0.23012836277484894,
0.4867529571056366,
0.4093153178691864,
-0.13098786771297455,
-0.11823166161775589,
-0.9526588916778564,
-0.5613981485366821,
1.071122646331787,
0.323130339384079,
1.3002568483352661,
-0.22183355689048767,
0.6955549120903015,
0.2990091145038605,
0.7110482454299927,
-0.783385694026947,
0.6491274833679199,
-0.14319726824760437,
-0.17572879791259766,
-0.1717214584350586,
-0.3896278738975525,
-0.7783684134483337,
0.14260490238666534,
-0.06521998345851898,
-0.3563013970851898,
0.014066317118704319,
0.24557048082351685,
-0.2322048395872116,
-0.12383396178483963,
-0.9453803300857544,
0.6339496374130249,
-0.4281158149242401,
-0.6789714694023132,
-0.5641719698905945,
-0.36652955412864685,
0.40418344736099243,
0.04989374801516533,
0.23171940445899963,
0.14358888566493988,
0.05917739123106003,
0.968475878238678,
-0.009569192305207253,
0.9325746297836304,
-0.07435215264558792,
0.18632584810256958,
0.23690739274024963,
0.2643165588378906,
0.059816181659698486,
-0.22045177221298218,
-0.19050100445747375,
-0.1636306196451187,
0.3503992557525635,
-0.23536892235279083,
-0.7357618808746338,
0.9138717651367188,
-0.5786128044128418,
-0.7710793018341064,
-0.71098393201828,
-0.7862064838409424,
0.17717263102531433,
0.2365236133337021,
0.02460261806845665,
0.4136525094509125,
-0.26080676913261414,
0.3228650987148285,
0.8905172348022461,
-0.15434712171554565,
0.1295597404241562,
0.7740291953086853,
-0.2802586257457733,
-0.20773282647132874,
1.148910403251648,
0.07350252568721771,
0.24848085641860962,
0.288918673992157,
0.3096485733985901,
-0.3107929229736328,
-0.5359720587730408,
-0.12043978273868561,
0.32665136456489563,
-0.9734283089637756,
-0.3005029559135437,
-0.6101507544517517,
-0.2474796324968338,
-0.5150372385978699,
-0.139249786734581,
0.22272822260856628,
-0.44558098912239075,
-0.6860413551330566,
0.041338443756103516,
0.7586764693260193,
0.84477698802948,
-0.10973193496465683,
0.17723289132118225,
-0.7787251472473145,
0.030289743095636368,
-0.15256105363368988,
0.30902862548828125,
-0.13160021603107452,
-0.80208820104599,
-0.30884093046188354,
0.027368230745196342,
-0.4260198473930359,
-0.905128538608551,
0.3211342394351959,
0.5736212134361267,
0.5501460433006287,
0.27265793085098267,
-0.07024551928043365,
0.8140469193458557,
-0.7267923355102539,
0.6269604563713074,
0.37995675206184387,
-0.5799431204795837,
0.5725691318511963,
0.028377700597047806,
0.16506093740463257,
0.2532639801502228,
0.8799231052398682,
-0.4490152895450592,
-0.25510114431381226,
-0.42265480756759644,
-0.6348606944084167,
0.6722765564918518,
-0.23051196336746216,
-0.045677971094846725,
0.238625630736351,
0.3237573504447937,
0.10467030853033066,
-0.11210580915212631,
-0.41595563292503357,
0.14115944504737854,
-0.4815557301044464,
-0.4051229953765869,
-0.09519895911216736,
-0.12521325051784515,
-0.39012613892555237,
-0.43568336963653564,
0.777614176273346,
-0.24549105763435364,
0.04146410524845123,
0.2534354329109192,
-0.2972933053970337,
0.01775144599378109,
0.4049808979034424,
0.7391567826271057,
0.570949375629425,
-0.14783133566379547,
0.1166360154747963,
-0.023547006770968437,
-0.8634433150291443,
-0.120960533618927,
0.4435170590877533,
-0.34063994884490967,
-0.1468225121498108,
0.3589536249637604,
0.6472094655036926,
0.4063113033771515,
-0.9185367822647095,
0.05783854424953461,
0.0738261416554451,
-0.3288091719150543,
-0.10427643358707428,
0.5787217617034912,
0.2807406485080719,
0.25252872705459595,
0.5365189909934998,
-0.20586253702640533,
0.5210204124450684,
-0.27576643228530884,
0.353213369846344,
0.16460074484348297,
-0.12458176910877228,
-0.24377046525478363,
0.5471736788749695,
-0.03875186666846275,
0.00788442324846983,
0.4250459372997284,
-0.15874157845973969,
-0.1581706404685974,
0.6989398002624512,
0.700590193271637,
0.31637391448020935,
-0.019876718521118164,
0.48296400904655457,
0.48625680804252625,
0.020774101838469505,
-0.32789888978004456,
0.21464519202709198,
-0.0460934042930603,
-0.17133381962776184,
-0.6123994588851929,
-0.5453749299049377,
-0.7761987447738647,
-0.10042720288038254,
-0.7763134241104126,
0.4472966492176056,
-0.4722832441329956,
0.13912196457386017,
0.15688921511173248,
0.19938898086547852,
-0.47612297534942627,
-0.37981024384498596,
-0.22116409242153168,
1.1974495649337769,
-0.8493036031723022,
0.9276277422904968,
0.7626351118087769,
-0.4632089138031006,
-0.522010862827301,
-0.4270937144756317,
-0.06027470901608467,
-0.5590617060661316,
1.0287286043167114,
-0.00416236137971282,
-0.2833424210548401,
0.032971277832984924,
-0.9251739978790283,
-0.9042577147483826,
1.3266459703445435,
0.312221884727478,
-0.7663401365280151,
-0.07141023129224777,
-0.42337486147880554,
0.6563469767570496,
-0.5358915328979492,
0.6506382822990417,
0.497758150100708,
0.2874571979045868,
0.5030742287635803,
-0.42393264174461365,
-0.055612899363040924,
-0.38974979519844055,
-0.2791784405708313,
-0.36717522144317627,
-0.2655412554740906,
0.3463072180747986,
-0.5415617227554321,
-0.10150487720966339,
0.32174941897392273,
0.9261614084243774,
0.6386704444885254,
0.5041948556900024,
0.18065638840198517,
0.030186720192432404,
0.8739484548568726,
0.013502130284905434,
0.8369169235229492,
-0.25004443526268005,
0.08777791261672974,
1.2754136323928833,
-0.5080495476722717,
0.7287603616714478,
0.48603060841560364,
0.1343163102865219,
0.6853564381599426,
0.5295253992080688,
-0.39279383420944214,
0.7212849855422974,
0.22479890286922455,
-0.3113180994987488,
0.13456742465496063,
-0.42643052339553833,
-0.264877051115036,
-0.04324797913432121,
0.8266000151634216,
-0.4255760908126831,
-0.30589428544044495,
0.343903511762619,
0.123509980738163,
0.027433332055807114,
-0.32164716720581055,
0.36997249722480774,
-0.05116557329893112,
-0.7983612418174744,
0.6833639740943909,
-0.28407666087150574,
0.32837387919425964,
-0.8169256448745728,
-0.5848619937896729,
-0.22584618628025055,
-0.11261823773384094,
-0.3707084655761719,
-1.0121259689331055,
-0.014592261053621769,
0.2847386598587036,
-0.1500117927789688,
-0.372737318277359,
0.699614942073822,
-0.5992653369903564,
-0.5608918070793152,
-0.06640665978193283,
0.07912004739046097,
0.5220617651939392,
0.7538471817970276,
-0.6201114058494568,
0.19318829476833344,
0.13119587302207947,
-0.3225002586841583,
0.404629647731781,
0.09132456034421921,
-0.09949294477701187,
0.8116903305053711,
0.5929689407348633,
0.32953423261642456,
-0.022533562034368515,
0.3452061712741852,
0.8181232213973999,
-0.33709654211997986,
-0.11099031567573547,
-0.3508261740207672,
0.3103358745574951,
-0.16198162734508514,
0.009712199680507183,
0.7176353931427002,
0.2614300549030304,
0.6377105712890625,
-0.040335338562726974,
0.8057394623756409,
-0.1840432584285736,
0.45632678270339966,
-0.5854707956314087,
0.7163136005401611,
-0.2539324462413788,
0.26268014311790466,
0.07457463443279266,
-0.49687036871910095,
-0.23332831263542175,
0.8775045871734619,
-0.2881324887275696,
-0.0664610043168068,
0.9425178170204163,
0.9270069599151611,
-0.13485386967658997,
0.34243589639663696,
-0.045795999467372894,
0.3935053050518036,
0.2414083182811737,
0.2909207344055176,
0.6635989546775818,
-0.1171768382191658,
0.413997083902359,
-0.34239131212234497,
-0.4636707901954651,
-0.11017128080129623,
-1.1106065511703491,
-0.9740321040153503,
-0.4007439911365509,
-0.4421445429325104,
-0.32575151324272156,
0.15021798014640808,
1.0204612016677856,
0.5676466226577759,
-0.8827859163284302,
-0.2662637233734131,
-0.07789767533540726,
0.0076361424289643764,
-0.2853350043296814,
-0.20783239603042603,
0.5171806812286377,
-0.437335342168808,
-0.6702613830566406,
0.5824247002601624,
-0.07818161696195602,
0.12423312664031982,
-0.4072449505329132,
-0.2434023916721344,
-0.06259807199239731,
-0.18871261179447174,
0.5053731203079224,
0.5459403991699219,
-0.4418144226074219,
-0.04137282073497772,
0.6040256023406982,
-0.17630502581596375,
-0.22334317862987518,
0.8087222576141357,
-0.5763989686965942,
0.3989146649837494,
0.5499154925346375,
0.5713497996330261,
0.6104611754417419,
-0.31090712547302246,
0.45803770422935486,
-0.4399968981742859,
-0.061088550835847855,
0.35608145594596863,
0.3723026514053345,
0.2513473629951477,
-0.43558427691459656,
0.595771849155426,
0.010785846039652824,
-0.6306806206703186,
-1.0193952322006226,
-0.1442972868680954,
-0.8690415620803833,
-0.2659091055393219,
1.0475311279296875,
-0.3311830461025238,
-0.33653882145881653,
0.09233984351158142,
-0.14919154345989227,
0.17255836725234985,
-0.535895586013794,
0.5530974268913269,
0.7712450623512268,
-0.32300102710723877,
-0.5587326288223267,
-0.8395283818244934,
0.3741661608219147,
0.5228262543678284,
-0.794244647026062,
0.16632623970508575,
0.6377003192901611,
0.5513070821762085,
0.1485569328069687,
0.4027755856513977,
-0.14360411465168,
0.5934177041053772,
-0.22584009170532227,
0.2043236941099167,
-0.2820768356323242,
-0.6885496973991394,
-0.41079798340797424,
0.030640415847301483,
0.04491004720330238,
0.2693883180618286
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06799v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06799v1
|
LLM-dCache: Improving Tool-Augmented LLMs with GPT-Driven Localized Data Caching
| 2024-06-10T21:08:39 | 2024-06-10T21:08:39 |
Simranjit Singh, Michael Fore, Andreas Karatzas, Chaehong Lee, Yanan Jian, Longfei Shangguan, Fuxun Yu, Iraklis Anagnostopoulos, Dimitrios Stamoulis
|
cs.DC
|
cs.DC, cs.CL
|
As Large Language Models (LLMs) broaden their capabilities to manage
thousands of API calls, they are confronted with complex data operations across
vast datasets with significant overhead to the underlying system. In this work,
we introduce LLM-dCache to optimize data accesses by treating cache operations
as callable API functions exposed to the tool-augmented agent. We grant LLMs
the autonomy to manage cache decisions via prompting, seamlessly integrating
with existing function-calling mechanisms. Tested on an industry-scale
massively parallel platform that spans hundreds of GPT endpoints and terabytes
of imagery, our method improves Copilot times by an average of 1.24x across
various LLMs and prompting techniques.
|
[
-0.20087657868862152,
-0.7009518146514893,
0.7298799157142639,
0.22351020574569702,
-0.4521617591381073,
0.45068010687828064,
-0.29345759749412537,
-0.5595895051956177,
0.24526634812355042,
0.38938623666763306,
-0.791893482208252,
-0.5986896753311157,
-0.03540520742535591,
-0.14930039644241333,
-0.3052099645137787,
0.47450166940689087,
-0.31147366762161255,
0.021076926961541176,
-0.36231204867362976,
0.12540796399116516,
-0.5897679924964905,
-0.5364010334014893,
-1.1356430053710938,
-0.2584581673145294,
0.846072793006897,
0.30545419454574585,
0.8943260312080383,
0.6670323014259338,
0.25511056184768677,
0.2865792214870453,
0.24473033845424652,
0.49235203862190247,
-0.3885171115398407,
0.2594558000564575,
-0.17969097197055817,
-0.768407940864563,
-0.7772877812385559,
-0.2984694838523865,
0.18364982306957245,
0.5474845170974731,
-0.35075655579566956,
-0.22240203619003296,
-0.16075022518634796,
0.6380049586296082,
-0.7043938040733337,
0.32366156578063965,
-0.7837245464324951,
-0.03817997872829437,
-0.19376087188720703,
-0.484417200088501,
-0.34666094183921814,
-0.17402134835720062,
0.3185734152793884,
-0.8863437175750732,
0.34476643800735474,
-0.32212379574775696,
0.4089179039001465,
0.5171765089035034,
-0.14484772086143494,
-0.39210763573646545,
-0.5067338347434998,
0.849776566028595,
-0.4802393317222595,
0.14141617715358734,
0.5308347940444946,
0.26767539978027344,
-0.28469157218933105,
-0.8905146718025208,
-0.441449910402298,
0.01604461297392845,
0.2089245319366455,
0.22180569171905518,
-0.010371293872594833,
0.014644182287156582,
-0.04318542033433914,
0.18681687116622925,
-0.36530280113220215,
0.37014439702033997,
0.13593076169490814,
-0.2708996832370758,
0.4152730107307434,
0.3760177791118622,
0.1973477452993393,
0.34729182720184326,
-0.2851640582084656,
0.010521036572754383,
-0.9382524490356445,
-0.12374621629714966,
0.39227381348609924,
0.544196605682373,
-0.029753809794783592,
0.22480234503746033,
-0.3410356938838959,
0.6216040849685669,
0.02221476472914219,
-0.03814973682165146,
0.15004843473434448,
-0.19373387098312378,
-0.19609268009662628,
0.06631766259670258,
0.07491471618413925,
0.39702072739601135,
0.07504982501268387,
-0.45793941617012024,
-0.3097553253173828,
-0.13129793107509613,
0.31900739669799805,
-0.9860261082649231,
-0.18278712034225464,
0.5242180228233337,
0.08380921185016632,
-0.17424143850803375,
0.08375483751296997,
-0.5932238101959229,
-0.6757324934005737,
-0.551021158695221,
0.18742835521697998,
0.02408190257847309,
-0.33732813596725464,
0.3104957044124603,
0.1138482615351677,
0.2905113995075226,
0.7494648694992065,
-0.6262084245681763,
0.4106826186180115,
0.7479410171508789,
1.1001273393630981,
-0.4646081328392029,
-0.13531486690044403,
-0.8754162192344666,
0.41824308037757874,
-0.4033987820148468,
0.9949561953544617,
-0.5985648036003113,
-0.709272563457489,
0.10182395577430725,
0.3205585777759552,
-0.03772471100091934,
-0.7176292538642883,
0.382881224155426,
-0.877776026725769,
-0.3666536509990692,
-0.7919981479644775,
-0.3511682450771332,
-0.13347648084163666,
0.20895886421203613,
-0.7811339497566223,
1.022973895072937,
0.06407807022333145,
-0.3358690142631531,
0.49956706166267395,
-0.4766814410686493,
-0.49577829241752625,
0.222618967294693,
-0.2733398973941803,
-0.3339989483356476,
-0.029138071462512016,
0.763087809085846,
0.39841875433921814,
-0.3523900806903839,
0.14261572062969208,
-0.24444659054279327,
-0.49407950043678284,
-0.08603664487600327,
-0.388313889503479,
0.5639150142669678,
0.20198743045330048,
-0.5164475440979004,
0.09558480232954025,
-0.48908373713493347,
-0.009130272082984447,
0.010178267024457455,
-0.39087045192718506,
-0.15269479155540466,
0.14443771541118622,
-0.1253269612789154,
-0.15585459768772125,
0.4398573935031891,
-0.2249753624200821,
0.6133495569229126,
-0.13764645159244537,
0.3790801465511322,
1.0816664695739746,
-0.0663830041885376,
0.39138707518577576,
-0.2621099352836609,
0.6339534521102905,
0.06375283747911453,
0.21253007650375366,
-0.17584356665611267,
-0.10795034468173981,
-0.7101016640663147,
-0.7122946977615356,
0.07634809613227844,
0.43181949853897095,
-0.975227415561676,
0.2989828884601593,
-0.2445618063211441,
-0.49569615721702576,
-0.45623400807380676,
0.30077216029167175,
-0.10555068403482437,
0.42322251200675964,
0.17575539648532867,
-0.5697018504142761,
-0.11855963617563248,
-0.4510139226913452,
0.3291877806186676,
0.03386477008461952,
0.04951166734099388,
0.7109280824661255,
-0.001570919412188232,
-0.5582626461982727,
0.8679693341255188,
-0.4124060273170471,
-0.05243608355522156,
0.20901179313659668,
0.0865895077586174,
0.2542351484298706,
0.12110219150781631,
0.5933116674423218,
-0.6885403990745544,
-0.4920312166213989,
0.028231773525476456,
-0.43608951568603516,
-0.48114505410194397,
-0.24306067824363708,
-0.208048015832901,
0.47608792781829834,
0.42423465847969055,
-0.8746287226676941,
0.7404682040214539,
0.2611735165119171,
0.1737181395292282,
0.8842054009437561,
-0.32773706316947937,
0.15090572834014893,
-0.503094494342804,
0.06366200745105743,
-0.7469055652618408,
-0.2844580113887787,
-0.32730525732040405,
0.04747141897678375,
0.09955309331417084,
-0.0471087209880352,
-0.5110600590705872,
0.6837479472160339,
-0.7508265972137451,
-0.48162755370140076,
-0.6959495544433594,
0.1843479722738266,
0.005720790941268206,
0.2635376453399658,
0.032497718930244446,
1.2464330196380615,
1.080372929573059,
-0.8436082601547241,
0.6327348351478577,
-0.12486544996500015,
0.02139480784535408,
0.6140620112419128,
-0.630843997001648,
0.5872657895088196,
0.19319060444831848,
0.47555306553840637,
-0.9717942476272583,
-0.04997267574071884,
-0.12840315699577332,
0.06151553615927696,
0.28647565841674805,
-0.4127005934715271,
-1.1939817667007446,
-0.37577855587005615,
-0.4377595782279968,
0.4259597063064575,
0.09431833028793335,
-1.143963098526001,
0.6324243545532227,
0.06800222396850586,
-0.2205493003129959,
-0.6622021794319153,
-0.43306979537010193,
0.209013432264328,
-0.036489926278591156,
-0.49009546637535095,
0.33918502926826477,
-0.3150302767753601,
-0.019680840894579887,
-0.13662269711494446,
-0.4108600616455078,
-0.05390311777591705,
0.008777543902397156,
0.24493321776390076,
0.24488823115825653,
0.06285159289836884,
0.305103063583374,
0.048032812774181366,
-0.12383508682250977,
-0.19117189943790436,
-0.48619702458381653,
1.0326812267303467,
0.10567750781774521,
-0.7035077214241028,
-0.36016085743904114,
0.16287660598754883,
0.5935584902763367,
-0.05537392944097519,
0.40098482370376587,
0.6381241679191589,
-0.07876169681549072,
-0.17986242473125458,
-0.5869544148445129,
-0.2784585654735565,
-0.6366302967071533,
0.042331136763095856,
-0.3468896746635437,
-0.7270941734313965,
1.0240815877914429,
-0.27859804034233093,
-0.049631740897893906,
-0.09300742298364639,
0.8080676198005676,
0.13093684613704681,
0.8861598372459412,
0.3009744882583618,
-0.5513691902160645,
0.6338371634483337,
-0.3686368465423584,
-0.031451206654310226,
-0.5711503028869629,
0.1457141637802124,
-0.27680346369743347,
-0.2951337695121765,
-0.5694112777709961,
-0.7540428638458252,
0.23361140489578247,
-0.08252035826444626,
-0.270175576210022,
0.1279187649488449,
-0.550614058971405,
0.5277404189109802,
0.44155943393707275,
0.32381492853164673,
0.24559246003627777,
0.16328878700733185,
-0.28972136974334717,
0.1814740151166916,
-0.6692151427268982,
-0.1976562887430191,
1.0013443231582642,
-0.06581869721412659,
1.2006739377975464,
-0.14278224110603333,
0.522943377494812,
0.17394918203353882,
0.13828149437904358,
-0.8871922492980957,
0.6710637211799622,
0.04783695936203003,
-0.4404197931289673,
0.11985894292593002,
-0.2751496434211731,
-1.1615992784500122,
0.006976158823817968,
0.5127621293067932,
-0.7532671689987183,
0.34278544783592224,
0.06750724464654922,
-0.137269526720047,
0.4312378168106079,
-0.690184473991394,
0.11854957044124603,
-0.48729127645492554,
-0.7085692286491394,
-0.34587353467941284,
-0.46558403968811035,
-0.15003708004951477,
-0.02279624156653881,
-0.0536026693880558,
-0.0067963856272399426,
-0.48594963550567627,
0.22074417769908905,
-0.7563464641571045,
1.1525530815124512,
-0.44837528467178345,
-0.33021992444992065,
0.4603041112422943,
0.19330891966819763,
1.136059045791626,
0.0842670351266861,
-0.15408065915107727,
-0.04544730484485626,
-0.08547662943601608,
-0.5767995715141296,
-0.6479747295379639,
1.1107420921325684,
-0.7654502987861633,
-0.5807763338088989,
-0.28542062640190125,
-0.8171828985214233,
-0.13344837725162506,
0.2671683728694916,
-0.1896156221628189,
0.5610581040382385,
0.2106778472661972,
-0.1689607799053192,
0.4942052662372589,
-0.35053184628486633,
0.5423222780227661,
0.8768406510353088,
-0.24043554067611694,
-0.22908790409564972,
0.8287402987480164,
0.21474802494049072,
0.29517433047294617,
0.2532307505607605,
-0.1527893990278244,
-0.32946911454200745,
-0.5444809794425964,
-0.14166651666164398,
0.25872594118118286,
-0.8471640944480896,
-0.3887477517127991,
-0.5139749050140381,
0.08063852787017822,
-0.149231418967247,
-0.54549640417099,
-0.49592530727386475,
-0.26940616965293884,
-0.5084686875343323,
-0.290264755487442,
0.7718663215637207,
0.40535226464271545,
-0.1493479311466217,
0.682805597782135,
-0.34672829508781433,
0.12807226181030273,
0.32004621624946594,
0.46352604031562805,
0.23265326023101807,
0.01834479719400406,
-0.3162824809551239,
-0.04554712027311325,
-0.2237069010734558,
-0.48568955063819885,
0.30874907970428467,
-0.12195569276809692,
0.6188549399375916,
0.3352605700492859,
0.06745840609073639,
1.098030924797058,
-0.42476820945739746,
0.7881601452827454,
-0.28543806076049805,
-0.7180596590042114,
0.4666425585746765,
-0.5141012668609619,
0.3404095768928528,
0.4839424788951874,
0.08148175477981567,
-0.21568824350833893,
-0.3451792597770691,
-0.4461583197116852,
-1.3130853176116943,
0.45998767018318176,
-0.14106515049934387,
0.22269313037395477,
-0.04442951828241348,
0.7283811569213867,
0.19687192142009735,
0.41768234968185425,
-0.2786445915699005,
-0.2080145627260208,
0.15597642958164215,
0.20522548258304596,
0.20381027460098267,
0.0475100502371788,
-0.22925496101379395,
-0.3455081284046173,
0.4073978364467621,
-0.41339701414108276,
0.5677124857902527,
0.3959376811981201,
-0.1673552542924881,
-0.267917662858963,
0.05736085772514343,
0.5760222673416138,
0.9336630702018738,
-0.18764005601406097,
0.2030302882194519,
0.14901085197925568,
-0.6830323338508606,
-0.03253305330872536,
0.2841387391090393,
-0.05066252499818802,
-0.15545035898685455,
0.08040782809257507,
0.3928111493587494,
0.10378444939851761,
-0.7111339569091797,
0.13918742537498474,
-0.16220404207706451,
0.19261594116687775,
-0.24455001950263977,
0.15844286978244781,
0.17562584578990936,
0.27607595920562744,
0.5993296504020691,
-0.28248897194862366,
0.08053266257047653,
-0.3469966948032379,
0.36621811985969543,
0.42378926277160645,
-0.20458553731441498,
-0.366638720035553,
0.3545876145362854,
0.143826425075531,
0.06504575163125992,
0.5160309076309204,
-0.06941158324480057,
-0.464335560798645,
0.7372939586639404,
0.3896181881427765,
1.0225319862365723,
-0.17699547111988068,
0.18272583186626434,
0.1090974435210228,
0.3161390423774719,
0.060438212007284164,
0.42676210403442383,
-0.3032289147377014,
-0.5784129500389099,
-0.4176526367664337,
-0.1428658366203308,
-0.6674103140830994,
0.015367149375379086,
-0.5899166464805603,
0.241283118724823,
-0.5230076313018799,
-0.14357832074165344,
-0.3557731807231903,
0.5847161412239075,
-0.9899994730949402,
-0.060101401060819626,
-0.2757262587547302,
1.031402349472046,
-0.24678641557693481,
0.9436625838279724,
0.41239404678344727,
-0.21554240584373474,
-0.6036637425422668,
0.002291698008775711,
0.25782594084739685,
-1.2685019969940186,
0.441626638174057,
0.280952513217926,
-0.36353930830955505,
0.13768383860588074,
-0.8036375045776367,
-0.6280639171600342,
1.7327913045883179,
0.5400622487068176,
-0.6881408095359802,
0.2909991145133972,
0.09169951826334,
0.48129886388778687,
-0.4272018074989319,
0.21375691890716553,
0.5221381783485413,
0.6300808787345886,
0.2335650622844696,
-0.8201621770858765,
0.06942421197891235,
0.1477680504322052,
-0.12748613953590393,
-0.0066603091545403,
-0.6675869226455688,
0.5820847153663635,
-0.32440629601478577,
-0.2873859405517578,
0.25691962242126465,
0.24065130949020386,
0.337578147649765,
0.21510423719882965,
0.5642397403717041,
0.584621250629425,
1.0681825876235962,
0.05269116535782814,
1.4395544528961182,
-0.1019577607512474,
0.05627806484699249,
1.3697482347488403,
-0.5649283528327942,
0.7049568891525269,
0.5210825800895691,
-0.13093268871307373,
0.21493275463581085,
1.0226645469665527,
0.09528589248657227,
0.8306723833084106,
0.1593303084373474,
-0.7619827389717102,
0.009552125819027424,
-0.3847145140171051,
-0.1734478920698166,
0.002320103347301483,
0.41400226950645447,
-0.011447323486208916,
-0.3839278817176819,
-0.12018957734107971,
0.16782423853874207,
-0.2761773467063904,
-0.3715559244155884,
0.7321628332138062,
-0.05127030983567238,
-0.40700003504753113,
0.47417882084846497,
-0.41396355628967285,
0.5546314120292664,
-0.41741979122161865,
0.1474185436964035,
-0.38163089752197266,
0.1269020289182663,
-0.15195229649543762,
-0.6259102821350098,
0.011433045379817486,
-0.07273269444704056,
-0.11334013938903809,
-0.04106501117348671,
0.7288776636123657,
-0.3884892165660858,
-0.22633247077465057,
0.7259208559989929,
0.49135810136795044,
0.12973010540008545,
-0.2220304310321808,
-0.8842360973358154,
0.41350188851356506,
-0.32778143882751465,
-0.24722197651863098,
0.21884001791477203,
0.37353724241256714,
-0.009450859390199184,
0.8816724419593811,
0.8246504068374634,
0.296139121055603,
0.12316830456256866,
0.5750322341918945,
1.2965974807739258,
-0.4004483222961426,
-0.3842126429080963,
-0.6716390252113342,
0.3664496839046478,
0.13868702948093414,
0.34413942694664,
0.4976757764816284,
0.6064010262489319,
0.7133397459983826,
0.06453729420900345,
0.7637119889259338,
0.01689283736050129,
0.24845680594444275,
-0.5945443511009216,
0.47607657313346863,
-0.4841395318508148,
0.5109906196594238,
-0.10082788020372391,
-0.7352930307388306,
-0.22054645419120789,
0.22325819730758667,
-0.6951128244400024,
0.1785435825586319,
0.4201190173625946,
1.3043214082717896,
-0.16140958666801453,
-0.35866913199424744,
0.20882493257522583,
0.0028132235165685415,
0.6815032362937927,
0.3048989474773407,
0.7372584342956543,
-0.2225477397441864,
0.4000868797302246,
-0.18449850380420685,
-0.1123829260468483,
-0.24007749557495117,
-1.0186794996261597,
-0.752985954284668,
-0.3665992319583893,
-0.26956310868263245,
0.14071142673492432,
0.02882949635386467,
0.5549625754356384,
0.932411253452301,
-0.6061505079269409,
-0.25260040163993835,
-0.25801974534988403,
0.15732333064079285,
-0.3488123118877411,
-0.2910915017127991,
0.5116371512413025,
-0.6168037056922913,
-0.7441034913063049,
0.33971425890922546,
0.48153388500213623,
0.15208113193511963,
-0.09089896827936172,
-0.1541854292154312,
-0.0012014282401651144,
0.07482811063528061,
0.44312599301338196,
0.23478274047374725,
-0.6199194192886353,
-0.2831648290157318,
-0.041570939123630524,
-0.020576486364006996,
0.27212756872177124,
1.0574182271957397,
-0.5936518311500549,
0.9473515152931213,
0.11267925798892975,
0.8736988306045532,
0.8378425240516663,
-0.02173435688018799,
0.6366015672683716,
-1.0534108877182007,
0.4413522481918335,
0.04772074148058891,
0.3012436032295227,
0.436626136302948,
-0.6507971286773682,
0.6863577365875244,
0.16647815704345703,
-0.7132622003555298,
-0.7316402196884155,
0.11219509690999985,
-1.4137887954711914,
-0.13645821809768677,
0.9055963754653931,
-0.3025703430175781,
-0.13241039216518402,
-0.17829446494579315,
-0.4649949371814728,
0.043684374541044235,
-0.5383769273757935,
0.6473949551582336,
0.5490028858184814,
-0.1544395238161087,
-0.3440428078174591,
-0.8525471687316895,
0.43612056970596313,
0.16241668164730072,
-1.0631216764450073,
0.41541343927383423,
0.47658663988113403,
0.252536416053772,
-0.08963674306869507,
0.7859377264976501,
-0.3189762830734253,
0.33812859654426575,
-0.2783412039279938,
-0.03294726461172104,
-0.005931843537837267,
-0.2795824110507965,
-0.19757887721061707,
-0.40254271030426025,
0.10432329028844833,
-0.07249659299850464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06773v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06773v1
|
Evaluating Zero-Shot Long-Context LLM Compression
| 2024-06-10T20:19:55 | 2024-06-10T20:19:55 |
Chenyu Wang, Yihan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This study evaluates the effectiveness of zero-shot compression techniques on
large language models (LLMs) under long-context. We identify the tendency for
computational errors to increase under long-context when employing certain
compression methods. We propose a hypothesis to explain the varied behavior of
different LLM compression techniques and explore remedies to mitigate the
performance decline observed in some techniques under long-context. This is a
course report for COS 598D Machine Learning and Systems by Prof. Kai Li at
Princeton University. Due to limited computational resources, our experiments
were conducted only on LLaMA-2-7B-32K.
|
[
-0.2080765962600708,
-1.075552225112915,
0.6581354141235352,
0.3202039301395416,
-0.3655458688735962,
-0.022734735161066055,
-0.4843391478061676,
-0.7074246406555176,
0.24045154452323914,
0.4808407723903656,
-0.4193922281265259,
-0.4251282811164856,
-0.5648555755615234,
0.291476309299469,
-0.5099666118621826,
0.748245120048523,
-0.12310991436243057,
0.02110421657562256,
-0.342599093914032,
-0.022354349493980408,
-0.7874945402145386,
-0.714966356754303,
-0.7427788376808167,
-0.2725474536418915,
0.5163631439208984,
0.5129583477973938,
0.37709638476371765,
0.3468017280101776,
0.43970006704330444,
0.18381308019161224,
-0.1325075775384903,
-0.31001994013786316,
-0.7114127278327942,
0.34649357199668884,
0.1125306636095047,
-0.45375847816467285,
-0.4379310607910156,
-0.347105473279953,
0.7909799218177795,
0.47815749049186707,
-0.17276841402053833,
0.3685016632080078,
0.008931816555559635,
0.4289240837097168,
-0.9687607288360596,
-0.049453698098659515,
-0.4614503085613251,
0.14061424136161804,
-0.34727245569229126,
-0.48646414279937744,
-0.6347571611404419,
0.08577528595924377,
-0.11907200515270233,
-0.18488064408302307,
0.10818199068307877,
-0.1528339982032776,
0.48626068234443665,
0.6045060753822327,
-0.38613587617874146,
-0.14826783537864685,
-0.8213615417480469,
1.046231746673584,
-0.7674816846847534,
0.09428045153617859,
0.23821868002414703,
0.231378436088562,
-0.3570863902568817,
-0.19500583410263062,
-0.5503679513931274,
-0.06350209563970566,
0.2874169647693634,
0.02735731191933155,
-0.19323422014713287,
0.2560328245162964,
0.5935819745063782,
0.3590412139892578,
-0.5345842242240906,
0.5874359607696533,
-0.4635864496231079,
-0.14016439020633698,
0.7201440930366516,
0.15463225543498993,
0.2102368026971817,
-0.1786288321018219,
-0.3489988446235657,
-0.05868811532855034,
-1.0762053728103638,
-0.010208634659647942,
0.3563936650753021,
0.1754462867975235,
-0.18477898836135864,
0.6520885825157166,
-0.41108644008636475,
0.9914268851280212,
-0.3109678328037262,
-0.3412446975708008,
0.15286558866500854,
-0.130828395485878,
-0.6739033460617065,
0.3651960492134094,
0.5341203212738037,
0.4497748911380768,
0.13853855431079865,
-0.10761655122041702,
-0.19552960991859436,
-0.002761778188869357,
0.11703964322805405,
-1.0274797677993774,
0.29809537529945374,
0.34140101075172424,
-0.13761593401432037,
-0.3539695739746094,
-0.1856391280889511,
-0.5932683944702148,
-0.14616964757442474,
-0.25574323534965515,
0.47829216718673706,
-0.183199942111969,
0.05366507172584534,
0.46525973081588745,
-0.30751416087150574,
0.32337072491645813,
0.24738869071006775,
-0.5876325964927673,
0.14062221348285675,
0.5887624621391296,
0.9043627381324768,
-0.2108110785484314,
-0.17401082813739777,
-0.3562283515930176,
0.11446203291416168,
-0.2991454601287842,
0.8845614790916443,
-0.21772615611553192,
-0.5726354122161865,
0.19164857268333435,
-0.038195375353097916,
0.07258213311433792,
-0.5067692399024963,
0.8662207722663879,
-0.3790435791015625,
-0.08194585144519806,
-0.07566633820533752,
-0.6653005480766296,
-0.18314780294895172,
0.2389180064201355,
-0.6151689291000366,
1.0182737112045288,
0.20262514054775238,
-0.4730237126350403,
0.1540018767118454,
-0.7365405559539795,
-0.4851859211921692,
0.035925306379795074,
-0.16209955513477325,
-0.3802953064441681,
0.46510034799575806,
-0.0065820347517728806,
0.7638372182846069,
-0.4066007733345032,
0.046567678451538086,
-0.4560502767562866,
-0.9278231859207153,
0.2430669367313385,
-0.49875667691230774,
0.8566398620605469,
0.03219035267829895,
-0.23905374109745026,
-0.20242951810359955,
-0.6883594989776611,
-0.0430244505405426,
0.37997913360595703,
-0.5002808570861816,
-0.20763413608074188,
-0.11988964676856995,
-0.24971190094947815,
0.04077084735035896,
0.15458379685878754,
-0.6919612288475037,
0.4887099266052246,
-0.2913334369659424,
0.31466832756996155,
0.5641560554504395,
0.037816423922777176,
0.19463865458965302,
-0.2457813322544098,
0.6026296615600586,
-0.17100229859352112,
-0.1124279797077179,
-0.2533394694328308,
-0.22891125082969666,
-1.046632170677185,
-0.11674245446920395,
0.10243865847587585,
0.5540643334388733,
-0.7257357835769653,
0.3320449888706207,
-0.4039415121078491,
-0.2806747257709503,
-0.13133785128593445,
0.16945277154445648,
0.31965377926826477,
0.5578785538673401,
0.3504333794116974,
-0.32688108086586,
-0.592512845993042,
-0.8220381140708923,
-0.06784388422966003,
0.10547104477882385,
-0.2469026893377304,
0.46600061655044556,
0.3957172632217407,
-0.30047735571861267,
0.8570107221603394,
-0.5067184567451477,
0.15771736204624176,
-0.11808326840400696,
0.34210580587387085,
0.32943859696388245,
0.25668081641197205,
0.7442609667778015,
-0.11246928572654724,
-0.2710755467414856,
-0.4841943681240082,
-0.6823652386665344,
-0.38696175813674927,
-0.05077401548624039,
0.22578687965869904,
0.7363874912261963,
0.41561681032180786,
-0.653297483921051,
0.7078585028648376,
0.8308067321777344,
-0.17716175317764282,
0.8604243397712708,
-0.09447824209928513,
0.15394654870033264,
-0.8677891492843628,
-0.056411344558000565,
-0.00932698417454958,
-0.19617986679077148,
-0.6683085560798645,
0.0710105448961258,
-0.05655241385102272,
-0.08970421552658081,
-0.7359563112258911,
0.37911441922187805,
-0.4039451479911804,
-0.3477270305156708,
-0.5171481370925903,
-0.06196913123130798,
-0.08317478001117706,
0.33045920729637146,
0.06318532675504684,
0.9302493333816528,
0.5240786075592041,
-0.659834086894989,
0.29413536190986633,
-0.3067815601825714,
-0.42850571870803833,
0.5673338770866394,
-0.8578247427940369,
0.5002046823501587,
-0.30686503648757935,
0.5652313232421875,
-0.8237608671188354,
-0.42284995317459106,
0.11052625626325607,
-0.22738049924373627,
0.5844448804855347,
0.03257380798459053,
-0.5521607398986816,
-0.385871022939682,
-0.6988431215286255,
0.6963094472885132,
0.3926711678504944,
-0.4550727605819702,
-0.0474541150033474,
-0.024770379066467285,
0.06743691861629486,
-0.8060439825057983,
-0.9036151766777039,
0.3737078011035919,
-0.3756197690963745,
-0.6304033994674683,
0.35391759872436523,
-0.48762983083724976,
-0.08927033841609955,
-0.3665371835231781,
-0.019878769293427467,
0.12399608641862869,
0.3045700490474701,
0.3359557092189789,
0.21981139481067657,
-0.264247864484787,
0.12256263941526413,
0.10288473218679428,
0.09285193681716919,
-0.012279190123081207,
-0.08401457965373993,
0.7007020115852356,
-0.035756610333919525,
-0.3344467878341675,
-0.3923937976360321,
0.2576066553592682,
0.4761822521686554,
0.5380174517631531,
0.7198399901390076,
0.27226465940475464,
-0.16514982283115387,
-0.15219512581825256,
-0.6050704717636108,
0.07524293661117554,
-0.43230772018432617,
0.305408775806427,
-0.21896623075008392,
-1.1757515668869019,
0.3856431841850281,
-0.17131109535694122,
-0.31015461683273315,
0.45271503925323486,
0.5883105993270874,
-0.11886385083198547,
0.49031582474708557,
0.894545316696167,
-0.26191237568855286,
0.4049050509929657,
-0.31704992055892944,
0.23325060307979584,
-0.8689190149307251,
0.07803912460803986,
-0.6224307417869568,
-0.3589116930961609,
-0.4040094017982483,
-0.7032695412635803,
0.17521972954273224,
0.5703821182250977,
-0.42834118008613586,
0.42680731415748596,
-0.46498778462409973,
0.760464072227478,
0.16049334406852722,
-0.10747887194156647,
0.048932358622550964,
0.20410671830177307,
0.19568310678005219,
0.42272046208381653,
-0.7591372132301331,
-0.26684534549713135,
1.0767096281051636,
0.5111569166183472,
0.6684846878051758,
0.2494105100631714,
0.7201570868492126,
0.2879456579685211,
0.17002902925014496,
-1.18846595287323,
0.5316296815872192,
0.06566508859395981,
-0.4055629372596741,
-0.43077215552330017,
-0.2286527454853058,
-1.0177348852157593,
-0.19969943165779114,
-0.014623463153839111,
-0.8962886929512024,
-0.026686273515224457,
-0.1090378537774086,
-0.4299162030220032,
0.234029620885849,
-0.4827164113521576,
0.41542118787765503,
-0.2407945841550827,
-0.1210351437330246,
-0.196376234292984,
-0.5644682049751282,
0.47827714681625366,
-0.2692979872226715,
-0.04180651530623436,
-0.08749642223119736,
-0.15251538157463074,
0.7678260207176208,
-0.10552263259887695,
0.8817731142044067,
0.01933462731540203,
-0.2989107668399811,
0.34920966625213623,
0.18942299485206604,
0.29998043179512024,
-0.11538615077733994,
-0.3288635313510895,
0.7664456963539124,
0.022152872756123543,
-0.6398297548294067,
-0.6165214776992798,
0.6516067385673523,
-0.6830154061317444,
-0.5579184293746948,
-0.43295028805732727,
-0.5951581597328186,
0.07557155191898346,
-0.017686055973172188,
0.27595216035842896,
0.2658138871192932,
-0.0842674970626831,
0.5203976035118103,
0.3997901678085327,
-0.47278738021850586,
0.913170337677002,
0.602191150188446,
-0.06888147443532944,
-0.3137272596359253,
0.42194491624832153,
0.28045856952667236,
0.29700952768325806,
0.1328665018081665,
0.16245819628238678,
0.02981770783662796,
-0.6764565706253052,
-0.5721186995506287,
0.12946343421936035,
-0.6756803393363953,
-0.5925664901733398,
0.054659198969602585,
-0.3080027401447296,
-0.45526522397994995,
-0.21254587173461914,
-0.1404372751712799,
-0.5099356174468994,
-0.2783258259296417,
0.0007091580773703754,
0.22333389520645142,
0.7513987421989441,
0.12877078354358673,
0.5797650218009949,
-0.7318513989448547,
-0.05503705516457558,
-0.10470862686634064,
0.3848104178905487,
-0.00439823605120182,
-0.7069512605667114,
-0.3359588384628296,
-0.03790517523884773,
-0.31697824597358704,
-0.8805774450302124,
0.24313969910144806,
0.2469387948513031,
0.24987123906612396,
0.4746495485305786,
0.026374563574790955,
0.8090744018554688,
-0.4543510377407074,
1.2279654741287231,
0.28266268968582153,
-0.8685409426689148,
0.49804922938346863,
-0.307447612285614,
0.5512068867683411,
0.18160010874271393,
0.5054810047149658,
-0.5158289074897766,
-0.03176456317305565,
-0.449398934841156,
-0.7000176310539246,
0.3974885642528534,
0.027928028255701065,
0.2736397087574005,
-0.1467597782611847,
0.8323601484298706,
-0.025234591215848923,
0.03825557976961136,
-0.6451124548912048,
-0.296783983707428,
0.12313343584537506,
-0.02484525367617607,
-0.2830084264278412,
-0.8647693395614624,
-0.030475733801722527,
-0.2087930291891098,
0.45237138867378235,
-0.3334469795227051,
0.4177522659301758,
0.4024101495742798,
-0.1630810797214508,
-0.2648317515850067,
0.43852683901786804,
1.2175904512405396,
0.5882299542427063,
-0.33777153491973877,
0.13629816472530365,
0.48000648617744446,
-0.22438602149486542,
0.10976888239383698,
-0.27656033635139465,
-0.2198827862739563,
-0.11433503031730652,
0.46384209394454956,
0.7449368238449097,
0.24542993307113647,
-0.7098497748374939,
0.4759432077407837,
-0.040123261511325836,
-0.05852798745036125,
-0.40443259477615356,
0.022406727075576782,
-0.04847235605120659,
0.08288760483264923,
0.34625890851020813,
-0.3121435046195984,
0.11629455536603928,
-0.6435818076133728,
-0.13892854750156403,
0.5575481057167053,
-0.11258259415626526,
-0.26046285033226013,
0.04417278990149498,
0.05802411213517189,
-0.4555211067199707,
0.5166486501693726,
-0.02168944478034973,
-0.40659818053245544,
0.4910002648830414,
0.8588569164276123,
0.8205649852752686,
-0.20595809817314148,
-0.21395087242126465,
0.27686917781829834,
-0.0002684704668354243,
-0.03810005635023117,
0.06522976607084274,
-0.337621808052063,
-0.605623185634613,
-1.0658981800079346,
-0.7900798320770264,
-0.45247572660446167,
0.41613489389419556,
-0.4241454005241394,
0.5679298043251038,
-0.2773609161376953,
-0.14614027738571167,
-0.22828945517539978,
0.22762875258922577,
-0.5109686255455017,
0.04518633708357811,
0.3465980589389801,
1.0344816446304321,
-0.6179744601249695,
1.0043801069259644,
0.2795455753803253,
-0.18370677530765533,
-0.6618441343307495,
-0.09283477067947388,
0.020056290552020073,
-0.7383700013160706,
0.8543644547462463,
0.24578700959682465,
-0.421573668718338,
-0.4021106958389282,
-0.7980857491493225,
-0.9428841471672058,
1.2761791944503784,
0.6638577580451965,
-0.7547808289527893,
0.2729867994785309,
0.4895876348018646,
0.5450688600540161,
-0.14834490418434143,
0.19625209271907806,
0.5276574492454529,
0.17615017294883728,
0.21462911367416382,
-1.1407201290130615,
0.0032141569536179304,
0.11525289714336395,
-0.10027877241373062,
0.195314422249794,
-0.6537808775901794,
0.7151581645011902,
0.03909488767385483,
-0.2706857919692993,
0.2632905840873718,
0.5418757796287537,
0.23902739584445953,
0.49634552001953125,
0.31282758712768555,
0.8669544458389282,
0.614450991153717,
0.24176332354545593,
1.1353851556777954,
-0.5717921257019043,
0.6021392941474915,
0.9625013470649719,
-0.2735144793987274,
1.1006969213485718,
0.5325920581817627,
-0.11381275206804276,
0.5994917750358582,
0.507707417011261,
0.1348038613796234,
0.10039038956165314,
0.5346071720123291,
-0.5003564357757568,
0.051655177026987076,
-0.24835456907749176,
-0.29673612117767334,
0.5327593684196472,
0.270038902759552,
-0.036524977535009384,
-0.11454872041940689,
-0.1946912258863449,
0.15452562272548676,
-0.44387391209602356,
-0.24025078117847443,
0.39074742794036865,
0.27590739727020264,
-0.5759978890419006,
0.9490174055099487,
0.11398245394229889,
1.0419652462005615,
-0.2265624850988388,
0.03782554715871811,
-0.1157880425453186,
-0.08928088843822479,
-0.27054545283317566,
-0.7999064922332764,
0.5176284313201904,
0.094850555062294,
-0.1267165094614029,
-0.12865686416625977,
1.0710927248001099,
-0.16916540265083313,
-0.3958613872528076,
0.33888670802116394,
0.15174810588359833,
0.5580573678016663,
-0.04540802910923958,
-0.4157533645629883,
0.4833016097545624,
-0.24175849556922913,
-0.2790360152721405,
0.4235794246196747,
0.10501743108034134,
0.06326261162757874,
0.5496551990509033,
0.5688960552215576,
0.15588560700416565,
-0.10913736373186111,
-0.021835170686244965,
0.7029022574424744,
-0.7584719061851501,
0.04019058868288994,
-1.084215521812439,
0.15797293186187744,
-0.08459648489952087,
0.02661489136517048,
0.8975147008895874,
0.5685126185417175,
0.8877019286155701,
0.006550580263137817,
0.46294161677360535,
0.08864688873291016,
0.21436437964439392,
-0.5875969529151917,
0.5240883827209473,
-0.4951343238353729,
0.3077022433280945,
-0.08932377398014069,
-0.8945030570030212,
-0.6612265706062317,
0.35044288635253906,
-0.18370717763900757,
-0.21396172046661377,
0.5895977020263672,
0.6713609099388123,
0.1326974630355835,
-0.2583528757095337,
0.5367795825004578,
0.16944178938865662,
0.3039337396621704,
0.6850011348724365,
0.8143100142478943,
-0.4644049108028412,
0.2854697108268738,
-0.357871949672699,
-0.047038186341524124,
-0.44165241718292236,
-1.332684874534607,
-0.7553067803382874,
-0.11623065918684006,
-0.2679365277290344,
-0.33192944526672363,
0.04545380920171738,
0.6843592524528503,
0.7226939797401428,
-0.44324925541877747,
-0.37524932622909546,
0.09333045035600662,
0.023667480796575546,
0.23463459312915802,
-0.23176917433738708,
0.32449841499328613,
-0.257181316614151,
-0.6056027412414551,
0.7091727256774902,
0.5247303247451782,
0.18333953619003296,
-0.3782791793346405,
-0.23659257590770721,
0.10360235720872879,
0.34072476625442505,
1.0547950267791748,
0.37855151295661926,
-0.6704736351966858,
-0.5815020203590393,
-0.016201315447688103,
0.13541780412197113,
0.20000751316547394,
0.8780797123908997,
-0.8428075909614563,
0.1955554485321045,
0.6191830039024353,
0.5133094787597656,
0.5255778431892395,
-0.023852059617638588,
0.3389294445514679,
-1.042870044708252,
0.43177804350852966,
0.14273445308208466,
0.42241114377975464,
0.19859790802001953,
-0.5161528587341309,
0.5344539880752563,
0.1933414340019226,
-0.9199666976928711,
-0.9769861102104187,
0.12961453199386597,
-1.287217617034912,
-0.47559818625450134,
1.4015412330627441,
-0.1375834345817566,
-0.4790682792663574,
0.2811330258846283,
-0.15314510464668274,
0.3380873501300812,
-0.21145625412464142,
0.8138995170593262,
0.8747914433479309,
-0.46684178709983826,
-0.16327965259552002,
-0.832465410232544,
0.3000819981098175,
0.3987058401107788,
-0.6182364225387573,
-0.19445158541202545,
0.5393258333206177,
0.418114572763443,
0.22340723872184753,
0.39466094970703125,
0.20316831767559052,
0.14565622806549072,
-0.24369853734970093,
0.05256272852420807,
0.025878669694066048,
-0.3194705843925476,
-0.9262893199920654,
0.09633074700832367,
0.11650078743696213,
0.08536195755004883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06769v1
|
DISCOVERYWORLD: A Virtual Environment for Developing and Evaluating Automated Scientific Discovery Agents
| 2024-06-10T20:08:44 | 2024-06-10T20:08:44 |
Peter Jansen, Marc-Alexandre Côté, Tushar Khot, Erin Bransom, Bhavana Dalvi Mishra, Bodhisattwa Prasad Majumder, Oyvind Tafjord, Peter Clark
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Automated scientific discovery promises to accelerate progress across
scientific domains. However, developing and evaluating an AI agent's capacity
for end-to-end scientific reasoning is challenging as running real-world
experiments is often prohibitively expensive or infeasible. In this work we
introduce DISCOVERYWORLD, the first virtual environment for developing and
benchmarking an agent's ability to perform complete cycles of novel scientific
discovery. DISCOVERYWORLD contains a variety of different challenges, covering
topics as diverse as radioisotope dating, rocket science, and proteomics, to
encourage development of general discovery skills rather than task-specific
solutions. DISCOVERYWORLD itself is an inexpensive, simulated, text-based
environment (with optional 2D visual overlay). It includes 120 different
challenge tasks, spanning eight topics each with three levels of difficulty and
several parametric variations. Each task requires an agent to form hypotheses,
design and run experiments, analyze results, and act on conclusions.
DISCOVERYWORLD further provides three automatic metrics for evaluating
performance, based on (a) task completion, (b) task-relevant actions taken, and
(c) the discovered explanatory knowledge. We find that strong baseline agents,
that perform well in prior published environments, struggle on most
DISCOVERYWORLD tasks, suggesting that DISCOVERYWORLD captures some of the novel
challenges of discovery, and thus that DISCOVERYWORLD may help accelerate
near-term development and assessment of scientific discovery competency in
agents. Code available at: www.github.com/allenai/discoveryworld
|
[
-0.463021844625473,
-0.44811663031578064,
0.7820776700973511,
0.29900994896888733,
0.09371158480644226,
0.3793109953403473,
-0.09031045436859131,
-0.5979047417640686,
-0.009329522959887981,
-0.015433491207659245,
-0.7343088984489441,
-0.40722784399986267,
-0.2847558856010437,
0.5644222497940063,
-0.023641739040613174,
0.7820538282394409,
-0.17727692425251007,
-0.3440245985984802,
-1.0598912239074707,
-0.04715804383158684,
-0.26449763774871826,
-0.10759341716766357,
-0.35364335775375366,
-0.36930176615715027,
0.328546404838562,
0.37315431237220764,
0.5557164549827576,
0.6289118528366089,
0.7732111215591431,
0.38354408740997314,
-0.052541933953762054,
0.5155858993530273,
-0.457527220249176,
0.36548328399658203,
-0.46155354380607605,
-0.2523347735404968,
-0.29255372285842896,
0.24316580593585968,
0.06614349782466888,
0.6086565256118774,
0.19276341795921326,
0.29488903284072876,
-0.5254796147346497,
0.4703448712825775,
-0.5157979130744934,
0.5498483180999756,
0.024495288729667664,
0.41993382573127747,
0.1119539737701416,
-0.2866358160972595,
-0.11830949038267136,
-0.19121919572353363,
0.6410647034645081,
-1.447946548461914,
0.4405287802219391,
0.282604843378067,
0.6599767804145813,
0.3370245099067688,
-0.4269053041934967,
-0.2697518765926361,
-0.8391478657722473,
0.6280725598335266,
-0.010808407329022884,
0.149809330701828,
-0.09250018745660782,
0.6818605661392212,
-0.16917791962623596,
-0.8171759843826294,
-0.6616175770759583,
-0.8213160037994385,
0.3075805604457855,
0.2065412551164627,
-0.044705137610435486,
-0.2365669459104538,
0.3767041862010956,
0.25629550218582153,
-0.8429825305938721,
-0.1998109221458435,
-0.20800475776195526,
-0.21413452923297882,
0.6241411566734314,
0.29422783851623535,
0.11432520300149918,
0.1829099953174591,
-0.15548919141292572,
-0.6060211062431335,
-0.2503678500652313,
0.23399442434310913,
0.10750099271535873,
0.28125208616256714,
0.17892739176750183,
0.6203720569610596,
-0.661119818687439,
0.12318475544452667,
-0.26291683316230774,
-0.053434666246175766,
0.6001961827278137,
-0.5404689908027649,
0.06152229383587837,
-0.13536177575588226,
0.1936817765235901,
0.31850332021713257,
-0.03299234062433243,
-0.23171062767505646,
-0.09775994718074799,
0.2813352048397064,
0.3467988967895508,
-0.8484926819801331,
-0.3182198703289032,
0.35618478059768677,
-0.1460108757019043,
-0.36714500188827515,
0.0668967068195343,
-0.3678898811340332,
-0.6778845191001892,
-0.1103532612323761,
0.7891976833343506,
-0.2322096824645996,
-0.24046878516674042,
0.03050881251692772,
-0.8685359954833984,
0.0031988678965717554,
0.6828863620758057,
0.10583610087633133,
0.4357863962650299,
0.5883495211601257,
0.9878541827201843,
-0.31517288088798523,
-0.4132760465145111,
-0.4880799651145935,
0.058259639889001846,
-0.20014002919197083,
1.150700569152832,
-0.4556763172149658,
-0.44253262877464294,
-0.3433162569999695,
0.08768664300441742,
0.3610893785953522,
-0.780196487903595,
0.42596501111984253,
-0.45594850182533264,
-0.09078402817249298,
-0.5155529379844666,
-0.39593157172203064,
-0.0022005534265190363,
0.5534141659736633,
-0.5827516913414001,
0.8779610395431519,
0.25476008653640747,
-0.563170850276947,
0.6012134552001953,
-0.9067552089691162,
-0.17893487215042114,
0.4648266136646271,
-0.06852416694164276,
-0.2069225311279297,
-0.00969176646322012,
-0.0784435123205185,
-0.22034390270709991,
-0.1575852781534195,
-0.10445775836706161,
-0.19998833537101746,
-0.5325659513473511,
0.03809245675802231,
0.14563019573688507,
0.299749493598938,
0.17969071865081787,
-0.5802359580993652,
0.21673424541950226,
-0.8378007411956787,
0.2667253911495209,
0.38005509972572327,
0.05454397201538086,
-0.4352104663848877,
-0.0002579446299932897,
-0.15604770183563232,
0.16409893333911896,
0.3294391930103302,
-0.8169544339179993,
0.46913933753967285,
-0.06673108786344528,
0.20051448047161102,
0.5951281189918518,
0.07457944750785828,
0.005059195216745138,
-0.6465708613395691,
0.49612703919410706,
-0.0019396175630390644,
0.328933447599411,
-0.2691275179386139,
-0.4783796966075897,
-0.4580555260181427,
-0.16354432702064514,
0.13308337330818176,
0.6579274535179138,
-0.418116956949234,
0.18743246793746948,
-0.32644230127334595,
-0.7560558319091797,
-0.37709590792655945,
-0.07766319811344147,
0.2903953790664673,
0.36654409766197205,
0.49325430393218994,
-0.3931832015514374,
-0.6008052229881287,
-0.7423466444015503,
0.07414165884256363,
-0.10198428481817245,
-0.06285317242145538,
0.7146080136299133,
0.8084133863449097,
-0.5503917336463928,
0.9502901434898376,
-0.2849046289920807,
-0.2721932828426361,
0.10939167439937592,
0.06664781272411346,
0.18067672848701477,
0.2987822890281677,
0.04012449458241463,
-0.8143349885940552,
-0.30911847949028015,
0.5304350852966309,
-1.1877548694610596,
-0.13276198506355286,
-0.027875840663909912,
-0.08705396950244904,
-0.3681533634662628,
0.36931827664375305,
-0.7771642208099365,
0.2804248631000519,
-0.039596207439899445,
-0.5566579699516296,
0.6744697093963623,
-0.5269625186920166,
0.10028418898582458,
0.002536335028707981,
0.4427260756492615,
-0.10423802584409714,
-0.24535958468914032,
-0.369547963142395,
0.3606608510017395,
-0.18834349513053894,
-0.21306979656219482,
-0.26100578904151917,
0.6015334725379944,
-0.4541130065917969,
-0.24567429721355438,
-0.4088970124721527,
0.25300490856170654,
0.13998909294605255,
-0.04694017395377159,
0.015560674481093884,
0.7269358038902283,
0.5238807797431946,
-0.62786465883255,
0.5303294658660889,
0.4373488128185272,
-0.18594706058502197,
0.3929785192012787,
-0.8578963875770569,
0.43891778588294983,
-0.35418403148651123,
0.43062713742256165,
-0.42074838280677795,
-0.057622697204351425,
-0.10616856813430786,
-0.357876718044281,
-0.2597903609275818,
0.30728402733802795,
-0.3051683008670807,
-0.4893077313899994,
-0.3705165684223175,
0.21690146625041962,
0.37099596858024597,
-0.38294556736946106,
0.47421953082084656,
-0.03078029491007328,
0.06938283145427704,
-0.5628710389137268,
-0.05094340443611145,
0.2810195982456207,
0.04959791526198387,
-0.6945897340774536,
0.6559281349182129,
-0.36335477232933044,
-0.6565718054771423,
0.321891725063324,
-0.5481522083282471,
0.447360098361969,
0.2126631736755371,
0.5903435945510864,
-0.12558279931545258,
-0.027831068262457848,
-0.16493885219097137,
-0.09043414145708084,
-0.33247804641723633,
0.2091260850429535,
-0.6020941138267517,
0.1861235350370407,
-0.33462098240852356,
-0.03143755719065666,
-0.1534360647201538,
0.2995554506778717,
0.4941001236438751,
-0.09911925345659256,
0.3809451460838318,
0.36725738644599915,
-0.4651236832141876,
-0.5024740695953369,
-0.2324293702840805,
0.07568803429603577,
-0.4600578248500824,
0.4016769826412201,
-0.5299512147903442,
-0.5196922421455383,
0.47832024097442627,
-0.5384239554405212,
0.17822685837745667,
0.5129885077476501,
0.3085733950138092,
-0.025981977581977844,
1.060172438621521,
0.7407140731811523,
0.5103979706764221,
-0.15606757998466492,
-0.4575348496437073,
0.04021431878209114,
-0.40292122960090637,
-0.7085853815078735,
-0.36580079793930054,
-0.13522708415985107,
-0.3841455578804016,
-0.7369308471679688,
0.7870242595672607,
-0.12812721729278564,
-0.48361626267433167,
0.21141928434371948,
-0.5874983072280884,
0.578000009059906,
0.8319470286369324,
0.005156229250133038,
0.4720126986503601,
-0.22847150266170502,
-0.24277423322200775,
0.03919122368097305,
-0.3238988220691681,
-0.6572206616401672,
0.9388877749443054,
0.11907975375652313,
0.3144998550415039,
-0.061087436974048615,
0.6428160667419434,
0.8805027008056641,
0.26488566398620605,
-0.4921641945838928,
0.49035441875457764,
0.3372914493083954,
-0.4318988025188446,
-0.3007637560367584,
-0.3774168789386749,
-0.8266973495483398,
0.27368906140327454,
-0.17973628640174866,
-0.13458101451396942,
0.06872127950191498,
-0.10279655456542969,
-0.34514930844306946,
-0.23631919920444489,
-0.5499757528305054,
0.961947500705719,
-0.24132490158081055,
-0.3706603944301605,
-0.4121389091014862,
-0.6441164612770081,
-0.161509171128273,
0.047584839165210724,
0.19516542553901672,
-0.10473168641328812,
-0.11458636820316315,
0.4029621183872223,
-0.44956767559051514,
0.35236093401908875,
-0.4710754454135895,
0.37927401065826416,
0.36619001626968384,
0.28909406065940857,
0.6957426071166992,
0.3812662363052368,
0.05043932795524597,
-0.22049583494663239,
0.32494041323661804,
-0.4780905544757843,
-0.5951197147369385,
0.7434906959533691,
-0.9423917531967163,
-0.5923907160758972,
-0.8483800888061523,
-0.6215912699699402,
-0.22430725395679474,
0.29469549655914307,
0.0042352015152573586,
-0.08247454464435577,
-0.5570086240768433,
-0.10322130471467972,
0.6675472855567932,
-0.3166998326778412,
-0.08502940833568573,
0.80799800157547,
-0.13158585131168365,
-0.10874916613101959,
1.1357470750808716,
-0.1677122265100479,
-0.11146074533462524,
0.2803418040275574,
0.19777844846248627,
-0.20820249617099762,
-0.8017099499702454,
-0.2988255023956299,
-0.12659722566604614,
-0.5538395047187805,
-0.13000690937042236,
-0.8765716552734375,
0.04034774750471115,
-0.27342551946640015,
-0.024612080305814743,
-0.3396989703178406,
-0.3172914683818817,
0.057061854749917984,
-0.1483016461133957,
0.012380518019199371,
0.7661126255989075,
-0.3205220401287079,
-0.23290017247200012,
-0.3640500009059906,
0.3800760805606842,
0.3402954936027527,
-0.01678204908967018,
-0.3131367564201355,
-0.07957281172275543,
-0.29992300271987915,
-0.20145003497600555,
-0.4922385513782501,
-0.3582301735877991,
0.3779439628124237,
0.27780821919441223,
0.7015729546546936,
0.22573965787887573,
0.2498590648174286,
0.5447073578834534,
-0.2805350720882416,
0.7274117469787598,
-0.43680092692375183,
-0.7839520573616028,
0.6875962615013123,
-0.07666774094104767,
0.11726265400648117,
0.5222881436347961,
0.3590047061443329,
-0.2603306174278259,
-0.3080955147743225,
-0.6745970249176025,
-0.6631783246994019,
0.28646063804626465,
0.33393198251724243,
-0.2165769636631012,
0.046904753893613815,
0.3756369352340698,
0.44956541061401367,
0.3667151927947998,
-0.44700005650520325,
-0.23723776638507843,
-0.37445855140686035,
0.22139552235603333,
-0.04764747619628906,
0.2966724932193756,
-0.3882950246334076,
-0.21486498415470123,
0.573478102684021,
-0.3212739825248718,
0.2800019681453705,
0.673740565776825,
-0.25998783111572266,
-0.19995810091495514,
-0.18428489565849304,
0.47521793842315674,
0.7318364977836609,
-0.5264155864715576,
0.09605304151773453,
-0.02779543213546276,
-0.4746946096420288,
0.191539466381073,
0.46755746006965637,
-0.17374782264232635,
-0.1729564219713211,
0.5998902320861816,
0.6476179361343384,
-0.48592743277549744,
-1.3629406690597534,
0.45039811730384827,
-0.19261105358600616,
-0.29306307435035706,
-0.5647105574607849,
0.34392687678337097,
-0.1507127583026886,
0.6748875975608826,
0.7486559152603149,
0.30243217945098877,
0.4236098825931549,
-0.7331861853599548,
0.20463666319847107,
0.3277495801448822,
-0.2737724483013153,
-0.3328622281551361,
0.7838940024375916,
0.11647640913724899,
-0.24910873174667358,
0.6686590313911438,
-0.8181665539741516,
-0.40363621711730957,
1.1181010007858276,
0.4148336946964264,
0.58863765001297,
0.18259383738040924,
0.47256436944007874,
0.3176879286766052,
0.3608624041080475,
0.07977119833230972,
0.31790682673454285,
-0.30259817838668823,
-0.47519710659980774,
-0.06635279208421707,
-0.4387616813182831,
-0.8959130048751831,
-0.1552412509918213,
-0.3640141189098358,
0.07345860451459885,
-0.524310290813446,
-0.06751472502946854,
0.2353656142950058,
0.6638694405555725,
-0.9072206020355225,
0.2834782302379608,
0.035307008773088455,
1.1172146797180176,
-0.5995440483093262,
0.21777239441871643,
0.825432300567627,
0.041354868561029434,
0.023768378421664238,
-0.5188202857971191,
0.17779229581356049,
-0.5611270070075989,
0.5979466438293457,
0.5810211300849915,
0.021840672940015793,
-0.21034450829029083,
-0.7258394360542297,
-0.8255990147590637,
1.3232622146606445,
-0.004241458605974913,
-0.4966157376766205,
0.027189748361706734,
-0.2015657275915146,
1.0463294982910156,
-0.5723791122436523,
0.5322425365447998,
0.36282938718795776,
0.7812747359275818,
-0.024273226037621498,
-0.7516395449638367,
0.031525202095508575,
-0.8548286557197571,
-0.32294315099716187,
-0.21041597425937653,
-0.4815504252910614,
0.6962229609489441,
-0.7835649847984314,
-0.26404720544815063,
0.13372166454792023,
0.6961551904678345,
0.6887911558151245,
1.1693809032440186,
0.6488186717033386,
0.5071870684623718,
0.9211466312408447,
-0.05664675310254097,
0.9874642491340637,
-0.007904397323727608,
0.19254747033119202,
0.6282627582550049,
-0.6546952724456787,
0.25670093297958374,
0.18212686479091644,
-0.23026560246944427,
0.527822732925415,
0.6431758403778076,
-0.3592780828475952,
0.7785584926605225,
0.6020138263702393,
-0.3311291038990021,
-0.2876405715942383,
-0.6421707272529602,
-0.43672117590904236,
0.07189421355724335,
0.2399352341890335,
0.11383659392595291,
-0.01791522465646267,
0.2839244306087494,
-0.3945320248603821,
0.10149474442005157,
-0.009944606572389603,
0.4528970718383789,
-0.21484483778476715,
-0.5531471967697144,
0.18348443508148193,
-0.01728760078549385,
0.32781627774238586,
-0.4935694932937622,
-0.36890578269958496,
-0.23104098439216614,
0.27350324392318726,
-0.06552315503358841,
-0.500183641910553,
-0.008198305033147335,
-0.14067912101745605,
-0.25393974781036377,
0.03559992089867592,
0.09021260589361191,
0.12844440340995789,
-0.3187579810619354,
0.2864798903465271,
0.6577631831169128,
0.19775143265724182,
-0.20198236405849457,
-0.4004235565662384,
0.09448974579572678,
-0.23629532754421234,
-0.38397547602653503,
0.27967020869255066,
0.4968922436237335,
-0.24264031648635864,
0.9936696887016296,
0.7666550278663635,
-0.1087782084941864,
-0.04592639580368996,
-0.08922639489173889,
0.7401740550994873,
-0.8130826354026794,
-0.464485228061676,
-0.147597998380661,
0.040962252765893936,
-0.2769933342933655,
-0.41823360323905945,
0.591939389705658,
0.8013541102409363,
0.8065748810768127,
0.013639693148434162,
1.0472030639648438,
-0.3707587420940399,
0.4359018802642822,
0.19921265542507172,
0.09737831354141235,
-0.5262205004692078,
0.10454128682613373,
-0.14468488097190857,
-0.970324695110321,
-0.08838307857513428,
0.5067338943481445,
0.29087650775909424,
0.03402915596961975,
0.5936692953109741,
0.5537155270576477,
0.20383107662200928,
0.07835149765014648,
-0.009412283077836037,
0.31182461977005005,
0.7715933918952942,
0.6700252294540405,
1.0679528713226318,
-0.22534014284610748,
0.47086408734321594,
-0.6342063546180725,
-0.5295549631118774,
0.14660604298114777,
-0.8193310499191284,
-0.7933536767959595,
-0.4136575162410736,
-0.5525766015052795,
-0.3605804741382599,
0.35760101675987244,
0.9330670237541199,
0.6467432379722595,
-0.6268307566642761,
0.03708256036043167,
-0.28302931785583496,
-0.28660067915916443,
-0.8591698408126831,
-0.17170335352420807,
0.31564658880233765,
-0.11865705251693726,
-0.8110688924789429,
0.919768750667572,
0.385756254196167,
-0.039984989911317825,
-0.27821409702301025,
-0.23785006999969482,
0.2875185012817383,
-0.026246847584843636,
0.43024444580078125,
0.6946558356285095,
-0.23376436531543732,
-0.225437194108963,
0.34680700302124023,
-0.004897118080407381,
-0.24782155454158783,
0.6501489281654358,
-1.2153264284133911,
0.681577205657959,
0.30878862738609314,
0.44707974791526794,
0.8188923001289368,
0.05104207247495651,
0.3643542528152466,
-0.30022603273391724,
0.051969435065984726,
0.4827927350997925,
-0.10010167211294174,
0.2608523666858673,
-0.3850190341472626,
0.7074302434921265,
0.5238029360771179,
-0.669427216053009,
-1.1732615232467651,
-0.2731455862522125,
-1.0376638174057007,
-0.1698513925075531,
0.5455449819564819,
-0.04434022307395935,
0.08476480841636658,
-0.12757287919521332,
-0.17157115042209625,
-0.02878466621041298,
-0.18525709211826324,
0.9919800758361816,
0.3315906226634979,
-0.38522446155548096,
0.23304639756679535,
-0.6870826482772827,
0.4879661500453949,
0.2583613991737366,
-0.8151798248291016,
-0.1965382844209671,
0.3936900794506073,
0.13324537873268127,
0.4920765459537506,
0.2696312665939331,
0.19787779450416565,
0.5339292287826538,
0.3136627674102783,
0.03525543212890625,
-0.7527127861976624,
-0.7419284582138062,
0.16710259020328522,
0.260295569896698,
-0.10911320149898529,
0.06177397072315216
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06764v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06764v3
|
$Classi|Q\rangle$ Towards a Translation Framework To Bridge The Classical-Quantum Programming Gap
| 2024-06-10T19:50:16 | 2024-07-01T14:37:09 |
Matteo Esposito, Maryam Tavassoli Sabzevari, Boshuai Ye, Davide Falessi, Arif Ali Khan, Davide Taibi
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.ET, cs.PL
|
Quantum computing, albeit readily available as hardware or emulated on the
cloud, is still far from being available in general regarding complex
programming paradigms and learning curves. This vision paper introduces
$Classi|Q\rangle$, a translation framework idea to bridge Classical and Quantum
Computing by translating high-level programming languages, e.g., Python or C++,
into a low-level language, e.g., Quantum Assembly. Our idea paper serves as a
blueprint for ongoing efforts in quantum software engineering, offering a
roadmap for further $Classi|Q\rangle$ development to meet the diverse needs of
researchers and practitioners. $Classi|Q\rangle$ is designed to empower
researchers and practitioners with no prior quantum experience to harness the
potential of hybrid quantum computation. We also discuss future enhancements to
$Classi|Q\rangle$, including support for additional quantum languages, improved
optimization strategies, and integration with emerging quantum computing
platforms.
|
[
-0.287282258272171,
-0.31492286920547485,
0.4875366985797882,
-0.08610987663269043,
-0.16705258190631866,
0.5858489274978638,
0.07540275901556015,
-0.47246766090393066,
0.21902358531951904,
0.018860602751374245,
-0.23760303854942322,
-0.21470819413661957,
-0.33831122517585754,
-0.22080925107002258,
-0.6436806917190552,
0.5111618638038635,
0.05045124515891075,
0.12849955260753632,
-0.08079139143228531,
0.25371912121772766,
-0.058651071041822433,
-0.3347911238670349,
-0.2724784314632416,
-0.055057160556316376,
0.26728546619415283,
0.361787885427475,
0.8507795929908752,
0.2102126032114029,
0.1771276742219925,
0.12140095233917236,
0.1254311501979828,
-0.20642253756523132,
-0.2551303505897522,
-0.34329602122306824,
0.05485033243894577,
-1.0831530094146729,
-0.6375043988227844,
-0.18123504519462585,
1.160197138786316,
0.8482356667518616,
-0.022392580285668373,
0.2413860559463501,
0.05887783318758011,
1.190643072128296,
-1.1156387329101562,
-0.10043759644031525,
-0.2547397315502167,
0.5622925162315369,
-0.47768303751945496,
-0.12807847559452057,
-0.3945963382720947,
-0.3169711232185364,
-0.3498007357120514,
-0.66376793384552,
-0.06979642808437347,
0.05137732997536659,
0.4119561016559601,
-0.09894471615552902,
-0.5339375734329224,
0.5253907442092896,
-0.7691500782966614,
0.911419689655304,
-0.7512742280960083,
0.7647463083267212,
0.06495282053947449,
0.6348628997802734,
-0.3021344840526581,
-0.6509584188461304,
-0.6175958514213562,
0.2665533423423767,
0.24691225588321686,
0.25795260071754456,
-0.11194609105587006,
0.15109331905841827,
0.1395302712917328,
0.8754333853721619,
-0.6866999268531799,
-0.10280392318964005,
-0.5706771016120911,
0.17871224880218506,
0.5471177101135254,
-0.0676361545920372,
0.5665844678878784,
0.23167435824871063,
-0.07491665333509445,
-0.08274126052856445,
-0.8314769864082336,
0.07501984387636185,
0.23264707624912262,
0.01941535249352455,
-0.3710853159427643,
0.485103577375412,
-0.36362677812576294,
0.9142541885375977,
-0.04022889956831932,
0.16963684558868408,
-0.02081161178648472,
-0.15078948438167572,
-0.11630748212337494,
0.42187294363975525,
0.46800392866134644,
0.19335508346557617,
-0.2596438229084015,
-0.45263758301734924,
-0.23820100724697113,
0.1387159377336502,
0.29458996653556824,
-0.730484664440155,
-0.3930773437023163,
0.4335661828517914,
-0.5587469935417175,
-0.3268272578716278,
0.01727188006043434,
-0.8060117363929749,
-0.13782665133476257,
0.058068156242370605,
0.2083587795495987,
-0.13585449755191803,
-0.44655200839042664,
0.3176857829093933,
-0.5283796787261963,
0.5808046460151672,
0.24497951567173004,
-0.8413299322128296,
0.183378666639328,
0.9250998497009277,
0.6359120607376099,
0.03665691986680031,
-0.12058550119400024,
-0.41659262776374817,
0.4744509756565094,
-0.6235371232032776,
0.393815815448761,
-0.7466065287590027,
-0.5394396185874939,
0.18287214636802673,
-0.29344865679740906,
-0.0589849054813385,
-0.19775281846523285,
0.4591452181339264,
-0.8564658761024475,
0.3036618232727051,
0.23918452858924866,
-0.6232422590255737,
-0.05913166329264641,
0.044618312269449234,
-0.3148359954357147,
0.5685519576072693,
0.36536332964897156,
-0.6981759667396545,
0.10383497178554535,
-0.5626939535140991,
-0.3587034344673157,
0.5892914533615112,
-0.49688583612442017,
-0.2718532681465149,
0.2593497633934021,
-0.18647493422031403,
-0.1657446324825287,
-0.6431083679199219,
0.05135655403137207,
-0.6114955544471741,
-0.6231732964515686,
0.4174453914165497,
0.10039763152599335,
0.7644039988517761,
0.4478137493133545,
-0.22841081023216248,
0.26829400658607483,
-0.8300508260726929,
0.43655166029930115,
-0.2357715517282486,
-0.43694502115249634,
-0.42983055114746094,
0.20427854359149933,
0.19137981534004211,
0.002047355752438307,
0.6687385439872742,
-0.7389192581176758,
0.48478564620018005,
-0.5125763416290283,
0.9536994099617004,
0.41513592004776,
-0.20725096762180328,
0.867820680141449,
-0.3025834262371063,
0.6301931738853455,
-0.1517682820558548,
0.4097025394439697,
0.3437473177909851,
-0.5048278570175171,
-0.8755810856819153,
-0.13649345934391022,
0.333486407995224,
0.5946891903877258,
-0.9365723729133606,
0.3682628571987152,
-0.41423892974853516,
-0.42596346139907837,
-0.7354556918144226,
-0.04614388197660446,
0.37699270248413086,
-0.1647641658782959,
0.28675317764282227,
-0.21651530265808105,
-0.4954192638397217,
-1.0755703449249268,
-0.3313341736793518,
-0.3896660804748535,
-0.009478986263275146,
-0.18216469883918762,
0.10543905943632126,
-0.3517807126045227,
0.542564868927002,
-0.17967402935028076,
0.11486988514661789,
-0.20004041492938995,
-0.20696517825126648,
0.06646714359521866,
1.1394240856170654,
0.09352169930934906,
-1.1317720413208008,
-0.17389924824237823,
0.21299788355827332,
-0.7682048678398132,
0.5098804235458374,
-0.18871866166591644,
-0.9568958282470703,
-0.06672106683254242,
0.37087082862854004,
-0.2775241434574127,
0.203263059258461,
0.5379875302314758,
-0.2550458610057831,
0.3035117983818054,
0.22308161854743958,
0.5288729667663574,
-1.1126707792282104,
0.04812415689229965,
-0.2313224971294403,
-0.14903616905212402,
-0.5115914344787598,
0.7559323906898499,
0.2849264442920685,
-0.5972602963447571,
-0.4689613878726959,
0.23401597142219543,
-0.2005969136953354,
-0.26395362615585327,
-0.06792603433132172,
0.04142846539616585,
-0.2354728877544403,
0.23742040991783142,
0.14217154681682587,
0.8931109309196472,
0.6703827977180481,
-0.6644402742385864,
0.285092294216156,
0.21526272594928741,
0.00038085985579527915,
0.5475643277168274,
-0.4850955605506897,
-0.06048453971743584,
0.6520205140113831,
0.023608297109603882,
-0.4510861039161682,
-0.014087609946727753,
0.183076873421669,
-0.6996851563453674,
0.14389844238758087,
-0.35231417417526245,
-0.5849815607070923,
-0.3839373290538788,
-0.4001871645450592,
0.9927701950073242,
0.818640410900116,
-0.3488907516002655,
0.5216172337532043,
0.38074249029159546,
0.4927310049533844,
-0.08141707628965378,
-0.7007729411125183,
0.30908671021461487,
-0.05124347284436226,
-0.6218942999839783,
0.446885883808136,
0.038043342530727386,
-0.05595133826136589,
0.18009686470031738,
-0.19437409937381744,
-0.48839712142944336,
0.38530272245407104,
0.12664519250392914,
0.30645254254341125,
-0.69249027967453,
-0.20455896854400635,
0.55704265832901,
-0.19554965198040009,
-0.008083168417215347,
-0.8131333589553833,
0.1773311048746109,
-0.47990939021110535,
-0.28839215636253357,
-0.5575433969497681,
0.46512657403945923,
0.7000787854194641,
-0.4341544508934021,
0.3427927792072296,
0.2760040760040283,
-0.4891349673271179,
-0.15945389866828918,
-0.19533725082874298,
-0.04135209321975708,
-0.5137573480606079,
0.17597679793834686,
-0.6574012041091919,
-1.0467530488967896,
-0.15610161423683167,
-0.44396427273750305,
0.09175766259431839,
0.17584800720214844,
0.06768263876438141,
-0.1331295520067215,
1.2073601484298706,
0.9142853617668152,
-0.19377101957798004,
0.6721970438957214,
-0.3917514979839325,
0.48290491104125977,
-1.060109257698059,
0.2889975905418396,
-0.4299233853816986,
-0.3146539032459259,
-0.6465689539909363,
-0.24775783717632294,
0.630092442035675,
0.9225512146949768,
-0.3378582000732422,
0.3672071099281311,
-0.7483020424842834,
0.28041407465934753,
0.8166727423667908,
-0.11986254900693893,
0.3177921772003174,
-0.0910109356045723,
0.32874324917793274,
-0.02239491045475006,
-1.166330337524414,
-0.39379653334617615,
0.8472569584846497,
0.1309565156698227,
0.22340461611747742,
0.3711934983730316,
1.1463310718536377,
0.364132821559906,
-0.297376811504364,
-0.5544359683990479,
0.6184511780738831,
0.0586230531334877,
-0.493656724691391,
-0.3529964089393616,
-0.46589094400405884,
-0.8427841067314148,
0.34702613949775696,
-0.42360249161720276,
-0.4170199930667877,
0.43248775601387024,
0.1091829165816307,
-0.19562265276908875,
0.38599154353141785,
-0.5836840271949768,
1.2655465602874756,
-0.02617805264890194,
-0.4000921845436096,
-0.8276310563087463,
-0.3909883499145508,
0.6402700543403625,
0.1856919378042221,
0.5799093246459961,
0.281194806098938,
-0.04646843299269676,
0.4642930328845978,
-0.4477584660053253,
0.6111106276512146,
0.09909466654062271,
-0.2707843482494354,
0.2861851751804352,
0.5133142471313477,
-0.019132036715745926,
0.18414591252803802,
-0.02706611342728138,
-0.12707403302192688,
0.7690199613571167,
-1.1433169841766357,
-0.7031245827674866,
0.6916926503181458,
-0.8539115786552429,
-0.3029751777648926,
-0.5754238963127136,
-0.2832978665828705,
-0.4556024968624115,
0.1760731190443039,
-0.020642727613449097,
0.2575087249279022,
-0.21408812701702118,
-0.2787260115146637,
0.6828780174255371,
-0.2609684467315674,
0.2461937516927719,
0.6008611917495728,
-0.37681156396865845,
-0.3240121304988861,
1.4876164197921753,
-0.39184871315956116,
0.29853376746177673,
0.8708950877189636,
0.04047282412648201,
0.1407518833875656,
-0.26514750719070435,
-1.2527564764022827,
0.1267259418964386,
-0.3215350806713104,
0.05564773827791214,
-0.01160737220197916,
-0.20195598900318146,
-0.4478249251842499,
-0.6745548844337463,
-0.5464831590652466,
-0.8648088574409485,
-0.016324004158377647,
0.33748263120651245,
0.06663066893815994,
0.3644633889198303,
-0.15467093884944916,
-0.11132146418094635,
-1.2864917516708374,
0.249130517244339,
0.4236651062965393,
0.06101581081748009,
0.21932101249694824,
-0.06373362243175507,
-0.5874536633491516,
0.046285081654787064,
-0.3449232280254364,
-0.6299228072166443,
-0.172681525349617,
0.28836268186569214,
0.219661682844162,
0.26630276441574097,
0.44803372025489807,
0.6796613931655884,
-0.32696837186813354,
0.8893560767173767,
0.6487298011779785,
-1.1907175779342651,
0.9277125000953674,
-0.23350544273853302,
0.31489652395248413,
0.49068981409072876,
0.1631566435098648,
-0.7712664008140564,
-0.8151991963386536,
-0.5938803553581238,
-0.7415003776550293,
0.23887069523334503,
0.15758667886257172,
-0.11149498075246811,
0.2816094160079956,
0.2326825112104416,
-0.28422608971595764,
0.6064468622207642,
-0.7770991921424866,
-0.07898373901844025,
-0.1278105229139328,
-0.08061129599809647,
0.052076321095228195,
-0.026836728677153587,
-0.1957038938999176,
-0.26037707924842834,
0.8736730217933655,
0.12345804274082184,
0.4229092299938202,
-0.06860145181417465,
-0.19706475734710693,
-0.28773239254951477,
0.6659016013145447,
0.17778968811035156,
0.48314768075942993,
0.06657761335372925,
0.3050309717655182,
-0.3212152421474457,
-0.15368779003620148,
0.015284659340977669,
-0.01716732606291771,
-0.5846599340438843,
-0.5214724540710449,
0.23829245567321777,
0.37648728489875793,
0.25282105803489685,
-0.7663719058036804,
0.5189478993415833,
0.2972443401813507,
0.2186029702425003,
-0.4641267955303192,
0.3545818328857422,
-0.09493537247180939,
0.5765882134437561,
0.19151094555854797,
-0.10296696424484253,
0.6783842444419861,
-0.7965946197509766,
-0.04384956881403923,
0.19115348160266876,
-0.5424419641494751,
-0.3569765090942383,
1.0112351179122925,
0.5245816707611084,
-0.2287585586309433,
0.3919413983821869,
-0.6247568130493164,
-0.515400767326355,
0.1809682697057724,
0.5565308928489685,
0.9404627680778503,
0.23121429979801178,
0.14977017045021057,
0.45422691106796265,
0.20053820312023163,
0.14352402091026306,
0.52292400598526,
-0.5029755234718323,
-0.30319398641586304,
-0.30056118965148926,
-0.6475096344947815,
-0.20560084283351898,
-0.5978840589523315,
-0.7341918349266052,
0.047166138887405396,
-0.5331001281738281,
0.1515064537525177,
-0.5203429460525513,
-0.16105708479881287,
0.0422339029610157,
-0.14491137862205505,
0.4141145348548889,
0.7058725357055664,
-0.6516830325126648,
1.2180042266845703,
1.0100281238555908,
-0.5877227783203125,
-0.3654527962207794,
-0.21696896851062775,
-0.21693727374076843,
-0.3944437503814697,
0.5081896185874939,
-0.2934377193450928,
-0.28340205550193787,
0.41943177580833435,
-0.5057341456413269,
-0.5189558863639832,
0.8184415698051453,
0.04346960410475731,
-0.6339382529258728,
-0.28422579169273376,
0.16039927303791046,
0.3305010497570038,
0.04105549305677414,
-0.2845403552055359,
0.3441399931907654,
0.3348231315612793,
-0.3998517394065857,
-0.7674676775932312,
-0.02362765744328499,
-0.5624072551727295,
0.4414912760257721,
0.7351244688034058,
-0.623479962348938,
0.7288623452186584,
0.12311955541372299,
-0.33939462900161743,
0.4459315836429596,
1.0066306591033936,
0.13378261029720306,
0.3452504277229309,
0.14238564670085907,
0.7279793620109558,
0.48020127415657043,
0.16358314454555511,
0.9437925219535828,
-0.8285307288169861,
0.0929424986243248,
0.6247062087059021,
0.04006010293960571,
1.1169418096542358,
0.48490604758262634,
-0.6745721697807312,
0.5102709531784058,
0.45796388387680054,
0.07345663011074066,
0.4312390983104706,
0.26679715514183044,
-0.8675838708877563,
-0.718411922454834,
0.1758263111114502,
-0.6746458411216736,
-0.32929855585098267,
0.2967323660850525,
0.3228754699230194,
0.07577996701002121,
0.1869981586933136,
-0.46586012840270996,
0.2990565001964569,
-0.4826710522174835,
0.4155401289463043,
0.34125497937202454,
-0.1705745905637741,
0.9653303027153015,
0.21833713352680206,
0.720255970954895,
-0.3136145770549774,
-0.21695378422737122,
0.03684646636247635,
0.11153948307037354,
-0.5133508443832397,
-0.2086450308561325,
0.09359578043222427,
-0.35710927844047546,
-0.23467858135700226,
0.08666577190160751,
0.24918672442436218,
-0.3360651433467865,
-0.6632202863693237,
0.11747019737958908,
0.5596784353256226,
0.22745361924171448,
0.09522230923175812,
-0.7175070643424988,
-0.07265470921993256,
0.05740679055452347,
0.5429154634475708,
0.6990280151367188,
0.39452749490737915,
-0.000330973940435797,
0.5263704657554626,
0.46346428990364075,
-0.061937082558870316,
0.3789789080619812,
-0.5359926819801331,
0.7279094457626343,
-0.673843264579773,
-0.721941351890564,
-0.21470332145690918,
0.2725076973438263,
0.2501083314418793,
-0.27120110392570496,
0.7335112690925598,
1.1568571329116821,
1.1253163814544678,
-0.1233002096414566,
0.8431395888328552,
-0.12476459890604019,
0.36294054985046387,
-0.5628734827041626,
0.755132794380188,
-0.7604981660842896,
0.08780495822429657,
-0.19526444375514984,
-0.7029289603233337,
-0.16462171077728271,
0.7086611390113831,
-0.1818961352109909,
-0.5563153624534607,
0.702552855014801,
0.5404902100563049,
-0.16034391522407532,
0.13302959501743317,
0.40274104475975037,
-0.13163205981254578,
0.18104758858680725,
1.1472196578979492,
1.036873459815979,
-0.7441568374633789,
0.2183832973241806,
-0.2503424882888794,
-0.22527562081813812,
-0.16326305270195007,
-0.2740181088447571,
-0.49315008521080017,
-0.6142207980155945,
-0.8917948007583618,
-0.550503671169281,
0.3074478209018707,
0.6035376191139221,
0.6477957963943481,
-0.7446408867835999,
-0.8411320447921753,
-0.5527787208557129,
0.23497793078422546,
-0.49074551463127136,
-0.23206524550914764,
0.14306046068668365,
-0.40997573733329773,
-0.7661648988723755,
0.6039711236953735,
0.24986127018928528,
0.08047406375408173,
-0.236434206366539,
-0.27005627751350403,
0.1650989055633545,
-0.27900323271751404,
0.7036827206611633,
0.9177618026733398,
-0.4120621085166931,
0.19102223217487335,
-0.19059430062770844,
-0.08715810626745224,
0.05757567286491394,
1.0155166387557983,
-0.7599219083786011,
0.2488655000925064,
0.23615635931491852,
0.9445856809616089,
0.4252459704875946,
-0.5197334885597229,
0.7911804914474487,
-0.08418808877468109,
0.38520631194114685,
0.4645121097564697,
-0.030307587236166,
-0.12873271107673645,
-0.17971721291542053,
0.35096022486686707,
0.3776475489139557,
-0.32902929186820984,
-0.9651409387588501,
0.5100991129875183,
-1.0825923681259155,
-0.6409496665000916,
0.7290816903114319,
0.18627651035785675,
-0.4127773344516754,
0.2168348878622055,
0.07451999932527542,
0.21489763259887695,
-0.3578120172023773,
0.5645900964736938,
0.27074435353279114,
-0.1018068790435791,
-0.12588588893413544,
-0.6855927109718323,
0.3932289183139801,
0.5329080820083618,
-0.45083528757095337,
-0.2942337393760681,
0.6364818215370178,
-0.37821823358535767,
0.19417545199394226,
0.539095938205719,
-0.32291489839553833,
0.823530375957489,
0.24184735119342804,
0.5527268052101135,
0.3267070949077606,
0.020125994458794594,
-0.24476708471775055,
0.10235267877578735,
0.5937333703041077,
-0.49520614743232727
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06739v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06739v1
|
Scaling the Vocabulary of Non-autoregressive Models for Efficient Generative Retrieval
| 2024-06-10T19:01:15 | 2024-06-10T19:01:15 |
Ravisri Valluri, Akash Kumar Mohankumar, Kushal Dave, Amit Singh, Jian Jiao, Manik Varma, Gaurav Sinha
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
Generative Retrieval introduces a new approach to Information Retrieval by
reframing it as a constrained generation task, leveraging recent advancements
in Autoregressive (AR) language models. However, AR-based Generative Retrieval
methods suffer from high inference latency and cost compared to traditional
dense retrieval techniques, limiting their practical applicability. This paper
investigates fully Non-autoregressive (NAR) language models as a more efficient
alternative for generative retrieval. While standard NAR models alleviate
latency and cost concerns, they exhibit a significant drop in retrieval
performance (compared to AR models) due to their inability to capture
dependencies between target tokens. To address this, we question the
conventional choice of limiting the target token space to solely words or
sub-words. We propose PIXAR, a novel approach that expands the target
vocabulary of NAR models to include multi-word entities and common phrases (up
to 5 million tokens), thereby reducing token dependencies. PIXAR employs
inference optimization strategies to maintain low inference latency despite the
significantly larger vocabulary. Our results demonstrate that PIXAR achieves a
relative improvement of 31.0% in MRR@10 on MS MARCO and 23.2% in Hits@5 on
Natural Questions compared to standard NAR models with similar latency and
cost. Furthermore, online A/B experiments on a large commercial search engine
show that PIXAR increases ad clicks by 5.08% and revenue by 4.02%.
|
[
-0.45947644114494324,
-0.7941027879714966,
0.10940805822610855,
0.1879424750804901,
-0.06855546683073044,
0.13108885288238525,
-0.19791346788406372,
-0.370408296585083,
0.2690967619419098,
0.3799128830432892,
0.0445072203874588,
-0.03740590438246727,
-0.6664235591888428,
0.017129823565483093,
-0.6193850636482239,
0.8556124567985535,
0.3239745497703552,
-0.32325291633605957,
-0.18821586668491364,
-0.23892152309417725,
-0.1639205366373062,
-0.6614341139793396,
-0.6143652200698853,
-0.14027224481105804,
0.6640870571136475,
0.19569669663906097,
1.2232238054275513,
0.9040448069572449,
0.6683971881866455,
0.22094856202602386,
-0.2743667662143707,
-0.10892212390899658,
-0.5209850072860718,
0.2610454261302948,
-0.33589187264442444,
-0.5215944647789001,
-0.18708324432373047,
-0.28160491585731506,
0.6356823444366455,
0.8041765689849854,
-0.33710259199142456,
-0.04086478054523468,
-0.21382565796375275,
0.7597151398658752,
-1.0600943565368652,
0.04955980181694031,
-0.6287052631378174,
0.15654809772968292,
-0.13495247066020966,
0.06309518963098526,
-0.3133474886417389,
-0.18116912245750427,
0.11259174346923828,
-0.4577326476573944,
0.5395007729530334,
0.037469282746315,
0.7031753659248352,
0.17961516976356506,
-0.3819458782672882,
-0.17830877006053925,
-0.8101047873497009,
0.8379141688346863,
-0.43338876962661743,
0.5772656202316284,
0.25975972414016724,
0.1482865810394287,
0.006112659815698862,
-0.682914137840271,
-0.5481919050216675,
-0.33110952377319336,
0.06673694401979446,
-0.16461044549942017,
-0.758573055267334,
-0.05372506380081177,
0.1604996621608734,
0.6998192071914673,
-0.4602315425872803,
-0.08605428785085678,
-0.2088131308555603,
-0.1540078967809677,
0.4981551468372345,
0.07670522481203079,
0.29239752888679504,
-0.14150774478912354,
-0.4297525882720947,
-0.48693397641181946,
-0.4610380232334137,
-0.3635108768939972,
0.06903515756130219,
0.4082278311252594,
0.2740638554096222,
0.8491164445877075,
-0.11068614572286606,
0.7981296181678772,
0.3449910581111908,
0.25820255279541016,
0.07967843860387802,
-0.5714706778526306,
0.07157043367624283,
-0.21051421761512756,
0.8339380621910095,
0.22759731113910675,
-0.13575968146324158,
-0.34935933351516724,
-0.36084771156311035,
0.02471175789833069,
0.3663611114025116,
-0.8040676712989807,
-0.44398748874664307,
-0.19094491004943848,
-0.42878827452659607,
0.11596160382032394,
-0.02729206532239914,
-1.044453740119934,
-0.14197707176208496,
-0.04237494617700577,
0.6642096042633057,
-0.6121074557304382,
-0.49959471821784973,
0.019890375435352325,
0.04154359921813011,
0.3191429674625397,
0.24489693343639374,
-0.7518121004104614,
0.2590087652206421,
0.35963788628578186,
1.2186336517333984,
-0.25088101625442505,
0.1265871375799179,
-0.719816267490387,
-0.20503117144107819,
-0.7015310525894165,
0.8950238823890686,
-0.698063313961029,
-0.7087366580963135,
-0.44313421845436096,
-0.33933332562446594,
-0.4210960865020752,
-0.5947139263153076,
0.17254050076007843,
-1.0233707427978516,
0.14234402775764465,
-0.019504543393850327,
-0.5599439144134521,
-0.11455971747636795,
0.03282006084918976,
-0.9534398317337036,
0.9858992695808411,
0.08035332709550858,
-0.5255031585693359,
0.2510872483253479,
-0.8194611072540283,
-0.555311381816864,
0.09654971957206726,
-0.00019777152920141816,
-0.37616175413131714,
0.36058539152145386,
0.22266262769699097,
0.03786202892661095,
-0.2816375494003296,
0.2176639586687088,
-0.12216892838478088,
-0.1594332456588745,
-0.007775663863867521,
-0.42372971773147583,
0.15849009156227112,
0.5577787160873413,
-0.33486443758010864,
-0.17502206563949585,
-0.5546066761016846,
0.2653384506702423,
0.0034946021623909473,
-0.4201395511627197,
-0.3824205696582794,
-0.07515466213226318,
0.25007036328315735,
0.2630392014980316,
0.3367096185684204,
-0.46081921458244324,
0.08866336941719055,
-0.5275457501411438,
0.18735045194625854,
0.18768738210201263,
-0.09894117712974548,
0.7781155109405518,
-0.25244230031967163,
0.8038439750671387,
-0.0412466824054718,
0.05506899207830429,
-0.22370967268943787,
-0.3948099613189697,
-0.8675105571746826,
-0.22287972271442413,
0.40093761682510376,
0.10790179669857025,
-0.754967451095581,
0.2605348527431488,
-0.39894604682922363,
-0.6348665356636047,
-0.3322921097278595,
0.006396077573299408,
0.5236574411392212,
0.41841796040534973,
0.47593429684638977,
-0.5927582383155823,
-0.24042777717113495,
-0.7720569968223572,
-0.2800430357456207,
-0.24769867956638336,
-0.004115001298487186,
0.3510311245918274,
0.38433441519737244,
0.09083666652441025,
1.151695966720581,
-0.3361830711364746,
-0.24752524495124817,
-0.34208858013153076,
0.43864601850509644,
0.2120770364999771,
0.2867787480354309,
0.3967559039592743,
-1.1152790784835815,
-0.7720577716827393,
-0.05298231914639473,
-0.20571959018707275,
0.06083020195364952,
-0.09190458059310913,
-0.00918634794652462,
0.1089966744184494,
0.43584421277046204,
-0.6157733798027039,
0.48761317133903503,
0.43865492939949036,
-0.30108538269996643,
0.15498538315296173,
-0.43073832988739014,
-0.05674069747328758,
-0.7612185478210449,
0.35181573033332825,
-0.10699182003736496,
-0.043023619800806046,
-0.6478880047798157,
0.05834838002920151,
0.26216354966163635,
-0.10592269897460938,
-0.3514181673526764,
0.7261528372764587,
-0.8057557344436646,
-0.18176411092281342,
-0.5582383871078491,
0.033927127718925476,
0.2585000991821289,
0.09108991175889969,
0.2158869057893753,
1.2508490085601807,
0.5336900353431702,
-0.9239821434020996,
0.02249152958393097,
0.2800540030002594,
-0.1852300614118576,
0.3803901970386505,
-0.7019687294960022,
0.07517145574092865,
-0.49456313252449036,
0.18129487335681915,
-0.826743483543396,
0.06518721580505371,
-0.08820145577192307,
-0.45700567960739136,
0.2047879993915558,
-0.16699856519699097,
-0.9050511121749878,
0.0216714758425951,
0.10263817012310028,
0.4735566973686218,
0.46271923184394836,
-0.6600762009620667,
0.8105825185775757,
0.3653913736343384,
0.026007283478975296,
-0.4261350929737091,
-0.44456902146339417,
0.37322524189949036,
-0.17656627297401428,
-0.28739669919013977,
0.4204391539096832,
-0.02762107364833355,
-0.1811656951904297,
0.07715907692909241,
-0.06428642570972443,
-0.011224246583878994,
-0.2083536833524704,
-0.17826396226882935,
0.13822057843208313,
-0.4241834580898285,
0.412030965089798,
-0.20294824242591858,
0.002106250263750553,
-0.341767281293869,
-0.2562870383262634,
0.6096291542053223,
-0.221587136387825,
-0.3389724791049957,
0.05722720921039581,
0.5084612965583801,
0.7266265153884888,
-0.5447571873664856,
0.9048610925674438,
0.3878619372844696,
-0.07933186739683151,
0.20965200662612915,
-0.7384696006774902,
-0.12966766953468323,
-0.41108301281929016,
0.4497847557067871,
-0.5123949646949768,
-0.6884585618972778,
0.3621188700199127,
0.04057003930211067,
-0.07343051582574844,
0.7069588303565979,
0.4832255244255066,
0.4204322099685669,
1.155447006225586,
0.7459278702735901,
-0.09128345549106598,
0.6931211948394775,
-0.25484639406204224,
0.18795600533485413,
-0.9156726598739624,
-0.2567886412143707,
-0.3103979825973511,
-0.19686740636825562,
-0.5079588294029236,
-0.9170240163803101,
0.3835601806640625,
0.1923777163028717,
-0.15418531000614166,
0.4547678530216217,
-0.5503420233726501,
0.43726789951324463,
0.6088314652442932,
-0.13655276596546173,
0.41566580533981323,
0.2299061417579651,
-0.23230767250061035,
-0.0022817410062998533,
-0.9867452383041382,
-0.17070738971233368,
1.0153566598892212,
-0.04513610526919365,
0.9015871286392212,
0.5210090279579163,
0.2678963541984558,
0.06553176790475845,
0.31813618540763855,
-0.749109148979187,
0.3282610774040222,
-0.34068384766578674,
-0.9043301343917847,
-0.26035019755363464,
-0.5111160278320312,
-1.28328275680542,
0.5877830386161804,
-0.17458832263946533,
-0.4783274233341217,
0.6515424251556396,
0.050213586539030075,
-0.42012259364128113,
0.5568350553512573,
-0.6900520324707031,
0.515383780002594,
-0.36988377571105957,
-0.5651973485946655,
-0.12804143130779266,
-0.6774399876594543,
-0.09314794838428497,
-0.2532828152179718,
0.13803188502788544,
0.00919329933822155,
-0.4312024712562561,
0.5779777765274048,
-0.4623214304447174,
0.6621944308280945,
-0.02362239733338356,
0.11961721628904343,
0.3077629804611206,
0.18121401965618134,
0.47683778405189514,
-0.2947883605957031,
-0.3616533577442169,
0.04829569533467293,
-0.14916647970676422,
-0.4432563781738281,
-0.723673939704895,
0.6208332777023315,
-0.611560046672821,
-0.37831753492355347,
-0.6352170705795288,
-0.5939897298812866,
-0.1561679095029831,
0.3342225253582001,
0.38183921575546265,
0.1554885357618332,
-0.23251540958881378,
0.48131638765335083,
0.7779029011726379,
-0.22222287952899933,
0.5568094849586487,
0.5961045622825623,
-0.20510154962539673,
-0.41730841994285583,
0.7787919640541077,
0.09869123250246048,
0.5312309265136719,
0.6889103055000305,
0.11788284033536911,
-0.763693630695343,
-0.32886314392089844,
-0.4336780607700348,
0.38471975922584534,
-0.3470363914966583,
-0.18617719411849976,
-1.0718610286712646,
-0.17423845827579498,
-0.2832925021648407,
0.1580996960401535,
-0.6353319883346558,
-0.5105517506599426,
-0.5398954153060913,
0.17888858914375305,
0.6547130942344666,
0.4556425213813782,
-0.39840567111968994,
0.3503764271736145,
-0.5935409069061279,
0.21120330691337585,
0.07417242228984833,
0.49528801441192627,
0.3371606171131134,
-0.6536151170730591,
-0.28843361139297485,
-0.21034550666809082,
-0.22873103618621826,
-0.5344461798667908,
0.7462578415870667,
0.6008641123771667,
0.3899082541465759,
0.38676249980926514,
0.2880334258079529,
0.9328070878982544,
-0.5243510603904724,
0.5111221671104431,
0.49190792441368103,
-0.5707846879959106,
0.511724591255188,
-0.14332658052444458,
0.48449698090553284,
0.5108758807182312,
0.27879855036735535,
-0.5187746286392212,
-0.16911986470222473,
-0.6487674713134766,
-1.1397795677185059,
0.2937687337398529,
0.3390076458454132,
0.6183245182037354,
-0.48259562253952026,
0.3719252943992615,
-0.09192021936178207,
0.22755537927150726,
-0.3603052794933319,
-0.214812234044075,
-0.3489193916320801,
0.08851169049739838,
-0.400673508644104,
-0.23808513581752777,
0.34387364983558655,
-0.0037562530487775803,
0.3507882356643677,
-0.08851933479309082,
0.4013230502605438,
0.3817358911037445,
-0.12827135622501373,
-0.10642807185649872,
0.29723548889160156,
0.12357562780380249,
0.40011852979660034,
0.045591626316308975,
0.06556166708469391,
-0.1943756639957428,
-0.5345795154571533,
0.11747328191995621,
0.18574301898479462,
-0.09790533781051636,
0.2313358038663864,
-0.0005899494281038642,
0.7198478579521179,
0.16752609610557556,
-0.7305928468704224,
0.50924152135849,
-0.05419106408953667,
0.013801087625324726,
-0.35837364196777344,
0.10949036478996277,
-0.09467170387506485,
0.2097596675157547,
0.598142147064209,
-0.004956286866217852,
0.19979903101921082,
-0.29158005118370056,
0.5108128786087036,
0.6533988118171692,
-0.43638595938682556,
-0.1372264325618744,
1.0540896654129028,
-0.17774564027786255,
-0.24615724384784698,
0.819796085357666,
-0.023289887234568596,
-0.10908269882202148,
0.5491464138031006,
0.58792644739151,
0.6158614158630371,
-0.22987039387226105,
0.13086378574371338,
0.4427540898323059,
0.16455532610416412,
-0.3504623770713806,
0.1892087310552597,
-0.18689480423927307,
-0.6994150280952454,
-0.4045162498950958,
-0.6500884890556335,
-0.3985162079334259,
-0.015430665574967861,
-0.7962080836296082,
-0.1226106658577919,
-0.41645240783691406,
-0.5867627859115601,
-0.11959607154130936,
-0.12047619372606277,
-0.37034761905670166,
0.2420136034488678,
-0.18342061340808868,
0.7812924981117249,
-0.40485304594039917,
0.6475858688354492,
0.676655113697052,
-0.6280915141105652,
-0.5842126607894897,
0.12501512467861176,
-0.28634190559387207,
-0.6368064284324646,
0.8998593688011169,
-0.08117922395467758,
-0.2029697149991989,
0.2715531885623932,
-0.20769008994102478,
-1.4824408292770386,
0.7913382649421692,
0.21487648785114288,
-0.614121675491333,
-0.2272939532995224,
-0.028322819620370865,
0.7600728273391724,
-0.2632981538772583,
0.2939869463443756,
0.0034431111998856068,
0.24244265258312225,
0.5005410313606262,
-0.9280349016189575,
-0.1739608496427536,
-0.45528849959373474,
0.4786769151687622,
0.5385361313819885,
-0.7246069312095642,
0.992090106010437,
-0.3765198290348053,
-0.37618201971054077,
0.31844642758369446,
0.8256169557571411,
0.1796588897705078,
0.10982955247163773,
0.6242855191230774,
0.5402247905731201,
0.5245603322982788,
0.25383663177490234,
1.2000283002853394,
-0.5719796419143677,
0.4700901210308075,
0.9757074117660522,
-0.04365420714020729,
1.0535589456558228,
0.5631425976753235,
-0.1283620148897171,
0.41774994134902954,
0.46773064136505127,
-0.09424103051424026,
0.5949491858482361,
0.17116384208202362,
-0.549027681350708,
-0.37621352076530457,
-0.3061041533946991,
-0.2466275990009308,
0.37520116567611694,
0.4263364374637604,
-0.49127933382987976,
-0.43898072838783264,
0.1280997395515442,
0.024033676832914352,
0.01055014505982399,
-0.23701211810112,
0.6997296810150146,
-0.03380953148007393,
-0.6485963463783264,
0.6187760233879089,
0.0003753845230676234,
0.6031392812728882,
-0.35371479392051697,
0.09609214961528778,
-0.43583282828330994,
0.22761742770671844,
0.04793767258524895,
-0.25019413232803345,
0.39891108870506287,
0.1035187691450119,
-0.28262415528297424,
-0.08428855985403061,
0.45986899733543396,
-0.3134615421295166,
-0.8634024858474731,
0.35428929328918457,
0.6520598530769348,
0.1733294576406479,
-0.2434084117412567,
-0.7382304072380066,
-0.2670551836490631,
-0.3047846853733063,
-0.14208786189556122,
0.531306266784668,
0.4405238926410675,
-0.06511034816503525,
0.7673046588897705,
0.7069016098976135,
0.18160004913806915,
0.3887942433357239,
-0.11591760814189911,
0.7946380376815796,
-0.6778122186660767,
-0.44078195095062256,
-0.5369408130645752,
0.0967792272567749,
0.09021959453821182,
0.04519668221473694,
0.7935211658477783,
0.8473280072212219,
0.6369563937187195,
0.1904851645231247,
0.6014120578765869,
-0.2094622105360031,
0.6207795739173889,
-0.2256326824426651,
0.6630803942680359,
-0.7864554524421692,
0.2854514718055725,
-0.07859060168266296,
-0.8405593633651733,
-0.5479263663291931,
0.7730026245117188,
-0.4067520201206207,
0.2795352637767792,
0.3195180594921112,
0.8428032994270325,
-0.1678222268819809,
-0.2868537902832031,
0.43814852833747864,
0.19003841280937195,
0.10049519687891006,
0.3085915148258209,
0.7021930813789368,
-0.39720290899276733,
0.9112705588340759,
-0.18077169358730316,
-0.22681674361228943,
-0.2641220688819885,
-0.6420939564704895,
-0.48680809140205383,
-0.4086221158504486,
-0.47633296251296997,
-0.21399171650409698,
0.09817288815975189,
0.5685591101646423,
0.7262321710586548,
-0.5590330958366394,
-0.25200146436691284,
-0.3197764456272125,
-0.11498034000396729,
-0.16281074285507202,
-0.30867400765419006,
0.417841374874115,
-0.507794201374054,
-0.7433085441589355,
0.3916834890842438,
0.1880212277173996,
0.051859427243471146,
-0.14893515408039093,
0.2497386634349823,
-0.3426320552825928,
0.1455421894788742,
0.5891956090927124,
0.5470771193504333,
-0.5969362258911133,
0.022648366168141365,
0.479092001914978,
0.05707424879074097,
0.31833401322364807,
0.7121309041976929,
-0.9694321751594543,
0.7951492667198181,
0.30462127923965454,
0.6083536744117737,
0.6923214197158813,
0.20738078653812408,
0.6601717472076416,
-0.41073864698410034,
-0.2224472165107727,
0.35735827684402466,
-0.04296661168336868,
0.42464330792427063,
-0.4156603217124939,
0.3006768524646759,
0.046162329614162445,
-0.3404882550239563,
-0.41253575682640076,
0.2800710201263428,
-0.39655542373657227,
-0.26995012164115906,
1.047845482826233,
0.04728804528713226,
-0.0819794237613678,
-0.12850967049598694,
0.30379101634025574,
0.07344647496938705,
-0.5379085540771484,
0.7539057731628418,
0.3718363046646118,
-0.59966641664505,
-0.45171278715133667,
-0.3838878571987152,
0.03092421218752861,
0.6006618738174438,
-0.19117403030395508,
-0.03299225866794586,
0.5603926777839661,
0.2560584843158722,
0.37116122245788574,
0.7295289635658264,
-0.4851011037826538,
0.08154457062482834,
0.03674541413784027,
0.08384744077920914,
0.26477715373039246,
-0.09527572244405746,
-0.4440252482891083,
0.3584481477737427,
0.18736661970615387,
-0.2197251170873642
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06737v1
|
Raccoon: Prompt Extraction Benchmark of LLM-Integrated Applications
| 2024-06-10T18:57:22 | 2024-06-10T18:57:22 |
Junlin Wang, Tianyi Yang, Roy Xie, Bhuwan Dhingra
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL
|
With the proliferation of LLM-integrated applications such as GPT-s, millions
are deployed, offering valuable services through proprietary instruction
prompts. These systems, however, are prone to prompt extraction attacks through
meticulously designed queries. To help mitigate this problem, we introduce the
Raccoon benchmark which comprehensively evaluates a model's susceptibility to
prompt extraction attacks. Our novel evaluation method assesses models under
both defenseless and defended scenarios, employing a dual approach to evaluate
the effectiveness of existing defenses and the resilience of the models. The
benchmark encompasses 14 categories of prompt extraction attacks, with
additional compounded attacks that closely mimic the strategies of potential
attackers, alongside a diverse collection of defense templates. This array is,
to our knowledge, the most extensive compilation of prompt theft attacks and
defense mechanisms to date. Our findings highlight universal susceptibility to
prompt theft in the absence of defenses, with OpenAI models demonstrating
notable resilience when protected. This paper aims to establish a more
systematic benchmark for assessing LLM robustness against prompt extraction
attacks, offering insights into their causes and potential countermeasures.
Resources of Raccoon are publicly available at
https://github.com/M0gician/RaccoonBench.
|
[
-0.34940996766090393,
-1.069101095199585,
0.27006465196609497,
0.039636630564928055,
-0.12284282594919205,
0.19224649667739868,
-0.10119517892599106,
-0.6673831343650818,
-0.22723573446273804,
0.32313403487205505,
-0.7736659646034241,
-0.29927030205726624,
-0.6709623336791992,
0.6692957878112793,
-0.1624174267053604,
0.9431671500205994,
0.31833595037460327,
-0.15206877887248993,
-0.06116316467523575,
-0.22835016250610352,
-0.9017020463943481,
-0.2094414085149765,
-0.3410455882549286,
0.05787162482738495,
0.559745728969574,
0.1830812394618988,
0.5062987804412842,
0.44358211755752563,
0.7105839252471924,
0.24020393192768097,
0.011926294304430485,
-0.10571158677339554,
0.030874334275722504,
0.6215180158615112,
-0.2120678573846817,
-0.0809406042098999,
-0.24104773998260498,
0.07839635759592056,
0.15630848705768585,
-0.09290150552988052,
-0.14277225732803345,
0.14206646382808685,
0.13468685746192932,
0.42026907205581665,
-0.9248570203781128,
-0.014699174091219902,
-0.7217267155647278,
0.08789416402578354,
-0.44984856247901917,
-0.35565170645713806,
-0.4884382486343384,
-0.6751488447189331,
0.08255959302186966,
-0.584558367729187,
0.11964389681816101,
-0.17334091663360596,
0.7698068022727966,
0.2583047151565552,
-0.19672630727291107,
-0.6264124512672424,
-0.44575589895248413,
0.6254052519798279,
-0.3585871458053589,
-0.05126325041055679,
0.36213505268096924,
0.8195144534111023,
-0.2793480157852173,
-0.7410169243812561,
-0.19009457528591156,
-0.6085389852523804,
0.0723307654261589,
0.34170547127723694,
-0.8756973147392273,
-0.035994838923215866,
0.6730493903160095,
0.4192962646484375,
-0.7563357949256897,
0.21453425288200378,
-0.20143833756446838,
-0.01081535778939724,
0.457075297832489,
0.27790355682373047,
0.7850313782691956,
-0.2082517147064209,
-0.610877513885498,
-0.018296923488378525,
-0.9100998044013977,
0.2255021631717682,
0.32032525539398193,
0.15922823548316956,
-0.04357749968767166,
0.7154379487037659,
-0.1862441599369049,
0.5491223335266113,
-0.250179260969162,
0.015739716589450836,
-0.12954074144363403,
-0.4371333718299866,
-0.1288783699274063,
-0.03958667069673538,
0.8295542597770691,
-0.03990587219595909,
0.1292194426059723,
-0.33980050683021545,
-0.6339631676673889,
-0.1800086945295334,
0.4399455785751343,
-0.8327261209487915,
-0.28102463483810425,
0.04176906868815422,
-0.42870819568634033,
-0.5617161989212036,
0.23178447782993317,
-1.152884840965271,
-0.45666518807411194,
0.5192917585372925,
0.02731035277247429,
-0.37656503915786743,
-0.26015591621398926,
-0.05315509811043739,
0.11821287870407104,
0.5569534301757812,
0.22548384964466095,
-0.6648524403572083,
0.2725779712200165,
0.9880638122558594,
1.1701384782791138,
-0.7192959785461426,
0.166059672832489,
-1.0541642904281616,
-0.03916601464152336,
0.04576540365815163,
1.0761983394622803,
-0.5717971920967102,
-0.7200560569763184,
-0.03040594793856144,
0.03965529054403305,
-0.13310569524765015,
-0.89476078748703,
0.9227244853973389,
-0.7361814975738525,
-0.33120274543762207,
-0.5114319920539856,
-0.24973581731319427,
-0.13684557378292084,
0.39806610345840454,
-0.92062908411026,
0.9670589566230774,
-0.0424489863216877,
-1.0127381086349487,
0.14237961173057556,
-0.43015021085739136,
-0.4336993098258972,
0.4659159779548645,
-0.4025097191333771,
-0.25314679741859436,
0.10070104151964188,
0.5870453119277954,
0.24470998346805573,
-0.7546272277832031,
0.006952442694455385,
-0.6146591901779175,
-0.21337538957595825,
0.4234740436077118,
-0.5174091458320618,
1.12543523311615,
0.580511212348938,
0.0005150240031071007,
-0.017473233863711357,
-0.6314193606376648,
-0.1106785237789154,
0.4834010899066925,
-0.185249462723732,
-0.41969749331474304,
-0.37842652201652527,
-0.4212867021560669,
0.00536862388253212,
0.24842673540115356,
-0.5377064943313599,
0.5451949834823608,
-0.10394556820392609,
0.3522070050239563,
0.796683132648468,
0.3788628876209259,
0.21195591986179352,
-0.15192212164402008,
1.0624653100967407,
-0.21853584051132202,
0.138499915599823,
-0.3350808918476105,
-0.2317921370267868,
0.03098095953464508,
-0.9160812497138977,
-0.192839115858078,
0.9589887261390686,
-0.7565172910690308,
0.38621261715888977,
-0.16481268405914307,
-0.44937998056411743,
0.0455053336918354,
-0.06559455394744873,
0.2307288497686386,
0.4396573305130005,
0.10492223501205444,
-0.016224868595600128,
-0.2175171971321106,
-0.6870197653770447,
-0.4171839952468872,
-0.03807729482650757,
-0.00819434318691492,
0.20639663934707642,
0.2939820885658264,
-0.07772080600261688,
1.1610832214355469,
-0.4740673303604126,
0.21539227664470673,
-0.4061276912689209,
0.19113479554653168,
0.48786377906799316,
0.41081222891807556,
0.5959176421165466,
-0.4827362895011902,
-0.02989364042878151,
0.036056287586688995,
-1.212626338005066,
-0.4178549349308014,
-0.03656615689396858,
0.2459227740764618,
-0.15836776793003082,
0.15881939232349396,
-1.111860990524292,
0.6523179411888123,
0.05652712285518646,
0.08355248719453812,
0.8911302089691162,
-0.19903664290905,
0.004890503827482462,
-0.8079355359077454,
0.06599746644496918,
0.1745455265045166,
0.21727120876312256,
-0.34226083755493164,
0.14603662490844727,
0.1341804563999176,
-0.3642028570175171,
-0.2846410572528839,
0.2999771535396576,
-0.4476964473724365,
-0.6111496090888977,
0.04129974544048309,
-0.19522015750408173,
-0.009273321367800236,
-0.13606318831443787,
-0.31340429186820984,
1.451157569885254,
0.45795395970344543,
-0.41316115856170654,
0.4544042944908142,
0.019352000206708908,
-0.6177186965942383,
0.38066256046295166,
-1.147321343421936,
0.49100208282470703,
0.29543861746788025,
0.028251037001609802,
-0.8712710738182068,
-0.014030726626515388,
0.6494815945625305,
-0.18314197659492493,
0.43779855966567993,
-0.2559892237186432,
-0.3775644302368164,
-0.12644366919994354,
-0.3547268509864807,
0.4432261288166046,
0.3009609282016754,
-0.8183921575546265,
0.5915862917900085,
-0.07016177475452423,
-0.5808917880058289,
-0.8917738795280457,
-0.21895335614681244,
0.16022075712680817,
-0.5334436297416687,
-0.6137533783912659,
-0.14928308129310608,
-0.17109642922878265,
-0.43473145365715027,
-0.15380267798900604,
-0.23889705538749695,
-0.05404619500041008,
0.6081165075302124,
0.37400856614112854,
0.5563259720802307,
-0.10487618297338486,
-0.5483124256134033,
-0.14911238849163055,
-0.43914321064949036,
0.23085777461528778,
0.24578224122524261,
0.2594847083091736,
0.024583347141742706,
-0.6102131009101868,
-0.4932270646095276,
0.41568416357040405,
0.6186856031417847,
-0.5158474445343018,
0.06479538977146149,
0.30479079484939575,
-0.2624177932739258,
-0.015447626821696758,
-0.40872490406036377,
-0.2869035303592682,
-0.48356688022613525,
0.5381534099578857,
-0.6578575372695923,
-0.4797433912754059,
0.617095947265625,
-0.010777754709124565,
0.2250874638557434,
0.14007191359996796,
0.03625139221549034,
0.2960721552371979,
0.737133800983429,
0.1950223743915558,
-0.21578453481197357,
0.4243954122066498,
0.07826820760965347,
0.05982017517089844,
-0.5425025224685669,
-0.26207488775253296,
-0.8550330400466919,
0.3664686977863312,
-0.3078290820121765,
0.22747108340263367,
0.33803942799568176,
0.3188932240009308,
0.08849555253982544,
0.566562831401825,
-0.4695766866207123,
0.4268895089626312,
0.2936292290687561,
-0.07209938019514084,
0.2749308943748474,
-0.08153394609689713,
0.07694149762392044,
-0.18123328685760498,
-0.31920841336250305,
-0.7282044887542725,
0.863407552242279,
0.2418096661567688,
0.8603218793869019,
0.15934723615646362,
0.6113097667694092,
0.7575771808624268,
0.29368075728416443,
-0.6137887239456177,
0.6297062039375305,
0.12644366919994354,
-0.24629811942577362,
0.14969535171985626,
-0.47071608901023865,
-0.8554264903068542,
0.1985182911157608,
-0.2984069287776947,
-0.9334847331047058,
0.024145184084773064,
-0.5501805543899536,
-0.843968391418457,
0.19070619344711304,
-0.4723831117153168,
0.7284507751464844,
-0.25025835633277893,
-0.3364310562610626,
-0.07420524209737778,
-0.18335404992103577,
0.6868361830711365,
-0.13116946816444397,
-0.12129512429237366,
-0.38019728660583496,
0.018218088895082474,
0.5680429339408875,
-0.27428102493286133,
0.39292672276496887,
-0.14166027307510376,
0.015300162136554718,
0.35765135288238525,
0.47157201170921326,
0.8304449915885925,
0.4582057297229767,
0.03214044123888016,
0.3307417035102844,
0.004499071277678013,
-0.08241725713014603,
-0.5574877858161926,
0.3971136510372162,
-0.7006700038909912,
-0.5110610723495483,
-0.6315052509307861,
-0.5031834840774536,
0.17397256195545197,
0.029732102528214455,
0.4320051670074463,
0.5293481945991516,
-0.2882588505744934,
-0.005684530362486839,
0.6162790060043335,
-0.6312920451164246,
0.8535560369491577,
0.5595713257789612,
0.28568845987319946,
-0.7882707715034485,
0.7207175493240356,
0.14025163650512695,
-0.04904722049832344,
0.04468511790037155,
0.22424016892910004,
-0.09859020262956619,
-0.6772473454475403,
-0.2958449721336365,
-0.1799512654542923,
-0.6952463984489441,
-0.6184167265892029,
-0.773915708065033,
-0.20310549437999725,
-0.2839209735393524,
-0.04302915558218956,
-0.17928241193294525,
-0.23595081269741058,
-0.349578857421875,
-0.2317858636379242,
0.3830251395702362,
0.9711369872093201,
-0.03858667612075806,
0.18069399893283844,
-0.8921417593955994,
0.12408306449651718,
0.4864567220211029,
-0.4049634635448456,
0.05771554261445999,
-0.4847673773765564,
0.1535373330116272,
-0.45630529522895813,
-0.4748094081878662,
-0.9239935278892517,
0.4069408178329468,
-0.24822548031806946,
0.6602282524108887,
0.665639340877533,
0.4005831182003021,
0.43129831552505493,
-0.19284170866012573,
0.7205332517623901,
0.1720489263534546,
-0.526465654373169,
0.5863186717033386,
-0.2829146385192871,
0.15837432444095612,
0.5079516768455505,
0.200575590133667,
-0.02962774969637394,
0.022845761850476265,
-0.31326478719711304,
-0.7510999441146851,
0.6448688507080078,
0.0008294658618979156,
-0.3994804620742798,
-0.22976545989513397,
0.5123931169509888,
0.5144334435462952,
-0.31836429238319397,
-0.5799918174743652,
-0.019788311794400215,
-0.05036328732967377,
0.03286916762590408,
0.3343505859375,
-0.6538737416267395,
-0.1615123748779297,
0.06844072788953781,
0.31286075711250305,
0.28038257360458374,
0.026902999728918076,
0.0853571966290474,
-0.3882578909397125,
0.24646352231502533,
0.239174485206604,
0.5238968133926392,
0.4674452245235443,
-0.36760321259498596,
0.22147850692272186,
0.21437585353851318,
-0.7992736101150513,
0.045767541974782944,
0.2072049230337143,
-0.33103057742118835,
-0.2944662570953369,
0.8834860920906067,
0.0795508399605751,
0.035544637590646744,
-0.5214524269104004,
0.6100553870201111,
-0.5287951231002808,
0.3400011956691742,
-0.28498077392578125,
0.15194325149059296,
-0.6164520978927612,
0.42580509185791016,
0.6060312390327454,
0.1233333870768547,
0.06465038657188416,
0.04437112808227539,
0.5024939775466919,
0.6036551594734192,
-0.26140061020851135,
-0.6224156618118286,
0.36488857865333557,
0.04175964370369911,
-0.2021203488111496,
0.6735884547233582,
-0.06395535171031952,
-0.16163313388824463,
0.7609396576881409,
0.6237966418266296,
1.5457805395126343,
-0.18742837011814117,
-0.17070291936397552,
0.6160897612571716,
0.6784878373146057,
0.021734468638896942,
-0.11509694904088974,
-0.5030932426452637,
-0.5585541129112244,
0.06252709031105042,
-0.1419542133808136,
-0.24422527849674225,
-0.09927736222743988,
-1.1456676721572876,
0.11896220594644547,
-0.7870506048202515,
-0.18399901688098907,
-0.2016908973455429,
0.1274767518043518,
-0.34883183240890503,
-0.4547872841358185,
-0.23688533902168274,
1.0467067956924438,
-0.9297879338264465,
0.8229010701179504,
0.4031938314437866,
-0.6171149611473083,
-0.3896135687828064,
-0.014773393049836159,
0.16511346399784088,
-0.8571394085884094,
0.7288980484008789,
0.5401018261909485,
-0.09395314007997513,
-0.5154984593391418,
-0.6511123776435852,
-0.5761044025421143,
1.1805354356765747,
0.5377389788627625,
-0.4434082806110382,
0.3437761664390564,
-0.14711587131023407,
-0.36886563897132874,
-0.3189094364643097,
0.6482599973678589,
0.8320978879928589,
0.3615400791168213,
0.037826057523489,
-0.2636709213256836,
0.3169393241405487,
-0.13341672718524933,
0.010713143274188042,
-0.28338009119033813,
-0.16172237694263458,
0.8122484087944031,
-0.2594703137874603,
-0.7443611025810242,
0.4615412950515747,
0.6802763938903809,
0.46638739109039307,
0.377196729183197,
0.42162400484085083,
0.670113205909729,
0.6352424621582031,
-0.2524966597557068,
0.8932203054428101,
-0.20114272832870483,
0.021167973056435585,
1.128766417503357,
-0.5990855693817139,
0.5755910277366638,
0.31172168254852295,
-0.08272281289100647,
-0.07275532931089401,
0.7634543180465698,
-0.022795088589191437,
0.9827640652656555,
-0.06169317662715912,
-0.5992313027381897,
-0.06275085359811783,
-0.14199364185333252,
-0.6195617318153381,
0.2510199546813965,
0.21183624863624573,
0.09908678382635117,
-0.49775925278663635,
0.060502905398607254,
0.1901254653930664,
-0.13245335221290588,
-0.12465865910053253,
0.9707232117652893,
0.13666804134845734,
-0.38502946496009827,
0.2780435085296631,
-0.4021933376789093,
0.6458957195281982,
-0.7296960353851318,
-0.07745468616485596,
-0.5471308827400208,
0.030512800440192223,
-0.22146861255168915,
-0.5645769238471985,
0.2779523730278015,
0.3665335476398468,
-0.1269192099571228,
0.07273995131254196,
0.8869394063949585,
0.34281492233276367,
-0.040249377489089966,
0.330961138010025,
0.15878961980342865,
0.004598915111273527,
0.06500384211540222,
-0.7663231492042542,
0.4831694960594177,
-0.10427273064851761,
-0.480697900056839,
0.3216067850589752,
0.503701388835907,
0.12305059283971786,
0.8088458180427551,
0.6963507533073425,
0.12620903551578522,
0.08368602395057678,
-0.22418953478336334,
0.9172152876853943,
-0.6516667604446411,
-0.17157773673534393,
-1.1971795558929443,
-0.016581183299422264,
-0.07230677455663681,
-0.3101031184196472,
1.0217746496200562,
0.4705067574977875,
0.2911738455295563,
0.10600200295448303,
0.7390022873878479,
-0.06590843945741653,
0.08322897553443909,
-0.4830845594406128,
0.5530800223350525,
-0.006350814364850521,
0.7077466249465942,
-0.3209702968597412,
-1.0307590961456299,
0.014824175275862217,
0.30611225962638855,
-0.3598356544971466,
-0.056976526975631714,
0.5238194465637207,
1.0549442768096924,
0.047709256410598755,
0.5566157698631287,
0.22821952402591705,
-0.15601058304309845,
0.5932283401489258,
0.4528244733810425,
1.3785992860794067,
-0.11942872405052185,
0.4985775649547577,
-0.19072340428829193,
-0.48809656500816345,
0.17969083786010742,
-1.1043944358825684,
-0.8118901252746582,
-0.0992814227938652,
-0.30955442786216736,
-0.40707096457481384,
0.16583721339702606,
0.8952328562736511,
0.4127863049507141,
-0.6748218536376953,
-0.09437509626150131,
-0.044002704322338104,
0.2307169884443283,
-0.29217398166656494,
-0.19334688782691956,
0.36124661564826965,
-0.22835247218608856,
-0.08797033876180649,
0.8847053647041321,
0.5434855818748474,
0.03733443468809128,
0.053706035017967224,
0.07451679557561874,
0.08715982735157013,
-0.16782580316066742,
0.10297776758670807,
0.8139421343803406,
-0.5976890921592712,
-0.3318335711956024,
-0.02663004957139492,
-0.16882289946079254,
-0.07284044474363327,
0.9172439575195312,
-0.43072831630706787,
0.3698817491531372,
0.4227343201637268,
1.047181248664856,
0.09324849396944046,
0.1337769478559494,
0.38631904125213623,
-0.468440979719162,
0.3344974219799042,
0.12047962099313736,
0.38105523586273193,
0.14221887290477753,
-0.3606194257736206,
0.6452611684799194,
0.47067710757255554,
-0.4583407938480377,
-1.024973750114441,
0.24022209644317627,
-0.9930561184883118,
-0.07292163372039795,
1.0136256217956543,
-0.5917321443557739,
-0.3362513482570648,
-0.12414705753326416,
0.022225122898817062,
-0.0066240509040653706,
-0.50397127866745,
0.538436770439148,
0.3455275893211365,
0.18913565576076508,
-0.19943438470363617,
-0.8088852167129517,
0.22978508472442627,
0.07884486019611359,
-0.8045161366462708,
0.38284429907798767,
0.30842533707618713,
0.2796260416507721,
-0.2107575237751007,
0.3332090377807617,
-0.40594902634620667,
0.3415621221065521,
-0.032268572598695755,
0.15254391729831696,
-0.4709460735321045,
-0.24572740495204926,
-0.8837780952453613,
0.360075443983078,
-0.02034015953540802,
-0.6253006458282471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06729v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06729v1
|
Synthetic Query Generation using Large Language Models for Virtual Assistants
| 2024-06-10T18:50:57 | 2024-06-10T18:50:57 |
Sonal Sannigrahi, Thiago Fraga-Silva, Youssef Oualil, Christophe Van Gysel
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Virtual Assistants (VAs) are important Information Retrieval platforms that
help users accomplish various tasks through spoken commands. The speech
recognition system (speech-to-text) uses query priors, trained solely on text,
to distinguish between phonetically confusing alternatives. Hence, the
generation of synthetic queries that are similar to existing VA usage can
greatly improve upon the VA's abilities -- especially for use-cases that do not
(yet) occur in paired audio/text data.
In this paper, we provide a preliminary exploration of the use of Large
Language Models (LLMs) to generate synthetic queries that are complementary to
template-based methods. We investigate whether the methods (a) generate queries
that are similar to randomly sampled, representative, and anonymized user
queries from a popular VA, and (b) whether the generated queries are specific.
We find that LLMs generate more verbose queries, compared to template-based
methods, and reference aspects specific to the entity. The generated queries
are similar to VA user queries, and are specific enough to retrieve the
relevant entity. We conclude that queries generated by LLMs and templates are
complementary.
|
[
-0.447159081697464,
-1.0113849639892578,
0.8118723034858704,
-0.05015607550740242,
-0.15678048133850098,
-0.1299952119588852,
-0.2442111074924469,
-0.5138558149337769,
0.6826419830322266,
1.0720319747924805,
-0.4998391568660736,
-0.4834561347961426,
0.012740816920995712,
0.36164021492004395,
-0.6984833478927612,
0.44407346844673157,
0.4765314757823944,
0.2406669557094574,
-0.3290044069290161,
-0.20247933268547058,
-0.3960237205028534,
-1.0364129543304443,
-0.7338740229606628,
-0.01022964995354414,
0.31249886751174927,
0.02275647409260273,
0.24328289926052094,
0.5379976630210876,
0.11335969716310501,
0.3795977532863617,
-0.17004331946372986,
0.5493448376655579,
-0.40636658668518066,
0.6616484522819519,
-0.323956698179245,
-0.7185832858085632,
-0.2398664355278015,
-0.46402081847190857,
0.5860913991928101,
0.5958955883979797,
-0.15675292909145355,
0.035990506410598755,
-0.18682651221752167,
0.36413145065307617,
-0.794366180896759,
-0.1292971819639206,
-1.1054277420043945,
-0.008456489071249962,
-0.3883635401725769,
-0.43935248255729675,
-0.41729816794395447,
-0.24613846838474274,
0.153143048286438,
-0.5872808694839478,
0.48364752531051636,
0.03331321105360985,
0.4696771800518036,
0.03492012619972229,
-0.5064979791641235,
-0.48895907402038574,
-1.1510553359985352,
0.665774941444397,
-0.6282230019569397,
0.6101279854774475,
0.47100117802619934,
0.6057596206665039,
-0.36026856303215027,
-0.9097819328308105,
-1.1413272619247437,
-0.6570507884025574,
0.12471956759691238,
-0.053119856864213943,
-0.10699958354234695,
0.07385161519050598,
0.4102552533149719,
0.19994477927684784,
-0.5659068822860718,
0.3118741810321808,
-0.3828257620334625,
-0.08539421111345291,
0.6848662495613098,
0.3517542779445648,
0.25174739956855774,
-0.30847516655921936,
-0.04426281154155731,
-0.12849968671798706,
-0.886817216873169,
-0.18260547518730164,
0.29798200726509094,
0.36639103293418884,
0.1832296997308731,
0.8850581645965576,
-0.29564881324768066,
1.154453158378601,
-0.10733027011156082,
-0.1866205334663391,
0.026858216151595116,
-0.43045181035995483,
-0.24648696184158325,
0.00020291795954108238,
0.8265513777732849,
0.12718720734119415,
0.5903218388557434,
-0.16308245062828064,
-0.2954541742801666,
-0.12456892430782318,
0.3567158579826355,
-0.35243794322013855,
-0.014678115025162697,
0.16058087348937988,
-0.2695578336715698,
-0.21185433864593506,
0.12344448268413544,
-0.5308157205581665,
-0.3798168897628784,
-0.720195472240448,
0.1273270696401596,
-0.18945373594760895,
-0.2981272339820862,
-0.13288114964962006,
-0.1526094377040863,
0.34466999769210815,
0.26425042748451233,
-0.8259971141815186,
0.45953190326690674,
0.6764655709266663,
0.6722759008407593,
-0.26889145374298096,
0.03308065980672836,
-0.8553017377853394,
0.30190911889076233,
-0.3222239911556244,
0.7500101923942566,
-0.770258367061615,
-1.0089741945266724,
0.2455550879240036,
-0.07761558890342712,
0.03819465637207031,
-0.9590345025062561,
0.3306352198123932,
-0.5663211345672607,
0.24237796664237976,
-0.4560166597366333,
-0.5750670433044434,
0.1285417228937149,
0.2790120840072632,
-0.7637608051300049,
0.964989185333252,
-0.16093774139881134,
-0.4278064966201782,
0.06977707147598267,
-0.255857914686203,
-0.4024278521537781,
0.07535456120967865,
-0.6130772233009338,
0.03491543233394623,
0.2603124678134918,
0.31982073187828064,
0.29164570569992065,
-0.7308515906333923,
0.012934527359902859,
-0.15925277769565582,
-0.3076837360858917,
0.3115394413471222,
-0.21962130069732666,
0.6189955472946167,
0.0300818532705307,
-0.1234816312789917,
0.1511584371328354,
-0.9619446396827698,
0.06371503323316574,
0.2210230976343155,
-0.2164812535047531,
-0.7161516547203064,
0.05545426905155182,
0.02376766875386238,
-0.024176638573408127,
0.10372073203325272,
-0.39957404136657715,
0.3506840169429779,
-0.5732095241546631,
0.1655818521976471,
0.5396319627761841,
0.19639776647090912,
0.19152431190013885,
-0.1337212175130844,
0.6458705067634583,
-0.23687663674354553,
-0.19738762080669403,
-0.20936653017997742,
-0.41290727257728577,
-0.6685647368431091,
-0.24152155220508575,
0.13099916279315948,
0.5477691888809204,
-0.9532877802848816,
0.2861395478248596,
-0.25954189896583557,
-0.5586758852005005,
-0.4649519920349121,
0.07407411187887192,
0.3951948285102844,
0.7242603302001953,
0.25562620162963867,
-0.1675775647163391,
-0.7277688980102539,
-0.9238146543502808,
-0.27488020062446594,
-0.38344597816467285,
-0.31719762086868286,
0.8531183004379272,
0.04408537596464157,
-0.18869073688983917,
0.818873405456543,
-0.5070392489433289,
-0.23735395073890686,
-0.09072518348693848,
-0.2142970860004425,
0.01968311332166195,
0.16510841250419617,
0.7667924165725708,
-0.9567376375198364,
-0.28508567810058594,
-0.0642176941037178,
-0.5515982508659363,
-0.1877099722623825,
0.00833471305668354,
0.015691056847572327,
0.1651696413755417,
0.7150598764419556,
-0.7926151752471924,
0.00015424257435370237,
0.333647221326828,
0.009213774465024471,
0.7750696539878845,
-0.21515214443206787,
-0.017657935619354248,
-1.3935480117797852,
0.09587029367685318,
0.12734229862689972,
-0.29439881443977356,
-0.558843731880188,
0.03629351407289505,
-0.2613750994205475,
-0.24414657056331635,
-0.4301668405532837,
0.8204972743988037,
-0.45305153727531433,
-0.2668670117855072,
-0.2681993842124939,
0.04128841683268547,
-0.022451533004641533,
0.04027630388736725,
0.24943339824676514,
1.0063639879226685,
0.6116534471511841,
-0.9153714776039124,
0.5156751275062561,
0.12091014534235,
0.03142476826906204,
0.540592610836029,
-0.8394511938095093,
0.5573002099990845,
-0.10871310532093048,
0.1991889923810959,
-0.7767128944396973,
-0.2607036828994751,
-0.22649239003658295,
-0.355197936296463,
0.2120566964149475,
-0.1779884397983551,
-0.6765557527542114,
-0.3229341506958008,
-0.1057603657245636,
0.4321187436580658,
0.4560016691684723,
-0.6787920594215393,
0.5552675127983093,
0.6490261554718018,
-0.1208093911409378,
-0.3136027455329895,
-0.4152332842350006,
0.13910315930843353,
-0.1741011142730713,
-0.5374158024787903,
0.5307728052139282,
0.27546486258506775,
-0.4119177758693695,
-0.1118365228176117,
-0.018420664593577385,
-0.0982585921883583,
-0.2982358932495117,
0.08318477123975754,
0.16956600546836853,
-0.5238051414489746,
0.1395072042942047,
0.030568214133381844,
0.3485654592514038,
-0.005377273540943861,
-0.3536551296710968,
0.8887605667114258,
0.1589924544095993,
-0.5693501830101013,
-0.22684822976589203,
0.6501258015632629,
0.6633497476577759,
-0.6124389171600342,
0.7336821556091309,
0.4958548843860626,
-0.38784608244895935,
-0.29683950543403625,
-1.0457605123519897,
-0.4367559254169464,
-0.4970753490924835,
0.25222399830818176,
-0.5211125016212463,
-0.8718323111534119,
0.6313146948814392,
0.06306291371583939,
-0.11339960247278214,
0.3099140524864197,
0.8269928097724915,
0.003421453759074211,
1.0712848901748657,
0.3799009323120117,
0.03608998283743858,
0.6282913684844971,
-0.15001800656318665,
-0.1943899393081665,
-0.7378698587417603,
-0.5267695188522339,
-0.8839539289474487,
0.1825595647096634,
-0.9245547652244568,
-0.5295820236206055,
0.5599242448806763,
-0.23368798196315765,
0.12918385863304138,
0.29450055956840515,
-0.4089992344379425,
0.23759277164936066,
0.9310727715492249,
-0.1358741968870163,
0.19598184525966644,
0.24149107933044434,
-0.12759238481521606,
0.00490227248519659,
-0.33511996269226074,
-0.49677300453186035,
1.250925064086914,
-0.2838398814201355,
0.6289178729057312,
0.23843899369239807,
0.8239742517471313,
0.15301577746868134,
-0.14311857521533966,
-0.7469774484634399,
0.7318251132965088,
-0.22756153345108032,
-0.30809831619262695,
-0.19378811120986938,
-0.50198894739151,
-1.3362128734588623,
0.4008956551551819,
-0.4414810836315155,
-0.9542512893676758,
0.1378597766160965,
0.2939876317977905,
-0.03907656669616699,
0.06468229740858078,
-0.6721726655960083,
0.42357751727104187,
-0.2814331650733948,
-0.32493045926094055,
-0.10690982639789581,
-0.2306780368089676,
0.3338955342769623,
-0.07729402929544449,
-0.27176690101623535,
0.2687508463859558,
0.02969895675778389,
0.5843852162361145,
-0.4699055552482605,
0.48076194524765015,
-0.0570208802819252,
0.04317021742463112,
0.517223596572876,
0.1514890193939209,
0.5176957845687866,
0.19138413667678833,
-0.4967733323574066,
-0.057379454374313354,
0.14462266862392426,
-0.08348644524812698,
-0.7531149983406067,
0.9802191853523254,
-0.4020381569862366,
-1.1206969022750854,
-0.18250691890716553,
-0.24948439002037048,
-0.3726055920124054,
0.36772435903549194,
0.17469000816345215,
0.3406170606613159,
-0.24949154257774353,
0.36780640482902527,
0.5973331928253174,
-0.3931333124637604,
0.009818431921303272,
0.7449053525924683,
-0.14592382311820984,
-0.012456909753382206,
0.8120502233505249,
0.24724331498146057,
0.06605929136276245,
0.49692341685295105,
0.0754888728260994,
-0.5092210173606873,
-0.4730963408946991,
-0.36219677329063416,
0.4792412221431732,
-0.25781694054603577,
-0.06446275115013123,
-0.6642026901245117,
-0.266775518655777,
-0.7418853044509888,
0.2468542605638504,
-0.3235529959201813,
-0.36867499351501465,
-0.3528856635093689,
0.0019064947264268994,
0.2636318802833557,
0.49946829676628113,
0.3361208736896515,
0.04128270223736763,
-0.8319148421287537,
0.6306132078170776,
0.3624700903892517,
-0.12094022333621979,
-0.13469193875789642,
-0.1893734633922577,
0.2930206060409546,
-0.03139563277363777,
-0.27160972356796265,
-1.1989493370056152,
0.5707729458808899,
0.1497507095336914,
0.7764883637428284,
0.13600262999534607,
-0.03993571177124977,
0.5395067930221558,
-0.680247962474823,
1.0098531246185303,
-0.03914136067032814,
-0.6199336051940918,
0.7638423442840576,
-0.4694135785102844,
0.12832821905612946,
0.2617282569408417,
0.33693188428878784,
-0.2646799087524414,
-0.26271387934684753,
-0.4599577784538269,
-1.020483136177063,
0.5124027132987976,
0.38115108013153076,
0.5738993287086487,
-0.21489961445331573,
0.5469865202903748,
-0.1239900290966034,
0.25670668482780457,
-0.28065595030784607,
-0.26370957493782043,
0.09036003053188324,
0.07482267171144485,
0.199957013130188,
-0.35813966393470764,
-0.06126538664102554,
-0.1569770723581314,
0.37222516536712646,
0.030793610960245132,
0.37249109148979187,
0.1534857451915741,
0.18146750330924988,
0.08494821190834045,
0.15083017945289612,
0.6534621715545654,
0.5406901836395264,
-0.08452746272087097,
-0.10446185618638992,
0.3073734939098358,
-0.32382309436798096,
-0.03430207818746567,
0.1646801382303238,
-0.14077730476856232,
0.2961692214012146,
0.28555724024772644,
0.7786061763763428,
-0.2479330450296402,
-1.0138899087905884,
0.2606109082698822,
-0.3028792440891266,
0.15947449207305908,
-0.6820843815803528,
0.3265298902988434,
0.18723708391189575,
0.171015202999115,
0.25657254457473755,
-0.47124627232551575,
0.4270481765270233,
-0.6511507034301758,
0.031220469623804092,
0.759655237197876,
0.11172403395175934,
-0.21843716502189636,
0.717440128326416,
0.1403883844614029,
-0.7968816757202148,
0.739616870880127,
0.1422942876815796,
-0.1233087033033371,
0.580892026424408,
0.8333277702331543,
0.8467985987663269,
-0.443940669298172,
-0.026503589004278183,
0.23712077736854553,
0.0023244230542331934,
-0.08777409046888351,
0.5781524777412415,
-0.30408182740211487,
-0.4407269060611725,
-0.2762102782726288,
-0.7687268853187561,
-0.4793224036693573,
0.6757408976554871,
-0.7695186138153076,
0.5434044003486633,
-0.31152206659317017,
-0.41886836290359497,
0.19609291851520538,
-0.41611820459365845,
-0.9472621083259583,
0.2239169329404831,
-0.007825741544365883,
0.6263541579246521,
-0.4196133613586426,
0.889611005783081,
1.036360502243042,
-0.3633064031600952,
-0.9389382600784302,
0.20973685383796692,
0.020088031888008118,
-0.6231430768966675,
0.49877792596817017,
-0.254518985748291,
-0.17316341400146484,
-0.22789128124713898,
-0.16713453829288483,
-0.8044618964195251,
0.7986758351325989,
0.6412740349769592,
-0.761681079864502,
-0.4459605813026428,
0.307794988155365,
1.0139919519424438,
-0.22308658063411713,
0.11435167491436005,
0.4083918035030365,
0.05058810114860535,
-0.00652006221935153,
-1.2305223941802979,
0.08733680844306946,
-0.20068660378456116,
0.19401982426643372,
0.017148049548268318,
-0.3189449906349182,
0.7571344971656799,
0.07476835697889328,
0.12498253583908081,
0.16875720024108887,
0.6719892024993896,
0.6284850835800171,
0.25122740864753723,
0.3503566086292267,
0.21059562265872955,
0.6708806157112122,
0.23553892970085144,
1.388282299041748,
-0.1803305447101593,
-0.18518085777759552,
1.1697639226913452,
-0.32026728987693787,
0.9738094210624695,
0.6451302170753479,
0.0231670830398798,
0.14596347510814667,
0.2041717767715454,
0.13067379593849182,
0.30065616965293884,
0.3358372449874878,
-0.361707478761673,
-0.14828552305698395,
-0.2255406379699707,
-0.496004581451416,
0.7577882409095764,
0.6539455652236938,
-0.6617268919944763,
-0.03796594589948654,
-0.00978055689483881,
-0.2718721330165863,
0.2343473881483078,
-0.052559319883584976,
1.1304235458374023,
0.35295581817626953,
-0.9686323404312134,
0.6911556124687195,
0.16727018356323242,
0.34279265999794006,
-0.5146586298942566,
-0.12038668990135193,
-0.14666880667209625,
-0.07747592031955719,
0.015567424707114697,
-0.4896870255470276,
0.2068725824356079,
0.24042610824108124,
-0.07066414505243301,
0.22335588932037354,
0.6977858543395996,
-0.27336636185646057,
-0.47774383425712585,
0.1388668566942215,
0.614364504814148,
0.15806658565998077,
-0.1676843762397766,
-0.516110360622406,
-0.00414527440443635,
-0.07780366390943527,
-0.27528759837150574,
0.23995494842529297,
0.43565061688423157,
-0.45166006684303284,
0.577770471572876,
0.909690797328949,
0.5986426472663879,
0.321328341960907,
0.3493732810020447,
0.9142777919769287,
-0.4336141049861908,
-0.6045807600021362,
-0.7991190552711487,
0.10228756070137024,
-0.22261078655719757,
-0.249024897813797,
0.7714198231697083,
0.5820433497428894,
0.8781025409698486,
-0.30152982473373413,
0.8167466521263123,
0.35788917541503906,
0.5574032664299011,
-0.9350274801254272,
0.38355380296707153,
-0.7731215357780457,
0.5783757567405701,
-0.2883533239364624,
-1.3120651245117188,
-0.001695431536063552,
0.40983015298843384,
-0.2019120454788208,
0.16905057430267334,
-0.009831572882831097,
1.128691554069519,
-0.37400975823402405,
-0.3310612142086029,
0.39838945865631104,
0.004833342973142862,
0.6813386082649231,
-0.0025511509738862514,
0.6655288338661194,
0.04881242662668228,
0.4269689917564392,
0.01733994297683239,
0.3401683568954468,
-0.467081755399704,
-0.4131990671157837,
-0.9121204018592834,
-0.843699038028717,
0.021843643859028816,
-0.4485233426094055,
0.17653372883796692,
1.0002963542938232,
0.7296949625015259,
-0.7183703184127808,
-0.22558681666851044,
-0.10951954871416092,
-0.13390730321407318,
0.30096158385276794,
-0.24219895899295807,
0.3080556094646454,
0.028035394847393036,
-1.0722651481628418,
0.7411548495292664,
-0.013247544877231121,
0.180952250957489,
-0.37458378076553345,
0.06308704614639282,
-0.0034669218584895134,
0.3704068660736084,
0.6289254426956177,
0.6251352429389954,
-0.9362203478813171,
-0.024325959384441376,
0.30716919898986816,
-0.1146569773554802,
-0.2958742380142212,
1.001965045928955,
-0.9510345458984375,
0.7976175546646118,
0.7338514924049377,
0.6704657077789307,
0.8205050230026245,
0.12275810539722443,
0.850825309753418,
-1.0516937971115112,
0.3059720993041992,
0.5790814161300659,
0.3806507885456085,
0.4164721965789795,
-0.43055346608161926,
0.25396084785461426,
-0.00431413296610117,
-0.194350928068161,
-1.1838102340698242,
0.4039640426635742,
-1.0724374055862427,
-0.041326455771923065,
1.522691249847412,
0.2832801342010498,
-0.11782142519950867,
0.061584342271089554,
-0.45971986651420593,
0.351364403963089,
-0.1934560388326645,
0.6399688124656677,
0.17109927535057068,
-0.33876413106918335,
0.0652187317609787,
-0.5210363864898682,
0.4627772569656372,
0.36571574211120605,
-0.7167092561721802,
-0.29829996824264526,
0.5745678544044495,
0.3113858103752136,
0.14923427999019623,
0.748887836933136,
-0.12239970266819,
0.21486082673072815,
-0.1443881392478943,
-0.28924453258514404,
-0.20322799682617188,
-0.1843699812889099,
0.11077464371919632,
0.2322435826063156,
0.1493203192949295,
-0.17840564250946045
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06723v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06723v1
|
Leveraging Large Language Models for Knowledge-free Weak Supervision in Clinical Natural Language Processing
| 2024-06-10T18:34:48 | 2024-06-10T18:34:48 |
Enshuo Hsu, Kirk Roberts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
The performance of deep learning-based natural language processing systems is
based on large amounts of labeled training data which, in the clinical domain,
are not easily available or affordable. Weak supervision and in-context
learning offer partial solutions to this issue, particularly using large
language models (LLMs), but their performance still trails traditional
supervised methods with moderate amounts of gold-standard data. In particular,
inferencing with LLMs is computationally heavy. We propose an approach
leveraging fine-tuning LLMs and weak supervision with virtually no domain
knowledge that still achieves consistently dominant performance. Using a
prompt-based approach, the LLM is used to generate weakly-labeled data for
training a downstream BERT model. The weakly supervised model is then further
fine-tuned on small amounts of gold standard data. We evaluate this approach
using Llama2 on three different n2c2 datasets. With no more than 10 gold
standard notes, our final BERT models weakly supervised by fine-tuned
Llama2-13B consistently outperformed out-of-the-box PubMedBERT by 4.7% to 47.9%
in F1 scores. With only 50 gold standard notes, our models achieved close
performance to fully fine-tuned systems.
|
[
0.03677714243531227,
-0.7112788558006287,
0.8699542284011841,
0.18247142434120178,
-0.3752427101135254,
-0.24936339259147644,
-0.5789238810539246,
-0.7107624411582947,
-0.029830440878868103,
0.804573118686676,
-0.3599991500377655,
-0.7539427876472473,
-0.9408669471740723,
0.09824629873037338,
-0.2725461423397064,
1.2701332569122314,
0.01572718657553196,
0.3637402355670929,
-0.2007211148738861,
-0.0014629712095484138,
-0.3421124517917633,
-0.3110911250114441,
-0.6699202656745911,
-0.6977719664573669,
0.4745228588581085,
0.6464855670928955,
0.7630881667137146,
0.5592746734619141,
0.7554208636283875,
0.14379891753196716,
-0.34430986642837524,
0.3744100332260132,
-0.523330807685852,
0.12771807610988617,
0.013986124657094479,
-0.41467833518981934,
-0.7893492579460144,
-0.3836233615875244,
0.36814650893211365,
1.1630189418792725,
0.03921269252896309,
-0.23649121820926666,
0.23404179513454437,
0.5534444451332092,
-0.5621910095214844,
0.2128007411956787,
-0.6809914708137512,
-0.014182285405695438,
-0.0717928409576416,
-0.020266715437173843,
-0.463773250579834,
-0.19404461979866028,
0.43037447333335876,
-0.34994205832481384,
0.43831318616867065,
-0.20273198187351227,
0.777765154838562,
0.31146240234375,
-0.4339914917945862,
-0.551059365272522,
-0.6254168152809143,
0.9491540789604187,
-1.117103934288025,
0.16714772582054138,
0.9331677556037903,
0.18315742909908295,
-0.27229049801826477,
-0.7633589506149292,
-0.055920347571372986,
-0.431698203086853,
-0.1944611668586731,
-0.09059794247150421,
-0.2032141536474228,
0.4420272707939148,
0.18468153476715088,
0.251581609249115,
-0.45223063230514526,
0.6054103970527649,
-0.3427933156490326,
-0.0743124932050705,
0.5819261074066162,
0.2251838892698288,
-0.060099296271800995,
0.054793328046798706,
-0.25651130080223083,
0.3119203746318817,
-0.7869855165481567,
-0.25071078538894653,
-0.1477736383676529,
0.728587806224823,
-0.17938590049743652,
0.6439050436019897,
-0.250315397977829,
0.5601048469543457,
0.015037985518574715,
-0.38238707184791565,
0.05841143801808357,
-0.0637773647904396,
-0.46531617641448975,
0.22649075090885162,
0.7908287048339844,
0.21930083632469177,
0.307602196931839,
-0.548003613948822,
-0.2817626893520355,
0.22185109555721283,
0.22092808783054352,
-0.7976426482200623,
-0.38641101121902466,
0.2634948194026947,
-0.4640915095806122,
-0.22741274535655975,
-0.5254459381103516,
-0.53599613904953,
-0.5803207755088806,
-0.534736156463623,
0.2314661145210266,
-0.4991036355495453,
0.04108736664056778,
0.08189478516578674,
0.23785604536533356,
-0.038262106478214264,
0.4927443265914917,
-1.16727614402771,
0.5903593897819519,
0.5500672459602356,
0.8414537906646729,
-0.0984668955206871,
0.1528453528881073,
-0.7337191104888916,
0.1975906640291214,
-0.2809610962867737,
0.6974368691444397,
-0.3153143525123596,
-0.20100826025009155,
0.13814961910247803,
0.05496898293495178,
0.02475128136575222,
-0.7871710658073425,
0.8338133096694946,
-0.3792051374912262,
-0.13984543085098267,
-0.08904622495174408,
-0.8028643727302551,
0.2495071142911911,
-0.02359175682067871,
-0.413821816444397,
0.7983713150024414,
0.19271863996982574,
-0.6250539422035217,
0.5043418407440186,
-0.1739102452993393,
-0.7338559627532959,
0.0345860980451107,
-0.06408221274614334,
-0.4953005313873291,
0.19419759511947632,
0.5866780877113342,
0.7430046200752258,
-0.25856396555900574,
0.6768034100532532,
-0.575928270816803,
-0.5082238912582397,
-0.11134357750415802,
-0.18350110948085785,
0.5027523040771484,
0.0671493411064148,
-0.247446209192276,
-0.0796404778957367,
-0.7885060906410217,
-0.16879217326641083,
-0.025565916672348976,
-0.3269484341144562,
-0.37628474831581116,
0.0783078745007515,
0.054840948432683945,
0.07892773300409317,
0.24210776388645172,
-0.3789142072200775,
0.18199899792671204,
-0.8126134276390076,
0.39207538962364197,
0.5155819058418274,
0.005800717975944281,
0.4729585647583008,
-0.23976069688796997,
0.06444534659385681,
-0.0963510125875473,
0.09197037667036057,
0.27488094568252563,
-0.5523669719696045,
-0.8913465738296509,
-0.3084031641483307,
0.08125603199005127,
0.4617387354373932,
-0.6724151968955994,
0.24063065648078918,
-0.07270697504281998,
-0.3543566167354584,
-0.731702446937561,
0.76387619972229,
0.4851701557636261,
0.7167278528213501,
0.7002378106117249,
-0.2354608029127121,
-0.4279351830482483,
-1.1654773950576782,
-0.14755725860595703,
-0.0911392793059349,
-0.28735271096229553,
0.4459746181964874,
0.3817507326602936,
-0.5488371849060059,
0.6845200061798096,
-0.4037608802318573,
-0.8359555006027222,
-0.46040666103363037,
0.2164669781923294,
0.5266452431678772,
0.4808237850666046,
0.3256773352622986,
-0.3144834339618683,
-0.22330543398857117,
0.05123203620314598,
-0.9732471704483032,
-0.2544269561767578,
0.04433821514248848,
0.058844294399023056,
0.17257606983184814,
0.6667881011962891,
-0.5401872396469116,
0.3470633029937744,
0.5251717567443848,
-0.16188280284404755,
0.23762357234954834,
-0.395839661359787,
-0.4164591133594513,
-0.7673503756523132,
0.03926966339349747,
0.08383724093437195,
-0.1952337771654129,
-0.8272072672843933,
-0.22300437092781067,
0.06464797258377075,
0.15337854623794556,
-0.3948371410369873,
0.37905406951904297,
-0.24882052838802338,
0.19074660539627075,
-0.4596210718154907,
0.03447648510336876,
-0.0443442277610302,
0.5112882852554321,
0.2520208954811096,
0.2927131950855255,
0.5753987431526184,
-0.5867903828620911,
0.05766028165817261,
0.35386064648628235,
-0.43469521403312683,
0.27460959553718567,
-0.8762046098709106,
0.11541932821273804,
-0.1580236405134201,
0.0628204420208931,
-1.0265586376190186,
-0.43824028968811035,
-0.095396026968956,
-0.15951251983642578,
0.5208982229232788,
-0.4830755591392517,
-0.7593236565589905,
-0.07667221128940582,
0.022969478741288185,
0.26438114047050476,
0.4157610833644867,
-0.4704759418964386,
0.10525742918252945,
0.1388976126909256,
-0.4472198486328125,
-0.31546828150749207,
-1.040526270866394,
0.1917794644832611,
-0.00803762674331665,
-0.4788103401660919,
0.3320348560810089,
0.2706027925014496,
-0.20736172795295715,
-0.07762783020734787,
0.037725962698459625,
-0.2765141427516937,
0.03419598937034607,
0.268535852432251,
0.273418128490448,
-0.29499551653862,
0.3840228319168091,
0.4389633536338806,
-0.13094323873519897,
0.043437425047159195,
-0.06722395867109299,
0.1712200939655304,
-0.030745726078748703,
-0.35623034834861755,
-0.655322790145874,
0.2928946912288666,
0.5200048685073853,
0.1283639520406723,
0.778312087059021,
0.49422985315322876,
-0.6386842727661133,
-0.35098883509635925,
-0.4371473491191864,
-0.4416959285736084,
-0.42625972628593445,
0.2519769072532654,
0.23227465152740479,
-1.1620546579360962,
0.2612280249595642,
-0.020183231681585312,
0.07219719141721725,
0.24935853481292725,
0.8366390466690063,
-0.21599902212619781,
1.2354120016098022,
0.6059309244155884,
-0.16076381504535675,
0.2519770860671997,
-0.040596313774585724,
0.28297674655914307,
-0.6911737322807312,
-0.1591334342956543,
-0.2567909359931946,
-0.2189350128173828,
-0.3985789120197296,
-0.3083030879497528,
0.4550783336162567,
0.24891461431980133,
-0.15452583134174347,
0.0951443463563919,
-0.3527093529701233,
0.16569459438323975,
0.5100114345550537,
0.3798556327819824,
0.40568384528160095,
-0.06138502061367035,
-0.10568409413099289,
-0.1624133288860321,
-0.6120126247406006,
-0.6216025948524475,
1.4688688516616821,
0.4658295512199402,
0.898472249507904,
0.011504197493195534,
0.552747905254364,
0.3026387393474579,
0.5285331606864929,
-0.8079665899276733,
0.27987945079803467,
-0.44937366247177124,
-0.4328590929508209,
-0.010183905251324177,
-0.3931419551372528,
-0.9450541138648987,
0.10918815433979034,
-0.3057399094104767,
-0.7918887138366699,
0.08183818310499191,
0.12572693824768066,
-0.5805880427360535,
0.20681443810462952,
-0.8736456036567688,
0.6299707293510437,
-0.17493022978305817,
-0.6395149230957031,
0.05658841133117676,
-0.7683313488960266,
0.6235979199409485,
-0.02707740291953087,
0.1305236667394638,
-0.1694025844335556,
0.15534204244613647,
0.5826048254966736,
-0.5996978282928467,
1.2330296039581299,
-0.16165578365325928,
-0.28255632519721985,
0.18778923153877258,
0.0398271270096302,
0.6266260147094727,
0.4553278982639313,
0.05735747888684273,
0.018159283325076103,
-0.1367003172636032,
-0.4743574857711792,
-0.363899827003479,
0.808942437171936,
-0.8117589950561523,
-0.19376489520072937,
-0.18392038345336914,
-0.5027492642402649,
-0.6640997529029846,
0.08145689219236374,
0.26919466257095337,
0.4672375023365021,
0.02849660813808441,
0.18855562806129456,
0.7685310244560242,
-0.1878102570772171,
0.15411442518234253,
0.5833920240402222,
0.18741381168365479,
-0.2666015326976776,
0.636201798915863,
-0.02844308689236641,
0.3412072956562042,
0.3593095541000366,
0.008865918964147568,
-0.31054991483688354,
-0.8620297908782959,
-0.19106915593147278,
0.3599945306777954,
-0.6223316192626953,
-0.3471910059452057,
-0.6753875613212585,
-0.16278387606143951,
-0.5467411279678345,
-0.26694953441619873,
-0.43921947479248047,
-0.13022714853286743,
-0.6853505373001099,
-0.04689956456422806,
0.3317703902721405,
0.7132489085197449,
0.20527803897857666,
0.5565672516822815,
-0.6098851561546326,
0.5303869247436523,
0.33070454001426697,
0.6255025267601013,
-0.025754237547516823,
-0.5318110585212708,
-0.38492900133132935,
-0.03063833713531494,
-0.23389720916748047,
-0.6506267786026001,
0.5494208931922913,
0.2801981568336487,
0.2862013280391693,
0.6148349046707153,
0.054270390421152115,
0.725113034248352,
-0.36354708671569824,
0.5355812907218933,
0.04735250771045685,
-0.6408723592758179,
0.7768528461456299,
-0.40523847937583923,
0.2219787985086441,
0.8719059228897095,
0.07529179751873016,
-0.19273480772972107,
-0.7879884839057922,
-0.43449071049690247,
-1.0948857069015503,
0.8359382152557373,
0.23604367673397064,
-0.10500594228506088,
-0.1152510866522789,
0.33764490485191345,
0.12393023073673248,
0.13448429107666016,
-0.4295315742492676,
-0.02778240293264389,
0.27178388833999634,
-0.23047231137752533,
-0.4060153067111969,
-0.34488776326179504,
-0.26893264055252075,
-0.31211864948272705,
0.5228343605995178,
-0.47893619537353516,
0.2948456406593323,
0.4842715263366699,
-0.26955753564834595,
-0.3407963514328003,
0.24470870196819305,
0.4116862714290619,
0.37550902366638184,
-0.5826029181480408,
0.18494290113449097,
0.3939705491065979,
-0.38165849447250366,
-0.2918287515640259,
0.12907487154006958,
0.015872826799750328,
0.02263152040541172,
0.8401433229446411,
0.8926467299461365,
0.4394984841346741,
-0.9726536273956299,
0.5585753917694092,
-0.066989466547966,
-0.44852888584136963,
-0.0786987915635109,
-0.02318374067544937,
0.15163040161132812,
0.2768499255180359,
0.0763261690735817,
0.06082180142402649,
0.10849267989397049,
-0.17952735722064972,
0.2726598083972931,
0.3192337453365326,
-0.7812675833702087,
-0.26872479915618896,
0.7214815020561218,
-0.12022409588098526,
0.161116361618042,
0.7658286690711975,
0.05110418424010277,
0.06117750704288483,
0.5288248658180237,
0.7316845059394836,
0.6602232456207275,
0.3004491329193115,
-0.044821590185165405,
0.1703791618347168,
0.2168906331062317,
-0.23391570150852203,
0.23187333345413208,
-0.025197112932801247,
-0.48108163475990295,
-0.6846444010734558,
-0.6565065383911133,
-0.6354039907455444,
0.3551681935787201,
-0.8096107244491577,
0.3259161114692688,
-0.7481153607368469,
-0.2247508317232132,
-0.09146618098020554,
0.015707803890109062,
-0.7780197262763977,
0.3462405204772949,
0.4247609078884125,
0.7695817351341248,
-0.9407023191452026,
0.9983041286468506,
0.6101383566856384,
-0.06043807789683342,
-0.642829418182373,
-0.2562396824359894,
0.05679050832986832,
-0.7398457527160645,
0.504217267036438,
0.06578374654054642,
0.08241908997297287,
-0.3325665295124054,
-0.6916240453720093,
-0.6803587079048157,
0.9752989411354065,
0.5405275821685791,
-0.5852056741714478,
0.020611472427845,
0.193001389503479,
0.9654045701026917,
-0.10886376351118088,
0.15992334485054016,
0.8161425590515137,
0.1071510761976242,
0.09935793280601501,
-0.9776020050048828,
-0.05127207189798355,
-0.15466707944869995,
-0.3012727200984955,
0.07475461065769196,
-0.4387952387332916,
0.6502463221549988,
-0.3813213109970093,
-0.08171337842941284,
0.21998274326324463,
0.5319798588752747,
0.3162216246128082,
0.4690251350402832,
0.12038561701774597,
0.7598947882652283,
0.8527694344520569,
0.05209445208311081,
0.8630536198616028,
-0.07306591421365738,
0.4002673029899597,
1.1390135288238525,
-0.5454356074333191,
0.8279277682304382,
0.7170897722244263,
-0.05106433480978012,
0.3153441548347473,
0.32497894763946533,
0.06471900641918182,
0.5908644795417786,
-0.08244302868843079,
-0.2759314477443695,
-0.44717690348625183,
-0.3894621729850769,
-0.3102169632911682,
0.31563514471054077,
0.5202826261520386,
-0.6764158606529236,
-0.45942890644073486,
-0.20711669325828552,
0.12703083455562592,
-0.0465107262134552,
-0.310293048620224,
1.0361790657043457,
0.5263144373893738,
-0.5822309851646423,
0.8297789692878723,
0.028716182336211205,
0.5316058993339539,
-0.7929567098617554,
0.004492351319640875,
-0.3271993100643158,
0.49362385272979736,
-0.3221491277217865,
-0.5351641178131104,
0.24664732813835144,
0.3310230076313019,
-0.1416883021593094,
-0.2725384533405304,
0.8219533562660217,
-0.38961729407310486,
-0.598379373550415,
0.5614711046218872,
0.5053718090057373,
-0.030633781105279922,
0.04622194916009903,
-0.30694150924682617,
-0.320096492767334,
-0.21757027506828308,
-0.15780846774578094,
0.7152214050292969,
0.40175187587738037,
-0.13956131041049957,
0.6308662295341492,
0.7494856715202332,
0.29406896233558655,
-0.15609343349933624,
0.42729541659355164,
1.0682178735733032,
-0.5114660263061523,
-0.26410621404647827,
-0.8896992206573486,
0.06897608190774918,
0.18980228900909424,
-0.4756549298763275,
0.4647592008113861,
0.3252215087413788,
0.5019556879997253,
0.09590963274240494,
0.6500544548034668,
0.2519306540489197,
0.5457571744918823,
-0.5633906126022339,
0.6285499334335327,
-0.5996468663215637,
0.3276195824146271,
-0.42978575825691223,
-0.4795776307582855,
-0.8203563094139099,
0.32105743885040283,
-0.42136216163635254,
-0.22584253549575806,
0.4385940134525299,
0.7581411004066467,
-0.12815216183662415,
0.1402190923690796,
0.2904856503009796,
0.34941136837005615,
0.38150760531425476,
1.0742508172988892,
0.6591202616691589,
-0.22088979184627533,
0.38312044739723206,
-0.3740209639072418,
-0.21070058643817902,
-0.41754671931266785,
-0.7236781716346741,
-1.184593915939331,
0.1277768313884735,
-0.09267119318246841,
-0.29906103014945984,
0.09964619576931,
0.9682729244232178,
0.7623712420463562,
-1.0389628410339355,
0.02207505889236927,
-0.29802167415618896,
0.029870934784412384,
-0.2380661517381668,
-0.1609199494123459,
0.6260494589805603,
-0.7190833687782288,
-0.4874507188796997,
0.6453239917755127,
0.2387656569480896,
0.001473401440307498,
0.04625123366713524,
-0.12003172188997269,
-0.03721974790096283,
-0.30453476309776306,
0.6356949210166931,
0.05212472751736641,
-0.5292619466781616,
0.1460234820842743,
-0.1283004879951477,
-0.343811571598053,
0.04066746309399605,
0.6425263285636902,
-0.8312518000602722,
0.35702401399612427,
0.25640225410461426,
0.655974268913269,
0.4908270835876465,
-0.03811681643128395,
0.3978072702884674,
-0.8946932554244995,
0.12508873641490936,
0.7212280035018921,
0.32878345251083374,
0.418105810880661,
-0.3145855665206909,
0.3111267685890198,
0.18095886707305908,
-0.6722623705863953,
-0.9195336103439331,
0.032670341432094574,
-1.023718237876892,
-0.2603987455368042,
1.3209720849990845,
-0.021693693473935127,
-0.000647128967102617,
-0.4194514751434326,
-0.21831780672073364,
0.2635742425918579,
-0.45966994762420654,
0.7492546439170837,
0.4091818630695343,
-0.35351744294166565,
0.09033182263374329,
-0.9408193230628967,
0.6089210510253906,
0.732358992099762,
-0.506659209728241,
0.08734697103500366,
0.23362009227275848,
0.20886516571044922,
-0.2577476501464844,
0.6478613018989563,
-0.1453477442264557,
0.12440089136362076,
-0.28326207399368286,
-0.18959476053714752,
0.1736508309841156,
-0.2946103513240814,
-0.44981780648231506,
0.24171851575374603,
0.23993559181690216,
0.2657623887062073
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10259v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10259v1
|
Optimal synthesis embeddings
| 2024-06-10T18:06:33 | 2024-06-10T18:06:33 |
Roberto Santana, Mauricio Romero Sicre
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
In this paper we introduce a word embedding composition method based on the
intuitive idea that a fair embedding representation for a given set of words
should satisfy that the new vector will be at the same distance of the vector
representation of each of its constituents, and this distance should be
minimized. The embedding composition method can work with static and
contextualized word representations, it can be applied to create
representations of sentences and learn also representations of sets of words
that are not necessarily organized as a sequence. We theoretically characterize
the conditions for the existence of this type of representation and derive the
solution. We evaluate the method in data augmentation and sentence
classification tasks, investigating several design choices of embeddings and
composition methods. We show that our approach excels in solving probing tasks
designed to capture simple linguistic features of sentences.
|
[
-0.4399419128894806,
-0.9522934556007385,
0.7945821285247803,
0.30799365043640137,
-0.18480877578258514,
0.13603034615516663,
-0.3153427541255951,
-0.015762807801365852,
0.3919249176979065,
0.13122892379760742,
-0.3916179835796356,
-0.48209497332572937,
-0.34452950954437256,
0.2233809530735016,
-0.31510230898857117,
0.6177071332931519,
-0.21531277894973755,
-0.05960270017385483,
-0.7405496835708618,
-0.24587060511112213,
-0.5924291014671326,
-0.2973489761352539,
0.04397270083427429,
-0.2909802496433258,
0.15667614340782166,
0.41027599573135376,
0.39304593205451965,
1.1467804908752441,
0.10811004042625427,
0.3700695335865021,
-0.027326662093400955,
0.35463330149650574,
-0.44851231575012207,
0.36257511377334595,
-0.030259646475315094,
-0.8141831755638123,
0.3243706524372101,
0.18727868795394897,
0.5250809192657471,
0.9405372142791748,
0.05731632560491562,
0.022236166521906853,
0.11741092801094055,
0.41795435547828674,
-0.8218433260917664,
0.1709330528974533,
-0.34795546531677246,
0.47302842140197754,
0.11356532573699951,
-0.5239626169204712,
-0.4230136275291443,
-0.4691672921180725,
0.155901238322258,
-0.7370942234992981,
-0.0040524681098759174,
0.24798719584941864,
0.2733543813228607,
0.23027437925338745,
-0.45458024740219116,
-0.32386597990989685,
-0.5434451699256897,
1.0262062549591064,
-0.3075410723686218,
0.24918131530284882,
-0.06193609908223152,
0.21164223551750183,
-0.2749153971672058,
-0.5770635008811951,
-0.6538693308830261,
-0.18421529233455658,
0.014094170182943344,
0.1896798014640808,
-0.09416704624891281,
0.11611713469028473,
0.31987452507019043,
0.3589508831501007,
-0.3022186756134033,
-0.1978624314069748,
-0.16168904304504395,
-0.3448234498500824,
0.5576325058937073,
0.31396934390068054,
0.5219156742095947,
-0.3590869605541229,
-0.5392042994499207,
-0.24493902921676636,
-0.7392793297767639,
-0.17556056380271912,
0.37210613489151,
0.12965935468673706,
0.2149638533592224,
1.0481370687484741,
0.07148776203393936,
0.7518594264984131,
-0.13587208092212677,
0.04866916686296463,
0.27530378103256226,
-0.39901575446128845,
-0.1144641563296318,
0.0903359204530716,
0.5531744956970215,
0.5508415102958679,
-0.07729756087064743,
-0.28448599576950073,
-0.2757149040699005,
0.422263503074646,
0.2258700728416443,
-0.3853008449077606,
-0.05560218542814255,
0.11912937462329865,
-0.36726993322372437,
-0.3597962558269501,
0.19082069396972656,
-0.5420710444450378,
-0.04648468643426895,
-0.6695230603218079,
0.6057308912277222,
-0.3703365921974182,
0.1876569539308548,
0.06073712185025215,
-0.5285395979881287,
0.1331302523612976,
-0.23805736005306244,
-0.8759139180183411,
0.39697909355163574,
0.6092641353607178,
0.8521593809127808,
-0.21049711108207703,
-0.09469137340784073,
-0.3390141725540161,
0.3996046185493469,
-0.5967163443565369,
0.6376922130584717,
-0.5430678725242615,
-0.6457695960998535,
0.13600020110607147,
-0.15285134315490723,
0.1641787439584732,
-0.41145655512809753,
0.4160076379776001,
0.017879003658890724,
0.44403576850891113,
-0.5216449499130249,
-1.3348815441131592,
-0.29759085178375244,
-0.08227221667766571,
-0.5566054582595825,
0.7428913712501526,
0.20209959149360657,
-0.683994472026825,
0.15903691947460175,
-0.7003728151321411,
-0.6160549521446228,
-0.10919730365276337,
-0.38806524872779846,
0.1372920274734497,
0.5490593314170837,
0.270643025636673,
0.5303354859352112,
0.16296836733818054,
-0.32876116037368774,
0.027761219069361687,
-0.38574060797691345,
0.3122192919254303,
-0.022485291585326195,
0.490922749042511,
0.3646167814731598,
-0.28850528597831726,
-0.07082533836364746,
-0.6078432202339172,
0.2636203169822693,
0.1851729452610016,
-0.5643697381019592,
-0.6120227575302124,
0.24519506096839905,
0.1551184505224228,
-0.2656261622905731,
0.22981691360473633,
-0.6787011623382568,
-0.04695836082100868,
-0.7153833508491516,
0.5691729187965393,
0.8406845927238464,
0.21622996032238007,
0.9219884276390076,
-0.6248764991760254,
0.4372614026069641,
-0.02941877581179142,
-0.32463550567626953,
-0.1921704113483429,
-0.254385381937027,
-0.7598168253898621,
-0.13707225024700165,
0.4959249496459961,
0.5111737847328186,
-0.8926342129707336,
0.88348388671875,
-0.36206573247909546,
0.006341984961181879,
-0.47217148542404175,
0.004933343268930912,
0.20769986510276794,
0.06454243510961533,
0.20473046600818634,
-0.14589586853981018,
-0.7393071055412292,
-0.9945449233055115,
-0.29272595047950745,
0.1444796621799469,
-0.033689528703689575,
-0.0026473277248442173,
0.25891974568367004,
-0.03858664259314537,
1.1419143676757812,
-0.9921460747718811,
-0.2275984287261963,
-0.2679388225078583,
-0.03646364063024521,
-0.1206338033080101,
0.5380470752716064,
0.6758221387863159,
-0.6408096551895142,
-0.47847649455070496,
-0.10888825356960297,
-0.6499975323677063,
-0.05344969034194946,
-0.006669213995337486,
-0.26492130756378174,
-0.005682834889739752,
0.7320951223373413,
-0.28212326765060425,
0.14212308824062347,
0.414465069770813,
0.06929917633533478,
-0.05439671501517296,
-0.2521870732307434,
-0.08748707920312881,
-1.2312901020050049,
-0.14523828029632568,
-0.060925353318452835,
-0.42193469405174255,
-0.5568428635597229,
0.267825722694397,
-0.338638037443161,
-0.055564478039741516,
-0.38245683908462524,
0.19472333788871765,
-0.5681588053703308,
0.2235552966594696,
-0.45264843106269836,
0.3777759075164795,
-0.04212845861911774,
0.502770185470581,
-0.19565239548683167,
0.4743827283382416,
0.4206177294254303,
-0.5936124324798584,
0.37374183535575867,
0.34271275997161865,
-0.5511066913604736,
0.651427686214447,
-0.803127646446228,
0.1874219924211502,
-0.5213521122932434,
0.04541096091270447,
-1.1473628282546997,
-0.12595902383327484,
0.22376573085784912,
-0.30785900354385376,
0.1705659031867981,
0.22971367835998535,
-0.31090009212493896,
-0.17783057689666748,
-0.48185163736343384,
0.25001487135887146,
0.6588299870491028,
-0.38467103242874146,
0.5057891011238098,
0.6090047359466553,
0.010255529545247555,
-0.30016064643859863,
-1.0148509740829468,
-0.17818544805049896,
-0.2659761309623718,
-0.5448135733604431,
0.8563438057899475,
-0.1970028132200241,
-0.08418960124254227,
0.37909647822380066,
-0.04846252128481865,
0.3136959373950958,
-0.11344294250011444,
0.09513722360134125,
-0.18182334303855896,
0.04954155534505844,
0.17586518824100494,
0.48172780871391296,
-0.11530754715204239,
-0.08132240921258926,
-0.18430304527282715,
0.3176518678665161,
0.240007683634758,
-0.32531389594078064,
0.06729769706726074,
0.9935836791992188,
0.3296353816986084,
0.022648321464657784,
0.459914892911911,
0.5585866570472717,
-0.5975537896156311,
-0.6484257578849792,
-0.3602902293205261,
-0.11293791979551315,
-0.4724479913711548,
0.26275086402893066,
-0.40595385432243347,
-0.8694477677345276,
0.4957539439201355,
-0.0169996228069067,
0.14317460358142853,
0.2392762452363968,
0.4138936996459961,
0.06542930752038956,
1.0521818399429321,
0.6357321739196777,
-0.0324680358171463,
0.48468437790870667,
-0.37919872999191284,
0.2965748906135559,
-0.9002730846405029,
-0.3682744801044464,
-0.43891140818595886,
-0.5476567149162292,
-0.6811367273330688,
-0.4623262584209442,
0.4762338399887085,
-0.15367472171783447,
-0.05985892191529274,
0.26718077063560486,
-0.8243252038955688,
0.7937150597572327,
0.7088394165039062,
0.4251417815685272,
-0.14291837811470032,
0.39872899651527405,
-0.5877886414527893,
-0.22190214693546295,
-0.7935067415237427,
-0.41245797276496887,
0.8457109928131104,
0.05076351761817932,
0.5720316767692566,
0.23003216087818146,
1.1060585975646973,
0.21294832229614258,
-0.1741323620080948,
-1.1469329595565796,
0.5356801152229309,
-0.24061676859855652,
-0.16993705928325653,
-0.11556193232536316,
-0.39378905296325684,
-0.9153567552566528,
0.30583399534225464,
-0.36136236786842346,
-0.4519036114215851,
0.0982295572757721,
-0.24853867292404175,
-0.24165861308574677,
-0.13271330296993256,
-0.8489534854888916,
0.5708882212638855,
0.04517284035682678,
-0.18664221465587616,
-0.09772809594869614,
-0.5405842661857605,
-0.09875466674566269,
0.3279229998588562,
0.14062994718551636,
0.13291531801223755,
-0.2831214964389801,
0.7398077249526978,
-0.5206643342971802,
0.5074210166931152,
-0.19832353293895721,
0.2552397549152374,
0.5055035948753357,
0.24082599580287933,
0.2996731996536255,
-0.25629666447639465,
0.19081668555736542,
-0.6518431901931763,
0.08957203477621078,
-0.37628602981567383,
-0.8406039476394653,
0.7590776085853577,
-0.48613759875297546,
-0.5947408080101013,
-0.1568479835987091,
-0.3364682197570801,
-0.19565333425998688,
0.0759749785065651,
0.4051886200904846,
0.4353336691856384,
-0.4490113854408264,
0.35763394832611084,
0.3231705129146576,
-0.19410009682178497,
0.5209419131278992,
-0.1573789417743683,
0.08520781248807907,
-0.5529822111129761,
0.8487695455551147,
0.12545114755630493,
0.05256019905209541,
0.6246476173400879,
0.39095833897590637,
-0.5336675047874451,
-0.4899652898311615,
-0.1697024703025818,
-0.041748300194740295,
-0.9953521490097046,
-0.14540594816207886,
-0.5425820350646973,
0.006104935891926289,
-0.10014256834983826,
-0.19704554975032806,
-0.1306486278772354,
-0.6271744966506958,
-0.45528385043144226,
-0.39158061146736145,
0.23103998601436615,
0.793182909488678,
-0.25885528326034546,
0.1415301114320755,
-0.5888587832450867,
0.0865202322602272,
0.3980751931667328,
-0.03469831869006157,
0.12331725656986237,
-0.10812537372112274,
-0.2095194011926651,
0.1479996293783188,
-0.607039749622345,
-0.9878293871879578,
0.19019891321659088,
0.3677789568901062,
1.023288607597351,
0.11096495389938354,
0.1005878672003746,
0.5290377140045166,
-0.7426784634590149,
1.0862658023834229,
0.3190285861492157,
-1.3264974355697632,
0.7116685509681702,
-0.06952807307243347,
0.07151377946138382,
0.47338375449180603,
0.45065757632255554,
-0.4232043921947479,
-0.4075523614883423,
-0.32650622725486755,
-0.9259284138679504,
0.08389347046613693,
0.37791678309440613,
0.6644619703292847,
-0.4258852005004883,
0.26559942960739136,
0.06171476095914841,
0.050613172352313995,
-0.4897880256175995,
-0.36442360281944275,
-0.12286948412656784,
-0.6323327422142029,
-0.08847565948963165,
-0.21846327185630798,
-0.21157342195510864,
-0.2542624771595001,
0.36227947473526,
-0.11054319888353348,
0.831565260887146,
0.24503058195114136,
-0.21603509783744812,
0.19616837799549103,
0.03921179473400116,
0.6387673020362854,
0.44189488887786865,
0.22497425973415375,
0.32297998666763306,
0.011883539147675037,
-0.031609851866960526,
0.5230252742767334,
-0.206281378865242,
-0.06438713520765305,
0.21108518540859222,
0.36547815799713135,
0.6688439846038818,
0.11376672238111496,
-0.4450373351573944,
0.7825626730918884,
0.3110979199409485,
-0.1563693881034851,
-0.035680271685123444,
0.12336026877164841,
0.13557273149490356,
0.19633449614048004,
0.10382931679487228,
-0.0980217307806015,
0.3677879869937897,
-0.5421232581138611,
0.23679429292678833,
0.266684889793396,
-0.12947264313697815,
-0.14999106526374817,
0.5357931852340698,
0.010720208287239075,
-0.0644097849726677,
0.46942323446273804,
-0.17105452716350555,
-0.6414573192596436,
0.3182101547718048,
0.6378050446510315,
0.8424245715141296,
-0.2258910983800888,
0.33812031149864197,
0.204279825091362,
-0.037229154258966446,
-0.24587860703468323,
0.5118575096130371,
-0.07461641728878021,
-0.8245692849159241,
-0.2706322968006134,
-0.3993103802204132,
-0.21996943652629852,
-0.5225774645805359,
-0.4735822379589081,
0.21085426211357117,
-0.34074801206588745,
-0.14379724860191345,
0.06611373275518417,
-0.20087853074073792,
-0.5635650753974915,
-0.08055014163255692,
-0.00012936251005157828,
0.39895373582839966,
-0.9622820019721985,
0.16714805364608765,
0.7228649854660034,
-0.36288365721702576,
-0.8629060983657837,
-0.24752788245677948,
-0.10548636317253113,
-0.40794557332992554,
0.3617589771747589,
0.12459669262170792,
0.18839555978775024,
-0.10666358470916748,
-0.7264893651008606,
-0.5307876467704773,
0.9110898375511169,
0.565384566783905,
-0.1753251999616623,
0.19015653431415558,
0.21692712604999542,
0.5514979362487793,
-0.6385483145713806,
-0.23637287318706512,
0.2154230922460556,
0.4772418737411499,
0.04013003408908844,
-0.275862455368042,
0.3483096957206726,
-0.2390703409910202,
0.4402715563774109,
-0.15182657539844513,
-0.2481856644153595,
0.7688902020454407,
0.19451627135276794,
-0.5156281590461731,
0.3145935535430908,
0.565394401550293,
0.00782486330717802,
0.02339758537709713,
0.3496861457824707,
0.6746677160263062,
0.6406145691871643,
-0.27454277873039246,
1.1630711555480957,
-0.13983598351478577,
0.3450049161911011,
0.7570969462394714,
0.11798974126577377,
0.6256206631660461,
0.5944928526878357,
-0.27308833599090576,
0.4858546257019043,
0.5568325519561768,
0.04462037235498428,
1.0689952373504639,
0.7287699580192566,
-0.3597407042980194,
-0.03937942534685135,
-0.19940410554409027,
-0.21889548003673553,
0.5098404884338379,
0.27942028641700745,
-0.5023059844970703,
0.09067613631486893,
0.4052291512489319,
-0.2544877529144287,
0.48030322790145874,
0.057317230850458145,
0.9890173673629761,
0.21319997310638428,
-0.5968202352523804,
0.5343172550201416,
0.3285112679004669,
0.5475006103515625,
-0.2519826889038086,
0.0030852656345814466,
-0.15354101359844208,
0.02509176917374134,
-0.15947087109088898,
-0.7035831809043884,
0.34993359446525574,
-0.6874547600746155,
-0.13615266978740692,
-0.2105111926794052,
0.3851693272590637,
-0.7126936912536621,
-0.35840967297554016,
-0.04956270754337311,
0.544712483882904,
-0.1440025120973587,
0.17793790996074677,
-0.24015392363071442,
0.17114706337451935,
0.053568728268146515,
-0.1057509332895279,
-0.12090621143579483,
0.5105412006378174,
0.31808507442474365,
0.31729769706726074,
0.4624919593334198,
0.06948932260274887,
0.1412174105644226,
-0.12947601079940796,
0.7969501614570618,
-0.5187132954597473,
-0.8709049820899963,
-0.8662506937980652,
0.4048381745815277,
-0.04749646410346031,
0.16051040589809418,
0.6311907172203064,
0.5357598066329956,
0.7294305562973022,
-0.3859565854072571,
1.0962097644805908,
-0.09987892210483551,
0.27598056197166443,
-0.8596985936164856,
0.128784641623497,
-0.6618592143058777,
-0.028516899794340134,
-0.4176056385040283,
-1.4851924180984497,
-0.411673903465271,
1.1204774379730225,
0.06771282851696014,
-0.041774824261665344,
0.9131643176078796,
0.7867153882980347,
-0.11592099815607071,
0.21997055411338806,
0.2173117995262146,
-0.22618889808654785,
0.2895393669605255,
0.6474806666374207,
0.9038659334182739,
-0.4448234438896179,
-0.03339415416121483,
-0.16162768006324768,
-0.07023195922374725,
0.05219804495573044,
-0.8786200881004333,
-0.7164118885993958,
-0.8360845446586609,
-0.33037179708480835,
-0.1800927370786667,
-0.18703895807266235,
1.283531904220581,
0.536716878414154,
-0.5304077863693237,
-0.09329064935445786,
-0.1932496875524521,
0.26005634665489197,
-0.2166322022676468,
-0.21913528442382812,
0.3991542458534241,
-0.36649447679519653,
-0.8566596508026123,
0.3909702003002167,
0.10551004856824875,
0.3216468095779419,
-0.36147162318229675,
-0.012754262425005436,
-0.006946594454348087,
0.3686121106147766,
0.87004554271698,
-0.2264638990163803,
-0.5078855752944946,
-0.6339242458343506,
0.07693790644407272,
0.018977688625454903,
0.0441412478685379,
1.0274680852890015,
-0.4380608797073364,
0.7105692028999329,
1.0686973333358765,
0.8870160579681396,
0.39842814207077026,
-0.012042301706969738,
0.7843636274337769,
-1.2425329685211182,
0.2607632875442505,
0.16896097362041473,
0.41044390201568604,
0.3799998164176941,
-0.1784224510192871,
0.34796521067619324,
0.1644122153520584,
-0.19843971729278564,
-0.5224862694740295,
0.3277495801448822,
-1.1587435007095337,
-0.46571940183639526,
1.0448976755142212,
-0.11332761496305466,
-0.2835331857204437,
0.25271037220954895,
-0.2531757056713104,
0.3061674237251282,
-0.12516629695892334,
0.46458208560943604,
0.7828167080879211,
0.0292411707341671,
0.12367535382509232,
-0.07187424600124359,
0.23531514406204224,
0.25333547592163086,
-0.5735616087913513,
-0.444573312997818,
0.6375216841697693,
0.26698172092437744,
0.37420183420181274,
0.1651248335838318,
-0.23874856531620026,
-0.10713307559490204,
0.06100305914878845,
-0.3371340334415436,
-0.29048487544059753,
-0.08258654177188873,
-0.014877582900226116,
0.30031445622444153,
-0.17494769394397736,
-0.5951985716819763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06699v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06699v1
|
In-Context Learning and Fine-Tuning GPT for Argument Mining
| 2024-06-10T18:01:55 | 2024-06-10T18:01:55 |
Jérémie Cabessa, Hugo Hernault, Umer Mushtaq
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become ubiquitous in NLP and deep learning.
In-Context Learning (ICL) has been suggested as a bridging paradigm between the
training-free and fine-tuning LLMs settings. In ICL, an LLM is conditioned to
solve tasks by means of a few solved demonstration examples included as prompt.
Argument Mining (AM) aims to extract the complex argumentative structure of a
text, and Argument Type Classification (ATC) is an essential sub-task of AM. We
introduce an ICL strategy for ATC combining kNN-based examples selection and
majority vote ensembling. In the training-free ICL setting, we show that GPT-4
is able to leverage relevant information from only a few demonstration examples
and achieve very competitive classification accuracy on ATC. We further set up
a fine-tuning strategy incorporating well-crafted structural features given
directly in textual form. In this setting, GPT-3.5 achieves state-of-the-art
performance on ATC. Overall, these results emphasize the emergent ability of
LLMs to grasp global discursive flow in raw text in both off-the-shelf and
fine-tuned setups.
|
[
-0.3646834194660187,
-0.7611407041549683,
0.7039483189582825,
-0.25843900442123413,
-0.8430840969085693,
0.06650826334953308,
-0.2932340204715729,
-0.11908867955207825,
-0.40873292088508606,
0.286624550819397,
-0.3434481620788574,
-0.7814156413078308,
-0.6204348206520081,
0.11276432126760483,
-0.21008402109146118,
1.3636027574539185,
-0.22451293468475342,
-0.04605335742235184,
-0.3362917900085449,
-0.2849062979221344,
-0.2444201558828354,
-0.7316702008247375,
-1.0266309976577759,
-0.5657459497451782,
0.3813788890838623,
0.7358402609825134,
0.40174368023872375,
0.7410914897918701,
-0.08784783631563187,
0.31978029012680054,
-0.108238086104393,
0.39384540915489197,
-0.11311564594507217,
0.20380890369415283,
-0.26707369089126587,
-0.40008074045181274,
-0.17458005249500275,
-0.026145493611693382,
0.6101524829864502,
0.25013017654418945,
-0.2570452094078064,
-0.17186613380908966,
0.2039082795381546,
0.30772942304611206,
-0.40721824765205383,
0.37676137685775757,
-1.1160043478012085,
0.012481600977480412,
-0.5270733833312988,
-0.30243390798568726,
-0.45453914999961853,
-0.27800482511520386,
0.1758939027786255,
-0.28417372703552246,
0.2651885151863098,
0.06938595324754715,
0.9217929244041443,
0.21180732548236847,
-0.3871021568775177,
-0.6976779699325562,
-0.2124461829662323,
0.6112984418869019,
-0.9999317526817322,
0.1531674563884735,
0.21353012323379517,
0.03864726051688194,
-0.2852073609828949,
-0.6810532212257385,
-0.4128681421279907,
-0.137807697057724,
-0.05153365433216095,
0.17888358235359192,
-0.05690503865480423,
0.23598505556583405,
0.15631616115570068,
0.34496456384658813,
-0.16834358870983124,
0.3879098892211914,
-0.03454377502202988,
0.030358076095581055,
0.41195550560951233,
-0.03969704359769821,
-0.016881363466382027,
-0.3249068260192871,
-0.2524474859237671,
0.09454847872257233,
-0.8632216453552246,
0.08779100328683853,
0.34537655115127563,
0.4909663200378418,
0.024064945057034492,
0.4646769165992737,
-0.05567849054932594,
0.6128182411193848,
0.32488054037094116,
0.0754593163728714,
-0.1879466325044632,
0.04605701193213463,
-0.23480698466300964,
0.43988093733787537,
0.7721300721168518,
0.03315763175487518,
0.1512884795665741,
0.033430468291044235,
-0.21465498208999634,
-0.12241285294294357,
-0.011509140953421593,
-0.8730065226554871,
-0.3546914756298065,
-0.11503991484642029,
-0.41772884130477905,
-0.37325519323349,
-0.11139116436243057,
-0.6373177170753479,
-0.514357328414917,
-0.4199979603290558,
0.22222623229026794,
-0.48353147506713867,
-0.08781764656305313,
0.1557549685239792,
0.02681700512766838,
0.3697412610054016,
0.2829776704311371,
-0.9550427794456482,
0.34738942980766296,
0.8989092707633972,
0.9731970429420471,
-0.17644089460372925,
0.08570339530706406,
-0.867254912853241,
0.16259203851222992,
-0.34019312262535095,
1.3273136615753174,
-0.7856207489967346,
-0.29337120056152344,
0.08059443533420563,
-0.29437920451164246,
-0.040701910853385925,
-0.6963393688201904,
1.0508543252944946,
-0.495616614818573,
0.3825015425682068,
-0.15744511783123016,
-0.9408139586448669,
-0.31968119740486145,
0.4303901493549347,
-0.3712303936481476,
0.7694939374923706,
0.01960214227437973,
-0.7184603810310364,
0.8131313323974609,
-0.9498103857040405,
-0.5873590111732483,
0.3892847001552582,
-0.41381868720054626,
-0.5583494901657104,
0.18728865683078766,
0.2957400679588318,
0.8347043395042419,
-0.21839962899684906,
0.10329234600067139,
-0.47060397267341614,
-0.1454761028289795,
-0.08917683362960815,
-0.5159285068511963,
0.49579599499702454,
0.18862445652484894,
-0.4189397096633911,
0.4199104905128479,
-0.4400295317173004,
0.09724212437868118,
-0.13258077204227448,
-0.4837893545627594,
-0.39792412519454956,
0.5848274230957031,
-0.3452337682247162,
0.30534297227859497,
-0.12882158160209656,
-0.4959460496902466,
0.2537665069103241,
-0.6913902759552002,
0.8293167948722839,
0.8359656929969788,
0.17089776694774628,
0.06080324202775955,
0.028756853193044662,
0.23199355602264404,
0.012315158732235432,
-0.24287723004817963,
0.13809938728809357,
-0.4956513047218323,
-0.7942581176757812,
-0.26846569776535034,
0.3069802522659302,
0.48171061277389526,
-0.6623954176902771,
0.42025741934776306,
-0.1883498728275299,
-0.2496984750032425,
-0.40696942806243896,
0.11721382290124893,
0.2534150183200836,
0.475749671459198,
0.37387755513191223,
-0.0011064602294936776,
-0.43207958340644836,
-0.8135152459144592,
-0.46353110671043396,
-0.3855913579463959,
-0.02607543021440506,
0.5096307396888733,
0.3540951907634735,
-0.06661062687635422,
0.9824033379554749,
-0.37625017762184143,
-0.2983092665672302,
-0.4727184772491455,
0.3215392529964447,
0.2303582727909088,
0.2396528273820877,
0.12698446214199066,
-0.6679678559303284,
-0.7033312916755676,
0.3836704194545746,
-0.5183329582214355,
-0.13719908893108368,
-0.0770864263176918,
0.20432302355766296,
0.33553674817085266,
0.7911498546600342,
-0.5601376295089722,
0.23159515857696533,
0.011180460453033447,
-0.32789090275764465,
0.3434441387653351,
-0.20999900996685028,
-0.020993761718273163,
-1.1837877035140991,
-0.4096955358982086,
0.19270896911621094,
-0.4059567451477051,
-0.429500013589859,
-0.07696942239999771,
-0.021406015381217003,
0.10525479167699814,
-0.38969624042510986,
0.45807594060897827,
-0.17703868448734283,
0.4712415933609009,
-0.4031617045402527,
0.030336054041981697,
-0.28350892663002014,
0.31814831495285034,
0.21209345757961273,
0.48468658328056335,
0.34994056820869446,
-0.5067746639251709,
0.23216357827186584,
0.03658689931035042,
-0.445009708404541,
0.6054529547691345,
-0.39366045594215393,
0.34671470522880554,
0.04947366192936897,
0.3063167333602905,
-0.799074649810791,
-0.32326173782348633,
0.17660903930664062,
-0.1429360806941986,
0.38882535696029663,
-0.517597496509552,
-0.6243289709091187,
-0.020954182371497154,
-0.21467626094818115,
0.18114915490150452,
0.20937511324882507,
-0.9157333970069885,
0.6179574131965637,
0.19347544014453888,
-0.2121068388223648,
-0.36238932609558105,
-0.17519521713256836,
0.19621829688549042,
-0.8365139365196228,
-0.2606211304664612,
0.3994746208190918,
0.08075691759586334,
-0.2392735332250595,
-0.13569258153438568,
0.02240634709596634,
0.03802676498889923,
0.008289137855172157,
0.13536208868026733,
-0.1286691427230835,
-0.1577564775943756,
0.20093843340873718,
0.20926164090633392,
-0.0897451713681221,
0.03155005723237991,
-0.25795218348503113,
0.45970702171325684,
-0.5583162903785706,
-0.3876678943634033,
-0.16488207876682281,
0.5006512403488159,
0.4120331406593323,
0.04298916831612587,
0.2557622790336609,
0.4640539586544037,
-0.2916760742664337,
-0.5473996996879578,
-0.3768060505390167,
-0.15232966840267181,
-0.5023176074028015,
0.5695788264274597,
-0.4658808708190918,
-0.977269172668457,
0.31281155347824097,
-0.4292091727256775,
0.3136575520038605,
0.4372362792491913,
0.7938562631607056,
0.022865308448672295,
1.104357123374939,
0.28098535537719727,
-0.27652469277381897,
0.4178379774093628,
-0.07431937009096146,
0.30787014961242676,
-0.6293389201164246,
0.06883729994297028,
-0.4975069463253021,
-0.14437806606292725,
-0.36281725764274597,
-0.21455997228622437,
0.18255120515823364,
0.22428612411022186,
-0.417807400226593,
0.05979827418923378,
-0.39033371210098267,
0.7683997750282288,
0.3494868576526642,
0.009914896450936794,
0.26085761189460754,
0.07069610059261322,
-0.2724643349647522,
-0.027306174859404564,
-0.8271755576133728,
-0.5672650337219238,
0.868806004524231,
0.36243563890457153,
0.48331892490386963,
-0.06383270025253296,
0.5933110117912292,
0.24762821197509766,
0.6604102253913879,
-1.0848240852355957,
0.6732044816017151,
-0.5425858497619629,
-0.3354777693748474,
-0.0018189592519775033,
-0.299849271774292,
-0.6364655494689941,
0.3202524483203888,
-0.11420860886573792,
-0.5901734232902527,
-0.12895989418029785,
0.32260820269584656,
-0.2872196137905121,
0.7200981974601746,
-0.8195108771324158,
0.845935583114624,
-0.08672423660755157,
-0.17143942415714264,
-0.33163973689079285,
-0.37726446986198425,
0.14346231520175934,
0.09951429814100266,
-0.08094251155853271,
0.16643385589122772,
0.05624089390039444,
0.61137455701828,
-0.25547388195991516,
0.84971022605896,
-0.4238322973251343,
-0.09565943479537964,
0.32868149876594543,
-0.15556183457374573,
0.5900216698646545,
0.3566461205482483,
-0.06365144997835159,
-0.01656402461230755,
-0.3807472884654999,
-0.07683492451906204,
-0.6021255254745483,
0.8161970376968384,
-0.5566790103912354,
-0.7860419750213623,
-0.4492713510990143,
-0.25919821858406067,
-0.36216333508491516,
-0.001617317902855575,
0.47302111983299255,
0.5673649311065674,
0.0005630245432257652,
0.5842257142066956,
0.6713831424713135,
0.10596741735935211,
0.5704923272132874,
0.3308523893356323,
0.4258914291858673,
-0.410590261220932,
0.879114031791687,
0.06242135539650917,
0.046545758843421936,
0.37057557702064514,
0.5963205099105835,
-0.6035808324813843,
-1.0025779008865356,
-0.6344971060752869,
-0.05079852417111397,
-0.9272267818450928,
-0.4239908456802368,
-0.5053118467330933,
-0.255454421043396,
0.11132033914327621,
-0.17170833051204681,
-0.2620376944541931,
-0.08848247677087784,
-0.33915677666664124,
-0.25871577858924866,
0.3031122088432312,
0.7144172787666321,
0.27494820952415466,
0.2508609890937805,
-0.39185401797294617,
-0.10395027697086334,
0.38766589760780334,
0.6861830949783325,
-0.11295600980520248,
-0.4424220025539398,
-0.26949506998062134,
-0.26833438873291016,
-0.4990641176700592,
-0.6114460825920105,
0.08565855026245117,
0.5191778540611267,
0.4605436623096466,
0.5780237913131714,
0.1159626767039299,
0.6896745562553406,
-0.6341821551322937,
0.7732567191123962,
-0.1257995367050171,
-0.8677645325660706,
0.4825279116630554,
-0.38898172974586487,
0.1758427619934082,
0.6380947828292847,
0.2676540017127991,
-0.4667281210422516,
-0.2622634172439575,
-0.630111813545227,
-0.9325516819953918,
0.5844636559486389,
-0.058666013181209564,
-0.1407419741153717,
-0.22789928317070007,
0.6539264917373657,
0.21371953189373016,
0.0452035553753376,
-1.008720874786377,
0.2240189164876938,
-0.28153422474861145,
-0.47645965218544006,
0.10311009734869003,
-0.050842028111219406,
-0.18595649302005768,
-0.43047407269477844,
0.7693732380867004,
-0.5456612706184387,
-0.08768001198768616,
0.12675881385803223,
-0.06182189658284187,
0.06843406707048416,
0.5613486766815186,
0.5023226141929626,
0.2665613889694214,
-0.11366653442382812,
0.14498557150363922,
0.4921087622642517,
-0.2188398838043213,
0.025458773598074913,
0.12158384174108505,
-0.07488515228033066,
-0.12504956126213074,
0.3807646334171295,
0.9146835207939148,
0.16381391882896423,
-0.38322120904922485,
0.3406060039997101,
-0.06181640923023224,
-0.602205216884613,
-0.20138634741306305,
0.11234992742538452,
-0.08542491495609283,
0.306651771068573,
0.23522113263607025,
0.09721875935792923,
0.12343624979257584,
-0.3510760962963104,
0.17182128131389618,
0.7849276065826416,
-0.5780947208404541,
-0.23711183667182922,
0.23793654143810272,
0.054979804903268814,
-0.19556072354316711,
0.4390040934085846,
-0.30074378848075867,
-0.7242953777313232,
0.18854938447475433,
0.6327546834945679,
1.1255005598068237,
0.14064951241016388,
0.026398727670311928,
0.11929943412542343,
-0.044219549745321274,
0.060235895216464996,
-0.09208065271377563,
-0.2093627005815506,
-0.7187365889549255,
-0.45279964804649353,
-0.38035622239112854,
-0.4598657190799713,
0.48417556285858154,
-0.26161497831344604,
0.3994481861591339,
-0.4764208197593689,
0.24159397184848785,
-0.1062704548239708,
0.32973378896713257,
-0.20598848164081573,
0.0524497888982296,
0.2584477961063385,
0.697449266910553,
-0.8262506127357483,
0.9716488718986511,
0.8609419465065002,
0.17340154945850372,
-0.6920427083969116,
0.12032055854797363,
-0.0033691972494125366,
-0.13416455686092377,
0.3714428246021271,
0.2759481966495514,
-0.27635663747787476,
-0.027467625215649605,
-0.7255913615226746,
-0.4039198160171509,
0.87611323595047,
0.4021635949611664,
-0.06510309875011444,
0.30031317472457886,
-0.020910853520035744,
0.4694962799549103,
-0.6856496334075928,
0.15187665820121765,
0.47350066900253296,
0.31808552145957947,
0.06240609660744667,
-0.5000529885292053,
0.038505662232637405,
-0.10923594981431961,
-0.1336430013179779,
0.19010193645954132,
-0.5692248344421387,
0.7535563707351685,
0.012441158294677734,
-0.350960910320282,
-0.22992698848247528,
0.8446769118309021,
0.4926203191280365,
0.22117185592651367,
1.0522117614746094,
0.6164992451667786,
0.6864087581634521,
-0.12332237511873245,
0.839788556098938,
0.08944325149059296,
0.1429954469203949,
1.1140170097351074,
-0.22922074794769287,
0.983034074306488,
0.26000115275382996,
0.1246759369969368,
0.7251121997833252,
1.0145429372787476,
0.15134197473526,
0.4744851291179657,
0.26428523659706116,
-0.5493414998054504,
-0.4933088719844818,
0.07991809397935867,
-0.12063472718000412,
0.48298346996307373,
0.6716993451118469,
-0.13724885880947113,
-0.508514940738678,
-0.05935345217585564,
0.3283134996891022,
0.1425522118806839,
-0.4449217617511749,
1.0918399095535278,
0.0747743770480156,
-0.7191739082336426,
0.46089428663253784,
0.00452023558318615,
0.8272860646247864,
-0.6927084922790527,
-0.25507575273513794,
-0.028802016749978065,
0.4549141824245453,
-0.26142725348472595,
-0.8201818466186523,
0.10820072889328003,
0.14604586362838745,
-0.2491643875837326,
-0.10360381752252579,
0.7596070766448975,
-0.41978326439857483,
-0.23807477951049805,
0.1692233383655548,
0.08611375093460083,
-0.009100661613047123,
-0.14713133871555328,
-0.714118242263794,
-0.4407573342323303,
0.09409715235233307,
-0.24455806612968445,
0.5098137259483337,
0.7363070845603943,
-0.36790987849235535,
0.6126918792724609,
0.540969967842102,
-0.011042851954698563,
-0.24934245645999908,
0.13534480333328247,
1.0796804428100586,
-0.4463019371032715,
-0.4896810054779053,
-1.2520548105239868,
0.28811243176460266,
-0.3497116267681122,
-0.5218486785888672,
0.5781159996986389,
0.6674829125404358,
0.7346556782722473,
0.07725394517183304,
0.7615504860877991,
0.022280337288975716,
0.40783482789993286,
-0.6531312465667725,
0.5451972484588623,
-0.4224359691143036,
0.10228245705366135,
-0.23414932191371918,
-0.6139993071556091,
-0.49135029315948486,
0.6869016289710999,
-0.34537631273269653,
-0.1369078904390335,
0.6851404905319214,
0.4663526713848114,
-0.29464060068130493,
0.27871471643447876,
-0.016173502430319786,
0.175059974193573,
0.9106714725494385,
0.4867769479751587,
0.6669044494628906,
-0.09438164532184601,
0.6200106739997864,
0.15372928977012634,
-0.4134969115257263,
-0.0402989387512207,
-1.2514033317565918,
-0.9352131485939026,
-0.5823943018913269,
-0.4852133095264435,
-0.20417189598083496,
-0.08721939474344254,
1.22972571849823,
0.8157598376274109,
-0.9327190518379211,
-0.2907814085483551,
-0.2597323954105377,
0.204637348651886,
-0.15537983179092407,
-0.1898263543844223,
0.5642170310020447,
-0.7089791893959045,
-0.5050055384635925,
0.6206634640693665,
0.2958446145057678,
-0.19497959315776825,
0.12570954859256744,
-0.13195891678333282,
-0.3569002151489258,
0.02400478534400463,
0.8096494674682617,
0.29170888662338257,
-0.8059386014938354,
-0.4415024518966675,
-0.5033326745033264,
0.36328765749931335,
0.2933039963245392,
0.954944372177124,
-0.7972589731216431,
0.2937917411327362,
0.2206931710243225,
0.6161684989929199,
0.45396140217781067,
0.18130771815776825,
0.5219282507896423,
-0.9885174036026001,
-0.03645653650164604,
0.36142104864120483,
0.49601462483406067,
0.4015994668006897,
-0.1858370453119278,
0.2965840697288513,
0.08331067115068436,
-0.7722002267837524,
-0.7181571125984192,
0.3468949496746063,
-0.8151206970214844,
-0.3063911497592926,
1.1912118196487427,
-0.18374274671077728,
0.05637221038341522,
-0.433498352766037,
-0.40478238463401794,
0.111065573990345,
-0.5453442931175232,
0.7069439888000488,
1.000672459602356,
-0.1579115390777588,
-0.19565941393375397,
-0.5043459534645081,
1.0189343690872192,
0.2797452211380005,
-0.7941465377807617,
0.3894422650337219,
0.25825875997543335,
0.19902309775352478,
-0.050356220453977585,
0.3176661729812622,
-0.1645268052816391,
-0.10310456901788712,
-0.4254184365272522,
-0.41565144062042236,
0.06106658652424812,
-0.1640477031469345,
-0.2770215570926666,
0.6164954304695129,
0.2221217304468155,
0.06302447617053986
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.10258v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.10258v2
|
Curating Grounded Synthetic Data with Global Perspectives for Equitable AI
| 2024-06-10T17:59:11 | 2024-06-18T08:58:42 |
Elin Törnquist, Robert Alexander Caulk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
The development of robust AI models relies heavily on the quality and variety
of training data available. In fields where data scarcity is prevalent,
synthetic data generation offers a vital solution. In this paper, we introduce
a novel approach to creating synthetic datasets, grounded in real-world
diversity and enriched through strategic diversification. We synthesize data
using a comprehensive collection of news articles spanning 12 languages and
originating from 125 countries, to ensure a breadth of linguistic and cultural
representations. Through enforced topic diversification, translation, and
summarization, the resulting dataset accurately mirrors real-world complexities
and addresses the issue of underrepresentation in traditional datasets. This
methodology, applied initially to Named Entity Recognition (NER), serves as a
model for numerous AI disciplines where data diversification is critical for
generalizability. Preliminary results demonstrate substantial improvements in
performance on traditional NER benchmarks, by up to 7.3%, highlighting the
effectiveness of our synthetic data in mimicking the rich, varied nuances of
global data sources. This paper outlines the strategies employed for
synthesizing diverse datasets and provides such a curated dataset for NER.
|
[
-0.5222411751747131,
-0.4732099771499634,
0.2797136902809143,
0.015875114127993584,
-0.10100481659173965,
0.6728888750076294,
-0.3466950058937073,
-0.6752792596817017,
0.48002421855926514,
0.14159542322158813,
-0.4660000503063202,
-0.41935548186302185,
-0.3727463483810425,
0.23038078844547272,
-0.39128097891807556,
1.3865714073181152,
-0.010068799369037151,
0.15030436217784882,
-0.2602274417877197,
-0.5093874335289001,
-0.3140561580657959,
-0.34807851910591125,
-0.4847002327442169,
-0.09769400954246521,
0.4380919635295868,
0.41005679965019226,
0.5967506170272827,
0.7354964017868042,
0.24592693150043488,
0.285722017288208,
0.13109372556209564,
0.6768163442611694,
-0.5302232503890991,
0.16966544091701508,
-0.33835622668266296,
-0.40243691205978394,
-0.18549174070358276,
0.2032330483198166,
0.8309738636016846,
0.7697591781616211,
0.08745407313108444,
0.18309061229228973,
-0.11840065568685532,
0.43475455045700073,
-0.4857374429702759,
0.013797277584671974,
-0.804395854473114,
0.2860490083694458,
-0.10746239870786667,
0.40593746304512024,
0.0011019654339179397,
-0.23446479439735413,
0.25122421979904175,
-0.9553892612457275,
0.5435388088226318,
-0.07742702215909958,
0.6030299067497253,
0.2777588665485382,
-0.5141599774360657,
0.007006464991718531,
-1.1529086828231812,
0.8300502896308899,
-0.237249955534935,
0.4252632260322571,
-0.1382434219121933,
0.6121708750724792,
-0.019390469416975975,
-0.7113625407218933,
-0.6422113180160522,
0.05452161654829979,
0.2002301663160324,
0.04104459658265114,
-0.004729159642010927,
-0.39887097477912903,
0.19288849830627441,
0.3502388000488281,
-0.389830619096756,
0.11400722712278366,
-0.49564987421035767,
-0.2162499874830246,
1.0130106210708618,
0.09487461298704147,
0.446527898311615,
0.1963990032672882,
0.028824685141444206,
-0.19199910759925842,
-0.7661451697349548,
-0.0003981027693953365,
0.6778317093849182,
0.5150372982025146,
-0.1304129809141159,
0.49094507098197937,
-0.5014616250991821,
0.41104117035865784,
-0.13909871876239777,
-0.03689277917146683,
0.4381265938282013,
-0.42780303955078125,
0.064988873898983,
0.0840691402554512,
0.4921000599861145,
0.29311084747314453,
0.2910231351852417,
-0.5098459720611572,
-0.17355979979038239,
0.053334373980760574,
0.43296709656715393,
-0.5891196131706238,
-0.16822713613510132,
0.12296175211668015,
-0.20850425958633423,
-0.2826984226703644,
0.4626922905445099,
-0.9390760660171509,
-0.43096300959587097,
-0.7042261362075806,
-0.10180920362472534,
-0.1358467936515808,
-0.1814528852701187,
-0.3248254060745239,
-0.3863294720649719,
0.33600637316703796,
0.3602127432823181,
-0.6525765657424927,
0.2769372761249542,
0.7530835866928101,
0.6209877729415894,
-0.3710252642631531,
-0.11569064855575562,
-0.29984647035598755,
0.18799568712711334,
-0.2124393731355667,
0.6384406685829163,
-0.5982233285903931,
-0.31277984380722046,
-0.19165454804897308,
-0.1420624852180481,
0.36233434081077576,
-0.8512930274009705,
0.41198545694351196,
-0.25349846482276917,
0.08229703456163406,
-0.17322178184986115,
-0.24648478627204895,
-0.1264152228832245,
0.536936342716217,
-0.8941499590873718,
0.7553052306175232,
0.031056275591254234,
-0.6977331638336182,
0.831495463848114,
-0.5404826402664185,
-0.5820904970169067,
0.03964175283908844,
-0.6513142585754395,
-0.44828322529792786,
0.16583393514156342,
0.5350126028060913,
0.0360540933907032,
-0.3460296392440796,
0.796271800994873,
-0.19452644884586334,
-0.1761762797832489,
0.10879912972450256,
-0.4454256594181061,
0.518878161907196,
0.2120109349489212,
-0.2106056660413742,
0.0003051056992262602,
-1.1005431413650513,
-0.011651327833533287,
0.07535560429096222,
-0.1668129712343216,
-0.5143595337867737,
0.16275238990783691,
0.2645137310028076,
0.1085255891084671,
-0.1781899482011795,
-0.5018177628517151,
0.22980919480323792,
-0.5515061020851135,
0.45336997509002686,
0.5518555641174316,
0.08573932945728302,
0.6571781039237976,
-0.5457338094711304,
0.46672725677490234,
0.13448448479175568,
-0.03750589117407799,
0.07910367846488953,
-0.48320135474205017,
-0.803657054901123,
-0.4358827769756317,
0.5053032040596008,
0.6220078468322754,
-0.6559177041053772,
0.4083145260810852,
-0.7031407356262207,
-0.6275997757911682,
-0.6653754115104675,
-0.05006475746631622,
-0.09515786916017532,
0.3499337434768677,
0.5023669004440308,
-0.0183141827583313,
-0.9354566335678101,
-1.1178810596466064,
-0.4854229688644409,
0.12008803337812424,
-0.19016632437705994,
0.5018004775047302,
0.5566657781600952,
-0.5209323763847351,
1.3036400079727173,
-0.27682963013648987,
-0.07419329136610031,
-0.40372633934020996,
0.07410886138677597,
0.14263133704662323,
0.7854247093200684,
0.3932291865348816,
-1.0608750581741333,
-0.19474533200263977,
-0.05065794289112091,
-0.8119783401489258,
0.3174140453338623,
-0.5361230373382568,
-0.4083690941333771,
-0.19717326760292053,
0.2533486485481262,
-0.5870658755302429,
0.2454955130815506,
0.025679850950837135,
0.054110608994960785,
0.09699508547782898,
0.19904465973377228,
-0.039173997938632965,
-1.3062748908996582,
0.2582107484340668,
-0.07888755202293396,
-0.12338795512914658,
-0.5427520871162415,
0.23659129440784454,
-0.27013063430786133,
-0.4037603735923767,
-0.36558589339256287,
0.8476450443267822,
-0.44405460357666016,
0.08730979263782501,
0.2311888188123703,
-0.13827277719974518,
-0.09580788016319275,
0.05078024044632912,
-0.012666051276028156,
0.5008363127708435,
0.39001235365867615,
-0.48393040895462036,
0.40605276823043823,
0.30044806003570557,
-0.18941301107406616,
0.41139453649520874,
-0.7286118865013123,
-0.07114700227975845,
-0.4277164936065674,
0.42018669843673706,
-0.33669573068618774,
-0.5562763214111328,
0.2967444658279419,
-0.2625964283943176,
0.23567530512809753,
-0.133631631731987,
-0.24826684594154358,
-0.18546441197395325,
-0.1421571671962738,
0.943855345249176,
0.4473738968372345,
-0.6462796926498413,
0.6841415166854858,
0.8076887726783752,
-0.09643921256065369,
-0.5586043000221252,
-0.7856729626655579,
0.22978200018405914,
-0.45021918416023254,
-0.4862063527107239,
0.805140495300293,
0.12053672224283218,
-0.412789523601532,
0.023704148828983307,
-0.2787313759326935,
-0.06539982557296753,
0.15983225405216217,
0.18560872972011566,
0.13996489346027374,
0.03737917169928551,
0.1205005794763565,
0.2666685879230499,
0.05474533885717392,
-0.04492320492863655,
-0.6391032338142395,
0.2258441299200058,
0.16058291494846344,
-0.3406110107898712,
-0.10973277688026428,
0.44976693391799927,
0.39284011721611023,
-0.3372923731803894,
0.6733511090278625,
0.6542983651161194,
-0.7419349551200867,
-0.6252159476280212,
-0.2850019931793213,
-0.09914883971214294,
-0.4015166461467743,
0.14177663624286652,
-0.15213654935359955,
-0.7977136373519897,
0.7167807221412659,
-0.15781567990779877,
0.15467460453510284,
0.4088587462902069,
0.39251255989074707,
0.22679592669010162,
0.90406733751297,
0.5828890204429626,
-0.309903085231781,
0.24057668447494507,
-0.6280713677406311,
0.5908833146095276,
-0.5307568311691284,
-0.5329107642173767,
-0.31720948219299316,
-0.744076669216156,
-1.0072827339172363,
-0.5243483781814575,
0.4384196996688843,
-0.3039619028568268,
-0.19744499027729034,
-0.1265258938074112,
-0.5586075782775879,
0.6624331474304199,
0.6856536269187927,
-0.014371675439178944,
0.11647802591323853,
0.26248157024383545,
0.004757331684231758,
-0.18686002492904663,
-0.47481945157051086,
-0.545799970626831,
1.2222697734832764,
0.07084858417510986,
0.586410403251648,
-0.00611720560118556,
1.067592978477478,
0.3934957981109619,
0.35917821526527405,
-0.7032250165939331,
0.42377161979675293,
-0.02090027928352356,
-0.494476318359375,
-0.19389118254184723,
-0.5810725092887878,
-0.9845132827758789,
0.050994228571653366,
-0.4455563426017761,
-0.3406178653240204,
0.38480594754219055,
-0.14555232226848602,
-0.3657224774360657,
0.22054524719715118,
-0.23189666867256165,
0.6247706413269043,
-0.177620530128479,
-0.2151898294687271,
-0.10975344479084015,
-0.4879612922668457,
0.4369274377822876,
-0.20844697952270508,
0.3466188311576843,
-0.034024517983198166,
-0.02255084179341793,
0.5475849509239197,
-0.2020568698644638,
0.5375202298164368,
0.013656538911163807,
0.16644132137298584,
0.3274836242198944,
-0.30139145255088806,
0.3874562978744507,
0.7571325898170471,
-0.1752743124961853,
0.2707759439945221,
-0.5888347625732422,
-0.43799102306365967,
-0.6469925045967102,
0.8153162002563477,
-1.003614902496338,
-0.5400554537773132,
-0.46221834421157837,
-0.7047349214553833,
-0.31923192739486694,
0.16302205622196198,
0.12373385578393936,
0.18013080954551697,
-0.6202051043510437,
0.29035183787345886,
0.3728347718715668,
-0.3497820794582367,
0.10472372174263,
0.1258603036403656,
0.22195236384868622,
-0.613876461982727,
1.0763579607009888,
0.37514549493789673,
-0.3348689675331116,
0.31664037704467773,
-0.375572144985199,
-0.042853571474552155,
-0.4619041085243225,
-0.5813114047050476,
-0.08887854218482971,
-0.43395671248435974,
-0.27163058519363403,
-0.7835390567779541,
-0.49384522438049316,
-0.35281917452812195,
-0.20557178556919098,
-0.25343674421310425,
-0.7415503263473511,
-0.23676183819770813,
-0.4339366555213928,
0.1430148482322693,
0.5118418335914612,
-0.050648145377635956,
-0.17543549835681915,
-0.7000720500946045,
0.5392900705337524,
0.2667215168476105,
0.20402196049690247,
-0.11354164034128189,
-0.0886496901512146,
-0.2628851532936096,
0.45222777128219604,
-0.23014573752880096,
-0.5873145461082458,
0.6207045316696167,
0.5151898860931396,
1.0375666618347168,
0.08584516495466232,
0.19571241736412048,
0.709289014339447,
-0.5382946729660034,
0.7818408012390137,
-0.28600379824638367,
-0.7605826258659363,
0.6708880662918091,
-0.3530946373939514,
0.0029613166116178036,
0.6726388931274414,
0.4840978682041168,
-0.3666660785675049,
-0.487179696559906,
-0.775114119052887,
-1.328454613685608,
0.5130359530448914,
0.31516680121421814,
0.4739486575126648,
-0.038836803287267685,
0.2987546920776367,
0.4447857141494751,
0.3026450574398041,
-0.6056150197982788,
-0.14249210059642792,
-0.34421926736831665,
-0.5491097569465637,
0.05168001726269722,
0.32426461577415466,
-0.2480584979057312,
-0.40054985880851746,
0.6336666345596313,
-0.10993067920207977,
0.07416865229606628,
0.13324151933193207,
-0.23224584758281708,
0.2770470976829529,
0.12080910801887512,
0.14433938264846802,
0.43577584624290466,
0.24407854676246643,
0.10063556581735611,
0.10826019197702408,
-0.3646894097328186,
0.3537462651729584,
0.3420681059360504,
-0.6313847303390503,
-0.02879500947892666,
0.25175178050994873,
0.6142860651016235,
-0.15884406864643097,
-0.9707887768745422,
-0.06072862073779106,
-0.14727361500263214,
0.1406419277191162,
-0.35051363706588745,
0.3255012035369873,
-0.16880446672439575,
0.3433752954006195,
0.46317967772483826,
0.2783324122428894,
0.36939460039138794,
-0.5705468058586121,
0.4265190362930298,
0.4220767319202423,
0.3213154375553131,
-0.19083663821220398,
0.6975239515304565,
0.28270095586776733,
-0.07073061913251877,
1.1189846992492676,
-0.4501296281814575,
-0.32754141092300415,
0.9304027557373047,
0.38234418630599976,
0.810252845287323,
0.1835639625787735,
0.42347773909568787,
0.566958487033844,
0.1182585209608078,
-0.05408788472414017,
0.26836052536964417,
-0.11789160221815109,
-0.8357492089271545,
-0.004065308719873428,
-0.6003116369247437,
-0.4171075224876404,
0.019861167296767235,
-0.5601096153259277,
0.24657928943634033,
-0.5848746299743652,
-0.19716262817382812,
-0.03288999944925308,
-0.04094700887799263,
-0.9978266358375549,
0.3047356605529785,
0.3791002035140991,
0.5902804732322693,
-0.9159191846847534,
0.5159469842910767,
0.8661556243896484,
-0.5418710708618164,
-0.5826292634010315,
0.18919578194618225,
-0.06429784744977951,
-0.6166982650756836,
0.6293225288391113,
0.38938668370246887,
0.5163496732711792,
-0.06498804688453674,
-0.5703027844429016,
-1.0472233295440674,
1.0791610479354858,
0.4356405436992645,
-0.3473000228404999,
-0.008862204849720001,
0.49466636776924133,
0.6965516209602356,
-0.6056148409843445,
-0.06560813635587692,
0.48508238792419434,
0.4848441779613495,
-0.02398582547903061,
-0.44565001130104065,
-0.020885638892650604,
-0.696017324924469,
0.07978256046772003,
-0.033599045127630234,
-0.5627306699752808,
0.7912336587905884,
-0.2775706350803375,
-0.3989531397819519,
-0.21144042909145355,
0.7414160370826721,
0.5586592555046082,
0.4461197257041931,
0.16119486093521118,
0.7365008592605591,
0.9920169711112976,
-0.210876926779747,
0.7504638433456421,
-0.21305212378501892,
-0.02392449602484703,
1.0324572324752808,
-0.36647993326187134,
0.3780500292778015,
0.3719055652618408,
-0.0874723270535469,
0.5832774043083191,
0.6891428828239441,
-0.5503453612327576,
0.49252113699913025,
0.4533645212650299,
-0.18620823323726654,
-0.15013527870178223,
-0.4961302876472473,
-0.19873131811618805,
0.662988543510437,
0.293283075094223,
-0.2674782872200012,
-0.27485278248786926,
0.04855427145957947,
-0.290054589509964,
0.0987439826130867,
-0.1562451422214508,
0.7519323229789734,
-0.0536714568734169,
-0.700306236743927,
0.22859647870063782,
0.13009442389011383,
0.576530396938324,
-0.11748522520065308,
-0.31818222999572754,
-0.5195866227149963,
0.0010689349146559834,
-0.09857503324747086,
-0.5647179484367371,
0.47731688618659973,
0.1408316045999527,
-0.47957152128219604,
-0.23861615359783173,
0.55414879322052,
-0.5342912673950195,
-0.8746191263198853,
-0.08732352405786514,
0.7403949499130249,
-0.011783478781580925,
0.11748115718364716,
-0.504831075668335,
-0.1827523559331894,
-0.04150763899087906,
0.10719146579504013,
0.29076457023620605,
0.5800158977508545,
-0.5518090128898621,
0.6055124402046204,
0.8510490655899048,
0.1874241977930069,
0.030382387340068817,
0.06270325183868408,
0.93804532289505,
-0.5531282424926758,
-0.6948938965797424,
-0.7424982786178589,
0.6701593995094299,
-0.40262818336486816,
-0.3117663860321045,
0.5645163655281067,
0.8264451622962952,
1.2084603309631348,
-0.0014754512812942266,
1.1543563604354858,
-0.08933605998754501,
0.23217536509037018,
-0.25190943479537964,
0.7096232175827026,
-0.4680549204349518,
0.2635563910007477,
0.11282753199338913,
-0.9939013123512268,
-0.3862762451171875,
0.5376899838447571,
-0.04052675887942314,
0.17361493408679962,
-0.18350882828235626,
0.5404348969459534,
-0.4294498562812805,
-0.019208654761314392,
-0.1604791134595871,
0.006479618605226278,
0.5388693809509277,
0.2597954273223877,
0.7757781147956848,
-0.3563619554042816,
0.19793152809143066,
-0.09620505571365356,
0.09814240038394928,
-0.01877996139228344,
-0.7602161169052124,
-0.5947530269622803,
-0.327108234167099,
-0.32791030406951904,
0.07930488884449005,
0.04228004440665245,
1.1914913654327393,
0.8441049456596375,
-1.0904492139816284,
0.1687345653772354,
-0.3477625846862793,
0.2851199209690094,
-0.017089271917939186,
-0.2307662069797516,
0.02996787801384926,
-0.20834343135356903,
-0.9031881093978882,
0.5072523355484009,
-0.052002426236867905,
0.29560571908950806,
-0.23974743485450745,
-0.022309046238660812,
0.17199555039405823,
-0.03316689655184746,
0.33000481128692627,
0.3660842478275299,
-0.5432594418525696,
-0.11928966641426086,
-0.08681407570838928,
0.2066890150308609,
-0.10382240265607834,
0.7831956148147583,
-1.1876064538955688,
0.3733097016811371,
0.4850881099700928,
1.0604240894317627,
0.056338366121053696,
0.13992393016815186,
0.859383225440979,
-1.0157577991485596,
0.40487444400787354,
0.6088711023330688,
0.3545801639556885,
0.6189171075820923,
-0.4356783628463745,
0.6686280369758606,
0.3661477565765381,
-0.23778651654720306,
-1.0210975408554077,
0.10437113046646118,
-0.7482905983924866,
-0.1461247354745865,
0.9532740116119385,
0.03753075376152992,
0.15559473633766174,
-0.05435464531183243,
-0.010915153659880161,
0.4624278247356415,
-0.5175482034683228,
0.9434887766838074,
0.4923628270626068,
-0.04984182119369507,
0.17362534999847412,
-0.3636743426322937,
0.4001091718673706,
0.05008948594331741,
-0.9984334111213684,
-0.2277604341506958,
0.7525270581245422,
0.13814347982406616,
0.18251538276672363,
0.007820675149559975,
-0.007006776053458452,
-0.10095366090536118,
0.010910185053944588,
-0.07958638668060303,
0.042256973683834076,
-0.7142543792724609,
-0.016709761694073677,
0.008898588828742504,
-0.3441689610481262,
0.15976831316947937
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06496v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06496v2
|
Direct Preference Optimization for Suppressing Hallucinated Prior Exams in Radiology Report Generation
| 2024-06-10T17:31:36 | 2024-06-14T19:47:20 |
Oishi Banerjee, Hong-Yu Zhou, Subathra Adithan, Stephen Kwak, Kay Wu, Pranav Rajpurkar
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Recent advances in generative vision-language models (VLMs) have exciting
potential implications for AI in radiology, yet VLMs are also known to produce
hallucinations, nonsensical text, and other unwanted behaviors that can waste
clinicians' time and cause patient harm. Drawing on recent work on direct
preference optimization (DPO), we propose a simple method for modifying the
behavior of pretrained VLMs performing radiology report generation by
suppressing unwanted types of generations. We apply our method to the
prevention of hallucinations of prior exams, addressing a long-established
problem behavior in models performing chest X-ray report generation. Across our
experiments, we find that DPO fine-tuning achieves a 3.2-4.8x reduction in
lines hallucinating prior exams while maintaining model performance on clinical
accuracy metrics. Our work is, to the best of our knowledge, the first work to
apply DPO to medical VLMs, providing a data- and compute- efficient way to
suppress problem behaviors while maintaining overall clinical accuracy.
|
[
-0.4225720167160034,
-0.40468716621398926,
0.8474112749099731,
-0.041696783155202866,
-0.5011569261550903,
-0.39089536666870117,
-0.04691973701119423,
-0.35411080718040466,
0.12982289493083954,
1.0185494422912598,
-0.5173394083976746,
-0.4362553060054779,
-0.5557992458343506,
0.08182547986507416,
-0.05413960665464401,
0.7900015115737915,
0.05015946924686432,
0.24504882097244263,
-0.40662842988967896,
0.19347912073135376,
-0.6279941201210022,
-0.6792104840278625,
-0.6766639947891235,
-0.341162770986557,
0.40752729773521423,
0.22081543505191803,
0.8259121775627136,
0.6112393736839294,
0.725134551525116,
0.12834127247333527,
0.01588618755340576,
0.42865049839019775,
-0.6282880902290344,
0.232655331492424,
0.2178325206041336,
-0.2478773146867752,
-0.6006067395210266,
-0.3256385028362274,
0.4108087122440338,
0.6431149244308472,
0.004702100530266762,
-0.21397681534290314,
-0.17475582659244537,
1.005959153175354,
-0.8680777549743652,
-0.061263907700777054,
-0.5831716060638428,
0.41008543968200684,
0.127815842628479,
-0.9969499707221985,
-0.7955640554428101,
-0.32523584365844727,
0.11303184181451797,
-0.5650022625923157,
0.3333316743373871,
-0.15386179089546204,
0.9354334473609924,
0.6592026352882385,
-0.2036745697259903,
-0.0634368434548378,
-0.9856471419334412,
0.5797478556632996,
-0.28746894001960754,
0.4284009337425232,
0.7393174767494202,
-0.010098119266331196,
-0.06796703487634659,
-0.6874139904975891,
-0.1721600890159607,
-0.4161728024482727,
-0.29145580530166626,
0.22748759388923645,
-0.3894056975841522,
0.5445526838302612,
0.29940757155418396,
0.27081432938575745,
-0.8051633834838867,
0.16563308238983154,
-0.423951655626297,
-0.1924368143081665,
0.728651225566864,
0.4352691173553467,
-0.11557292938232422,
-0.18893952667713165,
-0.23053881525993347,
-0.21130765974521637,
-0.8639337420463562,
-0.2702093720436096,
-0.04796129837632179,
-0.03975670784711838,
0.5329008102416992,
0.4313945174217224,
-0.4997415244579315,
0.8374997973442078,
0.2148471623659134,
-0.0069564338773489,
0.4792874753475189,
0.03314564749598503,
-0.39863458275794983,
0.18316739797592163,
0.40134668350219727,
0.5711485743522644,
0.0545867495238781,
-0.050377752631902695,
-0.1812514066696167,
0.3252948224544525,
0.6154100298881531,
-0.8851684927940369,
-0.3235439658164978,
0.2062075138092041,
-0.74959397315979,
-0.8490781188011169,
-0.2178688645362854,
-0.7741736173629761,
-0.5538979768753052,
-0.6024207472801208,
0.47224146127700806,
-0.2930162250995636,
-0.11509179323911667,
0.45157861709594727,
0.13893184065818787,
0.06421232968568802,
0.31068718433380127,
-0.6385973691940308,
0.31446805596351624,
0.42553338408470154,
0.4919090270996094,
0.028837118297815323,
-0.13313858211040497,
-1.0225595235824585,
0.14566780626773834,
-0.38301020860671997,
0.6107459664344788,
-0.4692283272743225,
-0.9578931331634521,
-0.11988982558250427,
-0.2862626314163208,
0.07984078675508499,
-0.8606324195861816,
0.46157413721084595,
-0.4160800874233246,
0.0861116498708725,
-0.032540690153837204,
-0.35429102182388306,
0.0809251070022583,
0.0066370912827551365,
-0.2667681872844696,
0.5742986798286438,
-0.04016326367855072,
-0.5170660018920898,
0.5058886408805847,
-0.2823638617992401,
-0.5667611956596375,
0.09811564534902573,
-0.43456998467445374,
-0.49310654401779175,
0.4541738033294678,
0.27394306659698486,
0.29859912395477295,
0.04793854430317879,
0.23900969326496124,
0.0924108549952507,
-0.42559656500816345,
-0.10340449959039688,
-0.1587783694267273,
0.491536945104599,
0.42071089148521423,
-0.3760680556297302,
0.46736371517181396,
-0.8109669089317322,
0.23968848586082458,
0.249211847782135,
0.1579471230506897,
-0.6711273789405823,
0.16477204859256744,
-0.5882670283317566,
0.18026582896709442,
-0.08250385522842407,
-0.2676674723625183,
0.15956099331378937,
-0.3054943084716797,
-0.16840577125549316,
0.9181034564971924,
0.0412663035094738,
0.12164989858865738,
-0.4857543408870697,
0.36248740553855896,
0.028394583612680435,
0.7551108598709106,
0.3438696563243866,
-0.37318164110183716,
-0.905310869216919,
-0.27768808603286743,
-0.26834118366241455,
0.3355843126773834,
-0.714942991733551,
0.4503142237663269,
-0.0944308340549469,
-0.38898342847824097,
-0.3261488974094391,
-0.16870464384555817,
0.4030306041240692,
0.8503496646881104,
0.38433638215065,
-0.3984750509262085,
-0.7162411212921143,
-0.9492591023445129,
0.24228540062904358,
-0.1660168319940567,
0.01023155264556408,
0.29138365387916565,
0.061585038900375366,
-0.3478028178215027,
0.6626595854759216,
-1.1481252908706665,
-0.5041140913963318,
-0.04544927179813385,
-0.0638299286365509,
-0.07192486524581909,
0.4523793160915375,
0.5996599793434143,
-0.9483956694602966,
-0.3295023441314697,
-0.1633937805891037,
-0.6981090903282166,
-0.17448341846466064,
-0.13349312543869019,
-0.287788063287735,
0.40364402532577515,
0.643232524394989,
-0.29914236068725586,
0.8271886110305786,
0.3229359984397888,
-0.324872761964798,
0.3964619040489197,
-0.4976927936077118,
0.06339434534311295,
-0.3437270224094391,
-0.02513037621974945,
-0.16974510252475739,
-0.19010065495967865,
-0.6929251551628113,
0.06854011863470078,
-0.11825075000524521,
-0.2277638018131256,
-0.2452915459871292,
0.41330453753471375,
-0.47248774766921997,
0.28152039647102356,
-0.3450324237346649,
-0.3070155680179596,
0.11680571734905243,
0.29698416590690613,
0.7852620482444763,
0.21921822428703308,
0.5650458335876465,
-0.8353727459907532,
-0.1860237568616867,
0.46485409140586853,
-0.09230001270771027,
0.2914021611213684,
-0.5058682560920715,
0.5555052757263184,
-0.534182071685791,
-0.10890619456768036,
-0.49107998609542847,
0.15291695296764374,
0.32186272740364075,
-0.3265434205532074,
0.4529656171798706,
0.06491155177354813,
-0.027992233633995056,
-0.5378490090370178,
-0.4520881474018097,
0.18411292135715485,
0.811144232749939,
-0.34012284874916077,
0.2814315855503082,
0.13933834433555603,
0.026103541254997253,
-0.5254576206207275,
-0.47614434361457825,
-0.18691737949848175,
0.09049785882234573,
-0.4669148623943329,
0.5638587474822998,
-0.2577921748161316,
-0.36296015977859497,
0.034482136368751526,
-0.3056384027004242,
-0.16418446600437164,
-0.025046823546290398,
0.29126662015914917,
0.5589670538902283,
-0.2239990532398224,
-0.025926612317562103,
0.05091677978634834,
-0.339053750038147,
-0.0809941366314888,
-0.08328289538621902,
0.8275105357170105,
0.11726607382297516,
-0.10766929388046265,
-0.35179436206817627,
0.46145713329315186,
0.5154441595077515,
-0.14211726188659668,
0.46815189719200134,
0.324673056602478,
-0.26623669266700745,
-0.11203420162200928,
-0.5920541882514954,
-0.45889517664909363,
-0.4868205189704895,
0.4858008325099945,
-0.44803452491760254,
-0.5900216698646545,
0.021081754937767982,
0.21060769259929657,
-0.19234131276607513,
0.1856319010257721,
0.49387067556381226,
0.25223448872566223,
1.2219172716140747,
0.49837958812713623,
0.25735288858413696,
0.41495296359062195,
-0.11893149465322495,
0.1439337432384491,
-0.6201688051223755,
-0.1679876446723938,
-0.36342382431030273,
0.20768053829669952,
-0.4216487407684326,
-0.17120499908924103,
0.5939233899116516,
-0.2901028096675873,
0.1510280966758728,
-0.4027351438999176,
-1.0505284070968628,
0.6417564749717712,
0.5208188891410828,
0.5914434790611267,
0.3557263910770416,
0.06544552743434906,
0.39963939785957336,
-0.3390246033668518,
-0.5950226783752441,
-0.28011807799339294,
1.2984914779663086,
-0.011759805493056774,
0.6736612915992737,
-0.3231726884841919,
1.0583323240280151,
0.19861428439617157,
0.10415661334991455,
-0.7625921368598938,
0.49624329805374146,
-0.4387737810611725,
-0.363239586353302,
-0.2935132086277008,
-0.5195930004119873,
-0.9543774724006653,
0.27880117297172546,
-0.16466109454631805,
-0.4889601171016693,
0.31270870566368103,
0.40589919686317444,
-0.5792635679244995,
0.011354601942002773,
-0.39169567823410034,
0.6059346795082092,
-0.3554403483867645,
-0.3754471242427826,
-0.4207639992237091,
-0.558702826499939,
0.36883345246315,
-0.11541042476892471,
-0.1496233493089676,
0.09069371968507767,
0.14864753186702728,
0.43047037720680237,
-0.4310291111469269,
0.6395661234855652,
-0.3048756420612335,
0.23362530767917633,
0.06532248109579086,
0.2286950796842575,
0.5337302088737488,
0.057340364903211594,
-0.042459290474653244,
-0.014689055271446705,
-0.049506865441799164,
-0.15988031029701233,
-0.40413105487823486,
0.5993711948394775,
-0.8108477592468262,
-0.8500564098358154,
-0.4784625470638275,
-0.3342006802558899,
-0.2841572165489197,
0.237251877784729,
0.7148024439811707,
0.653892993927002,
-0.08014465123414993,
-0.038168925791978836,
0.8131395578384399,
-0.25906819105148315,
-0.0052787489257752895,
0.45489630103111267,
-0.30819591879844666,
-0.2735130488872528,
0.9938702583312988,
0.10487306118011475,
0.3995521664619446,
0.34751254320144653,
0.5454772710800171,
-0.14197763800621033,
-1.1912119388580322,
0.011700395494699478,
0.3288876712322235,
-0.7536645531654358,
-0.14764173328876495,
-0.6685264110565186,
-0.2716643512248993,
-0.5272723436355591,
-0.3659808039665222,
-0.31250038743019104,
-0.07429548352956772,
-0.3030048906803131,
0.17983219027519226,
0.12514764070510864,
0.6041741967201233,
-0.11089278757572174,
0.07112262398004532,
-0.5935181379318237,
0.5969972610473633,
0.39967310428619385,
0.26367077231407166,
-0.17926594614982605,
-0.31232649087905884,
0.03597003221511841,
-0.28990474343299866,
-0.3507925570011139,
-0.5311630368232727,
0.5911067128181458,
-0.0517578050494194,
0.5874582529067993,
0.4754003882408142,
0.5887182950973511,
0.626541256904602,
-0.20743218064308167,
0.4298166036605835,
0.1878395676612854,
-0.9058229327201843,
0.885736346244812,
-0.1664901226758957,
0.07668238878250122,
0.695120096206665,
0.28261804580688477,
-0.1690119355916977,
-0.24783079326152802,
-0.4639081656932831,
-0.8534634709358215,
0.6642784476280212,
0.27650153636932373,
0.014771020971238613,
-0.07765617966651917,
0.38439619541168213,
0.18336252868175507,
0.3438853621482849,
-0.5244480967521667,
-0.31241217255592346,
-0.3124249577522278,
0.18071249127388,
-0.019516702741384506,
-0.6506816148757935,
-0.29567617177963257,
-0.5547462701797485,
0.6673823595046997,
-0.028197580948472023,
0.1812247931957245,
0.7471487522125244,
-0.06933042407035828,
-0.17309680581092834,
-0.12121981382369995,
1.0379589796066284,
0.7503156065940857,
-0.6936074495315552,
0.10070830583572388,
-0.25969281792640686,
-0.742565929889679,
0.15930110216140747,
-0.1637793332338333,
-0.46254879236221313,
0.1961156725883484,
-0.08838275820016861,
0.9062707424163818,
-0.43067696690559387,
-0.44232869148254395,
0.4135386049747467,
-0.26966118812561035,
-0.40255483984947205,
-0.4558630883693695,
0.0584319643676281,
-0.6014279127120972,
-0.20689597725868225,
0.17599204182624817,
0.43004167079925537,
0.24404948949813843,
-0.1322961002588272,
0.27762189507484436,
0.25365880131721497,
-0.492037832736969,
-0.10384403169155121,
0.6546069383621216,
0.47357597947120667,
-0.08127222210168839,
0.6341765522956848,
-0.0849200114607811,
-0.20589254796504974,
0.5626509189605713,
0.4488961696624756,
1.0337291955947876,
-0.21103093028068542,
0.3380097448825836,
0.3443983495235443,
0.35768213868141174,
-0.12451949715614319,
0.13908298313617706,
0.13216103613376617,
-0.7567741870880127,
-0.2730601131916046,
-0.2900860607624054,
-0.3469010889530182,
0.5227856040000916,
-0.9446430802345276,
0.6419584155082703,
-0.769329309463501,
-0.14361879229545593,
0.02394716627895832,
-0.1340862512588501,
-0.5582343339920044,
0.4429856240749359,
0.504368782043457,
0.33667463064193726,
-0.5439591407775879,
0.9253647923469543,
0.3400576114654541,
-0.2743517756462097,
-0.5953679084777832,
0.15597885847091675,
-0.03755989670753479,
-0.8499440550804138,
0.6642830967903137,
0.08101807534694672,
-0.38095539808273315,
0.0383632592856884,
-0.10885762423276901,
-0.5869557857513428,
0.5936170220375061,
0.30851247906684875,
-0.6198950409889221,
-0.04500909522175789,
-0.13738666474819183,
0.5367467999458313,
-0.2752891182899475,
-0.15846453607082367,
0.4250428378582001,
0.4221031367778778,
0.18922220170497894,
-0.7276793718338013,
0.2458466738462448,
-0.19706732034683228,
-0.05658521130681038,
0.23983538150787354,
-0.462058961391449,
0.6843442916870117,
-0.4192069172859192,
0.05826443433761597,
-0.028624098747968674,
0.2642984390258789,
0.18930156528949738,
0.5776073932647705,
0.6630610823631287,
0.2811186909675598,
0.8394315242767334,
0.10252325236797333,
1.3284006118774414,
-0.10378000140190125,
0.09880303591489792,
0.9538726806640625,
-0.7258501648902893,
0.413570374250412,
0.774962842464447,
0.09824638813734055,
0.15075790882110596,
0.3618561327457428,
0.011658089235424995,
0.9884032011032104,
0.24073515832424164,
-0.22801357507705688,
-0.4962303340435028,
-0.10832862555980682,
-0.8002603054046631,
0.6818070411682129,
0.06193295866250992,
-0.3772645592689514,
0.29337337613105774,
0.08968423306941986,
0.021560903638601303,
-0.0012034708634018898,
-0.32635074853897095,
0.7898952960968018,
-0.13767395913600922,
-0.7745947241783142,
1.0479053258895874,
-0.6037436127662659,
0.6235665678977966,
-0.8073045015335083,
0.13276360929012299,
-0.3470074236392975,
0.43081092834472656,
-0.36193427443504333,
-0.21810384094715118,
0.6918925642967224,
-0.3325716257095337,
-0.3643142282962799,
-0.2573535740375519,
0.674969494342804,
-0.045459140092134476,
-0.4149675965309143,
0.31110334396362305,
0.33732250332832336,
0.004406732972711325,
-0.2958916127681732,
-0.18499037623405457,
0.12861846387386322,
0.4149191081523895,
-0.3294362425804138,
0.4200696051120758,
-0.024343494325876236,
-0.0567462295293808,
0.4751873314380646,
0.5135564804077148,
0.4012014865875244,
-0.2808397710323334,
0.15016542375087738,
0.9575994610786438,
-0.40923428535461426,
-0.5729199051856995,
-0.6996536254882812,
0.2495971918106079,
-0.11972974240779877,
-0.39146578311920166,
0.39706307649612427,
0.5460261106491089,
0.8700344562530518,
-0.34940478205680847,
0.7464379072189331,
0.18320748209953308,
0.14015446603298187,
-0.8295785188674927,
0.8027541637420654,
-0.8892678618431091,
0.19367140531539917,
-0.5466331839561462,
-0.5952665209770203,
-0.5777140855789185,
0.6129654049873352,
-0.4046034812927246,
-0.20190419256687164,
0.8392805457115173,
0.8362084627151489,
0.21426108479499817,
-0.21234287321567535,
0.7380738258361816,
0.07355508953332901,
0.18507710099220276,
0.518450915813446,
0.8440664410591125,
-0.030822239816188812,
0.6258454322814941,
-0.7849904894828796,
-0.3109479248523712,
-0.40708670020103455,
-0.692850649356842,
-0.853541910648346,
-0.3365862965583801,
-0.6867632269859314,
-0.4621964395046234,
0.15904729068279266,
0.6029356122016907,
0.7318782210350037,
-0.4864678978919983,
-0.07622090727090836,
-0.10396455973386765,
0.08063945174217224,
-0.22545966506004333,
-0.16145439445972443,
0.38722336292266846,
-0.2720123827457428,
-0.473471462726593,
0.2639150321483612,
0.30297160148620605,
0.2402992695569992,
-0.031836751848459244,
-0.2845645248889923,
0.44830676913261414,
-0.07099925726652145,
0.7294034957885742,
0.07242878526449203,
-0.6408917903900146,
-0.37677207589149475,
0.27445635199546814,
-0.1669027954339981,
0.4036884605884552,
0.9674263596534729,
-0.8824504017829895,
0.7520905137062073,
0.4531826376914978,
0.10608889907598495,
0.6594598889350891,
-0.2920905351638794,
0.4763599634170532,
-0.4734075367450714,
0.6739323735237122,
0.667347252368927,
0.11195789277553558,
0.07801895588636398,
-0.8695558309555054,
0.6666427850723267,
0.24110959470272064,
-0.46208640933036804,
-1.154795527458191,
0.23014894127845764,
-0.9295855164527893,
-0.5051020979881287,
0.8548645973205566,
0.32535284757614136,
0.013575457967817783,
0.011642549186944962,
-0.5109056830406189,
0.011289001442492008,
-0.19737572968006134,
0.9446374773979187,
0.10777941346168518,
-0.5747900009155273,
-0.12085805833339691,
-0.3348187208175659,
0.980665922164917,
0.9099092483520508,
-0.7726584076881409,
-0.014279999770224094,
0.7075363397598267,
-0.008324339985847473,
0.07522505521774292,
1.0507892370224,
-0.08324664831161499,
0.6458501815795898,
0.07677977532148361,
0.19980178773403168,
-0.477731317281723,
-0.447772741317749,
-0.40129661560058594,
0.07019693404436111,
0.23186451196670532,
-0.5432859659194946
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06485v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06485v1
|
Can Language Models Serve as Text-Based World Simulators?
| 2024-06-10T17:24:44 | 2024-06-10T17:24:44 |
Ruoyao Wang, Graham Todd, Ziang Xiao, Xingdi Yuan, Marc-Alexandre Côté, Peter Clark, Peter Jansen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Virtual environments play a key role in benchmarking advances in complex
planning and decision-making tasks but are expensive and complicated to build
by hand. Can current language models themselves serve as world simulators,
correctly predicting how actions change different world states, thus bypassing
the need for extensive manual coding? Our goal is to answer this question in
the context of text-based simulators. Our approach is to build and use a new
benchmark, called ByteSized32-State-Prediction, containing a dataset of text
game state transitions and accompanying game tasks. We use this to directly
quantify, for the first time, how well LLMs can serve as text-based world
simulators. We test GPT-4 on this dataset and find that, despite its impressive
performance, it is still an unreliable world simulator without further
innovations. This work thus contributes both new insights into current LLM's
capabilities and weaknesses, as well as a novel benchmark to track future
progress as new models appear.
|
[
-0.20568227767944336,
-0.804896891117096,
0.8930243849754333,
0.24939605593681335,
-0.011931512504816055,
0.059852484613657,
-0.11489326506853104,
-0.5274707078933716,
-0.2258397489786148,
0.31870973110198975,
-0.6327153444290161,
-0.3476852476596832,
-0.40075764060020447,
0.2670477330684662,
-0.26428553462028503,
0.8150042295455933,
-0.24247229099273682,
-0.009526212699711323,
-0.4909357726573944,
0.2169876992702484,
-0.3218255341053009,
-0.5607209205627441,
-0.29226404428482056,
-0.6288917064666748,
0.13789743185043335,
0.011287438683211803,
0.6686626076698303,
0.5870235562324524,
0.4015251696109772,
0.34390053153038025,
-0.14533951878547668,
0.03269752860069275,
-0.39901140332221985,
0.10070088505744934,
0.048918649554252625,
-0.632046103477478,
-0.2636924088001251,
0.033119309693574905,
0.6073808073997498,
0.05132327973842621,
-0.2066318690776825,
-0.06401914358139038,
0.05165707319974899,
0.2584337592124939,
-0.2392081618309021,
0.6070502996444702,
-0.7083781361579895,
0.297533243894577,
0.1170744076371193,
0.01469704695045948,
-0.2039061337709427,
-0.23563410341739655,
0.17561842501163483,
-0.6850650310516357,
0.04425568878650665,
0.12136884778738022,
0.6894835829734802,
0.07559755444526672,
-0.44953957200050354,
-0.13461099565029144,
-0.9119513630867004,
0.7720864415168762,
-0.6927680969238281,
0.4616278409957886,
0.02688661776483059,
0.3267866373062134,
-0.5125194787979126,
-0.5744083523750305,
-0.6086186170578003,
-0.3648088872432709,
0.2956221401691437,
0.21846264600753784,
-0.3471332788467407,
0.085797019302845,
0.4771348834037781,
-0.02095087431371212,
-0.24289213120937347,
-0.14476649463176727,
-0.34802478551864624,
-0.36529529094696045,
0.39448535442352295,
0.47239911556243896,
0.4997985064983368,
-0.1320064812898636,
-0.43493303656578064,
-0.17978182435035706,
-0.7093757390975952,
0.18686263263225555,
0.25138601660728455,
0.19621211290359497,
-0.3768875002861023,
0.6298784613609314,
0.018996872007846832,
0.4721083343029022,
-0.31494805216789246,
-0.3295043408870697,
0.06167763099074364,
-0.16451309621334076,
-0.2617964446544647,
-0.04321809113025665,
0.7832121253013611,
0.6543070673942566,
0.3557564318180084,
-0.3481743633747101,
-0.4106542468070984,
0.38621842861175537,
0.22257766127586365,
-1.0238964557647705,
-0.26073119044303894,
0.12075448036193848,
-0.1607300490140915,
-0.3038143217563629,
-0.21389004588127136,
-0.6654290556907654,
-0.45409929752349854,
-0.10672398656606674,
0.3544561266899109,
-0.6721194982528687,
-0.3187568187713623,
0.13806742429733276,
-0.13055847585201263,
0.08919557929039001,
0.4490087628364563,
-0.7709726691246033,
0.7699404954910278,
0.8141807317733765,
1.202418565750122,
-0.5004814863204956,
-0.390485554933548,
-0.13497386872768402,
0.09583035111427307,
-0.5302638411521912,
0.9394145607948303,
-0.5359171628952026,
-0.7418040037155151,
0.05238033086061478,
-0.18915164470672607,
0.2957468330860138,
-0.636410117149353,
0.27586066722869873,
-0.2974552810192108,
-0.12315462529659271,
-0.32490333914756775,
-0.7953957915306091,
0.04266926273703575,
0.849522054195404,
-0.782780110836029,
1.163879156112671,
-0.1500558704137802,
-0.8312549591064453,
0.30912700295448303,
-0.3463901877403259,
-0.24729901552200317,
-0.08073879033327103,
-0.48714199662208557,
-0.2959408164024353,
0.34920424222946167,
0.0654863715171814,
0.3402561545372009,
-0.37116897106170654,
0.3508138954639435,
-0.35288697481155396,
-0.8014655113220215,
0.318260133266449,
-0.5955952405929565,
0.1857869029045105,
-0.08589757233858109,
-0.29581716656684875,
-0.2495800107717514,
-0.5091229677200317,
0.32348397374153137,
-0.011657766066491604,
-0.6028211116790771,
-0.07020031660795212,
0.47335541248321533,
0.021527709439396858,
0.31053870916366577,
0.37894800305366516,
-0.7205750942230225,
0.5334069728851318,
-0.27680504322052,
0.24840804934501648,
0.6246843934059143,
-0.10173572599887848,
0.2884380519390106,
-0.42026984691619873,
0.7549406886100769,
0.12027288973331451,
-0.08873698115348816,
-0.22039709985256195,
-0.7117289304733276,
-0.5264260172843933,
-0.0435938760638237,
0.1649501770734787,
0.6967249512672424,
-0.7353240847587585,
-0.09961641579866409,
-0.4101945161819458,
-0.6493759751319885,
-0.006835403852164745,
-0.3753977417945862,
0.3914813995361328,
0.1861475259065628,
0.36874887347221375,
0.10370112210512161,
-0.6683734655380249,
-0.7285747528076172,
-0.5512974262237549,
-0.5912557244300842,
0.1454368680715561,
0.40225720405578613,
0.5648655295372009,
-0.17984579503536224,
1.0628007650375366,
-0.2972431480884552,
0.0817895233631134,
-0.3200014531612396,
-0.00033078424166888,
0.08180651813745499,
0.2386811226606369,
0.1887470930814743,
-0.6692177057266235,
-0.26407548785209656,
-0.0020258205477148294,
-0.823088526725769,
0.07983331382274628,
-0.056499529629945755,
0.15365755558013916,
0.0454583466053009,
0.5590436458587646,
-0.37369027733802795,
0.28661343455314636,
0.9095591306686401,
-0.41681867837905884,
0.7810999751091003,
-0.5988321900367737,
0.2838123142719269,
-0.8117102980613708,
-0.2845161259174347,
0.16888797283172607,
-0.11083978414535522,
-0.42880040407180786,
-0.23485074937343597,
0.4026576280593872,
-0.05007367581129074,
-0.49550938606262207,
0.8657315373420715,
-0.4875280261039734,
-0.29429951310157776,
-0.19724492728710175,
-0.13689401745796204,
-0.3233010768890381,
0.2755090296268463,
0.020623505115509033,
1.1082720756530762,
0.47107598185539246,
-0.6440222263336182,
0.10979500412940979,
0.03154689446091652,
-0.6817207932472229,
0.30368685722351074,
-0.6016731262207031,
-0.05147967487573624,
0.008460956625640392,
0.4027249813079834,
-0.7447594404220581,
-0.0008672373951412737,
-0.172723650932312,
-0.28060564398765564,
-0.17088377475738525,
-0.2804431915283203,
-0.7806435227394104,
-0.31112751364707947,
-0.1113247200846672,
0.01011739019304514,
0.7298561334609985,
-0.1323036551475525,
0.6129103899002075,
0.4439329206943512,
0.08989571034908295,
-0.30532410740852356,
-0.9055697321891785,
0.1877003312110901,
-0.03256622329354286,
-0.26954537630081177,
0.6346493363380432,
-0.3147491216659546,
-0.222089022397995,
0.00849121157079935,
-0.2966388761997223,
-0.18478547036647797,
0.09487204998731613,
0.5644698739051819,
0.28432947397232056,
-0.1245565116405487,
0.003052461426705122,
0.10531044006347656,
-0.022068943828344345,
0.35353970527648926,
-0.24420718848705292,
0.4200499355792999,
-0.24674728512763977,
-0.07396380603313446,
-0.15787972509860992,
-0.07080037146806717,
0.4930402934551239,
-0.10105294734239578,
0.5453273057937622,
-0.03195064887404442,
-0.5704464912414551,
-0.2465449720621109,
-0.3971104919910431,
0.1944362372159958,
-0.5584461688995361,
0.6617565751075745,
-0.555937647819519,
-0.9021275639533997,
0.5395996570587158,
-0.47742077708244324,
0.24097804725170135,
0.20200827717781067,
0.4941737949848175,
-0.12230037897825241,
0.9103314280509949,
0.8604055047035217,
0.02535717375576496,
0.3047902286052704,
-0.042862989008426666,
-0.20059412717819214,
-0.6063345670700073,
-0.3152810335159302,
-0.17743128538131714,
-0.2533123195171356,
-0.8538288474082947,
-0.8073907494544983,
0.5197239518165588,
0.010765832848846912,
-0.3023109436035156,
0.2801934480667114,
-0.07588381320238113,
0.7171651124954224,
0.1129855141043663,
-0.04260341823101044,
0.25036683678627014,
0.08635885268449783,
-0.525094747543335,
-0.26854538917541504,
-0.45518958568573,
-0.7394864559173584,
1.0488630533218384,
0.12171145528554916,
0.8050029873847961,
0.03266916796565056,
0.8909408450126648,
0.34805428981781006,
0.6565943360328674,
-0.449222594499588,
0.7639247179031372,
0.05454361066222191,
-0.6883262991905212,
-0.19750531017780304,
-0.40569207072257996,
-0.7139183282852173,
0.39337360858917236,
-0.3150554597377777,
-0.8538358211517334,
-0.41710779070854187,
0.25591787695884705,
-0.163044735789299,
0.5346308946609497,
-0.6277728080749512,
0.8933231234550476,
-0.29124554991722107,
-0.35875067114830017,
0.016991451382637024,
0.006588205229490995,
0.14359968900680542,
-0.018735552206635475,
0.4749968349933624,
-0.5419735312461853,
-0.4353684186935425,
0.5426886677742004,
-0.11144677549600601,
0.6637428402900696,
-0.236532524228096,
-0.27536264061927795,
0.26983922719955444,
0.4491458833217621,
0.537668764591217,
0.017089201137423515,
-0.4265161156654358,
0.15146861970424652,
0.2319016456604004,
-0.04814233258366585,
-0.5345218181610107,
0.9631260633468628,
-0.785296618938446,
-0.3245607912540436,
-0.6276223063468933,
-0.4307976961135864,
-0.5509860515594482,
0.17667852342128754,
0.05582727491855621,
0.47436439990997314,
-0.8463546633720398,
-0.3425924777984619,
0.5265424847602844,
-0.3090175688266754,
0.4533554017543793,
0.6935706734657288,
-0.5722899436950684,
-0.27692970633506775,
0.9841475486755371,
0.05107355862855911,
0.008721120655536652,
0.478597491979599,
0.3694364130496979,
-0.48083898425102234,
-0.5191688537597656,
-0.47498229146003723,
-0.031910255551338196,
-0.5917874574661255,
-0.15434810519218445,
-0.5969806909561157,
0.020860515534877777,
0.027473492547869682,
-0.03647298365831375,
-0.3953253924846649,
0.05862287059426308,
0.0697169154882431,
-0.12662175297737122,
0.2745959758758545,
1.1576977968215942,
0.02581890858709812,
0.12237618863582611,
-0.814993679523468,
0.16407305002212524,
0.11395324021577835,
0.6633484363555908,
-0.13892827928066254,
-0.2145671546459198,
-0.1860419660806656,
0.12137015908956528,
-0.2547641396522522,
-0.9147611260414124,
0.33786749839782715,
0.10718312859535217,
0.37182217836380005,
-0.25559648871421814,
-0.13652263581752777,
0.6771775484085083,
-1.1363272666931152,
0.9047431945800781,
0.17213074862957,
-0.9423655867576599,
0.30226656794548035,
-0.4973504841327667,
0.4906317889690399,
0.3374079465866089,
0.13606210052967072,
-0.7863425016403198,
-0.4679979979991913,
-0.48681145906448364,
-0.43653085827827454,
0.7052692770957947,
0.21235978603363037,
0.32512494921684265,
-0.2747761011123657,
0.31264299154281616,
0.11950118094682693,
0.13507956266403198,
-0.7594612836837769,
-0.2363729178905487,
0.08431200683116913,
-0.2619969844818115,
-0.1491766721010208,
-0.21815359592437744,
0.35245078802108765,
-0.020183168351650238,
0.3862476050853729,
-0.15112903714179993,
0.5004176497459412,
0.0616798959672451,
0.03200181946158409,
0.08485638350248337,
0.18624302744865417,
0.3087135851383209,
0.5155734419822693,
-0.09826024621725082,
0.12354307621717453,
0.3854382038116455,
-0.5373095273971558,
0.5554186105728149,
0.026273002848029137,
-0.31035706400871277,
-0.09531766921281815,
0.11002043634653091,
0.7289848923683167,
0.7097045183181763,
-0.985673189163208,
0.5709860324859619,
-0.3119145631790161,
-0.2624937891960144,
-0.29589828848838806,
0.23293262720108032,
0.40839526057243347,
0.40524572134017944,
0.13283081352710724,
-0.16613347828388214,
0.11162658035755157,
-0.4983968138694763,
0.2799668610095978,
0.284845769405365,
-0.6021468639373779,
-0.4569646418094635,
0.7900168895721436,
0.3054315447807312,
-0.3886623978614807,
0.4252738654613495,
-0.3749823272228241,
-0.5052843689918518,
0.92368483543396,
0.8595914244651794,
0.6852751970291138,
0.047199830412864685,
0.2542695105075836,
0.3873502314090729,
0.46313950419425964,
-0.5826250910758972,
0.640897810459137,
0.2708273231983185,
-0.8491222858428955,
-0.38742339611053467,
-0.579710066318512,
-0.7245917916297913,
0.05179593339562416,
-0.389636367559433,
0.24165934324264526,
-0.566279947757721,
-0.2998943328857422,
-0.29408466815948486,
0.050700895488262177,
-0.8748619556427002,
0.5175623297691345,
0.4818761944770813,
0.8814302086830139,
-0.6727425456047058,
0.8330571055412292,
0.9319802522659302,
0.14331743121147156,
-0.4050220847129822,
0.27489030361175537,
0.13867127895355225,
-0.5939317345619202,
0.45432114601135254,
0.45707497000694275,
-0.216260626912117,
0.012023518793284893,
-0.4215152859687805,
-0.9473569393157959,
0.9835015535354614,
0.4963403642177582,
-0.7261021733283997,
-0.11254631727933884,
0.21096742153167725,
0.5976138114929199,
-0.016842074692249298,
0.4412896931171417,
0.42597442865371704,
0.36854973435401917,
-0.47756215929985046,
-0.8837490677833557,
-0.09375838935375214,
-0.22710198163986206,
0.2462233603000641,
0.44255197048187256,
-0.5759144425392151,
0.8658599257469177,
-0.363798588514328,
-0.3375836908817291,
0.027278097346425056,
0.9589260816574097,
0.4256793260574341,
0.09678813815116882,
0.6416904926300049,
0.37675875425338745,
0.606727123260498,
-0.2266371101140976,
1.183836579322815,
-0.5965055823326111,
0.4167611300945282,
0.8975566625595093,
-0.513704240322113,
1.0604997873306274,
0.2614833116531372,
-0.5300085544586182,
0.5208897590637207,
0.4511975049972534,
-0.04056355729699135,
0.5683907866477966,
0.5401753187179565,
-0.25048020482063293,
-0.3398222327232361,
0.2898150086402893,
-0.047835975885391235,
0.36574816703796387,
0.36261653900146484,
0.2563018202781677,
-0.30057093501091003,
-0.11726126819849014,
0.02191632241010666,
0.03359054774045944,
-0.05531208962202072,
0.5626991391181946,
-0.10974373668432236,
-0.7138186097145081,
0.12593583762645721,
0.28007423877716064,
1.0953856706619263,
-0.813839852809906,
-0.26158562302589417,
-0.23943325877189636,
0.17416371405124664,
0.3000998795032501,
-0.848181962966919,
-0.07191082835197449,
0.27148738503456116,
-0.08763030916452408,
-0.25661587715148926,
0.44165435433387756,
-0.36854493618011475,
-0.7052375078201294,
0.2597375512123108,
0.5958997011184692,
0.19486959278583527,
-0.050282519310712814,
-0.7825692296028137,
0.45810389518737793,
0.10423602908849716,
-0.28882408142089844,
0.5165135264396667,
0.6422906517982483,
-0.06502007693052292,
0.8287118077278137,
0.3292299807071686,
0.045926835387945175,
0.10433577001094818,
-0.4302569627761841,
0.636767566204071,
-1.00229012966156,
-0.6951797604560852,
-1.0285738706588745,
0.09963537752628326,
0.016210589557886124,
-0.5099910497665405,
0.6256701946258545,
0.9031367301940918,
0.7742895483970642,
0.12724779546260834,
1.1899399757385254,
-0.024547763168811798,
0.251010537147522,
-0.5708972811698914,
0.6527824401855469,
-0.5324774980545044,
0.15707914531230927,
-0.18852373957633972,
-0.7998887300491333,
0.14051887392997742,
0.3333336412906647,
-0.038284555077552795,
0.11787243187427521,
0.6306698322296143,
0.6852685213088989,
-0.07171691954135895,
0.06879473477602005,
0.5705714821815491,
0.08887103199958801,
0.652855396270752,
0.5433043241500854,
0.803860068321228,
-0.4102122485637665,
0.6757266521453857,
-0.34176695346832275,
-0.01114574447274208,
0.08639627695083618,
-1.2546604871749878,
-0.8728711009025574,
-0.4838564693927765,
-0.23807011544704437,
-0.1529613435268402,
0.3386280834674835,
0.745362401008606,
0.4610733687877655,
-0.43021366000175476,
-0.4515830874443054,
-0.2670459449291229,
-0.2892799377441406,
-0.17939132452011108,
-0.11190896481275558,
0.05195736885070801,
-0.023774370551109314,
-0.838067352771759,
0.5225256085395813,
0.2590838670730591,
0.38838669657707214,
-0.4032295346260071,
-0.027588510885834694,
0.31048583984375,
0.2769518792629242,
0.4789890944957733,
0.07752940058708191,
-0.8559967875480652,
-0.1567673534154892,
0.07675501704216003,
-0.2791004776954651,
0.05807225778698921,
0.9626415967941284,
-1.0530935525894165,
0.40616318583488464,
0.08815284073352814,
0.5168877243995667,
0.6526542901992798,
-0.20596858859062195,
0.7818043828010559,
-0.5381017327308655,
0.0777394250035286,
0.13478466868400574,
0.3045065701007843,
0.3200685679912567,
-0.023961441591382027,
0.3133256435394287,
0.06492679566144943,
-0.33787789940834045,
-0.6110813617706299,
0.009692839346826077,
-0.5859410762786865,
-0.07313328981399536,
1.3736224174499512,
-0.22618700563907623,
-0.41004297137260437,
0.09746164083480835,
-0.163474902510643,
-0.013619710691273212,
-0.49153080582618713,
0.6639133095741272,
0.9734063744544983,
-0.16511914134025574,
-0.01711214892566204,
-0.8491742014884949,
0.567646861076355,
0.0832764133810997,
-1.173100233078003,
0.31609708070755005,
0.6242454051971436,
0.3836822211742401,
-0.3099742829799652,
0.8855982422828674,
0.09564617276191711,
0.0020545986481010914,
0.29678037762641907,
0.11074484884738922,
-0.06667720526456833,
-0.22950035333633423,
-0.020699886605143547,
-0.12154077738523483,
-0.09747599065303802,
0.028820836916565895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06484v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06484v1
|
Parallelizing Linear Transformers with the Delta Rule over Sequence Length
| 2024-06-10T17:24:42 | 2024-06-10T17:24:42 |
Songlin Yang, Bailin Wang, Yu Zhang, Yikang Shen, Yoon Kim
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Transformers with linear attention (i.e., linear transformers) and
state-space models have recently been suggested as a viable linear-time
alternative to transformers with softmax attention. However, these models still
underperform transformers especially on tasks that require in-context
retrieval. While more expressive variants of linear transformers which replace
the additive outer-product update in linear transformers with the delta rule
have been found to be more effective at associative recall, existing algorithms
for training such models do not parallelize over sequence length and are thus
inefficient to train on modern hardware. This work describes a
hardware-efficient algorithm for training linear transformers with the delta
rule, which exploits a memory-efficient representation for computing products
of Householder matrices. This algorithm allows us to scale up DeltaNet to
standard language modeling settings. We train a 1.3B model for 100B tokens and
find that it outperforms recent linear-time baselines such as Mamba and GLA in
terms of perplexity and zero-shot performance on downstream tasks (including on
tasks that focus on recall). We also experiment with two hybrid models which
combine DeltaNet layers with (1) sliding-window attention layers every other
layer or (2) two global attention layers, and find that these hybrid models
outperform strong transformer baselines.
|
[
-0.5814968943595886,
-0.17392992973327637,
0.306300550699234,
0.29603496193885803,
-0.19406460225582123,
-0.2206355184316635,
-0.3116460144519806,
-0.1314719170331955,
0.3207540810108185,
0.27774983644485474,
-0.5503225326538086,
-0.23702460527420044,
-0.41783514618873596,
-0.15134911239147186,
-0.4097892940044403,
0.7670370936393738,
-0.26786625385284424,
0.05743509903550148,
0.11989733576774597,
-0.39229118824005127,
-0.40904104709625244,
-0.5302537679672241,
-0.5036507844924927,
-0.3590434491634369,
0.650742769241333,
0.18945953249931335,
0.5029303431510925,
0.7223271727561951,
0.5793947577476501,
0.2991775572299957,
-0.12482688575983047,
0.0034948019310832024,
-0.533645510673523,
0.10143695771694183,
-0.15977878868579865,
-0.2856038212776184,
-0.5211960077285767,
-0.3528921604156494,
0.47558242082595825,
0.5457584857940674,
-0.07659212499856949,
0.4545941650867462,
-0.014483709819614887,
0.6438275575637817,
-0.7728347778320312,
0.2094721496105194,
-0.6508656144142151,
0.30049604177474976,
0.21385325491428375,
-0.3379233181476593,
-0.5299668908119202,
-0.38981351256370544,
0.13803616166114807,
-0.6395817399024963,
0.39913272857666016,
-0.11736835539340973,
0.8911157846450806,
0.26195070147514343,
-0.19714689254760742,
-0.23230241239070892,
-0.997527003288269,
0.8434808254241943,
-0.5618427991867065,
0.507815957069397,
0.07614246010780334,
0.4797137975692749,
0.20504657924175262,
-0.9617392420768738,
-0.47614291310310364,
0.03265926241874695,
-0.0734742134809494,
0.09215238690376282,
-0.25972411036491394,
0.21736398339271545,
0.4191976487636566,
0.5793432593345642,
-0.29547712206840515,
0.01628325693309307,
-0.5207982063293457,
-0.09300462901592255,
0.08212986588478088,
0.37905994057655334,
-0.06693637371063232,
-0.08099355548620224,
-0.5913625359535217,
-0.30516406893730164,
-0.5476662516593933,
0.24356988072395325,
0.04611004516482353,
0.49216270446777344,
0.14053240418434143,
0.38590237498283386,
-0.16857101023197174,
0.2742648124694824,
0.30868545174598694,
0.1375480592250824,
0.0863979235291481,
-0.5319676995277405,
-0.21981912851333618,
0.031285014003515244,
0.3250747323036194,
0.16723689436912537,
0.2069106101989746,
-0.49928930401802063,
-0.48677024245262146,
0.09328383207321167,
0.701506495475769,
-0.8021206259727478,
-0.12348776310682297,
0.06621219962835312,
-0.5820196866989136,
0.2977209985256195,
-0.12545160949230194,
-0.5561351180076599,
-0.11395817995071411,
-0.7103111147880554,
0.8035458326339722,
-0.275747150182724,
0.2354138344526291,
0.11742687225341797,
-0.06652410328388214,
0.2657790184020996,
0.08185059577226639,
-1.1222232580184937,
0.5565463304519653,
0.7740806937217712,
0.7629386186599731,
0.09269237518310547,
-0.0415823832154274,
-0.44092196226119995,
-0.07789183408021927,
-0.19960372149944305,
0.42952030897140503,
-0.19662903249263763,
0.039690665900707245,
-0.023743588477373123,
-0.15839725732803345,
-0.06083020195364952,
-0.5520728230476379,
0.39368322491645813,
-0.8140009641647339,
-0.08715508878231049,
-0.5196349620819092,
-0.43850409984588623,
-0.2273017168045044,
-0.06822670251131058,
-0.7609273791313171,
0.8256558179855347,
0.04671500623226166,
-0.522499680519104,
0.3079843819141388,
-0.38828128576278687,
-0.4216838479042053,
-0.19344398379325867,
-0.026915431022644043,
-0.6738718152046204,
-0.020726338028907776,
0.47256264090538025,
0.4900435507297516,
-0.33511942625045776,
0.06089034676551819,
-0.20707698166370392,
-0.7048975229263306,
-0.290052205324173,
-0.15598654747009277,
0.5923869013786316,
-0.055275022983551025,
-0.6839636564254761,
0.15308550000190735,
-0.4539889693260193,
-0.20822221040725708,
0.004333806224167347,
-0.454132080078125,
-0.18113823235034943,
-0.2337980568408966,
0.031269241124391556,
0.34739890694618225,
0.22812730073928833,
-0.562427818775177,
0.19487710297107697,
-0.35489699244499207,
0.10319874435663223,
0.8416242003440857,
-0.1628885567188263,
0.8423452377319336,
-0.32564249634742737,
0.50230872631073,
0.07451636344194412,
0.3323572874069214,
-0.5575398206710815,
-0.10699211061000824,
-1.4227906465530396,
-0.24358971416950226,
0.2851647138595581,
0.45221439003944397,
-0.702948272228241,
0.5036646127700806,
-0.4644711911678314,
-0.2737472355365753,
-0.5399621725082397,
0.44624221324920654,
0.5080597400665283,
0.44455426931381226,
0.6300176382064819,
-0.7566046118736267,
-0.8698099255561829,
-1.196420431137085,
0.0014926801668480039,
0.3597445487976074,
-0.1432638168334961,
0.4463673532009125,
0.3118584156036377,
-0.007228445261716843,
0.9865503907203674,
-0.21268266439437866,
-0.38198748230934143,
-0.15568597614765167,
0.15382511913776398,
0.46438464522361755,
0.24534569680690765,
0.3506166338920593,
-0.33054468035697937,
-0.43963366746902466,
0.002580902073532343,
-0.8333231806755066,
0.18973234295845032,
-0.17144182324409485,
0.08543213456869125,
0.15249399840831757,
0.5436743497848511,
-0.711930513381958,
0.474257230758667,
0.09837689995765686,
0.05784350261092186,
0.2411612570285797,
-0.1406957358121872,
-0.3421098589897156,
-0.8982391953468323,
0.2442893087863922,
0.14309050142765045,
-0.23097997903823853,
-0.8240471482276917,
0.030480626970529556,
0.3653823733329773,
0.0314343236386776,
-0.3788270354270935,
0.35219913721084595,
-0.5185352563858032,
-0.2599566876888275,
-0.31957972049713135,
-0.26731351017951965,
-0.2042814940214157,
1.0615198612213135,
-0.1227991059422493,
0.6752423644065857,
0.41146236658096313,
-0.6879064440727234,
0.33269184827804565,
-0.08805420994758606,
-0.2478213608264923,
0.24225816130638123,
-0.47181662917137146,
0.3289194703102112,
-0.43806833028793335,
0.5133129358291626,
-0.7982099056243896,
0.34196847677230835,
-0.13644768297672272,
-0.05902847647666931,
0.30079084634780884,
0.13743902742862701,
-0.610011637210846,
-0.6302711963653564,
-0.27450311183929443,
0.4186391234397888,
0.7009647488594055,
-0.9768204689025879,
0.9754431843757629,
0.11340490728616714,
-0.09216516464948654,
-0.8651290535926819,
-0.41761305928230286,
-0.17623421549797058,
-0.2520126402378082,
-0.28769832849502563,
0.16826710104942322,
0.3184720277786255,
0.025140661746263504,
-0.03173219412565231,
-0.393052875995636,
0.08539560437202454,
-0.07791312783956528,
0.08278368413448334,
0.1847548633813858,
-0.5572649836540222,
0.07742667198181152,
-0.1757902204990387,
-0.24203041195869446,
0.0001576999929966405,
-0.6933487057685852,
0.7130618095397949,
-0.1800980567932129,
0.004993431735783815,
-0.5092087388038635,
0.3581743836402893,
0.5522480010986328,
-0.0917430967092514,
0.5875041484832764,
0.3976300060749054,
-0.37960875034332275,
-0.6252103447914124,
-0.5868196487426758,
-0.680941641330719,
-0.5338605046272278,
0.3750130236148834,
-0.228675976395607,
-0.6994518041610718,
0.5811389684677124,
0.10360202938318253,
0.3117419481277466,
-0.00033229569089598954,
0.7301061153411865,
-0.06282982975244522,
0.5926467180252075,
0.5469289422035217,
-0.3689282238483429,
0.5367352366447449,
-0.4343576729297638,
0.39319202303886414,
-0.6543618440628052,
-0.05113526061177254,
-0.09204365313053131,
-0.8703376054763794,
-0.14561578631401062,
-0.6110342144966125,
0.39141520857810974,
-0.034027062356472015,
-0.5244222283363342,
0.8500156402587891,
-0.2668398916721344,
0.45918548107147217,
0.829541027545929,
0.33070841431617737,
0.12755362689495087,
0.284133642911911,
-0.36516740918159485,
-0.05009487271308899,
-0.7295504808425903,
-0.09328587353229523,
1.1959261894226074,
0.4955810308456421,
0.6532454490661621,
-0.021064279600977898,
0.45553067326545715,
0.0666411742568016,
0.2108137607574463,
-0.6062781810760498,
0.6250635981559753,
-0.3989417850971222,
-0.5103059411048889,
-0.1958589106798172,
-0.3519715666770935,
-0.7639785408973694,
0.22327473759651184,
0.06616323441267014,
-0.6370476484298706,
0.5106682777404785,
0.32535362243652344,
-0.5501342415809631,
0.5682297945022583,
-0.608808696269989,
0.48274698853492737,
0.13453571498394012,
-0.33442196249961853,
-0.3963510990142822,
-0.5439601540565491,
0.451673686504364,
-0.21264880895614624,
-0.42998290061950684,
0.21297095715999603,
0.0890900269150734,
0.3108280897140503,
-0.42292436957359314,
0.7950965762138367,
-0.1393348127603531,
0.08731655031442642,
0.06541531533002853,
-0.1622057855129242,
0.390850305557251,
-0.27064603567123413,
0.18501706421375275,
0.03571229800581932,
-0.851012110710144,
-0.6250636577606201,
-0.7196268439292908,
0.5710689425468445,
-0.6960877180099487,
-0.4525003135204315,
-0.0051634470000863075,
-0.7974972128868103,
-0.2157718986272812,
-0.10809814184904099,
-0.04536489397287369,
0.46936342120170593,
0.07313014566898346,
0.32734596729278564,
0.7926743030548096,
-0.09648990631103516,
0.8362919688224792,
0.3233794867992401,
0.12178802490234375,
-0.19430653750896454,
0.8426098227500916,
0.16822172701358795,
0.29959967732429504,
0.5687114596366882,
-0.2628287076950073,
-0.27408474683761597,
-0.044589776545763016,
-0.2769269049167633,
0.07704878598451614,
-0.9205023646354675,
-0.26118895411491394,
-0.7317960858345032,
-0.41127628087997437,
-0.05257278308272362,
-0.09691143035888672,
-0.6932184100151062,
-0.6917567253112793,
-0.030159246176481247,
0.13874046504497528,
0.2817421853542328,
0.451392263174057,
0.012415585108101368,
0.19834640622138977,
-0.2890617847442627,
0.638309121131897,
0.7681748270988464,
0.5295815467834473,
0.6501530408859253,
-0.49187764525413513,
-0.5323047041893005,
-0.3174334168434143,
-0.5418475866317749,
-0.33910542726516724,
0.23784314095973969,
0.04393287003040314,
0.48736411333084106,
0.4109044075012207,
-0.04775165766477585,
0.7119213342666626,
-0.6534274816513062,
0.20649781823158264,
0.24237772822380066,
-0.8773253560066223,
0.06520777195692062,
-0.18241846561431885,
0.610821008682251,
0.43378061056137085,
0.5010684132575989,
-0.42472779750823975,
-0.16800916194915771,
-0.31544801592826843,
-1.1119650602340698,
0.9054105877876282,
0.36508771777153015,
0.1413266956806183,
0.25994905829429626,
0.2621822953224182,
-0.04238583520054817,
0.06273045390844345,
-0.5658228993415833,
-0.48439672589302063,
-0.34978213906288147,
-0.20317091047763824,
-0.16295699775218964,
-0.061735011637210846,
0.17549924552440643,
-0.3456268012523651,
0.549289345741272,
0.007458786945790052,
0.5252619981765747,
0.1492280662059784,
-0.08556162565946579,
-0.03731277957558632,
0.17426352202892303,
0.4135018289089203,
0.4506412148475647,
-0.3248593211174011,
0.13397110998630524,
0.3026978075504303,
-0.5103595852851868,
0.14524607360363007,
0.33906999230384827,
-0.33985981345176697,
0.19265219569206238,
-0.122822605073452,
0.978607177734375,
0.5389091968536377,
-0.3730542063713074,
0.32287919521331787,
-0.30008023977279663,
-0.1000574454665184,
-0.2354990541934967,
-0.1774204969406128,
0.3369397222995758,
0.44300544261932373,
0.4691705107688904,
0.12854227423667908,
0.14496393501758575,
-0.2671588063240051,
0.4097951352596283,
0.3137217164039612,
-0.42351841926574707,
-0.21364732086658478,
0.692798376083374,
0.10432300716638565,
-0.30914199352264404,
0.7316914200782776,
0.11644963175058365,
-0.43192341923713684,
0.759431004524231,
0.35864683985710144,
1.0417284965515137,
-0.21172288060188293,
-0.25937825441360474,
0.5972298979759216,
0.2863142192363739,
-0.07233404368162155,
0.09676545113325119,
-0.39427170157432556,
-0.5622313022613525,
-0.3009079098701477,
-0.6760197877883911,
-0.24841462075710297,
0.1624738574028015,
-0.6600332856178284,
0.2736818194389343,
-0.7582116723060608,
-0.2643307149410248,
0.09005557745695114,
-0.2527022063732147,
-0.7862808704376221,
-0.003971349447965622,
0.4617791175842285,
0.8805620670318604,
-0.6421314477920532,
1.137558102607727,
0.3015183210372925,
-0.2515527606010437,
-0.7703623175621033,
-0.09174878150224686,
-0.1343597024679184,
-0.4697049558162689,
0.7588751316070557,
0.34937188029289246,
-0.01574697159230709,
-0.07231560349464417,
0.05013357847929001,
-0.7445358633995056,
1.1830122470855713,
0.34708309173583984,
-0.7174500823020935,
-0.13168109953403473,
0.17071571946144104,
0.5764327049255371,
-0.29548394680023193,
0.44978684186935425,
0.6721298694610596,
0.053923819214105606,
-0.08515048772096634,
-1.119127869606018,
-0.12394935637712479,
-0.4327675700187683,
0.3091689348220825,
0.22599193453788757,
-0.6630268096923828,
1.0373879671096802,
0.036323431879282,
-0.25047871470451355,
0.09124355018138885,
0.9817219972610474,
0.3407540023326874,
0.13274167478084564,
0.6508488655090332,
0.7029324769973755,
0.3513757288455963,
0.04497652128338814,
1.0739836692810059,
-0.3585158586502075,
0.5541723966598511,
1.1281635761260986,
-0.22380636632442474,
0.810731828212738,
0.45849430561065674,
0.14322055876255035,
0.41754207015037537,
0.05941520258784294,
-0.04408608376979828,
0.6222111582756042,
0.24338877201080322,
-0.3965522050857544,
-0.17910327017307281,
-0.026348276063799858,
-0.03220820054411888,
0.2830054759979248,
0.19207364320755005,
-0.6736826300621033,
-0.3855230212211609,
0.06327635794878006,
-0.037362437695264816,
0.05824149027466774,
-0.5570866465568542,
0.609283447265625,
0.19994211196899414,
-0.7209294438362122,
0.8188583254814148,
0.11598490178585052,
0.79453444480896,
-0.4165582060813904,
0.0439595989882946,
-0.5114355087280273,
0.8494952917098999,
0.2369629293680191,
-0.214584618806839,
0.05624409765005112,
-0.030074534937739372,
-0.4776085615158081,
-0.37216171622276306,
0.3759031891822815,
-0.27842190861701965,
-0.47210633754730225,
0.5089011788368225,
-0.05864139273762703,
-0.3073658347129822,
0.11622809618711472,
-0.43277645111083984,
-0.2313557267189026,
-0.2610531747341156,
-0.18563027679920197,
0.2222030758857727,
-0.12827371060848236,
-0.22107772529125214,
0.7093205451965332,
0.39689919352531433,
-0.18215538561344147,
0.7284964919090271,
0.15257737040519714,
1.0666300058364868,
-0.6926504969596863,
-0.5899621248245239,
-0.5857428312301636,
0.31741052865982056,
-0.03264350816607475,
-0.13814103603363037,
0.7425538301467896,
0.7560858726501465,
0.6727603077888489,
-0.21108070015907288,
0.489941269159317,
0.3148932158946991,
0.36844757199287415,
-0.346664160490036,
0.5310794115066528,
-0.3932761549949646,
0.2080000936985016,
-0.06964094191789627,
-0.9768538475036621,
-0.14810514450073242,
0.3750455677509308,
-0.17848974466323853,
0.1928970068693161,
0.6742516756057739,
0.895615816116333,
-0.3905925750732422,
0.09270939975976944,
0.08616276830434799,
0.32356491684913635,
0.03514515608549118,
1.198783040046692,
0.5341535210609436,
-0.6709185242652893,
0.6851038932800293,
-0.5535111427307129,
-0.014343207702040672,
-0.09169239550828934,
-0.5436720848083496,
-1.0773173570632935,
-0.4482777416706085,
0.1015012338757515,
-0.2657894790172577,
0.22530820965766907,
0.7195656299591064,
1.0032281875610352,
-0.972463846206665,
-0.4379645586013794,
-0.17526379227638245,
-0.2836270332336426,
-0.3935227692127228,
-0.18309666216373444,
0.4420413076877594,
-0.5935892462730408,
-0.7810973525047302,
0.32948121428489685,
0.39346539974212646,
-0.23491927981376648,
-0.582798182964325,
-0.11015455424785614,
-0.19613073766231537,
0.2428882122039795,
0.43837130069732666,
0.5009784698486328,
-0.7789530158042908,
0.10383587330579758,
0.18248328566551208,
-0.29720184206962585,
0.2909165620803833,
0.9818459153175354,
-1.0819052457809448,
0.5420749187469482,
0.4613696038722992,
0.7958723902702332,
0.8029605150222778,
0.13789060711860657,
0.6714426875114441,
-0.9432767629623413,
0.42658737301826477,
0.25139120221138,
0.40295591950416565,
0.2563677728176117,
-0.18165016174316406,
0.05322132632136345,
0.03810432553291321,
-0.4305416941642761,
-0.423550546169281,
-0.009702695533633232,
-1.003523349761963,
-0.16077786684036255,
0.8749828338623047,
-0.10813770443201065,
-0.2847276031970978,
-0.17058664560317993,
0.03910583630204201,
0.12513789534568787,
-0.39606258273124695,
0.9236127734184265,
0.384309321641922,
0.2752438485622406,
-0.408497154712677,
-0.5235924124717712,
0.2612326145172119,
0.7113103866577148,
-0.27586689591407776,
0.028408171609044075,
-0.06080487370491028,
-0.05367821082472801,
0.32282987236976624,
0.4411066174507141,
0.00005253633571555838,
0.6594387888908386,
-0.12407530844211578,
0.404040664434433,
0.07976800948381424,
-0.44678810238838196,
-0.6810435652732849,
0.28791099786758423,
-0.45531222224235535,
-0.17747972905635834
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06474v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06474v1
|
Towards a Personal Health Large Language Model
| 2024-06-10T17:16:49 | 2024-06-10T17:16:49 |
Justin Cosentino, Anastasiya Belyaeva, Xin Liu, Nicholas A. Furlotte, Zhun Yang, Chace Lee, Erik Schenck, Yojan Patel, Jian Cui, Logan Douglas Schneider, Robby Bryant, Ryan G. Gomes, Allen Jiang, Roy Lee, Yun Liu, Javier Perez, Jameson K. Rogers, Cathy Speed, Shyam Tailor, Megan Walker, Jeffrey Yu, Tim Althoff, Conor Heneghan, John Hernandez, Mark Malhotra, Leor Stern, Yossi Matias, Greg S. Corrado, Shwetak Patel, Shravya Shetty, Jiening Zhan, Shruthi Prabhakara, Daniel McDuff, Cory Y. McLean
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In health, most large language model (LLM) research has focused on clinical
tasks. However, mobile and wearable devices, which are rarely integrated into
such tasks, provide rich, longitudinal data for personal health monitoring.
Here we present Personal Health Large Language Model (PH-LLM), fine-tuned from
Gemini for understanding and reasoning over numerical time-series personal
health data. We created and curated three datasets that test 1) production of
personalized insights and recommendations from sleep patterns, physical
activity, and physiological responses, 2) expert domain knowledge, and 3)
prediction of self-reported sleep outcomes. For the first task we designed 857
case studies in collaboration with domain experts to assess real-world
scenarios in sleep and fitness. Through comprehensive evaluation of
domain-specific rubrics, we observed that Gemini Ultra 1.0 and PH-LLM are not
statistically different from expert performance in fitness and, while experts
remain superior for sleep, fine-tuning PH-LLM provided significant improvements
in using relevant domain knowledge and personalizing information for sleep
insights. We evaluated PH-LLM domain knowledge using multiple choice sleep
medicine and fitness examinations. PH-LLM achieved 79% on sleep and 88% on
fitness, exceeding average scores from a sample of human experts. Finally, we
trained PH-LLM to predict self-reported sleep quality outcomes from textual and
multimodal encoding representations of wearable data, and demonstrate that
multimodal encoding is required to match performance of specialized
discriminative models. Although further development and evaluation are
necessary in the safety-critical personal health domain, these results
demonstrate both the broad knowledge and capabilities of Gemini models and the
benefit of contextualizing physiological data for personal health applications
as done with PH-LLM.
|
[
0.143662229180336,
-0.5726865530014038,
0.6419471502304077,
0.1657608598470688,
-0.07854882627725601,
0.07873863726854324,
-0.5071051120758057,
-0.553886890411377,
0.5034793615341187,
0.7620828747749329,
-0.5611813068389893,
-0.6937017440795898,
-0.397257536649704,
-0.013874577358365059,
-0.14417453110218048,
0.9208142161369324,
0.15725654363632202,
0.1286766231060028,
0.05372633785009384,
0.03630392253398895,
-0.5060873627662659,
-0.8251413106918335,
-0.4076903164386749,
-0.5034226179122925,
0.5133333206176758,
0.3280145823955536,
0.5791052579879761,
0.24624355137348175,
0.5574431419372559,
0.16469208896160126,
0.021794719621539116,
0.08019112795591354,
-0.4461824893951416,
0.16740740835666656,
-0.048484917730093,
-0.17533865571022034,
-0.6775884032249451,
-0.2345382422208786,
0.353150337934494,
0.8222978711128235,
-0.3201834559440613,
0.4790232181549072,
-0.11440522223711014,
0.6965407133102417,
-0.32428133487701416,
0.11538950353860855,
-0.13529576361179352,
0.1077972799539566,
-0.3453519642353058,
0.07158014923334122,
-0.3975830376148224,
0.00025715853553265333,
0.06289920210838318,
-0.2692849338054657,
-0.15998578071594238,
0.1637781858444214,
0.288818359375,
0.5540849566459656,
-0.6917476058006287,
-0.16114850342273712,
-0.8386048674583435,
0.5697615742683411,
-0.982860803604126,
0.6242111921310425,
0.4792564809322357,
0.14087174832820892,
-0.18407289683818817,
-0.5510134696960449,
-0.44375836849212646,
-0.38269367814064026,
-0.10151543468236923,
0.31134501099586487,
0.10124588012695312,
-0.0034163701348006725,
-0.061095770448446274,
0.23232227563858032,
-0.6990385055541992,
0.12487722933292389,
-0.3480571508407593,
-0.029448052868247032,
0.9701092839241028,
0.44583871960639954,
0.2692897617816925,
-0.3946656584739685,
-0.019885126501321793,
0.3221859037876129,
-0.5172922015190125,
-0.07770673930644989,
0.03684971109032631,
0.15712648630142212,
-0.4593481123447418,
0.7431517243385315,
-0.375296950340271,
0.7019441723823547,
-0.007975471206009388,
-0.6109370589256287,
0.4013717770576477,
-0.11276989430189133,
-0.1599649041891098,
0.18488404154777527,
0.6469341516494751,
0.24915426969528198,
0.05924184247851372,
-0.5445123314857483,
-0.09321648627519608,
-0.14915256202220917,
0.2799585163593292,
-0.6635664701461792,
-0.2185220569372177,
0.5347984433174133,
-0.6975500583648682,
-0.036084260791540146,
-0.14608024060726166,
-0.39342987537384033,
-0.6342506408691406,
-0.6742627620697021,
0.2733628451824188,
-0.46107181906700134,
-0.2251371443271637,
0.5723207592964172,
0.27525606751441956,
-0.18161654472351074,
0.053681910037994385,
-0.9092421531677246,
0.41010764241218567,
0.7606050372123718,
0.6014402508735657,
-0.4667818546295166,
-0.10393477976322174,
-0.08152855187654495,
0.25102517008781433,
-0.11016187071800232,
0.3371029496192932,
-0.2462550550699234,
-0.4725130796432495,
-0.2092347890138626,
-0.13036289811134338,
-0.27489781379699707,
-0.5748960375785828,
0.5124861598014832,
-0.2882634401321411,
0.19845540821552277,
-0.10085213929414749,
-0.5704283118247986,
0.04633007198572159,
0.11273981630802155,
-0.2340393215417862,
0.6210095882415771,
0.16178053617477417,
-0.6176061630249023,
0.2338225543498993,
-0.6848664283752441,
-0.8516883850097656,
0.13628368079662323,
0.05532294884324074,
-0.46121102571487427,
0.05123459920287132,
0.061762139201164246,
0.8218985795974731,
-0.30462518334388733,
0.41865694522857666,
-0.4825483560562134,
-0.17204636335372925,
0.6475694179534912,
-0.017801186069846153,
0.3213396966457367,
0.2787582278251648,
-0.3217995762825012,
0.021303048357367516,
-0.8955847024917603,
-0.05301842465996742,
-0.029373763129115105,
-0.34621742367744446,
-0.3836618959903717,
0.2771299183368683,
0.06032257899641991,
0.12637709081172943,
0.3640275001525879,
-0.6940319538116455,
0.03434378653764725,
-0.3092750608921051,
0.6316155195236206,
0.5348095297813416,
0.0636390969157219,
0.17863747477531433,
-0.4848445951938629,
0.23862144351005554,
-0.19641703367233276,
0.4201744794845581,
-0.10492034256458282,
-0.520408034324646,
-0.32246172428131104,
-0.4543372094631195,
0.03384658321738243,
0.4681498110294342,
-0.16297432780265808,
0.491361528635025,
-0.38959071040153503,
-0.3574848175048828,
-0.23447684943675995,
0.2882002890110016,
0.3859942555427551,
0.7394914627075195,
0.3788739740848541,
-0.10059846192598343,
-0.27568963170051575,
-0.6193293333053589,
-0.41610187292099,
0.02629600651562214,
-0.011174038983881474,
0.5986493229866028,
0.481406033039093,
-0.9560898542404175,
0.6775403618812561,
-0.800816535949707,
-0.27655646204948425,
-0.20256371796131134,
0.006854816805571318,
0.3510087728500366,
0.3635973632335663,
0.35612478852272034,
-0.6874263882637024,
-0.27258357405662537,
0.039062172174453735,
-0.8353270888328552,
-0.05286611616611481,
0.046480946242809296,
-0.026430530473589897,
-0.23960667848587036,
0.17602141201496124,
-0.44445985555648804,
0.05282403156161308,
0.8309041261672974,
-0.6573989391326904,
0.7003737688064575,
-0.18379878997802734,
-0.07702931016683578,
-1.282492995262146,
0.27387386560440063,
0.08607259392738342,
-0.2591906487941742,
-0.7246025204658508,
-0.11478766798973083,
-0.08355399966239929,
-0.28204604983329773,
-0.0872553139925003,
0.8817742466926575,
-0.11154057085514069,
0.06415516138076782,
-0.3595549762248993,
-0.3666139245033264,
-0.2701624929904938,
0.20325586199760437,
0.0799720510840416,
0.22388416528701782,
0.299421101808548,
-0.5961500406265259,
0.23649044334888458,
0.20280402898788452,
-0.5351293087005615,
0.33077284693717957,
-0.9541341662406921,
0.2365991771221161,
-0.0036255675368010998,
0.06486330181360245,
-0.7383652925491333,
-0.9069736003875732,
0.04620078206062317,
-0.3394288718700409,
0.24676822125911713,
0.2623630464076996,
-0.3873695731163025,
-0.4864761233329773,
0.07779119908809662,
0.24571296572685242,
0.5370320677757263,
-0.39589014649391174,
0.6797846555709839,
0.7251352667808533,
-0.39154869318008423,
-0.27914974093437195,
-0.5058305859565735,
-0.04965522512793541,
-0.2788895070552826,
-0.8069413900375366,
0.6902529001235962,
-0.24424447119235992,
-0.39876788854599,
-0.038932397961616516,
-0.10882490873336792,
0.050329145044088364,
0.1054244413971901,
0.5660668015480042,
0.3963949978351593,
-0.07673952728509903,
0.42100584506988525,
-0.10452020168304443,
-0.10358641296625137,
0.11067280918359756,
-0.4011373817920685,
0.2896506190299988,
-0.04444644972681999,
-0.24055051803588867,
-0.48127463459968567,
0.27788567543029785,
0.6596174836158752,
-0.10450764745473862,
0.8537710905075073,
0.5581926703453064,
-0.5429856181144714,
-0.05879075825214386,
-0.7727057337760925,
-0.180782750248909,
-0.40569308400154114,
0.045114725828170776,
-0.20437182486057281,
-0.955128014087677,
0.34077706933021545,
-0.09814359992742538,
-0.007991124875843525,
0.15717221796512604,
0.8910202383995056,
-0.3249598443508148,
1.067980408668518,
0.598475992679596,
-0.12352749705314636,
0.34403887391090393,
-0.043032556772232056,
0.15320387482643127,
-1.0454769134521484,
-0.5424042344093323,
-0.12846195697784424,
-0.43329957127571106,
-0.33791548013687134,
-0.33139726519584656,
0.6997178792953491,
-0.4170835018157959,
-0.5684057474136353,
0.07250197976827621,
-0.48819661140441895,
-0.037735987454652786,
0.298399418592453,
0.7792306542396545,
0.3087957501411438,
-0.39713630080223083,
0.025379696860909462,
-0.10192487388849258,
-0.26949986815452576,
-0.23998847603797913,
1.1261128187179565,
0.2926483154296875,
1.326650619506836,
0.21810296177864075,
0.6355716586112976,
0.35685503482818604,
0.3148329555988312,
-0.6418318748474121,
0.19279350340366364,
-0.5538060665130615,
-0.7756861448287964,
-0.14327272772789001,
-0.5804636478424072,
-0.9775352478027344,
-0.024062197655439377,
-0.3713192641735077,
-0.8681760430335999,
-0.09012660384178162,
0.19149726629257202,
-0.6781514286994934,
-0.12433966249227524,
-0.9029254913330078,
0.8165416717529297,
-0.7786419987678528,
-0.40078669786453247,
-0.35806432366371155,
-0.6423584222793579,
0.5410932302474976,
-0.22109414637088776,
0.326081246137619,
-0.45583489537239075,
-0.02496219612658024,
0.9027179479598999,
-0.2187599390745163,
1.1059553623199463,
0.1685686856508255,
0.267238974571228,
-0.06081419438123703,
-0.21788537502288818,
0.17347535490989685,
0.20660968124866486,
-0.13883045315742493,
0.1026008278131485,
0.13561302423477173,
-0.40795406699180603,
-0.3244389593601227,
0.985816478729248,
-1.0965657234191895,
-0.44980233907699585,
-0.4122511148452759,
-0.3177820146083832,
-0.5330775380134583,
0.23328803479671478,
0.05326736345887184,
0.4239053726196289,
-0.2377382069826126,
0.3290143609046936,
0.7115945219993591,
-0.39198970794677734,
0.015166785567998886,
0.8424264192581177,
-0.15057864785194397,
-0.4179531931877136,
0.8004688024520874,
-0.058814045041799545,
-0.1850654035806656,
0.6414945721626282,
0.7920565605163574,
-0.4091425836086273,
-0.4530559480190277,
0.10890384018421173,
0.5920168161392212,
-0.46285194158554077,
0.020429348573088646,
-0.730179488658905,
-0.021949579939246178,
-0.5531184077262878,
-0.06102906912565231,
-0.4356217384338379,
-0.10050030797719955,
-0.12101013213396072,
0.061760589480400085,
0.2159806489944458,
0.9299269914627075,
0.057688698172569275,
0.31431543827056885,
-0.8528240323066711,
0.6790758967399597,
0.41082075238227844,
0.24722492694854736,
-0.28365710377693176,
-0.4051859676837921,
-0.42123666405677795,
-0.09189673513174057,
-0.05595458298921585,
-0.8660783767700195,
0.4898397624492645,
0.07457229495048523,
0.5969973802566528,
0.2902982831001282,
0.033453814685344696,
0.4282812178134918,
-0.2939293384552002,
0.6858490705490112,
0.48934653401374817,
-0.8488979935646057,
0.5714336633682251,
-0.3589330017566681,
0.3778976798057556,
0.37099286913871765,
0.3545527756214142,
-0.790774405002594,
0.21473705768585205,
-0.49317631125450134,
-0.6520187854766846,
0.20356544852256775,
0.05829326808452606,
0.008784041740000248,
0.04850039631128311,
0.800055742263794,
0.1503756195306778,
0.25787585973739624,
-0.6526140570640564,
-0.07204233109951019,
-0.017853422090411186,
-0.4415113031864166,
-0.3723995089530945,
0.016810711473226547,
-0.09173206984996796,
-0.3465122878551483,
0.5174259543418884,
-0.41158950328826904,
0.23664510250091553,
0.2583799362182617,
-0.036969274282455444,
0.01702609285712242,
0.1376650184392929,
0.4610404670238495,
0.6221095323562622,
-0.1399488002061844,
-0.03211657330393791,
0.077611044049263,
-0.5376271605491638,
-0.08881793916225433,
0.07078120857477188,
-0.012767385691404343,
-0.25563085079193115,
0.49488770961761475,
0.5130347013473511,
0.44070374965667725,
-0.8625088930130005,
0.37879055738449097,
-0.10472660511732101,
0.3312755227088928,
-0.5310930609703064,
0.16157175600528717,
0.3204156756401062,
0.08381376415491104,
-0.037696994841098785,
0.2414352297782898,
0.10656490176916122,
-0.681541919708252,
0.051118653267621994,
0.24166671931743622,
-0.2491079866886139,
-0.6626994013786316,
0.9963818192481995,
0.5119704008102417,
-0.08772463351488113,
0.5187786221504211,
0.06175852194428444,
-0.3000883460044861,
0.5151419043540955,
0.40138566493988037,
0.4360577166080475,
-0.40203091502189636,
0.0997929722070694,
0.4469805359840393,
0.04949161037802696,
-0.19329163432121277,
0.48547205328941345,
0.18072688579559326,
-0.7302216291427612,
-0.5890494585037231,
-0.6819012761116028,
-0.5443088412284851,
0.10051809996366501,
-0.5991623401641846,
0.25453680753707886,
-0.30300483107566833,
-0.4217362403869629,
0.17257505655288696,
0.17803128063678741,
-0.8645622134208679,
0.5628144145011902,
0.6466001868247986,
0.6362457871437073,
-0.4258868396282196,
0.9797885417938232,
0.5635790228843689,
0.0031769119668751955,
-0.7249355912208557,
0.0510425791144371,
0.11703874915838242,
-1.025579810142517,
0.6694619655609131,
-0.034663256257772446,
-0.13943690061569214,
-0.28021231293678284,
-0.29737406969070435,
-0.7500516772270203,
1.158469557762146,
0.535908579826355,
-0.7605910301208496,
-0.06127183884382248,
0.07152248919010162,
0.6793720126152039,
-0.49922966957092285,
-0.03784973546862602,
0.5352458357810974,
0.32005244493484497,
-0.11513908952474594,
-0.9208235740661621,
0.02351815067231655,
-0.02594851888716221,
-0.13795678317546844,
0.04848421365022659,
-0.9692119359970093,
0.6308489441871643,
-0.7669854760169983,
0.16181552410125732,
0.12917202711105347,
0.3821948170661926,
0.16038493812084198,
0.5507614612579346,
0.14368318021297455,
0.6217759251594543,
1.0743353366851807,
0.07559020817279816,
1.4668834209442139,
-0.7516371011734009,
0.29293203353881836,
1.2942800521850586,
-0.5009180307388306,
0.9823566675186157,
-0.006098325829952955,
-0.09675498306751251,
0.5780702829360962,
0.5972370505332947,
0.42706215381622314,
0.47948163747787476,
0.24848921597003937,
-0.4445846676826477,
-0.3191445469856262,
0.056589819490909576,
-0.47046923637390137,
0.4879094064235687,
0.6841183304786682,
-0.592858076095581,
0.46527132391929626,
0.2819053828716278,
0.14181312918663025,
-0.14328905940055847,
-0.17710275948047638,
0.6871205568313599,
0.35051265358924866,
-0.6990453600883484,
0.2748102843761444,
0.0760037899017334,
0.5786283016204834,
-0.8733449578285217,
0.38492029905319214,
-0.0708846002817154,
0.5096107721328735,
-0.3713160753250122,
-0.7015411853790283,
0.3724350333213806,
-0.08670051395893097,
-0.1947101503610611,
-0.28996995091438293,
0.9715592265129089,
-0.15036487579345703,
-0.6008727550506592,
0.3563087284564972,
0.5592508912086487,
0.10116837918758392,
-0.25416818261146545,
-0.5044447779655457,
-0.03874196484684944,
-0.2625426948070526,
-0.2628295421600342,
0.3439677953720093,
0.032814931124448776,
0.30965447425842285,
0.8688346147537231,
0.8015349507331848,
0.11585081368684769,
-0.0013833384728059173,
0.10047361254692078,
0.6896618604660034,
-1.075302243232727,
-0.534523069858551,
-0.7286714911460876,
0.23789352178573608,
0.054002098739147186,
-0.6039496064186096,
0.512014627456665,
0.3896546959877014,
0.3223811686038971,
-0.11687669903039932,
0.9684308171272278,
0.048710405826568604,
0.7034887671470642,
-0.5385895371437073,
0.7070247530937195,
-0.4896905720233917,
0.1900482177734375,
0.172884002327919,
-0.36858370900154114,
-0.3193586468696594,
0.4149932861328125,
-0.5788111686706543,
-0.06314387172460556,
0.5695200562477112,
0.3424842357635498,
0.06123432144522667,
-0.037820085883140564,
0.39698559045791626,
0.5235766172409058,
0.21448053419589996,
0.6121516823768616,
0.7003383040428162,
-0.08316661417484283,
0.10832797735929489,
-0.42574286460876465,
-0.3164910078048706,
-0.4326106905937195,
-0.6176928877830505,
-1.0213592052459717,
-0.43004563450813293,
-0.46758970618247986,
-0.38818174600601196,
0.2230476438999176,
1.0910886526107788,
1.1435960531234741,
-0.7122549414634705,
-0.1572626829147339,
0.24012397229671478,
-0.018899377435445786,
-0.3726741075515747,
-0.14127081632614136,
0.2168189436197281,
0.044703688472509384,
-0.247161403298378,
0.5418833494186401,
0.3462141752243042,
-0.15151207149028778,
-0.2660747468471527,
-0.34411075711250305,
0.4450983703136444,
-0.08066857606172562,
0.8827233910560608,
0.28478333353996277,
-0.6557194590568542,
-0.13219447433948517,
0.48281577229499817,
-0.12463929504156113,
-0.1455511748790741,
0.9760488867759705,
-0.6499821543693542,
0.4817333519458771,
0.355166494846344,
0.4738580286502838,
0.6205300688743591,
-0.052810437977313995,
0.3696160316467285,
-0.4840424656867981,
-0.24871335923671722,
0.48950865864753723,
0.711033284664154,
0.4250212609767914,
-0.7356166243553162,
0.5225080251693726,
0.2583838403224945,
-0.8316553831100464,
-0.34867751598358154,
0.11875706911087036,
-1.322336196899414,
-0.2810194492340088,
1.3285020589828491,
-0.10142507404088974,
-0.26109951734542847,
-0.24636006355285645,
-0.20972608029842377,
-0.14354106783866882,
-0.33401578664779663,
1.080977439880371,
0.5599995255470276,
-0.6075878143310547,
0.1301426738500595,
-0.6213241219520569,
0.25127285718917847,
0.26894769072532654,
-1.000545620918274,
-0.1671028882265091,
0.17006054520606995,
0.6482962369918823,
0.1578339785337448,
0.7215414643287659,
0.008122499100863934,
0.2605687081813812,
-0.27644506096839905,
-0.1307438760995865,
0.13419212400913239,
0.00414273701608181,
0.04410305619239807,
-0.03327479586005211,
-0.07584411650896072,
0.05899471044540405
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06469v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06469v1
|
Husky: A Unified, Open-Source Language Agent for Multi-Step Reasoning
| 2024-06-10T17:07:25 | 2024-06-10T17:07:25 |
Joongwon Kim, Bhargavi Paranjape, Tushar Khot, Hannaneh Hajishirzi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language agents perform complex tasks by using tools to execute each step
precisely. However, most existing agents are based on proprietary models or
designed to target specific tasks, such as mathematics or multi-hop question
answering. We introduce Husky, a holistic, open-source language agent that
learns to reason over a unified action space to address a diverse set of
complex tasks involving numerical, tabular, and knowledge-based reasoning.
Husky iterates between two stages: 1) generating the next action to take
towards solving a given task and 2) executing the action using expert models
and updating the current solution state. We identify a thorough ontology of
actions for addressing complex tasks and curate high-quality data to train
expert models for executing these actions. Our experiments show that Husky
outperforms prior language agents across 14 evaluation datasets. Moreover, we
introduce HuskyQA, a new evaluation set which stress tests language agents for
mixed-tool reasoning, with a focus on retrieving missing knowledge and
performing numerical reasoning. Despite using 7B models, Husky matches or even
exceeds frontier LMs such as GPT-4 on these tasks, showcasing the efficacy of
our holistic approach in addressing complex reasoning problems. Our code and
models are available at https://github.com/agent-husky/Husky-v1.
|
[
-0.1552925854921341,
-0.8436532616615295,
1.003231406211853,
0.333855003118515,
0.062059011310338974,
0.20883575081825256,
-0.10400645434856415,
-0.10356961190700531,
-0.0535833016037941,
0.6390334963798523,
-0.5893266201019287,
-0.7755593657493591,
-0.31347209215164185,
-0.22464630007743835,
-0.1577633023262024,
0.7652688026428223,
-0.10445726662874222,
-0.06645044684410095,
0.12607155740261078,
-0.37190109491348267,
-0.4084077775478363,
-0.3425608277320862,
-0.7205331325531006,
-0.6125435829162598,
0.9014357328414917,
0.42486193776130676,
0.9284409880638123,
0.4529702663421631,
0.21460552513599396,
0.3637656569480896,
0.1761406660079956,
0.12655583024024963,
0.006633652839809656,
0.28863200545310974,
-0.4505152702331543,
-0.4291917085647583,
-0.5876930952072144,
-0.12662304937839508,
0.23326218128204346,
0.5467662811279297,
-0.41768065094947815,
0.14194004237651825,
-0.3222369849681854,
0.40215983986854553,
-0.6376446485519409,
0.27788883447647095,
-0.5080923438072205,
-0.13187861442565918,
-0.002063798252493143,
-0.0392208956182003,
-0.40558576583862305,
-0.27871668338775635,
0.027333874255418777,
-0.9468865990638733,
-0.03259152173995972,
-0.15848411619663239,
0.4329686760902405,
0.5104917287826538,
-0.4694875180721283,
-0.28507527709007263,
-0.7161369323730469,
0.9780128598213196,
-0.6650221943855286,
0.628876805305481,
0.19123397767543793,
0.3641742765903473,
-0.31587398052215576,
-0.8526761531829834,
-0.5824196338653564,
-0.44486430287361145,
-0.0033536460250616074,
0.04931756108999252,
-0.14775367081165314,
0.06441496312618256,
0.356230229139328,
-0.0839415118098259,
-0.6757224202156067,
0.1448758989572525,
-0.045085880905389786,
-0.09618987888097763,
0.5193429589271545,
0.37877774238586426,
0.45992428064346313,
0.13638067245483398,
-0.037782639265060425,
-0.28657928109169006,
-0.19825799763202667,
0.3942558467388153,
0.34767839312553406,
0.3709557056427002,
0.20377524197101593,
0.46311455965042114,
-0.4945398271083832,
0.5873528718948364,
-0.011533980257809162,
-0.11211184412240982,
-0.09250134229660034,
0.11574707925319672,
-0.39101794362068176,
0.20508071780204773,
0.7272034883499146,
-0.21931658685207367,
-0.12752538919448853,
-0.42442041635513306,
-0.34779679775238037,
0.06179484352469444,
0.5267892479896545,
-0.2679176330566406,
-0.16913878917694092,
0.6920228600502014,
-0.06973746418952942,
-0.06597669422626495,
-0.07938066869974136,
-0.4579681158065796,
-0.4163195788860321,
-0.6173977255821228,
0.6324318051338196,
-0.42744553089141846,
-0.4630368649959564,
0.7212782502174377,
-0.0280701145529747,
0.46944233775138855,
0.6534536480903625,
-0.42157211899757385,
0.32923081517219543,
1.020650029182434,
0.49623602628707886,
0.21682026982307434,
-0.8008665442466736,
-0.8964606523513794,
-0.019091647118330002,
-0.5341731905937195,
0.8434680104255676,
-0.5456976294517517,
0.24231593310832977,
-0.08700719475746155,
0.05865927040576935,
-0.10593051463365555,
-0.23720325529575348,
0.750482976436615,
-0.5566408038139343,
-0.013843820430338383,
-0.1724219024181366,
-0.2778952419757843,
-0.44136884808540344,
0.4038908779621124,
-0.942704975605011,
1.239343285560608,
-0.006420414429157972,
-0.6477225422859192,
0.20202402770519257,
-1.0917644500732422,
-0.36294978857040405,
0.1978287249803543,
0.19128043949604034,
0.00739566283300519,
-0.060921065509319305,
-0.0758100375533104,
0.5753973126411438,
-0.33116859197616577,
0.39036551117897034,
-0.4319835603237152,
-0.040741510689258575,
-0.03687594458460808,
0.07820335030555725,
0.8214343190193176,
0.11836816370487213,
-0.6047751903533936,
0.5494043231010437,
-0.6226834058761597,
0.27186810970306396,
0.13444784283638,
-0.503711998462677,
-0.4007912576198578,
0.03156020864844322,
-0.3111351728439331,
0.4971412420272827,
0.06507562100887299,
-0.7024496793746948,
0.15689148008823395,
0.008146492764353752,
-0.017654459923505783,
0.5508108735084534,
-0.5835214257240295,
0.38072898983955383,
-0.32581302523612976,
0.31146439909935,
-0.10179165750741959,
0.07812196761369705,
-0.0384199433028698,
-0.3922809958457947,
-1.055100440979004,
-0.0715881958603859,
0.10107197612524033,
0.6804420351982117,
-0.6475017666816711,
0.5120403170585632,
0.0015115066198632121,
-0.9142583012580872,
-0.815453827381134,
-0.010142482817173004,
0.33902567625045776,
0.20584186911582947,
0.4276663661003113,
0.030281007289886475,
-0.2389998584985733,
-0.7022776007652283,
-0.4950135052204132,
-0.32544416189193726,
0.016034407541155815,
-0.19298061728477478,
0.5077396631240845,
-0.21726496517658234,
0.7321649193763733,
-0.46205219626426697,
-0.10401393473148346,
-0.5160329341888428,
0.6720258593559265,
0.09079987555742264,
0.36354517936706543,
-0.026343677192926407,
-0.5647749900817871,
-0.339545339345932,
0.35587719082832336,
-0.8536336421966553,
0.01573496125638485,
-0.4001215994358063,
-0.37636497616767883,
0.1649453043937683,
0.37293025851249695,
-1.0428091287612915,
0.16974061727523804,
0.3844296634197235,
-0.6480379700660706,
0.7947514653205872,
-0.370263010263443,
0.025858884677290916,
-0.8533439040184021,
0.2072489857673645,
0.22407016158103943,
-0.22750957310199738,
-0.9973112344741821,
0.376920610666275,
0.03589427471160889,
0.10177632421255112,
-0.5767819881439209,
0.6364979147911072,
-0.1664532870054245,
-0.09771913290023804,
-0.06853128969669342,
-0.15453143417835236,
0.046177130192518234,
0.7728934288024902,
0.32006755471229553,
0.18646666407585144,
0.7303082346916199,
-0.6397219896316528,
0.6213741302490234,
-0.018153809010982513,
-0.3130037486553192,
0.5492159724235535,
-0.6260618567466736,
0.4646867513656616,
-0.1299493908882141,
0.0598132386803627,
-0.42455199360847473,
-0.10233549773693085,
0.10896497219800949,
-0.24583768844604492,
0.06944803893566132,
0.16008691489696503,
-0.8689125776290894,
-0.31566092371940613,
-0.02787523716688156,
-0.08855971693992615,
0.1742425560951233,
-0.4505693018436432,
0.9561754465103149,
0.2233680933713913,
-0.018603520467877388,
-0.6151465773582458,
-0.09643033891916275,
-0.021777642890810966,
-0.1266651153564453,
-0.5494006276130676,
-0.11670982837677002,
-0.16883720457553864,
-0.6049819588661194,
0.14525608718395233,
-0.22138120234012604,
-0.36074215173721313,
0.32842302322387695,
-0.07851502299308777,
0.006159614305943251,
-0.2611061632633209,
0.200047105550766,
-0.05070667713880539,
-0.09621022641658783,
0.09226975589990616,
-0.555467963218689,
0.3895983099937439,
-0.422331303358078,
-0.575355052947998,
-0.3427746891975403,
0.49869880080223083,
0.9672160744667053,
-0.34770411252975464,
0.37102726101875305,
0.7578661441802979,
-0.36040863394737244,
-0.24798820912837982,
-0.49490657448768616,
-0.021501343697309494,
-0.39635181427001953,
0.4519929885864258,
-0.7372072339057922,
-0.6148756742477417,
0.2883405089378357,
-0.09194200485944748,
0.7356380224227905,
0.3471124768257141,
0.7231932282447815,
-0.17921753227710724,
1.3804653882980347,
0.4637019634246826,
0.11096001416444778,
-0.03330659866333008,
-0.1499572992324829,
0.23321178555488586,
-0.4441404342651367,
-0.5348451137542725,
-0.7534635066986084,
-0.20098337531089783,
-0.02359962835907936,
-0.5178557634353638,
0.030107853934168816,
0.06855466961860657,
-0.5847692489624023,
0.4127534329891205,
-0.3434143662452698,
0.33749720454216003,
0.8497181534767151,
-0.17631305754184723,
0.35646307468414307,
-0.506556510925293,
-0.4312182068824768,
0.23143765330314636,
-0.5835592746734619,
-0.653861403465271,
0.6547660231590271,
0.45228973031044006,
0.9652652740478516,
0.16895166039466858,
0.34055376052856445,
0.3360559046268463,
0.28668326139450073,
-1.0955060720443726,
0.5249378681182861,
0.12840679287910461,
-0.5995990037918091,
-0.7192903757095337,
-0.26078590750694275,
-0.9967632293701172,
0.5048859119415283,
0.0737316906452179,
-0.721590518951416,
-0.46937546133995056,
-0.12532368302345276,
-0.11206195503473282,
0.52183997631073,
-0.4343407154083252,
1.0486559867858887,
-0.4546832740306854,
-0.14112675189971924,
-0.317963570356369,
-0.5052545666694641,
0.4004072844982147,
-0.15978263318538666,
0.24257241189479828,
-0.29595252871513367,
0.09738865494728088,
0.5796171426773071,
-0.4506285488605499,
0.7520359754562378,
-0.21126218140125275,
-0.2664802372455597,
0.20918628573417664,
0.4412260055541992,
0.6031895875930786,
-0.326021283864975,
0.0027151708491146564,
-0.14531747996807098,
0.14122751355171204,
-0.5388197898864746,
-0.9306268692016602,
0.5386733412742615,
-0.7387601137161255,
-0.8537137508392334,
-0.3682589828968048,
-0.7160254716873169,
-0.1830257922410965,
0.2165488749742508,
-0.32632169127464294,
0.45919105410575867,
-0.03972027823328972,
0.07630209624767303,
0.5671786069869995,
-0.09707529842853546,
0.3719305694103241,
0.9575797319412231,
0.037425559014081955,
-0.23966920375823975,
0.7288607954978943,
-0.14187903702259064,
0.11192160844802856,
0.4138769507408142,
0.288412481546402,
-0.5310794711112976,
-0.1665506213903427,
-0.7000892758369446,
0.24715740978717804,
-0.922701358795166,
0.14048133790493011,
-0.9921787977218628,
0.05614390969276428,
-0.20596742630004883,
-0.26997607946395874,
-0.5312774777412415,
-0.2626052498817444,
0.06274735182523727,
0.06618514657020569,
0.12778425216674805,
0.9248643517494202,
0.10352300107479095,
0.1643603891134262,
-0.8920455574989319,
0.30471470952033997,
0.7056517004966736,
0.29584965109825134,
0.00250437343493104,
-0.23377348482608795,
-0.19639363884925842,
-0.18936187028884888,
-0.48515626788139343,
-0.7290229797363281,
0.220499649643898,
-0.08713223040103912,
0.9919904470443726,
0.1326235830783844,
0.21261776983737946,
0.5626828670501709,
-0.2741348445415497,
0.5063828229904175,
0.2979351580142975,
-1.0866881608963013,
0.47073981165885925,
-0.29206666350364685,
0.6220433115959167,
0.2866787314414978,
0.4675086736679077,
-0.7809448838233948,
-0.8685850501060486,
-0.7480151057243347,
-0.349532812833786,
1.0338494777679443,
0.160653755068779,
-0.14766620099544525,
0.4872121214866638,
-0.07033731043338776,
0.3270856440067291,
-0.005986175034195185,
-0.5772659182548523,
-0.1510275900363922,
-0.3294597566127777,
-0.13234928250312805,
-0.004579044878482819,
0.4129806458950043,
-0.0076030041091144085,
-0.18616409599781036,
0.7155414819717407,
-0.6317383050918579,
-0.1816544532775879,
0.12190558016300201,
-0.3003510534763336,
-0.10309875011444092,
0.6197739839553833,
0.39592352509498596,
0.5591171979904175,
-0.06367768347263336,
0.31103354692459106,
0.21118570864200592,
-0.3220592737197876,
0.18739156424999237,
0.1293901801109314,
0.07408531755208969,
0.0878169909119606,
0.37785619497299194,
0.7130299806594849,
0.20544815063476562,
-0.7891983985900879,
0.20678146183490753,
-0.20113494992256165,
-0.49972212314605713,
-0.04160083830356598,
-0.023555072024464607,
0.25561949610710144,
0.4370241165161133,
0.13118913769721985,
-0.10739292949438095,
0.17518816888332367,
-0.6128256916999817,
0.2078382670879364,
0.1492905616760254,
-0.7116484045982361,
-0.7100763916969299,
0.5256702303886414,
0.0705341100692749,
-0.47381657361984253,
0.45966359972953796,
-0.34585121273994446,
-0.5900251269340515,
0.6575581431388855,
0.45130252838134766,
1.0197514295578003,
-0.23118115961551666,
0.7077134847640991,
0.2728573977947235,
0.3724682331085205,
-0.30119502544403076,
0.6820975542068481,
-0.08593592792749405,
-0.6746113896369934,
-0.6235806941986084,
-0.6152052283287048,
-0.5795638561248779,
0.40367192029953003,
-0.4110347330570221,
0.34606727957725525,
-0.34182098507881165,
0.11032325774431229,
0.13973842561244965,
0.0518493577837944,
-0.751763105392456,
0.1326388418674469,
0.05117616429924965,
1.1103755235671997,
-0.7437726855278015,
1.028277039527893,
1.2682160139083862,
-0.3562718331813812,
-1.1789451837539673,
-0.04861409589648247,
0.056560926139354706,
-0.38139569759368896,
0.6579175591468811,
0.126013845205307,
-0.15731891989707947,
0.121961809694767,
-0.4167785048484802,
-0.6652522683143616,
0.9776220321655273,
0.3775515556335449,
-0.09226366877555847,
-0.010584238916635513,
0.09747028350830078,
0.451255738735199,
-0.2145618051290512,
0.3244032561779022,
0.8806976675987244,
0.7095561027526855,
0.26503682136535645,
-1.0553706884384155,
0.08037305623292923,
-0.14852918684482574,
-0.5749906897544861,
0.3934684991836548,
-0.46866902709007263,
0.9780444502830505,
-0.3134706914424896,
-0.05254357308149338,
-0.12683649361133575,
0.36950695514678955,
0.5244747996330261,
0.42427295446395874,
0.7546154260635376,
0.9319191575050354,
0.908782958984375,
0.07201075553894043,
0.8490632176399231,
0.050247617065906525,
0.3328373432159424,
0.9696899056434631,
-0.4513531029224396,
0.6701999306678772,
0.10116276144981384,
0.10372669249773026,
0.7608783841133118,
0.5184286236763,
0.4807625412940979,
0.39568808674812317,
0.1054314523935318,
-0.3124588131904602,
-0.7298124432563782,
-0.26884186267852783,
0.33671078085899353,
0.5916095972061157,
0.36524078249931335,
0.2882884442806244,
-0.6510862112045288,
-0.2748897671699524,
0.16800224781036377,
-0.1020989865064621,
-0.3967594504356384,
0.8589758276939392,
-0.02051657624542713,
-1.0501633882522583,
0.35650497674942017,
0.03913617879152298,
0.1458943784236908,
-0.6511491537094116,
-0.12265138328075409,
0.015361802652478218,
0.15029826760292053,
-0.12064314633607864,
-1.0771170854568481,
0.26051121950149536,
0.027887217700481415,
0.23577997088432312,
-0.16190895438194275,
0.7895439863204956,
-0.3617607355117798,
-0.19136899709701538,
0.46009403467178345,
0.7465585470199585,
0.24627216160297394,
-0.3836057186126709,
-0.9973134994506836,
-0.2403538078069687,
-0.26943737268447876,
-0.3079051375389099,
0.05945858359336853,
0.8756300210952759,
-0.28281328082084656,
0.9023479223251343,
0.7543416619300842,
-0.02340771071612835,
0.01556189265102148,
0.19013990461826324,
0.8834396600723267,
-0.7693978548049927,
-0.4597941040992737,
-0.6527011394500732,
0.9023720026016235,
0.0028879104647785425,
-0.20498794317245483,
0.429788738489151,
0.4651485085487366,
0.6332987546920776,
-0.020696232095360756,
0.9357544779777527,
0.0026946517173200846,
0.33540794253349304,
-0.4101833999156952,
0.5124436020851135,
-0.6915022730827332,
-0.12897786498069763,
-0.050477467477321625,
-0.7563464641571045,
-0.3556162118911743,
0.1904866099357605,
-0.03486032038927078,
-0.448638916015625,
0.9826325178146362,
0.7866621017456055,
-0.18919609487056732,
0.0010841010371223092,
0.7753254175186157,
-0.028567666187882423,
0.4503459632396698,
0.5100956559181213,
1.2009118795394897,
0.10386749356985092,
0.6435716152191162,
-0.10047641396522522,
-0.16740059852600098,
-0.06256267428398132,
-0.5488409399986267,
-0.9228754043579102,
-0.6876572966575623,
-0.3028651773929596,
-0.25348135828971863,
-0.2916143536567688,
1.1024857759475708,
0.6951846480369568,
-0.6807621121406555,
-0.3084701895713806,
-0.10509424656629562,
0.3461364209651947,
-0.39177462458610535,
-0.1915472149848938,
0.17635594308376312,
-0.8221476078033447,
-0.6650938391685486,
0.40350526571273804,
0.4554324746131897,
-0.3716343641281128,
-0.4963243007659912,
-0.46925342082977295,
-0.16973839700222015,
0.2863785922527313,
0.609682023525238,
0.4077064096927643,
-1.105905294418335,
-0.2536412477493286,
0.34740692377090454,
-0.32927989959716797,
-0.04751446843147278,
1.0922272205352783,
-0.6315871477127075,
0.4974652826786041,
0.4901409447193146,
0.676639199256897,
0.11557816714048386,
-0.3197520673274994,
0.5499122142791748,
-0.2954537570476532,
-0.19033120572566986,
0.2965531647205353,
0.32484370470046997,
0.10708201676607132,
-0.18030190467834473,
0.35704612731933594,
-0.04598301276564598,
-0.47026336193084717,
-0.5145440697669983,
0.21319960057735443,
-0.9058817625045776,
-0.4368516206741333,
1.1823142766952515,
-0.32373014092445374,
-0.32802945375442505,
-0.7168286442756653,
-0.4194542467594147,
0.2905644476413727,
-0.5606229901313782,
0.6789663434028625,
0.6397979259490967,
-0.12372466921806335,
-0.15993846952915192,
-0.5732936859130859,
0.4478277266025543,
0.33055388927459717,
-1.2192176580429077,
0.19778980314731598,
0.329111784696579,
0.14021284878253937,
0.27990931272506714,
0.6750143766403198,
0.225304514169693,
0.48544472455978394,
-0.01483970321714878,
0.4006957709789276,
0.11193865537643433,
-0.6137232184410095,
-0.2734885811805725,
0.030722467228770256,
0.3171272575855255,
-0.14205482602119446
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06465v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06465v1
|
AID: Adapting Image2Video Diffusion Models for Instruction-guided Video Prediction
| 2024-06-10T17:02:08 | 2024-06-10T17:02:08 |
Zhen Xing, Qi Dai, Zejia Weng, Zuxuan Wu, Yu-Gang Jiang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Text-guided video prediction (TVP) involves predicting the motion of future
frames from the initial frame according to an instruction, which has wide
applications in virtual reality, robotics, and content creation. Previous TVP
methods make significant breakthroughs by adapting Stable Diffusion for this
task. However, they struggle with frame consistency and temporal stability
primarily due to the limited scale of video datasets. We observe that
pretrained Image2Video diffusion models possess good priors for video dynamics
but they lack textual control. Hence, transferring Image2Video models to
leverage their video dynamic priors while injecting instruction control to
generate controllable videos is both a meaningful and challenging task. To
achieve this, we introduce the Multi-Modal Large Language Model (MLLM) to
predict future video states based on initial frames and text instructions. More
specifically, we design a dual query transformer (DQFormer) architecture, which
integrates the instructions and frames into the conditional embeddings for
future frame prediction. Additionally, we develop Long-Short Term Temporal
Adapters and Spatial Adapters that can quickly transfer general video diffusion
models to specific scenarios with minimal training costs. Experimental results
show that our method significantly outperforms state-of-the-art techniques on
four datasets: Something Something V2, Epic Kitchen-100, Bridge Data, and
UCF-101. Notably, AID achieves 91.2% and 55.5% FVD improvements on Bridge and
SSv2 respectively, demonstrating its effectiveness in various domains. More
examples can be found at our website https://chenhsing.github.io/AID.
|
[
-0.13095222413539886,
-0.9323329925537109,
0.4440566897392273,
0.17974232137203217,
-0.17590665817260742,
-0.26924097537994385,
-0.26442357897758484,
0.0031480491161346436,
-0.3689565658569336,
0.43795090913772583,
-0.44345226883888245,
-0.17145580053329468,
-0.9232591390609741,
-0.39451634883880615,
-0.3487504720687866,
0.7390934228897095,
-0.2766570746898651,
0.4178464114665985,
-0.20860442519187927,
0.007228477392345667,
-0.8094106316566467,
0.06412706524133682,
-0.6685206890106201,
-0.15966521203517914,
0.0689157024025917,
0.2133599817752838,
0.6260775923728943,
0.3181881308555603,
0.2677437663078308,
0.30056050419807434,
0.14473013579845428,
0.1891542375087738,
-0.2818351984024048,
0.19532069563865662,
0.013467234559357166,
-0.3221510946750641,
-0.17196737229824066,
-0.20569874346256256,
0.7310092449188232,
0.1362309604883194,
-0.2764416038990021,
-0.013872796669602394,
0.10336554050445557,
0.6876698732376099,
-0.43454253673553467,
0.2005567103624344,
-0.5819804668426514,
0.30592718720436096,
0.2617051303386688,
-0.24939265847206116,
-0.5304856300354004,
-0.1572742611169815,
0.25397175550460815,
-0.6117401123046875,
0.2772449553012848,
0.03487573564052582,
0.3575339615345001,
0.6842079758644104,
-0.6074092388153076,
-0.12370967864990234,
-0.8779094219207764,
0.5407898426055908,
-0.4930693805217743,
0.7637546062469482,
0.575261652469635,
0.6009050011634827,
-0.31212571263313293,
-0.6641971468925476,
-0.5068895816802979,
-0.2195952981710434,
0.14109398424625397,
0.17919813096523285,
-0.2310212105512619,
0.030947180464863777,
0.22456888854503632,
-0.1939975619316101,
-0.7081537246704102,
0.24920214712619781,
-0.2161371111869812,
-0.10560636967420578,
0.3382181227207184,
0.07391264289617538,
0.28891536593437195,
-0.14841848611831665,
-0.5863744616508484,
-0.07284978032112122,
-0.39421546459198,
0.3102807402610779,
-0.0720176175236702,
-0.2883135974407196,
-0.35877716541290283,
0.5946051478385925,
0.24294401705265045,
0.6138874292373657,
0.21934650838375092,
-0.32047566771507263,
0.021209847182035446,
-0.3145986497402191,
-0.5511770248413086,
-0.054047975689172745,
0.6470620632171631,
0.6296401619911194,
0.10503134876489639,
0.19466985762119293,
0.027521956712007523,
-0.09570276737213135,
0.12568718194961548,
-1.1164439916610718,
-0.5255696773529053,
0.10641127079725266,
-0.4697847366333008,
0.2272755205631256,
-0.048714540898799896,
-1.1430033445358276,
-0.6883220076560974,
-0.40423423051834106,
0.4973495602607727,
-0.39999857544898987,
-0.3166285753250122,
0.11253063380718231,
-0.18688620626926422,
0.2801703214645386,
0.6325700879096985,
-0.8811243176460266,
0.18516391515731812,
0.336478054523468,
0.9663219451904297,
-0.2528655230998993,
-0.18744774162769318,
-0.9961566925048828,
0.31652963161468506,
-0.23281492292881012,
0.724640965461731,
-0.6990616321563721,
-0.2844507694244385,
0.2900121510028839,
0.37812340259552,
-0.06701214611530304,
-0.30262166261672974,
0.24195833504199982,
-0.6814671158790588,
0.37256595492362976,
0.09989676624536514,
-0.4995228052139282,
-0.19027824699878693,
0.01218207273632288,
-0.7598115801811218,
0.8746299743652344,
0.0569743849337101,
-0.39948394894599915,
0.40061673521995544,
-0.698453962802887,
-0.3351805508136749,
-0.3156736195087433,
-0.0930870994925499,
-0.5198460817337036,
-0.09334934502840042,
0.17448487877845764,
0.4736025631427765,
-0.10728944092988968,
0.48700398206710815,
-0.23687639832496643,
-0.13738738000392914,
0.125717893242836,
-0.9753542542457581,
0.23688745498657227,
-0.10706374794244766,
-0.4296033978462219,
0.24688473343849182,
-0.6774955987930298,
-0.25064682960510254,
-0.36901170015335083,
-0.16609884798526764,
-0.1682511866092682,
0.21998700499534607,
0.07019554823637009,
0.391676127910614,
-0.20836305618286133,
-0.19764012098312378,
0.30611300468444824,
-0.08651698380708694,
0.3230256736278534,
1.0220662355422974,
-0.12440512329339981,
0.8544215559959412,
0.21361741423606873,
0.8898363709449768,
0.04154503718018532,
0.24352718889713287,
-0.29668083786964417,
-0.6320974826812744,
-0.44161221385002136,
-0.025608576834201813,
0.08498715609312057,
0.7069098949432373,
-1.0716179609298706,
-0.10345551371574402,
-0.24347396194934845,
-0.18415102362632751,
-0.27250534296035767,
0.26790139079093933,
0.2168891280889511,
0.5150995850563049,
0.5990167856216431,
-0.07997288554906845,
-0.5208435654640198,
-0.46867215633392334,
0.2972497045993805,
0.023580629378557205,
-0.2549543082714081,
0.1552177518606186,
0.27157095074653625,
-0.14988595247268677,
0.47098276019096375,
-0.5980581045150757,
-0.5145482420921326,
0.10726623237133026,
0.08956035226583481,
-0.10126733779907227,
0.390584260225296,
0.47595492005348206,
-1.1301311254501343,
-0.5683113932609558,
0.007389270234853029,
-0.5956427454948425,
0.3056896924972534,
-0.2579917311668396,
-0.20052970945835114,
0.22665514051914215,
0.6679418087005615,
-0.3709148168563843,
0.5581415295600891,
1.0316869020462036,
-0.6500224471092224,
0.4551287591457367,
-0.5439673066139221,
0.19730153679847717,
-1.3056915998458862,
-0.4635127782821655,
0.2741967439651489,
-0.23965276777744293,
-0.34935808181762695,
-0.497123122215271,
-0.020764779299497604,
-0.11775636672973633,
-0.3753904104232788,
0.60922771692276,
-0.38434284925460815,
-0.04919227212667465,
-0.3935054540634155,
-0.09725380688905716,
-0.10070163756608963,
0.4155687093734741,
0.2672352194786072,
0.8782936334609985,
0.8074732422828674,
-0.5250644087791443,
0.512493908405304,
0.2652256190776825,
-0.4946996569633484,
0.5494051575660706,
-0.5753597617149353,
-0.24937325716018677,
-0.3049387037754059,
0.3710152804851532,
-1.1081843376159668,
-0.24972710013389587,
0.2344397008419037,
-0.2973095774650574,
0.5188958644866943,
-0.4364053010940552,
-0.06530144810676575,
-0.18011392652988434,
-0.27062633633613586,
0.3127284348011017,
0.6891317367553711,
-0.46473103761672974,
0.9545711278915405,
0.24759866297245026,
-0.22945962846279144,
-0.7210974097251892,
-0.6547474265098572,
0.01814541034400463,
-0.13164161145687103,
-0.47747543454170227,
0.5342453122138977,
-0.5463807582855225,
0.16537514328956604,
0.22117839753627777,
-0.04574381932616234,
-0.35170114040374756,
-0.19488707184791565,
0.6350897550582886,
0.43346118927001953,
-0.3323633372783661,
0.11151222884654999,
0.35127121210098267,
-0.01086544431746006,
0.08139931410551071,
-0.3832094073295593,
0.3109537959098816,
0.39198482036590576,
-0.25720787048339844,
-0.5192767977714539,
0.4011559784412384,
0.5720308423042297,
-0.23896092176437378,
0.6016385555267334,
1.2142245769500732,
-0.28598880767822266,
-0.2101832777261734,
-0.4189196527004242,
-0.0480111688375473,
-0.4784524738788605,
0.8725854754447937,
-0.15482668578624725,
-0.6928358674049377,
0.029352378100156784,
-0.12402444332838058,
-0.029417909681797028,
-0.0543932169675827,
0.6476742029190063,
-0.18336032330989838,
1.0507378578186035,
0.8215286135673523,
0.15886804461479187,
1.0639725923538208,
-0.40674903988838196,
-0.1024337112903595,
-0.7655483484268188,
-0.45148754119873047,
0.025411007925868034,
-0.39511242508888245,
-0.3765745162963867,
-0.9129235744476318,
0.5078315734863281,
0.08645892888307571,
-0.2170502096414566,
0.037765152752399445,
-0.19201669096946716,
0.3930320739746094,
0.3784170150756836,
0.15264621376991272,
-0.016253303736448288,
0.2683636546134949,
0.2197655588388443,
-0.185512974858284,
-0.6319557428359985,
-0.16252616047859192,
0.9666301608085632,
0.3792364001274109,
0.8049139380455017,
0.35596945881843567,
-0.07022535055875778,
0.7124857902526855,
0.30503174662590027,
-0.941311776638031,
0.39832669496536255,
-0.4361414909362793,
-0.18629120290279388,
-0.4223722517490387,
-0.09770302474498749,
-0.8108494281768799,
0.1378553807735443,
-0.4173089265823364,
-0.4236166775226593,
0.061564862728118896,
0.3868027627468109,
-0.3129720687866211,
0.2677031457424164,
-0.8075003027915955,
0.8466993570327759,
-0.29067176580429077,
-0.6521615386009216,
-0.19617809355258942,
-0.589444100856781,
0.2558028995990753,
-0.05623359978199005,
0.3475753962993622,
0.06827311962842941,
-0.17264872789382935,
0.6161871552467346,
-0.03746635094285011,
0.738319993019104,
-0.5138253569602966,
-0.07787322252988815,
0.2723034620285034,
0.138407900929451,
0.40489521622657776,
0.2700643539428711,
0.000030338764190673828,
-0.36060449481010437,
0.021420307457447052,
-0.20229211449623108,
-0.924243152141571,
0.6236763000488281,
-0.6342766284942627,
-0.5263293981552124,
-0.08029770106077194,
-0.38966768980026245,
-0.03729524835944176,
0.23584933578968048,
0.08867212384939194,
0.7085882425308228,
-0.022973041981458664,
0.24293938279151917,
0.951800525188446,
-0.09349782019853592,
0.7840700745582581,
0.5383056402206421,
-0.1615825742483139,
-0.6189830303192139,
0.6832544803619385,
-0.06208402290940285,
0.28014999628067017,
0.5887433886528015,
0.2190500795841217,
-0.4392165243625641,
-0.589210033416748,
-0.8563228845596313,
-0.19395604729652405,
-0.5540418028831482,
-0.40974366664886475,
-0.3469453752040863,
0.07286962121725082,
-0.39149239659309387,
-0.09445565193891525,
-0.262274831533432,
-0.16956201195716858,
-0.39636117219924927,
-0.20938721299171448,
0.32569047808647156,
0.5042318105697632,
0.008484098128974438,
0.26050055027008057,
-0.69091796875,
0.5515850782394409,
0.6217043399810791,
0.38084515929222107,
-0.21927981078624725,
-0.9416818022727966,
-0.2746456265449524,
-0.02943495661020279,
-0.36110976338386536,
-0.9246063232421875,
0.318050742149353,
0.5246772170066833,
0.3443939983844757,
0.4007068872451782,
-0.12835244834423065,
0.7504756450653076,
-0.9404253363609314,
1.0133880376815796,
0.4924473762512207,
-0.5664142966270447,
0.47599583864212036,
0.007402108516544104,
0.1538228988647461,
0.05285219848155975,
0.4864742159843445,
-0.233962282538414,
0.1551409214735031,
-0.06104952469468117,
-0.6253672242164612,
0.43695172667503357,
-0.26380717754364014,
0.38170310854911804,
0.3424670994281769,
0.14617250859737396,
0.14041006565093994,
-0.09154064208269119,
-0.604853093624115,
-0.1793949455022812,
-0.4639888107776642,
-0.1763734519481659,
-0.1640874445438385,
-0.39799851179122925,
-0.028008269146084785,
-0.2546434700489044,
0.5728021264076233,
-0.24432812631130219,
0.23617960512638092,
0.10061714053153992,
-0.10574934631586075,
-0.2631073594093323,
0.1438436061143875,
0.7690950036048889,
0.5441111922264099,
-0.028895342722535133,
0.11273226886987686,
0.05920660123229027,
-0.6668916940689087,
0.41999551653862,
0.41598233580589294,
-0.06069464609026909,
0.1037827655673027,
0.256305992603302,
1.045951008796692,
0.31358182430267334,
-0.6408072710037231,
0.7064208388328552,
-0.05397472158074379,
-0.19064302742481232,
-0.6609312295913696,
0.004516058135777712,
-0.13777980208396912,
0.5883673429489136,
0.2701309323310852,
0.3026990592479706,
0.18290676176548004,
-0.33628740906715393,
0.3534502685070038,
0.4070049524307251,
-0.4705892503261566,
-0.5124058127403259,
1.087273120880127,
0.14530985057353973,
-0.41105908155441284,
0.4454541504383087,
-0.1742672324180603,
-0.3160798251628876,
0.4336983859539032,
0.6184789538383484,
0.8516523241996765,
-0.5722882747650146,
0.5507427453994751,
0.4127316474914551,
-0.012233984656631947,
-0.2752438187599182,
0.02323979139328003,
-0.04474964365363121,
-0.5638671517372131,
-0.6739425659179688,
-0.5360742211341858,
0.08233673870563507,
0.028838688507676125,
-0.550083577632904,
0.5096868872642517,
-0.23369364440441132,
-0.18508900701999664,
-0.04374026134610176,
-0.33018767833709717,
-0.7536922693252563,
0.2296590358018875,
0.4195488691329956,
0.8599629998207092,
-0.9205318689346313,
1.2378649711608887,
0.7055464386940002,
-0.1902163028717041,
-0.6303662657737732,
-0.07823500037193298,
-0.03154969587922096,
-0.7061742544174194,
0.3961844742298126,
0.03877436742186546,
-0.1178143322467804,
-0.13931885361671448,
-0.26045912504196167,
-0.7161881923675537,
1.3395678997039795,
0.29637622833251953,
-0.5235240459442139,
-0.46931877732276917,
-0.14867565035820007,
0.36528444290161133,
-0.13648468255996704,
0.24509726464748383,
0.3007752299308777,
0.46811601519584656,
0.38071566820144653,
-0.6940838098526001,
-0.20599493384361267,
-0.11162478476762772,
0.08298846334218979,
0.1927911788225174,
-0.3065045475959778,
0.483979195356369,
-0.4479934573173523,
0.1378956437110901,
0.020070940256118774,
0.8406293392181396,
-0.12114444375038147,
0.6291372776031494,
0.5126881003379822,
0.24422623217105865,
0.4417611062526703,
0.25479766726493835,
0.7804458141326904,
-0.11376502364873886,
0.04582485929131508,
1.2813279628753662,
0.1294914335012436,
1.0233696699142456,
0.5327014923095703,
-0.3437308371067047,
0.7702333331108093,
0.28293707966804504,
-0.21718944609165192,
0.8035648465156555,
-0.21778728067874908,
-0.1359138935804367,
-0.10260038077831268,
-0.024998920038342476,
-0.3662048578262329,
0.4884119927883148,
0.3921850025653839,
-0.5964010953903198,
0.1590835154056549,
0.41820403933525085,
-0.11799564957618713,
0.03436284884810448,
-0.4103552997112274,
0.6537284255027771,
-0.14785386621952057,
-0.7547158598899841,
0.395090788602829,
-0.03663959726691246,
0.6525776386260986,
-0.7247000336647034,
-0.43141815066337585,
-0.11151731014251709,
0.08883679658174515,
-0.11906466633081436,
-0.8211961984634399,
0.07878571003675461,
-0.09302545338869095,
-0.3869905471801758,
-0.2625584602355957,
0.48023244738578796,
-0.8992450833320618,
-0.5110771656036377,
0.16364458203315735,
0.25324535369873047,
-0.20209598541259766,
0.20180931687355042,
-0.677556574344635,
0.06046605110168457,
0.10287287086248398,
-0.3445669412612915,
0.4589805603027344,
0.33911898732185364,
-0.0022458487655967474,
0.6828123331069946,
0.44550415873527527,
0.006308417301625013,
0.351833701133728,
-0.09299194812774658,
0.7117870450019836,
-0.27955296635627747,
-0.24590162932872772,
-0.7552797198295593,
0.7079750299453735,
0.1607826203107834,
-0.02286447212100029,
0.5280208587646484,
0.3857409358024597,
0.6373775005340576,
-0.19631169736385345,
0.5971636176109314,
-0.05434570461511612,
-0.1526784598827362,
-1.0065220594406128,
0.22030115127563477,
-0.6096336841583252,
0.18296338617801666,
-0.24848413467407227,
-0.7621573805809021,
-0.1457778811454773,
0.28475961089134216,
-0.21363483369350433,
-0.1504545360803604,
0.5731004476547241,
0.8005193471908569,
-0.28297343850135803,
-0.17626184225082397,
0.37892571091651917,
0.1340940147638321,
0.5532023906707764,
0.596927285194397,
0.5615357756614685,
-0.3976476788520813,
0.6963728070259094,
-0.24478667974472046,
-0.25339072942733765,
-0.10398972779512405,
-0.9396181702613831,
-0.7922298908233643,
-0.7887449860572815,
-0.3127225637435913,
-0.3744390606880188,
0.06777917593717575,
0.8072735071182251,
0.9272594451904297,
-0.6451608538627625,
-0.016613395884633064,
-0.0062496233731508255,
0.11114630103111267,
-0.2625499963760376,
-0.23745965957641602,
0.5610315203666687,
0.19645079970359802,
-0.8372575640678406,
0.47241488099098206,
0.1726081818342209,
0.27061331272125244,
-0.3197888135910034,
-0.2783491313457489,
0.027252238243818283,
-0.16731344163417816,
1.0238839387893677,
0.09828920662403107,
-0.8537725806236267,
-0.34651434421539307,
0.09169979393482208,
0.31082841753959656,
-0.03461441397666931,
0.868267834186554,
-0.7432243227958679,
0.812873125076294,
0.2925703823566437,
0.6666805744171143,
0.44455280900001526,
0.08669119328260422,
0.5924392938613892,
-0.4473245441913605,
0.33731797337532043,
0.08197026699781418,
0.3064374625682831,
0.2662465274333954,
-0.29533618688583374,
0.23414522409439087,
0.04601161554455757,
-0.6443933844566345,
-0.6387194991111755,
0.35988175868988037,
-1.0144942998886108,
-0.325361043214798,
1.3334511518478394,
-0.14131607115268707,
-0.07132823765277863,
0.08515118807554245,
-0.48181021213531494,
0.27445438504219055,
-0.47646549344062805,
0.6167973875999451,
0.36519214510917664,
-0.1597653478384018,
-0.6858518123626709,
-0.9046316742897034,
0.6545229554176331,
0.24127262830734253,
-0.5763216018676758,
0.009661322459578514,
0.8889215588569641,
0.3844088613986969,
-0.22188526391983032,
0.4555525481700897,
0.24127739667892456,
0.43616124987602234,
-0.15626397728919983,
-0.3375791311264038,
-0.28143513202667236,
-0.59103924036026,
-0.3939005136489868,
0.1944991499185562,
-0.14036913216114044,
-0.3604048490524292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06464v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06464v2
|
Transforming Wearable Data into Health Insights using Large Language Model Agents
| 2024-06-10T17:00:54 | 2024-06-11T15:17:43 |
Mike A. Merrill, Akshay Paruchuri, Naghmeh Rezaei, Geza Kovacs, Javier Perez, Yun Liu, Erik Schenck, Nova Hammerquist, Jake Sunshine, Shyam Tailor, Kumar Ayush, Hao-Wei Su, Qian He, Cory Y. McLean, Mark Malhotra, Shwetak Patel, Jiening Zhan, Tim Althoff, Daniel McDuff, Xin Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite the proliferation of wearable health trackers and the importance of
sleep and exercise to health, deriving actionable personalized insights from
wearable data remains a challenge because doing so requires non-trivial
open-ended analysis of these data. The recent rise of large language model
(LLM) agents, which can use tools to reason about and interact with the world,
presents a promising opportunity to enable such personalized analysis at scale.
Yet, the application of LLM agents in analyzing personal health is still
largely untapped. In this paper, we introduce the Personal Health Insights
Agent (PHIA), an agent system that leverages state-of-the-art code generation
and information retrieval tools to analyze and interpret behavioral health data
from wearables. We curate two benchmark question-answering datasets of over
4000 health insights questions. Based on 650 hours of human and expert
evaluation we find that PHIA can accurately address over 84% of factual
numerical questions and more than 83% of crowd-sourced open-ended questions.
This work has implications for advancing behavioral health across the
population, potentially enabling individuals to interpret their own wearable
data, and paving the way for a new era of accessible, personalized wellness
regimens that are informed by data-driven insights.
|
[
0.2186441272497177,
-0.7050148248672485,
0.9116582274436951,
-0.12219182401895523,
-0.02223844826221466,
0.20361101627349854,
-0.04588567093014717,
-0.7000516653060913,
0.510760486125946,
0.7479605674743652,
-0.8554346561431885,
-0.5395739078521729,
-0.25806981325149536,
-0.16623744368553162,
-0.019403791055083275,
1.0948870182037354,
0.19718234241008759,
0.05867718532681465,
-0.16329628229141235,
-0.3013339936733246,
-0.4185120165348053,
-0.601899266242981,
-0.4789491593837738,
-0.5670418739318848,
0.572874128818512,
0.3798883855342865,
0.6562541723251343,
0.3474302887916565,
0.37460416555404663,
0.19705712795257568,
0.12146738171577454,
0.3281799852848053,
-0.5305361747741699,
0.41413742303848267,
-0.18058720231056213,
-0.4102107584476471,
-0.6872631907463074,
-0.09229477494955063,
0.22616322338581085,
0.6595014333724976,
-0.1580735445022583,
0.707538902759552,
-0.21076199412345886,
0.6778347492218018,
-0.3723033368587494,
0.32527846097946167,
0.039975885301828384,
0.043326329439878464,
-0.30770838260650635,
-0.21194882690906525,
-0.29581648111343384,
-0.11714639514684677,
0.2890375554561615,
-0.36427244544029236,
-0.04794063791632652,
-0.10973784327507019,
0.2672925591468811,
0.4970008134841919,
-0.5726751685142517,
-0.07512985169887543,
-0.9888230562210083,
0.5155785083770752,
-0.5915924310684204,
0.595687985420227,
0.4650925099849701,
0.29675939679145813,
-0.09946004301309586,
-0.6899751424789429,
-0.3733981251716614,
0.010933708399534225,
0.04427144303917885,
0.08084103465080261,
-0.34281954169273376,
-0.20040282607078552,
-0.1278679519891739,
0.23711100220680237,
-0.7666148543357849,
-0.03272252902388573,
-0.14553019404411316,
-0.004593568854033947,
1.0605039596557617,
0.32417386770248413,
0.5071004033088684,
-0.04360421374440193,
0.05033343285322189,
-0.0032247488852590322,
-0.41280725598335266,
0.06186116486787796,
-0.12814591825008392,
0.272303968667984,
-0.4396471679210663,
0.666365385055542,
-0.5572154521942139,
0.4354238510131836,
0.04145273193717003,
-0.45727503299713135,
0.5200003981590271,
-0.09451855719089508,
-0.14462389051914215,
0.33374980092048645,
0.44191476702690125,
0.3294728398323059,
-0.12195660173892975,
-0.658520519733429,
-0.15488454699516296,
-0.3567655384540558,
0.2965158522129059,
-0.9294517636299133,
-0.13756497204303741,
0.8066108226776123,
-0.65041184425354,
-0.3277052044868469,
0.039591215550899506,
-0.7689574956893921,
-0.9410266876220703,
-0.44073593616485596,
0.24086052179336548,
-0.24166618287563324,
-0.2800855040550232,
0.6430829763412476,
-0.04029671475291252,
0.4620278775691986,
0.260791152715683,
-0.6002552509307861,
0.22779011726379395,
0.8029331564903259,
0.7847281098365784,
-0.08103427290916443,
0.04920687526464462,
-0.424905002117157,
0.22392670810222626,
-0.25473552942276,
0.801266074180603,
-0.45304498076438904,
-0.27401232719421387,
-0.0028660756070166826,
0.12618184089660645,
-0.11101433634757996,
-0.5522236824035645,
0.3897397816181183,
-0.5921992659568787,
-0.028335239738225937,
-0.38446301221847534,
-0.45607954263687134,
-0.04075883701443672,
0.3414413630962372,
-0.585089921951294,
0.747680127620697,
0.10624369978904724,
-0.6219499707221985,
0.17548996210098267,
-0.8744031190872192,
-0.5690234303474426,
0.347078800201416,
-0.012592415325343609,
-0.454929381608963,
0.09997331351041794,
0.3744336664676666,
0.5493892431259155,
-0.6881399154663086,
0.05553631857037544,
-0.5288000702857971,
0.0036364539992064238,
0.9272823333740234,
-0.15617886185646057,
0.6475117802619934,
0.2445470243692398,
-0.4771740734577179,
0.23779380321502686,
-0.7505101561546326,
0.07330717146396637,
0.49967125058174133,
-0.12173857539892197,
-0.33416637778282166,
0.23153764009475708,
-0.005319670774042606,
0.04751453921198845,
0.4064750671386719,
-0.746757984161377,
0.0010061173234134912,
-0.1560344099998474,
0.42868927121162415,
0.8164784908294678,
0.24235916137695312,
0.11414740234613419,
-0.7753027081489563,
0.7096427083015442,
-0.45087650418281555,
0.3742033541202545,
-0.0296607855707407,
-0.5088019371032715,
-0.15148228406906128,
-0.2940416634082794,
-0.2966575622558594,
0.49361851811408997,
-0.5159366130828857,
0.38023141026496887,
-0.6009082198143005,
-0.7976776361465454,
-0.3168908953666687,
0.12789110839366913,
0.10744322091341019,
0.741386353969574,
0.38004299998283386,
-0.06727056205272675,
-0.03160564973950386,
-0.40216177701950073,
-0.463687926530838,
-0.13786627352237701,
-0.12255368381738663,
0.5561567544937134,
0.43236640095710754,
-0.775593638420105,
0.8588720560073853,
-0.9138734340667725,
-0.011711218394339085,
-0.43704816699028015,
-0.1264384686946869,
0.12046168744564056,
0.36863359808921814,
0.4541502296924591,
-0.8021144866943359,
-0.15220794081687927,
0.17289340496063232,
-0.9435107111930847,
-0.21441659331321716,
-0.10804238170385361,
-0.3038959205150604,
-0.531635582447052,
0.26618531346321106,
-0.46420127153396606,
0.33817610144615173,
0.5715070962905884,
-0.6636293530464172,
0.6164185404777527,
-0.05853727459907532,
-0.15033729374408722,
-1.114377737045288,
0.5297607779502869,
-0.03206634894013405,
-0.4344145357608795,
-0.9684520959854126,
0.0773347020149231,
-0.17890578508377075,
-0.5741203427314758,
-0.208840012550354,
0.9790842533111572,
-0.21408982574939728,
0.038845568895339966,
-0.3578784167766571,
-0.41386666893959045,
0.015477933920919895,
0.2681812345981598,
-0.18656854331493378,
0.4347217082977295,
0.18593081831932068,
-0.626997709274292,
0.515177309513092,
0.41144710779190063,
-0.37498483061790466,
0.4991925060749054,
-0.9419059753417969,
0.69334477186203,
-0.22006452083587646,
0.3384367823600769,
-0.4781751036643982,
-0.8365367650985718,
0.47526150941848755,
-0.36714035272598267,
-0.11452220380306244,
0.10064741969108582,
-0.5863864421844482,
-0.3368082046508789,
-0.36029163002967834,
0.5640248656272888,
0.27039268612861633,
-0.5699338316917419,
0.704152524471283,
0.9340307712554932,
-0.26176387071609497,
-0.24458907544612885,
-0.6660995483398438,
-0.21915008127689362,
-0.22615772485733032,
-0.6918113231658936,
0.12876379489898682,
-0.4100070893764496,
-0.47650691866874695,
0.07750178873538971,
-0.307968407869339,
-0.05420239642262459,
0.1568402498960495,
0.2634653151035309,
0.2829269468784332,
-0.1286652684211731,
0.6019037365913391,
-0.13443110883235931,
-0.02408536709845066,
0.15783752501010895,
-0.5501039624214172,
0.6153708696365356,
-0.08298629522323608,
-0.29857131838798523,
-0.5677052736282349,
0.33064234256744385,
0.790742814540863,
-0.6138975024223328,
0.9117431640625,
0.35016295313835144,
-0.47384244203567505,
-0.07003851979970932,
-0.4198027551174164,
-0.1563621312379837,
-0.45028865337371826,
0.20254647731781006,
-0.07309626042842865,
-0.6538079977035522,
0.6218183040618896,
-0.09833251684904099,
0.019620051607489586,
0.0659472867846489,
0.6991923451423645,
-0.10150950402021408,
1.2701795101165771,
0.5791050791740417,
-0.16926461458206177,
0.61527019739151,
-0.1276068538427353,
0.07455086708068848,
-0.746972382068634,
-0.49695613980293274,
-0.4206353425979614,
-0.4561024010181427,
-0.4923552870750427,
-0.48661690950393677,
0.7459273934364319,
-0.5880321264266968,
-0.30965936183929443,
-0.1309523582458496,
-0.437355101108551,
0.10966792702674866,
0.4248637557029724,
0.9336962699890137,
0.17501521110534668,
-0.39806729555130005,
0.5206080675125122,
0.24681828916072845,
-0.23031659424304962,
-0.24422238767147064,
1.155814528465271,
0.40685200691223145,
1.1298933029174805,
0.5564524531364441,
0.5343654751777649,
0.38887014985084534,
0.1452140063047409,
-0.95851731300354,
0.10945339500904083,
0.052028536796569824,
-0.7295007705688477,
-0.46961522102355957,
-0.3781181871891022,
-1.2169275283813477,
0.10613120347261429,
-0.20240183174610138,
-0.9671229124069214,
0.6100554466247559,
0.027573641389608383,
-0.4145483672618866,
0.13891653716564178,
-0.5996334552764893,
0.9670336246490479,
-0.4990427494049072,
-0.3529416620731354,
-0.14889538288116455,
-0.5310193300247192,
0.14434604346752167,
-0.17296382784843445,
0.1744796484708786,
-0.4093318283557892,
-0.06300665438175201,
0.9328781366348267,
-0.5468790531158447,
0.9046488404273987,
0.0548393540084362,
-0.24969364702701569,
0.17105968296527863,
-0.21329665184020996,
0.4865226745605469,
0.2060861885547638,
-0.2039865255355835,
0.02094295620918274,
0.15142735838890076,
-0.6494176983833313,
-0.7395191788673401,
0.4560288190841675,
-0.8002883791923523,
-0.2563308775424957,
-0.4361547529697418,
-0.3706047832965851,
-0.6409962773323059,
0.35808971524238586,
-0.06939142942428589,
0.7533977627754211,
-0.263690322637558,
0.16172394156455994,
0.6525558829307556,
-0.27300703525543213,
-0.13494451344013214,
0.7320461273193359,
-0.0461464561522007,
-0.21772150695323944,
0.9241852760314941,
-0.10607344657182693,
-0.24414977431297302,
0.5511292219161987,
0.7131285667419434,
-0.34296661615371704,
-0.26270270347595215,
-0.11989673227071762,
0.6550642848014832,
-0.48743298649787903,
-0.14280980825424194,
-0.45916903018951416,
0.18369479477405548,
-0.6298345923423767,
0.038170669227838516,
-0.3456982672214508,
0.18178659677505493,
-0.1772584170103073,
-0.22227299213409424,
0.2753905951976776,
0.9203847050666809,
-0.12862813472747803,
0.20687024295330048,
-1.0348920822143555,
0.43764814734458923,
0.7044015526771545,
0.234545037150383,
-0.19692985713481903,
-0.121007539331913,
-0.536769688129425,
0.13956010341644287,
-0.022807177156209946,
-1.386889100074768,
0.5335065126419067,
0.0030777156352996826,
0.5367231965065002,
0.4593489468097687,
0.4024825990200043,
0.3943261206150055,
-0.15476179122924805,
0.4618886709213257,
0.08481229841709137,
-0.8011897206306458,
0.5907212495803833,
-0.4705067574977875,
0.4444005489349365,
0.4583004415035248,
0.17425942420959473,
-0.8800224661827087,
0.11901803314685822,
-0.4223684072494507,
-0.5237559676170349,
0.6365302801132202,
-0.0015183774521574378,
0.05775601789355278,
0.1947692334651947,
0.49712052941322327,
0.05370095744729042,
0.1457187384366989,
-0.3944714665412903,
-0.1920849084854126,
-0.06448474526405334,
-0.45902737975120544,
-0.14965520799160004,
-0.025038326159119606,
-0.2030869424343109,
-0.10577967762947083,
0.47254905104637146,
-0.5867772102355957,
0.2870597541332245,
0.3587910830974579,
-0.2311425507068634,
-0.1456354409456253,
0.2727354168891907,
0.2647663652896881,
0.6757457852363586,
-0.34388601779937744,
-0.04130559042096138,
-0.14759767055511475,
-0.6850810050964355,
0.023675033822655678,
0.24164797365665436,
-0.19159352779388428,
-0.29933756589889526,
0.5282583832740784,
0.5014007091522217,
0.1658104956150055,
-1.2491755485534668,
0.43461674451828003,
-0.2564333975315094,
0.3953014612197876,
-0.2592010200023651,
-0.15722733736038208,
-0.04765059053897858,
0.3989439606666565,
0.21108950674533844,
-0.14638391137123108,
0.3237638771533966,
-0.9093572497367859,
0.17395895719528198,
0.16401353478431702,
-0.5265485048294067,
-0.7265648245811462,
0.79141765832901,
0.305040568113327,
-0.08069662004709244,
0.3735029995441437,
-0.012270890176296234,
-0.38542914390563965,
0.604301929473877,
0.30620482563972473,
0.9440911412239075,
-0.3367398679256439,
0.551270604133606,
0.02037409134209156,
0.12515735626220703,
0.19310280680656433,
0.3444925844669342,
-0.007569118402898312,
-0.8249322772026062,
-0.4352577030658722,
-0.4291956424713135,
-0.6099486947059631,
0.1950344294309616,
-0.8962870240211487,
-0.07638974487781525,
-0.2588160037994385,
-0.11170604079961777,
0.20239314436912537,
0.18049371242523193,
-0.8463658094406128,
0.36311203241348267,
0.23634278774261475,
0.48124200105667114,
-0.6468504667282104,
0.7489786744117737,
0.9101762175559998,
-0.45125776529312134,
-0.8627229928970337,
0.5005784630775452,
0.23457320034503937,
-0.954135537147522,
0.42353200912475586,
0.11788741499185562,
-0.1974574327468872,
-0.2620486617088318,
-0.5414709448814392,
-0.7419594526290894,
1.1695424318313599,
0.8051115274429321,
-0.2063826471567154,
-0.10404416918754578,
0.14854800701141357,
0.5515534281730652,
-0.18152520060539246,
-0.0024727005511522293,
0.7425256371498108,
0.32739773392677307,
-0.20867742598056793,
-0.835045337677002,
0.22476263344287872,
-0.2546302080154419,
-0.5058482885360718,
-0.2519713342189789,
-0.8092856407165527,
0.7407771944999695,
-0.4314952492713928,
-0.16038095951080322,
-0.0008054397767409682,
0.3638819754123688,
0.019431546330451965,
0.8113635182380676,
0.37895750999450684,
0.3335697650909424,
1.3658522367477417,
0.4426523745059967,
1.4540822505950928,
-0.392517626285553,
0.4764724671840668,
1.2691888809204102,
-0.34108442068099976,
0.6498208045959473,
-0.24313797056674957,
-0.13859263062477112,
0.6432610154151917,
0.6493217349052429,
0.40165141224861145,
0.35672837495803833,
0.02641346864402294,
-0.6209760904312134,
-0.3558673560619354,
-0.2361968606710434,
-0.340173602104187,
0.8290172219276428,
0.37885499000549316,
-0.21682403981685638,
0.10143953561782837,
0.1769561916589737,
0.13119766116142273,
-0.11105399578809738,
-0.2955801486968994,
0.9662178158760071,
-0.013470914214849472,
-0.3406570851802826,
0.009946569800376892,
-0.10236170142889023,
0.1747814416885376,
-0.7072736024856567,
0.026666974648833275,
-0.2938278913497925,
0.2039005309343338,
-0.19645944237709045,
-0.5741782784461975,
0.1972915679216385,
0.01869322545826435,
-0.32962459325790405,
-0.2137235701084137,
1.020907998085022,
-0.016916310414671898,
-0.4088260531425476,
0.28785690665245056,
0.8006572723388672,
0.15017814934253693,
-0.5193411111831665,
-0.6997220516204834,
-0.1904570460319519,
-0.21113744378089905,
-0.2151062935590744,
0.3053523898124695,
0.3177860975265503,
0.21721208095550537,
0.9550848603248596,
0.8282375931739807,
0.16346600651741028,
-0.16762180626392365,
-0.24261721968650818,
0.7996350526809692,
-0.8683564066886902,
-0.7185252904891968,
-0.6462382674217224,
0.3520490825176239,
-0.06321065872907639,
-0.24494193494319916,
0.518706202507019,
0.47550851106643677,
0.3093765377998352,
0.08844894170761108,
0.9761489629745483,
0.1264164298772812,
0.7973490953445435,
-0.433443158864975,
0.9583879113197327,
-0.6956288814544678,
0.19101037085056305,
0.05001393333077431,
-0.33263513445854187,
-0.028722289949655533,
0.33859336376190186,
-0.4595792293548584,
-0.14990755915641785,
0.5182643532752991,
0.43825581669807434,
0.12138431519269943,
-0.11526451259851456,
0.15865936875343323,
0.21301846206188202,
0.8106512427330017,
0.2901810109615326,
0.4837552309036255,
-0.09405334293842316,
0.31440243124961853,
-0.3828210234642029,
-0.29048600792884827,
-0.43512433767318726,
-0.3037242591381073,
-0.7206975221633911,
-0.5186817049980164,
-0.33633866906166077,
-0.48181623220443726,
-0.007910064421594143,
1.1082639694213867,
0.9077683091163635,
-0.7497413754463196,
0.028429685160517693,
0.1219819039106369,
0.2951650023460388,
-0.32902249693870544,
-0.21431054174900055,
0.49862754344940186,
-0.014381829649209976,
-0.667280912399292,
0.7591353058815002,
0.16170339286327362,
-0.1457616239786148,
-0.1832709014415741,
-0.19182351231575012,
0.3094976842403412,
0.28858017921447754,
0.6002554297447205,
0.8222223520278931,
-0.2916279733181,
-0.33554473519325256,
0.20351830124855042,
-0.024718090891838074,
-0.12095379829406738,
1.0220308303833008,
-0.7340267896652222,
0.8230190277099609,
0.4722837507724762,
0.8901621699333191,
0.41860079765319824,
0.0879620686173439,
0.5184736847877502,
-0.571276068687439,
0.0387444905936718,
0.46029072999954224,
0.33883699774742126,
0.2949126064777374,
-0.652977466583252,
0.577081561088562,
0.22261467576026917,
-0.7012664675712585,
-0.8366008996963501,
0.010257373563945293,
-1.2372221946716309,
-0.3819279372692108,
1.2144176959991455,
-0.09125261753797531,
-0.5346473455429077,
-0.28936681151390076,
-0.22516284883022308,
0.09389294683933258,
-0.4326435625553131,
0.7075758576393127,
0.13660036027431488,
-0.6138522028923035,
0.11055947095155716,
-0.5853598117828369,
0.27572354674339294,
0.1462080180644989,
-1.2510535717010498,
0.09532108157873154,
0.3874838650226593,
0.31809207797050476,
0.05161885544657707,
1.0541164875030518,
0.217566579580307,
0.34126341342926025,
-0.14044669270515442,
-0.15330731868743896,
0.10209096223115921,
0.14006371796131134,
-0.25719714164733887,
-0.06310319155454636,
-0.0701652392745018,
-0.37366628646850586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06461v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06461v3
|
Reasoning in Token Economies: Budget-Aware Evaluation of LLM Reasoning Strategies
| 2024-06-10T16:55:08 | 2024-06-15T01:59:02 |
Junlin Wang, Siddhartha Jain, Dejiao Zhang, Baishakhi Ray, Varun Kumar, Ben Athiwaratkun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
A diverse array of reasoning strategies has been proposed to elicit the
capabilities of large language models. However, in this paper, we point out
that traditional evaluations which focus solely on performance metrics miss a
key factor: the increased effectiveness due to additional compute. By
overlooking this aspect, a skewed view of strategy efficiency is often
presented. This paper introduces a framework that incorporates the compute
budget into the evaluation, providing a more informative comparison that takes
into account both performance metrics and computational cost. In this
budget-aware perspective, we find that complex reasoning strategies often don't
surpass simpler baselines purely due to algorithmic ingenuity, but rather due
to the larger computational resources allocated. When we provide a simple
baseline like chain-of-thought self-consistency with comparable compute
resources, it frequently outperforms reasoning strategies proposed in the
literature. In this scale-aware perspective, we find that unlike
self-consistency, certain strategies such as multi-agent debate or Reflexion
can become worse if more compute budget is utilized.
|
[
-0.4636513590812683,
-0.5097733736038208,
0.8039159774780273,
0.25530683994293213,
-0.13500985503196716,
0.2906389832496643,
-0.42397838830947876,
-0.22379209101200104,
0.3747880458831787,
0.29989174008369446,
-0.3967284858226776,
0.175451397895813,
-0.4552122950553894,
-0.00493085291236639,
-0.17861047387123108,
0.6294953227043152,
0.1473245769739151,
0.10664277523756027,
-0.5196236371994019,
-0.29715868830680847,
-0.4578673839569092,
-0.7172384858131409,
-0.862969160079956,
-0.4700232744216919,
0.40107282996177673,
0.43859177827835083,
0.7513127326965332,
0.7576421499252319,
0.6584005355834961,
0.34070611000061035,
-0.058250416070222855,
0.20987114310264587,
-0.3683322072029114,
0.09683648496866226,
-0.5101572275161743,
-0.6037309169769287,
-0.3646009564399719,
-0.20639707148075104,
0.6318649649620056,
0.38076668977737427,
-0.3227249085903168,
0.296284943819046,
-0.07764756679534912,
0.6487065553665161,
-0.9887470602989197,
0.2619658410549164,
-0.9100757837295532,
-0.086085744202137,
-0.13998614251613617,
-0.06857521086931229,
-0.4548284709453583,
-0.013066676445305347,
0.019828321412205696,
-0.6111767888069153,
-0.32594573497772217,
0.08761768788099289,
0.42903074622154236,
0.33417651057243347,
-0.22412529587745667,
-0.5874155163764954,
-0.5481789112091064,
0.7026208639144897,
-0.6767579317092896,
0.18986071646213531,
0.19659122824668884,
0.24579373002052307,
-0.002886531176045537,
-0.8185860514640808,
-0.4981502890586853,
-0.23571906983852386,
0.16612505912780762,
0.3167252540588379,
-0.5743976831436157,
0.17783485352993011,
0.4825833737850189,
0.18128244578838348,
0.0034608368296176195,
0.034847188740968704,
-0.2074122428894043,
-0.39137521386146545,
0.4550818204879761,
0.2590070962905884,
-0.001578616676852107,
-0.32698434591293335,
-0.5310668349266052,
-0.045927245169878006,
-0.4877418279647827,
-0.003355864668264985,
0.4485733211040497,
0.2717120945453644,
0.022844484075903893,
0.7892991304397583,
-0.023177435621619225,
0.3832941949367523,
0.24561350047588348,
-0.240646094083786,
-0.10276931524276733,
-0.6497336626052856,
-0.2537730932235718,
-0.022479942068457603,
0.27256885170936584,
0.20975296199321747,
0.2644345164299011,
-0.16149215400218964,
-0.3073110580444336,
0.3228464722633362,
0.4466516375541687,
-0.66100013256073,
0.048049408942461014,
0.20166750252246857,
-0.5549753904342651,
-0.05838092043995857,
-0.20174457132816315,
-0.5889976620674133,
-0.418764591217041,
-0.5114036798477173,
0.4106810986995697,
-0.21965429186820984,
-0.2560749351978302,
0.0317944698035717,
-0.4947112202644348,
0.20753027498722076,
0.2466432750225067,
-0.7943041920661926,
0.5229489803314209,
1.1419974565505981,
0.8617653846740723,
-0.1741592139005661,
-0.2237345278263092,
-0.5017985105514526,
-0.035384856164455414,
-0.4879496991634369,
0.9324760437011719,
-0.2298828363418579,
-0.4697157144546509,
-0.20625893771648407,
-0.470977246761322,
-0.2317955046892166,
-0.631304144859314,
0.5096641778945923,
-0.19455450773239136,
-0.17732328176498413,
-0.7167987823486328,
-0.6615048050880432,
0.09138008207082748,
0.4894779920578003,
-0.728796124458313,
0.8492384552955627,
0.16144244372844696,
-0.8683235049247742,
0.6553851962089539,
-0.8893976211547852,
-0.4434819519519806,
-0.005126512609422207,
-0.10925062745809555,
0.08325576782226562,
0.19317489862442017,
0.10243331640958786,
0.14405620098114014,
-0.6058779358863831,
0.40646660327911377,
-0.367823988199234,
-0.5190014839172363,
0.41752368211746216,
-0.6161072850227356,
0.7525587677955627,
0.44276320934295654,
-0.7457016110420227,
0.2553611993789673,
-0.5287665724754333,
0.1438080221414566,
-0.18037129938602448,
-0.30514585971832275,
-0.10285359621047974,
0.18154878914356232,
-0.49648284912109375,
-0.1022484079003334,
0.39479878544807434,
-0.2848351299762726,
0.2543429434299469,
-0.5593044757843018,
0.7627975344657898,
1.0191305875778198,
-0.29759353399276733,
0.6250091195106506,
-0.3476940393447876,
0.5570679306983948,
-0.23215244710445404,
0.33238649368286133,
-0.16742946207523346,
-0.10486555844545364,
-0.8875772356987,
-0.7183226943016052,
0.2285185158252716,
0.4174899458885193,
-0.5410209894180298,
-0.21058721840381622,
-0.07334744185209274,
-0.43563878536224365,
-0.28292587399482727,
-0.1519768238067627,
0.3281978964805603,
0.4680039882659912,
0.16947217285633087,
-0.17944520711898804,
-0.6049935221672058,
-0.9412259459495544,
-0.5064789056777954,
-0.5279682278633118,
0.41437768936157227,
0.5895269513130188,
0.5150660872459412,
0.01390591450035572,
0.8508084416389465,
-0.27939656376838684,
0.3689356744289398,
-0.3748041093349457,
-0.13573841750621796,
0.015100684948265553,
0.42577436566352844,
0.40821775794029236,
-0.4536992907524109,
-0.046078577637672424,
-0.04269159212708473,
-0.4128151834011078,
-0.004456487018615007,
-0.40019533038139343,
-0.21255142986774445,
0.4416835308074951,
0.4484333395957947,
-0.8554136157035828,
0.3784060478210449,
0.10761337727308273,
-0.43336859345436096,
0.7722595930099487,
-0.39562955498695374,
0.0028382393065840006,
-0.6548545956611633,
-0.07723383605480194,
-0.1683637499809265,
-0.11652357131242752,
-0.26649272441864014,
0.4080287218093872,
-0.040440429002046585,
0.1684260070323944,
-0.125547394156456,
0.6945249438285828,
-0.40011996030807495,
-0.3577026128768921,
-0.20747432112693787,
0.3554176986217499,
0.24687784910202026,
0.40106403827667236,
-0.34024080634117126,
1.2147351503372192,
0.4185277819633484,
-0.420278400182724,
0.2990468442440033,
-0.3341834545135498,
-0.3879011273384094,
0.8096774816513062,
-0.6347204446792603,
0.04806402325630188,
0.25194740295410156,
0.27042171359062195,
-0.8836840391159058,
0.12509675323963165,
0.15247437357902527,
-0.3614848852157593,
0.19870568811893463,
0.0664994940161705,
-0.47682785987854004,
-0.3225223124027252,
-0.3323555290699005,
0.4428737461566925,
0.22959305346012115,
-0.6172302961349487,
0.7000058889389038,
0.3953932225704193,
0.11843874305486679,
-0.9174678325653076,
-0.6443108320236206,
0.22720609605312347,
-0.5131539702415466,
-0.47443315386772156,
0.1549949198961258,
0.03748413547873497,
-0.7409389019012451,
0.014294547028839588,
-0.36406409740448,
0.10506047308444977,
0.4011443853378296,
0.00723184272646904,
0.28048840165138245,
-0.2945476770401001,
0.3231247365474701,
-0.1798512190580368,
-0.12257707864046097,
0.35063573718070984,
-0.8850365281105042,
0.5490161180496216,
-0.3262656033039093,
-0.7165180444717407,
-0.11642463505268097,
0.09074896574020386,
0.705635666847229,
-0.15601575374603271,
0.5604602694511414,
0.3318665027618408,
-0.2583867907524109,
0.014441389590501785,
-0.9454359412193298,
0.06672824919223785,
-0.4436804950237274,
0.2837028205394745,
-0.5900710821151733,
-0.6710748672485352,
0.7399507761001587,
-0.5155478119850159,
-0.033217914402484894,
0.873856246471405,
0.7034432291984558,
0.12712500989437103,
1.016149878501892,
0.3511618971824646,
-0.027361424639821053,
0.15215405821800232,
-0.34549441933631897,
0.3609137237071991,
-0.8382565379142761,
-0.3523801267147064,
-0.6777331829071045,
-0.22662845253944397,
-0.5474017858505249,
-0.7425777316093445,
0.041498422622680664,
0.06436716020107269,
-0.8671653270721436,
0.1860101968050003,
-0.3111600875854492,
0.365059494972229,
0.5489596724510193,
-0.2239011824131012,
0.22932168841362,
-0.15548108518123627,
-0.40039965510368347,
0.07147113233804703,
-1.119960069656372,
-0.4858837425708771,
1.1380590200424194,
0.275341272354126,
0.4754571318626404,
0.006981483194977045,
0.582080066204071,
0.3724316358566284,
0.30933135747909546,
-0.8768599629402161,
0.48849207162857056,
0.1315687745809555,
-0.5283114910125732,
-0.3958011269569397,
-0.7440506219863892,
-0.7208722233772278,
0.3614991009235382,
-0.17524424195289612,
-0.6450067162513733,
0.24379181861877441,
-0.09718260914087296,
-0.1706063151359558,
0.593384325504303,
-0.8064143061637878,
0.8039044737815857,
-0.41547831892967224,
-0.4130619466304779,
-0.6771424412727356,
-0.1696976274251938,
0.1295081377029419,
0.02183462493121624,
0.39292582869529724,
0.020090976729989052,
-0.33636459708213806,
0.6564189195632935,
-0.5718613862991333,
0.5036718249320984,
-0.13900983333587646,
0.16487856209278107,
0.6251288652420044,
-0.09089267998933792,
0.43999847769737244,
0.03426824137568474,
-0.19254852831363678,
0.018800508230924606,
0.15687377750873566,
-0.6745578646659851,
-0.6881647706031799,
0.6663224697113037,
-0.6345078349113464,
-0.8891828060150146,
-0.2244887501001358,
-0.6455957293510437,
-0.23310808837413788,
0.1332172304391861,
0.11527851223945618,
0.5808535814285278,
-0.23923398554325104,
0.08131067454814911,
0.3439311981201172,
0.06144864484667778,
0.5142137408256531,
0.001734413206577301,
-0.012451444752514362,
-0.6195626258850098,
0.7667327523231506,
0.3090660274028778,
0.5223592519760132,
0.20777533948421478,
0.4794948101043701,
-0.5596070885658264,
-0.2683456242084503,
-0.43811485171318054,
0.08811629563570023,
-1.0002868175506592,
-0.3473145663738251,
-0.32861992716789246,
0.17370109260082245,
-0.33657106757164,
-0.3718727231025696,
-0.45881181955337524,
-0.8231489062309265,
-0.04422139748930931,
-0.2564977705478668,
0.21353723108768463,
0.573100745677948,
-0.3842099606990814,
0.20728744566440582,
0.054038528352975845,
-0.02130352519452572,
0.17597433924674988,
0.40431347489356995,
0.5968909859657288,
-0.28151652216911316,
-0.3604511618614197,
0.09060931205749512,
-0.23389451205730438,
-0.5805770754814148,
0.03912820667028427,
-0.3311622142791748,
0.8112672567367554,
0.5789225697517395,
-0.03774988651275635,
1.0633748769760132,
-0.12112181633710861,
0.6864017844200134,
0.42760583758354187,
-1.2998638153076172,
0.06977542489767075,
-0.008944270201027393,
0.25419852137565613,
0.5684061050415039,
-0.2069823443889618,
-0.18204277753829956,
-0.29046687483787537,
-0.9409077763557434,
-0.8380954265594482,
0.5127050876617432,
0.034371230751276016,
0.17835645377635956,
-0.29282957315444946,
0.48475873470306396,
-0.15105703473091125,
0.37153053283691406,
-0.5011274218559265,
-0.19141346216201782,
-0.20163056254386902,
0.1322433203458786,
0.1098015233874321,
-0.29396963119506836,
-0.2571973204612732,
-0.33903777599334717,
0.43124574422836304,
-0.2797248065471649,
0.22237025201320648,
0.2830212712287903,
0.036427658051252365,
0.22502855956554413,
0.30765655636787415,
0.5814618468284607,
1.0449522733688354,
0.2053016871213913,
0.29726797342300415,
0.48433995246887207,
-0.27039581537246704,
0.025469863787293434,
-0.2049543559551239,
0.06643405556678772,
-0.2882763743400574,
0.4616625905036926,
0.7624071836471558,
0.4906151294708252,
-0.9389159083366394,
0.5000324845314026,
0.05924905091524124,
-0.3990137279033661,
-0.3435842990875244,
-0.007303061429411173,
0.3490394651889801,
0.5884556174278259,
0.24150803685188293,
0.4700082540512085,
0.15823613107204437,
-0.7246458530426025,
0.030266299843788147,
0.7544622421264648,
-0.2289922833442688,
0.24322140216827393,
0.4487556219100952,
-0.0015635868767276406,
-0.39602208137512207,
0.44405338168144226,
-0.15876615047454834,
-0.690041184425354,
1.0251351594924927,
0.5978614687919617,
0.8908964395523071,
0.24884654581546783,
0.21196715533733368,
0.22051793336868286,
0.5233634114265442,
-0.21946504712104797,
0.25658005475997925,
-0.26229339838027954,
-0.6150413155555725,
-0.6612382531166077,
-0.24088558554649353,
-0.5527215003967285,
-0.3018511235713959,
-0.5401216149330139,
0.10246811807155609,
-0.770530104637146,
-0.38687601685523987,
-0.10699021071195602,
0.45643171668052673,
-0.7010664343833923,
-0.07602953165769577,
0.003537417622283101,
1.1508971452713013,
-0.15110710263252258,
0.22892314195632935,
0.552632749080658,
-0.2579924762248993,
-0.9423391222953796,
-0.2307845503091812,
-0.10997064411640167,
-0.9659090042114258,
0.569615364074707,
0.05367259681224823,
-0.5284872055053711,
-0.39643633365631104,
-0.2094455361366272,
-0.9501939415931702,
1.098160743713379,
0.6642752289772034,
-0.35162660479545593,
0.17168273031711578,
-0.07129107415676117,
0.46485665440559387,
-0.70151686668396,
0.5512123107910156,
0.6194873452186584,
0.7499390840530396,
0.239354208111763,
-0.8404634594917297,
-0.004477584268897772,
0.01740172691643238,
-0.24651694297790527,
0.1287253201007843,
-0.8303911685943604,
0.9150895476341248,
-0.4775414764881134,
-0.3213428854942322,
-0.12786932289600372,
0.45553362369537354,
0.16558076441287994,
0.7612289786338806,
0.5901007056236267,
0.6639348268508911,
1.071954607963562,
-0.029084818437695503,
1.1571338176727295,
-0.43326446413993835,
0.2579222023487091,
0.8044077754020691,
-0.26888570189476013,
0.716511607170105,
0.3553236126899719,
-0.28107258677482605,
0.45986178517341614,
0.5110718011856079,
0.1484297513961792,
0.1176014319062233,
0.67893385887146,
-0.042167484760284424,
-0.3820379972457886,
-0.079474538564682,
-0.007150191348046064,
0.5787279605865479,
0.3208531141281128,
0.053890153765678406,
-0.04480404779314995,
-0.265445739030838,
0.28119075298309326,
0.16929234564304352,
-0.606800377368927,
0.9164956212043762,
-0.024428797885775566,
-0.8435624837875366,
0.2888266146183014,
-0.008672389201819897,
0.5028408169746399,
-0.2923242151737213,
0.2036653757095337,
-0.09061024338006973,
0.2179841697216034,
-0.09438768774271011,
-0.4684358835220337,
0.4466237425804138,
0.06853189319372177,
-0.1945677399635315,
-0.13437765836715698,
0.7880922555923462,
0.19442524015903473,
-0.4273059070110321,
0.21132828295230865,
0.8415952324867249,
0.007128402590751648,
-0.03372816741466522,
-0.8327172994613647,
-0.010195452719926834,
-0.10025224089622498,
-0.0356382392346859,
0.39699605107307434,
0.6734108924865723,
-0.08793792873620987,
0.8722598552703857,
0.713888943195343,
0.2662963271141052,
-0.28720465302467346,
0.18903930485248566,
0.8173105716705322,
-0.599719762802124,
-0.6195852756500244,
-1.2552984952926636,
0.18526571989059448,
-0.28448113799095154,
-0.26002252101898193,
0.66105055809021,
0.6920977830886841,
0.6714310050010681,
0.3748708665370941,
0.7163790464401245,
0.27906686067581177,
0.12831269204616547,
-0.29883337020874023,
0.41798529028892517,
-0.43146201968193054,
0.5073456168174744,
-0.14459440112113953,
-0.6958461403846741,
0.09385503083467484,
0.6565871834754944,
-0.34520620107650757,
-0.1162804514169693,
0.7271602153778076,
0.36568185687065125,
0.07969463616609573,
0.231678307056427,
0.09329348057508469,
-0.028521966189146042,
0.129066601395607,
0.16241168975830078,
0.9365387558937073,
0.17691773176193237,
0.4249216616153717,
-0.07103303074836731,
-0.25270241498947144,
-0.04317740723490715,
-1.1023870706558228,
-0.6622990965843201,
-0.46709081530570984,
-0.2489212602376938,
-0.41238299012184143,
0.0005188146024011075,
0.8169448971748352,
0.5900299549102783,
-0.34012526273727417,
-0.49103420972824097,
-0.21608659625053406,
0.7122208476066589,
-0.4952436685562134,
-0.194719135761261,
0.3567191958427429,
-0.7397211790084839,
-0.3946412205696106,
-0.020568350329995155,
0.6149413585662842,
-0.43634524941444397,
-0.6095214486122131,
-0.03841080516576767,
-0.03536961227655411,
0.896790087223053,
0.6581042408943176,
0.14084996283054352,
-0.9244709014892578,
-0.2017672210931778,
0.29829397797584534,
0.015776675194501877,
0.05658640339970589,
1.1753772497177124,
-0.8421393036842346,
0.5283543467521667,
0.3802642524242401,
0.7693098783493042,
0.5044726133346558,
-0.030431507155299187,
0.4304506182670593,
0.04472612217068672,
-0.03235697001218796,
0.1279907375574112,
0.44587790966033936,
0.1374974250793457,
-0.3965495526790619,
0.5888720750808716,
0.2098313570022583,
-0.6575182676315308,
-0.9128634929656982,
0.16606740653514862,
-0.7694154381752014,
-0.4510670602321625,
0.9498975276947021,
-0.3089808523654938,
-0.12984628975391388,
0.12103750556707382,
-0.32167771458625793,
0.06281788647174835,
-0.20708081126213074,
0.6497229933738708,
1.0296597480773926,
-0.278997004032135,
0.16489346325397491,
-0.41340357065200806,
0.389510840177536,
0.468111127614975,
-0.6379753947257996,
0.2548283338546753,
0.4815058708190918,
-0.04048336669802666,
0.21968397498130798,
0.8881181478500366,
0.021034525707364082,
0.16184242069721222,
0.5304250121116638,
-0.5125255584716797,
0.06361113488674164,
-0.2524631917476654,
-0.06330038607120514,
0.2592061758041382,
0.32307863235473633,
0.08558403700590134
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06458v1
|
Evaluating the Retrieval Component in LLM-Based Question Answering Systems
| 2024-06-10T16:46:22 | 2024-06-10T16:46:22 |
Ashkan Alinejad, Krtin Kumar, Ali Vahdat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Question answering systems (QA) utilizing Large Language Models (LLMs)
heavily depend on the retrieval component to provide them with domain-specific
information and reduce the risk of generating inaccurate responses or
hallucinations. Although the evaluation of retrievers dates back to the early
research in Information Retrieval, assessing their performance within LLM-based
chatbots remains a challenge.
This study proposes a straightforward baseline for evaluating retrievers in
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG)-based chatbots. Our findings demonstrate
that this evaluation framework provides a better image of how the retriever
performs and is more aligned with the overall performance of the QA system.
Although conventional metrics such as precision, recall, and F1 score may not
fully capture LLMs' capabilities - as they can yield accurate responses despite
imperfect retrievers - our method considers LLMs' strengths to ignore
irrelevant contexts, as well as potential errors and hallucinations in their
responses.
|
[
-0.25883951783180237,
-0.6886836886405945,
0.5820326805114746,
0.11833977699279785,
-0.12347099930047989,
0.34747958183288574,
0.05825104936957359,
-0.4733009934425354,
0.27551087737083435,
0.5357344150543213,
-0.3693182170391083,
-0.16586463153362274,
-0.49323633313179016,
0.3648936450481415,
-0.48345279693603516,
0.7553550601005554,
0.4646438956260681,
-0.0997619554400444,
-0.6004252433776855,
0.10781432688236237,
-0.7440913319587708,
-0.6357283592224121,
-0.6273976564407349,
-0.3898375928401947,
0.4906337857246399,
0.14803564548492432,
0.7805156707763672,
0.15330182015895844,
0.7635636329650879,
0.31617408990859985,
-0.32418543100357056,
0.17681220173835754,
-0.9093618988990784,
0.4511137008666992,
-0.2349018156528473,
-0.7016998529434204,
-0.3506339490413666,
-0.28618860244750977,
0.4545471966266632,
0.5174351930618286,
-0.27283260226249695,
0.23495584726333618,
0.10970704257488251,
0.6132209300994873,
-0.7169238328933716,
-0.04819510132074356,
-1.0241090059280396,
0.061166711151599884,
0.17037509381771088,
-0.7430990934371948,
-0.6958216428756714,
-0.5662031769752502,
0.08394666761159897,
-0.5107418894767761,
0.14873620867729187,
0.23537081480026245,
0.842589795589447,
0.2319919764995575,
-0.2560354173183441,
-0.4121658504009247,
-0.8949193358421326,
0.7711561322212219,
-0.5628631114959717,
0.37268003821372986,
0.4454716145992279,
0.5299098491668701,
-0.419983446598053,
-0.516398012638092,
-0.36479267477989197,
-0.3059591054916382,
-0.27070048451423645,
0.23416496813297272,
-0.18710167706012726,
-0.04298119992017746,
0.15253600478172302,
0.5527797937393188,
-0.5339834690093994,
0.013356496579945087,
-0.31910258531570435,
-0.18157485127449036,
0.5338998436927795,
0.40214768052101135,
0.18869180977344513,
-0.41986918449401855,
-0.40076589584350586,
-0.10041387379169464,
-0.6324273347854614,
-0.07383452355861664,
0.07089722156524658,
0.3928820490837097,
0.2677101790904999,
0.7924832105636597,
-0.1355903297662735,
0.37783491611480713,
0.33389443159103394,
-0.18902184069156647,
0.21887479722499847,
-0.24468106031417847,
-0.18290266394615173,
-0.39586344361305237,
0.6199697256088257,
0.3007093369960785,
0.10627378523349762,
-0.5631666779518127,
-0.504195511341095,
-0.3941957354545593,
0.7177929282188416,
-0.7991008162498474,
0.13392481207847595,
0.27540722489356995,
-0.5081073045730591,
-0.1432972401380539,
0.018936961889266968,
-0.6809378862380981,
-0.554198682308197,
-0.014486943371593952,
0.786614716053009,
-0.3897266387939453,
-0.07061158120632172,
-0.1287248283624649,
-0.28335660696029663,
0.7221211194992065,
0.31471362709999084,
-0.5060824751853943,
0.4286801517009735,
0.7384119629859924,
0.587334930896759,
-0.32955843210220337,
0.16446322202682495,
-0.740344762802124,
-0.23374435305595398,
-0.4537268280982971,
0.9250140190124512,
-0.5485413670539856,
-0.7218125462532043,
0.1279839128255844,
-0.010298801586031914,
-0.02947344072163105,
-1.0449769496917725,
0.518466591835022,
-1.1830769777297974,
0.16253957152366638,
-0.1379333883523941,
-0.8210954666137695,
-0.10286297649145126,
0.37159982323646545,
-0.6276706457138062,
1.137279748916626,
0.353222131729126,
-0.5370082259178162,
0.06585261225700378,
-0.22028884291648865,
-0.29419153928756714,
0.31597626209259033,
0.00839282013475895,
-0.09758350253105164,
0.2364220768213272,
0.08547370880842209,
0.3392001688480377,
-0.29856014251708984,
0.04642138630151749,
-0.11611748486757278,
-0.7865836024284363,
0.5975393056869507,
-0.48284202814102173,
0.41626298427581787,
0.11342011392116547,
0.0784410610795021,
-0.05183911323547363,
-0.579168975353241,
0.30394071340560913,
0.08451136201620102,
-0.44326338171958923,
-0.2916223406791687,
0.044412702322006226,
-0.21504290401935577,
0.002890094416216016,
0.4224047362804413,
-0.5372079610824585,
-0.16265878081321716,
-0.5821930170059204,
-0.17549781501293182,
0.6724821329116821,
0.13256464898586273,
0.313726007938385,
-0.5264131426811218,
0.7759572863578796,
-0.2864532172679901,
0.021659959107637405,
-0.1895817518234253,
-0.1965053528547287,
-0.8153250813484192,
-0.17097614705562592,
0.3177506923675537,
0.726568341255188,
-0.9574256539344788,
0.5163491368293762,
-0.3890695571899414,
-0.5312297940254211,
-0.4842594861984253,
0.09396696835756302,
0.5915919542312622,
0.4687817692756653,
0.34417855739593506,
-0.3328440189361572,
-0.41269227862358093,
-0.8210170269012451,
-0.2431764006614685,
-0.40390947461128235,
-0.3938685655593872,
0.7397814989089966,
0.2957933247089386,
-0.09153600037097931,
0.8492821455001831,
-0.24435578286647797,
-0.04920000582933426,
-0.20340010523796082,
-0.25372636318206787,
0.19850796461105347,
0.12012121081352234,
0.20027850568294525,
-0.7645710110664368,
-0.18746861815452576,
-0.05985087528824806,
-0.6868855357170105,
-0.12052663415670395,
0.13455721735954285,
-0.16721361875534058,
0.1184217780828476,
0.29066500067710876,
-0.6961964964866638,
0.48289117217063904,
0.3174210786819458,
-0.19048531353473663,
0.5956602692604065,
-0.06868945062160492,
0.425293505191803,
-0.7865252494812012,
0.4052950143814087,
-0.3307945728302002,
-0.35203108191490173,
-0.6259254217147827,
0.04505329579114914,
0.010246631689369678,
0.11213041841983795,
-0.5432407259941101,
0.8894739747047424,
-0.32124659419059753,
-0.4165756106376648,
-0.3395867645740509,
0.5929776430130005,
0.16699743270874023,
0.2050454020500183,
-0.3341837227344513,
1.1601758003234863,
-0.05486546456813812,
-0.7036017179489136,
0.17197109758853912,
0.3545197546482086,
-0.192622110247612,
0.7669375538825989,
-0.7814516425132751,
0.5571519136428833,
-0.19584724307060242,
0.047067537903785706,
-1.1991060972213745,
-0.08473515510559082,
0.06034322828054428,
-0.7424230575561523,
0.3540377914905548,
-0.03631238266825676,
-0.6154370903968811,
-0.47369614243507385,
-0.2709849774837494,
0.1911313235759735,
0.5787134170532227,
-0.3957974910736084,
0.7267423868179321,
0.3049827516078949,
-0.18476514518260956,
-0.7259610295295715,
-0.24898724257946014,
0.10321854054927826,
-0.28615182638168335,
-0.4020584225654602,
0.3934650421142578,
-0.09579021483659744,
-0.20808355510234833,
-0.16716048121452332,
-0.3043360114097595,
-0.04709881171584129,
0.30636975169181824,
0.1811257153749466,
0.39241161942481995,
-0.1551385223865509,
0.22715561091899872,
-0.26672372221946716,
0.031046349555253983,
0.1275840699672699,
0.359786719083786,
0.7523841261863708,
-0.030381016433238983,
-0.40572574734687805,
-0.23936188220977783,
-0.07446411997079849,
0.24658432602882385,
-0.15419761836528778,
0.6712470054626465,
0.09916902333498001,
-0.2541099786758423,
0.1428634375333786,
-0.7979843020439148,
-0.3635912537574768,
-0.4734509289264679,
0.4605950117111206,
-0.4394289255142212,
-0.9831245541572571,
0.7878390550613403,
0.18713881075382233,
-0.09510254114866257,
0.5727366805076599,
0.4369127154350281,
-0.21754507720470428,
0.865542471408844,
0.4400114119052887,
0.07406925410032272,
0.32929670810699463,
0.1030302494764328,
0.04975353553891182,
-1.0719082355499268,
-0.5089409351348877,
-0.72707599401474,
-0.09770775586366653,
-0.5109440088272095,
-0.4724338948726654,
0.23940934240818024,
0.22047656774520874,
-0.1460433304309845,
0.18831227719783783,
-0.3346579074859619,
0.4431237578392029,
0.36968904733657837,
0.148299440741539,
0.4306112229824066,
-0.07776258885860443,
0.1555095613002777,
0.09643036872148514,
-0.5279197692871094,
-0.8095304369926453,
1.1186714172363281,
0.27273035049438477,
0.8596306443214417,
0.12061971426010132,
0.5510526299476624,
0.4310898184776306,
0.43328624963760376,
-0.9441061615943909,
0.6979591846466064,
-0.06310433149337769,
-0.6160431504249573,
-0.2793860137462616,
-0.5882835388183594,
-1.2529782056808472,
0.5014156699180603,
-0.06602858006954193,
-0.7934679388999939,
-0.0664588063955307,
-0.21299491822719574,
-0.44469261169433594,
-0.0634894147515297,
-0.37272655963897705,
0.4642364978790283,
-0.21152016520500183,
-0.08261691778898239,
-0.1389831006526947,
-0.5314518809318542,
0.2593417465686798,
-0.09148824959993362,
-0.09322259575128555,
-0.17314885556697845,
-0.12203642725944519,
0.6063528656959534,
-0.11710311472415924,
0.6321631073951721,
-0.15100955963134766,
-0.1758115440607071,
0.41822078824043274,
0.33197516202926636,
0.27125224471092224,
-0.14189568161964417,
-0.3126673996448517,
-0.2154834121465683,
0.3378218114376068,
-0.225790873169899,
-0.8786039352416992,
0.44769275188446045,
-0.6211576461791992,
-0.877687394618988,
-0.10527041554450989,
-0.5293145775794983,
-0.4750830829143524,
0.04040076211094856,
-0.17031049728393555,
0.2255292683839798,
-0.4022437632083893,
0.3963654935359955,
0.7036276459693909,
-0.45263245701789856,
0.03724281117320061,
0.59126216173172,
-0.5666119456291199,
-0.33922040462493896,
0.783972442150116,
-0.0530756376683712,
0.303023099899292,
0.6405447721481323,
-0.028872253373265266,
-0.5220028162002563,
-0.45892396569252014,
-0.2720351815223694,
0.21727925539016724,
-0.719879150390625,
-0.5426231026649475,
-0.5027511715888977,
-0.6176279187202454,
-0.1177598387002945,
0.2696582078933716,
-0.19522257149219513,
-0.28994953632354736,
-0.4350616931915283,
0.15530025959014893,
0.2533468008041382,
0.5745000243186951,
0.41146811842918396,
0.31946292519569397,
-0.8738895654678345,
0.38710999488830566,
0.28075769543647766,
0.4189494848251343,
0.03804795816540718,
-1.0235244035720825,
-0.09981676936149597,
0.03070499747991562,
-0.4502094089984894,
-0.7955814003944397,
0.2109103500843048,
0.09105870127677917,
0.7587258219718933,
0.01640051044523716,
0.05182497203350067,
0.6606600880622864,
-0.41953518986701965,
0.815570056438446,
-0.22008748352527618,
-0.5920658707618713,
0.6000621318817139,
-0.042254216969013214,
0.2325044572353363,
0.45502614974975586,
0.19042392075061798,
-0.4864262044429779,
-0.504999041557312,
-0.47942471504211426,
-0.6871102452278137,
0.519812822341919,
0.2720315158367157,
0.5465983748435974,
-0.2923939824104309,
0.6449978947639465,
0.10319007188081741,
0.2299346774816513,
-0.43278810381889343,
-0.2597305178642273,
0.20385964214801788,
-0.14067427814006805,
0.14846378564834595,
-0.48207470774650574,
0.05350038781762123,
0.304484099149704,
0.5135277509689331,
-0.06864181905984879,
0.37730228900909424,
0.1990521103143692,
-0.26302799582481384,
-0.0009541913168504834,
0.3080286681652069,
0.32102692127227783,
0.6888535022735596,
-0.33980002999305725,
-0.10467658936977386,
0.17187722027301788,
-0.34179165959358215,
0.23355749249458313,
0.004851416684687138,
-0.14499206840991974,
-0.09092944115400314,
0.12824828922748566,
0.4841468036174774,
0.1379094272851944,
-1.033095121383667,
0.5215973854064941,
-0.11482944339513779,
0.1998809576034546,
-0.16460534930229187,
0.26147064566612244,
-0.050069086253643036,
0.4443334937095642,
0.7542914152145386,
-0.22641338407993317,
0.3091546595096588,
-0.3567606806755066,
0.23063969612121582,
0.7584492564201355,
-0.43774330615997314,
-0.27433350682258606,
0.3506559431552887,
0.013934453018009663,
-0.7482540011405945,
0.58576500415802,
-0.12219394743442535,
-0.4910348057746887,
0.7523704767227173,
0.6412287354469299,
0.8834643363952637,
-0.28611016273498535,
0.1090245470404625,
0.24209024012088776,
0.27059170603752136,
0.11406126618385315,
0.2902579605579376,
0.16286152601242065,
-0.7298497557640076,
-0.4693359434604645,
-0.6965851187705994,
-0.5023276805877686,
0.1287868618965149,
-0.7544656991958618,
0.02946663647890091,
-0.1863802969455719,
-0.46488064527511597,
-0.3760913610458374,
0.04324891045689583,
-0.7491478323936462,
0.18695826828479767,
-0.09291743487119675,
0.8466002345085144,
-0.06989844888448715,
0.2780790328979492,
0.47877398133277893,
-0.3209240734577179,
-0.4287260174751282,
-0.024740394204854965,
-0.2603422701358795,
-0.9097602963447571,
0.7553526759147644,
0.061273377388715744,
-0.41051533818244934,
-0.16512273252010345,
-0.25928327441215515,
-0.924679696559906,
1.1272964477539062,
0.3337288200855255,
-0.3553142547607422,
-0.04732992500066757,
0.06732984632253647,
0.9314993023872375,
-0.23030754923820496,
0.6527444124221802,
0.4625208079814911,
-0.03894563019275665,
0.26581305265426636,
-1.1518930196762085,
0.017044877633452415,
-0.22403796017169952,
0.33074524998664856,
-0.046958521008491516,
-0.6569308042526245,
0.30370163917541504,
-0.054522156715393066,
-0.5051413178443909,
0.48981571197509766,
0.6768590807914734,
0.5446605682373047,
0.19732648134231567,
0.37063291668891907,
0.2518315315246582,
0.7928829193115234,
0.028647590428590775,
1.1341209411621094,
-0.23759357631206512,
0.18836365640163422,
1.118857741355896,
-0.25300881266593933,
1.319001317024231,
0.5343745350837708,
-0.41399329900741577,
0.30227890610694885,
0.3592812120914459,
0.19994275271892548,
0.39075425267219543,
0.4984298348426819,
0.021730056032538414,
-0.07750214636325836,
-0.14676988124847412,
-0.1790032833814621,
0.49289968609809875,
0.4373384416103363,
-0.2932674288749695,
-0.0021640530321747065,
-0.10935565084218979,
-0.19047561287879944,
0.12271780520677567,
-0.15092451870441437,
0.9681861400604248,
-0.004009346943348646,
-0.6170182228088379,
0.7459281086921692,
-0.26104721426963806,
0.5922806262969971,
-0.2356027513742447,
-0.0672779306769371,
-0.660116970539093,
-0.07080615311861038,
0.01787722110748291,
-0.9677876830101013,
0.3212459683418274,
0.1445593684911728,
-0.15885449945926666,
0.146855890750885,
0.922542154788971,
-0.09805247187614441,
-0.32751014828681946,
0.42468056082725525,
0.8381971120834351,
0.3750789761543274,
-0.01446276530623436,
-0.5536050200462341,
0.077901192009449,
-0.2516475021839142,
-0.2669883370399475,
0.21280783414840698,
0.4134601950645447,
0.16974230110645294,
0.9737134575843811,
0.3699610233306885,
-0.06301915645599365,
0.07937900722026825,
0.1372266709804535,
0.7441995143890381,
-0.7246466279029846,
0.1776731163263321,
-0.7188051342964172,
0.3138333857059479,
0.04078107699751854,
-0.06221023574471474,
0.793454647064209,
0.7326540350914001,
0.5408326983451843,
0.15149720013141632,
0.4803849458694458,
0.03701222315430641,
1.001685619354248,
-0.3847614526748657,
0.6561813950538635,
-0.6744544506072998,
0.554348349571228,
-0.18752872943878174,
-1.0801783800125122,
-0.11180326342582703,
0.4308834671974182,
-0.23903310298919678,
0.29775765538215637,
0.29400110244750977,
0.9901724457740784,
0.25632861256599426,
-0.17564205825328827,
0.6019152402877808,
0.14803577959537506,
0.2653333842754364,
0.35082903504371643,
1.3942687511444092,
-0.6652224659919739,
0.7947896718978882,
0.040848176926374435,
0.08327051997184753,
-0.3747864067554474,
-0.530976414680481,
-0.786364734172821,
-0.2730475068092346,
0.031007250770926476,
-0.5027549862861633,
0.19044654071331024,
0.566753089427948,
0.2899547815322876,
-0.6631298661231995,
-0.31606313586235046,
0.506756067276001,
0.20010575652122498,
0.033539485186338425,
-0.28971490263938904,
0.19186300039291382,
-0.7282006144523621,
-0.7129543423652649,
0.36694255471229553,
0.31448256969451904,
-0.11266990005970001,
-0.356618732213974,
-0.06535661220550537,
0.03664715960621834,
0.32191774249076843,
0.8684248924255371,
0.13442549109458923,
-0.9554004669189453,
-0.48549285531044006,
0.6291490197181702,
-0.45895054936408997,
0.36829376220703125,
0.287182092666626,
-1.0531253814697266,
0.3947477340698242,
0.41234952211380005,
0.9184292554855347,
0.3374073803424835,
0.3663496971130371,
0.41723716259002686,
-0.5139395594596863,
-0.3373958170413971,
0.4569375216960907,
-0.018464086577296257,
0.5042721033096313,
-0.18251006305217743,
0.5508887767791748,
-0.15804024040699005,
-0.8029715418815613,
-0.921049952507019,
-0.1926090270280838,
-0.7217645049095154,
-0.017943337559700012,
1.2132956981658936,
-0.08815829455852509,
-0.09005516022443771,
-0.05398152396082878,
-0.24687595665454865,
0.029256045818328857,
-0.24896487593650818,
0.8833759427070618,
0.5798816680908203,
-0.12800994515419006,
-0.16474801301956177,
-0.6383219361305237,
0.2919231057167053,
0.47084298729896545,
-0.8506789207458496,
-0.05046017840504646,
0.48607125878334045,
0.22244490683078766,
0.3129573464393616,
0.7738460898399353,
-0.2595180571079254,
0.15316566824913025,
-0.1970992535352707,
0.006421227939426899,
0.6107051372528076,
-0.15706397593021393,
-0.3119649589061737,
0.1261112242937088,
0.30858591198921204,
-0.04636306315660477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06455v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06455v2
|
A Large Language Model Pipeline for Breast Cancer Oncology
| 2024-06-10T16:44:48 | 2024-06-13T18:48:17 |
Tristen Pool, Dennis Trujillo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have demonstrated potential in the innovation of
many disciplines. However, how they can best be developed for oncology remains
underdeveloped. State-of-the-art OpenAI models were fine-tuned on a clinical
dataset and clinical guidelines text corpus for two important cancer treatment
factors, adjuvant radiation therapy and chemotherapy, using a novel Langchain
prompt engineering pipeline. A high accuracy (0.85+) was achieved in the
classification of adjuvant radiation therapy and chemotherapy for breast cancer
patients. Furthermore, a confidence interval was formed from observational data
on the quality of treatment from human oncologists to estimate the proportion
of scenarios in which the model must outperform the original oncologist in its
treatment prediction to be a better solution overall as 8.2% to 13.3%. Due to
indeterminacy in the outcomes of cancer treatment decisions, future
investigation, potentially a clinical trial, would be required to determine if
this threshold was met by the models. Nevertheless, with 85% of U.S. cancer
patients receiving treatment at local community facilities, these kinds of
models could play an important part in expanding access to quality care with
outcomes that lie, at minimum, close to a human oncologist.
|
[
0.047436632215976715,
-0.5870367884635925,
0.922234833240509,
-0.13224588334560394,
-0.08897175639867783,
0.003811680478975177,
-0.021870706230401993,
-0.08102461695671082,
0.05293191224336624,
0.9286299347877502,
-0.47603294253349304,
-0.6671317219734192,
-0.8813373446464539,
-0.0734441727399826,
-0.4138434827327728,
0.6854053735733032,
0.024910151958465576,
0.4329834282398224,
0.1775551289319992,
-0.02252250909805298,
-0.16144751012325287,
-0.31374016404151917,
-0.790655255317688,
-0.5600863099098206,
0.8605809807777405,
0.3056689500808716,
0.7472773790359497,
0.9456851482391357,
0.4439663589000702,
0.13297335803508759,
-0.36079922318458557,
0.08066919445991516,
-0.3778831362724304,
0.15856412053108215,
-0.06078056991100311,
-0.4625146985054016,
-0.5346124768257141,
-0.18579624593257904,
0.4653015434741974,
1.0985279083251953,
-0.31224215030670166,
-0.23532529175281525,
0.09883588552474976,
0.6201059818267822,
-0.5674307942390442,
0.0365695096552372,
-0.4966423809528351,
0.0742325484752655,
-0.18165245652198792,
0.019876940175890923,
-0.05743460729718208,
-0.8016804456710815,
0.043944504112005234,
-0.6002060174942017,
-0.02731855772435665,
-0.08190899342298508,
0.6033620834350586,
-0.027603769674897194,
-0.5595345497131348,
-0.4706517457962036,
-0.4784585237503052,
0.6600239276885986,
-1.0524667501449585,
0.09323274344205856,
0.35240593552589417,
0.49055367708206177,
-0.6135708689689636,
-1.0320415496826172,
0.014716273173689842,
-0.08056706190109253,
0.05193569138646126,
0.011306669563055038,
-0.2335609346628189,
0.6119666695594788,
0.324998140335083,
0.4509850740432739,
-0.5458012819290161,
0.7480152249336243,
-0.358978807926178,
-0.34706324338912964,
0.506255567073822,
0.4311979413032532,
0.35968926548957825,
-0.11159936338663101,
-0.159128800034523,
0.45187118649482727,
-1.1925160884857178,
0.1891794502735138,
0.05607971176505089,
0.6711346507072449,
0.2586657702922821,
0.7860286831855774,
-0.6549416780471802,
0.850607693195343,
-0.4645441472530365,
0.04560380429029465,
-0.30076247453689575,
-0.47899308800697327,
-0.2804934084415436,
0.29285353422164917,
0.8180213570594788,
0.16283483803272247,
0.15215609967708588,
0.10788439959287643,
0.23254109919071198,
0.22990763187408447,
0.06411348283290863,
-0.9161288738250732,
-0.2595880329608917,
0.4033370614051819,
-0.530698299407959,
-0.4780629277229309,
-0.038709383457899094,
-0.46933186054229736,
-0.45365214347839355,
0.053580544888973236,
0.3569691777229309,
-0.03945312649011612,
-0.10031295567750931,
0.4353885054588318,
0.17198339104652405,
-0.22201405465602875,
0.2727486491203308,
-0.6263949275016785,
0.1059822365641594,
0.73828125,
1.1078890562057495,
0.21243974566459656,
0.0022868793457746506,
-0.8277671933174133,
0.017048323526978493,
-0.342752069234848,
0.8767788410186768,
-0.6451764106750488,
-0.5348944067955017,
0.19909870624542236,
0.02822430431842804,
-0.02906636893749237,
-0.09740342199802399,
0.5517493486404419,
-0.2400715947151184,
0.30252841114997864,
-0.679514467716217,
-0.5914163589477539,
-0.09557592868804932,
0.05636992305517197,
-0.6727161407470703,
0.2556261122226715,
0.24821358919143677,
-0.7106600999832153,
0.24293676018714905,
-0.9607417583465576,
-0.13354092836380005,
0.13843201100826263,
0.1480555534362793,
-0.1373630166053772,
0.003913343418389559,
0.4450720250606537,
0.5577899813652039,
-0.5617039799690247,
0.35282206535339355,
-0.4413732588291168,
-0.3948417007923126,
0.4168676435947418,
-0.269185870885849,
1.030904769897461,
0.693348228931427,
0.18358756601810455,
0.24681665003299713,
-0.6056861877441406,
-0.010025093331933022,
-0.17551900446414948,
-0.30046799778938293,
-0.30898547172546387,
-0.14552661776542664,
-0.2562502920627594,
0.2123335748910904,
-0.08537950366735458,
-0.8715497255325317,
0.43720969557762146,
-0.8210321068763733,
0.9815220236778259,
0.48317423462867737,
0.24935226142406464,
0.07590702921152115,
-0.3621941804885864,
0.623847484588623,
-0.21493682265281677,
0.18480727076530457,
-0.42909514904022217,
-0.7134467363357544,
-0.6356954574584961,
-0.346990704536438,
0.5880233645439148,
0.17925597727298737,
-0.6049985885620117,
-0.08595043420791626,
-0.1646401286125183,
-0.3894747793674469,
-0.7674468755722046,
-0.07131887972354889,
0.43479302525520325,
0.48050710558891296,
0.026970364153385162,
-0.6304542422294617,
-0.5353958010673523,
-0.6215839385986328,
0.02655753120779991,
-0.25324341654777527,
0.042977940291166306,
0.0859566479921341,
0.17359395325183868,
-0.13461072742938995,
0.8026638031005859,
-0.6005255579948425,
-0.21529313921928406,
-0.25891464948654175,
0.23918630182743073,
0.4116264879703522,
0.09121009707450867,
0.00629982678219676,
-0.43421077728271484,
-0.21942587196826935,
0.29242458939552307,
-0.8631157875061035,
-0.571000337600708,
0.30750638246536255,
-0.21638336777687073,
-0.2071768045425415,
0.3811648488044739,
-0.4209235906600952,
0.44513964653015137,
0.5467364192008972,
-0.2951461672782898,
0.0838826522231102,
-0.45581385493278503,
0.2484273612499237,
-1.1054781675338745,
0.20694592595100403,
0.054708294570446014,
-0.09685927629470825,
-0.612331211566925,
-0.04797361418604851,
-0.2451256960630417,
-0.2875830829143524,
-0.4996209442615509,
0.6026217341423035,
-0.4851023554801941,
-0.1422518640756607,
-0.29700860381126404,
-0.13654440641403198,
0.07953843474388123,
0.04404355213046074,
0.08704094588756561,
0.3481232225894928,
0.46409064531326294,
-0.5749218463897705,
0.6079981327056885,
0.057077374309301376,
-0.7711898684501648,
0.24417252838611603,
-0.7979720830917358,
-0.07281338423490524,
0.04375561326742172,
0.3422837555408478,
-0.9640806913375854,
-0.40947726368904114,
0.1156744435429573,
-0.29237884283065796,
-0.006605254020541906,
-0.19525040686130524,
-0.30587565898895264,
-0.6057073473930359,
0.04974431172013283,
0.06503964215517044,
0.429109126329422,
-0.15627507865428925,
0.19380712509155273,
0.3711943030357361,
-0.5895145535469055,
-0.4560862183570862,
-0.9755688309669495,
0.004234590567648411,
-0.04103242978453636,
-0.6730390787124634,
-0.09011498093605042,
-0.02045825682580471,
-0.31447112560272217,
-0.10680846124887466,
0.46510523557662964,
-0.22983486950397491,
0.10286933928728104,
0.21427273750305176,
0.07133248448371887,
-0.296965628862381,
0.09238619357347488,
0.506116509437561,
-0.2685199975967407,
-0.00785745494067669,
-0.400325745344162,
0.32160666584968567,
0.34755849838256836,
-0.8034873604774475,
-0.33959636092185974,
0.5135999321937561,
0.5351589918136597,
-0.12068578600883484,
0.5473339557647705,
0.3782851994037628,
-0.49187561869621277,
0.1047593280673027,
-0.296875536441803,
-0.27038511633872986,
-0.336568146944046,
0.44085416197776794,
-0.2715110778808594,
-1.140759825706482,
0.5830174684524536,
-0.033614736050367355,
0.2966398000717163,
0.2047896385192871,
0.9241747856140137,
0.37976813316345215,
1.1944429874420166,
0.4373934268951416,
0.09044564515352249,
0.0293778944760561,
-0.05549231544137001,
0.07147800177335739,
-0.6289045214653015,
-0.06365817785263062,
-0.5082749724388123,
-0.032603804022073746,
-0.46190524101257324,
-0.44746845960617065,
0.6847816705703735,
-0.015331639908254147,
-0.4023827612400055,
0.14136774837970734,
-0.5600007772445679,
0.09478612244129181,
0.36693039536476135,
0.4025426208972931,
0.6353062391281128,
-0.0030174185521900654,
-0.2475476711988449,
-0.11233367025852203,
-1.1904950141906738,
-0.38926640152931213,
1.4373829364776611,
0.7468917369842529,
0.615710973739624,
0.09501965343952179,
0.4184229373931885,
0.2146511971950531,
0.3986818790435791,
-0.6876311898231506,
0.1917918622493744,
-0.23792922496795654,
-0.7638938426971436,
-0.34079915285110474,
-0.5114235281944275,
-1.169969081878662,
0.0069277030415833,
0.07193657010793686,
-0.5985440611839294,
0.2337954193353653,
0.02517065964639187,
-0.8298494219779968,
0.35387179255485535,
-0.30450668931007385,
0.9367300868034363,
-0.1875716596841812,
-0.08480460196733475,
0.08208044618368149,
-0.6203669309616089,
0.38804325461387634,
-0.18935653567314148,
0.6339406967163086,
-0.2441667765378952,
0.011347458697855473,
0.30935123562812805,
-0.6378349661827087,
0.5815988779067993,
-0.013164840638637543,
-0.2605260908603668,
0.42679983377456665,
0.1643708348274231,
0.42685672640800476,
-0.13079744577407837,
-0.30428123474121094,
0.05612611770629883,
-0.0623028539121151,
-0.4680125117301941,
-0.4813588857650757,
0.891135036945343,
-0.5488002300262451,
-0.18498343229293823,
-0.22955308854579926,
-0.39757972955703735,
-0.149124413728714,
-0.03614215552806854,
0.6785816550254822,
0.6648052930831909,
-0.39584261178970337,
0.0067702713422477245,
0.6628738045692444,
-0.4230150878429413,
0.05403862148523331,
0.6738713979721069,
-0.3708818256855011,
-0.20141880214214325,
0.7289988398551941,
0.32246503233909607,
0.3210859000682831,
0.381527304649353,
0.4814859628677368,
-0.17642758786678314,
-0.6871598958969116,
-0.3293444812297821,
0.08823784440755844,
-0.7481359839439392,
-0.21485112607479095,
-0.6988965272903442,
-0.3985092043876648,
-0.5634405612945557,
-0.10821754485368729,
-0.3856692910194397,
-0.34276002645492554,
-0.4245836138725281,
-0.05666671320796013,
0.4339248538017273,
0.8435487151145935,
-0.0642378181219101,
0.3111068904399872,
-0.8728736639022827,
-0.2115572988986969,
0.23393790423870087,
0.1431054323911667,
-0.08532705157995224,
-0.9256234169006348,
-0.3258887827396393,
0.2971334457397461,
0.03290743753314018,
-0.6411154866218567,
0.5938530564308167,
0.1636427938938141,
0.45101046562194824,
0.3546154797077179,
-0.02133539505302906,
0.20937016606330872,
-0.2322198897600174,
0.601685106754303,
0.3748873472213745,
-0.5574586987495422,
0.7873989343643188,
-0.7350602149963379,
0.48337996006011963,
-0.01849917694926262,
0.5183289051055908,
-0.607257604598999,
-0.22662222385406494,
-0.39886894822120667,
-0.6406973004341125,
0.6296681761741638,
0.2690161466598511,
-0.18299849331378937,
0.2755211293697357,
0.43520498275756836,
0.14542903006076813,
0.17435280978679657,
-0.40197575092315674,
0.04680842161178589,
-0.06444093585014343,
-0.34629642963409424,
-0.027877207845449448,
-0.3393266797065735,
-0.35186389088630676,
0.06135658919811249,
0.5111058354377747,
-0.15279990434646606,
0.24014750123023987,
0.04240041598677635,
0.2711907923221588,
-0.3458648920059204,
0.44988977909088135,
0.3270602226257324,
0.739925742149353,
-0.16743193566799164,
-0.2436179667711258,
0.17881520092487335,
-0.35798466205596924,
-0.007795214187353849,
0.14009152352809906,
-0.0782238095998764,
-0.16368015110492706,
0.5931069850921631,
0.8832371234893799,
0.11595434695482254,
-0.6449936032295227,
0.3420994281768799,
0.032246652990579605,
-0.10081614553928375,
0.07308391481637955,
0.09289334714412689,
-0.1609569638967514,
0.2900536358356476,
0.027708765119314194,
-0.228266179561615,
0.4527306854724884,
-0.6027714014053345,
-0.011570596136152744,
0.21538445353507996,
-0.8567902445793152,
-0.06161065399646759,
0.5258132815361023,
0.13782374560832977,
-0.07603656500577927,
0.3582925498485565,
0.23681525886058807,
-0.22427935898303986,
0.579303503036499,
0.35502225160598755,
0.5747150182723999,
-0.29087191820144653,
0.2435348927974701,
0.4684204161167145,
0.11585424840450287,
-0.5323758721351624,
0.12861615419387817,
0.6760278344154358,
-0.6669002175331116,
-0.4635571539402008,
-0.6444975733757019,
-0.487949937582016,
-0.07056654989719391,
-0.39341655373573303,
0.44180944561958313,
-0.5423868894577026,
-0.3187727928161621,
0.13619346916675568,
0.06098761409521103,
-0.25196608901023865,
0.36987099051475525,
0.1461290717124939,
0.6574826240539551,
-0.7410302758216858,
1.1280971765518188,
0.7579020261764526,
-0.42788180708885193,
-0.7987954020500183,
-0.4882428050041199,
0.1968591809272766,
-0.6217963099479675,
0.41564273834228516,
-0.09375198930501938,
0.1446596086025238,
0.15090106427669525,
-0.4369009733200073,
-1.1594232320785522,
1.2479195594787598,
0.5169708132743835,
-0.6627737283706665,
-0.2580007016658783,
-0.18036052584648132,
0.5532951951026917,
-0.7436984777450562,
0.5148126482963562,
0.5044599771499634,
0.3526926040649414,
0.3808014690876007,
-1.0934863090515137,
-0.029103150591254234,
0.05852730944752693,
0.3161812722682953,
0.030225884169340134,
-0.5157349705696106,
1.0814008712768555,
-0.35907095670700073,
-0.11179880052804947,
0.5974406599998474,
0.45848381519317627,
0.18337613344192505,
0.3513539433479309,
-0.036902640014886856,
0.5933812856674194,
0.7015609741210938,
-0.3791370093822479,
1.215172529220581,
-0.01691865734755993,
0.28260380029678345,
0.48002922534942627,
-0.2593517601490021,
0.6078059673309326,
-0.03766651079058647,
-0.37895363569259644,
0.4192105531692505,
0.7508621215820312,
0.34334227442741394,
0.4351653456687927,
0.19795502722263336,
-0.24880677461624146,
-0.43487972021102905,
-0.5662330389022827,
-0.4320776164531708,
0.2084021270275116,
0.5651243329048157,
-0.5769723653793335,
-0.0015050977235659957,
0.3474090099334717,
0.1723870486021042,
0.29478883743286133,
-0.6435967087745667,
0.5900629758834839,
0.38705241680145264,
-0.49385887384414673,
0.3892674148082733,
0.21839003264904022,
0.3860090374946594,
-0.9132336378097534,
0.07314431667327881,
-0.28750836849212646,
0.21548007428646088,
-0.3890601396560669,
-0.7504745721817017,
0.18321558833122253,
0.07410585880279541,
0.05283854529261589,
0.0604027695953846,
0.753179669380188,
-0.3777177631855011,
-0.7293649911880493,
0.1445721834897995,
0.3493701219558716,
0.3040991723537445,
0.10036157071590424,
-0.5841774940490723,
0.4741058945655823,
0.012859823182225227,
-0.1582091748714447,
0.3679753541946411,
0.3922223150730133,
0.04885432869195938,
0.8997253179550171,
0.5636194944381714,
0.5386258959770203,
-0.3188289403915405,
0.11823106557130814,
0.9378136396408081,
-0.4014010727405548,
-0.39788350462913513,
-0.7057974338531494,
0.41718590259552,
0.12822426855564117,
-0.5397355556488037,
0.5660060048103333,
0.07929486781358719,
0.2780248522758484,
0.4790816605091095,
0.8468360304832458,
0.4214116632938385,
0.893317699432373,
-1.0057278871536255,
0.7633950114250183,
-0.38437116146087646,
0.44962528347969055,
-0.29318684339523315,
-0.8104238510131836,
-0.48981302976608276,
0.5488703846931458,
-0.31261199712753296,
0.18053530156612396,
0.6200010180473328,
0.8007677793502808,
0.1459735929965973,
0.2485651969909668,
0.41757169365882874,
0.5141541957855225,
0.47417718172073364,
0.9914113879203796,
0.5791065692901611,
-0.5228726863861084,
0.15589091181755066,
0.03552732616662979,
-0.48531895875930786,
-0.20590952038764954,
-0.7986114025115967,
-0.6915676593780518,
-0.22151008248329163,
-0.32727953791618347,
-0.49346923828125,
0.44210126996040344,
1.1622250080108643,
0.7576916813850403,
-0.8593243360519409,
-0.5364024043083191,
-0.1347701996564865,
0.1040051206946373,
0.07201995700597763,
-0.07050076872110367,
0.13036735355854034,
0.10166559368371964,
-0.571838915348053,
0.5762985348701477,
0.4274630546569824,
-0.06691490113735199,
-0.6763185858726501,
-0.23142467439174652,
-0.24738092720508575,
0.09084238857030869,
0.5145265460014343,
0.41203996539115906,
-0.775083065032959,
0.1451442688703537,
-0.04223804920911789,
-0.3702174425125122,
-0.20124375820159912,
0.8063299655914307,
-0.6730695366859436,
0.7322871088981628,
0.4266403019428253,
0.4840450584888458,
0.3211035132408142,
-0.11006107181310654,
0.9379449486732483,
-0.231284499168396,
0.05560002475976944,
0.29935985803604126,
0.3536531329154968,
0.4487292766571045,
-0.2522781193256378,
0.19733548164367676,
0.22221030294895172,
-0.6783601641654968,
-0.8450408577919006,
0.4555276036262512,
-0.6721837520599365,
-0.4922408163547516,
1.363647699356079,
-0.5224533081054688,
-0.18337513506412506,
-0.4530537724494934,
-0.27425363659858704,
0.2959880232810974,
-0.5329560041427612,
0.5152588486671448,
0.6707448959350586,
-0.07279203832149506,
-0.27278828620910645,
-0.49172693490982056,
0.4838208556175232,
0.1291910707950592,
-0.5573641061782837,
-0.08448588103055954,
0.6948482990264893,
0.06332775950431824,
-0.3856576979160309,
0.931075394153595,
-0.22498559951782227,
0.19999255239963531,
-0.3548007011413574,
-0.0986517071723938,
-0.23388954997062683,
-0.27361252903938293,
-0.4913235604763031,
0.29588577151298523,
0.3855622708797455,
0.2732376158237457
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06443v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06443v1
|
LLM Dataset Inference: Did you train on my dataset?
| 2024-06-10T16:34:43 | 2024-06-10T16:34:43 |
Pratyush Maini, Hengrui Jia, Nicolas Papernot, Adam Dziedzic
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
The proliferation of large language models (LLMs) in the real world has come
with a rise in copyright cases against companies for training their models on
unlicensed data from the internet. Recent works have presented methods to
identify if individual text sequences were members of the model's training
data, known as membership inference attacks (MIAs). We demonstrate that the
apparent success of these MIAs is confounded by selecting non-members (text
sequences not used for training) belonging to a different distribution from the
members (e.g., temporally shifted recent Wikipedia articles compared with ones
used to train the model). This distribution shift makes membership inference
appear successful. However, most MIA methods perform no better than random
guessing when discriminating between members and non-members from the same
distribution (e.g., in this case, the same period of time). Even when MIAs
work, we find that different MIAs succeed at inferring membership of samples
from different distributions. Instead, we propose a new dataset inference
method to accurately identify the datasets used to train large language models.
This paradigm sits realistically in the modern-day copyright landscape, where
authors claim that an LLM is trained over multiple documents (such as a book)
written by them, rather than one particular paragraph. While dataset inference
shares many of the challenges of membership inference, we solve it by
selectively combining the MIAs that provide positive signal for a given
distribution, and aggregating them to perform a statistical test on a given
dataset. Our approach successfully distinguishes the train and test sets of
different subsets of the Pile with statistically significant p-values < 0.1,
without any false positives.
|
[
-0.3385344445705414,
-0.4479021728038788,
0.25836312770843506,
-0.12132147699594498,
-0.34943997859954834,
0.1584021896123886,
0.047796737402677536,
-0.35094472765922546,
0.22316871583461761,
0.5952206254005432,
-0.768627405166626,
-0.44419756531715393,
-0.6220456957817078,
0.32628870010375977,
-0.8378342390060425,
0.6301109194755554,
0.3848952651023865,
0.3308833837509155,
-0.4342038929462433,
-0.31914815306663513,
-0.2130582183599472,
-0.7983309030532837,
-0.17452554404735565,
-0.2975183427333832,
0.4684198498725891,
0.06848963350057602,
0.5008828639984131,
0.8493559956550598,
0.37135642766952515,
0.23813244700431824,
-0.09465117007493973,
0.025823256000876427,
-0.5747785568237305,
0.09961075335741043,
0.038355909287929535,
-0.8893260955810547,
0.016232803463935852,
0.1577049195766449,
0.5816418528556824,
0.6575940251350403,
0.07475165277719498,
0.09764841943979263,
0.060269251465797424,
0.6016849279403687,
-0.7162410020828247,
-0.21740390360355377,
-0.9614028334617615,
0.2339331954717636,
-0.23210522532463074,
-0.3171459138393402,
-0.759728729724884,
-0.4270819127559662,
-0.18122197687625885,
-0.37642902135849,
0.5288548469543457,
0.05461796373128891,
0.8605437278747559,
0.29395732283592224,
-0.4890509247779846,
-0.3194536864757538,
-0.45112672448158264,
1.0291404724121094,
-0.9066587686538696,
0.42065370082855225,
0.6151702404022217,
0.35486412048339844,
-0.30547699332237244,
-0.3781002163887024,
-0.760080873966217,
-0.13589312136173248,
0.04130267724394798,
0.07985832542181015,
-0.03457239270210266,
-0.12197647243738174,
0.3651338219642639,
0.414826899766922,
-0.5015448331832886,
0.47964930534362793,
-0.24806329607963562,
-0.10753948986530304,
0.6365485787391663,
-0.08279246836900711,
0.309594064950943,
-0.010581113398075104,
-0.46822598576545715,
-0.17482052743434906,
-1.126192569732666,
-0.477670282125473,
0.6829357147216797,
0.2888924777507782,
-0.14211346209049225,
0.8396631479263306,
0.11080799996852875,
0.6140742301940918,
-0.2106507420539856,
-0.23261189460754395,
0.30199798941612244,
-0.0872262567281723,
-0.42553579807281494,
0.07534853368997574,
0.6338265538215637,
0.19911113381385803,
0.6525763869285583,
-0.41884711384773254,
-0.2435295581817627,
0.04829278588294983,
-0.019679704681038857,
-0.4435614347457886,
-0.17321433126926422,
0.2518414258956909,
-0.5085766911506653,
-0.4008455276489258,
0.3350994884967804,
-0.7532716989517212,
-0.6166125535964966,
-0.33539217710494995,
0.32821470499038696,
-0.09261936694383621,
-0.07951060682535172,
-0.03867287561297417,
-0.44600406289100647,
0.23141025006771088,
0.1532829850912094,
-0.8884457349777222,
0.04733551666140556,
0.8331243395805359,
0.7108010649681091,
-0.04398169741034508,
-0.46818870306015015,
-0.5578189492225647,
0.19791407883167267,
-0.3600807785987854,
0.8386976718902588,
-0.5599451065063477,
-0.33886024355888367,
0.1295720338821411,
-0.10213451832532883,
-0.3065659701824188,
-0.7246124744415283,
0.09605827182531357,
-0.976885974407196,
0.23211362957954407,
-0.23965893685817719,
-1.040265679359436,
0.13570228219032288,
0.23545661568641663,
-0.8436451554298401,
0.7314152717590332,
0.07752160727977753,
-1.0195536613464355,
0.6734699606895447,
-0.08979616314172745,
-0.23430530726909637,
-0.25386664271354675,
-0.28037604689598083,
-0.44258877635002136,
0.1155230924487114,
0.23518884181976318,
0.4021528661251068,
-0.23355190455913544,
-0.051707517355680466,
-0.7496192455291748,
-0.4308220446109772,
0.8109967112541199,
-0.6044503450393677,
1.0491137504577637,
0.11612112075090408,
-0.21208103001117706,
-0.21441787481307983,
-0.6907978057861328,
-0.09017752856016159,
0.03190977871417999,
-0.5340375900268555,
-0.4881330728530884,
0.22107383608818054,
-0.3759700059890747,
0.029980046674609184,
-0.07072221487760544,
-0.3780399560928345,
0.4759843349456787,
-0.27974921464920044,
0.10327896475791931,
0.9525214433670044,
0.23750610649585724,
0.4018581509590149,
-0.5497864484786987,
0.5818312168121338,
-0.05590255931019783,
-0.028885433450341225,
0.08178260922431946,
-0.4141301214694977,
-0.6884028911590576,
-0.5342842936515808,
0.6701142191886902,
0.41500231623649597,
-0.849297046661377,
0.6594904065132141,
-0.4526579976081848,
-0.305733323097229,
-0.3660975992679596,
0.05061449483036995,
0.2606266438961029,
0.10472125560045242,
0.21342644095420837,
-0.10074298083782196,
-0.3269224166870117,
-0.788455069065094,
-0.37004098296165466,
-0.35526934266090393,
-0.36278998851776123,
0.19051766395568848,
0.5812742114067078,
0.03958612680435181,
1.0450364351272583,
-0.40043145418167114,
-0.17998570203781128,
-0.3645574450492859,
-0.023106398060917854,
0.2396167516708374,
0.25235673785209656,
0.7007851600646973,
-0.6669778227806091,
-0.35261332988739014,
-0.28909626603126526,
-0.8106747269630432,
-0.4239021837711334,
-0.5125728845596313,
0.01486183237284422,
0.1702209711074829,
0.3850244879722595,
-0.36412161588668823,
0.43914979696273804,
0.5629978179931641,
-0.3781289756298065,
0.5535373091697693,
-0.05064370110630989,
0.0388946570456028,
-1.0227128267288208,
-0.11543235927820206,
-0.1259118616580963,
-0.24188841879367828,
-0.39271464943885803,
0.1408350020647049,
0.02020025998353958,
0.21049576997756958,
-0.3743315637111664,
0.5344882011413574,
-0.5709955096244812,
-0.38366204500198364,
-0.1968381702899933,
-0.09752073138952255,
-0.03920472040772438,
0.35325899720191956,
-0.32140281796455383,
0.830795407295227,
0.7256622910499573,
-0.7002418637275696,
0.23661568760871887,
0.612826406955719,
-0.6993682980537415,
0.5746960043907166,
-0.19878621399402618,
0.27636396884918213,
-0.2619544267654419,
0.1434956043958664,
-0.8055790662765503,
-0.3441435694694519,
0.254763662815094,
-0.4310321509838104,
0.16115479171276093,
-0.5155900120735168,
-0.7073569297790527,
-0.11695574223995209,
-0.2781964838504791,
-0.052441950887441635,
0.31774666905403137,
-0.8748550415039062,
0.4674760699272156,
0.3921527564525604,
0.18694303929805756,
-0.9251601099967957,
-1.204782247543335,
0.1644653081893921,
-0.5755817294120789,
-0.3514517843723297,
-0.07729200273752213,
-0.11565642058849335,
-0.47854211926460266,
-0.07918364554643631,
-0.1960296481847763,
-0.5550273060798645,
0.3313407301902771,
0.224074587225914,
0.0950377807021141,
-0.1634231060743332,
0.10965333878993988,
0.015638895332813263,
0.10235603153705597,
0.03535992279648781,
-0.011274069547653198,
0.5169810652732849,
0.6885831356048584,
-0.8341513276100159,
-0.4677146375179291,
0.19357556104660034,
0.5117373466491699,
-0.15328310430049896,
0.8560150265693665,
-0.021833419799804688,
-0.1493724286556244,
-0.7336521744728088,
-0.4332200586795807,
-0.337589293718338,
-0.4781494140625,
0.12800058722496033,
-0.050873830914497375,
-0.7007843852043152,
0.5148828029632568,
0.10537683963775635,
0.3057309687137604,
0.04794829711318016,
0.33248579502105713,
-0.13260598480701447,
0.52489173412323,
0.2920088768005371,
-0.4649161398410797,
0.5355685353279114,
-0.29052823781967163,
0.11744935810565948,
-0.48630818724632263,
-0.10471603274345398,
-0.699164867401123,
-0.5769780874252319,
-0.4639180600643158,
-0.49400410056114197,
0.04197388514876366,
0.11817631870508194,
-0.03454769030213356,
0.29519379138946533,
0.026017291471362114,
0.8208482265472412,
0.575086772441864,
0.12354455143213272,
0.5318427681922913,
0.37902697920799255,
0.06306593865156174,
0.1417798399925232,
-0.6220926642417908,
-0.44799837470054626,
1.3012335300445557,
0.18149493634700775,
0.826397716999054,
0.3703341782093048,
0.8519813418388367,
0.69863361120224,
0.5890492796897888,
-0.7856363654136658,
0.6126963496208191,
-0.17507338523864746,
-0.830329179763794,
0.019415728747844696,
-0.7509375810623169,
-1.0626698732376099,
0.37482088804244995,
-0.18464280664920807,
-0.7398534417152405,
0.5161192417144775,
0.01666964963078499,
0.07254713773727417,
0.3867441415786743,
-0.5384077429771423,
0.7068413496017456,
-0.19833272695541382,
0.021932639181613922,
-0.06518891453742981,
-0.4384992718696594,
0.4257239103317261,
-0.5253267884254456,
0.23470112681388855,
-0.24238531291484833,
-0.02032223716378212,
0.770474374294281,
-0.4640146493911743,
1.029347538948059,
-0.10069001466035843,
0.10316168516874313,
0.338341623544693,
0.21003922820091248,
0.35260531306266785,
-0.09278403222560883,
-0.48155707120895386,
0.12473414093255997,
-0.05279028043150902,
-0.30712372064590454,
-0.5673379898071289,
0.4130460023880005,
-0.6186050176620483,
-0.3778199255466461,
-0.4070436358451843,
-0.29211121797561646,
-0.2186867594718933,
0.21960924565792084,
0.2775590121746063,
0.6093055009841919,
-0.11289536952972412,
0.40653523802757263,
0.3870549499988556,
-0.10211754590272903,
0.44565656781196594,
0.5268649458885193,
-0.02281351387500763,
-0.4536730647087097,
0.8057664632797241,
0.02218417264521122,
0.43077680468559265,
0.40992432832717896,
0.019696760922670364,
-0.40959933400154114,
-0.8542646169662476,
-0.35604405403137207,
0.3221471905708313,
-1.0179070234298706,
-0.21226072311401367,
-0.3885132670402527,
0.03204105794429779,
-0.19679084420204163,
0.11081409454345703,
0.00666621420532465,
-0.37001991271972656,
-0.42386120557785034,
-0.07531878352165222,
0.12642517685890198,
0.8182161450386047,
0.2095554620027542,
0.6803039312362671,
-0.8776310086250305,
0.1148189827799797,
0.1384916752576828,
0.11856959760189056,
-0.09902551770210266,
-0.7600550055503845,
-0.17961974442005157,
0.09623496234416962,
-0.093269482254982,
-1.2604550123214722,
0.4188013970851898,
0.43895256519317627,
0.7388865351676941,
0.5264444351196289,
0.14908896386623383,
0.42795732617378235,
-0.4354313611984253,
0.7013420462608337,
-0.14178137481212616,
-0.7527324557304382,
-0.01392462756484747,
-0.1989428699016571,
-0.20564046502113342,
0.691383957862854,
0.36036956310272217,
-0.39863258600234985,
-0.5281019806861877,
-0.7098163962364197,
-0.5492699146270752,
0.5705490112304688,
0.3791276216506958,
0.2889937162399292,
-0.05811477079987526,
0.4178892970085144,
-0.03932520002126694,
0.37985745072364807,
-0.9485231637954712,
-0.3730698227882385,
0.25033608078956604,
-0.21462507545948029,
0.07917734235525131,
-0.10454177856445312,
-0.11016079783439636,
0.11777377873659134,
0.6015157699584961,
-0.20422305166721344,
0.2829877734184265,
-0.06315623223781586,
-0.33001455664634705,
0.03724561631679535,
0.015856238082051277,
0.009785289876163006,
0.9950605034828186,
0.010968710295855999,
0.11731702834367752,
0.01863369345664978,
-0.3468288779258728,
0.22448033094406128,
-0.08821982145309448,
-0.07306087762117386,
0.2516278028488159,
0.7764347195625305,
0.43575653433799744,
0.01056578103452921,
-0.7211129069328308,
0.7544971704483032,
-0.0848100557923317,
-0.21878884732723236,
-0.23613038659095764,
0.30181968212127686,
0.10805516690015793,
0.2546665072441101,
0.31384825706481934,
-0.07453922182321548,
-0.1791449934244156,
-0.4932348430156708,
0.5802072882652283,
0.5542849898338318,
-0.05207890272140503,
-0.17102661728858948,
0.49432212114334106,
-0.13249945640563965,
-0.040782708674669266,
0.753980815410614,
-0.012352284044027328,
-0.6528270840644836,
0.8608971834182739,
0.38995125889778137,
0.694572925567627,
-0.21144309639930725,
0.1981915980577469,
0.18063262104988098,
0.39377105236053467,
-0.22979500889778137,
0.1633249670267105,
0.0487327054142952,
-1.064974308013916,
-0.34315112233161926,
-0.6735287308692932,
-0.386809378862381,
0.3344925343990326,
-0.6031806468963623,
0.23302061855793,
-0.39963415265083313,
0.0397060289978981,
-0.0339127853512764,
-0.23011824488639832,
-0.3122676610946655,
0.270661860704422,
0.1473361998796463,
1.0569870471954346,
-1.0918740034103394,
0.9617141485214233,
0.08794224262237549,
-0.12044108659029007,
-0.59804368019104,
0.43181678652763367,
0.3200072944164276,
-0.7752431631088257,
0.5848807692527771,
0.10950175672769547,
0.3861626982688904,
-0.03782982379198074,
-0.5387125611305237,
-0.6900059580802917,
0.8405066728591919,
0.5666758418083191,
-0.5448755025863647,
0.23877453804016113,
0.38609516620635986,
0.2731344401836395,
-0.15187425911426544,
-0.05730465054512024,
0.482784628868103,
0.2589794099330902,
0.16564548015594482,
-0.43781399726867676,
-0.21113750338554382,
-0.023484984412789345,
-0.40606021881103516,
0.1393829584121704,
-0.29065054655075073,
0.7592617273330688,
0.07898226380348206,
-0.30357563495635986,
0.15775518119335175,
0.6575707197189331,
0.47548672556877136,
0.19204892218112946,
0.7255038619041443,
0.5310431122779846,
1.0793871879577637,
0.014186977408826351,
1.2434757947921753,
-0.052536945790052414,
0.5273227095603943,
1.2039456367492676,
-0.40899205207824707,
0.7674468755722046,
0.35272443294525146,
-0.3200867772102356,
0.07852949947118759,
0.840836763381958,
-0.513656735420227,
0.6281473636627197,
0.3086022138595581,
-0.47689151763916016,
-0.28167271614074707,
0.15890491008758545,
-0.36898714303970337,
0.34818607568740845,
0.17469853162765503,
-0.5875329971313477,
-0.27822625637054443,
-0.297187477350235,
-0.07824808359146118,
-0.20587660372257233,
0.11100052297115326,
0.7883431911468506,
0.2414017617702484,
-0.45533570647239685,
0.5033722519874573,
-0.1214434951543808,
0.38760173320770264,
-0.7064006924629211,
0.16964682936668396,
-0.46462616324424744,
0.2215995490550995,
-0.1646588146686554,
-0.5883259177207947,
0.29882967472076416,
0.2917589843273163,
0.034639470279216766,
-0.030826950445771217,
0.41677767038345337,
-0.3466418981552124,
-0.4639331102371216,
0.16102997958660126,
0.5858305096626282,
0.4581822156906128,
-0.09593930095434189,
-0.6340535283088684,
-0.014249743893742561,
0.2162708193063736,
-0.42042502760887146,
0.50986647605896,
0.35976743698120117,
0.060702595859766006,
0.672116756439209,
0.7730252742767334,
0.22435249388217926,
0.15175946056842804,
0.29787686467170715,
0.9469813108444214,
-0.3282967209815979,
-0.5780270099639893,
-1.0791360139846802,
0.21787478029727936,
-0.21333818137645721,
-0.30741629004478455,
0.8364513516426086,
0.760576069355011,
0.9269920587539673,
-0.17481419444084167,
0.9617809057235718,
0.08348186314105988,
0.3577565550804138,
-0.8983760476112366,
0.8542085289955139,
-0.7036012411117554,
0.6643868088722229,
0.07650907337665558,
-1.0874497890472412,
-0.5103893280029297,
0.5164640545845032,
-0.3137025833129883,
0.10367816686630249,
0.6567602157592773,
0.8828541040420532,
-0.247906893491745,
0.15221388638019562,
0.2642385959625244,
0.18298865854740143,
0.5248892903327942,
0.15441490709781647,
1.0097675323486328,
-0.14035438001155853,
0.38399145007133484,
-0.2099643349647522,
-0.02074127271771431,
-0.07112167030572891,
-1.0435426235198975,
-1.181863784790039,
-0.17885716259479523,
-0.262362539768219,
-0.4734540283679962,
0.03918240964412689,
0.9958494305610657,
0.5211662650108337,
-0.8182072043418884,
-0.2270018309354782,
0.033023010939359665,
0.2478669285774231,
-0.1045875996351242,
-0.13273194432258606,
0.3265330195426941,
0.033969275653362274,
-0.704018235206604,
0.6698720455169678,
-0.28074952960014343,
0.23278957605361938,
-0.17147371172904968,
0.026961123570799828,
-0.2334318608045578,
0.2036643922328949,
0.007885846309363842,
0.10998145490884781,
-0.47592365741729736,
-0.1469222754240036,
-0.3074807822704315,
-0.07918189465999603,
0.23436297476291656,
0.8695539832115173,
-0.5229079127311707,
0.24495281279087067,
0.6361104846000671,
0.8598408102989197,
0.17670848965644836,
0.15471112728118896,
0.47960105538368225,
-1.0412710905075073,
0.25202125310897827,
0.21359257400035858,
0.5655459761619568,
0.3942689001560211,
-0.3321731686592102,
0.521889865398407,
0.5638242363929749,
-0.49303802847862244,
-1.0252059698104858,
0.21203219890594482,
-0.8248112797737122,
-0.5306597352027893,
1.0811902284622192,
-0.35556623339653015,
-0.3828146159648895,
-0.1659092754125595,
0.24035224318504333,
0.20060966908931732,
-0.10839985311031342,
0.9327725768089294,
0.6582995653152466,
0.2533182203769684,
0.11133439093828201,
-0.7363499999046326,
0.24441681802272797,
0.28839635848999023,
-1.061814785003662,
0.3421345055103302,
0.5802721381187439,
0.39766183495521545,
-0.16866272687911987,
0.34707415103912354,
0.12289676815271378,
-0.0005482904962264001,
-0.0982108935713768,
-0.19242417812347412,
-0.003304507816210389,
-0.31324273347854614,
-0.452330619096756,
0.08151281625032425,
-0.0249727051705122,
-0.15667079389095306
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06441v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06441v1
|
Interpretability of Language Models via Task Spaces
| 2024-06-10T16:34:30 | 2024-06-10T16:34:30 |
Lucas Weber, Jaap Jumelet, Elia Bruni, Dieuwke Hupkes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The usual way to interpret language models (LMs) is to test their performance
on different benchmarks and subsequently infer their internal processes. In
this paper, we present an alternative approach, concentrating on the quality of
LM processing, with a focus on their language abilities. To this end, we
construct 'linguistic task spaces' -- representations of an LM's language
conceptualisation -- that shed light on the connections LMs draw between
language phenomena. Task spaces are based on the interactions of the learning
signals from different linguistic phenomena, which we assess via a method we
call 'similarity probing'. To disentangle the learning signals of linguistic
phenomena, we further introduce a method called 'fine-tuning via gradient
differentials' (FTGD). We apply our methods to language models of three
different scales and find that larger models generalise better to overarching
general concepts for linguistic tasks, making better use of their shared
structure. Further, the distributedness of linguistic processing increases with
pre-training through increased parameter sharing between related linguistic
tasks. The overall generalisation patterns are mostly stable throughout
training and not marked by incisive stages, potentially explaining the lack of
successful curriculum strategies for LMs.
|
[
-0.5089916586875916,
-0.6260319948196411,
0.5996425747871399,
-0.026753807440400124,
-0.21899843215942383,
-0.11424535512924194,
-0.4590545892715454,
-0.4174201190471649,
-0.1087670624256134,
0.48176005482673645,
-0.5982369184494019,
-0.39136114716529846,
-0.7159498929977417,
-0.11601074784994125,
-0.43077391386032104,
0.8440192341804504,
-0.2470889538526535,
0.10863852500915527,
-0.27101173996925354,
-0.4031774699687958,
-0.43205997347831726,
-0.49762415885925293,
-0.577787458896637,
-0.5899749994277954,
0.4520778954029083,
-0.13585814833641052,
0.9212304949760437,
0.6902655959129333,
0.47887399792671204,
0.27386629581451416,
-0.2805060148239136,
0.0649198517203331,
-0.5386532545089722,
-0.07513462007045746,
-0.47670912742614746,
-0.6151885390281677,
-0.24381649494171143,
0.2037448287010193,
0.6021234393119812,
1.1664941310882568,
-0.12709441781044006,
0.06286384910345078,
0.6014929413795471,
0.4894026219844818,
-0.3949967324733734,
0.47014495730400085,
-0.4368078410625458,
-0.008776023052632809,
-0.05378295108675957,
-0.06379785388708115,
-0.22103744745254517,
-0.08804791420698166,
-0.08316027373075485,
-0.5107300877571106,
0.3485085964202881,
-0.10081511735916138,
0.704752504825592,
0.27691689133644104,
-0.15890230238437653,
-0.3916206955909729,
-0.6413761973381042,
0.835517406463623,
-0.7906100749969482,
0.5103558301925659,
0.4942879378795624,
0.3038519620895386,
0.004971692338585854,
-0.40320172905921936,
-0.5780237913131714,
-0.388869971036911,
-0.4246877431869507,
-0.2473265826702118,
-0.11817601323127747,
0.09066327661275864,
0.23610243201255798,
0.33765870332717896,
-0.6097744703292847,
0.2788398861885071,
-0.19934768974781036,
0.006896125618368387,
0.4294545352458954,
0.21329854428768158,
0.4856286644935608,
0.09320954233407974,
0.030590029433369637,
-0.0808693915605545,
-0.6973605155944824,
0.263668954372406,
0.43018996715545654,
0.6365671753883362,
-0.06056162714958191,
0.3477427065372467,
-0.24610097706317902,
0.743177592754364,
-0.009750274941325188,
0.1676638275384903,
0.08274463564157486,
-0.23260991275310516,
-0.28219732642173767,
-0.6257245540618896,
0.42314592003822327,
0.2553595006465912,
0.5090318918228149,
-0.3102203905582428,
-0.24451740086078644,
0.11038602888584137,
0.4088295102119446,
-0.41160041093826294,
-0.24725833535194397,
0.12992623448371887,
-0.4132583439350128,
-0.016938965767621994,
-0.21677066385746002,
-0.3278017044067383,
-0.14602452516555786,
-0.6837700605392456,
0.4708895683288574,
-0.3870871365070343,
-0.395258367061615,
0.292776882648468,
0.15004654228687286,
0.06738178431987762,
0.2504009008407593,
-0.9873745441436768,
0.7140986323356628,
0.7965946197509766,
0.7272127270698547,
-0.24459704756736755,
-0.48302364349365234,
-0.2907525897026062,
-0.14980509877204895,
-0.2796340584754944,
0.4461505711078644,
-0.5589966773986816,
-0.27103573083877563,
-0.014384142123162746,
-0.0006454269168898463,
-0.2309809774160385,
-0.7388362288475037,
0.20142687857151031,
-0.6205995082855225,
0.06534359604120255,
-0.25190675258636475,
-0.5799204707145691,
-0.0844038724899292,
0.1765364557504654,
-0.6880794763565063,
0.9575108885765076,
0.19161063432693481,
-0.4750930070877075,
0.47318994998931885,
-0.7168188691139221,
-0.26529690623283386,
-0.08287782967090607,
-0.16198383271694183,
0.13284718990325928,
0.26799991726875305,
0.09398259967565536,
0.7603476643562317,
-0.012446718290448189,
0.3884808123111725,
-0.32090282440185547,
-0.3188338279724121,
0.23082973062992096,
-0.028038805350661278,
0.547140896320343,
0.3588770925998688,
-0.27643316984176636,
-0.039498161524534225,
-0.6613336801528931,
0.1619994193315506,
-0.1350262463092804,
-0.17338964343070984,
-0.5038727521896362,
0.1643018126487732,
-0.05379068851470947,
0.30502915382385254,
0.0772823765873909,
-0.12874631583690643,
-0.04157967492938042,
-0.6521053314208984,
0.38719823956489563,
0.4349156320095062,
-0.36220958828926086,
0.7138946652412415,
-0.21637678146362305,
0.5497793555259705,
0.17427487671375275,
0.05808801203966141,
0.20306991040706635,
-0.31594404578208923,
-0.7510806918144226,
-0.031496915966272354,
0.015446558594703674,
0.19638679921627045,
-0.5091544389724731,
0.3585076928138733,
-0.18419292569160461,
-0.3641342222690582,
-0.5057504177093506,
0.41693559288978577,
0.4794746935367584,
0.1344766616821289,
0.24683842062950134,
-0.5003770589828491,
-0.21142372488975525,
-0.7936491370201111,
-0.6158490180969238,
0.04448404535651207,
-0.0349060520529747,
0.24885524809360504,
0.5556687116622925,
-0.212201789021492,
0.6938363909721375,
-0.4655345380306244,
-0.07168272882699966,
-0.3959287703037262,
0.03830980882048607,
0.3734111487865448,
0.4720397889614105,
0.588229238986969,
-0.6536082625389099,
-0.5289716124534607,
0.15338611602783203,
-0.6161600947380066,
-0.14370942115783691,
0.21084478497505188,
0.04767031967639923,
-0.07525226473808289,
0.661379873752594,
-0.5036871433258057,
0.18374672532081604,
0.5459966063499451,
-0.497612863779068,
0.26659733057022095,
-0.193016916513443,
0.08115719258785248,
-0.7749803066253662,
0.038169022649526596,
0.08551520854234695,
-0.24959146976470947,
-0.8862364292144775,
0.6077919006347656,
-0.11698636412620544,
0.026984527707099915,
-0.39852458238601685,
0.7839345932006836,
-0.47820204496383667,
-0.173054039478302,
-0.38960471749305725,
0.21331186592578888,
-0.021119318902492523,
0.4935562312602997,
-0.02451898157596588,
0.538891613483429,
0.6557751297950745,
-0.545950710773468,
-0.07834848761558533,
-0.07110618054866791,
-0.574253499507904,
0.3748779892921448,
-0.538840115070343,
0.04988422244787216,
-0.24767658114433289,
-0.1266469806432724,
-1.1832698583602905,
-0.03312752768397331,
-0.006794714368879795,
-0.3028542101383209,
0.3215908706188202,
-0.03760946914553642,
-0.42310041189193726,
-0.06949225068092346,
0.15176692605018616,
0.4604787230491638,
0.5143396854400635,
-0.32009172439575195,
0.4165990352630615,
0.2748214304447174,
-0.049406278878450394,
-0.514168381690979,
-0.6066601872444153,
-0.3671797811985016,
-0.3430609107017517,
-0.4007112681865692,
-0.02967837266623974,
0.0480642132461071,
-0.6327858567237854,
0.13496029376983643,
-0.20108848810195923,
-0.39868026971817017,
0.4419592022895813,
0.36593151092529297,
-0.009846413508057594,
-0.38444796204566956,
0.15783807635307312,
-0.0896221324801445,
0.024036038666963577,
0.014095759019255638,
-0.42767515778541565,
0.5234580039978027,
0.03989465907216072,
-0.3171006441116333,
-0.27055588364601135,
0.25568297505378723,
0.424490749835968,
-0.04770808294415474,
1.0579661130905151,
0.48876136541366577,
-0.4761083126068115,
-0.5190346240997314,
-0.2488582581281662,
-0.11899617314338684,
-0.4836527705192566,
0.2638716399669647,
-0.6444950699806213,
-1.0809543132781982,
0.7117360830307007,
-0.05053688585758209,
-0.09963743388652802,
0.5514422059059143,
0.4887186586856842,
-0.4049018621444702,
0.8157714605331421,
0.9563186168670654,
-0.12331361323595047,
0.45819005370140076,
-0.23770733177661896,
0.19785766303539276,
-0.61875319480896,
-0.09391529113054276,
-0.6216595768928528,
-0.27212998270988464,
-0.35591748356819153,
-0.7360942959785461,
0.05576984956860542,
0.4756566882133484,
-0.13407494127750397,
0.5021856427192688,
-0.14582961797714233,
0.7142132520675659,
0.287744402885437,
-0.05328856036067009,
0.2243824303150177,
0.048089224845170975,
-0.2281578928232193,
-0.2471333146095276,
-0.5743136405944824,
-0.7067616581916809,
0.8949130773544312,
0.4040490686893463,
0.7517207860946655,
0.05878571420907974,
0.4886002838611603,
0.22299355268478394,
0.3183573782444,
-0.534819483757019,
0.37785059213638306,
-0.38251444697380066,
-0.6429852843284607,
-0.48340484499931335,
-0.3357866406440735,
-0.9234711527824402,
0.5045801997184753,
-0.02874452993273735,
-0.9962645769119263,
-0.041286785155534744,
0.0414312407374382,
-0.31944069266319275,
0.24901393055915833,
-0.6282200217247009,
0.8136208057403564,
0.08424526453018188,
-0.1520220786333084,
-0.5808267593383789,
-0.33761680126190186,
0.21619582176208496,
-0.1031608134508133,
0.5590325593948364,
-0.12947994470596313,
0.16350753605365753,
0.49052953720092773,
-0.11158515512943268,
1.0704991817474365,
-0.19195926189422607,
-0.40669968724250793,
0.11926707625389099,
0.27215975522994995,
0.09832935035228729,
-0.1514197736978531,
-0.08849003911018372,
0.17419317364692688,
0.15631002187728882,
-0.48278361558914185,
-0.8736675977706909,
0.764385461807251,
-0.923328697681427,
-0.548757016658783,
0.09541372209787369,
-0.755814790725708,
-0.4537951648235321,
0.13282102346420288,
-0.007577653042972088,
0.5012061595916748,
-0.21966776251792908,
-0.17334038019180298,
0.44485902786254883,
-0.21951384842395782,
0.13242694735527039,
0.45853888988494873,
-0.20682114362716675,
0.2860463261604309,
0.6567947268486023,
0.04622786492109299,
0.5759812593460083,
0.5115867853164673,
-0.02436896599829197,
-0.4885624051094055,
-0.7326467037200928,
-0.0498724989593029,
0.1558544635772705,
-0.876061201095581,
0.33404138684272766,
-0.48810258507728577,
-0.14144565165042877,
-0.23950670659542084,
-0.10836060345172882,
-0.24314925074577332,
-0.33348944783210754,
-0.3381170928478241,
-0.05785617232322693,
-0.02602294459939003,
1.0111949443817139,
-0.052572257816791534,
0.4961774945259094,
-0.6353878974914551,
0.3961365818977356,
0.17026302218437195,
0.5724437236785889,
0.09855923056602478,
-0.694800853729248,
-0.3972489833831787,
0.16719451546669006,
-0.12027819454669952,
-0.6327219009399414,
0.3584119975566864,
0.21451716125011444,
0.765869677066803,
0.3016708195209503,
-0.35307857394218445,
0.6611542701721191,
-0.5617917776107788,
0.8011630773544312,
0.09199866652488708,
-1.1347572803497314,
0.5175708532333374,
-0.4090959429740906,
0.15936779975891113,
0.37654486298561096,
0.5738372802734375,
-0.475935697555542,
-0.6172260046005249,
-0.5201190710067749,
-0.5440890192985535,
0.6119853854179382,
0.21178877353668213,
0.2690037488937378,
0.23887790739536285,
0.5544933676719666,
0.41628125309944153,
0.16077931225299835,
-0.8509935140609741,
-0.18267759680747986,
0.07723955810070038,
-0.1361819952726364,
-0.7523714303970337,
-0.06132599338889122,
-0.19663818180561066,
-0.22624139487743378,
0.243606835603714,
-0.1417999118566513,
0.1605176031589508,
-0.21893833577632904,
-0.27801740169525146,
-0.15470288693904877,
0.42477431893348694,
0.3692404329776764,
0.8279075026512146,
-0.010560388676822186,
0.24727575480937958,
0.14668363332748413,
-0.18564872443675995,
0.1536693423986435,
-0.07789529860019684,
0.30780524015426636,
-0.038394417613744736,
0.6589167714118958,
0.8491995334625244,
0.15975849330425262,
-0.5662803053855896,
0.2240801900625229,
0.07793678343296051,
-0.20161157846450806,
0.23239175975322723,
0.4825354516506195,
0.1955385059118271,
0.5484581589698792,
-0.09659124165773392,
0.03036508709192276,
0.10769536346197128,
-0.8851388692855835,
0.20791679620742798,
0.3465743958950043,
-0.48400479555130005,
-0.5827019810676575,
0.6477482318878174,
0.024058006703853607,
-0.247700497508049,
0.31903815269470215,
-0.09699879586696625,
-0.25850602984428406,
0.5917313694953918,
0.308267742395401,
0.582467794418335,
-0.12891344726085663,
0.20580528676509857,
0.212079256772995,
0.24583011865615845,
-0.24688619375228882,
0.4082966446876526,
-0.08154942095279694,
-1.0537959337234497,
-0.6388899087905884,
-0.8003367781639099,
-0.19299520552158356,
0.35703226923942566,
-0.8534022569656372,
-0.18249335885047913,
-0.2538485825061798,
-0.01845739036798477,
0.05891721323132515,
-0.0978645533323288,
-0.8557194471359253,
0.44664403796195984,
0.1717773824930191,
0.7620980143547058,
-1.1068289279937744,
1.019040822982788,
0.7940777540206909,
-0.04489319771528244,
-0.926746129989624,
-0.0009497287101112306,
-0.14935661852359772,
-0.8301836848258972,
0.8944633603096008,
0.004290592856705189,
0.027550779283046722,
-0.0955614522099495,
-0.21306124329566956,
-0.7016264796257019,
0.6545671820640564,
0.44847428798675537,
-0.7012467980384827,
-0.010908321477472782,
0.42147737741470337,
0.9113709330558777,
-0.30804991722106934,
0.0960816964507103,
0.8202649354934692,
0.14892129600048065,
-0.4197695255279541,
-1.2823454141616821,
0.0021839526016265154,
-0.12465920299291611,
-0.11525178700685501,
0.2442314773797989,
-0.21952971816062927,
0.9210116267204285,
-0.04740370064973831,
-0.24165309965610504,
0.07208657264709473,
0.2645338177680969,
-0.02257956936955452,
0.1302805095911026,
0.578874409198761,
0.5268274545669556,
0.6514444947242737,
-0.13618947565555573,
0.9959940910339355,
-0.24971306324005127,
0.5919029712677002,
1.0178470611572266,
-0.15720532834529877,
0.9162182807922363,
0.6417924761772156,
-0.4136994481086731,
0.33667492866516113,
0.39680424332618713,
0.34913885593414307,
0.7499353885650635,
0.564426600933075,
0.11692613363265991,
-0.26080262660980225,
0.08664007484912872,
-0.11892552673816681,
0.25384026765823364,
0.5183899998664856,
-0.35502129793167114,
-0.4080730676651001,
0.08014687150716782,
-0.3641776442527771,
0.5240584015846252,
-0.435417503118515,
0.4612327814102173,
0.29886773228645325,
-0.5711455941200256,
0.6312743425369263,
-0.2093123346567154,
0.613033652305603,
-0.42774298787117004,
0.09337630867958069,
-0.23427490890026093,
0.2213810235261917,
-0.10169996321201324,
-1.0642155408859253,
0.578879714012146,
-0.0798712968826294,
-0.16134607791900635,
-0.634375810623169,
0.6123634576797485,
-0.46397408843040466,
-0.10883449763059616,
0.59829181432724,
1.002712368965149,
0.3174128532409668,
-0.010285348631441593,
-0.5819593071937561,
-0.04365547001361847,
-0.12175574898719788,
-0.0439642034471035,
0.5490660071372986,
0.3899843692779541,
0.028237583115696907,
0.7293052673339844,
0.29535478353500366,
0.3699752390384674,
0.05519276112318039,
0.2507708966732025,
0.6528109908103943,
-0.6687846183776855,
-0.45233696699142456,
-0.8942288160324097,
0.41349759697914124,
0.32074081897735596,
-0.351647287607193,
0.5602001547813416,
-0.007130676880478859,
1.2162530422210693,
-0.29216867685317993,
0.5906825661659241,
0.10256259143352509,
0.4567711651325226,
-0.6873897910118103,
0.7269906997680664,
-0.6805214285850525,
0.2582782804965973,
-0.1864374279975891,
-0.8066965341567993,
-0.24969318509101868,
0.7931607961654663,
-0.47127288579940796,
0.09300132840871811,
0.6541861891746521,
0.7546737790107727,
-0.42783111333847046,
-0.07691194117069244,
0.6342182159423828,
0.21932874619960785,
0.16548149287700653,
0.4510185718536377,
1.2283905744552612,
-0.09968636929988861,
0.11324620991945267,
-0.0690794587135315,
0.02002129890024662,
0.08432895690202713,
-0.5775982141494751,
-1.22616708278656,
-0.7851264476776123,
-0.18035823106765747,
-0.03324466571211815,
0.0289045087993145,
0.4756903648376465,
0.8167617917060852,
-0.8380950093269348,
-0.41408681869506836,
-0.2249874472618103,
-0.16102908551692963,
-0.3062116205692291,
-0.23385857045650482,
0.22650596499443054,
-0.5311135053634644,
-0.7410484552383423,
0.32286912202835083,
0.08326960355043411,
-0.10676757246255875,
-0.26983925700187683,
-0.13993306457996368,
0.22754019498825073,
-0.0038478916976600885,
0.5627150535583496,
-0.0026165980380028486,
-0.9027355909347534,
-0.38146933913230896,
-0.11873377859592438,
-0.12909118831157684,
-0.09302584826946259,
0.8803816437721252,
-0.43911367654800415,
0.20060907304286957,
0.3722856342792511,
0.5646557211875916,
0.23539119958877563,
-0.34533748030662537,
0.7181294560432434,
-0.7409879565238953,
0.18007735908031464,
0.0986354723572731,
0.4688214659690857,
0.14068369567394257,
-0.27968114614486694,
0.4814458191394806,
-0.06183187663555145,
-0.34632182121276855,
-0.7878668308258057,
0.29218631982803345,
-0.7705205678939819,
-0.5131504535675049,
1.1924856901168823,
-0.443438321352005,
0.12462394684553146,
-0.17340652644634247,
-0.0906681939959526,
0.27254894375801086,
0.044746529310941696,
0.673782467842102,
1.0071611404418945,
-0.19776839017868042,
0.05209304392337799,
-0.9177354574203491,
0.7147918939590454,
0.6004642844200134,
-0.599489688873291,
0.09610659629106522,
0.21286718547344208,
0.6119166016578674,
0.1751677542924881,
0.5808127522468567,
0.05230935290455818,
0.06770887970924377,
-0.1449759155511856,
-0.24877765774726868,
0.27110931277275085,
-0.29296305775642395,
-0.6868432760238647,
0.12844295799732208,
0.3955601751804352,
-0.05683134123682976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06438v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06438v1
|
Multimodal Contextualized Semantic Parsing from Speech
| 2024-06-10T16:31:34 | 2024-06-10T16:31:34 |
Jordan Voas, Raymond Mooney, David Harwath
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.HC, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
We introduce Semantic Parsing in Contextual Environments (SPICE), a task
designed to enhance artificial agents' contextual awareness by integrating
multimodal inputs with prior contexts. SPICE goes beyond traditional semantic
parsing by offering a structured, interpretable framework for dynamically
updating an agent's knowledge with new information, mirroring the complexity of
human communication. We develop the VG-SPICE dataset, crafted to challenge
agents with visual scene graph construction from spoken conversational
exchanges, highlighting speech and visual data integration. We also present the
Audio-Vision Dialogue Scene Parser (AViD-SP) developed for use on VG-SPICE.
These innovations aim to improve multimodal information processing and
integration. Both the VG-SPICE dataset and the AViD-SP model are publicly
available.
|
[
-0.3986302614212036,
-0.779053807258606,
0.6506050229072571,
0.4671896696090698,
0.03581110015511513,
0.019908538088202477,
-0.17579695582389832,
-0.3454168140888214,
0.11629503965377808,
0.466216117143631,
-0.6773617267608643,
-0.5625218749046326,
-0.43346717953681946,
-0.18467172980308533,
-0.1817992478609085,
0.4086274206638336,
0.386797159910202,
0.3434217870235443,
-0.5432186722755432,
-0.2069232016801834,
-0.7570847272872925,
-0.35601913928985596,
-0.5130704045295715,
-0.07169458270072937,
0.4202629029750824,
0.43933841586112976,
0.8470832705497742,
0.8657160997390747,
0.40531423687934875,
0.4564809203147888,
0.03374604508280754,
0.21840277314186096,
-0.09304507821798325,
0.4607434868812561,
-0.5145641565322876,
-0.14823107421398163,
-0.6687895655632019,
-0.007191746030002832,
0.5928774476051331,
0.69278883934021,
0.2751070261001587,
-0.08266675472259521,
-0.300921231508255,
0.17528870701789856,
-0.45803362131118774,
0.584316611289978,
-0.6180844902992249,
0.036112770438194275,
0.025161778554320335,
-0.5509962439537048,
-0.28798508644104004,
0.17372775077819824,
0.045418739318847656,
-0.7385005950927734,
0.02968246303498745,
0.05557863414287567,
0.7581408619880676,
0.40140947699546814,
-0.6457876563072205,
-0.23844312131404877,
-0.6234048008918762,
0.8870307803153992,
-0.15234893560409546,
0.7248172163963318,
0.22353284060955048,
0.5899172425270081,
-0.3222483992576599,
-1.1075657606124878,
-0.6636910438537598,
-0.27415522933006287,
0.02636331506073475,
0.12196634709835052,
-0.25980210304260254,
0.169975146651268,
0.1761740893125534,
0.11878328025341034,
-0.3704527020454407,
-0.5631828308105469,
-0.2721058428287506,
-0.2894289791584015,
0.2886822521686554,
0.10418809205293655,
0.5320016741752625,
-0.334638386964798,
-0.6456307768821716,
-0.42000752687454224,
-0.2517557144165039,
0.08826788514852524,
-0.22667230665683746,
0.3447340130805969,
0.14414715766906738,
0.5107337236404419,
-0.30861151218414307,
0.9096049666404724,
-0.4947906732559204,
-0.25881463289260864,
0.40943101048469543,
-0.6169319748878479,
-0.3028135895729065,
0.1266252100467682,
0.41428107023239136,
0.6659852266311646,
-0.08369746804237366,
0.05137244984507561,
-0.013787996955215931,
0.25406116247177124,
0.028841368854045868,
-0.3745882213115692,
-0.19705677032470703,
0.2001347839832306,
-0.028736332431435585,
-0.04704214259982109,
-0.05064522102475166,
-0.8738999366760254,
-0.46015608310699463,
-0.74526447057724,
0.32151010632514954,
-0.5098296403884888,
-0.05421479791402817,
0.013736652210354805,
-0.7235533595085144,
0.4889924228191376,
0.723680317401886,
-0.35642993450164795,
0.254364013671875,
0.6393275856971741,
0.8447166085243225,
0.2898388206958771,
-0.3587021231651306,
-0.7853338718414307,
0.6268265843391418,
-0.1356678158044815,
0.9441515207290649,
-0.8927961587905884,
-0.42977121472358704,
-0.4113241136074066,
0.27430543303489685,
-0.08392933756113052,
-0.4012262523174286,
0.6451722383499146,
-0.2401210218667984,
-0.10986445844173431,
-0.49775996804237366,
-0.22069606184959412,
-0.07197801023721695,
0.4878697991371155,
-0.40320155024528503,
0.7037436366081238,
-0.004075922537595034,
-0.35975176095962524,
0.6069048643112183,
-0.8580610752105713,
-0.2987035810947418,
-0.06946519762277603,
-0.3869108557701111,
0.23203986883163452,
-0.11452601104974747,
0.6868998408317566,
0.32828521728515625,
-0.1783493459224701,
0.31354326009750366,
-0.21957728266716003,
0.22272519767284393,
0.23686599731445312,
-0.5362144112586975,
0.30836623907089233,
0.7217771410942078,
0.044356267899274826,
0.6695835590362549,
-1.0058456659317017,
0.04520205780863762,
-0.03799446299672127,
0.005681260023266077,
-0.3306214511394501,
-0.013615456409752369,
0.15778128802776337,
0.6801667809486389,
0.15741048753261566,
-0.5451668500900269,
0.07100599259138107,
-0.2796609401702881,
0.47796282172203064,
0.691546618938446,
-0.06616809964179993,
0.46469399333000183,
-0.15243813395500183,
0.21582135558128357,
0.5213160514831543,
0.29143980145454407,
-0.6375084519386292,
-0.6007643938064575,
-0.6195589303970337,
-0.5213413834571838,
-0.13642656803131104,
0.7173656821250916,
-1.0263068675994873,
0.06650964170694351,
-0.30058959126472473,
-0.2711635231971741,
-0.2989029288291931,
0.175819531083107,
0.16071845591068268,
0.6381837129592896,
0.302806556224823,
-0.061817362904548645,
-0.5294644832611084,
-0.90833580493927,
-0.307082861661911,
0.008548280224204063,
-0.051733020693063736,
0.5405248999595642,
0.13674335181713104,
-0.45753544569015503,
1.4191268682479858,
-0.5404490232467651,
-0.48626381158828735,
-0.43349558115005493,
0.12645871937274933,
-0.14767050743103027,
0.7161419987678528,
0.45673924684524536,
-1.0119264125823975,
-0.2062440812587738,
0.34301313757896423,
-0.7877369523048401,
-0.1549232304096222,
0.12282063812017441,
-0.2313237488269806,
-0.5267360806465149,
1.0265501737594604,
-0.5177186727523804,
0.30121558904647827,
0.4066047966480255,
-0.5171144008636475,
-0.09722089022397995,
-0.23524586856365204,
0.4108603298664093,
-1.2917922735214233,
-0.35453999042510986,
0.04435563087463379,
-0.5917559266090393,
-0.9055089950561523,
-0.2926739752292633,
-0.0596173033118248,
-0.5377510786056519,
-0.8493754863739014,
0.7674018144607544,
-0.3893318772315979,
-0.3215465545654297,
-0.25665879249572754,
0.33432576060295105,
0.40575167536735535,
0.5117529034614563,
0.19354115426540375,
0.7298589944839478,
0.7358847260475159,
-0.4103953242301941,
0.7927678227424622,
0.315702885389328,
0.02573147602379322,
0.7465569972991943,
-0.634423553943634,
0.027505140751600266,
-0.4359152019023895,
0.26572370529174805,
-1.1331610679626465,
-0.6234590411186218,
0.3083942234516144,
-0.46732956171035767,
-0.14470575749874115,
-0.29170942306518555,
-0.3317360579967499,
0.2770703136920929,
-0.13599196076393127,
0.642660915851593,
0.1108100563287735,
-0.5570930242538452,
0.8209272623062134,
0.39986228942871094,
-0.15655119717121124,
-0.24131950736045837,
-0.6189199090003967,
0.30838701128959656,
-0.12091737240552902,
-1.0624735355377197,
0.09576691687107086,
0.26069360971450806,
-0.5062803626060486,
0.08429629355669022,
0.03100205771625042,
-0.13884402811527252,
-0.2525518834590912,
0.26287007331848145,
0.011068292893469334,
-0.3193562626838684,
0.1590385138988495,
0.06999442726373672,
-0.12721483409404755,
0.009405786171555519,
-0.3127293884754181,
0.5901177525520325,
-0.38964414596557617,
-0.42527908086776733,
-0.34094172716140747,
0.46380722522735596,
0.6533629894256592,
-0.3467969596385956,
0.6079806685447693,
0.7654305100440979,
-0.38566017150878906,
0.1014336571097374,
-0.41443192958831787,
0.009511133655905724,
-0.5143802762031555,
0.3059517741203308,
-0.5591537952423096,
-0.6218631863594055,
0.489242285490036,
-0.41508743166923523,
-0.2891993522644043,
0.29616960883140564,
0.27983424067497253,
0.132635697722435,
1.2756940126419067,
0.40175995230674744,
0.29443830251693726,
0.5956219434738159,
0.03502057492733002,
0.04986121878027916,
-0.7125200033187866,
-0.4179440438747406,
-0.3096318244934082,
-0.06211231276392937,
-0.22887396812438965,
-0.8101109266281128,
0.558754563331604,
-0.11582930386066437,
0.12647317349910736,
0.13711535930633545,
-0.24755515158176422,
0.6312452554702759,
0.7448028326034546,
0.06761976331472397,
0.25455522537231445,
-0.14179213345050812,
0.09312250465154648,
0.14137277007102966,
-0.588374674320221,
-0.38124528527259827,
0.6212698221206665,
0.5382384657859802,
0.9363484382629395,
0.1915939599275589,
-0.0018458697013556957,
0.316179096698761,
-0.2777450978755951,
-0.8490262031555176,
0.6602389812469482,
0.15458202362060547,
-0.2671293020248413,
-0.1774870753288269,
-0.24030162394046783,
-0.7493216395378113,
0.5588852763175964,
-0.058420710265636444,
-0.7994011640548706,
0.5235689282417297,
0.13558830320835114,
-0.03313102200627327,
-0.13516053557395935,
-0.9807634949684143,
1.233158826828003,
-0.08749236166477203,
-0.3232886791229248,
0.04921048879623413,
-0.815823495388031,
0.20270216464996338,
0.5472675561904907,
0.3825837969779968,
-0.2344129979610443,
-0.04069776087999344,
0.5213886499404907,
-0.4013444185256958,
0.7120896577835083,
-0.3288397789001465,
0.16165849566459656,
0.2318841814994812,
-0.1158972978591919,
0.28866246342658997,
0.30417177081108093,
0.41442206501960754,
0.008380582556128502,
0.09280673414468765,
-0.4738462269306183,
-0.7559310793876648,
0.8223593235015869,
-0.7256259918212891,
-0.5876774191856384,
-0.5909296870231628,
-0.9167376160621643,
-0.4828939139842987,
0.17981784045696259,
-0.18788768351078033,
0.7755283117294312,
-0.041811950504779816,
0.2779421806335449,
0.5742513537406921,
-0.42979034781455994,
0.23307979106903076,
0.11577128618955612,
-0.4874594807624817,
-0.5331088304519653,
1.1053739786148071,
-0.29540666937828064,
0.34929192066192627,
0.29898056387901306,
0.2677096128463745,
-0.33495068550109863,
-0.06837820261716843,
-0.4213431477546692,
0.016208352521061897,
-1.2723196744918823,
0.14988857507705688,
-1.0424655675888062,
-0.20119555294513702,
-0.8703374862670898,
-0.21235407888889313,
-0.4372056722640991,
-0.28077933192253113,
-0.1403101533651352,
0.052710290998220444,
0.347391277551651,
0.643747866153717,
-0.0743078738451004,
0.5190179347991943,
-0.7602014541625977,
0.5227858424186707,
0.45356228947639465,
0.07698268443346024,
-0.6555164456367493,
-0.03919047489762306,
0.05342812463641167,
0.07056757062673569,
-0.13896100223064423,
-0.8616844415664673,
0.5284446477890015,
0.3229961395263672,
0.5771867632865906,
0.41032761335372925,
-0.28034263849258423,
0.9580583572387695,
-0.47212907671928406,
1.0222934484481812,
-0.029419220983982086,
-1.0307050943374634,
0.981350839138031,
-0.3297002613544464,
0.4866968095302582,
0.334117591381073,
-0.06718508899211884,
-0.6630380749702454,
-0.29119744896888733,
-0.2850196361541748,
-0.9004579186439514,
0.9100964665412903,
0.12756769359111786,
-0.03679182380437851,
-0.16285154223442078,
-0.10905317962169647,
-0.23705768585205078,
0.29692378640174866,
-0.4712756872177124,
0.007684835698455572,
-0.6764066219329834,
-0.07525313645601273,
-0.23241889476776123,
-0.24526573717594147,
-0.38507482409477234,
-0.48297154903411865,
0.215606227517128,
-0.17651641368865967,
0.21657466888427734,
0.4433307945728302,
-0.34871652722358704,
0.3643648028373718,
0.3692515790462494,
0.8752976059913635,
0.6942133903503418,
-0.23252363502979279,
0.39007776975631714,
-0.047317985445261,
-0.3790523409843445,
0.034271977841854095,
-0.10802135616540909,
0.42142727971076965,
0.066512830555439,
0.3518444299697876,
0.9535471200942993,
0.15139809250831604,
-0.9110381603240967,
0.711206316947937,
-0.2837464511394501,
0.007942607626318932,
-0.45189595222473145,
0.011149645783007145,
-0.1749219447374344,
0.4631164073944092,
-0.08118558675050735,
0.3042330741882324,
0.43366020917892456,
-0.8395867943763733,
0.4199139475822449,
0.4016316533088684,
-0.5143923759460449,
-0.17734655737876892,
0.6655221581459045,
0.1124516949057579,
-0.010440900921821594,
0.3146422207355499,
-0.07968757301568985,
-0.28392714262008667,
0.45425230264663696,
0.5176538228988647,
0.6732648611068726,
-0.182220458984375,
0.1637926697731018,
-0.08819658309221268,
0.17691393196582794,
0.23647746443748474,
0.21988654136657715,
-0.27122825384140015,
-0.7078293561935425,
-0.2134876847267151,
-0.6569413542747498,
-0.43305593729019165,
-0.071458600461483,
-0.3698308765888214,
0.3067263960838318,
-0.5373137593269348,
-0.09154564887285233,
0.04239971190690994,
-0.7399451732635498,
-0.6261034607887268,
0.3631390929222107,
-0.045134205371141434,
0.8276737928390503,
-0.845041811466217,
0.85001140832901,
0.9779475927352905,
-0.27649131417274475,
-0.48957768082618713,
-0.20083796977996826,
0.25225451588630676,
-0.7659466862678528,
0.9910386204719543,
0.008465505205094814,
-0.2679066061973572,
-0.2397564798593521,
-0.30981314182281494,
-0.8993598818778992,
0.9847811460494995,
0.37888437509536743,
0.023316824808716774,
0.148068368434906,
0.3731338381767273,
0.4282241463661194,
-0.37858670949935913,
0.22822266817092896,
0.6099289655685425,
0.5462363362312317,
0.7984504699707031,
-0.709675669670105,
-0.329496294260025,
-0.5331325531005859,
0.11543018370866776,
0.04184146970510483,
-0.3899521231651306,
1.0279521942138672,
0.42273518443107605,
-0.09251399338245392,
-0.34996673464775085,
0.7879039645195007,
-0.04424043744802475,
0.7128349542617798,
0.5741961002349854,
0.3500289022922516,
0.34886470437049866,
-0.24353796243667603,
0.8609430193901062,
-0.29444989562034607,
-0.08558625727891922,
1.201801061630249,
-0.31874334812164307,
0.5005875825881958,
0.6292926073074341,
0.3505709767341614,
-0.07437103986740112,
0.26090407371520996,
0.40665730834007263,
0.5036091208457947,
-0.1493166834115982,
-0.5518950819969177,
-0.1544404923915863,
-0.5591826438903809,
-0.21579024195671082,
0.7503084540367126,
0.6299296617507935,
-0.1959846317768097,
-0.4519060552120209,
0.51887446641922,
-0.05560895800590515,
0.09489008784294128,
-0.3386307656764984,
1.0848119258880615,
-0.15301738679409027,
-0.44991952180862427,
0.08343661576509476,
-0.10185423493385315,
0.1607283055782318,
-0.6578022837638855,
-0.334597647190094,
0.0228811614215374,
0.2351742535829544,
-0.21618063747882843,
-0.7212069034576416,
0.45611441135406494,
-0.2056414932012558,
0.0011243378976359963,
-0.3294762670993805,
0.8464972972869873,
-0.6553977727890015,
-0.3629499077796936,
0.11857104301452637,
0.40114784240722656,
0.19977736473083496,
-0.2477792352437973,
-0.5524585247039795,
0.45657625794410706,
-0.31662943959236145,
-0.14821602404117584,
0.24392761290073395,
0.6396235227584839,
-0.1630946546792984,
0.6874926686286926,
0.6547052264213562,
-0.1282624751329422,
0.4014554023742676,
0.20352715253829956,
1.145961046218872,
-0.8705434799194336,
-0.6384110450744629,
-0.6670037508010864,
0.5549488663673401,
-0.38637036085128784,
-0.050418414175510406,
0.9042163491249084,
0.4361569583415985,
0.7747299075126648,
-0.05816543474793434,
0.6911581158638,
-0.01859336718916893,
0.20440039038658142,
-0.6867078542709351,
0.27391090989112854,
-0.7190197706222534,
0.3136623203754425,
-0.5796431303024292,
-0.9318382740020752,
-0.34484803676605225,
0.45333603024482727,
-0.23627063632011414,
-0.01375544536858797,
0.5147141218185425,
0.9869624376296997,
-0.4051855802536011,
0.0003652045561466366,
0.7044394016265869,
0.05887043848633766,
0.7787008881568909,
0.18665097653865814,
1.0763136148452759,
-0.14378023147583008,
0.2483709454536438,
-0.30768293142318726,
-0.36871138215065,
0.06311415880918503,
-0.8477761745452881,
-0.7697924971580505,
-0.8628025054931641,
-0.0719069093465805,
-0.15531755983829498,
-0.061908185482025146,
1.176679253578186,
0.6388843655586243,
-0.44466862082481384,
-0.16402696073055267,
0.010306544601917267,
-0.06444162875413895,
-0.07385338842868805,
-0.29007676243782043,
0.03114927187561989,
-0.6620208024978638,
-0.8283993005752563,
0.9919676184654236,
0.7407807111740112,
-0.09843838214874268,
-0.0015661458019167185,
0.08374176919460297,
-0.4053477942943573,
0.2723444104194641,
0.9699426293373108,
0.13642297685146332,
-0.820622444152832,
-0.42499247193336487,
-0.1563122272491455,
0.11447040736675262,
0.271055668592453,
0.807975172996521,
-0.6525304913520813,
0.8026826977729797,
0.6377744078636169,
0.6332428455352783,
0.11004940420389175,
0.22506681084632874,
0.6499483585357666,
-1.0243446826934814,
0.7087309956550598,
0.0013422844931483269,
0.542023777961731,
0.248378187417984,
-0.20817019045352936,
0.19955609738826752,
0.38885876536369324,
-0.3948180675506592,
-0.6996987462043762,
0.4427911937236786,
-1.5376211404800415,
-0.30311062932014465,
1.1266552209854126,
-0.06512877345085144,
-0.5990517139434814,
-0.2248956263065338,
-0.8240854740142822,
0.016733866184949875,
-0.5185120701789856,
-0.1395905762910843,
0.6126825213432312,
-0.3270054757595062,
-0.39390406012535095,
-0.5208384990692139,
0.5959545373916626,
0.18894341588020325,
-0.995883047580719,
-0.002340662758797407,
0.8459704518318176,
0.028701160103082657,
0.26205793023109436,
0.607406497001648,
-0.16637325286865234,
0.2900141179561615,
0.34984856843948364,
-0.18042303621768951,
-0.26571086049079895,
-0.7547712326049805,
-0.2622571587562561,
0.33878961205482483,
0.02820413000881672,
-0.4243980944156647
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06435v1
|
Language Models are Alignable Decision-Makers: Dataset and Application to the Medical Triage Domain
| 2024-06-10T16:25:23 | 2024-06-10T16:25:23 |
Brian Hu, Bill Ray, Alice Leung, Amy Summerville, David Joy, Christopher Funk, Arslan Basharat
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In difficult decision-making scenarios, it is common to have conflicting
opinions among expert human decision-makers as there may not be a single right
answer. Such decisions may be guided by different attributes that can be used
to characterize an individual's decision. We introduce a novel dataset for
medical triage decision-making, labeled with a set of decision-maker attributes
(DMAs). This dataset consists of 62 scenarios, covering six different DMAs,
including ethical principles such as fairness and moral desert. We present a
novel software framework for human-aligned decision-making by utilizing these
DMAs, paving the way for trustworthy AI with better guardrails. Specifically,
we demonstrate how large language models (LLMs) can serve as ethical
decision-makers, and how their decisions can be aligned to different DMAs using
zero-shot prompting. Our experiments focus on different open-source models with
varying sizes and training techniques, such as Falcon, Mistral, and Llama 2.
Finally, we also introduce a new form of weighted self-consistency that
improves the overall quantified performance. Our results provide new research
directions in the use of LLMs as alignable decision-makers. The dataset and
open-source software are publicly available at:
https://github.com/ITM-Kitware/llm-alignable-dm.
|
[
0.03375168517231941,
-0.47405296564102173,
1.093543529510498,
0.2228885293006897,
0.07625360786914825,
0.24895575642585754,
-0.09981199353933334,
-0.32247957587242126,
-0.20438019931316376,
0.5970179438591003,
-0.4733831584453583,
-0.4723024070262909,
-0.44481712579727173,
0.1099327802658081,
-0.26735055446624756,
0.8055652379989624,
-0.002557310974225402,
0.4314599931240082,
-0.3091879189014435,
-0.4905964434146881,
-0.5963054895401001,
-0.3701620101928711,
-0.955813467502594,
-0.5547223687171936,
0.4898086488246918,
0.4563426673412323,
1.2531441450119019,
0.9521127343177795,
0.7209841012954712,
0.24726194143295288,
0.16830165684223175,
-0.10371724516153336,
-0.16416609287261963,
-0.02277086116373539,
-0.4720306992530823,
-0.5156236886978149,
-0.6819140911102295,
0.012705598957836628,
0.3513375520706177,
0.46415507793426514,
-0.38606032729148865,
0.2901199758052826,
-0.3922611474990845,
0.6875386834144592,
-0.4147246479988098,
0.013484586961567402,
-0.5039180517196655,
0.069888636469841,
-0.011611086316406727,
-0.01849556528031826,
-0.37742263078689575,
-0.6852849125862122,
0.2275501936674118,
-0.7114517092704773,
-0.2831626832485199,
0.3740220069885254,
0.7258690595626831,
0.922041654586792,
-0.1432456374168396,
-0.23529620468616486,
-0.6269062757492065,
0.9398716688156128,
-0.8759097456932068,
0.10588113963603973,
0.5349741578102112,
0.5552536249160767,
-0.05357651039958,
-0.3549726605415344,
-0.551021933555603,
0.058816492557525635,
0.026387760415673256,
0.025970319285988808,
-0.1801089346408844,
0.17761826515197754,
0.1336393654346466,
0.19982363283634186,
-0.2846662402153015,
0.6157647371292114,
-0.08838169276714325,
0.03544094040989876,
0.7710785865783691,
0.3582456409931183,
0.46058452129364014,
-0.22663137316703796,
-0.33462563157081604,
0.0215884018689394,
-0.7245579957962036,
0.03476696088910103,
0.19297650456428528,
0.20112554728984833,
-0.1553560197353363,
0.5839685797691345,
-0.11088325083255768,
0.993659257888794,
0.06356605887413025,
-0.3345251679420471,
0.1976493000984192,
-0.0029552108608186245,
-0.4073668122291565,
0.2974700331687927,
1.0179275274276733,
0.6058520078659058,
0.7898300290107727,
0.104341059923172,
0.01374749094247818,
-0.12215154618024826,
0.3126843273639679,
-0.479361891746521,
-0.23196347057819366,
0.5073103308677673,
-0.48303237557411194,
-0.8333027958869934,
-0.2084077149629593,
-0.5310268998146057,
-0.7338187098503113,
-0.4307192265987396,
0.4160807728767395,
-0.46298736333847046,
-0.3126014769077301,
0.5249602794647217,
0.17270821332931519,
0.32683897018432617,
0.19485130906105042,
-0.4989258944988251,
0.259093314409256,
0.6456973552703857,
0.7523568868637085,
0.00996359996497631,
-0.212372824549675,
-0.4436981678009033,
0.15246950089931488,
-0.44338640570640564,
0.44398659467697144,
-0.8340879678726196,
-0.1747930347919464,
-0.2974482476711273,
-0.2433176338672638,
0.18483832478523254,
-0.3710060119628906,
0.5985892415046692,
-0.36500903964042664,
0.31677764654159546,
-0.3926122784614563,
-0.4599108099937439,
-0.24738235771656036,
0.22838813066482544,
-0.6380287408828735,
0.7297182083129883,
0.24197451770305634,
-0.6584471464157104,
0.5281984806060791,
-0.6391249299049377,
-0.031298134475946426,
0.3052506148815155,
-0.6222978234291077,
-0.6705835461616516,
-0.2064472883939743,
0.26055729389190674,
0.3839901089668274,
-0.6161878108978271,
0.635924220085144,
-0.4698236882686615,
-0.08304751664400101,
0.48745548725128174,
-0.1800183206796646,
1.2023735046386719,
0.19122426211833954,
-0.057986218482255936,
-0.01629423350095749,
-0.5752343535423279,
0.17178185284137726,
0.2597673833370209,
-0.07109437137842178,
-0.5039837956428528,
0.20003029704093933,
-0.37868261337280273,
0.39261704683303833,
0.24709606170654297,
-0.622455358505249,
0.18136517703533173,
-0.14131081104278564,
0.4279837906360626,
0.7814432382583618,
-0.17674878239631653,
0.3278430998325348,
-0.6458409428596497,
0.5362658500671387,
-0.041131265461444855,
0.3609975278377533,
0.3108198642730713,
-0.3999062776565552,
-0.5444637537002563,
-0.4795401394367218,
0.3942376375198364,
0.697927713394165,
-0.6235519647598267,
0.47245022654533386,
-0.2675055265426636,
-0.1558925062417984,
-1.228209376335144,
-0.141786128282547,
0.44903072714805603,
0.918647825717926,
0.316346675157547,
0.30858853459358215,
-0.5115317702293396,
-1.0591496229171753,
-0.1354803889989853,
-0.44020920991897583,
-0.02372373454272747,
0.33415332436561584,
0.17887839674949646,
-0.12338737398386002,
1.24019455909729,
-0.4982210695743561,
-0.16879086196422577,
0.0756542831659317,
-0.05222557485103607,
0.08119385689496994,
0.3668151795864105,
0.6140236854553223,
-0.5894562602043152,
-0.2946535646915436,
0.03246302902698517,
-0.9879624843597412,
-0.40480294823646545,
-0.043499428778886795,
-0.14416667819023132,
-0.004182817414402962,
0.2644833028316498,
-0.18356522917747498,
0.05451417341828346,
0.5236667990684509,
-0.23448802530765533,
0.1796223521232605,
-0.24841812252998352,
0.12040180712938309,
-1.2991831302642822,
0.14008177816867828,
-0.036264799535274506,
-0.45439645648002625,
-0.6449417471885681,
-0.21374693512916565,
0.08264662325382233,
0.06823674589395523,
-0.2877991497516632,
0.713534951210022,
-0.21867859363555908,
-0.15992431342601776,
-0.1889510601758957,
0.06334597617387772,
-0.02980816550552845,
0.13677653670310974,
0.10479201376438141,
0.7201775312423706,
0.6952866315841675,
-0.3781758248806,
0.30954819917678833,
0.6046581864356995,
-0.27425459027290344,
1.171621561050415,
-0.7588321566581726,
-0.020219041034579277,
-0.19601264595985413,
0.007988417521119118,
-0.493906170129776,
-0.21655453741550446,
0.2558326721191406,
-0.24526944756507874,
0.014105724170804024,
-0.12669968605041504,
-0.341827929019928,
-0.37331491708755493,
-0.15972335636615753,
0.5143026113510132,
0.606392502784729,
-0.3545510172843933,
0.43742549419403076,
0.6582010984420776,
-0.46372494101524353,
-0.7717505693435669,
-0.6262730956077576,
0.14921404421329498,
-0.24743956327438354,
-0.40485212206840515,
0.2192280888557434,
-0.08684568107128143,
-0.5235887169837952,
0.10860268026590347,
0.19770872592926025,
-0.0700916051864624,
0.011339298449456692,
0.3935968279838562,
0.6357715725898743,
0.02209465391933918,
0.37708666920661926,
-0.19977207481861115,
-0.20978306233882904,
0.004105060826987028,
-0.049185287207365036,
0.2514055669307709,
-0.3509240448474884,
-0.5597162842750549,
-0.3760286867618561,
0.28563186526298523,
0.6254433393478394,
-0.4929869472980499,
0.5154167413711548,
0.18360760807991028,
-0.4982638955116272,
0.04627729579806328,
-0.6384763121604919,
0.15410491824150085,
-0.4456423223018646,
0.1567772924900055,
0.05335767939686775,
-0.8069578409194946,
0.40151622891426086,
0.1295316517353058,
0.2935152053833008,
0.37307068705558777,
0.5300177931785583,
-0.27720391750335693,
1.30436110496521,
0.493409663438797,
-0.15256623923778534,
0.13513223826885223,
0.23545964062213898,
0.24641507863998413,
-0.7058645486831665,
-0.1809641569852829,
-0.4535784423351288,
-0.41214004158973694,
-0.46001678705215454,
-0.2926141321659088,
0.585974931716919,
-0.19579851627349854,
-0.645205557346344,
-0.24318811297416687,
-0.6549820303916931,
0.5844584703445435,
0.23152472078800201,
0.09221915155649185,
0.40209364891052246,
-0.33938756585121155,
-0.08820906281471252,
0.1971738636493683,
-0.7600610256195068,
-0.7317200303077698,
0.9557638168334961,
0.44490405917167664,
0.9333775639533997,
-0.08412422239780426,
0.6546364426612854,
0.19435900449752808,
0.19284173846244812,
-0.7726527452468872,
0.4219089448451996,
-0.17657867074012756,
-0.5579949021339417,
-0.3510136306285858,
-0.5540158152580261,
-0.7580968737602234,
-0.2627774477005005,
-0.36486631631851196,
-0.607826828956604,
0.09613531082868576,
0.025311823934316635,
-0.8134220242500305,
0.3717469871044159,
-0.5484188199043274,
0.5036932229995728,
-0.6644796133041382,
-0.011765260249376297,
0.03125663846731186,
-0.8604586124420166,
0.18368269503116608,
-0.20426276326179504,
0.2022312730550766,
-0.4777858257293701,
-0.12246187031269073,
0.5885058641433716,
-0.31053435802459717,
0.7089504599571228,
-0.09932535886764526,
-0.03215298429131508,
0.11476077884435654,
0.05334683507680893,
0.20506471395492554,
0.00021221788483671844,
-0.37410062551498413,
0.2518492043018341,
0.32396283745765686,
-0.10352630168199539,
-0.41666683554649353,
0.7463828325271606,
-0.796163022518158,
-0.6338521242141724,
-0.5383318066596985,
-0.8210197687149048,
-0.4326043128967285,
0.37908104062080383,
-0.0808805450797081,
0.28619781136512756,
-0.17967645823955536,
0.06179887428879738,
0.635933518409729,
-0.25879618525505066,
0.27055323123931885,
0.8544017672538757,
-0.2962135374546051,
-0.28834453225135803,
0.7983015179634094,
0.08778073638677597,
0.279933363199234,
0.26728856563568115,
0.4470828175544739,
-0.25820842385292053,
-0.4488275945186615,
-0.549336850643158,
0.2863890528678894,
-0.4384649097919464,
-0.5627322196960449,
-0.40441644191741943,
-0.5002489686012268,
0.20517240464687347,
-0.3740079700946808,
-0.2433197945356369,
-0.37922486662864685,
-0.0820026695728302,
-0.23452220857143402,
0.6821494102478027,
0.9078221321105957,
0.06073550134897232,
0.22646808624267578,
-0.7197531461715698,
0.2561706304550171,
0.24849621951580048,
0.7396575212478638,
-0.22008463740348816,
-0.035712745040655136,
0.07857395708560944,
0.2568223774433136,
0.06655881553888321,
-0.8065395355224609,
0.011777795851230621,
-0.15398147702217102,
0.6291214227676392,
0.22019550204277039,
0.24645312130451202,
0.42281943559646606,
-0.36486420035362244,
0.37644830346107483,
0.0952918604016304,
-0.8626177906990051,
0.4301120638847351,
-0.36350005865097046,
0.2841896116733551,
0.8732496500015259,
0.23043081164360046,
-0.5470950603485107,
-0.2653423249721527,
-0.49079301953315735,
-0.29874923825263977,
0.7900810241699219,
0.2175871580839157,
-0.45836108922958374,
0.16303333640098572,
0.38362282514572144,
0.024404581636190414,
0.260037899017334,
-0.48041632771492004,
-0.007060033734887838,
-0.024106480181217194,
-0.8611129522323608,
0.1008574590086937,
-0.03949330747127533,
-0.574882447719574,
0.0018187963869422674,
0.5481969118118286,
-0.15322399139404297,
-0.1560761034488678,
0.09127258509397507,
0.1714753359556198,
-0.24757131934165955,
0.43758106231689453,
0.34192797541618347,
0.7081629633903503,
-0.2805463671684265,
-0.05217672511935234,
0.15979667007923126,
-0.2030879408121109,
0.36577436327934265,
0.11049053817987442,
-0.2839381694793701,
-0.4802778959274292,
0.07531479746103287,
0.502652645111084,
-0.018842782825231552,
-0.6326799988746643,
0.5780994296073914,
-0.26067647337913513,
0.003266461193561554,
-0.18409763276576996,
0.006252477411180735,
0.007055799942463636,
0.2593124210834503,
-0.08886101096868515,
-0.10117951780557632,
-0.054766759276390076,
-0.12560655176639557,
0.08291421830654144,
0.5573698282241821,
-0.47272321581840515,
0.07762756198644638,
0.5171968936920166,
0.39855414628982544,
-0.426162451505661,
0.5598559975624084,
0.03515269607305527,
-0.24273298680782318,
0.5394625067710876,
0.25805309414863586,
0.8226433396339417,
-0.3806706368923187,
0.5075497627258301,
0.06495872139930725,
0.22627146542072296,
-0.2956041395664215,
0.45965027809143066,
0.25746315717697144,
-0.7992715835571289,
-0.3060861825942993,
-0.5454437136650085,
-0.6672075986862183,
-0.014894089661538601,
-0.810262143611908,
0.3420755863189697,
-0.5577979683876038,
-0.3017781972885132,
-0.0038532656617462635,
-0.1239941343665123,
-0.6941866278648376,
0.30596214532852173,
0.027340559288859367,
0.715362012386322,
-0.5710920691490173,
0.6529257893562317,
0.6511907577514648,
-0.3350878953933716,
-0.844694197177887,
-0.11605893075466156,
0.15886548161506653,
-1.1942548751831055,
0.14580678939819336,
-0.10863702744245529,
-0.2851153314113617,
-0.091151662170887,
-0.49269673228263855,
-0.7873643636703491,
1.3246146440505981,
0.5808161497116089,
-0.6466906666755676,
-0.2892261743545532,
0.3239113986492157,
0.4403679370880127,
-0.562821626663208,
0.11392897367477417,
0.7695346474647522,
0.5793908834457397,
-0.0009398903930559754,
-0.9970607757568359,
0.1694457083940506,
0.0933229848742485,
-0.164280965924263,
0.34740719199180603,
-0.6204786896705627,
0.6287651658058167,
-0.46073704957962036,
-0.06736882030963898,
-0.03300470486283302,
-0.03258988633751869,
0.4867144525051117,
0.1320383995771408,
0.5079694390296936,
0.6755526065826416,
1.0736497640609741,
-0.09469098597764969,
0.9877334833145142,
-0.4180452525615692,
0.07741980999708176,
1.1513233184814453,
-0.4996922016143799,
0.5702177882194519,
0.31476372480392456,
0.09377393871545792,
0.4554552435874939,
0.3844227194786072,
-0.023737477138638496,
0.2452622503042221,
-0.12074907124042511,
-0.08203449100255966,
-0.47013190388679504,
-0.42115306854248047,
-0.26398995518684387,
0.6758785247802734,
0.35846975445747375,
-0.48000866174697876,
-0.12240014970302582,
-0.295230507850647,
0.25768154859542847,
0.036708950996398926,
-0.41694220900535583,
0.9193686246871948,
0.09487015008926392,
-0.5648771524429321,
0.3081169128417969,
-0.194976344704628,
0.20089034736156464,
-0.5765090584754944,
-0.04609476774930954,
0.27470678091049194,
0.05442201718688011,
-0.41140103340148926,
-1.3982049226760864,
0.1602058857679367,
0.10860669612884521,
-0.26686161756515503,
-0.3066537380218506,
0.5227991938591003,
-0.40283524990081787,
-0.7375619411468506,
0.03959839418530464,
0.5763364434242249,
-0.20100344717502594,
0.2362428605556488,
-0.7681173086166382,
-0.0666670948266983,
-0.05133156478404999,
0.26939699053764343,
0.06085773929953575,
0.3430657982826233,
-0.24083839356899261,
0.9442086815834045,
0.4293646812438965,
0.24487890303134918,
-0.3959053158760071,
0.21922095119953156,
0.5936415195465088,
-0.6837899684906006,
-0.355152428150177,
-0.953028678894043,
0.3498096168041229,
-0.28285279870033264,
-0.26251333951950073,
0.4491400122642517,
0.21641606092453003,
0.3994476795196533,
0.3193054795265198,
1.0328929424285889,
0.16200418770313263,
0.6003981828689575,
-0.535605251789093,
0.8508987426757812,
-0.35735487937927246,
0.1457468867301941,
-0.06414254754781723,
-0.3566722273826599,
-0.27270275354385376,
0.5641318559646606,
-0.49479445815086365,
0.16600610315799713,
0.29622817039489746,
0.6541858315467834,
0.19180157780647278,
0.055589333176612854,
0.23169870674610138,
0.1778690367937088,
0.4343813359737396,
0.6395646929740906,
0.778744637966156,
-0.0008708488312549889,
0.298555463552475,
-0.10793215781450272,
-0.3970455825328827,
-0.15113864839076996,
-1.177599310874939,
-0.8771453499794006,
-0.49841099977493286,
-0.20052146911621094,
0.008357305079698563,
-0.03528920188546181,
1.110477328300476,
0.6941260695457458,
-0.5722227096557617,
-0.07876121252775192,
0.037493038922548294,
0.2850208878517151,
-0.07036129385232925,
-0.1283489167690277,
0.1644393801689148,
-0.061341360211372375,
-0.35298827290534973,
0.12837062776088715,
0.4796936511993408,
0.12274719774723053,
-0.32779330015182495,
-0.1404137760400772,
-0.25455382466316223,
0.3660559058189392,
0.21528911590576172,
0.2856961190700531,
-0.7661909461021423,
-0.4188275635242462,
0.000956226431299001,
-0.24716156721115112,
0.23215317726135254,
0.6232172846794128,
-0.6779496669769287,
0.6691755056381226,
0.18686820566654205,
0.7804276347160339,
-0.19188202917575836,
0.292413592338562,
0.9864761233329773,
-0.47008994221687317,
-0.27227669954299927,
0.5400592088699341,
0.5020646452903748,
0.6483088731765747,
-0.43296414613723755,
0.4538419544696808,
-0.46739983558654785,
-0.9218589663505554,
-0.648466944694519,
0.3252406120300293,
-0.880851149559021,
-0.07527231425046921,
1.1469806432724,
0.15085335075855255,
-0.1109565943479538,
-0.06913456320762634,
-0.4874814450740814,
0.0500129871070385,
-0.4396076500415802,
0.8639276027679443,
0.768699049949646,
-0.17313288152217865,
-0.03969772160053253,
-0.38707926869392395,
0.8126983642578125,
0.3906089663505554,
-0.958349883556366,
0.12223895639181137,
0.635461151599884,
0.44871002435684204,
0.03999217972159386,
0.6550809741020203,
-0.2590078115463257,
0.24485528469085693,
-0.5823501348495483,
0.02764703519642353,
-0.2815563976764679,
-0.34252139925956726,
-0.47228795289993286,
-0.22120985388755798,
0.27823275327682495,
-0.20142458379268646
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06665v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06665v1
|
Enrolment-based personalisation for improving individual-level fairness in speech emotion recognition
| 2024-06-10T16:01:05 | 2024-06-10T16:01:05 |
Andreas Triantafyllopoulos, Björn Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The expression of emotion is highly individualistic. However, contemporary
speech emotion recognition (SER) systems typically rely on population-level
models that adopt a `one-size-fits-all' approach for predicting emotion.
Moreover, standard evaluation practices measure performance also on the
population level, thus failing to characterise how models work across different
speakers. In the present contribution, we present a new method for capitalising
on individual differences to adapt an SER model to each new speaker using a
minimal set of enrolment utterances. In addition, we present novel evaluation
schemes for measuring fairness across different speakers. Our findings show
that aggregated evaluation metrics may obfuscate fairness issues on the
individual-level, which are uncovered by our evaluation, and that our proposed
method can improve performance both in aggregated and disaggregated terms.
|
[
-0.40090930461883545,
0.04859284311532974,
0.1669081449508667,
0.26373568177223206,
-0.008951686322689056,
-0.009438618086278439,
-0.1684829145669937,
-0.26655083894729614,
0.3932742476463318,
0.20653505623340607,
-0.25008222460746765,
-0.3597941994667053,
-0.5885015726089478,
0.3753160238265991,
-0.002585718408226967,
0.6293166875839233,
0.39106398820877075,
0.1812441647052765,
-0.4054005742073059,
-0.5050575733184814,
-0.3186355233192444,
-0.7491640448570251,
-0.7603330016136169,
-0.24316096305847168,
0.3083185851573944,
0.5826336145401001,
0.21274201571941376,
0.08938629925251007,
0.42248058319091797,
0.3513900339603424,
-0.48973649740219116,
-0.14670291543006897,
-0.5607603192329407,
0.04250989854335785,
-0.1419212967157364,
-0.34264275431632996,
-0.43508201837539673,
0.04065070301294327,
0.8298919796943665,
0.5690410137176514,
-0.5192765593528748,
0.11650720983743668,
0.2141643464565277,
0.8084669709205627,
-0.979221761226654,
-0.005473219323903322,
-0.6871017813682556,
0.5299961566925049,
-0.2535687983036041,
-0.19942308962345123,
-0.4261164963245392,
-0.3322764039039612,
0.1936739981174469,
-0.22570984065532684,
0.14197275042533875,
-0.018437188118696213,
0.09546320885419846,
0.3123292326927185,
-0.33601388335227966,
-0.2890184223651886,
-0.5510157346725464,
0.753757894039154,
-1.0294909477233887,
0.3349914252758026,
0.2919587790966034,
0.5313052535057068,
0.1157408207654953,
-0.40977445244789124,
-0.4744895100593567,
-0.1070508062839508,
-0.14402653276920319,
0.32018935680389404,
-0.3900371789932251,
0.2205384373664856,
0.3182376027107239,
0.39598360657691956,
-0.2941133975982666,
0.32507961988449097,
-0.1131431981921196,
-0.16206489503383636,
0.6366000175476074,
0.1465553343296051,
0.12588760256767273,
-0.1577245146036148,
-0.12601417303085327,
0.06292219460010529,
-0.2175695300102234,
0.5681527256965637,
0.6860957145690918,
0.5811821222305298,
-0.30342569947242737,
0.26585155725479126,
-0.3438974916934967,
0.3665640652179718,
0.44346582889556885,
-0.13259437680244446,
0.5538284778594971,
0.47404301166534424,
-0.22988538444042206,
0.6183861494064331,
0.4531233012676239,
0.12917587161064148,
0.22733692824840546,
-0.15926282107830048,
-0.21601565182209015,
0.012754717841744423,
0.026838991791009903,
-0.6801058650016785,
0.14245137572288513,
0.2309497892856598,
-0.5467743277549744,
-0.1702120304107666,
-0.05730797350406647,
-0.9997135996818542,
-0.9050295352935791,
-0.07040847837924957,
0.5621516704559326,
-0.09613332897424698,
-0.22928239405155182,
0.28076303005218506,
-0.08155257999897003,
0.05789395049214363,
0.24170807003974915,
-1.0968416929244995,
0.5132774114608765,
0.48254987597465515,
0.6588395237922668,
-0.08639703691005707,
-0.014635210856795311,
-0.8823357820510864,
0.0067574153654277325,
0.10807211697101593,
0.5317261815071106,
-0.920142650604248,
-0.4869915246963501,
0.011334656737744808,
-0.23855993151664734,
-0.017514556646347046,
-0.6401119828224182,
0.4449995458126068,
-0.15763182938098907,
0.45370790362358093,
-0.33691564202308655,
-0.5559399724006653,
-0.07544039189815521,
-0.2695144712924957,
-0.3590945601463318,
0.42375239729881287,
0.14030076563358307,
-0.7696979641914368,
0.5341131687164307,
-0.7951337099075317,
-0.4365112781524658,
0.1411380022764206,
-0.223840594291687,
-0.5252236127853394,
0.48798736929893494,
0.2782646715641022,
0.1584700495004654,
-0.029822204262018204,
-0.12610433995723724,
-0.31682392954826355,
-0.40733855962753296,
0.29299870133399963,
-0.502998948097229,
0.3840344250202179,
0.26888227462768555,
-0.33707502484321594,
0.10346656292676926,
-0.902446985244751,
-0.24096176028251648,
-0.3973805606365204,
-0.19451983273029327,
-0.3782515525817871,
0.287092387676239,
-0.16877596080303192,
0.08855586498975754,
0.38728010654449463,
-0.75922030210495,
-0.22649943828582764,
-0.6916471123695374,
0.15408828854560852,
1.270090103149414,
-0.1832062005996704,
0.5900272727012634,
-0.27167272567749023,
0.6436797976493835,
0.2738972008228302,
0.25038182735443115,
0.09673038870096207,
-0.46668410301208496,
-0.5837090015411377,
-0.4810708165168762,
0.30842530727386475,
0.3475184738636017,
-0.07493878155946732,
0.41414809226989746,
-0.09954721480607986,
-0.018416566774249077,
-0.9644384384155273,
-0.18567930161952972,
0.3694201409816742,
0.45015132427215576,
0.09274005144834518,
-0.8148328065872192,
-0.4997207820415497,
-0.9124583005905151,
-0.5334092974662781,
-0.2638052999973297,
-0.07061094045639038,
0.6430636644363403,
-0.024522989988327026,
-0.12837372720241547,
1.1036616563796997,
-0.09536448121070862,
-0.35850948095321655,
0.11937857419252396,
0.20490407943725586,
0.10734350979328156,
0.4145510196685791,
0.49048104882240295,
-0.8556081056594849,
-0.6268207430839539,
0.13476768136024475,
-0.4379177391529083,
-0.3328770399093628,
0.10340265184640884,
0.037889692932367325,
0.02651682309806347,
-0.06081036850810051,
0.20121531188488007,
0.681509792804718,
0.45083847641944885,
-0.6369056701660156,
0.1694020926952362,
-0.20688678324222565,
0.618780791759491,
-0.6374461054801941,
-0.3212684392929077,
0.08996833860874176,
-0.3165947198867798,
-0.6672618985176086,
-0.35192105174064636,
-0.1981874704360962,
-0.18344618380069733,
-0.6616713404655457,
0.722139835357666,
-0.08371742814779282,
-0.5217605829238892,
-0.1591877043247223,
0.29084092378616333,
-0.38913586735725403,
0.5160115957260132,
-0.3912979066371918,
0.6247897744178772,
0.5968023538589478,
-0.6384468078613281,
-0.02543763257563114,
0.4409191608428955,
-0.24402697384357452,
0.9446451663970947,
-0.28762686252593994,
0.4350074827671051,
-0.5146500468254089,
-0.09864936769008636,
-1.0611155033111572,
-0.29912906885147095,
-0.04965677112340927,
-0.6702712178230286,
0.11228810250759125,
-0.20744898915290833,
0.09444896876811981,
-0.1101410835981369,
-0.1294703185558319,
0.46555984020233154,
0.9802708029747009,
-0.7752601504325867,
1.0134215354919434,
0.5727490782737732,
-0.5052717328071594,
-0.42076748609542847,
-0.5203816890716553,
0.06668922305107117,
-0.6153762936592102,
-0.5641329288482666,
0.3326112926006317,
-0.03303604945540428,
-0.35836297273635864,
-0.2623176872730255,
-0.2927441895008087,
-0.17198508977890015,
0.1439683735370636,
0.25924256443977356,
-0.3886491060256958,
0.17634160816669464,
0.23365065455436707,
0.15489551424980164,
0.0469331219792366,
-0.2580367624759674,
0.11083542555570602,
0.429963082075119,
-0.13299785554409027,
-0.49396735429763794,
-0.7142617106437683,
0.4533770978450775,
0.37553998827934265,
-0.48385143280029297,
0.49219468235969543,
0.7485828995704651,
-0.5184640884399414,
-0.19746193289756775,
-0.6862331032752991,
-0.07304593175649643,
-0.5501244068145752,
0.39914649724960327,
-0.5333928465843201,
-1.120393991470337,
0.748500645160675,
-0.09757628291845322,
0.02452501468360424,
0.2788589894771576,
0.5747671127319336,
-0.15553493797779083,
1.2837642431259155,
0.8292804956436157,
-0.27032220363616943,
0.6122101545333862,
0.4273199439048767,
0.13927248120307922,
-0.8757719993591309,
-0.23817533254623413,
-0.7463849186897278,
-0.5663452744483948,
-0.7603914141654968,
-0.06494901329278946,
0.4885365962982178,
-0.0926654115319252,
-0.5402900576591492,
-0.38484427332878113,
-0.5149812698364258,
0.40969979763031006,
0.41548657417297363,
0.28419172763824463,
0.21521075069904327,
0.2827884554862976,
0.09895314276218414,
-0.3193948566913605,
-0.5447076559066772,
-0.5128709077835083,
0.8677611947059631,
0.20066964626312256,
0.7532786726951599,
0.505282998085022,
1.0123441219329834,
0.7291640639305115,
0.4996381998062134,
-0.5394811034202576,
0.42190197110176086,
-0.8053557276725769,
-0.17020224034786224,
-0.4447508156299591,
-0.82106614112854,
-0.9233881235122681,
0.24293363094329834,
0.054381467401981354,
-1.1867985725402832,
0.7252882719039917,
0.2524400055408478,
-0.5012152194976807,
0.20658284425735474,
-0.7272989749908447,
0.6390249133110046,
-0.04562228545546532,
0.04357904940843582,
-0.38161399960517883,
-0.21868927776813507,
0.04879969358444214,
-0.19488641619682312,
0.36210697889328003,
-0.39397329092025757,
0.1326342523097992,
0.9528411030769348,
-0.25285089015960693,
0.8804677128791809,
-0.7242159843444824,
0.10532605648040771,
0.13061942160129547,
-0.045113470405340195,
0.3122032582759857,
-0.1345655620098114,
-0.4927724301815033,
-0.13439108431339264,
-0.2631397843360901,
-0.36070960760116577,
-0.8492007255554199,
0.5306174159049988,
-0.8151669502258301,
-0.5566702485084534,
-0.27799591422080994,
-0.24076086282730103,
-0.5875860452651978,
-0.3112848997116089,
-0.08657997846603394,
0.545978307723999,
-0.356784462928772,
0.16615581512451172,
0.5133297443389893,
-0.6771958470344543,
0.21042205393314362,
0.8174909353256226,
0.03818186745047569,
-0.47253260016441345,
0.8344165086746216,
-0.15812049806118011,
0.2340032011270523,
0.23335228860378265,
0.401494562625885,
-0.48110106587409973,
-0.1242423728108406,
0.04539700970053673,
-0.1602301150560379,
-0.7791712284088135,
-0.09134756028652191,
-0.4874074161052704,
0.11681491136550903,
-0.801414430141449,
-0.21008378267288208,
-0.09452977031469345,
-0.43683135509490967,
-0.12598632276058197,
0.14046531915664673,
0.44586503505706787,
0.5922698974609375,
-0.4681810736656189,
0.5452636480331421,
-0.34509027004241943,
0.33796513080596924,
0.7858351469039917,
0.7476543188095093,
0.15206214785575867,
-1.1647169589996338,
-0.14305941760540009,
0.15009421110153198,
-0.06285876035690308,
-0.7580203413963318,
0.42731019854545593,
0.6522268056869507,
0.7625780701637268,
0.34966111183166504,
0.08819784969091415,
0.7514985203742981,
-0.6254101395606995,
0.6415309906005859,
0.5215098857879639,
-1.402897834777832,
0.5895841717720032,
0.1322752982378006,
0.13211604952812195,
0.6208853721618652,
0.13256892561912537,
-0.9009665250778198,
-0.17626959085464478,
-0.41472795605659485,
-0.8415116667747498,
0.719237208366394,
0.22952760756015778,
0.1389312595129013,
0.2095940262079239,
0.2981376349925995,
0.06654809415340424,
0.20504643023014069,
-0.6307399868965149,
-0.06103348359465599,
0.012170511297881603,
-0.6833970546722412,
-0.21179631352424622,
-0.147427499294281,
-0.056457046419382095,
-0.19098049402236938,
0.4926892817020416,
-0.06332787126302719,
0.41036349534988403,
0.21829067170619965,
-0.1214183047413826,
-0.098823182284832,
0.572995126247406,
0.15025117993354797,
0.23542481660842896,
-0.39482372999191284,
-0.22835586965084076,
0.3010544776916504,
-0.20787937939167023,
0.4544362723827362,
0.0024745112750679255,
0.05639457702636719,
0.07235726714134216,
-0.038436152040958405,
1.0503281354904175,
0.2593821585178375,
-0.6480704545974731,
0.5649130344390869,
-0.17524680495262146,
0.08524009585380554,
-0.21316853165626526,
-0.00025363275199197233,
-0.33136340975761414,
0.3947221040725708,
0.20184801518917084,
0.016223879531025887,
0.46636974811553955,
-0.6039299368858337,
0.26592501997947693,
0.25233814120292664,
-0.7557427883148193,
-0.006253709085285664,
0.6935768127441406,
0.36524462699890137,
-0.6403323411941528,
0.20786908268928528,
-0.504143238067627,
-0.4142155647277832,
0.6740078926086426,
0.33090445399284363,
1.3669887781143188,
-0.7419953346252441,
0.25913527607917786,
0.1377439647912979,
0.03034457005560398,
0.06029442697763443,
0.3859654664993286,
0.0025459304451942444,
-0.8034467101097107,
-0.12541626393795013,
-0.8711907863616943,
-0.6940375566482544,
-0.41996797919273376,
-0.9446627497673035,
0.06551449000835419,
-0.29444974660873413,
-0.25702983140945435,
-0.02385517582297325,
-0.2540757954120636,
-0.9697000980377197,
0.3302355706691742,
0.5508372783660889,
0.577041745185852,
-0.6583922505378723,
0.28225094079971313,
0.6390089392662048,
-0.217561736702919,
-0.41019299626350403,
-0.045419059693813324,
0.007670855615288019,
-0.5618528723716736,
0.45600003004074097,
0.11483122408390045,
-0.18135522305965424,
0.013938899151980877,
-0.274784117937088,
-0.5590053200721741,
0.738042414188385,
0.34522223472595215,
-0.8175702691078186,
0.2409925013780594,
0.1921699196100235,
0.5445078611373901,
-0.6603831052780151,
0.35953181982040405,
0.6801096200942993,
0.24914097785949707,
-0.15601253509521484,
-1.0588740110397339,
-0.366496205329895,
-0.14447493851184845,
0.03146296367049217,
-0.18838533759117126,
-0.6882659792900085,
0.7072028517723083,
-0.04245995357632637,
-0.3314131200313568,
-0.0860418975353241,
0.5054157972335815,
0.21402987837791443,
0.4302474558353424,
0.9061998128890991,
0.4838111698627472,
1.253933072090149,
-0.10239733010530472,
0.9061954021453857,
-0.18620404601097107,
0.31340786814689636,
1.2278386354446411,
-0.6071900129318237,
0.7532845735549927,
0.0806422084569931,
-0.49273043870925903,
0.27467823028564453,
0.48025527596473694,
0.30729106068611145,
0.7054433822631836,
0.5253770351409912,
-0.6778680682182312,
-0.15391193330287933,
-0.13286404311656952,
-0.2353987693786621,
0.6617411375045776,
0.22192621231079102,
-0.053358837962150574,
0.030535206198692322,
0.42279502749443054,
-0.45632681250572205,
0.24794714152812958,
-0.7674056887626648,
0.9564296007156372,
0.10486035794019699,
-0.04374950751662254,
0.3448178768157959,
0.11630312353372574,
1.059888243675232,
-0.4583151042461395,
0.24424302577972412,
-0.5622087121009827,
0.0613577775657177,
-0.3718399107456207,
-0.38554617762565613,
-0.12675371766090393,
0.45603588223457336,
-0.13683395087718964,
-0.015279469080269337,
0.4950965344905853,
-0.5544164180755615,
-0.4829229712486267,
0.27744773030281067,
0.23777350783348083,
0.3476836681365967,
0.016763119027018547,
-0.39708375930786133,
-0.13607564568519592,
0.09563962370157242,
0.12034761160612106,
0.4573679268360138,
0.6491660475730896,
0.2921801805496216,
0.6504477262496948,
0.07651682198047638,
0.21144135296344757,
0.20014050602912903,
0.7614925503730774,
0.555432915687561,
-0.683181881904602,
-0.9049571752548218,
-0.6965169906616211,
0.7464121580123901,
-0.22519369423389435,
-0.25463035702705383,
0.5369927287101746,
0.46136239171028137,
0.7008638978004456,
0.07663804292678833,
0.8805558085441589,
0.1325996369123459,
0.6519775986671448,
-0.1749502569437027,
0.620035707950592,
-0.7090907692909241,
0.16065627336502075,
-0.6939786076545715,
-0.5470346808433533,
0.059758543968200684,
0.8014460802078247,
-0.2513989210128784,
0.05900721997022629,
0.10408417135477066,
0.6948606967926025,
0.15314266085624695,
0.1672838032245636,
0.6899022459983826,
0.3529089093208313,
0.3265019357204437,
0.58116215467453,
0.7954725027084351,
-0.08654461055994034,
0.08862756192684174,
-0.0933431088924408,
-0.511537492275238,
-0.13243365287780762,
-0.6263489127159119,
-0.577680766582489,
-0.5013771057128906,
-0.3815770149230957,
-0.2238989621400833,
0.41537195444107056,
1.0379638671875,
0.590821385383606,
-0.9276201128959656,
-0.36389172077178955,
0.40686821937561035,
-0.047304488718509674,
-0.05893811210989952,
-0.22171369194984436,
0.10439427196979523,
-0.4980102777481079,
-0.7748866081237793,
0.21036341786384583,
0.5066299438476562,
0.02279287949204445,
-0.13357149064540863,
-0.29949697852134705,
0.36336153745651245,
0.29283326864242554,
0.6501064896583557,
0.2099105715751648,
-0.5084784030914307,
-0.3234023153781891,
-0.6881994605064392,
0.29445621371269226,
0.4082649350166321,
0.7403477430343628,
-0.8336082696914673,
0.7085817456245422,
0.22073878347873688,
0.6709826588630676,
0.358148992061615,
0.18939253687858582,
0.3972628116607666,
-0.9037137627601624,
0.4647122919559479,
0.5976463556289673,
0.48446691036224365,
0.4973337650299072,
-0.4271104037761688,
0.35702207684516907,
0.11135560274124146,
-0.5610051155090332,
-0.979505181312561,
0.3135475814342499,
-0.7632040977478027,
0.15756069123744965,
0.7115201950073242,
-0.2378665655851364,
0.10180049389600754,
0.19167031347751617,
-0.06340263783931732,
0.06888175755739212,
-0.6738578677177429,
1.0221623182296753,
0.4878001809120178,
-0.20244832336902618,
-0.024084705859422684,
-0.16875022649765015,
0.4559408128261566,
0.49423083662986755,
-0.7947995662689209,
-0.10481468588113785,
0.44369199872016907,
0.15132737159729004,
-0.22732572257518768,
0.9545965194702148,
-0.19928745925426483,
0.2928573787212372,
-0.11189229041337967,
0.2484797090291977,
0.48548218607902527,
-0.13805659115314484,
-0.9064530730247498,
0.08966387063264847,
-0.07766129821538925,
-0.09418832510709763
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06406v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06406v2
|
Controlling Emotion in Text-to-Speech with Natural Language Prompts
| 2024-06-10T15:58:42 | 2024-06-11T19:54:35 |
Thomas Bott, Florian Lux, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In recent years, prompting has quickly become one of the standard ways of
steering the outputs of generative machine learning models, due to its
intuitive use of natural language. In this work, we propose a system
conditioned on embeddings derived from an emotionally rich text that serves as
prompt. Thereby, a joint representation of speaker and prompt embeddings is
integrated at several points within a transformer-based architecture. Our
approach is trained on merged emotional speech and text datasets and varies
prompts in each training iteration to increase the generalization capabilities
of the model. Objective and subjective evaluation results demonstrate the
ability of the conditioned synthesis system to accurately transfer the emotions
present in a prompt to speech. At the same time, precise tractability of
speaker identities as well as overall high speech quality and intelligibility
are maintained.
|
[
-0.6323830485343933,
-0.8692117929458618,
0.5774878263473511,
0.5459176301956177,
-0.3183787763118744,
-0.029605770483613014,
-0.527032196521759,
0.07037190347909927,
0.24014103412628174,
0.2504030466079712,
-0.6989272832870483,
-0.4259822964668274,
-0.5569581389427185,
0.6066327095031738,
-0.17945866286754608,
1.0809943675994873,
-0.07242952287197113,
-0.008977081626653671,
-0.1592286229133606,
-0.03381963446736336,
-0.6798518300056458,
-0.557168185710907,
-0.5428632497787476,
-0.3710697293281555,
0.5470812320709229,
0.41547155380249023,
0.6254597902297974,
0.28430989384651184,
-0.14455750584602356,
0.3310917615890503,
-0.021364863961935043,
0.03612125292420387,
-0.268852561712265,
0.8429934978485107,
-0.09622412174940109,
-0.31892943382263184,
-0.0008349471027031541,
-0.0473768375813961,
0.42191046476364136,
0.24102485179901123,
-0.1472891867160797,
-0.4564080238342285,
0.22602246701717377,
0.5540313124656677,
-0.538888692855835,
0.08922646939754486,
-0.30870750546455383,
0.4746360778808594,
0.2860358655452728,
-0.43715420365333557,
-0.9192457795143127,
-0.4527132511138916,
0.3582402765750885,
-0.44008123874664307,
0.08171027898788452,
0.07960055023431778,
0.5437977313995361,
0.7189265489578247,
-0.4653439223766327,
-0.46341031789779663,
-0.5266945958137512,
0.49483034014701843,
-0.17116855084896088,
0.44221824407577515,
0.3173545300960541,
0.27365052700042725,
0.09203805774450302,
-0.4556540250778198,
-0.6272051334381104,
-0.2779823839664459,
-0.11893153935670853,
0.3936455547809601,
-0.4779743552207947,
0.28587955236434937,
0.15331262350082397,
-0.06334704905748367,
-0.5014913082122803,
0.11197225004434586,
0.0746176466345787,
-0.19117210805416107,
0.3609039783477783,
0.09806232899427414,
0.6068421006202698,
-0.4113146662712097,
-0.2510054111480713,
-0.3818022906780243,
-0.3145603835582733,
0.12400101870298386,
0.3184914290904999,
0.6313262581825256,
-0.34483182430267334,
0.6078734397888184,
0.009737146086990833,
0.503218948841095,
0.3323732614517212,
0.36039426922798157,
0.18786993622779846,
0.22653692960739136,
-0.40996095538139343,
0.41273897886276245,
0.9222725629806519,
0.45129743218421936,
0.5492208003997803,
-0.20640838146209717,
-0.2272765040397644,
0.3554536998271942,
0.37816664576530457,
-0.7770439982414246,
-0.12125365436077118,
0.3619573414325714,
-0.16453954577445984,
-0.09541268646717072,
-0.04741751030087471,
-1.0721549987792969,
-0.46793434023857117,
-0.5757647752761841,
0.43509137630462646,
-0.5684981942176819,
0.11877861618995667,
-0.12026377767324448,
-0.29408207535743713,
-0.024385761469602585,
0.18734386563301086,
-1.0659048557281494,
0.03611548990011215,
0.42029058933258057,
0.6467024683952332,
-0.02133147232234478,
-0.0028220422100275755,
-0.8826606869697571,
-0.1028989776968956,
-0.25093507766723633,
0.5983973741531372,
-0.7849603295326233,
-0.6107649207115173,
0.37593644857406616,
-0.00010008831304730847,
-0.028929350897669792,
-0.31941360235214233,
0.7998781204223633,
-0.4492432177066803,
0.6664184927940369,
-0.06710731238126755,
-0.5340059995651245,
0.04119926691055298,
0.12974566221237183,
-0.48001769185066223,
0.8339398503303528,
0.10830642282962799,
-0.6018944382667542,
0.03155069425702095,
-0.38089966773986816,
-0.5127715468406677,
-0.010275362990796566,
-0.00870200339704752,
-0.09227508306503296,
0.11924039572477341,
0.5436350107192993,
0.526161253452301,
-0.11904319375753403,
0.4374355375766754,
-0.08470191806554794,
-0.18960820138454437,
0.1566324084997177,
-0.36870232224464417,
0.27821776270866394,
0.33072349429130554,
-0.3189024329185486,
0.24751576781272888,
-0.5740129947662354,
-0.06558112800121307,
-0.17372828722000122,
-0.3085556626319885,
-0.2640265226364136,
-0.2450484186410904,
-0.035383690148591995,
0.12318173795938492,
-0.004969202447682619,
-0.4119874835014343,
0.1386115998029709,
-0.5257244110107422,
0.24758808314800262,
0.6791449785232544,
0.31254905462265015,
0.7367941737174988,
0.026786185801029205,
0.7433252930641174,
0.03283125162124634,
-0.23289376497268677,
-0.5359887480735779,
-0.5474266409873962,
-0.8320937752723694,
-0.13148514926433563,
-0.05579502880573273,
0.9101609587669373,
-0.937432587146759,
0.6855773329734802,
0.14772218465805054,
-0.2940896451473236,
-0.7308197617530823,
-0.3321596384048462,
0.2045944482088089,
0.5367985963821411,
0.4872308373451233,
0.3273346722126007,
-0.5526106953620911,
-0.6728543043136597,
-0.20141848921775818,
-0.06185856834053993,
-0.3913753926753998,
0.37254032492637634,
-0.024469543248414993,
-0.21319086849689484,
1.058273196220398,
-0.2946329414844513,
0.03633219748735428,
-0.0799134150147438,
0.3715222477912903,
0.3283115029335022,
0.5418000221252441,
0.2783723473548889,
-0.7126700282096863,
-0.62372225522995,
-0.14154785871505737,
-0.6656452417373657,
-0.4555651545524597,
-0.30163562297821045,
-0.250895619392395,
0.029380321502685547,
0.5657014846801758,
-0.7844858765602112,
0.30508488416671753,
0.49966832995414734,
-0.46373575925827026,
0.31821757555007935,
-0.24790649116039276,
0.3833390474319458,
-1.1262367963790894,
-0.11127214878797531,
0.09169135987758636,
-0.06812144815921783,
-0.8265945315361023,
-0.6062412261962891,
-0.015233770944178104,
-0.5006255507469177,
-0.2621745467185974,
0.5918709635734558,
-0.07913578301668167,
0.3878142535686493,
-0.22889678180217743,
0.3001510500907898,
0.11130309849977493,
0.6429699063301086,
0.05405377969145775,
0.6115758419036865,
0.7816135287284851,
-0.8297135829925537,
0.6162019968032837,
0.7110884189605713,
0.14039085805416107,
1.1329375505447388,
-0.9593507647514343,
0.22227726876735687,
-0.6134636998176575,
0.448822021484375,
-0.7661349773406982,
-0.44891875982284546,
0.5037148594856262,
-0.6175305843353271,
0.2800585627555847,
-0.015088384971022606,
-0.1482975333929062,
-0.28612175583839417,
0.05158596858382225,
0.015123171731829643,
0.8586483001708984,
-0.7260385155677795,
0.9223082065582275,
-0.10864080488681793,
-0.6746214032173157,
-0.21562576293945312,
-0.66629558801651,
0.2767581641674042,
-0.2035873979330063,
-0.5245537161827087,
0.47696414589881897,
-0.2622576355934143,
-0.07786440849304199,
-0.01432693563401699,
0.4372464418411255,
0.11661650240421295,
-0.17074565589427948,
0.5431085824966431,
0.16681566834449768,
0.06168029457330704,
0.6341233253479004,
0.4947112798690796,
-0.3411436676979065,
0.1443461775779724,
-0.1690281629562378,
0.47323867678642273,
0.20089882612228394,
-0.3635213375091553,
-0.8339094519615173,
0.7299821376800537,
0.5575376152992249,
-0.24677345156669617,
0.6098664402961731,
0.5107975602149963,
-0.43443822860717773,
-0.5107572078704834,
-0.0909716933965683,
-0.3861137330532074,
-0.5152592658996582,
0.11344046145677567,
-0.3196946680545807,
-1.0773136615753174,
0.3273313045501709,
0.08757264167070389,
-0.2917359173297882,
0.38742923736572266,
0.8054670691490173,
-0.07269395142793655,
1.3108769655227661,
0.39090514183044434,
-0.054726243019104004,
0.6261235475540161,
0.29266390204429626,
0.3350074291229248,
-0.4725208580493927,
-0.42540243268013,
-0.8011903166770935,
-0.36853912472724915,
-0.6226277351379395,
-0.2749338746070862,
0.26025575399398804,
-0.14713136851787567,
-0.48402443528175354,
-0.0683211088180542,
-0.725990891456604,
0.16284552216529846,
0.5197292566299438,
0.18376024067401886,
-0.3123469650745392,
-0.1492522954940796,
-0.22968555986881256,
-0.1689707189798355,
-0.4156522750854492,
-0.5375456809997559,
0.32187530398368835,
0.31358522176742554,
0.5124293565750122,
-0.09129950404167175,
0.6903756260871887,
0.47139522433280945,
0.2542474865913391,
-0.8485239148139954,
0.26162099838256836,
0.04042206332087517,
-0.2694872319698334,
-0.13362137973308563,
-0.5059989094734192,
-0.8089644908905029,
-0.11922405660152435,
-0.2129209190607071,
-0.8751139640808105,
0.3266043961048126,
0.2546486258506775,
-0.46095845103263855,
-0.10657408088445663,
-0.9053534269332886,
0.585169792175293,
0.01626085489988327,
-0.09878309816122055,
-0.06707851588726044,
-0.7505548596382141,
0.012404538691043854,
0.20271681249141693,
-0.05759834870696068,
-0.12269449979066849,
0.17534491419792175,
0.5379434823989868,
-0.31733807921409607,
0.886442244052887,
-0.40009284019470215,
0.03611643239855766,
0.31079596281051636,
0.12526866793632507,
0.7304625511169434,
0.029970910400152206,
-0.4157788157463074,
-0.6187661290168762,
-0.5860525369644165,
-0.1771366149187088,
-0.897826075553894,
0.5145440697669983,
-0.6708876490592957,
-0.48675113916397095,
-0.13474003970623016,
-0.2517988681793213,
-0.5492081642150879,
-0.20775125920772552,
0.52090984582901,
0.5241812467575073,
-0.3201461732387543,
0.07713353633880615,
0.7937454581260681,
-0.6276761293411255,
0.4928615689277649,
0.047634631395339966,
-0.029628245159983635,
-0.7630819082260132,
0.7861458659172058,
-0.46265119314193726,
0.04482252895832062,
0.3889625370502472,
0.28813982009887695,
-0.48660972714424133,
0.15660600364208221,
-0.5890885591506958,
-0.04348346218466759,
-0.756267249584198,
-0.28653502464294434,
-0.927282989025116,
-0.015561074949800968,
-0.39076265692710876,
-0.5401476621627808,
-0.013357890769839287,
0.02254348248243332,
-0.9318868517875671,
-0.42643284797668457,
0.6533040404319763,
0.7144148349761963,
0.09240290522575378,
0.45852506160736084,
-1.0930657386779785,
0.29573071002960205,
0.6058960556983948,
0.4626237154006958,
0.008599272929131985,
-0.6520882248878479,
-0.01710478775203228,
-0.08267876505851746,
-0.12322875112295151,
-1.122768759727478,
0.6662799715995789,
0.35790735483169556,
0.3434619605541229,
0.4245595335960388,
0.5270059704780579,
0.29761967062950134,
-0.5595061779022217,
0.973953902721405,
0.3670397400856018,
-1.2449625730514526,
0.8764172792434692,
-0.24894817173480988,
0.4134604036808014,
0.378215491771698,
0.45600664615631104,
-0.8405523896217346,
-0.5216335654258728,
-0.4547564387321472,
-0.7236396074295044,
0.7430517077445984,
0.011206230148673058,
0.6001389622688293,
-0.18888628482818604,
0.12996923923492432,
0.0017156593967229128,
0.027117356657981873,
-0.39330726861953735,
-0.19186049699783325,
-0.5786467790603638,
-0.5761146545410156,
-0.02402493730187416,
-0.358440637588501,
-0.07476742565631866,
0.01789076440036297,
0.6455353498458862,
-0.1668047308921814,
0.4397032558917999,
0.28402599692344666,
0.02921118400990963,
-0.10621029138565063,
0.506181001663208,
0.3778255581855774,
-0.3460336923599243,
-0.005571669898927212,
0.29993951320648193,
0.0823209285736084,
0.09851208329200745,
0.4241233766078949,
0.1997283697128296,
-0.08941978216171265,
0.2124103158712387,
0.173950657248497,
1.4429007768630981,
0.20970523357391357,
-0.5518313646316528,
0.39344435930252075,
-0.17989933490753174,
-0.10866552591323853,
0.27164703607559204,
0.03234749659895897,
0.09825132042169571,
0.25912898778915405,
0.3249240815639496,
0.0752987265586853,
0.007448726333677769,
-0.17611803114414215,
0.25610390305519104,
-0.08111623674631119,
-0.8310707807540894,
-0.4605266749858856,
0.6447940468788147,
0.5776334404945374,
-0.6968756318092346,
0.7671025991439819,
-0.2854173481464386,
-0.9402452111244202,
0.22646792232990265,
0.6158732175827026,
1.2263962030410767,
-0.5286757946014404,
0.3478907644748688,
0.43569523096084595,
0.04417724534869194,
0.2554190456867218,
0.42676079273223877,
-0.22449679672718048,
-0.5756984949111938,
-0.17628644406795502,
-0.5114649534225464,
-0.66610187292099,
-0.6387783885002136,
-0.6039139628410339,
0.25209662318229675,
-0.3022739887237549,
-0.258907288312912,
-0.4128897488117218,
-0.6497564315795898,
-0.647520899772644,
0.4867751896381378,
0.45926931500434875,
0.8538835048675537,
-1.1479307413101196,
0.44899335503578186,
0.6079153418540955,
-0.15265925228595734,
-0.9176577925682068,
-0.2292754352092743,
-0.04903271794319153,
-0.48992612957954407,
0.5372559428215027,
0.4286586344242096,
0.047495000064373016,
0.1529453545808792,
-0.48770618438720703,
-0.24484604597091675,
0.5555710196495056,
0.5647237300872803,
-0.45701050758361816,
0.27175647020339966,
-0.014901743270456791,
0.6494211554527283,
-0.30911386013031006,
0.2829136848449707,
0.44783124327659607,
0.6969209313392639,
0.26514995098114014,
-0.4855976402759552,
-0.05784379690885544,
-0.49906808137893677,
-0.16423745453357697,
0.1365053504705429,
-0.17314952611923218,
0.5293886065483093,
-0.07321730256080627,
-0.45578810572624207,
-0.07745631039142609,
0.9991589784622192,
0.13847090303897858,
0.283823162317276,
0.6214461922645569,
0.4948505759239197,
0.9888983964920044,
-0.3227463364601135,
0.98573237657547,
-0.3779540956020355,
0.10010262578725815,
0.7872409224510193,
-0.22340907156467438,
0.7420087456703186,
0.5190165042877197,
0.02453339844942093,
0.6170790791511536,
0.70334792137146,
0.1324005424976349,
0.6063584685325623,
0.2142203152179718,
-0.7557037472724915,
-0.24333202838897705,
-0.7137816548347473,
-0.22019751369953156,
0.17775855958461761,
0.34948164224624634,
-0.46006813645362854,
0.01121294405311346,
0.45792752504348755,
-0.03404444828629494,
0.1896253377199173,
0.03136010095477104,
0.8177698850631714,
0.22234371304512024,
-1.0197778940200806,
0.32129424810409546,
-0.31021785736083984,
0.6776536107063293,
-0.5601010322570801,
0.1087828278541565,
-0.32221171259880066,
-0.28558865189552307,
-0.09078443795442581,
-0.6970149278640747,
0.12476273626089096,
0.3453074097633362,
-0.2666434049606323,
-0.7395197153091431,
0.47926247119903564,
-0.7699492573738098,
-0.1608603298664093,
0.27541664242744446,
0.24718768894672394,
-0.11064424365758896,
-0.21809159219264984,
-0.21946534514427185,
0.19127000868320465,
0.06305009871721268,
-0.5257552266120911,
-0.09922201186418533,
0.9437260627746582,
0.3765133321285248,
0.4787417948246002,
0.3674737215042114,
-0.26256847381591797,
-0.21202346682548523,
0.4692307412624359,
0.9114561080932617,
-0.675141453742981,
-0.7616772651672363,
-0.9791088700294495,
0.8479348421096802,
0.15340940654277802,
-0.3813706338405609,
0.3310961127281189,
-0.02791402116417885,
-0.1248137578368187,
-0.13005943596363068,
0.8756252527236938,
-0.05061967670917511,
0.28154000639915466,
-0.5015051364898682,
0.6172751784324646,
-0.27541080117225647,
-0.23708420991897583,
-0.24056634306907654,
-0.775380551815033,
-0.2521674335002899,
0.34383535385131836,
0.1397990584373474,
-0.02810983918607235,
0.3854398727416992,
0.6490938663482666,
0.38077226281166077,
0.3399423360824585,
0.36454153060913086,
-0.012844307348132133,
0.47515738010406494,
0.5347956418991089,
0.982261061668396,
0.04251351207494736,
0.28639358282089233,
-0.06077578663825989,
-0.35479167103767395,
-0.37992459535598755,
-1.0570597648620605,
-0.5897678136825562,
-0.6969003081321716,
-0.2711068391799927,
-0.3391405940055847,
-0.027586905285716057,
1.2808587551116943,
0.4298933744430542,
-0.8656545877456665,
0.3850615918636322,
-0.05532325059175491,
0.12748749554157257,
0.2605701982975006,
-0.21422691643238068,
0.165236696600914,
-0.6000115275382996,
-0.8703161478042603,
0.5956554412841797,
0.4035452902317047,
0.38364413380622864,
-0.07704787701368332,
-0.3991212844848633,
0.2929932773113251,
0.2969570457935333,
0.548226535320282,
0.024869196116924286,
-0.5442613363265991,
-0.4382355213165283,
0.15618844330310822,
-0.2482329159975052,
-0.012370357289910316,
0.7176644206047058,
-0.9554799795150757,
0.8349703550338745,
0.6699076890945435,
0.8407568335533142,
0.13028274476528168,
0.14237119257450104,
1.0091803073883057,
-1.0038259029388428,
0.12391944229602814,
0.46857884526252747,
0.3401119112968445,
0.6228685975074768,
-0.41187572479248047,
-0.006253467872738838,
0.012965245172381401,
-0.6112317442893982,
-0.5125245451927185,
0.18184830248355865,
-0.9803736805915833,
0.16647422313690186,
0.912842869758606,
-0.18672509491443634,
0.056715838611125946,
0.22490432858467102,
-0.6073691248893738,
0.7750856876373291,
-0.753821849822998,
0.661712646484375,
0.621966540813446,
-0.05232277512550354,
-0.2864435911178589,
-0.024840909987688065,
0.4808453917503357,
0.6387115120887756,
-0.9755863547325134,
0.2352699637413025,
0.558294415473938,
-0.49875301122665405,
0.0648983046412468,
0.08942130208015442,
0.4130455255508423,
0.21495406329631805,
-0.11214713007211685,
0.33582329750061035,
0.21403998136520386,
-0.37340012192726135,
-0.6770404577255249,
0.28695011138916016,
-0.2948421537876129,
-0.12229916453361511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06403v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06403v1
|
Meta Learning Text-to-Speech Synthesis in over 7000 Languages
| 2024-06-10T15:56:52 | 2024-06-10T15:56:52 |
Florian Lux, Sarina Meyer, Lyonel Behringer, Frank Zalkow, Phat Do, Matt Coler, Emanuël A. P. Habets, Ngoc Thang Vu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
In this work, we take on the challenging task of building a single
text-to-speech synthesis system that is capable of generating speech in over
7000 languages, many of which lack sufficient data for traditional TTS
development. By leveraging a novel integration of massively multilingual
pretraining and meta learning to approximate language representations, our
approach enables zero-shot speech synthesis in languages without any available
data. We validate our system's performance through objective measures and human
evaluation across a diverse linguistic landscape. By releasing our code and
models publicly, we aim to empower communities with limited linguistic
resources and foster further innovation in the field of speech technology.
|
[
-0.44903090596199036,
-0.46003541350364685,
0.4171654284000397,
0.1740068793296814,
-0.19938308000564575,
0.23240721225738525,
-0.20340698957443237,
-0.23942312598228455,
0.35035067796707153,
0.36724409461021423,
-0.7676792144775391,
-0.525992751121521,
-0.30666759610176086,
0.41378146409988403,
-0.32529962062835693,
1.0669416189193726,
0.3835527002811432,
0.01627890020608902,
0.21842694282531738,
-0.0637693703174591,
-0.37013959884643555,
-0.5689401626586914,
-0.3804423213005066,
-0.01137568149715662,
0.6075443029403687,
0.5256147384643555,
0.21306166052818298,
0.3285064995288849,
-0.13266584277153015,
0.2419019341468811,
0.1983344703912735,
-0.022119535133242607,
-0.4938681423664093,
-0.037613049149513245,
-0.14954397082328796,
-0.005136447958648205,
-0.5998841524124146,
-0.09258124977350235,
0.8421039581298828,
0.6221744418144226,
0.16132652759552002,
0.6229006052017212,
0.19596803188323975,
0.4495028853416443,
-0.8831334710121155,
0.06843170523643494,
-0.7416263818740845,
0.12740477919578552,
-0.4908238351345062,
0.017998529598116875,
-0.6192724108695984,
-0.26885294914245605,
0.20831088721752167,
-0.4713214039802551,
0.151970773935318,
-0.43833449482917786,
0.04792644456028938,
0.10971152037382126,
-0.4783228933811188,
-0.11730245500802994,
-1.0068789720535278,
0.6302831768989563,
-0.6341322064399719,
0.5429192781448364,
0.08708813786506653,
0.41798684000968933,
0.2739369571208954,
-0.883452832698822,
-0.6709142327308655,
-0.05630843713879585,
0.2220836877822876,
0.20176167786121368,
0.06051081046462059,
0.04161189869046211,
-0.011877399869263172,
-0.07469232380390167,
-0.6642430424690247,
-0.3753252327442169,
-0.550797700881958,
-0.22268545627593994,
0.5356847643852234,
-0.07644538581371307,
0.1955575793981552,
-0.32870256900787354,
-0.05040184408426285,
-0.16957078874111176,
-0.5897943377494812,
-0.3511807322502136,
0.2996026277542114,
0.6350017786026001,
0.1497172862291336,
0.608910858631134,
0.03842198848724365,
0.829397439956665,
-0.21050497889518738,
-0.14992152154445648,
0.42037665843963623,
-0.3879217207431793,
-0.48348018527030945,
0.3155672550201416,
1.1494334936141968,
-0.09561242908239365,
0.04156983271241188,
-0.318807989358902,
0.08436638116836548,
-0.021533388644456863,
0.2851540446281433,
-0.5520570278167725,
0.39984071254730225,
0.03842621296644211,
-0.06010623276233673,
-0.14298520982265472,
0.01031450368463993,
-0.9000539183616638,
0.026778817176818848,
-0.1186637133359909,
0.5796012878417969,
-0.30901026725769043,
-0.604631781578064,
0.0971275046467781,
-0.1011890098452568,
0.04012209177017212,
-0.11153005808591843,
-0.8971855640411377,
0.028569044545292854,
0.30942949652671814,
0.7007648348808289,
0.1484283208847046,
-0.6307809352874756,
-0.5143741369247437,
0.5134972929954529,
-0.6336319446563721,
0.5468025207519531,
-0.490750789642334,
-0.6840386390686035,
0.009184901602566242,
-0.09239789098501205,
-0.10525816679000854,
-0.4698103964328766,
0.35794562101364136,
-0.1598382294178009,
0.1331382393836975,
-0.11637044697999954,
-0.212039515376091,
-0.10705439746379852,
-0.10322625935077667,
-0.6243199706077576,
0.9032009243965149,
0.07349329441785812,
-0.20449019968509674,
0.26031824946403503,
-0.8286980986595154,
-0.6543061137199402,
0.13980165123939514,
-0.06490013003349304,
-0.10051672160625458,
0.4078370928764343,
0.05650711804628372,
0.28618088364601135,
-0.26183021068573,
0.4151391386985779,
-0.02396794594824314,
-0.17795111238956451,
0.0403909906744957,
-0.5186437368392944,
0.46105390787124634,
0.5235044360160828,
-0.5065889358520508,
0.1039901152253151,
-0.8933321833610535,
0.31863632798194885,
-0.05026181787252426,
-0.2876488268375397,
0.028489332646131516,
-0.1265079379081726,
0.3284573554992676,
0.38796454668045044,
0.11977292597293854,
-0.5283401608467102,
0.03795074671506882,
-0.6524196267127991,
0.665998637676239,
0.25873470306396484,
-0.16154256463050842,
0.4052163362503052,
0.009484007023274899,
0.583263099193573,
-0.43093836307525635,
0.05452386662364006,
-0.40966078639030457,
-0.5189077854156494,
-0.6062807440757751,
-0.05986032634973526,
0.583436131477356,
0.6356076598167419,
-0.9355677962303162,
0.45400819182395935,
-0.4898052215576172,
-0.37439095973968506,
-0.8786095380783081,
0.049417681992053986,
0.5179300904273987,
0.4686177372932434,
0.4422488808631897,
-0.054214008152484894,
-0.777972400188446,
-0.620437741279602,
-0.32957082986831665,
0.009243438020348549,
-0.317484974861145,
-0.09682866930961609,
0.3135108947753906,
-0.33473122119903564,
0.9220225214958191,
-0.1474907249212265,
-0.504059374332428,
-0.41028618812561035,
0.12307695299386978,
0.12904849648475647,
0.32549309730529785,
0.48745718598365784,
-0.3746606707572937,
-0.6607751846313477,
0.0895773246884346,
-0.5977813005447388,
-0.009643972851336002,
0.06022217497229576,
0.1531207412481308,
0.21099159121513367,
0.7762818932533264,
-0.35422253608703613,
0.3399665355682373,
0.7407688498497009,
0.16373538970947266,
0.36209943890571594,
-0.1852836012840271,
0.1724618673324585,
-1.3079508543014526,
0.5754237174987793,
-0.36664286255836487,
-0.3176291286945343,
-0.8710864186286926,
-0.05234774202108383,
-0.1400901973247528,
-0.7449166178703308,
-0.8243166208267212,
0.4823698103427887,
-0.287058562040329,
-0.12170533835887909,
-0.27262115478515625,
0.09749946743249893,
-0.4442768096923828,
0.5609390139579773,
0.3020135164260864,
0.7276260256767273,
0.6195672154426575,
-0.694896399974823,
0.2902427911758423,
0.13691078126430511,
-0.303836464881897,
0.39075636863708496,
-0.7686355710029602,
0.138823002576828,
-0.07438034564256668,
0.42090028524398804,
-0.9039555191993713,
-0.3672608435153961,
0.15288467705249786,
-0.6720352172851562,
0.12405326217412949,
-0.1567937433719635,
-0.4016721844673157,
-0.3394015431404114,
0.0036868895404040813,
0.637484610080719,
0.48781245946884155,
-0.18788519501686096,
0.6812067031860352,
0.4894433915615082,
-0.28273269534111023,
-0.48018476366996765,
-0.8290369510650635,
0.452796995639801,
0.09127423912286758,
-0.3220537006855011,
0.2153196781873703,
-0.1205468401312828,
0.3056645095348358,
0.029221102595329285,
0.041286446154117584,
-0.08317309617996216,
-0.37217235565185547,
0.05567612498998642,
-0.11039330810308456,
0.0061594536527991295,
0.3106882870197296,
0.12228215485811234,
-0.5514450669288635,
-0.17543956637382507,
-0.6551193594932556,
0.6531460881233215,
0.18629030883312225,
-0.49416273832321167,
-0.4147765636444092,
0.4818919897079468,
0.7687724232673645,
-0.25622397661209106,
0.5120000839233398,
0.5541743636131287,
-0.3411394953727722,
-0.3203962445259094,
-0.3507669270038605,
0.1601569801568985,
-0.4906400144100189,
0.46419602632522583,
-0.42811521887779236,
-0.7775379419326782,
0.3076765239238739,
-0.20077945291996002,
0.06315957009792328,
0.8424693942070007,
0.5196039080619812,
0.23212715983390808,
0.9213361144065857,
0.5473452210426331,
-0.0708414763212204,
0.3943020701408386,
-0.07655230164527893,
0.08565571904182434,
-0.5019215941429138,
-0.23918035626411438,
-0.44914576411247253,
-0.13131394982337952,
-0.5441001653671265,
-0.49723631143569946,
0.842076301574707,
-0.4603845179080963,
-0.22869032621383667,
0.43061307072639465,
-0.6316192746162415,
0.5741148591041565,
0.7838812470436096,
0.05887162312865257,
0.1775224804878235,
0.09068778902292252,
-0.20876991748809814,
-0.08868087083101273,
-0.6751006841659546,
-0.3784579038619995,
1.3644036054611206,
-0.02667616866528988,
0.33965080976486206,
0.02682926133275032,
0.7819167971611023,
0.11516252905130386,
0.14369730651378632,
-0.6683597564697266,
0.48180532455444336,
-0.36534029245376587,
-0.9351077675819397,
-0.5939467549324036,
-0.5347650051116943,
-0.7848807573318481,
-0.0007899003103375435,
-0.38504403829574585,
-0.263529896736145,
-0.2677052319049835,
0.15685059130191803,
-0.40801841020584106,
0.28485703468322754,
-0.8490908741950989,
0.8591089248657227,
-0.10628817230463028,
-0.12393559515476227,
-0.23004843294620514,
-0.9444190263748169,
0.2123243659734726,
-0.37495067715644836,
0.470613956451416,
0.2914596498012543,
0.13233135640621185,
0.7743757367134094,
-0.23561817407608032,
0.9782537221908569,
-0.03887663036584854,
-0.11556506901979446,
0.5366926789283752,
0.03787486255168915,
-0.016481151804327965,
-0.06325390189886093,
-0.04980883002281189,
0.1661009043455124,
-0.10556093603372574,
-0.21430175006389618,
-0.23871728777885437,
0.4117635190486908,
-0.4578379690647125,
-0.32316693663597107,
-0.3593534529209137,
-0.2559575140476227,
-0.5065428018569946,
0.4701812267303467,
0.5749207735061646,
0.3647231161594391,
-0.6366371512413025,
0.19542106986045837,
0.6100033521652222,
-0.4762983024120331,
0.6179274916648865,
0.4761658310890198,
-0.2942140996456146,
-0.9964784979820251,
1.1154917478561401,
0.28818732500076294,
0.36093252897262573,
0.5517289042472839,
0.056445442140102386,
-0.3046412467956543,
-0.31785154342651367,
-0.8507543206214905,
0.3524249196052551,
-0.5267886519432068,
-0.10997477173805237,
-0.5429269671440125,
-0.3585212826728821,
-0.8209211230278015,
-0.022853469476103783,
-0.7065244913101196,
-0.40495598316192627,
-0.2770075798034668,
-0.2239813208580017,
-0.20113910734653473,
1.1005674600601196,
-0.22901864349842072,
0.3804072141647339,
-1.2002938985824585,
0.5508963465690613,
0.6893013715744019,
0.4027548134326935,
-0.007029534783214331,
-0.4085353910923004,
-0.2922954559326172,
0.30373790860176086,
-0.3629460334777832,
-0.9646814465522766,
0.39959636330604553,
0.5349486470222473,
0.511998176574707,
0.1829967051744461,
-0.08989651501178741,
0.6930228471755981,
-1.181943416595459,
0.9090152382850647,
0.5144616365432739,
-1.5334371328353882,
0.7347273230552673,
-0.18303821980953217,
0.6555480360984802,
0.49658966064453125,
0.37704983353614807,
-0.6816353797912598,
-0.29106393456459045,
-0.5172026753425598,
-0.6814604997634888,
0.7286096811294556,
0.19572626054286957,
0.27705228328704834,
0.034588370472192764,
0.30642324686050415,
0.15058255195617676,
0.2768208086490631,
-0.7298163771629333,
-0.3173922598361969,
-0.4222027361392975,
-0.23503953218460083,
-0.71910160779953,
-0.1898115873336792,
-0.14325487613677979,
-0.26557934284210205,
0.6693097949028015,
-0.1685863435268402,
0.22963902354240417,
0.032976988703012466,
-0.054356999695301056,
-0.14209504425525665,
0.34158560633659363,
0.9445788264274597,
0.6171926856040955,
-0.008749761618673801,
0.08269349485635757,
0.3413810431957245,
-0.48482561111450195,
0.2866269052028656,
-0.07962993532419205,
-0.06509804725646973,
0.2738264799118042,
0.4481734335422516,
0.8770185708999634,
0.3363848924636841,
-0.6057933568954468,
0.3950828015804291,
0.1868140995502472,
-0.5970871448516846,
-0.11889041215181351,
-0.06885317713022232,
0.22475296258926392,
-0.038347091525793076,
0.6553525924682617,
0.10096032917499542,
-0.01449622306972742,
-0.6458305716514587,
0.3606846034526825,
0.40590333938598633,
-0.4083839952945709,
-0.6688544154167175,
0.9177857637405396,
0.3900393545627594,
-0.28409698605537415,
0.232937291264534,
-0.17035996913909912,
-0.3787699043750763,
0.20423045754432678,
0.5419250726699829,
1.249869704246521,
-0.6738131642341614,
0.47157391905784607,
0.6337190866470337,
0.5070927739143372,
-0.10955961048603058,
0.17820903658866882,
-0.06398054212331772,
-0.16513855755329132,
-0.7380626201629639,
-0.714625358581543,
-0.42412424087524414,
0.07066939026117325,
-0.3972224295139313,
0.506699800491333,
-0.28047487139701843,
-0.2394724190235138,
-0.05217958614230156,
-0.48054271936416626,
-0.4263918995857239,
0.3030969798564911,
0.34007567167282104,
0.5835959315299988,
-1.037516474723816,
0.8933162093162537,
0.47577160596847534,
-0.29981619119644165,
-0.4696832001209259,
-0.16439929604530334,
-0.14533253014087677,
-0.6631667613983154,
0.490241140127182,
0.017279623076319695,
-0.2522651255130768,
0.3040301203727722,
-0.3878687620162964,
-0.7759920358657837,
0.7375684976577759,
0.8948448896408081,
-0.5361273288726807,
-0.19926953315734863,
0.6905527114868164,
0.6653276681900024,
-0.35470181703567505,
0.025195559486746788,
0.25592517852783203,
0.48128142952919006,
0.4495810568332672,
-1.3570921421051025,
-0.3925110399723053,
0.07054819166660309,
-0.12872414290905,
0.09808389097452164,
-0.4938943088054657,
0.5545228719711304,
-0.08327044546604156,
-0.5058255791664124,
-0.23351828753948212,
0.4692709147930145,
-0.1357010006904602,
0.38400334119796753,
0.16806437075138092,
0.5521167516708374,
0.4327734410762787,
0.09680929034948349,
0.5910307168960571,
-0.1623620092868805,
0.30489087104797363,
1.1155611276626587,
-0.25099343061447144,
0.866769552230835,
0.28248757123947144,
-0.22892838716506958,
0.2260221242904663,
0.36740830540657043,
0.4909054636955261,
0.6552525758743286,
-0.02678133361041546,
-0.6106683611869812,
-0.3183935880661011,
0.008047904819250107,
-0.5991297960281372,
0.5263071060180664,
0.4076331555843353,
-0.2630615234375,
-0.27188482880592346,
0.411675363779068,
-0.2659609913825989,
-0.1942891627550125,
-0.1719953864812851,
0.9465946555137634,
-0.057514965534210205,
-0.6621847152709961,
0.7129531502723694,
-0.25297486782073975,
0.4606306850910187,
-0.8862141966819763,
0.002809339202940464,
0.13316631317138672,
-0.020137125626206398,
-0.11576532572507858,
-0.5459316968917847,
0.6068809628486633,
0.040141742676496506,
-0.060795679688453674,
-0.36986684799194336,
0.376577764749527,
-0.7250360250473022,
-0.5978888273239136,
0.2534872591495514,
0.738285481929779,
0.056688934564590454,
-0.22137059271335602,
-0.38707709312438965,
0.056019723415374756,
0.17765063047409058,
-0.009027603082358837,
0.27473685145378113,
0.4560379385948181,
0.3141501247882843,
0.43485429883003235,
0.5540234446525574,
0.11185094714164734,
0.22088877856731415,
-0.14139635860919952,
0.6196231842041016,
-0.7552368640899658,
-0.4495110511779785,
-0.8357844352722168,
0.5863120555877686,
0.37703371047973633,
-0.28147849440574646,
0.7582931518554688,
0.5544469952583313,
0.9298239946365356,
-0.4315308928489685,
1.2844038009643555,
-0.24914228916168213,
0.572501003742218,
-0.27512675523757935,
0.6190987229347229,
-0.5189821124076843,
-0.11683493852615356,
-0.5572069883346558,
-1.1226043701171875,
-0.4271736443042755,
0.25827401876449585,
0.15161757171154022,
-0.0956924706697464,
0.6137322187423706,
0.46953392028808594,
0.04919249936938286,
-0.14494185149669647,
0.7196869254112244,
-0.07755525410175323,
0.24265599250793457,
0.5859264731407166,
0.49135836958885193,
-0.6365804076194763,
0.9317877292633057,
0.1429281085729599,
-0.28259941935539246,
0.04007524251937866,
-0.9791029095649719,
-0.5941377282142639,
-0.864210307598114,
-0.06889747083187103,
-0.20575787127017975,
-0.16766174137592316,
0.7675272822380066,
0.8368764519691467,
-0.9136688709259033,
-0.4739409387111664,
-0.05328444391489029,
0.03970368579030037,
-0.15678095817565918,
-0.12927697598934174,
0.14268630743026733,
-0.38349592685699463,
-1.0432456731796265,
0.7203343510627747,
0.32028862833976746,
0.007417948450893164,
-0.2995207905769348,
-0.10250648111104965,
-0.10801689326763153,
0.16277708113193512,
0.8032976984977722,
0.580073356628418,
-0.39260134100914,
-0.019909033551812172,
0.09480192512273788,
0.1779593527317047,
-0.21140073239803314,
0.9840905666351318,
-0.8010326027870178,
0.8534468412399292,
0.5307140946388245,
0.627049446105957,
0.5832164883613586,
-0.40380582213401794,
0.6311376690864563,
-1.0003528594970703,
0.2384352833032608,
0.2566017508506775,
-0.04899241030216217,
0.04535821080207825,
0.19994759559631348,
0.36884814500808716,
0.2880009412765503,
-0.48321595788002014,
-0.7947304248809814,
0.3246724009513855,
-0.8007991909980774,
-0.20125868916511536,
0.9945738315582275,
0.238973468542099,
-0.0651620551943779,
0.012121212668716908,
-0.19726242125034332,
0.5473705530166626,
-0.16592375934123993,
0.5253469944000244,
0.5508595705032349,
0.10666225105524063,
0.004572086967527866,
-0.6082780361175537,
0.6585077047348022,
0.10156790912151337,
-0.6643776297569275,
0.11032011359930038,
0.4899067282676697,
0.2687914967536926,
0.47180700302124023,
0.7564222812652588,
-0.03324049711227417,
0.2946237027645111,
-0.0207135621458292,
0.3159291744232178,
0.13872362673282623,
-0.6202256679534912,
-0.3483127951622009,
0.3347485065460205,
-0.2626323699951172,
-0.2397768199443817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06401v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06401v1
|
INTERSPEECH 2009 Emotion Challenge Revisited: Benchmarking 15 Years of Progress in Speech Emotion Recognition
| 2024-06-10T15:55:06 | 2024-06-10T15:55:06 |
Andreas Triantafyllopoulos, Anton Batliner, Simon Rampp, Manuel Milling, Björn Schuller
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We revisit the INTERSPEECH 2009 Emotion Challenge -- the first ever speech
emotion recognition (SER) challenge -- and evaluate a series of deep learning
models that are representative of the major advances in SER research in the
time since then. We start by training each model using a fixed set of
hyperparameters, and further fine-tune the best-performing models of that
initial setup with a grid search. Results are always reported on the official
test set with a separate validation set only used for early stopping. Most
models score below or close to the official baseline, while they marginally
outperform the original challenge winners after hyperparameter tuning. Our work
illustrates that, despite recent progress, FAU-AIBO remains a very challenging
benchmark. An interesting corollary is that newer methods do not consistently
outperform older ones, showing that progress towards `solving' SER is not
necessarily monotonic.
|
[
-0.6369813680648804,
-0.1317395567893982,
0.29159101843833923,
0.15889783203601837,
-0.1328635811805725,
0.14842113852500916,
-0.0390397273004055,
-0.5442013144493103,
-0.016733162105083466,
0.11870495229959488,
-0.8134956359863281,
-0.1466439813375473,
-0.7650517821311951,
0.25400182604789734,
-0.44606223702430725,
0.7455818057060242,
0.03061993420124054,
0.16446416079998016,
-0.20817069709300995,
-0.319252073764801,
0.03042142279446125,
-0.5131857395172119,
-0.6749560236930847,
-0.31831982731819153,
0.46627190709114075,
0.4647890627384186,
0.08290612697601318,
0.09312858432531357,
0.702017605304718,
0.2751772999763489,
-0.39650943875312805,
0.19086307287216187,
-0.35291147232055664,
0.22389759123325348,
0.13949230313301086,
-0.021535297855734825,
-0.28502964973449707,
0.19931560754776,
0.6910555958747864,
0.6152480244636536,
-0.1291186660528183,
0.11845768243074417,
0.07758545130491257,
0.9700567126274109,
-0.7147824764251709,
0.1107058972120285,
-0.6437980532646179,
0.30467939376831055,
-0.12284190207719803,
-0.060345303267240524,
-0.48844581842422485,
-0.27582481503486633,
0.26529738306999207,
-0.15878906846046448,
0.2760772407054901,
0.10222626477479935,
0.9970683455467224,
0.2784958481788635,
-0.5007295608520508,
-0.28934571146965027,
-0.7289215326309204,
0.5269588232040405,
-0.8145255446434021,
0.4821993410587311,
0.3420417308807373,
0.34449994564056396,
-0.2785910367965698,
-0.8130698204040527,
-0.5071231722831726,
-0.6436781883239746,
0.5190083384513855,
0.11785673350095749,
-0.6743290424346924,
0.049546197056770325,
0.46571484208106995,
0.505693256855011,
-0.4854392111301422,
0.30305778980255127,
-0.1313147246837616,
-0.21147684752941132,
0.7381123900413513,
0.19908609986305237,
-0.028419332578778267,
0.19341479241847992,
-0.3575415015220642,
-0.392436683177948,
-0.46127742528915405,
0.34667107462882996,
0.30395838618278503,
0.42340320348739624,
-0.062048569321632385,
0.31676971912384033,
-0.36878347396850586,
0.06747422367334366,
0.20969101786613464,
0.32283201813697815,
0.37925010919570923,
0.1609012335538864,
-0.09530380368232727,
0.25675150752067566,
0.6756068468093872,
0.17859552800655365,
0.24261188507080078,
0.039359696209430695,
-0.2419046312570572,
-0.036929816007614136,
0.2413395792245865,
-0.6847044825553894,
-0.1818198263645172,
0.17429119348526,
-0.5308966636657715,
0.021292006596922874,
-0.22316627204418182,
-0.8115838766098022,
-0.6914124488830566,
-0.31077444553375244,
0.3695100247859955,
-0.24960960447788239,
-0.2125176638364792,
-0.050512198358774185,
0.19267714023590088,
0.314515084028244,
0.5434521436691284,
-0.6517676115036011,
0.5393229722976685,
0.8692924976348877,
0.840550422668457,
0.03802202641963959,
-0.29278749227523804,
-0.7075194120407104,
-0.6245377659797668,
-0.3090723156929016,
0.632213830947876,
-0.47388795018196106,
-0.5229977965354919,
-0.1707751303911209,
-0.019147144630551338,
0.2651197910308838,
-0.7302152514457703,
0.7080705165863037,
-0.24691234529018402,
-0.10676614195108414,
-0.4918060600757599,
-0.9185943603515625,
-0.07966024428606033,
0.015588363632559776,
-0.5481019020080566,
1.0295019149780273,
-0.08511295169591904,
-0.4270502030849457,
0.32371148467063904,
-0.33180689811706543,
-0.17334461212158203,
-0.005701977293938398,
-0.06024159863591194,
-0.6959286332130432,
0.5480129718780518,
0.0017602432053536177,
0.24182502925395966,
-0.5684382319450378,
-0.10570231080055237,
-0.6661516427993774,
-0.328754186630249,
0.13923054933547974,
-0.3657084107398987,
0.5937061309814453,
0.2285279482603073,
-0.49946993589401245,
-0.1037827804684639,
-1.097001552581787,
-0.003407339798286557,
0.13671845197677612,
0.030530868098139763,
-0.08123607933521271,
0.04692836478352547,
-0.19187818467617035,
0.20891103148460388,
0.022961461916565895,
-0.8709375262260437,
0.05830052122473717,
-0.08574949204921722,
0.43347424268722534,
0.756820559501648,
-0.2597813606262207,
-0.051520127803087234,
0.10632416605949402,
0.4360734820365906,
0.14405220746994019,
0.255371630191803,
-0.002212259452790022,
-0.30535975098609924,
-0.823824405670166,
0.060425106436014175,
0.46000227332115173,
0.4568706750869751,
0.038626257330179214,
0.38884231448173523,
0.15240618586540222,
-0.8724920749664307,
-0.7731108069419861,
-0.4567156732082367,
0.27864569425582886,
0.7587747573852539,
0.44946616888046265,
-0.533794105052948,
-0.5815653204917908,
-0.8440836668014526,
-0.1343357264995575,
-0.21375495195388794,
0.36192989349365234,
0.5936110019683838,
0.5697680115699768,
-0.11769423633813858,
0.39255067706108093,
-0.09756448864936829,
-0.09491536021232605,
0.11283289641141891,
0.810157060623169,
-0.034596603363752365,
0.6679385900497437,
0.5567049980163574,
-0.7750396728515625,
-0.4538628160953522,
0.18688374757766724,
-0.3885059654712677,
-0.19633692502975464,
0.4041215777397156,
0.26546937227249146,
0.09228499978780746,
0.45180895924568176,
-0.11934444308280945,
0.7446385622024536,
0.44080525636672974,
-0.17170967161655426,
0.7873378396034241,
-0.135209321975708,
0.4056102931499481,
-0.5539275407791138,
0.050726987421512604,
0.13398142158985138,
0.05566127970814705,
-0.6181610226631165,
-0.4113486111164093,
0.16732366383075714,
-0.565021812915802,
-0.3124503493309021,
0.465453177690506,
-0.35706716775894165,
-0.4109156131744385,
-0.4533621072769165,
-0.16565600037574768,
-0.34716442227363586,
0.3965664803981781,
-0.08934906870126724,
0.6236091256141663,
0.4593678414821625,
-0.6706637740135193,
0.6673446893692017,
0.21690690517425537,
-0.611709475517273,
0.7248494029045105,
-0.5078469514846802,
0.46855735778808594,
-0.25725752115249634,
0.19224366545677185,
-1.1527910232543945,
-0.08914237469434738,
-0.2133781909942627,
-0.6477382183074951,
0.1780104786157608,
0.0527629628777504,
-0.05100761353969574,
-0.5559581518173218,
0.09772033244371414,
0.25124722719192505,
0.663486123085022,
-0.5111948251724243,
0.6204661130905151,
0.23228690028190613,
-0.3322577476501465,
-0.5914578437805176,
-0.6094030141830444,
0.2145526260137558,
-0.31674814224243164,
-0.17218030989170074,
0.2705574333667755,
-0.13504204154014587,
-0.2661602795124054,
-0.16627269983291626,
-0.3307209014892578,
-0.18979360163211823,
0.3367367386817932,
0.1502712070941925,
-0.2069879025220871,
-0.06768061965703964,
0.06970041245222092,
-0.0839080736041069,
-0.3130989372730255,
0.1209162101149559,
0.2524785101413727,
0.4685904383659363,
-0.32345062494277954,
-0.31167250871658325,
-0.8632694482803345,
0.5338564515113831,
0.389426589012146,
-0.5312325954437256,
0.28553301095962524,
0.6329108476638794,
-0.5682713389396667,
-0.12101766467094421,
-0.5859377384185791,
-0.12759920954704285,
-0.428466260433197,
0.44482606649398804,
-0.5952615141868591,
-0.991245448589325,
0.69347083568573,
-0.5594042539596558,
0.004997664131224155,
0.4441288113594055,
0.509173572063446,
-0.42778822779655457,
1.2558964490890503,
0.6034666299819946,
-0.0808945819735527,
0.43215492367744446,
0.13198912143707275,
0.18791702389717102,
-0.8055095672607422,
-0.4454852044582367,
-1.0089620351791382,
-0.699518084526062,
-0.665220320224762,
0.27221789956092834,
0.5430892705917358,
0.0004801263858098537,
-0.4213597774505615,
0.11019910126924515,
-0.22332991659641266,
0.15064869821071625,
0.64504474401474,
0.25191906094551086,
-0.09664306789636612,
-0.24748414754867554,
0.058436136692762375,
-0.1896747201681137,
-0.3698120415210724,
-0.0676216408610344,
0.736626148223877,
0.17917931079864502,
0.7133231163024902,
-0.08329229056835175,
0.8442378640174866,
0.5345051884651184,
0.05628064647316933,
-0.5359190702438354,
0.637507975101471,
-0.6042407155036926,
-0.14656169712543488,
-0.08041954040527344,
-0.43646013736724854,
-0.9315121173858643,
-0.013662595301866531,
0.004430601838976145,
-0.879707396030426,
0.5575253963470459,
0.34567490220069885,
-0.4777437150478363,
0.245039701461792,
-0.42187806963920593,
0.8377764225006104,
-0.29255813360214233,
-0.20826131105422974,
-0.25800833106040955,
-0.9133808016777039,
-0.027163555845618248,
0.20880696177482605,
-0.08061954379081726,
-0.5993965268135071,
0.22047466039657593,
0.5420787930488586,
-0.554115355014801,
0.47796374559402466,
-0.374740868806839,
-0.014813391491770744,
0.17189562320709229,
0.15241238474845886,
0.6731411218643188,
-0.48132213950157166,
-0.2614254653453827,
-0.3655349910259247,
-0.18415117263793945,
-0.3355165421962738,
-0.6009032130241394,
0.5613186955451965,
-0.6225346326828003,
-0.34708622097969055,
-0.6105703115463257,
-0.33328977227211,
-0.5324691534042358,
-0.012446829117834568,
0.335944801568985,
0.7386247515678406,
-0.3969776928424835,
0.43027594685554504,
0.8389755487442017,
-0.1598385125398636,
0.29540833830833435,
0.42423978447914124,
0.005484487395733595,
-0.5216459631919861,
0.7453882694244385,
0.08987580239772797,
0.15983794629573822,
0.28784090280532837,
0.3112999498844147,
-0.4109918475151062,
-0.47570380568504333,
-0.06290018558502197,
-0.07424826920032501,
-0.6572239398956299,
-0.14577068388462067,
-0.4008340537548065,
-0.18900072574615479,
-0.7221576571464539,
0.15193472802639008,
-0.653551459312439,
-0.0844549685716629,
-0.3989492952823639,
0.18837127089500427,
0.41900646686553955,
0.6922327876091003,
-0.4641181528568268,
0.01710471510887146,
-0.7307717204093933,
0.20108932256698608,
0.47635525465011597,
0.4505905508995056,
0.06789474934339523,
-0.6479375958442688,
-0.37856921553611755,
-0.0790565013885498,
0.007184345740824938,
-0.8156476616859436,
0.2697112262248993,
0.39445939660072327,
0.3968278765678406,
0.1784357726573944,
0.14703048765659332,
0.7348396182060242,
-0.48283565044403076,
0.7944971919059753,
0.12406793981790543,
-1.149715781211853,
0.6806929111480713,
0.056909073144197464,
0.4257698953151703,
0.645520031452179,
0.6318800449371338,
-0.6019466519355774,
0.24187111854553223,
-0.7363961935043335,
-0.8303676247596741,
0.5086977481842041,
0.06866385042667389,
-0.23230259120464325,
0.2931564748287201,
0.6444826722145081,
0.1384480744600296,
0.3484656810760498,
-0.39867493510246277,
-0.14714597165584564,
-0.03785465285181999,
-0.3323099911212921,
-0.024217624217271805,
-0.39446717500686646,
0.09819724410772324,
-0.3730316460132599,
0.6789953708648682,
-0.0493357814848423,
0.45307764410972595,
0.2700834274291992,
-0.006347384303808212,
-0.2831946313381195,
0.23632729053497314,
0.5384249091148376,
0.0958000048995018,
-0.35130053758621216,
0.04503028467297554,
0.18123754858970642,
-0.39294713735580444,
0.39163562655448914,
0.4259902238845825,
0.1378747522830963,
-0.128446564078331,
0.23907534778118134,
1.6775377988815308,
0.246576189994812,
-0.8183570504188538,
0.34098145365715027,
-0.09156417846679688,
-0.3481723964214325,
-0.14924293756484985,
-0.17949755489826202,
-0.4891340136528015,
0.7965947985649109,
0.33790114521980286,
-0.26076170802116394,
0.5094851851463318,
-0.512194812297821,
0.21749798953533173,
0.28145143389701843,
-0.6775239109992981,
-0.2528629004955292,
0.7817389965057373,
0.09736506640911102,
-0.4460151791572571,
0.5765474438667297,
-0.3152018189430237,
-0.714342474937439,
0.7786878347396851,
0.4338478446006775,
1.34602689743042,
-0.6492241024971008,
0.05049421638250351,
0.36959290504455566,
0.13863788545131683,
-0.15722006559371948,
0.6089586019515991,
-0.27506980299949646,
-0.5341057181358337,
-0.175527885556221,
-0.3415602445602417,
-1.0757330656051636,
0.1714174747467041,
-1.0637098550796509,
0.22743725776672363,
-0.43494912981987,
-0.2858079671859741,
0.07952851057052612,
0.24612466990947723,
-0.6135329008102417,
0.6267598867416382,
0.6109591126441956,
0.9748853445053101,
-0.6477787494659424,
0.46825355291366577,
0.7681148648262024,
-0.07588468492031097,
-0.49574393033981323,
-0.15437448024749756,
0.22061628103256226,
-0.6331509947776794,
0.521694540977478,
0.1507737785577774,
-0.2138025164604187,
0.24117545783519745,
-0.7662332057952881,
-0.802102267742157,
0.8185834288597107,
0.28478536009788513,
-0.8548620343208313,
0.11435366421937943,
0.01652195304632187,
0.6097543239593506,
-0.26700928807258606,
0.15104246139526367,
0.658883273601532,
0.24018414318561554,
-0.06985209137201309,
-1.0666583776474,
-0.39289048314094543,
-0.44391191005706787,
-0.19653692841529846,
0.21521413326263428,
-1.079786777496338,
1.0176916122436523,
-0.09557361900806427,
-0.14701221883296967,
0.2907504141330719,
0.9708506464958191,
0.3381216824054718,
0.620613157749176,
0.6477867960929871,
0.9410386681556702,
0.8939394950866699,
-0.34117987751960754,
0.7592418789863586,
0.09765931963920593,
0.4824621081352234,
1.2241352796554565,
-0.7074750065803528,
0.8979241847991943,
0.04213252663612366,
-0.5621058344841003,
0.21565918624401093,
0.8088194131851196,
0.022698916494846344,
0.6838976144790649,
0.3196669816970825,
-0.2935599982738495,
-0.2583041787147522,
-0.2876448333263397,
-0.600128710269928,
0.514699399471283,
0.24465209245681763,
0.09129873663187027,
-0.14562085270881653,
0.45518213510513306,
-0.158988818526268,
-0.05222903564572334,
-0.5496993064880371,
0.881271243095398,
0.16032613813877106,
-0.2804147005081177,
0.38526472449302673,
-0.5043430328369141,
0.4414670765399933,
-0.630850613117218,
0.17324446141719818,
-0.41790151596069336,
0.2109462469816208,
0.0909489095211029,
-0.6392003297805786,
-0.018521199002861977,
0.26410675048828125,
0.04247783496975899,
-0.0325508788228035,
0.7340422868728638,
-0.5226306915283203,
-0.18012191355228424,
0.2634974718093872,
0.06733059138059616,
0.2397027611732483,
-0.2318163812160492,
-0.8383957147598267,
0.47769132256507874,
-0.07808104157447815,
-0.33678677678108215,
0.2891865670681,
0.8336781859397888,
0.45844265818595886,
0.7187276482582092,
0.08937012404203415,
-0.06792889535427094,
0.17517460882663727,
0.2022058218717575,
0.5816936492919922,
-0.8763093948364258,
-0.6203652620315552,
-0.6426085233688354,
0.5150904059410095,
0.06636866182088852,
-0.6678400635719299,
0.37924230098724365,
0.41043564677238464,
0.6515846848487854,
0.2177402526140213,
0.6498056650161743,
0.06746064871549606,
0.8747916221618652,
-0.31598642468452454,
0.3436950743198395,
-1.0060255527496338,
-0.3559113144874573,
-0.47501417994499207,
-0.5795327425003052,
-0.0062479241751134396,
0.4806506931781769,
0.019113577902317047,
0.05647231638431549,
0.4534793198108673,
0.2765031158924103,
0.23733365535736084,
0.4130733013153076,
0.16370873153209686,
0.3536364436149597,
0.29925960302352905,
0.7172302603721619,
0.9656639099121094,
-0.5157132148742676,
0.05766770988702774,
-0.7035724520683289,
-0.2862565219402313,
-0.4401834309101105,
-1.049939513206482,
-0.15710356831550598,
-1.0283464193344116,
-0.5096701383590698,
-0.4846462905406952,
0.16483458876609802,
1.1717379093170166,
0.41266876459121704,
-1.015486240386963,
-0.24346788227558136,
-0.09291454404592514,
-0.4060589373111725,
-0.46882322430610657,
-0.11117788404226303,
0.22377341985702515,
-0.2054419219493866,
-0.8547878265380859,
0.6710448861122131,
0.32427388429641724,
0.332981675863266,
-0.209911048412323,
-0.07908429950475693,
-0.21737408638000488,
0.005338715389370918,
0.5278646349906921,
0.6998308300971985,
-0.6093112826347351,
-0.3367266058921814,
-0.1364327371120453,
0.047000423073768616,
0.22006073594093323,
0.7788680791854858,
-0.782874345779419,
0.5096307992935181,
0.522686779499054,
0.9735240936279297,
0.6654497385025024,
-0.19090399146080017,
0.38702771067619324,
-0.4360106587409973,
0.19267338514328003,
0.6123320460319519,
0.5027931332588196,
0.20038370788097382,
-0.001928596175275743,
0.6630561947822571,
0.36448559165000916,
-0.879435122013092,
-1.4254834651947021,
0.18837757408618927,
-1.0900757312774658,
0.1625593602657318,
0.4799115061759949,
-0.14193212985992432,
-0.02237648516893387,
0.4003021717071533,
-0.09257384389638901,
0.5032410621643066,
-0.38102400302886963,
0.7820279002189636,
0.9639905095100403,
-0.599125325679779,
-0.5980077385902405,
-0.12131369113922119,
0.6711107492446899,
0.6197817325592041,
-0.986885666847229,
0.06675675511360168,
0.40609854459762573,
-0.23708754777908325,
-0.17557035386562347,
0.43479061126708984,
-0.06525786966085434,
0.5467309951782227,
0.03864400088787079,
0.2558608651161194,
0.2748202681541443,
-0.5948903560638428,
-0.7219143509864807,
0.09005843847990036,
0.0003873657260555774,
-0.060952167958021164
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.06399v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.06399v1
|
Should We Fine-Tune or RAG? Evaluating Different Techniques to Adapt LLMs for Dialogue
| 2024-06-10T15:52:49 | 2024-06-10T15:52:49 |
Simone Alghisi, Massimo Rizzoli, Gabriel Roccabruna, Seyed Mahed Mousavi, Giuseppe Riccardi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We study the limitations of Large Language Models (LLMs) for the task of
response generation in human-machine dialogue. Several techniques have been
proposed in the literature for different dialogue types (e.g., Open-Domain).
However, the evaluations of these techniques have been limited in terms of base
LLMs, dialogue types and evaluation metrics. In this work, we extensively
analyze different LLM adaptation techniques when applied to different dialogue
types. We have selected two base LLMs, Llama-2 and Mistral, and four dialogue
types Open-Domain, Knowledge-Grounded, Task-Oriented, and Question Answering.
We evaluate the performance of in-context learning and fine-tuning techniques
across datasets selected for each dialogue type. We assess the impact of
incorporating external knowledge to ground the generation in both scenarios of
Retrieval-Augmented Generation (RAG) and gold knowledge. We adopt consistent
evaluation and explainability criteria for automatic metrics and human
evaluation protocols. Our analysis shows that there is no universal
best-technique for adapting large language models as the efficacy of each
technique depends on both the base LLM and the specific type of dialogue. Last
but not least, the assessment of the best adaptation technique should include
human evaluation to avoid false expectations and outcomes derived from
automatic metrics.
|
[
-0.5672600269317627,
-0.6455751657485962,
0.3494672477245331,
0.02476840652525425,
-0.2643773555755615,
0.11793940514326096,
-0.39380013942718506,
-0.37306535243988037,
-0.2524073123931885,
0.7332273721694946,
-0.47257694602012634,
-0.28060945868492126,
-0.2661885917186737,
0.3277193307876587,
0.045362915843725204,
1.3495374917984009,
0.07115905731916428,
0.19270874559879303,
-0.2690638601779938,
-0.2770489454269409,
-0.8191960453987122,
-0.4062103033065796,
-0.8301330208778381,
-0.39312607049942017,
0.22982090711593628,
0.5321760773658752,
0.3710763454437256,
0.21500393748283386,
0.6470194458961487,
0.2856021821498871,
-0.16045355796813965,
0.6192030310630798,
-0.8808439373970032,
0.13607846200466156,
-0.47889721393585205,
-0.6016591787338257,
-0.36382296681404114,
-0.13488639891147614,
0.543601393699646,
0.6564887762069702,
-0.02876483090221882,
0.5158728361129761,
0.25920453667640686,
0.7777746319770813,
-0.6867799162864685,
-0.0476805754005909,
-0.9238389730453491,
-0.09898310154676437,
0.09577345848083496,
-0.5251169800758362,
-0.2616354823112488,
-0.3364979326725006,
0.272559255361557,
-0.5678970217704773,
0.22497963905334473,
0.1594608724117279,
0.6360614895820618,
0.5255199074745178,
-0.24006786942481995,
-0.5112054944038391,
-0.9261835813522339,
0.8285468220710754,
-0.7603950500488281,
0.07919121533632278,
0.40829455852508545,
0.4615618586540222,
-0.4461522400379181,
-0.5225229859352112,
-0.2600513994693756,
-0.3104458153247833,
-0.020024074241518974,
0.34191498160362244,
-0.05021930858492851,
0.11244264990091324,
0.3081730008125305,
0.4450075924396515,
-0.2434529960155487,
0.24535039067268372,
-0.17283779382705688,
-0.070452019572258,
0.6149260997772217,
0.47447192668914795,
-0.06917357444763184,
-0.20389394462108612,
-0.24704113602638245,
-0.013059883378446102,
-0.5892645120620728,
-0.008537926711142063,
0.32794415950775146,
0.42094922065734863,
-0.06292729079723358,
0.33988243341445923,
-0.28342288732528687,
0.8286019563674927,
0.4242144227027893,
-0.5598847270011902,
-0.174455463886261,
-0.5051501989364624,
-0.29691803455352783,
-0.3079395294189453,
0.6120165586471558,
0.7635713815689087,
0.40636923909187317,
-0.19763252139091492,
-0.21185816824436188,
-0.09932702034711838,
0.43452000617980957,
-0.6391910910606384,
0.15457426011562347,
-0.1866394281387329,
-0.45798689126968384,
-0.23858505487442017,
-0.16616609692573547,
-0.8105291128158569,
-0.5490765571594238,
-0.4612955152988434,
0.5612416863441467,
-0.18323592841625214,
-0.12399259209632874,
0.13002894818782806,
-0.1919887214899063,
0.40145131945610046,
0.47763919830322266,
-0.7095918655395508,
0.6612104177474976,
0.6698673963546753,
0.4738039970397949,
-0.24986135959625244,
0.14609819650650024,
-0.6118865013122559,
-0.04114551097154617,
-0.43961989879608154,
0.8076035380363464,
-0.30867624282836914,
-0.5351919531822205,
0.028067104518413544,
-0.05272054672241211,
-0.24592377245426178,
-0.900905191898346,
0.912111759185791,
-0.31159940361976624,
0.28995591402053833,
-0.20093484222888947,
-0.4589357078075409,
-0.3299602270126343,
0.10694517940282822,
-0.4474559426307678,
0.6939366459846497,
0.49426648020744324,
-0.7293212413787842,
0.16668228805065155,
-0.6812105774879456,
-0.3008774518966675,
-0.1049303263425827,
0.07792271673679352,
-0.2696744203567505,
0.4698670208454132,
0.08376554399728775,
0.21590609848499298,
-0.7710978984832764,
0.1768006831407547,
-0.17513099312782288,
-0.40505656599998474,
0.5312274694442749,
-0.4836962819099426,
0.41638636589050293,
0.5399047136306763,
-0.11539214849472046,
0.047444578260183334,
-0.7458856105804443,
0.15264031291007996,
-0.11540035158395767,
-0.38863298296928406,
-0.10276038199663162,
0.06966999173164368,
-0.1782589852809906,
-0.03594977781176567,
-0.07540227472782135,
-0.22735480964183807,
-0.06895620375871658,
-0.6637499928474426,
0.23652206361293793,
0.7600778937339783,
0.2547423243522644,
0.4234551191329956,
-0.6544637084007263,
0.5471128225326538,
-0.08589343726634979,
-0.17781899869441986,
-0.1683785319328308,
-0.06299805641174316,
-1.1143519878387451,
-0.03364701196551323,
0.33633705973625183,
0.688578188419342,
-0.6028620600700378,
0.3546251356601715,
-0.22299718856811523,
-0.4475404918193817,
-0.6696203947067261,
0.15078724920749664,
0.5467200875282288,
0.6483095288276672,
0.1362311691045761,
-0.6981725692749023,
-0.6700947880744934,
-0.7429518699645996,
-0.5737308263778687,
-0.3019702434539795,
-0.09002542495727539,
0.685049831867218,
0.1930021345615387,
-0.10656872391700745,
0.9429916143417358,
-0.26280415058135986,
-0.10639472305774689,
-0.29214295744895935,
0.04890592768788338,
0.12565423548221588,
0.1697312742471695,
0.46700501441955566,
-0.45013558864593506,
-0.5186644196510315,
0.08354836702346802,
-0.5550254583358765,
-0.3201714754104614,
-0.21837222576141357,
0.014847596175968647,
0.43345823884010315,
0.30755752325057983,
-0.3575657606124878,
0.33177071809768677,
0.4859274625778198,
-0.06665433943271637,
0.528289794921875,
-0.05948159098625183,
0.3064127266407013,
-1.2145699262619019,
0.024619903415441513,
0.07470948994159698,
-0.32459208369255066,
-0.841099202632904,
-0.010322303511202335,
-0.26460957527160645,
-0.012750912457704544,
-0.3227238953113556,
0.7283118963241577,
-0.2713291049003601,
-0.27029740810394287,
-0.3361921012401581,
0.13490436971187592,
0.05568704754114151,
0.47762590646743774,
-0.26209133863449097,
1.0174813270568848,
0.19565941393375397,
-0.8593325614929199,
0.2772541344165802,
0.2230672538280487,
-0.5075092315673828,
0.5754594802856445,
-0.5241251587867737,
0.3803500235080719,
-0.0756804570555687,
0.3538445234298706,
-1.0624125003814697,
-0.2591421604156494,
0.33644768595695496,
-0.4317942261695862,
0.4182376563549042,
-0.1950378268957138,
-0.2688892185688019,
-0.10622603446245193,
-0.2931998074054718,
0.21193717420101166,
0.6054710745811462,
-0.43456345796585083,
0.4863012731075287,
0.22522921860218048,
-0.2990674078464508,
-0.3104664385318756,
-0.2201734185218811,
0.03041466698050499,
-0.7055620551109314,
-0.6155133247375488,
0.06303530186414719,
-0.27231812477111816,
-0.5197585225105286,
-0.45736366510391235,
-0.32331693172454834,
0.006726617459207773,
0.33100998401641846,
0.10679017007350922,
0.023237640038132668,
-0.3125708997249603,
-0.0928548201918602,
-0.11170137673616409,
-0.10186763107776642,
-0.160563126206398,
-0.08377593010663986,
0.3689560294151306,
-0.12373733520507812,
-0.2660823166370392,
-0.3585844039916992,
0.18227024376392365,
0.3806799650192261,
0.004877820145338774,
0.36470019817352295,
0.6934013366699219,
-0.0012045548064634204,
-0.03317048400640488,
-0.7056727409362793,
-0.21141426265239716,
-0.4508524239063263,
0.3384924829006195,
-0.3638139069080353,
-1.043764591217041,
0.37390023469924927,
-0.6222164034843445,
0.10582320392131805,
0.422525554895401,
0.8677003979682922,
-0.2180921584367752,
0.8686387538909912,
0.7276096940040588,
-0.07561473548412323,
0.3954814374446869,
-0.015859078615903854,
0.12666885554790497,
-1.171627163887024,
0.21532289683818817,
-0.7496421337127686,
-0.1601850837469101,
-0.7257627248764038,
-0.46417656540870667,
0.4529873728752136,
0.39865174889564514,
-0.18460813164710999,
0.08134915679693222,
-0.23756510019302368,
0.26429829001426697,
0.29023489356040955,
-0.08175733685493469,
0.3612443804740906,
0.16298745572566986,
0.13210409879684448,
-0.02787315659224987,
-0.8222413659095764,
-0.6682897210121155,
1.175384759902954,
0.44357621669769287,
0.9578400254249573,
0.0961158499121666,
0.5030856132507324,
0.03734190762042999,
0.28619900345802307,
-1.0669091939926147,
0.4369330406188965,
-0.22659575939178467,
-0.33419057726860046,
-0.3057362139225006,
-0.42039021849632263,
-1.0548663139343262,
0.24693040549755096,
-0.13677389919757843,
-0.6481778025627136,
-0.2573640048503876,
-0.03194383159279823,
-0.46736621856689453,
-0.07825683802366257,
-0.7041855454444885,
0.4981704354286194,
-0.16279442608356476,
-0.031112225726246834,
-0.15914788842201233,
-0.6350827813148499,
0.3152965009212494,
-0.27400556206703186,
0.3311046063899994,
-0.10517530888319016,
0.083931103348732,
0.6266027688980103,
-0.12477356195449829,
0.9047065377235413,
-0.025776531547307968,
-0.25679221749305725,
0.42792898416519165,
0.08060607314109802,
0.39172855019569397,
-0.019909264519810677,
-0.0743902400135994,
-0.13277766108512878,
0.05238503962755203,
0.04896736145019531,
-0.6710188388824463,
0.3794981837272644,
-0.9229056239128113,
-0.9500032663345337,
-0.007476016413420439,
-0.7085668444633484,
-0.5702003836631775,
-0.10763803124427795,
0.19370009005069733,
0.41065919399261475,
-0.4319887161254883,
0.12030351907014847,
0.7126511335372925,
-0.37718063592910767,
0.12030649930238724,
0.8008111119270325,
-0.028059108182787895,
-0.5067112445831299,
0.9776369333267212,
-0.02300938591361046,
0.6083464622497559,
0.285316526889801,
0.39688870310783386,
-0.12132492661476135,
-0.5863988995552063,
-0.44564417004585266,
0.2802696228027344,
-0.7060531377792358,
-0.4173203110694885,
-0.25694218277931213,
-0.23549367487430573,
-0.45731663703918457,
0.12752315402030945,
-0.00575658306479454,
-0.538902223110199,
-0.5106995701789856,
0.1614648848772049,
0.44304004311561584,
0.5100412964820862,
-0.019625630229711533,
0.27649983763694763,
-0.8074872493743896,
0.5908126831054688,
0.29890450835227966,
0.28426727652549744,
-0.2510448098182678,
-1.0341911315917969,
-0.3629879057407379,
0.19038045406341553,
-0.5349878668785095,
-0.4788033962249756,
0.14359821379184723,
0.44849491119384766,
0.5926486253738403,
0.16360712051391602,
0.15488141775131226,
0.796151876449585,
-0.677707850933075,
0.7521669864654541,
-0.018485281616449356,
-0.553638756275177,
0.3939897119998932,
-0.33464643359184265,
0.26514124870300293,
0.5743667483329773,
0.17785939574241638,
-0.566530704498291,
-0.44595906138420105,
-0.502237856388092,
-0.5225518941879272,
0.700387179851532,
-0.004135260358452797,
0.25457853078842163,
0.13441085815429688,
0.40620705485343933,
0.3292878270149231,
0.12259577214717865,
-0.1437377780675888,
0.0064337411895394325,
0.06186019629240036,
-0.1723954975605011,
-0.231052964925766,
-0.16337376832962036,
-0.6160480976104736,
-0.023374779149889946,
0.36177194118499756,
-0.4437616765499115,
0.3033986985683441,
0.12208111584186554,
-0.18943074345588684,
-0.3779577612876892,
0.48601704835891724,
0.7365872859954834,
0.7315133213996887,
-0.06129808351397514,
-0.37978610396385193,
0.5656539797782898,
-0.2201673537492752,
-0.0406201146543026,
-0.21812549233436584,
-0.061422985047101974,
-0.014829170890152454,
0.2956434488296509,
1.1497306823730469,
0.14716966450214386,
-0.6519073247909546,
0.07363076508045197,
-0.09089062362909317,
-0.19542622566223145,
-0.16349434852600098,
0.45227107405662537,
-0.10402144491672516,
0.3170839846134186,
0.12729021906852722,
0.09330770373344421,
0.23783765733242035,
-0.6524253487586975,
-0.13239048421382904,
0.555105447769165,
-0.22813032567501068,
-0.19885599613189697,
0.1697002649307251,
0.3040802478790283,
-0.5929879546165466,
0.10325086861848831,
0.20291365683078766,
-0.33516794443130493,
0.43577536940574646,
0.5427649617195129,
0.9917858242988586,
-0.2200307995080948,
0.035804033279418945,
0.30094560980796814,
0.11333171278238297,
0.03470352664589882,
0.09290925413370132,
-0.08760281652212143,
-0.8172363042831421,
-0.5395676493644714,
-0.8242908716201782,
-0.5640354752540588,
0.3005661964416504,
-0.805047869682312,
0.15372946858406067,
-0.3697374165058136,
-0.25514674186706543,
-0.15035726130008698,
0.1761263608932495,
-0.7676959037780762,
0.07596655935049057,
-0.04244139418005943,
0.9857912659645081,
-0.5696836709976196,
0.4496481120586395,
0.6403329968452454,
-0.06733318418264389,
-0.6893413066864014,
0.15941846370697021,
0.05763702094554901,
-0.8002851009368896,
0.48296603560447693,
-0.1453874707221985,
-0.27218255400657654,
0.038309842348098755,
-0.4895257353782654,
-0.8098362684249878,
0.9701384902000427,
0.3299768269062042,
-0.3485506772994995,
0.1440913826227188,
0.06362803280353546,
0.6750112175941467,
-0.48465245962142944,
0.2659206986427307,
0.930585503578186,
0.3700869381427765,
0.06203906610608101,
-1.4948816299438477,
-0.22549764811992645,
0.20145666599273682,
0.36006173491477966,
0.040616389364004135,
-0.7833656072616577,
0.2894245684146881,
-0.1281736046075821,
-0.2772262692451477,
0.6571353673934937,
0.35429996252059937,
0.2713005542755127,
0.20379658043384552,
0.46947646141052246,
0.5045314431190491,
0.6131159663200378,
-0.037205491214990616,
0.9593013525009155,
-0.18433219194412231,
0.19674766063690186,
1.1774386167526245,
-0.25991183519363403,
0.6318991184234619,
0.3893278241157532,
-0.1632540374994278,
0.2808428108692169,
0.5569517016410828,
0.1394340991973877,
0.49420681595802307,
0.4745388329029083,
-0.19350957870483398,
-0.14830954372882843,
-0.37501823902130127,
-0.27696725726127625,
0.5611339807510376,
0.6911647915840149,
-0.09781835228204727,
-0.31783822178840637,
-0.12087728083133698,
-0.07394424080848694,
0.1869162768125534,
-0.37555935978889465,
1.4804941415786743,
0.17801038920879364,
-0.9838813543319702,
1.1488091945648193,
0.16650350391864777,
0.4931626319885254,
-0.43787235021591187,
0.008651655167341232,
-0.29497987031936646,
0.09000161290168762,
-0.1851852685213089,
-0.5734848380088806,
0.1496558040380478,
0.28314799070358276,
-0.1830119788646698,
0.026853447780013084,
0.9179849624633789,
-0.32902196049690247,
-0.21619771420955658,
0.008645489811897278,
0.5946076512336731,
0.3221510052680969,
0.2820468842983246,
-0.7245428562164307,
0.1607082039117813,
0.03194589540362358,
-0.24915604293346405,
0.6399930119514465,
0.7250289916992188,
-0.1445889174938202,
0.6868351697921753,
0.5596296191215515,
-0.008561826311051846,
-0.15256758034229279,
0.401760458946228,
0.9606058597564697,
-0.41710180044174194,
0.04093465581536293,
-0.4849689304828644,
0.49500125646591187,
0.11580231040716171,
-0.2115439623594284,
0.7313978672027588,
0.2564941644668579,
0.7448943853378296,
0.004486044868826866,
0.9174540042877197,
0.31428343057632446,
0.9102297425270081,
-0.6445008516311646,
0.3207629919052124,
-0.3580930233001709,
0.1602085381746292,
-0.48083731532096863,
-1.014532446861267,
0.07404869794845581,
0.6604518890380859,
-0.1117594763636589,
0.06540966778993607,
0.6397322416305542,
0.8083076477050781,
0.1752074658870697,
0.004318849183619022,
0.42865338921546936,
0.16262726485729218,
0.20964288711547852,
0.45400547981262207,
0.9433960318565369,
-0.33647722005844116,
0.5662112832069397,
0.2231973111629486,
-0.3282695710659027,
-0.37803900241851807,
-0.8352127075195312,
-0.8915980458259583,
-0.3730137050151825,
-0.0560099333524704,
-0.2760901153087616,
0.05492977425456047,
0.7273772954940796,
0.4735945165157318,
-0.6239483952522278,
-0.566753089427948,
0.1927640736103058,
-0.048424769192934036,
-0.08590784668922424,
-0.23993940651416779,
-0.07435465604066849,
-0.8457220792770386,
-0.6184222102165222,
0.471474826335907,
0.2598367929458618,
-0.06182311847805977,
-0.10861476510763168,
-0.243769571185112,
0.2120676338672638,
0.27952462434768677,
0.7108575701713562,
0.27793899178504944,
-0.8847574591636658,
-0.566716730594635,
0.030033515766263008,
0.015291353687644005,
0.00604844419285655,
0.9461120963096619,
-0.6903884410858154,
0.5455200672149658,
0.301798939704895,
0.9074007272720337,
0.25926223397254944,
0.2127450406551361,
0.8123330473899841,
-0.5365498661994934,
-0.01380070298910141,
0.26661333441734314,
0.0681159719824791,
0.39218688011169434,
-0.06711018085479736,
0.6692936420440674,
-0.050298500806093216,
-0.8515339493751526,
-0.8745889067649841,
0.510299801826477,
-0.8491690158843994,
-0.10146340727806091,
1.3090474605560303,
-0.08691568672657013,
0.09052298218011856,
-0.25179949402809143,
-0.6139901280403137,
0.28770124912261963,
-0.17416296899318695,
0.7158594727516174,
0.7689124941825867,
-0.34258192777633667,
-0.023395340889692307,
-0.6910661458969116,
0.71681809425354,
0.42029672861099243,
-0.6760788559913635,
0.16628485918045044,
0.4020957052707672,
0.3789348006248474,
0.10729918628931046,
0.5871124863624573,
0.04776843264698982,
0.23432539403438568,
-0.3218156695365906,
-0.3742498457431793,
0.3334033489227295,
-0.22479256987571716,
-0.456699937582016,
-0.2671110928058624,
0.48873162269592285,
0.16712792217731476
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.