id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05990v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05990v2
|
Constructing Vec-tionaries to Extract Message Features from Texts: A Case Study of Moral Appeals
| 2023-12-10T20:37:29 | 2024-03-09T04:55:47 |
Zening Duan, Anqi Shao, Yicheng Hu, Heysung Lee, Xining Liao, Yoo Ji Suh, Jisoo Kim, Kai-Cheng Yang, Kaiping Chen, Sijia Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
While researchers often study message features like moral content in text,
such as party manifestos and social media, their quantification remains a
challenge. Conventional human coding struggles with scalability and intercoder
reliability. While dictionary-based methods are cost-effective and
computationally efficient, they often lack contextual sensitivity and are
limited by the vocabularies developed for the original applications. In this
paper, we present an approach to construct vec-tionary measurement tools that
boost validated dictionaries with word embeddings through nonlinear
optimization. By harnessing semantic relationships encoded by embeddings,
vec-tionaries improve the measurement of message features from text, especially
those in short format, by expanding the applicability of original vocabularies
to other contexts. Importantly, a vec-tionary can produce additional metrics to
capture the valence and ambivalence of a message feature beyond its strength in
texts. Using moral content in tweets as a case study, we illustrate the steps
to construct the moral foundations vec-tionary, showcasing its ability to
process texts missed by conventional dictionaries and word embedding methods
and to produce measurements better aligned with crowdsourced human assessments.
Furthermore, additional metrics from the vec-tionary unveiled unique insights
that facilitated predicting outcomes such as message retransmission.
|
[
-0.3253467083,
-0.6346536875,
0.5956447124,
0.2960635722,
-0.5599215031,
0.2229202986,
-0.2359794676,
-0.0722701252,
0.4910660982,
0.3798209727,
-0.3639132977,
-0.3871673644,
-0.6894591451,
0.15717493,
-0.5239390731,
1.2179555893,
0.0445225462,
-0.1473209262,
-0.2958029211,
-0.5287870765,
-0.2235635221,
-0.5205054879,
-0.2982127964,
-0.0336599946,
0.3995644152,
0.1804620922,
0.5039037466,
0.6512290835,
0.4466913939,
0.3176124096,
-0.1846169382,
0.2486037761,
-0.7761615515,
-0.0432992801,
-0.484774828,
-0.3174925148,
-0.1379472464,
0.2671259344,
0.3985937238,
0.260572046,
0.0080169821,
0.2876570821,
0.3051259518,
0.5655380487,
-0.7611036301,
0.0191039536,
-0.5561404228,
0.1958546937,
-0.1444547325,
-0.7849494219,
-0.0570383035,
-0.8251428008,
0.254093498,
-0.5032995343,
-0.0329467617,
-0.0932136551,
1.0423673391,
0.2414059192,
-0.4263858497,
-1.0402500629,
-0.4144012034,
1.2058095932,
-0.2957650721,
0.381673187,
0.4500612319,
-0.0555222817,
-0.0025569396,
-0.7716112137,
-0.5374782085,
-0.3364346027,
0.0713102147,
0.1855362058,
-0.3525376022,
-0.1282390505,
-0.1859707385,
0.3913040161,
0.221784696,
-0.4090920687,
-0.0897233486,
-0.3106821477,
0.4801966846,
0.3286367357,
0.2297004312,
-0.6665207744,
-0.5113249421,
-0.1940837204,
-0.3901235163,
0.370783776,
0.3378198445,
-0.0902633294,
-0.2994956076,
0.8654255867,
0.4014697671,
-0.050658334,
0.0780635402,
0.0181607511,
0.1941765994,
-1.0473704338,
0.1955000758,
-0.1594899595,
0.7928670049,
0.5364505053,
0.5270880461,
0.1314915121,
-0.1661204845,
0.0770954043,
0.508464694,
-1.0084302425,
0.1199545711,
0.1366464198,
-0.5047551394,
-0.7791782618,
-0.032557711,
-0.6347845197,
-0.360580802,
-0.1552519947,
0.201243341,
-0.5553609133,
-0.0958450884,
0.1351204067,
-0.3071780205,
0.1366000026,
0.1302053183,
-0.6236041188,
0.0122607024,
0.8363992572,
1.1142419577,
0.1858764589,
0.1431966871,
-0.8206985593,
0.0847070366,
-0.2263546288,
0.5857746601,
-0.6345309019,
-0.5188812017,
0.3128266931,
-0.0864340886,
0.4638164639,
0.0757737681,
1.1495828629,
-0.0771574527,
0.0246305224,
-0.5221447945,
-0.6773535609,
-0.0186405275,
0.3445757031,
-0.4891206324,
0.7151373625,
0.0482732356,
-0.9397067428,
0.4608612061,
-0.297758013,
-0.4896616936,
0.0280191489,
-0.3514610231,
-0.5760758519,
0.7445526123,
0.1567663401,
0.564019084,
-0.5029724836,
0.0450463109,
-0.4477253854,
-0.4452136457,
0.463044703,
-0.5827203393,
0.8848444819,
0.1234755442,
-0.237188369,
-0.0224099178,
-0.4272637963,
0.1331075877,
0.02044769,
-0.4405146241,
-0.6652263999,
0.4467794895,
0.1638169587,
-0.1724858284,
0.343115747,
-0.5987790227,
-0.2201576084,
-0.7922118306,
0.7386789918,
0.8037013412,
0.0317372531,
0.3865407705,
-0.2946725786,
0.2172345072,
-0.3042775989,
0.3459918797,
0.3806870282,
-0.3015550375,
-0.5656806827,
-0.3698895574,
-0.227308929,
0.4551219642,
-0.679289341,
0.5795622468,
-0.5665667653,
-0.2768834829,
-0.5141439438,
0.1216942444,
0.5457963943,
0.2342389226,
0.0309864953,
-0.1277602464,
-0.1623985767,
-0.6508597136,
-0.5311732292,
-0.6602592468,
-0.053560324,
0.4522990286,
0.6963452101,
-0.021367088,
0.8910630345,
-0.2870298326,
-0.3231113255,
0.0551462136,
-0.1454324573,
0.1189216971,
0.0866715387,
0.7039543986,
-1.093824029,
-0.231420204,
0.2417455167,
-0.5525305867,
-0.0684474632,
-0.0012988701,
0.0004118787,
-0.2516452372,
0.1781715602,
-0.0972159952,
0.5540310144,
0.3853537142,
-0.5670489073,
0.3991375566,
-0.0681649894,
0.4738017619,
-1.2103996277,
-0.3399184942,
0.0501037315,
-0.3585833311,
-0.335521698,
-0.3454081416,
-0.0355064906,
0.4271882474,
-0.4598968029,
0.4894274175,
-0.0833888873,
0.1124722585,
-0.077694416,
0.5256006718,
0.1817611754,
0.0854071453,
-0.271361351,
0.7637944221,
0.1830467582,
-0.3851268888,
0.5250888467,
0.4788603187,
0.1305688918,
1.0755631924,
-0.920548141,
-0.0262995735,
-0.1078159511,
-0.2109862566,
-1.0586270094,
-0.0916134641,
0.3266720176,
-0.7916980386,
-0.3863326013,
-0.1841560006,
-0.3748888373,
-0.2750012875,
-0.9014609456,
0.3213225007,
0.433257401,
-0.6533463001,
0.6773378253,
0.5749796629,
0.2096486092,
-0.4548089802,
-0.6819787621,
0.0928925052,
-0.4216988087,
-0.7032196522,
0.2801477313,
0.1563959271,
-0.1209311336,
0.2321501672,
-0.0700907335,
0.0875971541,
0.2004324049,
0.3419652283,
-0.0550350808,
-0.0244962648,
0.376696974,
0.1943047643,
-0.0659293011,
0.3517316282,
-0.4389126003,
0.4101231396,
-0.9105254412,
-0.2913554907,
-0.4060707986,
0.409516722,
0.3212886751,
-0.290728122,
0.6382269263,
0.7491374612,
-0.3595816791,
-0.1271800399,
-0.4314800203,
-0.1558218598,
-0.5116298199,
0.3188010156,
-0.1374839842,
-0.9828791618,
0.332487762,
-0.2065990567,
-0.0062351348,
0.1512025446,
0.7642469406,
-0.3157024384,
0.7109489441,
0.5809898376,
0.1221562102,
0.6043748856,
-0.218633458,
0.2185321301,
-0.5300810933,
-0.0315391943,
-0.7010328174,
0.0588999502,
-0.8509568572,
-0.4340916276,
0.5106102824,
0.1721077412,
-0.1916393042,
0.3497422636,
-0.7680323124,
0.2839048505,
0.3875052333,
0.0699859634,
0.208778739,
0.3315528035,
-0.0075362832,
-0.334920764,
-0.0782974437,
-0.8821512461,
0.8954600096,
0.232292369,
0.4701755345,
0.1823997945,
0.8072162271,
0.3956139684,
0.4376337826,
-0.9625992775,
0.3076394498,
-0.5221552849,
-0.2594369948,
-0.1253412962,
-0.4742534757,
-0.6271416545,
-0.0560012944,
-0.3432981372,
-0.913828373,
0.1569103599,
-0.0697437525,
0.0295109302,
0.1729578674,
-0.448938638,
0.5777553916,
-0.3644078374,
-0.4069254398,
-0.3432230353,
-0.2145885974,
-0.1454130262,
-0.0420210212,
0.1412446201,
-0.1427474022,
-0.4827810228,
0.5866952538,
-0.570537746,
0.7888905406,
0.0323349796,
-0.1370096952,
0.4323291183,
-0.1854043007,
0.4776417613,
0.4917461574,
0.0076345922,
0.1058845297,
0.3418161273,
-0.3471341133,
-0.4832908809,
0.6579281688,
-0.606169641,
-0.3736996949,
-0.1487787366,
-0.1258879602,
-0.0822602585,
0.0889061391,
0.3121603429,
0.5219058394,
-0.2327456623,
0.7710956335,
0.4726937711,
-0.2018239945,
0.4166347682,
-0.0965165049,
0.1373333782,
-0.8177153468,
1.0170273781,
-0.2211535871,
0.1443942487,
0.3943735659,
0.7189699411,
-0.5621209145,
-0.5779771805,
-0.1367244571,
0.1363666654,
-0.5796721578,
-0.1499097794,
-0.6967325211,
0.0572346412,
-0.0099134138,
-0.5398603678,
-0.5599171519,
-0.0823405683,
-0.417801559,
0.0373703316,
0.6662742496,
0.5244256854,
-0.1902287155,
0.1989111602,
-0.8219886422,
0.1721678376,
-0.0515889488,
0.2580213249,
-0.3757216036,
-0.3038697243,
-0.0979990587,
0.3250735402,
-0.2390321642,
-0.904037416,
0.2514960766,
0.3337577581,
0.1701928228,
0.2858383358,
0.2263789475,
0.6924043298,
-0.2071962506,
0.5442059636,
0.3658618331,
-1.3294451237,
0.6843244433,
-0.1218751743,
-0.4696772695,
0.5621323586,
0.2776277065,
-0.4475539923,
-0.4942638874,
-0.3242688179,
-0.5891659856,
0.1481018364,
0.8824445605,
0.7823751569,
-0.3115750253,
0.7033035755,
-0.2768730223,
0.2718376815,
-0.449049443,
-0.0952218175,
-0.5070469379,
-0.6934009194,
0.1288302243,
-0.3150193989,
-0.2328879982,
-0.1075258255,
0.1641506702,
-0.2050660104,
0.0829764605,
0.4799023867,
0.2164077312,
0.3655736148,
0.0680600628,
0.303739816,
0.3305624425,
0.0243498906,
-0.093446672,
0.0552579723,
-0.9566522241,
0.3190062046,
-0.1477112323,
0.0611970127,
-0.0325365439,
0.5542268753,
0.4116066992,
0.0486227162,
-0.5435649157,
1.0013207197,
-0.4009788334,
0.088501364,
-0.6586464047,
-0.1701400578,
0.1258902699,
0.4896765649,
0.0768873096,
-0.2364354134,
0.1689530164,
-0.3828708827,
0.5147246718,
0.5002164245,
-0.6525512934,
-0.3106423914,
0.5580317974,
0.2731755376,
-0.4585530162,
0.2955704033,
-0.1793212593,
-0.47910285,
0.5120531321,
0.1355208308,
0.9617487788,
0.2196648717,
0.5726920962,
0.2471944541,
0.3495332301,
0.203126356,
0.4598858058,
-0.183557108,
-0.8317997456,
-0.2986275256,
-0.852974236,
-0.0521691665,
-0.4271248281,
-0.6549680829,
0.2650146186,
-0.7273618579,
-0.5666764975,
-0.0563972965,
0.2956440449,
-0.6445633769,
-0.0629986078,
-0.2941584289,
0.44720155,
-0.5378046036,
0.3633505404,
0.5218731165,
-0.6266477704,
-0.6607125998,
-0.0181181952,
0.0407414511,
-0.9159195423,
0.4758556485,
0.0764097124,
-0.588334918,
-0.0945400149,
-0.5375080705,
-0.4282721281,
0.8383915424,
0.3249735236,
-0.4162111878,
-0.0148090255,
0.3604425192,
0.7295820117,
-0.5071322322,
0.037874952,
0.3724465668,
0.3527125418,
0.1385404915,
-0.4250369668,
0.2131890506,
-0.1383250058,
0.072222963,
0.2300729156,
-0.3200308383,
0.6449993253,
-0.1675132811,
-0.5551768541,
0.2062293887,
0.6320200562,
0.2450188845,
0.3637168109,
0.6154668927,
0.2228871286,
0.6623871326,
-0.1829481721,
1.2663526535,
-0.1360974908,
0.7951527834,
0.6408982277,
0.2159088105,
0.6467546821,
0.876965344,
0.0850643218,
0.1556195021,
0.2237001806,
-0.0626598671,
0.4454036653,
0.4892863333,
-0.3221677244,
-0.3119361401,
-0.6658385396,
0.0698735565,
0.4491451681,
0.7579419017,
-0.2043739259,
-0.2028648555,
0.2005293071,
0.1422315985,
0.5507847667,
-0.0405089147,
0.640417099,
0.3462683856,
-0.0685820654,
0.5263149738,
-0.2405479103,
0.7547904849,
-0.1152649671,
-0.1590582579,
-0.0435115993,
0.2887844741,
-0.0635977164,
-1.2264328003,
0.5163146853,
0.2586010396,
0.1891927719,
-0.1199157983,
0.6519544125,
-0.0760716796,
-0.5237422585,
0.5832100511,
0.4218915105,
0.0006492138,
0.0498673953,
-0.7205042839,
0.1969326437,
0.0796820372,
-0.1040369496,
-0.4195171297,
0.9001805782,
-0.0480642021,
0.7357314229,
0.7156578898,
0.1680613309,
-0.068649143,
0.1566688865,
0.9571922421,
-0.7266671062,
-0.4185848534,
-1.0681020021,
0.3653698564,
-0.4159716368,
-0.5609385967,
0.5206108689,
0.1349820197,
0.7622421384,
0.3089884222,
0.6053766012,
-0.179137677,
0.179753989,
-0.4212890565,
0.7869357467,
-0.8853892088,
0.333628267,
-0.3248512745,
-0.7645432949,
0.0341396071,
0.5771280527,
-0.1323298514,
-0.166241467,
0.3649694324,
0.52218467,
0.0610799082,
0.0923082381,
0.1964042485,
0.0868597776,
0.8641460538,
0.6858644485,
1.1323224306,
-0.3604568839,
0.7904754877,
-0.157329455,
-0.2725450993,
-0.2208213955,
-1.0271152258,
-1.3188666105,
-0.8968548179,
-0.0498027913,
-0.5249307752,
0.0846681893,
0.6127607226,
0.3468611538,
-0.5287768841,
0.1735287756,
-0.2929742634,
0.431518048,
0.1276575327,
-0.2254522294,
0.4364558458,
-0.2808874249,
-0.6857382655,
-0.2460192889,
0.4818661511,
-0.0529810041,
-0.2511325479,
-0.0337421857,
0.1001119316,
0.43889907,
0.6334062815,
-0.152493313,
-0.7354783416,
-0.9677884579,
-0.0108469632,
-0.2698617876,
-0.1502936184,
0.7426161766,
-0.389295876,
0.2232934684,
0.6820982695,
0.8888902068,
0.1771428883,
-0.0362554975,
0.5056593418,
-0.7881894112,
-0.0447698422,
0.4926863015,
0.3908728957,
0.2762253284,
-0.4608787596,
0.5015053749,
0.3312655985,
-0.2874633372,
-0.8119243979,
0.2471744716,
-1.064027071,
0.0868007615,
0.8481091261,
-0.2121039182,
-0.6328768134,
-0.0974922702,
-0.2834198475,
0.1319416016,
-0.3129786849,
0.6297035217,
0.7400640845,
0.3745983243,
0.1372743994,
-0.3114596903,
0.457062155,
0.244413659,
-0.8990353346,
0.0000743069,
0.35351035,
0.3602328002,
0.4047822058,
0.5285508633,
-0.4161822498,
0.2845877111,
-0.0258769933,
-0.3013131022,
0.1328535974,
-0.0211051721,
0.015807623,
0.2327491939,
-0.518160224,
-0.2802297771
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05979v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05979v1
|
NovaCOMET: Open Commonsense Foundation Models with Symbolic Knowledge Distillation
| 2023-12-10T19:45:24 | 2023-12-10T19:45:24 |
Peter West, Ronan Le Bras, Taylor Sorensen, Bill Yuchen Lin, Liwei Jiang, Ximing Lu, Khyathi Chandu, Jack Hessel, Ashutosh Baheti, Chandra Bhagavatula, Yejin Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present NovaCOMET, an open commonsense knowledge model, that combines the
best aspects of knowledge and general task models. Compared to previous
knowledge models, NovaCOMET allows open-format relations enabling direct
application to reasoning tasks; compared to general task models like Flan-T5,
it explicitly centers knowledge, enabling superior performance for commonsense
reasoning.
NovaCOMET leverages the knowledge of opaque proprietary models to create an
open knowledge pipeline. First, knowledge is symbolically distilled into
NovATOMIC, a publicly-released discrete knowledge graph which can be audited,
critiqued, and filtered. Next, we train NovaCOMET on NovATOMIC by fine-tuning
an open-source pretrained model. NovaCOMET uses an open-format training
objective, replacing the fixed relation sets of past knowledge models, enabling
arbitrary structures within the data to serve as inputs or outputs.
The resulting generation model, optionally augmented with human annotation,
matches or exceeds comparable open task models like Flan-T5 on a range of
commonsense generation tasks. NovaCOMET serves as a counterexample to the
contemporary focus on instruction tuning only, demonstrating a distinct
advantage to explicitly modeling commonsense knowledge as well.
|
[
-0.0772244409,
-0.3200364709,
0.4445002377,
-0.0740032941,
-0.2066614181,
-0.2930676639,
-0.1258362532,
-0.2669057548,
-0.1075574681,
0.794857502,
-0.5818879604,
-0.6685091853,
-0.5257796645,
-0.0451150015,
-0.3115608394,
1.1567203999,
0.1599566191,
-0.0405156091,
-0.4665199518,
-0.0769553259,
-0.4471184313,
-0.3600152135,
-0.5279636383,
-0.5427225828,
0.3021444082,
0.2062619627,
0.6433948278,
0.6072944999,
0.2563639581,
0.2981700003,
-0.0108784745,
0.3407215178,
-0.9605506659,
0.0209647696,
-0.4672040045,
-0.4138811827,
-0.4800512791,
-0.0104654543,
0.0983887911,
0.4484029114,
-0.0920476615,
0.1850236803,
0.0316924267,
0.443559736,
-1.0943427086,
0.25902614,
-0.8061820865,
-0.221111685,
-0.120631285,
0.0324767642,
-0.3987700641,
-0.7682628036,
0.1936827898,
-1.0157996416,
0.2965877354,
-0.0730746686,
0.7412708402,
0.5670280457,
-0.6144420505,
-0.2918227613,
-0.7107026577,
0.9726051092,
-0.6082341671,
0.1448732018,
0.2574062347,
0.7770478725,
0.1403439492,
-1.2358059883,
-0.5279429555,
-0.2803088725,
-0.1294688284,
0.2146510035,
-0.4261735082,
0.3752188981,
0.0000636873,
0.489482224,
-0.4277300239,
-0.082950294,
-0.6166411042,
-0.0688271523,
0.5966450572,
0.0963332504,
-0.0472166874,
0.0206012409,
-0.6543003321,
-0.0849826559,
-0.716910243,
-0.5778627396,
0.3106606305,
0.2244466692,
0.0655106679,
0.4522608519,
-0.3650922775,
0.8790428638,
0.118776232,
0.1107860655,
-0.0399198085,
-0.3404330015,
-0.3581228852,
0.0752649531,
0.603700459,
0.2407095134,
0.3570979834,
-0.0221421868,
-0.4002176225,
0.3196002841,
0.4499568939,
-0.6464635134,
-0.7260061502,
0.1275220811,
-0.2390211076,
-0.6277201772,
0.0058414578,
-0.3494144082,
-0.4718282521,
-0.6778593063,
0.5985776186,
-0.3203258216,
-0.4483414888,
0.3175460696,
-0.4172838628,
-0.3691033721,
0.524769783,
-0.8853386641,
0.5826525092,
0.9827930331,
0.8220520616,
-0.0431894697,
-0.02282927,
-0.3708992302,
0.1073433757,
0.0903233588,
0.5254691243,
-0.5528022647,
-0.3882924616,
-0.1873240024,
-0.3165876269,
-0.0739047527,
-0.6211007237,
0.1475885361,
-0.4526568651,
0.1476056427,
-0.6001102328,
-0.4837170243,
-0.1613708287,
0.4137503803,
-0.8811131716,
0.7842168808,
0.2126812786,
-0.9631432295,
0.431733489,
-1.1364715099,
0.1250836104,
0.1245389059,
-0.0381329432,
0.0367995612,
-0.0042002006,
0.127155304,
0.3461695313,
-0.3740202785,
0.3618519604,
-0.2226091176,
-0.1461134702,
-0.0419893339,
-0.4734077156,
0.8066413999,
0.3377894759,
-0.3026186526,
0.2127339095,
-0.3791308105,
-0.3114367127,
-0.0086877774,
0.0326937698,
-0.6256716251,
-0.1741851568,
0.0720454603,
0.3360173404,
0.5003807545,
-0.7040649652,
0.2092769891,
-0.3182252944,
0.5774151683,
1.0256565809,
0.0325909816,
0.3424375653,
-0.3521495163,
0.3573029041,
0.1868040562,
0.5168271065,
0.3670428395,
-0.5974982977,
-0.4619350433,
-0.1657420099,
0.3076691628,
0.311424017,
-0.8691409826,
-0.0942066759,
-0.3835960329,
-0.614567697,
-0.3858812451,
0.0241808817,
0.6533455253,
0.6533309817,
0.3382183015,
-0.2082390785,
-0.2714750171,
-1.0681568384,
-0.1037713066,
-0.0010813385,
0.1624626815,
0.366330415,
0.72514081,
0.1891777515,
1.1540391445,
-1.0015038252,
-0.1759627759,
0.0183347706,
0.4496512115,
0.1540563405,
0.3299914598,
0.5276191831,
-1.092813015,
-0.1918290555,
0.3145809174,
-0.7739344835,
-0.0681552291,
0.2225660682,
-0.1794963628,
-0.0492669828,
0.2960256636,
-0.4352115691,
0.0696336776,
0.6814431548,
-0.3781881928,
0.9003596902,
-0.0787502974,
0.0543596819,
-1.3931831121,
0.3424740732,
0.0799537301,
-0.056612432,
-0.621265471,
-0.0433940738,
0.0204854719,
-0.1833547056,
-0.8597048521,
0.9271867275,
-0.2083125263,
0.0549952127,
-0.2647309899,
0.2661854029,
0.0585287437,
0.3418954313,
0.2416779399,
0.6534843445,
0.301075846,
-0.4966813326,
0.4245989323,
0.1686880887,
-0.0498793907,
0.6528394818,
-0.8162757754,
-0.1354079396,
-0.0009137508,
0.1874212623,
-0.7589802146,
-0.2799964547,
0.0619225167,
-0.1976709366,
-0.1700014025,
-0.2639820278,
-0.3232926726,
-0.4179185033,
0.022875715,
0.4514285922,
0.3399079144,
-0.7013270855,
0.4415058196,
0.0829002857,
0.1782072335,
-1.0009511709,
-0.3363893628,
-0.3241075277,
-0.0784659982,
-0.6770334244,
0.2321642488,
0.336520344,
-0.4220288396,
0.3538861573,
-0.334415704,
-0.5931448936,
0.1086573303,
0.3447722197,
0.2000275254,
-0.3789393604,
0.323420465,
0.4091593325,
-0.1861200482,
0.0571095087,
-0.8312605023,
0.1849804223,
-0.1383926123,
-0.3420406282,
-0.3150904179,
0.1325033605,
0.6990733147,
-0.2596816421,
0.5194070339,
0.4082531333,
-0.4748160541,
-0.4623636305,
-0.4603843987,
-0.662374258,
-0.5099954009,
0.246040687,
-0.1867210269,
-0.9833543897,
0.0828111842,
-0.3049752116,
0.6609034538,
0.4307448864,
0.4042949378,
0.2102801651,
0.543949306,
0.4092198312,
0.1955931783,
0.1989710778,
-0.4169799984,
-0.1037855744,
-0.4342536032,
-0.2412938625,
-0.3703832924,
-0.491492033,
-0.203583315,
-0.3412882984,
0.4698070586,
-0.1017476022,
-0.4110325277,
0.414254427,
-0.7933836579,
0.6846826077,
0.8087860942,
0.2326176018,
0.4198789895,
-0.366430223,
0.0831610858,
0.26934883,
-0.7103521824,
-0.4948422313,
1.3115856647,
-0.0181684028,
0.6433196664,
-0.0186667368,
0.8800179362,
0.3260622025,
0.3530817628,
-0.3659996092,
0.5618721247,
-0.4891321957,
-0.8786255121,
-0.1298030466,
-0.5609477758,
-0.8045832515,
0.1934767812,
-0.1988658905,
-0.6053129435,
0.128673479,
0.7427623272,
-0.2943015993,
0.5337914228,
-0.9448510408,
1.1081992388,
-0.0749375597,
-0.3433059454,
-0.316588968,
-0.402136147,
0.8600260615,
0.1328241378,
-0.3561145365,
0.0627052337,
0.1622886658,
0.7068927288,
-0.5772086382,
1.2364836931,
-0.4085170627,
0.0026001416,
0.2888912261,
0.1549627781,
0.4981955588,
-0.02486475,
0.1159099787,
0.3075070977,
0.100615941,
-0.3593994975,
-0.8003250957,
0.8801377416,
-0.9477543831,
-0.5766975284,
-0.3520351648,
-0.7460548878,
-0.0595110096,
0.2604427338,
0.3201171458,
0.4793918729,
-0.3050056994,
0.0715011954,
0.8479745984,
0.247986123,
0.0581463389,
0.0785607547,
0.0566561706,
-0.3578144014,
0.9134876132,
0.0416314341,
0.5532006621,
0.5297751427,
0.3530809283,
-0.5790408254,
-0.3458028734,
-0.069310993,
0.3171442449,
-0.7769187689,
-0.1302260756,
-0.6314203143,
-0.0908263922,
-0.383703202,
-0.3517083824,
-0.598072648,
-0.7788012624,
-0.3976930082,
0.1036356166,
0.5185248852,
0.992300868,
-0.131874904,
0.3489558995,
-0.6197250485,
0.2520429492,
0.8487404585,
-0.0273792539,
-0.1389745176,
-0.0821722224,
-0.0866623819,
0.2214189023,
-0.702078104,
-0.7722950578,
-0.0082395626,
0.0419899076,
0.4524333775,
0.6633832455,
0.3336474597,
0.2552055418,
0.0458456986,
1.0124548674,
0.4511349201,
-0.8363913894,
0.5880858302,
-0.5869909525,
0.3444369733,
0.5082582831,
0.6439569592,
-0.325812012,
-0.2468944043,
-0.7676241994,
-0.5244361758,
0.4560028315,
0.3700305223,
-0.1657806039,
-0.1074245945,
0.1209003478,
0.477320224,
0.4278452396,
-0.3956739008,
0.0708890632,
-0.7095145583,
-0.2984437346,
0.0873548388,
0.1361922026,
-0.5236908793,
0.0593573414,
0.6858311892,
-0.2041038871,
0.0551056899,
-0.1277125031,
-0.0169489086,
0.3611723483,
0.2016924471,
0.6879273057,
0.8182657361,
-0.1505957246,
0.1414425224,
0.1493034959,
-0.7391217947,
-0.1892247349,
0.0013785129,
-0.0527677052,
-0.0747171789,
0.064729616,
0.8316918612,
0.4375295639,
-0.3298335969,
0.5346521139,
0.0638143793,
-0.6109017134,
-0.0670415014,
0.4539746046,
0.2169508487,
0.432603687,
0.0431929007,
0.1885268241,
0.1298015267,
-0.0823463202,
0.1804326624,
0.2046986073,
-0.386929512,
-0.2727530897,
0.7924272418,
0.5088438988,
0.1222271025,
0.7867773771,
0.1159726307,
-0.1382442117,
0.5195820928,
0.5283017755,
0.876429379,
-0.1345689446,
0.4048717618,
0.4416902661,
0.1574016362,
-0.2724669576,
0.2293789238,
-0.4166146219,
-0.4747093022,
-0.3290775716,
-0.6181495786,
-0.6283553243,
0.1606667042,
-0.692691505,
0.1575312316,
-0.4024501145,
-0.2171253562,
-0.1379045993,
-0.0494118258,
-0.5604783893,
0.3206157684,
-0.108954899,
1.0703773499,
-1.2199158669,
0.7032418847,
0.6896535754,
-0.2433521599,
-0.5505255461,
-0.3826364577,
0.2726650834,
-0.5837820768,
0.7278381586,
-0.0380675793,
0.0176209435,
0.1392990649,
-0.4323368669,
-0.4745365083,
1.5612125397,
0.6340795755,
-0.6876687407,
-0.336479485,
0.0495823026,
0.1866137236,
-0.1864030659,
0.1565907449,
0.4894239306,
0.625923574,
0.3571943939,
-1.0209223032,
0.1175642982,
-0.2567821741,
-0.116952613,
0.4346640706,
-0.3743116558,
1.0539594889,
-0.0122583741,
-0.0971182808,
-0.1790662557,
0.5586640835,
0.4654667974,
0.4388097823,
0.5087859631,
0.7725226879,
0.90500319,
-0.2830197811,
0.7958858609,
-0.0933609977,
0.1874449253,
1.2971534729,
-0.065653272,
0.627431035,
0.3592431545,
0.3418733776,
0.335660696,
0.3676588237,
0.083216764,
0.5944866538,
0.1052982062,
-0.583122611,
-0.3928135037,
-0.0794061348,
-0.397972405,
0.401420325,
0.1587860882,
-0.4185085297,
-0.6384006739,
-0.1027853936,
0.0244452972,
0.1413941532,
-0.4247243404,
0.6610958576,
0.1460390538,
-0.7080129981,
0.7056280375,
-0.3264849186,
0.4944997728,
-0.8094823956,
-0.1574365497,
0.1000977531,
0.1598248929,
-0.176362291,
-0.6525030136,
0.2873710394,
-0.1756636649,
-0.133981809,
-0.0823905766,
0.8120782375,
-0.1737595052,
-0.1128346026,
-0.1198084429,
0.3315288424,
0.1326301098,
-0.4038562775,
-0.6251677275,
-0.3529983163,
-0.2134655714,
-0.0666964129,
0.2080996782,
0.4730540812,
-0.1845901608,
0.5654254556,
0.7414612174,
0.0141030401,
0.034572497,
-0.2671012282,
1.100687623,
-0.2770258188,
-0.6179791689,
-0.4086669087,
0.7488624454,
-0.3317220211,
-0.808796227,
0.5368984938,
0.3332944214,
0.794477582,
-0.3363654315,
0.9258252382,
0.0764225274,
-0.1723838001,
-0.5247250199,
1.0535449982,
-0.4393303096,
-0.1965799034,
-0.0730353668,
-0.9907166958,
-0.044531364,
0.0329482555,
-0.790584743,
0.0774942413,
0.7255698442,
1.0309852362,
-0.5185039639,
0.5109030604,
0.3888946772,
0.1612579226,
0.0997913182,
0.8764269948,
0.5239934921,
-0.107633464,
0.5046596527,
-0.2423144728,
-0.3307395875,
-0.1931032687,
-0.7916812897,
-0.9696237445,
-0.8405812979,
-0.3187237382,
-0.1838676035,
0.4567972124,
0.5657408237,
0.9813845158,
-0.589125514,
-0.1056142077,
-0.4243881702,
-0.0552175343,
-0.493901521,
-0.2336131483,
0.2396210283,
-0.1232742071,
-0.6502634883,
0.3474424779,
-0.0370006077,
-0.1781128347,
-0.3157680035,
-0.0829635262,
-0.159417212,
0.1999881715,
0.5852377415,
0.4239919484,
-0.5455989838,
-0.1731047928,
-0.1013282835,
0.044294998,
-0.3418392539,
0.8009376526,
-0.8368597031,
0.5856176615,
0.4738010168,
0.2973417938,
0.5429698825,
-0.0296295881,
0.6397333145,
-0.7831431031,
-0.0339928009,
0.5114706755,
0.0866908878,
0.0010557482,
-0.3045570552,
0.363831073,
0.3537950516,
-0.5361511707,
-0.7205202579,
0.4759790301,
-1.00925529,
-0.3674623668,
1.0411431789,
-0.2092188895,
-0.3921919465,
-0.1758942306,
-0.0304058623,
0.2281351984,
-0.4463247955,
0.8344444036,
0.2479276508,
0.2207349688,
0.1906193048,
-0.3229385018,
0.4167662859,
0.0036725402,
-0.8282853961,
0.1709268391,
0.7268814445,
0.3696322143,
0.187716037,
0.4870113432,
-0.1124649197,
0.675660193,
0.3677091897,
0.1710795909,
-0.8298843503,
-0.5210758448,
0.0981676653,
0.5614712238,
-0.1809652299,
-0.391516149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11504v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11504v1
|
The performance of multiple language models in identifying offensive language on social media
| 2023-12-10T18:58:26 | 2023-12-10T18:58:26 |
Hao Li, Brandon Bennett
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Text classification is an important topic in the field of natural language
processing. It has been preliminarily applied in information retrieval, digital
library, automatic abstracting, text filtering, word semantic discrimination
and many other fields. The aim of this research is to use a variety of
algorithms to test the ability to identify offensive posts and evaluate their
performance against a variety of assessment methods. The motivation for this
project is to reduce the harm of these languages to human censors by automating
the screening of offending posts. The field is a new one, and despite much
interest in the past two years, there has been no focus on the object of the
offence. Through the experiment of this project, it should inspire future
research on identification methods as well as identification content.
|
[
-0.2297474146,
-1.3168082237,
0.1283823103,
0.4282736778,
-0.1872122437,
0.270277679,
-0.1757725924,
-0.9040126801,
-0.19295156,
0.4695913792,
-0.0779679716,
-0.4978969395,
-0.9482817054,
0.2576434314,
-1.047369957,
0.9533557892,
-0.1344369948,
-0.0619040318,
0.3816408813,
-0.278557092,
-0.1876510382,
-0.7928429842,
-0.9374542236,
0.2233478278,
0.640991509,
-0.0704222172,
0.406783551,
0.6265622377,
0.8014321923,
0.5381385088,
-0.0350233912,
0.0985945538,
-0.440207839,
0.0840054527,
-0.3542031944,
-0.1493304074,
-0.0587391555,
0.0915378705,
0.5783984661,
0.0023152435,
0.195359692,
0.1418481767,
0.0496215485,
0.319431603,
-0.9030914307,
-0.1315854639,
-0.6349213719,
-0.1695870757,
-0.4100495875,
-0.1619938761,
-0.5756067634,
-0.605905354,
-0.2524206638,
-0.2524279356,
0.2449093163,
-0.1094798818,
0.7081551552,
-0.2811315954,
-0.49484694,
-0.758025229,
-0.9196220636,
0.8123788238,
-0.6064439416,
0.2538903654,
0.3957846165,
0.4161331058,
0.1872208118,
-0.4193546474,
-0.6402490735,
0.0939441994,
-0.1432958543,
-0.198507145,
-0.2775707543,
0.0682932064,
0.1267462969,
0.2998862267,
-0.5328318477,
0.3419712186,
-0.5024051666,
-0.3114990592,
0.9694477916,
0.0692725107,
0.6358218789,
-0.1853219867,
-0.0786358565,
0.0213017687,
-0.1012315303,
0.0617669262,
0.7212842107,
0.5449416041,
-0.1213097945,
0.4327797294,
-0.3872787952,
0.5586518049,
-0.2419559658,
-0.0930825844,
0.3423576951,
-0.2961307764,
0.0111886039,
-0.181677267,
1.1572692394,
0.4755054712,
0.3604038358,
0.1476736218,
-0.4342645109,
0.7565355897,
0.4368513525,
-0.5982713103,
-0.0356471278,
-0.1878202558,
-0.5221821666,
-0.7064889669,
-0.1321054399,
-0.9816899896,
-0.5320873857,
0.1269008219,
0.558421433,
-0.4005249143,
-0.5870258808,
-0.1781555712,
-0.2229108065,
0.1809144914,
0.1417484879,
-0.8395764232,
0.6550856829,
0.6270920038,
0.6234036684,
-0.1787486374,
-0.1651690006,
-0.1874489635,
-0.2404640168,
-0.2905530035,
0.6812707782,
-0.8532419801,
-0.0372625552,
0.4691944718,
0.1586912274,
-0.0946980193,
-0.3979500234,
1.0356196165,
-0.89693892,
0.0944338441,
-0.1591072828,
-0.3459820151,
-0.4416387975,
0.2234550714,
-0.6698559523,
1.1854432821,
0.0102599384,
-0.9484829307,
0.2300054431,
-0.7268388867,
-0.6092103124,
0.0709562674,
0.0509785265,
-0.3428572118,
-0.0282959454,
-0.1985882521,
0.4318458438,
-0.0852753967,
0.0817520395,
-0.2469051629,
-0.3200496137,
0.0628891215,
-0.622176826,
0.7690036297,
0.5449879766,
-0.3573454916,
0.2288472354,
-0.6592384577,
-0.2142651528,
0.4105292857,
-0.3835041225,
-0.7867527604,
0.184348315,
0.3502575159,
0.2866366208,
0.0069967969,
-0.7618498802,
-0.3734185994,
-0.4186899662,
0.276551187,
0.5097208619,
-0.0245719962,
0.2861585617,
-0.2901240289,
0.5465025306,
-0.1480689049,
0.2648589015,
0.0212547891,
-0.6452491283,
-0.5062786341,
-0.143278867,
0.2311081588,
0.8295950294,
-0.7360591292,
0.0507815517,
0.1343652457,
-0.7030546069,
-0.4871453643,
0.1922860593,
0.75735116,
0.1398837417,
0.1964920014,
-0.2908597291,
-0.7546048164,
-0.7572184801,
-0.5553430915,
-0.4540296793,
0.3427806497,
0.2213551849,
0.3629749417,
-0.2004999518,
0.5102476478,
-0.1747062802,
0.0238411911,
0.0887326077,
0.5385369062,
-0.0541324168,
0.3024995327,
0.9328722954,
-1.0842789412,
-0.8290228248,
0.0349983387,
-0.8602502942,
-0.3941893578,
0.4528069794,
0.0250769928,
0.2964556515,
0.3012065291,
-0.1678751409,
0.5775649548,
0.6565893888,
-0.3073620796,
0.5518454313,
0.0959986821,
0.7416539788,
-0.5328070521,
-0.3257547617,
0.329855442,
-0.0989432707,
-1.036614418,
0.172770977,
0.0330203287,
-0.0022752706,
-0.6445668936,
0.5134559274,
-0.2695200443,
0.4143382311,
-0.3431789279,
0.0169647299,
-0.2400963306,
0.2618193328,
0.0042048059,
0.433724612,
0.6522491574,
-0.8180940747,
0.2917284667,
-0.166754961,
-0.306309551,
0.4344002306,
-0.2762117088,
0.3068802059,
-0.3389667273,
-0.4230408072,
-1.5389806032,
-0.2291148305,
0.6168278456,
-0.6970197558,
0.0638912618,
-0.1258923411,
-0.4861548543,
-0.5637789369,
-0.3201580644,
0.6964168549,
0.2136550695,
-0.3795117438,
0.5925331712,
0.8313756585,
-0.180975005,
-0.7229905128,
-0.4784071445,
-0.0197617523,
-0.589643538,
-0.3349106312,
0.1982653439,
0.1059126258,
-0.4785997868,
-0.0406764075,
0.3468148112,
-0.5754657388,
0.424205333,
0.1040878072,
0.060665343,
-0.1441875845,
0.1696640849,
-0.0171777848,
0.4859631658,
0.2580272853,
0.4686079919,
0.6383863688,
-0.0959679335,
-0.1785982251,
-0.621304214,
0.5094532967,
0.4708883464,
-0.2137277275,
0.7059118748,
0.7263544798,
-0.653593719,
-0.1398910284,
-0.7122242451,
0.2115007788,
-0.5130832195,
0.5279095173,
-0.2798578739,
-0.8534123898,
0.5442798138,
0.2333575338,
0.0817895308,
0.6306512952,
0.4963476658,
-0.0557822846,
1.1615591049,
0.5207331777,
-0.3627271652,
0.5857528448,
0.1528059989,
0.2708887458,
-0.2922340631,
0.1058301777,
-0.9381687045,
-0.0085187759,
-0.8034411073,
-0.1897038221,
-0.3000651896,
0.1142610684,
0.0642117411,
0.6711286902,
-0.7037675977,
0.5171477795,
0.031074265,
0.0021103865,
0.1989376694,
0.0509764887,
-0.0333841704,
-0.0503387339,
-0.2691175044,
-0.8871440291,
1.0640774965,
0.555303216,
0.4841785133,
0.5234752893,
0.3964248598,
0.6959879994,
0.7552786469,
-0.6897250414,
0.5583735108,
-0.4611785412,
-1.0972779989,
-0.4256565869,
-0.4787611961,
-0.9900060296,
0.4284810722,
-0.312164396,
-0.8859804273,
-0.0935765579,
0.2804152966,
-0.2983618677,
0.4609897435,
-0.8160738945,
0.7495401502,
-0.490062207,
-0.3457713723,
-0.2741816044,
-0.228739351,
0.51653409,
-0.4537252188,
0.9949617386,
-0.1366732866,
0.0921524912,
1.062096715,
0.0976417735,
1.087982893,
-0.3065473139,
-0.1867703646,
0.5054848194,
-0.0245343018,
0.1369313002,
-0.3751024604,
-0.3219844997,
0.1458982378,
0.0481890514,
0.068241924,
-0.1965156049,
0.5089039803,
-0.5403325558,
-0.2660492957,
-0.2754402161,
-0.220423311,
0.1016847864,
0.4286396801,
0.0966277421,
0.3530927002,
-0.5406854749,
-0.0448696949,
0.325738728,
-0.4539447427,
0.5629393458,
0.6430075169,
-0.498865813,
-0.1429498345,
1.002702117,
0.07016927,
0.0600671582,
0.2200876176,
0.2080914229,
-0.3827859461,
-0.8042994142,
-0.2799020112,
0.1410501003,
-0.6922848225,
0.0645311102,
-0.8459535241,
-0.333216995,
-0.7959582806,
0.1442564279,
-0.240564093,
-0.0489587709,
-0.1401300281,
0.1379026026,
0.0470546111,
1.0391285419,
-0.0435119309,
0.7383355498,
-0.6109443903,
0.4677044153,
0.2332574576,
0.3937742412,
-0.1276587546,
-0.6956830621,
-0.0461719967,
-0.1392956823,
-0.4592769742,
-1.2702778578,
0.4319123328,
0.2122706622,
0.8260242939,
0.6544607878,
0.1466020197,
0.3355511725,
-0.3974859416,
0.3191072345,
0.1464131027,
-0.726534605,
0.5632847548,
-0.4395919442,
-0.0622136183,
0.4930253029,
0.8278456926,
-0.5484772921,
-0.5457455516,
-0.4322377741,
-0.6396521926,
0.7793900371,
0.2523155808,
0.5588917732,
-0.3871886432,
0.2194260508,
-0.1060699448,
0.146599099,
-0.9409552813,
-0.3182251453,
0.2029714286,
-0.2165673375,
0.046993278,
-0.614402473,
-0.0309378505,
-0.2168730348,
0.5846480131,
0.131415531,
0.3700766265,
-0.1401174664,
-0.3895252943,
-0.1695299447,
0.1094439998,
0.3616602719,
0.564817071,
0.041467268,
0.1848730445,
0.237534225,
-0.3557090759,
0.2043955922,
-0.0389045663,
-0.0750470608,
0.2103231102,
0.3962055445,
0.7014950514,
0.0620752461,
-0.4806067944,
0.7090091705,
-0.2444617748,
-0.2105998695,
-0.3696597517,
0.0466720611,
-0.2817776501,
0.1286605895,
0.1792834103,
0.1014953703,
0.5637065172,
-0.7658119798,
0.3293512166,
0.3064650297,
-0.4496853054,
-0.3011457026,
0.4586231411,
0.2459329516,
-0.9947655201,
0.2034264803,
-0.5030890703,
-0.996135056,
0.5239387751,
0.3981131613,
0.5795108676,
-0.8058425188,
0.3754027486,
0.7002524734,
0.4979450107,
0.0174066089,
0.3229376972,
0.0301894918,
-1.2405180931,
-0.289180845,
-0.7481917143,
0.0157114249,
0.2345921248,
-0.5794578791,
0.2803960741,
-0.6696543097,
-0.5322771072,
0.5344281793,
-0.3583563864,
-0.4606364965,
0.28542009,
0.5661216974,
0.594448328,
-1.5709966421,
0.746634841,
0.6442611814,
-0.1220201179,
-0.3376180828,
-0.3594841957,
0.4473162591,
-0.6129047275,
0.7169748545,
0.2871726453,
-0.2437583208,
-0.126170665,
-0.4785195291,
-0.5968748331,
0.0690585673,
-0.1756354123,
-0.2398595959,
0.1525428295,
0.1398851126,
0.8938477635,
-0.2503995299,
0.4497068524,
0.6208738685,
0.3216365874,
-0.1174647808,
-1.0889936686,
-0.1260278076,
-0.4833164811,
-0.0972961336,
0.3659999669,
-0.4678028226,
0.8085801005,
0.2319059521,
-0.5582844615,
-0.1074211821,
0.3683281541,
0.0421429425,
0.2692683041,
0.7655187249,
0.4554780722,
0.6028102636,
-0.1306759715,
0.8652300835,
0.0410754196,
0.4079618454,
0.9640045166,
-0.1533693224,
0.9238954186,
0.0531111397,
-0.3154848516,
0.5017074347,
0.6110044718,
-0.0449176356,
0.5389312506,
0.4099099636,
-0.3553193212,
0.1008305922,
-0.2408270836,
0.0090783695,
0.6913778186,
0.5347459912,
-0.6195203662,
-0.1278461963,
0.2861344516,
0.1134763733,
0.4893982708,
-0.3335722387,
0.8273659348,
-0.1765306592,
-0.4465153813,
0.4179837406,
0.426148355,
1.0778125525,
-0.3974501789,
-0.0111298673,
0.2393246591,
0.1911323965,
-0.1581822634,
-0.7339966297,
0.7811962962,
0.2741750479,
-0.0269725155,
-0.1956644803,
1.1066178083,
-0.2044222206,
-0.5582775474,
0.8638433218,
0.0897090659,
0.3756846786,
-0.1624303758,
-0.8758947849,
0.2830237448,
-0.1217016876,
-0.0568832047,
-0.0642141029,
0.5152212977,
-0.3683075905,
0.5287517309,
0.4504418671,
0.0961939767,
0.3870877922,
0.1828010827,
0.6819440126,
-0.5160933733,
-0.3593764305,
-1.0962947607,
0.2213390619,
-0.3490839899,
-0.4121400714,
0.8475587964,
0.6006111503,
0.9640554786,
0.1643247306,
0.8006359935,
-0.3744729161,
0.9356517196,
-0.1148832217,
0.7590223551,
-0.3902743757,
-0.0323074721,
-0.8247285485,
-0.5708673596,
-0.3696265817,
0.5974736214,
-0.3511196971,
0.0472806916,
0.6225834489,
0.8808959126,
0.1485855579,
0.2000880092,
0.3952044249,
0.089042455,
0.0849219188,
0.2149999738,
1.1404756308,
-0.6396077871,
0.611928165,
-0.6095194221,
-0.3169556558,
-0.2256791741,
-0.546797514,
-1.1088302135,
-0.5111413598,
-0.3604870439,
-0.2147609442,
0.1595717221,
0.4830798805,
0.6537498236,
-1.2490588427,
-0.4247921109,
0.3328067064,
0.0177256819,
-0.0979770124,
-0.2433919162,
-0.0060195248,
-0.1345155388,
-0.8792570233,
0.244954899,
-0.0041397689,
-0.1892050803,
0.0120415241,
0.0091474885,
-0.755063653,
-0.076661244,
0.8295880556,
0.2562556863,
-0.5983706117,
-0.4091017842,
-0.119856663,
-0.2612332106,
-0.1287596375,
0.4942353964,
-0.1796806455,
0.4319724441,
0.7243471742,
0.8111204505,
0.1773847938,
0.2080727518,
0.2577629089,
-0.5353349447,
0.0791963935,
0.1824641228,
0.1796114296,
0.2416392416,
-0.4117205441,
0.4242828786,
0.3601445556,
-0.5063478351,
-0.8909644485,
-0.0915420353,
-0.4561246932,
-0.3262888789,
1.1763799191,
-0.0707401633,
-0.1726290733,
-0.5576831698,
-0.194207266,
0.519654572,
-0.4124571979,
0.8464672565,
1.0001752377,
0.1402949393,
-0.352551043,
-0.8010541201,
0.5600529313,
0.2103929669,
-0.6452292204,
-0.1421762407,
0.3826876581,
0.225034833,
0.3010774851,
0.788089335,
-0.3896917105,
0.1100987345,
-0.2867955863,
0.1344657838,
0.581905961,
-0.3313020766,
-0.3755688071,
0.4139610827,
-0.042758394,
-0.4169576168
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05964v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05964v2
|
ConSequence: Synthesizing Logically Constrained Sequences for Electronic Health Record Generation
| 2023-12-10T18:43:37 | 2023-12-20T22:10:27 |
Brandon Theodorou, Shrusti Jain, Cao Xiao, Jimeng Sun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Generative models can produce synthetic patient records for analytical tasks
when real data is unavailable or limited. However, current methods struggle
with adhering to domain-specific knowledge and removing invalid data. We
present ConSequence, an effective approach to integrating domain knowledge into
sequential generative neural network outputs. Our rule-based formulation
includes temporal aggregation and antecedent evaluation modules, ensured by an
efficient matrix multiplication formulation, to satisfy hard and soft logical
constraints across time steps. Existing constraint methods often fail to
guarantee constraint satisfaction, lack the ability to handle temporal
constraints, and hinder the learning and computational efficiency of the model.
In contrast, our approach efficiently handles all types of constraints with
guaranteed logical coherence. We demonstrate ConSequence's effectiveness in
generating electronic health records, outperforming competitors in achieving
complete temporal and spatial constraint satisfaction without compromising
runtime performance or generative quality. Specifically, ConSequence
successfully prevents all rule violations while improving the model quality in
reducing its test perplexity by 5% and incurring less than a 13% slowdown in
generation speed compared to an unconstrained model.
|
[
0.1754096895,
-0.5545071363,
0.7344402671,
0.0312234871,
-0.2151213735,
-0.4247040153,
0.1125061437,
-0.3552001417,
0.2050297409,
0.5099231005,
-0.803242147,
-0.5581201911,
-0.2636469305,
-0.0392353199,
-0.5435779691,
1.257381916,
-0.0012772058,
-0.1114355773,
-0.4884094894,
0.0514293872,
-0.505728662,
-0.7239146829,
-0.1687134653,
-0.5298065543,
0.4180677831,
0.0818127841,
0.4309383929,
0.8979927301,
0.4240445495,
0.3484372199,
0.2518143356,
0.4977759719,
-0.4860144556,
0.2095981687,
-0.1203636825,
-0.2721849978,
-0.6668244004,
-0.1867512912,
0.4948611259,
0.7860437036,
-0.4741550982,
-0.0628063753,
-0.1857221276,
0.735363543,
-0.501930356,
-0.0308324229,
-0.4866239727,
0.5476464629,
-0.2209871709,
-0.6151084304,
-0.716799438,
-0.352884829,
0.1646574289,
-0.9278959632,
0.4326553047,
-0.1371748596,
0.9932884574,
0.6015872955,
-0.4690048993,
0.0265747197,
-1.2987591028,
0.380332619,
-0.5541884303,
0.2800780535,
0.0046127434,
0.4480228126,
-0.2666841447,
-1.0622806549,
-0.545434773,
0.2578773797,
-0.1686118245,
0.3898237646,
0.0853318796,
0.2423141003,
0.4025066197,
0.2349537909,
-0.5199671388,
-0.333843112,
-0.3019838035,
-0.0607351884,
0.7861167192,
0.5810886025,
0.2295918912,
-0.4099641442,
-0.2529110014,
0.1119604334,
-0.9595611095,
-0.2981199026,
0.2509374321,
0.2235263735,
-0.0252894014,
0.6068920493,
-0.225757882,
0.682177186,
0.2885935009,
-0.1549881697,
0.3510749638,
-0.3278106153,
-0.1661341637,
0.2215633541,
0.4842222929,
0.1319548637,
-0.3804832995,
-0.0438321605,
-0.2314237505,
0.23870112,
0.5828991532,
-0.9318358302,
-0.3950539529,
0.4551716745,
-0.5075025558,
0.0304700639,
0.1079526618,
-0.4430963397,
-0.1681942195,
-0.6680622101,
0.595862627,
-0.69610852,
0.0738598481,
0.0811378434,
-0.1582037956,
-0.3127650023,
0.3939762712,
-0.729942441,
0.3089694977,
0.9082415104,
0.683884263,
-0.0540999882,
0.0178083479,
-0.6931977272,
0.4023989439,
-0.2538014948,
0.150733158,
-0.0405417979,
-0.2921741307,
-0.1138103977,
-0.201360628,
0.0362573899,
-0.7428427935,
0.3090041876,
-0.6009589434,
-0.04419614,
0.1829359829,
-0.8024612665,
0.0866497234,
-0.0339194648,
-0.5891155601,
0.3191660345,
0.2831465304,
-0.4991579354,
0.5045124888,
-0.0942298397,
-0.9344809651,
0.2670474052,
-0.6299468875,
-0.8052751422,
0.0313496962,
-0.0635633543,
0.4060189426,
-0.0909501389,
0.7294188142,
0.0350873992,
0.0417034775,
0.1079779714,
-0.0624379665,
0.6251283884,
0.2761984468,
-0.3095301688,
0.1386320293,
-1.1366865635,
0.1375288218,
0.091662012,
-0.4724676013,
-0.3567192256,
0.48696509,
-0.2490526736,
0.2847852707,
-0.1847599149,
-0.3437600434,
-0.0191340186,
-0.2234255373,
0.4310702085,
0.6200336814,
0.4441615939,
0.1884656996,
-0.6434729695,
0.2975953817,
0.1715377271,
0.6325542331,
0.0498682521,
-0.357170254,
-0.6150028706,
-0.1417298466,
0.2838352323,
0.4833961129,
-1.0769138336,
0.7087501287,
-0.6795988083,
-0.2826807797,
-0.1034873575,
-0.1362085193,
0.5698425174,
0.8090807199,
0.4501743317,
-0.6064230204,
-0.9256907105,
-0.7922953963,
0.1775711179,
-0.2730728686,
-0.1354015321,
0.3048355877,
0.4586153924,
-0.2334926128,
0.6741491556,
-0.5278346539,
-0.3689303994,
0.0434549041,
0.1168491691,
0.3545182645,
0.8238067031,
0.0873500183,
-0.9781504273,
-0.0036472408,
-0.1497728378,
-0.9804319143,
0.0883947611,
-0.3836861253,
-0.1799327284,
0.0546994247,
0.2337592095,
-0.7158551812,
0.6245261431,
0.2220543176,
-0.3093028665,
0.6628431082,
-0.2126341909,
0.1122772917,
-0.7386112809,
-0.00887373,
-0.1442265511,
-0.2165938467,
-0.8619029522,
0.0519686341,
-0.0866225287,
-0.0998756737,
-0.32566154,
-0.0460596234,
-0.0133652855,
0.1382787675,
0.341760397,
-0.3651534319,
0.272832036,
0.2867076099,
0.1923313886,
0.2665964663,
-0.1285609156,
-0.8726831079,
0.1292909533,
0.6054199934,
-0.3907562792,
0.5953785181,
-0.8001539111,
-0.0782776549,
-0.1669460833,
0.1630580723,
-0.1773537993,
-0.3598241806,
0.2994674444,
-0.394823283,
0.5238130689,
-0.211151287,
-0.3116761446,
-0.4159867764,
0.1813578457,
0.4921603203,
0.7968484163,
-0.6587594151,
0.8678148985,
0.1546375304,
0.2772308886,
-0.3278769851,
-0.9063591957,
-0.0930018499,
-0.0510691553,
-0.6423265338,
1.0838987827,
0.0711724684,
-0.3188653588,
0.4227083027,
-0.0132554937,
0.1775383651,
-0.1665255129,
0.2819453478,
0.3445446193,
-0.0713991299,
0.2730261385,
0.1736502349,
0.0653096586,
0.1738209873,
-0.5931610465,
0.2725826204,
0.6495730877,
-0.5436427593,
-0.4078360796,
0.5969495177,
0.3623761535,
-0.0544012859,
0.4928155839,
-0.0335366093,
-0.754060626,
-0.7478841543,
-0.2800152302,
-0.1812263131,
-0.4830438793,
0.2740531266,
-0.2924974859,
-0.4280154705,
0.4070672393,
-0.0731047615,
0.0175543539,
0.5323089957,
0.3783950806,
0.1559003294,
1.0177755356,
-0.0081161251,
0.4422378242,
0.1738998294,
-0.3010380566,
0.1889375746,
-0.7602851987,
-0.6020201445,
-0.0823515579,
-0.0171520896,
-0.5420290232,
-0.3452285528,
0.8912367821,
-0.0498484597,
-0.4230875969,
0.3098201156,
-0.5965955853,
-0.2552133203,
0.4270233214,
0.7840616703,
0.1868367195,
-0.0364933461,
-0.0603592135,
-0.1157593727,
-0.8753472567,
-0.1262655854,
1.1364394426,
-0.1507284045,
0.6286132336,
0.4373785853,
0.9923796654,
0.344638139,
0.2448385358,
-0.4383578897,
0.3874729574,
-0.4646687508,
-0.562656343,
-0.1636731923,
-0.7994635701,
-0.7724109292,
-0.1341098845,
-0.3227009773,
-0.4385298491,
0.2337400317,
0.6128689647,
-0.8243920803,
0.1433818489,
-0.5328101516,
0.5417686701,
-0.2254722118,
-0.895126164,
-0.2611763179,
-0.6841853857,
0.4802236557,
-0.0713480338,
-0.1814460903,
0.1146036461,
0.0709954575,
0.4085417688,
-1.2872264385,
0.8067931533,
-0.097769253,
0.2400808483,
0.5571914315,
0.0170419943,
0.5807721615,
0.0478535667,
-0.0086341146,
-0.0790451765,
-0.1658748984,
-0.1843654811,
-0.7326180935,
0.5699947476,
-0.6485429406,
-0.8329248428,
-0.2543794513,
-0.5242951512,
-0.2399694771,
0.1134101003,
0.4025588632,
0.7198165059,
-0.3203520775,
-0.3000786006,
0.7697688341,
-0.3649617136,
0.0693444535,
0.4406537414,
0.0761698559,
-0.5528945327,
0.8998575211,
0.3578207195,
0.3198412359,
0.4415669441,
0.1307623833,
-0.1738367528,
-0.4058447778,
-0.5047296882,
-0.0091299349,
-0.683206439,
-0.3902296126,
-0.6113945842,
-0.6088886261,
-0.54232198,
0.0790802911,
-0.2747768164,
-0.5738073587,
-0.334962666,
-0.0361160412,
0.3536836505,
0.7576262951,
-0.2623248398,
-0.0332929417,
-0.8664939404,
0.3692521751,
0.5980878472,
0.1799573898,
0.0433694795,
-0.3068628013,
-0.1140621006,
-0.3543628454,
-0.4734463692,
-0.7040463686,
0.403672874,
0.4678826332,
0.3508377969,
0.5007358193,
0.149425745,
0.6524208784,
-1.0980758667,
0.4895819724,
0.3634812534,
-1.0523546934,
0.822614193,
-0.3936533928,
0.0093935831,
0.2475956827,
0.1931921393,
-0.3686213195,
0.0360239148,
-0.832288146,
-1.0379343033,
0.3200927079,
0.3317373395,
-0.101976797,
-0.3075094223,
0.6894127131,
0.0346412994,
0.4204592109,
-0.2021422535,
-0.4229087234,
-0.2895985544,
-0.2709482014,
0.1405389607,
-0.1252471358,
-0.2600110769,
-0.4052123427,
0.787778914,
0.2093747556,
0.3471237719,
0.6324300766,
0.0408665799,
-0.1093434021,
0.0509142019,
0.6362593174,
0.6373526454,
-0.0447124206,
0.2040354162,
-0.3467795253,
-0.1457007676,
0.3088912666,
0.3173241019,
-0.831577599,
0.1188763157,
0.4121053219,
0.5922760367,
-0.2409147173,
-0.3229520917,
0.4074766338,
0.2057133317,
-0.2297377288,
-0.6186406016,
0.192352578,
-0.004998167,
-0.0059336494,
0.0291555412,
0.1812374294,
0.3855808973,
-0.3644456267,
0.7470986247,
0.024351202,
-0.0705067143,
-0.4376997948,
1.0999771357,
0.2455878705,
-0.1113606691,
0.8567216396,
-0.2569545507,
-0.6121756434,
0.9533116817,
0.7802352309,
0.5589178801,
-0.5003170371,
0.0563647263,
0.6340283155,
0.0214345828,
-0.0229191035,
0.5021470189,
0.2348864228,
-0.7693608999,
-0.5924181342,
-0.1490976959,
-0.1098748669,
0.0062680505,
-0.7139235139,
0.1282556206,
-0.7449721694,
-0.3959575891,
0.1313871592,
-0.3579200804,
-0.8335391879,
0.3986753821,
-0.0517786033,
0.5269431472,
-0.7977522612,
0.6222177148,
0.4187135398,
-0.5678999424,
-1.0058202744,
-0.3354264796,
0.4280106425,
-0.5750437975,
0.6983376741,
-0.0125686796,
0.1758067757,
-0.2133496702,
-0.1812606305,
-0.3782712519,
1.0146461725,
0.2429733276,
-0.7542717457,
0.094635196,
0.2292649746,
0.7192483544,
-0.2298554629,
-0.1922268569,
0.5201329589,
0.3282327652,
0.0435872525,
-0.4712797105,
0.4408545792,
-0.557793498,
-0.0195627436,
0.4324014187,
-0.4421103895,
0.7991697192,
-0.4080869257,
-0.5030347109,
0.137580514,
0.6829916239,
0.1655653566,
0.4130405486,
0.4017063677,
1.1353275776,
0.839520812,
-0.1909474581,
1.3189357519,
-0.1406576782,
-0.0287484229,
1.3509354591,
-0.5331053138,
0.4732135534,
0.5127493739,
-0.2826375067,
0.7081158757,
0.4647369385,
0.0565327741,
0.7275345325,
0.6092220545,
-0.6344390512,
-0.4060490727,
-0.5567235351,
-0.34254843,
0.1468715072,
0.473320365,
-0.6180677414,
0.3419805467,
-0.314883858,
-0.0610653907,
0.2659434974,
-0.2820678651,
0.6793782115,
0.2016743869,
-0.9921908379,
0.3500269651,
-0.2077491432,
0.0906549618,
-0.4121080339,
-0.5505891442,
0.0841837525,
0.4384009242,
-0.5362095833,
-0.0973336622,
0.406037271,
-0.3714738786,
-0.4819403291,
-0.1669843346,
0.4889317155,
-0.4464658797,
-0.3528419137,
0.1190026179,
0.3176416457,
-0.2729429007,
0.4764848351,
-0.3529909253,
-0.21772331,
-0.2537430823,
-0.0367261879,
0.0190202892,
0.4791029394,
-0.0372513235,
0.400973618,
0.4739769995,
0.4459209442,
0.0084658256,
0.2337122262,
0.8028655648,
-0.2351236194,
-0.4906205535,
-0.6160176992,
0.5773846507,
-0.1383390427,
-0.257776171,
0.2809672356,
0.6374523044,
0.8186915517,
-0.049320031,
0.8603628874,
-0.3227403462,
0.4465475678,
-0.77618891,
0.6538146734,
-0.5077667236,
0.3810236156,
0.018954834,
-0.2738307416,
-0.5590905547,
0.1543247551,
-0.2584268451,
-0.0325172357,
0.7829342484,
0.4750590324,
0.0483149514,
-0.1249610335,
0.2599821687,
-0.0295507386,
0.3066928983,
0.9739072323,
0.7453923821,
-0.4859027863,
0.2095929831,
-0.6353785396,
-0.1286585778,
0.0962563008,
-0.9367992282,
-0.590811193,
-0.5734506845,
-0.5504446626,
-0.6949989796,
0.4004533589,
0.9919387698,
1.0677570105,
-0.9036204815,
0.2576890886,
-0.1957287043,
0.0522378422,
-0.4941441417,
-0.226955846,
0.6182093024,
-0.0943519473,
-0.3069167733,
0.330044955,
0.1478076875,
0.1400291771,
0.2692045271,
-0.3315000832,
0.132375285,
-0.0859089121,
0.5961397886,
0.3805619478,
-0.4454801679,
-0.5041714907,
-0.1909884214,
-0.0040397588,
0.1561757624,
1.2143523693,
-0.77156353,
0.5154156685,
0.6083228588,
0.6837184429,
0.4859344959,
0.2213136554,
0.8227193356,
-0.968214035,
-0.0285686646,
0.5093723536,
0.5011403561,
0.318523556,
-0.8462845087,
0.5694765449,
0.4213938117,
-0.4766685665,
-0.4113891721,
0.4623066187,
-0.5230928063,
-0.0674301088,
0.8328756094,
-0.3623731136,
-0.1046877056,
-0.0988507643,
0.7388293147,
0.6313881278,
-0.1219894141,
0.9353250265,
-0.0085250475,
-0.4194627702,
0.2116840184,
-0.4911422431,
0.4227926433,
0.5793423653,
-1.0164853334,
-0.3052227497,
0.8434494734,
-0.0253656283,
0.0832259282,
0.60177356,
-0.3750928044,
0.5135675073,
-0.066207014,
0.2728853226,
-0.1066966802,
-0.560434401,
-0.2809489965,
0.0297906846,
-0.1804700643,
-0.1397321969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05934v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05934v3
|
Fine-Tuning or Retrieval? Comparing Knowledge Injection in LLMs
| 2023-12-10T16:52:00 | 2024-01-30T11:58:10 |
Oded Ovadia, Menachem Brief, Moshik Mishaeli, Oren Elisha
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs) encapsulate a vast amount of factual information
within their pre-trained weights, as evidenced by their ability to answer
diverse questions across different domains. However, this knowledge is
inherently limited, relying heavily on the characteristics of the training
data. Consequently, using external datasets to incorporate new information or
refine the capabilities of LLMs on previously seen information poses a
significant challenge. In this study, we compare two common approaches:
unsupervised fine-tuning and retrieval-augmented generation (RAG). We evaluate
both approaches on a variety of knowledge-intensive tasks across different
topics. Our findings reveal that while unsupervised fine-tuning offers some
improvement, RAG consistently outperforms it, both for existing knowledge
encountered during training and entirely new knowledge. Moreover, we find that
LLMs struggle to learn new factual information through unsupervised
fine-tuning, and that exposing them to numerous variations of the same fact
during training could alleviate this problem.
|
[
-0.5044671297,
-0.7122107148,
0.6702360511,
-0.2695152462,
-0.2521109581,
0.3520100415,
-0.7029590011,
-0.5115633011,
-0.1185147837,
0.6498542428,
-0.171106562,
-0.2950682044,
-0.6834869385,
-0.0932578668,
-0.3634114265,
1.0077120066,
0.0918369144,
0.1337391287,
-0.5492935777,
0.0287596416,
-0.5150808096,
-0.3692632616,
-0.7125954032,
-0.5771151781,
0.509783864,
0.4408793449,
0.4608185589,
0.5964559317,
0.5888783932,
0.3125838041,
-0.284940958,
0.8557515144,
-0.6733410954,
0.032264974,
-0.5169804692,
-0.541095674,
0.0812800005,
-0.156483084,
0.4154509902,
0.990647316,
-0.0614384525,
0.4000455141,
0.2959922552,
0.8545793891,
-1.0895111561,
0.0770693868,
-0.9742084742,
-0.1445114315,
-0.1601924151,
-0.3872630894,
-0.1983329654,
-0.2222917229,
0.0776689798,
-0.6480115056,
0.2465450913,
0.13760598,
0.9003170729,
0.5500717759,
-0.4411283135,
-0.3103499711,
-0.8283209801,
0.8207679987,
-0.5699265003,
0.5025658011,
0.2780246437,
0.0938099325,
-0.3353736699,
-0.6916663647,
-0.3882577121,
-0.2282853425,
-0.1785241216,
0.063344568,
-0.1639591604,
-0.019375179,
0.4228459001,
0.4656331837,
-0.1778492928,
0.433234185,
-0.2881309688,
-0.1282001436,
0.6154266,
0.04519137,
-0.1648610383,
-0.3245856464,
-0.2389833182,
-0.0203655437,
-1.0068135262,
-0.050513871,
0.2949362695,
0.5214357376,
0.2319176644,
0.8330640793,
-0.5790633559,
0.7161633968,
0.3747479618,
-0.2534756362,
0.1294501722,
-0.1941990256,
-0.2411270887,
-0.1927455813,
0.637478888,
0.4537082613,
0.4019538164,
-0.4372785389,
-0.3586847782,
-0.2101348341,
0.1017068401,
-0.6672521234,
0.0256430171,
-0.0600360632,
-0.2540966272,
-0.1533651799,
0.1334168315,
-0.5689929128,
-0.7297665477,
-0.6752483249,
0.5886231661,
-0.272859484,
-0.0619564764,
0.1667287648,
-0.3296023011,
0.2286987007,
0.496035099,
-0.881015718,
0.1140753627,
0.8468686938,
0.5387806892,
-0.5358871222,
0.0366474018,
-0.6242547035,
0.1984989345,
-0.4135119915,
1.0625393391,
-0.5437007546,
-0.2259825617,
0.1526400596,
-0.0324746631,
0.1224185005,
-1.0669009686,
0.4314597547,
-0.7050581574,
0.1263155341,
-0.5254523754,
-0.8555088639,
-0.0624783002,
0.090056777,
-0.2687844038,
1.1495888233,
0.1202600673,
-0.8746972084,
0.6817909479,
-0.3119665682,
-0.3948234916,
-0.0251984503,
-0.3410584033,
-0.1176076755,
0.4209144711,
0.1159447506,
0.7194068432,
-0.4916745424,
0.294274807,
-0.3002705276,
-0.4526833594,
0.2643031478,
-0.3753809035,
0.0615570247,
0.3133535385,
-0.0903912261,
-0.1984754503,
-0.8788588643,
0.0345528051,
-0.0439110771,
-0.6445883512,
-0.5177813172,
0.0022509678,
-0.3986943066,
-0.0646355078,
0.4747303724,
-0.5745967031,
0.1966639459,
-0.5911483169,
0.1118171439,
0.7476859093,
0.2328101546,
0.5416368246,
-0.6068565845,
0.1367511451,
0.1721311808,
-0.1860016584,
0.0665749162,
-0.0851882771,
-0.9192798734,
-0.0680759922,
0.4714707136,
0.4731625617,
-0.9783882499,
0.2191005349,
-0.1764870435,
-0.4186959267,
-0.5700979233,
0.3740410209,
0.4504036307,
0.4580575824,
0.539347887,
-0.1639614105,
-0.4469867945,
-0.882858932,
-0.5410388112,
0.1466630548,
-0.248051703,
0.5935267806,
0.307839185,
-0.1356578022,
0.643771112,
-0.6049254537,
-0.245542258,
-0.1493834555,
0.0649098679,
0.0855990574,
0.4816603959,
0.27233845,
-0.475964576,
-0.5822396874,
0.3359953165,
-0.6348959804,
-0.0010408098,
-0.0032085148,
0.0932603478,
0.3470850885,
0.6721523404,
-0.5429294705,
0.4559845328,
0.2275608629,
0.0619254969,
0.5047028065,
-0.4182252586,
0.3939535618,
-0.9561053514,
0.006727037,
-0.3589376509,
-0.232851401,
-0.5999732614,
0.0443405025,
0.1266472489,
0.2317797393,
-0.4852374494,
0.6886352897,
-0.6953322291,
-0.2598299086,
-0.4384092987,
0.2809281647,
0.0717373267,
0.3710904717,
-0.1887833327,
1.0633919239,
0.4257347286,
-0.8144224882,
0.3382427096,
0.0921332166,
-0.8439779282,
0.1244800016,
-0.5591538548,
0.1920580715,
-0.1799240708,
-0.174514696,
-0.6884332895,
-0.2806652188,
-0.1069165096,
-0.3336029053,
0.7506274581,
-0.2264572233,
-0.7211384177,
-0.1387159377,
-0.3192843497,
0.1822828352,
0.6515383124,
-0.6859428287,
0.2495033592,
0.2731251121,
0.0325908586,
-0.7084338069,
-0.5086054206,
-0.1715781987,
-0.3407186866,
-0.2930181623,
0.431242913,
0.1450678259,
-0.3437031806,
-0.0593495071,
-0.2970982194,
0.1187113002,
0.0797546655,
0.0211502258,
-0.1436244398,
-0.2503652573,
0.36917454,
0.1751798987,
-0.0399527736,
-0.1650300324,
-0.0321877897,
0.4301061332,
0.1288208812,
-0.5413713455,
-0.2511701584,
0.1973459572,
0.3305621445,
-0.3341931999,
0.86703825,
0.4962326884,
-0.0878048539,
-0.1824482232,
-1.0524462461,
-0.2379432768,
-0.5022696853,
0.2732689381,
-0.2936040461,
-1.0852222443,
0.3838413954,
-0.6317382455,
0.0733289123,
0.3688544929,
0.5233325958,
-0.3779856563,
0.970477879,
0.722982049,
0.1172298491,
0.6577084064,
-0.3059960008,
-0.1338484734,
-1.1259362698,
-0.2121112645,
-0.5211156607,
-0.1867039651,
-0.663267374,
-0.5368357897,
0.314332813,
0.3795299828,
-0.331723839,
-0.0274429582,
-0.4681404829,
0.5395815372,
0.6180424094,
0.2112928331,
0.5376391411,
0.1745309234,
-0.05310978,
0.0398246944,
-0.9064002037,
-0.3790525794,
1.4405437708,
0.0149852596,
0.9238490462,
0.0677289963,
0.5664898753,
-0.1204833835,
0.2022500634,
-0.7651161551,
0.5001472831,
-0.4848487973,
-0.3828837574,
-0.1632025987,
-0.6009361148,
-1.2334554195,
0.229351148,
-0.6213904023,
-0.6003844738,
0.2666144371,
0.1834176779,
-0.3160470724,
0.4383521676,
-0.7174505591,
0.4011161029,
-0.1789822876,
-0.3435978889,
-0.2278002799,
-0.4302473068,
0.2366463244,
-0.2673250437,
0.1632796228,
-0.0593217388,
-0.0568406954,
0.6135188341,
-0.2237889767,
0.7140503526,
-0.084476538,
-0.1523594707,
0.0810849518,
-0.1785442084,
0.5829990506,
0.0438774154,
-0.0878729597,
-0.0868342593,
0.0378518328,
-0.2090513557,
-0.9343280196,
0.7206795216,
-0.7437366247,
-0.9830770493,
-0.1361916661,
-0.6903550625,
-0.5964554548,
0.1789751351,
0.3736120164,
0.4930582345,
-0.0127351265,
0.4039830267,
1.0382909775,
-0.4661728144,
0.0996980965,
0.8566099405,
-0.1353560984,
-0.1665700525,
0.8293874264,
0.2816651165,
0.5219430923,
0.7063792944,
0.2096613199,
-0.202855587,
-0.814053297,
-0.2299565375,
0.4516710043,
-0.6088077426,
-0.5011366606,
-0.4673281312,
-0.2599853575,
-0.4673725069,
0.1025309786,
-0.4952123761,
-0.4681823552,
-0.4221583307,
0.0566999801,
0.6283869743,
0.815341413,
-0.261770308,
0.168244794,
-0.6213493943,
0.3987281024,
0.3280681372,
0.4645956755,
-0.2022917867,
-0.8883859515,
-0.4427179694,
0.2147105336,
-0.207259655,
-0.6267778873,
-0.1587377638,
0.1149119213,
0.5902170539,
0.4529899061,
0.1410894692,
0.9454289079,
-0.692091763,
0.5269959569,
-0.1084467247,
-0.4864596725,
0.4984086454,
-0.1285484582,
0.4425427914,
0.796320498,
0.3370142281,
-0.2614126503,
-0.492072016,
-0.5221690536,
-0.7631155849,
0.4373775423,
-0.233425945,
0.1760357916,
-0.0041074152,
0.7190186977,
0.2006184608,
0.5212011933,
-0.0822114572,
-0.2774140239,
0.2794625163,
-0.0000857703,
-0.2227147371,
-0.3014034331,
-0.1819449216,
-0.3851009309,
0.6228070259,
-0.0932783335,
0.1560250074,
0.039663516,
-0.2030646801,
-0.103236489,
0.2364925444,
0.4027493298,
0.7236890793,
-0.1251712739,
0.2277569175,
0.5465549231,
-0.1960551441,
-0.1342685372,
0.082980074,
-0.3141413331,
-0.0795287415,
0.4412359893,
0.9369335175,
0.4106206298,
-0.6794589162,
0.3502272964,
0.2245209515,
-0.2216353863,
-0.0002489724,
0.3795767128,
0.0626759976,
0.4453419745,
0.2054050565,
-0.0419853665,
0.0878359303,
-0.5900823474,
0.0318359658,
0.7434951067,
-0.0266144034,
0.1517910361,
0.2932789326,
-0.0488970317,
-0.0462812968,
0.2954753339,
-0.1027798802,
-0.1601584852,
0.2400772721,
0.3503033221,
0.4250627458,
0.0415795743,
0.0175480321,
0.2784681618,
0.1408883482,
-0.1642446816,
0.1708927453,
-0.1389676183,
-0.8440026641,
-0.7739502192,
-0.7052145004,
-0.3279132247,
0.3628261089,
-0.8945922256,
0.0863549113,
-0.2251643836,
-0.0362362489,
-0.1078306958,
0.2341514975,
-0.8325389624,
0.0163637046,
-0.3344706893,
0.9812262058,
-0.5435287952,
0.6987424493,
0.9448241591,
-0.302361995,
-0.7745035887,
0.0227221735,
-0.3526575565,
-0.8604290485,
0.6376670599,
-0.2791291475,
0.0310753603,
0.1097669452,
-0.5079079866,
-1.076679945,
1.1324343681,
0.4715655148,
-0.4926573932,
0.0940557197,
0.1532821357,
0.5152257085,
0.0452919081,
-0.019245211,
0.7097079158,
0.3901735246,
0.1633934975,
-0.9195998311,
-0.140729785,
0.3054421246,
-0.0296136402,
0.3003511727,
-0.6227986813,
0.5560020208,
-0.3488855958,
-0.4852496386,
0.0383085646,
0.7171722054,
0.1125926599,
0.1393972784,
0.4717099965,
0.6418249607,
0.9929874539,
-0.0850576684,
0.940618813,
-0.3056010306,
0.3106262386,
1.388655901,
-0.1106846258,
0.8986837864,
0.5906475782,
-0.1823785752,
0.1598156244,
0.5789189935,
0.0635649487,
0.633574903,
0.1708040088,
-0.2677394748,
-0.3335432112,
-0.2690074146,
-0.5043267012,
0.3536423147,
0.2895081937,
-0.0481826738,
-0.3511191308,
0.1965940148,
0.1126122922,
0.2124993801,
-0.406780988,
1.3331160545,
0.1086601987,
-0.8322187066,
0.803547442,
0.0573698282,
0.7353337407,
-0.4585365653,
0.148886323,
-0.4833867848,
0.1093496531,
-0.1841980815,
-0.8761957288,
0.3119037151,
0.2108033001,
-0.2839430273,
-0.1496120393,
0.8912072182,
-0.5640965104,
-0.1502676159,
0.1222833022,
0.755104959,
0.1154719591,
-0.0990325958,
-0.6302653551,
0.0123551618,
-0.1294062883,
-0.2910610139,
0.6388822794,
0.7750508785,
0.1851580441,
0.837544024,
0.7286277413,
0.3371355534,
0.0002356472,
0.1109009311,
1.1148680449,
-0.3876071274,
0.1124614552,
-0.6292985678,
0.205836907,
-0.0631370693,
-0.1718135625,
0.9620978236,
0.6029486656,
0.9949401021,
-0.0581708811,
0.6410013437,
0.1954408288,
0.8757148981,
-0.7886385918,
0.5181419849,
-0.8634234071,
0.4278172255,
-0.116836749,
-0.7406286001,
-0.1354331374,
0.4443882108,
-0.3248841763,
0.0979298353,
0.5975432992,
0.9484282732,
-0.1258860826,
-0.2638239861,
0.4445764422,
0.4100516737,
-0.0121570267,
0.3678632677,
1.104064703,
-0.1638578773,
0.3057789207,
-0.20583193,
-0.1301657557,
-0.0861385241,
-0.7248203158,
-0.9688777328,
-0.4614269137,
-0.1253612787,
-0.0801936015,
0.2191199362,
0.7844547629,
0.4884630144,
-0.7737752795,
-0.0358805582,
0.0139109539,
0.2698507607,
0.0564044937,
-0.1608018726,
0.2843429446,
-0.642691195,
-0.6347182393,
0.529032588,
0.0991182625,
0.0301186498,
-0.2014537752,
0.2604188323,
-0.1236851364,
0.1371427476,
0.6888483763,
0.2934831381,
-0.7131069303,
-0.5979796648,
-0.1265954226,
0.0733125955,
-0.1012790874,
0.7438102365,
-0.8846153617,
0.3300989866,
0.5087087154,
1.0349262953,
0.6381052136,
0.0269696992,
0.3932266831,
-0.8607587218,
-0.009410562,
-0.1035216898,
0.2638052702,
0.3798324168,
-0.3240511417,
0.4272665381,
-0.034295354,
-0.7212263942,
-1.0479706526,
0.3121724129,
-0.705760777,
-0.52970469,
1.44226408,
0.0735014826,
0.1675230563,
-0.2064617574,
-0.2060680538,
0.3327656984,
-0.118690297,
0.6852440238,
0.5490392447,
-0.131776914,
0.0550320297,
-0.8164079785,
0.8164248466,
0.4843625128,
-0.7436079383,
0.1268246472,
0.2515515387,
0.4252674878,
-0.0180349201,
0.4302151203,
0.0918648168,
0.0221394897,
-0.4253268838,
-0.1363767684,
-0.1940693259,
-0.3717755675,
-0.1741028875,
-0.0133839287,
0.209920451,
0.0792282149
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07573v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07573v1
|
Arabic Handwritten Text Line Dataset
| 2023-12-10T14:32:25 | 2023-12-10T14:32:25 |
Hakim Bouchal, Ahror Belaid
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Segmentation of Arabic manuscripts into lines of text and words is an
important step to make recognition systems more efficient and accurate. The
problem of segmentation into text lines is solved since there are carefully
annotated dataset dedicated to this task. However, To the best of our
knowledge, there are no dataset annotating the word position of Arabic texts.
In this paper, we present a new dataset specifically designed for historical
Arabic script in which we annotate position in word level.
|
[
-0.2645263672,
-0.4302192032,
0.3838258088,
-0.1286059767,
-0.6129158735,
0.1484315544,
0.3940839171,
-0.4278104007,
0.4069941938,
0.8862674236,
-0.4944333434,
-1.2543934584,
-0.7223733068,
-0.0037937022,
-0.660564959,
1.0719666481,
-0.2255842388,
-0.2095531523,
0.1937912703,
-0.4795064032,
-0.4895501733,
-0.5604252815,
-0.2024594098,
-0.0267474763,
0.216065228,
0.7902528048,
0.9721406102,
1.0988084078,
0.8094294667,
0.2595702708,
0.1314929277,
0.3205456436,
0.081558533,
0.3012430668,
0.2648324668,
-0.271261692,
-0.1545630395,
0.0626557842,
0.6140791774,
0.7263285518,
0.1038998216,
0.1397227347,
-0.5578302741,
0.6439151764,
-0.489144057,
-0.1440471411,
-0.3292898238,
0.1748645306,
-0.8149418235,
-0.372685492,
0.0274170693,
-0.9375581741,
0.4265978038,
-0.3250667453,
0.1732982248,
0.1310520023,
1.0276197195,
0.0488904305,
-0.4188026786,
-0.7979726791,
-0.4887370765,
0.6547092795,
-0.6715719104,
-0.0886384472,
0.4317182004,
0.4876246452,
-0.0595028289,
-0.825534761,
-0.498406738,
0.1220532358,
0.1018819362,
-0.1270650476,
0.1999883056,
-0.2181959301,
0.2226892859,
0.4713916481,
-0.3132647276,
-0.0960040689,
-0.2495639473,
-0.4937883317,
0.8710703254,
0.4525608122,
0.786219418,
0.04645437,
-0.3492419124,
-0.4550870359,
-0.718758285,
-0.0174507238,
0.5743966103,
0.0920325667,
0.0304528773,
0.5686393976,
-0.0277125072,
1.0424164534,
-0.2665108442,
-0.5238565803,
0.285533905,
0.0529444888,
-0.0175521225,
0.4949662387,
0.4628610611,
0.5702395439,
0.3437604308,
0.1207410246,
-0.2888783514,
-0.1316703409,
0.2195712477,
-0.8352984786,
-0.2998230755,
-0.2321487516,
-0.6369184852,
-0.1940318048,
0.4433900416,
-0.5691182017,
-0.6749300957,
-0.0924412385,
0.1121338978,
-0.4068483114,
0.1987858713,
-0.0656338334,
-0.2703242302,
0.3955583572,
0.4417318404,
-1.1635382175,
0.2783782184,
0.2406367362,
0.9419397712,
0.0129953697,
-0.14721708,
0.0983641893,
0.1368667334,
-0.59796381,
0.9082910419,
-0.6384794712,
-0.6159200668,
0.24635759,
-0.0954148024,
0.285844475,
-0.5988545418,
1.0326464176,
-0.5416252613,
0.1558329016,
-0.1636406481,
-0.6625598669,
-0.3895511031,
-0.2080912739,
-0.7463773489,
0.8741190434,
0.2137556672,
-0.9098072648,
0.5649748445,
-0.5090071559,
-0.6164531112,
0.0104153855,
-0.1655240059,
-0.5756911635,
-0.2066771537,
0.5585961938,
0.373265326,
-0.0821062177,
-0.2829754055,
-0.0922182798,
-0.6002113223,
0.1752303988,
-0.1607807577,
0.81176126,
0.4896309674,
-0.2510923445,
-0.09327472,
-0.8369623423,
0.198128134,
-0.305955857,
-0.3059604764,
-0.570376277,
-0.0260081068,
0.659103334,
0.2238271832,
0.5808670521,
-0.6759616733,
0.7127486467,
-0.5604032278,
0.0223803781,
0.4464527667,
0.1764652431,
0.1995496303,
-0.487565726,
0.6253945827,
-0.0434283875,
-0.3026305735,
-0.133870244,
-0.2392927408,
-0.7515342832,
-0.2534817159,
0.3726556003,
0.536578238,
-0.5831791162,
0.7442341447,
-0.1205636784,
-0.5229142904,
-0.5691750646,
-0.1435404271,
0.147647962,
0.3403677344,
0.4228282571,
-0.0941855162,
-0.6923030615,
-1.2008435726,
0.0385928936,
0.1373961419,
-0.0266744886,
-0.0888631269,
0.3142105341,
-0.0193108898,
1.0001862049,
-0.8956183195,
-0.6986668706,
-0.0291649569,
0.2916211784,
0.2991748154,
0.2295375615,
0.5019632578,
-0.6300845146,
-0.6177566051,
-0.0124583179,
-0.5880154967,
-0.4966843426,
0.013695702,
-0.2979743183,
0.2703863382,
0.6202420592,
0.1357681751,
0.9473266602,
0.4216690063,
-0.629314661,
0.0213502049,
-0.1018681601,
0.2334433198,
-1.2652028799,
0.2638643682,
-0.2460591793,
-0.1661768705,
-0.6063880324,
-0.6182101965,
0.2533034682,
0.0132241994,
-0.1150022373,
0.4805829227,
-0.5864816904,
0.1004577875,
-0.7436443567,
-0.1788056046,
-0.2827750444,
0.3055643141,
0.3088005781,
0.6611052155,
0.348898232,
0.0109684104,
0.3723936081,
0.7989115715,
-0.7275266051,
0.6450465322,
-0.2898751795,
0.377340585,
-0.0916275308,
0.0714188218,
-1.1135333776,
-0.1124107987,
0.1190771237,
-0.1675123721,
0.2373187542,
0.0599920154,
-0.1888329685,
-0.0403049365,
-0.2052544057,
0.5226293206,
0.3007690609,
-0.2518318892,
-0.1019830555,
0.6480867863,
-0.2648374438,
-0.8717828989,
-0.4878142476,
0.1693653464,
-0.3066836596,
-0.4362659156,
0.465074569,
0.4702230394,
-0.3222439885,
-0.4057365656,
-0.226624161,
-0.2925690711,
-0.1452003419,
0.729670465,
0.4265009463,
0.0217013024,
0.0869863853,
0.1965540946,
-0.2479051203,
-0.2246198356,
-0.1803542525,
0.5201224685,
0.3934118152,
-0.1315022558,
-0.6579009295,
0.5509849787,
0.666865468,
-0.2929310799,
0.6879024506,
0.3137251139,
-0.6106050611,
-0.1253972948,
-0.4441906214,
0.2269798815,
-0.350371033,
-0.0264534429,
-0.2728702426,
-0.766313374,
0.3695451319,
0.1073454767,
0.0165189151,
0.7514565587,
0.2739033103,
-0.2085835189,
0.7385300398,
0.4783494473,
-0.4729440808,
0.4349551201,
0.0033920992,
-0.0608167909,
-0.5628181696,
-0.1897737384,
-0.7637585402,
-0.6233532429,
-0.3100182712,
0.1135151461,
0.2682645917,
-0.0528607033,
-0.0796175376,
0.1957452744,
-0.4573831856,
0.4217867255,
0.3934796751,
0.0954789221,
0.1290647537,
-0.0021488646,
-0.2212816924,
-0.0261570998,
-0.0387461968,
-1.0294183493,
1.0847748518,
0.0896105468,
0.7800452709,
-0.1031722203,
0.8844516277,
0.6966596842,
0.2236306369,
-0.5287148952,
0.3673146367,
-0.0362278633,
-0.5795688629,
-0.8104764819,
0.0985166579,
-1.0815159082,
-0.3489575088,
-0.2387100011,
-0.606490016,
0.1711951643,
-0.2475474626,
-0.5722454786,
0.07814762,
-0.5376158953,
0.7205024958,
0.0087565035,
0.031967368,
0.2357209176,
-0.9562113285,
-0.4192574918,
0.0964708701,
-0.1867741644,
-0.2818750441,
-0.0526846349,
1.3670800924,
-1.2497208118,
0.5505722761,
-0.4301915169,
-0.2386827022,
0.6781412959,
-0.1040273532,
0.384275943,
-0.4191007614,
-0.0301953722,
0.1247571111,
0.3186147511,
-0.3331007957,
-0.1074525639,
0.4937740564,
-0.7873961926,
-0.1868512183,
-0.6601577997,
-0.5546240211,
0.009678809,
0.2526878715,
0.4526521564,
0.8287426233,
-0.1416150481,
0.0817489251,
-0.0680453256,
-0.1227292418,
0.6670569181,
0.0977095515,
-0.1931779534,
-0.6439818144,
0.4367052913,
0.4869688153,
-0.4266136289,
0.6420024037,
-0.1946888864,
-0.7022314668,
-0.8641272783,
-0.6822556853,
-0.0085708117,
-0.715049088,
-0.1262290925,
-0.1974617839,
-0.3039940298,
-0.1800115854,
-0.377902329,
0.2666648328,
-0.5676348209,
-0.2770825028,
-0.1859650016,
0.6665472388,
1.0116881132,
0.2868146598,
0.5626249313,
-0.8063371181,
0.1770535558,
-0.0008292898,
0.0916229412,
-0.1735191196,
-0.2634674609,
-0.539699614,
-0.1378447115,
-0.4101032019,
-1.0267710686,
0.7724616528,
0.0822734535,
0.1270634085,
0.3718387783,
-0.1143361554,
0.5378934741,
-0.6824755073,
0.4679926038,
0.0235517938,
-1.0632711649,
0.5418473482,
-0.5910525322,
0.5150256753,
0.7070353031,
0.4921363294,
-0.9221149683,
-0.0387585051,
-0.377255857,
-0.8668980002,
0.8592963219,
0.223464936,
-0.3263196647,
0.159273982,
0.3654051721,
0.5580186248,
0.2228656709,
-0.0588729046,
-0.5245111585,
-0.101831086,
-0.7800733447,
-0.0261223651,
-0.3080581129,
0.1375418305,
-0.0551461317,
0.466833055,
0.168974787,
0.2620717585,
0.2795903683,
-0.3382656276,
-0.0864045098,
-0.0139848506,
0.5836922526,
1.0587100983,
-0.2443684638,
0.2307889014,
0.1355310678,
-0.9527496099,
0.6275216937,
0.1674745828,
-0.3227590919,
0.018940011,
0.6294004321,
0.6721056104,
-0.3732614517,
-0.3518391252,
0.4809174836,
0.2541537583,
-0.2147172987,
-0.7614464164,
0.0557711348,
-0.0280294679,
0.1362161785,
0.6492830515,
-0.1119206995,
0.1818208396,
-0.3806640208,
0.3557725847,
0.3060455024,
-0.3645116091,
0.2187544107,
0.4527530372,
0.1313488632,
-0.7053775191,
0.8736255765,
0.3929891586,
-0.4500535131,
0.4926474988,
0.2922927737,
0.4125023186,
-0.4671854377,
0.2681143284,
0.1571715474,
-0.1482504457,
0.1178421378,
0.4987896681,
-0.0755833611,
-0.5869165659,
0.0054993937,
-0.6636951566,
-0.4509385824,
-0.1540890336,
-0.4269206822,
0.3535718322,
-0.6427308321,
-0.1478622556,
-0.0331672281,
0.1762944907,
-0.4211034179,
0.6017240286,
0.1848535836,
0.7818703055,
-0.7676383853,
0.9896276593,
0.478038609,
-0.3109190762,
-0.5633692741,
-0.1069224998,
-0.1237001345,
-1.0089042187,
0.6857204437,
0.4830649793,
-0.2977944016,
0.225271821,
-0.4806629717,
-0.9242803454,
1.2395660877,
-0.1019706354,
-0.4654743969,
0.0687262565,
0.439299494,
0.6936593652,
-0.3013537824,
0.4269520342,
0.447863251,
0.4299759269,
0.0316867642,
-0.5020552278,
-0.0165388789,
-0.2790122032,
-0.0136936512,
0.8368901014,
-0.4838298559,
0.5448557138,
0.2845393717,
-0.3774741888,
0.5632935762,
0.5546702147,
-0.4112655222,
0.3234956861,
0.3355423212,
0.9279322624,
0.6228161454,
-0.284941256,
0.6759297252,
0.0869098753,
0.1159624755,
0.6838827133,
-0.4816934466,
0.70766747,
0.2481694072,
-0.2391275167,
0.8594537973,
0.5911716819,
0.0712324902,
0.5089111924,
0.4985749125,
-0.4721780121,
-0.0424230732,
0.0133428723,
-0.3340444863,
0.7088559866,
0.3102861345,
-0.7874878645,
-0.1198433712,
-0.1550164223,
0.4571794868,
0.0140889324,
-0.3282512724,
0.7978084683,
-0.1863764077,
-0.5393016934,
0.5022957325,
0.1413583755,
0.448825717,
-0.6689914465,
-0.2893901467,
-0.1313693821,
0.0445288755,
-0.3671344817,
-0.7341881394,
0.3076300025,
-0.1165331751,
-0.017891176,
0.0130995065,
0.8102912307,
-0.4286665022,
-0.5631789565,
-0.3077027798,
0.2715938091,
0.3976066411,
0.2415404916,
-0.093583025,
-0.058652509,
0.1532573402,
0.0017782543,
-0.0120171253,
0.5380171537,
-0.3558091223,
0.2435020059,
0.5490038991,
-0.0496158116,
-0.1838110983,
-0.1186112389,
0.4286262691,
-1.2039018869,
-0.5419288874,
-0.9995254278,
0.2659212351,
-0.2134512067,
-0.6674481034,
0.7591211796,
0.5453975201,
0.4355169237,
-0.1905506402,
1.0182023048,
0.1055447608,
0.9035007358,
-0.6301139593,
1.0859098434,
-0.3255293965,
-0.2593556941,
-0.5495061874,
-0.9389311075,
-0.7122687697,
0.9004632831,
-0.5107547641,
-0.0276026558,
0.8319761157,
0.7687669992,
0.3603307307,
0.2946749926,
0.1155897528,
-0.2199541181,
-0.0954267308,
0.5555907488,
1.0537296534,
-0.270116955,
0.2927139401,
-0.238127932,
-0.1759519875,
-0.3511069119,
-0.7959791422,
-0.9552435279,
-0.8975421786,
0.0233706422,
0.0500074215,
0.1163080558,
1.1289703846,
0.4453677237,
-0.8748397231,
-0.5291487575,
0.0722937211,
-0.2303202897,
-0.0784694105,
-0.0692058802,
1.0744202137,
0.3451302946,
-0.6328413486,
0.1233598292,
0.3160149157,
0.4527469277,
0.106895186,
0.1220452711,
-0.4117211998,
-0.2581675351,
-0.0189587604,
0.232938394,
-0.1803179979,
-0.5200955868,
-0.2983050644,
-0.2096490711,
0.4435700476,
0.8626228571,
-0.6611404419,
0.3151862323,
0.5128528476,
0.5686146021,
0.4727284908,
0.1278174967,
0.4082253277,
-0.63579005,
0.2038855553,
0.3432995379,
0.5122765303,
0.4005999863,
-0.2929531038,
0.4364356399,
0.0517904907,
-0.7470058203,
-0.0685236901,
0.138900131,
-1.0877349377,
0.1608676165,
0.7976709008,
-0.0783435777,
-0.2050318569,
-0.5774274468,
-1.2359935045,
0.4854534864,
-0.4334620535,
0.8899190426,
1.1162497997,
-0.1689324528,
0.1394778043,
0.0629938841,
0.6902356744,
0.2912304699,
-0.8348309398,
-0.1167479604,
0.90936023,
0.0098598367,
0.1566509306,
0.6024147272,
-0.22245197,
-0.0421226732,
0.0073722014,
0.23193717,
-0.0434340239,
-0.3558363616,
-0.2416196913,
0.3959393203,
0.2677039504,
-0.6122926474
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06705v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06705v1
|
Perceiving University Student's Opinions from Google App Reviews
| 2023-12-10T12:34:30 | 2023-12-10T12:34:30 |
Sakshi Ranjan, Subhankar Mishra
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Google app market captures the school of thought of users from every corner
of the globe via ratings and text reviews, in a multilinguistic arena. The
potential information from the reviews cannot be extracted manually, due to its
exponential growth. So, Sentiment analysis, by machine learning and deep
learning algorithms employing NLP, explicitly uncovers and interprets the
emotions. This study performs the sentiment classification of the app reviews
and identifies the university student's behavior towards the app market via
exploratory analysis. We applied machine learning algorithms using the TP, TF,
and TF IDF text representation scheme and evaluated its performance on Bagging,
an ensemble learning method. We used word embedding, Glove, on the deep
learning paradigms. Our model was trained on Google app reviews and tested on
Student's App Reviews(SAR). The various combinations of these algorithms were
compared amongst each other using F score and accuracy and inferences were
highlighted graphically. SVM, amongst other classifiers, gave fruitful
accuracy(93.41%), F score(89%) on bigram and TF IDF scheme. Bagging enhanced
the performance of LR and NB with accuracy of 87.88% and 86.69% and F score of
86% and 78% respectively. Overall, LSTM on Glove embedding recorded the highest
accuracy(95.2%) and F score(88%).
|
[
-0.3871510625,
-0.6553167701,
0.3047548234,
0.1830343604,
-0.3033598959,
0.6461367011,
-0.1542122811,
-0.3491873443,
0.2007611096,
0.1438582093,
-0.3372737169,
-0.8734921217,
-0.1921991557,
-0.2088026702,
-0.2258692831,
1.3791002035,
-0.0161675923,
0.3150333464,
-0.2344647199,
-0.40450266,
-0.4410658479,
-0.5088013411,
-0.4529112875,
-0.5539265871,
0.0982585698,
0.6619738936,
0.5161570907,
-0.3188208044,
0.3149285614,
0.2836711407,
0.1870326996,
-0.2498142868,
-0.255125612,
-0.2223522812,
0.11255043,
-0.3127779961,
-0.2434877455,
0.4424368441,
0.2968436182,
0.2749465108,
-0.2529287636,
0.2368891537,
0.3381510377,
0.8986116052,
-0.4746769071,
0.1317331791,
-0.4614906609,
0.386030525,
0.1503801495,
-0.0334124342,
-0.401432544,
-0.3225634396,
0.2966899276,
-0.3737622797,
0.0808555856,
-0.0505980365,
0.8704956174,
-0.0702493265,
-0.1313808262,
-0.559065938,
-0.6871034503,
0.9814808369,
-0.5095499754,
0.2228613645,
0.1447790861,
0.3106046021,
-0.1007704213,
-0.1043857262,
-0.8549045324,
-0.1154285148,
0.2270747274,
0.4634845555,
0.1116439849,
0.0925499648,
-0.1869340241,
0.6562585831,
-0.6222516894,
-0.061536707,
-0.4272232354,
0.0074493941,
0.8862530589,
0.0962945521,
0.3783085942,
-0.1894106418,
-0.7817811966,
-0.5905414224,
-0.2257205099,
0.6997156143,
0.5704123974,
-0.1011628881,
-0.0828814507,
0.4467763901,
-0.137660861,
0.4231568873,
-0.0081979232,
0.1406472921,
0.6674371362,
0.0087576862,
-0.6963931322,
0.2834360898,
1.0670224428,
0.7010407448,
0.230443567,
-0.0109576443,
-0.3320820332,
0.5277336836,
0.5220578909,
-0.5383887887,
-0.3370500207,
0.5736454725,
-0.5368199348,
-0.4558658302,
0.1959422827,
-0.7745046616,
-0.5629151464,
-0.1645109653,
0.2387729585,
-0.2734265327,
-0.1583002806,
0.1970186532,
-0.0971728936,
0.3663897812,
0.2175208479,
-0.8078967333,
0.3940767348,
0.6797308326,
0.5978449583,
-0.1571245492,
-0.2988983691,
0.1703787446,
-0.3883245587,
-0.3130922019,
0.8658781648,
-0.7726650238,
-0.6585481167,
0.0075105247,
-0.4554308355,
-0.2406288534,
-0.52085495,
0.9659461975,
-0.662930727,
0.1857170314,
0.1379721016,
-0.8340537548,
-0.6552271843,
0.4659585357,
-0.3999066055,
1.1437863111,
0.0293692518,
-0.4113244116,
0.5878254771,
-0.6910974383,
-0.3225595951,
0.2597390115,
-0.2388035506,
-0.49890697,
0.4494985044,
0.5214311481,
0.7708199024,
0.356911689,
0.1464109272,
-0.4143895507,
-0.3970214427,
0.3451244533,
-0.0533182435,
0.5554043055,
0.374076128,
-0.1757957339,
0.0916127786,
-0.4197745025,
0.2804610431,
-0.0586176999,
-0.3056157827,
-0.5789456964,
-0.1621885002,
0.1256683171,
0.0754505992,
-0.2746115625,
-0.6933279634,
0.6543795466,
-0.3571882546,
0.3854417503,
0.6846956015,
-0.0718823373,
0.7669212818,
0.0382179618,
0.5811018944,
-0.034530174,
0.1432996094,
0.0479217954,
-0.681379199,
-0.2311889827,
0.0970245153,
0.4102303386,
0.4132565856,
-0.4374537766,
0.1865192354,
-0.2123758048,
-0.6187904477,
-0.7918224931,
0.3148605525,
0.1808083504,
0.3861589432,
0.135845542,
-0.3788953125,
-0.3437114358,
-0.3843124509,
-0.6241895556,
-0.4308696687,
-0.0305975489,
0.5300340056,
0.5265381932,
-0.6303242445,
0.9547007084,
-0.3911482394,
-0.5898710489,
-0.2739765644,
0.3635172248,
0.2091757953,
0.2093759179,
0.3325735033,
-0.9713699222,
-0.54960078,
-0.0469411574,
-0.6905376315,
0.0492478609,
-0.3346718252,
0.2174505442,
0.3124134541,
-0.0251741353,
-0.3002748191,
0.4138468206,
0.6536941528,
-0.5208317041,
0.4971625209,
-0.057075996,
0.2285911888,
-0.8570418358,
-0.2461571395,
0.6157630682,
0.1632840037,
-0.3169077933,
0.0343962051,
0.0097388709,
-0.1449193954,
-0.2726926804,
0.7618696094,
-0.291318804,
-0.0222247634,
-0.3019247651,
0.0964792967,
-0.0006808695,
0.150389418,
-0.0268443804,
0.6329848766,
0.2731429935,
-0.5163952708,
0.3008856475,
0.298245877,
-0.8842629194,
0.3955891132,
-0.3350606859,
0.017677702,
0.1623779982,
0.4464339316,
-1.3043931723,
-0.2696681321,
0.2469745278,
-0.8270535469,
0.024660008,
0.1233419478,
-0.2718447447,
-0.6998420954,
-0.7887555957,
0.0608608201,
0.3529609442,
-0.7451124787,
0.702311635,
0.7808741927,
-0.0886751041,
-0.5762922168,
-0.4452019334,
0.1404234767,
-0.2616198361,
-0.3383816183,
0.0799061283,
0.1548745185,
-0.2532304227,
-0.0446373485,
-0.0562073179,
-0.0660655871,
0.0185723975,
0.6211419702,
0.3823851347,
0.1920049489,
0.3425103426,
-0.0511167757,
-0.1234832034,
0.1076755226,
0.0503790118,
0.5709695816,
-0.4405545592,
0.1954786479,
-0.4673239887,
-0.0356129557,
0.6019195914,
0.1647072434,
0.2201524824,
0.8556950092,
-0.046924524,
-0.4626592398,
-0.493448168,
-0.2032786161,
-0.4070524275,
0.1807107478,
-0.4726192653,
-0.6005477309,
0.4191201627,
-0.1983045936,
0.0578460433,
0.3709914684,
0.5038602352,
-0.4688578546,
1.1311674118,
0.5488170981,
-0.739012301,
0.4968720973,
-0.5438938141,
0.4216102362,
-1.0399234295,
-0.4550330937,
-0.3871996403,
-0.6524170637,
-0.6074783206,
-0.0330416337,
0.1505503654,
0.1953473538,
-0.0862657428,
-0.0620228983,
-0.7023624778,
0.4821453094,
0.6077619791,
0.0916930288,
-0.2441259623,
0.6411853433,
-0.4139186442,
0.0811527222,
-0.4648149312,
-0.7166185975,
1.3181978464,
0.3918028176,
0.8234754205,
-0.1975716501,
0.6207834482,
0.6344183087,
0.5929102898,
-1.1183019876,
0.6495802402,
-0.2813618183,
-0.298238188,
-0.1193712428,
-0.3705368042,
-0.620819509,
0.2234633416,
-0.4196922481,
-0.8657248616,
-0.1607848257,
-0.1829415858,
-0.4431065917,
0.3072583675,
-0.9664433002,
0.7802018523,
-0.3680694997,
-0.3261167705,
-0.1284264177,
-0.2598124444,
0.2293101847,
0.0872942135,
0.35076648,
0.0626900122,
0.2750395834,
0.9026795626,
-0.4390572011,
0.6922017932,
-0.2810744047,
-0.0429770723,
0.6570281982,
-0.1110142693,
0.2083376348,
0.142527014,
-0.2599107623,
0.4395296276,
-0.3008167148,
-0.1931772679,
-0.4118799567,
1.094322443,
-1.0042262077,
-0.3446959257,
-0.7539853454,
-0.2644332945,
-0.084799543,
-0.1732954681,
0.0065954616,
0.0729867294,
-0.1313355267,
0.2579526901,
0.2547788024,
-0.2403960973,
0.6969796419,
0.2614516616,
-0.4834928513,
-0.4331123829,
1.0766019821,
0.102685906,
-0.4604822397,
0.0474434085,
0.6876885891,
-0.8035364747,
-0.4021829963,
-1.0033557415,
-0.1945138276,
-0.2252520174,
0.1095075011,
-0.7953487635,
0.272207886,
-0.3450928032,
-0.2594163716,
0.0099291531,
-0.0534432456,
-0.1040877923,
-0.2728621066,
-0.0084901527,
0.7199680209,
0.2339036763,
0.4273515642,
-0.8700779676,
0.0182396024,
0.2001280189,
0.4098640978,
0.2330256701,
-0.1438225359,
-0.2142771184,
-0.077802442,
-0.5664332509,
-0.6328408122,
0.5192334652,
0.2878904641,
0.215623796,
0.8787423372,
0.2239207327,
0.6627802849,
0.0428076312,
1.2250167131,
0.3120099902,
-0.7759643793,
0.4280771613,
-0.10588599,
0.2705037594,
0.7072201967,
0.4358803034,
-0.361097157,
-0.2673509121,
-0.5710006952,
-0.8984501362,
0.4519200027,
-0.1743160486,
0.4974504411,
0.3015796542,
0.3026661873,
0.3228102028,
0.3490149677,
-0.7583249211,
-0.064891018,
-0.027584197,
-0.3469891548,
-0.4381885529,
-0.3753578663,
0.3052603602,
-0.5000581145,
0.7118247747,
-0.0192831736,
0.0579602234,
-0.0171918515,
0.1260853112,
-0.0308786798,
0.4778423309,
0.3217008114,
0.3227822781,
-0.3440503478,
-0.0941990539,
0.0633998364,
-0.9107089639,
0.1997567564,
-0.2324289232,
-0.3249942362,
0.0622682273,
0.0721302852,
0.4892787337,
-0.1118673086,
-0.5928798914,
0.6189773679,
-0.3571823239,
-0.0205536615,
-0.3995555341,
0.0987300426,
-0.2936545312,
0.0641023442,
0.613429606,
0.2185056359,
0.5332600474,
-0.8505468965,
-0.1217914522,
0.5834778547,
-0.5277038217,
-0.4284267724,
0.3431562483,
0.4673011303,
-0.0979096442,
0.6727960706,
-0.164130196,
-0.8269430399,
0.4577400982,
0.3748110831,
1.294246316,
-0.3033381701,
0.6447702646,
0.4541434944,
-0.0607364215,
-0.0312307831,
0.3497617245,
-0.3734117746,
-0.691775322,
-0.1405343413,
-0.8754074574,
-0.6279881001,
0.1796879172,
-0.59865731,
0.0446296781,
-0.338907063,
-0.2906935513,
0.0730977058,
0.4834370613,
-0.5182925463,
0.7172675729,
0.0988601968,
0.5186161399,
-1.0342297554,
0.649926424,
1.3352302313,
-0.1648006737,
-0.9389632344,
0.1139036492,
0.0656011477,
-0.4229679406,
0.6491576433,
0.6031438112,
-0.2329632342,
-0.4138095081,
-0.4092637002,
0.0147623653,
0.5607793331,
-0.3309625387,
-0.8682510853,
0.450247854,
0.1408667117,
0.6698589921,
-0.4943268299,
0.5467928052,
0.1000175625,
0.0999238789,
0.0743931532,
-0.3283608258,
-0.501424253,
-0.4791300893,
-0.2063473016,
0.0925138369,
-0.3967453837,
0.6832488775,
-0.2192133218,
-0.4420473278,
-0.3698924184,
0.3080845475,
0.0329139531,
1.0867986679,
0.3999841213,
0.8733180165,
0.8798269629,
-0.0286440831,
1.2614796162,
-0.4465489984,
0.5493596196,
0.9031001925,
-0.4382890463,
1.32264781,
0.5890591741,
-0.2930873334,
0.7153056264,
0.9263015389,
-0.1234431267,
0.4774266481,
0.4104618728,
-0.417575866,
-0.0361250117,
0.2035454363,
-0.3769694269,
0.5331920981,
0.3415731192,
-0.4242553711,
0.1007014811,
0.4245146215,
-0.2520081699,
-0.0114400312,
-0.7120358348,
1.0995008945,
0.1687728465,
-0.5443354249,
0.203993991,
-0.0311909001,
0.8583475947,
-0.1302848309,
-0.0206799358,
-0.0296771936,
0.5932226777,
-0.5969934464,
-1.0785182714,
-0.030058736,
0.1632812172,
-0.2500623167,
-0.2266864777,
0.8770923018,
0.0557441153,
-0.7626309991,
0.3730898499,
0.2236138582,
0.2451263368,
-0.2078181654,
-0.7761350274,
0.2105382979,
-0.0784874484,
-0.434853524,
0.2836860418,
0.1212191954,
-0.1608404964,
0.6190130711,
0.7320823669,
-0.0530694537,
-0.2027095407,
0.0863474011,
0.6528240442,
-0.5498356819,
-0.8585927486,
-1.0108124018,
0.2649246454,
-0.2077212036,
-0.4805650115,
1.0716859102,
0.8362998366,
1.254373312,
-0.3560530841,
0.8732901216,
0.2994091511,
0.3341425061,
-0.2989894152,
0.8847178221,
-0.4431206286,
0.4343709052,
-0.4897981882,
-0.9421759844,
-0.3182863295,
0.8339985013,
-0.7410778403,
-0.01577227,
0.2760569453,
0.2718802392,
0.2389092147,
0.4951868355,
0.1552103311,
-0.0554019362,
0.0737501085,
0.5152045488,
0.9467110038,
-0.5981067419,
0.2392704189,
-0.2669069767,
-0.3119660914,
-0.5769449472,
-0.5045543313,
-0.77864182,
-0.3584869802,
-0.4539745748,
-0.5452234745,
-0.1791680306,
0.8137481213,
0.5713599324,
-0.919249475,
-0.4142740369,
-0.0618596934,
0.1781309098,
-0.247196883,
-0.304459095,
0.5063012838,
-0.2981905043,
-0.650087893,
0.1480261683,
0.122900106,
-0.3070541024,
-0.2549409568,
-0.3080889583,
0.1451163441,
-0.0373710059,
0.8065892458,
0.1937020123,
-0.5259640813,
-0.156141296,
-0.1276009232,
-0.2394373715,
0.1348426938,
0.5308648944,
-0.9913850427,
0.8726644516,
0.3457745016,
0.6130319238,
0.2780722678,
0.2298727036,
0.1894723326,
-0.5188511014,
-0.318836987,
0.3465325534,
0.1006452888,
0.2272734791,
-0.2129649967,
0.429685384,
-0.0424427949,
-0.6819213629,
-0.6831502318,
-0.2435735017,
-1.0354590416,
-0.2807361484,
0.9395296574,
-0.2311847657,
-0.4414964914,
0.1097212732,
-0.5022088885,
-0.1304841191,
-0.837059319,
1.4062768221,
0.6657093763,
-0.1920905709,
-0.1174532548,
-0.4294488728,
0.3709446788,
0.1857571304,
-0.5978909135,
-0.5588078499,
0.2115687579,
0.2031990439,
0.2989143729,
0.5281275511,
0.0730500296,
0.1033343077,
-0.2044705451,
0.1501743942,
0.0678869709,
-0.2768931687,
-0.701747179,
0.6114811897,
-0.4160857797,
-0.6368311048
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05842v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05842v1
|
Mutual Enhancement of Large and Small Language Models with Cross-Silo Knowledge Transfer
| 2023-12-10T09:52:32 | 2023-12-10T09:52:32 |
Yongheng Deng, Ziqing Qiao, Ju Ren, Yang Liu, Yaoxue Zhang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
While large language models (LLMs) are empowered with broad knowledge, their
task-specific performance is often suboptimal. It necessitates fine-tuning LLMs
with task-specific data, but such data may be inaccessible due to privacy
concerns. In this paper, we propose a novel approach to enhance LLMs with
smaller language models (SLMs) that are trained on clients using their private
task-specific data. To enable mutual enhancement between LLMs and SLMs, we
propose CrossLM, where the SLMs promote the LLM to generate task-specific
high-quality data, and both the LLM and SLMs are enhanced with the generated
data. We evaluate CrossLM using publicly accessible language models across a
range of benchmark tasks. The results demonstrate that CrossLM significantly
enhances the task-specific performance of SLMs on clients and the LLM on the
cloud server simultaneously while preserving the LLM's generalization
capability.
|
[
-0.2868127227,
-0.4341362417,
0.4696855843,
0.171259433,
-0.0573584698,
0.2203256041,
-0.5346370339,
-0.8274608254,
0.0391661562,
0.7576424479,
-0.4185684621,
-0.6736834049,
-0.5703081489,
-0.2014065832,
-0.2976908088,
1.0047500134,
0.224875316,
0.003881979,
-0.4042067826,
-0.2864019573,
-0.1968557835,
-0.6553159356,
-0.4304361343,
-0.1668877751,
0.4413375854,
0.3140327036,
0.8349861503,
0.4016239643,
0.4854540229,
0.2571681738,
0.2142042965,
0.3292004764,
-0.7891099453,
0.0187181477,
-0.6407331824,
-0.5350876451,
-0.6765053272,
-0.5270126462,
0.7718545198,
0.7361638546,
0.0814017281,
0.3322995007,
0.3016045094,
0.7240991592,
-0.7067263722,
0.1783888638,
-0.9669959545,
-0.1571376324,
-0.2400186211,
0.1966951638,
-0.188594684,
-0.1991603523,
0.1972981393,
-0.4766623974,
0.2594394982,
0.1938623637,
0.7366136909,
0.093657136,
-0.06797833,
0.0870956033,
-0.8074209094,
0.7594819665,
-0.7260517478,
0.7152620554,
0.474365741,
0.2585369945,
0.1189060584,
-0.6611523628,
-0.2783431411,
-0.1768191755,
-0.3555365801,
-0.395978719,
-0.2319542617,
-0.1173384711,
0.240929395,
0.1650131345,
-0.4306111932,
0.3404512405,
-0.3708096445,
-0.3694293797,
0.7775040865,
0.3821697831,
0.3870351017,
0.3957955241,
-0.2163307965,
0.2372807115,
-0.9756681323,
0.1375056356,
0.0884490386,
0.6051411629,
-0.1295572668,
0.4165964723,
-0.3185805678,
0.5607147217,
-0.1294436455,
-0.1250776798,
0.1848918796,
-0.6844270229,
-0.3731606603,
-0.2248734832,
0.6736006737,
0.0652023852,
-0.1201225445,
-0.6176015139,
-0.1657470465,
-0.2572149038,
0.0338570513,
-0.7387260199,
0.0814896598,
-0.3267127872,
-0.4345916808,
-0.0490724668,
-0.1239612252,
-0.6331574917,
-0.3652513027,
-0.3842004538,
0.5032423735,
-0.0707133263,
-0.211130783,
0.0971305817,
0.1637150496,
-0.2420930713,
0.3540065289,
-1.0131772757,
0.775144875,
0.8911006451,
0.8249922991,
-0.3145215809,
-0.4056988657,
-0.6259506941,
0.7448284626,
-0.1127630174,
0.287983954,
-0.6371901035,
-0.2218288481,
0.0193647929,
0.2569763362,
0.0125174485,
-0.4363168478,
0.0299234111,
-0.4843357205,
0.1245754957,
-0.3569194376,
-0.4166419506,
0.0832578987,
-0.0568747893,
-0.5167059898,
0.8860285878,
0.2140542716,
-0.7150149345,
0.2735546231,
-0.7716411948,
-0.4852401614,
0.2157863081,
-0.3568163812,
-0.3871083856,
0.0187101997,
0.399104774,
0.492552191,
-0.4799782634,
0.0863862187,
-0.5782231688,
-0.2238755524,
0.1382650137,
0.0420906991,
0.4814568758,
-0.0081227077,
-0.3817414641,
0.0423341431,
-0.5411185026,
0.0689637065,
-0.0847486258,
-0.1891658902,
-0.7202487588,
-0.4610466361,
-0.2295982391,
0.0828934535,
0.6610501409,
-0.5638595819,
0.075833641,
-0.3454809785,
0.2913721204,
0.6104695797,
-0.2042677402,
0.7829592824,
-0.5669727325,
0.5543396473,
-0.11486803,
0.3041314483,
0.437631309,
-0.3660725057,
-0.6404928565,
-0.4122881591,
0.3369878829,
0.295763135,
-0.6883866191,
0.3163462579,
-0.6622512341,
-0.6059673429,
-0.9397341013,
0.6569903493,
0.4695033729,
0.3318992853,
0.3473539054,
-0.3590838909,
-0.4360466003,
-0.980312407,
-0.4217208922,
0.240752697,
-0.0859620199,
0.7997286916,
0.0308843292,
-0.3352352977,
0.835953176,
-0.1997915059,
-0.4830687046,
-0.2444806844,
-0.0652688965,
-0.0184186827,
0.5631899834,
0.5412019491,
-0.5743886232,
-0.8256816268,
0.2439636588,
-0.4870075881,
-0.3026717901,
0.1498497576,
-0.3205855489,
0.1893575788,
0.3204034567,
-0.1467635185,
0.3755222261,
0.9661702514,
-0.3359037042,
0.3127497435,
-0.4421490729,
0.0373149738,
-0.8054466844,
-0.0134225478,
-0.2835409343,
-0.759316802,
-0.6823558807,
-0.0193479452,
-0.0047311741,
-0.2701341808,
-0.5117630959,
0.7054944634,
-0.7211344242,
-0.6600404978,
-0.4182774723,
0.1475823671,
0.0428056717,
0.3145336211,
0.1165888906,
0.7506369948,
1.0229020119,
-0.5529124737,
0.1030645296,
0.0938867331,
-0.2230081856,
0.3271836042,
-0.5028560162,
0.3441037238,
0.168167457,
-0.0217481758,
-0.3201186359,
0.1629527509,
0.1347634345,
-0.045091521,
0.015623739,
-0.2009441853,
-0.4595346749,
-0.0109757381,
-0.0540712886,
0.3393974304,
0.6545774937,
-0.5181831717,
0.5188863277,
0.5423966646,
-0.3325408995,
-0.4297276735,
-0.9684625268,
0.1017902568,
-0.113091059,
-0.7395305634,
0.3879935741,
-0.0674786493,
-0.1264668852,
0.3238348961,
0.0600856878,
-0.1341010332,
-0.1244734973,
0.6587659717,
0.2129680961,
-0.3083454967,
0.1303475201,
0.2412854731,
0.2310631126,
-0.1626906991,
-0.4643309116,
0.4972081482,
-0.2458402067,
-0.4898412824,
-0.3464469314,
0.2873434126,
0.3835013509,
-0.2434767932,
1.0129013062,
0.7545176148,
-0.3423363864,
-0.4459119439,
-0.6005077362,
-0.2107349187,
-0.5202600956,
0.2092390209,
-0.6316590905,
-1.4644328356,
0.3944298625,
-0.1010122225,
-0.082767047,
0.1273993701,
0.612131834,
0.2511257827,
0.9194740057,
1.0940014124,
-0.425794065,
0.5905188322,
-0.0174932927,
0.0398723148,
-0.8706496358,
-0.1887640804,
-0.59734267,
-0.1884453148,
-0.306350559,
-0.7381480336,
0.095136188,
0.1609689444,
-0.1061733961,
0.4923435748,
-0.3012640178,
0.4995456636,
0.4371662736,
0.4210576713,
0.5408329368,
0.1983202249,
-0.1420629472,
-0.2373979092,
-0.8226861954,
-0.3775120378,
1.0242017508,
0.4858301878,
0.8862763047,
0.1834331751,
0.7983557582,
0.482393235,
0.3242671192,
-0.1330385506,
0.6363518238,
-0.3788224757,
-0.4068771601,
-0.6448646188,
-0.6893681884,
-0.8469123244,
0.2574868202,
-0.2449129671,
-1.0299239159,
0.3308679163,
-0.1236614808,
-0.1067870706,
0.331861943,
-0.4578168094,
0.6593857408,
-0.3725113869,
-0.6862740517,
-0.4799537957,
-0.3519132733,
0.3148225546,
-0.2922776937,
0.4257515371,
-0.2512940466,
-0.3783295453,
0.6754618287,
-0.4918351769,
0.9105907083,
-0.2645703852,
-0.1938004792,
-0.0570264533,
0.2733897269,
0.7754320502,
0.1800453663,
-0.1495939493,
0.305547148,
-0.1940164864,
-0.5142403245,
-0.8469460011,
1.016671896,
-0.8851928711,
-0.7199409604,
0.2441245615,
-0.9461379051,
-0.4910912216,
0.3181746006,
-0.2919250429,
0.1158154607,
0.074070476,
0.2590189576,
0.2435671836,
-0.1318103224,
0.2017126232,
0.9930087328,
-0.3209252357,
-0.2689985633,
0.9548903704,
0.0094753448,
0.6946418881,
0.3400335908,
0.1801590174,
-0.4325560927,
-0.5945276618,
-0.1289063543,
0.3909596801,
-0.6046094894,
-0.0033187242,
-0.7428359985,
-0.2865974307,
-0.784368813,
-0.1611267477,
-0.3279970884,
-0.4213583767,
-0.1624484807,
0.0778016299,
0.3453834653,
0.6848167181,
-0.3336650431,
0.2195580304,
-1.1401133537,
0.2322091758,
0.3491906226,
0.4403616786,
0.0048261438,
-0.5611439943,
-0.4982971847,
0.2342261523,
0.380834341,
-0.4319426715,
0.4810595214,
0.1816996038,
0.690325439,
0.1295471787,
0.0868715942,
0.8679006696,
-0.2954698801,
0.6424438357,
0.1992897987,
-1.2690768242,
0.4277350307,
-0.1252043247,
0.1491247565,
0.5882444382,
0.4523898959,
-0.4032969177,
-0.7451713085,
-0.6462846398,
-0.4722167253,
0.789737761,
0.175651297,
0.0072530531,
0.772194922,
0.0760488212,
0.3739863038,
0.3229722381,
-0.8355038762,
0.091209501,
0.1450701803,
0.0284307897,
-0.0831683055,
0.1378197372,
-0.2733611166,
-0.2891996503,
0.6459434628,
-0.1496249735,
0.0365853496,
0.0770828277,
-0.2781300247,
-0.2355388403,
0.2673103213,
0.316934973,
0.8551849127,
0.1123097837,
0.2592119575,
0.5106999278,
-0.1114738658,
-0.0490395986,
-0.0016444655,
-0.3049275577,
-0.0307719987,
0.1319510192,
0.9917997718,
0.2085128129,
-0.4986832738,
0.3902828395,
-0.1508232057,
-0.0481269099,
0.3372468352,
0.2805104554,
0.2555497587,
0.7370964289,
0.0454960838,
-0.0807245895,
-0.1038051248,
-0.496486485,
0.237809822,
0.5745481253,
-0.2485556901,
-0.3088472188,
0.6188642383,
0.1138699576,
-0.3850593865,
-0.0390873961,
0.0320887007,
-0.4680118263,
0.2678488493,
0.8046513796,
0.6026446819,
0.0467491373,
0.1587488055,
-0.0791922957,
0.2796093225,
0.0987343043,
0.2258096039,
-0.344927609,
-0.5917656422,
-0.348834306,
-0.5366415381,
-0.4445495009,
0.1866528392,
-0.6335167289,
0.1519315988,
-0.454683274,
-0.075654231,
-0.2047069073,
0.1100666374,
-0.983981967,
-0.0016767365,
0.1738447249,
0.6447541714,
-0.7708925009,
1.4674117565,
0.4458560646,
-0.3148407042,
-0.7617413402,
-0.176872164,
-0.4619395435,
-1.0181233883,
0.8335661888,
-0.4086202085,
-0.0920760557,
-0.1165191755,
-0.2678306699,
-0.9598277211,
1.240146637,
0.5467402935,
-1.1910159588,
-0.0884829909,
0.9072317481,
0.7836277485,
-0.6734201908,
-0.1055321842,
0.2947765589,
0.3709974289,
-0.3034778833,
-1.2371596098,
0.5175216794,
0.2094534039,
0.2042018026,
0.0408257432,
-0.7016454935,
0.5241783261,
-0.1128019392,
-0.1512855887,
-0.1372999102,
0.7243725657,
0.1700708717,
0.4048433602,
0.6915978789,
0.3064112961,
0.9144727588,
0.419275403,
0.7459368706,
-0.5613192916,
0.3296571672,
1.4487302303,
-0.5790425539,
0.8129487634,
0.4330673218,
-0.1559778601,
0.2815398574,
-0.0150475921,
-0.0149769988,
0.5996512771,
0.1818138361,
-0.3376752138,
-0.2698138356,
-0.5010325909,
-0.5349196196,
0.0912400633,
0.2971681058,
-0.5122539997,
-0.164065823,
0.289390862,
-0.1451437324,
0.1743541956,
-0.4498480558,
0.7776833773,
0.1893804222,
-0.3257553875,
0.4589524865,
0.0853617862,
0.7357432246,
-0.5380776525,
0.2637088299,
-0.2450376898,
0.1102936789,
-0.3399874866,
-0.5257065296,
0.4938573837,
0.0688714832,
-0.1553099155,
-0.3784098923,
1.3149579763,
-0.8552886844,
-0.391902715,
0.7148215175,
0.7417506576,
0.1853134483,
0.0028089467,
-0.7100840211,
0.1443656981,
-0.1140476316,
0.265670836,
0.8211221099,
0.4141718149,
-0.0640476197,
0.7377899885,
0.8671552539,
0.7582271099,
0.4233702123,
0.3472504616,
1.0342404842,
-0.3527247012,
-0.5747361779,
-0.7237189412,
0.0652312264,
-0.196937561,
0.233217299,
0.9169430733,
0.5604872108,
0.9400715232,
-0.0766233504,
0.9810183644,
0.068125993,
0.6998416185,
-0.3553082347,
0.9235126972,
-0.5343844891,
0.3396101594,
-0.1651273519,
-0.7541435361,
-0.0555855483,
0.0581946149,
-0.5579942465,
-0.3955254257,
0.375896275,
1.1480813026,
-0.2155990899,
-0.1097628847,
0.7047418952,
0.0291960221,
0.2630028725,
0.7985402346,
0.7644393444,
-0.2377140969,
0.6757062078,
-0.5012565851,
0.0016330299,
-0.008181504,
-0.6384570599,
-1.1097717285,
-0.4567127526,
-0.3373724818,
-0.2212606221,
0.4725497961,
0.6162760258,
1.0401166677,
-0.6835281253,
-0.3018448949,
-0.0483268276,
0.1241729483,
-0.1186511517,
-0.2161012739,
0.2452720255,
-0.1686941832,
-0.6899895072,
0.5350942016,
0.2002476305,
0.0221387781,
-0.5384626389,
-0.4839058518,
0.1236717254,
-0.1472295076,
0.2884170115,
0.2072988302,
-0.5123288631,
-0.2712900043,
-0.2027942538,
-0.3482690752,
-0.2068476677,
1.0483058691,
-0.6357656121,
0.0343877673,
0.6226508617,
1.0686212778,
0.7107898593,
0.0372128338,
0.6277452111,
-0.9230415225,
0.2212094665,
0.2186513394,
0.3229010403,
0.2285231799,
-0.5741971731,
0.371453166,
0.2072773278,
-0.679805994,
-0.9034782052,
0.0611696877,
-0.6816587448,
-0.2709666789,
1.1022410393,
-0.4974297583,
-0.3187921047,
-0.0858814716,
0.0366278477,
0.1798526198,
-0.4427900016,
0.5797829628,
0.3244684935,
-0.0096084345,
-0.2671374083,
-0.2843795717,
0.6036564708,
0.6193192005,
-1.2120876312,
0.2039378881,
0.1973152906,
0.4402325451,
-0.1039351597,
0.6993133426,
-0.0681537539,
0.0196526069,
-0.1656600982,
-0.1470803767,
-0.3873928189,
-0.4348168075,
-0.2310517281,
0.1894235909,
0.1309458911,
-0.2028493583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05834v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05834v1
|
Evidence-based Interpretable Open-domain Fact-checking with Large Language Models
| 2023-12-10T09:27:50 | 2023-12-10T09:27:50 |
Xin Tan, Bowei Zou, Ai Ti Aw
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Universal fact-checking systems for real-world claims face significant
challenges in gathering valid and sufficient real-time evidence and making
reasoned decisions. In this work, we introduce the Open-domain Explainable
Fact-checking (OE-Fact) system for claim-checking in real-world scenarios. The
OE-Fact system can leverage the powerful understanding and reasoning
capabilities of large language models (LLMs) to validate claims and generate
causal explanations for fact-checking decisions. To adapt the traditional
three-module fact-checking framework to the open domain setting, we first
retrieve claim-related information as relevant evidence from open websites.
After that, we retain the evidence relevant to the claim through LLM and
similarity calculation for subsequent verification. We evaluate the performance
of our adapted three-module OE-Fact system on the Fact Extraction and
Verification (FEVER) dataset. Experimental results show that our OE-Fact system
outperforms general fact-checking baseline systems in both closed- and
open-domain scenarios, ensuring stable and accurate verdicts while providing
concise and convincing real-time explanations for fact-checking decisions.
|
[
-0.1530395448,
-0.8269565701,
0.8985064626,
0.0281604361,
-0.1867099702,
-0.363523066,
-0.3405357897,
-0.8251531124,
-0.0697618201,
0.4915538728,
-0.1753206104,
-0.3955186307,
-0.3256556392,
0.2506470978,
-0.0964795202,
0.9248105884,
-0.3457213938,
-0.0167146306,
-0.2809516191,
-0.2915976644,
-0.1917179227,
-0.5011952519,
-0.3771384358,
-0.4760750532,
0.3479444087,
0.5985459089,
0.665305078,
0.4673992097,
0.4271262288,
0.117248483,
0.2535854578,
0.4586483538,
-0.3959777355,
-0.0310898162,
-0.5832826495,
-0.4754492939,
-0.716766119,
-0.1169717088,
0.1995385736,
0.2993603945,
-0.2061136216,
0.3175736964,
-0.2702476978,
0.194874987,
-0.9075974226,
0.3456962407,
-0.5110527873,
-0.0327955782,
-0.0980007201,
-0.0860467106,
-0.6600660086,
-0.6363372207,
0.1797396541,
-0.5483506918,
0.2245844156,
0.2658680975,
1.0147601366,
-0.3360797167,
-0.4473031759,
-0.3362618983,
-0.7666262388,
0.4228032827,
-0.7124928832,
0.4253341556,
0.1266190112,
0.3585337698,
-0.1220101416,
-0.4777920246,
-0.9004318118,
-0.0526853241,
-0.1778414696,
0.108625263,
-0.1613902897,
-0.2196545452,
0.3263254166,
0.1865665466,
-0.7932732701,
0.0928691328,
-0.0528485402,
-0.4149703681,
0.3679889441,
-0.2434422672,
0.3866133094,
0.1157306284,
-0.4518017173,
0.2106613517,
-1.2740101814,
-0.189590171,
-0.0088919653,
0.3473041654,
-0.1125894338,
0.6333861947,
-0.4506335855,
0.6649816036,
-0.3027459979,
-0.3276803493,
-0.1610966772,
-0.0165525619,
-0.4676044583,
0.3616945446,
0.4172338247,
0.3553629518,
0.1505577266,
-0.2950016558,
-0.0686559528,
-0.0825065374,
-0.0836862028,
-1.0949113369,
0.1911578625,
0.2700556517,
-0.5101571083,
-0.1680639833,
0.4582388103,
-0.9060415626,
-0.5266063809,
-0.1133601218,
0.8305162787,
-0.3149065673,
-0.5019343495,
0.6621562243,
-0.0901080966,
0.1038221419,
0.5096343756,
-0.2926031649,
0.2394430488,
0.6424998045,
0.849887073,
-0.081627816,
-0.033053793,
-0.7573041916,
0.1553040445,
-0.2277674079,
0.866499722,
-0.254496187,
0.2798161209,
0.3875041008,
0.0063888496,
-0.0218046047,
-0.6275286674,
0.8478665352,
-0.9925941229,
0.2338484973,
-0.1753461808,
-0.4245746732,
-0.2575166523,
0.3444593251,
-0.5495791435,
0.4713443816,
-0.3309824765,
-0.6984347105,
0.5880041718,
-0.9841825366,
-0.4158476293,
-0.0128375916,
0.1100792885,
-0.4143070877,
-0.0286442544,
0.1847600639,
0.4092469215,
-0.4687073529,
0.3011780679,
-0.5097306371,
0.0069640009,
0.4233387411,
-0.3006840944,
0.8948238492,
0.472720623,
-0.4847664237,
-0.1343472749,
-0.9624057412,
-0.259190619,
0.4326023161,
-0.4217923582,
-0.3854573369,
0.2077895999,
-0.4152391255,
-0.0689133033,
0.1176615581,
-1.217966795,
0.3297034502,
-0.1515287608,
0.2562548816,
0.202871576,
0.1209781542,
-0.0100168884,
-0.2983075082,
0.201265499,
0.2519050837,
0.2133266181,
-0.229214713,
-0.4627988636,
-0.5683911443,
-0.419721067,
0.4672405124,
0.6354370117,
-0.9207788706,
0.3276384175,
-0.4244204462,
-0.0675553828,
-0.0406917669,
-0.5830767751,
0.0819609836,
0.7061287165,
0.4646563828,
0.0069110189,
-0.4186820686,
-0.5430647135,
-0.5173225999,
-0.4691980183,
-0.1516012549,
0.0085389819,
0.7259886265,
0.0990172774,
1.123988986,
-0.9162626266,
-0.0977783203,
0.0635792241,
0.0513137616,
0.3624460399,
0.1092140973,
0.4691466093,
-0.6475311518,
-0.1401938945,
0.2279777527,
-1.0050276518,
-0.331099391,
-0.0379423611,
0.0730077252,
0.2871974111,
0.3536303341,
-0.7443464994,
0.5266329646,
0.2418049574,
-0.7177473307,
0.8254421353,
-0.222736761,
0.4005025029,
-0.3616191149,
0.1016009748,
-0.1380476803,
-0.5214922428,
-0.4993454814,
0.3587402701,
0.366956234,
0.0067424239,
-0.5012856722,
0.5434187055,
-0.2617927194,
0.1755405962,
-0.1799325943,
0.2025928199,
0.229733482,
0.2277870625,
0.0373973623,
0.4534480572,
0.5405935049,
-0.6974222064,
0.2676755786,
0.0634686872,
-0.7332594991,
0.7961505651,
-0.309060365,
-0.2591638565,
-0.0295809899,
0.4005839527,
-0.5292132497,
-0.499632746,
0.3465931714,
-0.2609670758,
0.0083243903,
-0.2020994276,
-0.4721804261,
-0.3015144765,
0.0060866615,
0.332336992,
0.4185476601,
-1.2017556429,
0.6370405555,
0.1492385864,
-0.2338710576,
-0.5188634992,
-0.1364461631,
0.2430250049,
-0.2685538828,
-0.5569556952,
0.3041673899,
0.2438324839,
-0.7261577249,
0.2849047482,
-0.3430641592,
-0.2364002764,
0.0675976574,
0.0469309278,
0.2623473406,
-0.5873368979,
0.128371805,
-0.1363967806,
0.2620047033,
0.201480791,
-0.6035493016,
0.1286258847,
-0.0800001249,
-0.6440112591,
-0.2169244438,
0.2929172814,
0.677415669,
-0.1416817605,
0.8675604463,
0.1873450279,
-0.7141391039,
-0.2390079945,
-0.6371182203,
-0.0836646929,
-0.324857533,
0.0773544386,
-0.4052940905,
-0.8890194893,
0.4515257478,
-0.3272370994,
0.3011778891,
0.753700316,
0.4120664895,
0.1684359163,
0.7009624243,
0.2987199426,
0.3831297457,
0.0091599692,
0.2121403813,
0.4311137795,
-0.1971636266,
-0.2842633426,
-0.7328006625,
0.3407095373,
0.0503952578,
-0.397136718,
0.5246455669,
0.1565394402,
-0.416864723,
0.0918497443,
0.1699802876,
0.6623734832,
0.1713899523,
0.3987380564,
0.6802375913,
0.0807591006,
-0.1593649089,
0.478254348,
-0.57124722,
-0.5261175036,
0.8879699111,
0.3890680373,
0.6665844917,
0.6259057522,
0.3850255311,
0.5784001946,
0.6351541877,
-0.6213217378,
0.3725721538,
0.0664397404,
-0.8467071652,
-0.2149641663,
-0.4722054601,
-0.7798383236,
0.5351984501,
-0.4663576186,
-0.6971226931,
0.2078447938,
0.1229418367,
-0.4911261499,
0.5876694322,
-0.5703288317,
0.4757506251,
-0.255823791,
-0.3726029694,
-0.4568553269,
-0.1625728309,
0.6717408895,
-0.0993690044,
0.6166502237,
-0.058516521,
0.1938307583,
0.4984528124,
-0.7329341769,
0.8425683379,
-0.4072594941,
-0.5212857127,
0.448420465,
0.209283933,
0.3631594181,
0.3104309142,
-0.3424249589,
0.3132937849,
0.0068643223,
-0.2609834075,
-0.5357524157,
0.5987893939,
-0.6091279984,
-0.6407806873,
-0.5854798555,
-0.1734109819,
-0.2090165615,
0.3899502754,
-0.0115263062,
0.8260404468,
-0.5719245076,
0.04710811,
0.8220920563,
-0.3825407922,
0.1527873725,
1.1215858459,
-0.4963156581,
-0.208567515,
0.9673225284,
-0.0517999083,
0.2253678888,
0.5059158206,
0.4057002962,
-0.2897722423,
-0.4988213181,
-0.6964967847,
0.2026706338,
-0.6431058049,
-0.4134421647,
-0.6166654229,
0.1261716038,
-0.3249836564,
0.2785016894,
-0.0414356254,
-0.5374934673,
0.2640279233,
0.040079318,
0.328253597,
0.9161695838,
-0.300473094,
0.0823430419,
-0.7407379746,
0.7987264991,
0.3834587634,
0.856620729,
-0.2165923864,
-0.5081288218,
-0.4619121253,
0.0611211918,
-0.1614281237,
-0.9183334708,
-0.1284287721,
0.2109520435,
0.4206793606,
0.5310809612,
0.3188806772,
0.3187600672,
-0.4753110707,
0.7920640111,
0.0796631724,
-0.7778551579,
0.3080866039,
-0.1906019896,
-0.0764459148,
0.1109087244,
0.3680433333,
-0.2005259246,
-0.0050676879,
-0.4635873735,
-0.402148962,
0.8785889745,
0.0731621906,
-0.5432000756,
0.0802084804,
0.5855312347,
0.5256793499,
-0.1535173953,
-0.5794557929,
-0.0648000091,
-0.1882910728,
-0.0664960369,
0.1896959543,
-0.1479839385,
-0.3558410406,
0.2110130191,
1.048397541,
-0.3205388188,
0.2418994457,
0.5454387665,
-0.3375887275,
-0.307302773,
0.6267750263,
0.7510054708,
0.7167643309,
-0.4310875237,
0.4670350552,
0.0940498114,
-0.4888082147,
0.2320439219,
0.0533629619,
-0.2318321466,
-0.0081211869,
0.3242657185,
0.6638620496,
-0.1253848076,
-0.8369794488,
0.6895163059,
-0.2615737915,
-0.229447335,
0.0005161855,
0.0634384528,
-0.1273003519,
0.0871950611,
0.2669638097,
0.1878377646,
0.0331686474,
-0.7090362906,
-0.0052392846,
0.2539303303,
-0.0816191807,
-0.4267374873,
0.4138174951,
0.1423679441,
0.0398878902,
0.1708880067,
-0.0310793538,
-0.4605033398,
0.6545322537,
0.7281249762,
0.7162944078,
-0.0980344117,
0.2871892452,
0.3593656421,
0.2863642871,
-0.3510789573,
0.403593868,
0.2468879223,
-0.8384501338,
-0.6039184928,
-0.5386697054,
-0.7151936293,
0.4785553217,
-0.730174005,
0.1420666426,
-0.2493168414,
0.1183395162,
0.0936758071,
-0.5134986639,
-0.6663678288,
0.3180966973,
0.0689037964,
1.1982793808,
-0.9013937116,
0.5834263563,
0.6883853674,
-0.2014072388,
-0.3162146807,
0.3214082122,
0.2182748467,
-0.92709589,
0.5676506758,
0.0820576996,
-0.468177557,
-0.3524178565,
-0.6942985654,
-0.6461729407,
0.7630916834,
0.5234252214,
-0.3437195718,
0.3789820969,
-0.0134553825,
0.4000529349,
-0.5282665491,
0.1599942595,
0.4816598594,
0.4720338881,
-0.0384435989,
-0.8556289077,
0.2774744332,
0.1929704696,
-0.781860888,
0.1754364222,
-0.4104563296,
0.4614568353,
-0.5384883285,
-0.3067741096,
-0.1205359548,
0.8220524192,
0.0866399035,
0.4767997563,
0.8548680544,
0.5011299849,
0.7167615294,
-0.033453133,
0.9778875113,
-0.1798376143,
0.3621425629,
1.0136785507,
-0.6991781592,
0.9990003109,
0.1421125531,
-0.1182074994,
0.8913777471,
0.2035081983,
0.2930966318,
0.1527009308,
0.0784779862,
-0.4936981201,
-0.4830604494,
-0.3220235705,
-0.2098584026,
0.3689086735,
0.5550224185,
0.0420011543,
-0.4614438117,
-0.0240782797,
0.2404462546,
-0.1232521385,
-0.2971146107,
0.7299768925,
-0.1793232858,
-1.0843034983,
0.6223765612,
0.1219980195,
0.2144216299,
-0.5852659941,
-0.2024393529,
0.181658566,
0.339645952,
-0.4162456095,
-0.9318273664,
0.1284496188,
0.4350633025,
-0.2573238611,
-0.1080771834,
0.9303282499,
-0.3457692564,
0.0839837939,
0.0423884764,
0.5491434336,
0.0721937567,
-0.3010568619,
-0.126894787,
0.0216972008,
-0.2108461708,
-0.2262701988,
0.3617736399,
0.5504984856,
-0.2573031485,
0.4215124249,
0.5261232257,
0.2449709773,
-0.4340939224,
0.1078734994,
0.6585467458,
-0.3480746746,
-0.4072605968,
-0.9117028713,
0.166804105,
-0.1373989284,
0.267791003,
0.4777753949,
0.6228799224,
0.4595484138,
-0.2508438826,
1.1341776848,
-0.4126107693,
0.6387677789,
-0.7608837485,
0.6799881458,
-0.4108124971,
0.0233402252,
0.1859355718,
-0.5788843036,
-0.5880964994,
0.3392446339,
-0.1529906094,
-0.4699401259,
0.8895804882,
0.6299353838,
-0.2898410857,
0.4944957793,
0.189534381,
0.6744599342,
0.5366246104,
0.2578029037,
0.7691895366,
-0.1914922744,
0.509016037,
0.200679943,
-0.6867462397,
-0.4521137476,
-1.3932703733,
-0.7090108991,
-0.1124418825,
-0.5726361275,
-0.7209127545,
-0.0343227647,
0.9224581718,
0.4894459844,
-1.0994981527,
0.0617732108,
0.3443467915,
0.2793004513,
-0.4195183814,
-0.2239406854,
0.571372509,
-0.0953223035,
-0.128470093,
0.5111430883,
0.4436245561,
-0.2564243376,
0.0483152829,
0.0175344441,
-0.1404927969,
0.3830215335,
0.9072055817,
0.6676508188,
-0.813593626,
-0.7381266356,
-0.1964181364,
0.0977133885,
-0.040221937,
1.1862729788,
-0.6857030392,
0.4450517297,
0.5393145084,
0.5159339905,
0.0990998074,
-0.1029427052,
0.4917031825,
-0.3280952275,
-0.2877698243,
-0.2858829498,
0.8163900375,
0.0589082018,
-0.1824129224,
0.5041189194,
0.4079272747,
-0.4941222668,
-0.8073858619,
0.4603563249,
-0.8602330089,
-0.3701895177,
0.9871066809,
-0.5759109259,
-0.0925280899,
-0.5402108431,
-0.0998968482,
0.2325705737,
-0.271176815,
0.858007431,
0.6959994435,
-0.1814837307,
0.3459727466,
-0.4255584478,
0.296894908,
0.0060861059,
-1.1033204794,
0.4601164758,
0.6622284651,
0.4784428477,
0.2674077153,
0.3257682621,
-0.2815547884,
0.2845746577,
-0.17390728,
0.1509898752,
-0.1033808291,
-0.4239480197,
-0.2230774611,
0.5926929712,
0.0202460717,
0.0131113362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05821v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05821v2
|
ASVD: Activation-aware Singular Value Decomposition for Compressing Large Language Models
| 2023-12-10T08:41:24 | 2024-05-24T06:28:15 |
Zhihang Yuan, Yuzhang Shang, Yue Song, Qiang Wu, Yan Yan, Guangyu Sun
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we introduce a new post-training compression paradigm for
Large Language Models (LLMs) to facilitate their wider adoption. We delve into
LLM weight low-rank factorization, and find that the challenges of this task
stem from the outlier phenomenon in the LLM activations and the sensitivity
difference among various kinds of layers. To address these issues, we propose a
training-free approach called Activation-aware Singular Value Decomposition
(ASVD). Specifically, ASVD manages activation outliers by scaling the weight
matrix based on the activation distribution, thereby enhancing decomposition
accuracy. Additionally, we propose an efficient iterative calibration process
to optimize layer-specific decomposition by addressing the varying sensitivity
of different LLM layers. ASVD can compress a network by 10-20%, without
compromising the performance of LLMs. Based on the success of the low-rank
decomposition of projection matrices in the self-attention module, we further
introduce ASVD to compress the KV cache. By reducing the channel dimension of
KV activations, memory requirements for KV cache can be largely reduced. Thanks
to the 50-75% reduction in the rank of the KV projection matrices, ASVD can
further achieve 50% KV cache reductions without performance drop in a
training-free manner.
|
[
-0.2547145486,
-0.4802540243,
0.2612687349,
0.2860533595,
-0.293705225,
0.0377987362,
-0.3709407151,
0.0108912392,
0.2762026787,
0.6013367176,
-0.5090653896,
-0.4759183526,
-0.5453038812,
-0.2610837817,
-0.2981701791,
0.4032192528,
0.0811559781,
0.0082547963,
-0.5020140409,
-0.1139707193,
-0.2295063734,
-0.7305048704,
-0.7320156693,
-0.3310796618,
0.1487349421,
0.3840121627,
0.2089718729,
0.5553826094,
0.3850621581,
0.3452979326,
-0.2839990854,
0.0892008692,
-0.6599227786,
0.2192396969,
0.2398116142,
-0.32094118,
-0.6834948659,
-0.07139422,
0.9739388824,
0.782669425,
-0.0712441429,
0.2913950384,
-0.0350631177,
0.9419220686,
-0.7680607438,
0.3103320599,
-0.5731623173,
-0.0529162772,
0.1667940915,
-0.4259426892,
-0.6506109238,
-0.2485923916,
-0.3422375321,
-0.4063178301,
0.2982513607,
-0.0851778537,
0.540164113,
0.7776253223,
-0.479057163,
0.3275749683,
-0.7418428659,
0.8191241026,
-0.4252381027,
0.4212528765,
0.1623280942,
0.1622565687,
-0.0935283378,
-0.3295438588,
-0.4836374223,
0.0526506938,
0.4103433788,
0.0027988025,
-0.1857886612,
0.3263073862,
0.2933410406,
0.6991035938,
-0.3927639127,
0.3995714188,
-0.4072277844,
-0.1653900146,
0.6261376739,
-0.0863243863,
0.0573608428,
-0.2001107931,
-0.3809557259,
-0.077921249,
-1.2236886024,
0.2302059084,
0.6208196282,
0.376306355,
0.2163486183,
0.5523556471,
-0.2266702503,
0.4751121998,
0.0841908455,
0.0137551399,
0.4356188476,
-0.2657998204,
-0.6462144852,
0.3204340935,
0.6148940921,
0.2710680366,
0.0019023465,
0.081745021,
-0.3160860538,
0.1576436609,
0.3494270444,
-0.9636743665,
-0.3695105612,
0.2978140712,
-0.6648789644,
-0.5179817677,
-0.3398658335,
-0.2962064147,
-0.2703991234,
-0.3100868762,
0.5504124165,
-0.0883330628,
-0.3981277645,
0.3433615267,
0.1077994555,
0.104161635,
0.6084077358,
-0.9142590165,
0.4094507992,
0.4390804172,
0.4082348049,
-0.2005459219,
0.1648339778,
-0.9876791835,
0.0462369137,
-0.223493591,
0.7253724337,
-0.3030654788,
-0.3258966208,
0.0844901875,
-0.216660127,
0.0983775258,
-0.6808708906,
0.364628613,
-0.6674021482,
-0.1712300181,
-0.2315969765,
-0.3971450329,
-0.2830686867,
0.3031928539,
-0.6400572062,
1.2813825607,
0.0829669833,
-0.3607008755,
0.2033605576,
-0.4881270826,
-0.2866957188,
0.0946120098,
-0.0775210857,
-0.5046159029,
0.3854718506,
0.2409803122,
0.6504625082,
-0.6430516243,
0.1023982316,
-0.0549692661,
-0.3281177282,
-0.1255189925,
-0.3084851205,
0.8750852942,
-0.0983899683,
-0.2226076275,
0.3835267723,
-1.0058562756,
0.2008542269,
-0.0844770744,
-0.585632205,
-0.2215805948,
-0.0229276773,
-0.106598191,
0.3045521379,
0.1546616852,
-0.5494965315,
0.4761372209,
-0.549922049,
0.291000098,
0.8833797574,
0.0630268008,
0.6046551466,
0.1817626059,
0.5590468049,
0.1224777028,
0.214067027,
0.0620513372,
-0.1661652327,
-1.1245738268,
-0.3321799636,
0.2976436615,
0.280885756,
-1.0330839157,
0.6894483566,
-0.5965563059,
-0.354078263,
-0.6397943497,
0.2751479745,
0.4035507143,
0.3049832284,
0.56839329,
-0.4602856934,
-0.4057874978,
-0.9184951186,
0.1741062552,
-0.3128211498,
-0.0586910881,
0.2104192078,
0.2751579285,
-0.2155779153,
0.5711622834,
-0.490704596,
-0.5729080439,
-0.363900125,
0.2151136994,
-0.0070346678,
0.5389819741,
0.1046224013,
-0.5891076922,
-0.4188864529,
-0.2257733494,
-0.4515987337,
-0.1185184345,
0.1301190704,
0.4363978803,
0.2477022111,
0.9527229071,
-0.4267146289,
0.3057204485,
0.6661996245,
-0.0683627501,
0.4922646284,
-0.5167219639,
0.0070640859,
-0.8261057138,
0.0555109195,
-0.0481924899,
-0.3263385296,
-0.7514843941,
0.0066113644,
0.1578581929,
-0.0826107711,
-0.6611253619,
0.1659314036,
-0.6923035383,
-0.216831252,
-0.161385268,
-0.102526702,
-0.169281885,
0.6907663941,
-0.2217764258,
0.6312835217,
0.5768138766,
-0.5944265127,
0.3427245021,
0.1734059602,
-0.5015568137,
0.2638724744,
-0.5481895804,
0.0199707672,
-0.4804479778,
0.3093173802,
-0.9868043661,
0.219816789,
0.1248997003,
-0.2657880187,
0.469502002,
-0.4673431814,
-0.8193997145,
-0.0885000303,
-0.6223884821,
0.7053417563,
0.4749331474,
-0.5408865809,
0.6403220296,
0.5714114904,
0.0159061495,
-0.6585763097,
-0.4508406818,
-0.1036419645,
-0.1316600293,
-0.5699706674,
0.324901253,
-0.4456759691,
-0.0726492107,
-0.0574289002,
-0.1056949943,
0.1017713547,
0.1198465377,
0.4435064495,
0.0604563877,
-0.2712439597,
0.1383376569,
0.1224522367,
-0.3631616533,
-0.0037012883,
-0.2750287354,
0.6601070166,
0.0023208007,
-0.2663635314,
-0.2395693064,
0.4624855816,
0.6003475785,
-0.1843932271,
0.6702565551,
0.5680994987,
-0.2551282048,
-0.3406838477,
-0.6609626412,
0.0660066456,
-0.5286800861,
0.111868076,
-0.2307896167,
-1.0549182892,
0.4242326319,
-0.2650157511,
-0.1430979967,
0.5030331612,
0.7431074977,
0.2164607644,
1.0439052582,
0.9467397332,
-0.0668187812,
0.5128340721,
-0.5933099389,
0.3083488941,
-1.0613178015,
-0.1309044957,
-0.4184607565,
-0.2703256905,
-0.2627671063,
-0.8851976991,
0.4518789351,
-0.0773314759,
-0.1532026231,
0.0321700908,
-0.6041051745,
0.5138279796,
0.3549288809,
-0.1598688513,
0.261959821,
0.1355279088,
0.167579174,
0.0850543529,
-0.6705518961,
0.0654192418,
1.0170534849,
0.3647536039,
0.742822051,
0.1587780714,
0.5769833922,
0.2273498923,
0.2841491103,
-1.0844231844,
0.7466378212,
-0.2985377014,
-0.274035275,
-0.3746055663,
-0.5285225511,
-0.8663719296,
0.0906028971,
-0.1234818324,
-0.850210309,
0.3026722968,
0.1806489974,
-0.5166323185,
0.1205493659,
-0.6836973429,
0.6405156255,
0.2160413265,
-0.0434982628,
-0.3523845673,
-0.5439451933,
0.2467255145,
0.0669123232,
-0.0599502772,
-0.2324929237,
0.0031754025,
0.8702879548,
-0.5751203299,
0.7856120467,
-0.2776488364,
-0.1069205254,
0.1563126743,
-0.0258026719,
0.6329229474,
-0.0831048489,
-0.0733951032,
0.0291122831,
-0.4068084359,
-0.2712824047,
-0.688108027,
0.8983576298,
-0.9336593747,
-0.6092230678,
-0.1465952396,
-0.4854467213,
-0.1177463159,
0.1332533062,
0.2280748188,
0.79315418,
0.0924569145,
0.4464233816,
1.0092684031,
-0.1982415617,
0.4294765592,
0.4048009217,
0.0160633065,
-0.3623853922,
1.0790184736,
0.3470994532,
0.4164579511,
0.5926933885,
-0.143382445,
-0.2358846962,
-0.8748325109,
-0.1814108342,
0.2678485811,
-1.0689735413,
-0.4378131032,
-0.7276530266,
-0.4422259033,
-0.3669146597,
-0.3802654445,
-0.8266905546,
-0.4675568044,
-0.267205447,
-0.0807147548,
0.0956317335,
0.4956889153,
0.0172717925,
0.3710883856,
-0.460755378,
0.3134693503,
0.3696306348,
0.3755736947,
-0.0550614707,
-0.3964202106,
-0.3359721601,
-0.3564769626,
0.0100484481,
-0.3757017851,
0.6672350764,
0.2145242989,
0.4116373062,
0.3227029741,
0.1598675251,
0.614810884,
-0.4734196365,
0.9714697003,
0.379997611,
-0.9860576391,
0.2945900261,
-0.0855989084,
0.310465008,
0.6528092027,
0.1870441437,
-0.2701593637,
-0.2832029164,
-0.8274935484,
-1.2392481565,
0.6189588308,
0.0433883443,
0.0782687962,
0.3288032711,
0.2226021737,
-0.0513183698,
0.3831571043,
-0.7312515974,
-0.7382016182,
0.0231713653,
0.0264443122,
-0.4333409071,
-0.7512736917,
0.0121621825,
-0.484826684,
0.7529680133,
-0.26509431,
0.6298757195,
-0.0296494234,
-0.5254661441,
-0.36945346,
0.1094829217,
0.4737629294,
0.2625471056,
-0.3147573769,
0.4342525303,
0.0416344963,
-0.2876853943,
0.4175654054,
-0.0716451183,
-0.0645818785,
-0.1904693693,
-0.0948451906,
0.8531656861,
0.4327165484,
-0.4198080897,
0.8215832114,
-0.3299937248,
-0.2871554196,
-0.3825935125,
0.0132841179,
-0.1485233903,
0.1012067199,
0.376170069,
0.1677412689,
0.1251198947,
-0.3346607983,
-0.0587869734,
0.3961917162,
-0.5623398423,
-0.329115659,
0.6289705038,
0.2722051144,
-0.1594862789,
0.6513367891,
-0.329667151,
-0.579611063,
0.2720437646,
0.3786863387,
0.9463337064,
-0.3805924356,
0.1112214252,
0.2987498641,
0.3582122922,
-0.1091946363,
0.2666909695,
-0.2309107631,
-0.9706418514,
-0.8481787443,
-0.5840331316,
-0.1781810075,
0.4139152467,
-0.5709681511,
0.3820867538,
-0.6100921035,
0.2304889262,
-0.0339103565,
0.2113604248,
-0.6565459967,
0.239399299,
0.0882679299,
0.8010022044,
-0.9326440692,
1.0999457836,
0.4527665377,
-0.2001541555,
-0.8492143154,
-0.1667709947,
0.0145078646,
-0.7234185934,
0.8992987871,
0.2753197551,
-0.1265110373,
0.4928301275,
-0.3598925471,
-0.9577372074,
0.9971238971,
0.6626233459,
0.1154876798,
0.0837307498,
-0.0983018726,
0.41908741,
-0.3254199922,
0.0807015151,
0.4660257399,
0.3066282272,
0.263594538,
-0.7147722244,
0.1495816559,
-0.5945054889,
0.0750845745,
0.3004741073,
-0.5783190727,
0.8114127517,
0.1615181863,
-0.1360077411,
-0.3432925045,
0.6261276007,
-0.2092592269,
-0.2845848203,
0.6358438134,
0.4473297596,
0.5269049406,
0.1218948215,
0.9182139039,
-0.2575945258,
0.2906223834,
0.6593254209,
0.0479783081,
0.886441052,
0.5407564044,
0.1154353768,
0.3193370998,
0.383888334,
0.1909255981,
0.4853272736,
0.229271844,
-0.4397059083,
-0.529619813,
-0.2026311606,
-0.3070690334,
0.4325636923,
0.3860644698,
-0.2003270388,
-0.1621217132,
-0.1189503819,
-0.095131278,
-0.3655694127,
-0.7085923553,
0.6807190776,
-0.0076821558,
-0.5423121452,
0.9339575768,
0.0425518341,
0.5083019137,
-0.4539911449,
0.2616780102,
0.1088472009,
0.2251201123,
-0.2008606344,
-0.3804084957,
0.077733539,
-0.2952764034,
-0.4049327374,
-0.8756640553,
0.8730015755,
-0.5824407935,
-0.2814978659,
0.1867447793,
0.4058822989,
0.1150119603,
-0.377063036,
-0.3377589285,
0.4332190752,
0.0868178234,
-0.4041918814,
0.6127002239,
0.0880828127,
0.1056224257,
0.8109772205,
0.7856505513,
0.2984522879,
-0.0750712529,
0.1165186539,
1.2620838881,
-0.3890508115,
-0.5449315906,
-0.5215075612,
0.7638412118,
-0.149085477,
-0.0146337664,
0.66181916,
0.4844285846,
0.5461502075,
-0.039458409,
0.5739941597,
0.3587630689,
0.0902568996,
-0.5088509321,
0.6732997298,
-0.7339954972,
0.468650341,
-0.1680298895,
-0.858494997,
-0.6852185726,
0.4911910295,
-0.362161845,
-0.2921745777,
0.6374338865,
0.8504041433,
0.1740822941,
-0.5057375431,
0.5837082863,
0.2383078784,
0.553123951,
0.4017768204,
0.489163518,
-0.575682044,
0.6006696224,
-0.052453354,
-0.2195602208,
-0.606570363,
-0.9391807914,
-0.915436089,
-0.7760582566,
-0.5997769237,
-0.2873759866,
-0.3481939435,
1.1192920208,
0.635920167,
-0.6069831848,
-0.1048192382,
0.0376201831,
0.1687168479,
-0.2428146154,
-0.1442246735,
0.5522407293,
-0.2184526175,
-0.5768893957,
0.7269021273,
0.7539147139,
-0.1489508897,
-0.5507656336,
0.0126359826,
-0.0352327712,
0.0763332248,
0.9022084475,
0.215852797,
-0.33570382,
-0.4727692902,
-0.2832893729,
-0.0697594136,
0.3617784381,
0.967613101,
-0.9330527186,
0.681794107,
0.5334953666,
0.5156741142,
0.6646822095,
-0.1243748516,
0.6314082146,
-1.1878856421,
0.3801758587,
0.220431298,
0.3277727067,
0.4074572623,
-0.3783270717,
0.2400104105,
0.2794350684,
-0.5075559616,
-1.0770046711,
0.2077148855,
-1.2372642756,
0.0262366682,
1.5050839186,
0.0351243354,
-0.4177351892,
-0.2279602736,
-0.0252469387,
0.1748057902,
-0.4026747644,
0.7605831623,
0.3325304389,
0.1249423251,
-0.3575291932,
-0.3621612787,
0.8089686036,
0.2809190154,
-0.5843067169,
0.2216296792,
0.4004919529,
0.1188564077,
0.1150830165,
0.9036148787,
0.0113941971,
0.2183095217,
0.0076645329,
0.330278188,
-0.3419879377,
-0.3350773156,
-0.6611575484,
0.5133917928,
0.1781660467,
-0.0005337423
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.10078v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.10078v1
|
Early ChatGPT User Portrait through the Lens of Data
| 2023-12-10T07:08:51 | 2023-12-10T07:08:51 |
Yuyang Deng, Ni Zhao, Xin Huang
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Since its launch, ChatGPT has achieved remarkable success as a versatile
conversational AI platform, drawing millions of users worldwide and garnering
widespread recognition across academic, industrial, and general communities.
This paper aims to point a portrait of early GPT users and understand how they
evolved. Specific questions include their topics of interest and their
potential careers; and how this changes over time. We conduct a detailed
analysis of real-world ChatGPT datasets with multi-turn conversations between
users and ChatGPT. Through a multi-pronged approach, we quantify conversation
dynamics by examining the number of turns, then gauge sentiment to understand
user sentiment variations, and finally employ Latent Dirichlet Allocation (LDA)
to discern overarching topics within the conversation. By understanding shifts
in user demographics and interests, we aim to shed light on the changing nature
of human-AI interaction and anticipate future trends in user engagement with
language models.
|
[
-0.7040804029,
-0.8739132881,
0.4434882998,
-0.1482210606,
0.0194018092,
0.3995779157,
0.0252123252,
-0.3983719349,
0.0641110763,
0.1698158383,
-0.8353322148,
-0.1925936043,
-0.5632197261,
-0.4814149439,
-0.2765655518,
1.4632431269,
0.3736874461,
-0.2762996554,
0.0361523665,
-0.0632827953,
-0.5462422371,
-0.66820544,
-0.854547441,
-0.3211447001,
0.8689754009,
0.4417546988,
0.96925354,
0.1901515275,
0.3719533384,
0.1544633955,
-0.1427395642,
-0.1588325202,
-0.877992928,
0.1224360615,
0.2908800542,
-0.4194714725,
-0.2627269924,
0.3658545613,
0.3064306378,
0.6683499813,
-0.2236194909,
-0.0577976331,
0.1982061118,
0.4597045183,
-0.0194572899,
0.5071047544,
-0.5603479743,
0.0949376523,
-0.5129255056,
-0.0575433597,
-0.2890032232,
-0.1751352251,
0.4314318299,
-0.5707541704,
0.1942193508,
-0.1599864066,
0.6190977693,
-0.0147792585,
-0.5532289743,
-0.1096017063,
-0.9642872214,
0.5844754577,
-0.2402662635,
0.3565371335,
0.0301618669,
0.7971624136,
-0.3954515457,
-0.6654810309,
-0.6003450155,
-0.2024422586,
-0.0232656673,
0.194188714,
-0.1536711603,
-0.3289446533,
0.1709423512,
0.3345542252,
-0.6927553415,
-0.0399751477,
-0.4676727653,
0.0396000184,
0.5293047428,
0.2957450747,
0.464943558,
0.2463215888,
-0.3779118657,
-0.284947902,
-0.7033032179,
0.0107360631,
0.5387823582,
0.1712736934,
-0.2580318451,
0.5092765093,
-0.0122346971,
0.4608945549,
-0.0499045774,
0.2507963479,
0.170895502,
-0.3082931936,
0.016537318,
-0.1285203695,
0.7909141183,
0.3580951095,
0.571524322,
-0.0698235482,
0.1191288009,
-0.1915106624,
0.4217017293,
-0.7812553644,
-0.5957201123,
0.1574522108,
-0.3864499331,
-0.1732501686,
0.1031425819,
-0.920167625,
-0.8292999864,
-0.1609227657,
-0.0248581581,
-0.2849303484,
-0.377179563,
-0.0793554187,
0.0701212734,
0.6110875607,
0.6096532345,
-1.0432273149,
0.0862763226,
1.0061830282,
0.9435245991,
-0.2211605161,
-0.2333075851,
-0.1060149744,
-0.2634677887,
-0.1597960293,
0.907034874,
-0.3784303665,
-0.549880445,
0.0268596746,
-0.1401928812,
-0.094527103,
-0.2281904966,
0.293928802,
-0.6952285171,
0.7526126504,
-0.1312318146,
-0.3277680874,
-0.0618881918,
0.3573924601,
-0.3085075617,
0.8464795947,
0.0620266795,
-0.9366378188,
0.6460525393,
-1.1373331547,
-0.2090483755,
0.3936932683,
-0.3104047775,
-0.3473178744,
-0.0158798937,
0.2217670381,
0.4141207039,
-0.0854593962,
0.0276985038,
-0.0931646749,
-0.2157327831,
0.3457532227,
-0.5235958695,
0.7305145264,
0.2118929923,
0.0576451011,
0.0879287869,
-0.3040852249,
-0.368765682,
0.1392312944,
0.0567847565,
0.0743302852,
0.3225483298,
0.1454207301,
0.268155396,
0.1061481163,
-0.5057790875,
0.6109606028,
-0.318424046,
0.8514046073,
0.672644794,
0.3300574422,
0.1177956462,
-0.3359583318,
0.5106373429,
0.2642408609,
0.3493281007,
-0.4287968278,
-1.016485095,
-0.4231099188,
0.1357967705,
-0.050075721,
0.5951724052,
-0.3186752796,
-0.0465240069,
-0.5321574807,
-0.5282200575,
-0.4601885974,
0.1050220281,
-0.4236732423,
0.2398219407,
0.14435561,
-0.4266332984,
0.043221999,
-0.83840698,
-0.1436838657,
-0.6614521146,
-0.217059359,
0.7754759789,
0.1067101806,
-0.4555481076,
1.1222113371,
-0.7375811934,
0.0124859745,
-0.4541111588,
0.5109944344,
0.2865988612,
0.3231793046,
0.4586023092,
-1.0690315962,
-0.6392700672,
0.2408833057,
-0.3676057458,
0.2496723384,
-0.5919094682,
-0.3481826484,
-0.289738059,
0.2894223332,
-0.8337418437,
0.3152158856,
0.3828912377,
-0.4533831477,
0.3856210113,
0.1332465708,
0.1360867023,
-1.138450861,
-0.0332933515,
0.1129165292,
-0.1094893366,
-0.7004287839,
-0.4701761305,
-0.4714895785,
-0.4533514678,
-0.3337149918,
0.4720568061,
-0.1255865842,
-0.1285485625,
-0.1082508937,
0.1240326837,
-0.5856476426,
0.4598207176,
-0.0834881738,
1.0179402828,
0.5988183022,
-0.2263219208,
0.2844365835,
0.509709537,
-0.108309269,
0.4991043806,
-0.674711585,
0.6348183751,
-0.0346869305,
0.1232323125,
-1.4193930626,
-0.3446093202,
0.3730661869,
-0.5893039107,
-0.0240460262,
-0.4723521769,
-0.432292521,
-0.3153044283,
-0.1632730961,
0.2205211371,
0.5602937937,
-0.3457731307,
0.5505558848,
0.4444305003,
-0.6478969455,
-0.1326331496,
-0.2831297815,
0.4325826168,
-0.4553968608,
-0.8139436245,
0.2311410457,
-0.1951673627,
-0.2711009979,
-0.3683542311,
0.2826556563,
-0.2608691454,
0.1211638823,
0.2805629373,
0.2737098634,
-0.3638994396,
-0.0122753186,
-0.2518030405,
-0.4060106277,
-0.0873527527,
-0.064564459,
0.9571305513,
-0.2796704769,
-0.3578529954,
-0.4788552523,
0.1306299418,
0.6675216556,
-0.088046439,
0.7921484113,
0.8868803382,
0.1169754788,
0.3229319155,
-0.3179715276,
-0.2975025475,
-0.4021106958,
0.3740620315,
-0.0313829631,
-0.7721207738,
0.7476124763,
-0.0406661816,
0.5182464123,
0.396053493,
0.7836990952,
-0.3575778604,
0.9598748684,
0.6439789534,
-0.1478183866,
0.8340750933,
-0.0457677469,
0.2374671996,
-0.613851428,
-0.2858873606,
-0.1308255643,
-0.537989974,
-0.9584416151,
-0.165328294,
0.4260415435,
-0.0617765523,
-0.2033717781,
0.2252260596,
-0.3359407783,
0.4172379673,
0.5071978569,
-0.0050815796,
-0.0205241386,
-0.1926100701,
0.6445103884,
-0.1418768466,
-0.292581141,
-0.5993798971,
0.9942650795,
0.4416404068,
0.7359499335,
0.259198755,
0.5174356699,
0.6457279921,
0.5353890061,
-0.8494064808,
0.4968134761,
0.0630576983,
-0.4721378088,
-0.3454558551,
-0.3388872147,
-1.0893697739,
0.1245891675,
-0.1036067158,
-0.9468696117,
-0.1440670937,
0.3181457222,
-0.3320522308,
-0.0282998942,
-0.8802113533,
1.2238490582,
-0.3690711856,
-0.2965005338,
-0.0812045783,
-0.7764495015,
0.170578748,
0.046755828,
-0.1224426553,
-0.1357165873,
0.326133728,
0.6219297051,
-0.2046771497,
0.8412139416,
-0.3093099594,
-0.0427652299,
0.4249223173,
0.1066704914,
0.2753968537,
0.192663759,
0.3336819112,
0.1955326796,
-0.0442043766,
-0.3600492775,
-0.5574441552,
0.5042703152,
-0.8686505556,
-0.5005412698,
-0.2982401848,
-0.3318938613,
-0.3244306147,
0.1860248893,
-0.0728006437,
0.1755384505,
-0.5937846303,
0.1287433505,
0.2579610944,
-0.2339121997,
0.2376684844,
0.0898821205,
-0.3068432212,
0.0946993306,
0.8513072133,
-0.1682106405,
0.1415014416,
0.0567992553,
0.361345619,
-0.3332078159,
-0.2453992665,
-0.7497286797,
0.0402831808,
-0.407725364,
0.3630751371,
-0.5470981598,
0.0122052822,
-0.2769944966,
0.0517700464,
-0.2548067272,
-0.2256009877,
-0.2891447842,
0.2552536726,
0.3012783527,
0.8449001312,
0.3898048103,
0.8084645271,
-0.4852519333,
0.0480648056,
0.4826277494,
0.0940856636,
-0.2436532676,
-0.3258844018,
-0.0272642002,
0.0627046749,
-0.6341471076,
-0.9307466745,
0.3135731816,
0.4813311994,
0.6621873975,
0.503495574,
-0.4633677304,
0.1927239001,
-0.3491092622,
1.2482417822,
-0.0262779165,
-0.3540051579,
0.4759491086,
-0.6251370907,
0.2581405938,
0.3667292297,
0.3747286499,
-1.1952698231,
0.0902438462,
-0.5211840868,
-0.7368008494,
0.5995281935,
0.2605305612,
0.496965766,
0.278192699,
0.3740952909,
0.205359444,
0.0643984899,
-0.6267566681,
-0.2401892245,
-0.4952597916,
-0.2610163391,
-0.2324932963,
0.032159958,
-0.1470349729,
0.0120461229,
0.2995962501,
-0.3635766804,
0.5226786733,
-0.4308429956,
0.0920664594,
0.3877315521,
0.4103988409,
0.4487991631,
0.7049637437,
-0.134602651,
0.0004888418,
-0.2114497274,
-0.5804128051,
-0.0572149977,
0.2395395041,
-0.135057345,
-0.3946690857,
0.1776819676,
0.9117830396,
0.05097913,
-0.4398675561,
0.6163672209,
-0.2526989579,
0.1455133259,
-0.1154474765,
0.1967621595,
0.2227930576,
0.254452616,
0.4325961173,
-0.0264508389,
-0.0179133415,
-0.6639198661,
0.2599427104,
0.3144521713,
-0.5571572781,
-0.546356082,
0.6765654683,
0.1634094566,
-0.4861837626,
0.7731810808,
-0.0751061887,
-0.539649725,
0.2550213635,
0.2392629683,
1.1427203417,
0.1608328819,
0.5340055823,
-0.1418077946,
-0.0184865631,
0.1153491288,
-0.1389235854,
-0.2578882277,
-1.0334618092,
-0.0622475967,
-0.274052918,
-0.5304080844,
0.0170454364,
-0.5593695045,
0.2825555503,
-0.2144844234,
-0.308239609,
0.2850393057,
-0.0801348612,
-0.8764408827,
-0.0976713821,
0.2305918187,
0.2856777012,
-0.8256303668,
0.5671920776,
0.9115533829,
-0.3705127239,
-0.1296619922,
0.3580234349,
0.2628287077,
-0.9247429371,
0.7122873664,
0.1703182161,
-0.0605835952,
0.1353686601,
-0.5842713118,
-0.2075021565,
0.8363777995,
-0.037029095,
-0.3888835609,
0.110758543,
0.2471170872,
0.7457606792,
-0.3099302053,
0.5163128972,
0.4222381711,
-0.0127302278,
0.2137460411,
-0.6805582047,
-0.6521825194,
-0.0749658197,
-0.1581275761,
0.2942830026,
-0.7847143412,
0.9212562442,
-0.2479364723,
-0.4484398067,
-0.3711320162,
0.6021835804,
-0.125602439,
0.3947742879,
0.5884386897,
-0.0031960465,
0.5591616035,
-0.2250457704,
0.9653195143,
-0.4279266298,
0.4425210655,
0.783334136,
-0.2466295362,
0.7350069284,
0.3695616126,
-0.4656345248,
0.4681555629,
0.8388151526,
-0.0064082807,
0.4346921742,
-0.0206588283,
-0.3140620291,
-0.2414958179,
0.1080300212,
-0.2473772913,
0.5438700318,
0.2526659667,
-0.1735222489,
-0.1707591563,
0.0408983827,
-0.043552544,
-0.5136896372,
0.1125887036,
1.0888597965,
-0.1659851223,
-0.3564261794,
-0.1243943274,
-0.3796895742,
0.458448261,
-0.4062065184,
-0.1511474401,
-0.5089588165,
0.1306684613,
0.0900862813,
-1.2687612772,
0.0191673264,
0.0216285791,
0.1307964474,
-0.3951436877,
0.7005776167,
-0.2386274785,
-0.3638664484,
-0.0800605044,
0.8797424436,
0.5766137838,
-0.1965027601,
-0.8390039802,
-0.0146769825,
0.1123543158,
-0.345448792,
0.3707847297,
0.4101907909,
-0.1593351215,
0.8224678636,
0.4833462536,
-0.089529112,
0.0294809081,
0.1261931807,
0.9158024192,
-0.5727300048,
-0.5820654631,
-0.9483356476,
0.3947357833,
-0.071772851,
-0.8285553455,
0.5611447096,
0.6314242482,
0.6111166477,
0.1576500535,
0.6721945405,
-0.1469306648,
0.5515385866,
-0.266882062,
0.737914741,
-0.3627998233,
0.1918600947,
-0.160684824,
-0.8979510069,
-0.0413876735,
0.5806324482,
-0.4262192249,
0.2545268834,
-0.0681619346,
0.6172168255,
-0.193987295,
0.3704351783,
0.162071228,
0.1322891116,
0.8604966998,
0.3340235651,
1.1645715237,
-0.0744613335,
0.4768586457,
0.0244615208,
-0.4113314748,
-0.2643212378,
-0.7192505002,
-0.6309927106,
-0.5442685485,
-0.4000062048,
-0.0828800201,
-0.0134630045,
0.7357256413,
0.7761371732,
-0.7974844575,
-0.1292368323,
-0.0905724466,
-0.2005142719,
-0.038017761,
-0.3028173745,
0.2570742071,
-0.109790884,
-0.6307007074,
0.2975611687,
0.1407818645,
0.2224591076,
-0.5989486575,
-0.0025188096,
0.1590002477,
-0.1728219688,
0.5757946372,
0.5755019784,
-0.4278234839,
-0.4101558328,
0.0808849409,
-0.0332054608,
0.5065546036,
1.1250668764,
-0.5696594715,
0.3884909749,
0.2442775816,
0.7428821325,
0.7607706189,
0.4990428686,
0.6985027194,
-0.5895497203,
0.1293100566,
0.2904301286,
-0.0559959672,
0.4144730866,
-0.3345690072,
0.4184600711,
0.5078135133,
-0.8120476007,
-0.6489107609,
0.0007154802,
-1.0837306976,
0.1652030349,
0.7222446203,
-0.1249685213,
0.4313198328,
-0.2031937689,
-0.5704240799,
-0.0722484589,
-0.6713295579,
0.9661174417,
0.8426294923,
-0.8366244435,
-0.4736584425,
-0.9552830458,
0.5191681385,
0.1913034618,
-1.1218873262,
0.3370408714,
0.4878962934,
0.1318950802,
0.0984282345,
0.6179948449,
-0.0411257632,
-0.1724788696,
0.0436323769,
-0.2697922289,
0.3592741489,
-0.3485305905,
0.1362004131,
0.0791600794,
0.193699494,
-0.2891365588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11503v1
|
Speech and Text-Based Emotion Recognizer
| 2023-12-10T05:17:39 | 2023-12-10T05:17:39 |
Varun Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Affective computing is a field of study that focuses on developing systems
and technologies that can understand, interpret, and respond to human emotions.
Speech Emotion Recognition (SER), in particular, has got a lot of attention
from researchers in the recent past. However, in many cases, the publicly
available datasets, used for training and evaluation, are scarce and imbalanced
across the emotion labels. In this work, we focused on building a balanced
corpus from these publicly available datasets by combining these datasets as
well as employing various speech data augmentation techniques. Furthermore, we
experimented with different architectures for speech emotion recognition. Our
best system, a multi-modal speech, and text-based model, provides a performance
of UA(Unweighed Accuracy) + WA (Weighed Accuracy) of 157.57 compared to the
baseline algorithm performance of 119.66
|
[
-0.3702100515,
-0.3827638924,
0.0747060999,
0.2324342877,
-0.0640532896,
0.0881262124,
-0.1503106952,
-0.6241431832,
0.485827744,
-0.001600553,
-0.1874310076,
-0.221922487,
-0.5543596745,
0.2538926005,
-0.3444413245,
0.905818224,
0.0989572108,
0.1234402061,
-0.097711876,
-0.4756281376,
-0.2167929411,
-0.6766747236,
-0.4751112163,
-0.3585200906,
0.4509683847,
0.4075891078,
0.6408061385,
0.1702986956,
0.1742155999,
0.3306349814,
-0.2208660245,
0.0497787707,
-0.264760524,
0.2077310681,
0.1150115803,
-0.1133057997,
-0.3263857961,
-0.3848987222,
0.5270789266,
0.0880885646,
-0.1637606919,
-0.0207895227,
-0.1737326533,
0.7712779641,
-0.9301158786,
-0.0444657244,
-0.4909953773,
0.281404376,
-0.3050850928,
-0.0408680402,
-0.2606962919,
-0.2844782174,
0.2762651145,
-0.1937116235,
-0.1109557524,
-0.1319650114,
0.4631060064,
0.5017780662,
-0.5922629237,
-0.3624839783,
-0.5730839372,
0.6087892652,
-0.7466480136,
0.5356500745,
0.3899294734,
0.0687814727,
0.345208317,
-0.2864495218,
-0.7349059582,
0.2216615826,
0.2379815578,
0.3417794108,
-0.4976378977,
0.041367095,
0.195611015,
0.6551660895,
-0.5741900802,
0.1423532814,
-0.0565986745,
-0.2053517252,
0.4418340921,
0.2023856193,
0.4767046869,
-0.2287051827,
0.0004088688,
-0.176960662,
-0.092014052,
0.2985206246,
0.3298707902,
0.4923394024,
-0.4557246268,
0.7668380737,
-0.0916572958,
0.5884068012,
0.0343988799,
0.0668611825,
0.8200977445,
0.3091422021,
-0.4997553229,
0.4863957465,
0.7960214615,
0.2224454731,
0.1159823909,
0.0725547522,
-0.2070643306,
0.4495031834,
0.5052378178,
-0.686128974,
0.04704272,
0.5713146925,
-0.5637400746,
-0.1717853546,
-0.2109440565,
-1.2415175438,
-0.7580525875,
-0.5376582742,
0.5019776225,
-0.5911079645,
-0.3341460824,
-0.0729693547,
-0.0768570006,
0.0790243074,
0.2581749558,
-0.8598549962,
0.2993465364,
0.4718689322,
0.8618852496,
-0.2141766697,
0.1947064549,
-0.4708903432,
-0.2205882519,
0.0944566727,
0.3438293636,
-0.6475477219,
-0.5259702206,
0.1203415617,
-0.0396553315,
-0.0740207955,
-0.2907195389,
1.1563847065,
-0.3653977513,
0.3222430646,
-0.2458720505,
-0.8133726716,
-0.2102258503,
-0.0593288206,
-0.8558959365,
0.9386668801,
-0.0819158256,
-1.0194405317,
0.10215763,
-0.6604361534,
-0.6426158547,
0.1115962267,
0.0222170129,
-0.5513620377,
0.3290387392,
0.0398342013,
0.2657040656,
-0.2807376981,
-0.0997710153,
-0.2008600682,
-0.2712100446,
0.434101969,
-0.3538302481,
0.4115481675,
0.5956561565,
-0.5674609542,
0.1379301101,
-1.1358867884,
-0.0368917845,
-0.3320279717,
-0.4452127218,
-0.4127003253,
0.3692135811,
0.5047951341,
0.1752604246,
0.2019417882,
-0.8402281404,
-0.2442689389,
-0.4048228264,
0.3668988049,
0.5551350713,
-0.6122364402,
0.2887696326,
-0.0432177857,
0.503461659,
0.0332628228,
-0.2896544635,
-0.0229227282,
-0.1383186579,
-0.7637450695,
-0.5466314554,
0.1369657367,
0.8660113811,
-0.4054752886,
0.611928761,
0.0572271533,
-0.6025500894,
-0.8951432109,
-0.3688390553,
0.3843995631,
0.7567132115,
0.5205649734,
0.0868433565,
-0.802909255,
-0.6436294913,
0.0279148594,
-0.0450922698,
-0.0068300012,
0.5211442709,
-0.015286562,
-0.5273603797,
0.8889822364,
-0.1980683208,
0.0720166415,
0.1089395434,
0.538331151,
0.0471451133,
0.3931211531,
0.5216932893,
-0.9902817011,
-0.4185414314,
0.1750502437,
-0.7233669162,
-0.3110806048,
0.3318131566,
0.1135235727,
0.5272064805,
0.0314273797,
-0.2685852945,
0.4657128453,
0.754688561,
-0.3737562895,
0.3495760858,
-0.0102014905,
0.6749317646,
-1.0785064697,
0.147299394,
0.0698766857,
-0.1091086194,
-0.7667636275,
-0.7560575604,
0.2609941959,
-0.5098307729,
-0.4499141872,
0.4987806082,
-0.2172286212,
-0.3015370071,
-0.59042871,
-0.1736207902,
-0.289819926,
0.3457777202,
0.1120587587,
0.7911344767,
0.6726920009,
-0.6035919785,
0.5113739371,
0.2972008586,
-0.1498665065,
1.0096158981,
-0.6680711508,
0.1104432791,
-0.2308623791,
-0.1315108985,
-0.9939234257,
-0.3905878961,
-0.0893986449,
-0.4656791687,
0.1497412324,
0.1804068387,
-0.1046330258,
-0.3096076548,
-0.1787202358,
0.4952126443,
0.609220624,
-0.6581335664,
1.0012428761,
0.7244358659,
-0.5138109326,
-0.5514801741,
-0.7071502209,
0.051769197,
-0.3251364231,
-0.5397956967,
0.4003868997,
-0.0227097273,
-0.2202279866,
-0.0447935127,
0.0510636494,
-0.1571848243,
-0.2890418768,
0.7075226307,
0.2159302831,
0.0962058529,
0.5014648438,
-0.0271993652,
0.0990260541,
-0.146150738,
0.3788475692,
0.3816989362,
-0.4670625329,
-0.3010547459,
-0.624117732,
0.5152691603,
0.9355306625,
-0.2771624625,
0.5445026159,
0.7841520905,
-0.6354349852,
0.127801612,
-0.5485384464,
0.3138075769,
-0.3930953741,
0.1832706332,
-0.4348559976,
-0.9980019331,
0.622290194,
0.0188593175,
-0.290565908,
0.3241297603,
0.7653808594,
0.0392317548,
1.0696907043,
0.2930946648,
-0.6077806354,
0.6384443045,
0.4314922094,
0.0478088185,
-0.7569133043,
-0.1576222628,
-0.8271459937,
-0.4244394898,
-0.6091650128,
0.0436149463,
0.2625224888,
-0.4413627088,
-0.2687417269,
0.0764035508,
-0.6956022382,
-0.0316628292,
0.4764228165,
0.2639641762,
-0.2862184942,
-0.0709502622,
0.239532873,
-0.218791306,
-0.1348362416,
-0.3937338889,
0.7900765538,
0.1888504773,
0.8684408069,
0.1038421467,
0.4651921988,
0.5862549543,
-0.0785223246,
-0.9057292342,
0.2341942489,
-0.4509778917,
-0.2468874156,
-0.159249261,
-0.5953756571,
-0.7616410851,
0.0927582383,
-0.387832433,
-0.675753653,
0.4249539077,
0.1736284792,
-0.1008354872,
0.1715574414,
-0.8672423959,
0.7270457745,
-0.4864549041,
-0.4014773369,
-0.1611282378,
-0.7458021045,
0.0386925228,
-0.1068971902,
0.2939593196,
0.0400531814,
0.0840603635,
0.6572743058,
-0.4738084972,
0.5841848254,
-0.2521623969,
0.0696144328,
0.1693722904,
-0.2388793528,
0.2825892866,
-0.5117701292,
-0.7027563453,
-0.0837621018,
-0.0267964546,
-0.1779551059,
-0.4969957173,
0.5194019675,
-1.0329217911,
0.1979689151,
-0.541331172,
-0.4460588694,
-0.2983030379,
-0.0625562966,
0.0838337839,
0.5408606529,
-0.5630546212,
0.2796556354,
0.6726086736,
-0.5235645771,
0.4225975871,
0.5589424968,
0.1429242343,
-0.9277696013,
0.9303744435,
-0.1437217444,
-0.0603338145,
0.5068720579,
0.2839995325,
-0.4636328816,
0.0408322178,
-0.2429250777,
-0.2219554037,
-0.3921358585,
-0.3501351476,
-0.8125188947,
-0.0889232531,
-0.602660656,
-0.2801008821,
-0.2890394032,
-0.2489574105,
-0.5632101297,
-0.0762251541,
0.7524131536,
0.2873957455,
-0.3511179984,
0.3672988117,
-0.8130488992,
0.6373739243,
0.4412751794,
0.3649397492,
-0.1404281557,
-0.3417803049,
-0.1205156073,
0.2121593803,
-0.0740506425,
-1.0524203777,
0.6714522839,
0.3817425966,
0.2442796975,
0.4972180426,
0.2086637169,
0.5714357495,
-0.3189174831,
0.6241189241,
0.3589236438,
-1.53867805,
0.6699150801,
-0.1236363202,
0.3725345731,
0.5995008349,
0.3228982985,
-0.7029510736,
0.1171073392,
-0.5203412771,
-0.9562035203,
0.8345348239,
0.2543718219,
-0.0430374965,
0.1662455648,
0.2064922452,
0.0117405625,
0.3701542318,
-0.6425538063,
-0.067700997,
-0.4487357438,
-1.0014281273,
0.0425135531,
-0.3607380986,
0.1120943502,
-0.0624675751,
0.6602960229,
0.0664946139,
0.32491377,
0.2157331854,
-0.1511701047,
-0.129591167,
0.7195584178,
0.3657738566,
-0.1586540341,
-0.486187309,
0.3235734701,
0.0294399876,
-0.4491868615,
0.1437520385,
0.4207306802,
0.0288633294,
0.046801921,
-0.1594947278,
1.179109931,
0.1447714716,
-1.1052931547,
0.3943606913,
-0.071516946,
0.1550587565,
-0.1060698479,
-0.2517497241,
-0.0171086527,
0.3027250469,
0.2868556678,
-0.0819280222,
0.5148522258,
-0.5217258334,
0.123525627,
0.2803117931,
-0.5968388319,
-0.1726744473,
0.4216715693,
0.4243596196,
-0.5168156028,
0.4476572871,
-0.1724167615,
-0.7310984135,
0.4613049626,
0.5208719969,
1.0139684677,
-0.6081722975,
0.0676623732,
0.2207047492,
-0.2092521787,
0.1469823718,
0.884857595,
-0.1703377366,
-0.6874504685,
-0.1203007624,
-0.6893079877,
-0.9046052694,
-0.1562075168,
-0.7290352583,
0.3817299902,
-0.123496078,
-0.3786068857,
0.0132968994,
-0.1408618987,
-0.3447078168,
0.6727110147,
0.3804354966,
0.455285579,
-0.8078303337,
0.4278638363,
0.8879620433,
-0.2336264402,
-0.5625950694,
-0.4465737939,
0.2451671064,
-0.50669384,
0.4731463194,
0.2646515965,
-0.4767697155,
-0.1301063895,
-0.25552091,
-0.5004948974,
0.8396339417,
0.2537973225,
-0.56819731,
0.4404971302,
0.0605559647,
0.8037833571,
-0.1962537915,
0.4709972143,
0.2719923854,
0.2481906116,
0.2560350299,
-0.9608175159,
-0.368688792,
-0.7033885121,
-0.291348964,
0.4140071571,
-0.4142327905,
0.7936955094,
0.2469055504,
-0.1834095418,
-0.2110911012,
0.6377729177,
0.3127764761,
0.7042409182,
0.5812728405,
0.9132522941,
0.997969687,
-0.0354933925,
0.65907377,
-0.2777384222,
0.0354640782,
1.0840183496,
-0.6403984427,
0.985865891,
0.0391553193,
-0.2718271315,
0.4514358342,
0.6590394378,
0.0562286265,
0.4106267095,
0.1179409549,
-0.6239807606,
0.0709116533,
-0.4909263253,
-0.4032689333,
0.5389819145,
0.4435199499,
-0.1651882976,
0.1819370389,
0.402564466,
-0.005426792,
-0.0287670121,
-0.490809828,
0.9673033357,
-0.1983635277,
-0.2112688571,
0.2352179736,
-0.1932646185,
1.05296278,
-0.4813002646,
0.3061558604,
0.2333182693,
0.1105946675,
-0.5887174606,
-0.6665012836,
0.2747661471,
0.6420971751,
-0.4214880466,
-0.1759585291,
0.9894849658,
-0.5561234951,
-0.4425035715,
0.381836623,
0.1217649132,
0.1762133837,
-0.2225965112,
-0.4674249291,
0.5525404811,
-0.1442759037,
0.0254818406,
0.0607195906,
0.768316865,
0.3558334708,
0.4241586328,
0.2712976038,
0.0630805269,
-0.0125127705,
0.4602093399,
0.6433010101,
-0.7511819601,
-0.7122463584,
-0.7250905037,
0.7824590802,
-0.1373252273,
-0.2569901347,
0.4415946305,
0.6721948385,
0.0515826829,
-0.0315489955,
0.9554748535,
-0.292322278,
0.9327181578,
-0.2077529132,
0.4386444986,
-0.7158284187,
-0.358314991,
-0.8530812263,
-0.3565168679,
-0.0358925462,
0.6481107473,
-0.0009207618,
-0.1647369713,
0.2614196241,
0.4477920234,
0.2122227699,
0.5713638663,
0.0608972497,
0.0011799538,
0.1288058013,
0.6654506326,
0.7623177171,
-0.2992324531,
0.1787559986,
-0.0336899348,
-0.4560600519,
-0.3878837228,
-0.9315197468,
-0.4394786656,
-0.6949131489,
-0.2263050079,
-0.2797240019,
0.1136275679,
0.9775541425,
0.5481929183,
-0.8527033329,
-0.2871222198,
-0.0129833613,
-0.1090487391,
0.1511344761,
-0.2585866749,
0.1636333913,
-0.1601403803,
-0.7647536397,
0.3672197163,
0.3667891622,
0.2485228628,
0.3009719551,
-0.1621102244,
-0.2605395913,
0.0994766951,
0.8204069734,
0.5587868094,
-0.3455564082,
-0.1934812069,
-0.1233399436,
-0.1619262248,
0.054906223,
0.6670069695,
-0.6947956681,
0.7569227219,
0.7556402087,
1.0092128515,
0.4677090049,
0.1292261183,
0.5351883769,
-0.5244292617,
0.221855849,
0.4295365214,
0.4723349214,
0.6129569411,
-0.3451046348,
0.4747434556,
-0.0385270789,
-0.8623031974,
-0.7426847219,
0.0754833594,
-1.4682873487,
0.0754433572,
0.779322207,
0.2066883743,
0.0653231889,
0.1909746677,
-0.6043187976,
0.5163843036,
-0.8222463131,
0.6851761341,
0.7194012403,
-0.6465311646,
-0.1864981353,
0.068925783,
0.4102987647,
0.5104628205,
-1.2063599825,
0.1380096376,
0.9943425655,
-0.2252068669,
0.2574609816,
0.6499553323,
0.0022113479,
0.1189266965,
-0.16629605,
0.4675955772,
0.3044415712,
0.0436184704,
-0.796163857,
0.3022865057,
-0.4067331553,
-0.3511012197
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05762v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05762v1
|
Multi-Defendant Legal Judgment Prediction via Hierarchical Reasoning
| 2023-12-10T04:46:30 | 2023-12-10T04:46:30 |
Yougang Lyu, Jitai Hao, Zihan Wang, Kai Zhao, Shen Gao, Pengjie Ren, Zhumin Chen, Fang Wang, Zhaochun Ren
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multiple defendants in a criminal fact description generally exhibit complex
interactions, and cannot be well handled by existing Legal Judgment Prediction
(LJP) methods which focus on predicting judgment results (e.g., law articles,
charges, and terms of penalty) for single-defendant cases. To address this
problem, we propose the task of multi-defendant LJP, which aims to
automatically predict the judgment results for each defendant of
multi-defendant cases. Two challenges arise with the task of multi-defendant
LJP: (1) indistinguishable judgment results among various defendants; and (2)
the lack of a real-world dataset for training and evaluation. To tackle the
first challenge, we formalize the multi-defendant judgment process as
hierarchical reasoning chains and introduce a multi-defendant LJP method, named
Hierarchical Reasoning Network (HRN), which follows the hierarchical reasoning
chains to determine criminal relationships, sentencing circumstances, law
articles, charges, and terms of penalty for each defendant. To tackle the
second challenge, we collect a real-world multi-defendant LJP dataset, namely
MultiLJP, to accelerate the relevant research in the future. Extensive
experiments on MultiLJP verify the effectiveness of our proposed HRN.
|
[
-0.3138986826,
-0.6646674871,
0.7927321792,
0.3051315844,
-0.042367205,
0.1482291073,
0.0255033355,
-0.8466977477,
0.2073066235,
0.5968624353,
-0.5245622993,
-0.3437007964,
-0.5010642409,
-0.0923627913,
0.1303270459,
0.9813536406,
0.3580575585,
0.3915151954,
-0.0829384923,
-0.1364670843,
-0.545219183,
-0.5553151965,
-0.4039779007,
-0.383579582,
0.7354091406,
0.4980053902,
0.7464612126,
0.6246883869,
0.7906782627,
0.273881942,
0.0960178375,
-0.0212449599,
-0.0669141039,
0.0692146644,
-0.2353617996,
-0.2619401515,
-0.2696163356,
-0.2162555903,
0.2840035856,
0.5963919759,
-0.38074103,
-0.1538040787,
-0.2890439928,
0.6468832493,
-0.9744184017,
0.0876199231,
-0.5291211009,
0.6597562432,
-0.122334443,
-0.5018939376,
-0.624575913,
-0.2516186535,
0.1692244262,
-0.5196463466,
0.1568292975,
0.4107046425,
0.4060601592,
0.1503081471,
-0.6222089529,
-0.0324367434,
-0.7969136238,
0.2429403812,
-0.598161459,
0.0434818193,
0.2743970752,
0.6164299846,
-0.2068597823,
-0.5494894981,
-0.4238955081,
-0.6931243539,
-0.176711753,
0.5949565768,
0.1459524035,
0.4253157079,
0.4807766676,
0.0704219267,
-0.4351327419,
-0.030219188,
-0.202459693,
-0.0841950327,
0.5711177588,
0.2410939783,
0.0282992739,
-0.3835411966,
-0.5864911675,
0.1603298932,
-0.3997073472,
0.2848859727,
0.5435233116,
0.6972538233,
0.1120446995,
0.4725776613,
-0.1809398383,
0.3366272151,
0.1430308074,
-0.378713429,
0.4152109623,
-0.155211255,
-0.193375662,
0.4545767605,
1.0315198898,
0.3234409094,
0.1789665669,
0.0429756083,
-0.0557946935,
-0.2139784396,
0.4438961744,
-0.5288282037,
-0.2096951157,
0.2662325501,
-0.6597670913,
-0.2222341448,
0.1136496663,
-0.8243442774,
-0.7713586092,
-0.3977798223,
0.1939813793,
-0.3233471215,
-0.2416758984,
0.1106205359,
-0.2082824409,
-0.3000037372,
0.6019125581,
-0.5998056531,
0.532227993,
0.5498313308,
0.5215229392,
0.0727728009,
-0.4948966503,
-0.7468593717,
0.3310842216,
-0.0815450102,
0.6583538651,
-0.4418122172,
0.1228029057,
0.1101543978,
-0.1863476038,
0.1617855877,
-0.3481525779,
0.6882015467,
-0.4116043448,
-0.1234821081,
-0.0461370759,
-0.4407158792,
-0.0557468049,
0.6108946204,
-0.8778380752,
0.3771502972,
-0.1430654526,
-1.185718894,
0.7862151265,
-0.5010489225,
-0.5310505629,
0.3466961384,
-0.306301266,
-0.7791605592,
-0.1200781539,
0.2735680044,
0.4333187342,
-0.1626556218,
0.5069280863,
-0.8387086391,
-0.2881776392,
-0.2191612422,
-0.1074329466,
0.9777739644,
0.0677491277,
-0.2240279168,
0.3210479617,
-0.6227630973,
-0.2744334936,
0.0176486429,
-0.3527093232,
-0.1488601863,
0.2158927321,
-0.1100746468,
0.512817204,
0.0344748795,
-0.6500633359,
0.3237974346,
-0.1164467782,
-0.1722152531,
0.8904675245,
0.1779964417,
0.0744605064,
-0.2995576859,
0.6354606748,
0.2607792914,
0.3242224753,
0.1917379051,
-0.6384081244,
-0.310964793,
0.0892808363,
0.244243294,
0.9132561684,
-0.7975051999,
0.2762452066,
-0.2004670054,
-0.2285334915,
-0.0041333325,
-0.3792167902,
0.4564409256,
0.3594699204,
0.5576276779,
-0.1837777048,
-0.8337767124,
-1.0959390402,
-0.6753313541,
-0.5107036233,
0.3433702588,
0.3443484008,
0.9129325151,
0.095820494,
0.7674802542,
-0.3126553297,
-0.4743916094,
-0.2112174183,
0.3478172421,
0.3700956106,
0.514316678,
0.2600004077,
-0.9216735959,
-0.2568509579,
0.0950587392,
-0.7529181838,
0.3535758853,
-0.5127568245,
-0.0460290536,
-0.4154853821,
0.5378912687,
-0.2189723104,
0.5279117227,
0.0152806649,
-0.5221760869,
1.0558663607,
-0.1492791027,
0.4178875983,
-0.9397756457,
-0.3221931458,
0.4383972287,
-0.4853079617,
-0.5575960279,
0.3295995295,
-0.023735024,
0.1880515516,
-0.4561282098,
0.1896688938,
-0.1550127268,
-0.4139523208,
0.211484924,
-0.1891328543,
-0.4314573407,
0.9714670777,
0.119475089,
0.3490445912,
0.3811464608,
-0.415404886,
0.6651495695,
0.1218634322,
-0.4862101674,
0.5738250017,
-0.4071746171,
-0.2372834235,
-0.1976066083,
0.4244771898,
-0.5016551614,
-0.2036669552,
0.4518853128,
-0.2539491653,
0.2788124681,
-0.6563492417,
-0.6733916998,
-0.5166746378,
-0.2132439464,
0.5612957478,
-0.1133243293,
-0.3678814471,
0.7185838223,
0.4824599326,
0.0097353393,
-1.067804575,
-0.6561553478,
0.3756553829,
-0.2979781926,
-0.3579410315,
0.5238186717,
0.0518362224,
-0.2332796603,
0.0511537194,
0.2236756384,
-0.1617076993,
0.0579457246,
0.5164396167,
0.2129387707,
-0.0523796119,
0.2722441852,
-0.0060252557,
-0.0293917544,
0.3578786552,
-0.0931084901,
0.1781942099,
-0.3553981781,
-0.5790259838,
-0.5127568245,
0.453581214,
0.2549220026,
-0.0201580916,
0.5310416222,
0.112333864,
-0.4595547318,
-0.0663518533,
-0.5216755867,
0.2474661767,
-0.3287665546,
0.2787483633,
-0.7754172087,
-0.9219099879,
0.5223100781,
-0.3005498052,
0.151280269,
0.4610431492,
0.7938480377,
0.1282461733,
1.0913735628,
0.4034739435,
-0.0686779916,
0.4829427302,
0.1067603976,
0.2015204132,
-0.6101171374,
-0.3990500271,
-0.4736389816,
-0.1721745133,
-0.8482124805,
-0.1091482788,
0.6204275489,
-0.0130141759,
-0.4974659681,
0.4418175817,
-0.2370854467,
0.6173579693,
0.8290736675,
0.3741735816,
0.4823397994,
0.0002529594,
-0.6010882258,
0.1843663603,
-0.471101284,
-0.0093613314,
1.0245217085,
0.2371611297,
0.3025372028,
0.4499793649,
0.7785781622,
0.5642387271,
-0.1156560779,
-0.8066961765,
0.5371190906,
-0.0597172976,
-0.7210105062,
-0.2095508426,
-0.9231311679,
-0.8991611004,
0.5686861277,
-0.4329637885,
-0.8511868119,
0.2323368639,
-0.0797591731,
-0.7298221588,
0.3339291215,
-0.0405522808,
0.6268876195,
-0.0123174945,
-0.5313945413,
-0.4596051872,
-1.146502018,
0.7613986135,
0.1833341271,
0.3359323442,
-0.187611267,
0.4741286635,
0.6520161629,
-0.5862908363,
0.5465027094,
-0.3344765306,
0.1644103974,
0.3143742979,
0.2507092655,
0.3600180745,
0.3461250961,
-0.1569506079,
-0.2173602432,
-0.0338770039,
-0.1063642502,
-0.5486101508,
0.4288166761,
-0.506259799,
-0.3409043849,
-0.6986657977,
-0.7837272286,
-0.3648234308,
0.1884744763,
0.0506182052,
0.4843410552,
-0.1810812503,
-0.0311277863,
0.0692952499,
0.036821194,
0.2707717121,
0.2404596508,
-0.1179144755,
-0.5404164791,
0.5299166441,
-0.1577332765,
-0.0874688253,
0.5206655264,
0.5100678205,
-0.2968355119,
-0.5093826056,
-0.6202396154,
-0.0671615154,
-0.8790836334,
-0.3292302191,
-0.5807209015,
-0.0753993466,
-0.3994309008,
0.1636959612,
-0.2725946605,
-0.5389708281,
0.4670474827,
0.0989804268,
0.021316113,
0.5037865639,
-0.2217375785,
0.119991228,
-0.6726404428,
0.6845161319,
0.5239347219,
0.3724983037,
-0.0791659057,
-0.5650951266,
-0.3411499858,
0.013605237,
-0.2046823651,
-0.6644366384,
0.1120488569,
-0.1025966853,
0.3730084002,
0.3195209205,
0.1243038997,
0.9320270419,
-0.8239220977,
0.5022894144,
0.6288073659,
-0.6608666182,
0.715523243,
-0.3436405063,
-0.2257437706,
0.7739491463,
0.324850291,
-0.4077038765,
-0.2963893116,
-0.5300824642,
-0.4998435378,
0.8847501874,
0.170167163,
-0.2934186459,
0.2238764316,
0.2744012773,
-0.1348133087,
0.1744576544,
-0.9274247289,
-0.2078946978,
-0.007448467,
0.1053794101,
0.4304092228,
0.1232009232,
-0.2150890082,
-0.4796128869,
0.6616295576,
-0.2232050002,
0.2468241155,
0.1149281636,
0.2098887861,
-0.2676797211,
0.2380362749,
0.2696849704,
0.7062620521,
-0.3971236348,
0.0931539536,
-0.0248707905,
-0.0855917409,
0.3491185009,
0.0114195663,
0.1061726362,
-0.3126962483,
0.7259715796,
0.8009502888,
-0.1550255567,
-0.3704969287,
0.7511308193,
-0.367908597,
-0.4834122062,
-0.6668947935,
-0.1180173308,
-0.217604056,
0.5891183019,
0.0237634182,
0.6039344668,
0.6247604489,
-0.9759857655,
0.4436003864,
0.1394596994,
-0.5018299222,
0.3531192839,
0.5925082564,
-0.1203126833,
-0.0644591674,
0.6775810719,
-0.4953824878,
-0.7001877427,
0.7917240262,
0.5382073522,
0.7040817738,
-0.0958507285,
0.1206500307,
0.4808527827,
0.0187739749,
-0.525439322,
0.060427364,
0.0285142865,
-0.93890661,
-0.5970255733,
-0.4794020057,
-0.5978932977,
0.0018202499,
-0.7778167129,
0.1289723665,
-0.743365109,
-0.2396875471,
0.1790162027,
0.0522523373,
-0.3225871325,
0.2717200816,
0.2831459045,
0.4551432729,
-0.6053844094,
0.717862308,
0.4684402943,
-0.492429018,
-0.6529926062,
0.0273191109,
0.3697473109,
-0.5436031222,
0.7415581346,
0.357167244,
-0.3850971758,
-0.4544297159,
-0.4413054287,
-0.4277584255,
0.5754792094,
0.0722176582,
-0.7441364527,
-0.1809034646,
-0.0284506381,
0.3229132891,
-0.5217520595,
-0.0000959023,
0.6027702689,
0.4536023736,
0.3184709251,
-0.708060801,
0.1439668983,
-0.6026216149,
-0.2030672282,
0.3304362893,
-0.2245562822,
0.997518599,
-0.5450342298,
0.0547929257,
-0.1533894092,
0.8148460388,
0.4775273204,
0.4055179656,
0.9113903642,
0.9339279532,
0.6646443009,
-0.0111500677,
1.2741235495,
0.0318663381,
0.3517508209,
1.6321512461,
-0.4333780408,
0.5808283687,
0.4143472612,
-0.3776077628,
0.7772946954,
0.4741058052,
-0.4137132764,
0.3850820065,
0.5321993232,
-0.172170341,
-0.7024478912,
-0.2494654804,
-0.0868213922,
0.4761833847,
0.2049650252,
-0.171164602,
0.0312831104,
-0.1744850129,
-0.3276599944,
-0.0472521,
-0.4566903412,
0.6986712813,
-0.1861968935,
-0.6700876355,
-0.1296495348,
0.2092680037,
0.4056869149,
-0.2365806699,
-0.3364798427,
0.2845233679,
0.3956750929,
-0.4637014568,
-1.0596123934,
0.1532308757,
-0.3183072507,
-0.2730309367,
-0.1451680362,
0.7083200812,
-0.1362041384,
-0.4790874124,
0.6680305004,
0.4904531538,
0.0339725576,
-0.2361121178,
-1.1437748671,
-0.7193485498,
-0.1715320796,
-0.2235420048,
0.3862616718,
0.4560692906,
-0.0889119357,
0.6985833645,
0.7216359973,
0.2804732919,
0.0623249225,
0.718891561,
0.7381411195,
-0.6365072727,
-0.6755832434,
-0.9377715588,
0.56474787,
-0.3737311065,
-0.4246958196,
0.3593532741,
0.5668794513,
0.7890068293,
0.157765761,
0.6603766084,
-0.1767057478,
0.6201922297,
-0.6425479054,
0.1494287997,
-0.532710135,
0.1630545408,
-0.4980961382,
-0.6728239655,
-0.4639925659,
0.6247785687,
-0.0644768998,
0.1749704182,
0.8486735225,
0.5151480436,
-0.2022734135,
0.1494079977,
0.2995299995,
-0.106508702,
0.2957953513,
0.7941111922,
0.9045458436,
-0.3939782381,
0.4282432199,
-0.6461272836,
0.0077562905,
-0.3655892909,
-0.907248497,
-0.8719986081,
-0.2113393992,
-0.145575583,
-0.352596432,
-0.1200625822,
1.0489547253,
0.8389076591,
-0.8560275435,
-0.4314467609,
-0.4670265913,
0.1701970696,
-0.4034043252,
-0.2093704492,
0.2125183642,
-0.2620001733,
-0.1915093511,
0.4085974097,
0.2693290412,
-0.4004343152,
0.0692474395,
-0.1393786669,
-0.6464947462,
-0.3021237552,
0.5697869658,
-0.0915330946,
-0.7092496753,
-0.272441268,
-0.718986392,
-0.0973841175,
0.2523006499,
1.2095196247,
-0.6944149137,
0.3105863631,
0.4828161895,
0.6333161592,
0.5586971045,
0.1230148301,
0.500023663,
-0.8442246914,
0.011493817,
0.6243619919,
0.9093895555,
-0.1609847397,
-0.4010822177,
0.7087818384,
0.2983187139,
-0.6662998199,
-0.4050952196,
0.5507171154,
-0.7950986028,
-0.6778835058,
0.4616977572,
-0.4732458293,
0.0592526346,
-0.4482368231,
0.12537916,
0.3835883141,
-0.582377553,
0.6033367515,
0.4082629681,
-0.375850141,
-0.4133782089,
-0.7447023988,
0.3589524031,
0.3492997885,
-1.0744540691,
0.0860525891,
0.8069950342,
-0.1709199697,
0.6063550115,
0.4801531136,
0.1417879611,
0.476158917,
0.1539306939,
0.1301352382,
-0.2490361184,
-0.8803491592,
-0.1128425673,
0.5558205247,
-0.5214808583,
0.175563693
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05741v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05741v1
|
MISCA: A Joint Model for Multiple Intent Detection and Slot Filling with Intent-Slot Co-Attention
| 2023-12-10T03:38:41 | 2023-12-10T03:38:41 |
Thinh Pham, Chi Tran, Dat Quoc Nguyen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The research study of detecting multiple intents and filling slots is
becoming more popular because of its relevance to complicated real-world
situations. Recent advanced approaches, which are joint models based on graphs,
might still face two potential issues: (i) the uncertainty introduced by
constructing graphs based on preliminary intents and slots, which may transfer
intent-slot correlation information to incorrect label node destinations, and
(ii) direct incorporation of multiple intent labels for each token w.r.t.
token-level intent voting might potentially lead to incorrect slot predictions,
thereby hurting the overall performance. To address these two issues, we
propose a joint model named MISCA. Our MISCA introduces an intent-slot
co-attention mechanism and an underlying layer of label attention mechanism.
These mechanisms enable MISCA to effectively capture correlations between
intents and slot labels, eliminating the need for graph construction. They also
facilitate the transfer of correlation information in both directions: from
intents to slots and from slots to intents, through multiple levels of
label-specific representations, without relying on token-level intent
information. Experimental results show that MISCA outperforms previous models,
achieving new state-of-the-art overall accuracy performances on two benchmark
datasets MixATIS and MixSNIPS. This highlights the effectiveness of our
attention mechanisms.
|
[
-0.4802850187,
-0.8221501708,
0.670121789,
0.2298952192,
-0.067570515,
-0.2226096839,
0.191102773,
-0.5911698341,
0.6302493215,
0.4536760151,
-0.6409685612,
-0.2126642913,
-0.6060085893,
-0.0213891491,
-0.1927943826,
0.7233552337,
-0.0829855353,
-0.0148576796,
-0.3036113977,
-0.2840532064,
-0.997718513,
-0.3616324961,
-0.9338490367,
-0.0896119103,
0.8796604276,
0.5402039289,
0.4686795771,
0.0823500976,
0.4492297173,
0.2288664132,
0.1973842084,
0.5255615711,
-0.4274407625,
0.0086538317,
0.0200919006,
-0.2316814512,
-0.7275599241,
0.297852397,
0.3974821866,
0.5865537524,
0.0168780163,
-0.0223472286,
0.2091034949,
0.292783618,
-0.9746066332,
-0.0089078527,
-0.485225141,
-0.0691251159,
-0.2408936769,
-0.3593637049,
-0.7032356262,
-0.1726276577,
0.2622626126,
-0.8202192783,
0.0835259333,
0.2072010487,
0.7045116425,
0.3484822214,
-0.4255760014,
-0.3784776926,
-0.8283890486,
0.5872797966,
-0.1653949171,
0.3691234291,
0.4027986526,
0.2624135315,
-0.3180164397,
-0.6291735768,
-0.4780911803,
0.0169967934,
-0.072151266,
0.2746418417,
-0.0954207629,
-0.0401707329,
0.0806649625,
-0.1044075191,
-0.4234076738,
-0.2337193787,
-0.3353357911,
-0.295121938,
0.381537348,
0.1225565821,
0.5210257173,
0.4469534457,
-1.0154759884,
-0.0900170282,
-0.5338538289,
0.3208926916,
0.100131005,
0.4126304388,
-0.2853022516,
0.7232280374,
0.1339563727,
0.9521334767,
0.2705748379,
0.0786751136,
-0.0017772731,
-0.6757857203,
-0.3257165551,
0.1772267967,
0.7057986259,
0.1017161906,
-0.2229606807,
-0.1571333557,
0.2120603174,
0.3041404486,
0.4164945781,
-0.1671612859,
0.0908055976,
0.3780075908,
-0.3713552058,
-0.0884804726,
-0.0735873133,
-0.3571667075,
-0.1910863966,
-0.3122739196,
0.6897765398,
-0.3813283145,
-0.1212769449,
0.5310320854,
-0.1810236871,
-0.0047362801,
0.6088299155,
-0.6750104427,
0.2806940675,
0.8040305376,
0.7219988704,
-0.2353411764,
-0.6866033673,
-0.6337147951,
0.6360917687,
-0.1138204634,
1.0710892677,
-0.8143540621,
-0.1775939018,
-0.1773141772,
-0.2827700377,
-0.5533233285,
0.0273409951,
0.6745431423,
-0.5988396406,
0.2251256555,
-0.3651053607,
-0.5241336226,
-0.2475764453,
0.3542245328,
-1.0034041405,
0.9764902592,
-0.1835078448,
-0.7284733653,
0.5074712038,
-0.8558909893,
-0.3536036909,
0.073872976,
-0.0820676908,
-0.3759888113,
-0.0782768354,
0.1424967349,
0.2350821495,
-0.0734202713,
0.4293735325,
-0.8552700281,
-0.4164686203,
0.5444305539,
-0.6219805479,
0.707670927,
0.0104091726,
0.2111900449,
0.2806012332,
-0.2865571976,
-0.3399148583,
-0.2487363517,
-0.1413972974,
-0.5648182631,
-0.2145539671,
-0.2534516752,
0.4342244565,
0.328807354,
-0.4396241605,
0.1567477435,
0.0849944651,
-0.0614674874,
0.5261623859,
0.0099581266,
0.4561828971,
-0.325399369,
0.3224436045,
0.3118374646,
0.6526055932,
0.0746793374,
-1.0530079603,
-0.4870480895,
-0.2040726095,
0.248226583,
0.3010445833,
-0.508318603,
0.5142062306,
-0.0477971174,
-0.3101687133,
-0.4411872625,
-0.3713168204,
0.0926527753,
0.2513661683,
0.287191987,
-0.9063845873,
-0.0901114941,
-0.45742926,
-0.2802359164,
0.1347536594,
0.4148958623,
0.6686852574,
0.0029470772,
-0.0183315352,
0.8564514518,
-0.4681168795,
-0.7250868678,
-0.2472240329,
0.182557106,
0.0833083615,
0.2941786349,
0.5500198007,
-0.7205079198,
-0.5342878103,
-0.2795706391,
-0.3770215213,
0.2287502289,
-0.2580119073,
-0.477206558,
-0.3021608889,
0.2429207116,
-0.8408870101,
0.8335715532,
0.4183903039,
-0.3743164241,
0.342027545,
-0.1493881494,
0.2434261441,
-0.8645222187,
-0.0589472577,
-0.0679985806,
0.0064507774,
-0.8551076055,
-0.5522623062,
0.0812428519,
-0.2019553483,
-0.642054975,
0.4446336925,
-0.4085647166,
-0.3883570135,
-0.2333488762,
0.1746854186,
0.2628361881,
0.6466628909,
-0.0683573112,
0.6168388128,
0.6707456112,
-0.9235873818,
0.0668648034,
0.1790229231,
-0.1719980836,
0.5002353191,
-0.3274360895,
0.0321724415,
-0.1000581309,
0.6857938766,
-1.4858320951,
-0.3734461069,
0.7393234968,
-0.4483919144,
0.4268673062,
-0.1775080562,
-0.1793517023,
-0.3760919571,
-0.2264129817,
0.6677247286,
-0.5419420004,
-0.4552963078,
0.9946178794,
0.7813378572,
0.0079842918,
-1.0262169838,
-0.4531391859,
-0.2784551978,
-0.0919722021,
-0.773969233,
0.3963033259,
0.0556667522,
0.5674297214,
0.2077870369,
-0.0612655282,
-0.2486351579,
0.0195390936,
0.1629507542,
0.5411823988,
-0.0639864132,
0.2567656934,
0.1125826538,
-0.3088165522,
-0.286441803,
-0.215974912,
0.8669145107,
0.255220741,
-0.6698825955,
-0.7812966704,
0.430207938,
0.704369247,
-0.3781237602,
0.6952033639,
0.8084595799,
-0.4201794863,
0.1761196405,
-0.479202956,
-0.2222880721,
-0.4520485103,
-0.2309290022,
-0.6587722301,
-0.7457182407,
0.5202496052,
-0.0847303867,
0.0997516587,
0.0802343786,
0.3447240591,
-0.1120850518,
0.9217533469,
0.5014668107,
-0.1468479931,
0.7171926498,
-0.001821104,
0.5246385932,
-1.0759100914,
-0.2478313446,
-0.4856142402,
-0.5581261516,
-0.137595281,
-0.73991853,
0.6029759645,
-0.1357560009,
0.2188209891,
0.4159525633,
-0.4592334926,
0.490167141,
0.6537120342,
0.1812156588,
0.2949423492,
0.0242686383,
-0.2410100251,
0.258002162,
-0.8106337786,
-0.209853366,
1.3118338585,
0.1860781163,
0.9483193159,
0.2030403316,
0.5793048143,
0.073132664,
0.2399707437,
-0.5157755613,
0.2725795805,
-0.1067032367,
-0.8286826611,
-0.4122523367,
-0.1087903976,
-1.1112391949,
0.5974274278,
-0.1072192565,
-0.9029475451,
0.6936509013,
0.2400910109,
-0.7559578419,
0.3189719319,
-0.7617647648,
1.0582381487,
-0.1586374342,
-0.6080803275,
-0.2182302475,
-0.61729002,
0.5992604494,
0.2998265028,
0.0014001594,
-0.3318398595,
0.0647148788,
0.4765875638,
0.0018808325,
1.1046341658,
-0.0301373862,
-0.0819346383,
0.6350269318,
-0.1582014263,
0.7296161652,
0.0729780719,
0.3042003214,
-0.1040172428,
-0.4196327031,
-0.2003434449,
-0.2034025788,
0.7900612354,
-0.6210520267,
-0.0233873352,
-0.5313038826,
-0.8607729673,
-0.0697769672,
0.2526941895,
0.1603476405,
0.5346688628,
-0.1597256362,
-0.2592302859,
0.7205379605,
-0.0012264984,
0.2062039375,
0.1669349819,
-0.0074481168,
-0.0898399875,
0.7962588072,
-0.0932567641,
0.2156778872,
0.2876604795,
-0.0418720432,
-0.7230718136,
-0.1354532242,
-0.4901416004,
0.2747214735,
-0.2945550084,
-0.0892556682,
-1.0320911407,
0.0349708907,
-0.6140768528,
-0.000851649,
-0.5637280345,
-0.4382916987,
-0.4231981635,
0.303822875,
-0.0248880405,
0.5597885847,
-0.1511791348,
0.3525691926,
-0.6674724221,
0.4701166153,
0.3926143944,
0.4999417067,
0.0269185826,
0.0358261988,
0.0881559923,
0.0429532379,
-0.50022614,
-1.0713367462,
0.0491458252,
-0.2005952448,
0.6088197231,
0.4606318474,
-0.1237597764,
0.8848671317,
-0.0719446987,
0.2913438678,
0.4002741575,
-0.6005359292,
0.2806838751,
-0.0876791775,
0.0314967483,
0.7052460909,
0.3704069853,
-0.5401537418,
-0.4462577105,
-0.7159338593,
-0.5978367925,
1.3534840345,
0.2001188099,
-0.3840503097,
0.3120662272,
-0.044074025,
0.0149587477,
0.0354831219,
-0.8039194942,
-0.227399826,
0.2176985592,
-0.1543057561,
0.2143988609,
-0.2108660191,
-0.2298655212,
0.0573327616,
0.5186601281,
0.1274331659,
0.4117187858,
0.1765369326,
0.0237137564,
-0.222771436,
0.2561151087,
0.5832479,
0.3415307999,
-0.3007820249,
0.0377159379,
-0.1895027161,
-0.5799107552,
0.0056888377,
0.080931522,
-0.3571544886,
0.0016776489,
-0.1967474818,
0.7965556383,
0.2664734125,
-0.0383009128,
0.6604525447,
-0.5290886164,
0.2243309319,
-0.2230449319,
0.1444902867,
0.0756711662,
-0.0256648287,
-0.0790093318,
0.6734303236,
0.60055691,
-0.3889908791,
0.3335030377,
0.4692392349,
-0.7380734682,
-0.1086862609,
0.4135240018,
0.3288556635,
0.0009400439,
0.1932136714,
-0.3862787187,
-0.3255815506,
0.6941730976,
0.6425212026,
0.6285050511,
-0.4562354684,
0.3213525414,
0.5085568428,
0.327414304,
-0.0334621705,
0.3869140446,
-0.259729892,
-0.9309207201,
-0.3551100194,
-0.1248094887,
-0.4765203297,
0.1765355766,
-0.5964140296,
0.5312671661,
-0.1272988021,
-0.4766935706,
0.367659837,
-0.1827608943,
-0.7688680887,
-0.0390962288,
0.1375505179,
0.6086976528,
-1.0376448631,
0.7969682813,
0.6401675344,
-0.1334231347,
-0.8691447973,
-0.183262527,
0.0357490927,
-0.5391677618,
-0.0503846481,
0.4417104721,
-0.3785510659,
-0.1153000742,
-0.3844625652,
-1.3021706343,
0.9364310503,
-0.2924233675,
-0.4529186785,
0.0931588113,
-0.0109543512,
0.0537360758,
-0.6743700504,
0.3644352853,
0.3406246901,
0.5004301667,
0.3718360662,
-0.6835760474,
-0.044435937,
0.240357399,
-0.4626405537,
0.3198508322,
-0.7458714247,
0.9876170754,
-0.2553369701,
-0.549710393,
-0.308740288,
0.5234803557,
0.6843978167,
0.8438791633,
0.6831276417,
0.6709020138,
0.8475621343,
-0.0914310515,
0.8656480312,
-0.234902069,
0.2589540184,
1.3941102028,
-0.744056046,
0.5338336229,
0.4222499132,
-0.1334856898,
0.2718398273,
0.5505381823,
0.3842429519,
0.7331645489,
-0.3359453976,
-0.3645291626,
-0.3814080954,
-0.4432303309,
-0.4238092005,
0.3657723665,
0.9434865117,
0.1082609072,
-0.257689476,
-0.0810996592,
-0.3547792435,
-0.5465543866,
-0.0171974767,
0.7002470493,
-0.1380009949,
-1.047252655,
-0.0265376773,
-0.140744105,
0.5492850542,
-0.4746290743,
-0.0400692075,
0.0253478661,
0.1280859411,
0.0353493392,
-0.8520452976,
0.1830834001,
-0.3968056142,
0.0956664458,
0.1460038126,
1.277987957,
-0.7315098047,
-0.2169118524,
0.3162839711,
0.3156569302,
0.2227913588,
0.1443064511,
-0.803445816,
0.2371734232,
0.00898722,
0.3661447167,
0.149274081,
0.478340745,
-0.1282276362,
0.573682189,
0.9026810527,
-0.1115415618,
0.5118616819,
0.4637900591,
0.7405087352,
-0.3067541122,
-0.7744411826,
-0.473530978,
0.2782292962,
-0.3406865299,
-0.3680828214,
0.3194673359,
0.6762176752,
0.7765038013,
0.0090560969,
0.5875931978,
0.0245049521,
0.3469597101,
-0.257687211,
0.3274111748,
-0.5839967132,
0.266759187,
-0.174974665,
-0.8090356588,
-0.1977993399,
0.370066762,
-0.1607109308,
-0.0979665965,
0.6176367998,
0.6550418139,
-0.7353277802,
0.1604662538,
0.1702106446,
-0.1703869551,
0.2380703241,
1.0596586466,
1.0627281666,
-0.6362137794,
0.6111274958,
-0.2780807018,
-0.3402827978,
-0.6612405777,
-0.3003135324,
-0.7078614235,
-0.4534442723,
-0.2487325668,
-0.083348237,
-0.4296336472,
0.328741461,
0.7388265729,
-0.6158109903,
-0.1871787012,
0.0730314106,
0.6024042368,
-0.3969587684,
-0.2162653953,
0.4233689308,
-0.4328421354,
-0.6494967937,
0.360745132,
0.7223136425,
0.2651173174,
-0.0195219684,
0.017379323,
-0.7872353792,
0.2464576811,
0.4547984898,
0.0881354809,
-0.5920662284,
-0.243881911,
-0.1397091746,
-0.5005688071,
0.1107907966,
0.9968246818,
-0.4123646617,
0.6068033576,
0.5676314235,
0.3113841414,
0.743690908,
0.162415877,
0.2880449295,
-0.8105804324,
0.2361447513,
0.0577584431,
0.3329560459,
0.1113360971,
-0.5028107166,
0.5414222479,
-0.0396231003,
-0.3596271276,
-0.6079976559,
0.4177946448,
-1.5265316963,
-0.1669411063,
0.6418540478,
0.0384685174,
-0.5177127719,
-0.7459182739,
-0.1943395436,
0.4607676268,
-0.6131823063,
0.7194836736,
0.62871176,
-0.4731603861,
0.2620274723,
-0.305374831,
0.3706650734,
0.6029060483,
-0.7732719779,
0.005362784,
0.5508492589,
-0.0515335239,
0.5898290277,
1.1511907578,
-0.0372485667,
0.6575697064,
0.0295458268,
-0.0144859059,
0.1621273756,
-1.0407099724,
0.1296358109,
0.277900964,
-0.2796555758,
-0.6285175681
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05720v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05720v4
|
Beyond Gradient and Priors in Privacy Attacks: Leveraging Pooler Layer Inputs of Language Models in Federated Learning
| 2023-12-10T01:19:59 | 2024-03-15T18:23:05 |
Jianwei Li, Sheng Liu, Qi Lei
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Language models trained via federated learning (FL) demonstrate impressive
capabilities in handling complex tasks while protecting user privacy. Recent
studies indicate that leveraging gradient information and prior knowledge can
potentially reveal training samples within FL setting. However, these
investigations have overlooked the potential privacy risks tied to the
intrinsic architecture of the models. This paper presents a two-stage privacy
attack strategy that targets the vulnerabilities in the architecture of
contemporary language models, significantly enhancing attack performance by
initially recovering certain feature directions as additional supervisory
signals. Our comparative experiments demonstrate superior attack performance
across various datasets and scenarios, highlighting the privacy leakage risk
associated with the increasingly complex architectures of language models. We
call for the community to recognize and address these potential privacy risks
in designing large language models.
|
[
-0.3019486666,
-0.7721722126,
0.106070742,
0.1654993743,
0.2277011275,
0.0239125695,
0.0067729848,
-0.6237582564,
-0.2843432426,
0.7301633954,
-0.4561703801,
-0.2632752657,
-0.5220031738,
-0.4951675832,
-0.398064822,
1.0100345612,
0.2877995372,
0.1438976675,
-0.064306356,
0.036352206,
-0.0839553326,
-0.7002769113,
-0.7084383965,
-0.2289093733,
0.6187069416,
0.052102752,
0.6326665282,
0.3513042927,
0.5108587146,
0.3257267475,
0.2048663497,
-0.3486400843,
-0.5816210508,
0.3187858462,
-0.2885016799,
-0.6781693101,
-0.4721835852,
0.1870824099,
0.708593905,
0.7343732119,
-0.1768737584,
0.2025850564,
0.0641127899,
0.8111401796,
-0.9723607898,
0.270730406,
-0.4339103401,
0.2977823019,
-0.368773371,
-0.0496805385,
-0.6084638834,
-0.0584351048,
0.273026973,
-0.1051627323,
0.1659201235,
-0.089937374,
0.5346007943,
-0.1240375564,
-0.1593711674,
0.1239818633,
-0.8166760206,
0.639285028,
-0.2381245643,
0.5310959816,
0.4539286196,
0.5270646214,
-0.1125102416,
-0.8313913941,
-0.1841246188,
-0.105615899,
-0.3296738565,
-0.3174764812,
-0.4314085245,
0.1465002298,
0.3467841148,
0.4143094122,
-0.5117099881,
0.3651816249,
-0.2348055243,
-0.177855283,
0.7158479691,
-0.0282534752,
0.1577535868,
0.2931856215,
-0.6470782161,
-0.3801700473,
-0.6912202239,
0.3887036741,
0.5529360771,
0.3334857821,
-0.2480493933,
0.1348512769,
-0.1691660434,
0.642973125,
0.2621581852,
0.0463745482,
0.099703759,
-0.1088085473,
-0.3049867153,
-0.3068368435,
0.6458598375,
-0.1583984941,
0.0251872074,
-0.4201825559,
-0.5499252677,
-0.300889343,
0.2767680585,
-0.7677378058,
-0.4098742604,
0.3997614086,
-0.2603672743,
-0.4857075512,
0.3981319368,
-1.1174366474,
-0.6288181543,
0.124124147,
0.0790345073,
-0.0617337748,
-0.5988491774,
-0.0572205037,
-0.07769043,
0.2789393365,
0.0825051442,
-1.1339259148,
0.7052225471,
1.1719139814,
0.5930503607,
0.3189641237,
-0.301346302,
-0.9844429493,
0.1736785769,
-0.1203446239,
0.3486291766,
-0.6197525263,
-0.4116254449,
0.3230273128,
-0.3847816885,
-0.1951165348,
-0.0776300356,
0.076124534,
-0.9150473475,
0.5234591961,
-0.1652562916,
-0.5560760498,
-0.1034129709,
0.2598553896,
-0.7205281258,
0.6238925457,
0.2100042999,
-0.9736195207,
-0.0339086652,
-0.6858745217,
-0.5474267602,
-0.0161381066,
-0.2370438278,
-0.2366349101,
0.2438285947,
0.12260589,
0.7430545092,
0.0441718102,
0.0513735935,
-0.3217941225,
0.0163643975,
0.3648552001,
-0.1579191089,
0.9646892548,
0.2079330981,
-0.452993691,
0.0968899727,
-0.7676303387,
-0.1528575569,
0.1535208374,
-0.1496466994,
-0.4812196493,
-0.0826936513,
-0.130023703,
0.2538658082,
0.3684435487,
-0.5069007874,
-0.2536315024,
-0.5739722252,
0.3735178411,
0.8418682814,
-0.0308429394,
1.0095698833,
-0.2211501151,
0.6715054512,
-0.076710321,
0.4500900209,
-0.166316539,
-0.2346866876,
-0.4852719903,
-0.3392991722,
0.185178861,
0.5568170547,
-0.4760157764,
0.3317498565,
-0.1381091326,
-0.544170022,
-0.140721336,
-0.0193534065,
0.6677027941,
0.5956332088,
0.0944881141,
-0.3160326779,
-0.3100961745,
-0.6957505941,
-0.3617146909,
-0.1494790912,
-0.2388626188,
0.316526562,
0.2344159037,
-0.1435812116,
0.7143778205,
-0.6016619205,
-0.3098419607,
-0.1167709008,
-0.0188914053,
-0.2527809441,
0.8496503234,
0.6990157366,
-0.8348923326,
-0.2724300325,
0.085353896,
-0.6410341263,
0.2594510913,
-0.0328084379,
-0.216547519,
-0.0181778893,
0.447171092,
-0.4539818168,
0.1320982426,
0.4813752174,
-0.1669026166,
0.1701208949,
0.0705576465,
-0.3086326122,
-0.7654469013,
0.0446708165,
0.0662688762,
-0.340233922,
-1.1171845198,
0.6869112849,
0.0118221426,
-0.3072346449,
-0.3110067844,
0.5973460078,
-0.5327364802,
-0.1368410885,
-0.1042229086,
-0.2945782542,
-0.1000133157,
0.5328876972,
-0.0611158796,
0.4540172517,
0.892403841,
-0.271191746,
0.1203068644,
-0.0648674741,
-0.1257450581,
0.5579828024,
-0.4189344645,
0.5220980644,
-0.130792737,
0.3843505383,
-0.9370031953,
-0.3203638792,
0.3628641665,
-0.4749361575,
0.8155884147,
0.0673358962,
-0.2516758442,
-0.1466545314,
-0.6231489778,
0.1493296921,
0.3635469079,
-0.5321006179,
0.8349214792,
0.7121068835,
-0.1195089072,
-0.9839212298,
-0.7840322852,
-0.0544787459,
-0.1804009229,
-0.7469950318,
0.0315828361,
0.3485860825,
-0.3576099277,
-0.347923398,
-0.0213444475,
-0.4280376434,
0.6359360814,
0.4113129973,
-0.0594269074,
-0.2892338336,
-0.2996000648,
-0.0966223702,
-0.2379887104,
0.3907278478,
-0.591855824,
0.7477492094,
-0.0976879299,
-0.1226178184,
-0.63101542,
0.6017939448,
0.3575478792,
-0.648727417,
0.9489902854,
0.7122920156,
-0.5741304159,
-0.3501493633,
-0.6167666912,
-0.4850358367,
-0.5447227955,
0.3928761482,
-0.1718437076,
-1.0905970335,
0.6209810376,
0.0707004294,
0.5205205083,
0.0153129846,
0.3958032131,
-0.0037255483,
0.6670823693,
0.9336566925,
-0.3879159987,
0.9518240094,
-0.2249567062,
0.3530799448,
-0.5169433951,
-0.2725163102,
-0.5625196695,
-0.1153322235,
-0.5373449326,
-0.2944147885,
0.0209221728,
-0.0123278257,
-0.1988337934,
0.112553969,
0.0146872597,
0.4571127892,
0.5169606805,
0.2355769128,
0.0575744398,
0.2111790329,
0.0472252071,
0.3428061604,
-0.5744347572,
-0.1844900995,
1.1189340353,
0.7841030359,
0.7324732542,
0.1694260985,
0.846436739,
0.1345053911,
0.3826245964,
-0.2113992721,
0.3555366099,
0.0520104915,
-0.7184790969,
-0.2545474768,
-0.4216011167,
-0.6329702139,
0.5855456591,
-0.1181021631,
-0.8358693719,
0.515602231,
0.1607086957,
-0.4617559612,
0.143287465,
-0.5964027643,
0.7673708797,
0.0175019782,
-0.5664384961,
-0.1905572712,
-1.0991299152,
0.6209746003,
-0.0505749434,
0.3871458173,
0.347954303,
0.0951572359,
0.5052381754,
-0.3173238933,
1.0784109831,
-0.4960848689,
-0.1125211343,
-0.1650525182,
0.1048735902,
0.6074435711,
0.1660075933,
-0.0008951082,
0.2313731611,
-0.3429825902,
-0.5741937757,
-0.5762550831,
0.6898878813,
-0.5651637316,
-0.7471616268,
-0.330416739,
-0.3292724192,
-0.3884857595,
0.1144237816,
0.0845497996,
0.5253629684,
-0.3429108262,
0.0622231662,
0.7933210731,
0.0525285862,
0.4800805449,
0.5414425135,
-0.1066651866,
-0.3142703176,
0.7140408158,
-0.2325012684,
0.5121935606,
0.688561976,
0.2077077627,
-0.322943747,
-0.5571360588,
-0.0324257985,
0.1304820478,
-0.5616195798,
-0.2022039592,
-0.7313628793,
-0.2243292481,
-0.5650781989,
-0.0854568258,
-0.3649459779,
-0.4719216824,
-0.280275017,
-0.4608434439,
0.1128648669,
0.4677677453,
-0.2737576663,
0.4622590542,
-0.7406415343,
-0.1592504978,
0.3980584443,
0.3021285534,
0.4082634747,
0.0413531996,
-0.1109097824,
0.0159965456,
-0.1273737401,
-0.7231445909,
0.1452502161,
0.2651333511,
0.5745027065,
0.7029469609,
-0.1827756017,
0.260774225,
-0.6417892575,
0.6674208045,
0.1380023509,
-0.7205151916,
0.4216125309,
-0.2383596152,
-0.0789507031,
0.6549019814,
0.3585684299,
-0.2096800059,
-0.4606268108,
-0.835508287,
-0.5752407312,
0.6936985254,
0.1594291776,
0.3671329618,
0.3053084612,
0.2942274809,
0.033590652,
0.4164885581,
-0.7309746146,
-0.3050531447,
-0.1536863893,
0.1446593404,
0.0403293893,
-0.2453770638,
-0.4638384879,
-0.0708567947,
0.3486540914,
0.2264245301,
-0.0056334399,
-0.1270114928,
-0.1145147085,
-0.1307965368,
0.072964929,
0.4490901232,
0.4326787293,
0.1633606553,
0.1097122803,
-0.2833530903,
-0.5151023865,
-0.0675609857,
0.4736276865,
-0.2233085632,
-0.4027647376,
0.5670830607,
0.7040868998,
0.3906087875,
-0.3408024311,
0.8225275278,
-0.148126021,
0.0311477333,
-0.2261963934,
0.3239712417,
-0.1691478193,
0.3750481009,
0.2908213139,
0.1863776743,
0.093551293,
-0.4217140377,
0.4899115264,
0.5629386902,
-0.5387173891,
-0.4941335618,
0.6121848822,
0.2675273418,
-0.2489824891,
0.2750926912,
0.2452699095,
-0.5248957276,
0.2667874992,
0.3092651665,
0.8771528006,
-0.8455585837,
0.2149832845,
-0.0502574816,
0.2366272211,
-0.1922252625,
0.0498568527,
-0.4371770322,
-0.5978498459,
0.1854061037,
-0.6074330211,
-0.1664037257,
-0.0207492933,
-0.9880401492,
-0.2430193573,
-1.1464586258,
0.0540527962,
-0.0723647401,
-0.1221028641,
-0.4813211858,
-0.0885818452,
0.2277985662,
0.7835865617,
-0.8543189168,
0.8462171555,
0.3719104528,
-0.3125315309,
-0.6163982749,
-0.1053984016,
0.0306296274,
-0.6339291334,
0.4840649962,
0.0851954222,
0.029297879,
-0.1416848153,
-0.3509891331,
-0.6250982285,
0.8744271398,
0.3779104054,
-0.6957755089,
-0.0545003787,
0.272046864,
0.6167371273,
-0.389695853,
-0.2816385031,
0.6922774911,
0.1757765263,
-0.1250510365,
-0.4800716043,
-0.033114925,
-0.0272296537,
-0.07461413,
0.1180999428,
-0.5293909907,
1.2149349451,
-0.0047675525,
-0.3706875443,
-0.1590724438,
1.0687237978,
-0.0321708173,
0.1600341797,
0.4795435667,
0.3097065687,
1.0719035864,
0.2308381051,
1.2431215048,
-0.1914754361,
0.3354226053,
1.2130819559,
-0.4566236138,
0.8983486891,
0.2510307729,
-0.094587855,
0.3546381593,
0.4318876863,
0.2129856199,
0.847717464,
0.2560662925,
-0.4412791431,
0.0999460816,
0.1071659476,
-0.464621067,
0.319817394,
0.3957306743,
-0.5478473306,
-0.3857975304,
0.1719488651,
0.4792226255,
0.3110010326,
-0.3397805095,
0.8351445794,
0.1945701391,
-0.3094950616,
0.2208410203,
0.1436751336,
0.4693194032,
-0.6902244091,
0.170946002,
-0.3075168729,
0.2971047163,
-0.2216611058,
-0.2484460175,
0.128669858,
0.086808674,
-0.0604783036,
-0.2661001682,
0.5221945643,
-0.4042087197,
-0.4747911096,
0.3796136677,
0.2899283171,
-0.4245522618,
-0.1196552217,
-0.6009415388,
-0.1424423754,
-0.2159084529,
-0.2931943238,
0.7818758488,
0.1139910668,
0.1077069193,
0.470066905,
0.5211911201,
-0.0285408907,
0.1878107935,
0.1178528965,
1.0326766968,
-0.1808190197,
-0.8403078914,
-0.936123848,
0.3974605799,
-0.2936513424,
-0.093497552,
0.8376694322,
0.3821511567,
1.052562356,
0.0233358834,
0.5591030717,
0.3183320761,
0.3439058065,
-0.612259686,
0.9034287333,
-0.0314732678,
0.4722170234,
-0.3110596538,
-0.5878741145,
-0.5328533053,
0.6030184031,
-0.3877129853,
-0.116128929,
0.5282963514,
0.8676364422,
0.0605263971,
0.4552643299,
0.0379328094,
0.3914372027,
0.6603078842,
0.5624710917,
0.7532974482,
-0.2736634612,
-0.2207259685,
-0.6193317771,
-0.5121459961,
0.0962858275,
-0.6367402077,
-1.2612681389,
-0.4638543427,
-0.1693455577,
-0.184701845,
0.1322815865,
0.3696082234,
0.6895051003,
-0.9143049121,
-0.1445073038,
-0.0769143254,
0.1178025082,
-0.2175973952,
-0.2331097722,
0.282130152,
-0.165784359,
-0.4332970083,
0.4478622675,
0.1439568102,
-0.0854815245,
-0.817473352,
0.2314076871,
-0.1757175028,
-0.0989648923,
0.3518033028,
0.4410802126,
-0.474638164,
-0.3178863823,
-0.2587271929,
-0.2320302725,
-0.1233855411,
1.028914094,
-0.5811752677,
0.1687207371,
0.4979460537,
0.9438768029,
0.281032294,
0.1231724992,
0.7332641482,
-1.0907299519,
0.5420973301,
0.4243892133,
0.3074160516,
0.44249928,
-0.908125639,
0.2672576606,
-0.0411756597,
-0.1595112383,
-0.9950144291,
0.2791278362,
-0.6518714428,
-0.3460890651,
0.7345876098,
-0.7009122968,
-0.3753436208,
-0.0570943058,
0.3231756985,
-0.342243284,
-0.3240151405,
0.6696606874,
0.5155615211,
0.2340207249,
0.0473155975,
-0.4543519616,
0.7348939776,
-0.0220824871,
-0.5682628155,
0.3014981747,
0.4569837451,
0.2199965417,
0.0506749712,
0.6099524498,
-0.3431800008,
0.3582591712,
0.0637618676,
-0.6018721461,
-0.2068656832,
-0.6457518935,
-0.8150538206,
0.73055619,
-0.2279785126,
-0.2343771756
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.11502v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.11502v1
|
Labrador: Exploring the Limits of Masked Language Modeling for Laboratory Data
| 2023-12-09T23:43:35 | 2023-12-09T23:43:35 |
David R. Bellamy, Bhawesh Kumar, Cindy Wang, Andrew Beam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this work we introduce Labrador, a pre-trained Transformer model for
laboratory data. Labrador and BERT were pre-trained on a corpus of 100 million
lab test results from electronic health records (EHRs) and evaluated on various
downstream outcome prediction tasks. Both models demonstrate mastery of the
pre-training task but neither consistently outperform XGBoost on downstream
supervised tasks. Our ablation studies reveal that transfer learning shows
limited effectiveness for BERT and achieves marginal success with Labrador. We
explore the reasons for the failure of transfer learning and suggest that the
data generating process underlying each patient cannot be characterized
sufficiently using labs alone, among other factors. We encourage future work to
focus on joint modeling of multiple EHR data categories and to include
tree-based baselines in their evaluations.
|
[
-0.163167119,
-0.4863903224,
0.6971418262,
-0.0001655103,
-0.2168844193,
0.2712711394,
0.2568090856,
-0.4820935428,
0.0093886917,
0.9662920833,
-0.4663638771,
-0.3971380293,
-0.724630475,
-0.1518836915,
-0.7120939493,
1.1815021038,
0.1247052699,
0.0867865831,
0.1627313048,
-0.0326405875,
-0.3739824593,
-0.7659492493,
-0.690141201,
-0.5927774906,
0.3859788775,
0.1247447729,
0.7010178566,
0.4717794061,
0.2236347646,
0.1257980317,
0.3600808382,
-0.2333378494,
-0.6397888064,
-0.2347697765,
0.0508997701,
-0.336079061,
-0.4183788002,
-0.1285846084,
0.531907022,
0.8786443472,
-0.0413310155,
-0.1123445854,
-0.3591257036,
0.6890952587,
-0.4537950158,
0.0423777699,
-0.7036745548,
0.2826833427,
-0.0151249673,
0.1297201663,
-0.6698688269,
-0.2992065847,
0.5769601464,
-0.2858070433,
0.6571056247,
0.1578901857,
0.8699553013,
0.1632974297,
-0.5543112755,
-0.1304000765,
-0.8477350473,
0.6155455709,
-0.324667424,
0.7886314392,
0.5843095779,
0.4292738736,
0.1141984388,
-1.134521842,
-0.4228351414,
-0.3455972672,
-0.4355433285,
0.2701415122,
-0.3888548911,
0.0739023611,
0.0297207776,
0.2525029778,
-0.663934052,
-0.0333282538,
-0.8475054502,
-0.1733598858,
0.5374586582,
0.0725753382,
0.0901020616,
0.2205300033,
-0.3945161104,
-0.5090343952,
-0.4609951675,
0.0209635794,
-0.1877784282,
0.179813832,
-0.0046064076,
0.2041364312,
0.1124329045,
0.5136147141,
0.0679044649,
0.2500547767,
0.4563966691,
0.3101702034,
-0.6430609226,
0.2534986436,
0.7855062485,
-0.0577899031,
-0.220481202,
-0.4799276888,
-0.1568126082,
-0.1737690419,
0.6022266746,
-0.5577594638,
-0.7861164808,
0.3635467291,
-0.4343296289,
-0.0795864537,
-0.0436451398,
-0.6370357871,
-0.5277697444,
-0.2183376998,
0.6820714474,
-0.5613111854,
-0.1882236153,
0.0819849223,
0.0284074321,
0.2450850755,
0.2546786666,
-0.8416155577,
0.9127315879,
0.3661459684,
0.532192111,
-0.1948089451,
-0.2174889147,
-0.65939641,
-0.1694290787,
-0.2988169789,
0.3598355055,
-0.1567886025,
-0.5456389785,
0.0754185915,
0.3577373922,
-0.1550563723,
-0.6795549393,
0.4947145283,
-0.6787605882,
-0.1396615207,
0.0137468604,
-0.3740289509,
0.0680698603,
-0.1295813471,
-0.973482728,
0.954113543,
0.6124532223,
-0.4809233248,
0.2999082804,
-0.5793325901,
-0.6537527442,
0.2459752262,
-0.1643459201,
-0.7198222876,
0.100552313,
0.0793576315,
0.5128440261,
-0.1901977956,
0.6301904917,
0.1553126425,
-0.0312510245,
0.4870970845,
0.0464187004,
0.9013695121,
0.1091018245,
-0.3054696321,
0.2882862091,
-0.9473596811,
-0.1501077563,
-0.108992666,
-0.0113837374,
-0.189196825,
-0.2192327082,
0.2826670408,
0.2760747373,
-0.3485969901,
-0.7197906971,
-0.3061099946,
0.05614141,
0.3429935873,
0.581616044,
-0.5239164829,
0.1807819605,
-0.7411727309,
0.3516391516,
-0.2027187347,
0.4454787374,
0.2635482252,
-0.402102679,
-0.651499331,
-0.430585742,
0.4986220598,
0.464525789,
-0.6731327772,
0.33844769,
-0.4575595856,
-0.542568028,
-0.9363743067,
-0.2494214773,
0.3667288721,
0.7542726398,
0.6919105053,
-0.4471982419,
-0.5203830004,
-1.2172044516,
0.3093120158,
-0.2137275934,
-0.3524103463,
0.2092594057,
0.358810544,
-0.537078321,
0.884688437,
-0.5037898421,
-0.4317273498,
-0.3987711072,
0.417003721,
0.0682346001,
0.6126716733,
0.3622424901,
-0.8347240686,
-0.5329079628,
0.0823063552,
-0.5291375518,
-0.0312186722,
-0.0063615926,
-0.3448965847,
-0.0742597058,
0.5807643533,
-0.2654578686,
0.4079353809,
0.7928601503,
0.1317516118,
0.5456669331,
-0.2939205468,
0.0392532237,
-0.590697825,
0.0534554869,
-0.203068018,
-0.4449186027,
-1.2985515594,
-0.2775578499,
0.3526058495,
-0.1496048272,
-0.7185064554,
0.8433277011,
-0.263063252,
0.250292927,
-0.1567069888,
-0.3933633268,
-0.0334698446,
0.199645102,
0.4705283046,
0.2857707143,
0.6390218735,
-0.4929050207,
0.3154139817,
0.5047618151,
-0.1494810581,
0.1256785542,
-0.7668446302,
0.1617731452,
-0.0172365978,
0.3285197914,
-0.6893344522,
-0.3114043772,
-0.0271249879,
-0.4429591298,
0.6491382718,
0.0710861608,
-0.5782299638,
-0.5174123049,
-0.3320622146,
0.3323272765,
1.2045782804,
-0.6150888205,
0.6460998654,
0.3009439409,
0.1284380406,
-0.4022632837,
-0.8359789252,
-0.3466039896,
-0.119576931,
-0.5007172823,
0.6223032475,
-0.0097532226,
0.0310313944,
0.1379985064,
0.0239403266,
-0.4525946379,
-0.0597945265,
0.2163206637,
0.4509886503,
-0.0994276479,
0.4795995355,
-0.0747483522,
0.1670475602,
0.3381568193,
-0.0553249307,
0.4208476543,
0.0022735402,
-0.307531476,
0.0006332273,
0.2554364204,
0.4669457376,
0.0188465118,
1.220911026,
0.6139671803,
-0.5810782313,
-0.0326407664,
-0.7257269025,
-0.2496295273,
-0.3750521541,
0.4369623959,
-0.2520425618,
-0.8686026931,
0.6412956119,
0.0031059759,
-0.1552187651,
0.4223210514,
0.3887270093,
-0.1232416928,
0.7745605111,
0.9442498088,
0.1534552723,
0.2381752431,
0.0432477295,
0.1752919853,
-1.1090453863,
-0.1930296719,
-0.3587552905,
0.2707000673,
-0.8310216665,
-0.104850173,
0.4835939705,
-0.162346974,
-0.4149194658,
0.174571842,
-0.4610655904,
0.1370183229,
0.6715079546,
0.709332943,
0.0043646232,
-0.1655241251,
0.0697724223,
0.0666401461,
-0.7147031426,
-0.3362234235,
1.3219065666,
0.5666013956,
0.6457776427,
0.0110283345,
0.5496987104,
0.2754301131,
0.9087445736,
-0.4345549643,
0.1205358729,
-0.4668205082,
-0.8820791245,
-0.5369133949,
-0.2569824755,
-1.4092974663,
0.1956066042,
-0.2979252636,
-0.9102287889,
0.0236545447,
-0.0385215692,
-0.2743899226,
0.315119952,
-0.5496456623,
0.8511007428,
-0.2715654373,
-0.4213306606,
0.45353508,
-1.2481039762,
0.6205969453,
-0.8226892352,
0.4017231464,
0.0695562884,
0.5422961116,
0.8357409239,
-0.4483728707,
0.8192206025,
0.2377346456,
0.2794258296,
-0.0832002982,
-0.0304020569,
0.221210286,
-0.2099186182,
-0.1050912067,
0.0068662451,
0.1297397763,
-0.6363790035,
-0.3731290996,
0.2837456465,
-0.9767960906,
-0.6082863808,
-0.4470148385,
-0.5812971592,
-0.4263287783,
0.1591821015,
0.4482876956,
0.306681931,
-0.1426348984,
0.1644796133,
0.9793679118,
-0.4460214972,
-0.1687971801,
0.6644619107,
-0.3053745627,
-0.2078386396,
0.7197025418,
-0.0270705353,
0.5427834392,
0.4377031624,
0.247097373,
-0.3597844243,
-0.5203811526,
-0.3488102853,
0.5667002201,
-0.8218911886,
0.1598981321,
-0.9296912551,
-0.9119900465,
-0.4720163643,
-0.3801122308,
-0.3214637041,
0.077182427,
-0.1663645059,
-0.1738584936,
0.2725180089,
0.7189622521,
-0.0936437845,
0.6150069237,
-1.2463089228,
0.2385680825,
0.5710719824,
0.3182924092,
-0.2398454547,
-0.587628901,
-0.2583845258,
-0.329349786,
-0.2168525457,
-1.1055389643,
0.8796668649,
-0.0144849615,
0.7245519757,
-0.1294531226,
0.4524225593,
0.2977594435,
-0.5240548253,
0.5837571621,
0.2511440217,
-1.0615170002,
0.6197240949,
-0.080646351,
0.1938302964,
0.6153738499,
0.5846195817,
-0.1148444861,
-0.4932230711,
-0.955078125,
-0.7693709731,
0.876928091,
0.4653809965,
0.1056473404,
0.2260411233,
-0.0118778525,
0.5372802615,
0.1879215688,
-0.8866836429,
-0.4962017238,
-0.0993662775,
-0.188334927,
-0.1720763743,
0.0414330699,
-0.273360908,
-0.2997470796,
0.7414424419,
0.0625845268,
0.3262255788,
0.4854871929,
-0.1938669533,
-0.1204170063,
0.4160178304,
0.4652171135,
0.5814495683,
-0.7820970416,
0.4212013483,
0.2339171469,
-0.6826224327,
0.1925662309,
0.5783396363,
0.1168680191,
0.1556421518,
0.4040632844,
0.9114694595,
-0.0499684773,
-0.7342776656,
0.3316393197,
-0.2726595998,
-0.4514774084,
-0.1651402414,
-0.3602662683,
-0.135461539,
0.0279362872,
0.482696265,
-0.2011072636,
0.1617988944,
-0.5778791904,
0.3586328924,
0.1957556754,
-0.863211453,
-0.3894255757,
0.8256523609,
-0.1013276055,
-0.0959850773,
0.9672489762,
-0.0989717543,
-0.6370657086,
0.7318072319,
0.6398541927,
0.7445597053,
-0.4363102615,
0.2121051103,
0.2199406773,
0.4423955381,
-0.0540775545,
-0.1010565832,
0.2518178225,
-0.6109448075,
-0.2116259485,
-0.5881624222,
-0.5419319868,
0.7428427339,
-0.8255473971,
0.3623510003,
-0.1406710148,
-0.164148435,
0.2669940293,
-0.3745915592,
-1.0357728004,
0.5824909806,
0.0556480289,
0.6476534605,
-1.3084999323,
1.1509741545,
0.6917179823,
-0.1538563818,
-0.7272903323,
-0.2905652821,
-0.2396004647,
-0.7387480736,
0.9876083732,
0.0630989596,
0.2040676773,
0.0058832667,
-0.2892333865,
-0.6531454325,
0.9395763278,
0.1767009199,
-0.3780235946,
0.2476039976,
0.2204524577,
0.7850801349,
-0.2493781894,
0.316419363,
0.7661309242,
0.0085484125,
0.2101321369,
-1.3686174154,
0.1943847984,
-0.1231977344,
-0.2168189585,
0.2670552433,
-0.3214603364,
1.2453565598,
0.0374475531,
-0.2744641602,
-0.3817683458,
0.2172699869,
0.2314480245,
0.5076677799,
0.2317258716,
0.3430632353,
0.6712529659,
-0.0566541329,
1.3196811676,
0.193541199,
0.251019001,
1.0504370928,
-0.554192543,
0.6762353778,
0.2007674128,
-0.4518941939,
0.2672605515,
0.5234561563,
0.1252208352,
0.7729170322,
0.5185135603,
-0.3197636306,
0.0028116342,
-0.1247964874,
-0.4851776958,
-0.0892770588,
0.4673704207,
-0.6162881851,
-0.0087786876,
0.3191528022,
-0.2503384352,
-0.2489469647,
-0.1470745951,
0.5750870109,
-0.0038313284,
-0.4246061444,
0.5999186039,
-0.367955029,
0.3124196827,
-0.4951266944,
-0.0297120288,
-0.0748508275,
0.0038924925,
-0.1493908465,
-0.5855969787,
0.4316324592,
-0.2884681523,
-0.0286443811,
-0.1308371127,
0.8105890751,
-0.2876192033,
-0.5232211947,
0.4469660521,
0.8605508208,
0.4072012901,
0.1772277206,
-0.3637443185,
0.101029329,
-0.1080091521,
0.1569320709,
0.5554449558,
0.3792706728,
-0.1643787473,
0.5941131115,
0.4764503241,
0.0906503573,
0.446339637,
0.1344586015,
0.9949938655,
-0.3997937441,
-0.1390132457,
-0.7032424808,
0.5373257995,
0.0842504799,
0.115582712,
0.1682196707,
0.5402753353,
0.7817443013,
-0.5096269846,
1.0807191133,
0.1505543888,
0.6497524381,
-0.5447241068,
0.6477801204,
-0.1671612263,
0.1258708388,
0.0689955726,
-0.6495757699,
-0.5082064867,
0.3196665347,
-0.2342556417,
-0.1046632752,
0.9703575969,
0.4844864309,
-0.210613668,
-0.0794909745,
0.7333653569,
0.0765963346,
0.4002816975,
0.7276999354,
0.8562187552,
-0.6288175583,
0.3251045942,
-0.551548183,
-0.4561031163,
-0.2221711576,
-0.6256812215,
-1.1192321777,
-0.6941548586,
-0.4939116538,
-0.3306719661,
0.1305351853,
0.6343445778,
1.1814087629,
-0.910024941,
-0.0748445168,
-0.1648109406,
-0.2199042737,
-0.0387758538,
-0.2153892964,
0.6874632239,
-0.1995420307,
-0.4262120128,
0.1394319981,
-0.1905521154,
0.346168071,
0.0594154075,
0.0797164813,
0.0523013249,
0.0378924012,
0.6253323555,
0.4394785762,
-0.7797571421,
-0.1436658949,
0.2940478921,
-0.2128180861,
0.1281989068,
0.5851288438,
-1.1142847538,
0.7352206707,
0.0283498205,
0.6795321107,
0.9862912297,
-0.0719721243,
0.4612820148,
-0.8427411318,
-0.3208453059,
0.3685711622,
0.0525510088,
0.3580305874,
-0.3012131453,
0.6330912113,
-0.3417092264,
-0.6704264283,
-0.8486337662,
-0.0011056017,
-0.9688130021,
-0.2228035778,
0.8117368817,
-0.1160898432,
-0.1362741292,
-0.5210151076,
-0.1210303232,
0.4965854585,
-0.227514863,
0.8359025717,
0.5715252161,
-0.7134157419,
-0.4352631271,
-1.0856158733,
0.5918585062,
0.3204668164,
-1.0380110741,
-0.1876572222,
0.1813552082,
0.2410838157,
0.3015083373,
0.9033796787,
-0.0132347625,
0.2332276702,
-0.0169943161,
0.1176776588,
0.2261556536,
-0.0965464413,
-0.3352126479,
0.0359624997,
0.0882583112,
-0.3373103142
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05693v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05693v1
|
Agile-Quant: Activation-Guided Quantization for Faster Inference of LLMs on the Edge
| 2023-12-09T22:12:52 | 2023-12-09T22:12:52 |
Xuan Shen, Peiyan Dong, Lei Lu, Zhenglun Kong, Zhengang Li, Ming Lin, Chao Wu, Yanzhi Wang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) stand out for their impressive performance in
intricate language modeling tasks. However, their demanding computational and
memory needs pose obstacles for broad use on edge devices. Quantization is then
introduced to boost LLMs' on-device efficiency. Recent works show that 8-bit or
lower weight quantization is feasible with minimal impact on end-to-end task
performance, while the activation is still not quantized. On the other hand,
mainstream commodity edge devices still struggle to execute these sub-8-bit
quantized networks effectively. In this paper, we propose Agile-Quant, an
activation-guided quantization framework for popular Large Language Models
(LLMs), and implement an end-to-end accelerator on multiple edge devices for
faster inference. Considering the hardware profiling and activation analysis,
we first introduce a basic activation quantization strategy to balance the
trade-off of task performance and real inference speed. Then we leverage the
activation-aware token pruning technique to reduce the outliers and the adverse
impact on attentivity. Ultimately, we utilize the SIMD-based 4-bit multiplier
and our efficient TRIP matrix multiplication to implement the accelerator for
LLMs on the edge. We apply our framework on different scales of LLMs including
LLaMA, OPT, and BLOOM with 4-bit or 8-bit for the activation and 4-bit for the
weight quantization. Experiments show that Agile-Quant achieves simultaneous
quantization of model weights and activations while maintaining task
performance comparable to existing weight-only quantization methods. Moreover,
in the 8- and 4-bit scenario, Agile-Quant achieves an on-device speedup of up
to 2.55x compared to its FP16 counterparts across multiple edge devices,
marking a pioneering advancement in this domain.
|
[
-0.0731793046,
-1.079071641,
0.5199577212,
0.4360723197,
-0.5178313255,
0.2517577112,
-0.2316908687,
-0.2698553503,
0.0618593879,
0.1405748576,
-0.1852336675,
-0.5240987539,
-0.5455039144,
-0.1287556738,
-0.4010169506,
0.7001004815,
0.0291456878,
-0.054491505,
-0.0156096406,
-0.3201452196,
0.0863200575,
-0.3830314875,
-1.0347733498,
-0.2007429153,
0.3245529234,
0.0693786591,
0.8153848648,
0.824843049,
0.2114219517,
0.3555283248,
-0.270514369,
-0.22545214,
-0.0014936775,
-0.0560309887,
0.271830529,
-0.4844418764,
-0.9536166191,
-0.3679476082,
0.4536696374,
0.4634553492,
-0.2965589762,
0.1946377158,
-0.1314023882,
0.5881057978,
-0.7579855323,
-0.1766843498,
-0.4561917484,
-0.1779757589,
-0.2688676119,
0.1186289936,
-0.2989741266,
-0.3903419971,
-0.2279176116,
-0.6674486399,
-0.1773667932,
-0.0002918213,
0.709851265,
0.2001138777,
-0.8071027398,
-0.0277296938,
-0.6877171397,
0.835586071,
-0.6586244702,
0.5454512835,
0.2938920259,
0.1087748557,
0.1705800891,
-1.0676245689,
-0.3348124325,
-0.0320455618,
0.4735681415,
-0.0369589515,
-0.3375217319,
0.5647474527,
0.2478218973,
0.4728994668,
-0.6037555337,
0.3296048343,
-0.1032536998,
-0.0408195853,
0.55150038,
-0.1277054548,
0.0626343712,
0.3449169695,
-0.5195418,
0.0781554431,
-1.1396483183,
-0.0665761456,
0.2212844342,
-0.1857674271,
0.0299272519,
0.3671469688,
-0.3324430585,
0.7518196106,
-0.0217418522,
-0.2902728319,
0.3349764645,
-0.2917633653,
-0.2540868819,
0.134935081,
0.6698201299,
0.1941762716,
0.0719569325,
-0.0528824963,
-0.6620295048,
0.1011739001,
-0.1472308934,
-1.06835711,
0.0717857927,
0.3935084641,
-0.4259257317,
0.0853505656,
-0.6202754974,
-0.3659676313,
-0.005969516,
0.015970096,
0.6770499349,
-0.6118248105,
-0.3680410683,
0.2653452158,
-0.1382353157,
0.3730640709,
0.0946877077,
-0.8187326789,
0.5373368263,
0.7752599716,
0.9086608887,
0.0455079898,
-0.0111082308,
-0.7481558919,
0.2235364765,
-0.3254509568,
0.6739353538,
-0.3617266119,
-0.0638609752,
-0.0199505016,
-0.4792969525,
0.0630544797,
-0.4155413508,
0.6359264255,
-0.8377517462,
-0.4786333442,
0.2599827349,
-0.5937816501,
-0.1932838708,
0.1705949605,
-0.6725180745,
1.1692903042,
0.0904824957,
-0.1771786362,
0.2311661094,
-0.682978034,
-0.6151418686,
0.402254194,
-0.0941843241,
-0.4765908718,
0.3183963895,
0.1976513416,
0.1868901998,
-0.5171721578,
0.4645784497,
-0.2300435156,
-0.5234707594,
0.1522804946,
-0.4832306206,
0.5964496136,
0.2325363755,
-0.4197002351,
0.2802122831,
-0.8466767073,
0.3286633492,
-0.072825402,
-0.3133788109,
-0.498205781,
0.088519536,
-0.0247659124,
0.0367446505,
0.240200907,
-0.5418776274,
0.171037361,
-0.2965606451,
0.8920315504,
0.7720261216,
-0.2232749164,
0.506269455,
-0.145402208,
0.7515234947,
-0.2281649858,
0.2475028783,
-0.4276282191,
-0.5452030897,
-0.5589548945,
-0.6340910792,
0.6406463981,
0.6311606765,
-0.9006263614,
0.2434641868,
-0.5027793646,
-0.3062315583,
-0.646830678,
0.149421379,
0.6345870495,
-0.0664106309,
0.1968829632,
-0.1016747802,
-0.1051563621,
-0.8798772097,
-0.5775725245,
0.0726139545,
-0.3426161706,
0.0950809941,
0.3174343407,
0.0235296879,
0.8797118664,
-0.3507548273,
-0.1618748754,
-0.2508717179,
0.3513712883,
0.0952589214,
0.558383584,
0.301397562,
-1.06884408,
-0.4155626297,
0.1251732856,
-0.1822537333,
-0.2654594779,
-0.0777219534,
0.2760818899,
-0.0601203181,
0.5209913254,
-0.6023664474,
0.3185079098,
0.7881401777,
-0.1941505373,
0.3832961023,
-0.0939155295,
0.0078389049,
-0.9032537937,
-0.2446651161,
0.1350190192,
-0.2556890845,
-0.5665569901,
-0.1110046878,
0.2204496711,
0.0491361022,
-0.5265443921,
0.7149144411,
-0.4332716465,
-0.3365709484,
-0.2034751922,
0.1402647793,
0.1682305634,
0.5950567126,
-0.0635517165,
0.9015378952,
0.620568037,
-0.6197945476,
0.1768655032,
-0.1082866564,
-0.2835369706,
0.5587188601,
-0.7575108409,
0.0318914466,
0.2874133587,
0.1972164214,
-0.6441512108,
0.2451556921,
-0.3071782291,
-0.3141258359,
-0.1926165521,
-0.4218826592,
-0.7187678814,
0.0117301997,
-0.5298818946,
0.8399911523,
0.8164917827,
-0.4124533236,
1.1331326962,
0.2150531113,
-0.092957966,
-0.2652193606,
-0.721873641,
0.0724641159,
-0.5057910681,
-0.8872010708,
0.9010104537,
-0.0872601941,
-0.3863396049,
-0.081317082,
-0.2244357914,
-0.2800167501,
0.175532937,
0.2219806612,
-0.1092353016,
-0.4044261873,
0.1747079194,
0.454806596,
-0.2421937287,
-0.0703276321,
-0.5467948914,
0.4285056591,
-0.3772074282,
-0.3026785851,
-0.3831890225,
0.2069426477,
0.3503227532,
-0.572049737,
0.518537581,
0.6677051187,
-0.3298015594,
-0.3185340464,
-0.4714971185,
-0.2330257595,
-0.6123332977,
0.2720536888,
-0.6480056047,
-0.9205140471,
0.4690096974,
-0.7588914037,
0.1735592633,
0.2420418561,
0.5107357502,
0.2017371356,
1.0510884523,
0.5282561183,
0.3349706531,
0.7756814361,
-0.3555237055,
0.215418607,
-1.0990223885,
0.1899124533,
-0.3323518634,
-0.4172964394,
-0.3683343232,
-0.4272491038,
0.5050275326,
0.3683220744,
-0.3049770594,
0.1550168842,
-0.1937071085,
0.3835458755,
0.5138444304,
0.0485706143,
0.4345020056,
-0.0834578574,
-0.0956376567,
0.1891706139,
-0.8560073376,
-0.3147729933,
1.0908790827,
0.2317318618,
0.6667068005,
-0.0297468472,
0.4975260496,
0.2374147177,
0.472230345,
-0.6832570434,
0.6784843206,
-0.0805086121,
-0.363637358,
-0.1427234411,
-0.3468934298,
-0.8989834785,
0.4407975078,
0.2025095224,
-0.5581774116,
-0.0261151884,
0.2219292372,
-0.561999619,
0.1724973619,
-0.8573824167,
0.871984899,
-0.4261834025,
-0.4578470886,
-0.4248090088,
-0.3945971727,
0.3615513742,
-0.0176490508,
0.5120671391,
-0.159727037,
-0.440346092,
0.826846838,
-0.458674103,
0.7600058913,
-0.0452725589,
-0.1525706798,
0.493845135,
0.0160859264,
0.7071263194,
0.031830512,
-0.1793210953,
0.1405290365,
-0.4013170004,
-0.3801889718,
-0.6535600424,
0.5730367303,
-0.3326052725,
-0.4597676694,
-0.0318103172,
-0.4177896082,
-0.1524884999,
0.0950067267,
-0.0434923992,
0.6547454,
0.2194381356,
0.173878625,
0.5895712972,
-0.0556451902,
0.6418604851,
0.5065429807,
-0.1165049002,
-0.6034065485,
1.0097464323,
0.1014518067,
0.6928257942,
0.3678341806,
0.1205807626,
-0.2168734819,
-0.9462221265,
-0.6453021169,
0.0088543473,
-0.5521382093,
-0.4630065858,
-0.6084105372,
-0.0633393377,
-0.1050495356,
-0.3857917488,
-0.6328465939,
-0.6791113615,
0.0117242578,
-0.2053897232,
0.7702431679,
0.1565435082,
-0.0236698147,
1.1322989464,
-0.6649351716,
0.4055931866,
0.11355149,
0.3818790019,
-0.0202045888,
-0.4236121178,
-0.3712854087,
-0.0274573695,
-0.4790189862,
-0.7283856273,
0.2859259248,
0.5583407283,
0.0918209478,
0.5656268597,
0.0496256612,
0.8102317452,
-0.303483218,
0.5313777924,
0.0232178736,
-1.2446873188,
0.1741409153,
-0.0477313101,
0.3230248988,
0.3255336583,
0.300691098,
-0.3771376908,
-0.2493834496,
-0.5500190258,
-1.269149065,
0.3808911145,
0.1129554808,
-0.0094959838,
0.0586362556,
0.2820596993,
-0.1863999963,
0.4177753925,
-0.8594971299,
-0.0916426703,
0.2598399818,
-0.2040091455,
0.4115703702,
-0.1118373424,
0.0080876015,
-0.0379894562,
0.4787335694,
-0.3789683282,
0.0729972422,
0.0018222893,
-0.2373653799,
0.0120423147,
0.1877530962,
0.1667560041,
0.6323208809,
0.1216428652,
0.1332094222,
0.2957550585,
-0.4805659652,
0.1230915785,
0.250423342,
-0.2423493117,
-0.1990931928,
0.3216058016,
0.8713935018,
0.3620115519,
-0.8378814459,
0.5510134101,
0.0288314577,
-0.0895215496,
-0.2050048262,
-0.1300270706,
0.2012430429,
0.4044181406,
0.7139929533,
-0.255923003,
0.2063042521,
-0.260158807,
0.1988277733,
0.6687683463,
-0.0269594267,
-0.4607020319,
0.679122448,
0.378264159,
-0.5887688994,
0.5996320844,
-0.420248419,
-0.5754133463,
0.8306950331,
0.5706449747,
1.0252019167,
-0.3528819978,
-0.0730286837,
0.057787396,
0.3103234172,
0.0445377156,
0.4822105765,
-0.2386710197,
-0.4677732885,
-0.9975023866,
-0.8587228656,
-0.1021695435,
-0.0742103159,
-0.3708150387,
0.1922978312,
-0.2243961394,
-0.2660234571,
-0.1851841062,
-0.246109426,
-0.3105224669,
0.2171227038,
-0.092346631,
0.9236955643,
-0.5968008041,
1.0531060696,
0.4078046679,
0.1980660856,
-0.5723199248,
-0.3846103549,
-0.2395070046,
-0.7307955027,
0.476160109,
0.0900168046,
-0.0950824097,
0.5816407204,
-0.3045895398,
-0.7431108356,
1.425538063,
0.2513144016,
-0.6323434114,
0.0254715998,
0.0607428774,
0.3002477288,
-0.2861091197,
0.5529059172,
0.4734391868,
0.5472077131,
0.2427829057,
-0.8015936613,
0.0866414234,
0.0894141868,
0.0841614604,
0.5366966724,
-0.5510482192,
0.9314462543,
-0.2419122458,
-0.1442038566,
-0.0199605413,
0.7905652523,
0.5641714334,
0.3777515888,
0.5594264269,
0.5903488994,
0.2533760965,
-0.0625270307,
0.9610237479,
-0.6402986646,
0.0977327377,
0.5658833981,
-0.3149801195,
0.8091713786,
0.5674530864,
-0.1724958718,
0.3340750337,
0.5678887367,
0.2570791543,
0.3543098867,
0.4369608164,
-0.6444479823,
-0.1808726639,
-0.0139885526,
-0.089658685,
0.0788365975,
0.620418787,
-0.0962006226,
-0.1838185638,
0.2353058606,
0.1117010787,
-0.2595012486,
-0.5449389219,
0.5136754513,
0.3440885246,
-0.5314347744,
0.6403779387,
0.4925401807,
0.7731606364,
-0.8774198294,
-0.1206132025,
-0.3308272958,
0.3015394211,
-0.048954431,
-0.454398185,
0.0986607224,
-0.1519757211,
0.3428548872,
-0.6091305017,
0.5555071235,
-0.3045275509,
-0.3741796911,
0.3092619479,
0.4867389202,
-0.0362894163,
-0.5213139653,
-0.6358850598,
0.4900915921,
-0.1339691728,
-0.73832196,
0.6457704902,
0.6841247082,
-0.40094468,
1.0133817196,
0.7700320482,
-0.1764882803,
0.3122920394,
-0.2799628973,
0.9979220033,
-0.6721054316,
-0.45019117,
-1.0340987444,
0.4839061499,
0.2576304376,
-0.4875736237,
0.6470370293,
0.8179428577,
0.3981463313,
0.3555334508,
0.4119159579,
-0.1906644553,
-0.2516798079,
-0.6283150315,
0.2439548075,
-0.6343004107,
0.399351716,
0.2179161012,
-0.8088881969,
-0.1948229223,
0.3757344782,
-0.1251484156,
0.1972261965,
0.6692928672,
0.6444026232,
0.0404165648,
-0.1591048092,
0.2360913455,
0.2126277387,
0.3289330006,
0.7184216976,
0.455413729,
-0.4920115769,
0.8152866364,
-0.1376304477,
-0.5097825527,
-0.0804269463,
-0.9751548767,
-0.4094853103,
-0.4787882566,
-0.5416153669,
-0.1928417981,
0.3363642097,
0.562384665,
0.7347763181,
-0.0971350893,
-0.3661862016,
-0.2587162554,
0.3552871346,
-0.6769838333,
-0.1668323725,
0.4821451902,
-0.0885248408,
-0.7849016786,
0.4591525793,
0.4485187829,
-0.0817963183,
-0.1540621072,
-0.1844165921,
-0.1180040538,
0.1483974159,
0.7341125011,
0.1863972396,
-0.4214462936,
0.3366218209,
-0.0140355658,
0.0441241339,
0.22615242,
0.9289985299,
-1.1587272882,
-0.1384010613,
0.0329112522,
0.620721817,
0.6763548851,
0.1686701626,
0.5599308014,
-0.5694471598,
0.1683655977,
0.4857444763,
0.07251288,
-0.0163232014,
0.0212361906,
0.358821243,
0.1195107177,
-0.5377116203,
-0.9288606048,
0.2718446851,
-0.8594244123,
-0.1732061803,
1.3373212814,
-0.2230316848,
-0.6792846322,
-0.0103591634,
0.1023066714,
-0.0393019691,
-0.4784941375,
0.3618712723,
0.3427681923,
-0.1038914919,
-0.2624260187,
-0.7701100707,
0.4877283871,
0.5175041556,
-0.7848808765,
0.0680042356,
0.1965884417,
0.0901523307,
-0.1479394287,
0.7984335423,
0.0490545481,
0.3103041351,
0.1809986532,
0.3663361967,
-0.0661591962,
-0.0431518443,
-0.4002527893,
0.1335866302,
0.2334056199,
-0.1515981406
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05688v1
|
NLLG Quarterly arXiv Report 09/23: What are the most influential current AI Papers?
| 2023-12-09T21:42:20 | 2023-12-09T21:42:20 |
Ran Zhang, Aida Kostikova, Christoph Leiter, Jonas Belouadi, Daniil Larionov, Yanran Chen, Vivian Fresen, Steffen Eger
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has witnessed rapid growth, especially in the
subfields Natural Language Processing (NLP), Machine Learning (ML) and Computer
Vision (CV). Keeping pace with this rapid progress poses a considerable
challenge for researchers and professionals in the field. In this arXiv report,
the second of its kind, which covers the period from January to September 2023,
we aim to provide insights and analysis that help navigate these dynamic areas
of AI. We accomplish this by 1) identifying the top-40 most cited papers from
arXiv in the given period, comparing the current top-40 papers to the previous
report, which covered the period January to June; 2) analyzing dataset
characteristics and keyword popularity; 3) examining the global sectoral
distribution of institutions to reveal differences in engagement across
geographical areas. Our findings highlight the continued dominance of NLP:
while only 16% of all submitted papers have NLP as primary category (more than
25% have CV and ML as primary category), 50% of the most cited papers have NLP
as primary category, 90% of which target LLMs. Additionally, we show that i)
the US dominates among both top-40 and top-9k papers, followed by China; ii)
Europe clearly lags behind and is hardly represented in the top-40 most cited
papers; iii) US industry is largely overrepresented in the top-40 most
influential papers.
|
[
-0.437536329,
-0.5609297156,
0.4243760407,
0.2543990314,
0.0577767752,
0.2417590469,
0.2764495015,
-0.890468657,
-0.0713637322,
0.3784435391,
-0.0118771531,
-0.5430474877,
-0.8769508004,
0.2418737561,
-0.7159366012,
1.0353758335,
0.3399342597,
-0.2149124891,
-0.582193017,
-0.6495376825,
-0.0296420474,
-0.7785457373,
-0.9607141018,
-0.4541353881,
0.9027584791,
-0.3758291006,
0.736803174,
0.7223114371,
0.8019670248,
0.3174551725,
-0.5694203377,
0.0088611664,
-0.1457920074,
-0.2419975102,
0.0674677193,
-0.523147881,
-0.5821914673,
0.1369398683,
0.7678981423,
0.5442173481,
-0.0680594519,
0.268942982,
0.1748206913,
0.9069289565,
-0.5205998421,
0.235456869,
-0.4070870578,
0.1167685837,
-0.3146726489,
-0.0893267319,
-0.3688925505,
-0.2257926315,
0.2141879201,
-0.550978899,
-0.2521031201,
0.2366975397,
0.6872065663,
0.5875181556,
-0.5679057837,
-0.1791511476,
-0.4626970589,
0.847874403,
-0.3551838696,
0.3126268685,
0.2128016204,
-0.2111624628,
-0.13283059,
-0.9241920114,
-0.1452516168,
-0.099722743,
0.1038412824,
0.1245192736,
-0.7318798304,
-0.1363200545,
0.1737440377,
0.1218576133,
-0.6657406688,
0.0924601853,
-0.2713522613,
-0.0424588509,
0.5512837768,
-0.0096687926,
0.6169295311,
0.4898107052,
-0.1288495809,
-0.0701320916,
-0.6190125942,
0.0931007192,
0.2339837402,
-0.0796282887,
0.1897559017,
0.349072814,
0.1623036265,
0.6413611174,
-0.2274420857,
0.2704498768,
0.289101094,
-0.6900690198,
-0.0205121562,
-0.022204129,
0.7896896005,
0.0857328922,
-0.2880177796,
-0.3779169917,
0.1125922799,
-0.5593698621,
0.4336649477,
-0.4537895918,
-0.0597515032,
0.1308006346,
-0.5571010709,
-0.2216901034,
0.3549569845,
-0.5874903202,
-0.767482698,
-0.2372919917,
0.1238825694,
0.0111362217,
-0.1419248134,
-0.4165233672,
-0.1786724329,
0.699006319,
0.3672632575,
-0.6793972254,
0.0967644304,
0.9421735406,
1.061139822,
-0.4388664961,
-0.231452778,
-0.478844136,
-0.2802251279,
-0.6506072879,
0.9117193222,
-0.4052677453,
-0.2202760428,
0.0797543228,
-0.0926092714,
0.0647283643,
-0.5537664294,
0.5833170414,
-0.3755061924,
0.1988677979,
-0.4171271324,
-0.0543194972,
-0.4215332866,
0.3479397595,
-0.5875931978,
1.1158038378,
0.1906496733,
-0.6483031511,
0.4248627126,
-0.6093997955,
0.0144851413,
0.2433655709,
-0.2736873627,
-0.5538152456,
-0.2124096155,
0.0609272867,
0.0688376203,
-0.3404188454,
0.1565947682,
-0.1602535695,
-0.3441051245,
0.0885577872,
-0.4295229912,
1.0933508873,
0.1151297912,
-0.2381676137,
0.383326441,
-0.7363399863,
-0.1121872663,
-0.0902978554,
-0.3765223026,
-0.3367972672,
0.3216409385,
0.092773281,
-0.0238487516,
0.3391886353,
-0.2602888346,
0.4491514266,
-0.2971759737,
0.6454128623,
0.4978202581,
0.2871774435,
0.6501854062,
-0.4162427187,
0.7287918925,
-0.3580442369,
0.1661544293,
-0.0716592669,
-0.7481256127,
-0.5746995211,
-0.0118944198,
0.3857034743,
0.7752506137,
-0.343590647,
0.3947568238,
0.0414445065,
-0.7700347304,
-0.3897877038,
0.1202375963,
-0.0470325835,
0.4108599424,
0.1626449078,
-0.0126895271,
-0.4825284779,
-0.9344226718,
-0.4683431983,
-0.449491173,
0.1683779806,
0.2204162627,
0.2872220576,
-0.368036896,
0.6220325828,
-0.1660149395,
-0.3867897689,
-0.1849136651,
0.5282095671,
0.3709882498,
0.2490650415,
0.8107358217,
-1.0221946239,
-0.6426219344,
0.0077348906,
-0.7872388959,
-0.2280404717,
-0.3106315136,
-0.2094342411,
0.4759978652,
0.6396427155,
-0.26962924,
0.448759377,
0.3534606993,
-0.430028677,
0.2158024609,
-0.1838617176,
0.0020265239,
-0.5079538226,
0.3836456835,
0.0905811638,
0.05922205,
-0.3470132649,
0.0478414148,
-0.3534644842,
-0.1049955487,
-0.3334899545,
0.6144122481,
-0.3871905804,
0.1300263852,
-0.1244912297,
-0.1711274832,
-0.2702525258,
0.0837475583,
-0.3199747801,
1.0089595318,
0.5308308005,
-0.4248043895,
0.2995531261,
0.2407731861,
-0.2954637706,
-0.0140692685,
-0.848578155,
0.1524227709,
0.1413030773,
0.3417215049,
-0.5002670288,
0.0903791487,
0.2487185299,
-0.3664813638,
-0.038325768,
-0.0086210445,
-0.5637344718,
-0.1226969138,
-0.1706835777,
0.14523606,
0.5084351301,
-0.2347800583,
1.0004582405,
0.600897789,
-0.3251128793,
-0.8568788767,
-0.7037264109,
0.5064784288,
-0.2409323603,
-0.4394598007,
0.267601192,
-0.1008419693,
-0.6081973314,
0.0805515498,
-0.0181497186,
0.0335895978,
0.2621759176,
0.2960699797,
-0.0481893271,
-0.1292241365,
-0.0403618589,
-0.4918096662,
-0.1421732306,
0.5574220419,
-0.2186565548,
0.2519676387,
-0.6164438128,
-0.1051184908,
-0.3314734399,
0.4544099271,
0.7378148437,
-0.3167267442,
0.8232306838,
0.8627302051,
-0.0452343635,
-0.2195922881,
-0.0300709046,
0.1509345621,
-0.4416054487,
0.6122116446,
0.3844589293,
-0.5001388192,
0.509341538,
0.0044673746,
0.3759479225,
0.6505303979,
0.5338972807,
-0.130859375,
1.0915549994,
1.0241193771,
-0.4360662103,
0.6678673029,
-0.3762353659,
0.4774589539,
-0.5445562005,
-0.1378471553,
-0.7011297941,
-0.3188751638,
-0.9539610744,
-0.0639303699,
0.6572067738,
-0.0719987527,
0.0411872864,
-0.0685863867,
-0.6481976509,
0.4482926726,
1.1258655787,
-0.4741227329,
0.1479007006,
-0.1155886725,
0.4834481478,
0.0956739634,
-0.7877354026,
-0.4366146922,
1.085006237,
0.2326600105,
0.2132345289,
0.1406308562,
0.5719023943,
0.7440235019,
0.2309836298,
-0.9359457493,
0.5091232061,
-0.2688299716,
-0.3897044659,
-0.2553571463,
-0.0323764347,
-0.995267272,
-0.0396186337,
-0.431592375,
-0.5314819813,
0.024813652,
-0.0694602728,
-0.2427717894,
0.3415733278,
-0.3036093712,
0.4476580918,
-0.3050361276,
-0.5227737427,
0.0516071059,
-0.4027222991,
0.1261900812,
-0.0196222011,
0.2395999283,
0.0200259481,
-0.1383322775,
1.0903019905,
0.0026524921,
0.6419005394,
-0.0225741416,
0.0664103404,
0.5285458565,
-0.6045352817,
0.4443170428,
0.0523711368,
-0.2152235061,
0.4613303542,
0.1108087227,
-0.363293469,
-0.5730384588,
0.4700971842,
-0.9377369881,
-0.6898728609,
-1.0943585634,
-0.4661144316,
0.0133658275,
0.4050818682,
0.3124656677,
0.3004220128,
-0.0827114135,
0.7871002555,
0.7148384452,
-0.140529722,
0.6426398754,
0.0562779456,
-0.2795050144,
-0.3375956714,
1.0685391426,
0.5295510292,
-0.4045377672,
0.3971941173,
0.1661411673,
-0.163135618,
-0.877599299,
-0.2585098445,
0.1789762676,
-0.5483937263,
0.0451445878,
-0.7252690792,
-0.537312448,
-0.4732009172,
-0.2189942598,
-0.2347847372,
-0.2215964198,
-0.3116151392,
0.2742735744,
0.0937989429,
0.8181986213,
-0.0450072102,
0.154125765,
-0.6674702764,
0.0059364364,
0.2858946323,
0.1247764677,
-0.0240825675,
-0.1168177873,
-0.4332776666,
-0.323779881,
-0.3583032489,
-0.426918447,
0.4099074602,
0.1747201234,
0.7574797869,
0.5646445751,
0.2288152277,
0.1543180197,
-0.2966340184,
1.0377566814,
-0.1657411158,
-0.4676316977,
0.3309548497,
-0.6780626178,
0.5642157793,
0.460842222,
0.4024729133,
-0.5184890032,
-0.4376790226,
-0.7973425388,
-1.4261653423,
0.4196312428,
0.0107937679,
0.1544048488,
0.4104854465,
0.4133072197,
-0.1106327325,
0.1356674284,
-0.8769946098,
-0.457464695,
0.2947133482,
-0.0905139595,
0.3507396877,
-0.0380328111,
-0.2899296582,
-0.0792096481,
0.7320258021,
0.0113867596,
0.4384849966,
0.1329922229,
0.3647979796,
0.2740751207,
0.0232515298,
0.6523131132,
1.1714696884,
-0.3261817694,
0.0079939244,
-0.0577289686,
-0.6960920691,
-0.2539467812,
0.0278096087,
-0.6504326463,
-0.1090421155,
0.9405735731,
0.4724345505,
-0.5085587502,
-0.5643767118,
0.2978225052,
-0.0675724968,
-0.3760643899,
-0.8045281172,
0.4595369995,
-0.2723088562,
0.5144736171,
0.902379334,
0.273188591,
0.1850435287,
-0.6732510924,
0.1197629422,
0.4248111844,
-0.6554515958,
-0.2215334177,
0.7966656685,
0.2993875146,
-0.3392127752,
0.5793246627,
-0.172099486,
-0.6160283089,
0.990328908,
0.171380803,
0.7900144458,
0.4580254853,
-0.0307679381,
0.3530907631,
0.4411291182,
0.0846756324,
0.1061668769,
-0.0244425274,
-0.3291831017,
-0.1965528876,
-0.2881441712,
-0.6936817765,
0.3803130984,
-0.6532182693,
0.2751311362,
-0.4260968864,
-0.3140524328,
0.0217197407,
0.3168705404,
-0.3438071609,
0.0037440269,
0.2353625298,
0.797860384,
-0.569227159,
0.6946332455,
1.0374424458,
-0.3043755293,
-0.1650495678,
-0.0193929486,
0.4153146446,
-0.5194372535,
0.5197587013,
0.0375174247,
-0.1428035647,
0.1362687051,
-0.9537607431,
-1.1481722593,
1.1366750002,
-0.1974731684,
-0.1031471491,
-0.0460380726,
-0.0947318003,
0.6674838662,
-0.2925122976,
0.0969275013,
0.2093888372,
0.5351317525,
-0.184457615,
-0.4420683384,
-0.4830537736,
-0.5876305103,
-0.2791291773,
0.4103603363,
-0.9896164536,
0.3142035604,
0.0673331991,
-0.1225177348,
-0.1409863681,
0.969252646,
0.3703643382,
0.739582181,
0.3769498467,
0.3345238268,
0.6040232778,
-0.2646704316,
0.7953522205,
-0.4072229862,
-0.1822877228,
0.8207496405,
0.1640362889,
0.9921495318,
0.5500684381,
-0.3825019598,
0.3837121129,
0.541369915,
-0.6706971526,
0.4395166934,
-0.0051264712,
-0.059395019,
0.1599851549,
-0.3322330415,
-0.3803742528,
0.7651159763,
0.3309985995,
-0.2157363594,
0.1265826672,
0.0869190842,
0.2310661674,
-0.0959434137,
-0.2892269194,
0.8741737008,
-0.1866941452,
-0.7319837809,
0.1259844899,
-0.1304005384,
0.4777818322,
-0.7840256691,
-0.2646949291,
-0.3458719552,
-0.0119162342,
-0.0607133172,
-0.635666728,
0.6374348402,
0.1086819395,
-0.4438759983,
-0.5865387321,
0.3320293725,
0.0562216006,
-0.3877565563,
0.1951801926,
0.4176258743,
0.1408442706,
0.0177234467,
-0.863281846,
0.0818047151,
0.062078543,
-0.3583140075,
0.6023522615,
0.2796573937,
-0.2080087811,
0.6734067202,
0.4616243541,
0.2393969148,
0.0350618325,
-0.4270399809,
0.5757289529,
-0.5968269706,
-0.2097979039,
-0.4998390377,
0.3676065207,
-0.0954646617,
-0.7085211277,
0.6723421812,
0.3567955792,
0.4030133188,
0.6092277169,
0.8472367525,
-0.2641102672,
0.1868483722,
-0.3179524243,
1.1651496887,
-0.6200258732,
0.3838533163,
0.2339927554,
-1.0058435202,
-0.4385338128,
0.3000652492,
-0.2290457785,
0.0160993263,
0.3542505801,
0.1674123108,
0.5049482584,
-0.1692539603,
0.0822924748,
0.3657543361,
0.5599916577,
-0.1116878316,
0.5276799202,
-0.4215411544,
0.7522547245,
-0.3356094062,
-0.2071486413,
-0.1217510998,
-0.9877716303,
-0.4761554897,
-0.6998816133,
-0.707385242,
-0.2010120898,
-0.0747886896,
0.5104258657,
0.4904139936,
-0.8033043146,
0.0398802347,
-0.1340792626,
0.2598972023,
-0.3752299845,
-0.2747457027,
0.6674481034,
-0.2109211534,
-0.96748209,
0.2777725458,
0.4411098957,
-0.1594233215,
-0.3145741224,
0.2883472741,
-0.515011847,
-0.0589470863,
0.5468556285,
0.4986497164,
-0.7427762747,
0.0453660674,
0.248167932,
-0.1782885343,
0.0267341863,
0.5436112881,
-0.615273416,
0.234052673,
0.5665739775,
0.7652869821,
-0.044391036,
0.2664703429,
0.4667818546,
-0.4451404512,
0.1075627655,
0.4906101227,
0.0452311933,
0.005231123,
-0.542899251,
1.0022511482,
0.2700364888,
-1.1647998095,
-0.8124543428,
-0.2897623777,
-0.944249928,
-0.4208143055,
0.9445695877,
-0.0116232717,
-0.3546938598,
-0.2338915169,
-0.0460059047,
0.0372829437,
-0.4536575675,
0.8189710975,
0.974181354,
-0.935608387,
-0.5106040239,
-0.9762060046,
0.5242846012,
0.3816492856,
-0.6402307749,
-0.2125750333,
0.305473268,
-0.5440412164,
0.5213996768,
0.3011104167,
0.0358814895,
0.0504203252,
0.1647886187,
-0.1750540882,
-0.1814063936,
-0.356592536,
-0.3175332248,
0.2334958464,
0.1713003814,
0.2876298726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05677v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05677v3
|
Batched Low-Rank Adaptation of Foundation Models
| 2023-12-09T20:51:48 | 2024-04-25T21:45:35 |
Yeming Wen, Swarat Chaudhuri
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA) has recently gained attention for fine-tuning
foundation models by incorporating trainable low-rank matrices, thereby
reducing the number of trainable parameters. While LoRA offers numerous
advantages, its applicability for real-time serving to a diverse and global
user base is constrained by its incapability to handle multiple task-specific
adapters efficiently. This imposes a performance bottleneck in scenarios
requiring personalized, task-specific adaptations for each incoming request. To
mitigate this constraint, we introduce Fast LoRA (FLoRA), a framework in which
each input example in a minibatch can be associated with its unique low-rank
adaptation weights, allowing for efficient batching of heterogeneous requests.
We empirically demonstrate that FLoRA retains the performance merits of LoRA,
showcasing competitive results on the MultiPL-E code generation benchmark
spanning over 8 languages and a multilingual speech recognition task across 6
languages.
|
[
-0.2902629077,
-0.8030533195,
0.1640534699,
0.6830630302,
-0.067315273,
0.020091651,
-0.1127775982,
-0.4136588275,
0.4654652476,
0.3911396563,
-0.5475541949,
-0.0669173375,
-0.4957286716,
0.1751149148,
-0.4562825263,
0.9810478091,
0.0495616831,
-0.1718395501,
0.0507211983,
-0.4687967598,
-0.5293978453,
-0.2372292131,
-0.9647859335,
-0.0410666764,
0.7012178302,
0.8596836329,
0.5498780012,
0.6352316141,
0.5253213048,
0.2810095847,
0.2015219182,
0.0418298431,
-0.864251852,
0.3124952912,
-0.291641295,
-0.8270607591,
-0.8050581813,
-0.3752156496,
0.6718341112,
0.7973100543,
-0.0950003639,
0.4974155724,
0.0711817667,
0.7070137262,
-0.7621654272,
-0.160205394,
-0.8413687944,
0.218571499,
-0.1855489314,
-0.3961643875,
-0.4325454235,
-0.1806048602,
-0.0911956653,
-0.772451818,
0.2530331314,
-0.0170374662,
0.6522384882,
0.5496815443,
0.026314348,
-0.0605156459,
-0.7241947055,
0.5511734486,
-0.4582586884,
0.1997718215,
0.3151009083,
0.6529353261,
-0.1462048292,
-0.696831286,
-0.0665132552,
0.2213688046,
0.2758156359,
-0.1184073463,
-0.2507887781,
-0.3470175564,
0.3168587387,
0.3747303188,
-0.2778245211,
0.3356998563,
-0.0736802518,
0.0297233053,
0.1780772358,
-0.0497222655,
0.0966590643,
0.1439663172,
-0.2124897987,
-0.2083728313,
-0.6774852872,
0.3458464146,
-0.110461086,
0.9070778489,
-0.2605860531,
0.3583332896,
-0.4794445932,
0.5366325378,
0.5267444849,
-0.3911470473,
0.2515391409,
-0.1085502133,
-0.5482040048,
0.0702319816,
0.3564426899,
-0.0637739971,
-0.0774761662,
0.0385603644,
-0.2265531719,
0.1237546131,
0.0765024498,
-1.3753067255,
-0.1613146514,
0.062577717,
-0.4132217765,
-0.340839833,
-0.3656345904,
-0.9031861424,
-0.5343320966,
0.07211449,
0.4832738936,
0.0159817617,
0.0976489931,
-0.1856431812,
0.0853495523,
-0.0051334105,
0.6614019275,
-1.0206958055,
0.7388404608,
0.2983494997,
1.0383659601,
-0.2614240348,
-0.2215753496,
-1.5815087557,
0.0137012843,
-0.1840867102,
0.8235694766,
-0.3237523735,
-0.539670527,
-0.2875664532,
0.440477401,
-0.345140487,
-0.582212925,
0.2273783982,
-0.4156523943,
-0.2109479308,
-0.5020557642,
0.254377991,
0.1800928712,
0.0392856263,
-0.7284634113,
0.968286097,
0.4041813016,
-0.490427494,
0.6178250909,
-0.8751353621,
-0.8544487953,
-0.0265983958,
-0.1475271732,
-0.47320804,
0.3032813966,
0.4188516736,
0.4251641631,
-0.4015235901,
-0.2769954205,
-0.4223557711,
-0.477702111,
-0.245639056,
-0.1612515301,
0.6595153809,
0.2739439905,
-0.3664958179,
0.234814927,
-0.9041898251,
-0.0280855559,
0.2350264937,
-0.7389393449,
-0.2296546549,
-0.0635167882,
0.3460963666,
0.085645996,
-0.0294266306,
-0.1869375259,
0.5729696155,
-0.2832439542,
0.6576502323,
0.7648720145,
-0.1072787493,
0.3682816923,
-0.4480775595,
0.4663291276,
0.1170831919,
0.1348295659,
-0.001189399,
-0.4492788613,
-1.0288834572,
-0.6742843986,
0.3646528125,
0.4413734078,
-0.7218729854,
-0.167345345,
-0.7946430445,
-0.4260665774,
-0.5767742395,
0.5070768595,
0.3469194174,
0.3445240855,
0.4234857857,
-0.5841425657,
-0.302968353,
-0.7915631533,
-0.0593247712,
0.1347268671,
0.1879206449,
0.4463486671,
0.6312317848,
-0.4764844477,
0.993260026,
-0.4082039595,
-0.3847824931,
-0.0932145342,
0.1158577055,
0.5006890297,
0.6009189487,
1.0610979795,
-0.6742504835,
-0.609161973,
0.0823316947,
-0.3643028438,
0.0938765034,
0.0296265688,
-0.2519063056,
0.0951197222,
0.1977371573,
-0.1917975396,
0.2867547572,
0.7609855533,
-0.1135637909,
-0.0217836443,
-0.4606537819,
0.2986572087,
-1.332077384,
0.0904971659,
-0.2149281204,
-0.5419267416,
-0.5801623464,
0.1495592594,
0.0748300478,
-0.4859099984,
-0.5587178469,
0.527017653,
-0.2942885458,
-0.6509845257,
-0.1496715844,
-0.2567472756,
0.0207877588,
0.5552729368,
-0.1960325688,
0.999538064,
0.5996453166,
-0.958866775,
0.0329372771,
0.3061418235,
-0.2180617452,
0.7661432028,
-0.4790294766,
0.2357548773,
0.1950678378,
0.4428545535,
-0.6305843592,
-0.4457544088,
0.0240688436,
0.1165024415,
-0.0349142514,
-0.5893503428,
-0.3404999077,
-0.2553936541,
-0.2369220555,
0.5279434919,
0.5466569066,
-0.856299758,
0.7390062213,
-0.0485706516,
-0.1524921358,
-0.5074131489,
-0.8899385333,
-0.1641911268,
-0.2302642167,
-0.4771243334,
0.2663757205,
-0.2985519767,
-0.1514788568,
-0.2368046641,
-0.2388954014,
-0.0928471759,
0.6272675991,
0.603271544,
-0.3112109005,
-0.6335613728,
-0.3200966716,
0.2662185133,
0.2181428969,
-0.485173732,
-0.2905547321,
0.5408077836,
-0.2102044374,
-0.5831224322,
-0.3788598776,
0.1910490543,
0.9686080217,
-0.1346275657,
0.7609471083,
0.6171482205,
-0.5551939607,
-0.7039439678,
-0.0948728696,
-0.0974222049,
-0.4606329203,
0.3046474159,
-0.9447678924,
-0.5073018074,
0.5580309033,
-0.1139309332,
0.1067247838,
0.3649348915,
0.6690627933,
-0.0307196807,
0.4525836408,
0.8300173879,
-0.3700790405,
0.6508768797,
-0.4199084938,
0.0190680195,
-0.4749020636,
0.4115540981,
-0.7380253077,
-0.4166468382,
-0.6143597364,
-0.5836744308,
0.3866287768,
0.2764174342,
-0.1161908284,
0.4605241418,
-0.2584089339,
0.2075059861,
0.4536224902,
0.1396773607,
0.4714267254,
0.2309305668,
0.2110405862,
0.4075394571,
-0.8315379024,
0.0268738344,
0.930960536,
0.2342205495,
0.7208065987,
0.598054409,
0.6941765547,
0.865701735,
0.5219002366,
-0.8157100081,
0.3263627589,
-0.4825659394,
-0.3523506224,
-0.2538137436,
-0.3585591316,
-0.8150474429,
0.4723303616,
-0.1895425469,
-0.674661994,
0.6417609453,
0.4007256329,
-0.9322453737,
0.2094331235,
-0.7041026354,
0.7271355987,
-0.2131682783,
-0.52717489,
-0.2563813031,
-0.3319654167,
0.279576391,
-0.4428900778,
0.4138528407,
-0.1414991766,
0.2351818532,
0.6609948874,
-0.5433126688,
0.7868847847,
-0.4978073239,
-0.1341112405,
-0.1666934043,
0.1471878141,
0.6714549065,
0.1507476568,
-0.1966877729,
-0.3034951091,
0.1499192268,
-0.7687740922,
-0.455098629,
1.0364478827,
-0.9039807916,
-0.5575785041,
-0.2558487654,
-0.4667393565,
-0.6619723439,
0.2632713318,
0.1171463579,
0.5294705629,
-0.363143146,
0.2317457348,
0.6578418612,
-0.0593950078,
0.4241804183,
0.4229010344,
-0.419516623,
-0.027201429,
1.1123411655,
-0.0829889253,
0.4498725533,
0.6271090508,
0.0801087916,
0.361425817,
-0.6038941741,
-0.8799113035,
-0.1905778646,
-0.8356206417,
0.0206857827,
-0.6050634384,
0.1282826215,
-0.4198426902,
-0.4037427306,
-0.4866036177,
-0.4319921136,
-0.5558641553,
0.3563071489,
0.4867139459,
0.4372727871,
0.2699719965,
0.5888499618,
-0.5131985545,
0.8050298691,
0.4213837683,
0.1462000608,
-0.1625959873,
-0.6837898493,
-0.3560321629,
-0.0542036705,
0.1601531208,
-0.4763210416,
0.1104371324,
0.66654706,
0.300496012,
0.4952340126,
-0.0928937867,
1.0403357744,
-0.5535019636,
0.3416729271,
-0.0840374827,
-0.7161685824,
0.5532101393,
-0.3007164896,
0.2555040419,
0.8340252042,
0.0300036687,
-0.2442243993,
0.3741751909,
-0.0233938489,
-0.6033956409,
0.7771014571,
0.015343748,
0.0365255848,
0.4654578865,
0.1398408264,
0.2561573088,
0.052226577,
-0.535248518,
-0.0398582853,
-0.4142479002,
-0.034509439,
-0.1681490391,
-0.051954709,
-0.4598369896,
-0.2121269405,
0.6514042616,
-0.6870993972,
0.3268436491,
-0.0987420157,
-0.6236541867,
-0.3284903467,
0.3826045692,
0.7694293857,
0.4739978313,
-0.3960845172,
-0.1877886504,
0.3198849559,
-0.3483355045,
0.1952858716,
0.2696226239,
-0.0992980301,
-0.2733878791,
0.2359586209,
0.9401007295,
0.6526960731,
-0.5030909777,
0.3309814632,
-0.1673376262,
0.0101663927,
0.102775842,
0.2896226943,
-0.1406382918,
0.1302281767,
0.3118978441,
0.5771666169,
-0.0559152588,
-0.8589441776,
-0.0467618592,
0.1672228426,
-0.108240597,
-0.2922662199,
0.568287909,
0.492364496,
-0.1925019622,
0.1937414557,
0.0096299173,
-0.0138327144,
0.513101995,
0.5465449691,
0.7612921596,
-0.16497989,
0.1043972597,
-0.0198418368,
0.0929276496,
-0.1776046157,
0.3009721637,
-0.15836218,
-0.53951931,
-0.050913211,
-1.0185220242,
-0.3395397961,
-0.1851491183,
-0.7466246486,
0.2126811147,
-0.7248921394,
-0.1543325931,
0.1528793722,
-0.0419023149,
-0.8688169122,
0.1320398897,
-0.0198634192,
1.1227709055,
-0.9707736373,
1.1471471786,
0.6168541908,
-0.2991153002,
-0.3866571784,
0.017637996,
-0.0792407244,
-0.9226491451,
0.6021587253,
-0.1384264976,
-0.3990577161,
0.2322438508,
0.0609004274,
-0.9841522574,
1.264452219,
0.4661185741,
-0.6339130998,
-0.270807296,
0.1032432094,
0.3840933144,
-0.5319213867,
-0.0059847552,
0.4111461937,
0.334816128,
-0.1062575132,
-1.0404860973,
-0.0242110323,
-0.2221402675,
0.1766073257,
-0.1456629783,
-0.7214894295,
1.1038409472,
-0.2004744411,
-0.0240386073,
0.3847747147,
0.5403925776,
0.2863202691,
0.0728823468,
0.7848314643,
0.4234264493,
0.9081323743,
-0.0110325171,
1.1177407503,
-0.319711864,
0.0833324566,
1.206081152,
-0.4856701195,
0.87937361,
0.5088846684,
-0.0731688589,
0.5067012906,
0.701020062,
0.1349957436,
0.7212300301,
0.1499547809,
0.0255494416,
-0.0686251372,
-0.1394252926,
-0.5603442192,
0.3813283443,
0.3190242648,
-0.2625042498,
-0.0216516256,
0.2633520365,
-0.0777456239,
-0.292132318,
-0.7058806419,
0.4229876101,
-0.021658767,
-0.6195017695,
0.9006240964,
0.1733783334,
0.6656873822,
-0.5285040736,
0.0948663577,
-0.4619843364,
0.4594228268,
-0.3370684683,
0.1615645885,
-0.2627608776,
0.1285061538,
-0.52374053,
-0.2550364733,
0.6404947042,
0.1222128421,
-0.5536636114,
0.2257659435,
0.7360629439,
-0.050274048,
0.0930531919,
-0.6310448647,
0.2688774467,
-0.2183134407,
-0.3501416445,
0.7031543255,
0.1224105284,
-0.4458811283,
0.8521994948,
0.7988930345,
0.046864707,
0.2040028274,
0.3567244709,
0.9331573844,
-0.3138319254,
-0.5984766483,
-0.3376728594,
0.1732386351,
0.3440661728,
-0.2709015906,
0.6208144426,
0.5721770525,
0.6199654341,
-0.2796293199,
0.8223962188,
-0.2053163797,
0.1922138482,
-0.5448698401,
0.6355782151,
-0.7639350891,
0.1612335443,
-0.3272963166,
-0.8733531237,
0.0419804826,
0.3131651282,
-0.0608905107,
0.0967708081,
0.5899825096,
0.5476660728,
-0.5900015235,
-0.1374742836,
0.3124328554,
0.3609604836,
0.258926779,
0.5498296618,
0.3196494579,
-0.4471228421,
0.2601142228,
-0.2511742115,
-0.2255847901,
-0.822373867,
-0.8450369835,
-0.7829225659,
-0.3453370035,
-0.1330640912,
-0.330707401,
0.2318149209,
1.127289772,
1.1729563475,
-1.1822869778,
-0.1898377389,
0.1256460994,
-0.1156128347,
-0.6545212865,
-0.1343663037,
0.3081859052,
-0.0748255476,
-0.7639688849,
0.8943061233,
0.1847313195,
-0.1451960951,
-0.1930214316,
-0.1590989381,
-0.0563892648,
0.075806573,
0.5845607519,
0.5722471476,
-0.6504112482,
-0.144767791,
-0.3188130856,
-0.1872237921,
0.3118390739,
0.862775743,
-0.8247070312,
0.216526866,
0.2663220167,
0.9798696041,
0.7239527106,
0.0302513074,
0.1560163498,
-0.7260704637,
0.3182303607,
-0.0141203478,
0.6529411674,
0.2819342613,
-0.2152514905,
0.4367041588,
0.4303353131,
-0.079314366,
-1.1205652952,
0.1323620826,
-1.2876310349,
-0.160356164,
0.9163510203,
-0.1701355726,
-0.3604353964,
0.1262335181,
0.0531326793,
-0.0127978977,
-0.4997152388,
0.4076204598,
0.2825779021,
-0.1180353165,
0.0711116418,
-0.5878315568,
0.4773947895,
0.3958789706,
-1.1902137995,
-0.0844094157,
0.2124787867,
0.5311147571,
0.1533973217,
0.8622587323,
0.4468210936,
0.2931295633,
-0.1954138875,
-0.2049489617,
0.0396567881,
-0.5619685054,
-0.2509883344,
0.3605326116,
0.5055283904,
-0.1325944811
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05671v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05671v1
|
Hate Speech and Offensive Content Detection in Indo-Aryan Languages: A Battle of LSTM and Transformers
| 2023-12-09T20:24:00 | 2023-12-09T20:24:00 |
Nikhil Narayan, Mrutyunjay Biswal, Pramod Goyal, Abhranta Panigrahi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media platforms serve as accessible outlets for individuals to express
their thoughts and experiences, resulting in an influx of user-generated data
spanning all age groups. While these platforms enable free expression, they
also present significant challenges, including the proliferation of hate speech
and offensive content. Such objectionable language disrupts objective discourse
and can lead to radicalization of debates, ultimately threatening democratic
values. Consequently, organizations have taken steps to monitor and curb
abusive behavior, necessitating automated methods for identifying suspicious
posts. This paper contributes to Hate Speech and Offensive Content
Identification in English and Indo-Aryan Languages (HASOC) 2023 shared tasks
track. We, team Z-AGI Labs, conduct a comprehensive comparative analysis of
hate speech classification across five distinct languages: Bengali, Assamese,
Bodo, Sinhala, and Gujarati. Our study encompasses a wide range of pre-trained
models, including Bert variants, XLM-R, and LSTM models, to assess their
performance in identifying hate speech across these languages. Results reveal
intriguing variations in model performance. Notably, Bert Base Multilingual
Cased emerges as a strong performer across languages, achieving an F1 score of
0.67027 for Bengali and 0.70525 for Assamese. At the same time, it
significantly outperforms other models with an impressive F1 score of 0.83009
for Bodo. In Sinhala, XLM-R stands out with an F1 score of 0.83493, whereas for
Gujarati, a custom LSTM-based model outshined with an F1 score of 0.76601. This
study offers valuable insights into the suitability of various pre-trained
models for hate speech detection in multilingual settings. By considering the
nuances of each, our research contributes to an informed model selection for
building robust hate speech detection systems.
|
[
-0.3554830849,
-0.8429116011,
0.0717654899,
0.2148640305,
-0.2932533324,
0.346855253,
-0.4289813936,
-0.8457525969,
0.0770065859,
0.5461924672,
-0.3877667189,
-0.3693476617,
-0.985966742,
0.1215625703,
-0.6731848121,
1.002720356,
0.230778411,
0.2895427644,
0.0737624913,
-0.4363356531,
-0.1486997455,
-0.6330202818,
-0.6209905148,
-0.1621800065,
0.7399282455,
-0.043047972,
0.3958476484,
0.4528106451,
0.4979899228,
0.3608340621,
-0.2119179219,
0.0520481765,
-0.4159740508,
0.4625518024,
-0.1947885454,
-0.330435127,
-0.0237503685,
-0.2907053232,
0.5034310222,
0.0078548491,
0.1031805649,
0.0604284741,
-0.1376878023,
0.3191049099,
-0.5719462037,
-0.0834857523,
-0.9220815301,
-0.0594123304,
-0.6618471146,
0.0259846002,
-0.4041706324,
-0.4524727762,
-0.2275978327,
-0.1872087419,
-0.1214862466,
-0.0428523384,
0.9163877964,
0.2632932067,
-0.4262103736,
-0.7025441527,
-0.750792861,
1.0665409565,
-0.7655941844,
0.6163964868,
0.3603461087,
0.2606005967,
0.1626123041,
-0.317820102,
-0.6553094983,
-0.1176223531,
-0.0114894146,
0.0988973826,
-0.5711414814,
-0.1923436522,
0.0736620352,
0.3785522282,
-0.7631623745,
0.5616746545,
-0.579998374,
-0.3360257447,
0.786907196,
-0.0641827732,
0.4772745371,
-0.5423331857,
-0.4609064758,
0.1000496447,
-0.50073421,
-0.2750478387,
0.8607977033,
0.5883159041,
-0.1166003272,
0.3886449337,
-0.1071295291,
0.5437281132,
0.0625934824,
-0.1143157184,
0.3257006407,
-0.0517616794,
0.067223765,
0.0654135048,
0.7630004883,
0.2280833125,
0.6504052877,
0.0177489854,
-0.0863838792,
0.4945471585,
0.4906493723,
-0.5196789503,
0.2597548068,
0.0819211006,
-0.3359116316,
-0.2843674123,
-0.7187732458,
-0.802798152,
-0.7814384103,
-0.1864480823,
0.2356426716,
-0.6241672039,
-0.4675272703,
-0.4194223881,
-0.0845356733,
0.6677296162,
0.1643506587,
-0.6842935681,
0.1358152032,
0.6659297943,
0.5397815108,
-0.7362090349,
-0.1005690619,
-0.2582676709,
-0.0906407014,
-0.1498671174,
0.7193045616,
-0.6315739155,
-0.227491498,
0.2882823944,
-0.1845483482,
0.0332023203,
-0.6291335821,
0.8853666782,
-0.812107265,
0.0362175815,
0.1404016167,
-0.5678181052,
-0.3094823062,
0.4112083614,
-0.3671084344,
0.9987555742,
0.1604697257,
-0.8382185698,
0.3631770611,
-0.4443473816,
-0.5088720918,
0.4241546094,
-0.2333712429,
-0.6263273954,
-0.0380763337,
-0.143029958,
0.3583419621,
0.0271544289,
0.1741788387,
-0.311756283,
-0.0012171223,
0.0587683395,
-0.3714710772,
0.9917521477,
0.7115460634,
-0.4070787728,
0.4077025056,
-0.9119156003,
-0.09794195,
0.3406158984,
-0.08210852,
-0.6143125892,
0.1384052932,
0.2219137996,
0.2417835444,
-0.0267355721,
-0.698102951,
-0.4044266641,
-0.2852852643,
0.2642263174,
1.0175441504,
-0.2754929066,
0.0590684414,
-0.1963088065,
0.5609845519,
0.0154614681,
0.2061726153,
0.3042703867,
-0.5089291334,
-0.6877833009,
-0.2335681915,
-0.0660424232,
0.6746022105,
-0.4651169181,
0.0889128447,
-0.0593854897,
-0.8788381815,
-0.4490070641,
0.0132491412,
0.3260166645,
0.3777604103,
0.3310570717,
-0.1240570396,
-0.8855386376,
-1.159052968,
-0.6198848486,
-0.2655015886,
0.2105157375,
0.2042225748,
0.2928368151,
-0.33296597,
0.6812207103,
-0.0192249883,
-0.187109679,
-0.5176151395,
0.1629065573,
-0.0648396164,
0.1984119415,
0.7454327345,
-1.224992156,
-0.9560278654,
-0.0464633331,
-0.4755197465,
-0.3485701084,
0.3393254876,
0.0841381624,
0.4717039168,
0.2734791934,
-0.1697750986,
0.5242134929,
0.6074095964,
-0.1487713456,
0.5912898779,
0.4741811454,
0.4934923351,
-0.9840740561,
-0.2453482151,
-0.0791646987,
-0.4154448509,
-0.8886038661,
0.1730870008,
-0.2032110244,
-0.1229451597,
-0.8649374843,
0.512785852,
-0.0236029718,
0.1548453271,
-0.2281171083,
0.0527851582,
-0.6508908868,
0.5786534548,
0.1957760155,
0.5771204233,
0.336242795,
-0.4894062281,
0.260843575,
0.088084586,
-0.4826926291,
0.6842458844,
-0.3374111354,
0.0884392783,
-0.1062468588,
-0.2779369354,
-1.1034739017,
-0.2401909381,
0.4771294296,
-0.7049742937,
0.0740124807,
-0.1144652665,
-0.4161397517,
-0.3262275159,
-0.2611326575,
0.4539044201,
0.4838776588,
-0.2393825203,
0.8727281094,
0.6567059159,
-0.3913238645,
-0.6425568461,
-0.6952078342,
-0.1092614383,
-0.5945645571,
-0.6143022776,
0.093207106,
-0.2757413089,
-0.5056862831,
-0.2105166614,
0.1964502782,
-0.3854676485,
0.0515573211,
0.5557875633,
0.0323327668,
0.0093552982,
-0.1908912361,
0.0381948799,
0.3291378021,
0.0664699599,
0.2256130278,
0.8114953637,
-0.0546720847,
-0.1846411377,
-0.1326302588,
0.5786116719,
0.6138855815,
-0.1633684635,
0.5170618892,
0.9547330141,
-0.4616061449,
-0.1208319291,
-0.6167057157,
0.075803183,
-0.4334450364,
0.4413484633,
0.0240291171,
-1.0830197334,
0.6664247513,
0.3020253778,
-0.0064684707,
0.4876331985,
0.9136577249,
0.1931639314,
0.9856002927,
0.5824264884,
-0.1330251545,
0.5502141714,
0.3119511604,
0.4432254434,
-0.2775176764,
0.0727664456,
-0.7778123617,
0.0466125682,
-0.8924228549,
-0.1564419866,
0.3423726261,
-0.4359922409,
-0.0856445357,
0.4677351117,
-0.4309670627,
0.3604491651,
0.3267388046,
-0.3245000839,
0.1101421565,
0.1756460667,
0.2266705781,
-0.3629643917,
-0.427528441,
-0.2322956622,
0.9354016781,
0.308370173,
0.4138564765,
0.2314029634,
0.4222120643,
0.8586595654,
0.4517702758,
-0.6724823713,
0.4804727435,
-0.2968606055,
-1.117416501,
-0.0771066323,
-0.2904502749,
-0.6702908874,
0.2032541484,
0.0331386216,
-0.7586749792,
-0.0338620357,
0.0801962093,
-0.153739661,
0.5737009645,
-0.5850407481,
0.6596184969,
-0.3203928471,
-0.3638673425,
-0.4662848413,
-0.5717523694,
0.5114684105,
-0.2671095431,
0.6423411369,
-0.1523028761,
0.2561845183,
0.8569930792,
-0.1244142726,
0.8285232186,
-0.0503764004,
-0.276694417,
0.3351158798,
-0.0622414015,
0.244509533,
-0.4619352221,
-0.2674133182,
0.5917293429,
-0.2657743096,
-0.2956224084,
-0.1198685691,
0.6603513956,
-0.7349388599,
-0.3916429281,
-0.4768969417,
-0.5048197508,
-0.0261874404,
0.4483139813,
0.4283715785,
0.1991662234,
-0.0683567375,
0.0071534952,
0.5831538439,
-0.4974274635,
0.2480566651,
0.6148073077,
-0.432690233,
-0.2471549958,
1.0414897203,
0.2072219253,
0.3348801136,
0.0027462691,
0.0551413111,
-0.3883748055,
-0.6846755743,
-0.4279445708,
0.1932023317,
-0.8681948781,
-0.1406697482,
-0.8528645039,
-0.4399777055,
-0.6993792057,
-0.1087469086,
-0.3504093885,
-0.1289056838,
0.1589030623,
0.1777044982,
0.3143892884,
0.8088593483,
-0.4106160402,
0.4655148387,
-0.4190394282,
0.3520247042,
0.2345753908,
0.2922215462,
-0.123656936,
-0.896774888,
-0.1279996336,
0.0387446545,
-0.3375870585,
-0.9116216302,
0.4851578474,
-0.0636263713,
0.3250510395,
0.3756359518,
0.0420683585,
0.3929810226,
-0.5157304406,
0.7736569643,
0.0140493922,
-0.7067684531,
0.4982476234,
-0.3990498781,
-0.1107591242,
0.3004001379,
1.0406074524,
-0.7032271028,
-0.7772869468,
-0.5295663476,
-0.8641924262,
0.7042619586,
0.1371483505,
0.2320932597,
-0.154219687,
-0.1932336539,
0.156841442,
0.1914658397,
-1.1134516001,
-0.5262095928,
-0.1669718921,
-0.103351742,
0.2859914601,
-0.4857183099,
0.1137606129,
-0.163607344,
0.6828472614,
0.4569110572,
0.0414018072,
-0.1831262857,
-0.3457996845,
-0.13007541,
0.3904442489,
0.8800823092,
0.5692994595,
-0.2166136205,
0.0313949846,
0.0949230567,
-0.4259901941,
0.0671382248,
-0.0118070152,
-0.1932849139,
0.2571309209,
0.3341193199,
0.913374424,
-0.1120859534,
-0.8065977097,
0.5804209113,
-0.0930664465,
0.0315206647,
-0.7563020587,
-0.0064506494,
-0.1875168383,
0.0982135981,
0.338096559,
0.0766958818,
0.1013269126,
-0.337375313,
0.2429000437,
0.2790915966,
-0.6043226123,
-0.361833334,
0.5898310542,
0.0861303732,
-0.678243041,
0.3460486531,
-0.4045994282,
-1.0277875662,
0.4665068388,
0.4616806209,
0.6551412344,
-0.7252004743,
0.143917352,
0.431892097,
0.3342864215,
0.7470201254,
0.0812278911,
-0.0816712752,
-0.878608048,
-0.4673133194,
-0.8902029991,
-0.1818859428,
0.5296474695,
-0.5981492996,
0.3970071673,
-0.4733814001,
0.1182077006,
0.1646954864,
-0.2299692929,
-0.4722687602,
0.0274071265,
0.6647619605,
0.6327620745,
-0.9218989015,
0.5863827467,
0.374509424,
-0.1820173264,
-0.5995692015,
-0.386058718,
0.3954578638,
-1.0346488953,
0.7524997592,
0.111266017,
-0.1896713078,
-0.0378091149,
-0.4509889781,
-0.5276739597,
0.1275536269,
-0.0788909942,
-0.4915270507,
0.2203012407,
0.4584717453,
0.7647636533,
-0.1991434842,
0.3321094215,
0.4312275052,
0.5323717594,
-0.2359118462,
-0.7286758423,
-0.3499962687,
-0.1880754381,
-0.3208433092,
0.2690627873,
-0.6339606643,
0.8317877054,
0.2656244338,
-0.3776951432,
-0.0666012242,
0.5268465877,
0.06511987,
0.2717864811,
0.7076149583,
0.4942397773,
0.2885346413,
0.0731819347,
0.9607241154,
-0.1793197989,
0.0704778507,
0.9895604253,
-0.2657839954,
0.7508926392,
0.2838567197,
-0.2258107364,
0.5009041429,
0.5789404511,
0.0119808717,
0.2860693932,
0.4409449697,
-0.2573248446,
-0.2039547712,
-0.4971652329,
-0.3069669604,
0.8253601789,
0.5141071677,
-0.069760181,
-0.4609021544,
0.4414646327,
0.2578348517,
0.4462838471,
-0.4363946915,
0.7360199094,
-0.128734231,
-0.3848869801,
0.6750341654,
0.0038236638,
1.13808918,
-0.9433501363,
0.2330764681,
-0.1226801276,
0.0373945944,
-0.1105801538,
-0.5777692199,
0.8094165325,
0.4343624115,
-0.2016867697,
-0.1868404448,
0.8299292326,
-0.5646365285,
-0.235160619,
0.7907313704,
0.1068581194,
0.3661515713,
-0.0764439702,
-0.8425539732,
0.6383820772,
0.1805452108,
0.0376095101,
0.3026243746,
0.0361900367,
-0.3148031831,
0.60460186,
0.4103325903,
0.3331713378,
0.4862962365,
0.0831833482,
0.5421304107,
-0.3441849351,
-0.2975621819,
-0.8146159649,
0.2748570442,
-0.1969461441,
-0.3445840776,
0.9533122182,
0.6050654054,
1.3031601906,
-0.0607267916,
0.8594695926,
-0.332179904,
1.1209238768,
-0.0602468252,
0.8271672726,
-0.7168636918,
-0.2191182822,
-0.4639411867,
-0.6381944418,
-0.3509544134,
0.3129842877,
-0.4396046698,
-0.0813293308,
0.2510691881,
0.8889750242,
-0.0626149848,
0.0070694149,
0.4283833504,
0.4051100016,
0.4421768486,
0.2673894465,
1.1583104134,
-0.422421813,
0.6537277102,
-0.2317110598,
0.0056507173,
-0.1442208886,
-0.6379703879,
-0.7267165184,
-0.7078626156,
-0.2409231216,
-0.274715364,
0.049765978,
0.7270827889,
0.6094419956,
-1.0201159716,
-0.3545048237,
0.3476882577,
0.4133420885,
0.1799978614,
-0.2982706428,
0.0796381608,
-0.1472632438,
-1.039019227,
0.3587172031,
0.2855577469,
-0.206086576,
-0.1278187931,
-0.0879241079,
-0.6324290633,
0.3290257752,
0.7163581848,
0.4446320534,
-0.8613205552,
-0.4836111367,
-0.1960848421,
-0.1074617207,
-0.0200651735,
0.6263993382,
-0.4243754148,
0.2854768932,
0.4013871253,
0.8832623959,
0.139655292,
-0.1695972234,
0.0022512986,
-0.679094255,
0.4293562174,
0.3482882977,
0.1455265284,
0.4593763053,
-0.2121456414,
0.3775105476,
0.3328556418,
-0.6088899374,
-1.1735851765,
0.4754028618,
-0.9335182905,
-0.2114292979,
1.0711779594,
0.0956299305,
-0.3694660068,
-0.2438169271,
-0.1399188936,
0.3525182307,
-0.1704527736,
0.8289706111,
0.89506042,
0.013697763,
-0.0445254594,
-0.286062032,
0.7218859792,
0.6185532212,
-0.5433665514,
0.0023792263,
0.3924023807,
0.1851475537,
0.4208525717,
0.5091579556,
-0.1749938279,
0.2590346038,
-0.2865235209,
0.1465461105,
0.2358019054,
-0.1992287636,
-0.3358656168,
0.173866719,
-0.05794264,
-0.001241806
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05662v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05662v2
|
Understanding the Effect of Model Compression on Social Bias in Large Language Models
| 2023-12-09T20:04:20 | 2023-12-12T12:51:52 |
Gustavo Gonçalves, Emma Strubell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) trained with self-supervision on vast corpora of
web text fit to the social biases of that text. Without intervention, these
social biases persist in the model's predictions in downstream tasks, leading
to representational harm. Many strategies have been proposed to mitigate the
effects of inappropriate social biases learned during pretraining.
Simultaneously, methods for model compression have become increasingly popular
to reduce the computational burden of LLMs. Despite the popularity and need for
both approaches, little work has been done to explore the interplay between
these two. We perform a carefully controlled study of the impact of model
compression via quantization and knowledge distillation on measures of social
bias in LLMs. Longer pretraining and larger models led to higher social bias,
and quantization showed a regularizer effect with its best trade-off around 20%
of the original pretraining time.
|
[
-0.4000164568,
-0.6441073418,
0.5214470029,
0.267717123,
-0.3018560708,
0.1335726529,
-0.2840978801,
-0.4221009314,
0.3401674628,
0.3708693385,
-0.4576066732,
-0.2853117287,
-0.97504282,
0.0718969628,
-0.3573972881,
0.9734429717,
0.2579444945,
0.2314019203,
-0.3504076898,
0.2336305231,
-0.3313802779,
-1.1146458387,
-0.5063465834,
-0.2017026544,
0.5424477458,
-0.0178432278,
0.6403389573,
0.5670124888,
0.3428009152,
0.3516840041,
-0.4068447948,
-0.2654171884,
-0.8881474733,
0.1989803016,
0.0394789986,
-0.4892283678,
-0.3621617556,
0.1471462399,
0.6632454991,
0.744309485,
-0.0984038189,
0.4618735313,
0.5465250611,
0.6956768632,
-0.8552909493,
0.0857239366,
-0.471154958,
-0.1453095078,
-0.1466357112,
-0.1908051223,
-0.3673863113,
-0.3991266489,
-0.0486624986,
-0.302859813,
0.3000423014,
-0.0635800734,
0.6823866963,
0.5293094516,
-0.4916973114,
-0.0028833572,
-0.7480260134,
0.7364340425,
-0.6407019496,
0.2648685277,
0.4494508505,
0.1467516124,
-0.0542926416,
-0.4530241787,
-0.2819750905,
0.168699041,
-0.1547632366,
-0.2275894135,
-0.0691661313,
0.2615809441,
0.5337288976,
0.3586193919,
-0.1657366008,
0.2378229499,
-0.6921426058,
-0.1111463979,
0.7629421353,
-0.1261575371,
0.1237260997,
-0.3111390173,
-0.1342034936,
-0.2965167165,
-0.892180562,
-0.174766764,
0.6800330877,
0.1397794634,
-0.0503401868,
0.4021415114,
-0.2193362117,
0.5572599173,
0.1337673664,
0.0986948311,
-0.0328451023,
-0.178034544,
-0.191089958,
0.162210688,
0.9576075673,
0.4182499349,
0.8123972416,
0.1470528245,
-0.1192502156,
0.2324212044,
0.1640563756,
-0.857688725,
-0.0352236107,
-0.0844827145,
-0.6564621925,
-0.532284081,
-0.1186426282,
-0.7096551061,
-0.5455954075,
-0.3331007957,
0.2092123777,
0.0324722119,
-0.1792783141,
0.2365911752,
-0.3178970516,
-0.1656255722,
0.1916468292,
-0.900908947,
0.3477043808,
0.5404028296,
0.890131712,
0.0923381224,
0.0314497724,
-0.4536133707,
0.2410786897,
-0.0480134971,
0.6540299058,
-0.3418972194,
-0.3916015923,
0.0456681289,
-0.0540558174,
0.3700737655,
-0.469571054,
0.4329108298,
-0.5520631671,
-0.0233758315,
-0.382178396,
-0.5994724035,
0.1682383269,
0.0607447065,
-0.7273800373,
0.7383539677,
-0.0900647268,
-0.8345416784,
0.3140521944,
-0.0533630587,
-0.3460253477,
-0.120909676,
-0.2440621704,
-0.1580437571,
0.4432514906,
0.2625199258,
0.7657049894,
-0.3155063689,
0.3520203829,
-0.7657576203,
-0.4844372869,
0.1985667199,
-0.4613922238,
0.7126326561,
0.0866791829,
-0.3007644415,
-0.0721537173,
-0.5246062279,
-0.2454757243,
0.219193846,
-0.3261342943,
-0.9561468363,
-0.0585129485,
-0.3128463626,
0.2861524224,
0.1616239846,
-0.2475825399,
0.319906354,
-0.1692692637,
0.477019161,
1.110899806,
0.0328930281,
0.5555761456,
-0.2376069576,
0.4606172144,
-0.1756214499,
0.4982767403,
0.2601406872,
-0.1545769274,
-0.655089736,
0.0601466671,
0.4689989984,
0.0904507041,
-0.6738366485,
0.2483523488,
-0.4017450511,
-0.4758068025,
-0.5320967436,
0.1717911512,
0.3325433731,
-0.2361343205,
0.1227681339,
-0.1229065582,
-0.3594836295,
-0.8906350136,
-0.4861953557,
0.0314253606,
-0.2923343778,
0.0429858454,
0.4382254779,
-0.2270346284,
0.7228862643,
-0.6416101456,
-0.3228271008,
-0.0218750145,
0.2049697638,
-0.0985739008,
0.5237795115,
0.4059184194,
-0.5343863368,
-0.5005033612,
-0.6428492665,
-0.439013958,
-0.3950287104,
-0.0097331358,
-0.1403952539,
0.006526588,
0.5911809802,
-0.6016181707,
0.6297020316,
0.8773897886,
-0.1387691051,
0.6531933546,
-0.027510481,
0.1170020625,
-0.9260351062,
-0.405048579,
0.2401059717,
-0.1544641554,
-0.4442036152,
-0.1425013989,
0.0600255989,
0.0858419016,
-0.318015784,
0.376270175,
-0.860150516,
-0.207873404,
-0.1641127765,
0.2465751618,
0.2122797072,
0.2678289115,
-0.0243318807,
0.5750594139,
0.2926908731,
-0.6804645658,
0.0594006144,
-0.0699950755,
-0.481361717,
0.0873042792,
-0.9668156505,
0.4178130925,
-0.3147213459,
0.361112833,
-0.7369832397,
-0.0407907963,
-0.1299236566,
-0.3537709713,
0.4051514566,
-0.3626019955,
-0.7139376402,
-0.1520351022,
-0.5254235864,
0.6381758451,
0.510032475,
-0.4363407195,
0.4244061708,
0.5561522841,
-0.0485636964,
-0.4117485285,
-0.7263875008,
-0.149264127,
-0.4085630774,
-0.6618189812,
0.3825778365,
-0.0932457969,
-0.643502295,
-0.1914095283,
-0.1054381505,
0.0756034404,
0.0696727559,
0.3314117789,
0.2250877172,
0.2610712647,
0.2139841169,
0.3066633344,
0.2680330873,
0.2835560739,
-0.0794901326,
0.8368808031,
0.131706506,
-0.2471174002,
-0.2411699891,
0.1184775606,
0.3285123408,
0.0062023136,
1.011510849,
0.1813148707,
-0.1235054359,
-0.2126000375,
-0.8308610916,
-0.5286426544,
-0.5370463133,
0.1500176936,
-0.0102178538,
-1.1489355564,
0.3168306053,
-0.2588464916,
-0.3020914495,
0.1913023591,
0.3537328243,
0.1288330704,
1.1790112257,
0.5670452714,
-0.2544366717,
0.7111067772,
-0.2436356992,
-0.0288777854,
-0.8681185246,
0.0833597481,
-0.5393331051,
-0.2613158822,
-0.6527805328,
-0.4216613472,
0.244661063,
0.2819553614,
-0.1116953716,
-0.0194501821,
-0.5529276729,
0.5290933251,
0.4668238759,
0.2038120627,
0.1683484614,
0.0739424899,
0.3959739208,
-0.0211346429,
-0.8352436423,
-0.4955997765,
1.1506613493,
0.4345034957,
1.0219323635,
0.1018665582,
0.7748842239,
0.3706921935,
0.208357051,
-0.6100324392,
0.5263987184,
-0.1172578931,
-0.6443427801,
-0.2534822226,
-0.5916125774,
-0.919152379,
0.1484929621,
-0.3475114107,
-0.6084455252,
0.3424665034,
0.3768100739,
-0.4771239758,
0.017251052,
-0.7951033115,
0.6492022872,
-0.2126743793,
-0.5703961849,
-0.4355888665,
-0.6903612018,
0.4527384937,
-0.2023874223,
0.6311905384,
-0.03322329,
0.3310996294,
0.9510170221,
-0.424803555,
1.1912525892,
-0.0837918594,
0.0356715843,
-0.0214396715,
0.0772320777,
0.5712186694,
-0.0922759324,
0.1665104777,
0.5002440214,
0.3190664053,
-0.4564944506,
-0.6634432077,
0.4768574238,
-0.7935945988,
-0.8670737743,
-0.4202369153,
-0.3913350403,
-0.0830823407,
-0.0140310731,
0.2515693903,
0.4320065379,
-0.0667099655,
0.3006323576,
0.7801136971,
-0.4967734814,
0.0804549605,
0.3246848881,
-0.2881518006,
-0.1709933728,
0.3645566106,
0.2946592569,
0.7047513127,
0.0594798028,
0.291621834,
0.0534977429,
-0.2907861173,
0.1185723394,
0.4775852263,
-0.7832545042,
-0.1419080943,
-0.483050704,
-0.1030690223,
-1.1536403894,
0.0260331128,
-0.2505863011,
-0.3157658875,
-0.3159195185,
-0.1504909843,
0.1681806445,
1.0161691904,
-0.1391977668,
0.6312299967,
-0.7907034755,
-0.0064527094,
0.3283689618,
0.2075926214,
0.1557458788,
-0.550321579,
-0.3486763239,
0.0503109731,
-0.0543785617,
-1.0624399185,
0.3721652329,
0.0343399681,
0.2225518227,
0.6629397869,
0.2955734134,
0.7028483748,
-0.5728002787,
0.7284895182,
0.1242888346,
-0.8290160894,
0.4481107295,
-0.1498809904,
0.4373952448,
0.3457022011,
0.6029599309,
-0.5098779202,
-0.3726099432,
-0.5385150313,
-0.766300559,
0.4564879835,
-0.0235273913,
0.3099226952,
-0.2666033804,
0.4926290512,
-0.1700488925,
0.2798200548,
-0.9366067052,
-0.2577597499,
-0.0263198949,
0.0588799454,
-0.2083846182,
-0.9296944737,
-0.06591627,
-0.2758063972,
0.5882115364,
0.2025812417,
0.0785290152,
0.0272621345,
-0.2463733852,
0.041734647,
0.1907837838,
0.3065146804,
0.2390239984,
-0.098785907,
0.3771429062,
0.0189193096,
-0.2541219294,
0.0568587407,
0.0164061785,
-0.0449112244,
-0.1324700564,
0.4084575474,
0.8918462992,
0.2735998631,
-0.4174315333,
0.5968834162,
-0.2147869319,
-0.0443216674,
-0.3546470404,
-0.0246400405,
0.0350197032,
0.3748466969,
0.153152585,
-0.356541425,
0.194302842,
-0.6296420097,
-0.2746075392,
0.4657633007,
-0.1924101412,
-0.3007474244,
0.5685667992,
0.0916313902,
-0.2329181284,
0.3761107326,
0.0182792731,
-0.6546535492,
0.2912324071,
0.2774746418,
0.5315121412,
-0.3801876903,
-0.0118311364,
0.3169450462,
0.3117317855,
-0.3211697936,
-0.212521106,
-0.1482091844,
-0.7165711522,
-0.7968457937,
-0.7716200352,
0.0732616186,
0.0602219515,
-0.8153255582,
0.3138608932,
-0.3468015194,
-0.5686042905,
-0.1920082569,
-0.1586334705,
-0.6030715108,
0.0360249393,
0.2694067359,
0.6879352927,
-1.0035282373,
0.832062602,
0.2965450585,
-0.4494092166,
-0.968320787,
0.0629908293,
0.1388146281,
-0.6436650157,
0.9671217799,
0.1786950976,
-0.027942773,
0.0617477372,
-0.6794506311,
-1.0098595619,
0.8048753738,
0.5870380402,
-0.8116058707,
-0.3427716792,
0.3139005601,
0.5036237836,
0.0832342282,
0.0662768111,
0.4602906406,
0.1879432201,
-0.116248101,
-0.8705641627,
0.2470891625,
-0.0266921297,
0.2740307748,
0.2623202503,
-0.6761566401,
0.7021173835,
0.2519811988,
-0.3609802723,
-0.4850260913,
0.3819478452,
0.2146981806,
-0.073272638,
0.6259152293,
0.3005735576,
0.4643810093,
0.1003267467,
1.151143074,
-0.5295667648,
0.3188487291,
1.1249470711,
-0.197237581,
0.5333641171,
0.7041085362,
-0.2257106453,
0.4579507113,
0.760602653,
0.2727431655,
0.3808357716,
0.6074904203,
-0.2247872055,
-0.1535296291,
-0.228667438,
-0.324408412,
0.1261696517,
0.229386434,
-0.420735687,
0.2065312564,
-0.0658658221,
0.2559390366,
0.0543489829,
-0.4258540571,
0.7406190038,
0.3747320473,
-0.5957205892,
0.4922732711,
-0.2854779065,
1.0052537918,
-0.5293490291,
0.1759297699,
-0.2213612199,
-0.0662361905,
-0.2055957615,
-0.4660597146,
0.3328469992,
-0.0896725282,
-0.2295275331,
-0.4988142848,
0.9812952876,
-0.3978402317,
-0.2780204713,
0.6342425346,
0.4472608566,
0.2056640387,
-0.5557487011,
-0.2823265791,
0.3134084344,
-0.1600171328,
-0.4596748948,
0.7165490985,
0.5599354506,
0.0383006148,
0.5404094458,
0.5868292451,
0.3855057955,
0.2424409091,
0.3357706368,
1.0473976135,
-0.3110458553,
-0.2585375905,
-1.2286651134,
0.2172084451,
-0.4007644951,
0.1996462643,
0.9410899282,
0.2544439435,
0.9562442303,
0.1004147232,
0.6213620305,
0.1879484951,
0.0932821482,
-0.558906734,
0.8428761363,
-0.5582392812,
0.3622496426,
-0.5472622514,
-0.8356095552,
-0.08113233,
0.435120374,
-0.6972789764,
0.1527743042,
0.5776045322,
0.6218234897,
0.2366297543,
-0.3087384105,
0.3268576562,
0.2312022001,
0.1318376958,
0.1305276603,
0.9274605513,
-0.0398874693,
0.5059284568,
-0.3966640532,
-0.3177258074,
0.0490996279,
-0.8831096888,
-1.1292917728,
-0.4835489094,
-0.1933546662,
-0.5393629074,
0.1593361497,
0.9439722896,
0.8013296723,
-0.263558358,
-0.3749826849,
0.1599926203,
0.0802948251,
0.2609240711,
-0.2479012758,
0.3050093353,
-0.1952256858,
-0.6768496037,
-0.0565941148,
0.0375115685,
0.169744119,
-0.5595243573,
0.0497522764,
-0.1078975424,
0.0601188615,
0.7275825143,
-0.318354696,
-0.4010560811,
-0.2711419761,
-0.1640429646,
-0.0039207335,
-0.1989313811,
0.7678088546,
-0.7242870927,
0.1902175844,
0.3934879601,
0.2940118611,
0.54125458,
0.1399213374,
0.8083734512,
-0.8847376704,
0.2325142026,
-0.0818602443,
0.5100700259,
0.3881413043,
-0.6307705641,
0.4668653607,
0.2651101351,
-0.8937596679,
-0.9779458046,
0.286965698,
-0.4256201684,
-0.6319885254,
1.613653779,
-0.0007605114,
-0.3093074262,
0.1645767838,
-0.2325748205,
0.6783533692,
-0.3371101022,
1.1928021908,
0.8376031518,
0.2846218348,
-0.1020351127,
-0.5996744633,
0.6543444991,
0.2434802502,
-0.5862774253,
0.1211601719,
0.7216511369,
0.2655698061,
-0.0095647518,
0.6429507732,
0.210611403,
-0.2084814608,
-0.1847140938,
0.262313664,
0.1640530825,
-0.0016411555,
-0.6227573156,
0.0037637528,
0.1311344355,
0.3204475641
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2401.06774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2401.06774v1
|
Two Directions for Clinical Data Generation with Large Language Models: Data-to-Label and Label-to-Data
| 2023-12-09T19:35:40 | 2023-12-09T19:35:40 |
Rumeng Li, Xun Wang, Hong Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) can generate natural language texts for various
domains and tasks, but their potential for clinical text mining, a domain with
scarce, sensitive, and imbalanced medical data, is underexplored. We
investigate whether LLMs can augment clinical data for detecting Alzheimer's
Disease (AD)-related signs and symptoms from electronic health records (EHRs),
a challenging task that requires high expertise. We create a novel pragmatic
taxonomy for AD sign and symptom progression based on expert knowledge, which
guides LLMs to generate synthetic data following two different directions:
"data-to-label", which labels sentences from a public EHR collection with
AD-related signs and symptoms; and "label-to-data", which generates sentences
with AD-related signs and symptoms based on the label definition. We train a
system to detect AD-related signs and symptoms from EHRs, using three datasets:
(1) a gold dataset annotated by human experts on longitudinal EHRs of AD
patients; (2) a silver dataset created by the data-to-label method; and (3) a
bronze dataset created by the label-to-data method. We find that using the
silver and bronze datasets improves the system performance, outperforming the
system using only the gold dataset. This shows that LLMs can generate synthetic
clinical data for a complex task by incorporating expert knowledge, and our
label-to-data method can produce datasets that are free of sensitive
information, while maintaining acceptable quality.
|
[
0.1311337501,
-0.798261404,
0.9421291947,
-0.2129797786,
-0.235917747,
-0.2389774323,
-0.2042430043,
-0.5478407741,
0.3721490204,
0.6876919866,
-0.5345543623,
-0.9740264416,
-0.7871153355,
0.061124336,
-0.1338854581,
1.3774731159,
-0.0398792475,
0.1723668724,
-0.3585699201,
-0.0243515633,
-0.4377280772,
-0.5813682079,
-0.8275165558,
-0.4120216966,
0.5078216195,
0.4500668347,
0.6817909479,
0.832457602,
0.5301126838,
0.1915250421,
0.0445184112,
0.4718204439,
-0.1926898062,
0.1984053105,
0.2726246119,
-0.4065720141,
-1.0491635799,
-0.3188642859,
0.0800157487,
0.5233793259,
-0.1580158621,
-0.0392162539,
-0.1811104864,
0.7280965447,
-0.2835380435,
0.4547181726,
-0.3984096348,
-0.0161618944,
-0.4935342371,
-0.3399565816,
-0.4268298447,
-0.090100795,
0.0950346813,
-0.6443971992,
0.2301842421,
-0.0215625577,
0.8369045854,
0.2208732814,
-0.6113933325,
-0.7033149004,
-0.5490464568,
0.6521519423,
-0.8507269025,
0.2034497857,
0.6571698189,
0.1707581133,
-0.1217177436,
-0.8161774874,
-0.3157062829,
-0.3338180482,
-0.1761016697,
0.101440914,
-0.2005433887,
0.080377847,
0.0875406787,
0.501844883,
-0.6830691695,
0.286893338,
-0.5598186851,
-0.2317134589,
0.7794165611,
0.3799676001,
0.5001009703,
0.0190115254,
-0.1423750073,
0.1327018589,
-0.6371606588,
-0.3976494968,
-0.1801301539,
0.4440217614,
-0.0114892963,
0.6076721549,
0.088709116,
0.9615349174,
0.0847616941,
-0.4267692566,
0.4048552513,
0.0730748773,
-0.1499885619,
0.6255403757,
0.7217579484,
0.4412077665,
0.0094110267,
-0.2181022316,
-0.3235033751,
0.4779902697,
0.0301120225,
-0.5070636868,
-0.5567468405,
0.3739004433,
-0.4507011771,
-0.2120477855,
-0.3289621174,
-0.4336633086,
-0.5539010167,
-0.415486902,
0.4185851812,
-0.436609894,
-0.0633509159,
0.3237444162,
0.172650069,
-0.2841555178,
0.1273179352,
-0.6892012358,
0.3880788982,
0.6561444402,
0.6853840947,
-0.3141178787,
0.1391016841,
-0.7189663649,
0.4474769235,
-0.3054023385,
0.8162404895,
-0.3263446093,
-0.2355579138,
-0.0575579777,
-0.154257074,
-0.0927772969,
-0.6798861027,
0.4720285237,
-0.3912756443,
0.1426804364,
0.1132228673,
-0.6507942677,
0.0598043166,
0.0817363113,
-0.9266568422,
0.8674200177,
-0.0023356804,
-0.6234984994,
0.5921958685,
-0.3860209882,
-0.7206189632,
0.4033498764,
-0.3888111711,
-0.6182367802,
-0.0344087705,
0.2540302873,
0.695746541,
-0.4787012935,
0.5585615039,
-0.0397838727,
0.1245465875,
0.231461972,
-0.064640224,
0.2267202735,
0.1615506411,
0.0805877298,
-0.1773654521,
-0.8540375233,
-0.1581864953,
0.1602965444,
-0.4803186357,
-0.5881382227,
0.2058728188,
-0.1954023391,
0.1282398999,
0.2624337077,
-0.4886159003,
-0.1003466919,
-0.2549696267,
0.2347582281,
0.5101646185,
0.1523985416,
-0.012930789,
-0.7824926972,
0.4082477987,
0.3111082017,
0.0052107945,
-0.3182477355,
-0.689976573,
-0.3897092938,
-0.6578437686,
0.1040476412,
0.6591991186,
-0.3811118603,
0.7274821401,
-0.4519762695,
-0.3348195553,
-0.6779990196,
-0.0171110071,
0.3533861637,
0.7931394577,
0.5204181075,
-0.3229775429,
-0.2165257335,
-0.6391358376,
-0.0965734273,
-0.073120892,
-0.0437275767,
0.4375224411,
0.1152611673,
-0.4229131639,
0.6815185547,
-0.8338754773,
-0.8244375587,
-0.0534870252,
0.0828481615,
0.1499831378,
0.2173513323,
0.0715059638,
-0.6274201274,
-0.2887693644,
0.2625545561,
-0.7361899614,
-0.2511777878,
0.0359941758,
0.2093736976,
0.1310909539,
0.5854837894,
-0.5302026272,
0.2772777677,
0.5208405256,
-0.4251981676,
0.3174733222,
-0.4182009399,
-0.0453134403,
-1.0839399099,
0.0082359454,
0.1939604729,
-0.0839153826,
-0.8349204659,
-0.3962059319,
-0.2482554615,
-0.0916369185,
-0.0362969749,
0.5224654078,
-0.3566217422,
0.3426383436,
-0.0748176724,
0.0148438197,
0.1193909571,
0.0013901796,
0.1544074863,
0.2363149822,
0.7753633857,
-0.8242923617,
0.3004130125,
0.3245322704,
-0.2501072586,
0.3688322008,
-0.4496527612,
-0.07185027,
-0.4447714388,
0.1335778981,
-0.9659267068,
-0.3747497797,
0.1195790395,
-0.5083214641,
0.3905548155,
0.1137328222,
-0.5431549549,
-0.215841949,
-0.068618089,
0.4360473752,
0.4510450959,
-0.2127008587,
0.58412534,
0.5860127211,
-0.492405206,
-0.2057843357,
-0.944259882,
0.0275189709,
-0.3274851143,
-0.6659818292,
0.5418212414,
0.108672522,
-0.0953160375,
0.0678598136,
0.1078265384,
-0.1772039682,
-0.2719700634,
0.1406798512,
0.438305676,
-0.2495537847,
0.7072401047,
0.1760412157,
-0.1767989248,
0.1556867063,
-0.1049314141,
0.3028195202,
0.2116517127,
-0.3813297153,
-0.3881285489,
0.365878135,
0.5481958985,
-0.2248791903,
0.4447838366,
0.2146544456,
-0.4827192724,
-0.2722949386,
-0.2572099566,
-0.3131512403,
-0.3912758827,
0.3251208961,
-0.1437728405,
-0.6419599652,
0.3936941624,
-0.2529577911,
0.2182240784,
0.3542647064,
0.671102047,
0.2122898102,
1.4368652105,
0.3637361228,
0.0950171277,
0.0705458745,
0.0203368291,
0.3072015047,
-0.787486732,
-0.3962583542,
-0.2214818746,
-0.0466774888,
-0.4759726524,
-0.2908210754,
0.6079826951,
-0.3472628295,
-0.1598474383,
-0.2994467318,
-0.5573881865,
-0.0981455222,
0.0739224702,
0.5183883309,
0.453897655,
0.1647704244,
0.0836691484,
-0.2778584063,
-0.7397353053,
-0.6821236014,
1.4613447189,
0.2340333015,
0.7183821797,
0.0306341462,
0.7355487347,
0.4129522443,
0.7225908041,
-0.911914587,
0.4789881706,
-0.6989196539,
-0.3660915494,
0.0448737964,
-0.3344321251,
-1.1276119947,
-0.2217386067,
-0.1720608324,
-0.4259625971,
-0.0628767386,
0.3267241418,
-0.3941608071,
0.1044062227,
-0.6743798852,
0.6423977613,
-0.5781175494,
-0.094786182,
0.0527559817,
-0.5213738084,
0.3697323203,
-0.3938749433,
0.5563893318,
-0.038336698,
-0.1742255092,
1.0090169907,
-0.5572034121,
0.8472780585,
0.0798551217,
-0.3154965639,
0.2293463647,
0.1156867594,
0.4925093353,
-0.1053874865,
-0.0557670109,
-0.1674995869,
-0.2607227862,
-0.1450433284,
-0.3133441806,
0.7067808509,
-0.5482965112,
-0.4047794342,
-0.4925700724,
-0.6989084482,
-0.4707975686,
0.1634413898,
0.1615269184,
0.5564159155,
-0.0065132678,
-0.2660910189,
0.738512218,
-0.1293752939,
-0.3187681437,
0.6311735511,
0.1178540811,
-0.3385575116,
0.9978922009,
0.0496592112,
0.2478893995,
0.2602111101,
0.3287503421,
-0.1480891258,
-0.5687836409,
-0.2364474982,
0.6179295182,
-0.5910933614,
-0.1955590099,
-0.4397840798,
-0.031032145,
-0.361032635,
-0.0074428762,
0.0274906326,
-0.1539623737,
-0.5798355937,
-0.2840687335,
0.8562340736,
0.6456267238,
-0.0058430256,
0.3754987121,
-1.0240751505,
0.426223278,
0.2067831457,
0.0498715378,
-0.047680933,
-0.3229422867,
-0.1700880677,
0.0942094326,
-0.1762260497,
-0.8485577703,
0.6607047915,
0.4937424064,
0.3478132486,
0.6435061693,
0.0252785776,
0.6448158622,
-0.4756047726,
0.6829464436,
0.2970839143,
-0.3777002692,
0.5464996696,
-0.344311446,
-0.0720760003,
0.3154371977,
0.5394512415,
-0.3247597814,
-0.423871845,
-0.6899364591,
-1.1957874298,
0.7105256915,
-0.0667222217,
-0.1102273166,
-0.2195281535,
0.3334715664,
0.2313793749,
0.0841791779,
-0.3651821017,
-0.411534369,
0.3222305477,
-0.6938033104,
-0.2700932324,
0.0814627782,
-0.3207504749,
-0.0007134061,
0.5623217821,
-0.0409779437,
0.2809142172,
0.3808631003,
-0.0018537058,
-0.2660574019,
0.158277303,
0.1133421063,
0.5533897281,
-0.1423366815,
0.1975106895,
-0.1662836373,
-0.6191544533,
-0.1906439066,
0.2815278172,
-0.2102132142,
0.1491716653,
0.5217065215,
0.8425929546,
-0.2762313187,
-1.0082144737,
0.3708080947,
0.2184701711,
-0.1462153196,
-0.1748631895,
-0.0757177845,
0.0174758434,
-0.1422010511,
0.3074839115,
-0.2714693248,
0.148391813,
-0.5054603815,
0.4775419533,
0.3474122286,
-0.3864676654,
-0.2821719944,
0.6326376796,
-0.1045742184,
-0.2548830509,
0.5680884719,
0.1611854434,
-0.0980425924,
0.6101021171,
0.6879197955,
0.4326685965,
-0.2532164156,
0.2511711121,
0.0179261137,
-0.1035991758,
-0.2193676978,
0.4192627966,
0.1862840503,
-0.5895901322,
-0.4598968327,
-0.3698899746,
-0.0923597589,
0.5131893754,
-0.8984663486,
0.3609428406,
-0.0807889402,
-0.5861831307,
0.3646818399,
-0.2914231122,
-0.3963046968,
0.6212419271,
0.274035871,
0.5037608147,
-1.0974283218,
0.4322742522,
0.9797990322,
0.0642539561,
-0.6925592422,
-0.0527482815,
0.063878499,
-0.8332389593,
0.5317415595,
0.1005185843,
0.2455821037,
0.0616144352,
-0.3395959139,
-0.5851422548,
1.2521474361,
0.0430255458,
-0.4779094458,
-0.1056248322,
0.1174638495,
0.7481126785,
-0.5548744798,
-0.0919706076,
0.7109287977,
0.4320688844,
0.1760926694,
-0.8578644395,
0.2519582808,
-0.2208369374,
-0.3839900196,
0.4166395664,
-0.1500716805,
0.9074115753,
-0.3603247702,
-0.2385791242,
-0.1754921675,
0.3315078318,
0.7152549624,
0.6802732348,
0.2003719062,
0.8257312775,
1.0354846716,
0.1443676502,
0.9601711035,
-0.4337798357,
-0.0252272747,
0.6947699189,
-0.5515316129,
0.5571602583,
0.3025023639,
0.0429256894,
0.5668904185,
0.5235056877,
0.1557892412,
0.4302960932,
0.149393335,
-0.4585478902,
-0.4369743466,
-0.3052740097,
-0.2189367712,
-0.0657324195,
0.9638745785,
-0.5713675022,
-0.3154181242,
0.0780030191,
0.32290259,
0.0448659249,
-0.3998359442,
0.9497138858,
0.2867189646,
-0.5652074814,
0.633061111,
0.1174867377,
0.3596682549,
-0.8544788361,
-0.1581758857,
0.1251544952,
0.3370080292,
-0.2902348638,
-0.6917440891,
0.0352518037,
0.0198034514,
-0.0809445679,
0.0554916635,
0.7087556124,
-0.5785885453,
-0.6288401484,
0.0767223462,
0.5109567046,
0.423422426,
0.2079153359,
-0.4597433507,
-0.1818720549,
-0.2096515,
-0.123051703,
0.4376143217,
0.5882680416,
-0.5762917399,
0.6255787015,
0.6655588746,
0.6643199325,
-0.0723780096,
-0.0476838462,
0.8389502764,
-0.3879763484,
-0.5343881249,
-0.6827046275,
0.2893547118,
0.1778458059,
-0.2365079522,
0.4025995731,
0.5189737678,
0.2425378114,
-0.0277969074,
0.9961209893,
-0.0676388666,
0.5756646991,
-0.5419744849,
0.5212478638,
-0.5990042686,
0.1775290668,
0.1050935239,
-0.1889004707,
-0.5104215145,
0.280810982,
-0.4563369155,
-0.0034789641,
0.6649736166,
0.9020148516,
-0.0085083898,
-0.2777090073,
-0.0465546586,
0.4007229805,
0.3277568519,
0.9464586377,
0.2757766843,
-0.4177126586,
0.3653936684,
0.1920327842,
-0.4789808691,
-0.1685522348,
-0.6640408635,
-0.5940998793,
-0.5641259551,
-0.5584779978,
-0.4401150942,
0.1295703799,
0.6024070382,
0.4643429816,
-0.7414606214,
-0.0745589212,
-0.0964008048,
-0.2498677671,
-0.4138554633,
-0.1838982701,
0.875587225,
-0.0661878884,
-0.3327191472,
0.3056134582,
-0.0022798548,
0.0816109404,
0.1650745422,
-0.1396692544,
0.0562431142,
-0.0999950469,
0.6556165814,
0.2241109312,
-0.3660529852,
0.3356227875,
-0.0730205253,
-0.173693791,
0.0294955969,
0.7721890807,
-0.8031878471,
0.4227530956,
0.330126673,
0.2852987647,
0.3206035495,
0.2081718296,
0.4029898643,
-0.4809432328,
-0.2735802829,
0.5842681527,
0.0238796975,
0.3926795721,
-0.6644874811,
-0.0281541981,
0.0421290435,
-0.4978694022,
-0.7232593298,
0.227606073,
-1.0148910284,
-0.2007262707,
1.3316928148,
0.0873194858,
-0.2639734149,
-0.4592140019,
-0.1709784865,
0.1797182113,
-0.4418645799,
0.955822885,
0.2633003891,
-0.5822694898,
0.3505141437,
-0.578486383,
0.746224165,
0.2363011241,
-0.7858616114,
0.2324023098,
0.7708029747,
0.2327684015,
0.0701362118,
0.8921590447,
-0.3687702417,
0.3153729439,
-0.5176371932,
-0.064474076,
-0.2520396411,
-0.1176918522,
-0.1897605807,
-0.1271437854,
0.1618061513,
-0.0719358921
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05640v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05640v1
|
Keyword spotting -- Detecting commands in speech using deep learning
| 2023-12-09T19:04:17 | 2023-12-09T19:04:17 |
Sumedha Rai, Tong Li, Bella Lyu
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, eess.AS
|
Speech recognition has become an important task in the development of machine
learning and artificial intelligence. In this study, we explore the important
task of keyword spotting using speech recognition machine learning and deep
learning techniques. We implement feature engineering by converting raw
waveforms to Mel Frequency Cepstral Coefficients (MFCCs), which we use as
inputs to our models. We experiment with several different algorithms such as
Hidden Markov Model with Gaussian Mixture, Convolutional Neural Networks and
variants of Recurrent Neural Networks including Long Short-Term Memory and the
Attention mechanism. In our experiments, RNN with BiLSTM and Attention achieves
the best performance with an accuracy of 93.9 %
|
[
-0.5783913136,
-0.7735188603,
0.4111968577,
0.1961455792,
-0.4667900503,
0.2906018496,
-0.2993890643,
-0.433842808,
0.0430758707,
0.6630898714,
-0.6432601213,
-0.8473356366,
-0.6976748705,
-0.183884874,
-0.5732644796,
0.5323286057,
0.4142820537,
0.1303335428,
0.4534840882,
-0.0557266288,
-0.6023334265,
-0.7812586427,
-0.5812308788,
-0.2014936656,
0.6472888589,
0.516741395,
0.41073367,
0.551240921,
0.5500533581,
0.2729312479,
-0.484288156,
0.0455844477,
-0.1135721579,
0.2879236639,
0.1029882431,
-0.5090078115,
-0.1899324208,
0.0066442536,
0.5143096447,
0.5454427004,
-0.0348141342,
0.058752574,
0.266422987,
0.7063350677,
-0.7208066583,
0.3167728186,
-0.7237618566,
0.2181922048,
-0.4578512609,
-0.2338181734,
-0.1264541894,
-0.2395295948,
0.1815263182,
-0.1836343557,
0.6218464971,
-0.2036574483,
0.5093666911,
0.2472579479,
-0.1172254011,
-0.7341224551,
-0.8030980229,
0.7606824636,
-0.8044637442,
0.7550930977,
0.5420700908,
0.3644527197,
-0.0903661996,
-0.7305266261,
-0.536583364,
-0.4163030088,
0.2000046074,
0.0932586789,
0.0132168001,
0.3510261476,
0.1981986165,
0.2911497355,
-0.5084052682,
0.2379783839,
-0.2977539301,
-0.4053221047,
0.6242008209,
-0.0120240627,
-0.053749878,
-0.0943051428,
-0.0975672677,
-0.0223151036,
-0.5956584215,
0.2760779262,
0.1740949452,
0.5580918789,
-0.1485585868,
0.5808280706,
-0.4629826844,
0.7822790742,
-0.1144621,
-0.0917629153,
0.1866008937,
-0.5597732067,
-0.3970437944,
0.4319904447,
0.5275380611,
-0.1043242514,
0.3821206093,
-0.0701959282,
-0.0996897444,
0.2743168473,
0.0012879515,
-0.5931087136,
-0.4179641008,
0.0188652854,
-0.4748848677,
-0.6310766935,
-0.2983222306,
-0.5580813885,
-0.3799622655,
-0.465934664,
0.1376282722,
-0.3177623153,
-0.1026743203,
-0.0868635327,
-0.2648851573,
0.4423114657,
-0.023134781,
-0.9631479383,
0.0016594165,
0.8434287906,
0.7590686679,
0.1905365735,
0.0914798677,
-0.4955353141,
-0.111417152,
-0.2852325439,
0.5647929907,
-0.4672683179,
-0.7429081202,
-0.2118783444,
-0.0717432648,
-0.2353369296,
-0.6889972687,
0.651727438,
-0.5005913973,
-0.1237924024,
-0.0041733561,
-0.7293767333,
-0.4252655208,
-0.0099862162,
-0.5821672678,
0.6827223301,
-0.2169045806,
-0.3712886572,
0.425589025,
-0.7498434782,
-0.6797345877,
0.2992552817,
-0.1602740288,
-0.3989210725,
0.2948201299,
0.3446487188,
0.5826704502,
0.1056496352,
0.0714608878,
-0.4629030228,
-0.2944476306,
0.6558281779,
-0.7284224629,
0.6050769687,
0.4759691954,
-0.6156437397,
-0.0048101088,
-0.817460537,
-0.0074592032,
-0.2055441141,
-0.4917013049,
-0.1248171553,
0.2949573398,
0.1707031876,
0.183734253,
0.0564282723,
-0.4836502969,
-0.1605944633,
-0.5510264039,
0.5183939934,
0.3751896322,
0.1995837986,
0.2081728131,
0.2359819561,
0.4880096018,
-0.1145464405,
-0.0740958601,
0.0124294972,
-0.8356385827,
-0.4008297026,
-0.2444834709,
0.5404461026,
0.7358462811,
-0.2740784287,
0.6056882143,
0.0024741767,
-0.1836940199,
-0.7073358893,
0.382394731,
0.4431343079,
0.4882772267,
0.0333113745,
0.0316955335,
-0.5501782298,
-0.6731878519,
-0.3855945766,
0.1912347376,
-0.2050522864,
0.4872269034,
0.0589117445,
-0.0981365591,
0.8274102211,
-0.5157170296,
-0.6281610131,
-0.3045936525,
0.2012820244,
0.2983571589,
0.4192944765,
0.5081058145,
-1.1212744713,
-0.2959808707,
0.0150975129,
-0.4908913076,
-0.1167869717,
0.1842723489,
0.4702451527,
0.1275861412,
0.870644927,
-0.2056276202,
0.5842394233,
0.5651909113,
-0.1159879416,
0.0350780785,
0.0922423601,
0.0872867778,
-0.8875440955,
0.16212973,
0.0184460282,
-0.2328586876,
-0.7055525184,
-0.0058989446,
0.0996706486,
-0.4743513763,
-0.7253937125,
0.0521045662,
-0.3986678421,
-0.0765649229,
-0.5284358263,
0.2109998018,
-0.0052499305,
0.4689557552,
0.0921487585,
0.6359604597,
0.5087790489,
-0.7216756344,
0.5422295928,
0.0498155877,
-0.4235553443,
0.0968711004,
-0.4347665906,
0.3255083561,
0.1356871277,
-0.2127102166,
-1.3515803814,
0.1224763542,
0.1915499419,
-0.8726887703,
0.4752103686,
-0.3895388544,
-0.4984734356,
-0.4467499852,
-0.0733519271,
0.1491388828,
0.4882820845,
-0.4325743318,
0.231263265,
0.5004987121,
-0.2995224893,
-0.5413794518,
-0.6864497066,
0.186062336,
0.0123314233,
-0.2952975631,
0.2742230296,
0.3554615676,
0.1376181692,
-0.1023563519,
-0.1434757113,
-0.0624587685,
0.3035007715,
0.3313711286,
-0.0407173187,
-0.3563552499,
-0.0868477523,
0.0253446531,
-0.1423664838,
0.0446721911,
-0.2109013349,
0.8559532762,
0.1551747024,
-0.1839940995,
-0.7211686969,
0.372818023,
0.6438879967,
-0.6182084084,
0.1936111897,
0.7918555737,
-0.4791043699,
0.0509613417,
-0.4916687608,
-0.3150976598,
-0.5554465055,
0.5953434706,
-0.3782896399,
-0.8635430336,
0.3806132376,
-0.0112141417,
-0.0328841023,
0.2722139955,
0.4447585344,
-0.5948876143,
1.4290553331,
0.704978168,
-0.5058184266,
0.6055709124,
-0.3607352078,
0.3286605775,
-0.8341518044,
-0.1372582763,
-0.6973996758,
-0.5609459877,
-0.7130254507,
-0.2181634754,
0.1658809781,
0.3085570335,
0.2986924946,
0.3530760109,
-0.654098928,
0.0460661277,
0.6547228098,
0.3518098593,
-0.1399995387,
0.0107434876,
-0.1935885549,
0.0216143001,
-0.332646668,
-0.0759765282,
1.0569138527,
0.4908083677,
0.8817164302,
-0.3470025957,
0.8047257662,
0.3225930035,
0.0613258891,
-1.02386868,
0.5043931603,
-0.6085348725,
-0.6532360911,
-0.3635588288,
-0.1997799277,
-0.8972080946,
0.1677383631,
-0.1808052808,
-0.4859082103,
0.4781221747,
0.1597711146,
-0.4895337522,
0.1877441704,
-0.5558921695,
0.7214651704,
-0.3088922799,
0.3044687212,
-0.4878903627,
-0.6440650225,
0.1719232351,
0.1914303601,
0.1034397483,
-0.2762345076,
0.0390692502,
0.9046561718,
-0.0106739551,
0.8644147515,
-0.5583951473,
0.0714549571,
0.3220568597,
-0.2198111266,
0.2775822878,
-0.1033336818,
0.1863462031,
0.1858918816,
-0.2375909388,
-0.087521866,
-0.3220747709,
0.6115922332,
-0.3336237967,
-0.3996877372,
-0.2178841084,
-0.5368642211,
-0.2188345939,
0.1038025469,
0.2967149913,
0.3437994719,
-0.2174101025,
0.479540199,
0.8617369533,
0.0358696096,
0.8324840665,
0.418625772,
-0.164171353,
-0.5037686825,
0.9563989043,
0.1806417257,
0.0272710659,
0.6650275588,
0.2379303426,
-0.5041983128,
-0.9566975236,
-0.3574362695,
0.0046022609,
-0.3992351294,
-0.0761726573,
-0.7629808784,
-0.4623333812,
-0.7361308932,
0.101501815,
-0.0644725859,
-0.1251142621,
-0.5419156551,
0.0717636719,
0.2824068964,
0.1816824675,
0.1607925892,
0.6619951129,
-0.9917117953,
0.664084971,
0.5680972338,
0.0191034675,
-0.3468083739,
-0.4231293797,
-0.3511825204,
0.231207937,
-0.3167207539,
-1.2106666565,
0.6107745767,
0.2447687685,
0.6620998383,
0.6764442921,
-0.3450239003,
0.389911294,
-0.1175143272,
0.4692966938,
-0.14008753,
-0.9895746708,
0.6585505605,
-0.0899943784,
0.3910233676,
0.5727946162,
-0.0023582214,
-0.5656808615,
-0.4274329245,
-0.4238659739,
-0.610250473,
0.4322062433,
0.1945678741,
-0.2566557229,
0.2432991564,
0.3974964023,
-0.565541625,
0.5777564049,
-0.0371048488,
-0.2752459049,
-0.0061344607,
-0.3679336905,
-0.4739583135,
-0.1917984337,
0.1435276866,
-0.0446935259,
0.3153635859,
-0.0690737516,
0.2261388451,
0.2531096339,
-0.2960368395,
0.3808081448,
0.3811432719,
0.9390503764,
0.2560655773,
-0.417975992,
-0.0532678142,
0.3083091676,
-0.9828548431,
-0.1472496688,
0.2751555145,
0.0206741523,
0.4200260639,
0.0572679304,
0.5779144764,
0.3855002224,
-0.2765361965,
0.334782511,
0.1327270716,
-0.212055698,
-0.2747816741,
0.2732438147,
0.5264047384,
0.1796884835,
0.4060907364,
0.153400138,
0.5515223145,
-0.4194785655,
0.4543783069,
0.561532855,
-0.66808182,
0.1125802398,
0.4648615718,
0.1402937621,
-0.5893055201,
0.7366200686,
0.1627789289,
-0.9015207887,
1.0794922113,
0.2744221389,
1.0884603262,
-0.5843896866,
-0.2022455186,
-0.1804344207,
0.306381464,
0.5160726309,
0.6999706626,
-0.4561085403,
-0.5530614853,
-0.42116189,
-0.4392103255,
-0.4630211592,
0.2992491126,
-0.7579001188,
0.2773931324,
-0.5837556124,
-0.3132630587,
0.5732251406,
0.0993766934,
-0.8560859561,
0.4336014688,
0.6698440313,
0.9647594094,
-0.6313551664,
1.1755880117,
0.273478955,
0.0305024423,
-0.784013927,
-0.2587034702,
0.0942154527,
-1.1715531349,
0.7216277719,
0.3552517891,
-0.1696131676,
0.0636672378,
-0.6012659669,
-0.5658278465,
0.911275804,
-0.1928464025,
-1.21740973,
0.0699543655,
0.2540349662,
0.3206343353,
-0.343260169,
-0.3719295561,
0.7758080363,
0.3779906034,
-0.1913185865,
-0.8191682696,
-0.4730809629,
0.1723501533,
-0.0564234853,
0.2184209228,
-0.1416932493,
0.6242364049,
-0.1783167273,
-0.1521697342,
-0.0737861618,
0.6999179721,
0.4703969657,
0.7628233433,
0.6279793382,
0.550591886,
0.4548365474,
-0.0373347625,
0.560390532,
-0.2625011504,
0.2780553699,
1.0250256062,
-0.2766813934,
1.0413630009,
0.3448598087,
-0.1453608721,
0.1355623007,
0.5204208493,
-0.3031334281,
0.9235606194,
0.3328941464,
-0.4716198444,
0.0460421629,
0.1549604088,
-0.3597165942,
0.6426219344,
0.8910319209,
-0.6980183721,
-0.1600352675,
0.5063173175,
-0.1888346374,
-0.2466196269,
-0.4211650789,
1.0716153383,
0.3502507508,
-0.2319944799,
0.3656509221,
0.0545652434,
0.9125391841,
-0.520321846,
-0.1461465806,
-0.0019185496,
0.4374204874,
-0.2317689657,
-0.848125577,
0.2178535461,
-0.1982534528,
-0.2525551617,
0.0056502307,
0.7906296253,
-0.4736086428,
-0.5660005212,
0.2702219486,
0.1511601359,
0.136185661,
-0.687677145,
-0.8067755699,
-0.1126699224,
-0.000819728,
0.0992746949,
0.2032268643,
0.1319980025,
0.2639286518,
0.4911150336,
0.9234123826,
0.2119909823,
0.3771823645,
0.2767015994,
0.6092768312,
-0.9271373153,
-0.7807885408,
-0.8358851671,
0.0022345425,
0.1100745276,
-0.1698450893,
0.5386635661,
0.637393415,
0.5174309015,
-0.1005637273,
0.7513054013,
0.288803488,
0.7113984227,
-0.4184530675,
1.0651984215,
0.000504407,
0.1251089275,
-0.2268170267,
-0.6860790253,
-0.3187687099,
0.3082287908,
0.0033194772,
-0.2358900011,
0.345896244,
0.9691744447,
0.0591023192,
0.3371283412,
0.5121304989,
-0.2684889734,
0.4430207014,
0.623662889,
0.7985360026,
-0.431358844,
0.5307562947,
-0.6040551066,
-0.1984830648,
-0.480016768,
-0.5836231709,
-0.6181487441,
-0.4596728086,
-0.3945434093,
-0.2344478816,
0.1493701935,
0.4265987277,
0.9194988012,
-1.1936186552,
-0.1349968463,
-0.2087829411,
0.413618803,
-0.3634496331,
-0.2984111309,
0.4573880434,
-0.4217726886,
-0.5429244637,
0.6879549026,
0.2369297594,
0.269282192,
-0.2365300506,
0.2457273602,
-0.1791723967,
-0.2832619548,
0.559769094,
0.3776226044,
-0.6777848005,
-0.1118093729,
0.4018382132,
-0.2580027878,
-0.1642282456,
1.2175028324,
-0.8150784373,
0.2969821095,
0.7827332616,
0.5925958157,
0.5881274343,
-0.1686479449,
0.3358201981,
-0.5991293192,
0.1187137738,
0.5909477472,
0.2652880251,
0.1274252981,
-0.4165636003,
-0.0102088619,
0.3503850996,
-0.5833016634,
-0.7126823664,
0.0029652738,
-1.1583729982,
-0.1626446247,
0.6514482498,
-0.0010046286,
-0.2106288075,
-0.3555734754,
-0.2545376718,
0.4978277981,
-0.2091581672,
0.5247656107,
0.4157615304,
-0.235409677,
-0.4015812874,
-0.6474251151,
0.6100462079,
0.4663107693,
-0.3183405101,
-0.1614546925,
0.1135917753,
0.4938510656,
0.2766750157,
0.2191411257,
-0.2344679832,
0.4242936671,
-0.1492352635,
0.0581289455,
0.0080547081,
-0.2646091282,
-0.7285651565,
0.3872556686,
-0.1270871907,
-1.2080080509
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05621v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05621v1
|
PILLOW: Enhancing Efficient Instruction Fine-tuning via Prompt Matching
| 2023-12-09T17:38:39 | 2023-12-09T17:38:39 |
Zhenting Qi, Xiaoyu Tan, Shaojie Shi, Chao Qu, Yinghui Xu, Yuan Qi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction fine-tuning has conventionally been employed to adapt Large
Language Models (LLMs) to a variety of tasks. Nonetheless, this technique often
necessitates substantial computational resources, making it impractical for
deployment by individuals or small-scale entities. Recently, Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) has become a promising alternative, offering high
capabilities on par with full tuning with reduced resource overhead. However,
attaining satisfactory performance through the fine-tuning of LoRA is a
non-trivial challenge. In this paper, we propose PILLOW, which aims to improve
LoRA's performance by a discrimination-based prompting method, leveraging LLMs'
In-Context Learning ability. PILLOW incorporates a matching network that
selects prompts from a user-defined prompt pool, concatenates the selected
prompts with the user instruction as input, and performs inference using the
LoRA-fine-tuned LLMs. Trained with Reinforcement Learning, PILLOW exhibits
commensurate performance on various evaluation metrics compared with typical
instruction fine-tuning methods, utilizing only consumer-grade GPU resources
and exhibiting a large reduction in computational costs.
|
[
-0.1451554298,
-0.9717039466,
0.1963530332,
0.3223383725,
-0.3050791621,
0.0496591814,
-0.5220522881,
-0.189262554,
0.0345829092,
0.2641576529,
-0.5750385523,
-0.3384185135,
-0.3775292337,
0.1775434166,
0.2258357704,
0.7575531006,
0.3219644427,
-0.1977878511,
-0.2459517866,
-0.0505377837,
-1.0838551521,
0.2170401365,
-1.1678858995,
-0.1193194687,
0.5525830388,
0.9558368325,
0.3326619565,
0.6255763173,
0.2102080733,
0.3624642789,
-0.1922942847,
0.5927231908,
-0.5980299711,
0.3109321892,
-0.3031847179,
-0.6688138247,
-0.2931720018,
-0.1820527464,
0.6332623959,
0.4793922603,
-0.0821921006,
0.2879267931,
0.4456766248,
0.8609243035,
-0.947678268,
0.0365968309,
-0.8416580558,
0.0686586276,
0.0461616367,
-0.4317539632,
-0.6910615563,
-0.3867600262,
-0.2258504927,
-0.7007910609,
0.1201212853,
0.3552390337,
0.6134930849,
0.5962926149,
-0.0604090579,
-0.255199343,
-0.3520905674,
0.8350045681,
-0.5348607302,
0.1013719216,
0.4817682207,
0.558881104,
-0.6558253169,
-0.198211804,
-0.4255824387,
-0.0553074069,
-0.0498624817,
0.1040902212,
0.0458928123,
0.0726496205,
0.3390573561,
0.3115186691,
-0.2904928029,
0.5429136753,
-0.244557783,
0.0372353569,
0.3942097425,
0.0478027649,
0.2452929169,
-0.3386858106,
-0.1877724379,
-0.0293616354,
-0.6372330785,
0.5806530118,
0.1778611243,
0.845125854,
-0.150573954,
0.3145875931,
-0.2317151427,
1.0468111038,
0.4201005697,
-0.2139941156,
0.0468864962,
0.2433541268,
-0.332927078,
0.3769031763,
0.3730586767,
0.3640078604,
-0.0953013077,
0.0787971094,
-0.187135607,
-0.1041212752,
0.0091302292,
-0.9554323554,
-0.1213562787,
-0.1239239722,
-0.4482064545,
-0.2485828549,
-0.2409251183,
-0.9389287829,
-0.7953588367,
-0.3465202451,
0.6354240179,
-0.2832711339,
0.0962661132,
0.2525094151,
0.0140010761,
0.6470720768,
0.7040335536,
-1.0424326658,
0.1576465517,
0.7700173259,
0.9313638806,
-0.3529879749,
-0.0235812496,
-1.4188396931,
0.039528735,
-0.3051724434,
0.9271661639,
-0.8161870837,
-0.3298559189,
0.0340079293,
0.0745025054,
-0.2848955393,
-0.7003561854,
0.4416334927,
-0.3251182437,
0.4680233598,
-0.2605511248,
-0.3975850642,
0.0711107254,
0.0968852341,
-0.4507623315,
0.8522699475,
0.2516856492,
-0.4141403735,
0.3746916652,
-0.8557571769,
-0.6461696625,
-0.0376582406,
-0.2043447644,
-0.5536001921,
0.380420804,
0.5706986785,
0.4745347798,
-0.3027743995,
-0.4845632613,
-0.2416676879,
-0.9963374734,
-0.0594262443,
-0.0558513962,
0.713529706,
0.2147520036,
-0.183538273,
0.368080616,
-0.8379632235,
-0.1993285865,
-0.0595254675,
-0.4811934233,
-0.3167900741,
-0.1617292613,
-0.3592265546,
-0.1862141043,
0.0538731888,
-0.2689042091,
0.4795869291,
-0.255205214,
0.4724218249,
1.1569645405,
-0.064036794,
0.556628406,
-0.5433956981,
0.612118721,
-0.0991853327,
-0.0309105627,
-0.0855784863,
-0.3747803271,
-0.8473116159,
-0.7075257897,
0.1842922717,
0.5601986647,
-0.8273700476,
0.2411685288,
0.0426003076,
-0.1514484733,
-0.7842957377,
0.2702279687,
0.4236001372,
0.7308149338,
0.4544237852,
0.1368966103,
-0.4011226594,
-0.4716445208,
-0.3912130296,
-0.0794417411,
-0.0801410526,
0.6624174118,
-0.0681951791,
0.103211008,
0.6862243414,
-0.574839592,
-0.6849229932,
-0.1068215668,
-0.0444858558,
0.5456399322,
0.7128968835,
0.4229289591,
-0.2455628067,
-0.5555858612,
-0.0183463898,
-0.4082520902,
-0.1975069642,
-0.1598595232,
-0.3803039789,
0.3205435574,
0.8776997924,
-0.2877408266,
0.2039301246,
0.4017708004,
-0.4781567752,
0.3198902905,
-0.4404341877,
0.2983055115,
-1.1722234488,
-0.2631709278,
-0.1287232935,
-0.1425558031,
-0.1015665978,
-0.1246628091,
-0.0662680641,
-0.1989520192,
-0.2771633267,
0.7528498173,
-0.3382115662,
-0.0497350954,
-0.3238106966,
0.1410258859,
0.1012578011,
0.5337607265,
-0.202579692,
1.2239034176,
0.5880259275,
-0.8065695167,
0.0363043956,
0.4323634505,
-0.5698917508,
0.9739185572,
-0.4629817605,
0.2857762277,
-0.1477131397,
0.1180987358,
-0.8823206425,
-0.3781141341,
0.1871395707,
-0.211821422,
0.2916017473,
-0.481965214,
-0.0862934068,
0.0614320599,
-0.2787340879,
0.257507503,
0.9379224181,
-1.0175859928,
0.683177948,
-0.0767380893,
-0.1526079774,
-0.5960832238,
-0.1866199672,
-0.2923469841,
-0.4293068945,
-0.2215723395,
0.4101812243,
-0.1162102446,
0.1139370948,
-0.2179028243,
-0.1278436482,
0.1352767944,
0.4014208019,
0.2990415692,
0.0228984151,
-0.5508881807,
0.3226605058,
0.3448186815,
0.1404805034,
-0.2587591708,
-0.1426578164,
0.251411587,
-0.0829705074,
-0.1126128361,
-0.6968021393,
-0.0248088669,
0.3003001213,
-0.098228462,
0.574878633,
0.7544634342,
-0.2161061913,
-0.7614479661,
-0.3091188371,
-0.32511729,
-0.5866392255,
0.2339172959,
-0.6313967109,
-1.005384922,
0.3608291745,
-0.324310869,
-0.0746900886,
-0.1010308713,
0.1953443438,
-0.2990579307,
0.7736541033,
0.6416484714,
0.0740127861,
0.9733945131,
0.1556955278,
0.0226315912,
-1.049413085,
-0.1796507835,
-0.7816795111,
-0.7156063914,
-0.5742175579,
-0.462141037,
0.2662043273,
0.4803651273,
-0.480815798,
0.1450876892,
-0.7431501746,
0.9173226953,
0.6537752748,
0.4223025143,
0.189868167,
0.2220923156,
0.1095862314,
0.1725841016,
-0.6025173068,
-0.1863076538,
0.5120187402,
-0.0272358432,
0.7963451147,
0.3037005663,
0.6096209288,
0.45367378,
-0.0109129874,
-0.7664215565,
0.6480621099,
-0.3803528547,
0.0794776902,
-0.4880365729,
-0.5136500001,
-1.1670832634,
0.1718085259,
-0.4358774722,
-0.7513371706,
0.2426481247,
0.2662716806,
-0.8652877808,
0.0558404364,
-0.8871557713,
0.7948806286,
0.0914827883,
-0.5894902349,
-0.3152961731,
-0.0188469868,
0.1439629495,
0.166038096,
-0.1632982045,
-0.4576518238,
-0.0546387024,
0.7033601403,
-0.1156485304,
0.7233573794,
-0.549726367,
0.0413382165,
-0.0525887609,
0.2369574159,
0.5713464022,
0.1832989007,
-0.4138015807,
-0.4664150178,
-0.2291821092,
-0.738257587,
-0.8562529087,
0.92294842,
-0.9151582718,
-0.8750861287,
-0.2792545259,
-0.6759940982,
-0.4462706745,
0.066537872,
-0.0521116666,
0.3415178955,
-0.09220732,
0.1830070913,
0.8159399629,
-0.6796934009,
0.4246377349,
0.5476144552,
-0.2779911458,
-0.2332313806,
1.08946383,
-0.2985799909,
-0.0720625073,
0.5782821774,
0.5302178264,
-0.1061905473,
-0.5085761547,
-0.5726834536,
-0.0452470295,
-0.5277443528,
-0.4900270402,
-0.2480996996,
0.111172691,
-0.1731292158,
-0.5384765863,
0.0141745349,
-0.292824626,
-0.5950663686,
0.2755790651,
0.8408746719,
0.4636877477,
0.1248335987,
0.6807951331,
-0.2521003485,
0.4281183183,
0.6810460687,
0.5275209546,
-0.2169575095,
-1.0362496376,
-0.0586516932,
-0.3384162784,
-0.0117361331,
-0.2656108439,
-0.2337999344,
0.5884184241,
0.2776314318,
0.1940232664,
0.4936836064,
1.1026896238,
-0.5305704474,
0.3876462579,
-0.0754399598,
-0.968832314,
0.7419933081,
-0.2079420835,
0.4093216658,
0.7367704511,
-0.0788290724,
-0.3359966576,
0.0671197921,
-0.0301906541,
-0.437846452,
0.9246318936,
-0.3291131556,
0.3482069373,
0.0131686768,
0.5318443179,
0.1924798042,
-0.137464419,
-0.2047654837,
0.309658438,
-0.0826224163,
-0.2744381726,
0.0731468871,
-0.0810045227,
0.0411152653,
-0.3127378523,
0.751630187,
-0.5704672337,
0.3112582564,
-0.1169753969,
-0.3201655149,
-0.072627075,
0.2123232633,
0.8132871985,
0.2955584824,
-0.3352422118,
-0.0332483314,
0.3692559302,
-0.1803295612,
0.0471246876,
0.0388718061,
-0.2348840386,
-0.259794265,
0.1577170789,
1.0802972317,
0.3150930107,
-0.4384895265,
0.5349946618,
-0.3366793394,
0.3400721252,
0.0079911742,
0.7615941763,
-0.1773250997,
0.4238827825,
0.0535272844,
0.1005457863,
-0.1634032577,
-0.3442795575,
-0.001429063,
0.4643164277,
-0.4977050126,
-0.0047028824,
0.4422000349,
0.5184736848,
-0.69384408,
0.693947494,
-0.3981930912,
-0.0786637217,
0.4181170166,
0.7728917599,
0.7397555709,
-0.3754102588,
0.3527341187,
0.6068564057,
-0.0323194526,
0.094675824,
0.4357283413,
-0.1460823715,
-0.2835170627,
-0.5425342321,
-0.6805859804,
-0.4023119807,
0.1549893022,
-0.6921287775,
0.6274242401,
-0.842695117,
0.2512308359,
-0.2719437182,
0.0429735184,
-0.5882941484,
-0.21700041,
0.0304567255,
0.9703970551,
-0.6963974237,
0.6702920198,
0.5558732152,
-0.3159208298,
-0.4992017746,
0.0948422402,
-0.212716341,
-1.0258352757,
0.4225869477,
0.385684967,
-0.2980698347,
0.1620905548,
-0.4332178235,
-0.372438103,
1.0472601652,
0.6608043909,
-0.6045225859,
0.0266678873,
-0.1719760299,
0.175491035,
-0.4590496719,
0.3106091321,
0.5650961399,
0.089506492,
0.0244533103,
-0.6707104445,
0.3172603548,
-0.0299417339,
0.1058744565,
-0.1319255978,
-0.7266184688,
0.7542470694,
-0.3176522851,
-0.1446126997,
0.2076293379,
0.9471687078,
0.4270228744,
0.2069770247,
0.7066320777,
0.1466274858,
1.1690348387,
0.0016957747,
0.6417911649,
-0.1325388849,
-0.084547475,
1.3782389164,
-0.3175400198,
1.0109226704,
0.4533652663,
0.0746972635,
0.7970631123,
0.6380067468,
0.2435137182,
0.5609006286,
0.5766630769,
-0.2075269967,
-0.4635254443,
-0.448687166,
-0.2865639329,
0.5367029309,
0.4416766465,
0.0106009534,
-0.0783820376,
0.1356651187,
-0.1658347696,
0.3572139144,
-0.6046352386,
1.0541821718,
0.0528799817,
-0.8280511498,
0.9361911416,
-0.1996742636,
0.6717184186,
-0.3051610887,
-0.4369778037,
-0.5564571023,
0.3607009351,
-0.2044788003,
-0.3477383852,
-0.2342171669,
-0.1252416074,
-0.3161813319,
-0.0431098081,
0.6247121096,
-0.3187192976,
-0.3290400505,
0.0313427821,
0.3353603482,
-0.0114375493,
0.0878754631,
-0.7250312567,
0.3002333343,
-0.1265928894,
0.0377495699,
0.4907545745,
0.6376670003,
-0.1004977673,
0.6380670071,
0.644697547,
-0.0458710119,
-0.198018685,
0.0971228927,
0.6905204058,
-0.639479816,
-0.6014968157,
-0.5532935858,
0.2828806043,
-0.125670746,
-0.407168597,
0.4428496063,
0.3563106954,
0.7884043455,
-0.1499364525,
0.548778832,
0.0937211514,
0.4985030591,
-0.9176080227,
0.5111310482,
-0.5602959394,
0.432202965,
-0.1706615984,
-0.9617078304,
-0.2211286575,
1.0155615807,
-0.2914453149,
-0.0537455007,
0.4835498929,
0.9929839969,
-0.3021191359,
-0.1188352332,
0.3293189704,
0.1402866095,
0.1339046657,
0.6013457179,
0.8248777986,
-0.278036505,
0.3152267337,
-0.0050307368,
-0.4355417788,
-0.8082244992,
-1.11203444,
-1.2454236746,
-0.4025553167,
-0.4689076841,
-0.5959112644,
0.4839138985,
1.444593668,
0.7035255432,
-0.8605364561,
-0.137943238,
0.1258772314,
0.4901318848,
-0.5652418733,
-0.1334307641,
0.7873601913,
-0.8211198449,
-0.7475141287,
0.606901288,
0.1107575744,
-0.1936972886,
0.0961917117,
-0.2652165294,
0.1514906734,
0.2074570954,
0.6651934981,
0.4186779559,
-0.5434582829,
-0.5094566941,
-0.0173462592,
-0.0583928339,
0.1717144996,
0.618557632,
-0.9584752321,
0.4083028734,
0.4960440099,
1.1275982857,
0.1045917198,
-0.023430109,
0.3052200973,
-0.8142420053,
0.2261997014,
0.0835449025,
0.2356253564,
0.3872748613,
-0.4080348313,
0.2938901186,
-0.1647162139,
-0.5444352627,
-1.0456155539,
0.3209401369,
-1.0194015503,
-0.2793736756,
1.0682858229,
0.0141337356,
-0.4955456555,
0.0060299938,
-0.5549735427,
0.1463558078,
-0.641289413,
1.2439405918,
0.2530346513,
-0.1740309745,
-0.3918287158,
-0.2863539457,
0.9465571046,
0.6532509327,
-0.8402499557,
0.0690918267,
0.2905412614,
0.011836064,
-0.2480339706,
0.4363131225,
0.4194563031,
0.4842922986,
-0.3690054715,
-0.3110080361,
-0.2415057272,
-0.2258135676,
-0.4719027281,
-0.0345114805,
0.4147815406,
-0.5663866401
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05603v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05603v2
|
Sim-GPT: Text Similarity via GPT Annotated Data
| 2023-12-09T16:10:23 | 2023-12-12T08:04:30 |
Shuhe Wang, Beiming Cao, Shengyu Zhang, Xiaoya Li, Jiwei Li, Fei Wu, Guoyin Wang, Eduard Hovy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Due to the lack of a large collection of high-quality labeled sentence pairs
with textual similarity scores, existing approaches for Semantic Textual
Similarity (STS) mostly rely on unsupervised techniques or training signals
that are only partially correlated with textual similarity, e.g., NLI-based
datasets. To tackle this issue, in this paper, we propose the strategy of
measuring text similarity via GPT annotated data (Sim-GPT for short). The core
idea of Sim-GPT is to generate data with STS labels using GPT-4, based on which
an STS model is trained. Sim-GPT framework utilizes LLMs to provide a
substantial amount of reliable annotated data filling the gap of the lack of
training signals for STS. Sim-GPT is trained on a one-time generated dataset
using BERT or RoBERTa as the backbone, which offers long-term savings in cost
and speed compared to repeatedly invoking LLMs for each sentence pair. Trained
on the examples from GPT-4 (371K), Sim-GPT yields SOTA performances on the
widely-used seven STS benchmarks: +0.99 over supervised-SimCSE, and +0.42 over
the current SOTA PromCSE model. To encourage further advancements of the field,
we release both models and the 371K annotated examples from GPT-4. Code, models
and annotated data are available at: https://github.com/ShuheWang1998/Sim-GPT.
|
[
-0.2199388742,
-0.6747131348,
0.842538774,
0.2578266859,
-0.6677368283,
-0.2353078127,
-0.0932630002,
-0.3338637948,
0.1174587607,
0.4858486652,
-0.7942536473,
-0.683231473,
-0.304387033,
0.3844920397,
-0.3320669532,
1.2970322371,
-0.2881843746,
0.0614736006,
-0.520984292,
0.1196517944,
-0.0776793286,
-0.6234804392,
-0.4315629005,
-0.193832323,
0.2973971069,
-0.0713142231,
0.6406798363,
0.6480084658,
0.5942969918,
0.2134243697,
0.1087739244,
0.1037600785,
-0.5318713188,
-0.180555135,
-0.0664507225,
-0.244337216,
-0.3266851008,
0.2151102573,
0.613027513,
0.2056048959,
0.1809074581,
0.1528268307,
0.189902693,
0.45738855,
-0.0914749354,
0.3190736771,
-0.5992770791,
-0.026921289,
-0.4424435794,
-0.3905564845,
-0.0766992122,
-0.5312107801,
0.0771053284,
-0.7828794122,
0.2914165854,
0.1698595136,
1.2285275459,
0.3210757673,
-0.3976246417,
-0.2912865579,
-0.157621786,
0.7734258771,
-0.783313036,
0.1722629666,
0.2514725626,
0.0759942159,
-0.2002079338,
-0.5740613937,
-0.7981709838,
-0.5534940362,
-0.1245294288,
0.399600327,
0.3435285985,
-0.1020464599,
0.3044519126,
0.3115755618,
-0.8337160945,
-0.2092879266,
-0.0023620867,
-0.10268794,
0.629427731,
0.1487839371,
0.2972961366,
-0.3198111057,
-1.1569669247,
-0.086838156,
-0.6198362112,
-0.3827365339,
0.6575422883,
0.3126679957,
-0.0227968115,
0.5629761219,
-0.1208086014,
0.4686327875,
-0.5148193836,
-0.1200554967,
0.5885556936,
-0.6515146494,
-0.2920026779,
-0.0693325922,
1.0846123695,
0.4161679447,
0.5868656635,
-0.2500979602,
-0.2792455256,
0.1190583929,
0.1587886512,
-0.6805949211,
-0.127855435,
-0.4148855209,
-0.4526122212,
-0.3159816265,
0.3239859045,
-0.6175480485,
-0.1208869591,
-0.6337167621,
0.5771102905,
-0.6434781551,
-0.0024134356,
-0.009708534,
-0.0312101487,
0.2339801192,
0.0985112786,
-0.8075919151,
0.6221549511,
1.009450078,
1.0527513027,
-0.5176019073,
-0.4244084954,
-0.1083736345,
0.2165266722,
-0.179090783,
0.8441596627,
-0.3891799152,
-0.3090291023,
-0.2648095191,
-0.2648157179,
-0.331754148,
-0.3644712567,
0.9326072931,
-0.154605791,
0.0191623271,
-0.3799797595,
-1.0165275335,
-0.0656063706,
0.5144870877,
-0.5664870739,
1.4808461666,
0.1046793461,
-1.1435033083,
0.3889185786,
-0.5843786597,
-0.2202030122,
0.2013393641,
-0.3844728768,
-0.7841957211,
-0.1122296304,
0.1327607781,
0.5449903011,
-0.4191807806,
0.1440892518,
-0.2811198235,
-0.6836484075,
0.1588459909,
-0.5323523879,
0.4987367094,
0.1313789189,
-0.1973353475,
0.1113890931,
-0.5731006861,
0.1046090126,
0.1653756499,
-0.2308568358,
-0.7094466686,
-0.3261286318,
0.4095360935,
0.1331846267,
0.2549198568,
-0.6350106001,
0.3344216943,
-0.3518951237,
0.2712161839,
0.5884926319,
0.1712365448,
0.0667057782,
-0.4998210669,
0.3511057794,
-0.2126420289,
0.0821235701,
-0.0179057531,
-0.5261852741,
-0.181697458,
-0.4718410969,
0.6878725886,
0.5716231465,
-0.7205870152,
0.2437407672,
-0.8139392734,
-0.4666347802,
-0.5160725713,
-0.0800292864,
0.3149923384,
0.2956980169,
0.4610463381,
-0.1848754585,
-0.3428580165,
-0.9488906264,
-0.5631071329,
-0.0957848653,
-0.1761721969,
0.296377629,
0.5660076141,
-0.1017533019,
0.9931762815,
-0.4776112735,
-0.5058457851,
-0.1312963367,
0.3525700867,
0.0173170697,
0.3250410855,
0.5821982026,
-0.8838483095,
-0.6243005991,
0.0095030032,
-0.7533479333,
-0.2385959029,
-0.3670809269,
-0.0005751743,
0.1635383666,
0.6211779118,
-0.6964825988,
0.49416852,
0.3606818914,
-0.1510034949,
0.5324755907,
-0.1836280227,
0.4547207355,
-1.287042737,
0.0266113132,
-0.100480929,
-0.306869626,
-0.4641122222,
-0.1588351429,
0.0134701338,
0.1771764457,
-0.3216590583,
0.5289340615,
-0.3983899653,
-0.2534927428,
-0.088678889,
0.2491558194,
-0.3042346835,
0.3428233564,
-0.0822287276,
1.089902997,
0.3118146062,
-0.3376995623,
0.2845767736,
0.3254351914,
-0.4196197689,
0.4841215014,
-0.3587703705,
0.118876569,
0.1552516669,
0.3255577981,
-0.8923126459,
0.0826540813,
0.263848722,
-0.3421153128,
-0.0571495332,
-0.1344558299,
-0.760094583,
-0.128447637,
-0.553627193,
0.3933960795,
0.4384595156,
-0.3914856017,
0.5204461217,
0.109366402,
-0.5058649778,
-0.4228746891,
-0.5883126855,
0.1869689524,
-0.3311440349,
-0.5007951856,
0.4226713479,
0.0522763878,
0.064194873,
0.1338661909,
-0.0599250235,
0.0335368812,
-0.0858641788,
0.3877293468,
0.3524726629,
-0.1843806207,
0.3402268887,
-0.0076180222,
-0.3072012067,
-0.0076023578,
-0.4196926653,
0.4420084953,
-0.0943426937,
-0.4792832434,
-0.2473212481,
0.2133340985,
0.0643174499,
0.0799152553,
0.5798193812,
0.69092834,
-0.2094278187,
0.031373702,
-0.3927204609,
-0.0032985429,
-0.3475209773,
0.1876690686,
-0.7455158234,
-0.8772655129,
0.1480367184,
-0.3901304305,
-0.1039421484,
0.4140940607,
0.4512158632,
-0.0270992778,
0.4823055267,
0.4450446069,
-0.2168405354,
0.2966479063,
0.0320228003,
0.1393221021,
-0.4722670913,
-0.1273238957,
-0.4471920729,
-0.063909255,
-0.7340794802,
-0.6147838235,
0.0705133528,
-0.1169769168,
-0.2177455276,
0.3057805896,
-0.1859438717,
0.5822337866,
0.5551468134,
0.025125416,
0.455775708,
0.132877931,
-0.3484079242,
-0.269154191,
-0.3688409925,
-0.7962143421,
0.9084668756,
0.2065723538,
0.7555277944,
-0.1889941394,
0.8393346071,
0.1858269572,
0.30379498,
-0.5092920661,
0.8044399619,
-0.2157958895,
-0.1507548988,
-0.2494429797,
-0.7612632513,
-0.6426054239,
0.1171611026,
-0.2929773927,
-0.4640043378,
-0.5359329581,
-0.1059564948,
-0.0122983139,
0.2664892673,
-0.5398074985,
0.831415832,
-0.1232676357,
-0.1803719103,
0.2318810225,
-0.7201322913,
0.0880789533,
-0.2830207348,
-0.019472206,
-0.2031709105,
-0.1977862269,
0.7555453777,
-0.318020016,
0.6003187299,
0.0233743824,
-0.0972338393,
0.273673147,
-0.1946728528,
0.5404167771,
0.0472518802,
-0.0126873935,
0.4503681958,
-0.0513799265,
-0.3323254287,
-0.465426743,
0.9628728628,
-0.6264218092,
-0.2239743322,
-0.7215320468,
-0.5955010056,
-0.1304753125,
0.2968672216,
0.2651320398,
0.1764113903,
-0.3134978116,
-0.2018463612,
0.4117822647,
-0.0207794067,
0.3483386338,
0.2012070268,
-0.049608361,
-0.161896646,
0.9004010558,
0.0060910825,
0.1605001092,
0.5450453758,
-0.0658611059,
-0.5556617379,
-0.5332580209,
-0.4422754049,
0.3517540693,
-0.3301101625,
-0.3343801796,
-0.7413092852,
-0.2549489737,
-0.2920232117,
-0.0256614089,
-0.2322111577,
-0.2524586916,
-0.1925057322,
-0.3320481479,
0.7375172973,
0.9278908372,
0.1795126349,
0.2719448805,
-0.5645079613,
0.3418706357,
0.140200302,
0.5101033449,
-0.4625377357,
-0.2704593241,
0.0023167555,
0.0086049531,
-0.1230249777,
-0.7322024703,
0.3888102472,
0.1458811015,
0.2985731065,
-0.0922245607,
0.0216040891,
0.7395808101,
-0.6960179806,
0.7970299125,
-0.0254610367,
-1.1318005323,
0.2567443848,
-0.5007990599,
0.0473411568,
0.8522347808,
0.4309338629,
-0.230782181,
-0.3164917827,
-0.6849480271,
-0.7843481898,
0.5032345653,
0.6960955858,
0.0419428088,
0.0471217632,
0.6049605608,
0.3436093032,
0.1319491565,
-0.754320085,
-0.1411094069,
-0.125496164,
-0.7494407892,
-0.0892154649,
-0.174432978,
0.2096550465,
0.3104807436,
0.8032464385,
-0.1726902127,
0.4003727436,
0.1855926812,
0.002106599,
0.2615678012,
0.3845228255,
0.3954117894,
0.343603909,
-0.1844388396,
0.1767804027,
0.4960062504,
-0.9110929966,
0.0748594925,
0.2669396996,
-0.3157086074,
0.1119104326,
0.3852711022,
0.6585190892,
0.2697440088,
-0.5668973923,
0.7922608256,
-0.1603578031,
-0.4254404604,
-0.1358930022,
-0.1548889726,
0.1570092887,
0.0689854324,
0.1677658856,
-0.040885374,
0.2590970993,
-0.2600950599,
0.4446685612,
0.3122008741,
-0.5110484958,
-0.1024672389,
0.4771557152,
-0.0722097009,
-0.032741379,
0.4929507077,
-0.2128004283,
-0.5344187617,
0.4414958358,
0.5531622767,
0.4867325127,
-0.0241043493,
0.2665309906,
0.1809999943,
0.3322970867,
-0.4539783299,
0.4060258567,
0.1784473807,
-0.3360202909,
-0.498994261,
-0.5994463563,
-0.2818745375,
0.1708856225,
-0.709253788,
0.4016340971,
-0.1365148276,
0.0233414005,
-0.233818084,
0.1974231154,
-0.6108598113,
0.3509766757,
0.0151945557,
0.7848044634,
-1.175219655,
0.9045845866,
0.6895702481,
-0.3245078921,
-0.9118511677,
0.3649406731,
-0.149367556,
-0.5686978698,
0.357365042,
0.3582465351,
-0.0277972538,
0.1727532297,
-0.3706714213,
-0.487445116,
1.2924736738,
0.4228139222,
-0.6634536982,
0.3273105323,
0.4253912866,
0.6206759214,
-0.3646947742,
0.3143183291,
0.5681445599,
0.4234793186,
-0.0668585077,
-1.0067061186,
0.1557267457,
-0.108062461,
0.2186512649,
0.2577987611,
-0.5592349172,
0.8409034014,
-0.0463640764,
-0.2473179251,
0.3354947567,
0.5940649509,
0.3392630517,
0.4805276394,
0.5045874715,
0.8309851885,
0.5767066479,
-0.2533624768,
1.0107138157,
0.2329802364,
0.6844031215,
1.1346122026,
-0.4899051487,
0.8255233765,
0.3649454117,
-0.1579861939,
0.2298866808,
0.6300976276,
-0.2019328177,
0.5323436856,
0.4786846042,
-0.2104661465,
-0.1905821562,
-0.0731994063,
-0.4666861892,
0.161127165,
-0.0837006718,
-0.2800994813,
-0.1877234578,
-0.0070706769,
0.1390799433,
0.3183078766,
-0.0756346434,
1.0131298304,
0.1183965802,
-0.2869041562,
0.1952736527,
-0.2128769904,
0.6226739883,
-0.7946239114,
-0.1653156728,
-0.1347442269,
-0.0029085372,
0.011152124,
-0.8041753769,
0.1152093485,
0.1759569645,
-0.0430344567,
-0.157090053,
0.6841218472,
-0.5086476207,
-0.5925930738,
0.3978241682,
0.3933841884,
0.5161069036,
-0.169296056,
-0.7957072258,
0.1390978396,
0.0387736633,
-0.1446897388,
0.4346953034,
0.6913294196,
-0.3015224934,
0.5520640016,
0.5484936237,
0.1214937642,
0.0539381988,
0.4090601802,
0.9210574031,
-0.810338378,
-0.7540299296,
-1.0206725597,
-0.062535055,
-0.2180393189,
-0.3721105456,
0.8894480467,
0.8342262506,
0.8695849776,
-0.2046407312,
1.0755600929,
0.1362702101,
0.8041797876,
-0.7603156567,
0.5535079837,
-0.3812656403,
0.2637836933,
-0.671900034,
-1.1460857391,
-0.380541563,
0.6587361693,
-0.3571392894,
0.1920821667,
0.9159532189,
0.8292595744,
-0.186598286,
0.3723049462,
0.2519404292,
0.2045355588,
0.112023145,
0.545612812,
0.9198278189,
-0.6663928032,
0.6114047766,
0.1688496917,
-0.2225245535,
-0.0631046221,
-1.052610755,
-1.0156722069,
-0.6325067878,
-0.3305616677,
0.1074299887,
0.346989125,
0.8584882617,
0.4047753811,
-0.6265458465,
0.2351149321,
-0.1941787601,
-0.2119701952,
-0.3703536391,
-0.1791921109,
0.72655195,
-0.1637425423,
-0.5615867376,
0.1371529102,
0.2820544839,
0.3039565682,
0.1678978801,
0.0591117851,
-0.3906838298,
0.1445021331,
0.2867513299,
-0.2753676176,
-0.5743647814,
-0.3338886797,
-0.2194103748,
-0.3385250568,
-0.1987266839,
0.8661487103,
-0.7168784142,
-0.0320109501,
0.3870202303,
0.7682650089,
0.595348835,
0.5250896811,
0.2370874137,
-0.9148365855,
-0.0841665491,
0.1428148448,
0.1838222295,
0.5720020533,
-0.4293597639,
0.7812147141,
0.2638885975,
-0.6149820685,
-0.564391613,
0.0380643718,
-1.3733346462,
-0.0067636846,
1.3010261059,
-0.4792636335,
-0.0844667852,
-0.2799569666,
-0.504846096,
0.1450194418,
-0.2969703674,
0.6742377877,
0.4982175529,
0.0198812038,
0.1512266248,
-0.762164712,
0.6803474426,
0.2656650841,
-1.0876265764,
0.0722048283,
0.0124454498,
0.4338190854,
-0.1071660444,
0.7305388451,
-0.1895845532,
-0.1570966095,
0.1230612099,
0.0351937711,
-0.1233527735,
0.0186324138,
-0.0444485545,
0.1897051036,
-0.3653554916,
-0.1854092479
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05585v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05585v1
|
Enhancing Medical Specialty Assignment to Patients using NLP Techniques
| 2023-12-09T14:13:45 | 2023-12-09T14:13:45 |
Chris Solomou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
The introduction of Large Language Models (LLMs), and the vast volume of
publicly available medical data, amplified the application of NLP to the
medical domain. However, LLMs are pretrained on data that are not explicitly
relevant to the domain that are applied to and are often biased towards the
original data they were pretrained upon. Even when pretrained on domainspecific
data, these models typically require time-consuming fine-tuning to achieve good
performance for a specific task. To address these limitations, we propose an
alternative approach that achieves superior performance while being
computationally efficient. Specifically, we utilize keywords to train a deep
learning architecture that outperforms a language model pretrained on a large
corpus of text. Our proposal does not require pretraining nor fine-tuning and
can be applied directly to a specific setting for performing multi-label
classification. Our objective is to automatically assign a new patient to the
specialty of the medical professional they require, using a dataset that
contains medical transcriptions and relevant keywords. To this end, we
fine-tune the PubMedBERT model on this dataset, which serves as the baseline
for our experiments. We then twice train/fine-tune a DNN and the RoBERTa
language model, using both the keywords and the full transcriptions as input.
We compare the performance of these approaches using relevant metrics. Our
results demonstrate that utilizing keywords for text classification
significantly improves classification performance, for both a basic DL
architecture and a large language model. Our approach represents a promising
and efficient alternative to traditional methods for finetuning language models
on domain-specific data and has potential applications in various medical
domains
|
[
0.0158971697,
-0.3179814517,
0.5811347365,
-0.0463314652,
-0.4254919291,
0.2568014562,
-0.4415770173,
-0.3468737006,
0.2108498365,
0.810990274,
-0.3011865914,
-0.7278834581,
-0.8915756345,
0.2011452764,
0.0033315315,
1.0802072287,
0.1842540056,
0.3091242015,
-0.2919124663,
-0.2565562725,
-0.4090526998,
-0.9121829271,
-0.8555240631,
-0.5293029547,
0.6462945342,
0.2670440376,
0.6287596226,
0.8351535797,
0.9732929468,
0.2635855377,
-0.0241959319,
0.4973358512,
-0.1780854464,
-0.0196419284,
-0.254258275,
-0.4562362134,
-0.6415421963,
-0.2040079832,
0.4696196318,
1.0506714582,
-0.1293250024,
-0.0105988728,
-0.186939016,
0.7916631699,
-0.3195235133,
0.0936198458,
-0.8393918276,
0.0848213807,
-0.2222792208,
-0.4482873976,
-0.2772632837,
-0.3919835091,
0.3897348642,
-0.5445799828,
0.4149780273,
-0.2083331645,
0.8866669536,
0.5434030294,
-0.3453761339,
-0.2654849291,
-0.5212039948,
0.5431999564,
-0.7874166369,
0.4314420521,
0.3220250607,
0.1418760866,
0.1323519945,
-0.8495458961,
-0.1826971769,
-0.2618722618,
-0.0150122829,
0.1049422994,
0.207378611,
0.4270718694,
0.0706989989,
0.3654914796,
-0.3913785517,
0.5719266534,
-0.338393569,
0.021934012,
0.5595268011,
0.2926819921,
0.2016970664,
0.1199236289,
-0.1225163788,
0.0531948507,
-0.68619591,
-0.2977235019,
-0.2266480029,
0.54018116,
0.3415155113,
0.5983170271,
-0.1388780177,
0.7188867927,
0.1291435808,
-0.3809521496,
0.4879074693,
-0.1286239326,
-0.2594555914,
0.1064586118,
0.5832551718,
0.5278902054,
0.2661641538,
-0.4688413441,
0.0377079658,
0.1562891752,
0.7540363073,
-0.7944917679,
-0.3609001935,
0.1784907728,
-0.5055220127,
-0.4825577736,
-0.4831967354,
-0.5172593594,
-0.5271174312,
-0.5790781379,
0.2441375405,
-0.4831665158,
0.0592611656,
0.3752913475,
0.1427815706,
-0.1841025501,
0.303674221,
-0.9510002732,
0.4737344384,
0.7905068994,
0.7758076787,
-0.5433430076,
-0.0476877354,
-0.3327131867,
0.184856683,
-0.3938285708,
0.5165830255,
-0.6535078287,
-0.158131212,
0.0796849728,
0.0397309996,
-0.2608647943,
-0.8987988234,
0.5112239718,
-0.5849116445,
-0.1790315509,
0.2360364199,
-0.7252895236,
0.069848381,
0.1808830649,
-0.5221959949,
0.5562253594,
0.2536408901,
-0.4361557364,
0.5178427696,
-0.6646186113,
-0.5840474367,
0.2345021069,
-0.2167807221,
-0.6883406043,
0.2320437133,
0.4162288606,
0.7720546722,
-0.2637279928,
0.393873781,
-0.0457158089,
-0.0980131999,
0.4058116376,
-0.0324654765,
0.4260750413,
0.1588331312,
-0.0920109972,
-0.0056455699,
-0.5975691676,
0.0767040923,
-0.1363220364,
-0.4692665935,
-0.5761058927,
-0.0068555134,
-0.0339872614,
0.0925742462,
-0.0380197018,
-0.3955477774,
0.5579565167,
-0.9102970958,
0.3696800768,
0.3414348662,
0.0380464084,
0.5076001883,
-0.3047662377,
0.5830946565,
-0.1412395537,
0.139707759,
0.2089895904,
-0.4641038477,
-0.5478087068,
-0.5356916785,
0.7633053064,
0.590611279,
-0.7353007793,
0.457087934,
-0.5525183082,
-0.3791505694,
-0.8745780587,
0.1492693424,
0.3536762893,
0.6778957248,
0.5419338346,
-0.4826574624,
-0.2900494635,
-0.7856483459,
-0.2239363641,
0.1796056032,
-0.0188725665,
0.6188805699,
0.0964360684,
-0.512448132,
0.5940735936,
-0.7493858337,
-0.8038559556,
-0.0343418084,
0.0085297199,
0.3333748877,
0.4569337964,
0.4545157552,
-0.7471510172,
-0.5058607459,
0.1470927447,
-0.4462606311,
-0.1741809845,
-0.276230216,
0.1219915748,
-0.0236358587,
0.5364121795,
-0.3257512748,
0.1317660362,
0.5487846732,
-0.0531540401,
0.1821259558,
-0.4541628063,
-0.0761581808,
-1.1187899113,
0.1124410406,
-0.1419566721,
-0.1789215356,
-0.7482155561,
0.0774802864,
-0.0609209873,
-0.2383164614,
-0.3534322679,
0.4168973267,
-0.3551852703,
0.300819993,
-0.3976224065,
-0.1673154235,
0.015772244,
0.2116929442,
0.4353754222,
0.4767681658,
0.5947219729,
-0.6665018797,
0.1408643723,
0.4941089749,
-0.3352499306,
0.3468016684,
-0.6127434373,
0.1282614172,
0.0251476336,
0.1171572879,
-0.68601197,
-0.0688406974,
0.0681045949,
-0.2869392931,
0.5138439536,
-0.2494699359,
-0.4706934392,
-0.3881411552,
0.2032568008,
0.4624450207,
0.4457090199,
-0.4126048684,
0.2395792007,
0.5219382048,
-0.3434239924,
-0.4355832934,
-0.6863506436,
0.2671042681,
-0.2416152507,
-0.0781059191,
0.8419733047,
0.2217660695,
0.2492047399,
-0.1612593532,
-0.0067942175,
-0.546759069,
0.2318547815,
0.2041303366,
0.1498153955,
-0.1876774579,
0.5721746087,
0.2776082456,
-0.2637458444,
-0.0498813279,
-0.3812065423,
0.3632960916,
0.1359419376,
-0.21898444,
-0.3691747189,
0.3586274087,
0.6775344014,
-0.5129642487,
0.6092098951,
0.5197638869,
-0.4355596006,
-0.0991024747,
-0.5000011921,
-0.1925362647,
-0.4375551343,
0.594316721,
-0.1954626143,
-0.9467818737,
0.0853725672,
-0.6151608825,
0.115696907,
0.3114690781,
0.7244780064,
-0.0459299237,
0.9012911916,
0.4869609475,
-0.048632998,
0.1528410316,
-0.2411126047,
0.281640023,
-0.9561002254,
-0.2596026659,
-0.5527609587,
-0.2983414233,
-0.501571238,
-0.7336843014,
0.5392151475,
0.0250726119,
0.1559124887,
0.2104909271,
-1.0272072554,
0.197475493,
0.3538659215,
0.4914462566,
0.1811795235,
0.0527920946,
-0.0826514363,
-0.2546581328,
-0.8082315326,
-0.3028230667,
1.472459197,
0.4838030338,
0.6879668236,
-0.0834938213,
0.9116359353,
-0.0197113007,
0.5851130486,
-0.8958643079,
0.116204828,
-0.9309440851,
-0.3916669488,
-0.2220616341,
-0.2390308678,
-1.2289352417,
0.0809171274,
-0.4149916768,
-0.4400034547,
0.186252147,
0.2165790945,
-0.8452212811,
0.0960328504,
-0.4949920177,
0.8328751922,
-0.471380502,
0.0103726927,
-0.2709752619,
-0.6538510919,
-0.0352729037,
-0.4306857884,
0.0200766101,
-0.1509893537,
-0.307103008,
0.6897291541,
-0.4280400276,
0.9394734502,
-0.0662849918,
-0.0570600964,
-0.2422370315,
-0.3333074152,
0.1619486213,
0.1741671413,
-0.1089273244,
0.1237551942,
0.0437201187,
-0.0921640843,
-0.6266943216,
0.6744286418,
-0.7997443676,
-0.3523217738,
-0.1999467611,
-0.5496833324,
-0.650541544,
0.2142330259,
0.2724651396,
0.5393329859,
-0.0600871928,
0.2612208128,
0.9058983922,
-0.4664922357,
-0.0960897878,
0.5119880438,
0.0419880562,
-0.3107798398,
0.8759474158,
0.1697114706,
0.1250643879,
0.6453129053,
0.360089004,
-0.3795165122,
-1.0204273462,
-0.3382221758,
0.3100876212,
-0.4173735678,
-0.3946121037,
-1.0067230463,
-0.3590101302,
-0.5102980137,
-0.324282825,
-0.3993288875,
-0.1877025366,
-0.513638258,
0.203890726,
0.379013449,
0.2506778538,
0.2935558558,
0.4877771139,
-0.9735459685,
0.6379392743,
0.2786273956,
0.5157719254,
-0.3064073026,
-0.5712404847,
-0.397780627,
-0.2797852457,
-0.1251039952,
-0.8260020018,
0.4270540476,
0.5990772247,
0.6569898725,
0.415079087,
0.0601346716,
0.5578733683,
-0.8790459633,
0.4988898933,
0.2342847884,
-0.6999666691,
0.5723193884,
-0.2721810043,
0.2985257208,
1.0030199289,
0.5548241138,
-0.4059891701,
-0.3798367381,
-0.5666871667,
-1.0313975811,
0.3855912089,
-0.2163512409,
0.2887220383,
-0.1343784779,
0.7057952285,
0.119891502,
0.4304613173,
-0.3932235539,
-0.283554107,
0.220556125,
-0.3792010844,
-0.2578546107,
-0.1077865437,
-0.2997836173,
-0.545601368,
0.3498371243,
-0.5119327903,
0.4595575929,
0.2957785428,
-0.0694853142,
0.1688368022,
0.1589806676,
0.5639877319,
0.7578143477,
-0.0697708204,
0.0206864532,
0.2338691503,
-0.5390104651,
0.1078943238,
0.1559083015,
0.0987545326,
0.3653906882,
0.3546633422,
0.7181859612,
0.1584436297,
-0.6765601635,
0.6075357795,
0.1214759499,
-0.4408358932,
-0.0826849788,
0.0309905577,
0.1177011281,
0.0923656598,
-0.0153165786,
0.1265238374,
0.2446997613,
-0.176675126,
0.5690790415,
0.2778581679,
-0.5046280622,
0.1400684863,
0.5332911015,
0.2973923087,
-0.3949675858,
0.5952047706,
0.2794078887,
-0.515147984,
0.6572847366,
0.5233740211,
0.7557615638,
-0.367988348,
0.3097457886,
0.0701375902,
0.1450899541,
-0.0446687229,
0.0191463251,
0.3353635669,
-0.6465255618,
-0.788400352,
-0.6476787925,
-0.2785137296,
0.283832401,
-0.7808155417,
0.1187736541,
-0.6555767059,
-0.4515176415,
0.3304435909,
-0.0711444914,
-0.869304955,
0.5328122973,
0.267989248,
0.8320723176,
-0.8071654439,
1.0779548883,
0.9969756007,
-0.0162689164,
-0.6884673238,
-0.1113430485,
-0.2708579004,
-0.8012878895,
0.7125436068,
0.0698087066,
0.287453711,
-0.0554398336,
-0.0487953685,
-0.6290218234,
0.7299565673,
0.1366896629,
-0.8338801265,
-0.2954205871,
0.2663231194,
0.948507905,
-0.5919371843,
-0.114835605,
0.5311424732,
0.1028413028,
-0.3073620796,
-1.1108555794,
0.0978192911,
0.0649276599,
0.0725015402,
0.1343367994,
-0.4020496905,
0.5683907866,
-0.223593086,
0.3041110635,
-0.0320872553,
0.363571614,
-0.0901536345,
0.1754274517,
0.5616746545,
0.6441428065,
0.9333122373,
-0.0565315709,
0.9614093304,
-0.324175626,
0.3259970248,
1.0787307024,
-0.3480058014,
0.6776027679,
0.3808020055,
-0.1462052613,
0.2706551552,
0.5849859715,
-0.2021425962,
0.865103364,
0.3900906444,
-0.3050590456,
-0.3074373305,
-0.1430109739,
-0.3757193685,
0.5439830422,
0.6560359597,
-0.7882868648,
-0.1496437788,
0.3465825319,
-0.0636962503,
0.2186283618,
-0.3564313948,
1.0855592489,
0.2391286492,
-0.5810080171,
0.7019192576,
0.0803029388,
0.5576577187,
-0.5036103725,
-0.0205394626,
0.1543997377,
0.4875585735,
-0.2636829913,
-0.3268587291,
0.397312969,
-0.2595148385,
-0.2123717666,
-0.3717010021,
0.6235615611,
-0.5296525359,
-0.6506726146,
0.0183192808,
0.2474052608,
0.0459190868,
-0.0242872257,
-1.0483647585,
-0.2278345227,
-0.1161390468,
0.1824519932,
0.4026071131,
0.3601548374,
0.144682318,
0.585067451,
0.6226218939,
0.5685583949,
-0.1157234684,
0.2263790071,
0.9781886935,
-0.2549270988,
-0.4161305726,
-0.6340999603,
0.1521419585,
0.0375629216,
-0.5483380556,
0.2928569317,
0.4634699225,
0.5146095157,
-0.2303620279,
0.7558376193,
0.2705704272,
0.8127262592,
-0.5752491951,
0.6892222762,
-0.6666733027,
0.1274775714,
-0.3989524841,
-0.4421445429,
-0.7436321974,
0.6162913442,
-0.2516696453,
-0.2135366648,
0.7518018484,
0.6241589189,
0.0809861347,
-0.4310518503,
0.410556376,
-0.0966001973,
0.303681463,
0.6754094958,
0.3311527073,
-0.2084631175,
0.129299134,
-0.294882834,
-0.3685811758,
-0.4502676427,
-0.681494236,
-1.0782095194,
-0.2960511148,
-0.7081747055,
-0.3517528772,
0.2945080101,
0.9368655682,
0.8305279016,
-0.7859207392,
0.0786882043,
0.1800529212,
-0.2111952901,
-0.4981912971,
-0.125420928,
0.6915419698,
-0.4966202974,
-0.6275320053,
0.4900655746,
0.1759409457,
-0.1680719256,
0.076829426,
0.1606735885,
-0.1706784517,
-0.1129385382,
0.645432055,
0.0032238525,
-0.6567888856,
-0.1206701696,
0.1379396021,
-0.3412827849,
0.1821818054,
0.9949524999,
-0.6780639887,
0.4659387767,
0.0804213509,
1.3299721479,
0.3034378886,
0.1034433544,
0.5289013386,
-0.6688010693,
-0.0875210539,
0.7504829168,
-0.0242755059,
0.1696693897,
-0.7266364694,
0.3547011018,
0.05596615,
-0.5753715634,
-0.6401100755,
0.0698700026,
-1.0079301596,
-0.5188980699,
1.0751122236,
-0.1665886939,
0.1156500801,
-0.3618507087,
-0.2408803254,
0.2828104794,
-0.112313807,
0.9634125829,
0.3833406866,
-0.2218695581,
-0.0101808477,
-0.5535902381,
0.8086214662,
0.8239735365,
-0.7424752712,
-0.1084795892,
0.1768866777,
0.3842722178,
0.195315972,
0.9706972837,
-0.2110813707,
0.163683489,
-0.6045439243,
0.1223636866,
-0.0206262823,
-0.4958093464,
-0.4408412874,
0.1735643446,
0.2510160208,
-0.3268042803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05520v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05520v1
|
Augmenty: A Python Library for Structured Text Augmentation
| 2023-12-09T10:24:59 | 2023-12-09T10:24:59 |
Kenneth Enevoldsen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Augmnety is a Python library for structured text augmentation. It is built on
top of spaCy and allows for augmentation of both the text and its annotations.
Augmenty provides a wide range of augmenters which can be combined in a
flexible manner to create complex augmentation pipelines. It also includes a
set of primitives that can be used to create custom augmenters such as word
replacement augmenters. This functionality allows for augmentations within a
range of applications such as named entity recognition (NER), part-of-speech
tagging, and dependency parsing.
|
[
-0.3084641695,
-0.9264019728,
0.1801396757,
0.1860410571,
0.1492464393,
0.0134304464,
0.0232472885,
-0.3958043456,
0.6774289608,
0.4097499847,
-0.6130371094,
-0.0236248523,
-0.2068280131,
0.4685895741,
-0.3630892336,
0.7974030972,
0.183501035,
-0.1826173514,
-0.0574547499,
-0.0396538973,
-0.4197903872,
-0.3444548249,
-0.3526395261,
-0.7418538332,
0.6072853804,
0.2415335923,
0.9241736531,
0.9284155369,
0.4106627405,
0.5649531484,
-0.1463707536,
0.193891868,
0.0385032296,
0.5584933758,
-0.126434043,
-0.5667956471,
-0.2328700274,
-0.163579464,
0.5248532891,
0.7756349444,
0.1099818349,
-0.0274493545,
-0.0406298824,
0.4501903355,
-0.7419028878,
-0.1156700477,
-0.6005404592,
0.1491298378,
-0.0041087507,
-0.2770214081,
0.1599889398,
-0.3797869682,
0.2503580153,
-0.938806951,
-0.0347694419,
-0.0049933759,
0.516793251,
0.4407182932,
0.0382070318,
-0.3199981749,
-0.1342522353,
0.4303313494,
-0.6804773808,
0.2112701982,
0.2442472726,
-0.1535143256,
-0.5194007754,
-1.1997084618,
-0.933465302,
-0.3243773282,
-0.3038913012,
0.0880738646,
0.0837744325,
0.5292768478,
0.3625429869,
0.7143242955,
-0.592687726,
-0.081343241,
-0.24212569,
-0.3836584687,
0.4275522828,
-0.0173871294,
0.8347166181,
-0.3344095051,
-0.2976362407,
0.2252239585,
-0.1971275806,
-0.1681284457,
0.7885125279,
0.1877245307,
0.4485123456,
1.145698905,
-0.4393569231,
0.8512814045,
0.14169541,
-0.0924658179,
0.7253217697,
-0.0768806264,
-0.3522238731,
0.5887269974,
0.5390437841,
0.2890385389,
0.0174629856,
-0.3289256692,
-0.3942764401,
0.0033963514,
0.0838389918,
-0.7928530574,
-0.5760424137,
0.6955871582,
-0.4571896791,
-0.4165723622,
0.0607835837,
-0.0922415778,
-0.67359519,
-0.5102289915,
0.6587387919,
-0.7871228456,
-0.4668394625,
-0.1272234619,
-0.7482908964,
-0.0956557095,
0.2222108096,
-0.9660884142,
0.0379633605,
0.9797523022,
1.3102272749,
-0.1610181928,
-0.5723667741,
-0.5245470405,
-0.0700254068,
-0.301373899,
0.8092364073,
-0.7621287107,
-0.0571433157,
0.0759307444,
0.3808092475,
-0.0560703613,
-0.2507201731,
0.5707269311,
-0.290866375,
0.3270533979,
0.4211237133,
-0.673116684,
-0.3023605347,
0.4870414734,
-0.8101863861,
1.104778409,
0.4456111491,
-1.088986516,
0.244184494,
-0.447273463,
-0.4056590497,
0.6175082922,
0.2954299152,
-0.0061287847,
0.3317730129,
-0.0335218869,
0.1971997619,
0.629107058,
0.0891776904,
-0.1936457753,
-0.63868469,
0.7500362396,
-0.3831368387,
0.4757719636,
0.3728920221,
0.2292434871,
0.2544410527,
-1.2855905294,
0.184330821,
-0.5678800941,
-0.5509769917,
-0.8783833981,
-0.1860339642,
0.5648889542,
0.1563869268,
0.5479104519,
-0.6670162082,
0.399861753,
-1.5496981144,
0.9652729034,
0.5337873697,
-0.1790786535,
0.763702333,
-0.3865421116,
0.2377271652,
-0.184552744,
-0.2917792499,
-0.9233133793,
-0.6500025392,
-0.701870501,
-0.1318766028,
0.1752237231,
0.7848041058,
-1.085138917,
0.5049378872,
0.1863774955,
-0.3977037668,
-0.583725214,
0.0034196088,
0.0112079447,
0.3963085711,
0.3591829538,
-0.006725308,
-0.7991375923,
-0.8075684309,
-0.4009847045,
-0.0864670575,
-0.016717894,
-0.2287614048,
0.6673243046,
-0.4907761216,
0.8683984876,
-0.028600309,
-0.0428321324,
-0.0505899228,
0.0803790241,
0.582138896,
0.6605347395,
-0.064123258,
-0.7975326777,
-0.1420573145,
0.2686779201,
-0.2367314696,
-0.5885059834,
-0.1708582044,
0.1410914958,
0.1580613852,
0.2650489211,
-0.6599245071,
0.4366770983,
0.5679631233,
-0.4446843565,
0.7345201969,
-0.4216455817,
0.2248513401,
-1.5169234276,
0.0322445072,
-0.0396979973,
-0.2576238215,
-0.7813822031,
0.0806396678,
0.0523322076,
0.0051948954,
-0.240674898,
0.6334961653,
-0.4686742425,
0.1508404016,
-0.5414465666,
-0.0009778887,
0.0032520907,
-0.0219710823,
0.0182376578,
0.9421284795,
0.552003324,
-0.5111119151,
0.8365084529,
0.4378953576,
0.1119290218,
0.7273477912,
-0.8354002833,
-0.1478976011,
-0.1401184201,
-0.1120050251,
-1.1482573748,
-0.6114715934,
0.3997030854,
-0.7457944155,
0.2813979685,
-0.318251431,
-0.3594975471,
-0.175622195,
-0.4634559453,
0.1245877221,
-0.1579351127,
-0.5652020574,
0.5642818809,
0.5430414081,
-0.2440915704,
-0.9071692228,
-1.2560789585,
0.4082731009,
-0.2374402881,
-0.6554369926,
0.6117417216,
0.0383583866,
-0.2977927923,
0.1634475887,
0.0846458301,
-0.2946660221,
-0.0645918846,
0.7501565814,
0.2376250476,
-0.0878880396,
0.34452793,
-0.009584371,
-0.2852508426,
-0.1740669906,
-0.6620159745,
0.6324622631,
-0.0877290666,
-0.1486756057,
-0.340074271,
0.2419892699,
0.078866221,
0.0761843398,
0.5695465803,
0.9003108144,
-0.4554228187,
-0.2279049605,
-0.6830656528,
0.0511590727,
-0.5751318336,
0.398340106,
-0.5511599183,
-1.1254187822,
0.3246796429,
-0.0330315158,
-0.1692423075,
0.4106673598,
0.5375332832,
0.0743805096,
0.8204413652,
0.3535503745,
0.0152562242,
0.6893103123,
0.0098330555,
-0.1310671866,
-0.8560034633,
-0.3161903918,
-0.4575187862,
-0.3439467251,
-0.7810442448,
-0.3003450036,
-0.1603597552,
-0.0411258452,
-0.076004982,
0.5549347401,
-1.2669463158,
0.3778566718,
0.7027350664,
-0.1538047493,
0.2369983494,
0.1790937185,
0.2621878386,
0.1005688384,
-0.5042126179,
-0.4105258584,
0.6451580524,
0.206918776,
0.9674600959,
-0.118462719,
0.7902489901,
0.3211708069,
-0.1567819715,
-1.2589740753,
0.2877567708,
0.2121049762,
-0.3052293956,
-0.1183864251,
-0.4448386431,
-1.1572045088,
0.1731013358,
-0.5062838197,
-1.1958222389,
0.1168228537,
0.0280038752,
0.0097440947,
0.2165802121,
-0.8349739313,
0.6274722815,
0.085856542,
-0.405850023,
-0.0241872929,
-0.5540501475,
0.2656687498,
0.3905350566,
-0.1252761185,
0.1866874844,
-0.4727576673,
0.6517682672,
-0.7989956737,
0.3702303469,
0.1180404797,
0.3712896109,
0.2614884377,
0.131090641,
0.1969696134,
0.245564878,
0.065748319,
0.0237489045,
0.433490485,
0.1284826845,
-0.5039315224,
1.1928477287,
-0.6928837299,
-0.3247166872,
-0.7171133161,
-0.7941013575,
0.2674266994,
0.4326199293,
0.1262228787,
0.6893759966,
0.0609113649,
0.1588676721,
0.7543985248,
-0.2780391574,
0.849822998,
-0.0985386074,
-0.2506783903,
-0.8139189482,
1.1357684135,
0.3429108858,
-0.2951782644,
0.6911196709,
0.2465109527,
-0.5795304775,
-0.5480394959,
-0.4617387056,
-0.023141874,
-0.4971070886,
-0.0726968572,
-0.8894169331,
-0.5181487799,
-0.4876905084,
-0.0848878548,
0.0370307118,
-1.1716685295,
-0.418948859,
-0.0018814951,
0.6011837721,
0.7256399989,
-0.2050566077,
0.349785924,
-0.7733248472,
0.4288623035,
0.2028244734,
0.3407798409,
-0.4706773758,
-0.4557507336,
-0.0541001745,
-0.2648967206,
-0.0777155012,
-1.215285778,
0.7045043111,
0.4067977667,
0.709677577,
0.1379503906,
-0.2690918446,
0.5671007037,
-0.3499678671,
0.8987649083,
0.3634558916,
-0.9043776393,
0.6523746252,
-0.2060228288,
0.1944044679,
0.2588861287,
0.0263601765,
-0.690338254,
-0.1466011405,
-0.58522439,
-1.1964267492,
0.6949129105,
0.2814735174,
0.2750475705,
0.1180958897,
0.5384347439,
0.1873919815,
0.2997293472,
-0.7763924003,
-0.2781508267,
-0.6634337902,
-0.4919484556,
0.4269890189,
-0.263266176,
-0.0489277169,
-0.114517957,
0.9010179043,
-0.2263710201,
0.0362964161,
0.4716744423,
-0.4824438095,
0.1669433117,
0.3439669013,
0.1710212827,
0.4193153381,
-0.0754755586,
0.2266354263,
0.1677086949,
-0.8223047256,
0.0997214988,
0.6370381117,
-0.282376349,
0.1116533652,
0.2893778086,
0.6725915074,
-0.3067673147,
-0.6606423855,
0.3909133673,
0.1229129732,
-0.0991606042,
-0.6091500521,
0.2968698442,
-0.1135636717,
0.4961045086,
0.4851609468,
-0.0668665022,
0.6786974669,
-0.4368311465,
0.3928171694,
0.4376971424,
-0.590724051,
-0.2018340677,
0.5568459034,
-0.0261197686,
-0.7950178981,
0.2696227431,
-0.0787720308,
-0.3761712015,
0.3063472807,
0.8749574423,
0.8569044471,
-0.1097780243,
0.3354420066,
0.5261104107,
0.4592478573,
-0.0592567138,
0.2298373133,
-0.1255983114,
-0.776924789,
-0.6033427715,
-0.7697485089,
-0.411349982,
0.1864162087,
-0.0775139034,
0.1681955606,
-0.4873025715,
-0.2354011536,
-0.067200914,
0.0285513997,
-0.1774519533,
0.3843833506,
0.2730275691,
1.0383267403,
-0.3839186132,
0.5324980617,
1.4052764177,
-0.6273953319,
-0.7028830051,
-0.2426404953,
-0.1271676272,
-0.8388022184,
0.397326827,
0.7909195423,
0.1035283059,
0.0265624952,
-0.3834753633,
-0.8881626129,
0.9733990431,
-0.1370684355,
-0.300719589,
-0.0068376949,
0.2284341604,
0.5249586701,
-0.1457496583,
0.8013058901,
0.5718125105,
0.6931450367,
0.022308724,
-0.6710271835,
0.0518270209,
-0.6833257079,
0.2740029097,
-0.0285571124,
-0.1303384602,
1.0027607679,
0.1344380081,
-0.174582094,
0.3291763067,
0.6602498889,
0.3563828468,
0.533773005,
0.4656645358,
0.7355176806,
0.6770048738,
-0.3847583234,
0.6812636852,
-0.5235117674,
0.0985167846,
0.8061810732,
0.4837121964,
0.5100825429,
0.6667402983,
-0.0362574644,
0.5298403502,
0.665217936,
-0.0258261934,
0.1974311173,
0.1966532916,
-0.2057119757,
0.0701120198,
-0.1381068677,
-0.4439541996,
0.1445929259,
0.7480807304,
-0.2343878448,
0.1730056405,
-0.0145868491,
-0.1337128282,
0.0370699428,
-0.636488378,
0.8040047884,
-0.0411763117,
-0.614880383,
0.1825201362,
0.0122163147,
1.1524266005,
-0.4911726713,
-0.3823090792,
0.2038153261,
0.2912958264,
-0.9167966843,
-1.3188660145,
0.3913436532,
-0.6004116535,
0.004053412,
0.3067261875,
1.6274116039,
-0.6216762066,
-0.2915246189,
-0.1681800932,
0.2675224543,
0.00765847,
-0.3104707003,
-0.8455175757,
-0.1903661042,
-0.3390221894,
-0.4933865964,
0.1416997313,
0.5572205782,
0.3393916786,
0.7498479486,
0.8853298426,
0.3670142591,
0.1830859482,
-0.0704135597,
1.1162149906,
-0.4656377435,
-0.8398681879,
-0.8516455889,
0.6807906032,
-0.4869578779,
-0.4978489876,
1.0143024921,
0.6252486706,
0.5115458369,
-0.0434689112,
1.1552336216,
-0.4258633852,
0.2992305756,
-0.4120460153,
0.5340060592,
-0.515008986,
-0.0101028765,
-0.3216865957,
-1.1584802866,
-0.3341986835,
1.038734436,
-0.0054991352,
-0.3597515821,
0.4418628216,
1.2059220076,
-0.1120390221,
0.1225068271,
0.2963819802,
0.1092662886,
-0.0662571564,
0.2981418073,
1.4599057436,
-0.3534935713,
0.4281800687,
-0.145165056,
-0.2590637207,
-0.1488589495,
-0.6813983321,
-1.066639781,
-0.6699082851,
-0.1238896027,
-0.7588009238,
0.1370776892,
1.2193120718,
0.5118677616,
-0.8383335471,
0.216075629,
-0.4491227567,
0.2873361707,
-0.0335041098,
-0.4059820771,
0.1192502826,
-0.606959641,
-0.7872076035,
0.6150243878,
0.4568420649,
-0.2300402373,
-0.4325229824,
0.0244519878,
-0.1139472872,
0.027461607,
0.3802773654,
0.3180191815,
-0.4229624569,
-0.3513022065,
-0.2936246097,
0.0428577587,
0.0186590776,
0.6504471302,
-1.1270691156,
0.7454605103,
1.2273446321,
0.7971894741,
0.1135745347,
0.0031967983,
0.4166496694,
-0.8504347205,
0.5554904938,
0.009496212,
0.5501733422,
0.6598140001,
-0.3916507959,
0.5061552525,
0.5594822168,
-0.8708807826,
-0.7182863355,
0.0865521058,
-1.1424473524,
-0.3416773975,
1.2349419594,
-0.0165271126,
-0.5215872526,
-0.4514506161,
-0.7008357644,
0.2699053288,
-0.5732361078,
0.2992708087,
0.491744101,
0.0522105098,
-0.4731326103,
-0.3817392588,
0.320843488,
-0.3523887694,
-0.5593191981,
-0.2652746439,
0.6485226154,
0.3061057925,
0.5380964279,
0.4674555361,
0.2973017097,
0.0970468447,
0.3575831056,
-0.0645289123,
-0.7452231646,
-0.0133230984,
-0.3502575159,
0.3470221758,
-0.3172517121,
-0.182605505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05503v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05503v1
|
Aligner: One Global Token is Worth Millions of Parameters When Aligning Large Language Models
| 2023-12-09T08:25:55 | 2023-12-09T08:25:55 |
Zhou Ziheng, Yingnian Wu, Song-Chun Zhu, Demetri Terzopoulos
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, I.2; I.2.6; I.2.7
|
We introduce Aligner, a novel Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning (PEFT) method
for aligning multi-billion-parameter-sized Large Language Models (LLMs).
Aligner employs a unique design that constructs a globally shared set of
tunable tokens that modify the attention of every layer. Remarkably with this
method, even when using one token accounting for a mere 5,000 parameters,
Aligner can still perform comparably well to state-of-the-art LLM adaptation
methods like LoRA that require millions of parameters. This capacity is
substantiated in both instruction following and value alignment tasks. Besides
the multiple order-of-magnitude improvement in parameter efficiency, the
insight Aligner provides into the internal mechanisms of LLMs is also valuable.
The architectural features and efficacy of our method, in addition to our
experiments demonstrate that an LLM separates its internal handling of "form"
and "knowledge" in a somewhat orthogonal manner. This finding promises to
motivate new research into LLM mechanism understanding and value alignment.
|
[
-0.1952762157,
-0.7030934691,
0.5638622642,
0.0057656486,
-0.3375301957,
0.0377355814,
-0.2446586043,
-0.2549907565,
0.0080655077,
0.3933658302,
-0.267687887,
-0.1148914322,
-0.5555796623,
-0.3680025935,
-0.0975269377,
0.876023531,
-0.1131889001,
0.0722540095,
0.0026776956,
-0.2698299587,
-0.1978004724,
-0.2796665728,
-0.8629582524,
-0.2203146666,
0.8029182553,
0.2948910594,
0.6458914876,
0.9317478538,
0.6899660826,
0.2889007926,
-0.0839424431,
0.2308037877,
-0.6057451367,
-0.1137826368,
-0.3807035387,
-0.3816204667,
-0.6305078268,
-0.2063602954,
0.9721129537,
0.7651072741,
-0.0193461236,
0.2865066826,
0.0880513191,
0.6737554669,
-0.6965996623,
-0.0692170039,
-0.8305651546,
-0.3479192257,
-0.314229995,
-0.0076086284,
-0.3021554649,
-0.276275605,
-0.0510257892,
-0.5950065255,
-0.203438133,
0.2280355692,
0.8593735099,
0.5804834366,
-0.3430080712,
0.2420232296,
-0.5633868575,
0.9077597857,
-0.6887642145,
0.6913416386,
-0.3315590322,
0.3085001111,
-0.1979298592,
-0.5759565234,
-0.623737812,
0.1210486367,
0.0849831626,
-0.177297473,
-0.0202219374,
0.1207531542,
-0.0172862373,
0.3686518669,
-0.3327170312,
0.4154576659,
-0.2507523596,
-0.2945384979,
0.5045221448,
0.1025330201,
0.2997095585,
0.3364483118,
-0.4180832803,
0.0150795169,
-0.8644767404,
0.0124805635,
0.3911782205,
0.5157687068,
0.0761288181,
0.4116611183,
0.0228666086,
0.973359108,
0.5527970791,
-0.3323765397,
0.0056971726,
-0.4329285324,
-0.2659521401,
0.3274383843,
0.7991227508,
0.2959531844,
-0.0730060712,
-0.2299131453,
-0.1804903895,
-0.1921353042,
0.1753074378,
-0.8646544218,
0.0023950664,
0.0740713626,
-0.2937054038,
-0.0986420736,
0.0253633074,
-0.619908452,
-0.5295951962,
-0.6063246727,
0.6750465631,
-0.2844396532,
-0.1448840797,
0.2327854931,
-0.116195865,
0.8271281123,
0.3255855739,
-1.1592819691,
0.3438217044,
1.0920428038,
0.6960981488,
-0.219938159,
-0.4649141431,
-0.7617820501,
0.2525959015,
-0.229096055,
0.8224734068,
-0.7628168464,
0.139880091,
-0.4096125364,
-0.0031212326,
-0.1940074116,
-0.4240304232,
0.5153437257,
-0.6133909225,
0.1073968261,
-0.3424909711,
-0.6818865538,
0.0343951993,
0.0220319405,
-0.6710048914,
0.9803696871,
0.208294332,
-0.4631535113,
0.4849567711,
-0.7952833176,
-0.2605062127,
0.0574694425,
-0.1543703824,
-0.3542723656,
0.4186703861,
0.2198417634,
0.267477721,
-0.382268399,
0.3139798939,
-0.3515321016,
-0.5424364209,
0.1850289404,
-0.547405839,
0.5049085021,
0.1559140384,
-0.2337893993,
0.2673282623,
-0.7567590475,
0.0259382073,
0.033474382,
-0.5082198381,
-0.2973875105,
-0.0214240495,
-0.0279023722,
-0.004477208,
0.7634179592,
-0.5699052215,
0.3224737644,
-0.6302561164,
0.6327556372,
0.9718254209,
-0.1921331733,
0.7035095692,
-0.2527327538,
0.4334634244,
0.0166570507,
0.2094586492,
-0.2259147912,
-0.0790517703,
-0.8276411295,
-0.3774247468,
0.5004010201,
0.1745470762,
0.1885617375,
0.6437561512,
-0.3391510546,
-0.5328885913,
-0.9591247439,
0.2888906896,
0.3948150575,
0.535082221,
0.1543914825,
0.090360783,
-0.415956527,
-0.9759089947,
-0.5383970141,
-0.0366303623,
0.1101011559,
0.119361639,
0.149954021,
0.0985657647,
0.7900451422,
-0.3397810757,
-0.1271023005,
0.1300901324,
-0.2203960717,
0.3213762641,
0.6123901606,
0.4973601699,
-0.6173949242,
-0.6011695266,
0.4066651464,
-0.2810360491,
-0.0884692147,
-0.1460646987,
-0.4273072183,
0.2269225419,
0.6810516715,
-0.3140693307,
-0.2709870636,
0.6943625212,
-0.3753556311,
0.1647809744,
-0.1836521029,
0.0387835912,
-1.1574058533,
0.1340128481,
-0.0685287043,
-0.1138519943,
-0.494242996,
0.2380531132,
0.3869875968,
0.1063230038,
-0.4871448278,
0.9394869208,
-0.4858814478,
0.3008667529,
-0.220758006,
0.2975545228,
-0.0378869958,
0.444445014,
-0.4363771379,
1.0044739246,
0.6209022999,
-0.3730541468,
0.2938061953,
0.1111733243,
-0.2068954557,
0.8954660892,
-0.6875947714,
0.3909656405,
-0.2025338411,
-0.112450555,
-1.1362444162,
-0.2577244341,
0.1254564673,
-0.0457578301,
0.3522814512,
-0.2076862901,
-0.3883676529,
-0.0710994825,
-0.377671808,
0.4293829799,
0.4230049551,
-0.8099830747,
0.9849858284,
0.4912586808,
-0.2671815753,
-0.5013349056,
-0.3822306395,
0.0682446957,
-0.558454752,
-0.5254517198,
0.577557385,
-0.2131721973,
-0.1581380963,
-0.1638261229,
-0.4716897905,
0.0748679191,
0.1659522802,
0.1273237616,
0.2699815035,
-0.5073416829,
0.3360724449,
0.3177563548,
-0.2079089284,
-0.1464874446,
-0.6773478389,
0.5324677825,
-0.2485417575,
-0.5804883242,
-0.4733636379,
0.1707543731,
0.9249252677,
-0.4199889898,
0.9288099408,
0.4961859882,
-0.2960174978,
-0.0777464062,
-0.8423737288,
0.1108028591,
-0.5172033906,
0.4954464734,
-0.4377304018,
-1.0499216318,
0.6133599281,
-0.3589050174,
0.1772217453,
0.4902650714,
0.440993011,
0.2373361588,
1.2428469658,
0.8022077084,
-0.477217108,
0.5941066742,
0.3830544949,
0.520201683,
-1.0258637667,
-0.1346076131,
-0.5837931037,
-0.7150880098,
-0.3357309103,
-0.2902098298,
0.2175747305,
0.3979570568,
-0.6240672469,
0.1911178827,
-0.6935471892,
0.9670698047,
0.4132171869,
-0.0070010936,
0.2099946886,
-0.280786097,
0.0018201844,
0.0284509454,
-0.551858604,
-0.5970383883,
1.0736252069,
0.3042041361,
0.8712792993,
0.1717150807,
0.6150895953,
-0.3764207959,
0.090045087,
-0.9051488638,
0.4005244076,
-0.3790493906,
-0.318246156,
-0.4626277685,
-0.0940273777,
-0.7453513145,
0.2601926923,
0.1083246171,
-0.9169074893,
-0.0203951336,
0.319128722,
-0.5948523879,
0.2905015051,
-0.9417201281,
1.0482882261,
-0.6632522941,
-0.4309087694,
-0.0520406775,
-0.5804573894,
0.0480639488,
-0.5463084579,
-0.0089649763,
-0.2017774284,
-0.4367625713,
0.7006656528,
-0.1410779953,
0.766091764,
-0.2775763273,
-0.4712586701,
-0.2223050296,
-0.2001416981,
0.6569548249,
-0.0592352077,
-0.3359656632,
-0.1059180573,
0.0256927349,
-0.382928431,
-0.6527041197,
0.9925410748,
-0.7616795301,
-0.7351549864,
0.0964160711,
-0.7910750508,
-0.2690418661,
0.4634235799,
-0.2039560825,
0.2278348953,
-0.2957989573,
0.3836158514,
0.7460134029,
0.0790829733,
0.3073207438,
0.6505689025,
-0.0291765667,
-0.4209337533,
0.9017345905,
-0.0675103515,
0.3260515332,
0.7500100136,
0.3787231147,
-0.308844775,
-0.6166535616,
-0.3459820747,
0.4177691042,
-0.5699799657,
-0.333186239,
-0.3451369107,
-0.1505543441,
-0.2268432975,
-0.3764995933,
-0.4994128942,
-0.3554098308,
-0.1826651394,
0.0153987585,
0.4522660673,
0.4338156879,
0.222482428,
0.5526178479,
-0.7108176947,
0.0798864514,
0.4232868552,
0.7975782156,
-0.1456756741,
-0.7187239528,
-0.2801392972,
-0.1319071054,
-0.1569657922,
-0.3617986441,
-0.0476698838,
0.4957235456,
0.8690851927,
0.6521334052,
-0.1302273273,
1.1350283623,
-0.6331273913,
0.6214876771,
0.008265119,
-1.3240427971,
0.3717617095,
-0.2670839429,
0.4273034632,
0.6730967164,
0.1447176933,
-0.5121429563,
-0.328325808,
-0.3320599794,
-0.7321195602,
0.7134574056,
-0.413102597,
0.4182710946,
0.2562197745,
0.6961622834,
0.2223581821,
-0.007763396,
-0.5846124291,
-0.0397324376,
0.2466891408,
-0.6981799603,
0.0071930634,
-0.1689959615,
-0.3397271931,
-0.3885560334,
0.6155385971,
-0.6051400304,
0.1182824001,
-0.189284116,
-0.0433563665,
-0.4544391036,
0.3024806678,
0.5446867347,
0.8032469153,
0.0735127181,
0.2715203166,
0.3797052801,
-0.0731090829,
0.0201645996,
0.2387086004,
0.1667423993,
-0.5545996428,
0.0703389198,
0.873558104,
0.486977458,
-0.6610848308,
0.3833434582,
-0.0009254352,
-0.2886707187,
0.1148873195,
0.3051083684,
0.3123338521,
0.5149460435,
0.1141415536,
0.0810687542,
-0.2092921287,
-0.2709309161,
0.0619633049,
0.7186281085,
-0.4231856167,
-0.4393028915,
0.9262672067,
0.1232043132,
-0.3174865246,
0.3193106949,
0.0449400209,
-0.4014289081,
0.2983121276,
0.7229554057,
0.7628709078,
-0.3799548149,
-0.2039513588,
0.1364994794,
0.0979501158,
-0.154215917,
0.186862275,
-0.0042570061,
-0.8233585358,
-0.6119132638,
-0.8478875756,
-0.3069317937,
0.0568134412,
-0.4552898705,
0.3264114261,
-0.4016199708,
0.2123152167,
0.4978384078,
-0.099526003,
-0.4459424615,
-0.3147515357,
0.1936937124,
0.8383843899,
-0.803888917,
0.8623350263,
0.8559208512,
-0.1549530327,
-1.0066139698,
-0.0519258566,
0.0875386074,
-1.0610127449,
0.5183996558,
0.0657884851,
-0.2641353011,
0.1591298431,
-0.6031239033,
-1.1538404226,
0.9417123795,
0.9160547256,
-0.841804862,
-0.0584942102,
0.0926822647,
0.3670428991,
-0.2379736453,
-0.150842309,
0.7946977019,
0.7515169978,
0.0465908796,
-1.0350465775,
0.2422029674,
-0.1609060764,
-0.1054322869,
0.8778650165,
-0.9991828203,
0.6655814052,
-0.103603974,
-0.0166942757,
0.0883039162,
0.4078409672,
0.1948383451,
-0.2197740823,
0.509213686,
0.6619395614,
1.1056693792,
-0.0864283741,
0.4967097938,
-0.6584913731,
0.2469927669,
1.0939102173,
-0.3732529581,
0.8078575134,
0.9248193502,
-0.1960108727,
0.2550162971,
0.3580387235,
-0.0767744333,
0.3780556619,
0.2083114386,
-0.1790899783,
-0.4297652543,
-0.0550344959,
-0.0864970833,
0.4876767695,
0.1771339923,
-0.2472482622,
-0.0160929281,
-0.2246011943,
0.0773990974,
-0.0465685874,
-0.3706765473,
1.0089930296,
-0.020975057,
-0.791492939,
0.4549203813,
-0.1526401341,
0.561157465,
-0.5878203511,
0.0627253875,
-0.0768053979,
0.6638416648,
-0.0810488984,
-0.6070523858,
0.1815167069,
-0.2504612207,
-0.1472572535,
-0.3496542275,
0.5326411724,
-0.4707278311,
-0.5463238955,
0.1504036039,
0.3286373913,
-0.1532238424,
-0.184484303,
-0.6248730421,
0.1948533058,
-0.1459977478,
-0.1242811829,
0.5195716619,
0.7500220537,
0.0712671205,
0.4051709473,
0.4564959407,
0.0586274974,
-0.0055006305,
0.2392144203,
0.9600144029,
-0.7119394541,
-0.291728884,
-1.0788639784,
0.6358063817,
-0.0028053115,
-0.3975796998,
0.6334636211,
0.6947773099,
0.8227900863,
0.2250214517,
0.6108518839,
0.2398217916,
0.2440712005,
-0.5364946127,
0.5272221565,
-0.6697149277,
0.2686635852,
-0.103806138,
-1.0298515558,
-0.5333654881,
0.4186236858,
-0.1675889939,
-0.1752916425,
0.5663148165,
0.8609284759,
-0.2360934764,
-0.1258525401,
0.255621314,
0.1608447134,
0.4340866506,
0.546905756,
0.6618621945,
-0.4216692746,
0.5285959244,
0.1429149359,
-0.186183989,
-0.0753076375,
-0.9755678177,
-0.7418487668,
-0.5114052892,
-0.398876816,
0.2125440836,
0.0037227708,
0.9931280017,
0.8732290268,
-0.9150303602,
-0.0526082925,
-0.1589687616,
0.0754046291,
-0.3321662545,
-0.1606280804,
0.4100096822,
-0.5498125553,
-0.9231604338,
0.3607087135,
0.4996064603,
-0.0736689419,
-0.1818670928,
-0.1250117123,
0.1630365998,
0.2049411386,
0.4105052352,
0.0974786431,
-0.9497843981,
-0.5330635905,
0.1870515496,
0.1024846584,
0.3145855665,
0.6786961555,
-0.6370201707,
0.4508663416,
0.3547726572,
0.8852342963,
0.1698214412,
0.0092058405,
0.8279399276,
-0.6688603759,
-0.1464218199,
-0.0450689383,
0.5226019025,
0.1739101708,
-0.4469703436,
0.1320707053,
-0.3003646433,
-0.8775455356,
-0.8303032517,
0.1008260995,
-1.1788144112,
-0.0865320563,
0.7715668082,
0.225972563,
-0.3360714614,
0.2023688257,
-0.4745788574,
0.1814479381,
-0.4902264476,
0.7419993877,
0.5629851818,
-0.097156629,
-0.3499911726,
-0.0443191789,
0.2695741951,
0.4494321346,
-0.7803522944,
0.3627134264,
0.261451453,
0.3263623416,
0.1307867914,
0.2319612056,
-0.2416092455,
0.0475516096,
-0.1990028024,
-0.1300162375,
-0.0197571591,
-0.1940558255,
-0.718069613,
0.1555275917,
0.4854469001,
-0.093222864
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05497v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05497v3
|
History Matters: Temporal Knowledge Editing in Large Language Model
| 2023-12-09T07:51:56 | 2023-12-14T12:06:24 |
Xunjian Yin, Jin Jiang, Liming Yang, Xiaojun Wan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The imperative task of revising or updating the knowledge stored within large
language models arises from two distinct sources: intrinsic errors inherent in
the model which should be corrected and outdated knowledge due to external
shifts in the real world which should be updated. Prevailing efforts in model
editing conflate these two distinct categories of edits arising from distinct
reasons and directly modify the original knowledge in models into new
knowledge. However, we argue that preserving the model's original knowledge
remains pertinent. Specifically, if a model's knowledge becomes outdated due to
evolving worldly dynamics, it should retain recollection of the historical
knowledge while integrating the newfound knowledge. In this work, we introduce
the task of Temporal Knowledge Editing (TKE) and establish a benchmark AToKe
(Assessment of TempOral Knowledge Editing) to evaluate current model editing
methods. We find that while existing model editing methods are effective at
making models remember new knowledge, the edited model catastrophically forgets
historical knowledge. To address this gap, we propose a simple and general
framework termed Multi-Editing with Time Objective (METO) for enhancing
existing editing models, which edits both historical and new knowledge
concurrently and optimizes the model's prediction for the time of each fact.
Our assessments demonstrate that while AToKe is still difficult, METO maintains
the effectiveness of learning new knowledge and meanwhile substantially
improves the performance of edited models on utilizing historical knowledge.
|
[
0.2203916907,
-0.9024623036,
0.7659906149,
0.038676843,
0.0530777164,
0.3016829789,
-0.2584310472,
-0.4957989156,
-0.2037489563,
0.3527867198,
-0.4894909561,
-0.3152288198,
-0.4648126662,
-0.2131280452,
-0.1586383581,
0.7119067311,
-0.320094347,
-0.0049509718,
-0.0472021811,
-0.2955889106,
-0.5147380829,
-0.6585493088,
-0.9049313068,
-0.5364763737,
0.3677307963,
0.178173691,
0.947781086,
0.756600678,
0.1727304459,
0.3098615706,
-0.736972928,
0.3778051138,
-0.3642264605,
0.0879336819,
-0.5498611331,
-0.5203548074,
-1.0121914148,
-0.1539685726,
0.9670904279,
0.5738357306,
-0.1354824007,
0.2574837208,
-0.1451709569,
0.4539836943,
-0.7353993058,
0.2595509589,
-0.6240514517,
0.1189508736,
-0.203623876,
-0.2956646085,
-0.1545892358,
-0.3331073523,
0.0021137064,
-0.9088357091,
0.1068961769,
-0.1917790771,
0.6599532962,
0.1272184402,
-0.4763477743,
0.0854704231,
-0.8154726028,
1.1319527626,
-0.9350968003,
0.6572228074,
0.2055681199,
0.1184279919,
-0.3079613149,
-0.6025902629,
-0.6256321669,
0.0828099921,
0.1933493763,
0.0138451615,
-0.1776541173,
-0.0978253037,
0.4071335793,
0.1608582586,
-0.0151887722,
0.1982880682,
-0.3620751202,
-0.3058153987,
0.4432036281,
0.2905460894,
0.3650394082,
-0.3014395535,
0.0425376445,
0.06540218,
-0.8514331579,
0.0554045141,
0.3135858178,
0.0129050948,
0.0929787457,
0.555293262,
-0.2024167776,
0.6047173142,
0.0121400291,
-0.4617059529,
-0.0720424876,
-0.4202699065,
-0.0457202494,
-0.0898060799,
0.4404559433,
0.5553126335,
0.3337438107,
-0.0774679258,
-0.0446356758,
-0.2324052602,
0.134472996,
-0.5063742399,
0.2585082948,
-0.0526070483,
-0.4161019325,
-0.1374691874,
-0.3713153005,
-0.6826331615,
-0.2386518717,
-0.5831789374,
0.3034636378,
-0.3998820186,
-0.0138516445,
0.1223421693,
-0.3449408114,
-0.3959972262,
0.8572688103,
-0.6147249937,
-0.1240564585,
0.5975915194,
0.7877303958,
0.3363485038,
-0.6112256646,
-0.2453765422,
0.6475179195,
-0.5634179711,
0.5344645977,
-0.6919548512,
-0.4899320602,
-0.0437511615,
-0.0028963571,
0.0397689044,
-0.1268474609,
0.2214109451,
-0.7663396597,
0.3685851991,
-0.2828033864,
-0.6560444236,
-0.2732717693,
0.2242340297,
-0.4869441986,
0.8409816027,
0.0424001254,
-0.4564382434,
0.6234768033,
-0.8059596419,
-0.3026069403,
-0.4386256337,
0.3132466376,
-0.3297504783,
0.2583052814,
0.4517325461,
0.1853059828,
-0.0372715779,
0.6475242972,
-0.2676972449,
0.0589133538,
0.3150296509,
-0.3158519566,
0.7197780013,
-0.0729283467,
0.0210361816,
0.1520538926,
-0.8179323077,
-0.1068886966,
-0.04788284,
-0.6302819252,
-0.4289509058,
0.2994477451,
-0.2482767105,
0.1580742896,
0.3713858724,
-0.6049386263,
0.758736968,
-0.0853148773,
0.6707667112,
1.0089207888,
0.5374114513,
0.3584625125,
-0.5303955674,
0.2176060826,
-0.1082407981,
0.4746549428,
-0.0665956065,
-0.2663400769,
-0.7466148138,
0.4347586334,
0.2793980837,
0.4945669472,
-0.5894869566,
-0.1175003573,
-0.4711526334,
-0.4343267977,
-0.2874073982,
0.1630445719,
0.1251934618,
0.3358878493,
0.3532242179,
-0.1286743581,
-0.6977006197,
-0.7397789955,
-0.4663111866,
-0.4884561598,
0.199400112,
0.2139691263,
0.4238161743,
-0.3108608127,
0.8968440294,
-0.4628062248,
-0.1670254618,
0.0610729009,
0.2930690944,
-0.0276785512,
0.4148106873,
0.6496370435,
-0.4445499778,
-0.0181759652,
0.2194850743,
-0.8447577953,
-0.2019365281,
-0.2795279324,
-0.0026455089,
0.4114570618,
0.6000394821,
-0.4040156603,
0.2995120287,
0.4342745245,
-0.3044017255,
0.60980618,
-0.4113905132,
0.8415690064,
-1.031881094,
-0.0989031792,
-0.5543652177,
-0.1383530945,
-0.4999969304,
-0.1080575213,
0.4503399134,
-0.2567196786,
-0.6058425307,
0.9954656363,
-0.3986041248,
0.3897525966,
-0.0605875142,
0.0381104685,
-0.0546118282,
0.5200158954,
-0.0688967407,
0.5018184185,
0.1674845219,
-0.5713851452,
0.0163109023,
0.2237902284,
-0.3680252135,
0.3946720958,
-0.3320678473,
0.4662761092,
-0.1082001999,
-0.073460862,
-0.3960977793,
0.0447647125,
-0.1430796832,
-0.3634949028,
0.5555375218,
-0.3041337729,
-0.5754756927,
-0.0080838753,
-0.1546116024,
0.3539979756,
0.1343789101,
-0.3053302765,
0.7858477831,
0.348611623,
-0.3062074482,
-0.797545433,
-0.5740272403,
0.2205199748,
-0.0292495862,
-0.722216785,
0.3569820225,
-0.0587890968,
-0.5711805224,
0.2305710465,
-0.2790155113,
-0.2139467746,
-0.0152350757,
0.0166670717,
0.2642659843,
-0.0970063359,
0.4724713862,
0.3935296535,
-0.0306784697,
-0.2786485255,
-0.1810903698,
0.1951441318,
0.3033246994,
-0.2213609666,
-0.4808553159,
0.250497818,
0.9645752907,
-0.1556230336,
0.7553325295,
0.1376788765,
-0.5180168152,
0.0985941589,
-0.9806930423,
0.0770643204,
-0.3576933742,
0.589725852,
-0.4409214854,
-0.9177706838,
0.6703296304,
0.0431772955,
0.5659404993,
0.7475423217,
0.1907232255,
-0.0508841276,
0.6403052211,
0.5769254565,
-0.2535850704,
0.8400005698,
0.0019753231,
-0.0399716608,
-0.9399841428,
0.0869131312,
-0.4379972219,
-0.2539871037,
-0.2469359487,
-0.2520035207,
0.3237394094,
0.2572564483,
-0.4678479731,
0.1418324858,
0.189431712,
0.4008767903,
0.231163159,
0.3575761616,
0.7230837941,
-0.3523590565,
0.2826397419,
-0.3082068563,
-0.8427075744,
-0.530164659,
1.3386772871,
0.170586586,
0.66423136,
0.3968828619,
0.2511347532,
0.5646945834,
0.1755345464,
-0.5059454441,
0.4107278287,
-0.2261683941,
-0.7923480272,
-0.4149720967,
-0.3593383431,
-0.661465764,
0.0027885535,
-0.3333368599,
-0.7018656731,
0.3456718922,
0.5747571588,
-0.3664714396,
0.8289621472,
-0.6090538502,
0.849904716,
-0.2083849162,
-0.4321346283,
-0.7218159437,
-0.309145242,
0.0841526985,
-0.1657410413,
0.5029039979,
-0.0101001859,
-0.1035903022,
0.9220323563,
-0.1806760728,
0.8998015523,
-0.0829994753,
0.3338571489,
0.0862971097,
0.4362277687,
0.6321678162,
-0.0013082181,
-0.2047320604,
0.3044926226,
0.0899294913,
-0.2144942433,
-0.7905935645,
0.4590919018,
-0.7544355392,
-0.776407361,
-0.13559407,
-0.7154760957,
-0.0370175354,
0.1162534952,
-0.0028230753,
0.721372664,
-0.4073262215,
0.2406140566,
0.4096988738,
-0.2996840179,
0.546718061,
0.6691890955,
-0.274417907,
-0.1945023835,
0.3688507378,
0.511824131,
0.5718426108,
0.6499965191,
0.480375737,
0.0877682269,
-0.5841658115,
-0.4917398989,
0.2071346641,
-0.8722730279,
0.0051766983,
-0.8368675709,
0.0048732474,
-0.5486491919,
-0.2960196435,
-0.6371116638,
-0.6541159749,
-0.1993837357,
0.1756379455,
0.4641284645,
0.7475039959,
-0.3044412136,
0.3210796714,
-0.9047089815,
0.3047598004,
0.3187707365,
0.1439492553,
0.0860972404,
-0.7283378243,
-0.246009931,
-0.0775948837,
-0.2876434922,
-0.873709023,
0.1082143113,
0.1989413351,
0.7164999247,
0.0533485264,
-0.2833711803,
1.0672841072,
-0.6510608792,
0.7241334319,
-0.164904505,
-1.3708831072,
0.7562906742,
-0.3025991321,
0.7333886027,
0.1967180222,
-0.02292585,
-1.1238094568,
-0.42324844,
-0.6718589067,
-0.6015588641,
0.6762292981,
-0.1603504419,
-0.2027251571,
0.3352570832,
0.4467840493,
0.0682587028,
0.28843683,
-0.603346765,
0.0412252843,
-0.0551509485,
0.2804746032,
-0.0430910103,
-0.6050713062,
0.1170340553,
-0.2251339853,
0.969835341,
0.2793474197,
-0.0914449021,
0.1018376723,
-0.4862187207,
-0.3500224948,
0.7693784833,
0.6734443307,
1.3783637285,
-0.2298782319,
-0.248979032,
0.6688699722,
-0.390352726,
0.0189559311,
-0.1645834297,
-0.3285013735,
-0.0632784218,
0.6947368383,
0.8324685097,
0.6573520303,
-0.3061421216,
0.1018400714,
0.1871704012,
0.0814966634,
-0.2806661129,
0.0370200165,
-0.1184951216,
0.4568530619,
0.2192776799,
0.2877816856,
-0.274023205,
-0.7636113167,
-0.0629848167,
0.0144987348,
-0.0069061881,
-0.1889137179,
0.6413815022,
-0.0678095445,
-0.474996388,
0.6969020367,
0.110767886,
-0.8116677999,
0.276904732,
0.1849801838,
0.5715572834,
-0.715580225,
-0.2528927326,
0.635107398,
0.4895920455,
-0.1684384048,
-0.0663079768,
0.2017862946,
-0.7680718303,
-0.5761377215,
-0.3502579629,
-0.4756336808,
0.1843500733,
-0.3889248371,
0.1937256157,
-0.4408285022,
-0.3095261455,
-0.0136123141,
-0.0705371648,
-0.6528217793,
0.0928465128,
-0.4017238617,
0.6398231983,
-0.7767595649,
0.6714646816,
0.3728709519,
-0.0717136115,
-0.3895870745,
-0.2239205986,
0.4825256169,
-0.5515423417,
0.6720761061,
-0.5667748451,
0.0237942319,
-0.2357177734,
-0.2422439158,
-1.0550308228,
0.9364087582,
0.2529618144,
-0.7352293134,
-0.2017928213,
-0.4337107241,
0.4010346532,
0.1037145928,
-0.1269764751,
0.4835602045,
0.6764774323,
-0.1553387493,
-1.2342140675,
-0.2805215716,
-0.0958609805,
-0.1274049729,
0.6402690411,
-0.4787743986,
1.0445100069,
-0.3445369005,
-0.3676770926,
0.003127289,
0.5599504113,
-0.1917679459,
0.0263079889,
0.380781889,
0.6013589501,
0.7016284466,
-0.2350856215,
1.1093388796,
-0.0532499105,
0.2437770665,
1.5055816174,
0.0241731387,
0.6880293489,
0.4038174152,
-0.3140151501,
0.1611544639,
0.5180357099,
0.1009879857,
0.137124151,
-0.2537721992,
-0.1518731713,
-0.1403173804,
0.1444005072,
-0.519371748,
0.4196190834,
0.1799526662,
-0.1473601311,
-0.2058108747,
-0.0322522931,
0.6307507753,
-0.0353797488,
-0.5365467668,
0.7014496922,
-0.2603932023,
-0.5977490544,
-0.0653367639,
0.1480122209,
0.1512292176,
-0.8879471421,
-0.0891903043,
-0.1867738068,
0.3543575108,
0.0252620485,
-0.8159310222,
0.4486551583,
0.0571084134,
-0.6090992093,
-0.3335844278,
0.4207850993,
-0.5381901264,
-0.6570376158,
0.2947896719,
0.4728594422,
-0.1871422976,
-0.1213568226,
-0.5077999234,
0.2828791142,
0.0910941958,
-0.250205487,
-0.0201503541,
0.5066020489,
-0.3349056542,
0.6085819602,
0.5190519094,
0.4326615036,
0.0169741008,
0.2121231854,
0.4155260921,
-0.8780486584,
-0.5052022338,
-0.929885447,
0.559435606,
-0.0793214366,
-0.4333155751,
0.5681775212,
0.4562417865,
0.90076226,
0.0553336106,
0.6177355647,
0.0761586726,
0.5937967896,
-0.9229078293,
0.8536016941,
-0.8027172089,
-0.0130307814,
-0.3769714832,
-0.8577493429,
-0.272832334,
0.1533498466,
-0.5213741064,
-0.0149215423,
0.8360317349,
0.5847411156,
0.1411236972,
0.0592796057,
0.3240931034,
0.4224393666,
0.3902910948,
0.6171917319,
0.919441402,
-0.3658940196,
0.1527320892,
-0.4395445883,
-0.2126685679,
0.0585291907,
-1.062967062,
-0.7560721636,
-0.6423438191,
-0.4372286499,
-0.0522820987,
0.6090743542,
0.9588521123,
0.5253571868,
-0.6338261366,
-0.2840061188,
0.679992795,
0.1791321039,
-0.4026529789,
-0.1615565568,
0.6494360566,
-0.1440011859,
-0.8353046179,
0.4425284564,
0.3533999622,
0.210473761,
0.2483940423,
0.2486794889,
-0.4921478331,
-0.1415148824,
0.8166971803,
0.2964884043,
-0.6909889579,
-0.7023249865,
-0.2041313052,
0.2905507386,
0.2236562967,
1.1215872765,
-0.3917274177,
0.9860862494,
0.435300678,
0.5802256465,
0.6359609962,
-0.1883434355,
0.6490826011,
-0.5949540138,
0.1543509215,
-0.094831638,
0.7362638712,
0.3901340067,
-0.3804843426,
0.3717927337,
0.4554166794,
-0.649869144,
-0.4557885528,
0.035549216,
-0.8614369035,
-0.6981437802,
0.8930402398,
0.0165299531,
-0.1293535233,
-0.1761298329,
-0.1369388103,
0.6977066994,
-0.384183079,
0.8152913451,
1.1830205917,
-0.0491286144,
-0.0831488669,
-0.8100496531,
0.2483246922,
0.2060598582,
-0.6561020017,
0.1902897954,
0.8099753261,
0.1982292831,
0.109415479,
0.3515834808,
-0.316727072,
0.3977806866,
0.0149705,
0.136344552,
-0.3847393095,
-0.4557929039,
-0.118618086,
0.0773842335,
-0.0070959581,
0.1168631464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05491v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05491v1
|
Using Captum to Explain Generative Language Models
| 2023-12-09T07:35:24 | 2023-12-09T07:35:24 |
Vivek Miglani, Aobo Yang, Aram H. Markosyan, Diego Garcia-Olano, Narine Kokhlikyan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.7
|
Captum is a comprehensive library for model explainability in PyTorch,
offering a range of methods from the interpretability literature to enhance
users' understanding of PyTorch models. In this paper, we introduce new
features in Captum that are specifically designed to analyze the behavior of
generative language models. We provide an overview of the available
functionalities and example applications of their potential for understanding
learned associations within generative language models.
|
[
-0.5378976464,
-0.5949728489,
0.3169426918,
0.0310228691,
-0.3335313499,
0.1549500227,
-0.1965714991,
-0.13059403,
-0.1776208133,
0.3924868703,
-0.6316173673,
-0.5129723549,
-0.1329454929,
0.0477778018,
-0.7815740705,
1.0575876236,
-0.2301587611,
-0.0968274474,
-0.5708007812,
-0.2019423693,
-0.6968471408,
-0.6053625345,
-0.4758713543,
-0.442495048,
0.4684896469,
0.5528776646,
0.9199627638,
0.3300814033,
0.6607218981,
0.2660157382,
-0.0650436506,
-0.1945619434,
-0.2855353951,
0.0822643861,
-0.02197011,
-0.9194000363,
-0.3574401736,
-0.0686401725,
0.7741184235,
0.7902653217,
-0.176688388,
-0.1388448477,
-0.1445792019,
0.5798467994,
-0.4363418221,
0.545027256,
-0.3380232155,
0.0920854583,
-0.0934400931,
-0.4853090942,
-0.5328426361,
-0.0825032964,
0.5483444333,
-0.5584632158,
0.8846806288,
0.2212419659,
0.8873535395,
-0.029547058,
-0.0334348455,
-0.3967489898,
-0.4998327196,
0.4158631861,
-0.3298741281,
0.2901850939,
0.2633455694,
0.8626658916,
-0.0466534235,
-0.8473878503,
-0.7549329996,
-0.433598429,
-0.7447454333,
0.2850624323,
-0.4358142614,
0.5300338864,
0.2217550278,
1.1077786684,
-0.8235833049,
-0.0625540912,
-0.2038989216,
-0.2055169493,
0.3345891237,
0.0717312321,
0.7319868207,
-0.1935157776,
-0.2151734531,
0.0484445766,
-0.5005510449,
-0.2578337193,
0.3554487526,
0.1894218326,
-0.5273993611,
0.601793766,
0.0530607589,
1.069001317,
-0.5284463763,
0.6255757809,
0.0369183719,
-0.000435642,
-0.2735167146,
-0.3100286424,
0.4316898584,
0.1269133687,
0.4478352368,
-0.506822288,
-0.0157345776,
-0.0018079829,
0.2008634806,
-0.6589955688,
-0.8253830075,
0.2963875234,
-0.7091256976,
-0.2748913169,
0.2841276228,
-0.9356971979,
-0.4536437094,
-0.291236788,
0.2616609931,
-0.5271530151,
-0.5787463784,
0.0058611846,
-0.5131145716,
0.3977166116,
0.2255508006,
-1.0500695705,
0.4310775101,
0.7127034664,
1.2542456388,
-0.2535595596,
-0.4792403281,
-0.5150817037,
-0.1719338,
-0.071245335,
0.7517209053,
-0.4337800741,
-0.1024823561,
0.329234153,
0.1848777831,
-0.2435050607,
-0.6740175486,
0.1040276587,
-0.9051961303,
-0.0004531902,
-0.1550924182,
-0.5526346564,
-0.75046736,
-0.0337387621,
-1.0507459641,
0.3165837526,
0.2549037635,
-0.7878447175,
0.3154131174,
-1.0997512341,
-0.4541609287,
0.2201407999,
0.2990075946,
-0.5105345845,
0.4099149406,
0.0108997198,
0.37018767,
-0.0423950069,
0.0980832279,
-0.0778667033,
-0.1009194404,
0.8621858358,
-0.3047708273,
0.8209452033,
0.6697856188,
0.1250814497,
0.6515312791,
-0.3078503609,
-0.645519495,
0.0658045113,
0.0481095612,
-0.0407097898,
0.0034047877,
0.2338625938,
-0.3868465126,
0.1724024266,
0.0780336782,
-0.0108555518,
-0.3467201591,
0.776124239,
0.2457523793,
-0.0097916648,
0.6837667823,
-0.3596234918,
0.9437607527,
-0.1106940657,
-0.0037764045,
-0.5426834822,
-0.2381342947,
-0.9927364588,
-0.5832260847,
0.2496690005,
0.1706571132,
-0.8030525446,
0.2250633687,
0.0619658977,
-0.279206574,
-0.2095305771,
0.1117937639,
0.1853962392,
0.1933074445,
0.1369400024,
-0.5555665493,
-0.5874074697,
-0.8306415677,
-0.0591170229,
-0.3087235093,
-0.067047514,
0.0775180086,
0.6290199161,
-0.0181440935,
1.2188653946,
-0.3468636274,
-0.0032252704,
-0.8399628997,
0.5221729279,
0.0533836745,
0.1935350001,
0.7177577019,
-0.8580260277,
-0.0564815626,
-0.0244851802,
-0.8671273589,
-0.2684369385,
-0.2878601551,
-0.4162481725,
0.1770886183,
0.4115821123,
-0.7766676545,
0.3147169352,
0.6199553013,
-0.3870582283,
0.5266662836,
-0.4056108892,
-0.1094975248,
-0.8860166669,
0.2230247259,
-0.0020070504,
-0.2976534367,
-0.6702126265,
0.7739398479,
-0.1630281657,
-0.1884421408,
-0.2257155627,
0.276393503,
-0.6745353937,
-0.5385712385,
-0.4440969229,
0.3656133413,
-0.0684439242,
0.1485940814,
0.283548981,
0.9324422479,
0.6122452617,
-0.5553453565,
0.5839973688,
0.5730689168,
-0.4362612665,
0.3068771362,
-0.5385596752,
-0.2226622701,
-0.3034888208,
-0.0518103987,
-1.3082946539,
-0.456772089,
0.1676165015,
-0.7191243768,
0.2189082503,
-0.2958278656,
-0.7646502852,
-0.4096370637,
0.078122668,
0.3830265105,
0.4687081873,
-0.9051439166,
0.8140972853,
0.2676310837,
0.1674678922,
-0.1741394401,
-0.4721245468,
0.0112747643,
-0.6292796731,
-0.4362541437,
0.1125854328,
-0.0748843029,
-0.4128772616,
-0.0790927857,
0.1536357403,
-0.2462752908,
0.387827158,
0.4031099677,
0.401966542,
-0.1953428686,
0.3989409506,
-0.1353006214,
-0.1480485946,
0.1485840827,
0.0844145268,
0.9117240906,
-0.4056684077,
0.0798099712,
-0.7248104811,
-0.0293792821,
0.7993862033,
-0.5253734589,
0.8802461028,
0.3055195212,
-0.2634474039,
-0.2177923024,
-0.1984326243,
-0.3389009535,
-0.4185191393,
0.4951148331,
-0.494568646,
-0.757989645,
0.8300384283,
0.2096279114,
-0.0458805934,
0.4340808392,
0.7104640007,
-0.0935753807,
0.5745460987,
0.7922217846,
-0.0904900804,
0.6669692993,
-0.3520154059,
0.160079658,
-0.5253671408,
-0.2070231587,
-0.4772816002,
0.2338448763,
-0.5688797235,
-0.4053195119,
-0.117326051,
0.2740529776,
-0.173181355,
0.7566981316,
-0.3391225338,
0.4145375192,
0.4872708917,
-0.1478864849,
0.4961824119,
0.3910343051,
0.1602015346,
0.1304839104,
-1.0233007669,
-0.4531940818,
0.5085523725,
0.5315759778,
0.81526649,
0.2228197157,
0.247197032,
0.3271676004,
0.7639257908,
-1.1222366095,
0.396610558,
-0.0593921579,
-0.8230795264,
-0.1017012,
-0.4261102974,
-1.1287306547,
0.3253551722,
-0.2451630235,
-0.7391720414,
-0.2924298048,
0.4028937221,
-0.3245028555,
0.2382432222,
-0.9176159501,
1.2664301395,
-0.1885506809,
-0.0638034269,
-0.4759149253,
-0.4847041368,
0.3532577753,
0.3831925988,
0.1346042901,
0.1726428568,
0.3076104224,
0.7157313824,
-0.3312895894,
0.9085907936,
0.0098063005,
0.0227210671,
0.6272623539,
0.425503999,
-0.0207929872,
-0.1589006186,
0.1722335368,
0.1534154713,
0.1748449206,
-0.1590480208,
-0.7856704593,
0.580594182,
-0.676448226,
-0.3565109372,
-0.4376957417,
-0.9631597996,
0.1177560836,
-0.1372604221,
-0.1589472592,
0.4230850339,
-0.1690581441,
-0.0944524482,
0.3324829042,
-0.5473262072,
0.3666274548,
0.4853527844,
-0.3987675905,
-0.2473236471,
1.1363363266,
-0.2606920898,
0.2886606455,
0.6303597093,
0.1063779071,
-0.4459300637,
-0.5569398403,
-0.1590741724,
0.3986157179,
-0.8258732557,
0.1550022066,
-0.4437288046,
-0.2572940886,
-0.0253361631,
-0.2711643875,
0.3207291663,
-0.407165885,
-0.5296982527,
-0.330702275,
0.538465023,
0.6054331064,
0.0274127573,
1.0787992477,
-0.6027701497,
0.4173386693,
0.3681245148,
0.4080780745,
0.2673893273,
-0.6575003266,
0.0037338049,
-0.3504939973,
-0.1874942183,
-1.157798171,
0.4564054608,
0.1729421765,
0.712069571,
0.6885553002,
-0.1448920965,
0.4422652423,
-0.0754966512,
0.5546861887,
0.0853942409,
-1.1933978796,
0.4807795286,
-0.3369736373,
0.0645812228,
0.2710722983,
0.1920885891,
-0.520921886,
-0.139399156,
-0.6703284979,
-0.577159822,
0.6184895635,
0.5360836983,
0.1013246998,
0.1480615586,
0.5313965082,
0.2118859142,
0.3746075332,
-0.7317201495,
-0.2677569985,
-0.1137497351,
-0.3719869256,
-0.2778820693,
-0.5129616261,
-0.1226094738,
-0.0290803686,
0.4028661251,
-0.0158575065,
0.4009118676,
-0.2440034151,
-0.5398332477,
-0.0761019513,
0.1558995396,
0.468598336,
0.8323116302,
-0.326967895,
0.4291193485,
-0.0795314386,
-0.1214208826,
-0.3718444705,
0.3667054772,
0.087047711,
0.0457957536,
0.666533649,
0.7263264656,
-0.1950188279,
-0.7888546586,
0.4346596003,
0.103231214,
0.0773491412,
-0.574549675,
0.0152734546,
-0.0057277097,
0.1767387241,
0.0756166726,
-0.1422614306,
0.1915471405,
-0.8171223402,
0.2878482342,
0.5572897196,
-0.6022894979,
-0.3933364153,
0.8070579767,
0.1863899976,
-0.1275767386,
0.834610045,
0.0107525578,
-0.7145938277,
0.8630671501,
0.3871465325,
0.8326013684,
0.0844480097,
0.6521650553,
0.445943445,
0.4231155515,
0.2306907624,
-0.1335964054,
-0.4633926451,
-0.8948318362,
-0.4873486757,
-0.5966652632,
-0.3420068324,
0.0862346664,
-0.7908465862,
0.065294005,
-0.2203295082,
0.1797273606,
0.268602252,
-0.566513896,
-0.4848607183,
-0.0198104661,
0.0152133945,
0.9933488369,
-1.1416424513,
0.4817003012,
0.7304307818,
-0.9446508288,
-0.2486289442,
0.0587551482,
-0.1643566936,
-0.9855845571,
0.639182806,
0.3258593082,
-0.0009350574,
-0.0094517684,
-0.7344099283,
-0.3338113427,
0.7980425954,
0.3158412278,
-0.2886995077,
0.264107734,
0.1603015065,
0.6194599271,
-0.313968569,
0.2910879552,
0.9127762318,
0.3203057349,
0.1259784549,
-0.387349695,
0.1083150879,
-0.0060236882,
0.0819654092,
0.0078876587,
-0.312916249,
0.4408145249,
-0.5075269938,
-0.557238102,
0.7957345843,
0.9338828921,
0.1779303402,
0.3821987808,
0.4583622813,
0.4504212141,
0.4610584378,
-0.3901935816,
1.2835659981,
-0.1422336996,
0.7296482921,
0.9555946589,
0.2213674188,
0.5923458338,
0.4255383313,
-0.255437851,
0.6646216512,
0.70364362,
-0.1339598596,
0.3485520482,
0.4974735677,
-0.5653150678,
-0.5264191628,
0.0083122253,
-0.0574462973,
0.3157448471,
0.4239287674,
-0.5863124132,
-0.3392892182,
0.1542083919,
-0.1720833033,
0.0692607909,
-0.3026002347,
0.615182519,
0.0159509238,
-0.6495042443,
0.2462910861,
-0.1641562581,
0.128485769,
-0.227925092,
-0.3470820487,
-0.1402987689,
0.0590251535,
-0.3303236365,
-0.8124525547,
0.3452464938,
-0.2264270782,
-0.1901762933,
0.1560716033,
0.3726866245,
-0.4200642407,
-0.2148868889,
0.1008863524,
0.4789077342,
0.4028689563,
-0.2619741857,
-0.3362199068,
-0.071088247,
-0.2505942881,
0.3179605603,
-0.0198255703,
0.1791872829,
0.0359143168,
0.9749346972,
0.3797782063,
-0.2027944624,
-0.1079432219,
0.3856278956,
0.5730969906,
-0.4937493801,
-0.2672608197,
-0.8001567721,
0.5652380586,
0.0408683978,
0.1004219428,
0.6764919758,
0.5442302823,
0.6248582006,
-0.518288672,
1.0320048332,
-0.3407161832,
0.0557679497,
-0.588373363,
0.95087111,
-0.4424232841,
0.1850141585,
0.0520333201,
-0.8941985965,
-0.7814695239,
0.9558273554,
-0.3908772171,
0.0901687071,
0.8303028941,
0.872654438,
-0.0588774383,
0.1681777984,
0.4410501122,
0.4039459527,
0.1253062785,
0.2405190468,
1.3679189682,
-0.0231076628,
0.581915915,
-0.1448530555,
-0.4026809037,
-0.2054505944,
-0.5536389947,
-1.4589912891,
-0.8282501101,
-0.4907793105,
-0.3347562551,
0.056677863,
0.4784339964,
0.6984167695,
-1.0879528522,
-0.4233800471,
-0.7103505135,
0.3458560705,
-0.3184472322,
-0.3442983925,
0.4025534391,
-0.5727695227,
-0.6710008383,
0.0568303615,
-0.0375279076,
0.1843859851,
-0.3760685325,
0.0096902326,
0.1500613093,
-0.2804542184,
0.5309761167,
0.5350005627,
-0.6863421798,
-0.0706565306,
-0.363945812,
0.4673783183,
-0.0926976427,
1.3018269539,
-0.5465314984,
0.910692513,
0.8411265612,
0.3371520638,
0.5021092892,
0.0572979935,
0.7521663904,
-0.3164938688,
0.1180114746,
-0.20547916,
0.7143464684,
0.5013763309,
-0.0138935791,
0.439447552,
0.3131263852,
-0.2834772468,
-0.6001961827,
0.4807123542,
-1.2668765783,
-0.1958937496,
1.0065540075,
-0.2352749258,
-0.0687149018,
-0.2193668038,
-0.3877264857,
0.6406880021,
-0.0945174396,
0.8835336566,
0.5636825562,
0.0476547666,
-0.6877266169,
-0.8853203058,
0.3646650314,
0.2395103872,
-0.8654643297,
0.5199796557,
0.7125044465,
0.3820946515,
0.1106438637,
0.0702228844,
-0.2290549427,
0.4478307068,
-0.2523871362,
0.1919654459,
-0.0408308133,
-0.4991220832,
-0.5586619377,
0.3064631522,
0.6028496027,
-0.3524276614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05488v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05488v2
|
Can Large Language Models Serve as Rational Players in Game Theory? A Systematic Analysis
| 2023-12-09T07:33:26 | 2023-12-12T18:32:39 |
Caoyun Fan, Jindou Chen, Yaohui Jin, Hao He
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.GT
|
Game theory, as an analytical tool, is frequently utilized to analyze human
behavior in social science research. With the high alignment between the
behavior of Large Language Models (LLMs) and humans, a promising research
direction is to employ LLMs as substitutes for humans in game experiments,
enabling social science research. However, despite numerous empirical
researches on the combination of LLMs and game theory, the capability
boundaries of LLMs in game theory remain unclear. In this research, we endeavor
to systematically analyze LLMs in the context of game theory. Specifically,
rationality, as the fundamental principle of game theory, serves as the metric
for evaluating players' behavior -- building a clear desire, refining belief
about uncertainty, and taking optimal actions. Accordingly, we select three
classical games (dictator game, Rock-Paper-Scissors, and ring-network game) to
analyze to what extent LLMs can achieve rationality in these three aspects. The
experimental results indicate that even the current state-of-the-art LLM
(GPT-4) exhibits substantial disparities compared to humans in game theory. For
instance, LLMs struggle to build desires based on uncommon preferences, fail to
refine belief from many simple patterns, and may overlook or modify refined
belief when taking actions. Therefore, we consider that introducing LLMs into
game experiments in the field of social science should be approached with
greater caution.
|
[
-0.4925734997,
-0.8688431978,
0.9490450025,
0.1544577181,
-0.0513338819,
0.0780542642,
-0.6266493797,
-0.4821912944,
0.1510208249,
0.5057935715,
-0.3255320787,
-0.1859079301,
-0.5017820001,
0.2759949565,
0.0837444514,
0.6545231938,
-0.107426703,
0.1706634462,
0.0599244088,
-0.1421918422,
-0.4462499917,
-0.7091454268,
-0.672373116,
-0.5789978504,
0.6324118376,
0.326551944,
0.8456763029,
0.6467706561,
0.4737021029,
0.4307179153,
0.0739628002,
-0.1484162211,
-0.8733088374,
0.1319560558,
-0.3070113361,
-0.8546674848,
-0.31497702,
0.4178532362,
0.7690069079,
0.4483867288,
0.0265833884,
-0.1814549863,
0.0589985326,
0.6311772466,
-0.1321711689,
0.1793591231,
-0.6132441759,
0.1030862555,
-0.1198946089,
-0.2771876454,
-0.4065952897,
-0.4422175288,
0.3023970723,
-0.8246125579,
-0.0253034662,
0.1179481223,
0.6116690636,
-0.2266094089,
-0.3701572418,
-0.3794083595,
-0.9293048978,
0.9093632102,
-0.9072785378,
-0.0127816405,
0.4551995695,
0.3445212543,
-0.6258624792,
-0.0732057318,
-0.738809824,
-0.3245846927,
0.0486103743,
0.0408618264,
-0.0293275025,
0.3774399757,
0.8138235807,
0.1364201158,
-0.2088846713,
0.0789119303,
-0.3380641043,
0.0495232046,
0.9192288518,
0.2882860899,
0.1863177717,
0.0549877994,
-0.3024235964,
0.2026818246,
-0.7092615366,
0.4013238251,
0.3706049621,
0.076198101,
0.0455052778,
0.6808460355,
-0.2025221884,
0.3473807275,
0.1052716002,
-0.4995648265,
-0.2157671452,
-0.1447728872,
-0.1499972194,
-0.092888549,
0.7966336608,
0.5750149488,
0.5234506726,
-0.2211116105,
-0.3781488836,
0.4380989969,
0.0903559923,
-0.7695869207,
-0.0123827364,
0.0997011736,
-0.4178273976,
-0.2591232955,
-0.0469035096,
-0.6792862415,
-0.6093298197,
-0.3288604617,
0.3368935585,
-0.4144451618,
-0.4767846167,
0.1777403057,
-0.2195788771,
0.6271764636,
0.2686502039,
-1.0103869438,
0.5464698672,
0.9085761309,
0.6832713485,
-0.243554756,
-0.3695122004,
-0.2224852592,
0.3678925633,
-0.5861551166,
0.660161376,
-0.632475853,
-0.6179010868,
0.0969902724,
-0.2324794084,
0.0153501192,
-0.2754669785,
0.4754534662,
-0.5806414485,
-0.0013784375,
-0.6372916698,
-0.9009046555,
-0.3335795999,
0.6814382672,
-0.4872245193,
0.3298689723,
-0.1507491618,
-0.4125515819,
0.4917789102,
-0.5354730487,
-0.4154692292,
0.2127122134,
-0.5111947656,
-0.0118969055,
0.3866864443,
-0.3565764725,
0.3152773082,
-0.6094929576,
0.4175904989,
-0.8334850073,
-0.6105855703,
0.9130929708,
-0.510430932,
0.4745884538,
-0.0523076579,
-0.3353840113,
0.1354942769,
-0.0453124829,
0.1299872398,
0.1997082829,
-0.454082191,
-0.1118172854,
0.5793013573,
-0.3490988612,
0.4096562266,
-0.0529803224,
-0.3660835326,
0.3585562408,
-0.266194284,
0.6301816106,
0.9293652177,
-0.172112152,
0.7691332102,
-0.6717559695,
0.5274083018,
-0.6134368181,
0.1773438752,
0.411033541,
-0.4011908472,
-0.5913906097,
-0.5007821321,
0.2641717494,
0.4769934118,
-0.5539507866,
0.2913691103,
-0.2002450973,
-0.2721912563,
-0.0240564682,
-0.1615477055,
0.0942092091,
0.1270201653,
-0.1455134153,
-0.0678268522,
-0.552985549,
-0.8355961442,
-0.3701820374,
-0.505161643,
0.0468084216,
0.571141839,
0.3200010955,
-0.0413057059,
1.0354208946,
-0.2322833538,
-0.2755745053,
-0.3745603859,
-0.1693349779,
0.2051197141,
0.2946076095,
0.4234082401,
-0.6447232366,
-0.3539949358,
-0.1003593281,
-0.8312998414,
0.1131878421,
-0.1012850031,
-0.0495162271,
0.1828282773,
0.2763293386,
-0.8753344417,
0.3544687927,
0.4553203583,
-0.3357343972,
0.5374248028,
-0.1483662575,
0.3360390365,
-0.6471295357,
-0.100219436,
0.108868137,
0.1565789729,
-0.9645441175,
-0.0518785939,
-0.170929268,
0.2995336056,
-0.0467185229,
0.3833350539,
-0.2884249985,
-0.2706344724,
-0.3094135225,
0.3314014375,
-0.2255441099,
0.3387701213,
0.1753465533,
0.4941788614,
0.5321512818,
-0.7372635603,
0.102116406,
-0.2737883031,
-0.3359318376,
0.4866220057,
-0.795650661,
-0.1170159429,
0.0178794824,
0.2580599785,
-0.8936859369,
-0.3943096697,
0.3127518296,
-0.4100115597,
-0.0330372453,
-0.2472301424,
-0.5285825729,
-0.2693278193,
-0.3109400272,
0.2319166362,
0.7901175618,
0.0892912,
0.6790319681,
0.6525065303,
-0.0483465269,
-0.1716764122,
-0.4059821069,
-0.0579234734,
-0.6614164114,
-0.7511519194,
0.0705448315,
-0.2841359079,
-0.6965306401,
-0.2728133202,
0.0048788441,
-0.0242332835,
0.2775465548,
0.0113216573,
0.4239047766,
-0.2501656413,
-0.0075180456,
-0.28876248,
0.0955101252,
0.410623312,
-0.0200396422,
0.4738678336,
-0.2352560461,
-0.1752016544,
-0.1770067662,
0.2469069958,
0.5512931347,
-0.0549901761,
0.4137104452,
0.0627313703,
-0.317168802,
-0.0024391997,
-0.7371877432,
-0.2511913776,
-0.5149448514,
0.3146062493,
-0.4481160045,
-1.2201501131,
0.6875951886,
-0.1802945286,
0.0842720792,
0.2982711196,
0.4297051728,
-0.1641018391,
1.3046476841,
0.2489257455,
0.0834544003,
0.1734678894,
-0.0753710195,
-0.0270375051,
-0.854277432,
-0.1045380682,
-0.3188225031,
-0.434671551,
-0.6365830302,
-0.4302101433,
0.1209016219,
0.3520508707,
-0.5324876904,
-0.1285539567,
-0.0747403726,
0.7362528443,
0.0275088381,
-0.1119413376,
0.0749072507,
-0.0609579347,
0.0403271541,
-0.1512681097,
-0.713978529,
-0.6810026169,
0.8398244381,
0.5424623489,
0.553047359,
0.5465453863,
0.7240720391,
0.1042557061,
0.4504877031,
-0.9779869318,
0.7361928821,
0.3940960765,
-0.8315604925,
-0.7273471355,
-0.5413330197,
-0.8970897794,
0.4649299383,
-0.5533261895,
-0.729999125,
0.1140484288,
0.1256498694,
-0.4750828147,
0.3854801357,
-0.5696890354,
0.6583310366,
-0.2318624556,
-0.5523915291,
-0.295316577,
-0.1993352175,
0.8546247482,
-0.1013121828,
0.5082899928,
-0.3627527952,
-0.198616311,
0.7510908246,
-0.0270318892,
0.7277651429,
-0.1667160541,
-0.2662782669,
0.2854991853,
0.4954595268,
0.6403818727,
0.4521107972,
-0.0265145879,
0.1062980592,
-0.0173258204,
-0.5049646497,
-0.5288931131,
0.8874339461,
-0.8321155906,
-1.1697146893,
-0.7866057158,
-0.6484594345,
-0.290107131,
0.2877615094,
-0.1172562912,
0.0855121985,
-0.5376722217,
0.212504074,
0.8447244763,
0.0042383131,
0.4380579293,
0.6520346403,
-0.3157411218,
-0.2557759285,
0.8296154141,
0.1572541744,
0.4135306478,
-0.1351600289,
0.4127865434,
-0.2216379046,
-0.6713748574,
-0.0944834799,
0.3554641008,
-0.2517810166,
0.1225109473,
-0.2011631429,
0.0643701851,
-0.0556058101,
-0.4101886749,
-0.0598756187,
0.0598423667,
-0.1471206248,
0.1569077522,
0.213655889,
1.021484375,
-0.107089065,
0.1896678507,
-0.4545420706,
0.223201856,
0.3795697093,
0.4512736201,
0.1008411497,
-0.5443197489,
0.0902656317,
0.3697379231,
0.0549867488,
-0.8527982831,
0.2008120865,
-0.2329409122,
0.6844819188,
0.4739178419,
-0.0362816826,
0.7169428468,
-0.7915300727,
0.6348796487,
0.3339808583,
-0.8964189887,
0.0124423727,
-0.8037700653,
-0.0689230859,
0.3412159681,
0.1956237704,
-0.6047258973,
0.0333538838,
-0.5724021792,
-0.3020758629,
0.9143402576,
0.119911693,
0.0278572068,
-0.0858505815,
0.3050198853,
-0.0962122828,
0.0271500889,
-0.6813624501,
0.0468750782,
0.1889043748,
0.2289418727,
-0.265796721,
-0.3085183799,
-0.315536499,
0.0185673423,
0.4725624919,
0.0351499803,
0.0740958005,
0.1064646989,
0.2076413035,
-0.3309589326,
0.3899941742,
0.6855450869,
0.8712908626,
-0.0876648799,
0.0747851059,
0.319360882,
-0.1178338751,
0.4043568671,
-0.1204773411,
-0.3677814603,
-0.5812677741,
0.233992368,
0.3735192418,
0.2703968883,
-0.7168501019,
0.3492749333,
-0.0816929713,
-0.581202507,
-0.4731726646,
0.1441782713,
0.1218466088,
0.5809084773,
0.2622517943,
0.0877755508,
-0.0677188486,
-0.8916931152,
0.0827683881,
0.7461411357,
-0.2483198345,
-0.3937726021,
0.2345575392,
0.2370616347,
-0.5481771827,
0.2243653685,
-0.3508074582,
-0.5424748063,
0.5353131294,
0.5975196362,
0.6078641415,
-0.0166475885,
0.3687840402,
0.1841736287,
0.4235948622,
-0.4673813581,
0.1483262777,
0.4863272011,
-0.8838861585,
-0.7349912524,
-0.1937063634,
-0.2208549678,
0.1291102916,
-0.3421131968,
-0.0377663076,
-0.5870275497,
-0.3625217676,
-0.1093275994,
0.2101611346,
-0.3844279349,
-0.3834402263,
0.2137885094,
0.4706671536,
-0.5189681053,
0.7953077555,
0.2906048298,
-0.4033307135,
-0.851161778,
-0.05764357,
-0.0557040721,
-0.5612570047,
0.6534600258,
-0.1445790678,
0.1421144903,
-0.1938313097,
-0.7362756729,
-0.9239515066,
1.089469552,
0.2496638149,
-0.4317763746,
-0.0876763612,
0.1536744982,
0.5327942967,
-0.5063790679,
0.0364055261,
0.6886011362,
0.6444986463,
0.1813849807,
-0.7195637822,
0.1119517237,
0.133858785,
0.0853833109,
0.1246888191,
-0.729346633,
0.8481725454,
-0.3374303579,
-0.2531317472,
0.1008477733,
0.7442650795,
0.7387293577,
0.0556149296,
0.657684803,
0.0384610929,
0.5890387893,
-0.1098975092,
0.9894788861,
-0.1023064032,
0.1987164915,
0.5563615561,
-0.798397243,
0.6260083914,
0.5454009771,
-0.3042799234,
0.1678084135,
0.4740656316,
0.1327352375,
0.1478673965,
0.7287859917,
-0.1718201935,
-0.4977303445,
0.0580791831,
-0.0837231427,
0.2827296257,
0.6650386453,
0.0183095764,
0.0401116461,
-0.4219443798,
0.2482632846,
0.1629169434,
-0.435529083,
0.6376850009,
-0.0063636014,
-0.7603880167,
0.4033857882,
0.0847459063,
0.7395200729,
-0.846383512,
-0.163487047,
-0.1634752899,
0.1468325108,
0.0077733356,
-0.8080495596,
-0.2461310178,
-0.0371316224,
-0.041200269,
0.2562618256,
0.5968173742,
-0.3460965455,
-0.2251272947,
0.1279970706,
0.3837496638,
0.0573151298,
0.1453258991,
-0.6386507154,
0.4360487163,
0.1149838194,
-0.2752472162,
0.5183162093,
0.8658688664,
-0.0484885946,
0.5950657725,
0.7505939007,
0.2921653986,
-0.1664798856,
-0.4163387418,
0.8115076423,
-0.6989678144,
-0.1853575855,
-1.0564777851,
0.1520702988,
-0.359246552,
-0.1738412678,
0.8994386196,
0.4387575984,
0.6847234964,
0.0450580828,
0.9558599591,
-0.0761153996,
0.0193345174,
-0.4542131126,
0.5876457691,
0.0033882044,
0.3524909616,
-0.3704033792,
-0.9445957541,
-0.1738373488,
0.8121781945,
-0.5455579162,
0.056700591,
0.5336213112,
0.6271293163,
0.2194904685,
0.0982313901,
0.590931654,
0.192305997,
0.4423719347,
0.5860694647,
1.0372936726,
-0.0565536842,
0.3701990843,
0.0414038785,
-0.6288526654,
-0.165236339,
-0.6614817977,
-1.3886802197,
-0.2378067821,
0.0784788281,
-0.3785519898,
-0.0493647493,
1.032469511,
0.2942099273,
-0.4166743159,
-0.767411232,
0.0788548291,
0.1488068849,
-0.0558749028,
-0.2318506986,
0.157776013,
-0.254468441,
-0.5977250338,
0.2509470284,
0.1588305086,
0.1679923534,
-0.4553351104,
-0.5225379467,
-0.2675867379,
0.5750052929,
0.846737504,
0.5196787119,
-1.0190085173,
-0.518872261,
0.4017081857,
-0.1334811151,
-0.2267544717,
1.0713683367,
-0.4893731773,
0.1088149995,
0.4241029918,
0.3823672533,
0.0164951589,
-0.2393074483,
0.8042291999,
0.0556029752,
0.0890381411,
0.3614544868,
0.4019768834,
-0.0114565343,
-0.0060699359,
0.466678828,
0.2135844082,
-0.6097422242,
-0.7348777056,
0.3290846944,
-0.725812614,
-0.2006177008,
1.5734043121,
-0.0223506019,
-0.2622002661,
-0.0588645563,
-0.4219508171,
-0.0577136502,
-0.6027569175,
0.8269384503,
1.0845730305,
-0.2219039351,
0.1162462756,
-0.6244058609,
0.8421846628,
0.1561835557,
-0.4336481988,
0.234180212,
0.7151919007,
-0.0178990886,
0.0576298311,
0.7456949353,
-0.0354881808,
0.1545268148,
-0.0733121186,
-0.1102756262,
0.1796507388,
0.1157430932,
-0.1588860899,
0.0570990779,
0.4062013924,
0.4791681468
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05483v1
|
Teamwork Dimensions Classification Using BERT
| 2023-12-09T07:18:41 | 2023-12-09T07:18:41 |
Junyoung Lee, Elizabeth Koh
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Teamwork is a necessary competency for students that is often inadequately
assessed. Towards providing a formative assessment of student teamwork, an
automated natural language processing approach was developed to identify
teamwork dimensions of students' online team chat. Developments in the field of
natural language processing and artificial intelligence have resulted in
advanced deep transfer learning approaches namely the Bidirectional Encoder
Representations from Transformers (BERT) model that allow for more in-depth
understanding of the context of the text. While traditional machine learning
algorithms were used in the previous work for the automatic classification of
chat messages into the different teamwork dimensions, our findings have shown
that classifiers based on the pre-trained language model BERT provides improved
classification performance, as well as much potential for generalizability in
the language use of varying team chat contexts and team member demographics.
This model will contribute towards an enhanced learning analytics tool for
teamwork assessment and feedback.
|
[
-0.4072272778,
-0.5120513439,
0.0120366933,
0.3743662536,
0.0244208369,
0.7295352817,
-0.0339697637,
-0.6865112185,
0.1668985337,
0.3164436817,
-0.609872818,
-0.1422771811,
-0.5400643945,
0.318392992,
-0.3156164289,
1.0169272423,
-0.0462546647,
0.1117400154,
-0.4835437834,
-0.2870389819,
-0.6092718244,
-0.6817669868,
-0.7451300621,
-0.5167366862,
0.2135745734,
0.713817656,
0.2519614995,
0.0129747121,
0.8253273964,
0.4520874023,
0.1343972534,
0.0133776553,
-0.3528627455,
0.3244861066,
0.0233386159,
-0.524576664,
-0.5188973546,
0.3770999908,
0.5737985969,
0.8694469333,
-0.1584743559,
0.4211952686,
0.1738304347,
0.3726047575,
0.0499479361,
0.5570043921,
-0.3788963556,
0.1777787358,
0.1968646497,
0.0573576838,
-0.364564985,
-0.6046629548,
0.531914413,
-0.321795851,
0.4975970984,
-0.2638783753,
0.7800388336,
0.117100738,
-0.3317700624,
-0.3252580762,
-0.6600282192,
0.9123443961,
-0.6335749626,
0.1852386147,
0.4116555452,
0.6364483237,
0.2018231899,
-0.5624022484,
-0.5384345651,
0.0558157153,
0.0142484084,
0.3295755684,
0.2323644757,
0.2966062725,
-0.0428847559,
0.1907186359,
-0.5755848885,
0.4444620609,
-0.6481389403,
-0.1538409889,
0.9622783661,
0.2751152515,
0.3778979778,
-0.1585609317,
-0.3264198303,
-0.3139093816,
0.2463624924,
0.1930107623,
0.2253925055,
0.3414495885,
-0.1310898513,
-0.0499978475,
-0.133624956,
0.3746468723,
0.1109879389,
-0.0773026347,
0.359244585,
-0.2207935452,
-0.3608692586,
0.0265132338,
0.6789686084,
0.2548797429,
0.0489808917,
-0.1670511514,
-0.0691798851,
0.0183924232,
0.3812018335,
-0.7718650699,
-0.4112751782,
-0.0936051831,
-0.6293693185,
-0.5022037625,
0.2049506903,
-0.4855047166,
-0.1418245584,
-0.341711998,
0.3686241806,
-0.4059909582,
-0.1751186103,
-0.4201788902,
-0.1718714386,
0.3595865667,
0.6578425765,
-0.6807303429,
0.4447939396,
0.3893264532,
0.5908984542,
-0.1243529841,
-0.2345542908,
-0.2627240419,
-0.1211920977,
-0.3074273169,
0.6227968335,
-0.4906190932,
-0.2665774822,
0.035457816,
-0.1389224976,
-0.1523162425,
-0.3439910412,
0.3193489015,
-0.4743898809,
0.7638847232,
-0.2663886547,
-0.7314026952,
-0.5890983939,
0.1707167178,
-0.540585041,
1.1774206161,
0.3197537661,
-0.3790956438,
0.8515462875,
-1.1604851484,
-0.5979114175,
0.6994590759,
0.1903068572,
-0.4116103649,
0.1013099924,
0.0854879394,
0.860023737,
0.1570171863,
0.2153285295,
-0.0243955199,
-0.2742788792,
0.2927730381,
-0.1000401154,
0.8942430019,
0.0394162312,
-0.0155340806,
0.3751108646,
-0.5714375973,
0.3099865913,
-0.0624238253,
-0.4846258163,
-0.2546934485,
0.0025275031,
0.23160173,
0.3640781939,
0.3255794346,
-0.492760092,
0.1342867762,
-0.2773866653,
0.3240092099,
0.6536731124,
-0.1748387963,
0.5797767639,
-0.1345168948,
0.3385642767,
-0.4615291059,
0.1394922137,
0.2833827436,
-0.618070364,
-0.5342673063,
-0.3447760046,
0.2550632954,
0.7583255768,
-0.7831112742,
0.9297016263,
-0.2087669373,
-0.6408235431,
-0.5826240182,
0.2375817895,
0.2359837145,
0.4217902124,
0.4341342151,
-0.6073458195,
-0.6980779171,
-0.8145595193,
0.3184739947,
-0.7017025352,
-0.3127990961,
0.2125489265,
0.420566082,
-0.2772168815,
0.8341245651,
-0.2184650749,
-0.6040675044,
-0.8307189941,
0.711081028,
0.0185583029,
0.4698712826,
0.5294699073,
-0.6521858573,
-0.9588942528,
-0.1233301535,
-0.8550121188,
-0.4115737975,
-0.1619579792,
0.1501490325,
0.4023039341,
0.347897917,
-0.0444330461,
0.3864094913,
0.5127620697,
-0.4057988226,
0.3025355041,
-0.2853443921,
0.1409989148,
-0.9688767791,
-0.0436452515,
-0.1292161793,
-0.3383705616,
-0.8843989372,
0.0136702219,
0.1077857986,
-0.0322931297,
-0.1129026785,
0.0466437638,
-0.2317895889,
-0.0033124674,
-0.2424986511,
-0.0749402717,
0.0057211481,
0.5212704539,
0.0383145139,
0.5248498321,
0.1691872627,
-0.3789668083,
0.731148541,
0.3500851691,
-0.0519737154,
0.8801991343,
-0.6254656911,
0.4198442996,
0.1154253259,
0.4222097695,
-1.2196244001,
-0.1541395038,
-0.2665967047,
-0.834148407,
0.5846699476,
0.0783999041,
-0.6506140828,
-0.6092213988,
-0.2482982725,
0.1141330972,
0.5606244802,
-0.2795263827,
0.5594158769,
0.3795599937,
0.0407944471,
-0.0320287831,
-0.6488215923,
0.0649015903,
-0.2203308791,
-0.7898845077,
0.3975784779,
-0.0865004584,
-0.1221469119,
-0.111592643,
0.0625816584,
-0.9238152504,
0.4033829272,
0.3551654518,
0.5561582446,
-0.0163274091,
0.2328689098,
-0.2145859748,
0.1692648679,
0.167953968,
0.287009716,
0.5106053948,
-0.4371302128,
0.0813095048,
-0.6930704117,
0.4430183172,
0.4732166827,
0.0868588686,
1.221109271,
1.0039099455,
-0.3809604645,
-0.1829535961,
-0.6763978601,
-0.4061867297,
-0.4455608428,
0.7220829129,
0.0462611914,
-0.9117628932,
0.7339834571,
0.2783064842,
0.2615573406,
0.5670848489,
0.3491055667,
-0.716076076,
0.8524745107,
0.9794898033,
-0.4065331221,
0.4331782162,
-0.2996838987,
0.0598866157,
-0.4478027821,
-0.3815926015,
-0.5431948304,
-0.5141952634,
-0.2966071367,
-0.269315511,
0.0007894796,
-0.1474135965,
-0.2873753309,
0.634575367,
-0.5203213096,
0.2933185101,
0.3960221708,
0.0177889355,
-0.2189841121,
-0.3240686953,
0.1104806885,
-0.2808158994,
-0.4573789835,
-0.4393023252,
0.8019773364,
0.7357172966,
0.3265613616,
0.2028781921,
0.8899884224,
0.5123512149,
0.6046087146,
-0.8984192014,
0.5890145898,
-0.0275416076,
-0.7332442403,
-0.7129676938,
-0.474509716,
-0.7467996478,
-0.0985611752,
-0.3782045841,
-0.5649875998,
-0.3929331303,
-0.5373287201,
-0.3108022213,
0.2617371976,
-0.9822484851,
0.6459777355,
-0.1663926691,
0.0009624101,
-0.4468684196,
-0.6176928878,
-0.111231409,
-0.3200235069,
0.1494877338,
-0.1362483948,
0.1367892474,
1.1750870943,
-0.3907573223,
1.1127716303,
-0.3207370043,
0.0913146809,
0.1883371621,
0.2039874196,
-0.0248042028,
-0.1157605723,
-0.0830956325,
0.2178683281,
-0.0069251177,
-0.4518292844,
-0.4440824986,
0.3175542057,
-1.0212465525,
-0.372168988,
-0.3130351007,
-0.8209986091,
-0.243175745,
-0.0128784543,
-0.0693610981,
0.0089467168,
-0.1946199685,
0.4169993103,
0.3792451918,
-0.261744678,
0.7764310837,
0.4142931998,
-0.0050775982,
0.0292242561,
0.9415035248,
0.2884512246,
0.2503596246,
0.4096734226,
-0.0519445054,
-0.1716735363,
-0.3986727297,
0.0932594612,
0.0031948958,
-0.5445244908,
-0.2789618671,
-0.0784259066,
-0.4981927872,
-0.4500153363,
-0.4556621611,
-0.2423680276,
-0.2762562633,
-0.3975447118,
-0.1453847736,
-0.0428482182,
0.9829470515,
-0.0919636562,
0.1870940477,
-1.1370544434,
-0.1357970089,
0.8037527204,
0.5431411862,
-0.1687306613,
-0.5051150918,
-0.2880934179,
-0.3243531883,
-0.4834589064,
-0.8721334338,
0.6611508727,
0.3191034496,
0.9914455414,
0.3518424034,
0.1007913053,
0.3731018603,
-0.108862035,
0.9655952454,
0.408349961,
-1.0687361956,
0.5589841008,
-0.0291255768,
0.0408877805,
0.6083817482,
0.4122524261,
-0.4958693981,
-0.1545490474,
-0.7134461403,
-0.5841163397,
0.7386374474,
0.356099993,
0.0555267185,
0.1487775594,
0.050309062,
0.1911298037,
0.0272682514,
-0.4761959612,
-0.0566067584,
-0.1563529968,
-0.3398588002,
0.0686163083,
-0.2076907307,
0.1473593712,
-0.5900090337,
0.2240244299,
-0.2375727147,
0.5888857245,
0.0659506917,
-0.1365209669,
-0.232680738,
0.069604218,
0.2639937699,
0.7830450535,
-0.4265004694,
-0.2305778712,
0.9001944661,
-0.480253607,
-0.1988449842,
0.0446635,
0.7078720927,
-0.0495006032,
0.6945033073,
0.3530278504,
0.0200064834,
-0.3972382545,
0.6078057885,
-0.2637439966,
-0.6429412365,
-0.3497933149,
0.027918594,
-0.2492312342,
0.2979191244,
0.6998422146,
0.0708474293,
0.1502250582,
-0.7303586006,
0.1874607652,
0.3086462319,
-0.7434371114,
-0.4040915072,
0.2419972569,
0.6119987965,
-0.532453239,
0.780002296,
-0.0472554415,
-1.1520444155,
0.7412937284,
0.1272694618,
0.9813160896,
-0.6462295651,
0.4938907623,
0.2226225883,
0.2744571865,
0.4089684188,
0.2004971504,
-0.1775785685,
-0.7330446243,
-0.4765785038,
-0.4206338227,
-0.6187472939,
-0.0859189332,
-0.8073843122,
-0.0411543772,
-0.5685222149,
-0.0223157052,
-0.0546911061,
0.4822093248,
-0.9679217339,
0.2429201156,
0.6428086758,
0.5994161963,
-1.018102169,
0.9166359901,
0.9393734932,
-0.3392488062,
-0.6743753552,
-0.1758118421,
-0.0807627663,
-0.7679874301,
1.2500716448,
0.3305945098,
0.4688714445,
-0.4244287908,
-0.6165884733,
-0.427931428,
0.8922448754,
-0.189543888,
-0.1004649997,
-0.2060005218,
0.320246011,
0.9519142509,
-0.3237229884,
0.3085856438,
0.150820449,
0.143710956,
0.1478576958,
-1.5866657495,
-0.0393513218,
-0.0953650475,
-0.0433019288,
0.0025157288,
-0.4966517389,
0.714820087,
0.0900177285,
-0.0865527987,
-0.4569177926,
0.8016171455,
-0.2552864254,
0.0988604054,
0.649260819,
0.3548080027,
0.9905580878,
-0.1857687682,
0.5474099517,
0.0792246088,
0.5159224272,
0.7021019459,
-0.1556074023,
0.9526162148,
0.2584533393,
-0.4302960336,
0.8108591437,
0.2814843357,
-0.093326807,
0.2613593042,
0.2694818974,
0.0030651372,
-0.364681989,
0.0992076471,
-0.1109027639,
0.66559273,
0.5464904308,
-0.3433998525,
-0.1087298095,
0.060652595,
-0.3503853381,
0.1101729274,
-0.3356978595,
0.9826574326,
-0.0597309507,
-0.2619812489,
0.2153566629,
-0.1770698577,
0.6928576827,
-0.1662558317,
-0.364944458,
-0.0832863078,
0.2883528173,
-0.3685978651,
-1.2087839842,
0.6238567829,
-0.2341115922,
-0.0102724535,
-0.6425693035,
0.860096395,
-0.1361792833,
-0.3110924065,
0.3188483417,
0.4922274053,
0.0317533128,
0.1115901172,
-0.7015193105,
-0.3943329155,
-0.0027015954,
0.2004570961,
0.3503958285,
0.5155425668,
0.1087988615,
0.6617458463,
0.4773664773,
-0.2980872691,
0.0543157756,
0.1638236642,
0.6833024025,
-0.6278037429,
-0.5493332744,
-0.5536779761,
0.3989510834,
-0.4800659716,
-0.1778225452,
0.7592994571,
0.4602604806,
0.5849527121,
0.0589896329,
0.7167221904,
-0.1286597103,
0.7080748677,
0.1516575813,
0.8891281486,
-0.238294661,
0.0326036327,
-0.3993547857,
-0.6797987819,
-0.377530545,
0.78158921,
-0.247341156,
-0.1778642386,
0.4798365533,
-0.1429175884,
0.358294636,
0.3732067645,
0.3876337707,
-0.0520653464,
0.595508039,
0.7166935802,
0.7515823841,
-0.3258154094,
0.6252673268,
-0.4186006784,
-0.5266466141,
-0.502826035,
-0.6112682223,
-1.6133723259,
-0.8777341247,
-0.4593218863,
-0.2078291923,
-0.2767040431,
1.0023239851,
0.7256686091,
-0.8953352571,
-0.4331480563,
0.1621628106,
-0.1109065115,
-0.2377774566,
-0.369589895,
0.1359533221,
-0.6887437701,
-0.4469879866,
0.1737454534,
-0.1337279528,
0.0463890918,
-0.3616844714,
-0.0645637885,
-0.4070826471,
-0.11123503,
0.7654278278,
0.0716381595,
-0.3377390802,
-0.5404289961,
0.1051622257,
-0.2939499319,
0.0334434025,
0.2022044212,
-0.7777020335,
0.3104613125,
0.7435951829,
0.5617237091,
0.3238921165,
-0.2172874212,
0.6683518291,
-0.9374554157,
-0.194448635,
0.5204229355,
0.2384872884,
0.2591707408,
-0.2363918871,
0.5030887127,
0.3702504933,
-0.6729475856,
-0.6908454895,
-0.4563356638,
-0.930529058,
-0.2397693545,
0.669113636,
-0.3040385544,
0.0317601226,
-0.4372870028,
-0.2858574092,
0.6142570376,
-0.3987418115,
1.1681429148,
0.7868096232,
-0.3032258451,
-0.1069939956,
-0.4858699739,
0.3811627328,
0.2632528841,
-0.9411829114,
-0.404381007,
0.1357634962,
0.0907297134,
0.4900538027,
0.1917136312,
0.3277414143,
0.081245631,
-0.0963557586,
0.1618865132,
0.1693412513,
-0.325987339,
0.1190154552,
0.4738374949,
-0.3797407448,
-0.4248772562
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05471v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05471v1
|
Fine-Grained Analysis of Team Collaborative Dialogue
| 2023-12-09T05:38:32 | 2023-12-09T05:38:32 |
Ian Perera, Matthew Johnson, Carson Wilber
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Natural language analysis of human collaborative chat dialogues is an
understudied domain with many unique challenges: a large number of dialogue act
labels, underspecified and dynamic tasks, interleaved topics, and long-range
contextual dependence. While prior work has studied broad metrics of team
dialogue and associated performance using methods such as LSA, there has been
little effort in generating fine-grained descriptions of team dynamics and
individual performance from dialogue. We describe initial work towards
developing an explainable analytics tool in the software development domain
using Slack chats mined from our organization, including generation of a novel,
hierarchical labeling scheme; design of descriptive metrics based on the
frequency of occurrence of dialogue acts; and initial results using a
transformer + CRF architecture to incorporate long-range context.
|
[
-0.5887887478,
-0.9842672348,
0.1895962358,
0.1726125628,
-0.0314554311,
0.6302379966,
-0.2074752748,
-0.5374416113,
0.4512740374,
0.4084281325,
-0.9432858229,
-0.3994389474,
-0.3203151226,
0.0157099441,
-0.3693870604,
1.2261879444,
0.0634329468,
-0.1804031879,
-0.0611571707,
-0.3764247,
-0.6370738745,
-0.5415460467,
-0.6968476176,
-0.2589133084,
0.2061452121,
0.5761829019,
0.6232331991,
-0.0630369782,
0.855363071,
0.3823393583,
-0.0600078553,
-0.0189567246,
-0.7903764248,
0.2237069905,
-0.0798790529,
-0.2448126376,
-0.7961671948,
-0.1145754904,
0.4898776114,
1.0939567089,
-0.2634983361,
0.2718548179,
0.4090847373,
0.5354927182,
-0.1644504666,
0.6397734284,
-0.4076156318,
0.1651316583,
-0.380545646,
-0.2624492049,
-0.0470130891,
-0.1157905534,
0.5311328173,
-0.5896769762,
0.3230344057,
-0.0062992866,
0.5313683152,
0.1725212038,
-0.0341461189,
-0.5003841519,
-0.9092136025,
0.9355104566,
-0.5903232098,
-0.0566774569,
0.2692764103,
0.4427467585,
-0.3815641701,
-0.6631822586,
-0.2251159996,
0.0485856123,
-0.128889218,
0.0460734032,
-0.2505688071,
0.3024745286,
-0.1023601964,
0.6387241483,
-0.3442545533,
0.2422070354,
-0.3624838591,
-0.2242652923,
0.7622604966,
0.8024213314,
0.2798661292,
0.0958693326,
-0.1113719046,
0.3520709574,
0.0251761321,
0.210768342,
-0.1989898235,
0.4104550779,
-0.3302471638,
0.2666168809,
-0.321657002,
0.3335340619,
0.0338991694,
0.0250235833,
0.149621591,
-0.6197757125,
-0.3504442275,
-0.0374757797,
0.8599386811,
0.5789386034,
0.110138543,
-0.4609312415,
-0.0841076523,
0.2120102942,
0.1723705977,
-0.7544304729,
-0.511764586,
0.2486220002,
-0.3823754489,
-0.4006738365,
-0.2681443691,
-0.8184089661,
-0.5948314667,
-0.2789837122,
0.1373948008,
-0.0808770582,
-0.2744701803,
-0.2567797303,
-0.1289861202,
0.0734972656,
0.3376252949,
-0.7686823606,
0.9129704833,
0.8699092865,
0.6587578058,
-0.3587684333,
-0.2056303471,
-0.6845354438,
-0.0910102576,
-0.1697572917,
0.7665382028,
-0.3936508298,
-0.4477489889,
-0.0453879423,
-0.1407222599,
0.0956258923,
-0.500436306,
0.0087973485,
-0.1815980673,
0.326025635,
0.0960730091,
-0.6840602756,
0.1534916461,
0.2719859481,
-0.4499303699,
0.9577297568,
0.3885430992,
-0.5757355094,
0.5028604865,
-1.133703351,
-0.1270239502,
0.3984324634,
-0.3816407919,
-0.0877258927,
-0.0107662221,
-0.1148061156,
0.4503536224,
-0.4333853126,
0.6262428164,
-0.1344429404,
-0.369576782,
0.3653749526,
-0.2929004729,
0.4235033095,
0.1867439449,
-0.2776114345,
0.3609166443,
-0.7322204709,
0.1180414557,
-0.2027680427,
0.0242449325,
-0.1975123137,
0.1903678924,
-0.2604783773,
-0.1994531453,
0.1506161541,
-0.2593829632,
0.1136212796,
-0.2840144336,
0.3588166833,
0.2989720404,
0.1592612863,
0.6628178954,
0.1059380472,
0.6137113571,
-0.2415422648,
0.3544590771,
-0.1203985363,
-0.632674396,
-0.4446693063,
-0.3166132271,
-0.0478979312,
0.4936014712,
-0.4697009921,
0.2882683873,
-0.2723818421,
-0.3638370931,
-0.4112462699,
0.3254978955,
0.3707942367,
0.4700821638,
0.2289453745,
-0.9331737161,
-0.4339444339,
-1.0486799479,
-0.1557683498,
-0.2641061544,
-0.137427792,
0.215008691,
0.2586345077,
-0.3078341782,
1.4186922312,
-0.7090233564,
-0.485142082,
-0.5421998501,
0.6962274909,
0.1422200352,
0.3055312932,
0.3799584806,
-0.5699855685,
-0.4770596921,
0.0254261978,
-0.5054708719,
-0.4607492685,
-0.0159371588,
-0.0837623328,
0.0514905378,
0.688116312,
-0.3423998952,
0.5650371313,
0.5326791406,
-0.3053736985,
0.4894360602,
0.1377033889,
0.0589994751,
-0.8279738426,
0.0809577107,
0.0747614726,
-0.0529068746,
-0.8986222148,
-0.1438562721,
-0.6190142632,
-0.0978329554,
-0.2884185612,
0.3164308667,
-0.196541205,
-0.1337672621,
-0.1919191629,
0.5855063796,
-0.0579443239,
0.708768189,
-0.1687882692,
0.7231587768,
0.2090175748,
-0.4785011709,
0.4649658203,
0.3189082146,
-0.2869775891,
0.5064982772,
-0.5904747844,
0.1514001638,
0.219004333,
0.3364322782,
-0.9561553597,
-0.3829261363,
0.3008170724,
-0.4772950411,
0.0487378947,
-0.2888113856,
-0.3139799833,
-0.2969602942,
-0.2402283698,
0.4583663642,
0.278927654,
0.1070231944,
0.5516656041,
0.8264710903,
-0.215164274,
-0.043129012,
-0.4283048511,
0.2327810377,
-0.4320861995,
-0.899235487,
0.3242429197,
-0.0280780271,
-0.8246350288,
-0.1450868994,
-0.1378373057,
-0.8691725731,
0.3543582857,
0.3555088639,
0.158138752,
-0.3727242649,
-0.0062445854,
-0.4167360961,
-0.1336125135,
0.1586488485,
0.2906872928,
0.460896939,
-0.5649195313,
0.0528133363,
-0.7253106236,
0.5085736513,
0.3488632143,
0.0835960582,
0.7679217458,
0.7292755246,
-0.1716012359,
-0.1345124841,
-0.2845712006,
-0.0199807994,
-0.4699809551,
0.3654184043,
0.0124470731,
-0.9539934397,
0.9459477663,
-0.1503419727,
0.2415563315,
0.5032608509,
0.4695980251,
-0.2190483958,
0.9575588703,
0.8151578903,
-0.2989983857,
0.482742399,
-0.2872590125,
0.1360546649,
-0.5341692567,
-0.1818407476,
-0.5099418759,
-0.3533820212,
-0.4030792117,
-0.3623927534,
0.2330058962,
0.217356503,
-0.0678008869,
0.2932140529,
-0.4493237734,
0.5311825871,
0.1830243617,
-0.5492462516,
0.1633644104,
-0.5229455829,
0.3192365766,
-0.1889909655,
-0.5368099213,
-0.5096523166,
0.4152044952,
0.5713009238,
0.6812660694,
0.1567009985,
0.7044776082,
0.4586816132,
0.2845021784,
-0.9860618711,
0.6224606037,
-0.0787742585,
-0.4438245893,
-0.4923040271,
-0.4337954521,
-1.0454511642,
0.0570185073,
-0.0891926438,
-1.2706695795,
-0.4953936338,
0.1160019189,
-0.5701757669,
-0.1455343813,
-1.1156775951,
0.9575479031,
0.0103302095,
-0.0296222866,
-0.288330704,
-0.6690315604,
0.3481111228,
-0.1068422869,
0.4155567586,
-0.1217451245,
0.3326376081,
0.880440414,
-0.5247907043,
1.2863966227,
-0.1870296597,
-0.2083384693,
0.6033212543,
0.2877623439,
0.2110898495,
0.0881474242,
0.1248968169,
0.0163844284,
0.061010398,
-0.2046522647,
-0.701731205,
0.5170186162,
-0.375457406,
-0.5697077513,
-0.1273060441,
-0.6360940933,
-0.4430475533,
-0.0183120519,
-0.2066106945,
0.7928052545,
-0.6230892539,
0.1154360548,
0.2543468475,
-0.1688742638,
0.5381785035,
0.3588246107,
-0.2025282532,
-0.1709027439,
0.8420442343,
-0.1106124595,
0.3427781761,
0.0730276629,
0.2028689086,
0.1746534109,
-0.6003534794,
-0.0579742864,
-0.1409733295,
-0.3707145452,
-0.0221604798,
-0.1857605577,
-0.1002973914,
-0.2299639136,
-0.2128295898,
-0.4894666672,
-0.4894128144,
-0.343978256,
0.3450694382,
0.0911652297,
1.0395761728,
0.4163778722,
0.4990308583,
-1.1916646957,
0.2759532928,
0.0141822388,
0.6415328383,
0.0487534665,
-0.1602974534,
-0.5560446382,
0.1566381902,
-0.5680086017,
-0.5264127851,
0.3420471847,
0.1836375296,
0.6236576438,
0.2100163996,
0.1599756032,
0.914871037,
-0.2880827188,
1.3255250454,
0.3012373149,
-0.9897435308,
0.4722178578,
-0.4014546871,
0.3199656904,
0.6384241581,
-0.1142600998,
-0.530862093,
-0.6680552959,
-0.6605530381,
-0.8720476627,
0.9225599766,
0.5826084614,
0.0140069742,
0.0689861774,
0.0594401546,
0.0939951912,
0.0375649929,
-0.1901422888,
-0.0931727216,
0.2910957038,
-0.1747744828,
-0.0897720307,
0.087092407,
-0.4040820003,
-0.2251523137,
0.2125140429,
-0.3771690726,
0.2699481547,
0.1108508855,
-0.1107615456,
-0.0936265215,
0.2113646567,
0.6229895949,
0.7504602671,
-0.2478708625,
-0.1673713177,
0.4242293239,
-0.333694309,
-0.6475337744,
-0.095280394,
0.8160729408,
-0.1606509835,
0.5850017071,
0.6625881791,
0.3415416181,
-0.5827687383,
0.4386689365,
-0.2377213389,
-0.1938789338,
-0.2846577168,
0.2049798965,
0.1218316853,
0.4761427641,
0.497184962,
-0.1476351172,
0.2922637165,
-0.8603237271,
0.2585775256,
0.3844691813,
-0.7657194138,
-0.4487680793,
0.2383916378,
0.7594968677,
-0.6755880117,
0.4154320359,
-0.2343112379,
-0.6231420636,
0.6896603107,
0.098106049,
1.0670791864,
0.2452173531,
0.2618137598,
-0.2061012685,
-0.1249916106,
0.2836861908,
-0.1251318157,
-0.3155243397,
-0.4141291082,
-0.5709103346,
-0.2721505761,
-0.6846193671,
0.0158803985,
-0.6715546846,
0.0576554239,
-0.2305051088,
-0.380212307,
0.4811699986,
0.2849452794,
-0.5644069314,
0.0218498688,
0.0834161863,
0.6859906912,
-0.5320323706,
0.5121774077,
0.3017939925,
-0.237549901,
-0.4678089619,
-0.1130024195,
0.2933301926,
-0.5937451124,
0.7753674388,
-0.0234294329,
-0.3773157597,
-0.4458776414,
-0.6874619126,
-0.4390534461,
1.0002791882,
-0.158799842,
-0.2560895979,
-0.2001981735,
0.3052103519,
1.087361455,
-0.5604694486,
0.2360929549,
0.8564448953,
0.0652657002,
-0.0802056044,
-1.4374363422,
-0.3178751171,
-0.2447613776,
-0.2920940816,
0.674880445,
-0.6192768812,
0.2549443841,
0.1705467105,
-0.2010598183,
0.1430986226,
0.560991466,
-0.3591669202,
0.858862102,
0.4149303734,
-0.0109521672,
0.6879540086,
-0.0450997837,
0.7988157868,
-0.140191555,
0.5412955284,
1.3659753799,
-0.2888990045,
0.5362105966,
0.5139488578,
-0.2087192833,
0.4593345225,
0.128380239,
0.020664379,
0.1397286505,
0.4142374098,
-0.2537344396,
-0.0448399819,
-0.26763466,
-0.0076416833,
0.5225149393,
0.793853581,
-0.2510279119,
-0.2758705914,
-0.2866897881,
-0.1644051522,
-0.0864170492,
-0.2719170153,
1.1264364719,
0.2044124454,
-0.6369305253,
0.379122287,
-0.3931035399,
0.5484263897,
-0.3966649771,
-0.0511868894,
-0.1319747567,
0.2591922283,
-0.3315487206,
-1.1973180771,
0.6590176225,
0.1313625127,
0.0696331412,
-0.174980104,
0.4717963934,
-0.2700251639,
0.1632945836,
0.3083032668,
0.4256090224,
0.3202653527,
0.1564431787,
-0.6497904658,
0.1370651275,
-0.0249428879,
-0.0680308416,
0.2818466425,
0.6389467716,
-0.2816369534,
0.8379827142,
0.2052318752,
-0.3522040248,
-0.0418028682,
0.4115563929,
0.862118721,
-0.7229517698,
-0.2681634128,
-0.6614095569,
0.6321522593,
-0.3231878579,
-0.5122566819,
0.6207317114,
0.4506300092,
0.2733528018,
0.3092252016,
0.4612926841,
-0.116346404,
0.3627043068,
-0.1509165168,
0.5357640386,
-0.2408840358,
0.3493410349,
-0.7331243753,
-0.8013882041,
-0.3744341731,
0.1735827178,
-0.0471727066,
-0.3909231126,
0.6125851274,
0.5237250328,
-0.0177727826,
0.4619413316,
0.1299886256,
0.2218981236,
0.6418018937,
0.4191361666,
0.9770129323,
-0.12819767,
0.7703446746,
-0.2319700867,
-0.3461069465,
-0.2101482749,
-0.7182635665,
-0.9535142183,
-0.6039658189,
-0.6885900497,
-0.2653661072,
-0.1981039494,
0.9022473097,
0.5237093568,
-0.8656630516,
-0.4779398441,
-0.1632391959,
-0.178180024,
0.0557524487,
-0.3827627897,
-0.0094900522,
-0.6359785795,
-0.6169715524,
0.4241222441,
0.1645674407,
-0.1756636202,
-0.3344721794,
-0.149276495,
0.1529172212,
-0.0141311865,
0.6369888783,
0.4245935678,
-0.55401963,
-0.3574624658,
-0.0430678539,
-0.1234604344,
0.0717780665,
1.0470490456,
-0.5993226171,
0.4105093479,
0.4336999357,
0.492460072,
0.1699251086,
0.0438177548,
0.9141029119,
-0.8631782532,
-0.1481266618,
0.3388060331,
-0.017401129,
0.1115995571,
-0.1419893205,
0.6551842093,
0.1227268428,
-0.8157830238,
-0.903801024,
0.047290463,
-1.2279607058,
-0.0984654427,
0.9226386547,
-0.0525207967,
0.0292783417,
-0.5857673287,
-0.5963602066,
0.34713009,
-0.6269561648,
0.8077830076,
0.8535088301,
-0.6401286125,
0.2666925788,
-0.4603142142,
0.7556682229,
0.2266556621,
-0.7820330262,
0.3699485064,
0.6653161645,
0.1136968285,
0.5073340535,
0.8410524726,
0.1198378578,
0.0221218951,
-0.0086133927,
-0.3303106129,
0.4401361942,
-0.1844183058,
-0.1247261465,
0.1745807976,
0.0225504152,
-0.1780826002
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05467v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05467v1
|
Textual Toxicity in Social Media: Understanding the Bangla Toxic Language Expressed in Facebook Comment
| 2023-12-09T05:04:34 | 2023-12-09T05:04:34 |
Mohammad Mamun Or Rashid
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social Media is a repository of digital literature including user-generated
content. The users of social media are expressing their opinion with diverse
mediums such as text, emojis, memes, and also through other visual and textual
mediums. A major portion of these media elements could be treated as harmful to
others and they are known by many words including Cyberbullying and Toxic
Language . The goal of this research paper is to analyze a curated and
value-added dataset of toxic language titled ToxLex_bn . It is an exhaustive
wordlist that can be used as classifier material to detect toxicity in social
media. The toxic language/script used by the Bengali community as
cyberbullying, hate speech and moral policing became major trends in social
media culture in Bangladesh and West Bengal. The toxicity became so high that
the victims has to post as a counter or release explanation video for the
haters. Most cases are pointed to women celebrity and their relation, dress,
lifestyle are became trolled and toxicity flooded in comments boxes. Not only
celebrity bashing but also hates occurred between Hindu Muslims,
India-Bangladesh, Two opponents of 1971 and these are very common for virtual
conflict in the comment thread. Even many times facebook comment causes sue and
legal matters in Bangladesh and thus it requires more study. In this study, a
Bangla toxic language dataset has been analyzed which was inputted by the user
in Bengali script & language. For this, about 1968 unique bigrams or phrases as
wordlists have been analyzed which are derived from 2207590 comments. It is
assumed that this analysis will reinforce the detection of Bangla's toxic
language used in social media and thus cure this virtual disease.
|
[
0.1384441555,
-1.1004072428,
0.1068892479,
0.6544410586,
-0.3524934053,
0.1451195925,
0.0317859761,
-0.567784071,
-0.0427496396,
0.6064376235,
-0.3107208312,
-0.3375310004,
-0.685192287,
0.1034695357,
-0.54391855,
1.2474811077,
0.2103921622,
-0.1684060395,
0.0143532054,
-0.1748469472,
-0.5488092303,
-0.4286439717,
-0.5752727985,
0.0482713357,
0.7261383533,
0.0710179657,
0.4194177985,
0.2272161543,
0.2737668455,
0.4942156971,
-0.4151562452,
-0.0541893393,
-1.1144903898,
0.0794838667,
-0.8962829709,
-0.4120272696,
-0.1696124375,
-0.4028488398,
0.414738059,
0.3416114151,
0.1837552488,
0.5026996732,
0.0943604112,
0.6666107774,
-0.6931450367,
0.1061058491,
-0.4915546179,
-0.1714041233,
-0.4556970596,
-0.5252810121,
-0.5121790171,
-0.7115971446,
-0.2854557633,
-0.1240334436,
-0.4417754412,
-0.1116604879,
0.7717989087,
0.2392214537,
-0.7423709631,
-0.674048245,
-0.6764062643,
0.7637830377,
-0.5183009505,
0.1176039726,
0.4601808786,
0.4428474605,
0.0227412395,
-0.2094908208,
-0.5539258122,
-0.0168370679,
-0.060621392,
0.2408021092,
-0.0196528975,
-0.2487587482,
0.0481227376,
0.1419455409,
-0.6513618231,
-0.1501872838,
-0.6438931823,
-0.1925842911,
0.9955573678,
0.2332597822,
0.5311787128,
-0.6485212445,
-0.171345681,
0.2494857013,
-0.4654525816,
-0.0119841248,
0.5702266097,
0.3796859086,
-0.2097951472,
0.5400855541,
-0.1256437451,
0.6173535585,
-0.2643475831,
-0.3274815679,
0.2316979915,
-0.5563042164,
0.0066634724,
0.1677033454,
0.7305815816,
0.6345199347,
0.7507902384,
0.1076566428,
0.3065967262,
0.3136397898,
0.4042676985,
-1.001614809,
0.0788998008,
0.2723029554,
-0.7253898978,
-0.5422204137,
-0.250261724,
-1.1346325874,
-0.6718887687,
0.1796823442,
0.31992957,
-0.2067223191,
-0.6972727776,
-0.2347772121,
-0.2449729592,
-0.100471966,
0.1270058304,
-0.500351131,
0.0856712088,
0.2506475151,
0.6541784406,
0.2490904629,
0.1483756304,
-0.1065303683,
0.293882817,
-0.4833151698,
0.9293567538,
-0.6635921001,
-0.5039822459,
0.4970259964,
-0.0765561536,
0.1599264443,
-0.6407626867,
0.5558595061,
-0.4915277958,
-0.0552296117,
-0.3536480069,
-0.2569289207,
-0.5550308228,
0.054069005,
-0.3039402366,
0.6334301233,
0.2407077104,
-0.8813464046,
0.2337096632,
-0.3139737546,
-0.5044107437,
0.328256309,
0.135610193,
-0.2639583051,
-0.0769294202,
-0.5219213367,
0.4967959523,
-0.0996888503,
0.072686322,
-0.5680826306,
-0.5159761906,
0.5298483968,
-0.1267309636,
1.0935516357,
0.473388195,
-0.2227518857,
0.1060318127,
-0.7943153977,
0.0773979276,
0.2314910889,
-0.3992033005,
-0.7009865642,
0.1621235609,
0.6485546231,
0.53749156,
-0.1457204074,
-0.5338602066,
-0.3715803623,
-0.1677792817,
0.365003258,
0.8597739339,
0.2797316611,
-0.304220438,
-0.339915067,
0.3453404903,
0.0764621273,
0.0848660991,
0.0456549972,
-0.3189560175,
-0.1246459782,
0.0003022149,
-0.0168534964,
0.6272860169,
-0.4876447022,
0.1921043247,
-0.2657708228,
-0.5386955142,
-0.5042482615,
0.1797087342,
0.5736095309,
0.1623497009,
0.2400752753,
0.1246253401,
-0.3844069839,
-0.7631440759,
-0.217092067,
-0.4584581852,
0.4091590047,
0.4547623694,
0.264988631,
-0.7220217586,
0.7226051092,
-0.3430755734,
-0.3043025732,
-0.2307037264,
0.1329896003,
-0.2131147385,
-0.0868912488,
0.7052115202,
-0.9399638772,
-0.9438366294,
0.1549950242,
-0.9207380414,
-0.7552158833,
-0.0526841693,
-0.1224288344,
0.4196308255,
0.3976128995,
0.2511368394,
0.5229008794,
0.6166360378,
-0.5057633519,
0.6375099421,
0.3729377389,
0.3060676754,
-1.1884609461,
0.0509139225,
0.2013239861,
-0.2327555865,
-0.4044422805,
0.0498363562,
-0.2410921901,
0.1637910604,
-0.4684800506,
0.6011275053,
-0.0092061041,
0.4293328822,
-0.3602094054,
0.2120934427,
-0.3311884403,
0.1543559283,
-0.0239002872,
0.5220494866,
0.3470632136,
-0.4106699526,
0.4615348279,
0.529491365,
0.0013309298,
0.6540113688,
-0.3928582966,
-0.2911702693,
-0.2216106057,
0.0161278006,
-1.089574337,
-0.1459681988,
0.3039463162,
-0.5471779704,
0.0898721367,
0.0511021055,
-0.5229920745,
-0.3459391296,
-0.4196058512,
0.5087284446,
0.1483874917,
-0.0917318016,
0.0784184262,
0.7768592238,
-0.4168717265,
-0.5799621344,
-0.7711650133,
0.1825791895,
-0.3021204472,
-0.6034088731,
-0.0731369108,
-0.4883943796,
-0.5612801909,
0.1434566677,
0.0727187097,
-0.4241864681,
-0.3758681417,
0.5385132432,
-0.0547975749,
0.1712910682,
0.1618614048,
0.2579963505,
0.0975801647,
0.3354882002,
0.6198006868,
0.5566994548,
-0.111988984,
0.3176845312,
-0.1906140149,
0.5796830654,
0.2434085608,
0.259958744,
0.7421014309,
0.5171236396,
-0.1705340147,
-0.3023746014,
-0.5043975711,
0.1434158087,
-0.5133510232,
0.4848331809,
0.001787097,
-0.6740362048,
0.4535877109,
-0.1726477891,
-0.4376924038,
0.1893811673,
0.9294537902,
0.0432356484,
0.7479582429,
0.6360866427,
-0.1730946153,
0.3456349969,
0.0611086339,
0.3855538666,
-0.1920336038,
-0.2973863482,
-0.3365308344,
0.1268390566,
-1.1368097067,
0.0236684494,
0.1265980005,
-0.4391977191,
-0.2845340371,
0.3501995802,
-0.3033063114,
0.2913611531,
-0.0668700188,
0.356418401,
0.1899546832,
-0.099919416,
0.1131205261,
0.0318850279,
-0.4464152455,
-0.6209129095,
0.7485384941,
0.220727995,
0.6177264452,
0.2291111797,
0.4541380405,
0.7474688292,
0.3764501214,
-0.4965071976,
0.738701582,
-0.2371447384,
-1.1838943958,
-0.0709016025,
-0.4731124938,
-0.7909935713,
-0.1420005858,
-0.1851800084,
-0.9178348184,
0.0470071994,
-0.1011210456,
-0.2834461629,
0.1723325104,
-0.6702957153,
0.7064128518,
-0.0823570937,
-0.9733839631,
-0.5261707902,
-0.8455967903,
0.5901925564,
-0.4174114466,
0.5888741612,
0.1036131456,
0.3296334445,
0.639377892,
-0.2858303785,
0.8640732169,
0.1812247485,
-0.1773617119,
0.4788266718,
0.0559394993,
-0.2423804849,
-0.1581541598,
-0.2304694653,
0.2493906617,
0.2785711288,
-0.5107610226,
0.0731950626,
0.6181938052,
-0.5990740657,
-0.1445351392,
-0.5691857934,
-0.5630795956,
0.009150302,
0.1928694546,
0.1322290897,
0.4827919602,
-0.0217158087,
0.267693907,
0.400798589,
-0.8168863058,
0.3949274719,
0.3349514306,
-0.471103102,
-0.0620081834,
1.3586306572,
0.3468354642,
0.1236654744,
0.3143590987,
0.2871698141,
-0.3100153804,
-0.2948352993,
-0.0096562272,
0.5016704798,
-0.6772310734,
-0.1933070421,
-0.4403581917,
-0.4282613993,
-0.4909113944,
-0.1029838398,
0.0037388841,
0.0443895571,
0.0751420334,
0.0032482429,
0.2570935786,
1.1196275949,
-0.2274080217,
0.4805511832,
-0.9692026973,
0.1960796416,
0.173707813,
0.4874283075,
-0.0720445886,
-0.4515802562,
-0.3037923574,
-0.1154590324,
-0.4551913738,
-1.3658388853,
0.3860157132,
-0.1186423376,
0.1969318688,
0.8822056055,
0.0992193297,
0.6366693377,
-0.1818949729,
0.582596302,
-0.2381414771,
-0.7316548228,
0.5880387425,
-0.7439175248,
-0.247542575,
0.3117075562,
0.7879126668,
-0.8395892978,
-0.4392042458,
-0.4403964877,
-0.7876066566,
0.4399164021,
0.1611248404,
0.3791232705,
-0.2861505747,
0.2189436108,
0.1037377417,
0.3682343364,
-1.0009723902,
-0.4033987522,
-0.1973586679,
0.0315020755,
0.2234381735,
-0.9558464289,
0.0980802253,
-0.227371946,
0.6688727736,
0.3871700466,
0.2050943524,
-0.3723870814,
-0.1959545314,
-0.4658691585,
0.2111153305,
0.4125419557,
0.6886403561,
-0.3646281362,
-0.1456379294,
-0.1169384196,
-0.4352348149,
0.0265616477,
-0.1489257216,
-0.0363625623,
-0.1814411879,
0.3278596699,
0.4000685513,
0.1146357954,
-0.9304899573,
0.4645324349,
0.2840627432,
0.1483797282,
-0.3251094818,
0.0106143486,
0.2141706049,
0.0882049203,
0.0769757852,
-0.1635193825,
0.3513569236,
-1.0101362467,
0.3470927179,
0.2709903717,
-0.3201417625,
-0.2968388796,
0.4954568446,
0.2402783483,
-0.2238277495,
0.2685542703,
-0.3207449019,
-0.5970700383,
0.0404357687,
0.6705548763,
0.4691891074,
-0.6609621644,
0.7009059787,
0.4462247789,
0.2036815882,
0.6172215343,
0.423135221,
0.1716853082,
-0.5696883798,
-0.3837334216,
-0.9493867159,
0.0294375308,
0.3113456666,
-0.3510817885,
0.2732548714,
-0.4687869847,
-0.1450083703,
0.0441990122,
0.166583389,
0.0173212029,
0.3975311816,
0.1168797389,
0.4061022997,
-1.206895113,
0.4123670161,
0.6183366776,
-0.6105226278,
-0.6252498031,
-0.0275946613,
0.319935441,
-0.6241196394,
0.7025379539,
0.2474183589,
0.0017453331,
-0.1540140808,
-0.5357859135,
-0.4423160553,
0.2923251987,
-0.0589463636,
-0.2035374939,
0.3047765791,
0.5293011665,
0.936289072,
0.218703866,
0.4862943292,
0.3790960312,
0.5502737164,
0.1800525934,
-0.6987650394,
0.2378985584,
-0.8050310016,
0.0202321764,
-0.0088978428,
-0.8961830735,
0.494009465,
0.0522199385,
-0.2032127082,
-0.1040879562,
0.204823643,
0.1280595362,
0.4749365449,
0.2520659268,
0.1134824306,
0.208724007,
0.1991562843,
0.8971806169,
0.0303417183,
0.1588831246,
0.6021431684,
-0.3149282038,
0.7730571032,
0.1849633008,
-0.2306956202,
0.735883832,
0.7203229666,
0.0508609228,
0.3567323983,
0.5367910266,
-0.3132438362,
0.0830005109,
-0.6293690801,
-0.3198942542,
0.5362100601,
0.5866940022,
-0.2040476352,
-0.4483647346,
0.1954602152,
0.197106272,
0.5559993982,
-0.3964504004,
0.8842052221,
0.0132146198,
-0.1303424537,
0.4220103621,
-0.188082993,
0.4995972514,
-0.643086493,
-0.0781148076,
0.134257555,
0.3553890884,
-0.5334376693,
-0.8158397675,
0.8865028024,
0.0250162985,
-0.0210518949,
-0.0948067904,
0.7985636592,
-0.4037331939,
-0.5874952674,
0.8376282454,
0.3350732028,
0.4532566667,
-0.2080263495,
-0.6251249909,
0.2758512497,
-0.0728750601,
-0.0811486989,
0.5123534203,
0.4186934829,
-0.2886757255,
0.7266823649,
0.3676054478,
0.3803285956,
0.1800576448,
-0.1295817196,
0.9572151899,
-0.6008508801,
-0.4091160595,
-0.724216938,
0.4706344903,
-0.3201885819,
-0.0626605824,
0.8595187664,
0.4197245538,
0.668646276,
0.1561822146,
0.8833795786,
-0.3420065343,
0.7830968499,
-0.0372306146,
1.1532138586,
-0.5746982694,
-0.2198749632,
-0.8171138763,
-0.9318193793,
-0.0782504305,
0.5553326011,
-0.2254585326,
0.3345097303,
0.8020597696,
0.9369830489,
0.3112936616,
0.0607970022,
0.4257119894,
0.9327789545,
0.0711124763,
0.1922489703,
0.7556905746,
-0.3767482936,
0.8129825592,
-0.1397141963,
-0.6162843108,
-0.4122942388,
-0.8339738846,
-1.1150614023,
-0.7980089188,
-0.3286540508,
-0.6534974575,
0.4379612207,
0.7980398536,
0.2630622089,
-0.7830452323,
-0.48050493,
0.3284301162,
0.2921692729,
-0.0392157026,
-0.3522215486,
0.1707107723,
-0.0507150665,
-0.6562081575,
-0.0580213889,
0.2732934058,
-0.444396466,
0.0368339457,
0.3126500249,
-0.4793955088,
0.3886584938,
1.2477610111,
0.1835081279,
-0.1731951088,
-0.3448124528,
-0.3020931184,
-0.0821712986,
-0.330778569,
0.2885758281,
-0.3428040147,
0.5608607531,
0.680776298,
0.3731924891,
0.2747577131,
0.166729033,
0.0862037987,
-0.4418519139,
-0.0360639393,
0.0039387657,
-0.0286611244,
0.2509864271,
-0.4682973921,
0.395938158,
0.4030056298,
-0.6867695451,
-0.8695590496,
0.1385613233,
-1.2783360481,
-0.631888926,
1.6157501936,
0.1267594546,
-0.3173259497,
-0.4109205902,
-0.6511055827,
0.5236232877,
-0.4319752157,
1.383104682,
0.7318651676,
0.2734953165,
0.1477788687,
-0.6200094223,
0.3373169005,
-0.0134763848,
-0.811502099,
0.1965924352,
0.4462470412,
0.3139244914,
0.4185425639,
0.6181939244,
-0.249969244,
0.0860589892,
-0.1002141163,
-0.2506304383,
0.1736346781,
-0.1757986397,
0.0048283311,
0.3721016645,
-0.5645431876,
0.1733305156
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06681v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06681v3
|
Steering Llama 2 via Contrastive Activation Addition
| 2023-12-09T04:40:46 | 2024-03-07T02:06:00 |
Nina Rimsky, Nick Gabrieli, Julian Schulz, Meg Tong, Evan Hubinger, Alexander Matt Turner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
We introduce Contrastive Activation Addition (CAA), an innovative method for
steering language models by modifying their activations during forward passes.
CAA computes "steering vectors" by averaging the difference in residual stream
activations between pairs of positive and negative examples of a particular
behavior, such as factual versus hallucinatory responses. During inference,
these steering vectors are added at all token positions after the user's prompt
with either a positive or negative coefficient, allowing precise control over
the degree of the targeted behavior. We evaluate CAA's effectiveness on Llama 2
Chat using multiple-choice behavioral question datasets and open-ended
generation tasks. We demonstrate that CAA significantly alters model behavior,
is effective over and on top of traditional methods like finetuning and system
prompt design, and minimally reduces capabilities. Moreover, we gain deeper
insights into CAA's mechanisms by employing various activation space
interpretation methods. CAA accurately steers model outputs and sheds light on
how high-level concepts are represented in Large Language Models (LLMs).
|
[
-0.3433991075,
-0.8542032242,
0.4686696529,
0.6090666056,
-0.4595932961,
0.1089657545,
0.041483961,
-0.6073521376,
0.4212653339,
0.3024978638,
-0.4492289126,
-0.2449450493,
-0.6887680888,
-0.3120211065,
-0.5238057971,
0.8656591773,
0.237759009,
0.1652058214,
0.0354205705,
-0.1760730445,
-0.8288791776,
-0.3956814408,
-0.8928567767,
-0.6464993358,
0.8257930875,
0.4898494184,
0.9243115187,
0.5106188655,
0.190147087,
0.3325334191,
-0.3453504741,
-0.0337342732,
-0.7498100996,
0.1702949703,
-0.2627370656,
-0.7331109643,
-0.476670891,
-0.1369284093,
0.405262053,
0.6557258964,
-0.2342885882,
-0.1739527136,
0.1710276306,
0.4990671575,
-0.7426581383,
0.1725259721,
-0.7282575369,
-0.3707789779,
0.0278666615,
-0.4212510288,
-0.2986415327,
-0.0607646294,
0.1412570477,
-0.7466531992,
-0.1610327512,
-0.2434812635,
0.7609913945,
0.4787515998,
-0.4939526021,
-0.585398376,
-0.6831267476,
0.7552217841,
-0.5878494382,
0.2713742852,
0.3010658324,
0.0180194713,
-0.2807918191,
-0.6003094912,
-0.8865769506,
-0.3354213834,
0.0678777918,
0.1821504831,
-0.3942002654,
0.0500359833,
-0.0175082199,
-0.0609306917,
-0.0927804634,
0.7456973791,
-0.4249684513,
-0.0970964283,
0.4117431045,
0.0947832465,
0.2622247338,
0.2859864533,
-0.4888411164,
-0.310980767,
-0.9905789495,
0.0939404219,
0.3666734695,
0.3296813071,
-0.465960592,
0.7589843869,
-0.2751842141,
0.3592730165,
0.4128688276,
0.1484584063,
0.3504867554,
-0.1554473788,
-0.1425348967,
0.0602895543,
0.4973087609,
0.6077647209,
-0.0600576811,
0.1308779269,
-0.1635739505,
0.481784761,
0.0583199486,
-0.7932747602,
-0.1328797191,
0.436580807,
-0.3033314347,
-0.3922584355,
-0.2673041224,
-0.7812104225,
-0.7467984557,
-0.4660413265,
0.3573540151,
-0.2145539671,
-0.3244598508,
0.0973081514,
-0.1533845812,
0.9027224779,
0.373418808,
-1.0019204617,
0.3637275696,
0.7781820893,
0.6417421699,
-0.4604412615,
-0.2786304057,
-0.8311390877,
0.1199458912,
-0.5369845629,
0.9503211975,
-0.796600759,
-0.4688287675,
0.1157352775,
-0.3403689861,
0.2017934024,
-0.5521228313,
0.191700846,
-0.9088950753,
0.1212410703,
-0.2337013632,
-0.3031274974,
-0.3408991694,
0.0352286585,
-0.6592877507,
1.1119114161,
-0.2624935508,
-0.396466583,
0.1373121291,
-0.6912031174,
-0.5477452874,
-0.244449541,
-0.2002120167,
-0.114450112,
0.1659988016,
0.3563370705,
0.3591932654,
-0.0378602073,
0.276170522,
-0.1827840656,
-0.3557935655,
0.485417366,
-0.2423771918,
0.7362274528,
0.0963183269,
-0.4267992079,
0.4213188291,
-0.7102302909,
-0.5488991141,
0.133486256,
-0.2887930274,
-0.4022424519,
0.1953624338,
-0.1304445863,
0.2654497325,
0.2448292524,
-0.1538584083,
0.0285907686,
-0.462120384,
-0.0381362401,
0.7475576401,
0.0848880485,
0.659873426,
-0.1796623021,
0.5571783185,
0.2492843419,
-0.273786068,
-0.0603475608,
-0.8863829374,
-1.2295207977,
-0.1489048004,
-0.0542348064,
0.7293791175,
-1.0363399982,
0.2917536795,
-0.0854422897,
-0.5191659331,
-0.4805735052,
0.2391765863,
0.4516947269,
0.5426818728,
0.5333619118,
-0.2694905102,
-0.2345924079,
-0.6705616713,
0.1534199417,
-0.3790532649,
0.0629083142,
0.1626570225,
0.2882741392,
-0.1651915759,
0.5336990356,
-0.4563951492,
-0.0633311644,
-0.3940770328,
0.3878938258,
-0.0669791549,
0.5552369952,
0.4985802472,
-0.7280814052,
-0.1682506353,
-0.022932779,
-0.5257751942,
-0.4659733176,
-0.4152351916,
-0.3042736053,
0.0567040667,
0.7098212838,
-0.5886039734,
0.4821696877,
0.8081869483,
-0.5074890852,
0.1807217896,
-0.0172006227,
0.0757606179,
-0.8558549881,
-0.080405049,
-0.0119303968,
0.2536729872,
-0.9580833316,
0.2084688246,
-0.1456092745,
0.0893587247,
-0.6119127274,
0.733264029,
-0.2279698849,
-0.2283955663,
-0.6280841827,
0.4260246754,
-0.1799889952,
0.6980057359,
0.2032180578,
0.8645548224,
0.5292195678,
-0.9791946411,
0.1907782853,
0.2785379887,
-0.0727072805,
0.4614530206,
-0.6943734288,
0.2042613924,
-0.0966000184,
0.2921908796,
-1.5589300394,
0.0671540722,
0.3361307085,
-0.4591847956,
0.2687680423,
0.2729625404,
-0.102260761,
0.2441435605,
-0.4396674633,
0.456304729,
0.5351361632,
-0.7140777707,
0.6860740781,
0.4070084393,
-0.3668319881,
-0.5709809661,
-0.7838589549,
0.2889533937,
-0.2334695905,
-0.366661042,
0.600700736,
0.0091181993,
-0.4037196636,
-0.2579760253,
0.2094432116,
0.0110110799,
0.3615528643,
0.250039041,
0.3609265685,
-0.1526744217,
0.0244816244,
0.4953543842,
-0.347784102,
-0.0702854171,
0.1834701002,
0.8480960131,
0.2656003535,
-0.3429370821,
-0.8642210364,
0.2458944023,
0.3659590185,
-0.2898205221,
0.6287392378,
0.4710418284,
-0.170996666,
0.0687577873,
-0.4870363772,
-0.4301622212,
-0.5191864371,
0.5167844892,
-0.2877159417,
-0.7494180799,
0.6745666265,
0.0376548097,
0.2599997222,
0.3233391941,
0.9311417341,
-0.0200924315,
1.0034306049,
0.6863722205,
0.0534770899,
0.8142054677,
-0.1224312708,
0.0638682768,
-0.7390887141,
-0.3903036714,
-0.7188655138,
-0.533364296,
-0.5386574864,
-0.6490774751,
0.0438220017,
0.2050854862,
-0.1176107898,
0.1470008641,
-0.106092535,
0.2955670357,
0.4733180404,
0.2060741186,
0.3218381703,
0.0099855596,
0.0075167618,
0.1635743827,
-0.6151284575,
-0.3656584918,
0.9863885045,
0.5098084807,
0.7207795382,
0.2277455181,
0.4661865234,
0.1288251281,
0.6838718057,
-0.9780302048,
0.7085132599,
0.1563974172,
-0.3937109411,
-0.218527317,
0.1253439337,
-0.9450637102,
0.3237888515,
-0.3476547599,
-0.5974122286,
0.4498756826,
0.2961228788,
-0.2511674762,
-0.0345223956,
-0.6694739461,
0.3819721341,
-0.1966812313,
-0.5002580285,
-0.7512802482,
-0.5514447093,
0.3719440997,
0.1786434948,
0.0583244227,
0.0423985459,
-0.655071795,
0.688993156,
-0.1576440483,
1.3151031733,
-0.2342995703,
-0.6071845293,
0.3825573921,
0.2582815588,
0.7102287412,
-0.2499602884,
-0.1128907874,
0.1407505572,
-0.5781468749,
-0.3061266541,
-0.7884756923,
0.7961953878,
-0.7110157013,
-0.6016370058,
-0.2125853449,
-0.505551517,
-0.2785173953,
-0.2168819904,
-0.1971212476,
0.2818032205,
-0.09534771,
-0.001930343,
0.4173704088,
-0.3778925538,
0.4110761285,
0.5811920166,
-0.2066607326,
-0.2954909503,
1.0361821651,
-0.3119386137,
0.4816873968,
0.5435337424,
0.1182127371,
-0.5154262185,
-1.0188398361,
-0.3567022681,
0.2839444876,
-0.8931578398,
0.0451048277,
-0.3716934025,
0.1192342713,
-0.0799186081,
-0.2910615504,
-0.1595697403,
-0.596794188,
-0.61742872,
-0.2979447544,
0.1058417037,
0.7055882215,
0.0047815293,
0.7833379507,
-0.3628667295,
0.5149353743,
0.4815045893,
-0.0040901573,
0.1405813545,
-0.6947211027,
0.0571873747,
-0.0742829517,
-0.4178948104,
-0.9963516593,
0.2224022597,
0.056716688,
0.5556765795,
0.5987747312,
-0.3206343353,
0.8173416853,
-0.2964466512,
1.0432809591,
0.3989810944,
-0.8512851596,
0.4083412588,
-0.1107265353,
0.204422757,
0.244753927,
0.2495809048,
-0.1925944239,
-0.5577070117,
-0.3575775623,
-0.6693802476,
0.4656970203,
0.1880556792,
0.4984535277,
-0.1061129197,
0.2123296261,
-0.0749768168,
-0.0821786299,
-0.6607999206,
-0.4362204075,
-0.1813942939,
-0.1383043975,
-0.0429652408,
-0.5110220313,
-0.050086733,
-0.0088999998,
0.8743368983,
-0.2165228575,
0.0734711662,
-0.0659137368,
-0.0862821341,
0.07239113,
0.2587325573,
0.7557035685,
0.6313362122,
0.1747988462,
0.0820829943,
0.4075338542,
-0.3959051669,
0.1043202356,
0.0994771868,
-0.2675919831,
-0.257906884,
0.3132997155,
0.7912124991,
0.4564048648,
-0.5920094848,
0.3306105435,
0.1617769897,
-0.043698702,
0.2362232357,
0.2080169469,
0.236749053,
0.4034952223,
0.3406499922,
-0.1420519948,
0.109167859,
-0.4593627453,
-0.0208823271,
0.4827792346,
-0.6000488997,
-0.4113769829,
0.5945540667,
0.6360260844,
-0.268273741,
0.3901655972,
-0.0583803244,
-0.3568912148,
0.6258230805,
0.7173347473,
0.8650654554,
-0.3923635781,
0.1286393106,
0.24701868,
0.1092345119,
0.2488376796,
0.4316704273,
-0.1101380661,
-1.064340353,
-0.6393461227,
-0.2914457619,
-0.5037113428,
0.1503401846,
-0.5884722471,
0.3276999891,
-0.3534184098,
-0.1022776738,
0.0788526088,
-0.3100530803,
-0.4258623123,
0.0768928751,
0.3675443232,
0.8812386394,
-0.8055027723,
0.8041964173,
0.5476180911,
-0.359926194,
-0.4237347245,
-0.0911409035,
0.0967129245,
-1.0658113956,
0.734693706,
0.0330613479,
-0.5754599571,
-0.0295416098,
-0.8639668822,
-0.7221954465,
1.1716092825,
0.1755373776,
-0.4538839757,
0.2080555856,
-0.0751227811,
0.4684380591,
-0.4731783271,
0.0953726545,
0.7974480987,
0.3145590127,
0.4171950519,
-0.6848297119,
0.2226589471,
-0.151455909,
-0.0195829365,
-0.238340348,
-0.4550080299,
0.5207386613,
-0.5323664546,
-0.2956272662,
0.3367041051,
1.1770101786,
0.5848060846,
0.2003141493,
0.6204459071,
0.3144187927,
0.6506319642,
0.0285624899,
0.9476997256,
-0.3501436412,
-0.1634779721,
1.1754190922,
-0.4726798832,
1.1445082426,
0.9412619472,
-0.0300550666,
0.81549263,
0.290964514,
0.3334551156,
0.5844092965,
0.1054000333,
-0.3305826783,
-0.2584419549,
-0.3296840489,
-0.2582090199,
0.5204238892,
0.7737225294,
-0.0715654045,
-0.1523069292,
-0.1089624017,
0.1941514313,
0.229741022,
-0.3109505475,
0.9881768227,
0.018740451,
-0.9196965098,
0.5334370732,
0.1710242182,
0.6811265945,
-0.6591727138,
-0.3731200397,
-0.4099551737,
0.0431649014,
-0.0703167915,
-0.9059570432,
0.0002222439,
0.0657792985,
0.2662965953,
0.1139273793,
0.5752063394,
-0.454288274,
-0.2269305438,
0.4786122143,
0.5248978734,
-0.0100233061,
0.1734220684,
-0.7100625634,
0.2922567427,
0.0516602062,
-0.2490340173,
0.1932491958,
0.0676601753,
-0.2139538825,
0.8354129791,
0.8448923826,
-0.0258579087,
0.0967977718,
0.3287404478,
1.1520659924,
-0.5068605542,
-0.695728898,
-0.6678853631,
0.6809275746,
-0.0031370851,
-0.3655000329,
0.4796545804,
0.2712410986,
0.5967031717,
0.1820022166,
0.5234159231,
0.1120952517,
0.1081983298,
-0.7920014262,
0.3381951749,
-0.3444827497,
0.4558000267,
-0.0283301827,
-0.8432213664,
-0.3844210207,
0.4710283875,
-0.2547908425,
-0.0758681148,
0.5181869864,
1.2485291958,
0.0667035207,
-0.1367491037,
0.1691636741,
0.3875701725,
0.6782855988,
0.456810534,
1.0672591925,
-0.2750237882,
0.6256625056,
-0.1864008904,
-0.4149801433,
-0.2293686122,
-0.9458093643,
-0.955295682,
-0.3883997798,
-0.3580572903,
-0.3410318792,
-0.0811670348,
0.8001038432,
0.5602884889,
-1.0268095732,
-0.4815973938,
-0.0833262056,
0.2662359774,
-0.294936806,
-0.1950123012,
0.354483813,
-0.5842811465,
-0.7685278654,
0.7022713423,
0.2024137229,
0.177323252,
-0.4454673827,
-0.3979590237,
-0.4274405837,
0.2673415542,
0.6891684532,
0.3747928441,
-0.7942530513,
-0.221600756,
-0.278147161,
-0.014160879,
-0.0045552668,
0.7784281969,
-1.0042539835,
0.3781675994,
0.5486716032,
0.613987267,
0.5183272362,
0.1694515944,
0.6428655982,
-0.4644334316,
0.5673867464,
-0.0216800682,
0.2246043384,
0.289881736,
-0.0389959216,
0.210853368,
-0.005400694,
-0.0639103279,
-0.5505385399,
0.1893732846,
-1.2076903582,
-0.1608895212,
1.3879996538,
0.165903762,
0.0262453202,
-0.1164792702,
-0.5029696226,
0.2481431514,
-0.5488923192,
0.7623067498,
0.3859919012,
-0.1859105676,
-0.0379732177,
-0.2963500023,
0.3840941787,
0.5822561383,
-0.9537623525,
-0.0054000397,
0.6697021723,
0.0483525656,
0.2030608505,
0.6097787023,
-0.0412055291,
0.4417150915,
0.0120174121,
-0.1332697868,
-0.0622716807,
-0.4134437442,
-0.7584128976,
0.0900608823,
0.092039451,
-0.3884905279
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05448v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05448v1
|
Domain Adaptation of a State of the Art Text-to-SQL Model: Lessons Learned and Challenges Found
| 2023-12-09T03:30:21 | 2023-12-09T03:30:21 |
Irene Manotas, Octavian Popescu, Ngoc Phuoc An Vo, Vadim Sheinin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
There are many recent advanced developments for the Text-to-SQL task, where
the Picard model is one of the the top performing models as measured by the
Spider dataset competition. However, bringing Text-to-SQL systems to realistic
use-cases through domain adaptation remains a tough challenge. We analyze how
well the base T5 Language Model and Picard perform on query structures
different from the Spider dataset, we fine-tuned the base model on the Spider
data and on independent databases (DB). To avoid accessing the DB content
online during inference, we also present an alternative way to disambiguate the
values in an input question using a rule-based approach that relies on an
intermediate representation of the semantic concepts of an input question. In
our results we show in what cases T5 and Picard can deliver good performance,
we share the lessons learned, and discuss current domain adaptation challenges.
|
[
-0.28795439,
-0.6657397151,
0.605178535,
-0.0277819317,
-0.2160327733,
0.2325418144,
0.0684590861,
-0.7315892577,
-0.237606585,
0.4877290428,
-0.500508666,
-0.4912505746,
-0.6129108667,
0.3849770129,
-0.3964948952,
0.9513660073,
0.1011048779,
-0.0691972002,
-0.4696941078,
-0.0764881223,
-0.4142344892,
-0.8361024857,
-0.3938762248,
0.036474023,
0.3286722898,
0.5134212375,
0.5746782422,
0.2886198759,
0.8725304008,
0.1533150673,
-0.175484091,
0.3197534382,
-0.5467504263,
0.1800832301,
-0.8387815356,
-0.4554644525,
-0.548288703,
-0.2583371997,
0.3989875913,
0.9162957668,
-0.081880942,
-0.069380559,
-0.2075310051,
0.6762052178,
-0.7706167698,
0.0355146267,
-0.8960318565,
-0.1398477703,
-0.0882973522,
-0.353192091,
-0.722401619,
-0.2130901217,
0.3902001381,
-0.7787945271,
0.4129419327,
0.3093141615,
0.975774467,
0.1479292214,
-0.7523574829,
-0.4078126252,
-0.8883060813,
0.5843527317,
-0.3776503503,
0.3473978937,
0.3513922095,
0.4683091938,
-0.3819583356,
-0.8143945336,
-0.4560699463,
0.105600521,
-0.0250366405,
-0.0630674884,
-0.2631326318,
-0.152300626,
0.0250306316,
0.2641780674,
-0.3858900666,
0.1609200537,
-0.4221482277,
0.0671738014,
0.5981232524,
0.1549142599,
0.1081071347,
-0.0223286431,
-0.4124481082,
-0.1491599977,
-0.7557377219,
-0.1029795706,
-0.0889284089,
0.5104754567,
0.0727591664,
0.6801151633,
-0.1354409903,
0.7371620536,
0.2637141049,
0.2854953408,
0.0283659268,
-0.2195567936,
-0.1571848541,
-0.2111579776,
0.2316806763,
0.3653541505,
0.2182900012,
-0.54080832,
-0.126620248,
0.0446651131,
0.3969252408,
-0.7495172024,
-0.3780226409,
0.4893290997,
-0.1466783434,
-0.1581406593,
-0.2500699162,
-0.7711268067,
-0.7241342664,
0.0716073886,
0.6690405607,
-0.3625046015,
-0.2468087971,
0.0393765196,
-0.3172047734,
0.3553294241,
0.6495464444,
-0.8978096843,
0.7837505341,
0.5484021902,
0.6639605165,
-0.8035351634,
-0.1215244234,
-0.1854777038,
0.3760008812,
-0.4468227625,
1.2529500723,
-0.4709865153,
-0.5635181665,
-0.3031503856,
0.21917665,
-0.3855007589,
-0.63089782,
0.436971873,
-0.9195405245,
0.4821371436,
-0.1968968213,
-0.9163625836,
-0.2050534189,
0.2320084423,
-0.7366628051,
0.6857143044,
0.3252641559,
-0.6957861185,
0.5318448544,
-0.7291392088,
-0.4325370789,
-0.0008970638,
0.1297334135,
-0.4938353002,
0.2973932624,
0.1578064263,
0.3124272525,
-0.5644126534,
-0.051189255,
-0.4768838584,
-0.2877264619,
0.1806493104,
0.1726397425,
0.7786829472,
-0.0176961068,
0.0080287857,
-0.0678276196,
-0.7918894291,
0.0837993324,
0.3740850687,
-0.1807638705,
-0.3021790385,
0.4612011313,
0.0071122544,
0.1155517548,
-0.0950422436,
-0.3540410101,
0.347111553,
-0.2284285873,
0.415746063,
0.4592327476,
0.3963092268,
0.5382778645,
-0.291477561,
0.4000184238,
0.4071916342,
0.1551742405,
0.2067698538,
-0.3469523489,
-0.6430205703,
-0.0915491432,
0.6575068235,
0.6499633789,
-0.9070144892,
0.0808645114,
-0.3317869604,
-0.372151196,
-0.3113975823,
-0.2883723676,
-0.1323234588,
0.4431838393,
0.6035071015,
-0.5128787756,
-0.1817581207,
-0.7050723433,
-0.2656806707,
-0.1624227911,
0.1362194866,
0.4531649947,
0.5708155036,
0.1629603505,
0.8797072768,
-0.6005750299,
-0.351516217,
-0.1968627423,
-0.2829426229,
0.0999935642,
0.426225543,
0.5755630136,
-1.1921616793,
-0.3244927526,
0.0263852142,
-0.603939414,
0.2153173685,
-0.0089918263,
-0.0771116018,
0.505446434,
0.1677484661,
-0.5076721907,
0.3039349616,
0.4271011949,
-0.6759371758,
0.4605478942,
-0.0872038305,
0.3407746851,
-1.2498005629,
0.0169727597,
0.0289914478,
-0.3180681169,
-0.7892974615,
-0.0075074872,
0.248101905,
-0.2380273938,
-0.4690451622,
0.4416428208,
-0.54626441,
-0.2893570364,
-0.0569198653,
0.0237537008,
0.1938126087,
0.3975364864,
0.3167195618,
0.9893591404,
0.6460931301,
-0.9595087171,
0.2387785465,
0.5048664212,
-0.2924667299,
0.5608323216,
-0.5942508578,
0.2794935107,
0.127692461,
0.0708544329,
-0.8398291469,
-0.23619546,
0.1346572489,
-0.4431639016,
0.2070362568,
-0.3244558573,
-0.3911851048,
-0.0375760123,
-0.0040180683,
0.261385113,
0.5053210855,
-0.5121370554,
0.5109155178,
0.4765868783,
-0.0845773593,
-0.316082865,
-0.4952437878,
0.4958532751,
-0.2991505265,
-0.4453983009,
0.7473281026,
0.120198831,
-0.0401146635,
-0.0000806578,
-0.0745802894,
-0.7744131088,
0.205067575,
-0.2880376279,
0.2633251846,
-0.193073988,
0.223827973,
0.1679018885,
0.2154403627,
-0.0851147026,
-0.2703990638,
0.0579999425,
0.2604783475,
-0.1730759591,
-0.1786151826,
0.4640583694,
0.3960223198,
-0.1423327625,
1.0004752874,
-0.19271034,
-0.3757820427,
-0.745485723,
-0.0550467744,
-0.3555193543,
-0.4074530005,
0.3699025214,
-0.7385950685,
-0.7223162055,
0.2638855875,
-0.4924202263,
-0.0685953125,
0.5608459115,
0.1868732274,
-0.438940376,
0.7989248037,
1.084787488,
0.5432591438,
0.2892604172,
-0.1147809103,
0.2139498889,
-0.5424761772,
-0.3506504297,
-0.7497580647,
0.049002327,
-0.6880252957,
-0.4525022507,
0.3736519217,
0.2593825161,
-0.0379137658,
0.56186378,
-0.3746211231,
0.2424664944,
0.1406083852,
0.4057852328,
0.5094600916,
0.2037977576,
0.1251907945,
-0.0430153422,
-0.9645728469,
-0.2710592449,
0.9343435764,
-0.0345499963,
0.7803170085,
0.5792960525,
0.2902194262,
0.6800773144,
0.0056558256,
-0.7808577418,
0.5510644317,
-0.4476749003,
-0.769887805,
-0.1528785676,
-0.4614343345,
-0.8100212812,
0.3543221653,
-0.2153131962,
-0.7101669908,
0.6720906496,
0.1720860451,
0.1494804025,
0.2047328055,
-0.8848420382,
0.9781985283,
-0.0792468339,
-0.5781949162,
-0.0331157632,
-0.4454236329,
0.004865346,
-0.1999173164,
-0.0692829192,
-0.0526420623,
-0.3607751131,
0.4753358662,
-0.3030549288,
0.815949142,
-0.0317124724,
0.0296103936,
0.2400944382,
0.1887498945,
0.4833842814,
-0.4366919398,
-0.2624322176,
0.0778411031,
0.3659161031,
-0.6773572564,
-0.6179481745,
0.2327539027,
-0.6339817047,
-0.8387474418,
-0.6074727774,
-0.4163476229,
-0.7574435472,
0.2142472118,
0.0704641864,
0.2861193717,
-0.3699303865,
0.2178198397,
0.6340028048,
-0.1199956164,
0.3900382817,
0.5282922387,
-0.0209522545,
-0.1582407951,
0.7489407063,
-0.0401822254,
0.5503955483,
0.6185685396,
-0.0710768029,
-0.5239697695,
-0.7454595566,
-0.745359838,
0.0501276217,
-0.8492929339,
-0.0332072489,
-0.4268831015,
0.0796297714,
-0.382294029,
0.137773782,
-0.1984112561,
-0.8333246708,
-0.3738564551,
0.3640075624,
0.4021165669,
0.7396078706,
0.5533675551,
-0.0409797467,
-0.7618942857,
0.1222381443,
-0.0797630996,
0.4716567397,
-0.3656442165,
-0.7002053857,
-0.2388197333,
-0.2827200294,
-0.1769101769,
-0.9875217676,
0.0371653251,
0.5943592191,
0.2524823248,
-0.3927662671,
0.4245737195,
0.5599920154,
-0.5235186815,
0.7689385414,
-0.1303958893,
-0.913192451,
0.5854549408,
-0.1833562702,
0.1362365782,
0.3304573596,
0.6806833148,
-0.3297744989,
0.1063516736,
-0.3974826038,
-0.5083819032,
0.5584663749,
0.1280996799,
-0.1885856539,
0.2838940024,
0.5075768828,
0.2192035168,
0.2196760476,
-0.5446996093,
0.2056674808,
-0.1173924953,
-0.0631520227,
0.0688112155,
0.0024962726,
0.0587409735,
-0.1950596124,
0.5052389503,
-0.4110062122,
0.4033100903,
0.1913627386,
-0.5119619966,
0.2462948412,
0.4431168735,
0.3432480097,
0.9456354976,
-0.1292200685,
-0.1202162653,
0.2702404559,
-0.3849973977,
0.0871814638,
0.0547409318,
-0.1414004564,
-0.1712793112,
0.3075307906,
0.6879611015,
0.0733950064,
-0.4834866524,
0.516682446,
0.0012893445,
-0.2600723505,
0.0572701022,
0.1818949729,
-0.0065109497,
0.109025687,
0.3562242687,
0.1474655718,
0.2704916894,
-0.6084502339,
0.1816473305,
0.1036798954,
-0.3118637204,
-0.3304842114,
0.6192757487,
0.2311155796,
-0.2002052814,
0.3431033194,
0.0830078498,
-0.4750861824,
0.6081223488,
0.7703238726,
0.7254270315,
-0.149873361,
0.1199331954,
-0.0245367307,
0.1371004581,
0.1301751137,
0.5979605913,
-0.0361738726,
-0.7913064957,
-0.4076492488,
-0.2812058032,
-0.886803925,
-0.4192676842,
-0.7237117887,
0.1829532534,
-0.4129176438,
-0.1882208288,
0.1995124817,
-0.01099924,
-0.446365416,
0.4653477371,
-0.3204636872,
1.1213703156,
-0.6041418314,
1.0442032814,
1.126164794,
-0.4130350649,
-0.3976394534,
-0.0437247269,
-0.3063293099,
-0.4249889851,
0.4993963242,
-0.4185485244,
-0.2192805409,
0.1261027753,
-0.3433485329,
-0.6038780212,
0.9564414024,
0.3067521453,
-0.3098272085,
-0.1753538996,
0.2643412948,
0.6889756322,
-0.4641167819,
-0.0751058236,
0.4527672231,
0.0605902225,
0.3106076121,
-0.8332312107,
-0.0395958871,
-0.1333458126,
0.109762013,
0.1854878962,
-0.4371248782,
0.7388384342,
-0.4318500757,
-0.4120586216,
-0.0862548798,
0.5718521476,
-0.0114870947,
0.289372772,
0.5831887722,
0.1457359195,
0.6744784713,
-0.213809371,
1.1157467365,
-0.1097121462,
0.5008355379,
1.1781822443,
-0.7057723403,
1.2168922424,
0.4884653091,
-0.2891138196,
0.6671242714,
0.7925454974,
0.0145873008,
0.693085134,
0.0360605642,
-0.3187651038,
-0.2395888716,
-0.1155843586,
-0.1650010794,
0.5731474757,
0.5549518466,
-0.1409553736,
-0.261942178,
-0.1327110529,
-0.4383942187,
0.1589660496,
-0.2945595682,
1.1668456793,
-0.0692169294,
-0.459081918,
0.5093691349,
-0.1089709178,
0.1872057617,
-0.3469949663,
-0.2977808118,
-0.1942964941,
0.3714311123,
-0.1510454863,
-0.7846280932,
0.3211398721,
0.047637783,
-0.3659136891,
-0.0018532872,
0.8880191445,
-0.2211045176,
-0.2961062789,
0.249883011,
0.6093101501,
0.1677089483,
0.0670733228,
-0.6092034578,
0.098563619,
-0.2719861269,
-0.2045416087,
0.3094791472,
0.5042078495,
-0.3896725476,
0.6920087337,
0.2672828734,
0.0489792377,
0.0104529606,
-0.0106926616,
0.780926168,
-0.8699117303,
-0.5212497711,
-0.4234733284,
0.4107609391,
-0.2688376606,
-0.3256683648,
0.5044802427,
0.5517803431,
0.6965305209,
-0.1394150704,
0.6492401361,
-0.1817634851,
0.7657890916,
-0.4875648618,
0.6616988778,
-0.6248089075,
0.3300214708,
-0.1208491474,
-0.9243574142,
-0.2714357972,
0.1234533712,
-0.2198548168,
0.0948082581,
1.0890933275,
0.6816169024,
-0.0572655126,
0.2219989002,
0.4298341274,
0.1385250688,
0.2912704647,
0.6684769392,
0.5695211291,
-0.621019125,
0.5542005301,
-0.0547003336,
-0.1815894842,
-0.0558279939,
-0.9892066121,
-0.746809721,
-0.7913241386,
-0.4333012998,
-0.4801856577,
0.4897332191,
0.6190146208,
0.8094625473,
-1.1496944427,
-0.2853702307,
-0.0144131137,
0.1656100303,
-0.2800167203,
-0.1624202579,
0.5477910638,
-0.1989074945,
-0.6950021982,
0.4112721086,
0.2076889277,
0.1394408345,
0.215698868,
0.2525499165,
-0.3397351205,
0.0747911185,
0.7958609462,
0.2386784554,
-0.3883505464,
-0.485591948,
0.0695287213,
-0.2934984863,
0.1920125335,
0.8019766808,
-0.7998397946,
0.2738487422,
0.3007028103,
1.0768632889,
0.6946504712,
0.0116048045,
0.7439244986,
-0.5022647977,
-0.2392263561,
0.4256040752,
0.0373127051,
0.4547162056,
-0.3814924359,
0.6422333121,
0.4793264568,
-0.3293116987,
-0.7726200223,
0.2326280177,
-1.0310790539,
-0.6856375337,
0.8527516723,
-0.0617389046,
-0.3542743325,
-0.3266652226,
0.0907833427,
-0.075891979,
-0.0698293447,
0.8096849918,
0.7390676141,
-0.422093153,
-0.6214995384,
-0.3163025975,
0.6769855022,
0.406316191,
-1.210901618,
0.0339902639,
0.4599298537,
0.4895761609,
-0.2979471087,
0.321520716,
-0.1121704727,
0.5039639473,
0.1465784609,
-0.0057991077,
0.1080462784,
-0.4016439915,
-0.328225702,
0.4430973828,
0.3579882383,
-0.1328687817
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05435v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05435v1
|
Enhancing Robustness of Foundation Model Representations under Provenance-related Distribution Shifts
| 2023-12-09T02:02:45 | 2023-12-09T02:02:45 |
Xiruo Ding, Zhecheng Sheng, Brian Hur, Feng Chen, Serguei V. S. Pakhomov, Trevor Cohen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Foundation models are a current focus of attention in both industry and
academia. While they have shown their capabilities in a variety of tasks,
in-depth research is required to determine their robustness to distribution
shift when used as a basis for supervised machine learning. This is especially
important in the context of clinical data, with particular limitations related
to data accessibility, lack of pretraining materials, and limited availability
of high-quality annotations. In this work, we examine the stability of models
based on representations from foundation models under distribution shift. We
focus on confounding by provenance, a form of distribution shift that emerges
in the context of multi-institutional datasets when there are differences in
source-specific language use and class distributions. Using a sampling strategy
that synthetically induces varying degrees of distribution shift, we evaluate
the extent to which representations from foundation models result in
predictions that are inherently robust to confounding by provenance.
Additionally, we examine the effectiveness of a straightforward confounding
adjustment method inspired by Pearl's conception of backdoor adjustment.
Results indicate that while foundation models do show some out-of-the-box
robustness to confounding-by-provenance related distribution shifts, this can
be considerably improved through adjustment. These findings suggest a need for
deliberate adjustment of predictive models using representations from
foundation models in the context of source-specific distributional differences.
|
[
0.0204407759,
-0.3684337735,
0.378952235,
0.3036578298,
-0.1920547336,
-0.1285726279,
-0.1716848314,
-0.3314476609,
-0.0364566892,
0.6645986438,
-0.4754470289,
-0.5099620223,
-0.9321485758,
0.2103545517,
-0.5256673098,
0.8486767411,
-0.0266075674,
0.3165552318,
-0.1537466943,
-0.5078628659,
-0.7605450153,
-0.231262207,
-0.2019611448,
-0.4881621301,
0.0216428563,
0.2515202761,
0.880165875,
0.7139992714,
0.8155102134,
0.1701899916,
0.0818270445,
-0.2671512961,
-0.5533330441,
0.3920664787,
-0.4577263594,
-0.9144261479,
-0.1086311191,
-0.44276914,
0.6497576833,
1.0848932266,
-0.3448156714,
-0.1481462866,
-0.0358591117,
0.6536132097,
-1.0669722557,
0.124814868,
-0.7087694407,
-0.1898347735,
-0.1961627007,
-0.2392583638,
-0.8251456618,
-0.2019195557,
0.5088140965,
-0.7128050327,
0.747805059,
-0.3016744256,
0.8398428559,
0.5012632608,
-0.2682009935,
-0.3214397132,
-0.7515376806,
0.6113187075,
-0.4323937297,
0.5943723321,
0.4391860068,
0.4937321246,
-0.1597601175,
-0.6800844669,
-0.0986882448,
-0.1847671419,
-0.2907834351,
0.0290698316,
-0.0429062061,
-0.3225557208,
0.2582991719,
0.2460395396,
-0.2592437863,
0.0956156254,
-0.1063705236,
-0.2810824513,
0.4651058316,
-0.0303659793,
0.1241084486,
0.1734930724,
-0.3895508647,
-0.6643823981,
-1.1943284273,
0.1681843549,
-0.0520864949,
0.4613372684,
-0.2236495912,
0.4071345031,
-0.0616858974,
0.4395007789,
0.2118481398,
-0.1117540374,
0.2297542691,
-0.0825748369,
-0.2951254249,
0.3362411261,
0.2602922022,
0.3743881583,
0.0398835801,
0.0379831418,
-0.0697092116,
0.3262690008,
0.1925852001,
-0.9502210617,
-0.5565924644,
0.267560631,
-0.5344406366,
-0.5814595819,
0.2331274301,
-0.6990745664,
-0.7050434351,
0.022209255,
0.3601236045,
-0.2993991077,
-0.4973536432,
0.2798973918,
-0.0181238763,
-0.2956039011,
0.2589047849,
-1.0841034651,
0.218423605,
0.2688882053,
0.7019741535,
-0.2090601176,
0.0607847758,
-0.4707645178,
0.5376368165,
-0.5009666085,
0.5734379888,
-0.5731424093,
-0.5743854046,
0.1464448571,
0.5079408884,
-0.0722405091,
-0.7038766146,
0.347030133,
-0.2947749794,
-0.1559991986,
-0.4419105053,
-0.320166111,
0.2708936632,
0.233265847,
-0.9444612265,
0.4444096386,
0.3284541965,
-0.9252247214,
0.5259040594,
-0.4027987719,
-0.545327425,
-0.3353886902,
-0.3501373529,
-0.7927019596,
0.1889577657,
0.5232277513,
0.2949273586,
0.1019925177,
0.5059975386,
-0.3805403113,
-0.1753549725,
0.5754671097,
-0.4688470364,
1.0049320459,
0.0776092336,
-0.6205551028,
-0.0409654304,
-0.9594272375,
-0.5485801101,
-0.0561740547,
0.1321467906,
-0.6592743397,
0.0131574133,
-0.3302434385,
-0.0378568731,
-0.3560191393,
-0.2878366113,
0.1185649633,
-0.3939164281,
0.109032765,
0.7950034142,
0.0487921461,
0.6489912868,
-0.3071436584,
0.5744527578,
0.2923948467,
-0.0862153172,
-0.2661981285,
-0.2376561463,
-0.4130974412,
-0.2166018635,
0.3463949859,
0.4527348578,
-0.5569244027,
-0.1268509477,
-0.485701859,
-0.178008467,
-0.4470819235,
-0.2552122176,
0.1474791914,
0.8720545173,
0.5703628063,
-0.2106925398,
-0.3090166748,
-0.8514191508,
0.0560634136,
-0.0173261277,
0.1113997325,
-0.0624215826,
0.4551009238,
-0.3799925148,
0.8672097921,
-0.4729879797,
0.0286459625,
0.1115105599,
0.0720183104,
0.1445570737,
0.9137694836,
0.6146960855,
-1.1030445099,
-0.1223330572,
-0.2072520405,
-0.7453809977,
-0.1031709239,
-0.3047657311,
-0.4553121328,
-0.0804254636,
0.2470886111,
-0.7429535389,
0.666611433,
0.5295829177,
-0.3091040254,
0.7184903026,
0.0050794091,
0.0180101674,
-1.2214927673,
0.0877913758,
-0.1492594033,
-0.0068671005,
-0.4795812964,
0.2261669934,
0.3118060529,
-0.2175284326,
-0.0278337225,
0.4514290392,
-0.4630309343,
-0.0968606994,
0.0164190531,
-0.2779512703,
0.0644213408,
-0.2589125633,
0.3025608063,
0.595821023,
0.8566505313,
-0.5918847322,
-0.0133922966,
0.5727284551,
-0.0003369667,
0.8756923676,
-0.5018359423,
-0.3140483797,
-0.0186451059,
0.5933316946,
-0.83379668,
-0.2962475717,
0.1983219981,
-0.1617744863,
0.6789295673,
-0.3925769031,
-0.1010006666,
0.1006917879,
-0.169858247,
0.1826383173,
0.2537410855,
-0.6071212888,
0.4382127523,
0.0151065718,
-0.0558788702,
-0.9911658168,
-1.0724261999,
-0.3503953516,
-0.2502737343,
-0.8728961945,
0.7243975401,
0.0085431971,
-0.4829293191,
0.1510279924,
-0.5207873583,
0.036183089,
0.3196887076,
0.3521954715,
0.1558968276,
-0.5330479741,
0.452151984,
0.3033024967,
-0.2738747895,
0.1247055233,
-0.3731917441,
0.1766625643,
0.2609900832,
-0.5186673403,
0.0431757756,
0.3255033791,
0.5238072872,
-0.2058438063,
1.022927165,
0.3665005863,
-0.6076295972,
-0.4154631793,
-0.227970466,
-0.6051528454,
-0.4499909282,
0.1957769245,
-0.3628767133,
-0.6859482527,
0.729975462,
-0.257404834,
-0.1573251337,
0.4447754025,
0.5956327319,
-0.0029645464,
0.721698463,
0.8513290882,
0.2801065147,
0.3457455337,
-0.5070784092,
-0.0351557061,
-0.6018340588,
-0.1127772406,
-0.6636302471,
-0.1498731226,
-0.6679797769,
-0.070059225,
0.1342411488,
0.1900688112,
-0.0108624678,
0.1225811765,
-0.5026346445,
0.1403421015,
0.0831101239,
0.3601098061,
0.3646819293,
0.224071309,
-0.0543126836,
0.0246522278,
-0.5822547078,
-0.3516551554,
1.4310637712,
0.269518286,
0.7529627681,
0.2124113441,
0.5938537121,
0.1773611158,
0.773599267,
-0.1171250939,
-0.0407362655,
-0.2312644571,
-0.6190068126,
-0.2281602919,
-0.2937454879,
-0.9283778071,
0.2399413586,
-0.3302531838,
-0.7562952638,
1.1188174486,
0.3016664684,
-0.2861239016,
0.1400212198,
-0.5897452831,
0.935921073,
-0.0324781872,
-0.4424387813,
-0.1089843437,
-0.9021742344,
0.2761005759,
-0.0923378766,
0.3326798379,
-0.0398720317,
0.3770687878,
0.0763328373,
-0.6936145425,
0.8362526298,
-0.2353836,
-0.2362111807,
0.0782173946,
0.4312495887,
0.809632957,
0.3081201613,
-0.1910497546,
-0.0293946695,
0.2562024891,
-0.5922583938,
-0.690526545,
0.5729303956,
-0.7564311028,
-0.5466758609,
-0.2400053889,
-0.7280651331,
-0.4196705818,
0.0701971054,
0.7324911952,
0.6486535072,
-0.021137286,
0.5583993793,
0.8932213187,
0.0500406921,
0.145823732,
0.3740406334,
-0.0052154213,
-0.1532946825,
0.5569770932,
0.1121062189,
0.6824425459,
0.5716695786,
0.5473621488,
-0.478207618,
-0.8743401766,
-0.5956164598,
-0.0045180288,
-1.0090786219,
-0.0809573531,
-0.4224635661,
0.2459101379,
-0.673019588,
-0.4324299395,
-0.1690687835,
-0.4522488117,
-0.2942287326,
-0.3823524415,
0.2372240275,
0.2284662277,
0.0147672603,
0.4100148678,
-0.4169085324,
0.1250135601,
-0.0192977861,
0.1916030496,
-0.3906624019,
-0.504963696,
-0.1404172778,
0.2362744361,
-0.202770099,
-1.2413971424,
0.1724991798,
0.1209797934,
0.649572134,
0.5300816298,
0.3663128912,
0.5987583399,
-0.0490120277,
0.4728216231,
0.0822195038,
-0.7151246667,
0.7034320831,
-0.4632399976,
-0.1408032775,
0.631999135,
0.2823818922,
0.1184516475,
-0.4524699748,
-0.8162377477,
-0.6401854753,
0.2935144305,
0.3918076456,
0.0553248413,
0.2057586759,
0.3436186016,
0.4177526832,
0.1722561121,
-0.726926446,
-0.1700502038,
-0.6618748903,
-0.4014398456,
0.1254233569,
-0.0761324093,
-0.4458829165,
0.0251529757,
0.5596001148,
-0.3194573522,
-0.0563086085,
0.3330434859,
-0.3908786178,
-0.2562715709,
0.2040188909,
0.7000800371,
1.1766889095,
-0.3545098305,
0.4456062615,
-0.0240505096,
-0.6967786551,
0.2487382144,
0.5636080503,
-0.5302097797,
0.2454225719,
0.4707197547,
0.6743999124,
0.2522091866,
-0.4374134541,
0.5232838988,
0.2682222426,
0.2797166407,
0.0107127288,
-0.0794625878,
-0.1099524796,
0.2401360869,
0.4317662418,
0.4980407953,
0.0577322058,
-0.4594145715,
0.4464705586,
0.2535882592,
-0.1625162214,
-0.2244026959,
0.6844550371,
-0.0516547784,
0.0502576418,
0.6330690384,
0.1483340859,
0.0215748344,
0.763684392,
1.0656474829,
0.6314102411,
-0.4014473855,
0.3372543752,
0.2730736732,
0.2801172435,
-0.4973932207,
-0.2517466247,
0.1256349087,
-1.0402177572,
-0.2126075029,
-0.3484923542,
-0.3262614906,
-0.115669705,
-0.900682807,
0.3664166033,
-0.4444935918,
-0.2408032864,
-0.3935367167,
-0.3181303442,
-0.5853075981,
0.421856612,
-0.2163756639,
0.8607993126,
-1.1831488609,
0.7301923633,
0.7107281089,
-0.427313,
-0.8455361128,
0.1151610613,
-0.0969049707,
-0.5492124557,
0.3343435228,
0.1682929844,
0.0059368825,
-0.1675914675,
-0.678958416,
-0.984632194,
1.3611072302,
0.9274905324,
-0.7131040692,
0.1720256805,
0.1186586767,
0.5142927766,
-0.4503345191,
-0.1819571555,
0.4547721446,
0.0692475811,
0.1688674837,
-0.4395697713,
0.4479885697,
-0.0794193223,
-0.0160896294,
0.0529172942,
-0.102268666,
0.9491403699,
-0.1687443554,
-0.2313195914,
-0.0142478179,
0.3948338926,
0.9248582125,
0.4688596427,
0.3267786503,
0.5842465758,
0.9657377601,
-0.3079023957,
1.318595171,
-0.2555784285,
0.4672857523,
1.0271346569,
-0.2125287354,
0.5150066614,
0.5583860874,
-0.048227001,
0.7752241492,
0.5947155952,
-0.1800155789,
0.8774639964,
-0.000547257,
-0.02883479,
-0.2223909646,
-0.012461571,
-0.8272380233,
-0.0721235052,
0.5075414181,
-0.6933261156,
-0.1898846328,
-0.1337697357,
-0.0784260407,
0.0482053086,
-0.1242000014,
0.0400525592,
0.1763620228,
-0.4886572957,
0.4338569045,
-0.1716400385,
0.2476363033,
-0.5855004787,
-0.2593227625,
-0.4163977504,
0.4990133047,
-0.4409038723,
-0.4190375507,
0.2516002059,
-0.3936708272,
-0.2911279202,
-0.1792792082,
0.9285310507,
-0.3133862317,
-0.779545486,
0.1139126122,
0.2098383605,
-0.1810410768,
0.1664114594,
-0.5827923417,
0.2510631382,
-0.1863755435,
-0.0399850607,
0.2907687724,
0.6653036475,
-0.6176461577,
0.6357957125,
0.9014659524,
0.2605206966,
0.0920380726,
0.2381712496,
0.6860553026,
-0.1018260345,
-0.6999617815,
-0.8138456345,
0.7698814869,
-0.0245193169,
-0.3514074385,
0.4831525683,
0.0604515076,
0.7696774602,
-0.106399864,
0.6659458876,
0.02519181,
0.0341153629,
-0.679187417,
0.6499953866,
-0.2046117485,
0.4966640174,
-0.5056603551,
-0.7528143525,
-0.4980681539,
0.7599554062,
-0.2663203776,
-0.1721582115,
0.6018386483,
0.7902911901,
-0.1631875336,
0.2023944259,
-0.0351503827,
0.2883957624,
0.501452148,
0.2301707268,
0.6013842225,
-0.3082599342,
0.3362246156,
-0.6241605282,
-0.1673057526,
-0.3638003469,
-1.1225380898,
-0.5468053818,
-0.2966948748,
-0.4950258434,
-0.8476707339,
0.4162904322,
0.5747558475,
0.9313149452,
-1.3239020109,
0.1167447045,
-0.3485498726,
0.1797966957,
-0.567945838,
-0.1476529539,
0.7766144872,
0.0532599539,
-0.0080680074,
0.2789800763,
0.0704617798,
0.2408607453,
-0.3557237089,
-0.0563085303,
0.1828729063,
-0.3219985068,
0.2674037516,
0.1832216829,
-0.6260660291,
-0.3751758933,
0.0997571349,
-0.1114769876,
0.0927734151,
0.871368289,
-0.6173353195,
0.5807473063,
0.3435830176,
0.9103746414,
0.4868097007,
0.2974400818,
0.7768089175,
-0.8609287739,
0.2859798968,
0.1032442972,
0.5219985843,
0.6793092489,
-0.6289830804,
0.6789534688,
0.6561251283,
-0.1659769714,
-1.084592104,
0.3171472251,
-0.72492975,
-0.3643162251,
0.8925244808,
-0.2740277052,
-0.0114992559,
0.0856832564,
0.1769015044,
0.2636412084,
-0.1346321553,
1.0015261173,
0.8264634013,
0.0076445774,
-0.327996999,
-0.2924692333,
0.3200346529,
0.5019456744,
-0.6708739996,
-0.0809169784,
0.5065408945,
0.6347756982,
0.4480158985,
0.4636798203,
-0.1807757318,
0.3016143143,
0.0392191075,
-0.3044989705,
0.0353701897,
-0.3105650842,
-0.4581404924,
0.2797887921,
-0.197900176,
-0.1599400342
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05434v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05434v1
|
Beneath the Surface: Unveiling Harmful Memes with Multimodal Reasoning Distilled from Large Language Models
| 2023-12-09T01:59:11 | 2023-12-09T01:59:11 |
Hongzhan Lin, Ziyang Luo, Jing Ma, Long Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The age of social media is rife with memes. Understanding and detecting
harmful memes pose a significant challenge due to their implicit meaning that
is not explicitly conveyed through the surface text and image. However,
existing harmful meme detection approaches only recognize superficial
harm-indicative signals in an end-to-end classification manner but ignore
in-depth cognition of the meme text and image. In this paper, we attempt to
detect harmful memes based on advanced reasoning over the interplay of
multimodal information in memes. Inspired by the success of Large Language
Models (LLMs) on complex reasoning, we first conduct abductive reasoning with
LLMs. Then we propose a novel generative framework to learn reasonable thoughts
from LLMs for better multimodal fusion and lightweight fine-tuning, which
consists of two training stages: 1) Distill multimodal reasoning knowledge from
LLMs; and 2) Fine-tune the generative framework to infer harmfulness. Extensive
experiments conducted on three meme datasets demonstrate that our proposed
approach achieves superior performance than state-of-the-art methods on the
harmful meme detection task.
|
[
-0.547652483,
-1.212125659,
0.6762581468,
-0.0920058712,
-0.4648804367,
0.1504420787,
-0.0607857071,
-0.4368858337,
-0.0900231302,
0.6283546686,
-0.6655932665,
-0.4757950008,
-0.7595516443,
-0.1629042774,
-0.3760669827,
0.7048332095,
0.1730333865,
-0.3560542762,
-0.3336802721,
-0.0430694148,
-0.4310843647,
-0.2352863401,
-0.7344684601,
-0.0404494628,
0.6807941794,
0.5545301437,
0.4892007709,
0.0579080768,
0.3906165957,
0.407537967,
0.0056299451,
0.5818939209,
-0.5931529999,
0.2968737781,
-0.4517717063,
-0.3720928133,
-0.1844785511,
0.1909903437,
0.1281625181,
0.3657948673,
0.0765627101,
-0.0396299399,
-0.0124918092,
0.57043612,
-0.7525228262,
-0.2098643035,
-0.8766055703,
-0.0833847821,
-0.1493278891,
-0.4472260177,
-0.6032760143,
-0.1184079647,
-0.2940458655,
-0.307887584,
-0.1721849889,
-0.2421734035,
0.4805548489,
0.2829833925,
-0.6864081025,
-0.4069146514,
-0.6381582022,
0.9263414741,
-0.6023295522,
0.3160644472,
0.254881382,
0.4051301181,
-0.2876298428,
-0.5799549818,
-0.6855392456,
-0.2152379006,
0.0502335504,
-0.087289989,
-0.5723410249,
-0.0084480653,
0.1623702645,
0.1018293276,
-0.6151567101,
0.1554126889,
-0.3622529209,
-0.3746569455,
0.5366675258,
0.0529229119,
0.7082688212,
-0.3523648083,
-0.6042841673,
-0.1479187906,
-0.8816249967,
-0.1588458717,
0.2609690726,
-0.0937484652,
-0.0576721877,
0.5456100702,
0.0568228737,
0.2476999611,
-0.1703606695,
-0.2908440232,
0.0339273103,
-0.2123440206,
-0.0931018218,
-0.2784521282,
0.6792473197,
0.7975106239,
0.3818796575,
-0.091051057,
-0.055650115,
0.4857147038,
0.3345305324,
-0.7456973195,
-0.2261187732,
0.1707980037,
-0.4880856872,
-0.3062195778,
-0.3037362993,
-0.7616786361,
-0.6993727684,
-0.1740756482,
0.3935799599,
-0.696406424,
-0.5130516887,
-0.0030395484,
-0.1930386275,
0.0323214494,
0.3328734338,
-0.4727648795,
-0.3097958267,
0.6239031553,
0.5804038644,
0.3950312138,
0.0800445974,
-0.3570128381,
0.2751895487,
-0.3253677189,
1.0656651258,
-0.5911300182,
-0.1962552965,
-0.3223667741,
0.1952925473,
0.2038542181,
-0.5690998435,
0.849981904,
-0.2492047548,
-0.0042497986,
-0.2966825664,
-0.2332935631,
-0.7125831842,
0.4171443284,
-0.4514507949,
0.2182723731,
-0.1570244431,
-0.69460392,
0.303416878,
-0.4757141769,
-0.4852319062,
0.0094737578,
-0.0540568084,
-0.3822485507,
-0.0483747087,
0.1648678333,
1.0070259571,
-0.1519262642,
0.2523461878,
-0.666616261,
-0.1252455711,
0.1957233399,
-0.7969551682,
0.8346428275,
0.7176325917,
-0.3294719756,
0.2470196486,
-0.571798861,
-0.0247083995,
0.1499603838,
-0.0932660848,
-0.7274125218,
-0.0948046148,
-0.1836076975,
0.4816059172,
-0.231805712,
-0.5880298018,
-0.1535835117,
-0.0405136459,
0.6576380134,
0.7433486581,
0.1452935338,
0.4397861362,
-0.4048171043,
0.1177097559,
0.1915441304,
0.2676774859,
-0.2112465352,
-0.45173648,
-0.4275485575,
-0.5007869005,
-0.3745954931,
0.398645997,
-1.1627519131,
0.2405094653,
-0.0488803424,
-0.5593929291,
-0.222930178,
0.2730495334,
0.4520649016,
0.2911014259,
0.4565187991,
0.1699903905,
-0.4554554522,
-1.0548956394,
-0.3605029583,
0.12269485,
-0.0190311801,
0.2503941655,
0.4216340184,
-0.7007426023,
0.0949505344,
-0.3808968961,
-0.2820681632,
-0.0932421535,
0.3573496044,
-0.0726882964,
0.662515223,
0.6654640436,
-0.848690629,
-0.2640495002,
-0.3138058484,
-0.8994272351,
-0.1376924515,
-0.4127028584,
-0.1636505872,
-0.3619983196,
0.8304680586,
-0.5921758413,
0.1230051517,
0.5261163116,
-0.4792898595,
0.3034239411,
-0.1207810938,
0.5496270657,
-0.9738411903,
-0.2048859298,
0.1708855331,
-0.2447061539,
-0.4783186316,
0.1617069542,
0.0874335617,
0.01688952,
-0.3949127197,
0.3293501139,
-0.5372552872,
0.5381448269,
-0.3621290028,
-0.0688240379,
0.2284780443,
0.2394297272,
-0.4049153626,
0.622603476,
0.3746911883,
-0.6246669292,
0.3930659592,
-0.0349879414,
-0.5061189532,
0.562437892,
-0.2020801306,
0.1707203835,
-0.5383855104,
0.1274448484,
-1.1816880703,
-0.1039593294,
0.4815374613,
-0.4791715741,
0.3574676514,
0.1969398111,
-0.6029132009,
-0.3612590134,
-0.4501624107,
0.6739256382,
0.3507345617,
-0.6339249015,
0.6062575579,
0.5795279145,
-0.0020797632,
-0.4847705364,
-0.5381091237,
0.1875547916,
-0.5331401229,
-0.7535148859,
0.0811217204,
-0.1069257706,
-0.4557707012,
-0.0560815781,
-0.0684832484,
-0.0297896713,
0.3028792441,
0.4379869998,
-0.287089467,
0.0407726802,
0.1496871263,
0.43224141,
-0.256439507,
0.0948921219,
0.2669247985,
0.4232700169,
-0.2364529967,
-0.5438202024,
-0.1567623913,
0.4659404159,
0.9070248008,
-0.2262226194,
0.3852260113,
0.6769231558,
-0.5971041918,
-0.3517203927,
-0.7513144016,
-0.3600660861,
-0.5410706997,
0.3441995084,
-0.3283358812,
-0.6372908354,
0.2841637135,
-0.5506033897,
-0.0481032059,
0.3487230241,
0.4000119567,
-0.2278176993,
1.1716313362,
0.2519081533,
0.1439938843,
0.2120971233,
-0.496673733,
0.26882568,
-0.6004209518,
-0.6342098713,
-0.1708877832,
-0.3005566895,
-0.3077820539,
-0.7478435636,
0.5636218786,
0.174698621,
-0.2504798472,
0.1808801144,
-0.3753597438,
0.6712165475,
0.4136289954,
0.4934718311,
0.0906847939,
0.0459843427,
-0.2362943739,
0.0512894467,
-0.2188980132,
-0.6949776411,
0.6639748812,
0.4421597421,
1.0624880791,
0.3519060016,
0.0346838124,
0.4264117181,
0.2770054936,
-0.4343957603,
0.6154902577,
-0.4227622449,
-0.8406166434,
-0.0625459105,
-0.2776915431,
-0.8439558148,
0.2665787041,
-0.5891218185,
-0.4316150844,
-0.0976500288,
0.0721866116,
-0.1095235944,
0.6503753662,
-0.7277218699,
0.7749550343,
-0.3776665628,
-0.4506656229,
-0.8070430756,
-0.7471367121,
0.552059412,
0.2783824503,
0.6463474035,
-0.5316414833,
0.0567379743,
0.2847427428,
0.0883636177,
1.1369757652,
-0.2514537275,
-0.2915122807,
0.5910661221,
0.3317443728,
0.039907027,
0.0303021837,
0.2637611926,
0.235272184,
-0.313953042,
-0.4370363653,
-0.4390726984,
1.0175833702,
-0.4410600364,
-0.41655007,
0.0405828506,
-0.4885635674,
-0.1700374782,
0.32188797,
0.1178503186,
0.3607628047,
-0.1110010743,
0.4696840346,
0.8475629091,
-0.5797722936,
0.2987815142,
0.2235934138,
0.0982469916,
-0.3360512555,
1.1476125717,
-0.1617494822,
0.1841303855,
0.497580409,
0.2594950199,
-0.5465180278,
-0.5334147215,
-0.5053984523,
0.0314558148,
-1.1240397692,
-0.4392011166,
-0.7658089995,
0.1075577289,
-0.1060464457,
-0.0902584866,
-0.1923186034,
-0.0935259834,
-0.1048523784,
-0.2044548541,
0.0480918661,
0.5479969978,
-0.2206615061,
0.1929203123,
-1.0695728064,
0.5774863958,
0.4864996374,
0.3453284204,
0.0993229449,
-0.2510426939,
0.351100713,
0.3648399413,
-0.4616434872,
-0.8539435863,
0.0305199903,
0.1039562523,
0.7690923214,
1.0312359333,
0.1835379153,
0.4010486007,
-0.3607983887,
0.3781883717,
0.4109760225,
-0.5876814127,
0.5065457821,
-0.3699068725,
0.0804192945,
0.4008534253,
0.6176251769,
-0.5065661073,
-0.6529555321,
-0.434674859,
-0.6684467793,
-0.0078579178,
0.0305215158,
0.7087258697,
-0.3349402547,
0.4460991323,
0.3556956053,
0.0767873079,
-0.8688023686,
-0.0588742644,
-0.2174910009,
0.0338343754,
-0.1713794768,
-0.5934893489,
-0.1398880035,
-0.3568763733,
0.6182854176,
-0.0040447484,
-0.007454616,
-0.1719105989,
-0.3899086118,
-0.3205293715,
0.2705106735,
0.5483367443,
0.3867663443,
-0.054496415,
0.878347218,
0.0042904471,
-0.2148574591,
0.2477377057,
-0.3490642607,
0.1162813157,
-0.4874712229,
0.5727977753,
0.4476898611,
0.2835341692,
-0.9721109271,
0.7125166059,
0.1237971559,
-0.0895466954,
-0.0938619524,
0.1345232129,
0.2683088183,
0.479455322,
0.2058348954,
0.3393820524,
0.4720302522,
-0.5989311934,
0.5323503613,
0.7538374066,
-0.2042581439,
-0.4786145985,
0.5677711964,
0.3632189929,
0.4083175361,
0.3663288653,
-0.1253039241,
-0.5405819416,
0.4832102954,
0.4502640069,
0.6512693167,
-0.3729681373,
0.2904225588,
0.4844035506,
0.6464170218,
0.427136153,
0.3129333556,
0.1241554096,
-0.8474922776,
-0.4021556377,
-0.3656813204,
0.1071571037,
0.7306575775,
-0.0266687032,
0.1688483655,
-0.5232661366,
0.061223764,
0.4584682584,
-0.4541810751,
-0.2167259753,
0.3573349118,
0.5898626447,
0.626286447,
-1.1886268854,
0.2300270051,
0.6463512778,
-0.4890058637,
-0.3908143044,
-0.0525396429,
0.2174846828,
-0.9104548693,
0.2146931887,
0.5970824361,
-0.417440176,
-0.0802377388,
-0.8438839316,
-0.4091000557,
0.7013825178,
0.5957300663,
-0.3841491938,
0.2497226745,
-0.1002479419,
0.338683784,
-0.0517641567,
0.2052492946,
0.1183263436,
0.3791761696,
0.3354867697,
-0.4117400646,
0.4565103054,
-0.2892707884,
-0.2940231562,
0.2456454337,
-0.432492435,
0.9213383794,
-0.6358482838,
-0.4587750137,
-0.206045568,
0.4034979641,
0.0469937883,
0.430011332,
0.8708848357,
0.5301956534,
0.426345706,
0.1716351956,
0.7736384869,
0.0468224362,
0.010159675,
0.7161221504,
0.4015198052,
0.4453044236,
0.459579885,
0.1194690391,
0.5825197697,
0.6046666503,
0.0502496287,
0.7834575772,
0.3543701172,
-0.4766339362,
-0.6989954114,
-0.0757970884,
-0.2453336418,
0.6419473886,
0.7560617328,
-0.3575604558,
-0.6838036776,
0.5559586883,
0.2218919247,
0.4304439723,
-0.4427227676,
0.9614477158,
0.230699122,
-0.3758855462,
0.8234283924,
0.1218155026,
0.7458814979,
-0.1225089356,
-0.3498460948,
0.2027712315,
0.3846550286,
-0.2404528707,
-0.7833251953,
0.4847507775,
-0.2488515526,
-0.0479583293,
-0.0431412868,
1.2860530615,
-0.4737231135,
-0.3031852245,
0.5410847664,
0.8154932261,
0.2803771496,
-0.4947274327,
-0.9015396833,
-0.1670907438,
-0.0340062492,
-0.020423349,
0.1609821022,
0.6356624365,
-0.3149384558,
0.9013636708,
0.7052215934,
-0.3415846229,
-0.0038673182,
0.2283560038,
1.1490670443,
-0.4840767384,
-0.2401643991,
-1.0300086737,
0.5521933436,
-0.0495042689,
0.2062142789,
0.5448825955,
0.2725649476,
0.6337060332,
-0.1043597534,
0.6862053275,
-0.0114888754,
0.4641659558,
-0.5088515878,
0.7751635313,
-0.8571668267,
0.212913692,
-0.3257907033,
-0.6017335057,
-0.3366936147,
0.5872322917,
-0.168093577,
0.0138231423,
0.3354679942,
0.7359333038,
-0.2474677265,
0.0930611864,
0.476792872,
0.4186130166,
0.4472341835,
0.5743878484,
1.3961375952,
0.0463289507,
0.5656995773,
-0.4906673133,
-0.516941905,
-0.2225756049,
-0.9635386467,
-1.1903449297,
-0.7284251451,
-0.0816036761,
-0.3407378495,
-0.0891485438,
0.8143302202,
0.5074466467,
-0.7620162368,
0.3855490386,
-0.0688574538,
0.251711756,
-0.0049794083,
-0.1785504222,
0.2443705797,
-0.1957594007,
-0.5207039714,
0.4513249397,
0.2721431255,
0.2218456119,
-0.3321808577,
0.0682573318,
-0.3872861266,
-0.0118837971,
1.09047997,
-0.1418521553,
-0.7993862629,
-0.5844510198,
-0.2669516802,
-0.0967919827,
-0.3407808244,
0.7300716043,
-0.3782791793,
0.5237010121,
0.4452305138,
0.3518277109,
0.0535762459,
-0.0024244627,
0.2329732031,
-0.7988494039,
0.2690180838,
0.3135593832,
0.3848612607,
0.4385174215,
-0.6366394758,
0.3647927046,
0.2125227749,
-0.1560452878,
-0.7624910474,
0.3035499752,
-0.6890561581,
-0.9975950718,
1.2468283176,
-0.0224300716,
-0.0413140319,
-0.3538646698,
-0.4341791868,
0.2925280929,
-0.1234898418,
0.8444937468,
0.3230383992,
-0.0503012054,
-0.2451780289,
-0.4502378106,
0.489502579,
0.2469974011,
-0.8144137263,
0.0275102779,
0.6992922425,
0.4397122264,
0.4569488764,
0.4966786802,
-0.1774996519,
0.3787941635,
0.1472379565,
-0.0198679939,
-0.2328698039,
-0.6571412086,
0.1722807139,
0.2184608281,
-0.1862546206,
-0.2107802182
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05415v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05415v1
|
An Experimental Study: Assessing the Combined Framework of WavLM and BEST-RQ for Text-to-Speech Synthesis
| 2023-12-08T23:59:25 | 2023-12-08T23:59:25 |
Via Nielson, Steven Hillis
|
cs.SD
|
cs.SD, cs.CL, eess.AS
|
We propose a new model architecture specifically suited for text-to-speech
(TTS) models. We combine WavLM, a pre-trained self-supervised learning (SSL)
speech model, and the BEST-RQ vector quantization framework. We assess the
extent to which the more task-agnostic WavLM, coupled with the superior
suitability of the simplistic BEST-RQ framework for a wider array of downstream
tasks, yields favorable outcomes. Experiments on the LibriSpeech dataset with
SUPERB benchmarking assert that the proposed model significantly underperforms.
We speculate the underlying reason for this performance is related to the
difference between featurizing raw audio waveforms and spectrograms with a
quantizer. We discuss the limitations of this approach to better guide future
advancements in TTS.
|
[
-0.2615718842,
-0.6026437283,
0.4460005462,
0.1359616816,
-0.3024240732,
0.2640624046,
0.0877331719,
-0.4263722897,
-0.1797458827,
0.2278206497,
-0.4481250942,
-0.5633558035,
-0.3415108025,
0.1529163569,
-1.0083192587,
1.0248575211,
0.3285683692,
0.0018643992,
-0.254858464,
-0.0758508071,
-0.2955772579,
-0.8235689998,
-0.5563446879,
-0.2156315893,
0.3104989827,
-0.1216709539,
0.3764827847,
0.3677289188,
0.2912254035,
0.216170758,
-0.1142991334,
0.0629390329,
-0.2550529838,
0.2248919308,
0.0447487161,
-0.1139108911,
-0.725533545,
-0.1176321059,
0.4656804204,
0.2827845216,
-0.342564553,
0.4605866969,
0.1035856903,
0.5372001529,
-0.5866936445,
-0.2982503176,
-0.4651339054,
0.0639691353,
-0.1120470166,
-0.1179120392,
-0.5245216489,
-0.2434095144,
0.3855903447,
-0.5412576795,
0.0795190781,
0.1154576316,
0.3618585169,
0.5701766014,
-0.5766755342,
0.0684954971,
-1.0634986162,
0.8281591535,
-0.8312583566,
0.9976315498,
0.2023030072,
0.3092893362,
0.0780142695,
-1.1680938005,
-0.3166238368,
-0.2598600388,
0.2851312459,
0.3600651622,
-0.495639503,
0.3100461066,
0.0556318723,
0.4510847628,
-0.7531735301,
-0.0538025387,
-0.4321367741,
-0.415895462,
0.4796635509,
0.0737918019,
0.1278540343,
-0.2135673016,
-0.7098831534,
-0.1840889454,
-0.4265880287,
0.3304101527,
0.0760695264,
0.4533513188,
-0.0425270349,
0.5051542521,
-0.0533629917,
0.8296292424,
-0.1840911806,
0.0713393614,
-0.0204300415,
-0.4525295198,
-0.5624732375,
0.0462901071,
1.1066446304,
0.0990723222,
0.0309157949,
-0.2310883999,
-0.5592106581,
0.1608691514,
0.2330990285,
-0.6266044974,
-0.0823361501,
0.463423878,
-0.4777959287,
-0.2712652683,
-0.2141451091,
-0.2861382365,
0.1387888044,
-0.4560164511,
0.7349054217,
-0.4665812552,
-0.3208012581,
-0.0526538827,
-0.3866237998,
-0.1045430303,
-0.0522465818,
-0.7579904795,
0.3384982646,
0.5131685138,
0.7630619407,
-0.5490542054,
-0.0889081955,
-0.7318624258,
0.2071046233,
-0.6656355858,
0.6773669124,
-0.1129032448,
-0.7510488033,
-0.151928857,
-0.7083651423,
0.2735951543,
-0.4496372044,
0.6286864877,
-0.3069812953,
0.3904217184,
-0.1276600659,
-0.7995641828,
0.3401934505,
-0.301815182,
-0.581558466,
1.3778213263,
0.3250584006,
-0.6240777969,
0.2583123147,
-0.5654887557,
-0.5659599304,
-0.0089246323,
-0.0972194374,
-0.3304582834,
0.3468390405,
0.0475246757,
0.3144880831,
-0.4869415164,
0.4727199376,
-0.171759218,
-0.3838674128,
0.5360106826,
-0.6915938854,
0.615116179,
0.5888149142,
-0.1239994168,
0.4035789371,
-1.0572562218,
0.3932988048,
-0.2128600031,
-0.2426436692,
-0.3819143474,
0.0734447762,
0.4212068319,
0.0972505286,
0.1601850986,
-0.4307380319,
-0.1641533524,
-0.5295291543,
0.9148122668,
0.4985634089,
-0.1050887182,
0.443589747,
-0.3236379623,
0.4519612491,
-0.5157641768,
0.4240935445,
0.1516554654,
-0.2421328127,
-0.606702745,
-0.3023571968,
0.603695333,
0.2682997584,
-0.5566225052,
0.2151218355,
-0.1202257127,
-0.2980599999,
-0.7887908816,
-0.4219580591,
0.4918019176,
0.5367496014,
0.6065983772,
-0.189518407,
-0.7624919415,
-0.8264826536,
-0.3048859537,
-0.4360149801,
-0.4220553041,
-0.3319762945,
0.0931873247,
0.0439946167,
1.2263059616,
0.0404906124,
-0.3628610969,
0.0693780854,
0.1373799592,
-0.2116671652,
0.4005483389,
0.420953989,
-0.7919303179,
-0.0881339088,
-0.1828289032,
-0.3110369146,
-0.0401959606,
0.2537975013,
0.0430723988,
0.1337483823,
0.6632553935,
-0.3909479976,
0.5328431726,
0.5950897336,
0.0197567772,
0.5746657848,
-0.1415660977,
0.1635466963,
-0.9890388846,
0.0442036688,
-0.1009291559,
-0.4865689874,
-0.9967105389,
-0.0375624374,
0.0476984382,
-0.1558312029,
-0.5416048765,
0.3790755272,
0.0913281068,
-0.537271142,
-0.2301070988,
-0.084690325,
0.1459790766,
0.2577913702,
0.0993485525,
1.0839146376,
0.2385013998,
-0.7149426937,
0.1568015218,
0.2282104045,
-0.226687327,
0.3602901101,
-1.0108400583,
0.2202932388,
0.2188208401,
0.1439654529,
-1.1562458277,
0.0309201647,
-0.2589233816,
-0.8549118042,
-0.0066914936,
0.0240799896,
-0.3493289649,
-0.3634820282,
-0.1087340266,
0.4541704953,
0.9293693304,
-0.3685539365,
0.9649319649,
0.2946012914,
0.0921627358,
-0.2609587312,
-0.9204841256,
-0.117039457,
-0.3348935843,
-0.1993246675,
0.7018455267,
-0.2876882553,
-0.1391132623,
-0.2256548703,
-0.2772040367,
-0.2200304121,
-0.0348432586,
0.1478483379,
0.2718124092,
-0.2898251712,
0.2493477017,
-0.0313358828,
-0.1445372403,
0.0888838768,
-0.5438631773,
0.2953840792,
-0.1318850815,
-0.2523022592,
-0.6521134377,
0.2448278368,
0.6372956038,
-0.6531171203,
0.1331393719,
0.4938425422,
-0.0772944242,
-0.3114328682,
-0.2578004301,
-0.0213758443,
-0.5323653221,
0.2329366207,
-0.426681608,
-0.8529072404,
0.1582281739,
0.0082877334,
0.1389075369,
0.3989672363,
0.4575879276,
-0.4769900441,
1.1464947462,
0.5986935496,
0.1524200588,
0.6006680131,
-0.1897132993,
0.0495278575,
-0.7701703906,
-0.0967988372,
-0.4749726355,
0.2532212138,
-0.5535323024,
-0.340827167,
0.6123827696,
-0.2784402668,
-0.3083975613,
0.2007439286,
-0.7474647164,
-0.1073927805,
0.7312162519,
0.0326163098,
0.3217227757,
0.1261464953,
-0.2233049423,
-0.0520623066,
-0.9049906135,
-0.3585596681,
1.1583002806,
0.2574668527,
0.453674227,
-0.05701432,
0.7108293772,
0.5113950968,
0.0571578555,
-0.6760439277,
0.4218581915,
-0.4930595756,
-0.490393281,
-0.5499247909,
-0.1894089431,
-0.7524055839,
0.4012944102,
-0.4192724526,
-0.3312778771,
-0.2056767046,
0.2781177759,
-0.5018727183,
0.0522384755,
-0.5547205806,
0.6097341776,
-0.1770594865,
-0.3305880427,
-0.0213099644,
-0.6545389891,
0.2138371766,
-0.1010774672,
0.6445452571,
0.031417001,
0.0987334624,
0.7714897394,
-0.3298308849,
0.4646211267,
0.082334891,
-0.3216812313,
0.424862802,
0.091142334,
0.0846800208,
-0.3428360224,
-0.1330338418,
-0.1059124693,
0.421620816,
-0.10164655,
-0.5561524034,
0.1936141104,
-0.6461840272,
-0.3921500146,
-0.1838735491,
-0.3407698572,
-0.4924434721,
0.0774841085,
0.495751828,
1.0139870644,
-0.4317737222,
0.1461393982,
0.4922721982,
-0.0881678835,
0.4953127801,
0.4764858484,
-0.4098655581,
-0.6069037318,
0.9672721028,
-0.1381662786,
0.5886260867,
0.5932621956,
0.3520433009,
-0.5925940871,
-0.8714843988,
-0.3572075367,
-0.25014925,
-0.582346499,
-0.0368687585,
-0.4096824825,
-0.4328027964,
-0.5251023173,
0.3211831152,
-0.7050432563,
-0.5035281181,
-0.4249233305,
-0.0638792291,
0.307485491,
0.7273976803,
0.0013598836,
0.2009230405,
-0.8484994769,
0.6420599222,
0.5038653612,
0.0212270804,
0.0270318836,
-0.7434406877,
-0.0473677963,
0.2193377167,
0.0083654197,
-0.7142026424,
0.3353424966,
0.1907227784,
0.3483780026,
-0.1032914072,
0.3181708753,
0.7363632917,
-0.7360723615,
0.9465662241,
0.288267225,
-1.2259587049,
0.7206507325,
-0.3506877422,
0.3420326412,
0.1692719311,
0.0509794243,
-0.4467069209,
-0.8179297447,
-0.5132781267,
-0.8111252785,
0.1807233691,
0.636628747,
-0.1035343707,
0.1886210889,
0.1996178329,
0.0499674268,
0.24439843,
-0.7247148752,
-0.3439038694,
-0.2928852141,
-0.5886700153,
-0.0322525129,
-0.1265787929,
0.1040324122,
-0.263428688,
0.5186241269,
0.0918627456,
0.3010984063,
0.3948236108,
-0.0109878741,
-0.034538608,
0.4197359681,
0.4535508454,
0.6626774669,
-0.1268596202,
-0.0183252953,
0.0916373804,
-0.1594471484,
0.2388453335,
-0.057619337,
-0.1389122009,
-0.0186965298,
0.5706011057,
1.0254126787,
0.2540448606,
-0.607721746,
0.5342220068,
-0.2497341186,
-0.4534120262,
-0.1838195026,
0.1725373566,
-0.001936994,
0.3850384653,
0.740534544,
-0.0066076233,
0.5057873726,
-0.2544890344,
0.4004903436,
0.4574825764,
-0.3155082464,
-0.2573427856,
1.1777737141,
0.1265810281,
-0.6232709289,
0.1274742633,
0.2497184128,
-0.42850402,
0.4947844446,
0.3385519385,
0.7624293566,
-0.5513609052,
0.1520697176,
0.0856041685,
0.0854632258,
-0.0788855925,
0.3203070462,
-0.2898813784,
-0.0455725938,
-0.5687597394,
-0.6622327566,
-0.3972430229,
-0.0064332704,
-0.9518857002,
0.3007832766,
-0.1588520706,
-0.604722321,
0.1295051277,
-0.4922507107,
-0.5037748218,
0.5923757553,
0.0504587442,
0.5753424168,
-0.5857895613,
1.0226697922,
0.3676123619,
-0.1754503399,
-0.8120199442,
-0.0260775909,
-0.3340205848,
-0.5435413718,
0.6474637985,
-0.2557365,
-0.3459741175,
0.5061426759,
-0.2536183298,
-1.0357400179,
1.0042117834,
0.3107506037,
-0.7938766479,
-0.2471493632,
0.2365522981,
0.9127139449,
-0.080373764,
0.1297946721,
0.4953251183,
-0.1056186929,
0.2221478075,
-1.1886398792,
-0.2765744328,
0.2015117854,
0.3127152026,
0.014168391,
-0.5978116393,
0.7481483817,
-0.0263704471,
-0.3388930261,
0.2881323099,
1.0437648296,
0.2690528035,
0.2820821106,
0.5583252907,
0.1370429248,
0.710775733,
0.0419271737,
0.9502476454,
-0.1730717272,
0.3283185363,
1.1307926178,
-0.0755688921,
1.2160815001,
0.4713378549,
-0.6760007739,
0.2299487293,
0.5893117785,
0.2866657376,
0.8682700992,
0.1374993026,
-0.1222918928,
-0.2073811889,
-0.0244776458,
-0.4715981483,
0.5453023911,
0.194363147,
-0.0877979174,
0.1314270496,
0.5035467148,
-0.8996668458,
0.075655587,
-0.2062432021,
0.7654232383,
0.2021734864,
-0.5493458509,
0.7359105349,
-0.2150961012,
0.6100801229,
-0.5802324414,
0.1216902062,
-0.0037696434,
-0.2227141261,
0.0809322372,
-0.4636793733,
0.1890908778,
0.0478259437,
-0.0873817801,
-0.4796679616,
0.7654338479,
-0.6041227579,
-0.2359232157,
0.3390417397,
0.6335023642,
-0.1853101552,
0.0760969222,
-0.5711955428,
0.2272380888,
-0.0247114897,
-0.0860016793,
0.1497040093,
0.3602845073,
0.1450066864,
0.718303442,
0.7414754033,
-0.0058393306,
0.1378780603,
0.2021107972,
0.5864357948,
-0.6660168171,
-0.8058407903,
-0.8529512286,
0.6278364062,
0.2915811837,
-0.1703694016,
0.5367817283,
0.5663565993,
0.653321743,
0.0893253759,
0.9485331774,
0.3483822942,
0.7131034732,
-0.8171241283,
0.4508787692,
-0.8950889707,
0.1289908737,
-0.3143086731,
-0.7663568258,
0.1557043195,
0.4909241199,
0.2542100549,
-0.0765213519,
0.7781350017,
0.2629058063,
0.2523854971,
0.2490354329,
0.6823945045,
0.0401725732,
0.3162179589,
0.6466244459,
1.3348321915,
-0.6056909561,
0.6888519526,
-0.0292426255,
0.0733508468,
0.0684561059,
-0.7691149712,
-0.8840296268,
-1.028046608,
-0.2953722179,
-0.2463120371,
0.2255993336,
0.7898417711,
0.7989563942,
-0.6006594896,
-0.2764026523,
-0.2327475399,
-0.1397073269,
-0.0215969719,
-0.1568205953,
0.3078311086,
-0.1650377512,
-0.7821872234,
0.6735455394,
0.2154817581,
0.6005614996,
-0.2293867767,
0.0632979497,
0.3904715478,
0.0595103092,
0.7417043447,
0.0356724299,
-1.004945755,
0.0043920046,
0.1830273718,
-0.2400258482,
0.1487357914,
0.8896657228,
-0.9340406656,
0.4519239068,
0.2139219791,
0.5330785513,
0.6782258749,
-0.0362442546,
0.7973732352,
-0.8470234871,
0.0893750116,
0.3527882695,
-0.0020929447,
0.3125141859,
-0.0513881221,
0.2800592184,
-0.1391479075,
-0.465133965,
-1.0029460192,
0.0603540428,
-0.9365758896,
-0.4140073061,
1.1190677881,
0.2906789482,
-0.2784629762,
0.0220182091,
-0.1139919162,
0.6710074544,
-0.3239812553,
0.3280696571,
0.5757436156,
-0.177986294,
-0.0070176269,
-0.6577497721,
0.852816999,
0.49350667,
-0.6254054308,
0.1201970056,
0.5864444375,
0.3362018168,
-0.1371652931,
0.8257161379,
0.0775091872,
0.3781172633,
-0.2235665619,
0.039633587,
-0.1336061954,
-0.2247272432,
-0.3995658755,
0.1364144832,
0.1573421061,
-0.3322130442
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05402v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05402v1
|
Towards Controlled Table-to-Text Generation with Scientific Reasoning
| 2023-12-08T22:57:35 | 2023-12-08T22:57:35 |
Zhixin Guo, Jianping Zhou, Jiexing Qi, Mingxuan Yan, Ziwei He, Guanjie Zheng, Zhouhan Lin, Xinbing Wang, Chenghu Zhou
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The sheer volume of scientific experimental results and complex technical
statements, often presented in tabular formats, presents a formidable barrier
to individuals acquiring preferred information. The realms of scientific
reasoning and content generation that adhere to user preferences encounter
distinct challenges. In this work, we present a new task for generating fluent
and logical descriptions that match user preferences over scientific tabular
data, aiming to automate scientific document analysis. To facilitate research
in this direction, we construct a new challenging dataset CTRLSciTab consisting
of table-description pairs extracted from the scientific literature, with
highlighted cells and corresponding domain-specific knowledge base. We
evaluated popular pre-trained language models to establish a baseline and
proposed a novel architecture outperforming competing approaches. The results
showed that large models struggle to produce accurate content that aligns with
user preferences. As the first of its kind, our work should motivate further
research in scientific domains.
|
[
-0.2472420186,
-0.5463625193,
0.4862075448,
0.218454212,
-0.1798676848,
-0.0223562717,
-0.2302556932,
-0.1434171647,
0.1512230337,
0.7362094522,
-0.286090374,
-0.6617999077,
-0.3324923515,
0.4206303656,
-0.4626631439,
1.3130971193,
-0.3848723471,
-0.1130538583,
-0.5796830058,
0.25689587,
-0.2444857806,
-0.1450108737,
0.0532324314,
-0.0992451087,
0.5835453868,
0.6883351803,
0.7759922743,
0.8606234193,
0.4742554724,
0.284794271,
0.4601357877,
0.575360775,
-0.3496691585,
0.4192337096,
-0.2976949215,
-0.3029044271,
-0.4686373472,
-0.0929596499,
0.5340530276,
0.6401186585,
0.1029102951,
0.0609423779,
-0.0202095211,
0.6095229387,
-0.0537874885,
0.5280748606,
-0.8902071118,
0.3040699959,
-0.4042964578,
-0.469355762,
-0.719666779,
-0.4522499144,
0.1945896298,
-0.9886872172,
0.3960555792,
0.4121409059,
0.9656800032,
0.0981268212,
-0.3386583626,
-0.4885967374,
-0.5213946104,
0.5978206992,
-0.6211263537,
0.4127791524,
0.2030780762,
0.227421239,
-0.5052855611,
-0.995790422,
-0.8208966851,
-0.6146447062,
-0.373206228,
0.1521432996,
-0.0196579881,
-0.1483807713,
0.1016012132,
-0.0931854621,
-0.9639613628,
-0.1399747729,
-0.473374337,
-0.0057620546,
0.6374390125,
0.2677819431,
0.1292815208,
-0.4106341004,
-0.0296901297,
-0.1498876661,
-0.4546330869,
-0.1719793528,
0.0368171893,
0.2183296382,
0.1311916113,
0.9695839286,
-0.362614274,
0.6951588392,
-0.0385433622,
0.1333889812,
-0.09142261,
-0.3647398949,
-0.1446147114,
0.1512781829,
0.8260965943,
0.4679074883,
0.1306566447,
-0.2822372913,
0.0876978859,
0.3456676602,
0.4176634252,
-0.8762969375,
-0.4285021722,
0.1338315159,
-0.0623606481,
-0.4774493277,
-0.0717511922,
-0.8817989826,
-0.2873275578,
-0.3952453732,
-0.043589741,
-0.1687631756,
0.0997438133,
0.0987962186,
-0.054467041,
-0.2383882999,
0.5011518598,
-0.7327675223,
0.2840229273,
0.3249207437,
0.6004776359,
-0.5914291143,
-0.0660210028,
-0.0474603325,
0.6581240296,
-0.3471051753,
0.8530720472,
-0.5059150457,
-0.5924291015,
-0.3277602792,
-0.3003664911,
0.1044865549,
-0.1996029019,
0.4461963475,
-0.5300358534,
0.3590755761,
-0.3456184864,
-0.3836672306,
0.151432991,
0.1074544564,
-0.6515653729,
0.7912915349,
0.2059494555,
-1.0037328005,
0.655969739,
-0.8463386893,
-0.5165371299,
0.4214889705,
-0.6623758078,
-0.3903220892,
-0.1863313168,
-0.0457912274,
0.4810061157,
-0.4561003745,
0.7150495648,
-0.2628957033,
0.3785900176,
0.58492136,
0.1160341874,
0.1503901333,
0.5422327518,
-0.3245494366,
0.3863491118,
-0.726111412,
0.3119146526,
0.1322486401,
-0.1956259608,
-0.0803155899,
0.2015722245,
0.1094416231,
0.095814839,
0.1942747086,
-0.4938042164,
0.2232891768,
0.0122215599,
0.7741037607,
0.4022041559,
-0.1541874409,
0.3931572437,
-0.3101660609,
0.2310685515,
-0.0310405586,
-0.0535730422,
0.0872473121,
-0.0996002927,
-0.4631424844,
-0.0950824395,
0.1776329279,
0.3698218167,
-0.7862318158,
0.3495706022,
-0.440107137,
-0.5793489218,
-0.2248909473,
-0.0111895604,
0.2943895161,
1.3084303141,
0.5823889971,
-0.053956721,
-0.5772910714,
-1.1391348839,
0.1461805105,
-0.0847714543,
0.0278508198,
0.5552785993,
0.5483016372,
-0.1752817184,
1.1992536783,
-0.7463755012,
-0.1354411393,
-0.4004479945,
0.2006519884,
0.0672078878,
0.5310145617,
0.1838048697,
-0.940793395,
-0.6121516824,
0.4596430361,
-0.7978373766,
-0.3179907501,
-0.2671785653,
-0.2649060786,
0.2684781849,
0.2643098533,
-0.7654528022,
0.3106824756,
-0.0702946931,
-0.2605034709,
0.814181447,
-0.1512626112,
0.2939149439,
-0.9801313281,
0.4339376092,
0.221879378,
0.106418632,
-0.6193473339,
-0.0733943507,
-0.0406896211,
-0.0180391278,
-0.353438288,
0.5725479722,
-0.2823207676,
-0.0223214179,
-0.1878314167,
0.2829630971,
0.3899441957,
0.2167910039,
0.6427359581,
0.6779306531,
0.1258962154,
-0.5058780313,
0.1290355921,
0.8306494951,
-0.2111920267,
0.3487234414,
-0.8669695258,
-0.2253173739,
-0.1245325804,
0.4859180748,
-0.6925677061,
-0.6421903372,
0.0422635078,
-0.54856354,
0.2369735092,
0.3742442727,
-0.4895367622,
-0.5852131844,
-0.0715426877,
0.1321351975,
0.2212333083,
-0.1193827093,
0.43259269,
0.249974966,
-0.4589332342,
-0.4901353121,
-0.4588110745,
0.1536849439,
-0.1965432912,
-0.7923375368,
0.6013506055,
0.0383716188,
-0.3703949451,
-0.0814701095,
-0.2745148242,
-0.1477786154,
-0.0882868841,
0.3435823917,
0.5372591019,
0.0512481742,
0.1461693496,
0.5132995248,
0.1918897033,
0.134538278,
-0.3381198943,
0.4053976238,
-0.2354679853,
0.2122359574,
-0.2222310454,
0.4672502279,
0.3634488583,
-0.1929846853,
0.2073385417,
0.3316488862,
-0.1631022543,
-0.5254531503,
-0.2029510587,
-0.1662778854,
-0.5105013847,
0.5059868693,
-0.4411615133,
-0.7272658348,
0.4051370323,
0.2535505593,
0.3051392436,
0.5401473045,
0.5488438606,
-0.3682479858,
0.8942006826,
0.1881630421,
0.4784136117,
-0.1914882511,
0.0349046178,
-0.0693899989,
-0.3503018618,
-0.5572012067,
-0.9522981644,
-0.0541719459,
-0.3708474934,
-0.1618990749,
0.6021402478,
-0.2084291428,
-0.3309153318,
0.3838165104,
-0.9242610335,
0.2921989858,
0.3993992805,
0.0997379273,
0.1948351115,
0.0822438598,
-0.1571999937,
-0.3162828088,
-0.7283554673,
-0.8413276672,
0.9554379582,
0.0779800788,
0.83472085,
-0.3933770955,
0.4461140633,
0.5591608286,
0.4431881011,
-0.3707512915,
0.6100437641,
-0.2019343078,
-0.3859386146,
-0.2894107401,
-0.5571225882,
-0.87651968,
-0.0161783099,
-0.335069865,
-0.3075935543,
-0.1406975836,
0.3754963875,
-0.2107267231,
-0.0396662243,
-0.4830456078,
0.972373426,
-0.4733942747,
-0.6124501228,
0.0362656415,
-0.9334930182,
0.4151257873,
-0.2150825262,
0.1929315478,
0.2747133076,
0.2726514339,
0.7885098457,
-0.4529034793,
0.6575641036,
-0.0732386783,
0.218883723,
0.3230447471,
0.4632571936,
0.3137843013,
0.2541497946,
-0.0927832276,
-0.1876950115,
0.1921306103,
-0.2799213827,
-0.3495276272,
0.8305828571,
-0.631225884,
-0.6777415276,
-0.304315865,
-1.0233460665,
-0.2865843177,
0.3004462719,
0.2314688563,
0.1557313204,
-0.1616168171,
0.0293362718,
0.8494733572,
-0.205521822,
0.0826573297,
0.4124441445,
-0.152957961,
-0.3478659093,
0.7647204399,
-0.0971401632,
0.0557134189,
0.4962622225,
0.1558073461,
-0.4697046876,
-0.839874208,
-0.5275457501,
0.1372263134,
-0.4230546653,
-0.3095216155,
-0.8755017519,
-0.0466566458,
-0.4470555484,
-0.4841645658,
0.0510722436,
-0.71505934,
-0.648194313,
-0.2260164022,
0.2791752219,
0.6751971841,
0.131808579,
0.3030448854,
-0.8773984313,
0.3677510321,
0.0734251067,
0.0328606814,
-0.2116182446,
-0.2833476663,
-0.1685281545,
-0.0718541443,
-0.3872742653,
-0.8412188888,
0.8019895554,
0.2077958286,
0.4193897545,
0.1538985074,
0.0912861526,
0.3448159099,
-0.7610801458,
0.6246472001,
0.2482747883,
-0.7761726379,
0.7327929139,
-0.4379810393,
-0.178330794,
0.7115052938,
0.528087914,
-0.1680266559,
-0.3728380799,
-0.5083842874,
-0.6521852016,
0.3829595745,
0.0235600062,
-0.2382112443,
-0.1610793322,
0.4244164526,
0.6973252296,
0.460414499,
-0.8779740334,
0.2756862938,
-0.73377949,
-0.4414359927,
0.2764587402,
0.2440822423,
-0.3897917271,
-0.0697931945,
0.5469996929,
-0.3229844272,
0.0714713037,
0.322935462,
-0.2261700332,
-0.1821333766,
0.4517234564,
0.7169185281,
0.6142725348,
-0.1567962766,
0.2714204788,
-0.3148777187,
-0.3746471107,
-0.1890580058,
0.2990054488,
-0.4907504916,
-0.0158529989,
0.0096982801,
0.5910506248,
-0.235097006,
-0.7177534103,
0.1490419805,
0.1374425441,
-0.5458758473,
0.0764207095,
0.2070873082,
-0.0029924822,
-0.1546721011,
0.3297302127,
-0.0425313599,
0.1921467632,
-0.2531099617,
0.5018207431,
0.5820951462,
-0.0453990474,
-0.3777023554,
1.0678005219,
0.086967662,
0.1319372058,
0.5107091069,
-0.1646333039,
-0.4227508903,
0.6966937184,
0.6446404457,
0.3853508234,
0.1155770272,
0.625212431,
0.1174572855,
0.0451401286,
0.0420012772,
0.4428266287,
-0.3119823039,
-0.5274161696,
-0.1924053431,
-0.7011727095,
-0.4559892118,
-0.1065288633,
-0.5816632509,
0.2527630627,
-0.3841128051,
-0.1154162437,
0.4827779233,
0.1007019356,
-0.4454394281,
0.257199496,
-0.2492001057,
0.8951106668,
-0.8664204478,
0.9451864362,
0.3232820332,
-0.403708905,
-0.7837452888,
-0.7041789293,
-0.3016210198,
-0.384758383,
1.0725759268,
-0.1307007074,
0.2872301042,
-0.1254792213,
-0.7822829485,
-0.4809364676,
1.0464340448,
-0.0610320382,
-0.5740686655,
-0.3277727365,
0.422285974,
0.8273229003,
-0.6086241007,
0.0836195648,
0.5248078108,
0.9657552242,
0.2032824904,
-0.7528071404,
0.1639530808,
-0.3516723216,
-0.3789909482,
0.061744418,
-0.2655039728,
0.6746717095,
-0.2683584392,
-0.0702401996,
-0.0661505908,
0.9407094717,
0.5383498669,
0.538897872,
0.0745681524,
0.324927479,
0.5607253909,
-0.1281773448,
0.7168337703,
-0.0815776139,
-0.0653951541,
1.3210549355,
-0.7648437619,
0.4363628626,
0.4706991613,
-0.1425970495,
0.2949446738,
0.5931892395,
-0.3698162436,
0.5169223547,
0.4387108982,
-0.0346434265,
-0.0775398687,
-0.3832542896,
-0.4342585504,
0.1384482086,
0.7573615909,
-0.462056905,
-0.3256482184,
-0.1271659136,
0.0686862543,
0.5513027906,
-0.2813453972,
0.5031787157,
-0.1965939999,
-0.7832400799,
0.3041414917,
-0.0814165771,
0.2029417008,
-0.595487535,
-0.0975592509,
-0.0560246445,
-0.4139138758,
-0.4707550406,
-0.8779986501,
0.3211880028,
0.0588658042,
-0.2065267712,
-0.3791248798,
0.6241839528,
-0.6292169094,
-0.161593765,
-0.3547906578,
0.4808402658,
0.1475228667,
0.4698192179,
-0.48843503,
-0.1123689711,
0.3281447887,
-0.1969584972,
0.1470145434,
0.3210012019,
-0.471641928,
0.527692616,
0.5777945518,
0.1334428936,
0.1508047581,
-0.2884315252,
1.0546386242,
-0.4370061159,
-0.5421138406,
-0.4109859765,
0.3717170954,
-0.1341037899,
-0.1638701707,
0.5372886658,
0.7550054193,
0.5446661115,
-0.3912419677,
1.0173099041,
-0.3745887876,
0.4413600862,
-0.2429148406,
0.8984955549,
-0.2500231862,
0.0433998369,
-0.1522256583,
-0.6916796565,
-0.4558334351,
0.3366820812,
-0.0890441611,
-0.2700545192,
0.7301828861,
0.6484404206,
0.0669157952,
0.2335979491,
-0.1566218585,
0.3641049862,
0.5868314505,
0.4463276863,
0.6443221569,
0.1802329272,
0.4084689915,
-0.0322129354,
-0.2899041772,
-0.0149070416,
-1.0143736601,
-0.8283442259,
-0.5990430713,
-0.3043142855,
-0.4703614414,
-0.0724095255,
0.8820285201,
0.4355845153,
-0.8235883713,
-0.1970748156,
-0.3700399697,
-0.1546132416,
0.1929728091,
-0.2805123925,
0.7058281302,
-0.3258687854,
-0.3928291202,
0.2606503665,
0.2307568789,
0.1541669369,
-0.2215772122,
-0.0091728382,
0.1924201101,
0.2177820057,
0.4456854761,
0.5585665703,
-0.4996094108,
0.0503477156,
0.259701848,
-0.4333826303,
0.1533479989,
0.8124306202,
-0.6600443125,
0.3644416332,
0.5068354011,
0.5856006145,
0.7893939018,
-0.0119163273,
0.5378085971,
-0.4570097625,
-0.2990781963,
0.6354395747,
0.0481116585,
0.1961618513,
-0.4486958385,
0.3852095306,
-0.0283756498,
-0.7121556401,
-0.953476131,
0.1789744198,
-1.5995351076,
-0.3200055361,
0.9041934609,
-0.0565415695,
-0.3195770085,
-0.0042092996,
-0.2529664636,
0.2334472537,
-0.5196825266,
1.1961078644,
0.3787152767,
-0.2915700078,
0.250774771,
-0.2879289389,
0.7538658977,
0.3034698069,
-1.355677247,
0.2428773791,
0.8390251994,
-0.0137981288,
0.2260055542,
0.1395415962,
-0.2919206917,
0.3703537881,
-0.2515003681,
0.2272635549,
-0.5894393325,
-0.5719949007,
0.3972103,
0.4264983237,
-0.1334929317,
0.4169175029
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05356v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05356v3
|
Neuron-level LLM Patching for Code Generation
| 2023-12-08T20:28:08 | 2024-04-15T07:31:00 |
Jian Gu, Aldeida Aleti, Chunyang Chen, Hongyu Zhang
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have found widespread adoption in software
engineering, particularly in code generation tasks. However, updating these
models with new knowledge can be prohibitively expensive, yet it is essential
for maximizing their utility. In this paper, we propose a novel and effective
model editing approach, \textsc{MENT}, to patch LLMs in coding tasks.
\textsc{MENT} is effective, efficient, and reliable. It can correct a neural
model by patching 1 or 2 neurons. As the pioneer work on neuron-level model
editing of generative models, we formalize the editing process and introduce
the involved concepts. Besides, we also introduce new measures to evaluate its
generalization ability, and build a benchmark for further study. Our approach
is evaluated on three coding tasks, including API-seq recommendation,
line-level code generation, and pseudocode-to-code transaction. The
experimental results show that the proposed approach outperforms the state of
the arts by a significant margin in both effectiveness and efficiency measures.
In addition, we demonstrate the usages of \textsc{MENT} for LLM reasoning in
software engineering. By editing LLM knowledge, the directly or indirectly
dependent behaviors of API invocation in the chain-of-thought will change
accordingly. It explained the significance of repairing LLMs.
|
[
-0.0770131275,
-0.5869393945,
0.3159277737,
0.4921680987,
-0.0002498643,
0.1204489842,
-0.0905965418,
-0.3019129038,
0.2260340899,
0.4196335971,
-0.3703211546,
-0.5341402888,
-0.1340430081,
0.0016141302,
-0.3044182062,
0.7475471497,
-0.1838948131,
0.1146593094,
-0.1607450843,
0.0687628612,
-0.6648187041,
-0.6546536684,
-0.8170316219,
-0.4483652115,
0.462323308,
-0.0307272803,
0.4236503839,
0.5204181671,
0.4161255658,
0.3614874184,
-0.5255901814,
0.453094691,
-0.1863164455,
-0.0684879944,
-0.1900929809,
-0.6506608129,
-1.1692875624,
-0.3015684485,
0.2973317504,
0.4480653405,
-0.2401754558,
-0.1648012996,
0.1084152684,
0.7674531341,
-0.3625611961,
-0.1489086896,
-0.8718912601,
0.0928065106,
0.0985022634,
-0.3766291142,
-0.4738987386,
-0.1604474187,
-0.4263222218,
-0.5420567989,
0.2013199031,
-0.2393185049,
0.5038291216,
0.4389810264,
0.0509037413,
-0.0241581164,
-0.5380421877,
0.543325901,
-1.1958836317,
-0.0886699334,
0.409740746,
0.0336401276,
-0.5594676733,
-0.6104524136,
-0.3129807115,
-0.3033603132,
0.1723220348,
-0.1155561358,
-0.3307632208,
0.1744271666,
0.6491326094,
0.4005645514,
-0.1915997267,
0.0867496729,
-0.3398886919,
-0.4711140394,
0.5092008114,
0.1008825824,
0.8080407977,
-0.1664800197,
-0.1637761295,
0.3282959759,
-1.0437549353,
-0.3037998378,
0.5482032299,
-0.1191329136,
0.1960937679,
0.672872901,
-0.2591519952,
0.9001682997,
0.1055113375,
0.1502856612,
0.0745236203,
-0.186138019,
-0.3588873446,
-0.2922904789,
0.4588342309,
0.5806490779,
0.171813339,
-0.1666618437,
-0.767724812,
-0.0042675789,
0.5834647417,
-0.3929790854,
-0.3506470919,
0.1426563859,
-0.3375222385,
-0.4957329035,
-0.5391931534,
-0.2584696412,
-0.5448842645,
-0.4531946778,
0.3817020655,
-0.5290378332,
-0.1830099672,
0.256659925,
-0.0322835892,
-0.0774351433,
0.5051059127,
-0.8986502886,
-0.213086307,
0.6865298748,
0.9684610367,
0.252253741,
-0.4362412691,
-0.3672466278,
0.0811711922,
-0.5704193115,
0.8722596765,
-0.1845794916,
-0.1208991334,
-0.2482181937,
-0.3293541074,
0.2190184891,
-0.7108649015,
0.0088515747,
-0.7387558222,
-0.309949398,
-0.1474409848,
-0.5785114765,
0.1848687381,
0.4006006718,
-0.5203134418,
0.8720393777,
0.2356110364,
-0.6322838068,
0.1305330843,
-0.8169621229,
-0.5012453794,
-0.2035003752,
0.008199526,
-0.273640871,
0.2237157226,
0.4636259079,
0.3750076294,
-0.1048055142,
0.346378684,
-0.0769607127,
-0.280757755,
0.5711202621,
-0.1557757258,
0.5524346828,
0.133824423,
-0.2285417467,
0.428624928,
-0.760329783,
-0.0499669872,
-0.1775636226,
-0.5816687942,
-0.2826777399,
0.0015598038,
-0.0730393305,
0.2062246203,
0.1650677323,
-0.4847910702,
0.6731975079,
-0.5107656717,
1.0511463881,
1.1279329062,
0.1009910852,
0.5922591686,
-0.4508413076,
0.4287011325,
-0.1679906845,
0.3297035098,
-0.200893566,
-0.3528581858,
-0.8143249154,
-0.2529437542,
0.5164222121,
0.3788343966,
-1.0741710663,
0.209594056,
0.1792178005,
-0.4525810778,
-0.3701581359,
0.2357039452,
0.3012390435,
0.2742082179,
0.5496860147,
-0.1018656045,
-0.5029513836,
-0.8528655171,
-0.3973394632,
0.0343640745,
-0.2223658264,
0.1571510136,
0.3539871275,
-0.2567278147,
0.8498874307,
-0.5362918377,
-0.1497752666,
-0.155441165,
0.2089585811,
0.3260353506,
0.8714078665,
0.3953552246,
-0.243034184,
-0.1582150459,
-0.0732735693,
-0.8021970391,
-0.3056332767,
-0.5040757656,
-0.187273562,
0.1480314434,
0.8331096768,
-0.4955275357,
0.3801843822,
0.4082222581,
-0.2130170465,
0.470630765,
-0.7554523945,
0.2019417882,
-1.0033017397,
-0.257725507,
-0.1532395482,
-0.1459117979,
-0.7154217958,
0.3248144388,
0.2950989604,
0.0149103403,
-0.5201364756,
0.2881437838,
-0.7134728432,
-0.1705226749,
-0.6240301132,
-0.2565325499,
-0.228322506,
0.6329586506,
-0.4347223043,
0.8204728961,
0.5159264803,
-0.5587660074,
0.320632875,
0.1053407192,
-0.4408526421,
0.4614762664,
-0.9050297141,
0.5931683183,
-0.0141071724,
0.1508455127,
-0.585465312,
-0.0301216878,
0.1119801477,
-0.3777614236,
0.2313938737,
-0.2187193781,
-0.678755641,
0.0373694114,
-0.1787679493,
0.4349069297,
0.4163015187,
-0.5639512539,
0.7971940637,
0.2890225649,
-0.0016330348,
-0.4376641214,
-0.8531801701,
0.4043575525,
0.0854457244,
-0.8268480301,
0.5145823956,
-0.2277540118,
-0.1500885785,
-0.0483587496,
-0.160752058,
-0.0644728094,
0.182498157,
0.0944249406,
0.3597112,
-0.171644032,
-0.0097239595,
0.2837296724,
-0.3472246528,
-0.1513012499,
-0.1753935516,
0.5595426559,
0.0819790363,
-0.5875191689,
-0.0917783231,
0.0673125461,
0.5328242183,
-0.3680995405,
0.20156461,
0.2566109598,
-0.5772053599,
-0.4972117841,
-0.5645945072,
-0.3854690492,
-0.4547032714,
0.482545644,
-0.4906535745,
-0.8178415298,
0.4232200384,
-0.3819774985,
0.1985340416,
0.3091986775,
0.2412596792,
-0.2089903057,
0.788651228,
0.6488913298,
-0.1775422096,
0.4050954878,
-0.3724155426,
0.2356798947,
-1.1434445381,
0.1577540189,
-0.2754997015,
-0.6801041365,
-0.1384777576,
-0.7626179457,
0.2557625771,
0.5210591555,
0.0474743433,
0.488571167,
-0.6226450801,
0.7033302784,
0.5965387225,
0.4431353211,
0.405290395,
0.0561808348,
-0.0073450082,
0.0402041078,
-0.7653128505,
-0.394924134,
1.0613799095,
0.2121357918,
0.7621790171,
0.0285553411,
0.6234659553,
0.4546718597,
0.4214200079,
-0.3804776967,
0.7337132692,
-0.2114901245,
-0.363150686,
-0.2248723805,
-0.2689270377,
-0.4152090251,
0.0548608676,
-0.2606979907,
-0.480163455,
0.2395020574,
0.5454003811,
-0.2195875347,
0.7779342532,
-0.6093694568,
0.4969334006,
-0.0534525514,
-0.2924470305,
-0.5646401048,
-0.2427535653,
0.2717255354,
-0.1580679417,
0.0576912016,
0.1735759825,
-0.0337277874,
0.4238761663,
-0.5722962618,
0.994808197,
-0.1276392937,
-0.2166420817,
0.1769861579,
0.1220058352,
0.760114789,
0.00258527,
-0.1386099905,
0.3115055859,
-0.4559805095,
-0.3741742671,
-0.8075153828,
0.6311323643,
-0.5191209316,
-0.3850618899,
-0.2065293789,
-0.936714828,
-0.0523266532,
-0.1593131423,
0.1987587512,
0.5714130998,
0.1010122597,
-0.2065444142,
0.6581348777,
-0.6821696162,
0.3977315724,
0.3403196931,
-0.3667129278,
-0.5791199207,
1.033043623,
0.1765565127,
0.3876751661,
0.1776295006,
-0.0682063103,
0.3952766955,
-0.7974042892,
-0.5744948983,
0.1170060337,
-0.6502954364,
-0.3276047111,
-0.6366619468,
-0.3747303784,
-0.1111225039,
-0.4466949701,
-0.3265157938,
-0.3870718777,
-0.1993206143,
-0.0032151763,
0.3892337084,
0.9049403071,
-0.3645196855,
0.3328969181,
-0.6317510605,
0.4963572919,
0.3111588061,
0.411197722,
0.0587884635,
-0.3170939684,
-0.2302032262,
0.1211320311,
-0.2564738989,
-0.9014727473,
0.1030783653,
-0.1934692115,
0.5658664703,
-0.189940393,
-0.3365780413,
0.5736868382,
-0.5376862288,
0.7248418331,
0.2818561792,
-1.2216421366,
0.5819239616,
-0.3149183393,
0.2637590468,
0.0214166082,
-0.3551937342,
-0.6603800654,
-0.5251033306,
-0.4279200733,
-0.9188315272,
0.6614118218,
0.12475501,
0.3125089407,
0.0175677687,
0.6714179516,
-0.2882994115,
0.1559492648,
-0.6246933341,
-0.1739670485,
-0.0936209261,
0.0474277586,
0.2469505519,
-0.5099318027,
0.0848373696,
-0.4037935436,
0.8844796419,
-0.1109740734,
0.3028072119,
0.1874661297,
-0.3635254502,
0.1019921303,
0.5006502867,
1.0260326862,
0.8360956907,
-0.0739851221,
-0.0040896609,
0.2928067446,
-0.1961331815,
0.0944735706,
-0.3907187879,
-0.5390042067,
-0.1060571969,
0.3209681809,
0.7519901991,
0.1134541035,
-0.4682510197,
0.2374283969,
0.2049670368,
-0.4741686285,
0.1326119453,
0.15928334,
0.3186269999,
0.5272685289,
-0.0172262862,
0.6730315685,
-0.0727721453,
-0.2642804682,
0.0240052268,
0.2380486131,
-0.2519720495,
-0.1892405301,
0.5120792985,
0.0732039586,
-0.5279340744,
0.570319891,
-0.1633685678,
-0.4835098088,
0.807477951,
0.6644775867,
1.0308502913,
-0.2543037832,
0.1546078473,
0.3880419731,
0.6609222889,
-0.1512894332,
0.379861623,
0.2965674102,
-0.6444572806,
-0.8533678055,
-0.4573274255,
-0.1309518963,
0.1569960713,
-0.0444847681,
0.271561563,
-0.6974611282,
-0.1795128137,
-0.1056197956,
-0.9154883623,
-0.0887835845,
0.0298236478,
-0.2259743512,
0.9230285287,
-0.5771650672,
0.9198777676,
0.9210455418,
-0.503025949,
-0.9134818316,
-0.0971373618,
-0.1731274724,
-0.6563823819,
0.5495174527,
-0.2334038466,
0.1063604057,
0.0000072155,
-0.6721999645,
-0.5691308975,
0.8530371785,
0.5258384347,
-0.8081351519,
-0.0908770412,
-0.1035348326,
0.6318894625,
-0.2885549664,
0.2148266137,
0.2966089249,
0.3143466711,
-0.0245613977,
-0.6232882738,
-0.0139654912,
-0.5262723565,
0.2727082968,
0.2918855846,
-0.2008570582,
0.993403554,
-0.3964823186,
0.2327642739,
0.1311501712,
0.6420109272,
0.2021392584,
0.0003232626,
0.6541308165,
0.5722911358,
0.688023746,
0.0895026773,
0.8362891674,
-0.4914493561,
0.2737529576,
1.2761156559,
-0.0605583265,
0.7239695191,
0.6095323563,
-0.1727094054,
0.2604288459,
0.4969926476,
-0.2912534773,
0.4014849663,
0.8253272176,
-0.1682728231,
-0.252196908,
0.1846034527,
-0.4025908411,
0.0229918025,
-0.035560105,
-0.3484409153,
-0.0887407735,
0.1765684783,
0.1134195626,
0.0555321649,
-0.3343400657,
0.8747094274,
0.1259778738,
-0.5161965489,
0.5022730231,
0.3991267085,
0.7856924534,
-0.341291368,
-0.311298579,
-0.4429167509,
0.2627633214,
-0.4617823362,
-0.5739788413,
0.4965990484,
0.3005785942,
-0.4507807493,
-0.2859756649,
0.9120723009,
-0.2772495449,
-0.4085768461,
0.2545763254,
0.2558036447,
0.0922773704,
-0.4709920883,
-0.590069592,
-0.091093719,
0.2408193797,
-0.0208761916,
0.3830801249,
0.1851170063,
0.0208902657,
0.5804097652,
0.9132739305,
0.4391082525,
0.2176389247,
0.2411792278,
1.0852864981,
-0.6517995,
-0.3137681186,
-0.9211627245,
0.7010704279,
-0.1070992574,
-0.1990604699,
0.3936608732,
0.4253853858,
0.6245788932,
-0.2750345767,
0.8676891923,
-0.1068606153,
0.0862012804,
-0.7927181721,
0.7959990501,
-0.502809763,
0.7923701406,
-0.3369342387,
-1.0446221828,
-0.3186336458,
0.5583198071,
-0.346821785,
-0.1235285625,
0.6948427558,
1.3050335646,
-0.0813944414,
-0.0346650667,
0.3542978168,
0.4945031404,
0.3797124624,
0.7161177397,
1.1481841803,
-0.446515888,
0.1986920536,
-0.3535351753,
-0.380622983,
0.1829863936,
-0.9590395689,
-0.8899747133,
-0.2546214163,
-0.4813157618,
-0.400629878,
0.1279583573,
0.9817180634,
0.5120846033,
-0.4866632819,
-0.1331332475,
-0.4130546451,
0.1216739789,
-0.5423189998,
-0.0716747344,
0.3706893623,
-0.6517628431,
-0.4205658138,
0.6031735539,
0.5627986193,
-0.2328641117,
-0.2166181207,
-0.1796083748,
-0.2394998372,
0.0336633883,
0.6217788458,
-0.0260267202,
-0.7104702592,
-0.0802138373,
0.209636867,
-0.1086473912,
0.1533471197,
1.1292695999,
-0.4060467184,
0.4182525277,
0.58900249,
0.8663207293,
0.3228626251,
-0.4109710157,
0.7650816441,
-0.7375031114,
-0.155142501,
-0.0167808365,
0.5492742062,
0.4257635772,
-0.3862657249,
0.5552353859,
0.2682685256,
-0.710812211,
-0.7324566841,
0.1680413336,
-0.8538325429,
-0.4483657479,
1.1379144192,
-0.1692380756,
-0.2132923901,
0.0194736794,
-0.5589234233,
0.2481696904,
-0.1310094744,
0.8050793409,
0.6080238819,
0.0338597037,
-0.0444126539,
-0.5535557866,
0.2723961174,
0.4510670304,
-0.9610263109,
0.0066668387,
0.5854740143,
0.4211457968,
0.0586574748,
0.7936913967,
-0.132087931,
0.4228197634,
-0.1306468695,
0.6317853928,
-0.3184747398,
-0.1687553525,
-0.3800631762,
0.0070361057,
0.2138949186,
-0.046798069
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07559v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07559v2
|
PaperQA: Retrieval-Augmented Generative Agent for Scientific Research
| 2023-12-08T18:50:20 | 2023-12-14T19:40:04 |
Jakub Lála, Odhran O'Donoghue, Aleksandar Shtedritski, Sam Cox, Samuel G. Rodriques, Andrew D. White
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) generalize well across language tasks, but
suffer from hallucinations and uninterpretability, making it difficult to
assess their accuracy without ground-truth. Retrieval-Augmented Generation
(RAG) models have been proposed to reduce hallucinations and provide provenance
for how an answer was generated. Applying such models to the scientific
literature may enable large-scale, systematic processing of scientific
knowledge. We present PaperQA, a RAG agent for answering questions over the
scientific literature. PaperQA is an agent that performs information retrieval
across full-text scientific articles, assesses the relevance of sources and
passages, and uses RAG to provide answers. Viewing this agent as a question
answering model, we find it exceeds performance of existing LLMs and LLM agents
on current science QA benchmarks. To push the field closer to how humans
perform research on scientific literature, we also introduce LitQA, a more
complex benchmark that requires retrieval and synthesis of information from
full-text scientific papers across the literature. Finally, we demonstrate
PaperQA's matches expert human researchers on LitQA.
|
[
-0.2113870233,
-0.5614225864,
0.9086632133,
-0.0653041825,
-0.1384460479,
0.5250287056,
0.1057589427,
-0.4706339538,
0.4749678075,
0.585724473,
-0.0811887011,
-0.2731205821,
-0.3957887292,
0.297917515,
-0.6039127111,
0.970289886,
-0.0030151168,
0.0319873355,
-0.5751318932,
0.0867595747,
0.4135588706,
-0.3518833816,
-0.6254867911,
-0.5165191889,
0.9307532907,
0.047551617,
0.8909004331,
0.2376749367,
0.5779346228,
0.3448245525,
-0.3003446758,
0.5497219563,
-0.2695040405,
0.301459074,
-0.3556885421,
-0.6121564507,
-0.5582020283,
0.2138227671,
0.6100595593,
0.6245152354,
-0.1323279887,
0.2758975029,
-0.2547704875,
0.5622817278,
-0.6200644374,
-0.1386293173,
-0.5836623907,
-0.0790009648,
0.006995616,
-0.4935869277,
-0.5259582996,
-0.4644257128,
-0.0544822514,
-0.9763721228,
0.4910363257,
0.0764793009,
0.816203177,
0.3963213861,
-0.4337605536,
-0.4629637599,
-0.7179220319,
0.4417789578,
-0.4598046839,
0.2323323041,
0.471879214,
0.3042825162,
-0.3415383101,
-1.1558212042,
-0.777923882,
-0.4850786924,
-0.0326403901,
0.2260546088,
0.0651283562,
-0.0566628724,
0.3400440514,
0.2085658461,
-0.66550982,
-0.4999341369,
-0.4374670088,
-0.0536161028,
0.5181586742,
-0.003395688,
0.2927797437,
-0.3118649721,
-0.1052113324,
-0.1467225552,
-0.4454716444,
-0.0003153815,
-0.0545315705,
0.031522505,
0.5077682734,
0.7557092309,
-0.2607468665,
0.6468062997,
-0.0414963886,
-0.0937954038,
0.1024807319,
-0.1229634508,
0.0052061435,
-0.0752012953,
0.5694103837,
0.0548100621,
-0.2881718278,
-0.4579752982,
-0.2692973912,
-0.080186598,
0.4563772678,
-0.9054710865,
-0.2345803231,
0.2333438993,
-0.1727209687,
-0.2402049303,
0.0243298449,
-0.7665544152,
-0.8481467366,
-0.1212745532,
0.7448734045,
-0.0988069549,
-0.2876225412,
0.0409836657,
-0.2019833624,
0.2991383374,
0.5134757757,
-0.3234447837,
0.2493055314,
0.6585059762,
0.9525499344,
-0.1849849969,
-0.1565294266,
-0.6745141745,
0.2205772102,
-0.6501705647,
0.996316731,
-0.5134302378,
-0.3501646221,
-0.3173013628,
-0.0816867352,
0.11787159,
-0.5743408799,
0.7136712074,
-1.1065635681,
0.3260222077,
-0.3736491203,
-0.3279476464,
-0.3117888272,
0.1239564791,
-0.8658832312,
0.9125164747,
0.104043588,
-0.9741919041,
0.1407017857,
-0.7230986953,
-0.0496695787,
0.3748083115,
-0.1196576282,
-0.272307843,
0.05100004,
0.1111280173,
0.2220636904,
-0.5991741419,
0.345398128,
-0.1238638535,
-0.4016069472,
0.4755341709,
-0.138327226,
0.8036900163,
0.4437895119,
-0.0868271291,
0.0631167889,
-0.6796152592,
0.142478168,
0.0640682131,
-0.3128925562,
-0.500369668,
-0.0226921234,
0.0758345798,
-0.0992853492,
0.1697378755,
-0.680549562,
0.3738329411,
-0.1888174117,
0.397262156,
0.2931976914,
0.0991657302,
0.4510288537,
-0.7570872307,
0.5869993567,
-0.4202978909,
-0.1828359514,
0.185207054,
-0.4353545606,
-0.7279111147,
-0.3208371699,
0.5459321737,
0.4584724605,
-1.3028928041,
-0.0355512314,
-0.2277342677,
-0.6266527772,
-0.8411642313,
-0.030421285,
0.2110421062,
0.6618002057,
0.4218812585,
0.1057771966,
-0.4958376586,
-0.6668413877,
-0.3111438453,
-0.3376844525,
-0.3371318281,
0.1273426265,
0.6139486432,
-0.3033621013,
0.9274671674,
-0.3958074152,
-0.0292664617,
0.1885873079,
0.6246016622,
0.1944154501,
0.0645048916,
0.1892517358,
-1.3045367002,
-0.3360149264,
0.0497720204,
-0.8865343332,
-0.3738435507,
-0.1356441528,
0.039003551,
0.2858852744,
0.5462098718,
-0.8704875112,
0.3244406581,
0.5118896961,
-0.4954943955,
0.684518218,
-0.1884648055,
0.4934746027,
-1.0184457302,
0.4468539655,
-0.4455522597,
-0.3027150035,
-0.692489922,
0.2508645058,
0.0590955354,
-0.0001864076,
-0.1893772632,
0.7745989561,
-0.5367397666,
-0.267067641,
-0.6200042367,
0.1299030483,
0.3856543899,
-0.0375229791,
0.117291145,
1.4061590433,
0.1080774739,
-0.4423817694,
0.1456525773,
0.1490386128,
-0.3090025187,
0.2324899882,
-0.7041010261,
0.3820616603,
-0.3203945756,
0.2505557239,
-0.7798981071,
-0.2493312508,
0.0383524187,
-0.6690923572,
0.0625285879,
0.3249155581,
-0.6700002551,
-0.247809276,
-0.1531916261,
0.3736123741,
0.4601081908,
-0.583249867,
1.0501395464,
0.2360780239,
-0.3382326365,
-0.6190446019,
-0.2949819267,
0.3829488456,
-0.109905839,
-0.4585230052,
0.5411782861,
-0.2396789491,
-0.4833164811,
0.2109892964,
-0.1034841686,
-0.1753666699,
-0.0515698567,
0.1910808533,
0.2126381695,
0.0486347005,
0.2416044176,
-0.0814653859,
0.1179262325,
0.2280724496,
0.0420288071,
0.2219318002,
-0.2234084606,
-0.0403077081,
0.1042503193,
0.3304120302,
0.681684792,
-0.1471575648,
0.4907145202,
0.4721415043,
-0.3556246161,
-0.1086180285,
-0.7291082144,
-0.2068126947,
-0.5175619721,
0.2373820096,
-0.553093195,
-0.8220307827,
0.6035534739,
-0.0402340628,
-0.1290259808,
0.4213809371,
0.3383953273,
-0.3753660619,
0.900867939,
0.382915765,
0.364220649,
0.0581585206,
-0.2224146575,
-0.1352255195,
-0.9763845205,
-0.2916609347,
-0.8122899532,
0.1187515259,
-0.3694025278,
-0.8218906522,
0.6476905346,
0.2774665952,
-0.3124422431,
-0.0529000685,
-0.8218058944,
0.4783633649,
0.6067478657,
0.1053935364,
0.6599123478,
-0.0036389004,
0.0214217342,
0.099547416,
-0.5836200714,
-0.7745749354,
0.9382336736,
0.1373283416,
0.8231576085,
0.079352811,
0.5689554214,
0.4265581965,
0.696243763,
-0.5766658783,
0.645101428,
0.101019986,
-0.8529190421,
-0.2740722001,
-0.5980607271,
-0.9826087952,
0.4156675041,
-0.3593186438,
-0.2979286015,
0.1861958504,
-0.2928857803,
-0.2120523602,
0.32781443,
-0.3265953362,
0.2590891421,
-0.2796407342,
-0.3422157466,
0.0126155624,
-0.4429500401,
0.4636439681,
-0.3498489857,
0.2038670629,
0.2555892169,
-0.3835925758,
0.9475151896,
-0.1115513891,
0.5019952655,
-0.1218869314,
-0.0438168682,
0.4040122628,
0.2455756217,
0.4369276464,
0.2264924645,
-0.2178001851,
-0.2714926302,
0.4004609585,
-0.4904572666,
-0.7068350315,
0.5001710057,
-0.8833243847,
-0.8823658228,
-0.9078689814,
-0.7406437993,
-0.2561450601,
0.1824510843,
0.180076763,
-0.23513484,
-0.0415655039,
0.2640698552,
0.8089523911,
-0.2199319005,
0.2217979878,
0.8090596199,
-0.5968528986,
-0.5223198533,
0.7274858356,
0.0232239254,
0.0126865888,
0.3317767084,
0.0271197129,
-0.3162367344,
-0.7011487484,
-0.1218676642,
0.392246753,
-0.5512008071,
-0.3669470847,
-0.8479661942,
-0.5275925398,
-0.2317920774,
-0.0515364073,
-0.1106696799,
-0.446849525,
-0.4604043067,
0.0467447937,
0.4224746823,
0.6685903072,
-0.1228922829,
0.1200508699,
-0.7054803967,
0.8417631388,
0.6983007789,
0.1508002579,
-0.211863935,
-0.747626543,
-0.0213541556,
0.0414494872,
-0.1390774995,
-1.0038671494,
0.4132528305,
0.1867047101,
0.4217525423,
-0.0334339589,
0.1758027226,
0.4325315952,
-0.4388267398,
0.6470377445,
-0.0585766435,
-0.739192009,
0.1688037068,
-0.5367721915,
0.2051241547,
0.562903285,
0.5741578937,
-0.4459037483,
-0.349293381,
-0.3626398146,
-0.5780271292,
0.2924066186,
0.0833991468,
-0.1771472394,
0.2236046791,
0.719835043,
0.0579445474,
0.2237250507,
-0.7656792402,
0.198495537,
-0.2300527841,
0.2111798376,
-0.008205547,
-0.2901151776,
-0.4613616765,
-0.1602954417,
0.7275108695,
-0.3860369325,
0.2142026871,
0.6471071243,
0.002074278,
-0.4122971296,
0.2457732856,
0.5138130188,
0.9155632854,
-0.4762164652,
0.3155682981,
-0.1310637891,
-0.6279527545,
0.2152579576,
0.455593884,
-0.7202467918,
0.0288760215,
0.3531423509,
0.324301213,
-0.487924099,
-0.7199151516,
0.1401970088,
-0.2285289466,
-0.5539517403,
-0.3876667023,
0.0529000498,
0.3092555404,
0.464242965,
1.105386138,
-0.1467358172,
0.5015347004,
-0.4852963686,
0.3563275039,
0.5653819442,
-0.0601283461,
-0.1788782626,
0.8067754507,
-0.0359201208,
-0.4772269428,
0.2694542408,
-0.3721840382,
-0.5466651917,
0.6709571481,
0.3722716272,
0.7512119412,
-0.0724763721,
0.8519806266,
0.1750815511,
0.3696227968,
0.0122203082,
0.5746430755,
0.1727350652,
-0.4246861041,
-0.7167165279,
-0.785110414,
-0.7628997564,
0.2667340934,
-0.5195406079,
-0.0984734967,
-0.2439981848,
-0.2241940498,
0.2898676395,
0.3302733004,
-0.3035351634,
0.1199753508,
-0.0043899133,
0.8852069974,
-0.5877515674,
0.8911762238,
0.9678405523,
-0.4448776245,
-0.6297441125,
-0.1421560943,
-0.3089905977,
-0.3041481078,
0.7748736143,
-0.1842700839,
-0.1923502535,
-0.0655835122,
-0.8501424789,
-0.9498026371,
1.2419739962,
0.3412940502,
-0.1701551378,
-0.1856755614,
0.0262217037,
0.9927477837,
-0.355068773,
0.4174930751,
0.255925566,
0.5329973102,
0.4110252857,
-0.79465276,
0.1379591972,
-0.4754495621,
-0.0856398568,
0.0006725884,
-0.5836192966,
0.9577105641,
-0.1275104135,
-0.1632797271,
0.3041923642,
0.8085906506,
0.6304354072,
0.730543077,
0.4383202791,
0.4504217207,
0.8766670227,
0.04306769,
0.7701847553,
-0.0216818359,
0.1324389279,
1.1066907644,
-0.3713113964,
0.7857690454,
0.6133714914,
-0.1278408915,
0.5629089475,
0.5955193639,
0.0957150608,
0.4606841505,
0.1415337473,
-0.4963879883,
-0.1497526169,
-0.3684554696,
-0.4361103773,
0.2837823927,
0.4912397861,
-0.1636194736,
-0.086074017,
0.0923752338,
-0.1583520621,
0.4159318507,
-0.293713659,
0.6679486632,
0.0552131943,
-0.8354663849,
0.8203057051,
-0.158327058,
0.361250788,
-0.4337270856,
-0.3186756968,
-0.3648519814,
-0.3032574654,
-0.1871649921,
-0.6590216756,
0.2517236173,
-0.022457242,
-0.3206813037,
-0.0505438708,
0.6944589019,
-0.4014934897,
-0.4427974522,
0.1790351719,
0.6151638031,
0.2497895062,
-0.0848359242,
-0.6895524859,
-0.1488813609,
-0.223223716,
-0.5259255171,
0.2003489733,
0.3991101384,
-0.0656074882,
0.9021624327,
0.7044945359,
0.4054243565,
0.0110053774,
-0.2830997109,
1.0711238384,
-0.6291567087,
-0.078536883,
-0.0996785238,
0.2037886679,
-0.1193081811,
0.1048951149,
0.545106113,
0.5113368034,
0.4124855697,
-0.0444252454,
0.7212756276,
-0.1167466044,
0.9587183595,
-0.3706648946,
0.9266597033,
-0.7643660903,
0.25646016,
-0.0001142427,
-1.1110591888,
-0.3038217425,
0.4902781546,
-0.1454575956,
0.0489826687,
0.734397769,
0.8861009479,
0.150431022,
-0.0462828055,
0.274444133,
0.317178458,
0.4429370165,
0.284530282,
1.0280045271,
-0.3963635266,
0.5571735501,
-0.0349013172,
-0.261970818,
0.0483060479,
-0.8386012912,
-0.9930470586,
-0.8378382325,
-0.1419203281,
-0.5220503211,
0.3946350217,
0.5972570777,
0.4239322841,
-0.6781007051,
-0.063873753,
0.0675468445,
0.0218524616,
0.0135940854,
-0.278234452,
0.6114158034,
-0.3348302841,
-0.6908379197,
0.4340845346,
0.030128032,
-0.0199090783,
-0.3994624913,
-0.085991472,
-0.538744688,
0.3309694529,
0.3384447694,
0.5867649317,
-0.7194825411,
-0.0853244364,
0.3420935571,
-0.4004864991,
-0.1403096467,
0.6889178157,
-1.002520442,
0.6342719197,
0.6189970374,
0.9756539464,
0.7524086833,
0.2010616362,
0.2614853978,
-0.3279472589,
-0.0697660372,
0.7609878778,
-0.117458418,
0.3517847955,
-0.4072805941,
0.8653645515,
-0.0393645093,
-0.9992993474,
-1.0818228722,
-0.113512449,
-0.9768184423,
-0.5120439529,
1.1184905767,
0.0150049068,
-0.3473780155,
-0.158254534,
-0.2813078463,
0.2196663767,
-0.2684608698,
1.1568709612,
0.6310065985,
-0.0651713833,
-0.3754139245,
-0.7299365401,
0.8245768547,
0.5751541257,
-0.9297847152,
-0.1199814975,
0.5484204292,
-0.0410316773,
0.6246516705,
0.7616032958,
0.0615824237,
0.53903234,
-0.0591330454,
0.2583077848,
-0.1530688256,
-0.4796912372,
-0.0774902776,
0.3181648552,
0.3678123057,
0.3035872877
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05235v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05235v2
|
Generative AI in Higher Education: Seeing ChatGPT Through Universities' Policies, Resources, and Guidelines
| 2023-12-08T18:33:11 | 2024-03-05T05:49:24 |
Hui Wang, Anh Dang, Zihao Wu, Son Mac
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY
|
The advancements in Generative Artificial Intelligence (GenAI) technologies
such as ChatGPT provide opportunities to enrich educational experiences, but
also raise concerns about academic integrity if misused. This study aims to
explore how universities and educators respond and adapt to the development of
GenAI in their academic contexts by analyzing academic policies and guidelines
established by top-ranked US universities regarding the use of ChatGPT in
higher education. The data sources include academic policies, statements,
guidelines as well as relevant resources provided by the top 100 universities
in the US. Results show that the majority of these universities adopt an open
but cautious approach towards the integration of GenAI. Primary concerns lie in
ethical usage, accuracy, and data privacy. Most universities actively respond
and provide diverse types of resources, such as syllabus templates/samples,
workshops, shared articles, and one-on-one consultations, with topics focusing
on general technical introduction, ethical concerns, pedagogical applications,
preventive strategies, data privacy, limitations, and detective tools. The
findings provide two suggestions for educators in policy-making: establish
discipline-specific policies, and manage sensitive information carefully, as
well as four implications for educators in teaching practices: accept its
presence, align its use with learning objectives, evolve curriculum to prevent
misuse, and adopt multifaceted evaluation strategies rather than relying on AI
detectors.
|
[
-0.3186291456,
-0.7539798021,
0.2543506026,
-0.1215349808,
0.066136688,
0.3594093323,
-0.2015866637,
-0.2420196831,
-0.3408157527,
0.2196443677,
-0.3316474557,
-0.1151491404,
-0.5025807619,
-0.0329722762,
-0.4582488239,
1.3794052601,
-0.084776409,
0.0782339349,
-0.3677080572,
-0.08492174,
-0.5746290684,
-0.5720484853,
-0.720923543,
-0.4725291431,
0.3524589539,
0.4712823331,
1.0010186434,
0.1321410835,
0.8147206903,
0.2584147751,
0.0030536186,
-0.1559033394,
-0.493947953,
-0.1025088504,
-0.1411701888,
-0.5479056239,
-0.2009359747,
0.2707034647,
0.8045418262,
0.4294240177,
-0.3084647059,
0.1057160422,
0.5435467362,
0.5330454111,
-0.6043855548,
0.2020388842,
-0.0888327286,
0.4222691059,
-0.3149389029,
-0.1557185352,
-0.3855404556,
-0.6867979169,
0.3477257192,
-0.8783088326,
0.1795598865,
-0.2612223625,
0.6546063423,
0.3438423276,
-0.1311417967,
-0.1111122295,
-0.8047281504,
0.6201613545,
-0.1856016666,
0.3898027241,
0.3698712289,
0.3611386418,
-0.3466969728,
-0.8545320034,
-0.4375293255,
-0.0117073664,
-0.0032579168,
0.4627621472,
-0.1667336076,
0.3032307625,
0.2794141173,
0.4732956886,
-0.5760629773,
0.0102908136,
-0.5147643685,
-0.2635944486,
0.4538218677,
-0.0762844309,
0.4536578357,
0.136746332,
-0.3315408826,
-0.3564759791,
-0.7239303589,
-0.0422363169,
0.653624177,
-0.1519803703,
0.0485298,
0.4696025252,
0.090197973,
0.1730930209,
-0.3314957023,
0.4935622811,
-0.0278172828,
-0.4564110339,
-0.2078823447,
-0.0496476032,
0.8979817033,
0.1191721931,
0.6329684854,
-0.1637200564,
0.2737390399,
0.2021901011,
0.3995268941,
-0.6588421464,
-0.3996707201,
0.2071837485,
-0.2664704919,
-0.2886351943,
0.1279233098,
-0.9791849852,
-0.3872183263,
-0.3950454295,
0.1359449476,
-0.5611690283,
-0.1714044362,
-0.4208471477,
-0.2574020922,
0.4675222039,
0.2583118677,
-0.9738019705,
0.0280343741,
0.9145100713,
0.622874558,
-0.0649415627,
-0.4883058071,
-0.110999018,
0.0926796347,
-0.1811257303,
0.3101236224,
-0.7804105282,
-0.8330221772,
0.4257173836,
-0.2113345861,
-0.0695362017,
-0.2814030647,
0.5058379769,
-0.2137789279,
0.5262293816,
-0.1738891602,
-0.5425778031,
-0.0754451081,
0.0356072783,
-0.3326712549,
0.8568657637,
0.1654787958,
-0.4986753166,
0.4274101853,
-1.1372779608,
-0.3267253637,
0.4112330377,
-0.6298274398,
-0.3801997602,
-0.2879213393,
-0.0072173686,
0.2072577178,
0.0242309347,
0.6268696785,
0.1520255208,
-0.3989657462,
0.3868441582,
-0.9057230949,
1.1296756268,
0.3888243735,
-0.2707047462,
0.2298811078,
-0.4704243541,
-0.1405587494,
-0.0418276414,
-0.3585256338,
-0.2470565885,
0.1176756024,
-0.0022280361,
-0.4290032089,
0.0326623432,
-0.2346381694,
0.2899809778,
0.0951821283,
0.6714812517,
0.9894010425,
-0.1042323634,
0.4420078695,
-0.3662155867,
0.6007143855,
-0.329084754,
0.6445433497,
-0.0865829512,
-0.6602164507,
-0.6567724943,
0.2258670479,
0.0664394945,
0.5815120339,
-0.545052886,
-0.0198655687,
-0.0426404737,
-0.2082583308,
-0.8651043177,
0.0167012569,
0.2749535441,
0.3189163506,
0.2540520132,
-0.0284493603,
-0.1564059556,
-0.4587285817,
-0.2623825967,
-0.3341813385,
-0.1204206795,
0.3874360025,
0.4230637848,
-0.1905678958,
0.8177807927,
-0.2701829672,
-0.325074017,
0.1744645983,
0.394488126,
-0.2727665603,
0.7273722887,
0.505444169,
-0.9748572111,
-0.2058605552,
-0.0190213732,
-1.1249315739,
0.2856239378,
-0.3327941,
-0.4290325642,
-0.1445236653,
0.2130476385,
-0.3456745148,
0.4689620435,
0.0874132365,
-0.4447677135,
0.2129120976,
-0.113303408,
0.4229113162,
-1.024758935,
-0.0267718993,
-0.0234180205,
0.1272644252,
-0.5579932332,
0.4167769253,
-0.2929859757,
-0.3703160286,
-0.0964326411,
0.1608341932,
-0.0326683894,
0.0393004827,
0.008050276,
0.0631284714,
-0.0786377639,
0.0540096797,
-0.2165216804,
1.3563349247,
0.6426157355,
-0.4001880884,
0.2484789491,
0.7752425671,
-0.3515959084,
0.9960532784,
-0.4677452743,
0.2363334745,
-0.0892538503,
0.2638241053,
-0.2641335428,
-0.4022180736,
0.4706818163,
-0.5040556192,
0.1678481847,
-0.1095771044,
-0.1731016338,
-0.2343090326,
-0.3795188665,
0.5816529393,
0.5965950489,
-0.5179854631,
0.5247644186,
0.3331775069,
-0.1082885712,
-0.827700913,
-0.724450171,
0.2819412053,
-0.13046588,
-0.3702971935,
0.3129791319,
-0.2277502269,
-0.2478410602,
0.0819383636,
0.279627949,
-0.1657493114,
0.4599232376,
0.3433831334,
0.3948428929,
-0.1573261768,
-0.1401491463,
-0.0655402318,
-0.0208618119,
0.2814091444,
-0.133730948,
0.2973353565,
-0.1255087256,
-0.3999394178,
-0.8611185551,
0.5041238666,
0.5120673776,
0.0227230471,
0.3645097315,
0.8778398633,
-0.1889121383,
0.046207685,
-0.2074100673,
-0.4567358494,
-0.4620554447,
-0.0453877635,
0.0791621879,
-0.7238930464,
0.2156908214,
-0.0071414458,
0.4184564054,
0.1266736686,
0.382047087,
-0.3495060205,
0.5585536957,
0.6775184274,
-0.2676278651,
0.7722755075,
-0.5145012736,
0.335665524,
-0.9562501311,
-0.6102240682,
-0.5061976314,
-0.1118274778,
-1.0058982372,
-0.0949578434,
0.352434516,
-0.0905115083,
-0.3018637002,
0.0814639032,
-0.7549580336,
0.403961271,
1.0014972687,
0.0193876531,
0.280962795,
0.0309635382,
0.3320103884,
0.2974332869,
-0.5853777528,
-0.5017439723,
1.0526353121,
0.4087921679,
0.7854232788,
0.1651196033,
0.5745582581,
0.6351796389,
0.3440814912,
-0.6193938255,
0.4737788141,
-0.0466772318,
-0.5027173162,
-0.5102175474,
-0.3379347622,
-0.9394544363,
0.157997489,
-0.066175364,
-0.728654623,
0.1863236278,
0.0416662693,
-0.236065492,
0.3064624369,
-0.5372934937,
0.5182362795,
-0.0378770716,
-0.2536920309,
-0.1804518253,
-0.4892376661,
0.0562981367,
0.0966242626,
0.0058656591,
-0.0110347727,
0.4842077196,
0.9749429226,
-0.2303509414,
0.7653021216,
0.0240432955,
0.0525792278,
0.7230710387,
-0.3082591891,
0.2265115529,
0.0474313758,
0.018127311,
0.5008170605,
0.2231120169,
-0.3858290911,
-0.1862515211,
0.5386244655,
-1.1972489357,
-0.7699177265,
-0.6222548485,
-0.5812964439,
-0.1049807593,
0.1082689464,
0.5778346062,
0.2760585248,
-0.384221077,
0.3071505725,
0.7952757478,
-0.1153392345,
0.3441726267,
0.1015607417,
0.1097643524,
-0.0343714096,
1.1466683149,
0.3075120151,
0.0687043816,
0.0891693383,
0.3374593258,
-0.1601203829,
-0.2522088587,
-0.697635293,
-0.2876786888,
-0.7011478543,
-0.1062697843,
-0.2570336461,
-0.7007243633,
-0.7550920248,
-0.3571047783,
0.1616566777,
-0.0484031998,
-0.4642244577,
-0.1622154117,
0.4815654755,
0.5194744468,
-0.0971506312,
0.5219348073,
-0.3569536209,
0.039632991,
0.4248933494,
0.3515722752,
-0.3666826487,
-0.3400893211,
0.4275175333,
0.1325906515,
-0.4090167582,
-0.3512740135,
-0.1423233598,
0.4159389138,
0.526548028,
0.6019827127,
0.1578639448,
0.0746451318,
-0.3048227727,
0.8475953937,
-0.0716455504,
-0.461289674,
0.6845462322,
-0.3636835814,
-0.0332440063,
0.4996053874,
0.6383460164,
-0.3880905211,
-0.5637724996,
-0.5615086555,
-0.6869542003,
0.3702353537,
0.4164825678,
0.8484066129,
0.4055659175,
0.2978767753,
0.2283026129,
0.2484436035,
-0.6330299973,
-0.3976113796,
-0.5237047672,
-0.1940378249,
0.2678120434,
-0.2114005238,
-0.653419137,
0.0560503416,
0.4913625121,
0.0899751186,
0.1458589286,
-0.1307535321,
0.2011550218,
0.1575737894,
0.6506516933,
0.278093785,
0.7245026231,
-0.0844556987,
-0.3259911239,
-0.2221713066,
-0.9431507587,
-0.016202582,
0.2062981874,
-0.7589578629,
-0.2712847888,
-0.0390577205,
0.4559901655,
-0.1658643782,
-0.2686471641,
0.3866602182,
-0.0497578569,
-0.1306177527,
-0.5781465769,
0.433280915,
-0.7226402164,
0.0483707227,
0.312507093,
-0.1492147297,
0.3105084002,
-0.8068017364,
0.1617096961,
0.3359568417,
-0.3149304986,
-0.1062850803,
0.8597071767,
0.3420854509,
-0.2235078663,
1.0838750601,
0.3313766718,
-0.2288643867,
0.5365914702,
0.4920554757,
0.879932344,
-0.3054441512,
0.8008571863,
0.0299407244,
0.2001135796,
0.0841161311,
0.2880873978,
-0.3142746687,
-0.7418527603,
0.1116070077,
-0.3452137709,
-0.8080878258,
0.0775034875,
-0.7597735524,
-0.1011150628,
-0.7213551998,
-0.2210693061,
0.0199779943,
-0.3430407345,
-0.7192323208,
-0.0003558024,
0.0146027124,
0.5023398995,
-0.8288053274,
0.6207416654,
0.6592885852,
-0.7416725159,
-0.5890761614,
-0.0430957936,
0.3397380114,
-0.8291398287,
-0.0375538468,
-0.0734048113,
0.1026825085,
0.1273300052,
-0.5440487266,
-0.4410842359,
1.1100020409,
0.131105572,
-0.3648846447,
0.008968656,
0.3729458451,
0.3633857369,
0.2853644192,
0.1798472852,
0.7156587839,
0.4582916796,
-0.0746897981,
-0.436717838,
-0.224627465,
-0.0385955311,
-0.2711767554,
0.3483543396,
-0.7373647094,
0.5049688816,
-0.0910033435,
-0.341037333,
-0.0847449228,
0.4696882367,
-0.1143804863,
0.6594458222,
-0.2690641582,
0.3888206184,
0.9921644926,
-0.517290175,
0.9565275311,
-0.2088780701,
0.0820735767,
0.7002666593,
0.0046789781,
0.4787827432,
0.3541494906,
-0.4561740756,
0.5454802513,
0.6394851208,
-0.693721652,
0.4035155773,
-0.0307281483,
-0.6536768079,
0.4009023011,
-0.7305009365,
-0.6634867191,
0.6204384565,
0.5714805126,
-0.0459475219,
0.0155600701,
0.3473998904,
0.1015695632,
0.0259950124,
-0.4126692116,
0.8392601609,
-0.0685178041,
-0.7242459655,
-0.1863932461,
-0.2908165455,
0.4792816043,
-0.169044584,
-0.2272403091,
-0.3789847791,
-0.2311042249,
-0.3213301301,
-1.1111072302,
0.1499189436,
0.201489374,
0.1051967591,
-0.2318084389,
0.4799407125,
-0.2613260746,
-0.3038318455,
-0.205335781,
0.2381540984,
0.3084831536,
0.3930604756,
-0.6372688413,
-0.0006279223,
-0.1928966045,
0.2254865766,
0.5457201004,
0.1685577035,
-0.1943933219,
0.8061083555,
0.6583384871,
0.0373764373,
-0.0558828562,
0.407483995,
0.5516340137,
-0.1462661475,
-0.2670652568,
-0.5439860225,
0.2032344639,
-0.1501129121,
-0.5041137934,
0.3406889439,
0.1409384608,
1.3156245947,
0.5148132443,
1.0578660965,
-0.103730239,
-0.305064559,
-0.5082981586,
0.8609003425,
0.0955931693,
0.2072075009,
0.0578673966,
-0.9278376698,
0.0794807598,
0.6186313033,
-0.1091102287,
0.2661870122,
0.1195103824,
0.1949248165,
0.3764209747,
0.1861909479,
0.2409511805,
-0.1982920915,
0.4573133588,
0.1331509054,
0.7507367134,
-0.3163002133,
0.5550987124,
-0.4380095601,
-0.3540192246,
-0.1292356253,
-0.4907173216,
-0.636652112,
-0.4630021155,
-0.6459205747,
-0.184936583,
0.2322624028,
0.528167069,
0.3792287111,
-0.9835833907,
-0.0679885522,
-0.3257985711,
0.2294696569,
-0.0786447078,
-0.3702262342,
0.4462182522,
-0.2060192823,
-0.7033675313,
0.1845040172,
-0.0015321372,
0.3151555657,
-0.4663767219,
0.1496937275,
0.0534863211,
-0.1445621848,
0.4523143768,
0.6824279428,
-0.6530889869,
-0.6762150526,
-0.2740111351,
-0.052137807,
0.0489625931,
0.8169568777,
-0.4860836267,
0.6976095438,
0.3091469705,
0.9479582906,
-0.2441160083,
0.2378077358,
0.612534225,
-0.4293777645,
-0.0979765952,
0.4538368285,
0.2945817709,
0.2255981863,
-0.5994241238,
0.8198606372,
0.0155898891,
-0.9807024002,
-0.7306036353,
-0.0067636534,
-0.683999598,
-0.1831177622,
0.737847507,
-0.3826466501,
0.2965190709,
-0.1734042764,
-0.0408940092,
0.202338472,
-0.3721656203,
1.1652433872,
0.5589501262,
-0.2981106937,
-0.2206713259,
-0.9540890455,
0.7787759304,
0.2608578503,
-0.8116099238,
-0.0442513116,
0.3500679731,
0.1147202775,
0.0358520411,
0.3573975861,
-0.1960858405,
0.3504907489,
0.0258725844,
-0.226352632,
0.1132190824,
-0.5762690902,
-0.182559669,
-0.0225461908,
0.0829465911,
-0.4684238732
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05230v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05230v1
|
Language Models, Agent Models, and World Models: The LAW for Machine Reasoning and Planning
| 2023-12-08T18:25:22 | 2023-12-08T18:25:22 |
Zhiting Hu, Tianmin Shu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Despite their tremendous success in many applications, large language models
often fall short of consistent reasoning and planning in various (language,
embodied, and social) scenarios, due to inherent limitations in their
inference, learning, and modeling capabilities. In this position paper, we
present a new perspective of machine reasoning, LAW, that connects the concepts
of Language models, Agent models, and World models, for more robust and
versatile reasoning capabilities. In particular, we propose that world and
agent models are a better abstraction of reasoning, that introduces the crucial
elements of deliberate human-like reasoning, including beliefs about the world
and other agents, anticipation of consequences, goals/rewards, and strategic
planning. Crucially, language models in LAW serve as a backend to implement the
system or its elements and hence provide the computational power and
adaptability. We review the recent studies that have made relevant progress and
discuss future research directions towards operationalizing the LAW framework.
|
[
-0.332765609,
-0.7080689073,
0.9820989966,
-0.1340414286,
0.1577589512,
0.028114466,
0.0519979335,
-0.6063767076,
-0.2893738449,
0.8906154037,
-0.4840712845,
-0.1663529128,
-0.4205282032,
-0.1987694204,
-0.1964446455,
0.5712426901,
0.009796191,
0.1241436005,
-0.3227363527,
-0.2993909419,
-0.5811663866,
-0.6266070008,
-0.3536149561,
-0.7628152966,
0.2883185446,
0.1031516343,
1.2909969091,
0.6539465189,
0.3671864867,
0.3136146069,
0.0670234486,
0.0751806051,
-0.0172251742,
0.474663049,
-0.6208718419,
-0.4590781927,
-0.4347366989,
0.0470716432,
0.4684185386,
0.847397089,
0.1380007267,
-0.3273408413,
-0.3474692702,
0.4656302929,
-0.6604011059,
0.2802293003,
-0.6464461088,
-0.0048015369,
0.4584594667,
0.0271674152,
-0.3705116212,
-0.0556515083,
0.1870290637,
-0.6264836192,
-0.0527880378,
0.2251038849,
0.7564046979,
0.3423528671,
-0.6460719705,
-0.3429207802,
-1.0038659573,
0.6710901856,
-0.4993958771,
0.5453770161,
0.3846388757,
0.7077697515,
-0.4954602122,
-0.6516206264,
-0.5761987567,
-0.5546352267,
0.0969391987,
-0.2448089272,
-0.3003765345,
0.2053954303,
0.2661176622,
-0.4469600916,
-0.4663574994,
0.1574535072,
0.0531227626,
-0.2379792929,
0.9708030224,
0.3589763343,
0.5575608015,
0.2475796938,
0.0650287792,
0.1393136531,
-0.7392363548,
0.0090705687,
0.2586824,
0.2966697216,
0.0650734901,
0.5461255908,
-0.3432250917,
0.8071759343,
-0.5007092953,
-0.2635897994,
-0.3833726048,
-0.1470246166,
-0.0792181268,
-0.1999743134,
0.3906082511,
0.260889411,
0.4680766761,
-0.2249717712,
-0.3546344936,
0.0524245054,
0.2010603547,
-0.4573594928,
0.0596637912,
0.306794703,
-0.6196643114,
-0.0509303175,
0.1333048791,
-0.2011637241,
-0.6244854331,
-0.6277412772,
0.27883479,
-0.2480689138,
-0.3750528097,
0.4029854238,
-0.3576583564,
0.2607350349,
0.4039708674,
-0.8865354061,
0.5408992171,
1.2422099113,
0.3999605477,
0.3455905914,
-0.5711457133,
-0.2869254649,
0.4082046747,
-0.5914527774,
0.7634861469,
-0.8206712604,
-0.3362024128,
0.0971493796,
0.0926227942,
0.1611948162,
-0.3072864115,
0.4192307889,
-0.5320612788,
-0.2615014017,
-0.2398272306,
-0.5193836689,
-0.4564040005,
0.366637826,
-0.8384945989,
0.4785764515,
-0.0716799945,
-0.2420751303,
0.6481518149,
-0.8529325128,
-0.7473559976,
0.0814216137,
-0.2534074485,
-0.2093803585,
0.064640075,
-0.0738422424,
0.5052247047,
-0.6233537793,
0.6593908668,
-0.688787818,
-0.2231366187,
0.4035885036,
-0.0824335441,
1.0684159994,
0.6318661571,
-0.1876367182,
0.2196071893,
-0.6203715205,
-0.0002455176,
0.3297265768,
-0.250590533,
-0.1537044495,
0.4829022586,
-0.1228350401,
0.393909812,
0.2048178017,
-0.2494896054,
0.2582135797,
-0.1843624264,
0.9041870832,
0.4235192239,
-0.1405662596,
0.7589517832,
-0.4858389199,
0.5275599957,
-0.3316699266,
0.0663003847,
-0.0670233816,
-0.6304860711,
-0.407068193,
-0.0784987509,
0.0540197529,
0.7393155694,
-0.5304870009,
0.1422078907,
-0.1954472214,
-0.4806431532,
-0.2450187057,
-0.2850054801,
0.1166349053,
-0.0960588157,
0.0443450548,
0.157057941,
-1.0267835855,
-0.6649345756,
-0.6940953732,
-0.5072321296,
0.1460568458,
0.2307922393,
0.8061757684,
-0.248567909,
1.1323058605,
-0.0674207658,
0.3978714049,
-0.7566785216,
-0.1515868157,
-0.0079430565,
0.3423507214,
0.4792384803,
-1.0261923075,
-0.2556947768,
0.3267202377,
-0.9019158483,
0.0758297369,
-0.1699813455,
-0.2327442765,
0.035435535,
0.5070878267,
-0.7794220448,
0.4233510196,
-0.0949893966,
-0.6662093997,
0.6042993069,
-0.2558728755,
-0.0650439709,
-0.8098540306,
-0.1751811206,
-0.2068475485,
-0.3723023236,
-0.8443563581,
0.4688714743,
-0.2075647563,
-0.1458424628,
-0.2995598912,
0.947122395,
-0.478616327,
-0.3278281689,
-0.7293946743,
-0.0686933026,
0.2685465515,
0.0527700745,
0.0721385106,
0.4892005622,
0.6340642571,
-0.7305061221,
0.733784318,
-0.0797147304,
-0.0625073537,
0.5484138727,
-0.5050262809,
-0.0686073601,
-0.1628353149,
0.3108591139,
-0.2509792447,
-0.451584518,
0.1187851951,
-0.310703069,
-0.026724929,
-0.201219961,
-0.4937252104,
-0.4419699609,
0.2376181036,
0.1221331656,
0.5290081501,
-0.2058975101,
1.0581666231,
0.7458860874,
0.1968714297,
-0.5109928846,
-0.7357109785,
0.243786633,
-0.1795271486,
-0.6901085973,
0.2634663284,
0.1527135372,
-1.1308386326,
0.3000141978,
0.2677158713,
-0.5771022439,
0.1943653971,
0.21206218,
0.1054873392,
-0.2920802832,
0.1645949632,
-0.0923135132,
-0.0110163642,
0.2653289735,
-0.6786065698,
0.3762655258,
-0.2083953917,
-0.3715954721,
-0.1447372586,
0.4543654323,
0.6247355938,
-0.2172002345,
0.6386014819,
-0.00961773,
-0.6133619547,
-0.0939574838,
-0.3178462684,
-0.0060591535,
-0.3580405712,
0.415563792,
-0.8913727403,
-0.7709136009,
0.4706454873,
-0.044194933,
0.1513080895,
0.366843462,
0.7582130432,
0.0074891709,
1.1477872133,
0.8466852903,
-0.0573668815,
0.3733738661,
0.0435053371,
0.2617982924,
-0.3343870342,
-0.2339427322,
-0.6820041537,
-0.0566885509,
-0.6178599,
-0.3685973287,
-0.1762882918,
-0.1714511812,
-0.4914224148,
0.4169117212,
-0.1487678587,
0.6743600368,
0.5775514841,
-0.3061566055,
0.2968252003,
-0.2683892548,
-0.4101237953,
0.2775834501,
-0.6721401215,
-1.0533497334,
1.0888159275,
0.2554662228,
0.635689199,
0.0122782663,
0.5307154059,
0.3529848456,
-0.1108670607,
-0.6871573329,
0.7750869393,
0.2275653332,
-1.0558764935,
-0.3937097192,
-0.2929258645,
-1.1746132374,
0.5532308221,
-0.2004177719,
-0.7632116079,
0.1612859219,
-0.067523621,
-0.3678791225,
0.6399948597,
-0.5134644508,
0.8493763208,
-0.2730511427,
-0.4047667384,
-0.3614850938,
-0.7155392766,
0.1175196841,
0.2813000381,
0.4568784833,
-0.5275547504,
-0.2067648917,
0.2217762023,
-0.6648874283,
0.637584269,
-0.0871340781,
-0.1600218266,
0.9022126198,
0.0413466953,
0.611810267,
-0.2329691052,
-0.1338951141,
-0.2544167638,
0.1593384892,
-0.5279958248,
-0.7660873532,
0.2771686316,
-0.6222672462,
-0.610253036,
-0.2443941832,
-0.8937231898,
-0.029496491,
0.2586816251,
-0.1169740185,
0.1701047271,
-0.5700095296,
-0.1842294782,
0.5121959448,
-0.0019027675,
0.3786704838,
0.7240469456,
-0.4678645432,
-0.0026727007,
1.0115406513,
0.1672672182,
0.1799028963,
0.456638962,
0.1253449917,
-0.2869427502,
-0.4774155021,
-0.1573965698,
0.0715157241,
-0.9893094897,
0.2947276533,
-0.7162203193,
-0.2593279183,
-0.6814613938,
-0.2186837494,
-0.2355881482,
-0.6648861766,
0.1924292147,
0.1739385426,
0.2149965018,
0.9605945349,
-0.1525359899,
0.0707888752,
-0.4402532876,
0.2357818484,
0.3533045352,
0.0269945804,
-0.211372897,
-0.1936673373,
-0.0274371803,
0.0855045617,
-0.4356724322,
-0.7264536619,
0.1837777048,
0.0512220897,
0.884909749,
0.192160964,
-0.0388961025,
0.3110861778,
-0.6517583132,
0.2735929489,
-0.0145503255,
-0.7034834027,
0.6613364816,
-0.2876555324,
0.0581326261,
0.0750250369,
0.0319711156,
-0.560161531,
-0.4314750135,
-0.6653071046,
-0.3266082704,
0.3475723863,
0.1282758713,
0.1782525033,
0.294677496,
0.3421224356,
0.1455407292,
0.1696134955,
-0.7716174722,
0.2315975875,
-0.0956509262,
-0.0857784674,
0.1308679581,
0.1210813224,
0.0100084245,
-0.3777318299,
0.6183972359,
-0.3053797185,
0.2868885398,
-0.2035416961,
-0.1763393134,
0.0380548276,
0.488245517,
0.5133180022,
0.7885597944,
0.3423781991,
0.305331707,
0.1306473017,
-0.2046186626,
0.4789482355,
0.1816153526,
-0.350782305,
-0.3625299931,
0.5466345549,
0.7767589092,
-0.0342191197,
-1.049957037,
0.1852860302,
0.2031736821,
-0.4391884506,
-0.2786667645,
0.4086535275,
0.1291051656,
0.6797561049,
0.0399005711,
0.1795248985,
0.2276941687,
-1.0020866394,
0.0603758097,
0.4293370545,
-0.3148493767,
-0.1269247681,
0.7915661335,
-0.0293490253,
-0.5538421869,
0.1820138395,
-0.3700610697,
-0.5962153077,
0.8698586226,
0.5940907001,
0.8017526269,
0.0252068918,
0.1264218837,
0.0274838544,
0.621165812,
-0.3449214399,
0.6514939666,
0.1711814255,
-0.9619470835,
-0.4670689404,
-0.2453761846,
-0.4843240976,
-0.2405235618,
-0.0543990768,
0.1333246231,
-0.4588848948,
-0.2457882911,
-0.0545492209,
0.0921857506,
-0.487511009,
0.1439989954,
0.0825885311,
0.7066986561,
-0.5214384198,
0.8915860653,
1.0423080921,
-0.5801239014,
-0.5168167949,
-0.0930290073,
0.2346346974,
-0.7170050144,
0.508790791,
0.1984317005,
-0.3083232939,
-0.290273279,
-0.7380475402,
-0.6937062144,
0.8663915396,
0.6873417497,
-0.3783082962,
-0.1325399727,
0.2952873111,
0.5182132125,
-0.835619092,
-0.1500922889,
0.8795539737,
0.6444493532,
0.1178893521,
-0.7356068492,
0.0256252028,
-0.2018747479,
-0.0774573162,
0.2100169808,
-0.3855525255,
0.8858447671,
-0.5558031201,
-0.0524775051,
0.1236036345,
0.6826224923,
0.4022098482,
0.6607450247,
0.2923581302,
0.5564380288,
0.7765063643,
-0.0527773313,
1.2192358971,
-0.1269509494,
0.0128118256,
1.0099098682,
-0.7266879678,
0.5827780962,
0.0777760372,
-0.2822213173,
0.6138193011,
0.5101783872,
0.0108519113,
0.2560177445,
0.1633610427,
-0.1382751465,
-0.6534355283,
-0.2524813414,
0.0097153056,
0.5531389713,
0.283093065,
-0.233052358,
-0.0433449782,
0.150411427,
0.1186558083,
0.3661790192,
-0.2680821121,
0.6653571725,
0.0937540904,
-0.8861343265,
0.15440467,
0.1880901009,
-0.0307738446,
-0.0848793611,
-0.1451640427,
0.2543229759,
0.154364109,
0.1705162674,
-0.8187215924,
0.4093926549,
-0.0411036387,
-0.246925354,
-0.2251997292,
1.1367067099,
0.0636493489,
-0.427406162,
0.4121134579,
0.6788375974,
0.3974983096,
-0.0945122987,
-1.0316371918,
-0.008469942,
-0.4086395204,
0.0113096749,
0.0171665791,
0.7699956298,
-0.3958937526,
1.2066801786,
0.4558910131,
0.1293099225,
0.1264831275,
0.0789447948,
0.7208846211,
-0.9321783185,
-0.7115331292,
-1.0304282904,
0.2085187584,
-0.1210556403,
0.0518759005,
0.2858564854,
0.4281123579,
0.527874887,
0.3445844054,
1.0168842077,
-0.2256667912,
0.3747930527,
-0.5555042624,
0.5924789906,
-0.5387486815,
0.1889239252,
-0.0251891203,
-0.7299316525,
-0.3149082065,
0.6856380105,
-0.5229154229,
0.2180557847,
0.5195833445,
0.5330184102,
0.0028401155,
0.0559867471,
0.6797392964,
-0.0487864055,
0.4270906448,
0.6528353095,
1.1606818438,
-0.1119251698,
0.5236986876,
0.2393108904,
0.1842039526,
-0.4461652935,
-0.6387195587,
-0.9218699336,
-0.4447138608,
-0.0017793627,
-0.1380674988,
0.0577218682,
0.9179797173,
0.9045562148,
-0.6133967042,
-0.4993723035,
-0.470256567,
0.5703526735,
-0.3804558814,
-0.1025397852,
-0.3122615516,
-0.4981863201,
-0.5136608481,
0.3298254311,
0.3677994907,
0.2764006257,
-0.4130175412,
-0.7204470038,
-0.2952762246,
0.4972305,
0.7341431975,
0.5381000042,
-1.1568033695,
-0.1339830011,
-0.2854628861,
-0.2717907429,
-0.1240066439,
1.0924515724,
-0.613442421,
0.4279690683,
0.422604233,
0.6114710569,
0.048258394,
-0.546464026,
0.921379149,
-0.0681098402,
0.5243285894,
0.4096352458,
0.725568831,
0.0281644892,
-0.1894472092,
0.6587756872,
0.1176778376,
-0.6166261435,
-0.7197124362,
0.873711288,
-0.3038448393,
-0.9268554449,
0.7509039044,
-0.1081279218,
-0.3398304284,
-0.6052033305,
-0.2785718143,
0.2539973259,
-0.1997367293,
0.4253491759,
0.8916185498,
-0.2808910608,
-0.2895970941,
-1.0075061321,
0.2850998938,
0.2218759358,
-1.0327891111,
0.0227759797,
0.634717226,
-0.0267253295,
0.0796779543,
0.5296514034,
0.1719911546,
0.3797107935,
0.3409138024,
0.0385443307,
0.1596066952,
-0.575652957,
-0.0319624171,
0.1401486695,
0.3466883302,
0.1973830611
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05291v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05291v2
|
GlitchBench: Can large multimodal models detect video game glitches?
| 2023-12-08T18:14:21 | 2024-03-29T16:49:59 |
Mohammad Reza Taesiri, Tianjun Feng, Anh Nguyen, Cor-Paul Bezemer
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large multimodal models (LMMs) have evolved from large language models (LLMs)
to integrate multiple input modalities, such as visual inputs. This integration
augments the capacity of LLMs for tasks requiring visual comprehension and
reasoning. However, the extent and limitations of their enhanced abilities are
not fully understood, especially when it comes to real-world tasks. To address
this gap, we introduce GlitchBench, a novel benchmark derived from video game
quality assurance tasks, to test and evaluate the reasoning capabilities of
LMMs. Our benchmark is curated from a variety of unusual and glitched scenarios
from video games and aims to challenge both the visual and linguistic reasoning
powers of LMMs in detecting and interpreting out-of-the-ordinary events. We
evaluate multiple state-of-the-art LMMs, and we show that GlitchBench presents
a new challenge for these models. Code and data are available at:
https://glitchbench.github.io/
|
[
-0.3619284928,
-0.9697773457,
0.9450256228,
-0.0012112189,
-0.2683854103,
0.2645430863,
0.0525066331,
-0.6556231976,
-0.0451424345,
0.3909935653,
-0.9957571626,
-0.3231609166,
-0.4289737046,
-0.2205539495,
-0.2310749739,
0.5167968869,
-0.2251225561,
0.1488252282,
-0.5511858463,
-0.3414735794,
-0.6132019758,
-0.5548430681,
-0.3737778366,
-0.114415288,
0.1611714512,
0.1129776016,
0.9770225883,
0.3275749683,
0.8175023794,
0.3960530162,
0.183598578,
0.4924132824,
-0.450853467,
0.3118104637,
-0.2581861913,
-0.4518646598,
-0.2415064424,
-0.2515254021,
0.3019813597,
0.2779450417,
-0.0338145383,
0.3907471299,
-0.1296204776,
0.1873687804,
-0.8878326416,
0.3509849906,
-0.3351391554,
0.1950566322,
-0.0984943658,
0.0339730158,
-0.3272995353,
0.013891736,
-0.4599675834,
-0.5337668061,
0.2418288887,
-0.0848999247,
0.8266137242,
0.5083382726,
-0.1770074964,
-0.004276996,
-0.5641165376,
0.5074395537,
-0.7527185678,
0.6299567223,
0.1826914549,
0.7320710421,
-0.5330460072,
-0.4007132649,
-0.819257021,
-0.611777842,
0.3065927625,
-0.0367358923,
-0.4290603101,
0.0929071829,
0.6851812005,
0.233322531,
-0.6264140606,
0.1295140982,
0.0591769032,
-0.2342197001,
0.6183251739,
0.3928809464,
0.7274466157,
-0.2822501659,
-0.3106623292,
-0.2044037431,
-0.2762668729,
0.4272815883,
0.5348639488,
-0.2766885757,
-0.1783334166,
0.6221433282,
-0.2871713936,
0.5257638097,
-0.3810223341,
-0.3710980415,
0.340651691,
-0.6129665375,
-0.0369176827,
-0.4271394908,
0.6761092544,
0.8060602546,
0.1828932762,
-0.2792583704,
-0.1421625465,
0.2782170177,
0.1329688877,
-0.6326217055,
-0.2898186445,
0.3158029914,
-0.4156243801,
-0.0899780765,
0.0660079569,
-0.8741647005,
-0.8285014629,
-0.0080237975,
0.5409969687,
-0.3371516168,
-0.3452658355,
0.3039836287,
-0.3896026313,
0.0061251954,
0.4013234675,
-0.602494359,
-0.243092075,
0.6463728547,
0.8394443393,
-0.0145791294,
-0.4066979885,
-0.8297498822,
0.0910785347,
-0.3208105564,
0.7929908037,
-0.4818209112,
-0.4233373702,
-0.1324974298,
0.1227008328,
0.2786918283,
-0.6222154498,
0.4015915692,
-0.2487786561,
-0.1907051653,
-0.1941693276,
-0.2461562753,
-0.143428117,
0.5868031979,
-0.8929082155,
0.7982116938,
0.0625380501,
-0.3517828286,
0.5182235837,
-0.2539720237,
-0.0212353375,
0.0024774023,
-0.4351639152,
-0.3540802598,
0.532250762,
0.2400092632,
0.0474271663,
-0.38496086,
0.419393152,
-1.0358244181,
-0.5427078605,
0.6264843941,
-0.6365031004,
0.4502932131,
-0.1554082185,
-0.3379822671,
0.2829424739,
-0.6489376426,
0.3278433681,
-0.1045715287,
-0.1821401417,
0.0693832934,
0.2549261451,
0.0357923657,
0.6373597383,
-0.1296931207,
-0.3922366202,
0.3520304263,
0.1432344168,
0.5085686445,
0.4597420394,
-0.0157359336,
-0.0010325909,
-0.1147608161,
0.5579570532,
0.1000560522,
0.3772450984,
-0.3907678723,
-0.4817168713,
-0.4061611891,
-0.535297215,
0.3008626699,
0.6461100578,
-1.247838378,
0.1332529336,
-0.1444306523,
-0.4775918126,
-0.4667715132,
0.1467172652,
0.3563596308,
0.1507602632,
0.4403916597,
-0.6773129702,
-0.3579898477,
-0.6958599687,
-0.344143033,
-0.1807598472,
-0.236961171,
0.1765269786,
0.5962890387,
-0.3714203238,
0.6520251632,
-0.1807418615,
-0.2170347273,
-0.2311761379,
0.2666074932,
-0.0188055094,
0.3283081055,
0.7418872714,
-0.4658086598,
0.1593521386,
-0.2441227287,
-1.0248318911,
-0.089834474,
-0.2207526565,
0.2011042833,
-0.0671998635,
0.9881190062,
-0.6105000973,
0.5952957869,
0.865357995,
-0.5676617026,
0.8634630442,
-0.391136378,
0.6427446604,
-0.4006406069,
-0.2026258707,
-0.1401305944,
-0.1676608175,
-0.3583660424,
0.4676678777,
0.0930861384,
-0.1789034605,
-0.3942849636,
0.5396504402,
-0.4549561739,
-0.3135303259,
-0.2417287976,
0.0599268973,
-0.0048648347,
0.3510512114,
-0.4038687348,
0.69613868,
0.4312976301,
-0.1812597066,
1.0176010132,
-0.1042294577,
-0.8434073925,
0.6178705692,
-0.5119002461,
0.0139716258,
-0.1924522817,
0.2894277275,
-1.147510767,
-0.52589643,
0.3200933933,
-0.4214825034,
-0.1561657041,
-0.2938379049,
-0.8411031961,
-0.4324390292,
-0.2567361891,
0.4469784498,
0.2073953748,
-0.5475663543,
0.7103945613,
0.3025696278,
0.1720680445,
-0.3286952376,
-0.7257240415,
0.1715600491,
-0.1004346833,
-0.7979861498,
0.0458110534,
-0.3036568761,
-0.1932088137,
0.0527209751,
-0.1425507367,
-0.2142436355,
0.2082716078,
0.3550257087,
0.1927960366,
-0.2920837998,
0.063436836,
-0.2863519192,
0.0319330953,
0.303260535,
0.2713466287,
0.5148459673,
0.0249449871,
-1.086194396,
-0.2841458917,
0.3118789792,
0.8262875676,
-0.4231529534,
0.2190819085,
0.6636354923,
-0.2217704207,
-0.0617160909,
-0.7203798294,
-0.0675268844,
-0.4737004638,
0.8766450882,
-0.3518389165,
-0.735619545,
0.7278828025,
-0.08818762,
-0.2882701755,
0.0718188807,
0.2995874584,
0.1635347158,
1.5748064518,
0.5609003305,
0.069570221,
0.361792922,
0.1933463961,
0.1511339545,
-0.4878563285,
-0.3060419261,
-0.2641685903,
-0.5694496632,
-0.4040735662,
-1.0623269081,
0.4188886881,
0.3446082175,
0.0477486216,
-0.2840284705,
0.1600984484,
1.0031222105,
0.3022148013,
0.237614736,
0.4086534679,
-0.1662968993,
-0.1273761094,
-0.1590941399,
-0.3807455897,
-0.1327296048,
0.6289606094,
0.3616783023,
0.6445212364,
0.5040589571,
0.347458154,
0.1426196247,
0.0413727798,
-0.7158845663,
0.5325729847,
-0.1054944769,
-0.7483847141,
-0.2126456499,
-0.4419034123,
-0.412026614,
0.3255649805,
-0.4222202897,
-1.1296764612,
0.2433686405,
0.1010458022,
-0.6168059111,
0.5176463723,
-0.6826535463,
1.1505030394,
-0.5343515277,
-0.675919652,
-0.2110108286,
-0.1467971206,
0.7177712321,
0.0961789712,
0.6033726931,
-0.4311713874,
0.1387335956,
0.0694297403,
0.0660132542,
0.5227375627,
-0.1999682039,
0.0137130851,
0.1715567857,
0.594404161,
0.4386813939,
0.4414232671,
0.214088276,
0.1599630117,
0.0697352886,
-0.32530123,
-0.7581797838,
0.5449399352,
-0.5367829204,
-0.487931937,
-0.4609614313,
-0.7186689973,
-0.6619312763,
0.0507695638,
-0.0135279745,
0.3397083879,
-0.3070020974,
0.3346159756,
0.4979380369,
-0.3853818476,
0.5084639192,
0.4782263041,
-0.5337961316,
-0.2669899464,
0.8846553564,
-0.1217766032,
0.2204682082,
-0.2228215486,
-0.2384734899,
-0.0759813711,
-0.5706351399,
-0.730935216,
-0.1575924754,
-0.7622928619,
-0.1457332522,
-0.2444883138,
-0.0042142039,
0.1438355595,
0.2168566883,
-0.2297741771,
-0.0099439155,
0.0736362264,
-0.075752683,
0.0350241363,
0.5834568143,
-0.2302284837,
0.1089194044,
-1.0283409357,
0.6971709132,
0.3590097725,
0.6215888262,
-0.1116914004,
-0.2420791537,
0.0820060596,
-0.0197272133,
-0.1774224788,
-1.0291198492,
0.1064545587,
-0.1056585312,
0.759213686,
0.3328464925,
-0.4409512877,
0.8577273488,
-0.5373789072,
0.9330036044,
0.3855564594,
-0.9910698533,
0.1384392828,
-0.4443650842,
0.5677984357,
0.5638032556,
0.08754161,
-0.6672285795,
-0.3157400191,
-0.6054778695,
-0.8405424953,
0.5704360008,
-0.2248748094,
0.1457208842,
0.1719009876,
-0.0483559817,
-0.092613481,
0.2647482753,
-0.535603404,
0.1295182109,
0.0377977155,
0.0965405703,
-0.4324662387,
-0.2801805437,
-0.1062499806,
-0.1568728685,
0.1778080761,
-0.2229450792,
-0.0440227799,
-0.0137272524,
-0.3547873497,
-0.279081881,
0.2577683926,
0.8343046308,
0.9152488112,
-0.1421889514,
0.1284978539,
0.2876185775,
-0.3044060469,
0.1596893221,
0.035046082,
0.0492060408,
0.1501061469,
0.4775609076,
0.8973853588,
0.6317394972,
-1.1920745373,
0.5759258866,
-0.2662804425,
-0.1307603717,
0.0431956574,
0.2304000407,
0.0210228004,
0.7164245248,
0.2377980202,
0.0435380787,
0.1687135249,
-0.8087632656,
0.3794202209,
0.608792901,
-0.388338536,
-0.1645163894,
0.7281645536,
0.0209396686,
-0.033943627,
0.566640079,
-0.4308628142,
-0.3310891092,
0.7169864774,
0.1719557345,
0.6976011992,
-0.031322185,
0.4246931076,
0.2229314297,
0.5033131838,
-0.2935119271,
0.299421221,
0.4000056982,
-0.6023488045,
-0.6532312632,
-0.3694257736,
-0.6776065826,
0.3973774612,
-0.3230219781,
0.2736631334,
-0.4797904193,
-0.2497067302,
0.0906490684,
-0.4639291167,
-0.6102510691,
-0.0863947272,
0.524454236,
0.7771195769,
-0.6862499714,
0.4716457129,
0.4484605193,
-0.531275332,
-0.5092400312,
-0.0051081753,
0.308352828,
-0.674372375,
0.4302733243,
0.1532144397,
-0.058447022,
-0.3225334585,
-0.5773590207,
-0.7463813424,
0.7235634327,
0.5951648951,
-0.6910173297,
-0.175472647,
0.3228238523,
0.4560083151,
-0.1069277674,
0.5568356514,
0.7269001603,
0.5054531693,
-0.0573966615,
-1.0035738945,
-0.1345195025,
-0.1811903268,
-0.2643308938,
0.1198294684,
-0.4076182842,
0.9797057509,
-0.3950667381,
0.1564927399,
0.0317403302,
0.3933133185,
0.5403210521,
0.4351080358,
0.5816066265,
0.7935869098,
0.7061554193,
-0.4986155927,
1.0184861422,
-0.1190904155,
0.3162596226,
1.0842717886,
-0.2603283525,
0.737924695,
0.3870970011,
0.0489733256,
0.4880793095,
0.4702274501,
-0.3446140885,
0.418114543,
0.3610842526,
-0.200644061,
-0.7208757401,
0.0984639898,
-0.5585903525,
0.6546718478,
0.2288807184,
-0.0054722577,
-0.6260012388,
0.2257288098,
-0.0350305103,
-0.1327011734,
-0.4910584688,
0.5055428743,
-0.2556932569,
-0.5447728634,
0.2972878218,
-0.1075197905,
0.628623426,
-0.61594069,
-0.1503638029,
-0.2611747086,
0.6450849175,
-0.0129859075,
-0.7238249779,
-0.0593674146,
-0.0437061675,
-0.1398914605,
0.27281183,
0.468701601,
-0.3177668154,
-0.4711006582,
0.311804831,
0.6473266482,
-0.1505369246,
-0.3838715255,
-0.8030508757,
0.7112947106,
-0.1200337186,
-0.0341582969,
0.4708217978,
0.6980340481,
-0.3091216683,
0.5898780227,
0.7046564817,
-0.1895737946,
0.0731966197,
-0.0165321231,
0.6862319708,
-0.6770014763,
-0.5313991904,
-0.9016618133,
0.5930912495,
-0.2002046406,
-0.4381971657,
0.7169078588,
0.413436234,
0.9310338497,
-0.3877105117,
0.6978682876,
0.1854941547,
0.0118854083,
-0.6220555305,
0.6193302274,
-0.6518753767,
-0.1093547866,
-0.2790660262,
-0.6182914972,
-0.2425389439,
0.3513271511,
-0.2811859846,
-0.1328908652,
0.6866481304,
0.7814311981,
-0.3249830902,
-0.0788401216,
0.5051956773,
0.0746795312,
0.5269215107,
0.7829048038,
1.1620554924,
-0.1353180856,
0.5572131276,
-0.0804334804,
-0.3776099086,
-0.316552788,
-1.0133254528,
-0.877635181,
-0.2509194314,
-0.284768194,
-0.3914575279,
0.2332087457,
0.5910048485,
0.3736829758,
-0.8626308441,
-0.1593838483,
0.146779865,
0.0603715293,
-0.370352,
-0.1645097286,
-0.2457197458,
-0.2142908573,
-0.6283637285,
0.6803714037,
0.240877986,
-0.0019651442,
-0.3987741172,
0.170826301,
-0.0163771901,
0.050800845,
0.6349236965,
0.3863978684,
-0.8008815646,
-0.7693319321,
-0.053925097,
-0.0189913325,
-0.197916314,
0.8644706607,
-0.7835915089,
0.7391447425,
0.6646013856,
0.6556819081,
0.2091722339,
-0.2317467183,
0.4005530179,
-0.6612411141,
0.4023021162,
0.0470045954,
0.4854998887,
0.2296876758,
0.0676594824,
0.4332137108,
0.2686012089,
-0.3599766195,
-1.2925276756,
0.386987865,
-0.7890690565,
-0.4626475573,
1.1087198257,
0.0830048323,
-0.1747455448,
-0.0216176789,
-0.4285615981,
-0.099314332,
-0.0568139665,
0.8418798447,
1.065112114,
-0.0947026685,
-0.3400744796,
-1.1420041323,
0.6416187882,
0.1723307073,
-0.9678664207,
0.160344243,
0.8862276077,
0.1826281399,
0.4314288795,
0.2430073619,
-0.1059160382,
0.8669102788,
0.0906181708,
0.085541673,
-0.3258003891,
-0.3451340497,
-0.286075443,
0.4420780838,
-0.1484441161,
-0.0614082478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05209v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05209v2
|
HALO: An Ontology for Representing and Categorizing Hallucinations in Large Language Models
| 2023-12-08T17:57:20 | 2024-04-02T17:55:52 |
Navapat Nananukul, Mayank Kejriwal
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recent progress in generative AI, including large language models (LLMs) like
ChatGPT, has opened up significant opportunities in fields ranging from natural
language processing to knowledge discovery and data mining. However, there is
also a growing awareness that the models can be prone to problems such as
making information up or `hallucinations', and faulty reasoning on seemingly
simple problems. Because of the popularity of models like ChatGPT, both
academic scholars and citizen scientists have documented hallucinations of
several different types and severity. Despite this body of work, a formal model
for describing and representing these hallucinations (with relevant meta-data)
at a fine-grained level, is still lacking. In this paper, we address this gap
by presenting the Hallucination Ontology or HALO, a formal, extensible ontology
written in OWL that currently offers support for six different types of
hallucinations known to arise in LLMs, along with support for provenance and
experimental metadata. We also collect and publish a dataset containing
hallucinations that we inductively gathered across multiple independent Web
sources, and show that HALO can be successfully used to model this dataset and
answer competency questions.
|
[
-0.3368514776,
-0.8357528448,
0.6947200298,
0.2810587287,
0.2289906591,
-0.0711741447,
-0.1668520272,
-0.6265812516,
0.4578390419,
0.8516966701,
-0.4243198633,
-0.855507493,
-0.5987356901,
0.2172567397,
-0.7949047685,
0.8557816744,
0.270819813,
-0.1297222376,
0.103570044,
0.1789867133,
-0.4399982989,
-0.7462590933,
-0.323476553,
-0.2359873503,
0.3223266006,
0.2380453497,
0.9135501981,
0.6309546232,
0.7738998532,
0.1835646182,
0.1696216911,
0.3052704036,
-0.530488193,
0.224953711,
-0.1531696022,
-0.3637030125,
-0.4635276496,
-0.0936241895,
0.0836600214,
0.8388573527,
-0.5558596253,
-0.1815793067,
-0.2332673669,
0.2153839916,
-0.5137785673,
0.5168082714,
-0.9561233521,
0.4377739727,
-0.0640071258,
-0.4301580191,
-0.4533547163,
-0.2669522166,
0.2786615491,
-0.9917352796,
0.2010854334,
0.245643273,
0.3916095495,
0.6194254756,
-0.108018063,
-1.0141148567,
-0.6066026688,
0.5760239363,
-0.4194511771,
0.4185628891,
0.5735127926,
0.5436060429,
0.0786276832,
-0.8780201077,
-0.4460918605,
-0.454556942,
-0.1385920495,
0.1091980636,
-0.1281292886,
0.0728033036,
0.1569721252,
0.5568215847,
-0.9332572222,
0.1253641695,
-0.2756159306,
-0.3501953483,
0.5301738381,
0.4387178123,
0.5676692128,
-0.2036914229,
-0.2770393193,
0.1141839251,
-0.5134720206,
-0.5771120787,
0.0901740715,
0.5124200583,
0.3133839369,
0.6520766616,
-0.1035362631,
0.5296381116,
-0.1027390584,
-0.0229309015,
0.0789813697,
0.200977996,
-0.0032600553,
0.6101189852,
0.4112907052,
0.2826981843,
0.0435661338,
-0.7229797244,
-0.0339706764,
0.6476668119,
0.5723077059,
-0.4265182018,
-0.5092867613,
0.4604489505,
-0.3720038235,
-0.1601745188,
0.2445763648,
-0.8478206396,
-0.8852082491,
-0.2033071518,
0.398067385,
-0.4271347225,
-0.1863640249,
0.4096328914,
-0.0393054448,
0.0085575636,
0.1804279536,
-0.9661562443,
0.216119647,
0.8347104192,
0.7597230673,
-0.166868642,
-0.3351798058,
-0.2046236545,
0.5083270669,
-0.4853872955,
0.8500186801,
-0.867241621,
-0.1193120331,
0.4480531812,
-0.0956014842,
0.2143130153,
-0.8032178879,
0.6055087447,
-0.4847845733,
-0.0015112784,
-0.264778167,
-0.5803063512,
-0.4956650734,
0.4658446014,
-0.6356064677,
0.8477782607,
0.0451385044,
-0.7545103431,
0.3913243711,
-0.7277646065,
-0.0952232853,
0.4019850194,
-0.2917759418,
0.1043654084,
0.0094961813,
-0.0210764557,
0.4002025723,
-0.2395306677,
0.2837827504,
-0.272336334,
-0.3477318883,
0.0767864585,
0.0868072212,
0.5047319531,
0.15752244,
-0.3381490409,
0.2396179587,
-0.8886812329,
-0.1796445847,
-0.1097533405,
-0.0982586145,
-0.4569875598,
0.1129812449,
-0.0681460425,
0.2615529895,
0.1161221638,
-0.2202743739,
0.4901992381,
-0.3823876381,
0.5324539542,
0.4345173836,
-0.2076153457,
0.1688870788,
-0.1521964967,
0.2978437543,
0.0803736448,
0.1490710825,
-0.0305613242,
-0.5240577459,
-0.9760102034,
-0.0626056343,
-0.205043301,
0.6037706733,
-0.6833506227,
0.5919384956,
-0.1122710183,
-0.4671007693,
-0.6762808561,
-0.0934716538,
0.193524152,
0.4391838312,
0.6102285385,
0.0807914734,
-0.8147827983,
-0.8739685416,
0.1994799376,
-0.3765442967,
-0.1143883988,
0.2351300567,
0.5984901786,
-0.8621755838,
0.8774320483,
-0.4706543982,
-1.0603041649,
0.0652988628,
0.3339862227,
-0.2440082431,
0.0892622843,
-0.0751732811,
-0.7633333802,
-0.1244786605,
0.2478789687,
-1.353887558,
-0.4090973735,
-0.14568156,
-0.1085093543,
0.0546322949,
0.5615169406,
-0.5195749402,
0.3014039993,
0.5538468957,
-0.2735178471,
0.708445549,
0.1462334096,
0.0390343256,
-0.7782611251,
-0.0132153248,
-0.6648611426,
0.0626370683,
-0.5224496126,
0.2170497328,
-0.5087382197,
0.1332881302,
-0.1393263489,
0.3545489907,
-0.2061966211,
-0.0200089533,
-0.2728925645,
0.3245265186,
-0.2745422423,
0.2260219306,
0.4882154167,
0.3688697815,
0.8089255095,
-0.5059249401,
0.5132266879,
0.6211766601,
-0.2536532283,
0.1498615742,
-0.3087178171,
0.0023037351,
0.0423444994,
0.2489008456,
-0.4290281236,
-0.6497781277,
0.3932456672,
-0.1933252811,
-0.3812480867,
0.2496269643,
-0.7874159217,
-0.3218285441,
-0.0368185565,
0.2930954397,
0.3223350346,
-0.6977622509,
0.5460480452,
0.5028908849,
0.2169615328,
-0.3189432919,
-0.8255380392,
0.2735032141,
-0.3393427432,
-0.6687244177,
0.5134979486,
-0.0491376072,
-0.4153925478,
0.0770014152,
0.2197215408,
-0.2425278723,
-0.2949565649,
0.6140939593,
-0.1621857285,
-0.2328444421,
0.5349324942,
-0.2742474079,
-0.3064079285,
0.1171854362,
-0.3240013123,
0.8105306625,
-0.3035646081,
-0.4033654332,
-0.1830667555,
0.4367676377,
0.2814590037,
0.2642064095,
0.6929473877,
0.5059088469,
-0.6806250215,
-0.5565598011,
-0.5392689705,
-0.5268179774,
-0.3398071229,
0.2254202664,
-0.2870288491,
-1.0490999222,
0.8207358122,
0.2429503202,
-0.0166317895,
0.4104017913,
0.848054111,
0.2908096313,
1.1402903795,
0.5027662516,
0.348207891,
-0.1298829615,
-0.0221177898,
0.3086950779,
-0.5253996253,
-0.312727809,
-0.1208676696,
0.2355832458,
-0.4704684615,
-0.3860034645,
0.3206853271,
0.0813101679,
-0.183460325,
0.0298405606,
-0.7983887196,
0.2399170846,
0.3845582902,
-0.1247506291,
0.7568920851,
-0.050551407,
0.3205747306,
0.0507408455,
-0.71194309,
-1.090747714,
0.7052066922,
0.1922852248,
0.7300639153,
0.0121676326,
0.3942908347,
0.5026161671,
0.278726995,
-0.5252332687,
0.5146066546,
-0.1413655728,
-1.1172193289,
-0.2150559276,
-0.3261342347,
-0.9341070056,
0.26714921,
-0.2358969897,
-0.9146420956,
0.0631444305,
0.2938691974,
-0.4425483346,
0.2244338542,
-0.2280748785,
0.7329908609,
0.0247642472,
0.1193919554,
-0.0678711832,
-0.6267366409,
0.8587465882,
-0.3475143015,
0.1215649545,
-0.0112138558,
0.133185789,
0.7654772997,
-0.5069687366,
0.9195620418,
0.3125082552,
-0.3445371389,
0.6395582557,
0.3205971718,
0.2113699615,
0.1686557978,
-0.0309272427,
0.3941034973,
0.1460818499,
-0.0541233085,
-0.6813728213,
0.5000323653,
-0.5851892233,
-0.5624172091,
-0.4777981341,
-0.7838545442,
-0.191045776,
-0.1693296134,
0.6369324923,
-0.00281875,
-0.1491302103,
0.0176822785,
0.5337189436,
-0.3170884252,
-0.0182614978,
0.3170007467,
-0.8164131641,
0.048450999,
1.0985603333,
0.2744803131,
-0.054043822,
0.1555308104,
0.0482417569,
-0.1586111635,
-0.3030177653,
-0.0218145475,
0.1452563256,
-0.9476124048,
-0.0259795003,
-0.9388332367,
-0.5033990145,
-0.5053668022,
-0.3248836696,
-0.3165734112,
-0.204314664,
-0.2674300075,
-0.0950981379,
0.3144645691,
0.8910990357,
-0.1913582236,
0.4173825681,
-0.6690989733,
0.3550528288,
0.4227591753,
0.2996391058,
0.1252777725,
-0.285674572,
-0.0207915194,
-0.1509542316,
-0.1539449394,
-0.7899552584,
0.4713228941,
0.0589272901,
0.3854543567,
0.8661782146,
0.3127101958,
0.6931696534,
-0.3452446163,
0.8260000348,
0.0497495458,
-0.8456092477,
0.4790548384,
-0.28388834,
-0.2053281069,
0.4816660583,
0.4741866291,
-0.6716402173,
-0.5009108782,
-0.4090987742,
-0.7039254308,
0.3220609128,
0.3291592002,
-0.1099302843,
-0.2655367255,
0.1339401752,
0.7516146898,
0.1617187113,
-0.8726280928,
0.1374447197,
-0.3315553367,
-0.0102277687,
0.2055514902,
-0.2594181299,
-0.3103146553,
0.1594880521,
0.6276538372,
-0.0344760418,
0.1386035234,
0.0565255918,
-0.3929905295,
0.0631089881,
0.0974304304,
0.1185314953,
0.677462101,
-0.2424090952,
0.6146535277,
0.0810351446,
-0.3667119443,
-0.0980264768,
-0.2135488987,
-0.0904236287,
-0.1609314978,
0.8001721501,
0.5356208086,
0.0062474753,
-1.0575883389,
0.2270211577,
0.27669397,
-0.1481222361,
-0.4798874259,
0.1258815974,
-0.1868410259,
0.3526161313,
0.3288528621,
-0.53801018,
0.5891045928,
-0.687110424,
0.2386838496,
0.1910463125,
-0.6071974635,
-0.3997869492,
0.5020985603,
-0.1235020384,
-0.2478426397,
0.8910658956,
-0.4408969283,
-0.6249406338,
0.1528691947,
0.5432630181,
0.7108348608,
-0.1928907484,
0.2579782605,
0.1078496426,
0.3844572306,
-0.246602267,
0.2120565772,
0.3039216101,
-0.6332881451,
0.0224885978,
-0.8618628383,
-0.2600475848,
0.0236723237,
-0.5477004647,
0.0863016844,
-0.2278649509,
-0.138096109,
-0.1238686666,
-0.4672278762,
-0.2143400908,
0.1561599821,
0.3503737748,
0.6163609028,
-1.0057929754,
0.3833445907,
0.406727463,
-0.6456733346,
-0.3459873199,
-0.0452946499,
-0.0566612333,
-0.7645320892,
0.7435104847,
0.3912129402,
0.0404898524,
0.0007466922,
-0.5482493639,
-0.6712409854,
0.7594572306,
0.1268507093,
-0.3767792284,
-0.3586798906,
0.5308277011,
0.780837059,
-0.6644643545,
-0.0899910331,
0.6834844947,
0.7998532653,
0.077633515,
-0.5818414688,
0.0841986537,
-0.0682008043,
-0.0816781968,
-0.2650328577,
-0.3260665536,
0.9038049579,
-0.1267019659,
-0.4126676023,
0.0067610666,
0.4658026099,
0.4814190865,
0.3710970879,
0.3460030258,
0.6509771347,
0.8332256675,
-0.2072031945,
0.9860807657,
-0.2308232784,
0.2287222594,
1.0367316008,
-0.40855968,
0.7286609411,
0.4057391882,
0.1030130237,
0.5206561089,
0.8417037129,
-0.2155212313,
0.3841797113,
0.3833721578,
0.0379957408,
-0.6065584421,
-0.4036079645,
-0.71267277,
0.5505964756,
0.5095055103,
-0.295001328,
-0.1975340992,
0.3146733046,
-0.3192192316,
-0.0544999354,
-0.2241123319,
0.7631155252,
0.1129457131,
-0.4760545194,
0.3387278616,
-0.3581644297,
0.4289963543,
-0.3423396349,
-0.368036747,
0.0718328431,
0.0003856628,
-0.5590010881,
-0.6330563426,
0.575211525,
-0.1701150388,
-0.4324264824,
0.1503143013,
0.3568573296,
-0.3755222857,
-0.6852272749,
0.7388475537,
0.349406004,
0.7398633361,
-0.3547755182,
-0.3845337331,
0.4374945164,
-0.5082990527,
-0.0795153156,
-0.0634950027,
0.5064841509,
-0.3912723958,
0.7854707837,
0.4886182845,
-0.0003160572,
0.4353290796,
0.1144051254,
0.7121645808,
-0.6312531233,
-0.5405423641,
-0.7650982141,
0.2822143137,
0.1331169009,
-0.412992537,
0.7550676465,
0.5032578707,
0.4938631952,
-0.071187079,
0.8751896024,
-0.1280531287,
0.4500648677,
-0.5911695957,
0.8313648701,
-0.5830439925,
0.3509263098,
-0.2161571383,
-1.1613919735,
-0.7088632584,
0.8839297295,
-0.2157135457,
0.05748282,
0.6745020151,
0.9487444758,
0.060280025,
0.2463515252,
0.4991581738,
0.6237083673,
0.1564259082,
0.6409648657,
1.2263635397,
-0.1129221544,
0.6523566246,
0.0078438614,
-0.1890711337,
-0.6615169048,
-0.5593398809,
-0.9602328539,
-0.9291946888,
-0.3252110481,
-0.4047391713,
0.1860099733,
0.8155575395,
0.849247396,
-0.8621666431,
-0.13755849,
-0.1643910855,
-0.158841759,
-0.0626682267,
-0.2257001847,
0.5453566909,
-0.4916872978,
-0.3861087263,
0.1954374313,
0.4800359309,
-0.1448695958,
-0.6974451542,
-0.1416923702,
0.1318230182,
0.1517564803,
0.7846983671,
0.0754211172,
-1.3115682602,
-0.2900147736,
0.0221927129,
-0.2459759265,
0.0219008271,
0.7013471127,
-0.5997219682,
0.5082341433,
0.1700362712,
0.4851084054,
0.0823523626,
-0.1203655079,
0.1904851943,
-0.2114229202,
-0.1138003394,
0.405725956,
0.1481324583,
0.195886299,
-0.336307019,
0.8013724089,
-0.015173126,
-0.4556263983,
-1.0877370834,
0.1807080954,
-1.0818904638,
-0.5100180507,
1.1644479036,
0.1152050346,
0.067572102,
-0.4287007749,
-0.3694262505,
0.209029898,
-0.0591586791,
1.6324492693,
0.8870880604,
-0.2873625159,
0.0722792968,
-0.5697771907,
0.6398305297,
0.0769256875,
-1.0930733681,
0.4436249137,
0.4274927676,
-0.4332157671,
0.6908143163,
0.2316775769,
0.0192141961,
0.098471947,
0.3593218923,
0.2699125409,
0.0761964098,
-0.5250450373,
-0.0426704288,
0.6475479603,
-0.2481288016,
0.3531237841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05200v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05200v1
|
DelucionQA: Detecting Hallucinations in Domain-specific Question Answering
| 2023-12-08T17:41:06 | 2023-12-08T17:41:06 |
Mobashir Sadat, Zhengyu Zhou, Lukas Lange, Jun Araki, Arsalan Gundroo, Bingqing Wang, Rakesh R Menon, Md Rizwan Parvez, Zhe Feng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Hallucination is a well-known phenomenon in text generated by large language
models (LLMs). The existence of hallucinatory responses is found in almost all
application scenarios e.g., summarization, question-answering (QA) etc. For
applications requiring high reliability (e.g., customer-facing assistants), the
potential existence of hallucination in LLM-generated text is a critical
problem. The amount of hallucination can be reduced by leveraging information
retrieval to provide relevant background information to the LLM. However, LLMs
can still generate hallucinatory content for various reasons (e.g.,
prioritizing its parametric knowledge over the context, failure to capture the
relevant information from the context, etc.). Detecting hallucinations through
automated methods is thus paramount. To facilitate research in this direction,
we introduce a sophisticated dataset, DelucionQA, that captures hallucinations
made by retrieval-augmented LLMs for a domain-specific QA task. Furthermore, we
propose a set of hallucination detection methods to serve as baselines for
future works from the research community. Analysis and case study are also
provided to share valuable insights on hallucination phenomena in the target
scenario.
|
[
-0.5092611909,
-1.0462694168,
0.6759230494,
0.0525875948,
-0.0919957012,
-0.0036624828,
0.1952572465,
-0.3746037781,
0.5112789273,
0.8594594598,
-0.7389101982,
-0.6802625656,
-0.261159569,
0.2660870254,
-0.7456816435,
0.6254601479,
0.0089336475,
0.0090584382,
-0.4653847218,
-0.0142217455,
-0.6034398079,
-0.8885166645,
-0.5499079227,
0.0233727973,
0.2732546628,
0.3213232756,
0.6237667203,
0.0893604159,
0.3826844394,
0.2456007898,
-0.0621246397,
0.4547233582,
-0.5363110304,
0.6138028502,
0.0221949685,
-0.3744962811,
-0.2963930964,
-0.3101913929,
0.3392798901,
0.7193284631,
-0.2112120986,
-0.0621751696,
-0.0200721826,
0.5389148593,
-0.6487336755,
-0.2197957784,
-0.8933053613,
0.191875428,
0.1648102403,
-0.4959798157,
-0.2901306748,
-0.6154273152,
0.0194528122,
-0.4545789957,
0.4031418562,
-0.0123907747,
0.5673747063,
0.7234188318,
-0.2702224851,
-0.5955405235,
-0.7747911215,
0.5847401023,
-0.5743604302,
0.5691744685,
0.6991150975,
0.2939355671,
-0.2612910867,
-0.588334322,
-0.8800585866,
-0.1986334771,
-0.0864457786,
-0.1196635216,
0.0479485542,
0.0199714974,
0.3656090498,
0.4276747406,
-0.9352671504,
-0.1044653878,
-0.2188557386,
-0.4202167988,
0.3411692381,
0.473795712,
0.3247028589,
-0.2193779647,
-0.0762350708,
0.2302293479,
-0.5034193993,
-0.3354925811,
0.1601933241,
0.0190314855,
0.5061907172,
0.6301546097,
-0.3682320714,
0.4655720294,
0.1029819772,
0.1372642815,
0.3912093639,
-0.1648934633,
-0.2234442681,
0.0728988945,
0.4103067815,
0.091606997,
0.201075241,
-0.4157963097,
-0.231615141,
-0.0532190241,
0.5846429467,
-0.7740575075,
-0.4192684293,
0.7069126368,
-0.2949993908,
-0.1619921923,
-0.1808023453,
-0.7216150165,
-0.7966018915,
-0.3214845061,
0.5913751125,
-0.4822617769,
-0.2752935886,
0.2043489218,
0.0721896514,
0.5111333132,
0.1827897131,
-0.604223907,
0.430557102,
0.4977341294,
0.6091926694,
-0.6548647285,
-0.3165558875,
-0.6741844416,
-0.0342182182,
-0.3266393542,
0.8621500731,
-0.4438250363,
-0.3470015824,
0.2775003612,
0.154843688,
0.0717462078,
-1.1096178293,
0.6586972475,
-0.6402281523,
0.2821316421,
-0.3018471897,
-0.4433361292,
-0.3621356487,
0.6144673824,
-0.8866143227,
1.0100519657,
0.1281712055,
-0.6927192211,
0.2885415554,
-0.2518915534,
-0.3521921635,
0.1765664071,
-0.3241638243,
-0.35510692,
0.0202278011,
0.3110792041,
0.3921622634,
-0.0578801259,
0.1263819933,
0.0448519401,
-0.5137653351,
0.4495464265,
-0.3177939057,
0.6505141854,
0.1067870408,
-0.4539314806,
0.1186244041,
-0.7367405295,
-0.0401414745,
0.0710894465,
-0.02041829,
-0.3779616058,
-0.0875352845,
-0.0782207847,
0.1723929644,
0.1416182518,
-0.2641299069,
0.004779458,
-0.3445228636,
-0.1215137318,
0.3526414037,
0.4303346574,
0.0484243594,
-0.3473217487,
0.7834802866,
0.2707213163,
0.2480822951,
0.2497154176,
-0.2104679942,
-0.7941397429,
-0.2623295188,
0.0801610947,
0.629357636,
-1.0790179968,
0.4059832394,
0.078562431,
-0.1178945675,
-0.4894796908,
-0.0974806026,
0.2346534282,
0.6262403131,
0.5059717894,
0.0135121634,
-0.5534491539,
-0.9348827004,
0.0620008484,
-0.0956920609,
-0.1818638146,
0.2959762514,
0.5020344853,
-0.4904786348,
0.6931631565,
-0.7504240274,
-0.6699969769,
-0.1354204267,
-0.1027078331,
-0.0677837506,
0.2533010542,
0.4211064577,
-1.0827912092,
0.0498690307,
-0.440549612,
-0.9338457584,
-0.1961615235,
-0.2566712797,
-0.3007393479,
0.333496362,
0.4148439467,
-0.690951407,
0.438893646,
0.2922339737,
-0.3740461469,
0.8347596526,
0.0771059096,
0.6442162991,
-1.0517120361,
0.0653516129,
-0.4118574858,
-0.105949305,
-0.6844172478,
-0.102420114,
-0.326025933,
0.1239653304,
-0.2950097919,
0.2411934882,
-0.1877744049,
0.0024002099,
-0.2670781314,
0.3393707871,
0.0844716206,
0.5802562237,
0.2235234529,
0.8196060061,
0.3316289186,
-0.7367121577,
0.2976427376,
0.6963238716,
-0.2424255311,
0.3257331252,
-0.4449951053,
0.2358244658,
-0.0253638923,
-0.0912308097,
-1.0382595062,
-0.2469566613,
0.5025595427,
-0.6090474129,
-0.2281882316,
0.3495922089,
-0.6728616357,
-0.1674459577,
-0.3602590263,
0.5666738153,
0.2906362712,
-0.6281554103,
0.6444318891,
0.5151175261,
-0.0665082335,
-0.6503040195,
-0.7056818604,
0.0721740425,
-0.1934191734,
-0.4073743522,
0.3414972126,
-0.2993169725,
-0.2239631414,
-0.1776622534,
-0.1209902763,
-0.3916246593,
0.242759347,
0.3739981353,
0.0243205577,
0.0483932346,
0.2783998549,
0.2937472165,
0.2408844978,
0.5064361095,
-0.0347020105,
0.8794696927,
0.2688801289,
-0.3881857693,
-0.5719265938,
0.5368779302,
0.6035549045,
-0.0358265154,
0.7769610882,
0.3028012812,
-0.9477674961,
-0.4945335388,
-0.6705284715,
-0.4737276137,
-0.4669891298,
0.3427808881,
-0.593447268,
-0.7159991264,
0.9295153618,
0.1316273957,
-0.1967623085,
0.2009376287,
0.6625886559,
0.198780477,
1.0153518915,
0.3763253391,
0.1849912405,
0.1093557701,
-0.1764250398,
0.3100805879,
-0.634085536,
-0.6272168756,
-0.5753744841,
0.0130517483,
-0.4246001542,
-0.3052292466,
0.1726025343,
-0.0752195045,
-0.0927511379,
0.1061615795,
-0.6330363154,
0.4409988225,
0.3894491494,
0.15688169,
0.5296946168,
0.0248458628,
0.0122583741,
-0.1106048003,
-0.2912106514,
-0.5663097501,
0.7201990485,
0.1344035715,
0.6572090983,
0.1899774969,
0.8360899091,
0.616778791,
-0.1262546182,
-0.9330439568,
0.7848778963,
0.1647350788,
-0.4673642218,
-0.380073607,
-0.4521909058,
-0.8389961123,
0.1321617663,
-0.1239004284,
-0.5663872957,
0.2674601376,
-0.0524799563,
-0.4002241492,
0.1226865277,
-0.1576811075,
0.7050876021,
-0.0466164201,
-0.0301401615,
-0.0555703864,
-0.295879364,
0.4303034544,
-0.2630129457,
-0.2521304488,
0.1022108272,
0.0178279877,
0.7135100365,
-0.1428791285,
0.6285197139,
-0.263127178,
-0.558807373,
0.3522660732,
0.59953475,
0.2988173664,
0.141429618,
0.0091566006,
-0.0468164273,
0.2474970818,
-0.1508960128,
-0.7006712556,
0.6980696321,
-0.4729295671,
-0.6744235754,
-0.3796770871,
-0.5692418218,
-0.5108631849,
-0.0736350417,
0.2555429935,
0.2866292298,
-0.2886333764,
-0.1162100583,
1.1606631279,
-0.4345953763,
-0.0487840511,
0.2567894161,
-0.5209487677,
-0.280194968,
0.8895102143,
-0.0263128411,
-0.0859769508,
0.2543790042,
-0.2725503147,
-0.4122407138,
-0.9576051235,
-0.1706804782,
0.3246781826,
-0.7879297137,
-0.2518685162,
-0.9098097682,
-0.4129173756,
-0.517475009,
0.1193337888,
0.0215932019,
-0.4504592717,
-0.5086483955,
-0.183253482,
0.2116774023,
0.4838652909,
0.2382307947,
-0.0745424107,
-0.7241652012,
0.7777571678,
0.378991574,
0.1938989311,
-0.0530501045,
-0.6450785398,
-0.0422500297,
-0.077375479,
-0.1087760255,
-1.0042021275,
0.6265566349,
-0.0572450943,
0.6005094051,
0.3058213294,
0.4735356569,
0.4443624616,
-0.171173811,
0.9562115669,
-0.3520831466,
-0.8553160429,
0.5571365952,
-0.0257023387,
0.1251997352,
0.7784268856,
0.7285219431,
-0.586016953,
-0.6407397985,
-0.2615123093,
-0.8021993041,
0.3481487036,
0.3302153051,
0.1557331234,
-0.3091713488,
0.6532542706,
0.4759358764,
0.3046283424,
-0.4985299408,
-0.1255200952,
-0.0041291504,
-0.341353178,
0.481234163,
-0.4253170788,
-0.0757248476,
0.0587072149,
0.6701678634,
-0.1077199802,
0.232199356,
0.4316687882,
-0.4207234085,
0.0861799717,
-0.075109899,
0.5193389058,
0.7858099937,
-0.3189781308,
0.0895004272,
0.2708990872,
-0.7766193151,
0.0675337911,
-0.0229938794,
-0.2303674668,
0.1704004258,
0.0614260025,
0.2423667908,
-0.3853026032,
-1.1099516153,
0.3995527923,
-0.3612268567,
-0.4250251055,
-0.7350956202,
0.0289712157,
-0.2965940833,
0.3846787214,
0.6475670934,
-0.4666186273,
0.773879528,
-0.3601624966,
0.5277696848,
0.3976545334,
-0.4293382764,
-0.227568984,
0.6552557945,
0.0717495233,
-0.3091531098,
0.8878569603,
-0.366312176,
-0.7497447729,
0.6390934587,
0.3568143845,
1.2137453556,
-0.2645150125,
0.3419516087,
0.2194808722,
0.3139482439,
0.20393911,
0.711809516,
0.0376788452,
-0.7630885243,
-0.2668295503,
-0.6132787466,
-0.4550747871,
0.5792946219,
-0.6422595978,
0.0333768427,
-0.2456303984,
-0.0963384509,
-0.257950455,
-0.0202174541,
-0.4385201037,
0.2533214688,
0.2465583533,
0.6128140688,
-0.6674007177,
0.5499666929,
0.3547529876,
-0.4454243183,
-0.2538242936,
0.5665466189,
-0.1620100141,
-0.4321143627,
0.7067008018,
0.297975719,
-0.4628399611,
-0.176383093,
-0.453040868,
-0.5015543103,
0.9803555608,
0.061397355,
-0.2783902287,
-0.1214602962,
0.4840978682,
0.5564514399,
-0.3483831882,
-0.2049522251,
0.7357948422,
0.2136146128,
0.1257002205,
-0.5690111518,
0.5109957457,
-0.1075400487,
-0.2216080278,
0.11287117,
-0.2862713337,
0.5079187751,
-0.1515972763,
-0.3525232375,
0.2780030966,
0.7430371642,
0.4143538773,
0.4948277175,
0.4943214953,
0.395784229,
1.0577167273,
0.0363161638,
0.5871251822,
-0.3344266117,
0.0015594828,
1.1513209343,
-0.4563799202,
0.6857072115,
0.464764595,
0.1912404001,
0.3048965335,
0.6581420898,
0.0890240669,
0.4984763563,
0.4663124979,
-0.4023790061,
-0.3129220903,
-0.2533005476,
-0.3152222335,
0.38737005,
0.4890287519,
-0.2024342269,
0.2043403983,
0.3407457173,
-0.190168187,
0.0965960622,
-0.1142905131,
0.87248528,
-0.1019328237,
-0.629355967,
0.8218817115,
-0.5479548573,
0.4435141981,
-0.2466648668,
-0.4243218601,
-0.6288471818,
0.0025593883,
-0.2195143998,
-0.6125897169,
0.558031559,
-0.0416820124,
-0.3211638033,
0.2961740494,
0.5149688721,
-0.5080686212,
-0.0849010125,
0.367302835,
0.7951706648,
0.5359120369,
-0.4973105192,
-0.4750193357,
0.0389933996,
-0.0212324169,
-0.1900975555,
0.0287716277,
0.7636728883,
-0.0108144013,
0.777993381,
0.3007315993,
-0.0852314681,
-0.0112130418,
0.3440657258,
0.9763928652,
-0.8319315314,
-0.1713715792,
-0.4893274903,
0.1008954644,
-0.0783223733,
-0.2203166932,
0.5914015174,
0.7033010125,
0.6715751886,
-0.1200710908,
0.7120903134,
0.1461914033,
0.5894206762,
-0.6831433773,
0.8212539554,
-0.6680583954,
0.4464529455,
-0.0435976274,
-1.0457754135,
-0.4770340621,
0.3990252018,
-0.1259040534,
-0.0462738127,
0.8135333657,
1.0572286844,
0.2427836359,
-0.0377234109,
0.5471243858,
0.1807136834,
0.1680983007,
0.5034883022,
1.1370790005,
-0.356040746,
0.7911458015,
-0.1401055753,
0.0494513586,
-0.2534389794,
-0.3548202217,
-1.0823643208,
-0.9719063044,
-0.5415885448,
-0.6121556759,
0.0418545529,
0.6703827977,
0.2722429633,
-1.1025590897,
0.1554089636,
0.1570819914,
0.1883751899,
-0.1730260402,
-0.279371053,
0.547064364,
-0.3502235413,
-0.7312245369,
0.1978489757,
-0.0080166934,
0.154938817,
-0.4926887453,
0.0531074107,
-0.135843426,
0.3506989181,
0.6291965246,
0.040175505,
-0.6418575644,
-0.1538671851,
0.3174938858,
-0.1918559372,
0.0121279359,
0.7692086697,
-1.0807207823,
0.1315381676,
0.6127724648,
0.8603602052,
0.2347288281,
0.0919543579,
0.201128602,
-0.6038861871,
-0.2064681053,
0.6667521596,
0.1082963943,
0.3086398244,
-0.6751220822,
0.4750824571,
0.0458507873,
-0.6168459654,
-1.0174182653,
0.2097766846,
-1.010597229,
-0.5597893,
1.1612482071,
0.2467468232,
-0.1880451143,
-0.5159386396,
-0.4821515977,
0.0858087689,
-0.1258035004,
1.3664088249,
0.5173576474,
-0.2730531096,
-0.0685415566,
-0.5469158292,
0.8526726961,
0.4455571175,
-1.1964843273,
0.3507461548,
0.8176400065,
-0.0204214659,
0.2521028519,
0.4599119723,
0.0214877408,
0.3292762637,
-0.0787442327,
0.1263181269,
0.1541237235,
-0.4421791732,
-0.4185762405,
0.461298883,
0.0085834879,
-0.3593172729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05187v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05187v1
|
Seamless: Multilingual Expressive and Streaming Speech Translation
| 2023-12-08T17:18:42 | 2023-12-08T17:18:42 |
Seamless Communication, Loïc Barrault, Yu-An Chung, Mariano Coria Meglioli, David Dale, Ning Dong, Mark Duppenthaler, Paul-Ambroise Duquenne, Brian Ellis, Hady Elsahar, Justin Haaheim, John Hoffman, Min-Jae Hwang, Hirofumi Inaguma, Christopher Klaiber, Ilia Kulikov, Pengwei Li, Daniel Licht, Jean Maillard, Ruslan Mavlyutov, Alice Rakotoarison, Kaushik Ram Sadagopan, Abinesh Ramakrishnan, Tuan Tran, Guillaume Wenzek, Yilin Yang, Ethan Ye, Ivan Evtimov, Pierre Fernandez, Cynthia Gao, Prangthip Hansanti, Elahe Kalbassi, Amanda Kallet, Artyom Kozhevnikov, Gabriel Mejia Gonzalez, Robin San Roman, Christophe Touret, Corinne Wong, Carleigh Wood, Bokai Yu, Pierre Andrews, Can Balioglu, Peng-Jen Chen, Marta R. Costa-jussà, Maha Elbayad, Hongyu Gong, Francisco Guzmán, Kevin Heffernan, Somya Jain, Justine Kao, Ann Lee, Xutai Ma, Alex Mourachko, Benjamin Peloquin, Juan Pino, Sravya Popuri, Christophe Ropers, Safiyyah Saleem, Holger Schwenk, Anna Sun, Paden Tomasello, Changhan Wang, Jeff Wang, Skyler Wang, Mary Williamson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Large-scale automatic speech translation systems today lack key features that
help machine-mediated communication feel seamless when compared to
human-to-human dialogue. In this work, we introduce a family of models that
enable end-to-end expressive and multilingual translations in a streaming
fashion. First, we contribute an improved version of the massively multilingual
and multimodal SeamlessM4T model-SeamlessM4T v2. This newer model,
incorporating an updated UnitY2 framework, was trained on more low-resource
language data. SeamlessM4T v2 provides the foundation on which our next two
models are initiated. SeamlessExpressive enables translation that preserves
vocal styles and prosody. Compared to previous efforts in expressive speech
research, our work addresses certain underexplored aspects of prosody, such as
speech rate and pauses, while also preserving the style of one's voice. As for
SeamlessStreaming, our model leverages the Efficient Monotonic Multihead
Attention mechanism to generate low-latency target translations without waiting
for complete source utterances. As the first of its kind, SeamlessStreaming
enables simultaneous speech-to-speech/text translation for multiple source and
target languages. To ensure that our models can be used safely and responsibly,
we implemented the first known red-teaming effort for multimodal machine
translation, a system for the detection and mitigation of added toxicity, a
systematic evaluation of gender bias, and an inaudible localized watermarking
mechanism designed to dampen the impact of deepfakes. Consequently, we bring
major components from SeamlessExpressive and SeamlessStreaming together to form
Seamless, the first publicly available system that unlocks expressive
cross-lingual communication in real-time. The contributions to this work are
publicly released and accessible at
https://github.com/facebookresearch/seamless_communication
|
[
-0.2573521435,
-0.6715180874,
0.3739777803,
0.5285644531,
-0.2035614699,
0.4430528581,
-0.258525461,
-0.7532865405,
0.3521118164,
0.4609308243,
-0.7879984975,
-0.4313581586,
-0.7335686684,
0.1309247017,
-0.6978005171,
1.0094096661,
-0.1919680834,
0.0329994038,
-0.0547664948,
-0.4259362519,
-0.3241522014,
-0.3408899605,
-0.3859716356,
-0.3335216641,
0.6047074795,
0.2743803561,
0.9830282331,
0.489230603,
0.5039029717,
0.3386794627,
-0.1799014211,
-0.0903933495,
-0.6398248076,
0.4450978339,
-0.1150383353,
-0.1363531053,
-0.6683008671,
0.0846764371,
0.6691183448,
0.6855188608,
-0.0674831495,
0.2623734772,
0.1679345071,
0.4154776931,
-0.4818598926,
0.4597017169,
-0.3412863314,
0.065724045,
-0.2642375231,
-0.0932513326,
-0.3442250788,
-0.3570975065,
0.1476094425,
-0.4358600378,
-0.2689765394,
-0.286357224,
0.5306048393,
0.4411704242,
-0.4030564129,
-0.1531127393,
-0.8277384043,
0.6309882402,
-0.5660375357,
0.6738587022,
0.1502983719,
0.3531571329,
0.0394073613,
-0.8415936828,
-0.515871942,
-0.0411247239,
0.2237882912,
0.4554062784,
-0.3738933504,
0.1323918849,
-0.2650382817,
0.4233254492,
-0.7816634774,
0.1253421158,
-0.0334833376,
-0.18733944,
0.5503026247,
0.0133325607,
0.282712698,
-0.0450537577,
-0.2376689464,
0.0531792529,
-0.237854749,
0.1005202159,
0.203366071,
0.4839335084,
-0.5101421475,
0.5837019086,
-0.3354031146,
0.4203002453,
-0.3415019214,
-0.1803127229,
0.377153933,
-0.5048260093,
-0.0589143448,
-0.0078078811,
0.7075733542,
0.1986091286,
-0.0167574435,
-0.3041234016,
-0.1555232555,
0.0115401633,
-0.1037370488,
-0.5696925521,
-0.0506237634,
0.5003231168,
-0.4596329033,
-0.2656207383,
-0.3164424002,
-0.4258942604,
-0.0730199441,
-0.629016161,
0.380305022,
-0.2508237958,
-0.556240499,
0.0097358637,
0.0963944271,
0.0496274382,
0.3348002136,
-0.4899511635,
0.1376727372,
0.6098054647,
1.084954381,
-0.0936112851,
-0.4799326062,
-0.7485165,
0.2236730158,
-0.3815294206,
0.5305304527,
-0.4397031963,
0.0439396389,
0.1404689103,
0.1175665334,
0.175066635,
-0.3545630872,
0.5154805183,
-0.2502554655,
0.2777322829,
-0.1721910089,
-0.4761926234,
-0.3740621209,
-0.0344468094,
-0.5738822222,
0.4828592539,
-0.008839,
-0.4115360677,
0.0110785924,
-0.6849695444,
-0.3248057365,
0.3198964298,
0.2946825624,
-0.3546587825,
0.0813588724,
-0.2764360905,
0.3186486661,
-0.0935590342,
0.2583096325,
-0.429482609,
-0.078810744,
0.1076329276,
-0.424887836,
0.680550456,
0.3596872985,
-0.4736888707,
0.388546139,
-0.207056731,
0.074699685,
0.1138925925,
-0.2872950435,
0.1451990306,
0.0456712507,
0.5337719321,
0.4795060158,
0.2937237322,
-0.5921777487,
-0.1244203225,
-0.0965943113,
0.5944797993,
0.4817091823,
-0.4169761539,
0.4526841044,
-0.019055374,
0.5255548954,
0.0260216817,
0.360707134,
-0.5232502222,
-0.5778511763,
-0.5590391159,
-0.4977472425,
0.2205226123,
0.8127289414,
-0.8007321954,
0.2022252232,
-0.4651284218,
-0.3986563385,
-0.7039818764,
0.1237487197,
0.7190340161,
0.1631477028,
0.4822336733,
-0.4267574251,
-0.2170379758,
-0.8542006612,
-0.3473689258,
-0.0720021278,
0.0838940144,
0.1107570603,
0.1638091207,
-0.3407014012,
0.5875688195,
0.0478912927,
-0.4163384736,
-0.3171602786,
0.3500355482,
-0.1147642732,
0.4447040558,
0.3884560764,
-0.8184602857,
-0.5382367969,
0.1614407301,
-0.7889407277,
-0.2503046095,
-0.109917514,
-0.1380205154,
0.2785181999,
0.306866914,
-0.5781264901,
0.2271375954,
1.2465239763,
-0.3329378664,
0.2040294111,
-0.0055371332,
0.1341025084,
-1.0873743296,
0.0590317473,
-0.0971331596,
-0.8403436542,
-0.8323776126,
0.3210960925,
-0.0781187341,
-0.3711853325,
-0.8340803981,
0.4245962501,
-0.4840459824,
-0.2352766991,
-0.3088908195,
0.1785111129,
-0.0700513273,
0.3634496927,
0.0035995189,
0.6358613968,
0.5163507462,
-0.272225827,
0.4592993259,
0.3978641033,
0.0772911459,
0.5213932395,
-0.5161076784,
0.0699371547,
-0.1576867849,
0.5251879096,
-0.9118052721,
-0.4098847508,
0.269561857,
-0.62321347,
0.3838655949,
-0.214734152,
-0.4350135326,
0.0061521214,
-0.0360816196,
0.3418988585,
0.4272291362,
-0.2458588183,
0.56633389,
0.4698762894,
-0.7502372265,
-0.1769625098,
-0.710915029,
0.5977066755,
0.0555719249,
-0.7096567154,
0.4151210189,
-0.0645399243,
0.0785780549,
0.0178164076,
0.0077674524,
-0.2211285383,
-0.0941196382,
0.0736223757,
0.1664044559,
0.0210742801,
-0.2069019079,
0.3203616142,
-0.1843698323,
-0.1385170221,
-0.5304675102,
0.4391735792,
-0.0983445644,
-0.3911224008,
-0.8519792557,
1.0276908875,
0.8828761578,
-0.4855733514,
0.6701550484,
0.9233437181,
-0.250713855,
0.2935441732,
-0.4384359121,
-0.0083855083,
-0.373054117,
0.3673281968,
-0.3678788245,
-1.2196341753,
0.5574193001,
-0.1442386955,
0.2970245779,
0.0714628696,
0.6184592843,
-0.0508870594,
1.1439181566,
0.5626484156,
0.0986508802,
0.5865069628,
-0.0211561993,
0.2697533965,
-0.5697795749,
-0.2570295334,
-0.4181163013,
-0.3419905901,
-0.6568213701,
-0.4025382102,
0.4673277736,
0.055215992,
0.0614040159,
0.3949239254,
-0.3028754294,
0.2999361753,
0.512580514,
-0.0989192352,
0.150428161,
-0.0545112379,
0.0944219455,
-0.1746929586,
-0.4622032344,
-0.3903541565,
0.6173653603,
0.4842547178,
0.3793606162,
0.5584982038,
0.5383632183,
0.241993472,
0.1579197198,
-0.7192673087,
0.2529333532,
-0.3239279091,
-0.5509522557,
-0.2357513458,
-0.5365834236,
-0.5495433211,
0.2626863122,
-0.2248470336,
-0.4538870752,
0.0479110777,
0.218242228,
-0.0587029159,
0.086014688,
-0.6434672475,
0.9801335931,
-0.2963939309,
-0.6630275249,
-0.2120070755,
-0.8342242241,
0.4001258612,
-0.2065126896,
0.3092873394,
-0.3299037516,
-0.0141021237,
0.2521167397,
-0.0178595427,
0.7503885031,
-0.2244808376,
-0.2249180824,
0.1565739065,
0.4531717896,
0.5030264258,
-0.0389573425,
0.2830478251,
0.7121431828,
0.0102203796,
-0.5482448339,
-0.3543527126,
0.5439668298,
-0.4888187647,
-0.15052028,
-0.1543479711,
-0.7308199406,
0.1045603901,
0.3342294991,
0.0395942815,
0.4312327206,
-0.1027991101,
0.2542329729,
0.4990757108,
-0.2662712634,
0.6186707616,
0.4976136386,
-0.3986728787,
-0.4420706332,
0.9552367926,
0.0090739504,
0.5658561587,
0.3156873882,
-0.2031689882,
-0.7366202474,
-0.2872608304,
-0.5748921037,
0.2880359888,
-0.5212824345,
-0.0505151339,
-0.8057114482,
-0.0709291771,
-0.7143400908,
-0.0538140759,
-0.7979130745,
-0.5356392264,
-0.1198687628,
0.1925325096,
-0.0069688577,
0.691806078,
-0.2958621979,
0.1909480691,
-0.9355480671,
0.4247655571,
0.1869422793,
0.3398954272,
-0.4095230401,
-0.5089386702,
-0.2664572895,
0.0083093559,
-0.3458045721,
-0.861287117,
0.6251882315,
0.4381106794,
0.286590606,
0.2462172061,
-0.1323022842,
0.6797959208,
-0.7752206922,
0.778452754,
0.3816418052,
-1.2564920187,
0.357139796,
-0.5231451392,
0.4283121228,
0.2666377723,
0.3747276366,
-0.9212403297,
-0.5655572414,
-0.1590643823,
-0.959341526,
0.5521380305,
0.5007528663,
0.2505723238,
0.1760993153,
0.1460286528,
0.04928267,
0.3375573456,
-0.6662696004,
-0.1623343825,
-0.5973106623,
-0.2029848248,
-0.3727507293,
-0.1376272738,
-0.1146954969,
-0.1823830903,
0.4929755628,
-0.1927490234,
0.3424310684,
0.1397727281,
-0.1236703321,
-0.0929479003,
0.3285085261,
0.8444631696,
0.3661706448,
-0.0923388973,
0.0452858545,
-0.2900806367,
-0.204471603,
0.2053018361,
0.2997611165,
-0.1382301152,
0.369052887,
0.3532729745,
0.952009201,
0.3823910952,
-0.5287581086,
0.5285028815,
-0.0308223087,
-0.1427673846,
-0.3555812836,
-0.4476177394,
0.2733326554,
0.3831709623,
-0.0754665285,
0.2627111971,
0.3131223917,
-0.5936107635,
0.127638489,
0.3792373836,
-0.6217139363,
-0.5395208597,
1.1158708334,
0.4394576252,
-0.2676816881,
0.2484302819,
-0.2347158641,
-0.4943121076,
-0.1278518587,
0.3017126322,
1.2865536213,
-0.5438939929,
0.3916461766,
0.0263252016,
0.1940428019,
0.00628191,
0.2671827972,
-0.1713133454,
-0.2450440377,
-0.8209930062,
-0.631549716,
-0.4920643866,
-0.1449363083,
-0.709007442,
0.0795230716,
0.140310362,
-0.2027350217,
0.0005547573,
-0.4816008508,
-0.3778106272,
-0.0696829632,
0.5430952311,
0.6755408645,
-0.9554887414,
0.6911907792,
0.6694917679,
-0.4662550986,
-0.6351798177,
-0.1407489479,
0.3770308197,
-0.2646747231,
0.3848427832,
0.0067607905,
-0.2340036929,
0.2669889033,
-0.3740890324,
-0.969432652,
0.9246983528,
0.6642324328,
-0.5603896379,
0.1023232639,
0.3975386918,
0.3740341663,
-0.2076315135,
0.3279554546,
0.4074116051,
0.4154597819,
0.227944538,
-1.3767012358,
-0.1887899041,
-0.1661519259,
0.0496227928,
0.0637438893,
-0.7067807317,
0.9964335561,
0.0982542783,
-0.1733092815,
0.1099325269,
0.5779465437,
0.0561443493,
0.2480260432,
0.2200990766,
0.4829370677,
0.4349911213,
-0.1775939316,
1.056966424,
-0.3031001985,
0.2450715303,
1.0539932251,
-0.4331684411,
0.9266895652,
0.3822204769,
0.1465158463,
0.1317165345,
0.5010116696,
0.6107480526,
0.5198017955,
-0.140083313,
-0.567954421,
-0.3608685732,
-0.5593468547,
-0.3468526602,
0.6330029368,
0.0548614487,
-0.0806282684,
-0.191582799,
0.1641489863,
0.1633535475,
0.0043399483,
-0.0900518969,
0.8407707214,
0.1557025313,
-0.5232945681,
0.6720603704,
-0.022861179,
0.5762766004,
-0.5841393471,
0.0098279333,
-0.4030958116,
0.1522977948,
-0.2488439679,
-0.7919408083,
0.3831378818,
0.1259690076,
-0.1024602577,
-0.5598305464,
0.3209740222,
-0.7746939063,
-0.3807900846,
0.5278002024,
0.6149355769,
0.4287722707,
-0.2471500188,
-0.8229196072,
0.3770114183,
0.0441109799,
-0.2171111256,
0.1614364535,
0.4111870229,
-0.1018150374,
0.8465742469,
0.7807374001,
0.3332174122,
0.4184812605,
0.2434722036,
0.6981039047,
-0.3906385005,
-0.5676355958,
-0.5089380741,
0.7547497749,
0.1835434884,
-0.0861445144,
0.6460604072,
0.5627170205,
0.8474761248,
0.0609926693,
0.7351797223,
0.0923580751,
0.5666940212,
-0.2791287899,
0.8346956372,
-0.6396731734,
-0.2833922505,
-0.597497046,
-1.1145272255,
-0.3520437181,
0.2938750088,
0.2637766302,
-0.2189811617,
0.5522554517,
0.4121370316,
-0.1324909925,
0.0559570268,
0.4696510136,
0.2474739403,
0.5832335353,
0.3467500806,
0.5985347629,
-0.5040343404,
0.6718994975,
-0.1469138265,
-0.4309952557,
-0.0474308357,
-0.815644443,
-0.326469332,
-0.6615521908,
-0.5037928224,
-0.2475609183,
0.1386018842,
0.7643198967,
0.9377744198,
-0.6358593702,
-0.2584659159,
0.0164155625,
-0.3168975711,
-0.264778465,
-0.1648721844,
-0.1259957552,
-0.4035209715,
-1.0118436813,
0.5948881507,
0.627377212,
0.2081128955,
-0.485211879,
-0.3702530563,
-0.0792936459,
-0.0070010223,
0.9344516993,
0.2937420309,
-0.9094337225,
-0.0494101085,
-0.0582149141,
0.1751964837,
-0.2416076213,
0.4520703554,
-0.41968292,
0.5219785571,
0.4187214077,
0.6477436423,
0.3527062833,
-0.0101364404,
0.4422499835,
-0.6162298918,
0.4260368347,
0.2751069665,
0.0793463588,
0.4032592475,
-0.057200972,
0.2308705151,
0.3182065487,
-0.6557590961,
-0.8774588108,
0.4010728002,
-1.0420926809,
-0.0862980932,
0.9466074109,
-0.3684818447,
-0.0707633495,
-0.2012804449,
0.0407546982,
0.5017797947,
-0.4342180789,
0.3824145794,
0.6031991243,
-0.172927931,
-0.4155037701,
-0.9081056714,
0.2789624929,
0.4308727384,
-0.6012325287,
0.2310996503,
0.6719194055,
0.0958002433,
0.1428644508,
0.5352464318,
-0.2620308995,
0.1800441146,
-0.2058021128,
0.3540187478,
-0.0246018916,
-0.4621834755,
-0.4445108473,
0.0965910554,
-0.1610437185,
-0.2218453586
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05180v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05180v2
|
PathFinder: Guided Search over Multi-Step Reasoning Paths
| 2023-12-08T17:05:47 | 2023-12-12T16:06:32 |
Olga Golovneva, Sean O'Brien, Ramakanth Pasunuru, Tianlu Wang, Luke Zettlemoyer, Maryam Fazel-Zarandi, Asli Celikyilmaz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With recent advancements in large language models, methods like
chain-of-thought prompting to elicit reasoning chains have been shown to
improve results on reasoning tasks. However, tasks that require multiple steps
of reasoning still pose significant challenges to state-of-the-art models.
Drawing inspiration from the beam search algorithm, we propose PathFinder, a
tree-search-based reasoning path generation approach. It enhances diverse
branching and multi-hop reasoning through the integration of dynamic decoding,
enabled by varying sampling methods and parameters. Using constrained
reasoning, PathFinder integrates novel quality constraints, pruning, and
exploration methods to enhance the efficiency and the quality of generation.
Moreover, it includes scoring and ranking features to improve candidate
selection. Our approach outperforms competitive baselines on three complex
arithmetic and commonsense reasoning tasks by 6% on average. Our model
generalizes well to longer, unseen reasoning chains, reflecting similar
complexities to beam search with large branching factors.
|
[
-0.1187873259,
-0.7169688344,
1.0945318937,
-0.0096644023,
-0.2517254651,
0.4281247258,
0.4442639351,
-0.1835783869,
0.0394844748,
0.4314320982,
-1.0521717072,
-0.5660867691,
-0.5291332006,
0.0299928673,
-0.1753149778,
0.3781340718,
-0.1557633728,
-0.223752737,
0.2475774586,
-0.0756318346,
-0.8375273347,
0.029835321,
-0.7136254907,
-0.2953215837,
0.6489565969,
0.3776454926,
0.8993888497,
0.6200517416,
0.4988241792,
0.1606830657,
-0.3357507586,
0.6802307963,
-0.3489926457,
0.8726574779,
-0.4423549473,
-0.3034932017,
-0.50390172,
-0.1370421052,
0.6330897808,
0.4962841272,
-0.3552953601,
0.1653315872,
-0.5801655054,
0.5639235973,
-0.7647939324,
0.0981865302,
-0.6950472593,
0.0982803851,
-0.382434845,
-0.6600533128,
-0.5468817353,
-0.3847060204,
-0.1160954162,
-0.7301387787,
0.1082178429,
0.200162679,
0.2581796944,
0.2998877764,
-0.8385645151,
-0.5027329922,
-0.7092967629,
0.7891463041,
-0.4354389906,
0.5579422712,
0.2469954789,
0.6897224784,
-0.6344818473,
-0.6136265397,
-0.1412346214,
0.1630436629,
-0.0078177284,
0.1092328355,
-0.1095346734,
0.3354750276,
0.4920761287,
0.0297461189,
-0.6087684631,
-0.5335015059,
-0.1589588374,
-0.1140687317,
0.7691616416,
0.3711887896,
-0.0335101448,
-0.2324636132,
0.2334474027,
-0.429895699,
-0.7064028382,
0.1846113205,
0.3231061399,
0.3174531758,
0.8238356709,
0.363204658,
-0.6138142943,
1.0324349403,
0.0932208747,
-0.4413464665,
-0.0285016205,
-0.7422932982,
0.1089139283,
0.1998438686,
0.3935012221,
0.2111785561,
-0.2224295735,
0.1960947216,
-0.1845552325,
0.0014074703,
0.1057892293,
-0.8037078381,
-0.1964713037,
0.2769565582,
-0.4781549871,
-0.1903260648,
-0.235582754,
-0.6114906669,
-0.4326557815,
0.174063623,
0.1190031096,
-0.5825279951,
-0.2380468994,
0.3301302195,
-0.4699957967,
0.2104309499,
0.5811659098,
-0.5243778229,
-0.0075333323,
0.4715687335,
0.7513214946,
0.3642983437,
-0.1172817126,
-1.0901604891,
0.2402334213,
-0.5524124503,
0.8084685802,
-1.0577259064,
-0.4000288248,
-0.307916373,
-0.3631541431,
0.0487942621,
-0.141467154,
0.6080983281,
-0.6291416883,
0.035453584,
-0.237788856,
-0.189245522,
-0.4205406904,
0.4273965955,
-0.6476139426,
1.1844916344,
-0.0003779826,
-0.5908733606,
0.7098121643,
-0.7745380402,
-0.545260787,
0.3772654533,
-0.2607089579,
-0.0947953612,
0.0872777998,
0.5564704537,
0.1874589771,
-0.3394489884,
0.6562516093,
-0.0895632803,
-0.501685977,
-0.4922218323,
-0.3125379682,
0.8174949884,
0.217401281,
-0.5222126245,
0.2204334587,
-0.7448772788,
0.2740158439,
0.1934171617,
-0.5582638383,
-0.2182359397,
0.5952356458,
-0.5926053524,
0.3936950564,
-0.1647912711,
-0.535622716,
0.4121917188,
-0.3691777885,
0.1854460388,
0.5745349526,
0.1882827133,
0.0753904283,
-0.1452597529,
0.8086181283,
-0.1038018912,
0.2267466635,
-0.4370567501,
-0.6956634521,
-0.5016224384,
0.162157774,
-0.1737433374,
0.3883283436,
-0.5978776217,
0.3647757173,
0.0186695494,
-0.7558287382,
-0.4576644599,
-0.1458505392,
0.3184946179,
0.1936460882,
0.498244226,
-0.3243175745,
-0.4500717819,
-0.3424893022,
-0.4019254446,
-0.2171207517,
0.3222912252,
0.3671007454,
0.2460847646,
-0.3367253542,
0.9248118997,
-0.6345228553,
-0.0085599096,
-0.2989845574,
0.096327737,
0.6166086793,
0.2950633168,
0.0256533045,
-0.8776817322,
-0.3671931922,
-0.1458553672,
-0.4941914678,
0.1204707623,
-0.3916020393,
-0.4063908458,
-0.4958875775,
0.4860793352,
-0.8518048525,
0.4732299149,
0.3328822851,
-0.77260077,
0.4504487216,
-0.207366392,
-0.0097669605,
-0.8461660147,
0.122577019,
-0.2683269382,
-0.1552279741,
-0.4620562196,
0.4247128665,
-0.2727332115,
0.011928414,
-0.023528168,
0.4506593347,
-0.6171939373,
-0.0752328709,
-0.1238877252,
0.1381269395,
0.0996887162,
0.2931694388,
0.0868091211,
0.3547739685,
0.6972159147,
-0.4478264451,
0.796208322,
0.4051175416,
-0.0372534916,
0.4442743957,
-0.2286334634,
0.2383386195,
-0.3684408367,
0.9088044763,
-0.6676260233,
-0.0818335339,
0.0344924368,
-0.1919426322,
0.0090464707,
-0.2654509842,
-0.4680342972,
-0.5692084432,
-0.3152144551,
0.6951437593,
0.3257262111,
-0.5451979041,
0.9358790517,
-0.0835233256,
0.1661820412,
-0.5967081785,
-0.065480575,
0.0790533647,
-0.0269636288,
-0.5826179981,
0.2218283117,
-0.1670068949,
-0.1002239659,
-0.2229804993,
-0.5272016525,
0.1872291863,
0.1851923615,
0.1120608225,
-0.1530506015,
-0.1367084086,
0.1067195386,
0.2933662534,
-0.1428934932,
0.1514882743,
-0.5861716866,
0.4481144547,
0.0422498621,
-0.7460158467,
0.114006795,
0.3943375945,
0.5608472228,
-0.64907372,
0.2004076093,
0.4358737767,
-0.2285494506,
-0.4223640561,
-0.3218981922,
-0.2366314232,
-0.4786517024,
0.2976753116,
-0.6691595912,
-0.5733482242,
0.0004073433,
-0.4813774526,
0.3762726486,
0.3185796738,
0.181710273,
0.1808478236,
1.6119980812,
0.3327568471,
0.7078568935,
0.1665037572,
-0.2440148443,
0.7188883424,
-0.675647974,
-0.5369152427,
-0.3246625066,
-0.2667110562,
-0.6217508912,
-0.7059342265,
0.4645945728,
0.2618949711,
-0.1078950092,
0.2486969084,
-0.8862131834,
0.4358927608,
0.8826113343,
0.1238835603,
0.4488748014,
-0.3814384341,
-0.4355023503,
0.2619013786,
-1.0096770525,
-0.2006985247,
1.0145684481,
0.0928130671,
0.6594482064,
0.2417505085,
0.9306262136,
-0.1284902394,
-0.1179704368,
-0.8628545403,
0.7541139126,
0.2045626342,
-0.991014123,
-0.5424894094,
-0.4919268489,
-0.8525044322,
0.2736479938,
-0.2098972648,
-0.7194789052,
0.0449367948,
0.3583904803,
-0.4575003386,
0.2452191263,
-0.1490620971,
0.7416495085,
-0.5666439533,
-0.4049978256,
-0.4855671525,
-0.7485351562,
0.3817992508,
-0.0909000188,
0.1881869733,
-0.1823181808,
0.4908673167,
0.7047665715,
-0.3220082819,
0.2173326164,
-0.4190993309,
0.3171828985,
0.299875617,
0.6193907857,
0.9618908167,
-0.0354290456,
-0.0861449316,
-0.6062765718,
0.06705603,
-0.3260221481,
-0.555488646,
0.2801621556,
0.060544949,
-0.9206815958,
-0.59573102,
-0.7100667357,
-0.506242156,
0.6342375278,
-0.0205334518,
0.406644851,
0.0712000579,
0.1714712679,
0.4308125377,
-0.1854337156,
0.2263335586,
0.2046132833,
-0.2686712742,
0.0947442949,
0.6865693331,
-0.2636933029,
0.0711784363,
0.3083526194,
0.4111057818,
-0.3804155588,
-0.77369982,
-0.4520729184,
0.1559904218,
-0.8099976182,
-0.2309177071,
-0.5057783127,
-0.1688148081,
-0.1481395811,
-0.2059911191,
-0.2418296188,
-0.2357763201,
0.2768936753,
-0.3531532884,
0.2969810367,
0.9447235465,
0.0032713092,
0.1033858806,
-0.7791900635,
0.1663286835,
0.515656352,
0.3543395996,
0.0141489143,
0.1126259565,
-0.0975988656,
-0.0699245185,
-0.6187226176,
-0.9629663825,
0.2459653467,
0.0871226639,
0.7580214143,
0.230154261,
0.0526011437,
0.852694869,
-0.3869716525,
0.4925318956,
0.3598252833,
-0.7981129885,
1.0009837151,
-0.4199752808,
0.5971604586,
0.4742616117,
0.2471145242,
-0.446644932,
-0.578674674,
-0.6592307687,
-0.7827458978,
0.842920661,
0.3207063377,
-0.3523084521,
0.2451896816,
-0.1172254607,
-0.1589369625,
0.0284228399,
-0.4545767605,
0.1239878088,
-0.3174105883,
-0.0707038939,
0.1024599597,
-0.0556676574,
-0.1144713089,
-0.3131687343,
0.6182982922,
-0.4242099226,
-0.0416184254,
0.1786075681,
0.204869017,
-0.334944129,
0.210437268,
0.089330487,
0.7855692506,
-0.4666472971,
0.3047353625,
0.0322406106,
-0.2888089716,
0.3138442636,
0.3337537348,
-0.2149095237,
0.2339757383,
0.4765103757,
0.7404042482,
-0.1268681288,
-0.8129668832,
0.3137344122,
0.0067292135,
-0.2028031349,
0.2164190561,
0.4387840927,
0.129586041,
0.4197693467,
0.5028727055,
0.1419183612,
0.4326635003,
-0.51121521,
0.1564761996,
0.6642202139,
-0.1571473777,
-0.0217739344,
0.6266594529,
0.2828519642,
-0.497734189,
0.6582266092,
-0.3664348722,
-0.5110690594,
0.4140846431,
0.3842926025,
0.7683169842,
-0.2542508841,
0.4334716499,
0.6329941154,
0.3442666829,
-0.308362782,
0.2531301677,
-0.495944947,
-0.5214260817,
-0.443143785,
-0.684047997,
-0.4365320802,
-0.3039405048,
-0.1585691571,
0.2159204483,
-0.2845140994,
-0.1161829755,
-0.1659114212,
0.0830632895,
-0.4535286129,
0.3316885829,
0.0234499499,
1.0890543461,
-0.4455364645,
0.7806484699,
0.3774141967,
-0.1848831475,
-1.3715316057,
0.0672911555,
0.1114198416,
-0.4621042609,
0.6322263479,
0.3940346837,
-0.5964870453,
0.006854462,
-0.1380134672,
-1.1983138323,
1.4565694332,
0.1961571872,
-0.5157402754,
-0.6718456745,
-0.2736059427,
0.2017038167,
-0.3167416751,
0.636304915,
0.6618457437,
0.6730011702,
0.7526999116,
-0.7387790084,
0.2329814434,
-0.1804802269,
-0.1070809364,
0.4615836442,
-0.2249487042,
0.7011119127,
-0.1894708425,
-0.2883898616,
-0.175009653,
-0.1007352993,
0.9310467243,
0.527389586,
0.5060106516,
0.3125956655,
0.8408831358,
0.044976227,
0.7068556547,
-0.2509652376,
0.1985982507,
0.8650694489,
-0.2629568875,
0.4533002973,
0.3706385195,
0.0040405635,
0.8011065125,
0.7904179096,
0.1924380511,
0.5546035767,
0.1418651044,
-0.1053687483,
-0.6468928456,
-0.1066181287,
-0.00574899,
0.5090223551,
0.3356419802,
-0.2716461122,
-0.5806494951,
-0.5010459423,
-0.1229978874,
-0.0559516884,
-0.2731890082,
0.3369051218,
-0.1687995493,
-1.2246804237,
0.4069146514,
0.0148966676,
0.260946095,
-0.8026365638,
-0.5563930869,
-0.2618892491,
-0.0122639555,
-0.337143153,
-0.8299244642,
0.1741634309,
-0.1256989837,
0.2933087349,
-0.6274486184,
0.7802587748,
-0.1011580527,
-0.5494551063,
0.5699816942,
0.6450520754,
-0.0763827637,
-0.0518769622,
-0.6386362314,
-0.1454222053,
0.2475954145,
-0.440579921,
-0.2505967021,
0.4185991585,
-0.1882179379,
0.8164663911,
0.855058074,
0.1604272723,
0.1917234063,
-0.2194689363,
0.7865465879,
-0.9118719697,
-0.5612530112,
-0.6131693125,
0.4976612628,
-0.1713288724,
-0.1976761073,
0.6759282351,
0.5210078359,
0.5758296251,
0.3572431803,
0.3984778225,
-0.051701542,
0.4309156239,
-0.5763394237,
0.0956682265,
-0.5179914236,
0.2473871559,
-0.2775073647,
-1.1156656742,
-0.3247106373,
0.67692554,
-0.0867591649,
0.107740052,
0.9793345332,
0.793900907,
-0.3334067464,
-0.1353846639,
0.1687105298,
-0.0799081698,
0.7409800291,
0.9999698997,
0.822714448,
-0.1293499172,
0.8665565848,
0.2636710703,
-0.2471735328,
-0.1298379749,
-0.7754198909,
-0.6246417165,
-0.3601039648,
0.0107435333,
-0.2725438476,
0.0784551352,
0.5355405211,
1.0181958675,
-0.3460192978,
-0.3186919093,
-0.8506058455,
0.3475646675,
-0.4395343363,
-0.1604717374,
0.0288358126,
-0.1557910591,
-0.2351925075,
0.9172238111,
0.5030249953,
-0.4860687852,
-0.2757970095,
-0.3363826573,
-0.5881787539,
0.2827106714,
0.4397732615,
0.007566663,
-0.7394236326,
-0.1695235819,
0.2121844441,
0.2319554538,
0.0311677288,
0.894153893,
-1.0125640631,
0.8900748491,
0.4315527081,
0.2426772863,
1.0062770844,
0.0093551464,
0.707292676,
-0.5567728281,
-0.1491278559,
0.6131390333,
0.2413881868,
0.1367440522,
-0.2862010002,
0.6461267471,
0.2422259748,
-0.3587933183,
-0.7202526927,
0.7901499867,
-0.7846264243,
-0.3894588053,
1.078024745,
0.0785864964,
0.124671109,
-0.0048746122,
-0.3838281929,
0.1998374164,
-0.4258624613,
0.2225084305,
0.5623128414,
-0.6171348095,
-0.1587443054,
-0.145216763,
0.6589155793,
0.2738874853,
-0.5815415978,
0.0716935247,
0.7682594657,
-0.1593748182,
0.4336883128,
0.7984411716,
0.2840919197,
0.5531267524,
0.3018034995,
-0.596193552,
-0.0709546655,
-0.5489812493,
0.1066695303,
0.3194372356,
0.4522490799,
0.0681414157
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05172v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05172v1
|
From Lengthy to Lucid: A Systematic Literature Review on NLP Techniques for Taming Long Sentences
| 2023-12-08T16:51:29 | 2023-12-08T16:51:29 |
Tatiana Passali, Efstathios Chatzikyriakidis, Stelios Andreadis, Thanos G. Stavropoulos, Anastasia Matonaki, Anestis Fachantidis, Grigorios Tsoumakas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Long sentences have been a persistent issue in written communication for many
years since they make it challenging for readers to grasp the main points or
follow the initial intention of the writer. This survey, conducted using the
PRISMA guidelines, systematically reviews two main strategies for addressing
the issue of long sentences: a) sentence compression and b) sentence splitting.
An increased trend of interest in this area has been observed since 2005, with
significant growth after 2017. Current research is dominated by supervised
approaches for both sentence compression and splitting. Yet, there is a
considerable gap in weakly and self-supervised techniques, suggesting an
opportunity for further research, especially in domains with limited data. In
this survey, we categorize and group the most representative methods into a
comprehensive taxonomy. We also conduct a comparative evaluation analysis of
these methods on common sentence compression and splitting datasets. Finally,
we discuss the challenges and limitations of current methods, providing
valuable insights for future research directions. This survey is meant to serve
as a comprehensive resource for addressing the complexities of long sentences.
We aim to enable researchers to make further advancements in the field until
long sentences are no longer a barrier to effective communication.
|
[
-0.5364430547,
-1.1045497656,
0.6259578466,
0.6443964839,
-0.5061827302,
0.2850060463,
-0.4065526426,
-0.9548117518,
0.5446798205,
0.7721546888,
-0.3946542144,
-0.1396288425,
-0.5733222365,
0.6663161516,
-0.463237375,
1.0016181469,
-0.0899757519,
-0.2065902948,
-0.1751643121,
-0.0609525405,
-0.5311993361,
-0.4435025454,
-0.3596892059,
0.0905077159,
0.7639692426,
0.2409598082,
0.6487796307,
0.3065003753,
0.8130307794,
0.2657321393,
-0.3396144807,
0.3197531402,
-0.3104674518,
0.4563831389,
-0.0406649224,
-0.2685492933,
-0.3463896215,
-0.2685355842,
0.7869462967,
1.0428210497,
-0.0063667446,
-0.0215519127,
0.2171882242,
0.8940050602,
-0.4851042032,
-0.2004422396,
-0.0548765585,
0.1243683919,
-0.7014781237,
-0.3900590539,
-0.474221915,
-0.2180233747,
-0.0363964215,
-0.3471111953,
-0.1215786263,
0.2298277617,
0.4916782677,
0.1729284525,
-0.6460208297,
-0.5942590833,
-0.7224336267,
1.1096222401,
-0.4710714221,
-0.1761366427,
0.2259916663,
0.0867016912,
-0.2494966686,
-0.8660175204,
-0.2915146649,
-0.0955184102,
-0.1614004672,
-0.002182048,
-0.0631049871,
0.2098635137,
0.6096130013,
0.1284677833,
-0.7364735603,
0.3185747266,
-0.7061071396,
0.1578157544,
0.9410161972,
0.0397225358,
0.5452708602,
-0.6545599103,
-0.6298868656,
0.1877116859,
-0.5122461915,
0.0014345372,
0.4051662385,
0.0895017982,
0.4030891657,
0.7921261191,
-0.3092293739,
0.9142241478,
-0.3227627873,
-0.2859446704,
0.285833329,
-0.5557268858,
-0.1258323193,
0.0406383388,
0.9157999754,
0.5373057127,
0.208907187,
-0.2798188925,
-0.2047668397,
-0.2013629973,
0.1847117394,
-0.72138834,
0.2959446907,
0.4147237539,
-0.5427385569,
-0.0894057378,
-0.0849935785,
-1.2340985537,
-0.1212785617,
-0.2573164999,
-0.1954374611,
-0.2033320367,
0.0111409444,
0.533721745,
-0.1108692959,
0.2166443914,
0.1174694598,
-1.0212594271,
0.5420525074,
1.0366344452,
1.0834499598,
-0.5215110779,
-0.17554681,
-0.2656105459,
-0.0703808218,
-0.2056794316,
0.801807344,
-0.1841021627,
-0.381919235,
0.1569899172,
-0.0932995677,
0.0100141438,
-0.3433521688,
1.0146154165,
-0.2331999093,
0.7144345045,
-0.028223224,
-0.6533614993,
0.1037634909,
0.1637622416,
-0.6341263056,
0.7277960181,
-0.0768924505,
-0.8831143379,
0.1604052484,
-0.662983954,
-0.5012952685,
0.1525331289,
0.0360812806,
-0.5300713181,
0.0086246356,
0.4851585627,
0.6934072375,
-0.3471660018,
0.2589562535,
-0.1954942644,
-0.4109578729,
0.1937214881,
-0.3783873916,
0.9901583195,
0.2366358191,
-0.2137463093,
0.133984074,
-0.5317130685,
0.2541824579,
-0.0902053863,
0.2214358896,
-0.5200906992,
-0.0157385394,
0.3731938303,
0.2999633849,
0.0865930021,
-0.6281808615,
0.5581194162,
-0.4454317093,
0.7221304774,
0.3859913647,
0.2614333034,
0.4078111947,
-0.343203485,
0.7500171065,
-0.4206348658,
0.4965865016,
-0.1307079345,
-0.3621032238,
-0.5537145138,
-0.2029446512,
0.3207680285,
0.3908745348,
-0.8484833241,
0.8524523973,
-0.4921569824,
-0.2166532874,
-0.5281957984,
0.2920734584,
0.1105089113,
0.2170373648,
0.7642133236,
-0.4582586586,
-0.3376615047,
-0.8608341217,
-0.2703827918,
0.102748543,
-0.0877364352,
0.0219544303,
0.7682212591,
-0.0962916538,
1.1407302618,
-0.549484551,
-0.4143236578,
-0.4038667381,
0.3303066194,
0.0668428093,
0.42551139,
0.3890751302,
-0.8210472465,
-0.5712871552,
-0.5773166418,
-0.8130643368,
-0.0209671315,
-0.5913280249,
0.1268573701,
0.2321525365,
0.4868764281,
-0.9509469867,
0.3657310605,
0.4767469764,
-0.3091448843,
0.5192709565,
0.1335756332,
0.0346378349,
-0.9407866597,
-0.1577427536,
-0.0725540072,
-0.2558534443,
-0.4642129838,
0.1554125994,
-0.0738194808,
0.1315318495,
-0.2132022679,
0.3175245225,
-1.0678460598,
0.1855714917,
-0.4753006995,
0.1753622591,
-0.070340097,
0.0485814326,
0.0172647163,
0.5152801871,
0.418505013,
-0.0487111136,
0.6865695119,
0.2673083246,
-0.7004802823,
0.4393815398,
-0.8257197142,
0.2465772778,
-0.2623381317,
0.6331548095,
-0.5261082649,
-0.0565570369,
0.4540108442,
-0.1379716992,
0.2420421988,
-0.0373670943,
-0.6267752647,
-0.4296286106,
-0.4528105259,
0.4900779426,
0.6875832677,
-0.3900521398,
0.2505839467,
0.0556771308,
-0.5576604009,
-0.8453615904,
-0.7816408873,
0.6902285218,
-0.4824596941,
-0.9252346754,
0.3795560598,
-0.170388937,
-0.4229742289,
-0.4132458568,
0.1134018674,
-0.1314396858,
0.0153570296,
0.0793024227,
-0.0326277055,
0.0571025535,
0.3119091392,
0.0169942714,
-0.0577473193,
0.2032901943,
0.2951206565,
0.4630634487,
0.1057450622,
0.0501937605,
-0.3297415078,
0.7771652341,
0.1928609163,
-0.2695691288,
0.5193818808,
0.4759986103,
0.0601664484,
-0.4935641289,
-0.6636741757,
-0.2431265265,
-0.3831793964,
0.0456730127,
-0.0521116741,
-0.9180923104,
-0.0299309175,
-0.2931170166,
-0.03406436,
0.0471319743,
0.0114222104,
-0.2028029263,
0.647369504,
0.8713192344,
-0.0864958987,
0.2565394938,
-0.0215919167,
0.6070449352,
-0.8596822023,
0.0251051057,
-0.4173675478,
-0.2695681751,
-0.3852551579,
-0.6610011458,
0.1508489102,
0.3798906505,
0.7474016547,
-0.0232260022,
-0.8014409542,
0.4454277754,
0.0627815127,
-0.1766480207,
0.2273463458,
-0.1649723649,
0.564718008,
-0.1166708767,
-0.4814283252,
-0.3417046666,
0.9318088293,
0.5341615081,
0.570605576,
0.0078165391,
0.9742501974,
0.1565367132,
-0.1311798394,
-0.9779548645,
0.6679054499,
0.3071118593,
-0.4891251624,
-0.68256706,
-0.5375394821,
-1.372084856,
0.2355802953,
-0.0402792096,
-0.4666033983,
0.0377646349,
-0.4778138399,
-0.3230741024,
0.059106186,
-0.3308487833,
0.5728700161,
-0.4798759818,
-0.5243960023,
0.0322524011,
-1.2392604351,
0.4671565592,
-0.122926563,
0.0841957703,
-0.1673355848,
-0.2592385709,
0.9063999057,
-0.4663825035,
0.6050883532,
0.2417770475,
-0.0118870977,
0.2305614054,
-0.4045521319,
0.3787808418,
-0.0817778334,
0.2847473323,
-0.0858245715,
0.0225224886,
-0.7183008194,
-0.7764614224,
0.4658469558,
-0.0449377038,
-0.33138448,
-0.9336359501,
-0.2934999466,
-0.2106035501,
0.1595183909,
0.3539140224,
0.1776981652,
-0.1833601892,
0.5894171,
0.5108242035,
0.1370741129,
0.8372884989,
0.0179494713,
-0.2603327632,
-0.3196158111,
0.3213319182,
0.2654841542,
0.0922642127,
0.1351019442,
-0.0385462977,
-0.2575568855,
-0.8473486304,
-0.0751784369,
0.4416551292,
-0.1758516729,
-0.073446773,
-0.5294938684,
-0.1397501677,
-0.6099862456,
-0.3540278077,
-0.093928501,
-0.4269174635,
-0.2756684422,
-0.0555663258,
0.1064819917,
0.6698520184,
0.2098535299,
0.0747687966,
-0.7262532711,
0.4666593969,
0.0083461339,
0.065238215,
-0.2686348855,
-0.0426633283,
-0.0522939377,
-0.3129324019,
0.1635921448,
-0.8782615662,
0.657789886,
-0.0276430175,
0.0425137021,
0.235066846,
0.4158536196,
0.7888630629,
-0.4191981852,
1.0450710058,
0.4374663532,
-0.7092583179,
0.560649395,
-0.2057838887,
0.4088032842,
0.5770585537,
0.7750977874,
-0.8193097115,
-0.205601275,
-0.4022422135,
-1.255312562,
0.0346978828,
0.1900669932,
0.2390057147,
-0.0295172576,
0.3828315139,
-0.0423784144,
0.1148465872,
-0.7973462939,
0.0610590763,
0.3503678441,
-0.1493088603,
-0.2645069659,
-0.6557492614,
-0.4694212079,
0.0134397205,
0.3058954179,
-0.133373037,
-0.1630665809,
0.3894249201,
-0.2811921537,
0.3299280405,
0.7098825574,
0.4393147826,
0.9512283802,
-0.099632591,
-0.0833805725,
-0.2400759757,
-0.3413156271,
-0.1354958415,
0.208261773,
-0.4582839608,
0.1413245201,
0.6458613276,
0.5241866708,
0.0207979418,
-0.7161538005,
0.8019480705,
0.0309973005,
-0.2529076636,
-0.5996768475,
-0.3866560459,
-0.339206785,
-0.0604855493,
0.2401846945,
-0.1072637886,
0.4258370101,
-0.5682837963,
0.082953766,
0.3524230421,
-0.2726351619,
0.063989751,
-0.0118160229,
0.4192811549,
-0.1478825659,
0.924960494,
0.0480725914,
-0.1427167207,
0.2818033993,
0.3597007692,
0.6464423537,
0.1110095978,
0.3194417953,
0.0378836058,
0.284302175,
-0.5143606067,
0.0820067227,
-0.2960976362,
-0.32308653,
-0.6585534811,
-0.4450699687,
-0.2547796369,
-0.0899747834,
-0.8940466642,
0.1618130207,
-0.2164383978,
-0.3944405317,
0.0841667801,
0.3866963983,
0.0493533425,
-0.1003650129,
0.047937993,
0.9048332572,
-0.5218624473,
0.6442327499,
-0.0042429981,
-0.4519754648,
-0.2841028571,
-0.0320771374,
-0.1040206403,
-0.048114337,
0.2538267374,
0.2977889776,
-0.2193710059,
-0.3230215013,
-0.8347590566,
-0.4875091314,
0.8216377497,
-0.1081915498,
-0.6434326172,
-0.5075019002,
0.1112459749,
0.7774856687,
-0.1006679907,
-0.0149631314,
0.5421395898,
0.483897686,
-0.3163508177,
-1.0271385908,
-0.0282146372,
-0.1951744258,
-0.0161490459,
0.2271449417,
-0.853946209,
0.4334235489,
-0.0198687427,
-0.3590419292,
0.592818439,
0.780479908,
-0.0215128679,
0.2905268073,
0.4925521612,
0.3017100692,
0.7053446174,
-0.0927599147,
0.8369958997,
-0.2345466316,
0.3996443748,
1.0345312357,
-0.4523755312,
1.0311927795,
0.9162790775,
0.1070946008,
0.644724071,
0.2763690352,
-0.3966460824,
-0.0167659745,
0.5740346909,
-0.3806553483,
-0.0877072066,
-0.1931819171,
-0.3997791409,
0.3658565879,
0.2548812628,
-0.3710430861,
0.0466389433,
0.4368565381,
0.3460238576,
0.2960479856,
-0.1976142377,
0.6567364931,
0.304679364,
-0.9955675602,
0.3978382647,
0.0528896041,
1.1713796854,
-0.8194538951,
0.0036690449,
-0.0244632289,
-0.1405986696,
-0.3914149404,
-1.0234341621,
0.2616078854,
0.0272444841,
0.0479684807,
-1.0607751608,
0.8960925341,
-0.5353906751,
-0.1851633936,
0.3138192892,
0.4491292238,
0.3316733837,
-0.0440875851,
-0.6427636743,
0.1042702496,
-0.1293460876,
-0.3526825905,
0.2770439684,
0.0955362394,
0.1629236341,
0.7313073277,
0.4030854404,
0.2223486453,
0.0315012001,
0.0613148846,
0.5182331204,
-0.9564771056,
-0.329766959,
-0.5439119339,
0.4475511611,
-0.6106792688,
-0.5403324366,
1.1023519039,
0.7185251117,
0.4395343363,
0.1729494184,
0.4506525695,
0.1133326516,
0.6918210387,
-0.7532139421,
0.4942517281,
-0.2520304918,
0.0322007425,
-0.0663747862,
-0.9143791795,
-0.6116108298,
0.3545796275,
-0.2941399813,
-0.0450688377,
0.9987593293,
0.4199334383,
0.1944001466,
0.1120216846,
0.0980547443,
0.0556372777,
0.3433882594,
0.5364774466,
0.9376396537,
-0.2463802397,
0.3764271438,
-0.5089632273,
-0.0133797126,
-0.1696695834,
-0.7625794411,
-0.7001098394,
-0.4039154649,
-0.306340307,
-0.3525215685,
0.2900381982,
0.7027419806,
0.6085782051,
-0.0927005559,
-0.2592904866,
0.0563596636,
0.18725501,
-0.2534311414,
-0.2234032154,
0.4423333704,
-0.5386084318,
-0.8740526438,
0.556357801,
0.4114412665,
-0.0204041842,
-0.3577591777,
0.4228990674,
-0.1090778261,
0.0412812158,
0.8469884992,
0.5563893318,
-0.5459913015,
-0.2060584873,
-0.0255549848,
-0.3100235462,
-0.0089444462,
0.9760798812,
-0.5347248316,
0.5146811008,
0.7857143283,
0.3758948445,
0.5241369009,
0.1955254972,
0.3887723684,
-0.6251123548,
-0.0479048975,
0.8457698822,
0.1986729205,
0.402030617,
-0.291130513,
0.6747941375,
0.1139683276,
-0.7920388579,
-1.085168004,
0.2319032699,
-1.7518316507,
-0.608350873,
1.2856016159,
-0.0110442033,
-0.2839870155,
-0.3313426375,
-0.1009648815,
-0.299418062,
-0.0599698313,
0.8815656304,
0.8739109635,
-0.3877180517,
-0.1016609445,
-0.4461531043,
0.7357718945,
0.5350251794,
-1.0133544207,
0.0194403473,
0.64441818,
0.1141558215,
0.3033619523,
0.767609477,
-0.1337578595,
0.0208711401,
-0.2040769607,
-0.1205460727,
0.1768442392,
-0.5605207682,
-0.6550487876,
0.5181447864,
-0.1688417643,
0.356939882
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.10075v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.10075v1
|
Assessing LLMs for Moral Value Pluralism
| 2023-12-08T16:18:15 | 2023-12-08T16:18:15 |
Noam Benkler, Drisana Mosaphir, Scott Friedman, Andrew Smart, Sonja Schmer-Galunder
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The fields of AI current lacks methods to quantitatively assess and
potentially alter the moral values inherent in the output of large language
models (LLMs). However, decades of social science research has developed and
refined widely-accepted moral value surveys, such as the World Values Survey
(WVS), eliciting value judgments from direct questions in various geographies.
We have turned those questions into value statements and use NLP to compute to
how well popular LLMs are aligned with moral values for various demographics
and cultures. While the WVS is accepted as an explicit assessment of values, we
lack methods for assessing implicit moral and cultural values in media, e.g.,
encountered in social media, political rhetoric, narratives, and generated by
AI systems such as LLMs that are increasingly present in our daily lives. As we
consume online content and utilize LLM outputs, we might ask, which moral
values are being implicitly promoted or undercut, or -- in the case of LLMs --
if they are intending to represent a cultural identity, are they doing so
consistently? In this paper we utilize a Recognizing Value Resonance (RVR) NLP
model to identify WVS values that resonate and conflict with a given passage of
output text. We apply RVR to the text generated by LLMs to characterize
implicit moral values, allowing us to quantify the moral/cultural distance
between LLMs and various demographics that have been surveyed using the WVS. In
line with other work we find that LLMs exhibit several Western-centric value
biases; they overestimate how conservative people in non-Western countries are,
they are less accurate in representing gender for non-Western countries, and
portray older populations as having more traditional values. Our results
highlight value misalignment and age groups, and a need for social science
informed technological solutions addressing value plurality in LLMs.
|
[
-0.3683221936,
-0.3456962705,
0.4037451446,
0.2797914743,
-0.3192951977,
0.2351340652,
-0.1083974913,
-0.6460959315,
0.0431815609,
0.2447673082,
-0.4487567544,
-0.3449772,
-0.8100661039,
0.1723642349,
-0.048868902,
0.8317600489,
0.4057855606,
0.280113101,
-0.3532988429,
-0.5853351355,
-0.1064469367,
-0.5033042431,
-0.4119084179,
-0.2257981896,
0.5646769404,
0.1406699121,
0.5485099554,
0.1623836309,
0.5940100551,
0.3169620931,
-0.5690382719,
0.1988271922,
-0.8259524107,
0.0440110415,
-0.2595672011,
-0.0835728645,
-0.3740382791,
0.482195884,
0.5497445464,
0.550560534,
0.2771148384,
0.7367753386,
-0.0698950961,
0.9013932943,
-0.5511267185,
0.0215203706,
-0.7655321956,
0.2543602586,
0.0383667685,
-0.3130416572,
-0.1600825042,
-0.9785414338,
0.2099332362,
-0.1892239749,
-0.0293527264,
-0.0741699859,
0.8866475224,
0.0924704596,
-0.7084283233,
-0.4360464215,
-0.7352218032,
1.2110849619,
-0.4257280529,
0.2965789735,
0.2457091659,
-0.0574543178,
-0.0739388615,
-0.3926612139,
-0.6528223753,
-0.1957154125,
0.1101663113,
0.3753299117,
-0.138520807,
-0.2410527319,
0.2759688497,
0.4389887154,
-0.1217863038,
0.1172120124,
-0.5921969414,
0.069716461,
0.9586397409,
0.3738686144,
0.2807304859,
-0.4027585685,
-0.4974938929,
-0.0993467495,
-0.6818662286,
0.7878838778,
0.6781096458,
0.1486658603,
-0.0177351702,
0.7135784626,
0.2622536719,
0.3593154848,
0.0347666927,
-0.3238370717,
0.0985967368,
-0.5259977579,
0.0850027204,
0.1247628257,
0.8692093492,
0.9789433479,
0.8456603885,
0.526664257,
-0.1406142861,
0.1078578755,
0.2362394631,
-0.771477282,
0.5661156774,
0.0154375862,
-0.7728593946,
-0.466082871,
-0.0636183396,
-0.5248844028,
-0.5171641707,
-0.3257266581,
-0.0894428045,
-0.2140846252,
-0.1886452734,
0.1204130352,
-0.3955555856,
0.4904156029,
0.4219612181,
-0.8654367328,
0.0969601944,
0.5491371155,
0.7915475965,
-0.165206641,
0.0692959055,
-0.3541906178,
0.0088649727,
-0.4624515772,
0.7693806887,
-0.6918407679,
-0.7719113231,
-0.0555637851,
-0.0644086078,
0.3836823702,
-0.3785689771,
0.519947648,
-0.5182626843,
0.2056239992,
-0.7006539106,
-0.351238668,
-0.0218069144,
0.4629344344,
-0.736841619,
0.9149680138,
-0.0572360791,
-0.8001383543,
0.4656907618,
-0.4009647369,
-0.2365975082,
0.2288997322,
-0.3275541961,
-0.3824207485,
0.2138638943,
-0.0247124508,
0.3528394699,
-0.371794641,
0.4005325735,
-0.4499360323,
-0.6397536397,
0.4142124653,
-0.9880937338,
0.8721573353,
-0.0124826832,
-0.1339094639,
0.1335788965,
-0.5246196985,
0.0644854084,
0.2452618927,
-0.3899223208,
-0.5395559072,
0.1740598828,
0.0388261303,
0.0941307768,
0.3878321648,
-0.577634573,
0.1552300155,
-0.2388721555,
0.1839214563,
1.1581882238,
-0.0439504124,
0.2499572933,
-0.5721036196,
0.4559371471,
-0.2986543477,
0.3796901107,
0.45941028,
-0.6066997647,
-0.48969993,
-0.0892946199,
-0.1702458262,
0.5728721619,
-0.1062176898,
0.3969132006,
-0.2848369479,
-0.4537242353,
-0.5690078139,
-0.1187156662,
0.0367961824,
0.2049586624,
0.4008146524,
-0.2797401547,
-0.4247103035,
-0.9461239576,
-0.5187692642,
-0.7385961413,
-0.1447010189,
0.4306744039,
0.4640455246,
-0.0736925155,
0.912442863,
-0.2737076879,
-0.2211806476,
-0.0505555458,
0.1942673922,
0.0800665915,
0.0418868624,
0.0526695848,
-0.9892293215,
-0.2929476202,
-0.0208619051,
-0.7098834515,
-0.2309219986,
0.1253484488,
0.2264400721,
0.1254408956,
0.0970801786,
-0.105004631,
0.3456210494,
0.6816453934,
-0.408690691,
0.5940672159,
0.1615327895,
0.5721237063,
-0.8484668732,
0.1433004439,
0.1393022239,
0.0821342766,
-0.0385725014,
-0.521137476,
-0.1075689867,
0.3066190779,
-0.7498058081,
0.5965209603,
-0.2507815957,
-0.2889356017,
-0.011147867,
0.2744936347,
0.067257151,
-0.1269539446,
-0.009650561,
0.8761799932,
-0.1586938947,
-0.4700622261,
0.5416378975,
0.3027836084,
-0.1435954571,
0.9977064729,
-0.6853690743,
-0.0666772574,
-0.4578554928,
0.2930014133,
-0.8252073526,
0.2054124326,
0.1313423961,
-0.5337052345,
-0.3317336738,
-0.5875269175,
-0.1578887403,
-0.1479874104,
-0.5198162198,
0.6762632728,
0.6629596353,
-0.3089597225,
0.5824522972,
0.6571435928,
-0.3245275915,
-1.0100530386,
-0.3954544365,
-0.0288248826,
-0.495662123,
-0.8526213765,
0.2283126861,
-0.1557684541,
-0.7113440633,
0.0368115082,
-0.0668785423,
0.1590347439,
-0.1091486588,
0.1883060783,
0.2743546069,
-0.1195429787,
0.3428418934,
0.1865659654,
-0.1626052856,
0.2029819787,
-0.0827809647,
0.2852121294,
-0.9358786345,
-0.4612547755,
-0.0520348102,
0.397529006,
0.7479855418,
-0.4687580466,
0.6210286617,
0.7941539288,
-0.2495051026,
0.0575875789,
-0.6774181724,
0.0826459453,
-0.5014125705,
0.1043273658,
0.0470976494,
-1.0984176397,
0.5115651488,
-0.0373233967,
0.0463721044,
0.4954253435,
0.5677850246,
-0.3499951363,
0.8239066005,
0.3699706197,
0.1707850546,
0.3022400439,
-0.347753197,
0.1692062765,
-0.8160626292,
-0.4288675189,
-0.459492147,
-0.3701256514,
-0.8652408123,
-0.4088313878,
0.583211422,
-0.0675620213,
-0.3370419741,
-0.3036195338,
-0.5637736917,
0.6492288113,
0.2582868636,
-0.4110172093,
0.6108583808,
-0.0886127353,
0.0817580596,
-0.3862133324,
-0.2821424305,
-1.1210938692,
0.8037935495,
0.3488856256,
0.8782309294,
0.1709005684,
0.4307141304,
0.669946909,
0.529103756,
-1.0813837051,
0.6247939467,
-0.3715237379,
-0.3615876734,
-0.4396369457,
-0.3956467509,
-1.1788998842,
0.4866075218,
-0.2625444531,
-0.575666368,
0.1988130361,
-0.1132207736,
-0.2245765924,
0.4508908689,
-0.0899177939,
0.5916748047,
-0.4449091852,
-0.3784853518,
-0.1673891246,
-0.5801888704,
0.5065850019,
0.2070767134,
0.2838089764,
-0.6404477358,
-0.1263308376,
0.6893793941,
0.1438728124,
0.911706388,
0.0677880347,
-0.3884481192,
0.3300025463,
-0.0020226887,
0.1194504574,
0.3344396055,
-0.1387044638,
0.4079927206,
0.3832731545,
-0.2223688364,
-0.1727905869,
0.7186994553,
-0.885763526,
-0.6285448074,
-0.7365797162,
-0.5197485685,
0.0742571726,
0.0399690606,
0.0771074146,
0.1902820319,
-0.6294458508,
0.2938588858,
0.7307676673,
-0.4826185107,
0.3506051898,
0.4894780815,
-0.1080472916,
-0.3919334114,
0.7044094801,
0.1973998845,
0.3781660795,
0.073479034,
0.5274480581,
-0.6853224635,
-0.124894008,
-0.4780035615,
0.2501721382,
-0.9230811596,
0.0249991715,
-0.4919596314,
-0.1707928777,
-0.0957940891,
-0.3592486978,
-0.4367758632,
-0.0896224976,
-0.2209440172,
-0.0369126722,
0.4792086482,
0.8897159696,
0.028046608,
-0.3214716911,
-1.0008852482,
0.341881156,
0.3848656416,
0.3429926038,
-0.2945165932,
-0.5093095303,
0.2966226637,
0.1754082441,
-0.1458929926,
-0.8031927943,
0.233651951,
-0.1154616103,
0.4899685681,
0.33072716,
0.2950702906,
0.6851338744,
-0.3954190016,
0.9422100186,
0.0631619394,
-1.0832418203,
0.3143677413,
-0.1707922965,
-0.0308865495,
0.4542517364,
0.6260024905,
-1.0831012726,
-0.3964743614,
-0.5462070704,
-0.7697541118,
0.2387088537,
0.0301400349,
0.5863928199,
-0.2437680364,
0.0141374841,
-0.0302900467,
0.1084736437,
-1.0623117685,
-0.1063069627,
-0.1506260633,
-0.3816584647,
0.3201165497,
-0.1814330667,
-0.3185483813,
-0.1841326952,
0.3838270903,
-0.2732375264,
0.0311515853,
0.2962923348,
0.0655697435,
-0.3943775594,
0.4916699529,
0.494307071,
0.8104819059,
-0.1917521954,
0.1687069237,
0.371563375,
-0.3785293996,
0.6706946492,
-0.2918605804,
-0.2077257931,
-0.1731107235,
0.2161765844,
0.2382656038,
-0.3419198096,
-0.7613168359,
0.8496733904,
-0.3226799965,
0.0548802614,
-0.7678025365,
-0.1528388709,
0.3126688898,
0.2645273507,
0.3675741851,
0.0695813373,
-0.0262519661,
-0.5445484519,
-0.0217423029,
0.8241660595,
-0.7018360496,
-0.0275939628,
0.3048275411,
0.2602688372,
-0.4581773281,
0.6909935474,
-0.2863428295,
-0.4067094028,
0.7575852871,
0.2531595826,
0.555573523,
-0.1845903993,
0.3033283651,
0.3163881004,
0.6166534424,
0.0840308368,
0.3663663566,
0.3151642382,
-1.0387086868,
-0.5754886866,
-0.7743787169,
-0.3002669215,
0.1139438152,
-0.7990370393,
0.2282401472,
-0.4066343606,
-0.3287764192,
-0.4071750045,
-0.0253235996,
-0.4319422841,
0.2200049162,
0.2503858209,
0.3465437591,
-0.9947490692,
0.3160869181,
0.3506254554,
-0.3932513893,
-0.3165888488,
0.0561228245,
0.1814731359,
-0.8438791633,
0.7823030353,
0.3017604649,
-0.6942307949,
-0.1359403431,
-0.5469210744,
-0.8303278089,
0.9926782846,
0.1169143543,
-0.3243398368,
0.254421562,
0.3136979043,
0.6633483768,
-0.3303772807,
0.2802628875,
0.3509443998,
0.6652932167,
0.0639651865,
-0.6815065742,
0.0356263481,
-0.3725358248,
0.196393922,
0.1139135212,
-0.7049828172,
0.5546576381,
-0.3206875622,
-0.3351038992,
-0.2589800656,
0.5701293945,
0.6160215139,
0.4705291092,
0.678268373,
-0.0216383524,
0.7770947814,
0.0154159879,
0.8527814746,
-0.0326358899,
0.33214733,
0.5059342384,
-0.2897047698,
0.6915953159,
0.5540646911,
-0.2793139219,
0.3944615722,
0.5097038746,
-0.3818794489,
-0.0342734233,
0.4922325611,
-0.3233858049,
-0.1410705149,
-0.6045652032,
-0.3992937207,
0.5379717946,
0.5311217308,
-0.3018879592,
0.2801727355,
-0.3669757843,
-0.0794988871,
0.3181250095,
-0.269701153,
0.7065737844,
0.3791404068,
-0.4531073868,
0.5769830942,
0.1139170751,
0.7800802588,
-0.7607690096,
-0.0913259089,
-0.1744344532,
-0.1161272749,
-0.2115645558,
-1.0973886251,
0.3899111152,
0.2594175339,
-0.1382057667,
-0.3626126051,
0.5869781375,
-0.3800751567,
-0.7059713006,
0.5921335816,
0.5870648026,
0.0897408128,
0.3466757834,
-0.6641575694,
0.0907170996,
-0.1213053986,
-0.1027672365,
0.1177875623,
0.2622713447,
-0.2403367609,
0.9359349012,
0.821883738,
0.167243138,
-0.0605760179,
0.3052251041,
0.4327961504,
-0.8168854713,
-0.2815075517,
-0.9829093218,
0.6012402773,
-0.1482485384,
-0.5164996982,
0.6171446443,
0.3200164735,
0.9960718155,
0.2729260027,
0.7257128358,
0.1015448049,
0.0110175852,
-0.5568321943,
0.7148037553,
-0.5901382565,
0.4205526114,
-0.3530454934,
-0.8545790315,
0.0350999124,
0.7262327671,
-0.4169687033,
0.2583899498,
0.4224517047,
0.591478169,
0.1400644779,
0.2342577875,
0.3736965954,
-0.0302385427,
0.3706827462,
0.1939223856,
1.6363043785,
-0.1519633532,
0.6027104259,
0.0381855108,
-0.1563092321,
0.0276603941,
-1.0200690031,
-0.5893947482,
-0.3477070034,
-0.0455238,
-0.3853904009,
-0.0610734597,
1.1692866087,
0.2861480117,
-0.4825571775,
-0.5246693492,
0.5058578253,
0.3235214949,
-0.2098206729,
-0.2550899386,
0.1583933383,
0.0311641749,
-0.8406880498,
0.1939210594,
0.3946138024,
0.1031254083,
-0.4425208569,
-0.1102572158,
0.020607926,
0.3729778826,
0.8586696386,
-0.1000840142,
-1.0805599689,
-0.5551383495,
-0.0593359247,
-0.239884004,
0.1179993823,
0.6915150285,
-0.3321909904,
0.1965410262,
0.4866386354,
0.4455241561,
0.146547243,
0.2663135529,
0.4799487889,
-0.4691589475,
-0.2198807597,
0.7759960294,
0.3134535849,
0.4254663289,
-0.4083714485,
0.2700821757,
0.3894146979,
-0.5857514739,
-0.5439683795,
0.5764350891,
-1.0357036591,
-0.1790307015,
1.1987748146,
-0.0367815867,
0.0586341359,
-0.3252748847,
-0.1796932518,
0.0631751642,
-0.4117918313,
0.8013094664,
0.4889083505,
0.0759636611,
0.0830131173,
-0.4381189942,
0.3656993508,
0.3373303413,
-0.7232082486,
-0.0275031514,
0.6672235131,
0.3628400862,
0.1403214335,
0.5890781283,
-0.474583894,
0.0478574261,
-0.250793308,
0.1700488776,
0.1191211566,
-0.0198652521,
-0.3011027277,
0.1817090511,
-0.0176461115,
0.2276618779
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05103v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05103v1
|
TMID: A Comprehensive Real-world Dataset for Trademark Infringement Detection in E-Commerce
| 2023-12-08T15:31:39 | 2023-12-08T15:31:39 |
Tongxin Hu, Zhuang Li, Xin Jin, Lizhen Qu, Xin Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Annually, e-commerce platforms incur substantial financial losses due to
trademark infringements, making it crucial to identify and mitigate potential
legal risks tied to merchant information registered to the platforms. However,
the absence of high-quality datasets hampers research in this area. To address
this gap, our study introduces TMID, a novel dataset to detect trademark
infringement in merchant registrations. This is a real-world dataset sourced
directly from Alipay, one of the world's largest e-commerce and digital payment
platforms. As infringement detection is a legal reasoning task requiring an
understanding of the contexts and legal rules, we offer a thorough collection
of legal rules and merchant and trademark-related contextual information with
annotations from legal experts. We ensure the data quality by performing an
extensive statistical analysis. Furthermore, we conduct an empirical study on
this dataset to highlight its value and the key challenges. Through this study,
we aim to contribute valuable resources to advance research into legal
compliance related to trademark infringement within the e-commerce sphere. The
dataset is available at https://github.com/emnlpTMID/emnlpTMID.github.io .
|
[
-0.1549171954,
-0.6226890683,
0.0889158696,
0.1307425499,
-0.5223195553,
0.3894276321,
0.3990270793,
-0.7755025029,
0.3603181541,
0.6668817401,
-0.5041773319,
-0.5971464515,
-0.1970721036,
-0.3055039048,
0.0348333456,
0.615444839,
-0.1023833826,
-0.0303916074,
0.006226718,
-0.4914434552,
-0.2817789316,
-0.6411052942,
-0.4764184058,
0.4981026053,
0.1548181772,
0.57862854,
-0.1521636695,
0.6319657564,
0.5485030413,
0.1709323078,
0.3876407146,
0.235918656,
-0.2333281338,
0.2113795131,
-0.2766088247,
-0.4002021253,
-0.7289287448,
0.0416199788,
0.0397345275,
0.3465392888,
-0.2352545708,
0.7008936405,
0.0505153909,
0.5437497497,
-1.0527127981,
0.1165827289,
-0.3290907443,
0.1849186867,
-0.5127933621,
-0.4582767785,
-0.297185421,
-0.4540281594,
0.0159042478,
-0.7742319703,
0.4206045866,
0.5291009545,
1.3106480837,
0.2244175076,
-0.6647800207,
-0.0116231777,
-0.5580501556,
0.7299453616,
-0.5261902809,
0.2544838786,
-0.0181124844,
0.5291215181,
0.0742949843,
-0.8690339327,
-0.4094924331,
0.1706311703,
0.3425640464,
0.0021038896,
-0.2785498202,
-0.1162926555,
0.5618951321,
0.168405056,
-0.6482007504,
0.0301817283,
-0.3302069008,
-0.1043281704,
0.5805047154,
0.2176953554,
0.5048254132,
0.3697284162,
-0.6436548829,
0.1574344635,
-0.8685290217,
0.1516512334,
0.3687226474,
0.1137288958,
-0.0932039917,
0.3463546336,
-0.2848653793,
0.4480353296,
0.2906873226,
-0.064118728,
0.5923790932,
-0.0704477057,
-0.228325665,
0.1306359619,
0.4251748323,
0.6975746751,
0.3548051417,
0.042667184,
-0.4567506909,
-0.29399243,
-0.0860637948,
-0.6240076423,
-0.1357621402,
0.3342925012,
-0.8139492273,
-0.3316497207,
0.4491580427,
-0.7149221301,
-0.5483545065,
-0.2820323706,
0.5347188711,
0.3663530946,
-0.5080231428,
0.1247686446,
-0.518433392,
0.3377443254,
0.1205632761,
-0.4097347558,
0.0492370464,
0.9910262227,
0.6638912559,
0.0161619764,
0.1563454866,
-0.3704100847,
0.6946049929,
-0.2080252618,
0.8626042604,
-0.2963603437,
-0.1605263054,
-0.0027664967,
0.0658732057,
-0.1801091433,
-1.0159317255,
0.8033786416,
-0.671772182,
-0.3651385605,
-0.3300969601,
-0.8001171947,
-0.0374310985,
0.6898286939,
-1.1256140471,
0.2156017125,
0.0175812989,
-0.6106598973,
1.0321731567,
-0.6102567315,
-0.5167342424,
0.4577459097,
0.0781579539,
-0.6193971634,
0.125906527,
-0.0487155132,
0.6518854499,
-0.3031663597,
0.0551766455,
-0.747163713,
-0.1161293089,
0.4604583979,
-0.2451035529,
1.0373191833,
0.4855089188,
-0.2599007785,
-0.4861144423,
-0.655207932,
-0.2209060937,
0.2393729687,
0.0839494169,
-0.3410359919,
-0.1240518466,
0.3552636802,
0.3801054955,
0.2118105292,
-0.9940384626,
0.1628289074,
0.1595927775,
0.2300201952,
0.7461349368,
0.6182945371,
-0.0221667793,
-0.7518715858,
0.9100780487,
0.0296444297,
0.4660043418,
-0.040989764,
-0.521853447,
-0.6880793571,
-0.3874633312,
0.4375621676,
0.5551211238,
-0.3732350469,
0.3614496291,
-0.8284996152,
-0.2786171138,
-0.5207137465,
-0.1768460572,
0.1099145114,
0.3661552966,
0.0877788141,
-0.2526789606,
-0.3870230317,
-1.0894941092,
-0.5933119655,
0.0573851205,
-0.1986611187,
0.3334777653,
0.4175756276,
0.1570914835,
1.1246346235,
-0.522591114,
-0.8738594651,
-0.0255607441,
-0.0083875638,
0.1170109436,
0.527140379,
0.5885010362,
-0.6462073326,
-0.6674506664,
-0.090882957,
-0.6943244338,
-0.4505366683,
-0.3610789776,
-0.066266261,
0.1271626353,
0.5012543797,
-0.4450781643,
0.3925096393,
0.0652654395,
-0.5280669332,
0.5603058338,
0.1217338964,
0.5294336677,
-1.0593719482,
0.4985476732,
0.0983979404,
-0.1640127897,
-0.7057424784,
0.3080366552,
0.3138464689,
-0.005701052,
-0.7359910011,
0.6387659311,
-0.0525560342,
0.0410179719,
0.0214604698,
-0.4256974161,
0.3293643296,
0.1018882692,
-0.1897943765,
0.6744169593,
0.1988032311,
-0.6172770262,
0.2311709672,
-0.0724757835,
-0.5765810013,
1.1454387903,
-0.4845002592,
-0.4394534528,
0.2354837358,
0.2428195477,
-0.6089016199,
-0.0192646068,
0.5870671272,
-0.3702844679,
0.2478408813,
-0.5701935887,
-0.7383925319,
-0.2852886021,
-0.4467773438,
0.5165824294,
0.1981931925,
-0.8922100067,
0.7817465663,
0.590544939,
0.244500488,
-0.7907221913,
-0.8234720826,
0.319897145,
-0.6775572896,
-0.6527649164,
0.0227732472,
-0.137895897,
-0.2873697281,
-0.2139244378,
-0.0342961624,
-0.2852611244,
0.355083704,
0.1970567703,
-0.0660988837,
-0.2152555138,
-0.085413821,
0.0246175621,
-0.4907416701,
0.2771363258,
-0.3370876908,
0.3419114649,
0.501766324,
-0.4954179823,
-0.9256794453,
0.2243047953,
0.6577531695,
-0.2744355202,
0.2823742032,
0.0437888801,
-0.4425494671,
-0.6109209061,
-0.502897203,
0.2804712951,
-0.5009428859,
-0.2182623297,
-0.6947788596,
-0.3327819407,
0.696999073,
-0.264195174,
0.1769988537,
0.4777987003,
0.154560715,
-0.1350349337,
0.7313234806,
0.2838795781,
0.0092855673,
0.2242655456,
-0.2821570337,
0.5198863745,
-0.5768917799,
-0.6006882787,
-0.4281947017,
-0.5075024366,
-0.6610686779,
-0.2782869041,
-0.1057360843,
-0.1407422125,
-0.3129977882,
0.1211692467,
-0.1465363652,
0.53268224,
0.3679366112,
0.3566592336,
0.4246665835,
0.1003825739,
-0.2050097436,
0.0771435946,
-0.1719083041,
-0.4777151048,
1.3879636526,
0.0815293342,
0.6477882266,
0.4279581606,
0.5451897979,
0.8895742893,
0.1993390024,
-0.8918794394,
0.5348476768,
0.0137926107,
-0.9092982411,
0.6014486551,
-0.2246206701,
-0.9746008515,
-0.0804439411,
0.0260193907,
-0.6594848037,
0.7355572581,
0.3199925423,
-0.2768011093,
0.7626488805,
-0.5630194545,
0.8849781752,
-0.2767358422,
-0.8625907898,
-0.0582269467,
-0.5723910928,
0.312291503,
-0.5058757663,
0.1856149435,
-0.3719227016,
-0.3600876629,
0.7187076211,
-0.7071411014,
0.3673836291,
-0.4994579256,
0.0510264523,
0.1408130378,
0.3942563534,
0.3355201483,
-0.1186123043,
0.152729705,
0.081439808,
-0.1041279137,
-0.5997602344,
-0.0740512833,
0.671580255,
-0.1219149902,
-0.1861574799,
-0.5612126589,
-0.0555376373,
-0.2248144895,
0.0244620126,
0.2095657736,
0.0282112565,
-0.4279700816,
0.0177872125,
0.5678039193,
-0.0960530564,
0.4408524334,
0.6423689723,
0.1303927153,
-0.0808368251,
1.2411134243,
-0.0432615541,
0.1519129723,
0.3241692781,
-0.0697968081,
-0.4778885245,
-0.2937009931,
-0.6045088768,
0.120469816,
-0.6684641242,
-0.223094061,
-0.3739094436,
0.2258961797,
-0.0698578209,
-0.0817856118,
-0.1182045117,
-0.8292076588,
-0.1745873541,
-0.1089121997,
0.0279895868,
0.4045309424,
-0.0849131793,
0.2480026335,
-1.0327234268,
0.3191005886,
0.1245257854,
0.5113405585,
0.12660411,
-0.2711996138,
-0.1731228679,
0.0748525858,
-0.2847977877,
-0.351546824,
0.3950986862,
0.3889859915,
0.6717920899,
1.3508415222,
0.2693228126,
0.4595894516,
-0.2039165497,
0.6430466771,
-0.0447108671,
-0.8776445389,
0.2250523567,
-0.3150056899,
-0.1886257976,
0.5559843183,
0.4154806435,
-0.5633763075,
0.0241761412,
-0.7762891054,
-0.8804304004,
0.443574816,
0.1306769699,
-0.1523152888,
0.3713055849,
0.136418581,
0.1998242289,
0.4117924273,
-0.294832319,
-0.1991845369,
0.3633076251,
-0.1067261174,
0.2723451555,
-0.094280459,
-0.1352301836,
-0.0764786452,
0.6066149473,
0.358369261,
0.2336778343,
-0.4795493484,
-0.5192508698,
-0.0159607437,
-0.0645285696,
0.2356060594,
0.7818387747,
-0.3001489639,
-0.2662259042,
-0.3958444595,
-0.5623476505,
0.2068606317,
-0.0658719391,
-0.1200863868,
-0.2629602253,
0.2547605038,
0.1024292335,
-0.4238784015,
-0.8486607671,
0.8677178621,
-0.245286718,
-0.218211174,
-0.4330918789,
-0.1158819944,
-0.3217752874,
0.2189571112,
0.6313201189,
0.1994371116,
0.5942518115,
-0.1263764203,
0.643185854,
0.0979165807,
-0.0937302709,
-0.131215021,
0.6869576573,
0.5130093098,
-0.07564082,
0.6713250875,
-0.1464917213,
-0.6378031373,
1.1112544537,
0.3094053268,
1.1104556322,
-0.3749722838,
-0.1526441127,
0.1754828095,
0.2512695789,
-0.0413553007,
0.5406658053,
-0.200006023,
-0.6995337009,
0.0901625976,
-0.2914873064,
-0.4250334501,
0.0210905336,
-0.7852749825,
0.5314596295,
-0.7958801389,
-0.2430368364,
-0.1387205571,
-0.0083587486,
-0.5973386168,
0.095639132,
0.1007058471,
0.4584588706,
-0.9780424833,
0.5698424578,
0.2138857096,
-0.0830135643,
-0.2252602726,
0.1913982481,
0.3582125604,
-0.6555902362,
0.4351063371,
0.5023005605,
-0.1137734279,
0.071458973,
-0.3473519981,
-0.3249245286,
1.043415308,
0.0621865913,
-0.7865256667,
0.7848441601,
0.484480679,
0.2604457736,
-0.3767243326,
-0.0699738339,
0.624078691,
0.3892690837,
0.2116903216,
-0.396674186,
0.118772462,
-0.4573425055,
-0.3887725174,
0.472558409,
-0.4626899958,
0.4392828345,
-0.128868565,
-0.3636470735,
0.1197154745,
-0.0552920252,
0.386757642,
0.7499400973,
0.4253428578,
1.1546635628,
0.6257873178,
-0.2701355517,
0.6624965668,
-0.4248996675,
0.4818184674,
0.8162124157,
-0.5062482357,
0.793799758,
0.3637984693,
0.122093983,
0.2037667334,
0.8960809112,
-0.7029728293,
0.3360453248,
0.3016052246,
-0.58400774,
-0.262488991,
-0.5734648705,
-0.3374550343,
0.0822549686,
0.7115716934,
-0.4408041239,
0.0505489558,
0.0595489256,
-0.0587545298,
-0.3402238488,
-0.268886745,
0.3443818092,
-0.0792458802,
0.316298306,
0.188291803,
-0.0087934928,
0.5403380394,
-0.180137977,
-0.1005276591,
-0.3329292834,
0.5775626302,
-0.280323565,
-0.5408374071,
-0.0853036493,
-0.0900858119,
0.3812594414,
-0.2212961316,
0.3543125689,
0.0387175232,
-0.1734303981,
0.275516361,
0.4199132621,
0.1297622174,
-0.1335699707,
-0.8681984544,
-0.03965462,
-0.2691754401,
-0.2028717995,
0.1134095415,
0.4168132842,
-0.137313664,
0.8764950633,
0.5360346437,
-0.2037829459,
0.1446523219,
-0.1173545793,
0.6395009756,
-0.6024662256,
-0.7592028975,
-0.5684494376,
0.4755102694,
-0.5432792902,
-0.2132439911,
0.5363869667,
1.1842120886,
0.8177972436,
-0.2455330193,
0.7757202983,
-0.1368380785,
0.5138673782,
-0.17488648,
0.9731146097,
-0.8637362719,
0.5891100764,
-0.0507686809,
-0.8622047901,
-0.7795414329,
0.2062129378,
0.2922746837,
0.0314602852,
0.4593217075,
0.8911096454,
-0.5448561907,
0.0161449276,
0.1999870986,
0.0446215533,
0.6173577309,
0.4503700137,
0.8181436062,
-0.6712554097,
0.5769588351,
-0.1052521244,
0.0790436417,
-0.5527853966,
-0.8677122593,
-0.6644203067,
-0.2535248101,
-0.4092653692,
-0.4626451135,
-0.0788915008,
1.0855209827,
0.5932254791,
-1.0184327364,
-0.409930557,
0.3612250686,
-0.217699632,
-0.2282004356,
-0.2802693844,
0.4681624174,
0.0945529118,
-0.5338464975,
-0.1801023483,
0.2070130259,
0.2695073485,
0.5604553819,
0.1360931695,
-0.238468796,
0.1420175284,
0.4345321655,
0.6158899069,
-0.3515550494,
0.0030413065,
-0.2497612089,
-0.0691538528,
0.1809364706,
1.1734883785,
-0.3810848594,
0.6060073972,
0.7152475715,
0.4891853929,
0.3073241413,
0.1749564856,
0.3943293095,
-0.6126079559,
0.0972570851,
0.283655107,
0.3957445025,
-0.0379432477,
-0.0526544936,
0.4667263925,
0.6169466972,
-0.2787185013,
-0.4763360023,
-0.0144869732,
-1.2696266174,
-0.3832706511,
0.6963661313,
-0.4915291369,
-0.2033196092,
-0.6393476129,
0.1699507087,
-0.0474765934,
-0.6660908461,
0.6337726116,
0.4272942245,
0.1731755584,
0.0432176366,
-0.6201891303,
0.2174022496,
-0.0715880319,
-0.7705873847,
0.212875098,
0.6355279088,
0.4175759554,
-0.5118106008,
0.2470152825,
0.0738978535,
0.4089204073,
-0.1933551133,
0.178051129,
-0.2149797082,
-0.1293363571,
-0.2521859705,
0.198394686,
0.0385244638,
-0.5888571739
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05061v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05061v2
|
LaCour!: Enabling Research on Argumentation in Hearings of the European Court of Human Rights
| 2023-12-08T14:30:08 | 2024-06-14T18:27:49 |
Lena Held, Ivan Habernal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Why does an argument end up in the final court decision? Was it deliberated
or questioned during the oral hearings? Was there something in the hearings
that triggered a particular judge to write a dissenting opinion? Despite the
availability of the final judgments of the European Court of Human Rights
(ECHR), none of these legal research questions can currently be answered as the
ECHR's multilingual oral hearings are not transcribed, structured, or
speaker-attributed. We address this fundamental gap by presenting LaCour!, the
first corpus of textual oral arguments of the ECHR, consisting of 154 full
hearings (2.1 million tokens from over 267 hours of video footage) in English,
French, and other court languages, each linked to the corresponding final
judgment documents. In addition to the transcribed and partially manually
corrected text from the video, we provide sentence-level timestamps and
manually annotated role and language labels. We also showcase LaCour! in a set
of preliminary experiments that explore the interplay between questions and
dissenting opinions. Apart from the use cases in legal NLP, we hope that law
students or other interested parties will also use LaCour! as a learning
resource, as it is freely available in various formats at
https://huggingface.co/datasets/TrustHLT/LaCour.
|
[
-0.5028360486,
-0.6867018938,
0.4440443814,
-0.1711025685,
-0.1643900424,
0.1494127661,
-0.232647121,
-0.4521247149,
0.0906065106,
0.4069482982,
-0.3985186815,
-0.3090299964,
-0.2988049686,
0.0144839697,
-0.6996844411,
1.0838823318,
-0.0595195629,
0.5439268947,
-0.2857150137,
-0.5578733087,
0.0798811391,
-0.7282371521,
-0.3086630404,
0.0502748862,
0.7836223245,
0.2639482021,
0.2215815634,
0.2411340922,
0.2015937865,
0.3743897378,
-0.2203711867,
0.1626979709,
-0.0582443513,
0.2287173867,
-0.2424114347,
-0.3638956547,
-0.1593480557,
-0.0188402012,
0.339581877,
0.5899470448,
-0.2828996181,
0.3159742653,
-0.3133103848,
0.9295102954,
-0.5558698177,
-0.1611055881,
-0.5282236934,
0.2969101071,
-0.3856636882,
-0.0490414724,
-0.4127099812,
-0.0504633449,
0.4616577029,
-0.2896795869,
0.4360134304,
0.1648004949,
0.7217485905,
0.1831019372,
-0.1729190797,
-0.4333199263,
-0.4399453402,
0.766682148,
-0.7258659601,
0.5816574693,
0.2390877753,
0.0628189445,
0.0190050285,
-0.9169952273,
-0.5771625638,
-0.0947694331,
0.0975810513,
0.504861474,
-0.4075548649,
-0.1206144169,
0.361061722,
-0.0587651469,
-0.4489052594,
0.047100924,
-0.7595466971,
-0.3594480455,
0.5264374614,
-0.4049275219,
0.3663787842,
0.0308047254,
-0.11250747,
-0.0884366408,
-0.5294476151,
0.0887001008,
0.6128382087,
0.4079402685,
-0.0325817652,
0.4015821517,
0.2695588171,
0.5453272462,
0.0944783688,
0.5036996603,
-0.0684509948,
0.3264292777,
-0.2252821326,
0.5769796968,
0.8017285466,
0.3375555575,
-0.0120276026,
0.0782903805,
0.1017582119,
-0.1182558388,
0.0732979327,
-0.6678848863,
-0.0047755176,
0.5044753551,
-0.3879026771,
-0.0277396869,
0.2964403331,
-0.8319152594,
-0.2683266401,
-0.2660320103,
-0.2593075633,
0.0209499616,
-0.0324003696,
0.303551048,
0.0370590724,
0.3180249333,
0.2973902225,
-0.7457864285,
0.5154134035,
0.4125035107,
0.4665014744,
-0.0878649205,
-0.0502720848,
-0.8924465775,
-0.1062448174,
-0.2616606057,
1.0445045233,
-0.5660686493,
-0.5019478798,
0.4353870749,
0.2437233031,
0.0523939282,
-0.7143865228,
1.4262521267,
-0.5862649083,
0.5728657842,
-0.4798994362,
-0.7803446651,
-0.2087581456,
-0.2198711336,
-0.7237721682,
0.7102883458,
-0.1583327949,
-0.6542058587,
0.4185142815,
-0.9558358788,
-0.5329633355,
0.1774523705,
-0.5584926009,
-0.4484170377,
0.0873750597,
0.1815383136,
0.0541199036,
-0.1825643033,
0.0571133792,
-0.1698014885,
0.2201365232,
0.5006202459,
-0.2362537831,
0.8226087093,
0.1172478497,
-0.2748422325,
-0.0860751495,
-0.3523953557,
-0.0460834093,
-0.0336912237,
-0.2084471285,
0.0464966074,
0.3911909461,
0.4359068274,
0.3033219576,
-0.2226310521,
-0.8434240818,
-0.3411726356,
-0.3635513186,
0.7233700156,
0.5844810605,
-0.0460341163,
0.1084770411,
-0.4338463545,
0.434273243,
-0.1742310226,
0.1832825989,
-0.1825806201,
-0.6794548035,
-0.7238530517,
0.4320122302,
0.3687139452,
0.3829620481,
0.2182435989,
-0.0808687434,
0.3979337513,
0.2209771723,
-1.0511478186,
0.0201403126,
0.1056839451,
0.6145069003,
0.467853725,
0.0707229674,
-1.0409812927,
-1.0813925266,
-0.127551347,
-0.5344219208,
0.3478432,
0.0754606351,
0.6625519991,
0.0686241016,
1.0652801991,
0.1061944887,
-0.1269798577,
-0.1010888889,
0.272744447,
0.0477194078,
0.1817676872,
0.4666513503,
-1.0034070015,
-0.4367502034,
0.3688284457,
-0.6816895604,
-0.3503771424,
0.0591514967,
-0.0486662313,
0.250064671,
0.5084316134,
-0.3354380429,
0.2320466191,
0.3266506195,
-0.1133060977,
0.7550216317,
-0.0995241255,
0.0612534769,
-0.5738351941,
-0.1957001835,
-0.0540668666,
-0.2733781338,
-0.7503345013,
-0.0530164242,
-0.0900701731,
0.0058883568,
-0.8713943958,
0.5323485732,
-0.2485131621,
0.2913461626,
-0.2152288556,
0.3021879196,
0.1274018437,
0.1202304438,
0.1180490181,
0.5615603924,
0.3600567281,
-0.3467880189,
0.1844676584,
0.6621065736,
-0.3984962106,
0.6528375745,
-0.6155218482,
0.3045638204,
0.0218853056,
-0.0971542075,
-0.4372442961,
-0.3338658214,
-0.0073044663,
-0.3690012395,
0.0274982937,
-0.3098455369,
-0.0554074645,
-0.4767791629,
-0.3649001718,
0.2058943659,
0.229047969,
-0.1786376238,
0.2760556042,
0.876691401,
-0.2760802805,
-0.7607476711,
-0.6910398006,
0.3600749075,
-0.2697938085,
-0.5303049684,
0.1639839709,
-0.3497551382,
-0.7852112651,
-0.0538748316,
-0.0947947502,
-0.0874071345,
-0.1330513656,
0.3333526552,
0.1510933936,
-0.2891915739,
0.0179731399,
0.291985184,
0.0459455624,
0.3656606674,
-0.0654138103,
0.2770382762,
-0.3943430781,
-0.7438168526,
-0.5554907918,
0.8881151676,
0.555275619,
0.107135348,
0.0633248538,
0.0864559039,
-0.5238729119,
-0.2076639086,
-0.9140453339,
0.0468772873,
-0.3686335683,
0.1800672263,
0.0623687096,
-1.1231989861,
0.5030263662,
0.0878845379,
0.3607265055,
0.4479797482,
0.8571433425,
-0.696162045,
0.6290876269,
0.1357906014,
-0.1234942451,
0.1667697877,
-0.2101503313,
0.258851707,
-0.7045356035,
-0.1186881214,
-0.5606088638,
-0.1252774,
-0.4084419608,
-0.3181936741,
0.1549240351,
-0.0449642465,
-0.0582861006,
-0.0107133342,
-0.0978713632,
0.5097641349,
0.2507201731,
0.2343013883,
0.2740701437,
-0.0603163354,
-0.2461329252,
-0.3058806956,
-0.5484745502,
-0.8152894378,
0.5310994387,
0.2164053768,
0.0635730103,
0.0196541287,
0.5225073099,
0.7806263566,
0.2604411542,
-0.7464132309,
0.621927619,
-0.0253285524,
-0.6185836196,
-0.225560531,
-0.0109743057,
-0.8584011793,
0.3739351928,
-0.0478892811,
-0.7018658519,
0.4504782856,
-0.102788426,
-0.6655322909,
0.4212647974,
-0.373324275,
0.7210173607,
-0.3573346436,
-0.7280265093,
-0.0179435629,
-0.5204696059,
0.0596233048,
0.020558659,
0.6632450819,
-0.1622387171,
0.241429612,
1.0827575922,
-0.8014996052,
0.5906515121,
-0.012313894,
-0.2047708333,
0.6588553786,
-0.0403750315,
0.1657657325,
-0.127989769,
-0.1439091861,
-0.3952249885,
-0.0623190701,
-0.1524152011,
-0.4857771397,
0.4277765453,
-0.5296376348,
-0.7894204855,
-0.3115367591,
-0.2441364676,
-0.0879076347,
-0.046523951,
-0.0707447231,
0.3746009767,
-0.4660036266,
0.1991373301,
0.4043645859,
-0.2057979405,
0.5773578286,
0.5991970897,
-0.0121353706,
-0.2809845805,
0.6504271626,
0.0126496106,
-0.1260454357,
0.3586512208,
0.3693131506,
-0.7142717242,
-0.4567242861,
-0.5335543752,
0.179906562,
-0.8298429251,
-0.0026345006,
-0.6573637128,
-0.0505881719,
-0.214525789,
-0.3885645866,
-0.2592283189,
-0.5994368792,
0.0399445891,
-0.627466321,
0.2712897658,
0.6286713481,
-0.3445476592,
-0.0191129241,
-0.8491600156,
0.011572645,
0.4271771312,
-0.1289744824,
-0.3158301711,
-0.4802318811,
-0.1161174923,
-0.0353130028,
-0.2726763487,
-0.7406637669,
0.2855193019,
0.0812499896,
0.6169292331,
0.4614030421,
0.2048578709,
0.6826041341,
-0.6166185737,
0.7334506512,
0.2082004696,
-0.7204712033,
0.6379824877,
-0.4249592125,
-0.2230057269,
0.6110540032,
0.2402967811,
-0.5935511589,
-0.4922549129,
-0.4814187288,
-0.9115461707,
0.5918884873,
0.2215599269,
0.1123305336,
-0.1237064376,
0.0293683372,
0.3635246754,
0.0250330511,
-0.6042399406,
0.1425228715,
0.0137706576,
0.3436273336,
0.5160349011,
-0.3402569592,
-0.6192867756,
-0.297703743,
0.4914273918,
0.1760520339,
-0.0925750807,
0.5002310872,
-0.4246512651,
-0.2931773067,
0.5419255495,
0.5578463674,
0.7566504478,
-0.3085810244,
-0.0343631245,
0.2828190327,
-0.3650541008,
0.0923800915,
0.0492999852,
-0.3859989047,
0.2390914857,
0.3199964762,
0.6867154837,
0.1911565512,
-1.0271539688,
0.3785552382,
-0.087403737,
-0.7255414128,
-0.2983233631,
-0.3485566676,
-0.0621389002,
0.404029429,
0.4203707278,
-0.1844829917,
0.1869884431,
-0.6597572565,
0.5861013532,
0.0353733487,
-0.5919547677,
-0.1524141133,
0.9192372561,
0.1588838845,
-0.2364364117,
0.2823536694,
0.1282653213,
-0.5066592097,
0.4284502864,
0.1140309572,
0.8516951799,
-0.0934235156,
0.6482726932,
0.2050029635,
-0.0568482839,
-0.157110855,
0.3371095955,
-0.2418746203,
-0.7492297888,
-0.4227258563,
-0.4092478752,
-0.889723599,
-0.15956074,
-0.8220291734,
-0.0763730183,
-0.2010742128,
-0.2534508407,
0.0937510654,
-0.0573580973,
-0.3937540948,
-0.20516029,
0.368645668,
0.7961593866,
-0.6842572689,
0.3423786759,
0.4709464908,
-0.3442015052,
-0.0115401801,
-0.3207081854,
0.1990394741,
-0.4146147072,
0.5933941007,
-0.0711050257,
-0.3417043686,
-0.4003864229,
-0.5575059652,
0.0469604805,
0.5763727427,
0.6674591303,
-0.6797211766,
0.2326662838,
0.3488049805,
0.3743104041,
-0.1229512841,
0.2342590541,
0.5652629137,
0.6545496583,
-0.0283007417,
-0.499337554,
-0.3550388217,
-0.5575405955,
-0.6567183137,
-0.1808864474,
-0.6487932801,
0.5325461626,
-0.3278078139,
-0.4060147703,
0.0794896483,
0.6515636444,
0.1674604714,
0.3676041067,
0.3616039455,
0.4738262892,
1.1024819613,
-0.2097045779,
1.1138974428,
-0.234660551,
0.2262793779,
1.134649992,
-0.7715535164,
0.931953609,
0.4837440252,
-0.4500771761,
0.558039248,
0.8009482622,
0.1651618332,
0.3185888231,
0.3445675671,
-0.6337127686,
-0.2391728163,
-0.4198365808,
-0.249812603,
0.1736222655,
0.3062079251,
0.1981433928,
-0.3021369278,
0.0323409475,
-0.0577163436,
0.4246073365,
-0.1478480846,
0.4333549738,
0.2953004837,
-0.2785328925,
0.0530093797,
-0.1731856316,
0.0891942605,
-0.3742627501,
0.0833828598,
-0.2572968602,
-0.1373682022,
-0.4740056098,
-0.7612703443,
0.0880652964,
0.3789329827,
-0.1462949663,
-0.3143616915,
0.3760641217,
-0.0497280583,
-0.6104161739,
0.4268328846,
0.9021847248,
0.3766282201,
0.2888427675,
-0.746440649,
0.1135773361,
-0.2719289362,
-0.2607737184,
0.3227660358,
0.6584186554,
-0.1757307053,
0.5312871337,
0.5928903222,
0.170986563,
0.3259684741,
0.8437001705,
0.9856068492,
-0.3995164931,
-0.0507268645,
-0.8763836622,
0.6279552579,
-0.2742821276,
-0.1836275011,
0.4364500344,
0.9452752471,
0.8010266423,
0.1385471076,
1.0808979273,
-0.086886704,
0.4964466095,
-0.6014556289,
0.45244205,
-0.2844236195,
-0.1200288683,
-0.2378451377,
-0.4434410334,
-0.3695777059,
0.7942937613,
-0.1113236547,
-0.3586747348,
0.6342968941,
0.5719252229,
0.0009652615,
0.3427304327,
0.3804264069,
0.2951784134,
0.2962681055,
0.2199743837,
1.2437815666,
-0.3275430202,
0.3013390899,
-0.0406703763,
0.1488002837,
0.0097893821,
-0.6969026327,
-0.7310516238,
-0.6100144982,
-0.2476102412,
-0.2831734419,
0.213881284,
1.1545082331,
0.5095143914,
-1.3893253803,
-0.6821032763,
0.0239980575,
-0.0334815346,
-0.0412598923,
-0.0816421285,
0.5947825313,
-0.1734545529,
-0.7767577767,
0.5264903903,
0.2639313936,
-0.1772069186,
0.0917673931,
-0.119079642,
-0.4076162279,
-0.0181953739,
0.6364736557,
0.8731744289,
-0.6898818016,
-0.2190856338,
-0.1093700379,
0.501996696,
0.2465515435,
1.1413605213,
-0.1793998927,
0.5107145309,
0.1778331101,
0.7233425379,
0.4114228487,
-0.0776847079,
0.5482984781,
-0.4063493609,
0.3366766572,
0.4851450324,
1.0617114305,
0.1683997065,
0.2583301365,
0.4033844471,
0.2261322588,
-0.5320732594,
-0.9636876583,
0.0409231186,
-1.3174942732,
-0.0457435884,
0.7569368482,
-0.1187762022,
-0.1322598606,
-0.375634551,
-0.4173273444,
0.0513791889,
-0.5572017431,
0.8479093909,
1.0514008999,
-0.2546031177,
-0.2669797242,
-1.1231484413,
0.3002997637,
0.2297647893,
-0.7109727263,
0.2794160545,
0.3913247585,
-0.3029656112,
0.0521925613,
0.5888611078,
-0.34212026,
0.2852996886,
-0.3662295341,
-0.0935652554,
0.3544072509,
-0.1424411088,
-0.0658875555,
0.2002608925,
-0.2202803046,
0.0539402254
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05047v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05047v1
|
Converting Epics/Stories into Pseudocode using Transformers
| 2023-12-08T14:01:09 | 2023-12-08T14:01:09 |
Gaurav Kolhatkar, Akshit Madan, Nidhi Kowtal, Satyajit Roy, Sheetal Sonawane
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The conversion of user epics or stories into their appropriate representation
in pseudocode or code is a time-consuming task, which can take up a large
portion of the time in an industrial project. With this research paper, we aim
to present a methodology to generate pseudocode from a given agile user story
of small functionalities so as to reduce the overall time spent on the
industrial project. Pseudocode is a programming language agnostic
representation of the steps involved in a computer program, which can be easily
converted into any programming language. Leveraging the potential of Natural
Language Processing, we want to simplify the development process in
organizations that use the Agile Model of Software Development. We present a
methodology to convert a problem described in the English language into
pseudocode. This methodology divides the Text to Pseudocode conversion task
into two stages or subtasks, each of which is treated like an individual
machine translation task. Stage 1 is Text to Code Conversion and Stage 2 is
Code to Pseudocode Conversion. We find that the CodeT5 model gives the best
results in terms of BLEU score when trained separately on the two subtasks
mentioned above. BLEU score is a metric that is used to measure the similarity
between a machine-translated text and a set of reference translations.
|
[
-0.3580633104,
-0.3919798136,
0.3567533493,
0.2548502088,
-0.4121890366,
0.1757812053,
-0.1805398911,
-0.8086700439,
0.2245888263,
0.403452754,
-0.5240556002,
-0.2316409796,
-0.0629792511,
0.3378244936,
-0.5170351267,
1.3214526176,
-0.3637489676,
-0.418867141,
0.1196837798,
-0.1029582322,
-0.6185496449,
-0.4169707596,
-0.3076004386,
-0.4710659683,
0.2192892283,
0.5903887153,
0.4945875704,
0.397212863,
0.5234635472,
0.2935505807,
0.2391462177,
0.0799799412,
-0.515114665,
-0.2401613295,
-0.2290036976,
-0.7578387856,
-0.2828241885,
0.2326406538,
0.0817458183,
0.1917273998,
-0.241748184,
0.8491343856,
0.0598821342,
0.3640473187,
-0.1369705051,
0.2409986258,
-0.4183398485,
0.0776140988,
0.0217942875,
-0.3869853914,
-0.5128426552,
-0.5864975452,
-0.2258430719,
-0.396071732,
0.4082538784,
0.5791556239,
0.9215012193,
0.1250364631,
-0.0538524166,
-0.4033587575,
-1.3475666046,
0.8919429183,
-0.6263293624,
0.0703426078,
0.2031398863,
0.5058799386,
0.3342909217,
-0.9716073871,
-0.9703114033,
-0.4025901556,
-0.4008312523,
0.1238811985,
-0.3717083037,
-0.0778015405,
0.2749294341,
0.5006968975,
-0.8697058558,
-0.0167662501,
-0.7652112842,
-0.0065549789,
0.8777933121,
0.1929695159,
0.3339935839,
-0.6336266398,
-0.4079570174,
-0.2156808823,
-0.5504308939,
0.0798224285,
0.2580760419,
-0.0986036658,
-0.1198383421,
0.6682072282,
0.0441561081,
0.2644610703,
0.1302409172,
-0.5722682476,
0.5117456317,
-0.3660695553,
-0.0705838427,
0.3346813023,
0.5649983287,
0.5616261363,
0.2418385148,
-0.2974227965,
-0.6670935154,
0.5161341429,
0.7673885226,
-0.5718106627,
-0.0065591815,
0.1578840613,
-0.7989273071,
-0.2967614233,
-0.3221020699,
-0.262119472,
0.2195794582,
-0.2589309514,
0.3193617463,
-0.6228162646,
0.0381154455,
-0.1059885621,
-0.1175760999,
0.3715825379,
0.0470580384,
-0.3907489777,
0.0925216302,
0.175395146,
0.8535553217,
0.1589076519,
-0.3285823762,
-0.2912698984,
0.4061825871,
-0.5225330591,
0.7983065844,
-0.0656513348,
-0.5789349675,
-0.0921613574,
-0.5050398111,
-0.0459059961,
-0.6935927272,
0.6963934898,
-0.4305689335,
0.0083733182,
0.3300265372,
-0.3424786925,
-0.396840632,
0.3595635295,
-0.390237093,
1.2168908119,
0.4389359057,
-0.5923435688,
0.0841710493,
-0.7763751149,
-0.6643342972,
0.4947144091,
-0.1519035846,
-0.238324061,
0.4345745444,
0.1152241379,
0.314373821,
-0.7154037356,
0.0700867921,
0.1922774464,
-0.3603028357,
0.0906653032,
0.1536935568,
0.257794261,
0.4948236942,
-0.3473496139,
0.0216902364,
-0.571521461,
0.0592879951,
0.0446324237,
-0.1833801717,
-0.2441489995,
0.0460677706,
0.3752260208,
0.4872731566,
0.2581795752,
-0.541582346,
0.3070486784,
-0.6452308893,
0.3781648874,
0.3918189406,
0.1169980168,
0.4202281237,
-0.5305309296,
0.5733312964,
-0.1053040326,
0.3198264241,
-0.2322351187,
-0.556142509,
-0.707164526,
0.0297018811,
0.3104562163,
0.786354661,
-1.2916446924,
0.3882146478,
-0.3704794049,
-0.6983927488,
-0.9660022855,
0.3157839179,
0.2643957138,
0.6848614812,
0.6160805821,
-0.4663248658,
-0.5220944285,
-1.0630670786,
-0.1334363222,
-0.6443782449,
-0.4820425808,
-0.008101129,
0.545527637,
-0.5667413473,
1.2434880733,
-0.6443219781,
-0.6758045554,
-0.8738635778,
0.711468339,
0.4168760478,
0.5622886419,
0.9091242552,
-0.8078920841,
-0.4042364359,
0.2559804916,
-0.8378238678,
-0.0731365457,
-0.4146590829,
0.3581771851,
0.1127563566,
0.3335796893,
-0.5948961377,
0.7590566874,
0.4366699755,
0.1171844229,
0.676674366,
-0.4227871299,
0.4815081656,
-1.104906559,
0.2437822074,
0.1357336342,
-0.2851243317,
-0.3808540404,
0.2568817735,
-0.0157245155,
-0.2418137193,
-0.4658520222,
0.2957049608,
-0.4051603675,
0.0125230867,
-0.1362289637,
-0.2265156507,
-0.282407552,
0.5116688609,
-0.0273986515,
0.6604470611,
0.1856705993,
-0.5753252506,
0.5333263874,
0.3682300448,
-0.2937942743,
0.4828667641,
-0.6350975633,
0.4892785251,
0.0373155959,
0.2349681258,
-0.8201681376,
0.2392789871,
0.1753336489,
-0.6786420345,
-0.1313783377,
-0.2532206178,
-1.0359660387,
-0.8085376024,
-0.2394994795,
0.1654945761,
1.1933580637,
-0.2938079536,
0.7157161236,
0.053501565,
-0.0229309034,
0.2034249902,
-0.8771314621,
0.2365135252,
-0.3599062562,
-0.7543234825,
0.5305486917,
-0.3388696015,
-0.0357350372,
0.1147744209,
-0.2073535621,
-0.1456442326,
-0.4536525607,
0.0442705154,
0.2260412276,
-0.285272181,
-0.4394407272,
0.1837802082,
-0.4106664658,
0.0451113544,
-0.4736869931,
0.2182670832,
0.1168712527,
0.1450743824,
-0.4751939476,
0.6222810745,
0.3909859061,
-0.377718389,
0.814843595,
0.4615317583,
-0.3598152399,
-0.8237144351,
-0.4451156259,
-0.2759311795,
-0.4955636263,
0.0078992145,
-0.4528477192,
-0.421410799,
0.5589573383,
-0.5305921435,
0.1687358767,
0.3767673373,
0.598290801,
-0.4399475455,
0.7294133306,
0.9145410657,
-0.0551464669,
0.0676119551,
-0.552611053,
0.8406067491,
-0.2498232722,
-0.0644916669,
-0.6398115754,
-0.4560937881,
-0.1603141576,
-0.4704430997,
0.6405629516,
0.1614844501,
0.5081124306,
0.8587043881,
-0.3879585862,
0.297994256,
0.318793565,
-0.0904386044,
0.227185145,
-0.0364074782,
-0.1306856126,
-0.2184326053,
-0.9398064613,
-0.6030070186,
0.808734417,
0.2889702022,
0.6044795513,
-0.0908297598,
0.9894920588,
0.7310140133,
0.463440448,
-0.7237372398,
0.4498382509,
0.0429792777,
-0.5720480084,
-0.0471850932,
-0.4794078767,
-0.5748717189,
-0.2843244672,
-0.2344338298,
-0.5950015187,
-0.0648700073,
0.3277068138,
-0.1985723078,
0.0361172818,
-1.121768117,
0.8330690265,
-0.2211681604,
-0.008796039,
-0.5921252966,
-0.680593133,
0.2484588921,
-0.3909870684,
0.5341938138,
0.5511466265,
0.3732993007,
0.7723762393,
-0.4909168184,
0.7062321901,
0.1409728229,
0.0633326322,
0.7105307579,
0.2403549701,
0.4848700464,
0.0137323011,
0.0489355214,
0.2554037869,
-0.240465194,
-0.3869294822,
-0.5224524736,
0.4050858617,
-0.6521315575,
-0.1949388236,
-0.4335695803,
-0.3720142841,
-0.0205664039,
0.0544973314,
0.5658888221,
0.2105845809,
-0.0113135334,
-0.2520985305,
0.349227339,
-0.1679917127,
0.7467899323,
0.4310908318,
-0.0132322265,
-0.1171434298,
0.7242532969,
0.3027598262,
-0.1419861168,
0.3414122164,
-0.0213160794,
-0.4264375865,
-0.7912896276,
-0.6480929255,
0.2557099462,
-0.5617294312,
-0.4464346766,
-0.0743832216,
-0.1941998005,
-0.3320980966,
-0.5197202563,
-0.5184919238,
-0.021156393,
0.02600036,
-0.2272684425,
0.1778102964,
0.8070012331,
0.0651256144,
0.4142867923,
-1.267932415,
0.8782596588,
-0.0170118138,
0.0685628355,
-0.0975931957,
-0.493658036,
-0.5886369944,
-0.2923800945,
-0.2124183923,
-1.1231918335,
0.6753373742,
0.0253450051,
0.5120275617,
0.0848599449,
0.3342219591,
0.7973018885,
-0.8421337605,
0.7217773199,
0.4735738933,
-1.0444216728,
0.6177498102,
-0.0697979704,
0.0249465723,
0.4983973801,
0.6117767096,
-0.4940535128,
-0.302703321,
-0.8878135681,
-1.0683603287,
0.8712827563,
0.8347516656,
0.0909137875,
0.2436362058,
0.3401310444,
0.1940169036,
0.3012956679,
-0.7577998638,
-0.3957573771,
-0.2158794701,
-0.2126167119,
-0.3967849016,
-0.1193076298,
0.0837242305,
-0.2916100919,
0.4810101986,
-0.0495489426,
0.2801356316,
0.213332206,
-0.4947455227,
-0.1934673488,
0.26622051,
0.2233369201,
0.6403983831,
-0.072410129,
-0.0536545478,
0.2434069216,
-0.4156159461,
0.0248730779,
0.1378952265,
-0.2066971809,
0.2202958614,
0.5393764377,
0.5465484262,
-0.0313961096,
-0.518271327,
0.268807143,
0.0621942542,
0.0310074501,
-0.288045615,
-0.0882436708,
0.0057784799,
0.2014967501,
0.7407360673,
0.2782258987,
0.3062441349,
-0.5957126021,
0.3988369405,
-0.5179567337,
-0.0143369539,
-0.4988651574,
0.5972507,
0.499047339,
-0.7396192551,
0.4439829886,
-0.5610643029,
-0.5092843175,
0.3938961327,
0.7655786872,
0.87921983,
-0.5078208447,
0.4367913604,
0.4344465733,
0.825915575,
-0.065765813,
-0.0306109563,
0.1043206677,
-0.3334587514,
-0.6355011463,
-0.9255018234,
-0.0333977453,
0.1101297811,
-0.4158550799,
0.4308638573,
-0.3114272356,
0.1409513354,
-0.1767735481,
-0.2240165323,
-0.5819666982,
0.4972210824,
0.2502359748,
0.6566425562,
-1.0371800661,
0.8693315387,
1.0769830942,
-0.7024222612,
-1.2517757416,
0.1186330169,
-0.2669546902,
-0.2949692309,
0.4366312623,
0.0008164849,
-0.0792566538,
0.1575117111,
-0.2744034231,
-0.1807513237,
0.8312488198,
0.3593588769,
-0.81681633,
-0.2642761767,
0.4155516028,
0.9802866578,
-0.4297836125,
0.2109796554,
0.4807889462,
0.4087210596,
0.0831576809,
-1.1747436523,
-0.0915538296,
-0.2284688354,
0.1922962368,
0.1504232585,
-0.2027528733,
0.4798810482,
0.033267431,
-0.1082034409,
-0.1763122827,
0.8519499898,
0.2138271034,
0.5965403318,
0.5057464242,
0.428801924,
0.2286283821,
0.4429361522,
1.2356384993,
-0.3235091567,
0.6467378736,
0.4988804162,
-0.1449209154,
0.7023658156,
0.4739881754,
-0.106543906,
0.4884773493,
0.4625985324,
0.0414247736,
0.3099388182,
0.1775808036,
0.1762932688,
-0.1193299145,
0.3821139932,
-0.2706494033,
0.4524326026,
0.0611000471,
-0.1794603765,
-0.3649418354,
0.3018164039,
0.0523918383,
0.4015417099,
-0.3799926341,
0.586151123,
0.2971859872,
-0.6485055685,
0.8106428981,
0.5559634566,
0.6128451824,
-0.7747151852,
-0.1893621981,
-0.3794186115,
0.2023080885,
-0.3530156016,
-0.5539598465,
0.7244247198,
0.4257052243,
-0.2533439696,
-0.6331988573,
0.6329414248,
-0.2264160961,
-0.6708565354,
0.4063114822,
0.4328362644,
0.1905870885,
0.014490597,
-0.7388330698,
-0.1690690666,
0.2100189477,
-0.0962643325,
0.0294098221,
0.3147604764,
-0.3837316632,
0.4590690434,
0.6004049778,
-0.0816675276,
-0.0501283854,
-0.2906699777,
0.8023785949,
-0.6044243574,
-1.0530302525,
-0.4883886278,
0.5964406729,
0.291361481,
-0.433070451,
0.7824633121,
0.7826879621,
0.743665278,
-0.5530285239,
0.7795768976,
-0.42605564,
0.3727859557,
-0.4875231981,
0.8934787512,
-0.4271975756,
0.3312919438,
-0.4378593266,
-1.1047800779,
0.0141026918,
0.6360175014,
-0.205482021,
-0.2808897197,
1.109934926,
0.484339416,
-0.3297688365,
-0.1765537262,
0.2186984122,
0.2999201715,
0.1301059425,
0.5509986281,
0.5570906997,
-0.4575289786,
0.8366534114,
-0.2022155672,
-0.3534074128,
-0.0170921143,
-0.6879100204,
-0.7527033091,
-0.6753005981,
-0.4053956568,
-0.2817606926,
-0.0866102353,
0.5581290126,
0.6317595243,
-0.6053183675,
-0.6517778039,
0.1640057117,
-0.0752239153,
-0.4461705685,
-0.1902113557,
0.0196745973,
-0.2171838135,
-0.5251657963,
0.3889263868,
0.1383487284,
-0.3708631098,
0.0074096345,
-0.131003961,
-0.0445077084,
0.2501013577,
0.5537242889,
0.2008685768,
-0.1593555659,
-0.3698481619,
-0.1231152117,
0.1003119797,
0.3361376822,
0.9552309513,
-0.9850282669,
0.038020391,
0.3714912832,
0.3805820644,
0.9276648164,
-0.0498025529,
0.5480210781,
-0.9390078783,
0.2822196782,
0.5239137411,
0.0625276864,
0.1221183389,
-0.3854572177,
0.5052185059,
0.3991858661,
-0.2252081037,
-0.8785714507,
0.2912559211,
-1.0918792486,
-0.3173109293,
0.8709548116,
0.005549592,
-0.4303589165,
-0.1887983829,
-0.5447522998,
0.2296167612,
-0.2972517908,
0.8677609563,
0.2530559003,
-0.3014429212,
-0.0979601294,
-0.4611243606,
0.4693502486,
0.1742874533,
-0.8603913188,
-0.3954924345,
0.2704816759,
0.1417158842,
0.6119671464,
0.4971985221,
-0.0489861667,
0.2510648966,
0.1824555099,
0.5636646152,
0.1438799202,
-0.3521564305,
0.0582331382,
0.3832981586,
0.0288252123,
-0.1969629526
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04982v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04982v1
|
Boosting Prompt-Based Self-Training With Mapping-Free Automatic Verbalizer for Multi-Class Classification
| 2023-12-08T11:43:00 | 2023-12-08T11:43:00 |
Yookyung Kho, Jaehee Kim, Pilsung Kang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, prompt-based fine-tuning has garnered considerable interest as a
core technique for few-shot text classification task. This approach
reformulates the fine-tuning objective to align with the Masked Language
Modeling (MLM) objective. Leveraging unlabeled data, prompt-based self-training
has shown greater effectiveness in binary and three-class classification.
However, prompt-based self-training for multi-class classification has not been
adequately investigated, despite its significant applicability to real-world
scenarios. Moreover, extending current methods to multi-class classification
suffers from the verbalizer that extracts the predicted value of manually
pre-defined single label word for each class from MLM predictions.
Consequently, we introduce a novel, efficient verbalizer structure, named
Mapping-free Automatic Verbalizer (MAV). Comprising two fully connected layers,
MAV serves as a trainable verbalizer that automatically extracts the requisite
word features for classification by capitalizing on all available information
from MLM predictions. Experimental results on five multi-class classification
datasets indicate MAV's superior self-training efficacy.
|
[
-0.4154737294,
-0.615532279,
0.1314918995,
0.1659961641,
-0.1189693883,
0.0509579331,
-0.2794880867,
-0.2008277774,
0.0408782661,
0.1314526051,
-0.5258885026,
-0.500769496,
-0.6722493768,
0.2388072163,
-0.1470174938,
0.9128590822,
0.1866234243,
-0.0663915649,
0.0044838339,
-0.1106481627,
-0.8551616073,
-0.6415153742,
-0.7425617576,
-0.1388017237,
0.6229961514,
0.7604029775,
0.3983119726,
0.7426664233,
-0.02660916,
0.3374310136,
0.3029126823,
0.3184507191,
-0.1538112462,
0.2513056993,
0.1864783317,
-0.1830312163,
-0.4427941144,
0.4100582302,
0.6654199362,
0.2977079451,
-0.0982018709,
0.3087095916,
0.2012604922,
0.3531659842,
-0.7067828774,
0.3683283031,
-0.716356039,
-0.0546559691,
-0.0491926149,
-0.4259290993,
-0.5452264547,
-0.209473446,
-0.1332316101,
-0.6474511027,
0.4294322133,
0.0986843482,
0.604655087,
0.4361917973,
-0.3261485994,
-0.1348603368,
-0.3668066561,
0.7855514288,
-0.3062602282,
0.2632015646,
0.5983368158,
0.6133918166,
0.1728871614,
-0.3140541017,
-0.4401014745,
-0.1507844329,
-0.0123021668,
0.2603049874,
0.0095976302,
0.2669247687,
0.1291180998,
0.2150136828,
-0.4690990746,
0.2795101106,
-0.1699710935,
-0.2941409349,
0.4232805967,
0.013653677,
0.379404068,
-0.1004608646,
-0.4454353452,
-0.0166718476,
-0.3836554587,
0.2767989039,
0.1390899718,
0.87388134,
0.0546487309,
0.4077675641,
-0.3790000379,
0.8881513476,
0.006747527,
-0.4101353884,
0.3331428468,
-0.1626564264,
-0.0765741318,
0.3912852108,
0.8402547836,
0.4013179839,
0.4472231865,
-0.155808121,
-0.1261705607,
0.1447795331,
0.0480374247,
-0.9995686412,
-0.0512210615,
0.0189003684,
-0.2564105988,
-0.4514481425,
-0.0014718124,
-0.5594841242,
-0.2974647284,
-0.1360500008,
0.4517170787,
-0.2872060239,
0.0249714833,
-0.0067602829,
-0.1587009728,
0.3623327613,
0.3365025222,
-1.0973567963,
0.100060381,
0.4742029309,
1.0065230131,
-0.144446671,
-0.4985682368,
-0.9142591953,
0.0172649734,
-0.3580699861,
0.8506506085,
-0.6475255489,
-0.3498809338,
0.0067225294,
-0.0287282225,
-0.2327237129,
-0.2775485516,
0.4913254678,
-0.0217546131,
0.3882496655,
0.0203096066,
-0.6181492209,
-0.108503364,
0.5268224478,
-0.2659817636,
1.2456161976,
-0.095637247,
-0.3814675808,
0.3796270788,
-0.4228670299,
-0.0973429233,
0.3204109669,
-0.1548601985,
-0.3521465957,
-0.0105801253,
0.5530048013,
0.7339323163,
-0.0143802753,
0.2147736549,
-0.1359823942,
-0.3745140135,
0.1575392187,
-0.4364070892,
0.4588177502,
0.0742472932,
-0.3472095728,
0.3196202517,
-1.1044789553,
0.0945980325,
-0.1373180151,
-0.2401489019,
-0.3151785731,
-0.4286495149,
-0.1826897562,
0.5819380283,
-0.0250858162,
-0.6001031399,
0.6262404919,
-0.5789321065,
-0.1476170719,
0.7662642598,
0.0063572456,
0.6354824901,
-0.3501728177,
0.8823449016,
-0.089454338,
0.053959094,
-0.5992330313,
-0.8270216584,
-0.9292808175,
-0.7094708085,
0.2686728835,
0.7174206376,
-0.6928300858,
0.5858080983,
-0.1299406141,
-0.5676102638,
-0.920167625,
0.0885853842,
0.4156146049,
0.6521574855,
0.6636297703,
-0.0612512641,
-0.168171078,
-0.7322010398,
-0.3773385882,
0.2398723513,
0.1015084237,
0.2591722012,
0.1280724406,
-0.1085093692,
0.9506750703,
-0.3439680338,
-0.863411665,
-0.2571201921,
0.2244909555,
-0.1508801281,
0.4008737803,
0.4402480721,
-0.0469431579,
-0.6501902342,
-0.3721524477,
-0.5922546387,
-0.3688133359,
-0.3125428557,
-0.053581018,
-0.1233981699,
0.4592546225,
-0.273584038,
0.315348804,
0.273276329,
-0.3157124817,
0.3020528257,
-0.2396737486,
0.0115443915,
-1.0261408091,
-0.0978629589,
-0.0718557537,
-0.2791123986,
-0.8607376814,
-0.1271528602,
0.2212443054,
-0.34073475,
-0.4876948893,
0.9355586171,
-0.6075095534,
0.20852229,
-0.6754487753,
0.1827616841,
-0.2250611633,
0.7047518492,
-0.0855305269,
0.9310742617,
0.881572485,
-0.7526214123,
0.2051030993,
0.4057664573,
-0.0859311596,
0.4891365767,
-0.4702383578,
0.238868624,
-0.2292744666,
0.2269618064,
-0.9656786919,
0.0969870239,
0.3841431141,
-0.5680579543,
0.2848944068,
-0.3182120621,
-0.2935006022,
-0.2444342822,
-0.4307678342,
0.3115664124,
0.3420726657,
-0.7608923316,
0.5525080562,
0.1396298707,
0.0672652125,
-0.696392715,
-0.519855082,
0.0658658817,
-0.1235972792,
-0.2422048151,
-0.0619822629,
-0.1934807599,
0.3896478713,
-0.4736402333,
-0.0513216145,
0.0636238009,
0.4652724564,
0.5281371474,
0.224192813,
0.1162143052,
0.4905011952,
0.1801964492,
-0.601621151,
-0.0790105835,
-0.3592890203,
0.2940095663,
-0.2336484939,
-0.0517294705,
-0.7541819811,
0.2946208715,
0.2042309195,
-0.5117939711,
0.7829899788,
0.6650284529,
-0.2739414275,
-0.5166754723,
-0.4689712524,
-0.2397910655,
-0.5247567296,
0.0271739457,
-0.7050380707,
-0.8952889442,
0.1600506306,
-0.1047299132,
-0.0738807842,
0.3524853289,
0.4829519987,
0.151047051,
1.034565568,
0.5629303455,
-0.0408871397,
0.4957129657,
-0.2023030221,
-0.0664536357,
-0.5111562014,
-0.2043591291,
-0.7286651731,
-0.2201219797,
-0.4618777633,
-0.2145410329,
0.1722804755,
-0.1416818351,
-0.1046753973,
0.0459476225,
-0.8557306528,
0.70505476,
0.8026168942,
-0.1888489723,
0.1808953136,
0.0403000638,
-0.1931819022,
0.0060874005,
-0.7223082185,
-0.4167385399,
0.8828770518,
0.1198375523,
0.540941596,
-0.2945957184,
0.8425503969,
-0.0280710217,
0.2146112174,
-1.1555354595,
0.6018664241,
-0.0107085733,
-0.5244575739,
-0.2679934204,
-0.3139688075,
-1.0021476746,
0.5463944674,
-0.424911052,
-0.3393919766,
0.1427695602,
0.3453093767,
-0.3793737292,
0.1576951295,
-0.801625371,
0.8784705997,
-0.1307228655,
0.1056546196,
0.096566245,
-0.7704434395,
0.1986263394,
-0.1077025011,
0.4284510612,
-0.5229995251,
-0.1242686361,
0.691863358,
-0.3044073582,
0.9474005103,
-0.5255351067,
0.0194481313,
0.2629711628,
-0.0356872529,
0.2549657226,
-0.1948854625,
0.1586149633,
0.0731987432,
-0.2065299898,
-0.4068027139,
-0.8206937909,
0.5283020139,
-0.8156147599,
-0.4530587792,
-0.723859787,
-0.1660063714,
-0.5096846223,
0.2928102314,
0.3070302606,
0.5704140663,
-0.1819809228,
-0.085559614,
0.303573221,
-0.2332478464,
0.5732913613,
0.5904447436,
-0.1809616387,
-0.4367107153,
1.1587002277,
0.0461167172,
0.1272074282,
0.3519186378,
0.5560195446,
-0.2671348155,
-0.2419325262,
-0.5168249011,
0.0984831527,
-0.6286462545,
-0.442073077,
-0.7730600834,
-0.2888090611,
-0.4971188307,
-0.25032866,
-0.3430349529,
-0.6655906439,
-0.4323384762,
-0.2200175971,
0.2212968469,
0.3738002777,
0.0109569943,
0.6703294516,
-0.7268010974,
0.4284266233,
0.6008621454,
0.2454964817,
-0.1613829285,
-0.6564794183,
-0.3129530847,
-0.196817562,
-0.211947158,
-0.8336482048,
0.3957911134,
0.705460012,
0.465767175,
0.3233382106,
0.0422371775,
0.6452358961,
-0.6059683561,
0.6552690864,
0.3011826575,
-0.8044292927,
0.8369464278,
-0.0531681105,
0.6195435524,
0.7603002787,
0.3147940636,
-0.6937588453,
-0.5045235753,
-0.2858866453,
-0.6672419906,
0.7753725052,
-0.0941027254,
0.2340611964,
-0.1936093867,
0.3134510219,
0.4100266695,
0.2274624556,
-0.6404296756,
-0.6061162353,
-0.5719481707,
-0.3546509445,
-0.4063393474,
-0.318305552,
0.1417668909,
-0.5720738173,
0.9096692801,
-0.5404626131,
0.0741086677,
0.0583126582,
-0.3399766684,
0.2936441898,
0.7193219662,
0.4283375442,
0.1091316938,
-0.0609418601,
0.2415260375,
0.1339454502,
-0.3427374959,
0.6298974156,
0.1847504079,
-0.3779610991,
0.0270902943,
-0.0271388888,
0.9683654904,
0.2793178856,
-0.2245289981,
0.8709394932,
-0.1760013402,
-0.1880488396,
-0.007107337,
0.1945870817,
-0.4140495062,
-0.0430173092,
0.1657563746,
0.1931535751,
0.2858935893,
-0.1713275164,
0.0272980332,
0.522149682,
-0.4574097991,
-0.2106335461,
0.6502745152,
0.3274466991,
-0.2550623417,
0.3508433998,
-0.460937202,
-0.4404145479,
0.0394053608,
0.5237827897,
1.1391786337,
-0.6111947298,
0.3023403883,
0.6033455729,
0.3802331388,
-0.022976784,
0.1040584743,
-0.3420676887,
-0.7346731424,
-0.1476862133,
-0.6046401858,
-0.2943369448,
-0.2086350769,
-0.443570435,
0.3683713377,
-0.3910094202,
-0.1797224432,
-0.046519313,
-0.0728775188,
-0.5734553337,
0.3306944668,
0.2168994844,
0.741525352,
-0.6610780954,
0.9758483768,
0.5263968706,
-0.2794975042,
-0.8518779874,
-0.225970611,
0.0266953949,
-0.9096063375,
0.3095980883,
0.8508346677,
-0.3942464292,
0.2725595236,
-0.4037349224,
-0.6284680367,
0.856565237,
0.3191054463,
-0.5440811515,
-0.117801711,
0.0086165359,
0.3672212362,
-0.3906961977,
0.3540602624,
0.2990882695,
0.2584978044,
0.0865561441,
-0.820074439,
-0.0059459815,
-0.2048203945,
0.0849696696,
0.0152116837,
-0.6464273334,
0.3828465641,
-0.1046392471,
-0.3266340792,
-0.0444448106,
0.7089611888,
-0.0584246852,
0.2242355347,
0.5124462247,
0.3592672348,
1.0156828165,
-0.0058402438,
0.7327434421,
-0.5340988636,
0.1574523896,
1.371427536,
0.2327734381,
0.7455635667,
0.0543179661,
0.2550472021,
0.4247763753,
0.4600300193,
-0.2630669773,
0.5193520784,
0.1504408419,
-0.3988088369,
-0.4604528844,
0.0177075714,
-0.4749376178,
0.7544500828,
0.187430203,
-0.186995998,
-0.3000574112,
0.3376152813,
-0.1236792579,
-0.153848201,
-0.3531005383,
1.0495715141,
0.0717914626,
-0.5961108208,
0.7398945689,
0.0942974091,
0.9740835428,
-0.5382929444,
0.238249287,
-0.0904834196,
-0.0120134167,
-0.1143899858,
-0.2413809597,
-0.0594033413,
-0.1366595179,
0.1344999671,
-0.6400957108,
1.0285514593,
-0.7228759527,
-0.3981321454,
0.023749996,
0.7649197578,
0.2428855747,
-0.3102432489,
-0.7740511894,
-0.4451632202,
-0.4074087143,
-0.1607542336,
0.2209643871,
0.330565542,
0.3332290351,
0.7407554388,
0.5174958706,
-0.0910017043,
0.3485164344,
0.2613918781,
0.643897295,
-0.8657479286,
-0.8793388009,
-0.8156940937,
0.3642684519,
0.1764187962,
-0.4523341656,
0.9618531466,
0.6770315766,
0.4172313511,
-0.0770045668,
0.6761721969,
0.6553329825,
0.5330815315,
-0.2725166678,
0.7583332658,
-0.5359089375,
-0.1387293935,
0.0091172475,
-0.7061360478,
-0.4487226307,
0.6293475628,
0.1229811162,
0.1375263482,
0.5624526739,
0.7304446101,
0.1588837653,
-0.0742755532,
0.5013850331,
-0.1228540093,
0.3290463686,
0.154264465,
0.6970264912,
-0.3577125371,
0.551132381,
-0.3152266145,
-0.576382637,
-0.0906855538,
-0.6863865256,
-1.2569080591,
-0.5764489174,
-0.3898813725,
-0.1635829508,
-0.0628942773,
1.1152193546,
0.8143236637,
-0.7091004848,
-0.067369394,
0.1315053701,
-0.0718086213,
-0.1875680685,
-0.1807690412,
0.1215960905,
-0.878329277,
-0.5882521272,
0.7948197126,
0.2881590128,
0.3708886504,
-0.0507865846,
0.0949803591,
-0.0446722917,
0.14781183,
0.681024909,
0.2698137462,
-0.5787429214,
-0.0426895283,
-0.0531832054,
-0.2190718353,
0.3462703824,
0.7509297132,
-1.0883910656,
0.8015244603,
0.0201792084,
0.709389925,
0.4717800319,
0.0782743916,
0.2733187973,
-1.2594748735,
0.2567885816,
-0.0121672824,
0.1996088177,
0.4436828792,
-0.1940331161,
0.1916204095,
0.2648590207,
-0.5634237528,
-0.4961664975,
0.1123125106,
-1.0380187035,
-0.2072665095,
1.2166304588,
0.2279549837,
-0.0765847489,
-0.1294792742,
-0.4738130867,
0.3911155462,
-0.6493846774,
0.7525982261,
0.6250119805,
0.0205950867,
-0.2079108059,
-0.265389204,
0.7323554754,
0.3514508307,
-0.9853118062,
-0.0429751873,
0.5784594417,
0.1450750083,
-0.0346076749,
0.8855826259,
0.3226995468,
0.0922902599,
-0.3260564208,
0.1644700468,
-0.4780474901,
-0.5951330066,
-0.7552242875,
0.3697635531,
0.1415324658,
-0.6355045438
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04945v1
|
The ICL Consistency Test
| 2023-12-08T10:22:43 | 2023-12-08T10:22:43 |
Lucas Weber, Elia Bruni, Dieuwke Hupkes
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Just like the previous generation of task-tuned models, large language models
(LLMs) that are adapted to tasks via prompt-based methods like
in-context-learning (ICL) perform well in some setups but not in others. This
lack of consistency in prompt-based learning hints at a lack of robust
generalisation. We here introduce the ICL consistency test -- a contribution to
the GenBench collaborative benchmark task (CBT) -- which evaluates how
consistent a model makes predictions across many different setups while using
the same data. The test is based on different established natural language
inference tasks. We provide preprocessed data constituting 96 different
'setups' and a metric that estimates model consistency across these setups. The
metric is provided on a fine-grained level to understand what properties of a
setup render predictions unstable and on an aggregated level to compare overall
model consistency. We conduct an empirical analysis of eight state-of-the-art
models, and our consistency metric reveals how all tested LLMs lack robust
generalisation.
|
[
-0.3897218108,
-0.8981134892,
0.3762925267,
0.2178896219,
0.0938826799,
0.1102623343,
-0.456353277,
-0.4236418605,
-0.4440541565,
0.1961237639,
-0.4545943439,
-0.6195132136,
-0.5620111227,
0.3237602711,
-0.6347633004,
1.010209918,
-0.1904318631,
0.0651076436,
-0.5349296927,
-0.3068295717,
-0.7224028707,
-0.2423566282,
-0.5472272635,
-0.458124131,
0.2003828585,
0.305226773,
0.800920248,
0.467030853,
0.4511511028,
0.1811906546,
-0.2805154324,
0.3042382598,
-0.294832319,
0.1134415194,
-0.3696641624,
-0.1632931232,
-0.2090331316,
0.1039442867,
0.7987414598,
1.0327320099,
-0.1400011182,
-0.0663346574,
0.6592301726,
0.288436234,
-0.5120772123,
0.2052358985,
-0.8758111,
-0.2062045336,
0.1051817015,
0.4707593024,
-0.658647716,
-0.410480082,
0.0403992422,
-0.3957284093,
0.418081075,
0.3699010909,
1.0861339569,
0.2510812283,
-0.5457915068,
-0.1804668456,
-0.5939307809,
0.8718515635,
-0.8938416243,
0.5363195539,
0.6715904474,
0.1870636642,
-0.4502924383,
-0.6738260984,
-0.5603474379,
-0.9064080119,
-0.1442845017,
-0.1038574874,
0.0446401723,
0.1051726267,
0.4117047489,
0.1705494374,
-0.6258250475,
0.3488225639,
0.2040394992,
-0.2002485842,
0.2735286653,
0.0949230045,
0.3979487121,
0.1402084678,
-0.4040392339,
-0.0884865224,
-0.8080473542,
0.2948092222,
0.1932702363,
0.5992485285,
-0.1596387625,
0.5064541101,
-0.1775615364,
0.9227217436,
0.3671406507,
-0.171908617,
0.0089794081,
-0.5647892356,
-0.1651783735,
-0.0492370427,
0.692528367,
0.1823162884,
0.3157813847,
-0.3661753237,
-0.2617168427,
0.2166193277,
-0.0606375709,
-0.4606435895,
-0.055772569,
0.1352305561,
-0.2350628823,
0.1285375506,
0.0706054643,
-0.0900677294,
-0.132087931,
-0.6505361795,
0.3766122758,
-0.6982941628,
-0.0012772221,
0.0175696891,
0.0990363136,
0.1874639243,
0.1793642193,
-1.0483133793,
0.4502251744,
0.8475159407,
0.6493881345,
-0.3824787736,
-0.5984413028,
-0.6231063008,
0.0502993092,
-0.5902608633,
0.7219465971,
-0.3847379088,
-0.1277206093,
-0.0636068061,
0.1514155567,
-0.2973710001,
-0.7707701325,
0.4229911864,
-0.1156089008,
0.0873090029,
-0.4877892733,
-1.0093966722,
0.2223735899,
0.6619901061,
-0.2265574932,
1.2062344551,
0.1125717014,
-0.6378446221,
0.9347242713,
-0.243163079,
-0.1253625154,
0.0006869141,
-0.2959367633,
-0.3639632761,
-0.0877230912,
-0.0534671023,
0.2671824396,
-0.2826056182,
0.8466255069,
-0.6841803789,
-0.7653346062,
0.1309995055,
-0.4617879689,
0.898283422,
-0.0404635221,
-0.5322722197,
-0.0212444346,
-0.6369529366,
0.0231523551,
-0.3587456644,
-0.4784350395,
-0.1963527352,
0.2051941901,
-0.1232203171,
0.1058275104,
0.1464146227,
-0.7429355383,
0.4072587788,
-0.1685848683,
0.2815303504,
0.7523844838,
-0.2994789779,
0.0655661002,
-0.3828846514,
0.2490467876,
0.1275890023,
-0.0207868963,
-0.0468293056,
-0.320061028,
-0.7199446559,
-0.120703958,
0.3841095567,
0.3996050954,
-0.3922121227,
0.5389965773,
-0.2366935462,
-0.4164170921,
-0.3208026886,
0.2307939678,
0.450550288,
0.6343339682,
0.1959910691,
-0.1704322547,
-0.285300076,
-1.0529024601,
-0.4676024616,
-0.2866120636,
-0.0697905719,
0.0246183332,
0.4895534217,
-0.2547043264,
1.019666791,
0.2702369988,
0.1969939917,
-0.3191639483,
0.2359143794,
0.1871757954,
0.7357490659,
0.6028628349,
-0.5418130755,
-0.8206403852,
0.057919912,
-0.7922381163,
0.036484275,
0.0960102528,
0.2300475836,
0.0707186386,
0.724568665,
-0.4462948143,
0.4111075699,
0.7543208599,
-0.4648964703,
0.6581611037,
-0.1969544142,
0.185220331,
-0.7715950608,
0.0229325332,
0.0465266332,
-0.3182708323,
-0.5476219058,
0.0037485927,
0.4253310859,
0.0710640773,
-0.2427697927,
0.6583898664,
-0.358068794,
-0.050581377,
-0.1702659577,
0.0225079004,
0.0589881167,
0.1864245385,
-0.4030425251,
1.0845966339,
0.6029254794,
-0.6266316175,
-0.0069834469,
0.244437322,
-0.3855982125,
0.8629495502,
-0.750356853,
0.3208411038,
-0.1853617579,
0.0352376923,
-1.2003762722,
-0.2695451975,
-0.0657766163,
-0.081362091,
0.2940222025,
-0.0658717602,
-0.7710193396,
-0.1459203809,
0.0621129535,
0.2822178602,
0.5344930887,
-0.75075984,
0.5537147522,
-0.1878836602,
0.1643878818,
-0.680947125,
-0.7354393005,
-0.0158088636,
-0.0993197784,
-0.5764861107,
0.2686930001,
-0.5605779886,
-0.6317079067,
-0.0707507432,
-0.0132604241,
-0.282849282,
0.3226019144,
0.2817097306,
0.1098847091,
-0.3555464447,
0.1636568159,
-0.1690327227,
0.3070600629,
-0.2229474485,
-0.2090043426,
0.4324755967,
-0.3492371142,
-0.7148816586,
-0.626475811,
0.0061936234,
0.5897877812,
0.0589208119,
0.7126889229,
0.2431492507,
-0.3142420053,
-0.2511744797,
-0.5475111008,
-0.111957103,
-0.4634801447,
0.0460889824,
-0.3162180483,
-0.7349959016,
0.6849652529,
0.0521481782,
0.3147971928,
0.4095751345,
0.1908657849,
-0.1105698124,
1.1399316788,
0.7270471454,
-0.0426710919,
0.1823859662,
0.1642140299,
0.2090843022,
-0.6162445545,
-0.1544194818,
-0.6695263386,
-0.144591704,
-0.4305497706,
0.2636803389,
0.1155244708,
0.2858411372,
-0.5961649418,
0.3777475953,
-0.098834984,
0.6171580553,
0.7819364667,
0.0188328978,
0.4799015224,
-0.2479884773,
-0.4751266837,
0.000131341,
-0.5802039504,
-0.6803476214,
0.8000757098,
-0.0788213834,
0.5586349964,
-0.0645500124,
0.3714858294,
0.4068389535,
0.4941376448,
-0.4223762453,
0.4042409062,
-0.3164837658,
-0.6075962186,
-0.128174305,
-0.0838438943,
-0.977884531,
0.000037171,
-0.0103463298,
-0.8181999922,
0.0516709983,
0.370519489,
-0.1805783808,
0.356990993,
-0.5159305334,
0.8427472711,
-0.0667179227,
-0.366247654,
0.2731604278,
-0.5042389035,
0.5127311349,
-0.055888705,
-0.034928374,
-0.3997272849,
0.3370198607,
0.256624192,
-0.2431486845,
0.9656646252,
0.0581224412,
0.2121427059,
0.2433131933,
0.1046538055,
0.5560389757,
-0.0491674133,
-0.3283773065,
-0.0554862097,
0.0308666956,
-0.7312911153,
-0.455245167,
0.6114059687,
-0.6729469299,
-0.5349053144,
-0.2279722095,
-0.8385816813,
-0.508623898,
0.1568342745,
0.3434313238,
0.7217537165,
-0.4380214512,
0.3648890853,
0.8528792262,
-0.051738359,
0.4693160057,
0.5156692863,
-0.0973659605,
0.0214339532,
0.2984161973,
0.0626740307,
0.6273631454,
0.0599937178,
0.0773244724,
-0.1269898713,
-0.7804982066,
-0.4604169428,
-0.1395271569,
-0.7029353976,
-0.1277914494,
-0.364449054,
-0.1911487281,
-0.5261367559,
-0.3455600441,
-0.2850267887,
0.2619971931,
-0.0739207119,
0.0063611623,
-0.0655369759,
0.990488708,
0.1385101676,
0.1813430637,
-0.434696883,
0.0700889826,
0.1822071373,
0.3687895834,
-0.0913636833,
-0.554172039,
-0.0003313796,
0.1564100832,
-0.1235118583,
-0.5041636825,
0.0393112376,
0.3910554945,
0.780739069,
0.5409096479,
0.0163838062,
0.5367127657,
-0.337924391,
0.9032158852,
0.0724109039,
-1.0687403679,
0.384619385,
-0.5324755311,
0.5285094976,
0.9753043652,
0.2115749568,
-0.6173989773,
-0.805932343,
-0.7471482754,
-0.4890862703,
0.2671211064,
-0.1477749348,
0.0192775857,
-0.3348973989,
0.4012535214,
0.437626034,
0.1435755044,
-0.718287766,
-0.0953188986,
0.0098141478,
-0.4977279305,
-0.1069977656,
-0.1984439641,
0.0485745333,
-0.1541314423,
0.4914526343,
-0.3500908613,
-0.3204671144,
0.0662062392,
-0.1318570375,
0.0616769046,
0.2040738314,
0.5164481401,
0.9578975439,
-0.3084378242,
0.2722646296,
0.2678369582,
-0.3383122087,
0.3693308532,
0.0522173643,
-0.5197725296,
0.0508756265,
0.5574600697,
0.5736516714,
0.4786004722,
-0.9099842906,
0.5403422117,
-0.2085208595,
-0.2596886158,
-0.220763281,
0.1884670854,
0.0880077928,
-0.0306713525,
0.1417076737,
0.2709397376,
-0.1525713503,
-0.839768827,
0.4653495252,
0.6697884202,
-0.5965447426,
-0.2494847924,
0.6848413348,
-0.3038256764,
-0.239162907,
0.8891779184,
-0.5083529353,
-0.2419677377,
0.8192793727,
0.6235937476,
0.6605388522,
-0.062982887,
0.0833373293,
0.3663665056,
0.4476574063,
-0.4786064327,
0.2701191008,
0.2857650518,
-0.7554962635,
-0.41004619,
-0.3708285987,
-0.5968765616,
0.0504631475,
-0.6602786183,
0.3498226702,
-0.6248265505,
0.0517908707,
-0.2348494083,
-0.0167680383,
-0.8976436257,
0.0989020988,
-0.2254437953,
1.0198748112,
-0.9837536812,
0.9537129998,
0.5030491948,
-0.1974675655,
-1.0026680231,
0.1389231682,
-0.0064108861,
-0.7215034366,
0.6074054241,
0.2639946938,
0.2143448144,
-0.1367753893,
-0.770647645,
-1.1454869509,
1.0719184875,
0.7448827028,
-0.7493310571,
0.1850755811,
0.0799023286,
0.4693006277,
-0.3849264979,
0.1601052135,
0.5459319949,
0.6207180023,
-0.2181919068,
-1.2116941214,
-0.0734268874,
0.0740358755,
-0.1517150849,
0.0415958315,
-0.5461201668,
0.9864646792,
-0.0538051911,
-0.17693156,
0.3674705029,
0.5768460035,
0.5462388396,
0.4966933727,
0.5132661462,
0.6612294912,
0.9776039124,
-0.3556282222,
1.2569257021,
-0.3286012709,
0.452318728,
1.3323239088,
-0.466848284,
0.7757031322,
0.272572577,
-0.0434990898,
0.4654048085,
0.7531687021,
-0.2192204446,
0.4240553677,
0.1565473229,
-0.112011008,
-0.3235575259,
-0.4815716445,
-0.0238140821,
0.3651812971,
-0.1194933057,
-0.2831785381,
-0.3026074767,
0.0654508695,
-0.0318642035,
0.3096354306,
-0.3158734143,
0.5326334834,
-0.1010209993,
-0.9561744332,
0.6613616347,
-0.4319812655,
0.6657434702,
-0.5915034413,
0.0452257842,
-0.4660337269,
0.2288496941,
0.1298166364,
-0.5759903193,
0.1880825758,
-0.2505274713,
-0.2794550657,
-0.0158353206,
0.6015241146,
-0.6322844028,
-0.45296067,
0.3331869543,
0.6440156102,
0.0877561271,
0.2382564396,
-0.6859666705,
0.1336864382,
-0.0662084371,
0.0020360465,
0.5122690797,
0.3258654177,
-0.0143133672,
0.7854106426,
0.408013761,
-0.1060019583,
0.0678081289,
0.0208204817,
0.4354662001,
-0.4327822626,
-0.0893826783,
-0.8964036107,
0.417465657,
-0.0221274458,
-0.7004538178,
0.9705623984,
0.480171591,
0.8732045889,
0.2492413819,
0.8010460138,
0.1152219325,
0.4447489679,
-0.5158774257,
0.2980432212,
-0.3983992636,
0.1050107479,
-0.0701489523,
-0.9323214889,
-0.1888759732,
0.176596269,
-0.17331855,
0.094416827,
0.844296217,
0.6670483351,
-0.4516962767,
-0.0817007273,
0.6035419106,
0.2250681221,
0.2048965394,
0.2746092975,
0.8991737366,
-0.1854379475,
0.2056488693,
-0.3028660119,
0.1017638966,
0.0230667684,
-1.0909973383,
-0.9544661641,
-0.4718799591,
-0.4126155376,
-0.4453658164,
0.395739615,
1.0317800045,
0.7352004051,
-0.9983164668,
-0.2386823595,
-0.4564910233,
-0.0385789275,
-0.5574094653,
-0.2006840408,
0.3708048761,
-0.7246966958,
-0.8289440274,
0.5532910228,
0.1647923589,
0.1789824218,
-0.2169843912,
0.0274520181,
-0.1558970064,
-0.120045945,
0.2087831497,
0.209380582,
-0.9946180582,
-0.5249083638,
0.0057825511,
-0.2876114845,
0.1114909798,
0.5117064118,
-0.6801012754,
0.3472711444,
0.2480108291,
0.6488113999,
-0.0027918774,
0.1323312819,
0.7555847168,
-0.5800146461,
-0.0353993252,
0.1861017793,
0.6391863823,
0.6048531532,
-0.1740725189,
0.4628527761,
0.0139463767,
-0.8632041812,
-0.7398072481,
0.2292274088,
-0.801287353,
-0.3217058182,
0.9750234485,
-0.4991613626,
0.0883961767,
-0.356893301,
0.1067327037,
-0.0141315833,
-0.2605653107,
0.8399138451,
0.8931413889,
-0.0265666842,
0.1623065919,
-0.7026047111,
0.4861063063,
0.6395723224,
-0.5546401143,
0.1671113074,
0.3018793762,
0.6718969941,
-0.1120557413,
0.3514001369,
0.2978114188,
0.1015448794,
-0.0928519219,
-0.0665854216,
0.2743331492,
-0.2046690136,
-0.2778458595,
0.1539780349,
0.5329735875,
0.2988851368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04927v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04927v1
|
Zoology: Measuring and Improving Recall in Efficient Language Models
| 2023-12-08T09:44:25 | 2023-12-08T09:44:25 |
Simran Arora, Sabri Eyuboglu, Aman Timalsina, Isys Johnson, Michael Poli, James Zou, Atri Rudra, Christopher Ré
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Attention-free language models that combine gating and convolutions are
growing in popularity due to their efficiency and increasingly competitive
performance. To better understand these architectures, we pretrain a suite of
17 attention and "gated-convolution" language models, finding that SoTA
gated-convolution architectures still underperform attention by up to 2.1
perplexity points on the Pile. In fine-grained analysis, we find 82% of the gap
is explained by each model's ability to recall information that is previously
mentioned in-context, e.g. "Hakuna Matata means no worries Hakuna Matata it
means no" $\rightarrow$ "??". On this task, termed "associative recall", we
find that attention outperforms gated-convolutions by a large margin: a 70M
parameter attention model outperforms a 1.4 billion parameter gated-convolution
model on associative recall. This is surprising because prior work shows gated
convolutions can perfectly solve synthetic tests for AR capability. To close
the gap between synthetics and real language, we develop a new formalization of
the task called multi-query associative recall (MQAR) that better reflects
actual language. We perform an empirical and theoretical study of MQAR that
elucidates differences in the parameter-efficiency of attention and
gated-convolution recall. Informed by our analysis, we evaluate simple
convolution-attention hybrids and show that hybrids with input-dependent sparse
attention patterns can close 97.4% of the gap to attention, while maintaining
sub-quadratic scaling. Our code is accessible at:
https://github.com/HazyResearch/zoology.
|
[
-0.5642322898,
-0.7757581472,
0.0701995119,
0.126683861,
0.0067112353,
-0.0059157559,
-0.1968243271,
-0.6557668447,
0.2044232637,
0.0750626177,
-0.185431093,
-0.1691893488,
-0.4698205292,
0.2380858809,
-0.5168492198,
0.9251464605,
0.0819550902,
0.0464363359,
-0.1455523521,
-0.5144665837,
-0.1592205167,
-0.7385644317,
-0.8421148658,
-0.2258521318,
0.6824889183,
0.069235079,
0.6302531362,
0.6971073747,
0.422824204,
0.2720080018,
-0.201942116,
0.2347913235,
-0.4446333051,
-0.0623965897,
-0.1812059432,
-0.5144928098,
-0.1533036232,
0.0505322255,
0.7495476007,
0.6533248425,
-0.1747281849,
-0.0618840046,
0.1722266525,
0.7263376713,
-0.9620789886,
0.1582873166,
-0.5789736509,
0.086301364,
-0.0449048653,
-0.2411499023,
-0.291074574,
-0.1618780047,
0.1577165872,
-0.6877467632,
0.3057169914,
0.1003936753,
0.648596704,
0.0096152341,
-0.2818912864,
-0.3329941332,
-0.7352202535,
0.635383606,
-0.5034309626,
0.6329907179,
0.4963145256,
0.1754796207,
-0.2422476858,
-0.4886057973,
-0.7687804103,
-0.4030451179,
-0.2588065863,
0.0798970833,
-0.2900079489,
0.2591261268,
0.4524400234,
0.7594248056,
-0.5092062354,
-0.3815813065,
-0.3559216857,
-0.4064116776,
0.4005793333,
0.071417816,
0.3569281995,
0.2567032576,
-0.2152682394,
-0.4032005668,
-0.7990605235,
0.3007520437,
0.3158399761,
0.0212805923,
0.1931780428,
0.586317122,
-0.3776346743,
0.4961304069,
0.1305154562,
0.1621442884,
0.0252430923,
-0.4633157253,
-0.0255183931,
-0.2059656978,
0.600476265,
0.1339907795,
0.3609260321,
-0.196356684,
-0.3528090715,
0.2283451706,
0.2312684804,
-0.4411482215,
-0.5308817029,
0.0017744197,
-0.4220852852,
0.2389494181,
-0.2161227465,
-0.6957079172,
-0.2179823965,
-0.0425441675,
0.7205158472,
-0.6851426363,
-0.2044019848,
0.3522526026,
0.0954528227,
0.399166435,
0.0202854648,
-1.2226601839,
0.6712397933,
0.6111139059,
0.8885221481,
0.0516436249,
-0.4156086445,
-0.7850264311,
-0.0047110575,
-0.3633425832,
0.8231577277,
-0.5467646718,
-0.1913167536,
-0.0990937054,
-0.0176827051,
-0.3592657447,
-0.5784797072,
0.2597996891,
-0.6320480704,
-0.1135278568,
-0.3281441033,
-0.5648153424,
-0.60177809,
0.4924486578,
-0.8771538734,
0.9370589256,
-0.0152181704,
-0.5862106681,
0.1923485696,
-0.420314014,
-0.5073114038,
-0.191893056,
-0.0761320665,
-0.3899146616,
-0.0352801494,
0.117989108,
0.1372863948,
0.007497956,
0.0013645096,
-0.2876444459,
-0.4431852698,
0.3272141218,
-0.1470284164,
0.5549560189,
0.0111391926,
-0.2024811804,
0.1208830401,
-0.7133501768,
-0.1515997946,
-0.1377709657,
-0.6438945532,
-0.4608491957,
-0.0413452871,
-0.2472614944,
0.1750247926,
-0.043843016,
-0.5208489299,
0.129087612,
-0.6086004972,
0.3536472321,
0.2235244662,
-0.0158924516,
0.5402673483,
-0.5029926896,
0.4761410654,
-0.0417292193,
0.0075008571,
-0.3863540888,
-0.1434333622,
-1.0714045763,
-0.1405798793,
0.1813506484,
0.4190421402,
-0.4743889272,
0.0714622289,
0.0624989681,
-0.3843368292,
-0.5389009714,
0.0291455835,
0.7498537302,
0.2629909813,
0.3146197796,
-0.6181017756,
-0.4283595979,
-0.8026280403,
-0.2050131708,
-0.0729775876,
0.0601385757,
0.3113808036,
0.4825362265,
0.024800526,
0.4799619019,
-0.1601364762,
-0.424325496,
-0.1788682789,
0.1972033828,
-0.1134591326,
0.4845553935,
0.5952261686,
-0.6991848946,
-0.1629904211,
-0.0379525051,
-0.4968835115,
0.3230369687,
-0.016990779,
-0.1125074103,
0.2443877608,
0.3910411298,
-0.9225985408,
0.3777122498,
0.2556034029,
-0.0698911399,
0.7024876475,
-0.2930331528,
0.3142953217,
-0.5623195171,
0.3974597752,
-0.1218603402,
0.0237214956,
-0.7014662027,
0.2361834347,
0.1407082826,
0.0737565383,
-0.3495652676,
0.6489698291,
-0.7511059046,
-0.2603178322,
-0.1234516278,
0.0926746279,
-0.0493216589,
0.7412301898,
0.0112208882,
0.9421927333,
0.5491626263,
-0.9843008518,
0.286909312,
0.3943083882,
-0.2485876232,
0.1259874851,
-0.4624921083,
0.2691115737,
0.0509409234,
0.2875453234,
-1.1892552376,
-0.2786191106,
0.2448463887,
-0.6271980405,
0.4201532006,
0.1520698667,
-0.374522835,
-0.177216664,
-0.5619849563,
0.6661970019,
0.3152807951,
-0.4966798425,
0.7017580271,
0.4433821142,
-0.1208355948,
-0.6723418236,
-0.4917125702,
-0.1063831151,
0.0438530818,
-0.3482019305,
-0.0754020363,
0.0533336326,
-0.0461881794,
-0.0135448007,
-0.3411848843,
0.1084621921,
0.1298547983,
-0.3451769352,
-0.036156904,
-0.3437254727,
0.4886919558,
-0.344250828,
-0.1600405872,
0.0853300765,
-0.2574947774,
0.7224255204,
-0.1143212467,
-0.2970328927,
-0.1779361218,
0.5080686212,
0.5397042036,
-0.6696813107,
0.5625528097,
0.384332478,
-0.5910615921,
0.162736401,
-0.5646200776,
-0.4267541766,
-0.3788423836,
0.4332796335,
-0.4453378916,
-0.8268478513,
0.8512919545,
0.2372122854,
-0.0375465341,
0.3359017074,
0.2496951669,
-0.0089074457,
1.1073743105,
0.7212345004,
-0.1081264168,
0.6361401677,
-0.3941820562,
0.2002990246,
-1.1095349789,
-0.335488826,
-0.5093941092,
-0.4316094816,
-0.4590393603,
0.0431298949,
0.2683864832,
0.1075236201,
-0.0473703928,
0.2035835385,
-0.3622874916,
0.5544958115,
0.7809789777,
0.0424319059,
0.3453812897,
-0.0819194689,
-0.1007502154,
0.1411721855,
-0.7988333106,
-0.4342234433,
0.8973748684,
-0.0838499516,
0.9038604498,
0.1362554133,
0.4571458697,
-0.0842506066,
0.0835298821,
-0.933421731,
0.5625400543,
-0.2191843837,
-0.7743991613,
-0.2802256048,
-0.2050783336,
-1.0407385826,
0.5623008013,
-0.3544157743,
-0.9082404971,
0.3318003416,
0.5174927711,
-0.7460106611,
0.3062945902,
-0.6985664368,
0.7631742954,
-0.0144479787,
-0.6246011257,
-0.3834376037,
-0.7656834126,
0.6542330384,
0.0074956371,
-0.072458595,
-0.04703179,
-0.0346865617,
0.6910151243,
-0.1056974083,
0.6219707131,
0.083065547,
0.1593658626,
0.3099034131,
0.2346456647,
0.3925495446,
-0.2400390357,
-0.0639405772,
-0.2879081964,
0.1978159845,
-0.341270864,
-0.6758637428,
0.5820457935,
-0.4861395955,
-0.6140560508,
-0.5519845486,
-0.6354938745,
-0.2157772332,
0.1067634672,
0.1073304564,
0.4754798114,
-0.2166313231,
0.3279662728,
0.9517114162,
-0.1733795255,
0.351900667,
0.4799942076,
-0.084162645,
-0.1829950064,
0.8829410672,
0.2095145881,
0.3403521478,
0.5507278442,
0.041303616,
-0.4301121831,
-0.4239991903,
-0.4584481418,
0.0706021637,
-0.6310607195,
-0.2707896233,
-1.1770240068,
-0.4148000181,
-0.3666279316,
0.1711515784,
-0.1349975318,
-0.4153808951,
-0.1410334706,
-0.0147616118,
0.4208095372,
0.5245438814,
-0.2011252791,
0.3144946694,
-0.8337149024,
0.4565814137,
0.3022860885,
0.3308112025,
0.3509314656,
-0.3467957675,
-0.2468956709,
0.2055201381,
-0.4047051072,
-0.8135199547,
0.4455179274,
0.7063817382,
0.7868657112,
0.2207306176,
-0.1015845314,
0.5634342432,
-0.1497171819,
0.4596930742,
0.0859857127,
-0.8655323982,
0.3246198297,
-0.2168538719,
0.3922717869,
0.3960256279,
0.2858215868,
-0.7582310438,
-0.6314509511,
-0.4865978658,
-0.7254033089,
0.7389118075,
0.1308929026,
0.1466054618,
-0.2583009005,
0.297706455,
0.0896383375,
0.0145575209,
-0.6008560658,
-0.0524501428,
0.0217086077,
-0.1879048496,
-0.3389822245,
-0.2927305102,
0.0584549643,
-0.3313870728,
0.7245076299,
-0.0253403354,
0.1743116677,
0.2500112057,
-0.3176589906,
-0.0216627978,
0.2967147231,
0.6013429165,
0.3160351515,
-0.099299334,
0.5163587332,
0.2587906122,
-0.7334284186,
0.2879295349,
0.1536911875,
-0.1699810624,
-0.1529687345,
0.3006074727,
0.445502162,
0.5484846234,
-0.6273419261,
0.384719342,
0.0490490124,
0.0194752328,
0.0974517986,
0.2902406454,
0.1892432868,
0.253718555,
0.3591424227,
0.0692618862,
0.6292716265,
-0.6808340549,
0.3340662122,
0.5960211754,
-0.2072579414,
-0.3923061788,
0.5977119803,
0.1372676939,
-0.2348386645,
0.5945519209,
-0.2717346549,
-0.5115427375,
0.7175475955,
0.6656873822,
0.786118269,
-0.4133544564,
-0.0898456946,
0.6341632605,
0.2730376124,
-0.2553022206,
0.3918112516,
-0.3134826124,
-0.71477139,
-0.1849529892,
-0.5725232959,
-0.3230475187,
0.2971470952,
-0.6143068671,
-0.1003105417,
-0.4451045096,
0.0749092177,
0.1689214706,
0.1652297229,
-0.2458861023,
0.3209909201,
-0.1768939048,
1.0066436529,
-0.7610890865,
0.8085048199,
0.6825876832,
-0.6481736302,
-0.7920359969,
-0.1500498801,
-0.1465177685,
-0.7224065065,
0.0427771695,
0.3829712868,
-0.6267991662,
0.2695794404,
-0.6057263017,
-0.9076260328,
0.7798138857,
0.2191012949,
-0.6783130169,
0.2159885317,
-0.3227945566,
0.6561245918,
-0.2384395897,
0.1500445008,
0.7584043741,
0.0717477128,
0.0765106529,
-0.638366878,
-0.0461357348,
-0.4257870615,
-0.1753475517,
0.4151946008,
-0.6244479418,
0.8743742704,
-0.4343861341,
-0.5977417231,
0.3472516537,
0.5738708377,
0.4000035524,
0.3670047522,
0.3504889905,
0.3988874853,
0.6952833533,
-0.0273131356,
1.1002826691,
-0.1450278759,
0.2310520411,
1.0193792582,
-0.0520194434,
1.0091899633,
0.4968987107,
-0.1865776032,
0.0111901378,
0.797106266,
0.2474986911,
0.6669476032,
0.3100058436,
-0.332285285,
-0.2847363055,
-0.0287053101,
-0.2872861028,
0.3207873404,
0.4217943251,
-0.1460191309,
-0.1152167097,
0.2500677407,
-0.259727329,
0.0933496431,
-0.2258134633,
0.9983192086,
0.1415714473,
-0.6887356043,
0.6883358359,
-0.4000600576,
0.6883385181,
-0.5894771218,
-0.1960134208,
-0.6271538138,
0.4257780313,
0.0029585883,
-0.6906472445,
0.358566314,
-0.1570826173,
-0.319632113,
0.2833204269,
0.6087511182,
-0.7962846756,
-0.2136648893,
0.3565601707,
0.2550056279,
0.3801836371,
-0.0488472953,
-0.3696606755,
0.0214127228,
-0.2127895951,
-0.1983032227,
0.209288463,
0.3598792255,
-0.3366060853,
0.9582137465,
0.6168296337,
-0.0175026041,
0.4009698033,
-0.0803761184,
0.7489588261,
-0.7229363322,
-0.3575188518,
-0.8280364871,
0.098192893,
0.1611554772,
-0.2709658146,
0.5901087523,
0.8727455735,
1.0496428013,
-0.2265175432,
0.560601294,
0.1105260476,
0.3641944528,
-0.561516583,
0.7546953559,
-0.6103563905,
-0.1063225716,
0.0694865957,
-0.7950052619,
-0.3971913755,
0.7355413437,
-0.1951012611,
0.104205884,
0.6607971787,
1.0559052229,
-0.3790728152,
-0.1726898849,
0.4663965106,
0.1314495653,
0.1895549893,
0.9475662112,
1.2502766848,
-0.5480231643,
0.7098096609,
-0.1589628309,
-0.2107443064,
-0.3486335874,
-0.4304436743,
-0.5484139919,
-0.600389421,
-0.1939371973,
-0.145459041,
0.3023154736,
0.6233443022,
0.5890610814,
-0.9628503919,
-0.1811544001,
-0.112143226,
-0.0334422849,
-0.5670984983,
-0.1544899046,
0.4578754902,
-0.5315828919,
-0.6143047214,
0.0261846446,
0.4540913999,
0.2873243988,
-0.2146279067,
-0.0951344147,
-0.6164336205,
0.1998350769,
0.549379468,
0.6573019624,
-0.8842321634,
-0.3889921904,
0.2690028548,
-0.4071289897,
0.1400790662,
0.6676350236,
-0.6386609077,
0.6169403195,
0.4486812353,
0.5509054661,
0.6025738716,
-0.1214391515,
0.6086353064,
-0.567435503,
0.0978970453,
0.1462480426,
0.3229857087,
0.5030575991,
-0.2029767483,
0.4523606598,
-0.0347831845,
-0.4210425913,
-0.4574639201,
0.1130496189,
-0.8683091402,
0.1044073924,
1.1498092413,
-0.2341522127,
-0.4363523722,
-0.2257831395,
-0.5632513165,
0.4777071774,
-0.2217497677,
1.0366663933,
0.8100855947,
-0.127098605,
-0.3601911664,
-0.4327001274,
0.7246233821,
0.48358953,
-0.6615533829,
0.1469096988,
0.6501243711,
0.2663983107,
0.3059705198,
0.8235004544,
-0.0399753526,
0.6486583352,
0.091936864,
0.1425984055,
0.1542587876,
-0.2922163308,
-0.4299272597,
-0.1589089334,
-0.0749336034,
-0.6748523116
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.05278v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.05278v2
|
Lyrics: Boosting Fine-grained Language-Vision Alignment and Comprehension via Semantic-aware Visual Objects
| 2023-12-08T09:02:45 | 2024-04-12T10:26:01 |
Junyu Lu, Dixiang Zhang, Songxin Zhang, Zejian Xie, Zhuoyang Song, Cong Lin, Jiaxing Zhang, Bingyi Jing, Pingjian Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Vision Language Models (LVLMs) have demonstrated impressive zero-shot
capabilities in various vision-language dialogue scenarios. However, the
absence of fine-grained visual object detection hinders the model from
understanding the details of images, leading to irreparable visual
hallucinations and factual errors. In this paper, we propose Lyrics, a novel
multi-modal pre-training and instruction fine-tuning paradigm that bootstraps
vision-language alignment from fine-grained cross-modal collaboration. Building
on the foundation of BLIP-2, Lyrics infuses local visual features extracted
from a visual refiner that includes image tagging, object detection and
semantic segmentation modules into the Querying Transformer, while on the text
side, the language inputs equip the boundary boxes and tags derived from the
visual refiner. We further introduce a two-stage training scheme, in which the
pre-training stage bridges the modality gap through explicit and comprehensive
vision-language alignment targets. During the instruction fine-tuning stage, we
introduce semantic-aware visual feature extraction, a crucial method that
enables the model to extract informative features from concrete visual objects.
Our approach achieves robust performance on 13 datasets across various
vision-language tasks, and demonstrates promising multi-modal understanding,
perception and conversation capabilities in 11 scenario-based benchmark
toolkits.
|
[
-0.4343224466,
-0.5758082271,
0.3112389743,
0.0635043755,
-0.2790208161,
0.0277741607,
-0.5365831852,
-0.7047127485,
-0.0422792248,
0.6339139342,
-0.7157661319,
-0.4901251495,
-0.4383779764,
-0.0602495931,
-0.3510890305,
0.9421417117,
0.0694418624,
0.0199414343,
-0.1532554477,
0.0722995251,
-0.6979040504,
0.2557005584,
-0.170263648,
0.3085705936,
0.7163120508,
0.6150138974,
0.5937460661,
0.6656455398,
0.4668761492,
0.3034767509,
0.3174673617,
0.4042510986,
-0.5785631537,
0.1002317369,
-0.2073943466,
-0.5594010353,
-0.1328977644,
0.0628874153,
0.3831933439,
0.3408157229,
0.1011515856,
0.3377123773,
0.0677065477,
0.5437641144,
-0.8134160042,
0.3035760224,
-1.2102679014,
0.0966409445,
-0.4284040332,
-0.2506531477,
-0.2150003314,
0.2098303139,
0.3911373913,
-1.1215478182,
0.1974893659,
0.0959228203,
1.2543576956,
0.7090771198,
0.0849863142,
-0.2919972539,
-0.2303974628,
0.6907336116,
-0.2381404787,
0.5351618528,
0.1818743646,
0.5862292647,
0.153222084,
-0.8635242581,
-0.8294929862,
0.0653765127,
-0.1249250919,
0.2494591027,
0.2901014984,
0.2045626044,
0.1021976843,
0.3673863709,
-0.3599641919,
-0.0636361316,
-0.3531404138,
-0.2920079529,
0.1001064628,
-0.0538816079,
0.5018630028,
-0.3895067275,
-0.7990828753,
-0.0207233075,
-0.4170278013,
0.3288276494,
-0.0314458124,
0.6343730092,
-0.2324294001,
0.5804192424,
-0.2746843398,
1.19792068,
-0.0006265435,
-0.3733755052,
0.1903313845,
-0.4976843894,
-0.437389344,
0.1131228507,
0.7501153946,
0.4865866005,
0.5652560592,
-0.3531971276,
-0.1679236293,
0.3999839425,
0.2609201372,
-0.7052897215,
-0.3498296142,
-0.1665414721,
-0.2364919037,
-0.2832216024,
0.0514717549,
-0.7602809668,
-0.3334392607,
-0.7986504436,
0.9365025163,
-0.3381299973,
0.0852238461,
0.2595448196,
-0.0356208198,
0.2564792633,
0.4770684242,
-0.8924390674,
-0.2840506434,
0.738332808,
0.7403016686,
0.0768820196,
-0.6281078458,
-0.8258217573,
0.5151149631,
-0.3694661558,
0.7490794063,
-0.7789177895,
0.1641447544,
0.0444151536,
0.1822709292,
-0.1743953526,
-0.3254383802,
0.1373016536,
-0.1652280241,
0.1139028668,
-0.3060036004,
-0.2498559058,
-0.0400671661,
0.3352705538,
-0.280359447,
0.7193658352,
-0.0013313649,
-0.6441522241,
0.769836843,
-0.3808810711,
-0.3556661904,
0.029430218,
-0.5500888228,
-0.1873228997,
0.163522616,
0.2175091058,
0.5159527063,
-0.1699619144,
0.104420349,
-0.0611370169,
-0.564814508,
0.0310952868,
-0.313413769,
0.198027119,
0.0997147337,
-0.4353395104,
0.4044150412,
-0.804805398,
0.1690834016,
-0.2728951573,
-0.0873019621,
-0.1205157638,
-0.0667806119,
0.3996346295,
0.3880246282,
0.2681278586,
-0.4136633575,
0.0715320185,
-0.4258308113,
0.1418015361,
0.5459665656,
-0.4328725934,
0.4523682296,
0.057184875,
0.3699578345,
0.1877071112,
0.2775611877,
-0.6021769643,
-0.283113718,
-0.8906773329,
-0.3577853143,
0.0548403524,
0.5432015657,
-1.1996020079,
0.2621890008,
-0.3141579926,
-0.1813625842,
-0.7564188242,
0.4535709918,
0.7156586051,
0.818343401,
0.5066947937,
-0.223326683,
-0.4952848256,
-0.8327428102,
-0.1536228508,
0.2439053208,
0.0635287315,
0.2838916779,
0.200533852,
-0.1687129885,
0.996638,
-0.5339839458,
-0.9818424582,
-0.1164821312,
-0.0313778184,
-0.2096872777,
0.4647057652,
0.4882406294,
-0.8583635688,
-0.5581297278,
0.1778590232,
-0.5286515951,
-0.1670135111,
-0.078515552,
-0.3084881604,
0.1257627904,
0.688333869,
-0.4277775288,
0.2667300403,
0.5016521811,
-0.4714663625,
0.256439805,
0.0702107102,
0.1087543443,
-1.1845319271,
-0.1383258253,
-0.1069656387,
-0.1552323997,
-0.3786324859,
-0.2086770833,
-0.0624101199,
-0.1216554865,
-0.4361168444,
0.2419073135,
-0.4587121904,
-0.2186207622,
-0.2678569853,
0.5032632947,
0.291045785,
0.3538022935,
0.1153213009,
0.907313168,
0.9800570607,
-0.212202996,
0.1996751726,
0.326405853,
-0.7538564801,
0.7839507461,
-0.3565663099,
-0.2391522676,
-0.3291827142,
-0.0823541731,
-0.9443974495,
-0.3566011786,
0.2353649586,
-0.3329076767,
0.3991111219,
-0.3825828433,
-0.2601239681,
-0.072957918,
-0.0134641984,
0.173061803,
0.1218465939,
-0.4407705367,
0.547254324,
0.2012712061,
0.2289139479,
-0.7489852309,
-0.7144949436,
0.2179122865,
0.0092362314,
-0.5941435099,
0.2091756165,
0.2195779979,
0.2970527411,
-0.0155955385,
-0.1386574954,
-0.0289389193,
0.0120914271,
0.2203970402,
0.1849252284,
-0.3567464948,
0.279491663,
-0.1632459015,
-0.2845932543,
-0.2866779268,
-0.5209057927,
0.4207622707,
-0.1965650916,
-0.1689130813,
-0.5222576261,
0.1559675038,
0.7481205463,
-0.8147190213,
0.3213790357,
1.2037446499,
-0.159583196,
-0.1274286807,
-0.3756859601,
0.02730936,
-0.4758172333,
0.5969641209,
-0.5288490653,
-0.9218444824,
0.2812172771,
-0.0132655529,
-0.2476468086,
0.0674998611,
0.2453633994,
-0.230590567,
0.6848962903,
0.6713341475,
0.3025135398,
0.7694618106,
-0.3698177338,
0.2294827402,
-0.8919330239,
-0.4917290211,
-0.1501699984,
-0.5329062343,
-0.446349144,
-0.8085958958,
0.3009607792,
0.4558971524,
-0.1141840592,
0.2079700977,
-0.4886766672,
0.8120803237,
0.4092869759,
0.1499667019,
0.0849810243,
0.0106216203,
0.1202174574,
-0.2688057125,
-0.3723163307,
-0.1814430952,
0.6544911265,
0.1214043051,
0.8325466514,
-0.1409509927,
0.4483320117,
-0.3424602747,
-0.0230769422,
-0.9759902358,
0.4103632867,
-0.4650350511,
-0.4630364478,
-0.2773936689,
-0.0844392478,
-0.4906077683,
0.2026692629,
-0.5599445105,
-0.8950195312,
0.109590441,
0.2201158106,
-0.462095052,
0.1680561602,
-0.8540881872,
1.4919894934,
-0.4450007677,
-0.4555494189,
0.1224353388,
-0.9125497341,
0.2908262908,
0.0266711228,
0.1103352457,
-0.2861139774,
-0.1933477968,
0.2638311684,
-0.2459169328,
0.9130809903,
-0.2819584608,
-0.224021256,
0.1909505278,
0.0038021889,
0.1653771847,
-0.0027759627,
0.6190795302,
0.0141891213,
0.0886868834,
-0.1918001026,
-0.6452138424,
0.6969886422,
-0.3833914399,
-0.3467406332,
0.0880040899,
-0.7757799029,
-0.3597746193,
0.2954740226,
0.3146893084,
0.7365720868,
0.4201148152,
0.4288327694,
0.4051887989,
-0.23933734,
0.4193930924,
0.2935954928,
-0.4433285594,
-0.5374515057,
1.1702774763,
-0.0066969926,
0.5165455937,
0.5670683384,
0.1512052715,
-0.1043298021,
-0.3704322278,
-0.7396851778,
-0.208774507,
-0.6395120621,
-0.3820612431,
-0.4987477064,
0.1704746783,
-0.1066539735,
-0.3476801515,
-0.5669497252,
0.0305991434,
-0.2045378238,
0.2623532116,
0.4663047493,
0.4823327363,
0.0970199034,
0.3849564493,
-0.6884422898,
0.7074720263,
0.4577052593,
0.6818113923,
-0.0590406246,
-0.322268188,
-0.4212157726,
0.0205680989,
0.0487042032,
-0.5870679021,
-0.00484727,
0.4085547626,
0.1301838905,
0.5452548265,
-0.2890140414,
1.3903516531,
-0.6151708364,
0.72893852,
0.4379841387,
-0.9836251736,
0.7291781306,
-0.422771126,
0.2411671579,
0.8273597956,
-0.1375848949,
-0.5777503848,
-0.2799425423,
0.0805380121,
-0.6914960742,
0.8286878467,
-0.0213549733,
0.040647205,
0.0700261667,
0.2774924934,
0.0002867054,
0.3991529047,
-0.6578745246,
-0.0579645149,
-0.5515646935,
-0.5802112222,
-0.2090632468,
0.0264051631,
-0.037069913,
-0.5076624155,
0.1926605254,
-0.5042917728,
-0.2757334411,
0.2434531897,
-0.2230198383,
-0.1472824514,
0.0693569407,
0.6564392447,
0.4624049067,
0.112801075,
0.1830271184,
-0.2090830803,
-0.5483337045,
-0.178124994,
0.061310906,
-0.3039435446,
-0.2756213844,
0.2332240492,
1.0149062872,
0.6609153152,
-0.7565980554,
0.7232112885,
0.0604830086,
0.1944799423,
0.0077570416,
0.123007983,
-0.1160184443,
0.3755092919,
0.115455173,
0.3933935761,
0.0525796376,
-0.6840456724,
0.3900930583,
0.6153120399,
-0.868580997,
-0.1802107096,
0.6694103479,
0.1205739304,
-0.0671045482,
-0.0929564834,
-0.0646315813,
-0.6751240492,
0.2964841723,
0.4624824226,
0.6544789672,
0.1337617934,
0.2597653568,
0.1216926202,
0.2812441289,
0.1472991109,
0.4048968256,
-0.3282736838,
-0.6417927742,
-0.6315227747,
-0.93704772,
0.0249420702,
-0.0155055476,
-0.5140601397,
0.3307648301,
-0.2051308453,
0.2767110765,
-0.0845251307,
-0.2196526974,
-0.6041052341,
0.3988172114,
0.3030529022,
0.7330704331,
-0.764289856,
0.5918951035,
0.6948366761,
-0.6163091063,
-1.0620785952,
0.169034794,
-0.1351717561,
-0.788916409,
0.708681047,
0.6249855161,
-0.330267489,
0.1385870129,
-0.5313490629,
-0.8426753283,
0.9610543251,
0.3394202292,
-0.7075130343,
0.0430520661,
0.1059787944,
0.4148751795,
-0.3968786299,
-0.1734033376,
0.5173403621,
0.46869573,
0.3818599284,
-0.9767772555,
-0.3193970025,
0.0428662449,
-0.0342680551,
0.2700098753,
-0.539282918,
0.7308742404,
-0.2747165859,
-0.1195870489,
0.1825290769,
0.5283203125,
-0.1915657371,
0.4227101505,
0.4909189045,
0.7129557133,
0.523989439,
-0.3846687078,
0.7944611311,
-0.4761183858,
0.1617215574,
1.3415734768,
0.0211563446,
0.9898182154,
0.7188869715,
0.3014851809,
0.4557027221,
0.3256264031,
0.0748298317,
0.7034939528,
0.0690876171,
-0.0998776704,
-0.7148936987,
-0.3379223347,
-0.2901223302,
1.1219217777,
0.2534758747,
-0.2743606269,
-0.2522545457,
0.2312364876,
-0.3005754948,
0.260592252,
-0.344807744,
0.8516591787,
-0.1226002127,
-0.5589215755,
0.5056822896,
-0.6287696362,
0.8165354729,
-0.5026538372,
-0.117244415,
0.2661913335,
0.2388035357,
-0.2819065154,
-0.8200596571,
0.0685191602,
0.002429307,
-0.2249542922,
-0.154899925,
0.5242913961,
-1.0768297911,
-0.5437456369,
0.1503596455,
0.2460389733,
-0.13736929,
-0.1268654615,
-0.6057299972,
0.3635344803,
-0.124799259,
0.2392320633,
-0.0002408249,
0.7894698381,
0.2487239689,
0.3669499159,
0.5432910323,
0.0714585483,
0.1728748083,
0.4763338268,
0.7768403292,
-0.4150700867,
-0.3657341897,
-0.5517543554,
0.7268569469,
-0.0200762283,
-0.3115409613,
0.4760987759,
0.6878932714,
1.11162889,
-0.2830859423,
0.4370515347,
0.0173167177,
0.2143606544,
-0.8629821539,
0.8366369605,
-0.9020653367,
-0.0250139609,
-0.5653730035,
-0.8715076447,
-0.3366442919,
0.6887317896,
-0.1550679505,
-0.219357118,
0.4090532959,
0.8025138974,
-0.1733522862,
-0.3023939431,
0.4458836019,
0.2537716031,
0.2094471455,
0.5489082336,
0.8615282178,
-0.6326935887,
0.6742622852,
-0.2736091316,
-0.0022281555,
0.033936616,
-0.7717874646,
-0.9550797343,
-0.7319251299,
-0.0599144325,
0.0618241057,
-0.2238746285,
0.7224250436,
0.6907867789,
-0.5832971334,
0.0734537616,
-0.1845868975,
0.0625550598,
0.1587653756,
-0.2377124578,
0.1766923815,
-0.7958785892,
-0.6716667414,
0.4559166133,
0.7763938904,
0.1975355595,
-0.2729893625,
-0.0434619673,
-0.0692746639,
-0.2049270719,
0.7294285893,
-0.1044556573,
-1.1298458576,
-0.6236142516,
0.0247651413,
-0.0461657755,
-0.0187069476,
0.6281862259,
-0.8326563835,
1.0219355822,
0.3181184232,
0.5968248248,
0.1184670404,
0.1051492989,
0.2634373903,
-0.7731463909,
0.4667499959,
-0.2138729244,
0.2710623443,
0.4510480762,
-0.0259835944,
0.142012462,
0.2169960439,
-0.0859028399,
-0.7045277357,
0.4482774138,
-1.2840336561,
-0.1331449151,
0.8739989996,
0.0735167488,
-0.2955396771,
-0.0258971918,
-0.6826614738,
0.2224804163,
-0.0127964113,
0.7024011612,
0.31915012,
0.3728390634,
-0.1786932051,
-0.53752321,
0.9491906762,
0.2237090766,
-0.7056279182,
0.2015810013,
0.6592876315,
0.1284777969,
0.351366967,
0.1343528628,
-0.1656312943,
0.4493754208,
-0.088074781,
-0.0460803509,
-0.3047620356,
-0.8529840708,
0.1220756024,
0.0713934228,
-0.1859917045,
-0.5861031413
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04906v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04906v1
|
Ophtha-LLaMA2: A Large Language Model for Ophthalmology
| 2023-12-08T08:43:46 | 2023-12-08T08:43:46 |
Huan Zhao, Qian Ling, Yi Pan, Tianyang Zhong, Jin-Yu Hu, Junjie Yao, Fengqian Xiao, Zhenxiang Xiao, Yutong Zhang, San-Hua Xu, Shi-Nan Wu, Min Kang, Zihao Wu, Zhengliang Liu, Xi Jiang, Tianming Liu, Yi Shao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In recent years, pre-trained large language models (LLMs) have achieved
tremendous success in the field of Natural Language Processing (NLP). Prior
studies have primarily focused on general and generic domains, with relatively
less research on specialized LLMs in the medical field. The specialization and
high accuracy requirements for diagnosis in the medical field, as well as the
challenges in collecting large-scale data, have constrained the application and
development of LLMs in medical scenarios. In the field of ophthalmology,
clinical diagnosis mainly relies on doctors' interpretation of reports and
making diagnostic decisions. In order to take advantage of LLMs to provide
decision support for doctors, we collected three modalities of ophthalmic
report data and fine-tuned the LLaMA2 model, successfully constructing an LLM
termed the "Ophtha-LLaMA2" specifically tailored for ophthalmic disease
diagnosis. Inference test results show that even with a smaller fine-tuning
dataset, Ophtha-LLaMA2 performs significantly better in ophthalmic diagnosis
compared to other LLMs. It demonstrates that the Ophtha-LLaMA2 exhibits
satisfying accuracy and efficiency in ophthalmic disease diagnosis, making it a
valuable tool for ophthalmologists to provide improved diagnostic support for
patients. This research provides a useful reference for the application of LLMs
in the field of ophthalmology, while showcasing the immense potential and
prospects in this domain.
|
[
-0.1146444455,
-0.9365496635,
0.7839332819,
-0.0314130671,
-0.5344426036,
-0.1240635738,
-0.3798032105,
-1.0297256708,
0.332586199,
0.5398024321,
0.0136035653,
-0.6522887349,
-0.4599919021,
0.1890911013,
-0.288657248,
0.5933858156,
-0.1591326594,
0.5141550303,
-0.1840468943,
-0.1215534732,
-0.3136739135,
-0.2538464367,
-0.6858273745,
-0.358371675,
0.6067448258,
0.6282196045,
0.6033543348,
0.5346298218,
1.0590106249,
0.21280846,
-0.1983413994,
0.2017098516,
-0.1623399705,
0.2051199228,
-0.1059013009,
-0.5944741368,
-0.7744870186,
-0.0853443965,
0.5401912928,
0.9541932344,
-0.4637129307,
0.1325706542,
-0.1298346221,
0.5735345483,
-0.2439780533,
-0.0487792231,
-0.1681897044,
0.3103182316,
-0.3354204297,
-0.2091307938,
-0.2958314717,
-0.1705939919,
0.2464165539,
-0.7763881087,
-0.2589454651,
0.4044042528,
0.5850608945,
0.1198104993,
-0.4632585049,
-0.1471758634,
-0.4716712832,
0.562384665,
-0.7797128558,
0.1208683401,
0.4462629855,
0.4909456074,
0.055773858,
-0.6266335249,
-0.3981642723,
-0.4108748734,
0.1282232553,
0.006815684,
-0.1571968049,
-0.0509368181,
-0.0713028014,
0.3612044454,
-0.7776113153,
0.860748291,
-0.4923415482,
0.1198362783,
0.5406166315,
0.3247843087,
0.1751047224,
0.092307739,
-0.5092819333,
0.1388183981,
-0.7608878016,
-0.4385230243,
0.0209882073,
-0.0906432718,
-0.1329931468,
0.6583583355,
-0.4108898342,
0.8642429709,
-0.057937298,
-0.5510418415,
0.4427068233,
-0.1269631684,
-0.2795852423,
0.0858661905,
0.5983404517,
0.4894705117,
0.3104613423,
-0.0047543719,
-0.1878612489,
0.0832079127,
0.0434614643,
-0.7391433716,
-0.0533992313,
0.3011003137,
-0.8460118175,
-0.5870931149,
-0.3426177502,
-0.8005288839,
-0.4608007669,
-0.3370683491,
0.3247861564,
-0.1780888289,
-0.4153545201,
0.6171140075,
0.2912961245,
0.1606150717,
0.3768031895,
-0.8999825716,
0.3302815855,
0.4062840044,
0.6825689673,
-0.4602641463,
-0.1435091794,
-0.439119488,
0.031013418,
-0.6919009686,
0.8215019107,
-0.6389428377,
-0.3601967394,
0.0968756527,
-0.3501894176,
0.2185793966,
-1.0513199568,
0.0954940245,
-0.4730475843,
-0.1541189849,
0.0198374353,
-0.3360090852,
-0.2973187268,
0.1573606431,
-0.5345554352,
0.748408854,
0.2278130054,
-0.3042751849,
0.3227076232,
-0.6483514309,
-0.3230546713,
0.2475607991,
-0.1245440692,
-0.4537425041,
0.2299192846,
0.075474456,
0.3842192292,
-0.8324903846,
0.4720852673,
-0.3135816455,
-0.0675439984,
0.2014650255,
-0.0687704086,
0.4774337113,
0.0765835568,
0.0325105675,
0.0256505869,
-0.716139555,
-0.1642618477,
0.403309077,
-0.452822417,
-0.1444780082,
0.2754912078,
0.0184557158,
-0.1328265816,
0.4625399709,
-0.6002953053,
0.4147647321,
-0.5904470682,
0.2806279957,
0.5295185447,
-0.1518246531,
0.1210360751,
-0.1868131161,
0.5490617156,
0.2659590244,
0.4643118382,
-0.0464663617,
-0.7357935905,
-0.8109527826,
0.1214305907,
0.3826706111,
0.8206680417,
-0.493265599,
0.1899149269,
0.0106047075,
-0.3958063126,
-0.3083168566,
0.0947695002,
0.1760589629,
0.6480082273,
0.4069487154,
-0.2609158456,
-0.5156787634,
-1.0306913853,
-0.0164999906,
-0.0916750729,
0.1114968732,
0.2140674144,
0.4736595154,
-0.5720110536,
0.7300220728,
-0.8443164229,
-0.7443618178,
-0.368260622,
-0.180531919,
0.3045074344,
0.3126338422,
0.7320522666,
-0.7119232416,
-0.3635458946,
0.333384186,
-0.8592582941,
-0.3525421321,
0.4447422624,
0.1035512537,
0.2138632238,
0.4864856005,
-0.343868494,
0.5170813203,
0.8644518852,
-0.4943565428,
0.6214056611,
-0.2614408135,
-0.0053165946,
-0.8531247377,
0.2519714236,
-0.0768394321,
-0.5843086243,
-0.3269788921,
0.0606706999,
-0.2813876271,
-0.000050641,
-0.078806743,
0.4446635246,
-0.21242778,
-0.0827522278,
-0.1067838669,
0.0883198306,
-0.2726328671,
0.1185076758,
0.0540263467,
0.4853566587,
0.7850857377,
-0.3887943625,
0.5973718166,
0.2861364186,
-0.6830335855,
0.5086084604,
-0.7441640496,
-0.1708007008,
0.0879011154,
0.1154719889,
-0.7865475416,
-0.3492417336,
0.474236846,
-0.2834024727,
0.3323486447,
0.4071202278,
-0.7122123837,
-0.4373615086,
-0.0768766403,
0.7454171777,
0.686994493,
-0.5369260311,
0.4948788285,
0.5268087387,
-0.4260577559,
-0.2770062089,
-0.9532544017,
0.1405850798,
-0.1943832785,
-0.4145528376,
0.2373113334,
0.0661317408,
-0.5279768705,
-0.1363988519,
0.0854110122,
-0.2282376587,
0.0264443718,
0.0934856534,
0.3947808146,
-0.7047187686,
0.371113956,
-0.3416561484,
-0.4534739852,
-0.058555223,
0.0260279085,
0.3886125088,
0.0669177324,
-0.6205717921,
-0.5115351081,
0.4901289344,
0.2735074759,
-0.2067089081,
0.4233454168,
0.2907959819,
-0.2232518047,
-0.2186230123,
-0.6166911125,
-0.2872466445,
-0.4303221107,
0.3564318717,
0.1293569207,
-0.8096624613,
0.1918017268,
-0.2058834136,
-0.139458552,
0.4462114871,
0.5470405221,
-0.0512071997,
0.8750878572,
0.5999339223,
0.1788875312,
0.2049348652,
0.0577811636,
0.3690137267,
-0.7721428275,
-0.3700375855,
-0.2268290371,
-0.2575567067,
-0.1493979692,
-0.4601467848,
0.7818278074,
0.0142006995,
0.0514328666,
-0.2077378184,
-0.4298715889,
0.3095415235,
0.2296845913,
0.2831155062,
0.5123656988,
0.1489412338,
-0.0238734521,
0.1427191198,
-0.581766367,
-0.451734215,
1.3425371647,
0.506449163,
0.6869598031,
0.2683378458,
0.1319179684,
0.3236464858,
0.3894009292,
-0.8959907293,
0.5385807753,
-0.3796681762,
-0.2399862707,
-0.0647898763,
-0.0730847865,
-1.0494772196,
0.251229912,
-0.129164964,
-0.7108392119,
0.0844694972,
0.3839934766,
-0.456343174,
0.2230632007,
-0.5678406954,
0.7960502505,
-0.3351644278,
0.0169744696,
-0.5489498973,
-0.5798749924,
0.4036564827,
-0.1870009303,
0.1137854606,
-0.1522661299,
-0.4943306744,
0.8569091558,
-0.3242680132,
1.0549981594,
0.114347972,
-0.4853864908,
0.1067678407,
-0.0294638202,
0.1716425419,
0.089409031,
0.0064551341,
0.4799081385,
-0.1940982938,
-0.0278745126,
-0.180266425,
0.4305883646,
-0.3321772218,
-0.632221818,
-0.5566979647,
-0.2844315171,
-0.3704096973,
0.1600356698,
0.0288139433,
0.6242567897,
0.070150122,
0.2192148566,
0.5880346298,
-0.2496772856,
0.1955653578,
0.9227360487,
-0.6907624006,
-0.214815259,
0.646607399,
-0.0081579844,
0.2119153887,
0.4678649306,
0.3012933433,
-0.1082949638,
-0.9507618546,
-0.2949797213,
0.3212946951,
-0.7217457294,
-0.4775702059,
-0.1622509658,
-0.0092140986,
-0.0239909012,
-0.0696809515,
-0.1686794758,
-0.0287970025,
-0.5001391172,
-0.0430349931,
0.6716671586,
0.9434080124,
-0.2456546724,
0.2534976006,
-0.4483561814,
0.7440953255,
0.2057306767,
0.5988894105,
-0.0932025313,
-0.3048883677,
-0.147800222,
-0.0722049251,
-0.0757306516,
-0.8628201485,
0.3916344941,
0.293517828,
0.3500222266,
0.6263222098,
-0.3283286095,
0.4751371741,
-0.4456631541,
0.757758975,
0.4698314071,
-0.6977723241,
0.6578992009,
-0.1836277992,
-0.0084190769,
0.214487955,
-0.0169136934,
-0.3349592388,
-0.0973160788,
-0.1275624484,
-0.8836065531,
0.6261265874,
-0.3055984676,
-0.3945399821,
0.0217262842,
0.1578742564,
0.2759204805,
0.0931448489,
-0.3457897007,
-0.2776165903,
0.3414649069,
-0.1886443943,
-0.4114925563,
-0.5972544551,
-0.0604485013,
-0.4013814032,
0.3059512675,
-0.1881805956,
0.1691939831,
0.4320070446,
-0.134900853,
-0.1434364468,
0.0694809705,
0.6087694764,
0.8057377338,
0.093809925,
0.1314432919,
0.4034309685,
-0.6838405728,
-0.0516403653,
-0.1517381966,
0.1169044524,
0.0510939211,
0.4770590961,
0.5784975886,
0.3874200583,
-1.1231269836,
0.6321905851,
0.5080652833,
-0.2499587238,
-0.361795485,
0.1340971887,
0.0681496635,
0.2616136372,
0.4864173234,
0.1909461915,
0.268196851,
-0.3818801343,
0.001483646,
0.2831601799,
-0.0754755735,
-0.1893099546,
0.4703930616,
0.3174149394,
-0.0873752683,
0.3975076079,
0.100185208,
-0.2868223488,
0.8658227921,
0.6021798253,
0.2878699303,
-0.3059095442,
0.0219204016,
0.1594372839,
0.0829536095,
-0.2743396759,
0.4731644988,
0.1820907891,
-0.5447248816,
-0.4571499527,
-0.7266754508,
-0.2013620287,
0.2296221107,
-0.7059729099,
0.2378149331,
-0.3994573057,
-0.2359751612,
0.1760524064,
-0.1943424195,
-0.2840572,
0.3148595989,
0.3228929341,
1.1334841251,
-0.3572926223,
0.650547266,
0.4438560307,
-0.1398734599,
-0.3413051069,
-0.2283365279,
0.0280809868,
-1.304056406,
0.7611204982,
0.1817867607,
-0.130970031,
0.0105920834,
-0.4875505865,
-0.6939091086,
0.9893246889,
0.4801493287,
-0.9329078794,
-0.0363075137,
0.1362686902,
0.5999627709,
-0.403549403,
-0.1793337166,
0.5134977698,
0.5784063339,
-0.18482849,
-1.3528696299,
-0.0096697062,
-0.1119046584,
-0.0205462016,
0.2495426983,
-0.3478631377,
0.8812440038,
-0.5028859377,
-0.0747092813,
0.3911846578,
0.2221306711,
0.0749206021,
0.1308607906,
0.211895287,
0.5805516243,
0.4702574909,
-0.0189705566,
1.1940103769,
-0.1203183532,
0.2455952913,
0.4828653634,
-0.4038717449,
1.3306442499,
0.4832206666,
-0.2727126181,
0.4842574298,
0.6117289066,
-0.0771921277,
0.2626022995,
0.2021449655,
-0.1951108575,
-0.3844699264,
-0.1656024605,
-0.7611197233,
0.6680775285,
0.47653687,
-0.4905900359,
-0.0590793788,
-0.0737169757,
-0.1991929859,
0.0013724818,
-0.5656671524,
0.7427971959,
0.2173426449,
-0.4244117737,
0.5560727715,
0.0325146243,
0.6827600598,
-0.7973484993,
-0.0917238966,
0.2036497742,
0.2030069828,
-0.3661752939,
-0.8691828847,
0.3229244053,
-0.1081089377,
-0.2498862892,
0.0895349607,
0.4746106565,
-0.3393926024,
-0.461491406,
0.4412937164,
0.3700628281,
0.2159650326,
0.127549544,
-0.1380339712,
0.1311465502,
-0.2418012172,
-0.3539246023,
0.1264223754,
-0.001259712,
0.1124450713,
0.7659551501,
0.6191197634,
0.4386794865,
-0.3881755173,
0.0706842765,
0.5881239772,
-0.5319154263,
-0.393650949,
-0.813533783,
0.2253451645,
-0.0168185644,
-0.5258489847,
0.2566552162,
0.4601561725,
0.4128365219,
-0.2286487967,
0.5169255733,
0.2531079352,
0.6515591145,
-0.8406297565,
0.5184562802,
-0.9032518268,
0.0467426293,
0.2155918926,
-0.5089150667,
-0.7371307015,
0.772520721,
-0.1609353274,
0.0166645981,
0.7465415597,
0.5161229372,
-0.0646651685,
-0.0961049423,
0.3538337648,
0.5141580105,
-0.1563026458,
0.813208878,
0.7018960118,
-0.0692040771,
0.2484537065,
0.0457056277,
-0.1238220185,
-0.9766992331,
-0.5883498192,
-0.7735414505,
-0.4163700938,
-0.2921353579,
0.0825855583,
-0.0781650543,
0.6821246147,
0.7893492579,
-0.6443278193,
-0.0029556958,
-0.0255440809,
-0.1011536941,
-0.1683720797,
-0.1130637303,
0.2202739418,
-0.1198420897,
-0.3446047902,
0.4355045855,
0.6313760281,
0.1780756712,
-0.4794610739,
0.0285203084,
0.1090161726,
-0.2370547801,
0.8821617365,
0.1979756802,
-1.0885579586,
0.0164094958,
-0.1992157698,
-0.1662734151,
0.2819917202,
0.5480991006,
-0.8581987023,
0.3441402316,
0.2423347086,
0.350341022,
-0.0756657645,
-0.2016259432,
0.5660745502,
0.0717171282,
0.2252638191,
0.3511936069,
0.4318894744,
0.2886154056,
-0.336124599,
0.5732911825,
0.2195747644,
-0.3416387737,
-0.8706775308,
0.3584463596,
-1.2880094051,
-0.3462619483,
1.4437426329,
0.1712156683,
-0.1195257381,
-0.2036040574,
-0.5003166199,
-0.0365132019,
-0.2736511827,
0.5132346749,
0.2316785157,
-0.1256070882,
-0.0722300485,
-0.7846974134,
0.3285003304,
0.4914749861,
-0.9967257977,
-0.283603102,
0.4016316533,
0.3504883051,
0.0186713524,
0.5118821263,
-0.0923676491,
0.4661741555,
0.0088486578,
-0.234361425,
-0.1952550113,
-0.2603589892,
-0.288046509,
0.2826015353,
0.2140511423,
-0.2672801912
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04889v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04889v3
|
KwaiAgents: Generalized Information-seeking Agent System with Large Language Models
| 2023-12-08T08:11:11 | 2024-01-10T09:44:45 |
Haojie Pan, Zepeng Zhai, Hao Yuan, Yaojia Lv, Ruiji Fu, Ming Liu, Zhongyuan Wang, Bing Qin
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Driven by curiosity, humans have continually sought to explore and understand
the world around them, leading to the invention of various tools to satiate
this inquisitiveness. Despite not having the capacity to process and memorize
vast amounts of information in their brains, humans excel in critical thinking,
planning, reflection, and harnessing available tools to interact with and
interpret the world, enabling them to find answers efficiently. The recent
advancements in large language models (LLMs) suggest that machines might also
possess the aforementioned human-like capabilities, allowing them to exhibit
powerful abilities even with a constrained parameter count. In this paper, we
introduce KwaiAgents, a generalized information-seeking agent system based on
LLMs. Within KwaiAgents, we propose an agent system that employs LLMs as its
cognitive core, which is capable of understanding a user's query, behavior
guidelines, and referencing external documents. The agent can also update and
retrieve information from its internal memory, plan and execute actions using a
time-aware search-browse toolkit, and ultimately provide a comprehensive
response. We further investigate the system's performance when powered by LLMs
less advanced than GPT-4, and introduce the Meta-Agent Tuning (MAT) framework,
designed to ensure even an open-sourced 7B or 13B model performs well among
many agent systems. We exploit both benchmark and human evaluations to
systematically validate these capabilities. Extensive experiments show the
superiority of our agent system compared to other autonomous agents and
highlight the enhanced generalized agent-abilities of our fine-tuned LLMs.
|
[
-0.4450088739,
-0.6814114451,
0.9589762092,
-0.0994086936,
-0.1484218538,
0.0943333879,
-0.4528541565,
-0.6831220984,
0.1996580362,
0.2951865494,
-0.5866560936,
-0.485712409,
-0.5208251476,
0.1130128577,
-0.3097562194,
0.6467952728,
0.268959254,
-0.1708083451,
-0.0655880496,
-0.1395260245,
-0.2755384743,
-0.4464918673,
-0.5457264781,
-0.6057374477,
0.7688792944,
0.4110480845,
1.092094779,
0.2543590665,
0.1727020591,
0.3934542239,
0.1975916922,
0.3339108825,
-0.5060015917,
0.3743720651,
-0.3521136642,
-0.6841605306,
-0.4648938775,
-0.1598300189,
0.4577445388,
0.2026275396,
-0.1648325026,
0.0550283492,
0.0574080162,
0.4719647765,
-0.8491587639,
0.3321990967,
-0.491863519,
0.0296411831,
-0.1421269625,
-0.3202136457,
-0.3596574068,
-0.4220729172,
0.2799403667,
-0.8559539318,
0.2694040835,
-0.2117000818,
0.71146667,
0.2176855206,
-0.4530745149,
-0.4893856943,
-0.7775098681,
0.7706967592,
-0.3322920203,
0.3384898007,
0.7139723301,
0.5995507836,
-0.3660399914,
-0.7635581493,
-0.47720927,
-0.603997767,
0.0580517948,
-0.0890277922,
-0.322317332,
0.2561221719,
-0.0066592866,
0.0889298916,
-0.6704140902,
0.0276134443,
0.0693272203,
-0.4590791166,
0.592176795,
0.3455123305,
0.3314000666,
0.1525517702,
0.0463923104,
-0.134813264,
-0.4119719863,
0.0051319399,
0.2566426098,
0.0831727162,
0.2554732561,
0.5816930532,
-0.4650606513,
0.5736047029,
-0.1042289138,
-0.027530767,
0.0232915021,
0.0072969459,
-0.1833816022,
-0.1756056845,
0.4484311938,
0.0445258319,
0.5131575465,
-0.546901226,
-0.3767577112,
0.1861773729,
0.6785042882,
-0.7272350788,
-0.1022919267,
0.3369649947,
-0.4587293267,
-0.4041918814,
-0.2147271782,
-0.5411211252,
-0.601929605,
-0.3097262681,
0.6437419653,
-0.7251864672,
-0.1415154338,
0.0641365871,
-0.1823452711,
0.4139516056,
0.4429016113,
-0.8734415174,
0.3297080994,
0.4353057444,
0.7777045965,
0.0734928772,
-0.2729654014,
-0.3496379554,
0.2571039796,
-0.3716936707,
0.8003014922,
-0.8858762383,
-0.5357618928,
0.0627786815,
-0.0627763942,
-0.0195017308,
-0.2132597417,
0.6678391695,
-1.0572843552,
-0.0780326277,
-0.5470973253,
-0.4397147596,
-0.4243264794,
0.4553042054,
-0.5213605762,
0.9090064764,
0.0781843662,
-0.3289389014,
0.194677487,
-0.8371617198,
-0.2538809776,
0.3073576689,
-0.2847052217,
-0.0460391715,
0.2504019141,
0.1374598891,
0.3560531735,
-0.5701352358,
0.1460429877,
-0.2183136642,
-0.5351842046,
0.3050456643,
-0.30279392,
0.2738301158,
0.1892098933,
-0.325437814,
0.1737297177,
-0.5805955529,
0.4369670451,
0.4716591537,
-0.5428757668,
-0.258236289,
0.2583573163,
-0.1045366898,
-0.0470537283,
0.5936585665,
-0.4245319366,
0.4231625497,
0.0175853278,
0.3120491207,
0.8393118978,
-0.2235184163,
0.377943784,
-0.475818634,
0.594379127,
-0.2747789025,
0.1827324033,
0.0572201125,
-0.3266212046,
-0.8704345226,
-0.1380447149,
-0.0326683708,
0.3607011139,
-0.8718008995,
0.2963053286,
-0.3270352185,
-0.5881821513,
-0.2434941679,
-0.0751014426,
0.1396652013,
0.1614159793,
0.3590556085,
-0.0815476477,
-0.2647690177,
-0.8405051231,
-0.2123743743,
0.0629563928,
-0.390312463,
0.7731217742,
0.4524263144,
-0.5651339293,
0.986445725,
-0.6696015,
-0.277815491,
-0.2999519706,
-0.0124775684,
0.1125397012,
-0.1480655223,
0.5386403799,
-0.850390017,
-0.1799001992,
0.111588411,
-0.8352765441,
-0.1010002866,
0.4196750224,
-0.0886706263,
0.1038577706,
0.3361054063,
-0.8889349103,
0.2419194728,
0.1285532117,
-0.2698048949,
0.6533126831,
-0.5967395306,
-0.0748738348,
-0.7389342189,
0.4137611985,
-0.1827270836,
-0.2318526208,
-0.6757677794,
0.1761517525,
0.1637872308,
0.0291349608,
0.0823987648,
0.4861225784,
-0.5452815294,
-0.2022861242,
-0.4931005239,
0.2976205051,
-0.2598135769,
0.6020829082,
-0.2323927432,
0.8886286616,
0.3765953183,
-0.966498673,
0.5829312205,
-0.0514814332,
-0.2105694711,
0.5744595528,
-0.6213266253,
0.520586133,
-0.4397281408,
0.3920454383,
-0.6443715096,
-0.5042225718,
0.0900005773,
-0.2859574854,
0.1889730692,
-0.014888363,
-0.5807567835,
-0.343916297,
-0.1282144487,
0.3087917864,
0.3630185723,
-0.447580874,
1.0395448208,
0.3603536189,
-0.2029023468,
-0.6851390004,
-0.0584772527,
0.3879029453,
0.0271509029,
-0.6883727908,
0.2653032541,
0.0352610648,
0.0339069664,
0.0845271125,
0.0389170162,
-0.1113790348,
0.0659180507,
0.0901717246,
0.1375132352,
-0.0569989569,
0.7040190101,
-0.1878942996,
-0.2136619389,
-0.1165453047,
-0.8081808686,
0.858749032,
-0.4033006132,
-0.2537664771,
0.0858993754,
0.1333604157,
0.681152463,
-0.4212166071,
0.5294305086,
0.5576004982,
-0.2350732982,
-0.2186974585,
-0.7163745761,
-0.2500092983,
-0.5066787004,
0.5667666793,
-0.4974768162,
-0.8424897194,
0.435901314,
-0.2021760494,
-0.1680097282,
0.3661824465,
0.5119576454,
-0.0497559756,
1.0521554947,
0.8368729353,
-0.4476385713,
0.4305706024,
-0.351724565,
-0.1576327085,
-0.6089605093,
-0.2711524069,
-0.581677556,
-0.5369754434,
-0.4641104341,
-0.292453438,
0.5613260865,
-0.4357940257,
-0.2463603914,
0.0525187925,
-0.4422462881,
0.5620096922,
0.6457942724,
0.176510185,
0.2799098492,
-0.2075973749,
-0.5536448956,
0.3094109297,
-0.5719431043,
-0.6036986113,
1.1505658627,
0.0528768376,
0.7742305994,
0.2711327076,
0.2625918984,
0.6542317271,
0.0992879272,
-0.7288798094,
0.7589061856,
0.1059579998,
-0.5196329951,
-0.5042154193,
-0.3341764808,
-1.292242527,
0.5499438047,
-0.0049431985,
-0.9260415435,
0.1288639903,
-0.1287942976,
-0.000935844,
0.2530840635,
-0.3535360694,
0.485781908,
-0.3013113439,
-0.4088963568,
-0.7858486176,
-0.7091853023,
-0.0135274502,
0.0462468304,
-0.0576594435,
-0.1063776612,
-0.4071926773,
0.2800158858,
-0.383959353,
0.8391242027,
-0.2861784101,
-0.1110048965,
0.217643857,
0.1797115058,
0.688403964,
-0.2562237382,
-0.015670551,
0.004737163,
-0.2132907808,
-0.5851547718,
-0.6276515126,
0.6310659051,
-1.0165702105,
-0.5220017433,
-0.3676550388,
-0.6991177797,
-0.1318043023,
0.4870099425,
0.2285419703,
0.3120024204,
-0.4812473655,
0.0358419754,
0.5620949864,
0.0524004996,
0.3104493618,
0.9350849986,
-0.1878405362,
-0.0504100509,
0.8823364973,
0.174485907,
-0.0344177783,
0.4175512195,
0.0876981616,
-0.4429615438,
-0.4347608984,
-0.2704403698,
0.2295539081,
-0.615003109,
-0.0658918098,
-0.6402049065,
-0.0925374255,
-0.0192318168,
-0.0090257926,
-0.0435551852,
-0.1671738178,
-0.0323099568,
0.0905405432,
0.2460449934,
1.0433313847,
0.0507790707,
0.1696629077,
-0.7150751948,
0.2970177829,
0.5126780272,
0.4313348234,
0.2384801209,
-0.1419006288,
-0.3378769755,
0.2082990408,
-0.652002573,
-0.8116371632,
0.0978342667,
0.2025425583,
0.7157121301,
0.5287305117,
0.0454817154,
0.1587175131,
-0.1291953325,
0.4766750336,
-0.5193898082,
-0.7893038988,
0.4324756265,
-0.5635005236,
0.3993979394,
0.3428515792,
0.3099322021,
-0.6878733635,
-0.2495546341,
-0.2679784596,
-0.6112049818,
0.730550468,
0.3513742089,
-0.0629576743,
0.091009222,
0.4546067417,
-0.1423931569,
0.3465505242,
-0.2874954343,
0.210767433,
-0.055486843,
-0.051446721,
-0.386128068,
-0.1748347282,
0.1160957962,
0.1699465066,
0.810077548,
-0.4547480643,
0.2069619894,
0.3523719311,
-0.3683342338,
-0.195255205,
0.4139317572,
0.6617683172,
0.4784437418,
-0.2900319695,
0.1174397469,
0.2109642327,
-0.8331958055,
0.4515545666,
0.0889937058,
-0.0966252387,
-0.2331011146,
0.0856276676,
0.3630702496,
0.1117790118,
-0.7258137465,
0.2360186875,
-0.2804128528,
0.1397395879,
-0.4565737545,
0.4177529812,
0.1905061007,
0.4926230013,
0.6028891206,
-0.0398482606,
0.1071119756,
-0.4058055878,
-0.1827468872,
0.5746397376,
-0.3350194395,
-0.366227299,
0.35501647,
0.1891053915,
-0.3930880129,
0.7218014002,
-0.2152229249,
-0.4526426196,
0.621078074,
0.297210753,
1.147550106,
-0.3728635013,
0.2536592782,
-0.1320056468,
0.4071207941,
-0.0425937697,
0.3108160198,
-0.4926700592,
-0.8207938671,
-0.178393051,
-0.440295279,
-0.4686186612,
0.1129645184,
-0.3766166568,
-0.0574818738,
-0.2371336818,
-0.5101563334,
-0.1926068813,
0.2624361515,
-0.8340851665,
0.0450158343,
-0.0876637176,
0.8962518573,
-0.3334573209,
0.9183344841,
0.8730855584,
-0.3731387556,
-0.4884622097,
0.0862526149,
-0.0847438201,
-0.9573102593,
0.3701700866,
0.2590325475,
-0.5007567406,
-0.0722998306,
-0.5773139,
-1.0091614723,
1.4714077711,
0.4142728448,
-0.2833146155,
-0.326764822,
0.1832154989,
0.7672852278,
-0.1863784939,
0.3230851889,
0.71097821,
0.6218598485,
0.0533614382,
-0.7659040093,
0.0234802738,
-0.3943615854,
-0.0257935077,
0.3864151239,
-0.7528473735,
0.7621762156,
-0.3829122186,
-0.2122444361,
0.2601495981,
0.3223237395,
0.0608962029,
0.2447211146,
0.4845083356,
0.4319203198,
1.1148941517,
0.1187431216,
1.3186229467,
-0.3168138266,
0.2150835246,
0.799449265,
-0.2883032858,
0.4563229084,
-0.0378118455,
-0.134659186,
0.5244820118,
0.2449177355,
0.2620862126,
0.4269072711,
0.0531023964,
-0.5550418496,
-0.4638690054,
-0.2416754663,
-0.2090067863,
0.6267303824,
0.6063149571,
-0.2123648077,
-0.3526750207,
-0.1667179316,
-0.1812594235,
-0.1846307665,
-0.2369389534,
0.7533940077,
0.0423421338,
-0.6898775101,
0.4383897185,
0.125915423,
0.3697063923,
-1.079133153,
0.1097343117,
0.0518987067,
0.397806257,
-0.004307799,
-0.6526479125,
-0.2458686829,
-0.1136826202,
-0.1313256621,
0.2828263342,
1.161646843,
-0.1537973583,
-0.192603901,
0.56162709,
0.3951264322,
0.1146021336,
-0.2968100905,
-0.3324447572,
-0.0811601579,
-0.2494449317,
-0.2549403906,
0.3638449311,
0.3395538926,
-0.2042353898,
1.1468961239,
0.6146060824,
-0.039785061,
-0.3261756301,
-0.0442329235,
0.9650737047,
-0.7395335436,
-0.627086997,
-0.7311672568,
-0.0319016762,
-0.090451926,
-0.0268904455,
0.4317335784,
0.3823069036,
0.3673039079,
0.0923922211,
1.0657091141,
0.1593763232,
0.3041317463,
-0.2617943585,
0.8006270528,
-0.3948794305,
0.1218473762,
-0.1013648063,
-1.0168560743,
0.2072294056,
0.4700241983,
-0.3581474721,
0.4289513528,
0.251262486,
0.7492274642,
-0.1514053792,
0.2395000905,
0.5287415385,
0.3620757163,
0.6405957341,
0.7454555035,
0.9470270872,
0.0866085142,
0.6355162263,
0.1926190555,
-0.2721760273,
-0.6180016398,
-0.5160340667,
-0.7888585329,
-0.5060126185,
0.5678983331,
-0.0927230343,
0.384414345,
0.9414411187,
0.5270659328,
-0.319453001,
-0.1738751233,
-0.1324547082,
0.0839344561,
0.0907033607,
-0.1559493244,
0.2287393361,
-0.5842784047,
-0.3651415706,
0.5612924695,
0.4399353266,
0.0135082351,
-0.3055303693,
-0.1896280199,
0.1007566676,
0.4604373574,
0.4994927943,
0.3394145072,
-0.6187126637,
-0.4694804549,
0.1610212624,
-0.3616643846,
-0.1555643082,
0.8291362524,
-0.981235981,
0.5371904969,
0.1885221899,
0.465649277,
0.7167595625,
-0.1478615105,
0.6696447134,
-0.43843624,
0.1058811471,
0.3760504127,
0.3086277246,
0.0775831267,
-0.3845079541,
0.5189136863,
-0.1620966792,
-0.7525870204,
-0.1913111806,
0.3699413538,
-0.6307508349,
-0.3336291909,
0.7635199428,
0.1075456515,
-0.1265256554,
-0.3257733285,
-0.5253081322,
0.0876986533,
-0.6718325615,
0.9918714166,
0.67022717,
-0.1682209969,
0.2126340866,
-0.4820263386,
0.3354246914,
0.3582190573,
-0.6320601702,
-0.1582372934,
0.4567962885,
0.3240487576,
0.2533578873,
0.7947444916,
0.1552495062,
0.5442896485,
-0.0924035683,
0.1051710919,
-0.1310265362,
-0.2918685675,
-0.1577615291,
0.2416179329,
0.1726199836,
-0.1802971959
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04882v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04882v1
|
Classification of Human- and AI-Generated Texts for English, French, German, and Spanish
| 2023-12-08T07:42:06 | 2023-12-08T07:42:06 |
Kristina Schaaff, Tim Schlippe, Lorenz Mindner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this paper we analyze features to classify human- and AI-generated text
for English, French, German and Spanish and compare them across languages. We
investigate two scenarios: (1) The detection of text generated by AI from
scratch, and (2) the detection of text rephrased by AI. For training and
testing the classifiers in this multilingual setting, we created a new text
corpus covering 10 topics for each language. For the detection of AI-generated
text, the combination of all proposed features performs best, indicating that
our features are portable to other related languages: The F1-scores are close
with 99% for Spanish, 98% for English, 97% for German and 95% for French. For
the detection of AI-rephrased text, the systems with all features outperform
systems with other features in many cases, but using only document features
performs best for German (72%) and Spanish (86%) and only text vector features
leads to best results for English (78%).
|
[
-0.6296486259,
-0.6293544173,
0.4028016627,
0.4150359631,
0.1064882055,
0.3810205758,
-0.4167262614,
-0.8951315284,
0.0817208514,
0.4073813558,
-0.1090769023,
-0.6016655564,
-0.6360330582,
0.7149955034,
-0.5851125717,
1.0735198259,
-0.3135010004,
-0.0562669598,
-0.2413820773,
-0.386020869,
-0.2299033552,
-0.8369100094,
-0.72571522,
-0.4527651966,
0.4414152503,
0.2809449434,
0.5417383313,
0.4778622389,
0.5213418007,
0.461220324,
0.1967492402,
0.2733510435,
0.0815133825,
0.1057282239,
-0.1330381036,
-0.2685194016,
-0.1306019723,
0.1242183894,
0.6623068452,
0.2268903404,
0.2361399382,
-0.0932803527,
0.112037085,
0.4524655044,
-0.3461161852,
0.2419849485,
-0.3387697935,
0.0270702168,
-0.1900387406,
-0.2343687862,
-0.5723559856,
-0.3399364054,
0.1494630426,
-0.3700896204,
0.7540070415,
0.0685348138,
1.1436079741,
0.0970481858,
-0.3513164818,
-0.6027006507,
-0.5728603601,
0.8793250918,
-0.1833383143,
0.5408238173,
0.2397886217,
0.253667295,
0.1888787746,
-0.6318431497,
-0.9086612463,
-0.417275846,
-0.4002775252,
0.0087300614,
-0.2534798384,
-0.2396857291,
-0.0593814589,
0.3884879947,
-0.7880589366,
0.4856193066,
-0.2465816438,
-0.5511906147,
1.1297674179,
-0.1525114924,
0.5980465412,
-0.0856915936,
-0.0865563154,
-0.44214347,
-0.3952534497,
-0.0103710033,
0.4507666528,
0.1428290606,
-0.0704349875,
0.3908230662,
-0.1379039884,
0.4780749977,
-0.3671582937,
-0.4878325462,
0.8062125444,
-0.4804348648,
-0.1198715419,
-0.0229679942,
1.2580797672,
0.1830694377,
0.65564394,
-0.0967442542,
-0.4000037014,
0.1571798176,
0.1045006067,
-0.471950829,
-0.0726803541,
-0.0605965555,
-0.4841473401,
-0.4323687255,
0.3153413236,
-0.5201473236,
-0.2088674158,
-0.0534886979,
0.0327282548,
-0.2821075022,
-0.2328333259,
0.0375002064,
-0.2979910374,
0.2259260267,
0.4917156994,
-0.7105866671,
-0.0280424133,
0.5394701958,
0.6678752899,
-0.4499841332,
-0.7527533174,
-0.1601423472,
-0.2953864932,
-0.1552612036,
1.1693481207,
-0.3620120287,
-0.3512743115,
0.2555971742,
0.22084409,
-0.0321723036,
-0.5027114153,
0.6696739197,
-0.3185213506,
0.7952982187,
0.1143472642,
-0.4790072143,
-0.3601040542,
0.3548548818,
-0.883402884,
1.2102333307,
0.0810299516,
-0.9205495715,
0.592871964,
-0.6519858837,
-0.9463086724,
0.0339237787,
-0.3484182358,
-0.5224998593,
-0.2949571013,
0.230189383,
0.5780671835,
-0.3411832154,
0.2409854829,
0.2033174634,
-0.3317919075,
0.2073543072,
-0.6855419278,
0.5131386518,
0.331210494,
-0.4635531306,
0.1063917726,
-0.7263946533,
0.0372871161,
0.0311877411,
-0.8242586851,
-0.1747528911,
-0.095310159,
0.7773604393,
0.2565730512,
0.1914595664,
-0.5937632322,
-0.1211185604,
-0.4718430936,
0.3422313035,
0.2991605997,
0.0056153783,
0.3977903128,
-0.4084092677,
0.6587162018,
-0.0600907579,
-0.2462716401,
-0.3754747808,
-0.7849869728,
-0.7769492865,
-0.4855434597,
0.4282164574,
1.1609677076,
-0.8016727567,
0.8581493497,
-0.2884936333,
-0.6059513688,
-0.5951326489,
0.1118659377,
0.7189490795,
0.2452742755,
0.4391422272,
-0.0232823212,
-0.1444095671,
-1.1279636621,
-0.2934735715,
-0.3251469731,
-0.2075194567,
0.1188248768,
0.6690388918,
-0.2622979283,
0.6075467467,
-0.1028400734,
-0.1326642931,
-0.440795809,
0.4118438959,
-0.2166597843,
0.3544570506,
1.0246943235,
-0.8897351623,
-0.8138045669,
0.545579493,
-0.7741509676,
-0.1629965007,
-0.0139553156,
0.3799261749,
0.7437654734,
0.6228862405,
-0.2273859233,
0.6633864045,
0.0736568123,
-0.2269685119,
0.1497739553,
-0.3973405361,
0.6175931096,
-1.1322337389,
0.0708446279,
0.2494057417,
-0.3743628263,
-0.4274517298,
-0.1241198331,
0.0224467199,
0.0536428615,
-0.5844136477,
0.8671973944,
-0.1751997024,
0.1981714666,
-0.404545933,
0.2504154444,
0.1640183032,
0.3241380751,
0.372071445,
0.80315274,
0.2332566679,
-0.4686836004,
0.3566194177,
0.0825463682,
-0.4834721684,
0.4720071256,
-0.4849054217,
-0.0423751175,
-0.43025437,
0.048176676,
-1.0993139744,
-0.1924980879,
0.1040906087,
-0.7297391295,
0.2522410452,
0.3259392381,
-0.7599818707,
-0.3572174311,
-0.3953815997,
0.1854306906,
0.4349495769,
-0.4326736927,
0.5492514968,
0.3353290558,
-0.2412963361,
-0.6051060557,
-0.8369214535,
-0.0475356989,
-0.3245880902,
-0.5602346659,
0.405218035,
0.2111158967,
-0.2916347086,
0.206349209,
0.4312553108,
-0.0745769367,
0.2554877996,
0.2031520456,
-0.1051781997,
-0.1818341464,
0.2436359376,
0.356159687,
-0.0460331552,
-0.3471196294,
0.0364678912,
0.7110944986,
-0.1984937191,
-0.2053416967,
-0.6841884851,
0.6636887789,
0.740183115,
-0.4917718172,
0.685095489,
1.0184925795,
-0.3975299597,
-0.1279818565,
-0.5937256813,
0.1205418557,
-0.3928093016,
0.4148772061,
-0.6935549974,
-1.0083887577,
0.6191247702,
0.3646028638,
0.30684641,
0.9116812944,
0.8011767268,
-0.1946202219,
1.0958808661,
0.9205421805,
-0.3829939365,
0.5319969654,
-0.082656756,
0.2567604482,
-0.1156766638,
-0.1884078979,
-1.0959634781,
-0.2615453005,
-1.1839958429,
-0.0880017206,
0.0641147941,
-0.0587674044,
-0.1942602098,
0.5054854155,
-0.5469185114,
0.6725189686,
0.87422508,
-0.2602428198,
0.2882914841,
0.2332801074,
-0.0581990033,
-0.0012094754,
-0.5211364627,
-0.8703461289,
1.024979353,
0.4123825431,
0.1822019219,
0.0038791585,
0.896600008,
0.7114367485,
0.646422863,
-0.7059723735,
0.3108766973,
-0.4628638327,
-0.3145648241,
-0.2929046154,
-0.3414421976,
-0.9635397792,
0.28466326,
-0.5008106232,
-0.5071766973,
-0.0228611454,
-0.1410952806,
0.0226453617,
0.0147434203,
-0.8550627828,
0.9433948398,
-0.410567522,
0.2012976557,
-0.2505720258,
-0.2713115215,
-0.041719459,
-0.3148136139,
0.3129209578,
-0.0969058275,
-0.0100530563,
0.7555738091,
-0.1544976234,
0.5572952628,
0.1980284303,
-0.1585344225,
0.2888596654,
-0.2153916955,
-0.0257451795,
0.1030897424,
-0.1775692552,
0.3582561314,
-0.1809680462,
-0.2519804537,
-0.3887129426,
0.5889793634,
-0.9494891763,
-0.3141079843,
-0.6457699537,
-0.2610940039,
0.1299614906,
0.3510579169,
0.708342433,
0.0492153578,
-0.3921750188,
-0.013540512,
0.3540834188,
-0.630118072,
0.6187159419,
0.6076430678,
-0.5209408402,
-0.339787364,
1.1105594635,
-0.1304820329,
-0.1380664408,
0.5691350102,
-0.0368458442,
-0.382919997,
-0.5103731155,
-0.6744121313,
0.2377231568,
-0.6934245229,
-0.1633158922,
-0.6361482739,
-0.476767987,
-0.3422172964,
-0.279232502,
-0.0687947795,
-0.3856469393,
-0.313269943,
-0.1920277923,
0.182054624,
0.7234229445,
0.2019587755,
0.1948601604,
-0.8485329151,
0.2607544363,
-0.0382894613,
-0.067917712,
-0.2398779094,
-0.4509406984,
-0.1113756597,
-0.2171822488,
-0.388171047,
-0.811807096,
0.4839638174,
0.4146451652,
0.7351323366,
0.309015274,
-0.2218720913,
-0.0710547268,
-0.6457480788,
0.7065134048,
0.0554417111,
-0.868329823,
0.6128975749,
0.0099618994,
0.1025968865,
0.6472524405,
0.6510851383,
-0.621036768,
-0.8448419571,
-0.5264952779,
-0.716858089,
0.6730921268,
0.2635800838,
0.3435377181,
-0.2505595088,
0.3063767254,
0.118650943,
0.2493882775,
-0.8363970518,
-0.4069671631,
-0.1285259575,
-0.6710056663,
-0.1769030094,
0.0668729991,
0.3427234292,
-0.1217894182,
0.4264641106,
-0.0400926098,
0.2051562667,
0.1359516233,
-0.1914166063,
0.1936908066,
0.3031690121,
0.7432140708,
0.4211972952,
0.2238861918,
-0.0323320143,
0.0472049527,
-0.513797462,
0.3477846384,
0.1818413138,
-0.4171569049,
0.3205839992,
0.8528508544,
0.7066662908,
-0.1501254588,
-0.9137960672,
0.4000318646,
-0.3082291186,
-0.406537503,
-0.3323870003,
0.2324646264,
-0.2422158718,
0.268479526,
0.1531058997,
0.0965438709,
0.1550063044,
-0.6816983819,
0.2579362094,
0.2551098764,
-0.0233573113,
-0.1859246492,
0.390232414,
0.4015328884,
-0.6702334881,
0.6184030771,
-0.6372065544,
-0.9837588668,
0.7636993527,
0.3879992068,
0.8734616041,
-0.351775974,
0.4656940699,
0.4030558169,
0.4606205821,
-0.2057937831,
0.4186719954,
-0.0020816384,
-1.1937353611,
-0.1332960278,
-0.7567528486,
-0.3016964495,
0.1099139452,
-0.4774977863,
0.4021140933,
-0.2924682796,
-0.0859485045,
0.4480478466,
-0.0888239145,
-0.8668352962,
0.2168973684,
0.192774266,
0.7921073437,
-1.1401786804,
1.0341571569,
1.0238193274,
-0.4577502012,
-0.4432919621,
0.0300184339,
-0.1003869846,
-0.6643590331,
0.5585839152,
0.4840750694,
-0.1667086035,
-0.1056224108,
-0.0748117566,
-0.5483896136,
0.7866159678,
0.1670095176,
-0.3572473526,
0.1882606,
0.4363535643,
1.0285910368,
-0.3833313584,
0.1718301773,
0.7077467442,
0.6401774287,
-0.396985203,
-1.4632537365,
-0.5173924565,
-0.529873848,
-0.2371009439,
0.2809626758,
-0.5221511126,
0.7661876082,
0.1399835944,
-0.4958668053,
0.0051702224,
0.5576301813,
-0.0226374306,
0.4789693654,
0.4306419492,
0.5956572294,
0.8419699073,
-0.3264539242,
1.1097441912,
-0.2446279675,
0.234104827,
0.7018521428,
-0.3408321142,
1.0316369534,
-0.0232454464,
-0.1232032776,
0.5537080765,
0.6629747748,
-0.1068883687,
0.2892218232,
0.1706001461,
-0.2367074937,
0.1129085496,
-0.0912996903,
-0.248540163,
0.7827405334,
0.3604338169,
-0.4788150191,
-0.1494517773,
0.690099895,
0.1969601661,
0.4618939757,
-0.1573166996,
0.9321430922,
-0.2582657039,
-0.882827282,
0.500554502,
0.6240935922,
0.9270375371,
-0.1029300913,
0.0587558299,
-0.382237643,
0.156992808,
-0.2012058645,
-1.0490766764,
0.2899629176,
0.4786101878,
-0.4964433014,
-0.353903085,
0.5375611186,
-0.5818167925,
-0.6950811744,
0.3676230013,
0.6881235242,
0.2295241952,
-0.071223706,
-0.7664256096,
-0.0828615129,
0.0717820153,
-0.1502120495,
0.1256989986,
0.4012024105,
-0.4615514278,
0.6129618287,
0.3452779353,
-0.2100143582,
0.1172033325,
0.2139819413,
0.4358940721,
-0.7095066905,
-0.5828799605,
-0.8060400486,
0.1678295583,
-0.145246923,
-0.4545642734,
0.6468877196,
0.6411379576,
1.2927702665,
-0.0406247452,
1.1059138775,
-0.0727481842,
0.5974417329,
-0.3958825469,
0.8646760583,
-0.63129282,
0.0510294996,
-0.2004228234,
-0.9410483837,
-0.4320560098,
0.8107232451,
0.0030621549,
0.1737679988,
0.7850347161,
0.4511003494,
0.2107435018,
-0.1731053144,
0.1104991511,
-0.3959923387,
0.4691449106,
0.4139809608,
0.8018352985,
-0.4605694711,
0.4170246124,
-0.3736193776,
-0.1414627582,
-0.084931314,
-0.6654903889,
-1.0704259872,
-0.7066506743,
-0.482598573,
-0.2352278978,
-0.3958641291,
0.6229209304,
0.4393164814,
-1.1557494402,
-0.1260715425,
0.1005192921,
0.354083091,
-0.0556706116,
-0.2944929004,
0.5071932673,
-0.4171696007,
-1.11183393,
0.3681004047,
0.2583484352,
0.1813519001,
-0.3302377164,
-0.0289370921,
-0.0562789664,
-0.0836726129,
0.5758437514,
0.3507431746,
-0.6584686637,
-0.4174917042,
0.0775004327,
-0.4147446752,
-0.0099014686,
0.7900971174,
-0.6643086672,
0.2020955533,
0.7416374683,
0.6588361859,
0.2215269506,
-0.0384184048,
0.386631608,
-0.8488918543,
0.5265450478,
0.2804481089,
0.4331392944,
0.3777326643,
-0.2240951955,
0.4757135808,
0.1547856927,
-0.4675189555,
-0.759200573,
0.2548517883,
-0.6414785981,
-0.3743296266,
0.7569858432,
-0.3318201005,
-0.0767523795,
-0.3024332523,
-0.2479676902,
0.1045270413,
-0.1606593877,
0.71702981,
0.9082532525,
-0.1766393036,
-0.1912941337,
-0.3285998404,
0.6972091794,
-0.0324011073,
-1.0684928894,
-0.4781713188,
0.4497616589,
0.1542590708,
0.7123690248,
0.557466805,
-0.083842203,
0.4926076829,
-0.2811507881,
0.2736869454,
0.2219467312,
-0.5924630761,
-0.2677696347,
0.1259427071,
0.0856850892,
-0.1121582091
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04881v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04881v1
|
Predictive Chemistry Augmented with Text Retrieval
| 2023-12-08T07:40:59 | 2023-12-08T07:40:59 |
Yujie Qian, Zhening Li, Zhengkai Tu, Connor W. Coley, Regina Barzilay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This paper focuses on using natural language descriptions to enhance
predictive models in the chemistry field. Conventionally, chemoinformatics
models are trained with extensive structured data manually extracted from the
literature. In this paper, we introduce TextReact, a novel method that directly
augments predictive chemistry with texts retrieved from the literature.
TextReact retrieves text descriptions relevant for a given chemical reaction,
and then aligns them with the molecular representation of the reaction. This
alignment is enhanced via an auxiliary masked LM objective incorporated in the
predictor training. We empirically validate the framework on two chemistry
tasks: reaction condition recommendation and one-step retrosynthesis. By
leveraging text retrieval, TextReact significantly outperforms state-of-the-art
chemoinformatics models trained solely on molecular data.
|
[
0.073906213,
-0.3775021732,
0.9316738844,
-0.1003315896,
0.2154565752,
0.4687543213,
-0.0917267203,
-0.5687636733,
0.2554704547,
0.6578387022,
-0.851934731,
-0.5700001121,
-0.1085443869,
0.3068661392,
-0.2152326703,
1.201459527,
-0.2725601792,
0.330375582,
-0.6399372816,
0.3807301819,
-0.1303376406,
-0.2245455384,
-0.389385879,
-0.6332643032,
0.5581052303,
0.2575552166,
0.5105528831,
0.4024040103,
0.7751722336,
0.2455118448,
-0.0458817147,
0.1540770531,
-0.1393857151,
0.2964810431,
-0.3705825806,
-0.3479229808,
-0.4616548419,
0.1679939032,
0.4423025548,
0.6507015824,
0.1512614787,
-0.3149060905,
0.0602876469,
0.7601702809,
-0.8631078005,
0.1777403951,
-0.5280356407,
0.1486546099,
0.191016376,
-0.0753617659,
-0.3572375774,
-0.5449424982,
0.4615593553,
-0.7865162492,
0.1502225995,
-0.0449129269,
0.4759670496,
0.1124929637,
-0.5251286626,
-0.3924148977,
-0.6648242474,
0.6392393112,
-0.4214761555,
0.3408167064,
0.5137279034,
0.4264232516,
-0.2784098685,
-0.9137873054,
-0.5774083734,
-0.5010018349,
-0.4067668915,
0.4448144436,
0.3606486917,
0.5239351392,
0.0006814367,
0.6679826379,
-0.6255145073,
-0.4537799954,
-0.3090802133,
-0.5430591702,
0.3740290701,
0.3102671206,
0.2786799371,
-0.2160616666,
-0.7285363078,
0.1728622466,
-0.2065849155,
-0.1483824998,
0.1492041945,
0.5428458452,
0.2382154763,
0.752748847,
-0.3855766654,
0.5378389359,
-0.0479022302,
0.1576724797,
0.1120885238,
-0.8148351312,
-0.1251920313,
0.5553260446,
0.6893246174,
0.2316066474,
-0.0096861813,
-0.3082464039,
-0.1261476576,
0.1874769032,
0.2591115534,
-0.9925566316,
-0.4992192686,
0.5055437088,
-0.0367817581,
-0.5319839716,
0.25634408,
-0.9656631351,
-0.6214140058,
-0.3313274682,
0.5196756721,
-0.4266051948,
0.2322973013,
-0.0817688629,
-0.4072344899,
-0.3671767116,
0.4690733552,
-0.6819126606,
0.4694373906,
0.675712347,
0.7695969343,
-0.2580165863,
0.0223392844,
-0.469281435,
0.1646545976,
-0.1850300878,
0.7424113154,
-0.760434866,
-0.2332425565,
0.1141646877,
0.1094655171,
0.1910884082,
-0.4990997016,
0.7114232183,
-0.3846722543,
0.2859325111,
-0.0588682964,
-0.5834775567,
0.1073708832,
0.2254909426,
-1.0002607107,
0.9620712399,
0.1768902093,
-0.6711094379,
0.2759141028,
-0.5068660975,
-0.5106361508,
-0.0189548992,
0.2644345462,
-0.3768394291,
-0.1927154064,
0.1457998902,
0.2999101579,
-0.0100494344,
0.1075063273,
-0.2874376178,
-0.120306842,
0.4595507681,
0.1364809275,
0.2510235906,
0.4471718371,
0.059903238,
0.0794332847,
-0.8668149114,
0.1612270325,
-0.5786125064,
-0.6192626953,
-0.159730196,
-0.0894651115,
0.3717008829,
0.3059005141,
0.413744092,
-0.708250761,
0.1965358704,
-0.5244817734,
0.1422075629,
0.4669081569,
0.2251825482,
0.8524710536,
-0.1272478253,
0.5661864877,
-0.3759641051,
-0.145653829,
-0.5416709781,
-0.1351246834,
-0.3839818239,
-0.2164165229,
0.3232673705,
0.6633108258,
-0.830529511,
0.2388890833,
-0.1309056282,
-0.5742487311,
-0.2660492957,
0.204930231,
0.4498459995,
0.6313204765,
0.5897804499,
0.281426847,
-0.9993998408,
-0.8129220009,
-0.6344963908,
-0.2177921832,
0.0155347204,
-0.0193061717,
0.456145376,
-0.5198876858,
0.8764111996,
-0.4506815672,
-0.4641587734,
-0.3630677462,
0.1159031317,
0.1160361916,
0.360350579,
-0.1506976634,
-0.7542728782,
-0.5721068382,
0.4154503644,
-0.5233895183,
-0.1658952981,
-0.0579647012,
-0.3878006637,
0.2850297391,
0.6880635619,
-0.375264138,
0.3871608377,
0.4572937191,
-0.2460836619,
0.1857392639,
0.0710743591,
0.3050916493,
-1.1857275963,
0.2781611085,
0.2117261291,
-0.356615603,
-0.6710397601,
-0.1381801218,
0.2083075643,
-0.2447677702,
-0.4744505286,
0.7900387049,
-0.2674443424,
0.3117066622,
-0.4022071958,
-0.1769988537,
0.2482283413,
0.1808599681,
0.5429442525,
0.3947381377,
0.0878848508,
-0.4311316609,
0.212246716,
0.0596919619,
-0.2128654271,
0.2749375701,
-0.5029729009,
-0.1609685719,
0.0484133586,
0.5646030307,
-1.2569005489,
-0.5853446722,
0.1287800372,
-0.4309222698,
0.2817379832,
0.1353262514,
-0.2296944112,
-0.224783361,
-0.3158671558,
0.301464349,
0.0386618339,
-0.5088802576,
0.9725341201,
0.0204636566,
-0.1480500102,
-0.4763427675,
-0.6418128014,
-0.194164902,
0.0052203713,
-0.1212945506,
0.5661579967,
-0.24057962,
-0.1656986326,
-0.0963240564,
-0.3554801345,
-0.225445047,
-0.1967781633,
0.2838633358,
0.5321062207,
0.3953651488,
0.3435005546,
-0.0518177487,
-0.0368503593,
-0.0093749855,
-0.1995731443,
0.3265518844,
0.274684459,
0.4176868498,
-0.401499778,
0.2907403111,
0.3911940157,
0.0177192707,
0.6652618051,
0.3635856807,
-0.4960090816,
0.069090724,
-0.1919935346,
-0.3581641316,
-0.4911868572,
0.3763679862,
-0.1805845201,
-0.5166071057,
0.4501900673,
-0.0166857988,
-0.3213285804,
0.5081593394,
0.2491640151,
-0.2959008813,
0.9695360661,
0.5760635734,
0.0819483325,
0.4211767912,
0.2032787949,
0.1069352329,
-0.6457247138,
-0.6227535009,
-0.5240926147,
-0.0651851371,
-0.4807418585,
-0.3630430996,
0.3915857971,
-0.0447507352,
-0.2322185487,
0.5731270313,
-0.5528054237,
0.5625167489,
0.037357267,
0.4733985364,
0.4131341577,
0.2703851461,
-0.3203742206,
-0.2548039854,
-0.3443587422,
-0.3357011676,
1.098072648,
0.2823826969,
0.9303969145,
-0.0507192761,
0.8130501509,
0.2864354551,
0.247245267,
-0.8146395087,
0.4126758873,
0.0695209801,
-0.9556033015,
0.0538452268,
-0.4551709592,
-0.6590807438,
-0.2140153795,
-0.6192860603,
-0.4575775564,
0.0248760823,
0.1106765866,
-0.1772061139,
-0.2110940069,
-0.4643492103,
0.723536253,
-0.2919028997,
-0.6271062493,
0.076730378,
-0.661008954,
0.2285676152,
-0.3617797792,
0.2581836879,
0.2115711421,
-0.1796367764,
0.5563654304,
-0.5246229172,
0.5575782061,
0.3678272367,
-0.1710188985,
0.1828465909,
0.2921640873,
0.4904107153,
-0.0963049084,
-0.2535615861,
-0.4130147696,
0.2760927677,
-0.3435506523,
-0.7751843929,
0.7907714248,
-0.2180785686,
-0.1423727721,
-0.611800909,
-0.3582399786,
-0.1714963764,
0.2757186294,
0.5574553609,
0.1306386441,
-0.5640344024,
-0.3414669633,
0.439966321,
-0.1068033129,
0.4195256233,
0.2788261473,
-0.4618592262,
-0.8002425432,
0.8207349181,
-0.3535396457,
0.4814785123,
1.0031306744,
0.007505347,
-0.3928047717,
-0.0114560826,
0.1845061928,
-0.1545307785,
-0.8852118254,
-0.2242548168,
-0.6876635551,
0.0096101826,
-0.4575052559,
-0.1432760656,
-0.3511911929,
-0.6225551367,
-0.2502409518,
-0.4053492546,
0.4425825477,
0.6852536201,
0.0562744141,
0.1109588966,
-0.7698128223,
0.4183447063,
-0.0412719622,
0.3808125556,
-0.4912047684,
-0.1382481456,
-0.5035558939,
-0.0001826145,
-0.2439668477,
-1.0290153027,
0.4423657358,
0.3744834065,
0.3676691055,
0.0411327779,
0.0900699198,
0.4239184856,
-0.5317623615,
0.6639726758,
0.1865741909,
-0.8486092091,
0.9942831993,
-0.3980719447,
0.3739209771,
0.8414806724,
0.6977920532,
-0.4228384495,
-0.1703935564,
-0.2890310287,
-0.8127856851,
0.408791244,
0.2020336986,
-0.063265264,
-0.0282411706,
0.3516961336,
0.2507070303,
0.103021048,
-0.7391364574,
-0.0295364521,
-0.2498717159,
-0.7296229005,
-0.3155981898,
0.005464613,
0.0250189286,
-0.3833113015,
0.7537748814,
-0.0571042299,
0.2570904791,
0.4149348438,
-0.0975782201,
-0.2484897226,
0.3077228665,
0.354042083,
0.3114124537,
-0.6451222301,
0.1426758617,
-0.1219646409,
-0.6252123117,
0.0957486629,
0.2961328924,
0.2668772042,
0.1921778172,
0.3675129414,
0.3887810707,
0.0716828778,
-0.9238969088,
0.1509796679,
0.0778115615,
-0.1517524719,
-0.2102548182,
-0.0074218651,
-0.0709159672,
0.2458613366,
0.5015380979,
0.2451224476,
0.7333013415,
-0.7662633061,
0.347874403,
0.4387454391,
-0.8609911203,
-0.0705432147,
0.6601483822,
0.1679354161,
-0.0162653606,
0.2065914571,
0.2017111033,
-0.7635161877,
0.5151718855,
0.2142066509,
0.7576964498,
-0.16123344,
0.2024170607,
0.6245787144,
0.0070939497,
-0.0030458479,
0.2207285613,
-0.0422095284,
-0.3816241324,
-0.1881131083,
-0.6367363334,
-0.400551796,
-0.0409077108,
-0.4500060976,
0.3753531873,
-0.6861587763,
-0.1006444842,
0.2240955383,
0.3019321561,
-0.432703644,
0.4727561772,
0.0682551041,
0.8149319291,
-0.793784678,
0.6272669435,
0.8277354836,
-0.4357552528,
-0.4905585647,
0.1880574673,
0.2136353701,
-0.1608220041,
0.8553521037,
0.2324484736,
-0.01526599,
-0.2408881038,
-0.4626691639,
-0.7149702311,
0.7996513247,
0.0008227488,
-0.3508170545,
0.2270191014,
0.1173275337,
0.5787680149,
-0.3925826848,
0.4356454015,
0.5296646953,
0.4688437879,
0.2582006752,
-0.8359726667,
0.2343415916,
-0.5849161148,
-0.1168570668,
0.1174508035,
0.051286459,
0.6625480652,
-0.2451379597,
-0.1256460696,
0.5608443022,
0.5622535348,
0.0606930666,
0.5329927206,
-0.1161544099,
0.3066926599,
0.5356538296,
-0.1068490893,
1.2512716055,
-0.0736808106,
0.3623318374,
1.055518508,
-0.260877192,
0.9059644938,
0.5559327602,
-0.231715709,
0.7405635118,
0.8954173923,
0.1596173346,
0.9120902419,
-0.0797230974,
-0.6375136375,
-0.1954142898,
-0.1886584163,
-0.1382255107,
0.1476912051,
0.3428933918,
-0.6727001667,
-0.139336884,
0.1235883459,
-0.147765696,
0.4379733801,
-0.5605329275,
0.8959398866,
-0.2616492808,
-0.8996680975,
0.4080429375,
-0.1258897483,
0.6321063638,
-0.4083629549,
-0.3467000425,
-0.0633201599,
0.4426755607,
-0.5243302584,
-0.8564694524,
0.0269396827,
-0.4039395452,
-0.4313325286,
0.08102566,
0.9279636741,
-0.8805374503,
-0.579234302,
0.1009550691,
-0.0217109695,
-0.1475075334,
-0.2340257317,
-0.4110796154,
-0.1351183057,
0.1919204593,
0.1851132065,
0.2153713852,
0.0731378794,
0.0807912499,
0.6006501317,
0.5297046304,
-0.1560762227,
-0.2758083344,
-0.3883605301,
0.8315640092,
-0.6650307775,
-0.3307976723,
-0.7528555393,
0.6132290363,
0.0436887629,
0.1565080136,
0.6009278297,
0.8193366528,
0.5568014979,
-0.3674350083,
1.0592281818,
0.4104541838,
0.7845044136,
-0.8056861162,
0.4692584574,
-0.4191504419,
0.2671544254,
-0.6216914058,
-1.1264933348,
-0.2518333197,
0.5326576829,
-0.2526241839,
0.2817503512,
1.0162791014,
0.7584294081,
0.0208944492,
0.0417040251,
-0.2039118409,
-0.0902999267,
0.0662614405,
0.5225037932,
0.7732105851,
-0.5411419868,
0.315279305,
-0.3688079417,
0.1241010576,
-0.1217099652,
-0.8743665218,
-1.0468922853,
-0.5909439325,
-0.339422375,
-0.7457665205,
0.0638445616,
1.0540009737,
0.3067499995,
-0.7725331783,
-0.0894823447,
-0.4680630863,
-0.0610274076,
0.1973913163,
-0.3133675158,
0.1567572206,
-0.25744313,
-0.8343602419,
0.4240364432,
0.0428655744,
0.2071292847,
-0.1164470389,
-0.220704332,
-0.2680307031,
0.1342276633,
0.443339467,
0.284171015,
-0.5641941428,
0.2217229158,
0.1536079198,
-0.3683770299,
-0.0368676968,
0.9257605672,
-1.113969326,
0.6843176484,
0.522810936,
0.4917546511,
0.6040320396,
-0.0915432051,
0.8694150448,
-0.7111453414,
-0.1205210164,
0.280543685,
-0.0145470183,
0.4695924222,
-0.8288999796,
0.476031214,
0.0468531623,
-0.3352662027,
-0.474686265,
0.0533996634,
-1.1368385553,
-0.5640667677,
1.0725058317,
0.1895437688,
-0.1942789555,
0.0789230242,
-0.359148711,
0.2715435922,
-0.6399700642,
0.4397212267,
0.7197474837,
-0.1437502056,
-0.2269954085,
-0.5749996305,
0.9435082674,
0.539119482,
-0.8083953857,
0.0217852592,
0.6462944746,
0.0556867085,
0.1160475537,
0.2605310977,
-0.0376674049,
0.4245863259,
-0.4466697872,
0.1026969552,
0.1037191376,
-0.325232178,
-0.3358905315,
-0.2984214425,
-0.4158402681,
0.2134608477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04877v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04877v3
|
Generating Explanations to Understand and Repair Embedding-based Entity Alignment
| 2023-12-08T07:27:26 | 2024-03-21T07:22:54 |
Xiaobin Tian, Zequn Sun, Wei Hu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB
|
Entity alignment (EA) seeks identical entities in different knowledge graphs,
which is a long-standing task in the database research. Recent work leverages
deep learning to embed entities in vector space and align them via nearest
neighbor search. Although embedding-based EA has gained marked success in
recent years, it lacks explanations for alignment decisions. In this paper, we
present the first framework that can generate explanations for understanding
and repairing embedding-based EA results. Given an EA pair produced by an
embedding model, we first compare its neighbor entities and relations to build
a matching subgraph as a local explanation. We then construct an alignment
dependency graph to understand the pair from an abstract perspective. Finally,
we repair the pair by resolving three types of alignment conflicts based on
dependency graphs. Experiments on a variety of EA datasets demonstrate the
effectiveness, generalization, and robustness of our framework in explaining
and repairing embedding-based EA results.
|
[
-0.4791029692,
-0.8150355816,
0.9517113566,
-0.2717173398,
0.0214930363,
-0.0129611725,
0.0091510396,
-0.5537182093,
0.6096497774,
0.3880541027,
-0.646101892,
-0.6181673408,
-0.425301224,
0.0363465771,
-0.2825396359,
0.9151859879,
-0.5527788997,
-0.0241683852,
-0.5515758991,
-0.4300449789,
-0.8681859374,
0.1717724949,
-0.6557254791,
-0.1338827908,
0.4634749293,
0.6823176146,
0.9205132723,
1.1223654747,
0.3024270535,
0.3467607796,
0.3115445673,
0.3749657869,
-0.3935147524,
0.050744459,
-0.4063910842,
-0.4321652651,
-0.6206431985,
-0.3747406602,
0.4420176148,
0.952476263,
-0.087961182,
-0.1190698668,
0.1491528749,
0.6383313537,
-0.4158474207,
0.097674422,
-0.6171557903,
0.0734933466,
-0.0275293961,
-0.1146470308,
-0.3141847849,
-0.2302017957,
0.2513699234,
-0.9243161678,
0.4800297618,
0.2398613095,
1.2204842567,
0.477683574,
-0.5763976574,
-0.2459057868,
-0.7121502161,
0.5442137122,
-0.3521454036,
0.5948588848,
0.1019281,
0.3016023934,
-0.1694535911,
-0.5469789505,
-0.5225949883,
0.4663784802,
-0.3017995656,
-0.0197291635,
-0.1342597306,
-0.0429220423,
-0.0080339657,
0.3847090602,
-0.6336016059,
0.3823588192,
-0.1317749321,
-0.2164637893,
0.4461312592,
0.1383700222,
0.3958872259,
0.2830955386,
-0.6843510866,
0.264877826,
-0.9249819517,
-0.2393299788,
0.2845856845,
0.1279922277,
0.1488800496,
0.5575761199,
0.294636935,
0.7165684104,
0.41377455,
0.2140618116,
0.1673698723,
-0.0613651238,
-0.3530944288,
0.4845528603,
0.4558230937,
0.6509613395,
0.0094455145,
-0.6307129264,
-0.1731448472,
-0.0483277589,
0.3020813763,
-0.6669590473,
0.0015194378,
0.5995832682,
-0.62586236,
-0.2405979931,
-0.0133068375,
-0.7575482726,
-0.5869669318,
-0.6987458467,
0.3559083939,
-0.6007090211,
-0.5187708735,
-0.0077932207,
0.0378176346,
0.2775465548,
0.2995892167,
-0.9631596804,
0.0817970708,
0.8345866799,
0.7793316245,
0.0526262447,
-0.4228110015,
-0.3034517169,
0.5446076989,
-0.3530222774,
0.8067830801,
-0.3029950857,
0.1716121584,
0.2308726311,
0.0355818532,
0.1590052694,
-0.5215486884,
0.1998243332,
-0.5140570998,
0.0010449534,
-0.6122334599,
-1.0210795403,
-0.2112429738,
0.1145769432,
-0.8305966258,
0.6031116843,
-0.1121565923,
-0.9746103883,
0.8273799419,
-0.4632088542,
-0.1738402247,
-0.1257495582,
-0.2422934324,
-0.6518274546,
0.0801834688,
0.5718230009,
0.4123216867,
-0.0099604111,
0.2028442174,
-0.6584011912,
-0.3561239839,
-0.0904368088,
0.1453514099,
0.8286200166,
-0.0362336971,
-0.5150478482,
-0.1294272244,
-0.5475470424,
-0.2726838887,
0.2015664726,
0.2476142347,
-0.4538395703,
0.1830819547,
-0.6963062882,
-0.1218343154,
0.3773808777,
-0.5219937563,
0.1926920265,
-0.4292677641,
0.3011856377,
0.823321104,
0.1903248131,
0.8040796518,
-0.2619941533,
0.4447939098,
0.3922057748,
-0.1258684844,
-0.2433359772,
-0.2484479249,
-0.3914821446,
-0.1695347726,
0.3302623034,
0.2205872834,
-0.6130592227,
0.1650190651,
-0.6032764912,
-0.2608997524,
-0.9110620022,
0.0317007564,
0.2759086788,
0.904953301,
0.5389589667,
-0.040816959,
-0.6088758111,
-1.0769841671,
-0.490020752,
-0.0752155334,
0.1365795583,
0.3887291253,
0.3261834681,
-0.1884390414,
1.1178925037,
-0.3230298162,
-0.3831151128,
0.367728442,
-0.1442048103,
-0.2094389498,
0.3896578252,
0.8365353942,
-0.7094179392,
-0.1645075679,
0.0961724073,
-0.898370862,
0.0719124153,
-0.2786748707,
-0.4763305783,
0.0531926714,
0.5419069529,
-0.5082168579,
0.4363586605,
0.23532556,
-0.3891121149,
0.2853528559,
0.0455220342,
0.1437626928,
-0.9113702178,
-0.28179124,
0.0765456036,
-0.4434691966,
-0.27607885,
0.1173264086,
-0.2218994498,
-0.023080932,
0.0271987487,
0.1549047083,
-0.640198648,
-0.3585769236,
0.1024568081,
0.7494916916,
0.2095664144,
0.2248186916,
-0.0656581223,
0.2780585587,
0.5317135453,
-0.5267105699,
0.2616916895,
0.5523286462,
-0.0643633083,
0.7353855371,
-0.7383719087,
0.2273196876,
-0.546069622,
0.1317602098,
-0.9290835857,
-0.1687926948,
0.230223,
-0.4549860656,
0.5469661355,
-0.686154604,
-0.1393294334,
-0.0600160882,
-0.1074784547,
0.3393116295,
-0.0212630536,
-1.1221445799,
0.9301996827,
0.4320974648,
0.1206610352,
-0.8023360968,
-0.6341278553,
-0.1773698181,
-0.3157074153,
-0.9556539059,
0.8778606057,
0.2880350947,
-0.2676724195,
0.6537814736,
-0.3652606308,
-0.073765412,
0.2495036274,
0.4590469897,
0.21497114,
-0.6654936075,
0.3741434515,
0.2282362282,
-0.2035568655,
0.313780576,
-0.4881419539,
0.0441008769,
-0.1059275046,
-0.5377073884,
-0.1612624824,
0.4720546305,
0.2914300263,
-0.3898826838,
1.1310707331,
0.5749893785,
-0.7263468504,
-0.2270025611,
-0.4191347957,
-0.1123206988,
-0.422966212,
0.2653132081,
-0.4719403386,
-0.6532253623,
0.6641619802,
-0.2437334359,
0.4369679987,
0.6151582003,
0.4347700477,
-0.2407029569,
1.1784807444,
0.5621016026,
0.1378897876,
0.3081089556,
-0.1110804975,
0.5548793077,
-0.5177774429,
-0.4802338481,
-0.4853360057,
-0.6209620833,
-0.5579090714,
0.0875430778,
-0.0023323968,
0.4673990905,
-0.3521187901,
0.5607168674,
-0.7717016935,
0.5853426456,
0.0429720543,
0.1798160225,
0.0362509936,
0.009317439,
-0.2505198717,
-0.234420076,
-0.3613729477,
-0.6917517781,
0.7217461467,
0.5088487864,
0.438074559,
0.3917987645,
1.2913950682,
-0.0693289563,
0.4653807282,
-0.6694732308,
0.0372798778,
0.1206585839,
-0.454036206,
-0.3968770206,
-0.4729415476,
-1.1056672335,
0.0857992917,
-0.2613894045,
-0.7970350981,
0.3263987899,
0.6246933341,
-0.1682872772,
0.450201869,
-0.8584928513,
1.125674367,
-0.2240899503,
-0.2134385109,
-0.1198002249,
-0.3595572114,
0.3228441775,
0.2471916527,
0.3037419915,
0.1702770442,
-0.0718336403,
0.5079832077,
-0.6932111979,
0.4181261659,
-0.4881519675,
-0.3105006218,
0.0593663268,
0.2606651485,
0.557174623,
0.2513382137,
-0.1135052517,
-0.0215568431,
-0.1079406217,
-0.4964755774,
-1.0345044136,
0.9411892295,
-0.5123204589,
-0.6400560141,
0.1386083215,
-0.1382613182,
-0.1164437085,
0.1031903848,
0.2349169105,
0.414798528,
-0.1636101305,
-0.0885800868,
0.9142361283,
-0.1561509967,
0.1057336479,
0.3380813003,
-0.4457651377,
-0.1059452221,
0.9933903217,
0.0405205749,
-0.2851456106,
0.4468926787,
-0.3455744386,
-0.1900734603,
-0.3921513259,
-0.6306577921,
0.101631403,
-0.7729585171,
-0.4111205339,
-0.5252737999,
0.3912660778,
-0.2179548442,
-0.3116143346,
-0.3159324825,
-0.3122517169,
-0.3552042544,
-0.5382350683,
0.3117087483,
0.9143946767,
-0.0090574902,
-0.1795866638,
-0.7419570684,
0.1747047752,
0.0624330118,
0.5123695135,
0.260402739,
-0.0459139273,
-0.5271708965,
0.260003984,
-0.3249215484,
-1.4369229078,
-0.0377833135,
0.0910179615,
0.3955588639,
0.5324375629,
-0.2320140004,
0.9536144733,
-0.6158821583,
0.6952774525,
-0.0536732599,
-1.1342504025,
0.6138747334,
-0.0094899125,
-0.6673004627,
0.2127011716,
0.41555354,
-0.1386564523,
-0.2410325706,
-0.8210678101,
-1.0251408815,
0.3048272729,
-0.1152417362,
-0.2618438601,
-0.0752528459,
0.8352282643,
0.1211667955,
-0.2122822106,
-0.3897677958,
-0.6655189991,
-0.2925199568,
-0.5329270959,
0.3677121997,
-0.0041370462,
-0.2318769544,
0.1486858726,
0.8802369833,
-0.2102547735,
0.6767607927,
0.2664694786,
-0.5483079553,
-0.4009621739,
-0.0848637521,
0.4618681371,
0.8348534703,
0.2224585712,
0.1307624727,
0.2160466313,
0.2005222142,
0.0696028993,
0.3652590215,
0.0980893075,
0.3129373789,
0.67702806,
0.707308054,
0.2864988446,
-0.0404261947,
0.8571457267,
-0.0278138388,
-0.0703537986,
-0.2616513371,
-0.2387150228,
0.4575862288,
0.2014255822,
0.020725783,
0.0041693747,
0.2439080328,
-0.3222775757,
0.3795278966,
0.5216348171,
-0.3627720177,
-0.2900378108,
0.9293364286,
-0.065083541,
-0.2101188749,
0.5931934118,
-0.1125730723,
-0.5825942755,
0.7146561146,
0.4423500896,
0.6691797972,
0.0947729275,
0.385265857,
0.2907319069,
0.2184621245,
0.2777080238,
0.2856299579,
0.0544562787,
-0.8361423016,
-0.5736079812,
-0.1550429463,
-0.1264453679,
-0.1684296727,
-1.0160756111,
0.2506871223,
-0.3417989314,
0.0931094065,
0.6947530508,
-0.2128007561,
-1.156370163,
0.1219168827,
-0.0982065201,
0.7545054555,
-1.0110844374,
0.2775003314,
1.0059746504,
-0.8803790212,
-1.1719912291,
0.083783634,
0.0215397943,
-0.9914616942,
0.4119799733,
0.1497574747,
0.1662779748,
-0.2150169462,
-0.713470161,
-0.7670921683,
1.2840098143,
0.8365355134,
-0.7758561373,
-0.2311281413,
-0.1337292939,
0.5142399073,
-0.4720321894,
0.0036824634,
0.4503991008,
0.490031749,
-0.6309055686,
-0.3717566133,
0.4237715006,
0.0820888728,
-0.0470911935,
0.7577316761,
-0.3772649765,
0.3587336838,
-0.4043721855,
-0.2058542669,
-0.0888631344,
0.9603992105,
-0.060434632,
0.3622759581,
0.4878537953,
1.0460778475,
0.9207090139,
-0.3559256196,
0.9814936519,
-0.1863269508,
0.48612082,
1.3154417276,
-0.0700888187,
0.4884112477,
0.5559889078,
0.026212113,
1.0856856108,
0.6905733347,
-0.0432570912,
0.4268918633,
0.0023460458,
0.0095628649,
-0.2422806621,
0.0006678815,
-0.3289682567,
0.2707278132,
0.2687532604,
-0.8393894434,
-0.1701849103,
-0.2061593384,
-0.2005420625,
0.0406673811,
-0.2149550319,
1.0501074791,
-0.0034331491,
-0.6449095607,
0.1127614081,
-0.070367761,
-0.1182407439,
0.2711638212,
-0.5065015554,
-0.0733706057,
0.1455397457,
-0.674957335,
-0.8644007444,
0.4437126815,
-0.2824105024,
-0.6036573052,
-0.2666041255,
0.5566995144,
-0.6178898215,
0.1052123457,
0.3522021174,
0.2831870914,
0.1529567093,
0.3017453551,
-0.6329382658,
-0.1675385386,
0.0848511606,
-0.0924374908,
0.1871861517,
1.0479457378,
0.0493515581,
0.2527296841,
0.3507665992,
-0.2018416077,
-0.1102773026,
-0.0285005197,
0.5514609218,
-0.2818064392,
-0.2034436017,
-0.9652764201,
0.6327453852,
-0.1131077707,
-0.1465093046,
0.3328979313,
0.5061125755,
0.7859777212,
0.1840193123,
0.4166784286,
-0.0268699341,
0.3330133557,
-0.7415682077,
0.4097412527,
-0.5991987586,
0.4531679749,
-0.2344476879,
-0.9701084495,
0.0100123985,
0.6263495088,
-0.0128339864,
0.03851147,
0.5727612972,
0.7221543789,
-0.2249713987,
0.1136874333,
-0.1098820642,
0.532940805,
0.2776416242,
0.4546092749,
0.4959115982,
-0.4455651641,
0.6560522318,
-0.2843592167,
-0.1106081381,
0.2045204043,
-1.1193991899,
-0.5813345313,
-0.686876297,
-0.6400600076,
-0.6906706095,
-0.0728059486,
0.6690812707,
0.4215414226,
-0.7799799442,
0.7503810525,
-0.3331302404,
0.6619529724,
-0.3416638374,
-0.3306791484,
0.6339315176,
-0.1689730734,
-0.4628725648,
0.2771945298,
0.25716874,
0.0206737835,
-0.0923154727,
-0.1040518805,
0.2562875748,
-0.3299400508,
-0.0590466596,
0.2390375882,
-0.8314263821,
-0.5969156027,
-0.1286300868,
0.1612524688,
0.1281641424,
0.9457234144,
-0.6671772003,
0.3154456913,
0.1754425168,
1.0353995562,
0.2704929113,
-0.0689507797,
1.0062098503,
-0.9855694175,
-0.4919415116,
-0.0369143225,
0.9020023346,
0.5560846925,
-0.8333750963,
0.5483031869,
-0.1607080102,
-0.7037425637,
-0.8250516057,
0.3348377347,
-0.5351871848,
-0.006945163,
0.6737082601,
-0.6515347362,
-0.0083273593,
0.004690629,
-0.0456691012,
0.7461720705,
-0.1233157367,
0.703989923,
0.7058181167,
-0.0544929132,
-0.0424738191,
0.1086255684,
0.5343211293,
0.5473222136,
-0.6717759371,
-0.1475655437,
0.4565554857,
0.4641960859,
0.2156547457,
0.1370361,
-0.1257848442,
0.3709532619,
-0.1779450625,
-0.1731219441,
-0.1657233387,
-0.2231520563,
-0.3156932592,
-0.0071819574,
0.0568055473,
-0.2878497839
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04854v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04854v1
|
Apollo's Oracle: Retrieval-Augmented Reasoning in Multi-Agent Debates
| 2023-12-08T06:22:12 | 2023-12-08T06:22:12 |
Haotian Wang, Xiyuan Du, Weijiang Yu, Qianglong Chen, Kun Zhu, Zheng Chu, Lian Yan, Yi Guan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Multi-agent debate systems are designed to derive accurate and consistent
conclusions through adversarial interactions among agents. However, these
systems often encounter challenges due to cognitive constraints, manifesting as
(1) agents' obstinate adherence to incorrect viewpoints and (2) their
propensity to abandon correct viewpoints. These issues are primarily
responsible for the ineffectiveness of such debates. Addressing the challenge
of cognitive constraints, we introduce a novel framework, the Multi-Agent
Debate with Retrieval Augmented (MADRA). MADRA incorporates retrieval of prior
knowledge into the debate process, effectively breaking cognitive constraints
and enhancing the agents' reasoning capabilities. Furthermore, we have
developed a self-selection module within this framework, enabling agents to
autonomously select pertinent evidence, thereby minimizing the impact of
irrelevant or noisy data. We have comprehensively tested and analyzed MADRA
across six diverse datasets. The experimental results demonstrate that our
approach significantly enhances performance across various tasks, proving the
effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.7264332175,
-0.9383618236,
0.8366943598,
-0.0203640871,
-0.080686152,
0.1534439623,
0.0152743664,
-0.4217939079,
0.489091903,
0.7936680317,
-0.270540446,
-0.1710210592,
-0.4770548046,
0.3994617164,
-0.1786822528,
0.7339792848,
0.1994583756,
-0.1584576517,
-0.1356688738,
-0.4232819378,
-0.588802278,
-0.5538505316,
-0.6172701716,
-0.3560236096,
0.5442079902,
0.4119332135,
0.8317043185,
0.5750568509,
0.3047794402,
0.3567495644,
-0.0671784431,
0.7783483267,
-0.1254965216,
0.6062783003,
-0.4746441245,
-0.4016885161,
-0.1441099197,
0.055541005,
0.2348494977,
0.191977039,
-0.3911018968,
-0.2842048705,
-0.2443359345,
0.5888383985,
-1.2416236401,
0.1817670316,
-0.9152574539,
-0.0356386863,
-0.2520347536,
-0.0138072036,
-0.4985575676,
-0.3156123161,
0.2587152421,
-1.2078989744,
-0.1607269645,
0.1192135587,
0.764529407,
0.6606381536,
-0.6340590715,
-0.5463003516,
-0.8593396544,
0.3671578467,
-0.1975953877,
0.0806854516,
0.4088482261,
0.3951564431,
0.0534696095,
-0.7416906357,
-0.7888752818,
-0.3098697662,
0.1071149111,
0.4589275122,
-0.1816858798,
0.1886719316,
-0.2004714161,
0.1962814033,
0.0247377139,
-0.3676726222,
-0.3588293195,
-0.2506708801,
0.5902761817,
0.252192378,
-0.0728795826,
-0.2703170776,
-0.2373244911,
-0.2956919372,
-0.407217294,
-0.5044497252,
0.2910340428,
0.4049867094,
0.5993933678,
0.7720356584,
-0.4122990072,
0.5778682828,
0.647102654,
0.2852699757,
0.0974596366,
-0.1661973298,
-0.1323510706,
0.1078343987,
0.5838198662,
-0.093053177,
-0.3474874794,
-0.0967390686,
0.1017029881,
0.2607856393,
0.5085531473,
-0.2289874405,
-0.1853532344,
0.3708539903,
-0.0324100591,
0.162670061,
-0.1418554932,
-0.7047891021,
-0.6765196919,
-0.2848578095,
0.7891278267,
-0.4193094373,
-0.348773241,
0.1595693082,
-0.3081550598,
-0.1116889268,
0.6252709627,
-0.5077600479,
0.3917329609,
0.5167454481,
0.3507457376,
0.0771355256,
-0.3786548972,
-0.5840325356,
0.5105392337,
-0.6038246751,
1.0936785936,
-0.8237720728,
-0.4018006623,
-0.0285649672,
-0.2880314291,
-0.211788252,
-0.7886190414,
0.5705935955,
-0.6290943623,
0.0975787342,
-0.7864074707,
-0.4682854712,
-0.0725950152,
0.6907873154,
-0.8225399852,
1.0424997807,
-0.332156688,
-0.4003006816,
0.4066270292,
-0.6340040565,
-0.244713828,
-0.0741649643,
-0.3772636056,
-0.1689361185,
-0.2671625316,
0.3481147885,
-0.0648447573,
-0.3594869077,
-0.0469291136,
-0.2880200446,
0.0275505204,
-0.0664587393,
-0.0377643593,
0.3548418283,
0.697165072,
-0.2827406228,
0.2274072319,
-0.6195531487,
-0.0442337133,
-0.1609858125,
-0.1925964057,
-0.6650077105,
0.0180544332,
-0.5223975778,
0.2656528354,
0.1624726057,
-0.5905777216,
0.5075898767,
-0.3560598493,
0.0523890816,
0.69503057,
0.040844284,
0.4560941458,
-0.2653056085,
0.2821022272,
0.0219447911,
0.4558639526,
0.1637221724,
-0.3080151975,
-0.6282248497,
-0.2415314019,
-0.1609716862,
0.6273501515,
-1.2997962236,
-0.1852764487,
0.2124699205,
-0.5397070646,
-0.7855503559,
-0.0014492106,
0.5364095569,
0.353179574,
0.6190161705,
-0.1154648513,
-0.456099391,
-0.7875799537,
-0.1232536137,
-0.4320880473,
0.4580028951,
0.6079912186,
0.5246892571,
-0.0601380877,
0.9341835976,
-0.4913207591,
-0.3582032621,
-0.0103922617,
0.3044683635,
-0.2484786958,
0.3203594685,
0.2398152947,
-0.671063602,
-0.2477430105,
0.2723477781,
-0.9279085994,
0.0852995291,
-0.1492481977,
-0.4231797755,
0.1549611986,
0.2679935694,
-1.2015568018,
0.5991939902,
-0.1077623889,
-0.3960242569,
0.7386011481,
-0.3656408787,
0.3865990043,
-0.8726655841,
-0.0435572639,
-0.3758863509,
0.0603117496,
-0.2355505526,
0.2168355137,
-0.1792906374,
0.1446233094,
-0.2910454571,
0.6416220665,
-0.5148422718,
0.0582836531,
-0.5657165647,
0.3699323237,
0.2671894133,
0.2613270581,
0.1987962276,
0.8172531724,
0.3955284953,
-0.672855854,
0.4740776718,
0.6359918118,
0.1611242741,
1.0759009123,
-0.4976574183,
0.5082575679,
-0.2359766811,
0.2729735374,
-0.6160460711,
-0.0013877349,
0.5523135662,
-0.2826782763,
-0.0511994362,
-0.0728058368,
-0.3582770526,
-0.1051158905,
-0.0452674329,
0.3461962342,
-0.2024457902,
-0.5383980274,
1.0131533146,
0.5915185809,
0.1411772966,
-1.2486368418,
-0.0684335157,
0.2867574096,
-0.1858569682,
-0.2371452302,
0.1733674556,
-0.0347685888,
-0.5119287372,
0.336690098,
-0.1310441345,
-0.0120011,
-0.3567322791,
0.158779487,
-0.0160459466,
-0.0740425289,
0.4164385498,
0.124201566,
0.0395012759,
-0.1058773324,
-0.4709349275,
0.2790342569,
-0.1729517281,
-0.4228754342,
-0.2097157687,
0.4614444971,
0.563095808,
-0.5293815732,
0.7829743624,
0.2727828622,
-0.2158384621,
-0.0830028355,
-1.1355346441,
-0.1493711621,
-0.4294950962,
0.2013878226,
-0.6589320302,
-0.6054447293,
0.6784795523,
-0.2160555869,
-0.0873880014,
0.5984716415,
0.5859709382,
0.1250607371,
0.8600031137,
0.2880803645,
0.0831225812,
0.3732850552,
-0.2214507163,
-0.3741967678,
-0.9830775261,
-0.5823965073,
-0.7603622675,
0.1499674022,
0.0671715066,
-0.3116574585,
0.3920855522,
-0.2861129344,
-0.4919116497,
-0.026760865,
-0.7042300105,
0.445497334,
0.5670465231,
0.2629486322,
0.4699424505,
-0.35848701,
-0.2576467395,
0.1868579537,
-0.4599453211,
-0.2501685619,
1.0897767544,
-0.5194414854,
0.7262793779,
0.3295030296,
0.4567753971,
0.5423112512,
0.2915474772,
-0.249729231,
0.4947022796,
0.3142486811,
-1.2999640703,
-0.4165790081,
-0.4316845238,
-1.5862495899,
0.6767522693,
-0.4205242395,
-0.6616066694,
0.4984560311,
0.0791222751,
-0.5768985748,
0.2153440267,
-0.6144450903,
0.7113205194,
0.0253426619,
-0.657959044,
-0.6976171136,
-0.7191159129,
0.1758192927,
0.3552739918,
0.0293198638,
0.1079109311,
-0.0528662391,
0.5976371169,
-0.7088165283,
0.4594662488,
-0.1554413885,
0.1211141571,
0.8634408712,
0.0653103665,
0.5429922342,
0.180545181,
0.0279613622,
-0.5891449451,
0.2524749339,
-0.50339818,
-0.8019569516,
0.5948067307,
-1.0626282692,
-0.9793354273,
-0.6396653652,
-0.5900940895,
-0.2303369343,
0.1081421226,
0.0069064302,
0.1376375258,
-0.1987303495,
-0.1187358275,
0.5299707055,
0.1286820173,
0.0218541976,
0.5940010548,
-0.1134730428,
-0.7158441544,
0.7275009155,
0.359615922,
0.1318606287,
0.1497721076,
-0.059896227,
-0.6263383627,
-0.5666322708,
-0.4173843861,
0.1623723358,
-0.8346975446,
-0.1461016238,
-0.6457986832,
0.0848795772,
-0.1590969712,
0.2557102442,
-0.8647663593,
-0.6662901044,
0.008508197,
-0.1952178925,
0.1193383336,
0.890239656,
-0.2171479613,
0.1795073003,
-0.4395761788,
0.3612622321,
0.7024649978,
0.0093959551,
0.0105575146,
0.0228815712,
-0.2204836458,
-0.2813735306,
-0.7399093509,
-1.397521615,
0.1072582453,
-0.1271424443,
0.7804264426,
0.2725812495,
0.3910602927,
0.8762263656,
-0.0074092029,
0.4486998022,
-0.2278738171,
-0.7787965536,
0.8265112042,
-0.320114404,
-0.0108878175,
0.6828724146,
-0.0558043234,
-0.1295965761,
-0.4555723667,
-0.6099628806,
-0.7416201234,
0.5543208718,
0.5182006955,
-0.2914167345,
-0.3752641082,
0.7073016763,
0.1107367054,
0.3097765148,
-0.2405769974,
-0.4710645378,
-0.2984087765,
0.2122424096,
0.2336846292,
0.1546112001,
-0.4401045442,
-0.1214812025,
0.7147187591,
-0.0955075324,
-0.0862595364,
0.8030683994,
-0.1558016837,
-0.093842335,
0.3091324568,
0.1588204503,
0.641289115,
-0.0991463065,
0.2136990875,
0.2181724012,
-0.5220159888,
0.3284500241,
0.4639569819,
-0.2317258269,
-0.1732839346,
-0.1480539441,
0.4475191236,
-0.2740018964,
-0.503713727,
-0.0842693225,
-0.2594517171,
0.0550016575,
-0.3440221846,
-0.0911537483,
-0.1730277687,
0.663490355,
0.7422819138,
0.4898172617,
0.340454042,
-0.7510861754,
0.1247183159,
0.6593214273,
-0.2990447879,
0.0075831744,
0.799716413,
0.261348635,
-0.0777573735,
0.4915340841,
-0.2702778876,
-0.1899073124,
0.7648736835,
0.352057755,
0.4399401546,
-0.3202858567,
0.3842769265,
0.1911639124,
0.4766392112,
-0.2326402515,
0.4342420101,
0.0852291659,
-0.7995855808,
-0.4456043541,
0.1082947478,
-0.8269187212,
-0.1249109507,
-0.6930410862,
-0.162168175,
-0.3874626756,
-0.5494326353,
-0.0392548852,
0.4496060908,
-0.3917988241,
0.1437035501,
0.0776086599,
0.6554786563,
-0.446367681,
0.7174098492,
0.8488305807,
-0.5654150248,
-0.6811742783,
-0.3426416218,
0.1002839878,
-0.4378833175,
0.1667933315,
-0.4910301864,
-0.4844629467,
-0.2065723091,
-0.3926644623,
-0.8658923507,
0.9366525412,
0.8078188896,
0.0607485734,
0.210929051,
-0.2464762032,
0.501172483,
-0.2348864079,
0.6088122725,
0.4845291972,
0.6770954728,
0.44442451,
-1.0023362637,
-0.0167728327,
-0.4358598888,
-0.6488107443,
0.1905941218,
-1.0195684433,
1.0445523262,
-0.271222353,
0.0076252269,
0.1551294476,
0.8825085759,
0.5399458408,
0.8783535957,
0.5337235332,
0.644959271,
1.0358345509,
0.1028394476,
1.0162504911,
-0.0708960369,
0.3131020069,
1.0159534216,
-0.4673059285,
0.745965302,
0.4795341194,
-0.0235126466,
0.3701151311,
0.39611274,
0.5268915892,
0.4736682177,
-0.288289845,
-0.2910426855,
-0.6646068096,
-0.4574884176,
-0.5947794318,
0.4446214437,
0.5738382339,
0.2947360575,
0.0693618134,
-0.1150608733,
0.2696680129,
0.3350361288,
-0.291297704,
0.8177459836,
-0.2367901951,
-1.1972309351,
0.5058518052,
-0.3348689079,
0.0745501518,
-0.6095052361,
-0.1537729502,
-0.267908901,
0.3635320067,
-0.0637660474,
-0.4788971245,
0.3022883236,
-0.5142408609,
0.06497702,
0.3958281875,
0.6737737656,
-0.1707277298,
-0.277968049,
0.3282425702,
1.1125947237,
-0.0439438634,
-0.3561329842,
-0.6568217874,
0.0617925413,
-0.4096154869,
-0.3297968209,
0.216381669,
0.6746515036,
-0.0768670365,
0.9843400717,
0.4961119294,
0.0339185372,
0.0205642097,
-0.2259973586,
1.1778453588,
-0.572439909,
-0.387040168,
-0.7532154322,
0.0934973806,
-0.3190101385,
-0.3550090194,
0.8232209682,
0.6468726397,
0.34013623,
0.1124999449,
0.7712873816,
-0.1218795106,
0.3002465665,
-0.3514642119,
0.4673031867,
-0.5503016114,
0.2255108505,
-0.4233459532,
-0.606230557,
-0.0738853812,
0.5191943645,
-0.4121107161,
0.0251273289,
0.8017854095,
0.555351615,
0.1898971796,
0.0829132795,
0.0405143946,
0.4174267054,
0.1541281193,
0.6878795028,
1.4121365547,
-0.2153934836,
1.0277762413,
-0.0965385959,
0.1359708607,
0.0282543916,
-0.2922032475,
-0.8754379153,
-0.7213166952,
-0.3724250197,
-0.4328916371,
0.6150804162,
0.8478669524,
0.9412658811,
-0.4636238813,
-0.1215964779,
0.2646638155,
0.4653005302,
-0.5282218456,
-0.1319662035,
0.5841152072,
-0.2476963848,
-0.6388567686,
0.3442461193,
0.3284673393,
-0.4541571736,
0.0569927059,
-0.415450573,
-0.6422912478,
0.5439400077,
0.417757839,
0.6391471028,
-0.8781341314,
-0.4843605161,
-0.0218633227,
0.0263457652,
0.2149313688,
0.6013035774,
-1.2900141478,
0.7682217956,
0.0533680134,
0.5864691734,
0.8073399067,
0.2926582396,
0.2757729292,
-0.4278762937,
0.223815009,
0.342474699,
0.1902833134,
0.0178845413,
-0.3432914615,
0.5730512738,
0.2127285749,
-0.7461290956,
-0.6438081264,
0.238178879,
-1.020583868,
-0.3772116899,
0.6353623271,
-0.058023937,
-0.0173971001,
-0.6269010901,
-0.8338131905,
0.4112302661,
-0.6818212271,
1.2758120298,
0.660209775,
-0.4025965631,
-0.3200294971,
-0.31288445,
0.4483731985,
0.6605685353,
-0.9498044848,
-0.0248636752,
0.6800916791,
-0.1863661855,
0.5658625364,
0.8260023594,
0.0654145181,
0.4446360171,
0.3194984198,
-0.1121806502,
-0.1754070073,
-0.483282119,
0.319054693,
0.6041764021,
0.0613930784,
-0.1991462857
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04843v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04843v1
|
FREDSum: A Dialogue Summarization Corpus for French Political Debates
| 2023-12-08T05:42:04 | 2023-12-08T05:42:04 |
Virgile Rennard, Guokan Shang, Damien Grari, Julie Hunter, Michalis Vazirgiannis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in deep learning, and especially the invention of
encoder-decoder architectures, has significantly improved the performance of
abstractive summarization systems. The majority of research has focused on
written documents, however, neglecting the problem of multi-party dialogue
summarization. In this paper, we present a dataset of French political debates
for the purpose of enhancing resources for multi-lingual dialogue
summarization. Our dataset consists of manually transcribed and annotated
political debates, covering a range of topics and perspectives. We highlight
the importance of high quality transcription and annotations for training
accurate and effective dialogue summarization models, and emphasize the need
for multilingual resources to support dialogue summarization in non-English
languages. We also provide baseline experiments using state-of-the-art methods,
and encourage further research in this area to advance the field of dialogue
summarization. Our dataset will be made publicly available for use by the
research community.
|
[
-0.7811697721,
-0.6108940244,
0.1554871947,
0.1942588985,
-0.2681351304,
0.3111457825,
-0.334422648,
0.0424297526,
0.5540780425,
0.7888244987,
-0.0687006041,
-0.3044150174,
-0.7363266945,
0.3745809495,
-0.4947412312,
1.0642498732,
0.2745677233,
0.132472232,
-0.1579487771,
-0.3835250735,
-0.0918705612,
-0.7831894755,
-0.3551670611,
-0.0075618541,
0.5335940719,
0.7221341729,
0.483313024,
0.0835783109,
0.1829035431,
0.380441606,
-0.2326518148,
0.1900655627,
-0.6336869001,
0.2601892054,
-0.1355629861,
-0.1729797721,
-0.309610337,
-0.1351256371,
0.8200580478,
0.5899708867,
-0.1781813949,
-0.4304897785,
-0.0440861546,
0.7012625933,
-0.5393126011,
0.3768204153,
-0.6205406785,
-0.1495748162,
-0.1187764555,
-0.2811449766,
-0.2272662371,
-0.6676924229,
0.0479628853,
-0.3103893399,
0.3929981589,
-0.2443696856,
0.6448800564,
0.0470360704,
-0.5931537151,
-0.466647476,
-0.4064021707,
0.4238632917,
-0.7099359035,
0.3216722608,
0.1282359809,
0.2286803573,
-0.1749199778,
-0.6496632695,
-0.62418437,
0.3152224123,
-0.3950703144,
0.3353855014,
0.0427048691,
0.1411786824,
0.0263202097,
0.4611680508,
-0.1394843161,
-0.4222442508,
-0.7523002625,
-0.1244631261,
0.7784007192,
-0.0608698167,
-0.1453409195,
-0.5470259786,
0.163979277,
-0.1526889801,
-0.4999644756,
0.0062695583,
0.737686038,
0.4821203649,
-0.348467052,
0.5184230208,
-0.3126479685,
0.5041966438,
-0.0596370958,
0.2023202032,
0.1877314895,
-0.7526125312,
-0.0460482351,
0.0138916075,
1.156627655,
0.4690888822,
0.4459927976,
0.295868814,
0.0006011708,
-0.3011997342,
-0.1474179924,
-1.0939512253,
-0.7859207988,
0.4599789381,
-0.2014207542,
-0.2623441517,
0.1026275679,
-1.0902596712,
-0.5010055304,
-0.1777526289,
-0.3805656433,
-0.2896074951,
-0.4553786814,
-0.0128073264,
-0.4464792907,
-0.2300649583,
0.7053557634,
-0.9316567183,
0.2513094246,
0.6596437097,
0.7370563149,
0.1463911682,
0.1493411213,
-0.5390771031,
-0.282171458,
-0.5033175349,
0.9637116194,
-0.7204047441,
-0.7386230826,
0.2475335896,
0.2846131027,
-0.0500977226,
-0.5064762831,
0.5446520448,
-0.1808571219,
0.6686061621,
-0.6152828336,
-0.525170207,
-0.3313011527,
0.1590579748,
-0.8391702175,
0.8326908946,
-0.1283173263,
-0.9174547791,
0.2302695513,
-0.870341599,
-0.6585492492,
-0.1648516655,
-0.4708059728,
-0.046563454,
-0.0205386076,
0.6040437222,
0.6992160678,
-0.24021703,
0.5950465798,
0.1044674441,
-0.078489922,
0.2645343244,
-0.2648691535,
0.829376936,
0.005866427,
-0.1303697228,
0.270534426,
-0.5982615352,
-0.6689151525,
0.0591719784,
-0.0439975895,
-0.1541661471,
0.2513279617,
0.1452327073,
0.2068409771,
-0.0074873157,
-0.648260355,
-0.0658876598,
-0.4986159503,
0.4994139373,
0.6391345859,
0.3429203629,
0.4197377563,
-0.2850515842,
0.2714995742,
0.1074709073,
-0.2913859785,
-0.7473846674,
-0.4828632474,
-0.6979854703,
-0.3394148648,
0.5490409136,
0.7410811186,
-0.7757095695,
0.1039423272,
-0.2439662665,
-0.1921764612,
-0.4510132074,
-0.003585455,
0.024406027,
0.5053239465,
0.2626138926,
-0.1120636836,
-0.4109071195,
-1.0706864595,
-0.0086546717,
-0.1529891789,
0.0602886751,
0.6749280095,
0.6498900652,
0.1973191351,
0.9462763667,
-0.2822702527,
-0.0941643044,
-0.2392573506,
0.4006125033,
0.1516361535,
0.289386481,
0.7577123046,
-0.8843414783,
-0.4048753679,
-0.0068115774,
-0.4236744046,
-0.0159538276,
-0.2061211616,
-0.1171229258,
0.4700735509,
0.2885825932,
-0.1223070696,
-0.0072046909,
0.426038295,
-0.038884528,
-0.0253496617,
0.1031256542,
0.7864295244,
-1.489254117,
0.1282977015,
-0.1913346946,
-0.3873353302,
-0.4282077551,
-0.4802971482,
-0.0843228251,
-0.1164733768,
-0.4510790408,
0.3696985543,
0.0263409782,
0.3645840287,
-0.1467841417,
0.3947390914,
0.0105972663,
0.4214959443,
0.5603022575,
0.8894096613,
0.1220532954,
-0.1895496547,
0.338627845,
0.7099747658,
-0.3328319192,
0.6960903406,
-0.7452628613,
0.0079583274,
-0.3087036014,
0.5281063914,
-1.2899464369,
-0.5868061185,
0.3149726093,
-0.455812782,
0.2360301167,
-0.4117746055,
-0.4517022669,
0.2059300691,
-0.4681839347,
0.2504354715,
0.2037886232,
-0.3604178131,
0.4151955843,
0.9279299378,
-0.9569528103,
-0.831328094,
-0.4543611407,
0.2351174504,
-0.0001737128,
-0.4937681258,
0.0364956446,
0.1837811619,
-0.2326811403,
0.018030718,
0.2189719975,
-0.1661169976,
-0.3346680403,
0.0901556462,
-0.134624213,
-0.1967189908,
0.2318208516,
0.2637253404,
0.0458838046,
0.1034822389,
0.0934203342,
0.4292396307,
-0.015565576,
-0.0133085931,
-0.1629613042,
0.8121917248,
0.5403370261,
-0.380217582,
0.6296437383,
0.3650954962,
-0.4102733135,
0.0798326209,
-0.6421660185,
-0.1292021871,
-0.3824701011,
0.2292124033,
-0.0786562413,
-1.0657082796,
0.6996756196,
-0.1908687353,
0.6274086833,
0.7197715044,
0.7217232585,
-0.3281918168,
0.4849434197,
0.2579065561,
-0.1012436897,
0.320615828,
-0.2706571817,
0.2461292595,
-0.4488675296,
-0.2255309224,
-0.7177578807,
-0.2225500345,
-0.475761205,
-0.3949249089,
0.0347421244,
-0.5186001658,
-0.0611763299,
0.2459304184,
-0.4560123086,
0.5294498801,
0.2868742645,
-0.4123913944,
0.16268076,
0.0071793199,
0.1082193032,
-0.2444059104,
-0.7982370853,
-0.4492039382,
0.9141608477,
0.0059011192,
0.6255996227,
0.1297664791,
0.5988277793,
0.3267819583,
0.3184798956,
-0.3863786757,
0.2677503824,
-0.2297586054,
-0.6975695491,
-0.2147012949,
-0.7007380724,
-0.7691255212,
0.5375705361,
-0.4073042572,
-0.350579679,
0.614782989,
0.1147347912,
-0.4500389099,
0.3991929293,
-0.4129068851,
1.0725685358,
-0.2127889693,
-0.0562167838,
-0.3351848125,
-0.7463229299,
0.5048258305,
0.0591601171,
0.4749418199,
-0.3676480949,
0.2341575921,
0.9999203086,
-0.2897952497,
0.7136015892,
-0.1012596041,
-0.2490433604,
0.1161137298,
-0.3665304482,
0.1421604604,
0.4387432337,
0.1297739595,
0.1642092913,
0.2655589283,
-0.3406646252,
-0.3537330031,
0.692653656,
-0.5587104559,
-0.3879312575,
-0.5795406699,
-0.5409318209,
0.0291062221,
-0.1750801206,
0.2454357445,
0.633282423,
-0.6706271768,
0.5055479407,
0.5232364535,
-0.2355415523,
0.240450725,
0.0624389984,
-0.165082112,
-0.858954668,
1.0381839275,
0.2470162064,
0.0635205582,
0.4826268554,
0.0233542249,
-0.4609259963,
-0.1249540821,
-0.5384914279,
0.1635023504,
-0.8800221682,
-0.2876132727,
-1.1062510014,
-0.1760917604,
-0.3477186263,
-0.47412467,
-0.4204685688,
-1.1160590649,
-0.2177674323,
-0.1096108779,
0.5016683936,
0.657171607,
-0.0640269816,
0.320928216,
-0.6494362354,
0.491963774,
0.1358471066,
0.1075107753,
-0.3923049867,
-0.2270108014,
-0.005140895,
0.2148402333,
-0.2794916928,
-1.1121544838,
0.1528228074,
0.3202945292,
0.252632916,
0.2264168113,
0.3621591032,
0.3385976851,
-0.4826090038,
0.9956454635,
0.1092704162,
-0.664476037,
0.5297037959,
-0.4857658744,
0.1047498584,
0.8761924505,
0.2830153406,
-0.6327717304,
-0.4098369181,
-0.541701436,
-0.9636031389,
0.6551542878,
0.3348960876,
0.2830579281,
-0.1841858029,
-0.0556736179,
0.148905918,
0.4617345035,
0.0042618136,
-0.061379645,
-0.4938440025,
-0.0615767986,
-0.276148349,
-0.3129590452,
-0.6442434788,
-0.3610146344,
0.7930676937,
-0.1340974718,
0.0282787308,
0.2252653688,
0.040520642,
0.2047741115,
0.464282155,
0.8342023492,
0.6152783632,
-0.2974468172,
-0.0830280781,
0.3063652217,
-0.0742077827,
0.0669089928,
0.4916945696,
0.0343225375,
0.617591083,
0.3310467899,
0.5665139556,
0.389010191,
-0.51927948,
0.518029809,
-0.4675222039,
-0.5209947824,
-0.3595612943,
-0.1863737106,
0.3822006881,
0.1643419564,
0.2225977927,
0.1125092432,
0.2761362195,
-0.5702856779,
0.2874110043,
0.282769084,
-0.1831940413,
-0.0365067646,
0.6082354784,
0.8714234829,
-0.1440219283,
0.3784877658,
0.0564557873,
-0.6630606651,
0.5116126537,
-0.1398230642,
0.6770859957,
-0.2951512337,
0.2631415725,
0.5285577178,
0.3566523194,
0.2922001183,
0.4705346525,
-0.2131981552,
-0.4182226062,
-0.4580182731,
-0.2869561017,
-0.9635421634,
-0.0367402025,
-0.3128792048,
0.1152029037,
-0.4161338806,
-0.1976428926,
0.2234336883,
0.1136442795,
-0.3576996326,
-0.1231576949,
-0.2041592449,
0.8539770842,
-0.7800619602,
0.4041561186,
0.2259147018,
-0.1537590325,
0.1436565071,
-0.376157254,
0.099325642,
-0.0161192063,
0.1252787262,
-0.1507475078,
-0.2433911115,
-0.4648151994,
-0.3781222701,
-0.2764893472,
0.5377810001,
0.66525805,
-0.5834040642,
0.2797217965,
0.0793424547,
0.120296672,
-0.2735181451,
0.3602386415,
0.521561563,
0.5470709205,
0.1274858862,
-0.6824046969,
-0.2335924953,
-0.5538342595,
-0.5359116197,
0.4369179904,
-0.6877489686,
0.7423399687,
0.0313535184,
-0.3243148327,
-0.1782381237,
0.6520728469,
-0.2496964484,
-0.0621669292,
0.2115465999,
-0.0027224442,
0.6789604425,
-0.5533900261,
0.9439514875,
-0.6713792086,
0.1307849884,
1.2479025126,
-0.2311559618,
0.6582121849,
0.2513113916,
0.0956796482,
0.1210786924,
0.5788975358,
0.3173438907,
0.1854383349,
0.0850690827,
-0.3953073323,
-0.2023536414,
-0.276281774,
-0.5140783787,
0.27883479,
0.8375467658,
-0.1795150042,
-0.3378680944,
-0.312171787,
0.2394168228,
0.390720576,
0.3467681408,
1.0850625038,
0.0758914426,
-0.496811986,
0.3701816797,
-0.1081114709,
0.4320844114,
-0.6192020774,
-0.4204812646,
-0.3466577828,
-0.0347123295,
-0.2631198466,
-0.9421525002,
0.3365108073,
0.2000481337,
0.0736139491,
-0.2313930392,
0.2466186881,
-0.8141274452,
-0.5464951992,
0.0950002745,
0.496373862,
0.1575566381,
0.1204350665,
-0.4228484631,
0.0523848869,
-0.1607021391,
-0.096422039,
0.0563844219,
0.5636307597,
0.1944921315,
0.1641901582,
0.6795685887,
-0.1182965711,
-0.3217464089,
0.1706466675,
1.1308385134,
-0.4676343799,
-0.4572909176,
-0.7006136775,
0.6669115424,
-0.6566529274,
-0.4170722365,
0.468696177,
0.9257858396,
0.6973628998,
0.1459682435,
1.0904221535,
-0.0704143941,
0.4717932045,
-0.400349766,
0.9862240553,
-0.4885927439,
-0.206745699,
-0.2189458907,
-0.5948873162,
-0.2255895436,
0.9160250425,
0.048512958,
-0.1132235602,
0.4749252796,
0.6373250484,
-0.2715159655,
0.4159303606,
-0.0214066897,
0.1056574211,
0.449731648,
0.5113000274,
0.6667408347,
-0.264713347,
0.3885850608,
-0.5054460168,
-0.0781435594,
-0.2623793781,
-0.9235533476,
-1.2442835569,
-1.0822701454,
-0.3600308597,
-0.2825085223,
0.2447544783,
1.0534148216,
0.542060256,
-1.292345643,
-0.3783139884,
0.4416131973,
0.2863868773,
0.3567746878,
-0.1681148857,
0.4580539763,
-0.2592457235,
-0.9579641819,
0.2555088699,
0.2762609422,
-0.1581915021,
-0.0312998928,
-0.0374503806,
-0.5219275951,
0.4594726562,
0.555409193,
0.3286574185,
-0.6328266263,
-0.2583318353,
-0.1621944308,
0.1299401522,
0.2578753829,
1.1060506105,
-0.5913243294,
0.7231223583,
0.789440155,
0.7441934943,
0.4909186065,
0.2906615138,
0.9119702578,
-0.838906467,
0.4700002074,
0.4225034118,
0.6707633734,
0.6472001076,
-0.0117444769,
0.5994468927,
0.0958552808,
-0.4265040755,
-0.6380138397,
0.0703341067,
-0.8286939263,
-0.042033229,
0.805777669,
-0.1330586672,
0.1789305359,
-0.2478242218,
-0.5896306634,
0.2212707847,
-0.8746375442,
0.492038399,
1.0567128658,
0.0931039825,
-0.4864350855,
-0.6323899031,
0.7108956575,
0.185522005,
-0.862755239,
0.4423850477,
0.7418782115,
-0.0468926989,
0.1619638652,
0.9811734557,
-0.1248329282,
0.3667087555,
-0.0392700359,
-0.1820256263,
0.0961973965,
-0.4051827788,
-0.3090028465,
0.4584549665,
-0.5427333117,
-0.004985956
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04837v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04837v2
|
Localized Symbolic Knowledge Distillation for Visual Commonsense Models
| 2023-12-08T05:23:50 | 2023-12-12T05:48:14 |
Jae Sung Park, Jack Hessel, Khyathi Raghavi Chandu, Paul Pu Liang, Ximing Lu, Peter West, Youngjae Yu, Qiuyuan Huang, Jianfeng Gao, Ali Farhadi, Yejin Choi
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV
|
Instruction following vision-language (VL) models offer a flexible interface
that supports a broad range of multimodal tasks in a zero-shot fashion.
However, interfaces that operate on full images do not directly enable the user
to "point to" and access specific regions within images. This capability is
important not only to support reference-grounded VL benchmarks, but also, for
practical applications that require precise within-image reasoning. We build
Localized Visual Commonsense models, which allow users to specify (multiple)
regions as input. We train our model by sampling localized commonsense
knowledge from a large language model (LLM): specifically, we prompt an LLM to
collect commonsense knowledge given a global literal image description and a
local literal region description automatically generated by a set of VL models.
With a separately trained critic model that selects high-quality examples, we
find that training on the localized commonsense corpus can successfully distill
existing VL models to support a reference-as-input interface. Empirical results
and human evaluations in a zero-shot setup demonstrate that our distillation
method results in more precise VL models of reasoning compared to a baseline of
passing a generated referring expression to an LLM.
|
[
-0.2124741375,
-0.6802589893,
0.9571751356,
-0.264972806,
-0.4087118208,
-0.2682559788,
-0.2109037042,
-0.3436963856,
-0.2780990005,
0.6077338457,
-0.3181990087,
-0.5908043385,
-0.5119211078,
0.1666366905,
-0.3315279186,
0.7372769117,
-0.2357160598,
0.0752967522,
-0.5547116995,
-0.3171311617,
-0.5275181532,
-0.44881019,
-0.2490591258,
-0.2738582194,
0.4578513503,
0.3578064144,
0.4141404331,
0.5455383658,
0.3806722164,
0.4081330001,
-0.1670863032,
0.207292214,
-0.4132638872,
-0.0571670793,
-0.3226985037,
-0.6399840117,
-0.0095377425,
-0.005839203,
0.4631573558,
0.4934815168,
-0.0956434533,
0.2705805302,
-0.1619352996,
0.3938287497,
-0.8696931005,
0.0592616685,
-0.9935531616,
0.1369949281,
0.0008329077,
0.0856369734,
-0.3521800339,
-0.3910130262,
0.283919245,
-0.7801789045,
0.3756380379,
-0.3963213563,
1.0109088421,
0.5483697653,
-0.4825839698,
0.090494886,
-0.6257485747,
0.88560009,
-0.7322129607,
0.2767389119,
0.4041709602,
0.7188662291,
0.2172762901,
-1.0252199173,
-0.849899292,
-0.47699067,
-0.2691418529,
0.1877610534,
-0.4039969444,
0.0331130438,
0.4351606667,
0.0558687076,
-0.271256268,
-0.2348832339,
-0.8099024892,
0.035621915,
0.362590313,
0.1309344918,
0.0803559572,
0.0041455077,
-0.7401586771,
0.1069873124,
-0.7614012957,
-0.2060265988,
-0.059446115,
0.1438232362,
-0.0956479236,
0.4205356836,
-0.4582290053,
1.1703828573,
0.2056670636,
-0.2064747512,
0.2649855316,
-0.346139133,
-0.2951990068,
-0.1386891007,
0.4856146872,
0.3936845958,
0.3571713865,
0.2199105918,
-0.4050596356,
0.0158935636,
0.2856889069,
-0.6939563751,
-0.3705453575,
-0.0572863854,
-0.0806663036,
-0.2923238873,
-0.1585917622,
-0.3812508881,
-0.5382752419,
-0.8753176928,
0.3824153841,
-0.2351932824,
-0.2386557907,
-0.0110497912,
-0.525541544,
0.0216644835,
0.5365488529,
-0.5898872018,
-0.0046788095,
0.2733186185,
0.7682394981,
-0.0470419154,
-0.289955318,
-0.4943757951,
0.1932610422,
-0.1291792989,
0.7920938134,
-0.6424198151,
-0.3583199084,
0.0883367807,
-0.1250115037,
0.0793261454,
-0.8992820382,
0.1239069849,
-0.2775741518,
-0.2079164833,
-0.4410823584,
-0.1834762543,
-0.1403225511,
0.3967276812,
-0.6282942295,
0.7836080194,
-0.0509972088,
-0.6107732654,
0.5707273483,
-0.527017951,
-0.3000807762,
0.1312091798,
-0.3439587653,
0.043683894,
0.4543984532,
0.4349833429,
0.5425974131,
0.0369513519,
0.3287882805,
-0.4825382829,
-0.2829464376,
0.2923921347,
-0.9033662081,
0.6935932636,
0.4184590876,
-0.1168070734,
0.1889461875,
-0.6330043674,
-0.3701057732,
0.046843458,
-0.0075246738,
-0.6593104601,
-0.2274803966,
-0.224973321,
0.2817753851,
0.4733416736,
-0.6052955985,
0.2192005217,
-0.011590586,
0.3749456406,
0.8137952089,
0.0562531091,
0.4881438911,
0.0627480894,
0.2077642083,
0.4157412648,
0.4094008803,
-0.0760833472,
-0.4294329584,
-0.728965044,
-0.320646435,
-0.2264154404,
0.4150902927,
-1.3292970657,
-0.1676251888,
-0.2233429849,
-0.4566623569,
-0.4340582192,
0.2990756631,
0.5740876198,
0.9654824138,
0.3875619769,
-0.1014977843,
-0.0505770594,
-1.0302503109,
0.1006584167,
-0.0047968049,
-0.024555767,
0.3031481206,
0.4902126789,
0.1852126122,
1.0346945524,
-0.7436551452,
-0.3594810367,
-0.3275479078,
0.1776312292,
0.2349193692,
0.0465423204,
0.5059882402,
-1.0207393169,
-0.6062219739,
0.2190971822,
-0.9978770614,
-0.1584152728,
-0.1202513278,
-0.1329137385,
0.2415827215,
0.5335128307,
-0.4858829081,
0.6069265008,
0.3746497631,
-0.3034520149,
0.5703588724,
-0.4646539688,
0.1689392626,
-1.0295776129,
0.0680398792,
0.6331633329,
-0.1769606173,
-0.6091398001,
0.3545728326,
0.1632166952,
-0.0559074804,
-0.9284361601,
0.8068925738,
-0.5918287635,
0.0664376542,
-0.1842371076,
0.3463413119,
0.1672028154,
0.5717773438,
0.7059941888,
0.5582259893,
0.6198887825,
-0.4639928937,
0.4877390862,
-0.1470040977,
-0.3860874474,
0.8953786492,
-0.7141871452,
-0.1301208138,
-0.1781736016,
-0.0631794333,
-0.9553683996,
-0.0588805228,
-0.0043926779,
-0.0547028482,
0.1865822822,
-0.3856786788,
-0.2892961502,
-0.4012937844,
0.0732907355,
0.5586948991,
0.6765924692,
-0.770165801,
0.6089798212,
0.1922105998,
0.1808960289,
-0.7527428865,
-0.7333708405,
-0.2528263927,
-0.282389015,
-0.3633176386,
-0.1205507368,
0.0907276422,
-0.5205763578,
0.2229094505,
-0.1920329928,
-0.6359722614,
-0.1060066074,
0.2656038702,
0.4398153424,
-0.1837860495,
0.0153031107,
0.0330473669,
-0.0510044657,
-0.2377476394,
-0.2557011545,
0.0442661494,
-0.1274452507,
-0.519103229,
-0.6018590331,
0.1730738431,
0.6516390443,
-0.3139947057,
0.2759851515,
0.517002821,
-0.2252732515,
-0.3104532063,
-0.5999857783,
-0.2943291068,
-0.5602653027,
0.5214036703,
-0.4582870007,
-0.70483464,
0.2868154049,
-0.0372642092,
0.2144938707,
0.1153941527,
0.4514880776,
-0.2591519356,
0.6087189913,
0.5092998743,
0.186334163,
0.4979612529,
-0.2466852665,
0.0753577873,
-0.5152261853,
-0.0047655618,
-0.1910375953,
-0.4129287004,
-0.000212254,
-0.8284473419,
0.5449642539,
0.0324442536,
-0.2268771678,
0.2915116847,
-0.6109560132,
0.9899253249,
0.8258858919,
0.1751512438,
0.3577077091,
0.2587881386,
-0.1420263499,
-0.1141700149,
-0.5905933976,
-0.2654885352,
0.8613294363,
0.0955678746,
0.7186565399,
-0.0631139427,
0.8194933534,
0.1158555895,
0.4707587659,
-0.5279704332,
0.6449251175,
-0.4298694134,
-0.5514010191,
-0.2283692807,
-0.4336272776,
-0.5938948989,
0.2818761468,
-0.0092395246,
-0.8266869187,
0.1610816121,
0.4998110831,
-0.3759278655,
0.5278294683,
-0.9020288587,
1.0331251621,
-0.2197909355,
-0.4107656181,
-0.1474735439,
-0.3737590611,
0.719974339,
0.1201785728,
-0.079464972,
-0.0509481058,
0.2222458124,
0.1084959507,
-0.4591861963,
1.3362125158,
-0.4458420575,
-0.1351875663,
0.6073938012,
0.222754702,
0.3185899854,
-0.0920832753,
0.3016501367,
0.6075788736,
0.0468368456,
-0.2417952567,
-0.8875252008,
0.8377441168,
-0.7653673887,
-0.7144568563,
-0.2529890537,
-0.4470581114,
-0.0486123562,
0.1019523442,
0.2268652171,
0.6383109093,
0.2010755688,
-0.1159794778,
0.774238646,
-0.291988194,
0.3135519326,
0.5047816634,
-0.114031814,
-0.2249586284,
1.0899814367,
0.0707605258,
0.5355376005,
0.5759131908,
0.1153550372,
-0.5616559982,
-0.3960844874,
-0.5273495317,
0.1335616708,
-1.1042351723,
-0.2578264773,
-0.0926564857,
-0.1330153346,
-0.1087635979,
-0.4239206016,
-0.5352573395,
-0.3063209057,
-0.2023100406,
-0.1279200166,
0.3200822175,
0.7436956763,
-0.0536917746,
0.0392650366,
-0.8818492293,
0.5375749469,
0.5169291496,
0.1363992989,
0.0114212381,
-0.6466188431,
-0.0706625283,
0.0940919146,
-0.1443555802,
-0.8618975282,
0.3660402596,
-0.072917223,
0.6520676613,
0.6276988387,
0.1915679574,
1.0623390675,
-0.4343305528,
1.0117875338,
0.4829663336,
-0.8066645265,
0.6661172509,
-0.1063301563,
0.6938138008,
0.556006074,
0.4054920971,
-0.4247821569,
-0.5181815624,
-0.2830794156,
-0.7202615738,
0.3482435942,
-0.1213288829,
0.3595781326,
-0.1350357682,
0.225277096,
0.0888817385,
-0.0282895695,
-0.9164150357,
-0.2066826969,
-0.2586700618,
-0.2592704296,
0.3086155951,
-0.1507389247,
-0.2946524918,
-0.4925327003,
0.4482880831,
-0.0639815256,
-0.051828891,
0.2399415225,
-0.2586690187,
0.3059069216,
-0.0585491993,
0.703352809,
0.7785238028,
0.0574202463,
0.3511413634,
0.3214354217,
-0.3332199454,
-0.0297593232,
-0.172579959,
-0.4013592005,
0.220114246,
0.2401477247,
0.9151163697,
0.2152795941,
-0.6126390696,
0.5857473612,
-0.0673887581,
-0.3384132683,
-0.3330144584,
0.0520746894,
-0.0884248018,
0.4214493036,
0.0703777224,
0.1148888916,
0.1189512089,
-0.2082495391,
0.2734600604,
0.2201723903,
-0.514723897,
-0.138473779,
0.597328186,
0.3649342358,
0.2518948019,
0.8926013708,
-0.2413725853,
-0.1912310421,
0.6508899331,
0.4187135696,
0.8485784531,
0.1213347986,
0.4876698256,
0.754514277,
0.1208661422,
0.0941189975,
0.043859221,
-0.4019044936,
-0.8261447549,
-0.412112534,
-0.6700258851,
-0.1235542595,
0.0571447872,
-0.5288596153,
0.216950044,
-0.3289352953,
-0.0517740175,
-0.2137434632,
-0.4854668975,
-0.7831340432,
0.0713161156,
0.5807964802,
0.9423165917,
-0.9246126413,
1.0525105,
0.6810712218,
-0.7006692886,
-0.8776334524,
-0.2049752921,
0.1456431001,
-0.9347683787,
1.12652421,
-0.0238472484,
-0.0072203353,
-0.3895517886,
-0.6076393723,
-0.7109597921,
1.1461482048,
0.4653454125,
-0.8515964746,
0.1085407212,
0.1383841336,
0.4349822402,
-0.0311534405,
0.301213026,
0.3992857039,
0.376827836,
0.6057607532,
-1.0324990749,
0.0596789122,
-0.3120239973,
0.1626819372,
0.0736058727,
-0.3225040138,
0.7371122837,
-0.4696532488,
-0.1933664531,
-0.1029746011,
0.6388890147,
0.4116544724,
0.4121690691,
0.3144151568,
0.6884816885,
0.5350337029,
-0.0560781546,
1.100019455,
-0.1679889411,
0.0682641789,
1.5314376354,
-0.3486355245,
1.0175772905,
0.7267646194,
0.1496664733,
0.2524416447,
0.2338231355,
-0.1055067107,
0.7602220774,
0.0709719732,
-0.5249111652,
-0.3724293709,
-0.1564976424,
-0.1114674881,
0.3981441855,
0.1245686486,
-0.3551418781,
-0.5626008511,
-0.0213559326,
-0.2249273807,
0.2465318888,
-0.4758326113,
0.803629756,
0.0781959295,
-0.7385607362,
0.7396365404,
-0.259047538,
0.5595297813,
-0.6030381322,
-0.3502258658,
-0.5749130249,
0.2682276666,
-0.0209109932,
-0.9879288673,
0.3313419521,
0.1580848992,
-0.0372202881,
-0.18549712,
0.65017277,
-0.56178689,
-0.5737776756,
-0.1388239413,
0.443423748,
0.348057121,
-0.1099713817,
-0.5380433202,
-0.1850219369,
0.1167284772,
-0.0334933922,
0.2616634667,
0.7308319211,
-0.2323963791,
0.5559945703,
0.6257307529,
0.1172019765,
0.2299657464,
0.2441695333,
0.7505275011,
-0.391987443,
-0.158257857,
-0.9041446447,
0.8562950492,
-0.3735664487,
-0.4154169559,
0.6376369596,
0.1733425111,
1.205929637,
-0.4804876745,
0.8785772324,
0.0931420177,
-0.2834780812,
-0.5716132522,
0.795635879,
-0.7750563622,
0.0920664743,
-0.0792077929,
-0.7925243378,
-0.3398286998,
0.6941047311,
-0.6165312529,
-0.2125648111,
0.5100781918,
0.9008412361,
-0.3303555548,
-0.4166601598,
0.7904286385,
0.1569142044,
0.0851958022,
0.6836169958,
0.8870440125,
0.1025532335,
0.3635881841,
-0.4611464143,
-0.0909070149,
0.211843282,
-0.9661573172,
-0.9169110656,
-0.6753588915,
-0.4428125918,
-0.0136797689,
-0.0449321009,
0.5363290906,
0.7350466251,
-0.4907584488,
-0.1024235487,
-0.0981655866,
0.1424485743,
-0.2566307187,
-0.2330422848,
0.0727605149,
-0.3016473651,
-0.8423656821,
0.0426642783,
0.3849303722,
-0.0121624488,
-0.3425979316,
-0.0569115244,
0.0719841272,
0.0540899001,
0.6393705606,
0.3490073085,
-1.0477535725,
-0.1953973621,
-0.1885266453,
-0.1595611721,
-0.0966683477,
0.6635817289,
-0.871407032,
0.7633875012,
0.4062324762,
0.3208703399,
0.4944523871,
-0.1779020727,
0.5503271222,
-1.0373995304,
0.4021361172,
0.0178314783,
0.618272841,
0.2030050159,
-0.1440155357,
0.398624301,
0.3906895518,
-0.1283333749,
-0.6758053899,
0.3812004626,
-0.9911828637,
-0.5536214709,
1.3702516556,
-0.4289986193,
-0.4196465313,
0.0818686858,
-0.3130491376,
0.0220982898,
-0.2768603563,
0.784260571,
0.3562864065,
0.2173368633,
-0.3432357907,
-0.5198836327,
0.3254707456,
-0.018654326,
-0.5717365146,
0.1611467898,
0.9104263186,
0.460033834,
0.182844013,
0.677028954,
-0.0666889921,
0.4089780152,
0.3017047346,
0.2375612855,
-0.508254528,
-0.5001511574,
-0.1857206523,
0.1771991402,
0.0277914871,
-0.2313312888
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04828v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04828v2
|
Human-Readable Fingerprint for Large Language Models
| 2023-12-08T05:01:47 | 2024-02-07T11:01:25 |
Boyi Zeng, Chenghu Zhou, Xinbing Wang, Zhouhan Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Protecting the copyright of large language models (LLMs) has become crucial
due to their resource-intensive training and accompanying carefully designed
licenses. However, identifying the original base model of an LLM is challenging
due to potential parameter alterations. In this study, we introduce a
human-readable fingerprint for LLMs that uniquely identifies the base model
without exposing model parameters or interfering with training. We first
observe that the vector direction of LLM parameters remains stable after the
model has converged during pretraining, showing negligible perturbations
through subsequent training steps, including continued pretraining, supervised
fine-tuning (SFT), and RLHF, which makes it a sufficient condition to identify
the base model. The necessity is validated by continuing to train an LLM with
an extra term to drive away the model parameters' direction and the model
becomes damaged. However, this direction is vulnerable to simple attacks like
dimension permutation or matrix rotation, which significantly change it without
affecting performance. To address this, leveraging the Transformer structure,
we systematically analyze potential attacks and define three invariant terms
that identify an LLM's base model. We make these invariant terms human-readable
by mapping them to a Gaussian vector using a convolutional encoder and then
converting it into a natural image with StyleGAN2. Our method generates a dog
image as an identity fingerprint for an LLM, where the dog's appearance
strongly indicates the LLM's base model. The fingerprint provides intuitive
information for qualitative discrimination, while the invariant terms can be
employed for quantitative and precise verification. Experimental results across
various LLMs demonstrate the effectiveness of our method.
|
[
-0.370960176,
-0.5265871882,
0.3483365476,
-0.0066102017,
-0.4720450342,
0.477622062,
-0.2792750895,
-0.5293956995,
0.0087215751,
0.943118751,
-0.3815076649,
-0.4473500252,
-0.5512492657,
0.0427803434,
-0.3554539382,
0.7089626193,
0.2359084636,
0.0554073788,
0.1010344699,
-0.250708431,
-0.0801419765,
-0.7936239243,
-0.647164166,
-0.4219455421,
0.4684726894,
0.0636897609,
0.5911768675,
0.9186671376,
0.2204754353,
0.2383427471,
-0.3269418776,
0.1117447615,
-0.2978216112,
0.0106518986,
-0.0890850425,
-0.6254774332,
-0.3832499683,
0.0365664624,
0.6850438714,
0.4532056451,
0.0251489319,
0.3626455665,
0.1320067197,
0.5492933393,
-0.6315714121,
-0.0701019168,
-0.8035203218,
-0.12077602,
-0.6247680783,
-0.3051279485,
-0.6412537694,
-0.1569972932,
-0.3218007982,
-0.2152471691,
0.4787582755,
-0.1215528026,
1.0385180712,
0.1183423549,
-0.4279239476,
0.08808887,
-0.9043571353,
0.5624101758,
-0.7123860717,
0.6551620364,
0.3141852021,
0.3517541885,
-0.2989445329,
-0.3563745618,
-0.7419849634,
-0.338399291,
-0.1434612423,
-0.2400379777,
0.0093244892,
-0.0460751913,
0.4830594063,
0.1774657369,
-0.5787011981,
0.2204458565,
-0.125828445,
-0.4968208075,
0.4272781909,
0.109752275,
0.5127942562,
0.2199114114,
-0.5794853568,
-0.2648932934,
-1.1018334627,
0.2444847971,
0.3778612316,
0.2589625418,
-0.128266111,
0.3149660826,
0.0217071809,
0.4330705106,
0.380989641,
-0.4678636193,
0.3252625167,
0.070283398,
-0.0998924524,
-0.0150036756,
0.6839314103,
0.1419418007,
0.4162919819,
-0.3755774498,
-0.2273926288,
-0.2575253546,
0.2401902974,
-0.897606194,
0.0348209627,
-0.020321928,
-0.3333949149,
-0.323431015,
0.3730029762,
-0.6358103156,
-0.7462152839,
-0.2768543959,
0.2204962969,
-0.2171028554,
-0.3496846855,
-0.0802871287,
0.1125551984,
0.7422604561,
0.0264423843,
-1.1688896418,
0.066402927,
1.0528632402,
0.6669980288,
-0.1674069613,
-0.2868134379,
-0.4344025552,
0.3617701232,
-0.4576182067,
0.3277772367,
-0.3554635942,
-0.2131099999,
-0.0237728208,
0.3728454709,
0.1482526362,
-0.7994049191,
0.1985978037,
-1.0867859125,
-0.3468563557,
-0.0682656467,
-0.4861612916,
-0.0556605831,
0.2877179384,
-0.8671438694,
0.8060750961,
0.0105774039,
-0.9082827568,
0.2221198678,
-0.1336499006,
-0.4088754058,
0.3012416959,
-0.3479812145,
-0.5744733214,
0.0527386479,
0.1783898175,
0.5143116117,
-0.1173886806,
0.100265719,
-0.3823461235,
-0.2907941639,
0.3718897998,
-0.4575479031,
0.9363280535,
-0.1717995554,
-0.4362557828,
0.0919944271,
-1.1624006033,
-0.0301280599,
0.3748949766,
-0.5122388005,
-0.3303188682,
-0.0763520077,
-0.0887861177,
0.0938281342,
0.4828795493,
-0.7498178482,
0.2335720807,
-0.2654597461,
0.2099876553,
0.6084864736,
-0.0632863641,
0.2833659947,
-0.0613064803,
0.6283343434,
-0.1464126408,
0.0857537836,
-0.1041230336,
-0.3395882547,
-0.8167183399,
-0.5243316293,
0.3654019535,
0.6586293578,
-0.3860331774,
0.5537862778,
-0.3748250008,
-0.7461566329,
-0.341989845,
0.2702622712,
0.4640865326,
0.4322475791,
0.1645613313,
-0.2632034123,
-0.481223166,
-1.0355856419,
-0.2997047901,
-0.1511855274,
-0.3331405818,
0.2700031698,
0.4083648026,
-0.1640322506,
0.9430254102,
-0.2385715544,
-0.1106493622,
-0.2063556463,
0.0598439313,
0.3557159305,
0.419873625,
0.5078656673,
-0.4869689047,
-0.3859880865,
0.1757381856,
-0.4570165873,
-0.2082830667,
-0.1926246881,
-0.2154876739,
0.0414411463,
0.7319111824,
-0.5080297589,
0.2151857913,
0.530349791,
-0.4778734744,
0.4090726078,
-0.2712773085,
-0.1219425499,
-0.772978127,
0.3071195185,
-0.1736196429,
-0.3471534848,
-0.6866863966,
0.3783108294,
0.3827707171,
0.1195458993,
-0.2685391903,
0.6476031542,
-0.3265643716,
0.1549814492,
-0.2262666225,
-0.5780647993,
-0.1451375186,
0.4207172096,
0.1266568452,
0.7339583039,
0.3504710793,
-0.2245494276,
0.0975721031,
-0.0517530032,
-0.3618602753,
0.4938776791,
-0.656237781,
0.6350618601,
-0.0867123604,
0.2989579141,
-0.700104475,
-0.0156703983,
0.2339993715,
-0.3452990651,
0.5819460154,
-0.6248767376,
-0.5777012706,
0.0170023423,
-0.1348655224,
0.0637638867,
0.5230077505,
-0.949306488,
0.9754608274,
0.1878076494,
-0.0533148795,
-0.6422284245,
-0.3021695912,
0.0883773491,
-0.2646068037,
-0.6889109015,
0.4204584062,
0.1421192586,
-0.0577810742,
-0.581600368,
-0.0105887,
-0.2812287807,
0.4506534636,
0.499897629,
0.3641418815,
-0.2583477795,
-0.2394877225,
-0.2453141063,
-0.3072554469,
0.1988570988,
0.0803721771,
0.6398615241,
-0.0717153475,
-0.16913867,
-0.3081580698,
0.3003183603,
1.0478124619,
-0.6032453775,
0.4583441913,
0.7350648642,
-0.3385628164,
-0.4130077362,
-0.598690629,
-0.2097239196,
-0.5302231908,
0.3874602914,
-0.4106454551,
-0.727329731,
0.6047157645,
-0.0587935224,
-0.0724802762,
0.1921743453,
0.7185537815,
-0.1029369533,
0.9198584557,
0.6259772182,
-0.4636455476,
0.4530558586,
0.15533562,
0.0484382808,
-0.8223777413,
-0.1631025225,
-0.400393784,
-0.3115222454,
-0.3977144659,
-0.304307431,
0.0103066768,
0.231294468,
-0.2882913649,
0.2538950145,
-0.3566656709,
0.7666653991,
0.6023411155,
0.1348564774,
0.3620262742,
-0.1924895346,
-0.2707736492,
0.0089530535,
0.1311685145,
-0.932649672,
1.1064853668,
0.6100990772,
0.7173579335,
0.1764930487,
0.7334333658,
0.0674126446,
0.4402453601,
-0.5210732818,
0.649960041,
-0.0370461568,
-0.8395847678,
-0.1752785593,
-0.2339920104,
-0.8796240687,
0.4184889197,
-0.061902754,
-0.7681697011,
0.147062093,
0.3282130063,
-0.3187072873,
0.424161762,
-0.4869847298,
0.7559091449,
-0.5864239931,
-0.2936739028,
0.0282613281,
-0.6949718595,
0.1790605634,
-0.3813622296,
0.0412773602,
-0.1788214594,
0.1200454682,
0.6412718296,
-0.5605698228,
1.0030882359,
-0.3294747174,
-0.2775264084,
-0.0821082443,
0.2029124796,
0.6749405861,
0.0467986166,
0.0815512091,
0.3303254247,
0.1016023532,
-0.1145436242,
-0.6279891133,
0.2773532569,
-0.6614289284,
-0.6979492307,
-0.0983449444,
-0.1124974117,
-0.3752901256,
0.3900955021,
0.3181197643,
0.2085273117,
-0.0619572848,
0.2617584467,
0.5609106421,
-0.1339741945,
0.2542415261,
0.8722966313,
-0.1131874099,
-0.1627448499,
0.9187216163,
-0.1706647873,
0.1359993964,
0.3071937263,
0.3872734308,
-0.1775046289,
-0.6508245468,
-0.5731539726,
0.3598635495,
-0.6322970986,
0.1625148654,
-0.1947689801,
-0.1536040455,
0.2053758055,
-0.029683359,
-0.4636098742,
0.0893477425,
-0.2868289948,
0.1345857829,
0.1042958871,
0.5327685475,
0.2148515433,
0.3256644607,
-0.6511257291,
0.3012526035,
0.5581277013,
0.4564622343,
0.0889736786,
-0.6884722114,
0.0432924889,
-0.0463175811,
-0.0827637166,
-0.7725715637,
0.2668124735,
0.1420032531,
0.450655371,
0.6385452151,
-0.1351277083,
0.296857655,
-0.7301338911,
0.5367504358,
-0.0029097535,
-0.9228815436,
0.1589992046,
-0.3005633652,
0.0874019936,
0.5722416043,
0.0816861615,
-0.3660827577,
-0.4289422929,
-0.3175174594,
-0.8255437016,
0.3557058573,
-0.3023999929,
0.3806664646,
0.2650927007,
0.4645268917,
0.0362342894,
-0.0043091564,
-0.6341189742,
-0.3034419119,
-0.1169986799,
-0.0084639024,
0.0256542582,
-0.4246293306,
-0.0439764857,
-0.4251567423,
0.5726402402,
-0.098924689,
-0.0540146418,
-0.2610307932,
-0.2220208347,
0.1024399474,
0.2714167237,
0.6713726521,
0.3860464394,
-0.4808432758,
0.4218443632,
0.0743680373,
-0.818025887,
0.3543913364,
-0.1378933191,
-0.2266867012,
0.1713210642,
0.5154544115,
0.4746494293,
0.0050845793,
-0.578730762,
0.6861978769,
-0.0640014037,
-0.0817341805,
-0.4545398951,
0.1283748746,
0.3004281819,
0.4041986763,
0.4776872098,
-0.2287657708,
-0.3028177321,
-0.159811601,
0.1739692837,
0.5604316592,
-0.2936760187,
-0.4772524238,
0.5801618099,
0.0476308577,
-0.4787529409,
0.5491833687,
-0.1689542383,
-0.7845167518,
0.6865143776,
0.690947175,
0.892724514,
-0.3881457448,
-0.1857257634,
0.2554164827,
0.4588007629,
-0.0213421714,
0.194294557,
-0.0018200282,
-1.0120904446,
-0.0258431509,
-0.6368358135,
-0.3539779484,
0.5248837471,
-0.7341229916,
0.2421095371,
-0.8859920502,
-0.1953302026,
0.2800506353,
-0.3064407408,
-0.5442044735,
0.1488087475,
0.6618509293,
0.6276537776,
-0.8423656225,
1.1369677782,
0.425814867,
-0.0231438354,
-0.8164387345,
0.0668940768,
0.1292285323,
-0.942509234,
0.865740478,
0.2399290353,
-0.3376451135,
0.0742825344,
-0.5966878533,
-0.8959628344,
1.0192382336,
0.7317296863,
-0.8783182502,
0.1556666493,
0.2508068979,
0.5077865124,
-0.08157368,
-0.0354006588,
0.7143278718,
0.4528716505,
0.1122350544,
-0.6693223715,
0.3757365644,
-0.2846293151,
-0.0478914902,
0.2564882338,
-0.4468303621,
0.7276092768,
-0.1737598181,
-0.4310749471,
-0.05563353,
0.3674249053,
0.3205254972,
-0.2605706751,
0.7111866474,
0.3699013591,
0.8712263703,
0.0368683152,
0.8222106695,
-0.5352891684,
0.4421783984,
1.1932458878,
-0.244600907,
1.0992999077,
0.529755652,
-0.2694998682,
0.2752648592,
0.2797616422,
-0.5222587585,
0.4735085666,
0.500783205,
-0.2626433074,
-0.5291153193,
0.1500292867,
-0.3210166693,
0.6439716816,
0.2674503326,
-0.6735141873,
-0.1192019507,
-0.3361041248,
0.1778207123,
-0.1995560825,
-0.0745578706,
0.5530322194,
-0.0554095805,
-0.2492257208,
0.7537215948,
0.2018609494,
0.8631072044,
-0.5430135131,
0.0957531855,
-0.1775131077,
0.3449860811,
-0.2153552771,
-0.3899910748,
0.151274249,
0.0267084967,
-0.2872188389,
-0.1019740328,
0.5253843069,
-0.4115568995,
-0.4977151453,
0.3086560667,
0.1221579462,
-0.1460805684,
-0.1694128513,
-0.3167113066,
0.2313286066,
-0.0538507402,
-0.3316215575,
0.3260383308,
-0.1182887554,
-0.1693099737,
0.524720788,
0.6917219758,
0.2164665163,
0.1555283666,
0.0972572416,
0.4621106088,
-0.6160462499,
-0.4614059329,
-1.1911447048,
0.1829927266,
0.0201333035,
-0.417846173,
0.5954303145,
0.4238420725,
0.7335967422,
-0.1783318818,
0.7493524551,
0.4085393846,
0.5033983588,
-0.481785655,
1.2158148289,
-0.2645398676,
0.3345704675,
-0.0965238363,
-0.6399254799,
-0.4083113074,
0.5647719502,
-0.0187012572,
-0.1085125133,
0.2275876105,
1.0515953302,
-0.0870622173,
-0.2684507072,
0.3102242947,
0.046471376,
0.6187006235,
0.4698716998,
0.8068939447,
0.0206352603,
0.3594673276,
-0.3660740256,
-0.2180515975,
-0.2658431232,
-0.9206185937,
-1.2036235332,
-0.4748212099,
-0.3768506646,
-0.4769502878,
-0.1880317926,
0.7538245916,
0.8873355985,
-0.8605237603,
-0.0677402169,
0.2568081915,
-0.0670135617,
-0.1445973516,
-0.1701812595,
0.4642386734,
0.3295811713,
-0.4196363986,
0.3747782707,
0.2537055314,
0.2476119101,
-0.531016767,
0.0154409967,
0.2973845601,
0.1159702167,
0.3113234639,
0.6108497977,
-1.0100394487,
-0.4969222844,
-0.0981586576,
-0.369666934,
0.2313387841,
0.8241022229,
-0.4264009893,
0.4748185277,
0.3243626058,
0.9466303587,
0.3355472982,
0.084368974,
0.5523638725,
-0.8953197002,
0.1137984097,
0.1259248555,
0.4465832412,
0.3972604275,
-0.4090452194,
0.1266920567,
0.1895304918,
-0.1578590125,
-0.6433561444,
0.2703079283,
-1.1169184446,
0.0184256546,
1.1542794704,
-0.2943884432,
-0.2695596516,
-0.2553048134,
-0.1019326448,
0.0956510529,
-0.0534170792,
0.5916765928,
0.5643624067,
0.3167494535,
-0.2262269408,
-0.3490796685,
0.4049597681,
0.1208318546,
-0.5537291169,
0.2372349352,
0.044598829,
0.752215445,
0.0907563716,
0.2720070183,
-0.22799173,
0.0563965589,
-0.2053579837,
0.372916013,
-0.3657760918,
-0.0660987273,
-0.5153202415,
0.2168964446,
0.2946981192,
-0.3562631607
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04807v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04807v1
|
Improving Neural Machine Translation by Multi-Knowledge Integration with Prompting
| 2023-12-08T02:55:00 | 2023-12-08T02:55:00 |
Ke Wang, Jun Xie, Yuqi Zhang, Yu Zhao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Improving neural machine translation (NMT) systems with prompting has
achieved significant progress in recent years. In this work, we focus on how to
integrate multi-knowledge, multiple types of knowledge, into NMT models to
enhance the performance with prompting. We propose a unified framework, which
can integrate effectively multiple types of knowledge including sentences,
terminologies/phrases and translation templates into NMT models. We utilize
multiple types of knowledge as prefix-prompts of input for the encoder and
decoder of NMT models to guide the translation process. The approach requires
no changes to the model architecture and effectively adapts to domain-specific
translation without retraining. The experiments on English-Chinese and
English-German translation demonstrate that our approach significantly
outperform strong baselines, achieving high translation quality and terminology
match accuracy.
|
[
-0.2785566449,
-0.501973629,
0.672972858,
0.4413532615,
-0.3146065474,
-0.0205479395,
-0.3482109606,
-0.043079637,
0.141357258,
0.2966742516,
-0.4238622487,
-0.330016464,
-0.5675291419,
0.26271227,
-0.173819676,
0.6975541711,
-0.0872928649,
0.4766921997,
-0.045130983,
-0.0734610632,
-1.071406126,
-0.3387868702,
-0.6812406778,
-0.6317552328,
0.6024667025,
0.2737028301,
0.4609971642,
0.4395871758,
0.2263237238,
0.2063090652,
-0.1981866211,
0.6601451635,
0.1703492552,
0.3972572386,
-0.2441192269,
-0.2806385458,
-0.4608280659,
-0.2454019189,
0.6124697924,
0.4982879162,
0.0335357413,
-0.1376966685,
0.3761955202,
0.4129122794,
-0.2987684011,
0.0751608238,
-0.455427289,
0.054848738,
0.2294772416,
-0.5549649,
-0.5792998672,
-0.3480466604,
0.2326166332,
-0.7265993953,
0.0041059284,
-0.0667170957,
0.5353706479,
0.4631534219,
-0.6656891108,
-0.1602157801,
-0.4434549212,
0.3939350545,
-0.7121451497,
0.6105353236,
0.1181170568,
0.1620293558,
-0.1688910872,
-0.5487131476,
-0.3137403727,
-0.4403840303,
-0.1050175354,
0.419183135,
0.0783669278,
0.2213810831,
0.1529786736,
0.0848172754,
-0.4885471463,
-0.1462281793,
-0.2891509533,
-0.1107537374,
0.1320372671,
-0.0202586818,
0.3806628883,
-0.1280709654,
-0.5931923389,
-0.0124949664,
-0.5483534336,
-0.1197098196,
0.1462650895,
0.4962655902,
0.2002244294,
0.5044947863,
-0.251897037,
0.9306536913,
0.0888176039,
0.1266259998,
0.1362039149,
-0.5167120099,
-0.028907476,
-0.1954861134,
0.7701140642,
0.3731082976,
0.2034616917,
-0.3833591044,
-0.3382461667,
-0.3844001889,
0.3303738534,
-0.5135608912,
-0.0095416773,
0.1517522782,
-0.2372238934,
0.0797638968,
-0.0067880456,
-0.6530730128,
-0.4832502604,
-0.4925631285,
0.7598141432,
-0.8430005312,
-0.4397054017,
0.4213294089,
-0.4668629169,
0.2329782248,
0.406946063,
-0.8476238847,
-0.1280493587,
0.3917652965,
0.9876613021,
-0.1807782054,
-0.5907359719,
-0.4103005826,
0.1474342793,
-0.2472409606,
0.7139635086,
-0.1363031566,
-0.2370250672,
-0.0343362503,
-0.3232547939,
-0.5194696784,
-0.4366306365,
0.295946151,
-0.7839548588,
0.2702147663,
-0.3619903028,
-0.4741720557,
-0.4656403363,
0.4979782104,
-0.4450649619,
0.9780970216,
0.1099996269,
-0.3619144857,
0.1524161845,
-1.3667968512,
-0.6041235328,
0.0622308925,
0.0976578146,
0.3008103967,
0.3619107008,
0.6392031908,
0.467107147,
-0.3414694965,
0.7236075401,
0.1628464311,
-0.1468360424,
0.3255236447,
-0.4351702332,
0.500621736,
0.1385305822,
-0.1712821275,
0.3281258047,
-0.4455198944,
0.1440791786,
-0.1240940616,
-0.4067567587,
-0.0978932902,
-0.4805567563,
-0.1374260932,
0.4244943261,
0.2573093474,
-0.0613531396,
0.5181178451,
-0.2817428112,
0.6315697432,
0.5162858367,
0.1650767475,
0.6796122789,
-0.1160237417,
0.7372202277,
0.3418730497,
0.0475509204,
-0.4440124631,
-0.7686811686,
-0.7701711059,
0.1130007207,
0.558300674,
0.5648116469,
-1.2096502781,
0.3119153976,
-0.3054893315,
-0.2209908664,
-0.6871379614,
-0.0373101197,
0.3226448894,
0.6973001957,
0.8274895549,
-0.1096786931,
-0.3835967481,
-0.558190763,
-0.2777476907,
0.1026806831,
-0.0650265887,
0.0187295657,
0.3026944995,
-0.1057666987,
0.7708119154,
-0.176580593,
0.0123058185,
-0.1045179293,
0.32275635,
0.2503561974,
0.7042136192,
0.2673917115,
-0.6915439963,
-0.4687148333,
0.1692076772,
-0.7484420538,
0.0664577186,
-0.1430266649,
-0.1536235213,
-0.2994022667,
0.4965098202,
-0.7073007226,
0.0978062972,
0.3289828002,
-0.2591892481,
0.5246374011,
-0.2453478277,
0.3677629232,
-1.4683156013,
0.1368631572,
-0.4014229178,
0.0864399895,
-0.919978261,
0.178114742,
0.4509190917,
-0.0204202533,
-0.5835937858,
0.5499979854,
-0.4716033638,
0.1254594028,
-0.1253466904,
0.1348378509,
0.3471877873,
0.3364148736,
0.1277795434,
1.0701826811,
0.5418305397,
-0.9469758868,
0.4164052308,
0.357345283,
0.0389175713,
0.6193175912,
-0.6317198277,
0.3211744726,
-0.0958118215,
0.0187673289,
-0.7860859632,
-0.2306765616,
0.2759673595,
-0.7737072706,
0.2774238884,
-0.3440639973,
-0.4277005494,
-0.2672988772,
0.1588621587,
0.1177929267,
0.4330553412,
-0.538746655,
0.8270480633,
-0.3442099988,
-0.0932727605,
-0.7994323969,
-0.7270317674,
0.2661198676,
-0.0443138741,
-0.672244668,
0.3632406592,
-0.0678558052,
0.3980001211,
-0.0631721467,
0.0155039439,
-0.2670690715,
0.1037189066,
-0.2118349075,
0.163391605,
-0.6383669972,
0.4478648305,
0.3907903433,
-0.2959442139,
-0.120303005,
-1.0556653738,
0.7069027424,
-0.0824320614,
-0.2753182352,
-0.4580754638,
0.4078297615,
0.6436011791,
-0.4677662253,
0.7499971986,
0.8883960247,
-0.2760332227,
-0.0281843822,
-0.381182313,
-0.5592024922,
-0.4298548698,
0.2514312267,
-0.7168358564,
-0.8666042686,
0.3587095439,
-0.2817949653,
0.080735974,
0.3202778399,
0.2901167274,
-0.03102809,
1.1036288738,
0.4496206641,
0.3009785116,
0.4004056752,
-0.106063813,
0.0185877886,
-1.1211198568,
-0.1654515415,
-0.3021348417,
-0.2503597438,
0.1090914011,
-0.3919881284,
0.2618324161,
0.3287517428,
-0.2022269815,
0.5530308485,
-0.5406008363,
0.4301743507,
0.7077818513,
0.1271230876,
0.3686779439,
-0.2105945647,
-0.6418153644,
0.0434574299,
-0.971668005,
-0.372705996,
0.9569716454,
0.1780553758,
0.3286846578,
0.0287613478,
0.63770473,
-0.0798930824,
0.2751716375,
-0.9278413653,
0.1737995744,
0.0026797592,
-0.5791635513,
-0.1502697766,
-0.4909486473,
-0.7090717554,
0.3157347441,
0.0109515795,
-0.4039393663,
0.1339933425,
0.2924778461,
-0.7501704693,
0.183677718,
-0.8585243821,
0.8447375894,
-0.2658746541,
0.2536801994,
0.2211416513,
-0.536375463,
0.408152312,
0.0662471801,
-0.0891402587,
0.052904848,
-0.259747982,
0.43059659,
-0.0089832209,
0.6684564948,
-0.28586483,
-0.0715306923,
0.0529712364,
-0.0110334093,
0.3169866204,
0.0204816312,
-0.2324173152,
-0.0566477254,
-0.2819139361,
-0.2133831233,
-0.9471744299,
0.2269863933,
-0.6171966791,
-0.3796574771,
-0.0205948856,
-0.8980572224,
-0.4778191447,
0.3708913028,
0.5945053101,
0.3003652692,
0.03461973,
0.0467968509,
0.9233729243,
-0.1457404792,
0.1046713293,
0.3096109927,
-0.265139699,
-0.7545864582,
0.8342345953,
0.1169410422,
0.4495645165,
0.376855135,
0.2957841754,
-0.5918908715,
-0.6788679957,
-0.9542383552,
0.0157817267,
-0.7687876225,
-0.6027079225,
-1.0101369619,
-0.1778021902,
-0.8293095827,
-0.0849470794,
-0.3516750038,
-0.3596096337,
-0.3448097408,
0.0087374263,
0.5586180687,
0.923274219,
-0.0041030068,
0.7822365761,
-1.1751288176,
0.3340869844,
0.3976842165,
0.3140024543,
0.0731654093,
-0.8568242192,
-0.3341920674,
-0.0157334767,
-0.2407896817,
-1.1232311726,
0.3349003196,
0.0162398107,
0.5508886576,
0.2694834173,
-0.0852685645,
0.6641349196,
-0.5967146754,
0.7558603883,
0.3576622903,
-1.1863908768,
0.4899053872,
-0.3019406497,
0.5396757722,
0.5406799316,
0.3169172406,
-0.9858723283,
-0.1205030531,
-0.2784864008,
-0.691539228,
0.6946867704,
-0.1399029642,
0.2401745319,
0.1571376026,
0.4184205234,
0.0451188721,
0.3120224476,
-0.5164662004,
-0.1424019635,
-0.3630670309,
-0.2373446524,
0.1722526997,
0.144941628,
-0.0985185206,
-0.2747161388,
0.7106484771,
-0.4963275194,
0.3118910193,
0.1390497386,
-0.3699527681,
0.3124386966,
0.3971618712,
0.7836488485,
0.4641360939,
0.1696839482,
0.1608804315,
0.4384509325,
-0.2775785923,
0.3102656007,
-0.03321537,
-0.4733638763,
0.1548716277,
-0.0075617963,
0.8004983068,
0.2516259551,
0.0680760443,
0.2543209195,
-0.0957703665,
-0.2930499911,
0.2549363375,
0.0339137167,
0.4509257078,
0.0434539467,
0.1094756052,
0.4392082095,
0.1545430869,
0.0288181882,
0.2093110681,
-0.0052882978,
-0.5965015888,
-0.2578388155,
0.4592587352,
0.3371822238,
-0.3160464764,
0.6549710035,
-0.2046271861,
-0.8348697424,
0.4084197879,
0.6679800153,
0.8215181231,
-0.5981097817,
0.2955918908,
0.5002624393,
0.5060667396,
-0.4230116606,
0.4485949278,
0.036416702,
-0.7924150229,
-0.6842058897,
-0.2196185291,
-0.4367616475,
-0.0511583872,
-0.6142693162,
0.2367499024,
-0.2579534352,
-0.2732807994,
-0.260120064,
-0.4906089902,
-0.6492628455,
-0.0651549995,
-0.0981705859,
1.1928606033,
-0.710519433,
0.9197759032,
0.820356667,
-0.6923736334,
-0.8826721907,
-0.1480411142,
-0.0994779021,
-0.8479859233,
0.4892489612,
0.2278341502,
-0.1096081063,
0.5648897886,
-0.4246573448,
-0.7935391665,
1.0204869509,
0.4235115051,
-0.0127604771,
-0.156012997,
0.0718061477,
0.224232167,
-0.3917865455,
0.30427441,
0.5793765783,
0.9310721755,
0.0437047593,
-0.7793418169,
-0.0281105042,
-0.1402121931,
0.1460051388,
0.1307626367,
-0.2774764895,
0.8347283006,
-0.0689728558,
-0.1876641661,
0.0703617632,
0.7122625709,
0.0602185689,
0.0367606804,
0.3550658822,
0.2686505318,
0.8643481731,
-0.2481750101,
0.6374154687,
-0.4459482729,
0.0401426405,
1.1517201662,
-0.0154202916,
0.6308764815,
0.5655860305,
0.2012378424,
0.1957623661,
0.6132049561,
0.1553387493,
0.3207419217,
-0.0435878374,
-0.3150136471,
-0.3194298446,
-0.311403662,
-0.6764053106,
0.2201857716,
0.5440439582,
-0.3451317549,
-0.1459024698,
0.2451874614,
-0.0294967573,
-0.0959777161,
-0.0104169995,
1.0155544281,
0.2008671016,
-1.139829874,
0.6096053123,
0.058506649,
0.9183410406,
-0.656083405,
-0.051212322,
-0.1527262628,
-0.2114615142,
-0.0445202291,
-0.6891787648,
0.1896243691,
-0.1795088053,
-0.3396014273,
-0.5078912377,
0.6517603397,
-0.7429891825,
0.1015881151,
0.3861298859,
0.9895365238,
0.0899143741,
-0.5088788271,
-0.8041012287,
-0.4153429568,
-0.0364787169,
-0.107667096,
0.0156338476,
0.702552855,
0.258110404,
0.337161839,
0.9041039944,
-0.091460757,
0.2264143229,
0.2855389416,
0.8156020045,
-0.7593582869,
-0.4097606242,
-0.7320636511,
0.8573669195,
-0.0577500761,
-0.6388137341,
0.6464432478,
0.1114568487,
0.3370181918,
-0.3131328225,
0.6990492344,
0.0356271863,
0.1624320298,
-0.6923955083,
0.9646708369,
-0.4203158021,
-0.1897896677,
0.19452779,
-0.8410742879,
-0.4983555973,
0.2961204946,
-0.0501455292,
0.0280801225,
0.9011939168,
0.8179118037,
-0.0409236364,
0.0975163877,
0.5813477039,
-0.1871539503,
0.1923188269,
0.5828014612,
1.1660019159,
-0.4057270586,
0.5124474764,
0.0069220667,
-0.0737972036,
-0.2029508352,
-0.9385277629,
-0.6985877752,
-0.5636979938,
-0.0267456286,
-0.3979869485,
-0.0008941531,
0.9380318522,
0.8706359267,
-0.8714697361,
-0.0679932311,
0.0396421291,
0.3727104962,
-0.5478219986,
-0.1771726459,
0.0954430923,
-0.9058848619,
-0.531175971,
0.89273417,
0.260823071,
0.2483721375,
-0.2418640554,
-0.2472400069,
-0.1477832198,
-0.0851318389,
0.6071308851,
0.0875665098,
-0.6437244415,
-0.022016976,
0.6176109314,
-0.0438866578,
0.2476069629,
0.9222853184,
-0.5783313513,
0.4851417243,
0.557869792,
1.018974781,
0.0063498397,
-0.1169972941,
0.9507696629,
-0.8879314661,
-0.2337727249,
0.3382263482,
0.4224525392,
0.4293238223,
-0.4111176729,
0.4563301802,
0.1630337983,
-0.3890189826,
-0.3871694207,
0.2945431173,
-0.6311266422,
-0.1152678207,
1.0550239086,
-0.2545681298,
-0.0123031354,
-0.4283798933,
-0.1902406067,
0.4458104372,
-0.5597526431,
0.2668156624,
0.8715934753,
-0.035985671,
-0.1887409836,
-0.6810823083,
0.330806911,
0.5873250961,
-0.734549284,
-0.0573513135,
0.2307765186,
0.0941130221,
0.2920181453,
0.4511213005,
-0.061339464,
0.5846979618,
-0.0308214873,
0.3163755238,
-0.2321021259,
-0.5050759912,
-0.9069856405,
-0.0325466245,
0.0113636935,
-0.1687771976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04804v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04804v1
|
Hate Cannot Drive out Hate: Forecasting Conversation Incivility following Replies to Hate Speech
| 2023-12-08T02:39:17 | 2023-12-08T02:39:17 |
Xinchen Yu, Eduardo Blanco, Lingzi Hong
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.CL
|
User-generated replies to hate speech are promising means to combat hatred,
but questions about whether they can stop incivility in follow-up conversations
linger. We argue that effective replies stop incivility from emerging in
follow-up conversations - replies that elicit more incivility are
counterproductive. This study introduces the task of predicting the incivility
of conversations following replies to hate speech. We first propose a metric to
measure conversation incivility based on the number of civil and uncivil
comments as well as the unique authors involved in the discourse. Our metric
approximates human judgments more accurately than previous metrics. We then use
the metric to evaluate the outcomes of replies to hate speech. A linguistic
analysis uncovers the differences in the language of replies that elicit
follow-up conversations with high and low incivility. Experimental results show
that forecasting incivility is challenging. We close with a qualitative
analysis shedding light into the most common errors made by the best model.
|
[
-0.4854981601,
-0.641918838,
0.381097883,
0.1801717281,
0.0969491899,
0.4019187689,
-0.0331920236,
-0.7177208066,
0.3628713489,
0.5782927275,
-0.7998937368,
-0.0524255633,
-0.7720389366,
-0.1710453182,
-0.6079669595,
1.282528162,
0.5056921244,
0.0382705517,
-0.2733868361,
-0.3131183982,
-0.3551464677,
-0.8372671604,
-0.5633548498,
-0.4355433583,
0.6808206439,
0.3986399174,
1.0127296448,
0.4480867386,
0.5379528403,
0.2682280242,
0.0674042776,
-0.3648006618,
-0.8286427259,
0.4997813702,
-0.079405576,
-0.1370271742,
-0.0090277605,
-0.0042889421,
0.2202034742,
0.4943754375,
-0.2040794343,
0.0447800495,
0.1620122492,
0.2689392567,
-0.0016160451,
-0.2482269853,
-1.0637223721,
-0.0768950209,
-0.3801093698,
-0.1245716885,
-0.2851224542,
-0.4771535993,
0.0726402625,
-0.1822525859,
0.2359884083,
0.1810746193,
0.4154876173,
0.1871377826,
-0.1285230815,
-0.4102872014,
-0.7282698154,
0.816499114,
-0.7630319595,
0.3421517015,
0.4445209801,
0.0596888699,
-0.3390855491,
-0.0882783607,
-0.630951643,
-0.5495398045,
0.0422752723,
0.2562323213,
-0.3342937231,
-0.1808411479,
0.3518335819,
0.2642636895,
-0.5258205533,
0.1642871946,
-0.4968028069,
0.0157112554,
0.7562550306,
0.540887773,
0.412388742,
0.0255847014,
-0.5354532599,
0.2787291408,
-0.4928469062,
0.008832722,
0.6002013087,
0.3391999006,
-0.0156171555,
0.6453266144,
0.0537237749,
0.1571473181,
0.103245914,
0.015519564,
-0.0293960106,
-0.1840305477,
-0.2211126834,
-0.1390301436,
0.6317020059,
0.6144564748,
0.2286359072,
-0.3472317755,
0.078725636,
0.4582869709,
0.4500409365,
-0.6967046261,
-0.2845356166,
0.0649765655,
-0.1975051761,
-0.418438673,
-0.3110361993,
-1.2905589342,
-0.8863180876,
0.0234110728,
0.0150352502,
-0.3208420277,
-0.3069499135,
-0.6061299443,
-0.2302367389,
-0.0813691765,
0.3434786201,
-0.6523171067,
0.6495600939,
0.491946578,
0.8123800755,
-0.3751241863,
-0.189607814,
-0.6151319146,
-0.0580214225,
-0.2762769163,
0.7097386122,
-0.5984711647,
-0.4421464503,
0.032974489,
-0.3189464211,
0.1289238334,
-0.4861886203,
0.5950359702,
-0.5667788386,
0.1914084107,
-0.0305163618,
-0.4977376759,
-0.3117343187,
0.3156917691,
-0.1969972402,
0.7633950114,
0.2722911537,
-0.700899601,
0.2612597048,
-0.3252003789,
-0.4401732981,
0.2820514739,
-0.0392412543,
-0.4109412134,
0.2223810256,
-0.4129907489,
0.0403395519,
-0.4705846906,
0.205184117,
-0.9059793353,
0.1682154685,
0.2036223263,
-0.0583378375,
0.9090157151,
0.1703907847,
-0.4754627645,
0.3982194662,
-0.5064141154,
-0.3628484011,
0.2006849349,
0.0972563103,
-0.6210852265,
0.1878286451,
-0.0715931281,
0.4435765147,
-0.1666786373,
-0.9332361817,
-0.2257766873,
-0.6804659963,
-0.0169304684,
1.2084302902,
-0.1288095117,
0.4349754155,
-0.7040135264,
0.8098438978,
0.0759454295,
0.1392613947,
0.3646173477,
-0.5661070347,
-0.7324243784,
0.3547255397,
-0.7174580097,
0.6394079328,
-0.5604458451,
-0.2491023391,
-0.0034665482,
-0.8965467811,
-0.0455504954,
0.1885140538,
0.5728471875,
0.659496665,
0.4736251831,
-0.4829598367,
-0.9418263435,
-0.5170350671,
-0.5895143747,
-0.4927950203,
0.4101870656,
0.2812154591,
0.3153514564,
0.0498701073,
0.5642760396,
-0.2677347958,
0.0004147581,
-0.1909304261,
0.3740306497,
-0.0768292323,
0.4401106536,
0.4897359312,
-0.7080959082,
-0.73669523,
-0.1854841709,
-0.4174714386,
0.0474201702,
0.0560276322,
-0.0419837423,
0.0055913469,
0.4847232401,
-0.1043505147,
0.6453190446,
0.4818528295,
-0.6711763144,
0.5322161317,
0.479727596,
0.1946091056,
-0.7486348152,
-0.3850134313,
0.1934785992,
-0.0246831793,
-0.8175107837,
-0.2702361643,
-0.6701695919,
0.0396292694,
-0.4251556098,
0.4485999644,
0.1210597456,
0.1593522429,
-0.0920849517,
-0.2734135687,
-0.5291158557,
0.3384184539,
-0.0225576181,
0.5734449029,
0.1799465269,
-0.7942711115,
0.4642639756,
0.4671806693,
-0.480448544,
0.7460083365,
-0.469592154,
0.293032527,
-0.1886512786,
-0.2097148448,
-1.2422585487,
-0.2284927666,
0.3865916729,
-0.8023613691,
-0.1724036932,
-0.0653964356,
-0.1486192942,
-0.446606189,
-0.3161416948,
0.1214909628,
0.532946229,
-0.1945961565,
0.526165545,
0.5809188485,
-0.5390173197,
-0.2684767842,
-0.6886134148,
0.0135894436,
-0.4051742852,
-0.3915478885,
0.1845319122,
-0.7469132543,
-0.7324879169,
-0.2113090307,
0.2708919048,
-0.0852814913,
0.1256384104,
0.6611762643,
0.2704966068,
0.204056561,
0.0670942739,
-0.3130120337,
0.2170449495,
0.4061755538,
0.0268198438,
0.545920372,
0.4444972575,
0.0206458326,
-0.1054584235,
0.6532233953,
0.7427448034,
0.4397200942,
0.7913094759,
0.1801049113,
-0.0612036921,
0.2702894509,
-0.555062294,
-0.2479244024,
-0.3957319558,
0.4237282872,
-0.1278035641,
-0.869152844,
0.530949235,
0.5197862387,
0.3176122308,
0.4334181249,
0.7327987552,
-0.2233648896,
1.3211842775,
0.8636437654,
-0.0145297889,
0.4847975373,
0.4579366744,
0.0787740946,
-0.4164989293,
-0.3530801237,
-0.8624326587,
0.0276955254,
-0.5557586551,
0.0565011427,
0.1820718199,
-0.5918827653,
-0.3553125858,
0.4380986691,
-0.4989527464,
0.001092128,
0.4976733923,
-0.3612872958,
0.2080565095,
0.2413916439,
0.2792182863,
-0.5718961358,
-0.6026442051,
0.1426723599,
0.8159255385,
0.359200716,
0.6417773366,
0.3393983543,
0.3034587502,
0.5399128199,
1.0788697004,
-0.7261325121,
0.4260880053,
0.1683976799,
-0.7775435448,
-0.2190431952,
-0.5988253355,
-0.6358829737,
0.1117307097,
-0.0117547167,
-0.8208964467,
-0.0675651953,
0.2809322178,
-0.3386365175,
0.6081972122,
-0.4064089358,
0.6957499385,
-0.1459366083,
-0.1896282285,
-0.404604286,
-0.6746352315,
0.4700680375,
0.1185894012,
0.5580561161,
-0.3171915412,
0.1988159716,
1.0681499243,
-0.4238951802,
0.7718113661,
-0.1554481685,
-0.0726750344,
0.2364079207,
0.2995638549,
0.3236424327,
-0.5476680398,
-0.1509999186,
0.0329520144,
-0.2572875023,
-0.2898463309,
-0.4992507398,
0.7283092737,
-0.5808307528,
-0.5983967781,
-0.4770560265,
-0.4927839637,
-0.3399882019,
0.0029237433,
0.726994276,
0.2566137314,
-0.4557445645,
-0.2819176018,
0.4455599487,
0.134635374,
0.4376490116,
0.4456356168,
-0.3876420856,
-0.6730530858,
0.9767952561,
0.4499325752,
0.4535134733,
0.078408733,
0.2845837474,
-0.3973754346,
-0.5897775888,
-0.3844018281,
0.0716671869,
-0.3738276362,
-0.3314976692,
-0.8185297847,
0.1504594982,
-0.6920900345,
-0.1449365914,
-0.1192735434,
-0.2211404443,
-0.1484877616,
0.1064276472,
0.5388064981,
1.260134697,
-0.1847525239,
0.3560363352,
-0.4483406246,
0.0128244879,
0.3627124131,
0.259028852,
0.2194021046,
-1.2664418221,
-0.2697705925,
-0.2167954296,
-0.3723953664,
-1.1828891039,
0.6358228922,
-0.3785478771,
0.0852200463,
0.1919132769,
0.5708098412,
0.6915901899,
-0.2696943879,
0.7255519629,
0.7116671205,
-0.6065871716,
0.5589565039,
-0.2323198915,
-0.049136959,
0.4001493156,
0.6769883633,
-0.7029579282,
-1.0644193888,
-1.0335628986,
-0.7490002513,
0.5177887678,
-0.0875326768,
0.4189531505,
-0.1813419163,
-0.1961622536,
0.1806446463,
0.3155584335,
-0.8851316571,
-0.614677608,
-0.3584915102,
-0.0487495773,
-0.2196436226,
-0.6801354289,
-0.3398276567,
-0.3489171863,
0.7377328277,
0.3004583418,
0.0402627811,
-0.0366108194,
0.1967604309,
-0.509811759,
0.2659700811,
0.5705407858,
0.5223626494,
-0.3017773032,
-0.0317842886,
0.1046853289,
-0.4867371321,
0.2640605569,
0.0208304934,
-0.326872468,
0.1534619182,
-0.0955460519,
0.5064467788,
-0.0845622122,
-0.4633847475,
0.4565264285,
-0.1246960759,
-0.1159109324,
-0.8521126509,
-0.1264781207,
-0.3293653727,
0.1037153453,
0.3152611554,
0.3339749575,
-0.0142057175,
-0.7029655576,
0.1129934639,
0.6660425663,
-0.977689743,
-0.445150584,
0.7279165387,
0.2730731964,
-0.5343235731,
0.41483441,
-0.2597217858,
-0.7592930198,
0.4566994011,
0.5827286839,
0.8543477058,
-0.5337485671,
0.1000914872,
0.4083564579,
0.3367246687,
0.6385830641,
0.0068247952,
-0.0008421159,
-0.9110981822,
-0.2740442157,
-0.3902762532,
-0.6604949832,
0.450193584,
-0.5332709551,
-0.2049420029,
-0.9113939404,
-0.1207875311,
0.078717269,
-0.0522993319,
-0.5263051391,
0.2730662227,
0.0199469626,
0.830915153,
-0.8355427384,
0.4001497924,
0.4303786755,
-0.6290390491,
-0.5850660205,
-0.082154274,
0.4378606975,
-0.6497526169,
0.6434372663,
0.0896181837,
-0.3882166445,
-0.0564680658,
-0.9789996743,
-0.6372626424,
0.1868634224,
0.1986958236,
-0.2676557302,
0.405439496,
-0.2230409533,
0.259883523,
-0.4697591662,
0.3178915381,
0.5960642695,
0.3046709895,
0.1935837567,
-0.8275864124,
0.0115791503,
-0.2595317364,
-0.3930277526,
0.2417453974,
-0.6540740132,
0.5983169079,
-0.3662198782,
-0.3757851124,
0.2986381054,
0.8298726678,
-0.4210274518,
0.5660820603,
0.7640371323,
0.7196835876,
0.4499920607,
0.0302229933,
1.0813748837,
0.0696694627,
-0.0361489505,
1.2999620438,
-0.1192246154,
0.531940341,
0.3711079657,
-0.2868267298,
0.8121861815,
0.0387184508,
0.1405978948,
0.3369701505,
0.2469058037,
-0.6075872183,
-0.2179525942,
-0.6415243745,
-0.3264712989,
0.3975152671,
0.3176936805,
-0.1408362091,
-0.080053255,
0.1515804529,
0.4553881884,
0.5693520904,
-0.3555355668,
1.0674304962,
-0.2735072672,
-0.9567874074,
0.2749117315,
-0.1519972384,
0.7714898586,
-0.3976681828,
0.1709712297,
-0.209985137,
0.1229498237,
-0.3021751642,
-0.7735785246,
0.7384060025,
0.0341418982,
-0.4205355644,
-0.153974995,
0.3873230815,
-0.416603446,
0.013958538,
0.6023749709,
0.4249837399,
0.1380729675,
-0.0272658877,
-0.8237299323,
0.081389837,
0.2700439394,
0.0083383517,
0.6936554909,
0.0478474684,
0.3287544549,
0.8054548502,
0.7431867719,
0.1387846321,
-0.0754006729,
-0.1874199212,
0.9761940837,
-0.7434209585,
-0.4413879216,
-1.0315382481,
0.3702064753,
-0.3242856562,
-0.4263952076,
0.9476213455,
0.4132255912,
1.0154451132,
0.1046381742,
0.9979721904,
-0.1736586839,
1.4386677742,
0.0942107812,
0.3068851531,
-0.413082093,
-0.1221477613,
-0.4833810031,
-0.4877764285,
-0.1730668992,
0.3526325524,
-0.608219564,
-0.1525892615,
0.4406072199,
0.9372594357,
0.357835412,
0.1343653202,
0.5452287793,
0.4317917824,
0.3875616193,
0.4120188653,
1.0808941126,
-0.0662167817,
0.9359000325,
-0.3863815069,
-0.3541455865,
-0.1746520698,
-0.5126673579,
-0.6460381746,
-0.4081596434,
-0.2492477149,
-0.9943130612,
-0.0843790844,
0.6907306314,
0.617675364,
-0.8871881366,
-0.4863870442,
-0.2689597607,
0.4941679835,
-0.1442627907,
-0.3081364632,
-0.2370275408,
-0.2290066183,
-0.6602100134,
0.1859797239,
0.4480867386,
0.1544930637,
-0.3084905744,
-0.1408382356,
-0.2391143143,
0.3350810111,
0.6478719711,
0.8251770139,
-0.6609867811,
-0.2703554928,
-0.1766863614,
-0.0528536104,
0.1229489371,
1.0233086348,
-0.8351421356,
0.4127014577,
0.2503600121,
0.408041656,
0.0796076804,
0.0897890702,
0.5953095555,
-0.4466208518,
0.1267036349,
0.6946136355,
0.117805995,
0.3853644431,
-0.3950835168,
0.365439117,
0.6373825669,
-0.6516492963,
-0.8976080418,
0.719368577,
-0.4728634953,
0.1058049574,
0.7441037297,
-0.0752846971,
0.070899643,
-0.601724565,
-0.1105918288,
-0.0107891979,
-0.8018696904,
0.6261725426,
0.6566185355,
-0.4027741551,
-0.3846228421,
-0.376000613,
0.8663823605,
0.7400291562,
-0.6598901153,
0.2898602188,
0.5396050215,
0.0392384604,
0.3708476722,
0.8797389269,
0.1489800364,
0.2601260841,
0.0883398056,
-0.2605807781,
0.246242553,
-0.3172642589,
-0.0378190018,
0.4305123389,
0.0970326513,
0.1767726541
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04775v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04775v1
|
How to Determine the Most Powerful Pre-trained Language Model without Brute Force Fine-tuning? An Empirical Survey
| 2023-12-08T01:17:28 | 2023-12-08T01:17:28 |
Jun Bai, Xiaofeng Zhang, Chen Li, Hanhua Hong, Xi Xu, Chenghua Lin, Wenge Rong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Transferability estimation has been attached to great attention in the
computer vision fields. Researchers try to estimate with low computational cost
the performance of a model when transferred from a source task to a given
target task. Considering the effectiveness of such estimations, the communities
of natural language processing also began to study similar problems for the
selection of pre-trained language models. However, there is a lack of a
comprehensive comparison between these estimation methods yet. Also, the
differences between vision and language scenarios make it doubtful whether
previous conclusions can be established across fields. In this paper, we first
conduct a thorough survey of existing transferability estimation methods being
able to find the most suitable model, then we conduct a detailed empirical
study for the surveyed methods based on the GLUE benchmark. From qualitative
and quantitative analyses, we demonstrate the strengths and weaknesses of
existing methods and show that H-Score generally performs well with
superiorities in effectiveness and efficiency. We also outline the difficulties
of consideration of training details, applicability to text generation, and
consistency to certain metrics which shed light on future directions.
|
[
-0.4569497108,
-0.6855511069,
0.7282128334,
0.1121763214,
-0.2277479917,
-0.0567353442,
-0.4983180761,
-0.6206270456,
-0.070201017,
0.2891410291,
-0.2926296592,
-0.3410117626,
-0.89702034,
0.1062613428,
-0.4719364047,
0.6300205588,
-0.1154341623,
-0.3210687339,
-0.4983130693,
-0.0999258012,
-0.260673821,
-0.3151752055,
-0.1859154105,
-0.2297058254,
0.0121446829,
0.2725307941,
0.5549111962,
0.7538606524,
0.9518046975,
0.376919359,
-0.1416596919,
0.1256633699,
-0.5829135776,
-0.2417111099,
-0.2947419286,
-0.4944618046,
-0.387036562,
0.0703983977,
0.5764366984,
0.7688669562,
0.0875422806,
0.4184889495,
0.3829437494,
0.519589901,
-0.8326053619,
0.0445745178,
-0.8028041124,
-0.159414798,
-0.4385836422,
-0.00118506,
-0.4526925683,
-0.5174666643,
0.4410633743,
-0.5891802907,
0.2006190717,
0.0554742403,
1.1084676981,
0.1531964839,
-0.3343870938,
-0.0875707269,
-0.8171371222,
1.0454882383,
-0.6066296697,
0.5130405426,
0.5454397202,
0.4096180499,
-0.0481910706,
-0.7155660391,
-0.3421638012,
-0.6074198484,
0.1705924571,
-0.0599597879,
-0.2632162571,
-0.0921131745,
0.1098287925,
0.2997928858,
-0.5870838761,
-0.0281315651,
-0.4753597081,
-0.237456888,
0.564337194,
0.0035889987,
0.294007808,
0.1747725159,
-0.1787863523,
-0.2878863513,
-0.3456558883,
-0.020706242,
0.0789203793,
0.2236949354,
-0.0151966717,
0.3508459926,
-0.2732898891,
0.8297775388,
0.0582562238,
-0.2017207444,
-0.0096907429,
-0.4759161174,
-0.1010909975,
-0.3600797057,
0.9026743174,
0.1848943979,
0.6665892005,
-0.2563602924,
-0.0911680609,
-0.0041162916,
0.3989045918,
-0.7954174876,
-0.3111850619,
-0.3933663666,
-0.467292577,
-0.0867448747,
-0.0380875319,
-0.5401002765,
-0.0353070013,
-0.3559195101,
0.3745779693,
-0.3620993197,
-0.2254184186,
-0.1453918815,
0.2995015681,
0.0352677517,
0.3345959485,
-0.8380712867,
0.3848342597,
0.4742599726,
0.7801399231,
-0.5733506083,
-0.3479183018,
-0.2033475637,
-0.1603463292,
-0.4128381014,
1.0283466578,
-0.3569838405,
-0.1125466004,
-0.1160264909,
-0.1330777556,
-0.3232720792,
-0.6186050773,
0.481182456,
-0.1944576949,
0.1378545016,
-0.056529399,
-0.7766215205,
-0.2136018127,
0.2965618074,
-0.5470250249,
0.825720787,
0.2067685872,
-0.5081385374,
0.4421845078,
-0.1038801447,
-0.5073987246,
0.0731034353,
0.1843152195,
-0.3633019626,
0.2885740995,
0.1643988043,
0.4492495954,
-0.3792715371,
0.4209161997,
-0.6531901956,
-0.4331639707,
0.1940360814,
-0.5529769659,
0.6953360438,
0.2546784878,
-0.2646991014,
-0.0776195303,
-0.8010942936,
0.1818563491,
-0.1690026671,
-0.3479308486,
-0.3008058071,
-0.2339598238,
0.1568775922,
0.1182737276,
0.3461379409,
-0.3811936975,
0.0213904139,
-0.3746339679,
-0.0605272427,
0.5441807508,
-0.4446164668,
0.7228273749,
-0.2164591998,
0.4749667048,
-0.4103516638,
0.161781013,
0.0962905809,
-0.4232428372,
-0.594737649,
-0.0490368754,
0.4625000656,
0.5717319846,
-0.3948850036,
0.4204701781,
-0.1952883899,
-1.0412572622,
-0.5835855007,
0.325430572,
0.5698248744,
0.4755565226,
0.2558320463,
-0.3808473945,
-0.4287006557,
-0.9298429489,
-0.7956774831,
-0.3339648247,
0.2317630649,
0.2077250183,
0.329636693,
0.0350499004,
0.924387157,
-0.6747174263,
-0.1484575421,
-0.3239200115,
0.2004851252,
0.2034527361,
0.5505510569,
0.6648661494,
-0.5434613824,
-0.7362287641,
0.0609005801,
-0.6509786248,
-0.0979655311,
0.0423842706,
-0.0901466385,
0.1033348069,
0.5597600341,
-0.4757066369,
0.6394400597,
0.7497022152,
-0.1394639164,
0.7741879225,
-0.3582382798,
0.3119350374,
-0.9981768131,
0.5050415397,
0.2573750317,
-0.3407018483,
-0.6724446416,
0.1753163934,
0.0933022276,
0.1045440584,
-0.4921642542,
0.7302767038,
-0.4501223564,
0.1405066699,
-0.3601831496,
0.0389570296,
-0.1728852689,
0.4972755313,
-0.2497000396,
0.7929592729,
0.619171381,
-0.7041673064,
0.1972152591,
0.2803343534,
-0.6650463343,
0.5519644022,
-0.738235414,
0.1825489253,
0.1502607018,
-0.1395090222,
-0.9330121279,
-0.0538512319,
0.0626375675,
-0.4698135257,
0.3223280907,
-0.0777984262,
-0.0798858255,
-0.2437155247,
0.0706758946,
0.4850006104,
0.718200326,
-0.1988136917,
0.4976201952,
0.3678153753,
-0.1829619259,
-0.41069749,
-0.520819962,
0.1222057045,
-0.2521107793,
-0.5752070546,
0.3472949564,
-0.2244160175,
-0.1017749384,
-0.1501372457,
-0.119796589,
-0.5660714507,
0.1424423009,
0.1442571282,
0.2579316199,
-0.4197778106,
-0.1638333946,
-0.1738299876,
-0.2923657,
-0.0004016156,
0.1511664242,
0.1729096025,
-0.2588642836,
-0.2635164261,
-0.47723791,
-0.0860913396,
0.7301990986,
-0.2680357993,
0.6602877975,
0.4419842064,
-0.2630620003,
-0.1207213625,
-0.7130299807,
-0.0222970471,
-0.4381503165,
0.5113730431,
-0.2777192295,
-0.5906560421,
0.3517307639,
-0.4090186357,
-0.1473136097,
0.2715516984,
0.4044321179,
0.0492024682,
0.9241123199,
0.8404293656,
-0.1090179011,
0.6173118949,
0.1326072663,
0.1815326959,
-0.3800489902,
0.0053554019,
-0.7383384705,
-0.0973144546,
-0.5098481178,
-0.1026456878,
0.2359475195,
0.2168849856,
0.1292527914,
0.8399537802,
-0.1771707386,
0.3177807033,
0.5716785192,
-0.0220623892,
0.2883243263,
0.070086062,
-0.0500377417,
-0.0706770793,
-0.477217406,
-0.5112146735,
0.9273709655,
0.2099131793,
0.6439468265,
-0.0229659937,
0.5449761152,
-0.0639043227,
0.2492426932,
-0.6640760303,
0.7493808866,
-0.453581512,
-0.4145261347,
-0.4037350416,
-0.5130952597,
-0.9775611758,
0.2158667892,
-0.5112618804,
-0.8277793527,
-0.0103640696,
0.3861303627,
-0.0716745034,
0.0063420301,
-0.6721628308,
0.8861400485,
-0.1062361449,
-0.4356433153,
-0.1139020398,
-0.4648145139,
0.3169304132,
-0.3064037263,
0.139436245,
-0.2558474541,
0.3368086219,
0.7853418589,
-0.2710634768,
0.4737702608,
0.0694104359,
-0.0079598334,
0.175148204,
0.1973968148,
0.335261941,
-0.5221823454,
-0.1735913157,
0.1769001484,
0.2141209096,
-0.2523801923,
-0.6676328182,
0.4387289882,
-0.6165539026,
-0.5446733832,
-0.0589690916,
-0.421251446,
-0.3783183694,
0.5667527914,
0.5518270731,
0.4966211617,
-0.4954363704,
0.2061228752,
0.3368205726,
-0.0563991629,
0.5709302425,
0.2504878342,
-0.1756672561,
-0.0397826955,
1.0488562584,
0.2858109474,
0.2342640013,
0.2611771822,
0.3773989081,
-0.2038373053,
-0.761294961,
-0.4399106801,
0.1214578673,
-0.3641296625,
0.032860145,
-0.4177774191,
-0.2241566181,
-0.4745899737,
-0.1524528116,
-0.8018242121,
-0.1683823615,
-0.2398123145,
0.1568807662,
0.0601833649,
0.572140336,
0.0472568311,
0.3341262639,
-0.9091864824,
0.3166795969,
0.3458949625,
0.5050442219,
-0.081953086,
-0.7887800932,
-0.2437861115,
-0.0288529154,
-0.1448156834,
-0.7632469535,
0.4055117071,
0.3417374492,
0.6420859098,
0.2252854854,
0.1528084576,
0.8212499619,
-0.2861777544,
0.4185655713,
0.1661858559,
-1.1153454781,
0.5212560892,
-0.0938406661,
0.3987185061,
0.9664800167,
0.1996353865,
0.0526986495,
-0.4936504662,
-0.5232877731,
-0.6324853897,
0.5169058442,
0.2962813675,
0.0410008691,
0.453610599,
0.0916657522,
0.160632804,
-0.0116569623,
-0.3539416194,
-0.0054146103,
0.1777626425,
-0.2880020142,
-0.1864071637,
0.0556643121,
0.4749534428,
-0.4351650178,
0.5004908442,
-0.0788922161,
-0.104440093,
-0.1588058174,
-0.4877004623,
0.0638379455,
0.1022233218,
0.4310330451,
1.0081263781,
-0.3036250472,
0.1961508989,
0.3265938759,
-0.868191123,
0.1083657369,
0.0548026748,
-0.1730003506,
0.0002206519,
0.7035936117,
0.9124320149,
0.0713834241,
-0.6470248103,
0.8726359606,
-0.0061570075,
-0.2792138159,
-0.019631017,
0.1817370653,
-0.1564098299,
0.0571159422,
0.0812816247,
0.3542381823,
0.1850841641,
-0.4003659785,
0.1571129709,
0.3200705945,
-0.6030774713,
-0.3900414705,
0.3374122977,
0.2228412479,
-0.4094979465,
0.8421026468,
0.08260151,
-0.4022245407,
0.5965189338,
0.5483810902,
0.7696853876,
-0.4392153025,
0.2809574008,
0.4059174657,
0.3313361704,
-0.4385861754,
-0.0026741843,
-0.0349556319,
-0.8282415867,
-0.5477828383,
-0.5578933358,
-0.3705094755,
-0.0813097879,
-0.8615439534,
0.1715126783,
-0.0768481046,
-0.3573578894,
-0.100831002,
0.0083407676,
-0.9466617703,
0.3074631393,
0.0637576208,
0.9596245885,
-1.0784313679,
0.7377367616,
0.6554931998,
-0.0829100385,
-0.7906416655,
-0.1959604621,
-0.2808127999,
-0.8266252279,
0.3601025939,
0.0800295696,
-0.2678773701,
0.0178952236,
-0.6206395626,
-0.8382272124,
0.6967353225,
0.7683423162,
-0.6274009347,
-0.0294906441,
-0.0405667983,
0.5637577176,
-0.0394132063,
0.3151918054,
0.784259975,
0.6074868441,
0.1201312467,
-1.3819345236,
0.0361167341,
-0.2864079177,
-0.0426669717,
0.0369475558,
-0.251175791,
0.6407185197,
-0.2341009378,
-0.3669967353,
0.2379688323,
0.6948957443,
0.1690179706,
0.3408557773,
0.4168965518,
0.4639838636,
0.6776610613,
0.1290007383,
0.9600661397,
-0.3361110985,
0.4745358527,
1.0319027901,
-0.1164095253,
1.0614771843,
0.4976986051,
-0.341265142,
0.3164134622,
0.2543111444,
-0.214300245,
0.4945239723,
0.233985275,
0.0492003411,
-0.4265145659,
-0.0837764516,
-0.134300068,
0.7600455284,
-0.0886341706,
-0.158861801,
-0.105558075,
-0.0563927069,
-0.1183439121,
0.2402253747,
-0.1311348677,
0.917901516,
0.1685092896,
-0.9392056465,
0.6982930899,
-0.3066892028,
0.6614980102,
-0.5440160632,
-0.0245935768,
-0.1641826034,
0.3622528315,
-0.0997997299,
-0.674970746,
0.3413493931,
-0.0107884752,
-0.0473981649,
-0.1291240156,
0.9311136603,
-0.4004487693,
-0.46082443,
0.0990208238,
0.8178779483,
0.4933316112,
-0.2242079824,
-0.5526282787,
0.0668338463,
-0.1133625731,
-0.1978687644,
0.4701923728,
0.2132245898,
0.0829731226,
0.6950995326,
0.4427237213,
0.356646359,
0.0501335561,
-0.4202593267,
0.5415216684,
-0.5380865335,
-0.3947635591,
-0.885389626,
0.37924999,
-0.0531204604,
-0.7102385759,
0.8267489672,
0.2413712293,
0.6513436437,
-0.1996814311,
0.6632272601,
0.1837982684,
0.3492992222,
-0.4508961439,
0.8474498987,
-0.4351692796,
-0.0894500464,
-0.6220293045,
-1.3651559353,
-0.3807890713,
0.7337017059,
-0.2993764877,
0.0747627169,
0.7348364592,
0.7915139794,
-0.1874675304,
-0.1045096293,
0.4828935564,
0.0960208401,
0.0729583055,
0.5821784735,
0.7197421193,
-0.370817095,
0.6690492034,
-0.0945530012,
-0.4093066752,
-0.318998605,
-1.1191430092,
-0.8445536494,
-0.61778301,
-0.4983503222,
-0.1138876081,
-0.0070036286,
0.5829908252,
1.0885722637,
-0.7295352221,
-0.416537106,
-0.0998384655,
-0.1079689264,
-0.3863629103,
-0.1085371226,
0.5220454335,
-0.1624116004,
-0.6353029609,
0.3883145452,
0.0455564708,
0.1229492575,
-0.0370707586,
0.0863113254,
0.0153561039,
0.0046309186,
0.4865756631,
0.4918747246,
-0.5646513104,
-0.3071622252,
0.0109219123,
-0.2218484879,
-0.1330840737,
0.6064417362,
-0.609670639,
0.4809443653,
0.6778934002,
0.8901485801,
0.4340659976,
-0.0814452395,
0.8039855957,
-0.407720834,
-0.17733863,
-0.0211974569,
0.13400051,
0.2895364165,
-0.1101133376,
0.4704081714,
0.0877904743,
-0.6277614236,
-0.7095313668,
0.1109153852,
-0.9866636992,
-0.3177270293,
0.9633291364,
-0.3876969516,
-0.3466011584,
-0.1648712754,
-0.1308883727,
0.3512168527,
0.0647044703,
0.75986588,
0.71712327,
-0.1277441233,
-0.2492480427,
-0.3393808603,
0.4877612889,
0.4183110297,
-0.7912570834,
-0.0198116284,
0.2174689621,
0.2697749436,
0.2257935852,
0.4660883844,
0.1636329442,
0.1571790427,
0.1521545202,
-0.0107571911,
-0.1082376614,
-0.4850306213,
-0.2570078969,
0.3409577012,
0.2261605114,
-0.0800705403
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.09463v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.09463v1
|
Partial Rewriting for Multi-Stage ASR
| 2023-12-08T00:31:43 | 2023-12-08T00:31:43 |
Antoine Bruguier, David Qiu, Yanzhang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
For many streaming automatic speech recognition tasks, it is important to
provide timely intermediate streaming results, while refining a high quality
final result. This can be done using a multi-stage architecture, where a small
left-context only model creates streaming results and a larger left- and
right-context model produces a final result at the end. While this
significantly improves the quality of the final results without compromising
the streaming emission latency of the system, streaming results do not benefit
from the quality improvements. Here, we propose using a text manipulation
algorithm that merges the streaming outputs of both models. We improve the
quality of streaming results by around 10%, without altering the final results.
Our approach introduces no additional latency and reduces flickering. It is
also lightweight, does not require retraining the model, and it can be applied
to a wide variety of multi-stage architectures.
|
[
-0.0021835687,
-0.5137003064,
0.4501393139,
0.0378027633,
-0.492100805,
0.2361157984,
-0.1423342526,
-0.4804684222,
0.3693833947,
0.612601161,
-0.5364740491,
-0.131430611,
-0.8184090257,
0.0328046978,
-0.9404829144,
0.838545382,
-0.1574707478,
-0.1874125004,
0.11292772,
-0.1309137791,
-0.314483732,
-0.4297974706,
-1.1774147749,
-0.4702455699,
0.6541410089,
0.4309438765,
0.5709149837,
0.9249207377,
0.3281217217,
0.4516203105,
-0.1492246985,
0.006685962,
-0.1128398478,
0.3140659034,
0.1311096102,
-0.0992590338,
-0.5146942139,
0.0114171579,
1.1922961473,
0.5747253895,
-0.3872410059,
0.0043514296,
0.3392798603,
0.7695770264,
-0.2816736102,
0.0787937269,
-0.5410345793,
-0.0009196337,
-0.1647196859,
-0.5992847085,
-0.4946460724,
0.0609316379,
0.1419204473,
-0.5918859839,
0.3786407709,
-0.1859557331,
0.9329526424,
0.7240815759,
-0.4141967893,
-0.1896827966,
-1.0693439245,
0.8200966716,
-0.8359691501,
0.620529592,
0.194837451,
0.647012651,
0.0342910402,
-0.9352519512,
-0.8012930155,
0.0968987718,
-0.1295730472,
-0.0242193863,
-0.2142150551,
0.0916073546,
0.1541411281,
0.4007236362,
-0.446641475,
-0.0646327063,
-0.5411993265,
-0.4246757329,
0.697337687,
-0.1053388491,
0.1869472116,
0.1290644258,
-0.1064299121,
-0.2159944028,
-0.4647818208,
0.1312373728,
0.4208972752,
0.6680749059,
0.0285767019,
0.758436501,
-0.1516011804,
0.7403608561,
0.2073072046,
-0.2112211436,
0.527510643,
-0.54620713,
-0.3923373818,
0.2877717018,
0.5663716793,
-0.0531503856,
-0.274448365,
0.0581089593,
-0.4258763194,
0.2509919703,
0.4729231298,
-0.5880985856,
-0.1727329344,
0.4011760354,
-0.5144370198,
-0.0300011784,
-0.1723125875,
-0.5922588706,
-0.163905099,
-0.816470623,
0.6337378621,
-0.2791017592,
-0.0099224122,
-0.0453169718,
-0.1977892071,
0.0897573307,
0.5934988856,
-0.3264936507,
0.2923518717,
0.5347545147,
0.7202238441,
0.0100644836,
-0.3843027353,
-1.2237395048,
0.4033058286,
0.1242770553,
0.6947522163,
-0.7569817305,
-0.355112046,
-0.0599129051,
-0.1492460519,
-0.0120944697,
-0.4088603556,
0.8623903394,
-0.6650989056,
0.3124378622,
0.0680557489,
-0.5601888299,
-0.2151076347,
-0.1421213597,
-0.8421450853,
0.7527006269,
-0.4399063289,
-0.772143662,
0.3152707815,
-0.5322388411,
-0.8824161887,
-0.3070518672,
-0.1937446445,
-0.5605795979,
0.0303909499,
0.3279871643,
0.2720544338,
0.0417886078,
0.2775937021,
0.2721851468,
-0.5123770833,
-0.0202248357,
-0.6786352396,
0.2473761439,
0.1820805669,
-0.3546277285,
0.5179510713,
-1.0581231117,
-0.129796207,
-0.4283757806,
-0.8454505205,
0.0267189052,
0.4220636189,
0.276486814,
0.310090512,
0.1056746021,
-0.5226268172,
-0.0261740629,
-0.4341290295,
0.5449147224,
0.564378202,
-0.2191564888,
0.7686535716,
-0.5143837333,
0.3238269389,
0.108517319,
0.0462819859,
-0.2229232788,
-0.3794342875,
-1.1531233788,
-0.5221282244,
0.3791353703,
0.3735863566,
-1.3008596897,
0.3999356329,
-0.3348402977,
-0.3460253179,
-0.851401329,
0.1175593957,
0.6185879111,
0.6332652569,
0.6154711246,
-0.306145519,
-0.6530290246,
-0.8976063728,
-0.4945249856,
-0.0498120114,
-0.1374863833,
0.1251351535,
-0.1457744241,
-0.2827726603,
0.6221159697,
-0.4673470855,
-0.5302190781,
-0.1489258558,
0.3589684367,
0.3642717004,
0.5981175303,
-0.0797235072,
-0.9939171076,
-0.5786454082,
-0.0025518727,
-0.2416619658,
-0.0748728067,
-0.187067315,
0.0524166934,
0.144379124,
0.5890606046,
-0.2324996144,
0.5912572742,
0.6173536181,
-0.2337992638,
0.3823953867,
-0.3054285645,
0.3547692001,
-1.0413265228,
0.0085557215,
-0.001122585,
-0.3966225684,
-1.0898604393,
0.0533224382,
-0.1656771153,
-0.172908783,
-0.4188830554,
0.4021590352,
-0.4689733982,
-0.221324265,
-0.6630001664,
0.101546064,
-0.0573707633,
0.36929968,
0.1440763026,
0.6460075974,
0.4555568397,
-0.5891817212,
0.1328796595,
0.071965605,
-0.0619115233,
0.2055130452,
-0.6094858646,
0.1650709957,
-0.2805651724,
0.6599627733,
-1.0507479906,
-0.3039191365,
0.1155985966,
-0.7519126534,
0.5537641644,
-0.2729459703,
-0.385027498,
-0.0591950528,
-0.1569643766,
0.4345909953,
0.4625202715,
-0.5368869305,
1.245310545,
0.3140339255,
-0.4727406502,
-0.5677211285,
-0.5347392559,
0.0541951954,
-0.1829978079,
-0.5756132007,
0.701508522,
-0.0606299564,
0.1482765973,
-0.081905596,
-0.3917309344,
-0.2722429633,
-0.4706692696,
0.1506230235,
0.0633582845,
-0.065577358,
-0.3287390172,
0.5276073813,
-0.3226095438,
-0.4796859622,
-0.039502427,
0.3990446329,
0.5360175967,
-0.4061843455,
-1.1336010695,
0.7171158195,
0.7121070027,
-0.2590421438,
0.3163785934,
0.6932799816,
-0.5538224578,
-0.0985567346,
-0.5872086287,
0.0029399958,
-0.5351845622,
0.0389920287,
-0.5528692007,
-0.9968190193,
0.4757147431,
0.2906382978,
0.2231130451,
0.3562488854,
0.434663564,
-0.2636578381,
0.8898615837,
0.5774725676,
0.0427583978,
0.8417688608,
-0.1300422847,
0.2541034818,
-0.9166446328,
-0.1873344481,
-0.6880129576,
-0.5032640696,
-0.3016420007,
-0.7352963686,
0.4407696724,
-0.2257387936,
0.153033793,
0.366939187,
-0.4241811037,
0.3727878034,
0.6444565654,
0.298867017,
0.5056523085,
0.3153984249,
0.112357147,
-0.046046149,
-0.4536176622,
-0.4769872427,
0.851403594,
0.2383676469,
0.5344070196,
0.3210798502,
0.8106583357,
0.4703962803,
-0.0125831133,
-0.5332387686,
0.4138707221,
-0.5379373431,
-0.3291268349,
-0.5976150036,
-0.5894386768,
-0.7966458201,
0.5662011504,
-0.0160407368,
-0.3426723182,
0.1481256932,
0.4980889857,
-0.5328422189,
0.0544624701,
-0.7324789166,
0.2971881628,
0.2806820273,
-0.3046339452,
-0.4403023124,
-0.7944837809,
0.1499502659,
-0.1660878211,
0.3255831301,
0.0218792427,
0.0673420355,
0.8547332287,
-0.5221590996,
0.6545295715,
-0.3773602545,
-0.0765278712,
0.2824429572,
-0.0757275745,
0.5544008613,
-0.1444807202,
-0.0018519303,
-0.1857994497,
-0.0660216063,
-0.325860858,
-0.6701394916,
0.7749532461,
-0.729624331,
-0.4085696638,
-0.460395515,
-0.2942128778,
-0.1648527235,
0.1303234249,
-0.0103124389,
0.8203658462,
0.2219435275,
-0.0316078812,
0.3273532689,
-0.1565596908,
0.5931438804,
0.5126008391,
-0.041459702,
-0.4565275609,
0.7760574818,
-0.0081544006,
0.2609097064,
0.5633682609,
0.0214432292,
-0.5134474635,
-0.6017881632,
-0.4519453347,
0.1509895772,
-0.5960396528,
-0.1279951334,
-0.7776011229,
-0.414065659,
-0.483572036,
-0.1891546845,
-0.5471413136,
-0.421818912,
-0.4635639489,
0.2616200447,
-0.0737329572,
0.3812654018,
-0.0688061416,
0.6142416596,
-0.9785340428,
0.652703166,
0.493655175,
0.1831011027,
0.1446170062,
-1.0696949959,
-0.1671300679,
0.0779588446,
-0.1255040914,
-0.5792806745,
0.5461360812,
0.6311514974,
0.3233345151,
0.2657792568,
-0.1562964767,
1.2694023848,
-1.0910209417,
0.5475546718,
0.2340439558,
-1.1515733004,
0.4861827493,
-0.0318780914,
0.3202378452,
0.5158070326,
0.0619046837,
-0.5335711837,
-0.4432958961,
-0.3202907145,
-0.933411777,
0.8570131063,
0.5312452912,
0.0204929616,
0.6378785372,
0.3540324271,
0.1737353951,
0.103921853,
-0.3926546574,
-0.3152733147,
-0.1969317198,
-0.1142232865,
-0.4735971391,
-0.1719077528,
-0.0923472568,
-0.5901424885,
0.8025556803,
0.0493006557,
0.3196468055,
0.2790521681,
-0.0928025842,
-0.1786031574,
0.3114084601,
0.5585351586,
0.437400043,
-0.0728855729,
0.2745214403,
-0.2003605664,
-0.3151670694,
0.3264524043,
0.2432755381,
-0.0301797818,
0.1943783611,
0.5019677281,
0.7553741932,
0.4354909658,
-0.4980207682,
0.4409430623,
-0.2529097795,
-0.1482199579,
-0.3136153817,
0.0037625977,
-0.0669096485,
0.4198823869,
0.6705867648,
0.3884416819,
0.4721778035,
-0.6350849867,
0.5557742119,
-0.0441179648,
-0.2123313695,
-0.3696581125,
0.8872765303,
0.3030221164,
-0.5312365294,
0.6968497634,
0.0635035709,
-0.5605573058,
0.1961765289,
0.3861148059,
0.8932995796,
-0.5388578176,
0.0490640625,
0.3492417037,
0.0464789979,
0.0501137786,
0.3800140619,
-0.2457605898,
-0.7200122476,
-0.9772806168,
-0.8675303459,
-0.3191394806,
-0.1958405972,
-0.702545464,
0.3840332925,
-0.077235423,
-0.146744296,
0.4523578286,
-0.1825878918,
-0.2796033025,
0.3953117728,
0.0473684035,
0.7172667384,
-0.9467721581,
1.1965404749,
0.5467643142,
-0.3520649374,
-0.7962779403,
0.2166994214,
0.0958470926,
-0.4565356374,
0.2224697024,
0.0759223104,
-0.369900316,
-0.0387019478,
-0.2217025161,
-1.0909488201,
1.0594094992,
0.1499091983,
-0.8366302848,
-0.4009964764,
-0.183270514,
0.5399915576,
-0.1297482848,
-0.0382296443,
0.5603536367,
0.3276562691,
0.7955896258,
-1.3046299219,
-0.1834855527,
-0.2041727901,
-0.0358692855,
0.1477717161,
-0.432280153,
0.6941844225,
0.0653800964,
-0.67995435,
-0.0268362351,
0.8468421698,
0.3221217692,
0.5548388958,
0.6784422398,
0.4311034381,
0.4534524083,
-0.0997733027,
0.840046823,
-0.0714445412,
0.2218020409,
1.6283756495,
-0.3594349921,
1.2373497486,
0.732636869,
-0.2602013946,
0.3394540548,
0.4347744286,
0.589359045,
0.7938427329,
0.1124445423,
-0.2828668952,
-0.1819524318,
0.2302789688,
-0.1883084327,
0.674998343,
0.0111616114,
-0.369512707,
-0.1030526385,
-0.019492723,
0.0262290593,
0.2138013691,
-0.2958533168,
0.7775016427,
-0.0315938666,
-0.5908043385,
0.3389268219,
0.2365035266,
0.7918407321,
-0.3827030957,
-0.0847757906,
-0.1275891662,
0.2400570661,
-0.3263539076,
-0.5000067949,
0.8724790812,
0.2624346912,
-0.4179888368,
-0.5000414848,
0.6260442734,
-0.7460139394,
-0.5806216598,
0.3000025153,
0.3463872969,
0.2081483901,
-0.2059312314,
-0.4433866143,
0.6104646325,
0.2495861799,
0.0294741243,
0.1524987966,
0.1091054231,
0.3091074824,
0.6752889156,
0.8661814928,
0.2070672512,
0.4886376262,
0.2651895285,
1.0149457455,
-0.5422807336,
-0.6654134989,
-0.5759421587,
0.7874957919,
-0.128807798,
0.1700214595,
0.5294290781,
0.6546667218,
0.8364866376,
0.1997129619,
0.5753481388,
0.015831843,
0.7047719955,
-0.50513798,
0.7929893732,
-0.8205674291,
0.2327864021,
-0.4497059882,
-0.8286126256,
-0.583030045,
0.5071539879,
0.100098893,
-0.0961441249,
0.4948718846,
0.632694304,
-0.0611003824,
-0.0426810868,
0.5081121325,
0.1354335696,
0.5383964181,
0.3219885826,
0.6615808606,
-0.7358172536,
0.5820925236,
-0.0939376131,
-0.2634293735,
0.0471430123,
-0.6966313124,
-0.4250503778,
-0.911583364,
-0.6362786293,
-0.2740660608,
0.0104697905,
0.621314168,
0.7361847758,
-0.7276355624,
-0.1762945652,
0.3788074851,
-0.1827186644,
-0.3116479516,
-0.205995515,
0.3598842323,
-0.1100634336,
-1.0354238749,
0.8441585898,
0.2941836417,
-0.0816394091,
0.055552274,
-0.1700734645,
-0.325504303,
0.1687444597,
0.7966683507,
0.1928374469,
-0.8930740356,
-0.4216801226,
-0.4706215858,
0.2206237018,
0.1350608617,
0.8863888383,
-0.6725091338,
0.6345399618,
0.4948280752,
0.6649519205,
0.7058843374,
0.1813622713,
0.530798018,
-1.0378388166,
-0.0650221333,
0.2273949385,
0.4386487901,
0.4740310311,
-0.1141412407,
0.087769866,
-0.0308893193,
-0.6138040423,
-0.8889175653,
0.1180005595,
-1.1317795515,
0.0243483596,
1.0473008156,
0.0361831151,
0.0767098516,
0.0842698961,
-0.2656958699,
0.7754858136,
-0.6100901961,
0.5356318951,
0.5179472566,
-0.4208068848,
-0.2188922763,
-0.2860383689,
0.3760253489,
0.1664893478,
-0.5326995254,
-0.0541346371,
0.6796438098,
0.3939606249,
0.1371398717,
0.8088405132,
-0.1276219785,
0.0086285677,
-0.0967747942,
0.1000924185,
0.0584089011,
-0.7341609001,
-0.7697586417,
0.1138535663,
-0.1223220453,
-0.5402870774
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04764v1
|
First Attempt at Building Parallel Corpora for Machine Translation of Northeast India's Very Low-Resource Languages
| 2023-12-08T00:28:41 | 2023-12-08T00:28:41 |
Atnafu Lambebo Tonja, Melkamu Mersha, Ananya Kalita, Olga Kolesnikova, Jugal Kalita
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents the creation of initial bilingual corpora for thirteen
very low-resource languages of India, all from Northeast India. It also
presents the results of initial translation efforts in these languages. It
creates the first-ever parallel corpora for these languages and provides
initial benchmark neural machine translation results for these languages. We
intend to extend these corpora to include a large number of low-resource Indian
languages and integrate the effort with our prior work with African and
American-Indian languages to create corpora covering a large number of
languages from across the world.
|
[
-0.3796490431,
-0.3964903057,
0.3528006971,
0.4671956599,
-0.3076948524,
0.3562569618,
-0.5016369224,
-0.2908757925,
0.4623245001,
0.1803519577,
-0.6844201088,
-0.384670198,
-0.7178036571,
0.6438012123,
-0.4580161572,
0.8893273473,
0.16147089,
0.010229053,
0.0659361929,
-0.4138437212,
-0.3244069815,
-0.4383139908,
-0.4811197519,
0.175325349,
0.3844080269,
0.7338598967,
0.832676053,
0.7580776811,
0.4325376451,
0.4265694022,
0.0243971832,
0.3651963472,
-0.3269842267,
-0.1849979758,
-0.1689504087,
-0.6952216029,
-0.3974296749,
-0.2789754272,
0.9867822528,
0.9729425311,
-0.0188801251,
0.3192790151,
-0.0094419578,
0.6130920649,
-0.4560199082,
-0.0402280837,
-0.4847010672,
0.0482003577,
-0.8244578838,
-0.1104147434,
-0.2951688766,
-0.27243343,
-0.27257061,
-0.6572852135,
0.227779448,
0.388021946,
0.4867728949,
0.1759690493,
-0.2188572437,
-0.3069246411,
-0.5754747391,
1.1464548111,
-0.3997757733,
0.2211497724,
0.3944975734,
0.3816760182,
0.2609826028,
-0.6454955339,
-0.5168220997,
0.0455680378,
-0.2926779091,
-0.0578889772,
-0.2500655651,
-0.499340564,
0.0842060819,
0.5021373034,
-0.6668427587,
0.2752047777,
-0.9416256547,
-0.0536367968,
0.3645353615,
0.6164932251,
0.6142203212,
-0.2783522904,
-0.3099324405,
-0.159134984,
-0.6203887463,
-0.2674439549,
0.2984647453,
0.6984156966,
-0.5480200052,
0.9342448115,
-0.3242250383,
0.6789166331,
-0.0835487843,
-0.1856846809,
0.2752626836,
-0.8616306782,
-0.3136732876,
0.4263072014,
0.7522547245,
0.0813298002,
0.067473866,
-0.1934961677,
-0.1650737673,
0.2550584972,
-0.0223297011,
-0.4566504061,
0.3052200973,
-0.2406185418,
-0.7510272264,
-0.124033317,
-0.6631626487,
-0.8875078559,
-0.2527297735,
-0.4798854291,
-0.0788164437,
-0.3098874688,
-0.4606503248,
-0.3601128459,
0.3083116114,
0.2469399869,
-0.1689561456,
-1.1314198971,
0.6420782208,
0.7189896703,
0.9629526734,
-0.1928962916,
-0.7058236599,
-0.5140911341,
-0.1093435287,
-0.3374940753,
0.7199967504,
-0.4901364446,
-0.4685907066,
0.1527432352,
-0.0486723334,
0.1506596655,
-0.5727206469,
0.6697924137,
-0.4973061979,
-0.2673615515,
-0.3034604192,
0.1474056542,
0.2527797818,
0.2281791866,
-0.2870046198,
0.5040224791,
0.1843320131,
-0.8248862028,
0.1671289951,
-0.3448260427,
-0.6497986317,
0.2093416899,
-0.3344433606,
0.3276580572,
0.3986861408,
0.147595197,
0.0604003705,
-0.9410874248,
-0.0750611722,
0.0278838817,
-0.1169340089,
-0.2316183746,
-0.3324594796,
1.1176985502,
0.4618701935,
-0.1286285222,
-0.083289139,
-0.8853374124,
0.2425163537,
-0.0405327752,
-0.0474141203,
-0.4730763733,
-0.4603987634,
0.2897478938,
0.1727414131,
0.5746399164,
-0.6549021006,
0.0460628532,
-0.3477594554,
0.2768701315,
0.7305985689,
-0.5287236571,
0.8401905894,
-0.0544277728,
0.6567872167,
0.0667331219,
0.0878252909,
0.0667981803,
-0.5691367388,
-0.7459227443,
-0.1183652431,
0.369720757,
0.7882266641,
-0.5893099904,
-0.1775602698,
-0.3708672523,
-0.4230977893,
-0.7226458192,
0.5814351439,
0.7792339325,
0.2447809875,
0.3095538318,
-0.3038725853,
-0.9162275195,
-1.4782460928,
0.1337116063,
-0.0802843869,
0.1553633809,
-0.134086296,
0.0598107465,
-0.1108343378,
0.5535912514,
-0.3821165562,
-0.1825886071,
-0.1132585481,
0.3396428823,
0.2027707696,
0.5531539917,
0.5053687096,
-0.7074704766,
-0.8649802208,
0.2041218728,
-0.8481248021,
-0.1172667369,
0.2429468781,
-0.5465146899,
0.4725261331,
0.6139454842,
-0.5775049925,
0.3430419564,
0.8086388707,
0.0840277821,
0.3143585026,
-0.4211704135,
-0.0885904059,
-1.2880694866,
-0.0629221722,
-0.3342041671,
0.0684792101,
-0.3546665311,
-0.244793281,
-0.2174033523,
-0.3387188017,
-0.4564280808,
0.5602245927,
-0.5587291718,
-0.3140784502,
-0.3045078218,
0.1516092569,
-0.5974665284,
0.2909298241,
-0.2000103891,
0.9432700276,
0.5142971277,
-0.3876775503,
0.0540982075,
0.5522500873,
-0.1830624789,
0.7833064198,
-0.621771872,
-0.023395488,
-0.0336913392,
-0.3511755168,
-0.581378758,
-0.1369890422,
0.0019452567,
-0.4674419463,
0.2892597914,
0.0084635317,
-0.6987879872,
-0.0481074192,
0.3234438002,
0.6206704974,
0.7259615064,
-0.5287253261,
0.0877924785,
0.587357223,
-0.6331304908,
-0.3748618662,
-1.3246650696,
0.2436825186,
0.1275283694,
-0.5534080267,
0.4103080928,
-0.184659183,
-0.4785734713,
0.230290249,
0.2662296891,
-0.422513634,
-0.4026422501,
0.1326312423,
0.283421874,
-0.4154751897,
-0.2436396778,
0.0453334711,
-0.2188359946,
-0.0926468298,
-0.2218448371,
0.5536552072,
-0.6823316216,
-0.2818888128,
-0.3257721364,
0.8996145725,
0.5229856968,
-0.3164655566,
0.6688671112,
0.5716608167,
-0.3935972452,
0.0205508415,
-0.5053831339,
0.0964859948,
-0.4420775771,
0.2896516621,
-0.433480829,
-0.8032957315,
0.5030301213,
0.0134637346,
-0.2553421557,
0.4674156606,
0.8972664475,
0.4139392376,
0.8912211061,
0.9434440136,
-0.2449040711,
0.0011220103,
0.0040394138,
0.5716174841,
-0.7108215094,
-0.1805637926,
-0.6305878758,
-0.3312754929,
-1.3490352631,
-0.4340262711,
0.2581900656,
0.1152966022,
-0.2469877005,
0.5324917436,
-0.7391025424,
0.3667288721,
0.8902568817,
-0.0842388496,
0.3628472984,
0.18671529,
-0.2520182431,
-0.3545852304,
-0.8538596034,
-0.5597579479,
1.1192554235,
-0.2072829306,
0.1740496159,
0.2424544692,
1.1611632109,
0.0602491014,
0.3882437348,
-0.3962731361,
0.6102292538,
-0.5920177698,
-0.6163243055,
-0.2030717582,
-0.1691175252,
-0.7842487693,
0.0072102998,
-0.0731420591,
-0.1466414928,
0.3030430079,
-0.2375483513,
-0.414065063,
0.3010851741,
-0.8273370266,
0.7577271461,
-0.5274662971,
-0.5565710664,
-0.3356018364,
-0.4836397767,
0.7255501747,
-0.1211415753,
0.3105507493,
0.134443596,
-0.2686127424,
0.3314501941,
-0.5940560102,
0.7600343227,
-0.0353291556,
0.3949427605,
0.4400640428,
0.028009383,
0.1659234762,
0.2264332324,
0.0162099581,
0.0888440162,
-0.3109236062,
-0.9286836982,
-0.1641287208,
1.0446084738,
-0.7753528953,
-0.4475049973,
-0.5383023024,
-0.625445962,
-0.0309531298,
0.5557723641,
0.0636082143,
0.169736892,
-0.0762636364,
0.1826516092,
0.3561528921,
-0.3437595665,
0.6872704625,
0.3719201684,
-0.0478681959,
-0.6412153244,
0.8936296701,
0.0577315837,
-0.0721978396,
0.1051357538,
-0.0473929048,
-0.1008660346,
-0.5454859734,
-0.5567474365,
0.1428916752,
-0.4662881196,
-0.1461657435,
-0.5389388204,
-0.0288787205,
-0.4436379075,
-0.3471425176,
-0.5420716405,
-0.3900568485,
0.1014065668,
0.4088973701,
0.2441661954,
0.8341858983,
-0.5303029418,
0.2245985568,
-1.0094161034,
0.2627942562,
0.48087731,
0.0471456535,
-0.1199801564,
-0.3241648078,
-0.3918861747,
-0.0775160417,
-0.0071288641,
-0.5083893538,
0.6808579564,
-0.1352599114,
0.6516417265,
0.0650064722,
-0.0995165408,
0.6053210497,
-0.8469052911,
0.6568053365,
0.4808754325,
-0.6893202662,
0.3630926311,
-0.3724072576,
0.4448297322,
0.7294042706,
0.5641384125,
-0.0911908373,
0.0869159102,
-0.4122010469,
-0.7662031054,
0.5903405547,
0.2751969993,
0.1941879094,
-0.3720143437,
-0.0918187499,
0.1199422255,
0.2218070924,
-0.2426663935,
-0.3760557771,
-0.087777406,
0.0243276805,
-0.3269883096,
-0.3146584928,
-0.1985629648,
-0.3322978318,
0.3617775738,
0.0469836332,
0.2507103384,
0.2336016893,
-0.147532478,
-0.0445900969,
0.4323117137,
1.0838603973,
0.7921885252,
-0.1032967716,
0.0725532621,
0.3939702511,
-0.3140042722,
0.1422025859,
0.1577487141,
-0.1349203438,
0.2189090699,
0.0804125965,
0.8158507943,
0.3530682325,
-0.4977135062,
0.1136470661,
0.0516696833,
0.1957495809,
-0.6666471362,
-0.6409870982,
0.3591719866,
0.2027380615,
0.257127583,
0.1924897432,
-0.1919706613,
-0.620718658,
0.0433421358,
0.2092884481,
-0.0152960662,
-0.3881871998,
0.6912164092,
0.2070835382,
-0.4957025349,
0.748033464,
-0.774764955,
-0.605612278,
0.4551357329,
0.7570049167,
1.0055720806,
-0.0340781249,
0.0710009038,
0.696988821,
0.688888073,
0.0161793977,
0.2780256569,
-0.0821650252,
-0.2338980883,
-0.4816654325,
-0.9849060774,
-0.4246273339,
-0.2082673758,
-0.4245329797,
0.3875955045,
-0.624458909,
-0.0644444674,
-0.1067837477,
-0.0308390334,
-0.8326286077,
-0.0370595865,
0.4597736299,
0.8099910617,
-0.8888148665,
0.8054103851,
0.9778812528,
-0.7536437511,
-0.3617766201,
-0.3327969909,
0.0258003399,
-0.9502006769,
1.4966363907,
-0.2417243272,
-0.1222391129,
-0.0319530927,
-0.3107252121,
-0.9928377271,
0.857265532,
0.1297758669,
-0.5670691133,
-0.0135171358,
0.6264896393,
0.64903754,
-0.5385710597,
0.1944777668,
0.1904677898,
0.5135226846,
-0.4913956225,
-1.01897645,
0.0967825577,
-0.4442558587,
0.3027974069,
0.2196031809,
-0.8723896742,
1.3404830694,
-0.0054602064,
-0.1461187899,
0.242843166,
0.8966322541,
0.394230336,
0.3479876816,
0.4366407394,
0.8450793624,
0.507086575,
0.2150752246,
1.320985198,
-0.7391072512,
-0.3273423016,
1.2996588945,
-0.2380996495,
0.8570959568,
0.6384979486,
-0.3579414785,
0.3012448251,
0.3805278242,
0.2124325931,
0.5488865972,
0.4216840565,
-0.404334873,
-0.0878193676,
-0.6035801768,
-0.6197532415,
0.4668397605,
0.2865996659,
-0.1223935336,
-0.3912359178,
0.0339268632,
0.1044449657,
0.4376729727,
-0.3087360263,
0.191104278,
0.2221969962,
-0.6952971816,
0.9751387835,
0.0043390929,
1.0229004622,
-0.3693596721,
0.0347808413,
-0.5549450517,
0.1660484225,
-0.1577605307,
-0.4499496222,
0.8974584341,
0.3687715232,
-0.6267672777,
-0.3153689206,
0.4524124861,
-0.4617085755,
-0.6355435252,
0.4307760596,
0.645668745,
0.3034293354,
0.2066643238,
-0.3524052501,
0.1201810092,
-0.2176463306,
0.2709493935,
0.7175378799,
0.4531740844,
-0.1269134283,
0.0671671927,
0.7384468913,
0.2297134399,
0.7313332558,
-0.381373167,
0.5877465606,
-0.5283488631,
-0.2128150761,
-0.5303528309,
0.2458911985,
-0.0737507194,
-0.4860949814,
0.779879868,
0.8137735128,
1.1466743946,
-0.2607227266,
0.9160835147,
-0.4876866043,
0.3972280025,
-0.1268476844,
0.8030993342,
-0.7761079073,
-0.21793513,
0.1730371267,
-0.995021522,
-0.07096228,
0.1214016601,
-0.1136650518,
-0.4472507536,
0.9494749308,
0.8791626096,
-0.3156963885,
-0.0554245263,
0.4328035414,
0.2208668143,
-0.3799982369,
0.7188431025,
0.5073502064,
-0.5080579519,
0.8951056004,
-0.9211400747,
-0.2738133371,
0.1769332588,
-0.8772891164,
-0.484529525,
-0.5050071478,
-0.0162770953,
-0.3841844797,
-0.0909488499,
0.789483726,
0.4307514131,
-1.0207290649,
-0.5283004045,
-0.2837763429,
-0.1117431894,
0.151904285,
-0.135043636,
0.256785661,
-0.5884491801,
-1.2939155102,
0.7902623415,
0.2009095997,
-0.2810964286,
-0.3589859605,
-0.2763952017,
-0.5828342438,
-0.3257499337,
0.6998304725,
0.8656526208,
-0.5100893378,
0.352469027,
0.1608351022,
-0.5037251115,
-0.0075825443,
0.7470346093,
-0.4281949997,
0.3168580234,
0.8166898489,
0.9499670267,
0.3636318743,
-0.4015412927,
0.3302765489,
-0.5991101861,
0.6903108954,
-0.0143289119,
0.1337450296,
0.5238005519,
-0.1287762076,
0.5147518516,
0.3161222637,
-0.4623568058,
-1.030171752,
-0.0158812944,
-0.8744707704,
0.2782941759,
0.6928266287,
0.1570026875,
-0.5498406887,
0.1703882068,
0.0611945614,
0.4800690114,
-0.035884127,
0.4481663108,
0.5933440328,
0.0480593257,
0.0087294839,
-1.0022832155,
0.2811171114,
0.8847078681,
-0.6571706533,
-0.1673832834,
0.2926653326,
-0.1906634867,
0.7601345181,
0.8159885406,
-0.331251502,
0.1032616869,
0.4919906259,
0.1992803812,
0.0985998735,
-0.2274282724,
-0.2888784707,
0.1818679124,
0.0414773747,
-0.3697669804
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04748v1
|
Forcing Generative Models to Degenerate Ones: The Power of Data Poisoning Attacks
| 2023-12-07T23:26:06 | 2023-12-07T23:26:06 |
Shuli Jiang, Swanand Ravindra Kadhe, Yi Zhou, Ling Cai, Nathalie Baracaldo
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Growing applications of large language models (LLMs) trained by a third party
raise serious concerns on the security vulnerability of LLMs.It has been
demonstrated that malicious actors can covertly exploit these vulnerabilities
in LLMs through poisoning attacks aimed at generating undesirable outputs.
While poisoning attacks have received significant attention in the image domain
(e.g., object detection), and classification tasks, their implications for
generative models, particularly in the realm of natural language generation
(NLG) tasks, remain poorly understood. To bridge this gap, we perform a
comprehensive exploration of various poisoning techniques to assess their
effectiveness across a range of generative tasks. Furthermore, we introduce a
range of metrics designed to quantify the success and stealthiness of poisoning
attacks specifically tailored to NLG tasks. Through extensive experiments on
multiple NLG tasks, LLMs and datasets, we show that it is possible to
successfully poison an LLM during the fine-tuning stage using as little as 1\%
of the total tuning data samples. Our paper presents the first systematic
approach to comprehend poisoning attacks targeting NLG tasks considering a wide
range of triggers and attack settings. We hope our findings will assist the AI
security community in devising appropriate defenses against such threats.
|
[
-0.2696512341,
-1.0544251204,
0.3503356874,
-0.1481332779,
-0.0798740163,
-0.0499374643,
0.0467227362,
-0.4237504601,
-0.366127938,
0.7142657638,
-0.4402449131,
-0.6660051942,
-0.6585093141,
0.2030569464,
-0.6839455962,
0.8860952258,
0.3849822879,
-0.2217377424,
-0.1823540628,
0.3374283314,
-0.6977461576,
-0.8162345886,
-0.862521708,
-0.1264437437,
0.7250914574,
0.1284530163,
0.7267556787,
0.4881305099,
0.5209100246,
0.2669999599,
-0.1025929525,
0.0512951836,
-0.5537469387,
0.4362306595,
-0.2530424595,
-0.7593812346,
-0.2433811128,
-0.0566637851,
-0.0018996465,
0.3407056928,
-0.0976126641,
-0.1737755537,
0.1521789581,
0.674118042,
-0.8493705392,
-0.1457085013,
-1.2794528008,
0.1780812591,
-0.4457294345,
-0.3023326397,
-0.8869147301,
0.1569487303,
-0.2031635791,
-0.2935663462,
0.257864058,
0.0279709548,
0.5753493309,
0.54290694,
-0.2889924943,
-0.3408058882,
-0.7954077721,
0.8735163212,
-0.6862766147,
-0.2450389862,
0.5028727055,
0.1640876383,
-0.4150737226,
-0.5754944086,
-0.4331943989,
-0.2399865091,
-0.1059191674,
0.0185758341,
-0.6900706291,
0.3410153687,
0.4644270241,
0.2794468105,
-0.6972956657,
0.3534694612,
-0.0399282202,
0.1352010369,
0.8026995063,
0.5467915535,
0.7197178006,
-0.5616702437,
-0.4965803921,
-0.1520968825,
-1.0058460236,
-0.7003569007,
0.5589257479,
0.266759485,
0.0580670573,
0.3161921203,
0.0856196433,
0.8554034233,
-0.1732944101,
0.2792999744,
-0.4211216569,
-0.3236670196,
-0.3845283389,
-0.0056646876,
1.0412182808,
0.3963455558,
0.2707110941,
-0.3292531371,
-0.0615539476,
0.1874434203,
0.7264631391,
-0.7327962518,
-0.4947141707,
0.3495941758,
0.0259939767,
-0.9167215824,
-0.2204678655,
-1.1132438183,
-0.7762259841,
0.171903193,
0.4066932797,
-0.4589532018,
-0.1811258942,
0.1178529263,
-0.2529295087,
0.1883808076,
-0.0439362563,
-1.2413716316,
0.0800210312,
0.8212203383,
0.7228593826,
-0.0625285953,
-0.165201351,
-0.5381381512,
0.2501029968,
-0.3771997094,
0.7498642206,
-0.2684703171,
-0.4876272678,
0.0635816306,
-0.3904518783,
-0.1142044738,
-0.8453402519,
0.4974927902,
-0.7612521052,
-0.2077450603,
-0.1744835824,
-0.3579612076,
-0.1727199554,
0.4291132092,
-0.7021560669,
0.6541569829,
-0.2842979431,
-1.0130429268,
0.3303233385,
-0.3190399706,
-0.5928700566,
0.1390875131,
-0.0716773793,
-0.3107292056,
0.0738125518,
0.2472943366,
0.7581890225,
-0.2989789248,
0.0322298445,
-0.2973216474,
-0.0034271304,
0.057161916,
-0.6130967736,
0.9232260585,
0.3027738035,
-0.0486489125,
0.164370656,
-0.6283115149,
-0.0473606475,
0.3860727847,
-0.1198499352,
-0.5062753558,
0.2922604084,
-0.1099928543,
-0.1198784336,
-0.1782790869,
-0.3068054914,
0.0967021286,
-0.5673087835,
0.6076414585,
0.7415877581,
0.5123019814,
0.2615329325,
-0.4918112457,
0.5282829404,
-0.0341963582,
0.4480547309,
-0.2884925306,
-0.3240278363,
-0.5476093292,
-0.2645840347,
0.0769839436,
0.6685260534,
-0.9573662877,
0.591350317,
-0.2106816173,
-0.8714067936,
-0.0993000343,
0.2653276324,
0.3116577864,
0.4118234515,
0.2956615388,
-0.0073471926,
-0.3666745424,
-0.5585816503,
-0.526129961,
-0.0830356926,
-0.1820626557,
0.159174487,
0.5742129087,
-0.3434133232,
0.663765192,
-0.4461857975,
-0.4476779401,
-0.2333188504,
0.1345247626,
-0.0104901828,
0.4934494495,
0.7051501274,
-0.6280449033,
-0.4531996548,
-0.2036742717,
-1.0798015594,
0.0034193599,
-0.3273890316,
-0.1226813644,
0.1238002181,
0.6123166084,
-0.5865896344,
0.4074859619,
0.3709908128,
0.0080590984,
0.5334627628,
0.0911571234,
-0.0807484463,
-1.0441660881,
0.0453482382,
-0.081065625,
-0.0170297008,
-1.1761436462,
0.4050237834,
-0.0679985359,
-0.1401506066,
-0.7007336617,
0.4045818746,
-0.2563866079,
0.4237325788,
-0.0685870498,
-0.1181825474,
0.096712634,
0.1725639403,
-0.4648008347,
0.3443190157,
0.9117875695,
-0.5342642665,
0.5862335563,
0.1618423909,
-0.3791674078,
0.5185830593,
-0.6860771179,
0.3899181783,
-0.0925728753,
0.0218165033,
-0.8098145127,
-0.568549633,
0.3887595236,
-0.2582950592,
0.5787810087,
-0.3348978758,
-0.8721038699,
-0.0861028209,
-0.3365373611,
0.3240325451,
0.4371614754,
-0.8006842136,
0.5884407759,
0.1031411663,
0.1229575649,
-0.5331360102,
-0.8159296513,
0.6124158502,
-0.7397122383,
-0.7396153212,
0.4036352336,
0.0620130934,
-0.5228855014,
-0.2591727674,
0.0811501667,
0.1890696287,
0.6212655902,
0.3861104846,
0.1240767986,
0.3582569659,
-0.1826886237,
-0.0754093453,
-0.0646053031,
0.3246129751,
0.1445576996,
0.6631399393,
0.4100325108,
-0.4977139831,
-0.4302014112,
0.431799978,
0.6831752062,
-0.1936992705,
0.8008968234,
0.0603098311,
-0.388723731,
-0.5509411693,
-0.2737548947,
-0.2988879979,
-0.548627317,
0.4091359377,
-0.1259639114,
-0.1878660172,
0.543161273,
0.1120338589,
0.0572320893,
0.2672056556,
0.2544447184,
0.0726316869,
1.1155554056,
0.2697664201,
-0.3788788021,
0.3751326799,
-0.2749526501,
0.2938883305,
-0.703347683,
-0.2514529526,
-0.3072873354,
-0.0769102201,
-0.4548937976,
-0.0757090002,
0.6161292791,
0.3548645079,
-0.0267341919,
0.2414456606,
-0.5101354122,
0.7715336084,
0.3548527956,
0.0677381903,
0.1344856173,
0.2259266526,
0.1460668147,
0.1985884458,
-0.7474361658,
-0.4123907685,
1.0507713556,
0.2423302084,
1.1184413433,
0.1030190289,
0.7936159968,
0.381044656,
0.1914704591,
-0.7421337962,
0.6147181392,
-0.3234488666,
-0.7132987976,
-0.0453326777,
-0.3713988662,
-1.0990941525,
0.1955375373,
0.0363453478,
-0.6489521861,
-0.1023790613,
0.1332217157,
-0.3129106462,
0.4779425263,
-0.7270474434,
0.7948752046,
-0.3493869305,
-0.3722824156,
-0.1523546278,
-0.4129032195,
0.6337412596,
-0.2610832751,
0.0505810603,
-0.1071141213,
0.3326404095,
0.5632029772,
-0.2361279428,
1.1299258471,
-0.1304264069,
-0.2024845779,
0.1500193328,
0.477001518,
0.4306886792,
-0.0536137521,
-0.2338932604,
0.4399826527,
-0.2027304024,
-0.3350260854,
-0.5492824316,
0.6820021868,
-0.3374493718,
-0.8911337256,
-0.4474492371,
-0.3851722479,
-0.1338859499,
0.0768931061,
0.6885530949,
0.2252476066,
-0.0718442723,
-0.0525193699,
0.6722661853,
-0.4696030915,
0.5639955401,
0.1694332361,
0.0317792296,
-0.2268950492,
0.9266803861,
0.0444292687,
0.6788241267,
0.2405952215,
0.0306996703,
0.03917538,
-0.6878379583,
-0.5009940863,
-0.0551361255,
-0.7196064591,
-0.6584046483,
-0.5239020586,
-0.3771351278,
-0.3828764558,
-0.0597226545,
-0.0363882184,
0.2220315635,
-0.6805450916,
-0.1395516694,
0.5530831814,
0.8343561292,
-0.0309156608,
0.296995014,
-0.6851573586,
0.2084707618,
0.4377993941,
-0.0216328446,
0.1724263877,
-0.3497012854,
0.1542893499,
-0.0201144125,
-0.5335705876,
-1.2458872795,
0.4985651076,
0.1699536592,
0.401748538,
0.6252650619,
0.2566359043,
0.3020803928,
-0.4761507511,
1.0364278555,
0.1439837217,
-0.7890259027,
0.8573684692,
-0.5086045265,
0.0155995404,
0.2965507507,
0.387768358,
-0.5649609566,
-0.5986750126,
-0.3190387189,
-1.1295969486,
0.4812776446,
0.1539725065,
0.5899047256,
-0.3202694356,
0.4297007322,
0.0200099945,
-0.15203695,
-0.632776022,
-0.3298354447,
-0.0391340889,
-0.1212909892,
0.0584307723,
-0.372762084,
-0.3072921336,
0.0331349932,
0.557128191,
0.1687670946,
-0.0249649435,
-0.0258430764,
-0.1164231896,
0.1412430108,
0.2637195587,
0.3225962818,
0.020674523,
0.1669201851,
0.5874041915,
0.1057708189,
-0.2902886868,
0.1761441827,
0.0187061038,
-0.2024726868,
-0.3785010576,
0.668177247,
0.6053327918,
-0.1228232235,
-0.7153767943,
0.4262958467,
-0.0239403807,
-0.0705254897,
-0.1679264009,
0.6063046455,
-0.1525477767,
-0.1447472125,
0.3945127428,
0.0017389909,
-0.0476147421,
-0.5365012884,
0.1558861136,
0.868237555,
-0.1563701928,
-0.2213886827,
0.5563651323,
0.042732574,
-0.1669152528,
0.6108609438,
-0.1074702889,
-0.6233376265,
0.5795419216,
0.4974672794,
0.9977605343,
-0.4322699904,
-0.0077481903,
0.2627479136,
0.5772731304,
0.1495358199,
-0.0848907828,
0.0094307885,
-0.7339156866,
-0.0891189799,
-0.6645772457,
-0.1169056371,
0.5871886015,
-0.580773592,
-0.0085145775,
-0.6574330926,
-0.0969682708,
0.215825364,
-0.5709210634,
-0.3621093631,
-0.081135571,
0.2926980853,
0.646015048,
-0.9369688034,
0.3942399919,
0.1296721101,
-0.3212201595,
-0.5112984776,
0.2422668785,
0.1481936723,
-0.596096158,
0.6421599388,
0.227303341,
0.0764405429,
0.0189412087,
-0.5864881277,
-0.5413085818,
0.6404619813,
0.3836926222,
-0.3661198616,
-0.1060473472,
0.4826060534,
0.5295054913,
0.2765074074,
-0.3305048943,
0.6916037202,
0.3616976738,
-0.1198752597,
-0.4368881583,
0.2066051215,
-0.2482914925,
-0.0146837179,
0.1767540574,
-0.3404808342,
0.5490703583,
-0.1841388196,
-0.5687534213,
0.0359430239,
0.1856012344,
-0.0355124474,
0.1255626231,
0.49219805,
0.8204605579,
0.4590705633,
-0.0674013197,
1.1657086611,
-0.108057864,
-0.0695498586,
0.9769459963,
-0.4282998443,
0.7353367209,
0.3179491162,
-0.0027775839,
0.3326655924,
0.4810272157,
-0.5217202306,
0.6522623897,
0.544472158,
-0.5665755272,
-0.0973403826,
-0.0981082916,
-0.0192149431,
0.4204467237,
0.4897723496,
-0.4714758396,
-0.2981698513,
0.4902128279,
0.315990448,
-0.0271919221,
-0.2155918926,
1.1743952036,
0.0875882283,
-0.7428953052,
0.8678946495,
0.058341749,
0.5731523633,
-0.3575840592,
0.171344623,
-0.2285755426,
0.0907656997,
-0.3441829383,
-0.599630177,
0.4872905612,
0.4033400714,
-0.0424170904,
-0.1419310123,
0.7893371582,
-0.0371221602,
-0.2173563838,
0.4197512269,
0.0018317612,
-0.0265828855,
-0.4937584698,
-0.392277211,
0.1410659552,
-0.0095289387,
-0.2496047318,
0.3779853582,
-0.0200324841,
0.2397829294,
0.722371161,
0.5696085691,
0.1533342898,
0.3470747471,
0.0121376775,
0.7730430365,
-0.3553149104,
-0.0548593998,
-1.4260401726,
0.3955323696,
-0.015284773,
0.1828830689,
0.8950513005,
0.34703058,
0.7422447205,
0.0063252337,
0.8854423165,
-0.0392937697,
-0.0474485382,
-0.7068921328,
0.9870764613,
-0.3480703235,
0.5324054956,
-0.1463061571,
-0.5623381734,
-0.5571486354,
0.1212551147,
-0.3662427366,
-0.0799218267,
0.4210466444,
1.0833472013,
0.2310182899,
-0.0527996011,
0.3617639244,
0.2757095993,
0.7173822522,
0.6216372252,
1.1327650547,
-0.4172290862,
0.4963504672,
-0.3518043756,
-0.0990923271,
-0.0543182604,
-0.8326634765,
-1.2829447985,
-0.4023251235,
-0.2944290042,
-0.3131712973,
0.0260706767,
0.2487717569,
0.7461476326,
-0.4932540953,
0.3467085958,
-0.6023423672,
0.0546591803,
-0.0356605425,
-0.2789089382,
0.2954330146,
-0.3743638992,
-0.6643315554,
0.5126130581,
0.1383386552,
0.187100485,
-0.3972109556,
0.3641822338,
0.1700717658,
0.2389661521,
0.4280932546,
0.0877837166,
-0.724036932,
-0.2202724218,
-0.330592066,
-0.2252493352,
-0.2551497817,
0.4967468977,
-0.5195116997,
0.5229766965,
0.4838601947,
0.4951694608,
0.0302923005,
-0.1388922036,
0.3063628674,
-1.1560525894,
-0.073940374,
0.379704982,
0.1131578609,
0.4354971051,
-0.7391338348,
0.3347201645,
0.0636680275,
-0.4545912445,
-1.2321065664,
0.5725616217,
-0.6772093177,
-0.5415356159,
1.3061239719,
-0.0577174015,
-0.1974435896,
0.019654505,
0.0096746916,
0.1310515255,
0.1352604181,
1.056383729,
0.4681511223,
0.0177947618,
0.3021094799,
-0.6477420926,
0.8360141516,
0.3462130725,
-1.2830507755,
0.6778334975,
0.3503356278,
0.3189072311,
0.314465791,
0.0271190945,
-0.1914808452,
0.1347087622,
0.1092191339,
-0.1924634874,
0.0784765035,
-0.4045199752,
-0.4275612235,
0.3041464686,
-0.0299920402,
-0.121142529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04746v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04746v2
|
Quilt-LLaVA: Visual Instruction Tuning by Extracting Localized Narratives from Open-Source Histopathology Videos
| 2023-12-07T23:16:37 | 2024-04-09T21:48:42 |
Mehmet Saygin Seyfioglu, Wisdom O. Ikezogwo, Fatemeh Ghezloo, Ranjay Krishna, Linda Shapiro
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Diagnosis in histopathology requires a global whole slide images (WSIs)
analysis, requiring pathologists to compound evidence from different WSI
patches. The gigapixel scale of WSIs poses a challenge for histopathology
multi-modal models. Training multi-model models for histopathology requires
instruction tuning datasets, which currently contain information for individual
image patches, without a spatial grounding of the concepts within each patch
and without a wider view of the WSI. Therefore, they lack sufficient diagnostic
capacity for histopathology. To bridge this gap, we introduce Quilt-Instruct, a
large-scale dataset of 107,131 histopathology-specific instruction
question/answer pairs, grounded within diagnostically relevant image patches
that make up the WSI. Our dataset is collected by leveraging educational
histopathology videos from YouTube, which provides spatial localization of
narrations by automatically extracting the narrators' cursor positions.
Quilt-Instruct supports contextual reasoning by extracting diagnosis and
supporting facts from the entire WSI. Using Quilt-Instruct, we train
Quilt-LLaVA, which can reason beyond the given single image patch, enabling
diagnostic reasoning across patches. To evaluate Quilt-LLaVA, we propose a
comprehensive evaluation dataset created from 985 images and 1283
human-generated question-answers. We also thoroughly evaluate Quilt-LLaVA using
public histopathology datasets, where Quilt-LLaVA significantly outperforms
SOTA by over 10% on relative GPT-4 score and 4% and 9% on open and closed set
VQA. Our code, data, and model are publicly accessible at
quilt-llava.github.io.
|
[
-0.4083223045,
-0.4960307479,
0.5738917589,
0.0105542103,
-0.2838257253,
0.1826087385,
-0.2863787711,
-0.055841092,
0.1674319804,
0.754350543,
-0.7238297462,
-0.5879629254,
-0.4260439873,
-0.1285944879,
-0.200486213,
1.2642136812,
-0.1004262045,
0.2923459709,
-0.714645505,
-0.1537799537,
-0.2494949251,
0.1392605603,
-0.3471516967,
0.1417195797,
0.7195972204,
0.9107838273,
0.4306785464,
0.7691723704,
0.7433568239,
0.2579192817,
0.1211569309,
0.164499566,
-0.5892212987,
0.2536569536,
-0.1429770738,
-0.3666115403,
-0.072018519,
0.0092787612,
0.6418851018,
0.58917588,
-0.3943186998,
0.4776344001,
-0.298114568,
0.674983561,
-0.8453090787,
-0.0690366775,
-0.2035692781,
0.1208984256,
-0.3517742455,
-0.1886313409,
-0.4395804405,
-0.5264208317,
0.0975772589,
-0.6349990368,
0.2384756356,
-0.1922950298,
0.6114431024,
0.1888912916,
-0.5459961891,
-0.0031681766,
-0.5325482488,
0.828120172,
-0.4486738741,
0.0504188836,
0.4738530815,
0.8741831779,
0.0233759061,
-0.7534663081,
-0.0474653468,
-0.1768751293,
0.1027126983,
0.2699970603,
-0.0251933523,
-0.0437438823,
0.4860273302,
0.6590622663,
-0.4868255854,
0.1009998992,
-0.3896810114,
-0.5382589102,
0.4520320892,
0.4872949123,
0.4799807966,
-0.2926706672,
-0.6856322885,
-0.1154787838,
-0.5724475384,
0.175685063,
0.0522805415,
0.0034738504,
-0.1357776523,
0.4010273516,
-0.1656779796,
0.6627239585,
0.0052744667,
-0.7279118896,
0.202692762,
-0.1548713148,
-0.1309611499,
0.0447416641,
0.4487007558,
0.3164575696,
-0.0555068552,
-0.0320661888,
0.1840809286,
-0.0264594797,
0.4104530513,
-1.0363893509,
-0.1313576102,
0.1516250372,
-0.4175402224,
-0.4625789225,
-0.3910509646,
-0.9228528738,
-0.7785823345,
-0.3001829684,
0.5195261836,
-0.4089487493,
-0.1286433339,
-0.1851697117,
-0.309571892,
0.1161697507,
0.4387893379,
-0.4650550485,
0.2018975914,
0.1814596504,
0.5796567798,
-0.0100282654,
-0.3425637484,
-0.7314622998,
0.4138412178,
-0.3919059336,
1.0828192234,
-0.9609328508,
-0.1330196857,
-0.1177698672,
0.274877578,
-0.1521958113,
-0.1464410424,
0.2033593506,
-0.1423015594,
0.6188169122,
-0.7492122054,
-0.4859108627,
-0.0143799959,
0.2435349673,
-0.4534913599,
0.7105340958,
0.414203167,
-0.9241011739,
0.227707997,
-0.4605144858,
-0.0810546651,
-0.2655523121,
-0.1813711226,
-0.5187731385,
-0.2054877579,
0.6496565342,
0.3383523226,
-0.352135092,
0.1361843944,
-0.1029159427,
-0.4681312442,
-0.069035612,
-0.3017422855,
0.6272411346,
-0.0205216929,
-0.2729926407,
0.2166170776,
-0.6696529388,
0.059721455,
0.0094825029,
0.0631631166,
-0.0541792251,
-0.3392321765,
-0.4821962416,
-0.0233973674,
-0.0021809249,
-0.7534624934,
0.4683319032,
-0.4168431759,
-0.0652387515,
0.7467182875,
0.3805554807,
0.3610386848,
-0.6026284695,
0.8429297805,
0.1513228863,
0.5308217406,
-0.4571124911,
-0.8414878249,
-0.3887209892,
-0.5663241744,
0.1390872747,
0.4653463662,
-0.6557711959,
-0.450889796,
-0.1143970266,
-0.5914009809,
-0.3643454313,
-0.0233529806,
0.5745220184,
0.8038592339,
0.3880362511,
-0.3909546435,
-0.5973182321,
-1.0280003548,
0.2638806701,
0.4801483452,
-0.0259166081,
0.4730543792,
0.4042737186,
-0.0003761031,
0.4599711895,
-0.6424224973,
-0.5898870826,
-0.0393845439,
0.0427245088,
0.103438288,
0.1088654622,
0.2553479373,
-0.2530947328,
-0.5354927778,
0.2411037236,
-0.7373267412,
0.0438167863,
-0.0270052906,
-0.3724348247,
-0.125839904,
0.4874148667,
-0.3096143901,
0.6530234218,
0.4019505382,
-0.2489661872,
0.6574794054,
-0.4927999973,
0.7098282576,
-1.0996717215,
-0.1958060712,
-0.109922573,
-0.2327123135,
-0.1628019661,
0.1408688128,
-0.0203778278,
-0.0809496865,
-0.0394769982,
0.0757922456,
-0.402441591,
-0.5077785254,
0.0116840368,
0.1884933114,
0.2311049849,
0.5022743344,
-0.2675650716,
0.9829365611,
0.7325392962,
-0.1781941056,
0.297991693,
0.4971402884,
-0.4741503298,
0.5893864036,
-0.1178797409,
0.1933358163,
-0.1237276793,
0.4754542708,
-0.8939656019,
-0.6095486283,
0.0192199517,
-0.2024788707,
0.3841016889,
-0.6197511554,
0.006041694,
-0.3000852168,
-0.4843248427,
0.1763201952,
0.6833559871,
-0.5550867915,
0.4393516779,
0.3293288052,
-0.0525406599,
-0.9091906548,
-0.2693906724,
0.0796099976,
-0.1788943708,
-0.6368895173,
0.2237497717,
-0.1708026379,
-0.1512304693,
-0.2753777802,
-0.0245159324,
-0.2764762938,
-0.3365196586,
0.4213632345,
0.0793680772,
-0.4809545279,
0.1826724112,
0.1645118445,
-0.0199966375,
-0.1203211695,
-0.0096164998,
0.2058534175,
-0.1421117336,
-0.7267721891,
-0.3432360291,
0.2958132327,
0.5730029345,
-0.3117180467,
0.414778322,
0.85841465,
-0.1829780787,
-0.1904748976,
-0.6702670455,
-0.1194175258,
-0.4412725568,
0.035090927,
-0.1298466623,
-0.4739337564,
0.5027857423,
-0.2645722926,
0.0529090911,
0.1180465221,
0.5719331503,
-0.5331701636,
0.8894835114,
0.3698887825,
0.1575578004,
0.3120932877,
-0.5255941749,
-0.3605846763,
-1.0321338177,
-0.1355587244,
-0.1771607399,
-0.3003356159,
-0.3746917546,
-0.8489978313,
0.7952311039,
-0.3002378047,
-0.4460357428,
-0.1638040245,
-0.7135745883,
0.9607254267,
0.4470149279,
0.7349911332,
0.042154517,
0.2396045923,
0.0708851069,
-0.3616479933,
-0.6287990212,
-0.282199949,
1.3205327988,
0.1410960257,
0.3591533303,
0.1508869976,
0.8062580824,
0.4307774007,
0.2409430891,
-0.4830110967,
0.363704443,
-0.3808357418,
-0.2631940544,
-0.393427223,
-0.240798831,
-1.1874829531,
-0.0097337104,
-0.0091485772,
-0.7535905838,
0.0482061692,
0.1098494753,
-0.2648199201,
0.5326833725,
-0.5824215412,
0.9162380099,
-0.0572461672,
-0.5410015583,
-0.3412772715,
-0.7513195872,
0.603279829,
0.4569629729,
0.5429614186,
0.0243499819,
-0.007870852,
0.5863018036,
-0.2989089191,
1.1306788921,
-0.4582039118,
-0.0008296545,
0.1830494255,
0.317293942,
0.4447299242,
0.0429476947,
0.1702331305,
-0.1889821291,
0.0915645137,
-0.6317486763,
-0.5651359558,
0.8532832265,
-0.7249222994,
-0.5090277195,
0.0631911829,
-0.5229697227,
-0.5337310433,
-0.0439055413,
0.4015620351,
1.0712991953,
0.0644004568,
-0.1098326594,
1.121199131,
-0.3800477087,
0.2231484503,
0.1003587693,
-0.0331505686,
-0.523825109,
1.2608821392,
-0.2293894887,
0.2210422605,
0.2207786143,
0.7274372578,
0.2825410664,
-0.576839745,
-0.9414840937,
0.0339392722,
-0.923509419,
-0.5246761441,
-0.3010835946,
-0.022086367,
0.0063314601,
-0.3719124496,
-0.3205674589,
-0.300152272,
-0.0455640219,
0.0081217056,
0.6767789125,
0.9942047,
-0.2315884829,
0.1699291766,
-0.665813446,
0.3856956959,
0.4005848467,
0.445805043,
-0.2581675053,
-0.6582050323,
-0.3366928995,
0.1083145365,
-0.1254737079,
-1.0004661083,
0.146154061,
0.4263264537,
0.4844268858,
0.3492806554,
-0.0404272191,
0.9660328031,
-0.2611485422,
0.7276099324,
0.0720924661,
-0.6419415474,
0.8710196614,
-0.598151803,
0.1978070438,
0.5277231932,
0.3908552527,
-0.2925314307,
-0.5393184423,
-0.5863253474,
-0.5364281535,
0.8519927859,
-0.0169126522,
-0.3032631874,
0.1681364328,
0.225201264,
0.5142383575,
-0.0734256431,
-0.4151377082,
0.0529915132,
-0.2664398849,
-0.2075544745,
0.0651020631,
-0.27362293,
-0.6526602507,
-0.4728153646,
0.4497822523,
-0.3556314111,
0.3576340377,
0.311416477,
-0.363239944,
-0.2485698014,
-0.1000435874,
0.637449801,
0.6514065862,
-0.1846575141,
-0.1424088329,
0.2965913117,
-0.5781810284,
-0.0690908432,
-0.4628812969,
0.2185602486,
-0.2435898632,
0.7737122178,
0.6519809365,
0.5414449573,
-0.4679606855,
0.9569805861,
-0.113279216,
-0.2259501219,
-0.1166942492,
0.1335768849,
0.011229706,
0.3358488381,
-0.1732478142,
0.3009668589,
0.363268882,
-0.1628073901,
0.3603156209,
0.2939104736,
-0.4950901866,
-0.1272230595,
0.2142311186,
0.0722796172,
-0.0156413149,
0.7863229513,
-0.0520771891,
-0.2454634458,
0.9434937835,
0.3249194324,
0.3905959427,
-0.1191648617,
0.6437708735,
0.7715597153,
0.2335654199,
0.1386459619,
0.2870053947,
-0.2288184017,
-0.2722339928,
-0.6253069043,
-0.4989646673,
-0.6608552933,
-0.0716448724,
-0.8696200252,
0.1273629814,
-0.4206476212,
0.2772935331,
-0.0023176726,
-0.0501881205,
-0.3959443271,
0.2360310853,
0.3926734626,
0.8859172463,
-0.7723665833,
0.6591476202,
0.3551743329,
-0.4514169395,
-0.6791703701,
0.0076039373,
-0.0211604554,
-0.9438734055,
0.2962159812,
0.1335920244,
0.0396800078,
-0.1695240587,
-0.7064639926,
-1.0040031672,
1.1562424898,
0.5224504471,
-0.4181533456,
0.1565012634,
-0.2210842371,
0.5906383395,
-0.4397339523,
0.6956973672,
0.4691829085,
0.4936068356,
0.3245581388,
-0.9142256379,
-0.0945440605,
-0.0472490937,
-0.4111342728,
0.2523506284,
-0.433032304,
0.636677444,
-0.8951445818,
-0.0964074731,
-0.0251392946,
-0.0104806842,
0.0004084771,
0.5614562631,
0.3116297722,
0.6719792485,
0.9239686131,
-0.0346695445,
1.4300633669,
-0.1449030936,
0.038434688,
0.7736246586,
0.194719702,
0.7245545983,
0.2033603638,
-0.2182376832,
1.0256294012,
0.6607840657,
0.096042946,
0.5824472904,
0.1265108883,
-0.197090283,
-0.598395586,
0.1121859774,
-0.5476886034,
0.6898866296,
0.5082219243,
-0.0856730863,
-0.3478783369,
0.4857253432,
-0.1914526522,
-0.0120729795,
-0.3692062795,
1.0594786406,
-0.508562386,
-0.3994840384,
0.7256878018,
-0.6146727204,
0.22136724,
-0.7999745011,
-0.3095456362,
-0.4778086543,
-0.0979829058,
-0.3746211827,
-0.7195801735,
0.267860204,
-0.1033420637,
-0.2315606177,
0.0715268031,
0.4794866741,
-0.2969558537,
-0.567281127,
-0.1627809703,
0.4719165862,
0.409763515,
0.1217807978,
-0.4699989557,
-0.0515362062,
0.3073403239,
-0.2385558039,
0.6809188128,
0.3642732799,
-0.413526237,
0.7507601976,
0.6159746647,
-0.0025835277,
-0.3475645483,
0.3465262055,
0.9887395501,
-0.5740793943,
-0.1480865628,
-0.4047274888,
0.5096282363,
-0.3753410876,
-0.3882508278,
0.4893619716,
0.3029429913,
0.4692787528,
-0.0735841915,
0.4958144128,
0.1755064726,
0.4598766863,
-0.4180343747,
0.3976245522,
-0.5746429563,
0.2130705863,
-0.3072451651,
-0.2916257679,
-0.0474921763,
0.450522393,
-0.3940339983,
-0.168445453,
0.7854839563,
0.7912395,
-0.1839885116,
0.0124441376,
0.3204800785,
0.2671412826,
0.0413936265,
0.5143332481,
0.9960441589,
-0.2338189185,
0.6291193962,
-0.7162797451,
-0.6223763227,
-0.0585241728,
-0.853743732,
-0.9717460275,
-0.5174040198,
-0.4604204595,
-0.2098580301,
0.2799991965,
0.5612211227,
0.7886814475,
-0.6685821414,
-0.1150187775,
0.183609128,
0.3098620772,
-0.200494647,
-0.1216160804,
0.5756636262,
-0.4439162612,
-0.3335293233,
0.6888218522,
0.4560816884,
-0.3113469183,
-0.232626155,
0.3315991759,
0.166298151,
-0.1091278195,
0.5892471075,
0.0488715358,
-0.4981217682,
-0.0747019798,
-0.1633602977,
-0.0352386869,
0.340274781,
0.9670632482,
-1.0297048092,
0.5634728074,
0.023382172,
0.3766288757,
0.6339451075,
-0.2533724606,
0.4354433119,
-0.9029405713,
-0.0074159326,
0.2624925673,
0.3088851869,
0.3199993074,
-0.7140783072,
0.3120562136,
0.1165872738,
-0.7289789319,
-0.9583184719,
0.340202868,
-1.0160883665,
-0.3691332936,
1.0553566217,
-0.0835064575,
-0.4036621153,
-0.116631873,
-0.6402424574,
-0.1627675444,
-0.1896429211,
0.7562851906,
0.1140746698,
-0.3003116846,
-0.3881683648,
-0.4209062755,
0.7330789566,
0.010756718,
-0.883762598,
0.1097767502,
0.5048125386,
0.4955512881,
-0.1487082988,
0.6492648125,
0.0737711117,
0.7517231703,
0.3769916594,
0.0583753623,
-0.3914265931,
-0.2209888995,
0.0223414749,
0.2281705886,
-0.1217655465,
-0.3107425272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04737v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04737v1
|
Efficient Large Language Models Fine-Tuning On Graphs
| 2023-12-07T22:35:16 | 2023-12-07T22:35:16 |
Rui Xue, Xipeng Shen, Ruozhou Yu, Xiaorui Liu
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Learning from Text-Attributed Graphs (TAGs) has attracted significant
attention due to its wide range of real-world applications. The rapid evolution
of large language models (LLMs) has revolutionized the way we process textual
data, which indicates a strong potential to replace shallow text embedding
generally used in Graph Neural Networks (GNNs). However, we find that existing
LLM approaches that exploit text information in graphs suffer from inferior
computation and data efficiency. In this work, we introduce a novel and
efficient approach for the end-to-end fine-tuning of Large Language Models
(LLMs) on TAGs, named LEADING. The proposed approach maintains computation cost
and memory overhead comparable to the graph-less fine-tuning of LLMs. Moreover,
it transfers the rick knowledge in LLMs to downstream graph learning tasks
effectively with limited labeled data in semi-supervised learning. Its superior
computation and data efficiency are demonstrated through comprehensive
experiments, offering a promising solution for a wide range of LLMs and graph
learning tasks on TAGs.
|
[
-0.0435427651,
-0.8303005099,
0.5328977704,
-0.1350077838,
-0.5284366012,
0.3903784752,
-0.6536688209,
-0.3317770958,
-0.045965828,
0.4655098319,
-0.4283232093,
-0.9169636965,
-0.7729197145,
0.034248881,
-0.0899866745,
1.0580877066,
0.1044577137,
-0.1323683411,
-0.0088898996,
0.075197503,
-0.2957832813,
-0.1611029655,
-1.130351305,
-0.4360774755,
0.8285399675,
0.3061439991,
0.6152001023,
0.9934699535,
0.2913277149,
0.2693428993,
-0.2292039245,
0.8090296984,
-0.9518330097,
-0.0321176201,
-0.4833516777,
-0.2263186276,
-0.4956903458,
-0.1266881078,
0.7667384148,
0.7550311685,
0.1640575081,
0.1328806877,
0.0217564125,
0.6007151604,
-0.2494655848,
0.414642334,
-0.917275548,
-0.3058781028,
-0.2350462228,
-0.3485617936,
-0.8728471994,
-0.4166197479,
-0.1487908363,
-0.617779851,
0.0612420551,
0.1862576157,
1.1086673737,
0.2928493023,
-0.2541102767,
-0.1918637305,
-0.5175952911,
0.7434775233,
-0.5354835987,
0.3972994089,
0.415400207,
0.1243418008,
-0.2072578073,
-0.8915513754,
-0.3149066567,
0.0814632103,
-0.0342346877,
-0.1250692308,
-0.481472671,
0.1919192821,
0.1762316823,
0.1411815882,
-0.4393004775,
0.5450921059,
-0.0780241862,
-0.0106957881,
0.6052336097,
-0.050200928,
0.3107829988,
0.0343753137,
-0.2022853792,
-0.0231343023,
-0.8103820086,
-0.2757713199,
0.3850327134,
0.9198921919,
-0.0498365425,
0.4518983066,
-0.2353325486,
1.0407176018,
-0.1361421049,
-0.0689580664,
0.2579697371,
-0.2137739062,
-0.3613398671,
-0.2613057494,
0.6652696729,
0.4356542528,
0.7322466373,
-0.4945628047,
-0.2357698083,
-0.1351655275,
-0.1281042695,
-0.9339225292,
-0.6592004895,
-0.2168647647,
-0.1734624803,
-0.0873794407,
-0.3652141988,
-0.3720622361,
-0.4314583242,
-0.3242973089,
0.2858022153,
-0.5133917928,
-0.028046634,
-0.0166207608,
-0.1493403018,
0.0472772866,
0.3850252926,
-0.7360454798,
0.0205454193,
0.7895649672,
1.0808050632,
0.0238299388,
-0.0017807561,
-0.8549422622,
0.3019092083,
-0.5694190264,
0.7104927897,
-0.8031011224,
-0.1685161293,
-0.2719355524,
0.1130077168,
-0.1126632318,
-0.3729643524,
0.4556515813,
-0.6548433304,
-0.3570032716,
0.086123839,
-0.7342311144,
-0.1498054862,
0.1689627916,
-0.3862695694,
0.9910151958,
0.0120430971,
-0.7679083347,
0.0732771009,
-0.150061965,
-0.9228618145,
0.1062798724,
0.0074690487,
-0.6031191945,
0.0180326998,
0.4165210426,
0.8979099989,
-0.3402733207,
0.1639075428,
-0.2410656512,
-0.36032179,
-0.096573256,
-0.0719753578,
0.6047862768,
-0.057785552,
0.1778592616,
0.3965793252,
-0.7715390325,
0.1330591142,
0.2785414457,
-0.3097882271,
-0.7332423329,
0.1965851337,
-0.1718183458,
0.0047261901,
0.2213131934,
-0.6239210367,
0.4031263888,
-0.4979670644,
0.5331559181,
1.1230812073,
-0.0059019388,
0.3447508812,
-0.2218505889,
0.1640416086,
-0.4533340931,
-0.1178530976,
-0.1824169904,
-0.588435173,
-0.5695863962,
-0.52876544,
0.5233706236,
0.3376708925,
-0.8523837924,
0.421138078,
-0.5780185461,
-0.75740242,
-0.2388579696,
0.1860392392,
0.4568833709,
0.6334013343,
0.3747146428,
-0.0096603381,
-0.3579724133,
-0.6612612605,
-0.3863177896,
0.0710765272,
0.0655890629,
0.6542800069,
0.1541230232,
-0.2392414957,
0.6650281549,
-0.846111238,
-0.4233073592,
-0.4526705146,
-0.0106829172,
0.3778437674,
0.4093572497,
0.2413150072,
-0.4984436035,
-0.8808090091,
0.3856306076,
-0.2757809162,
-0.2834797204,
-0.2003130615,
-0.2970065176,
0.0855330527,
0.7027208209,
-0.4440563917,
0.0384180881,
0.6405272484,
-0.2412672192,
0.1994480491,
-0.2368209362,
-0.3916466236,
-0.9925657511,
-0.0831183717,
0.180631578,
-0.6072835326,
-0.4797146022,
-0.0622174144,
0.236136198,
0.0046429592,
-0.0055525727,
0.5273768902,
-0.850079298,
0.1072141081,
-0.2047701776,
0.2968714833,
-0.135651648,
0.5634265542,
-0.2381635904,
0.8365671635,
0.9038414955,
-0.5928159356,
0.2162978053,
0.2329421788,
-0.1403639466,
0.1502943188,
-0.4937206209,
0.2776565254,
-0.3936421573,
0.1776687503,
-1.1809492111,
-0.0306148399,
0.0452823192,
-0.5673037171,
0.7216175199,
-0.6016834378,
-0.7604843974,
-0.1784448624,
-0.1647032052,
0.0443966053,
0.6660875082,
-0.6773712039,
0.5369741321,
0.5087082386,
-0.3037659824,
-0.2509258091,
-0.4254529476,
0.1975242198,
0.0114896419,
-0.3790647089,
0.3963550627,
0.1132486761,
0.3070189953,
-0.1982370615,
0.0071670241,
0.1217991337,
0.1209781021,
-0.0367018692,
0.0529114902,
0.0027386367,
0.5056657791,
0.2239474356,
-0.3555491269,
-0.2758607566,
-0.5102685094,
0.7915483713,
0.2254984081,
0.0825895369,
-0.4686348438,
0.0741952732,
0.4039152861,
-0.625180006,
0.7074455619,
0.3937853873,
-0.480040133,
-0.7567279339,
0.0225292388,
0.1077859849,
-0.4772933125,
0.6652886868,
-0.3302733302,
-0.8994091153,
0.4362911582,
-0.6168014407,
-0.002056713,
0.2946721911,
0.4800178111,
0.1184018776,
1.2046918869,
0.8560014963,
-0.1155166775,
0.6942508817,
-0.2583938539,
0.5046215057,
-0.9143528938,
-0.0723270923,
-0.5812975168,
-0.2953757346,
-0.6177861094,
-0.7694259882,
0.1433013827,
0.207694903,
-0.2688108683,
0.3096333146,
-0.6086724401,
0.6797692776,
0.1422557682,
0.2405864745,
0.4912889898,
0.1107875779,
-0.1460833102,
0.124263525,
-0.5616081953,
-0.2763586938,
1.1352477074,
0.3388401568,
1.1109623909,
-0.0085304342,
0.6161086559,
0.0994441584,
0.4264146686,
-0.763841629,
0.6509924531,
-0.6212934256,
0.0454732515,
-0.4497815371,
-0.5858258009,
-0.8613963127,
0.0710168779,
-0.0382116698,
-0.8488584161,
-0.3039934337,
0.1355941147,
-0.0327610485,
0.5690362453,
-0.6363937855,
0.6347330213,
0.1207781136,
-0.3398997188,
-0.1621204019,
-0.5356704593,
-0.0577133335,
-0.1028619707,
0.246372059,
-0.4614562988,
-0.0837005898,
0.8150083423,
-0.2319862992,
0.959708333,
-0.2117601186,
-0.3164488375,
0.0424505137,
-0.1139614359,
1.0819735527,
0.0697677657,
-0.0985138714,
0.0117030488,
-0.7787983418,
-0.1845928282,
-0.4620915353,
0.8547633886,
-0.5894115567,
-0.2502340376,
-0.037467394,
-0.6240537167,
-0.3318753242,
0.5470086336,
0.0605210327,
0.5898680091,
0.0915618762,
0.0030199096,
0.7825158238,
-0.2661033571,
0.3228802383,
0.2881656289,
-0.3228934109,
-0.3244548738,
1.1594127417,
0.2744311094,
0.4226360023,
0.5337699652,
0.2130711526,
-0.1473926753,
-0.9745008945,
-0.6101008654,
0.5215696096,
-0.6745277047,
-0.6630478501,
-0.8718741536,
-0.0760312155,
-0.2710530162,
-0.1734959483,
-0.4963558316,
-0.3236336708,
-0.4389265478,
-0.2411743253,
0.7137743831,
0.5353394151,
0.1346482486,
0.4769451618,
-0.4801111519,
0.2530528903,
0.0653705224,
0.7230737805,
0.2180846483,
-0.4213475883,
-0.4815523326,
-0.0736260712,
-0.0314370319,
-0.6777727604,
0.1924043298,
0.5542298555,
0.3946327865,
0.1334068924,
0.0557295643,
0.806679368,
-0.7489078641,
0.3230835497,
-0.0165949073,
-0.9029899836,
0.35108459,
-0.5044781566,
0.0833475515,
0.22611022,
0.335983634,
-0.3895817101,
-0.4633139074,
-0.2230020314,
-1.0641958714,
0.5741564631,
-0.0233943388,
0.3297559917,
-0.1677770615,
0.3171107769,
0.0029650603,
-0.0798119605,
-0.5063168406,
-0.2709508836,
0.3722231388,
-0.2609587908,
-0.3392151892,
0.1430113316,
0.0109970914,
-0.6119796038,
0.9585271478,
-0.5646293163,
0.0443501286,
0.0160260852,
-0.1900665313,
-0.1166698262,
0.0862911567,
0.0624299981,
0.6109111309,
0.0880225822,
0.2796604037,
0.3081128895,
-0.1465429962,
-0.1969392449,
0.2413993478,
-0.2549701929,
-0.0265911948,
0.2365155369,
0.8408740163,
0.2315001935,
-0.5978480577,
0.4515742958,
0.0971631557,
0.2990133762,
0.1864548624,
-0.0189237762,
0.4409886301,
0.1831015348,
0.3398608863,
-0.1819211394,
-0.1822495311,
-0.4264115095,
0.3618244231,
0.6570544243,
-0.3941827714,
-0.1277546138,
0.4807783067,
0.0733769685,
-0.2892415226,
0.5727567673,
-0.1941112727,
-0.5440203547,
0.4609791338,
0.8924019337,
0.6247029901,
-0.0499412529,
0.2071867436,
0.394097358,
0.2053718269,
0.2540286779,
0.3026540875,
0.0256948266,
-0.5967819691,
-0.6274172068,
-0.7412009239,
-0.2209327072,
-0.2746188641,
-0.3500033319,
0.3229303956,
-0.6922230721,
-0.1630018055,
0.3251280189,
-0.0780953765,
-0.480509311,
0.2477426678,
0.2378964722,
0.9836808443,
-0.7579330802,
1.010228157,
0.7392839789,
0.0530085154,
-0.9693385363,
-0.1821392179,
-0.6710244417,
-0.9594809413,
0.3762718141,
0.273634702,
-0.2565734982,
0.7808905244,
-0.7311412096,
-0.8081851602,
0.9074866176,
0.38005355,
-0.6497522593,
-0.1149800047,
-0.266030103,
0.4879426062,
-0.1907383651,
0.1071915254,
0.4403670132,
0.3612049222,
0.1506932229,
-0.7761563063,
0.2894784808,
-0.1173689514,
0.1359188706,
0.6820438504,
-0.8425240517,
0.9051795006,
-0.4595829844,
-0.5338979363,
-0.0493089072,
0.7274007201,
-0.0520556606,
-0.012958141,
0.2291485965,
0.6329013705,
1.1862134933,
-0.1237812042,
0.9544721842,
-0.194755286,
0.7641989589,
1.0368243456,
-0.2001007199,
0.7285889387,
0.2803331316,
-0.0703193173,
0.4701592922,
0.5914614797,
-0.0813569799,
0.6252390146,
0.4892780781,
0.0553385727,
-0.5598457456,
-0.1750781387,
-0.1385211796,
0.3089765608,
0.3820267022,
-0.5009952784,
-0.5654022098,
-0.1335403472,
0.3767015338,
0.1803984046,
-0.5524998903,
0.8408512473,
0.083415024,
-0.2992471159,
0.7272112966,
0.3990873694,
0.6183541417,
-0.6240162849,
-0.0560597107,
0.0200687069,
0.3306129575,
-0.2149803787,
-0.8372786641,
0.1514355838,
0.1218367293,
-0.1460439414,
-0.4072690606,
0.8224691153,
-0.4236110449,
-0.5141534209,
0.4429186285,
0.2834285796,
0.0246624481,
-0.0175622087,
-0.3418703973,
0.0242354758,
0.0589253567,
-0.1688019037,
0.2612636983,
0.456782341,
-0.1370272636,
0.7731005549,
0.8394958377,
0.2322056741,
0.1382395625,
0.0564134568,
1.192688942,
-0.6010631323,
-0.754966855,
-1.0829840899,
0.3455034494,
-0.2180821747,
-0.3055817485,
0.7942243218,
0.7403411269,
0.8462635279,
0.1994926929,
0.7787722945,
0.1177747697,
0.5064746737,
-0.6464054585,
1.0107572079,
-0.4301892221,
-0.0710942671,
-0.4250858724,
-0.7858111858,
-0.6016282439,
0.5746397376,
-0.2158276588,
-0.1082154214,
0.3719642162,
0.7073339224,
-0.1224102899,
-0.0845509171,
0.1971523762,
0.5383309722,
0.5020726919,
0.7710434794,
0.3240167499,
-0.3096027374,
0.27697438,
-0.0030659409,
-0.4586846828,
0.0778691694,
-0.9236708879,
-1.2377561331,
-0.4553180039,
-0.3303564191,
-0.1140595526,
0.2646381259,
0.7501448989,
0.5986739397,
-0.4684070051,
0.1979064196,
-0.1730732173,
0.3897557557,
-0.0547842346,
-0.1235514805,
0.6468430758,
-0.3252730072,
-0.882755518,
0.3545669317,
0.3537657559,
-0.0432430208,
0.140015319,
-0.0574837886,
-0.344941169,
0.1366442889,
0.6223701239,
0.0161723383,
-0.3362166584,
-0.572632134,
-0.1823854297,
-0.1287587434,
0.1996266544,
0.5673429966,
-0.7676135898,
0.3161500394,
0.6167132258,
0.8644526005,
0.5618132353,
0.1555634886,
0.4331198037,
-0.9121829271,
-0.1100986004,
0.1318723857,
0.2534335554,
0.6601971984,
-0.3433752954,
0.4037929177,
0.1878566891,
-0.4130156636,
-1.0260998011,
0.381611973,
-1.0164805651,
-0.2241148651,
1.2053240538,
-0.2334076166,
-0.1752434969,
0.1275078803,
-0.1365449727,
0.7556883693,
-0.2271131873,
0.264526993,
0.2980880141,
-0.0320453867,
-0.0993471295,
-0.3632131219,
0.3929464519,
0.0308154821,
-0.6879380941,
0.5580749512,
0.2852930427,
0.3743489087,
-0.1904954314,
0.5643225312,
0.1175974756,
-0.2531048357,
-0.3445689678,
-0.1417633891,
-0.3809587359,
-0.5614544153,
-0.1558925807,
0.0549839698,
0.0859246328,
-0.1373663396
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04736v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04736v1
|
Is Feedback All You Need? Leveraging Natural Language Feedback in Goal-Conditioned Reinforcement Learning
| 2023-12-07T22:33:34 | 2023-12-07T22:33:34 |
Sabrina McCallum, Max Taylor-Davies, Stefano V. Albrecht, Alessandro Suglia
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite numerous successes, the field of reinforcement learning (RL) remains
far from matching the impressive generalisation power of human behaviour
learning. One possible way to help bridge this gap be to provide RL agents with
richer, more human-like feedback expressed in natural language. To investigate
this idea, we first extend BabyAI to automatically generate language feedback
from the environment dynamics and goal condition success. Then, we modify the
Decision Transformer architecture to take advantage of this additional signal.
We find that training with language feedback either in place of or in addition
to the return-to-go or goal descriptions improves agents' generalisation
performance, and that agents can benefit from feedback even when this is only
available during training, but not at inference.
|
[
-0.2382639349,
-0.5020288825,
0.2947415709,
0.2277348191,
-0.0421222299,
0.2040139586,
-0.6080337167,
-0.4130802751,
0.2417740226,
0.5066110492,
-0.7888534665,
-0.1690532416,
-0.5093297362,
0.0832121894,
0.2230179906,
1.431172967,
0.1437208802,
0.0517230853,
0.0299953613,
0.0986555144,
-0.5633633733,
-0.4202376008,
-1.1228784323,
-0.8764612079,
0.7514594793,
0.5532561541,
0.3699170053,
0.2055808902,
0.1883138567,
0.3246222436,
0.1248566881,
0.3222651482,
-0.3821067214,
0.1939599067,
-0.2038859129,
-0.5321877003,
-0.1450146884,
0.0802115351,
0.6175405979,
0.5387486219,
-0.3554071784,
-0.0715629682,
0.2887945473,
0.8621844649,
-0.6240800023,
0.6153233647,
-0.0748690218,
0.4011718929,
0.5450929999,
-0.1004339308,
-0.4471180737,
-0.5033961535,
0.2024157792,
-0.7771092057,
0.1175942346,
-0.1154995337,
0.8778530359,
0.5627173781,
-0.3716136813,
-0.3615790606,
-1.3240026236,
0.7754717469,
-0.4835807085,
0.5446615815,
0.35858199,
0.5235537887,
-0.2330601364,
-0.4745366573,
-0.4363023341,
-0.8160426021,
-0.4123758972,
0.4049779475,
0.2341968566,
0.3315817118,
0.2537848651,
-0.0215151515,
-0.1281737238,
-0.1688990295,
-0.3582975864,
-0.403228581,
0.8103376627,
-0.1790521294,
-0.0207511,
0.0603276081,
-0.1269421875,
-0.595833838,
-0.3935912848,
0.4722015858,
0.3280666173,
0.4354196787,
-0.0636782423,
0.1146322489,
-0.283701241,
0.7241539955,
0.1394156069,
-0.1769406646,
0.0453146733,
-0.302053988,
0.0979683325,
-0.0715068579,
0.7873258591,
0.2923409045,
0.3117293715,
-0.6926910281,
-0.5004705787,
0.1621390283,
0.5467002988,
-0.6647518277,
-0.1626254171,
-0.1032741144,
-0.1378291696,
-0.1667080671,
0.4880393147,
-0.800122261,
-0.2413554192,
-0.5097796917,
0.2174109071,
-0.3621530533,
-0.4491057396,
0.0116813313,
-0.3851065338,
0.6734713316,
0.155012548,
-1.1385333538,
0.4442890584,
0.6829323769,
0.428817749,
0.0626061037,
-0.3661544323,
-0.9558442831,
0.1138297468,
-0.5299372077,
0.8666900992,
-0.5109013319,
-0.5647153854,
0.1165537909,
-0.0188722275,
-0.235975489,
-0.6027631164,
0.5178096294,
-0.4082297087,
0.3032741845,
-0.1172636375,
-0.221855849,
-0.1497637779,
0.4837602079,
-0.5111327767,
0.6763765216,
0.1383786649,
-0.0306062121,
0.6916934848,
-0.8811318278,
-0.9102377295,
0.0208705794,
-0.0404373854,
-0.4126512408,
0.0046481956,
0.0765137821,
0.092967473,
0.1343768239,
0.3850055635,
0.0807914808,
-0.1423439831,
0.3284293413,
-0.2952969372,
-0.0427400954,
0.2736512721,
-0.4452955425,
0.3566742837,
-0.6698082685,
0.2736801803,
-0.0842176005,
-0.9232407808,
0.0626621395,
-0.0359570272,
-0.0384385251,
0.1015196219,
0.0872944817,
-0.5735218525,
0.3807365894,
-0.5869606733,
0.3728590906,
0.3869074881,
0.2043335289,
0.5857561231,
-0.4784062505,
0.7571764588,
-0.1996070743,
0.209262684,
0.1260263175,
-0.3871533573,
-0.7654482722,
0.0575570874,
0.3694511056,
0.3716788888,
-0.7633380294,
0.292085886,
-0.1932086647,
-0.1038131267,
-0.7377821803,
0.3768494725,
0.7394866347,
0.3334651589,
0.1840753704,
-0.4236801863,
-0.8380000591,
-0.7153107524,
-0.212215215,
-0.4804646969,
-0.2523927987,
0.1146825254,
0.3913794458,
-0.2736520767,
1.0033127069,
-0.3528270721,
-0.5436529517,
-0.797514677,
0.1087807268,
0.1601801366,
0.2531625032,
0.1675428003,
-0.8008880615,
-0.2661411166,
0.0475737229,
-0.5241503716,
0.1223789006,
-0.4040800035,
-0.0416687354,
0.05851987,
0.3377577364,
-0.5945468545,
0.1569123119,
0.3091409206,
-0.3299833238,
0.4531736076,
-0.4557994306,
0.1508700103,
-0.5720618963,
0.0423193984,
0.0807202682,
-0.5003039241,
-0.8201979995,
0.0226916783,
-0.1136109382,
0.1310350895,
-0.3585999906,
0.448387295,
-0.1141947359,
0.0039428095,
-0.4866968095,
0.2579348087,
0.0241009034,
0.8641294241,
0.3629383147,
0.5869609118,
0.362526536,
-1.1215010881,
0.4828121066,
0.3443844616,
0.1077434719,
0.566247344,
-0.6667402983,
0.0439463295,
-0.3112018406,
0.5130911469,
-0.6478712559,
-0.4510785043,
0.5855345726,
-0.7022602558,
0.4242051244,
-0.0231977161,
0.1322559267,
-0.559586823,
-0.3094869256,
-0.2279424667,
0.5148510337,
-0.4631757438,
0.6869097352,
0.172908321,
0.2911671102,
-0.4449931681,
-0.6525483131,
0.0043846574,
0.1241231114,
0.0898941308,
0.1629070789,
-0.1916019469,
-0.1568435729,
0.08796148,
0.0393215157,
0.0595071018,
0.2152064443,
0.3813145757,
0.0580024607,
0.1668263674,
0.1709941775,
-0.3430930674,
-0.3582924902,
0.2099873424,
-0.598212719,
0.3921239674,
-0.2572660148,
-0.2019712031,
-0.4030653834,
0.1671992242,
0.3151221573,
-0.1511047035,
0.4422520697,
0.4224161804,
-0.1059072837,
-0.3986144066,
-0.0208586901,
-0.3953253329,
-0.4465805888,
0.3356399536,
-0.2238404006,
-0.6901437044,
-0.0000249483,
-0.0301121771,
0.3634230196,
0.3028635085,
0.4762636423,
-0.1324425042,
1.0290434361,
0.8554108143,
-0.1477451026,
0.5643542409,
-0.4851906002,
0.2855923474,
-0.7953366041,
-0.6312277913,
-0.3146124482,
-0.3654050231,
-0.4082283974,
-0.0190954581,
-0.0176036265,
-0.0734520033,
-0.2439427823,
0.2266006917,
-0.5684838891,
0.3896328211,
0.7187883854,
0.3179602325,
0.210002467,
-0.4022554755,
-0.0216678642,
0.0946887955,
-0.8204133511,
-0.2808141708,
0.7341783047,
0.1646226496,
0.6726822257,
-0.043885015,
0.9302024841,
0.3576548994,
0.7011418343,
-1.1175390482,
0.3844444454,
0.297819227,
-0.3707613945,
-0.3435663581,
-0.476141572,
-1.1504704952,
0.1927827001,
-0.061547298,
-0.3766802549,
-0.1933783144,
0.3184145689,
-0.7196149826,
0.0719754249,
-0.6093864441,
0.6046090126,
-0.3508256376,
-0.1836757809,
-0.3747545481,
-0.5825806856,
0.1192966625,
0.2998874784,
0.3594318628,
0.1440828294,
0.0559145883,
0.83021456,
-0.5424996614,
1.0184073448,
-0.4934870005,
-0.1585075706,
0.3606937528,
-0.2057436705,
0.3500153422,
0.0216754675,
0.2013719082,
-0.6336414218,
-0.3090242445,
-0.3906276524,
-0.9543150067,
0.5171667933,
-0.9129042029,
-0.6428709626,
-0.4143265188,
-0.2290317565,
-0.5728068352,
0.0535912327,
0.0628404766,
0.1629382074,
-0.2984343767,
-0.1604437381,
0.4782011211,
0.0929412991,
0.5607203245,
0.7852190137,
-0.3630771637,
-0.4261800349,
1.014103651,
-0.3288669586,
0.1593058854,
0.4069144428,
0.2419828326,
-0.5960507393,
-0.1514998823,
-0.6122903228,
0.2984098196,
-0.6322584748,
-0.0585788116,
-0.3182906508,
-0.3426751792,
-0.4044062495,
-0.0455767512,
-0.3592981994,
-0.1475527138,
0.0683392361,
-0.3430641294,
0.2007827312,
1.3002015352,
-0.4779588282,
0.4435142577,
-0.7245073915,
0.4258824885,
0.7610149384,
0.5545164347,
0.1178582609,
-0.3475539088,
-0.3817877471,
0.2373788804,
-0.3276672661,
-0.8338484168,
0.3742820024,
0.5404840708,
0.5956263542,
0.3625974059,
0.0040188064,
0.3555660844,
-0.2659493983,
0.8356931806,
0.2123818994,
-0.4830959439,
0.840441227,
0.041347757,
0.354534775,
0.5915572047,
0.1873231828,
-0.845181942,
-0.3682708144,
-0.4791238606,
-0.654376924,
0.7124090195,
-0.1403890103,
0.1551389694,
0.0166192874,
0.4403935969,
-0.0655701607,
0.3258419931,
-0.7833063006,
0.0484918728,
-0.4302301407,
-0.0280251466,
-0.15032731,
0.1391617805,
-0.2481056452,
-0.3060514331,
0.8956070542,
-0.3530666828,
0.2704150975,
0.2826718092,
-0.2082196474,
-0.2971704006,
0.5434932113,
0.2859016061,
0.3524675667,
0.0966456607,
-0.1183950454,
0.2822334468,
-0.2544973493,
0.385763377,
-0.2019340396,
-0.1566478461,
-0.0736426488,
0.4503507316,
1.0165811777,
0.4278521538,
-0.7420535684,
0.3601245284,
-0.5123697519,
-0.4591344595,
-0.2097928822,
0.455702275,
-0.1885159314,
0.1958867759,
0.2448111027,
0.1110126153,
-0.0936606154,
-0.724052906,
0.4377338588,
0.364248395,
-0.8583799005,
-0.359900713,
0.5542488098,
0.3834683001,
-0.7259927392,
0.6539994478,
-0.3739024699,
-0.8564566374,
0.4621988535,
0.5389785767,
1.0147907734,
-0.0381205678,
0.84891361,
0.4521586597,
0.1162764877,
-0.0155235427,
0.2523849308,
-0.5662179589,
-0.52943331,
-0.8641880155,
-0.7881444097,
-0.8055548072,
-0.0700226948,
-0.6705457568,
0.0412716679,
-0.6283553839,
-0.0203808658,
-0.3293381035,
-0.0076054242,
-0.7919306159,
0.2571983933,
0.4097911716,
0.4941833019,
-0.7234743237,
0.757134378,
0.9591007829,
-0.6486741304,
-1.0149053335,
0.046920307,
-0.3698081672,
-0.6181439757,
0.7959231138,
0.351270169,
-0.4041899741,
-0.0589319393,
-0.5035121441,
-0.4784341156,
0.7046404481,
0.1745260805,
-0.56673491,
-0.1953203976,
0.2923356593,
0.8116139174,
-0.1832089424,
0.5662987828,
0.9966825247,
0.7808304429,
0.1544502228,
-0.6532546878,
-0.2392760366,
-0.2505876124,
0.0809225962,
0.1800517738,
-0.6833591461,
0.088326849,
-0.380848527,
-0.2366071045,
-0.2031494379,
0.9185028076,
-0.0352396294,
0.0379960649,
0.6908240318,
0.560392797,
0.710267663,
-0.2281952351,
1.3618255854,
-0.3118638992,
0.2410017401,
0.8658359647,
0.1487606317,
0.6260684133,
0.2610350251,
-0.1877163947,
0.6763646603,
0.7036270499,
0.2538096607,
0.6990135908,
0.3347228169,
-0.2682667673,
-0.4311894476,
-0.3126531243,
0.015974598,
0.1553422511,
0.3420075178,
0.0626030788,
-0.1808380038,
0.3222184181,
-0.1720349938,
0.1956832409,
-0.3108942807,
1.2099153996,
0.0419468321,
-1.2337474823,
0.5897575021,
-0.2809818685,
0.9006073475,
-0.8082023859,
-0.2990515232,
-0.3440358043,
0.3220054507,
-0.2276760787,
-0.6135555506,
0.3827417493,
-0.1473055631,
-0.0891499743,
-0.4823244214,
0.4847940803,
-0.5959008336,
-0.0936347693,
0.5243806839,
0.3258028328,
-0.0096529229,
0.1982917786,
-0.5199788809,
-0.3384413123,
0.0136050731,
-0.2236727476,
0.2871402204,
0.0309464857,
0.2541487813,
0.9040824175,
0.6037425995,
0.4282288551,
-0.0545722991,
0.2422990203,
0.7605580688,
-0.6788614988,
-0.6709634662,
-0.7017347813,
0.3064593971,
-0.1209807023,
-0.355550766,
0.4371153414,
0.0610847138,
0.8007264137,
-0.1882807165,
1.1458400488,
-0.2263284624,
0.3586276174,
-0.3851668239,
0.4006294608,
-0.2665235698,
0.1035702154,
0.2832731307,
-0.8294955492,
-0.2637941837,
0.5286762714,
-0.2451324016,
-0.0731122941,
0.5685102344,
0.6467057467,
0.2860008478,
-0.0509430878,
0.2922468483,
-0.0135841314,
0.5449787378,
0.7416887283,
1.1472975016,
-0.1375950724,
0.8061491251,
-0.112522535,
-0.1875464916,
-0.1706244648,
-0.4727520049,
-0.7024503946,
-0.4206195772,
-0.4514075518,
-0.4172892869,
0.5352994204,
1.1276493073,
0.7893059254,
-1.0146436691,
-0.1673074812,
-0.1895276606,
0.3354445994,
-0.4541591704,
-0.1958605796,
-0.126133576,
-0.9051750302,
-0.6811876893,
0.6330622435,
0.0815198421,
-0.2339652926,
-0.4296421707,
-0.7512028813,
0.0982084796,
-0.100422658,
0.4812463224,
0.8325428963,
-0.4430335164,
-0.3906371593,
-0.3094340563,
0.0500513688,
0.1627912074,
1.0207281113,
-1.0559639931,
0.2478796691,
0.233271569,
0.7648150325,
0.4441298842,
-0.198019594,
0.8509076238,
-0.8342811465,
0.1277034879,
0.2572511435,
0.161363408,
0.4534653127,
-0.1565794647,
0.4553844035,
0.1062751338,
-0.5985090733,
-0.1240845621,
0.4744670093,
-0.4447766244,
-0.0388641059,
1.2884607315,
-0.1122544706,
-0.5406086445,
-0.0332106017,
-0.5456514955,
0.4581840336,
-0.7002624869,
0.7702185512,
0.5087046623,
-0.2996714115,
-0.1157655343,
-0.4219899476,
0.891291976,
0.4912134111,
-0.8108451962,
-0.1383805573,
0.3694477677,
0.025608588,
0.2178788781,
0.5237768888,
0.3876038492,
0.3410449028,
-0.2443199903,
0.1406135559,
0.1381825507,
-0.5599150658,
-0.4629300833,
0.0181641243,
0.5197758079,
-0.3747060895
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04720v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04720v1
|
From Big to Small Without Losing It All: Text Augmentation with ChatGPT for Efficient Sentiment Analysis
| 2023-12-07T21:58:37 | 2023-12-07T21:58:37 |
Stanisław Woźniak, Jan Kocoń
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In the era of artificial intelligence, data is gold but costly to annotate.
The paper demonstrates a groundbreaking solution to this dilemma using ChatGPT
for text augmentation in sentiment analysis. We leverage ChatGPT's generative
capabilities to create synthetic training data that significantly improves the
performance of smaller models, making them competitive with, or even
outperforming, their larger counterparts. This innovation enables models to be
both efficient and effective, thereby reducing computational cost, inference
time, and memory usage without compromising on quality. Our work marks a key
advancement in the cost-effective development and deployment of robust
sentiment analysis models.
|
[
-0.3587082028,
-0.7914309502,
0.4690493047,
0.2145725787,
-0.3241945505,
0.0630571991,
-0.3809289932,
-0.4729365706,
0.1282180101,
0.2493778765,
-0.7052573562,
-0.1413660944,
-0.7646410465,
-0.0945669785,
-0.1154164076,
1.4304056168,
0.3381380439,
0.0084664933,
-0.1584090292,
-0.3088076711,
-0.3212068975,
-0.7260259986,
-0.8140537739,
-0.2263609022,
0.4414759874,
0.453378737,
1.066752553,
0.5178477168,
0.7983864546,
0.2401839942,
-0.09411899,
0.3992591202,
-0.5382959247,
-0.2296085805,
0.0236704405,
-0.520323813,
-0.5764026046,
0.1324829012,
0.5751911402,
0.8053939939,
0.0878219381,
0.0754918233,
0.1522271186,
1.0035336018,
-0.4297600687,
0.467236191,
-0.6991149783,
0.2449661344,
-0.121354714,
-0.0405858085,
-0.2527648807,
-0.5089905858,
0.2456045151,
-0.5789187551,
0.3456619084,
0.1390268952,
0.6699711084,
0.5048242211,
-0.1862011254,
-0.2658451498,
-0.786311388,
0.800579071,
-0.599443078,
0.0803600624,
-0.1215116456,
0.1446267515,
0.0857958868,
-0.9407639503,
-0.735112071,
-0.2097651213,
-0.1747501642,
0.2950677872,
-0.3090735078,
0.1650562882,
0.2647373378,
0.7036550641,
-0.513610065,
-0.3227384984,
-0.1823515147,
-0.073823981,
0.7822708488,
0.1115224957,
0.404689163,
-0.1850594282,
-0.0923348963,
-0.360412389,
-0.6436365843,
-0.3041022718,
0.3812338114,
0.4938895106,
-0.056562461,
0.7156543136,
-0.0928703919,
0.4177406132,
-0.0288567133,
0.129980281,
0.3119235933,
-0.3843480051,
-0.3442950845,
0.1043031439,
1.0585927963,
0.3634852469,
0.2244583815,
-0.0815570429,
-0.0076597761,
0.3029939532,
0.2826222181,
-0.9893479347,
-0.6619554758,
0.0057290983,
-0.5680938959,
-0.631020844,
0.0345111676,
-0.9996395707,
-0.6902353764,
-0.1828623712,
0.479844451,
-0.5113844872,
-0.1367111504,
0.0363452733,
-0.3134052753,
0.1364239901,
0.3351334333,
-1.0273097754,
0.0280269906,
0.8540586829,
1.1243815422,
0.1519556791,
0.0617541745,
-0.3285256326,
-0.3630001843,
-0.6200432181,
0.8342080712,
-0.4761116505,
-0.5982583165,
-0.1842695326,
-0.1928628832,
-0.071638748,
-0.4650432765,
0.6758978367,
-0.226508975,
0.300684154,
-0.0835748538,
-0.4701249599,
-0.1710015386,
0.3706038892,
-0.7761031389,
1.0143250227,
0.2765795887,
-0.988704145,
0.285707444,
-0.8788850307,
-0.4764848053,
-0.0279324483,
0.0939980447,
-0.7029727101,
0.3116508722,
0.4289969206,
0.2997377217,
-0.2810147405,
-0.2180827856,
-0.3053866625,
-0.1746742278,
0.4708461165,
-0.5990517139,
0.4956842959,
0.2254258394,
-0.135175854,
-0.0306032766,
-0.651700139,
-0.044862885,
-0.0044571455,
-0.3509868681,
-0.2113126814,
0.0594696216,
0.2395922989,
0.0467865206,
0.23833552,
-0.6146978736,
0.4462533295,
-0.8380440474,
0.6643582582,
0.6164281964,
0.119356975,
0.7830424309,
-0.1888715476,
0.4470552802,
-0.1384409368,
0.3066391647,
-0.1693912148,
-0.5668913722,
-0.8771984577,
-0.3673430085,
0.588003397,
0.5669711828,
-0.7447561026,
0.3634832501,
-0.7298412323,
-0.6738333702,
-0.7243489623,
0.1735595614,
-0.1808376163,
0.2237523496,
0.2168707252,
-0.2663995624,
-0.7092766762,
-0.81514889,
-0.3856212199,
-0.2882803679,
-0.1835356951,
0.0740355402,
0.4001218677,
-0.3928050995,
1.1271531582,
-0.5284757018,
-0.4111529887,
-0.5457370877,
0.2228673398,
-0.0807635859,
0.5617527962,
0.4040584564,
-0.8553214073,
-0.5687690973,
0.2517725527,
-0.6002175808,
0.1457493454,
-0.3973031044,
-0.1631276459,
0.0008928634,
0.2600308359,
-0.9786987305,
0.3407502472,
0.5271770954,
-0.1487942189,
0.1951588541,
-0.090744704,
-0.024413662,
-1.0616103411,
-0.0624352694,
0.0366632752,
-0.238791585,
-0.5248568654,
-0.1931230575,
0.0354966782,
-0.4291902184,
-0.005904342,
0.4948521256,
-0.1275282651,
0.2298828065,
-0.4104869366,
0.179973051,
0.1669568866,
0.3309501708,
-0.1885601878,
0.925925374,
0.1842494458,
-0.0936936811,
0.4875223637,
0.3518183231,
-0.0899670199,
0.5288880467,
-0.7136928439,
-0.0100416159,
-0.3245897591,
0.4186046422,
-1.1305350065,
-0.4050625861,
0.4444790184,
-0.8577766418,
0.1960452944,
-0.2565509081,
-0.617762804,
-0.1708217114,
-0.5741464496,
0.0056501715,
0.9029713869,
-0.6202007532,
0.7173544168,
0.3623481393,
-0.4578658342,
-0.2179434299,
-0.8720127344,
0.3250555694,
-0.4155997336,
-0.5642806292,
0.277156651,
-0.03469887,
-0.109135583,
-0.0373436585,
0.1268972754,
0.0177371632,
-0.1460969597,
0.2539927363,
0.3656101525,
-0.128426373,
0.5870745182,
-0.0541577637,
-0.2938966453,
0.0008624437,
-0.52803725,
0.572456181,
-0.2753195465,
-0.0469698422,
-0.423913449,
0.4183717072,
0.5878869295,
-0.2371087521,
0.7950420976,
0.8307656646,
-0.1348314583,
-0.2519758046,
-0.3069009781,
-0.0455232412,
-0.5029156208,
0.4344295859,
-0.0209065359,
-0.8707687855,
0.2118198276,
-0.2210263312,
0.1031293571,
0.7405493259,
0.4897012711,
-0.1618689448,
1.4683276415,
0.7566934824,
-0.4364487529,
0.6731349826,
-0.2338044941,
0.7093324065,
-0.697627306,
0.0961538851,
-0.4279351532,
-0.2328791618,
-0.944393456,
-0.404227972,
0.6047942042,
-0.1690555513,
-0.262117058,
-0.2428262681,
-0.889973402,
0.3395464718,
0.4981364012,
0.2470145375,
0.1608431041,
0.0703282952,
0.6629146338,
-0.120717898,
-0.8616275191,
-0.5865513682,
1.167273283,
0.4050510228,
0.748598814,
-0.0206525996,
0.5167813301,
0.4852934182,
0.5290173888,
-1.2778500319,
0.414836973,
-0.3938932717,
-0.3206761479,
-0.1993232369,
-0.4937295914,
-0.792006135,
0.1697550714,
-0.3092274666,
-0.4536243081,
0.0223207343,
0.3482723534,
-0.434630543,
0.2735385597,
-0.9400969148,
0.9090980291,
0.0809609815,
-0.1829919368,
-0.070841819,
-0.4533093274,
0.2853862047,
-0.1000951678,
0.1349516064,
0.1281014681,
-0.120312795,
0.709471941,
-0.7088004947,
0.9960339069,
-0.0489426889,
0.0950202197,
0.5442436337,
-0.2653536797,
0.7630664706,
0.1033947691,
0.0211638324,
-0.0707951114,
-0.299782753,
-0.4061439633,
-0.891937077,
0.6526162624,
-0.7160872221,
-0.1657509506,
-0.3738557398,
-0.4175205231,
-0.3782098889,
-0.2254481018,
0.3180910349,
0.1852743924,
-0.1726058125,
0.4080220461,
0.8053621054,
-0.1720638424,
0.4786740839,
-0.3776760995,
0.2512978315,
-0.629126966,
1.0808144808,
0.1290586889,
0.1617195159,
0.1533192545,
0.4312161207,
-0.4461399019,
-0.2683261633,
-0.6259896755,
0.0627358183,
-0.7234677672,
-0.2634085715,
-0.7844933271,
-0.1141663343,
-0.284293443,
-0.21625036,
-0.673743844,
-0.6607744098,
-0.1081974432,
-0.2673333287,
0.674513936,
0.2523232996,
-0.1647286117,
0.9253759384,
-0.9140409827,
0.0716866404,
0.6058225632,
0.1306540817,
0.0864328071,
-0.2611986995,
-0.25398013,
0.1287682801,
-0.367821306,
-0.6150803566,
0.6573902369,
0.4119054973,
0.1196166947,
0.2887640297,
0.0651433915,
0.6251550317,
-0.317907542,
1.1527056694,
0.2942537367,
-0.9599904418,
0.5479373336,
-0.4819223881,
0.114104405,
0.457310766,
-0.0646476597,
-0.5533752441,
0.0056641749,
-0.9706283212,
-0.9992790818,
0.4669214785,
0.3789208531,
0.5371893048,
0.1500582695,
0.2977855206,
-0.001925553,
0.3102158606,
-0.8009743094,
0.0361098051,
-0.415875107,
-0.8056443334,
-0.1364388168,
-0.2425401956,
-0.1806471795,
-0.2912929952,
0.8799303174,
-0.3098282516,
0.6321157813,
0.0785836801,
0.0097193401,
0.1622681171,
0.3067944646,
0.1443236619,
0.1090961471,
0.1439419389,
-0.0097952886,
0.3574367166,
-0.504034102,
-0.0968497545,
0.1739431024,
-0.1084067002,
0.1014753953,
0.3493990302,
0.8654339314,
-0.0827895254,
-0.6707758904,
0.6130829453,
-0.081350483,
-0.100720264,
-0.3756790161,
0.1220677868,
-0.1217017025,
0.208494097,
0.239336431,
0.2556291223,
0.2807452381,
-0.5567687154,
-0.0092828935,
0.608671844,
-0.6413232684,
-0.162527889,
0.5142078996,
0.1667491794,
-0.014514097,
0.535394609,
-0.1742889732,
-0.6500075459,
0.415468812,
0.1888953447,
0.9392927289,
0.0775096044,
0.4730361998,
0.2516024113,
0.4228531718,
-0.2568036914,
-0.0169743989,
0.0466208495,
-0.5927951932,
-0.5145130157,
-0.6395382285,
-0.6075018048,
-0.157844007,
-0.2584859729,
-0.0177665297,
-0.6409217119,
-0.140067637,
0.2265151292,
0.1356308758,
-0.4885029495,
0.5865101814,
0.0148762232,
0.4788832366,
-0.7913967967,
0.5608636737,
0.68914783,
-0.5092413425,
-0.8028817177,
-0.0511916131,
-0.1104377583,
-0.5740366578,
0.3632439971,
0.2721169591,
0.0525444187,
0.028436929,
-0.8125033975,
-0.4646899402,
0.6899113655,
0.0094878282,
-0.2832008004,
0.1293570548,
0.3215719163,
0.7133577466,
-0.2754828632,
0.1281324029,
0.8808426261,
0.4313476682,
0.1349993646,
-0.5190295577,
-0.3005736768,
-0.2969470918,
0.1418607831,
0.3143336177,
-0.7729871869,
1.0048904419,
0.0843655393,
-0.1338749379,
0.0861574411,
0.561358273,
-0.136617586,
0.2624212205,
0.3853479922,
0.469188571,
0.7488952875,
-0.44714728,
1.1684285402,
-0.0366856083,
0.5954706073,
0.811953783,
0.082665123,
0.6611117721,
0.402551651,
-0.2201133072,
0.3066670001,
0.6679914594,
-0.0759100392,
0.4339163601,
-0.0770750493,
-0.6460145116,
-0.2270489633,
0.0088592395,
-0.2425970137,
0.4568306506,
0.5218092203,
-0.3404100239,
-0.0272234958,
0.3411604464,
0.2459349483,
-0.0787994936,
-0.380795598,
0.975230217,
0.0341323242,
-0.3166888356,
0.1077521518,
-0.0562182032,
0.7719061375,
-0.5928500891,
0.0965863615,
-0.3063237667,
0.4368461967,
-0.2557893097,
-0.5375908613,
0.5346246958,
0.0270743314,
-0.0577371307,
-0.0732274726,
0.9133476615,
-0.2281043231,
-0.7692832947,
-0.2971362472,
0.3440711498,
-0.1717014164,
-0.563266933,
-0.588914454,
-0.0088034179,
0.1671072841,
-0.4289352596,
0.3317726254,
0.7313054204,
0.0747228116,
0.5875120759,
0.9166457057,
0.2635895312,
-0.1259642541,
-0.1504536569,
1.0683413744,
-0.6776847839,
-0.7583298683,
-1.1273298264,
0.6858452559,
-0.642444849,
-0.0479891934,
0.6932409406,
0.4014664292,
0.512316227,
-0.2269412875,
1.431312561,
-0.242215991,
0.6607618332,
-0.3376832902,
0.8039488792,
-0.3297095895,
0.1659739614,
-0.3140070736,
-1.0035887957,
-0.5465282202,
0.9579761028,
-0.4561189711,
-0.07945887,
0.3886268139,
0.7941739559,
0.0357021652,
0.3204382062,
0.148828879,
-0.0300811324,
0.5139403939,
0.3762283325,
0.9551618099,
-0.7192096114,
0.716136694,
-0.2271030247,
-0.3022902906,
-0.2674917877,
-0.734685719,
-0.8100351691,
-0.2332001179,
-0.4010950923,
-0.2569356859,
-0.1073704809,
0.9571733475,
0.7171022296,
-0.5667629242,
0.3106332421,
-0.2216730118,
-0.142050311,
-0.1578560174,
-0.3005267382,
0.5527284145,
-0.6341529489,
-0.8724637032,
0.0114804897,
0.2870963216,
0.2387981862,
-0.2010382414,
0.1110729948,
0.4320205748,
0.3424890339,
1.0785428286,
0.188062951,
-0.2474329919,
-0.4938256443,
-0.3685511947,
0.0818905085,
0.2675506473,
0.77285254,
-0.6686276197,
0.3895271122,
0.4543943107,
0.9993008971,
0.3860194087,
0.2867749035,
0.3722297847,
-0.9215496182,
0.4179553092,
0.2886563838,
0.1315204352,
0.7042329311,
-0.4280346036,
0.6195479035,
0.2598362565,
-0.6178132892,
-0.6365482807,
0.0102850329,
-1.1644903421,
-0.0254590735,
0.9123761654,
0.0240402259,
-0.1949295104,
0.2778407633,
-0.7364054322,
0.2154174149,
-0.2643874288,
1.0433280468,
0.6118875742,
-0.3054391742,
-0.3118312955,
-0.5608832836,
0.7525945306,
0.3282220662,
-1.0753594637,
0.2907425463,
0.6006886959,
-0.0896113813,
0.1958799213,
0.5162792206,
-0.1353431046,
-0.0700849965,
0.4469805658,
-0.0485177375,
0.1872967035,
-0.1070358828,
-0.1791384369,
0.3311470449,
0.1566249728,
-0.4557012618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04715v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04715v1
|
Deep Emotions Across Languages: A Novel Approach for Sentiment Propagation in Multilingual WordNets
| 2023-12-07T21:44:14 | 2023-12-07T21:44:14 |
Jan Kocoń
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Sentiment analysis involves using WordNets enriched with emotional metadata,
which are valuable resources. However, manual annotation is time-consuming and
expensive, resulting in only a few WordNet Lexical Units being annotated. This
paper introduces two new techniques for automatically propagating sentiment
annotations from a partially annotated WordNet to its entirety and to a WordNet
in a different language: Multilingual Structured Synset Embeddings (MSSE) and
Cross-Lingual Deep Neural Sentiment Propagation (CLDNS). We evaluated the
proposed MSSE+CLDNS method extensively using Princeton WordNet and Polish
WordNet, which have many inter-lingual relations. Our results show that the
MSSE+CLDNS method outperforms existing propagation methods, indicating its
effectiveness in enriching WordNets with emotional metadata across multiple
languages. This work provides a solid foundation for large-scale, multilingual
sentiment analysis and is valuable for academic research and practical
applications.
|
[
-0.6238937378,
-0.5589625239,
0.3485843539,
0.7971068025,
-0.4422359765,
0.1202946156,
-0.7467422485,
-0.4868789911,
0.4770083427,
-0.0084316991,
-0.5935126543,
-0.6509621143,
-0.6401165128,
0.0975426212,
0.0671297684,
0.9127029181,
-0.0441928282,
0.3795758188,
-0.0507958233,
-0.4000044465,
-0.0171296597,
-0.5574080348,
-0.3622362912,
-0.4048905671,
0.9242050052,
0.1749836206,
0.6674614549,
-0.1579791307,
0.4026171565,
0.2141788155,
-0.2394868433,
0.4789149761,
-0.2169810236,
0.1279084831,
-0.1343953758,
-0.0954642966,
-0.3277530968,
-0.2120642513,
0.5358964801,
0.8583911061,
0.0079241451,
0.0829410404,
-0.0423090383,
0.8033162355,
-0.6546561718,
0.041963838,
-0.1593046039,
0.6548088789,
-0.1840916723,
-0.0574326068,
-0.394970715,
-0.3409927785,
0.2431260496,
-0.392357856,
-0.3150503635,
-0.189283818,
0.4092408121,
-0.1940927655,
-0.6560739875,
-0.1206928864,
-0.3992143571,
0.7490252256,
-0.5330050588,
0.3565038443,
-0.3471132517,
0.1046977192,
0.255453676,
-0.5776873231,
-0.5014722943,
-0.1370494366,
-0.0548020154,
0.3929061294,
0.0339976437,
0.1839507818,
0.0663325489,
0.3254148364,
-0.3154887259,
-0.0329400897,
-0.2266440988,
-0.1420935392,
0.6700726748,
-0.0019410903,
0.3541046083,
-0.21321401,
-0.4694800079,
-0.238223955,
-0.5547422767,
-0.1609338522,
0.5476395488,
0.4143771827,
-0.2178206593,
0.4568179846,
-0.2132561803,
0.3742822409,
-0.352111876,
0.2781787813,
0.8802919984,
-0.3183349669,
-0.2662754655,
0.2769069374,
0.9437645674,
0.3782534301,
0.5685178638,
0.0711529925,
-0.1397791654,
0.3826827407,
-0.0438821353,
-0.5551686287,
-0.2253368497,
0.2294618785,
-0.6311963201,
-0.2643932402,
-0.062788561,
-0.9752656221,
-0.8668336272,
-0.2839362025,
0.3558824658,
-0.0742142051,
-0.7184938788,
0.312009573,
-0.2503526509,
0.0392950885,
0.0647248775,
-0.3977806866,
0.0332203209,
0.6497228742,
0.8104088306,
0.0817663968,
-0.3540102541,
0.088264294,
-0.4067180753,
-0.3651497662,
0.4310120642,
-0.6460052729,
-0.0893422067,
0.3717350662,
0.1349262893,
0.00182834,
-0.1392659694,
0.4653927982,
-0.5224127173,
0.263512671,
-0.3102754354,
-0.4372885227,
-0.4347125888,
0.4887990355,
-0.6395446658,
0.8558422923,
-0.0189405307,
-1.0324161053,
-0.0374297723,
-0.996154964,
-0.7429081202,
-0.4095882773,
0.4289571941,
-0.0267965104,
0.3638312519,
0.2425721735,
0.816945672,
0.0656737685,
0.1136764959,
-0.4582030475,
0.0712395161,
0.2672146261,
-0.4782788455,
0.8109012246,
0.230344981,
-0.5354422331,
0.0637827292,
-0.3907347322,
-0.009318267,
0.0676990747,
0.2690833211,
-0.5865054131,
-0.2647108138,
0.1417801976,
0.6303898096,
0.347348392,
-0.8795008063,
0.0885552317,
-0.595259428,
0.1643533856,
0.4580987394,
0.1304338127,
0.7103496194,
0.3633896708,
0.4710677862,
0.4661603272,
0.3805497587,
-0.240168497,
-0.2591018677,
-0.6457971334,
0.2757612467,
0.032981839,
0.6075253487,
-0.8122261167,
0.0307713132,
-0.2802677155,
-0.532559216,
-0.8823941946,
0.1455923319,
0.4281418622,
0.4288550317,
0.5412892699,
-0.1063959822,
-0.6571556926,
-1.1115196943,
-0.1920279711,
0.172458455,
0.4722425938,
0.1326795071,
0.2683490217,
-0.2795136869,
0.2759627998,
-0.306733191,
-0.2192310393,
-0.2404194772,
0.4312525094,
0.0368942618,
0.3348582983,
0.4332796037,
-0.9933162332,
-0.6284533143,
0.105610922,
-0.6579033732,
-0.0025856483,
-0.2198948264,
-0.1683986336,
0.413415879,
0.1203068495,
-0.3082332313,
0.1286467165,
1.0228192806,
-0.1025078595,
0.3848035634,
-0.0159783307,
0.1187342554,
-1.3510217667,
0.0494013354,
0.0533155017,
-0.1678954661,
-0.6330453753,
0.0831888691,
0.0207065362,
0.0650915429,
-0.7240692377,
0.5845918059,
-0.6783275008,
-0.1540005207,
-0.0497912504,
0.4680439234,
0.2843435109,
0.35882321,
0.1420004815,
0.2201897055,
0.6772391796,
-0.0838857666,
0.8011521697,
0.2317841053,
-0.1555909961,
0.6487284303,
-0.4043286443,
-0.1000210941,
-0.4486356676,
0.4037777781,
-0.8936895132,
0.2549234033,
0.4936455488,
-0.3275693059,
0.2489109188,
-0.1024487391,
-0.4189160466,
-0.2917669117,
-0.4624916017,
0.3157273829,
0.3227245212,
-0.5524250269,
0.4513441622,
0.2513162196,
-0.163884595,
-0.7380850911,
-1.1587464809,
0.5456513166,
-0.1979354173,
-0.7259161472,
-0.078312777,
-0.0264092796,
-0.3579469025,
0.0984397903,
0.3985265493,
0.0661905929,
0.0818958804,
0.1474175751,
-0.1642473787,
-0.3910545707,
0.4623959959,
0.1164631993,
0.0402262248,
0.1275523901,
-0.6052886844,
0.4236138165,
-0.4588861763,
-0.1209458038,
-0.3002463579,
0.7614751458,
0.4867962301,
-0.5665156841,
0.8265517354,
1.0336383581,
-0.306455791,
-0.5479432344,
-0.4833267331,
-0.1201080382,
-0.3335816264,
0.345872432,
-0.3687891066,
-0.7808001637,
0.421998173,
-0.272960484,
-0.0642888173,
0.4718033671,
0.4826520681,
-0.225617528,
1.136089921,
0.5617937446,
-0.3517509401,
0.2949979007,
-0.300168097,
0.3041912019,
-0.9887835383,
-0.0598351061,
-0.1531322151,
-0.6463065147,
-0.7720435262,
-0.5795862079,
0.3693814278,
-0.2131517977,
-0.1035841331,
-0.1098791733,
-0.2301743031,
0.1947234273,
0.284254998,
0.030129971,
-0.1051984951,
0.0914602131,
-0.4459290206,
0.016800534,
-0.5454261303,
-0.0736166164,
0.485937506,
0.4714332223,
0.3667674661,
-0.0337138213,
0.7042025328,
0.1746681184,
0.5835031271,
-0.8632042408,
0.3251643777,
-0.5443386436,
-0.3732172847,
-0.3722935021,
-0.4188918471,
-0.5688647032,
0.3750909865,
-0.104770489,
-0.5012711287,
0.3556005359,
-0.0141292633,
-0.1935242712,
0.4438550174,
-0.4706248939,
1.0752646923,
-0.1952162981,
-0.3368641138,
-0.4695322216,
-0.9093537331,
0.229304716,
0.1350056678,
0.2997351885,
-0.2383456528,
-0.1297318041,
0.4613049328,
-0.1478609294,
0.9947785735,
-0.6838950515,
-0.3200560212,
0.3224291503,
0.2933953702,
0.5751054287,
-0.0608575828,
-0.4596273303,
0.2100688517,
-0.3502005041,
-0.19250606,
-0.7389004827,
0.7625528574,
-0.5645426512,
-0.0961747244,
-0.1633380949,
-0.3054899871,
-0.4455575347,
0.1065584719,
0.0285924785,
0.4797846079,
0.0091023296,
0.1517237127,
0.6065077186,
-0.3235403299,
0.5219727755,
0.1119122952,
0.111383073,
-0.6111679077,
0.6859272122,
0.0473045036,
0.1230477914,
0.4752945006,
0.4694430828,
-0.4951682985,
-0.0358123071,
-0.5315961838,
0.2291341275,
-0.9757264853,
-0.2082518041,
-0.6621587873,
0.1646147221,
-0.2626423538,
-0.3089829087,
-0.75519979,
-0.3235067129,
0.0237659104,
-0.408447057,
0.4902890325,
0.4916595519,
-0.3232997656,
0.2877835631,
-1.0361727476,
-0.0178888533,
-0.2099808455,
0.5775495768,
0.2018884867,
-0.1860264242,
-0.3049425185,
0.4287895262,
0.4562878609,
-1.0304896832,
0.528441906,
0.3661698699,
0.139131844,
0.2738472223,
0.0952125788,
0.8772240877,
-0.4796504676,
0.888240099,
0.3022975624,
-1.0472383499,
0.3644063175,
-0.2795289457,
0.2110607475,
0.5861081481,
0.6956501603,
-1.2291339636,
-0.08084438,
-0.4190403223,
-1.0318808556,
0.4019161463,
-0.380319953,
0.6401152015,
-0.147454381,
0.1405686438,
-0.0306812376,
0.2985237837,
-0.6647013426,
-0.3597221971,
-0.2073305696,
-0.4138290882,
-0.5499064326,
-0.3825227916,
-0.1711847484,
0.1140215248,
0.6007406712,
-0.3148671091,
0.1906518042,
0.6100201607,
-0.3604747355,
0.0807338357,
0.1910912991,
0.5757091045,
0.1077397019,
0.2510436773,
0.3707563281,
0.1619395167,
0.0378623791,
0.1612334847,
-0.148489207,
0.0883556008,
0.1641113609,
0.1237471402,
0.9814555645,
0.3287097812,
-0.0838525519,
0.9093034863,
0.1466543674,
-0.0863276795,
-0.4509821832,
-0.8252598047,
0.4406936169,
0.3646942079,
-0.0689831153,
-0.0956525654,
0.3581320345,
-0.4025117457,
0.0918451846,
0.1363155246,
-0.6855511069,
-0.6636857986,
0.0887483507,
0.3980265558,
0.3496115804,
0.4688224792,
-0.2902998626,
-0.9613080621,
0.3903549612,
0.3482563794,
1.22275424,
-0.1841151565,
0.519610405,
0.2389999181,
0.3111145794,
-0.3014163971,
0.6953735948,
-0.0504272096,
-0.7306653261,
-0.6683808565,
-0.5582844615,
-0.1766463518,
-0.5140626431,
-0.3910881877,
-0.2102312595,
-0.1010082439,
0.0309613366,
-0.2116148919,
0.0272925161,
-0.7636384368,
0.396222651,
0.8006824255,
1.1439452171,
-1.0368784666,
0.6425165534,
1.0619602203,
-0.2360022217,
-0.8248183727,
-0.3131758869,
0.0079122847,
-0.4836063981,
0.8022219539,
0.1842407584,
-0.3393316865,
-0.0861416608,
-0.1849318743,
-0.5683700442,
0.5798788667,
-0.0757846236,
-0.5137082934,
0.3946681023,
0.2365657389,
0.827306211,
-0.3329987526,
0.222329393,
0.0443239547,
0.8864912391,
-0.2702243924,
-0.6383360624,
0.0541960038,
-0.3811631501,
-0.1909391582,
0.3730732203,
-0.7940130234,
0.5490670204,
0.0905030221,
-0.1434644163,
-0.1200021803,
0.6542211771,
-0.4300790727,
0.2116231024,
0.5906602144,
0.4587221444,
0.7849828601,
0.0029649728,
0.8714222312,
-0.4973243475,
0.1808023304,
0.9022560716,
-0.4902596772,
0.9298231602,
0.5045688748,
0.1718205959,
0.6193979383,
0.5447151661,
-0.1084472835,
0.2067748457,
0.5762596726,
-0.4247260988,
-0.1174574569,
-0.4333630502,
-0.2574256063,
0.3891485035,
0.4086608887,
-0.314168781,
-0.1060765684,
0.5019458532,
0.1993075907,
0.0297882408,
-0.4563348889,
0.6253857613,
0.3549611866,
-0.5090220571,
0.0904748216,
0.0981641039,
0.913926363,
-0.700288415,
0.249814257,
-0.5055959821,
0.2441726327,
-0.4529089034,
-0.9667336941,
0.4565665126,
-0.1550398916,
0.1166698784,
-0.5946087241,
0.8223863244,
-0.7393410206,
-0.4813850522,
0.7805241942,
0.5487031341,
0.1098996699,
-0.2066100538,
-0.6191371679,
0.0425909832,
-0.1852429658,
-0.7862824798,
0.0786010921,
0.797970593,
-0.1473615766,
0.4356097877,
0.5103434324,
0.4300044775,
0.0458003096,
0.5649092793,
0.76123631,
-0.4902225733,
-0.4485072196,
-0.8565445542,
0.8184861541,
-0.1777225882,
-0.2839420438,
0.9283463359,
0.2880833745,
0.7700503469,
-0.2130042315,
0.7886604071,
0.0196295194,
0.0842128694,
-0.2015165091,
0.5853601694,
-0.7933248878,
-0.2522589862,
-0.5208272934,
-0.8800798059,
-0.8015298843,
0.4524629712,
-0.1739283055,
-0.1701873839,
0.5622553229,
0.6382394433,
0.1001553312,
0.0216673184,
0.1763533652,
0.243855387,
0.0523182824,
0.5393838882,
0.9453621507,
-0.2169376016,
0.1803171337,
-0.8896387219,
0.1212671399,
-0.093241103,
-1.224845767,
-0.4539032578,
-0.372833252,
-0.4462005198,
-0.2978381515,
0.3043985963,
1.2765209675,
0.6142390966,
-0.7412632108,
-0.1041848958,
0.1442896128,
-0.0296311248,
-0.1761770397,
-0.2302618921,
0.5041152239,
-0.5958794355,
-0.6648907661,
0.3702176213,
0.3271648884,
-0.2622616887,
-0.6719781756,
0.0861829221,
-0.1423921138,
-0.1109364778,
0.837341845,
0.0016292258,
-0.3451904655,
-0.3301358223,
0.0997121111,
-0.1730894148,
-0.0552440993,
0.7134202719,
-0.4676592648,
0.6106475592,
0.8870117068,
0.72631073,
-0.047929056,
-0.1712285131,
0.5463154912,
-1.131457448,
0.3175833225,
0.4023918808,
0.5376098752,
0.5733766556,
-0.2782720625,
0.3433706164,
0.2507578433,
-0.1236206889,
-0.6449225545,
0.167907536,
-0.7488052249,
-0.2760706246,
1.3224656582,
-0.3849851489,
-0.2940063477,
0.2778208554,
-0.0676482841,
0.2372768074,
-0.1045359895,
0.411649406,
0.5248473883,
0.2341416776,
-0.1402643323,
-0.3883132637,
0.3636717498,
0.5731317997,
-0.5072512627,
0.2354887724,
0.4242857397,
-0.0834444687,
0.2890769243,
0.2093688995,
-0.2042958587,
0.0664393455,
0.0030604291,
0.5588445663,
-0.0548828989,
-0.4388178289,
-0.6090356708,
0.2989436686,
-0.2896386087,
-0.0200405214
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04691v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04691v3
|
Simul-LLM: A Framework for Exploring High-Quality Simultaneous Translation with Large Language Models
| 2023-12-07T20:42:05 | 2024-06-05T03:12:13 |
Victor Agostinelli, Max Wild, Matthew Raffel, Kazi Ahmed Asif Fuad, Lizhong Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) with billions of parameters and pretrained on
massive amounts of data are now capable of near or better than state-of-the-art
performance in a variety of downstream natural language processing tasks.
Neural machine translation (NMT) is one such task that LLMs have been applied
to with great success. However, little research has focused on applying LLMs to
the more difficult subset of NMT called simultaneous translation (SimulMT),
where translation begins before the entire source context is available to the
model. In this paper, we address key challenges facing LLMs fine-tuned for
SimulMT, validate classical SimulMT concepts and practices in the context of
LLMs, explore adapting LLMs that are fine-tuned for NMT to the task of SimulMT,
and introduce Simul-LLM, the first open-source fine-tuning and evaluation
pipeline development framework for LLMs focused on SimulMT.
|
[
-0.3823074102,
-0.5388097763,
0.5738174319,
0.5038959384,
-0.5175537467,
0.3860856295,
-0.5604647994,
-0.1557638198,
-0.117908746,
0.5393930078,
-0.6498425603,
-0.5086411834,
-0.7797421813,
0.4014374316,
-0.2536668181,
0.7477445006,
-0.4085207582,
0.3885854483,
-0.1235552654,
-0.2055246979,
-0.4972312152,
-0.4599146545,
-0.6153910756,
-0.3615591228,
0.5301201344,
0.235011518,
0.782540381,
0.6575416923,
0.6130049229,
0.256580025,
-0.0203417651,
0.5708992481,
-0.5331478119,
0.1371278614,
-0.0820859596,
-0.3734858334,
-0.3906746507,
-0.0597721674,
0.8595086336,
0.7955546379,
0.1020246446,
0.2829411924,
0.2481595278,
0.5389347672,
-0.3873916268,
0.0854602903,
-0.5147889853,
-0.0820178166,
-0.32050246,
-0.4630432129,
-0.2343836427,
-0.4282583594,
-0.1836251467,
-0.4187555611,
-0.2525756061,
0.3583869338,
0.6388158202,
0.7466992736,
-0.6005626321,
-0.1496896595,
-0.6434975863,
0.8420723677,
-0.7669250965,
0.4540967941,
-0.1244522706,
0.3706737161,
-0.5331828594,
-0.6407055855,
-0.2917145193,
-0.2164607644,
0.1396335214,
-0.077442497,
0.0752310082,
0.1219772771,
0.2222619206,
0.4477676749,
-0.5966418386,
0.2323264778,
-0.0495218672,
0.0042047799,
0.5503301024,
0.4278153181,
0.225521788,
0.1694760472,
-0.6344237328,
0.1680086702,
-0.576908648,
-0.3603662252,
0.2924179733,
0.3949401975,
-0.0466575585,
0.7305232286,
-0.1886117309,
0.6532574892,
-0.265419364,
0.1480101049,
0.0400813892,
-0.4791648388,
-0.3811865151,
-0.0570255183,
0.8485235572,
0.1924175024,
0.4614255726,
-0.2953121364,
-0.3674013019,
-0.1997537464,
0.1151381955,
-0.8750877976,
0.4842366576,
0.2250695378,
-0.3140718043,
-0.2200974375,
-0.151623711,
-0.4821597934,
-0.3348987699,
-0.6361035109,
0.4212806821,
-0.2378534079,
-0.4274642467,
0.4695744812,
0.3685351014,
0.2488368005,
0.4866240919,
-0.586727798,
0.526981771,
0.921017468,
0.9609801173,
-0.508007288,
-0.5695675611,
-0.4954965413,
0.0209616795,
-0.3050692081,
0.3994132876,
-0.0347356349,
0.0487604067,
-0.1578653455,
-0.2456732392,
-0.2727008462,
-0.522398293,
0.6350676417,
-0.4659769237,
-0.2726769745,
-0.2416127175,
-0.6039150953,
-0.1244654581,
0.2839803398,
-0.4567932487,
0.8447520733,
0.0408137552,
-0.756796658,
0.0834057704,
-0.6595332623,
-0.4057036042,
-0.0004637666,
-0.0522693358,
-0.0720182061,
0.5503810048,
0.1012837365,
0.4433065653,
-0.8813121319,
0.4460681677,
-0.1833770573,
-0.5041547418,
0.2266389877,
-0.4299272597,
0.7376613021,
0.4178914726,
-0.0047542495,
0.3276355267,
-0.3701761067,
0.0622262023,
0.1593389362,
-0.290379405,
-0.1075320765,
-0.0761310607,
0.1896909773,
0.4435136616,
0.3345293105,
-0.3987811804,
0.2849496603,
-0.1998275369,
0.3630741537,
0.6376461983,
-0.3145027459,
0.1791082621,
-0.3917966783,
0.5418832302,
0.0280798879,
-0.0594108738,
-0.042163115,
-0.1267180145,
-0.8052394986,
-0.2430828214,
0.6238674521,
0.5850520134,
-0.5751214027,
0.1291931421,
-0.4478310347,
-0.2963179052,
-0.8704561591,
0.3502117395,
0.0497085713,
-0.1825232506,
0.3832536638,
-0.2220093459,
-0.5491076708,
-0.8938552141,
-0.4275068343,
0.263042897,
0.1997117102,
0.149800241,
0.2481245995,
-0.1185942739,
0.5157412291,
-0.2262963057,
-0.3488647938,
-0.3277249634,
0.1919526756,
0.3084816337,
0.4086640775,
0.2036359757,
-0.6163565516,
-0.327804774,
0.2523076832,
-0.8790764213,
-0.356679976,
-0.2750230432,
-0.0873047486,
-0.0209347494,
1.0300949812,
-0.6469353437,
-0.0041330312,
0.8031130433,
0.1541820467,
0.3754231632,
-0.2601915598,
0.0931894332,
-1.2428549528,
-0.0121238343,
-0.2715923786,
-0.3958230913,
-0.4598553181,
0.2977502942,
0.1367246509,
0.0971805528,
-0.7284657359,
0.5769958496,
-0.6127520204,
-0.2000483125,
-0.3896914721,
-0.0965428054,
-0.4048729539,
0.3192656934,
-0.2501960695,
0.8143048286,
0.3561194241,
-0.4671413898,
0.3809488714,
-0.0757829174,
-0.3374277353,
0.3194396496,
-0.4880545437,
0.1676415652,
0.1040928066,
0.0962226465,
-0.7077668309,
-0.2064492106,
0.093438521,
-0.1692085564,
0.4040966034,
-0.1512172669,
-0.973195374,
-0.2216320634,
0.0225413926,
0.6955627799,
0.4404482543,
-0.4162719846,
0.6508883834,
-0.1006342024,
-0.2178547531,
-0.5909910798,
-0.5533718467,
0.2739388049,
-0.0396192633,
-0.8531578779,
0.1512556374,
-0.1311317831,
-0.2270929515,
-0.1719118804,
-0.3075565696,
0.0692270845,
0.3739792407,
0.1215348542,
-0.1072506532,
-0.6345490813,
-0.1787452996,
0.2322389036,
-0.2531834245,
-0.054027129,
-0.3989208043,
0.6563885808,
-0.131880641,
-0.502399385,
-0.2604066133,
0.2826837003,
0.875564456,
-0.1901622862,
0.6322445273,
0.6571087837,
-0.3888580501,
-0.4413757324,
-0.6154803634,
0.0273762103,
-0.4240834415,
0.4335399866,
-0.5293929577,
-1.105191946,
0.2893966436,
-0.7108212709,
0.0515992679,
0.1780258566,
0.7889709473,
-0.0274971239,
0.9477002025,
0.5237616897,
0.2134715766,
0.1309982091,
0.172276184,
0.1431777626,
-0.8913271427,
0.0096897949,
-0.2871872187,
-0.4852905273,
-0.4504174888,
-0.5990795493,
0.0780740082,
0.4832825065,
0.0109187067,
0.3208614588,
0.0789247006,
0.512742877,
0.3260851502,
-0.2100326568,
0.5469467044,
-0.2001951337,
-0.4588264227,
-0.1365856826,
-0.6036258936,
-0.5158066154,
0.9059300423,
0.347096771,
0.7805926204,
0.0341606103,
0.6602343321,
-0.0989686474,
0.2013247609,
-0.8307387233,
0.7504275441,
-0.388284117,
-0.4380114377,
0.0239949021,
-0.4744337201,
-0.7033654451,
0.4638659954,
-0.037191201,
-0.2433629632,
-0.2442100197,
-0.0276841521,
-0.2845012844,
0.3892091215,
-0.4207698703,
0.851816833,
-0.7108721137,
-0.3912974894,
-0.0660431236,
-0.543854177,
0.495909363,
-0.4773440957,
0.1577504277,
-0.46458143,
-0.2804074287,
0.0775756985,
-0.2234117389,
0.4922298491,
0.1524277478,
-0.1191372201,
-0.1525657326,
0.3117444515,
0.2546271086,
0.0756613538,
-0.1024212018,
0.3869291842,
-0.1091002151,
-0.2253193259,
-0.4884637892,
0.8711258173,
-0.6202965379,
-0.6321590543,
-0.4899092913,
-1.1348522902,
-0.1621354371,
0.3825033605,
0.0865684822,
-0.1475268602,
-0.324962616,
0.3358589709,
0.5276360512,
-0.3066100776,
0.2192943394,
0.3239988983,
-0.589858532,
-0.3727121651,
0.8130040765,
0.0988332108,
0.4783398807,
0.244347021,
0.0601580478,
-0.1636897475,
-1.1394118071,
-0.605646193,
0.2706812322,
-0.4490123987,
-0.3081124723,
-0.6349260807,
-0.3657838106,
-0.2606505752,
-0.0742020458,
-0.620174706,
-0.2250525504,
-0.3037667572,
0.3707018197,
0.0476358794,
0.7651757002,
-0.0715845302,
0.2882730663,
-0.725513339,
0.4828526676,
0.09425091,
0.3628675044,
-0.3653689027,
-0.3591167331,
-0.2220360488,
0.1482701153,
-0.0716767013,
-0.472022444,
0.3821553588,
-0.1346052438,
0.4707983434,
-0.1909709126,
-0.0378126651,
0.62327528,
-0.5291007161,
0.4209517837,
-0.1039850414,
-0.9040232301,
0.150592193,
-0.4337699413,
0.3522682488,
0.5587186217,
0.3628175259,
-0.6168586612,
-0.1696107537,
-0.0971131697,
-0.823353231,
0.7971386313,
0.4527975619,
0.1368650198,
0.2517080307,
0.2948203385,
0.2226516157,
0.3442057073,
-0.5026223063,
-0.2083271146,
0.2370989621,
-0.3379594982,
-0.1860603094,
-0.0238644257,
0.0858619884,
-0.2463706881,
0.6037032604,
-0.1863389611,
-0.0286268108,
-0.1664819419,
-0.4629722834,
-0.2383425385,
0.3553405404,
0.6389247775,
0.4635563493,
-0.3790238798,
-0.0083493525,
0.3571254015,
-0.1495864242,
0.2343500257,
0.2530090809,
-0.2642271519,
-0.0565551966,
0.1089562401,
0.9205226302,
0.3617933691,
-0.3735977709,
0.5668811798,
-0.1882098913,
-0.2893039286,
-0.1236454546,
0.0369460881,
0.5025526881,
0.2317388505,
0.1840401888,
0.1765522361,
-0.3040350676,
-0.1864801645,
0.1449788064,
0.35443905,
-0.2370473742,
-0.1292754263,
0.6862199306,
0.0526032262,
-0.3352262676,
0.4339887798,
0.0066710236,
-0.3686714172,
0.4475777149,
0.6091915965,
1.0137627125,
-0.2767438293,
-0.1885628849,
0.1812301576,
0.59114182,
-0.4445662796,
0.3980215192,
0.284750551,
-0.4789449573,
-0.7388823628,
-0.97235322,
-0.3652170599,
0.1964586526,
-0.6091464162,
0.7498596907,
-0.4831045568,
0.0354544148,
-0.1625408977,
-0.1987591982,
-0.6923356056,
-0.1289892793,
0.1802707464,
1.1809897423,
-0.5794392824,
1.0294873714,
0.6718705297,
-0.2777299285,
-0.6034758687,
0.0689834505,
0.0828390643,
-0.7529243231,
0.63645643,
0.0526647307,
-0.2494306415,
0.506927073,
-0.3946328461,
-0.7525348663,
1.0795388222,
0.9460836053,
-0.6648785472,
-0.2119974494,
0.6069068909,
0.3916937411,
-0.4104223251,
-0.0156798828,
0.583120048,
0.5691817403,
0.0410254933,
-1.1061806679,
0.0844557732,
0.1088349223,
0.0893492177,
0.3279712796,
-0.7251167297,
0.9131421447,
-0.1508692652,
-0.1416185647,
0.2956359684,
0.5518437624,
0.0184096154,
0.0368143283,
0.2772533298,
0.5350310206,
0.2676585913,
-0.1953883916,
1.1531140804,
-0.0653537363,
0.3124311864,
1.4190605879,
-0.392260015,
0.8708465099,
0.6830673218,
0.0437640175,
-0.2460951209,
0.5852791667,
0.0994242728,
0.1596269011,
0.6791234612,
-0.2891522646,
-0.4876052141,
-0.3535732627,
-0.5453617573,
0.3930564523,
0.4555808902,
-0.3459576368,
-0.3604916334,
-0.0613724068,
-0.1336987764,
-0.0428813398,
-0.1767080277,
0.7142637968,
0.5688556433,
-0.4447624683,
0.700394094,
0.152544111,
0.7918037176,
-0.5656213164,
0.1142077073,
-0.3560305834,
0.2277642041,
-0.0727725476,
-0.5752225518,
0.2711916268,
-0.1240957156,
0.0486399122,
-0.416249603,
0.5216165185,
-0.5926338434,
-0.4836337864,
0.6029570103,
0.9079023004,
0.0806164816,
-0.2858754396,
-0.7360133529,
0.5279725194,
-0.1079893038,
-0.2492031306,
0.3922533393,
0.7888416648,
0.0643303543,
0.5914088488,
0.6916524172,
0.2420290112,
0.3305824995,
0.0769454837,
0.6629245281,
-0.67043221,
-0.0359744728,
-0.9576595426,
0.3055295348,
0.2783384919,
-0.232120648,
0.7259297967,
0.558753252,
0.9550862908,
0.004362782,
0.6551514864,
0.2194079757,
0.1452400088,
-0.658787787,
0.7753994465,
-0.7496967912,
0.2652237415,
-0.1665680856,
-1.2038546801,
-0.5875643492,
0.2168231159,
0.0281446241,
-0.0837796032,
0.993719399,
0.7638047338,
-0.4770808816,
0.0539994054,
0.5996366143,
0.3768753111,
0.0286345836,
0.6750068665,
1.0588520765,
-0.5503889918,
0.582662046,
-0.0578789636,
0.1777165979,
-0.2177359909,
-1.1471437216,
-0.805101037,
-0.2823803127,
-0.3887341917,
-0.1504426897,
0.1409920603,
1.4282397032,
0.6163458228,
-0.717143774,
-0.5106028318,
-0.1692546606,
0.0093185408,
-0.1770411134,
-0.0414382294,
-0.0222118162,
-0.4559654593,
-0.7773846984,
0.6136572361,
0.3963928521,
0.1575499326,
-0.2302936316,
-0.330116719,
-0.4075481296,
0.0690225959,
0.4071600139,
-0.0089849904,
-0.8317360282,
-0.0249404144,
-0.0663779154,
-0.4072633684,
0.1137794405,
1.0215139389,
-0.2698728144,
0.2938234508,
0.3925115168,
1.2774530649,
0.3835190535,
-0.2458755523,
0.8325947523,
-0.6963974237,
-0.0080297999,
0.2636623681,
0.3535386622,
0.3014840484,
-0.144576326,
0.5843835473,
0.0746898204,
-0.4067535996,
-0.9484093189,
0.2123973072,
-1.099796176,
-0.1242350638,
1.1854025126,
-0.0509415902,
-0.0186364539,
-0.1787191182,
-0.3706565201,
0.4287991226,
-0.0242031682,
0.0521137901,
0.8983290195,
0.1515548825,
-0.1637093425,
-0.9374315739,
0.3018823564,
0.695925653,
-0.7800060511,
0.2643610537,
0.2100191414,
0.3315404654,
-0.2355800569,
0.3873916566,
-0.1426032782,
0.0542230345,
-0.198895812,
-0.070590958,
-0.5337610841,
-0.2954916656,
-0.538569212,
0.2165426463,
0.3160715699,
-0.0831887275
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04684v1
|
Latent Skill Discovery for Chain-of-Thought Reasoning
| 2023-12-07T20:36:10 | 2023-12-07T20:36:10 |
Zifan Xu, Haozhu Wang, Dmitriy Bespalov, Peter Stone, Yanjun Qi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advances in Large Language Models (LLMs) have led to an emergent
ability of chain-of-thought (CoT) prompting, a prompt reasoning strategy that
adds intermediate rationale steps between questions and answers to construct
prompts. Conditioned on these prompts, LLMs can effectively learn in context to
generate rationales that lead to more accurate answers than when answering the
same question directly. To design LLM prompts, one important setting, called
demonstration selection, considers selecting demonstrations from an example
bank. Existing methods use various heuristics for this selection, but for CoT
prompting, which involves unique rationales, it is essential to base the
selection upon the intrinsic skills that CoT rationales need, for instance, the
skills of addition or subtraction for math word problems.
To address this requirement, we introduce a novel approach named Reasoning
Skill Discovery (RSD) that use unsupervised learning to create a latent space
representation of rationales, called a reasoning skill. Simultaneously, RSD
learns a reasoning policy to determine the required reasoning skill for a given
question. This can then guide the selection of examples that demonstrate the
required reasoning skills. Our approach offers several desirable properties: it
is (1) theoretically grounded, (2) sample-efficient, requiring no LLM inference
or manual prompt design, and (3) LLM-agnostic. Empirically, RSD outperforms
existing methods by up to 6% in terms of the answer accuracy across multiple
reasoning tasks.
|
[
-0.5209303498,
-0.9632390141,
0.9083702564,
0.1845262498,
-0.3383197486,
0.3957339227,
-0.0459221415,
0.0844261199,
0.1285541654,
0.439045161,
-0.8109245896,
-0.4607066214,
-0.4153684676,
-0.1539420485,
-0.0434463397,
0.6836190224,
-0.1871978492,
-0.1129985005,
-0.3730045855,
-0.0046917112,
-0.3969461024,
-0.5919876695,
-0.6008526683,
-0.3809851408,
0.6437446475,
0.4989772141,
0.3005798459,
0.294516176,
0.0939876139,
0.2069390863,
-0.2975668907,
0.5936546922,
-0.2067521363,
0.0446703024,
-0.527844131,
-0.5386123657,
-0.4065557718,
0.1417225897,
0.4180617034,
1.0568420887,
-0.0452100001,
-0.0859665275,
-0.1602811962,
0.6394153237,
-0.6163327098,
-0.0393572487,
-0.8250676394,
0.0639631674,
0.0607522763,
-0.5823194981,
-0.5682196617,
-0.2321305573,
0.2522296906,
-0.653947711,
0.3040961325,
0.0038527038,
0.3130967617,
0.2576936185,
-0.4105086625,
-0.2827525735,
-0.5244935751,
0.7434284687,
-0.3588161469,
0.2661674321,
0.3773964643,
0.1642720401,
-0.404217422,
-0.4817637503,
-0.6221526861,
-0.0013215686,
0.0810089633,
0.048734393,
0.1342877746,
-0.1437318623,
0.6876123548,
0.1823596358,
-0.4181856811,
-0.0831515938,
-0.1470001787,
-0.1786964834,
0.5307382941,
0.0686634257,
0.0704555064,
-0.0153193939,
-0.3985312879,
-0.2715241909,
-0.9642341733,
0.2859649658,
0.3534665704,
0.2396474928,
0.1697866023,
0.8349434733,
-0.2137665004,
0.6756556034,
-0.0377032384,
-0.2574399114,
-0.0729175135,
-0.1735756248,
0.0290037766,
0.0362616517,
0.5511589646,
0.0016977938,
0.1951930225,
0.1796180904,
-0.3846724331,
0.1845234483,
0.1782335341,
-0.3233537078,
-0.478338033,
-0.2202811092,
-0.3000789583,
-0.4240147769,
0.0149962595,
-0.4716819227,
-0.4837191701,
-0.2809939682,
0.3923854232,
-0.3268837631,
-0.3151635826,
0.0050079408,
-0.3899281919,
0.0708242282,
0.4572272301,
-0.7287557721,
0.264343977,
0.5088472366,
0.5453343987,
-0.2998591363,
-0.1406460553,
-0.824555099,
-0.0648516566,
-0.7691517472,
1.0156263113,
-0.598307848,
-0.2774004638,
-0.256167084,
-0.1434343904,
0.0107796704,
-0.3716292977,
0.4061302543,
-0.7152773142,
0.0750381276,
-0.609852016,
-0.4958011806,
-0.1000620425,
0.2140033543,
-0.5366643071,
1.0040601492,
0.3464788496,
-0.7470462322,
0.4509278238,
-0.6573469639,
-0.4173707962,
0.1019407958,
-0.5518764853,
-0.2475054562,
0.0649905279,
0.3473607898,
0.4476688504,
-0.1911038458,
0.2474103868,
-0.3068258166,
-0.3026956022,
0.546996057,
-0.6018078923,
0.5809028745,
0.0909945816,
-0.3836188316,
0.1085364968,
-0.6862075329,
0.2152842432,
0.0967949852,
-0.0188580081,
-0.4189814031,
0.1380762458,
-0.6249435544,
0.3412242532,
0.1309782416,
-0.1865708381,
0.2553768158,
-0.4117797911,
0.2705178857,
0.9117828012,
0.2624049187,
0.5211176872,
-0.3207416534,
0.6928956509,
0.0885877237,
-0.0718134195,
-0.143043533,
-0.4864462316,
-0.7493897676,
-0.1100855544,
-0.0122769792,
0.3227849603,
-0.9737930298,
0.626357913,
0.3118041456,
-0.3783913553,
-0.2289422452,
0.1092163324,
0.4927517474,
0.5801493526,
0.5233493447,
0.0303816516,
-0.4126503468,
-0.6500385404,
-0.1507846266,
-0.1178740934,
0.0398832113,
0.248532325,
0.4085927904,
0.0451487713,
0.8325559497,
-0.7954359055,
0.0797859281,
-0.3435614407,
0.2100993544,
0.3178746402,
0.2673539519,
0.1785602123,
-0.5820501447,
-0.1263643503,
-0.0238448344,
-0.7623444796,
-0.151884973,
-0.190486446,
-0.2983477414,
0.0990195274,
0.6682804227,
-0.3293165565,
0.7204502821,
0.177060172,
-0.3921477795,
0.7231966257,
-0.2669411898,
-0.0283922646,
-0.8824679852,
-0.016918987,
-0.228663981,
0.0137937786,
-0.2191839367,
-0.1629563868,
-0.0301127229,
-0.0571446754,
-0.2750464082,
0.540179491,
-0.5928868055,
-0.4437918067,
-0.2986239195,
0.2882160842,
0.0462915339,
0.6293478608,
0.2562868297,
1.1123509407,
0.6182528138,
-0.8466499448,
0.2339797467,
0.1937157959,
-0.2581455112,
0.3124867678,
-0.5580666065,
0.2288331538,
0.1490244269,
0.1836087555,
-0.8910946846,
0.151661858,
-0.0556888767,
-0.3378870785,
-0.1056855097,
-0.1999597251,
-0.3106607199,
-0.6014028192,
-0.0878579766,
0.3450120986,
0.4666965902,
-0.7766203284,
0.580055058,
0.2834279239,
-0.1665216386,
-0.6893740296,
-0.2511041462,
-0.3137362897,
0.0759986117,
-0.4705383778,
0.220349744,
-0.111976251,
-0.1657646,
-0.1887499839,
-0.4900218546,
0.10539563,
0.3394287527,
0.0694228783,
0.3944427073,
-0.082745187,
0.239484176,
0.3881329596,
-0.3478558958,
0.2523913085,
-0.514955759,
0.6439080834,
-0.1280937493,
-0.6793673635,
-0.1249349341,
0.2322021425,
0.4664567709,
-0.2934274971,
0.4472754002,
0.2519288063,
-0.3301381767,
-0.7580603361,
-0.4797951281,
-0.4288170636,
-0.4559902251,
-0.0068462971,
-0.5293552876,
-0.7790641785,
0.4303458035,
-0.3726247251,
-0.2184954435,
0.1547614336,
0.2610090673,
-0.0338032916,
1.0943564177,
0.4834512472,
0.4736648798,
0.3342821896,
-0.5329018235,
0.4681459963,
-0.9608896375,
-0.4587436318,
-0.1999919415,
0.018589532,
-0.2830794454,
-0.7758917809,
0.546411097,
0.4077221155,
-0.1249721497,
0.1145657822,
-0.500007093,
0.7534307241,
0.5623746514,
0.2673914731,
0.245853126,
-0.0475482158,
-0.8134458661,
0.1288425028,
-0.8031936288,
-0.6506280899,
0.9682517648,
0.0152135119,
0.7585936189,
-0.0205574725,
0.5451840162,
0.1924915165,
0.0154773807,
-0.759185195,
0.86617589,
0.0324318372,
-0.1242665574,
-0.4031852484,
-0.3261692226,
-0.7016895413,
0.1310702711,
-0.3744341135,
-0.4846837223,
-0.0910965577,
0.2359972,
-0.4427670538,
0.3998763859,
-0.5712698102,
0.5333245397,
-0.3112677336,
-0.5299921632,
-0.3879765272,
-0.4344525933,
0.2667132616,
-0.0260860864,
-0.0756361783,
0.0843749121,
0.0989534631,
0.7760627866,
-0.6409268379,
0.7010377049,
-0.208407566,
-0.1113281026,
0.4491915703,
0.2943857312,
0.6500778198,
0.1742538959,
0.0669429377,
-0.4111169279,
-0.278041333,
-0.2882139385,
-0.987098515,
0.6933912039,
-0.6894152761,
-0.7147815824,
-0.4891111255,
-0.3976872861,
-0.4781495035,
0.1576353461,
0.0303002801,
0.4761896133,
-0.1463831961,
-0.0169382859,
1.1290531158,
-0.1597761661,
0.411711663,
0.3331478238,
-0.0945266858,
-0.3231213391,
0.7063310742,
0.0124539416,
0.3251199722,
0.3681338727,
0.444932133,
-0.6174498796,
-0.3362634182,
-0.1801213622,
0.1481178701,
-0.8401646018,
-0.118743524,
-0.8164296746,
-0.4320734441,
-0.1456784308,
-0.4523789287,
-0.3035960495,
-0.3988277018,
-0.3486839831,
-0.4006072283,
0.5418319702,
0.8081567883,
0.0588024817,
-0.0067582214,
-0.2659155428,
0.3866973817,
0.7230109572,
0.2350637317,
0.2224947065,
-0.3370041251,
0.1867485046,
0.0734325945,
-0.4841126502,
-0.712257266,
0.2130235881,
-0.4158701003,
0.8057212234,
0.6055138707,
0.269435823,
0.6266925335,
-0.2988975942,
0.6779028773,
0.4179961681,
-0.9733931422,
0.867811203,
-0.1618783772,
-0.049364727,
0.1873310506,
0.4494654238,
-0.3237707317,
-0.1105876118,
-1.025536418,
-0.6313242912,
0.4119630754,
0.0167458206,
-0.3279212713,
-0.3723572195,
0.1924021989,
0.2659961879,
0.2063566595,
-0.2992468178,
-0.1013191342,
-0.071633026,
0.1452732682,
0.1132439971,
-0.1601894051,
-0.1558193117,
-0.2600922287,
0.4341388941,
-0.5897556543,
0.2192155123,
0.510735929,
-0.036109142,
-0.0560994111,
0.3446550965,
0.5997489095,
0.9848495126,
0.0748141184,
0.4787768126,
0.3592430949,
-0.0794103965,
0.1814250946,
-0.3599288762,
0.0746196434,
-0.2331990004,
0.3713288903,
0.8391386271,
0.1538452208,
-0.7566567063,
0.7410270572,
0.1783751398,
-0.357132107,
-0.5813301206,
0.341175437,
0.0283853207,
0.3205115497,
0.5532391071,
0.2699479759,
-0.1376063228,
-0.5047356486,
0.3185268939,
0.5331717134,
-0.2323743999,
-0.1962643266,
0.3658512235,
0.0647090152,
-0.4333908856,
0.6258940101,
-0.4546891451,
-0.7355635166,
0.5921307206,
0.5560280681,
0.6440882087,
0.0786729231,
0.3683772683,
0.1515118927,
0.0345919393,
-0.2239666581,
0.5450908542,
-0.2719704211,
-0.9498574138,
-0.5016448498,
-0.1277887076,
-0.5063524246,
0.1665432751,
-0.6050904989,
0.3813809454,
-0.7466289401,
0.017437268,
-0.1574032456,
0.1927402616,
-0.5814918876,
0.1346187592,
0.0178040247,
0.8377720714,
-0.9151114225,
0.6693967581,
0.5326011777,
-0.2833065093,
-1.0813928843,
-0.0862180218,
-0.1219229922,
-0.8725745082,
0.59905231,
-0.001177569,
-0.2778520584,
-0.0271201748,
-0.723700285,
-0.5143755674,
1.3069442511,
0.0128953904,
-0.4389822781,
0.0278418828,
-0.3985402882,
0.4299732149,
-0.7425301075,
0.4969284832,
0.2819198966,
0.1446118057,
0.5257757902,
-0.5606917143,
0.1965692043,
-0.0889184922,
0.0558867306,
0.1601456404,
-0.3221554756,
0.9400041103,
-0.8677538633,
0.0003542669,
-0.0958551541,
0.6712420583,
1.0264298916,
0.526233077,
0.6783888936,
0.421042949,
1.1956541538,
0.0845268741,
0.7146705985,
0.0305208508,
-0.1056355461,
1.0002506971,
-0.4665161967,
0.9158160686,
0.6610739827,
-0.0798764229,
0.8629631996,
0.5367665887,
0.2071557492,
0.5947409272,
0.4723761082,
-0.4188598096,
-0.5759436488,
-0.1323847175,
-0.2411518693,
0.0890099928,
0.4285364449,
-0.2686150074,
-0.0509473272,
-0.0919903815,
-0.2318121493,
0.3854746222,
-0.2436248511,
0.7827717066,
0.0150153451,
-0.9546918869,
0.4875643253,
-0.3372189701,
0.4103571773,
-0.5137456656,
-0.5146814585,
-0.1469199508,
0.0729208067,
-0.0515268221,
-1.0893511772,
0.0993083939,
-0.1067713648,
-0.3259361982,
-0.3652565777,
0.6319036484,
-0.2773540318,
-0.2815918922,
0.3584463894,
0.8219045401,
0.1205621511,
0.0091688614,
-0.3763974309,
-0.1970796436,
-0.0469013602,
-0.0564048402,
0.1748266071,
0.975712955,
-0.5083215833,
0.8613308668,
1.1497756243,
0.1524261981,
-0.0908404663,
0.3016109765,
1.309571743,
-0.7913892269,
-0.5809271932,
-0.5319846869,
0.3737904429,
-0.3429428935,
-0.3592197895,
0.4365713,
0.4376872778,
0.840052247,
-0.1368665844,
0.9329057932,
0.148554787,
0.5533941388,
-0.7745372057,
0.2483693957,
-0.2421900928,
0.5935103893,
-0.3627765477,
-0.6313326955,
0.0128167802,
1.0040094852,
-0.4193207324,
-0.0548467189,
1.333823204,
0.9693703055,
0.0671049803,
0.1781316996,
0.367179513,
-0.1818449646,
0.3689471483,
0.6846821904,
1.139123559,
-0.1738308668,
0.3319265246,
-0.2322610319,
-0.5063263178,
0.1221142709,
-1.1011571884,
-1.3420444727,
-0.6880338192,
-0.2640812099,
-0.3066216707,
-0.1484373212,
1.1633139849,
0.5234079361,
-0.5895906687,
-0.1074717417,
-0.5085981488,
0.5395600796,
-0.4993639886,
-0.2175490111,
0.316588521,
-0.3962640166,
-0.0910153836,
0.6915239692,
0.2547749877,
0.1454060674,
-0.2518546283,
-0.1680044234,
-0.3645913601,
0.014035292,
0.6126840711,
0.1284249127,
-0.8018887639,
-0.1292209625,
0.341098696,
0.1635274142,
-0.3067575991,
1.1887960434,
-1.0649204254,
0.1387674809,
0.5417662859,
0.5726441145,
0.463768065,
-0.0426073,
0.5952907801,
-0.7817014456,
0.1719046384,
0.4157440662,
0.3378770649,
0.1456325948,
-0.3160166442,
0.5131250024,
0.5775264502,
-0.3022599816,
-0.6389519572,
0.4428646863,
-0.9477271438,
-0.3288817704,
1.1756427288,
-0.1217568889,
-0.2318782061,
-0.2979565561,
-0.3570099473,
0.0621081628,
-0.2973566949,
0.5966579914,
0.54465276,
-0.2078537494,
-0.3546052277,
-0.0396056287,
0.5067243576,
0.3617032766,
-0.6227341294,
0.2212972492,
0.2359545976,
0.050085105,
0.1907240152,
0.7136211395,
-0.0652640536,
0.3617878258,
-0.0625278503,
-0.0619410798,
-0.0876932815,
-0.6583974361,
0.0800641477,
0.0773492083,
0.2395722866,
0.1665804386
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04668v1
|
TOD-Flow: Modeling the Structure of Task-Oriented Dialogues
| 2023-12-07T20:06:23 | 2023-12-07T20:06:23 |
Sungryull Sohn, Yiwei Lyu, Anthony Liu, Lajanugen Logeswaran, Dong-Ki Kim, Dongsub Shim, Honglak Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Task-Oriented Dialogue (TOD) systems have become crucial components in
interactive artificial intelligence applications. While recent advances have
capitalized on pre-trained language models (PLMs), they exhibit limitations
regarding transparency and controllability. To address these challenges, we
propose a novel approach focusing on inferring the TOD-Flow graph from dialogue
data annotated with dialog acts, uncovering the underlying task structure in
the form of a graph. The inferred TOD-Flow graph can be easily integrated with
any dialogue model to improve its prediction performance, transparency, and
controllability. Our TOD-Flow graph learns what a model can, should, and should
not predict, effectively reducing the search space and providing a rationale
for the model's prediction. We show that the proposed TOD-Flow graph better
resembles human-annotated graphs compared to prior approaches. Furthermore,
when combined with several dialogue policies and end-to-end dialogue models, we
demonstrate that our approach significantly improves dialog act classification
and end-to-end response generation performance in the MultiWOZ and SGD
benchmarks. Code available at: https://github.com/srsohn/TOD-Flow
|
[
-0.1264630705,
-0.8063524365,
0.5862021446,
0.0404274091,
-0.2772445977,
0.3754822612,
0.0040894565,
-0.4643062055,
0.1039452702,
0.9831513762,
-0.8117666841,
-0.4374710321,
-0.7153359056,
-0.1349212825,
-0.2639940381,
1.0170179605,
0.0489222407,
0.1167549342,
-0.3386792243,
-0.0330277532,
-0.2720559835,
-0.4188714027,
-0.8185728192,
-0.5958942175,
0.4365713894,
-0.003291195,
0.4904070199,
0.4096440971,
0.0369492806,
0.4072274268,
0.0101347556,
0.17251876,
-0.379560858,
0.5514485836,
0.2118327022,
-0.3427253366,
-0.6380178928,
-0.0247985367,
0.3739643097,
0.7821620107,
-0.1594448835,
-0.1625720412,
0.2537508905,
0.247036159,
-0.183524549,
0.7720091939,
-0.4336566329,
-0.0941452682,
-0.2699687779,
-0.229670763,
-0.6554861069,
-0.0542363934,
0.4429450929,
-0.6123151779,
-0.25438416,
0.0459444858,
0.5063256025,
0.4346786439,
-0.3075181842,
-0.3972007632,
-0.601143539,
0.4562569857,
-0.6918696761,
0.2682567239,
0.4325985014,
0.4537755251,
-0.4036010504,
-0.9061791897,
-0.5247812271,
-0.456078887,
-0.1074493751,
0.1421900094,
0.0479593314,
0.5061085224,
0.1709753722,
-0.0623159148,
-0.4263395369,
-0.2263240963,
-0.1119872555,
-0.2560995221,
0.4313580692,
0.2750763297,
0.2593422532,
-0.1669920683,
-0.3195104897,
-0.0117909601,
-0.331936866,
0.2557086051,
0.2680900991,
0.5421354771,
-0.2975968719,
0.4955315888,
-0.3659218252,
0.792748034,
0.0268998388,
-0.3046840727,
0.2331525534,
-0.2863177359,
-0.312032342,
-0.2815959454,
0.8569201231,
0.0887192637,
0.2762761116,
-0.2392373383,
-0.0150732566,
-0.3204057813,
0.207786113,
-0.8458706737,
-0.3472090662,
0.2192998528,
-0.2069909573,
-0.0318735279,
-0.0600197837,
-0.4417150915,
-0.5287517905,
-0.4261152446,
0.170584172,
-0.3704144061,
-0.1558920145,
-0.3305772245,
-0.1200920865,
-0.2404358834,
0.7830367088,
-0.1967057884,
0.4104484022,
0.5837189555,
0.8829267025,
-0.1590685695,
-0.0406713597,
-0.7760030031,
0.3231987059,
-0.0617425442,
0.5913785696,
-0.7791366577,
-0.4675343633,
-0.2350937277,
-0.1415548921,
-0.3093128502,
-0.3116419315,
0.4067233205,
-0.3008999527,
0.2305766493,
0.3214337528,
-0.5328981876,
-0.2006840259,
0.2569812536,
-0.6141370535,
0.6298648119,
0.2181402892,
-0.7099515796,
0.0363917165,
-1.1175931692,
-0.3319140077,
0.1332770437,
-0.1368882656,
-0.2445449233,
-0.1455441415,
0.0474404916,
0.4139687121,
-0.288066715,
0.4962666035,
-0.4191098511,
0.0338568874,
0.2348072976,
-0.3615505695,
1.0478166342,
0.2331844121,
-0.3104510307,
0.5501140356,
-0.589615345,
0.1227890849,
-0.2540034652,
0.000893591,
-0.1457551122,
0.1002893075,
-0.3900786936,
0.1781096756,
-0.0173484441,
-0.7855425477,
-0.033758834,
-0.3897733688,
0.5274208784,
0.8067868352,
-0.1213647425,
0.3775144517,
-0.1950744838,
0.6780404449,
0.1519130021,
0.2731558084,
-0.1979331523,
-0.7806376219,
-0.4846333861,
-0.5371330976,
0.1307293177,
0.5460311174,
-0.9728274941,
0.1151513904,
-0.1895552278,
-0.4048977494,
-0.2709514797,
-0.0680271164,
0.6754622459,
0.8678478599,
-0.0379817933,
-0.4327025115,
-0.3224879205,
-0.5119481087,
-0.1616820097,
-0.5090766549,
0.0112480288,
0.6656997204,
0.1610639542,
-0.0083274227,
0.8860804439,
-0.4375241101,
-0.0737429559,
-0.4266960323,
0.4506419003,
-0.0141141592,
0.444626987,
0.2753212154,
-0.716591239,
-0.7028774023,
0.1224640831,
-0.3478169441,
-0.2414734811,
0.18716003,
-0.3379896581,
0.0992689878,
0.4184725285,
-0.7483893633,
0.7511715889,
0.52377671,
-0.5777511597,
0.3920517266,
0.0319537222,
-0.067912735,
-0.9562475681,
-0.0097809536,
-0.0448116772,
-0.6144229174,
-0.7892369032,
-0.2979650199,
-0.2683993578,
-0.3823123872,
-0.2420213968,
0.7059969902,
-0.120176591,
-0.1401401907,
-0.2721938789,
-0.0435414165,
-0.0511186086,
1.0235310793,
0.0534273311,
0.7869105935,
0.5633110404,
-0.5690653324,
0.1062525287,
0.3206693828,
-0.1942088306,
0.4208449125,
-0.6008076072,
0.3972302377,
-0.1856992245,
0.6908535361,
-1.0411900282,
-0.3606098294,
0.5575216413,
-0.4953182042,
0.385312587,
-0.5840197206,
-0.3777725101,
-0.0989876986,
0.0041517536,
0.2748691142,
0.3403429389,
-0.2214461267,
1.0621738434,
0.666066587,
-0.5929707289,
-0.3541988134,
-0.0976019278,
-0.1357910335,
-0.0426748246,
-0.53841573,
0.2009701133,
-0.3599322736,
-0.1463420093,
-0.2329780459,
-0.1229751408,
-0.4516493678,
0.1506327987,
0.8744140267,
0.1686142385,
0.2550247908,
-0.0903774723,
0.0107782958,
-0.0649823025,
0.135594368,
-0.4671034515,
0.710770905,
0.1304339021,
-0.3170365691,
-0.7809162736,
0.2926000357,
0.9388973117,
-0.3069489598,
0.3569021821,
0.3555389941,
-0.0942895338,
-0.2965148091,
-0.0593602024,
-0.078987211,
-0.4781273603,
0.2100417614,
-0.3746482432,
-0.6911430359,
0.4277598262,
-0.2176668197,
0.2227418423,
0.0751197562,
0.3609983325,
-0.3886032403,
1.3070789576,
0.6468983293,
0.1451367438,
0.8189837933,
-0.3250496686,
0.1696016639,
-0.846006155,
-0.5560271144,
-0.5914359689,
-0.2283504307,
-0.4040168524,
-0.5525068045,
0.4600103199,
0.0373607837,
-0.2022578716,
0.1819039434,
-0.1149024218,
-0.0346514508,
0.5680678487,
0.1013180614,
0.2883783281,
-0.0220087282,
-0.2025546283,
0.2179249227,
-0.6012408733,
-0.4849267006,
1.0554536581,
0.4228463173,
0.5993452072,
-0.0893747061,
0.5627585053,
0.2684359848,
0.6024469137,
-0.6991690397,
0.7507013083,
-0.027535392,
-0.3614520729,
-0.5509807467,
-0.46306023,
-0.8394372463,
0.1638888568,
0.2016620487,
-1.1108853817,
-0.1707770526,
0.1636978686,
-0.1897971779,
0.1579521149,
-0.9092838168,
0.7623539567,
-0.0106703173,
-0.0732135251,
-0.0495044701,
-0.6432241201,
0.1037824452,
0.2695654929,
0.1589677781,
-0.4178656638,
0.3746977746,
0.7439503074,
-0.8988324404,
1.2129346132,
-0.558326304,
-0.0886965394,
0.5121983886,
0.0943229944,
0.7629832625,
0.0710018277,
-0.0086772926,
-0.0365585014,
-0.2068559527,
-0.2185049504,
-0.8482052088,
0.3918156028,
-0.6035776138,
-0.5697342157,
0.0319086872,
-0.9338438511,
-0.4489693642,
0.143107757,
-0.0616930462,
0.9319972992,
0.1528015882,
-0.1150592789,
0.1980613917,
0.2656910121,
0.4958302975,
0.2140635103,
-0.2393836528,
-0.3857063055,
0.6942960024,
-0.0168924741,
0.3649170697,
0.2166586816,
0.0134441769,
-0.533319056,
-0.7929531932,
-0.5144342184,
0.1031801403,
-0.3972115219,
-0.0799911916,
-0.7400727272,
-0.1433018893,
-0.3280335665,
0.3746764958,
-0.1603387296,
-0.5205878019,
-0.2294622511,
-0.0165928528,
0.3134062886,
0.8053616285,
0.4191472828,
0.3967275023,
-0.5296523571,
0.2809285522,
0.3228929937,
0.6013758183,
-0.1351665407,
-0.3748444617,
0.021775756,
0.3042797446,
-0.5191710591,
-0.8493745923,
0.3160508275,
0.2713643014,
0.5433185101,
0.3494678736,
0.3580767214,
0.8358219266,
-0.4022351801,
0.6333526969,
0.2431033552,
-0.9234938025,
0.5541736484,
-0.3571919203,
0.1198135912,
0.3361245096,
-0.0218831245,
-0.1135781109,
-0.9573289156,
-0.5937497616,
-0.5801930428,
0.8917770982,
0.4348410368,
-0.0219750814,
0.1475242674,
0.1679708362,
0.2768606544,
0.4626744986,
-0.6392136216,
-0.2353166342,
-0.400529772,
-0.4925625026,
0.0328032076,
0.1754585505,
-0.2529504299,
-0.1143472418,
0.4043789506,
-0.4028481543,
0.3337275684,
0.2543346584,
-0.1054005697,
-0.0824953541,
0.1387621313,
0.4807306826,
0.7082993388,
-0.1801462322,
-0.044015795,
-0.2692654431,
-0.4225867689,
-0.1090619415,
0.1873744428,
-0.0928132758,
0.0284880158,
0.2195957452,
1.2065639496,
-0.1019910946,
-1.0449199677,
0.3104778528,
0.0086572785,
-0.073458083,
-0.1637763828,
0.2474042624,
-0.1601189673,
0.678316474,
0.2070845217,
0.0934914276,
0.2929902673,
-0.7686489224,
0.0560842901,
0.6507067084,
-0.5768523216,
-0.4300233126,
0.509336412,
0.501473248,
-0.6373103857,
0.4247358739,
-0.3088991046,
-0.6059605479,
0.5058714151,
0.3593915701,
1.0092405081,
0.0467289574,
0.6070044041,
0.1536379009,
-0.299285233,
0.3638850152,
0.3835201859,
-0.5379084945,
-0.4501482844,
-0.6811367273,
-0.3958061635,
-0.6294267178,
0.0224882942,
-0.4351235628,
-0.2467291504,
-0.4778559506,
-0.4367283285,
-0.1165012866,
-0.007255652,
-0.5337949991,
0.1927289069,
0.1526720524,
0.6195166111,
-0.3657993078,
0.9366135597,
0.6238465905,
0.0165357478,
-0.7298870683,
0.0823797882,
-0.1304335743,
-0.5440260172,
0.774107337,
0.1595172733,
-0.3691703677,
0.0348259844,
-0.493586719,
-0.7550168037,
1.1042479277,
0.4347935915,
-0.2484049499,
-0.1105926558,
-0.0936877578,
0.449072063,
-0.7919246554,
0.4173837304,
0.265748769,
0.3210925758,
0.3358695805,
-1.2095909119,
-0.1077851877,
-0.3945097327,
-0.0686375275,
0.3202288449,
-0.3004226983,
0.778968513,
-0.2312429398,
-0.433380425,
0.2378243953,
0.4816226959,
0.4902599156,
0.649936378,
0.7173885107,
0.3219051957,
0.8011515737,
-0.2880083621,
1.0773277283,
-0.319971323,
-0.0901887193,
1.3584432602,
-0.2203895599,
0.6814255118,
0.4192947447,
0.0281915702,
0.7266786098,
0.3272461295,
0.5442726016,
0.6917407513,
0.1019051895,
-0.0106800124,
-0.1000419259,
-0.4623754323,
0.2015627176,
0.4018166065,
0.5226625204,
-0.1053881645,
-0.1276567131,
0.0693762526,
-0.0611869283,
-0.1470155418,
-0.3347414136,
0.9522740245,
-0.2195703089,
-0.8156508207,
0.3401101232,
-0.4290845692,
0.2962842584,
-0.5993119478,
-0.1275192797,
-0.0077602761,
-0.2978962064,
0.0971482024,
-0.81768471,
0.1327605397,
0.0824930817,
0.1035027206,
-0.4823546112,
0.5954454541,
-0.6254069209,
-0.115988493,
0.2861036956,
0.6203485131,
0.1875373125,
-0.0660880283,
-0.6421040297,
-0.1012931168,
0.1659782827,
-0.1751371771,
0.1152060404,
0.4374316037,
-0.2555080652,
1.0595128536,
0.546782136,
-0.0346474499,
0.20336999,
0.2784464955,
0.8235598803,
-0.3855566084,
-0.8058073521,
-0.3796558082,
0.8577729464,
-0.4375069737,
-0.1920378357,
0.2898589373,
0.1506360918,
0.6563040614,
0.2560369372,
0.9319691062,
-0.1164417341,
0.6531202793,
-0.4887563586,
0.6124812961,
-0.330560267,
0.1075339094,
-0.2348617166,
-0.4683125913,
0.1010909304,
0.3286088109,
-0.1144739985,
0.2209766656,
0.430426687,
0.6799573898,
0.1291546673,
0.0691108704,
0.18572326,
0.3939575553,
0.5249156952,
0.3966611922,
0.8491271734,
0.0271687116,
0.6649534106,
-0.3349861503,
-0.0898612738,
-0.1463007927,
-0.6883262992,
-1.051268816,
-0.8490784168,
-0.407720983,
-0.1739821285,
-0.0505218618,
0.6003995538,
1.08289814,
-0.56339854,
-0.3613210022,
-0.5287887454,
0.2798696756,
-0.1830571294,
-0.1717308313,
0.0938709378,
-0.3186889291,
-1.0795891285,
0.5075597763,
0.4599911571,
0.3667805791,
-0.1135745123,
-0.4389844239,
0.2325070649,
0.140852496,
0.6023806334,
0.3106936812,
-1.0732877254,
-0.1499566138,
-0.2097679675,
0.120046854,
0.0336974785,
1.0931524038,
-0.7889957428,
0.7154625654,
0.4304512739,
0.3970006406,
0.5815858841,
0.1609711498,
0.9503259063,
-0.8058764935,
0.157120809,
0.4412692785,
0.3107080162,
0.137631014,
-0.0866642445,
0.3864488304,
-0.0037913544,
-0.1294469982,
-0.8853521347,
0.5589808822,
-1.2523846626,
-0.2785877287,
0.6848620772,
-0.4640650749,
-0.1981071234,
-0.5828729868,
-0.4429467022,
0.4303317964,
-0.6864815354,
0.4389017224,
0.4422893226,
-0.5983785987,
-0.2929213047,
-0.5618221164,
0.6141232252,
0.2233864665,
-1.0328925848,
0.3009488583,
0.4480453134,
0.0618466102,
0.241832912,
0.8670128584,
-0.0179028828,
0.0278251935,
-0.3242604136,
-0.379273355,
-0.4862494469,
-0.614603281,
0.1562397182,
0.439304322,
0.0350309536,
-0.2426276803
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06674v1
|
Llama Guard: LLM-based Input-Output Safeguard for Human-AI Conversations
| 2023-12-07T19:40:50 | 2023-12-07T19:40:50 |
Hakan Inan, Kartikeya Upasani, Jianfeng Chi, Rashi Rungta, Krithika Iyer, Yuning Mao, Michael Tontchev, Qing Hu, Brian Fuller, Davide Testuggine, Madian Khabsa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We introduce Llama Guard, an LLM-based input-output safeguard model geared
towards Human-AI conversation use cases. Our model incorporates a safety risk
taxonomy, a valuable tool for categorizing a specific set of safety risks found
in LLM prompts (i.e., prompt classification). This taxonomy is also
instrumental in classifying the responses generated by LLMs to these prompts, a
process we refer to as response classification. For the purpose of both prompt
and response classification, we have meticulously gathered a dataset of high
quality. Llama Guard, a Llama2-7b model that is instruction-tuned on our
collected dataset, albeit low in volume, demonstrates strong performance on
existing benchmarks such as the OpenAI Moderation Evaluation dataset and
ToxicChat, where its performance matches or exceeds that of currently available
content moderation tools. Llama Guard functions as a language model, carrying
out multi-class classification and generating binary decision scores.
Furthermore, the instruction fine-tuning of Llama Guard allows for the
customization of tasks and the adaptation of output formats. This feature
enhances the model's capabilities, such as enabling the adjustment of taxonomy
categories to align with specific use cases, and facilitating zero-shot or
few-shot prompting with diverse taxonomies at the input. We are making Llama
Guard model weights available and we encourage researchers to further develop
and adapt them to meet the evolving needs of the community for AI safety.
|
[
-0.1838102341,
-0.8722288013,
0.3224419057,
0.142245546,
-0.1530270576,
0.3163928092,
0.3437537551,
-0.6748775244,
0.0078092567,
0.768738687,
-0.4331888258,
-0.5602926016,
-0.8306902051,
0.1051332206,
-0.3286853433,
1.1457637548,
0.0633069873,
-0.1457070857,
-0.2545138299,
0.2096356899,
-0.8548235893,
-0.7776224613,
-0.9406765103,
-0.3734640479,
0.6010634899,
0.5296913385,
0.485761404,
0.6819936633,
0.6145356894,
0.2742765546,
-0.1309726536,
0.107243754,
-0.2539857328,
0.3409510553,
0.0760416165,
-0.6380775571,
-0.731589973,
0.0694875717,
0.2120318413,
0.048272647,
-0.4314017296,
0.1019972786,
-0.0380681902,
0.1637227535,
-0.5738476515,
0.0890614837,
-0.7391762137,
0.0139669273,
-0.2004011422,
-0.3905052543,
-0.5814735293,
-0.0639855117,
-0.0078441501,
-0.2255969346,
-0.4464434683,
0.118587926,
0.6368052959,
0.6207946539,
-0.5147074461,
-0.0494545624,
-0.6822208166,
0.6648697853,
-0.4685524106,
-0.0527783148,
0.7760750651,
0.4151152968,
-0.0967098624,
-0.634822011,
-0.4701264501,
-0.2663461566,
0.1311831176,
0.0752092823,
-0.4673545361,
0.3700345159,
-0.1009801179,
-0.0366937555,
-0.2398488224,
0.6232771873,
-0.16736193,
-0.4377599359,
0.8601685762,
0.5993897915,
0.3849489391,
0.05353228,
-0.571557641,
-0.2670578957,
-1.0681842566,
0.2661777139,
0.366733402,
0.0187416729,
-0.1679470986,
0.327039808,
-0.2883349657,
0.4657407701,
-0.1264903247,
-0.4386216104,
-0.2760380507,
-0.1661684513,
-0.0395434424,
0.1707960665,
0.9513275027,
0.6970413327,
-0.0093852403,
0.0222238582,
-0.2105232179,
0.1128831506,
0.4812552333,
-0.8377277255,
-0.132190153,
0.0099705588,
-0.4141637683,
-0.939240098,
-0.0775250047,
-0.8173464537,
-0.7362395525,
0.0476094969,
0.1754106879,
0.0510744229,
-0.023474047,
0.0534405522,
0.2166340053,
0.3001159132,
0.4005564749,
-0.8699944615,
0.4307307303,
0.6548343897,
0.8141643405,
-0.5818840265,
-0.0274278335,
-0.6311638951,
0.2815503478,
-0.1510687172,
0.965444684,
-0.66124475,
-0.765188992,
-0.0084461886,
-0.2604953647,
0.0115785263,
-0.3354168534,
0.6489865184,
-0.6673578024,
0.0560042635,
0.1885883659,
-0.289218843,
-0.3210859895,
0.5573854446,
-0.4368373752,
0.6654274464,
-0.1739312857,
-0.7616207004,
0.2046360075,
-0.7291703224,
-0.3887940049,
0.1355616748,
-0.1303422451,
-0.4376212955,
-0.5291597247,
0.2215914279,
0.3875295222,
-0.4438377023,
0.1416566372,
-0.4677567482,
-0.3541051447,
0.4240549207,
-0.783389926,
0.5530096292,
0.2500517964,
-0.1884588301,
0.6120868921,
-0.4630644917,
-0.1373148859,
0.0366160087,
-0.7022383809,
-0.134728983,
0.371960789,
-0.1157368571,
0.1279268414,
0.2714152336,
-0.5402802229,
-0.0111426031,
-0.1200479716,
0.6866562963,
1.0700762272,
0.2683508992,
0.3097872734,
-0.6034744978,
0.7589154243,
0.009297302,
0.5073832273,
-0.1520006806,
-0.6477844715,
-0.6662983298,
-0.2429185659,
0.0543164387,
1.1599788666,
-0.6415905952,
0.6878148317,
0.014648336,
-0.5943211317,
-0.4113944173,
0.0555474646,
0.413286984,
0.6535185575,
0.1824490279,
-0.5571761131,
-0.4164532721,
-0.6442936063,
0.2151391953,
-0.8664398193,
-0.0261324737,
0.2764965892,
0.0905121118,
-0.514657855,
0.7207221389,
-0.4774889946,
-0.2234991789,
-0.3662839532,
0.04291052,
-0.0569291934,
0.3161046803,
0.5368216634,
-0.5336687565,
-0.1319512427,
-0.2281267941,
-0.6439733505,
-0.2520266473,
-0.1123198271,
-0.4778865874,
0.1912679672,
0.5434457064,
-0.7237356901,
0.7588580251,
0.277772367,
-0.262201339,
0.3844338059,
0.1993308216,
-0.0280412026,
-1.104999423,
-0.1320478171,
-0.1303537786,
-0.2404692918,
-0.8586189151,
-0.0428613797,
-0.2538927495,
-0.0152966231,
-0.7243131399,
0.540327847,
0.3217034936,
0.1445072591,
-0.4721568227,
-0.2682659328,
-0.0320894383,
0.3490034938,
0.0900780559,
1.0448900461,
0.494453907,
-0.9430274963,
0.4224647582,
0.5246546865,
-0.1032479256,
0.5730631351,
-0.9357347488,
0.470613867,
0.3358774185,
0.4067528844,
-0.726580143,
-0.4291580319,
0.6662080288,
-0.2734977603,
0.3098190725,
-0.1308847666,
-0.3772071898,
-0.3798600733,
-0.6426979303,
0.15771465,
0.4624602199,
-0.4123062193,
0.4395596385,
0.78737849,
-0.5118802786,
-0.7587113976,
-0.526396811,
0.3452087343,
-0.7426379323,
-0.6123663187,
0.2543490529,
-0.3670349717,
-0.2975458801,
-0.4363946915,
-0.1021021977,
-0.1065370664,
0.7590616345,
0.5631119609,
0.76179111,
0.1178332716,
-0.0597169884,
0.0782250166,
-0.0940666348,
0.4135841429,
0.2277153432,
0.7054983377,
-0.0343082845,
-0.3908235431,
-0.6744213104,
0.3775549829,
0.3817951381,
-0.2238329351,
0.6106200218,
0.3518921137,
-0.1974618882,
0.0725538284,
-0.2486416996,
-0.3811817169,
-0.5835357904,
0.2670823336,
0.1032732353,
-1.026727438,
0.3517423272,
0.1513141096,
0.3773594499,
0.1922363937,
0.6585820913,
-0.420766443,
1.1143481731,
0.7744709253,
-0.5319730043,
0.67906183,
0.1703189909,
0.009202403,
-0.5718185306,
-0.3718960881,
-0.4058701396,
-0.2895370424,
-0.469201386,
0.0116074905,
0.6108354926,
-0.2495725602,
-0.5198239088,
0.2167994529,
-0.5405825377,
0.4269102216,
0.7540763617,
0.1836218536,
0.2059348524,
-0.0891653895,
0.4699490666,
0.2692765296,
-0.4850507677,
-1.077354908,
1.2050894499,
0.6776396036,
1.2635352612,
0.2494643033,
0.8518180847,
0.760035336,
0.4034718871,
-0.8817965388,
0.8388209343,
0.2170892656,
-0.3671615124,
-0.1391053051,
-0.355140686,
-1.0364495516,
-0.0474405102,
-0.1738572419,
-0.9458711743,
-0.2002082616,
0.2815871835,
-0.6028773785,
0.3051892221,
-0.5709030032,
0.4825864732,
-0.4661739469,
-0.0455664955,
-0.2702046633,
-0.7545955777,
0.7153719664,
0.0443241112,
-0.2307060957,
-0.3321750164,
-0.0707851201,
0.8295401335,
-0.2694240212,
1.4182239771,
0.0466981903,
-0.1613611728,
0.6652028561,
0.2640125751,
0.2976676822,
0.2876211405,
0.1804396957,
0.3575557768,
0.0620190986,
0.099388577,
-0.1749805659,
0.3362132907,
-1.0570976734,
-1.0732359886,
-0.473490715,
-0.5509023666,
-0.0918683335,
0.0534518659,
0.1843927205,
0.0008902058,
-0.0608274452,
0.0482022986,
0.7300702929,
-0.3962145746,
0.5441753864,
0.4778985083,
0.0607654825,
-0.3266707361,
0.7835014462,
-0.2381187975,
0.218738988,
0.485897541,
0.0165463053,
-0.2666836083,
-0.5102834702,
-0.4258612096,
-0.224765867,
-0.665581584,
-0.8715187311,
-0.5246762633,
-0.632753551,
-0.302179426,
0.1352059543,
0.2182295322,
-0.40484339,
-0.6106706858,
-0.4365294874,
0.655356586,
0.8024910092,
0.1310002357,
0.7629451752,
-0.8259783983,
0.1270067841,
0.5538833737,
0.0859120339,
-0.2762026191,
-0.613158524,
0.1909016967,
-0.2075715959,
-0.8813117743,
-0.9569732547,
0.3659197986,
0.1954345256,
0.609695971,
0.5624107122,
0.427251339,
0.1241810322,
-0.3245101869,
0.7667127848,
0.1185432896,
-0.6786976457,
0.7195757627,
-0.3032701612,
-0.1530059874,
0.4687548578,
0.0583177693,
-0.6720763445,
-0.1792291105,
-0.3156693578,
-0.802549243,
0.8337761164,
0.0552088693,
0.2887338698,
-0.0841923729,
0.0768505931,
-0.0703598037,
0.1334572583,
-0.7546966076,
0.1340362281,
-0.2052396089,
-0.2760831118,
0.3103351593,
-0.393238306,
-0.6291185021,
0.2243576944,
0.4920760691,
-0.1747155935,
0.4331076741,
-0.1883089393,
-0.11610993,
-0.0394460633,
0.4504681528,
0.6332047582,
-0.0586887375,
-0.0911473483,
0.3666205406,
0.4545188844,
-0.6829385161,
0.3435885906,
0.0407465324,
-0.3449199796,
-0.6639129519,
0.4140563011,
0.7568727732,
-0.062874347,
-0.7600312233,
0.399199903,
-0.2882176042,
0.08022324,
-0.1854128093,
0.7041521072,
-0.3774665892,
0.1141822785,
0.0408890918,
0.1343100518,
0.2086892575,
-0.3315561116,
0.2947516739,
0.2797253728,
-0.1455005407,
-0.2620052695,
0.8969587088,
0.5288797617,
-0.4767305851,
0.5808032751,
-0.0076309233,
-0.5053100586,
0.7752745152,
0.3838648796,
0.8936570883,
-0.3741713464,
0.2345476449,
0.0616148338,
0.3559935987,
0.1659729779,
0.2116544247,
-0.0483233482,
-0.8013277054,
-0.0669368953,
-0.4612632394,
-0.7738150358,
0.0957401246,
-0.5466911793,
0.160808295,
-0.9824389219,
-0.4705980718,
-0.3841469884,
-0.252050519,
-0.3678780794,
-0.1344271451,
0.4611608386,
1.0212614536,
-0.7203266025,
0.6832820177,
0.404938519,
-0.4139923155,
-0.6542660594,
0.0044956198,
0.3173188269,
-1.0329834223,
0.3919420838,
0.3935565352,
-0.318179369,
-0.432333082,
-0.8191184998,
-0.7768127918,
1.3699806929,
0.3667710125,
-0.3612322807,
0.0224645622,
0.2160129249,
0.4327513278,
-0.4645412564,
0.1064293608,
0.7763438225,
0.2645585239,
-0.0719289035,
-0.7362725139,
-0.1485523432,
-0.3451878428,
0.0261504836,
-0.1912489235,
-0.6769499779,
0.5192809105,
-0.0620124228,
-0.2778047919,
0.2493266165,
0.6986831427,
0.6056577563,
0.4777971804,
0.5057898164,
0.3103497028,
0.739913106,
-0.1339194179,
1.1835486889,
-0.2269795239,
-0.4497390687,
1.0727717876,
-0.5154759884,
0.9717334509,
0.2275730819,
-0.0811536312,
0.4828792512,
1.0714594126,
0.1098554134,
0.5693221092,
-0.0243907981,
-0.5154234171,
-0.2765807509,
-0.6116234064,
-0.1544403583,
0.6506775618,
0.5285090804,
-0.0751485378,
0.2358427793,
-0.2531813681,
0.2818595767,
-0.1825914979,
-0.4438247085,
0.9703172445,
0.1430255473,
-0.7006950974,
0.2309083194,
0.0749940425,
0.8975549936,
-0.565808773,
-0.0443041995,
-0.3779493272,
0.0216343943,
-0.0876677781,
-1.134365797,
0.2870898843,
0.4228197038,
0.0160966571,
-0.1939704269,
0.9503390193,
-0.2379476577,
-0.2431565225,
0.1871614009,
0.0926227421,
0.1400054991,
0.3116796613,
-0.6480535269,
0.1321086138,
-0.2356344759,
-0.1277748793,
0.3706454337,
-0.0647705495,
-0.5475052595,
1.0180037022,
0.5701414943,
-0.2086939812,
0.2131936103,
0.0261690505,
0.9812459946,
-0.2456926405,
-0.4726082385,
-0.8245714903,
0.3448291719,
-0.0632800534,
-0.2757530212,
0.2566643953,
0.0356319584,
0.576200366,
0.1316687614,
0.8652130365,
0.1222778708,
0.192217201,
-0.4845314026,
1.0026419163,
0.0078221019,
0.471227169,
-0.0368279405,
-0.5116938949,
-0.292773068,
0.4561314583,
-0.1517003179,
-0.0845378488,
0.0544847958,
0.8276332617,
0.2599344254,
-0.1628328264,
0.219231531,
-0.2163154185,
0.7338671088,
0.5487887263,
1.209890008,
-0.0507949702,
0.8781803846,
-0.0284422245,
-0.1296782941,
-0.1935129613,
-0.7720292807,
-1.0071470737,
-0.0937531963,
-0.2490727156,
-0.147841379,
-0.0538690388,
0.9103660583,
0.8529955745,
-0.75687325,
-0.2345143855,
0.0520053618,
0.2210188806,
0.1081431136,
-0.178370297,
-0.0734580606,
-0.1279912889,
-0.3508706987,
0.6253368258,
0.1958423555,
0.3483745456,
-0.1437609196,
-0.4040246606,
0.0272896346,
0.2565428615,
0.5480670929,
0.4767025411,
-0.6998955011,
-0.5103746653,
-0.0552409664,
-0.2024798095,
0.0139029082,
0.2977191508,
-0.3893813491,
0.2084545642,
0.3439145088,
0.9850090146,
0.1643177718,
-0.0510572568,
0.6617191434,
-0.9101869464,
0.121660158,
0.2253801376,
0.5164450407,
0.3883398175,
-0.7026689649,
0.7777637243,
-0.0511988886,
-0.6663349867,
-0.8658946157,
0.5493217707,
-0.9400449991,
0.1201171875,
1.0757806301,
-0.2795954645,
-0.1159850135,
-0.0566362627,
-0.4970534742,
0.1950612366,
-0.6623367071,
1.1365557909,
0.5392647982,
-0.2343967259,
-0.3903849125,
-0.3767533898,
0.3659801483,
0.1841959059,
-1.405790925,
0.0468946882,
0.3814849257,
0.1835212111,
0.0841128379,
0.4006152749,
-0.0430688933,
0.4274953902,
-0.3394986987,
0.1231738105,
-0.0689227805,
-0.6657770276,
-0.3030653298,
-0.0825672522,
0.3451109529,
-0.4928264618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04657v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04657v1
|
Self-Supervised Behavior Cloned Transformers are Path Crawlers for Text Games
| 2023-12-07T19:39:11 | 2023-12-07T19:39:11 |
Ruoyao Wang, Peter Jansen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we introduce a self-supervised behavior cloning transformer for
text games, which are challenging benchmarks for multi-step reasoning in
virtual environments. Traditionally, Behavior Cloning Transformers excel in
such tasks but rely on supervised training data. Our approach auto-generates
training data by exploring trajectories (defined by common macro-action
sequences) that lead to reward within the games, while determining the
generality and utility of these trajectories by rapidly training small models
then evaluating their performance on unseen development games. Through
empirical analysis, we show our method consistently uncovers generalizable
training data, achieving about 90\% performance of supervised systems across
three benchmark text games.
|
[
-0.0816542655,
-0.4272914231,
0.5959005952,
0.3613916337,
0.1684270203,
0.0419851206,
0.1863383204,
-0.030107243,
0.3858664036,
0.6949805617,
-0.8600285053,
-0.2839945555,
-0.3335525692,
0.0607078448,
-0.8410522342,
1.3101769686,
0.0580210239,
-0.435252279,
-0.4897584915,
-0.033600606,
-0.2489563525,
-0.6599562168,
-0.4531273842,
-0.3229960203,
0.1611106843,
0.1664411724,
0.4807728529,
1.0542879105,
0.3252277672,
0.4949418604,
0.1450334638,
0.0051462343,
-0.7865222692,
0.2705062032,
-0.2790120542,
-0.3809253573,
-0.1669094265,
0.0060445275,
0.0630673543,
-0.089923121,
0.001813701,
0.398819685,
0.0614031404,
0.4771522582,
-0.4887310863,
0.178650558,
-0.1793619692,
0.561180532,
0.2922873795,
-0.204737857,
-0.399979651,
-0.40182814,
0.1936244816,
-0.9619652033,
0.6906278729,
-0.3312769532,
0.5278875828,
0.4079661667,
-0.4581637084,
-0.6294292212,
-1.1758546829,
0.8254496455,
-0.1398976445,
0.1235264912,
-0.2037787288,
0.4152972996,
-0.1483645439,
-0.9851730466,
-0.4192880094,
-0.0824436769,
-0.4073031843,
0.1507560909,
-0.2569208741,
-0.1903490871,
0.5569749475,
-0.0067085461,
-0.3309375644,
-0.3599855602,
-0.4829489291,
-0.1123683676,
0.7740220428,
0.4877304733,
0.2318338454,
-0.2054396272,
-0.4041055441,
-0.5969403386,
-0.1997728497,
0.5499058366,
0.5641487241,
-0.1378986388,
0.0531718023,
0.6173425913,
-0.0140271746,
0.2845516801,
0.5190314054,
-0.2869974375,
0.4718281031,
-0.5829096437,
0.2814188898,
0.0305659939,
1.0312662125,
0.4345714748,
0.4755088687,
-0.5346191525,
-0.2292695194,
-0.0070141675,
0.9122431874,
-0.7371302247,
-0.616743803,
0.0871612132,
-0.4681344926,
-0.4901843369,
0.0791063756,
-1.376686573,
-0.2147615254,
-0.2754619122,
0.6275804639,
-0.613781333,
-0.0385253578,
0.0383785293,
-0.5886473656,
0.361248523,
0.0900977105,
-1.0755008459,
0.105282113,
0.6472812891,
0.9411486983,
-0.7579578757,
-0.5039620996,
-0.5093238354,
0.4375197291,
-0.304948926,
0.7962348461,
-0.4069348872,
-0.8800418973,
0.0014635378,
0.2108016312,
-0.0842936561,
-0.4487062693,
0.5103964806,
-0.026994396,
0.1681586951,
0.058996018,
-0.6172718406,
0.1119913384,
0.5114155412,
-0.7376790643,
1.1350535154,
0.0125914467,
-0.5551914573,
0.3589553237,
-0.8207293749,
-0.8762821555,
-0.2824252248,
0.1347529739,
-0.4886901379,
0.0828375891,
0.3721261621,
0.2621759176,
0.6729441881,
0.1068123505,
-0.1956327856,
-0.7456940413,
-0.1871688813,
-0.2610521615,
0.5407424569,
-0.0040533622,
-0.5560717583,
0.1696114689,
-0.6219967604,
-0.0336222686,
0.1696130335,
-0.1236609444,
-0.4499157965,
0.3416619599,
-0.4728860557,
0.40285936,
0.3179904819,
-0.4727313817,
0.5833417177,
-0.1970586479,
0.2472111881,
0.6449312568,
0.1064214036,
0.6881480813,
-0.317445308,
0.6511061788,
-0.023841599,
0.5533506274,
-0.3682697117,
-0.2911033332,
-0.7799578905,
-0.1884118766,
0.0097342031,
0.5989031196,
-0.7615507841,
0.5124768019,
-0.5782435536,
-0.6792573929,
-0.5074242353,
-0.1343584955,
0.1741834581,
0.2840355933,
0.6849784255,
0.0695139319,
-0.3250953257,
-0.777787149,
-0.3853159547,
-0.0329191126,
-0.1871545017,
0.3305037916,
0.7079153061,
-0.4441767931,
1.1916774511,
-0.2914255857,
-0.4691861868,
-0.1039488092,
0.4543853998,
-0.0240426343,
0.615742147,
0.8152419329,
-0.5805548429,
-0.3537728488,
-0.4222618043,
-0.8787260652,
-0.0138727995,
-0.4809934795,
-0.0763867646,
-0.2138119787,
0.702178359,
-0.5293782353,
0.64776963,
0.5712886453,
-0.3450108171,
0.6158764362,
-0.5086583495,
0.4460521042,
-0.6644617319,
0.1120184138,
-0.1099911556,
-0.2566547394,
-0.6030598283,
0.0815506503,
-0.2884928584,
0.3142896891,
-0.389337182,
0.4023485184,
-0.1329219639,
-0.1781049818,
-0.1544049233,
-0.0561343879,
-0.211703673,
0.5756071806,
0.1575855762,
0.941226244,
0.419456929,
-0.8976451159,
0.4908734858,
0.5467219949,
-0.1306694299,
0.5703397393,
-0.8058823347,
0.2084059566,
-0.0672243536,
0.1146950349,
-0.665838778,
0.194378987,
0.1052878946,
-0.489277333,
-0.216470927,
-0.367412895,
-0.625483036,
-0.7899295092,
-0.2614269257,
0.2694120109,
0.8497270942,
-0.9322472811,
0.8886996508,
0.2324196398,
0.5030622482,
-0.4614798129,
-0.5087483525,
-0.4189800024,
-0.4297700524,
-0.1593769938,
0.2363996059,
-0.2870873511,
0.2183697522,
-0.1518755853,
-0.0858930945,
0.0303228833,
0.1350533813,
0.5412195921,
-0.1977415234,
0.0744437948,
-0.0434430651,
0.1641798317,
-0.1989873648,
0.5359984636,
-0.0862982571,
0.328656137,
0.2088780999,
-0.4733988345,
-0.0316107422,
-0.0757183358,
0.320471257,
-0.0403357521,
0.0590228923,
0.4792557359,
0.0903174877,
-0.3325186968,
-0.1251134276,
-0.1845626235,
-0.5755333304,
0.2618134022,
-0.480661869,
-0.8324058056,
0.2383965105,
-0.3601447046,
0.1529880762,
0.4023017287,
0.2792908549,
-0.2014198601,
1.4022595882,
0.6569905281,
-0.0682008937,
0.2377557456,
-0.3017806113,
-0.0229446832,
-0.3723799288,
-0.4761428237,
-0.3441759944,
-0.5551231503,
-0.8426136374,
-0.4614495933,
0.3894967437,
-0.1821527034,
-0.3652248979,
0.6174939275,
-0.7876396179,
0.5919564366,
0.8896939158,
0.0718554705,
0.4928838015,
-0.0845240429,
-0.1220410615,
-0.1691087633,
-0.4260187745,
-0.4033640623,
1.1248655319,
-0.0326747485,
0.6711246967,
-0.1929861903,
1.1314805746,
0.5476276278,
0.2658172846,
-0.6714869142,
0.5006890297,
-0.1495255679,
-0.7519595027,
-0.4644598365,
-0.3772897422,
-1.1149357557,
-0.0157386102,
-0.4201820493,
-0.9102391601,
-0.2992292345,
0.3012280762,
-0.3833010793,
0.3900783062,
-0.4674646556,
0.9815155864,
-0.3613805771,
-0.37492311,
-0.1800814271,
-0.4688084126,
0.5003805161,
-0.2040219605,
0.0900009871,
0.4300378561,
0.3120412827,
0.6463193297,
-0.1272183806,
0.3993295133,
-0.0813976303,
0.1130380556,
0.4119295776,
0.7492794394,
0.4429408312,
-0.0761352107,
0.3418828249,
0.0195037201,
0.375728786,
-0.0392543636,
-0.6658140421,
0.6888979673,
-0.5231245756,
-0.4702210128,
-0.5587512255,
-0.3461095691,
-0.2409014851,
0.2075840682,
0.1662706882,
-0.0282264203,
-0.4476566315,
0.186254859,
0.6274084449,
-0.3382453024,
0.6064897776,
0.4073612094,
-0.2968613505,
0.0347431675,
1.0647847652,
-0.5510711074,
-0.1783992648,
0.3675161898,
0.1522813588,
-0.3808992207,
-0.1176516637,
-0.4016879499,
-0.1454247683,
-0.240782693,
-0.0273769647,
-0.8116374612,
-0.2826873958,
-0.0637198091,
-0.2531930208,
-0.5625751019,
-0.0302895866,
-0.2913109958,
-0.1731449068,
0.3113770485,
1.2384209633,
-0.4056206346,
0.7286910415,
-0.9195399284,
0.5429968238,
0.5955336094,
0.4629554451,
-0.144327119,
-0.382918179,
0.0155161964,
0.1667040437,
-0.578027606,
-0.5819948316,
0.4519618452,
-0.1704160422,
0.5968534946,
0.2127955705,
-0.2565213442,
0.7743657231,
-0.7880565524,
1.0182282925,
0.0943092331,
-1.0150606632,
0.524498105,
-0.2615911961,
0.0978647768,
0.4507400095,
0.5109302402,
-0.1711990386,
-0.2595576048,
-0.83267802,
-0.395113945,
0.8653157949,
0.5025234818,
0.3590406179,
0.0069269734,
0.3873845935,
0.1252415925,
0.0888799801,
-0.6204143167,
-0.4550127089,
-0.5839928985,
-0.3887165785,
-0.3417253792,
0.0137810446,
0.1132127047,
-0.4301247597,
0.2408077419,
-0.3176337183,
0.4479883909,
0.103433162,
-0.1530960649,
0.1252909601,
-0.2045173943,
0.2898097336,
0.2502142489,
0.0337288678,
-0.0340794362,
0.1070180759,
-0.545488894,
0.5867344737,
0.0044303443,
-0.3445472419,
0.0369948745,
0.3179197013,
0.4046143591,
0.2694523335,
-0.6752920747,
0.8691145778,
-0.2135394663,
-0.2985223532,
-0.2678310573,
0.4758583605,
-0.0599213615,
0.4285592139,
0.1125564575,
0.0277880598,
0.4808186889,
-0.2664603591,
0.7350949645,
0.3107753098,
-0.6235634089,
-0.5562637448,
0.8650032282,
0.011253708,
-0.4909608662,
0.709212184,
-0.3219543695,
-0.5476938486,
0.7627123594,
0.5278170705,
0.6614475846,
-0.1025685817,
0.6449441314,
0.7771962881,
0.2069318295,
-0.5157061815,
-0.0961774811,
-0.0311211683,
-0.3648766279,
-0.4158517718,
-0.4892094135,
-0.3516016304,
0.1229909062,
-0.5791996121,
0.3452866971,
-0.2383471429,
-0.0888187364,
-0.323592335,
-0.6033468246,
-0.8458939195,
0.154692471,
-0.0100479918,
0.6523867249,
-0.6624526381,
0.570597589,
0.3963556886,
-0.3969577551,
-0.4190091193,
-0.0402722321,
-0.3658351898,
-0.639134407,
0.5460429788,
0.0513060987,
-0.1043534502,
0.161307916,
-0.7791464329,
-0.8822842836,
1.0037764311,
0.0403862558,
-0.4696406424,
-0.3291441798,
0.2751668394,
0.9798269868,
-0.2093871832,
0.5501756668,
0.7958809137,
0.3736461401,
0.0608696528,
-0.5522061586,
-0.2723172009,
-0.0059037772,
-0.2920995951,
0.1139112115,
-0.5816953778,
0.407671243,
-0.4252438843,
-0.0622134767,
0.2105763853,
0.7336134911,
0.4238586426,
0.1666722298,
0.7182807922,
0.4754825234,
0.1351994872,
-0.1438255012,
0.8491340876,
-0.3595451713,
0.526660502,
1.01380229,
0.0530442223,
0.3704443276,
0.3176263273,
-0.0377837792,
0.8769220114,
0.1941306442,
-0.4926571548,
0.6977047324,
0.2437074333,
0.5436971784,
-0.368008256,
0.3287025392,
0.1611699611,
0.7165998816,
0.0830225721,
-0.2748910785,
-0.3281441927,
-0.0906708837,
-0.2454963177,
0.1898214072,
-0.0688012093,
0.8759096861,
-0.4373925626,
-0.8862392902,
-0.2319397181,
-0.309058845,
0.8207029104,
-0.6501363516,
-0.3699686825,
-0.3891737461,
0.2887178659,
0.1487997323,
-1.0262001753,
0.2824228406,
0.0255006384,
0.1021005213,
-0.4221616089,
0.5183857679,
-0.1569275856,
-0.2629471719,
0.4035114348,
0.6118981242,
0.1020329446,
-0.0347617231,
-0.6765258908,
-0.3399550915,
0.1223349124,
-0.3435006142,
0.2623428404,
0.678170383,
0.1421655715,
0.9246693254,
0.481262207,
-0.2797991633,
0.2426565886,
-0.4959295392,
0.5438835025,
-0.9466248751,
-0.6028878093,
-0.8068091869,
0.4159005582,
-0.1926166564,
-0.450519532,
0.8933297992,
0.9299857616,
0.84965837,
-0.5138671398,
0.7979827523,
0.0597715266,
0.4826307297,
-0.1933217943,
0.398769021,
-0.4562317133,
-0.3032164872,
-0.259770155,
-0.7190641165,
0.3149865866,
0.7440811396,
0.0274627898,
0.0436238162,
0.462251991,
0.3816811144,
-0.5174690485,
-0.0799785927,
0.11462529,
-0.1486016065,
0.5179626942,
0.6482743025,
0.8148012161,
-0.4592401683,
0.9984695315,
-0.5317456722,
-0.0194413532,
0.0567340478,
-0.9213213921,
-1.1581807137,
-0.499391973,
-0.1510174572,
-0.43787238,
-0.0286082793,
0.5627126694,
0.7101005316,
-0.784065485,
-0.1535802037,
-0.1715927571,
0.0901969224,
-0.5662848353,
-0.3411145508,
0.1236771271,
-0.2159464359,
-0.9474273324,
0.4229154289,
-0.1203276142,
0.2850898802,
-0.43855685,
0.0110043921,
0.2070509791,
0.0283716097,
0.5741391778,
0.3636424243,
-0.2144394368,
-0.5761751533,
0.2807635665,
-0.1556423903,
0.0664009154,
0.9168727398,
-1.2472416162,
0.5012336969,
0.2347311229,
0.4061442614,
0.9227304459,
0.2790198922,
0.589227736,
-0.7214740515,
-0.0623730458,
0.1124915555,
-0.0164755154,
0.1041557863,
-0.2027746141,
0.7334474325,
0.2684085369,
-0.4998437166,
-0.5524644852,
0.0599729344,
-0.6713725924,
-0.0444263779,
1.3224250078,
-0.0758157969,
-0.3406858146,
0.2305106819,
-0.187598139,
0.2891796231,
-0.29093045,
1.1278231144,
0.3880546689,
-0.341313988,
0.1634213179,
-0.2661128938,
0.8316448331,
-0.2362665534,
-0.8317023516,
-0.1870592386,
0.4424842894,
0.3884465098,
0.4428402781,
0.1242995262,
0.0618414804,
0.0305874217,
0.0719134063,
0.2546255887,
-0.0141923353,
-0.4251840115,
-0.1958247125,
0.1202328652,
-0.7786215544,
-0.2373662591
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04649v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04649v1
|
PyThaiNLP: Thai Natural Language Processing in Python
| 2023-12-07T19:19:43 | 2023-12-07T19:19:43 |
Wannaphong Phatthiyaphaibun, Korakot Chaovavanich, Charin Polpanumas, Arthit Suriyawongkul, Lalita Lowphansirikul, Pattarawat Chormai, Peerat Limkonchotiwat, Thanathip Suntorntip, Can Udomcharoenchaikit
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
We present PyThaiNLP, a free and open-source natural language processing
(NLP) library for Thai language implemented in Python. It provides a wide range
of software, models, and datasets for Thai language. We first provide a brief
historical context of tools for Thai language prior to the development of
PyThaiNLP. We then outline the functionalities it provided as well as datasets
and pre-trained language models. We later summarize its development milestones
and discuss our experience during its development. We conclude by demonstrating
how industrial and research communities utilize PyThaiNLP in their work. The
library is freely available at https://github.com/pythainlp/pythainlp.
|
[
-0.2052063942,
-0.5316810012,
0.0636828542,
0.4487548769,
-0.2000868469,
-0.0406565145,
-0.5000981688,
-0.662422061,
0.4276349247,
0.6349598169,
-0.0137441056,
-0.4737894535,
-0.1408942491,
0.1416420639,
-0.270703882,
1.0167732239,
-0.1150889248,
-0.0568891764,
0.4742152989,
-0.2996441126,
-0.2393041551,
-0.4032468498,
-0.6672620773,
-0.4004620314,
0.6180411577,
0.8303772211,
0.7050389647,
0.4691770077,
0.4779889286,
0.1537689716,
0.1061319932,
-0.3256352842,
0.1610357463,
0.5977202654,
-0.1750638187,
-0.4305744767,
-0.2288514078,
-0.2284080535,
0.5532083511,
0.8343633413,
-0.1605177075,
0.2183786929,
-0.12475954,
0.9935536981,
-0.8855738044,
0.1813737601,
-0.3860763609,
0.3076492846,
-0.3719465435,
-0.2564329803,
-0.2609137595,
-0.7023354769,
0.4928982854,
-0.4926270843,
-0.1485933214,
-0.2610968947,
0.4174381495,
0.0594306998,
-0.4877989888,
-0.4947841465,
-0.5241858959,
0.4779823422,
-0.6301313639,
0.3074598908,
0.4801199436,
0.5388455987,
-0.2683866024,
-1.204533577,
-0.5398121476,
-0.2290118933,
0.143976301,
-0.1857199669,
-0.2560059428,
0.4708156288,
0.1017653197,
0.76347363,
-0.8884334564,
-0.0246243477,
-0.3662031293,
-0.3590166867,
0.3742306828,
-0.418372035,
0.5707888603,
-0.3230468631,
0.1728492975,
0.0862932801,
-0.4364583194,
0.0390941463,
0.3495740592,
0.1194163263,
0.0049506566,
1.0736796856,
-0.7456300855,
0.7011065483,
-0.5973819494,
0.1861001849,
-0.1023621261,
-0.1888940185,
-0.3578788936,
0.623541832,
0.6392628551,
0.4732917249,
0.5650830269,
-0.1377381682,
0.0080161393,
0.1820916533,
-0.2146308422,
-0.702952981,
-1.0032203197,
0.4655329883,
-0.3599943519,
-0.3411425352,
-0.2037858814,
-0.8097237945,
-0.3479323387,
-0.0521188639,
0.0357422084,
-0.3134145439,
-0.855643034,
0.1649903953,
-0.2920745909,
0.2670537233,
0.0319828801,
-0.8146199584,
0.3035040796,
0.5180857778,
1.2479529381,
0.0057451585,
-0.28705284,
-0.6995464563,
-0.0616658218,
-0.1912984699,
0.5992891192,
-0.4329992831,
-0.0542469472,
0.1699674726,
-0.1620653421,
0.4806856513,
-0.532951951,
0.7146062851,
-0.4991444349,
0.1601691246,
0.18770051,
-0.1956001669,
-0.4021180868,
0.0190423932,
-0.9686751366,
0.9372924566,
0.1607262492,
-1.3253010511,
0.2851934135,
-0.9894215465,
-0.350818038,
0.2740590274,
0.2951772809,
-0.1710267216,
0.0435333513,
0.4093305767,
0.2404736429,
0.0232019015,
0.3472222388,
-0.3193860054,
-0.0992888734,
0.3099354804,
-0.2515295148,
1.37900424,
0.608350873,
-0.0328988805,
0.3422469497,
-0.7461361289,
0.3400629461,
-0.2015701681,
-0.5069771409,
-0.2948996127,
-0.1593583673,
0.7501739264,
0.2352126688,
0.2409111261,
-0.4868617356,
0.5032302141,
-0.8076473475,
0.811829865,
0.4600974917,
-0.1796196997,
0.4987693727,
-0.0097148819,
0.5849347711,
0.0574731082,
-0.3409699798,
-0.3147825897,
-0.9046573639,
-0.6363972425,
-0.3352091908,
0.4758799076,
0.530305326,
-1.0468323231,
0.3051923811,
-0.0047932933,
-0.6010127664,
-0.579366684,
0.0114135165,
-0.0620750971,
0.1717958152,
0.2028529048,
-0.3102620244,
-1.2041978836,
-0.8102368712,
-0.544075191,
-0.3720090389,
-0.0888552666,
-0.3218820393,
0.4738052785,
-0.3831843734,
1.262332201,
-0.485093236,
-0.052355852,
-0.4781737924,
0.2198401242,
0.2165233791,
0.6498221755,
0.3483271897,
-0.5480038524,
-0.4745467305,
0.3311115801,
-0.5107936263,
-0.374561578,
0.4109635651,
-0.1104533896,
0.6273748279,
0.0911966339,
-0.613783896,
0.4770819247,
0.6422772408,
-0.1889954507,
0.9531573057,
-0.1838389188,
-0.2242556214,
-1.2516297102,
0.4686156213,
0.1422233284,
-0.4050958157,
-0.6204473972,
0.1887082309,
-0.1150321588,
-0.4051579237,
-0.4145338237,
0.5876242518,
-0.072848022,
-0.3780860007,
-0.3480817974,
-0.2202763557,
-0.3874794841,
0.2018136829,
0.4490797222,
0.7838193178,
0.6246411204,
-0.614317596,
0.9020148516,
-0.266115576,
-0.3500535786,
0.2877936363,
-0.5107789636,
0.2319489419,
0.3172071874,
0.2620002329,
-0.7724624872,
-0.457657665,
0.4063867033,
-0.5134407282,
-0.1980345845,
-0.489317596,
-0.5411217809,
-0.3581366539,
-0.3784915805,
0.4744901657,
0.1609036624,
-0.6198759079,
-0.0946775228,
0.4537568986,
-0.3770445883,
-0.461409986,
-0.7953796387,
0.4049338698,
-0.4692495465,
-0.4989843071,
-0.0448880531,
0.0560924746,
-0.4195375443,
-0.0759926587,
-0.0615076795,
-0.8114352822,
-0.0930684358,
-0.0511346497,
-0.3475368619,
-0.4705258012,
0.0009557261,
-0.210336566,
-0.360627383,
-0.0594399273,
-0.9242206216,
0.7292158008,
-0.2416918129,
0.2485246807,
-0.9613943696,
0.2194143832,
0.4482345581,
-0.14982979,
0.1384838521,
0.4859195948,
-0.5520927906,
-0.1020057201,
-0.1457044929,
0.1653996259,
-0.4633476138,
0.3463947177,
-0.2853818238,
-0.6960286498,
0.2974179387,
-0.0201052632,
0.1563055962,
0.2713620663,
0.5430101156,
0.087334007,
0.758654058,
0.8185921907,
-0.4076705873,
0.5264822841,
0.0307924487,
0.3023706079,
-0.4499937296,
0.3143299818,
-0.71122998,
-0.2820357382,
-1.009955883,
-0.2007674426,
-0.0094456375,
0.3460099101,
-0.0981432945,
0.5822119117,
-0.8994681835,
0.5923522711,
0.827747941,
-0.4623235464,
0.5484088063,
0.1683332175,
-0.1050131842,
-0.2431784868,
-0.7222513556,
-0.6474857926,
1.2771641016,
0.3841223419,
0.6541419625,
-0.1369667053,
0.6681082249,
0.2245263457,
-0.2021073252,
-1.0055859089,
0.4422321022,
0.3756378591,
-0.2803995609,
-0.1244755834,
-0.3265286684,
-1.2065925598,
-0.1832224429,
0.425100714,
-0.9810327888,
-0.2894482315,
-0.0754177943,
-0.0454817489,
0.3579662442,
-0.9243281484,
0.9916667938,
-0.0066916873,
-0.0260564014,
-0.2919283509,
-0.4872372746,
0.5613261461,
0.3851669431,
-0.2005752325,
0.3220850229,
0.1831557751,
0.9674813747,
-0.4936662614,
0.3424861133,
-0.2486723065,
-0.2210084349,
0.2963216901,
0.3947327435,
-0.0521415137,
0.5242410302,
-0.1717637628,
0.203180477,
0.5447488427,
-0.4092606008,
-0.3281406164,
0.8893021345,
-0.7058321238,
0.0268921312,
-0.8669902086,
-0.5560778379,
0.332475543,
0.3484860957,
-0.0169084743,
0.1054038107,
0.1424067616,
0.1288621873,
0.1370478421,
-0.4161954224,
0.7376999855,
0.4023254812,
-0.8808822632,
-0.6882281899,
1.0828920603,
0.2925540209,
-0.1057412997,
0.3367809057,
0.3482959867,
-0.3820042014,
-0.4706864357,
-0.28235811,
-0.0204236768,
-0.8768640757,
0.0734355077,
-0.4132467806,
-0.2170021683,
-0.427002281,
-0.0763607025,
-0.2262198031,
-0.9986813664,
0.0585138611,
0.1753861308,
0.5954334736,
0.7951585054,
-0.1903288066,
0.170881778,
-0.2858280241,
0.5336631536,
0.2309819907,
0.6313351989,
-0.267770499,
0.1719436646,
-0.304266572,
0.2901833355,
-0.4275208116,
-0.829325974,
0.6189713478,
0.1945338547,
0.0563336723,
0.2579801083,
0.288973242,
0.3745447993,
-0.0589488186,
1.0439223051,
0.0356855839,
-0.8922255635,
0.9872840643,
-0.2008178681,
0.4178456068,
0.1662885398,
0.2243742049,
-1.1011413336,
-0.3514285684,
-0.4661214352,
-0.7975973487,
0.7553303242,
0.4081926346,
-0.5023553967,
0.1467426121,
0.1894283295,
0.0879582837,
0.3763978183,
-1.0049077272,
-0.1057775915,
-0.5720670223,
-0.1462616473,
0.0366083682,
0.0041273399,
0.2712096274,
-0.5225839019,
0.4515423477,
-0.250417769,
0.1762660742,
0.4354422987,
-0.6137161851,
0.0385868102,
0.2051092535,
0.5894158483,
0.6228579283,
-0.4371790588,
0.4632079303,
-0.2337652594,
-0.8261314034,
0.0571248941,
-0.1241798848,
0.0419597439,
0.2669734657,
0.1553701758,
0.3209454715,
-0.1818615645,
-0.7359858751,
0.1142162755,
-0.1156435385,
0.2734889388,
-0.4837970436,
-0.0624349713,
0.0167385451,
0.2276850492,
0.5004738569,
-0.2537335157,
0.2231203467,
-0.618219614,
0.3394368887,
0.0722908154,
-0.2779809535,
-0.3531811833,
0.6538227797,
0.1166127026,
-0.750100553,
0.8574619293,
-0.1921933144,
-0.5517494678,
0.4782386422,
0.5298253298,
1.2396492958,
0.113579154,
0.26880759,
0.4169605374,
0.2566444874,
0.1511849463,
0.441203028,
-0.5060317516,
-0.3169824183,
-0.6486094594,
-0.7099097967,
-0.5317382812,
0.2588081658,
-0.2931611538,
0.4460549653,
-0.5286154151,
0.0109795313,
-0.0880530179,
0.5485957265,
-0.2457472235,
0.0070362217,
-0.0460374989,
1.0124692917,
-0.4492384493,
1.4675503969,
0.9194921255,
-0.5118352175,
-0.3350069523,
0.2568568587,
-0.2953929305,
-0.3845736682,
1.0983855724,
0.5694130659,
0.0635975376,
0.4175625145,
-0.5588114262,
-0.430727303,
0.712539196,
0.5042647123,
-0.1746413112,
-0.0991451144,
0.4519962966,
0.408115983,
0.104267031,
0.4646163881,
0.8369953036,
0.4002240896,
-0.403067559,
-1.2226684093,
-0.3429712355,
-0.4807109237,
0.0249905027,
-0.0131587731,
0.0269064996,
0.5214652419,
0.1183390096,
-0.2440163493,
0.2787596583,
0.8312769532,
0.219338268,
0.3554469049,
0.054535836,
0.5822908878,
0.7060974836,
-0.1823416501,
0.7954609394,
-0.3668919206,
0.2213930637,
0.7553673387,
-0.0244333353,
0.852603972,
0.78587538,
-0.1726061553,
0.3003002703,
0.6877644658,
0.6060919166,
0.2708932459,
0.4679074585,
-0.3736959696,
0.3488902152,
-0.1038707942,
-0.4846192896,
0.4040987492,
0.2669058442,
0.2060713768,
-0.4934000671,
0.0148438765,
-0.1313271075,
-0.2125178128,
-0.3081655502,
0.4962479472,
0.0607984103,
-0.577691853,
0.6338160634,
0.1768005192,
1.0135643482,
-0.5505900383,
-0.0523822829,
-0.0014532552,
0.0370850228,
-0.4730119109,
-1.2044886351,
0.6838659048,
-0.0893835276,
-0.0120295566,
-0.1109914631,
0.6862200499,
-0.3836107254,
-0.1151600108,
0.0820663422,
0.0370115452,
0.322806567,
-0.3340083063,
-0.5361274481,
-0.1168620586,
-0.1468327641,
-0.3665205836,
0.1245287806,
0.5540166497,
-0.266330868,
0.8150150776,
0.9118693471,
0.5692859292,
0.2786470056,
-0.2675051987,
0.4257897735,
-0.7919117808,
-0.8155677319,
-0.6790953875,
0.4165450931,
0.0707423016,
-0.4980458319,
0.6969679594,
0.7935684323,
1.0444651842,
-0.0748165324,
0.9337493777,
-0.1767979264,
0.2222109586,
-0.403467685,
1.034735322,
-0.1841548085,
-0.0074811373,
-0.3463275731,
-1.0968571901,
-0.7322598696,
0.9483085275,
-0.1054241881,
-0.4013619721,
0.7097758651,
0.6655414104,
-0.0929584876,
0.2300519794,
0.0573563054,
0.0416878313,
0.6127089262,
0.5693520904,
0.8395775557,
-0.3539777994,
0.3906412423,
-0.5715306997,
0.1006813273,
-0.2540326416,
-0.8887123466,
-0.684407711,
-0.8268947601,
-0.4468219876,
-0.3797461092,
-0.0677684918,
1.2662960291,
0.4206398427,
-0.9916033745,
-0.787234664,
-0.8278731108,
0.448415786,
-0.3723424673,
-0.3300130367,
0.2951771319,
-0.4746029973,
-0.7439165711,
0.193072021,
0.4823649824,
-0.171040386,
-0.4810987711,
-0.1793907136,
-0.5271166563,
-0.6687415838,
0.5132211447,
0.7762336135,
-0.622844398,
-0.0583189577,
-0.4323947728,
0.0098358942,
0.2584007382,
1.091599226,
-1.0319436789,
0.8572887778,
0.7593846321,
0.6705795527,
0.2005956769,
-0.6546183228,
0.9901043773,
-0.6652510762,
0.7011156678,
0.483887881,
0.311668843,
0.4346241653,
0.0359674245,
0.4946223497,
0.3176621497,
-0.7145552039,
-1.2254209518,
0.2681576312,
-0.6877940297,
-0.0411229916,
1.0089458227,
0.1363275796,
-0.1913418472,
-0.5957728624,
-0.7862240076,
0.7021149993,
-0.3456041813,
0.6018392444,
0.8718595505,
0.2519280612,
-0.4565526545,
-1.0139125586,
0.6768581867,
0.0819903538,
-0.5594482422,
0.1999070048,
0.2560058832,
0.1413092315,
0.0011964714,
0.7525426745,
0.3426605761,
0.5511021614,
-0.1909189075,
0.2379725128,
0.2817013264,
-0.404137373,
-0.6097353697,
0.2402819395,
0.3583579659,
-0.1862939894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04642v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04642v1
|
On Sarcasm Detection with OpenAI GPT-based Models
| 2023-12-07T19:00:56 | 2023-12-07T19:00:56 |
Montgomery Gole, Williams-Paul Nwadiugwu, Andriy Miranskyy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Sarcasm is a form of irony that requires readers or listeners to interpret
its intended meaning by considering context and social cues. Machine learning
classification models have long had difficulty detecting sarcasm due to its
social complexity and contradictory nature.
This paper explores the applications of the Generative Pretrained Transformer
(GPT) models, including GPT-3, InstructGPT, GPT-3.5, and GPT-4, in detecting
sarcasm in natural language. It tests fine-tuned and zero-shot models of
different sizes and releases.
The GPT models were tested on the political and balanced (pol-bal) portion of
the popular Self-Annotated Reddit Corpus (SARC 2.0) sarcasm dataset. In the
fine-tuning case, the largest fine-tuned GPT-3 model achieves accuracy and
$F_1$-score of 0.81, outperforming prior models. In the zero-shot case, one of
GPT-4 models yields an accuracy of 0.70 and $F_1$-score of 0.75. Other models
score lower. Additionally, a model's performance may improve or deteriorate
with each release, highlighting the need to reassess performance after each
release.
|
[
-0.261849612,
-0.735011816,
0.4711582065,
0.2605879903,
-0.4085445702,
-0.2799605727,
-0.1764893681,
-0.3441150784,
-0.2390202284,
0.2802428901,
-0.4967444539,
-0.3838704228,
-0.7639845014,
0.1558556855,
-0.3247969449,
1.4197621346,
0.0300240591,
-0.1532892287,
0.3495138586,
-0.0688552037,
-0.4402086139,
-0.466937393,
-0.8247199059,
-0.2332767546,
0.4249313772,
0.064221561,
0.7688684464,
0.0192540903,
0.6643742919,
0.2723480165,
0.1324527562,
-0.3685024083,
-0.3085262179,
-0.0336591713,
-0.0477799028,
-0.7151220441,
-0.286134392,
0.3173496425,
0.3459279537,
-0.0565210395,
0.136006251,
0.2223739028,
-0.2722505331,
0.3546624482,
-0.7238149047,
0.3090015054,
-0.5915751457,
0.1294856071,
-0.2802563906,
-0.0769206807,
-0.5277529955,
-0.5712998509,
-0.0672562644,
-0.3576385379,
0.5279142261,
-0.2169915885,
0.8393703699,
0.7398899198,
-0.3565867543,
-0.1186128557,
-0.8435508013,
0.6968281269,
-0.9068018198,
0.0165342428,
0.1042935848,
0.6785466075,
0.1797094792,
-0.8241283298,
-0.7543234229,
-0.3944658637,
-0.2233033031,
0.3163700104,
-0.3853884637,
0.259126246,
0.462547034,
0.4545810819,
-0.7627174854,
-0.1659134924,
-0.157498315,
0.0418600254,
0.3162831068,
-0.1145707667,
0.308295399,
-0.4632138908,
-0.4937347472,
0.0860626698,
-0.3250227273,
-0.1349742115,
0.6026149392,
0.2754577398,
-0.1238549426,
0.2988872826,
-0.1278110147,
0.4586903751,
-0.0704974458,
0.2132717669,
0.1838472039,
-0.1659098864,
-0.5410679579,
-0.3664657474,
0.8946126103,
-0.1118236855,
0.7843947411,
0.1106471345,
-0.4717879593,
0.3293781281,
0.1637874395,
-0.5736053586,
-0.4761208892,
-0.1929596215,
-0.3599467278,
-0.5937235355,
0.1097505242,
-0.4191749394,
-0.150849402,
-0.2278981209,
0.414172411,
-0.3925709426,
-0.3505266011,
0.091636166,
-0.4281012714,
0.3461354375,
0.4426189661,
-0.6399531364,
0.0221290793,
0.6826725602,
0.9180437922,
0.2201270908,
-0.1626044959,
-0.3205354512,
-0.1326026618,
0.038707573,
0.7485240698,
-0.4865992665,
-0.1708658636,
-0.2691786885,
-0.1970084012,
-0.4128606617,
-0.2934180498,
0.9950131178,
-0.4659323394,
0.3937670887,
-0.0551795736,
-0.1596983224,
-0.1585685909,
0.4787243903,
-0.7697121501,
1.1173509359,
0.6161025167,
-1.2736247778,
0.2280627787,
-1.0247044563,
-0.491787672,
0.1668204516,
-0.1352314651,
-0.2081830651,
0.2320706844,
0.2101768106,
0.3174472153,
-0.4758726358,
0.4136952162,
-0.2533337474,
-0.6296246648,
0.3680463433,
-0.972550571,
0.948138535,
0.2600171268,
-0.8132712245,
0.0311105065,
-0.0816486701,
-0.0342105627,
0.0575837977,
0.0371930636,
-0.1005183309,
-0.3192395866,
0.0062843622,
0.5055129528,
-0.0902375802,
-0.5017721653,
0.0119812917,
-0.2535114288,
0.5793212056,
0.8330296874,
-0.2202118337,
0.0836844146,
-0.1859851629,
0.8113040328,
0.1939774156,
0.5932558179,
0.0325228907,
-0.6694808602,
-0.6368532777,
-0.5882735252,
0.4624698758,
0.9340012074,
-0.9461563826,
0.2731488645,
-0.3603592515,
-0.2656733096,
-0.6366682649,
-0.3791819811,
0.2443194687,
0.5739392638,
0.3931575716,
-0.1323133707,
-0.1549634039,
-0.8068438768,
-0.74236238,
-0.3048105836,
-0.1082930937,
0.3145100176,
0.6569858789,
-0.1711026579,
0.8426454663,
-0.4587310851,
-0.1453980207,
-0.1885392666,
0.7193723321,
0.0783362091,
0.1952629685,
0.6817159653,
-0.897138834,
-0.6791110635,
0.077027753,
-0.8027641177,
-0.0980993211,
0.0760651082,
0.0261030141,
0.3558798134,
0.191707924,
-1.0655407906,
0.9481512904,
0.1310816109,
-0.1053677425,
0.7325291038,
0.3439775705,
0.4063064158,
-0.8512421846,
0.2615583241,
0.1448000371,
-0.4049059153,
-0.7444255948,
0.0837447047,
-0.0921730399,
-0.0822422132,
-0.5081645846,
0.6269005537,
-0.1122327298,
0.0554798767,
-0.163608551,
0.0651973858,
-0.249317795,
0.3453662992,
-0.3648461699,
0.5191688538,
0.3167639673,
-0.2822256386,
0.385674268,
-0.2869475186,
-0.1328222454,
0.6787173748,
-0.7115837932,
0.1919522434,
-0.1992499977,
0.6355460882,
-0.9509002566,
-0.4634367526,
0.7598777413,
-0.6676412225,
0.2795469165,
-0.401250571,
-0.445156008,
-0.7585285306,
-0.3379426897,
0.6523565054,
0.5254311562,
-0.5354241133,
0.793300271,
-0.1238751188,
-0.0243425108,
-0.9032216072,
-0.8931279182,
-0.2375769168,
-0.232202962,
-0.7435190678,
-0.058847256,
0.0829909295,
-0.0053842203,
0.1149994582,
0.0300233904,
0.0142730288,
0.0442682132,
0.2198064923,
0.2794487774,
-0.3375596106,
0.1306097806,
-0.2707147002,
-0.1610638648,
-0.0436489508,
-0.2993678451,
0.5289734602,
-0.3303665221,
-0.4007403255,
-0.9233317375,
0.2512431443,
0.6848215461,
-0.0921952277,
0.5941772461,
1.0269719362,
-0.3944537044,
-0.2224725485,
-0.5840574503,
-0.1870736927,
-0.4601299763,
0.0758469328,
-0.313537091,
-0.8222051263,
0.5839716792,
0.1264782697,
-0.3176826835,
0.7299070358,
0.3583050072,
0.1709771603,
1.0657452345,
0.6139948964,
-0.4165458381,
0.5141056776,
0.0233218484,
0.8508526683,
-0.4691354036,
0.1187920198,
-0.7022468448,
-0.4114720225,
-0.7090376019,
-0.4399738312,
0.2068910599,
-0.0988360345,
-0.5389184952,
-0.0531376526,
-0.5161594152,
0.711437881,
0.5114780664,
0.0441492982,
0.0982692614,
-0.0605409406,
0.2933244407,
0.2257387489,
-0.3331218362,
-0.4393776655,
0.8293320537,
0.4538866878,
0.7715344429,
0.1405055523,
0.4700203538,
0.4740567803,
0.8685691357,
-0.8233135939,
0.3255033791,
-0.4759821594,
-0.6306108236,
-0.2164945602,
-0.8987345099,
-0.2003201693,
-0.1139212325,
0.3878715634,
-0.3934961259,
-0.0983146355,
0.312276423,
-0.2246225327,
0.3910214603,
-0.9759516716,
1.0451973677,
-0.2023470849,
0.1734535545,
0.1121835411,
-0.9428070188,
0.7061260343,
0.2052238882,
-0.0731439218,
-0.1835068613,
0.4700579643,
0.1901748031,
0.0607892089,
0.9039959908,
-0.6089189649,
0.2973476052,
0.4525071383,
-0.0634192005,
0.5422765017,
-0.0209043063,
-0.2000366002,
0.1930427253,
-0.2777496874,
-0.4773717821,
-0.7983246446,
0.559355557,
-0.8718866706,
-0.5238428116,
-0.4983991981,
-0.3316387534,
0.1602896601,
0.0652174801,
0.6506807804,
0.1295701563,
-0.3299090564,
-0.1688072234,
0.4940899909,
0.0338180996,
0.3407445252,
0.1406595558,
0.2118338794,
-0.2212878615,
0.6971536279,
-0.0767439678,
0.3100210726,
0.1589220166,
0.125508666,
-0.2884116769,
-0.1181113124,
-0.3499284387,
0.3402603865,
-0.9509422183,
-0.4151310623,
-0.6738889813,
-0.4570879638,
-0.7370222211,
-0.0590952709,
-0.0825904459,
-0.4812257588,
-0.5112419128,
0.0157957431,
0.1602375954,
0.9254834652,
0.1094803289,
0.5806244612,
-0.2357502431,
0.3300409317,
0.1909005642,
0.4511124194,
-0.1369203627,
-0.7934815288,
0.1754602194,
0.1192406863,
-0.4108421504,
-0.9582779408,
0.2653475404,
0.1101237983,
0.3641326725,
0.3621857762,
0.0812633485,
0.2969354093,
-0.0248022191,
0.9093727469,
0.0415507369,
-1.0218228102,
0.5381436944,
-0.4807132781,
0.3199976683,
0.5384717584,
0.5450902581,
-0.5248385072,
-0.2836606503,
-0.6774451733,
-0.5559197068,
0.8399643302,
0.1744813919,
0.2106499225,
-0.2392678112,
0.6819280386,
-0.0826575533,
0.2656585574,
-1.2669094801,
0.0207164343,
-0.5597942472,
-0.6454284787,
0.010792397,
-0.037907891,
-0.1836309135,
-0.1280493885,
0.7189227343,
-0.3876387775,
0.4647685289,
0.042521216,
-0.2086578161,
-0.0120957382,
0.4132686555,
0.7302681208,
0.0027706013,
-0.0453707725,
0.1984281689,
-0.0886730775,
-0.3149240613,
-0.0786256865,
0.0977435336,
-0.2089550197,
0.014052338,
0.2184079438,
1.0372805595,
-0.0465470552,
-0.1321024597,
1.0732964277,
-0.2866047621,
-0.1994859129,
-0.2794895172,
-0.0263549872,
-0.3026713133,
0.1344718486,
0.1378111541,
0.6511422396,
0.3068636358,
-0.5577369928,
-0.055198323,
0.6521775126,
-0.4677644074,
-0.705878973,
0.4003345072,
0.161892131,
-0.2711795866,
0.9039106965,
-0.4554932714,
-1.093994379,
0.6274964213,
0.5941494703,
1.3669041395,
-0.4679710567,
0.6512171626,
0.1331382394,
0.7426491976,
-0.271882534,
0.2191016674,
-0.0779554471,
-0.445530653,
-0.2178995013,
-0.5682305694,
-0.0964672789,
0.1162863076,
-0.4286917746,
0.5823554397,
-0.4191669524,
-0.33966133,
-0.0543334447,
-0.4051070511,
-0.9325162172,
0.2312759161,
0.1066744402,
0.824880898,
-1.3383640051,
0.5238066316,
0.4272034764,
-0.4595833719,
-0.8685486913,
0.4926772416,
-0.0063871215,
-0.4885670841,
0.6446706057,
0.4684093297,
-0.3541141748,
0.0709387437,
-0.6777439713,
-0.3630397618,
0.8955726624,
0.7710951567,
0.0111717843,
-0.165914923,
0.2719197869,
0.796931386,
-0.2992897928,
0.8545039892,
0.7927465439,
0.6191254854,
0.1700235456,
-0.9187592268,
0.029580472,
-0.2656833827,
-0.1592356861,
0.415686518,
-0.6701951027,
1.2406228781,
-0.0154484641,
-0.4340080023,
-0.0109015545,
0.3159827888,
-0.1692273468,
0.5111942291,
0.4650501013,
0.9143417478,
0.676012814,
-0.4084280431,
1.2233541012,
0.0241347793,
0.5585638881,
0.9888491035,
-0.2561152577,
0.6508156061,
0.050739374,
0.0818931237,
0.6299855709,
0.4831517041,
0.14506194,
0.3230359256,
0.0321779959,
-0.6112473011,
-0.0409815051,
0.0599047765,
-0.3741065264,
0.315402627,
0.2743315399,
-0.4754590094,
-0.1869692653,
0.0542143844,
0.1634589583,
-0.4100541472,
-0.2587590218,
0.5839378238,
0.0718301088,
-0.7639930844,
0.3246358335,
0.0735656992,
0.7097412348,
-0.2828907669,
0.2319286764,
-0.3339606225,
0.2439624369,
-0.2646346986,
-0.6474189162,
0.3169887364,
0.0562289357,
-0.2078921646,
0.1647272855,
0.9877107739,
-0.160647884,
-0.3074923754,
0.3446688652,
0.221838966,
0.0809888318,
-0.5180141926,
-0.8121750355,
-0.2136784792,
-0.0166129041,
-0.3511030376,
-0.174326092,
0.868421495,
-0.2412562668,
0.5141003728,
0.5193825364,
-0.2185761929,
0.1985582709,
0.4900161624,
0.9139617085,
-0.603638947,
-0.6131931543,
-0.8796022534,
0.5301586986,
-0.0295679551,
-0.4572969079,
0.3727076054,
0.0582634248,
0.6919417977,
-0.301342994,
1.0681399107,
-0.0642374977,
0.3190556169,
-0.2216309756,
0.512879312,
-0.3225426674,
0.0558289364,
-0.2906483114,
-0.7888956666,
-0.590236187,
0.5444547534,
-0.6783463359,
0.6252064109,
0.7518238425,
0.7063234448,
-0.3958587646,
0.5467047691,
0.1708985269,
0.1530742347,
0.3073841333,
0.4664156139,
0.9306205511,
-0.4719930589,
0.4010008276,
-0.0517599471,
-0.468885541,
-0.2983099818,
-0.6818835139,
-0.9836968184,
-0.1712908298,
-0.200680092,
-0.2409549803,
0.0326979198,
0.5077012181,
0.6119400263,
-0.6649088264,
0.3562226295,
-0.2846314013,
-0.0235524792,
0.1200362742,
-0.3939297795,
0.0795719102,
-0.4063045681,
-0.3491165042,
-0.0762613043,
0.3332114518,
0.0571170859,
-0.0938044339,
0.1072628498,
-0.1093902513,
0.2532846928,
0.4605602622,
0.2960804105,
-0.8427529335,
-0.6077370048,
0.0650244504,
-0.1889811158,
-0.1381566674,
1.0381766558,
-0.787173152,
0.1876887232,
0.5724679232,
0.4728443027,
0.2283955067,
0.3110513389,
0.2570189238,
-0.925612092,
0.2155850232,
0.525054276,
0.0069718659,
0.6093301177,
-0.6395772099,
0.5184464455,
0.5939629674,
-0.88758111,
-0.9300009012,
0.344311744,
-0.7379703522,
-0.0346468464,
0.8537472486,
-0.3092250824,
-0.2184841633,
-0.0589269362,
-0.0191032551,
0.5498349667,
-0.192330569,
0.8110262156,
0.6033803821,
-0.0797804594,
-0.1376260668,
-0.7940428853,
0.6869321465,
0.493699491,
-0.851798594,
0.0406994224,
0.2236352712,
0.2771731019,
0.1543029398,
0.8716548085,
-0.2228646427,
0.5345744491,
-0.1883882731,
0.0494643264,
0.3129522502,
-0.4979214668,
-0.4997939467,
0.1667162478,
-0.1392861754,
0.0508340262
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04556v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04556v2
|
Large Language Models for Mathematicians
| 2023-12-07T18:59:29 | 2024-04-02T14:35:40 |
Simon Frieder, Julius Berner, Philipp Petersen, Thomas Lukasiewicz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, math.HO
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT have received immense interest
for their general-purpose language understanding and, in particular, their
ability to generate high-quality text or computer code. For many professions,
LLMs represent an invaluable tool that can speed up and improve the quality of
work. In this note, we discuss to what extent they can aid professional
mathematicians. We first provide a mathematical description of the transformer
model used in all modern language models. Based on recent studies, we then
outline best practices and potential issues and report on the mathematical
abilities of language models. Finally, we shed light on the potential of LLMs
to change how mathematicians work.
|
[
-0.32797122,
-0.5406289697,
0.5663942099,
0.270486623,
-0.2047788352,
0.0988700241,
-0.3368077278,
-0.4246776402,
0.0566302985,
0.6869713068,
-0.2310237288,
-0.0877501294,
-1.0065381527,
-0.0224508941,
-0.7294213176,
0.8654406667,
0.0259683318,
0.3986053467,
-0.3164987564,
0.2205327749,
-0.3498863876,
-0.7107852101,
-0.9299566746,
-0.5809489489,
0.5396940112,
0.144384101,
1.2301836014,
0.421189189,
1.0053842068,
0.3754165769,
-0.2626572847,
-0.2070729434,
-0.8215016127,
0.5148949027,
-0.0140927015,
-0.7962528467,
-0.4977231324,
-0.0764507651,
0.5163934827,
1.1006535292,
-0.3039289415,
0.0181789603,
-0.1677899361,
0.615157485,
0.1527590156,
0.4934089482,
-0.4101777077,
-0.1044773757,
-0.3105566204,
-0.0210078396,
-0.2904885411,
-0.6880773902,
0.1142227203,
-0.2320159376,
0.1050507873,
-0.036944177,
0.4303104281,
0.1542290449,
-0.3879437447,
-0.5256201625,
-1.0000981092,
0.6667043567,
-0.85253793,
0.5485186577,
0.2149795145,
0.6082739234,
-0.3458768129,
-0.6903927922,
-0.303442955,
-0.3059196174,
0.0792899579,
-0.0059910384,
-0.1960373223,
-0.0778811947,
0.4889243245,
0.5673390627,
-0.3542389572,
0.2117744684,
-0.4357018173,
0.1066281572,
0.6319743991,
0.4395139515,
0.6019790173,
0.0840369612,
0.3615294695,
0.1755000651,
-1.064183712,
-0.2466213852,
0.4778344631,
0.0109125972,
-0.0103884265,
0.7390446663,
0.288980335,
0.660353899,
-0.6234137416,
-0.294715941,
-0.4500312507,
0.0271194465,
-0.0040411153,
-0.4270803928,
0.5180518031,
0.0371226557,
0.8472507,
-0.3388449252,
-0.3494744003,
0.1741144806,
0.0720358714,
-0.9956336617,
-0.6126785278,
-0.0903820992,
-0.3198929429,
-0.1694295108,
-0.1072514206,
-0.6956246495,
-0.5740118623,
-0.6922834516,
-0.0191564355,
-0.3189887702,
-0.366502732,
0.1899173856,
0.0571009666,
0.1436178982,
0.5972765684,
-1.0192115307,
0.5391820073,
0.9044103026,
0.7835102677,
-0.0059400508,
0.0741325244,
-0.3834979832,
-0.0843989253,
-0.5969823599,
0.7434218526,
-0.6857430339,
-0.6295428872,
0.1999337822,
-0.2859120667,
0.0496604852,
-0.6376026273,
0.4991270006,
-0.7727591991,
0.2882986069,
-0.0669042915,
-0.6768126488,
-0.1495196968,
-0.0623937286,
-0.6836657524,
0.6276539564,
0.2402109653,
-0.4422097504,
-0.2975678742,
-0.8216667175,
-0.3379129469,
0.209721908,
-0.0971093848,
-0.2315464169,
0.5968346,
0.0507472344,
0.4050517976,
-0.7002938986,
0.3621348441,
-0.101311937,
-0.1537468284,
0.8489117026,
-0.5767282844,
0.8146268725,
0.1414049417,
0.2438455522,
-0.0427087471,
-0.3568309844,
-0.3101891279,
0.2706819177,
-0.2763770819,
-0.0010678119,
0.2739348412,
0.128585428,
0.0955545679,
0.0630922541,
-0.3082489669,
0.4268788695,
-0.5000472665,
0.7025876641,
0.6770986915,
-0.1836685985,
0.3557409644,
-0.3649059832,
0.8186411858,
-0.1716074497,
-0.1013321877,
-0.4183925688,
-0.7391895056,
-0.8725017905,
-0.322979182,
0.6943432689,
0.4217987657,
-0.6535536647,
-0.1074696854,
-0.381780237,
-0.6306233406,
-0.3516532779,
0.1968529224,
0.0810373873,
0.1321368366,
-0.0851745456,
-0.1998790205,
-0.3390410841,
-0.5709736347,
-0.502797246,
0.186647132,
-0.3180776536,
0.455722779,
0.2745337784,
-0.2640684545,
0.8541274071,
-0.7357444763,
-0.0643963143,
-0.2314828783,
-0.0011660642,
0.629851222,
0.1479012668,
0.4527040124,
-0.7129452229,
-0.6360290647,
-0.1641800553,
-0.7007677555,
-0.2116443962,
0.0576184094,
-0.0016304855,
-0.1500172317,
0.560923636,
-0.8465358615,
0.1854709983,
0.6433022022,
-0.1622203439,
0.526909411,
-0.2833308876,
-0.1859528869,
-1.0221133232,
-0.3396150172,
0.2352401763,
-0.5606125593,
-0.8699190021,
0.1237187907,
-0.0764581561,
-0.5946626663,
-0.4079553485,
0.5340621471,
-0.4843396544,
-0.2270973474,
-0.3064082563,
0.4294191003,
-0.6564507484,
-0.0446407422,
-0.2326148152,
1.0821876526,
0.7911491394,
-0.5785434842,
0.5633381009,
0.1911370307,
-0.3811278641,
0.5166788101,
-0.8585070372,
0.1672208607,
-0.2417966127,
0.0581746139,
-1.0321320295,
-0.4178019166,
-0.1548478603,
-0.3987443447,
0.4532062411,
-0.2298553139,
-0.8271828294,
-0.5218862891,
0.1291203201,
0.2739988565,
0.78404814,
-0.5255708694,
0.5850965977,
0.6856274009,
-0.5797147155,
-0.1428654492,
-0.3859722316,
0.3032687008,
-0.1550459713,
-0.7893294692,
0.1443773657,
-0.1308128536,
-0.5821392536,
-0.1845506877,
0.2021198869,
-0.1807362735,
0.103861019,
0.2413619012,
0.3988826275,
-0.2810256481,
0.1908123046,
-0.3431020379,
-0.5221393704,
0.2627353668,
-0.195150122,
0.7841941118,
-0.0173601471,
-0.5460715294,
-0.1642189026,
0.194149673,
0.6990044713,
-0.2068607211,
0.6641457677,
0.2857403159,
-0.4695220888,
0.0137848333,
-0.4946779907,
-0.2635741234,
-0.5207554102,
0.3974711299,
-0.229582265,
-1.0909258127,
0.5818223953,
-0.4019152224,
0.1922037452,
0.4259903431,
0.8706579804,
0.0187307727,
1.0935698748,
0.8173323274,
-0.269980967,
0.6176723242,
-0.0695355609,
0.6728181839,
-0.7357817292,
0.0454860516,
-0.7192349434,
-0.0560887046,
-0.4808977842,
-0.4617389441,
0.3772358,
0.0925031975,
-0.2164798081,
0.2902460992,
-0.3053452671,
0.7397776842,
0.2150357366,
-0.239027977,
0.2275695056,
-0.0619397908,
0.2024387717,
-0.2851662338,
-0.6730579734,
-0.7252913117,
0.9996194839,
0.5952215195,
1.2995995283,
0.4931358695,
0.3852166831,
-0.1353407949,
0.6343368888,
-0.8795240521,
0.5486053228,
-0.33941257,
-0.5397928357,
-0.333309114,
-0.4935528934,
-0.9982613325,
0.1841109842,
0.0162284561,
-0.6204804778,
-0.371016711,
-0.009246802,
-0.0154070966,
0.3802652955,
-0.5432504416,
0.5137069225,
-0.2635111213,
0.1208532155,
-0.3234386444,
-0.1613337249,
0.4914087355,
-0.3573470414,
0.3694163263,
-0.2582704127,
-0.096708715,
0.6363005638,
-0.1917022765,
0.8395478129,
0.115802452,
-0.3789279759,
0.2083460838,
0.5325089097,
0.458211869,
0.1783522964,
-0.1637893319,
0.2422902137,
-0.040663857,
-0.1789533347,
-0.4432325661,
0.7070209384,
-0.8742268682,
-0.7648359537,
-0.2620749176,
-0.9208807349,
-0.0731377974,
0.0483853705,
-0.0508758277,
0.6100793481,
-0.0839955285,
0.274574846,
0.7806804776,
-0.2559564114,
0.6232751608,
0.3305039108,
-0.521902144,
-0.2546768188,
0.8051449656,
0.3364014328,
0.2220101953,
0.2213546187,
0.1587357223,
-0.4810100198,
-0.3712246418,
-0.2575260699,
0.6343043447,
-0.9588447213,
-0.2638373077,
-0.4137855768,
-0.5053107142,
-0.2885474563,
-0.1206995845,
-0.2349175811,
-0.6763603687,
-0.4392600358,
0.3540002108,
0.5675840974,
1.1417082548,
0.287312001,
0.7758552432,
-0.784643054,
0.2065115273,
0.4786702693,
0.4937059581,
-0.1214370579,
-0.6878808737,
-0.0535950549,
-0.0968429223,
-0.4257661104,
-0.67489779,
0.6137980223,
0.0988111943,
0.6748927236,
0.2665964663,
-0.3056252599,
0.3517662585,
-0.8847208023,
0.8800755143,
0.4179518521,
-1.0572295189,
0.036079105,
-0.4737336636,
0.2447334081,
-0.2947172821,
0.590932548,
-0.9271216989,
-0.3378548324,
-0.465923816,
-0.3542103767,
0.2893090546,
0.3785770237,
0.7752626538,
0.1481168121,
0.4720165431,
0.0045523793,
0.1837401092,
-0.6553388834,
-0.1787078083,
0.0987455994,
-0.2681191564,
-0.3891201317,
-0.4645993412,
-0.2092640251,
-0.1016073525,
0.3805499971,
-0.0174676292,
0.5896682143,
-0.4185705185,
-0.1126284376,
-0.259673804,
0.2753159106,
0.7310601473,
1.3007240295,
0.39939031,
0.1349252313,
0.3245664537,
-0.450605154,
0.0624694042,
-0.0332123078,
0.2553729415,
0.0561425164,
0.2963252068,
0.4941059053,
0.3912047148,
-0.5548478961,
0.4198004305,
-0.1596017182,
-0.1980165541,
-0.4728523493,
0.3061477542,
0.577593565,
0.3309656382,
0.2817094028,
-0.0892019272,
-0.3315596282,
-0.4662086368,
0.0304305106,
0.55696702,
-0.0536725856,
-0.3824776709,
0.628189683,
0.0632712469,
-1.0664306879,
0.6672259569,
0.1998465359,
-0.8021646142,
0.5631296039,
0.8817802668,
0.526856184,
-0.4673844576,
-0.1048738733,
-0.0201446339,
0.1474199593,
-0.2479184866,
0.0783764049,
0.5643371344,
-0.5303748846,
-0.6654057503,
-0.4781979918,
-0.8048667312,
-0.1495187879,
-0.1862007678,
0.4561060369,
-0.330747962,
-0.1883596778,
0.2574824691,
-0.1988811493,
-0.6847114563,
-0.0601714514,
0.1470185965,
0.7869437337,
-0.5427254438,
0.8816088438,
0.56071347,
-0.1780376285,
-0.557792902,
-0.3892681301,
-0.1884341836,
-0.9078044891,
0.8097550869,
-0.2268347889,
0.0307020023,
0.1222829074,
-0.6300750971,
-1.0056339502,
0.7479403019,
0.6898648739,
-0.7704662681,
0.0061205649,
0.4625513554,
0.7196215987,
-0.2719474435,
0.6476159096,
0.3771521151,
0.1716084033,
0.1536646336,
-0.8619039059,
-0.2807547152,
0.1168527827,
0.4573753476,
0.553719461,
-0.493758738,
1.093180418,
0.0242311899,
0.0545357466,
0.0884474516,
0.6368839145,
-0.032809712,
-0.2133296579,
0.1702425927,
0.2240599841,
0.8037847281,
-0.4013366997,
1.0232419968,
-0.6561558247,
0.5716607571,
0.6577046514,
-0.1311152428,
0.7198894024,
0.2587348521,
-0.5578036904,
0.2865583003,
0.4406805038,
0.0252867714,
-0.0521432795,
0.5449308157,
-0.3498639762,
-0.3283613622,
0.2060871273,
-0.4843532145,
0.2302865386,
0.6762918234,
-0.3071186841,
-0.3404777348,
-0.1048972085,
0.1952446997,
0.0458290726,
-0.357242465,
0.590798974,
0.5847452283,
-0.4621636868,
0.3383529782,
0.0282897819,
0.4046203196,
-0.455739826,
0.0243657213,
-0.2284078598,
0.3005487323,
-0.0604048036,
-0.9970193505,
0.4395903051,
0.0619360022,
0.041684024,
-0.2166320533,
0.7786961198,
-0.3344442844,
-0.7477789521,
-0.0487312563,
0.6117089987,
0.4439502656,
-0.0291609336,
-0.6792709827,
0.0983676091,
-0.3514633775,
-0.1105597913,
0.3521236777,
0.6059677005,
0.0961185694,
1.0447772741,
0.7268624306,
0.2217871249,
0.1330173016,
0.2683751583,
1.0084687471,
-0.7123161554,
-0.2591240108,
-0.9847858548,
0.2471773326,
0.0275250543,
-0.1168865189,
0.8497004509,
0.5060251951,
0.5050938129,
-0.2761093676,
0.56484586,
0.2725559771,
0.6417383552,
-0.3555711508,
0.7647097111,
-0.091553852,
0.3596287966,
-0.1563297361,
-1.2716754675,
-0.6684520841,
0.7239094973,
-0.6185969114,
0.0816957727,
0.6018532515,
0.6683201194,
-0.2210688144,
0.2288723141,
0.6556129456,
0.0845611095,
0.8351731896,
0.4463437796,
1.0758849382,
-0.2786071599,
0.5784311295,
0.0395281352,
-0.12738657,
-0.2099712491,
-0.9243161678,
-1.2082824707,
-0.2550087869,
-0.3629799187,
-0.2361028492,
-0.2855543494,
0.7895541191,
0.7104003429,
-0.5912815928,
-0.6531084776,
-0.1371714175,
0.1514114738,
0.2247085869,
-0.1171702445,
0.0628824309,
-0.5269895196,
-0.7649818063,
0.057589367,
0.2387942672,
0.2913983464,
-0.4811411798,
-0.0134205725,
0.4548027217,
0.3345463872,
0.7919409275,
0.018169865,
-0.6223596931,
-0.0673250556,
0.0126748905,
-0.1900114417,
0.1299046129,
1.1111437082,
-0.3699237108,
0.1861531287,
0.3552404046,
0.830820322,
0.5524887443,
-0.2699245512,
0.6224586368,
-0.1266272515,
0.1123004556,
0.3891604841,
0.5938308239,
0.3748039603,
-0.1749916673,
0.5733245015,
0.1672929227,
-0.9306274652,
-0.8067678809,
0.3368452489,
-0.6036974788,
-0.0155038442,
1.2080482244,
-0.07564722,
-0.1821827292,
0.0734200105,
-0.4228116274,
0.0446225218,
-0.1294407845,
0.7474420071,
0.9393446445,
-0.1016452834,
-0.6150744557,
-0.9362546802,
0.3330501914,
0.2294100523,
-0.9552397728,
0.048295036,
0.2144358456,
0.3432632387,
0.1315280199,
0.2817775607,
-0.278632313,
-0.0756974444,
-0.1038453802,
-0.2803362608,
0.2501440048,
-0.2283789814,
-0.412229836,
-0.0285531562,
0.486218363,
0.4867359102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04554v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04554v1
|
Improved Visual Grounding through Self-Consistent Explanations
| 2023-12-07T18:59:22 | 2023-12-07T18:59:22 |
Ruozhen He, Paola Cascante-Bonilla, Ziyan Yang, Alexander C. Berg, Vicente Ordonez
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Vision-and-language models trained to match images with text can be combined
with visual explanation methods to point to the locations of specific objects
in an image. Our work shows that the localization --"grounding"-- abilities of
these models can be further improved by finetuning for self-consistent visual
explanations. We propose a strategy for augmenting existing text-image datasets
with paraphrases using a large language model, and SelfEQ, a weakly-supervised
strategy on visual explanation maps for paraphrases that encourages
self-consistency. Specifically, for an input textual phrase, we attempt to
generate a paraphrase and finetune the model so that the phrase and paraphrase
map to the same region in the image. We posit that this both expands the
vocabulary that the model is able to handle, and improves the quality of the
object locations highlighted by gradient-based visual explanation methods (e.g.
GradCAM). We demonstrate that SelfEQ improves performance on Flickr30k,
ReferIt, and RefCOCO+ over a strong baseline method and several prior works.
Particularly, comparing to other methods that do not use any type of box
annotations, we obtain 84.07% on Flickr30k (an absolute improvement of 4.69%),
67.40% on ReferIt (an absolute improvement of 7.68%), and 75.10%, 55.49% on
RefCOCO+ test sets A and B respectively (an absolute improvement of 3.74% on
average).
|
[
-0.2994418442,
-0.7143968344,
0.6893219352,
0.1860040724,
-0.4938445091,
-0.5212399364,
-0.1185059473,
-0.2089783698,
0.0061803986,
0.7099072337,
-0.2576879263,
-0.7480126619,
-0.2744552195,
0.0848943442,
-0.5163958073,
0.8362340927,
-0.1854253113,
0.0005708526,
-0.4219273925,
-0.4409959018,
-0.6433658004,
-0.2934424877,
-0.3311790526,
-0.1290016919,
0.3812365532,
0.5835964084,
1.1094040871,
1.2022954226,
0.8165791035,
0.2976953983,
0.2009045333,
0.0245604776,
-0.3658908308,
0.1033270061,
-0.4638552964,
-0.3900922537,
0.0088955667,
-0.2033933103,
0.507242918,
0.4865579605,
-0.0314478055,
-0.047716599,
0.106312871,
0.8044572473,
-0.7537810206,
0.0409333967,
-0.447001189,
0.1897173673,
0.0872518122,
-0.4320639372,
-0.0487927869,
-0.1038873419,
0.0446154252,
-0.8137885928,
0.6039981842,
-0.0410914496,
1.0720005035,
0.5791703463,
-0.061749611,
0.1203698292,
-0.4414608479,
0.7001032829,
-0.5632370114,
0.3439475298,
0.3529097438,
0.4142953157,
0.0395622589,
-0.798551023,
-0.5157527328,
-0.0094104363,
-0.2280539274,
0.5191709995,
0.0794588327,
0.1169378534,
0.293604821,
0.6038947105,
-0.2787098289,
-0.2133688629,
-0.3072600365,
-0.1206697226,
0.3794566989,
-0.0726664141,
0.4720881879,
-0.4872121811,
-0.4189935625,
-0.1623642445,
-0.4884084463,
0.1722976714,
-0.1538641006,
-0.0604191869,
0.0715087354,
0.661908865,
-0.630078733,
0.7878368497,
0.2727131546,
-0.0541586503,
0.1649909467,
-0.5004826784,
-0.3197413385,
-0.2806616127,
0.7702256441,
1.0330678225,
0.3363466859,
-0.2318270355,
-0.2217023969,
-0.0781728476,
-0.0444031172,
-0.6184163094,
-0.6112444997,
0.097767517,
-0.762193799,
-0.2258786857,
-0.0362821855,
-0.9192245603,
-0.275865823,
-0.5009727478,
0.5197648406,
-0.4323292673,
0.0149416421,
0.0494567156,
-0.3718661368,
0.4567020833,
0.5612871647,
-0.9437403679,
0.1796967238,
0.3013878167,
0.986697793,
-0.1317194253,
-0.633225441,
-0.5536527634,
0.2775511146,
-0.6274522543,
1.0619692802,
-0.3439965546,
-0.0258925203,
-0.0100487182,
0.1805703789,
0.2740519047,
-0.6459385157,
0.49224931,
-0.0646363497,
0.1644538194,
-0.3527412117,
-0.372213155,
-0.1531835794,
0.0688853711,
-0.3697040081,
1.2664681673,
-0.2702387869,
-0.6307994127,
0.2844244242,
-0.2854953706,
-0.3929749429,
0.0486569665,
-0.416777879,
-0.2241714001,
0.1903203875,
0.8747624159,
0.7939988375,
-0.0385868363,
0.2997196615,
-0.2732334137,
-0.6047676206,
-0.0157046337,
-0.2303564101,
0.4104737639,
0.2323399633,
-0.5608005524,
-0.1255634129,
-0.6125270724,
0.0709920153,
0.2265321016,
0.1803707927,
-0.3322393596,
-0.0066805999,
-0.2731901407,
0.2664752007,
0.3232049942,
-0.1100199819,
-0.1856304854,
-0.268730104,
0.374263227,
0.4570152164,
0.2137109488,
0.7747686505,
-0.2423911244,
0.4687914252,
0.1596037745,
0.2161099315,
-0.8747441769,
-0.3187215626,
-0.8240774274,
-0.1959999651,
0.0014201938,
0.5544426441,
-0.8742045164,
0.0646619499,
-0.2807562053,
-0.224639073,
-0.4143320918,
0.3327896595,
0.5352155566,
0.9799678326,
0.8439425826,
-0.0368737243,
-0.2292494178,
-1.1687033176,
-0.3399319351,
0.1571855098,
-0.0239736959,
0.1470990181,
0.4020245373,
0.109418802,
0.879591167,
-0.3828973472,
-0.2747747004,
0.1056230739,
0.0782573074,
0.1423982233,
0.5814974904,
0.6928305626,
-0.8809543848,
-0.5799256563,
-0.0786426067,
-1.2427165508,
-0.214815557,
-0.4121058881,
-0.2786467671,
-0.2553418577,
0.8393450379,
-0.3122751415,
0.5545547605,
0.2602914274,
-0.2154645622,
0.3576154411,
-0.3505052924,
0.4006989002,
-0.819423914,
-0.321049124,
0.3409340084,
-0.5349453688,
-0.4193784893,
0.322835803,
0.2561831772,
-0.2377454489,
-0.3456154466,
0.4964512289,
-0.6545980573,
0.1067002118,
-0.3712658584,
0.4652372003,
0.3295123875,
0.4152461886,
0.0884560198,
0.8868665695,
1.1103553772,
-0.474317342,
0.286678195,
0.3222880065,
-0.0935971886,
0.7958880067,
-0.9073127508,
-0.1120631546,
-0.5136880279,
0.0546631627,
-1.2854322195,
-0.3346368968,
0.1857740432,
-0.2449815422,
-0.0434481762,
-0.4255809784,
-0.2959368229,
-0.2257186919,
-0.3258475959,
0.2055161595,
0.6717627048,
-1.0016278028,
0.5889803171,
-0.0618717298,
0.0057211746,
-0.5345711708,
-0.7782165408,
0.3459051251,
-0.5008106232,
-0.6084382534,
0.3935745955,
0.0234661158,
-0.1084216684,
-0.1350098848,
-0.2332639396,
-0.1622194797,
-0.0102418736,
0.3806109726,
0.0859108642,
-0.2082824707,
0.4043171108,
-0.0523675717,
-0.0373125076,
-0.0332145877,
-0.3012627959,
-0.0487583354,
-0.2709859908,
-0.0634125471,
-0.7910183668,
0.3575241268,
0.3271890581,
-0.2556092739,
0.4577362239,
0.5752747655,
-0.2639042139,
0.0795560405,
-0.7009373903,
-0.2186298966,
-0.4917570055,
0.0622509643,
-0.7404299974,
-0.422298491,
0.6127744913,
-0.1113494858,
-0.2152914703,
0.6235055923,
0.107460916,
-0.6875899434,
0.9477146268,
0.5125778913,
0.2744183242,
0.7570800781,
-0.1867198199,
-0.1528093666,
-0.6549152136,
-0.0468178242,
-0.1900614202,
-0.142855674,
-0.3734028935,
-0.4737997353,
0.0330011956,
0.6479557157,
0.0074795992,
0.1827354729,
-0.6623800397,
0.9499940276,
0.7798324823,
0.4444039762,
0.3595153987,
0.4298172891,
-0.0597177334,
-0.4437472522,
-0.8287727237,
-0.4718637466,
1.0209652185,
0.2628771663,
0.9059742689,
-0.3381521702,
0.8948031664,
0.0647962466,
0.1265192032,
-0.4783728719,
0.4898090065,
-0.3078276217,
-0.3491182029,
-0.4778787792,
-0.283300519,
-0.6789860725,
0.3632226884,
-0.3442751169,
-0.5913398266,
0.3490970135,
0.5128237605,
-0.2583919764,
-0.1540260017,
-0.9478401542,
1.1477020979,
-0.1885482371,
-0.6074422002,
0.1401340216,
-0.6567882895,
0.1818149537,
0.1037733927,
0.1182663292,
-0.0638776198,
0.1095084548,
0.6170255542,
-0.5101517439,
0.6610813141,
-0.2824275196,
0.008431389,
0.432482779,
0.0308185015,
0.5655584335,
0.0349457338,
0.0990902781,
0.2660827041,
0.091895476,
-0.6108189225,
-1.1169333458,
0.6739894748,
-0.4636588693,
-0.7498858571,
0.0211253688,
-0.2894785404,
0.16026254,
0.2506600916,
0.5337118506,
0.647755444,
0.3195747137,
0.5242197514,
0.6494909525,
-0.0863118395,
0.3829422891,
0.0364723876,
-0.2422929406,
-0.6226923466,
0.8523744941,
0.0116417063,
0.1204913333,
0.3592028916,
0.3767977357,
-0.4570334554,
-0.6950274706,
-0.3675034642,
0.1870784014,
-1.2720551491,
-0.2396323383,
-0.5822731853,
0.3221724331,
-0.4194929898,
-0.5586705804,
-0.3691105545,
-0.4128521085,
-0.1793239117,
0.0572327524,
0.3266741931,
0.3229243755,
-0.0623809807,
0.5196897984,
-0.3724791408,
0.8596426845,
0.4083845913,
0.2324919999,
-0.2595767677,
-0.8082563877,
-0.1870465279,
0.1220991164,
-0.0797212273,
-0.9169300795,
0.2138091624,
0.3003332317,
0.6307593584,
0.2927754819,
-0.02390421,
1.3617289066,
-0.5946598649,
0.794475913,
0.4139641523,
-1.0101697445,
1.0085192919,
-0.5643296838,
0.4745462239,
0.7057136297,
0.0870917663,
-0.3085513413,
-0.6616622806,
-0.6658930779,
-0.6908251643,
0.3030399084,
0.3787342906,
0.1999080628,
-0.0451460332,
0.8300004601,
-0.2250936776,
-0.2085044533,
-1.1234955788,
-0.319437921,
-0.8012563586,
-0.5255470276,
-0.2077435702,
-0.178121686,
-0.4094317257,
-0.3761515021,
0.2643654346,
-0.4794000089,
0.1774112582,
0.8229258657,
-0.2622485161,
-0.0464438349,
-0.1666830182,
0.3157735765,
0.8188524246,
0.0066669513,
0.5424751043,
0.2133987397,
-0.0796542466,
-0.0293561146,
0.0236594193,
-0.3489040732,
0.1855897456,
0.4961761534,
0.5368429422,
0.268555522,
-0.4322223663,
0.6294430494,
0.1152680218,
-0.1978431344,
0.0047073294,
0.124531664,
-0.2098765969,
0.3681719303,
0.4474545419,
-0.0539401732,
0.3796828091,
-0.3913363218,
0.2814778686,
0.257324785,
-0.2522508502,
0.0733770952,
0.7884688973,
-0.0240023229,
0.0211028289,
0.2021881342,
0.1210925654,
-0.3239572048,
0.7345716953,
0.6818309426,
0.5624102354,
0.0829817802,
0.3801356256,
0.5368533731,
0.2528816462,
-0.4645067751,
0.1755972505,
-0.2258638889,
-0.6477898359,
-0.3634424806,
-0.1808529645,
-0.2892416418,
-0.1271250546,
-0.6358363628,
0.2152857929,
-0.3615681827,
0.1449010372,
0.1754766256,
-0.5198016167,
-0.6805613041,
0.6949055195,
0.0626437739,
0.5213903785,
-0.766947031,
0.4192693233,
0.8446003795,
-0.5847333074,
-0.7403329611,
0.1891930848,
-0.5046485662,
-0.7376844287,
0.6393076181,
0.3584705889,
-0.1592447013,
0.1489293873,
-0.8413361907,
-0.9444064498,
1.135538578,
0.3369065821,
-0.4812105894,
0.3343687654,
-0.2098407149,
0.6540259719,
-0.3482931852,
0.1840613782,
0.1716371775,
0.2009118199,
0.1204137877,
-0.4940651655,
0.1625588685,
0.0355269089,
0.2360868901,
-0.1323583275,
-0.5713543296,
0.4031126797,
-0.2265475094,
-0.2015630752,
-0.033383172,
0.9193177223,
-0.0075115599,
0.3499276936,
0.3113015592,
0.5125889778,
0.6259422302,
-0.0488506593,
1.0721977949,
-0.271939218,
0.5681437254,
1.4238603115,
0.2739109099,
0.7005150318,
0.7229147553,
0.1791562736,
0.4543710947,
0.5235859752,
-0.1894173026,
0.7600401044,
-0.2257471085,
0.1833196133,
-0.621712327,
0.0017465389,
-0.2504081428,
0.3262977004,
-0.1511113793,
-0.6472555995,
-0.4418759942,
0.2405988276,
-0.444637835,
0.415620178,
-0.4389706552,
0.6279238462,
0.0544826128,
-0.7728773355,
0.8627004027,
-0.2104325444,
0.2653997838,
-0.0487031527,
-0.155528605,
-0.5391381383,
0.042716749,
-0.2551580071,
-0.9571812749,
0.2262226939,
-0.1100855693,
-0.2242708951,
-0.488214463,
0.8319732547,
-0.4349930882,
-0.4669313133,
0.0965558663,
0.3469205499,
0.2823592722,
-0.349815011,
-0.9099148512,
-0.3527565598,
-0.0376905352,
-0.0222158041,
-0.0874233097,
0.7766315937,
-0.0644484162,
0.8132483363,
0.4838539064,
-0.3207948506,
0.1687519103,
0.160334453,
0.6076091528,
-0.8568147421,
-0.476952821,
-0.9493459463,
0.5041416883,
-0.2746998966,
-0.3730806708,
0.9728220701,
0.417501837,
0.598152101,
-0.4091377556,
0.3761550486,
0.2859813273,
0.1102166697,
-0.8670096993,
0.2394922674,
-0.7334930301,
-0.1116910949,
-0.4048357308,
-1.054861784,
-0.5407479405,
1.0806440115,
-0.3140845001,
-0.2118495852,
1.0131418705,
0.7070232034,
-0.2273470908,
-0.4297200143,
0.5813750029,
0.0381319039,
0.0256107468,
0.0098719401,
0.8881808519,
-0.7565213442,
0.6790226102,
-0.6299391985,
-0.2127488703,
0.0590655729,
-0.8997347951,
-1.064688921,
-0.3392712772,
-0.7946103215,
-0.2856464386,
0.1587042511,
0.156647861,
0.8808423877,
-0.6041212082,
0.1347992718,
-0.5242769122,
0.0466223359,
-0.3134820163,
-0.2314046025,
0.3287727833,
-0.5776094198,
-0.5783866048,
0.3371081054,
0.4276225269,
0.366953969,
-0.0601291768,
0.1071431413,
0.0886823907,
-0.1124931872,
0.2963244021,
0.2262612581,
-0.9287660122,
-0.3486001194,
0.0343880095,
-0.1720773131,
0.4574816227,
0.5070512295,
-0.7280647755,
0.6710419655,
0.2795106769,
0.456350714,
0.526129961,
0.5776506662,
0.5371755362,
-0.6913205385,
0.2474764585,
-0.1335147321,
0.5443042517,
0.630282402,
-0.5228351355,
0.6271826029,
0.2809790075,
-0.4616122246,
-0.4151554704,
0.037623018,
-0.9758874774,
-0.2119134665,
1.0846117735,
-0.3697348237,
-0.2682498395,
0.0334839262,
-0.3304057717,
0.1296420246,
-0.0911316574,
0.7714059949,
0.6938869357,
0.1250149459,
-0.6277205348,
-0.5248889923,
0.4966502488,
0.8202680945,
-0.7913653255,
-0.0040531596,
0.6146118045,
0.4633400738,
0.1270861775,
0.6440027952,
0.0064990511,
0.4937266707,
-0.1672484875,
0.1116249412,
0.0790978521,
-0.4954154193,
-0.5828602314,
-0.0411484428,
-0.1755502224,
-0.4181275368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04965v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04965v1
|
Inversion-Free Image Editing with Natural Language
| 2023-12-07T18:58:27 | 2023-12-07T18:58:27 |
Sihan Xu, Yidong Huang, Jiayi Pan, Ziqiao Ma, Joyce Chai
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Despite recent advances in inversion-based editing, text-guided image
manipulation remains challenging for diffusion models. The primary bottlenecks
include 1) the time-consuming nature of the inversion process; 2) the struggle
to balance consistency with accuracy; 3) the lack of compatibility with
efficient consistency sampling methods used in consistency models. To address
the above issues, we start by asking ourselves if the inversion process can be
eliminated for editing. We show that when the initial sample is known, a
special variance schedule reduces the denoising step to the same form as the
multi-step consistency sampling. We name this Denoising Diffusion Consistent
Model (DDCM), and note that it implies a virtual inversion strategy without
explicit inversion in sampling. We further unify the attention control
mechanisms in a tuning-free framework for text-guided editing. Combining them,
we present inversion-free editing (InfEdit), which allows for consistent and
faithful editing for both rigid and non-rigid semantic changes, catering to
intricate modifications without compromising on the image's integrity and
explicit inversion. Through extensive experiments, InfEdit shows strong
performance in various editing tasks and also maintains a seamless workflow
(less than 3 seconds on one single A40), demonstrating the potential for
real-time applications. Project Page: https://sled-group.github.io/InfEdit/
|
[
-0.199446395,
-1.0314875841,
0.6368739009,
0.3097082675,
-0.2658835649,
-0.0399977043,
-0.2118992805,
-0.7049483061,
-0.0689229146,
0.7278058529,
-0.6694054008,
-0.3858993948,
-0.7029995918,
0.1690785885,
-0.569881022,
0.842890799,
-0.3446604013,
0.0353488661,
-0.2524399757,
-0.3339989185,
-0.4125513434,
0.3343011439,
-0.8896415234,
-0.3855777085,
0.086056523,
0.4344779551,
1.0407141447,
0.9139044881,
0.4865324199,
0.2012850195,
-0.411835134,
0.1307189763,
-0.4407574236,
-0.0913945362,
-0.38928473,
-0.2202716619,
-0.4181885421,
0.0075667431,
0.756344676,
0.6293856502,
-0.1284909397,
-0.0110717267,
0.0485974699,
1.1245996952,
-0.5141344666,
-0.3643201292,
-0.5598852634,
-0.0254751705,
0.023073243,
0.1440441757,
-0.1062064171,
-0.6412390471,
-0.0699226931,
-1.071143508,
0.4876097143,
-0.3000640869,
0.8709797263,
0.6815605164,
-0.2619476616,
-0.1627041996,
-0.6708496809,
0.5982284546,
-0.5077369213,
0.4465471506,
0.3439941406,
0.0638376027,
-0.2074581236,
-0.7061139345,
-0.7033119202,
0.1841748506,
0.2173102796,
0.2601638138,
-0.2454139739,
0.2743108571,
0.114252463,
0.4550261199,
-0.3594652116,
0.1496832371,
0.0544031225,
0.0364341922,
0.3615166545,
0.0182368811,
0.1854119152,
0.0660823286,
-0.3217151165,
0.203883782,
-0.6281836629,
-0.2250943482,
0.5169759989,
-0.3521719575,
-0.1440754533,
0.7876386046,
-0.0752444342,
0.9143360257,
0.4853950441,
0.137520209,
-0.122899875,
-0.19838579,
-0.535585165,
-0.1406972706,
0.4732900858,
0.8365000486,
0.0925623998,
-0.3678833246,
-0.2908763885,
0.1792726219,
0.1793990582,
-0.791056335,
-0.283631742,
0.3120566308,
-0.3072734177,
-0.4466591477,
-0.0719196051,
-0.9071445465,
-0.5536355376,
-0.4774895012,
0.4253989458,
-0.4365777373,
-0.1492699534,
0.4218960702,
-0.4945477247,
0.1198830381,
0.6571192741,
-0.5567749143,
0.4235957265,
0.5183754563,
1.0143642426,
-0.2690275013,
-0.01302954,
-0.5663412213,
0.4060179591,
-0.4148072004,
0.927857101,
-0.7342318296,
-0.6479873061,
-0.3241994679,
0.0204829816,
0.1990591139,
-0.7240506411,
0.510011971,
-0.6585457325,
0.2224902958,
0.027195856,
-0.749138236,
-0.0257980004,
0.1987764537,
-0.77113235,
1.2225720882,
0.2655529976,
-0.738979876,
0.1902510524,
-0.9530953169,
-0.1141615435,
-0.1029501036,
0.2144708335,
-0.3997066915,
0.0563335828,
0.3175837398,
-0.090269275,
-0.0146246348,
0.128908813,
-0.1512215137,
-0.5015565753,
0.0114784474,
-0.3049767017,
0.9001242518,
-0.0575763397,
-0.2876985371,
-0.0076042567,
-1.1519788504,
-0.1943439841,
-0.0575063191,
-0.3292821944,
-0.500824213,
-0.3212872446,
0.1092327684,
0.0614843778,
0.0893960595,
-0.9084349871,
0.541336298,
-0.4726969004,
0.1617245078,
0.8592913747,
0.4684749246,
1.0923702717,
-0.1301994473,
0.6234676242,
0.0902597234,
0.1469302624,
0.0647957101,
-0.4872317016,
-0.6196305752,
-0.6412134767,
0.2604384422,
0.7258777618,
-0.9240860939,
-0.0726496056,
-0.2991415262,
-0.4929982722,
-0.9412180185,
0.3780400753,
0.3661133647,
1.0421081781,
0.4671857357,
-0.401651293,
-0.2593074441,
-0.9219548106,
-0.6138260365,
0.3645760715,
-0.1291561574,
0.0653008893,
0.2145132571,
-0.5677654147,
0.9971746802,
-0.7295838594,
-0.3595201671,
0.181631729,
0.4174063802,
0.0711057186,
0.7746486068,
0.5590523481,
-0.6953411698,
-0.6395121813,
-0.0509219356,
-0.5888113976,
-0.4961082339,
-0.3726696074,
-0.5153118968,
0.3359533548,
0.5376504064,
-0.7991059422,
0.7397907972,
0.4754258394,
-0.1960929334,
0.463996917,
-0.3610459268,
0.1582168937,
-0.7574557066,
-0.0735728964,
0.2596710324,
-0.4227951467,
-0.7107629776,
0.0484566912,
0.5850597024,
0.0948423296,
-0.3614574969,
0.6806490421,
-0.5538295507,
0.1946032345,
-0.2997361422,
0.0968102962,
0.3225467503,
0.2711392045,
-0.0000401043,
0.5435922146,
0.6673159599,
-0.6383509636,
0.1104541644,
0.2718333304,
-0.2686930001,
1.2383047342,
-0.6859012246,
0.4728250802,
-0.6500524282,
0.0979191214,
-0.9161041379,
0.0151843075,
0.3850879371,
-0.1669829041,
0.3647264838,
-0.3528608978,
-0.5523888469,
0.2136399448,
-0.462652564,
0.3408559263,
0.2216037661,
-0.5726616979,
0.5092982054,
0.1144188419,
0.0512344316,
-0.5154559016,
-0.8352249861,
0.25270468,
-0.0537116863,
-0.4424217343,
0.7379558086,
-0.3007087111,
-0.4127882421,
0.3889456987,
-0.1267745793,
-0.3105204105,
-0.0574666895,
0.2201454639,
0.3495564163,
0.1806182265,
-0.09212818,
0.5076126456,
-0.1785712689,
-0.4404740334,
-0.3614441752,
-0.1758900285,
0.2166030556,
-0.1870930046,
-0.7080562115,
0.377078712,
0.5472822189,
-0.1345384717,
0.3914495111,
0.3792548776,
-0.4916475117,
0.2258123308,
-0.4404525459,
0.1362666041,
-0.4453943074,
0.0586274527,
-0.0271868911,
-0.5483688116,
0.4675804675,
-0.1838700175,
0.308778584,
0.2763538957,
0.0780601799,
-0.397011131,
0.6809219718,
0.8809233308,
0.3224155605,
0.6956064105,
-0.3457378447,
-0.1397069097,
-1.0376045704,
0.1732370406,
-0.3279639184,
-0.5738679767,
-0.1054804549,
-0.462290436,
0.4259781539,
0.1306557357,
0.0615276471,
0.1502363086,
-0.5671176314,
0.9222678542,
0.2558270991,
0.2401188612,
0.6394191384,
-0.2182124406,
0.0860329196,
-0.2873274982,
-0.3594432771,
-0.4077447355,
0.7373665571,
-0.1037705392,
0.900290072,
0.03575987,
0.4957593083,
0.2695461512,
0.4934803545,
-0.5185912251,
0.4911807477,
0.0307294633,
-0.4598816633,
-0.3309696317,
-0.0735868365,
-0.7567256093,
0.1745629758,
-0.1961101741,
-0.3546228707,
0.346213907,
0.3031618297,
-0.0290553328,
0.6368365884,
-0.8917284608,
0.7638628483,
0.1439262629,
-0.6521285176,
-0.2089161724,
-0.7984236479,
0.2878520191,
0.0090724947,
0.2955110371,
-0.0376826599,
-0.417183429,
0.0728282109,
-0.2675396502,
0.7350097895,
-0.5151782632,
-0.0786435306,
0.0801730305,
0.5313267112,
0.5563706756,
0.1633768827,
-0.1958310902,
0.1159254611,
-0.0515495129,
-0.3556254804,
-0.7616157532,
0.7306677699,
-0.395188272,
-0.3362098336,
-0.032856334,
-0.6073027253,
0.0321510658,
0.3435299695,
0.1935127378,
0.4659209251,
-0.2537468374,
-0.0643487796,
0.738878727,
-0.077215597,
0.6210865974,
0.1980963945,
-0.2744171321,
-0.4475911856,
0.5864277482,
0.1914135069,
0.5369018912,
0.3783248067,
0.0914671496,
-0.1587937921,
-0.5118865967,
-0.98845011,
0.1739548445,
-0.7492591739,
-0.1644634455,
-0.6490584612,
0.2366109937,
-0.3171440065,
-0.5795112252,
-0.4663201272,
-0.8587545753,
-0.6806538105,
0.0255135447,
0.3330367506,
0.6446939111,
-0.0852869079,
0.350304842,
-0.6919469237,
0.8517920375,
0.1081435755,
0.7702447176,
-0.2840566337,
-0.4901958406,
-0.1892407387,
0.1492622197,
-0.4742715955,
-0.9847654104,
0.3095582426,
0.5074583292,
0.4317061603,
0.2576116621,
-0.0881998986,
1.0842293501,
-0.2884933949,
0.8453754783,
-0.2196926028,
-0.9755667448,
0.4770662487,
-0.185988754,
0.6174838543,
0.5278967619,
0.1552777439,
-0.6795240045,
-0.731862247,
-0.5665717125,
-0.6839825511,
0.4279768765,
0.1192187518,
0.0662619397,
0.1738571227,
0.6302309632,
0.3745043576,
0.3251956999,
-0.6525844336,
-0.0708970502,
-0.5638750792,
-0.2394928038,
0.2409829497,
-0.1357762665,
-0.2084147334,
-0.5868691206,
0.6944120526,
-0.038971398,
0.0473713614,
0.6870722175,
-0.5616317987,
-0.4102410376,
0.0998255685,
0.650642097,
0.4664463997,
-0.1176273152,
0.0576315597,
-0.0088400776,
-0.5564174056,
0.0826492608,
-0.1574950516,
-0.6936115623,
0.050797727,
-0.0670016557,
0.6463932395,
0.3230576515,
-0.5012088418,
0.378174603,
-0.159252882,
-0.4246969819,
-0.1263450831,
-0.1530992985,
-0.0197106544,
0.1434044838,
0.0478474721,
0.5611840487,
0.1939127594,
0.0992590785,
-0.2082858533,
0.5190507174,
-0.3645166755,
-0.2278349102,
0.9557142854,
-0.1223860309,
-0.3351300955,
0.6556178331,
-0.2268841714,
0.0465937331,
0.397952944,
0.387306869,
1.1013798714,
-0.0372623019,
0.2543947697,
0.3140144646,
0.4375105798,
-0.086851418,
0.2971816957,
-0.0298164897,
-0.6896595359,
-0.2557526231,
-0.2427640259,
-0.5292244554,
-0.2428685874,
-0.5504366159,
0.2593846917,
-0.5667783022,
0.0266126059,
-0.0578447767,
-0.5637174249,
-0.4057452083,
0.1669315994,
-0.3445575237,
1.1277838945,
-0.5326604843,
0.7636575103,
0.7660742402,
-0.0762481987,
-0.0741625205,
-0.0342935696,
0.0869396776,
-0.2715929747,
-0.0813209116,
0.0861649141,
-0.3569681048,
0.3028597236,
-1.0224742889,
-0.5555787683,
1.0002132654,
0.6852030158,
-0.0723616034,
0.0293548256,
-0.2089171857,
0.5615056753,
0.0046211258,
-0.1835642606,
0.6168014407,
0.6886237264,
0.1190026775,
-0.490423888,
-0.3555853069,
-0.0190683696,
0.0863294601,
0.2537357807,
-0.3941766322,
0.4978584349,
-0.2168249488,
-0.3896046579,
0.0327710286,
0.4808476567,
-0.3214517236,
0.2735503018,
0.5193589926,
1.1131108999,
0.7098016143,
0.0261727571,
0.9588971138,
-0.0625574961,
0.0653375611,
1.1680194139,
-0.199840486,
0.4278043807,
0.8700990677,
0.19167234,
0.6015170217,
0.3981476426,
0.0327619426,
0.6803620458,
-0.2976891398,
-0.2742163539,
0.0877465829,
0.2235670537,
0.0438343994,
0.1502849162,
0.1421551257,
0.0427443348,
-0.4187971354,
0.0210308786,
0.0553598516,
0.3415400386,
-0.4245170355,
0.7798478603,
-0.2203341275,
-0.5453949571,
0.4434712231,
0.1542910486,
0.7258715034,
-0.394825995,
-0.2061924636,
-0.2119695991,
0.046104528,
-0.3299716711,
-1.0339683294,
0.7590309978,
0.1126657352,
-0.2791658044,
-0.6103991866,
0.7291724682,
-0.5586670637,
-0.5528412461,
-0.0363570862,
0.1607743055,
-0.1232786924,
-0.1929798871,
-0.5794559717,
-0.1691219211,
-0.0780528188,
-0.3936802745,
0.1374478936,
0.4506835938,
-0.0349500142,
0.5969865322,
0.6215378046,
0.2388495952,
0.2505649626,
-0.1309050471,
0.6974728107,
-0.5401734114,
-0.3794070482,
-0.8357172608,
0.7641569972,
-0.1797206104,
-0.2335801572,
0.5130109787,
0.6192581058,
0.8148782849,
-0.2981255949,
0.6600322127,
0.1532331854,
0.38614133,
-0.5600992441,
0.6521043181,
-0.646515131,
-0.0504431762,
-0.5838491917,
-0.767580986,
-0.6991138458,
0.4295225739,
-0.0361557156,
-0.4985499978,
0.5748872757,
1.1552433968,
-0.1866244078,
-0.0322876759,
0.1504334956,
0.1254720688,
0.441437304,
0.1435268074,
0.47116822,
-0.4191847444,
0.3035567403,
-0.5133292675,
-0.1982715875,
0.2003826946,
-1.2815465927,
-0.3254600167,
-0.3533166349,
-0.6122076511,
-0.1589072049,
-0.2508646548,
0.7580747008,
0.2403982431,
-0.3284417093,
0.1670061052,
-0.439421773,
0.3993269801,
-0.6668832302,
-0.2177722007,
0.1102335528,
0.118285358,
-1.015078783,
0.2821176648,
0.7220243812,
0.5358657241,
0.1297235489,
-0.0129662128,
-0.1892384738,
0.1851592213,
0.3676869571,
0.3677401841,
-0.4527075589,
-0.2058077902,
-0.1099835411,
-0.1772026569,
0.3903105557,
0.6121993661,
-0.6618057489,
0.8855026364,
0.2803583741,
0.7034159303,
0.563071847,
0.2051488608,
0.2211141139,
-0.8876410127,
0.469868809,
0.1194527373,
0.0461357422,
0.552801013,
-0.4828215539,
0.5125109553,
0.5035586953,
-0.5928376317,
-0.8165739179,
0.2498839051,
-1.1576759815,
-0.1413916051,
0.994369328,
0.2137064189,
-0.144963026,
-0.1191617548,
-0.757031858,
0.4362480342,
-0.0745724514,
0.8295333385,
0.8720248938,
-0.3296260238,
-0.40298751,
-0.553552568,
0.5019071102,
0.1295599937,
-0.49786219,
0.2392998636,
0.9274461865,
0.328343749,
-0.1818059981,
0.7694006562,
-0.4349396527,
0.3375228345,
-0.3087154925,
0.2944400311,
-0.1729452461,
-0.1386236548,
-0.7469335794,
-0.0652486533,
-0.0364668332,
-0.1861587465
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04515v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04515v1
|
Efficient Monotonic Multihead Attention
| 2023-12-07T18:34:57 | 2023-12-07T18:34:57 |
Xutai Ma, Anna Sun, Siqi Ouyang, Hirofumi Inaguma, Paden Tomasello
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We introduce the Efficient Monotonic Multihead Attention (EMMA), a
state-of-the-art simultaneous translation model with numerically-stable and
unbiased monotonic alignment estimation. In addition, we present improved
training and inference strategies, including simultaneous fine-tuning from an
offline translation model and reduction of monotonic alignment variance. The
experimental results demonstrate that the proposed model attains
state-of-the-art performance in simultaneous speech-to-text translation on the
Spanish and English translation task.
|
[
-0.1866947562,
-0.7778805494,
0.1773455292,
0.5105002522,
-0.3511500955,
-0.0130723016,
-0.4604041874,
-0.4401088655,
0.3914681077,
0.2945495248,
-1.0496020317,
-0.2864102721,
-0.6668019295,
0.1882572323,
-0.4646386504,
0.9447402954,
0.1758669019,
0.2140577883,
-0.0752660856,
-0.4499961138,
-0.4782329202,
-0.0603101067,
-0.902771771,
0.0511768088,
0.7363707423,
0.5140479207,
0.8561580777,
1.0433647633,
0.9640846848,
0.3333980143,
-0.2218276858,
0.1700639576,
-0.6774939299,
-0.043725431,
-0.2057452947,
-0.128067255,
-0.8814675808,
-0.261287421,
0.9522458315,
0.7680727243,
-0.1299288273,
0.5231546164,
0.2597977817,
0.5507889986,
-0.4429242909,
-0.1679864079,
-0.6281862259,
0.0234670769,
-0.2465443164,
-0.2744158804,
-0.6155816317,
0.0012153118,
0.3678524196,
-0.8847161531,
0.0462738313,
0.1433447003,
0.6944100857,
0.8480995893,
-0.4681291282,
-0.0718481764,
-0.5792363882,
1.4251343012,
-0.2898615897,
0.7713828087,
-0.0445813537,
0.149528414,
0.0940886587,
-0.4610168636,
-0.4202350974,
0.1596620083,
0.0184339248,
0.4494692683,
-0.1033746898,
0.1414620876,
-0.1018007994,
0.5695135593,
-0.4429545999,
-0.0378508531,
-0.0681027994,
0.0573179126,
0.5638466477,
-0.0411522053,
0.2555088103,
-0.0017471979,
-0.7186372876,
-0.1055957526,
-0.1475228965,
0.0214472115,
0.0357099511,
0.6819754243,
-0.2639622688,
0.4246844947,
0.0633330867,
0.8464937806,
0.1828339398,
-0.4618662298,
0.1976415068,
-0.601385653,
-0.4119370878,
0.0837236196,
0.6969058514,
0.4479501545,
0.2010680735,
-0.2897283435,
0.1173197404,
0.1703435183,
0.3995313644,
-0.3001810312,
0.5075698495,
0.6897292733,
-0.3293065131,
-0.1502243727,
-0.3243240118,
-0.9931973219,
0.1459107548,
-0.5402171016,
0.4214241803,
-0.295461446,
-0.1460090876,
0.2901059389,
0.0356326178,
0.0291898791,
0.4853272438,
-0.840066433,
0.0529836714,
0.4048846364,
0.9019314647,
-0.3981439173,
-0.7112826109,
-0.6688283682,
0.1949506402,
-0.2440456301,
0.5427105427,
0.1232773215,
0.2812016904,
-0.1553165615,
-0.1149786711,
-0.3887707889,
-0.1354634613,
0.6797545552,
-0.1865502745,
0.0616114922,
-0.0031364372,
-0.1622127146,
-0.2258673757,
0.1024440378,
-0.5160647631,
1.1083955765,
0.2834358513,
-0.8909131289,
0.0159015823,
-0.8233872652,
-0.5967200398,
-0.1563656032,
0.394949913,
-0.6002230048,
0.1238178164,
0.2527468204,
0.2790816426,
-0.4878890514,
0.1785779148,
-0.2215288579,
0.0642762259,
-0.1451888531,
-0.17019324,
0.9388045669,
0.2777069807,
-0.237633571,
0.4263654053,
-0.8447375894,
-0.1260311902,
0.140275076,
-0.1832670122,
-0.2502540946,
0.0084915673,
0.2294664234,
0.2816358805,
0.4254077077,
-0.5398708582,
-0.1202255711,
-0.2638553977,
0.3339819312,
0.4105194509,
-0.2591637373,
0.4648899436,
-0.3903095722,
0.4119639695,
-0.0707491934,
0.1936602741,
-0.4886511862,
-0.4441209435,
-0.6578107476,
-0.7971010208,
0.335085243,
0.7163817286,
-0.2821770608,
0.2935317159,
-0.2661815882,
-0.3616440296,
-1.3072547913,
0.1952556521,
0.8099556565,
0.7499156594,
0.7774771452,
-0.1604102701,
-0.3961542249,
-0.8011302948,
-0.3743056953,
0.117894128,
0.1070319936,
-0.090875119,
0.1307275891,
-0.0117493104,
0.6210557818,
-0.166354239,
-0.5514627695,
-0.1855713129,
0.316773206,
0.0648540258,
0.6690115929,
0.5082120299,
-0.7526170015,
-0.7472220659,
0.3974280059,
-0.745285511,
0.0251447447,
-0.4199890196,
-0.5464227796,
-0.1951334029,
0.1533737481,
-0.5283865333,
0.3392751515,
0.6966947913,
-0.0665217489,
-0.1342630833,
-0.1128179356,
0.3026219904,
-1.2919191122,
0.1266717464,
0.1305517554,
-0.8138331771,
-0.9601777196,
0.5293518901,
0.4745910466,
0.1334550381,
-0.8390117288,
0.4314455688,
-0.7254089713,
0.0806453601,
-0.1910824776,
0.3362729847,
-0.1189431474,
0.7270548344,
0.1442490667,
0.7677796483,
0.7614762187,
-0.6160632968,
0.2247448415,
0.7664607167,
-0.0616876818,
0.8916425705,
-0.5493109226,
0.3916022182,
-0.5101007819,
-0.3069754243,
-1.2277044058,
-0.2625450194,
-0.1520163566,
-0.5593720078,
0.5807211995,
0.0463519841,
-0.0693304166,
-0.4458469748,
-0.4655882716,
0.3606722057,
0.1069122106,
-0.5041311383,
0.5686018467,
0.7154321074,
-0.4152170718,
-0.9082137346,
-0.8293375373,
-0.1643866152,
-0.3101433516,
-0.7896561027,
0.4420617819,
-0.070694305,
-0.1787699312,
-0.3576821685,
-0.1768769473,
0.0188708417,
0.0024438549,
-0.2893824279,
0.2591871023,
-0.5524674654,
-0.0866748095,
0.3458842933,
-0.0880665481,
-0.3468758464,
-0.4403871298,
0.2513366938,
0.1964690685,
-0.031875141,
-0.812535882,
0.7103008628,
1.0575578213,
-0.4823392034,
0.8870677352,
0.1719319522,
-0.5060121417,
0.0697889179,
-0.4692034423,
-0.1032779291,
-0.3793038726,
0.5075006485,
-0.4063190222,
-0.5512538552,
0.505574584,
0.1581017226,
0.3196404278,
0.4265024662,
0.720367074,
-0.1349083036,
1.1203480959,
0.6026360393,
0.0107168872,
0.3618111908,
0.1128457114,
0.0143314535,
-0.887219131,
0.2152048796,
-0.6105172634,
-0.4641654491,
-0.2752519846,
-0.3047644794,
0.3475264609,
0.0397989787,
0.1778088063,
0.7057155967,
-0.6247001886,
0.3840897679,
0.7416772246,
0.1338676214,
0.3556860983,
-0.2713842094,
-0.0987408012,
-0.1664736271,
-0.6592161655,
-0.2905568182,
1.2416626215,
0.3742283881,
0.5163097382,
0.250898838,
0.1882655174,
-0.0154349636,
0.2961849868,
-0.7021884322,
0.138975352,
-0.2184123844,
-0.9736604691,
-0.7302959561,
-0.4274998307,
-0.9119182825,
0.5576182008,
-0.3386327326,
-0.6639540195,
0.0756294355,
0.4707979858,
-0.768601954,
-0.0277932975,
-0.8742162585,
1.4389725924,
-0.1974057555,
-0.7147581577,
-0.2460527122,
-0.878466785,
0.2813028097,
-0.6258234382,
0.4483556747,
-0.1238853857,
0.0578837618,
0.4633693397,
0.0175582431,
0.295950532,
-0.0211867336,
-0.0137794735,
0.0710275173,
-0.3803460002,
0.4968883395,
0.105773069,
0.0942188948,
0.0968000516,
0.0294403862,
-0.6453939676,
-0.1609169245,
0.374091208,
-0.6355518103,
-0.3861547709,
-0.2473095059,
-1.091973424,
-0.0813848302,
0.4993173182,
0.2486991882,
0.1866272241,
-0.3404396772,
0.2411942035,
0.6401650906,
0.0378778391,
0.5419338346,
0.5683772564,
-0.2566282451,
-0.4203821123,
0.4278919399,
0.2051528394,
0.4946132898,
0.7891959548,
0.0382906906,
-0.3847356439,
-0.5160203576,
-0.7437572479,
0.4991070032,
-0.4354104698,
-0.1324696392,
-0.9410558343,
0.2294865847,
-0.5876405835,
-0.2553054988,
-0.9608493447,
-0.5492727757,
0.0656918287,
0.1884189993,
0.0854272842,
0.3073310256,
0.0036559175,
0.680873692,
-0.6817038655,
0.625320971,
0.1737890095,
-0.1111378744,
-0.3385404348,
-0.7490714192,
-0.4801567495,
-0.0268247109,
-0.383805722,
-1.035084486,
0.3987997174,
0.1666985601,
0.3232118189,
0.4953500628,
0.0159230288,
0.9761571288,
-0.6115438342,
0.1502671838,
0.3285245597,
-1.1227599382,
0.4276293516,
-0.5880864859,
0.6971439123,
0.938750267,
0.3950110674,
-0.472422272,
-0.8142322302,
0.0142575614,
-0.7173520923,
1.0351331234,
0.2664104104,
0.0473457947,
0.0807982683,
-0.0768155381,
0.0047457698,
0.4110582173,
-0.6153972745,
-0.4392865896,
0.0804972798,
-0.4736553133,
-0.1205537543,
0.0955186263,
-0.0210723598,
-0.5737414956,
0.8812422156,
-0.1580842137,
0.3064614236,
0.2503559291,
-0.3411753774,
-0.5774198771,
0.0149328709,
0.9070137739,
0.5378419161,
-0.4670131207,
0.0489317104,
0.3595761359,
-0.4779451489,
0.1666454822,
0.2093952149,
-0.2238044739,
0.2267621011,
0.1410580277,
0.7818114161,
0.5900354981,
-0.3350934684,
0.3581983447,
-0.0297359303,
-0.0193099696,
-0.2043559402,
-0.5786185861,
0.3690507114,
-0.1141845584,
0.1453318447,
0.4342755973,
-0.0328563973,
-0.4334007502,
0.2210053504,
0.5513085127,
-0.3617043793,
-0.1985325217,
1.2287489176,
0.3031447232,
-0.4771362245,
0.1203598306,
-0.0236068163,
-0.1335782111,
0.3185079396,
0.4129279852,
0.7676979899,
-0.9448313713,
-0.0769036263,
0.5938473344,
0.5576898456,
-0.1882832795,
0.4042131603,
0.0552199073,
-0.6788398623,
-0.6200073361,
-0.4294682741,
-0.5269958377,
-0.112165004,
-1.100717783,
0.6095666289,
0.0105012944,
-0.3684878349,
0.5334947109,
-0.5202146173,
-0.4547121823,
0.2827628255,
-0.0953361765,
0.7391093373,
-0.5363577604,
0.9782778621,
0.6644672751,
-0.3281860352,
-0.3385619521,
-0.2236107141,
0.298284322,
-0.7191295624,
-0.2445960641,
0.154345721,
-0.3869894147,
0.5045523643,
0.0106580313,
-1.288659215,
0.8946130276,
0.7922446728,
-0.8749490976,
-0.1672529578,
0.0709957033,
0.2367523164,
-0.2800457478,
0.317143321,
0.5042265654,
0.4875486791,
-0.1753987521,
-1.1710284948,
-0.5150922537,
-0.176569581,
-0.2182822824,
0.4364237189,
-1.1033366919,
0.8586161733,
-0.0263885986,
-0.3183695078,
-0.1479165703,
0.9184928536,
-0.288261205,
0.2757381499,
0.3351562023,
0.7527244687,
0.879978478,
-0.0186588783,
1.0389840603,
-0.8000743985,
0.6590895057,
1.3453325033,
-0.2227090001,
0.905262053,
0.8687824011,
-0.0507967398,
-0.2306951433,
0.3797769248,
0.4201142192,
0.6913793087,
-0.2707452476,
-0.138443172,
-0.0963100716,
-0.0396300852,
-0.1746331304,
0.4504966438,
-0.1180158854,
-0.3380706608,
-0.0875453353,
0.2875826061,
0.2610007226,
0.2325498015,
-0.435020268,
0.7947018147,
-0.070197545,
-1.2420423031,
0.8123916984,
0.2324032187,
0.6081833243,
-0.5609894991,
0.5070441365,
-0.1893045604,
0.6957096457,
0.0421881303,
-0.241316542,
0.5051459074,
0.0844037011,
-0.3268436491,
-0.5339183807,
0.0633421689,
-0.7891091704,
-0.5623555183,
0.6874476075,
0.3504434526,
0.0636786297,
-0.1797428429,
-0.6573542953,
0.0248584151,
0.0727919638,
-0.3209258616,
0.1334412843,
0.3470667899,
0.22984083,
0.2956338823,
0.3471576571,
-0.1709982455,
0.6058833599,
-0.1336731315,
0.36130476,
-0.431979239,
-0.5608380437,
-0.9196666479,
0.8435949087,
-0.0924786031,
-0.5743016005,
0.8379596472,
0.6408196688,
0.7333677411,
-0.1286543906,
0.5036846995,
0.4736130536,
1.0012003183,
-0.3586194217,
0.4307477474,
-0.7336596251,
-0.3799287975,
-0.4467456639,
-1.0632141829,
-0.5515449047,
0.816387713,
0.2496087402,
-0.3198195398,
1.3134254217,
0.6183555722,
-0.2952313125,
0.1428228021,
0.47349751,
-0.0537820943,
-0.5233684182,
0.6650419235,
0.4140520394,
-0.4852904975,
0.3713065386,
-0.1494262069,
-0.6555669904,
0.0650461838,
-0.842201829,
-0.7844733,
-0.3183183968,
-0.6422895193,
-0.2101865262,
0.0633258224,
1.2255897522,
0.9444462061,
-1.0968574286,
-0.4402367473,
0.0420900732,
-0.0404298641,
-0.6668739915,
-0.0667404458,
0.1794274747,
-0.6752156615,
-1.2373148203,
0.611109376,
0.7122756243,
-0.0899778455,
-0.1314667761,
-0.0451391637,
-0.7118915319,
0.5715470314,
0.4849753082,
0.1653224528,
-0.6691673398,
-0.0141324503,
0.292414546,
-0.3205983639,
0.614841342,
0.378465265,
0.1016718224,
0.6299127936,
0.227786839,
0.9049033523,
0.5176951885,
0.264860183,
0.477604419,
-0.8511912227,
0.4962608516,
-0.0550302006,
0.2898769975,
0.3538943231,
-0.4322195947,
0.5384925008,
0.0772612616,
-0.4840599895,
-0.9730046988,
-0.0297025498,
-1.2013349533,
0.1014197916,
0.7562575936,
-0.2743085325,
-0.508174479,
-0.0989504978,
-0.214448303,
0.5891986489,
-0.3096596599,
0.6041923761,
0.982029736,
0.2606574893,
-0.3218057454,
-0.7868763804,
0.3239913583,
0.8829895854,
-0.7099129558,
0.1361317188,
0.018619325,
-0.2770644128,
0.5171349645,
0.677421093,
-0.0889337733,
0.4001287818,
-0.0876572952,
0.2622211576,
0.4002965093,
-0.5741583705,
-0.3584413826,
0.2164965421,
-0.0246639196,
-0.6717182398
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04511v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04511v3
|
An LLM Compiler for Parallel Function Calling
| 2023-12-07T18:32:04 | 2024-06-05T03:53:10 |
Sehoon Kim, Suhong Moon, Ryan Tabrizi, Nicholas Lee, Michael W. Mahoney, Kurt Keutzer, Amir Gholami
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The reasoning capabilities of the recent LLMs enable them to execute external
function calls to overcome their inherent limitations, such as knowledge
cutoffs, poor arithmetic skills, or lack of access to private data. This
development has allowed LLMs to select and coordinate multiple functions based
on the context to tackle more complex problems. However, current methods for
function calling often require sequential reasoning and acting for each
function which can result in high latency, cost, and sometimes inaccurate
behavior. To address this, we introduce LLMCompiler, which executes functions
in parallel to efficiently orchestrate multiple function calls. Drawing
inspiration from the principles of classical compilers, LLMCompiler enables
parallel function calling with three components: (i) a Function Calling
Planner, formulating execution plans for function calling; (ii) a Task Fetching
Unit, dispatching function calling tasks; and (iii) an Executor, executing
these tasks in parallel. LLMCompiler automatically generates an optimized
orchestration for the function calls and can be used with both open-source and
closed-source models. We have benchmarked LLMCompiler on a range of tasks with
different patterns of function calling. We observe consistent latency speedup
of up to 3.7x, cost savings of up to 6.7x, and accuracy improvement of up to
~9% compared to ReAct. Our code is available at
https://github.com/SqueezeAILab/LLMCompiler.
|
[
-0.2095104158,
-0.4633620083,
0.7162047029,
0.5561537743,
-0.1823008358,
0.1597237587,
-0.0892316699,
-0.3687018156,
0.0601148419,
0.6782334447,
-0.5273537636,
-0.3070400059,
-0.3701333106,
0.112671189,
-0.2046214789,
0.5264809132,
-0.2849188149,
0.177929908,
-0.7100607753,
0.0013415579,
-0.2118830085,
-0.3057510555,
-0.6108525395,
-0.4059725404,
0.3621607423,
0.4848283231,
0.5266281366,
0.8434935212,
0.6198034883,
0.5199253559,
0.1329137981,
0.1975015402,
-0.4873116016,
0.2834237516,
0.1451406777,
-0.840485096,
-0.343521446,
-0.2922786176,
0.3829884529,
0.214359358,
-0.1133308858,
0.3520302773,
-0.1019946709,
0.8017151952,
-0.7526381016,
0.5369651914,
-0.2947214246,
0.1521620005,
-0.4406558275,
-0.2865429521,
-0.0973844752,
-0.817959249,
-0.4820666611,
-0.5454308987,
-0.1138722897,
0.0327599347,
0.0488328561,
0.7764238715,
0.014417571,
-0.1517421603,
-0.7265430689,
0.6953827143,
-0.3056794405,
0.2409799844,
0.1216378063,
0.6915983558,
-0.0803366676,
-1.2150410414,
-0.3735939562,
-0.2371116877,
0.151169613,
0.1246358678,
0.0757901371,
0.1177801266,
0.4825310409,
0.504542172,
-0.4174580276,
0.1817198396,
-0.3111222088,
-0.0186729543,
0.4759672284,
0.4926630855,
0.1579179168,
0.3267570734,
-0.3696312606,
0.1056467369,
-0.6188754439,
0.2299112231,
0.6143282056,
-0.0173204262,
-0.2065987885,
0.6065016389,
-0.3338551521,
0.7967666388,
-0.1208209991,
-0.3228304982,
0.0964600816,
-0.0502353013,
-0.1047535762,
0.1489044279,
0.5406869054,
0.410341382,
0.5300189257,
0.0282777473,
-0.2043911666,
0.2020871639,
0.4486581385,
-0.9386966825,
-0.2038083076,
0.5007944703,
-0.1833972782,
-0.2882553637,
0.0088453367,
-0.7399877906,
-0.2621281445,
-0.5631516576,
0.1252329946,
-0.2400901914,
0.3966137767,
-0.1230578721,
0.0514125116,
-0.0541140176,
0.3844092786,
-0.6324617267,
0.6004317999,
0.865114212,
0.6183462143,
-0.2910043597,
-0.3785889149,
-1.2199419737,
0.2506217957,
-0.029250199,
0.9206849933,
-0.4909579158,
-0.4669975638,
-0.2390467227,
-0.1572113782,
-0.1525146812,
-0.6917791963,
0.6613508463,
-0.4734151959,
-0.5459753275,
-0.1009996235,
-0.5293792486,
0.0829262882,
-0.095367752,
-0.642911911,
1.0019935369,
-0.0183564853,
-0.5903607607,
0.0247291028,
-0.3675785065,
-0.5894964933,
0.2050967216,
-0.6234968901,
-0.3773718774,
0.2195575386,
0.3289360106,
0.3044346571,
-0.6011740565,
-0.001645416,
-0.2587539554,
-0.6869833469,
0.1279749423,
0.0095074782,
0.5772675872,
0.1971507668,
-0.2984721959,
0.4942117929,
-0.6311421394,
0.053248208,
-0.1200509369,
-0.4166967571,
0.2197555304,
0.1468406916,
-0.299046278,
0.1373665482,
0.3574200869,
-0.4522323608,
0.0633908063,
-0.1779513955,
0.2212753743,
0.8052575588,
-0.3774653673,
0.1968963444,
-0.7885103822,
0.6984702945,
-0.1378275603,
0.3699791729,
-0.1677470207,
-0.6790204644,
-0.8488556147,
-0.6095778942,
-0.1258025616,
0.841121912,
-0.6458489299,
0.2390814126,
-0.1945895404,
-0.4101040065,
-0.4740989804,
0.2451871485,
0.41281268,
0.4638578594,
0.3006775379,
0.0606105663,
-0.5428480506,
-0.903113246,
-0.2851803899,
-0.1871077567,
0.1274077743,
0.2385327816,
0.2038629204,
0.1063487828,
0.6376713514,
-0.486876756,
-0.2262468934,
-0.0070775733,
-0.1236944571,
0.3618849218,
0.2265869081,
0.1111628339,
-0.6354379654,
-0.5595550537,
0.1379567683,
-0.6321850419,
-0.5994454622,
0.1478382796,
-0.1138459593,
0.1080751568,
0.5671172142,
-0.4375488162,
0.1577041298,
0.6966635585,
0.3364664614,
0.8524330258,
0.0338891596,
0.2120369226,
-0.7839158177,
0.0493016504,
-0.5636287928,
-0.2156393826,
-0.3821426928,
0.2350344658,
0.0665251315,
-0.050666634,
-0.769759953,
0.3982551694,
-0.3701083064,
-0.2958643138,
-0.1646139324,
-0.1404514611,
-0.4093498588,
0.1797547638,
-0.3956955373,
1.0814493895,
0.6703181267,
-0.5202684999,
0.722080946,
0.0459254459,
-0.3889566362,
0.3910013437,
-0.5854823589,
0.2270727754,
0.257945627,
0.078139782,
-0.8829633594,
-0.3016342521,
0.0319028795,
0.1474399269,
0.0556539036,
-0.396340102,
-0.8916476965,
-0.5646785498,
-0.3614424765,
0.2549458444,
0.4605534375,
-0.6941800714,
0.7353791595,
0.2715032995,
-0.2669792771,
-0.4516150653,
-0.7772497535,
-0.4951194227,
0.067332603,
-0.7981735468,
0.3146712482,
-0.2226348072,
-0.4053784013,
-0.1017682031,
-0.3816554248,
0.0743416324,
-0.2520393729,
0.7193184495,
0.1226254925,
0.0027743774,
-0.2387095094,
0.19272165,
-0.3571147323,
0.0287881084,
-0.3874084055,
0.5506750941,
-0.1927332282,
-0.8427670598,
-0.3734360337,
0.3227146566,
0.9077803493,
-0.1919842213,
0.2396583557,
0.3887536228,
0.0790044442,
-0.1296664178,
-0.9415317774,
0.0662869588,
-0.5371516943,
-0.1196703389,
-0.6044008136,
-1.2347580194,
0.6357011199,
-0.360226512,
0.0116003659,
-0.0932669491,
0.9216722846,
0.2710412443,
0.5723173022,
0.2234743834,
0.0403459407,
0.3231494129,
-0.0143350381,
-0.0603855699,
-0.6020653844,
-0.1898763925,
-0.4257114232,
-0.3556730151,
-0.6304623485,
-1.0874655247,
0.6627264619,
0.1579232812,
-0.2040694505,
0.2402667701,
-0.4918049574,
0.7986148,
0.5633021593,
-0.0783386603,
0.5351718068,
0.089972958,
-0.4682996273,
-0.0068431171,
-0.5270624757,
-0.4223986268,
0.7025701404,
-0.0209102146,
0.7812737823,
0.025812082,
1.0715450048,
-0.2083556801,
0.5412899256,
-0.7778708339,
0.8412357569,
-0.1850459576,
-0.1638881862,
0.0580396764,
-0.4342214763,
-0.4726672471,
0.4436938465,
0.3806227446,
-0.9427908659,
0.0094576487,
0.0540074334,
-0.3286498487,
0.3146454096,
-0.510422051,
0.5419035554,
-0.2227804214,
-0.6780143976,
-0.3653991818,
-0.6135709286,
0.564614594,
-0.2442348748,
0.1659179777,
-0.323204577,
-0.1781197488,
0.252083391,
-0.6888314486,
0.6752628088,
0.1382150501,
0.0112075675,
0.3352794647,
0.1785908192,
0.9347885847,
0.0342913903,
-0.370213896,
0.002387281,
-0.1805080026,
0.0062500606,
-0.5315195322,
1.0966471434,
-0.4478439987,
-0.6428471804,
-0.0615852885,
-0.6647612453,
-0.06837897,
0.0578809455,
0.022460917,
0.2691817284,
0.0129373483,
-0.1533836722,
0.1142327785,
-0.0121774701,
0.6350303292,
0.3576154709,
-0.3800576627,
-0.5759228468,
0.8425962925,
-0.1084517986,
0.2547208965,
0.5494856834,
0.07834398,
-0.3111785352,
-0.2549344599,
-0.2926408648,
0.20878461,
-0.5755416751,
-0.3583495319,
-0.728156805,
-0.0439570174,
0.1081339642,
-0.4104530811,
-0.4309006333,
-0.7605845332,
-0.0996820033,
0.1604776382,
0.2902180552,
0.4412641525,
-0.0742639005,
0.2965420485,
-0.7468852997,
0.405009836,
0.4202269614,
0.2929330766,
-0.2587606907,
0.1175450161,
-0.1222693622,
-0.6540427804,
-0.6198408008,
-0.6384070516,
0.2098279744,
-0.0731397197,
0.7321349978,
0.1992947012,
0.0923273787,
0.7994393706,
-0.806378603,
0.3736980855,
0.1992414445,
-0.9660729766,
0.5898857713,
-0.1140968204,
0.3149436414,
0.5514939427,
0.2973139286,
0.1195641905,
-0.6849508286,
-0.2744101882,
-0.7111899257,
0.7393108606,
0.3505645692,
-0.2755801976,
-0.1038868576,
-0.0442618243,
-0.0766489804,
0.3048279583,
-0.0035628676,
-0.3627735078,
0.2086748332,
0.0965141654,
-0.163096264,
-0.211883828,
-0.4930746257,
-0.2875244021,
0.0586783364,
-0.2869559526,
0.5013438463,
0.1491758078,
0.0175808072,
-0.2460882515,
0.2747840285,
0.7617021203,
0.8439287543,
0.0058607706,
0.1522415429,
0.2811081707,
-0.3942871094,
0.1979969442,
0.619225204,
0.1869346797,
-0.212321803,
0.211806193,
0.4901696742,
0.4444107711,
-0.6339660287,
0.3525677025,
0.1918740273,
-0.0101105049,
-0.2001123279,
0.1120262519,
0.4167780876,
0.6062047482,
0.116694726,
0.1465243548,
0.2106493413,
-0.0871686116,
0.4642037153,
-0.020965863,
-0.1396885365,
-0.0437020883,
0.9126777053,
0.2650930882,
-0.3365878463,
0.4420556128,
-0.027418999,
-0.4430638552,
0.7044516206,
0.4087536633,
1.0202364922,
-0.3433895111,
-0.126157999,
0.0771448761,
0.2306456715,
-0.0629702732,
0.7395785451,
-0.2827448845,
-0.3121992052,
-0.9464620352,
-1.0619534254,
-0.6534816027,
-0.3990373909,
-0.4137508571,
0.2211298347,
-0.5743554831,
-0.092378296,
-0.1785034239,
-0.2490357459,
-0.3806208968,
-0.3850777447,
0.0749918446,
0.9668352008,
-0.2254467756,
0.8407581449,
0.8137755394,
-0.095522061,
-0.4937048256,
-0.028681973,
0.5798048377,
-0.7642509341,
0.9782621861,
0.3547034264,
-0.4886715114,
0.2353147715,
-0.0201853942,
-0.4890663624,
1.223459959,
0.6926519871,
-0.890006721,
0.474868089,
0.2472116798,
0.3339811862,
-0.52590698,
0.292894572,
0.3236513436,
0.6002693772,
0.3607205153,
-1.0877726078,
0.2032494843,
-0.0297971461,
0.2192884535,
0.3155179918,
-0.782797873,
0.7907422185,
-0.5294274688,
0.0119609861,
0.2877625525,
0.5012910366,
0.7625187039,
0.1485156715,
0.3980654478,
0.6341803074,
0.6285816431,
-0.1421698928,
1.3734470606,
-0.7554785609,
0.1280410439,
1.1679834127,
-0.4419703782,
0.694827199,
0.6469857693,
-0.3714966178,
0.1770017892,
0.2796182334,
0.0540670305,
0.363309741,
0.6228057146,
-0.688733995,
-0.2065787017,
0.0206503253,
-0.028435912,
0.1508536041,
0.2518830001,
-0.1760355383,
-0.2448303401,
-0.4759724438,
-0.2034330517,
-0.2442732006,
-0.2402926534,
0.3582180738,
0.3671772182,
-0.5978851318,
0.3732027113,
-0.2964579761,
0.2847641408,
-0.454056263,
-0.0409690402,
-0.2026987672,
0.5801501274,
-0.2859144211,
-0.6527808309,
0.5725017786,
-0.203759864,
0.0575085394,
-0.1189788505,
0.6612640023,
-0.0441701859,
-0.3464825749,
0.5818907619,
0.4386680722,
0.2804175615,
-0.1889451146,
-0.6195773482,
0.7716334462,
-0.1883206964,
0.0192658473,
0.1411323845,
0.2168132961,
-0.0905630141,
1.0681165457,
0.8596925139,
0.0219631381,
0.4047598541,
0.3818036318,
1.0530633926,
-0.3759129643,
-0.4332176745,
-0.831394434,
0.5764554143,
-0.0105957668,
-0.0794058666,
0.7025506496,
0.9997826219,
0.7379741669,
-0.3283078969,
0.4363791645,
0.1369610578,
0.0544831045,
-0.6741903424,
0.291937381,
-0.3520767987,
0.4498610795,
-0.1237061992,
-0.9444459081,
-0.4711941183,
0.3555986285,
-0.4092888236,
-0.0953843445,
0.7854170799,
1.0285813808,
-0.2398287207,
0.1721635461,
0.5121892691,
0.0298666842,
0.0637986884,
0.5510517359,
1.2060080767,
-0.0935660824,
0.6255000234,
-0.4552498758,
-0.2474276423,
-0.3871249557,
-0.6441742182,
-0.8395609856,
-0.0786588266,
-0.334767133,
0.042178262,
0.3575820327,
0.6462797523,
0.6989194155,
-0.6657534242,
-0.8174802661,
-0.2941732407,
0.1632021219,
-0.3488629162,
-0.2495935857,
-0.135091424,
-0.6608439684,
-0.8159627914,
0.6749974489,
0.6700632572,
-0.2596271932,
0.0970439464,
-0.1129208058,
0.1439484209,
-0.1546836793,
0.6991823912,
0.2679522932,
-0.8512800932,
0.1149154976,
-0.4750467539,
-0.0555550791,
0.1047334075,
1.1953493357,
-0.4715793431,
0.4671184719,
0.5767371058,
0.7029241323,
0.9052755833,
0.0381596163,
0.4772159159,
-0.6584583521,
0.0222348012,
0.0608736835,
0.2229661644,
0.148237139,
-0.4575186074,
0.7215262651,
0.2949723005,
-0.86848557,
-0.4975122511,
0.3511104286,
-1.1953234673,
0.1094026119,
0.8672323823,
-0.1490450501,
-0.2154835016,
-0.1017747745,
-0.0574216731,
0.0701740757,
-0.4991686344,
0.201105237,
0.3002043962,
-0.8982759118,
-0.4323803782,
-0.8839137554,
0.3724731803,
0.1511929184,
-0.895401001,
0.0565327704,
0.503955543,
0.2555290759,
0.2213902771,
0.7105740309,
-0.3955233097,
0.0913878307,
0.0612593554,
0.1002099589,
-0.3488951623,
-0.3022985458,
-0.2223859876,
0.2114894986,
-0.1798613369,
-0.412492007
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04510v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04510v1
|
A Block Metropolis-Hastings Sampler for Controllable Energy-based Text Generation
| 2023-12-07T18:30:15 | 2023-12-07T18:30:15 |
Jarad Forristal, Niloofar Mireshghallah, Greg Durrett, Taylor Berg-Kirkpatrick
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Recent work has shown that energy-based language modeling is an effective
framework for controllable text generation because it enables flexible
integration of arbitrary discriminators. However, because energy-based LMs are
globally normalized, approximate techniques like Metropolis-Hastings (MH) are
required for inference. Past work has largely explored simple proposal
distributions that modify a single token at a time, like in Gibbs sampling. In
this paper, we develop a novel MH sampler that, in contrast, proposes re-writes
of the entire sequence in each step via iterative prompting of a large language
model. Our new sampler (a) allows for more efficient and accurate sampling from
a target distribution and (b) allows generation length to be determined through
the sampling procedure rather than fixed in advance, as past work has required.
We perform experiments on two controlled generation tasks, showing both
downstream performance gains and more accurate target distribution sampling in
comparison with single-token proposal techniques.
|
[
0.0079958159,
-0.4800291657,
0.4723169804,
0.0931740552,
-0.1627064049,
0.2285757661,
-0.3413153887,
-0.1323222816,
0.5501346588,
0.4865754545,
-0.5044971108,
-0.2894168496,
-0.2240602374,
-0.0824596807,
-0.4091323018,
0.8911874294,
-0.1867610514,
-0.3146838844,
0.2260475457,
0.4066336155,
0.0608802028,
-0.2617734075,
-0.8076819777,
-0.4065381289,
0.8583009243,
0.3428873718,
0.5912184715,
0.6888340116,
0.2403486073,
0.2092697769,
0.1734031886,
0.157727614,
-0.3196454644,
0.0712942928,
-0.2371050268,
-0.3889273405,
-0.1763014942,
-0.0571587719,
0.8948159814,
0.6389107704,
-0.3430199921,
0.1110556796,
-0.0537011772,
0.5944855213,
-1.0192443132,
-0.1296129972,
-1.0613905191,
0.2166555524,
-0.3308587074,
-0.3682122231,
-0.8232528567,
-0.3647885323,
-0.4559760094,
-0.1932915747,
0.6389374733,
0.2831219435,
0.5797145963,
-0.0040451703,
-0.307952553,
-0.3390008807,
-0.7346080542,
1.100071311,
-0.6617766619,
0.0833704695,
0.2547726035,
0.4542426467,
-0.1275489181,
-0.7085835338,
-0.8376718163,
-0.2038282603,
0.0307462141,
0.1138313413,
-0.281406343,
0.2089919001,
0.1018913314,
0.0148308324,
-0.1772131622,
0.2058048844,
-0.3948031068,
-0.2696803808,
0.8172268867,
0.2779360712,
-0.0928148851,
-0.695956111,
-0.2397283167,
-0.390665859,
-0.6728727221,
0.0683319867,
0.5500263572,
0.5786703825,
-0.1479993463,
0.6805362105,
-0.0692887902,
0.794344604,
0.1660238653,
0.0250450633,
0.0170363691,
0.0187435132,
-0.2686759531,
0.0493955165,
1.0367581844,
0.5263917446,
0.2243539989,
0.1358528733,
-0.2946637273,
-0.2446399927,
0.3713749945,
-0.9586261511,
-0.5498737097,
0.4404689074,
-0.4835160077,
-0.3942891657,
0.0532481186,
-0.8677060604,
-0.2208874375,
-0.099299483,
0.1244883984,
-0.2445181757,
-0.24089849,
-0.0036116603,
-0.2288178802,
-0.1282327175,
-0.0752128735,
-1.1346223354,
0.2439094037,
0.1363462955,
0.8047850728,
-0.3903508484,
0.0809589028,
-0.5042815804,
0.3369157314,
-0.4627763629,
0.5992675424,
-0.7200365663,
-0.443123281,
0.1341812164,
-0.2437831908,
-0.0726827234,
-0.3223181367,
-0.0266265739,
-0.4777250588,
-0.1561259478,
-0.165612042,
-0.4983185828,
0.373767674,
-0.1849591285,
-0.8558471799,
0.7957330346,
-0.0131515395,
-0.8886609077,
0.4440241456,
-0.609075129,
-0.3699019849,
-0.1169322655,
-0.315066278,
-0.5632186532,
0.2000282556,
-0.028335318,
0.4874532521,
0.0730299652,
0.2378170043,
0.1379974931,
-0.0275065321,
0.2340813875,
-0.762853682,
0.377713263,
0.6595238447,
-0.3007385433,
0.2429370135,
-1.1707539558,
0.239395231,
0.0871286765,
-0.5502650142,
0.0009119989,
0.2560842931,
0.5002621412,
-0.108109735,
0.2382600754,
-0.945694685,
0.1517444402,
0.071039483,
0.2477551997,
0.7808703184,
0.1720380634,
0.2715015113,
-0.7406451106,
0.6584008932,
-0.2841494083,
-0.382172823,
-0.309112519,
-0.0728209391,
-0.4736681581,
-0.5981664658,
0.211695686,
0.3584321141,
-0.9090898633,
0.5779802799,
-0.1372987777,
-0.797878027,
-0.4807432592,
-0.1716118455,
0.3639663458,
0.232631579,
0.3703835011,
0.1691777706,
-0.398734659,
-0.7627179623,
-0.4649102688,
0.2351684421,
-0.3748526573,
0.3068449497,
0.3002809584,
0.2342563421,
1.2505069971,
-0.7239854932,
0.4964770079,
-0.4238193333,
0.2701336145,
0.1626130044,
0.760320425,
0.3236732781,
-0.6838905811,
-0.4983451366,
-0.2931182683,
-0.2516919076,
-0.3689472377,
-0.4914513826,
-0.1592493951,
-0.0212164912,
0.5011745095,
-0.297008276,
0.407525301,
0.5788039565,
-0.1224536151,
0.7323114872,
-0.4887435436,
0.1794854254,
-1.3940480947,
0.273970902,
-0.0735969692,
-0.2887814939,
-0.5878789425,
0.0473951995,
0.2538213134,
-0.2562296391,
-0.5377390385,
0.2803272903,
-0.5436066389,
0.2340321988,
-0.6320677996,
0.0196208283,
-0.0492480062,
0.3169956803,
0.1207228079,
0.6541039348,
0.1368087977,
-0.9332409501,
0.2984021008,
-0.0541274399,
-0.567892909,
0.3364143968,
-0.5553486943,
0.282840699,
-0.4222523272,
0.4726570547,
-1.1046936512,
-0.4000596702,
-0.1051250696,
-0.2200175226,
0.4868783057,
0.4052232802,
-0.5122740865,
-0.514716804,
-0.2705839276,
0.338367939,
0.5808799267,
-0.5930785537,
0.2800156474,
0.1256954968,
-0.1849500835,
-0.310185194,
-0.9347984791,
-0.1188974902,
-0.0340722613,
-0.1765356809,
0.3436762989,
-0.3414787352,
-0.3797642589,
-0.3162330389,
-0.0553395785,
0.0674955919,
-0.1674147248,
0.0937901288,
-0.1035334542,
0.3276987672,
0.2410530895,
0.4468364418,
-0.0951197743,
-0.1198266968,
-0.3501160741,
0.6457913518,
0.7901878953,
-0.5227281451,
-0.5683325529,
0.6315151453,
0.2821740508,
-0.1363163739,
0.6568908691,
-0.0170061942,
-0.46874699,
-0.373660326,
-0.3263883889,
-0.2021843642,
-0.50446558,
0.1705681533,
-0.654417634,
-0.7860120535,
0.1225150153,
0.0618147142,
0.5171145201,
0.3879266679,
0.7234810591,
-0.0494347252,
0.7855761051,
0.6505699754,
-0.0188193489,
0.6454043388,
-0.0988495722,
0.1845338941,
-0.5372465849,
0.0371220671,
-0.7845740914,
-0.4792052507,
-0.5678762794,
-0.4010063112,
0.1587574035,
-0.131617412,
-0.0797119886,
0.3508223891,
-0.5522276759,
0.4069723487,
0.4932273328,
0.1247523427,
0.2100647986,
0.2737462521,
-0.4627120495,
-0.3024980128,
-0.760093987,
-0.4573390186,
0.8999516964,
-0.0626309961,
0.9686823487,
0.0043649101,
0.83667624,
0.3523874879,
0.3578350842,
-0.5143277049,
0.3090726137,
0.0718054697,
-0.6442711353,
-0.135016188,
-0.5976313949,
-1.1514337063,
0.2699089348,
-0.0445212536,
-1.0058376789,
-0.1012538001,
0.4674966335,
-0.3859956264,
0.8560725451,
-0.4618492424,
0.4178053737,
0.3073269725,
-0.3392656147,
-0.2926886976,
-0.2759549618,
0.157716319,
-0.2510939538,
0.4745180309,
-0.1845074445,
0.0441550985,
0.5330857038,
-0.6575727463,
0.7527239919,
-0.3239849806,
-0.5155655742,
0.5551641583,
0.2250070572,
0.6254743338,
-0.5010778308,
-0.4800740778,
-0.4391106665,
-0.3014289141,
-0.62400949,
-0.3472162783,
0.6194152832,
-0.1595204771,
-0.3830345869,
0.0012542661,
-0.9044124484,
0.0881846324,
0.1309423447,
0.8983604908,
0.6456835866,
-0.0495559387,
0.1350782365,
0.1795198023,
-0.2893196344,
0.6944874525,
0.2984473705,
-0.252869904,
-0.4006682932,
0.9097533822,
0.1020104736,
0.7856788039,
0.8271816969,
0.1650533527,
-0.2135058194,
-0.4527802467,
-0.2023515403,
-0.1775527596,
-0.3210319579,
-0.0819871798,
-0.5869729519,
0.0241944976,
-0.3155067861,
-0.6378089786,
-0.3266245425,
-0.3951143324,
0.085357435,
-0.3067218959,
0.4168078601,
0.5423238277,
-0.57632339,
0.6072502136,
-0.7042355537,
0.4084805846,
0.015446269,
0.1347419471,
-0.1071185693,
-0.212544322,
-0.1578265429,
0.2373548597,
-0.319306463,
-0.948969543,
0.3292012513,
0.0514057837,
0.1539318115,
0.4183401465,
0.2240558714,
0.2715545893,
-0.8691862822,
0.9735123515,
0.6334040165,
-0.7333992124,
0.6608567238,
-0.3683090806,
0.519177258,
0.5008560419,
0.3373541832,
-0.4864732623,
-0.579636097,
-0.6127007008,
-0.684948802,
0.2811117768,
0.2935808599,
0.2695506811,
-0.4571647644,
0.2073779255,
0.0845085159,
0.418451637,
-0.4454478621,
-0.2598384619,
0.0595554784,
-0.4433483481,
-0.1189064533,
-0.0552814677,
0.2323330194,
0.0191494152,
0.6163722873,
-0.2498918623,
0.1708282232,
0.2695603967,
0.1772481501,
-0.3366069496,
0.496304065,
0.2604078352,
0.5958319902,
-0.266515404,
0.344312638,
0.026135657,
-0.5891013145,
0.3127151728,
0.0197370276,
-0.5759182572,
0.3424277008,
-0.0525632426,
0.605599761,
0.2817389667,
-0.7507725954,
0.1009342149,
0.1801338792,
-0.2672388256,
-0.0228060167,
0.0785663426,
-0.0316369049,
-0.0087600257,
0.39793697,
0.0490592197,
-0.0242192708,
-0.2685424089,
0.3354190886,
0.3363309205,
-0.50192523,
-0.0800480917,
0.9380170703,
0.1274415553,
-0.3995054662,
0.2753235102,
-0.5043563247,
-0.1062244773,
0.6127375364,
0.8181936741,
0.6538643241,
-0.2110921741,
0.0601464845,
0.6876772046,
0.326151073,
0.2907638252,
0.7051814795,
-0.4434426427,
-0.8048663139,
-0.4729026854,
-0.6694366336,
-0.5748314261,
-0.105777435,
-0.8577598929,
-0.1859891266,
-0.6875162721,
-0.2583783567,
-0.0421825834,
-0.0325083025,
-0.2295871079,
0.2855815291,
-0.0413724519,
1.2542198896,
-0.4847833514,
0.9238905907,
0.2430058718,
-0.0127614867,
-0.7141820192,
0.0530617647,
0.0658554435,
-0.372392416,
0.1633296758,
-0.009906915,
-0.3721713722,
0.2647162974,
-0.9284141064,
-0.5187835097,
1.1039444208,
0.2322624475,
-1.0271812677,
0.1594491303,
-0.0601986051,
-0.0288293324,
-0.1085360274,
-0.003479836,
0.6109848022,
0.3838734031,
0.2322119921,
-0.737113297,
-0.0109892106,
-0.2215777189,
0.1627710462,
0.5747343302,
-0.738899529,
0.8413238525,
-0.4430521429,
-0.2494385242,
0.4269801378,
1.0757812262,
0.8593791723,
0.1565761268,
0.4224857092,
0.2612901628,
1.2632460594,
0.2621098757,
1.2748091221,
-0.4510371983,
0.4276783168,
1.0994298458,
-0.3145398796,
1.04928267,
0.6024589539,
-0.2315633595,
0.4765707552,
0.2639496028,
0.0651713014,
0.5098291039,
1.0314514637,
-0.6063002944,
-0.0170080736,
-0.1969934553,
-0.1769437194,
0.0599880144,
0.230607301,
-0.2440714538,
-0.2548805773,
-0.1285608709,
0.3954493701,
0.4710721374,
-0.4391284585,
0.1740928143,
0.0863013864,
-0.6899077296,
0.4121762514,
0.3121135235,
1.0256900787,
-0.7863079906,
0.1617564261,
0.1316841543,
0.2238941193,
-0.1479693651,
-0.5130556822,
0.2641081512,
0.5504825711,
-0.3141777515,
-0.3878896534,
0.6466500163,
-0.6133274436,
-0.4774764478,
-0.3148860931,
-0.0584176891,
0.3727812767,
0.0557234995,
-0.139430508,
-0.0671262294,
0.177423045,
-0.2333542109,
-0.0488355868,
0.2181653082,
0.3589003086,
0.2906475663,
0.5275210738,
0.2904178202,
0.3607501388,
0.0636905059,
0.3747588098,
-0.7312015295,
-0.5610632896,
-0.7336730957,
0.4917443097,
-0.1542705745,
-0.2503207624,
0.7123500705,
0.7189017534,
0.5298124552,
-0.131868735,
1.2455747128,
-0.2721417546,
0.5510104895,
-0.8600354195,
0.8198658824,
-0.3902132213,
-0.3367472887,
-0.1381727308,
-0.8627142906,
0.0182204545,
0.6135823727,
0.0302347913,
0.073951453,
0.7137101293,
0.7883436084,
0.0186348706,
-0.073866725,
0.2656526566,
0.1411120892,
0.7002744675,
0.7999957204,
0.466535598,
-0.1584837437,
0.3557193577,
-0.202758342,
-0.266415298,
0.1221649349,
-1.1446810961,
-0.6295859814,
-0.4123643935,
-0.2054822892,
-0.3211007118,
-0.296476692,
1.2392814159,
0.6598174572,
-0.8882778883,
-0.3641137183,
-0.2825019062,
-0.2573445737,
-0.1248962507,
-0.2320136726,
0.3365591466,
-0.4302620888,
-0.9991891384,
0.6005650759,
-0.0173937902,
0.0122236591,
-0.2067909986,
0.1404332072,
-0.0682389587,
0.4862955213,
0.3042217493,
0.2892814577,
-0.152812615,
-0.3517003357,
-0.2716010213,
-0.2872959375,
-0.1213272735,
1.1734972,
-0.5325904489,
0.5870068669,
0.4352506995,
0.5519774556,
0.7747681737,
-0.1169484779,
0.6891303062,
-1.1891050339,
0.2665680647,
-0.06588047,
0.4355556071,
0.2492235601,
-0.1489284784,
-0.0862214938,
0.2610177398,
-0.3062862754,
-0.329584837,
0.5337361693,
-0.8625839353,
-0.3642635942,
1.1480431557,
0.2390580773,
-0.3481150866,
0.2872508466,
-0.4858727753,
0.3352563977,
-0.4383475184,
0.5960165858,
0.4775756299,
0.0605385453,
0.1849798411,
-0.5985666513,
0.372757107,
0.218180418,
-0.7854104042,
0.1727017313,
0.5954506397,
0.1307576299,
0.3106721938,
1.1167168617,
0.2378943413,
-0.0204856731,
0.3376811743,
0.3398920596,
0.1645938605,
-0.394238025,
-0.1158337146,
0.3357215822,
-0.2645159066,
-0.4391640425
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04474v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04474v2
|
Chain of Code: Reasoning with a Language Model-Augmented Code Emulator
| 2023-12-07T17:51:43 | 2023-12-08T03:04:46 |
Chengshu Li, Jacky Liang, Andy Zeng, Xinyun Chen, Karol Hausman, Dorsa Sadigh, Sergey Levine, Li Fei-Fei, Fei Xia, Brian Ichter
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, cs.RO
|
Code provides a general syntactic structure to build complex programs and
perform precise computations when paired with a code interpreter - we
hypothesize that language models (LMs) can leverage code-writing to improve
Chain of Thought reasoning not only for logic and arithmetic tasks, but also
for semantic ones (and in particular, those that are a mix of both). For
example, consider prompting an LM to write code that counts the number of times
it detects sarcasm in an essay: the LM may struggle to write an implementation
for "detect_sarcasm(string)" that can be executed by the interpreter (handling
the edge cases would be insurmountable). However, LMs may still produce a valid
solution if they not only write code, but also selectively "emulate" the
interpreter by generating the expected output of "detect_sarcasm(string)" and
other lines of code that cannot be executed. In this work, we propose Chain of
Code (CoC), a simple yet surprisingly effective extension that improves LM
code-driven reasoning. The key idea is to encourage LMs to format semantic
sub-tasks in a program as flexible pseudocode that the interpreter can
explicitly catch undefined behaviors and hand off to simulate with an LM (as an
"LMulator"). Experiments demonstrate that Chain of Code outperforms Chain of
Thought and other baselines across a variety of benchmarks; on BIG-Bench Hard,
Chain of Code achieves 84%, a gain of 12% over Chain of Thought. CoC scales
well with large and small models alike, and broadens the scope of reasoning
questions that LMs can correctly answer by "thinking in code". Project webpage:
https://chain-of-code.github.io.
|
[
-0.3711857796,
-1.0434664488,
0.6412462592,
0.0571820438,
-0.0195360985,
0.2400610447,
-0.25606969,
-0.4454367161,
0.3981135786,
0.6782864928,
-0.4109722674,
-0.3696912825,
-0.0098873759,
0.0439730771,
-0.5531098247,
1.0323193073,
-0.0881312266,
-0.0636632517,
-0.2876956761,
0.0470476896,
-0.2386853695,
-0.8655744195,
-0.2914971411,
-0.3274035156,
0.4094806612,
0.3091436923,
0.7734729648,
0.5388156772,
0.6395990252,
0.1828341484,
0.1951841563,
0.1894880086,
-0.242578581,
-0.1166726127,
-0.246441856,
-0.6135260463,
-0.6905727386,
-0.2123981714,
0.2518571615,
0.6854966283,
-0.2388553172,
0.0220330227,
-0.3355379999,
0.6031174064,
-0.767106235,
-0.084712863,
-0.5816834569,
0.0291844551,
0.2551407814,
-0.3375173509,
-0.7111586928,
-0.388520956,
-0.2942661047,
-0.4563641846,
-0.464183569,
0.353028208,
0.6347165108,
0.2847457826,
-0.1802122742,
-0.6721423268,
-0.9280457497,
0.6423957944,
-0.7766044736,
0.2293070108,
0.2491577417,
0.0963697731,
-0.1565739661,
-0.9011285901,
-0.6855945587,
-0.4439178705,
0.0783881918,
0.2088544965,
-0.191401884,
0.225716725,
0.7268422246,
0.5921458602,
-0.3835207522,
-0.2342554778,
-0.1021943912,
0.061600253,
0.3508571684,
0.1775593162,
0.6953470111,
0.0931440517,
-0.3106429279,
0.1641223133,
-0.7193148732,
0.0504071824,
0.345749706,
-0.1703333259,
0.0634867325,
0.5887197852,
-0.2128689736,
0.7862333655,
0.0512507446,
0.1320091039,
-0.080349654,
-0.1516864896,
-0.3103328049,
0.1352495104,
0.5441892147,
0.3282681704,
0.402402997,
-0.0846857429,
-0.3529626429,
0.5607562661,
0.290515691,
-0.6737709045,
-0.4817885458,
0.2114316374,
-0.3607001305,
-0.2588223815,
0.0834622383,
-0.3836555779,
0.0018876269,
-0.37155357,
0.3279589117,
-0.3795876503,
-0.1732713729,
0.278984338,
-0.2642207444,
0.1049560532,
0.2270149142,
-0.639266789,
0.7396507263,
0.7402210236,
0.623889029,
0.1612943262,
-0.2073387653,
-0.6492827535,
0.1154195666,
-0.458101362,
0.5745313764,
-0.6794691086,
-0.0322239511,
-0.1388056427,
-0.2161837816,
0.0535724051,
-0.3474605978,
0.3511477411,
-0.5500680804,
-0.0440698862,
-0.0245336145,
-0.8356253505,
0.0713760182,
0.2693350911,
-0.8546890616,
0.8907845616,
0.0785477385,
-0.7803788185,
-0.0088115633,
-0.571721375,
-0.4056461751,
-0.1706826687,
-0.3419938385,
-0.1411546022,
0.168151781,
0.0914853886,
-0.0398542769,
-0.3049797416,
0.3743700087,
-0.5416395664,
-0.6520095468,
0.5037296414,
-0.0897697508,
0.6289838552,
0.4351212084,
-0.337336421,
0.0148153715,
-0.5714033842,
0.3375872076,
-0.0566390343,
-0.2469475716,
-0.5678872466,
0.0328685492,
-0.413299948,
0.4131514132,
0.0070352033,
-0.3396631181,
0.4666343629,
-0.392863512,
0.3723913729,
0.415825218,
-0.1337704211,
0.5991429687,
-0.3860228956,
0.716909647,
-0.1740284711,
0.18445988,
-0.222261548,
-0.4176981151,
-1.0552854538,
-0.2289074659,
0.1952733994,
0.6820045114,
-1.2475026846,
0.5297519565,
-0.0750120878,
-0.2536715269,
-0.4338492453,
0.1565588564,
0.5361961126,
0.2718056142,
0.3231943548,
-0.3791146576,
-0.7696490288,
-0.5188971162,
-0.7077887654,
-0.2387441844,
0.3055148125,
0.0849816576,
0.6445254087,
-0.0574244447,
0.98508358,
-0.5729365349,
0.3124405444,
-0.4453111589,
-0.0578882694,
0.3197660744,
0.6164788008,
0.1523022354,
-0.4857610762,
-0.2100677341,
0.0382897072,
-0.7876524925,
-0.3039231896,
-0.2389749736,
-0.3096841276,
0.1290240884,
0.5909714699,
-0.3339619339,
0.5767619014,
0.583757937,
-0.4052585363,
0.6472988725,
-0.3468770087,
0.1571848094,
-0.7730372548,
0.2154636532,
-0.3755420148,
-0.3402190506,
-0.5936565995,
0.4550214708,
0.0013471941,
-0.1812161058,
-0.30916664,
0.3285843134,
-0.3450661004,
-0.1874587685,
-0.4234978259,
-0.0073795132,
0.1616288126,
0.5719838738,
0.0893227682,
0.4771792889,
0.3540670872,
-0.6400981545,
0.5020542741,
-0.1486505717,
-0.4516943991,
0.3046431541,
-0.5931301117,
0.6158609986,
0.2734234333,
0.4765351713,
-0.4408605099,
-0.0088895196,
0.2265363485,
-0.2385732383,
-0.0558748953,
-0.1210425496,
-0.7061014771,
-0.4578254521,
-0.2313656211,
0.4962901175,
0.7440655828,
-0.630322516,
0.5824494362,
0.2829344869,
0.3811863959,
-0.4625085592,
-0.9462628365,
0.0963922739,
-0.0336508788,
-0.5114831924,
0.0493420176,
-0.2056121677,
-0.5732107162,
0.1678012609,
-0.079762511,
-0.2707311213,
0.151844427,
0.1465668529,
0.3955925703,
-0.1505478024,
0.2688581645,
0.3650604188,
-0.0718482882,
0.1311708838,
-0.5912094712,
0.6432112455,
-0.533008635,
-0.5868695974,
-0.2664737701,
0.3597247899,
0.3547659814,
-0.2628698051,
0.5249859691,
0.1968737841,
-0.411531359,
-0.4025212228,
-0.3115777671,
-0.0769516304,
-0.4190200865,
0.0484042875,
-0.6028439403,
-0.9313226342,
0.4597806633,
-0.4370450974,
-0.2541622818,
0.1985919327,
0.5301803946,
0.0287605282,
1.0772438049,
0.4954067767,
0.0541144945,
0.374391526,
-0.2913935483,
0.519793272,
-0.7825424671,
0.0099789621,
-0.3662756383,
-0.1024048328,
-0.4463331699,
-0.7215639949,
0.0839001834,
0.5716545582,
-0.1674858779,
0.4806598723,
-0.5124090314,
0.6278101802,
0.3781353533,
0.2045011967,
0.5745661855,
-0.132845059,
-0.3124180436,
0.3289379776,
-0.9726393819,
-0.6094905734,
0.7771369815,
0.2861082852,
1.1269390583,
-0.1488612443,
0.9062989354,
0.4286907613,
0.2019172907,
-0.6910918355,
0.6776373982,
-0.135609746,
-0.5799009204,
0.0504656136,
-0.4800928533,
-0.2821021378,
-0.1210668385,
0.1232468709,
-0.7120897174,
0.1414819211,
0.5765294433,
-0.3127196729,
0.4831244051,
-0.8011851311,
0.7867069244,
-0.3111557662,
-0.5710092187,
-0.4061001837,
-0.5130342245,
0.4170792997,
0.1337330341,
0.4493650496,
0.2205011994,
-0.0558901876,
0.4718933105,
-0.8889434934,
0.805824101,
0.1636541486,
-0.1629768461,
0.8710334301,
0.4901059866,
0.632245481,
-0.0848652199,
-0.0324971937,
-0.1239775196,
0.0927393213,
-0.2769698203,
-0.9655964971,
0.8741142154,
-0.3846542537,
-0.5473992229,
-0.2911663353,
-0.6778127551,
0.1647941619,
-0.035222318,
-0.1657410711,
0.5304213166,
-0.060714066,
-0.0781196877,
0.365578562,
-0.2093285769,
0.3383128941,
0.0596714132,
-0.7599779963,
-0.3814387619,
0.859556973,
-0.1432843804,
0.7241622806,
0.5918418765,
0.1408417821,
0.0224661026,
0.0949013457,
-0.4242259562,
-0.1332347989,
-1.0235145092,
-0.0305497795,
-0.7454022765,
-0.1511640549,
-0.0660508126,
-0.3331061304,
-0.2589022219,
-0.8232488036,
0.1694701463,
0.0376827866,
0.4877597094,
0.6849312782,
0.0646492541,
0.135703966,
-0.4587584436,
0.1220313683,
0.1701268405,
0.2888791561,
0.0130930915,
-0.2127908021,
-0.413654089,
0.0728510767,
-0.0789413303,
-0.6835849881,
0.3213099241,
-0.1335340589,
0.1284998506,
0.2178791761,
0.0968775377,
0.9096754193,
-0.3733101785,
0.5109271407,
0.4146886766,
-1.4734549522,
0.6165065169,
-0.069294937,
0.238069281,
0.3854347467,
0.0937538967,
-0.5240208507,
-0.6643092036,
-0.5965928435,
-0.5088599324,
0.4446233213,
0.2627706826,
-0.0994765162,
-0.3211158514,
0.2885534465,
-0.0510697961,
0.2472305745,
-0.7784373164,
-0.0807289258,
-0.1920214444,
-0.3416930437,
0.3628949225,
-0.0447887369,
0.0494761504,
-0.4800256193,
0.2728617489,
-0.2564013004,
0.4204930961,
0.3682475984,
-0.3281309307,
-0.03299639,
0.3754734695,
0.4458787739,
0.6281735897,
-0.0982899442,
0.601154983,
0.2521481812,
-0.2124682069,
-0.1056767404,
-0.4424250424,
-0.1708120257,
-0.1593804359,
0.4813402593,
0.7508537173,
0.1670350283,
-0.9192876816,
0.2693502009,
0.1479356438,
-0.0193033796,
-0.3185871542,
0.3779044449,
0.1300035566,
0.0967722535,
-0.1172859147,
0.2751870453,
0.3144053221,
-0.9832618237,
0.2644554079,
0.1131339297,
-0.4780985415,
-0.2932802141,
0.4350692034,
0.3376982212,
-0.484523654,
0.5196809173,
-0.3540172577,
-0.843067348,
0.8870863914,
0.8402533531,
0.8104185462,
0.0313436873,
-0.0896448493,
0.2350851148,
0.3791415393,
-0.1745999902,
0.5806227326,
-0.105622597,
-0.7113292813,
-0.6371005177,
-0.3848027289,
-0.3659506738,
-0.3729245663,
-0.6130104661,
0.3427058756,
-0.6061236858,
-0.0927063227,
-0.420941025,
-0.1734889597,
-0.5144819021,
0.1985770613,
0.1718934625,
1.0212296247,
-0.6310993433,
1.1551046371,
0.6683486104,
-0.5553624034,
-0.9183080196,
-0.0805967897,
-0.2804906368,
-0.6522948742,
0.5612975955,
0.1485455036,
-0.3286212683,
0.1623201072,
-0.6133591533,
-0.5169571042,
1.0102572441,
0.3162152469,
-0.8900530934,
0.0369945057,
0.0202310923,
0.6687297821,
-0.8076958656,
0.6154771447,
0.5271936059,
0.2420511842,
-0.0665519908,
-0.8967878222,
0.2577055395,
-0.305066973,
-0.0495813973,
0.3003713191,
-0.4635294974,
0.903632164,
-0.4842759669,
-0.0387703739,
0.2350079268,
0.3778036535,
0.3317812681,
0.5324110985,
0.4826858044,
0.725797236,
0.7650926709,
-0.0092622256,
1.473662734,
-0.6065991521,
0.4362677634,
1.3280831575,
-0.55124259,
0.7596330643,
0.7829270363,
-0.0318525657,
1.0451053381,
0.0902098715,
0.1041794419,
0.315666914,
0.5064095259,
-0.0917522982,
-0.5412891507,
-0.1810776144,
-0.1989471465,
0.2095063925,
0.2816418111,
-0.4464288652,
0.2671909928,
-0.2112976462,
0.0034966555,
0.2532082796,
-0.3427684009,
0.5460876822,
0.4501796067,
-0.7216185927,
0.4885948598,
-0.2023385912,
0.358276397,
-0.3844283819,
-0.3110763729,
-0.0442821868,
0.5258668065,
-0.3823235929,
-0.6108834743,
0.4777826369,
0.1437809616,
-0.1134008393,
-0.1478270143,
0.9311713576,
-0.4812147617,
-0.4716336727,
0.473896116,
0.6175218225,
0.2529532015,
0.0851365924,
-0.5658006072,
0.2900509536,
-0.094265759,
-0.0174177643,
0.0887837783,
0.4879237115,
-0.1159762517,
0.7601515651,
0.7285758853,
-0.0085473182,
0.0671832487,
0.3702704906,
1.0962654352,
-0.8066036701,
-0.4766136706,
-1.0037978888,
0.3421483934,
-0.2187826633,
-0.0038092434,
0.7257550359,
0.7336726189,
0.9531140327,
-0.247129038,
0.7285027504,
-0.3235635161,
0.1340322942,
-0.6533483267,
0.3996550143,
-0.404743284,
0.4949627817,
-0.4848206937,
-0.598346591,
-0.2263311595,
0.5088458657,
-0.5240365267,
0.0106331864,
1.2665418386,
0.6538761854,
0.0588257872,
0.0728505626,
0.3750858605,
-0.0758105293,
0.229019925,
0.9362470508,
1.2949333191,
-0.4623003006,
0.5583432317,
-0.3638441265,
-0.1711230278,
-0.084636353,
-0.7938544154,
-1.0709229708,
-0.0680327117,
-0.4049980938,
-0.5993189812,
0.117852129,
1.022665143,
0.4680128992,
-0.7040920854,
-0.586484015,
-0.5833078027,
0.3846440017,
-0.4222572744,
-0.2193170935,
0.0366328023,
-0.2352002859,
-0.5770838857,
0.1159359813,
0.5230742693,
-0.3726108074,
-0.107470274,
-0.4254148006,
-0.3644247353,
0.2777499259,
0.6628563404,
0.1921156198,
-0.7745344043,
-0.3029975295,
0.2440315336,
-0.2222522646,
-0.2344195843,
1.3491975069,
-0.8156433105,
0.5859661102,
0.55943048,
0.5066975951,
0.2022167444,
-0.046102155,
0.7151110768,
-0.3382156789,
0.1988602728,
0.3529823124,
0.4064337313,
-0.0864060521,
-0.2900770605,
0.4820652902,
0.2855521441,
-0.4567073286,
-0.7602071166,
0.4646732509,
-0.9378082156,
-0.3856922388,
1.0307973623,
-0.3801487982,
-0.4722357094,
-0.0513978116,
-0.1839786023,
0.3138535917,
-0.3073404729,
0.5812056065,
0.5613014698,
-0.2391845435,
-0.141474694,
-0.280020833,
0.2936523259,
0.5194399357,
-1.0473314524,
-0.1194430366,
0.3602510989,
0.0389713012,
0.2258456498,
0.5792865157,
-0.0072571523,
0.4828541279,
0.20482485,
0.4744719267,
-0.0378731526,
-0.3670294285,
-0.1776575595,
-0.0838906839,
0.0120727085,
0.0835058093
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04469v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04469v3
|
On the Learnability of Watermarks for Language Models
| 2023-12-07T17:41:44 | 2024-05-02T07:05:56 |
Chenchen Gu, Xiang Lisa Li, Percy Liang, Tatsunori Hashimoto
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
Watermarking of language model outputs enables statistical detection of
model-generated text, which can mitigate harms and misuses of language models.
Existing watermarking strategies operate by altering the decoder of an existing
language model. In this paper, we ask whether language models can directly
learn to generate watermarked text, which would have significant implications
for the real-world deployment of watermarks. First, learned watermarks could be
used to build open models that naturally generate watermarked text, enabling
watermarking for open models, where users can control the decoding procedure.
Second, if watermarking is used to determine the provenance of generated text,
an adversary can hurt the reputation of a victim model by spoofing its
watermark and generating damaging watermarked text. To investigate the
learnability of watermarks, we propose watermark distillation, which trains a
student model to behave like a teacher model that uses decoding-based
watermarking. We test our approach on three decoding-based watermarking
strategies and various hyperparameter settings, finding that models can learn
to generate watermarked text with high detectability. We also find limitations
to learnability, including the loss of watermarking capabilities under
fine-tuning on normal text and high sample complexity when learning
low-distortion watermarks.
|
[
-0.0505849533,
-0.8002292514,
0.5569526553,
-0.1016272157,
-0.4209073782,
0.0464480668,
-0.0611446202,
-0.6718676686,
-0.3850641251,
0.7476263642,
-0.1999604702,
-0.1685724109,
-0.7763011456,
-0.0473023877,
-0.7063227296,
1.1187183857,
-0.0869999081,
-0.0675081462,
-0.1601676941,
-0.0927427784,
-0.2008846551,
-0.9043379426,
-0.450281024,
-0.3432801366,
0.2946154773,
0.1295630783,
0.580986321,
1.1232823133,
0.31374228,
0.2797775567,
-0.3000012636,
-0.0837841034,
-0.5797590613,
0.2918547988,
-0.2291402072,
-0.7089716196,
0.1290074885,
0.225729391,
0.431527257,
0.4381890297,
0.0675305799,
0.1570764929,
0.3040453196,
0.6472575068,
-0.7717054486,
0.3097496927,
-1.0235394239,
0.0007341762,
-0.334610492,
0.0086104032,
-0.7594215274,
-0.2401512116,
0.2318239212,
-0.4598344862,
0.3208242953,
0.094211705,
1.1922225952,
0.123539485,
-0.1495297551,
-0.4174172282,
-1.0427778959,
0.821503222,
-0.9287965298,
0.1956968606,
0.7311292887,
0.6787834167,
0.1434374601,
-0.9108912945,
-0.4769455492,
-0.0141321486,
0.1278118491,
0.0406714752,
-0.2806434929,
-0.2840824127,
0.538600862,
0.459890157,
-0.0307428893,
-0.3641132414,
-0.1323500723,
-0.0575053766,
0.4260003865,
0.0747112706,
0.5167754292,
0.1585853994,
-0.3188050091,
-0.3275225461,
-0.6778517365,
-0.024855366,
0.7637193203,
0.5234702229,
0.1137251332,
0.2442321777,
0.1157250404,
0.5840400457,
-0.324221909,
-0.1220588163,
-0.3849439025,
0.0494806953,
-0.1668986529,
-0.0628470853,
0.5333296061,
-0.1761581153,
0.7536093593,
-0.2456803024,
-0.4182108939,
-0.2005621195,
0.3787582815,
-0.90901649,
-0.6550924778,
-0.2524765134,
-0.3310982585,
-0.4944111705,
0.0222430862,
-0.5085248351,
-0.436937958,
-0.1367031336,
0.8120390773,
-0.5142296553,
-0.4583597779,
0.2644739747,
-0.4009163082,
-0.174724251,
0.0718555152,
-0.8374705911,
0.3077511191,
0.3313032687,
0.5180999637,
0.1086624935,
-0.3719440699,
-0.2035753578,
0.2069323063,
-0.2699329257,
0.5687798858,
-0.6929398775,
-0.1914626658,
0.0731744692,
0.0041656522,
-0.0205068476,
-0.806338191,
0.0327975862,
-0.8851997852,
0.1038138717,
-0.2454727888,
-0.8912497163,
-0.2245677859,
0.0274688713,
-1.1083244085,
0.7205421925,
0.0104002748,
-1.1147112846,
0.3080241084,
-0.1179133058,
-0.3581938744,
0.1065520048,
0.3222061992,
-0.8474541903,
0.0292694308,
-0.1960476041,
0.5206784606,
-0.0683851093,
0.4395814836,
-0.1757476479,
-0.3405318856,
0.4112895727,
-0.8629540801,
0.6386613846,
0.0208237767,
-0.5098344684,
-0.411101222,
-0.9242001772,
-0.0754220337,
0.466583252,
-0.6411235929,
-0.7278693318,
0.172935918,
0.0802800879,
-0.2447891831,
0.1347563416,
-0.375861764,
-0.0810395181,
-0.0390062518,
0.4227133393,
0.7780096531,
0.1541824043,
0.1563246995,
-0.2397061288,
0.4484027326,
0.1624376625,
0.0864148289,
-0.4684571624,
-0.4958072007,
-0.7163389325,
-0.43632406,
0.544023335,
0.3165693879,
-0.9281707406,
-0.1048415229,
-0.0136909364,
-0.6800075769,
-0.4772548676,
0.3530797958,
0.8643309474,
0.5326941013,
0.4519183636,
0.0496466942,
-0.301574856,
-0.7703004479,
-0.7896503806,
-0.2467685938,
0.32987234,
0.3236735165,
0.7020793557,
0.1537745595,
0.9196567535,
-0.6313203573,
0.0432648025,
-0.298173219,
0.2736336887,
-0.1747731417,
0.4151817262,
0.5121958852,
-0.9151704311,
-0.6563559175,
-0.1822882891,
-0.5528464913,
-0.2126694173,
0.2151927352,
0.1377948523,
0.0528213978,
0.3734459877,
-0.1457346678,
0.6351535916,
0.5854489803,
-0.2594497502,
0.5837577581,
-0.40782094,
-0.0646870658,
-1.092859745,
0.1083343849,
-0.1245966703,
-0.1544190496,
-0.7630158663,
0.1747183949,
0.2049504668,
-0.2657994926,
-0.5411511064,
0.5073540211,
-0.3746929467,
0.3139168918,
-0.6299600601,
-0.4415598512,
0.2814607024,
0.1920437515,
0.2709256709,
0.6384257078,
0.5385657549,
-0.6846369505,
0.0523237027,
-0.1815417856,
-0.6395723224,
0.3142038286,
-0.8177839518,
0.1019846871,
-0.2487648726,
0.0177269913,
-0.9807460308,
0.0960740745,
-0.0178977028,
-0.1544351727,
0.3851737976,
-0.6824063063,
-0.4929420054,
0.1930774599,
0.198377341,
0.4018496871,
0.529391408,
-0.7792492509,
0.2519456446,
0.1343345195,
0.0812068731,
-0.463131249,
-0.7557859421,
-0.0066095125,
-0.295561552,
-0.1938351095,
0.278272301,
-0.0022061598,
-0.1507957876,
0.1040092632,
0.0125943068,
-0.4442605674,
0.5526631474,
0.5539240241,
0.0842416808,
-0.0788615048,
0.0370431021,
0.0132539114,
-0.1903765798,
-0.0408541933,
-0.1424576938,
0.3779702783,
0.190483138,
-0.4802149832,
-0.372956425,
0.1549984068,
0.3506641686,
-0.4774338305,
0.9141945243,
0.2686955333,
-0.7083907127,
-0.5588052273,
-0.3474363089,
-0.3537926078,
-0.4827401042,
0.1680112183,
-0.2705340981,
-0.7202178836,
0.3932910264,
-0.0670337677,
0.0799461678,
0.1978668123,
0.0701904073,
0.0201452076,
0.9588441253,
0.9389261007,
-0.1635666192,
0.6115009785,
-0.2959983647,
0.2404414564,
-0.3729506433,
-0.1015724242,
-0.804751575,
0.0095380312,
-0.3011555374,
-0.2766479254,
-0.1750064641,
0.3782071769,
-0.1287586987,
0.7257867455,
-0.3868664801,
0.7176430821,
0.5619630814,
0.1690471768,
0.4356943667,
0.3046528995,
-0.1673624367,
-0.3435206711,
-0.4412896335,
-0.8560674191,
0.8428931832,
0.3430737853,
0.6672505736,
-0.0666949004,
0.7510848641,
0.3299124837,
0.4171235263,
-0.3432099223,
0.2792549729,
0.0011064719,
-0.9083395004,
-0.3009821475,
-0.3673223853,
-0.8497177958,
0.1959592998,
-0.223625809,
-0.4599978328,
-0.030001685,
0.2163808495,
0.0006130287,
0.7203868032,
-0.6580797434,
0.7712600827,
-0.1590248197,
-0.4276476502,
0.0491387323,
-0.2212443054,
-0.0295258984,
-0.3340518475,
0.4683255255,
-0.0827685297,
0.2473035157,
0.7892090678,
-0.2801356316,
1.0243694782,
-0.5493243933,
-0.4276168048,
0.3478315473,
0.4617493451,
0.3649598658,
-0.1614343971,
-0.2622438073,
0.1050241515,
0.0175103899,
-0.4387539029,
-0.5107808709,
0.3752111197,
-0.5903659463,
-0.6367298961,
-0.2345071137,
-0.3047207296,
-0.1012212485,
0.4209834039,
0.1940901726,
0.5513564944,
-0.0528472327,
-0.0372450426,
0.7358901501,
-0.253110677,
0.7133768797,
0.8446775079,
-0.0844706669,
-0.2334308773,
1.3652311563,
0.171490103,
0.2330756485,
0.3064157367,
0.3526785076,
0.009649016,
-0.8295812011,
-0.4224863648,
0.1253067255,
-0.6907067299,
-0.1038961112,
-0.3496137559,
-0.3313599825,
0.1604835689,
0.0556213148,
-0.5381336808,
-0.1384520084,
-0.4930313826,
-0.1541764736,
0.3403929472,
0.9620198011,
0.262719661,
0.315087229,
-0.8017936945,
0.1188452542,
0.604562521,
0.46127069,
0.1025264561,
-0.841550529,
-0.4232798219,
0.4355479777,
-0.2303521931,
-0.7077133656,
0.325871557,
0.3165733516,
0.3779146969,
0.5433537364,
0.2204398811,
0.5873903036,
-0.7627600431,
0.7321968079,
-0.1466560662,
-1.1427282095,
0.6171476841,
-0.0629641637,
0.0611687265,
0.3816943169,
0.5174860954,
-0.085990794,
-0.6419255137,
-0.5587589741,
-0.7297844887,
0.5988975167,
0.0567024723,
0.792503953,
-0.0304155685,
0.6275960803,
0.3298794329,
0.0519247204,
-0.9023706317,
-0.1295936853,
-0.4035428166,
-0.0220880471,
-0.1015158072,
-0.5196838379,
0.0416408628,
0.0228478052,
0.7540350556,
-0.0193790458,
-0.2112532854,
-0.0984287038,
-0.3350255787,
0.0305081978,
0.207278192,
0.2572598755,
0.3429514468,
-0.1154830903,
0.4526559711,
-0.2747360766,
-0.3650453687,
0.2662510872,
-0.1871305108,
-0.3252535164,
0.0324103348,
0.5330985785,
0.9622986913,
0.159573853,
-0.64656955,
0.6428639293,
-0.1918959618,
-0.1706594974,
0.0616800375,
0.1865024418,
0.3590373397,
0.1669705063,
0.3790129721,
-0.2036535889,
-0.117300801,
-0.450268507,
0.1236165091,
0.3229321837,
-0.574257195,
-0.5250831842,
0.8859890103,
-0.0688652173,
-0.2619941533,
0.508616209,
0.2501800358,
-0.641141355,
0.6351690888,
0.9165199399,
0.6391240358,
-0.3655345738,
0.1473890841,
0.3608470857,
0.2384431213,
-0.3017685115,
0.0782579631,
-0.1815310568,
-0.9160775542,
-0.0634082556,
-0.5872048736,
-0.629117012,
0.2133775055,
-0.9974070787,
-0.0759748071,
-0.4279094636,
-0.3167075813,
0.343331635,
-0.3290110826,
-0.3457185924,
0.4805563986,
0.1574453712,
0.6698218584,
-1.1139074564,
0.9209865332,
0.8571540117,
-0.2891696095,
-0.643928349,
0.1099791527,
-0.3055719733,
-0.6783562303,
0.6249328256,
0.2543368638,
-0.1698279083,
0.0609107204,
-0.8212276101,
-0.4637954533,
0.7864633203,
0.8570802212,
-0.3282503188,
0.2184096873,
0.468716234,
0.7736515403,
-0.0084724892,
0.0281830151,
0.1923660636,
0.2067331374,
-0.381480664,
-0.6348148584,
0.1964771301,
-0.3837128282,
0.2754324377,
0.0036567806,
-0.4521956146,
0.8826032877,
-0.0615749359,
-0.4798993468,
-0.1514798105,
0.3536441028,
0.0008514697,
0.1273794174,
0.3698224723,
0.5162204504,
0.4564145803,
-0.1501302719,
1.0295768976,
-0.4054437578,
0.4139986634,
0.9681022167,
-0.2898096442,
1.0674743652,
0.4625394642,
-0.1596155167,
0.5702686906,
0.1302246004,
-0.1270871162,
0.7507282495,
0.4639209211,
-0.3265742958,
-0.4008854628,
-0.0265728012,
-0.2030583322,
0.3292770982,
0.0787582695,
-0.5747712255,
-0.1553374082,
0.1179109365,
0.0950275585,
0.4665617645,
0.1601092815,
0.8563067913,
0.217466414,
-0.2865896821,
0.7193061113,
0.2502596974,
0.5771645904,
-0.4920073152,
-0.1894198209,
-0.122592628,
0.2980661988,
-0.0579105802,
-0.529309094,
0.2057640851,
0.1415545642,
-0.4312480092,
-0.3513939083,
0.7713050842,
-0.5136094093,
-0.296528995,
0.4007595479,
0.4882248044,
0.1547238827,
-0.3911038637,
-0.4315621257,
0.003873216,
-0.0012398666,
-0.4048911631,
0.6508908272,
0.2154171318,
0.0621073432,
1.0312383175,
0.6289545894,
0.1993535161,
0.1730192304,
0.0227761175,
0.6145626307,
-0.4364530444,
-0.1804890335,
-1.2074941397,
0.2615444362,
0.1637083292,
0.0644177049,
0.8826643229,
0.4606681466,
0.9697172642,
-0.282070905,
1.0749274492,
0.2788239717,
0.4147188962,
-0.3752036691,
1.197511673,
-0.5047399402,
0.2624458075,
-0.4064389169,
-0.7349677086,
-0.0963773131,
0.3620797694,
-0.0848555937,
-0.1203573346,
0.4046536684,
0.6430972219,
-0.161104396,
0.2501848042,
0.5031653047,
-0.2966227531,
0.4007697999,
0.3173708916,
0.8725563884,
-0.5851589441,
0.7063625455,
-0.6526578069,
-0.020628253,
0.0853447467,
-1.0629140139,
-1.025301218,
-0.8196041584,
-0.6683562994,
-0.4101715982,
0.3135635257,
0.2221220583,
0.7336905599,
-1.0169883966,
-0.0676215589,
-0.0220644046,
0.1034566313,
-0.2510220706,
-0.2572967708,
0.3612429798,
-0.0264721196,
-0.8870512247,
0.1706777811,
-0.0782449618,
0.6623312235,
-0.0971061513,
0.0455789715,
0.1399559379,
0.3066359162,
0.2668637633,
0.2802121341,
-0.2541584074,
-0.2258607298,
-0.3435492814,
-0.2005981952,
-0.3262000382,
0.8102828264,
-0.4906332791,
0.5489165783,
0.2200551182,
0.7286884785,
0.4220200181,
-0.1775060892,
0.4056710601,
-0.6689870954,
0.0448681526,
0.0275562853,
0.3176646531,
0.5453773737,
-0.0969086662,
0.1367162168,
0.4795029461,
-0.1469453871,
-1.0440528393,
0.1244930103,
-0.0738800317,
-0.403241694,
1.1523070335,
-0.8964325786,
-0.1827888787,
-0.3085885048,
-0.1924988478,
0.3707763851,
0.0423920155,
0.806507647,
0.8397721052,
0.679985106,
-0.1285221279,
-0.485093236,
0.5836967826,
0.3050602973,
-0.6202480197,
0.4053189754,
0.1124077737,
0.8401575685,
-0.0677265301,
0.2138355374,
-0.2391810268,
0.1017699391,
0.1564283669,
0.2036693096,
-0.4625463784,
-0.3087235987,
-0.2711242139,
0.2083020359,
0.2713036537,
-0.1257555336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04455v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04455v4
|
Fortify the Shortest Stave in Attention: Enhancing Context Awareness of Large Language Models for Effective Tool Use
| 2023-12-07T17:24:51 | 2024-06-04T07:33:12 |
Yuhan Chen, Ang Lv, Ting-En Lin, Changyu Chen, Yuchuan Wu, Fei Huang, Yongbin Li, Rui Yan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
In this paper, we demonstrate that an inherent waveform pattern in the
attention allocation of large language models (LLMs) significantly affects
their performance in tasks demanding a high degree of context awareness, such
as utilizing LLMs for tool-use. Specifically, the crucial information in the
context will be potentially overlooked by model when it is positioned in the
trough zone of the attention waveform, leading to decreased performance. To
address this issue, we propose a novel inference method named Attention
Buckets. It allows LLMs to process their input through multiple parallel
processes. Each process utilizes a distinct base angle for the rotary position
embedding, thereby creating a unique attention waveform. By compensating an
attention trough of a particular process with an attention peak of another
process, our approach enhances LLM's awareness to various contextual positions,
thus mitigating the risk of overlooking crucial information. In the largest
tool-use benchmark, our method elevates a 7B model to achieve state-of-the-art
performance, comparable to that of GPT-4. On other benchmarks and some RAG
tasks, which also demand a thorough understanding of contextual content,
Attention Buckets also exhibited notable enhancements in performance.
|
[
-0.4674601257,
-0.9153826237,
0.6662690043,
0.4132577777,
-0.3847572505,
-0.3200052083,
-0.3245929182,
-0.5292064548,
0.1752527356,
0.4915278256,
-0.6172684431,
-0.4926612079,
-0.6854947209,
0.0075055226,
-0.4057898223,
0.6531197429,
0.0931123942,
-0.4535001218,
-0.3417187929,
-0.1106037498,
-0.6359829307,
-0.3996825516,
-0.5943785906,
-0.2035417557,
0.61328125,
0.4584876001,
0.6727449298,
0.8974807858,
0.5674449801,
0.3885870278,
-0.2134579569,
-0.1773069352,
-0.6139056683,
0.1258022934,
-0.2748863399,
-0.4133580625,
-0.5018361211,
-0.3290753663,
0.6222848296,
0.905177176,
0.0335395299,
0.3555092812,
0.2456205636,
0.5388917923,
-0.7859916091,
0.1366925091,
-0.7218932509,
-0.1706548035,
-0.5313543677,
-0.1264019608,
-0.435821563,
0.001692735,
0.4110740721,
-0.3197831213,
0.5263154507,
0.1568693817,
0.6490863562,
0.77465415,
-0.2048369646,
0.105387859,
-0.6363916397,
0.8677230477,
-0.4866767824,
0.5361055136,
0.2956850529,
0.3223164082,
-0.2462399751,
-0.7460387945,
-0.3933789432,
0.2548768222,
0.1057266295,
0.0652341247,
-0.0879960358,
0.2506187856,
0.5877100229,
0.2864234746,
-0.3339396119,
-0.0266320501,
-0.156842649,
-0.1609741747,
0.2858369648,
0.0903140381,
-0.0640143752,
-0.0678367168,
-0.5524173975,
-0.0480482988,
-0.8705464005,
0.3087643981,
-0.1087202877,
0.1773982644,
-0.1797802895,
0.5915938616,
-0.4058797359,
0.773701787,
0.0637312829,
-0.2212295383,
0.2376400083,
-0.110093452,
-0.7414823174,
0.0877298713,
0.4347152114,
0.2680667937,
0.0226198118,
-0.0798727721,
-0.3071857691,
0.0347838104,
0.3322706521,
-0.6782444715,
-0.0057423157,
0.3109921813,
-0.2176060975,
0.0520441681,
-0.4509322345,
-0.5122984052,
-0.5158953667,
-0.3180125654,
0.2261892259,
-0.2111201137,
0.0638089776,
0.1926172227,
-0.1840138733,
0.1553931087,
0.435061574,
-0.8672043085,
0.0714643374,
0.6046887636,
0.7506514192,
-0.0227421485,
-0.231031999,
-0.6943885088,
0.6065223217,
-0.118642576,
1.0581396818,
-0.5154877305,
-0.1123876274,
-0.0402839445,
0.0076728915,
-0.084923394,
-0.6331680417,
0.671255827,
-0.55915308,
-0.0426602662,
-0.3093465567,
-0.3721709847,
-0.230186969,
0.0805455968,
-0.745799005,
1.2244473696,
0.2843496799,
-0.8119729161,
0.335859865,
-0.4821512699,
-0.434864372,
0.0940352157,
0.0122067975,
-0.3867276609,
0.2626361251,
0.4263258874,
0.4723550081,
-0.4055841565,
0.2228335291,
-0.5706207156,
-0.3314029276,
-0.0553641506,
-0.2487072498,
0.5190810561,
-0.137899667,
-0.4622862041,
0.5271966457,
-0.3173595667,
-0.2497618794,
0.0128849717,
-0.3669057488,
-0.3474586606,
0.041646421,
0.0333922133,
0.2473836541,
0.2528782189,
-0.3677737415,
0.0371807404,
-0.7093368769,
0.2113803625,
0.8765063286,
0.0838619992,
0.4607421458,
-0.1753786057,
0.4413886666,
-0.0999135822,
0.3119851351,
0.026028499,
-0.3212910891,
-0.8533324003,
-0.4642255604,
0.1428035498,
0.3342552185,
-0.5836875439,
0.2823736966,
-0.345571816,
-0.2924006283,
-0.5285970569,
0.3985338807,
0.4268729091,
0.6352192163,
0.2158064991,
-0.4104736447,
-0.6415995359,
-1.2925719023,
-0.2882936001,
0.2019663453,
-0.213575989,
0.35397771,
0.158319369,
-0.1315722317,
1.0361756086,
-0.3928542137,
-0.3361676633,
-0.4417815804,
-0.1999326646,
0.3605146706,
0.1818463951,
0.5006318688,
-0.7676925063,
-0.4301785827,
-0.3884804249,
-0.3928957582,
-0.3494841456,
0.0020465611,
-0.3954024315,
0.1490536183,
0.5895287991,
-0.7470136881,
0.4137390554,
0.3584846556,
-0.2869244814,
0.4219631255,
0.1933952868,
-0.2610217929,
-0.6866842508,
0.1872832328,
0.0787370577,
-0.3583340943,
-0.6574813128,
-0.1653515548,
0.2275994867,
0.228041932,
-0.6177791357,
0.7331867218,
-0.5614132881,
-0.3290297985,
-0.3169322014,
0.4459747672,
-0.0439820588,
0.7060486078,
0.0566605628,
0.7156965733,
0.5773950815,
-0.5716117024,
0.2457027584,
0.2911918163,
-0.3851584196,
0.4021743536,
-0.7623307705,
0.0727181509,
-0.1000754684,
0.0919970796,
-1.0939639807,
-0.3413395584,
0.0666839927,
-0.2461769432,
0.3341633081,
-0.2528523207,
-0.5269307494,
-0.3835338056,
-0.2809824646,
0.3342033625,
0.3630017936,
-0.3944293857,
0.5595479012,
0.6891162992,
-0.4707030952,
-0.6638237238,
-0.4174119532,
-0.0776153579,
-0.5301911235,
-0.6890406609,
0.2908433378,
-0.0102281272,
0.009114556,
-0.3312686384,
-0.5427401662,
0.1082771569,
0.2784011066,
0.3528668582,
0.2859149277,
-0.0454780683,
0.1528818607,
-0.0850115865,
-0.0462519787,
0.179593727,
-0.2116878331,
0.59339571,
-0.0312960856,
-0.3181485832,
-0.2801602781,
0.2382018566,
0.6948144436,
-0.2846925259,
0.658972919,
0.5183652639,
-0.4188258648,
-0.3041939139,
-0.7865576744,
-0.3898328543,
-0.518750608,
0.3638826311,
-0.4450148344,
-0.9294092655,
0.4849076569,
-0.1983654648,
-0.0171317887,
0.1088260934,
0.6812858582,
0.0799413547,
1.11924541,
0.8599303961,
-0.3190327585,
0.8468950987,
-0.0210307017,
0.2716279626,
-1.2210698128,
0.0223159585,
-0.5674741268,
-0.2889432013,
-0.047105033,
-0.5934743285,
0.5502858758,
0.2941922247,
-0.1518378705,
0.1323245317,
-0.4176086783,
0.3868642449,
0.596957624,
0.1216087937,
0.0485658906,
0.1071066186,
-0.2029453963,
0.0125635508,
-0.9268615246,
-0.4914526045,
0.8063308001,
0.4168738127,
0.4319738746,
0.1666881442,
0.4286063313,
0.0374003984,
0.5147362947,
-0.8529580832,
0.5011030436,
0.2592152059,
-0.5564604402,
-0.5715574622,
-0.0514332615,
-1.0066882372,
0.4863090813,
0.1687410474,
-0.9791055918,
-0.0356831029,
0.2274858803,
-0.4104440808,
-0.13563025,
-0.9906895757,
1.1605517864,
0.1446466744,
-0.7156245708,
-0.2927649319,
-0.696003139,
0.3184887767,
0.0791755021,
0.3608568907,
-0.3747904003,
-0.0851134658,
0.6353608966,
-0.1270277351,
1.1523391008,
-0.282384485,
-0.1027480215,
0.2439681888,
-0.0228481945,
0.9795894623,
-0.0908984616,
0.1070810333,
-0.0811920539,
-0.4351915717,
-0.5342071652,
-0.4160903394,
0.6030868292,
-0.4197350442,
-1.1780587435,
-0.0265488401,
-0.8260352015,
-0.4325814247,
0.4389404655,
-0.0884209871,
0.3614318371,
0.0838392228,
0.3517717123,
0.7150332928,
0.0267678648,
0.6393902898,
0.2485282272,
0.188050583,
-0.0643268451,
0.2900095582,
-0.1237879246,
0.3104610741,
0.4169824421,
0.1915274262,
-0.5840983391,
-0.6776376367,
-0.347134918,
0.2902587652,
-0.8790282011,
-0.1865770072,
-0.7991001606,
0.1818398237,
-0.5677072406,
-0.2334580868,
-0.3232994676,
-0.2433467209,
0.1063389406,
-0.0365938097,
0.3402827382,
0.3550359011,
0.3059010506,
0.381853193,
-0.7614455819,
0.4213157594,
0.2086619288,
0.365128845,
0.0738454238,
-0.5042261481,
-0.3630304039,
-0.1577417552,
-0.1373241544,
-0.7666122317,
0.3699447513,
0.0874156952,
0.8109438419,
0.3830159009,
0.2672609687,
0.8125408888,
-0.4348402023,
0.4232549667,
-0.0983781442,
-1.0750461817,
0.6150406003,
-0.4881262481,
0.6889694929,
0.2121012062,
0.0479319654,
-0.5605131984,
-0.7017810941,
-0.6617893577,
-1.1792805195,
0.8581753373,
0.1065111682,
-0.318294853,
-0.0011611002,
-0.0437171198,
-0.1992886811,
0.2720112205,
-0.5517393947,
-0.0458721705,
0.1541049629,
-0.3134165406,
-0.0440635197,
-0.5103361011,
-0.2637563646,
-0.01972178,
0.5705165267,
-0.2441357523,
0.2063450664,
0.3196163476,
-0.2835245728,
-0.1394411772,
0.2147084624,
0.47807616,
0.6094868183,
-0.1250226945,
0.3013278246,
0.4244216383,
-0.5532493591,
-0.2221979499,
-0.0064913491,
-0.11739593,
-0.1559114158,
0.4264400899,
0.7848492861,
0.6392336488,
-0.716163516,
0.4355492294,
0.1759431362,
0.3615434468,
-0.2426283658,
0.1596779227,
0.3897781074,
0.5031027794,
0.2514017224,
0.0603524037,
0.2995941937,
-0.1396191865,
0.0104592089,
0.4651969969,
-0.3636496961,
-0.044627931,
0.5162062049,
0.2443776727,
-0.0598145388,
0.2721066177,
0.0909019411,
-0.6025567651,
0.7427477241,
0.4903534651,
0.8979716301,
-0.3265094757,
-0.3902783394,
0.2811615169,
0.3513950706,
0.0245286077,
0.1708253175,
-0.2918401062,
-0.6130023599,
-0.6034646034,
-0.7262498736,
-0.1626644284,
0.0887569338,
-0.4779965878,
0.214672327,
-0.2810630798,
-0.1790412217,
0.1022626013,
-0.2173740417,
-0.8382020593,
0.127309233,
0.1014615223,
0.9037027955,
-0.6912521124,
0.9109373689,
0.7427781224,
0.1230552346,
-0.7367918491,
-0.1374919862,
0.114531301,
-0.6817723513,
0.4217869937,
0.4292950332,
-0.3171821833,
0.1854018718,
-0.3837137222,
-1.3153208494,
0.9968520999,
0.4183044434,
-0.5894799232,
0.2385975122,
0.0055598668,
0.2931050658,
-0.2862862945,
0.0529341884,
0.7304577231,
0.4968914986,
0.1021488085,
-1.0512262583,
0.3028992116,
-0.1301713437,
0.1580873877,
0.3310563564,
-0.6042903662,
0.4926808476,
-0.2338130921,
-0.6154000163,
-0.2308437377,
0.4947007,
0.5324223638,
0.1892475039,
0.7205454707,
0.5057550669,
0.6327226162,
-0.1029956415,
1.2214719057,
-0.1926762164,
0.2544879913,
1.1552590132,
-0.3045031428,
0.8920938373,
0.7916178703,
-0.111970067,
0.0054049692,
0.6836002469,
0.2627539635,
0.6607998013,
0.0434297733,
-0.3099731207,
-0.304933399,
-0.2604921162,
-0.1301437914,
0.2823763788,
0.6061275005,
-0.2013089061,
-0.2002674341,
0.0493872389,
-0.0824270099,
-0.2398293912,
-0.3842974901,
0.6690628529,
0.0408981144,
-0.8024526238,
0.7811567783,
-0.1218166873,
0.4644873142,
-0.383449465,
0.1823044419,
-0.1252687275,
0.454775244,
-0.030625565,
-0.6050613523,
0.3038899899,
-0.084149912,
-0.4644809067,
-0.1994919181,
0.7393693924,
-0.316049844,
-0.1485945433,
0.3326731622,
0.3676618636,
0.1096724048,
-0.5017759204,
-0.4403546751,
0.1905381531,
0.0786584914,
-0.5270902514,
0.2684897184,
0.5198613405,
-0.34163481,
0.8023814559,
0.6153588891,
-0.1452154815,
0.1940497458,
0.2977053523,
0.8406681418,
-0.6350967288,
-0.5551965237,
-0.815466404,
0.5196985602,
-0.1677185297,
-0.1190464124,
0.785559833,
0.4772490263,
0.8144445419,
-0.2784039974,
0.7594202161,
0.0662518218,
0.6415508986,
-0.4532212317,
0.4895908535,
-0.3165939748,
0.3060099483,
-0.2424142659,
-1.0287684202,
-0.2433510572,
0.4209895432,
-0.56025666,
-0.1102552861,
0.8470196724,
0.7836681008,
-0.031702958,
-0.2406867296,
0.3392393887,
0.3750838935,
0.2392609715,
0.8187550902,
0.6421784759,
-0.1330291927,
0.5605351925,
-0.428775847,
-0.2897858024,
-0.5602219701,
-0.7437154055,
-0.9015259743,
-0.412555337,
-0.1982962936,
-0.0587878413,
-0.1384276003,
0.6426584125,
0.8433853984,
-0.639200449,
-0.0669722036,
0.0151099823,
0.2937415838,
-0.2873730958,
-0.1931300461,
0.5145356655,
-0.442096591,
-0.9508824944,
0.4094133675,
0.5330018401,
0.110397242,
-0.029511258,
0.1763792485,
-0.127027303,
-0.1057456136,
0.7695553303,
0.1092527658,
-0.9558600783,
-0.4947870672,
-0.0123771755,
-0.2660531998,
0.0590099059,
0.7084206343,
-0.8594194651,
0.2864418626,
0.5433966517,
0.4881134629,
0.6120631099,
0.05767259,
0.5754956007,
-1.1170320511,
0.5578181744,
0.1958468556,
0.5747374296,
0.4417724609,
-0.5136407018,
0.5232002735,
0.1102481633,
-0.4273825884,
-0.8228361011,
0.3746263683,
-1.1183214188,
-0.1115498543,
0.981341064,
-0.0123632653,
-0.5417880416,
-0.4251970947,
-0.2744699121,
0.3696395457,
-0.4010222852,
0.9888046384,
0.6570530534,
-0.0339540914,
-0.4087416828,
-0.7978901267,
0.6242415905,
0.6913109422,
-0.641641736,
0.4426179528,
0.514462471,
0.1731911898,
0.1337462664,
0.4171648622,
0.0629511252,
0.3031165004,
-0.1226139292,
0.239455387,
0.0284493864,
-0.3899297416,
-0.2086486816,
0.4251741171,
0.2193794698,
-0.0518455207
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04440v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04440v1
|
OpenAsp: A Benchmark for Multi-document Open Aspect-based Summarization
| 2023-12-07T17:06:20 | 2023-12-07T17:06:20 |
Shmuel Amar, Liat Schiff, Ori Ernst, Asi Shefer, Ori Shapira, Ido Dagan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The performance of automatic summarization models has improved dramatically
in recent years. Yet, there is still a gap in meeting specific information
needs of users in real-world scenarios, particularly when a targeted summary is
sought, such as in the useful aspect-based summarization setting targeted in
this paper. Previous datasets and studies for this setting have predominantly
concentrated on a limited set of pre-defined aspects, focused solely on single
document inputs, or relied on synthetic data. To advance research on more
realistic scenarios, we introduce OpenAsp, a benchmark for multi-document
\textit{open} aspect-based summarization. This benchmark is created using a
novel and cost-effective annotation protocol, by which an open aspect dataset
is derived from existing generic multi-document summarization datasets. We
analyze the properties of OpenAsp showcasing its high-quality content. Further,
we show that the realistic open-aspect setting realized in OpenAsp poses a
challenge for current state-of-the-art summarization models, as well as for
large language models.
|
[
-0.59661901,
-0.4869081676,
0.4187110066,
0.2628366649,
-0.1513632983,
-0.2012082338,
-0.1459773481,
-0.6978798509,
0.4585698843,
0.4137947559,
-0.2072952539,
-0.4470583498,
-0.5669414401,
0.0050585028,
-0.2557707429,
1.0188356638,
-0.4122528732,
-0.3244172335,
-0.4286094606,
-0.5382193327,
-0.0182074215,
-0.6866104007,
-0.3336149454,
-0.2239374816,
0.4379662275,
0.3137831092,
0.5610296726,
0.5928162336,
0.8548026681,
0.1630875617,
-0.0269091316,
0.4972058833,
-0.0480540693,
0.3496469557,
0.0845843703,
-0.2452327758,
-0.828804493,
0.2411000431,
0.8902012706,
0.8364098668,
0.0732688978,
0.286582619,
0.1748149991,
0.8041778207,
-0.9545930624,
0.3747115731,
-0.10970781,
0.124944903,
-0.2697901428,
-0.0629659221,
-0.012474048,
-0.376996845,
0.1173480004,
-0.6675885916,
0.3379271626,
-0.0977953002,
0.9890673757,
-0.1143696532,
-0.1793543249,
-0.1300875098,
-0.768864572,
0.2628013194,
-0.789005518,
0.2013310343,
0.3618286848,
0.5352606177,
0.0756832212,
-0.6616126299,
-0.4298367798,
0.1451866329,
-0.0748553351,
0.2584294677,
0.0961407423,
-0.0432934351,
-0.0447247028,
0.8090674281,
-0.2972986996,
-0.1541695744,
-0.1468435675,
0.0023404597,
0.4794365466,
0.0612564012,
-0.1557497233,
-0.0144787189,
-0.2646036744,
-0.2004020214,
-0.551697135,
0.2084555775,
0.4524678588,
0.5418206453,
-0.4278671443,
0.7756041288,
-0.8623200059,
0.4386144578,
-0.3891683221,
-0.0147642484,
0.2723625302,
-0.4892732799,
-0.0953827277,
-0.1821002215,
0.6792337298,
0.6710858941,
0.0280832313,
0.0170130134,
-0.2952733934,
-0.3530617058,
0.0516145416,
-0.7400112748,
-0.0704130828,
0.6694595814,
-0.5410681963,
-0.1017548218,
0.3589985073,
-0.8908712864,
-0.4728430212,
-0.2431321293,
0.3216565847,
-0.3585675657,
-0.3163797855,
-0.0861619115,
-0.2350899577,
-0.180538252,
0.5105701685,
-0.8361407518,
0.4568078518,
0.8936280608,
1.4458384514,
-0.0856021047,
-0.5061419606,
-0.5719007254,
0.1131371036,
-0.224706009,
1.1273304224,
-0.4102937877,
-0.0946272165,
0.0499939732,
-0.3635981381,
0.1719381809,
-0.3638320565,
0.4643806815,
0.0988213718,
0.1118934304,
-0.5129667521,
-0.2882900238,
-0.2582461238,
0.370087117,
-0.6787862778,
0.6948086619,
0.1321468502,
-0.691460669,
0.5262893438,
-0.9044101834,
-0.3322872818,
-0.237735793,
-0.2281749547,
-0.4950527847,
0.4414428771,
0.4936662912,
0.2965039909,
-0.2147812247,
0.0403919145,
-0.4277588129,
0.067397587,
0.2375733405,
-0.338262409,
0.1587125808,
0.0800056681,
0.2778020203,
0.2867912352,
-0.7591173649,
-0.2893594205,
0.0894310996,
-0.258543402,
-0.4566424787,
0.0494465008,
0.0524370484,
0.283526063,
0.3204352558,
-0.7731365561,
0.3176632524,
-0.2725184858,
0.1566837579,
0.4946780503,
0.0818933621,
0.1846773177,
-0.6212291718,
0.4168518186,
0.2279767394,
0.1029492691,
-0.8205088973,
-0.3913498521,
-0.5228641629,
-0.4505993426,
0.4413461387,
0.2085091174,
-0.4163034558,
0.2501766384,
-0.1652660519,
-0.601646781,
-0.7572639585,
-0.3411775231,
0.469607681,
0.515956521,
0.4771840572,
-0.7724460363,
-0.2522884905,
-1.0026549101,
-0.3306971192,
-0.165713653,
-0.3176537454,
0.1798622012,
0.4300168157,
0.6813670397,
0.8945091367,
-0.7325646281,
-0.6316924095,
-0.2987172306,
0.435026139,
-0.0021618782,
0.4111235738,
0.5418384075,
-0.5882800221,
-0.0555629246,
-0.1751477718,
-0.9758153558,
-0.0931998938,
-0.1407387108,
0.0119334515,
0.1311976463,
0.1679267436,
-0.5062435269,
0.4610879719,
0.6363251805,
-0.3177146018,
0.5434088111,
-0.6346713305,
0.6623117924,
-1.0202732086,
0.3085754514,
0.131517902,
-0.1284839809,
-0.4186027646,
0.3487102091,
0.329133451,
-0.4761937857,
-0.4122918844,
0.4916595817,
-0.3589653671,
-0.3961445093,
-0.2650010586,
0.1905445606,
0.0863600522,
0.5264689326,
0.2467563152,
0.6647601724,
0.2992378771,
-0.5064137578,
0.0562861003,
0.3762662411,
-0.1628217995,
0.8022969365,
-0.6334677339,
-0.1375214905,
-0.2940235138,
0.5967838168,
-0.6436047554,
-0.4655320048,
0.0240745153,
-0.3828703165,
-0.0032070421,
-0.013435767,
-0.5568861365,
0.073725298,
-0.722238183,
0.3398576379,
0.0647618398,
-0.5019574165,
0.7027680278,
0.3351708949,
-0.5114921331,
-0.3988407552,
-0.4123574495,
0.2773864269,
0.0900941789,
-0.5202847123,
0.3252678812,
0.2632370591,
-0.1710582227,
-0.0474476628,
-0.2888301909,
0.0084429523,
0.0185144581,
0.4753008187,
-0.1801624447,
-0.3351578414,
-0.1223117039,
0.2942968905,
-0.3518004119,
-0.2348932326,
-0.1084992886,
0.545388341,
-0.0804209188,
-0.7033697367,
-0.3104760051,
0.7926557064,
0.3835124373,
-0.7739621997,
0.7103232741,
0.0112636834,
-0.5564543605,
0.0847971365,
-0.2743138671,
0.2575667202,
-0.3411856294,
0.3391818404,
-0.5450469255,
-0.4254157245,
0.6839652061,
0.1024592966,
0.8608828783,
0.5432206392,
0.0847993791,
-0.0976590365,
0.6746259332,
0.6405878663,
-0.0089599136,
0.2961942852,
-0.0248553958,
-0.0600397326,
-0.9910590053,
-0.2733114958,
-0.858294785,
-0.2846634388,
-0.1321185827,
-0.1391292959,
0.5613928437,
0.2626674771,
0.0903577432,
0.3055455983,
-0.2400746047,
0.3635227084,
0.8185150623,
-0.0343488976,
0.7255159616,
-0.343049705,
0.2319221497,
0.2278275937,
-0.3165864944,
-0.6873556972,
1.2911800146,
0.442856133,
0.414172858,
0.3706904054,
0.6754767299,
0.2826187611,
0.132617563,
-0.1658281535,
0.5093827844,
-0.1723784655,
-0.2403027564,
-0.3193096817,
-0.2998755574,
-0.8348689079,
0.4968598485,
-0.3773238063,
-0.6450123191,
0.1783684194,
0.4765629768,
-0.3190064728,
0.5000556111,
-0.4842011631,
0.7190514207,
0.0909027383,
0.1083251163,
-0.0657927096,
-0.4936830103,
0.3317432702,
-0.0733446628,
0.2154260129,
-0.358061552,
-0.2960823476,
0.6393395066,
-0.5133853555,
0.3919743001,
-0.1626995802,
0.0833804756,
0.0277432278,
-0.0897321925,
0.2089003623,
0.1592465043,
-0.0741457567,
0.5446189642,
-0.0175728947,
-0.4613495469,
-0.3483265042,
0.6322495341,
-0.4641629457,
-0.1260477602,
-0.6618439555,
-0.6919904947,
-0.3107984066,
0.1607796401,
0.1622861624,
0.7532891631,
-0.351141721,
0.0139873167,
0.2845100164,
-0.3476617038,
0.6693432927,
0.6607988477,
-0.3274537921,
-0.5100620389,
0.9478678703,
0.2982004881,
0.4502938092,
0.3924134672,
0.0366895609,
0.0210412294,
-0.7216850519,
-0.7081273198,
0.0434444956,
-0.5951151848,
-0.0880937874,
-0.7193912864,
-0.1899239868,
-0.6516751051,
-0.1671694517,
-0.5153002739,
-0.8743827939,
0.2053709775,
0.0994851962,
-0.0734324083,
0.5095095038,
-0.1804388314,
0.0911758393,
-0.8934524655,
0.7266954184,
-0.0506294891,
0.7904316783,
-0.0213111714,
-0.1495973021,
-0.3325106502,
-0.1574273556,
-0.5578637123,
-0.5992410183,
0.128054291,
0.2487653941,
0.4940304458,
0.3776344955,
0.3115705848,
0.2311915457,
-0.1719783247,
0.9962649941,
0.0004222807,
-0.6626168489,
0.7162228227,
-0.3871923983,
0.742726624,
0.8085200787,
0.246326834,
-0.7454276681,
-0.7383714318,
-0.6004027128,
-1.0907642841,
0.6565538049,
0.3603612185,
-0.3920339942,
0.1218460873,
0.1385194063,
0.4565409124,
0.4499181509,
-0.365860194,
-0.2279476821,
-0.2759286165,
-0.2993963063,
-0.1927778572,
0.0682569593,
-0.0773106441,
0.3653090596,
0.6864882112,
-0.2136171162,
0.1762362123,
0.3597199321,
0.0302149877,
-0.0278670881,
0.2792772651,
0.7528556585,
0.8647378683,
-0.496789366,
0.0914217383,
-0.2216827124,
-0.6615508199,
-0.0985345244,
0.6267901659,
-0.5098131895,
0.0704265237,
0.6431306601,
0.5952662826,
-0.028103739,
-0.7117785215,
0.5655614734,
-0.1440654248,
0.0213405266,
-0.0991927981,
-0.0218944587,
-0.2620754242,
0.1683063209,
0.3965905607,
0.0498019606,
0.2249723673,
-0.6325410604,
-0.0385057852,
0.1598617882,
-0.3994753361,
-0.2825363576,
0.7694962621,
0.4543941319,
-0.3416820168,
0.1035636589,
-0.0061407471,
0.0464695618,
0.4345006645,
0.0719787702,
0.9842725992,
-0.0760112405,
0.1174197719,
0.2832739353,
0.3340021968,
-0.1476012319,
0.398815304,
-0.1506106257,
-0.2177155167,
-0.3414169848,
-0.6203891635,
-0.9856581688,
0.1112003773,
-0.802508533,
0.0465146489,
-0.403729111,
0.1624628007,
0.3209841549,
-0.2869298458,
-0.3499146104,
0.1505749822,
-0.1558278501,
1.1516925097,
-0.8854368925,
0.4335440695,
0.738304913,
-0.8561751246,
0.0456983298,
0.1734625101,
0.1793163568,
-0.3484545648,
-0.2990193069,
0.3509390354,
0.2377585322,
-0.6180782318,
-0.0860714018,
-0.7040920854,
0.8328272104,
-0.009584167,
-0.3195859194,
-0.1800580919,
0.3377751112,
0.3092975318,
-0.3514324725,
0.2452189177,
0.4764330089,
0.2741516232,
-0.3160736263,
-1.0608273745,
-0.0456196219,
-0.192832157,
-0.2166050971,
0.6718075275,
-0.7847955227,
0.9755971432,
-0.0782111958,
0.0428406782,
0.0367930196,
1.2183986902,
0.0745136216,
0.7791107893,
0.3401191533,
0.5028280616,
0.3661124706,
-0.2264849544,
0.9574571848,
-0.2119139135,
0.134601146,
1.5770543814,
-0.1204192266,
1.0689860582,
0.3122878671,
-0.1554080248,
-0.019015668,
0.3943663239,
0.2686739564,
0.5049452782,
-0.1044041365,
-0.1906661242,
0.1611227542,
-0.1139470413,
-0.5084778666,
0.260111779,
0.1263315231,
-0.2954830229,
-0.4892583191,
0.0008969229,
-0.0434432104,
0.247434631,
-0.3481627405,
0.9898192286,
-0.0846430063,
-0.7453948259,
-0.2245688885,
0.2110291868,
0.490196377,
-0.8272992969,
-0.0842273384,
-0.3573376834,
0.0116461152,
-0.1408518702,
-1.0880429745,
0.4278728962,
0.0642887726,
-0.084376961,
-0.0961262137,
0.3922910988,
-0.3995637298,
-0.2442404926,
-0.275544405,
0.3599738181,
0.1645041257,
-0.5076420307,
-0.0905558839,
-0.022379294,
-0.476318121,
-0.3317963481,
0.6944832206,
0.4708425105,
0.0376139842,
0.4095673561,
0.4760876,
0.3317898512,
-0.5353332758,
0.0660463125,
0.6549808979,
-0.6603147388,
-0.8856437206,
-0.3716753721,
0.5413461328,
-0.3727292717,
-0.9315863252,
0.6187676787,
1.0253263712,
0.769700408,
0.2982317805,
0.926071167,
-0.0667936727,
0.8091853261,
-0.5722895861,
0.6930722594,
-0.4563557804,
0.1178098395,
-0.3818046749,
-0.9237729311,
-0.1577180177,
0.1904769838,
-0.0212143417,
-0.1078245193,
0.6149889827,
0.2566825747,
-0.2649932206,
0.3158232272,
0.0092440424,
-0.1635290086,
0.6533567905,
0.3586318791,
0.2527252436,
-0.2876431346,
0.3320880532,
-0.6090297699,
-0.6320448518,
-0.1535369009,
-1.0067905188,
-0.7168788314,
-0.9786729813,
-0.3591593802,
-0.2747858763,
0.0481305309,
0.8884207606,
0.5112339854,
-0.7046085,
-0.0559181049,
0.2956198454,
-0.268858999,
-0.752912879,
-0.132455036,
0.5201945901,
-0.1293315291,
-0.4571708739,
0.2796255946,
0.6527410746,
0.2370150983,
-0.4501062036,
0.2220176607,
0.0314047523,
0.2800368369,
0.4984968901,
0.6196430922,
-0.4944759011,
-0.2997367978,
-0.5061574578,
0.0953289047,
0.2017660588,
0.9034472704,
-0.3943569362,
0.4903849661,
0.4493390322,
0.5489906669,
0.5881550908,
0.2484190762,
0.7245023251,
-0.9671196342,
0.0548906699,
0.0306508504,
0.3246843815,
0.2585652471,
-0.0349622294,
0.5252822638,
-0.1032001078,
-0.2738011777,
-0.7745822072,
0.090200603,
-1.0041116476,
-0.1751867384,
0.7711330652,
-0.4197733104,
0.0581479743,
-0.1003708541,
-0.1283072233,
0.0312877893,
-0.6801381707,
0.8718219399,
0.6018368006,
-0.5027376413,
0.0019106329,
-0.5011709332,
0.2600545287,
0.0750956908,
-1.4509997368,
0.4973079264,
0.7695798278,
-0.3152444065,
0.2676602602,
0.8086596727,
-0.1533100158,
0.3452169597,
0.2012533695,
0.1612330675,
-0.6172224879,
-0.679101944,
-0.2923404276,
0.806568861,
-0.0391853787,
-0.5355198383
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04372v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04372v2
|
LaMPilot: An Open Benchmark Dataset for Autonomous Driving with Language Model Programs
| 2023-12-07T15:43:52 | 2024-04-04T05:20:11 |
Yunsheng Ma, Can Cui, Xu Cao, Wenqian Ye, Peiran Liu, Juanwu Lu, Amr Abdelraouf, Rohit Gupta, Kyungtae Han, Aniket Bera, James M. Rehg, Ziran Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Autonomous driving (AD) has made significant strides in recent years.
However, existing frameworks struggle to interpret and execute spontaneous user
instructions, such as "overtake the car ahead." Large Language Models (LLMs)
have demonstrated impressive reasoning capabilities showing potential to bridge
this gap. In this paper, we present LaMPilot, a novel framework that integrates
LLMs into AD systems, enabling them to follow user instructions by generating
code that leverages established functional primitives. We also introduce
LaMPilot-Bench, the first benchmark dataset specifically designed to
quantitatively evaluate the efficacy of language model programs in AD. Adopting
the LaMPilot framework, we conduct extensive experiments to assess the
performance of off-the-shelf LLMs on LaMPilot-Bench. Our results demonstrate
the potential of LLMs in handling diverse driving scenarios and following user
instructions in driving. To facilitate further research in this area, we
release our code and data at https://github.com/PurdueDigitalTwin/LaMPilot.
|
[
-0.2465216964,
-0.5448206067,
1.0035104752,
0.2999325693,
0.012856409,
-0.1532490104,
-0.4123849273,
-0.5123179555,
-0.3042445183,
0.1978255659,
-0.5420360565,
-0.5256953239,
-0.0204240941,
-0.2486670315,
-0.6118139029,
0.6100822091,
-0.1477219313,
0.1097464785,
-0.3196999729,
0.0165036395,
-0.3407557011,
-0.2399390638,
-0.1023685932,
-0.3045611978,
0.5169163346,
0.1647231877,
0.9449025989,
0.7929602861,
0.4524118304,
0.2902894914,
0.4920355082,
-0.113783285,
-0.2056984007,
-0.0731568709,
-0.3605599999,
-0.0457735956,
-0.4115546644,
-0.1259287,
0.6628239155,
0.8179801702,
-0.2375213653,
-0.209736973,
-0.2888330817,
0.13479352,
-0.7366454601,
0.3772038817,
-0.3337564766,
-0.3308993876,
-0.1838924885,
-0.0635501146,
-0.2863769233,
-0.8817180991,
0.0446712784,
-0.6113293767,
-0.1602062583,
0.0149737094,
0.6055603027,
0.3192644417,
-0.430257827,
-0.3410028219,
-0.787615478,
0.7309222817,
-0.761215806,
0.3084406257,
0.1054359376,
0.4862668812,
-0.1715225726,
-0.5405223966,
-0.6791083217,
-0.3844994605,
-0.0531188324,
-0.1330097616,
-0.0922949016,
0.1145883799,
0.022746291,
0.2593090236,
-0.9281214476,
0.3355917633,
-0.2459266633,
0.2118998319,
0.5634205341,
0.2645053566,
0.2349784225,
0.2426840067,
-0.8853935599,
-0.3537960351,
-0.9416776299,
0.0895021781,
0.083229661,
0.2304234058,
-0.0214378405,
0.3578283489,
-0.3679995537,
1.0688484907,
-0.6353204846,
0.2626079917,
0.3985690475,
-0.0243051592,
-0.2747390866,
-0.0550314076,
0.8284382224,
0.3442014456,
0.3516635001,
-0.2968985736,
-0.7379552722,
0.2618491352,
-0.0071563264,
-0.6073646545,
-0.4125446379,
0.1803335994,
-0.0380482972,
-0.0966098607,
0.1755675226,
-0.6548700929,
-0.3722289205,
-0.5114215612,
0.4129164517,
-0.5229156017,
-0.2481997311,
0.5531897545,
0.3484289348,
0.6231181622,
0.436216861,
-1.0156339407,
0.6441956162,
1.0168296099,
0.7250116467,
-0.5106893182,
-0.4421322644,
-0.4970142841,
0.2993411124,
-0.3280639648,
1.1007267237,
-0.2340832204,
-0.4388816059,
0.0527423993,
-0.2256037444,
-0.17574054,
-0.4653042853,
0.3505745828,
-0.5010965466,
0.0423966609,
-0.0337884724,
-0.6179510951,
-0.4077898264,
0.0743271783,
-0.5448487401,
0.9531968832,
0.1178545207,
0.0675301328,
0.1955034286,
-0.7659626603,
-0.7605093718,
0.2706600428,
-0.5472576022,
-0.0628586709,
0.0516237728,
0.1058776677,
0.3564555943,
-0.4786272943,
0.324053973,
-0.3496441245,
-0.3631802499,
0.4480323195,
-0.4560557306,
0.9221224189,
-0.0793657601,
-0.2248654664,
0.3520151675,
-0.6051647663,
0.2012979388,
0.0398132391,
-0.3639856577,
-0.2174690813,
-0.0020130691,
0.5610920787,
0.125529021,
0.333283782,
-0.6602733731,
0.3078674376,
-0.1778450906,
0.0211359076,
1.1603486538,
-0.3573590815,
0.0494486764,
-0.3801763654,
0.688174963,
-0.6721488833,
-0.0671190321,
-0.4037353396,
-0.4047429562,
-0.5520439744,
-0.2222085595,
0.0575589389,
0.6464582682,
-0.3720267117,
0.3467422426,
-0.3936384022,
-0.3316752911,
-0.3562033474,
0.1817600131,
0.4260000587,
0.2655932009,
0.2826417983,
-0.0792885125,
-0.1489019394,
-0.6527750492,
-0.0692068413,
-0.2158531696,
-0.1468043178,
0.3865164816,
0.3988342583,
-0.2075791806,
1.1220561266,
-0.692905426,
-0.2728372812,
-0.1753977537,
0.2026670724,
0.0567648709,
0.522397697,
0.755417347,
-0.5747749209,
-0.444293946,
0.1887365133,
-0.8372064233,
-0.4482018054,
-0.1616313457,
0.2167819291,
-0.0188027509,
0.5384322405,
-0.7429766059,
0.2902834117,
0.6591342688,
-0.393630147,
0.5954366326,
-0.3784461021,
0.0056470055,
-0.3399165571,
0.2668475509,
-0.2036803663,
-0.5590656996,
-0.3895778358,
-0.0187944435,
0.0567420572,
-0.0649058819,
-0.4163458347,
0.5019907355,
-0.3678506315,
-0.5177438855,
-0.4195360839,
0.2344541699,
-0.3382580578,
0.2144729197,
0.2123238891,
0.9905663729,
0.891906321,
-0.5042392612,
0.7160694599,
-0.016031282,
-0.7562912703,
0.4403277338,
-0.7471631765,
0.02413694,
-0.0179871563,
-0.0365974568,
-1.1537280083,
-0.2852404714,
-0.2392233163,
0.0198099352,
-0.0846388489,
0.2302535623,
-0.9194923043,
-0.1176247522,
0.1184116229,
0.3662548065,
0.6685020328,
-0.6604109406,
0.435816139,
0.3728188574,
-0.0568523556,
0.03914636,
-0.4088837504,
0.0494521335,
-0.0509973913,
-0.6652094722,
0.311735481,
-0.0958873853,
-0.3785099983,
0.0111075388,
0.1635023803,
-0.0372861698,
0.0238345265,
0.2155177146,
0.2242794931,
-0.3746779263,
0.3274492919,
-0.4399297833,
-0.4401989579,
0.2490092665,
-0.1689756513,
0.6202107072,
-0.3254539967,
-0.4745171666,
-0.5541989803,
0.1910038441,
0.5000619888,
-0.4770139754,
0.224445954,
0.2936009467,
0.0237243827,
-0.4898797572,
-0.2175135911,
-0.2657254636,
-0.5765832067,
0.2528782487,
-0.4125781059,
-0.2816724479,
0.0877371132,
-0.4401453137,
0.1980252415,
-0.1448466331,
0.5651182532,
-0.2254178226,
0.8490930796,
0.6647502184,
-0.0097168181,
0.6007319689,
0.0186650474,
-0.1037989631,
-0.1969298273,
-0.0314595997,
-0.0492425784,
-0.2042473406,
-0.3492944241,
-0.6897624135,
0.4791473746,
-0.4436894953,
-0.0081396159,
0.3510276377,
-0.0383897275,
0.6757209301,
0.4907805026,
-0.0149533078,
0.4605620503,
-0.4415095747,
0.1538373977,
0.2695016265,
-0.6765908003,
-0.3872763216,
0.890634656,
0.1139920726,
1.2219030857,
0.3076286912,
0.3370479643,
0.3270111084,
0.5082440376,
-0.4990643859,
0.9097838402,
-0.0405480787,
-0.4637662172,
-0.1903644651,
-0.4007796347,
-0.9083381295,
0.2497230172,
0.2630902827,
-0.8596758246,
0.0958837867,
0.0934109464,
-0.5975571275,
0.0256067682,
-0.5871583223,
1.1607055664,
-0.8506103754,
-0.4506193995,
-0.297408998,
-0.4375571907,
0.4585776329,
0.0322939679,
0.3128401339,
-0.5034321547,
-0.1560189277,
0.3239962757,
-0.3378285766,
0.7358630896,
-0.1740399152,
-0.2397642285,
-0.0017353676,
0.1636704654,
0.4018364251,
-0.1736968756,
-0.012430991,
-0.1846384257,
-0.1479518563,
-0.3320281804,
-0.7177380323,
1.0326892138,
-0.4238645136,
-0.3959137201,
-0.5513466597,
-0.7429053783,
-0.1424914747,
0.2621852458,
-0.2775619924,
0.2891994715,
-0.4536478221,
0.1365379691,
0.7667089701,
-0.246960327,
0.6208903193,
0.7471762896,
-0.87301898,
-0.0194217283,
0.8451836705,
-0.2027604282,
0.5510379672,
0.2726337016,
0.1312523186,
-0.4092990756,
-0.3291125894,
-0.7599805593,
0.0529632643,
-0.7384172082,
-0.0664468482,
-0.2843578458,
0.211294502,
-0.1474135071,
-0.2297016233,
-0.6575722694,
-0.3882136047,
0.1294537038,
-0.0462442711,
0.442117542,
0.9473320842,
-0.0712284744,
0.6261612773,
-0.0658964291,
0.2880383432,
0.4377451241,
0.5480334759,
-0.1417708248,
0.1271475852,
-0.118189685,
-0.2546899021,
-0.0922454894,
-0.7412273288,
0.1205622256,
-0.0929717198,
0.623414278,
0.5571209788,
0.1770480275,
0.4361636937,
-0.3696464896,
0.3426772654,
0.0958339348,
-0.811861515,
0.43790555,
-0.6090395451,
0.5668406487,
0.4689574242,
0.1732980907,
-0.311924994,
-0.1745229959,
-0.0447330363,
-0.8640373349,
0.5134593844,
0.1551711708,
-0.1609239131,
0.3541424572,
-0.0968651846,
0.0838809088,
0.1559940428,
-0.9467889667,
-0.0147225289,
0.1194847673,
-0.2565290034,
-0.3626737595,
0.3970966935,
0.0042389762,
-0.1861483604,
0.3934177756,
-0.0369252227,
-0.0526407883,
-0.1472718865,
-0.2078542411,
-0.0049812621,
-0.0050441679,
0.5781214833,
0.7468960881,
-0.3774232268,
0.1904001534,
-0.1816761345,
-0.1173889488,
0.1266141832,
0.3623536229,
-0.4705977738,
-0.021821091,
0.1465732753,
0.4842009544,
0.5038970113,
-1.2524206638,
0.6344283223,
0.1318765581,
0.314206183,
-0.6006156802,
0.3909896314,
-0.0978492945,
-0.032462094,
0.3623510897,
-0.0781340748,
0.0370279849,
-0.5373161435,
0.4500902891,
0.4924389422,
-0.4656423628,
-0.2557505369,
0.8408257961,
0.2041987032,
-0.1994230002,
0.3186636269,
-0.1220368221,
-0.2719582021,
0.4729172885,
0.2736001015,
0.7477246523,
-0.3346017897,
-0.0181275532,
0.0392972715,
0.3207165599,
-0.0951859429,
0.3692763448,
-0.0762350038,
-0.473079294,
-0.4472012818,
-0.4607049227,
-0.3551388085,
-0.0300752781,
-0.3724499941,
0.2623806298,
-0.5841080546,
0.0817474574,
0.040617507,
-0.3997333646,
-0.5949454308,
0.0690450445,
0.0576176979,
0.9418711662,
-0.7913089991,
1.1205989122,
0.6890056729,
-0.3442046046,
-0.2185451239,
0.0232292339,
0.2244758755,
-0.705337584,
0.4489701092,
0.3764797747,
-0.5416570902,
0.0719702244,
-0.3663757145,
-0.6636511087,
1.0617326498,
0.2741663456,
-0.3682927489,
0.1339128017,
0.3480434716,
0.3123226464,
-0.5466617346,
0.0050275852,
0.6315435767,
0.6071721911,
-0.0254386645,
-0.9219700098,
0.101147525,
0.0711017549,
-0.1025452241,
-0.0410512984,
-0.475278616,
1.0247825384,
-0.2345039994,
-0.1043973267,
0.5691695809,
0.4823589325,
0.2765984535,
0.110990651,
0.5346924663,
0.3920189142,
0.4706200063,
-0.0990372673,
1.109577179,
-0.3415617943,
0.199699536,
1.2230850458,
-0.5618457794,
0.9260929227,
0.4054301977,
-0.1618424952,
0.6997218132,
0.2087499052,
-0.1190244034,
0.7787992358,
0.2602962255,
-0.514272511,
-0.3950189352,
0.0221165493,
-0.242012307,
0.539862752,
0.3238477707,
-0.2886293828,
-0.5222861171,
0.1613317728,
-0.1594798863,
0.3449518383,
-0.0495995693,
0.8223310709,
-0.0902402177,
-0.653852582,
0.5662894845,
0.0837581009,
0.3286626339,
-0.6727499962,
-0.0700155795,
-0.1125105098,
0.7439174652,
0.074963741,
-0.9577009082,
-0.1380707771,
-0.1547735035,
0.1383516937,
-0.7040531039,
0.254668206,
-0.3137819469,
-0.4880902171,
0.3043013513,
0.5965598226,
0.3024767637,
0.14995116,
-0.3326131999,
0.3536401987,
-0.0739465654,
-0.1780850291,
0.1409084648,
0.3772038817,
0.0700099468,
0.975564301,
0.5495926738,
0.0640366375,
0.0944773629,
-0.2184873521,
0.9242324233,
-0.7057855725,
-0.6196135879,
-0.7848773003,
0.4192683101,
-0.0093924897,
-0.4565219879,
0.9265424609,
1.0496362448,
0.6973563433,
-0.0922130868,
0.7530302405,
-0.1370413452,
0.5878552198,
-0.6326053739,
0.5837396383,
-0.3719649613,
0.6097429395,
-0.0727272555,
-0.732707262,
-0.2934705019,
0.8400030732,
-0.6643326879,
0.1169294193,
0.1835505515,
1.0296595097,
-0.6179619431,
-0.0218776371,
0.392680347,
0.138965264,
0.4585710764,
0.8307448626,
0.8592069745,
-0.1025694013,
0.5092923641,
-0.1844295412,
-0.5111432076,
-0.2950486541,
-0.7846138477,
-0.7461072206,
-0.3061052263,
-0.1376264691,
0.1548439711,
0.3116992414,
0.854459703,
0.9577075839,
-0.764996171,
-0.7933400273,
-0.4728322327,
0.1275831163,
-0.4515147805,
-0.2172424495,
0.2865687311,
-0.2782390416,
-0.6635348201,
0.7543826699,
0.1894848049,
0.2846076488,
-0.8273543715,
-0.2872653306,
-0.1823764145,
-0.0612075105,
0.3576018214,
0.357293874,
-0.6345107555,
0.0369441546,
-0.1574968249,
-0.3067910969,
0.0785618648,
1.1004729271,
-1.1163005829,
0.4543557465,
0.2493913323,
0.369679302,
0.5280975103,
0.2090213597,
1.0323842764,
-0.4950457811,
0.1971988529,
0.3596496284,
0.1680124104,
0.4258567393,
0.1422665417,
0.5537807345,
0.1117345467,
-0.5462363958,
-0.8327569962,
0.3802813888,
-0.8286772966,
-0.5986639261,
1.1628712416,
-0.2513804436,
-0.2196797431,
-0.1212203056,
-0.0838375539,
-0.457006216,
-0.5502784848,
0.7901982665,
0.1407365948,
-0.366913259,
-0.5312401056,
-1.0099067688,
0.5571435094,
0.3002340496,
-1.0200144053,
0.5904675722,
0.7208943963,
0.0486257076,
-0.1204740107,
0.5098062754,
0.2118971348,
0.6224431396,
0.0115964096,
0.0582783446,
-0.0142539404,
-0.2203922719,
-0.3254561424,
-0.0041209217,
0.0361222997,
-0.1184224412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04362v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04362v1
|
PCoQA: Persian Conversational Question Answering Dataset
| 2023-12-07T15:29:34 | 2023-12-07T15:29:34 |
Hamed Hematian Hemati, Atousa Toghyani, Atena Souri, Sayed Hesam Alavian, Hossein Sameti, Hamid Beigy
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humans seek information regarding a specific topic through performing a
conversation containing a series of questions and answers. In the pursuit of
conversational question answering research, we introduce the PCoQA, the first
\textbf{P}ersian \textbf{Co}nversational \textbf{Q}uestion \textbf{A}nswering
dataset, a resource comprising information-seeking dialogs encompassing a total
of 9,026 contextually-driven questions. Each dialog involves a questioner, a
responder, and a document from the Wikipedia; The questioner asks several
inter-connected questions from the text and the responder provides a span of
the document as the answer for each question. PCoQA is designed to present
novel challenges compared to previous question answering datasets including
having more open-ended non-factual answers, longer answers, and fewer lexical
overlaps. This paper not only presents the comprehensive PCoQA dataset but also
reports the performance of various benchmark models. Our models include
baseline models and pre-trained models, which are leveraged to boost the
performance of the model. The dataset and benchmarks are available at our
Github page.
|
[
-0.5328838229,
-1.0415322781,
0.5749752522,
-0.1014551744,
-0.1830966324,
0.2721458077,
-0.0900132209,
-0.0940821543,
-0.1419537216,
0.5077475905,
-0.8489916325,
-0.3651301861,
-0.0839154273,
0.0587004088,
-0.256839931,
0.6217131615,
0.2850141823,
0.0313506909,
-0.2711091638,
0.2613374889,
-0.446793884,
-0.763663888,
-0.5284135342,
0.0812489614,
0.3470405042,
0.9790870547,
0.9814158082,
0.3423154354,
0.3870991468,
0.2312560081,
0.0035093133,
0.0246237535,
-0.7010043859,
-0.0797975361,
0.0095481891,
-0.4271365404,
-0.2240357995,
0.1055990905,
0.5628938675,
0.9291414618,
-0.4552890658,
0.4182476401,
-0.1495056897,
0.5054484606,
-0.6675884724,
-0.3472227752,
-0.5684168339,
0.0725778416,
-0.2069858313,
-0.1052261069,
-0.2563172579,
-0.5376113653,
0.3743267357,
-0.9014773965,
0.0925291777,
0.0989822969,
0.75320822,
0.0559629202,
-0.6166523099,
-0.4060545862,
-0.5321100354,
0.8540278673,
-0.4781547785,
0.3683899343,
0.5360754132,
0.4570387006,
-0.3222611248,
-0.6487763524,
-0.7667729855,
-0.1914123297,
0.1428311616,
0.2461571097,
-0.2100870311,
-0.198010534,
0.0429980904,
0.6864356399,
-0.7225086689,
-0.2902621925,
-0.4554237127,
-0.0108267125,
0.5267332792,
0.3720913231,
0.4101617038,
-0.2138944864,
-0.5859177709,
-0.2950407267,
-0.5169568658,
0.4313668609,
0.2852342129,
0.1098828837,
-0.0908334553,
0.4519682229,
-0.6895058155,
0.7502865195,
0.2521074116,
0.0854556561,
0.1019357368,
-0.4221537113,
-0.1232262105,
-0.0079363342,
0.8461066484,
0.191476047,
0.0863284767,
-0.1774532348,
0.4738012552,
-0.2430674583,
0.4071359038,
-0.6206816435,
-0.3462989628,
0.3944993317,
-0.4416850805,
-0.040111661,
0.1566668451,
-0.7750450969,
-0.1799912602,
-0.3526569605,
0.2291525751,
-0.4053588808,
-0.225635767,
0.0982745141,
-0.1581783593,
0.5692589283,
0.5053461194,
-0.38928774,
0.6587880254,
0.557336092,
0.6432251334,
-0.2196242064,
0.0451714136,
-0.3929560781,
-0.2381663322,
-0.5303311348,
0.7591432333,
-0.6611126661,
-0.4681706727,
-0.2849386334,
0.0765322894,
-0.1661476642,
-0.4767001867,
0.7869411111,
-0.6433168054,
0.6081468463,
-0.7400000095,
-0.3295535445,
-0.3090524077,
0.40473634,
-0.4370521605,
1.1264326572,
0.0079119112,
-0.8230332732,
-0.0837549269,
-0.445761919,
0.1863250732,
0.1536671519,
-0.2152312696,
0.0083510727,
0.0226920918,
0.207152918,
0.1777653694,
-0.9636676311,
0.2834957242,
-0.0827292353,
-0.4067396522,
0.5397083163,
-0.3594784439,
0.8775653839,
0.4300364256,
-0.1461404711,
-0.0917760208,
-0.8754783273,
0.4112956822,
0.0664189756,
-0.265632987,
-0.250813812,
0.1664180458,
0.121626161,
0.401684165,
0.3047600985,
-0.8340895176,
-0.1081570089,
-0.1587086767,
0.2671307027,
0.5679345727,
0.225724861,
0.1012876481,
-0.5416023731,
0.8854273558,
-0.2199523896,
0.3463084996,
-0.1546328068,
-0.5190716386,
-0.5442593098,
-0.0910417363,
0.0864415541,
0.8731389046,
-0.949968338,
0.0454564244,
-0.077238366,
-0.7563403249,
-0.1216386929,
-0.0786373615,
0.494250834,
0.8358877301,
0.2203829288,
-0.4398646057,
-0.2253747433,
-0.9837625027,
-0.0526947826,
-0.3570945859,
-0.1237887144,
0.6815158725,
0.2309062034,
0.4078769982,
0.7529999614,
-0.5611399412,
0.1617105305,
-0.1324773878,
0.1104275957,
0.3693393469,
0.2117017508,
0.3002851009,
-1.0170747042,
-0.6980561018,
-0.0313356183,
-0.6080145836,
-0.0482399352,
-0.147501111,
-0.5001941323,
-0.4147771895,
0.575388968,
-0.3230575621,
0.3611853421,
0.5537948012,
-0.2707836628,
0.5968911648,
0.1669551432,
0.4740083516,
-1.3927189112,
0.5134503841,
-0.3030758798,
-0.0911968052,
-0.8935505748,
0.061501801,
-0.165046677,
-0.3511841595,
-0.6563659906,
0.2876452506,
-0.3403202593,
0.1980518103,
-0.1156950593,
0.1621269733,
-0.0767786056,
0.7327112556,
0.2119118422,
1.2992725372,
0.4303268194,
-0.5934773684,
0.441100657,
0.7828810215,
-0.254114151,
0.5912855268,
-1.0072164536,
0.4495388269,
-0.0578527972,
0.084340319,
-1.0859410763,
-0.143702209,
0.3291857243,
-0.613181293,
-0.4610284865,
0.0537920818,
-0.4230362773,
-0.2335398942,
-0.2522937357,
0.6535816789,
0.2253147513,
-0.4326035678,
0.3099365234,
0.476811707,
-0.5593075752,
-0.5717333555,
-0.1269795746,
0.2178139538,
-0.1374521255,
-0.3868997395,
0.3016114235,
-0.3026333451,
-0.2174294442,
-0.2524035275,
0.1005268991,
-0.5467486978,
0.0153480517,
0.3645586371,
0.2306448817,
-0.2728578448,
0.2817100883,
-0.3068227768,
0.1762404293,
0.1425257474,
0.0354090817,
0.7496839166,
-0.1932155341,
-0.0998356417,
-0.7140621543,
0.6913245916,
0.3616953194,
-0.1659728885,
0.7107673287,
0.1337041706,
-0.1609427482,
0.3605746329,
-0.5176565051,
0.0977548361,
-0.4670292139,
0.2011287212,
-0.5061840415,
-0.8276644945,
0.5253309011,
-0.109238863,
-0.2756544948,
0.3591844738,
0.416467756,
-0.0631039366,
0.872964263,
0.4900794029,
-0.2184426188,
0.2650058568,
0.1497681439,
0.0233105067,
-0.7009430528,
-0.3399529457,
-0.768951416,
0.1809332073,
-0.6915541887,
-0.5670016408,
0.5284977555,
0.0948304757,
-0.3806395829,
0.1826263219,
-0.357544601,
0.5160635114,
0.8235676885,
0.2415122241,
0.3079119921,
-0.0404433832,
-0.0728146955,
0.1748722047,
-0.8705707192,
-0.4940407276,
1.1142860651,
0.1111908704,
0.4389113188,
0.4040427804,
0.2183349878,
0.2905384302,
-0.2414201349,
-0.6059778333,
0.5336156487,
0.047006797,
-0.7181019187,
-0.4484651387,
-0.6340963244,
-0.8946834803,
0.0038839867,
-0.2222552001,
-0.7724205852,
0.5804304481,
0.1540772617,
-0.5190269947,
0.0484512709,
-0.2431582808,
0.9194256067,
-0.2746444345,
-0.4594306052,
-0.125271365,
-0.7168083191,
0.2697624564,
0.0681262463,
0.0024365708,
-0.1081240922,
0.194264859,
0.6630654931,
-0.5116101503,
0.5053464174,
-0.0284693092,
0.1733414233,
0.5961816311,
-0.0188238919,
0.0412759818,
0.1455738544,
-0.0588581972,
0.0630938187,
0.4669616818,
-0.7957063317,
-0.1644316465,
0.3877744675,
-0.8976649046,
-0.6527078748,
-0.6696617007,
-0.4099148214,
-0.4740079939,
0.1135726944,
0.232659772,
0.3473393619,
-0.6686457992,
0.4037611187,
0.8742996454,
-0.7197518349,
0.0668108836,
0.358025521,
-0.0000410823,
-0.3932908177,
0.5289164782,
-0.4368672073,
0.4157441854,
0.5226739645,
-0.1205856502,
-0.1903215796,
-0.2413333207,
-0.4956325889,
0.0730377957,
-0.4015392959,
-0.0921676904,
-0.4042932391,
-0.2657651007,
-0.1523635238,
0.3415597081,
-0.3908278346,
-0.4899820089,
-0.1460630298,
0.3131034374,
0.1463086754,
0.641245544,
0.317606777,
0.489592433,
-0.6159462929,
0.624093771,
0.7215108871,
0.2555671632,
-0.1070541367,
-0.4189637005,
-0.0629427433,
0.193231672,
-0.5104922056,
-1.211152792,
0.3017758131,
0.3594988286,
0.5957330465,
0.2049190253,
0.2435880154,
0.6468434334,
-0.3593471348,
0.8391567469,
0.0262768827,
-0.9422430396,
0.6961816549,
-0.6786039472,
0.5305467844,
0.9460071325,
0.8607339263,
-0.9041918516,
0.0889178365,
-0.3842530549,
-0.7198681235,
0.770647645,
0.3531525433,
-0.0082803704,
-0.1101437658,
0.5885176063,
0.0076622735,
0.4137578309,
-0.3567804694,
-0.0868648514,
-0.1949166507,
-0.001070846,
-0.14136675,
-0.2563523352,
0.133662343,
-0.0533288978,
0.7810153961,
-0.1815314889,
0.3128753006,
0.5017722249,
-0.0262644105,
0.0135122864,
0.4996144176,
0.3325430751,
0.7417663932,
-0.4354459345,
-0.2989836633,
0.0114535093,
-0.5938377976,
-0.061779771,
0.0322776288,
0.0475259013,
-0.2548242211,
-0.1608851701,
0.5091132522,
-0.2586463988,
-1.1328954697,
0.4516705275,
-0.6182892919,
-0.1942490041,
-0.680980742,
-0.006128137,
-0.1024345383,
-0.0261228997,
0.6161102653,
-0.4073766768,
0.58877635,
-0.9399896264,
0.0899075866,
0.4329353869,
-0.489025563,
-0.1283251494,
0.5140509605,
0.0648305342,
-0.0722773299,
0.9677658677,
0.043793302,
-0.6969565749,
0.5926498175,
0.1108664945,
0.345969528,
-0.263771534,
0.5558262467,
0.5516955853,
0.0503905825,
0.2482233793,
0.6772994399,
-0.4684915841,
-0.5631702542,
-0.2218525559,
-0.4159635007,
-0.8968210816,
0.1875710934,
-1.0410163403,
-0.123096101,
-0.53536129,
-0.0604212023,
-0.0547185242,
0.2325274199,
-0.6122707129,
0.3991556466,
0.0863333493,
0.9476001263,
-0.6812976003,
0.6659722924,
0.6849637032,
-0.1588147283,
-0.6506568193,
0.0978607908,
0.1053472012,
-0.4988827705,
0.4029570818,
-0.1734471321,
-0.1352823079,
-0.1874446869,
-0.6287513971,
-1.1238645315,
1.090665102,
0.055175554,
-0.4426321983,
0.1850874126,
0.6454201341,
0.4643521905,
-0.334611088,
0.2114124894,
0.4765431881,
0.0019026583,
0.2131854147,
-1.1974473,
-0.0204451568,
-0.9309104681,
0.0261139628,
-0.0185467266,
-0.7775405049,
1.1213482618,
0.2094598711,
-0.2728753388,
0.6481106281,
0.295476228,
0.2959378064,
0.2969015539,
0.4218248725,
0.3980938494,
0.754390955,
-0.1176750064,
0.9864655733,
-0.3181323111,
-0.089402698,
1.4105552435,
-0.0560485758,
1.0785472393,
0.3833075166,
-0.1901026517,
0.5764194131,
0.8201412559,
0.2823549807,
0.406273365,
0.2475743294,
-0.2044942081,
-0.5034160018,
-0.4431659281,
-0.4637212455,
0.7728577256,
0.2865483165,
-0.1253804117,
0.105705075,
-0.1852632612,
-0.132053718,
0.333260417,
-0.2351404577,
0.9639743567,
-0.3165320158,
-0.7892985344,
0.5921059251,
-0.0864513814,
0.08183074,
-0.4113479555,
-0.2241816223,
-0.2591807544,
-0.1247066632,
0.1899505705,
-0.5351741314,
-0.0286614597,
0.0036369371,
-0.2643750906,
0.0585847087,
0.3631095886,
-0.1906096488,
-0.5601191521,
-0.2001149505,
0.7441897392,
0.2385738939,
-0.3098741472,
-0.760299921,
-0.1757007539,
-0.100478597,
0.124212265,
0.0499245785,
0.3917762041,
-0.2358739525,
0.5964193344,
0.6389788389,
-0.1468902528,
0.1226048023,
-0.2590481639,
0.9695925713,
-0.7744973898,
-0.6762105823,
-0.2009517998,
0.2641646266,
-0.2338551581,
-0.5504773259,
0.8496053815,
0.7400360703,
0.7267917395,
0.1336001754,
0.6751111746,
-0.0912005678,
1.0498825312,
-0.3530350924,
0.4108418524,
-0.3635101914,
0.1865421236,
-0.2093138993,
-0.7469286323,
0.1942551285,
0.459459424,
-0.3778609037,
-0.1008237228,
0.4287813008,
0.6777015924,
-0.0642009601,
0.4277402461,
0.2049124837,
0.2035594732,
-0.1103524342,
0.9279057384,
1.2774991989,
-0.7157981396,
0.4541060925,
-0.3725572526,
-0.2126395106,
0.0690618679,
-0.4970324039,
-0.8336705565,
-0.7834165692,
-0.1589961052,
0.0304834191,
0.4277019799,
0.9370590448,
0.8900454044,
-0.9385177493,
-0.5999497175,
-0.1420383751,
-0.1504881382,
-0.034156885,
-0.2440631539,
0.3140047193,
-0.0590646826,
-0.5779091716,
0.3498811424,
-0.1466832459,
-0.2336005569,
0.1794284135,
0.0275268257,
-0.5358544588,
0.3143388331,
0.2713033259,
0.5563021302,
-0.4651275575,
0.0049022119,
0.3692963123,
0.2356194407,
0.3118482232,
0.8323652148,
-0.9617145061,
0.4353924394,
0.2436242104,
0.6020047665,
0.4450035393,
0.3871375024,
0.7574025393,
-0.5351750851,
-0.0071291695,
0.1096896604,
-0.1335849017,
0.27593413,
-0.4803191423,
0.2994634807,
-0.2324164212,
-0.5720753074,
-0.5731227994,
0.117402032,
-1.1625219584,
-0.4023308456,
0.6284379363,
-0.1561384946,
-0.1504701972,
-0.3354834616,
-0.3988786042,
-0.0248823389,
-0.4035112858,
0.8340978622,
0.702060461,
-0.3074801564,
-0.463260442,
-0.6798006892,
0.528513968,
0.5578305721,
-1.1481124163,
-0.090151228,
0.7507062554,
0.193263635,
0.1411648691,
0.6642861962,
-0.1215913296,
0.896907568,
-0.1444111764,
-0.1558809876,
0.3210875392,
-0.3305827081,
-0.0857827291,
0.5190131068,
0.103739664,
-0.1822846979
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04350v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04350v3
|
CLadder: Assessing Causal Reasoning in Language Models
| 2023-12-07T15:12:12 | 2024-01-17T14:41:55 |
Zhijing Jin, Yuen Chen, Felix Leeb, Luigi Gresele, Ojasv Kamal, Zhiheng Lyu, Kevin Blin, Fernando Gonzalez Adauto, Max Kleiman-Weiner, Mrinmaya Sachan, Bernhard Schölkopf
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The ability to perform causal reasoning is widely considered a core feature
of intelligence. In this work, we investigate whether large language models
(LLMs) can coherently reason about causality. Much of the existing work in
natural language processing (NLP) focuses on evaluating commonsense causal
reasoning in LLMs, thus failing to assess whether a model can perform causal
inference in accordance with a set of well-defined formal rules. To address
this, we propose a new NLP task, causal inference in natural language, inspired
by the "causal inference engine" postulated by Judea Pearl et al. We compose a
large dataset, CLadder, with 10K samples: based on a collection of causal
graphs and queries (associational, interventional, and counterfactual), we
obtain symbolic questions and ground-truth answers, through an oracle causal
inference engine. These are then translated into natural language. We evaluate
multiple LLMs on our dataset, and we introduce and evaluate a bespoke
chain-of-thought prompting strategy, CausalCoT. We show that our task is highly
challenging for LLMs, and we conduct an in-depth analysis to gain deeper
insights into the causal reasoning abilities of LLMs. Our data is open-sourced
at https://huggingface.co/datasets/causalNLP/cladder, and our code can be found
at https://github.com/causalNLP/cladder.
|
[
-0.2266351879,
-0.9926089048,
0.779120028,
0.5575735569,
-0.1440834552,
-0.3473315537,
-0.2310011834,
-0.528400898,
-0.0116024651,
0.5597840548,
-0.63587749,
-0.311135143,
-0.467222333,
0.3815439641,
-0.3968101442,
0.6455389857,
0.0184881892,
0.0331295282,
-0.4599558115,
0.1218213588,
-0.8647370338,
0.0104227737,
-0.7608687878,
-0.5450985432,
0.9030474424,
0.3748782277,
0.6626501083,
0.6214787364,
0.6443379521,
0.4071961641,
0.1174354032,
0.2905448377,
-0.3726485074,
0.319041878,
-0.7259824872,
-0.3351574838,
-0.1767768264,
-0.1268613487,
0.5536426902,
0.8692299128,
0.2070335895,
0.0522423834,
-0.0492673405,
0.5561865568,
-0.6829271317,
0.3237738907,
-0.6503454447,
-0.2194199264,
-0.1813621819,
-0.3827748597,
-0.6640487909,
-0.198805213,
-0.0748189986,
-0.3785567284,
0.147779882,
0.5740868449,
0.6217607856,
0.5761386752,
-0.5947458148,
-0.2836932838,
-0.730096221,
0.7490077615,
-0.8675855994,
0.2258141339,
0.4634617567,
0.1798134148,
-0.3214633167,
-0.7098735571,
-0.7819688916,
-0.1096684486,
-0.1801008135,
0.1057670712,
-0.2393606752,
0.0222630911,
0.4864371121,
0.3268595934,
-0.7588266134,
0.3947885036,
-0.0075145387,
-0.0564732663,
0.7309158444,
0.2726016045,
0.4386319518,
-0.4105035365,
-0.3883913159,
0.0529105254,
-0.4336916208,
-0.2735740244,
0.1889782399,
0.2653369308,
-0.084405601,
0.7082582116,
-0.0289087668,
0.7215179801,
-0.2036684453,
0.2301065326,
-0.4283742011,
-0.0340405665,
-0.464664191,
0.2633731365,
0.7236481905,
0.5135152936,
0.0672978312,
-0.2785376906,
0.0176570807,
0.3040164709,
0.0868039951,
-0.6791797876,
-0.1520682573,
0.5432105064,
-0.1557056904,
0.0410632007,
-0.1448084265,
-0.5295619369,
-0.591627121,
-0.5814172029,
0.2367268354,
-0.3255285919,
-0.1788602918,
0.6582231522,
-0.2488850653,
0.5530548692,
0.1439919323,
-0.7687975168,
0.1842017025,
1.0778665543,
0.5973169804,
0.064858973,
-0.4434765577,
-0.5593314767,
0.1913236231,
-0.4117672145,
1.1494389772,
-0.5283640027,
0.0249912478,
-0.0158289541,
0.0253474955,
-0.3677790463,
-0.2903504968,
0.9487567544,
-0.6720303297,
0.3563168645,
-0.6625528932,
-0.8319028616,
-0.195541352,
0.0754170343,
-0.7034643292,
0.6759132743,
-0.5411784053,
-1.2980680466,
0.5830802917,
-0.4386587739,
-0.6690710187,
0.2017201036,
-0.1934283972,
-0.1572664678,
0.0201025885,
0.2555198669,
0.6219082475,
-0.9570840001,
0.9195610881,
-0.6276914477,
0.0285148062,
0.1681443304,
-0.5341963768,
0.9774926305,
0.0165121388,
-0.433249414,
0.2396763116,
-0.5889791846,
-0.2083774507,
-0.0628552586,
0.1243764386,
-0.6002384424,
0.3149748445,
-0.0357661322,
0.3615706265,
-0.0414085537,
-0.5156023502,
0.2144259661,
-0.330817163,
0.226837948,
0.7710929513,
0.1852394193,
0.1467163116,
-0.4350335598,
0.1667922139,
-0.501439929,
0.0149235073,
0.0070458008,
-0.5864013433,
-0.8579130173,
-0.3829441369,
-0.1590268016,
0.4849660993,
-0.9883401394,
0.612421453,
-0.2913500965,
-0.2178881466,
-0.096610032,
-0.0059288829,
0.4727944732,
0.6192173362,
0.3022170961,
0.0866499096,
-0.639716506,
-0.7546589971,
-0.6798387766,
-0.2735330462,
-0.0504884273,
0.1566155702,
0.7902933955,
-0.2505020201,
1.0750905275,
-0.4416254163,
0.1625661701,
-0.1479047537,
0.4895928502,
0.4445163906,
0.4334599376,
-0.046782285,
-0.6653624177,
-0.0860486925,
0.0681509301,
-1.1156641245,
-0.3951518238,
-0.4639894068,
-0.3985738158,
-0.2213004827,
0.7687305808,
-0.6539299488,
0.104198046,
0.3548241556,
-0.6703133583,
0.6886252761,
-0.1710307747,
0.043153502,
-0.9094473124,
0.414414376,
-0.1147058457,
0.0320179872,
-0.4134212732,
0.025979137,
-0.1603608429,
0.1264571697,
-0.3152807057,
0.9393348098,
-0.2457393408,
-0.0589537621,
-0.2340048403,
0.0372983739,
0.0281984992,
0.4056378603,
0.0042756447,
0.4476578236,
0.4345633388,
-0.5551401377,
0.4220355451,
0.268089503,
-0.5594866872,
0.7048395872,
-0.8240000606,
-0.0825752094,
-0.2340793312,
0.0497100987,
-0.9178168774,
-0.6750348806,
-0.1996484846,
-0.0626058504,
0.1301808208,
0.0590854995,
-0.8054561615,
-0.3663330078,
0.0023343433,
0.1471418887,
0.1122868955,
-0.6609624624,
0.585421145,
0.0889362618,
-0.132254824,
-0.3368910551,
-0.5965808034,
0.3646141589,
-0.2800059319,
-0.9725746512,
0.0841892213,
-0.0115079684,
-0.6925446987,
-0.0485966504,
-0.022515025,
0.0440496989,
0.127901867,
0.2146162689,
0.1807237864,
-0.1671141982,
0.2924779952,
0.0792631507,
-0.206987977,
0.4906478524,
-0.2734936476,
0.352745831,
-0.1240892634,
-0.6549662948,
-0.3682329357,
0.2754411697,
0.7069783211,
-0.092646651,
0.790866673,
0.369479835,
-0.3049039543,
-0.3248415589,
-0.6638058424,
-0.2092048079,
-0.4101396203,
-0.0036511109,
-0.0062811524,
-0.7948555946,
0.5753198862,
-0.1098145694,
0.090455845,
0.621645391,
0.5853773355,
-0.0001567267,
0.9436045885,
0.2430586815,
-0.0965943784,
0.0928069949,
-0.0324877948,
0.3247203827,
-0.7833633423,
-0.1963623017,
-0.5192178488,
-0.1008454263,
-0.50142169,
-0.4945436716,
0.1058811098,
0.0716631711,
-0.5246896148,
0.1078018397,
-0.0183745623,
0.5992013812,
0.319843322,
0.0231134146,
0.3571811616,
-0.3662599325,
-0.2414702326,
0.1856072247,
-0.7930120826,
-0.5829904675,
0.506026566,
0.2497074455,
0.7835181952,
0.1357227713,
0.3285088241,
0.2675295472,
0.3409448564,
-0.6055604815,
0.6140993237,
-0.038793914,
-0.7046265602,
-0.2216841877,
-0.5106455684,
-0.9057980776,
0.2527153194,
-0.2482085526,
-0.5540726781,
0.3530271053,
-0.0586027578,
-0.1069353223,
0.2990876138,
-0.5980876684,
0.9749389291,
-0.265486598,
-0.8592377305,
-0.1154423058,
-0.6736065745,
0.8649866581,
0.021707423,
0.2531349361,
-0.1885567755,
0.4150026739,
0.7335675359,
-0.4124104977,
1.0097917318,
0.0990386903,
-0.2946387231,
0.0636732727,
0.0160129704,
0.5143451691,
0.0917927176,
-0.1885333508,
-0.0416663513,
-0.2971554101,
-0.4140635729,
-0.798353672,
0.663731575,
-0.3635096848,
-0.5738375783,
-0.4116847813,
-0.5885099769,
-0.2190447748,
0.3171498179,
0.038006071,
0.6157563925,
-0.1877745688,
0.1739947647,
0.5790006518,
-0.2561866045,
0.4752533138,
0.4790923893,
-0.2686039805,
-0.2746087611,
0.7694217563,
-0.3592723906,
0.2105324566,
0.5685659051,
0.5627917647,
-0.3343330622,
-0.2623877525,
-0.1518611908,
0.4418528974,
-0.7772828937,
-0.1404319853,
-0.5096662641,
0.0518499315,
-0.1527699828,
-0.3206317127,
-0.1736162603,
-0.1371696889,
-0.1249882355,
0.0307314489,
0.370875895,
0.7940870523,
0.0393734537,
0.0624041744,
-0.4643746912,
0.2409072965,
0.72734797,
0.257419467,
0.0981324241,
-0.2599547505,
0.0322643518,
-0.1528457254,
0.1843669415,
-0.5161443949,
0.3631391823,
-0.0182209313,
0.4571764171,
0.6684789658,
0.3833982646,
0.7647583485,
-0.57975775,
0.5837295055,
0.1077545062,
-0.8679513335,
0.3949668109,
-0.6315207481,
0.4198617637,
0.4518721104,
0.3619464338,
-0.649966538,
-0.5965370536,
-0.5660780668,
-0.7717608809,
0.2508056164,
0.2271889001,
-0.2842119932,
-0.4704867899,
0.171635434,
-0.1025494486,
-0.0823525339,
-0.4352816045,
0.0365349837,
0.2259735763,
0.1246988103,
-0.1255099177,
-0.250574708,
-0.0976477042,
-0.2417455316,
0.5922467113,
-0.1721897572,
0.1258860976,
0.2507458925,
-0.2508664429,
-0.0057433993,
0.3748140335,
0.6543429494,
0.531632483,
-0.2327826023,
0.5136320591,
0.0561743937,
-0.1028195694,
-0.2565304041,
-0.0042039165,
0.0763143525,
-0.2601305544,
1.2217187881,
0.8684090972,
0.6811962128,
-0.6378111243,
0.4603363276,
-0.1848572195,
-0.0932845995,
0.0444548354,
-0.108853437,
0.1416701525,
0.3728441298,
0.2057671398,
0.0352314897,
0.0749146342,
-0.4470400512,
0.2497107685,
0.4405846894,
-0.2026199549,
-0.2358261645,
0.6967889071,
0.15892075,
-0.0456911922,
0.6279233694,
-0.1677113473,
-0.5433021784,
0.4673521221,
0.5987855196,
1.1132698059,
-0.0353896432,
0.0689973384,
0.3474175036,
0.5194923282,
-0.2316949666,
0.2482255399,
0.0519632585,
-0.7521121502,
-0.9979595542,
-0.6311164498,
-0.4625194669,
-0.1484021395,
-0.63954705,
0.1713291854,
-0.3699472249,
0.1286775619,
0.1164881364,
-0.1204938516,
-0.4704637229,
-0.0419464819,
-0.0076028276,
0.8941156864,
-1.3313602209,
0.5115990043,
0.2788309157,
-0.3889276981,
-0.5987449288,
-0.133931756,
-0.0139733441,
-0.5975209475,
0.8766629696,
0.1821500361,
-0.2757851481,
-0.1674883664,
-0.6770429611,
-0.5757741928,
0.8545076847,
0.5260339379,
-0.4281722903,
0.0332531929,
0.0807104334,
0.3893900216,
-0.0576238967,
0.2725430131,
0.5758622289,
0.7263405919,
0.1819880158,
-0.7269314528,
0.1967944801,
-0.3811663389,
-0.0405171514,
0.0351056308,
-0.209456563,
0.7723249197,
-0.0306742955,
-0.4048017859,
-0.2013552934,
0.7131816149,
0.1925487518,
0.3147317767,
0.3087664247,
0.6388748288,
0.9828106165,
0.0882342905,
1.4086971283,
-0.1399473846,
0.2991253138,
1.2610317469,
-0.6060919166,
0.8334496617,
0.5734639764,
0.0060560307,
0.7326741219,
0.3115390837,
0.2917987108,
0.223528564,
0.0887682885,
-0.3975430727,
-0.6506733298,
-0.236049071,
0.0012872991,
0.3907940686,
0.2381084114,
-0.031139655,
-0.4301299155,
0.0355803184,
0.0955695137,
0.082981959,
-0.1696788073,
0.6515366435,
0.1680817157,
-0.7201038599,
0.4792688787,
-0.136995703,
0.3154041469,
-0.5330095291,
-0.1397812814,
-0.1681348979,
0.2472251654,
-0.164375633,
-0.6936312914,
0.4664613903,
-0.0884307399,
-0.2331974357,
-0.3235282898,
0.6366516948,
-0.2121805251,
-0.5797759295,
0.2428351343,
0.3462253809,
0.0281172022,
-0.0405957811,
-0.4970162809,
0.127150923,
-0.2623142004,
0.0074867802,
-0.0281788912,
0.5849305391,
-0.247224167,
0.7912683487,
0.9504165649,
0.042198699,
-0.046217896,
0.1033442616,
0.7656856775,
-0.6863147616,
-0.3468539417,
-1.0668190718,
0.4904629588,
-0.307852298,
-0.2657844424,
1.1384257078,
0.4553951025,
0.3968300819,
0.1068681777,
0.5156911016,
-0.0668690056,
0.3351263404,
-0.8812283278,
0.6147096753,
-0.2737876475,
0.4585366249,
-0.462148577,
-0.6208402514,
-0.6866157651,
0.6788166165,
-0.8432419896,
-0.2675710618,
1.0139963627,
0.7163351178,
-0.0115523608,
0.4681231678,
0.3158636093,
0.4961468875,
0.4724061489,
0.46249336,
1.0179831982,
-0.1500297934,
-0.2334443629,
0.1417215914,
-0.2278835475,
-0.183647275,
-1.3342891932,
-1.1153649092,
-0.5197284818,
-0.2666693032,
-0.1051895991,
-0.0665792227,
0.8022418618,
0.3296761513,
-0.6489855647,
-0.266636163,
-0.5387169123,
0.598195076,
-0.1723023504,
-0.1956120431,
0.6030145288,
-0.6597583294,
-0.3006848097,
0.5322287083,
0.3763885498,
-0.6177037358,
-0.2815348804,
0.1027761325,
-0.6312830448,
0.1606554687,
0.7817454338,
0.3143613636,
-0.7630927563,
-0.4086960554,
-0.1371206939,
0.0423386358,
-0.4961611927,
1.0827150345,
-0.4445824623,
0.5749110579,
0.5883988142,
0.7711147666,
0.2454176694,
-0.3190823197,
0.6898430586,
-0.4344491363,
-0.0505542085,
0.2064943612,
0.5548883677,
0.2919935882,
-0.1706483662,
0.1720264703,
0.2230906785,
-0.6921218038,
-0.6953322291,
0.2411320955,
-0.8333953619,
-0.3743885756,
1.2471394539,
0.0998833999,
-0.3036213219,
-0.4363204241,
-0.0887240097,
0.0550348833,
0.0985419676,
0.5510273576,
0.6004628539,
-0.2053582966,
0.0357408039,
-0.5890613794,
0.3768735826,
0.4017390013,
-0.9833840132,
0.4421895444,
0.5807343721,
-0.0422300063,
0.0129824346,
0.3702915013,
0.2358151227,
0.098013103,
0.0056965267,
-0.0287465807,
0.1450386345,
-0.3338010311,
-0.2841686606,
-0.0849396661,
-0.0685916618,
0.4223075211
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04348v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04348v1
|
When Input Integers are Given in the Unary Numeral Representation
| 2023-12-07T15:09:24 | 2023-12-07T15:09:24 |
Tomoyuki Yamakami
|
cs.CC
|
cs.CC, cs.CL, cs.FL
|
Many NP-complete problems take integers as part of their input instances.
These input integers are generally binarized, that is, provided in the form of
the "binary" numeral representation, and the lengths of such binary forms are
used as a basis unit to measure the computational complexity of the problems.
In sharp contrast, the "unarization" (or the "unary" numeral representation) of
numbers has been known to bring a remarkably different effect onto the
computational complexity of the problems. When no computational-complexity
difference is observed between binarization and unarization of instances, on
the contrary, the problems are said to be strong NP-complete. This work
attempts to spotlight an issue of how the unarization of instances affects the
computational complexity of various combinatorial problems. We present numerous
NP-complete (or even NP-hard) problems, which turn out to be easily solvable
when input integers are represented in unary. We then discuss the computational
complexities of such problems when taking unary-form integer inputs. We hope
that a list of such problems signifies the structural differences between
strong NP-completeness and non-strong NP-completeness.
|
[
-0.6426272392,
-0.5423516035,
0.7195169926,
0.4675000012,
-0.4339418113,
0.4934127033,
-0.0992039219,
-0.4342213273,
0.2126207054,
0.422965169,
0.0482438654,
0.321916014,
-0.6147905588,
0.6270442009,
-0.3924344182,
0.9565569758,
-0.0149750691,
0.2320093364,
-0.4866530001,
-0.1536733955,
-0.3036749363,
-0.9305368066,
0.0655461922,
-0.5981974006,
0.0896041915,
0.0428285189,
0.926284492,
0.4940740168,
0.6904027462,
0.5086994171,
-0.4485743046,
-0.3255438209,
-0.26034078,
0.2002205104,
-0.0193644818,
-0.5926972032,
0.2730138302,
-0.3631227016,
0.9587865472,
1.6781884432,
0.3203387558,
-0.0968545973,
-0.2897984982,
0.8930965662,
-0.4584590793,
0.2030843347,
-0.5369676948,
0.0798631161,
-0.3509971201,
-0.2088713348,
-0.1368242651,
-0.144293949,
-0.1126950681,
-0.5410421491,
0.2146827132,
-0.3633085489,
0.1262346059,
0.3922341168,
-0.4491738379,
-0.3492752016,
-1.0938431025,
0.8369327784,
-0.5066943169,
-0.2147854567,
0.424480617,
-0.0227559973,
-0.6168374419,
-0.0803204626,
-0.136249736,
-0.1512394547,
-0.1959179938,
-0.1110184342,
-0.5512810946,
0.3261678815,
0.7459390759,
0.6631845236,
-0.0921288282,
-0.1177630946,
-0.9008923173,
-0.0043691467,
0.4271667004,
0.0345181301,
0.4402616024,
-0.3164437115,
0.0874054134,
0.1807868332,
-0.6452763081,
0.1704303324,
0.5040838122,
0.361367017,
0.1094180569,
0.8780143857,
-0.2529281378,
0.8425737023,
0.2780268192,
0.1672525853,
0.2545850873,
-0.4065897167,
-0.2012334764,
0.1791993082,
0.4626610279,
-0.3496287465,
0.1722207218,
-0.3987050951,
-0.2272320688,
0.1869565248,
0.2665088475,
-0.7372355461,
-0.3228365779,
0.2867611647,
-0.2370559275,
-0.3775786757,
0.3481585383,
-0.3541801274,
-0.4915759265,
-0.2437628061,
0.6424036026,
-0.2445524186,
-0.0420778506,
-0.1160405055,
-0.3485994339,
-0.0534009524,
0.4502746463,
-0.7679656148,
0.3379027545,
0.744064033,
0.7357693315,
0.1625344008,
0.207553342,
-0.2786014676,
-0.4465306997,
-0.8015942574,
0.6265542507,
-0.5700759292,
-0.4254081249,
-0.4969614148,
-0.1846863329,
0.031866245,
-0.6895201802,
-0.0658731312,
-0.5349952579,
-0.2529646158,
-0.1099825874,
-0.3631764352,
-0.3231990933,
-0.1066882685,
-0.8629534841,
0.5896638036,
0.3665548861,
-0.4449062943,
-0.2198602855,
-0.4662799239,
-0.5198042989,
0.3413229883,
-0.440841198,
-0.2173922062,
0.8820876479,
-0.4155281484,
-0.0205058604,
-0.3630107939,
0.0808353052,
-0.4163763523,
-0.6444687843,
0.8806046844,
-0.3799347878,
1.1222561598,
-0.0290723946,
-0.4096088707,
-0.1688857526,
-1.0700352192,
0.3842189312,
0.0536323637,
-0.3035569489,
-0.3632014692,
0.026721796,
-0.3713373244,
0.0506691784,
0.4425540864,
-0.7978687882,
0.2435917407,
-0.7037439942,
0.6499398947,
0.6810629368,
0.1076085791,
0.7592045665,
-0.1977312863,
0.3593326807,
0.0974072963,
-0.2222206295,
-0.050918065,
-0.6161820292,
-0.6981661916,
0.1030016914,
0.7953786254,
0.4515041709,
-0.5507134199,
0.2227379829,
0.1997846663,
-0.3638310432,
-0.0831831023,
0.0342041254,
0.4323520064,
-0.078063786,
0.1306553483,
-0.5093968511,
-0.6818891168,
-0.8568660021,
0.2044040859,
-0.2921918333,
-0.0738521591,
-0.1330113709,
0.7063218355,
-0.0958001763,
0.6250845194,
-0.0982667208,
0.0477771685,
0.1770614535,
0.6447268724,
0.4172154069,
0.582118392,
0.2847895622,
-0.8190079331,
-0.4467539489,
0.0496976115,
-0.7053621411,
-0.0538866632,
0.0082705598,
0.1801622361,
0.3476826847,
0.2058312744,
-0.4582882524,
1.1577146053,
0.2463845909,
-0.0976563618,
0.4850461483,
-0.7186003327,
0.0059375078,
-0.2033191323,
-0.043485608,
-0.5095031857,
0.138180688,
-0.8000404239,
-0.2262219787,
-0.2177035809,
-0.318687886,
-0.2895003557,
-0.0836079195,
-0.8435740471,
-0.6462233663,
-0.2149425149,
-0.7685436606,
-0.1264260858,
0.5111114383,
-0.2123411894,
0.5964903831,
0.5246109366,
-0.5134423375,
0.2055001259,
-0.125407815,
-0.0732299834,
0.3899430931,
-0.9456492662,
0.1961716115,
-0.2692437768,
-0.1066049337,
-1.0865085125,
-0.0284864809,
-0.013790396,
-0.5288835168,
0.0581389181,
-0.56992805,
-0.5339018106,
0.0166465826,
-0.2951182723,
0.8591906428,
0.4101439714,
-0.1762850136,
0.4979485869,
0.0799211636,
0.2109275609,
-0.5358108878,
-0.4454912841,
-0.106992282,
0.0175326522,
-0.4285861254,
0.5452226996,
-0.3820097446,
-0.6402136683,
0.1896668524,
-0.1555946469,
-0.509077549,
0.2698088288,
0.6103218794,
0.316069454,
-0.1224582493,
-0.1311135739,
-0.2976636589,
-0.3390171528,
0.1677137464,
0.1934991628,
0.3788956702,
-0.4115179181,
-0.186343044,
0.0118064098,
1.1660736799,
0.8213857412,
-0.1869840622,
0.4709234536,
0.1444854438,
-0.7073563337,
0.0716736764,
-0.1859475523,
0.1137265489,
-0.4898065925,
0.0751617029,
-0.4748173952,
-0.7716146708,
0.6529690623,
0.2849538922,
0.0464555137,
0.4721294641,
0.4913906455,
-0.2466640025,
1.2177320719,
0.1069976687,
0.4503079355,
0.3084229231,
-0.2306942791,
0.4357189238,
-0.924934566,
-0.06134139,
-0.7075645924,
-0.3310235441,
-0.6643625498,
-0.4922405481,
0.2463583946,
0.44401443,
-0.5416562557,
0.2884977162,
-0.7317243218,
0.7165637016,
0.5728416443,
-0.3840868771,
0.219990775,
0.1019168422,
0.0638668761,
-0.1724830717,
-0.430306673,
-0.0220952146,
1.0642938614,
-0.1328104138,
0.6445148587,
0.4674846828,
0.830008328,
0.3320162296,
-0.0952589363,
-0.9542245269,
0.3008772135,
-0.3397763968,
-0.6377927065,
-0.3017848134,
-0.8515347242,
-1.4238206148,
0.2010156959,
-0.2541449964,
-0.9711859226,
0.6203340888,
-0.1228331476,
-0.396189034,
0.3429921865,
-0.5606515408,
0.5184175372,
-0.7214331031,
0.0631496832,
0.0049616811,
-0.4371095896,
0.1178215742,
-0.0937214941,
0.136616528,
-0.0002089041,
0.0747099519,
0.9423969388,
-1.0548753738,
0.7163189054,
0.0103793107,
0.4477104545,
0.3342678547,
0.4196536243,
0.146265462,
-0.00305421,
0.2124384344,
0.3550838232,
0.2172371,
-0.3489673138,
-0.826033175,
0.3453276753,
-1.0409367085,
-0.4567269087,
-0.8858432174,
-0.4017606676,
0.040638607,
0.3455754817,
0.679012537,
0.9596960545,
0.179613784,
0.4867990911,
0.791981101,
-0.0522066951,
0.4482952952,
0.2016172409,
0.06714762,
-0.5733093023,
0.8535898328,
0.9490199685,
0.2037804276,
0.4155570567,
0.0306432806,
-0.1669897884,
-0.6656304598,
-0.4739530683,
0.2268635035,
-0.7290879488,
-0.4212402403,
-0.2804626822,
-0.4930691719,
-0.1864588708,
-0.4500238299,
-0.4562796652,
-0.8437770009,
-0.5396841764,
0.3835428059,
0.3979176581,
0.9720024467,
-0.4767136276,
0.0784089416,
-0.2578944564,
0.5470895767,
0.5222614408,
0.305708617,
0.0951857567,
-0.3894774318,
0.0954390392,
-0.1198770106,
0.2278699279,
-1.1169015169,
-0.0384880044,
-0.2599788904,
0.4083783925,
0.3390428722,
0.0640797243,
0.8315931559,
-0.2235990614,
0.243262291,
0.5428463221,
-0.9415277243,
-0.0176343117,
-0.245509848,
0.4304714203,
0.9204822183,
0.2159104049,
-0.3940593898,
0.1218130812,
-0.9482647777,
-0.9898218513,
0.5421987176,
0.6063088179,
-0.1499631405,
0.0749800354,
0.1913579255,
-0.2188795507,
0.2365964949,
-0.4576317072,
-0.5771018863,
-0.3793177009,
0.161085546,
0.1321534812,
-0.3077039421,
0.037249811,
-0.3279316127,
0.5121985674,
0.4068959057,
0.8786017895,
-0.0527515598,
-0.2583250105,
-0.2228632271,
0.5585788488,
0.4883590639,
0.7808885574,
-0.3078539371,
0.3922783136,
-0.1466421336,
-0.1968615949,
0.3939981759,
0.1029940024,
-0.4414640665,
0.1347058266,
0.2858574986,
0.5782363415,
0.466371417,
-0.3772786558,
0.3714341819,
-0.0269028712,
-0.2468793988,
-0.7289400697,
0.0617727302,
-0.1340532005,
-0.121187523,
0.6898261309,
0.2245666534,
0.2601674497,
-0.7573258281,
-0.0970641971,
0.625865221,
-0.3794096708,
-0.2219403386,
0.1662116945,
-0.056069348,
-0.8004752398,
0.9146897793,
-0.506380856,
-0.8182587028,
1.1145241261,
0.8595924973,
0.4459244311,
0.0946357474,
0.3090495765,
0.4460526407,
0.2817932367,
-0.0302451421,
0.0078004906,
-0.3892956376,
-0.5590975285,
-0.5056883097,
-0.4512831867,
-0.6622356176,
0.177798152,
-0.6327183843,
-0.362372607,
-1.0506666899,
-0.1682805568,
0.402622968,
0.1964074224,
-0.4640361667,
0.0176902749,
0.1957107186,
0.0569250993,
-0.6763350964,
-0.0628807843,
0.9027617574,
-0.3438192904,
-0.8490365744,
-0.8891118765,
-0.018511204,
-0.4196862876,
0.4499605596,
0.2088414431,
0.1585987359,
-0.2079875022,
-0.3362703323,
-1.1247611046,
0.4415584803,
0.1893428266,
0.0053702206,
0.2254809737,
0.5942035317,
0.6111062169,
-0.1397563219,
0.5328494906,
0.2994799316,
0.708344996,
0.2294488996,
-0.966208756,
-0.3162989914,
-0.6105120778,
0.2482263297,
0.8749727607,
-0.2702975571,
1.3441894054,
-0.1863010228,
-0.2978872359,
0.1462292969,
0.3975509107,
0.1460207999,
0.1465431899,
0.5312898755,
0.4047857523,
0.7423331141,
-0.1539375037,
0.6721837521,
0.159478724,
0.0484287851,
0.7641348243,
0.0860257372,
0.5178064108,
0.3762069046,
-0.6349482536,
0.780331254,
0.4098546505,
-0.0533125922,
0.1234172955,
0.6691497564,
-0.3213698566,
-0.3484579623,
0.1558131725,
-0.412443608,
0.5349889994,
0.2834549844,
-0.1732358932,
-0.4383785129,
-0.1673360318,
-0.0651379898,
0.0032382486,
-0.6893302202,
0.5875617266,
0.0708176419,
-0.6168970466,
0.7287412882,
0.2751520574,
0.5969639421,
-0.7014030218,
-0.2966942191,
-0.0140888477,
-0.1639703363,
-0.5824549794,
-0.6472399235,
0.3579313755,
0.0611352436,
-0.6780226231,
0.1147684678,
0.7038657069,
0.0285408385,
-0.9029114246,
-0.0488946177,
0.4213772416,
0.5306893587,
-0.3630800247,
-0.3685533106,
0.0316636525,
-0.0464959703,
0.2489744127,
0.4714893997,
0.5210678577,
-0.5076514482,
0.2111112326,
0.7376814485,
-0.0871922225,
0.258082509,
-0.3271241784,
0.4639113843,
-0.8142334819,
-0.4314961731,
-0.7319761515,
0.2428195477,
0.1889729649,
-0.2814371884,
0.4788229167,
0.4882428944,
0.5596250892,
-0.0090722833,
0.688898921,
-0.3154292703,
0.0190670732,
0.1146432012,
0.2718792856,
-0.0818278342,
0.1310680807,
-0.3576470017,
-0.8825628757,
-0.3910883069,
1.0387228727,
-0.4499601722,
-0.0525042973,
0.677710712,
0.2828139961,
0.2111373246,
-0.0858832449,
0.3037064373,
-0.0627660304,
-0.166877225,
0.7931945324,
0.9266510606,
-0.2058904171,
0.489969939,
-0.7057119608,
-0.1793346703,
0.0262986682,
-0.6783831716,
-0.8550841808,
-0.6934541464,
-0.3819753528,
-0.3651182055,
-0.3493262827,
0.5223647356,
0.3293153644,
-0.6838238835,
-0.3092723489,
-0.2537972331,
0.5649370551,
-0.2353989631,
-0.2193893939,
0.286637038,
0.0153509472,
-0.2800564766,
0.183079496,
0.357026428,
0.4812974036,
-0.4363664687,
0.2766904235,
0.3600622118,
0.0931656435,
0.449306041,
0.8690518737,
-0.2747990191,
-0.057434544,
0.0798409879,
0.3350166976,
0.5242257118,
0.9816404581,
-0.9568552375,
0.5341102481,
0.5822412372,
0.6778167486,
0.5126727223,
0.2151517868,
0.2259073257,
-0.2717102468,
0.0438537933,
0.3990766406,
0.4195968807,
0.3193472922,
-0.5521213412,
0.4669106901,
0.2867522836,
-0.3627288938,
-0.987977922,
0.377497524,
-1.2107719183,
-0.3976742029,
0.9048865438,
0.3297876716,
-0.5630165339,
-0.5439681411,
0.2120012492,
-0.1377902031,
-0.2660464644,
0.5574019551,
0.7540178299,
-0.5277143121,
0.1351956576,
-0.0668251887,
0.1182248816,
0.5410469174,
-0.3981617391,
-0.049629651,
0.5121341944,
0.114990145,
0.8194542527,
0.9380806684,
-0.4808090627,
0.5341115594,
0.0538693368,
-0.3554874659,
-0.2322133183,
-0.2464301735,
-0.4832307696,
0.4608923495,
0.2067911178,
0.329469353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04344v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04344v2
|
Enhancing Medical Task Performance in GPT-4V: A Comprehensive Study on Prompt Engineering Strategies
| 2023-12-07T15:05:59 | 2023-12-12T06:37:53 |
Pengcheng Chen, Ziyan Huang, Zhongying Deng, Tianbin Li, Yanzhou Su, Haoyu Wang, Jin Ye, Yu Qiao, Junjun He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
OpenAI's latest large vision-language model (LVLM), GPT-4V(ision), has piqued
considerable interest for its potential in medical applications. Despite its
promise, recent studies and internal reviews highlight its underperformance in
specialized medical tasks. This paper explores the boundary of GPT-4V's
capabilities in medicine, particularly in processing complex imaging data from
endoscopies, CT scans, and MRIs etc. Leveraging open-source datasets, we
assessed its foundational competencies, identifying substantial areas for
enhancement. Our research emphasizes prompt engineering, an often-underutilized
strategy for improving AI responsiveness. Through iterative testing, we refined
the model's prompts, significantly improving its interpretative accuracy and
relevance in medical imaging. From our comprehensive evaluations, we distilled
10 effective prompt engineering techniques, each fortifying GPT-4V's medical
acumen. These methodical enhancements facilitate more reliable, precise, and
clinically valuable insights from GPT-4V, advancing its operability in critical
healthcare environments. Our findings are pivotal for those employing AI in
medicine, providing clear, actionable guidance on harnessing GPT-4V's full
diagnostic potential.
|
[
-0.0349852331,
-0.4973353148,
0.9927524328,
0.1514172107,
-0.3578146398,
-0.0900800973,
-0.0589221716,
-0.6276554465,
-0.267986238,
0.223573938,
-0.399839431,
-0.3345347345,
-0.6095474958,
0.3272053599,
0.0752204135,
0.8982272744,
-0.3557705879,
0.3044237196,
-0.2386787981,
-0.200226903,
-0.6132675409,
-0.3513464034,
-0.7262361646,
-0.0301548522,
0.3753128052,
0.1882307678,
0.7207717299,
0.715696454,
0.9096465707,
0.2670096755,
0.0298590008,
-0.0603495799,
-0.1502965987,
0.2660102844,
0.1164529771,
-0.1932331026,
-0.4340823889,
0.0260050111,
0.6219747066,
0.2408362776,
0.1018823311,
-0.051369492,
0.0183639377,
0.5725200772,
-0.3987695575,
0.2659808397,
-0.166514948,
0.0083651384,
-0.3278394043,
-0.4934097528,
-0.0599455647,
-0.023555439,
0.1798665524,
-0.9042055011,
0.1334928572,
-0.0170733016,
0.9315404892,
0.823738277,
-0.1493507475,
-0.267462194,
-0.4954847097,
0.392695874,
-0.6188839674,
0.2308093607,
0.1917770952,
0.6173713803,
-0.0389324725,
-1.0728981495,
-0.0460685864,
-0.5861890912,
0.1055523679,
0.4191692472,
-0.1740212888,
0.4971629679,
0.6316633821,
0.3064429164,
-0.6770080924,
0.3134044111,
-0.4672126472,
-0.2309961617,
0.1885728091,
0.1987187713,
0.6341230869,
0.0660688132,
-0.3862594962,
0.3274940252,
-0.7409793139,
0.2620206475,
-0.0072399471,
-0.0401035585,
0.1008846015,
0.5745187402,
-0.4343443811,
0.6958094239,
-0.130778417,
0.0165753197,
0.3134854138,
-0.7382829785,
-0.2833522856,
-0.1236196533,
0.6536368132,
0.4699236751,
-0.1608062834,
0.0207303111,
-0.3420609534,
0.0979534537,
0.4780986905,
-0.9207924008,
-0.1769393235,
0.4234783947,
-0.6138227582,
-0.3071470559,
-0.4275045097,
-0.5471445918,
-0.3518132567,
-0.1821096539,
0.2296347618,
-0.6371123195,
-0.079205893,
0.0797643512,
-0.0476584621,
0.3238438964,
0.3959296048,
-0.65398103,
0.1322553307,
0.5124139786,
1.20327878,
-0.1290226132,
-0.0646721423,
-0.725856781,
-0.1926718205,
-0.3951331973,
0.7986522317,
-0.6000302434,
-0.421492666,
-0.2113261074,
-0.1589883417,
0.1579391211,
-0.5719069839,
0.8626831174,
-0.2240819633,
0.1631608605,
-0.5787949562,
-0.2567715943,
-0.1752977669,
0.408500284,
-0.7397186756,
0.6444265246,
0.2356087714,
-0.5680025816,
0.3169102371,
-1.1896896362,
-0.2500133514,
0.5279160738,
-0.5871483088,
-0.5033224225,
0.147214517,
0.6755598783,
0.4621355832,
-0.6278321147,
0.2513667047,
-0.0138471471,
-0.2968479693,
0.0569673292,
-0.2520236969,
0.4268685281,
0.4202237427,
-0.3098471165,
0.5087103248,
-0.5886975527,
-0.1152911037,
0.2226355076,
-0.0138568254,
-0.1264345199,
-0.172364682,
-0.2962978184,
0.1272324771,
0.1673568189,
-0.6397797465,
0.3461756706,
-0.4702994823,
0.4485586286,
0.6677986979,
0.2046041936,
0.3001768887,
-0.4237188995,
0.7381724715,
-0.0605960339,
0.610427022,
-0.3617054522,
-1.0326805115,
-0.2134122849,
-0.5586893559,
-0.0471475162,
0.69068712,
-1.1640688181,
-0.2873731256,
-0.0234155636,
-0.3949466646,
-0.7148715258,
-0.3564533889,
0.3298135698,
1.0939888954,
0.4628593326,
-0.3036903739,
-0.3124352396,
-0.9150767922,
-0.2062643319,
-0.0316179097,
-0.0710388869,
0.2465038151,
0.1799630225,
-0.3545165956,
0.488899678,
-0.3750408292,
-0.351475805,
-0.0643844903,
0.0019705372,
0.704230845,
0.4100212455,
0.6540768743,
-0.7749420404,
-0.2913587987,
0.2286384255,
-1.129116416,
-0.2285392284,
-0.2037664801,
0.0222324971,
0.0686905831,
0.3807576597,
-0.5527901649,
0.5653561354,
0.1761294007,
-0.2895648181,
0.5450069308,
-0.5859333277,
0.6844618917,
-0.8406223655,
0.2438415438,
0.1784770191,
-0.1587133408,
-0.7565150857,
0.3206656575,
0.2663755417,
-0.2666184604,
-0.3529106379,
0.3704017103,
-0.5347725749,
-0.1075912192,
-0.3394955993,
-0.3275311589,
-0.3767842948,
0.19146806,
-0.0902937502,
0.8850714564,
0.8957885504,
-0.4022344351,
0.5297399759,
0.0164140686,
-0.1565629095,
0.5518839359,
-0.9394250512,
0.1655659974,
-0.1631088555,
-0.0872643217,
-0.9492225051,
-0.3496614993,
0.4922840893,
-0.4513466656,
0.5013635159,
-0.2996539772,
-0.4080122709,
-0.482117027,
-0.2190437019,
0.5666233301,
0.8852691054,
-0.3148707151,
0.5577757359,
0.0300632864,
-0.4045242071,
-0.5628042817,
-0.3557627201,
0.1760924011,
-0.1051148325,
-0.7218797803,
0.3752996325,
-0.2416131049,
-0.1285309047,
0.0152800446,
0.0121433996,
-0.0776113048,
0.2356364876,
0.2809355557,
0.6633729935,
-0.1692972034,
-0.1189396828,
-0.0956525877,
-0.3634246588,
-0.013932487,
-0.4255825579,
0.0403036699,
-0.1251798719,
-0.5415278077,
-0.5896542668,
0.255990386,
0.6705801487,
-0.2651460469,
0.0043252646,
0.4591338933,
-0.5769244432,
0.4080395103,
-0.3246806562,
-0.2335663885,
-0.511805892,
0.6021963358,
-0.5013961196,
-0.6672672629,
0.5243698359,
-0.1091264114,
0.1614465714,
0.2549624443,
0.6236027479,
-0.1144497171,
0.9224765897,
0.3756558001,
0.1446676701,
0.3193530142,
-0.0821698532,
0.1021851897,
-0.8111419678,
-0.2830511332,
-0.24285312,
-0.1959413588,
-0.3447501659,
-0.5567068458,
0.9381716251,
-0.5855009556,
-0.0949392244,
-0.4148390293,
-0.8464481831,
0.335111469,
0.4350949228,
0.2253298014,
0.150041312,
-0.2353926152,
-0.1027944311,
-0.0946184695,
-0.593170166,
-0.2775655389,
1.0647397041,
0.4937225878,
0.7394896746,
-0.1212356091,
0.3637804091,
0.2766624093,
0.1656626761,
-0.7060002685,
0.3344231844,
-0.1006040871,
-0.2712162137,
-0.2154110819,
-0.1292834729,
-0.8707590699,
-0.0113824606,
0.0098812692,
-0.3267999589,
-0.2232681811,
0.5191240311,
-0.6972670555,
0.1411420852,
-0.4955421686,
0.7694702148,
-0.4215273559,
-0.2619565427,
0.1156771556,
-0.7880991101,
0.2773751318,
-0.0712561086,
0.047498256,
0.137887761,
-0.3313751817,
0.428512305,
-0.4097473919,
0.6392189264,
-0.4638206363,
-0.0561575815,
0.0629614294,
-0.3039586842,
0.591694355,
0.0788144022,
0.2141646445,
0.1956320554,
-0.1474222094,
-0.4658640027,
-0.6132366657,
0.7234950662,
-0.7819324732,
-0.507562995,
-0.4622664452,
-0.4296247661,
-0.1811618656,
0.2280158252,
0.5556257963,
0.6396147609,
0.0627672449,
-0.2754988968,
0.6477593184,
-0.3530358672,
0.4217423797,
0.1631622016,
0.0400803462,
-0.4330104291,
0.8878237009,
0.3023042679,
0.0693771318,
0.2558232248,
0.1500998735,
-0.2585825324,
-1.0852634907,
-0.8703519106,
0.2633289695,
-0.7224898338,
-0.2292416245,
-0.5503703952,
-0.1417746991,
-0.4707215726,
-0.1390873492,
-0.4541231394,
0.0400643609,
-0.3457950056,
0.1167009994,
0.309704572,
0.731221199,
0.1625622511,
0.0611257218,
-0.7981155515,
0.3466454446,
0.0065276749,
0.3479678929,
-0.4910699725,
-0.5205305219,
-0.1322482228,
-0.1841959804,
-0.1351534426,
-0.8017463684,
0.1144615561,
-0.0318562016,
0.8633858562,
0.2651714683,
-0.1280864477,
0.4714635313,
-0.5105007887,
1.0077521801,
0.2084375024,
-0.641523838,
0.7295978069,
-0.3627839088,
0.3045917153,
0.2045372427,
0.3753940761,
-0.3033543527,
-0.2604105175,
-0.3946027756,
-0.8618198037,
0.4135169387,
0.272664547,
-0.3651077449,
0.2508229017,
0.6950828433,
0.0954069942,
0.0201611407,
-0.3569053411,
0.1286082864,
-0.4271554947,
-0.3722627759,
0.1168382093,
-0.1199134886,
-0.0390206762,
0.0608007982,
0.4839600623,
-0.3812369704,
0.5336027145,
0.5774965286,
0.0570622049,
0.0815153569,
0.0406926125,
0.8725408316,
0.5808670521,
0.0830097198,
-0.188546598,
-0.0092021301,
-0.7552323341,
0.1173613295,
0.3654264808,
-0.085562706,
-0.2071067095,
0.3803333938,
0.9362127781,
-0.2931331992,
-0.6565864086,
0.6282433271,
-0.2093823403,
-0.1749339253,
-0.1390915513,
0.0220038164,
-0.4325132966,
0.399441123,
0.3129557073,
0.3986435533,
0.4966147542,
-0.1628771871,
0.0790670365,
0.2298896909,
-0.4062968791,
-0.567922771,
0.9475181103,
0.3086580634,
0.096155189,
0.8232660294,
0.0299230106,
-0.1534855366,
0.5943940878,
0.4054872394,
0.7471445799,
-0.3170520663,
-0.0816708058,
0.3772979975,
0.4538815618,
-0.1403845698,
0.6000316143,
0.0136979679,
-0.4133864939,
-0.831537962,
-0.0142333237,
-0.2783618569,
0.0674411431,
-0.4463707805,
0.3599246144,
-0.4824873507,
-0.2560409307,
-0.2028153688,
-0.301646173,
-0.6793476343,
0.2542988658,
0.2710234821,
0.9052586555,
-0.549674511,
0.5392763615,
0.9324672222,
-0.4635386169,
-0.6314287782,
-0.0062323706,
0.0790679231,
-1.0369646549,
0.4430790842,
0.3356848955,
0.1925375164,
0.0340342298,
-0.5810064077,
-0.8050922155,
1.206330061,
0.2865587175,
-0.5144915581,
-0.3497941792,
-0.1579157263,
0.5199661851,
-0.1712601483,
0.4710732996,
0.317183286,
0.3926923275,
0.2649879158,
-1.0155955553,
0.4057266712,
-0.4884724915,
-0.0253937561,
0.1172769368,
-0.3996666074,
0.5092096329,
-0.7545497417,
-0.1570599824,
0.3544222116,
0.512060523,
0.2003972679,
0.6200093031,
0.3670800626,
0.4981313944,
0.937504828,
-0.213201955,
1.4017909765,
-0.3217164576,
-0.1237348095,
0.5527305007,
-0.361897409,
0.2029511184,
0.4797187746,
0.0540768728,
-0.0548610277,
0.9080737829,
-0.0151179433,
0.7376239896,
-0.0331014395,
-0.3153219521,
0.0129614035,
-0.0512059964,
-0.5122193098,
0.2818769217,
0.3708572984,
-0.3682743907,
0.0299237613,
0.5460860729,
-0.1590446532,
-0.4222463965,
-0.510935843,
0.7604089379,
-0.0695994496,
-0.8583827615,
0.4988510311,
-0.4327327609,
0.5289268494,
-0.642387569,
-0.1609922945,
-0.0354934745,
-0.2016083747,
-0.0552542172,
-0.880335629,
0.1723304838,
-0.0025374624,
-0.0371706747,
-0.138368696,
0.7543964982,
0.1431526095,
-0.0695600957,
-0.0297224503,
0.36208722,
0.3089263737,
-0.1974340826,
-0.5869089961,
0.1497594565,
0.1914798319,
-0.0396995842,
0.1216660514,
0.4059023559,
-0.0862407535,
0.6926648021,
0.6444809437,
0.3153499365,
-0.1295938641,
0.0442068577,
1.0745489597,
-0.6769205928,
-0.4949848056,
-0.9313969016,
0.6260088086,
-0.1502379179,
-0.3637743592,
0.2835996747,
0.3585166633,
0.4675709605,
0.0136768389,
1.1301425695,
0.121993497,
0.2097957581,
-0.7835158706,
0.4757015407,
-0.4482790828,
0.2338939309,
-0.0085462853,
-0.4452626705,
-0.5529078245,
0.2871145606,
-0.1873057187,
0.1317685843,
0.6945977211,
0.6808307171,
0.0665186942,
0.009606556,
0.6405507326,
0.3494154513,
0.7198480964,
0.4895811081,
0.9589399099,
-0.097600691,
0.3409162462,
0.0316804498,
-0.7517539859,
-0.132218942,
-0.7300266027,
-0.6759316325,
-0.6091293097,
-0.3553420007,
-0.2375555784,
0.1605802029,
0.7740899324,
0.545883894,
-0.1955259889,
0.5194446445,
-0.0311958492,
-0.4260796607,
-0.2326411307,
-0.0285098962,
0.3346659541,
-0.6936069727,
-0.6298030019,
0.5745554566,
0.7136914134,
0.207112208,
0.0517620109,
-0.1239882782,
0.3700521886,
-0.3926880062,
0.378977865,
0.3946406841,
-0.7146134377,
-0.0840677768,
0.3818956017,
0.0075446977,
0.2484449744,
0.9711773396,
-0.7081163526,
0.8691123128,
0.4795707762,
0.8665763736,
0.0495696254,
0.0296625849,
0.6235024929,
-0.3648049831,
-0.0438492671,
0.4474515915,
0.6062095165,
0.414588809,
-0.8303220272,
0.6009120941,
0.3794985414,
-1.0370674133,
-0.6675630212,
0.1280519515,
-0.9671025872,
-0.1626267731,
1.2007571459,
-0.2436110377,
-0.2045309693,
-0.2373044938,
-0.5662992001,
0.2518602312,
-0.4007704556,
0.3918726444,
0.2443982661,
-0.6091216803,
-0.2059666067,
-0.8197494745,
0.6158406734,
0.2470644414,
-0.8531922102,
-0.5167341828,
0.4888749123,
0.3562219739,
0.017978223,
1.0466617346,
-0.2697185278,
0.6976529956,
-0.296515435,
-0.0475177914,
-0.4458985925,
-0.1521684378,
-0.5082762241,
0.0961170644,
0.1948768049,
-0.6915314794
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.