id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04339v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04339v2
|
Merging by Matching Models in Task Parameter Subspaces
| 2023-12-07T14:59:15 | 2024-04-13T16:31:25 |
Derek Tam, Mohit Bansal, Colin Raffel
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Model merging aims to cheaply combine individual task-specific models into a
single multitask model. In this work, we view past merging methods as
leveraging different notions of a ''task parameter subspace'' in which models
are matched before being merged. We connect the task parameter subspace of a
given model to its loss landscape and formalize how this approach to model
merging can be seen as solving a linear system of equations. While past work
has generally been limited to linear systems that have a closed-form solution,
we consider using the conjugate gradient method to find a solution. We show
that using the conjugate gradient method can outperform closed-form solutions,
enables merging via linear systems that are otherwise intractable to solve, and
flexibly allows choosing from a wide variety of initializations and estimates
for the ''task parameter subspace''. We ultimately demonstrate that our merging
framework called ''Matching Models in their Task Parameter Subspace'' (MaTS)
achieves state-of-the-art results in multitask and intermediate-task model
merging. We release all of the code and checkpoints used in our work at
https://github.com/r-three/mats.
|
[
-0.4486352503,
-0.2757086754,
0.7280727029,
-0.087438941,
-0.2512264848,
-0.0420014746,
-0.0499226116,
-0.4391494095,
0.1586054713,
0.6597801447,
-1.0265903473,
-0.0746281669,
-0.3730581701,
-0.5646461248,
-0.4829126894,
1.0282359123,
-0.4059577584,
0.0493701957,
-0.6676003337,
-0.1440384239,
-0.595267117,
-0.4525415301,
-0.5644869804,
-0.4355024993,
0.4767417014,
0.3487355113,
0.6824817657,
0.5159366727,
0.9624091983,
0.2092458308,
0.0482282564,
0.4429467618,
-0.5023065209,
0.4048769772,
0.0312336795,
-0.4447971582,
-0.4829262197,
0.3367343545,
0.5039530396,
1.2531578541,
-0.1895087212,
0.3571831584,
0.5514832139,
0.3722400665,
-0.8344365358,
-0.1854895055,
-0.1921578646,
0.3289737105,
-0.4537882209,
-0.2587351799,
-0.0511113927,
-0.2494086623,
-0.2784381211,
-0.472591579,
0.5285485983,
-0.0857384801,
0.7179560661,
0.408490032,
-0.3128165007,
0.1907237917,
-1.0426160097,
0.7655001283,
-0.8833177686,
0.3719048798,
0.0673017576,
0.4032852352,
-0.1252173781,
-0.3709612787,
-0.5898194909,
-0.0523196869,
-0.2336407006,
-0.1361034065,
-0.3257515728,
0.3280581832,
0.3934700191,
0.3194639683,
-0.8952512741,
-0.0089847296,
-0.7084724307,
0.0373854227,
0.3802555203,
0.5733465552,
0.2161937207,
0.1447675079,
-0.7508797646,
-0.1399934888,
-0.460054487,
0.0693020076,
0.3888082802,
0.5194633007,
0.0423014835,
0.5041589737,
-0.0644381121,
1.0834331512,
-0.0347316712,
-0.1705684066,
0.0746260285,
-0.7068277597,
-0.4071874321,
-0.5521582365,
0.4123010635,
0.724612236,
-0.1962400526,
-0.135019511,
-0.2708185017,
0.2285637408,
0.3612997234,
-0.2902229726,
-0.1242554262,
0.0336770006,
-0.8309358358,
-0.0026542742,
-0.1752268672,
-0.663428247,
-0.3977042735,
-0.8300368786,
0.5418803096,
0.1310436875,
-0.211319685,
0.2620561421,
-0.177338466,
0.2196807116,
0.494826287,
-0.4902438521,
0.7480719686,
0.9904546738,
0.9144813418,
-0.3675318062,
-0.3112381101,
-0.6928319335,
-0.2092278004,
-0.4891705513,
0.4035277963,
-0.239606604,
-0.4106573761,
0.0526704863,
-0.1863225698,
-0.1386181563,
-0.6492225528,
0.224315837,
-0.4630310237,
0.3103263676,
-0.4761546254,
-0.3506005108,
-0.4034582078,
0.2246958613,
-0.5862393379,
1.1499345303,
0.0700846463,
-0.2819193304,
0.2326145768,
-0.4644674361,
-0.0728958994,
0.0647790581,
0.0459075496,
-0.2995717525,
0.0258038603,
-0.3903128207,
0.8486405611,
-0.7387367487,
0.0478397422,
-0.6168029308,
-0.2251081467,
-0.1029105932,
0.0662532374,
0.6813184023,
0.3083848655,
0.0303701088,
0.1509526074,
-0.2630587518,
-0.0471432731,
-0.194923833,
0.1120450869,
-0.3804524839,
-0.1006404459,
0.1698224396,
0.4289377332,
0.3965875506,
-0.3656327128,
0.3148090541,
0.2856377065,
0.2692758739,
0.3641523421,
-0.0421180055,
0.6280626655,
-0.9234900475,
0.7756202221,
-0.0041026408,
0.1888965964,
0.1681843698,
-0.6099268794,
-0.6935729384,
-0.1526536047,
-0.0185954794,
0.227516517,
-0.1946174651,
-0.127995342,
-0.1733122021,
-0.8525304794,
-0.1106398329,
0.0908154547,
0.6722501516,
0.5973728299,
0.4140154719,
-0.3857658803,
-0.5291292667,
-1.1673862934,
-0.0580236614,
0.1312304735,
-0.0266827438,
0.3227901459,
0.4130395055,
0.156693235,
0.76018852,
-0.8112208247,
-0.5833206177,
0.0362220518,
0.0946348086,
0.4730593562,
1.0648680925,
0.7353086472,
-0.6954766512,
-0.3539010882,
0.0367344692,
-0.6076108813,
0.2844042182,
0.0346367694,
-0.2169866413,
-0.6404790282,
0.9461138248,
-0.7803790569,
0.3711417913,
0.6807553768,
-0.0125981374,
0.3853079081,
-0.1839474738,
0.4167397916,
-1.2590324879,
0.2854653299,
0.1455388516,
-0.4144528508,
-0.9013831019,
0.3104354441,
0.046983771,
-0.6279748678,
-0.3443059325,
0.3104226589,
-0.643001914,
-0.2200295925,
-0.4392266572,
0.0662884191,
-0.0990109295,
0.7010329962,
-0.7263769507,
0.4037822187,
0.4218109548,
-0.5453013182,
0.512915194,
0.1630344987,
0.0118000321,
0.7421580553,
-0.315187484,
0.2488251925,
-0.3668398857,
0.3460871577,
-1.1578255892,
-0.1395690441,
0.3021759987,
-0.2030329406,
0.1076883674,
-0.2444753051,
-0.1061807275,
-0.2563726306,
-0.2752536535,
0.9190546274,
0.5649291873,
-0.1778416783,
0.7915648818,
0.1284628808,
-0.1854046434,
-0.5905120373,
-0.7337588668,
-0.0971623659,
-0.2682716548,
-0.5279927254,
0.8838856816,
-0.2185906023,
0.0224133804,
0.460716486,
-0.2109202892,
-0.2683272064,
-0.0530201793,
0.2952557504,
0.503708005,
-0.3609905243,
-0.2521653175,
-0.004040258,
-0.0305759832,
-0.1878068447,
-0.1755728424,
0.3811862171,
0.503103137,
-0.5058362484,
-0.4138242006,
0.9316084385,
0.9811290503,
-0.5289934874,
0.5904870629,
0.1706713289,
-0.8808687925,
-0.3149088621,
-0.6633176804,
-0.053569857,
-0.3825916052,
0.2684620917,
-0.4435727596,
-0.7520771623,
0.9623392224,
-0.0311089568,
0.2583415508,
0.2697234154,
0.2081440687,
-0.1105338261,
0.7632092834,
0.8418368697,
0.1686417013,
0.5376887918,
-0.2913305461,
0.2980246842,
-1.0724306107,
-0.4770010114,
-0.686093688,
-0.7785865068,
-0.1613890678,
-0.7946407199,
0.357280314,
0.0614453144,
-0.2163369507,
0.5440419912,
-0.4294796586,
0.3206573725,
0.5931234956,
0.2586836815,
0.0422588885,
-0.3322975636,
-0.0292366706,
-0.1215773895,
-0.7036552429,
0.0575616248,
0.8023870587,
0.1482940763,
0.5479422808,
0.1608457863,
0.6925401688,
0.2360827178,
0.1435789615,
-0.5136092305,
0.7543237209,
-0.4181728363,
-0.4202693403,
-0.032120619,
-0.2477873862,
-0.9181478024,
0.5265293717,
-0.403141886,
-0.5785915256,
0.7949815392,
0.2946191728,
-0.7858000398,
0.2837959826,
-0.3652629852,
0.895278275,
0.2433763295,
-0.1947342902,
-0.3689649701,
-0.4787270129,
0.6614333391,
0.001646357,
0.2055715472,
-0.4541155994,
-0.139096424,
0.9131623507,
-0.4403608441,
0.5453317761,
-0.2737296522,
0.1308959424,
-0.2270122617,
0.4227040112,
0.3632207215,
-0.3652691245,
0.2824510336,
-0.1026863307,
0.0562566109,
-0.3427278399,
-0.9527511597,
0.8379671574,
-0.2908779681,
-0.4719538987,
-0.2159976363,
-0.8031344414,
-0.2198508233,
0.1226023883,
-0.0265848469,
0.9097141623,
0.1945383698,
0.1478375494,
0.4205268025,
0.5470309258,
0.3323344588,
0.5146702528,
-0.2881654203,
-0.235441044,
0.6148381233,
-0.0436427146,
0.3479071259,
0.1323139369,
-0.1950155199,
0.0949511975,
-0.4991047084,
0.0204689037,
0.228441298,
-0.8152182698,
-0.6826922297,
-0.127973184,
-0.1789147109,
0.0855524465,
-0.4129881859,
-0.3931933939,
-0.0751716495,
-0.369982928,
0.3962168396,
-0.1464585662,
0.7943153381,
-0.1678900272,
0.2587524652,
-0.9019770026,
0.453245759,
0.2759631276,
0.4349732399,
-0.0009821216,
-0.2145313919,
-0.3420262635,
0.1293570101,
-0.1155151874,
-1.3230075836,
0.1874842197,
0.1146119758,
0.6931410432,
0.1106882095,
-0.1741777658,
0.9070783854,
-0.4040017128,
0.7344005704,
0.5759707093,
-0.9264048934,
0.1573132724,
-0.4427836537,
-0.1283329427,
0.3783428967,
0.4472119212,
-0.7397786379,
-0.1868759543,
-0.4555298984,
-0.6630954146,
0.7334996462,
0.1708426327,
-0.0790193751,
0.57188344,
0.4854755998,
-0.1937995404,
0.1726428121,
-0.4146539569,
-0.3352480531,
0.3921174109,
-0.4001475871,
-0.3832931817,
0.0728247687,
-0.5824793577,
-0.12601614,
0.3072225451,
-0.0564720854,
0.3070349693,
-0.030777419,
0.045513045,
-0.2600218952,
-0.3201887012,
0.6555392146,
0.3989217281,
-0.0365667641,
0.1268740743,
-0.054141093,
0.0676647648,
0.3783820868,
0.3773579001,
0.1288429648,
0.0275334641,
0.268933028,
0.7417728305,
0.4865578115,
-0.1698650122,
0.5900612473,
-0.0217972919,
-0.6654002666,
0.2642782629,
0.1022206694,
-0.0448770411,
0.540171206,
0.3464769721,
0.994145453,
0.3544487357,
-0.3067507446,
0.0458278358,
0.9445300102,
-0.3552485108,
-0.0800426751,
0.9297605753,
0.1691644341,
-0.3884600997,
0.3622900546,
-0.0452315584,
-0.443308264,
0.6930180192,
0.2156009674,
0.898637712,
-0.1826832741,
-0.0343915708,
0.234229669,
0.1470108479,
-0.4428251386,
0.1422757208,
-0.3132027686,
-0.5578900576,
-0.7613511682,
-0.247164607,
-0.5611459017,
0.0592057854,
-0.8912721276,
0.263833642,
-0.148765251,
-0.2992649972,
0.2188049406,
-0.2994038463,
-0.7555437088,
0.214433521,
0.1892233789,
0.4994846582,
-1.1437106133,
0.3305951655,
0.8873099089,
-0.3394848406,
-0.8753088713,
-0.0053399764,
-0.1267831028,
-0.310544163,
0.4835489094,
-0.0967881754,
-0.0971474573,
-0.0917135999,
-0.3386049867,
-1.3106622696,
0.9616879225,
0.725695014,
-0.251134634,
-0.3331825435,
-0.1691699624,
0.1094242185,
-0.2636761963,
-0.1547524929,
0.3414464891,
0.1377987564,
-0.1822512299,
-1.3620350361,
0.3919915855,
-0.3996393681,
0.0987263024,
0.6372705102,
-0.4472687542,
1.4122694731,
0.0879754871,
-0.184798032,
0.128139168,
0.5033957362,
-0.0392752625,
0.1323218644,
0.690438211,
0.4580508769,
0.6331201792,
-0.0949303135,
0.5113012195,
-0.4336729944,
0.8873631954,
0.7683292627,
-0.1980412006,
0.8007315993,
0.3513900042,
-0.3392595351,
0.3736504912,
0.4112919271,
0.2475755066,
0.3975368142,
0.0587454475,
-0.0982027501,
-0.4770050347,
0.0810940266,
-0.4499220848,
0.2714599371,
-0.027740309,
0.0248046964,
-0.6152250171,
0.3457718492,
-0.1649680585,
0.1513693333,
-0.2195910215,
0.4928497076,
-0.0865716785,
-1.1123236418,
0.4941020012,
-0.1210203245,
0.6120695472,
-0.7018204927,
-0.2118447125,
-0.1588807851,
0.280824542,
-0.1990501881,
-0.6318856478,
0.455555141,
-0.6190922856,
-0.4902247787,
-0.5728167892,
0.6492031217,
-0.7702635527,
-0.1244542673,
0.2958796918,
0.4391588271,
-0.1912326813,
0.0667811334,
-0.4862571359,
0.2409597188,
-0.1010602713,
0.3179225922,
0.3451664746,
-0.4297662079,
0.3022032082,
0.6251037121,
0.6820362806,
-0.1961477995,
-0.0612151325,
-0.5664635897,
0.9652357101,
-0.3075151742,
-0.590988934,
-0.5523457527,
0.6927236915,
0.2203863859,
-0.5101350546,
0.5280196071,
0.5994397998,
0.6209244132,
-0.2577038109,
0.5497636795,
0.107628338,
0.6469729543,
-0.6125901937,
0.3102020621,
-1.2347410917,
-0.0788083524,
-0.3173377216,
-1.0735265017,
-0.2590177059,
0.1949546635,
0.085989289,
0.1978452206,
0.9142325521,
0.8492226005,
-0.4311512709,
-0.4081485569,
0.3205660582,
-0.415745765,
0.1665517986,
0.8206830025,
0.5551550984,
-0.3294835091,
0.2581684291,
-0.3361551762,
-0.3400893509,
-0.3398689926,
-0.7777568698,
-0.424526155,
-1.1385298967,
-0.3600241244,
-0.5119684935,
0.1829431951,
0.7830269337,
0.9506930113,
-0.4216194153,
-0.4464274943,
-0.0605253316,
-0.1871261597,
-0.6335279942,
-0.1471034437,
0.0802816302,
-0.4461066127,
-0.7501432896,
0.5064789653,
0.1345295906,
-0.159710899,
-0.4295179248,
0.1419446766,
-0.0360219702,
0.1066067591,
0.0817188472,
0.3035303354,
-0.6500864029,
0.1778146029,
0.1141824648,
-0.2136879116,
-0.1488308012,
1.3312089443,
-0.6923813224,
0.4274816811,
0.6942225099,
0.5557425022,
0.6395734549,
0.0205032304,
0.7824901938,
-0.7571003437,
0.0725308433,
0.3201497495,
0.5906407833,
0.2523973882,
-0.1771334857,
0.1720113754,
0.1948217154,
-0.4591274559,
-1.038487792,
0.3424890637,
-1.2092728615,
-0.0457748435,
0.8164263368,
0.096234411,
0.1926244348,
0.0800861046,
-0.1240612119,
0.1074648947,
0.161633119,
0.0542723499,
0.446307689,
-0.2724476457,
-0.0736570731,
-0.5519152284,
0.7450783253,
0.7475817204,
-0.6194176078,
0.0312284045,
0.3484346271,
0.1772321463,
0.2486784905,
0.6124428511,
0.4017755389,
0.6658433676,
-0.0496489108,
0.2260072231,
-0.0526521578,
-0.127847299,
-0.4624375999,
0.4034013152,
-0.0356206819,
-0.7718503475
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04333v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04333v4
|
Is Bigger and Deeper Always Better? Probing LLaMA Across Scales and Layers
| 2023-12-07T14:50:41 | 2024-01-09T07:33:07 |
Nuo Chen, Ning Wu, Shining Liang, Ming Gong, Linjun Shou, Dongmei Zhang, Jia Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents an in-depth analysis of Large Language Models (LLMs),
focusing on LLaMA, a prominent open-source foundational model in natural
language processing. Instead of assessing LLaMA through its generative output,
we design multiple-choice tasks to probe its intrinsic understanding in
high-order tasks such as reasoning and computation. We examine the model
horizontally, comparing different sizes, and vertically, assessing different
layers. We unveil several key and uncommon findings based on the designed
probing tasks: (1) Horizontally, enlarging model sizes almost could not
automatically impart additional knowledge or computational prowess. Instead, it
can enhance reasoning abilities, especially in math problem solving, and helps
reduce hallucinations, but only beyond certain size thresholds; (2) In vertical
analysis, the lower layers of LLaMA lack substantial arithmetic and factual
knowledge, showcasing logical thinking, multilingual and recognitive abilities,
with top layers housing most computational power and real-world knowledge.
|
[
-0.5238249302,
-1.0291303396,
0.7476273775,
0.3062956035,
-0.2039632797,
0.212387085,
-0.4435878396,
-0.6942871809,
0.086563319,
0.5334265828,
-0.2873592377,
-0.1863557249,
-0.9251379967,
0.0946775079,
-0.4337938726,
0.7763228416,
0.1220242009,
-0.2171947658,
-0.391343683,
-0.0447160862,
-0.5491971374,
-0.3762713075,
-0.8313516974,
-0.5105225444,
0.6726639271,
0.5124102831,
0.8181524873,
0.7636691928,
0.7979480624,
0.4054802358,
-0.4656096697,
0.3136679232,
-0.7209447026,
0.1164942458,
0.0557739474,
-0.5912125707,
-0.2902669609,
0.0437513776,
0.6358177066,
0.9006360173,
-0.0970540196,
0.4615032077,
-0.172469914,
0.6931494474,
-0.4377492368,
0.0524425246,
-0.693449378,
-0.0052132909,
0.0217958372,
0.1119153947,
-0.29706496,
-0.187344417,
0.204059124,
-0.3241122067,
-0.2043970227,
0.0671868622,
0.737452805,
0.5057945848,
-0.8257136941,
-0.202104643,
-0.6030219793,
1.0107390881,
-0.649833262,
0.3276368976,
0.3486468792,
0.3796108365,
0.0012173355,
-0.6221368313,
-0.5235674381,
-0.5160354972,
-0.0536072701,
-0.2765555084,
-0.4577452242,
-0.1312628835,
0.291258961,
0.6616262794,
-0.4444088638,
0.448168546,
-0.445289731,
-0.120922938,
0.6983707547,
0.2095810771,
0.3927672207,
-0.052732382,
-0.2000494897,
-0.0984679312,
-0.7851272821,
0.250058502,
0.3399887383,
0.1766982377,
-0.1289962679,
0.8002051115,
-0.0197830331,
0.6742939949,
-0.0424979962,
-0.3616034985,
-0.0851623192,
-0.2024795711,
-0.394264847,
0.0046127029,
0.5833492875,
0.1980739981,
0.4368263781,
-0.0318168812,
-0.0455482416,
0.0661689043,
0.3677469492,
-0.7711083293,
-0.0873540938,
0.3413518965,
-0.3826776445,
-0.261318177,
-0.3414210677,
-0.4658859074,
-0.5574555993,
-0.4334866703,
0.379370153,
-0.1156973317,
-0.3218918443,
0.5241932273,
0.0614547729,
0.376197964,
0.2448210567,
-0.6875244379,
0.3495012522,
0.98802495,
0.7739949822,
-0.028125694,
-0.2881256044,
-0.4358025789,
-0.0360946916,
-0.6944443583,
0.8968945146,
-0.7867208123,
-0.3131173849,
-0.3685997725,
-0.3346065283,
0.2032499015,
-0.6324334145,
0.5806759596,
-0.5095875263,
0.1452820003,
-0.4519159198,
-0.2952919304,
-0.3291271329,
0.3816561997,
-0.7698670626,
1.044537425,
-0.1231139153,
-0.7842387557,
0.2362439334,
-0.6572688222,
-0.3640787899,
-0.1452797204,
-0.2848426402,
-0.1995871514,
0.2801928818,
0.5194372535,
0.4510408342,
-0.6087951064,
0.4203309417,
-0.2030251473,
-0.3544680178,
0.3066065609,
-0.2170692086,
0.8916671276,
0.0644517913,
-0.4197803736,
0.1592799276,
-0.6553028226,
-0.0332410634,
0.4573121965,
-0.4448293746,
-0.2347775251,
0.0612261109,
-0.4260411561,
-0.0072521293,
0.3198875189,
-0.6709526777,
0.2282628715,
-0.3680354953,
0.5904343724,
0.7157664895,
-0.2323872596,
0.6027153134,
-0.1780519187,
0.4238162637,
-0.1430893987,
0.0383302458,
0.0883051902,
-0.484585762,
-1.0124331713,
-0.3837364316,
0.1277343333,
0.4432995319,
-0.266449213,
0.1993348002,
-0.4226020575,
-0.7465233803,
-0.4937029481,
0.2764835656,
0.3243406415,
0.356012404,
0.1820441484,
-0.1637567282,
-0.5511382222,
-1.1410989761,
-0.1838644892,
-0.2791822255,
-0.0852773562,
0.3944604099,
0.6541360021,
-0.4822809398,
0.6571568847,
-0.5694340467,
-0.2034753412,
-0.4310449064,
-0.0917294845,
0.3846167326,
0.0794094652,
0.5229359269,
-0.5484828949,
-0.1671920717,
0.2640126944,
-0.6272364855,
-0.1154750884,
-0.028273249,
-0.2501507998,
-0.3481995165,
0.3466004133,
-0.9480650425,
0.1472923607,
0.7114155889,
-0.1478917152,
0.3574832678,
-0.1444832087,
-0.3251095414,
-0.7340322137,
-0.1558699459,
0.0013214173,
0.1047132015,
-0.6909925938,
0.4070202112,
0.1774892062,
0.0661135688,
-0.0945762098,
0.4391546249,
-0.6166609526,
-0.3677583039,
-0.33291924,
0.0946051925,
0.0433381386,
0.2719825506,
-0.2171489894,
0.8555330634,
0.6154469252,
-0.5681393147,
0.3071205914,
-0.09389171,
-0.7824698091,
0.1302936673,
-0.8748584986,
0.4145341814,
-0.1994895339,
0.2902312875,
-1.2149537802,
-0.2063000649,
-0.292773217,
-0.4478746951,
0.1619849801,
0.1971913427,
-0.5831407309,
-0.4830622375,
-0.4472945035,
0.5205828547,
0.3705234528,
-0.6770150661,
0.5887274742,
0.6142712235,
-0.1539983451,
-0.7414419651,
-0.787340045,
0.297224611,
-0.4018837214,
-0.73157233,
0.1163420007,
-0.2149250954,
-0.8332558274,
-0.361081332,
-0.1247076914,
-0.0723274127,
0.2176069319,
0.1535819322,
0.1273486167,
-0.662737608,
0.063823007,
0.0420154482,
0.2113869339,
0.2784950733,
0.0494994931,
0.5600297451,
-0.544605732,
-0.2885484397,
-0.2596002519,
0.3202727735,
0.7232495546,
-0.4464466572,
0.6694819927,
0.3118000031,
-0.2845935524,
-0.1588792801,
-0.8236334324,
-0.0580902845,
-0.5303530693,
0.2578070462,
-0.4784767032,
-1.2670036554,
0.524708271,
0.1665368676,
0.0582794361,
0.5027795434,
0.604321897,
0.040665824,
1.0763123035,
0.8100866675,
-0.4327782393,
0.095753774,
-0.3712175786,
0.5302934051,
-0.9299461246,
-0.1708543152,
-0.4953281283,
-0.3166019022,
-0.3331232667,
-0.5075554252,
0.2716549337,
-0.041067943,
-0.5577350855,
0.1016886681,
-0.4373596907,
0.855484128,
0.2514571846,
-0.0490140468,
0.3493438959,
0.0379993208,
0.0706115216,
0.1333065629,
-0.4257656634,
-0.641448915,
1.0103498697,
0.7125917077,
0.6054012775,
0.2809292972,
0.3471492231,
-0.0826488882,
0.2390699238,
-1.0819745064,
0.6607828736,
0.0265362766,
-0.6451001763,
-0.5212460756,
-0.3897467256,
-1.062271595,
0.6307593584,
0.1174908578,
-0.6461024284,
0.0177785326,
-0.1691149473,
-0.3530952632,
0.601018846,
-0.7041488886,
0.340769738,
-0.4050782621,
0.0063622496,
-0.2405404299,
-0.4617859125,
0.6050899625,
-0.0204812121,
0.4185702801,
-0.0165494662,
-0.4458885193,
0.4943142235,
0.042503722,
0.987357676,
0.3167076707,
-0.7052119374,
0.436368227,
0.4779848456,
0.3174811602,
0.1700817049,
-0.0858923867,
0.2162983119,
-0.361759305,
-0.4705031812,
-0.5521370769,
0.7326130271,
-1.0012993813,
-0.9534906745,
-0.095110327,
-0.6415112019,
-0.1365367919,
0.0481958129,
-0.1151659042,
0.3712368011,
0.0839257836,
0.5415322781,
0.7794501185,
-0.1333675683,
0.2024290264,
0.2305950969,
-0.1668389291,
0.0074269585,
0.6918962002,
0.1203410551,
0.1915962994,
0.6248383522,
0.5656462908,
-0.056975957,
-0.7283665538,
-0.4168596566,
0.5230452418,
-0.7727195621,
-0.1062243581,
-0.7618220448,
-0.18729496,
-0.3744176328,
-0.0822192281,
-0.4149886668,
-0.2554634809,
-0.2568623126,
-0.4618899822,
0.3427455425,
0.9096153975,
0.022470681,
0.2451564968,
-0.339117676,
0.3803012669,
0.7347819209,
0.1518124789,
0.2752907276,
-0.5866087675,
0.131956771,
-0.0850946307,
-0.0877331644,
-0.6403477192,
0.350073874,
0.0716385022,
0.5572575927,
0.422080785,
-0.3696998954,
0.7440087795,
-0.4968408644,
0.8388341069,
-0.0537313446,
-0.8573415279,
0.3337196112,
-0.3387479484,
0.4571178257,
0.2245550901,
0.4180520773,
-0.383174181,
-0.2201028913,
-0.2618532181,
-0.7620671391,
0.3036811352,
0.0908688158,
0.4260571897,
0.0582096986,
0.3759408891,
0.3013420105,
0.1932465583,
-0.9422702193,
0.0590175614,
0.1628781706,
0.1120009869,
-0.3820302188,
-0.3991468251,
-0.1800083965,
-0.4394842684,
0.2432912588,
-0.1130439565,
0.2521761656,
-0.0676203892,
-0.1208649725,
-0.1580198109,
0.2381694913,
0.5647267699,
0.7895766497,
0.0261849519,
0.4692352712,
0.4709062278,
-0.5314975977,
-0.1403666288,
-0.4440546334,
0.3884523809,
-0.4653752148,
0.7493083477,
0.724781394,
0.1671937108,
-0.8362018466,
0.3692721128,
-0.0740116909,
-0.2877504528,
-0.0959782526,
0.0414437056,
0.408242017,
0.454152137,
0.3112490177,
-0.3990342617,
0.1734132767,
-0.7178256512,
-0.4065353274,
0.448910892,
-0.0687657446,
-0.1064329445,
0.1774085015,
-0.0646212026,
-0.2798342109,
0.6901512742,
0.2850069106,
-0.4809879065,
0.9001483321,
0.4807657301,
0.4851324856,
-0.0330544636,
0.2012105584,
0.2623125315,
0.6954861283,
-0.0348171219,
0.121778436,
-0.4233925045,
-0.6774415374,
-0.7051586509,
-0.5610035658,
-0.4184511304,
0.4844449759,
-0.4067747891,
-0.2349120975,
-0.5125007629,
0.0017410605,
0.03880959,
0.2639905214,
-0.5499997139,
0.2800819874,
0.197999537,
0.8373031616,
-0.5714772344,
0.666772902,
0.6012737155,
-0.2559628487,
-0.7807102799,
-0.1913222224,
-0.0793438032,
-0.9727461338,
0.9010812044,
0.316300422,
-0.4121682942,
-0.2862348855,
-0.8099505305,
-1.4024721384,
0.9972152114,
0.4800032377,
-0.4006792605,
-0.0564070866,
0.2026951164,
0.8458548784,
-0.437253952,
0.3000309467,
0.7279837728,
0.4059926569,
-0.0937084556,
-1.0471779108,
0.0078991996,
-0.2823620141,
0.0437737033,
0.2215010524,
-0.715174377,
1.1103844643,
-0.5018287897,
-0.1481973827,
0.1585743576,
0.6884921789,
0.2104061842,
-0.0229029078,
0.6288394332,
0.5832307339,
0.7742363214,
0.1609036773,
1.3285050392,
0.1889743954,
0.0046650767,
0.9761232734,
-0.2581992447,
1.0000126362,
0.5108677149,
-0.1641985625,
0.6085538268,
0.8484105468,
0.2967037857,
0.1849088967,
0.5330700874,
0.0109988861,
-0.350345403,
-0.0116418442,
-0.4193674028,
0.6370505095,
0.5190802813,
-0.0749699995,
-0.0014652632,
-0.1109268516,
0.0168105494,
0.0207975879,
-0.37328282,
0.672432065,
0.1866281331,
-0.5778198242,
0.5541492105,
-0.0409129448,
0.6804965734,
-0.3854132891,
0.2245093584,
-0.4677619934,
0.061173249,
-0.067015022,
-0.9895768166,
0.0572285317,
0.1836551577,
0.0546968766,
-0.0573282503,
0.8538472056,
-0.0605606139,
-0.4541259706,
0.5151734352,
0.5350960493,
0.1759839654,
-0.1745248884,
-0.5371941924,
0.320124656,
-0.2822092175,
-0.520221591,
0.2594687939,
0.5504401922,
-0.1850232035,
0.9783306718,
0.67616117,
0.0406526811,
0.2296324372,
0.2696064711,
0.9361318946,
-0.5524368286,
-0.2310510874,
-0.8736301064,
0.294301182,
-0.1964770406,
-0.2789870799,
0.8101341724,
0.4487577379,
0.9703837037,
0.1481925845,
0.3679927588,
0.4486121535,
0.3314573169,
-0.3614113331,
0.4293487668,
-0.6667351723,
0.2548979521,
-0.1755044311,
-1.0274932384,
-0.3704569638,
0.8256195784,
-0.6736690402,
-0.0986727402,
0.6282355785,
0.6363586783,
-0.1499983966,
0.1840040386,
0.3127678633,
0.3746601641,
0.3981949985,
0.5845985413,
1.2655314207,
-0.073895745,
0.4960448742,
-0.2620861232,
-0.1674433649,
-0.0787814707,
-0.7127474546,
-1.2672463655,
-0.4120874405,
0.0130450502,
0.2075537592,
-0.4054932892,
0.5881464481,
0.5926753879,
-0.3510295153,
-0.6051651239,
0.1139530316,
0.1780874878,
0.0730636567,
-0.1543389112,
0.2247636914,
-0.1114594117,
-0.5069306493,
0.5723733306,
0.4113001525,
-0.1380792856,
-0.5532643795,
0.2397455573,
-0.146846205,
0.3656183779,
1.0927834511,
-0.0408541374,
-0.9119059443,
-0.4141698778,
0.1267895103,
-0.0916382149,
0.0978172347,
0.8058152199,
-0.5719656348,
0.2138523459,
0.4975013137,
1.0516803265,
0.4968631268,
-0.3956623077,
0.2361321598,
-0.3123438656,
-0.091589503,
0.1117954105,
0.2882322669,
0.3927609622,
-0.5858727098,
0.5757288337,
-0.3732582331,
-0.5994330049,
-1.0605493784,
0.3366339505,
-0.9670584202,
-0.4934582114,
1.2987881899,
0.2896074951,
-0.3205902874,
0.2591612637,
-0.6151288152,
0.0208420586,
-0.1584833115,
0.9412941933,
0.8537392616,
-0.1472393274,
-0.0865028501,
-0.7207180858,
0.0745457932,
0.5239048004,
-0.9040814042,
-0.0621901043,
0.3867771626,
0.0411897823,
0.3180510998,
0.4540652633,
-0.0576950721,
0.0269504823,
-0.1048480645,
-0.5827943683,
0.0515155941,
-0.6219965816,
-0.3821099699,
0.3835029304,
0.1333880723,
0.2537845075
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04306v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04306v1
|
nerblackbox: A High-level Library for Named Entity Recognition in Python
| 2023-12-07T14:04:15 | 2023-12-07T14:04:15 |
Felix Stollenwerk
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
We present nerblackbox, a python library to facilitate the use of
state-of-the-art transformer-based models for named entity recognition. It
provides simple-to-use yet powerful methods to access data and models from a
wide range of sources, for fully automated model training and evaluation as
well as versatile model inference. While many technical challenges are solved
and hidden from the user by default, nerblackbox also offers fine-grained
control and a rich set of customizable features. It is thus targeted both at
application-oriented developers as well as machine learning experts and
researchers.
|
[
-0.5208508968,
-0.7990153432,
-0.0777175575,
0.1989744753,
0.0286696348,
0.14597179,
0.3162533939,
-0.5501258373,
0.4494092762,
0.646030128,
-0.4777709246,
-0.3920572102,
-0.5888456106,
0.2179538608,
-0.9028813839,
1.0502938032,
0.1218618304,
-0.2106179148,
-0.0228738058,
0.2472503483,
-0.5053315759,
-0.3107125163,
-0.7511347532,
-0.5363277197,
0.6868651509,
0.3185287714,
0.7208579779,
0.2190681994,
0.4755508006,
0.2281796634,
-0.2758703232,
-0.3848692179,
-0.2488732338,
0.3373671174,
-0.418671757,
-0.5787675977,
-0.4781547189,
-0.2056140155,
0.5728063583,
0.3618585765,
-0.2312084883,
0.3768607676,
-0.1997635663,
0.3800137341,
-0.9006457925,
0.1540487558,
-0.7937543392,
0.4475880265,
-0.2040221989,
-0.0081019597,
-0.594080925,
-0.5417107344,
0.3255250752,
-0.5849511623,
0.3496854603,
0.30763641,
1.1759058237,
0.3158976138,
-0.3454251587,
-0.4322041571,
-0.4097596705,
0.5852738619,
-0.5548458099,
0.466371268,
0.369463861,
0.7622441053,
-0.3190954924,
-0.8066189885,
-0.4235278368,
-0.0988951474,
-0.1679399312,
-0.2381805331,
-0.6833776832,
-0.0320238732,
0.4608660936,
0.1800818443,
-0.44652161,
0.2771895826,
-0.3283677697,
-0.5045391917,
0.3100632429,
0.2476289868,
0.2847411335,
-0.4207602739,
-0.2177842259,
0.1913923472,
-0.7037097216,
0.2195953131,
0.4988366365,
0.1270840764,
0.1905290484,
0.5686495304,
-0.3152866066,
0.7607240677,
0.2458510399,
0.100290589,
0.2022619247,
0.2577434182,
-0.4017860293,
0.5696742535,
0.4980136156,
0.0265792105,
-0.2495120615,
-0.2389879823,
-0.3359377682,
-0.3870165944,
0.4187479615,
-1.2315722704,
-0.6406430006,
0.339056164,
-0.5672997236,
-0.4643951952,
0.1034670919,
-1.0726733208,
-0.682005167,
-0.0924041718,
0.5156531334,
-0.282037735,
-0.3255429864,
-0.0904264599,
-0.247949332,
0.2717088461,
0.6471269131,
-0.8473374248,
0.2264994979,
0.6045923233,
0.7295435667,
0.0289964844,
-0.0982209668,
-0.8220558167,
0.0711749941,
-0.2550081313,
1.1371988058,
-0.8518101573,
-0.0499238186,
-0.0980744064,
0.4856331646,
0.3367418051,
-0.7185618877,
0.3003018796,
-0.6282536387,
0.0670779124,
0.4469748735,
-0.5066702366,
-0.5188304186,
0.1279942989,
-1.0542998314,
0.9405570626,
0.0325327441,
-0.9292061925,
0.2795660198,
-0.4983943403,
-0.4135169685,
0.6826591492,
0.1474073231,
-0.8692367077,
0.2532976568,
0.0594589561,
0.5927160978,
-0.3938269317,
0.5462796688,
-0.397934556,
-0.3073482513,
0.3790694177,
-0.1784824282,
0.9522345066,
0.2968186736,
-0.1753842831,
0.0054102787,
-1.0327459574,
-0.0501404554,
-0.0603056625,
-0.3780063093,
-0.3642707765,
-0.1741804481,
0.4732263982,
-0.141125232,
0.190240413,
-0.5517362952,
0.2688027024,
-0.026619494,
0.8458725214,
0.4510197639,
-0.2264819741,
0.3554958701,
0.1985601634,
0.7898265123,
-0.0582807735,
-0.0555170961,
-0.2684957683,
-0.5519021153,
-0.6468052268,
-0.2694872022,
0.7453289032,
0.477001667,
-0.696513772,
0.5001186132,
0.0674964711,
-0.813138485,
-0.5275471807,
-0.1374047101,
-0.062275514,
0.4549326301,
0.4363199472,
-0.0258203037,
-0.7047761679,
-1.0209441185,
-0.0246240441,
0.0307807997,
-0.0254574027,
0.4248737097,
0.8631173372,
-0.6988641024,
1.2519774437,
-0.2439170927,
-0.1565028578,
-0.2761150002,
0.2406044602,
0.5868057609,
0.4793659747,
0.214727059,
-0.8705706,
-0.3947330713,
-0.0304061174,
-0.6219710112,
-0.3000202477,
0.0580794811,
-0.2471415699,
0.0538547561,
0.2711791098,
-0.7277781963,
0.5440841317,
0.4706274569,
-0.3499703705,
0.7630671263,
0.0095116608,
-0.3298543394,
-1.0181465149,
0.2366392016,
-0.2797968984,
-0.0688758716,
-0.7398142219,
-0.1476078779,
0.6154361963,
-0.4004817605,
-0.5509358644,
0.7859318256,
-0.5024654865,
-0.1263324618,
-0.355450362,
-0.2555657327,
0.0604035445,
-0.0778317824,
0.3683153689,
0.3841199875,
1.048469305,
-0.5594507456,
0.9660607576,
0.2582579255,
-0.5238575935,
1.0121380091,
-0.7139894962,
0.1646444649,
-0.3105774224,
0.2688277364,
-0.502576828,
-0.5138658881,
0.2306772918,
-0.348787725,
0.3343898952,
-0.5131317973,
-0.3965582252,
-0.5084576011,
0.1742642969,
0.2825434208,
0.3450229466,
-0.8463307619,
0.8429233432,
0.664188087,
-0.0294159781,
-0.8510591984,
-0.7135203481,
0.286149025,
-0.4179981947,
-0.1878482699,
0.2030223459,
0.1619193107,
0.1559422463,
0.2209098935,
-0.2313431352,
-0.6571353674,
0.2176241279,
0.5972294211,
0.2615167797,
-0.1749952435,
0.5627849102,
-0.0731384084,
-0.417460382,
-0.1218387708,
-0.3824477196,
0.5148076415,
-0.2335266024,
0.0794957802,
-0.4770607352,
0.0554697737,
0.134422183,
-0.4162821472,
0.6088547707,
0.7417623997,
-0.9137821198,
-0.4621955156,
-0.529753387,
-0.0157246739,
-0.4797645211,
0.4992806017,
-0.5505524278,
-0.7904047966,
0.3546349704,
0.0380564183,
-0.2241366655,
0.1505306661,
0.5031550527,
-0.2147847712,
0.3630055189,
0.5753808022,
0.0688521937,
0.3589129448,
-0.1815782189,
0.5448134542,
-0.8403428793,
-0.5147479177,
-0.7617707849,
-0.4698245227,
-0.281465143,
-0.0735220164,
-0.30925107,
0.2341512293,
-0.2123857886,
1.184612751,
-0.9878670573,
0.5914413929,
0.4959385097,
-0.2781088054,
0.1601951718,
-0.1203843206,
0.311121881,
0.1919218153,
-0.4757484794,
-0.4985275269,
0.8922221065,
0.4805582464,
1.4393808842,
-0.040839307,
1.063775897,
0.1955293119,
0.2670637667,
-0.929333806,
0.5833388567,
0.3474366963,
-1.0348985195,
-0.2792905569,
-0.3496944606,
-1.4863576889,
0.1555692405,
-0.3497279584,
-0.9614655375,
0.3766125143,
0.0325621031,
-0.451734215,
0.3757688403,
-0.6781451702,
1.0395768881,
-0.023038974,
-0.1446672529,
-0.043273773,
-0.1761755496,
0.1024460942,
-0.1559287161,
0.0467731506,
-0.3394325674,
0.0036126433,
0.8261739612,
0.0500010327,
0.5569044948,
-0.1975244284,
-0.0169141367,
0.2503223419,
0.4553653002,
0.3460169435,
0.5877946019,
0.078221783,
0.4520204365,
0.3716419935,
-0.248501718,
-0.5090792775,
0.7545903921,
-0.4809825718,
-0.3393575847,
-0.5223158598,
-0.7860469818,
0.5497172475,
0.7153307796,
0.0700175911,
0.6096433401,
-0.070524238,
0.731913507,
0.7478020191,
-0.6088465452,
0.4924158454,
0.6774411798,
-0.4345852435,
-0.4327671826,
0.9962173104,
0.3070827723,
-0.3937141299,
0.8552503586,
-0.0457883216,
-0.261376977,
-0.5171434879,
-0.2369311601,
-0.0046330593,
-0.7922335863,
-0.4736280441,
-0.86175704,
-0.3426168561,
-0.2469488233,
-0.0526606701,
-0.2515179813,
-0.4623767138,
-0.27689448,
-0.0973682702,
0.1746039838,
0.9994568229,
0.2947722971,
0.2312301844,
-0.6392652988,
0.3909896612,
0.3286163211,
0.4620945752,
-0.1541857421,
-0.2065289021,
-0.2523976564,
-0.3900472224,
-0.3197634816,
-1.2400038242,
0.5195050836,
0.0723733008,
0.8647253513,
0.320563823,
0.0637112856,
0.4225298166,
-0.4410681427,
0.4762559533,
0.0833004192,
-0.9583104253,
0.7392177582,
0.3094840944,
0.0964894965,
0.0092501305,
0.4243522286,
-0.5560392737,
-0.1247757822,
-0.7576156855,
-0.534630537,
0.8224152327,
0.1406525522,
-0.0545885153,
0.2136504501,
0.0960533842,
0.3705571592,
0.5062567592,
-0.9813883901,
-0.0254049636,
-0.4836278558,
-0.107302323,
0.0924895182,
-0.1610187888,
0.119989261,
-0.2163671851,
0.7652267218,
-0.0719601586,
0.46510759,
-0.1572132409,
-0.6483982801,
0.0748101473,
0.4301058948,
-0.0108303828,
0.2654114366,
-0.3935951889,
0.4515224993,
0.2454694659,
-0.4763270915,
0.258426249,
0.337182194,
-0.350527823,
0.2880586982,
0.2900199294,
0.8184976578,
0.2757109404,
-0.6639412045,
0.2222723961,
-0.0437412262,
0.1126266047,
-0.4625159502,
0.1164162308,
0.2592802644,
0.4233976901,
0.3136338592,
0.0192266535,
0.3234139681,
-0.3729865849,
0.272072643,
0.6128843427,
-0.459286809,
-0.1145226806,
0.7279729843,
-0.0546967238,
-0.9291983843,
0.7223172188,
-0.1859703064,
-0.2307666391,
0.9537929893,
0.6714017391,
1.0604313612,
-0.2067011148,
0.3954892755,
0.5873659849,
0.3108846843,
0.1436168849,
-0.1516346186,
-0.2966277301,
-0.6941215992,
0.1794685274,
-0.8731738329,
-0.5431516171,
0.0881314278,
-0.7267177105,
0.7371730208,
-0.3959921598,
-0.4374850988,
0.3510973752,
-0.0872278586,
-0.7779386044,
-0.1689256132,
0.4261627197,
1.1375111341,
-0.4020735323,
1.3074777126,
1.0079426765,
-0.3586135507,
-0.3858826458,
-0.3093020022,
-0.1899913996,
-0.5488413572,
1.009152174,
0.7179291844,
0.1865562946,
0.2088533789,
-0.5212780833,
-1.0716588497,
1.2885512114,
0.3277960122,
-0.5712223053,
-0.3251600862,
0.0069720084,
0.3643959761,
-0.3410737813,
0.9831578135,
0.4759475887,
0.6195078492,
-0.1022649109,
-0.8929249644,
-0.1355118006,
-0.3868716955,
0.2119153887,
0.170236513,
-0.1865410209,
1.0184233189,
-0.0987027958,
-0.325805068,
-0.0652855784,
0.5354747772,
0.124387607,
0.2796474993,
0.3126215935,
0.6548281908,
0.9186441898,
-0.2998154461,
0.6310783029,
-0.1629056931,
0.7739250064,
0.9597988129,
-0.1655541509,
0.6862366796,
0.3249453902,
-0.2353602052,
0.7079457641,
0.5591409206,
-0.6006231308,
0.4737295508,
0.2477495372,
0.0998090357,
-0.147010088,
-0.0212847292,
-0.3549743593,
0.0487169027,
0.5060393214,
-0.0858994424,
-0.6151121855,
0.2205848098,
-0.3464919329,
-0.4946456552,
-0.379691869,
0.5454113483,
0.0265454687,
-0.269053638,
0.8033927083,
-0.274628371,
0.7890723944,
-0.3831445277,
-0.1488272995,
0.1152299494,
0.2270364165,
-0.6993213296,
-1.0513691902,
0.2279852182,
-0.1292662323,
-0.0525216274,
-0.0316663943,
0.8895295262,
-0.3485304415,
-0.3242825568,
0.2768054008,
-0.1234144792,
0.4285062551,
-0.0958154872,
-0.8288916349,
-0.0206313003,
-0.4018175602,
-0.1706636995,
0.2081657201,
0.2813149095,
0.1035674289,
1.1131943464,
0.5287490487,
-0.1092092097,
0.408978492,
-0.1848785579,
0.364448607,
-0.8353950381,
-0.6024441123,
-0.6813536882,
0.3975313306,
-0.1510123014,
-0.1483291984,
0.6519939899,
0.7284017205,
0.753947556,
-0.3269569874,
0.7390492558,
-0.5056964159,
0.3724069893,
-0.1746113002,
0.780965507,
-0.4289941192,
-0.007736336,
-0.1757484823,
-1.1724779606,
-0.2978791595,
0.8723438978,
-0.1901383102,
-0.5851480961,
0.5740433931,
1.0229115486,
-0.191882655,
0.2649199069,
0.2617205083,
0.2678447366,
0.5164588094,
0.8943060637,
1.1950986385,
-0.4069819748,
0.4415316582,
-0.3952895403,
-0.0494422726,
-0.5209437609,
-0.931085825,
-1.2631849051,
-0.6778610945,
-0.3780878484,
-0.3441014886,
0.0854047164,
1.0317437649,
0.8157724738,
-1.2639342546,
-0.147741586,
-0.172909528,
0.4225188792,
-0.2386568636,
-0.3060041964,
0.2284372896,
-0.2395834327,
-0.9769040346,
0.1882604063,
0.2030174136,
-0.0179280918,
-0.2993255258,
-0.0449737497,
0.170193091,
-0.1219839379,
0.3750476241,
0.3841660917,
-0.8274860978,
0.0881511122,
-0.3009178638,
-0.1516193748,
0.0286200978,
0.5130306482,
-1.1149046421,
0.5501263142,
0.7517177463,
0.7706714272,
0.4629357755,
-0.4099897146,
0.143268317,
-0.0913359821,
0.4158053696,
0.3181663752,
0.7426187992,
0.163466081,
-0.3773323596,
0.2643521726,
0.1211495399,
-0.5440839529,
-1.2923178673,
0.0373167992,
-0.8179945946,
-0.1436317414,
0.8606405258,
-0.0574394204,
-0.3646939695,
-0.230414927,
-0.4284958541,
0.050431177,
-0.5466662049,
0.629714191,
0.6711733341,
0.0069581335,
-0.6197897196,
-0.8668576479,
0.2926653922,
-0.0454261452,
-0.8393265009,
-0.1456002891,
0.1640916169,
0.5075581074,
0.3157499731,
0.1420567334,
0.0375218578,
0.3542523384,
-0.0367442556,
0.4700864255,
-0.2985710204,
-0.6698804498,
-0.4488359094,
0.4287933707,
-0.3550303876,
0.1384812444
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04302v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04302v2
|
Prompt Highlighter: Interactive Control for Multi-Modal LLMs
| 2023-12-07T13:53:29 | 2024-03-20T23:32:08 |
Yuechen Zhang, Shengju Qian, Bohao Peng, Shu Liu, Jiaya Jia
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
This study targets a critical aspect of multi-modal LLMs' (LLMs&VLMs)
inference: explicit controllable text generation. Multi-modal LLMs empower
multi-modality understanding with the capability of semantic generation yet
bring less explainability and heavier reliance on prompt contents due to their
autoregressive generative nature. While manipulating prompt formats could
improve outputs, designing specific and precise prompts per task can be
challenging and ineffective. To tackle this issue, we introduce a novel
inference method, Prompt Highlighter, which enables users to highlight specific
prompt spans to interactively control the focus during generation. Motivated by
the classifier-free diffusion guidance, we form regular and unconditional
context pairs based on highlighted tokens, demonstrating that the
autoregressive generation in models can be guided in a classifier-free way.
Notably, we find that, during inference, guiding the models with highlighted
tokens through the attention weights leads to more desired outputs. Our
approach is compatible with current LLMs and VLMs, achieving impressive
customized generation results without training. Experiments confirm its
effectiveness in focusing on input contexts and generating reliable content.
Without tuning on LLaVA-v1.5, our method secured 70.7 in the MMBench test and
1552.5 in MME-perception. The code is available at:
https://github.com/dvlab-research/Prompt-Highlighter/
|
[
-0.2756352425,
-0.8659667969,
0.6649532914,
0.5742403269,
-0.1611322314,
-0.2079339772,
-0.1874617338,
-0.0236083176,
0.0931705162,
0.2100542486,
-0.8755759597,
-0.3660814166,
-0.383618474,
0.2864000201,
-0.1616697013,
0.8146144152,
0.0315632299,
-0.0789108723,
-0.1327905953,
0.0183797181,
-0.6608642936,
-0.1468833387,
-0.6176139712,
0.0871804431,
0.9033349156,
0.3424829543,
0.4268457592,
0.5756376982,
-0.0794255584,
0.3066600263,
-0.2517497241,
0.4658464491,
-0.3101211786,
0.5675470829,
-0.072459504,
-0.3573598862,
-0.2223561406,
-0.0844883695,
0.4507184923,
0.5817810893,
0.235922128,
-0.1385778636,
0.3031018674,
0.3099804819,
-0.7109706402,
0.1638700664,
-0.5887511373,
-0.0035971955,
-0.0375739001,
-0.3030394614,
-0.6174089909,
-0.1178087965,
-0.1296796352,
-0.7087928653,
0.2393633872,
0.2715945542,
0.6132581234,
0.5389238596,
-0.7787977457,
-0.175125435,
-0.5338793397,
0.8704020977,
-0.327826947,
0.3363368511,
0.2453187704,
0.4346613884,
-0.0398280583,
-0.8667669892,
-0.4596169591,
-0.3097909093,
-0.0889568627,
0.4946856499,
-0.1137282923,
0.2605414093,
0.4165500104,
0.1581290662,
-0.270749867,
0.0891613737,
-0.0033634966,
-0.3170972764,
0.1615579575,
0.1821816266,
0.1000837758,
-0.4395602643,
-0.5749135613,
-0.0025690987,
-0.5754721165,
0.2208174914,
0.0895205066,
0.2040408552,
-0.1766266227,
0.5444161296,
-0.1959965825,
0.5712752342,
0.4352437854,
-0.2652322352,
0.1664963961,
-0.7377977371,
-0.3485984802,
-0.0853562504,
0.7981938124,
0.6046786308,
-0.1106480211,
-0.0521862358,
-0.2605772316,
-0.0908392891,
-0.0584624857,
-0.7695185542,
-0.1022568494,
0.1929075122,
-0.3344027102,
-0.2067663968,
-0.104885675,
-0.8171297908,
-0.4161874652,
-0.3065420389,
0.4484069645,
-0.1802522242,
0.0928159133,
-0.3169121444,
-0.2041395456,
0.10311497,
0.7728098035,
-0.8658818603,
-0.1810326725,
0.1521362513,
0.7528958321,
-0.4061503708,
-0.2130266875,
-0.8070617914,
0.392903924,
-0.0581224151,
0.5824229717,
-0.4300359786,
-0.5207378864,
-0.0494681783,
0.0346533209,
-0.2698790431,
-0.2324396372,
0.4077239931,
-0.5628872514,
0.5143194795,
-0.3184676468,
-0.4777728617,
-0.0407155976,
0.0568729304,
-0.743395865,
0.9140258431,
-0.079359971,
-0.8277481794,
0.7644654512,
-0.4499818981,
-0.0799998939,
-0.0787421912,
-0.4926616848,
-0.3600732386,
-0.0765407085,
0.4042119384,
0.2590598166,
-0.0367226265,
0.5353726149,
-0.2890335917,
-0.0657026395,
0.2122247219,
-0.8321810365,
0.5463231206,
0.2012765259,
-0.5747843385,
0.8992973566,
-0.7413014174,
-0.2479939759,
-0.1385809034,
-0.2994072139,
0.1781154126,
-0.2071619779,
0.1393134445,
0.1623664349,
0.2146439403,
-0.2491263449,
0.1304276735,
0.1533243358,
0.2096798271,
0.7636365891,
0.2534146905,
0.6146607995,
-0.3493975103,
0.5862351656,
0.0000914065,
0.2286596298,
-0.8939546347,
-0.5360167623,
-0.7655105591,
-0.8757825494,
0.3362720311,
0.5494758487,
-0.749037683,
0.4929417074,
0.2874407172,
-0.0175097566,
-0.3611746728,
0.1572302133,
0.2913405001,
0.8234046102,
0.3413584232,
0.1836274564,
-0.2909889519,
-0.7647967339,
0.0136832586,
0.1956322342,
-0.1136981398,
0.517125845,
0.1580929756,
-0.0436235182,
1.0930600166,
-0.2261675298,
0.0816959143,
-0.3627628386,
0.1747086197,
-0.0117004747,
0.6232209206,
0.531482935,
-0.8976280689,
-0.3596586585,
-0.5041472316,
-0.6435516477,
-0.6440603137,
-0.4702496529,
-0.2645250857,
-0.0326461419,
0.7363795638,
-0.3989863396,
0.5484114885,
0.1585444212,
-0.6439400911,
0.5953754187,
-0.2045173943,
0.2036310434,
-0.8648020625,
0.1585184634,
-0.0629839376,
-0.392717272,
-0.5085680485,
-0.2297095209,
0.3912662864,
0.0956175923,
-0.4157859981,
0.8149619699,
-0.5914167166,
0.1328418702,
-0.3473009169,
0.0145369964,
0.4073689282,
0.5689105392,
-0.0935031921,
0.9182516932,
0.6041006446,
-0.6780173779,
0.0469773859,
0.2332184315,
-0.064986527,
0.5520985723,
-0.6141010523,
-0.342520088,
-0.1948757768,
0.2094042152,
-1.3088396788,
-0.340634644,
0.2835688889,
-0.1528588682,
0.2340548635,
-0.0386241712,
-0.5590581894,
-0.1839566529,
-0.3425352573,
0.1301185936,
0.5270466805,
-0.6215184927,
0.5359340906,
-0.2653796375,
-0.3205282092,
-0.3900396526,
-0.6375898123,
-0.0985803753,
-0.4450739026,
-0.3781055212,
0.1467795819,
-0.6732990742,
-0.3009245396,
-0.3788883686,
-0.1135933846,
0.0653955489,
0.4451164305,
0.4481769502,
0.271532625,
-0.05395668,
0.2397656739,
0.6389742494,
-0.2131698877,
-0.0245824941,
-0.0043363539,
0.2422344536,
0.2563637793,
-0.7644513249,
-0.6122816205,
0.4093082845,
0.5956504345,
-0.3134487867,
0.3850953281,
0.5614925027,
0.1207705364,
-0.2000107765,
-0.5535020828,
-0.4475879967,
-0.5235673785,
-0.0037016466,
-0.2479218096,
-0.897459209,
0.5085383058,
-0.1456233114,
0.1777798086,
0.2064579427,
0.6515018344,
0.2072010934,
1.3037941456,
0.6877349019,
0.4001015723,
0.9305437207,
0.175785467,
-0.4305600226,
-0.6748347282,
-0.3127265275,
-0.1492492855,
-0.2800503373,
-0.1868838668,
-0.4611071646,
0.5051378608,
0.5384510159,
-0.1015263051,
-0.3222834766,
-0.359300524,
0.3659888208,
0.861602962,
0.1107532606,
0.4501121342,
-0.07549759,
-0.4692043066,
-0.1050368026,
-0.6042698026,
-0.5027876496,
0.6302883029,
0.1631107926,
0.6633246541,
0.084242925,
0.5404262543,
0.2950762808,
0.2669069469,
-0.6383674145,
0.3690278828,
0.4647394121,
-0.3355775476,
-0.1179871485,
-0.1072930992,
-0.8707284331,
0.5104153752,
-0.2652517259,
-0.5843188763,
0.1917418391,
0.359213531,
-0.5736641884,
0.0506299101,
-0.7236273885,
0.8015254736,
-0.132272929,
-0.7313644886,
0.2439948618,
-0.8223618865,
0.3500814736,
-0.0276710335,
0.1326793879,
-0.2338881642,
-0.4294225574,
0.336270839,
-0.3459335566,
1.2392286062,
-0.2205790132,
-0.0810606629,
0.2420712858,
0.1210339218,
0.4101109207,
0.3072453141,
-0.2147024423,
-0.4656886458,
-0.600892663,
-0.3709353507,
-0.4718605578,
0.634162426,
-0.2773398161,
-0.5970130563,
0.0555428825,
-0.6722541451,
0.0350666046,
0.5589715838,
0.2869955599,
0.5689553022,
-0.0694194064,
-0.1981245726,
0.7859910727,
-0.0847652256,
0.8974241018,
0.6297115088,
-0.3747745454,
-0.6445624232,
0.6692942381,
-0.2431453168,
0.2811324596,
0.2974360287,
0.2818861902,
-0.4290117323,
-0.6602401733,
-0.8497507572,
0.050362438,
-0.7808352709,
-0.1140579134,
-0.9060555696,
0.267560333,
-0.2375214249,
-0.5554030538,
0.2094234377,
-0.4133442044,
-0.8304575682,
-0.1465314478,
0.5218151212,
0.7691367865,
-0.033858344,
0.5387561917,
-0.5689612627,
0.210248813,
0.5191475153,
-0.061804451,
-0.0841227621,
-0.3937447965,
0.218001619,
-0.3563864827,
-0.3352310956,
-1.0812730789,
0.3135465682,
0.0707005262,
0.7084824443,
0.6645675302,
0.045878619,
0.4221054316,
-0.4533481896,
1.0237252712,
0.3172254562,
-0.9151221514,
0.6878438592,
-0.4420237243,
0.5451076031,
0.6074576378,
0.1553974301,
-0.1309047341,
-0.7590065002,
-0.5961045623,
-0.8953457475,
0.5738528967,
0.1221578568,
-0.1818361729,
-0.3674711883,
0.2058690786,
0.3530444205,
0.6307316422,
-0.5531830788,
-0.4416976273,
-0.2985311747,
-0.3015829921,
0.0103410902,
-0.4076024294,
-0.1587645411,
0.0856366456,
0.1181313172,
-0.3790535629,
-0.0716325641,
0.3952791989,
-0.2549952269,
0.0554301031,
0.3605464101,
0.7929792404,
0.6450462937,
-0.0427123122,
0.3870756626,
0.1165563688,
-0.0558656491,
-0.0098488489,
0.3092969656,
-0.5770604014,
0.069887422,
0.2280056775,
0.9922323227,
0.3784726262,
-0.5756489635,
0.7506065369,
-0.0488744378,
-0.0594501793,
0.0513074398,
0.1456726789,
-0.1280502528,
0.4846797287,
0.4032731652,
0.160185039,
0.2081669122,
0.0919212848,
0.3746113181,
0.4199061394,
-0.5478311777,
-0.3591367602,
1.2222585678,
0.3772317171,
0.1404582858,
0.0408659726,
-0.3525084853,
-0.241674453,
0.5614263415,
0.4978981018,
0.8516040444,
-0.0021226765,
-0.0251847189,
0.3110786676,
-0.0228364114,
0.1616836339,
0.3738467097,
-0.5945698619,
-0.283529371,
-0.439997524,
-0.3933351934,
-0.5181553364,
-0.1517082155,
-0.6241503954,
0.2012580335,
-0.3352983892,
-0.1750844717,
-0.1291480809,
-0.3396468461,
-0.4414007366,
0.0040236707,
0.2974761724,
1.0059883595,
-0.8382136226,
0.5489310026,
0.4854601324,
-0.4870148599,
-0.4689351618,
-0.0117019406,
0.2391376942,
-0.6809585094,
0.7783813477,
0.4296653569,
-0.1332311183,
0.1414424628,
-0.6184601188,
-0.5774520636,
1.266143918,
0.2780527771,
-0.3869038224,
-0.0671725795,
-0.3916615248,
0.0962894559,
-0.2023131847,
0.7705941796,
0.2821391523,
0.8089660406,
0.2914985716,
-0.9762801528,
0.1670591682,
-0.0917093083,
-0.1136303395,
-0.0629970804,
-0.7568123937,
0.857776165,
-0.4352229238,
-0.3458466232,
0.2103388757,
1.05610919,
0.570181191,
0.3963236511,
0.6273542047,
0.1442928314,
0.947353363,
0.0582242608,
0.903020978,
-0.3329942226,
-0.0725367442,
1.0463609695,
-0.1969747096,
0.2237027735,
0.6421425343,
0.2959176898,
0.3009244204,
0.4831635654,
-0.0274926443,
0.7261312604,
-0.0408923812,
-0.6351778507,
-0.4651897848,
-0.484986335,
-0.1338701546,
-0.0219834875,
0.2200836986,
-0.5279215574,
-0.385566473,
0.2281142622,
0.1579090953,
-0.0053388486,
-0.2854257524,
0.76156497,
-0.2123190314,
-0.6990106702,
0.3466734588,
-0.3089756072,
0.9238229394,
-0.7107560039,
-0.0833054259,
-0.2653563321,
-0.0994408876,
0.0090389745,
-0.5939193368,
-0.2030099928,
-0.0494858138,
-0.4330500364,
-0.6058844924,
0.592179656,
-0.6644949913,
-0.1917694807,
0.0040761884,
0.8541920781,
-0.0390959233,
0.0292620063,
-0.5865787864,
0.1412399858,
0.2699216902,
-0.5801773071,
0.1723635644,
0.6784597039,
-0.0937871188,
0.6017592549,
0.5241578221,
-0.1529688835,
0.3974843919,
0.1939463913,
0.96213305,
-0.6664175987,
-0.6315743327,
-0.7320008874,
0.6769785285,
-0.0752556995,
-0.3939547241,
1.106287241,
0.4598309696,
0.3569607437,
-0.0607002415,
0.8195537329,
0.1161895096,
0.4661214054,
-0.6482235789,
0.5148870349,
-0.5449157357,
0.0557111539,
0.1079986468,
-0.4815100431,
-0.3693801761,
0.2578340471,
-0.0348372422,
0.1185909882,
0.6421906352,
0.7301273346,
-0.0590052456,
-0.2522033155,
0.3021169603,
-0.0001601354,
0.4581702352,
0.0926881582,
0.8980196118,
0.1686413735,
0.5048303008,
-0.281321913,
-0.3697427511,
-0.3039924502,
-1.1672247648,
-0.9956838489,
-0.2238008082,
-0.2773551643,
-0.20274055,
-0.1797486842,
0.8730562329,
0.6182967424,
-0.6722744703,
0.1391460747,
-0.2401438951,
0.3074193597,
-0.1491463929,
-0.2666752636,
0.3492533565,
-0.7467324734,
-1.0134813786,
0.8215539455,
0.1182427332,
0.4551963806,
-0.2714941204,
0.1060228646,
0.0944246128,
-0.0146540198,
0.5662468076,
0.2721195519,
-0.8888090849,
0.0057862946,
0.0408598594,
-0.3026697338,
0.066833742,
0.9070977569,
-0.9926374555,
0.6311509013,
0.5367037058,
0.3023395836,
0.2721307576,
0.1967396885,
0.5472276211,
-0.8971689939,
0.2300487161,
-0.034964256,
0.5554837584,
0.2243443429,
-0.22430484,
-0.0079553286,
0.21495305,
-0.5296364427,
-0.6258048415,
0.3640379906,
-1.2538715601,
-0.2793944776,
1.2477421761,
0.0752431229,
-0.2374618798,
-0.2011132091,
-0.679196775,
0.3894272447,
-0.8248154521,
0.2813636363,
0.0973849893,
-0.3020136058,
-0.251780659,
-0.6312590241,
0.6503559351,
0.6732609868,
-0.6659239531,
0.2242978364,
0.9507335424,
0.0103594232,
0.0101721799,
0.5754746795,
0.2154478878,
0.2477831542,
-0.1369383931,
0.1427240521,
-0.5026866794,
-0.4856701791,
-0.5827196836,
0.3491059244,
8.699e-7,
-0.1608846486
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04262v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04262v2
|
PsyChat: A Client-Centric Dialogue System for Mental Health Support
| 2023-12-07T12:40:00 | 2024-03-20T01:59:39 |
Huachuan Qiu, Anqi Li, Lizhi Ma, Zhenzhong Lan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.HC
|
Dialogue systems are increasingly integrated into mental health support to
help clients facilitate exploration, gain insight, take action, and ultimately
heal themselves. A practical and user-friendly dialogue system should be
client-centric, focusing on the client's behaviors. However, existing dialogue
systems publicly available for mental health support often concentrate solely
on the counselor's strategies rather than the behaviors expressed by clients.
This can lead to unreasonable or inappropriate counseling strategies and
corresponding responses generated by the dialogue system. To address this
issue, we propose PsyChat, a client-centric dialogue system that provides
psychological support through online chat. The client-centric dialogue system
comprises five modules: client behavior recognition, counselor strategy
selection, input packer, response generator, and response selection. Both
automatic and human evaluations demonstrate the effectiveness and practicality
of our proposed dialogue system for real-life mental health support.
Furthermore, the case study demonstrates that the dialogue system can predict
the client's behaviors, select appropriate counselor strategies, and generate
accurate and suitable responses.
|
[
-0.5711566806,
-0.5088889599,
1.1194592714,
0.8120565414,
-0.0378963761,
0.1725881398,
-0.0397685133,
-0.2901780307,
0.7737765908,
0.3772559762,
-1.0229240656,
-0.0995405093,
-0.2766728699,
0.0983669087,
0.132234022,
0.9993844032,
0.2929740548,
0.3929752409,
-0.1279848665,
0.0442685895,
-0.7878360748,
-0.3711279035,
-0.7468035817,
-0.4518119991,
0.3424568772,
0.5871537924,
0.3727126122,
-0.3257373869,
0.4125802219,
0.2395720631,
0.2982130647,
0.0702679157,
-0.2652538121,
0.5981532931,
-0.1737065464,
-0.3523449898,
-0.9346014857,
-0.2224175632,
-0.1345297396,
0.3055341244,
-0.7493935823,
0.3530159295,
-0.2359614074,
0.3258781433,
-0.4416660666,
0.0875052437,
-0.0866842791,
0.2472662926,
0.1410397142,
-0.1881426424,
-0.248088941,
-0.5399420261,
0.4528602064,
-0.778383255,
-0.0080540832,
-0.1933512241,
0.2874842584,
0.1085750833,
-0.1345282495,
-0.0093083186,
-0.979665339,
0.3748073876,
-0.6541543007,
0.1225862652,
0.8164199591,
0.7615834475,
-0.2804529071,
-0.6346123815,
-0.091606617,
-0.0458189249,
-0.2627360523,
0.3644023538,
-0.2580629885,
0.3873912692,
0.3431817591,
0.1886750013,
-0.6178858876,
-0.4529875219,
-0.1120151803,
-0.5185358524,
0.4986301064,
0.3210839331,
0.4177294374,
-0.0260895174,
-0.0194595736,
0.1742863953,
0.0529828072,
0.1890137345,
0.03163746,
0.1539218128,
0.2428201586,
0.5422509313,
-0.3197877705,
0.1403214484,
0.5810046792,
-0.6209877729,
-0.0827738196,
0.1673559844,
-0.1820355803,
0.6300023198,
0.5874643922,
0.6683554053,
-0.1275714189,
-0.0654818043,
-0.0038043559,
0.3490601182,
0.6290094256,
-0.7060002089,
-0.3459484577,
0.4454837143,
-0.5384914875,
-0.117065981,
-0.2604275346,
-0.9497420192,
-0.7459813356,
-0.2099081129,
0.2799500823,
-0.6749271154,
-0.4564089775,
0.3158316016,
-0.3032463491,
0.0257605761,
0.5410381556,
-0.4174468219,
0.7828593254,
0.5544064641,
0.940593183,
0.1307746917,
-0.0129174087,
-0.7450616956,
0.0667370185,
0.0449308567,
0.8522558808,
-0.4845867753,
-0.6018013358,
-0.0400159918,
0.1106646731,
0.2015648931,
-0.1669517308,
0.6337658167,
0.0151360119,
0.3462992013,
-0.5396618843,
-0.6167606711,
0.2930186689,
0.2989917397,
-0.1902163178,
0.662288487,
0.1683847606,
-1.0218508244,
0.2806436718,
-0.8642790914,
-0.2581419051,
0.5678845048,
-0.3802852631,
-0.2516121566,
0.0987421423,
0.0769309178,
0.0865273029,
-0.0606765933,
0.0797341019,
-0.725530684,
-0.6393271685,
0.5812718272,
-0.174635008,
0.565166235,
0.3260069788,
-0.2965756059,
0.1173686236,
-0.6947634816,
0.2462981045,
0.2021692842,
0.0312806517,
-0.2231763154,
0.1773084849,
-0.055781953,
0.0703471676,
0.151299119,
-0.9808045626,
0.1679337174,
-0.1632663012,
0.28696087,
0.4175391793,
0.3215506375,
-0.0209933314,
-0.3974594474,
0.7816143036,
-0.4450413883,
0.4207177758,
-0.0630757436,
-0.5918102264,
-0.201731205,
-0.9771822691,
-0.596073091,
0.8814581633,
-0.4180084765,
0.488964498,
0.1564945728,
-0.6954731941,
-0.4167323411,
-0.293798238,
0.0902517661,
0.4277040362,
0.182930842,
-0.7034335732,
-0.6525501609,
-0.7270569801,
-0.1658138335,
-0.364665091,
-0.161189124,
0.1024307236,
-0.2848606706,
-0.2910107672,
1.2863271236,
-0.9086278081,
-0.3359959126,
-0.4696405828,
0.1072710231,
-0.1432679594,
0.1295937747,
0.5260618925,
-0.1301948577,
-0.5646820068,
-0.1341314316,
-0.5404136181,
-0.5908850431,
0.0156884454,
-0.2206980139,
-0.4065111578,
0.1846638471,
-0.5585971475,
0.5671399236,
0.1892003268,
-0.468914032,
0.4850837886,
-0.3624095321,
-0.0910408869,
-0.8818138838,
0.0783277825,
-0.0742076635,
-0.5288620591,
-0.6508885622,
-0.5836022496,
-0.3481763005,
-0.6088417768,
-0.2391036898,
-0.0763328448,
0.2416871637,
-0.1076968238,
-0.2488305867,
0.0765971541,
0.0926482826,
0.6424478889,
0.1071087867,
0.6283858418,
0.5113024116,
-0.0335546099,
0.9168027639,
0.3501010537,
-0.0004076851,
1.530017972,
-0.4593827426,
0.1880566627,
-0.18493177,
0.9027938843,
-0.9798585176,
-0.3053579628,
0.6319585443,
-0.1364786923,
-0.1749689728,
0.0251904316,
-0.0756403655,
-0.283333838,
-0.3795282841,
0.3696873188,
0.0829227343,
0.0165967941,
0.355063647,
0.3792878687,
-0.5932935476,
-0.1037952825,
-0.2618665993,
0.1186442748,
-0.4360510409,
-0.174161762,
-0.1301331371,
-0.3092970252,
-0.1356914043,
-0.2450955957,
-0.0359517857,
0.1090243682,
-0.0317380801,
0.7243266702,
0.2278797328,
-0.0555241667,
0.2880308032,
0.0256020837,
-0.2389377505,
0.2333513051,
-0.4146225154,
0.7398260832,
-0.5379520655,
-0.6786789298,
-0.7849189043,
0.7031172514,
0.7629645467,
-0.2525381446,
0.4090723991,
0.6719390154,
-0.3756504655,
0.2616319358,
-0.6598462462,
-0.3244468868,
-0.459731251,
0.2401050776,
-0.3032016754,
-0.5152051449,
0.3340062499,
-0.2918470204,
-0.0300566219,
-0.3002172112,
0.3307771385,
-0.2065837234,
1.7569065094,
0.3475752175,
0.1608844846,
0.491006583,
0.2154101133,
0.5804420114,
-0.6075372696,
-0.2171148062,
-0.1626873016,
-0.384526521,
-0.4978592098,
0.2029582113,
0.3541827202,
-0.2716449201,
-0.6078707576,
0.4062393606,
-0.9150275588,
-0.1284897178,
0.2881710231,
0.5009042025,
0.295894146,
-0.0164702814,
-0.2101025432,
-0.6982383728,
-0.249668479,
-0.3760831058,
0.4966684878,
0.4930035174,
0.8622512817,
0.3360749781,
0.4873023033,
0.259398967,
0.5785014033,
-1.0329413414,
0.6440444589,
0.421346575,
-0.6096454263,
-0.2723255455,
-0.107344158,
-0.6481328607,
0.2783107758,
-0.1828344166,
-1.3525485992,
0.3995041847,
-0.1689796001,
-0.677578032,
-0.0784941465,
-0.5316078067,
0.6114610434,
-0.460290581,
-0.1115060225,
-0.2549832463,
-0.4879049659,
0.0600094534,
-0.0911944732,
-0.0121830851,
-0.5274003744,
0.2934516072,
0.5026376247,
-0.7280505896,
0.8788298368,
-0.343126148,
0.1672701836,
0.1000721827,
0.492777288,
0.0999450907,
0.3753478229,
0.1789306849,
-0.6126705408,
0.9329949021,
-0.3657504022,
-0.8014321923,
0.4893984199,
-0.8299722075,
-0.587436676,
-0.5526861548,
-0.303295821,
-0.8610016704,
0.1691868752,
0.2221675217,
0.5296779275,
-0.4350712895,
-0.2184527069,
0.3431707025,
-0.1585557759,
-0.0867740959,
0.6981959343,
-0.8387658,
-0.549729526,
0.9740784764,
-0.1852107793,
-0.0684462711,
-0.2590965331,
0.3940815926,
-0.116980806,
0.2862024307,
-0.012876085,
0.6330921054,
-0.5346727967,
-0.2225553244,
-0.5214286447,
0.0659383908,
-0.4567711353,
-0.214135021,
-0.2659340501,
-0.2709519565,
0.2230086327,
-0.2539322972,
0.4860192835,
0.585578382,
0.0565174222,
0.5124432445,
-0.779042542,
0.0879803896,
0.6204558611,
0.5692436099,
-0.1474176794,
0.2647387683,
-0.0321943201,
0.0145629179,
-0.7039725184,
-1.4117475748,
0.3159753382,
0.1082983539,
0.4385202229,
0.8076367378,
0.4525085986,
0.743730247,
-0.1729613841,
0.5598556995,
0.3726674616,
-0.8438706398,
0.7950087786,
-0.2918149829,
0.2311829627,
0.8342164755,
0.156115666,
-1.1166518927,
-0.5337802768,
-0.6306845546,
-0.1395370364,
0.9783676863,
0.0142851127,
-0.1330360621,
0.0966209695,
0.2933211327,
-0.0357252844,
0.3800789416,
-0.3227797151,
0.0915555358,
-0.6839929819,
-0.1932747662,
0.4081453681,
0.0816674009,
-0.5877507925,
-0.183839187,
0.484303683,
-0.426107347,
0.6059037447,
0.628716886,
0.2847369313,
-0.5056709051,
0.3889879584,
0.3044632971,
0.5481395125,
-0.5975757241,
-0.0591960512,
0.2335316837,
-0.627410233,
0.2009541988,
0.0286931936,
0.2683674395,
0.0198326167,
-0.1620170325,
0.5935825109,
0.0493318029,
-0.9167876244,
0.797601819,
-0.6587966084,
-0.1104065701,
-0.3519327343,
-0.0705385432,
0.1065715402,
0.2862855494,
0.0238755383,
-0.0343095027,
0.4215141237,
-0.6119247079,
0.097191073,
0.353664726,
-1.0329400301,
-0.3815710247,
0.1953195482,
0.115738295,
-0.7492647171,
0.5210152268,
-0.1349179,
-0.5856202245,
0.0847207308,
0.7104485631,
0.7953805923,
-0.2619063258,
0.9784575701,
0.078736864,
-0.2245921046,
-0.1875737011,
0.3694256246,
-0.1012981609,
-0.3555287719,
-0.246474728,
-0.2406956702,
-0.7871937156,
0.2149265558,
-0.9532578588,
0.1959894598,
-0.8243224025,
-0.789883554,
-0.3507676125,
0.1738702208,
-0.4110514522,
0.0901070461,
0.3620405197,
0.8146252632,
-0.9040676951,
0.5142207146,
1.2236179113,
-0.3290522993,
-0.7084298134,
0.0006678924,
0.3529341519,
-0.4750520289,
0.0826137885,
0.1819758117,
-0.4822821617,
-0.4388240278,
-0.3453891575,
-0.5364051461,
1.1043606997,
0.551469028,
-0.1219521835,
0.1773608476,
0.3529142737,
0.9988000989,
-0.4087347984,
0.655133903,
0.5843449235,
0.4169062972,
0.1985626221,
-0.9699311852,
0.1777775586,
-0.1847896427,
-0.0457748435,
0.0462055877,
-0.7057518363,
0.1788593978,
0.3100480735,
-0.2417262644,
0.1976560801,
0.2431216091,
0.2742801607,
0.4647960961,
0.7071604729,
0.2432119101,
0.7942379117,
0.23895064,
0.5538005829,
-0.3922938406,
0.2996151745,
0.9102526903,
-0.6057196856,
0.578109622,
0.501350224,
-0.2231333256,
0.5926650167,
0.5383313298,
0.3989605606,
0.4598061144,
0.0941628367,
-0.5476825833,
-0.480122149,
-0.5712525249,
-0.1632166952,
0.2328992337,
0.6645556688,
0.2717346847,
-0.2681085765,
0.2616502941,
0.0591099188,
-0.1736480892,
0.2267428339,
0.9050713181,
0.2593459487,
-0.6815628409,
-0.0751735717,
-0.1299805939,
0.0808029175,
-0.9104517102,
0.0774280652,
-0.0964431614,
0.4447050095,
-0.5075499415,
-0.5397939086,
0.1499022394,
-0.1334479749,
0.2732072771,
-0.2894402146,
1.0336867571,
-0.1986546516,
-0.4637437165,
0.3847229183,
0.639087677,
0.0394746363,
-0.1885354817,
-0.781879127,
-0.1211973578,
-0.2435867339,
-0.0138548696,
0.5173951983,
0.3602902293,
-0.1258189678,
0.7061830163,
0.4751363099,
0.3943843842,
-0.4338776171,
0.0246510766,
0.5775517821,
-0.2533697486,
-0.8014402986,
-0.3075433075,
0.090856038,
-0.3257059753,
-0.1854178607,
0.6572564244,
0.1808183491,
-0.022056682,
0.2605727911,
0.863345623,
-0.0340558141,
0.8142537475,
0.457267046,
0.3296105862,
-0.3490145504,
0.0873164535,
-0.3591112494,
-1.0080339909,
-0.1027492955,
0.8563418984,
-0.4764491618,
-0.5226496458,
0.6523535848,
0.6859516501,
-0.0283716805,
0.514051199,
0.173470065,
-0.0408052728,
0.8807714581,
0.3324360847,
1.05793643,
0.0772904679,
0.5109418631,
-0.4522812963,
-0.4732137024,
-0.433316648,
-0.4834803045,
-0.5715819597,
-0.3528485596,
-0.1757703573,
-0.32483989,
-0.1042435318,
1.4504863024,
0.5441559553,
-0.5862793922,
-0.413610369,
0.0472723283,
-0.5618804693,
-0.4472444654,
-0.2681008577,
-0.095218949,
-0.2595822811,
-0.1140376478,
0.3310213983,
0.5591468215,
-0.3633200824,
-0.6185562015,
-0.0236224402,
0.103550829,
0.3735953867,
0.2897360623,
0.4540788829,
-0.5334461331,
-0.4253641665,
0.2171573341,
-0.3997509778,
0.1512919217,
1.156545043,
-0.7781540751,
0.7559767365,
0.4985224605,
0.5055662394,
0.4815182984,
0.1007385775,
0.9734433889,
-0.2229820639,
0.0716025829,
0.2870788276,
0.2911438942,
0.2741203904,
-0.5108837485,
0.1726842672,
0.2389954031,
-0.5254303813,
-0.5823313594,
0.3124096394,
-0.825791657,
-0.1743474305,
0.5815891027,
-0.4138605893,
-0.0226783305,
-0.4613656402,
-1.2826805115,
0.1346987933,
-0.7789734602,
0.6841661334,
0.778015554,
-0.8884682655,
-0.0072088414,
-0.2661894262,
0.4708566666,
0.5963672996,
-0.6765033007,
-0.1397420317,
0.4507039487,
0.3232496083,
0.3235716224,
0.9714639783,
0.3250755668,
0.2716470361,
-0.3781988025,
-0.130142197,
0.3204887509,
0.2661556602,
-0.1318599731,
0.0090398416,
0.1905979365,
0.0151314335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07553v2
|
Hijacking Context in Large Multi-modal Models
| 2023-12-07T11:23:29 | 2024-05-13T10:42:05 |
Joonhyun Jeong
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Multi-modal Models (LMMs) have demonstrated their ability to
understand the visual contents of images given the instructions regarding the
images. Built upon the Large Language Models (LLMs), LMMs also inherit their
abilities and characteristics such as in-context learning where a coherent
sequence of images and texts are given as the input prompt. However, we
identify a new limitation of off-the-shelf LMMs where a small fraction of
incoherent images or text descriptions mislead LMMs to only generate biased
output about the hijacked context, not the originally intended context. To
address this, we propose a pre-filtering method that removes irrelevant
contexts via GPT-4V, based on its robustness towards distribution shift within
the contexts. We further investigate whether replacing the hijacked visual and
textual contexts with the correlated ones via GPT-4V and text-to-image models
can help yield coherent responses.
|
[
-0.5508006215,
-1.0414124727,
0.6674715877,
-0.0805480182,
-0.604498744,
-0.2777354121,
-0.2098134905,
-0.5413478017,
-0.0972570851,
0.6903126836,
-0.5660912991,
-0.1995076984,
-0.6964780092,
0.025896512,
-0.2781482041,
1.2087404728,
-0.0142142652,
-0.1047528461,
-0.1711294055,
-0.0581836067,
-0.7087708712,
-0.4779310226,
-0.2943489254,
-0.0951296166,
0.3514327705,
0.0973990411,
0.7495594621,
0.4326366782,
0.4436762035,
0.2652043104,
0.1025071219,
-0.0076948586,
-0.7669556737,
0.2298598886,
-0.1579838097,
-0.1384486109,
-0.4553392828,
-0.1150647551,
0.7868586183,
0.3243706822,
0.0570020452,
0.0154419318,
0.5023540258,
0.2613830864,
-0.7829600573,
0.2149982005,
-0.9073979259,
-0.0969473124,
-0.3087439239,
-0.6207159758,
-0.5277786851,
0.1784886271,
0.2753276229,
-0.8859691024,
0.0225632787,
-0.1175539121,
1.0117241144,
0.2893228531,
-0.4572292566,
-0.3065246642,
-0.6696602106,
0.8638939261,
-0.5734889507,
0.2590995431,
0.5832239985,
0.1940427423,
-0.2256864756,
-0.6869727969,
-0.5169024467,
0.182332173,
-0.1629944593,
0.2256847173,
-0.0447622202,
-0.0326278321,
0.2713876367,
0.017184943,
-0.3888533711,
-0.2062433809,
-0.2048060149,
-0.4649817646,
0.0851334184,
-0.0191066079,
0.3222500682,
-0.4208528399,
-0.7391215563,
-0.1087682098,
-0.8101682067,
-0.070636943,
0.1140294075,
0.0830828846,
-0.1707190722,
0.3799895644,
0.1240839437,
0.8839111924,
0.3207490146,
-0.4618838131,
0.1714419425,
-0.8179163337,
-0.5226070285,
-0.3135531545,
0.6236656904,
0.1444934607,
0.0243836902,
0.2203139961,
-0.3288705945,
-0.164832592,
0.1935677528,
-0.9126209021,
-0.0103459628,
-0.1004132703,
-0.6216318011,
-0.045634862,
-0.0938623771,
-0.9992935658,
-0.1966415048,
-0.1888243407,
0.8774998784,
-0.3442044854,
-0.1428579092,
0.0145179396,
-0.0472845063,
0.3029682338,
0.3763692081,
-0.625418067,
-0.1208559275,
0.1804772168,
0.7526994944,
-0.1238096356,
-0.4040091038,
-0.7499247789,
0.4892883301,
-0.0745868832,
0.6016043425,
-0.6771635413,
-0.4443474114,
0.1030416936,
0.120380044,
0.1138673797,
-0.2183266729,
0.2588074207,
-1.0639206171,
0.3687623739,
-0.4264704585,
-0.2279236019,
-0.1161351725,
0.4603190124,
-0.7591079473,
0.5339543819,
-0.0735209733,
-0.8793267608,
0.4939514697,
-0.3535460234,
-0.5885825157,
0.0327997766,
-0.410223335,
-0.5621033907,
-0.1593774259,
0.5499234796,
0.5227603316,
-0.0909300074,
0.4994000196,
-0.4547236264,
-0.4736171067,
0.0571255758,
-0.8458345532,
0.5719766021,
0.2183807641,
-0.3635450304,
0.2380398363,
-0.5036709905,
-0.3243854642,
0.0267102644,
-0.4406858385,
-0.5068349838,
-0.0074223559,
0.0970844477,
0.4850140512,
0.3445209265,
-0.1922219247,
0.1431275159,
-0.2181334496,
0.4622721672,
0.8733641505,
0.2134987861,
0.7360785604,
-0.2166228592,
0.4987890124,
0.35539186,
0.153730765,
-0.7576577663,
-0.6516644955,
-0.2017185688,
-0.6840993166,
-0.1885202378,
0.158615008,
-1.3561484814,
0.133913815,
-0.2257735878,
0.2237841636,
-0.0489106439,
0.1924770325,
0.2305794507,
0.7414740324,
0.5452654958,
-0.3404782712,
-0.3816647828,
-0.8993741274,
-0.2890673578,
0.0762769505,
-0.0264183581,
0.2837210894,
0.4801366329,
-0.4128058255,
0.9037442803,
-0.254296273,
-0.569426775,
0.0129421605,
-0.0164369121,
0.0718335211,
0.3264703453,
0.4949617982,
-0.9788064957,
-0.3727692962,
-0.0992425084,
-0.6826053858,
0.1320007592,
-0.3565030694,
-0.1255846918,
0.0501765385,
0.7425458431,
-0.5620064139,
0.7090255022,
0.5467990041,
-0.3350411057,
0.4692701995,
-0.230505988,
0.2707149386,
-1.356066823,
-0.016614154,
-0.0046622935,
-0.5188828111,
-0.4437466264,
-0.0406468846,
0.2975347638,
-0.1367605627,
-0.5114085078,
0.5150462389,
-0.7150543928,
-0.0776362717,
-0.2904116809,
0.0532379784,
0.1926029027,
0.4628452957,
-0.000666085,
0.7217665911,
0.6126534939,
-0.4816652834,
-0.0645339936,
0.3210056424,
-0.3032723367,
0.614459157,
-0.39265275,
-0.2172037214,
-0.3046952188,
0.6461527944,
-1.0121484995,
-0.5628438592,
0.2387383729,
-0.0295173097,
0.3823645115,
-0.3954096138,
-0.2999973893,
0.0035383028,
-0.2417973131,
0.8895697594,
0.4347348809,
-0.7451529503,
0.6220445633,
0.2786886692,
0.0436199866,
-0.7649265528,
-0.5938552618,
0.1893094331,
-0.3416902423,
-0.3933183849,
0.4626738727,
-0.0865914226,
0.232024014,
-0.0526037589,
0.0057987678,
-0.2405647784,
-0.0858271867,
0.2112942338,
0.3798369765,
-0.0875136256,
0.1558983177,
-0.0877241716,
0.2093249261,
-0.0137068275,
-0.324296236,
0.4227668643,
0.1009531468,
-0.4639185965,
-0.4413321316,
0.3390483856,
0.9620876908,
-0.339672178,
0.5050889254,
0.7052313089,
-0.3865743279,
-0.070952706,
-0.2925088108,
-0.3762919009,
-0.5229772329,
0.6781921983,
-0.5447292924,
-1.0294010639,
0.4251138866,
0.0899457037,
-0.2510839999,
0.1274155378,
0.6335962415,
0.0745021477,
0.9631136656,
0.5525029898,
-0.0862845033,
0.8369823694,
-0.0007418001,
0.2495872676,
-0.706619978,
0.0836948156,
-0.0658812895,
-0.1807168126,
-0.412156105,
-0.4284643829,
0.7084136009,
0.0480871238,
-0.0683402792,
0.1101222783,
-0.2557492852,
0.6889297962,
0.393923223,
0.3508040011,
0.3009711206,
0.33347404,
-0.0604982339,
0.0511100888,
-0.6057780385,
-0.2485215813,
1.153973341,
0.2801305354,
0.9518510699,
0.1588868201,
0.4277623594,
0.0328590535,
0.286804527,
-0.5859476328,
0.4320072234,
0.1976821423,
-0.6638459563,
-0.3074201643,
-0.3063169718,
-1.061209321,
0.598198235,
-0.3612464964,
-0.6158851981,
0.2997913659,
0.2769652605,
-0.3008165956,
0.403990835,
-0.529804945,
0.8945243955,
0.0276597086,
-0.7391473651,
-0.1818083376,
-0.7396531105,
0.6701492071,
-0.4077455103,
0.4065767527,
0.1200716123,
0.0337464772,
0.2945195735,
-0.1359183639,
1.1570802927,
-0.1407715231,
-0.2993399203,
0.2498524934,
0.2355204523,
0.52451998,
0.2962196767,
0.2129535079,
0.1276843548,
-0.0087710386,
-0.5066851974,
-0.3761158884,
0.7810399532,
-0.6989921927,
-0.6604841352,
-0.2700182199,
-0.5293763876,
-0.1497243047,
0.3753721118,
0.6239108443,
0.7271772027,
-0.2147435248,
0.2373156399,
0.4517558813,
-0.2915035486,
0.830113709,
0.2377699763,
-0.174033314,
-0.3544713855,
0.6403775811,
-0.0744845271,
0.3735215068,
0.176720053,
0.0687932447,
-0.2792660296,
-0.4412978292,
-0.5589728951,
-0.0149147781,
-0.9386721253,
-0.2391096354,
-0.4712615609,
0.1285644472,
-0.1999720931,
-0.1782115251,
-0.1706847847,
0.1923567057,
-0.5064055324,
0.3177033067,
-0.1963528544,
0.6260565519,
0.1809411645,
0.4785339832,
-0.8296332955,
0.4948461652,
0.499666363,
0.245476678,
0.0316121988,
-0.7314007282,
-0.37998119,
-0.0165326018,
-0.5304408073,
-1.0576258898,
0.5352132916,
0.1966573,
0.2094370425,
0.7091198564,
-0.0459408276,
0.8835841417,
-0.7144383192,
0.8209383488,
0.2784962356,
-1.0930047035,
0.4134570062,
-0.5306187868,
0.6870250106,
0.1297148615,
0.262855798,
-0.1376831234,
-0.2506366968,
-0.2758415639,
-0.7977594137,
0.6227231026,
0.2361041456,
0.2234915942,
-0.0647001266,
0.3218629956,
0.1313308775,
0.2329077423,
-1.1182841063,
0.2317926139,
-0.4534144104,
-0.0913064927,
-0.1843041182,
-0.338121444,
-0.1953781545,
-0.1242143884,
0.311317116,
-0.3410880268,
0.1410099864,
0.3743388951,
-0.5557337999,
-0.2289835066,
0.3632755876,
0.6657416224,
0.7986937761,
0.0450162739,
0.4630259573,
-0.0100536253,
-0.4137006998,
0.1307146251,
-0.2209191918,
-0.1271385998,
-0.2962784767,
0.5079999566,
0.721942246,
0.4346772432,
-0.4336385131,
0.9022587538,
-0.0231484547,
0.0211296044,
-0.0262562353,
-0.2378369272,
-0.2237285376,
0.0662854686,
0.35942626,
0.4840558171,
0.1945877373,
-0.6401231885,
0.4057795107,
0.6422946453,
-0.2500917315,
-0.6861096025,
0.6187524199,
0.0009546029,
0.1911294013,
0.2784065604,
0.1269037277,
-0.4913135171,
0.3988927901,
0.9096851945,
0.7202273011,
-0.1750003695,
0.0284003709,
0.2871314585,
0.3024995029,
-0.2147602439,
0.0220428091,
-0.2425956428,
-0.9202451706,
-0.6129285693,
-0.4880975485,
0.0480246656,
0.3929558694,
-0.5599352121,
0.3310568631,
-0.2847056687,
-0.243330434,
-0.1839419603,
-0.780921042,
-0.7898777127,
0.1129490957,
0.0623362772,
0.213127777,
-0.7090791464,
1.1398562193,
0.7055443525,
-0.3289115429,
-0.4997730553,
0.4555667043,
0.0314421095,
-0.7482720613,
0.6343513131,
0.2406142056,
-0.2039989531,
0.0062174383,
-0.7640661001,
-0.9109993577,
0.7714364529,
0.3265127242,
-0.4179347157,
-0.0862948149,
-0.0984239355,
0.2460511327,
-0.3529573977,
0.1122368649,
0.335514307,
0.5069375038,
0.0667070523,
-0.9036970139,
0.1701626927,
0.101786606,
-0.1117758527,
0.0542143397,
-0.3239908516,
1.1433509588,
-0.0391607881,
-0.301612705,
-0.1141408011,
0.3037457168,
0.0428884029,
0.1494563371,
0.5816384554,
0.2552128732,
0.3831689954,
0.1491017342,
1.1481360197,
-0.1371306479,
0.4109719098,
1.1868618727,
-0.3637913465,
0.8168624043,
0.8622652888,
0.3075689375,
0.351572752,
0.5224056244,
0.2965524197,
0.8121051788,
-0.2449529618,
-0.2989748418,
-0.413472712,
0.3348011672,
-0.413073957,
0.5193067193,
0.4270213842,
-0.2431147844,
-0.3542609811,
0.3902563751,
-0.1445119083,
-0.1714327633,
-0.28608796,
0.8003610373,
0.0165088959,
-0.7704911232,
0.7114118934,
-0.1443779022,
0.7575734258,
-0.5496674776,
0.0303607192,
0.0839918926,
0.2295985967,
-0.1146850884,
-0.5194068551,
0.294622004,
-0.33330217,
-0.3103625774,
-0.3134064078,
0.9336187243,
-0.6478582621,
0.0336530395,
0.3931080103,
0.639033556,
-0.1937620491,
-0.219219476,
-0.48770383,
0.1496470273,
0.0308742337,
-0.4147682786,
0.5403707623,
0.4268771112,
-0.2789445221,
0.3462846279,
0.708694756,
-0.1623436958,
0.070284754,
-0.2386206836,
0.8980715871,
-0.6051896214,
-0.912692368,
-1.0418462753,
0.2862121463,
0.0579374619,
0.0001482918,
0.8136764765,
0.1695446372,
0.8265777826,
-0.3212598562,
0.7991926074,
0.2320433259,
-0.1941530108,
-0.6687129736,
0.7273864746,
-0.864005208,
0.3985335827,
-0.4712978601,
-0.9558303952,
-0.3071813881,
0.4031443,
-0.2703662813,
0.0946282372,
0.7519034743,
0.6546741724,
-0.5158036351,
-0.056697689,
0.7331944704,
0.3655662835,
0.435962975,
0.5358474255,
0.966308713,
-0.1998965293,
0.6915915608,
0.3412035406,
-0.3313551247,
-0.2299532741,
-1.009373188,
-0.9589671493,
-0.6409477592,
-0.0131776426,
-0.4084979296,
-0.1585626304,
0.5039702654,
1.1084522009,
-0.6096873283,
-0.0659023076,
0.0607144125,
0.1110862866,
0.0717152059,
-0.1971303076,
0.3580850065,
-0.4064504802,
-0.6177543998,
0.5473255515,
0.4942672253,
0.2423576713,
-0.2669260502,
-0.0464524888,
-0.1475151628,
0.158990413,
0.8226328492,
0.0615726896,
-0.8147289753,
-0.5233777165,
-0.1754295826,
-0.1020370126,
0.3319570124,
0.8836535811,
-0.815040648,
0.6404687762,
0.5246055722,
0.6379179358,
0.603297472,
-0.0328017212,
0.6518009305,
-1.0088895559,
0.4621627629,
-0.0304793175,
0.5690204501,
0.2516815066,
-0.3886067569,
-0.1787384599,
0.2840109468,
-0.5711596012,
-0.617641747,
0.5912675261,
-0.9034950733,
-0.6896902323,
1.0970412493,
-0.0650666803,
-0.2551802397,
-0.200715825,
-0.2938620746,
0.1528348625,
-0.2691856027,
0.5884283185,
0.7257761955,
0.1639642715,
-0.1565092951,
-0.5927540064,
0.6513778567,
0.4849071503,
-0.7320588231,
-0.1355481446,
0.8735199571,
0.4459518492,
0.0198103748,
0.6452607512,
-0.3121553659,
0.1943460703,
-0.3404019773,
-0.0498065911,
0.1619182378,
-0.4149950445,
-0.5643357038,
0.5144324303,
-0.2486461848,
-0.1892182529
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04219v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04219v1
|
Swap distance minimization in SOV languages. Cognitive and mathematical foundations
| 2023-12-07T11:10:28 | 2023-12-07T11:10:28 |
Ramon Ferrer-i-Cancho, Savithry Namboodiripad
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, physics.soc-ph
|
Distance minimization is a general principle of language. A special case of
this principle in the domain of word order is swap distance minimization. This
principle predicts that variations from a canonical order that are reached by
fewer swaps of adjacent constituents are lest costly and thus more likely. Here
we investigate the principle in the context of the triple formed by subject
(S), object (O) and verb (V). We introduce the concept of word order rotation
as a cognitive underpinning of that prediction. When the canonical order of a
language is SOV, the principle predicts SOV < SVO, OSV < VSO, OVS < VOS, in
order of increasing cognitive cost. We test the prediction in three flexible
order SOV languages: Korean (Koreanic), Malayalam (Dravidian), and Sinhalese
(Indo-European). Evidence of swap distance minimization is found in all three
languages, but it is weaker in Sinhalese. Swap distance minimization is
stronger than a preference for the canonical order in Korean and especially
Malayalam.
|
[
-0.2437332124,
-0.6916033626,
0.6922872663,
0.1606166065,
-0.1111178026,
-0.3324306607,
-0.1359960139,
-0.4970962107,
0.270529896,
0.6539738774,
-0.5645314455,
-0.1749062091,
-0.5292455554,
-0.0980116129,
-0.1289463937,
0.5219503641,
-0.204353869,
0.2915657461,
-0.1972578019,
-0.4423123002,
-0.4286954701,
-0.47461465,
-0.2699647546,
-0.2042967975,
0.1460656971,
0.4870012999,
1.1224536896,
0.8651251793,
0.4855659604,
0.2565742135,
-0.0510457046,
0.0176398885,
-0.3281116486,
0.2963215411,
-0.038770631,
-1.0518792868,
-0.0518371612,
0.0101406658,
0.5709694624,
0.7761170268,
-0.2464307547,
-0.172677651,
-0.70192945,
1.2587765455,
-0.753412962,
-0.0330345519,
-0.3435217142,
0.0013354353,
-0.6780871749,
0.0597236827,
-0.0420588814,
-0.4460266531,
0.1790765077,
-0.7549892068,
0.0259255245,
0.0869498476,
0.9943589568,
0.2040316015,
-0.1893246323,
-0.1904328167,
-0.8386795521,
0.8220855594,
-0.1649829596,
0.6023136973,
0.4444999099,
0.4039386213,
-0.2317004353,
-0.243755132,
-0.7527638674,
-0.2087519765,
0.1924102008,
0.2359501719,
-0.1330125928,
0.2762224376,
0.3102671206,
0.2259323597,
-0.2818778455,
0.2016335428,
-0.6905418634,
-0.0882044733,
0.5395755172,
0.2589725852,
0.4699332118,
-0.2335412502,
-0.5090923905,
-0.1064892709,
-0.9448248744,
0.2886106074,
0.4625334144,
0.1652389616,
0.1474642158,
0.802687645,
-0.1939289272,
0.4078601897,
0.1452996284,
-0.1873658895,
0.206341669,
-0.5603803396,
-0.057016205,
0.0358680747,
0.6128172874,
0.3764133751,
0.1349509656,
0.151912868,
-0.0298866201,
0.4073442221,
0.220556125,
-0.2971272469,
0.1056291908,
-0.2018754929,
-0.6199039221,
-0.0376753397,
0.1097863019,
-0.4878047705,
-0.0977132767,
-0.301218003,
0.2321666181,
-0.7681163549,
-0.2787582576,
0.4227145612,
-0.0303992182,
0.1202237085,
0.3909564018,
-0.8936375976,
0.6184335351,
0.734756887,
0.6329798102,
-0.4950171411,
-0.4502335787,
-0.2532216609,
0.2080679536,
-0.5215936303,
0.732665956,
-0.7624031901,
-0.6706208587,
-0.1845613718,
-0.4965180457,
-0.0289987307,
-0.4696014822,
0.1485235244,
-0.4163770676,
0.272752732,
-0.0522486493,
-0.4225274324,
-0.2045602202,
-0.3815528452,
-0.3906370699,
1.344350338,
0.113714911,
-0.6779802442,
0.3402490616,
-0.2516498864,
-0.5526803732,
0.0077167521,
-0.4249978065,
-0.1942086965,
0.5416734815,
-0.4289984703,
0.2534504831,
-0.4413813055,
-0.1572319418,
-0.0728678256,
-0.198235482,
-0.0378739238,
-0.0872339532,
0.632121563,
0.299677521,
-0.4127569497,
-0.0136192748,
-0.566637218,
-0.0668702647,
0.0203438699,
-0.3919672668,
-0.9165782332,
0.0682769418,
-0.2417955697,
0.2445882708,
0.0134223355,
-0.3021717668,
0.4215173423,
-0.4900825024,
0.1195524856,
0.7501159906,
-0.218494907,
0.9316902757,
0.0594810918,
0.6727004051,
0.1780906916,
0.4005001485,
0.3694778383,
-0.5173755884,
-0.7756726742,
-0.5029122829,
-0.0216197483,
0.5681588054,
-0.8622574806,
-0.1269772798,
-0.3216156065,
-0.2672900259,
-0.3714039922,
-0.0930728167,
0.5068098903,
-0.0870428979,
0.3627177477,
-0.0167503953,
-0.3157891631,
-0.9808375239,
-0.452150166,
-0.4067494571,
0.1528595835,
0.0365346558,
0.1795321703,
-0.372266233,
0.7263551354,
-0.7988176942,
-0.0320346169,
-0.2559668124,
0.1315584928,
-0.0903762281,
0.1749776304,
0.5260548592,
-0.9296595454,
-0.6693967581,
0.0530955866,
-0.0425063558,
-0.1237595752,
0.0121929497,
-0.2163252681,
0.6218698025,
1.0608059168,
-0.761649847,
0.7949964404,
0.2750412226,
-0.1173719913,
0.4027367234,
-0.4240406752,
-0.4615228176,
-0.8973990679,
-0.5236771703,
-0.4116077423,
-0.304192245,
-0.8163366318,
-0.0645697713,
-0.0257034991,
0.4098262191,
-0.5465295911,
0.393956691,
-0.4002213776,
0.0203238018,
-0.286107868,
0.3031071723,
-0.4669327438,
0.1670432687,
0.0933009237,
0.3930315077,
0.4872617722,
-0.9891015291,
0.0638278201,
0.0178858154,
-0.3479504883,
0.7676309347,
-0.3453936577,
-0.3276005089,
-0.3823765516,
-0.108404696,
-0.9115068316,
0.3329675198,
0.1220660657,
-0.1500760615,
0.3828640282,
0.2381293327,
-0.2066245675,
-0.1338857412,
-0.3326613009,
0.6081100106,
0.431248039,
-0.2159983218,
0.3082306683,
0.3824849129,
-0.0192627963,
-0.623201251,
-0.5230236053,
-0.5391452909,
-0.0383226871,
-0.5569018722,
0.4165113568,
-0.1350811124,
-0.4437751174,
-0.0534897074,
-0.5578972697,
0.2369462401,
-0.0841978714,
0.2434764802,
0.1108503193,
-0.1491163671,
0.2886541486,
-0.0487653613,
-0.5150621533,
-0.275772661,
-0.4898379445,
0.5574205518,
-0.3254721463,
-0.294701606,
-0.0008507174,
0.1036396176,
0.7759237289,
0.1676550806,
0.5340421796,
0.3047001958,
-0.3136939108,
0.1610843092,
-0.8207634687,
0.1955376714,
-0.4758457839,
0.3050895333,
-0.6015834212,
-0.787564218,
0.2204225063,
0.0076489169,
-0.2526009977,
0.6898295283,
0.4587916434,
-0.0594260842,
0.6556990147,
0.7291262746,
-0.1502356678,
0.6605529189,
-0.1372414678,
0.3229248226,
-0.4907211363,
-0.140132606,
-0.53691113,
-0.1420480311,
-1.2362829447,
-0.9219616652,
0.3326592743,
0.4058457315,
-0.1897953004,
0.2991923392,
0.0695091262,
0.7647750378,
0.6580875516,
-0.3396650553,
0.1145181209,
0.0518873632,
-0.5848183036,
-0.227813974,
-0.6449210644,
-0.2489340752,
0.6757004857,
0.0752445981,
0.8291463852,
0.1978268772,
0.9537870884,
0.0645204559,
-0.3688933551,
-0.8297111392,
0.8209463358,
-0.2332613915,
-0.2847058475,
-0.7114679813,
-0.3055695593,
-1.24390769,
0.3262009323,
0.0065858779,
-0.689312458,
0.232260406,
-0.3226184845,
-0.2000491768,
0.1019492671,
-0.3586608469,
0.4251640737,
-0.1530824304,
-0.0104163177,
-0.6996287704,
-0.7934788465,
0.0864315554,
0.2498770058,
0.2228021622,
-0.2725379765,
-0.1657316089,
0.6379889846,
-0.9501585364,
0.4165129662,
-0.0075407461,
0.2690922916,
0.2795243561,
0.4342874885,
0.4033519924,
-0.1481543183,
0.1780288368,
0.27767995,
0.0571269654,
-0.542632699,
-0.3220690787,
0.6293087006,
-0.9419564605,
-0.6660502553,
-0.6228420138,
-0.3662517965,
0.0277753249,
0.4520962536,
0.4261236787,
-0.1232487634,
-0.0807162896,
0.0602921396,
0.472032696,
-0.1056963876,
0.5786994696,
0.6761484146,
-0.3062224388,
-0.4398473203,
0.8601272106,
0.3554283381,
0.6189326048,
0.6786501408,
0.7363895774,
-0.2208891958,
-0.3311963379,
-0.0482472368,
0.4501325488,
-0.6259827018,
-0.0170278195,
-0.42595312,
0.0614527129,
-0.2248729169,
-0.4028053582,
-0.8713178635,
-1.0371037722,
0.0366617292,
-0.1755412519,
0.3950326145,
0.7124814987,
-0.1775134802,
0.2319910079,
-0.4730926454,
0.6108207703,
0.3021180928,
0.2559229434,
-0.4689972997,
-0.3039621711,
-0.0767523348,
0.1433417052,
-0.346984148,
-0.6019743085,
0.201734215,
0.0564308092,
0.5979201794,
0.5958029628,
0.086435169,
0.9574447274,
-0.7147384286,
0.9144589901,
0.8123850226,
-1.1327586174,
0.369129926,
-0.3466693759,
0.1028017625,
0.5339874029,
0.2593567371,
-0.9185656309,
-0.4474597871,
-0.8593697548,
-0.9972064495,
0.9895455241,
0.4103699327,
-0.000017236,
-0.1190344989,
0.4430749118,
0.3014785051,
0.3816708326,
-0.5648572445,
-0.816367507,
-0.0918865278,
-0.0238415543,
0.0927408114,
-0.1327739507,
0.3076183498,
-0.2256507427,
0.5885071158,
0.1446920931,
0.3958034217,
-0.1505854428,
-0.1482102424,
-0.1860874742,
-0.0329740308,
1.2508716583,
0.3805274367,
0.1811562628,
0.1439650804,
0.1757531017,
-0.7419876456,
0.3170268238,
-0.518579483,
-0.4373263121,
-0.0602642559,
-0.0669584349,
0.8998287916,
0.0435889065,
-0.2120739073,
0.5364506245,
0.0601684377,
-0.0904760659,
-0.1877308637,
0.0261069983,
0.1013443992,
0.1667600125,
-0.0535020642,
0.4510521591,
-0.1441105753,
-0.390442729,
-0.1426081508,
0.3062859476,
-0.2409576327,
-0.5309234858,
0.3560137153,
-0.1368240863,
-0.436432004,
0.5205429792,
-0.0979888961,
-0.5723727345,
0.4548195004,
0.3557802439,
0.9434781075,
-0.6925423145,
0.3106584847,
0.0508542322,
0.3074393868,
-0.6069309115,
0.7124097943,
0.1672615409,
-0.7290884256,
0.1050075367,
-0.3807908595,
-0.2790851891,
-0.1520636976,
-0.7604457736,
0.6101661325,
-0.4628316462,
-0.0487362817,
-0.1165229306,
-0.2064743638,
-0.609254241,
0.0432675332,
0.1525807232,
0.3647312522,
-0.6311348081,
0.8217448592,
0.6595215201,
-0.3516501486,
-0.4775417447,
0.2004303336,
0.0034713545,
-1.2417850494,
1.1762876511,
0.1378422081,
-0.5314417481,
-0.5560573339,
-0.1567092538,
-1.2637956142,
0.8350585103,
0.247983858,
-0.1815327257,
0.2105558068,
0.5041201115,
0.7440143228,
-0.3015859425,
0.1904206574,
0.4754531384,
0.4155985415,
-0.0485665165,
-0.7556907535,
-0.1281324923,
0.1435221732,
0.6735928655,
0.6235849261,
-1.0506318808,
0.8715785742,
-0.2014198601,
-0.3346481621,
-0.1126787663,
0.6396739483,
-0.0168712754,
0.2664189637,
0.5445559025,
0.4034859538,
0.7304325104,
-0.1033110395,
0.9495544434,
-0.2416473478,
0.0436482355,
0.7861821055,
-0.3029942214,
0.8990505338,
0.9084509611,
-0.5005485415,
0.5058646798,
0.3406116664,
0.6121082306,
0.7049859166,
0.4591072202,
0.2388449013,
-0.0198398773,
0.1361351758,
-0.2419509888,
0.6728240252,
0.4805367589,
0.1790523827,
0.2658149302,
0.0847312436,
0.2613624632,
0.0402243324,
-0.2674850821,
0.6958271265,
0.0131032458,
-0.606372416,
0.8575264812,
0.1395231932,
0.3103162646,
-0.6720371842,
0.3678012788,
-0.2791239917,
0.3989956081,
0.1161240265,
-0.4106585681,
0.3988210261,
-0.660982132,
-0.5349399447,
-0.4161918163,
0.3275643587,
-0.4128247797,
-0.4267873168,
0.3362370431,
0.2794801295,
0.072421208,
0.299634248,
-0.4802064598,
-0.320967555,
-0.0530057698,
-0.4328076243,
0.4082885087,
0.5106480122,
-0.488278985,
0.8151127696,
0.3192826807,
0.388486892,
0.3974868953,
-0.211098671,
0.5475386381,
-0.7094766498,
-0.7664519548,
-0.8219360113,
0.0326008014,
0.1813528538,
-0.1789770275,
0.8014783859,
0.3008634448,
1.0967509747,
-0.3620728254,
0.6680489779,
0.2112221122,
0.3445541263,
-0.5445321202,
0.104094252,
-0.7065287828,
0.145053938,
-0.3682024181,
-0.9775998592,
-0.3352556527,
0.8571881056,
-0.6102674007,
-0.163174957,
1.344071269,
0.7263794541,
0.0292694774,
0.0135603854,
0.5072558522,
0.1326092929,
0.0450599343,
0.1043547615,
0.7440018058,
-0.4987125397,
0.5349900126,
-0.3837462366,
0.1057170555,
-0.5988256335,
-0.6775220037,
-0.6925527453,
-0.5416858792,
-0.607027173,
-0.47986269,
-0.1169519797,
0.9936922193,
0.4447464943,
-0.6329959631,
-0.5090814233,
-0.5382257104,
0.4449234307,
-0.6568710804,
-0.2103995532,
0.4863168299,
-0.1848499477,
-0.5690573454,
0.2112370133,
0.7927666306,
0.1665620357,
0.0928333327,
-0.3680562377,
-0.305627197,
0.4352958202,
0.5480180979,
0.3987587094,
-1.1107041836,
-0.2967735529,
0.2242053002,
-0.462703228,
0.2105404586,
1.0254900455,
-0.3413120508,
0.7385957241,
0.8585780263,
0.2839718163,
0.569960475,
-0.304364413,
0.5875908732,
-0.7461894751,
0.3693912923,
-0.1240378991,
0.1377033889,
-0.0524505526,
-0.3960134089,
0.5821866393,
0.6484225392,
-0.1539900452,
-0.4858289063,
0.751832068,
-0.6569741368,
-0.2385842353,
1.3277720213,
0.1375717372,
-0.238145262,
-0.2655117512,
-0.2764607966,
0.1200422719,
-0.1914381087,
0.6418520808,
0.61415869,
-0.3912779391,
0.2443549484,
-0.368285656,
0.7400630116,
0.8781169057,
-0.4761846662,
0.0349353813,
0.3444608748,
0.1747045815,
0.5676580071,
0.6979352236,
-0.0653617084,
0.2508369386,
-0.1307524592,
0.2417174131,
0.22876136,
-0.2408463806,
-0.1430871934,
-0.2215812802,
-0.175738737,
-0.3998598754
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04193v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04193v2
|
Language Model Knowledge Distillation for Efficient Question Answering in Spanish
| 2023-12-07T10:21:22 | 2024-03-16T17:44:27 |
Adrián Bazaga, Pietro Liò, Gos Micklem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, stat.ML
|
Recent advances in the development of pre-trained Spanish language models has
led to significant progress in many Natural Language Processing (NLP) tasks,
such as question answering. However, the lack of efficient models imposes a
barrier for the adoption of such models in resource-constrained environments.
Therefore, smaller distilled models for the Spanish language could be proven to
be highly scalable and facilitate their further adoption on a variety of tasks
and scenarios. In this work, we take one step in this direction by developing
SpanishTinyRoBERTa, a compressed language model based on RoBERTa for efficient
question answering in Spanish. To achieve this, we employ knowledge
distillation from a large model onto a lighter model that allows for a wider
implementation, even in areas with limited computational resources, whilst
attaining negligible performance sacrifice. Our experiments show that the dense
distilled model can still preserve the performance of its larger counterpart,
while significantly increasing inference speedup. This work serves as a
starting point for further research and investigation of model compression
efforts for Spanish language models across various NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.3528719246,
-1.0240952969,
0.6691887975,
0.4680846035,
-0.2928696573,
0.1370540857,
-0.4867240489,
-0.4725116193,
0.0765797794,
0.4323074222,
-0.4568346441,
-0.151654318,
-0.7479689717,
0.2267438471,
-0.361110121,
0.9506586194,
0.3005388379,
0.1481295526,
-0.2668406963,
-0.0442936011,
-0.4203186333,
-0.499917239,
-0.683314383,
-0.4077577293,
0.5256461501,
0.3612712622,
0.5818388462,
0.5370221138,
0.4575031102,
0.3848464191,
-0.4838406742,
-0.0661506131,
-0.6331118345,
0.484284997,
-0.1767153144,
-0.5614858866,
-0.2537404597,
-0.248406902,
0.4038155079,
0.7332537174,
-0.4800860286,
0.340213269,
0.1422618628,
0.6395546198,
-0.2817364037,
0.1348937601,
-0.8873382807,
-0.2195919901,
-0.0244252998,
-0.1588465124,
-0.32598719,
-0.6467645764,
0.3295158744,
-0.2629912794,
0.4431002438,
0.0207039751,
0.6496269107,
0.8035712242,
-0.1831718832,
-0.4385246634,
-0.873169899,
0.7443206906,
-0.7225498557,
0.3449454904,
0.2764177024,
0.6390336156,
-0.2794133127,
-0.9477927089,
-0.7072287798,
-0.2457140982,
0.1099577099,
-0.2610342801,
-0.4579388499,
0.09195555,
0.0532786585,
0.5069771409,
-0.5894477963,
0.0869372338,
-0.663939774,
0.1045961231,
0.1815257818,
-0.0422074609,
0.1098463386,
-0.1240722388,
-0.1328029782,
-0.2184818387,
-0.5299354196,
-0.0911276266,
0.2614970505,
0.3157408535,
0.4137604833,
0.5211555362,
-0.3740490377,
1.0044077635,
-0.0469263308,
-0.1681679487,
-0.0831502825,
0.0496869199,
-0.3252653778,
-0.0569605976,
0.7012223005,
-0.0508978441,
0.1825279593,
-0.3279975653,
0.2431318164,
-0.1108138934,
0.1269907206,
-1.0912110806,
-0.4731296003,
0.4155836701,
-0.2306560278,
-0.1582762301,
-0.1728650033,
-0.72742033,
-0.3496686816,
0.0106687667,
0.1455048174,
-0.2036459893,
-0.3279052079,
0.6659579277,
-0.3399353921,
-0.300860852,
0.3516740203,
-0.7769069672,
0.4234612882,
0.5277381539,
0.7552115917,
0.0446142554,
0.0550333522,
-0.4123650789,
-0.1117567495,
0.1947381347,
0.7077797651,
-0.3075799644,
-0.1866776496,
-0.4594435096,
-0.0650560558,
-0.0566735379,
-0.7236459255,
0.6206407547,
-0.8017446995,
0.4311498106,
-0.0621629283,
-0.3831987083,
-0.5195642114,
0.3435564935,
-0.9990822673,
1.2628221512,
0.1655045897,
-0.7625769377,
-0.0546250083,
-0.3800376654,
-0.3014739752,
-0.0371250324,
0.2705984712,
-0.0932677239,
0.4316821098,
0.2218145281,
0.4220713079,
-0.9233366847,
0.463616699,
-0.2460654229,
-0.0435629673,
0.4104480147,
-0.66113621,
0.9560350776,
0.3486798704,
-0.1121506765,
-0.2909464836,
-0.7409505248,
0.1514156163,
0.1254585683,
-0.4510269761,
-0.563319087,
-0.2592895925,
-0.0068495553,
0.3897354007,
0.5860930085,
-0.5293034315,
0.1541625112,
-0.2113220543,
0.4133440852,
0.2596371472,
0.0429462194,
0.4103854895,
-0.1637552679,
0.9822793603,
-0.4892389774,
0.2110011429,
0.2408859581,
-0.4639576674,
-0.7223742008,
-0.2662431896,
0.5475690961,
0.5616053939,
-0.8773493171,
0.2073615789,
-0.314165622,
-0.7004995346,
-0.4986145794,
0.2386141419,
0.3665812612,
0.7789748311,
0.4583877623,
0.2344511896,
-0.6510635614,
-0.7334278822,
-0.0526033267,
-0.3103991747,
-0.3027111292,
0.154696852,
0.3803922236,
0.2140984535,
0.8528167605,
-0.8540428877,
-0.2570645809,
-0.7735988498,
0.1956076771,
0.5092009902,
0.4962032437,
0.7180524468,
-0.8906194568,
-0.5977593064,
-0.1370764077,
-0.4798721969,
-0.2643070519,
0.3155974746,
-0.0805810243,
-0.1621774137,
0.5421053767,
-0.2695517242,
0.0830264911,
1.059350729,
-0.1823976636,
0.2863750756,
-0.4759082198,
0.2016914338,
-1.3082309961,
0.2315571159,
-0.1346341372,
-0.3571553826,
-0.834261179,
-0.001977683,
0.0493421108,
0.1820859164,
-0.6736109257,
0.5072356462,
-0.5186749697,
0.3964311779,
-0.3491145074,
0.0138213569,
0.3494792581,
0.4780760407,
0.2905965447,
0.7161118388,
0.3260811269,
-0.6224838495,
0.3232540488,
0.1198821515,
-0.3615726531,
0.225358963,
-1.2830681801,
0.0621752404,
-0.2867049575,
0.1274058372,
-0.9118899107,
0.0099745765,
-0.2083625495,
-0.2071409076,
0.1916899085,
-0.4994262159,
-0.5095493197,
-0.5496276021,
0.013116302,
0.4565610886,
0.6263523102,
-0.4227502346,
0.5194553733,
0.5784877539,
-0.3816222548,
-0.4748391807,
-0.8014776111,
-0.16355367,
-0.5498222113,
-0.6271873116,
0.3210134208,
-0.1532916576,
-0.2952212691,
-0.0229944475,
-0.1069345772,
-0.6690492034,
0.2394582629,
0.061665725,
0.1455355287,
-0.1361275315,
0.2829251587,
0.1744750142,
0.0821753591,
-0.1716215014,
-0.2886031568,
0.9529044032,
-0.1298704892,
0.0186042748,
-0.4530318081,
0.1035140976,
0.6197497845,
-0.1978197992,
1.1228780746,
0.0783994272,
-0.2390259057,
-0.2428484112,
-0.8440087438,
-0.2289608121,
-0.4568217993,
0.3871924579,
-0.3910126984,
-1.0010209084,
0.8271118402,
-0.1679767072,
-0.1603819132,
0.3410773277,
0.4100148082,
0.0557907447,
0.7305908203,
0.877576232,
0.0185933076,
0.6478335261,
-0.334104985,
0.0245281029,
-0.6820807457,
-0.2701444328,
-1.1680413485,
-0.249337554,
-0.1403468847,
-0.8347007036,
0.4249742925,
0.2927682996,
0.3371228278,
0.5857254863,
-0.3595530987,
0.8102901578,
0.4920293689,
0.1743584275,
0.7065807581,
-0.2191417366,
0.2032677531,
0.013669434,
-1.195904851,
-0.3664430082,
1.040646553,
0.2045707107,
0.7083562016,
0.2750024498,
0.6016196012,
-0.0650526509,
0.1489727646,
-0.5180262923,
0.2784436643,
-0.2263099998,
-0.9020086527,
-0.4232378006,
-0.6353136897,
-0.9366940856,
0.4267478585,
-0.0733968168,
-0.5894652605,
0.1936134994,
0.3196075857,
-0.4441763163,
0.0897811428,
-0.7176578045,
1.070492506,
-0.0896556079,
-0.2205046713,
-0.3099805713,
-0.386528343,
0.4668205976,
-0.0284428094,
-0.019396944,
-0.1147817671,
0.2029557079,
0.7083664536,
-0.7412928939,
0.5185256004,
-0.2792022824,
-0.1044246033,
0.3777415454,
0.3091339171,
0.426857233,
0.1916583329,
-0.3319815695,
-0.021007726,
0.1804585606,
-0.2825788856,
-0.9549756646,
0.5208623409,
-0.2748629451,
-0.5104662776,
-0.3201011717,
-0.6993086934,
-0.2199595869,
0.0646832809,
0.0561059862,
0.4268725812,
-0.3809579611,
0.540366888,
0.9780420065,
-0.0727173686,
0.359377712,
0.632103622,
-0.3119438887,
-0.079721421,
0.4936617017,
0.0358590111,
0.3340771198,
0.3770365119,
0.3148755729,
-0.8265626431,
-0.8659996986,
-0.3747074604,
0.2551181614,
-0.4193587303,
-0.2747074366,
-0.8629403114,
0.0591818094,
-0.2795431018,
0.1836879551,
-0.5913295746,
-0.9647797942,
-0.2497865856,
-0.0028153306,
0.6042845845,
0.6722952127,
0.2875500321,
0.4666452408,
-0.7863187194,
0.4862757921,
0.4199852943,
0.0810993314,
0.1320645958,
-0.790245831,
-0.1422420889,
0.1757493615,
0.1718794554,
-0.9073454738,
0.5312975049,
0.3697803617,
0.5252393484,
0.1617385894,
0.394354254,
0.9707605839,
-0.4002520442,
0.4172638059,
-0.077653341,
-0.6491641998,
0.5878460407,
-0.1029103324,
0.3718359768,
1.1492019892,
0.5285051465,
-0.4060043395,
-0.7139447927,
-0.6110101938,
-0.8784040213,
0.4559853673,
0.0674234778,
0.1200600117,
-0.0682859272,
0.2117277086,
0.1655151993,
0.5345822573,
-0.7107710838,
-0.0349672846,
0.0790001377,
-0.3505039513,
-0.077257216,
-0.3219392598,
0.0794220716,
-0.4104916155,
0.714969933,
-0.0322118066,
-0.2399315834,
0.081823118,
-0.5587848425,
0.4592419267,
0.2031172812,
0.391564548,
0.4262518883,
-0.2748574913,
0.2117963731,
0.0658074692,
-0.5997757912,
0.0926377699,
0.2431723922,
-0.1442528218,
0.0396863185,
-0.0411035754,
0.5258260965,
0.1070405245,
-0.9635592103,
0.254488498,
-0.4708186984,
0.0000133939,
-0.1691746861,
0.1010281071,
0.1913974285,
0.4988068342,
0.4224204123,
-0.1588947177,
0.1879226565,
-0.5038542747,
-0.1403425932,
0.3389656544,
-0.1544006616,
-0.0655329302,
0.8045624495,
0.0535625629,
0.0295745898,
0.6836418509,
-0.2495253831,
-0.6853419542,
0.6131395698,
0.4625767171,
0.6535189152,
-0.1475203782,
0.3704279363,
0.4237862527,
0.1785093546,
-0.5714243054,
0.3717404008,
-0.2701116502,
-0.5221911073,
-0.5242948532,
-0.9815337062,
-0.2418943048,
-0.0189191326,
-0.6521420479,
-0.185328275,
-0.3459326029,
-0.1860834658,
-0.2717609704,
0.0565452911,
-0.5754243135,
-0.0176467933,
-0.507514894,
0.978854239,
-0.9145474434,
1.1885938644,
0.2820920646,
-0.4594161212,
-0.9048222899,
-0.3330954909,
-0.2703560889,
-0.4958167076,
0.8211284876,
-0.1591979861,
-0.2284915596,
0.1749025434,
0.0513260402,
-0.9018179178,
1.0502822399,
0.6479071975,
-0.426849097,
0.0582996048,
0.1292180419,
0.996563077,
-0.1293322891,
0.2127594501,
0.6346688271,
0.4184465408,
0.4422897398,
-1.0492371321,
-0.0830601379,
-0.3919569552,
0.0721013919,
0.0631103516,
-0.3054920435,
0.9581608772,
0.0957731977,
-0.2267422676,
0.3124780357,
0.7430163026,
0.0808628574,
-0.1213687584,
0.4128943384,
0.5776171684,
1.0740935802,
-0.2360899895,
0.9291419387,
-0.3677058816,
0.2178856581,
1.5482001305,
-0.1355710179,
0.9585185647,
0.7428449392,
-0.2288535088,
0.4853398204,
0.2755968273,
0.3129568696,
0.4113000929,
0.1901641339,
-0.3157639802,
-0.0883161649,
-0.3260897994,
-0.3133768737,
0.6527651548,
0.1312296689,
-0.3092224002,
-0.2538578212,
0.1055843011,
0.1664544195,
0.3804709315,
-0.1469236612,
0.731842041,
-0.3135673106,
-0.9529922009,
0.7513182759,
-0.0504826754,
0.6162739396,
-0.5695031285,
0.1224619225,
-0.2943805754,
0.0778623819,
0.0705934092,
-0.4723141193,
0.5210703015,
0.3563997447,
-0.380908072,
-0.5521708727,
0.3357336223,
-0.7675171494,
-0.6119684577,
0.0913561136,
0.7703757882,
0.2738548219,
-0.4522250593,
-0.3693588674,
-0.0313304439,
0.0491641834,
-0.2393424958,
0.2045006752,
0.5283939838,
0.1073614433,
0.806779027,
0.6193367243,
0.3266257346,
0.5400974154,
0.2385151386,
0.893222034,
-0.2530592084,
-0.5333212018,
-0.7010061741,
0.4811769426,
-0.2398697585,
-0.1239481643,
0.8855910301,
0.5452754498,
0.5991606116,
-0.1079367027,
0.4587644637,
-0.4078183174,
0.5991460681,
-0.6107640862,
0.7386196256,
-0.378899008,
0.3839794099,
-0.2420438379,
-1.0543657541,
-0.3459671736,
0.605111599,
-0.2498186529,
-0.0759317279,
0.7155310512,
0.8418250084,
-0.0377205908,
-0.0895284787,
0.1319567114,
0.2298425734,
0.2334693521,
0.6145194769,
0.6859121323,
-0.3176105022,
0.7342689037,
-0.6668027043,
-0.1083843708,
-0.1713766456,
-1.0521682501,
-0.9077527523,
-0.7041459084,
-0.2159130573,
-0.2847675681,
-0.0923152864,
0.6692388058,
0.5636962652,
-0.5478904843,
-0.2558454275,
-0.3376728892,
0.2599252164,
-0.1589446515,
-0.2009881288,
0.2754111588,
-0.0986161754,
-1.0518633127,
0.4731681347,
0.0384565219,
0.2885776758,
-0.2844250798,
0.0349817052,
-0.2179812938,
-0.0712089241,
0.2835997939,
0.5091494322,
-0.2886445522,
0.0257570297,
0.1762048155,
0.1060639098,
-0.0975283533,
0.8541001081,
-1.0605772734,
0.3862013519,
0.7801601291,
0.5741586685,
0.7227010727,
0.1085093394,
0.6276981235,
-0.760174334,
0.7759536505,
0.4857395291,
0.3214960992,
0.2379722297,
-0.136520192,
0.4220115244,
-0.2144601643,
-0.3530271053,
-0.9645919204,
0.2127216905,
-1.0027287006,
-0.5379932523,
0.8434965611,
-0.1814443767,
-0.4665591717,
-0.2756213248,
-0.3035838306,
0.2253851444,
-0.2398271263,
1.0033131838,
0.55944103,
-0.0336951166,
-0.2007639557,
-0.6021515727,
0.6004788876,
0.2502296865,
-0.8018924594,
0.1537193358,
0.5955778956,
0.2777498364,
0.0191783942,
0.5064118505,
-0.0304310378,
0.2791422009,
-0.0836727023,
0.0030944089,
-0.328877449,
-0.608469069,
-0.3976401985,
0.5792290568,
0.3227972984,
0.0539921597
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04134v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04134v1
|
Using a Large Language Model to generate a Design Structure Matrix
| 2023-12-07T08:48:54 | 2023-12-07T08:48:54 |
Edwin C. Y. Koh
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The Design Structure Matrix (DSM) is an established method used in dependency
modelling, especially in the design of complex engineering systems. The
generation of DSM is traditionally carried out through manual means and can
involve interviewing experts to elicit critical system elements and the
relationships between them. Such manual approaches can be time-consuming and
costly. This paper presents a workflow that uses a Large Language Model (LLM)
to support the generation of DSM and improve productivity. A prototype of the
workflow was developed in this work and applied on a diesel engine DSM
published previously. It was found that the prototype could reproduce 357 out
of 462 DSM entries published (i.e. 77.3%), suggesting that the work can aid DSM
generation. A no-code version of the prototype is made available online to
support future research.
|
[
-0.5546290874,
-0.5682561398,
0.8699247837,
0.2412990928,
-0.4535267353,
0.0680519715,
-0.0500664152,
-0.3533630371,
0.1842017174,
0.5273681283,
-0.5022855997,
-0.6715050936,
-0.2693420351,
0.1175767556,
-0.1687428206,
0.6784649491,
-0.6109225154,
0.0895134062,
-0.0827183723,
0.42650491,
-0.4380365312,
-0.4045483172,
-0.4001559317,
-0.3956079185,
0.6559267044,
0.1404724568,
0.4485783875,
0.6270236373,
0.5805897713,
0.3777583539,
-0.4487509131,
0.1044940129,
-0.3537840545,
0.4521279037,
-0.2751126587,
-0.3572942615,
-1.0665652752,
-0.1808558404,
0.4924300611,
0.7907887101,
-0.2007187158,
0.3520613015,
0.3086012006,
0.6896320581,
-0.4999412,
0.6758770943,
-0.3033001721,
-0.0571302995,
-0.2525935471,
-0.0360271372,
-0.4544035792,
-0.3437835872,
-0.3453279138,
-0.1219305396,
-0.1252272576,
-0.3676798344,
0.4792292118,
0.2349891812,
-0.3688486814,
-0.0900892168,
-0.9673721194,
0.7420592904,
-0.9605155587,
0.1924726814,
0.1203228384,
0.517906785,
-0.564337194,
-0.3888649642,
-0.3510563076,
-0.1432559937,
0.0156827923,
-0.2878423631,
0.2351459861,
0.2551724911,
0.3201443255,
0.3212152421,
-0.4762347341,
0.0820309892,
-0.6151661277,
0.2048684061,
0.8263526559,
0.6156057119,
0.3354825675,
-0.2798901796,
-0.2177510262,
0.073796466,
-0.7855194807,
-0.4590803981,
0.3590350747,
0.5952447653,
-0.1678939313,
0.7870746851,
-0.2133424133,
0.6781441569,
-0.0415754952,
-0.5878492594,
0.2372543514,
-0.4508777559,
-0.4088411331,
-0.0978388563,
0.4342958331,
0.1400089115,
-0.0479173549,
-0.0012489946,
-0.7895351052,
0.4609288871,
0.6268006563,
-1.0965702534,
-0.0445796959,
0.230131343,
-0.5998386145,
-0.553039372,
-0.261751622,
-0.5196376443,
-0.111442484,
-0.7994293571,
0.1955687255,
-0.0837677792,
-0.4917326272,
-0.0564655736,
-0.0414304361,
0.1930795759,
0.3898039758,
-0.6173499227,
0.088843666,
0.4893120527,
0.9423080087,
-0.2658204138,
0.0768101588,
-0.4027321041,
0.5763244629,
-0.6313104033,
1.0177404881,
-0.4263606668,
-0.5272589922,
-0.1838784367,
-0.0930628181,
0.0432571471,
-0.6368314624,
0.4603889287,
-0.5720958114,
-0.1214564592,
0.1069542542,
-0.4316926301,
-0.0036878586,
0.0861789361,
-0.8552715182,
0.7631546259,
0.2640120983,
-0.5840049386,
0.3419426084,
-0.8385334611,
-0.61769104,
0.3077732027,
-0.6334940195,
-0.4104917049,
0.4222204685,
-0.2011541426,
0.5867444873,
-0.4182491302,
0.6122207046,
-0.6025611758,
-0.2593884766,
-0.0565737225,
0.0929576829,
0.6697733402,
0.2926878035,
-0.4540851116,
-0.0317304209,
-1.1276916265,
0.0357322209,
0.0935447142,
-0.8399681449,
-0.1680370122,
0.1745244712,
0.1281139106,
0.6515706778,
0.0772752464,
-0.5044543743,
0.0991931558,
-0.3771529496,
0.1948391944,
0.7411543131,
0.0261781476,
0.4940233231,
-0.5406227708,
0.8233090043,
0.2052988559,
-0.2924748063,
-0.0617468394,
-0.186226964,
-0.6176255345,
-0.4427858293,
-0.1342286468,
0.1005166396,
-0.5027447343,
0.4297042489,
-0.0311856139,
-0.5120878816,
0.0007740991,
0.3163675666,
0.2620149553,
0.2718909383,
-0.0642619729,
-0.1414761394,
-0.8938244581,
-1.0938196182,
0.2292383611,
-0.2836467028,
-0.3134462535,
0.2438227981,
0.5831906199,
-0.4391114712,
0.738327682,
-0.9122874141,
-0.2314971387,
-0.473505199,
0.3490871787,
0.4613331854,
0.4401359558,
0.5344532132,
-0.3330688179,
-0.5400851965,
-0.3169173896,
-0.9005405307,
-0.2602100074,
0.3528684676,
-0.3471214175,
0.4918545485,
0.3768470585,
-0.7436381578,
0.4030119777,
0.3327105641,
-0.0743844733,
0.5082982183,
-0.1304886639,
-0.1334161907,
-1.7321138382,
0.3710955679,
0.0658125132,
0.0802203342,
-0.4664486647,
0.0377124101,
0.0215568524,
-0.3626174629,
-0.4518114924,
0.3231023848,
-0.7649857998,
-0.1290577203,
-0.4638491869,
-0.0298781805,
0.0111576216,
0.6271274686,
-0.0308904629,
0.7627854347,
0.3123807609,
-0.8458336592,
0.1044216603,
0.2417206764,
-0.6330548525,
0.7218587399,
-0.7180578113,
0.143509388,
-0.5791871548,
0.1132275313,
-1.1341114044,
-0.1849494427,
-0.1953894198,
0.0734389424,
0.6086739898,
-0.2604086995,
-0.6336656809,
-0.3500471413,
-0.165605709,
0.1379309893,
0.4567569792,
-0.4774850905,
0.5189061761,
0.9218360782,
-0.5342711806,
0.2952557504,
-0.3798597455,
0.2064954042,
-0.2663105726,
-1.1076674461,
0.5338207483,
-0.3810739219,
-0.5636550188,
-0.4557073116,
-0.1390295178,
-0.1366430968,
0.298188448,
0.3218930364,
0.5322877765,
-0.5050886273,
0.1218015701,
-0.0876995996,
-0.1348790079,
0.2839851677,
-0.0919148624,
0.5020064712,
0.3967526555,
0.0768743381,
-0.43706429,
0.8276101947,
1.0090041161,
-0.0807613209,
0.6768699288,
0.1349907368,
-0.5422560573,
-0.7967786193,
-0.1406867057,
-0.1101910546,
-0.5134166479,
0.4442827106,
-0.6381033659,
-0.3876560032,
0.2671770155,
-0.2752432823,
0.3905675411,
0.3554696143,
0.9410010576,
-0.0379903875,
1.5092202425,
1.1065121889,
0.0731451288,
0.3804242015,
-0.1516623497,
0.4294607639,
-0.7647510171,
-0.2344375104,
-0.7725045681,
-0.3751899004,
-0.2317496985,
-0.5237599611,
0.2688283622,
0.1637727469,
-0.0795186758,
0.5111893415,
-0.2709732354,
0.0089124851,
0.0273379553,
0.0669288412,
0.4065618217,
0.1762658358,
-0.5845016837,
0.0329447091,
-0.4020937085,
-1.0379593372,
0.9736790061,
0.2112765759,
1.2835366726,
0.4052185416,
0.7714833617,
0.1720163673,
0.4097525477,
-0.7895846963,
0.6532064676,
0.0755354241,
-0.4603986442,
-0.1544522792,
-0.4773828387,
-0.6310517788,
-0.0449107066,
0.2958498299,
-0.4662227631,
-0.0070525538,
-0.0830392241,
-0.2248548418,
0.1527958065,
-0.5332278013,
0.4989058375,
-0.0428511463,
-0.3396417797,
-0.3299162388,
0.1446264088,
0.4952992201,
-0.4165954292,
0.0902941748,
-0.1746540517,
0.1508926749,
0.8049010634,
-0.7915430665,
0.9138371944,
-0.050621707,
-0.8205969334,
0.1515291631,
0.1769451052,
0.8544455767,
-0.0782230943,
-0.2663864791,
-0.3515823185,
-0.3571387529,
-0.2085825056,
-0.5422327518,
0.7807557583,
-0.6273126006,
-0.839183569,
-0.1139526144,
-0.5465959311,
-0.2937209904,
0.192782566,
-0.3181785643,
0.5963653922,
-0.1808681935,
0.1105256528,
0.3604143262,
-0.0060709566,
0.6518512964,
0.6428427696,
-0.1979610175,
-0.2842272818,
0.4688122869,
0.2790109217,
0.2897595167,
0.3632503152,
-0.1781645268,
-0.1318411678,
-0.5467393994,
-0.5095019341,
0.278329879,
-0.6335349679,
-0.2101712227,
-0.7426278591,
-0.4347022474,
-0.4066298008,
-0.1409556121,
-0.4103682935,
-0.4515464306,
-0.0702730715,
-0.1842191517,
0.1073520109,
1.3971408606,
0.184187457,
-0.1401449442,
-0.6043204665,
0.2869945467,
0.4097700119,
0.7235044241,
0.0725949556,
-0.272497952,
-0.4877536595,
0.1283891648,
-0.5327557325,
-0.8475726843,
0.3929983675,
-0.1888317019,
0.9534505606,
0.1195956618,
0.1194482893,
0.4519949853,
-0.4911618531,
0.377476275,
0.0549699292,
-0.5587262511,
0.6276370287,
-0.469099611,
0.4207904935,
0.1824425459,
0.1705064774,
-0.0124925943,
-0.4448944628,
-0.1198957935,
-0.698582828,
0.7358565927,
0.1893129349,
-0.2243037075,
-0.0271009859,
0.1468338817,
-0.1027283967,
0.2782060802,
-0.3116960227,
-0.0833753124,
0.3059711158,
-0.3235363066,
-0.0125360023,
-0.4627123773,
-0.1788281947,
0.0258980878,
0.816649735,
-0.2746916413,
0.1533952206,
-0.1311571598,
-0.2710206509,
-0.3080918789,
0.3089642823,
0.7850447893,
1.1106485128,
-0.085305512,
0.3112425506,
-0.016763106,
-0.3206543028,
0.4538322985,
-0.0748085827,
-0.3100611567,
0.2116878331,
-0.1501277834,
0.5307380557,
0.2142974138,
-0.5705316067,
0.1530275494,
-0.1321230084,
-0.4725769758,
-0.2006344348,
0.0872946009,
0.4627326429,
0.4549072981,
0.13798365,
-0.2639737129,
-0.1004971638,
-0.387355715,
0.2624206841,
0.2781001925,
-0.1590571851,
-0.4304850996,
0.7486091852,
0.3419930637,
-0.4219203591,
0.2309309542,
-0.1214484125,
-0.3573225141,
0.7336881757,
0.8017731309,
1.1828773022,
-0.1620919257,
0.3328389823,
0.5253543258,
0.1489782929,
-0.1166578159,
0.7478809953,
0.0424479097,
-0.2870878279,
-0.6544252634,
-1.1195195913,
-0.2263896763,
0.2777169347,
-0.3444115818,
0.6207940578,
-0.4210706055,
-0.1242732927,
0.0717597306,
0.0686380789,
-0.6663150191,
0.1169136316,
0.3068856001,
0.7190464139,
-0.736358583,
0.8178362846,
1.0338134766,
-0.5927242637,
-0.8352752924,
-0.2967474163,
0.1040700302,
-0.5278915167,
0.9521276951,
-0.0254025105,
-0.2308576852,
-0.2671462297,
-0.0601120628,
-1.1326925755,
1.0819109678,
0.4027321935,
-0.6156343222,
-0.1076810434,
0.2269181758,
0.5380601287,
-0.7255758047,
0.0250030551,
0.2476592064,
0.3797832429,
0.0504072011,
-0.7123375535,
0.5276722908,
-0.668213129,
0.5502263308,
0.5349358916,
-0.4201064706,
0.8951206803,
-0.2076535076,
-0.5131819248,
0.0507250726,
0.2360658199,
0.5678997636,
-0.2560068667,
0.5702323914,
0.456920445,
0.5871405602,
0.5130092502,
0.4043268263,
-0.836787343,
0.141547963,
1.0693999529,
-0.5618507266,
0.8195389509,
0.4664134085,
-0.2480160743,
0.5997286439,
0.4790990949,
0.0577657707,
0.3547893465,
0.6203337312,
-0.3661942184,
-0.2282741815,
-0.1083406061,
-0.4328362942,
0.3101806939,
0.189932242,
-0.6735402942,
-0.520412147,
-0.2825163901,
0.1912931353,
-0.1025943458,
-0.1740585417,
0.9291229248,
0.4073266685,
-0.7112209201,
0.7122989297,
0.1345085502,
0.1482511908,
-0.2745931447,
-0.0542002879,
-0.4453949332,
0.4580473602,
-0.1731614918,
-0.4972020984,
0.5153904557,
0.1527486145,
-0.742796123,
-0.5583373308,
0.6025516391,
-0.4834338129,
-0.8268159032,
0.4270240068,
0.5345155597,
0.1795177907,
0.0825622305,
-0.1818113327,
0.098012127,
-0.2743568122,
-0.1432775557,
0.420437187,
0.3147205412,
-0.018075075,
0.3601258695,
0.4529022276,
0.0633176491,
-0.2451048344,
0.2024276108,
1.1577302217,
-0.7654042244,
-0.639839828,
-0.8245977163,
0.4303800464,
-0.1241416857,
0.0521184914,
0.5617136955,
0.7973675728,
0.5915092826,
-0.0299882945,
1.0970506668,
0.0908005312,
0.4579799175,
-0.3541205823,
0.7913000584,
-0.5633601546,
0.5618647933,
-0.6087555289,
-1.1708133221,
-0.0681116059,
0.4120782912,
0.179540053,
-0.0578825846,
0.7581407428,
1.1260479689,
-0.0322092883,
0.0721117035,
0.407220453,
0.5296763778,
0.6491444707,
0.6309886575,
0.6656926274,
-0.0741821975,
0.6690351963,
-0.1489359587,
-0.3351736367,
-0.0713190138,
-0.83564955,
-1.2766121626,
-0.4449162781,
-0.3911114633,
-0.415558368,
-0.2299925089,
0.8019502163,
0.7545496225,
-0.5261182189,
-0.6578570604,
-0.2231282741,
0.1510143429,
0.0187042952,
-0.119670637,
0.0730985031,
-0.5827183723,
-0.7159784436,
0.6733717322,
0.5158672333,
0.0535066128,
-0.8431574106,
-0.0477036797,
-0.0235856902,
0.1570043415,
0.8126777411,
-0.2837152183,
-0.1903191656,
-0.1094255447,
-0.0568832383,
-0.4190824628,
0.1347544044,
0.9823344946,
-0.5152868629,
0.2559087276,
0.9645175338,
0.4732780159,
0.652192533,
-0.4509363472,
1.4145383835,
-0.40638116,
-0.2311336696,
-0.124861449,
0.5717592835,
0.1336286515,
-0.2842050493,
0.3881933689,
0.2228481323,
-0.400562495,
-0.7808449864,
0.4197219908,
-0.5456590056,
-0.2591434419,
1.0630199909,
0.1036984175,
-0.4586795866,
-0.3894853294,
-0.2080367506,
0.1226823926,
-0.3445268273,
1.1091691256,
0.5710782409,
0.1637045592,
0.1149497032,
-0.3906653821,
0.4473610818,
0.0101547241,
-1.1155523062,
-0.0199799873,
0.3025985062,
0.3794057965,
0.0912998691,
0.691690743,
-0.2059876472,
-0.0482790358,
0.0430422463,
0.277523011,
0.0632766709,
-0.371637255,
-0.0761498362,
0.4183593392,
0.0772616416,
0.0213228613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04127v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04127v2
|
Analyzing the Inherent Response Tendency of LLMs: Real-World Instructions-Driven Jailbreak
| 2023-12-07T08:29:58 | 2024-02-23T07:32:27 |
Yanrui Du, Sendong Zhao, Ming Ma, Yuhan Chen, Bing Qin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extensive work has been devoted to improving the safety mechanism of Large
Language Models (LLMs). However, LLMs still tend to generate harmful responses
when faced with malicious instructions, a phenomenon referred to as "Jailbreak
Attack". In our research, we introduce a novel automatic jailbreak method
RADIAL, which bypasses the security mechanism by amplifying the potential of
LLMs to generate affirmation responses. The jailbreak idea of our method is
"Inherent Response Tendency Analysis" which identifies real-world instructions
that can inherently induce LLMs to generate affirmation responses and the
corresponding jailbreak strategy is "Real-World Instructions-Driven Jailbreak"
which involves strategically splicing real-world instructions identified
through the above analysis around the malicious instruction. Our method
achieves excellent attack performance on English malicious instructions with
five open-source advanced LLMs while maintaining robust attack performance in
executing cross-language attacks against Chinese malicious instructions. We
conduct experiments to verify the effectiveness of our jailbreak idea and the
rationality of our jailbreak strategy design. Notably, our method designed a
semantically coherent attack prompt, highlighting the potential risks of LLMs.
Our study provides detailed insights into jailbreak attacks, establishing a
foundation for the development of safer LLMs.
|
[
-0.3371755481,
-1.2983310223,
0.3506726921,
0.3321285248,
-0.434769243,
-0.0253363084,
-0.1850567609,
-0.67952317,
0.335986048,
0.6534074545,
-0.7180203795,
-0.3942029178,
-0.3390252888,
0.0477743819,
-0.3070399761,
1.061195612,
0.1421833932,
0.1315981895,
0.1109632999,
-0.1237063408,
-0.6473329067,
-0.4490352273,
-0.3346963525,
0.1449516565,
0.4995160103,
0.557446897,
0.3161083162,
0.43262133,
0.9360367656,
0.239617914,
0.110132426,
-0.0836347491,
-0.335226804,
0.284188062,
0.0396141745,
-0.6083074212,
-0.5764204264,
0.0875750259,
0.1334010661,
-0.0081860172,
-0.1779664457,
0.2659256756,
-0.0624479428,
0.9789358377,
-0.5314466953,
-0.4197252095,
-0.8448169827,
0.2062537968,
-0.233290866,
-0.2197001874,
-0.7089837193,
-0.5588830113,
-0.1172282174,
-0.0405710191,
0.114020884,
0.1983623207,
0.3811753988,
0.0495016947,
-0.0120067168,
-0.5759559274,
-0.6002226472,
0.5032327175,
-0.8034130931,
-0.0841260552,
0.0104265455,
0.408403039,
-0.2838943601,
-0.3976605833,
-0.4715933204,
-0.7010084391,
0.0826848298,
-0.0127917081,
-0.2093684375,
0.1245111823,
0.2450060844,
0.2400969863,
-0.7225205898,
0.0743717328,
-0.3136996925,
-0.1356353015,
0.7918686271,
0.2650541067,
0.6597261429,
-0.0895495415,
-0.5991644859,
0.0166425034,
-1.1592987776,
0.1365293413,
0.6467317343,
0.2324156612,
-0.220753938,
0.6821072102,
0.0808414146,
0.5627644062,
0.0779218897,
-0.0723926947,
0.0351929367,
-0.1413900852,
-0.121695824,
0.4185603857,
1.0139366388,
0.4586146176,
0.3542771041,
-0.275189817,
-0.2962633967,
-0.0789101273,
0.4753393233,
-0.8309078813,
-0.0836964846,
0.4377201498,
-0.3690591753,
-0.5509412289,
0.3825611174,
-0.7492021918,
-0.4307152331,
0.2749695778,
0.2252900302,
-0.4528932869,
-0.2256859541,
-0.0463156812,
0.0301197544,
0.35782215,
-0.0010980527,
-0.6827583313,
0.2475090921,
0.7374551892,
0.853271246,
-0.1088606268,
-0.0250691958,
-0.7062265873,
0.109346889,
-0.0832623318,
0.761441052,
-0.0853718072,
-0.6062833667,
-0.0910242051,
-0.1342685521,
0.2312582582,
-0.5775729418,
0.6026245356,
-0.6590932012,
-0.3151851594,
-0.0070666131,
-0.2862923443,
-0.0784812644,
0.4613481164,
-0.6985241771,
0.5712200999,
-0.4798353314,
-1.0123140812,
-0.0075586652,
-0.5410732627,
-0.6473814845,
-0.1841009855,
0.0570788309,
-0.501234889,
0.2766325176,
0.0165578648,
0.2933404148,
-0.1290416867,
0.1737811267,
-0.5795453191,
-0.3785430193,
0.7741851807,
-0.5982567668,
0.845911324,
0.3681370914,
-0.4782041311,
0.1961883157,
-0.6531524658,
-0.06998799,
0.5354911685,
-0.124466151,
-0.4678062797,
0.2073886693,
-0.2304074615,
0.1791921854,
0.3731246889,
-0.8614219427,
0.2945180237,
-0.7755323648,
0.3529395163,
0.9735301733,
0.173193723,
0.1834311634,
-0.1111663431,
0.4704866707,
-0.1801044792,
0.4705848098,
-0.2005470246,
-0.2954936922,
-0.549554944,
-0.1029288545,
-0.3005238771,
0.826359272,
-0.2617785931,
0.3213787079,
-0.1491392851,
-0.5471106172,
-0.4740520418,
0.2176035494,
0.6491752267,
0.470216006,
0.3042768836,
-0.262606144,
-0.5608192086,
-0.794733882,
-0.5779156089,
-0.5119197965,
0.0858903006,
0.1227448359,
0.1465726644,
0.0013399601,
0.7960986495,
-0.6016204357,
0.0352903381,
-0.4495618343,
-0.1580728143,
0.3055810332,
0.2694676816,
0.618576169,
-0.5293647051,
-0.4568981826,
-0.2747320235,
-0.8627924323,
-0.3095254302,
-0.0021306498,
0.112770319,
0.231482923,
0.5451174974,
-0.4153140187,
0.3794850111,
0.1996872425,
-0.4696138203,
0.8933712244,
0.0050337529,
-0.0742051303,
-0.777310729,
-0.1554375887,
0.1131563857,
0.0977969095,
-0.5905111432,
0.4671803713,
0.1890643984,
0.0096856747,
-0.7087591887,
0.3782654405,
-0.240890637,
0.0798874646,
-0.3992441893,
0.0629926845,
-0.383869648,
0.1883535981,
-0.2996510565,
0.840793848,
0.1589312404,
-0.3683088422,
0.6653266549,
-0.0373368077,
-0.1206694394,
0.3970762193,
-0.8538534641,
0.2488017678,
-0.1249097884,
-0.0401631668,
-1.2219213247,
-0.1459899694,
0.4404349625,
-0.5344479084,
0.2292262912,
-0.0467495956,
-0.3205017745,
-0.5217879415,
-0.7067856193,
0.0364279374,
0.4363488555,
-0.52000314,
0.3389601409,
0.1989413053,
-0.2349844426,
-0.6243122816,
-0.6348295808,
0.2540637851,
-0.7174840569,
-0.7898923755,
-0.0377910696,
-0.2140660882,
-0.6535090804,
-0.2286271453,
-0.1614182144,
0.2116998136,
0.5444071889,
0.4382901788,
0.6477724314,
-0.0586513095,
-0.4665164649,
-0.1493698657,
-0.1140606403,
0.7227442265,
-0.0244009756,
0.4654596448,
-0.1431621164,
-0.4577204287,
-0.5213262439,
0.134058401,
0.6057729125,
-0.1949739009,
0.5465441942,
0.227393657,
0.1101349816,
-0.2256641537,
-0.4962455332,
-0.3841032684,
-0.5690694451,
0.3643636703,
-0.4036149085,
-0.763145566,
0.4683090746,
-0.0142584853,
0.3223771751,
-0.0354520194,
0.3455601931,
-0.1728039384,
0.9059129357,
0.6577746272,
-0.4216488898,
0.2951995134,
0.0497244298,
0.4571394324,
-0.766323328,
-0.1380868405,
-0.5796675682,
-0.2647841275,
-0.4496453404,
0.1031836718,
0.3872989714,
0.0609887727,
-0.3429923356,
0.3886812031,
-0.5267699361,
0.4119965732,
0.1639173776,
0.154761076,
0.2932449281,
0.0037544197,
-0.3735342026,
-0.1284911484,
-0.3871598542,
-0.4547997713,
1.20936656,
0.5971924067,
1.103528142,
0.4243925214,
0.8215175271,
0.3560761809,
0.4882237315,
-0.8665189147,
0.768281281,
0.1365788728,
-0.4714946449,
-0.0776140988,
-0.2821381688,
-0.5951992273,
0.0938389972,
-0.082536526,
-0.7979043126,
-0.4125362337,
0.1933664531,
-0.3654735982,
0.2125272751,
-0.5697212219,
0.4919971526,
-0.5413324237,
-0.5236719251,
-0.2060737312,
-0.8913493752,
0.8410413861,
-0.1240146905,
0.511788249,
-0.1764071137,
0.1759797186,
0.5472720265,
-0.3954886496,
1.0188633204,
-0.3309061825,
-0.3209433258,
0.4056897759,
0.4526400566,
0.7930319309,
0.4270203412,
-0.0802405179,
-0.2101820558,
-0.5710818172,
-0.1136842966,
-0.5341058969,
0.8028140664,
-0.6407702565,
-0.9610674977,
-0.268764019,
-0.3255629241,
-0.11077369,
-0.0323233344,
0.2237303108,
0.1434696019,
-0.4010805488,
-0.2882998288,
0.8704499006,
-0.3128333092,
0.6531867981,
0.7755740285,
-0.2263567001,
-0.4761621654,
0.7236531377,
-0.0960727856,
0.3259897232,
0.1205919757,
0.2885374427,
-0.1447998285,
-0.7582646012,
-0.5224679112,
0.1444780529,
-0.4551380277,
-0.2526885867,
-0.4522751272,
-0.2307980359,
-0.2541792691,
-0.2296440601,
-0.2833734453,
-0.2712971866,
0.2878910899,
-0.2949616015,
0.436655134,
0.5066551566,
0.0332379676,
0.2431028634,
-1.1432162523,
0.3826030791,
0.3280065358,
0.0406401381,
0.1619552225,
-0.5086826682,
-0.2319542468,
-0.0740802884,
-0.4163301289,
-1.1830720901,
0.4137997925,
-0.0204228088,
0.6085912585,
0.6007204056,
0.4503027499,
0.5195119381,
-0.6623404622,
0.6641204357,
0.2735440433,
-0.640458703,
0.9538869262,
-0.267414093,
-0.0377796143,
0.4491187632,
0.0299393199,
-0.4945445955,
-0.8205461502,
-0.5076476336,
-1.0815289021,
0.4990057349,
-0.0671763867,
0.524415195,
-0.2657502294,
0.5248310566,
0.0356730223,
0.0465757772,
-0.9710371494,
-0.5634222031,
-0.1117570251,
-0.1476487666,
0.3670247495,
-0.3288800716,
-0.3592768908,
-0.0132938065,
0.5471473336,
0.1592675298,
0.29493016,
0.2548034191,
-0.3233284652,
-0.2029477954,
0.373521775,
0.5289227962,
0.2321642339,
-0.3366535306,
0.2402777225,
0.092838116,
-0.9082499146,
0.4620904922,
-0.2043332011,
-0.257243216,
-0.2798746228,
0.4262901545,
0.5097455978,
-0.1510245502,
-0.8684524298,
0.5106492639,
-0.2747165859,
0.087802805,
-0.4813587368,
0.5495573878,
-0.098527208,
0.0794891268,
0.5741066933,
-0.1051120982,
0.1025945842,
-0.5303047299,
0.3898420036,
0.6975355148,
-0.5621259809,
-0.4680962861,
0.6256415844,
0.3457540572,
-0.2881045341,
0.6819408536,
-0.1749149114,
-0.4833349288,
0.8224791288,
0.9326491356,
1.1423188448,
-0.4121884406,
0.0179465003,
0.4806372821,
0.7049333453,
0.2340698391,
0.2560009062,
0.0249674525,
-0.7636176944,
-0.4672194421,
-0.5233289003,
-0.1759755164,
0.0757090226,
-0.6680363417,
0.1992758065,
-0.9159258008,
0.029228298,
-0.4144517481,
-0.2002777904,
0.122329995,
0.0969992876,
0.2249122709,
1.1695350409,
-0.7736747265,
0.8472323418,
0.6899495721,
-0.098343417,
-0.6495280862,
0.245624125,
0.3180485666,
-0.9109572768,
0.7360718846,
0.5496944785,
-0.1727311909,
-0.2109650522,
-0.7820168734,
-0.4522111118,
0.749889791,
0.135168314,
-0.726886332,
0.2525927424,
0.2248838991,
0.152196452,
-0.2423724085,
-0.0367870964,
0.6626313329,
0.3614875972,
-0.0658817887,
-0.5536188483,
0.3321297169,
-0.4104636312,
-0.1691214293,
0.5070643425,
-0.5400434732,
0.361479491,
-0.596067965,
-0.0471848883,
0.1306138486,
0.7025857568,
0.6821972728,
0.347681731,
0.362821728,
0.7303578854,
0.2878473401,
0.0542683788,
0.6802437305,
-0.4664101601,
0.1298352033,
0.9986357689,
-0.3665391803,
0.7947929502,
0.7395474911,
-0.2014815658,
0.4376136959,
0.2458920479,
-0.0331611037,
0.7450072765,
0.4810152352,
-0.6206490993,
0.1310352534,
0.2275189161,
-0.1708578914,
0.2405105382,
0.4801270664,
-0.0888357386,
-0.1926555634,
0.4117081761,
0.3241698146,
0.2156583369,
-0.339235276,
0.9746604562,
0.1934840679,
-0.4436113834,
0.4848587513,
0.3218888342,
0.9263080955,
-0.5822657943,
0.1512013227,
-0.266076237,
0.0502105057,
-0.2946475148,
-0.7777796984,
0.4977287054,
0.4619865716,
0.0047146725,
0.3187557459,
0.7836786509,
0.1583246142,
-0.2338805795,
0.3596601188,
0.1046294346,
-0.0713900179,
0.1476432532,
-0.7333173752,
0.1724097133,
0.235623017,
-0.3991623223,
0.5281066895,
0.3058962822,
-0.0096846968,
0.8708384633,
0.714786768,
0.1216933057,
0.148621738,
-0.2689359188,
0.9198496342,
-0.8113425374,
-0.4390252531,
-1.3804947138,
0.5685182214,
-0.0670042261,
0.1265114099,
0.9291913509,
0.4411276579,
0.5924485922,
0.0187084805,
0.9983130693,
-0.2378133386,
0.2131669819,
-0.6372413635,
0.6684890389,
-0.1257447451,
0.8896291256,
-0.2854594588,
-0.811067462,
-0.3379644752,
0.5088375807,
-0.4269615412,
-0.4572955072,
0.4678673148,
0.8179949522,
0.2121189833,
0.0486109965,
0.0033517766,
0.256210655,
0.4807721078,
0.4592418969,
0.8935673237,
-0.1811836511,
0.5102991462,
-0.2506521344,
-0.3289854228,
-0.2387131304,
-0.8050212264,
-0.8703712821,
0.0435815193,
-0.0832432136,
-0.6200373173,
0.2682709992,
0.9708018899,
0.078843914,
-0.6413303018,
-0.357940942,
-0.3465098739,
0.0092371833,
-0.0472897701,
-0.2940006554,
0.1847197562,
-0.5365696549,
-0.1830612868,
0.4876381755,
0.4268276095,
0.0937800556,
-0.2535088956,
-0.1388345212,
0.1817587614,
0.1715277284,
0.4826188385,
0.4201222062,
-0.5013272762,
-0.2062991261,
0.2472960055,
-0.3244154751,
0.0800696164,
0.7632749081,
-0.5847281218,
0.3028359115,
0.3932459652,
0.4171638787,
-0.0150188254,
-0.0287181772,
0.5602050424,
-0.7364682555,
0.5055498481,
0.2274991125,
0.1994303167,
0.1231318265,
-0.5222551227,
0.3586765528,
0.1520796567,
-0.3555110693,
-0.8385788798,
0.4655846059,
-0.7663120627,
-0.5615028739,
1.0526088476,
-0.3460821211,
-0.5299358368,
-0.0850061625,
-0.3548099995,
0.0531083196,
-0.4085328281,
1.024507761,
0.3602988422,
-0.2249789536,
-0.0677972808,
-0.6561979055,
0.2804960907,
0.1333031654,
-0.6475348473,
0.2126801908,
0.4635006487,
0.2774238586,
0.0792846307,
0.3499248922,
-0.5031231642,
0.44299528,
-0.4031895399,
0.1147409976,
-0.1915477216,
-0.418484062,
-0.3288809359,
0.4013566971,
0.5207065344,
-0.0597428344
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04103v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04103v2
|
Enhancing the Rationale-Input Alignment for Self-explaining Rationalization
| 2023-12-07T07:37:15 | 2023-12-15T03:04:04 |
Wei Liu, Haozhao Wang, Jun Wang, Zhiying Deng, YuanKai Zhang, Cheng Wang, Ruixuan Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Rationalization empowers deep learning models with self-explaining
capabilities through a cooperative game, where a generator selects a
semantically consistent subset of the input as a rationale, and a subsequent
predictor makes predictions based on the selected rationale. In this paper, we
discover that rationalization is prone to a problem named \emph{rationale
shift}, which arises from the algorithmic bias of the cooperative game.
Rationale shift refers to a situation where the semantics of the selected
rationale may deviate from the original input, but the predictor still produces
accurate predictions based on the deviation, resulting in a compromised
generator with misleading feedback.
To address this issue, we first demonstrate the importance of the alignment
between the rationale and the full input through both empirical observations
and theoretical analysis. Subsequently, we introduce a novel approach called
DAR (\textbf{D}iscriminatively \textbf{A}ligned \textbf{R}ationalization),
which utilizes an auxiliary module pretrained on the full input to
discriminatively align the selected rationale and the original input. We
theoretically illustrate how DAR accomplishes the desired alignment, thereby
overcoming the rationale shift problem. The experiments on two widely used
real-world benchmarks show that the proposed method significantly improves the
explanation quality (measured by the overlap between the model-selected
explanation and the human-annotated rationale) as compared to state-of-the-art
techniques. Additionally, results on two synthetic settings further validate
the effectiveness of DAR in addressing the rationale shift problem.
|
[
-0.3469526172,
-0.8457701206,
0.6865946651,
0.197115317,
-0.2218908668,
-0.0185369179,
-0.2544273436,
-0.1079042107,
-0.0387850888,
0.2785062194,
-1.1162464619,
-0.1772913039,
-0.5549724102,
0.1093471348,
-0.0118749049,
0.9992651939,
-0.1822144836,
0.3267776966,
-0.1345543861,
-0.4417923391,
-0.6694188118,
-0.2680918872,
-0.8306478262,
-0.4474681914,
0.6700801849,
0.1470852792,
0.7578571439,
1.140011549,
0.5649056435,
0.3326788843,
0.2029170543,
0.0338819996,
-0.330915153,
0.3812653422,
-0.3614040315,
-0.5112440586,
-0.410264045,
0.226439327,
0.4246189594,
0.6116404533,
0.029463267,
0.1895985156,
-0.0308541916,
0.8016500473,
-0.6386779547,
-0.0910534337,
-0.5298657417,
0.0415404253,
0.2618149221,
-0.2181539983,
-0.3798143566,
-0.2680362463,
0.2549324036,
-1.2081108093,
-0.0067521045,
-0.3076011837,
0.7903994918,
0.7218017578,
-0.232838437,
-0.2296945751,
-0.8170292974,
0.9315757751,
-0.6085569859,
0.1515771151,
0.0253430977,
0.6152872443,
-0.151677236,
-0.3894331753,
-0.6948552728,
0.1393975765,
0.0090198731,
0.2932214141,
-0.0710099339,
0.0819607079,
0.4076101482,
0.021802444,
-0.346678555,
0.0606828779,
0.0022471286,
-0.2054663897,
0.9362068772,
0.0810224637,
0.1814151555,
0.195831269,
-0.7342876792,
-0.1811487973,
-0.4472599626,
0.2239697725,
0.3249408603,
-0.0852619559,
0.1585100889,
0.5395526886,
-0.0350245498,
0.5969983339,
0.8477951884,
-0.0436584279,
-0.0618259348,
-0.632177949,
-0.2002007961,
0.072703898,
0.6182560325,
0.6494345069,
0.2178828716,
-0.0900193006,
-0.257392168,
0.3631156981,
0.3123057187,
-0.6384758949,
-0.1533067524,
0.1846404672,
-0.5755363107,
-0.352793932,
-0.1037133858,
-0.9277723432,
-0.5601555109,
-0.8877239227,
0.3950240016,
-0.3608930111,
-0.2491653562,
0.0126308175,
-0.1261383146,
0.4826194346,
0.4268995225,
-1.0545036793,
0.145535782,
0.6783602834,
0.6057776213,
-0.4602076709,
-0.309020102,
-0.4117035866,
0.2716734111,
-0.2654273808,
0.7809888124,
-0.4443334341,
-0.1012390107,
-0.1921800524,
-0.1586920619,
-0.2058179229,
-0.4118817151,
0.3613475561,
-0.4413954616,
0.3769480884,
-0.4791388214,
-0.7349660397,
-0.0728182271,
0.319514513,
-0.4747324884,
0.5306687951,
-0.1308374852,
-0.4857576191,
0.5777285695,
-0.916734755,
-0.1791182607,
-0.2654221654,
-0.3650662601,
-0.5393530726,
0.1123783067,
0.5056650639,
-0.0683885291,
-0.0123372152,
0.5075725913,
-0.4245212972,
-0.1412894428,
0.8985287547,
-0.6932798028,
1.036913991,
0.3662728369,
-0.543477118,
0.5261346698,
-0.6281352639,
0.0609391779,
0.0703767017,
0.0626559407,
-0.121658124,
-0.0460067615,
-0.4524046183,
0.2805218697,
0.3769419193,
-0.3359486163,
0.3804196417,
-0.3499488533,
0.3637900352,
1.0157136917,
-0.1450409442,
1.3720505238,
-0.4324479699,
0.7058624029,
0.0355897769,
0.4197568893,
-0.0742949545,
-0.0758965388,
-0.7661912441,
-0.4600557387,
0.5409599543,
0.5176833272,
-0.5118309259,
0.6096435785,
-0.0268009361,
0.0366572291,
-0.7815675139,
-0.0554196201,
-0.0076217325,
0.7279283404,
0.4770992696,
0.025351122,
-0.6674686074,
-0.8063077331,
-0.3360925913,
0.0458322987,
-0.0048196618,
0.0506024621,
0.0114921685,
-0.3533838987,
1.318631053,
-0.4004204273,
-0.2130508423,
-0.0720305368,
0.3091138601,
-0.0132631985,
0.8122019172,
0.3973663151,
-0.6406205893,
-0.4084488153,
-0.0100749731,
-0.8409261703,
-0.2957338095,
-0.6909169555,
-0.5711629987,
0.4195480049,
0.3769463003,
-0.7744960189,
0.6361512542,
0.2090667337,
-0.3489702344,
0.593360126,
-0.1521834582,
-0.0129257198,
-1.1042971611,
-0.0491915643,
-0.1255760491,
0.1348026693,
-0.4577361047,
0.0521773733,
-0.0175450779,
0.1683735996,
0.1509412378,
0.4347295165,
-0.4252054989,
-0.032647945,
-0.3656634986,
0.1968543828,
0.2090406567,
0.3208070397,
-0.0529548861,
0.7597516775,
0.4823210537,
-0.4628138244,
0.2299982607,
0.0183068365,
0.0818707272,
0.5807628632,
-0.5272455215,
0.123206608,
-0.0906952322,
0.4614142776,
-0.8877824545,
0.055118002,
0.5468256474,
-0.5285753608,
0.1999255866,
-0.2465807199,
0.046034731,
0.0830349848,
-0.1462168247,
0.8046944737,
0.540027678,
-0.7514999509,
0.9179692864,
0.2203572392,
0.0775887147,
-0.8411800265,
-0.4189575911,
-0.2012009472,
-0.6468437314,
-0.9602614045,
0.3995160162,
-0.3636783063,
-0.4700684249,
-0.0676251203,
-0.5118699074,
-0.134632796,
0.3622383177,
-0.2119906098,
0.5030412674,
-0.4518838823,
0.1423899084,
0.2501383722,
-0.3330288529,
0.4594423175,
-0.4267551899,
0.3259682059,
0.2399938852,
-0.1227861196,
-0.5917543173,
0.3673823774,
0.4509809911,
-0.1522651464,
0.3655997217,
0.5165937543,
-0.1217847764,
-0.447008431,
-0.3990609944,
-0.4877981246,
-0.520229578,
0.1229961738,
-0.2819958329,
-0.524908483,
0.7715939283,
-0.3785392046,
0.0249946155,
0.3509165943,
0.309237361,
-0.402136296,
1.3729684353,
0.3212272525,
0.2183137685,
0.4963039458,
-0.2520898283,
0.3938252628,
-0.7321452498,
-0.116901502,
-0.2634246647,
-0.6470364332,
-0.470133841,
-0.3325258493,
0.059366513,
0.1947997659,
-0.2010262311,
0.1131342798,
-0.5893548727,
0.8328630328,
0.3123709261,
-0.0255649574,
0.0766050369,
-0.0022047593,
0.0783883259,
-0.2305593938,
-0.6318890452,
-0.3420800865,
0.9264634848,
0.3108641803,
0.7935082912,
0.1631788313,
0.9653332233,
0.1111364812,
0.0811407268,
-0.945864439,
0.443077296,
0.1389604509,
-0.3910673559,
-0.7231363654,
-0.4242875278,
-1.0831372738,
0.4210098982,
-0.337883234,
-0.2981564701,
0.397364676,
0.3093722761,
-0.5774227977,
-0.2191562802,
-0.7944231033,
1.0857183933,
-0.4312493205,
-0.5058931112,
-0.4345887005,
-0.6846551895,
0.2586373389,
0.2405828983,
0.210367471,
-0.0944879204,
0.0490931794,
0.3835093677,
-0.5288408399,
0.7259121537,
-0.3298482597,
-0.2171203643,
0.1051732674,
0.3134280145,
0.581225574,
0.3703391552,
0.0836354643,
0.0687595978,
-0.240748331,
-0.4439214468,
-1.3575854301,
0.7078496814,
-0.9388427734,
-0.9665656686,
-0.5956314206,
-0.8550829887,
0.0143800052,
0.1284759045,
0.2140273601,
0.2244989574,
-0.1608643532,
-0.2091993541,
0.6709015965,
0.15661937,
0.3263122737,
0.3619823158,
-0.0089723775,
-0.5417639613,
0.9505553842,
0.0833068192,
0.4201518893,
-0.0171260405,
0.5065489411,
-0.487775296,
-0.4430196583,
-0.6355915666,
0.1512313634,
-0.7416102886,
-0.2038541436,
-0.4201183915,
-0.2159708887,
-0.4961448312,
-0.594861567,
-0.1674944758,
-0.7464798689,
-0.4352069795,
-0.0879002362,
-0.0328828283,
0.5277457833,
-0.2888612747,
0.2784954906,
-0.3300905824,
0.2727155387,
0.4056326747,
0.1338228583,
-0.1709247828,
-0.6609169245,
0.0402846262,
0.4989673793,
-0.3804240823,
-0.7245392203,
0.2411470562,
-0.1167868525,
0.5910104513,
0.373241663,
0.1273804605,
0.916683197,
-0.3431006968,
0.5629400015,
0.3467798829,
-1.1864600182,
0.5082393885,
-0.3201307356,
0.471455276,
0.6781656146,
0.0508717969,
-0.2597729266,
0.0513804443,
-0.6166165471,
-0.6237508059,
0.820869267,
0.1907588989,
-0.2158001661,
0.1011921018,
0.4582896829,
0.4159079492,
-0.1220942065,
-0.8316434622,
-0.3118880987,
-0.5423850417,
-0.449940294,
0.278605938,
-0.1176482067,
-0.4270049334,
-0.3590177,
0.7439651489,
-0.2606652081,
0.1463832259,
0.3029155433,
-0.1393651366,
-0.2968007326,
0.1912614256,
0.7987474203,
0.8322826624,
0.1052160487,
0.0902084857,
-0.072739765,
0.0493112653,
0.236597389,
0.2034092098,
-0.4222961366,
-0.2304700613,
0.2193426192,
0.6304528713,
-0.0352412537,
-0.1980996281,
0.6172077656,
-0.1709959954,
-0.3071010709,
-0.349447459,
0.0533919632,
-0.2679383457,
0.397739768,
0.1740703434,
0.6412532926,
0.3186239302,
-0.2776733339,
0.1951257288,
0.6245351434,
-0.179970786,
-0.3672433197,
0.4536940157,
0.3550136089,
-0.305680871,
0.4382630885,
-0.1550139338,
-0.3854768574,
0.8577045798,
0.8142823577,
1.2199187279,
-0.0861061588,
0.5486500263,
0.568879962,
0.1098067984,
-0.0495703481,
-0.1829618216,
-0.3866828978,
-0.93906039,
-0.7742261291,
-0.2792429924,
-0.1394601464,
-0.2311558425,
-0.6817482114,
0.2010891736,
-0.5142913461,
-0.1493777782,
0.0718984827,
-0.3692884147,
-0.2706760764,
-0.1114332303,
0.1393085122,
0.4990817606,
-0.577378571,
0.7260579467,
0.5162650347,
-0.3126692176,
-0.6639902592,
0.2573497593,
-0.1769540012,
-0.9216554165,
0.6728445888,
0.0868955776,
-0.1153948605,
-0.1239793599,
-0.9235357046,
-1.1311309338,
1.1951920986,
0.5230448246,
-0.4938742518,
0.0623713546,
0.1237020269,
0.5234906673,
-0.6195232868,
0.0667133406,
0.6216683388,
0.6670198441,
0.1570448279,
-0.4850056469,
0.191596061,
0.1230885535,
-0.0685068816,
0.1712378263,
-0.5325633287,
0.5142298937,
-0.2412039191,
-0.432564795,
0.1405297965,
0.681438148,
0.3823721111,
0.5328304768,
0.6608614326,
0.5009380579,
0.7917337418,
-0.1503712088,
0.7454728484,
-0.0848615021,
0.1420397311,
1.2491488457,
-0.323222369,
0.2068973184,
0.7431840301,
0.0493861176,
0.5595291257,
0.3796880245,
0.0288215298,
0.6902688146,
0.2546223998,
-0.2526914775,
-0.5706572533,
0.0866664499,
-0.1364991963,
0.3906278014,
0.3087670207,
-0.3501370251,
-0.2539884746,
-0.1631923318,
-0.2622567415,
0.3497501314,
-0.165460974,
1.1575982571,
-0.0996141732,
-1.1662377119,
0.5876241326,
-0.3839622438,
0.507360518,
-0.585930109,
-0.1914200634,
-0.2545936108,
0.3952118754,
-0.1525007337,
-0.4623595476,
0.3655486107,
-0.4267272949,
-0.4725412428,
-0.4484039247,
0.5687185526,
-0.6015800834,
-0.3552320302,
0.2289371192,
0.3180234432,
-0.3495648801,
0.2322245985,
-1.0247983932,
0.320867002,
0.2124622762,
0.0694267452,
0.3633583784,
0.8578793406,
-0.0627858341,
0.4771771133,
0.7193245292,
-0.3410063386,
0.2103786767,
0.0643750802,
0.7690250278,
-0.5726783872,
-0.402204752,
-0.9919377565,
0.4754585624,
-0.2515878379,
-0.4134331346,
0.7589837313,
0.2464763671,
0.7266564369,
-0.1096393764,
0.8558331728,
0.0882081166,
-0.097303398,
-0.5587126017,
0.4385162294,
-0.1725752503,
0.3213376999,
-0.0211024676,
-0.9998859763,
-0.3590666354,
0.997207582,
-0.3616037965,
-0.2512089908,
0.7440737486,
0.6566306949,
0.0672411397,
0.1768959612,
0.207724601,
0.2087940872,
0.3394889235,
0.1594731957,
0.9972061515,
-0.3142834008,
0.3915938139,
-0.4399755895,
-0.3717785776,
0.1709882766,
-0.83421731,
-0.9145426154,
-0.360812813,
-0.585536778,
-0.4475117922,
0.1076043472,
1.010674715,
0.5928437114,
-0.8466106057,
-0.271471411,
-0.5808339119,
0.26240623,
-0.65234375,
-0.2896341681,
0.1453074515,
-0.823792696,
-0.5914492011,
0.5062343478,
0.1145275235,
0.1419281512,
-0.232049644,
-0.2681158781,
-0.1603085697,
0.2022490203,
0.4647628963,
0.1974026412,
-0.9787236452,
-0.3570641279,
0.3307762444,
0.1312086284,
0.1996101737,
1.0397696495,
-0.7503897548,
0.5329799652,
0.4033157825,
0.8998216391,
0.1144597307,
0.3583512604,
1.1070153713,
-0.4340022504,
-0.1721804142,
0.2779571712,
0.1731210798,
0.1476356685,
-0.678360939,
0.4898040891,
0.198508963,
-0.8676142097,
-0.5691455007,
0.3548133373,
-1.1783492565,
-0.3893350661,
1.169431448,
-0.0127271265,
-0.3039996326,
-0.0417880565,
-0.4834596515,
0.3481559157,
-0.5642243624,
1.1898421049,
0.8062480688,
-0.2631442845,
0.0458100215,
0.32043311,
0.6058350801,
0.9343697429,
-0.5044951439,
0.3265854418,
0.8089873195,
0.2194199413,
0.2271805704,
0.3721511662,
-0.0750982165,
0.5648550391,
-0.2414031476,
0.0153831365,
0.1129828542,
-0.1579356045,
-0.7855323553,
-0.1312033534,
-0.1549186856,
-0.315181613
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04068v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04068v1
|
Making Translators Privacy-aware on the User's Side
| 2023-12-07T06:23:17 | 2023-12-07T06:23:17 |
Ryoma Sato
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
We propose PRISM to enable users of machine translation systems to preserve
the privacy of data on their own initiative. There is a growing demand to apply
machine translation systems to data that require privacy protection. While
several machine translation engines claim to prioritize privacy, the extent and
specifics of such protection are largely ambiguous. First, there is often a
lack of clarity on how and to what degree the data is protected. Even if
service providers believe they have sufficient safeguards in place,
sophisticated adversaries might still extract sensitive information. Second,
vulnerabilities may exist outside of these protective measures, such as within
communication channels, potentially leading to data leakage. As a result, users
are hesitant to utilize machine translation engines for data demanding high
levels of privacy protection, thereby missing out on their benefits. PRISM
resolves this problem. Instead of relying on the translation service to keep
data safe, PRISM provides the means to protect data on the user's side. This
approach ensures that even machine translation engines with inadequate privacy
measures can be used securely. For platforms already equipped with privacy
safeguards, PRISM acts as an additional protection layer, reinforcing their
security furthermore. PRISM adds these privacy features without significantly
compromising translation accuracy. Our experiments demonstrate the
effectiveness of PRISM using real-world translators, T5 and ChatGPT
(GPT-3.5-turbo), and the datasets with two languages. PRISM effectively
balances privacy protection with translation accuracy.
|
[
-0.3264630437,
-0.0473087095,
0.321703881,
0.7997626066,
-0.2021277845,
0.096915625,
0.0134684201,
-0.4804332852,
0.0802380219,
0.942569375,
-0.329793781,
-0.4447020888,
-0.7316654921,
0.2797953188,
-0.7020739913,
1.1925359964,
0.1081326455,
0.1438438743,
0.0841065347,
-0.0235210061,
-0.1805521399,
-0.545093894,
-0.2392129749,
-0.1437535286,
0.3477452695,
0.3662514985,
1.1486895084,
0.7781583667,
0.6113616824,
0.356254369,
0.2345214933,
-0.1028807685,
-0.3684072495,
0.2376961112,
-0.3076765239,
-0.6080980897,
-0.616881907,
-0.021191489,
0.6518973112,
0.4138202965,
-0.1041713282,
0.1121743545,
0.1511995047,
0.8470285535,
-0.5116197467,
0.0532007106,
-0.253816247,
0.5190784335,
-0.4302657843,
-0.45854038,
-0.4529740512,
-0.3049667776,
0.0054400959,
-0.591704011,
0.021793846,
0.4563801885,
0.737955749,
0.2500417531,
-0.4984332025,
0.18768996,
-0.7167657614,
0.8073595762,
-0.2044136673,
0.6574081182,
0.7862765789,
0.3807205558,
-0.1415079236,
-0.7452132702,
-0.3205659986,
0.1973742843,
-0.1365329325,
0.239984259,
-0.359836787,
-0.1946875006,
0.192341134,
0.6392393708,
-0.7143371701,
0.0517094769,
-0.493203789,
-0.5850594044,
0.6295647621,
0.1973147243,
0.4362457097,
-0.0119652217,
-0.6560088396,
0.0042158575,
-1.0347101688,
-0.1593663394,
0.4534454346,
0.0369739793,
-0.1796834022,
0.7530496716,
-0.3615229428,
0.397875309,
0.1260332167,
0.1200008392,
0.4277721345,
-0.3332159221,
-0.2537148595,
0.0932942703,
1.0027832985,
0.5976442695,
0.1997642815,
-0.4250696301,
-0.1947051883,
-0.3878011703,
0.1484358907,
-0.9178919792,
-0.3362930119,
0.3192704916,
-0.4643559754,
-0.304495573,
0.0258791912,
-0.876080513,
-0.9833131433,
-0.1587043107,
0.2551988065,
-0.0814354867,
-0.1946143657,
0.3072626293,
0.0241128448,
0.2361618578,
0.1203223169,
-0.9933835268,
0.444396764,
0.849239707,
0.7110852599,
-0.0971886367,
-0.5236449838,
-0.6741167307,
0.4747678638,
-0.3637729585,
0.3257678747,
-0.4587545395,
-0.541457057,
-0.1627064496,
0.0731116831,
0.1747653782,
-0.4597379863,
0.2457014322,
-0.4230293036,
0.7708178163,
-0.4034056365,
-0.4114323854,
0.0376595296,
0.0600260682,
-0.3624087274,
0.8261162639,
0.0966904685,
-0.8278452158,
0.3355140984,
-0.4457023442,
-0.31618613,
0.2794075012,
-0.2921766937,
-0.4819207191,
0.1644823253,
0.2819465995,
0.3896690607,
-0.2523683906,
0.0368754826,
-0.0873898715,
-0.0845063776,
0.5183065534,
-0.1906865835,
1.2033593655,
0.4409307539,
-0.2504108548,
0.053052891,
-0.3508744538,
-0.1244390011,
-0.1745110154,
-0.1128884852,
-0.118360348,
-0.2353268117,
0.0279410165,
0.3579546809,
0.5462452173,
-0.5700571537,
0.159763515,
-0.6520757079,
0.310025394,
0.7791033387,
-0.0956967399,
0.8852632046,
-0.1644241065,
0.7088365555,
0.1014099717,
0.6938126087,
0.1769358367,
-0.8458194733,
-0.6613007784,
-0.0476029478,
0.4590778649,
0.9587083459,
-0.7541972995,
0.3219434023,
-0.5641692281,
-0.1933333129,
-0.729075253,
0.4096259475,
0.524682641,
0.4041350186,
0.2725311816,
-0.6853560209,
-0.2566341162,
-1.1911453009,
-0.7030888796,
-0.0887174457,
-0.3219204247,
0.1160869375,
0.2199303061,
-0.2162525654,
1.0109174252,
-0.2468299419,
-0.524050355,
-0.2540206611,
-0.2369664609,
-0.0623249635,
0.7092231512,
0.2836020887,
-1.2992780209,
-0.8624103069,
0.2184960544,
-0.8629242778,
-0.3729972243,
0.0205176007,
-0.2629654109,
-0.0620245859,
0.185021013,
-0.2120699435,
0.4531233609,
0.8253498077,
-0.5066344738,
-0.1661549807,
-0.4379337728,
-0.0438172892,
-1.1936956644,
0.0603842624,
-0.4921203852,
-0.8112201095,
-0.9004736543,
-0.0752923563,
0.2217216045,
-0.4970838726,
-0.6343635321,
0.4864483178,
-0.433011353,
-0.3913143575,
-0.3157855868,
0.0431421399,
0.1039032489,
0.2874191701,
0.0100139892,
0.9877449274,
0.7309169769,
-0.3582182229,
0.3738898635,
0.4142703414,
-0.1145814583,
0.7344900966,
-0.4084084332,
0.2012709826,
0.0725628808,
0.0173913408,
-0.2546000481,
-0.1236449182,
1.0779454708,
-0.6075508595,
0.3749233782,
-0.0524972938,
-0.5803035498,
0.1177278757,
-0.3237549365,
0.083126016,
0.3285538554,
-0.2950873375,
0.808701396,
0.8511174321,
-0.242297262,
-0.7325441241,
-1.1310638189,
0.7061063051,
-0.4262366295,
-0.7146981359,
0.0614216067,
-0.1087951064,
0.0416489579,
-0.0308355168,
-0.098028332,
-0.4085815549,
0.2365728617,
0.4120298624,
-0.098555468,
0.1900564134,
-0.1766673476,
-0.0811212957,
-0.9310600162,
-0.0363675728,
-0.524841249,
0.2740679681,
-0.4877896011,
-0.155336082,
-0.6136719584,
0.6457677484,
0.2523679733,
-0.57714504,
0.8951140642,
0.5753254294,
-0.178151235,
-0.0869741291,
-0.4140294492,
-0.1321178526,
-0.4997189045,
0.0178815853,
-0.5157912374,
-0.5496708751,
0.604500711,
0.1060184911,
-0.0579469725,
-0.044702325,
0.597568512,
-0.0026487128,
1.0185483694,
0.9603241682,
-0.3468008041,
0.5367943048,
0.0523614772,
0.5640595555,
-0.846028626,
-0.1926567554,
-0.3616698682,
-0.4487025738,
-0.8610377908,
-0.1852437407,
0.4082119167,
-0.250146836,
0.1498404443,
0.6995526552,
-0.5388644338,
0.6922242045,
0.6412495971,
0.0792336389,
0.5766527057,
-0.0324522145,
0.5188233256,
-0.116890572,
-0.3795333505,
-0.3185306191,
1.027624011,
0.3675400913,
0.8411390781,
0.2535513341,
0.8926652074,
0.2944060266,
0.2435995638,
-0.3632152975,
0.6229137778,
0.0098429471,
-0.8630831838,
-0.0677283704,
-0.6827682257,
-0.9715610743,
0.4564422965,
0.0725269467,
-0.7537202239,
0.4936674535,
0.3528449237,
-0.1190613806,
-0.1179657951,
-0.6381816268,
1.219686985,
-0.3685159087,
-0.6048259735,
0.0859272927,
-1.1182534695,
-0.0718970522,
-0.1575546712,
0.1495311856,
-0.1093053222,
-0.4595516622,
0.4597519636,
-0.1919352263,
0.7117214203,
-0.1513901055,
-0.0123015745,
-0.3132967651,
0.4874567688,
0.3887209594,
0.0646700785,
0.1164792553,
0.3269326985,
-0.0988523215,
-0.3102582693,
-0.5060281157,
0.5917180181,
-0.400904566,
-0.8070919514,
-0.6523186564,
-0.5869696736,
-0.1502155215,
0.5619525909,
0.5498155355,
-0.0028085234,
0.18903552,
0.5237967968,
0.6676593423,
-0.1363219619,
-0.0421912111,
0.8181309104,
-0.6311104298,
-0.1857375205,
1.1820325851,
-0.0742576569,
0.2573448122,
0.3709783554,
0.4706294537,
-0.2285290956,
-0.4343321025,
-0.8520671129,
0.057198178,
-0.5272585154,
-0.0465205573,
-0.5428999662,
-0.0035921365,
-0.3247489333,
-0.0665762722,
-0.6173302531,
-0.7281231284,
0.1182653233,
-0.0314846747,
0.1071446165,
0.3495274186,
-0.1974226534,
0.3550160229,
-0.8171092272,
0.4328561723,
-0.068829827,
0.3124423921,
-0.8405095935,
-0.262511611,
-0.3094147146,
0.0554190166,
-0.3260194957,
-0.9301626086,
0.6179739237,
0.2300315946,
0.2478335947,
0.2153737992,
0.1541497409,
0.2302017659,
-0.5257561207,
0.7613071799,
-0.0284057539,
-1.0866444111,
0.419775188,
-0.2015992403,
0.0240390897,
0.6784374118,
0.0190469809,
-0.9114846587,
-0.7746040225,
-0.5170444846,
-0.7045111656,
0.7274534702,
0.5627125502,
0.1875872612,
0.4865178168,
-0.1344990134,
0.0358316861,
0.6287468076,
-0.9214812517,
-0.1906162649,
-0.3200875819,
-0.2005043775,
-0.0282378383,
0.0953085944,
-0.3138727546,
0.2010843605,
0.6994181275,
0.1389243454,
0.0430476218,
0.1157925129,
-0.1670453399,
0.085304454,
0.3067606091,
0.3059139848,
0.619343102,
0.1428473294,
0.1517697573,
-0.0549493097,
-0.5532736778,
-0.1197899655,
-0.0509666875,
-0.5438843966,
-0.2520294785,
-0.2438218296,
0.3533262312,
0.0468787402,
-0.2564686239,
1.0588937998,
-0.1993298531,
0.2017681003,
-0.3867720068,
-0.0185032394,
0.0372503996,
0.1035712957,
-0.2439793646,
0.145134598,
0.4640612006,
-0.2419782877,
-0.0162447095,
0.128044188,
-0.3308657706,
-0.397269398,
0.6658061147,
0.3553201854,
-0.4348244667,
0.4737521112,
0.025873363,
-0.7800069451,
0.0949995816,
0.4368164241,
1.1365705729,
-0.6697462201,
-0.0006721175,
-0.4787836969,
0.5578394532,
-0.1607962698,
0.2642806768,
-0.3865164816,
-0.490842402,
0.127000317,
-0.2368922979,
-0.5034248829,
-0.3530960083,
-0.7174190283,
0.0620205067,
-0.160741657,
-0.1405939609,
-0.4848633707,
-0.1946132779,
-0.4636206329,
-0.0666765273,
0.0044601676,
0.7009599209,
-0.8082970977,
0.8902714849,
0.0923008099,
-0.2378541529,
-0.1463253647,
-0.2972458303,
0.1666705012,
-0.7132443786,
0.2716156244,
0.1531008184,
-0.2824471593,
-0.2476594597,
-0.1136560589,
-0.5490598679,
0.7184057832,
0.5975795388,
-0.3215118051,
0.1860213578,
0.8749304414,
0.6221626997,
-0.0370910801,
-0.5716308951,
0.3937158883,
0.615988493,
-0.4112248123,
-1.0251504183,
-0.1344915181,
-0.1906016767,
-0.1014510095,
0.405264616,
-0.6218737364,
0.5843266845,
0.3804847896,
-0.5015158653,
-0.1100804582,
0.5834076405,
-0.4964427352,
0.4439970851,
0.1604055613,
0.34640643,
0.707187593,
0.0419363901,
1.3164622784,
-0.5035635829,
0.2119637281,
1.099149704,
-0.192960009,
0.5751430392,
0.7005227804,
0.169627279,
-0.0969200134,
0.3397738039,
-0.0286820345,
0.6006107926,
-0.0808652267,
-0.3042703569,
-0.1929601133,
-0.0901336595,
-0.6132180095,
0.3837689459,
0.2295736521,
-0.6562044024,
-0.0622566454,
0.1808762401,
0.2312050164,
0.0842917785,
-0.056275066,
0.8452136517,
0.3406887054,
-0.5051686764,
0.1476267278,
0.1331948042,
0.0444163978,
-0.6032540202,
0.4243621826,
-0.2299659997,
0.425542891,
-0.5030269623,
-0.9553835988,
0.4621180892,
0.2036548257,
0.0191094186,
-0.9196285009,
0.4334663153,
-0.5771888494,
-0.3615892231,
0.1267231703,
0.3331127465,
0.482652694,
-0.1735783815,
-0.8430585861,
0.0976473168,
0.0839394256,
-0.354857713,
0.4986799657,
0.2749140859,
-0.0893356577,
0.8420226574,
0.4184477627,
0.2379313856,
0.3171716034,
-0.0737545341,
0.7063879371,
-0.3758817017,
-0.8244445324,
-0.8642443419,
0.4137795269,
-0.2657287419,
-0.3871045411,
1.3893409967,
0.9402837157,
0.8784155846,
0.1258360744,
0.6295176744,
0.1139831766,
0.4414547086,
-0.2726458907,
0.8613221645,
-0.3715184927,
0.4603405297,
0.163089484,
-1.0991424322,
-0.619609952,
0.5348613858,
-0.5431728363,
-0.3887482285,
0.4515120387,
0.9830116034,
-0.2235403359,
0.269497633,
0.213065505,
0.0873942226,
0.6501280665,
0.6911180019,
0.6155638099,
-0.5467423201,
0.6563580632,
-0.4952004254,
-0.2708060145,
0.0495090671,
-0.8906682134,
-0.723926425,
-0.4837543368,
-0.116800949,
-0.2615144849,
-0.0787828043,
0.5135704875,
0.6952454448,
-0.677816093,
-0.3089190423,
0.0407343581,
-0.048649855,
-0.1149635538,
-0.0790781081,
0.2217175364,
0.1122385636,
-0.8765470982,
0.5677424073,
0.6078375578,
-0.0230756663,
-0.3280304372,
-0.1666313708,
0.4953887165,
-0.1525636762,
-0.0225278921,
0.5132777095,
-0.4336921871,
-0.104797639,
-0.0880330577,
-0.4022577405,
0.1823191643,
0.7884165049,
-0.4932247102,
0.9411595464,
0.6713411212,
0.8129638433,
0.5926812291,
0.2516866028,
0.826698482,
-0.6108750701,
0.323422879,
0.3895403743,
0.2636986375,
0.6597813964,
-0.5985306501,
0.5190182328,
-0.0461136475,
-0.6417155862,
-0.8225660324,
0.5097888112,
-0.865557611,
0.1721938998,
0.7655158043,
-0.3471615911,
-0.4306799769,
-0.3271443248,
-0.271330744,
-0.2008484751,
-0.385180831,
0.8317565918,
0.5640876889,
0.0429002233,
0.1059074178,
-0.548843503,
0.5885483623,
0.4356896579,
-0.6389659643,
0.4226904511,
0.1430171579,
0.1998961121,
0.2348708063,
0.7460156679,
-0.4181418419,
0.2691173255,
-0.2459878772,
-0.3391156495,
-0.2849451005,
-0.5584899783,
-0.3822072148,
0.0235220455,
-0.2600813806,
-0.3586956859
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04059v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04059v1
|
Comparing Large Language Model AI and Human-Generated Coaching Messages for Behavioral Weight Loss
| 2023-12-07T05:45:24 | 2023-12-07T05:45:24 |
Zhuoran Huang, Michael P. Berry, Christina Chwyl, Gary Hsieh, Jing Wei, Evan M. Forman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Automated coaching messages for weight control can save time and costs, but
their repetitive, generic nature may limit their effectiveness compared to
human coaching. Large language model (LLM) based artificial intelligence (AI)
chatbots, like ChatGPT, could offer more personalized and novel messages to
address repetition with their data-processing abilities. While LLM AI
demonstrates promise to encourage healthier lifestyles, studies have yet to
examine the feasibility and acceptability of LLM-based BWL coaching. 87 adults
in a weight-loss trial rated ten coaching messages' helpfulness (five
human-written, five ChatGPT-generated) using a 5-point Likert scale, providing
additional open-ended feedback to justify their ratings. Participants also
identified which messages they believed were AI-generated. The evaluation
occurred in two phases: messages in Phase 1 were perceived as impersonal and
negative, prompting revisions for Phase 2 messages. In Phase 1, AI-generated
messages were rated less helpful than human-written ones, with 66 percent
receiving a helpfulness rating of 3 or higher. However, in Phase 2, the AI
messages matched the human-written ones regarding helpfulness, with 82% scoring
three or above. Additionally, 50% were misidentified as human-written,
suggesting AI's sophistication in mimicking human-generated content. A thematic
analysis of open-ended feedback revealed that participants appreciated AI's
empathy and personalized suggestions but found them more formulaic, less
authentic, and too data-focused. This study reveals the preliminary feasibility
and acceptability of LLM AIs, like ChatGPT, in crafting potentially effective
weight control coaching messages. Our findings also underscore areas for future
enhancement.
|
[
0.0152277974,
-0.6861374378,
0.2462920249,
0.3459718823,
-0.0439169966,
0.1411114931,
-0.3103458285,
-0.6112735868,
0.2118658423,
0.2213345766,
-0.6006028652,
-0.1635089368,
-0.7380768061,
0.2268630266,
-0.6061444283,
1.1332752705,
-0.0907851532,
0.5441634059,
-0.1924314052,
-0.0030928487,
-0.9104688764,
-0.6036605239,
-1.1806833744,
-0.832395494,
0.6189501882,
0.2256980091,
0.6755987406,
0.1692258865,
0.6504878402,
0.2602697909,
-0.1442688257,
0.1639264524,
-0.6217270494,
-0.0765838847,
0.038606219,
-0.6828337908,
-0.4488642216,
0.2538941503,
0.3799078465,
0.676607132,
-0.5302177668,
0.2153335661,
0.3044829071,
0.8208460808,
-0.2546571493,
0.3434348404,
-0.5741554499,
0.3671428859,
0.165982604,
-0.1082765535,
-0.3886274993,
-0.2357673496,
0.0452004522,
-0.5321057439,
-0.3084652126,
0.4582282305,
0.8187826276,
0.4249011874,
-0.439386189,
-0.8867408037,
-1.1050530672,
0.6144980192,
-0.9397060275,
0.3416894972,
0.5756729245,
0.1387017667,
-0.2772273719,
-0.2489053011,
-0.6048554778,
-0.6920633912,
-0.0505694263,
0.4836636782,
-0.4249916077,
0.1374641806,
0.2235947847,
0.1923655272,
-0.6677975059,
0.4369610548,
-0.2699168324,
-0.2362295687,
0.9599292874,
0.3121214509,
0.3644504249,
-0.090388678,
-0.0050732014,
-0.0709804967,
-0.4909383059,
0.056854941,
0.1651899517,
0.0457933731,
-0.2099045515,
1.0174540281,
-0.1113683209,
0.3866378069,
0.3337939382,
-0.4356587529,
-0.1998243779,
-0.3079006672,
-0.2607014179,
0.1750011891,
0.6932864189,
0.6943201423,
0.6686295271,
-0.2720227838,
-0.2565571666,
-0.0742369294,
0.0695563406,
-0.7853145003,
-0.106986627,
0.2693315744,
-0.9873826504,
-0.106123127,
0.1548124999,
-0.3172147274,
-0.6981662512,
-0.4092805386,
0.452368021,
-0.5926634073,
0.0457782596,
0.0862842873,
-0.2562914789,
0.5865457654,
0.5767784715,
-0.8924521804,
0.5082918406,
0.6357123852,
0.9254264832,
-0.3083482087,
0.0571004413,
-0.3960172832,
0.1180584133,
-0.4098797739,
0.7052016854,
-0.5121135712,
-0.5720505714,
-0.0566842556,
-0.2541394532,
-0.0843898803,
-0.7035475969,
0.3183961809,
-0.2906253934,
0.2338347435,
-0.3204307556,
-0.7620381117,
-0.0129303578,
0.48556602,
-0.4794472456,
0.7562711835,
-0.1061212271,
-0.3997378051,
0.6788650751,
-0.4759589434,
-0.6926234365,
0.1771778911,
0.0358350798,
-0.3174161017,
0.0165992379,
0.1483095586,
0.4606577754,
-0.4057176709,
-0.0235023852,
-0.2714886367,
-0.3882656991,
0.4702741504,
-0.6707512736,
0.3371651769,
0.2716059387,
-0.4665818512,
0.2088180184,
-0.3415132463,
0.0434814654,
0.123730205,
-0.7271194458,
-0.1960217208,
0.2156068981,
0.1139193401,
0.1166991889,
0.1228058562,
-0.5884560943,
0.4565275908,
-0.2602627277,
0.5675737262,
0.6911298633,
-0.0405630283,
0.2370265871,
-0.8488184214,
0.66340065,
-0.5540295243,
0.0910394937,
0.0369469374,
-0.658573091,
-0.3691238761,
-0.2469909489,
-0.0628818795,
0.8329456449,
-0.6359940171,
0.6003635526,
-0.3062218726,
-0.5111298561,
-0.4622691572,
0.1978610903,
0.5815968513,
0.5027760863,
0.1539200842,
-0.3054870367,
-0.21247679,
-0.6915971637,
-0.5394693613,
-0.2806821167,
-0.2699957788,
0.6274914742,
0.6820022464,
-0.0252177436,
0.605660975,
-0.4554295838,
-0.3661523759,
-0.5495906472,
0.0895219594,
-0.1820982397,
0.3988282084,
0.5378279686,
-0.7311809659,
-0.8191536665,
0.1004325897,
-0.5546615124,
0.0954164416,
-0.4350475669,
0.1455814689,
0.0118552083,
0.247855559,
-0.8627601266,
0.7494877577,
0.5606895685,
-0.2957825363,
0.7088631392,
-0.2084574103,
0.3385965228,
-0.9264450669,
0.2145676017,
0.0339882262,
-0.169834584,
-0.45430848,
-0.6507428288,
-0.2739777267,
-0.2647317052,
-0.0436659902,
0.8911395669,
-0.2586382329,
-0.0599009693,
-0.3299925327,
-0.0980698988,
-0.2341780812,
0.3812765181,
-0.1340439767,
0.6806604266,
0.1239003539,
-0.3838077188,
0.4776851833,
0.4231026173,
-0.3782590926,
0.9477292895,
-1.0439912081,
0.1169235185,
-0.3826597333,
0.7827153206,
-1.2416721582,
-0.405277133,
0.5881857872,
-0.5919359326,
0.1553358138,
0.2758236825,
-0.4763665497,
-0.6157112718,
-0.3052240908,
-0.095032908,
0.5970390439,
-0.1644794643,
0.4307362437,
-0.023717517,
-0.1987938434,
-0.1203967929,
-1.0352514982,
0.1668073982,
-0.2156172395,
-0.4375064671,
0.1928649843,
-0.4654028416,
-0.2078871876,
-0.0619780235,
-0.3767945766,
-0.0015069246,
0.0815756992,
0.3068676293,
0.0091005461,
0.2538337409,
0.1812939495,
-0.1633227319,
0.1111841425,
0.1265509129,
-0.2465239465,
0.7039078474,
0.1205309704,
-0.4584867358,
-1.1039317846,
0.392603755,
0.4630653262,
-0.2420955747,
1.0777804852,
0.7883471847,
-0.171565339,
-0.0627331808,
-0.5306383967,
-0.2950903475,
-0.443724215,
0.3215101361,
0.1516906768,
-0.7110724449,
0.3199960589,
-0.0288730934,
0.1180148944,
0.063442871,
0.7000430822,
-0.3746403456,
1.5031678677,
0.3026538491,
-0.3275681436,
0.8920781612,
-0.1482058018,
0.1142162308,
-0.6142663956,
-0.4897560775,
-0.562297821,
-0.6401578784,
-0.3339920342,
0.0418717414,
0.2490966469,
-0.2245285362,
-0.4602012634,
-0.0766064823,
-0.5969137549,
0.0685950145,
0.518789053,
0.3258140087,
0.0481824763,
-0.1327607483,
0.2550643384,
-0.2012059838,
-0.6889681816,
-0.197428897,
0.9466922879,
0.2652312517,
1.1292524338,
0.0406483524,
0.541757524,
0.7143139839,
0.7899602056,
-1.2194774151,
0.4604980648,
-0.1825955361,
-0.6187258363,
-0.2976081669,
-0.7543429732,
-1.0075736046,
-0.0772869214,
-0.2980798781,
-1.0213924646,
-0.600035727,
0.4228110611,
-0.1705266237,
0.3389408588,
-1.0970195532,
0.6092892885,
-0.6292262077,
0.0049074423,
-0.3673244119,
-0.5726274848,
0.1505436003,
-0.0723238364,
0.1419272572,
-0.2063397318,
0.116252549,
0.9728743434,
-0.6290429831,
0.8921732903,
-0.2235799432,
-0.2189294994,
0.1437690705,
0.1480556428,
0.7865722775,
-0.1327564269,
-0.1957091838,
-0.2852761745,
-0.0143417418,
-0.3871844709,
-0.8628949523,
0.4164569378,
-0.7878574729,
-0.504606843,
-0.1873051226,
-0.3596622646,
-0.2364091277,
0.3758565784,
0.0359400883,
0.3791441619,
-0.0936213806,
0.3318514228,
0.3605189919,
-0.4573603868,
0.2645563185,
0.4018400908,
-0.0124518014,
-0.3962437212,
0.8540276289,
-0.1051157489,
0.1745831519,
0.6094538569,
0.661270082,
-0.0829803348,
-0.4943287373,
-0.0521315187,
0.2443115413,
-0.2938857675,
-0.2227377445,
-0.1564687192,
-0.1785883754,
-0.5044079423,
-0.1295354664,
-0.3120182157,
-0.0049687298,
0.0184506588,
0.191841647,
0.2380882949,
1.018879056,
0.1860285699,
0.7411596179,
-0.8395044804,
0.112145178,
0.0891640186,
0.3657609224,
0.4581067562,
-0.4059630632,
-0.2928597331,
0.3343929946,
-0.1444069445,
-0.8389222622,
0.3989330828,
0.2438335419,
0.5190735459,
0.4278060794,
-0.2494256794,
0.643281579,
-0.2644532323,
0.9554002881,
0.4140130877,
-0.8568640351,
0.4611290991,
-0.250289917,
0.6096143126,
0.2557944357,
0.5024157763,
-1.0298629999,
-0.0704952031,
-0.1485350728,
-0.5379703641,
0.6006562114,
0.2724762261,
0.3314913511,
0.0899482891,
0.5959392786,
0.059640687,
0.6142820716,
-0.7774615288,
-0.3270731866,
-0.1580629945,
-0.4715868831,
0.1599375457,
-0.0902481303,
0.0667045638,
-0.2955534458,
0.5218598843,
-0.1021227613,
0.5570479035,
0.139382571,
0.2086369246,
-0.0400276743,
0.1270827204,
0.7268646955,
0.2680865228,
-0.1529092044,
-0.3754030764,
0.1944862306,
-0.6017613411,
-0.1172115877,
-0.095571205,
-0.1464585811,
-0.3680832088,
0.9199875593,
0.799459517,
0.2351987809,
-0.8109577298,
0.4251742065,
-0.2350912094,
-0.4257836938,
-0.3313428164,
0.1763546616,
0.073428385,
0.1456504315,
0.1987876296,
0.0278841741,
0.0434192903,
-0.5476164818,
-0.0012932556,
0.9021739364,
-0.4672009051,
-0.3655042648,
0.8847062588,
0.2986964285,
-0.6242537498,
0.8553379178,
-0.1791771203,
-0.3309364915,
0.549192071,
0.5034524798,
0.6486812234,
-0.1423442215,
0.3296691775,
0.2248447686,
0.2244378179,
-0.2454968095,
0.0829055533,
-0.08182621,
-0.7812460065,
-0.3378376961,
-0.4989213645,
-0.5773889422,
0.1080710962,
-0.6528868675,
-0.0058411695,
-0.6400024295,
-0.2843579948,
0.1795490533,
0.1389734,
-0.8915763497,
0.1501705796,
0.344447583,
0.8469341397,
-0.5898244977,
0.6048865318,
0.9775496721,
-0.4993436933,
-1.1862388849,
0.3363234401,
0.2809672952,
-1.2367728949,
0.6070150137,
0.1790122539,
-0.0631947815,
-0.0991283283,
-0.8510793447,
-0.8606895804,
1.2476215363,
0.2222441733,
-0.5081840158,
-0.4868208766,
0.203331247,
0.7074766755,
-0.1367785484,
0.4253275394,
0.2755218446,
0.672478497,
0.3971218467,
-1.159001112,
-0.1114728227,
0.1437626034,
0.0332453661,
-0.0455062911,
-1.1660223007,
0.5502945185,
-0.1321412772,
-0.1846350729,
0.3544278443,
0.4756199419,
-0.0213030633,
0.3319869936,
0.4948216379,
0.2670188546,
0.8054985404,
0.2573704123,
1.209823966,
-0.299910754,
0.2967448831,
0.9452181458,
-0.4576902688,
0.5235093832,
0.2189246714,
-0.1243660972,
0.2915683389,
0.449678421,
-0.1004528701,
0.2879622877,
0.454528302,
-0.0459463447,
-0.0111727742,
-0.3597991765,
0.0880269781,
0.6514354944,
0.3696146905,
-0.2198534906,
-0.0338364616,
0.2763901055,
0.4306647182,
-0.0356522836,
-0.433380872,
0.7741330266,
0.1061212048,
-0.7127494812,
0.4164380729,
0.0079521891,
0.8604748845,
-0.822142899,
-0.1510742158,
-0.3396189809,
0.2632061839,
-0.2878414094,
-0.7164331675,
0.1661370844,
0.0845284015,
0.1162267998,
-0.6358294487,
0.7557182312,
-0.4775777161,
-0.3291103244,
0.0949932262,
0.528470993,
0.1903883517,
-0.0397957712,
-0.9867653251,
0.0459094457,
-0.0131701054,
-0.4829704463,
0.233481884,
0.1031923816,
0.053157039,
1.0428448915,
0.5648971796,
0.3889517188,
-0.3065520823,
-0.0906487554,
0.6799564958,
-0.6741114855,
-0.1581605077,
-0.7769529819,
0.103837736,
-0.0507264137,
-0.3265720308,
0.925881505,
0.3930564225,
0.7403350472,
-0.0591856763,
0.930357635,
-0.3481131494,
0.3220756948,
-0.5113123059,
0.845842123,
-0.6911346912,
0.1103521511,
-0.1672582179,
-0.7475489974,
-0.1498630494,
0.4217064083,
-0.403039515,
0.4442066252,
0.5278626084,
0.6734938622,
0.364933461,
-0.2131324708,
0.1264882833,
0.1608480513,
0.7189413905,
0.345626086,
0.7226772904,
0.1389163733,
0.7143455744,
0.1721976846,
-0.3272998333,
-0.2829223573,
-0.5497462153,
-1.127169013,
-0.2040298134,
-0.0369889922,
-0.2319916487,
0.2758302391,
1.2027339935,
0.7042678595,
-0.5958404541,
-0.1897653341,
0.0671446249,
0.0563780628,
-0.4278935194,
-0.2736073434,
0.1653346121,
0.1040353775,
-0.6001188159,
0.0773320645,
0.0681524873,
0.0927190706,
-0.1951012611,
-0.2641989589,
-0.0286470391,
0.2415011078,
0.7037603855,
0.3389090598,
-0.5974985361,
-0.5808931589,
0.0463675782,
-0.2523725331,
-0.0450629145,
0.830298543,
-0.32216236,
0.1970056891,
0.279802829,
0.6035709977,
0.4094672501,
0.2854361236,
0.5799094439,
-0.3701352179,
-0.007304912,
0.2489144057,
0.1136053577,
0.2776499093,
-0.5139265656,
0.3297468126,
0.2640984654,
-0.636723876,
-0.4001991451,
0.0855714902,
-0.9989574552,
-0.1601161808,
1.3712477684,
-0.1299008727,
-0.245469287,
0.2442890257,
-0.7823385,
0.1762264073,
-0.7201090455,
0.9801712036,
0.9357036352,
-0.640859127,
0.0793096349,
-0.5797667503,
0.5626361966,
0.655303061,
-1.0497303009,
-0.0769581869,
0.4800245762,
0.2686718106,
-0.2990404963,
0.7437602878,
0.3919689655,
0.0236068238,
-0.0941210613,
-0.0104768332,
0.0897269845,
-0.0066132182,
-0.0898443907,
-0.3988050818,
0.2283929288,
0.0916602686
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04052v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04052v1
|
Multimodal Misinformation Detection in a South African Social Media Environment
| 2023-12-07T05:20:15 | 2023-12-07T05:20:15 |
Amica De Jager, Vukosi Marivate, Abioudun Modupe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the constant spread of misinformation on social media networks, a need
has arisen to continuously assess the veracity of digital content. This need
has inspired numerous research efforts on the development of misinformation
detection (MD) models. However, many models do not use all information
available to them and existing research contains a lack of relevant datasets to
train the models, specifically within the South African social media
environment. The aim of this paper is to investigate the transferability of
knowledge of a MD model between different contextual environments. This
research contributes a multimodal MD model capable of functioning in the South
African social media environment, as well as introduces a South African
misinformation dataset. The model makes use of multiple sources of information
for misinformation detection, namely: textual and visual elements. It uses
bidirectional encoder representations from transformers (BERT) as the textual
encoder and a residual network (ResNet) as the visual encoder. The model is
trained and evaluated on the Fakeddit dataset and a South African
misinformation dataset. Results show that using South African samples in the
training of the model increases model performance, in a South African
contextual environment, and that a multimodal model retains significantly more
knowledge than both the textual and visual unimodal models. Our study suggests
that the performance of a misinformation detection model is influenced by the
cultural nuances of its operating environment and multimodal models assist in
the transferability of knowledge between different contextual environments.
Therefore, local data should be incorporated into the training process of a
misinformation detection model in order to optimize model performance.
|
[
-0.5718460083,
-0.6516288519,
0.3706576824,
0.3555621207,
-0.3232991099,
-0.2348383516,
-0.0966960937,
-0.578138113,
0.3812708259,
0.210795626,
-0.5126882792,
-0.3034076095,
-0.9011691809,
0.218067795,
-0.3291440606,
0.5436506867,
-0.2939128578,
0.0048722411,
-0.352199167,
-0.4482240975,
-0.5284432173,
-0.7958292365,
-0.3571597338,
-0.1494400501,
0.4295591116,
0.3344023228,
0.4207451046,
0.1016525179,
0.3240885139,
0.2197393775,
0.0429842807,
0.6012730598,
-0.4571840763,
0.2068087608,
-0.2733970582,
-0.5010365844,
0.2903693318,
-0.0415788256,
0.3913051188,
0.1414260268,
-0.1599569619,
0.2591589689,
-0.0555640385,
0.3589081466,
-0.7456216812,
0.4258158803,
-0.5307052135,
-0.0967366695,
-0.0948324502,
-0.3227218986,
-0.3630286455,
-0.4143705368,
-0.1460119784,
-0.3588582575,
0.2379682511,
-0.2125067562,
0.9014186263,
-0.1385487318,
-0.7028692365,
-0.5218071938,
-0.7795544863,
0.2893169522,
-0.6240738034,
0.3772823513,
0.366443783,
0.5889554024,
0.2675091028,
-0.6119122505,
-0.9267973304,
0.28115502,
-0.080045566,
0.0334573165,
-0.3573671877,
-0.5348180532,
-0.018334182,
-0.1117486209,
-0.2534788847,
-0.0898316428,
-0.595181644,
-0.375718385,
0.4647643566,
-0.220315963,
0.3130069971,
-0.6740272641,
-0.5284737349,
-0.0977368429,
-0.2939463854,
-0.1153362691,
0.3628293276,
0.4011813104,
-0.3976116478,
0.4146673977,
-0.0236275159,
0.6198197007,
0.0005331696,
-0.3588761389,
0.4711823165,
-0.4591737986,
0.021862682,
0.1231371909,
0.5296987891,
0.5881601572,
0.4196609259,
0.027524218,
-0.4399484396,
0.2737576962,
0.4197080135,
-0.633251071,
-0.1577566117,
-0.3257792592,
-0.6702030897,
-0.1458571106,
0.1917813122,
-0.6740084291,
-0.5919043422,
-0.5114002228,
0.5182923675,
-0.713386476,
-0.3490946889,
-0.3078768551,
-0.3031995296,
-0.0568740033,
0.4478499293,
-0.4568550289,
-0.4442018569,
0.0852049738,
0.9815294743,
0.029252125,
-0.2821798921,
0.123469919,
0.3977071941,
-0.0673211291,
0.9195063114,
-0.511493504,
-0.1338162571,
0.3031780124,
0.3120797873,
-0.6164740324,
-0.4551163912,
0.4822015166,
-0.5548488498,
0.0111964447,
-0.5375495553,
-0.2771496475,
-0.7014657259,
0.358092308,
-0.7721747756,
0.7994497418,
0.2993390858,
-0.7935416102,
0.5875916481,
-0.6311604381,
-0.7316220999,
-0.1951481998,
-0.0805626512,
-0.1658992469,
0.0986247435,
0.5439304113,
0.4652423263,
-0.0615467764,
0.0636340156,
-0.4732091725,
-0.4727604091,
0.474937886,
-0.9294701219,
0.626237452,
0.346539706,
-0.2235468477,
-0.1584617794,
-0.6757019758,
-0.4152450264,
0.0716109872,
-0.39951092,
-0.5027761459,
-0.3346313536,
0.2453101277,
0.6671904922,
-0.0333408788,
-0.452267617,
0.0982755944,
0.3113587201,
0.3545107543,
0.6272034645,
0.3768936396,
0.3972524405,
-0.3838817775,
0.4015114009,
0.6068214178,
0.2109665275,
-0.1084140986,
-0.5093588233,
-0.5227487683,
-0.1462751925,
0.3570920229,
0.5924740434,
-1.3324501514,
0.075768292,
-0.2956814766,
-0.3526698649,
-0.6476550698,
0.1407357752,
-0.2668662667,
0.4791865945,
0.2338657081,
-0.1171444356,
-0.7084386945,
-1.212436676,
-0.2953037918,
0.0614991151,
0.0371051207,
0.3892703652,
0.6275421381,
-0.7503941059,
0.9781250954,
-0.0271436311,
-0.4748985469,
-0.4204064906,
0.3961907625,
0.032405179,
0.1578330845,
0.9948345423,
-1.1612706184,
-0.3050615191,
-0.1659596115,
-1.1840827465,
-0.0263583437,
-0.2801664472,
0.0577615462,
0.315959394,
0.2520587146,
-0.5362610221,
0.6025611162,
0.578422904,
-0.097278595,
0.3885357678,
-0.2640113533,
0.6977449059,
-1.32099998,
-0.0746135265,
0.2283214629,
-0.1923322827,
-0.5172359347,
-0.1857423633,
0.29783535,
-0.055758819,
-0.5054847598,
0.296737045,
-0.4395586252,
0.0366335623,
-0.2798988223,
0.2641662359,
-0.0061042565,
0.3958446085,
-0.0182461664,
0.8183764219,
0.5146198273,
-0.7727022171,
0.3649829924,
0.3416347802,
-0.4966697097,
1.0571402311,
-0.2070521414,
-0.0278463941,
-0.334056735,
0.2112223059,
-0.9055446386,
-0.3218812943,
0.389852643,
-0.5722862482,
0.0400680937,
-0.4353569746,
-0.8434453011,
-0.3349263072,
0.1473265439,
0.1357472092,
0.0916743651,
-0.5530881286,
0.8873539567,
0.3301582336,
-0.0739636198,
-0.3880705237,
-1.0018869638,
0.1589602828,
-0.0896219164,
-0.8941984773,
-0.0972192511,
0.366448611,
-0.0464305133,
-0.0136796068,
-0.1948363185,
-0.2638090849,
-0.2055160105,
0.4567137659,
0.0754766539,
-0.1210466847,
0.1859079152,
0.0824900195,
0.2401658297,
0.0158307105,
-0.0032648034,
0.5255202651,
0.0796523318,
-0.3833922446,
-0.5346822143,
0.2781395912,
0.7334344387,
-0.1744461954,
1.4984680414,
0.8970267773,
-0.5476406217,
-0.0526772179,
-0.6862694621,
-0.0816252083,
-0.4009593725,
0.264674902,
-0.2165647596,
-0.2711663246,
0.5842796564,
-0.2152564079,
-0.3397428989,
0.3424285352,
0.3365125954,
-0.3147673905,
0.7150661945,
0.7836293578,
-0.0234039687,
0.5055035949,
-0.3713262975,
0.1410046369,
-0.4940350354,
-0.4896450341,
-0.1921793669,
-0.4237584174,
-0.1723925769,
-0.4921185672,
0.2927047908,
0.1255571544,
0.0411844067,
0.4994766712,
-0.1080665067,
0.1286162734,
0.4559965432,
0.4722676873,
0.0817016736,
0.4136706591,
-0.1633144468,
-0.0388377421,
-1.0435214043,
-0.5181182623,
0.9322903156,
0.298786819,
0.7646925449,
0.3945309222,
0.3372023404,
0.6714821458,
0.6270970702,
-0.3066054285,
0.108314842,
0.1104617044,
-0.5010179877,
0.05040057,
-0.4768119454,
-0.6679061651,
0.2441260219,
-0.5008197427,
-0.3945552111,
0.8065593839,
-0.1127293408,
-0.0455137379,
0.6137931943,
-0.8949585557,
0.7097713351,
-0.1769830734,
-0.0624612756,
-0.1669470668,
-0.6224564314,
0.2316452712,
-0.3153024614,
0.4815548956,
0.2090538144,
0.3579161167,
0.6544378996,
0.272544682,
0.9861710668,
-0.3829921484,
-0.0349579453,
0.3218261898,
0.2141538411,
0.5039401054,
0.0204019248,
0.0644340813,
0.4863786399,
-0.097907044,
-0.252679795,
-0.5192768574,
0.6131613255,
-0.7112362981,
-0.0461074561,
-0.3727244735,
-0.711777389,
-0.1283068061,
0.0673873946,
0.4667392075,
0.4219106436,
0.0687224194,
0.4438218176,
0.6014378071,
-0.2428497225,
0.2917149365,
0.5090863705,
0.107232213,
-0.1056064591,
0.6024237275,
0.3233059645,
0.1894185245,
0.0308511276,
-0.3338989615,
-0.4326224029,
-0.170040369,
-0.420692265,
0.1528142542,
-1.2264425755,
-0.274490267,
-0.5011570454,
-0.4641021192,
-0.5224357843,
-0.093911916,
-0.1252298653,
-0.1904331744,
-0.2995972335,
-0.0765093416,
0.2939867079,
0.7567075491,
-0.414675504,
0.6087512374,
-0.857768774,
0.4754884243,
0.0469064265,
0.289100796,
-0.0360432044,
-0.7052396536,
-0.4328303933,
0.6500201225,
-0.1390534341,
-1.2206019163,
0.4669121802,
-0.1307322979,
0.8080854416,
0.5422691107,
-0.0723021924,
0.4528167844,
0.0263024326,
0.4618031383,
0.0751202554,
-0.4645470977,
0.4042288065,
-0.1560961753,
0.2226481736,
0.6763279438,
0.7668735385,
-0.8044449687,
0.0737632215,
-0.3342412412,
-0.5522264838,
0.651126802,
0.2240450084,
0.1035528705,
-0.0050948146,
0.3279729486,
0.1829015315,
0.22988379,
-0.8326567411,
-0.2241992205,
-0.2903678119,
-0.0427862853,
-0.0236364231,
-0.3643293083,
-0.2744070292,
-0.0801564604,
0.5094401836,
-0.0160967615,
0.4288989604,
0.1984760761,
-0.8459022641,
0.1077350304,
0.0601183064,
0.4714060426,
1.0476102829,
-0.1705451757,
0.1277317703,
0.0873278826,
-0.3380645216,
0.1196106821,
0.1359773725,
-0.4050333798,
0.3711465597,
0.3656181097,
0.8142980337,
0.1537030637,
-0.2100591809,
0.70114851,
-0.015396582,
-0.1410309076,
-0.2121712267,
-0.3429662287,
0.1022563353,
0.3962076604,
0.4075506628,
0.7498219609,
-0.0117678577,
-0.7051761746,
0.2916032076,
-0.0488613918,
-0.4040171206,
-0.0573819168,
0.5143193007,
0.1703045368,
-0.1307542622,
0.6984689236,
0.1413339078,
-0.5955154896,
0.4985441566,
0.5208665133,
0.3814441264,
-0.1813491881,
0.420592159,
0.1299165636,
0.7191873193,
-0.103378661,
0.1185473576,
-0.0375024192,
-0.9477927685,
-0.0894789472,
-0.4544524848,
0.0864494815,
0.0479827747,
-0.6546996832,
0.106892556,
-0.0705860034,
-0.3187543452,
-0.113429375,
-0.7320289016,
-0.9840472341,
0.1416004449,
0.2771518528,
1.056938529,
-1.1546750069,
0.6942911148,
0.5832898617,
-0.671426177,
-0.4994950593,
0.1162884831,
0.1109274253,
-0.6503552198,
0.7480341792,
0.2716705203,
-0.0533389188,
-0.6033086181,
-0.4415883422,
-0.7179205418,
1.1262259483,
0.4734806418,
-0.5327833891,
0.1371153444,
0.1286573559,
0.4985471666,
-0.481664449,
0.1136171147,
0.2879793048,
0.5622990727,
0.1379087865,
-0.6579568982,
-0.1759398431,
-0.116318509,
0.074801527,
-0.0998858437,
-0.3684429526,
0.9317601919,
0.0427669026,
-0.3683499992,
-0.3626448512,
0.5352852941,
0.0569725633,
0.3977753222,
0.3820706606,
0.2885598838,
0.5282959938,
-0.1382753402,
1.1085773706,
-0.526309371,
0.3345350921,
0.848831892,
-0.1733350307,
0.6521213651,
0.3768524826,
0.3072251976,
0.7309904695,
0.6685413718,
-0.0424140841,
0.5367635489,
-0.2556883693,
-0.1778586954,
-0.2725766301,
0.070658721,
-0.5655898452,
0.5258067846,
0.3844727278,
-0.6461516023,
-0.3165408373,
0.4787939489,
-0.1437196881,
0.0506228134,
-0.325650841,
0.486405462,
-0.1923587322,
-0.1757919937,
0.4259064794,
0.1599511653,
0.7575355768,
-0.7819017768,
-0.0902452916,
-0.3398027122,
0.372505635,
-0.1693206877,
-0.7281608582,
0.4171212912,
-0.4115822613,
-0.3034644425,
-0.0823131502,
1.2321628332,
-0.4750795066,
-0.5381792784,
0.4861642718,
0.6972759366,
-0.024886772,
-0.3487274647,
-0.5631404519,
-0.1073586568,
0.0492870435,
0.1627344042,
0.2193078548,
0.5820260644,
-0.098900564,
0.9078813195,
0.6497916579,
0.0544418059,
0.0464503393,
0.1600214839,
0.8633185625,
-0.3340469003,
-0.6898789406,
-0.5763263702,
0.0450247936,
-0.3401216567,
-0.0413295478,
1.1254146099,
0.4659499824,
0.8167465925,
-0.3105821311,
1.0679274797,
-0.0318328142,
0.4273695052,
-0.298879236,
1.045240283,
-0.4667594135,
0.1759395599,
-0.1621021926,
-0.995588541,
0.1750208139,
0.7251718044,
-0.2286350429,
0.1056072786,
0.356099695,
0.6773173809,
-0.4036080837,
0.3298732936,
0.1375286132,
0.2327194363,
0.0060017938,
0.2618818879,
0.7780311108,
-0.3778482974,
0.5304502249,
-0.3571000993,
-0.1435457319,
-0.260322839,
-0.5549330711,
-0.8288576007,
-0.6773630381,
0.0690023154,
-0.5400640368,
0.1859782636,
0.576769352,
0.7179762125,
-0.7717324495,
0.0262246616,
0.692219317,
-0.1002099812,
-0.371307075,
-0.3204197884,
0.1863503605,
0.2344454527,
-0.1322577894,
0.3493497074,
0.24055098,
0.2306141108,
-0.1598779112,
0.0647667348,
-0.8202709556,
0.3573631644,
0.8974232674,
0.1028083786,
-0.3449109495,
-0.2644435465,
-0.2540934682,
-0.0902621374,
0.0588491596,
0.7328729033,
-0.7048143148,
0.5053560734,
0.1702845395,
0.5655869246,
0.5748311281,
0.1359713674,
0.5296828151,
-1.0647079945,
0.2700431645,
-0.1233668253,
0.5354642272,
0.5514174104,
-0.3641867638,
0.4217892587,
0.5992790461,
-0.1677625477,
-0.5336871743,
-0.0670827404,
-0.7247043848,
-0.5570020676,
1.3191870451,
0.02409059,
-0.1628934741,
-0.3189505935,
-0.3771772683,
0.3532429934,
-0.3965418935,
0.8863025308,
0.8509202003,
0.0896061435,
-0.2233081758,
-0.6870300174,
0.0559979901,
-0.2127494663,
-0.717299521,
-0.1775664836,
0.3763296902,
0.6449705362,
0.2878590822,
0.1853913069,
0.0149623174,
0.3624267578,
0.2717432976,
0.1540109366,
-0.457343936,
-0.499430716,
-0.3536011577,
0.2453999966,
-0.7881447673,
-0.2107359618
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04032v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04032v1
|
RoAST: Robustifying Language Models via Adversarial Perturbation with Selective Training
| 2023-12-07T04:23:36 | 2023-12-07T04:23:36 |
Jaehyung Kim, Yuning Mao, Rui Hou, Hanchao Yu, Davis Liang, Pascale Fung, Qifan Wang, Fuli Feng, Lifu Huang, Madian Khabsa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Fine-tuning pre-trained language models (LMs) has become the de facto
standard in many NLP tasks. Nevertheless, fine-tuned LMs are still prone to
robustness issues, such as adversarial robustness and model calibration.
Several perspectives of robustness for LMs have been studied independently, but
lacking a unified consideration in multiple perspectives. In this paper, we
propose Robustifying LMs via Adversarial perturbation with Selective Training
(RoAST), a simple yet effective fine-tuning technique to enhance the
multi-perspective robustness of LMs in a unified way. RoAST effectively
incorporates two important sources for the model robustness, robustness on the
perturbed inputs and generalizable knowledge in pre-trained LMs. To be
specific, RoAST introduces adversarial perturbation during fine-tuning while
the model parameters are selectively updated upon their relative importance to
minimize unnecessary deviation. Under a unified evaluation of fine-tuned LMs by
incorporating four representative perspectives of model robustness, we
demonstrate the effectiveness of RoAST compared to state-of-the-art fine-tuning
methods on six different types of LMs, which indicates its usefulness in
practice.
|
[
-0.2949918211,
-0.8941419125,
0.0943833962,
0.2990715802,
-0.1419221163,
-0.0454697423,
-0.4901674688,
-0.0871868059,
0.0116994409,
0.6066550016,
-0.4099893868,
-0.4905668497,
-0.5798809528,
-0.185065642,
-0.3009961545,
1.2669790983,
0.3091448545,
-0.0130488854,
0.1752815247,
-0.0479277708,
-0.2066427916,
-0.4130407572,
-0.6493042111,
-0.3331720233,
0.8013934493,
0.1780121773,
1.0363940001,
0.7787597775,
0.4706228673,
0.2843311429,
-0.2156653255,
0.3016009331,
-0.5895549059,
0.3623791933,
0.0017610079,
-0.5982126594,
-0.2969709635,
0.1525504589,
0.5667721629,
0.6769604683,
0.0352286361,
-0.0780560896,
0.2473556846,
0.683821559,
-0.9202477932,
-0.2151993662,
-1.4700206518,
-0.1254882216,
-0.2065356225,
-0.2388939559,
-0.475145787,
-0.2123722285,
-0.2047179639,
-0.3881225884,
0.1323296428,
-0.1950002164,
0.9489756227,
0.6242857575,
-0.1846967936,
0.0987855271,
-0.8816429377,
1.0183857679,
-0.9225069284,
-0.0160538908,
0.5048524737,
0.5085564852,
-0.3437079489,
-0.4812696278,
-0.1619751006,
-0.3753365576,
-0.0612611175,
0.0689945444,
-0.0206892304,
0.0103769479,
0.2430225015,
0.4604605138,
-0.3388912678,
0.4981707931,
0.2085873634,
-0.267741859,
0.244070977,
-0.2043500245,
0.3330551684,
0.2143761069,
-0.3748495281,
-0.2912298143,
-0.6894285679,
-0.0207983702,
1.0094726086,
0.7940062284,
0.1874874979,
0.2848857343,
0.0337011628,
0.6069006324,
-0.0415041409,
0.1023162827,
-0.062559396,
-0.138730973,
-0.294054985,
-0.4511046708,
0.8905647993,
0.0664215684,
0.3878537416,
-0.2757073939,
-0.2450122833,
0.3062232137,
0.4179689586,
-0.6773967743,
-0.5100655556,
0.3314206302,
-0.1456555724,
-0.7826051116,
-0.1414817423,
-0.620795548,
-0.4210829139,
0.0920494646,
0.1160455719,
-0.5369426012,
-0.4845021367,
0.0858197361,
0.0886554942,
0.0256489124,
0.2257552743,
-1.1320676804,
0.0695126206,
0.5533205271,
0.4113636315,
-0.0258310176,
-0.4074582756,
-0.6481121778,
0.1798052788,
-0.192690745,
0.7792513371,
-0.5201511383,
0.1167349443,
0.1804133356,
-0.2291692793,
-0.2527934611,
-0.6148346066,
0.7469619513,
-0.6360986233,
0.0092794234,
-0.119499974,
-0.2137888223,
0.0566255935,
0.6691118479,
-0.6314698458,
0.9340106249,
-0.1346674412,
-1.2118649483,
0.3342357278,
-0.3462721407,
-0.6347391605,
-0.2767193615,
-0.1181586757,
-0.7434937954,
0.0106031671,
0.6745171547,
0.505484283,
0.0723280385,
0.1734691858,
-0.5019118786,
-0.2163752764,
0.1914975494,
-0.5790098906,
0.8512900472,
0.2568838,
-0.1180720031,
0.5168886185,
-0.8725992441,
0.1516342014,
0.3392109871,
-0.4126725793,
-0.492544502,
0.0653089955,
0.0740274936,
-0.1479997784,
0.0921870545,
-0.1663389653,
0.1138083935,
-0.7795616984,
0.5668520331,
0.613556385,
-0.3235380352,
0.4189832211,
-0.4332821071,
0.3840492666,
0.120394662,
0.0222067274,
-0.4901354611,
-0.108767882,
-0.6705083847,
-0.5079935193,
0.4789601862,
0.6255374551,
-0.4558906555,
0.6662634611,
0.2941887975,
-0.4937915206,
-0.5225388408,
0.1708394289,
0.3786868751,
0.4173159599,
0.421112746,
-0.0318247043,
-0.5513759255,
-0.8813165426,
-0.6943668127,
-0.185553059,
-0.2273256779,
0.0857198685,
0.1633054912,
-0.1835304797,
0.5249476433,
-0.124807477,
-0.3779052794,
-0.231608063,
0.0772025064,
0.1301040649,
0.6050415635,
0.8026310802,
-0.6326267123,
-0.5146542192,
0.1618796438,
-0.2788305581,
-0.0726692602,
-0.0783594102,
-0.0994647145,
-0.2249680161,
0.4215522707,
-0.2534408271,
0.2288681269,
0.5692263842,
0.0034054013,
0.8189911246,
-0.0520337,
-0.0518303029,
-0.9905589223,
-0.0422659144,
-0.0441887677,
-0.4400072694,
-0.5536649823,
0.491864115,
-0.0209379084,
0.0155521678,
-0.4096648097,
0.2959246635,
-0.3438039124,
0.3263435364,
-0.3721197546,
-0.1280463785,
0.0439331122,
0.422762841,
-0.1619745493,
0.5597207546,
0.9041452408,
-0.5313984156,
0.2895112336,
-0.1864017993,
-0.0518179536,
0.1823982596,
-0.6289457679,
0.3605619073,
-0.10653653,
0.0346949697,
-1.1097471714,
-0.0928204209,
0.1791981459,
-0.3854137361,
0.4913054705,
-0.2423193008,
-0.4596598446,
-0.0372772887,
-0.313225925,
0.2796886861,
0.1860578507,
-0.4905417264,
0.478690505,
0.3262358308,
0.1895955205,
-0.5484841466,
-0.6078580022,
-0.1176036298,
-0.4330740869,
-0.4156655967,
0.3334379196,
-0.1362853199,
-0.1120196655,
-0.3888799548,
-0.1594234258,
0.121463865,
0.3285725713,
-0.1023720801,
-0.1474207491,
-0.2508860528,
-0.2661513984,
-0.0296589769,
-0.2330176979,
-0.1475886852,
-0.3385298848,
0.6013416052,
-0.2018034756,
-0.3979229629,
-0.4632096291,
0.3360083401,
0.6174274087,
-0.2615211606,
0.7589432001,
0.8995119333,
-0.4595375061,
-0.298571378,
-0.6827535629,
-0.4167855382,
-0.4710093439,
0.4546074271,
-0.3197285533,
-0.7587321997,
0.8750280738,
-0.2531271279,
0.237412557,
0.3055791855,
0.5592198968,
-0.11060635,
1.2736330032,
0.7145906091,
-0.3394349813,
0.6310841441,
0.0704997778,
-0.1383471787,
-0.7083169222,
0.0878790766,
-0.9484007359,
-0.4891849756,
-0.4765154719,
-0.0265577566,
-0.0047020013,
0.130074814,
-0.4210622013,
0.4575912356,
-0.5067488551,
0.5785027146,
0.5404871106,
0.1939042062,
0.1477656364,
0.1764274389,
-0.6325626969,
-0.3393477201,
-0.6191058755,
-0.5894989967,
0.8175916672,
0.5647314787,
0.9240839481,
-0.0937724337,
0.3729584217,
-0.0810890943,
0.2161951363,
-0.6099501252,
0.2864833176,
-0.5550148487,
-0.5858428478,
-0.3022303879,
-0.5665637851,
-0.7520026565,
0.3051570058,
-0.2288243175,
-0.7674940825,
-0.2104101777,
0.3076988459,
-0.4219399989,
0.5060667992,
-0.7389872074,
0.9128212929,
-0.3397500813,
-0.1660119444,
0.0715969577,
-0.6716569066,
0.1814566255,
0.2217802256,
0.0381907299,
-0.1694846749,
0.1786000133,
0.4619617462,
-0.121227622,
1.0644775629,
-0.098546207,
-0.1109751239,
-0.187044397,
0.2640314698,
0.7761983871,
0.3291060925,
-0.328496635,
-0.0709756985,
-0.0350502506,
-0.5901735425,
-0.7592970133,
0.9152821898,
-0.9167128801,
-0.7455505729,
-0.2451783419,
-0.690099895,
-0.624632895,
0.4659871757,
0.2842278779,
0.0149758263,
-0.1427925229,
0.3092080057,
0.7145033479,
-0.2753298283,
0.1250450611,
0.3911855519,
-0.1798460186,
-0.4244942963,
0.5561630726,
-0.3416626453,
0.3794672787,
0.4872453213,
0.3723962009,
-0.0194123145,
-0.8166904449,
-0.2463654727,
-0.0180616658,
-0.4170337617,
-0.2941382527,
-0.5549075603,
-0.3788362443,
-0.4639990926,
-0.0617715009,
-0.8230773211,
-0.0908217803,
-0.5275747776,
0.0893557966,
0.0147561217,
0.1582574546,
0.3488351405,
0.5929110646,
-0.2934651375,
0.2708151639,
0.242939204,
0.4340691566,
-0.1388941109,
-0.635430336,
-0.0765085667,
0.255420655,
-0.3852198124,
-0.6552042365,
0.2604230344,
0.3901161551,
0.4810686111,
0.8151791096,
0.2822613418,
0.7257218361,
-0.4740624428,
0.3994931281,
0.2682881355,
-0.5147795081,
0.837611258,
-0.6182843447,
0.554772079,
0.8265628219,
0.2335048765,
-0.0810430795,
-0.9232397676,
-0.3067108095,
-0.9292635918,
0.4846111834,
0.1399903148,
0.3978228867,
0.1239252612,
0.378344506,
0.3138495982,
0.0362774916,
-0.883099854,
-0.3850319386,
-0.3751745224,
0.0542615727,
0.1191477627,
-0.2062007934,
-0.3659765422,
-0.2281939536,
0.7475001812,
-0.1495196372,
-0.1630381793,
-0.2328065783,
0.1356928796,
-0.2159668207,
0.2348984927,
0.3240261376,
0.3988075554,
-0.3160383105,
0.4146742225,
-0.1109422222,
-0.3400333524,
-0.1212252602,
0.1602519602,
-0.4230158329,
-0.3136103153,
0.1761266291,
0.9333014488,
0.189989537,
-0.1092426628,
0.3001711667,
-0.3301438093,
0.0115242936,
-0.0592741929,
0.2056822032,
0.0537214801,
0.1175005063,
0.2893829346,
0.7138636708,
-0.1901905388,
-0.3181778491,
0.1097233742,
0.8598640561,
-0.3551512659,
-0.4444601238,
0.9186860919,
-0.0265618712,
-0.2105374932,
0.3381122649,
0.0556477048,
-0.5721051097,
0.4056992829,
0.8825011253,
0.8117921352,
-0.3359832168,
0.1279977411,
0.2256128043,
0.6932436228,
-0.030337194,
-0.1346090734,
0.1346408427,
-0.9966232777,
-0.4950827658,
-0.7872601151,
-0.2498378307,
0.7377871871,
-0.6489875317,
0.2845219374,
-0.6647948027,
-0.2352491021,
-0.0234358981,
-0.0017540995,
-0.5694631934,
0.3509867489,
-0.0125079658,
0.805010438,
-0.8935770392,
0.9329953194,
1.0988030434,
-0.1762865484,
-0.793102026,
0.380983144,
-0.1386114508,
-0.7221143246,
0.028264137,
0.1754613966,
-0.0928136781,
0.0173689425,
-0.5430901051,
-0.6001534462,
0.4350544512,
1.0544762611,
-0.3833571672,
0.0683456287,
-0.0285867155,
0.566880703,
-0.2397665679,
0.485093385,
0.4366010427,
0.342925787,
0.3159665465,
-0.7209206223,
-0.0159314368,
-0.3452484012,
0.1672479957,
-0.0810464099,
-0.6343265176,
0.4127472341,
-0.193654269,
-0.3050983846,
0.1052359417,
0.8814539909,
0.0146718761,
-0.133061558,
0.6550878882,
0.5048166513,
0.6552477479,
-0.1696877331,
0.7164335251,
-0.22352314,
0.1459814608,
1.0875042677,
-0.1454750448,
0.7479602695,
0.4672495127,
-0.2530242801,
0.090559721,
0.63907516,
0.3018392324,
0.6905179024,
0.2167550027,
0.0495661385,
-0.4142241478,
0.07331305,
-0.5710759759,
0.4534707367,
0.3571318984,
-0.2709251642,
-0.2943959832,
-0.0526075885,
0.1738134176,
0.4336492717,
-0.0798032358,
0.6703335047,
0.0078868354,
-0.6947085261,
0.8345969319,
0.131617412,
0.838000834,
-0.7464721799,
0.4297823608,
-0.1906863451,
0.4764696658,
-0.259806782,
-0.2846234143,
0.5301792622,
-0.1850621849,
-0.3492272496,
-0.2651544511,
0.8596470952,
-0.4915502071,
-0.4169310927,
0.4415871203,
0.1395415366,
-0.1482362598,
-0.4650075734,
-0.6519483924,
0.3815650046,
-0.0791629776,
-0.3379144669,
0.633884728,
0.2827924192,
0.4016009867,
0.5740185976,
0.6857225895,
0.5248898864,
-0.0772032142,
0.4758299887,
1.1384071112,
-0.2386147231,
-0.4987821281,
-0.9721752405,
0.394225359,
0.1924115717,
-0.3810736239,
0.8302193284,
0.1991460621,
0.9348522425,
-0.0092013068,
0.8200316429,
0.2424145639,
0.5306844711,
-0.428447634,
0.9765110016,
-0.5667160153,
0.5851042271,
-0.3153425753,
-1.0114688873,
-0.9016251564,
0.6093139648,
-0.3796181679,
0.1387356222,
0.3991716206,
0.8250546455,
-0.2039376944,
-0.0453352109,
0.5789371729,
0.3735516965,
0.1722279489,
0.2163787931,
0.7261362672,
-0.3409430385,
0.7050768733,
-0.3581355214,
-0.4219002128,
-0.1350981593,
-1.0492984056,
-1.1581044197,
-0.4216818213,
-0.5088564157,
-0.3150232434,
0.2723070383,
0.5624117851,
0.9854524136,
-1.2618355751,
0.0957647488,
-0.049309209,
0.122558102,
-0.600564301,
-0.2157021016,
0.2316124737,
-0.7644414306,
-0.7343128324,
0.5700089335,
0.1908985972,
-0.3334914744,
-0.5168809891,
0.3009878993,
-0.2019374073,
0.0150276311,
0.3039928079,
0.2538378537,
-0.6259640455,
-0.2171337456,
-0.1607698202,
-0.0948813781,
0.1010024622,
0.7449806333,
-0.6315070391,
0.5109759569,
0.1991371512,
0.7969290018,
0.1662370861,
-0.0145379202,
0.6022806764,
-1.196642518,
0.4794199765,
0.4267623127,
0.3171497285,
0.4870087206,
-0.3879422843,
0.024959024,
-0.0816060528,
-0.6563650966,
-0.9779379964,
0.5737405419,
-0.6423895955,
-0.1263560355,
1.2271891832,
-0.346621424,
-0.1163197532,
0.0298143942,
-0.2080082893,
0.4046980441,
-0.2749223709,
0.9943656325,
0.5231382251,
0.3856078088,
-0.1180606037,
-0.2970571518,
0.5812192559,
0.7601467371,
-0.5849487185,
0.0505600534,
-0.0143232001,
0.236671567,
0.0643052906,
0.2149523497,
-0.1805032641,
-0.1686019152,
-0.0826139599,
-0.3695599139,
-0.1935992241,
-0.4578778446,
-0.1225200146,
0.411529839,
0.3132258058,
-0.1890134215
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.04021v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.04021v4
|
A Study on the Calibration of In-context Learning
| 2023-12-07T03:37:39 | 2024-03-28T03:01:45 |
Hanlin Zhang, Yi-Fan Zhang, Yaodong Yu, Dhruv Madeka, Dean Foster, Eric Xing, Himabindu Lakkaraju, Sham Kakade
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Accurate uncertainty quantification is crucial for the safe deployment of
machine learning models, and prior research has demonstrated improvements in
the calibration of modern language models (LMs). We study in-context learning
(ICL), a prevalent method for adapting static LMs through tailored prompts, and
examine the balance between performance and calibration across a broad spectrum
of natural language understanding and reasoning tasks. Through comprehensive
experiments, we observe that, with an increasing number of ICL examples, models
initially exhibit increased miscalibration before achieving better calibration
and miscalibration tends to arise in low-shot settings. Moreover, we find that
methods aimed at improving usability, such as fine-tuning and chain-of-thought
(CoT) prompting, can lead to miscalibration and unreliable natural language
explanations. Furthermore, we explore recalibration techniques and find that a
scaling-binning calibrator can reduce calibration errors consistently.
|
[
-0.3522851467,
-0.7348979115,
0.4558388591,
-0.1092229038,
-0.0768783987,
-0.0066853487,
-0.3527987599,
-0.3378756642,
-0.8934158683,
0.2700141668,
-0.4481975734,
-0.25352633,
-0.2635243833,
0.0703485236,
0.0169878099,
0.8420061469,
-0.1226730645,
0.199420616,
-0.5102849007,
-0.2438536584,
-0.9059202075,
-0.4610960186,
-0.5529388785,
-0.5823307633,
0.2601247132,
0.7141550183,
0.8668172359,
0.3113484979,
0.2299363166,
0.1235084906,
-0.0580521487,
0.389131844,
-0.4962618053,
0.0738211051,
-0.3354596198,
-0.6052169204,
-0.0126510058,
-0.1712117195,
0.7160459161,
0.9997358918,
-0.0632097051,
0.1094424501,
0.5212041736,
0.8458703756,
-1.0200966597,
-0.050520312,
-0.6004399061,
-0.0674524978,
0.2842829525,
-0.3134769499,
-0.7400761247,
-0.3778758943,
0.520455122,
-0.5924831033,
-0.0046293172,
0.1494881362,
0.5752488375,
0.7631509304,
-0.6001497507,
-0.5584142804,
-0.7106278539,
1.1306966543,
-0.8814213276,
0.3938286901,
0.5710368156,
0.4135632217,
-0.2561911345,
-0.4116987884,
-0.1131198406,
-0.2671454549,
-0.1303825676,
-0.2219192535,
0.0303664524,
0.0757183656,
0.2890485823,
0.0090312278,
-0.3961142898,
0.2490867674,
-0.1434573829,
-0.3318138421,
0.3679998219,
0.0914642438,
0.1654985249,
0.2578187883,
-0.2450720668,
-0.2594979405,
-0.8379593492,
0.4324213266,
0.1770121157,
0.6039306521,
-0.1326502413,
0.0958072543,
-0.0677185208,
1.2405077219,
0.2082759589,
-0.2404703796,
-0.1518063247,
-0.3605772257,
-0.2822030485,
0.277731657,
0.2907377183,
0.4106193781,
0.283985436,
-0.0144945309,
-0.1325998008,
-0.3058139384,
0.4380467236,
-0.7917270064,
-0.0926653966,
0.0333558396,
0.0430504754,
-0.1629460007,
-0.0980748087,
-0.3509472311,
-0.3921973407,
-0.6970255375,
0.6603352427,
-0.570730567,
0.2344202548,
0.1928677261,
0.0666953772,
0.3173417151,
0.4361864328,
-0.7785755992,
0.1167105436,
0.438591212,
0.4771686494,
0.1514312178,
-0.1539360136,
-0.4786280692,
-0.0929349363,
-0.5827851295,
0.4051647484,
-0.1914408952,
-0.2707678974,
-0.0068699988,
-0.3040771782,
-0.191930443,
-0.5213397145,
0.4702179432,
-0.384472698,
0.2479223162,
-0.446981281,
-0.6293746233,
-0.4450212121,
0.4023253024,
-0.396697104,
1.0211217403,
0.1972180009,
-0.6505248547,
0.6427242756,
-0.556593895,
-0.2302413732,
0.0000578216,
-0.0430637933,
-0.106932655,
0.1469012201,
0.2444008589,
0.3568517268,
-0.313598305,
0.3406613469,
-0.2079251558,
-0.7710779309,
0.4024945199,
-0.7789227366,
0.7470855117,
0.3756768703,
-0.3596703708,
-0.1505215913,
-0.6292203665,
0.2781134844,
-0.3858403862,
-0.3378167152,
-0.4010635316,
0.1471114457,
-0.256326735,
0.1704410315,
0.0599814244,
-0.2675689757,
-0.2309051454,
-0.6358831525,
0.461635381,
0.4570189416,
0.0442313552,
0.7088362575,
-0.4202858508,
0.2853274345,
-0.0169094689,
-0.084808208,
-0.3470629752,
-0.2032390386,
-0.6942417622,
0.0132302912,
0.2057918906,
0.5821022987,
-0.5719968677,
0.4119690359,
-0.0671776086,
-0.3911990523,
-0.4581377506,
0.144839555,
0.4922757149,
1.1230237484,
0.3178176582,
-0.0556300506,
-0.2581901848,
-0.6710029244,
-0.639198482,
-0.1736394316,
-0.2391239703,
0.3490061164,
0.3148707449,
-0.1053527147,
1.3440089226,
0.0779634789,
0.2049159557,
0.0707515106,
0.2203793079,
-0.097100392,
0.5110126734,
0.5401784182,
-0.6771935821,
-0.5473644137,
-0.0847085491,
-0.7039787769,
-0.1534998715,
-0.2026940137,
-0.0552053861,
0.2817008793,
0.64085567,
-0.0319961049,
0.4724998772,
0.3756549358,
-0.1339943111,
0.4437613785,
-0.4428635836,
0.165390417,
-0.8882589936,
-0.007187305,
0.1780468225,
-0.4592528939,
-0.6708735824,
0.2402728498,
0.5809983015,
0.053714525,
-0.6993076801,
0.5162479877,
-0.248902455,
0.1282521486,
-0.2307227999,
0.5066131949,
0.3351367414,
0.1122853011,
-0.2943452299,
0.9715806842,
0.4712650478,
-0.9179961681,
0.0133081684,
-0.1253163964,
-0.5271806121,
0.9427754879,
-0.3314571977,
0.0991409644,
-0.2702926695,
0.4666024446,
-0.9346262813,
-0.3277396262,
0.0129401833,
-0.1755561233,
0.3341194689,
-0.0687726438,
-0.4542452097,
-0.0751237795,
-0.1396018863,
0.6921924949,
0.1610839665,
-0.6799669862,
0.2632843554,
0.1153736711,
0.3949888945,
-0.5508664846,
-0.9628235102,
-0.0925902128,
-0.3270210028,
-0.3478464484,
0.3488940895,
-0.3206825852,
-0.4072864652,
-0.4618952274,
-0.1010431424,
-0.0699441954,
0.4131930768,
0.1206176206,
0.0809092075,
-0.3170910776,
0.4915946424,
0.0454521105,
0.0060783844,
0.0385279804,
-0.2121938765,
0.3066366613,
-0.4745527506,
-0.5312712789,
-0.6459354162,
-0.0064946064,
0.5185637474,
0.0840323642,
0.6622575521,
0.3824988008,
-0.6617491841,
-0.2583659291,
-0.3162362278,
-0.3231982887,
-0.4881809354,
0.2903286815,
-0.3344641328,
-0.6602376699,
0.2709944248,
-0.1570189446,
0.1836140156,
0.4014695287,
0.3601201475,
-0.4209957719,
1.1945366859,
0.7155258656,
-0.068183057,
0.3690437973,
0.0041126348,
0.4107780755,
-0.8102835417,
0.0080003124,
-0.6123779416,
-0.3683227003,
-0.4387789667,
-0.2617454231,
0.2590916753,
0.3299234807,
-0.7085028291,
0.2571249902,
-0.4254885018,
0.7622135878,
0.4958202541,
0.1900657713,
0.117607981,
-0.2269956023,
-0.2463973463,
-0.2029709965,
-0.7750325203,
-0.807010591,
0.8862973452,
0.3110385835,
0.9911515117,
0.0206770822,
0.3175169528,
0.1324698329,
0.4207739532,
-0.6233907938,
0.1215667352,
0.1416554451,
-0.5782056451,
-0.3006002903,
-0.493188411,
-0.5431861281,
0.1924561411,
-0.0001207421,
-1.0486769676,
0.0948006585,
0.4139590263,
-0.7513794899,
0.1822839528,
-1.013438344,
0.9069923759,
-0.2423397154,
-0.1723693609,
-0.0465782769,
-0.7501603365,
0.1750383675,
-0.0953989401,
0.4293823838,
-0.0589260906,
0.1120932177,
0.1049351096,
-0.1730613559,
0.9761520028,
-0.1540493369,
-0.1805903763,
0.3448408842,
0.2684903741,
0.4040751457,
0.1322427839,
-0.5239136219,
-0.2561026812,
0.3058667183,
-0.4126476943,
-0.622220397,
0.6189550757,
-0.6514364481,
-0.2814607024,
-0.2068312168,
-0.9162146449,
-0.4773958325,
-0.2106621116,
0.4450373948,
0.7197082043,
-0.2304109335,
0.5082333684,
0.8099125028,
-0.3395774662,
0.3882540166,
0.3177721202,
-0.0012505744,
-0.06293533,
0.687269032,
0.054075405,
0.7740139961,
0.5273362398,
0.1562406719,
-0.2767548859,
-0.1297179759,
-0.6508832574,
-0.257494241,
-1.0074497461,
-0.3199000657,
-0.086449787,
-0.1011396572,
-0.1007974371,
-0.5247420669,
-0.203154996,
-0.1470435262,
-0.7370100617,
0.006533091,
0.1568382382,
0.5166420341,
0.2478953004,
0.5887297988,
-0.5557537079,
-0.321452558,
0.1607474089,
0.1817124039,
-0.103983365,
-0.901992321,
-0.4545905888,
0.6295802593,
-0.3827375174,
-0.6981956959,
0.1521915644,
0.5454840064,
0.4229817688,
0.3181474209,
0.2366778105,
0.9682112336,
-0.1828921586,
0.8218680024,
-0.2115795314,
-1.0206078291,
0.5595422983,
-0.0629611388,
0.9643318653,
1.0250250101,
0.2232671082,
-0.7293395996,
-0.3329345584,
-0.2461368442,
-0.5792145133,
0.6821151376,
-0.2012250274,
0.3336922228,
0.3169156611,
0.6327239871,
0.014257744,
0.0392455049,
-0.5925766826,
-0.2002084702,
0.0902673081,
-0.5210245848,
-0.2316846102,
-0.0882624015,
-0.0988211259,
-0.3250105381,
0.6782520413,
-0.6828146577,
-0.0522825159,
0.0258713439,
-0.7234634757,
-0.3265832365,
0.0982869565,
0.7485608459,
0.9586992264,
-0.3304287791,
0.2342489511,
0.6099389195,
-0.0917485729,
-0.0309441164,
-0.1790631711,
-0.3169083297,
-0.2297632545,
0.2104386389,
0.9104840159,
0.7548604608,
-0.8675663471,
0.4404954314,
-0.1781912744,
-0.1246666089,
-0.0699455142,
0.2151742131,
-0.2394203097,
0.0680551901,
0.4619123936,
0.3825349808,
-0.0301600993,
-0.4825237095,
0.2306680977,
0.4561292529,
-0.7700158358,
-0.1305748224,
0.5386574268,
-0.0708783939,
-0.4772692025,
0.5596376061,
-0.1033869758,
-0.4124757946,
0.5133414865,
0.7322506309,
0.5861650109,
-0.0610656738,
0.1470582634,
0.4558749795,
0.4118728042,
-0.0758610889,
-0.0499214157,
-0.2872030139,
-0.7584303021,
-0.3284303248,
-0.4806196988,
-0.8100885153,
-0.1688211858,
-0.6493039727,
0.2820494771,
-0.2631838918,
-0.0896323323,
-0.3158184886,
-0.0225614738,
-0.8298276067,
0.3163590729,
0.1685061306,
1.0180230141,
-0.644407928,
0.7453023195,
0.5546272397,
-0.0731104538,
-0.7809662223,
0.1523132473,
0.2383850068,
-0.500916481,
0.3650298715,
0.5699363947,
-0.2619315982,
0.111090824,
-0.5849941969,
-1.0278872252,
1.1890643835,
0.768779099,
-0.3797393441,
0.0908843502,
0.2490917295,
0.5783749819,
-0.4821258783,
0.3620485365,
0.6201341152,
0.2504324615,
-0.1647854447,
-0.9556019902,
-0.1155657321,
0.2779982388,
0.0253185984,
0.1021063924,
-0.2477777898,
0.6765725613,
-0.1364417821,
-0.205184266,
-0.1140803769,
0.4473647773,
0.312112242,
0.2848934531,
0.5546348095,
0.3072675467,
0.9732051492,
-0.2541035712,
1.0085686445,
-0.3146691322,
0.3069113195,
1.2485642433,
-0.049167227,
0.7990113497,
0.6643864512,
0.0551346019,
0.5290621519,
1.055581212,
0.6759625673,
0.5118294954,
0.2406259626,
-0.4152692854,
-0.2833501399,
0.0159860812,
-0.1481032819,
0.1500038654,
0.6907893419,
-0.1524467617,
-0.4117940664,
0.3613581061,
-0.1178602949,
0.1408499628,
-0.1973698735,
0.5880783796,
0.1620623916,
-0.871106267,
0.7117315531,
-0.0848547965,
0.5388643742,
-0.2781611383,
0.1363308579,
-0.0060154679,
0.4258485138,
0.0368227884,
-0.6773885489,
0.2490041405,
-0.1344705522,
-0.0106349671,
-0.3107492626,
0.6285174489,
-0.4538481534,
-0.3174423575,
0.058714997,
0.3450163305,
0.1208670735,
-0.1686106026,
-0.6629374027,
-0.1228416413,
0.025099799,
-0.1037112027,
0.3885445297,
0.3744994104,
-0.0293495357,
0.849416852,
0.3467832506,
-0.468749702,
0.1116664335,
0.0611867607,
0.5147242546,
-0.3507244289,
-0.3385906219,
-0.8606171012,
0.7335387468,
0.1492561102,
-0.4717469811,
0.4697695971,
0.3277107775,
1.1585702896,
0.2626910508,
0.5010604262,
0.1875615716,
0.2704296112,
-0.4668035209,
0.6251501441,
-0.6867021918,
0.3832071424,
-0.1168980896,
-0.6632435918,
-0.67617625,
0.7888660431,
-0.2772104442,
-0.0104685985,
0.5752645135,
0.8883029819,
-0.0772115365,
0.1527702063,
0.4292353094,
-0.1765588373,
0.3179637194,
0.3824728727,
0.6047925353,
-0.6165004373,
0.3071507514,
-0.4567940533,
-0.2629043162,
-0.486177206,
-1.2563403845,
-0.5693230033,
-0.6209130287,
-0.1280288994,
-0.090042457,
-0.0505751111,
1.1449257135,
0.8512888551,
-0.8655830622,
-0.3598894477,
-0.2323833257,
0.1733083725,
-0.2289908826,
-0.2359241247,
-0.008255057,
-0.9071002007,
-0.6023820043,
0.5855640769,
0.2143123001,
0.0335233249,
-0.2334520221,
-0.3407577574,
-0.0947913006,
0.1758643389,
0.5600127578,
0.2871283591,
-0.8687691092,
-0.531834662,
-0.1227689534,
-0.3957536817,
0.1204498857,
0.5340238214,
-0.9713307023,
0.9076046348,
0.3267854154,
0.722168088,
0.322039485,
0.0146021768,
0.8475779891,
-1.0864762068,
0.176776439,
0.2267565578,
0.2487248778,
0.4816684723,
-0.2477913052,
0.2952165604,
-0.3098416328,
-0.8266025782,
-0.9909258485,
0.1905786097,
-0.410084039,
-0.1836672574,
0.761534214,
0.0089429999,
-0.0594569445,
-0.1514036506,
-0.4268813431,
0.1922560036,
-0.3100309074,
0.6228036284,
0.9548302293,
-0.0412611924,
-0.0740604326,
-0.7822147012,
0.6128031015,
0.5277398825,
-0.6289948821,
0.1600937396,
0.4451291561,
0.1311183274,
0.0625323951,
0.0823208243,
0.2925426364,
0.3207991123,
-0.3859511912,
-0.1984672248,
0.4929287434,
-0.2862630188,
-0.561013937,
-0.2254954278,
0.3765584528,
-0.005008521
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07552v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07552v1
|
Large Language Models for Intent-Driven Session Recommendations
| 2023-12-07T02:25:14 | 2023-12-07T02:25:14 |
Zhu Sun, Hongyang Liu, Xinghua Qu, Kaidong Feng, Yan Wang, Yew-Soon Ong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Intent-aware session recommendation (ISR) is pivotal in discerning user
intents within sessions for precise predictions. Traditional approaches,
however, face limitations due to their presumption of a uniform number of
intents across all sessions. This assumption overlooks the dynamic nature of
user sessions, where the number and type of intentions can significantly vary.
In addition, these methods typically operate in latent spaces, thus hinder the
model's transparency.Addressing these challenges, we introduce a novel ISR
approach, utilizing the advanced reasoning capabilities of large language
models (LLMs). First, this approach begins by generating an initial prompt that
guides LLMs to predict the next item in a session, based on the varied intents
manifested in user sessions. Then, to refine this process, we introduce an
innovative prompt optimization mechanism that iteratively self-reflects and
adjusts prompts. Furthermore, our prompt selection module, built upon the LLMs'
broad adaptability, swiftly selects the most optimized prompts across diverse
domains. This new paradigm empowers LLMs to discern diverse user intents at a
semantic level, leading to more accurate and interpretable session
recommendations. Our extensive experiments on three real-world datasets
demonstrate the effectiveness of our method, marking a significant advancement
in ISR systems.
|
[
-0.2106227726,
-0.8641880751,
1.1877137423,
0.3200345933,
-0.2667908072,
-0.0845454559,
-0.399479866,
-0.2074150741,
0.2043150961,
0.4784722626,
-0.8066408634,
-0.5751972795,
-0.2835462689,
-0.2128978223,
-0.1262869835,
0.892562151,
-0.0184950512,
-0.0075108884,
-0.3248438239,
-0.0667482689,
-0.7941040397,
-0.1436716318,
-0.8115381598,
-0.3842503428,
0.5571762323,
0.6460174918,
0.3568131924,
0.2337103635,
0.4774080515,
0.2846446037,
-0.1448604912,
0.4174362719,
-0.4483734667,
0.4909388721,
-0.1581444889,
-0.1998155415,
-0.3205024004,
-0.4780866206,
0.5085169077,
0.4558821917,
-0.2787228823,
-0.1909587383,
0.071469523,
0.6277298927,
-0.6066447496,
0.0426376574,
-0.7785826921,
-0.0244403072,
0.0235746223,
-0.3667395115,
-0.6778669953,
-0.0920050368,
0.2911198139,
-0.5470711589,
-0.0575066917,
0.3934698403,
0.3035930991,
0.0808856711,
-0.412694484,
-0.2144242078,
-0.9222353101,
0.6439125538,
-0.4770259261,
0.5895915031,
0.3228755891,
0.6030472517,
-0.3690676391,
-0.5583557487,
-0.214873597,
-0.339220345,
-0.0783706382,
-0.2225002795,
-0.3465877473,
0.0779562965,
0.3221298754,
0.1919134855,
-0.7820896506,
0.0610709153,
-0.0415463746,
0.0131011726,
0.5312901735,
0.2608145177,
0.2510733008,
0.3711095452,
-0.3773212433,
0.2793366611,
-0.7116889954,
0.1013368964,
0.0927328914,
0.5490484238,
-0.0731760338,
0.5494380593,
-0.2175115645,
0.6319360733,
0.3422131836,
-0.1289711446,
-0.3332365155,
-0.2212010622,
0.1093355119,
0.2166506052,
0.7625346184,
0.472359091,
0.0510888435,
-0.3364237845,
-0.2485830188,
-0.3192695975,
0.3556120098,
-0.8493682742,
-0.0289444886,
0.3090415895,
-0.3930727243,
0.0986292139,
-0.030710917,
-0.3928306103,
-0.6513978243,
-0.3728872836,
0.4292011261,
-0.5095419288,
-0.0153525267,
0.262629509,
0.1957748085,
0.0290764254,
0.5988537073,
-0.9233390689,
0.360125035,
0.8054660559,
0.9170097709,
-0.561839819,
-0.2222438157,
-0.6870651245,
0.3253906667,
0.0778572038,
0.98805511,
-0.9064933658,
-0.6212342381,
0.0290322788,
-0.0404156074,
0.1515071243,
-0.2602825463,
0.3704312146,
-0.7914843559,
0.1151704863,
-0.3497772217,
-0.640835464,
-0.4844669998,
0.3221853971,
-0.4295058846,
0.7634166479,
0.047562547,
-0.2885714173,
0.417952776,
-0.9260603189,
-0.481990993,
0.3876339495,
-0.2122569233,
-0.3036211729,
0.1982704103,
0.19253245,
0.2975229323,
-0.4225491881,
0.7901694775,
-0.4678538442,
-0.3287517726,
0.4386431873,
-0.4568974972,
0.3290100694,
0.2762376368,
-0.29982844,
0.7711791992,
-0.4661189616,
-0.0907304287,
-0.1375065297,
-0.196300894,
-0.2128795087,
0.0985757038,
0.2768656909,
-0.1632821858,
0.2767252624,
-0.4458673894,
0.3722943366,
-0.0886691362,
0.4080118537,
0.8612986803,
0.1695157737,
0.4099152386,
-0.1895041019,
0.5061258078,
-0.1087462083,
0.2828209102,
-0.5357658863,
-0.4070077837,
-0.5880178809,
-0.2861993313,
-0.0862150788,
0.2780142128,
-0.3283931911,
0.658454299,
-0.4169507325,
-0.471453011,
0.1075209305,
-0.1617889404,
0.3436224461,
0.1186802238,
0.2283823192,
-0.1989423037,
-0.2986247241,
-0.5712617636,
-0.4951361716,
-0.2384523302,
0.1988805681,
0.6885395646,
0.1371790618,
-0.5680898428,
0.9829570055,
-0.6682035327,
-0.2724949718,
-0.4038334787,
-0.3112199605,
0.3604122698,
0.3501347899,
0.2132569402,
-0.7983530164,
-0.865367949,
-0.0697293878,
-0.452223748,
-0.0665890202,
-0.4046645761,
-0.2668924332,
0.019045189,
0.6990502477,
-0.5033823848,
0.2355407327,
0.303322494,
-0.7346948981,
0.3495883942,
-0.3509236574,
0.1132960916,
-0.7430976629,
-0.0327671319,
0.0252405573,
-0.2904680669,
-0.4993462861,
-0.2639665306,
0.1792518646,
-0.14517124,
-0.1573521048,
1.0709149837,
-0.2949143052,
-0.0231893286,
-0.4109135866,
-0.1691313982,
-0.0013627132,
0.4701014459,
0.0406630039,
0.8245260119,
0.6689075232,
-0.7235616446,
0.1785480976,
0.2928139567,
-0.4409377575,
0.4335808754,
-0.6730886698,
0.220198378,
-0.0575012267,
0.3650065958,
-1.2721859217,
-0.3113756478,
0.1128036231,
-0.1100193039,
0.1068834364,
-0.3332642913,
-0.1648388058,
-0.1037878841,
-0.1275051683,
0.5456692576,
0.213656202,
-0.6781520247,
1.0696220398,
0.3142648041,
-0.3495818079,
-0.3956910372,
-0.25473243,
0.192492187,
-0.2973117828,
-0.5761376619,
0.5643844604,
-0.5290843248,
-0.3091733456,
-0.0871219411,
-0.0321457237,
0.1310968697,
0.0638351589,
0.5017228127,
0.2862283587,
-0.0681879222,
0.1368120909,
0.2154044062,
-0.2550726235,
-0.0859860331,
-0.6086393595,
0.6740531921,
-0.2848050296,
-0.7325125337,
-0.4072152078,
0.4704850018,
0.6036995649,
-0.2250907719,
0.5840005279,
0.499098748,
-0.0962846875,
-0.1985595673,
-0.7265794873,
-0.3495109081,
-0.6069256663,
0.2993039489,
-0.42046538,
-1.1890457869,
0.3798568547,
-0.1011452153,
0.2925102115,
-0.1970517784,
0.770978868,
0.2527026236,
1.0619835854,
0.6347052455,
0.2852738202,
0.772354722,
0.0179918818,
0.4796309471,
-0.7712385654,
-0.309351474,
-0.0575467236,
-0.2044155449,
-0.3814311028,
-0.2419195324,
0.5991665125,
-0.3489810228,
-0.2089257538,
-0.0090541011,
-0.2291837931,
0.6916626692,
0.7599136233,
0.1295750886,
0.2605134845,
-0.0527286455,
0.0512127914,
0.136339888,
-0.3139210343,
-0.6148354411,
0.91108042,
0.2183667272,
0.7910434604,
0.4161568582,
0.2832712531,
0.5562827587,
0.2006203979,
-1.1460777521,
0.7796312571,
0.0155562153,
-0.5986970067,
-0.3839796484,
-0.1617344171,
-1.095458746,
0.273719728,
-0.1274548173,
-0.9490987659,
-0.1460720301,
0.2961753607,
-0.7177749872,
0.3253780007,
-0.4365659356,
0.7491933703,
-0.4951738417,
-0.473210454,
-0.23696208,
-0.4709623158,
0.0568961836,
-0.0656573996,
0.0761979744,
-0.3311044574,
-0.0139082437,
0.5633506775,
-0.0085663246,
0.5193843246,
-0.3561367393,
0.0111349756,
0.3486038148,
0.2445456982,
0.7311295271,
0.1808635592,
-0.1028077975,
-0.1708194911,
-0.2294369489,
0.0121622644,
-0.6241089702,
0.7801127434,
-0.5105054975,
-0.7679765224,
-0.3386181593,
-0.5817281604,
-0.5510011315,
0.5892053246,
-0.0423342623,
0.5871451497,
-0.460515976,
0.252196461,
0.7722676396,
-0.3307088315,
0.3735648096,
0.8032459021,
-0.5393679738,
-0.3299122155,
0.5714377761,
-0.2324171513,
-0.0713676214,
0.4442296624,
0.328985244,
-0.6155155301,
-0.9446450472,
-0.3867479563,
0.3017852604,
-0.8201553226,
-0.0905464068,
-1.0294715166,
0.2379170358,
-0.4799471498,
-0.366388768,
-0.1162348539,
-0.0533406883,
-0.1559753716,
-0.0871421322,
0.5411328077,
0.5341719985,
0.2627304494,
0.8827579618,
-0.7176986933,
0.1869200319,
0.3125183582,
0.6349497437,
-0.0964494795,
-0.5565059781,
-0.1510997266,
-0.3103712499,
-0.1932914555,
-0.334813118,
0.3947100043,
0.187222138,
0.7796437144,
0.8063929677,
0.1071074903,
0.3806415498,
-0.7696167827,
0.6382004023,
0.2637278736,
-0.5082002282,
0.5854982138,
-0.6054353118,
0.3914781213,
0.9289617538,
0.2530229092,
-0.7074160576,
0.0525610931,
-0.4518942833,
-0.9498662353,
0.8428885937,
-0.3573974371,
0.2525037527,
0.1570254862,
0.3792801797,
0.3910709023,
0.0700673684,
-0.5910579562,
-0.236411497,
0.363978833,
-0.2281285375,
-0.26041466,
-0.4903482199,
-0.0298684072,
0.1830766648,
0.7830145955,
-0.2282045633,
0.225676015,
-0.1653123498,
-0.0240326412,
-0.4254940748,
0.3750991225,
0.4387527704,
0.8345963955,
-0.2780694962,
0.1330451518,
0.0163209513,
-0.3943140507,
0.2112661451,
-0.0470130891,
-0.3075875342,
-0.156785503,
-0.1955649853,
1.1455031633,
0.1079090312,
-0.9336779714,
0.560649395,
-0.5458286405,
0.2144656628,
-0.5333900452,
0.4237048924,
-0.0601968281,
0.3908602595,
0.2064211518,
-0.0059923287,
0.3522334993,
-0.4836589396,
0.0904725417,
0.4949007034,
-0.9074379802,
-0.2200098336,
0.4012389183,
0.3064292669,
-0.6441088915,
0.5464870334,
-0.1201553866,
-0.2202624083,
0.0364054441,
0.6986091733,
1.1974328756,
-0.0772341192,
0.04610347,
0.3617641032,
-0.1427039057,
-0.1395654529,
0.2486883998,
-0.1298842877,
-0.5621544123,
-0.2940448821,
-0.5346210599,
-0.5705158114,
0.1643920988,
-0.4848025739,
0.4372993708,
-0.368701756,
-0.3172791898,
0.020403808,
-0.3157936335,
-0.3338068724,
-0.2204235047,
0.2752071917,
0.7480288148,
-0.5612774491,
0.5288504958,
0.8211182356,
0.136924997,
-0.3901894391,
0.0645102113,
0.1378111392,
-0.7553263903,
0.2409209609,
0.3924180269,
-0.3539333642,
-0.0279943999,
-0.3760481179,
-0.9295698404,
1.0163636208,
0.2757317722,
-0.7560257912,
0.0781486034,
-0.1241097599,
0.2479043901,
-0.4969255626,
0.3028468788,
0.2205322236,
0.5019476414,
0.3879909813,
-0.646410346,
0.2580814362,
-0.0589327104,
0.0972138867,
0.2790226042,
-0.5748479962,
0.4897931814,
-0.3787708282,
-0.1494292319,
-0.0558122545,
0.7683885694,
0.699490428,
0.4895464778,
0.7730811238,
0.0990002453,
0.6505872607,
0.2117168754,
0.9174358249,
-0.4037033319,
-0.0993746445,
1.1581567526,
-0.5437598228,
0.461743474,
0.5502800941,
-0.1250570863,
0.5865808725,
0.7062838078,
0.1745172888,
0.6767923236,
0.0769918188,
-0.4883352518,
-0.4357451797,
-0.2422320098,
0.0748125464,
0.3355953693,
0.5042492747,
-0.1722141504,
-0.0935427696,
0.0824309662,
0.0735232607,
-0.0328522101,
-0.3102454841,
1.1131812334,
-0.0514433533,
-1.2336819172,
0.2156190723,
0.0943437889,
0.7749430537,
-0.8619446158,
0.0080028949,
0.0239791758,
0.347876966,
0.0521889217,
-0.7426452041,
-0.1851004064,
0.0508903824,
-0.2094076723,
-0.3325565159,
0.9154413939,
-0.3679082394,
-0.3722471595,
0.06502112,
0.5153968334,
0.1250019968,
-0.2683113515,
-0.6585964561,
0.068865113,
0.0988114178,
-0.2598914206,
0.3106224537,
0.520160675,
-0.1941909045,
0.879306674,
0.5898810625,
-0.1047639623,
-0.2889349461,
0.1478909552,
0.7216339111,
-0.6252734661,
-0.9755764008,
-0.965598464,
0.3061113656,
0.1377100497,
-0.2358772755,
0.7184042931,
0.6955958009,
0.4731406868,
0.1987560391,
0.9096345901,
0.1535239518,
0.4022636116,
-0.5376002192,
0.1921343356,
-0.3522942066,
0.6481735706,
0.0454071388,
-0.9564340711,
-0.2633168399,
0.418912828,
-0.6286310554,
0.2467269301,
0.3655816019,
0.9067188501,
-0.3255425692,
0.1857020408,
0.1987784207,
-0.0835335627,
0.6183133721,
0.3063873947,
1.1233625412,
0.1477775872,
0.3441486359,
0.1510658264,
-0.2288166881,
-0.6475840807,
-0.9007253051,
-0.7543372512,
-0.5564232469,
-0.280436337,
-0.2396636456,
0.1659618914,
1.3540040255,
0.5584419966,
-0.8472235203,
-0.4323753417,
-0.2322765887,
0.0309171062,
0.0027695312,
-0.1617678404,
0.3610927761,
-0.4449360371,
-0.4135768414,
0.5016150475,
0.5783341527,
0.2018215656,
-0.2548547089,
-0.2824150622,
-0.1036880836,
0.1384678781,
0.7009420991,
-0.006350134,
-0.7170342207,
-0.1148887575,
0.1326323003,
-0.0171031579,
0.0635339096,
1.0778859854,
-0.5165748596,
0.4473348856,
0.3632455766,
0.5388609171,
0.5891057849,
-0.0904570669,
0.4947235286,
-0.5207923055,
-0.1150348857,
0.3504128754,
0.3788671196,
0.3070938587,
-0.4437382221,
0.3677393496,
-0.3906707168,
-0.6028510928,
-0.9864853024,
0.2791637778,
-1.2000836134,
-0.5938614607,
1.7488025427,
-0.2315803915,
-0.0273593608,
-0.2834687531,
-0.5121216178,
-0.1217031926,
-0.8041191101,
0.8118548393,
0.3667526841,
-0.5191449523,
0.0249901358,
-0.1078784615,
0.4151223898,
0.2270590216,
-0.6493151188,
0.5586093068,
0.695070684,
0.0803444162,
-0.1200817004,
1.0059330463,
0.1178194806,
0.091519922,
-0.4124704897,
-0.3440673947,
-0.0904220045,
-0.5570281148,
-0.3052734137,
-0.0938371569,
0.4207735956,
0.3597937822
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03987v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03987v1
|
Cost-Effective In-Context Learning for Entity Resolution: A Design Space Exploration
| 2023-12-07T02:09:27 | 2023-12-07T02:09:27 |
Meihao Fan, Xiaoyue Han, Ju Fan, Chengliang Chai, Nan Tang, Guoliang Li, Xiaoyong Du
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Entity resolution (ER) is an important data integration task with a wide
spectrum of applications. The state-of-the-art solutions on ER rely on
pre-trained language models (PLMs), which require fine-tuning on a lot of
labeled matching/non-matching entity pairs. Recently, large languages models
(LLMs), such as GPT-4, have shown the ability to perform many tasks without
tuning model parameters, which is known as in-context learning (ICL) that
facilitates effective learning from a few labeled input context demonstrations.
However, existing ICL approaches to ER typically necessitate providing a task
description and a set of demonstrations for each entity pair and thus have
limitations on the monetary cost of interfacing LLMs. To address the problem,
in this paper, we provide a comprehensive study to investigate how to develop a
cost-effective batch prompting approach to ER. We introduce a framework BATCHER
consisting of demonstration selection and question batching and explore
different design choices that support batch prompting for ER. We also devise a
covering-based demonstration selection strategy that achieves an effective
balance between matching accuracy and monetary cost. We conduct a thorough
evaluation to explore the design space and evaluate our proposed strategies.
Through extensive experiments, we find that batch prompting is very
cost-effective for ER, compared with not only PLM-based methods fine-tuned with
extensive labeled data but also LLM-based methods with manually designed
prompting. We also provide guidance for selecting appropriate design choices
for batch prompting.
|
[
-0.9209952354,
-0.6448932886,
0.6013883352,
0.1434846222,
-0.454773277,
-0.0793943852,
-0.3865168989,
-0.5726395845,
-0.0604737774,
0.4850527048,
-0.5608136058,
-0.4178931117,
-0.0720545948,
0.15226008,
-0.1018458009,
0.8011602759,
-0.6158106327,
-0.2322289199,
-0.3386413455,
-0.1768710315,
-0.7402652502,
-0.3536283374,
-1.1916227341,
-0.1551184654,
0.3438628316,
0.8351722956,
-0.0827525035,
0.7766900659,
0.1948436052,
0.2426274568,
0.1647075117,
0.4777102172,
-0.2897420228,
0.2290220112,
-0.2592642605,
-0.3964062333,
-0.2696025074,
-0.0274035428,
0.6118296981,
0.6929572821,
-0.2610040307,
0.2439606786,
0.4189911783,
0.6439572573,
-0.474395901,
0.2395181507,
-0.664409399,
0.0779173374,
-0.2395008206,
-0.2004933804,
-0.7721076012,
0.1489771456,
0.1605051011,
-0.7853421569,
0.3640834093,
0.4782486558,
1.025894165,
0.4514875114,
-0.3123212457,
-0.4906520545,
-0.7549166083,
0.8590079546,
-0.40651232,
0.5065625906,
0.255432874,
0.1715821624,
-0.2054334879,
-0.8530393839,
-0.4153254926,
-0.1226288006,
-0.0737649724,
-0.0592169166,
-0.2008613944,
0.1913544089,
0.4768816233,
0.2088660002,
-0.5031684041,
0.3245256245,
-0.1233590543,
-0.0582389012,
0.1654295176,
-0.0017511444,
0.0111274412,
0.2572947145,
-0.7674873471,
-0.1189570725,
-0.8948199153,
0.0472687483,
-0.0133429691,
0.3369984925,
0.2550073266,
0.383205682,
-0.0851929858,
0.7753525376,
0.5158492327,
0.1732100546,
-0.0949111134,
-0.130948931,
-0.5465283394,
0.1475601941,
0.3567539454,
0.3483783603,
0.0279665403,
-0.03041205,
-0.627905786,
-0.3319460452,
0.4328868985,
-0.9958367348,
-0.0358722992,
0.2401209176,
-0.3111748695,
0.1848385334,
-0.2869360149,
-0.9506779313,
-0.2027383298,
-0.6986422539,
0.7542519569,
-0.4259535372,
0.0816083625,
-0.1443594545,
0.2088002115,
0.0790918916,
0.5529881716,
-0.8526601791,
0.4097288251,
0.2905620635,
0.9453988075,
0.1516048759,
-0.0685553849,
-0.7798252702,
0.2425351292,
-0.4714347124,
0.8416998386,
-0.1107645407,
-0.4790324569,
-0.2248679549,
-0.191305846,
0.0459803306,
-0.7969524264,
0.3843485415,
-0.7214463949,
0.2073771656,
-0.5392863154,
-0.7751461864,
-0.1899506897,
0.2407341301,
-0.7527645826,
0.7323121428,
0.1615377069,
-0.5090515614,
0.9780391455,
-0.8312962055,
-0.215485543,
0.364239186,
-0.4474564493,
-0.431176126,
-0.1489727348,
0.6470166445,
0.5628140569,
-0.2923234403,
0.3296314776,
0.0682160854,
-0.4655528069,
-0.2260624021,
-0.2979106307,
0.2248372734,
0.4753745794,
-0.7955539823,
0.2505012751,
-0.5984681845,
-0.0918983966,
-0.0255317278,
-0.3971241117,
-0.3566005826,
-0.0273275264,
-0.179053396,
0.090391703,
-0.0568017438,
-0.2225567847,
-0.0290351771,
-0.2857756615,
0.1392652243,
0.844655931,
0.105250515,
0.6917691827,
-0.3076256514,
0.4474819899,
0.0800737813,
-0.0506530926,
-0.3505278826,
-0.2737466693,
-0.7502680421,
-0.6378595233,
0.2124120444,
0.1736186296,
-0.7916052341,
0.1090931594,
-0.0916714072,
-0.2553138137,
-0.2286823839,
0.112163417,
0.356546551,
0.9567492604,
0.67356354,
-0.1831366122,
-0.5147659183,
-0.8797309995,
-0.3473704755,
-0.1469170153,
-0.2970010638,
0.5212649107,
0.2924109399,
0.2681397796,
1.0609797239,
-0.0939203575,
-0.5151790977,
-0.0802596062,
0.1671340168,
0.0718045756,
0.408935219,
0.5480721593,
-0.8627718687,
-0.5520282388,
-0.1445989907,
-0.5154718757,
-0.0968198553,
-0.3668295741,
0.0890298262,
0.4061645269,
0.5814301968,
-0.4290677309,
0.3916564286,
0.3091228604,
-0.0454906113,
0.2712801695,
-0.4030764401,
0.3473528624,
-1.0767979622,
0.0639257506,
0.3435395658,
-0.1399670839,
-0.5120213628,
0.072558336,
0.3525719345,
-0.2630190551,
-0.529387176,
0.6678747535,
-0.8752770424,
-0.0372669324,
-0.1608664393,
0.1605783701,
0.0997471064,
0.5938104391,
0.1527628899,
1.0797170401,
0.2532195151,
-0.9340524673,
0.132624492,
-0.0222577546,
-0.4343498051,
0.8455520272,
-0.5062913299,
0.1695193946,
-0.193969354,
0.5975026488,
-0.8032605052,
-0.2495241463,
0.3210825026,
0.1412769556,
0.7926830649,
-0.4809989333,
-0.3729662895,
-0.2074665427,
0.0823205933,
0.4364331961,
0.3360482156,
-1.1557768583,
0.6278703213,
0.2737210989,
-0.0818406641,
-0.5235905051,
-0.534300983,
0.0782354102,
-0.7097808123,
-0.3939711452,
0.6612727046,
0.0529555269,
-0.1602290422,
0.0160061922,
-0.4099160731,
0.1065533012,
-0.1099999174,
0.1858549416,
0.37986812,
-0.3385932744,
0.352443397,
0.0676890388,
0.0122605097,
0.0968754515,
-0.7522677779,
0.4298899174,
-0.3074483573,
-0.5768398046,
-0.3911184669,
0.3351305127,
0.3480130434,
-0.3295003772,
0.6617244482,
0.1858002692,
-0.8475442529,
-0.4382213652,
-0.7588613033,
-0.2203357667,
-0.4982928038,
0.3093887269,
-0.7110120058,
-0.7543060184,
0.322655946,
-0.429525882,
0.3837895095,
0.0010658855,
0.385245949,
-0.0488589965,
0.6999409199,
0.2953597307,
0.0496665798,
0.5511161089,
-0.1502404809,
0.2572799921,
-0.7713868618,
-0.2202547044,
-0.415723443,
-0.3299060762,
-0.1297469437,
-0.5228436589,
0.3827230632,
0.2880475521,
-0.408539474,
0.4282176495,
-0.4401093423,
0.6368852854,
0.5696778297,
0.2458432913,
0.1175988317,
0.1974615455,
-0.1431035697,
-0.0032173668,
-0.5711621046,
-0.6702958345,
0.8769669533,
0.4013373256,
0.7125591636,
0.1924151182,
0.8883457184,
-0.04437856,
0.4266965985,
-0.722538352,
0.5435527563,
0.1990481019,
-0.3970013857,
-0.6754533052,
-0.5293731093,
-0.8495864868,
0.2198034674,
0.1228640079,
-0.8331145048,
0.4600585103,
0.6154993176,
-0.526748538,
0.5538133979,
-0.7669830322,
0.7790460587,
-0.0960240588,
-0.4217532575,
-0.1747397631,
-0.3896012902,
0.0729108676,
-0.2047383785,
0.1989434361,
0.2098291218,
-0.1675966233,
0.5816321373,
-0.2161281258,
0.7206712961,
-0.3997129798,
-0.2527806759,
0.2079402506,
0.0905743465,
0.8798212409,
0.2424979061,
0.015138316,
-0.2567290664,
-0.4667745531,
-0.3489433229,
-0.5739719868,
0.8455517888,
-0.2393156737,
-0.6313409805,
0.0431376956,
-0.422503531,
-0.4465568364,
0.1711069643,
0.4052968919,
0.7575187087,
-0.0889200419,
-0.049740281,
1.1852687597,
-0.2353975028,
0.5065997839,
0.2242144346,
-0.0827304944,
-0.3132358491,
0.7581061721,
0.1450205445,
0.2861775458,
0.5184077621,
-0.0683705136,
-0.5667392612,
-0.4723389745,
-0.9203332067,
0.0101457154,
-0.8141196966,
-0.2845428884,
-0.5795411468,
0.2130640745,
-0.077795662,
-0.273676604,
-0.3596715927,
-0.0411124527,
-0.5636921525,
-0.1483743638,
0.2131718546,
0.402292788,
0.1121550649,
-0.0203762297,
-0.5602284074,
-0.0164486691,
0.3971577287,
0.5308176875,
0.1228962913,
-0.4940270782,
-0.2882401645,
0.0015896233,
-0.2946052253,
-0.82708323,
0.3132201433,
0.222275719,
0.5830455422,
0.5164095759,
0.366884619,
1.0206187963,
-0.6420688629,
0.5816510916,
-0.040258795,
-1.0181984901,
0.6503264308,
-0.0362189561,
-0.1653608829,
0.4312539399,
0.467569232,
-0.4348954558,
-0.1143560633,
-0.5725646019,
-1.2180767059,
0.6578142643,
-0.1645542979,
-0.0609302297,
-0.178251043,
0.5513563752,
-0.0390341282,
0.0432943031,
-0.3993611336,
-0.200419724,
0.0332456529,
0.0100449519,
0.0389135033,
-0.073137328,
-0.1613077074,
0.1377577186,
0.6872546673,
-0.2628484666,
0.2573845088,
0.3034978807,
-0.2982729673,
-0.2959363759,
0.4013912976,
0.7407836914,
0.5991713405,
-0.0728649646,
0.151649639,
0.4948768616,
-0.0358198136,
0.2363816649,
0.1343290955,
0.0742401108,
-0.0126176085,
0.010751999,
1.0583577156,
0.289686501,
-0.6151493788,
0.383179605,
-0.0118259797,
-0.3355773985,
-0.2774594724,
-0.1505162567,
0.0484777056,
0.3529221714,
0.3225618899,
-0.0474409871,
0.1995198578,
-0.2146144956,
0.3222843111,
0.3054710329,
-0.3839475214,
0.1762336493,
0.8825112581,
0.1734992862,
-0.1614005417,
1.0362179279,
-0.2490926236,
-0.2672511935,
0.614646256,
0.6865848899,
0.4934194088,
-0.173588559,
0.0415665768,
0.3822333813,
0.2254330963,
-0.1613132209,
0.022802636,
-0.1781694442,
-0.5526691079,
-0.5863676667,
-0.2136225253,
-0.5682062507,
0.2608685195,
-0.8568822742,
0.4888424277,
-0.4116990864,
-0.0918467045,
-0.3067843914,
0.0118236216,
-0.8750646114,
0.3174961805,
0.1236626431,
1.1111619473,
-0.5139872432,
0.5615679622,
0.8357852697,
-0.5473230481,
-1.1056745052,
0.0139893489,
-0.0296488516,
-0.4424758852,
0.6509465575,
0.3533800542,
0.1798955947,
0.3786618114,
-0.2690356672,
-0.6234306693,
1.2099056244,
0.5278205872,
-0.8027153611,
-0.1908038557,
-0.2344708145,
0.1958622485,
-0.3833982348,
0.1335055232,
0.2476921529,
0.39786309,
0.0362955704,
-0.8298950195,
0.3296571076,
0.066774942,
0.0635896027,
0.5472824574,
-0.4532115459,
0.6581586599,
-0.4109636545,
-0.5849735737,
-0.1680045873,
0.7848139405,
0.5782247186,
0.4611395299,
0.9650306106,
0.4086169899,
0.8553627729,
-0.0050450484,
0.8038070202,
-0.0271643065,
0.4262251556,
1.1087290049,
-0.5368222594,
0.6926235557,
0.8677273989,
-0.1497452408,
0.2459983081,
1.1246623993,
0.0642381161,
0.4841634631,
0.482314676,
-0.6476785541,
-0.1395624429,
0.0044743735,
-0.1569160074,
-0.2054700702,
0.512744844,
-0.3014389575,
-0.1713863909,
0.263284713,
-0.2057110816,
-0.0502294265,
-0.2476404756,
0.7319227457,
0.0299956352,
-0.7261235714,
0.2606514692,
-0.2326434106,
0.4364865124,
-0.263995707,
-0.2689504325,
-0.3187963068,
0.0761747956,
-0.0045011993,
-0.4786392152,
0.1025433615,
-0.0143921115,
-0.1906420141,
-0.4255436957,
0.4114069641,
-0.4625701904,
0.1095251963,
0.1542965919,
0.3078900278,
0.2573030591,
-0.2844530642,
-0.3216692507,
-0.2834747732,
-0.1337590814,
-0.4258808196,
0.5610318184,
0.5275041461,
-0.3369722366,
0.705272913,
0.5811150074,
0.0180769581,
-0.0938229486,
0.0749567151,
0.7783657312,
-0.3089553118,
-0.4012004137,
-0.7025042772,
0.5356001854,
-0.0660492107,
-0.0256280657,
0.2042355984,
0.5397047997,
1.3041805029,
-0.1053057313,
0.6020655036,
-0.0214802306,
0.3406594694,
-0.8408858776,
0.4206675887,
-0.6066080332,
0.6278467774,
-0.241070807,
-0.8154327869,
-0.3042339683,
0.6206384897,
-0.0920704529,
0.1782240272,
0.6806387901,
0.8266681433,
-0.2201831043,
-0.0059783747,
0.3616547585,
-0.361115247,
0.5896375179,
0.4692619741,
0.815104723,
-0.0285972953,
0.5340030193,
-0.3553112149,
-0.4170748293,
-0.1391787827,
-1.0807232857,
-0.7336246967,
-0.7360736132,
-0.3509534001,
-0.3068653047,
-0.0074243206,
1.4786931276,
0.7868824005,
-0.6930049658,
-0.0940751061,
-0.1336094439,
-0.1556155384,
-0.4881668985,
-0.2001428008,
0.4586654007,
-0.6207773089,
-0.9418575168,
0.5190734267,
0.1156771854,
0.1584431827,
0.0594481193,
0.0318521298,
0.214768827,
-0.0935864598,
0.4308120906,
0.3554059863,
-0.8836004734,
-0.2539770305,
-0.0084071979,
0.0690077543,
0.0479514934,
1.0285665989,
-0.8105548024,
0.39966169,
0.0342124254,
0.9456208944,
0.5230294466,
0.0064249891,
0.6910108328,
-1.0057954788,
-0.1566251069,
0.1745585948,
0.5907464027,
0.2212370932,
-0.6412456036,
0.4970184565,
-0.0828523934,
-0.705726862,
-0.7363182306,
0.2085979879,
-0.6002913117,
-0.1225959733,
0.7389841676,
-0.3783890009,
0.0818893909,
-0.1428705156,
-0.4548672736,
0.3785860538,
-0.513092041,
0.5429366231,
0.6304935217,
-0.5040973425,
-0.4040527344,
-0.5440508723,
0.4021244645,
0.3306932151,
-0.7211849689,
0.0648302585,
0.5523905158,
0.206026122,
-0.0434523709,
0.5541635752,
0.1063711867,
0.1680273563,
-0.2417745888,
0.3016846478,
-0.0450132117,
-0.3932601213,
-0.409458667,
0.1004709303,
0.3171285391,
-0.4469243884
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07551v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07551v1
|
Language Model Alignment with Elastic Reset
| 2023-12-06T22:53:34 | 2023-12-06T22:53:34 |
Michael Noukhovitch, Samuel Lavoie, Florian Strub, Aaron Courville
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Finetuning language models with reinforcement learning (RL), e.g. from human
feedback (HF), is a prominent method for alignment. But optimizing against a
reward model can improve on reward while degrading performance in other areas,
a phenomenon known as reward hacking, alignment tax, or language drift. First,
we argue that commonly-used test metrics are insufficient and instead measure
how different algorithms tradeoff between reward and drift. The standard method
modified the reward with a Kullback-Lieber (KL) penalty between the online and
initial model. We propose Elastic Reset, a new algorithm that achieves higher
reward with less drift without explicitly modifying the training objective. We
periodically reset the online model to an exponentially moving average (EMA) of
itself, then reset the EMA model to the initial model. Through the use of an
EMA, our model recovers quickly after resets and achieves higher reward with
less drift in the same number of steps. We demonstrate that fine-tuning
language models with Elastic Reset leads to state-of-the-art performance on a
small scale pivot-translation benchmark, outperforms all baselines in a
medium-scale RLHF-like IMDB mock sentiment task and leads to a more performant
and more aligned technical QA chatbot with LLaMA-7B. Code available at
github.com/mnoukhov/elastic-reset.
|
[
-0.1485680789,
-0.6103987098,
0.2770432234,
-0.1831355095,
-0.0775030553,
0.3599048555,
-0.4986944199,
-0.3617340326,
0.3290733993,
0.4193933606,
-0.8768537641,
-0.1512577832,
-0.3373738825,
-0.0335745774,
-0.3514083028,
1.3102496862,
-0.0074777901,
-0.1777333319,
-0.1316526532,
-0.5215241313,
-0.5262842178,
-0.1176034659,
-0.6765794754,
-0.5522916913,
0.4999406636,
0.2214104384,
0.5611174107,
0.9075047374,
0.4713711143,
0.2401254624,
-0.0152317323,
0.0492057204,
-0.7704392672,
0.154540211,
-0.00415897,
-0.5695451498,
-0.3596508801,
-0.1850795746,
0.5941045284,
0.4213079214,
-0.6121991873,
0.2573833466,
0.0052675689,
0.7331071496,
-0.6627334952,
-0.0925067663,
-0.6292228699,
-0.2192958295,
-0.0542074703,
-0.3668071628,
-0.4288125038,
-0.509303987,
-0.2747348547,
-0.5989356041,
-0.1617151648,
0.1057470888,
1.1716649532,
0.7439288497,
-0.1146889701,
-0.0820618793,
-0.8698558807,
0.7356331944,
-0.8871677518,
0.4911802709,
0.0955063403,
0.2425366789,
-0.1396604329,
-0.2294530869,
-0.5888233781,
-0.2273290604,
0.3177225292,
0.0379783288,
0.0148862572,
-0.1746317595,
0.2153656632,
0.2649499178,
-0.4203884006,
0.5414933562,
-0.4268285334,
-0.0434662998,
0.474055618,
0.3918942511,
0.2523491085,
0.2716056406,
-0.3536396325,
-0.3876152337,
-1.060005784,
0.4298297167,
0.6836559772,
0.5373653769,
0.0064102886,
0.392963171,
-0.2116874754,
0.5755979419,
0.2213051468,
-0.145487234,
0.3986719251,
-0.1142221615,
0.1463074237,
0.1859229058,
0.4477982819,
0.5819303989,
0.2647957802,
0.0202966649,
-0.5434333682,
0.1447974741,
0.3941906393,
-0.531251967,
-0.0549862571,
0.4716655612,
-0.3438130915,
-0.3024427295,
-0.0578117929,
-0.4210932255,
-0.4404976964,
-0.4666042924,
0.243645981,
-0.3426175714,
-0.4524477422,
0.1567416787,
0.0180472042,
0.4591313303,
0.3310697079,
-1.0235688686,
0.4732579291,
1.0287766457,
0.6546812654,
-0.0010730854,
-0.4291644692,
-0.7064119577,
-0.1779305637,
-0.1850376576,
0.7193108797,
-0.3880005479,
0.1642760038,
0.2155726254,
0.0121953711,
0.0657792836,
-0.4684279561,
0.3005945086,
-0.5000541806,
0.4299497008,
-0.0445564389,
-0.6765693426,
0.0493741333,
0.3341258168,
-0.6311878562,
1.1396306753,
-0.1352507174,
-0.4448394775,
0.3245589733,
-0.4023736715,
-0.161766395,
0.0105210254,
0.0526525974,
-0.5537288785,
0.0594592132,
0.0012796492,
0.0474013239,
-0.2623049617,
0.1861036718,
-0.3183795214,
-0.6030647159,
0.0874658972,
-0.0879390538,
0.6233685017,
0.1340637356,
-0.4926764369,
0.0380611159,
-0.5769099593,
0.1952821314,
0.0892011747,
-0.3969684541,
-0.3889680207,
0.2504350245,
0.1182866916,
0.2149733305,
0.1811078191,
-0.5945127606,
0.397672981,
-0.6439934373,
0.5881212354,
0.8830397129,
-0.3182787001,
0.3096144497,
-0.4703911543,
0.6920795441,
-0.1691752821,
-0.1183202937,
-0.2701661289,
-0.165831998,
-0.5609526634,
-0.2461799234,
0.6193339825,
0.7278003693,
-0.312015146,
0.4291730523,
-0.5114670396,
-0.4064653814,
-1.2084605694,
0.0501886718,
0.4504385591,
0.3557128608,
0.1744501442,
-0.2789915502,
-0.3695124686,
-0.8160225153,
-0.6071332693,
0.0416473523,
-0.1466990411,
0.3130969107,
0.3068704903,
-0.0744751096,
0.8384470344,
-0.2824169993,
-0.316380322,
-0.0857595578,
0.2307855487,
0.160955593,
0.5501796603,
0.2143268138,
-0.3611544073,
-0.302195549,
0.085335128,
-0.2241750509,
-0.387632519,
-0.2759598494,
0.1561895609,
0.4892319739,
0.3857990205,
-0.2615049779,
0.1067450494,
0.6135376096,
-0.3333513737,
0.1660621166,
-0.1375430077,
0.3498267233,
-0.9597091079,
0.1473045796,
-0.222871542,
-0.4222229123,
-0.4748324752,
0.0680448264,
0.2707112134,
-0.02129809,
-0.5054195523,
0.6923789978,
-0.3315008581,
-0.0131887672,
-0.5068804026,
0.4222117364,
-0.2072188705,
0.6905865073,
-0.2698585689,
0.6161376238,
-0.0483247302,
-0.476413995,
0.1673772782,
0.0905139893,
-0.1897376776,
0.6872871518,
-0.5875892639,
0.3876027465,
-0.1610729545,
0.2175486237,
-0.7911785841,
0.0577444695,
0.0690926164,
-0.3407050371,
0.3960053623,
-0.0054025617,
-0.294690609,
-0.0068075345,
-0.4742414057,
0.4970256388,
0.64164114,
-0.5971530676,
0.395252198,
0.4882912338,
-0.1248409078,
-0.607288301,
-0.3906094134,
-0.0907140002,
-0.3597493172,
-0.4371392727,
0.5442234278,
0.1174062863,
-0.1349846125,
0.1399844736,
0.0120886443,
0.1725599468,
0.349939853,
0.0284432862,
0.1514166296,
-0.1550114006,
0.2456101626,
-0.1754831225,
-0.0896979943,
-0.2398753911,
-0.275519222,
0.81013906,
-0.4249460101,
-0.211987108,
-0.4489895105,
0.068701461,
0.4343243837,
-0.2532449365,
0.7362559438,
0.3552582562,
-0.5317652822,
0.0336723067,
-0.6543852091,
-0.4538841546,
-0.4183603525,
0.4486377239,
-0.1778141558,
-0.9621286988,
0.7238794565,
-0.0097799879,
0.2318638861,
0.3592998981,
0.7286143303,
-0.1230047643,
1.2742593288,
0.984616518,
-0.1598102301,
0.6614125371,
0.2223267704,
0.3325559199,
-0.872431159,
-0.0938951299,
-0.6768276691,
-0.6179568768,
-0.742788136,
0.1820668578,
-0.040204145,
0.0240854118,
-0.3187580407,
0.4689587355,
-0.4142138958,
0.7518818974,
0.4658778608,
-0.06682235,
0.2355637848,
-0.2489024401,
0.1984741092,
-0.0975805148,
-0.605961144,
-0.5498698354,
0.8917686939,
0.4368754923,
0.7792622447,
-0.0295452569,
0.8230705857,
0.0451061912,
0.3436949253,
-0.5192091465,
0.1543717682,
0.1061078385,
-0.3566753566,
-0.3791097105,
-0.4401400685,
-0.9588105679,
-0.0561426207,
-0.1061201021,
-0.9137682915,
-0.0967854261,
0.4191530645,
-0.439607352,
0.1553450674,
-0.5630527139,
0.8978586793,
-0.311673224,
-0.206762895,
-0.366848886,
-0.5437345505,
0.3342631757,
0.0248086061,
0.2587035298,
-0.4405344427,
0.0159143806,
0.6896934509,
-0.3642703295,
0.7163645625,
-0.1508060843,
-0.1970209479,
-0.2078805119,
0.2067127377,
0.7086106539,
-0.2312177718,
0.2742129564,
-0.0181031041,
0.217757225,
-0.490821898,
-0.7664346099,
0.6962720156,
-0.6138757467,
-0.4454395175,
-0.3149823546,
-0.6549122334,
-0.0190333612,
0.1589879543,
-0.0353717729,
0.2207827419,
-0.0853417739,
0.0776179209,
0.5855290294,
-0.1882660985,
0.1936140805,
0.6136643291,
-0.2343835831,
-0.3115465045,
1.0846889019,
-0.1243634075,
0.4453845024,
0.3120467067,
0.1153523475,
-0.2548838854,
-0.0120851081,
-0.4474695325,
0.2992760241,
-0.3294562399,
-0.321834892,
-0.2937597632,
0.1327222884,
-0.3529897928,
-0.2968853414,
-0.7433114052,
-0.5854896903,
0.0585064217,
0.1215924174,
0.4138278365,
0.5227999687,
0.1551249921,
0.1962849647,
-0.7097102404,
-0.0420562215,
-0.2825949192,
0.6012455225,
-0.1457345039,
-0.7162902951,
-0.357367605,
0.2266777158,
-0.2573251128,
-0.7466112375,
0.4296786189,
0.2098198682,
0.3477066755,
0.1229326576,
-0.1292544305,
0.6214580536,
-0.6757907271,
0.4859957099,
0.1174823791,
-0.9519380331,
0.4205022156,
-0.364243865,
0.6017050147,
0.625153482,
0.0444699526,
-1.1389924288,
-0.6536244154,
-0.6984331012,
-1.0011614561,
0.6689024568,
-0.1300209463,
0.0853438005,
0.1576544344,
0.2929378152,
-0.0400341153,
0.339612782,
-0.8066883683,
-0.0136620738,
-0.0782691613,
-0.6705887914,
0.0947199613,
0.01673574,
-0.2743446231,
-0.0114943134,
0.859307766,
-0.3049587309,
0.2150259018,
-0.2747355998,
-0.265858829,
-0.4059356749,
0.2927353978,
0.8926907182,
0.5221674442,
-0.173464343,
-0.1274778992,
0.2202400267,
-0.1547732949,
0.2407026887,
-0.0482236966,
-0.2824289799,
-0.5895915031,
0.1144391596,
0.8133624792,
0.4975438416,
-0.9931069016,
0.2907428741,
-0.0560606606,
-0.0574186593,
-0.0780665725,
-0.0391481891,
0.1078091264,
0.2397542894,
0.0919189677,
-0.2379383743,
-0.2672090828,
-0.5938583016,
0.2132079154,
0.4132442474,
-0.3971968889,
-0.3618462384,
0.7220373154,
0.1544075459,
-0.8432378769,
0.8434731364,
-0.0902944803,
-0.7143175006,
0.6587293148,
0.6549591422,
0.889685154,
-0.2302301377,
0.0015579424,
0.2183707803,
0.4790835381,
-0.2965696752,
0.3928171396,
0.3089856207,
-0.7948121428,
-0.4566858411,
-0.3663361073,
-0.4702778757,
-0.1060564592,
-0.69799757,
0.3594982028,
-0.4042087495,
0.185539946,
-0.191940099,
-0.0595510267,
-0.5914027691,
-0.1078315303,
0.1223693937,
0.7591165304,
-0.919419229,
0.721180439,
0.6445838809,
-0.5355559587,
-0.8327650428,
-0.1798391044,
0.1617557108,
-0.7308347821,
0.4552436173,
0.3133229911,
-0.0971907303,
0.1573838592,
-0.5128850937,
-1.0660485029,
1.0562027693,
0.4228513241,
-0.7416574359,
0.1996333599,
-0.0425921977,
0.6739524603,
-0.4115277529,
0.3117865622,
0.7172766924,
0.2359568775,
-0.4143086374,
-1.0344026089,
0.1792991608,
-0.3009749949,
-0.1724215001,
0.8624534607,
-0.7531956434,
0.5116917491,
-0.0138206892,
-0.2557060122,
-0.0938075632,
0.4232430458,
0.2828590572,
-0.0036547414,
0.7088632584,
0.9821356535,
0.8894001245,
-0.2420936972,
0.9482142925,
-0.501057148,
0.5378777981,
1.0377153158,
-0.5744612813,
1.0720279217,
0.6138987541,
-0.0216851979,
0.4330962896,
0.5901207924,
0.0550692305,
0.5267053246,
0.2497092336,
0.2262732387,
-0.1281779855,
-0.1315459013,
-0.1341553777,
0.2317536771,
0.0353158005,
0.2126189619,
-0.1900320351,
0.0301566832,
-0.0171926264,
0.2382087409,
-0.1822238714,
0.7513713837,
-0.0773750842,
-0.9332879782,
0.7156822681,
0.0720811933,
0.5526487827,
-0.2680833042,
0.0269474648,
-0.4251851141,
0.4151275158,
-0.1565633714,
-0.3713171184,
0.2952136397,
-0.1049173921,
-0.1270011514,
-0.3519107699,
0.3558333516,
-0.7651844025,
-0.0866208449,
0.0769815445,
0.1451624185,
-0.002221497,
0.264896065,
-0.6605741382,
0.1746916473,
-0.0897276774,
-0.2343452871,
0.4621889293,
0.0154443113,
-0.1234390661,
0.851817131,
0.5155041218,
0.1174537092,
0.0845216885,
0.0696910545,
0.6180488467,
-0.750243485,
-0.6088727713,
-0.7611183524,
0.5215217471,
0.0957826748,
-0.4760819972,
0.3813401163,
0.4131137729,
1.1521795988,
0.1782637984,
0.2978748977,
0.1027729586,
0.6915994287,
-0.6733164787,
0.5069941282,
-0.6290249228,
0.3331092,
-0.0860810652,
-0.835945785,
-0.0800342187,
0.4205759168,
-0.0697004497,
-0.1492248029,
0.8079860806,
0.9141845703,
0.0242253374,
-0.0827039406,
-0.0127537549,
0.1882874221,
0.4190230966,
0.5817704797,
0.7912782431,
-0.5083645582,
0.4086083174,
-0.1780131012,
-0.1080515385,
-0.2402277887,
-1.0931755304,
-0.3143423796,
-0.4478315115,
-0.4874790311,
-0.4731465876,
0.2183872014,
1.2721400261,
0.3184552491,
-0.8204392791,
-0.4292925596,
0.0237282421,
0.221509099,
-0.6960237026,
-0.2130331397,
0.1302532703,
-0.5960887074,
-0.7796445489,
0.2702645957,
0.3591704667,
-0.2633881271,
-0.2757191062,
-0.2638802528,
-0.2570071518,
0.1002615243,
-0.0276659913,
0.731441617,
-0.8495397568,
-0.4847017229,
0.1310171932,
-0.2242359072,
0.135109067,
0.8598579764,
-0.8649209142,
0.2818371356,
0.4798032939,
1.186940074,
0.239164114,
0.1278594583,
0.9753391743,
-0.6894271374,
0.1096316725,
0.241511181,
0.3342460096,
0.2878949046,
-0.3773420155,
0.316555202,
-0.093701683,
-0.786324501,
-1.2611551285,
0.2898970842,
-0.588986814,
-0.0297803655,
0.8839121461,
0.1349805892,
-0.4237317443,
0.28431952,
0.0536317937,
0.1245200709,
-0.3920935392,
1.2112631798,
0.8521254063,
0.1598418206,
-0.2637681663,
-0.3663414717,
0.5885801911,
0.9659724832,
-0.7841154337,
0.163816154,
0.3895684481,
0.322465241,
-0.0109176533,
0.5706320405,
0.0364650562,
0.4466194808,
-0.4522902668,
0.493479073,
0.0075444281,
-0.2828836441,
-0.9122145772,
-0.154249683,
0.1842316985,
0.0148126818
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03912v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03912v2
|
Collaboration or Corporate Capture? Quantifying NLP's Reliance on Industry Artifacts and Contributions
| 2023-12-06T21:12:22 | 2024-06-22T15:27:04 |
Will Aitken, Mohamed Abdalla, Karen Rudie, Catherine Stinson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Impressive performance of pre-trained models has garnered public attention
and made news headlines in recent years. Almost always, these models are
produced by or in collaboration with industry. Using them is critical for
competing on natural language processing (NLP) benchmarks and correspondingly
to stay relevant in NLP research. We surveyed 100 papers published at EMNLP
2022 to determine the degree to which researchers rely on industry models,
other artifacts, and contributions to publish in prestigious NLP venues and
found that the ratio of their citation is at least three times greater than
what would be expected. Our work serves as a scaffold to enable future
researchers to more accurately address whether: 1) Collaboration with industry
is still collaboration in the absence of an alternative or 2) if NLP inquiry
has been captured by the motivations and research direction of private
corporations.
|
[
-0.570586741,
-0.3145758212,
0.4936277568,
0.3145711422,
0.160941273,
-0.0193791799,
0.0646319836,
-1.1043077707,
0.4856768548,
0.6716165543,
-0.3689754009,
-0.0780427679,
-0.55351758,
0.4449128509,
-0.4024447203,
0.7188435197,
0.1975571513,
-0.1134012714,
-0.5365746021,
-0.2723357081,
-0.3916137815,
-1.028775692,
-0.5915302038,
-0.2891785204,
0.7639463544,
-0.2792993486,
0.543520093,
0.4229286611,
0.7099171877,
0.2919386923,
-0.2568614781,
0.1041400954,
-0.0564919487,
-0.0371075645,
-0.2913873792,
-0.3284944892,
-0.4979664683,
0.4153732359,
0.3379316926,
1.0646249056,
0.0026702364,
0.4932134449,
0.4256159961,
0.470634371,
-0.6719250083,
0.1289280951,
-0.6680352688,
0.1656994671,
-0.1881023049,
-0.4319556355,
-0.6373977065,
-0.2209537625,
0.1382609159,
-0.4672753513,
0.1614297777,
0.2305134386,
0.833404839,
0.1866421551,
-0.1081549451,
-0.2649528384,
-0.9269281626,
0.9032605886,
-0.6086213589,
0.1724576205,
0.4611884952,
-0.1593035311,
-0.0106486166,
-1.2274484634,
-0.0464166068,
-0.0539961718,
-0.1602229923,
0.1057228819,
-0.3198657036,
-0.0242121257,
0.2182879597,
0.4007123411,
-0.3230932653,
0.2948810458,
-0.645604372,
-0.0920865089,
0.6055941582,
-0.1188852191,
0.2394824177,
0.1950060576,
-0.4087729454,
0.0143313613,
-0.6424686313,
-0.1158453599,
-0.1054355204,
0.1872995496,
0.2126222253,
0.6968459487,
0.0899799094,
0.6173426509,
-0.2266747206,
0.4396574199,
0.0771832988,
-0.538903594,
-0.3579737246,
0.26019907,
0.8187736273,
0.099426806,
-0.0841089189,
-0.4548872709,
-0.035442058,
-0.1375401467,
0.4566042423,
-0.3942351937,
-0.0608206652,
0.3016816676,
-0.2986219227,
-0.0749553889,
0.1459998637,
-0.5027761459,
-0.1348731071,
-0.4766973257,
0.2485540211,
0.351870209,
-0.2498316318,
0.0533938035,
-0.4440333545,
0.3139193356,
0.266882956,
-0.8642608523,
0.0222387966,
1.245506525,
1.1743574142,
0.0005998284,
-0.3387757242,
-0.5617346168,
0.2528343797,
-0.7399669886,
0.8075732589,
-0.1088052168,
-0.2667329907,
0.2918300629,
-0.0678560063,
-0.098919563,
-0.6261296868,
0.5349952579,
-0.5374442339,
0.2503356934,
-0.6519802809,
-0.5301584005,
-0.1194504797,
0.3658156991,
-0.9134957194,
0.6530615091,
-0.2021100819,
-0.8571449518,
0.7200585604,
-0.6750942469,
0.0678557456,
0.3165024221,
-0.2930647135,
-0.3094173968,
0.2263502926,
0.067346327,
0.3358305693,
-0.2117573917,
0.3528548181,
-0.6646918058,
-0.1186174676,
0.3978209198,
-0.1042202339,
1.0366760492,
0.1751662493,
-0.0129096145,
-0.2257982343,
-0.6425258517,
-0.1245482937,
-0.1708054245,
-0.2581349909,
-0.5187888741,
-0.0448314212,
0.0237017795,
0.3952912092,
0.2260201126,
-0.5416705608,
-0.0420741774,
-0.2856905162,
0.4331824481,
0.3686795533,
0.1487849653,
0.4572181404,
-0.4418502748,
0.5834512115,
-0.622089386,
0.0340792686,
0.0620547794,
-0.5629937053,
-0.6578438282,
-0.1376500577,
0.5094764233,
-0.0558336787,
-0.3070654571,
0.4497931004,
-0.1183607951,
-0.502219677,
-0.5755897164,
-0.2101339102,
-0.0771281049,
0.3614902496,
0.2314884663,
-0.72126472,
-0.7909870744,
-0.6512396336,
-0.5833565593,
-0.0987500995,
-0.3831993937,
0.0778532997,
0.444139719,
0.1531695575,
1.3397048712,
-0.2210332453,
-0.8439311385,
-0.3180697262,
0.6496781707,
0.2769874334,
0.6395336986,
0.6744167805,
-0.5704219937,
-0.3592932522,
-0.2205274403,
-1.1985582113,
-0.0176855288,
-0.1051395237,
-0.2177777588,
0.2259546071,
0.8238361478,
-0.4168367684,
0.2830119133,
0.782984674,
-0.2232680917,
0.3687954545,
0.0412294343,
0.021720672,
-0.9006504416,
0.6508426666,
-0.1604633182,
-0.0324289091,
-0.4922600389,
-0.017502768,
-0.34661901,
-0.3844673932,
-0.3271549046,
0.1993750185,
-0.6926847696,
-0.3490599692,
-0.1643776596,
0.1697200835,
0.3131090105,
0.2196878046,
0.3618959188,
0.4896570444,
0.0877722055,
-0.6230185032,
-0.0356764644,
0.4059394002,
-0.4612624943,
0.3867481351,
-0.9023731351,
0.3971767426,
0.307356298,
0.3415890634,
-0.4956837296,
-0.0782878101,
-0.2011490315,
-0.5348932147,
0.0956882685,
-0.1813588887,
-0.6243277788,
-0.2533147335,
-0.1742299646,
0.0135725727,
0.2627341747,
-0.4115175903,
0.759999454,
0.605814755,
-0.1947986037,
-0.5535898209,
-1.3795427084,
0.3534088433,
-0.2278512865,
-0.7489464879,
0.3918117285,
0.2274140418,
-0.2582347095,
0.0932633057,
-0.0353412591,
-0.1387822926,
0.2264560908,
0.0777239576,
0.1976438314,
-0.3500446677,
-0.2260947824,
-0.4909316003,
-0.1242051274,
0.6566995382,
-0.0851171762,
0.5299835801,
0.0524261408,
-0.2324566543,
-0.6528599858,
0.4576345682,
0.3285162449,
-0.5446028709,
0.9245398045,
0.3896660507,
-0.1796268672,
-0.1312533021,
-0.4702760279,
-0.1430768967,
-0.5196298957,
0.2645956576,
0.1341393143,
-0.8933824301,
0.4992463589,
-0.2107468396,
0.3462500274,
0.6130403876,
0.1075858697,
-0.0558969602,
0.7913563251,
0.9913343191,
-0.1155897081,
0.2485884279,
-0.3358020782,
0.4703041911,
-0.8325650096,
-0.4227539897,
-1.0369929075,
-0.192901656,
-0.6088700294,
-0.0413789786,
0.2323821932,
0.0445838347,
0.172821939,
0.5941189528,
-0.6296548843,
0.3017369807,
0.7419043779,
-0.4622985125,
0.5376717448,
-0.1377761215,
0.3207604587,
-0.285644114,
-0.8681718707,
-0.4594938755,
0.8069107533,
0.3386050761,
0.3573698103,
-0.0956318974,
0.7485848665,
0.2344120145,
0.2146735787,
-0.5905454159,
0.4872023165,
-0.0195463151,
-0.9365383983,
-0.09244138,
-0.1048330665,
-1.1520941257,
0.1566401124,
-0.09615127,
-0.5712485909,
0.5826853514,
0.0877229571,
-0.3956305385,
0.1742801815,
-0.288838774,
0.8254241943,
0.1111528277,
-0.4939899445,
-0.2154623717,
-0.3454320133,
0.2880913615,
-0.1927547306,
0.310703814,
-0.0229417384,
0.1602621824,
1.0498950481,
-0.2715439498,
0.7936353683,
0.1478609592,
-0.1531257331,
0.3272174597,
0.0685811639,
0.223570317,
-0.1545645148,
-0.1639138609,
0.4178045392,
0.001531782,
-0.1450449079,
-0.3109898269,
0.4774034619,
-0.3235595226,
-0.3467998505,
-0.8792186975,
-0.1230360568,
-0.1753721833,
-0.0038007062,
0.4863245189,
0.3875567615,
-0.2956276238,
0.8632878661,
0.1702784747,
-0.0471236631,
0.776999414,
0.2468279004,
-0.1342140883,
-0.4941536188,
0.4749318659,
0.5897932649,
0.2798173428,
0.2477433085,
-0.0643378273,
-0.2626266479,
-0.2866044641,
-0.0312315878,
0.1789641231,
-0.6521001458,
-0.1035253927,
-0.7821169496,
-0.3584113121,
-0.300779283,
-0.5155845284,
-0.6744533181,
-0.2118662745,
-0.2749029398,
0.0695645735,
-0.0169337057,
0.7536226511,
-0.2721013725,
-0.2840904295,
-0.9069643617,
-0.0645114407,
0.3754482269,
0.1797592938,
0.0154026486,
-0.249781087,
-0.6179321408,
-0.0462004431,
-0.2110555917,
-0.5130679011,
0.4614316225,
0.0795638189,
0.6391915083,
-0.0507380627,
0.1450802684,
0.584174931,
-0.1176587567,
1.1249872446,
0.1888169646,
-0.9725913405,
0.408110559,
-0.2711263895,
0.2591452301,
0.7109467983,
0.6503150463,
-0.51517874,
-0.5683973432,
-0.9063167572,
-1.0981794596,
0.8103701472,
0.2739216089,
0.0447075367,
0.1880225986,
-0.1918818206,
-0.3026937544,
0.3808173239,
-0.8025390506,
0.0577743351,
0.4300097227,
0.2074970603,
0.0367633738,
-0.2219536752,
-0.2758993804,
0.0312355477,
0.3392867148,
0.2530748546,
0.1932833195,
0.3343145847,
0.204457283,
0.2702071369,
-0.1490679085,
0.0741477236,
0.8200263977,
-0.293366611,
0.1444759071,
-0.0758902505,
-0.4075235724,
-0.3849565983,
-0.1884955168,
-0.2484870851,
0.5018926859,
0.5237208009,
0.2632513642,
0.0038233295,
-0.4095589817,
0.4468911886,
0.0470305905,
-0.5151319504,
-0.6249631047,
-0.2084132135,
0.0485697947,
0.2970739007,
0.3764725924,
0.3969477117,
0.3791032434,
-0.6435266137,
0.2062961906,
0.2879424095,
-0.4032979608,
-0.2849727869,
0.9108316898,
0.3327071071,
-0.2010464966,
0.4440567493,
0.1012413055,
-0.3505780697,
0.6479331255,
0.3576084375,
1.062661171,
0.1884921044,
-0.0418414958,
0.5261664987,
0.3870668709,
-0.4098401666,
-0.2287843078,
-0.0188577045,
-0.4271882474,
-0.8368858099,
-0.5270968676,
-0.7494698763,
0.4372718334,
-0.751832366,
0.5120436549,
-0.2839316726,
-0.2718799412,
0.2322344035,
-0.1063443646,
-0.5307604074,
-0.0537087768,
0.1356351972,
0.6074693203,
-0.8569271564,
0.5172038674,
0.2783449292,
-0.7111353278,
-0.7645295858,
-0.1165944189,
-0.0025871173,
-0.1359537691,
0.5990973711,
0.3242486119,
-0.1502012014,
-0.069279708,
-0.6846857667,
-0.999022007,
1.0155553818,
0.1864595413,
-0.368920207,
0.052548252,
0.0776903704,
0.6299538016,
-0.3512348831,
-0.1510127485,
0.3137022555,
0.1415446103,
-0.0595720373,
-1.1111706495,
-0.2689917684,
-0.2204325795,
0.0198742114,
0.0344573632,
-0.4539059103,
0.6034286022,
0.2988506556,
-0.2156742513,
-0.135822311,
0.7937986851,
0.5961779952,
0.695849359,
0.1971624643,
0.265026629,
0.4862778187,
-0.0076424875,
0.8874896169,
-0.2606255114,
0.3138355911,
1.2878569365,
-0.2374275476,
1.2302427292,
0.5539428592,
-0.2813273966,
0.2168273479,
0.4016468525,
-0.5014794469,
0.2902947962,
-0.0738357082,
-0.1560781598,
-0.0280293971,
-0.5012561679,
-0.559579432,
0.6062639952,
0.2254634202,
-0.5777640939,
0.2157320082,
-0.2630215883,
0.2256954163,
0.2423617691,
0.029027136,
0.8085973263,
0.3338503838,
-1.0765515566,
0.1992258877,
-0.2048582286,
0.7805818319,
-0.7131462097,
0.1564041078,
-0.1718227267,
0.1196196005,
-0.2502241433,
-0.4999382496,
0.918260932,
0.062088497,
0.1574701965,
-0.5113232732,
0.4033075571,
-0.4590778947,
-0.113264963,
0.5271168351,
0.322298795,
0.2467752844,
-0.173140347,
-0.2870560586,
0.1945702732,
-0.1162493601,
-0.1615874916,
0.3998836279,
0.4615414739,
0.3806174994,
0.2211442739,
0.6259052157,
0.1506486684,
0.1074188054,
0.0793103501,
0.5417381525,
-0.463981092,
-0.4068319201,
-0.6638548374,
0.5437119007,
-0.4427435994,
-0.5001222491,
0.9137042761,
0.7403309345,
1.01169765,
-0.1067005917,
0.6906615496,
-0.145271942,
0.3379498124,
-0.5492149591,
0.730412066,
-0.6289590597,
0.336181879,
-0.264238596,
-1.0143082142,
-0.4641678929,
0.4411132932,
-0.0739061609,
0.1040231809,
0.736438334,
0.5331482291,
0.101598464,
0.1077559739,
0.2458634526,
-0.2836958766,
0.3654909432,
0.0992069766,
0.7253538966,
-0.2488143295,
0.4773989618,
-0.4997595251,
0.0493580438,
-0.3065373302,
-1.1131278276,
-0.4971852899,
-0.7139064074,
-0.6953662634,
-0.277231425,
-0.3267622888,
0.8026510477,
0.6200318336,
-0.5532680154,
-0.3824396729,
-0.43392542,
-0.3722448051,
-0.4330790639,
-0.2116420716,
0.3137074113,
-0.5542794466,
-0.8777586818,
0.3398493528,
0.4207419753,
-0.149862811,
-0.4063605368,
0.3657046556,
-0.3185782433,
0.1599024236,
0.6141150594,
0.3735421896,
-0.4321342707,
0.2121946365,
0.2845802605,
-0.1112132892,
-0.053956043,
0.9197740555,
-0.4956006706,
0.3808386624,
0.7242921591,
0.7805382609,
0.5264818072,
-0.0806509629,
0.9145866036,
-0.7276169062,
0.145149231,
0.5807094574,
0.2364428043,
0.4274643064,
-0.2190150172,
0.9115176797,
0.2093221694,
-1.03881073,
-1.0197150707,
-0.1006046906,
-0.9574323297,
-0.3050207198,
0.8151122332,
-0.1545887887,
-0.1864617616,
-0.4514206946,
0.153903231,
0.1418299675,
-0.0928121284,
0.8394005895,
0.7022730708,
-0.2331066281,
0.0727708116,
-0.8233655691,
0.6665551066,
0.4523806274,
-0.5651744604,
-0.0959299505,
0.2829610407,
-0.323092103,
0.6763132811,
0.7384669185,
-0.2600740194,
0.0439055674,
0.404535532,
0.3156907558,
0.1039828584,
-0.4281079769,
-0.3274269402,
0.4367174506,
0.4930811822,
-0.2038946748
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03905v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03905v2
|
A Pseudo-Semantic Loss for Autoregressive Models with Logical Constraints
| 2023-12-06T20:58:07 | 2024-01-27T00:25:22 |
Kareem Ahmed, Kai-Wei Chang, Guy Van den Broeck
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Neuro-symbolic AI bridges the gap between purely symbolic and neural
approaches to learning. This often requires maximizing the likelihood of a
symbolic constraint w.r.t the neural network's output distribution. Such output
distributions are typically assumed to be fully-factorized. This limits the
applicability of neuro-symbolic learning to the more expressive autoregressive
distributions, e.g., transformers. Under such distributions, computing the
likelihood of even simple constraints is #P-hard. Instead of attempting to
enforce the constraint on the entire output distribution, we propose to do so
on a random, local approximation thereof. More precisely, we optimize the
likelihood of the constraint under a pseudolikelihood-based approximation
centered around a model sample. Our approximation is factorized, allowing the
reuse of solutions to sub-problems, a main tenet for efficiently computing
neuro-symbolic losses. Moreover, it is a local, high-fidelity approximation of
the likelihood, exhibiting low entropy and KL-divergence around the model
sample. We evaluate our approach on Sudoku and shortest-path prediction cast as
autoregressive generation, and observe that we greatly improve upon the base
model's ability to predict logically-consistent outputs. We also evaluate on
the task of detoxifying large language models. Using a simple constraint
disallowing a list of toxic words, we are able to steer the model's outputs
away from toxic generations, achieving SoTA detoxification compared to previous
approaches.
|
[
-0.0518053137,
-0.5747842193,
0.6291118264,
-0.1630438417,
-0.0793591812,
-0.3840500116,
-0.1786070317,
-0.1446833462,
0.1600016505,
0.4124135673,
-1.082113266,
-0.2394746989,
-0.5982877612,
0.1454533637,
-0.4640023112,
1.0616465807,
0.0453931727,
0.0226809904,
-0.0262698289,
0.0792354047,
-0.5342367291,
-0.7288613319,
-0.5172133446,
-0.4698134363,
0.4600242674,
-0.1484009326,
0.6650184393,
0.7265933752,
0.3755638301,
0.368234843,
0.163971439,
-0.0709057301,
-0.3428825736,
-0.0317083746,
-0.2842583656,
-0.7590122223,
0.1833461076,
0.223360911,
0.5143820643,
0.7523450255,
-0.4131452441,
-0.0626150221,
-0.2628107667,
0.4929058254,
-0.6901391149,
0.2739884853,
-0.6233089566,
0.5194631219,
0.1726335287,
-0.0193885621,
-0.4493548274,
-0.4995465279,
0.0972919837,
-0.7276534438,
0.0732054189,
-0.0232045185,
1.0358375311,
1.0559706688,
-0.225171715,
-0.0095077176,
-1.0477975607,
0.8108967543,
-0.529446125,
0.3204444349,
0.3787709773,
0.3359801471,
-0.2145755738,
-0.5748766065,
-0.5843046904,
-0.3671610057,
-0.1517075002,
0.3143018186,
-0.3652799129,
0.1240576059,
0.2537026405,
0.0119017437,
-0.357270956,
0.0129148439,
-0.2447983921,
-0.4130063355,
0.6259015203,
0.4034135342,
0.3849060535,
-0.1704954505,
-0.1595116556,
-0.1840935051,
-0.6177893877,
-0.538364768,
0.4170257747,
0.157591328,
0.1808201224,
0.4501003623,
0.0474120602,
0.5032424927,
0.0021348742,
0.1686160564,
0.0949439853,
-0.3466967642,
-0.044636786,
-0.0407208502,
0.7958400846,
0.1046250165,
0.280721575,
-0.1352019459,
-0.3290804029,
0.2969353199,
0.1651912481,
-0.5576589108,
-0.7265584469,
-0.3049890101,
-0.513002634,
-0.0884279981,
-0.2977332473,
-0.226669848,
-0.3404510319,
-0.5553031564,
0.7848058343,
-0.5054481626,
-0.1831651926,
0.0108073717,
-0.1145524681,
-0.1519854665,
0.3028079271,
-0.6905580759,
0.3408038914,
0.3220812678,
0.7759759426,
0.1806467026,
-0.2046802342,
-0.3078430891,
0.1328456998,
-0.4682957828,
0.3656359315,
-0.2499959171,
-0.0366925858,
-0.3242006898,
-0.2105449289,
-0.2240317315,
-0.6148622632,
0.0319614634,
-0.2934890091,
0.1068176031,
-0.1413224638,
-0.436634779,
-0.2807655036,
-0.2005934864,
-0.4992884398,
0.6065507531,
0.1272735,
-0.5830399394,
0.2860171497,
-0.3461962938,
-0.5270843506,
-0.255184859,
-0.1593075395,
-0.281847775,
0.4087050259,
-0.3301388025,
0.189324528,
-0.4655334353,
0.4252230227,
-0.426803261,
-0.0927250832,
-0.1984975338,
-0.4597342014,
0.8857957721,
0.3055584133,
-0.62155509,
0.2924253941,
-0.6626800895,
-0.1864716411,
0.3268972635,
0.2933662236,
-0.5150448084,
0.3738112152,
-0.1539102197,
0.549202323,
0.123874791,
-0.4673527181,
0.1182402596,
-0.5987114906,
0.651802063,
0.9888417721,
-0.0522643514,
0.645672977,
-0.1092168018,
0.2558090687,
0.0418358184,
0.539963603,
0.4850223958,
-0.3160223663,
-0.7184243202,
-0.2928968966,
0.2314677835,
0.6861850619,
-0.8455315232,
0.7482535243,
-0.0208884981,
-0.6685917377,
-0.2358682156,
0.1072453931,
0.3818312287,
0.7483007312,
0.2937318385,
-0.2923749983,
-0.393116653,
-1.2163552046,
0.0123263365,
-0.464374423,
-0.1825601161,
0.1613557488,
0.5990850925,
-0.1595749408,
0.6965970397,
-0.6056922674,
-0.6326937079,
-0.0682398453,
0.4560701847,
0.308949858,
0.5828201771,
0.2692902684,
-0.539482832,
-0.166881904,
-0.3431231678,
-0.8713747263,
-0.1755309254,
-0.2743271291,
-0.1516866237,
0.240544498,
0.3872807026,
-0.8181197047,
0.7299026251,
0.1357666105,
-0.2336726934,
0.4586576521,
-0.4268081486,
-0.4988671243,
-0.7545713782,
-0.0570841394,
0.0074533219,
0.094012551,
-0.5559558272,
-0.2245400399,
-0.2004113644,
-0.0852639079,
-0.2410249859,
0.3772633374,
-0.1707447618,
0.008183415,
-0.1262867302,
-0.186413452,
-0.1917761415,
0.5525641441,
0.5424676538,
0.3748899996,
0.5763714314,
-0.6189809442,
0.1093193665,
0.2396808565,
0.1273210198,
0.33691746,
-0.7775145173,
-0.1728228778,
-0.512352705,
0.5735863447,
-0.5716634989,
0.0609226301,
0.4370603859,
-0.2136695683,
0.2979764938,
0.1112567559,
-0.6462077498,
-0.0750027895,
-0.0074732397,
0.3999716938,
0.7760786414,
-0.3885371089,
0.8246594071,
0.4306218326,
0.2644692957,
-0.3412643671,
-0.8774877191,
0.0094217826,
-0.1067232639,
-0.3613083661,
0.2185335755,
0.0526444949,
-0.0649122149,
0.2311257124,
-0.1196925789,
0.0766417161,
0.0875991508,
0.1131039634,
0.2287733853,
-0.1112447828,
0.203881219,
-0.0455492474,
-0.3654277027,
0.3807196319,
-0.5189319253,
0.3815602064,
-0.0946651325,
-0.2198287547,
-0.6596285105,
0.4506191015,
0.1348010004,
-0.0848989785,
0.8289666772,
0.4822767675,
-0.5909096003,
-0.4429715574,
-0.1958148479,
-0.6869679689,
-0.470872432,
0.5650956035,
-0.2312995791,
-0.3412997425,
0.3931319118,
0.0954544321,
0.0167636015,
0.7758648396,
0.5284612179,
-0.1500118822,
1.2822998762,
0.5493400097,
-0.0139584998,
0.1958019435,
-0.4606203437,
0.5407236218,
-0.3583059311,
-0.1723242998,
-0.2863216996,
-0.4078926444,
-0.634660244,
-0.1796057075,
0.2979990542,
-0.1307868212,
-0.442511797,
0.5357650518,
-0.6939541101,
0.1261588037,
0.9891210794,
-0.0053605549,
-0.1373478323,
-0.2148074955,
-0.0211321712,
-0.2691563964,
-1.1327540874,
-0.0737631693,
0.6900333166,
0.1462663859,
0.8649442196,
0.10520906,
0.9755052924,
0.1183396652,
0.6084219813,
-0.7052494884,
0.6088444591,
-0.2633441687,
-0.7542318702,
-0.3544284999,
-0.9455724955,
-0.6989014149,
-0.131642431,
-0.2258039862,
-0.823113203,
0.298566848,
0.4352279902,
-0.3925074637,
0.518689394,
-0.7850422263,
0.9719688892,
-0.2182305008,
-0.2185737342,
-0.3280692697,
-0.9126471877,
0.464496851,
-0.1594416201,
-0.0591430366,
0.0208925661,
-0.0589548796,
0.7962262034,
-0.885258019,
0.8654671311,
-0.4430740178,
0.2017143816,
0.4084478319,
0.3235731721,
0.5221651793,
-0.3603027761,
0.2232362032,
0.3039319813,
0.0891615078,
-0.1696086526,
-0.8914856315,
0.5573541522,
-0.9988455772,
-0.7484888434,
-0.6988885403,
-0.6756703854,
-0.1762136072,
0.1379799545,
0.4535247684,
0.2964029908,
0.2725702822,
-0.1373716593,
0.5962908268,
-0.4274079204,
0.4381128848,
0.0777238458,
0.1466281563,
-0.3074784577,
1.3183259964,
0.3513219059,
0.1754052788,
0.2177768499,
0.496656239,
-0.7087153792,
-0.4204771519,
-0.2591262162,
0.4703758359,
-0.9383565187,
-0.1856154054,
-0.4877627194,
-0.455429405,
-0.1450925171,
-0.0370009057,
-0.3895004094,
-0.5654876232,
-0.4190828204,
0.025875628,
0.29890576,
0.7280094028,
-0.382068187,
0.2049442232,
-0.5009120107,
0.2109333873,
0.2154093087,
0.0460838377,
0.05102567,
-0.5255674124,
0.1041439548,
-0.0644327775,
-0.1078235507,
-1.0496582985,
0.4752514064,
0.4776913822,
0.4083051383,
0.4022245705,
0.3245365024,
0.5048115849,
-0.5873972178,
0.3925354779,
0.5556975603,
-0.7263453603,
0.4366059303,
-0.1754772961,
0.1574533433,
0.6244871616,
0.4651716948,
-0.2585763633,
-0.4205627441,
-0.9204025865,
-0.8888058662,
0.6808370948,
0.4645799696,
0.2615866661,
-0.3626595736,
0.3260931671,
-0.1934821904,
0.1980789602,
-0.6730034947,
-0.5019058585,
-0.5290279984,
-0.5121151209,
-0.0288633239,
0.0687191635,
0.0408986919,
-0.4598689079,
0.969479084,
0.1173521057,
0.2713766396,
0.300927192,
-0.2848808765,
0.1518345922,
-0.367623508,
0.4658996761,
0.169896543,
-0.0568373799,
0.376770854,
0.0844366178,
-0.2198348939,
0.4391793013,
0.0851537436,
-0.7162774205,
0.0440592989,
0.1584329158,
0.6453260779,
-0.0991025716,
-0.5603485703,
0.3239809573,
-0.0681243092,
-0.350504458,
-0.5073745847,
0.0835292935,
-0.029691156,
-0.060602054,
0.2390994579,
0.485178113,
0.3305471241,
-0.4001237154,
0.5402327776,
0.5021986365,
-0.645001173,
-0.333579123,
0.9887933135,
-0.0426597707,
-0.233532384,
0.8784586787,
-0.3337443471,
-0.6195522547,
0.7186619639,
0.5516697168,
1.1329325438,
-0.1392709017,
0.1531329304,
0.5765731931,
0.6010842919,
-0.0471775569,
0.1145246178,
0.0311980471,
-0.4930794239,
-0.4947045445,
-0.6091739535,
0.1253917515,
0.0147290174,
-0.2347179204,
0.0396061055,
-0.9184409976,
-0.4006955326,
-0.0511139557,
-0.2897720933,
-0.5140864849,
0.2969000936,
0.0757753998,
0.5103577375,
-1.0964231491,
0.6369712949,
0.4079933167,
-0.6856517792,
-0.9336795211,
-0.3065500855,
0.0786203593,
-0.5678120852,
1.0098457336,
0.0046371473,
-0.2333728969,
0.0097753145,
-0.2733804882,
-0.9653503895,
0.5450224876,
0.6173618436,
-0.3919118643,
-0.0984691978,
0.1013988554,
0.5355318785,
0.0560253114,
0.3333259225,
0.3300399184,
0.5830057859,
0.0840947181,
-0.6805764437,
0.1697652936,
-0.4229126871,
-0.0133481286,
0.5481625795,
-0.5374265909,
0.7729358673,
0.0001184598,
-0.2018653303,
-0.1477331519,
0.9221130013,
0.0486484841,
0.0580324419,
0.7875102758,
0.6194848418,
0.4368391931,
-0.1152785793,
1.1334788799,
-0.2708420455,
0.1805180609,
1.1503762007,
-0.0443096422,
0.5679175258,
0.5695072412,
-0.061178796,
0.2658176422,
0.6503530145,
0.0549650639,
0.6961418986,
0.7355546355,
-0.1299890876,
-0.3846492767,
-0.3485209048,
-0.0015259117,
0.2842377424,
0.1648464948,
-0.3419085741,
-0.3350216448,
-0.1974717081,
0.0289313812,
0.1930522323,
-0.1467297524,
0.570151329,
0.2134037018,
-0.7049250007,
0.6383345127,
-0.0100326743,
0.462168932,
-0.6304373741,
-0.1638198942,
-0.199837476,
0.1904925853,
-0.0655307621,
-0.137051031,
0.7093262076,
-0.3983462155,
-0.1256593764,
-0.1587676555,
0.7225192189,
-0.353315115,
-0.6949499249,
0.2673357427,
0.2240469456,
0.0738657638,
0.0283112656,
-0.7888622284,
-0.3938883245,
-0.1927542239,
-0.2567236125,
0.3039862812,
0.2448724359,
-0.2620588243,
0.8662086129,
0.4748440087,
0.1750593036,
0.1853360236,
-0.0345109105,
0.5411704779,
-0.3797910213,
-0.524445653,
-0.8523468375,
-0.0481363833,
0.114799045,
-0.2819873095,
0.5463029146,
0.2442403138,
0.6436297297,
-0.0977787152,
0.5681226254,
-0.1325948685,
-0.1265933365,
-0.3892297447,
0.8859419823,
-0.7609862685,
-0.0444416888,
-0.2274234742,
-0.9725196362,
-0.4529168904,
0.8394625783,
-0.478221029,
0.1603643149,
0.8233146071,
0.8049624562,
-0.1056774035,
-0.1900700778,
0.296985656,
0.2469597608,
-0.1162702218,
0.9166945815,
0.939403832,
-0.2304052114,
0.4229355156,
-0.7477061152,
-0.2298812121,
0.1756341457,
-0.8250245452,
-0.7056490779,
-0.7402713299,
-0.5811753869,
-0.3662543893,
0.099879019,
0.9078660607,
0.943185389,
-0.6429191232,
-0.1133239269,
-0.4436504543,
0.046978768,
-0.3119023442,
-0.1987984627,
0.5318850279,
-0.2675878704,
-0.4599587917,
0.1715814173,
0.1811706871,
-0.0685251653,
-0.3641841114,
-0.1491214335,
-0.2889424264,
0.2214384824,
0.3857444823,
0.334299773,
-0.5990304947,
-0.5001651049,
0.1075855121,
0.0289711561,
-0.3101406693,
0.5401091576,
-0.7228332162,
0.198016569,
0.5770776272,
0.7066378593,
0.4025757611,
-0.2908416688,
0.7708611488,
-0.5928736925,
0.3159707487,
0.570743084,
0.2731322646,
0.0880975798,
-0.3487861454,
0.4712177217,
0.5331830382,
-0.164221257,
-0.6833031178,
0.4743185639,
-0.3795645535,
-0.3657280207,
0.9051195383,
-0.0506517962,
-0.6350696683,
-0.1280039251,
0.2290008962,
0.4952879846,
-0.1537155211,
0.8491862416,
0.4541399181,
-0.1621568501,
-0.0738773048,
-0.5404391885,
0.6789640784,
0.9700126052,
-0.6077414751,
0.0289184377,
0.7937610149,
0.074466072,
0.2062455416,
0.3466005027,
0.1232358143,
0.3487605155,
-0.1192685887,
0.2931070626,
0.0559665672,
-0.5696427226,
-0.1792806834,
-0.012464691,
-0.2031658739,
0.0512334742
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03897v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03897v1
|
Revisiting the Optimality of Word Lengths
| 2023-12-06T20:41:47 | 2023-12-06T20:41:47 |
Tiago Pimentel, Clara Meister, Ethan Gotlieb Wilcox, Kyle Mahowald, Ryan Cotterell
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Zipf (1935) posited that wordforms are optimized to minimize utterances'
communicative costs. Under the assumption that cost is given by an utterance's
length, he supported this claim by showing that words' lengths are inversely
correlated with their frequencies. Communicative cost, however, can be
operationalized in different ways. Piantadosi et al. (2011) claim that cost
should be measured as the distance between an utterance's information rate and
channel capacity, which we dub the channel capacity hypothesis (CCH) here.
Following this logic, they then proposed that a word's length should be
proportional to the expected value of its surprisal (negative log-probability
in context). In this work, we show that Piantadosi et al.'s derivation does not
minimize CCH's cost, but rather a lower bound, which we term CCH-lower. We
propose a novel derivation, suggesting an improved way to minimize CCH's cost.
Under this method, we find that a language's word lengths should instead be
proportional to the surprisal's expectation plus its variance-to-mean ratio.
Experimentally, we compare these three communicative cost functions: Zipf's,
CCH-lower , and CCH. Across 13 languages and several experimental settings, we
find that length is better predicted by frequency than either of the other
hypotheses. In fact, when surprisal's expectation, or expectation plus
variance-to-mean ratio, is estimated using better language models, it leads to
worse word length predictions. We take these results as evidence that Zipf's
longstanding hypothesis holds.
|
[
-0.7734416127,
-0.7173880339,
0.6793037653,
0.1549630165,
-0.2833609879,
-0.1619506776,
-0.5283838511,
-0.6142777801,
0.6143037677,
0.2016970068,
-0.3963518739,
0.2903524935,
-0.6227791309,
0.2007963806,
-0.3609223366,
0.551841259,
0.1863651872,
-0.227075696,
-0.2615692317,
-0.2607934177,
-0.2233225256,
-0.4622524381,
-0.2892518342,
-0.2593259215,
0.7606033683,
0.5667209029,
1.1736294031,
0.7525421977,
0.4554228783,
0.2178276628,
-0.031866651,
-0.1068070829,
-0.4921890497,
-0.0403176658,
0.4768571258,
-0.5141217709,
0.0646943003,
0.0732135773,
0.5586287379,
1.1683452129,
-0.2901975214,
0.0004707634,
-0.0819765255,
1.1587405205,
-0.8929433227,
-0.1543642879,
-0.265637368,
-0.2012291402,
-0.321480602,
-0.4864622653,
-0.3418729901,
-0.2303196043,
0.3507703841,
-0.6650452018,
-0.0242939368,
0.2752903104,
0.9030402303,
0.1352730393,
-0.1371054649,
-0.6224182248,
-0.5858279467,
0.8646408916,
-0.5800418854,
0.6067412496,
0.5948284864,
0.2354852259,
-0.1256515533,
-0.1988874972,
-0.6525215507,
-0.6319464445,
-0.0924360678,
0.1519802511,
-0.590411067,
0.347427249,
0.5484752059,
0.4167443216,
-0.5636879802,
0.1115621924,
-0.7212451696,
-0.0902402401,
0.70370543,
0.0286455154,
0.3830052018,
-0.1084540412,
-0.0670049489,
0.1781546623,
-0.9756270051,
0.1669188738,
0.8560782075,
0.0598170273,
-0.1105678082,
0.750133276,
-0.4220440984,
0.4240528047,
-0.0860590339,
-0.1270540655,
0.0783235356,
-0.18129462,
-0.2630477846,
0.304694742,
0.4435019791,
0.3233285546,
0.3668093085,
-0.267978996,
0.1618844569,
-0.0547432117,
0.1873858124,
-0.7269679308,
-0.0880009159,
0.1477802545,
-0.5097405314,
-0.1212945133,
-0.0004623251,
-0.5037503242,
-0.0134417312,
-0.0691623762,
0.4112585783,
-0.4840593338,
-0.0164685659,
0.2624434531,
-0.3424474597,
0.0524668172,
-0.2480851114,
-1.136482954,
0.6252855659,
0.4748056531,
0.8410015702,
-0.0649043471,
-0.1838667244,
-0.3114207685,
-0.1961599737,
-0.793361783,
0.7774991989,
-0.3226182461,
-0.5487831235,
-0.1345566064,
-0.2564689815,
0.1294138283,
-0.1742453724,
0.550229311,
-0.3781972229,
0.2539250255,
-0.4905727506,
-0.7225803733,
-0.0413388461,
-0.5676055551,
-0.749766767,
0.4567182064,
0.2147236317,
-0.9344163537,
0.4067416489,
-0.2951672971,
-0.6682117581,
0.3403951526,
0.0824779049,
-0.28246665,
0.623246789,
-0.1201284751,
-0.0132237813,
-0.5268890262,
0.1345616579,
-0.4232918024,
-0.578436017,
0.4180384278,
-0.8163691163,
0.8206760287,
0.503549099,
-0.2163809836,
-0.3372049332,
-0.7328621745,
0.0347735472,
-0.1180718467,
-0.5031837821,
-0.5370902419,
0.3913348317,
-0.2924730182,
-0.1710472107,
-0.1149386391,
-0.6660678387,
-0.3121902943,
-0.7966483235,
0.3780175447,
0.5786319971,
-0.1513406485,
0.5565541387,
-0.5830134749,
0.4701405764,
-0.7238883376,
0.3399596214,
0.2134355009,
0.0165855698,
-0.8046170473,
-0.4250199795,
0.1668282896,
0.0470316112,
-0.3743638694,
0.1424241364,
-0.5713443756,
-0.4112440646,
-0.2301968932,
-0.2499409318,
0.18269068,
0.1108740941,
0.2231715769,
-0.5506274104,
-0.4972059727,
-1.0533179045,
-0.3125532269,
-0.5228022337,
-0.0037037376,
0.279528439,
0.113649942,
0.3170103431,
0.7449695468,
-0.5467432737,
0.2491004169,
-0.4241695106,
0.0257167872,
0.3152244985,
0.0649138093,
0.5145576596,
-0.5973095894,
-0.3601608276,
-0.3963385224,
0.0908695385,
-0.5609112978,
-0.1048994139,
0.1840008795,
0.353472352,
0.0387991741,
-0.7620719671,
0.58355093,
0.7062582374,
-0.0654014945,
0.9039677382,
-0.4716258943,
-0.0205221698,
-0.6714134216,
-0.1680373698,
-0.030355297,
0.2926772535,
-0.5382627845,
-0.0407742634,
-0.0711902454,
0.1416944563,
-0.2791194618,
0.2790958583,
-0.6457623243,
-0.2574084699,
-0.6212050319,
0.1713109463,
-0.1787372977,
0.5418041348,
-0.1287415624,
0.9029479623,
0.0921228454,
-0.6879653335,
0.3880307078,
-0.064785026,
-0.6514973044,
0.3951234221,
-0.6368016601,
-0.4235426486,
-0.0472310781,
0.2167823911,
-1.052474618,
-0.1550120115,
-0.1366328746,
-0.5637919903,
-0.0196360424,
0.1516303867,
-0.409884274,
-0.4588706493,
-0.3531293869,
0.5086046457,
0.7288500667,
-0.3793731034,
-0.1306809783,
0.4883572161,
-0.0136141358,
-0.5158547163,
-0.7909347415,
0.0824772716,
-0.3721403182,
-0.6706782579,
0.3018025458,
-0.281721741,
-0.3635464907,
-0.1842100173,
-0.4780850708,
-0.032512024,
0.1089447588,
0.3045315146,
0.1371628195,
-0.2048486173,
0.5224536657,
0.0233958401,
-0.0101186521,
0.2755062282,
-0.3477863669,
0.5548843741,
0.007257299,
-0.3800974488,
-0.1099572852,
0.4661360979,
0.3111255467,
0.0344618633,
0.62914747,
-0.0019915379,
-0.1938761622,
0.1740530431,
-0.8199825883,
0.0078081056,
-0.4260052145,
0.2586524487,
-0.3770990074,
-0.9639166594,
0.199538514,
0.157542333,
-0.3461247087,
0.4890548885,
0.2816577256,
-0.005877885,
0.8379134536,
0.7325147986,
0.0444216579,
0.3255366087,
-0.12848185,
0.5482184887,
-0.8550001979,
0.034539286,
-0.6677546501,
-0.0799952298,
-0.993031323,
-0.2025638223,
0.2590259016,
0.2690659463,
-0.3415949345,
0.6015131474,
-0.0674614087,
0.4906260669,
0.5076143742,
-0.1816874444,
0.0167520251,
0.0113742696,
-0.0669653937,
-0.0545809716,
-0.9080972075,
-0.2363930196,
0.6926980019,
0.3166564107,
0.667206049,
0.3200925291,
0.4923433959,
0.0918946341,
0.0679695979,
-0.9833903909,
0.3565012217,
-0.0213493928,
-0.4330715835,
-0.7352323532,
-0.3630760014,
-1.0852752924,
0.2063734084,
-0.1650961936,
-0.858684063,
0.4350052774,
0.0559302755,
-0.1825259328,
0.1799535602,
-0.4605864286,
0.3595457375,
-0.2354569882,
-0.1624220163,
-0.4807507396,
-0.4276617169,
0.1861374825,
-0.1099815369,
0.4690099061,
-0.2473222017,
-0.2165770829,
0.8458369374,
-0.893053174,
0.3473151624,
0.4094729722,
0.0013966826,
0.4457115829,
0.0300794952,
0.3167617023,
-0.0750101656,
0.1882360429,
-0.0450935774,
0.1200976968,
-0.5736597776,
-0.4177663624,
0.6396722794,
-0.5613795519,
-0.6786777973,
-0.2866059542,
-0.4098260999,
0.0342688151,
0.0823634937,
0.7112309337,
0.7648499608,
-0.2685012817,
0.473383069,
0.447856456,
-0.5317947268,
0.6487076879,
0.3804517388,
0.2164405584,
-0.3806600869,
0.7324134707,
0.3895371854,
0.6840476394,
0.685097754,
0.5971363783,
-0.4120030999,
-0.4407907426,
0.0718150958,
0.1329316497,
-0.5419281125,
0.0582067519,
-0.6737991571,
-0.1276387423,
-0.3053047359,
-0.309917897,
-0.2604492307,
-0.5769103169,
0.1004650816,
-0.2141509801,
0.1801477373,
0.2424835563,
-0.5733042955,
0.3637916744,
-0.3927784562,
0.0321195982,
0.3493358195,
0.252040118,
0.0910829902,
-0.6154285669,
-0.2186519057,
0.066467315,
-0.1814213693,
-1.0545945168,
0.5512031317,
0.2051709145,
0.5773558021,
0.1941298842,
0.2435548455,
0.6993367076,
-0.5150085092,
0.6798084974,
0.686313808,
-1.0513243675,
0.1120225862,
-0.1415352821,
0.2989150286,
0.2503538132,
0.5389773846,
-0.8898856044,
-0.5186619759,
-0.9667013884,
-1.0364164114,
0.2305361629,
0.3536397517,
0.4580337107,
-0.4712723196,
0.0658534616,
0.2239268869,
0.0209775735,
-0.4386656582,
-0.3524650037,
0.0930245891,
-0.0192639288,
-0.2535779476,
-0.6974185705,
0.2547256649,
-0.0420036316,
0.692892313,
-0.0306411758,
0.6605734229,
0.21786578,
-0.2516058981,
-0.275960356,
0.6657058597,
1.0520985126,
1.1291137934,
-0.0599804483,
0.3222172558,
0.4701348543,
-0.6495808363,
0.0978101492,
-0.1858155131,
0.0708929524,
0.0749519542,
0.7036454678,
0.8833140135,
0.1960232556,
-0.767696619,
0.7271670699,
0.195562005,
-0.3862275481,
-0.5483180285,
-0.2442125827,
0.2251982242,
-0.0300827976,
0.3468351364,
-0.1329451948,
0.3755408525,
-0.4590828717,
0.1537015736,
0.4895666838,
-0.5507975817,
-0.1623546779,
0.3279829323,
0.045401793,
-0.3583797514,
0.4582895041,
0.1363427639,
-0.4719192088,
0.7617700696,
0.3592593372,
0.8160396218,
0.0441528149,
0.3440918922,
0.3413148522,
0.3896657825,
-0.1458847076,
-0.0363020338,
-0.1374231279,
-0.4789559841,
-0.5187299848,
-0.6726538539,
0.0636364669,
0.1014086157,
-0.6104300618,
0.2061608732,
-0.0187187586,
0.0695459992,
0.1793640405,
0.3952261209,
-0.3113702536,
0.1563680768,
0.1334061027,
0.9802444577,
-0.5414292812,
0.5561439395,
-0.255877018,
-0.2895494699,
-1.1270999908,
0.0650095046,
-0.0874780715,
-0.7235149145,
0.7169764042,
0.1749835014,
-0.2009770274,
-0.1609384865,
-0.3526803255,
-1.1077828407,
0.927855432,
0.2708588839,
-0.7049482465,
0.2726798952,
0.248618871,
0.6363880038,
-0.3200761676,
0.3259061873,
0.2796680331,
0.2240458727,
0.205934301,
-0.912922442,
0.0397322141,
0.1271595955,
0.241455704,
0.5453125834,
-0.4541279674,
0.6758964658,
-0.786714673,
-0.6348598003,
0.4299383461,
0.5788248777,
-0.2484107763,
0.0221815426,
0.4454687834,
0.4863107204,
0.4562972486,
0.1158476621,
1.3676474094,
-0.1967839599,
0.3961237073,
0.6156131625,
0.1798003465,
0.7253030539,
0.5685264468,
-0.3328710794,
0.2029320896,
0.7181569934,
0.2871478498,
0.7461554408,
0.8829937577,
-0.1210226864,
-0.1478845328,
-0.0423425436,
-0.1081181392,
0.2872605026,
0.0406826213,
-0.3041099012,
-0.0085575739,
-0.0734349117,
-0.0858408734,
0.2049550861,
-0.0255233739,
0.6031271219,
0.3207479715,
-0.700902462,
0.8631352186,
-0.0259594861,
0.4712332487,
-0.4314041138,
0.4697952271,
-0.3162269294,
-0.1259946227,
0.1423675567,
-0.5837637782,
0.4056866467,
-0.3218421638,
0.0551873706,
0.2415444553,
0.6546381116,
-0.4554095566,
-0.1616471559,
0.115325354,
0.2302260101,
0.1333155036,
0.1421338171,
-0.2981220186,
0.0922307447,
-0.3198085725,
-0.0855758712,
0.1755154431,
0.1129767671,
0.0625890344,
0.8438980579,
0.5609470606,
0.5086064339,
0.0650187656,
-0.0909275189,
0.4791055918,
-0.3138921261,
-0.6070122719,
-1.04812181,
-0.1044451222,
-0.1088409722,
-0.172858268,
0.4064681232,
0.5571728349,
0.9279057384,
0.0435719639,
0.7922798991,
-0.2082869411,
0.1453105658,
-0.514131546,
0.3636605442,
-0.6308252811,
0.2042624056,
-0.3099730313,
-1.0399942398,
0.0168865435,
0.4926789105,
-0.5824959874,
-0.1408257037,
1.2117019892,
0.672475636,
0.23183994,
0.3282395303,
0.5716045499,
-0.2305177897,
0.068228811,
0.8191632032,
0.8685370088,
-0.3551043868,
0.6459159255,
-0.4140699208,
-0.2091939151,
-0.2418588847,
-0.7257992029,
-0.6533243656,
-0.8918728828,
-0.1919910312,
-0.2302088886,
0.448114872,
0.8376988173,
0.5864256024,
-0.2419733256,
-0.4283995628,
-0.3628487587,
0.099180378,
-0.389606446,
-0.1621803194,
0.3991191983,
-0.1999273449,
-0.2276680321,
-0.2184655368,
0.47117275,
0.1548367143,
0.0481765978,
-0.2593513429,
-0.0657348409,
0.7005770206,
0.4909695685,
0.4829311073,
-0.9297440052,
-0.6797828078,
-0.0268099122,
-0.3975579739,
-0.0430891849,
0.8493911624,
-0.2666401565,
0.2594170272,
0.7498984933,
0.4824380875,
0.2093446404,
-0.3065488935,
0.7119227648,
-0.5481670499,
0.0053314324,
-0.1185202524,
0.2509128153,
0.1535357237,
-0.4416717589,
0.25946787,
0.2137970179,
-0.4099134505,
-0.6371161342,
0.525919199,
-0.8097067475,
-0.5092175007,
1.1756650209,
0.0826503932,
-0.2632270157,
0.1447529048,
-0.0091614667,
0.1243404672,
-0.0664082691,
0.8693038821,
1.013952136,
-0.0447122641,
-0.3119074106,
-0.5612453818,
0.7051479816,
0.3212263584,
-0.5764786601,
0.191227302,
0.5301440954,
0.2702863514,
0.3669517338,
0.8150342107,
0.041208867,
0.3853981793,
0.1373669058,
-0.3760373592,
0.1364285648,
-0.1316978931,
0.0175711643,
-0.0800596401,
0.0484113693,
-0.0530562773
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.07550v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.07550v1
|
Understanding (Un)Intended Memorization in Text-to-Image Generative Models
| 2023-12-06T19:53:17 | 2023-12-06T19:53:17 |
Ali Naseh, Jaechul Roh, Amir Houmansadr
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CR, cs.LG
|
Multimodal machine learning, especially text-to-image models like Stable
Diffusion and DALL-E 3, has gained significance for transforming text into
detailed images.
Despite their growing use and remarkable generative capabilities, there is a
pressing need for a detailed examination of these models' behavior,
particularly with respect to memorization. Historically, memorization in
machine learning has been context-dependent, with diverse definitions emerging
from classification tasks to complex models like Large Language Models (LLMs)
and Diffusion models. Yet, a definitive concept of memorization that aligns
with the intricacies of text-to-image synthesis remains elusive. This
understanding is vital as memorization poses privacy risks yet is essential for
meeting user expectations, especially when generating representations of
underrepresented entities. In this paper, we introduce a specialized definition
of memorization tailored to text-to-image models, categorizing it into three
distinct types according to user expectations. We closely examine the subtle
distinctions between intended and unintended memorization, emphasizing the
importance of balancing user privacy with the generative quality of the model
outputs. Using the Stable Diffusion model, we offer examples to validate our
memorization definitions and clarify their application.
|
[
-0.1178636476,
-0.6564319134,
0.5437176824,
0.1122592762,
-0.3909134865,
-0.2062318474,
-0.0521254502,
-0.0996332616,
-0.5407469869,
0.61258775,
-0.1912628412,
-0.7509155273,
-0.6399976015,
-0.2538233697,
-0.6663159132,
1.4271740913,
-0.4380320311,
-0.1721931845,
-0.499450624,
-0.2767249942,
-0.3076882064,
-0.641751349,
-0.4695689678,
-0.1932376325,
0.5530009866,
0.1176687181,
0.5490686893,
0.7110256553,
0.4371508062,
0.2787251174,
-0.1526916921,
0.0093000941,
-0.590716064,
0.2053586543,
-0.0095318519,
-0.5690594316,
-0.2799786031,
0.1146003902,
0.7882486582,
0.569341898,
-0.0405178964,
0.2043039501,
-0.034155909,
0.8801534176,
-0.9793729186,
0.1542044431,
-0.6459287405,
0.2915045023,
0.0428205058,
-0.3571857214,
-0.746594727,
0.0277388338,
0.1245310828,
-0.4732797146,
0.4758706689,
-0.2146335989,
0.6519268751,
0.2440843582,
-0.7477760315,
-0.3936947286,
-0.8797748685,
0.4901627898,
-0.0714557543,
0.374322474,
0.4805498421,
0.4057561755,
0.1187917069,
-1.0616130829,
-0.2631168365,
0.2516575754,
-0.1447839141,
0.3320054412,
-0.1764511764,
0.3117462695,
0.3014544547,
0.4704871774,
-0.0306186378,
-0.086387299,
-0.6262984872,
-0.2507715225,
0.3214933574,
0.1045719162,
0.2679049671,
0.2070850283,
-0.5872725844,
0.0766767189,
-0.5987994075,
-0.0121223284,
0.2017668933,
-0.128966555,
-0.1245615259,
0.760801971,
0.2026273459,
0.2697526217,
0.0728233159,
-0.1599720567,
0.1558959931,
-0.1030045599,
-0.365665406,
-0.0334710777,
0.7085831165,
0.6633430719,
0.2037950754,
-0.3920067251,
-0.3241820633,
-0.1504313946,
0.4040471017,
-0.9987694025,
-0.2745059133,
0.0334994793,
-0.7707788348,
-0.0370235071,
-0.1275389344,
-0.6239444613,
-0.2178328186,
-0.1328013986,
0.6237132549,
-0.4484639764,
-0.0141862109,
-0.1180942878,
-0.3228455186,
-0.3974183798,
0.4848024249,
-0.9260031581,
0.2280168235,
0.3381970525,
0.5918236375,
0.019953372,
-0.4947083592,
-0.1260574907,
0.7989550829,
-0.3920334876,
0.5002390146,
-0.2039186209,
-0.5811417699,
0.1037353799,
-0.0508214049,
-0.4467655122,
-0.227534309,
0.3560079932,
-0.6892058253,
0.42105335,
0.0952804759,
-0.7469859719,
-0.7901364565,
0.1655543596,
-0.5404473543,
0.4313009083,
0.0559933148,
-0.7938664556,
0.319070518,
-0.5320057273,
-0.4355007112,
-0.193703115,
-0.0578448772,
-0.8145308495,
0.4407940805,
-0.1709959954,
0.8500617743,
0.1050357074,
0.200773865,
-0.201065883,
-0.3549182117,
0.5994557142,
-0.7176479101,
0.2678400576,
0.3924481571,
-0.1055849195,
-0.0548135787,
-0.7345910668,
0.0037625569,
0.0012631835,
-0.547749877,
-0.470272392,
-0.0445949547,
-0.0950989053,
0.1286567152,
0.350592196,
-0.1011582986,
-0.2437597364,
0.0093422523,
0.6706573367,
0.7107998133,
0.219029516,
0.8445849419,
-0.2173877954,
0.2332432568,
0.4418863356,
0.2604346573,
-0.8624902964,
-0.4062483311,
-0.5846893191,
-0.4465978444,
0.2173951119,
0.3745537102,
-0.1535798013,
-0.025723571,
-0.1839822382,
-0.1267400235,
-0.2337779254,
0.2620634139,
0.7980710268,
0.2989374995,
0.1946382821,
-0.4762299955,
-0.2351852059,
-0.9687585831,
-0.1948968917,
-0.1312430054,
0.0440738723,
0.4434781969,
0.5200027823,
-0.638389349,
0.7244068384,
-0.1717542261,
-0.5303416252,
0.1546854824,
0.2571964562,
-0.5157127976,
0.3734001219,
0.3907520473,
-1.1063046455,
-0.3135935664,
-0.0186628196,
-0.5704097152,
0.5140827894,
-0.4111127257,
-0.0790144578,
0.4425000548,
0.6349800229,
-0.7814233899,
0.7140188217,
0.3040251434,
-0.0647393987,
-0.1137075201,
-0.6344461441,
0.1721001863,
-1.1324509382,
-0.0111058475,
-0.149527967,
-0.1934488714,
-0.6762681007,
0.1793377399,
0.4625849724,
-0.0398727804,
-0.5688555837,
0.2638087869,
-0.7620677352,
-0.1740952432,
0.0184076317,
-0.2750629485,
0.1389497668,
0.4739035666,
0.0388197005,
0.5829330683,
0.589145422,
-0.8608570695,
-0.318005234,
0.1665821373,
-0.1368548572,
0.3444768488,
-0.3424752951,
0.3851850927,
-0.3818422258,
0.0674050152,
-1.0601719618,
-0.3164934218,
0.1980386376,
-0.3927126527,
0.607072413,
-0.2762251198,
-0.7213492393,
-0.0706392229,
-0.1809149086,
0.7832421064,
0.7459887266,
-0.5788398981,
0.7007017732,
0.448508352,
0.4530111849,
-0.5075263977,
-0.6879186034,
-0.2285976857,
-0.5201069117,
-0.3289176524,
0.5058024526,
-0.0013826208,
-0.0526263192,
-0.0419733264,
-0.0442823172,
-0.4371649325,
0.1988093555,
0.7718113065,
-0.0121673914,
0.1476352513,
0.1612517536,
0.0793115422,
0.0179260746,
0.1929519624,
-0.0813155249,
0.1571348608,
-0.1138088629,
-0.3923801482,
-0.4088310599,
0.3372978568,
0.6499896049,
-0.1446472406,
0.8155887723,
0.7663488984,
-0.4206363261,
-0.0975297913,
-0.3777862489,
0.0418864451,
-0.4640212953,
0.126808688,
-0.3930458128,
-0.7255687118,
0.737147212,
-0.322090745,
0.0468829498,
0.2604606748,
0.5651583076,
-0.4111405313,
1.0296776295,
0.6050046682,
0.4331327081,
0.3347319961,
-0.0910105258,
0.1463323385,
-0.8489953876,
-0.6185562611,
-0.1757643223,
-0.146501258,
-0.5433399677,
-0.4222845733,
0.159096241,
0.1720785201,
-0.1571461111,
0.1076001301,
-0.2824964225,
0.6638801098,
0.3882739246,
0.2509356141,
0.1914916337,
0.2100858986,
-0.1481409967,
0.0818031281,
-0.2879099846,
-0.5521514416,
1.3845967054,
0.4743519127,
0.9218639135,
0.0055306815,
0.8629630804,
0.1765217632,
0.3252240121,
-0.5655056834,
0.6203870773,
-0.4370032847,
-0.8730706573,
0.0287712142,
-0.304420948,
-0.9447889328,
0.162906006,
0.0604710318,
-0.503133297,
0.0487416163,
0.619987905,
-0.0531223863,
0.29021734,
-1.1175707579,
1.0483994484,
-0.1548222601,
-0.3537764251,
-0.2632780373,
-0.7400943637,
0.5238941312,
-0.0704539493,
0.1807893962,
0.002267167,
-0.1401430219,
0.5047323108,
0.1573697478,
1.0030165911,
-0.0703644753,
0.0680460706,
0.3224646449,
0.1266567558,
0.138081789,
-0.0891157761,
0.3336233199,
0.2286842316,
-0.1910419315,
-0.1912377477,
-0.3773657382,
0.4602380991,
-0.6685768366,
-0.6101182103,
-0.0956269577,
-0.6623507142,
0.1705240309,
0.2199561,
0.4977868795,
0.1915989071,
-0.5594245791,
0.1812982261,
1.1635894775,
-0.232212916,
0.3115421832,
0.448241502,
-0.1952970326,
-0.3245225847,
0.8322459459,
0.0935778469,
0.3662274182,
0.6099611521,
-0.0362082757,
-0.4772855937,
-0.7896332741,
-0.2388697863,
-0.0157607123,
-1.2658842802,
0.1869509965,
-0.8092091084,
-0.2406842709,
-0.2078260332,
-0.0979826599,
-0.2661985457,
-0.496612072,
-0.9741294384,
-0.1341479123,
0.0820553005,
0.3709295094,
0.1625262946,
0.2961413264,
-0.8047956228,
0.6069118977,
0.4632856548,
0.3456710875,
-0.1692964137,
-0.5835987926,
-0.0616393574,
-0.1623805314,
-0.5947161913,
-0.8640454412,
0.1965091079,
0.5372823477,
0.6085003614,
0.7814733982,
-0.0543027706,
0.6575421691,
-0.6593943238,
0.5662897825,
0.3575089574,
-0.7910600305,
0.5538821816,
-0.3051345646,
0.0784363896,
0.3530225158,
0.2812681198,
-0.4025173187,
-0.2777835727,
-0.6801915169,
-0.9539161325,
0.5179916024,
0.1463074088,
0.6916321516,
-0.1805841029,
0.4510971606,
0.2931307256,
0.3399440348,
-1.001262188,
-0.2349043339,
-0.4307029247,
-0.1041660905,
-0.1883884519,
-0.6657782197,
-0.3277409375,
0.0426989645,
0.2933552861,
0.1753505617,
0.4301434159,
-0.195234403,
-0.4637144208,
-0.0010174339,
0.4810527861,
0.7461436391,
0.3764983714,
-0.1814856529,
0.2802024484,
-0.1259540021,
-0.3636325002,
0.1666706502,
-0.0112153748,
-0.4968792796,
-0.0426266417,
-0.0389248952,
0.9453166127,
0.109628126,
-0.3394548595,
0.5615254641,
-0.0764099807,
-0.3133027554,
-0.4655391872,
0.2445818782,
0.0727008805,
-0.2231313437,
0.0734856278,
0.4987656772,
0.3213510215,
-0.5995083451,
0.0711518228,
0.4310911894,
-0.445109874,
-0.4160161018,
0.8559777737,
0.0729922578,
-0.2306224257,
0.6289829016,
-0.0934585035,
-0.3671251237,
0.5956761837,
0.5673527718,
1.0591779947,
-0.4108356237,
0.3034265041,
0.3718408942,
0.3402533829,
-0.3087574244,
0.1236320809,
-0.3994733393,
-0.5625322461,
0.4228919744,
-0.1153326407,
0.0150473947,
-0.0948905051,
-0.8777503967,
0.0273665655,
-0.6196238995,
-0.4004961252,
0.1087486446,
-0.8280302286,
-0.6851089597,
0.2462403923,
0.0796376243,
0.574996829,
-0.7129617333,
0.6104397178,
0.6669419408,
-0.2278838605,
-0.4366463721,
0.2125573754,
-0.0412273854,
-0.8114551902,
0.6398596168,
0.6575418711,
0.1793787926,
-0.130245164,
-0.2338993251,
-0.2638716102,
1.0888552666,
0.1879715919,
-0.3763096035,
0.0539963692,
0.2268252522,
0.6654865742,
-0.352910161,
0.1384639442,
0.1783134788,
0.1810396463,
0.0613959506,
-0.4061254263,
-0.1243597567,
-0.1197673455,
0.5310711861,
0.230302006,
-0.5487957597,
0.9225154519,
-0.7304578424,
-0.6433025002,
0.0094959801,
0.4116727412,
-0.0346988738,
0.8242189884,
0.3013498187,
0.570828557,
0.4785930812,
-0.0095434021,
1.0613226891,
-0.0019162102,
0.1218183786,
0.8687049747,
0.0108763343,
0.6380645633,
0.6882100701,
0.0629611239,
0.158576116,
0.812274754,
0.0089445673,
0.8746296167,
0.0784671754,
-0.3653229475,
-0.1491391808,
0.1290507168,
-0.271474719,
0.1462026685,
0.6452431679,
-1.0453195572,
-0.3029913902,
0.1199104413,
-0.20196639,
0.1584561616,
-0.52142483,
1.1181770563,
0.0634713769,
-0.7641934752,
0.4925320446,
0.1350483447,
0.198784247,
-0.2768496573,
0.1618267447,
-0.0915651545,
0.4109754562,
-0.1639519334,
-0.8694164753,
0.271401614,
-0.10067413,
-0.5615265965,
-0.4629734755,
0.3848699927,
-0.4530800283,
-0.3462824523,
0.266911447,
0.0877995938,
0.4048570096,
0.0563100055,
-0.8094776273,
-0.2413001209,
0.0296654254,
-0.2976474464,
0.5032556057,
0.5855841041,
-0.2284378111,
0.6387078762,
0.3933022618,
-0.5780121088,
0.3514227867,
0.1568420976,
0.5253528357,
-0.3144037426,
-0.4503866434,
-1.0591921806,
0.59246701,
0.3720043302,
-0.2479549497,
0.7645074725,
0.6877875924,
0.7550806999,
-0.4816559851,
0.5818652511,
0.3942116797,
0.0678391606,
-0.7254309058,
0.6918244362,
-0.5355781913,
0.2943347692,
-0.1069957763,
-0.6191511154,
-0.2565445006,
0.4465673268,
-0.0094869053,
0.0323754065,
0.6486888528,
0.6027168036,
-0.1793924421,
-0.1587575972,
0.4700535834,
-0.0577086769,
0.0114084771,
0.7133526206,
1.037587285,
-0.5178251863,
0.8346198797,
-0.359372437,
0.0620799325,
-0.0048856316,
-0.9069378972,
-1.2035740614,
-0.8864465356,
-0.5977107286,
-0.1911561638,
0.0824449137,
0.2128970474,
0.740879178,
-0.4300480783,
0.1064619571,
-0.3582979739,
0.121803768,
-0.0003074626,
-0.0898359641,
0.3092792034,
-0.1913578063,
-0.6771618128,
-0.2098414004,
0.4413746893,
0.8549487591,
0.0371076129,
-0.0913535208,
0.4765472412,
0.0281074438,
0.4955482185,
0.3745922744,
-0.7852239609,
0.2682746053,
-0.2467626929,
-0.3129477501,
0.2399707139,
0.7886139154,
-0.356469214,
0.5558742881,
0.2805354595,
0.3765587509,
0.7823830247,
-0.0587395988,
0.3638691306,
-0.9857698679,
0.2294646651,
0.0085412906,
0.350325644,
0.3993635774,
-0.5636234879,
0.145964399,
-0.0287797116,
-0.4278334975,
-0.8017413616,
0.4336996675,
-0.8190444112,
-0.4510725737,
1.0531100035,
-0.6048465371,
-0.2597603202,
0.0978382751,
-0.1490986645,
0.164159745,
-0.1976897866,
1.1116379499,
0.6119099855,
0.2975227237,
-0.477855593,
-0.3843042254,
0.4726687074,
0.1441351622,
-0.6025672555,
0.0364844278,
0.6102375388,
0.304736793,
0.2317879349,
0.7411587834,
-0.3640640378,
0.6080310345,
-0.2488697469,
-0.0303016156,
-0.0621511154,
-0.4214295745,
-0.232557863,
0.3665089011,
-0.1333371252,
-0.5856355429
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03872v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03872v1
|
The BigCode Project Governance Card
| 2023-12-06T19:37:08 | 2023-12-06T19:37:08 |
BigCode collaboration, Sean Hughes, Harm de Vries, Jennifer Robinson, Carlos Muñoz Ferrandis, Loubna Ben Allal, Leandro von Werra, Jennifer Ding, Sebastien Paquet, Yacine Jernite
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.PL
|
This document serves as an overview of the different mechanisms and areas of
governance in the BigCode project. It aims to support transparency by providing
relevant information about choices that were made during the project to the
broader public, and to serve as an example of intentional governance of an open
research project that future endeavors can leverage to shape their own
approach. The first section, Project Structure, covers the project
organization, its stated goals and values, its internal decision processes, and
its funding and resources. The second section, Data and Model Governance,
covers decisions relating to the questions of data subject consent, privacy,
and model release.
|
[
-0.5043608546,
-0.4003257453,
0.6970854402,
0.0689471662,
-0.2960020602,
0.0609522872,
-0.0587682053,
-0.5210843682,
0.379781574,
0.8823160529,
-0.2455780953,
-0.7616335154,
-0.685672462,
-0.0618183203,
-0.4132446051,
1.3078930378,
-0.3174554706,
0.0894280896,
-0.2393393517,
0.1959007829,
-0.5510197282,
-0.7059084773,
-0.3450889885,
-0.2976834178,
0.7092536688,
0.6184235215,
0.9717330337,
0.9665275812,
0.7730023265,
0.2259482443,
-0.5183675289,
-0.3080305159,
-0.4506021738,
-0.4820924699,
-0.5216528177,
-0.905579865,
-0.6239185929,
0.5221475959,
0.4828936458,
0.2754948735,
-0.3470225334,
0.6354624033,
-0.0884583592,
0.701752305,
-0.7630108595,
0.6581988335,
-0.0771664158,
0.2881987989,
-0.2865664959,
-0.1657971293,
-0.0048492481,
-0.5216565132,
-0.4162059426,
-0.3348264098,
0.2633129656,
0.2408077568,
0.5240356326,
-0.0360506177,
-0.2272894979,
-0.7820166945,
-0.9256125689,
0.1025436297,
-0.3617693782,
-0.1876598746,
0.7024876475,
0.4266374409,
0.0801477656,
-0.8504818082,
-0.6129778624,
0.0636375919,
-0.2157152593,
0.2224606872,
0.0979957208,
0.6530204415,
0.5297042131,
0.9086410403,
-0.4057068527,
-0.0904655308,
-1.0678393841,
-0.091606304,
0.661496222,
0.1583776474,
0.0764098689,
-0.3440269828,
-0.1172733381,
-0.0749280155,
-0.6983035803,
0.027831044,
0.7632606626,
0.0462731533,
-0.4939863384,
0.6473222375,
-0.0204544906,
0.4483247101,
-0.084237054,
0.3342186213,
0.3827893734,
-0.3935035467,
-0.5121317506,
0.5227959156,
0.1713558584,
0.4402630627,
-0.1674709171,
-0.0429451242,
-0.0764811933,
-0.010421358,
0.5398287177,
-0.8091795444,
-0.0787981376,
0.7025645971,
-1.0225595236,
-0.3352958858,
0.6418941617,
-0.7672399879,
-0.2207210362,
-0.8593625426,
0.2622300386,
0.1967151612,
-0.4380106628,
0.1977473944,
-0.5437353849,
0.6537203193,
0.0569776893,
-0.9391994476,
0.2531274855,
1.1617116928,
0.8126551509,
0.2276331186,
-0.1604051143,
-0.2168640643,
0.4611088932,
-0.4472698271,
-0.0003591348,
-0.8268221617,
-0.6176559925,
0.1719199121,
0.1950350404,
0.2301270217,
-0.2710997462,
0.6006022096,
-0.3486797214,
0.1105942056,
-0.5461014509,
-0.382886827,
-0.0844800472,
0.2729139924,
-0.9249317646,
0.5751348138,
-0.3473356366,
-0.7531807423,
0.5908349752,
-1.2546759844,
-0.0451759249,
0.1766858399,
-0.3595587611,
-0.1091558933,
0.6169484258,
-0.1560230851,
0.4523410797,
-0.3250642121,
0.5018703938,
-0.0278002545,
-0.5620530844,
0.0413543396,
0.028463535,
0.769694984,
0.3659706414,
-0.1435185969,
0.4911312759,
-0.559351027,
0.0010970185,
-0.206201449,
-0.5317270756,
-0.2909663022,
-0.1061124429,
0.0105425371,
0.1011133566,
0.1097935811,
-0.5045653582,
0.7304773331,
0.0609389842,
0.7908437252,
0.6975769401,
0.1986218989,
0.506429255,
-0.1725540161,
0.6023575664,
0.1287333965,
1.0656493902,
-0.0887151659,
-0.7866182923,
-0.3933129013,
-0.1023661718,
0.7735142708,
0.2251734585,
-0.1973712742,
0.3253376484,
-0.0748620927,
-0.4076730311,
-0.6933121681,
-0.3036066592,
0.5370835066,
-0.1163247824,
-0.0111453356,
-0.5493167639,
-0.3934195042,
-1.0452288389,
0.4591799974,
-0.3430122137,
0.115427427,
0.3628774285,
1.2147248983,
-0.1846166551,
0.7286380529,
-0.6296921968,
-0.1943285167,
0.2281982154,
0.3032123446,
0.6544454098,
0.6106045842,
0.4488700926,
-1.5430996418,
0.0345850959,
-0.1793944687,
-0.5430887341,
0.4179686308,
0.3453668058,
-0.5428013802,
-0.5298957825,
0.4599742293,
-0.7857907414,
0.785956502,
0.6034654379,
-0.5573467016,
0.3216416538,
-0.4219799638,
0.5924288034,
-0.9139808416,
0.330252558,
-0.6171362996,
0.3240462542,
-0.5063135028,
0.4805498123,
0.2321804762,
-0.3599807024,
-0.1895420849,
0.1488295645,
-0.3857153654,
-0.2824405432,
-0.0477277935,
-0.1130575389,
0.1852094382,
0.2330137938,
-0.0540394261,
0.5868878961,
0.7781437039,
-0.5138661861,
0.3330850899,
0.4272824824,
-0.2282719463,
0.4503409564,
-0.7171440125,
0.3261893392,
-0.5525413156,
0.0998308286,
-0.7647107244,
-0.509299159,
0.4112149775,
-0.7622658014,
0.3542525172,
-0.4354782104,
-0.7910019755,
-0.6671969295,
-0.2450066209,
0.0565095618,
0.4902815521,
-0.4861245453,
0.652305007,
0.6666765809,
0.2479480952,
-0.2248704284,
-0.9901382923,
0.2568579018,
-0.1432158202,
-0.2959314585,
0.3040162623,
-0.4298354387,
-0.198137328,
0.2939976156,
0.2193010449,
-0.4483959377,
-0.0586410277,
0.9593365192,
-0.0624408424,
-0.233210668,
-0.0042947414,
-0.0285286568,
-0.0053862287,
0.259051621,
-0.4011721909,
0.113367036,
0.2856426835,
-0.3168441951,
-0.1287272274,
0.6487374306,
0.6788393855,
-0.5728138685,
0.7940509319,
0.3077483177,
-0.5061228275,
0.0971947089,
-0.1346397698,
0.1947249472,
-0.43247509,
-0.1476711333,
-0.4314391017,
-0.7510798573,
0.761362493,
0.0957141891,
0.1477477103,
0.1336762607,
0.6778922081,
0.210713163,
0.7490134239,
0.8440711498,
-0.2804852426,
0.0860061571,
-0.1887422055,
0.300034374,
-0.9074285626,
-0.8075194359,
-1.0318323374,
-0.3728337884,
-0.5036247969,
-0.5512363911,
-0.061901018,
0.7179008722,
-0.2232691944,
0.2430842072,
-0.8392530084,
0.6654533744,
0.912057519,
0.1381919831,
0.2036746144,
-0.1734454632,
-0.0406475998,
0.3493233025,
-0.528834641,
-0.6641657948,
1.0590565205,
0.599371314,
0.6472500563,
0.4103964269,
0.9593817592,
0.5217002034,
0.2782023847,
-0.320496887,
0.4224896133,
0.2040759474,
-1.383800149,
-0.1996303648,
-0.1335635632,
-0.7071971893,
-0.0661901683,
-0.1952821612,
-0.5101752877,
0.5579160452,
0.267744571,
-0.0390155166,
0.3331947625,
-0.8099756241,
0.6393809915,
0.0356524736,
-0.3087408543,
-0.4176054895,
-0.4062313437,
0.3093967438,
0.0025709621,
0.2702277899,
0.2511643469,
-0.0268300604,
0.7316777706,
-0.358104527,
0.8014242649,
-0.3673349619,
0.1543198526,
0.5946085453,
-0.2441743016,
0.320954442,
0.2989148498,
-0.2746942341,
0.506529808,
-0.2117218971,
-0.1762646437,
-0.2318753153,
0.4229249954,
-0.5855131149,
-0.4797112346,
-0.4253019392,
-0.3369296789,
0.1130548641,
0.1357458234,
-0.0952940807,
0.3784732521,
-0.0412445515,
0.4680125415,
0.6898308396,
-0.3088155687,
0.2506469786,
0.3099746108,
-0.2327727377,
-0.1601419598,
0.2724744081,
-0.065740414,
-0.0583014674,
0.5120029449,
0.4777825773,
-0.2076532096,
-1.0686181784,
-0.2515045404,
-0.1305776983,
-0.7098040581,
-0.0953359231,
-0.2159384638,
-0.2351759374,
-0.5089888573,
-0.2208093852,
-0.0017111575,
0.0129091451,
0.0040285923,
-0.5260285139,
0.2089935988,
1.0136370659,
-0.4890947342,
0.2420478463,
-0.5657964945,
0.4393294156,
0.1019995883,
0.8159839511,
-0.2668382525,
0.1224922314,
-0.1461611986,
-0.0538925491,
0.0442723855,
-0.6551256776,
-0.1804015636,
-0.3410824835,
0.81095469,
0.2916529775,
-0.0911605507,
0.5221047401,
-0.392288506,
0.9718205333,
0.3376176357,
-0.8163583875,
0.8324704766,
-0.3565936983,
0.0846308544,
0.6219897866,
0.460297972,
-0.1338124722,
-0.1677977741,
-0.6526252627,
-0.5662668943,
0.7509741187,
0.4611018598,
0.1294095218,
0.1738436371,
0.6949529052,
-0.0816310421,
0.7210083008,
-0.7674207687,
-0.3009105921,
-0.0446144305,
0.10369353,
0.1124079153,
-0.7152637243,
-0.6492865086,
-0.0910719261,
0.2318173051,
0.2793407142,
0.4145278931,
0.1980510652,
0.4692488611,
-0.1254739761,
0.2816596031,
0.2608026266,
1.1794798374,
-0.3062178195,
-0.2206647992,
-0.4176796377,
-0.8542240262,
-0.1821707189,
-0.1202272549,
-0.3057214916,
-0.3081527948,
0.6546741724,
0.8133912683,
-0.0681504458,
-0.2655537426,
0.6121248603,
-0.0693167746,
-0.7662135363,
-0.2234371305,
0.1899130642,
-0.0382290073,
0.5985375643,
0.2265912592,
-0.2850067914,
0.4843050539,
-1.036509037,
0.1528012305,
0.0626508817,
-0.3372086585,
-0.1108404696,
0.8471879959,
0.3328226209,
-0.3893134594,
0.4414055049,
0.0270394012,
-0.2879513502,
0.9590358734,
0.1556012034,
0.6530311704,
-0.1415840536,
0.3434024155,
0.4142099917,
0.6899299026,
-0.1559057385,
0.6127939224,
-0.1697585583,
-0.1192524433,
-0.3682243526,
-0.7106969953,
-0.4702225029,
0.1128738746,
-1.0549584627,
0.0816916227,
-0.6607919931,
-0.1044928432,
0.0677693635,
-0.0313184746,
-0.5737733841,
0.4296981692,
0.3263645768,
1.3336349726,
-0.7292187214,
0.8364551067,
0.4931942225,
-0.5474787951,
-0.7304154038,
-0.0712312013,
-0.1539661735,
-0.6587352157,
0.8304421306,
-0.091168955,
0.184586212,
-0.563957274,
-0.9574533105,
-0.703363061,
1.171857357,
0.0040222271,
-0.8189953566,
-0.3021684587,
0.0963109732,
0.397549063,
-0.2050774544,
-0.0408451669,
0.1653506458,
1.0920877457,
0.3494935632,
-0.8147720695,
-0.0581246875,
-0.0701387525,
-0.0575723462,
0.491753608,
-0.4400680661,
0.9975605607,
-0.0306163263,
-0.13179636,
-0.1441853344,
0.3271194994,
-0.0306103285,
0.3506724536,
0.2204856575,
0.264254272,
0.7398130298,
-0.3457662165,
1.1769735813,
-0.5529673696,
0.3062112629,
1.0526691675,
-0.1242872328,
0.4224304259,
0.4440737367,
-0.0737795085,
-0.1045623049,
0.5399485826,
-0.2564181387,
0.6204396486,
0.5834537148,
0.3204877675,
0.2546077371,
-0.0459249057,
-0.5481999516,
0.4868013263,
0.3718484044,
-0.579475224,
0.1500571668,
0.0064299088,
-0.0277652927,
-0.0613861084,
-1.0170087814,
0.3420692086,
-0.1722135544,
-0.5793792605,
-0.3524919748,
0.2893188,
0.243852511,
-0.8036373854,
-0.5497410297,
-0.0121152652,
0.0701412335,
-0.514282465,
-1.3312542439,
0.6004804969,
-0.0876565874,
-0.5840494633,
-0.2375001907,
0.3590994775,
-0.0411985032,
-0.266503185,
0.3886607587,
-0.2370876521,
0.1407970041,
-0.2037539184,
-0.8094629049,
0.456433177,
-0.147062704,
-0.0979352891,
0.0073710568,
0.48617208,
-0.1555680633,
0.1637780368,
0.6217677593,
0.4278870225,
-0.0014019568,
0.1291775256,
0.6269165874,
-0.9860649109,
-0.7614492178,
-0.6373089552,
0.3567400277,
-0.4891780913,
-0.6832911372,
0.6336861849,
0.9143247008,
0.730427146,
-0.0198076461,
0.8097625971,
-0.5165386796,
0.0236581564,
-0.8350589275,
0.5928695202,
-0.135503605,
-0.0815686658,
-0.11928913,
-0.812654376,
-0.4602017701,
0.3720230162,
-0.0698870197,
-0.1493387371,
0.3879778981,
0.7546963096,
0.0089092311,
0.288161546,
0.2488958389,
0.3167417645,
0.3895035684,
0.4605389535,
0.4491873682,
-0.2282595783,
0.4351806939,
-0.0727326199,
-0.3691000342,
-0.0658005103,
-0.9236197472,
-1.167945385,
-0.7985725403,
-0.3247213066,
-0.2208042145,
0.2558773756,
0.4146639407,
1.2603598833,
-0.5876858234,
-0.1862902939,
-0.0285297818,
0.0826754943,
0.0044522421,
-0.1164858863,
0.4946951866,
0.4738031924,
-0.4239800274,
-0.220393315,
0.4298742712,
-0.2931218743,
-0.3284809887,
-0.0479742177,
-0.1940936297,
0.1281743795,
0.4687559903,
0.2896360159,
-0.1737723351,
-0.1896433681,
-0.6277240515,
-0.0641298965,
-0.1213282794,
1.1742390394,
-0.0890697762,
0.2780640423,
0.5922950506,
0.2269829214,
0.7300239801,
-0.0521968901,
0.3521917164,
-0.3509796262,
0.2920460105,
0.0431317724,
0.1664083302,
-0.3120962679,
-0.6393277645,
0.7311015129,
-0.465613544,
-0.5654652119,
-0.5549612641,
0.1740351319,
-0.8289211392,
-0.5164210796,
0.9586555362,
0.1894277036,
-0.4878668189,
-0.2401869744,
-0.3299779594,
-0.114985317,
-0.1967404038,
0.5245596766,
0.8149604201,
0.0155778751,
0.1673339307,
-1.0504565239,
0.4252488017,
-0.8548623919,
-0.908490479,
0.1014560685,
0.5243648887,
-0.0181007776,
0.2731292844,
0.869199276,
-0.6798419356,
-0.1015650779,
0.1008139774,
0.3686759472,
-0.2548727989,
-0.6929923296,
-0.3187505603,
0.6298677921,
0.0438883789,
-0.5668038726
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03863v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03863v4
|
Efficient Large Language Models: A Survey
| 2023-12-06T19:18:42 | 2024-05-23T06:08:37 |
Zhongwei Wan, Xin Wang, Che Liu, Samiul Alam, Yu Zheng, Jiachen Liu, Zhongnan Qu, Shen Yan, Yi Zhu, Quanlu Zhang, Mosharaf Chowdhury, Mi Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have demonstrated remarkable capabilities in
important tasks such as natural language understanding and language generation,
and thus have the potential to make a substantial impact on our society. Such
capabilities, however, come with the considerable resources they demand,
highlighting the strong need to develop effective techniques for addressing
their efficiency challenges. In this survey, we provide a systematic and
comprehensive review of efficient LLMs research. We organize the literature in
a taxonomy consisting of three main categories, covering distinct yet
interconnected efficient LLMs topics from model-centric, data-centric, and
framework-centric perspective, respectively. We have also created a GitHub
repository where we organize the papers featured in this survey at
https://github.com/AIoT-MLSys-Lab/Efficient-LLMs-Survey. We will actively
maintain the repository and incorporate new research as it emerges. We hope our
survey can serve as a valuable resource to help researchers and practitioners
gain a systematic understanding of efficient LLMs research and inspire them to
contribute to this important and exciting field.
|
[
-0.3526360989,
-1.03926754,
0.5422568917,
0.3319294751,
-0.0504785478,
0.0328128673,
-0.483304143,
-0.300021559,
0.1429255307,
0.5013503432,
-0.0839674026,
-0.4057183564,
-0.6501926184,
0.236170724,
-0.7289293408,
0.5795640945,
0.0291970614,
0.3523035049,
-0.184829995,
-0.1551350355,
0.045042526,
-0.6109140515,
-0.5712660551,
-0.3691978157,
0.588508904,
0.2603912055,
0.3609643877,
0.6640561223,
0.6851046681,
0.3137943149,
-0.3265312314,
0.0590901487,
-0.6566272378,
0.3890979588,
-0.0925228447,
-0.2365102172,
-0.5998584628,
-0.1704311967,
0.8295267224,
0.9131110907,
-0.4538674951,
0.4041190743,
0.029162541,
0.6725224853,
-0.5417917967,
0.0752870664,
-0.6483201981,
-0.1958327293,
-0.4178577065,
0.0014333914,
-0.4158826172,
-0.3980665803,
0.0112349223,
-0.3281891048,
-0.1822777539,
0.0514795966,
0.1751844138,
-0.0099153416,
-0.4614161253,
-0.508972168,
-0.7503114939,
0.9310890436,
-0.660867691,
0.6321205497,
0.0220062528,
0.1764755696,
-0.1043775752,
-0.7958332896,
-0.3738662899,
-0.3113672137,
0.1034983099,
-0.143826589,
-0.3987436295,
-0.0493723974,
0.1412740052,
0.4266970158,
-0.5162007809,
0.5077065229,
-0.125869453,
-0.1860786676,
0.6339401603,
0.4066711366,
0.2970044613,
-0.1216650978,
-0.0823046118,
0.1920648962,
-0.716792047,
-0.2629901469,
0.4143835306,
0.3259937167,
0.1167986467,
0.7747875452,
-0.194251135,
0.9132149816,
-0.3596309721,
-0.3570106924,
0.0792188942,
-0.554363966,
-0.1074491218,
-0.3761502504,
0.8710373044,
0.2021861821,
0.1157020926,
-0.2359585315,
-0.6486577988,
-0.1400291622,
0.1396939605,
-0.8986495137,
0.009663499,
0.1525447965,
-0.4593363404,
-0.1679323912,
-0.3521169126,
-0.5074601173,
-0.466439873,
-0.4073163867,
0.0354893506,
-0.266245842,
-0.4808564186,
-0.0074060434,
0.0126020266,
0.2370787859,
0.3496238887,
-0.6676392555,
0.2666938901,
0.8865431547,
0.9465023875,
-0.1757162213,
0.0211856551,
-0.2509962618,
0.0676849559,
-0.4298231602,
0.6038367748,
-0.3607969582,
-0.4137837887,
0.3558979332,
-0.2411673069,
0.1002819017,
-0.5743515491,
0.6855843663,
-0.6110803485,
0.1219596192,
-0.3346408308,
-0.6468448043,
-0.1863702983,
0.4614700675,
-0.7480754256,
0.8108004928,
0.0387280323,
-0.7290202975,
-0.0617271289,
-0.591214776,
-0.2966585457,
0.1870706975,
-0.0648815483,
-0.2212172449,
0.3422233164,
-0.0553014576,
0.8899906278,
-0.7891865969,
0.5781163573,
-0.3003990352,
-0.1167971566,
0.3916449249,
-0.4143748879,
0.7734690309,
0.5235595703,
-0.1463674009,
0.1013760641,
-0.8178955913,
-0.0422912464,
0.2389766276,
-0.4095880985,
-0.4995065629,
0.0857461244,
0.1668858975,
-0.1107456014,
0.3948134482,
-0.4866613746,
0.3886924386,
-0.2177287936,
0.4768602252,
0.5398002863,
-0.1999723613,
0.6005526185,
-0.1759721488,
0.4433559775,
-0.2944030762,
0.1523627043,
-0.0707749352,
-0.1496091187,
-0.7646425366,
-0.4939733148,
0.2219626755,
0.2789824307,
-0.6949980855,
0.3940494359,
-0.3481439948,
-0.7976799607,
-0.2642610967,
0.2057175785,
0.3625621498,
0.1914183199,
-0.0168863311,
-0.1505143493,
-0.3709888458,
-0.9841014147,
-0.2323343754,
-0.2687012851,
0.0567813106,
0.3955075145,
0.4571033716,
-0.3232742548,
0.8525133729,
-0.4660721123,
0.0502679162,
-0.4935516417,
-0.0315563008,
0.2307592779,
0.1590450257,
0.6280696988,
-0.5118325949,
-0.4500608146,
-0.0631300211,
-0.5805978775,
-0.3272491992,
0.3769701719,
0.0933834836,
0.4322718084,
0.4848012328,
-0.7102640867,
-0.2570818365,
0.7554268241,
-0.1342855394,
0.4207552969,
-0.0291953739,
0.0694971979,
-0.8662419915,
0.4053453505,
0.0201566331,
-0.1960259676,
-1.0004116297,
0.3002435267,
0.1259590983,
0.2042058706,
-0.1734099239,
0.5697747469,
-0.7239041328,
-0.0114342803,
-0.2371714264,
0.167314738,
-0.3975748122,
0.0865650252,
-0.1271459907,
0.7835044861,
0.4596764743,
-0.5485309362,
0.4045518339,
-0.0315991864,
-0.5199849606,
0.1729479879,
-0.6073541045,
0.0159090906,
-0.2548111975,
0.2885231674,
-0.8612627983,
-0.4227543771,
0.3174791932,
-0.2161128521,
0.3256491721,
0.1833634526,
-0.8892165422,
-0.1749114841,
-0.4169495106,
0.3092493117,
0.4290785789,
-0.4205648303,
0.4729265273,
0.7405254245,
-0.351708442,
-0.5645558834,
-0.5385049582,
0.0334969237,
-0.3733693361,
-0.3889497221,
-0.2297701389,
-0.0704382062,
-0.6985805035,
-0.0481878147,
0.2223335356,
-0.0255862493,
0.2720634639,
-0.1860095114,
-0.0092046754,
-0.058729995,
0.4139821827,
-0.3838731945,
0.2271448225,
0.2603725791,
-0.1624060422,
0.8868477941,
-0.1261893511,
-0.3067061305,
-0.1357098669,
0.4666697383,
0.7798877358,
-0.2821326852,
0.7345229387,
0.5578753352,
-0.2150216103,
-0.3131005764,
-0.9049313068,
-0.0597629473,
-0.3887794614,
0.5417701602,
-0.1499496102,
-1.2164857388,
0.5215562582,
-0.1408600956,
0.4643732905,
0.4387747943,
0.842649579,
0.2189566642,
0.8982202411,
0.6371825337,
-0.2216008902,
0.4978021979,
-0.1854391545,
0.4236563146,
-0.7711312175,
-0.2243850231,
-0.8442422748,
0.0049259234,
-0.5201203227,
-0.6409144402,
0.2288694978,
0.0467441566,
-0.2182154655,
0.1665187925,
-0.3693032563,
0.0119551159,
0.2350199819,
-0.3818324506,
0.5058332682,
-0.0607779324,
0.0657588542,
0.1680903733,
-0.8214452863,
-0.7095295787,
1.1623005867,
0.5011184216,
0.8419470191,
0.4383434057,
0.6295289993,
-0.0430696867,
0.5639829636,
-0.9997233152,
0.7858182788,
-0.107851781,
-0.7938864231,
-0.469648242,
-0.7485140562,
-0.9587919116,
0.3023763299,
-0.0231307019,
-0.5541455746,
-0.2858228385,
0.144805342,
0.0195580609,
0.3770855069,
-0.5370369554,
0.44795838,
-0.3871724904,
-0.4535576999,
-0.3451894224,
-0.4719898999,
0.8553324938,
-0.3785309792,
0.3551909328,
-0.2541139722,
-0.3357603848,
0.7681081891,
-0.2152473629,
0.5426881909,
-0.2086879164,
-0.3857987523,
0.4110333323,
-0.1190300658,
0.5426964164,
-0.1119906604,
-0.374759227,
0.1801028699,
-0.163357541,
-0.1591344178,
-0.4415870607,
0.7696262598,
-0.4689367115,
-0.3864525259,
-0.4631630182,
-0.5171257257,
-0.2513199151,
0.0974596366,
-0.1155343577,
0.4339802563,
-0.3344674706,
0.4077860713,
0.6944651604,
-0.2352620363,
0.5938731432,
0.6938585639,
-0.5733156204,
-0.3987644017,
0.7414503694,
0.4825339317,
0.2252368331,
0.3229704201,
0.0732263401,
-0.501345098,
-0.9189136028,
-0.2502634227,
0.3670966327,
-0.6225969791,
-0.2054338157,
-0.8987102509,
-0.1024378315,
-0.4683435857,
0.1352427155,
-0.4831515849,
-0.4691853523,
-0.3816545904,
-0.0379429199,
0.395901978,
0.8974535465,
0.0826544985,
0.4816560447,
-0.873765707,
0.1326661557,
0.2168333381,
0.4524978697,
0.2958092391,
-0.3558191359,
-0.2691140771,
-0.2830156982,
-0.0525489599,
-0.6514136791,
0.4923608303,
-0.0639476627,
0.8141630292,
0.3521526754,
-0.0889921412,
0.5624472499,
-0.5092343688,
0.9077243805,
0.4388166666,
-0.7191242576,
0.0415991805,
-0.514454484,
0.2971330583,
0.554230392,
0.6072171926,
-0.5385276675,
-0.3267898262,
-0.4557274282,
-1.1232904196,
0.4514155388,
0.1930450648,
0.3138911724,
0.0241064504,
0.2247072011,
-0.0037798798,
0.3445507288,
-0.6338814497,
-0.197712332,
0.5253647566,
-0.2197366655,
-0.1731464863,
-0.4846346676,
-0.1381620318,
-0.1378318816,
0.7550315261,
-0.0395094901,
0.0801052749,
-0.1096699387,
-0.2853833437,
0.1503653824,
0.5842016339,
0.3974669874,
0.8306694627,
-0.005419042,
0.2233522683,
0.0966197625,
-0.3698885739,
0.2159293443,
0.021059135,
-0.0839348063,
0.036089085,
0.3635860085,
0.4879131317,
0.1322194934,
-0.8974749446,
0.4710232913,
-0.2696999013,
-0.1431507617,
-0.289026916,
-0.114923358,
0.4385891557,
0.2142756581,
0.3128054142,
-0.3214678764,
0.2939828336,
-0.5245317221,
-0.1224302649,
0.6493452191,
-0.065455921,
-0.1049255058,
0.2446392924,
0.4102444351,
-0.2382728755,
0.5956604481,
-0.1915233284,
-0.2719831467,
0.1436126828,
0.4019538164,
0.9360313416,
-0.0976107419,
-0.0892955437,
0.3724072278,
0.3385284245,
-0.3889136612,
0.1908989847,
-0.0508364253,
-0.6447330713,
-0.5247852802,
-0.8656762838,
-0.4547192454,
0.2516974211,
-0.4274826348,
0.1245710328,
-0.2861041725,
-0.2600838542,
-0.0780678019,
0.1568296701,
-0.3201050758,
-0.1463772207,
0.1727340668,
1.0902596712,
-0.6533075571,
0.6442068219,
0.7654901743,
0.0147812292,
-0.7804080248,
-0.3428481817,
0.0177484211,
-0.5952758789,
0.359509021,
-0.0168975685,
-0.3061335087,
0.0235599782,
-0.6525924802,
-0.8604406714,
1.0170758963,
0.3485867083,
-0.8820822835,
0.2134410888,
0.0005886292,
0.6340907812,
-0.3294346333,
0.3676581979,
0.785274446,
0.4608888924,
-0.0737003088,
-0.8759003282,
-0.1850502938,
-0.3075443804,
0.241070047,
0.3177913427,
-0.8125759363,
0.6425727606,
0.1074111834,
-0.1952190548,
0.2885878682,
0.5959131122,
0.379016459,
0.1365538985,
0.6073368192,
0.4734691978,
0.5301017165,
-0.0885509029,
0.9703426957,
-0.6089648008,
0.3622462749,
0.7632846832,
-0.3709439635,
0.7913001776,
0.5589337945,
-0.1656697989,
-0.0541276261,
0.4340126514,
0.2150810659,
0.0807567388,
0.5215600729,
-0.4043445289,
-0.3437254727,
-0.3466560841,
-0.1747874171,
0.6764241457,
0.334012866,
-0.4164562225,
-0.1690539122,
-0.1967322379,
0.2729419172,
0.1032736525,
-0.3075942993,
0.862205863,
0.1599000245,
-0.6512507796,
0.3276880085,
0.2053946704,
0.7851019502,
-0.9111605287,
0.2136830389,
-0.1829208583,
-0.0256925412,
-0.0913877413,
-0.6959363222,
0.1063326523,
0.4272614419,
-0.1090813354,
-0.5961146355,
0.6181272268,
-0.4377748668,
-0.4647140801,
0.2645887136,
0.8879780173,
0.2109689265,
0.2761342824,
-0.3880293369,
0.4185912311,
-0.1870824993,
-0.6927186847,
0.2563858032,
0.3082222641,
-0.0265768096,
0.8333586454,
0.3936430216,
0.2677942216,
0.1165465117,
0.2849910259,
0.967076242,
-0.7628784776,
-0.1255657077,
-0.8388317823,
0.3679849207,
-0.2540970743,
-0.2428130805,
1.0381147861,
0.8339424133,
0.56710428,
-0.0195072163,
0.8749947548,
-0.149393335,
0.7156561613,
-0.3110949695,
0.7528244853,
-0.5692994595,
0.3816037476,
-0.277741909,
-0.9568690062,
-0.487090975,
0.2786737978,
-0.0761716813,
-0.0031281295,
0.4512357116,
0.8413738608,
0.1129551455,
-0.0102579286,
0.2786604166,
0.249997884,
0.4473877549,
0.1529497653,
1.1035423279,
0.075370729,
0.1730481684,
-0.0730814636,
-0.2170069814,
-0.3308463991,
-0.783875525,
-0.6414690018,
-0.4910742044,
-0.1915206164,
0.0856980383,
-0.0549521036,
1.0565905571,
0.4885139763,
-0.4756546319,
-0.6821620464,
0.0159847662,
0.182270363,
0.2264615297,
-0.1418211609,
0.2069859058,
-0.4818237126,
-1.011400938,
0.2246284634,
0.2555040121,
-0.0504862368,
-0.5639284253,
-0.0054705921,
-0.1259335279,
0.0392804705,
1.079709053,
0.0398727544,
-0.7160023451,
-0.0462479442,
0.2242222726,
-0.437109381,
-0.3956666291,
1.0215506554,
-0.2725101113,
0.2797106504,
0.9461678267,
0.6767505407,
0.1842486411,
-0.1525363624,
0.4636401236,
-0.343749851,
-0.1810727566,
0.3889791965,
0.4054731429,
0.5117617249,
0.0814027861,
0.6657240391,
0.066471912,
-0.7170327902,
-1.0380963087,
0.1936335266,
-1.1578565836,
-0.336841166,
1.528272748,
-0.0507413819,
-0.056199871,
0.0964187756,
0.0141212009,
0.1954628676,
-0.2984489501,
0.468603313,
0.6140230298,
-0.1845216304,
-0.0679973811,
-0.5659499168,
0.1954013854,
0.1472578645,
-0.8866118789,
0.3386220336,
0.7860551476,
0.2781487107,
0.0180644393,
0.7947354317,
-0.2174256146,
-0.306601584,
-0.280543983,
0.1264353544,
0.1162417457,
-0.2382929474,
-0.5776203275,
0.5009030104,
0.4850133359,
0.3434716463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03818v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03818v2
|
Alpha-CLIP: A CLIP Model Focusing on Wherever You Want
| 2023-12-06T18:59:30 | 2023-12-13T05:52:05 |
Zeyi Sun, Ye Fang, Tong Wu, Pan Zhang, Yuhang Zang, Shu Kong, Yuanjun Xiong, Dahua Lin, Jiaqi Wang
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Contrastive Language-Image Pre-training (CLIP) plays an essential role in
extracting valuable content information from images across diverse tasks. It
aligns textual and visual modalities to comprehend the entire image, including
all the details, even those irrelevant to specific tasks. However, for a finer
understanding and controlled editing of images, it becomes crucial to focus on
specific regions of interest, which can be indicated as points, masks, or boxes
by humans or perception models. To fulfill the requirements, we introduce
Alpha-CLIP, an enhanced version of CLIP with an auxiliary alpha channel to
suggest attentive regions and fine-tuned with constructed millions of RGBA
region-text pairs. Alpha-CLIP not only preserves the visual recognition ability
of CLIP but also enables precise control over the emphasis of image contents.
It demonstrates effectiveness in various tasks, including but not limited to
open-world recognition, multimodal large language models, and conditional 2D /
3D generation. It has a strong potential to serve as a versatile tool for
image-related tasks.
|
[
-0.8229160309,
-0.7774380445,
0.3916948736,
0.3473231494,
-0.47355932,
0.038046997,
-0.1958705634,
-0.5772138238,
0.5318253636,
0.3201497197,
-0.6060265303,
-0.3597626984,
-0.6446461082,
-0.0350607149,
-0.606921494,
0.6233807206,
-0.1294914782,
0.0662663206,
-0.0191148352,
-0.1258936971,
-0.6720116735,
-0.6784040332,
-0.4562312067,
-0.1830120981,
0.247066468,
0.5249277353,
0.750787735,
0.7759552002,
0.6070184112,
0.2946612537,
0.0786854848,
-0.1058493853,
-0.2780089974,
-0.0788204446,
-0.253213793,
-0.4902614951,
-0.3657332957,
0.0187936667,
0.5541186929,
0.2000218481,
0.2573404014,
-0.1717267781,
0.0307099503,
0.3604608178,
-0.9338451624,
-0.1307540387,
-0.611735642,
0.0593133382,
-0.1530963033,
-0.0996820927,
0.066488415,
-0.2038674355,
0.4014421105,
-0.6428602338,
0.4119331539,
-0.1822480857,
1.3003669977,
0.1241146997,
0.0729077458,
-0.1170178056,
-0.5243434906,
0.8293482661,
-0.0938034728,
0.7310644984,
0.6033377051,
0.2218450755,
0.4643600285,
-0.8726319671,
-0.5186163187,
0.2902037501,
0.1537068188,
0.0235663783,
-0.0527850948,
0.130335927,
-0.0829034299,
0.5597165227,
0.2227327526,
-0.2435107976,
-0.4040604532,
-0.2419364154,
0.3111997545,
-0.0995710567,
0.5996323228,
0.0066879503,
-0.2223249227,
-0.3998927474,
-0.8061295748,
0.0094162766,
-0.0461530164,
-0.0300493576,
-0.0387326665,
0.3962619305,
0.1337446421,
0.348449558,
0.1648688316,
-0.2707609236,
-0.0934628621,
-0.2883973122,
0.0248187948,
-0.2478888929,
0.633364141,
0.6357741952,
0.1362106353,
0.0769537836,
-0.271856457,
0.1070742607,
0.2470111698,
-1.0066000223,
-0.5751364827,
-0.2949967086,
-0.3398759663,
-0.1149205118,
0.0117507512,
-0.6755847931,
-0.0664064884,
-0.2092451751,
0.4959244132,
-0.6168584824,
0.1219240278,
0.0339321569,
-0.1181058884,
0.1784175783,
0.4725264013,
-0.9687393904,
0.4709999859,
0.2499792725,
1.0877109766,
-0.3772427142,
-0.5298752785,
-0.1816517264,
0.1709985882,
-0.1491405666,
1.3076008558,
-0.674932003,
-0.451949507,
0.0973757505,
0.1645923555,
0.3402383626,
-0.3770927787,
0.4241520762,
-0.5471978188,
0.0514303781,
-0.339867413,
0.0238811709,
-0.4063529372,
0.3642233908,
-0.8544675112,
0.8165389299,
0.0951536372,
-0.5968173146,
0.3189237416,
-0.4859739244,
-0.4046057165,
0.0144740622,
-0.3996993601,
-0.5453262329,
-0.1213127896,
0.8215223551,
0.0530760027,
-0.1579091102,
-0.1628777534,
-0.2996893227,
-0.33270365,
0.3851990104,
-0.1510282904,
0.1311808378,
-0.0660125539,
-0.0860527605,
0.2722668052,
-0.3606026471,
0.0489234142,
0.1179285049,
-0.1536676735,
-0.4252681732,
-0.0607735775,
0.230532676,
0.2843925655,
0.096301958,
-0.383844465,
-0.0310575273,
0.0785663873,
0.5062454343,
0.616255939,
0.2067525387,
0.5950459242,
-0.2355313301,
0.9745946527,
-0.2718914151,
0.3605699539,
-0.625103116,
-0.3481694758,
-0.7046427727,
-0.8817491531,
0.4603540003,
0.6334859729,
-0.7159410715,
0.2430813611,
0.0721064806,
-0.14745,
-0.7404819131,
0.1499101669,
0.4510406554,
0.4247418046,
0.3348496854,
-0.7220568657,
-0.6652880907,
-1.0710849762,
0.2557615936,
0.3157989681,
-0.1476802081,
0.4926857352,
0.5086036921,
-0.15337345,
1.0068649054,
-0.8237909675,
-0.601295948,
-0.3099347949,
-0.1018213481,
-0.1743555814,
0.3640999198,
0.564096272,
-0.8993431926,
-0.4575307667,
-0.319857806,
-0.4470945895,
-0.1120319739,
-0.0024387531,
-0.4690826833,
-0.4705343843,
0.7173534036,
-0.1964825839,
0.3646201789,
0.4107582867,
-0.10969688,
0.331330508,
-0.1595301926,
0.4141242206,
-0.6448312402,
0.0707491562,
0.0018614723,
-0.2879644036,
-0.4829725325,
0.0069253216,
0.2162695974,
-0.4625278413,
-0.6781972051,
0.4772991538,
-0.5207993388,
-0.2517704964,
-0.5693243742,
0.1309312135,
0.6113573909,
0.5681299567,
0.6520114541,
1.1043907404,
0.7511329651,
-0.5493969917,
0.0931432247,
0.7983981371,
-0.5163698196,
0.5852274299,
-0.8211163282,
0.4204373658,
-0.0139046758,
0.037128333,
-0.5329363942,
-0.1411716193,
0.1669541448,
-0.2261145115,
0.2305762023,
-0.0606254078,
-0.1850975305,
-0.0368135944,
-0.7944144011,
0.8633931279,
0.4987136722,
-0.4971292615,
0.4462151527,
0.7641268969,
-0.468324393,
-0.5882254243,
-0.8171933293,
-0.0584947653,
-0.0060213646,
-0.2795078456,
0.6231241822,
0.0301560275,
0.1694132239,
0.1237710193,
0.1796170026,
-0.4864391685,
-0.0167509783,
0.3977092803,
0.3796325028,
-0.1724431515,
-0.1588693559,
-0.0559155121,
0.1202482581,
-0.3123848736,
0.1210296154,
0.4510433376,
-0.1571539789,
-0.4121635556,
-0.2511984408,
0.7347306013,
0.2046697587,
-0.5487586856,
0.2784925401,
0.1971378326,
-0.440205723,
-0.0098050004,
-0.3026289344,
-0.3287290931,
-0.490593642,
0.8153418303,
-0.3197272122,
-0.6246503592,
0.4148278236,
0.118158713,
-0.1490087658,
0.0536359809,
0.2349694669,
-0.0874949172,
0.9181333184,
1.2086488008,
0.1236966327,
1.1747331619,
-0.4190488458,
-0.0278223287,
-1.2377022505,
-0.2262941897,
-0.2847804725,
-0.2435676008,
0.201092273,
-0.6517153978,
0.2887432873,
0.393007338,
0.1950244009,
0.1978927106,
-0.4976658523,
1.0429947376,
0.4550756812,
0.443862468,
0.1721331626,
-0.0219491925,
0.2568849623,
-0.3835031688,
-0.5936203599,
-0.3087119758,
0.854333818,
0.6461903453,
0.9729747772,
-0.2892599404,
0.2331619114,
0.2250149995,
0.3531380594,
-1.0255668163,
0.5743597746,
-0.2112922221,
-0.4191265702,
-0.0096963001,
0.3369051516,
-0.7023539543,
0.2903198302,
-0.5845980644,
-0.3658711612,
0.365580529,
0.497725755,
-0.320420742,
0.1624397188,
-0.60990417,
0.7967399955,
-0.3820536435,
-0.27951473,
-0.0682742819,
-0.3666728437,
0.2448088825,
0.0198723506,
0.1839816421,
-0.0603945591,
-0.3121519685,
0.5793150663,
-0.2775191963,
0.6788697839,
0.2382092476,
0.1819935143,
0.2316562384,
0.0684544146,
0.0343504883,
-0.0613416694,
0.372053355,
0.0931492001,
-0.365616709,
-0.1728173494,
-0.6208003163,
0.3140757382,
-0.8183194995,
-0.4075285494,
-0.1649285108,
-0.4475233853,
0.0394913331,
0.3456278145,
0.6378296614,
0.7281906009,
-0.3560714126,
-0.0928247124,
0.6790037155,
-0.291197449,
0.1286008209,
0.2117040902,
-0.4626066387,
-0.8534159064,
1.0017689466,
-0.3120243847,
0.1093840674,
0.3440444767,
-0.1148969606,
-0.3785768151,
-0.8438768983,
-0.1526701003,
0.3571249545,
-1.2686958313,
-0.2608790994,
-0.4662791789,
-0.1018944755,
-0.1456404775,
-0.7242733836,
-0.534809947,
-0.2277412862,
-0.3765256703,
0.0536659434,
0.2600058317,
0.697311759,
0.045139499,
0.4927054346,
-0.7809438109,
0.6517041922,
0.6901667714,
0.5357473493,
-0.3204832077,
-0.4818779528,
-0.4216541946,
-0.3908867836,
-0.6727375984,
-0.9237929583,
0.5282472372,
0.8336285353,
0.5261592865,
0.4811989367,
-0.2884578109,
0.734669745,
-0.6004576683,
0.7398197055,
0.3520103097,
-1.1244350672,
0.7588845491,
0.0246080477,
0.5906274915,
0.8034559488,
0.4396487772,
-0.4404110909,
-0.4917503893,
-0.4367050231,
-1.0291234255,
0.6987727284,
0.1298803538,
-0.0048724455,
-0.0980679914,
0.1859730035,
-0.0042826086,
0.2241718322,
-0.8282676339,
-0.0296695828,
-0.7801432014,
0.0196798276,
0.1511182934,
-0.3209887147,
-0.2360931784,
-0.2521250546,
0.5082672238,
-0.2213716656,
0.424747169,
0.4723605514,
-0.5216544271,
-0.0005777747,
0.1432492435,
0.5847284198,
0.5541141629,
-0.1920458823,
0.2353530824,
0.1771538705,
-0.9629801512,
0.0787914544,
-0.0812016204,
-0.3232401013,
0.1068233922,
0.4000715613,
0.9851026535,
0.4846830368,
-0.7536277771,
0.6944026947,
-0.2772879004,
-0.1395730525,
-0.0810806677,
-0.1372121274,
-0.3691698611,
0.1286134571,
0.2138933837,
-0.0123235034,
0.3024750352,
-0.7076569796,
0.3818131089,
0.4741657376,
-0.4061150551,
-0.4825218022,
0.3778891265,
0.5242089629,
-0.3184861839,
0.5697113872,
0.1665762961,
-1.1975280046,
0.499450624,
0.649853766,
0.8233397603,
-0.102846913,
-0.1036583334,
0.3734384179,
0.1525065452,
-0.1239829585,
0.1862991601,
-0.2206675261,
-0.8563235998,
-0.3676348329,
-0.311044842,
-0.725853622,
0.2205591202,
-0.778675139,
0.5550400615,
-0.5814706087,
-0.2568020225,
-0.166310817,
-0.4405831695,
-0.5041770339,
0.2621209621,
0.3996204734,
1.025255084,
-0.8202280998,
0.8719858527,
0.9580407739,
-0.3484299481,
-0.4693444669,
-0.0292769577,
-0.430377543,
-0.6983919144,
0.4420532584,
0.2847177386,
-0.413482666,
-0.3782497048,
-0.5824177861,
-0.7574973106,
0.9124478102,
0.4615471065,
-0.2402282655,
-0.0744841471,
-0.3638851941,
0.1394972205,
-0.634558022,
0.3741888404,
0.5809018016,
-0.0174882188,
0.2197618037,
-0.762306869,
-0.1538192928,
-0.4584204853,
0.2242607027,
0.2417813241,
-0.5405268073,
0.8985503316,
-0.2474497706,
-0.4267846644,
-0.1608583182,
0.7732368112,
0.1976166815,
-0.2034849823,
0.5389402509,
0.14585495,
0.2638855875,
0.0208891202,
1.0297619104,
-0.3276352584,
-0.0228113066,
1.1324555874,
0.0025937755,
0.860730052,
0.4259168804,
0.144085139,
0.3583562374,
0.4877077043,
-0.1869203746,
1.1136296988,
-0.3041099608,
-0.2061736435,
-0.2777149975,
-0.2869146466,
-0.3070195615,
0.2978101373,
0.5345557332,
-0.241188392,
-0.0564138256,
0.2909031808,
-0.2043949515,
0.2329350561,
-0.5960239172,
0.7101870775,
0.0809240416,
-0.6695552468,
0.4785173237,
-0.0817795321,
0.8957089186,
-0.8865341544,
-0.3119742572,
0.0022633055,
0.1808159053,
-0.136505574,
-1.0839464664,
0.3797051013,
-0.0197816938,
-0.1132254004,
-0.2898783684,
0.8566085696,
-0.5934382677,
-0.1212946028,
0.1193199754,
-0.1216326952,
0.0323270746,
-0.2048212439,
-0.8109158874,
0.4775642753,
-0.0642780587,
-0.0268086605,
0.278632462,
0.2133091539,
0.0216577519,
0.5249888301,
0.300860405,
0.2321552932,
-0.1139751002,
-0.1119638458,
1.0081516504,
-0.6657466888,
-0.8954852223,
-0.5852267146,
0.1490023434,
-0.0242654495,
-0.4197507203,
0.4217946827,
0.2641247809,
0.6174330711,
-0.2919930816,
0.7755892873,
0.0818466097,
0.1769582182,
-0.7309194207,
0.4598355889,
-0.3597082496,
-0.1411076337,
-0.3330937028,
-0.9035846591,
-0.2352273017,
0.9341958165,
-0.2612395585,
-0.2498714626,
0.9557155967,
0.4898138642,
-0.1794620007,
-0.2122251242,
0.1559206545,
-0.2966937423,
0.2375899553,
0.5686205029,
0.9586490989,
-0.3844619393,
0.9087252021,
-0.5111378431,
-0.2634536326,
-0.0507370159,
-0.9364927411,
-1.0432162285,
-0.5977756381,
-0.4032478631,
-0.0224928129,
-0.1255653352,
0.8031346202,
1.2125171423,
-0.6983985901,
-0.05400737,
0.20800744,
0.0397144333,
0.0216918755,
-0.0761517361,
0.4099870622,
0.144799158,
-0.7041812539,
0.3026705682,
0.4307854474,
0.4592983425,
-0.1112923473,
-0.0420986935,
-0.2227311581,
0.1291031539,
0.5470975637,
0.7835125327,
-0.4247678816,
-0.218547374,
-0.0744974464,
-0.0711819455,
0.5269734263,
1.1338636875,
-0.5676221251,
0.2556654513,
0.2462824434,
0.5097726583,
0.620806694,
0.1713148206,
0.8934816718,
-0.8381180167,
0.7487180829,
0.2718723714,
0.5114144683,
0.7250600457,
-0.2070875019,
0.1417060941,
-0.0034470004,
-0.3453122973,
-0.6081978679,
0.4812709987,
-1.0219539404,
-0.3205159009,
0.824889183,
-0.4371684492,
-0.3887304664,
-0.2039000988,
-0.663931191,
-0.0705567673,
-0.5196765065,
0.6095362902,
0.6728312373,
-0.0434576534,
-0.7649716139,
-0.2775142193,
0.7232044935,
0.3835810721,
-0.9092296958,
-0.3793351948,
0.4186899066,
0.1413662285,
0.325688988,
0.944003284,
-0.2443384826,
0.6147254705,
-0.0902737379,
0.3093029559,
-0.1041176319,
-0.5803537369,
-0.4749403596,
0.2137998194,
0.5563855767,
-0.6331921816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03700v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03700v1
|
OneLLM: One Framework to Align All Modalities with Language
| 2023-12-06T18:59:19 | 2023-12-06T18:59:19 |
Jiaming Han, Kaixiong Gong, Yiyuan Zhang, Jiaqi Wang, Kaipeng Zhang, Dahua Lin, Yu Qiao, Peng Gao, Xiangyu Yue
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.MM
|
Multimodal large language models (MLLMs) have gained significant attention
due to their strong multimodal understanding capability. However, existing
works rely heavily on modality-specific encoders, which usually differ in
architecture and are limited to common modalities. In this paper, we present
OneLLM, an MLLM that aligns eight modalities to language using a unified
framework. We achieve this through a unified multimodal encoder and a
progressive multimodal alignment pipeline. In detail, we first train an image
projection module to connect a vision encoder with LLM. Then, we build a
universal projection module (UPM) by mixing multiple image projection modules
and dynamic routing. Finally, we progressively align more modalities to LLM
with the UPM. To fully leverage the potential of OneLLM in following
instructions, we also curated a comprehensive multimodal instruction dataset,
including 2M items from image, audio, video, point cloud, depth/normal map, IMU
and fMRI brain activity. OneLLM is evaluated on 25 diverse benchmarks,
encompassing tasks such as multimodal captioning, question answering and
reasoning, where it delivers excellent performance. Code, data, model and
online demo are available at https://github.com/csuhan/OneLLM
|
[
-0.1698987335,
-0.6654898524,
0.5024732947,
0.3054177165,
-0.203712523,
-0.1130824164,
-0.2986632586,
0.146406278,
-0.0509341247,
0.7378705144,
-0.5657501817,
-0.5601317286,
-0.2602408826,
-0.2122359574,
-0.1536156386,
0.707547307,
-0.0119918529,
0.3976199031,
-0.3388189673,
-0.5243676901,
-0.5285266042,
-0.3534556627,
-0.2440431118,
-0.4063134789,
0.598410666,
0.2288201153,
0.9395837784,
0.8217787147,
0.5235953331,
0.3059137464,
0.2445646375,
0.3496547937,
-0.2886636853,
-0.0011188785,
-0.3109276295,
-0.1296492815,
-0.5220727921,
-0.3653823733,
0.8572126627,
0.6134206653,
-0.1210729107,
0.1558362842,
-0.0391473509,
0.6016150713,
-0.5440991521,
-0.1025539041,
-0.3910835683,
0.1098427549,
-0.1906713396,
-0.1498014629,
-0.3644086123,
-0.102180101,
-0.1379873753,
-0.6896327138,
-0.3885408044,
0.2011169493,
0.7150195837,
0.5009174347,
-0.638669908,
-0.0683401674,
-0.4130941331,
0.9234752655,
-0.7581295371,
0.7254790068,
0.0532203503,
0.2842469215,
0.0524291024,
-0.581338048,
-0.6651806235,
-0.010136012,
-0.1896299273,
0.1433085799,
0.1523324847,
0.2856955826,
-0.1632916629,
0.1245245114,
-1.1049338579,
0.2007099688,
-0.176129818,
-0.1572491676,
0.3252306879,
0.3933369219,
0.3727623522,
-0.0243798159,
-0.9282605648,
0.1726437658,
-0.6299923658,
-0.2247824669,
0.123745434,
0.2917963266,
-0.1756527573,
0.45963642,
0.3002964258,
1.0747092962,
-0.0260872878,
-0.3669829071,
0.0567431599,
-0.4344402552,
-0.5017134547,
0.0986521319,
1.0031175613,
0.2813961208,
0.0236288346,
-0.2667095661,
-0.116150558,
0.0986581072,
0.4145503044,
-0.6184415221,
0.1247093678,
0.1081321239,
-0.4308954477,
-0.0114100594,
0.0526695922,
-0.5575836301,
-0.485340178,
-0.4316065013,
0.7424352765,
-0.3572113216,
-0.5212321877,
0.3871990442,
0.333381027,
0.3258583248,
0.2482905388,
-0.7650927305,
0.111217238,
0.5610058308,
0.6332131028,
-0.3580114245,
-0.4738935828,
-0.3259289563,
0.2457158267,
-0.3110435307,
0.4921989441,
-0.6773008704,
0.1542132944,
0.2145842314,
-0.0469916537,
-0.4464071989,
-0.1835709959,
0.4306631684,
-0.3844462335,
0.6636265516,
0.1121122539,
-0.6380617619,
-0.4013697207,
0.4920312464,
-0.6008780599,
0.6825353503,
0.129433006,
-0.5169167519,
0.0651228428,
-0.8875166178,
-0.2907001078,
0.0645942912,
-0.5988531113,
-0.0431935936,
-0.0197053757,
0.0691429749,
0.3730996847,
-0.4913800359,
0.4389828146,
-0.0382927284,
-0.2524257898,
0.4473187625,
-0.7643623352,
0.6776295304,
0.4814762473,
-0.1024750322,
0.4682412446,
-0.6810483932,
0.0955867842,
-0.2462374568,
-0.5721277595,
0.2013209611,
-0.0825728476,
0.5829145908,
0.4534468949,
0.3050538599,
-0.6578142643,
0.3558765948,
-0.1439402848,
0.3421200514,
0.764772892,
-0.4748095274,
0.7682546973,
-0.2688244879,
0.7172048092,
0.1522117257,
0.2351069003,
-0.653937757,
-0.1969115436,
-0.7247453928,
-0.6504102349,
0.2133812457,
0.5380287766,
-0.3814367056,
0.4287479222,
-0.5148789883,
0.1896106899,
-0.8942906857,
0.537147522,
0.5962524414,
0.4629868865,
0.289241761,
-0.1869009286,
-0.6297252178,
-0.8603382707,
0.2523520589,
-0.0384864621,
-0.1242947355,
-0.1688990146,
-0.1364855617,
-0.4369259775,
1.0864900351,
0.029235037,
-0.7366479635,
-0.1795007586,
0.0267109387,
0.1541380882,
0.694948256,
0.3188994527,
-0.8317371607,
-0.3087928295,
0.2147508711,
-1.0130861998,
0.1070833132,
-0.385741502,
-0.1906560808,
0.3735317588,
0.3644997478,
-0.4382334948,
-0.1186751127,
0.8804052472,
-0.4961101711,
0.0588934831,
-0.1454052925,
0.1531101316,
-1.2692902088,
0.0491185151,
-0.2170007825,
-0.294505924,
-0.6569784284,
0.2358601242,
0.1714449078,
-0.1418197304,
-0.5612440705,
0.7005975842,
-0.6044233441,
0.3370708525,
-0.1268708408,
0.1552079618,
0.1849309653,
0.6922982335,
-0.1169183776,
0.3924916387,
0.8809668422,
-0.1902318597,
0.4733324945,
0.1180795655,
-0.3317605853,
0.4448017478,
-0.2431042343,
0.2741100192,
-0.417155236,
-0.0686780885,
-1.2338556051,
-0.1292337328,
0.1121269763,
-0.0771955624,
0.6550885439,
0.110085316,
-0.3994742036,
-0.0129272323,
-0.2563095689,
0.4016792476,
0.2875820398,
-0.5503391623,
1.2494728565,
0.1818619072,
0.0866102874,
-0.6810160875,
-0.8361591697,
0.1319937259,
-0.0764866397,
-0.7706582546,
0.1875880659,
-0.3573147357,
0.0088569969,
0.1436885446,
-0.1712708026,
-0.2217033356,
-0.1890634745,
0.3939400911,
0.360545069,
-0.5808933377,
0.3447020948,
-0.1309847683,
0.0404935889,
-0.3165282309,
-0.306902349,
0.5338807702,
-0.2246229053,
-0.6879782677,
-0.3069735467,
0.5464078188,
0.8733386993,
-0.242778182,
0.3610323966,
0.8455867767,
-0.2646735907,
0.2590888441,
-0.8257730603,
0.0755305067,
-0.4476082623,
0.5393570662,
-0.4863805771,
-0.9751315117,
0.1468068957,
0.0840293318,
0.1155933514,
-0.0182151236,
0.5834070444,
-0.0066131037,
1.4873569012,
0.7227988243,
-0.2398940772,
0.4255567193,
0.0259947684,
0.2191405594,
-0.7165431976,
-0.2546037436,
0.0456213541,
-0.4202949703,
-0.1085889488,
-0.517098248,
0.1324206889,
0.3091976345,
-0.2974231243,
0.2326557189,
-0.460454762,
0.4991398752,
0.2251425385,
0.0915105268,
0.3921220899,
0.0180618558,
-0.4192172587,
-0.1489191204,
-0.9870465398,
-0.8217336535,
0.9046103358,
0.4380535781,
1.2598063946,
0.292198807,
0.2595294714,
0.0125856791,
0.5318952799,
-0.7067191601,
0.5997885466,
-0.3053658605,
-0.7388733029,
-0.2152795345,
-0.1271280348,
-0.6975058913,
0.4130626917,
-0.3576080501,
-0.589479506,
-0.0291645564,
0.0950092301,
-0.3547001481,
0.1633861959,
-0.5840833187,
1.2701759338,
-0.6482285857,
-0.4094360173,
-0.1206893548,
-0.7535013556,
0.3234648407,
-0.0229744501,
0.3366669416,
-0.2390916646,
-0.1879556477,
0.2661692798,
0.1759342253,
0.7874499559,
0.1832255572,
-0.2743344903,
0.0319135562,
0.1814908385,
-0.0790949762,
-0.0496325493,
-0.05821364,
0.0201713908,
-0.1180609837,
-0.2847920656,
-0.6008806229,
0.9276146889,
-0.517160356,
-0.5219469666,
-0.11049404,
-1.0031323433,
-0.1460110098,
0.0720515475,
0.1345836222,
0.8023141026,
-0.3153693974,
0.2672573328,
0.5573146343,
0.0659045279,
0.5792148709,
0.7370977402,
-0.5826206803,
-0.4429950416,
0.9575256705,
-0.2156425267,
0.2772934735,
0.8173611164,
0.109625645,
-0.5225435495,
-0.1526588053,
-0.938352406,
0.0067293602,
-0.8046805263,
-0.3641739786,
-0.556753397,
0.0556339025,
-0.4926070571,
-0.3116909564,
-0.4156793654,
-0.3405126929,
-0.1459764242,
0.0836235061,
-0.1136261672,
0.5544864535,
0.048393175,
0.1500712037,
-0.8395675421,
0.2252136916,
0.5792766809,
0.2790758312,
-0.3320044875,
-0.5897423625,
-0.172689423,
0.1173681244,
-0.436522156,
-0.6897448301,
0.1400568187,
0.5986320972,
0.7389974594,
0.9489440918,
-0.3365707099,
0.756911993,
-0.5138071179,
0.7140191197,
0.8216584325,
-0.831748724,
0.2291635424,
-0.0832982212,
0.7086499929,
0.3423011601,
0.4940144718,
-0.6076883078,
-0.3641528189,
0.1346110702,
-0.4082680047,
0.3453737497,
-0.1619497538,
0.2840149403,
0.0229243077,
-0.1402781159,
0.0569299087,
0.0856232867,
-0.840698719,
-0.1861706823,
-0.4494372308,
-0.8411146998,
0.1639216244,
-0.114742361,
-0.5157439709,
-0.3017037511,
0.3334099352,
-0.4606859982,
0.1345907301,
0.0253254548,
-0.5736091733,
-0.2638756633,
0.5081012249,
0.8287331462,
1.1037775278,
0.0031550403,
0.3207363188,
-0.0937108099,
-0.0945741832,
0.160791114,
0.0545756221,
0.0916574821,
0.0146612618,
0.4147002101,
0.909211874,
0.4712282419,
-0.9836509228,
0.4888227284,
0.0474218354,
-0.1671752036,
0.2078040987,
-0.1197109744,
0.1503601521,
0.422837913,
0.4819661081,
-0.148809135,
-0.2083909214,
-0.7212296724,
0.1440916359,
0.5656992197,
-0.557277143,
-0.4143727422,
0.8415207863,
0.180732891,
-0.3002911508,
0.3757476509,
-0.1066095382,
-0.579672277,
0.0738971904,
0.7586163878,
0.8313050866,
-0.2809191644,
0.1947208047,
0.1952635348,
0.3547681868,
0.0607021078,
0.3893164992,
0.0353669487,
-0.9781956077,
-0.7729488015,
-0.8532059789,
-0.1060612053,
-0.0023987126,
-0.3228063881,
0.0077078193,
-0.1820803136,
0.0756279156,
-0.1922540218,
-0.5231505036,
-0.585431993,
0.0632636771,
0.4562061727,
0.5438668132,
-0.6389234066,
1.1455608606,
1.2372654676,
-0.5218270421,
-0.6287279725,
-0.4843767881,
0.2311830372,
-0.8411138058,
0.678647697,
0.1922060996,
-0.1557244062,
0.114763625,
-0.450691849,
-0.6115102768,
0.9371076822,
0.6620799303,
-0.7111632228,
-0.0909109563,
0.2995973229,
0.1881764829,
-0.911673367,
0.092901662,
0.2852385938,
0.6000791788,
0.0040224171,
-0.9190871119,
0.1607807875,
-0.1396397054,
0.1369234771,
0.3088536859,
-0.2556020021,
0.6720945835,
-0.2344263196,
-0.4469911754,
0.1179184318,
0.4471377432,
-0.0346124209,
-0.0834450051,
0.4611155987,
0.691700995,
0.3498936594,
-0.0255220663,
0.5960764289,
-0.5609582067,
0.1944420934,
1.1291626692,
-0.1996758282,
0.6049556732,
0.7833948135,
0.1485715657,
0.3580302298,
0.1403888762,
0.2494796813,
0.4957340062,
0.0584595688,
-0.4817373157,
-0.5368335843,
-0.2467828989,
-0.2436056733,
0.6401383877,
0.236231029,
-0.2863693833,
-0.3435370922,
0.3731301725,
-0.1069625467,
0.3675641716,
-0.3030695915,
0.7720279694,
-0.0689655989,
-0.3909673691,
0.6843311787,
-0.2097788006,
1.0042322874,
-0.9001585841,
-0.0473613217,
-0.2285716385,
0.3102804422,
-0.1910457611,
-0.6629095078,
0.0533737391,
-0.3241711855,
-0.1518560946,
-0.5207775831,
0.5521737337,
-1.1482012272,
-0.556651473,
0.1145672202,
0.4491866529,
-0.0390209965,
-0.0849194974,
-0.6708105206,
0.4445621967,
-0.1242369935,
-0.2138237655,
0.4550837576,
0.3027348518,
0.2303015292,
0.6888455153,
0.3819270134,
-0.247924462,
0.3098159134,
0.3672330081,
0.8318869472,
-0.5933334827,
-0.0217741448,
-0.8478900194,
0.7636587024,
0.1764260381,
-0.4720274508,
0.7399952412,
0.651464045,
0.6423826814,
-0.0872851312,
0.3724419177,
-0.0770227388,
-0.075784795,
-0.6425520778,
0.5053750873,
-0.7664599419,
0.0192463044,
0.121835418,
-0.9074351788,
-0.3767308295,
0.7385692596,
0.5301166773,
-0.4785456061,
0.6833800673,
1.1383577585,
-0.119418487,
-0.2321237475,
0.8105854988,
0.0602466129,
0.0903240591,
0.4543437064,
0.697413981,
-0.3202816546,
0.7157654166,
-0.0733636543,
-0.0307914075,
0.0858420283,
-0.9553168416,
-0.7532151937,
-0.5215606689,
-0.3693848848,
0.0039706281,
-0.0305987149,
1.2054532766,
0.9136494398,
-0.6757408381,
-0.4425613284,
0.1601332575,
0.0369436517,
-0.207791701,
-0.2625710964,
-0.011585108,
-0.4973604381,
-0.7159113288,
0.6742139459,
0.7258846164,
-0.2104533613,
-0.7231523991,
-0.4250257015,
-0.4838195145,
0.0338581502,
0.796790123,
0.1176283881,
-1.0281499624,
-0.258683145,
0.2755551636,
-0.3473078609,
0.1574698091,
0.9173087478,
-0.4730250239,
0.814955771,
0.3496333957,
0.7371498942,
0.3229207098,
-0.0943620726,
0.6836515665,
-0.788536489,
0.131950289,
0.2471532375,
0.4476292133,
0.4095467925,
0.0305863936,
0.4190278649,
-0.2597266436,
-0.5168544054,
-0.7315547466,
0.2965586483,
-1.2011158466,
-0.3346580863,
1.0027530193,
-0.0262479149,
-0.0765661746,
-0.1413811445,
-0.3844468594,
-0.0145455906,
-0.1382132471,
0.3785190284,
0.6554685831,
0.0723973513,
-0.4402635694,
-0.3404860795,
-0.0014673545,
0.569077909,
-0.4959943593,
-0.2107671201,
0.5634784698,
0.2021121383,
0.3330227137,
0.6839801073,
-0.1589380503,
0.1621926129,
-0.384411335,
0.3632793128,
-0.2490132153,
-0.3028405905,
-0.5852527618,
0.1768532991,
-0.1780370623,
-0.3681911528
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03699v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03699v3
|
PROMISE: A Framework for Developing Complex Conversational Interactions (Technical Report)
| 2023-12-06T18:59:11 | 2024-04-08T13:32:31 |
Wenyuan Wu, Jasmin Heierli, Max Meisterhans, Adrian Moser, Andri Färber, Mateusz Dolata, Elena Gavagnin, Alexandre de Spindler, Gerhard Schwabe
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The advent of increasingly powerful language models has raised expectations
for language-based interactions. However, controlling these models is a
challenge, emphasizing the need to be able to investigate the feasibility and
value of their application. We present PROMISE, a framework that facilitates
the development of complex language-based interactions with information
systems. Its use of state machine modeling concepts enables model-driven,
dynamic prompt orchestration across hierarchically nested states and
transitions. This improves the control of the behavior of language models and
thus enables their effective and efficient use. In this technical report we
show the benefits of PROMISE in the context of application scenarios within
health information systems and demonstrate its ability to handle complex
interactions. We also include code examples and present default user interfaces
available as part of PROMISE.
|
[
0.1496516913,
-0.7626080513,
0.8141484261,
0.3352513015,
0.3914151192,
0.530374229,
0.1188048422,
-0.6950309277,
0.2323116213,
0.183450982,
-0.6650967002,
-0.5034474134,
-0.389908582,
-0.1743975729,
-0.65135324,
0.8593994975,
-0.0822376236,
0.0237591602,
-0.1522113234,
0.2527061105,
-0.6111748815,
-0.4663259089,
-0.7404113412,
-0.6573286057,
0.216753751,
0.4610024989,
1.1449940205,
0.5181389451,
0.7071422935,
0.3289449513,
0.0937726125,
-0.1230805889,
-0.3844167888,
0.5792102218,
-0.151853174,
-0.5921089053,
-0.6148364544,
-0.2557004094,
0.2194477022,
1.1073594093,
-0.3641960919,
-0.1184588447,
0.0174336918,
0.474344939,
-0.3323648572,
0.669160068,
-0.208781898,
0.2624208927,
0.0386184938,
-0.103924185,
-0.4901791811,
-0.1838008016,
0.4564520419,
-0.7961720228,
-0.4433474839,
0.2115053684,
0.9798731208,
-0.2176826149,
-0.3962686062,
-0.5178439021,
-1.2577210665,
0.5725176334,
-0.5028973818,
0.3500146568,
0.3597769737,
0.616271317,
-0.6411809325,
-1.0282152891,
-0.5917466879,
-0.5794516206,
-0.1037405804,
-0.0112410467,
-0.5795962214,
0.5737066269,
0.0686740279,
0.4598484933,
-0.37001127,
0.2592282891,
-0.3090099692,
-0.0852228254,
0.0222749822,
0.5760244131,
0.6793612838,
-0.1383679509,
-0.141579479,
0.126772359,
-0.348636061,
0.4325389266,
-0.1450964808,
0.5291833282,
-0.5197027326,
0.9104194045,
-0.5160170794,
0.6933318973,
0.0193903521,
-0.3910513818,
0.138126269,
-0.177960217,
-0.2956443429,
0.1508329809,
0.481343627,
0.4759186506,
-0.0858600438,
-0.1662704945,
-0.225485608,
0.4379676282,
0.3334117234,
-0.7504803538,
0.1169882417,
0.7072141767,
-0.6443658471,
-0.4931381941,
0.0871116072,
-0.6038122177,
-0.434312284,
-0.5139473677,
0.317381382,
-0.7235953212,
-0.3996617198,
0.3788777888,
0.2424005568,
0.0881874189,
0.2928868234,
-0.8247499466,
0.8129832745,
0.7306206822,
0.8131674528,
-0.2982273996,
-0.1166703105,
-0.8593861461,
0.2373113632,
-0.4654518962,
0.1930856556,
-0.728102386,
-0.4393429458,
0.5110602975,
-0.1321446598,
0.1698884368,
-0.5326951742,
0.6056237221,
-0.2489321977,
-0.0162614789,
0.2954151928,
-0.4682719111,
0.0395223908,
0.4636984169,
-0.5229127407,
0.4820401669,
0.3098078668,
-0.3423383236,
0.0208856538,
-1.1154867411,
-0.6205077767,
0.1839929223,
-0.3638854623,
-0.1709868908,
0.1205865666,
-0.4163660407,
0.3682467639,
-0.335706234,
0.6965789795,
-0.173495084,
-0.2283326983,
0.413625896,
0.1166706309,
0.2574709952,
0.5557156801,
-0.3006655872,
0.5278260112,
-0.9199225307,
0.0306838714,
0.0830204561,
-0.4575833678,
-0.0047479067,
0.1929054707,
0.0830849484,
0.0074525573,
0.386588186,
-0.2080651969,
0.2785636783,
-0.4829240441,
0.4737711549,
0.1617085785,
-0.3186640441,
0.5162087679,
-0.425365299,
0.9017140269,
0.1487166584,
0.4153300822,
-0.7703073621,
-0.294590652,
-0.6081377268,
-0.0930248275,
0.0910397023,
0.6884759068,
-0.8259071112,
0.2864528,
0.0266842134,
-0.2880572379,
-0.5696335435,
-0.5464228988,
0.5344400406,
0.5413408279,
0.3795253932,
0.0074654426,
-0.4719812572,
-1.091047287,
-0.0691348463,
-0.5060904622,
-0.1329910308,
0.0422171056,
0.0412658677,
-0.3288724124,
1.1148942709,
-0.2620802522,
-0.1860197783,
-0.3739970624,
0.2418641001,
0.3525380492,
0.5996595621,
0.369435966,
-1.227219224,
-0.2046749145,
0.2941062152,
-0.9180787802,
-0.0092167659,
-0.0307840221,
0.0482985899,
-0.129690662,
0.2696914673,
-0.5448694229,
0.5277434587,
0.9173465967,
-0.4744662344,
0.6994891763,
-0.1197074875,
0.7550352812,
-1.2745699883,
0.0382676311,
-0.1740519106,
-0.2739959955,
-1.225296855,
-0.0269224625,
-0.2695432305,
-0.7097623944,
-0.4213007987,
0.3863731027,
-0.1633349061,
-0.1435838938,
-0.2564292252,
-0.2204044759,
-0.0682079867,
-0.0422253236,
-0.0776422694,
0.4885727763,
0.9216880798,
-0.790316999,
0.298088938,
0.4693205655,
-0.2510007322,
0.8683211207,
-0.6845232248,
-0.3113133311,
0.1513463557,
0.0643235371,
-0.7382740378,
-0.6469782591,
0.296467334,
-0.5285409689,
0.1725031734,
0.0086092064,
-0.5386813283,
-0.503403008,
0.2482200712,
0.0070643998,
0.3224526048,
-0.1676444709,
0.8385773897,
0.5136412382,
-0.2779467404,
-0.3001930714,
-0.9318470955,
0.3975313902,
0.0472793952,
-0.3968118131,
0.5640772581,
-0.255787909,
-0.6093964577,
-0.0468296185,
0.0071606906,
-0.2781997621,
0.1204340607,
0.7269583344,
0.3526228368,
-0.149948433,
0.219529137,
0.3167258203,
-0.2550573647,
-0.0905885771,
-0.5447587371,
0.7397112846,
-0.3726151586,
-0.6443907022,
-0.9981646538,
0.7226037383,
1.133961916,
-0.1588558406,
0.7100409269,
-0.0100083854,
-0.7443438172,
0.4624658823,
-0.172833249,
-0.3479302824,
-0.5288136005,
0.3815099895,
-0.7145017385,
-1.0117824078,
0.5365316868,
-0.4888831973,
0.0888000056,
-0.1786095649,
0.3217226267,
-0.0964073166,
1.1410931349,
0.9029901028,
0.1625460535,
0.3778060079,
0.2774077058,
0.2840507627,
-0.141644761,
-0.6229307652,
-0.5768395066,
-0.1841163933,
-0.5418894887,
-0.1189491674,
0.5967870951,
0.3318120241,
-0.1777962148,
0.2477185875,
-0.3269801438,
-0.1896069199,
0.311737746,
0.0570640154,
0.4271102846,
-0.1319169849,
-0.075502567,
-0.3614949584,
-0.5972265601,
-0.6078489423,
0.2825806141,
0.4140355885,
0.9419648647,
0.2763824463,
0.4684588015,
0.3488625586,
0.0028199821,
-0.9301285148,
0.5156971812,
0.1401490718,
-0.3019539118,
-0.2155754417,
-0.2361053228,
-1.2993024588,
-0.2209008485,
-0.6194857955,
-1.1959418058,
-0.0267690327,
0.3926390707,
-0.3898718953,
0.0447201431,
-0.5529578924,
0.7447407246,
-0.1543691456,
0.0813866109,
-0.3334092498,
-0.6557526588,
0.0519579127,
0.0983339846,
0.2090756595,
-0.0703946277,
0.1061069667,
0.3731275797,
-0.2419391125,
0.857103169,
0.3445522785,
-0.028834857,
0.2241084576,
0.7561019659,
0.5780090094,
-0.2434469163,
-0.3460121751,
-0.2347974032,
0.0907217711,
-0.3418743014,
-0.4933201373,
0.6013767719,
-0.2786925137,
-0.4829466939,
-0.1715943366,
-0.7242907286,
-0.4105045199,
0.6101952195,
-0.2883619368,
0.5973110199,
-0.4305024743,
0.2627779841,
0.5914833546,
-0.4756419957,
0.2738060951,
0.8227286935,
-0.7607722282,
0.0499858223,
0.5568755865,
-0.1068573371,
0.6430142522,
0.6045269966,
0.3165702522,
-0.03199628,
-0.305336535,
-0.2705195546,
-0.3782875836,
-0.3926066458,
-0.1380067766,
-0.8375505209,
-0.1629416794,
-0.4349448979,
-0.3957436979,
-0.326392293,
-0.3315484524,
-0.0763138086,
-0.2979746759,
0.3422562778,
0.9869573116,
0.1037131995,
0.5044509768,
-0.9684797525,
0.2773098052,
-0.0289451741,
0.3707210124,
-0.2667892873,
0.0971676037,
-0.2514036298,
-0.1725353748,
-0.24758479,
-1.1299372911,
0.3000945449,
-0.0037009958,
0.5460435748,
0.3247848451,
0.2213660181,
0.3213202059,
-0.5241543651,
0.7645944357,
0.6113043427,
-1.1548913717,
0.9772592783,
-0.659252584,
0.3923178613,
0.2873275876,
0.3824559152,
-0.6795744896,
-0.6838604808,
-0.7380982041,
-0.7379843593,
0.6312200427,
0.2477404624,
0.1009812728,
0.0962677374,
0.3790158629,
-0.0327613093,
0.6227235794,
-0.4494938552,
-0.3486367464,
0.2812295854,
-0.4381049573,
0.5089385509,
-0.2875775099,
-0.3988294899,
0.3943520784,
0.1195303872,
-0.2842223644,
0.0843322948,
0.0244359057,
0.3787652552,
-0.3188551962,
0.5397345424,
0.2987033427,
0.8728217483,
0.2630398273,
0.1650365293,
-0.2868605852,
-0.1277208775,
0.1576741189,
0.2526973188,
-0.2393611819,
-0.1515955776,
0.0206550173,
0.7585139871,
0.471270293,
-0.878719151,
0.3129372001,
0.0262098256,
0.2052965462,
0.0047360635,
0.1113419235,
0.2122950256,
0.4626421928,
0.3154867291,
0.0307956059,
0.4410450757,
-0.8413783908,
0.6180515289,
0.0240829661,
-0.7235478759,
-0.1986159831,
0.7603780031,
0.1682396531,
-0.8542699814,
0.3146061003,
-0.1547628194,
-0.3590728641,
0.5206849575,
0.9226862788,
0.2898239195,
-0.5257508755,
0.5212836862,
0.1413356513,
-0.0601896308,
-0.0915612653,
0.481248945,
0.3556992412,
-0.5239081979,
-0.4786639512,
-0.3456207216,
-0.6725537181,
0.1342705637,
-0.8527311087,
0.3714569807,
-0.3293980658,
-0.2997316122,
0.0032698852,
-0.3027735949,
-0.4987334609,
0.2839494646,
0.249090001,
0.7636904716,
-0.5876724124,
0.5599067211,
0.721446991,
-0.3606104553,
-1.0070272684,
-0.0079318974,
0.253347367,
-0.6275370717,
0.7249289155,
0.2169084847,
-0.2715363503,
-0.00414048,
-0.3918326497,
-0.5967479348,
0.9703775048,
0.6038101912,
-0.75628829,
0.1072498262,
0.1793380976,
0.4608323276,
-0.5963477492,
0.0040437421,
0.5435041189,
0.5650874972,
0.1204121262,
-1.430986166,
0.141996488,
0.0836077332,
-0.0742142573,
-0.0779077262,
-0.2046134472,
0.7305745482,
-0.3609373271,
-0.3661007583,
0.4596776962,
1.0015999079,
0.3112507463,
0.414696604,
0.610227406,
0.138490364,
0.9145387411,
-0.1370778978,
1.1018086672,
-0.3727841079,
0.0712225661,
1.1100765467,
-0.3911709487,
0.5655978322,
0.3977206051,
-0.0946920216,
0.5918952227,
0.549176991,
0.4353159964,
0.120224081,
0.3603670001,
-0.5155030489,
0.0745347962,
-0.847902596,
-0.2163231671,
0.2907601893,
0.7972764969,
-0.0830507576,
-0.2407096773,
0.451631695,
0.1538002342,
0.4713917673,
-0.3793208301,
0.586039722,
0.2020352334,
-0.7966232896,
0.0473137535,
-0.142737776,
0.2223102748,
-0.8396705985,
-0.4155892134,
0.3140385747,
0.0036723749,
-0.21881935,
-0.8874480724,
0.1416245252,
-0.0806666464,
-0.4469962716,
0.0113261975,
0.6833174825,
-0.600851357,
-0.0503264442,
0.5270080566,
0.5757859349,
0.1191621199,
0.3441237509,
-0.9347671866,
0.4346179962,
-0.18320629,
-0.1396779716,
0.3350764215,
0.3549005091,
-0.0640614629,
1.076592803,
0.6299359798,
0.0259623993,
-0.2613599002,
0.1343933344,
0.7051478624,
-0.3267130554,
-0.8199084401,
-0.4118467867,
0.5903254747,
0.023879528,
0.0805635676,
0.1617769748,
0.44937253,
0.2926429808,
0.1577566713,
0.8665117025,
-0.5015555024,
0.4745135307,
-0.5310766101,
0.4176602066,
-0.3031062186,
0.1298267096,
0.0312098935,
-0.3742561936,
-0.4528238773,
0.2664075494,
-0.0255144779,
-0.299151361,
0.5085247159,
0.6943194866,
0.1570389569,
0.0550949574,
0.7341917157,
0.3535961807,
0.7470821142,
0.2900461555,
0.9129564762,
-0.0386321247,
0.4891916215,
0.0588715822,
-0.5670493245,
-0.2786206603,
-0.8483989239,
-0.402368784,
-0.6985125542,
-0.1396201998,
-0.9952202439,
0.2964349091,
1.1072432995,
1.0054553747,
-0.8453063965,
-0.3862909675,
-0.0197056904,
-0.2262106836,
-0.2788171768,
-0.2532682419,
-0.1225684732,
-0.5275859833,
-1.0288159847,
0.812332809,
0.6474297047,
0.4247895777,
-0.3493776023,
-0.1826308072,
0.0774061158,
-0.1199069768,
0.5368734002,
0.6481932402,
-0.6398570538,
-0.2168745399,
-0.022793876,
-0.3943073153,
0.0264291652,
1.2038506269,
-0.6228399873,
0.6360192895,
0.1033532247,
0.798997879,
0.256908983,
-0.1332208961,
1.1837369204,
-0.30987674,
0.2108304352,
0.2737867236,
0.236717537,
0.2984183431,
-0.7225382924,
0.3093173504,
-0.1666977406,
-0.3019146621,
-0.6658310294,
0.7264986038,
-1.0963771343,
-0.2964288294,
0.8405619264,
-0.2994132042,
-0.0047924346,
-0.2798389196,
-0.3079626262,
0.2249208093,
-0.6496146321,
0.5747654438,
0.4920649827,
-0.4534218609,
0.2232911736,
-0.8820560575,
0.4633973539,
0.3722444773,
-1.0678693056,
-0.1077094376,
0.3976058364,
-0.187176913,
0.572557807,
0.8078796268,
-0.1768192947,
0.0666727871,
-0.2878140807,
0.0928409547,
0.2312151045,
-0.6200503111,
-0.129235521,
0.2054699659,
0.0867778808,
-0.3706049323
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03689v1
|
Evaluating and Mitigating Discrimination in Language Model Decisions
| 2023-12-06T18:53:01 | 2023-12-06T18:53:01 |
Alex Tamkin, Amanda Askell, Liane Lovitt, Esin Durmus, Nicholas Joseph, Shauna Kravec, Karina Nguyen, Jared Kaplan, Deep Ganguli
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
As language models (LMs) advance, interest is growing in applying them to
high-stakes societal decisions, such as determining financing or housing
eligibility. However, their potential for discrimination in such contexts
raises ethical concerns, motivating the need for better methods to evaluate
these risks. We present a method for proactively evaluating the potential
discriminatory impact of LMs in a wide range of use cases, including
hypothetical use cases where they have not yet been deployed. Specifically, we
use an LM to generate a wide array of potential prompts that decision-makers
may input into an LM, spanning 70 diverse decision scenarios across society,
and systematically vary the demographic information in each prompt. Applying
this methodology reveals patterns of both positive and negative discrimination
in the Claude 2.0 model in select settings when no interventions are applied.
While we do not endorse or permit the use of language models to make automated
decisions for the high-risk use cases we study, we demonstrate techniques to
significantly decrease both positive and negative discrimination through
careful prompt engineering, providing pathways toward safer deployment in use
cases where they may be appropriate. Our work enables developers and
policymakers to anticipate, measure, and address discrimination as language
model capabilities and applications continue to expand. We release our dataset
and prompts at https://huggingface.co/datasets/Anthropic/discrim-eval
|
[
-0.3676246703,
-0.8237097263,
0.5351849198,
0.3115057051,
0.2182045281,
0.0007332455,
-0.2625649273,
-0.3850419819,
-0.1378390789,
0.7232313156,
-0.1995191872,
-0.3995395005,
-0.5153886676,
-0.1567353308,
-0.3039650321,
0.7204661965,
-0.0347194858,
0.0962522775,
-0.268214196,
-0.0272052642,
-0.9179611206,
-0.4965679646,
-0.5303362012,
-0.1229585707,
0.6227499843,
0.3955855966,
0.6610663533,
0.4782346785,
0.2529082894,
0.1578290015,
-0.2930722535,
-0.2703844607,
-0.4240297675,
0.0444055423,
-0.1776373386,
-0.3747972846,
-0.1457335204,
0.4395234287,
0.4599769711,
0.8338369131,
-0.3295978606,
0.49210006,
0.0511376597,
0.4429963529,
-0.985565722,
-0.0486789607,
-0.4989961088,
0.0271970127,
-0.3002047539,
0.0048883636,
-0.6737588644,
-0.6247293353,
0.0245491248,
-0.1939419359,
0.0730855614,
0.2764619589,
0.6149341464,
-0.1092893109,
-0.6444838047,
-0.4201542139,
-0.7149843574,
0.9560959339,
-0.5380730629,
0.5238851309,
0.7528025508,
0.5000751615,
-0.22854276,
-0.4222472906,
-0.4617644548,
-0.5449787974,
-0.1439978182,
-0.0733313188,
-0.2875944972,
-0.0593585894,
0.4918688834,
-0.0997643098,
-0.6300672293,
0.5299419165,
-0.5303741693,
-0.504957974,
0.5767621994,
0.0336763896,
0.2847588062,
-0.3058839142,
-0.2011592835,
-0.0592126474,
-0.5812925696,
0.2573061883,
0.794344604,
0.6394913197,
-0.141801402,
0.5764549375,
0.0408677794,
0.4826559126,
-0.2175860554,
0.3726712167,
0.2482201308,
-0.0776541606,
0.0449682102,
-0.0110043418,
0.3616181314,
0.7351277471,
0.4033578038,
0.1865873635,
-0.3971367478,
0.4831501842,
0.1929179579,
-0.6493924856,
0.1894476414,
0.32710585,
-0.6094302535,
-0.3020572662,
-0.2761087418,
-0.9552829862,
-0.9004215598,
-0.2851940393,
0.1006642431,
0.1628413051,
-0.3793160617,
0.1432080865,
-0.1772289276,
0.3707720935,
0.1906859428,
-0.6269190311,
0.2887372971,
0.3473173976,
0.5643200278,
0.05479379,
0.1829298884,
-0.7898322344,
-0.1643685699,
-0.3775874376,
0.4409396052,
-0.8041452169,
-0.586446166,
0.3202721775,
-0.1175260767,
0.1453744769,
-0.7918860316,
0.8498510718,
-0.4870608449,
0.3978846073,
-0.2900790572,
-0.4531316459,
-0.1324441582,
-0.0267808232,
-0.7429330945,
0.8760133982,
0.2752252519,
-0.6401171088,
0.5227934122,
-0.7867027521,
-0.2716799676,
0.2274225652,
-0.1691922396,
-0.6658285856,
0.17433846,
-0.0400944464,
0.209289968,
-0.1891548634,
0.4493235648,
-0.5052428842,
-0.1380159557,
0.1396669894,
-0.2933931351,
1.0384324789,
0.3262041211,
-0.2172018588,
0.230586201,
-0.4987109005,
-0.2250006199,
0.1851338893,
-0.1644960493,
-0.5657526851,
0.2613024712,
0.1301745027,
0.4441913366,
0.053352382,
-0.5019229054,
-0.2159448564,
-0.113326177,
0.0583722256,
0.9436122775,
-0.2289742082,
0.3784962296,
-0.3069404364,
0.8792431951,
-0.1774526983,
0.5354836583,
0.2622622848,
-0.4721900225,
-0.585393846,
-0.1876294017,
0.273968488,
0.6891775131,
-0.6310796738,
0.115716137,
0.2362235337,
-0.1658334583,
-0.4975373447,
0.0210415926,
0.3786708117,
0.4721564353,
0.1981503963,
-0.0671349987,
-0.7358186841,
-0.998514533,
-0.4482988417,
-0.4524361789,
0.0795406625,
0.5070447922,
0.4728051126,
-0.1555840224,
1.08814013,
-0.2304973602,
0.1451370418,
-0.3005673587,
0.0887747929,
0.0437432751,
0.501394093,
0.7975836992,
-0.7680350542,
-0.1866415441,
-0.2867319882,
-0.6500654221,
-0.5861669183,
-0.0185125507,
-0.2361884266,
0.0380010828,
0.3403721452,
-0.3577166498,
0.4754016399,
0.5498836637,
-0.5746546388,
0.6368578672,
-0.1122343764,
0.1300679743,
-0.5817184448,
0.0052438932,
0.3499028981,
-0.0260472652,
-0.6906324625,
0.1465621591,
0.1219489127,
-0.2243828177,
-0.6507627964,
0.8521596789,
-0.2011877,
0.2329803705,
-0.1516029537,
0.0442614183,
-0.193148464,
0.0018338698,
0.0175779387,
0.6013673544,
0.3690449595,
-0.7386015058,
-0.106402263,
0.2622962594,
-0.459977448,
0.5375603437,
-0.5364586711,
0.0736981183,
-0.514590621,
0.194303304,
-0.6117430925,
0.0659892112,
0.4067258537,
-0.2340069264,
-0.2400108874,
0.0339520797,
-0.3354102969,
-0.525092423,
-0.4557900429,
0.5370990634,
0.5949760675,
-0.2896283269,
0.2706026733,
0.7358728647,
-0.3629797399,
-0.2451096028,
-0.41214782,
0.1098335758,
-0.6829735041,
-0.374219805,
0.0403843038,
-0.2652799189,
-0.7335910201,
-0.4189523458,
0.1730179638,
0.0051577855,
0.5477701426,
0.0589781404,
0.3342171013,
0.1970444173,
-0.0169535354,
0.0358987935,
-0.2282228023,
0.1504014283,
-0.1842647493,
0.4323431551,
0.2007099688,
-0.1933090687,
-0.1080089658,
0.5812009573,
0.3832072616,
-0.4798596501,
0.5994215608,
0.2995762825,
-0.6072058082,
-0.0788203031,
-0.5948247313,
-0.0851909816,
-0.4544233978,
0.3744961619,
0.0701062232,
-1.0294610262,
0.5182992816,
-0.0062230793,
0.1938566267,
0.021171866,
0.6418352127,
-0.1891948581,
1.20548594,
0.8312235475,
0.266002506,
0.6925724745,
0.2166645527,
0.4083932042,
-0.6394979358,
-0.2508630753,
-0.7857958674,
-0.1096324176,
-0.8395200372,
-0.5450838208,
0.2072528452,
0.2542452514,
-0.1190236807,
0.3574184775,
-0.2399300039,
0.3042967916,
0.4092045426,
0.113542147,
0.0425603911,
-0.0969854817,
-0.1783701479,
-0.1665339321,
-0.4624340534,
-0.8164722323,
1.0234043598,
0.5918807983,
0.4331949651,
0.3229947686,
0.4154246449,
0.8730256557,
0.675578773,
-0.6761845946,
0.6395735741,
-0.0498401597,
-0.7432368994,
-0.1256756335,
-0.6657774448,
-1.100692153,
0.2487747818,
-0.1825789958,
-0.933811307,
0.5703001022,
0.2243644148,
-0.4039696753,
-0.1563796252,
-0.835847199,
0.9278951287,
-0.3316990733,
-0.2882831395,
-0.3110206127,
-0.346536845,
0.2892732024,
-0.4432320595,
0.7010607719,
-0.4223544002,
0.2220057994,
0.5784293413,
-0.3722386658,
0.9073050022,
-0.6703321338,
-0.5117074847,
0.3734520972,
0.1593022943,
0.4763129056,
-0.1459922642,
-0.7112396359,
0.1585023254,
-0.1770219505,
-0.452585727,
-0.3385452032,
0.3405945897,
-0.4901807606,
-0.4870019853,
-0.1095264032,
-0.4171741605,
-0.2269333005,
-0.0317717902,
-0.0733983591,
0.227868706,
-0.3131828904,
-0.1076763123,
0.2105177194,
-0.7441480756,
0.3280318081,
0.8543284535,
-0.5109773874,
-0.0998039022,
0.8158752918,
0.1768574119,
0.27105093,
-0.0702107027,
0.532679081,
-0.558625102,
-0.4344084561,
-0.1097100973,
0.0537281297,
-0.6398413181,
0.0650712252,
-0.2487401664,
0.2266183347,
-0.3435307443,
-0.1075740233,
0.0019672555,
-0.2284870148,
0.1579624563,
-0.3585192263,
0.0795119032,
0.4750281572,
0.0070303068,
0.1755118221,
-0.494997859,
0.1969878376,
0.2315244973,
0.290401727,
-0.2702939808,
-0.5631567836,
-0.2368261814,
0.0592664778,
-0.031222105,
-0.8061442971,
0.1916987002,
-0.142761752,
0.774625957,
-0.0976336598,
0.3865117133,
0.3595651686,
-0.5221113563,
0.604414165,
0.1170478389,
-0.8547339439,
0.8575108647,
-0.3819261789,
-0.0009741469,
0.497492969,
0.1848167479,
-0.5882943869,
-0.4984296858,
-0.289185226,
-0.958563447,
0.6275680065,
0.4640639126,
0.2445581257,
-0.2007997334,
0.1939293891,
0.0284621101,
0.297457248,
-0.8317510486,
0.01313884,
0.0206239969,
-0.0399238542,
0.202283442,
-0.373688817,
-0.0206386987,
-0.1958875209,
0.6435866952,
0.1476806402,
-0.1366124302,
-0.2790919542,
-0.3636374772,
0.0222423393,
0.514588654,
0.6794320941,
0.519130826,
-0.0144486604,
0.032941483,
0.1580840647,
-0.1980728656,
0.325458318,
0.2080941498,
-0.4670311809,
-0.033126343,
0.0944425836,
0.837043643,
-0.0804193914,
-0.7771466374,
0.4827362299,
-0.1451165974,
-0.0135477493,
-0.1507462114,
-0.1914080381,
-0.2968042195,
0.2135370076,
-0.1322704256,
-0.1420238912,
0.1339543313,
-0.3748981357,
0.1744255126,
0.2586255968,
-0.5268443823,
-0.0789482296,
0.6486978531,
0.6490712166,
-0.5631120205,
0.6406442523,
-0.333627224,
-0.1684343517,
0.6499726772,
0.431861937,
0.9976237416,
-0.4806656837,
0.5036451221,
0.2631168067,
0.4111576378,
0.0374975279,
0.3020451665,
0.2402087003,
-0.9750798941,
-0.3898158669,
-0.6610842943,
-0.1501268148,
0.0027395713,
-0.7299281359,
0.418926239,
-0.4964413941,
-0.492169708,
-0.185866788,
-0.2426042855,
-0.5252400637,
-0.0723809674,
0.4352339804,
0.9212444425,
-1.1385189295,
0.4979814589,
0.6834634542,
-0.2937484384,
-0.4236086607,
0.1057149172,
0.1919990033,
-0.7411828637,
0.6455104351,
0.3418536186,
-0.1834603399,
-0.1215899959,
-0.4679243863,
-0.1717059165,
0.5086554289,
0.92136693,
-0.7602617145,
0.291714251,
0.3456733525,
0.2928629518,
-0.0418251567,
0.439832747,
0.7235653996,
0.8118680716,
-0.3764106929,
-1.0349655151,
0.0795787573,
-0.3257433474,
0.2704119086,
0.2187291682,
-0.3412047625,
0.6102300882,
-0.2494838089,
-0.4221068323,
-0.0584827103,
0.2446408123,
0.4343117476,
0.2894681096,
0.8183969855,
0.1933974177,
0.9491562843,
-0.0170450583,
1.0527781248,
-0.2648152709,
0.5179056525,
0.7573307753,
-0.6548888683,
0.606675148,
0.3934013247,
-0.1741258204,
0.3244612813,
0.6401792169,
0.1864201576,
0.3116790056,
0.7368755937,
-0.4543278813,
-0.4431814253,
-0.9155571461,
-0.2610661387,
0.469797343,
0.4567917585,
-0.2746523619,
-0.4065241516,
0.2598567009,
0.0583158433,
0.4379742742,
-0.1994484812,
0.4242144823,
0.1070694551,
-0.38570261,
0.2996336222,
0.1946934164,
0.4809751809,
-0.5151324868,
-0.2441090792,
-0.3111593425,
-0.0387549214,
-0.1725598872,
-0.7021846175,
0.2815586925,
0.294036299,
-0.3826956153,
-0.5991178155,
0.4934761524,
-0.2948152721,
-0.7004519701,
0.706867218,
0.5937348008,
0.0330018811,
0.0519214161,
-0.7125298977,
0.3711525202,
-0.1266308427,
-0.0012250877,
0.1598120779,
0.0292658266,
-0.6923860312,
0.6156357527,
0.5758529902,
0.1424485594,
-0.1813270897,
0.6765043139,
0.5269402862,
-0.5087290406,
-0.6346353292,
-0.8581274748,
0.5908648372,
-0.1236492991,
-0.2100880593,
0.641215682,
0.4847410023,
0.6932653189,
0.2452089936,
0.9307622313,
-0.1422871351,
0.4463144839,
-0.4834498763,
0.4557171762,
-0.3623931408,
0.66478616,
-0.2753700912,
-0.800907135,
-0.2999388576,
0.8241710067,
-0.5380892158,
0.1782234907,
0.2535718083,
0.9688345194,
0.3470038772,
-0.0699522272,
0.2821016014,
0.0709709898,
0.5146840215,
0.2454337031,
1.2048033476,
-0.0934160501,
0.345685482,
0.1027010828,
-0.4474125803,
-0.1405441463,
-0.9521734715,
-0.7135765553,
-0.2246993333,
-0.5212349892,
-0.4371460974,
0.2721508145,
0.9100556374,
0.7768802047,
-0.9412341714,
-0.4988469183,
0.0563386567,
0.3489916027,
-0.0834565684,
-0.280349642,
0.0094693452,
-0.0116527136,
-0.6079076529,
0.2848491073,
0.180171445,
-0.1006900072,
-0.3558645546,
-0.3095208108,
-0.0335317925,
0.1092085838,
0.7538033724,
0.2453389764,
-0.5060847402,
-0.627133131,
-0.1982534975,
-0.0117765712,
-0.2222689539,
0.9378074408,
-0.740124464,
0.5048239231,
0.333416611,
0.4614344537,
-0.0630320758,
-0.1756864041,
0.8640280962,
-0.6912598014,
0.1776617914,
0.4492340684,
0.3878824413,
0.2894058526,
-0.3227472603,
0.2498649955,
0.1223728359,
-0.3000245094,
-0.9916206598,
0.5244215727,
-0.5152975917,
-0.2381219119,
1.2241728306,
0.1363627166,
0.2829890549,
-0.4198393822,
-0.295411557,
0.1237265095,
-0.5026785135,
0.8910421133,
0.6922743917,
0.0011728999,
-0.3634098172,
-0.959640801,
0.2446209639,
0.4604018033,
-0.7664811611,
0.3397565484,
0.65718472,
0.011271649,
-0.0517055281,
0.6364013553,
-0.1174076051,
0.1518701017,
-0.379417479,
0.2286212444,
0.2925797403,
-0.1993972957,
-0.4688530564,
-0.0671440065,
0.1945738941,
-0.1554373354
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03815v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03815v2
|
LLM as OS, Agents as Apps: Envisioning AIOS, Agents and the AIOS-Agent Ecosystem
| 2023-12-06T18:50:26 | 2023-12-09T18:10:39 |
Yingqiang Ge, Yujie Ren, Wenyue Hua, Shuyuan Xu, Juntao Tan, Yongfeng Zhang
|
cs.OS
|
cs.OS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper envisions a revolutionary AIOS-Agent ecosystem, where Large
Language Model (LLM) serves as the (Artificial) Intelligent Operating System
(IOS, or AIOS)--an operating system "with soul". Upon this foundation, a
diverse range of LLM-based AI Agent Applications (Agents, or AAPs) are
developed, enriching the AIOS-Agent ecosystem and signaling a paradigm shift
from the traditional OS-APP ecosystem. We envision that LLM's impact will not
be limited to the AI application level, instead, it will in turn revolutionize
the design and implementation of computer system, architecture, software, and
programming language, featured by several main concepts: LLM as OS
(system-level), Agents as Applications (application-level), Natural Language as
Programming Interface (user-level), and Tools as Devices/Libraries
(hardware/middleware-level). We begin by introducing the architecture of
traditional OS. Then we formalize a conceptual framework for AIOS through "LLM
as OS (LLMOS)", drawing analogies between AIOS and traditional OS: LLM is
likened to OS kernel, context window to memory, external storage to file
system, hardware tools to peripheral devices, software tools to programming
libraries, and user prompts to user commands. Subsequently, we introduce the
new AIOS-Agent Ecosystem, where users can easily program Agent Applications
(AAPs) using natural language, democratizing the development of software, which
is different from the traditional OS-APP ecosystem. Following this, we explore
the diverse scope of Agent Applications. We delve into both single-agent and
multi-agent systems, as well as human-agent interaction. Lastly, drawing on the
insights from traditional OS-APP ecosystem, we propose a roadmap for the
evolution of the AIOS-Agent ecosystem. This roadmap is designed to guide the
future research and development, suggesting systematic progresses of AIOS and
its Agent applications.
|
[
-0.4539605081,
-0.4673838615,
0.6319040656,
-0.0914721116,
0.2308239639,
0.6321436763,
-0.0249062479,
-0.894071877,
0.4301680326,
0.8444607854,
-0.6076620817,
-0.3167517483,
-0.3717779517,
0.1074297726,
-0.3899293244,
0.7348722219,
0.1211746931,
-0.0769559965,
-0.2917952538,
0.0987029374,
-0.4436570406,
-0.1489003599,
-0.7238335609,
-0.4972173274,
0.0486040898,
0.3311904967,
0.8338375688,
0.8251923919,
0.4105777442,
0.4814966023,
0.3752148747,
0.0852503777,
0.0402708836,
0.3461174965,
-0.0025201729,
-0.3637497127,
-0.797917068,
0.1165138036,
0.4972221851,
0.3321007192,
0.086221166,
-0.0381606892,
0.0237783771,
0.8080867529,
-0.3868561983,
0.107094489,
-0.6250612736,
0.0052629053,
0.0570974983,
-0.3094478846,
-0.300660491,
-0.115158394,
-0.1605413258,
-0.7137660384,
-0.4507481158,
0.2283881456,
0.5377151966,
0.1713957936,
-0.5757082105,
-0.6357731223,
-0.8568559885,
0.6849328876,
-0.6042253971,
0.1974088401,
0.185569033,
0.3731897473,
-0.4360382259,
-0.6522849798,
-0.6251892447,
-0.5928484201,
0.3831534684,
-0.0544933379,
-0.1057152823,
0.3563076556,
-0.302641958,
0.2744409442,
-0.3096164465,
0.0683726743,
-0.2927704751,
-0.2251309454,
0.8310365677,
0.3297874331,
0.7266941667,
0.4739636779,
-0.6183796525,
0.1405681223,
-0.7021237612,
0.1007906124,
0.340765506,
0.2790174782,
-0.1099374965,
0.4768655002,
-0.3787174523,
0.6476902366,
-0.3717627823,
-0.4530109763,
0.1520239562,
-0.1633729041,
-0.2067007869,
0.1434489787,
0.6979891062,
0.402320832,
0.288520962,
-0.3212920129,
-0.5631639361,
0.2936763167,
0.5184579492,
-0.473240912,
0.3000692129,
0.4020887911,
-0.4567078054,
-0.483579129,
-0.1871172637,
-0.3038952947,
-0.6542742252,
-0.524117291,
0.3138120472,
-0.2868251204,
-0.0915550515,
-0.1425514221,
-0.0051704985,
0.5689600706,
0.559564352,
-0.7179555297,
0.9002666473,
0.998609066,
0.6606149673,
-0.0149472989,
-0.6360213757,
-0.2117361724,
0.3811556995,
-0.4064636827,
0.7636847496,
-0.6389517784,
-0.5134490132,
-0.1118607447,
-0.2492384017,
0.3363598287,
-0.4714684784,
0.0041050427,
-0.5043715835,
-0.0818997771,
-0.0064544943,
-0.4951381683,
-0.1721613109,
0.6071832776,
-0.3994137049,
0.647465229,
-0.2118361294,
-0.060261596,
-0.0110502755,
-1.0794639587,
-0.5238275528,
0.2476262152,
-0.2503191233,
0.2612348497,
0.0433283709,
-0.2309603244,
0.1238310114,
-0.6807981133,
0.1599409878,
-0.2075753063,
-0.4184347689,
0.1845620275,
-0.1004671752,
0.8157486916,
0.4744951427,
-0.2621936202,
0.1878142804,
-0.4763600528,
0.0228260551,
-0.0060793571,
-0.0852531344,
-0.2886283696,
0.4924674332,
-0.2019554377,
0.0516345054,
0.5878277421,
-0.6297600865,
0.6494868994,
-0.2628590167,
0.775244236,
0.9546121955,
-0.3153884411,
0.8081616759,
-0.2908344269,
0.5404649973,
-0.1679116637,
0.6690441966,
-0.3141132593,
-0.5718208551,
-0.4855292737,
-0.1471347362,
-0.3551537097,
0.7340888381,
-0.7432471514,
0.2599160075,
-0.1489774138,
-0.4203581512,
-0.4047337174,
0.0898505002,
0.1079480127,
0.3623330593,
-0.0079181604,
-0.4599308074,
-0.3857814074,
-0.8595453501,
-0.1163054183,
-0.8320578337,
0.2405086458,
0.3559914529,
0.449205488,
-0.8927952051,
1.3231891394,
-0.2791803181,
-0.2021241486,
-0.2129635811,
-0.3149193227,
-0.0894370079,
0.2898830473,
0.3621292412,
-0.6932376027,
-0.4393475652,
0.2470423132,
-0.7701221704,
-0.1315891594,
0.1514749527,
0.0241291765,
0.1633035839,
0.4590429664,
-0.6739160419,
0.0406440832,
0.3568033576,
-0.4235629737,
0.5444860458,
-0.2197841406,
0.0064186952,
-1.1277076006,
-0.0937239975,
-0.4546025693,
-0.0368533954,
-0.7891216278,
0.3229541481,
-0.2831838429,
-0.3341266513,
-0.3140093088,
1.1002334356,
-0.5696851611,
-0.6105858684,
-0.7322902679,
-0.0155004943,
0.0727919266,
-0.0598650128,
-0.124906674,
0.9725878239,
0.7680931687,
-0.5266855359,
0.7175887823,
-0.1278574318,
0.2219758183,
0.4198242426,
-0.3876552582,
0.2267567366,
0.0357450098,
0.2971062362,
-0.6635715365,
-0.0307830293,
0.3604384065,
-0.4703426361,
-0.0387129001,
0.238144666,
-0.44227916,
-0.3673473299,
-0.5495692492,
0.2102750391,
0.3834328949,
-0.0709243342,
0.9387018085,
0.6244134307,
-0.1290716827,
-0.7040240169,
-0.3952559531,
0.7295790911,
-0.14269346,
-0.78263098,
0.1968945265,
-0.0860938877,
-0.7742432356,
0.3139502704,
0.2892761528,
-0.0310115851,
0.519007802,
0.4575808048,
0.2078865618,
-0.3067125678,
0.1798514128,
0.0132021802,
-0.2420251667,
0.0155414511,
-0.4713150561,
0.4194599986,
-0.5403651595,
-0.1024129391,
-0.2812031806,
0.4125705659,
0.8347097039,
-0.3213937879,
0.5156983733,
0.2051088363,
-0.4382307827,
-0.1641907096,
-0.4084504545,
-0.2254702002,
-0.4994003475,
0.1592146307,
-0.3281268477,
-0.6873539686,
0.7113378048,
-0.2721677721,
0.2447176427,
0.2819559872,
0.4684080482,
-0.2073369473,
0.6520892382,
0.9068943262,
-0.4301620424,
0.5718917847,
-0.1438165456,
0.0830648318,
-0.819340229,
-0.2308530658,
-0.2732275128,
-0.515502274,
-0.5436086059,
-0.1616617143,
0.2617832124,
-0.2378364354,
-0.4696947932,
0.0027424728,
-0.492567271,
0.4294125438,
0.6144387722,
-0.469892025,
0.4023270309,
-0.1421574801,
0.2767217457,
0.5540869832,
-0.1901623458,
-1.0882706642,
1.1745016575,
0.7638421059,
0.7200269103,
-0.0388795361,
0.9416936636,
0.8895058632,
0.5535854101,
-0.9492788315,
0.9031766057,
0.0501377769,
-0.7245150208,
-0.4107613862,
0.0979152024,
-0.8713842034,
0.1796519309,
0.0913906395,
-0.8601794243,
0.1569564193,
-0.1285669804,
-0.2914998829,
0.1831152886,
-0.8457722664,
0.624714613,
-0.5576274991,
-0.2566739023,
-0.2479696274,
-0.7844625711,
0.1238811612,
0.3463840485,
0.3943031132,
-0.2979377806,
-0.6474357843,
0.3690476418,
-0.7180019021,
0.7824323177,
-0.1130400226,
-0.1598166078,
0.7934933305,
0.0889803916,
0.5583720207,
-0.373713553,
-0.1597768962,
0.0606781282,
-0.1507384777,
-0.1485711783,
-0.2799630165,
0.573325932,
-1.1009210348,
-0.5210914016,
-0.5391543508,
-0.5662236214,
-0.0907316059,
0.1961451173,
-0.201569885,
0.3494990468,
-0.4713384509,
-0.1397058219,
0.2954941094,
-0.1354341656,
0.5366232991,
0.6849921942,
-0.3790862262,
-0.2544740438,
0.9004248381,
0.0223427992,
0.0712643042,
0.2943837941,
0.0554436892,
-0.1744268686,
-0.5286161304,
-0.4526981711,
0.0306804813,
-0.4376792014,
-0.0724399611,
-0.4082304537,
-0.1346522868,
-0.5873673558,
-0.4357467294,
-0.4873509407,
0.0897607729,
-0.2622134089,
0.1627880782,
0.3075117767,
0.9728745222,
0.0199558567,
0.5226404667,
-0.5500508547,
0.3582138419,
0.1840529144,
0.2951900363,
0.0534710437,
0.0062905736,
-0.2375263274,
0.2034620792,
-0.5219908953,
-1.0267539024,
0.4730162621,
0.3314284682,
0.5295372009,
0.6900418997,
-0.0280518346,
0.2574998438,
-0.4602694809,
0.9075341821,
0.0800187066,
-0.8901224732,
0.5865676999,
-0.2735586762,
-0.0888754949,
0.5091369748,
-0.0583170913,
-0.7867666483,
-0.3702017367,
-0.3591429293,
-0.8060944676,
0.8688468933,
-0.1040568054,
0.3007834256,
0.0900047943,
0.3192642927,
0.0998406187,
0.6037624478,
-0.8297031522,
-0.2516195774,
-0.0921388268,
-0.0863583982,
-0.1976331174,
0.0552101433,
-0.0799504146,
0.1338611841,
0.6526082158,
-0.2627366185,
0.5418506265,
-0.0033724275,
-0.0191138778,
-0.0957239494,
0.4032641053,
0.4673986137,
0.3855652809,
-0.1024855077,
0.3750079572,
-0.3356354535,
-0.6450626254,
0.3776391447,
-0.1772254854,
-0.5296853781,
-0.5453635454,
0.2783309221,
0.8405906558,
-0.4678482115,
-0.8637855649,
0.0784377307,
0.1679764688,
0.175614506,
-0.5844525099,
0.3237181604,
0.0293316767,
0.7266309261,
0.8322287202,
-0.0484041683,
0.5627103448,
-1.3751673698,
-0.1245948151,
0.7061308622,
-0.3478525579,
-0.3021907806,
0.4838040173,
0.6151130795,
-0.7644731402,
0.4766945243,
-0.3292001486,
-0.4446400404,
1.0555224419,
0.5203210115,
1.4038069248,
-0.2202034593,
0.2517957389,
-0.4787602723,
0.8300226331,
-0.0326169282,
0.326785028,
-0.2844482064,
-0.8946346641,
0.0484869629,
-0.4748119712,
-0.4629079103,
-0.0691331327,
-0.0383820869,
0.086997509,
-0.5281071067,
-0.3774550259,
-0.3970126212,
0.4173489511,
-0.1129360273,
0.3217718601,
0.5491276383,
0.9109084606,
-0.76843822,
0.8921282291,
1.1997411251,
-0.0904184431,
-0.3405351043,
0.1887035519,
0.0076714298,
-0.8962782025,
0.4802340567,
0.1661028713,
-0.3137292862,
0.0626584068,
-0.6634040475,
-0.7768391371,
1.3859807253,
0.3218116462,
-0.2963070869,
0.0302541014,
0.3061889112,
0.6682339311,
-0.8144181371,
0.320453763,
0.2462735325,
0.487206012,
-0.0822537839,
-0.804063797,
-0.1884380728,
-0.4894751012,
0.0702441707,
0.1522572786,
-0.7160365582,
0.8482214808,
-0.3265306056,
-0.0229520686,
0.0911212415,
0.5084010363,
0.0331152603,
0.8683810234,
0.219468236,
0.2717164457,
0.4755949676,
0.0501667187,
1.1609146595,
-0.691123426,
-0.0834964141,
0.5400213599,
-0.6572611928,
0.7073282003,
0.5652456284,
-0.2513688803,
0.3990257382,
0.5505698919,
0.4047599137,
0.33495453,
-0.0686254054,
-0.4124991298,
-0.0056925942,
-0.2324981987,
-0.3991136253,
0.4493306577,
0.4686593711,
-0.0750377774,
-0.0108430348,
0.0926345959,
-0.2128947824,
-0.0853147358,
-0.4834160209,
0.8215346336,
0.2609843612,
-0.4180096984,
0.0349532925,
0.2949385345,
0.5965209007,
-0.7939372063,
0.2028037757,
-0.2282510847,
0.0644939467,
-0.0596743226,
-0.8509428501,
0.2034851462,
-0.1545777023,
-0.1404799819,
-0.4320908189,
1.053037405,
0.0787179768,
-0.1913699657,
0.4690721333,
0.4792515039,
0.1922677159,
-0.0646118298,
-0.8534151912,
0.2398440093,
-0.3412593603,
-0.303973645,
0.3379651308,
0.3969896138,
-0.1780704409,
1.2146092653,
0.4321451187,
0.1711674929,
-0.0544787645,
-0.5978870392,
0.8272700906,
-0.6182219386,
-0.7115117311,
-0.9166750312,
0.317663461,
0.165791139,
0.0202340875,
0.5562039614,
0.6134517789,
0.431949079,
0.0832366645,
0.8168916702,
-0.2916714549,
0.0072346674,
-0.1470183283,
0.6411630511,
-0.8000292182,
0.4450146854,
-0.2636004984,
-0.9506241679,
0.1848590225,
0.3848490119,
-0.3970192373,
0.2605215311,
0.1565915942,
0.6204307675,
0.2294864804,
-0.0648855567,
0.2639065087,
0.3042943776,
0.2045322657,
0.3810476959,
1.0493245125,
-0.3986226618,
-0.0141366133,
0.0273541138,
-0.3320533037,
-0.5249109268,
-0.6932489872,
-0.1758515984,
-0.6806303263,
-0.1204373166,
-0.0666106269,
0.353544414,
1.0984072685,
0.3802998066,
-0.4680525661,
-0.9919422269,
-0.1129378527,
0.4620674253,
-0.2647426724,
-0.1552292258,
-0.3640313148,
-0.2478569448,
-0.5691012144,
0.4975833595,
0.7361162901,
-0.0164740365,
-0.6411643028,
-0.6278755665,
0.013813925,
0.2580366433,
0.8201668262,
0.760592103,
-0.6708792448,
0.0774360597,
0.1364197433,
-0.4186895192,
-0.1152092516,
0.6238626242,
-0.9387903214,
0.4560629427,
0.182956636,
0.4716530144,
-0.1828232706,
-0.11935734,
0.6111673713,
-0.2565498948,
0.1720718741,
0.3920463026,
-0.09187603,
0.0111679751,
-0.3631170988,
0.3959214091,
0.2704255283,
-0.330911994,
-0.9450021982,
0.4206555188,
-0.96092695,
-0.4480894804,
1.0536123514,
0.3832067251,
-0.3095676005,
-0.2733775675,
-0.2972647846,
-0.0533562601,
-0.6828222871,
0.7526811361,
0.4314259589,
-0.4219689071,
-0.0879311711,
-0.5724911094,
0.286929369,
-0.2156672329,
-1.0185438395,
-0.047010079,
0.5174739361,
0.022298729,
0.2754212618,
1.1772199869,
0.0332394093,
0.0665265173,
0.1834460646,
0.5868252516,
-0.2021299452,
-0.6660833359,
-0.0076928707,
0.0418011025,
0.4210095406,
-0.1973143518
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03668v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03668v2
|
Integrating Pre-Trained Speech and Language Models for End-to-End Speech Recognition
| 2023-12-06T18:34:42 | 2024-06-06T15:24:16 |
Yukiya Hono, Koh Mitsuda, Tianyu Zhao, Kentaro Mitsui, Toshiaki Wakatsuki, Kei Sawada
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Advances in machine learning have made it possible to perform various text
and speech processing tasks, such as automatic speech recognition (ASR), in an
end-to-end (E2E) manner. E2E approaches utilizing pre-trained models are
gaining attention for conserving training data and resources. However, most of
their applications in ASR involve only one of either a pre-trained speech or a
language model. This paper proposes integrating a pre-trained speech
representation model and a large language model (LLM) for E2E ASR. The proposed
model enables the optimization of the entire ASR process, including acoustic
feature extraction and acoustic and language modeling, by combining pre-trained
models with a bridge network and also enables the application of remarkable
developments in LLM utilization, such as parameter-efficient domain adaptation
and inference optimization. Experimental results demonstrate that the proposed
model achieves a performance comparable to that of modern E2E ASR models by
utilizing powerful pre-training models with the proposed integrated approach.
|
[
-0.577121377,
-0.5553513169,
0.3102812171,
0.0549313091,
-0.4919759929,
-0.0074482658,
-0.392760843,
-0.7652312517,
0.1749508083,
0.6441014409,
-0.2578984797,
-0.0252843294,
-0.6991478801,
-0.0158156939,
-0.5767877698,
0.5813792348,
-0.2817572653,
0.2219194025,
-0.184517011,
0.0658758953,
-0.3587693572,
-0.7392695546,
-0.828130126,
-0.5988462567,
0.0800983086,
0.04765293,
0.1880922318,
0.5575966239,
0.3202372193,
0.3320050836,
0.0181689877,
-0.0709461644,
-0.2366722673,
-0.1849387437,
-0.2803349197,
-0.1474374682,
-0.6133075356,
0.0594707951,
0.8440618515,
0.7485471368,
-0.1307399869,
0.1395472437,
0.1874406338,
0.172128424,
-0.4328258932,
0.0457512997,
-0.4348407388,
-0.1200177819,
-0.1940564364,
-0.2548838258,
-0.2268174887,
-0.0321770795,
0.3873620331,
-0.3774982393,
-0.247228384,
-0.0739811808,
0.9467409849,
0.343201369,
-0.2556062043,
-0.3825983107,
-1.0524920225,
0.5445538759,
-0.7701588869,
0.781335175,
0.2939710319,
0.4950320423,
0.0407015346,
-0.8120427728,
-0.7592579126,
-0.2673947513,
0.0075214431,
0.2250299901,
-0.251737982,
0.2323452085,
0.0616747066,
0.1165990829,
-0.5983885527,
0.5819240212,
-0.3454141021,
-0.1392072886,
0.7078806758,
-0.2753760517,
0.2564627528,
0.273447454,
-0.3119015098,
-0.0063826465,
-0.6605507135,
0.1947565079,
0.124879837,
0.581509769,
-0.1668584645,
0.485796243,
0.0741468444,
0.6608592272,
-0.0421760418,
0.0189130884,
0.2026971728,
-0.0312175769,
-0.243514508,
0.2659250498,
0.7337260842,
-0.1121794358,
0.739138186,
-0.2168868631,
-0.474938333,
0.0911114216,
-0.029348867,
-0.7719245553,
0.0187032726,
0.0791529268,
-0.3733442128,
0.1115555763,
-0.0769304559,
-0.2232702225,
0.1544349641,
-0.7617537379,
0.6237595677,
-0.0866750628,
-0.5071332455,
0.293605566,
0.1969007105,
0.4465920627,
0.2244582623,
-0.7209500074,
0.7486328483,
0.5267047882,
0.721870482,
0.0186742414,
-0.1595952213,
-0.7838697433,
0.4235389531,
-0.0323118679,
0.7019518614,
-0.53468889,
-0.4641492069,
-0.0848635063,
-0.0473583154,
-0.1899148524,
-0.4356858134,
0.4029504657,
-0.7341857553,
0.0679796115,
0.4516817033,
-0.7259446383,
-0.2024303526,
-0.1098643914,
-0.783804059,
0.6635468602,
-0.112833634,
-0.4719380736,
-0.0698152259,
-0.812658906,
-0.6442408562,
0.1023425087,
-0.263656795,
-0.5603457689,
0.1141498536,
0.2828889489,
0.4798380435,
-0.6435989141,
0.2952346206,
-0.0480467901,
-0.3382885754,
0.0938611031,
-0.330160588,
0.7349935174,
0.1523822099,
-0.1336796284,
-0.0377790555,
-0.7250746489,
0.0055819857,
0.0895369798,
-0.508402884,
-0.2085080892,
0.0077548334,
0.4754959047,
0.2777336836,
0.4516232312,
-0.4697957039,
-0.2853182554,
-0.5245966911,
0.490329206,
0.5008018613,
-0.3197562993,
0.5466470122,
-0.0692912117,
0.470462352,
0.0506859645,
-0.1352170259,
-0.1634753644,
-0.1127260476,
-0.6783927083,
-0.093578957,
0.6349850297,
0.8708456755,
-0.3929192722,
0.7170031667,
-0.4414601326,
-0.1710631996,
-0.6005958915,
0.0108438833,
0.4732962549,
0.34025684,
0.4729105532,
-0.4276827276,
-0.8283637762,
-0.6780843735,
-0.1386971623,
-0.2112403959,
-0.3001723289,
0.2732480168,
0.2393766791,
-0.2386693209,
1.2484892607,
-0.1076873019,
-0.4505808949,
-0.4616492689,
-0.0738001615,
0.3573909104,
0.6381267309,
0.3217742145,
-0.8203033805,
-0.5924594998,
0.2041939199,
-0.5484000444,
-0.2962691486,
0.035811834,
0.1608615816,
-0.0807051435,
0.6654289961,
-0.3134377897,
0.2846600413,
0.5652232766,
0.0750364438,
0.3961354196,
-0.2597508729,
-0.0868223161,
-1.1893882751,
0.0807357654,
0.1922352612,
-0.4645547271,
-1.052698493,
-0.2685905993,
-0.147020191,
-0.3924129605,
-0.1826485246,
0.6206675768,
-0.8047825098,
-0.4560867846,
-0.4240773618,
0.1642931402,
-0.0923923627,
0.349904269,
0.4371818006,
0.6769259572,
0.8996935487,
-0.5468230844,
0.403260082,
0.1444698423,
-0.1227500811,
0.2627122104,
-0.9028201103,
0.357712239,
-0.2110035717,
0.116279617,
-0.6833652258,
-0.0671481714,
-0.046937976,
-0.5383635759,
0.7722921968,
-0.1263745725,
-0.4313961565,
-0.3182924092,
0.1102301553,
0.4174714983,
0.6468924284,
-0.5999936461,
1.0782366991,
0.647577703,
-0.5159688592,
-0.2297352105,
-0.5962252617,
0.0960985199,
-0.1897722483,
-0.6703805923,
0.6672089696,
0.1728490293,
0.1977763325,
-0.1453044415,
0.1164615527,
-0.2668998539,
-0.2160369903,
0.0724221393,
0.2432116419,
-0.440744549,
-0.0394894183,
-0.0640027747,
-0.4554814696,
0.051946681,
-0.37646088,
0.7176643014,
0.1162991747,
-0.532476902,
-0.6931251884,
0.6422637105,
0.4045284092,
-0.7377275229,
0.3484148979,
0.3868987858,
-0.6661893129,
-0.0298398025,
-0.8074144721,
-0.310283035,
-0.4653116763,
0.7400191426,
-0.5873180628,
-0.9804970622,
0.380700171,
-0.5469441414,
0.0315115415,
-0.069236055,
0.2984112203,
-0.4039996564,
0.8627331853,
0.7296137214,
-0.3319419324,
0.7509704232,
-0.1416496485,
0.4410841763,
-0.9642038345,
-0.0994757041,
-0.5818328857,
-0.1227484792,
-0.2960045338,
-0.4932946563,
0.2079423368,
0.3842856288,
-0.3010961115,
0.4043843448,
-0.0944173709,
0.3919027746,
0.4107291698,
0.068479076,
0.1833748668,
0.268450588,
0.133927539,
0.1664043963,
-0.610558629,
-0.5879388452,
0.9936720133,
0.5178557634,
0.5852484703,
-0.0386715345,
0.6986431479,
0.0115547115,
0.1430015266,
-0.6405543089,
0.4851911068,
-0.5089119077,
-0.2781873047,
-0.5376493335,
-0.4044037163,
-0.7075734735,
0.1094140336,
-0.111247167,
-0.6481515169,
0.0689394921,
0.2170085609,
-0.3609190583,
0.0874957517,
-0.4853961468,
0.5014313459,
-0.3237972856,
-0.0150771439,
-0.2121420205,
-0.6915571094,
-0.1152833551,
-0.3009214997,
0.3398314118,
0.1118966192,
0.217053026,
0.8058313727,
-0.2991347015,
0.6467319131,
-0.3587720692,
0.124809809,
0.3771732748,
-0.5076113343,
0.817874074,
-0.4230563343,
-0.0954212472,
0.2917520702,
-0.4763242304,
-0.0986504927,
-0.5693302155,
0.2202904224,
-1.0000083447,
-0.460919708,
-0.0191942565,
-0.1650601923,
-0.3876821697,
0.0260495599,
0.0915287808,
0.6375125051,
-0.1134102866,
0.0192680694,
0.5821797252,
-0.2510829568,
0.6344698668,
0.579448998,
-0.1393435001,
-0.4645976424,
0.861369133,
0.2997392118,
0.304782182,
0.4384254813,
0.0915805027,
-0.6149397492,
-0.783410728,
-0.435646534,
0.350820452,
-0.5015352368,
0.0511987284,
-0.6976147294,
-0.7374601364,
-0.5687372088,
-0.1809589863,
-0.3855285347,
-0.0888504833,
-0.4852496088,
-0.0167126711,
0.2950058579,
0.435679853,
-0.2140801102,
0.8266848326,
-0.8230953813,
0.333710283,
0.4093418419,
0.3680526316,
-0.0014090246,
-0.8779318929,
-0.4471861422,
-0.0713419542,
0.1786842793,
-0.8759767413,
0.3676424026,
0.6342346072,
0.7402895689,
0.3666037917,
-0.3412733674,
0.747543633,
-0.8226589561,
0.1874099076,
0.5431881547,
-1.086012125,
0.5521616936,
-0.0508374199,
0.1328139454,
0.3311279714,
0.4042312801,
-0.3509130776,
-0.0196935497,
-0.1211190894,
-0.8046172261,
0.6710178256,
0.0613132827,
0.0589822195,
0.3742102981,
0.2536377013,
-0.2867226601,
-0.003655209,
-0.804910183,
0.0992212221,
-0.2090446502,
-0.3049632013,
-0.1210144907,
-0.2145403773,
0.2285399139,
-0.2646833062,
0.5848274231,
0.0060442304,
0.1787135154,
-0.144817397,
-0.4937855303,
0.0302180201,
0.2127932608,
0.2067843378,
0.2738088667,
0.0052777082,
-0.0874319077,
0.4500842094,
-0.4666679204,
0.1575536281,
0.4996206462,
0.1190750003,
0.0489078425,
0.4248000681,
0.8794854879,
0.2491631508,
-0.5394057035,
0.4962079823,
0.2089385092,
0.0019170897,
-0.6225600243,
-0.2264671475,
0.3346476555,
0.4349817932,
0.374969393,
-0.1805440038,
0.1798291504,
-0.3138669431,
0.4249584973,
0.394770205,
-0.3238565028,
-0.2335882336,
0.6498360634,
0.3652155101,
-0.5391076803,
0.5932761431,
0.151720494,
-0.6938095093,
0.5639081001,
0.7269958258,
0.9573701024,
-0.8276552558,
-0.3119185567,
0.3698582053,
0.2399412543,
0.0835191458,
0.3899128139,
-0.1229827479,
-0.7663614154,
-0.8281629682,
-0.9888821244,
-0.1574575901,
0.044866655,
-0.5809947848,
0.7061290145,
-0.3339535892,
-0.1327633858,
-0.1561873853,
-0.1287541091,
-0.716769278,
0.5603298545,
0.5071946979,
0.695281446,
-0.9165910482,
1.1477681398,
0.6127201319,
-0.344368875,
-0.9580834508,
-0.2900848985,
-0.2910377979,
-0.6029596329,
0.7260771394,
0.2199843973,
-0.4056173861,
0.3978022039,
-0.1541324109,
-0.8545600176,
1.0095347166,
0.355641067,
-1.1541179419,
-0.1642636955,
0.4679405093,
0.3479551375,
-0.694357574,
0.2952721119,
0.552754879,
0.2533858716,
0.3183360398,
-1.3847453594,
-0.2214012146,
-0.3621416688,
0.3210118711,
0.1214664355,
-0.258012861,
0.7699888945,
-0.1242348328,
-0.4057208598,
-0.2938774526,
0.8829296231,
0.3933935165,
0.116405569,
0.828660965,
0.5024058819,
0.3859010339,
0.062338464,
0.4524947107,
-0.310222894,
0.066449903,
1.2925499678,
-0.4963590801,
1.2186211348,
0.2782330811,
-0.2485563457,
0.0317318216,
0.6512371302,
0.248085022,
0.7135887742,
0.4915807545,
-0.5194894671,
-0.1736958772,
-0.1029211283,
-0.4494002759,
0.6883434653,
0.45194906,
-0.2889980674,
-0.1911220849,
0.3028604686,
-0.1353898346,
-0.0187708735,
-0.4735877812,
1.0507718325,
0.3227384388,
-0.1421402544,
0.3241895139,
-0.0802752897,
0.795329988,
-0.5655990243,
-0.0009491678,
0.1329277307,
-0.0463740416,
-0.1901947707,
-0.3583739698,
0.3697123528,
0.246917814,
-0.2379200459,
-0.3307347894,
0.755584538,
-0.7170006633,
-0.4335848391,
0.7528327703,
0.4584400952,
0.3853905201,
-0.1794588864,
-0.3835823834,
0.1673344076,
-0.2669019997,
-0.2020250112,
0.2691566348,
0.2891488075,
0.0901856422,
0.3983938694,
0.8748002648,
0.3516631722,
0.1579824835,
0.5485773087,
1.0019447803,
-0.393635124,
-0.7804006934,
-0.7911726832,
0.6781209111,
-0.0916848332,
0.1231297776,
0.0853462219,
0.5947036147,
0.786531508,
0.1854961663,
0.984383285,
0.2356705815,
0.7647297978,
-0.5057460666,
0.8010317683,
-0.5527544618,
0.1525293589,
-0.2352717966,
-1.0882722139,
-0.1304781884,
0.8163954616,
-0.1786988527,
0.3195180297,
0.2565120459,
0.756860435,
-0.156074658,
0.0230078697,
0.5289844275,
0.1494355202,
0.4192564785,
0.6404434443,
0.7097831368,
-0.2737431824,
0.3809223473,
0.0995089188,
-0.5127401352,
-0.2358238697,
-0.7284597754,
-0.8469622731,
-0.7665402293,
-0.2603593469,
0.0362861566,
0.1040922403,
0.9941164851,
0.7728123665,
-0.7481129766,
-0.602314353,
-0.0108380374,
-0.5799838305,
0.1654221267,
-0.0720882937,
0.3354708552,
-0.1607671082,
-0.7788298726,
0.5745233893,
0.3518539369,
0.3899174035,
-0.2196128666,
-0.4025371969,
-0.1049156711,
0.1604318917,
0.6318334937,
0.2963188291,
-0.5223992467,
-0.087802127,
-0.0334577449,
0.2196544111,
-0.0759567171,
0.7107620835,
-0.8033528924,
0.3883495927,
0.2944212556,
0.9204012752,
0.8559340835,
-0.0940480009,
0.9310213923,
-0.5293578506,
0.0583039261,
0.3844286501,
0.4339710772,
0.3964452744,
0.0104539627,
0.2387446612,
-0.0992166996,
-0.4392180145,
-0.9197689891,
0.4317387044,
-0.7641817927,
0.0121410042,
0.6993640065,
-0.3630335629,
0.1200290322,
-0.2201905549,
0.0809200853,
0.7572623491,
-0.0657748654,
0.3497015536,
0.5217152834,
-0.1637516767,
-0.4654464126,
-0.6437588334,
0.1543634981,
0.311193496,
-0.9967623949,
-0.1568097621,
0.1749834716,
0.0583295487,
0.0080933655,
0.7192248106,
0.0125336433,
0.1346978396,
-0.1994474232,
0.2223615646,
-0.1521003246,
-0.5023798943,
-0.5467397571,
-0.0315148421,
-0.0127843479,
-0.2933090329
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03664v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03664v2
|
Generative agent-based modeling with actions grounded in physical, social, or digital space using Concordia
| 2023-12-06T18:33:50 | 2023-12-13T20:13:25 |
Alexander Sasha Vezhnevets, John P. Agapiou, Avia Aharon, Ron Ziv, Jayd Matyas, Edgar A. Duéñez-Guzmán, William A. Cunningham, Simon Osindero, Danny Karmon, Joel Z. Leibo
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Agent-based modeling has been around for decades, and applied widely across
the social and natural sciences. The scope of this research method is now
poised to grow dramatically as it absorbs the new affordances provided by Large
Language Models (LLM)s. Generative Agent-Based Models (GABM) are not just
classic Agent-Based Models (ABM)s where the agents talk to one another. Rather,
GABMs are constructed using an LLM to apply common sense to situations, act
"reasonably", recall common semantic knowledge, produce API calls to control
digital technologies like apps, and communicate both within the simulation and
to researchers viewing it from the outside. Here we present Concordia, a
library to facilitate constructing and working with GABMs. Concordia makes it
easy to construct language-mediated simulations of physically- or
digitally-grounded environments. Concordia agents produce their behavior using
a flexible component system which mediates between two fundamental operations:
LLM calls and associative memory retrieval. A special agent called the Game
Master (GM), which was inspired by tabletop role-playing games, is responsible
for simulating the environment where the agents interact. Agents take actions
by describing what they want to do in natural language. The GM then translates
their actions into appropriate implementations. In a simulated physical world,
the GM checks the physical plausibility of agent actions and describes their
effects. In digital environments simulating technologies such as apps and
services, the GM may handle API calls to integrate with external tools such as
general AI assistants (e.g., Bard, ChatGPT), and digital apps (e.g., Calendar,
Email, Search, etc.). Concordia was designed to support a wide array of
applications both in scientific research and for evaluating performance of real
digital services by simulating users and/or generating synthetic data.
|
[
-0.3963278532,
-0.9740022421,
0.7305294871,
0.2916712463,
0.2202124894,
0.2749536335,
0.0992902443,
-0.0377215482,
0.3756263852,
0.4632843435,
-0.5861032009,
-0.6955152154,
0.0383077413,
-0.3862440586,
-0.4062025547,
0.6996450424,
0.1617667228,
0.1916320771,
-0.6373673081,
-0.043148499,
-0.5103666782,
-0.6168798804,
-1.0134199858,
-0.5527652502,
0.5034021139,
0.1318452805,
0.9230450392,
0.2709136009,
0.3900952339,
0.3127661049,
0.0014596939,
0.2591651678,
-0.4694120884,
0.0512118712,
-0.4599523544,
-0.2674326599,
-0.7533691525,
-0.1340328902,
0.512537837,
0.3891389072,
-0.1486581415,
0.0619754456,
-0.1659549326,
0.32534495,
-0.3877267241,
0.5305092931,
-0.0555586033,
0.1578123271,
0.2528531551,
-0.1573922336,
-0.4090852737,
-0.2945808172,
-0.0511519052,
-0.7024227381,
0.3651100695,
0.0737287849,
0.7880866528,
-0.1030095369,
-0.5024459362,
-0.4326218963,
-1.1032520533,
0.576818943,
-0.3782868087,
0.3208051026,
0.6146847606,
0.2734433711,
-0.4809496403,
-0.734239161,
-0.7279854417,
-0.2289350331,
-0.0024153129,
0.3685472608,
-0.2138040066,
0.3281620443,
0.2313153595,
0.2140070498,
-0.588383317,
-0.1083621904,
-0.3481912613,
-0.1262686402,
0.8633216023,
0.5803744793,
0.525939405,
-0.1251185089,
-0.1293977052,
-0.0788826644,
-0.5812832117,
0.102123484,
0.4186732769,
0.0814777389,
-0.1779310852,
0.620310545,
0.028377587,
0.4058991969,
-0.1128469035,
0.0333098844,
-0.0866353661,
-0.116999954,
-0.1420784444,
-0.3648254275,
0.5968124866,
0.5211503506,
-0.0616740845,
-0.2847782075,
-0.2253433615,
0.2723583579,
0.6202427149,
-0.5270885825,
-0.3797819912,
0.3491480947,
-0.4768455327,
-0.265245378,
-0.2422449738,
-0.6304984689,
-0.4148760438,
-0.7287852764,
0.4052921236,
-0.5136538148,
-0.3665133417,
0.005240567,
0.0833852664,
0.3989422619,
0.5628647208,
-0.843800962,
0.7095573545,
0.7512700558,
1.1803126335,
-0.2008517534,
-0.2054159045,
-0.5286146402,
0.3075666428,
-0.3239376545,
0.5488865972,
-0.475782305,
-0.7056939006,
0.1818390638,
-0.0176636726,
0.0547360741,
-0.3617323339,
0.6214478016,
-0.7764433026,
-0.1718025655,
-0.1613661349,
-0.6332228184,
-0.2472811341,
0.2751064301,
-0.7429108024,
1.0490121841,
-0.2237077951,
-0.2087261379,
-0.0563268848,
-1.0425851345,
-0.2676777244,
0.2366007566,
-0.2037913203,
-0.2354543507,
0.4259236455,
-0.2150514275,
0.5236873031,
-0.2262750566,
0.4237915874,
-0.210222885,
-0.283949852,
0.1004401222,
-0.1962516755,
0.8343302608,
0.2987890244,
0.0611289553,
0.1688706428,
-0.6201809049,
0.0845751092,
0.1827678233,
-0.1210846305,
-0.3478445411,
0.4200864136,
0.0416664183,
0.2058701515,
-0.121906966,
-0.3883314729,
0.3585742712,
0.1038472727,
0.3792628944,
0.5205575824,
-0.1888564527,
0.7312699556,
-0.5151207447,
0.5976760387,
-0.1053449586,
0.1229579672,
-0.2032065243,
-0.6408196092,
-0.5463324189,
-0.5435805917,
0.2031476349,
0.4478381276,
-0.9496356249,
0.1273704916,
-0.1747624725,
-0.5911403894,
-0.4149264693,
-0.3271159232,
-0.0201160908,
0.1208505109,
0.3041930497,
-0.574319303,
-0.2811006308,
-0.5428086519,
0.3085086346,
-0.4265442789,
0.0177048482,
0.4896460474,
0.5888592005,
-0.3633721173,
1.4464006424,
-0.5861824751,
-0.2547003925,
-0.2302047014,
0.3394006789,
-0.1278218776,
0.400534898,
0.6014737487,
-0.8667458296,
-0.1607381254,
-0.0598515123,
-0.9370013475,
-0.2026856244,
-0.2777023315,
-0.2615641057,
-0.1997436881,
0.2478718758,
-0.9324401021,
0.6105130315,
0.5692675114,
-0.3663802445,
0.8283625841,
-0.477039963,
-0.046634905,
-0.9197856784,
0.1224800944,
-0.3532631397,
-0.239763394,
-1.0669178963,
0.4922846258,
-0.1020125747,
-0.4145650864,
-0.5024337769,
0.9542612433,
-0.3649674952,
-0.3147262335,
-0.4147564471,
-0.210893929,
0.1338682324,
0.4469504058,
0.4478461444,
0.7595616579,
0.584235847,
-0.8451616764,
0.5356820226,
0.2023698688,
-0.0189867076,
0.6097775698,
-0.7219222784,
0.2405948341,
-0.4460232854,
0.2366448939,
-0.8269679546,
-0.0643907115,
0.3123642504,
-0.333286643,
-0.1009483635,
-0.2198341638,
-0.8689450622,
-0.2154114693,
0.1010545567,
0.2985500991,
0.3095145524,
-0.2959848642,
1.3656542301,
0.3593348265,
-0.1346814334,
-0.1188878119,
-0.5068987012,
0.1174220443,
-0.0908183604,
-0.6290956736,
0.2127061337,
-0.3619000018,
-0.3953934014,
0.0677293688,
0.2426540703,
-0.1986132264,
0.263661474,
0.566647768,
0.3906936347,
0.0193810649,
0.2923735976,
0.096576862,
-0.0282004774,
0.1971906573,
-0.3706169724,
0.7393783331,
-0.1609150916,
-0.6389979124,
-0.1197576821,
0.5759528279,
0.662445128,
-0.168930769,
0.818474412,
0.3567876518,
-0.426099211,
-0.1959910691,
-0.3889915347,
-0.2108008265,
-0.4933067262,
0.0728377029,
-0.4901562929,
-0.5064482689,
0.8461751342,
-0.2423715293,
0.2153370976,
-0.1041558385,
0.6226674318,
-0.1971263438,
0.9052510858,
0.4541062415,
0.16615206,
0.4529247284,
-0.5193583369,
0.0652411282,
-0.7831118107,
-0.2256755978,
-0.2895627022,
-0.4091369212,
-0.0527519099,
-0.8077901006,
-0.0245376248,
-0.1182868555,
-0.2707092166,
0.2393898517,
-0.1817494482,
0.4627661705,
0.6251145601,
-0.2351331562,
0.5013123751,
0.2175093591,
-0.7168755531,
-0.1996905804,
-0.5796881318,
-0.8211746216,
0.958519876,
0.4020344913,
0.8681024313,
0.365863651,
0.6065709591,
0.657666564,
0.4647372067,
-0.786750257,
0.8618612289,
0.2826310992,
-0.8754861355,
0.0456874371,
-0.3297983706,
-0.7979372144,
0.3558196723,
-0.1954743564,
-0.6688534021,
0.2297062427,
-0.033700332,
-0.3704583347,
0.3197388947,
-0.67864573,
0.6034785509,
-0.2552160621,
-0.8024219871,
-0.2208226025,
-0.1697685868,
0.1019511744,
0.097011596,
0.2871023715,
-0.0063101165,
0.1272557825,
-0.0050926805,
-0.1749035418,
0.9473190904,
-0.2087414265,
-0.2043712735,
0.4294549525,
0.5267380476,
0.6156711578,
0.1961701065,
-0.0058012395,
0.1657533646,
-0.0296149384,
-0.2788081765,
-0.6716730595,
0.6356338859,
-1.0787501335,
-0.4234797359,
-0.5956798792,
-0.7124252319,
0.0722593665,
-0.0061348989,
-0.1979994774,
0.3867977858,
-0.6463096142,
-0.053016454,
0.6247435808,
-0.3835387528,
0.2638987601,
0.894978106,
-0.7438802719,
-0.1448233426,
0.8882191181,
0.177385658,
0.104082182,
0.1685309559,
-0.2021993548,
-0.2613582909,
-0.4540280104,
-0.3140618205,
0.1259656847,
-0.4859862626,
0.0666653812,
-0.7477933168,
-0.4005625546,
0.0303958654,
-0.4105823338,
-0.3070628047,
-0.2939776182,
-0.3254571557,
-0.2208642364,
0.160923928,
0.6458187103,
-0.2953952849,
0.4765150547,
-0.5154336095,
0.3394156396,
0.319676131,
0.2263563871,
0.2169046551,
-0.0612385683,
-0.2546174228,
0.1719636619,
-0.6069408059,
-0.7879782915,
0.5645951033,
0.1273096949,
0.4723355174,
0.4250728488,
0.0646124855,
0.6218329072,
-0.7475787401,
0.8126506805,
-0.0022256325,
-0.8049951196,
0.2858859003,
-0.6032193899,
0.1078919619,
0.1023268625,
0.366250962,
-0.7179559469,
-0.3976866603,
-0.6505416036,
-0.8301100135,
0.7491173744,
0.4983589351,
0.5064723492,
-0.1623728424,
0.3306080401,
-0.0622714274,
0.2594929934,
-0.5892311335,
-0.341109097,
-0.2004765421,
-0.0567253269,
-0.1001749039,
-0.048413936,
-0.2998287082,
-0.1451134235,
0.5902659893,
-0.2872647047,
0.8041494489,
0.0578985289,
-0.0770942569,
0.1108443961,
-0.0134385945,
0.6687911153,
0.372930944,
-0.0882458687,
0.177217856,
0.1148215458,
-0.5864779949,
0.4189310074,
-0.0402879454,
-0.5880346298,
0.0377683342,
-0.0941417143,
0.6645396352,
0.0114162304,
-0.6239812374,
0.2211543918,
-0.2748767436,
-0.2557286024,
-0.7905882001,
0.0514319837,
0.4712970257,
0.4752707183,
0.3861519098,
-0.0026445678,
0.1251196563,
-0.7062886357,
0.0749140605,
0.4257784188,
-0.3008455634,
-0.5402408242,
0.8113865256,
0.2531353831,
-0.4882512689,
0.5621314049,
-0.5869393349,
-0.1298598349,
0.6164727807,
0.6389167905,
0.8141516447,
0.0499607995,
0.7440448403,
0.20944646,
0.0855889022,
-0.1542710811,
0.4534211457,
0.0221468098,
-0.8575632572,
-0.3800944686,
-0.4830829203,
-0.5286028385,
0.0930359438,
-0.4197566211,
0.2283620387,
-0.6460600495,
-0.5693401694,
-0.3198947906,
0.1103391796,
-0.7766272426,
-0.0730008259,
0.297197938,
0.821388185,
-0.8616585135,
0.7349315286,
1.1540957689,
-0.460432291,
-0.549476862,
-0.1556389779,
0.2271122783,
-0.3804534674,
0.7480893731,
-0.2659369111,
-0.1229305789,
0.1727005243,
-0.4787820876,
-0.7445845008,
1.3744409084,
0.3394453526,
-0.2971631885,
-0.2775662541,
0.2681074739,
0.8425393701,
-0.4998110235,
0.6391922832,
0.057529632,
0.1458285898,
0.2887918651,
-0.5309672356,
-0.1829138249,
-0.2000018507,
0.1715490669,
-0.0588227585,
-0.9235622883,
0.7957779765,
0.0254466962,
-0.3061878383,
0.279879272,
0.8138906956,
0.4200842679,
0.6819064021,
0.1029419303,
0.6653320789,
0.8828754425,
-0.1771693379,
0.9603202939,
-0.2182779461,
0.5346744657,
0.9077159166,
-0.6236318946,
0.5896148086,
0.2243750393,
0.0976355076,
0.6326924562,
0.3557861745,
0.035108339,
0.5885525346,
0.3591649234,
-0.6357342005,
-0.0792692006,
-0.1941163689,
-0.0345854089,
0.2329808623,
0.6579326391,
-0.1620995849,
-0.2176614553,
0.0799273625,
-0.0778132975,
-0.0062352191,
-0.407948792,
0.6704890132,
0.1472383291,
-0.3374751508,
-0.0371604227,
0.1271906644,
0.0947999656,
-0.7265894413,
-0.1057977602,
-0.3078355193,
0.2370979935,
-0.0455475822,
-0.613137722,
0.3569621146,
-0.0337671414,
-0.2453989536,
-0.3970677555,
0.8431665897,
-0.1792744696,
-0.2893341482,
0.4884465933,
0.7098988891,
0.2267965525,
0.2002744675,
-0.7190942764,
0.1742744595,
-0.4664040804,
-0.0918811262,
0.3516472876,
0.4604793489,
-0.2704545557,
1.0345413685,
0.812078476,
0.1540136337,
-0.0302361548,
-0.1072584391,
0.8091118336,
-0.5285156369,
-0.6388636827,
-0.5258997083,
0.6401806474,
-0.1314500868,
0.0520960316,
0.710373342,
0.6986582279,
0.5870992541,
-0.2183673978,
0.8362756371,
-0.2877443731,
-0.0062642652,
-0.3331560493,
0.7836923599,
-0.4196150899,
0.1423750222,
-0.289806664,
-1.1288464069,
-0.2900243402,
0.7306098342,
-0.4217776954,
-0.1415137351,
0.3814893365,
0.9097485542,
-0.4014801681,
0.1099499315,
0.532369256,
-0.0465287529,
0.5821264386,
0.2312806398,
1.1296986341,
-0.1739656031,
0.2002772093,
0.2005663961,
-0.0223994944,
-0.2699110508,
-0.7904238105,
-1.0584443808,
-0.5573055148,
-0.2659776807,
-0.2601986527,
0.2357430011,
1.1253371239,
0.7024568319,
-0.7106051445,
-0.3877004385,
-0.2220910639,
0.0044102794,
-0.363203913,
-0.2643660009,
0.1960498989,
-0.1384411007,
-0.9235337377,
0.361856699,
0.1196839735,
0.0705363229,
-0.4359536171,
-0.430021137,
-0.206822589,
0.3307430148,
0.7258555889,
0.5211369991,
-0.5105428696,
-0.2780325115,
0.1731849015,
-0.2370355725,
-0.2925499678,
0.8510742784,
-0.7884108424,
0.6278538108,
0.4709846079,
0.6115756035,
0.4740085304,
0.0556533299,
0.8694046736,
-0.7139714956,
-0.0466550998,
0.2488758713,
0.1377767026,
0.1562082469,
-0.1219459996,
0.6611876488,
0.3496943712,
-0.5691093206,
-0.6196504831,
0.2723439336,
-0.7320014238,
-0.048268158,
1.13020432,
-0.2626953423,
-0.0498241372,
-0.3840628564,
-0.5587286949,
0.0198637377,
-0.5355829,
0.8259708285,
1.1110005379,
0.0210084505,
-0.2710045576,
-0.9884922504,
0.2966972589,
0.2315555662,
-0.5317534208,
-0.0497411117,
0.6419734955,
0.0117463851,
0.3413210213,
0.6872056127,
0.0642429143,
0.2701101303,
-0.0639460087,
0.3756506741,
-0.2728169262,
-0.4136250913,
-0.2577999532,
0.181692034,
-0.0635801256,
0.0687691867
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03813v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03813v1
|
Improving Activation Steering in Language Models with Mean-Centring
| 2023-12-06T18:27:07 | 2023-12-06T18:27:07 |
Ole Jorgensen, Dylan Cope, Nandi Schoots, Murray Shanahan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Recent work in activation steering has demonstrated the potential to better
control the outputs of Large Language Models (LLMs), but it involves finding
steering vectors. This is difficult because engineers do not typically know how
features are represented in these models. We seek to address this issue by
applying the idea of mean-centring to steering vectors. We find that taking the
average of activations associated with a target dataset, and then subtracting
the mean of all training activations, results in effective steering vectors. We
test this method on a variety of models on natural language tasks by steering
away from generating toxic text, and steering the completion of a story towards
a target genre. We also apply mean-centring to extract function vectors, more
effectively triggering the execution of a range of natural language tasks by a
significant margin (compared to previous baselines). This suggests that
mean-centring can be used to easily improve the effectiveness of activation
steering in a wide range of contexts.
|
[
-0.3850944936,
-0.6636083126,
0.3680137694,
0.2296053916,
-0.5073747635,
-0.1464897543,
-0.6012887955,
-0.2643357217,
0.34418419,
0.2058609277,
-0.4952605069,
-0.340796262,
-0.9110526443,
-0.0651034787,
-0.6967257857,
0.905256331,
-0.106342569,
0.0057436526,
-0.2350254953,
-0.3470695913,
-0.4008211493,
-0.5571011901,
-0.7645103931,
-0.8717807531,
0.6367434859,
0.3090519607,
0.8405234814,
0.5555642843,
0.2797032893,
0.3284668624,
-0.2161127478,
-0.2070908248,
-0.5748882294,
0.1393904686,
0.0437991992,
-0.4534884989,
-0.3427285254,
0.312040776,
0.5416129231,
0.790273726,
-0.0602484383,
-0.2783811688,
0.2312152684,
1.0776107311,
-0.5983564258,
0.2957489491,
-0.3333432376,
-0.2121251673,
-0.1635882407,
-0.4021873176,
-0.3555878997,
-0.1287942529,
0.2821385264,
-0.6997641325,
0.0245466754,
0.1691325754,
0.5570802689,
0.1277181953,
-0.3674601018,
-0.5466831923,
-0.890194416,
1.2405877113,
-0.3941241205,
0.609980762,
0.5127248764,
0.1556837112,
-0.1676295102,
-0.2567334175,
-0.428517133,
-0.2875513434,
-0.0080282288,
0.0489078499,
-0.4178691804,
0.2334762067,
0.2169483006,
0.1138302013,
-0.3722597659,
0.2750953436,
-0.3343448043,
-0.1863761842,
0.5291064978,
-0.2470826805,
0.2260493934,
0.015257881,
-0.3294923007,
-0.1799281687,
-0.9426051974,
0.2592564225,
0.4802187085,
0.211129725,
0.0042943554,
0.6997376084,
-0.3207689822,
0.5273783803,
0.1269382685,
0.0592726395,
0.5616950989,
-0.3325528204,
-0.1797934324,
-0.009629474,
0.6081680059,
0.7954385281,
0.5390005708,
-0.2027738243,
-0.3994722962,
0.0020242189,
0.4838761389,
-0.4754347503,
-0.078295134,
0.3415687978,
-0.5106035471,
-0.4922042787,
-0.330940634,
-0.602907896,
-0.3096583486,
-0.7676190138,
0.3288897574,
-0.5284772515,
-0.5540825725,
0.0117250746,
-0.2376031131,
0.4997342229,
0.0107801361,
-1.1904886961,
0.1112285778,
0.9160043597,
0.7114074826,
-0.4514818788,
-0.150586158,
-0.8430795074,
-0.0939598233,
-0.4666380882,
0.6566271782,
-0.5232893825,
-0.3114587665,
0.1585674435,
-0.2812995017,
-0.0329521634,
-0.8114292622,
0.4553886354,
-0.5800759196,
0.0397755019,
-0.2834742367,
-0.4480664432,
-0.3031267524,
0.3998482227,
-0.599085629,
1.1902625561,
-0.0080376947,
-0.5265117884,
0.3540542126,
-0.691901803,
-0.6450579166,
-0.4038467109,
-0.2577650249,
-0.4798728228,
0.4303212762,
0.3121593297,
0.3323803842,
-0.2443710715,
0.2936219573,
0.0259280615,
-0.1895532161,
0.3096520901,
-0.1611403376,
0.690002501,
-0.074021019,
-0.3030733168,
0.5597121119,
-0.7536166906,
-0.2665998936,
-0.2395504564,
-0.2325908542,
-0.5387701988,
0.3182636201,
-0.1071915701,
0.1044390798,
-0.126200974,
-0.5864893198,
-0.1332188994,
-0.6406286359,
0.1368199736,
0.479845047,
0.0787207335,
1.2310642004,
-0.5338251591,
0.5840256214,
0.2945151329,
0.0253034662,
0.1390571892,
-0.6435174346,
-1.0911604166,
-0.4353507459,
0.0291736014,
0.3819445372,
-1.1542185545,
0.5206347108,
-0.2784895301,
-0.4850474596,
-0.2983552814,
0.3768227398,
0.2954071462,
0.6199153662,
0.6230529547,
-0.3030529618,
-0.3728273809,
-0.840595901,
-0.1975603998,
-0.4088959098,
-0.2996688187,
0.0120370192,
0.0682100281,
0.0642067418,
1.1134667397,
-0.3503800631,
-0.178417623,
-0.6256961823,
0.6888961196,
0.2269501388,
0.4957035184,
0.44444713,
-1.0018317699,
-0.3346197307,
0.0196788069,
-0.6299012303,
-0.3843093812,
-0.1155976802,
-0.3408411145,
-0.0247451123,
0.7143859863,
-0.7714216113,
0.3529785275,
0.3651507795,
0.0000745533,
0.6415719986,
-0.0425581671,
0.1276970953,
-0.6441829801,
0.064847514,
0.2742421329,
-0.1208060607,
-1.1680998802,
-0.1470192522,
0.3433602452,
0.2211930156,
-0.7480956912,
0.4055948257,
-0.4690269232,
0.2223362774,
-0.6670932174,
0.1017715335,
-0.2221165299,
0.5486529469,
-0.0417111963,
0.5937706828,
0.6128528118,
-0.8885547519,
0.3925889432,
0.0099011241,
-0.2515260279,
0.5919004083,
-0.4443500936,
-0.0471772142,
-0.4793697894,
-0.1112057418,
-0.859913528,
0.1311825365,
0.2523176074,
-0.4254586995,
0.4520130157,
-0.2169760317,
-0.240275383,
-0.3666807711,
-0.4491922855,
0.1808031797,
0.7076711059,
-0.411676079,
0.9180807471,
0.3079832494,
-0.3045025766,
-0.4548627734,
-0.5147072077,
-0.1687454134,
-0.6252717376,
-0.5166909695,
0.5114996433,
0.1757184565,
-0.2727695405,
-0.23418127,
-0.0753354728,
0.0457319841,
0.2416186035,
0.2059098631,
0.1767143011,
-0.0427944325,
0.2041522712,
0.2186994851,
-0.7268890142,
0.2236320823,
-0.1586706787,
0.462716639,
0.3665742874,
-0.330491364,
-0.0583175309,
0.3890943527,
0.6990734339,
-0.6030620933,
0.718890667,
0.3715662658,
-0.3367914557,
-0.1859536767,
-0.4028629363,
-0.3591910899,
-0.5075848103,
0.6359868646,
-0.0690861568,
-0.6973884702,
0.4536642432,
-0.0517400168,
0.2349105477,
0.1538306028,
0.8367167711,
-0.1398120672,
1.0691821575,
0.9793932438,
-0.3810387254,
0.8351832032,
-0.1883382052,
0.3489266038,
-0.802585125,
-0.0064857402,
-0.482080698,
-0.5871931911,
-0.318122983,
-0.6308328509,
0.4139803052,
0.2106892318,
0.1362491548,
0.3896858096,
-0.1950798631,
0.4234771132,
0.5567150116,
0.1052826867,
0.3227344155,
0.1270860285,
-0.2957852781,
0.0241993777,
-0.5040044188,
-0.4120275378,
1.0306220055,
0.5279454589,
0.8547208309,
-0.0230463501,
0.7056806087,
-0.1386616379,
0.9000433683,
-1.0567469597,
0.5034660697,
-0.0498659052,
-0.5992158055,
-0.4816440046,
-0.256488353,
-0.7897122502,
0.2234571129,
-0.298411727,
-0.5297019482,
0.0967136919,
0.1638244987,
-0.1373380423,
-0.011153318,
-0.7028259039,
0.6932781339,
-0.127021119,
-0.0972493216,
-0.4468221068,
-0.4220824838,
-0.0302990954,
-0.0556154102,
0.297634095,
-0.2614564598,
-0.0622120649,
0.8570485115,
-0.1160680428,
0.8696747422,
-0.3304011226,
-0.0362637937,
0.6168962121,
-0.0702965781,
0.6582381725,
-0.5797964334,
-0.3038506806,
-0.1539832354,
-0.7390942574,
-0.1905884147,
-0.7767145634,
0.5723201036,
-0.4797520936,
-0.4493042827,
-0.0457646325,
-0.7143930197,
-0.2062661201,
0.0242794827,
0.2437603623,
0.5132082105,
-0.232797429,
0.3217826784,
0.5546544194,
0.0304497257,
0.8093745708,
0.3343110085,
-0.2824319303,
-0.20166789,
0.9740794897,
0.1783623993,
0.4670228958,
0.3682135344,
0.1679188907,
-0.5525978208,
-0.924215734,
-0.4371784925,
0.0863202214,
-0.7639494538,
-0.1847237349,
-0.6076245308,
-0.1982963979,
0.0043074572,
-0.25080809,
-0.4503074884,
-0.51869452,
-0.3978903294,
-0.3392078876,
0.2163360864,
0.5757384896,
0.2408557385,
0.509711504,
-0.6979806423,
0.0161137283,
0.1616640985,
0.2019781768,
0.1769075841,
-0.4145404994,
-0.406059891,
-0.0567243099,
-0.6540490985,
-1.0035502911,
0.547185421,
0.2393383235,
0.800809145,
0.3460840583,
0.0315740258,
0.2087790817,
-0.5886896253,
0.6148470044,
0.4848990142,
-0.7136904597,
0.2595549524,
-0.383589536,
0.3812440336,
0.4071579278,
0.8380068541,
-0.5283460617,
-0.9092966318,
-0.2653183639,
-0.864348352,
0.1646377742,
0.3740454018,
0.205150798,
-0.2050746083,
0.1816751957,
-0.0572882779,
0.12494912,
-0.9098520875,
-0.3627561033,
0.0608531684,
-0.5932247639,
-0.274874568,
-0.2764829099,
0.0104320152,
-0.1190082803,
0.8007193208,
-0.1700336188,
0.176936537,
0.0123422286,
-0.3195851743,
-0.3770327866,
0.3732070625,
0.3519482911,
0.6677740812,
0.2009235322,
0.3726893067,
0.0581439361,
-0.4261703789,
0.340541929,
0.0823705196,
-0.2982527316,
-0.0494778641,
0.293122232,
0.4590995908,
0.4692163169,
-0.3657012582,
0.6162754297,
0.3761184812,
-0.2185172141,
0.1577156335,
0.1690901667,
0.2196841091,
0.1754393578,
0.5714939237,
-0.0364996679,
0.1337172538,
-0.0856839046,
0.3054996729,
0.4610456228,
-0.8160037994,
-0.3201018572,
0.3270714879,
0.5663001537,
-0.2204564661,
0.6723612547,
-0.1864742339,
-0.8336142302,
0.6876683831,
0.4719389379,
1.138992548,
0.0171227325,
-0.0624441728,
0.4197586179,
0.4288896024,
-0.0663680509,
0.175727874,
0.2065223306,
-0.7753354311,
-0.9520328045,
-0.6201334596,
-0.2674464881,
-0.2549086511,
-0.5543465614,
0.5577517152,
-0.1376087219,
-0.1991672367,
0.0196249317,
-0.4909313917,
-0.320518434,
0.0073161502,
0.3207918108,
1.0204384327,
-1.2218643427,
0.8530231118,
0.8029075265,
-0.227896437,
-0.4828534424,
-0.1882962137,
0.2403336167,
-0.4253283739,
0.6464057565,
0.4840758443,
0.0839217305,
0.0959872454,
-0.4815339446,
-0.7148233056,
0.9833184481,
-0.1291537881,
-0.4912294447,
0.1517008245,
0.3044174016,
0.5633164048,
-0.6640471816,
0.2065195739,
0.6978619099,
0.1916368902,
0.1553184539,
-0.8568845391,
-0.1273072511,
-0.1089135706,
-0.2163171768,
0.4203894138,
-0.1268526763,
0.5035895109,
0.1432460546,
-0.0568832196,
-0.1377232671,
1.1229815483,
0.2060105354,
0.2240597308,
0.8930426836,
0.4931266904,
0.5853517652,
-0.111461319,
0.9061527252,
-0.2820542157,
0.1383218467,
0.877815485,
-0.0000254954,
0.9654210806,
0.7785884142,
-0.0319738463,
0.4292943478,
0.2083706707,
0.5455825925,
0.6510491371,
0.2276337296,
-0.5085083246,
-0.3179827332,
0.0744146258,
0.0681862235,
0.3191841841,
0.2834744751,
-0.327162534,
-0.3860962093,
0.4596109986,
-0.0212707352,
0.0800921991,
-0.2970017493,
0.7782459855,
0.209227711,
-0.9187281728,
0.3783668578,
0.078739807,
0.7079951167,
-0.5370767117,
0.0176761821,
-0.1526010931,
0.0239775628,
0.1270167232,
-0.7986133099,
0.4970597923,
0.0413343348,
-0.4062774479,
-0.619505167,
0.9018000364,
-0.7321628928,
-0.3355738521,
0.3915383518,
0.576374352,
-0.0973607674,
-0.3591084778,
-0.5715532899,
0.1306257844,
0.0614066757,
-0.4179445505,
0.2483223379,
0.2857801616,
-0.0998615921,
0.8178893924,
0.682924211,
0.0211345479,
0.3104688227,
0.0891644061,
1.2109487057,
-0.6290253997,
-0.5156965852,
-0.9503744841,
0.8090400696,
0.0107600354,
-0.1160646901,
0.5891345739,
0.5611165762,
0.4921927452,
0.0814474523,
0.5559934974,
-0.1750317067,
0.5461704135,
-0.5354944468,
0.7382941246,
-0.2387653291,
0.2613093853,
0.1585920453,
-1.1801810265,
-0.3540994525,
0.5188368559,
-0.5886297226,
-0.0950782448,
0.6643128395,
1.0466557741,
-0.1776805669,
0.0421775505,
0.2389793247,
0.2280829698,
0.7218573689,
0.3446212709,
0.8685120344,
-0.1435415596,
0.4278901517,
-0.540984571,
-0.7124655843,
-0.003790187,
-1.2912435532,
-1.114667058,
-0.2415325046,
-0.3868328631,
-0.2565922439,
-0.2004798949,
1.154178977,
0.8026748896,
-0.9400911331,
-0.3622857928,
-0.1079144925,
0.2313691229,
-0.3513442874,
-0.0769123435,
0.081159547,
-0.7854691148,
-0.7633215189,
0.3725387454,
0.3196991682,
0.0689777806,
-0.3146039844,
-0.2598823905,
-0.3779915869,
-0.1186196879,
0.6608496904,
0.1735317111,
-0.3350065351,
-0.341710031,
0.0321234949,
-0.1214730814,
0.2007758617,
1.0276859999,
-0.6565392017,
0.5111026168,
0.5688397884,
0.5240745544,
0.3569877744,
-0.0171669219,
0.9308692217,
-0.913418293,
0.3603537083,
0.154283002,
0.1240238845,
0.3583110869,
0.0297273304,
0.3949017823,
0.1577928513,
-0.3523635566,
-0.3276278973,
0.0654450655,
-0.8243889809,
0.2122848034,
1.2043384314,
0.1276337653,
-0.4618251622,
-0.3576765954,
-0.134298712,
0.3181141019,
-0.178947106,
0.3907223642,
0.995701313,
-0.2692318857,
-0.0575959012,
-0.5670866966,
0.6453583837,
0.7728917599,
-0.5516341329,
0.3933212459,
0.33509323,
0.1588076055,
0.3355842829,
0.5105714798,
-0.2571545243,
0.2533407509,
-0.4317055941,
0.0525607802,
0.1127031595,
-0.5234131813,
-0.3786065578,
-0.155585438,
0.2515026629,
-0.0999098346
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03656v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03656v2
|
Interpretability Illusions in the Generalization of Simplified Models
| 2023-12-06T18:25:53 | 2024-06-05T15:03:37 |
Dan Friedman, Andrew Lampinen, Lucas Dixon, Danqi Chen, Asma Ghandeharioun
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
A common method to study deep learning systems is to use simplified model
representations--for example, using singular value decomposition to visualize
the model's hidden states in a lower dimensional space. This approach assumes
that the results of these simplifications are faithful to the original model.
Here, we illustrate an important caveat to this assumption: even if the
simplified representations can accurately approximate the full model on the
training set, they may fail to accurately capture the model's behavior out of
distribution. We illustrate this by training Transformer models on controlled
datasets with systematic generalization splits, including the Dyck
balanced-parenthesis languages and a code completion task. We simplify these
models using tools like dimensionality reduction and clustering, and then
explicitly test how these simplified proxies match the behavior of the original
model. We find consistent generalization gaps: cases in which the simplified
proxies are more faithful to the original model on the in-distribution
evaluations and less faithful on various tests of systematic generalization.
This includes cases where the original model generalizes systematically but the
simplified proxies fail, and cases where the simplified proxies generalize
better. Together, our results raise questions about the extent to which
mechanistic interpretations derived using tools like SVD can reliably predict
what a model will do in novel situations.
|
[
-0.1351346523,
-0.4361809492,
0.6376673579,
0.0814128593,
-0.4422662556,
-0.0814954937,
0.0041171694,
-0.1739723533,
0.0172917005,
0.3560295999,
-0.7846418619,
-0.3192626834,
-0.6131999493,
0.0333390869,
-0.6295557022,
0.8267499208,
-0.2119284719,
0.3008609116,
-0.2720901668,
-0.0431911126,
-0.3934556246,
-0.4750927389,
-0.2845423818,
-0.5274869204,
0.2981541455,
-0.00808095,
1.015304327,
0.6259894371,
0.7296396494,
0.2375077307,
-0.3138834238,
-0.1705955118,
-0.4452015758,
-0.0040264949,
-0.0261215866,
-1.0126644373,
-0.2232521921,
0.086621806,
0.5853201151,
1.2044196129,
-0.1726582348,
-0.1332209259,
0.2679242194,
0.4736450613,
-0.6511664391,
0.2937888205,
-0.3414486647,
0.2843724191,
0.2630791366,
0.1211795732,
-0.5524530411,
-0.1947916895,
0.3185406327,
-0.8072710037,
0.6924268007,
-0.2759787142,
0.9051680565,
0.6269723773,
-0.4771391153,
-0.3195764422,
-1.193557024,
0.8605146408,
-0.6788159013,
0.3309015334,
0.0184998587,
0.9434183836,
-0.1612913311,
-1.0897985697,
-0.5531659126,
-0.2780694366,
-0.5461815596,
0.1170133501,
-0.3827135265,
0.395296514,
0.6802678704,
0.5571715236,
-0.3768569827,
-0.0147770848,
-0.5418226719,
-0.0666580722,
0.5281117558,
0.2528443336,
0.1932325959,
-0.2482709438,
-0.2938918769,
-0.4488675296,
-0.6799090505,
0.4005223513,
0.4493160844,
0.1706209481,
-0.030415846,
0.4400120676,
-0.0000984811,
0.3612217605,
0.121196948,
0.1372967064,
0.1003288403,
-0.2066500783,
-0.6383043528,
-0.4496939778,
0.4196189046,
0.4289798141,
0.3880724013,
-0.1977137029,
-0.2219345421,
0.2314815819,
0.6034733653,
-0.5883688331,
-0.3963285089,
0.1545026004,
-0.737006247,
-0.479594022,
0.285992682,
-0.4180180728,
-0.1190944463,
-0.4624761343,
0.3868941665,
-0.1825133413,
-0.2078183293,
0.3126067519,
-0.3368630409,
0.3197131157,
0.3821473122,
-0.7249000669,
0.4454633296,
0.6716673374,
0.5123168826,
-0.1951041371,
-0.2430295199,
-0.0028671352,
0.051463183,
-0.5292320848,
0.3464317918,
-0.4710761905,
-0.2508346736,
-0.1917181611,
0.1468527019,
-0.1969069391,
-0.7094131112,
0.6489866972,
-0.3860757947,
-0.1938554049,
-0.216021955,
-0.582690239,
-0.27113989,
-0.01249569,
-0.9083068967,
0.4861690104,
-0.0651475862,
-0.6550763845,
0.6617819667,
-0.3479124606,
-0.105565764,
-0.3725138903,
-0.2375717908,
-0.3481766582,
0.6356375813,
0.2038910836,
0.4964964688,
0.1080206484,
0.303337127,
-0.4107570946,
-0.612937212,
0.1391488016,
-0.7729399204,
0.6808911562,
0.2800699472,
-0.3655555546,
-0.0273887869,
-0.5352784991,
-0.1621461064,
0.0826839283,
-0.158532992,
-0.4361232221,
0.2393013686,
-0.2049917877,
-0.1365286708,
-0.0188567042,
-0.2874523997,
0.5134614706,
-0.4640945792,
0.2025823295,
0.7387661338,
-0.0707048774,
0.792858243,
0.0788727626,
0.639703095,
0.2839565873,
0.5916479826,
-0.2249845862,
-0.2532362938,
-1.0137084723,
-0.0630660951,
0.4497337937,
0.2460036427,
-0.8446947932,
0.2007713467,
-0.4513716996,
-0.3498272002,
-0.6152305007,
-0.113981545,
0.195295155,
0.2175703645,
0.296570152,
0.1290168911,
-0.4403266311,
-1.2914372683,
-0.5259287953,
0.0415248461,
-0.3901638985,
0.1505505741,
0.5576018691,
-0.4239245951,
0.8911598325,
-0.5977485776,
0.015549819,
-0.236604467,
0.0150027974,
0.4285172224,
0.5916717052,
0.622617662,
-1.1242209673,
-0.3838522136,
-0.0573428757,
-0.9890729785,
0.347345978,
-0.2295645177,
0.2618224323,
-0.3298317492,
0.4973300993,
-0.5066441894,
0.8674482107,
0.3619575202,
-0.0638556927,
0.4155618846,
-0.2175440788,
-0.1914126426,
-0.8924558163,
-0.058995001,
-0.0448220596,
-0.1378210634,
-0.8368235826,
0.2924367189,
0.0705051422,
0.0423541702,
-0.2540390491,
0.0575837605,
-0.2962007821,
-0.0534748957,
-0.1188252196,
-0.3789642155,
0.0607791282,
0.3150021136,
-0.2616662383,
0.5390923619,
0.7345917225,
-0.6594824791,
0.2593844533,
-0.0030531716,
-0.1969742626,
0.2793082297,
-1.1076630354,
-0.1831027865,
-0.5525185466,
0.4275561869,
-0.9034719467,
-0.4411903918,
0.1312924773,
-0.2323999703,
0.4114765823,
-0.3190079927,
-0.2493575215,
-0.3673202991,
-0.139098078,
0.467083782,
0.6826657057,
-0.7248317003,
0.9965700507,
-0.2411525995,
0.2896706462,
-0.9063973427,
-0.8660954237,
-0.2978562117,
-0.2773883641,
-0.5093178153,
0.0861873478,
-0.071687445,
-0.4504285455,
0.0511498302,
-0.3760118186,
-0.1111965925,
0.3017305136,
0.4164377451,
0.1702556759,
-0.1324326247,
0.0965636894,
0.4289571643,
-0.1683745533,
0.2138098031,
0.0877647847,
0.2377567738,
-0.1227453426,
-0.7977697849,
-0.4984110594,
0.3285204768,
0.5302211046,
0.3825177252,
0.4621652663,
0.2813565135,
-0.4019726217,
-0.3640168905,
-0.3372359574,
-0.3318664134,
-0.5166870952,
0.0531583875,
-0.709762454,
-0.4626874924,
0.6110098362,
-0.168296814,
0.0293789655,
0.6753499508,
-0.1082401872,
-0.4993394315,
1.3377379179,
0.8241169453,
0.2737657726,
0.1994735748,
-0.6895666122,
0.2009691,
-0.5546008945,
-0.3756682277,
-0.3517425656,
-0.4877244234,
-0.6602452397,
-0.2555573583,
0.2520084977,
0.3843143284,
-0.0068801334,
0.2563020289,
-0.4059554935,
0.6128830314,
0.4201692939,
0.1006070524,
0.2633984387,
0.1814322919,
-0.1086201146,
-0.3322619498,
-0.6567716599,
-0.4986563027,
1.082280159,
0.5605387688,
1.1258064508,
-0.0394135676,
0.6020632386,
0.2069307715,
0.3649648428,
-0.9799467325,
0.0760109052,
-0.3006775379,
-0.3579285741,
-0.081169866,
-0.5483310819,
-1.032143712,
0.3882959485,
0.0810097009,
-0.2635745704,
0.7547715306,
0.2229736,
-0.1444939077,
0.2778455913,
-0.900005579,
0.7513124943,
0.1899418086,
0.391285032,
-0.1722388864,
-0.5513695478,
0.4909388423,
0.0154238362,
0.0691199899,
0.3338287473,
0.2458312511,
0.4214637578,
-0.491869539,
1.0803806782,
-0.4161895812,
0.1164112687,
0.122820735,
0.1122641563,
0.6033688188,
-0.2053161561,
0.1153907403,
0.137202099,
0.0419477746,
-0.5803873539,
-1.2097491026,
0.3520884812,
-0.8417055607,
-0.7806314826,
-0.1393373609,
-0.4887735546,
0.1525786519,
0.0512785017,
0.5084043145,
0.3257847726,
-0.2016858459,
0.3233191371,
0.6493932605,
0.0507615767,
0.250751853,
0.0032221698,
-0.131938234,
-0.0649830848,
0.44563061,
0.1869843453,
0.4431527853,
0.102671504,
0.1012240127,
-0.2348846495,
-0.598867774,
-0.2017870396,
0.0796647221,
-1.1056492329,
0.140197143,
-0.3950356543,
-0.1511277556,
-0.2522788048,
-0.1238017157,
-0.1975303292,
-0.4470555782,
-0.3038161397,
-0.351313144,
-0.3062573373,
1.2308912277,
0.0231685415,
0.5089076757,
-0.4372678995,
0.2651051879,
0.6058440208,
0.1826731116,
0.0214418042,
-0.4957959652,
-0.0708750188,
0.2651877999,
-0.1133293137,
-0.7310990095,
0.0512868576,
0.0793294907,
0.8312591314,
0.6609594226,
0.0141268307,
0.6557978988,
-0.4013146758,
0.7578958273,
0.1928814203,
-1.0112071037,
0.5958238244,
-0.1214601099,
-0.1454884857,
0.3224264085,
0.4314237535,
-0.2447593808,
-0.3225221336,
-0.9391252398,
-0.5511998534,
0.4408961833,
0.3233112693,
0.4483032227,
0.3032738268,
0.7813975215,
0.3178056777,
0.1401340961,
-0.7173774838,
-0.6456164122,
-0.4540606141,
-0.1536282897,
-0.1761947721,
-0.4462949634,
-0.139594838,
-0.1978517026,
0.1534591317,
-0.201082781,
0.157748431,
0.0027490866,
-0.0665179566,
0.0077393414,
0.1149289608,
0.4948726296,
0.7318604589,
-0.1740094572,
0.3655779064,
0.1602873206,
-0.4303258955,
0.2067919225,
-0.2078028172,
-0.3389789164,
0.3450045288,
0.6306348443,
0.9963757992,
0.0402571745,
-0.2993440926,
0.6515206099,
-0.1954644024,
-0.2201562673,
-0.3267914653,
0.3064347208,
-0.0919825509,
0.3814943135,
0.4899888337,
0.5234293938,
0.4806291461,
-0.4621164501,
0.0602262653,
0.3659544289,
-0.5019586086,
-0.5292313695,
0.5698093176,
-0.2287759334,
-0.0762574002,
0.6174637675,
0.0698240846,
-0.3894987404,
0.8872243762,
0.2122016996,
0.9747809172,
-0.2524350882,
0.2587857842,
0.1990920007,
0.5812781453,
-0.3065258861,
-0.032121677,
0.0417602323,
-0.6658091545,
-0.6248509288,
-0.3764184117,
-0.4797637463,
0.0599287599,
-1.2482428551,
0.1297010183,
-0.228687644,
-0.0559745878,
0.0500919446,
-0.456391722,
-0.8255928159,
0.3079321384,
-0.1945931613,
0.9907910824,
-1.4491788149,
0.6891443133,
0.4921076298,
-0.4445816278,
-1.0518012047,
0.1631276011,
-0.3779064119,
-0.6334112883,
0.7642704248,
0.0654451996,
0.1625026166,
-0.4549832046,
-0.8793345094,
-0.7753056288,
1.2427604198,
0.7109261751,
-0.4305772185,
-0.2811734378,
0.3643579185,
0.7717391849,
-0.2515904903,
0.1233879775,
0.7366507649,
0.4769316018,
0.2838868797,
-0.8696369529,
0.0596031323,
-0.0954238847,
0.2516045868,
-0.111214377,
-0.2594517767,
1.1418753862,
-0.1892154366,
-0.343257755,
-0.1766802371,
0.5497447848,
-0.073059231,
0.3617323935,
0.6005732417,
0.5128944516,
0.7179399729,
-0.2065912038,
1.3796725273,
0.3306853771,
0.6877227426,
0.8301110864,
0.2953502536,
0.5213943124,
0.5830361247,
-0.2625217438,
0.4392323196,
0.4941492379,
-0.2313058376,
0.7265396118,
0.1590580344,
0.1201539189,
-0.4631677866,
0.1815186143,
-0.3272311985,
0.2625538707,
0.2864798605,
-0.4699895382,
-0.4018492699,
0.1211791337,
-0.3069805503,
-0.0892447755,
-0.2905250192,
0.5826442838,
0.2681097686,
-0.3796963692,
0.6396640539,
-0.3327613771,
0.4883671403,
-0.3627995551,
-0.325799942,
-0.3769878149,
0.319811523,
-0.3367797732,
-0.6399558187,
0.573628664,
-0.3884066939,
-0.4429346919,
-0.1722330749,
0.6989529133,
-0.0874985904,
-0.6098092198,
0.2301962674,
0.3724171817,
0.3239769042,
-0.1825312823,
-0.5983105898,
0.008460205,
0.2278793603,
-0.2094107121,
0.0755476877,
0.3255071938,
0.0120868636,
0.966679275,
0.4635157585,
-0.0276297349,
0.2057016641,
0.1202427745,
1.048004508,
-0.2984421551,
-0.2997526526,
-0.7694867253,
0.6549764276,
-0.0840333104,
0.1179393828,
0.7023219466,
0.3278824091,
0.9116182923,
-0.4172561765,
0.8822705746,
0.4847646654,
0.2602125704,
-0.4958264828,
0.5144261122,
-0.5789360404,
0.2972327769,
-0.1046092659,
-0.9966279864,
-0.3272058964,
0.6204242706,
-0.3270195723,
0.0409954675,
0.6246476173,
0.4074685574,
-0.4839672446,
-0.0833199546,
0.5640413761,
0.2453247607,
0.4300929308,
0.2296142578,
1.0772815943,
-0.6655166745,
0.5960895419,
-0.382682234,
-0.0436271131,
-0.2138055563,
-0.5522802472,
-0.8888028264,
-0.2802003026,
-0.1377283186,
-0.2208746821,
-0.3561060727,
0.3724366128,
0.5652938485,
-0.8929053545,
0.0939998552,
-0.1984004229,
0.2760333419,
-0.4360188246,
-0.2395158261,
0.4407787025,
-0.2509818077,
-0.9195914268,
0.3146499693,
-0.1111657321,
0.5110091567,
-0.4907183647,
-0.0222700145,
0.7266414165,
0.0528095365,
0.289832294,
-0.0818664208,
-0.8729079962,
-0.3853948116,
0.1795675159,
0.0430755056,
-0.0619576313,
0.8817850947,
-0.6305590868,
0.5667227507,
0.4788082838,
0.359159708,
0.6150594354,
-0.0106614763,
0.7007116079,
-0.7095974088,
0.0334887877,
0.1800571978,
0.4149069786,
0.1554092467,
-0.360963136,
0.5438588858,
0.1882670075,
-0.1914653033,
-0.8872661591,
0.4436590075,
-0.8617855906,
-0.3468333781,
0.9240424037,
-0.5252248645,
-0.1779653728,
-0.0918598473,
0.1328682452,
0.1276350319,
0.0298280679,
0.663154006,
0.5687811375,
-0.0369617082,
0.1093947291,
-0.6426810622,
0.6098339558,
0.3104399443,
-0.3333423734,
-0.0535591654,
0.2674764395,
0.5620083213,
0.4258727431,
0.0167721547,
0.2595738471,
0.1990632564,
0.2109085023,
-0.0612831116,
-0.0237115435,
-0.3149386346,
-0.7350545526,
0.126166597,
-0.0972075686,
-0.140583232
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03633v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03633v3
|
Exploring the Reversal Curse and Other Deductive Logical Reasoning in BERT and GPT-Based Large Language Models
| 2023-12-06T17:29:45 | 2024-07-01T18:13:24 |
Da Wu, Jingye Yang, Kai Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
The term "Reversal Curse" refers to the scenario where auto-regressive
decoder large language models (LLMs), such as ChatGPT, trained on "A is B" fail
to learn "B is A," assuming that B and A are distinct and can be uniquely
identified from each other, demonstrating a basic failure of logical deduction.
This raises a red flag in the use of GPT models for certain general tasks such
as constructing knowledge graphs, considering their adherence to this symmetric
principle. In our study, we examined a bidirectional LLM, BERT, and found that
it is immune to the reversal curse. Driven by ongoing efforts to construct
biomedical knowledge graphs with LLMs, we also embarked on evaluating more
complex but essential deductive reasoning capabilities. This process included
first training encoder and decoder language models to master the intersection
and union operations on two sets and then moving on to assess their capability
to infer different combinations of union and intersection operations on three
newly created sets. The findings showed that while both encoder and decoder
language models, trained for tasks involving two sets (union/intersection),
were proficient in such scenarios, they encountered difficulties when dealing
with operations that included three sets (various combinations of union and
intersection). Our research highlights the distinct characteristics of encoder
and decoder models in simple and complex logical reasoning. In practice, the
choice between BERT and GPT should be guided by the specific requirements and
nature of the task at hand, leveraging their respective strengths in
bidirectional context comprehension and sequence prediction.
|
[
-0.1053320989,
-0.9625748992,
0.6558275223,
0.176570788,
-0.3453133404,
0.1347798556,
0.0369505286,
-0.5737550855,
0.2315280288,
0.7028754354,
-0.404931277,
-0.1021230817,
-0.8730733991,
0.3189802766,
-0.5821956396,
1.2308735847,
0.1544342935,
0.3225252032,
-0.1794621199,
0.211309731,
-0.6287679672,
-0.6223013997,
-0.8411108255,
-0.5487516522,
0.3773330748,
0.052815102,
0.9019904733,
0.2709162235,
0.5654119849,
0.1932215095,
0.0800432935,
0.0588624738,
-0.6049919128,
0.1238648295,
-0.3781178892,
-0.3767617345,
-0.2596310675,
-0.1050907746,
0.3963209987,
0.9724008441,
-0.0121910013,
-0.2257054001,
0.1739887148,
0.6579828262,
-0.274666667,
0.1639958024,
-1.0238730907,
-0.1515017301,
-0.0072903628,
-0.0468792506,
-0.3199071288,
-0.6369394064,
0.2199255675,
-0.2480065823,
0.1382197738,
-0.1786363125,
0.8294243813,
0.3415369093,
-0.5340096354,
-0.2929052413,
-0.8201738596,
0.6967017651,
-0.6930594444,
0.4052666426,
0.3170389235,
0.2695788145,
-0.3933030367,
-0.5685580969,
-0.7971419692,
-0.0514039174,
-0.1368893236,
0.3219147921,
-0.3061850369,
0.1318820119,
0.1815789491,
0.0179297607,
-0.6040228009,
0.2842108607,
-0.4594823718,
-0.1130244806,
0.3043507934,
0.0315388255,
0.2527822852,
-0.2808781564,
-0.6742626429,
0.2129830718,
-1.0765275955,
-0.2024199218,
0.3454439938,
0.1836272627,
0.1212165356,
0.4734752178,
0.2198757976,
0.871176362,
-0.1202410236,
-0.1064514667,
0.0316966213,
-0.1733448952,
-0.3426257372,
0.1783305109,
0.4457984567,
0.1652644873,
0.4719956219,
-0.2784079015,
-0.2797976434,
0.1348041296,
0.2636242807,
-0.5477097034,
-0.4610735476,
-0.0038919596,
-0.4525029063,
-0.1250738502,
-0.2046214342,
-0.3759135306,
-0.6718127728,
-0.5392007828,
0.682982862,
-0.6471469998,
-0.2900361717,
0.462063849,
-0.3461506367,
0.4544341862,
0.2653952241,
-0.6595008373,
0.1169892326,
0.8454302549,
0.4207336605,
0.0208422914,
-0.2763541937,
-0.2573270202,
0.1061385497,
-0.0607016981,
0.6341402531,
-0.5895534754,
-0.2307561189,
-0.1677584946,
-0.0174604636,
-0.4266321659,
-0.2918875813,
0.5414460897,
-0.6154339314,
0.0883955732,
-0.4753083885,
-0.4088269174,
-0.4681797028,
0.3137377799,
-0.4120944738,
0.3714940548,
-0.0428251624,
-0.9011616707,
0.4414749444,
-0.0821536332,
-0.8902496099,
-0.0337720402,
-0.3355554342,
-0.2902145386,
0.0435552336,
0.1312270761,
0.2311284244,
-0.5291990042,
0.3754750192,
-0.3784453273,
-0.2912282646,
0.2508535683,
-0.6974048018,
1.2412805557,
0.0628792197,
-0.4750588536,
-0.3238623142,
-0.6676853299,
-0.2606363595,
0.2180383652,
-0.2809979916,
-0.6205948591,
0.2172545046,
-0.4891748726,
0.2133544832,
0.2298586369,
-0.6032625437,
0.294999361,
-0.3755567372,
0.4898746312,
0.7794341445,
-0.1403678507,
-0.1046863124,
-0.1416178644,
0.2454678714,
0.1717698574,
0.1556401998,
0.3171359003,
-0.819347024,
-0.7159759402,
-0.268453002,
0.1509860456,
0.8411296606,
-1.0209265947,
0.4494577944,
-0.2601892948,
-0.181644246,
-0.6377505064,
-0.0282377955,
0.6040428281,
0.8002977967,
0.5042537451,
-0.3389656544,
-0.639749825,
-1.2053287029,
-0.274823159,
-0.3194949329,
0.1905122697,
0.2204186767,
0.6131035686,
-0.3127484024,
0.9643142223,
-0.4017025232,
-0.1195100695,
-0.3857006133,
0.2303382456,
0.550781846,
0.4434758723,
0.362619549,
-0.8541067243,
-0.0656442344,
-0.2349609882,
-0.7621576786,
-0.2117139995,
-0.2477139682,
-0.0333524048,
0.5155457854,
0.2218059003,
-0.6660325527,
0.5635867715,
0.5124353766,
-0.5554122329,
0.9249118567,
-0.1689039916,
0.0649169311,
-0.6793388724,
0.105197899,
-0.5937026143,
-0.0610451289,
-0.672241807,
-0.1400641054,
-0.1660286486,
0.3411232233,
0.0354535878,
0.2494242638,
-0.3497312367,
-0.2493961602,
-0.147870779,
0.0745222941,
0.1040540561,
0.2274876386,
0.2105734795,
0.4518823326,
0.6165007949,
-0.5980547667,
0.2675634027,
0.2979754508,
-0.2748912573,
0.541911006,
-0.7076877952,
0.1163796112,
-0.2163743377,
0.1237097979,
-1.2306779623,
0.1905338615,
0.1761084497,
-0.4921756387,
0.2699224353,
-0.2141917199,
-0.6173114181,
-0.8106693029,
0.0947564095,
0.2825015783,
0.714060843,
-0.7132131457,
0.4550051391,
0.1184225455,
-0.1367269009,
-0.8685484529,
-0.9235126972,
0.1591757387,
-0.0635890588,
-0.6882290244,
0.0839628503,
0.1656544954,
-0.3133232594,
-0.0232700389,
-0.1482585669,
0.0185362063,
0.1492134035,
0.1170442253,
0.4002563357,
0.0173484981,
0.2362223119,
0.1919985116,
-0.0119596338,
0.1524879783,
-0.5385890603,
0.5768149495,
-0.1770002097,
-0.5938548446,
0.1917193234,
0.1167266369,
0.507332325,
-0.1100397483,
0.799546957,
0.5637577772,
-0.3711884916,
0.1708321422,
-0.8364331126,
-0.346126616,
-0.3659660518,
0.1933239549,
-0.3597653508,
-0.6966432929,
0.7573865056,
0.3412829638,
-0.0542508736,
0.2829123139,
0.5875896215,
-0.0029704254,
1.0210461617,
0.2065995932,
-0.1202550083,
-0.0678994879,
-0.1715334058,
0.5921472311,
-0.6489744782,
-0.00452221,
-0.3424009681,
-0.3023448288,
-0.4688001573,
-0.211739853,
0.5570001602,
0.41320315,
-0.4066577852,
0.3195702136,
-0.4827193022,
0.430372715,
0.7280876637,
0.2477760911,
0.5710115433,
-0.2006722987,
-0.196517095,
0.2103069574,
-0.6027145386,
-0.3112897277,
1.0525788069,
0.1289193481,
0.7666872144,
0.2099146247,
0.8538915515,
0.0059338952,
0.0888872296,
-0.53540802,
0.6711065173,
-0.3495273292,
-0.6980799437,
-0.2308129668,
-0.5588858724,
-1.2151335478,
0.3385896385,
-0.0867836028,
-0.6722189188,
0.2754971087,
0.1721576899,
-0.267160207,
0.5377553105,
-0.8043132424,
0.8151110411,
-0.3844660819,
-0.2809125185,
-0.4340031445,
-0.9086828232,
0.6557207108,
0.0225340109,
0.2180029005,
0.2001031339,
0.4571065605,
0.4336467087,
-0.2863762975,
1.1328299046,
-0.269287914,
-0.2974178791,
0.3572942615,
0.5439742208,
0.6026709676,
0.0677931234,
0.1772706509,
0.0489474721,
0.013151696,
-0.233511582,
-0.3570852578,
0.7219341993,
-0.7219763994,
-0.9848381281,
-0.3203772306,
-0.5198942423,
-0.2458857894,
0.3627776802,
0.1899645329,
0.4384394288,
0.0189958513,
-0.1886613667,
0.6341212988,
-0.4496805668,
0.1572001874,
0.6184117794,
-0.1801925153,
-0.2316553593,
0.8777779937,
0.0509709865,
0.5116899014,
0.2701655924,
0.1832811087,
-0.1385690272,
-0.6239907146,
-0.2325715125,
0.411100328,
-0.7300437093,
-0.3841475248,
-0.5632902384,
-0.3291201591,
-0.5397015214,
-0.1428050399,
-0.1412506253,
-0.7217283249,
-0.0483188182,
-0.0965041444,
0.3252416551,
0.5830347538,
-0.3311186433,
-0.1510100961,
-0.7149856091,
0.405728519,
0.6173098087,
0.3517789841,
-0.0094708279,
-0.4622333348,
0.1877169013,
0.1677848697,
-0.1866182685,
-0.9068585634,
0.2540142536,
-0.1311549097,
0.4961079359,
0.4982981682,
-0.0625054762,
0.4055263102,
-0.4847530723,
0.5729926229,
0.2194071114,
-0.7154909372,
0.3016037047,
-0.4420775473,
-0.0191087704,
0.2412439585,
0.3690940142,
-0.5045186281,
-0.6227681041,
-0.5586095452,
-0.688757956,
0.3694597185,
0.1670122594,
-0.1016561836,
-0.3817921281,
0.1022951901,
0.5455514193,
0.1917056292,
-0.7953929305,
-0.0245509986,
-0.289131552,
0.0585615933,
0.1278027296,
-0.2326190174,
-0.3008598089,
-0.4384423792,
0.5744634867,
0.1479025483,
0.4477645755,
0.2602244616,
-0.3852925301,
0.2059596479,
0.3263531029,
0.4217934012,
0.6704771519,
-0.307682395,
0.4027950764,
-0.0696270913,
-0.4202000201,
-0.2663077712,
0.4811409712,
-0.2369172424,
-0.295042038,
0.5328654051,
0.8296352029,
0.0602946132,
-0.4557632506,
0.4494313002,
0.4012819231,
-0.1833532155,
-0.3329752982,
-0.2653782666,
0.1022026539,
0.3645670414,
0.2534596324,
0.0086343056,
0.33062464,
-0.479747653,
-0.0299754124,
0.7044828534,
-0.1193711832,
-0.3021748066,
0.4923183918,
0.1130208001,
0.1915683597,
0.9876414537,
-0.3123168647,
-0.9064038992,
0.720595777,
0.9336492419,
0.9200296402,
0.0303209089,
0.1502283067,
0.2137656659,
0.57313627,
0.1124071926,
0.4147112072,
0.2423184514,
-1.1538752317,
-0.3771889806,
-0.6178845167,
-0.1717538983,
-0.0220609847,
-0.4933871031,
0.1209652796,
-0.1392116398,
-0.0589793399,
-0.1492924988,
-0.5033678412,
-0.8551990986,
-0.0236327797,
0.2637143433,
0.6726447344,
-0.7720062733,
0.8057584763,
0.4921346605,
-0.5718494058,
-0.5068755746,
-0.2075667381,
-0.0738518238,
-1.3063691854,
0.9748253226,
-0.0281295534,
-0.1722062081,
0.0324371196,
-0.4529781342,
-0.6268153787,
0.8825455904,
0.2077295184,
-0.5653347373,
-0.2269508392,
0.2288132161,
0.5292559862,
-0.1188435256,
0.1462619156,
1.1017885208,
0.6704345345,
-0.0672067851,
-1.1984431744,
0.1950241923,
0.3045085967,
-0.2375109494,
0.3852820694,
-0.3999281824,
0.9256869555,
-0.56358248,
-0.1637462229,
-0.1399942786,
0.0322191939,
0.2887965739,
0.0581953041,
0.546174705,
0.8437970877,
0.515252769,
-0.2187284082,
1.0320595503,
-0.0472871214,
0.2014461756,
0.9555122256,
-0.3267799914,
0.4914332032,
0.5987433791,
-0.1679714769,
0.6617571115,
0.1276115626,
-0.0831710175,
0.5484502912,
0.2851324379,
0.0757573694,
-0.5482724905,
0.2789588273,
-0.4518604279,
0.4778891206,
0.5512373447,
-0.4500752985,
-0.3748424053,
0.2573758662,
0.2127561271,
-0.1094156355,
-0.398222059,
0.6616449356,
0.2189065814,
-0.6417297721,
0.8431127071,
-0.3484429121,
0.5357652903,
-0.4603662193,
-0.0954696015,
-0.2875516713,
0.3718645275,
-0.101838924,
-1.0223001242,
0.3471678495,
-0.3062511384,
-0.070139274,
-0.0900180265,
0.9932015538,
-0.4038285017,
-0.4718002379,
0.475828737,
0.4915730357,
0.2451419532,
0.1006589755,
-0.5668823123,
-0.1204501167,
-0.0106432633,
-0.1995474845,
0.0667047203,
0.42072016,
-0.1064284667,
0.7526050806,
0.3908093572,
0.3791248798,
0.0139991278,
0.3854694068,
0.8508172035,
-0.7012534142,
-0.180685699,
-0.9357710481,
0.3004871309,
0.1711451858,
0.05283048,
0.6279560328,
0.3606210053,
0.6580925584,
-0.3146790266,
0.9795171618,
-0.2129878402,
0.6746262312,
-0.6726099849,
0.6514770985,
-0.222336486,
0.2942218781,
-0.3647411466,
-0.6770800948,
-0.3202681839,
0.5870088339,
-0.7938134074,
0.0198245607,
0.7525078654,
0.5193142295,
0.0555366613,
0.192283228,
0.0740637407,
0.5899078846,
0.4421919584,
1.0628021955,
0.8458904028,
-0.1482117176,
0.6884688735,
0.0788212344,
-0.3063079119,
-0.1179495677,
-0.8465695977,
-0.917188704,
-0.4904518723,
-0.0540322773,
-0.5608035326,
0.3580273688,
0.6492449641,
0.0323805436,
-0.7270909548,
0.0417394489,
-0.2912773788,
0.4511218667,
-0.5240417719,
-0.2509335876,
0.5237494707,
-0.3722007573,
-0.405536592,
0.0762037635,
0.1685906947,
0.0675262213,
-0.182392627,
0.1415958256,
-0.2092373073,
0.0357025787,
0.7567203641,
0.334292978,
-0.8298042417,
-0.6479590535,
-0.2086357921,
-0.0804674327,
-0.2729504406,
0.7852147818,
-1.0729869604,
0.4710536301,
0.6241406798,
0.6840832829,
0.2786283493,
-0.086310938,
0.7043551207,
-0.3635555208,
-0.0623703785,
0.3393124044,
0.4947448671,
0.2543169558,
-0.1738860756,
0.5269231796,
0.4371232688,
-0.6538382173,
-0.8229381442,
0.5315586925,
-0.8128961921,
-0.5298755765,
1.1416527033,
0.1370386928,
0.2808091938,
-0.3469896913,
-0.156616807,
0.1977555603,
0.07528276,
1.1080476046,
0.6634809971,
-0.2683280408,
0.1032081395,
-0.3897352219,
0.4184182286,
0.6121578813,
-0.3497127891,
0.2752922475,
0.4682912529,
0.2745756209,
0.0966030806,
0.4666443169,
-0.3084514737,
0.2192900777,
-0.167346105,
0.1745785475,
-0.0728238747,
-0.3797437549,
-0.1640358418,
-0.3910520673,
-0.0016100288,
-0.0396016426
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03577v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03577v1
|
Improving Bias Mitigation through Bias Experts in Natural Language Understanding
| 2023-12-06T16:15:00 | 2023-12-06T16:15:00 |
Eojin Jeon, Mingyu Lee, Juhyeong Park, Yeachan Kim, Wing-Lam Mok, SangKeun Lee
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Biases in the dataset often enable the model to achieve high performance on
in-distribution data, while poorly performing on out-of-distribution data. To
mitigate the detrimental effect of the bias on the networks, previous works
have proposed debiasing methods that down-weight the biased examples identified
by an auxiliary model, which is trained with explicit bias labels. However,
finding a type of bias in datasets is a costly process. Therefore, recent
studies have attempted to make the auxiliary model biased without the guidance
(or annotation) of bias labels, by constraining the model's training
environment or the capability of the model itself. Despite the promising
debiasing results of recent works, the multi-class learning objective, which
has been naively used to train the auxiliary model, may harm the bias
mitigation effect due to its regularization effect and competitive nature
across classes. As an alternative, we propose a new debiasing framework that
introduces binary classifiers between the auxiliary model and the main model,
coined bias experts. Specifically, each bias expert is trained on a binary
classification task derived from the multi-class classification task via the
One-vs-Rest approach. Experimental results demonstrate that our proposed
strategy improves the bias identification ability of the auxiliary model.
Consequently, our debiased model consistently outperforms the state-of-the-art
on various challenge datasets.
|
[
-0.7576980591,
-0.7980189919,
0.236802578,
0.0524552204,
-0.1667496264,
-0.060923215,
-0.2592312396,
-0.6116338372,
0.3139584959,
0.6626982689,
-0.6229615211,
-0.3215304613,
-0.7983581424,
0.2105909437,
-0.0471979529,
0.9433736801,
0.1668513715,
0.3162311018,
-0.1348770559,
-0.26105389,
-0.7362973094,
-0.3833089769,
-0.7509880662,
-0.3826854229,
0.2779962122,
0.5843293667,
0.6912971139,
0.3681916595,
0.3397868872,
0.2456252426,
-0.156887114,
0.1272219867,
-0.3488732874,
-0.0866949037,
-0.1640342325,
-0.3297482431,
-0.1130145118,
0.1538934559,
0.3706144094,
0.9252823591,
0.1576269865,
-0.0132961413,
0.065072149,
0.831338644,
-0.7672929764,
0.2763569951,
-0.7509064674,
0.1830317229,
-0.0773117319,
-0.0991208106,
-0.3729103506,
-0.5023418665,
0.4965227842,
-0.640969336,
0.4660989642,
0.1130318642,
0.5516926646,
0.5752943754,
-0.5124105215,
-0.0723308101,
-0.6084651351,
0.7463145256,
-0.7578402758,
0.2547813058,
0.4150983691,
0.3827152848,
-0.0130453091,
0.0877450109,
-0.4139133394,
0.1188421994,
-0.1070800051,
-0.0111703118,
0.0299116541,
0.2149201185,
0.1550053358,
0.1170379072,
-0.1530988365,
0.2461182475,
-0.3595487177,
-0.1786358505,
0.6639899611,
-0.2129897177,
0.032763917,
0.0086307162,
-0.4269491732,
0.2000739574,
-0.3894914091,
-0.2437633425,
0.6140089631,
0.40182513,
0.08646667,
0.1745108217,
-0.2587984204,
0.5654050112,
0.1382554173,
0.0838383436,
0.338899076,
-0.1220985949,
-0.2535479963,
0.4505089521,
0.4660922289,
0.3795268536,
0.5592882037,
-0.3146930933,
0.0501695573,
0.2971960604,
0.2200912386,
-0.5297093987,
-0.2542369664,
-0.0052631395,
-0.4862196147,
-0.485658586,
-0.2105393559,
-0.9917155504,
-0.6664223671,
-0.4582250118,
0.3159177005,
-0.1973804384,
-0.5051393509,
0.0732421875,
-0.240059942,
-0.1199641675,
0.1781805307,
-0.9692487717,
0.5691068769,
0.4681950212,
0.6057271361,
-0.072445035,
-0.0235299673,
-0.3415893912,
0.0839308947,
-0.2852527201,
0.7265725136,
-0.6858165264,
-0.2057623416,
-0.1221723258,
-0.4521290362,
-0.1167941391,
-0.3865620494,
0.8268520236,
-0.4993306994,
0.2274637073,
-0.5204433799,
-0.4564011991,
-0.5546955466,
0.357498765,
-0.6930295825,
0.9012197852,
-0.0459832363,
-1.1731479168,
0.7521164417,
-0.5916658044,
-0.2402774394,
-0.2488161623,
-0.2878250182,
-0.3536854982,
0.1491256803,
0.6124471426,
0.2895437777,
-0.3178226352,
0.2458182722,
-0.4749521017,
-0.1041961163,
-0.0047322148,
-0.577224791,
0.6893729568,
-0.0421759933,
-0.4481509328,
0.0705204234,
-0.7560937405,
-0.2413787544,
-0.2961787879,
-0.1222916692,
-0.8489441872,
0.161740616,
-0.0253676865,
0.4037050903,
-0.3919099271,
-0.4946196079,
0.2344818562,
-0.5369725227,
0.1456041038,
1.1375564337,
0.1862913817,
0.8062902093,
-0.1563527137,
0.201483503,
0.0537733436,
0.2551700175,
0.1712483317,
-0.5082815886,
-0.830352664,
-0.3388721347,
0.4023691714,
0.2895085812,
-0.6281449199,
0.2997068465,
-0.2643328607,
-0.1881655157,
-0.7908951044,
0.3165821135,
0.4199771881,
0.8645948172,
0.7216286659,
-0.4602072239,
-0.564920783,
-1.1551156044,
-0.6060600877,
0.3039292991,
0.061695952,
0.2239334434,
0.4565135241,
-0.3045985997,
1.2084391117,
-0.2674511671,
-0.4718041122,
-0.2082639933,
0.3016701937,
0.0004999566,
0.6333204508,
0.493441999,
-0.8511534929,
-0.4325306416,
-0.3705573976,
-0.4533038735,
-0.1399001628,
-0.1467857808,
-0.3992715776,
0.228366375,
0.1235514879,
-0.3293259442,
0.3957954347,
0.1961103678,
-0.3837132752,
0.3725378811,
0.0472980924,
-0.1111354008,
-0.7728553414,
-0.1304712445,
0.3561172783,
-0.1503558308,
-0.7918058634,
-0.4352560341,
-0.2083807141,
0.2246787846,
-0.0820158646,
0.4824790359,
-0.4767438769,
0.1318721473,
-0.2901320159,
0.1529795378,
0.1206037626,
0.5072353482,
0.3224953115,
0.2432539612,
0.554408133,
-0.8363739252,
-0.0528105237,
0.4550370872,
-0.2194533646,
0.5634540319,
-0.4845875502,
0.1734646857,
-0.4993469715,
0.3067642748,
-0.6850269437,
-0.080333367,
0.5837911367,
-0.3074843287,
0.3970756829,
-0.4867647588,
-0.1288760304,
-0.2810304165,
-0.3610911667,
0.2104727179,
0.2104849368,
-0.5286450982,
0.5427851081,
0.4744565785,
-0.0267583057,
-0.9915278554,
-0.877073884,
-0.0636798739,
-0.1693142951,
-0.5788256526,
0.4063639939,
0.0012519176,
-0.4075747728,
-0.0591040663,
-0.4275242686,
-0.2782163024,
0.1887248456,
-0.0998357087,
0.2247973979,
0.0937794298,
0.357775569,
0.2843310535,
-0.3964994848,
0.2834481001,
-0.328471154,
0.3109196723,
0.3276004791,
-0.3164891303,
-0.3827108443,
0.3995908797,
0.3670899272,
-0.2337200642,
0.7842536569,
0.5765290856,
-0.3993200362,
-0.2054304332,
-1.014757514,
-0.3689109385,
-0.4234751463,
0.2565137744,
-0.1012736708,
-0.3499009311,
0.2505464554,
0.2394186407,
0.2269152701,
0.392291069,
0.2720082402,
0.381079793,
1.0560772419,
0.7169010043,
-0.5758095384,
0.3240661025,
-0.2613513768,
0.0872809216,
-0.7552902699,
-0.2417990118,
-0.6479508877,
-0.4354498088,
-0.3226863146,
-0.2644847333,
0.1900544167,
-0.0066695781,
-0.1628889889,
-0.0934987739,
-0.8360346556,
0.452126652,
0.8284648061,
0.3752038777,
0.2255874425,
-0.0225348193,
-0.1023034677,
-0.094539389,
-0.6242188811,
-0.4168672264,
0.9559448361,
0.5235440135,
0.7785579562,
-0.0724283531,
0.6276516318,
0.4109883308,
0.3014289737,
-0.6268588305,
0.1348703951,
0.2104915529,
-1.0342787504,
-0.2309581488,
-0.679186523,
-0.3978332579,
0.5554684997,
-0.4347975552,
-0.5921387076,
0.6376709342,
0.2586608529,
-0.2745715082,
0.3680104911,
-0.8325428963,
0.9064785242,
-0.2657045126,
-0.5804640055,
-0.2229274362,
-0.715356946,
0.3803673983,
0.1381889284,
0.5987941623,
-0.2983208001,
0.2236416936,
0.9131128788,
-0.2532818615,
1.0344713926,
-0.5466051102,
0.1039939672,
0.1514118612,
-0.0337574631,
0.5668861866,
0.2322614342,
-0.25380072,
0.081096597,
-0.4362178147,
-0.5276944637,
-0.3818849921,
0.4722333848,
-0.7117111087,
-0.3010497987,
-0.37622419,
-0.4746063054,
-0.4071350098,
0.258487761,
0.1835846007,
0.4413332641,
0.0059053572,
-0.2166619748,
0.914198041,
-0.1283544898,
0.3966800272,
0.4034444094,
0.314130336,
-0.3887995183,
0.6222586632,
0.0984446257,
0.2724972665,
0.2673162818,
0.4059089124,
-0.2846590877,
-0.5514814258,
-0.3885413706,
-0.1872805059,
-0.7922385931,
-0.1563788056,
-0.8343756199,
0.2282628566,
-0.5128257275,
-0.0620271824,
-0.3110467196,
-0.4472953379,
-0.2170959264,
-0.250826925,
0.319478482,
0.6157408357,
0.0251659434,
0.2556900382,
-0.6509216428,
0.3021167815,
0.3438368142,
0.4459864795,
0.167427808,
-0.4252138138,
-0.1141452491,
0.2068365365,
-0.2900572717,
-0.9909179807,
0.4546382129,
0.132325381,
0.8840564489,
0.5887011886,
0.2273254693,
0.4518541694,
-0.3577733338,
0.3189812899,
0.1542333066,
-1.0627715588,
0.3430363536,
-0.1671485454,
-0.0411132313,
0.9518563151,
0.5409056544,
-0.4284616411,
-0.2122796029,
-0.4863056839,
-0.9905164838,
0.7760516405,
0.2279650271,
0.0085310219,
0.0412186459,
0.2986206114,
0.4578898251,
0.4907412231,
-0.7948081493,
-0.4413584769,
-0.265809536,
-0.2951324284,
0.0284890812,
-0.3802753091,
-0.0234804917,
-0.3171876073,
0.9036489725,
-0.1018546298,
-0.0108839702,
0.3174545765,
-0.3617351949,
0.0198255181,
0.4964593351,
0.3920105398,
0.4460889101,
-0.2690202594,
0.1406270266,
0.3294413686,
-0.4177983105,
-0.1806684583,
0.2621205747,
-0.4489444494,
0.1950172186,
0.1790973991,
0.8584411144,
0.382940352,
-0.183042556,
0.3956872225,
0.095294863,
-0.0746144652,
-0.1990028024,
-0.1400179714,
-0.260424912,
-0.0050723022,
0.487645179,
0.5798988342,
0.4197866917,
-0.2596409917,
0.0927559435,
0.4275224507,
-0.7483248711,
-0.1446531713,
0.6032978296,
0.646268785,
0.0412057154,
0.45882985,
-0.1804476231,
-0.8999909163,
0.5769255161,
0.290948689,
0.8777145147,
-0.1074351072,
0.0960588902,
0.3216189444,
0.5923092365,
-0.3498423994,
0.0031514743,
-0.0230256431,
-0.8346177936,
-0.4638234377,
-0.379797399,
-0.5154204369,
-0.2390279323,
-0.6937974095,
0.2508632839,
-0.287271142,
-0.1005215123,
-0.0033372988,
-0.1057755947,
-0.8931868672,
0.1293034405,
0.2024542838,
1.010565877,
-1.0371195078,
0.520754993,
0.5780425072,
-0.6451765895,
-0.4079240561,
-0.0613354966,
0.0339073017,
-0.3220324814,
0.5652323365,
0.4870246649,
0.0885937661,
-0.00585054,
-0.3064168096,
-0.5948368907,
0.5573247671,
0.2695695162,
-0.492641747,
-0.1364827454,
-0.0907928944,
0.2555205822,
-0.3391954601,
0.7598378062,
0.6731227636,
0.6778659225,
-0.3170797825,
-0.7849841118,
0.037814334,
-0.1173593923,
-0.2300306112,
0.1361095756,
-0.4214939177,
0.7197421193,
-0.0737358108,
0.092261456,
-0.625954628,
0.4164803922,
-0.1378746182,
0.3972219229,
0.6690407991,
0.5033026338,
0.8333056569,
-0.0076237498,
0.8111960888,
-0.0087057231,
0.2743518651,
1.1935482025,
-0.1805199534,
0.2756597996,
0.5241632462,
0.0735081732,
0.5499975085,
0.5248733759,
0.1727425158,
0.6427711248,
0.4016481638,
-0.255224973,
-0.2687811852,
-0.0852905288,
-0.3814458847,
0.1820195168,
0.3465807438,
-0.3829448819,
-0.2717889249,
0.1041744575,
0.0452133976,
0.210028097,
-0.5265312791,
0.7742901444,
-0.0787077397,
-0.3607876003,
0.4304097295,
-0.1434733123,
1.0591514111,
-0.3270614445,
0.0284539443,
-0.0965698063,
0.2884717584,
-0.3485403359,
-0.1560506225,
0.302431643,
-0.2380083203,
-0.3822509944,
-0.1701787412,
0.7904883623,
-0.3810382485,
-0.5745819211,
0.309199661,
0.2224726379,
-0.1361724883,
-0.3690404892,
-0.6341554523,
-0.0569106787,
-0.133868888,
-0.147556141,
0.0577642769,
0.2390486747,
0.107830368,
0.6923921108,
0.3087885678,
-0.0163413994,
0.1364777386,
0.2587364912,
0.8734939098,
-0.3003879786,
-0.4835925698,
-0.9623984694,
0.4207781553,
-0.4971650243,
-0.2413865626,
0.8036616445,
0.4669262469,
0.9446661472,
-0.0290353168,
1.1389400959,
0.0882309601,
0.67536062,
-0.3245167434,
0.6328209639,
-0.1577904671,
0.3719706833,
-0.6218671799,
-0.7455587387,
-0.2658127546,
0.7239263058,
-0.547434032,
0.1313199103,
0.4516238272,
0.4634384513,
-0.0852106288,
0.2407683879,
-0.1766805798,
0.084292233,
0.297464937,
0.4142164588,
0.4702862799,
-0.2952311933,
0.4902943373,
-0.7233501673,
-0.3686246276,
-0.1875302494,
-0.8345726132,
-1.3327832222,
-0.0769199133,
-0.4023619592,
-0.2385334074,
0.244584024,
1.2721916437,
0.7397580743,
-0.9807790518,
0.2874833047,
-0.4348530471,
0.4833423495,
-0.3575420082,
-0.265408814,
0.2738146782,
-0.5180093646,
-0.7459760904,
0.1853176653,
-0.083460398,
-0.1448056549,
-0.3408124745,
0.0092506632,
-0.3209369183,
0.0143698212,
0.3909951448,
0.1060939878,
-0.3412364423,
-0.4004234374,
-0.2599993348,
0.2046030313,
-0.0466236956,
0.7733513713,
-0.8800166249,
0.566685915,
0.5236914158,
0.8005672693,
0.221887216,
0.1624800265,
0.6056408286,
-0.8472213149,
0.2183156908,
0.3679225743,
0.3190565705,
0.3799138367,
-0.4403076172,
0.5657371879,
0.1980772465,
-0.4360616505,
-0.7366541028,
0.2130630314,
-0.57209903,
-0.216522187,
1.1266511679,
0.2637958229,
0.0159175843,
-0.6951587796,
-0.3539161384,
0.3601881266,
-0.6289343834,
1.0832983255,
0.6438887715,
0.0398918018,
0.0284733567,
-0.6413938999,
0.5788785219,
0.548083365,
-0.6135798693,
0.1310245097,
0.437659055,
0.2642171085,
0.0865400061,
0.5889386535,
0.1749626845,
-0.0836829469,
-0.1620853841,
0.3616578579,
-0.2094951868,
-0.2877806723,
-0.199407652,
-0.186877951,
-0.0393855684,
-0.3364533484
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03567v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03567v1
|
XAIQA: Explainer-Based Data Augmentation for Extractive Question Answering
| 2023-12-06T15:59:06 | 2023-12-06T15:59:06 |
Joel Stremmel, Ardavan Saeedi, Hamid Hassanzadeh, Sanjit Batra, Jeffrey Hertzberg, Jaime Murillo, Eran Halperin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, I.2.7
|
Extractive question answering (QA) systems can enable physicians and
researchers to query medical records, a foundational capability for designing
clinical studies and understanding patient medical history. However, building
these systems typically requires expert-annotated QA pairs. Large language
models (LLMs), which can perform extractive QA, depend on high quality data in
their prompts, specialized for the application domain. We introduce a novel
approach, XAIQA, for generating synthetic QA pairs at scale from data naturally
available in electronic health records. Our method uses the idea of a
classification model explainer to generate questions and answers about medical
concepts corresponding to medical codes. In an expert evaluation with two
physicians, our method identifies $2.2\times$ more semantic matches and
$3.8\times$ more clinical abbreviations than two popular approaches that use
sentence transformers to create QA pairs. In an ML evaluation, adding our QA
pairs improves performance of GPT-4 as an extractive QA model, including on
difficult questions. In both the expert and ML evaluations, we examine
trade-offs between our method and sentence transformers for QA pair generation
depending on question difficulty.
|
[
-0.3142180443,
-0.7361444235,
0.7761713862,
-0.33529827,
-0.2061672658,
0.0688098222,
0.2275883406,
-0.5462019444,
0.4107068479,
0.4403913617,
-0.6502461433,
-0.178186819,
-0.418407768,
0.078816168,
-0.3327391744,
1.1190334558,
0.038725432,
0.2367800921,
-0.5376346707,
-0.1799388528,
-0.3148832023,
-0.4390769303,
-0.8234793544,
-0.1517457515,
0.5502253175,
0.4038383961,
1.0895930529,
0.9342789054,
0.4435377121,
0.2751615644,
0.1971134394,
0.2720023394,
-0.1487011164,
0.2739878297,
-0.0670123398,
-0.7447111607,
-0.3397794664,
-0.2625137269,
0.3023361862,
0.5512664318,
-0.0884173512,
0.2540152371,
-0.6030893326,
0.5640625358,
-0.2047958672,
0.1095130444,
-0.5594623089,
-0.1409286708,
0.0317591131,
-0.561198473,
0.0079404358,
-0.4504918754,
0.422139436,
-0.7206961513,
0.2824670374,
0.0179613568,
0.925496161,
0.418756783,
-0.454307884,
-0.3842902482,
-0.5872666836,
0.3952962458,
-0.6616688371,
0.2803764939,
0.185255751,
0.6624955535,
0.0113760745,
-1.0714454651,
-0.9133961797,
-0.0413742177,
-0.1525331885,
0.1843205541,
-0.2001831532,
0.0703345686,
0.2194924653,
0.7992246747,
-0.6972592473,
-0.0669929087,
-0.4609540701,
0.2232780308,
0.9020795822,
0.3451731801,
0.7959228158,
-0.3380408585,
-0.2278440893,
-0.0967802405,
-0.7326205373,
0.1664329767,
-0.1330784857,
-0.1649530083,
0.1199418902,
0.5396518707,
-0.3317196369,
0.3233996332,
0.1246760339,
-0.1018221527,
0.48454386,
-0.3268597126,
-0.1705483943,
0.0242340099,
0.7066402435,
0.3622637987,
-0.1612728685,
-0.3539284468,
-0.0544296131,
0.0519303717,
0.3216443658,
-0.6683169603,
-0.5926823616,
0.665309608,
-0.5101709366,
-0.4057473838,
-0.1530370116,
-0.7781224847,
-0.360301733,
-0.3148100376,
0.7051824331,
-0.326738596,
-0.2412876189,
-0.0477019995,
-0.2852486074,
0.5163687468,
0.0406482741,
-0.7683799267,
0.3002437055,
0.5409324765,
0.4191403091,
-0.2417569607,
0.3307836056,
-0.764988482,
0.032134302,
-0.2177324295,
0.6856334805,
-0.4853521585,
-0.3500052691,
-0.1704836488,
0.0466508083,
-0.0013675432,
-0.6373711824,
0.6358966827,
-0.5957885385,
0.5778508782,
-0.1097695306,
-0.6283535361,
-0.1644475609,
0.171246767,
-0.7490796447,
0.944222033,
0.4587764144,
-0.6072202921,
0.2324638069,
-0.7915903926,
-0.258990705,
0.6083623767,
-0.6658571362,
-0.3912268579,
-0.0538597181,
0.6397075653,
0.110753186,
-0.5514302254,
0.2699320912,
0.1222543791,
-0.001546729,
0.5595454574,
-0.4229904711,
0.7180671096,
0.1383492947,
-0.3738877475,
0.3024819791,
-0.9621250033,
0.3966518939,
0.227869615,
-0.203250736,
-0.4401820004,
-0.0872172341,
-0.2834883332,
0.4205582142,
0.0378564075,
-0.5658233762,
0.0010957462,
-0.7133566737,
0.4801227152,
0.2525294125,
0.3727463484,
0.2194581777,
-0.7235384583,
1.0204416513,
-0.2332452536,
0.1547982544,
-0.5092299581,
-0.6588638425,
-0.7480840683,
-0.2481754571,
0.3721714616,
0.60238868,
-1.168566227,
0.1817253679,
-0.5104070902,
-0.4325444102,
-1.1544665098,
0.0894804224,
0.4842023253,
0.769002974,
0.5206950307,
0.0017056658,
-0.5007407665,
-0.8901216984,
-0.0182445552,
-0.3417194486,
-0.2488720864,
0.4662583768,
0.1292431206,
0.0093263052,
0.9085041881,
-0.7551187277,
0.0969855264,
-0.2997282743,
-0.0513328314,
0.0369722247,
0.4307070971,
0.3508270979,
-1.1879001856,
-0.2374422252,
0.1025666595,
-0.7944021821,
-0.0800381899,
-0.347438693,
-0.2051907331,
-0.0826719105,
0.3234191537,
-0.6830227971,
0.302088201,
0.2293433845,
-0.1986204237,
0.5040934086,
-0.2793575525,
0.227628991,
-1.3073196411,
0.0963538885,
-0.037647035,
-0.346719265,
-0.8440899253,
0.5622327924,
-0.0176325757,
-0.0788539872,
-0.3387763202,
0.5307572484,
-0.362709403,
0.2555875778,
-0.0645178333,
0.1023873463,
0.2425082475,
0.3442120254,
-0.0084584523,
0.5680536032,
0.4560219944,
-0.3783764243,
0.4335972965,
0.6887453198,
-0.0601141416,
0.5218600035,
-0.9715896249,
0.2627585828,
-0.2276469916,
-0.0269086547,
-0.9450618029,
-0.4461030066,
0.2622201741,
-0.7666540146,
0.1194911227,
-0.0893686265,
-0.2620758116,
-0.5008039474,
-0.2597974241,
0.4101113677,
0.7887597084,
-0.5603810549,
0.4968557358,
0.558622241,
-0.6243552566,
-0.2242991775,
-0.6587791443,
0.2273859829,
-0.329385072,
-0.7878553271,
0.3483190835,
-0.1456605643,
-0.2710363865,
-0.0165677369,
-0.1230775937,
-0.4212529659,
0.0677183867,
0.2802438438,
0.4580554366,
-0.4595732391,
0.4478515089,
0.5771469474,
-0.0676228777,
0.5550389886,
-0.1213438287,
0.0943764001,
0.3789115548,
-0.1980550885,
-0.4817604423,
0.7874433994,
0.5119689107,
-0.395875752,
0.4953304529,
0.3482968211,
-0.3712424636,
0.1622807533,
-0.4688741267,
-0.2542061806,
-0.4562978745,
0.3145607412,
-0.4513458014,
-0.6030369401,
0.2991163731,
0.2292277515,
0.1731069237,
0.4700250924,
0.6013858914,
0.0048782919,
1.4210141897,
0.1917624176,
0.3604676127,
-0.1173673347,
-0.1216140389,
0.181724757,
-0.4958766997,
-0.4109205306,
-0.3705129027,
-0.0210860185,
-0.6653062701,
-0.3721132278,
0.8514297605,
-0.2430336177,
0.2149368972,
-0.1881670654,
-0.4860704243,
0.30872944,
0.7142329812,
0.4422133863,
0.3869298995,
-0.1135898232,
0.4778572619,
0.0817475915,
-0.7203956842,
-0.3439417779,
1.1406431198,
0.3351310194,
0.4073300958,
0.2535667419,
0.7940800786,
0.0645573139,
0.1201181412,
-0.7069680691,
0.1864691079,
-0.0466932729,
-0.6007633209,
-0.2997612357,
-0.5579555035,
-0.9820971489,
0.1140105948,
-0.4963117242,
-0.3227861822,
0.0245920904,
0.2089569867,
-0.8292076588,
-0.0246536378,
-0.6802250147,
0.6899819374,
-0.2426929921,
-0.0197302755,
0.0730401576,
-1.0372152328,
0.4154359698,
-0.151640892,
-0.0277263429,
0.3046494424,
-0.0645413473,
0.7401025295,
-0.6692201495,
0.3322684467,
-0.1522745937,
-0.1475872248,
0.2486676276,
-0.1433714032,
0.2208684832,
0.2245118171,
-0.0245636627,
-0.356623888,
0.5648999214,
-0.4013608098,
-1.1487491131,
0.5868633986,
-0.6609756947,
-0.8480747938,
-0.0220997483,
-0.7487868071,
-0.3534711897,
0.0029263699,
0.0816967189,
0.7918846607,
0.1495571882,
-0.0711231157,
0.6996614337,
-0.3177173734,
-0.112209551,
0.3068098724,
0.0457757525,
-0.3073825836,
0.9573124647,
0.0252197925,
0.278490901,
0.5412828922,
0.3886273801,
-0.5756436586,
-0.7204928994,
-0.7392920852,
0.1968941987,
-0.5812562704,
-0.125773862,
-0.9296510816,
-0.3222975433,
-0.4562522769,
0.2042016238,
0.3685859442,
-0.865891099,
-0.162799105,
-0.1707981974,
0.5296884775,
0.5712562799,
0.1802070588,
0.2586636841,
-1.2478265762,
0.7589967251,
0.4598752558,
-0.0743722916,
-0.1188135743,
-0.3767548501,
-0.0845875293,
0.1355540752,
-0.1327924132,
-0.9769874811,
0.5052930713,
0.264487952,
0.6282421947,
0.4533994198,
0.318169862,
0.6816574335,
-0.3151165247,
0.915088892,
0.002057866,
-0.6278774738,
0.5633417964,
-0.1605577618,
0.1367393285,
0.5094916224,
0.5797099471,
-0.3254275322,
-0.2596321106,
-0.733466208,
-0.9189029932,
0.447406143,
0.1891825944,
0.1459842175,
-0.2115672678,
0.7382176518,
0.4897331893,
0.0664826632,
-0.4123740196,
-0.4687902331,
0.0288449246,
-0.5825688839,
0.1259007007,
-0.2049323618,
-0.1560364366,
-0.1974130869,
0.5465807915,
-0.2800076902,
0.1614608616,
0.564804852,
-0.1476933211,
-0.0417933129,
0.3891213834,
0.1215930954,
0.6198539734,
-0.0008690173,
0.1576890051,
-0.0855509788,
-0.2516611218,
0.117430225,
0.4128808975,
-0.2481798381,
-0.004411588,
0.1759916693,
0.6164175868,
-0.1729494482,
-0.9477664232,
0.4959555268,
-0.2435734868,
-0.2108239681,
-0.2109791487,
0.1721379757,
-0.0485299639,
0.2379749864,
0.3256345093,
-0.2783704102,
0.5314998627,
-0.4685537517,
0.4153865576,
0.3617131412,
-0.3844652772,
-0.2712418139,
0.8384938836,
0.2462665737,
-0.2762470543,
0.5559129119,
-0.067766957,
-0.3770276606,
0.6017193198,
0.4604233801,
0.6137225032,
-0.1598235965,
0.3065516651,
0.2268590033,
-0.0748057887,
0.2987644672,
0.6506612301,
-0.2332757562,
-0.3527750671,
-0.5593342781,
-0.1783481985,
-0.4712130725,
0.1415815502,
-0.9880960584,
0.0243267417,
-0.046655193,
0.1939872056,
0.3166170716,
-0.0496480353,
-0.5117676854,
0.5641242862,
0.1022570878,
0.8082427382,
-0.7585976124,
0.6417739987,
0.6342187524,
-0.6503619552,
-1.0319939852,
-0.1527012736,
-0.2475339621,
-0.8366934657,
0.2879177034,
-0.0019937758,
0.358166337,
0.0200382732,
-0.4047822058,
-0.5982679129,
1.0250874758,
0.2366933078,
-0.3514153063,
-0.4166898131,
0.2720767558,
0.7358686924,
-0.2919140756,
0.5533009171,
0.8442146182,
0.1419299543,
0.0860451609,
-0.7010244131,
0.4305873215,
-0.644361794,
-0.3103614748,
0.2338363677,
-0.0971403345,
0.4169985354,
-0.5226040483,
-0.32539922,
0.5675560236,
0.5802558064,
0.1768186241,
0.5757283568,
0.4819853306,
0.3853670359,
0.9164341092,
0.0715795681,
1.3642317057,
-0.2075403035,
-0.2444751412,
1.1863623857,
-0.0704215243,
0.693567574,
0.5264782906,
-0.1497893929,
0.7261440158,
0.5791318417,
0.212955907,
0.1522366107,
0.2220443934,
-0.2936768532,
-0.2625481188,
-0.0559740923,
-0.4201945662,
0.3336559534,
0.3613627255,
-0.6072261333,
0.0658709407,
-0.0742828026,
-0.0172231514,
0.0273886304,
-0.2563906908,
1.0334726572,
-0.0472408868,
-0.8744871616,
0.5687987804,
-0.3499477804,
0.0914262608,
-0.4918101132,
-0.3612606823,
-0.1212583706,
-0.2106226385,
-0.3224999607,
-0.81740731,
0.1306658387,
-0.1312464923,
-0.2859280407,
0.2889273465,
0.4460615516,
-0.7060522437,
-0.5167065263,
-0.2348019481,
0.8175818324,
0.3509510756,
-0.0810031667,
-0.6281312704,
-0.5560994148,
0.1018225402,
0.0896823555,
0.1119299158,
0.4525777996,
-0.3092038929,
0.7418739796,
0.8034744263,
0.1811545342,
0.2255735397,
0.074179776,
1.0264357328,
-0.4952044487,
-0.6636396646,
-0.4951483607,
0.4566941261,
-0.1496767104,
-0.2084522545,
0.4859520793,
0.3046658933,
0.2768267691,
0.0743693188,
0.9333165288,
-0.0344347358,
0.8088361025,
-0.5264883041,
0.6191110611,
-0.591774106,
0.2080494314,
0.0147249121,
-0.434766382,
-0.3667996526,
0.0060446411,
-0.0436762422,
-0.1830626428,
0.5614750981,
0.8819491863,
0.1807849109,
0.1550594568,
0.2665859461,
0.1667384803,
0.591324389,
0.6675888896,
0.7690768838,
-0.6182314754,
0.7885957956,
-0.2433473915,
-0.4855234027,
0.2106307298,
-0.3274891973,
-0.6614218354,
-0.5517203212,
-0.5526134968,
-0.3698771596,
0.0674041063,
1.058398962,
0.6892021298,
-0.6831880808,
0.4407159388,
0.1304266751,
-0.0529281907,
-0.2745529115,
-0.3236463964,
0.6532827616,
-0.2121867537,
-0.6458439827,
0.5245417356,
-0.022562312,
-0.0334426612,
-0.2782994807,
-0.0375720002,
0.1376192868,
0.1395514011,
0.3108157218,
0.5105240345,
-0.5190365314,
-0.1091731042,
0.1661053449,
0.2171419114,
0.3698156178,
0.774659574,
-1.1655020714,
0.7308773994,
0.6435199976,
0.9918076396,
0.2237266302,
0.3140672445,
0.7467175126,
-0.4497856796,
-0.5144816041,
0.1658352911,
0.0981997177,
0.3712025285,
-0.6529989839,
0.3488793671,
-0.1301451027,
-0.6097047329,
-0.7545909286,
0.1193710938,
-1.0185935497,
-0.0192988161,
0.9886741042,
-0.2584412396,
-0.2079702616,
-0.4879957139,
-0.4732842147,
0.1557347029,
-0.2120300978,
0.8649821281,
-0.0939391255,
-0.4429193437,
-0.3438943923,
-0.3300239742,
0.5260074735,
0.4812210798,
-1.2082408667,
-0.2515660226,
0.2580341995,
0.2817573547,
0.1362088919,
0.450438261,
-0.4322661161,
0.7869914174,
-0.1741387844,
-0.0671623498,
-0.0886266157,
0.2179530114,
-0.4868780375,
0.2496967167,
0.0922123119,
-0.4622167051
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03549v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03549v4
|
Holmes: Towards Distributed Training Across Clusters with Heterogeneous NIC Environment
| 2023-12-06T15:27:26 | 2024-04-29T06:56:25 |
Fei Yang, Shuang Peng, Ning Sun, Fangyu Wang, Yuanyuan Wang, Fu Wu, Jiezhong Qiu, Aimin Pan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DC
|
Large language models (LLMs) such as GPT-3, OPT, and LLaMA have demonstrated
remarkable accuracy in a wide range of tasks. However, training these models
can incur significant expenses, often requiring tens of thousands of GPUs for
months of continuous operation. Typically, this training is carried out in
specialized GPU clusters equipped with homogeneous high-speed Remote Direct
Memory Access (RDMA) network interface cards (NICs). The acquisition and
maintenance of such dedicated clusters is challenging. Current LLM training
frameworks, like Megatron-LM and Megatron-DeepSpeed, focus primarily on
optimizing training within homogeneous cluster settings. In this paper, we
introduce Holmes, a training framework for LLMs that employs thoughtfully
crafted data and model parallelism strategies over the heterogeneous NIC
environment. Our primary technical contribution lies in a novel scheduling
method that intelligently allocates distinct computational tasklets in LLM
training to specific groups of GPU devices based on the characteristics of
their connected NICs. Furthermore, our proposed framework, utilizing pipeline
parallel techniques, demonstrates scalability to multiple GPU clusters, even in
scenarios without high-speed interconnects between nodes in distinct clusters.
We conducted comprehensive experiments that involved various scenarios in the
heterogeneous NIC environment. In most cases, our framework achieves
performance levels close to those achievable with homogeneous RDMA-capable
networks (InfiniBand or RoCE), significantly exceeding training efficiency
within the pure Ethernet environment. Additionally, we verified that our
framework outperforms other mainstream LLM frameworks under heterogeneous NIC
environment in terms of training efficiency and can be seamlessly integrated
with them.
|
[
-0.3396962285,
-0.9081360698,
0.6322485805,
0.2637347281,
-0.0447792448,
0.1599813849,
-0.2943677902,
-0.2776314914,
0.3179455698,
0.1157501116,
-0.5263454318,
-0.3923089504,
-0.4496670663,
0.0508185104,
-0.2115420699,
0.6943121552,
-0.0640476793,
0.0423727818,
-0.2781581581,
-0.180133298,
-0.1765943468,
-0.4093916118,
-0.7017738223,
-0.3631784022,
0.4957779348,
0.3832616806,
0.5195177197,
0.9202244282,
0.7220059633,
0.2760002315,
0.0803788677,
0.0555114113,
-0.3303159475,
0.0040558409,
-0.0735434294,
-0.5737581253,
-0.3952645957,
-0.166120857,
0.9854492545,
0.8287620544,
-0.6236532927,
0.0223604962,
0.0742364153,
0.4272892475,
-0.5613213181,
0.1422168612,
-1.028380394,
0.4550949633,
-0.4106687903,
-0.4535393715,
-0.18577151,
-0.1296986192,
-0.0592801608,
-0.8211574554,
0.4570384026,
-0.0075313393,
0.7164469957,
0.382794559,
-0.022328157,
0.2637916207,
-0.6106692553,
0.7621515989,
-0.5268121958,
0.160036698,
-0.0532086045,
0.6568172574,
-0.0157506391,
-0.6244001985,
-0.4543171823,
0.1705237329,
0.044893194,
0.3506056368,
0.0648826435,
-0.0256940424,
0.4476156831,
0.3338973224,
-0.5088486671,
0.5902286172,
-0.0408162475,
0.2359648943,
0.280287534,
0.5758464932,
-0.0450592563,
0.4640090168,
-0.3455784917,
0.2218713313,
-0.749219954,
-0.2885546684,
0.4085923731,
0.5789807439,
-0.1487506181,
0.3281887472,
-0.2297844589,
0.6125560403,
0.0095527256,
-0.3466655016,
0.4229994714,
-0.0022757659,
-0.4840968549,
0.2642710507,
0.55381006,
-0.181103617,
-0.0913841128,
-0.2843486071,
-0.1657845527,
0.3123613894,
0.3835754395,
-0.6979160309,
-0.0329642557,
0.1869192272,
-0.2482063323,
-0.3203577995,
-0.4671883285,
-0.7455016971,
-0.2522387207,
-0.4210892916,
-0.0030076948,
0.1290263981,
-0.4452569485,
0.0873289928,
-0.0740445405,
-0.0224863049,
0.4751869142,
-1.2274857759,
0.3728948832,
0.8632518649,
0.8591024876,
-0.5052694082,
-0.663589716,
-0.6901060939,
0.5324597955,
-0.123609826,
0.6159877777,
-0.5536029935,
-0.2588799894,
0.1577464938,
0.1425673664,
-0.403676331,
-0.6043056846,
0.1830390394,
-0.3976754248,
0.1524662971,
0.1302130669,
-0.3788445294,
0.100663282,
0.6570129395,
-0.3658379316,
0.7586538196,
-0.1874673218,
-1.0140763521,
0.1176710874,
-0.6866090894,
-0.7100476027,
0.2950240672,
-0.6043003201,
-0.6140905023,
-0.0198150724,
0.2494389564,
0.8566799164,
-0.5624470115,
0.4701108932,
-0.5875431299,
-0.5503854752,
-0.4914663434,
-0.2972534597,
0.8756572604,
0.0492737927,
-0.6990606189,
0.2089722604,
-0.5697502494,
-0.1230911016,
0.1241302043,
-0.4416042864,
0.0350137725,
0.0745127797,
0.3027412295,
-0.1397530437,
0.078816399,
-0.7929466367,
0.1583908051,
-0.0432858542,
0.6482388973,
0.8585927486,
-0.3637169003,
0.236138925,
-0.3536021113,
0.6629793644,
0.1585039198,
0.3003160059,
0.1274846196,
-0.5150926709,
-0.4626634717,
-0.4775891304,
-0.3814822733,
0.5589743853,
-0.6280747652,
0.3792916834,
-0.6073425412,
-0.4270891249,
-0.3035686314,
-0.0816869289,
-0.0595963337,
0.5017196536,
0.4497611821,
-0.2089463621,
-0.3989378512,
-0.8398044705,
0.1220787317,
0.1908088177,
0.2754406035,
0.415466398,
0.2155582756,
-0.6742943525,
0.8464197516,
-0.3268320858,
-0.2841176689,
-0.1735640913,
-0.1912209392,
0.4831252992,
0.5496758223,
0.2247425616,
-0.4605419636,
-0.5091986656,
0.5016927719,
-1.0156023502,
0.2129621357,
-0.2139784992,
0.001110213,
0.1657734364,
0.7326940894,
-0.3706506193,
0.2108180672,
0.8825691938,
0.3627869785,
0.6291999221,
-0.2193627805,
-0.1078888625,
-0.9515167475,
0.103476882,
0.0926403254,
-0.3435569108,
-0.1526672095,
-0.0142704239,
-0.2872289717,
-0.3212877512,
-0.3723660409,
0.4014989436,
-0.453086108,
-0.3363349438,
-0.1657328308,
-0.1755427271,
-0.2787529528,
0.6440769434,
0.3642597198,
0.8916374445,
1.0968528986,
-0.4916745722,
0.2438203543,
0.0056287795,
-0.2443546802,
0.7596132755,
-0.7744170427,
-0.1720435619,
-0.0187312551,
0.3305593431,
-0.3571946025,
-0.0855430141,
0.0363426991,
0.1814394295,
0.1507312655,
-0.16737625,
-0.5325723886,
-0.105459407,
0.0906477794,
0.4745424688,
0.506193161,
-0.9164972901,
0.7183369398,
0.5632120371,
0.2475445271,
-0.5895252824,
-0.7670226693,
0.006443508,
-0.6003925204,
-0.5140113831,
0.3768153191,
0.0280082878,
0.0539129898,
0.0362518281,
0.0883306265,
-0.285431236,
0.3724472225,
0.5708094835,
0.0681523755,
-0.2133527696,
0.0031370686,
0.1266890764,
-0.177639395,
0.0108607672,
-0.5467120409,
0.4686841071,
-0.1781451553,
-0.5898569226,
-0.6249216795,
0.3277378082,
0.2780139446,
-0.1005174145,
0.7170664072,
0.9052568674,
-0.2143418491,
-0.4502630532,
-0.5072924495,
-0.3063498437,
-0.4980431199,
0.4681716859,
-0.4856629968,
-1.2120826244,
0.297767967,
-0.2347870767,
0.2429619133,
0.2888456583,
0.7657375336,
-0.1520591825,
0.6957552433,
0.6799037457,
-0.3041163683,
0.5678037405,
-0.1830173135,
0.265145123,
-0.8577391505,
0.1617838442,
-0.3395805359,
-0.3210076988,
-0.6653037071,
-0.40877527,
0.7404097319,
-0.2683342993,
-0.5051221251,
0.1173905581,
-0.4767002165,
0.6516278386,
0.5772393346,
0.1575442553,
0.2705676854,
0.5523480773,
-0.0830555037,
0.309900403,
-1.2069295645,
-0.1610044986,
1.0936917067,
0.6098707914,
0.536966145,
0.0032049334,
0.7087538838,
0.0967066586,
0.3311535418,
-0.3964055777,
0.51369977,
0.0111756846,
-0.6285965443,
-0.3167608678,
-0.8400020599,
-1.0227564573,
0.2281331718,
-0.0309039094,
-0.6842538714,
0.0748187676,
0.117942892,
-0.2209425867,
0.7977235317,
-0.2394703776,
0.7417067885,
0.0315121971,
-0.6480518579,
-0.725869596,
-0.5495780706,
0.3287596107,
-0.0714268237,
-0.0111247543,
-0.3418097198,
0.1843385249,
0.4424248934,
-0.2870427668,
0.7580316663,
-0.2016592175,
0.2028281689,
-0.0489242673,
-0.1679484546,
0.4153086245,
0.3252329826,
-0.0493326411,
0.442376107,
-0.3163461387,
-0.6797770858,
-0.2299218923,
0.9751518965,
-0.9371973872,
-0.3151140511,
-0.4867111742,
-0.676186204,
-0.4652636945,
0.009392349,
0.1347542703,
0.6555530429,
-0.1510841101,
-0.0613242276,
0.7429951429,
-0.2555078566,
0.5233361721,
0.1520011872,
0.0048482777,
-0.0501965955,
0.8705785275,
-0.3046286404,
0.3356642425,
0.4093962014,
-0.0324010141,
0.0851688236,
-0.8313499093,
-0.4321266115,
0.1991377324,
-0.5345234275,
0.0179211162,
-0.7353429198,
-0.1971092969,
-0.1100779027,
-0.311388433,
-0.5039404631,
-0.1745560765,
-0.3166702688,
0.1566600651,
0.245199874,
0.3984324932,
-0.1527469456,
0.7577207685,
-0.5217049718,
-0.079008311,
0.4006026387,
0.5468880534,
0.1076019108,
-0.3478606939,
-0.510258913,
-0.2482676357,
-0.1032590121,
-0.1060614288,
0.1033265144,
0.0746585056,
0.6147594452,
0.1382142603,
-0.5455750823,
0.6261193156,
-0.6711249948,
0.4471161962,
0.3980392516,
-0.569665432,
0.1660623252,
-0.7577263117,
0.1583407372,
0.7493072152,
0.6183131933,
-0.3806967437,
-0.0582060851,
-0.6348077655,
-0.540341258,
0.5112293363,
-0.2462631017,
-0.0240179989,
-0.0221438035,
0.0629734322,
-0.0408357121,
0.3515169024,
-0.5080267787,
-0.1418985277,
0.1054649651,
-0.1102418825,
-0.1435419768,
0.189001441,
-0.4537188709,
-0.4322938323,
0.881937027,
-0.427719593,
0.4248213768,
-0.0703883916,
0.0178972892,
0.2418816835,
-0.0610176437,
0.175799042,
0.8232020736,
-0.2203413397,
-0.078296937,
-0.0442387722,
-0.4714162052,
0.0557516627,
0.120845139,
0.0076383175,
0.0481856577,
0.2443731129,
0.9087614417,
-0.1499473602,
-0.6393918395,
0.465949744,
-0.204732269,
-0.2344241589,
-0.2157030255,
0.0753835365,
0.0534171425,
0.1984924674,
-0.1385294944,
0.0554289222,
-0.0167654455,
-0.5580154657,
0.0279563908,
0.4836722314,
-0.2231158912,
-0.0912057161,
0.6022775769,
0.3542485237,
0.0456729606,
0.935927093,
-0.2289850414,
-0.4277445674,
0.5716138482,
0.4762023389,
0.8720092773,
0.1027515605,
0.1523322165,
0.347571075,
0.1983354837,
-0.2570552528,
-0.0083040008,
0.0065767043,
-0.7502288222,
-0.3180265725,
-0.606307447,
-0.4619856477,
-0.2919008434,
-0.4268291295,
0.0941416174,
-0.9189289808,
-0.006031557,
-0.3054992557,
-0.1048702598,
-0.9196432233,
0.1876057535,
0.1104075089,
0.6357345581,
-0.8650397658,
1.1173075438,
0.6449398994,
0.2415087223,
-0.8652777076,
-0.2756848335,
0.0118409833,
-0.977214992,
0.3188446462,
0.157318607,
0.063087903,
0.2041418999,
-0.1086823419,
-0.4309056997,
1.046875,
0.2241091877,
-1.0011751652,
0.113353163,
0.2653549016,
0.2866281867,
-0.3105745912,
0.6002895236,
0.5765929818,
0.1083415225,
-0.1115560085,
-0.8809615374,
-0.2275365144,
-0.228064537,
0.0983577594,
0.1270296574,
-0.4822630286,
0.7792936563,
0.0964471102,
-0.0236702599,
-0.408294946,
0.4238826632,
0.3173552752,
0.0617524832,
0.5194109082,
0.8699992895,
0.8574674129,
-0.0274446644,
1.0704616308,
-0.3371862173,
0.2701464593,
1.1953914165,
-0.4322249293,
0.6454632878,
0.6149442196,
-0.220710516,
0.402127713,
0.5679771304,
0.0697379857,
0.5056959987,
0.4283780456,
-0.4645992815,
-0.1476377696,
-0.2017302513,
-0.5357125401,
0.1152264252,
0.1279765218,
-0.0243815798,
-0.3234924674,
0.144096151,
-0.0891062245,
0.0476657748,
-0.414686501,
0.5379315615,
-0.0157474857,
-0.1865619421,
0.5416634083,
-0.0207717493,
1.0410676003,
-0.6781966686,
0.3175618947,
-0.3871240318,
0.3937318921,
-0.3847012818,
-0.3909721673,
0.4047668874,
-0.1406455934,
-0.1688151807,
-0.2584064305,
0.0869172961,
-0.1726605296,
-0.4246844053,
0.165949434,
0.3618617058,
0.1602933407,
-0.0979509503,
-0.6410984397,
0.4216171801,
-0.2363655716,
0.0842609927,
0.6506462693,
0.315766722,
0.1760284454,
0.5919376612,
0.5643548369,
0.1727728099,
0.3458501101,
0.1656123549,
0.756994307,
-0.1928828061,
-0.5995224714,
-0.6257917285,
0.0995359719,
-0.0269398112,
-0.3917579651,
0.8283593059,
0.6413348913,
0.877307117,
0.1047515422,
0.8299072385,
0.1398415565,
0.2729253173,
-0.3023043573,
0.3935039043,
-0.5885412693,
0.4121248424,
-0.0479086563,
-1.2073335648,
-0.200971663,
0.5498503447,
-0.3204510212,
-0.2117089033,
0.8304220438,
0.8261959553,
-0.6136223078,
0.3808674812,
0.0300010163,
-0.0912202597,
0.5818489194,
0.8038008809,
0.6010550261,
-0.1224807128,
-0.1607047617,
-0.3492765129,
-0.1770424694,
0.0021341897,
-0.869370997,
-0.8413136005,
-0.2827584147,
-0.5750119686,
-0.0016867998,
0.3110790849,
0.8027575016,
0.9486489296,
-0.4133578837,
-0.6505773067,
-0.5844463706,
-0.1632383168,
-0.3008421659,
-0.1531934291,
0.3539649248,
-0.5557983518,
-0.6551268697,
0.4745237827,
0.2471630722,
-0.266816318,
-0.3920040727,
0.0576702803,
-0.0867590606,
-0.4268456697,
0.2984419465,
0.1393910795,
-0.1724445522,
0.0522348098,
-0.4653069675,
-0.3034915328,
0.253693521,
0.7547413707,
-0.8022176027,
0.0455516949,
0.1903405339,
1.3934988976,
0.7161755562,
-0.1886448115,
0.3425231576,
-0.604321599,
0.4809882343,
0.4752958417,
0.2340330631,
0.2906236649,
-0.1828430146,
0.5277767181,
0.6105145216,
-0.6496952176,
-0.8597878814,
0.0514733046,
-1.1288830042,
-0.233704105,
0.9880545139,
-0.124284111,
-0.2010582238,
0.0276170578,
0.3943387866,
-0.1837704331,
-0.0311604794,
0.6238562465,
0.0913809314,
0.1762889028,
0.053802494,
-0.8171085119,
0.2214257568,
0.7891491055,
-1.1793712378,
-0.0044463808,
0.2924537063,
0.2455098778,
-0.2748596966,
0.7060905695,
0.2144542933,
0.0828170329,
0.1162867621,
0.0992599651,
-0.2584896982,
-0.6608959436,
-0.471475035,
0.2159142643,
-0.2175447643,
-0.3406007588
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14945v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14945v1
|
Empowering ChatGPT-Like Large-Scale Language Models with Local Knowledge Base for Industrial Prognostics and Health Management
| 2023-12-06T15:24:01 | 2023-12-06T15:24:01 |
Huan Wang, Yan-Fu Li, Min Xie
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Prognostics and health management (PHM) is essential for industrial operation
and maintenance, focusing on predicting, diagnosing, and managing the health
status of industrial systems. The emergence of the ChatGPT-Like large-scale
language model (LLM) has begun to lead a new round of innovation in the AI
field. It has extensively promoted the level of intelligence in various fields.
Therefore, it is also expected further to change the application paradigm in
industrial PHM and promote PHM to become intelligent. Although ChatGPT-Like
LLMs have rich knowledge reserves and powerful language understanding and
generation capabilities, they lack domain-specific expertise, significantly
limiting their practicability in PHM applications. To this end, this study
explores the ChatGPT-Like LLM empowered by the local knowledge base (LKB) in
industrial PHM to solve the above limitations. In addition, we introduce the
method and steps of combining the LKB with LLMs, including LKB preparation, LKB
vectorization, prompt engineering, etc. Experimental analysis of real cases
shows that combining the LKB with ChatGPT-Like LLM can significantly improve
its performance and make ChatGPT-Like LLMs more accurate, relevant, and able to
provide more insightful information. This can promote the development of
ChatGPT-Like LLMs in industrial PHM and promote their efficiency and quality.
|
[
-0.2339771837,
-0.7375272512,
0.6592600346,
0.068076238,
-0.2570084035,
0.1677135974,
-0.2341176867,
-0.6368514299,
0.0613924637,
0.6171576381,
-0.2504327297,
-0.4667318165,
-0.1850943714,
-0.2440927178,
0.0398664586,
1.1305112839,
-0.0729409456,
0.0688586161,
-0.1506459266,
0.1824215502,
-0.5009962916,
-0.791603148,
-0.8426433802,
-0.4942105412,
0.4663646817,
0.2940265238,
0.8758240938,
0.4694514573,
0.8834097385,
0.2181769162,
-0.0558361784,
0.1861091852,
-0.2553568184,
0.2473024279,
-0.0138229607,
-0.4607570171,
-0.8057682514,
-0.4220481813,
0.3130066395,
0.7404827476,
-0.2345777452,
-0.1668023914,
0.18069686,
0.568995297,
-0.2207374871,
0.639300406,
-0.5413880348,
0.1269975454,
-0.0722750202,
-0.1494111419,
-0.1134620234,
-0.505453825,
0.1455385238,
-0.1934133172,
-0.2647221982,
0.0241595507,
0.5382170677,
0.1888168454,
-0.244651109,
0.1081506014,
-0.9902966022,
0.5917152166,
-1.0591142178,
0.2919044197,
0.0333554372,
0.588083446,
-0.564424336,
-0.8178154826,
-0.46501261,
0.0381402001,
-0.0392398611,
0.5612534285,
-0.0939713717,
0.4637778699,
-0.3219702542,
0.3554806411,
-0.5313051343,
0.3647225797,
-0.3228567243,
-0.0972903296,
0.2956694365,
0.2949694991,
0.3582880795,
-0.224843502,
-0.4708719552,
0.2013893574,
-0.6510049701,
0.0201262273,
-0.2368561625,
0.2657839954,
0.1772941351,
0.1866172999,
-0.3860356212,
0.6367222667,
-0.3721661866,
-0.6787652373,
0.283831656,
0.0733507276,
-0.4561120272,
0.0294624921,
0.9809157252,
0.3223565817,
0.2104894072,
-0.3141998947,
0.0602812991,
-0.0562986024,
-0.0269564036,
-0.5498377085,
-0.0941781178,
0.4309768081,
-0.5459210873,
-0.2723192871,
-0.3873561621,
-0.5080388784,
-0.6441166997,
-0.2265927047,
0.5285815597,
-0.6562752724,
-0.6487319469,
0.2767209709,
0.1393492073,
0.2000900358,
0.2037161142,
-0.5609815717,
-0.3624657691,
0.810690701,
0.8492498994,
-0.0469041429,
-0.1310052574,
0.0206541177,
0.4053630531,
-0.175999254,
0.8803996444,
-0.3184734583,
-0.5427635312,
-0.0626026914,
-0.1401030868,
-0.0790277719,
-0.9541971684,
0.5629377961,
-0.3702379465,
-0.1793068647,
0.073788017,
-0.374740839,
-0.2581495047,
0.3816569149,
-0.2917898893,
0.9853998423,
-0.0151230525,
-0.8214459419,
0.2521893084,
-0.4498551488,
-0.5082685947,
0.2260016948,
-0.279974103,
-0.4758481681,
-0.2509914935,
-0.0360445827,
1.0317701101,
-0.2742540836,
0.2356739938,
-0.3027588129,
0.0304096118,
0.0385402739,
-0.2616351545,
0.4080006182,
0.3135713935,
0.0191371776,
0.0120438049,
-0.7568200827,
0.0084483167,
-0.0079391543,
-0.4779655337,
-0.2388154119,
0.3672130108,
-0.4648578465,
0.3223737776,
0.5174825191,
-0.1942692846,
0.1502836198,
-0.5471858382,
0.4082000256,
0.3409829736,
0.5895805359,
0.18075037,
-0.7418268919,
0.447727263,
0.0904721171,
0.4277088046,
-0.092834644,
-0.7535135746,
-0.6505598426,
-0.3631302714,
-0.2221908271,
0.9029546976,
-0.717933774,
0.3668891788,
-0.2579663694,
-0.9744591117,
-0.4273115396,
-0.0038647314,
0.023120407,
0.7739677429,
0.2868921459,
-0.2485551834,
-0.6474608183,
-0.9790621996,
-0.1175217703,
-0.3294919431,
-0.2911099195,
0.1310791373,
-0.065431878,
-0.44034338,
1.1581532955,
-0.2676798701,
-0.5235366225,
-0.4459796548,
-0.091836378,
0.8651406765,
0.3392027915,
0.2110097408,
-0.4758842587,
-0.6128056049,
0.6322027445,
-0.8704046011,
-0.0452040322,
0.220448494,
-0.3431640565,
-0.2486729473,
0.288649261,
-0.5695437193,
0.2573164403,
0.3010804057,
0.0941871703,
0.7573722601,
-0.2713999152,
0.0705800131,
-1.1885480881,
-0.1297316551,
-0.1610960364,
-0.351646632,
-0.8505297899,
0.01648774,
-0.2019977272,
-0.2516432703,
-0.5597777367,
0.3338922858,
-0.3358252347,
0.0884024352,
-0.4212119579,
0.1628110409,
-0.051021602,
0.6157671809,
0.3146742284,
0.4486862421,
0.817938745,
-0.5347111821,
0.5090597868,
0.0684338436,
-0.3403019309,
0.3142960072,
-0.5516300797,
-0.202472657,
-0.1719906777,
0.1278960556,
-0.5721587539,
-0.0836199149,
0.2154556513,
-0.1616963148,
0.2335195392,
-0.1531416476,
-0.6537129879,
-0.2831333578,
0.1853605956,
-0.0898713991,
0.9976950288,
-0.3049337864,
0.8183419704,
0.3662302196,
-0.4546416402,
-0.1619829983,
-0.6094122529,
-0.2718234658,
-0.3292301297,
-0.8513055444,
0.0287602805,
0.1183952019,
-0.5025715232,
-0.2217781395,
-0.2361181974,
-0.0921152905,
-0.012160969,
0.2114166915,
0.3402440846,
-0.2478767484,
0.1454550177,
-0.2756340206,
-0.2309195697,
0.0764092878,
-0.3934788406,
0.5606172085,
-0.0998166203,
-0.3959187865,
-0.3128267527,
0.2765706182,
0.6353411078,
-0.4168688655,
0.96384269,
0.6250461936,
-0.3818004727,
-0.0180093553,
-0.4334974885,
-0.281067282,
-0.5028108954,
0.5737717748,
0.026007155,
-0.68961972,
0.6892111897,
-0.5508072376,
0.0829947665,
0.3153196573,
0.8704382777,
-0.2566155493,
0.8852578998,
0.3613388836,
-0.4160704315,
0.3190999031,
-0.0873695761,
0.8157461286,
-0.7474598289,
-0.4844350517,
-0.4211057425,
-0.1878256649,
-0.5974894166,
-0.5999591351,
1.0195944309,
0.1735861748,
-0.4072393775,
0.0065805432,
-0.5037721395,
0.1572537273,
0.3655010164,
0.4561874568,
0.4539804757,
-0.1762773395,
-0.2395034879,
0.1168982759,
-0.9150813222,
-0.5379596353,
0.495618701,
0.489631176,
0.8240271211,
0.0431048535,
0.6229385138,
0.0701203197,
0.2368068099,
-0.8386533856,
0.4093495607,
-0.1220517233,
-0.4548994005,
-0.1620378643,
-0.3727615774,
-0.819442451,
0.1056001112,
0.0216616075,
-1.0070112944,
0.205007121,
0.1244242489,
-0.4391899407,
0.4780240357,
-0.940399766,
0.7909964323,
-0.418907553,
-0.1654489338,
-0.1239942089,
-0.3793327212,
0.2926062346,
-0.0128256502,
0.7155109644,
-0.3450684249,
0.2057581395,
0.5916768909,
-0.5463466048,
1.0292431116,
-0.0514058508,
-0.3882830739,
0.3438386917,
0.0181936938,
0.7697221041,
-0.0160334669,
-0.1473926604,
0.2453530729,
-0.1494620889,
-0.1704431474,
-0.581084609,
0.6366609335,
-0.7032493353,
-0.6731694937,
-0.1552586704,
-0.2345157266,
-0.7995415926,
0.3608456254,
0.1084299535,
0.4323171675,
0.2398798317,
0.2257084697,
0.6655370593,
-0.4879072607,
0.321916908,
0.5328065753,
-0.3567656279,
-0.0687038749,
1.1405637264,
0.1189099327,
0.3647730052,
0.6197121739,
0.1792083979,
0.165787369,
-0.456147939,
0.0204671118,
-0.0363866165,
-0.7669944763,
-0.6555787325,
-0.6561636925,
-0.6533259749,
-0.1592395753,
-0.1377580911,
-0.304813683,
-0.0816736668,
0.0539924353,
-0.1150978953,
0.7874464393,
0.5947921872,
-0.0246440899,
0.4468241036,
-0.9996857047,
0.2075119466,
0.2716818154,
0.5338097811,
0.2550683022,
-0.1259700954,
-0.6474843621,
0.0994967297,
-0.2299260646,
-1.0431871414,
0.54979527,
0.0968078971,
0.7504312992,
0.582567513,
0.0803517997,
0.4031066,
-0.4974177778,
0.5247885585,
0.1322131306,
-0.4289548695,
0.4896097779,
-0.7618537545,
0.1187872887,
0.0341459028,
0.3932078779,
-0.7252632976,
-0.7974953651,
-0.4856487811,
-1.2880294323,
0.3073848784,
0.0107685858,
-0.1440721005,
0.0450942814,
0.2101407945,
-0.04694039,
-0.0577605963,
-0.4026975036,
-0.3134067059,
-0.0547927804,
-0.3524417877,
0.5149069428,
-0.1497680247,
0.079524681,
-0.0651104227,
0.9961448908,
0.0905043706,
0.4334086478,
0.2149536759,
0.2145588845,
0.2139444053,
0.4063375592,
-0.1604753435,
0.4109347463,
-0.2930133939,
-0.0346163139,
0.408480078,
-0.3956715167,
-0.1833703369,
-0.0119361039,
0.0391450413,
-0.2325425893,
0.4171102345,
0.7710348368,
0.2464770675,
-0.8094518185,
0.0208253469,
0.2873353958,
0.2903318405,
-0.3490025103,
0.4697919786,
0.44040519,
0.5064458251,
0.6075085402,
-0.0772269517,
0.0660631582,
-0.46484074,
-0.0591171756,
0.3380185366,
-0.1016155705,
0.0759992003,
0.5380746126,
0.1730180085,
-0.1800203919,
0.1880833358,
-0.0438001044,
-0.6742994785,
0.6766403317,
0.4129073024,
0.3782905638,
-0.1885240227,
-0.0261796322,
0.1954868287,
0.1645309925,
-0.0784147233,
0.2573164403,
0.3852541149,
-0.9872724414,
-0.508017838,
-0.7120265365,
-0.6123742461,
0.3760476112,
-0.3478417993,
0.2769736648,
-0.5705422759,
-0.0547050238,
-0.2455820888,
0.1520684659,
-0.639900744,
0.4010403752,
-0.0468283668,
0.690607667,
-0.3842230737,
0.8869335651,
0.6735547185,
-0.4006011784,
-1.1304502487,
-0.0100173187,
-0.2745409906,
-1.0243694782,
0.3332850039,
-0.1207620874,
0.2687993348,
0.1451390386,
0.1135145277,
-0.8023874164,
1.220485568,
0.1785590351,
-0.8534079194,
0.1249825507,
0.2582421899,
0.5940089226,
-0.0047065723,
0.2393387258,
0.6045892835,
0.6502361298,
-0.1262254715,
-1.226634264,
-0.1711434126,
-0.0674287528,
-0.1658395231,
0.2240991741,
-1.0039774179,
0.6025238037,
0.0381895192,
-0.0938781649,
-0.3493290842,
0.6560628414,
0.344558239,
-0.0307974238,
0.1284588873,
0.3509890437,
0.6290744543,
-0.0797539279,
0.8527479172,
-0.5485047698,
0.1488022059,
0.7822834849,
-0.3381774724,
0.8873836994,
0.1149174497,
-0.4639737904,
0.4560728073,
0.5611434579,
0.1939649433,
0.308811605,
-0.1118697301,
-0.6498000026,
-0.2529226243,
-0.1151208356,
-0.7331066728,
0.482483387,
0.5374649167,
-0.1781241,
-0.330178827,
0.1617447734,
0.4384092689,
-0.180352211,
-0.3602777421,
0.851398468,
0.1929268986,
-0.3288635015,
0.4090534747,
0.0981228501,
0.5800001025,
-0.7121713161,
0.1274002641,
-0.363501817,
0.2660131752,
-0.2954819202,
-0.7253484726,
0.4327598214,
-0.1525650918,
-0.3522821367,
-0.0753196701,
1.1546264887,
-0.3752668798,
-0.5094040036,
0.3094207942,
0.6363636255,
0.1727447808,
-0.0494767204,
-0.1249914244,
-0.1163426265,
-0.0487163812,
0.0124150552,
0.437096864,
0.6852544546,
-0.1154840589,
0.8845768571,
0.4931995273,
0.4353779554,
-0.156716615,
-0.0274356678,
0.8206970096,
-0.4324486554,
-0.3889549375,
-0.7518320084,
0.4794853926,
0.1963213831,
0.2716994882,
0.5642806888,
0.2214222252,
0.5259886384,
-0.0464956947,
1.3849487305,
-0.1739836633,
0.7198480964,
-0.4786759913,
1.100866437,
-0.2472202331,
0.257456094,
-0.0793459564,
-0.411013037,
-0.3017888665,
0.5682432652,
-0.3882670701,
0.0616390817,
0.3549186587,
0.6498395801,
0.1033430919,
-0.3107595146,
0.5405065417,
0.6353023052,
0.2954174876,
0.7415530682,
0.5697562099,
0.0958530679,
0.7150619626,
-0.2994306087,
-0.310374707,
-0.2765488327,
-1.0667085648,
-0.6633751988,
-0.3383128643,
-0.119933933,
-0.0038587425,
0.0012235527,
0.9896355867,
0.607971251,
-0.7868072987,
0.0107882237,
0.0040945671,
0.0952483341,
-0.2527537644,
-0.2656321228,
0.3862672448,
-0.3569791317,
-0.421906054,
0.4370453954,
0.4321572483,
-0.0943605006,
-0.2850723863,
-0.0960438848,
0.1599961072,
-0.0832052976,
0.5188214779,
0.2798330486,
-0.3027011752,
-0.1030436605,
-0.1602067202,
0.1832525879,
0.1935340613,
0.6506471038,
-0.9103598595,
0.1343888938,
0.5227190852,
0.5852758288,
0.0172390305,
-0.3222861886,
0.8817642331,
-0.7622156143,
0.2959039211,
0.259483397,
0.7631248236,
0.3236395121,
-0.6987420321,
0.3229076266,
0.2067664266,
-0.7795559764,
-0.4594690502,
0.2992957234,
-0.7846841216,
-0.0318835042,
1.0844308138,
-0.2030007541,
-0.1105573624,
-0.1316368431,
-0.4419327378,
0.6418424249,
-0.345593214,
0.8227288127,
0.459048897,
-0.4249324799,
-0.2141761482,
-0.7428237796,
0.4286589921,
0.0990848392,
-1.0359554291,
-0.0188386645,
0.0630554855,
0.2071754783,
0.0867577791,
0.6079337001,
-0.0643156841,
0.1317996681,
-0.3337925673,
0.2852812707,
-0.1075786203,
0.0429341458,
0.2166251838,
0.0113157099,
0.4460365772,
-0.0048462506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03523v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03523v2
|
Sig-Networks Toolkit: Signature Networks for Longitudinal Language Modelling
| 2023-12-06T14:34:30 | 2024-02-06T12:14:19 |
Talia Tseriotou, Ryan Sze-Yin Chan, Adam Tsakalidis, Iman Munire Bilal, Elena Kochkina, Terry Lyons, Maria Liakata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We present an open-source, pip installable toolkit, Sig-Networks, the first
of its kind for longitudinal language modelling. A central focus is the
incorporation of Signature-based Neural Network models, which have recently
shown success in temporal tasks. We apply and extend published research
providing a full suite of signature-based models. Their components can be used
as PyTorch building blocks in future architectures. Sig-Networks enables
task-agnostic dataset plug-in, seamless pre-processing for sequential data,
parameter flexibility, automated tuning across a range of models. We examine
signature networks under three different NLP tasks of varying temporal
granularity: counselling conversations, rumour stance switch and mood changes
in social media threads, showing SOTA performance in all three, and provide
guidance for future tasks. We release the Toolkit as a PyTorch package with an
introductory video, Git repositories for preprocessing and modelling including
sample notebooks on the modeled NLP tasks.
|
[
-0.0747906119,
-0.6672653556,
0.2629231811,
0.4204422534,
-0.191212222,
-0.2665217519,
-0.06912902,
-0.1748819649,
0.3995645344,
0.6257137656,
-0.7714485526,
-0.5795984268,
-0.7619856596,
-0.2503572702,
-0.6648550034,
1.1460772753,
0.2282938957,
0.1600189209,
0.1798486412,
-0.3876979053,
-0.1937036067,
-0.2642506063,
-1.136534214,
-0.6948577166,
0.790928185,
-0.0128242048,
0.5705827475,
0.4421112239,
0.38159132,
0.1602918655,
-0.4080635905,
-0.0967766717,
-0.4752057493,
0.1724191457,
-0.1853366345,
-0.115101479,
-0.770003438,
0.1469528228,
0.6506186128,
0.970710218,
0.0692231506,
0.5556696653,
0.2797643542,
0.291100353,
-0.5034501553,
0.359462589,
-0.5191140175,
0.1952968687,
-0.2695403695,
-0.1022175029,
-0.4033732414,
-0.2576040924,
0.101029478,
-0.14234519,
-0.1248286963,
-0.1533136815,
0.6263592839,
0.1852734089,
-0.5977806449,
-0.3227773011,
-0.7390486598,
0.3963534832,
-1.0474454165,
0.2891317308,
0.1876590401,
0.0418197438,
-0.1995076388,
-1.045199275,
-0.0181033742,
-0.3811455369,
-0.3534438312,
0.0249146055,
0.0361485295,
0.2276602834,
0.4295583367,
0.4828849733,
-0.8941553235,
0.1952505112,
-0.5139440894,
-0.4315251708,
0.4313137233,
0.3582240641,
0.2365800291,
-0.0356156714,
-0.2487633526,
0.3477793336,
-0.8505368233,
-0.0861061588,
0.5953082442,
0.4929049313,
-0.1806392372,
0.5688339472,
-0.0448097959,
0.7052941322,
-0.2102445513,
0.1258327812,
-0.0036152431,
-0.1847543418,
-0.1783321202,
0.1056780443,
1.0937749147,
-0.1809943467,
-0.1492732316,
-0.143741563,
-0.0191449784,
0.1169152111,
-0.0875340551,
-0.6743639708,
-0.6827870607,
0.0460524485,
-0.4972510934,
-0.3825795352,
-0.1376128048,
-0.4750734866,
-0.4483812153,
-0.4119351804,
0.5438194871,
-0.1140154377,
-0.4797081351,
0.295417726,
0.1362680048,
0.0672285333,
-0.1120868102,
-0.5294272304,
0.4892935455,
0.6550596952,
1.0212029219,
-0.0023281511,
-0.4421551228,
-0.688061893,
-0.1232027039,
-0.052700486,
0.3249266446,
-0.2832157016,
-0.1706981659,
-0.1588503569,
0.185475871,
-0.1360724866,
-0.1481308788,
0.1995739043,
-0.4462612569,
0.3812984824,
0.1063963026,
-0.4164616168,
-0.0774163753,
0.1453792751,
-0.8369656801,
1.3710300922,
-0.025736535,
-0.6858948469,
0.1445468217,
-0.7512332201,
-0.5325521827,
0.1082878634,
-0.0179394055,
-0.484903872,
-0.1819053739,
0.1762230098,
0.8198292851,
-0.2927500904,
0.2868232727,
-0.2983923256,
-0.2517437935,
0.1633439362,
-0.2121706754,
1.1820878983,
0.2171314806,
-0.5137147903,
0.1701379269,
-0.7695971131,
-0.1127696186,
-0.077649273,
-0.2611082494,
-0.0549712703,
-0.2749966979,
0.0689569935,
0.2987776399,
0.4028649628,
-0.301195085,
0.2091666907,
-0.2833846211,
0.8551585078,
0.5099146962,
0.0421134345,
0.2973456383,
-0.0227665007,
0.6783244014,
0.2342043817,
0.3248906136,
-0.3575871289,
-0.8308492899,
-0.3641334176,
0.0150253503,
0.2331839651,
0.5160284638,
-0.3846846521,
0.5095466375,
-0.4151383936,
-0.720633626,
0.0483611301,
0.0642641336,
0.594666481,
0.2197572738,
0.0182409137,
-0.7616728544,
-0.5492388606,
-0.7104376554,
-0.2775380313,
-0.5679473281,
0.1643024832,
0.1930325031,
0.4728438258,
-0.0946450084,
0.770808816,
-0.3578743935,
-0.2003092021,
-0.2359417528,
0.4937593043,
0.2763471901,
0.3062129021,
0.2995725274,
-0.6260757446,
-0.2306932509,
0.0236218143,
-0.5223694444,
-0.4509675503,
-0.1259350926,
0.2205159962,
-0.3735912144,
0.873116672,
-0.361621052,
0.2854884565,
1.0539553165,
-0.5839602351,
0.7144750953,
0.1537474394,
-0.0133036356,
-1.1326498985,
0.4057781398,
-0.0519306064,
-0.4255979359,
-0.7260605693,
-0.2251221091,
-0.2247142047,
-0.286033392,
-0.719345212,
0.9294681549,
-0.3011431694,
-0.2793149352,
0.0488168783,
-0.1337712109,
-0.1452355236,
0.4531491101,
-0.3689484894,
0.6747683287,
0.501912415,
-0.4576972425,
0.2753409445,
0.2348056585,
-0.119391039,
0.1413775682,
-0.6594673991,
0.3229841292,
0.0154561084,
-0.0214272235,
-0.7165370584,
-0.1336148828,
0.6110867262,
-0.5711166859,
0.1915559471,
-0.5257314444,
-0.310475409,
-0.2326397747,
0.0784593672,
0.3411836624,
0.3005664647,
-0.3098944128,
0.8710163236,
0.3224675357,
-0.1896976382,
-0.5529343486,
-0.6533192396,
0.2776533663,
-0.3233654201,
-0.5190515518,
0.2716358006,
0.1201634035,
-0.0381763205,
0.1724880785,
0.1926394254,
-0.1213077307,
0.074625887,
0.6050156355,
-0.2236655504,
-0.5870266557,
0.0707851723,
-0.168186754,
-0.2985208333,
-0.0442689434,
-0.6532441974,
0.6598131061,
-0.3342674077,
-0.2014875412,
-0.2362229824,
0.0694069713,
0.8361324668,
-0.3639629483,
0.9271718264,
0.8522549272,
-0.4323950708,
-0.1873952299,
-0.4294144213,
-0.4575355649,
-0.4292930961,
0.3153078556,
-0.2174854279,
-1.2057950497,
0.7994294763,
-0.3803568184,
-0.0188053213,
0.2853754163,
0.7154732943,
0.0173391234,
0.7260055542,
0.4444025457,
-0.4405086935,
0.7569975853,
-0.2351862192,
0.5889630914,
-0.6768787503,
0.0473465659,
-0.3378104568,
-0.3657754362,
-0.1577895433,
-0.0288670193,
0.4134149849,
0.2131586075,
-0.3092204034,
0.7179211974,
-0.5035141706,
0.3178490996,
0.3859136403,
0.0978397578,
0.1186540797,
-0.1706650108,
0.0349250436,
0.0041765519,
-0.8025540709,
-0.7016845345,
1.0232946873,
0.3268321157,
0.5236256719,
-0.3444600701,
0.4087813199,
0.2541281283,
0.1790422052,
-0.4827541709,
0.8398481011,
-0.3323869705,
-0.6835678816,
-0.4075001776,
-0.3445244133,
-0.9684837461,
-0.2813296318,
-0.0379875489,
-1.1372948885,
-0.1963889301,
0.2312125117,
-0.3163332939,
0.4507479668,
-0.3717387617,
1.2032232285,
-0.0663121864,
-0.3277994692,
-0.0501668863,
-0.7237209678,
0.3803860843,
0.2393027395,
-0.1458985507,
-0.381149292,
0.3250173032,
0.9294753671,
-0.2236029357,
1.1251785755,
-0.2112149,
0.2003440857,
0.3712804615,
0.2667937279,
0.5556150675,
0.0649063587,
-0.1914200634,
0.2224379629,
0.3380761743,
-0.0844427124,
-0.4892730415,
0.5742773414,
-0.5436884165,
-0.0413284935,
-0.2016495019,
-0.4452880323,
0.1152485833,
0.2411720008,
0.1165585369,
0.7667168379,
-0.1756995767,
0.3738912046,
0.4727736115,
0.0860540196,
0.2996277213,
0.2283904701,
-0.4093589783,
-0.2191767991,
0.547257483,
0.0816084743,
0.0387162566,
0.141704455,
0.4023447335,
-0.1179511771,
-0.6110459566,
-0.2725136578,
0.3153509498,
-0.847928226,
0.132579267,
-0.7268750072,
-0.5194250941,
-0.4485550523,
0.128084451,
-0.4247284532,
-0.5009217858,
-0.2155967057,
-0.038898997,
0.5766965747,
0.8358789682,
-0.0603430793,
0.7652746439,
-0.8139635324,
0.1004380956,
0.3410156071,
0.3499418795,
-0.2233251184,
-0.3464922905,
-0.4566240609,
-0.266551137,
-0.0829951093,
-1.0299981833,
0.1802102476,
0.275823921,
0.3708365262,
0.260217011,
-0.4415726066,
0.3648037314,
-0.1634029299,
1.1931838989,
0.0642279387,
-0.8568733335,
0.4945717752,
-0.80984056,
0.2573930919,
0.4529014528,
0.3328919113,
-0.8497279286,
-0.3026708961,
-0.6181496382,
-0.9500995278,
0.5411753058,
0.2740698159,
0.0886614993,
0.2139874846,
0.650380969,
0.1173007488,
0.2503201067,
-1.0619392395,
-0.2105131447,
0.0110758552,
-0.357875824,
-0.0312366392,
-0.2239924669,
-0.0615540333,
-0.0666526109,
1.1140263081,
-0.3271303475,
0.2138614357,
-0.294296205,
-0.1029313877,
0.2460074723,
0.0590719655,
0.2826600373,
0.493013382,
0.0282460954,
0.0593007877,
0.1935672611,
-0.6712000966,
0.1850128919,
-0.0203827564,
-0.321759671,
-0.0377300978,
0.329865396,
0.9564564824,
0.3358653486,
-0.0757701993,
0.4505302012,
-0.0121108145,
-0.0867118686,
-0.3509498239,
0.0187893715,
0.3851297796,
0.248521477,
-0.1961399168,
-0.1011290401,
0.1234652624,
-0.3705891669,
0.1358852237,
0.0815479383,
-0.8044071198,
-0.5427156687,
0.7779640555,
-0.2394315451,
-0.4955511391,
0.531852901,
-0.2141712457,
-0.4717231691,
0.4907731712,
0.3012244403,
1.0430010557,
-0.1312439591,
0.3061127365,
0.489692837,
0.2692968249,
-0.3197994232,
0.3812672794,
-0.008633812,
-0.6067079306,
-0.4647047818,
-0.5708788633,
-0.3104725182,
0.4175335467,
-0.6298178434,
0.5165720582,
-0.5383521914,
-0.4130758643,
-0.139532432,
-0.318833679,
-0.6786065102,
0.4098556042,
-0.052459605,
0.4799692929,
-1.3083406687,
0.8911314011,
0.8543894887,
-0.2606776357,
-1.0218845606,
-0.2259493172,
0.3297596276,
-0.5833448172,
0.6535140276,
0.0525913127,
-0.254506886,
0.3735895157,
-0.2845745385,
-0.8037614822,
1.1480835676,
0.3086994588,
-0.3605467379,
-0.2831279933,
0.3233200908,
0.5337647796,
-0.3016237319,
0.1983151883,
0.8173559308,
0.2789380252,
-0.0474644378,
-0.8962541223,
-0.0404153578,
-0.3560836613,
-0.2001521736,
0.3197416365,
-0.3885679841,
0.7496327162,
0.5577090979,
-0.0679868534,
0.1576660424,
0.3596660495,
0.012580283,
0.2528397441,
0.4320858121,
0.6390289664,
0.5287362337,
-0.3208900392,
0.5806099772,
-0.6356221437,
0.2513355613,
1.2364515066,
-0.1290326416,
0.4987683296,
0.3798258007,
-0.1110593602,
0.3205753267,
0.3958156109,
0.2091433704,
0.1899128705,
0.2411284447,
-0.3031221926,
-0.0521218367,
-0.1489086896,
-0.1821868122,
0.3265898228,
0.6174122095,
-0.5600145459,
-0.0750108138,
-0.0229562838,
0.1392049789,
-0.1030618101,
-0.3340323865,
0.7239493132,
0.4834099412,
-0.3422694206,
-0.1004412398,
-0.0822920799,
0.5615414977,
-0.9172082543,
0.3983173966,
-0.1186784133,
0.1709916592,
-0.2550699711,
-0.7034560442,
0.6585741639,
-0.3619504869,
-0.0174309593,
-0.5586639047,
0.9532612562,
-0.4138788879,
-0.3733616471,
0.4409913421,
0.5740537643,
0.3544676006,
-0.0741231292,
-0.8343893886,
0.0358527713,
-0.4684399664,
-0.5110933781,
0.0352802128,
0.342243731,
-0.1949795932,
0.5061209798,
0.5231827497,
0.5970596671,
0.440530926,
0.3126786351,
0.6304765344,
-0.4116404355,
-0.6699681282,
-0.7720703483,
0.7438869476,
0.0600691475,
-0.5276100039,
0.6160857081,
0.4907380641,
0.6742976904,
0.011152206,
0.6016116738,
-0.0496658497,
0.3579562008,
-0.6311249137,
0.8733660579,
-0.335070461,
0.1117227897,
-0.2828370631,
-0.9578050971,
-0.7987030745,
0.279139787,
-0.6309671402,
-0.0788523033,
0.7560705543,
1.3501614332,
-0.1556525975,
0.2531474531,
0.2703848779,
0.2772605717,
0.418961376,
0.5397673845,
0.8651816249,
-0.6254543066,
0.415751785,
-0.0250534117,
0.1370162219,
-0.0801854953,
-1.090349555,
-1.1418396235,
-0.9799509048,
-0.7057429552,
-0.5372026563,
0.1879669279,
0.8270981908,
0.9552637935,
-0.8269300461,
-0.1996435225,
-0.1758733094,
-0.2661571503,
-0.2712691724,
-0.1491933763,
0.3135941625,
-0.0345440097,
-0.1259599328,
0.5427398086,
0.5449681878,
-0.0045906943,
-0.5898195505,
-0.0534957871,
-0.0270585511,
-0.1004133075,
0.3668954968,
0.4889739454,
-0.6011929512,
-0.147218734,
-0.0349889919,
-0.0959975049,
0.0095421569,
1.3057221174,
-0.6988579631,
0.1753422022,
0.6643770337,
0.5254741907,
0.6891857386,
-0.5993407369,
0.5232767463,
-0.8923001289,
0.3496642113,
0.3426313996,
0.574238658,
0.3434293568,
-0.3789992929,
0.5400027633,
0.1354519278,
-0.5680845976,
-0.6219018102,
0.2735386789,
-0.5978525877,
0.0872848406,
0.9996619821,
-0.3396230638,
-0.2544262111,
-0.2981419563,
-0.226090923,
0.3149099052,
0.1056867018,
0.5954540372,
0.6763364673,
0.2117933929,
-0.3370885253,
-0.3819849491,
0.4293867946,
0.2828436494,
-0.6682616472,
-0.1114534661,
0.2934245467,
0.2287354171,
-0.0307200309,
1.0129897594,
-0.4665727615,
0.2712890208,
0.0373926163,
-0.0144045958,
-0.2824753821,
-0.628361702,
-0.5615586638,
0.3556106985,
0.0427263677,
0.2830583751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03483v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03483v1
|
Exploring Answer Information Methods for Question Generation with Transformers
| 2023-12-06T13:26:16 | 2023-12-06T13:26:16 |
Talha Chafekar, Aafiya Hussain, Grishma Sharma, Deepak Sharma
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
There has been a lot of work in question generation where different methods
to provide target answers as input, have been employed. This experimentation
has been mostly carried out for RNN based models. We use three different
methods and their combinations for incorporating answer information and explore
their effect on several automatic evaluation metrics. The methods that are used
are answer prompting, using a custom product method using answer embeddings and
encoder outputs, choosing sentences from the input paragraph that have answer
related information, and using a separate cross-attention attention block in
the decoder which attends to the answer. We observe that answer prompting
without any additional modes obtains the best scores across rouge, meteor
scores. Additionally, we use a custom metric to calculate how many of the
generated questions have the same answer, as the answer which is used to
generate them.
|
[
-0.8411230445,
-1.0439945459,
0.5199426413,
0.1294579506,
0.0264134966,
-0.0640024692,
-0.0793004483,
-0.3889591396,
0.3665896654,
0.3879137933,
-0.7315964699,
0.0462041199,
-0.2866651118,
0.3686049581,
-0.3563460708,
1.1137880087,
0.0824619532,
0.2011713833,
-0.531504035,
-0.0076169302,
-0.4463531673,
-0.4891282916,
-0.7570741177,
-0.1816003919,
0.7513871193,
0.5395454168,
0.5694327354,
0.4982206523,
0.9328483939,
0.3076609969,
0.0283056181,
0.2299282104,
-0.1944881827,
0.2995833457,
-0.1472779661,
-0.5838550329,
-0.1975030154,
0.0454325378,
0.187530607,
0.4776198268,
0.0315794423,
1.0152335167,
0.002990002,
0.0504535064,
-0.8463478088,
-0.1087394133,
-0.3758311272,
0.4729920328,
0.1150040403,
-0.6971265078,
-0.4552308023,
-0.6062574983,
0.0943558365,
-0.3169058561,
0.680088222,
-0.0573366359,
0.665096283,
0.3905161321,
-0.3592499495,
-0.5553436875,
-1.2061634064,
0.6450631618,
-0.4620715976,
0.0718609914,
0.2249376327,
0.6274074912,
0.2542841136,
-0.8551996946,
-0.583414495,
0.1497379988,
-0.3109601438,
0.7425800562,
-0.2263041884,
-0.169193089,
0.498844862,
0.329492867,
-0.7319005132,
-0.1617126018,
-0.4444732368,
-0.0098818559,
0.7690958977,
0.5278223753,
-0.0232523326,
-0.5869780779,
-0.2495745271,
-0.5150313377,
-0.3986352682,
0.3356599808,
0.6687635779,
-0.097154744,
0.1250792295,
0.9657846689,
-0.1712768227,
0.6718869209,
0.3961751163,
0.4130875468,
0.0403759331,
-0.5929853916,
0.0750579536,
-0.2252960652,
0.8726431727,
0.5334603786,
0.1483624429,
-0.1488380581,
-0.1322763711,
-0.1737843454,
0.553825438,
-0.6982697248,
0.0894435272,
0.3988835812,
-0.4490165114,
-0.4050858021,
0.1931986064,
-0.9505284429,
-0.1225959212,
-0.2177422345,
0.6788339615,
-0.023866076,
-0.1452693492,
-0.1700299233,
-0.660887301,
0.6821560264,
0.1573291719,
-0.837656796,
0.3874103725,
0.2928442955,
0.3618359268,
-0.1700912565,
0.0461537652,
-0.7406328917,
-0.1387336403,
-0.2541872263,
0.9498839378,
-0.2667400837,
-0.4099270403,
-0.0788839683,
-0.1630291641,
-0.1320770532,
-0.744358182,
0.0770995468,
-0.7922816873,
0.6216334105,
-0.3388789594,
-0.5496247411,
-0.150305897,
0.4169898927,
-0.733782351,
1.1249729395,
0.3510173261,
-0.8699535131,
0.0964361355,
-0.7630553842,
-0.2995083332,
0.0000043874,
-0.1398338974,
-0.1448442638,
0.31384027,
0.468069911,
0.2786565721,
-0.4600842297,
0.0982507989,
0.2341112494,
-0.078693293,
0.7860715985,
-0.6494628191,
0.4289263785,
0.2290451676,
-0.3249350488,
0.116847761,
-0.4804344773,
0.2962824404,
0.2927089334,
-0.1286413819,
0.3033218682,
-0.2112548202,
0.0985184684,
0.2165272534,
0.3868397474,
-0.7310963273,
-0.1597199142,
-0.1471245885,
0.0591520853,
0.6641331911,
0.670347333,
0.1836163849,
-0.5535385013,
0.9593282342,
-0.078561537,
0.4385979474,
-0.2323985547,
-0.710308969,
-0.8849080801,
0.692694664,
0.4291967452,
0.4901863039,
-0.5697963238,
0.2245519608,
-0.0713277757,
-0.5402673483,
-0.7141544819,
-0.1154649332,
0.2504901588,
0.8416848779,
0.6155128479,
-0.3549180329,
-0.6029568315,
-1.1642152071,
-0.1768401116,
-0.269090265,
-0.2194069326,
0.4743843377,
0.4489858747,
0.2253315747,
1.1920735836,
-0.9224117994,
0.4435325563,
-0.7134231925,
0.1309690922,
0.1545525193,
0.14035137,
0.4161982238,
-0.8492013812,
-0.4743974209,
-0.2680965364,
-0.7586733103,
0.0774114728,
-0.1314914525,
-0.0223562326,
-0.3081963956,
0.2379782051,
-0.6195864081,
0.4260532558,
0.2787203491,
0.0885591432,
0.5969616771,
0.0198075511,
0.481954664,
-1.3133263588,
0.1640673131,
-0.0252334103,
-0.2408782691,
-0.805066824,
0.2324407995,
-0.0374416895,
-0.0455144122,
-0.5827211142,
0.6118730903,
0.0942765251,
-0.0305807292,
-0.1673126072,
0.3935753107,
0.226474613,
0.4084213376,
0.0086637875,
0.6596013308,
0.0165109988,
-0.7199619412,
0.7592594624,
0.4542202353,
-0.1865840852,
0.2631495297,
-1.0077369213,
0.4805117548,
-0.5497342944,
0.0715560541,
-1.1536848545,
-0.3245646358,
0.3489094675,
-0.6754191518,
0.1140955687,
-0.0171241537,
-0.5517982841,
-0.7126938701,
-0.1680658013,
0.4379677474,
0.8197096586,
-0.4806392491,
0.4988261759,
0.0062701609,
-0.2508040369,
-0.4700109363,
-0.5773769021,
-0.2087356299,
-0.3480215073,
-0.7080212831,
0.1453068554,
-0.4860710204,
-0.2513813972,
0.0585832745,
-0.0465526059,
0.0306659937,
-0.0866191387,
-0.0815182179,
0.1630244702,
-0.3935143948,
0.1336079836,
0.0088119712,
-0.206395939,
0.2773464918,
0.1865265965,
0.6871538758,
0.1587275714,
-0.3982467353,
-0.3154672384,
0.6351575851,
0.1480480283,
-0.5539594889,
0.6396034956,
0.591950655,
-0.1135594547,
-0.0975033194,
-0.5737242699,
-0.7081503272,
-0.496050328,
0.2974891067,
-0.1240528226,
-0.4637631178,
0.5806056261,
0.3395305276,
0.2473091632,
0.4423026741,
0.7277902961,
-0.1747282594,
1.3961393833,
0.2192907929,
0.4399673343,
0.2334301472,
-0.5529503226,
0.1469377428,
-0.8476959467,
-0.4753117859,
-0.5823284984,
-0.623909533,
-0.296590358,
-0.5573179126,
0.459824115,
-0.0581749007,
-0.0210911129,
0.5592395067,
-0.4749082029,
0.2794528008,
0.5776498318,
0.1344486624,
0.2161904275,
-0.2313437611,
0.2577938735,
-0.0136930235,
-0.8495867252,
-0.207047537,
1.3098822832,
0.1863295883,
0.722102344,
-0.2030757666,
0.7179620266,
-0.0673795715,
0.5617517829,
-0.9244834781,
0.5097042322,
0.3656114638,
-0.7549167275,
-0.3142848611,
-0.5509695411,
-0.8647677302,
0.1502874196,
-0.0958733186,
-0.5274503827,
-0.0468610525,
-0.0380892605,
-0.5221723318,
-0.1303083897,
-0.6165582538,
0.6535093784,
-0.2335255146,
-0.1789430976,
-0.0348172709,
-0.5664904118,
-0.0319960639,
0.1443529129,
-0.2269328833,
0.3499106467,
0.1799378693,
0.8680643439,
-0.170495823,
0.3996578753,
-0.1209008396,
0.0824659839,
0.7043941617,
-0.153476432,
0.3777379692,
0.3338647783,
-0.2270780653,
-0.3322876692,
-0.294252634,
0.0134216221,
-1.2445846796,
0.360008508,
-0.6164416671,
-0.9032590985,
-0.0206900015,
-0.8163211942,
-0.3550901413,
-0.051899869,
0.8525939584,
0.7303512692,
0.0411887504,
0.2776921988,
0.6000686884,
-0.2950755954,
0.532423079,
0.4447686374,
-0.1574845165,
-0.3940931857,
0.4207189679,
0.0415626131,
0.4105857909,
0.4668665528,
0.4461810291,
-0.5560218096,
-0.0756604224,
-0.6233554482,
0.139077425,
-0.8052423596,
-0.4462319911,
-0.6914101839,
-0.6538145542,
-0.4273641109,
0.2079556435,
-0.3105368316,
-0.596139133,
-0.014838594,
-0.3477154672,
0.3074401021,
0.899165988,
0.2444753796,
0.2168865949,
-0.8482285142,
0.5284889936,
0.4975962341,
0.0082897302,
0.0401211232,
-0.3272945881,
-0.3392744958,
0.2798937261,
-0.6356452107,
-1.2086464167,
-0.031898357,
-0.148197189,
0.6501124501,
0.1046793014,
0.0632331893,
0.6218530536,
-0.4670137465,
1.0224914551,
0.073727943,
-0.5226873755,
0.7871696353,
0.0039779502,
0.4678691626,
0.4448634386,
0.4783475995,
-0.4854967296,
-0.7663641572,
-0.7650689483,
-0.5820740461,
0.5481719375,
0.4328733981,
0.5318275094,
-0.2614121735,
0.2770237923,
0.1524199545,
0.1575469822,
-0.486427933,
-0.5841014981,
-0.1232849881,
-0.3064142466,
-0.0643733665,
0.2929603159,
-0.2610983253,
-0.1419427395,
0.1832356006,
-0.0688877702,
0.3202397227,
0.5041847229,
-0.0344753638,
-0.3331589401,
0.222544536,
0.3452511132,
0.4907504022,
0.0589816198,
-0.1734847128,
0.3449776471,
-0.3269447088,
0.0444578566,
-0.1843401045,
-0.4145540297,
0.1782872677,
0.2101943791,
0.5983460546,
-0.2464242429,
-0.3961058855,
0.4962833226,
-0.4162786007,
-0.2902037203,
-0.2841299474,
0.3856068552,
0.0027739389,
0.0322936885,
0.3977300227,
0.3345529437,
0.217768535,
-0.2631238401,
0.1755425185,
0.3717091382,
-0.7653768659,
-0.2862076461,
0.6575897336,
-0.0767434686,
-0.6508481503,
0.6391091943,
0.18702209,
-0.2590149939,
0.9434664249,
0.7695595622,
0.8793928027,
-0.4367029667,
0.6324827075,
0.4859816432,
0.2099972367,
0.2780325413,
0.5440104008,
-0.0840683058,
-0.5711222887,
-0.5048742294,
-0.5049453974,
-0.5130847692,
0.2736036777,
-0.9091954827,
0.2502887547,
-0.1767100543,
-0.3945232928,
-0.1555488259,
-0.4215647876,
-1.0908626318,
0.3592963517,
-0.1398167908,
0.8449987769,
-0.6161746979,
-0.2049330026,
0.7099115849,
-0.6068361402,
-1.1038631201,
0.2960473597,
-0.4162268639,
-0.2655568123,
0.5912586451,
0.2440661639,
-0.0535086244,
0.2219312936,
-0.4840745032,
-0.7868901491,
0.923635304,
0.1614498496,
0.2268492877,
-0.1593982875,
0.5930142403,
0.6946820021,
-0.3500007093,
0.8588944077,
0.3258225918,
0.547947824,
0.0108190645,
-0.5775597692,
-0.0648524165,
-0.5557592511,
-0.2288482487,
0.1461155415,
-0.5014792681,
0.5086101294,
-0.0563552566,
-0.1224455684,
0.1802811623,
0.5215722919,
0.1145749018,
0.1596553028,
0.4435074329,
0.3476690352,
0.3699331582,
-0.0721067786,
1.3352866173,
-0.289101243,
0.2730590999,
0.9412651062,
0.0492403097,
0.7189671993,
0.5296456218,
-0.0173080992,
0.6253432631,
0.5275212526,
-0.1776493937,
0.3105233908,
0.3729208708,
-0.0416931175,
-0.0688873455,
-0.1661722213,
-0.3010599911,
0.6235084534,
0.0547873154,
-0.3735312223,
-0.2984843254,
0.1084582135,
-0.4439330697,
-0.1501044184,
0.0736907348,
0.9583564401,
-0.0666402653,
-1.1619280577,
0.2429659069,
-0.0277541019,
0.1153948084,
-0.5708685517,
-0.0432175137,
-0.4602077603,
-0.0247623343,
-0.2923922241,
-0.8902848959,
0.2540573478,
0.1758218855,
-0.2290314138,
-0.2566819787,
0.3339718878,
-0.2656043172,
-0.5964520574,
0.0162058398,
0.701004982,
-0.1081478596,
0.2746429741,
-0.4077880681,
-0.6407225132,
-0.2557356954,
-0.6219038367,
-0.091064997,
0.0876435265,
0.1814669669,
0.5777309537,
0.4463922977,
-0.129275009,
0.3692491055,
0.1939832419,
0.72383672,
-0.3800986409,
-0.4367293119,
-0.5944580436,
0.9405896664,
-0.2546223998,
-0.5557245612,
1.1943315268,
0.8951013088,
0.5538835526,
-0.3679274619,
0.7938719392,
-0.0846506134,
0.38791278,
-0.2868333161,
0.3865483403,
-0.4633511603,
0.0713964403,
-0.4293033481,
-1.3960599899,
-0.0185435023,
0.2487776279,
-0.2972274721,
0.0452530608,
0.8558983803,
0.792291224,
-0.1003121957,
0.3663537502,
-0.1164391339,
-0.4058896601,
0.2864083946,
0.345533818,
1.2364574671,
-0.7660350204,
0.7355602384,
-0.4311382771,
-0.0878266841,
-0.0417623669,
-0.2865066826,
-0.6384519339,
-0.4968066216,
-0.3052958846,
-0.5113021731,
-0.3689433336,
0.5825429559,
0.4633696675,
-0.7135614157,
-0.2890314162,
-0.0589484088,
-0.0363917574,
-0.1919184923,
-0.3069427311,
0.2057590187,
-0.4413851798,
-0.765080452,
0.2870522738,
0.0971687362,
-0.0161821917,
-0.2760227919,
0.1438034922,
0.2770044804,
0.2185685188,
0.2123565674,
-0.0958804414,
-0.2773499191,
-0.5521442294,
0.8604946733,
0.0238991044,
0.2236508876,
1.128364563,
-0.8403211236,
0.394005537,
0.867438972,
0.5372331738,
0.7294037938,
0.5213916898,
0.936868012,
-0.7671026587,
-0.2045711279,
0.5631595254,
0.0187369864,
0.2990860045,
-0.3344698846,
0.3892664611,
-0.2495799214,
-0.5133024454,
-0.4992666841,
0.6697843075,
-0.5833579898,
0.0903367177,
1.0351566076,
0.1738895923,
-0.1069840789,
-0.191689238,
-0.1867047697,
0.3303915262,
0.081284076,
0.568354845,
0.4803055823,
-0.538353622,
-0.1050293148,
-0.5649338365,
0.3243799508,
0.493514806,
-0.921993494,
-0.3142515123,
0.0141481217,
0.2068582624,
0.6058613658,
0.1866453439,
-0.3284434676,
0.5038095117,
0.0365698412,
-0.2388145775,
0.0950070396,
-0.2890363634,
-0.1649218947,
0.2068870962,
-0.1837726831,
0.019410897
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03480v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03480v1
|
AMR Parsing is Far from Solved: GrAPES, the Granular AMR Parsing Evaluation Suite
| 2023-12-06T13:19:56 | 2023-12-06T13:19:56 |
Jonas Groschwitz, Shay B. Cohen, Lucia Donatelli, Meaghan Fowlie
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, J.5
|
We present the Granular AMR Parsing Evaluation Suite (GrAPES), a challenge
set for Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR) parsing with accompanying
evaluation metrics. AMR parsers now obtain high scores on the standard AMR
evaluation metric Smatch, close to or even above reported inter-annotator
agreement. But that does not mean that AMR parsing is solved; in fact, human
evaluation in previous work indicates that current parsers still quite
frequently make errors on node labels or graph structure that substantially
distort sentence meaning. Here, we provide an evaluation suite that tests AMR
parsers on a range of phenomena of practical, technical, and linguistic
interest. Our 36 categories range from seen and unseen labels, to structural
generalization, to coreference. GrAPES reveals in depth the abilities and
shortcomings of current AMR parsers.
|
[
-0.3224397004,
-0.9535983801,
0.5114203691,
0.3677556813,
-0.2496193647,
0.4681074321,
-0.3724353909,
-0.7685433626,
0.3394179344,
0.1668534875,
-0.6149584055,
-0.1546795368,
-0.7534862757,
0.3153760731,
-0.2774802744,
1.167504549,
-0.0567566231,
-0.185101524,
-0.4961291552,
-0.3706126809,
-0.3964764178,
-0.6770992279,
-0.4592248797,
-0.5912793279,
0.3004278541,
0.2719792724,
0.6297901869,
0.6151177287,
0.6805003285,
0.3330166936,
-0.3676429987,
0.0446096547,
-0.0024723117,
0.1707281172,
-0.1775246561,
-0.3603170216,
-0.5274235606,
-0.0064810296,
0.4859095216,
0.7926583886,
0.1800986081,
0.4486246705,
-0.3230044246,
1.0442458391,
-0.6373946667,
0.3114061952,
-0.6849347949,
0.2308703065,
-0.4448112249,
-0.0989472121,
-0.3296106458,
-0.0577048883,
-0.2505292892,
-0.4419331849,
0.315592587,
0.2281033546,
0.9429034591,
0.3851183951,
-0.3368913531,
-0.3677946627,
-0.6786624789,
0.7698027492,
-0.1343911737,
-0.1002261043,
0.1261346489,
0.7193617225,
-0.0926332995,
-0.6264918447,
-0.5136930943,
-0.1822936982,
-0.1682857722,
-0.132762447,
-0.659478724,
-0.1212818101,
0.242822051,
0.8096951246,
-0.1674242616,
-0.4660056233,
-0.2586592734,
-0.0819235295,
0.5976135731,
0.2715488374,
0.281537652,
-0.4235821664,
-0.308724165,
-0.2559768856,
-0.3236919045,
0.4093293846,
0.1249632165,
0.1182703525,
-0.0599621385,
0.778377533,
-0.3742832243,
0.8357844353,
-0.1140904576,
0.3331796825,
0.6780071855,
-0.2185231149,
-0.1565964818,
-0.086288318,
0.7969639897,
0.2042621821,
0.6242982745,
-0.1336624175,
-0.4940420389,
0.5424801707,
0.3170525134,
-0.236639142,
-0.5268663764,
0.212622717,
-0.2764755189,
-0.3732888103,
0.1181059703,
-0.7452115417,
-0.3596492112,
0.0233034734,
0.2583076656,
-0.1694760472,
0.0902652144,
0.0493503511,
-0.6060062647,
0.0334303863,
0.4156401455,
-0.7663519382,
0.7348805666,
0.7465634942,
0.8796411157,
0.1147493273,
-0.1658467948,
-0.6064567566,
-0.1406300813,
-0.1955480576,
1.0777599812,
-0.9782114625,
-0.4030517936,
-0.290027082,
-0.0115345754,
-0.1817828566,
-0.8155915141,
0.6614747047,
-0.1175603047,
-0.3393070102,
-0.4404904544,
-0.3315334916,
-0.1898987591,
0.6245740652,
-0.5439823866,
0.9085627794,
0.107973367,
-0.7341299653,
0.3061851263,
-1.0056377649,
-0.5018033385,
0.1289597005,
-0.6556963325,
-0.1482861489,
0.3390796483,
0.3101972938,
0.3267079592,
-0.2250994444,
0.2748217881,
0.1033457965,
-0.2587751746,
0.4075756073,
-0.3232123554,
0.5746258497,
-0.0720846877,
-0.306109041,
0.4519892335,
-0.8424524665,
0.0239703283,
0.2069391906,
-0.2606661618,
-0.1782050133,
0.2897987664,
0.0681799129,
0.143299669,
0.1593917906,
-0.8673664927,
0.1380436122,
-0.1697269976,
0.729396522,
0.7669907212,
-0.0728582516,
0.2155492604,
-0.2926183045,
0.5478273034,
0.2039968222,
-0.086529091,
-0.4046010673,
-0.8716865182,
-1.017190814,
0.1447354257,
0.2405789495,
0.599684298,
-0.3736210167,
0.4275788367,
-0.6139016747,
-0.4196726978,
-0.5028228164,
-0.2239885926,
0.6779132485,
0.4754290283,
0.5901338458,
-0.2925378382,
-0.3149075806,
-1.2171826363,
-0.7696664333,
-0.3389698267,
0.005088028,
0.3050887585,
0.9515317082,
-0.2554821074,
1.2304416895,
-0.7761025429,
-0.3939193189,
-0.0435191281,
0.2921850383,
0.2845949829,
0.5199429989,
0.279635936,
-0.7925981283,
-0.1481957734,
0.3557869196,
-0.5831854939,
-0.0066729365,
0.1759396493,
0.3960254788,
-0.1272163987,
0.442889303,
-0.4235641658,
0.4136283398,
0.5202713013,
-0.614410162,
0.8674186468,
-0.0585847273,
0.3241621852,
-0.5408769846,
-0.0410597362,
0.1294707656,
-0.4596232176,
-0.1495636702,
-0.0312853009,
0.1729048938,
-0.2125496566,
-0.2224764824,
0.7203956842,
-0.3560962975,
0.0364738926,
0.0024851933,
-0.0474456139,
0.2378165722,
0.3202891052,
-0.2698613405,
0.81353122,
0.3268247247,
-0.4573606849,
0.5961567163,
0.1765330732,
-0.2727831304,
0.5003397465,
-0.8031848669,
-0.0507810526,
-0.1816731095,
0.2710007727,
-0.8394661546,
-0.5327617526,
0.6047061682,
-0.5990275145,
0.0920146182,
-0.2377897948,
-0.3158444762,
-0.4111501276,
-0.2144553959,
0.7819693685,
0.6070588827,
-0.5008412004,
0.4030560553,
0.332852006,
0.1398614794,
-0.4409317076,
-1.0329873562,
0.3406509459,
-0.128303647,
-0.8558332324,
0.264644444,
0.134837538,
-0.6881067157,
0.4181811512,
-0.2275652289,
-0.1917186975,
-0.2059783787,
0.1687107384,
-0.6065693498,
-0.2589479983,
0.2583223283,
-0.1800775528,
-0.499194026,
0.1647694856,
0.0830130503,
0.1611765772,
-0.7505943179,
-0.4703274965,
0.0462639742,
0.2245233655,
0.3143880367,
-0.4725242257,
0.4314979911,
0.1525923759,
-0.3611701429,
-0.1370578855,
-0.4216108322,
0.4402538836,
-0.4335093796,
0.273421526,
-0.614361465,
-0.9303349257,
0.4661541879,
-0.0459570251,
-0.1230702028,
0.6452767849,
0.1883032918,
0.0224806666,
0.5602728724,
0.3089844882,
0.3534047902,
0.0875589773,
0.0667088628,
0.2824001312,
-0.9879958034,
-0.5059633255,
-0.6117430925,
-0.4191907346,
-0.3047376275,
-0.7374354005,
0.3924093544,
-0.1497587562,
0.0233768132,
0.0354949757,
-0.6653667092,
0.8095985651,
0.3880436122,
0.0451517254,
0.3666638434,
-0.1083223298,
0.1038281173,
0.0558221675,
-0.2727913857,
-0.7941630483,
0.3840684891,
0.3783859015,
0.5895967484,
-0.0656954423,
0.3754744232,
0.5453391075,
0.0123146437,
-1.1711974144,
0.6547785997,
-0.4678444266,
-0.6961663961,
-0.0079184985,
-0.5584436655,
-0.8788896799,
0.6478007436,
-0.2083779871,
-0.880840838,
0.059030354,
0.3354164958,
0.0681847259,
0.3698831797,
-0.6983678937,
1.2465102673,
-0.1845670044,
0.1881819963,
0.1927635223,
-0.8666690588,
0.4201431274,
0.129206866,
0.678578794,
-0.420081377,
0.052136559,
0.8966966271,
-0.4814994037,
0.7184327245,
-0.0801582634,
0.3628656864,
0.3607311845,
0.012345721,
0.2056551874,
-0.2277868539,
-0.0455193892,
0.0935058817,
-0.0683442205,
-0.6769436598,
-0.6940892935,
0.4087453783,
-0.3469212949,
-0.4731691182,
-0.7666270733,
-0.2402791977,
-0.1436698139,
-0.0606422648,
0.2497663945,
0.4560643435,
-0.4831172526,
0.0190320816,
0.3717466891,
0.0642658696,
0.4941864014,
-0.2283635288,
-0.2893755436,
-0.4675528407,
0.7724650502,
-0.0812379643,
0.0309119485,
0.3307277858,
0.4149877429,
-0.0619629435,
-0.420927614,
-0.8837483525,
-0.0630357787,
-0.9975177646,
-0.1796500236,
-0.717872858,
0.0429000184,
0.0055804597,
-0.0934167057,
-0.2837593555,
-0.7565693259,
-0.0040433649,
0.0735951066,
0.4253633916,
1.1974714994,
0.3666450977,
0.604136169,
-1.0596190691,
0.2743037045,
0.0704100281,
0.3624662459,
-0.180622533,
-0.0699992925,
-0.1144257039,
0.0342079215,
-0.2980735302,
-0.8945577145,
-0.0925735012,
0.3497653902,
0.2393589467,
0.2479615659,
-0.1523757279,
0.9761744142,
-0.8821514249,
1.1403512955,
0.3073883951,
-1.2520143986,
0.7176327109,
-0.2105827928,
0.276699543,
0.8219670653,
-0.1003018245,
-0.4999369085,
-0.1982380897,
-0.7232286334,
-0.9419486523,
0.4556836486,
0.526945591,
0.2289305776,
-0.4218043685,
0.3665861487,
0.0096286545,
0.2168086171,
-1.0303300619,
-0.3164793849,
-0.0554570332,
-0.0617383979,
-0.4358535409,
-0.2201286107,
-0.0961801484,
-0.2772432268,
0.5587991476,
0.1668350697,
-0.0628855154,
0.3030803502,
-0.0739600211,
-0.308467567,
0.6027160287,
0.0894651487,
0.6856387258,
-0.0036958295,
0.5772281885,
-0.2387156934,
-0.3463319242,
0.3560813069,
-0.1628544033,
-0.0317801759,
0.1307628155,
0.7027196288,
0.5812882185,
0.1908890009,
-0.8761341572,
0.8113438487,
-0.0751599371,
0.0511633642,
-0.3312449157,
0.1570436507,
-0.1300437748,
0.029161403,
0.2641240358,
0.655690074,
0.178527683,
-0.5424278975,
0.2024889737,
0.4192798436,
-0.7826015949,
-0.3880887628,
0.4648526609,
0.2402252257,
-0.5167431831,
0.367197454,
-0.4327623248,
-0.6704830527,
0.5632352829,
0.4490171075,
0.8325600624,
0.0700959191,
0.1580461413,
0.1067028493,
0.5076212883,
0.0266178511,
0.0556315333,
-0.0944641382,
-0.5040339828,
-0.4744127989,
-1.0067526102,
-0.3788709939,
-0.407566607,
-0.5645585656,
0.0404979996,
-0.2961024046,
-0.1136711761,
0.2133166343,
-0.2692126334,
-0.2628020346,
0.6309185028,
-0.4053032696,
0.8710526228,
-1.2647275925,
0.2959488332,
1.5565108061,
-0.3299666345,
-0.2992784083,
0.116350688,
-0.0671029463,
-0.591384232,
0.5027039647,
0.3452958465,
-0.2414391786,
-0.3385508955,
-0.3782401383,
-0.3022233844,
0.4766289294,
0.18451415,
-0.3121794462,
0.3345488012,
0.0326669924,
0.5198620558,
-0.333532989,
-0.0516537093,
0.6029197574,
0.5713528395,
0.2738237083,
-0.7743903995,
0.1635017246,
-0.6753396392,
-0.1707655489,
0.6996141076,
-0.3926554024,
0.8630825281,
-0.0922143832,
-0.2142072469,
-0.1145931333,
0.5929781199,
0.1892026067,
0.498365283,
0.4836935997,
0.8247526288,
0.8065268993,
-0.3025411665,
1.3539322615,
0.332449913,
0.3482035995,
1.1854964495,
0.3252823055,
0.9594252706,
0.7547294497,
-0.4859749675,
0.5342202783,
0.7624229789,
0.0720798448,
0.0905229524,
0.6494424343,
-0.3808233142,
-0.3649919927,
-0.0232766643,
-0.2534316778,
0.3240483999,
0.3813276887,
-0.241430521,
-0.4279649258,
-0.2527147532,
-0.0897836089,
0.4738648832,
-0.1966771334,
0.5182750225,
0.1975344419,
-0.4236314297,
0.3538707197,
0.0885650069,
0.4696724713,
-0.4037508965,
-0.3366602361,
0.2695001364,
0.0445023812,
-0.577224791,
-0.8653122783,
0.6754683256,
0.1618605703,
-0.3131982982,
-0.0724407211,
0.731482029,
0.0796534047,
-0.7173668146,
0.3560986817,
0.6055615544,
0.4200794995,
-0.2829020917,
-0.5349149704,
0.2404068112,
-0.0912035182,
-0.1098331437,
-0.1282863766,
0.6936794519,
-0.1725814939,
0.6000567675,
0.3241817057,
-0.0655946359,
0.388466984,
-0.0437913947,
0.9705607295,
-1.0013465881,
-0.3469836414,
-1.1692717075,
0.7235523462,
-0.0541003942,
-0.4351840317,
0.574349463,
0.744977653,
0.7360004783,
-0.1520157456,
0.846334815,
-0.3805792034,
0.1466933638,
-0.49073717,
0.2947744727,
-0.6052902937,
0.2698337734,
-0.3720635474,
-1.2631492615,
-0.6287153959,
0.6700025797,
-0.4199683964,
0.1153755635,
0.9371845126,
0.0567464195,
-0.4060018361,
0.1858942211,
0.2346029729,
0.2621354163,
0.2708796561,
0.4254738688,
1.2643640041,
-0.3685932159,
0.3275525272,
-0.2345304936,
-0.6432185173,
0.1433565319,
-1.0266342163,
-0.8109896183,
-0.4771490991,
-0.3836218119,
-0.1399941146,
0.1481078863,
0.7887442708,
0.3551315367,
-0.7470858097,
-0.2009336948,
-0.3250232637,
0.0223142244,
-0.0230269544,
-0.235695973,
0.2276997119,
-0.7188997865,
-0.3777004778,
0.5172493458,
0.3846681118,
-0.1090736389,
0.1777882427,
0.1619154513,
-0.0493832342,
-0.3043804765,
0.5554350019,
0.0946557522,
-0.8669831157,
-0.5330407619,
-0.4701319337,
0.4942507744,
0.610188365,
0.9197234511,
-0.7816926837,
0.5624729991,
0.4373757541,
0.6782634258,
0.4404148161,
0.5341979861,
0.2101041824,
-1.009141326,
-0.0342066661,
0.4248070717,
0.4006973505,
0.4093447924,
-0.1214125901,
0.5970926881,
0.2453445941,
-0.4921387136,
-0.477275759,
0.534566164,
-1.1514045,
-0.3806402087,
0.9349339604,
-0.1982220858,
-0.6607185006,
-0.3048548996,
-0.0932777002,
-0.1230388284,
-0.3636611402,
0.307517916,
0.7195131183,
-0.6907444,
0.2140329778,
-0.5250571966,
0.2706539929,
0.3364924192,
-0.7444170117,
0.2315231562,
0.613070488,
0.2607062161,
0.6619498134,
0.8943485022,
-0.4190531969,
-0.0699392259,
0.1473129094,
-0.0891117454,
0.0533890873,
-0.4558976293,
-0.5789430737,
0.2179909348,
0.3440414667,
-0.3329735696
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03463v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03463v2
|
DBCopilot: Scaling Natural Language Querying to Massive Databases
| 2023-12-06T12:37:28 | 2024-04-23T08:54:57 |
Tianshu Wang, Hongyu Lin, Xianpei Han, Le Sun, Xiaoyang Chen, Hao Wang, Zhenyu Zeng
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.DB, cs.IR
|
Text-to-SQL simplifies database interactions by enabling non-experts to
convert their natural language (NL) questions into Structured Query Language
(SQL) queries. While recent advances in large language models (LLMs) have
improved the zero-shot text-to-SQL paradigm, existing methods face scalability
challenges when dealing with massive, dynamically changing databases. This
paper introduces DBCopilot, a framework that addresses these challenges by
employing a compact and flexible copilot model for routing across massive
databases. Specifically, DBCopilot decouples the text-to-SQL process into
schema routing and SQL generation, leveraging a lightweight
sequence-to-sequence neural network-based router to formulate database
connections and navigate natural language questions through databases and
tables. The routed schemas and questions are then fed into LLMs for efficient
SQL generation. Furthermore, DBCopilot also introduced a reverse
schema-to-question generation paradigm, which can learn and adapt the router
over massive databases automatically without requiring manual intervention.
Experimental results demonstrate that DBCopilot is a scalable and effective
solution for real-world text-to-SQL tasks, providing a significant advancement
in handling large-scale schemas.
|
[
-0.3871275485,
-1.2394676208,
0.6328029037,
0.1431761384,
-0.3355611861,
0.0025677613,
-0.3065613508,
-0.3300319612,
0.4554252923,
0.9627102613,
-0.7568032742,
-0.4707730711,
-0.0316331834,
0.0697234496,
-0.5387864113,
0.9862633348,
0.6012172699,
-0.0635884777,
-0.2597562671,
0.037987031,
-0.3753912747,
-0.8977844119,
-0.7424317598,
0.0298148151,
0.8362214565,
0.5028290153,
0.7245729566,
0.4877483845,
0.509485662,
0.1496529579,
-0.1170210689,
0.2876852751,
-0.4201102257,
0.4969878495,
-0.4630484581,
-0.5890370607,
-0.6064261198,
-0.7485746741,
0.5502666831,
1.2923395634,
-0.357743293,
-0.161589697,
-0.2446661144,
0.9891703725,
-0.2611385584,
0.0370302647,
-0.6980866194,
-0.2185098976,
-0.254685998,
-0.1422112733,
-0.3843262196,
-0.4559125006,
0.0845858604,
-0.6433334947,
0.2599505186,
0.5040963292,
0.5318110585,
0.1432540864,
-0.7845374346,
-0.5132120252,
-0.6772753596,
0.3981143236,
-0.4369669259,
0.162827462,
0.1262836456,
0.7396190166,
-0.3812839985,
-0.8347228169,
-0.5763376355,
-0.1762100607,
-0.2271405756,
-0.2535377741,
0.218987897,
0.0733126998,
0.1419112831,
0.1535965353,
-0.803686738,
0.2725639641,
-0.1825416535,
0.1234117746,
0.9875643849,
0.416865617,
0.1177508682,
-0.3910057843,
0.0285876673,
0.1136270538,
-0.7274885178,
-0.3234243989,
0.2461718768,
0.8227038383,
0.1533816457,
0.6924222708,
-0.374412477,
1.2637708187,
0.1017501801,
0.288013041,
-0.3266930878,
-0.4303461909,
-0.3162198365,
0.1402817518,
0.8175828457,
0.2173888683,
0.084316887,
-0.4440170527,
0.1392494291,
-0.4516618848,
0.4068751037,
-0.6763644218,
-0.301353246,
0.7318738699,
-0.0286871642,
-0.3070486188,
-0.4058468044,
-1.1588038206,
-0.6702692509,
-0.3364289105,
0.2229657471,
-0.4090279043,
-0.2902166843,
0.0511793084,
0.2174078524,
0.2698242664,
0.3598272204,
-1.044904232,
0.4980674386,
0.8463863134,
0.8954069018,
-0.1652938575,
0.1239778623,
-0.3978247046,
0.2687194347,
-0.5034761429,
0.9618574977,
-0.1431874335,
-0.4537170231,
-0.0641873777,
0.1176200062,
-0.3611188233,
-0.3952064514,
0.5192601085,
-0.6661480069,
0.2235469073,
-0.289503634,
-0.6804547906,
-0.0715141073,
0.3483722806,
-0.709669888,
0.7937815785,
-0.1409725547,
-0.5475598574,
0.2347368151,
-0.7680137157,
-0.5754368305,
0.2588039339,
-0.124312669,
-0.4578001499,
-0.1885576248,
0.1692529172,
0.5598226786,
-0.4811236858,
0.5564522743,
-0.0833314881,
-0.2855686545,
-0.135270685,
-0.0173873436,
1.0241824389,
0.0592484437,
-0.1679206192,
0.0437071137,
-0.9711713791,
0.2434003204,
0.1869698614,
-0.4079553783,
-0.2665231824,
0.3216161132,
0.1671988815,
0.0736872926,
0.0452214405,
-0.3620924354,
0.5436290503,
-0.6345838904,
0.5430093408,
0.2735543251,
0.2722734809,
0.6815999746,
0.0184719954,
0.3732004464,
-0.34289065,
-0.0199313425,
-0.2223174721,
-0.2839606106,
-0.7924435139,
-0.2415083349,
0.0742818415,
0.5708953142,
-0.7428072691,
0.7093154788,
-0.5555815101,
-0.8613196611,
0.2408926785,
-0.1074378565,
-0.2806584537,
0.4882875383,
0.4377011359,
-0.1466756463,
-0.4375403523,
-0.6867184043,
-0.3011399209,
0.149030149,
-0.3824156225,
0.4918482006,
0.3837794363,
0.0577317514,
0.9175308347,
-0.6604163647,
-0.537681818,
-0.2726477981,
0.0359486789,
0.2953122556,
0.4965344965,
0.4772029817,
-0.8423851728,
-0.4932383597,
0.2035887688,
-0.5642217994,
0.133262068,
-0.3791097105,
-0.3413546681,
0.2974239588,
0.7414981127,
-0.7090364099,
-0.0353449062,
0.4179073274,
-0.4192070663,
0.5360342264,
-0.0867270529,
-0.1249155775,
-1.0880438089,
0.2565193176,
-0.4081333578,
-0.1056599021,
-0.5636527538,
0.0381256007,
0.0834365711,
-0.4364212751,
-0.1067912653,
0.2142667621,
-0.5033370256,
-0.2244218439,
0.1871782839,
0.214481473,
0.093062833,
0.5785552859,
0.1526126266,
0.5011178255,
0.7076634169,
-0.737205565,
0.7012722492,
0.1513752937,
-0.1436122656,
1.157284379,
-0.5695242882,
0.2401595712,
-0.0954926312,
0.4576918781,
-1.1779332161,
-0.4180543125,
-0.0607843846,
-0.2540770471,
0.2044015229,
-0.4881415665,
-0.6068962812,
-0.246896401,
0.1859814525,
-0.0729588419,
0.0755626038,
-0.48113361,
0.9048473239,
0.065921329,
-0.3434541821,
-0.3056948483,
-0.8410675526,
0.5804988742,
-0.0165376868,
-0.6421253681,
0.258081913,
0.220444411,
0.0340603143,
-0.2608403265,
0.0425497741,
-0.6281142831,
-0.0900458395,
0.1124861464,
0.154903546,
-0.2817504406,
0.4054810107,
0.3893471956,
0.2835797966,
0.2187717408,
-0.6604898572,
0.5693419576,
0.2153827846,
-0.1343954206,
0.0212147143,
0.5876145959,
0.5088614225,
-0.4168714881,
0.9879408479,
-0.0991841704,
-0.0232092664,
-0.4456865489,
-0.1889062673,
-0.2189273834,
-0.4615267515,
0.4823884964,
-0.2423672378,
-0.6591394544,
0.1529792994,
-0.3960686326,
0.1585397273,
0.2970118523,
0.3869750202,
-0.264500767,
0.4650772512,
0.5397542119,
0.4844296277,
0.3083177805,
-0.3853126466,
0.373762995,
-0.5993255973,
-0.3731146157,
-0.7192900777,
-0.1843085736,
-0.4720310569,
-0.7906143069,
0.261708647,
-0.13788414,
-0.3577511609,
0.5077993274,
-0.5670275688,
0.45121032,
0.1789894551,
0.0190795101,
0.5913101435,
0.1534314603,
-0.2542899847,
-0.0114893541,
-0.9171282053,
-0.2572726607,
1.1536685228,
-0.4770226181,
0.5923705697,
0.2531531453,
0.4809906483,
0.1707387567,
0.319378227,
-0.7612450123,
0.784226656,
-0.0950267985,
-1.1055293083,
-0.7034367323,
-0.4581447542,
-0.9176831841,
0.3829312623,
-0.3762322366,
-0.4952046871,
0.4162286818,
0.1681078374,
-0.1807070374,
0.4172404408,
-0.8122121096,
0.8887995481,
-0.5186355114,
-0.7058908343,
-0.001487757,
-0.7019078135,
0.2272110879,
-0.3205743432,
0.1596674323,
0.112474516,
-0.2478503436,
0.3848145306,
-0.6632273197,
0.7458479404,
-0.090998061,
-0.0525268093,
0.3778754473,
0.3984837234,
0.4625781476,
-0.053824164,
-0.2993738651,
0.2500850558,
-0.2059226334,
-0.4906903207,
-0.663425982,
0.7862189412,
-0.1750171483,
-0.1243313551,
-0.3132491112,
-0.4917160273,
-0.3716080487,
0.3803238869,
0.0568570979,
0.399396807,
-0.2908828557,
0.4246539772,
0.5082787275,
-0.3919750452,
0.2425330281,
0.6169605255,
-0.2639526725,
-0.0672075525,
0.6422223449,
0.4796676934,
0.4298305809,
0.799331367,
-0.1813491732,
-0.5719056726,
-0.3243020177,
-0.5108643174,
0.2749257684,
-0.3534620702,
-0.1880743206,
-0.7680363655,
0.1622580886,
-0.2298800349,
-0.4593776166,
-0.433180958,
-0.8745245337,
0.0397328176,
-0.1533287764,
0.5605163574,
0.2719514072,
0.2008785009,
0.3913071752,
-0.2444317937,
-0.0091406973,
0.4935394228,
0.4670986831,
-0.0906465948,
-0.2480302751,
-0.151673004,
-0.2077519596,
-0.2356242985,
-0.8525361419,
0.4434530139,
0.2723448277,
0.1242599487,
-0.0765822306,
0.2639496922,
0.4815585315,
-0.6657378078,
0.6936510205,
0.0334660523,
-0.7427204251,
0.6851809025,
-0.7362254262,
0.0376803875,
0.426886797,
0.6370841861,
-0.4598404765,
-0.0904894099,
-0.2669185102,
-1.0709139109,
0.3658792078,
0.1283485293,
-0.1197019741,
0.0879923403,
0.4571150541,
-0.0750121772,
0.3178671896,
-0.4360843003,
-0.1366278231,
-0.3569637239,
-0.0207218993,
-0.221232757,
0.1046018824,
0.0394037478,
-0.0961543769,
0.0894798413,
-0.5951251388,
0.1530814469,
0.240120396,
0.0486479066,
0.0942694023,
0.5230904818,
0.2474971563,
0.6654872298,
-0.4441611767,
-0.1933451146,
0.0066334722,
-0.3383337557,
-0.0774085522,
0.2526778579,
-0.3611579537,
0.0036968319,
0.1446288079,
0.5157134533,
0.2092277408,
-0.7727810144,
0.3579097986,
-0.0781371444,
-0.3329417706,
-0.133455053,
0.1039684713,
0.6136597991,
-0.2716846168,
0.4644851983,
0.0184353683,
0.1227109805,
-0.3171394467,
0.1917191595,
0.2745672166,
-0.2987604439,
0.0720514134,
1.0033946037,
0.4218809903,
-0.5145792365,
0.5495849848,
0.2032296211,
-0.1117807701,
0.7598499656,
0.1401980817,
0.4716704488,
-0.1056607291,
0.1911718994,
0.6515644193,
0.4935620427,
0.1102142781,
0.0974957943,
-0.228887409,
-0.2026806921,
-0.603585124,
-0.3505564332,
-0.8267142177,
-0.447006464,
-0.6908606291,
0.1825795621,
-0.62282902,
0.0521250889,
0.1123688221,
0.1130413115,
-0.5201204419,
0.3419643641,
-0.378115207,
0.9174673557,
-0.5127684474,
0.9833670259,
0.6985660195,
-0.4137254655,
-0.7869853973,
-0.339655906,
-0.1183448061,
-0.4249022007,
0.4785797894,
-0.1523309648,
0.1858255565,
0.1538021117,
-0.5899798274,
-0.5347971916,
1.2041541338,
0.3172515333,
-1.0158948898,
-0.2565625012,
0.3317686319,
0.7344335318,
-0.170033887,
0.0729129612,
0.4476852417,
0.2492048591,
0.2377688587,
-0.6778315902,
0.0956718624,
0.2610985041,
-0.0812828392,
0.3367579281,
-0.6073148251,
0.826795578,
-0.3118362725,
0.057275407,
-0.0154960649,
0.4336185455,
0.0973881185,
0.1895167381,
0.5004791617,
0.0788835436,
0.9909939766,
-0.2122421861,
1.2419335842,
-0.0036342554,
0.3484469652,
1.3265435696,
-0.5928994417,
0.9927041531,
0.505905807,
-0.1863714159,
0.8008126616,
0.2425186783,
0.1915794909,
0.3156138659,
0.3519867063,
-0.1191057339,
-0.2620259821,
0.0417757072,
-0.1997576505,
0.2220752686,
0.6113401651,
-0.0721673891,
-0.2705277503,
-0.1501570791,
0.1060721725,
0.399802357,
-0.1890709996,
0.594433248,
-0.1010072678,
-0.5928382277,
0.5552644134,
-0.1137085855,
0.4326753616,
-0.9242921472,
0.114729777,
-0.6489219069,
0.0284692533,
-0.2744220495,
-0.6865872741,
0.6711204648,
-0.015570269,
0.1055150405,
-0.0039457139,
0.5464890599,
-0.3867739141,
-0.4563021362,
0.1789477915,
0.3580653965,
0.0630565062,
-0.4228756726,
-0.6660906076,
-0.1168406233,
-0.1669166684,
-0.2427233905,
0.3055090606,
0.7029799223,
-0.0666922629,
0.8538064957,
0.8085343838,
0.1678516567,
0.2131483108,
-0.1233452484,
0.7629457116,
-0.8671572208,
-0.7587419152,
-0.363027662,
0.3795486391,
-0.4906355739,
0.0482948236,
0.7278365493,
0.6802029014,
0.1951767653,
-0.0746798888,
0.4282054603,
-0.3287287056,
0.8837116957,
-0.3505691886,
0.8005076051,
-0.6419609189,
0.4371483624,
-0.1872397065,
-0.8471118212,
-0.4934714139,
0.4824264944,
-0.3344267011,
-0.2787871659,
0.7840480208,
1.016392827,
0.2185050398,
-0.0311781857,
0.2882096171,
0.4338094592,
0.5287331939,
0.5905327797,
0.2193574309,
-0.2716070116,
0.9976294637,
-0.0370404199,
-0.064973034,
-0.3975738287,
-0.9910497665,
-0.8511120081,
-0.3623572588,
-0.2392643839,
-0.2038098425,
0.1327065527,
0.5209897161,
0.9622670412,
-0.6975450516,
-0.4831815064,
-0.5695994496,
0.2057686597,
-0.3661659658,
-0.3272087276,
0.6524823308,
-0.1493399739,
-0.5095261931,
0.3433887661,
0.4275268316,
-0.3157266378,
-0.3671402335,
0.3506056964,
-0.4350236058,
0.2732921839,
0.7338675261,
0.4472469985,
-0.1506041437,
0.1458574235,
0.0825114772,
-0.2742705643,
-0.082037434,
0.8403247595,
-0.7794024944,
0.3861179948,
0.3224815428,
0.6980112791,
0.7393841147,
-0.0711271316,
0.5799607635,
-0.8745702505,
0.2146271765,
0.4340472221,
-0.0838622898,
0.4517462552,
-0.6269882321,
0.7681154609,
0.2494916022,
-0.6460946798,
-0.7184122205,
0.3276902139,
-1.359418273,
-0.3471871614,
0.9020150304,
0.3708031774,
-0.287168622,
-0.4713773131,
-0.490069896,
-0.4196497202,
-0.0982088223,
0.355576545,
0.3169163764,
-0.2443035543,
-0.1537002325,
-0.5134387016,
0.3289068639,
0.397657752,
-1.0854377747,
0.3440598249,
0.6506481171,
0.342677325,
0.073557809,
0.7644314766,
0.0458435975,
0.1325736195,
0.1836609989,
-0.0479322858,
-0.0037958594,
-0.0139874117,
0.0456723757,
0.4124209285,
-0.2268313468,
0.0957759917
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03458v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03458v1
|
Think from Words(TFW): Initiating Human-Like Cognition in Large Language Models Through Think from Words for Japanese Text-level Classification
| 2023-12-06T12:34:46 | 2023-12-06T12:34:46 |
Chengguang Gan, Qinghao Zhang, Tatsunori Mori
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The proliferation of Large Language Models (LLMs) has spurred extensive
research into LLM-related Prompt investigations, such as Instruction Learning
(IL), In-context Learning (ICL), and Chain-of-Thought (CoT). These approaches
aim to improve LLMs' responses by enabling them to provide concise statements
or examples for deeper contemplation when addressing questions. However,
independent thinking by LLMs can introduce variability in their thought
processes, leading to potential inaccuracies. In response, our study seeks to
bridge the gap between LLM and human-like thinking processes, recognizing that
text comprehension begins with understanding individual words. To tackle this
challenge, we have expanded the CoT method to cater to a specific domain. Our
approach, known as "Think from Words" (TFW), initiates the comprehension
process at the word level and then extends it to encompass the entire text. We
also propose "TFW with Extra word-level information" (TFW Extra), augmenting
comprehension with additional word-level data. To assess our methods, we employ
text classification on six Japanese datasets comprising text-level and
word-level elements. Our findings not only validate the effectiveness of TFW
but also shed light on the impact of various word-level information types on
LLMs' text comprehension, offering insights into their potential to cause
misinterpretations and errors in the overall comprehension of the final text.
|
[
-0.5227469802,
-1.1637661457,
0.7976148129,
-0.1116970032,
-0.4560560286,
0.3464422524,
-0.2680590451,
-0.5470324755,
-0.0572456531,
0.4705762267,
-0.6435154676,
-0.3716489673,
-0.4498714805,
0.1396442205,
-0.2021612823,
0.6311218143,
-0.3866558969,
-0.33388111,
-0.1718348712,
0.0617849305,
-0.5755789876,
-0.4281741381,
-0.6170193553,
-0.6418378949,
0.4874370396,
0.426830858,
0.570435822,
0.1989186257,
0.1861263663,
0.1729437858,
0.1236175597,
0.3844722211,
-0.483473748,
0.1634073704,
-0.3597118855,
-1.0108941793,
-0.2565096319,
0.0566080436,
0.4376038015,
0.6650547385,
-0.1229545251,
0.0180343445,
0.1370877177,
0.7396131754,
-0.6981735229,
0.1200834215,
-0.712897718,
0.5308984518,
-0.0787061527,
-0.3566039801,
-0.5877444148,
0.0232803002,
0.3763642609,
-0.6356339455,
0.2346134782,
0.3306630254,
0.5159084797,
0.1050043777,
-0.1482120752,
-0.3726464808,
-0.4330270886,
0.527687788,
-0.5920440555,
0.4531878829,
0.5430831909,
-0.1677490175,
-0.2622104287,
-0.5554491282,
-0.950802505,
0.0202525891,
-0.0029869399,
0.3947462738,
0.0058418219,
0.1088099703,
0.3873375356,
0.2783473134,
-0.4937869906,
-0.0939798802,
-0.0690425336,
-0.0932783857,
0.4831611514,
0.1138542742,
0.6035934091,
-0.0823684335,
-0.5089688301,
-0.255544275,
-0.7289619446,
0.010862153,
-0.1337269694,
0.0612469465,
-0.172839433,
0.7115941644,
-0.0961510837,
0.5379317999,
-0.2843313813,
-0.0575395264,
0.2087122053,
-0.3086369336,
-0.3554777801,
0.0804003328,
0.8985705376,
0.1789619029,
0.5094547272,
-0.2137375772,
-0.2817651033,
0.2129873186,
0.384250313,
-0.4367158711,
-0.154663533,
0.1264470518,
-0.4070811272,
-0.2483772337,
0.0265724398,
-0.7079549432,
-0.3229994476,
-0.3678300083,
0.7533660531,
-0.4629870951,
-0.296154201,
0.1402779371,
-0.2450668663,
0.2380909026,
0.299569726,
-0.6756091714,
0.2324518561,
0.5726686716,
0.6848564744,
-0.3040781319,
-0.3833865821,
-0.1593218744,
0.3529801965,
-0.6938664913,
0.946323216,
-0.5560050607,
-0.6871973872,
0.0173607096,
-0.1933794767,
-0.2090432346,
-0.2902234793,
0.4452196062,
-0.3748644292,
0.5319890976,
-0.2948012054,
-0.6891901493,
-0.2757368088,
0.4317728579,
-0.2561809123,
1.151448369,
-0.0407648571,
-1.045284152,
0.2837518156,
-0.7539821267,
-0.474755466,
0.3910349011,
-0.3596595228,
0.0688961372,
0.4029474258,
0.343930006,
0.6318812966,
-0.205439195,
-0.0065635904,
-0.2329265922,
-0.2793001533,
0.5591421127,
-0.4795908928,
0.2896213531,
-0.0795173347,
-0.4390708804,
0.0764115453,
-0.2570457757,
0.3519256711,
0.2594959438,
-0.1261504441,
-0.6117128134,
0.0444615148,
-0.3116476536,
0.178260088,
0.1388708353,
-0.5945949554,
0.0442267843,
-0.5971186161,
0.278966397,
0.4606791735,
0.0709150508,
0.3282780945,
-0.5043686628,
0.5578814149,
0.0034676215,
-0.0330990665,
-0.3193396032,
-0.4612368643,
-0.937622726,
0.139055863,
-0.1475878954,
0.4628061652,
-1.2119058371,
0.2291320115,
-0.2340817451,
-0.5256842971,
-0.6325811744,
0.0374215357,
0.5593289137,
0.5977138281,
0.4785375297,
-0.0466269217,
-0.3003953397,
-0.5580729246,
-0.4215612113,
-0.467340678,
0.0008395624,
0.3031516373,
0.4112042487,
-0.2914274633,
0.8121139407,
-0.9244052768,
-0.0799416751,
-0.6080086827,
0.1606113911,
-0.2556084692,
-0.0346855447,
-0.0829037428,
-0.6549704075,
-0.3828045428,
-0.0194770843,
-0.6282119751,
0.03211537,
0.123048164,
-0.4308829606,
0.2982176244,
0.7296629548,
-0.4251003563,
0.4530748725,
0.2142620385,
-0.402664423,
0.3115454614,
-0.4380057156,
0.0033039872,
-1.3375108242,
-0.116675958,
-0.0330018327,
-0.2416974306,
-0.6006308198,
0.3316558003,
0.1443184912,
-0.0387006328,
-0.1866361201,
0.591804564,
-0.4573854804,
-0.0609068125,
-0.5669531822,
0.3866703212,
0.0787547007,
0.4035952389,
0.2609605789,
0.8709558845,
0.247793138,
-0.6003807187,
-0.1136979535,
0.2225060761,
-0.6629809141,
0.2717037499,
-0.3174723983,
0.4611677229,
-0.3924667239,
0.4287597239,
-1.0402206182,
-0.1989000291,
0.2385432273,
-0.4942534268,
0.2342173159,
0.5642600656,
-0.5798062682,
-0.3158452809,
-0.2900047004,
0.1125584021,
0.4513154626,
-0.6300080419,
0.543811202,
0.6422816515,
-0.195804581,
-0.5018630624,
-0.9815676808,
0.0632176548,
-0.2131317556,
-0.0892262831,
0.348015219,
-0.0940947235,
-0.1780382991,
-0.0553394184,
-0.0474603213,
0.0623838678,
0.2137789577,
-0.0396668054,
0.4334593415,
-0.0474595018,
0.2868723869,
0.2274163365,
0.1420477033,
0.243497625,
-0.2135314643,
0.7971234322,
0.1753564924,
0.148542732,
-0.1413196176,
0.3273499012,
0.3871343434,
-0.1616981626,
0.4799382687,
0.5049809813,
-0.4157399535,
-0.6968397498,
-0.4019808769,
0.081399709,
-0.4066087902,
0.3797140718,
-0.6056172848,
-0.9122447371,
0.1508954763,
0.1307269186,
0.113532044,
0.2686617374,
0.3971389234,
-0.4907553494,
0.8761846423,
0.7920339108,
-0.0109880967,
0.3594154418,
-0.2630628347,
0.1686374247,
-1.2373973131,
-0.4496870041,
-0.1213700771,
-0.2769732773,
-0.3385255337,
-0.804207921,
0.1957228184,
-0.0385381244,
-0.0838380083,
0.1036861613,
-0.2079217732,
0.5043323636,
-0.0019921567,
0.2953150868,
0.3030784726,
0.0599223413,
-0.3829882443,
0.1930007786,
-0.6789821386,
-0.3680621982,
1.0563864708,
0.2312178612,
0.7094715834,
-0.1130349189,
0.6800985336,
0.1798701137,
0.4208830297,
-1.1247711182,
0.7248678803,
0.0102201207,
-0.4643242955,
-0.3205489516,
-0.3764129281,
-1.0176774263,
0.4982475936,
-0.1396186203,
-0.8299921155,
-0.2224393785,
-0.2362815887,
-0.1799417138,
0.3129337728,
-0.5526391864,
0.337125361,
-0.0328965187,
0.1073189378,
-0.5054738522,
-0.4341599345,
0.2950281799,
-0.3010683954,
0.3321118057,
-0.0137478281,
-0.63488096,
0.934038043,
-0.2320005596,
0.6742377281,
0.0662546307,
-0.3941491842,
0.5835968852,
0.0108686853,
0.2173912972,
-0.1950269639,
0.1686956584,
-0.027718842,
-0.1697306782,
-0.1819320917,
-0.6266595721,
0.5130443573,
-0.7812082767,
-0.6355600953,
-0.3197536767,
-0.6380854249,
-0.6649875045,
0.1656199694,
0.5157384276,
0.4742841721,
-0.0732642189,
0.0051266206,
0.8419920206,
-0.1204674467,
0.5546600819,
0.4841237962,
-0.5375933647,
-0.3467745483,
0.6761521101,
0.2445930988,
0.4180862606,
0.7367636561,
0.4091218412,
-0.4895367026,
-0.4096827209,
-0.2698277235,
0.1241234764,
-0.6555377841,
-0.0851375163,
-0.7905783653,
-0.0738637373,
-0.0267586093,
-0.069776848,
0.0647594482,
0.0299687479,
-0.1500107348,
-0.1807564199,
0.1461967975,
0.7146883607,
0.6016073227,
0.2306194156,
-0.7897827029,
0.3769309223,
0.0611920096,
0.2248107046,
0.5663382411,
-0.4300129116,
-0.1601252854,
0.1257837117,
-0.2384018898,
-0.8108455539,
0.2975678742,
0.0983888805,
0.5862856507,
0.3172056079,
0.1345217824,
0.7295008898,
-0.4018602967,
0.7166853547,
0.3253595233,
-1.0364743471,
0.5686256886,
-0.1500313878,
0.7004076242,
0.5995187759,
0.4240392447,
-0.7110474706,
-0.5802946091,
-0.6197004914,
-0.6246832013,
0.6792672276,
0.0572753362,
0.1515547633,
-0.1986811161,
0.4125448763,
0.2502949834,
0.1031843051,
-0.4616564214,
0.0391779281,
0.2350551039,
-0.4209472239,
-0.2495363504,
-0.1846378297,
0.2818091512,
-0.0621360168,
0.6115077734,
-0.4709161818,
0.2947332561,
0.5818479657,
-0.2992362082,
-0.1913296878,
0.3010430634,
0.1841193438,
0.6152345538,
0.2906006575,
0.2447713614,
0.5357080102,
-0.6811901927,
0.0938607603,
-0.5691826344,
-0.2126496434,
-0.2623111904,
0.4966291189,
0.801404953,
0.2925339341,
-0.7562168837,
0.349021405,
-0.2683364749,
-0.1883165091,
-0.1486768126,
0.3646401465,
0.2399423718,
0.0164704248,
0.1951352358,
-0.1929691881,
-0.0397513993,
-0.9863761663,
-0.1097883582,
0.2064509541,
-0.5555559993,
-0.203727141,
0.256165117,
0.1475968808,
-0.2645357251,
0.5019119382,
-0.0264049917,
-0.7043557167,
0.3282606006,
0.810334444,
1.017619133,
0.0250600334,
0.1654241979,
0.2625496686,
0.1257711649,
-0.2474694103,
0.6399482489,
-0.364823401,
-1.1884863377,
-0.6352745891,
-0.4103874862,
-0.3412895203,
0.1994605958,
-0.5880615711,
0.0821698755,
-0.6996475458,
-0.2151164114,
-0.2462079823,
0.2437303066,
-0.4858301878,
0.4406066835,
0.6719831824,
1.1338590384,
-0.5578095913,
0.8925044537,
0.8417640328,
-0.1186855286,
-0.9611059427,
0.8049955368,
-0.2470134795,
-0.7422443032,
0.2086978853,
0.4616590142,
-0.3823334277,
0.1605880111,
-0.4798622131,
-0.681681633,
0.9768428206,
-0.192986235,
-0.6101926565,
-0.1921147406,
0.0036102468,
0.4362194538,
-0.4814248085,
0.2276260257,
0.6831014156,
0.2242168486,
0.0347798243,
-0.5985561013,
0.1424870789,
-0.0761820972,
0.1444348246,
0.4378298521,
-0.6537707448,
0.348121196,
-0.3834300637,
-0.3277054429,
-0.0316383988,
0.7514448166,
0.2719893157,
0.3673309088,
0.670873642,
0.6472247243,
1.1378563643,
0.0931189135,
1.0901522636,
0.0442263149,
0.0357015729,
1.0723714828,
-0.0665248409,
1.1685249805,
0.270904541,
-0.2576428056,
0.6649698615,
0.4407868981,
0.2820685208,
0.3625202477,
0.0766332671,
-0.2988765538,
-0.1243887693,
-0.0707738549,
-0.1785905361,
0.417378664,
0.7456988096,
-0.0812764466,
0.1823216826,
0.197200045,
0.1432234198,
0.123954609,
-0.632658124,
1.190612793,
0.400405556,
-0.9949436188,
0.226702407,
-0.1500923783,
0.7869641185,
-0.5435355306,
0.2957386672,
-0.0568126813,
0.1051043272,
-0.0670279786,
-1.293738246,
0.1440469623,
0.3048221469,
-0.1344239116,
-0.1079570428,
0.8030588627,
-0.4813878834,
-0.4174374342,
0.3555571437,
0.5472335219,
0.1727934927,
-0.0020150065,
-0.645652771,
-0.0483891815,
0.1892073005,
-0.2648750246,
0.287368983,
0.6178110242,
-0.0729696751,
0.7697678804,
0.5401336551,
0.0751754493,
-0.1367431879,
0.1023584828,
0.5623301268,
-0.8048355579,
-0.7220012546,
-0.8797694445,
0.1574679166,
-0.2127417773,
-0.4497529566,
0.4590388238,
0.3358806968,
1.0719405413,
0.1356541067,
0.9783520699,
0.1051584035,
0.4503602982,
-0.5480195284,
0.7980118394,
-0.5633291006,
-0.1823737621,
-0.3631187379,
-0.9223818183,
0.0286326166,
0.5263857245,
-0.3904069662,
-0.2177745104,
1.0537403822,
0.3500574827,
0.2044452727,
0.5251953602,
0.4149888754,
0.1132269651,
0.2473953217,
0.6415576935,
1.0285413265,
-0.2577968836,
0.2266542912,
-0.1073525846,
-0.147534132,
0.1022675261,
-0.505613029,
-0.9869811535,
-0.5155645013,
-0.2477343231,
-0.2050504833,
-0.3188118041,
1.1239629984,
0.1542773098,
-0.3625915349,
-0.1898530573,
-0.4972062111,
0.0317787454,
0.2442807406,
-0.2271318734,
0.2897215188,
-0.5894333124,
-0.5544697046,
0.3783087432,
0.3122882545,
0.029740233,
-0.2353373766,
-0.0371817797,
-0.1153108627,
0.5247527957,
0.8352845907,
-0.0880656987,
-0.6904283166,
-0.2157262117,
-0.1923054606,
-0.1340584904,
-0.1464129686,
0.8274002671,
-0.8939802647,
0.6831797361,
0.7602260709,
0.6504181027,
0.3498997688,
-0.056953378,
0.7000796199,
-0.332650423,
-0.005782146,
0.3186198771,
0.3909068108,
0.4427458346,
-0.3037357032,
0.4063489735,
0.1907782108,
-0.1073241532,
-0.5989924669,
0.3567464948,
-0.7505690455,
-0.7208638191,
1.1238542795,
-0.2375915945,
-0.4753181338,
0.0020935989,
-0.4127829075,
0.4137766063,
-0.0304723531,
0.7088617086,
0.9497349262,
-0.0712963641,
-0.0845432654,
-0.2682908773,
0.3884474337,
0.3836662173,
-1.1127983332,
0.1805941463,
-0.0319516547,
0.172926113,
0.0198106803,
0.6427052021,
-0.1960693449,
-0.1006943807,
-0.0724341869,
-0.2175111175,
0.1656226963,
-0.3187093437,
0.0107418196,
0.0697273314,
-0.062039651,
-0.0144143384
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03789v1
|
Comparative Analysis of Multilingual Text Classification & Identification through Deep Learning and Embedding Visualization
| 2023-12-06T12:03:27 | 2023-12-06T12:03:27 |
Arinjay Wyawhare
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This research conducts a comparative study on multilingual text
classification methods, utilizing deep learning and embedding visualization.
The study employs LangDetect, LangId, FastText, and Sentence Transformer on a
dataset encompassing 17 languages. It explores dimensionality's impact on
clustering, revealing FastText's clearer clustering in 2D visualization due to
its extensive multilingual corpus training. Notably, the FastText multi-layer
perceptron model achieved remarkable accuracy, precision, recall, and F1 score,
outperforming the Sentence Transformer model. The study underscores the
effectiveness of these techniques in multilingual text classification,
emphasizing the importance of large multilingual corpora for training
embeddings. It lays the groundwork for future research and assists
practitioners in developing language detection and classification systems.
Additionally, it includes the comparison of multi-layer perceptron, LSTM, and
Convolution models for classification.
|
[
-0.2688623071,
-0.8342504501,
0.3744683564,
0.247090891,
-0.0767526403,
0.5414392352,
-0.428948313,
-0.6233844161,
0.1305364221,
0.18555215,
-0.0603947453,
-0.8127399683,
-0.6437335014,
0.2262660414,
-0.3975331485,
0.786647439,
-0.1401549429,
0.1921755821,
-0.3040266633,
-0.2580206394,
-0.3689357936,
-0.745112896,
-0.8317492008,
-0.2030061781,
0.5324084163,
0.3640243709,
0.4784093797,
0.3652836084,
0.6550706625,
0.4588274062,
-0.075008899,
-0.1849455386,
-0.2873764932,
0.0006987768,
0.1212581694,
-0.5789030194,
0.0217400696,
-0.0541989766,
0.6933345199,
0.6476207972,
0.141325146,
-0.1199948862,
0.0008436004,
0.2964405119,
-0.5135511756,
0.3596071303,
-0.2091672719,
0.5140655637,
-0.2495650798,
-0.0528832786,
-0.4495156109,
-0.4739361703,
0.2137852609,
-0.3636334538,
0.2160326242,
-0.0217247661,
0.470308125,
0.0963404402,
-0.7577035427,
-0.4860783815,
-0.6465454698,
0.8913356662,
-0.41511935,
0.7846939564,
-0.1106818691,
0.4836620092,
0.6602908969,
-0.851549685,
-0.4962749779,
-0.0180237237,
-0.3598184586,
0.0852783769,
0.0326225385,
-0.3201902807,
0.0757705644,
0.4944187403,
-0.8871008158,
0.5863246918,
-0.2169631571,
-0.4318542182,
0.5414924622,
0.0038283805,
0.4587318599,
-0.0819057375,
-0.4498321116,
-0.5657557845,
-0.4677410126,
0.0135264825,
0.3146885633,
0.2896055281,
-0.3131925762,
0.1435648054,
-0.0023794358,
0.3483915627,
-0.3311136365,
-0.4187051654,
0.791991055,
-0.3433808982,
-0.2830585837,
0.3323361576,
0.9455160499,
0.2928262651,
0.3651432395,
-0.155719474,
-0.0281084757,
0.0632000118,
-0.0870711207,
-1.1312402487,
-0.1530111134,
0.0331169218,
-0.7571544647,
-0.2443677187,
0.1429033577,
-0.8466751575,
-0.5010928512,
-0.2458017915,
0.1083400622,
-0.3833915889,
-0.3847018182,
-0.0634597018,
-0.0723593161,
0.1864861399,
0.1407648176,
-0.8068081141,
0.0804534927,
0.6752712727,
0.8754656315,
-0.4051455557,
-0.527286768,
0.0055839741,
-0.1468386054,
-0.2715169787,
0.7582444549,
-0.56731987,
-0.1356419176,
0.3816957176,
0.1979829222,
-0.2505164146,
-0.5002173781,
0.6168153286,
-0.4569383264,
0.3559686542,
-0.0951808542,
-0.5467355251,
-0.4499929547,
0.3701457083,
-0.8686659932,
0.6891454458,
-0.2185057849,
-0.9620201588,
0.6069511175,
-0.2844495475,
-0.4424801767,
0.1692806482,
-0.4437582493,
-0.5169346929,
-0.0961240157,
0.1653626263,
0.8713644147,
-0.1186828092,
0.1425225735,
-0.1425334066,
-0.4739938676,
0.3062711358,
-0.5825946331,
0.8014181256,
0.3550328314,
-0.2553250492,
0.1381399333,
-0.7808677554,
-0.0092031676,
0.2590416372,
-0.324241817,
-0.6511597633,
-0.1743922234,
0.5735195279,
0.2541901171,
0.2513948083,
-0.5929949284,
0.056089282,
-0.3799340725,
0.412548542,
0.3188219965,
-0.1636311412,
0.6081796885,
0.3101728261,
0.5167383552,
0.1891508549,
-0.0100550782,
-0.3363355994,
-0.3400928974,
-0.6155574918,
-0.2768907845,
0.6065704226,
0.9846663475,
-0.8179029226,
0.3212393224,
-0.5037554502,
-0.4646978676,
-0.3682157397,
-0.1319525391,
0.5327593088,
0.0063078585,
0.2570823729,
-0.0619019866,
-0.4220594764,
-1.0137739182,
-0.2135881037,
0.1654731482,
0.2354740649,
0.045752503,
0.5391277075,
-0.5058458447,
0.2365422696,
-0.3969153464,
-0.2766153812,
-0.3635171056,
0.1771883667,
0.0218364354,
0.4488687217,
0.9022082686,
-0.9182109833,
-0.8920915723,
0.5239351988,
-1.0235760212,
0.279392004,
0.1097931638,
0.335616678,
0.310408026,
0.8106997609,
-0.2378078103,
0.4095590115,
0.4660466015,
-0.3443956971,
0.0624718741,
-0.1912173778,
0.3902540505,
-1.0511983633,
-0.0290761385,
-0.0309891552,
-0.0425689407,
-0.7425254583,
0.223112464,
0.4656386673,
-0.2895827293,
-0.3903976679,
0.55545187,
-0.283205837,
0.1424545944,
-0.114356339,
0.104754433,
-0.1482976675,
0.3011004329,
0.0117922481,
0.7160412073,
0.5057691932,
-0.2750144899,
0.2762794793,
0.3703866005,
-0.5652279854,
0.4971346855,
-0.4931083322,
0.0041221222,
-0.1407234222,
0.1667247117,
-1.0264703035,
0.1060161144,
0.0589707457,
-0.2321335524,
0.4781106412,
0.18873851,
-0.6927993298,
-0.2066458613,
-0.5581567883,
0.6336750984,
0.2060276568,
-0.7088670731,
0.3490687907,
0.3204444647,
-0.2466517389,
-0.6499531865,
-1.0034470558,
0.0154815754,
-0.4791383445,
-0.2658900917,
0.3888283968,
-0.0848489702,
-0.2998309731,
-0.1832980216,
0.1860053688,
-0.1956469119,
0.06941773,
0.0473713577,
-0.139150247,
-0.1043419018,
0.4032866657,
0.2336308956,
-0.2508861423,
-0.040220242,
-0.0374114476,
0.4898603559,
-0.2195931226,
-0.1547438353,
-0.5910539031,
0.5138329268,
0.5037857294,
-0.3894969821,
0.7730717659,
1.1313450336,
-0.2297244072,
-0.0471879095,
-0.4644738436,
0.0685199723,
-0.4044489563,
0.3702029288,
-0.6151062846,
-1.121784687,
0.4188243449,
-0.1101811603,
-0.2938579023,
0.5641456246,
0.4212681949,
0.1716766357,
1.0363029242,
0.9227050543,
-0.4296093881,
0.3860055804,
-0.3281553686,
0.4239073992,
-0.3080973625,
-0.4144766033,
-0.7044035196,
-0.2198330611,
-0.9959157705,
-0.2664396465,
0.1459429711,
-0.0637887716,
-0.1959859431,
0.1961633861,
-0.5221855044,
0.3730044067,
0.312120229,
-0.2539243698,
0.1873949468,
0.3413645625,
-0.35080567,
-0.3203143179,
-0.6498427987,
-0.5131628513,
0.9614549279,
0.3843469322,
0.434543997,
0.1763158888,
0.6714108586,
0.24053289,
0.1885790229,
-0.7767725587,
0.2860241234,
-0.4506726861,
-0.2409300804,
-0.1869304478,
-0.5351837873,
-1.1216875315,
0.5822175145,
-0.4175115526,
-0.6645939946,
0.28174299,
-0.3275924325,
-0.0789246559,
0.2852375507,
-1.0062328577,
1.1375062466,
-0.2825406194,
0.1036513746,
-0.2625016272,
-0.4399557114,
0.1695459336,
-0.2791343033,
0.3980737031,
0.1249703169,
0.0457763076,
0.9513655305,
0.0909918547,
0.824816823,
-0.2062256038,
-0.2874240577,
-0.0162533913,
-0.0520719811,
0.1782107353,
0.1262273192,
0.0695988685,
0.4467226863,
0.1329405606,
-0.2394312918,
-0.5472970009,
1.0925676823,
-0.7398996353,
-0.1405568868,
-0.4275093377,
-0.314748019,
0.0312505886,
0.2361925244,
0.1723951399,
0.5172052979,
-0.4723945856,
0.3990169168,
0.636331439,
-0.7094752789,
0.6932544112,
0.3588089645,
-0.4789898098,
-0.4513374567,
1.1704208851,
0.0698729977,
-0.1417862624,
0.9701544046,
0.1563336402,
-0.324093014,
-0.445586592,
-0.3125005662,
0.2087936103,
-0.8771038651,
-0.03297057,
-0.7567740679,
-0.2188880891,
-0.5603047609,
-0.0578535944,
-0.1231392398,
-0.4305498004,
-0.0788993612,
-0.3360372782,
0.0979469344,
0.7219503522,
0.2550264001,
0.3330449462,
-0.6815482378,
-0.1287014484,
0.197686106,
0.258286804,
0.1847353131,
-0.0473856851,
-0.5062851906,
-0.3829313815,
-0.22762613,
-0.7147811055,
0.3468265533,
0.0855160877,
0.6760485768,
0.654517889,
-0.5171796679,
0.3223598599,
-0.6467629075,
0.5859612226,
0.2677470744,
-0.9425069094,
0.3692862988,
0.1797236055,
0.4081466496,
0.4959115386,
0.6533648968,
-0.5973725915,
-0.1631264687,
-0.3844519854,
-0.692966938,
0.3068990111,
-0.0246825572,
-0.0022435836,
0.0430499576,
0.2522501647,
0.3884890079,
0.173290655,
-0.8006436229,
-0.3797764778,
-0.2109327316,
-0.4565797746,
-0.5897599459,
-0.3743752539,
0.1850585639,
-0.3370610476,
0.1312626004,
-0.2331342399,
0.2136601508,
-0.0947176889,
-0.419087261,
0.4937604666,
0.2312000394,
0.5634835362,
0.5522662997,
0.1550412774,
0.4754735231,
0.3222561181,
-0.3878561556,
0.1576139629,
0.1445928514,
-0.1018141136,
0.1354106069,
0.8764379025,
0.9403164387,
0.3171423972,
-0.5722529292,
0.6587010622,
-0.2576773465,
-0.1958863586,
-0.2929776013,
-0.3548810184,
-0.0714183152,
0.427875936,
0.1026504114,
-0.2288733125,
0.4585238099,
-0.4217593372,
-0.1231978387,
0.3765799403,
-0.3139081597,
-0.2953451276,
0.3861524761,
0.1476932764,
-0.2754822671,
0.5315708518,
-0.0088240169,
-0.5821983218,
0.5711656213,
0.4444325268,
0.6683524847,
-0.5216116309,
0.3069476783,
0.3585341871,
0.2817288637,
0.1663784534,
0.091272071,
-0.1444634646,
-0.8117090464,
-0.4518614113,
-0.5610252619,
-0.1297970265,
0.0189574491,
-0.4796707332,
-0.0727868527,
-0.2209572047,
0.0421971455,
0.2776774466,
0.1873553842,
-0.9189144373,
0.2611240149,
0.2655520141,
0.7949840426,
-1.1219878197,
1.019459486,
0.7293880582,
-0.2788334191,
-0.373673588,
0.0190600585,
-0.0674292222,
-0.4149039686,
0.9635538459,
0.620259881,
-0.0038950648,
-0.2594098151,
-0.2274785787,
-0.6829817295,
1.0589164495,
0.0157272778,
-0.6055656075,
0.4180191159,
0.2838132977,
0.7754498124,
-0.3287160099,
0.3618509173,
0.5718308091,
0.6386861801,
-0.3838561773,
-0.8577858806,
-0.0069720894,
-0.2329866737,
0.2574196756,
0.3011571169,
-0.5398608446,
0.9566549659,
0.2085355818,
-0.3873856366,
-0.060582567,
0.5337347984,
-0.0860029832,
0.3610063195,
0.4691876471,
0.6595547795,
0.8248690367,
-0.1623479426,
1.1005100012,
-0.0676400438,
0.3862071335,
0.7547339797,
-0.3620136082,
0.8118655086,
0.3081685305,
-0.1753584296,
0.7343454361,
0.555142045,
-0.0676139742,
0.6243193746,
0.1329040676,
-0.0832464322,
0.1115422323,
0.1148237363,
-0.463211894,
0.5298864841,
0.3366298676,
-0.2718602419,
-0.1785373539,
0.609094739,
0.0694241002,
0.2132157385,
-0.0614891127,
0.7749803662,
0.0715412274,
-0.2369274646,
0.3950105906,
0.1891288757,
0.8680725098,
-0.2272112072,
0.170297876,
-0.2235478461,
0.5529482961,
-0.1724528819,
-0.6313154697,
0.2740760446,
-0.2482889742,
-0.1655360758,
-0.3836938441,
0.6654280424,
-0.5331190228,
-0.5791215897,
0.7268645167,
0.6752089858,
0.2272027135,
0.0698790476,
-0.7575628161,
0.2874927223,
-0.1116803139,
-0.0012941899,
0.3341078162,
0.5882787704,
-0.2303198874,
0.4622616768,
0.2998150587,
-0.3129303455,
-0.0200070646,
0.5472121835,
0.4246931076,
-0.7168704271,
-0.4923021793,
-0.880887866,
0.0682463124,
-0.3650070727,
-0.1773616672,
1.0973207951,
0.7990273237,
1.0934889317,
-0.3255779445,
0.6323160529,
0.1983884573,
0.5220219493,
-0.5427745581,
0.7960794568,
-0.5547288656,
0.0110732885,
-0.2294253558,
-0.9273682833,
-0.7147552371,
0.5790480375,
-0.2054858655,
-0.005876346,
1.1654801369,
0.4906585217,
-0.1417697221,
-0.0566012487,
0.3050633371,
0.1479505301,
0.3621775508,
0.344442457,
0.9089483619,
-0.4415365756,
0.4027022719,
-0.320939362,
-0.1708321869,
-0.1103367433,
-0.6725918055,
-1.1699073315,
-0.7526229024,
-0.4374929667,
0.2224060893,
-0.1188184917,
0.4837295115,
0.5353793502,
-1.0085172653,
-0.331312269,
0.1522155702,
0.1849085242,
-0.350261867,
-0.2919060588,
0.56562078,
-0.3818414509,
-0.9479689002,
0.5024791956,
0.1898101121,
0.0794126242,
-0.3898630142,
0.1038325056,
-0.1079372391,
-0.2526600361,
0.9683535695,
-0.0772627741,
-0.5933735967,
-0.2133665532,
-0.2419317961,
-0.196424827,
-0.0268063135,
0.9373394251,
-0.6964393258,
0.1700859368,
0.6807935834,
0.7177826762,
0.6377623081,
-0.5110629797,
0.1037833989,
-0.7619134784,
0.5953752995,
-0.0802408606,
0.3635138571,
0.5409958959,
-0.2566097081,
0.4152984023,
0.0155289629,
-0.4841573238,
-0.5843268633,
-0.0035502701,
-0.901905477,
-0.6504833102,
0.857196331,
-0.1914277524,
0.0637537166,
0.113090165,
-0.2010325789,
0.1180010214,
-0.1121635064,
0.5087654591,
0.6145873666,
0.1887269169,
-0.3488030136,
-0.5025058985,
0.4007152617,
0.1521665752,
-0.8306261301,
-0.547801137,
0.179538846,
0.1091481522,
0.5846236348,
0.2240601927,
-0.0063588037,
-0.2228925228,
-0.1990786195,
0.2510614097,
0.2102310508,
-0.5752373934,
-0.6262927651,
0.5567739606,
-0.2440983802,
-0.1217326894
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03788v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03788v1
|
SmoothQuant+: Accurate and Efficient 4-bit Post-Training WeightQuantization for LLM
| 2023-12-06T11:10:55 | 2023-12-06T11:10:55 |
Jiayi Pan, Chengcan Wang, Kaifu Zheng, Yangguang Li, Zhenyu Wang, Bin Feng
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable capabilities in various
tasks. However their huge model size and the consequent demand for
computational and memory resources also pose challenges to model deployment.
Currently, 4-bit post-training quantization (PTQ) has achieved some success in
LLMs, reducing the memory footprint by approximately 75% compared to FP16
models, albeit with some accuracy loss. In this paper, we propose SmoothQuant+,
an accurate and efficient 4-bit weight-only PTQ that requires no additional
training, which enables lossless in accuracy for LLMs for the first time. Based
on the fact that the loss of weight quantization is amplified by the activation
outliers, SmoothQuant+ smoothes the activation outliers by channel before
quantization, while adjusting the corresponding weights for mathematical
equivalence, and then performs group-wise 4-bit weight quantization for linear
layers. We have integrated SmoothQuant+ into the vLLM framework, an advanced
high-throughput inference engine specially developed for LLMs, and equipped it
with an efficient W4A16 CUDA kernels, so that vLLM can seamlessly support
SmoothQuant+ 4-bit weight quantization. Our results show that, with
SmoothQuant+, the Code Llama-34B model can be quantized and deployed on a A100
40GB GPU, achieving lossless accuracy and a throughput increase of 1.9 to 4.0
times compared to the FP16 model deployed on two A100 40GB GPUs. Moreover, the
latency per token is only 68% of the FP16 model deployed on two A100 40GB GPUs.
This is the state-of-the-art 4-bit weight quantization for LLMs as we know.
|
[
-0.0983122811,
-0.7445560694,
0.8137429357,
0.2736358643,
-0.551666677,
0.1555836201,
-0.2240094841,
-0.2363384068,
-0.0135511439,
0.2251704186,
-0.06913656,
-0.3778131008,
-0.5837835073,
-0.3820532262,
-0.4287653863,
0.6837722063,
-0.0601467714,
0.3028165102,
-0.2293294817,
-0.0035913391,
-0.0109737245,
-0.720892489,
-0.9129799604,
-0.3651104569,
0.3812536597,
-0.0149790207,
0.8832073212,
0.5474473834,
0.3677571714,
0.3240028322,
-0.0391022563,
0.0022922975,
-0.3574897349,
-0.1090451181,
0.4541924,
-0.6395384669,
-0.7656801939,
-0.1350156069,
0.7245141268,
0.3981989622,
-0.3109901547,
0.0575423874,
-0.105275698,
0.5518419147,
-0.5834504962,
0.1504305899,
-0.5438658595,
0.034845721,
-0.449919194,
-0.2594566047,
-0.063678816,
-0.6790791154,
-0.1419282854,
-0.7256734967,
0.0909012333,
-0.1329848021,
0.9278537035,
0.2804331481,
-0.4597909153,
0.092552349,
-0.4407917559,
0.8596378565,
-1.1596568823,
0.734552145,
0.0031756142,
0.0428173132,
-0.1138861924,
-0.8875421286,
-0.5967490077,
-0.1511328667,
0.5690838099,
0.0012429351,
0.0303549003,
0.1522597671,
0.1788849235,
0.4476185739,
-0.4401475787,
0.036381539,
-0.1505094618,
-0.3016794622,
0.3513067365,
-0.075333938,
-0.1767055392,
0.3082267642,
-0.3980652392,
-0.081906803,
-0.8245236278,
0.1181848347,
0.5253652334,
-0.0943124443,
-0.1732775867,
0.376672864,
-0.110980317,
0.7781352401,
0.2888250649,
-0.2561737299,
0.2653553784,
-0.1945696175,
-0.207930401,
0.1059716195,
0.757578969,
0.0868683979,
0.2474651039,
-0.0843956918,
-0.3889778852,
0.1082883105,
0.18436189,
-1.1522930861,
-0.4546706975,
0.3176473379,
-0.1059224308,
-0.2684988379,
-0.3260087967,
-0.1836058199,
-0.2952297032,
-0.2837997377,
0.763191402,
-0.6054084897,
-0.1858125031,
0.3771804273,
0.1720548272,
0.3905022144,
0.614361167,
-0.4818488657,
0.520776093,
0.9863793254,
0.8478375077,
-0.1469592303,
0.1025806218,
-0.7054764032,
-0.1241008565,
-0.3626899123,
0.5149611831,
-0.2126728296,
-0.0946321934,
-0.1638421714,
-0.2843180001,
0.1925689429,
-0.3431243002,
0.7920203805,
-0.6944441199,
-0.0158435758,
-0.0081403647,
-0.6651241183,
-0.307364434,
0.3636515737,
-0.4419869781,
1.1360330582,
0.0966333002,
-0.6721365452,
0.2120878547,
-0.0703715011,
-0.2686731517,
0.329752028,
-0.2050533444,
-0.6792547107,
0.3317193985,
0.058047317,
0.3183896542,
-0.3612701297,
0.3978174031,
-0.4611401856,
-0.8669711351,
0.3788609207,
-0.5684069395,
0.6718487144,
0.1267922223,
-0.4049137831,
0.2104099244,
-0.7467768192,
0.408226043,
0.0545203872,
-0.4680301547,
-0.2444322258,
-0.2024371326,
-0.0480548628,
0.235427931,
0.6156637669,
-0.6820117235,
-0.0197617989,
-0.3311626613,
0.4893291295,
0.6369167566,
-0.3938954771,
0.386197567,
-0.1714271307,
0.4779772758,
-0.0682415441,
0.346874088,
0.249871105,
-0.6624063253,
-0.7732268572,
-0.4277492166,
0.4880475402,
0.541734159,
-0.892675817,
0.3151064515,
-0.5304527283,
-0.3575011194,
-0.460351944,
0.1308778971,
0.4253696501,
0.4021311104,
0.1943312436,
-0.4225905538,
-0.2059247792,
-0.5867310166,
0.0033902104,
-0.0193398315,
-0.2807503045,
0.0531479567,
0.0471298955,
0.0261104479,
0.4464671016,
-0.307374239,
0.0518610775,
0.0773022696,
-0.0697437599,
0.1845536977,
0.5547032356,
0.2395081222,
-0.5594619513,
-0.3582191765,
-0.0285659488,
-0.4764142036,
-0.0531735457,
0.1118514985,
-0.2209349722,
0.1031426638,
0.2189046144,
-0.7490642071,
0.2541732788,
0.9377582669,
-0.1162953749,
0.3758972883,
-0.4333394766,
0.1468487233,
-0.913600266,
-0.1245681718,
0.2153749913,
-0.5998754501,
-0.488045156,
0.0588654429,
0.449580133,
-0.1408195347,
-0.4671265781,
0.3785285354,
-0.2176573724,
-0.0779861212,
-0.0742342472,
0.0678725615,
0.4213980734,
0.6311476827,
0.1315255016,
0.7205197215,
0.5301529169,
-0.475220263,
0.2965402305,
-0.2367016226,
-0.1812802404,
0.6457211375,
-0.6825184226,
0.1883914918,
-0.0419157296,
0.2271537632,
-0.7879337072,
0.1980202198,
0.2068257481,
-0.2220281512,
0.4684354663,
-0.2038831115,
-0.5043392181,
-0.1186430454,
-0.7339356542,
0.5624529123,
0.5549538732,
-0.2372025847,
0.3933746219,
0.2625791728,
-0.049504295,
-0.3846037686,
-0.7334820032,
-0.0510028377,
-0.2006969154,
-0.6892538667,
0.393063724,
-0.1580215693,
-0.0449229665,
-0.2030806839,
-0.3810135722,
-0.3249518871,
-0.0319267288,
0.2039520442,
0.1130451784,
-0.2598003149,
-0.1216974407,
0.08993233,
0.0177555978,
-0.0034046029,
-0.408737421,
0.5840220451,
-0.3073149621,
-0.1529184282,
-0.4870333672,
0.0635336116,
0.3049514294,
-0.2358877659,
0.500338912,
0.9900975227,
-0.3511001766,
0.0691538304,
-0.6680639982,
-0.0870266333,
-0.4931863844,
0.2948137522,
-0.4622443914,
-1.0940667391,
0.3545174897,
-0.0337785296,
0.0361358635,
0.0964744315,
0.4062403738,
0.0515120439,
0.9339870811,
0.4734425843,
0.1903506368,
0.5104251504,
-0.2237301618,
0.2833522856,
-0.7844645381,
-0.1098702997,
-0.3364785314,
-0.204538241,
-0.4993195534,
-0.7553226352,
0.404163003,
0.2236363739,
-0.4657820165,
0.1235282049,
-0.345903337,
0.0162162334,
0.5466022491,
0.4180996418,
0.2953948081,
0.0326280482,
0.2192444503,
-0.0641370788,
-0.5469323993,
-0.163180843,
1.1430462599,
0.3663935065,
0.969017148,
0.1026084349,
0.667527318,
-0.0017410151,
0.3420474231,
-0.8578208089,
0.444634974,
-0.1507280767,
-0.2721656263,
-0.2102267444,
-0.8442594409,
-0.5890815258,
0.2806805968,
-0.0929077342,
-0.4442806542,
0.0713520944,
0.2410828471,
-0.6413573027,
0.2987549305,
-0.7424094081,
0.6905547976,
-0.3741075397,
-0.4467552304,
-0.1247201264,
-0.4364647865,
0.7156275511,
-0.4319743216,
0.1395179927,
-0.3245966136,
-0.4674630165,
0.6680020094,
-0.7215214968,
0.2620194256,
-0.2404829562,
-0.4638645351,
0.2609968483,
0.134970814,
0.7372925878,
0.1975760311,
-0.1927791983,
0.4265025854,
0.1331890523,
-0.4399439096,
-0.5512878299,
1.067912221,
-0.6919932961,
-0.4246197939,
-0.3907279074,
-0.6447381973,
-0.2999304831,
0.0413171649,
-0.0960396975,
0.6882690787,
0.4811659455,
0.1341212839,
0.9821665287,
-0.2330449224,
0.4378846586,
0.4580222368,
-0.1840720624,
-0.4969233871,
1.0270060301,
0.0642631948,
0.2638165355,
0.4114575386,
0.1156739965,
-0.4778117239,
-0.8597423434,
-0.3938033879,
0.2364697307,
-0.3701779842,
-0.5648050308,
-0.6520228386,
-0.1874611229,
-0.2576010525,
0.0183502771,
-0.6303230524,
-0.6103547812,
-0.1037092805,
0.1981848776,
0.6298316717,
0.1181570366,
0.0956388116,
0.8569021821,
-0.7214652896,
0.2411266267,
0.2913470864,
0.4981304407,
-0.2244303674,
-0.7318400741,
-0.380580008,
0.0419612043,
-0.4250904322,
-0.5105127096,
0.4585706294,
0.3774495423,
0.0314818434,
0.3795098662,
-0.230467394,
0.9271953106,
-0.4588576555,
0.5627560019,
0.1120967567,
-1.1060856581,
-0.1425937116,
-0.1356976479,
0.5020269156,
0.4961996377,
0.4400509894,
-0.1477603018,
-0.2960653305,
-0.5687531233,
-0.7450369596,
0.3947248459,
0.1310961545,
0.131311819,
0.3794698715,
0.598662734,
-0.1260355413,
0.5261293054,
-0.6997255087,
-0.2233599871,
-0.2170223445,
-0.305326134,
0.0873614773,
-0.321922332,
0.2157776803,
-0.2606402934,
0.7370976806,
-0.077661179,
0.2856107652,
-0.045645766,
-0.0223237518,
-0.199903667,
0.0635343194,
0.3464121521,
0.7659788728,
-0.4846216738,
0.2945600152,
0.0532567315,
-0.6693227291,
0.1924746484,
0.5272762179,
-0.1768024713,
-0.0288663357,
-0.1028707102,
0.6274884343,
0.5515409708,
-0.5338191986,
0.7759279609,
-0.3339779377,
-0.068528235,
-0.2106978446,
-0.1718102396,
0.1283820719,
0.3130159676,
0.3059327304,
-0.0312383976,
0.2283764035,
-0.1955156177,
0.3034987748,
0.6407179832,
-0.343406707,
-0.3945926726,
0.9352041483,
0.1065269709,
-0.0248774141,
0.3777789772,
-0.2777573168,
-0.3960496187,
0.251208216,
0.2381986231,
0.594699204,
-0.2773902118,
0.0794319808,
0.11097534,
0.0992294177,
-0.1280777901,
0.6903159022,
-0.0280196071,
-0.6941555142,
-1.0851460695,
-0.9587250352,
-0.3779687285,
0.131160289,
-0.3927376866,
0.1605339944,
-0.6858571768,
-0.4308423102,
-0.1959111243,
0.3944377303,
-0.6262962818,
0.2571810186,
0.3822893202,
0.7077159882,
-0.3962498307,
1.3773936033,
0.3115166128,
0.0240842588,
-0.9183026552,
-0.3806479275,
-0.2735206485,
-0.8609628081,
0.2956556082,
0.0036979152,
0.101671122,
0.4142883122,
-0.4858028889,
-0.8950428963,
1.00392735,
0.6729720831,
-0.8435047865,
0.1807697564,
-0.0145169627,
0.1926225126,
0.2080823183,
0.4274922311,
0.3988086283,
0.3075123131,
0.311737895,
-0.8281459808,
0.1790462434,
0.0542447492,
0.0858263448,
0.5319903493,
-0.664652586,
1.233348608,
0.0272099655,
0.1316883415,
0.1444074959,
0.7493688464,
0.464137733,
-0.0427274182,
0.4023212194,
0.759853363,
0.6234120727,
-0.232588768,
1.0588160753,
-0.5422747731,
0.2435602546,
0.9514733553,
-0.3277383447,
0.7562469244,
0.5250863433,
-0.3709773123,
0.2621208131,
0.5930734277,
0.4865808189,
0.357572943,
0.5348010063,
-0.6860281229,
-0.3481038809,
0.0455244146,
-0.338983953,
0.1057415307,
0.3192200661,
0.2262652665,
-0.2302309573,
-0.3367317915,
0.3893721998,
-0.3729020953,
-0.4879589677,
0.3065828085,
0.325153321,
-0.2695414722,
0.7496242523,
0.2794117033,
1.0580515862,
-0.922781527,
-0.0335143358,
-0.3219536245,
0.3444847167,
-0.2876631618,
-0.5164163709,
-0.0919527039,
-0.1547895819,
0.3920572698,
-0.1725262254,
0.4650529623,
-0.62337327,
-0.755422473,
-0.1549019367,
0.3875961006,
0.2063464373,
-0.5884103179,
-0.7121028304,
0.4933851957,
-0.0415790454,
-0.3253082931,
0.5021791458,
0.737788856,
-0.1809330136,
0.7220177054,
0.6727264524,
0.3117510974,
0.4684039652,
0.1275132895,
0.8658542633,
-0.4321200252,
-0.1960974485,
-0.6249469519,
0.35617733,
0.1879215389,
-0.1288669705,
0.8670393825,
0.6191447377,
0.6350678802,
0.2673294842,
0.4530489743,
0.1006309837,
0.0201803502,
-0.436674118,
0.4544920921,
-0.586297214,
0.1790695339,
-0.0811230764,
-0.9891163707,
-0.4078558385,
0.5001994967,
-0.2021736205,
0.0501290523,
0.5240103006,
0.7967100143,
-0.0033758879,
-0.3087124825,
0.46494174,
-0.0278858617,
0.3812899888,
0.7871524692,
0.433295548,
-0.7238385081,
0.7066434026,
-0.4563802183,
-0.3036523461,
-0.0241576992,
-0.9447526932,
-0.4535995424,
-0.1112214923,
-0.636985898,
-0.2514918745,
0.1508739144,
0.6314531565,
0.7355553508,
-0.6229812503,
-0.2780665755,
-0.0742038488,
0.0205562636,
-0.0395309776,
-0.2166700512,
0.4105832577,
-0.2494352162,
-0.7125905156,
0.2280296981,
0.2238158435,
0.0812653899,
-0.4328887165,
-0.3194697797,
-0.0976843536,
0.1020120755,
0.56407094,
0.0908344463,
-0.4945637286,
-0.206489712,
-0.2332480401,
-0.0785128325,
0.2008250654,
0.728636682,
-0.8724483252,
0.297873199,
0.3547732234,
0.6584676504,
0.8826856017,
0.04865399,
0.5627748966,
-0.6924253702,
0.4436638951,
0.2985720932,
0.238509208,
0.5037079453,
-0.3350334764,
0.2519675791,
0.162553668,
-0.5719658732,
-0.6907989383,
-0.1429888159,
-1.1230180264,
0.1408963352,
0.9538541436,
-0.3004936874,
-0.352022171,
0.2434155494,
-0.1445094794,
0.2924286425,
-0.5703212619,
0.4997337461,
0.2936969399,
-0.1104820669,
-0.4367643893,
-0.6329537034,
0.5691596866,
0.380534023,
-0.6789104342,
-0.4296523929,
0.4655992389,
0.2955036759,
-0.2801403999,
0.6340973377,
-0.194974944,
0.0293281861,
-0.1259055585,
0.3113560081,
-0.0956078544,
0.0407422371,
-0.4109265506,
0.1712035388,
0.3068200052,
-0.1314108372
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03414v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03414v2
|
Compressed Context Memory For Online Language Model Interaction
| 2023-12-06T10:50:43 | 2024-02-06T05:53:02 |
Jang-Hyun Kim, Junyoung Yeom, Sangdoo Yun, Hyun Oh Song
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
This paper presents a context key/value compression method for Transformer
language models in online scenarios, where the context continually expands. As
the context lengthens, the attention process demands increasing memory and
computations, which in turn reduces the throughput of the language model. To
address this challenge, we propose a compressed context memory system that
continually compresses the accumulating attention key/value pairs into a
compact memory space, facilitating language model inference in a limited memory
space of computing environments. Our compression process involves integrating a
lightweight conditional LoRA into the language model's forward pass during
inference, without the need for fine-tuning the model's entire set of weights.
We achieve efficient training by modeling the recursive compression process as
a single parallelized forward computation. Through evaluations on conversation,
personalization, and multi-task learning, we demonstrate that our approach
achieves the performance level of a full context model with $5\times$ smaller
context memory size. We further demonstrate the applicability of our approach
in a streaming setting with an unlimited context length, outperforming the
sliding window approach. Codes are available at
https://github.com/snu-mllab/context-memory.
|
[
-0.4828380942,
-0.7476673126,
0.5321189761,
0.1720467806,
-0.1450309753,
-0.3451136053,
-0.6811245084,
-0.3703955114,
0.3884537816,
0.4432787001,
-0.5743699074,
-0.119021818,
-0.5526612401,
-0.070926033,
-0.4448268712,
0.6386201978,
0.0672047809,
-0.4063341022,
-0.352732718,
-0.2223230004,
-0.670217514,
-0.5587977767,
-0.7000141144,
0.0154583761,
0.2891053557,
0.2298132628,
0.4068110883,
0.4780302346,
0.3397552967,
0.3539445996,
-0.2393607944,
-0.0724273399,
-0.752296567,
0.3920478523,
0.0631657243,
-0.3071465194,
-0.4739701748,
-0.2043955773,
0.6881309152,
0.5234025717,
-0.305229187,
0.1598764062,
-0.0177340582,
0.4701320231,
-0.9822536707,
0.1936626136,
-0.5574230552,
0.1495033205,
0.1997119486,
-0.2891790569,
-0.5491517186,
-0.1350022852,
0.0709713995,
-0.3548135757,
-0.0034075426,
-0.2009854317,
0.6981847882,
0.7534419298,
-0.1982408315,
0.1005259007,
-0.7534087896,
0.7494276166,
-0.6922588348,
0.519579947,
0.3579369187,
0.4569495618,
0.1987664104,
-0.8721246123,
-0.5993998647,
0.1471318603,
-0.0206747502,
-0.0089031802,
-0.0773266554,
0.0303643383,
0.35862872,
0.3434125483,
-0.2908307314,
-0.2570382357,
-0.3430321813,
0.0162836891,
0.2732267082,
0.0244411193,
0.0914082304,
0.1678646654,
-0.2750157416,
-0.1126284972,
-0.6659830213,
0.0443853848,
0.0146941757,
0.3074213564,
-0.1753975004,
0.2253482044,
-0.3316075504,
0.9075796008,
0.1003444642,
-0.2281577885,
0.1529265493,
-0.1543417722,
-0.4243176281,
0.0445830785,
0.4776443243,
0.296264708,
0.0095671136,
-0.3674649894,
-0.0925854445,
0.2039556801,
0.5469563007,
-1.0434553623,
0.054258626,
0.3369321525,
-0.2676851153,
-0.0066676242,
-0.12278606,
-0.7357331514,
0.0316596664,
-0.1157692447,
0.3677627444,
-0.3467863202,
0.0468422025,
0.1774483621,
-0.0255602971,
-0.0193860363,
0.3036138415,
-0.9072524309,
0.5700496435,
0.3987185061,
0.7384075522,
-0.3105732203,
-0.1432541758,
-0.7789930105,
0.2584355474,
0.3783924282,
0.8387161493,
-0.5855267048,
-0.2859717011,
0.0810808912,
-0.0164095182,
-0.1051002815,
-0.4332945645,
0.5792385936,
-0.7121032476,
0.2404948026,
0.1048034728,
-0.6785771251,
-0.0200121235,
0.3154424131,
-0.7551723123,
0.8679295182,
0.1927344352,
-0.6851488948,
-0.1136343703,
-0.6242859364,
-0.2815604508,
0.1272118539,
-0.2252935022,
-0.2554382384,
0.1301016659,
0.242372036,
0.5477300286,
-0.1461984515,
0.2478138208,
-0.1557740271,
-0.6074540019,
0.2831910253,
-0.3018606007,
0.411154747,
0.183559373,
-0.1375518292,
0.1431516409,
-0.5458644032,
0.1580439955,
0.1983395368,
-0.7573598027,
-0.170685336,
0.0042250874,
0.1943766326,
0.2325688452,
0.3930844367,
-0.5549930334,
0.4174947143,
-0.365870446,
0.6819820404,
0.3762330115,
-0.1209691614,
0.5088037252,
-0.0599500947,
0.340479821,
-0.0670249462,
0.1238620728,
-0.5354671478,
-0.3042688668,
-1.0516346693,
-0.0899011791,
0.3267690837,
0.3490584195,
-0.5351933241,
0.5825316906,
-0.9068235755,
0.131682843,
-0.4251021147,
0.0162942521,
0.2275771201,
0.4201669991,
0.4267995059,
-0.1710811555,
-0.5819081068,
-0.8238681555,
-0.0304068383,
0.2739552557,
-0.3081941605,
0.5292241573,
0.1221797466,
-0.4599499106,
1.2296916246,
-0.6397582889,
-0.3224250078,
-0.2565635741,
-0.056394469,
0.0751224607,
0.4663570225,
0.3229269683,
-0.8794795871,
-0.3483654857,
-0.4487072825,
-0.3792777956,
-0.1030185297,
-0.0412501246,
0.1226754114,
0.2695106864,
0.5186384916,
-0.6310079098,
0.4624494612,
1.032389164,
-0.3175476789,
-0.041295249,
-0.2007591575,
0.109644495,
-1.1079528332,
0.2078959048,
-0.2540062368,
-0.5843833089,
-0.7028731704,
0.2478423417,
0.2439428419,
-0.243038699,
-0.7283609509,
0.6381229758,
-0.417301476,
-0.0905478001,
-0.5505304337,
0.4078837335,
-0.0273145344,
0.9147434235,
0.3535522819,
0.7823527455,
0.2816529572,
-0.7148961425,
0.1119957268,
0.1997472346,
-0.3534400463,
0.4078703523,
-0.4475281835,
0.3780833185,
-0.0591764189,
0.5311802626,
-0.749268651,
-0.2228919119,
0.0131091299,
-0.2612607181,
0.4189681411,
-0.0516941063,
-0.4149391651,
-0.0895441398,
-0.069425419,
0.5437415242,
0.5628342628,
-0.5297532082,
0.6752354503,
0.6360378265,
0.0288840104,
-0.3381462097,
-0.873034656,
0.103816174,
-0.2768518329,
-0.6737518311,
0.7167314887,
-0.3665544391,
0.0598955005,
0.0859071761,
-0.0751966611,
-0.3132957518,
-0.0373981223,
0.2923733592,
0.1132219955,
-0.1712045819,
0.1100239977,
0.0255884137,
-0.1365628839,
-0.2044072449,
-0.2078396678,
0.6777247787,
-0.2294804305,
-0.0547630899,
-0.3499054611,
0.5101887584,
0.4512980282,
0.1696411073,
1.059683919,
0.2175283581,
-0.5096882582,
-0.1166796982,
-0.6617907882,
-0.3368770778,
-0.5011119843,
0.1054081097,
-0.3887761235,
-1.2791436911,
0.5034769177,
-0.1719316095,
-0.1110041961,
0.1498812288,
0.4638400674,
0.1858862638,
0.7402193546,
0.7871383429,
-0.2377365381,
0.5989499688,
-0.2548036277,
0.230020225,
-1.0836397409,
0.0713874623,
-0.1972246468,
-0.3855276704,
-0.1503321826,
-0.6691675186,
0.3394627869,
0.1135260686,
-0.1690573245,
0.5756621957,
-0.5294092894,
0.6949373484,
0.1824545711,
0.2868528962,
0.1787801832,
-0.0763945356,
0.1136565134,
0.1199634746,
-0.9356549978,
-0.0917061865,
0.6307283044,
0.3352358937,
0.6437785029,
0.2040061951,
0.4622056782,
0.053128019,
0.4157330692,
-0.8224544525,
0.5442807674,
0.317946285,
-0.4366541803,
-0.3619633019,
-0.4689074159,
-0.9419381022,
0.1280843616,
0.0695954338,
-1.2393624783,
-0.0334522538,
0.2390749902,
-0.703099668,
0.1645492911,
-0.6228622794,
0.8715960979,
0.1036254987,
-0.4398141205,
-0.3950275183,
-0.8278084397,
0.378875643,
0.0147226695,
0.0787080824,
0.143572703,
-0.1313041598,
0.6438229084,
-0.3858100176,
1.0877481699,
-0.0224878695,
-0.0175712965,
0.2549017668,
0.0302602556,
0.6737357378,
-0.0914148167,
0.1770779639,
0.251552254,
-0.0628369823,
-0.3106488585,
-0.7524263859,
0.9616520405,
-0.5141865611,
-0.5164441466,
-0.1440780014,
-0.5977901816,
-0.3324528039,
-0.0563006438,
0.1550138891,
0.3498095274,
-0.0226319153,
0.4559628367,
0.7256243229,
-0.2327342033,
0.6607109904,
0.3680072725,
-0.1051607877,
-0.3584313989,
0.6606407166,
-0.1139603704,
0.330558002,
0.6007266641,
0.2485495359,
-0.2383619696,
-0.088648051,
-0.2151319981,
0.0624596141,
-0.8751586676,
-0.3176929057,
-0.8508947492,
-0.3539339006,
-0.5206674337,
-0.2720066011,
-0.5787956715,
-0.4529926181,
-0.0873343721,
0.2340140343,
0.3405888081,
0.1963639408,
0.3497646749,
0.5529536605,
-1.0149301291,
0.2389259785,
0.3079437912,
0.477917105,
0.1436531693,
-0.6253938079,
-0.4802820086,
-0.2038619071,
-0.2267721891,
-0.7422817349,
0.6263998151,
0.3330511749,
0.3852276802,
0.6546664834,
0.1220212355,
0.8183369637,
-0.6873357892,
0.6870180368,
0.0360420235,
-0.9584205747,
0.438810885,
0.0183976106,
0.7674217224,
0.5726719499,
0.1743828058,
-0.6979468465,
-0.1678649187,
-0.722184062,
-0.8805987835,
0.6436520815,
0.3334615827,
0.181870535,
-0.029510187,
0.3287958503,
-0.1798334122,
0.2415880263,
-0.7508386374,
-0.2732102573,
-0.1366955489,
-0.0981684178,
-0.0981847942,
-0.4115859866,
-0.0561105348,
-0.2333953828,
0.219137311,
-0.3472749889,
0.6772577763,
0.0406941697,
-0.1473912895,
0.0149484491,
0.3447046578,
0.7885841131,
0.3476770818,
-0.2135096043,
0.2347778529,
0.4324159622,
-0.3336431086,
-0.0538725629,
-0.0907049179,
-0.0406821705,
-0.2030088305,
0.0114583196,
1.0178716183,
0.9195728898,
-0.91859442,
0.5466869473,
-0.4014540315,
0.1893696636,
-0.397878617,
0.0208815876,
0.3255802095,
0.1468585879,
0.1217119545,
-0.0812662616,
0.03678222,
-0.4862319827,
0.1433428675,
0.2211957276,
-0.3576771617,
-0.2146529704,
0.5761067867,
0.2613258362,
-0.3655906022,
0.468100667,
-0.0185686387,
-0.5810282826,
0.2398867905,
0.7014405727,
0.8480401039,
-0.3103187084,
-0.3595172763,
0.4604088068,
-0.0940974057,
-0.1702913791,
0.171093747,
-0.712685287,
-0.8267588615,
-0.6418097615,
-0.7225070596,
-0.3805190921,
0.3053828776,
-0.4588131607,
0.0467716679,
-0.1642508358,
-0.1327551305,
-0.5208635926,
-0.3033697903,
-0.5508931279,
0.1754434109,
0.2939466536,
0.9451752901,
-0.4588363171,
1.3599609137,
0.1969556063,
-0.1846404076,
-0.528839767,
0.008002351,
-0.1544878185,
-0.3819164932,
0.7842488885,
0.4580078125,
-0.2335782051,
-0.0117491465,
-0.3015346825,
-1.1304308176,
0.932744205,
0.3746787608,
-0.5446927547,
0.0191796049,
-0.0983201712,
0.471149236,
-0.5353288651,
0.0768529922,
0.5258290172,
0.3606229424,
0.2113724351,
-0.7263508439,
0.2037629336,
-0.2214991897,
0.0342530906,
0.2546031177,
-0.6157049537,
0.62069875,
0.0696611702,
-0.6113157868,
-0.0442797653,
0.8291525841,
0.1191607714,
-0.0950768366,
0.5690118074,
0.7703312635,
0.4145341814,
0.127554059,
1.0751132965,
-0.7509008646,
0.4075514078,
1.316364646,
-0.3190870881,
1.204872489,
0.7528604269,
0.0780265406,
0.3804398775,
0.3176747859,
0.485568136,
0.6255035996,
-0.0360715538,
-0.4507493675,
-0.2530457973,
-0.0500817075,
-0.1865160018,
0.1472840011,
0.4485718906,
-0.1667261273,
-0.128376469,
0.0208739862,
-0.1676572263,
-0.1366767734,
-0.0901138633,
0.6439882517,
0.1465258598,
-0.947332859,
0.6319959164,
0.0991497487,
0.7979654074,
-0.5314273834,
0.1754463166,
-0.1373412758,
0.3008916974,
0.0822490528,
-0.4287304878,
0.6230784655,
0.0913661644,
-0.0952363685,
-0.507160306,
0.6869077086,
-0.5197644234,
-0.1041786745,
0.2883969843,
0.2512020171,
0.1569109708,
-0.2699786723,
-0.2918244004,
0.4410299361,
-0.2659481764,
-0.4960763752,
0.597830534,
0.0006310582,
0.2218675166,
0.7769501805,
0.4368501306,
-0.0795098692,
0.1446881741,
-0.0022881746,
1.0621231794,
-0.6044104695,
-0.7970948815,
-0.7054501772,
0.4007750154,
-0.1390486062,
-0.078863889,
0.6431044936,
0.4701029062,
0.8360728621,
-0.1123217866,
0.5441657305,
-0.0287907384,
0.3248619735,
-0.5571842194,
0.6118011475,
-0.4771156609,
0.1817698181,
0.1559911817,
-0.7442784905,
-0.2417583168,
0.6961214542,
-0.1280968338,
-0.1259319037,
0.8506721854,
0.4450385869,
-0.3736152053,
-0.0856468827,
0.5504305959,
-0.021816073,
0.0585435778,
0.8827805519,
0.4380175173,
-0.5242370367,
0.5791033506,
-0.2366538048,
-0.0307568125,
-0.3424391448,
-1.0101245642,
-0.8617546558,
-0.6595448256,
-0.3487719595,
-0.250677526,
-0.1793884337,
0.9122458696,
1.041326642,
-0.6462075114,
-0.1577964723,
-0.1764955372,
-0.2186579406,
-0.1759712547,
-0.2580142021,
0.2056921422,
-0.3228651583,
-0.8271100521,
0.667288065,
0.3482225537,
-0.0923877582,
-0.5492690206,
-0.238325417,
-0.0517179742,
0.2214934081,
0.6697722673,
0.3771364093,
-0.6629280448,
-0.312245816,
-0.1473201215,
-0.1203007922,
0.3390610516,
1.0269179344,
-1.1951022148,
0.3379143178,
0.6189055443,
0.8693714738,
0.8661740422,
-0.0155917825,
0.4734503031,
-1.0485554934,
0.5247786641,
0.1014066711,
0.5484052896,
0.2644828856,
-0.4653666615,
0.3704516292,
0.0622264706,
-0.5767779946,
-0.6367486119,
0.2806724608,
-1.1506136656,
-0.5600188971,
1.1103179455,
-0.2845968902,
-0.4218937159,
0.1581492722,
-0.0195876751,
0.2006244361,
-0.5249857306,
0.9566401243,
0.5403867364,
-0.164151907,
-0.4853070676,
-0.5909196734,
0.4664416015,
0.1550334543,
-0.8311984539,
0.1053934172,
0.416003257,
0.0208287556,
0.3696551919,
0.5375615954,
0.3774145842,
0.0519812815,
-0.0164699927,
0.1453854442,
0.0233250689,
-0.3673780262,
-0.5643052459,
0.5796909332,
-0.5204889178,
-0.0298432633
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03379v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03379v1
|
A Text-to-Text Model for Multilingual Offensive Language Identification
| 2023-12-06T09:37:27 | 2023-12-06T09:37:27 |
Tharindu Ranasinghe, Marcos Zampieri
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
The ubiquity of offensive content on social media is a growing cause for
concern among companies and government organizations. Recently,
transformer-based models such as BERT, XLNET, and XLM-R have achieved
state-of-the-art performance in detecting various forms of offensive content
(e.g. hate speech, cyberbullying, and cyberaggression). However, the majority
of these models are limited in their capabilities due to their encoder-only
architecture, which restricts the number and types of labels in downstream
tasks. Addressing these limitations, this study presents the first pre-trained
model with encoder-decoder architecture for offensive language identification
with text-to-text transformers (T5) trained on two large offensive language
identification datasets; SOLID and CCTK. We investigate the effectiveness of
combining two datasets and selecting an optimal threshold in semi-supervised
instances in SOLID in the T5 retraining step. Our pre-trained T5 model
outperforms other transformer-based models fine-tuned for offensive language
detection, such as fBERT and HateBERT, in multiple English benchmarks.
Following a similar approach, we also train the first multilingual pre-trained
model for offensive language identification using mT5 and evaluate its
performance on a set of six different languages (German, Hindi, Korean,
Marathi, Sinhala, and Spanish). The results demonstrate that this multilingual
model achieves a new state-of-the-art on all the above datasets, showing its
usefulness in multilingual scenarios. Our proposed T5-based models will be made
freely available to the community.
|
[
-0.1937463284,
-0.6804941893,
-0.0490620993,
0.2374591976,
-0.4265309274,
0.2858692408,
-0.3322202265,
-0.7292882204,
-0.2156835943,
0.4221557975,
-0.3162902296,
-0.5874528885,
-0.9585246444,
0.4001758099,
-0.7477971315,
1.0252997875,
0.0891802683,
-0.2272651047,
0.5303830504,
-0.2636908889,
-0.2674975693,
-0.6353169084,
-0.5966843367,
0.0467612781,
0.5823448896,
0.0839931071,
0.3707813323,
0.4356450737,
0.540951848,
0.4150433242,
0.095120661,
0.1089709401,
-0.6917148829,
-0.1971086115,
-0.2244866937,
-0.0811186731,
-0.2452691346,
-0.3112309575,
0.1799342036,
-0.0987825692,
-0.0185215082,
0.1043391749,
-0.204156369,
0.0078258542,
-0.8638398647,
-0.080394417,
-0.6868019104,
0.0973744318,
-0.4423328638,
0.2085090727,
-0.8637630343,
-0.2149516642,
-0.1328435391,
-0.416015625,
0.0467661284,
-0.3010262549,
0.713460505,
0.0402720198,
-0.4598635733,
-0.4320584238,
-0.8216158748,
0.7924315333,
-0.6680895686,
0.801292181,
0.2473160028,
0.3025225699,
0.3874140084,
-0.7597218752,
-0.5038602948,
-0.0047065984,
-0.1433479339,
0.1617278308,
-0.487257123,
-0.1738654375,
-0.08917173,
0.0315665491,
-0.4583298564,
0.3820302188,
-0.5316517353,
-0.2476671934,
0.5486583114,
-0.0675341934,
0.5637462139,
-0.0324236415,
-0.4630337656,
0.1099082455,
-0.2813579738,
-0.1106650159,
0.4145100415,
0.5857669115,
-0.3520459235,
0.1938134134,
0.1717981547,
0.2654896677,
0.1558637023,
-0.1166172549,
0.3886879981,
-0.151294291,
-0.0995610431,
0.1039134413,
1.095610857,
0.185473457,
0.5559005141,
-0.4211753011,
-0.4359440207,
0.3648838401,
0.6382286549,
-0.9020441175,
-0.1700680852,
0.1428833604,
-0.2611539066,
-0.5610278845,
-0.254904598,
-0.8268444538,
-0.4101845622,
0.1190994978,
0.3337754309,
-0.4975695908,
-0.6750306487,
-0.1743991673,
-0.0800205022,
0.3188052475,
-0.0884930193,
-0.816860795,
0.2871252,
0.5072290897,
0.3732585311,
-0.3924077153,
-0.111677587,
-0.0560533516,
0.0141616343,
-0.3657212853,
0.4237381816,
-0.8422312737,
-0.0814964697,
0.3777877688,
0.2046479434,
0.2012965381,
-0.4546466172,
0.9141533971,
-1.0475962162,
0.0475171357,
0.1296984255,
-0.0674244538,
-0.1265136003,
0.3965826631,
-0.6365263462,
0.9508365989,
0.0342383981,
-0.9023011327,
0.2694211006,
-0.5338256955,
-0.5902339816,
0.2357895523,
0.0469647981,
-0.7278317213,
-0.0805956572,
0.2396347225,
0.2823034227,
-0.2235075831,
0.2580651939,
-0.2922593355,
-0.1244241297,
0.0864614844,
-0.6634634733,
0.9477226138,
0.4695956707,
-0.2544544041,
0.109661296,
-0.6142562628,
-0.203995049,
0.5840280652,
-0.2886062264,
-0.3053182662,
-0.0884886682,
0.3662086427,
0.238079384,
0.2584390938,
-0.8276680112,
-0.5737090111,
-0.183331579,
0.3171637058,
0.6114007235,
-0.3799452186,
0.13516967,
-0.0716866031,
0.508870244,
0.3440393507,
0.1553886384,
-0.1041779891,
-0.2935049832,
-0.4882521033,
-0.2748530209,
0.2689803243,
0.9222093225,
-0.8819260597,
0.2084285319,
-0.4071237445,
-0.5846176744,
-0.4863377512,
-0.157824859,
0.7223597765,
0.2262833863,
0.4765282273,
-0.0896086022,
-0.7668007016,
-0.7557545304,
-0.4332390428,
-0.0455036163,
0.0247624833,
0.2151604146,
0.4744688869,
-0.1005374864,
0.7678002715,
0.0243717227,
-0.2290578634,
-0.467305243,
0.1523483247,
-0.0597397573,
0.0644003674,
0.6831233501,
-0.9705075026,
-0.8486710191,
0.1760870665,
-0.6108581424,
-0.3565218151,
0.3295340538,
0.2213470191,
0.1159546822,
0.300660193,
-0.0082563628,
0.2999098301,
0.5799070597,
-0.1386437863,
0.4098077416,
0.0600677095,
0.3546955884,
-1.1621794701,
-0.1075818986,
0.1709794849,
-0.2333728224,
-1.2620844841,
0.0646012351,
0.2727468908,
-0.2433285266,
-0.9159306288,
0.3883034587,
-0.1724409163,
0.3842789233,
-0.0469329283,
-0.0890083313,
-0.3215561211,
0.5611197352,
0.1765087843,
0.6839199066,
0.224183023,
-0.5309072137,
0.2552322447,
0.2235319316,
-0.3225108683,
0.4502392113,
-0.4632853568,
0.3595530689,
-0.3925770521,
-0.0278039426,
-0.9562547803,
-0.0762365907,
0.5771193504,
-0.5796881914,
0.2787656188,
-0.3263300359,
-0.230935514,
-0.4062222838,
-0.0339826308,
0.7262274027,
0.3564518392,
-0.7598409057,
0.9208142161,
0.6127921343,
-0.0220007244,
-1.0535595417,
-0.6941629052,
0.1363453716,
-0.5088204145,
-0.3577330709,
0.4460721016,
0.1304633766,
0.0609041415,
-0.3924752772,
0.2522770762,
-0.6450568438,
0.1072384641,
-0.1440336406,
0.1746935844,
-0.0468730442,
0.0257536918,
-0.115238592,
0.1558343768,
0.2089862227,
0.0532671362,
0.4168231785,
0.0912651196,
-0.0952464715,
-0.3430619538,
0.5192385316,
0.5783090591,
-0.6165761352,
0.6025028229,
0.8515688777,
-0.4427804649,
-0.0714483187,
-0.4376520216,
0.0402317047,
-0.476410836,
0.8194702864,
-0.4055962563,
-0.7587072253,
0.4356333911,
0.0350181051,
0.4154536128,
0.3378919959,
0.5350778103,
0.2110292464,
0.8503596783,
0.6357868314,
-0.2765724063,
0.6741703153,
0.2831731737,
0.4288826585,
-0.242155239,
-0.0657248572,
-0.6833038926,
0.0509036928,
-0.6749557257,
-0.237147972,
0.0611465462,
-0.3585804403,
-0.3564935625,
0.553907454,
-0.5356200337,
0.5345464349,
-0.1462665647,
0.1904253811,
0.0128421569,
0.0281352047,
-0.0209442191,
-0.1344378442,
-0.515650928,
-0.4179414809,
1.122551918,
0.4966644645,
0.5723257065,
0.5143142939,
0.3486060798,
0.503749311,
0.6553522348,
-0.5352826118,
0.30908373,
-0.7280718684,
-0.9568628073,
-0.1520780474,
-0.4102063179,
-0.9365698099,
0.3057784736,
-0.2838557065,
-0.6737337112,
0.0514714904,
0.041725155,
-0.162105307,
0.5704068542,
-0.8313472271,
0.917283535,
-0.4292915463,
-0.3346351981,
0.1089872196,
-0.4730173945,
0.4270066917,
-0.560115695,
0.6677382588,
0.0913018137,
0.0572971515,
0.7401518822,
0.0597950444,
1.0626839399,
-0.2202404588,
-0.3462283313,
0.1576782465,
-0.2145911753,
0.5576910973,
-0.474119395,
-0.1233967841,
0.520873487,
-0.3492315412,
-0.1055033356,
-0.1303869635,
0.1456702948,
-0.7736742496,
-0.3141769767,
-0.0378872752,
-0.310408622,
0.112750493,
0.5041757822,
0.3901604116,
0.5282317996,
-0.4659944773,
0.2716705799,
0.6891568899,
-0.5184227824,
0.5169370174,
0.6048893332,
-0.1417636573,
-0.4012357295,
0.9640473127,
-0.0989130214,
0.1420521587,
0.5229301453,
0.1340895742,
-0.4319726527,
-0.4834767878,
-0.4652398825,
-0.0568297021,
-0.6697030663,
-0.121029228,
-0.851303637,
-0.3660213649,
-0.3987038136,
-0.0231667571,
-0.5715728402,
0.1932295412,
-0.1448456943,
0.1076792628,
0.0370882303,
0.7392249107,
0.1126161069,
0.5305930972,
-0.7177173495,
0.558406949,
0.1319917738,
0.4094048738,
-0.0865866244,
-0.9328690767,
-0.2162883282,
0.0823361874,
-0.3163205683,
-1.0946902037,
0.4432909787,
0.054144565,
0.37054196,
0.6476716995,
0.3743671477,
0.3905139267,
-0.6689148545,
0.3906620741,
0.2603554726,
-0.6282611489,
0.0648769736,
-0.3943604231,
0.1463988572,
0.1057285294,
0.6254940629,
-0.4869274497,
-0.4453529119,
-0.2861580551,
-0.7120098472,
0.8257464767,
0.2422410548,
0.6034619212,
-0.2860107124,
-0.1266512573,
0.1058695912,
0.0560772307,
-1.2353999615,
-0.3953559995,
-0.5098941922,
-0.4225741625,
0.1596902013,
-0.4277555048,
0.0917603672,
0.0211830679,
0.5118926764,
0.1151958853,
0.4676730335,
-0.3794513047,
-0.5455020666,
0.136882022,
0.5342763662,
0.5308044553,
0.4675894678,
0.0237218123,
0.0448144227,
0.5557235479,
-0.511392355,
0.2328255922,
0.0136294272,
0.0588421859,
0.0930814594,
0.2320950031,
0.8414872885,
0.0952721462,
-0.4061102867,
0.6796453595,
-0.1545980275,
-0.2071365118,
-0.4098649621,
-0.245047763,
-0.1210670695,
0.1244712174,
0.2718521953,
-0.1997728646,
-0.0064582773,
-0.2682650685,
0.2750735581,
0.313682884,
-0.5573481321,
-0.3529789746,
0.5970531106,
0.3458559811,
-0.6950885653,
0.5633214116,
-0.1108368263,
-0.997893095,
0.5351516604,
0.8591758013,
0.7994065881,
-0.685634017,
0.1663024127,
0.5045285821,
0.6706174016,
0.4548254609,
0.0383671746,
0.0521752834,
-1.1750645638,
-0.1996601075,
-0.4821278751,
0.0029459852,
0.4002747834,
-0.5206156969,
0.3183479607,
-0.4088838995,
-0.2331817001,
0.16199027,
-0.3663742542,
-0.6099551916,
0.4214058518,
0.5331729054,
0.7227255702,
-1.1546543837,
0.7681301832,
0.4689613581,
-0.1471363902,
-0.4646035433,
-0.3305980265,
-0.0647109896,
-0.8181825876,
0.4271876514,
0.3532534242,
-0.1277139932,
0.0938282534,
-0.3948590159,
-0.4184689522,
0.4734090865,
0.296520412,
-0.3397756219,
0.053716775,
0.6334683895,
0.6180074811,
-0.3474382162,
0.539013803,
0.5558618903,
0.3440627158,
0.0288144164,
-0.6737374663,
-0.052358564,
-0.4260683656,
-0.1583537161,
0.5632752776,
-0.5431786776,
0.6928347945,
0.0236968193,
-0.4652397931,
-0.359928906,
0.5234897733,
-0.0378695801,
-0.0022754909,
0.5658800602,
0.5483230352,
0.4305633903,
-0.124576591,
0.7032978535,
-0.2464488745,
0.1796187013,
1.0157668591,
0.0341910124,
0.7412747145,
0.0199155547,
-0.1229472235,
0.3441269994,
0.429556638,
-0.1206285879,
0.5498695374,
0.0639442801,
-0.3116132617,
-0.1371910274,
-0.3481174111,
-0.1593435407,
0.5800159574,
0.5403938293,
-0.5635629892,
-0.3712240458,
0.0359698981,
0.1158533171,
0.0680189952,
-0.2740516067,
0.9654019475,
-0.1284101158,
-0.2261251956,
0.5841813684,
0.3949099183,
1.0265049934,
-0.6666741371,
0.243472904,
-0.0143962903,
0.2110152692,
-0.0768914372,
-0.5803078413,
0.4143823385,
0.4311474562,
0.0450782627,
-0.3214253783,
0.7339245677,
-0.6341495514,
-0.4708395302,
0.6175823808,
0.0028832371,
0.0777860284,
0.0467123836,
-0.7020614743,
0.222146526,
0.0264361799,
0.1026390865,
0.0928292722,
0.5174956918,
-0.2601096034,
0.5037417412,
0.4582771957,
-0.3099464178,
0.296400696,
0.2165502161,
0.6157767177,
-0.3580688536,
-0.5087276697,
-0.8706524968,
0.5151206255,
-0.0013033502,
-0.2813155055,
0.333754003,
0.4490424991,
1.0096811056,
-0.1397686154,
0.9051370621,
-0.1146811172,
0.513961792,
-0.0829830021,
0.861627996,
-0.5232518315,
-0.0673343837,
-0.4176941216,
-0.4833955467,
-0.1649447083,
0.2627874911,
-0.2531061769,
0.2663657367,
0.4654328823,
0.7852121592,
-0.2892765999,
-0.0005319172,
0.553568244,
0.1896954775,
0.409029752,
0.5968897343,
0.7024922967,
-0.6148471236,
0.9922215939,
-0.2834181488,
-0.087146841,
-0.059547849,
-0.7558748126,
-1.1552500725,
-0.4193139672,
-0.0980665833,
-0.0774003565,
0.2093915939,
0.6940466762,
0.6263777018,
-1.001688242,
-0.2645221353,
0.2860562503,
-0.1825025827,
0.1483543813,
-0.1261730194,
-0.0098075364,
-0.1123383194,
-0.8325856924,
0.1480137408,
-0.0027655098,
0.0157935694,
0.1662191302,
0.0326427072,
-0.3779396713,
0.2192614079,
0.7144616842,
0.1566649228,
-0.6765148044,
-0.2960891426,
-0.0668040439,
-0.1232978031,
0.2206450254,
0.3456718922,
-0.4229278564,
0.5183269978,
0.2211951613,
1.011813283,
0.2241787016,
0.0634163618,
0.4622413218,
-0.8047785163,
0.1733383685,
0.1641191393,
0.2102658153,
0.36201033,
-0.2190178335,
0.2227128595,
-0.0407471731,
-0.1815392226,
-0.5813865662,
0.2636344135,
-0.392767638,
-0.1486784071,
0.9145614505,
-0.2963726819,
-0.1405162662,
-0.4976882637,
0.00751324,
0.6672856808,
-0.4398724139,
0.8488837481,
0.6557846665,
0.7834496498,
-0.6033204794,
-0.2727591991,
0.4168610871,
0.2644724548,
-0.8598232865,
0.181309849,
0.0739928707,
0.2544574738,
0.1047848538,
0.3296990097,
-0.2648436129,
0.179527685,
-0.2063993365,
0.1989652365,
-0.0125970151,
-0.4750778079,
-0.100255765,
0.3672412336,
-0.3865879774,
-0.2517031133
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03367v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03367v1
|
Lazy-k: Decoding for Constrained Token Classification
| 2023-12-06T09:08:32 | 2023-12-06T09:08:32 |
Arthur Hemmer, Mickaël Coustaty, Nicola Bartolo, Jérôme Brachat, Jean-Marc Ogier
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We explore the possibility of improving probabilistic models in structured
prediction. Specifically, we combine the models with constrained decoding
approaches in the context of token classification for information extraction.
The decoding methods search for constraint-satisfying label-assignments while
maximizing the total probability. To do this, we evaluate several existing
approaches, as well as propose a novel decoding method called Lazy-$k$. Our
findings demonstrate that constrained decoding approaches can significantly
improve the models' performances, especially when using smaller models. The
Lazy-$k$ approach allows for more flexibility between decoding time and
accuracy. The code for using Lazy-$k$ decoding can be found here:
https://github.com/ArthurDevNL/lazyk.
|
[
0.2645916939,
-0.3998932838,
0.4687413275,
0.2350064516,
-0.5552147031,
0.2448291034,
-0.1370252967,
-0.629827857,
0.2307101041,
0.4568044245,
-0.7236903906,
-0.5767374635,
-0.6425424218,
0.4310954511,
-0.3168194294,
0.8753365874,
0.1227300242,
0.2312920392,
-0.220817253,
0.3770765066,
-0.4891318679,
-0.6591218114,
-0.1179216132,
-0.1125952899,
0.2773620188,
0.5635422468,
0.7813969254,
0.8837217093,
0.7013981342,
0.2530691028,
-0.0785076097,
-0.0392510556,
-0.4869770706,
0.1252073646,
0.2199519277,
-0.6335437298,
-0.4016454518,
-0.0928881988,
0.7801095843,
1.1061114073,
-0.1017003208,
0.1407210231,
-0.1050196514,
0.3333705366,
-1.1296850443,
0.6710647941,
-0.6038508415,
0.1157388389,
-0.2213288248,
-0.1434251517,
-0.7224223614,
-0.1075382233,
-0.1657675058,
-0.8499447703,
0.5093766451,
0.0788271353,
0.7438192964,
0.3908577263,
-0.4410026371,
-0.3744122684,
-0.8753291368,
0.7404559255,
-0.5649409294,
0.8357068896,
0.923684299,
0.0584693439,
-0.248006016,
-1.0237225294,
-0.4735428989,
-0.3096820712,
-0.3298437595,
0.2130008787,
0.2530204654,
0.5196688771,
0.0773445666,
0.3868221939,
-0.327132076,
0.1157791689,
-0.484721303,
-0.5987118483,
0.5790327787,
0.3550351858,
-0.3743193746,
-0.7627208233,
-0.0732021481,
0.2030754387,
-0.3244479001,
0.1267460734,
0.6243180037,
0.4423007071,
0.1112961695,
0.6481681466,
-0.5222705007,
0.7797032595,
0.138036266,
-0.3432599008,
0.1706282943,
-0.4911625087,
-0.078998737,
-0.0189204402,
0.4403897524,
0.0842210203,
-0.2176262885,
-0.6436262131,
-0.3322713673,
0.0102333575,
0.2658723295,
-0.766869545,
-0.6958881617,
0.2377207875,
-0.8145777583,
-0.2958158851,
0.2880471647,
-0.5980635881,
-0.0105969887,
-0.1702846438,
0.2097592354,
-0.3035070896,
-0.1643202752,
0.4488144815,
-0.2927334309,
-0.0002447902,
0.0748399124,
-0.9884530902,
0.4898575544,
0.8485307693,
0.6815540195,
-0.0567777902,
0.2014190704,
-0.6737654209,
0.1343769133,
-0.3031803966,
0.5037776232,
-0.651157558,
-0.6435132027,
-0.0096589644,
0.1239116117,
0.0715522617,
-0.4427250028,
0.9652242064,
-0.5642026067,
-0.4430434108,
-0.1285006553,
-0.6457862258,
0.0539916158,
0.2668936551,
-0.9782486558,
0.7574740648,
0.4174719155,
-0.7933653593,
0.3822973669,
-0.2991835773,
-0.3646718562,
0.472333312,
0.2331818044,
-0.5385162234,
0.3158632517,
0.1138129011,
0.5633305311,
0.1177166551,
0.1205010563,
-0.4751053452,
-0.4944883883,
0.4333690703,
-0.040217977,
0.6691332459,
0.5488414764,
0.1597410589,
-0.1240727082,
-1.157340765,
0.2476329654,
0.1236532256,
-0.7757872343,
-0.3322797716,
0.2048843503,
0.1983525008,
-0.3617117703,
0.3288369179,
-0.6489343643,
0.417065382,
-0.6060605645,
0.4002572596,
0.7913492918,
-0.0513170883,
0.6219361424,
0.153861478,
0.6438136101,
0.004157715,
0.3305568993,
0.090593189,
-0.2389820963,
-0.5326780081,
-0.345267415,
0.9311391711,
0.5191571712,
-0.8063060045,
0.2239090651,
-0.2093508989,
-0.2260130048,
-0.6124105453,
0.2193153501,
0.3509559333,
0.3885198236,
0.2127905935,
-0.4077064693,
-0.9692117572,
-0.6676222086,
-0.3135163188,
-0.4626882374,
0.0756068751,
0.1572137475,
0.4400391579,
-0.2698763013,
0.6991956234,
-0.5159114599,
-0.0101897577,
-0.345369041,
-0.1802385002,
0.3934987187,
0.7817094922,
0.1514980644,
-1.0363044739,
-0.4237594008,
-0.2797570229,
-0.4197992086,
0.305973798,
0.0305712037,
0.0331710428,
-0.0267588627,
0.4905338287,
-0.8480188251,
0.5909898281,
0.3220380247,
-0.558347404,
0.9236275554,
0.1023547724,
-0.16779764,
-0.8908792138,
-0.0693973973,
-0.4301088154,
-0.4171706736,
-0.7084729075,
0.2280158103,
0.1468892992,
0.0192009099,
-0.076797545,
0.1420544684,
-0.617177844,
0.0660379007,
-0.0793405175,
-0.3115052283,
-0.1703602225,
0.3671514392,
-0.0852302983,
0.2817009985,
0.3759982586,
-0.4285422266,
0.4074762762,
0.377527535,
-0.5999963284,
-0.1255612969,
-0.531093061,
0.4129958451,
-0.2190558612,
0.3608175814,
-0.9879923463,
-0.6649091244,
0.5109061599,
-0.4889774024,
0.5653176904,
-0.5131451488,
-0.8415241241,
-0.6318449974,
-0.1964457631,
0.7891254425,
0.4980486035,
-0.5179752111,
0.5329065919,
0.2449062318,
0.0245475378,
-0.8302919269,
-0.5728510618,
-0.1119278297,
0.0527369007,
-0.2093614191,
0.7260969877,
0.0198688786,
-0.0283528753,
0.5575590134,
-0.3724708259,
-0.2109337151,
0.2157134116,
0.4576668739,
0.4280615151,
-0.091942966,
0.0315057375,
-0.160306409,
-0.2507622838,
-0.0957688466,
-0.6250013709,
0.2775649428,
-0.0206752531,
-0.029270798,
-0.7525756955,
0.4456536174,
0.1696325839,
-0.0181040298,
0.7415874004,
0.6187595129,
-0.5445520282,
-0.045534309,
-0.2834312022,
-0.3182562292,
-0.5374858379,
0.5811576247,
-0.7557576895,
-0.9533051848,
0.5996466279,
-0.1036908627,
-0.1967797577,
0.3029915392,
0.4864447713,
-0.1990249157,
1.1908355951,
1.1104849577,
0.080342494,
0.4782257676,
-0.4363680184,
0.3759326041,
-0.544932127,
-0.6672887802,
-0.6666110754,
-0.3229417503,
-0.6067512035,
-0.1483269036,
-0.0192551017,
0.6926892996,
0.1892689019,
0.3473072052,
-0.6303766966,
0.4910894036,
0.5981916785,
0.1321511716,
0.1103977486,
-0.1728961319,
-0.0159943439,
0.0448482893,
-1.0081602335,
-0.0932867751,
1.3626828194,
0.2756591737,
0.7216414213,
0.0334312916,
0.8931564689,
0.1648007929,
0.3492619693,
-1.0837298632,
0.5456061959,
-0.2474409491,
-0.6966217756,
-0.0263722278,
-0.6910578012,
-1.1750048399,
-0.3776057661,
-0.2760767639,
-1.0926625729,
0.4805132449,
0.404655993,
-0.4312900305,
0.1437739581,
-0.8925522566,
0.9496276975,
0.080661945,
0.0061457027,
-0.0025458049,
-0.6755248308,
0.4776454568,
0.1021764353,
0.0649532527,
-0.0577191785,
-0.0828303695,
0.9505032301,
-0.6473275423,
1.0147681236,
-0.4057819545,
0.3973643482,
0.4721788466,
0.2258626968,
0.9396808147,
0.2338508368,
-0.1952503622,
-0.0176480655,
0.4942165017,
-0.7649586797,
-0.5622346401,
0.2326079309,
-0.8106150627,
-0.4808921516,
-0.1900741756,
-0.7964779735,
-0.4370140433,
0.1048896015,
0.4070135355,
0.2596522868,
0.0855158642,
0.3378992677,
0.1242232621,
0.3290899694,
0.2898510098,
0.2340931296,
0.1863020062,
-0.4090959132,
0.8959844112,
0.2451127619,
-0.1142221764,
0.5495297313,
0.1506198049,
-0.4901386201,
-1.0188839436,
0.1764897257,
0.0551669598,
-0.9146555066,
-0.6272756457,
-0.5688942671,
-0.283167541,
-0.759903729,
0.0980050117,
-0.3008188605,
-0.8476694226,
-0.3981240988,
-0.3511343598,
0.0753852352,
0.626363039,
-0.0966778174,
0.6288002729,
-0.9205039144,
0.2884190679,
0.0488666221,
0.5717020035,
-0.2000481635,
-0.270786047,
-0.5609771609,
-0.3358154595,
-0.0895891041,
-1.1412600279,
0.2616721988,
0.1754416823,
0.6070308685,
0.5026298761,
0.5353116989,
0.6918542385,
-0.1212080419,
0.6034272909,
0.1707576215,
-0.8321405053,
0.3556931615,
-0.0883935392,
0.1988894939,
0.628144145,
0.33506459,
-0.2351106703,
-0.2894086242,
-0.7702425718,
-0.9290708303,
0.8874455094,
0.2961651087,
0.0584880114,
0.0006905109,
0.7452958822,
0.445993036,
0.1594638526,
-0.7615509629,
-0.0443323888,
-0.4780475497,
-0.5682297349,
-0.0115086706,
-0.6586948037,
0.1780891418,
-0.4126532674,
0.559427619,
-0.1643408984,
0.5798962712,
0.1449144781,
-0.1436209828,
-0.1557559222,
0.0984172598,
0.2353674173,
0.4369771779,
-0.4548407793,
0.1675420254,
0.0208385885,
-0.789768517,
-0.0454975627,
0.3342400789,
-0.2868834734,
0.2465876043,
0.5528621078,
0.7652448416,
0.1309455782,
-0.6853519678,
0.2223972678,
-0.0455661602,
-0.3473929763,
-0.2958462834,
0.0291229915,
-0.1228097901,
0.2877348363,
0.4713701308,
0.1171242744,
0.3603084981,
-0.4426379502,
0.0655026659,
0.2119069397,
-0.0166474748,
-0.6135190129,
0.7788684368,
0.1315699518,
-0.5056735873,
0.9750918746,
-0.6353926063,
-0.6354625225,
0.6640562415,
0.7565746903,
0.948420465,
0.0240816101,
0.1141005382,
0.6139183044,
0.1261910349,
-0.1799480468,
0.4777605534,
-0.5427796245,
-0.8016898036,
-0.6227773428,
-0.9139245152,
-0.2805673778,
0.1488133073,
-0.7383124232,
-0.0345977731,
-0.4999518394,
-0.4118497074,
0.0379784033,
0.2315115333,
-0.9362884164,
-0.0905225798,
-0.0640745983,
0.8327713609,
-0.3712031543,
0.9988720417,
0.5409089923,
0.0389163867,
-1.1177229881,
0.07183671,
-0.1731427312,
-0.4036009908,
0.7842546105,
0.2740639746,
0.154121533,
0.0529894121,
-0.7813258171,
-0.9407446384,
0.8177993894,
0.3384759426,
-0.7656630278,
-0.3841601014,
0.0308758747,
0.1211943701,
-0.0956871659,
-0.5279720426,
0.5284072161,
0.4412608445,
-0.0430587456,
-0.9530391097,
0.0391832329,
-0.2806048393,
-0.2452882826,
0.1242556572,
-0.4105625749,
0.7484939694,
-0.5127226114,
-0.4911875427,
0.5773692131,
0.7987132668,
-0.0689392611,
0.5447574258,
0.6255132556,
0.4469203353,
0.8406384587,
-0.0800723433,
1.1053109169,
-0.23382321,
0.5601122975,
0.9241372943,
0.2197860926,
0.8785027862,
0.5125050545,
-0.4159259498,
0.3720858693,
0.8986043334,
-0.0955562443,
0.8941119313,
0.0404023975,
-0.1665592045,
-0.5990535021,
0.0289519988,
0.0126172667,
0.6670036316,
0.5663505197,
-0.0860882625,
0.1418474615,
-0.0709845871,
-0.4427451789,
-0.1997041106,
-0.5445669293,
0.5834895372,
0.0873998627,
-0.5695151091,
0.6192232966,
0.4607354701,
0.5370828509,
-0.5164915919,
0.1203798056,
0.1820354015,
0.3871742189,
-0.3887827098,
-0.4260817766,
0.4039849341,
-0.2851617932,
-0.2599839866,
-0.0241855066,
1.0968346596,
-0.2720251977,
-0.6916939616,
-0.062135417,
0.2124336213,
0.2614401579,
0.1943208128,
-0.5732364655,
0.0130215865,
-0.101680845,
-0.1804420054,
0.0400161333,
0.2818082273,
0.059970092,
0.6068526506,
0.733133316,
-0.0053905784,
0.4380312264,
-0.1717612147,
0.8012285829,
-0.6458135843,
-0.9585572481,
-0.6367254853,
0.3671089113,
0.1640169919,
-0.0945039019,
0.5357325077,
0.6177250147,
0.9954680204,
-0.3674040437,
0.5194661617,
-0.2117396146,
0.1821325123,
-0.6966277957,
0.2688931525,
-0.411594063,
0.1674361378,
-0.0612272285,
-0.6876759529,
-0.3425684571,
0.3905384839,
-0.1667099148,
-0.092726469,
0.5302703977,
0.7263528705,
-0.0334160887,
0.0261071343,
0.0923636183,
0.1543717682,
-0.0618436076,
0.779990077,
0.8904511929,
-0.2884150445,
0.862333715,
-0.557084024,
0.0813619792,
-0.4656402767,
-0.4483020008,
-0.7653334141,
-0.7554857135,
-0.3454572856,
-0.5729707479,
0.1743487567,
0.6990999579,
1.0220011473,
-0.8004110456,
0.1841331124,
-0.1601647437,
0.312366873,
-0.5013815761,
-0.2438310832,
0.5087466836,
-0.4566898346,
-0.7755095959,
0.3262118399,
-0.0563797876,
0.1595624834,
0.0823469311,
-0.3882880211,
0.0468237661,
-0.0234589949,
0.3958219886,
0.4254734218,
-0.4928356707,
-0.2860506773,
0.0699090213,
0.0813136995,
-0.0729520395,
1.2474138737,
-0.9003486037,
0.4198795855,
0.6555495858,
0.7867793441,
0.8281527758,
0.1702672094,
0.2927285433,
-1.1403155327,
0.5357017517,
0.759429574,
0.2217723429,
0.1112996861,
-0.7378342748,
0.4102353752,
0.711990118,
-0.301327765,
-1.3133249283,
0.379365623,
-1.2874876261,
-0.4988554418,
0.9947235584,
-0.2905788422,
-0.4999975264,
-0.368424058,
0.2465589643,
0.2678220272,
-0.1378556937,
0.8075544834,
0.7034175992,
-0.1503612101,
-0.130761534,
-0.5415564179,
0.5155691504,
0.3565215468,
-0.3156688809,
0.0051267645,
0.2988892496,
0.36769256,
0.1843518764,
0.8352984786,
-0.0582889915,
0.4778096974,
0.4110306203,
-0.3299326003,
-0.3313572705,
-0.4086081684,
0.0980015397,
0.5721250772,
0.1711468995,
-0.5078370571
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03361v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03361v1
|
KhabarChin: Automatic Detection of Important News in the Persian Language
| 2023-12-06T09:01:21 | 2023-12-06T09:01:21 |
Hamed Hematian Hemati, Arash Lagzian, Moein Salimi Sartakhti, Hamid Beigy, Ehsaneddin Asgari
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Being aware of important news is crucial for staying informed and making
well-informed decisions efficiently. Natural Language Processing (NLP)
approaches can significantly automate this process. This paper introduces the
detection of important news, in a previously unexplored area, and presents a
new benchmarking dataset (Khabarchin) for detecting important news in the
Persian language. We define important news articles as those deemed significant
for a considerable portion of society, capable of influencing their mindset or
decision-making. The news articles are obtained from seven different prominent
Persian news agencies, resulting in the annotation of 7,869 samples and the
creation of the dataset. Two challenges of high disagreement and imbalance
between classes were faced, and solutions were provided for them. We also
propose several learning-based models, ranging from conventional machine
learning to state-of-the-art transformer models, to tackle this task.
Furthermore, we introduce the second task of important sentence detection in
news articles, as they often come with a significant contextual length that
makes it challenging for readers to identify important information. We identify
these sentences in a weakly supervised manner.
|
[
-0.2787998915,
-0.7262714505,
0.6273421049,
0.136300236,
-0.421788156,
0.1394774318,
-0.4549705684,
-0.6485722065,
0.0320355631,
0.1849093735,
-0.0229169447,
-0.4237698913,
-0.7510868907,
-0.0449238755,
-0.6153925061,
1.069524169,
-0.1767867059,
0.0808626711,
0.3337517679,
-0.4480878711,
-0.3495863676,
-0.1247564927,
-0.6465216875,
-0.1440147161,
0.3910433948,
0.7279134989,
0.7746808529,
0.7972280979,
0.6895794868,
0.1447870731,
-0.1743891835,
-0.0766876936,
0.1747034192,
0.375580132,
-0.3869997263,
-0.4156827331,
0.0417958349,
-0.1390123963,
0.7670050263,
0.6310785413,
0.0238710847,
0.5635284781,
-0.0762656406,
1.2468078136,
-0.494482398,
0.1205100417,
-0.482796967,
0.0768567249,
-0.5983321667,
0.1701447219,
-0.1430537254,
-0.636556983,
-0.1719442457,
-0.0459324084,
0.113090165,
0.1669191271,
0.991088748,
0.2207708359,
-0.7060711384,
-0.2685303092,
-0.4058265388,
0.8731210828,
-0.6113618016,
0.3465151489,
0.1747169346,
0.5226533413,
-0.3918129802,
-0.4004953504,
-0.709397316,
-0.1686160713,
-0.2346725911,
-0.1180362478,
-0.5306969881,
-0.3694517314,
0.0677795708,
0.4937738478,
-0.4726127684,
-0.2105081379,
-0.2783979475,
-0.0949890465,
0.4203639328,
-0.0669718832,
0.4869849682,
-0.5238293409,
-0.096167922,
-0.1624796987,
-0.320956856,
0.1656228602,
0.4825990498,
0.1205306798,
-0.0781943724,
0.4787935019,
-0.693357408,
0.7605127692,
0.1731981635,
-0.0881689936,
0.3482771814,
-0.2975508869,
0.1697869301,
0.4701346159,
0.5116826892,
0.2449500412,
-0.0392051153,
0.0716587454,
0.1039820313,
0.1269342005,
0.3542766571,
-0.5474818945,
-0.0784866288,
0.3133024871,
-0.8740984797,
-0.6609717607,
0.0841381997,
-0.7636401653,
-0.4308978021,
-0.290584445,
0.1108971611,
-0.1524197906,
-0.2841329277,
0.193036586,
-0.1647456437,
0.2729296684,
0.4044853151,
-0.7204765081,
0.1520003378,
0.4764787853,
0.821451962,
-0.1025707945,
0.0494893789,
-0.6625629663,
0.0603443272,
-0.4731194973,
0.9970160127,
-0.486769706,
0.4284766614,
-0.2080291659,
0.1430869699,
0.3075252473,
-0.458253026,
1.3778529167,
-0.4424479604,
0.168188408,
0.0903870761,
-0.4694927037,
-0.6010131836,
0.2099333107,
-0.6709469557,
0.9856693745,
0.2748673558,
-1.0195572376,
0.4592912793,
-0.461333245,
-1.0047696829,
-0.1488392502,
-0.0250366293,
-0.9401988983,
0.335521847,
0.3891946673,
0.5611109138,
-0.2705769241,
0.3986766636,
0.059155155,
-0.1546943337,
0.2634193301,
-0.1308260262,
0.5157335997,
0.3066605926,
-0.6712949872,
0.0160139035,
-0.8672950864,
0.2993862033,
-0.0973979831,
-0.5948469043,
-0.4270196855,
0.1466366202,
0.4581767619,
0.3459557295,
0.1489502043,
-0.4272944033,
0.1440911889,
-0.2466378063,
0.3367313147,
0.3261239827,
0.3884819448,
0.3832779825,
-0.4058551788,
0.4008797109,
0.1387506872,
0.1456778646,
-0.1143466681,
-0.1033602953,
-0.8547022343,
0.0815858319,
0.5324980617,
0.3367097974,
-0.4159718156,
0.5400770307,
0.0389874168,
-0.7039180398,
-0.1791862249,
-0.0651164278,
0.1398327351,
0.1507880241,
0.2335446179,
-0.1716116816,
-0.8665784001,
-0.9423775673,
-1.0216046572,
-0.0465763249,
0.2243111581,
0.0449830927,
0.287353456,
0.0812038928,
0.7476873398,
-0.3427222371,
-0.6387895346,
-0.6795080304,
0.1664669216,
0.6694355011,
0.4294228256,
0.4062531888,
-1.0172758102,
-0.7426583767,
0.3444158137,
-0.6922814846,
-0.3368196487,
-0.2322340161,
-0.037488766,
0.1027502194,
0.8433401585,
-0.3472555876,
0.3287948966,
0.3420117199,
-0.0885976404,
0.3257350028,
-0.0348148458,
0.1685412377,
-0.9703018069,
0.1764898598,
0.1586517841,
-0.5265028477,
-0.5904245377,
0.1109227538,
0.3013913035,
-0.1037978753,
-0.3955975175,
0.6072357893,
-0.5208364129,
0.0772362798,
-0.5596801043,
0.137049824,
-0.0844852105,
0.433603853,
0.1079142243,
0.4420603514,
0.3535290956,
-0.4417743087,
0.2400560528,
0.048752252,
-0.8949168921,
0.378616035,
-0.4907654226,
-0.3923428059,
-0.0736709014,
0.3349257708,
-0.5239630342,
-0.3881919682,
0.5517732501,
-0.5013118386,
-0.0780946836,
-0.1278668642,
-0.5491558313,
-0.2921043932,
-0.2226013392,
0.3329533935,
0.4581576288,
-0.3089855909,
0.3451150954,
0.6588125825,
-0.2423955798,
-0.3146678209,
-0.2047946155,
0.2968115807,
-0.3371572793,
-0.0735375658,
-0.0718852207,
0.6391403079,
-0.3608451188,
0.0639105365,
-0.468067199,
-0.2949561775,
0.2983992994,
0.2830134034,
-0.2098061889,
-0.2232411057,
0.3809718192,
0.1402687132,
-0.3746275902,
-0.0043702447,
-0.2299233675,
0.3586985171,
-0.1578454971,
-0.0504501238,
-0.9291990995,
0.4048951566,
0.6112049222,
-0.3516353071,
0.59114784,
1.0617260933,
-0.4032285511,
-0.0239775162,
-0.4410483837,
0.0368663557,
-0.3234532177,
0.4451955855,
0.354033649,
-0.3201262057,
-0.0017578908,
-0.4138019383,
-0.2549082339,
0.7486876249,
0.5371105671,
0.1280666143,
1.3867932558,
0.6665690541,
-0.7919695973,
0.586392343,
0.2111975998,
0.5463516712,
-0.4658159912,
0.3397733271,
-0.7384998798,
-0.4573359191,
-0.4147034883,
-0.1685309559,
0.4965465367,
0.0019817543,
-0.0413694419,
0.2456954271,
-0.5241295099,
0.6955192685,
0.630138576,
0.0849411786,
0.5050114989,
0.0648269802,
0.3102403283,
-0.0360917747,
-0.4404069185,
-0.7188369632,
0.8327884674,
0.2277684063,
0.8317063451,
0.1509537846,
0.3369151056,
0.860656321,
0.0010092766,
-0.6874634624,
0.2255184501,
0.0336031951,
-0.5875239372,
-0.2478082776,
-0.1747442037,
-0.7523258328,
0.151348725,
-0.1245818585,
-0.3540868759,
0.2665623426,
-0.3442493677,
-0.3741836846,
0.2832306325,
-0.414041847,
0.7505890131,
-0.0777786002,
-0.0782115981,
-0.7633543611,
-0.7283274531,
0.3378838003,
-0.0277768448,
0.459091574,
-0.5604948997,
0.0318969637,
0.7219501734,
-0.2140846848,
0.5537850857,
-0.0839346424,
0.2020763457,
0.0754589513,
-0.3305989802,
0.5602034926,
0.320374161,
-0.0624986142,
-0.0344223566,
-0.1108129993,
-0.5788758993,
-0.1623667479,
0.3872911036,
-0.5129913688,
-0.4627426565,
-0.9859720469,
-0.3080475032,
0.0337794088,
0.3658519685,
-0.1058501899,
0.3971474767,
-0.2859302163,
0.5016233325,
0.2904801667,
0.0346724875,
0.4120191634,
0.5891156793,
-0.1392193139,
-0.0308644474,
0.851747334,
-0.2647176981,
-0.2348646224,
0.2685434222,
0.1995331794,
0.1344498843,
-0.5726795197,
-0.8152114153,
-0.0630823001,
-0.5807948709,
-0.3380118906,
-0.8535121679,
-0.2593826652,
0.1861977279,
-0.1070233658,
-0.2792755365,
-0.6016054153,
-0.0239517651,
0.1975251883,
0.2933399379,
0.67663908,
-0.273655951,
0.109594509,
-0.9158110619,
0.7154887915,
0.0941772684,
0.0668802708,
0.0050138463,
-0.1773814112,
-0.8993060589,
0.1317196041,
-0.3841394484,
-0.5458009839,
0.3059216142,
0.3249971271,
0.507471323,
0.5208477974,
0.4071093798,
0.0842830613,
-0.5038977861,
0.5469888449,
-0.1533653587,
-0.9942705631,
0.9405909777,
-0.541693747,
0.4255623817,
0.8514899611,
0.354549855,
-0.9134362936,
-0.7617383599,
-0.6253378987,
-0.7665553093,
0.7854861617,
0.2269821614,
0.1094805151,
-0.1489029676,
0.2280576825,
0.0648261979,
0.3337174356,
-0.757055223,
-0.2167235464,
0.2008984983,
-0.2222136855,
0.237409085,
-0.2326124609,
0.0673514605,
-0.3155992627,
0.8170864582,
-0.0024805546,
-0.1119428873,
0.2242709696,
-0.595295012,
-0.2479194254,
0.5193914771,
0.4880101979,
0.5468393564,
-0.0464622006,
0.020107951,
0.0136596151,
-0.7992961407,
0.4028463662,
0.0408189297,
0.1266467124,
0.4731908143,
0.2036573142,
0.2814655304,
0.2748489082,
-0.8325240612,
0.818947494,
-0.2137335092,
0.042674575,
-0.5880529284,
0.1502065659,
-0.4317097664,
0.5323384404,
0.7389917374,
0.4334090948,
0.3536016047,
-0.6814321876,
0.2603775859,
0.0864364281,
-0.4950323701,
-0.1206038743,
0.6498142481,
0.1261045337,
0.2106670439,
0.2600438595,
-0.3466952443,
-1.0337828398,
0.7703895569,
0.046000991,
0.6249039173,
-0.0628239438,
0.4341769814,
0.5500928164,
0.1171287745,
-0.3458666801,
0.1234419569,
-0.1367496699,
-0.5373459458,
-0.0844231248,
-0.4682093263,
-0.523152709,
-0.2098386139,
-0.834749639,
0.4778303206,
-0.4234004617,
-0.0139571056,
0.2289145589,
0.4016382694,
-0.3557060361,
0.3652169704,
-0.0292974804,
0.6199778914,
-0.8841342926,
0.7925534248,
0.5227874517,
-0.2717471421,
-0.516263783,
0.4732454419,
0.0126893986,
-0.5146042109,
0.75446105,
0.2170873731,
0.2863997221,
-0.035223078,
-0.1554371417,
-0.7501942515,
0.6337713599,
0.118379049,
-0.4056487978,
0.2686457634,
-0.1580906808,
0.3410872519,
-0.077900894,
0.0044332277,
0.5381948948,
0.8462402821,
-0.4988666177,
-0.673304677,
0.0817928463,
-0.3332187831,
-0.3469105363,
0.6530125737,
-0.9278636575,
0.7830999494,
-0.0395520069,
-0.3214793205,
0.0998196751,
0.5524927974,
-0.3100816905,
0.141178906,
0.6330480576,
0.4861246049,
0.5644817948,
-0.0326953866,
0.7547984719,
-0.496232748,
0.2011419386,
0.8427734375,
-0.0968260244,
0.8555204868,
0.200315699,
-0.1664641052,
0.7782732248,
0.5023623109,
-0.1844694614,
0.6223154068,
0.1807533503,
-0.5333380103,
-0.3361837268,
-0.3744934201,
-0.7881726623,
0.7768344283,
0.18541646,
-0.5212941766,
-0.6397218108,
0.1642322093,
0.2834292054,
0.1632445902,
-0.3760280311,
0.7082650661,
-0.1275611222,
-0.5160263777,
0.184859857,
0.3795976043,
0.1815431267,
-0.3164184988,
-0.0374847613,
-0.0157468114,
0.4854620397,
-0.2376221567,
-0.5766367912,
0.4791264236,
0.0040576379,
-0.6516464949,
-0.0719330013,
1.0349533558,
-0.3014221191,
-0.6343036294,
-0.1067401767,
0.7329117656,
0.1339515895,
-0.5113592148,
-0.3451504111,
0.086403124,
0.0400690734,
-0.1802636534,
0.251627028,
0.502763927,
-0.3146686256,
0.2367569655,
0.7265835404,
0.0828929916,
-0.4268363118,
-0.029857846,
0.8800963759,
-0.8542485237,
-0.6292202473,
-0.7032817602,
0.0651337951,
-0.4802798927,
-0.1677559763,
0.9796413779,
0.6594994068,
0.4648348689,
0.1178636923,
0.9540864825,
-0.1377516538,
1.0425320864,
-0.5380352736,
1.157402873,
-0.5243130326,
-0.0191782806,
-0.1402058154,
-0.8157435656,
-0.4277592599,
0.7888367772,
-0.2597591281,
-0.2750337422,
0.8192389011,
0.1974336803,
-0.1256284416,
0.2840843499,
-0.0990334377,
0.2105502933,
0.0097156297,
0.5336049795,
0.875873208,
-0.6885182858,
0.5205856562,
-0.1402321905,
0.0248993039,
-0.5825135112,
-0.9835432768,
-0.9298465848,
-0.6375140548,
-0.3897245526,
0.0309804194,
0.2211607099,
0.7671173215,
0.5954858065,
-1.0032922029,
-0.0119445827,
-0.2214691639,
0.5730095506,
-0.4208531082,
-0.2191719562,
0.5763781667,
-0.633389771,
-0.5108255744,
0.1118183509,
0.3027661145,
-0.1757258028,
0.0509418212,
0.5281097293,
-0.4113853574,
-0.2743653357,
0.2747157216,
0.4207722247,
-0.3572813272,
-0.5067692995,
-0.4730613232,
-0.2218705118,
0.1487402916,
0.8475498557,
-0.988152802,
0.0826596469,
0.3907957077,
0.5779540539,
0.1955083907,
-0.0734051988,
0.5587384701,
-0.5560815334,
0.4208691418,
0.1364103109,
0.2848951817,
0.2151489407,
-0.3297177255,
0.5200343728,
-0.0518409796,
-0.7209624648,
-0.7160571814,
-0.0023309668,
-0.6347363591,
-0.1813932657,
0.8539564013,
0.0374584347,
-0.4681748748,
-0.5759342909,
-0.6512331963,
0.2147993445,
-0.4618673027,
1.0048029423,
0.9361919165,
0.193038702,
-0.2489885837,
-0.7542065382,
0.6004549265,
0.4864322841,
-0.9075511098,
-0.0412387699,
0.3649251461,
-0.1136273369,
-0.1058481336,
0.2335621715,
0.0617435053,
0.6553997993,
-0.1684310436,
-0.1098131984,
0.345677495,
-0.1792454273,
-0.3156833947,
0.0833400264,
0.0356277749,
-0.1494653523
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03360v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03360v2
|
Teaching Specific Scientific Knowledge into Large Language Models through Additional Training
| 2023-12-06T08:55:55 | 2023-12-18T01:43:56 |
Kan Hatakeyama-Sato, Yasuhiko Igarashi, Shun Katakami, Yuta Nabae, Teruaki Hayakawa
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Through additional training, we explore embedding specialized scientific
knowledge into the Llama 2 Large Language Model (LLM). Key findings reveal that
effective knowledge integration requires reading texts from multiple
perspectives, especially in instructional formats. We utilize text augmentation
to tackle the scarcity of specialized texts, including style conversions and
translations. Hyperparameter optimization proves crucial, with different size
models (7b, 13b, and 70b) reasonably undergoing additional training. Validating
our methods, we construct a dataset of 65,000 scientific papers. Although we
have succeeded in partially embedding knowledge, the study highlights the
complexities and limitations of incorporating specialized information into
LLMs, suggesting areas for further improvement.
|
[
-0.2201744914,
-0.482145071,
0.8662016392,
0.142384842,
-0.4008271694,
0.3817421496,
-0.3079232574,
-0.6199945211,
0.3033142984,
0.6655936241,
0.0356632248,
-0.3725894094,
-0.806602478,
0.1605909616,
-0.3081183136,
1.0739593506,
-0.2144327462,
0.2918893993,
-0.6175761819,
-0.0450730771,
-0.0169656705,
-0.6040449142,
-0.3003071845,
-0.5529899597,
0.5639166832,
0.5127534866,
0.4654601514,
0.953404367,
0.7179999948,
0.1965475678,
-0.3282984197,
0.569909811,
-0.4569298327,
-0.109329924,
-0.2981286049,
-0.8682522774,
-0.2625730038,
0.0369270779,
1.0094964504,
0.8750529289,
0.0155404741,
0.0153571013,
-0.0013179458,
0.383063674,
-0.3889917135,
0.2107467651,
-0.4953808784,
0.2212730795,
-0.0228258334,
-0.2214452028,
-0.3540520668,
-0.2475201041,
0.389413774,
-0.8511846662,
-0.0028862923,
0.0534876063,
0.6354483366,
0.4131796062,
-0.6854377985,
-0.2747506797,
-0.5969847441,
0.9617477059,
-0.7133760452,
0.2686857581,
0.4947209358,
-0.0636961833,
-0.1508684903,
-0.7566770911,
-0.6368666291,
-0.2829387486,
-0.0451314934,
0.111364767,
0.1122381538,
0.0069644772,
0.1799315214,
0.012911181,
-0.2379678041,
0.2969976962,
-0.5820690989,
0.103879489,
0.6850687861,
0.084680438,
0.0364914872,
0.1476705521,
-0.16640912,
-0.2888431549,
-0.7561231852,
-0.3297224939,
0.5003700256,
-0.0402170159,
-0.0114793414,
0.7358521819,
0.1972993761,
0.5868178606,
-0.1554884762,
-0.3288695514,
0.2542177737,
-0.4184637666,
-0.0408194885,
0.0227911528,
0.4661762416,
0.1013216153,
0.0149061065,
-0.0864654705,
0.082245715,
-0.3178999424,
0.2523501515,
-0.7161858678,
-0.0609249212,
-0.1141616851,
0.0263631642,
-0.1771866679,
-0.2476560622,
-0.6076816916,
-0.4489069283,
-0.4234673381,
0.2495938838,
-0.2281467915,
-0.0834110081,
0.163065955,
-0.3143468499,
-0.0175671875,
0.5074560642,
-1.1435650587,
0.1358116865,
0.6779474616,
0.943825841,
-0.1144041196,
-0.3974722922,
-0.1290545166,
0.6563650966,
-0.4184236825,
1.0274920464,
-0.9378272891,
-0.5175823569,
-0.0440303646,
-0.0136499908,
-0.0331683792,
-0.3246848881,
0.4190527201,
-0.7104113102,
0.1104773954,
-0.3812468648,
-0.5894850492,
-0.3884775341,
0.1653417051,
-0.4302788675,
1.0705498457,
0.2121254355,
-0.7374221683,
0.2548114657,
-0.6524896026,
-0.4318206906,
0.0100188591,
-0.2143038958,
-0.1505644768,
0.0823539421,
0.0908311605,
0.4227023125,
-0.4076423943,
0.4058967829,
-0.2285586149,
-0.1560557932,
0.1429151446,
-0.025302073,
0.3527834713,
0.1882757694,
-0.0014239488,
-0.0611527637,
-0.7810151577,
-0.1639665514,
-0.0487845615,
-0.7578422427,
-0.6822849512,
-0.106211625,
-0.0276463944,
-0.1405449957,
0.5138602257,
-0.5042850971,
0.6745228767,
-0.4676316679,
0.5385737419,
0.4681744576,
-0.0375174247,
0.6585618854,
-0.164522022,
0.4561561048,
0.0358219035,
-0.1432607919,
-0.1251869649,
-0.5684805512,
-0.8860293627,
-0.0804802701,
0.107241936,
0.4745919704,
-0.5814339519,
0.312703371,
-0.069328323,
-0.5490944982,
-0.4921733737,
0.5829484463,
0.280662328,
0.5228717327,
0.5214409232,
-0.2504119873,
-0.6437155008,
-0.9673328996,
-0.0703540221,
0.0678137764,
0.1645716578,
0.0516540445,
0.8234767318,
-0.5096801519,
0.7997463942,
-0.5458661318,
0.0058974349,
-0.1571316868,
-0.0711861253,
0.1777639687,
0.5518029332,
0.4981327653,
-0.6460336447,
-0.4048525095,
0.4717656672,
-0.9748710394,
0.2635540664,
0.0063843378,
0.0037874687,
-0.1677893847,
0.3951695561,
-0.3430341184,
0.043844834,
0.6665757895,
-0.0649469718,
0.4144869149,
-0.5138601661,
0.0216236394,
-1.0744997263,
-0.2164645791,
0.2604009211,
-0.04642554,
-0.6750665307,
0.0660581291,
0.0651521087,
0.0029472793,
-0.3432962894,
0.6378116608,
-0.5816371441,
-0.0277136713,
-0.5270472169,
0.0661446005,
0.178698808,
0.1153851375,
0.4597187936,
0.7067487836,
0.3170421422,
-0.4756136537,
0.4903210402,
0.4226565361,
-0.5547750592,
0.2731532454,
-0.7181770205,
0.2826682925,
-0.1868027002,
0.4178674221,
-0.6138916016,
-0.5074191093,
0.0183192175,
0.0199101251,
0.5394778848,
-0.0290736333,
-0.567014277,
-0.3233049214,
-0.30337888,
0.3287495673,
0.4297316074,
-0.5783804655,
0.3501003087,
0.4974336922,
-0.4778592587,
-0.7917075753,
-0.8857780099,
0.1745990664,
-0.1547929794,
-0.5590734482,
0.3223311007,
0.0796414614,
-0.1965045631,
0.14146851,
0.0971521363,
-0.0797133595,
-0.1518231332,
-0.1274585724,
0.000790648,
-0.324257344,
0.2518669963,
0.6848611236,
0.0729780048,
-0.0879119337,
-0.4543244839,
0.3492647409,
-0.0170841794,
-0.4640423357,
-0.5275688171,
0.457836926,
0.5878533721,
-0.0427936055,
0.9917727709,
0.5498136878,
-0.246081084,
-0.0304766763,
-0.7203550339,
-0.2233895957,
-0.4505065382,
0.8677491546,
-0.1068839431,
-1.0827465057,
0.4193272591,
-0.1746446341,
0.0760621205,
0.3719323874,
0.5107617378,
-0.074333176,
1.1032172441,
1.0265809298,
0.1668580174,
0.5253491998,
-0.4525909424,
0.0268609338,
-1.105019927,
-0.7180011868,
-0.4734426737,
-0.055042021,
-0.2516902983,
-0.8347436786,
0.4280998111,
0.1622466296,
-0.5842469931,
0.2123749554,
-0.5705191493,
0.656996429,
0.6160625815,
0.2058997005,
0.5365982652,
0.3025720417,
0.0707871839,
-0.1543100327,
-0.8692783713,
-0.8929954767,
1.3383033276,
0.6231956482,
0.8780297637,
-0.0678613335,
0.6439541578,
-0.1197689772,
0.5479590893,
-0.8317940831,
0.2303296179,
-0.119806096,
-0.2787824273,
-0.2616209984,
-0.1859979182,
-0.5567121506,
0.351621002,
-0.1075484902,
-0.4638675749,
0.369554013,
-0.0075549255,
-0.1950303614,
0.2538237572,
-0.684091866,
0.2607798874,
-0.3309036791,
-0.2089671344,
-0.4769105315,
-0.5109276175,
0.428706646,
-0.5147380829,
0.3368389904,
0.1438530385,
-0.5075681806,
1.1430552006,
-0.2419908047,
1.1011202335,
0.0293717757,
-0.2228285223,
0.1998233497,
-0.2971276045,
0.6329169273,
0.2874640822,
-0.2277480811,
-0.090321742,
0.0476415083,
-0.5939679146,
-0.6414419413,
0.8537794352,
-1.1435027122,
-1.0517133474,
-0.5223114491,
-1.0282199383,
-0.4792051613,
-0.1212270185,
-0.0347405039,
-0.1381254345,
0.1982203126,
0.3169256747,
0.9738998413,
-0.2072492242,
0.030492086,
0.5597822666,
0.0958001241,
-0.4958951771,
0.783701241,
0.2558875084,
0.2585286498,
0.2759884,
0.310565263,
-0.2460680008,
-0.8583729863,
-0.3391903937,
0.5932505727,
-0.9375094175,
-0.1690438837,
-1.0075906515,
-0.1832998246,
-0.5224894881,
-0.3296661675,
-0.2282824367,
-0.4465453327,
-0.7762721181,
-0.3136929274,
0.6789315939,
1.1477108002,
-0.2154512703,
0.8150752783,
-0.9465405345,
-0.2130499929,
0.3045649529,
-0.0111002028,
0.1394148916,
-1.0259149075,
-0.5971480608,
0.1338774115,
-0.2769687474,
-0.8494265676,
0.4404204488,
0.354811132,
0.8357937336,
0.5750684738,
-0.5425066352,
0.5937947035,
-0.5057402253,
0.6688975096,
0.4364180565,
-0.735449791,
0.6115837097,
-0.3057760298,
0.0007659648,
0.3970913589,
0.9784695506,
-0.3880475163,
-0.3433738649,
-0.3934769034,
-0.7022232413,
0.6193602085,
-0.4950143993,
0.5968506932,
0.1745160371,
0.6289265752,
0.1733465493,
0.2530876696,
-0.7122261524,
0.1354533285,
-0.1250627041,
-0.1847691238,
-0.2530139089,
-0.4864064753,
-0.5693911314,
-0.7034567595,
0.6838155985,
-0.1768508554,
-0.0280607045,
0.1747584045,
-0.0468646698,
-0.0044067143,
-0.0004666669,
0.8102123737,
0.8279319406,
0.156504184,
0.2082644701,
0.4115060568,
-0.8220407367,
0.194663465,
-0.034014184,
0.0276089944,
-0.2251805514,
0.5960971117,
0.7723580599,
0.2175980061,
-0.6269581914,
0.1023503393,
0.4866618514,
-0.2460117042,
-0.0025254856,
0.2027616203,
0.4000807106,
0.409085691,
0.669696331,
-0.1152467206,
-0.1844748408,
-0.5730465055,
0.0064871251,
0.2465360165,
-0.1282304227,
-0.3755464852,
0.4682136476,
0.218408972,
0.0863231495,
0.2207357138,
-0.0120043419,
-0.6075309515,
0.8354586363,
0.9219842553,
0.045578409,
-0.3180726469,
0.2577197254,
0.2999671698,
0.4885977805,
-0.5014306307,
0.0666209906,
0.0199264437,
-0.5911474228,
-0.6726866364,
-0.7837058902,
-0.8430895805,
-0.0756605789,
-0.4349482656,
0.2180889994,
-0.6236076355,
-0.091407299,
-0.0192992352,
0.1951101571,
-0.6273490787,
0.00796891,
-0.1914111525,
0.8081467152,
-1.0660943985,
0.9302937388,
1.0454480648,
-0.5918622613,
-0.6822444201,
-0.44542557,
-0.1714771688,
-1.0148458481,
1.0713744164,
-0.3044088185,
0.0428815633,
0.1177039519,
-0.7324076891,
-1.0891909599,
1.0751892328,
0.520588696,
-0.9048730731,
-0.1196915433,
0.0703672543,
0.7596302629,
-0.6127662659,
0.1529000401,
0.5829875469,
0.6793910265,
0.2793910801,
-0.7793602347,
-0.087134786,
-0.0057861162,
-0.0273490809,
-0.1264117509,
-0.7827097774,
0.6619346142,
-0.4429276884,
0.1888842881,
-0.1307670623,
0.8849210739,
0.1630420685,
0.3601512909,
-0.0384914316,
0.6945983171,
1.0393877029,
0.2602192461,
0.896863699,
-0.0216167755,
0.2154632956,
0.8587408066,
-0.3224534392,
0.7987549305,
0.794621408,
-0.3237107694,
0.5768741369,
0.8240834475,
-0.3344792724,
0.6104679108,
0.1760836691,
-0.5548740625,
-0.1424742043,
-0.3958622813,
-0.7946054339,
0.3398021758,
0.7166696191,
-0.5029670596,
0.0886656642,
0.3870422244,
0.1469675004,
0.1273900867,
-0.2541233897,
0.643696785,
0.2939942479,
-0.4663279951,
0.3701773286,
-0.0135489302,
0.7505757213,
-0.5829914212,
-0.0886755362,
-0.2438768297,
-0.1034987643,
-0.505200088,
-0.8095399141,
0.3026248217,
0.1350068599,
-0.3673027456,
0.0054007373,
0.5192489624,
-0.6258260012,
-0.6020835638,
0.0316287614,
0.4857641459,
0.3312790096,
0.3502014577,
-0.2040811777,
0.0225266349,
0.0069602872,
-0.412884146,
0.626313448,
0.3360077739,
-0.0626810193,
0.5959326625,
0.9002315998,
0.3172000051,
-0.0396330059,
0.0234140512,
1.1843613386,
-0.416077733,
-0.2774036527,
-0.7086282372,
0.1083732471,
-0.1258957684,
-0.1774101704,
0.8284483552,
0.5914569497,
0.7701358199,
-0.241578415,
0.9860650301,
0.3596970439,
0.1714951545,
-0.442389518,
0.686419785,
-0.4383848011,
0.2968806624,
-0.0386316665,
-1.1115980148,
-0.4217064083,
0.6524523497,
-0.5507256985,
-0.1144406125,
0.7681881785,
0.4890332818,
-0.0305858515,
0.0074425372,
0.2364066243,
0.0487846695,
0.293407172,
0.4362244308,
0.9471835494,
-0.0580573343,
0.450731039,
-0.1450309306,
-0.431791842,
-0.2457710356,
-0.9079991579,
-0.9915875196,
-0.5616257787,
-0.3171672225,
-0.1527167261,
0.2092742473,
0.8004824519,
0.6868935227,
-0.5520713925,
-0.1146868467,
0.1092885211,
0.1239058301,
0.3134726882,
-0.1228494123,
0.4079267383,
-0.2928439975,
-0.9272869825,
0.6224969029,
0.3368370235,
0.3628521562,
-0.5160235167,
-0.0107671991,
-0.2766754627,
0.0885922089,
0.7119171023,
0.3280584812,
-0.5283512473,
-0.357401371,
0.0073054587,
0.013316121,
-0.0842946023,
0.9029736519,
-0.5466423035,
0.2941997349,
0.3536347151,
1.0017700195,
0.8418307304,
-0.2413131744,
0.5612902641,
-0.583883822,
0.4894084036,
0.4715788364,
0.251334548,
0.4642294943,
-0.4872235656,
0.4503223598,
0.2822474241,
-0.6008448005,
-1.1401138306,
0.0361667946,
-0.9050413966,
-0.1430402398,
1.3409985304,
-0.2762784362,
-0.2381161451,
-0.1701887101,
-0.1737030894,
0.3352383375,
-0.2545453608,
0.5977231264,
0.8998028636,
-0.3010794222,
-0.0355786495,
-0.6204006672,
0.3082425296,
0.4608802795,
-1.073938489,
-0.3407459259,
0.167287901,
0.2573787272,
0.2763230801,
0.2793831825,
0.0195926316,
0.1421590447,
0.1467191279,
-0.032061927,
-0.3057481647,
-0.3592891097,
-0.2689325213,
-0.0445874818,
0.1656896323,
0.3972107172
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03342v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03342v1
|
Topic and genre in dialogue
| 2023-12-06T08:33:51 | 2023-12-06T08:33:51 |
Amandine Decker, Ellen Breitholtz, Christine Howes, Staffan Larsson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper we argue that topic plays a fundamental role in conversations,
and that the concept is needed in addition to that of genre to define
interactions. In particular, the concepts of genre and topic need to be
separated and orthogonally defined. This would enable modular, reliable and
controllable flexible-domain dialogue systems.
|
[
-0.7194282413,
-0.9698352814,
0.7343828678,
0.4653923213,
-0.2683855891,
0.323998183,
-0.0721963197,
-0.3125983775,
0.7012140155,
0.8353867531,
-0.3510392904,
-0.0485490672,
-0.5701133013,
-0.2106175721,
-0.2840274274,
0.9158290029,
0.065985173,
0.0235152915,
-0.3938493133,
-0.4594103098,
-0.8823162913,
-0.6080707908,
-0.5906977057,
-0.2935494184,
0.5034459829,
0.2899948359,
0.8204700947,
0.3717008829,
0.4030897319,
0.4310991168,
-0.2556198537,
-0.2449680716,
-0.3638016284,
0.88688308,
-0.4421916008,
-0.6313843727,
-0.3432596624,
0.0705132782,
0.575591445,
1.1187148094,
-0.0945768282,
-0.3223253787,
-0.0980487317,
0.3609981537,
0.082919158,
-0.0037820963,
-0.20499672,
0.0694652125,
-0.2164535373,
-0.3643105924,
0.1228269711,
-0.2799030542,
0.5304430127,
-0.3051427305,
0.0877681971,
-0.0611371584,
0.9108443856,
-0.0702705234,
-0.6282073259,
-0.0684351027,
-1.0898988247,
0.5501629114,
-0.2605846226,
0.1361582577,
0.5212456584,
-0.0200437047,
-0.2173898816,
-0.6213715076,
-0.5654623508,
0.0549037717,
0.0339038558,
-0.0863914937,
-0.1395885646,
0.3745323718,
0.2675602734,
0.5855494738,
-0.0462410524,
-0.0945192277,
-0.6468439102,
-0.0664935932,
0.4829410315,
0.7086156607,
0.4510520697,
-0.3001847863,
-0.0090472065,
0.4726480842,
-0.6939273477,
0.4628721774,
0.5168835521,
-0.0874465704,
-0.0968391597,
0.2798818946,
-0.2391052246,
0.596131742,
0.2680973411,
-0.5525602102,
-0.2007674426,
-0.3727655411,
0.0689105093,
-0.1526940465,
0.404253006,
0.6257793307,
-0.1288122535,
-0.1062169597,
0.0526144505,
-0.1177205369,
0.3843807876,
-0.7589524984,
0.0078126304,
0.4442746937,
-0.5635934472,
-0.0476282574,
0.0258754026,
-0.5491601229,
-0.0758513883,
-0.626629293,
0.0860367417,
-0.033130955,
-0.480014056,
-0.0805686116,
-0.4148481786,
0.0410079211,
0.4193326235,
-1.0537563562,
0.4275657833,
0.8611130118,
0.7247915864,
-0.3034064472,
0.0143418843,
-0.109837912,
0.2879266441,
-0.5298788548,
0.9996401668,
-0.7641960979,
-0.8801492453,
-0.1027302369,
0.0958309919,
0.1457517445,
-0.2479632646,
0.2828365862,
-0.0574647635,
0.4362646043,
-0.13800174,
-0.5446166396,
-0.1667996496,
-0.0003534878,
-0.4897740781,
0.4543051124,
-0.0071672658,
-0.496635437,
0.4245316386,
-0.5584334135,
-0.4158535004,
0.3433998227,
-0.6134197712,
0.0822561607,
0.1329129636,
-0.6305808425,
0.1100537106,
-0.5810409188,
0.9082989097,
-0.4031559229,
-0.2091287971,
0.4699635506,
-0.2496069819,
0.3038207591,
0.3914770782,
-0.2153856307,
0.2786919177,
-0.4568530321,
-0.0011470384,
-0.3748829663,
-0.0302520469,
-0.5014224648,
0.4595631361,
0.1399980336,
-0.0419149809,
-0.0661553144,
-0.3466552198,
-0.0086595956,
-0.378460139,
0.725679934,
0.3243509531,
0.3321931064,
0.6007494926,
-0.5670103431,
0.6414365768,
-0.2850551605,
-0.0984272361,
-0.1748988628,
-0.7491915226,
-0.8625768423,
-0.2285425961,
0.3219931126,
0.5741795897,
-0.4408572614,
0.7192006707,
0.506010294,
-0.4107436538,
-0.0081116147,
-0.3162388206,
0.225324735,
0.3203631639,
-0.1023697481,
-0.6806573272,
-0.3918747902,
-1.0571041107,
0.2664629519,
-0.3769787252,
0.0013550338,
0.5443702936,
-0.0765342489,
0.0854734331,
1.587531209,
-0.7269716859,
-0.0267779026,
-0.6273472905,
0.3322736025,
0.2083391696,
0.5735764503,
0.7561511993,
-1.1323488951,
-0.531319499,
-0.302276969,
-0.7560296655,
-0.327293992,
-0.1198420823,
-0.2334996909,
-0.2370892167,
0.5594115853,
-0.6793957949,
0.472854495,
-0.09626811,
-0.4354034364,
0.2419052422,
0.093698293,
0.2597070634,
-1.1964383125,
-0.2429956794,
0.0665960312,
0.0013272829,
-1.0356451273,
-0.2169945985,
-0.6460283399,
-0.4450222552,
-0.2879613638,
0.2343787551,
0.0833937153,
0.1024682522,
-0.5090192556,
0.1228547394,
0.353887707,
0.1680745035,
0.5600678921,
0.6171332598,
0.767624259,
-0.5788173676,
0.3540374637,
0.4789972305,
-0.222561419,
0.7903451324,
-0.7249525785,
0.0084677953,
-0.0802653953,
0.4760057628,
-1.0646172762,
-0.2146566212,
0.1526042074,
-0.1641752422,
0.3859199882,
-0.1714363098,
0.0204697549,
0.0477152057,
-0.0113689601,
0.3851014674,
0.1602610648,
0.4890283048,
0.3613516986,
0.8483695984,
-0.8122267723,
-0.3367013931,
-0.1412949562,
0.0362527035,
-0.675116539,
-0.5543525219,
0.330218643,
-0.1997015178,
-0.6302112341,
-0.170141831,
-0.3296350241,
-0.417970866,
0.2504378557,
0.6001694798,
-0.0318141133,
-0.45465523,
0.2911213338,
0.2773180008,
-0.2781638801,
-0.01505512,
-0.0329750776,
0.6882879138,
0.0047791135,
-0.1323774457,
-0.3912962377,
1.2019561529,
0.6214520335,
-0.0759935901,
0.5065591335,
0.1144679785,
-0.1080139205,
0.1838335395,
-0.44393152,
-0.1197554693,
-0.530688405,
0.2611117065,
-0.2883709967,
-1.2198181152,
0.4507385492,
-0.1109473035,
-0.4078098536,
0.3973145187,
0.5335066319,
-0.3984004557,
0.3773720562,
0.9417262673,
0.227579385,
0.5426296592,
-0.0385750011,
0.5074080229,
-0.8406378627,
-0.2267007232,
-0.7578416467,
-0.3299248815,
-0.6076328158,
-0.3010399342,
0.1533762664,
0.4331159592,
-0.1345918477,
0.2804540098,
-0.2508698106,
0.3962283731,
0.1896976829,
-0.3244312108,
0.0580748245,
-0.3166246116,
0.0391439982,
-0.4930917323,
-0.2597155571,
-0.8101351261,
0.6407377124,
0.5727741718,
0.6358929276,
0.4538903832,
0.5057106614,
0.2665919363,
0.1243915036,
-0.7646112442,
0.6688805223,
0.1020209491,
-0.7286300659,
-0.3854551315,
0.1191218197,
-0.9109980464,
0.3391735852,
-0.0795967877,
-1.2838867903,
0.5628070235,
-0.3073912859,
-0.4529892504,
0.2074514627,
-0.4762701392,
0.8128694892,
0.1469875127,
-0.2540730238,
-0.2175601125,
-0.5662544966,
0.2132009119,
0.0448945388,
0.046674896,
-0.4076362252,
0.0957540199,
0.9156201482,
-0.3419024348,
0.9199274778,
0.2551422119,
-0.1242262274,
0.8099370003,
0.2238678187,
-0.5366895199,
0.7058888674,
0.4967868626,
0.0756953806,
0.1669887453,
-0.0344775394,
-0.543069005,
0.3168715835,
-0.8940241337,
-1.5024534464,
-0.3670240045,
-0.7204447985,
-0.3979533017,
0.056097202,
0.1749625504,
1.1567325592,
-0.3646892905,
0.5766670704,
0.8814226985,
0.0529669523,
0.5113855004,
0.5458392501,
-0.4787470102,
-0.2480293959,
0.7999293804,
-0.0422234982,
0.6891342402,
0.3761046827,
0.1132018268,
-0.0895933211,
-0.5857930779,
-0.0475293808,
-0.0524099208,
-0.7839042544,
-0.1129642874,
-1.1282912493,
-0.1612867564,
-0.0492681488,
-0.172379151,
-0.1108312607,
-0.6938210726,
-0.2123113573,
-0.2005841583,
0.4706634879,
0.6364924312,
-0.1984785944,
0.5340651274,
-0.8916884661,
0.3310617805,
0.5947909951,
0.3233484626,
-0.2725876868,
-0.301292181,
0.0684798583,
-0.2677481174,
-0.7396495938,
-0.8657490611,
0.1095929071,
0.17059201,
0.8914576769,
0.5849609375,
-0.0330490209,
0.2367981225,
-0.5134397745,
1.2114363909,
0.1787901968,
-1.1115465164,
0.6435592175,
-0.6998736858,
-0.0775847733,
0.5278998613,
0.5497958064,
-1.075989604,
-0.7353569865,
-0.7327873111,
-0.7951052189,
0.9110205173,
0.1296851039,
0.4710350037,
-0.0165065657,
-0.0584555455,
0.263387084,
0.6674906611,
-0.4592279792,
-0.4655435979,
-0.1140150204,
0.3217536211,
-0.1140575707,
-0.361279428,
-0.6281754971,
-0.2204837799,
-0.1547971368,
0.1460895985,
0.661499083,
0.0561331771,
0.3629520237,
-0.2796801925,
0.4930124283,
0.7687579393,
0.9995787144,
-0.3833081722,
-0.2573786378,
-0.4583631754,
-0.5518174767,
0.3369602263,
-0.3323014677,
0.0991472527,
-0.1104165018,
0.1828783005,
0.8392722607,
0.0329684988,
-0.2882524133,
0.1656733751,
0.0958819166,
-0.1695023328,
0.0139875244,
0.3909059763,
0.2608929574,
0.3545092046,
0.4471764565,
0.3114562035,
0.1840774715,
-1.1546734571,
0.6816048026,
0.085238643,
-0.582437098,
-0.1047885567,
0.3623639643,
0.7601735592,
-0.8409489393,
0.0767626613,
0.1229244992,
-0.7906050682,
1.0384670496,
0.5249095559,
0.988561213,
-0.04438968,
0.5459558964,
-0.0195278171,
-0.2014544904,
0.189591527,
0.189201355,
-0.3643041849,
-0.9168192744,
-0.2351547331,
-0.390951544,
-0.892077744,
-0.0469525345,
-0.5881632566,
-0.0085947029,
-0.4366616607,
-0.1953801811,
0.3992563784,
-0.1060032025,
0.068629384,
-0.041156821,
0.0787984952,
0.6277159452,
-0.6513334513,
0.8840888143,
0.4413460195,
-0.3665471673,
-0.6832066774,
0.3109885156,
0.1644870341,
0.2083369941,
1.0565462112,
-0.1397480965,
-0.226875037,
-0.4440077245,
-0.3852616549,
-0.9508752823,
0.7732963562,
-0.2002863139,
-0.0725919083,
0.3442203104,
-0.0703608692,
0.7427393198,
-0.9516963959,
0.2962372601,
0.2509134114,
0.3437079191,
0.2921607792,
-1.2914284468,
-0.4145610631,
-0.2169930339,
0.0916573703,
0.406824708,
-0.8447319865,
0.9819517136,
0.3945519626,
0.0057849786,
0.2574524283,
0.7803063393,
-0.0744813904,
0.3472144306,
0.27386868,
-0.1361235529,
0.2188686728,
-0.469440043,
0.6340460777,
-0.0044254544,
0.3417765796,
0.6422263384,
-0.589377284,
0.4605597258,
0.2086442709,
-0.2863142192,
0.4429219663,
0.7342022657,
0.4136998057,
0.695751071,
0.2350286841,
-0.2220282406,
-0.3389573991,
-0.1639636606,
-0.6318052411,
0.7258403301,
1.0427120924,
0.1419902593,
-0.1034268141,
0.2178996652,
-0.0476143211,
0.310039103,
-0.1047143489,
0.922029078,
0.133319959,
-0.7148207426,
0.1732620448,
0.0486498661,
0.4495948255,
-0.9052407146,
-0.0200212821,
-0.3311955631,
-0.3145785332,
-0.0548330992,
-0.9124407172,
0.5467613935,
-0.3920999765,
-0.2526227534,
-0.3065428734,
0.8543717861,
-0.5936353207,
0.0622702166,
-0.1527806371,
0.4305538833,
-0.0847011656,
0.4962742031,
-0.5179570317,
0.1935992986,
0.0630893186,
-0.0327081718,
0.5063912272,
0.7045077085,
-0.3792112172,
0.553853631,
0.2490098178,
-0.0792175606,
-0.4832295179,
-0.2398371398,
0.9373036623,
-0.7540866733,
-0.9886188507,
-0.2888828814,
0.3939301372,
-0.2019589096,
-0.5811728239,
0.4079247117,
0.2428723723,
0.1469546407,
0.0792224109,
0.6022735238,
-0.5278818607,
0.4059703648,
-0.3555726409,
0.7276645303,
-0.1730738729,
0.1949974149,
-0.4352373779,
-1.111651659,
-0.0027787685,
0.6870189905,
-0.2786314487,
-0.0764432251,
0.9499792457,
0.4387666583,
0.0483977348,
0.5619986653,
0.4086101651,
-0.1612762064,
0.4000850618,
0.1113799438,
1.279335618,
0.1405676007,
0.0131225949,
-0.179249391,
-0.165454179,
-0.0605933405,
-0.6535112858,
-0.7636546493,
-1.0560190678,
-0.6823889017,
-0.2128205001,
-0.2071304023,
0.8699060678,
0.679566443,
-0.6040521264,
-0.7709427476,
0.3352720439,
0.5654477477,
0.0360908583,
-0.2279433608,
-0.0916673839,
-0.4454878569,
-0.8183946609,
0.2850431204,
0.8005578518,
-0.0976388007,
-0.3518437147,
0.2953537405,
-0.1892875135,
0.3091485798,
0.5362949371,
0.4810937345,
-0.8645156622,
-0.4980296493,
-0.393765837,
-0.1494176537,
0.2424761951,
1.6237267256,
-0.4810968041,
0.333617121,
0.3314576149,
0.3727050126,
0.2203326076,
0.0179916173,
1.1572693586,
-0.41531533,
0.6237132549,
0.2674013674,
0.2382428944,
-0.0539953113,
-0.4333450496,
0.4037911594,
0.7419216633,
-0.5147674084,
-0.71896559,
0.7113320827,
-1.1290544271,
-0.3461069167,
1.0475102663,
-0.1211808026,
0.0495764203,
-0.9950974584,
-0.5525835156,
-0.3970570564,
-0.4239811003,
0.1785684973,
1.109687686,
-0.3966551125,
-0.2197058499,
-0.5918200016,
0.781535387,
0.3129293621,
-0.5776051879,
-0.2238935381,
0.3999210894,
0.2153789401,
0.570831418,
0.9118233919,
0.0501105264,
0.1691402793,
0.0067311982,
-0.297444731,
0.481677264,
-0.5151263475,
0.0579752401,
0.3659209311,
0.0690410435,
-0.081734322
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03330v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03330v1
|
Measuring Misogyny in Natural Language Generation: Preliminary Results from a Case Study on two Reddit Communities
| 2023-12-06T07:38:46 | 2023-12-06T07:38:46 |
Aaron J. Snoswell, Lucinda Nelson, Hao Xue, Flora D. Salim, Nicolas Suzor, Jean Burgess
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
Generic `toxicity' classifiers continue to be used for evaluating the
potential for harm in natural language generation, despite mounting evidence of
their shortcomings. We consider the challenge of measuring misogyny in natural
language generation, and argue that generic `toxicity' classifiers are
inadequate for this task. We use data from two well-characterised `Incel'
communities on Reddit that differ primarily in their degrees of misogyny to
construct a pair of training corpora which we use to fine-tune two language
models. We show that an open source `toxicity' classifier is unable to
distinguish meaningfully between generations from these models. We contrast
this with a misogyny-specific lexicon recently proposed by feminist
subject-matter experts, demonstrating that, despite the limitations of simple
lexicon-based approaches, this shows promise as a benchmark to evaluate
language models for misogyny, and that it is sensitive enough to reveal the
known differences in these Reddit communities. Our preliminary findings
highlight the limitations of a generic approach to evaluating harms, and
further emphasise the need for careful benchmark design and selection in
natural language evaluation.
|
[
-0.0981837735,
-0.5602990389,
0.329911679,
0.1202659905,
0.0129766436,
-0.1396187991,
-0.0070641758,
-0.5871081352,
-0.151135698,
0.1410070658,
-0.4919802547,
-0.4235653579,
-0.5591040254,
0.513644278,
-0.4832895696,
0.9550324082,
0.2664133906,
0.1004174873,
-0.407104969,
-0.3419567645,
-0.7687065601,
-0.4856440723,
-0.5277177691,
-0.0513921864,
0.6187563539,
0.451788187,
0.7343037724,
0.3275719583,
0.4140235186,
0.2636918426,
-0.2758592367,
0.0952976122,
-0.6508644223,
0.3809054792,
-0.2986108065,
-0.2118650526,
0.0265344735,
0.2142978162,
0.1174912825,
0.7603719831,
0.0032392526,
0.2917323709,
0.0008712466,
0.6590232253,
-1.0116189718,
-0.475887835,
-0.799557209,
0.2448038161,
-0.1538249701,
0.2179448158,
-0.3579140604,
-0.7782694697,
0.0833436102,
-0.3252758086,
0.4213369489,
0.0914200619,
0.6580913067,
-0.0910233781,
-0.6005627513,
-0.7873604298,
-0.8477623463,
1.0348422527,
-0.7187659144,
0.2301706821,
0.0477780961,
0.1556304693,
-0.0172191411,
-0.5660422444,
-0.3672983944,
-0.6299850941,
-0.2716257274,
-0.1177050844,
-0.5207346082,
-0.1383499205,
0.2079409361,
0.4256439805,
-0.5639272332,
0.0642138943,
-0.4421660602,
-0.2079932243,
0.5813133121,
0.2016557753,
0.5095542073,
-0.3687086999,
-0.2423287779,
0.2066147774,
-0.6138338447,
-0.3508387804,
0.9179669619,
0.5100880861,
0.1839960068,
0.4391945899,
0.3479425907,
0.1985028684,
-0.0628876835,
0.0379683822,
0.1509466618,
-0.3924538195,
-0.0826456919,
-0.0732751489,
0.9073268771,
0.3845117092,
0.4653512537,
0.002069667,
0.0437520631,
0.6141192913,
0.6548663378,
-0.5892077684,
-0.3589150012,
-0.1109106615,
-0.3451545537,
-0.705642283,
-0.1720733941,
-0.9449587464,
-0.4675356448,
0.1517911553,
0.0957667977,
-0.1155589595,
-0.4653501511,
-0.1558406949,
-0.5926644802,
-0.058107838,
-0.0450895168,
-0.8630347848,
0.3306632638,
0.4414584637,
0.5386240482,
0.0021065392,
-0.0910936967,
-0.2825173736,
-0.240039289,
-0.4485569,
0.6926995516,
-0.7479386926,
-0.5227813125,
0.4170113504,
-0.3966382444,
0.0576209836,
-0.8815162182,
0.8879114985,
0.1271174252,
0.3553845882,
-0.1866725236,
-0.2831752896,
0.0792277679,
0.1785446405,
-0.3101521432,
1.0691401958,
0.1536214203,
-1.0951145887,
0.5277410746,
-0.4172403514,
-0.5642296672,
-0.1544246227,
0.0146404132,
-0.4070345461,
0.1866599321,
-0.2650440931,
0.122608684,
-0.2831213474,
0.2601566315,
-0.7069529295,
-0.1657630056,
0.3727421463,
-0.450651139,
0.6150990725,
0.2336451709,
-0.2164406031,
0.1020553261,
-0.6236513853,
-0.054331664,
0.0787729546,
-0.1918470562,
-0.7162014246,
0.1427539289,
0.2303744853,
0.4036595225,
-0.0442872345,
-0.6877715588,
-0.2724334598,
-0.3707139492,
0.5566005111,
0.6459593773,
-0.1660727412,
0.3682177663,
-0.4208391905,
0.3315490484,
-0.2769472301,
0.2864840925,
0.6591540575,
-0.3807027042,
-0.6967923045,
0.2982083261,
0.2135137171,
0.2366897464,
-0.3548456728,
0.4024861455,
-0.053165473,
-0.6670839787,
-0.4536791146,
0.0555679649,
0.8104883432,
0.508841157,
0.3876374662,
-0.4685226679,
-0.7562618852,
-1.0881822109,
-0.8404027224,
-0.481603384,
-0.0478761904,
0.3712798655,
0.5148537755,
-0.3444498181,
0.8367020488,
-0.2793519795,
-0.1668544114,
-0.1904638261,
0.5962058902,
-0.3655567467,
0.2711628377,
0.4570348859,
-0.569850266,
-0.3371616006,
-0.0950199142,
-0.7824554443,
-0.3733721673,
0.3306380212,
-0.2579927444,
0.0074695875,
0.3323489428,
-0.2334810793,
0.2871504128,
0.5236923695,
-0.388818562,
0.9317418933,
0.1490968168,
-0.0192094911,
-0.7209734917,
0.1969422102,
0.2513003349,
-0.0910216123,
-1.0208632946,
0.0526034385,
-0.0431959219,
-0.0614254922,
-0.6780238748,
0.4798123837,
-0.1796729416,
0.0735580921,
-0.2711770236,
0.206656456,
-0.2072894871,
0.0529194549,
-0.1214441359,
0.3928080499,
0.0663056374,
-0.6808130145,
-0.0029364373,
0.3711750209,
0.135951072,
0.6427381039,
-0.4356905818,
0.2759812474,
-0.1631359011,
0.1971547455,
-0.7984255552,
-0.4240209758,
0.3583704829,
-0.4258702397,
-0.0979581699,
-0.2943967879,
-0.3974275291,
-0.643226862,
-0.4226866961,
0.3590598106,
0.3825686574,
-0.3836095929,
0.1686037481,
0.3613372147,
-0.1083256826,
-0.5269939899,
-0.6979478002,
-0.0427297652,
-0.4016129673,
-0.6119953394,
0.0360677652,
-0.2180437297,
-0.6681708097,
-0.0342005417,
-0.2551667392,
-0.1967754066,
0.0598483421,
0.3880067766,
-0.0308664106,
0.0860492364,
0.6173122525,
0.2099070996,
0.1082211435,
0.3114642203,
0.2641665339,
0.4408869445,
-0.1016320214,
0.0631446019,
-0.0764874518,
0.6242194176,
0.3270733953,
-0.0786902159,
0.6125875711,
0.142724365,
-0.3358535469,
-0.4498419762,
-0.4201750159,
-0.0943708345,
-0.4382750392,
0.2519013584,
0.2146584541,
-0.8206005096,
0.1132953241,
-0.0082322629,
0.181117177,
0.7726784348,
0.3048835993,
-0.1369185746,
0.8505273461,
0.6314667463,
0.0856834352,
0.1765482277,
0.3336814344,
0.195345819,
-0.4280457497,
0.1658479869,
-0.8480111361,
-0.2708803713,
-0.6234698892,
0.2310989499,
0.1531125158,
-0.1268510222,
-0.6001226902,
0.351249367,
-0.5685564876,
0.2368106544,
0.3549198508,
-0.0979669839,
0.373997122,
-0.0624328032,
-0.0191936828,
-0.3526950181,
-0.7110838294,
-0.8621678948,
0.9939350486,
0.3931286633,
0.557474792,
0.184271425,
0.4475901723,
0.4238370955,
0.8511744738,
-0.3774585426,
0.4063551724,
-0.5159137845,
-1.0665378571,
0.0737308413,
-0.7973615527,
-0.866876781,
0.0859551728,
-0.2257155776,
-0.2655389607,
0.088823162,
0.1803503931,
-0.1435191482,
0.316222012,
-0.7649784088,
1.0055913925,
0.0052461843,
-0.0663265511,
0.1001254395,
-0.4640750885,
0.7643973827,
0.0668913275,
0.4903567135,
-0.3207983375,
0.2543669939,
0.8177157044,
-0.4230492413,
0.9745480418,
-0.0821719691,
-0.2312338352,
0.3350253105,
0.2046043128,
-0.0045268401,
-0.0641330928,
-0.0814130679,
0.0702366829,
-0.1420431435,
-0.1262025088,
0.0691854432,
0.7552332878,
-0.621936202,
-0.2757132351,
-0.4327588379,
-0.3319906294,
-0.2880016863,
0.0647996068,
0.5295283198,
0.3583360314,
-0.4586000144,
-0.0727565363,
0.3492010236,
-0.4176762402,
0.2172841877,
0.2921642065,
-0.0980729312,
-0.3418221772,
0.8558166027,
-0.0537544042,
0.5014504194,
0.0586549602,
0.5584300756,
-0.1798364967,
-0.2726441324,
-0.2801446915,
0.1622601002,
-0.7269259095,
-0.2724748254,
-0.4276873767,
-0.1951300055,
-0.6181037426,
-0.0347198769,
-0.4943932295,
0.1619143784,
-0.40323928,
-0.0470968783,
0.103440471,
1.0076528788,
-0.037669614,
0.0086843669,
-0.7325656414,
0.189264819,
0.6731809974,
0.2353685796,
-0.1653933227,
-0.4443254769,
0.3325430751,
0.0469500721,
-0.53544873,
-1.1737406254,
0.4470158815,
0.2103171498,
0.2729793787,
0.419043988,
0.2784405649,
0.4720258117,
-0.2386097759,
0.7482585311,
0.4015443325,
-0.8532961607,
0.7626583576,
-0.2889278829,
0.0476547144,
0.7497128248,
0.4864860177,
-0.8993279934,
-0.9171487689,
-0.6944804788,
-0.5956424475,
0.3904944062,
0.5354877114,
0.504847765,
-0.5079528689,
0.2647772431,
0.5130798817,
0.2527902722,
-1.1127500534,
-0.6065199375,
-0.0783641562,
-0.2271888703,
0.2019337118,
-0.5377467871,
-0.2432864308,
-0.014265256,
0.6724696755,
0.1682354659,
0.2672365308,
0.1142691076,
-0.1767568141,
-0.4977859557,
0.4974660575,
0.3948497474,
0.4123048186,
-0.1397696882,
0.0836369619,
0.1891861707,
-0.5432981849,
0.2773522437,
-0.0313739032,
-0.2565783858,
0.2786489427,
0.451444447,
0.5088644624,
0.4675130546,
-0.699680388,
0.6516316533,
-0.1185111254,
-0.5460050702,
-0.3859012723,
0.1353721172,
0.0300085321,
-0.0520566814,
0.136852771,
0.3872276545,
0.0533855408,
-0.8436954021,
-0.0196030382,
0.3865138888,
-0.6409962177,
-0.2162252963,
0.6656520367,
0.4817323387,
-0.385373652,
0.4781714678,
-0.5526649356,
-0.2967165709,
0.4841040075,
0.3661759496,
0.9425240755,
-0.1436752379,
0.3242216408,
0.7657238245,
0.4366053641,
0.0570075065,
0.1157077551,
0.5169710517,
-0.731564343,
0.1058950052,
-0.7411643863,
-0.2789937556,
0.2697637379,
-0.4392141998,
0.1518141925,
-0.5068871975,
-0.115582183,
-0.0147706801,
-0.136796996,
-0.5269216895,
0.1001954973,
0.2966477573,
0.7913011909,
-1.1925806999,
0.2064841092,
0.5512176156,
-0.3198947608,
-0.4826851785,
0.1303394884,
0.0110487267,
-0.0980091169,
0.4999679625,
0.5430725217,
-0.1541959643,
-0.4397530556,
-0.5637233257,
-0.4656477273,
0.7220025063,
0.2923077643,
-0.7010749578,
-0.0877317637,
0.1652787924,
0.7783927917,
-0.238930285,
0.2183239162,
0.4268325865,
0.4570123255,
-0.2186418921,
-0.9053980708,
0.0101632327,
-0.2897838652,
0.1991655976,
0.3920857012,
-0.1495651305,
0.9032273889,
-0.0735171065,
-0.7825238109,
0.1864293218,
0.5667254925,
0.0801487863,
0.4350377917,
0.7027142644,
0.6103330255,
0.5989412665,
0.1011739969,
0.9137793183,
0.390480727,
0.362147063,
1.135130167,
-0.1786776483,
0.8041822314,
0.0890335217,
-0.3873126805,
0.5651275516,
0.3981644809,
0.2223514915,
0.2641157508,
0.6249549985,
-0.4660333991,
-0.1997842342,
-0.157667473,
-0.3730150759,
0.2858386338,
0.2652063966,
-0.6201879978,
-0.5241861343,
0.0988459513,
0.1238964796,
0.472121805,
-0.2791509628,
0.7717234492,
0.1071930155,
-0.6115453839,
0.408887893,
0.0549312942,
0.9395076036,
-0.3917043209,
0.1948671788,
-0.3638337553,
-0.0371549055,
-0.2257347107,
-0.6471752524,
0.4807729721,
0.4194718301,
-0.1218024865,
-0.0093524382,
1.1283501387,
-0.4515500665,
-0.572276473,
0.4323742986,
0.5359423161,
0.1895685643,
-0.1805382073,
-0.4424932599,
-0.1223543659,
-0.1223482564,
0.2790506184,
0.3158595562,
0.2832424641,
0.1428673118,
0.6634633541,
0.6209362745,
-0.1095336229,
0.2400723249,
0.0592477731,
0.6490322351,
-0.7017527819,
-0.0126399836,
-0.8271930814,
0.2834358513,
-0.0316310488,
-0.9453738928,
0.6837210059,
0.3224917054,
0.8480554223,
-0.0348006189,
0.8579699993,
-0.2523219287,
0.7045941353,
-0.0997557119,
0.6839987636,
-0.4456205368,
0.083826527,
-0.3435629308,
-0.8993332386,
-0.4018653035,
0.393437326,
-0.3499296904,
0.1505125761,
0.6795329452,
0.8318586946,
-0.0297246762,
0.1765832156,
0.2384513766,
0.4439206719,
0.1814798415,
0.373082757,
1.1122362614,
-0.4486733973,
0.9814887047,
-0.2893286645,
-0.0142076463,
-0.1906594485,
-0.8438435197,
-0.9104091525,
-0.3096844256,
-0.4642184377,
-0.3227582276,
0.2076072842,
0.6437081695,
0.2411329001,
-0.5508654714,
-0.1465910971,
-0.5523375273,
0.1080916598,
-0.1568768322,
-0.2534323037,
-0.2906657755,
-0.4222432971,
-0.6018161178,
0.1321203411,
-0.0244179573,
-0.358832866,
-0.4742595851,
-0.0244479422,
-0.1747441739,
0.0330514871,
0.7277697325,
0.2375592887,
-0.5997475982,
-0.7330722809,
-0.3873324096,
-0.4728194773,
-0.0894486159,
0.7218170762,
-0.4885464609,
0.3060820401,
0.3413701355,
-0.0629259124,
-0.2390165478,
-0.2208702862,
0.5210578442,
-0.9060487747,
-0.4650074244,
0.4855662286,
0.1597283185,
0.4863357842,
-0.1523689181,
0.423594296,
0.4466552138,
-0.4949748218,
-0.8414148092,
0.474922359,
-0.50849998,
-0.436301291,
1.3472012281,
0.1954790652,
0.0066233892,
-0.2389988303,
-0.1941074878,
0.2511316836,
-0.5110903978,
0.8335649967,
0.5976774096,
0.2074680477,
0.1876530498,
-0.8354074955,
0.6888492107,
0.2638171315,
-0.9786410332,
0.3198446631,
0.6050077677,
0.4839923084,
0.3410407305,
0.3611822724,
-0.0902126059,
0.3662517071,
0.2694776356,
0.1689101458,
0.3771136701,
-0.1782104075,
-0.2067008466,
0.260558337,
-0.0435806736,
0.0834750459
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03312v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03312v1
|
Optimizing Two-Pass Cross-Lingual Transfer Learning: Phoneme Recognition and Phoneme to Grapheme Translation
| 2023-12-06T06:37:24 | 2023-12-06T06:37:24 |
Wonjun Lee, Gary Geunbae Lee, Yunsu Kim
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
This research optimizes two-pass cross-lingual transfer learning in
low-resource languages by enhancing phoneme recognition and phoneme-to-grapheme
translation models. Our approach optimizes these two stages to improve speech
recognition across languages. We optimize phoneme vocabulary coverage by
merging phonemes based on shared articulatory characteristics, thus improving
recognition accuracy. Additionally, we introduce a global phoneme noise
generator for realistic ASR noise during phoneme-to-grapheme training to reduce
error propagation. Experiments on the CommonVoice 12.0 dataset show significant
reductions in Word Error Rate (WER) for low-resource languages, highlighting
the effectiveness of our approach. This research contributes to the
advancements of two-pass ASR systems in low-resource languages, offering the
potential for improved cross-lingual transfer learning.
|
[
-0.1862507313,
-0.3498374224,
0.073447071,
0.1180320159,
-0.3951908052,
0.2510030866,
-0.237381041,
-0.6701282263,
-0.0676505938,
0.3782038093,
-0.2032727301,
-0.3017064631,
-0.6670295,
0.0240958128,
-0.1151494309,
0.3512376845,
-0.0831487626,
0.5017732978,
0.2002275288,
-0.2199555337,
-0.4088736773,
-0.2418604344,
-1.1865333319,
-0.7405977845,
0.4663478136,
0.5414315462,
0.4476706684,
0.2928115129,
0.3602958024,
0.1718660444,
-0.0623293929,
0.2675941586,
-0.4294815958,
-0.2088809609,
-0.2298416942,
-0.338029176,
-0.4923766851,
-0.020948993,
0.7355952263,
1.0424075127,
-0.0312164519,
-0.076500982,
0.1747767478,
0.5304814577,
-0.4787885845,
0.2366614044,
-0.5678415895,
0.1607644856,
-0.2886194587,
-0.2715777457,
-0.461977303,
-0.4230008423,
0.0594970621,
-0.8296072483,
-0.0477930903,
0.1378710866,
0.619333744,
0.0266267695,
-0.429630518,
-0.3492787778,
-0.5428519845,
0.9509422779,
-0.4723213613,
0.8892541528,
0.5268252492,
0.2043847144,
0.0847001299,
-0.5744167566,
-0.292075634,
0.1025502011,
-0.0838266462,
0.0380271673,
-0.393019557,
0.0107704103,
0.1027203351,
0.1222338453,
-0.7104994059,
0.2502258718,
-0.7572029233,
-0.6443363428,
0.652530551,
-0.3255244792,
0.5627630949,
0.1185361221,
-0.3429272175,
-0.1937379092,
-0.7004979253,
0.2309445292,
0.214891836,
0.5280187726,
-0.1963674426,
0.0458531529,
0.0764035806,
0.6995778084,
0.0388419367,
-0.0548023954,
0.4631074369,
-0.6756973863,
0.0491837934,
0.3612518311,
0.7221847773,
0.106088154,
0.3773673475,
-0.3661534488,
-0.1379639953,
0.0953210518,
-0.1249525771,
-0.9714879394,
-0.0080435332,
-0.1995099038,
-0.299728632,
-0.1678924561,
-0.2119106501,
-0.5747435093,
-0.0579409376,
-0.406802237,
0.4718517661,
-0.5990734696,
-0.379330188,
0.2786357105,
-0.0009584168,
0.2059427053,
0.3774445951,
-0.7616621852,
0.7598046064,
0.3439545929,
0.9457273483,
-0.3268935978,
-0.4290111065,
-0.9189471602,
0.1871140152,
-0.5226998329,
0.753069818,
-0.2448742837,
-0.6730920076,
-0.065613389,
0.0713593736,
-0.504549861,
-0.6710781455,
0.2873655856,
-0.4538123012,
0.154432103,
-0.1879250705,
-0.3630711436,
-0.4490467906,
-0.236393556,
-0.5979951024,
0.9576665759,
0.2525595129,
-0.4548152089,
0.1333130449,
-0.8223394752,
-0.8985027671,
-0.0233835299,
0.1383367628,
-0.2671928704,
-0.0285488926,
0.0269287396,
0.1422845423,
-0.3127430975,
-0.3712930083,
0.2208702415,
-0.5052449107,
0.1610563844,
-0.2741389573,
1.0593408346,
0.4050251245,
-0.1705882847,
-0.2761364877,
-0.9330371618,
0.3029716313,
-0.0058133383,
-0.5600667,
-0.3956680298,
-0.5507685542,
0.3234641254,
0.1872176677,
0.2079892159,
-0.5417870283,
0.0114557464,
-0.4103519619,
0.5062659383,
0.2204972059,
-0.1668270826,
0.8818420768,
-0.1547659338,
0.4189665914,
0.0955596343,
-0.1018808559,
0.3221985698,
-0.4685356319,
-0.4842082262,
0.1622793823,
0.6336357594,
0.9016799927,
-0.7822470069,
0.1393014342,
-0.2427407503,
-0.2069416195,
-0.5430573821,
0.5178573132,
0.5310797691,
0.3967330158,
0.4420517385,
-0.796446383,
-0.6050217748,
-0.5178402662,
-0.12762326,
-0.3474577367,
-0.0040625758,
0.3166882992,
-0.1401664466,
-0.2773142457,
0.3238123357,
-0.0704184175,
-0.256283462,
-0.4362368286,
0.2955415547,
-0.1258803457,
0.4617453814,
0.5650800467,
-0.6059895754,
-0.8184512258,
0.4667342901,
-0.254699856,
-0.5218172073,
0.1585733593,
-0.0369508564,
0.4213316143,
0.592517674,
-0.2814796865,
0.1668694466,
0.7589511871,
-0.3641098738,
0.0807944238,
-0.0499173366,
0.1744896024,
-1.0201742649,
0.1497362107,
-0.2810915709,
-0.4819571078,
-0.6663187146,
-0.5178111196,
0.0272843763,
-0.3538195789,
-0.6341941953,
0.6034126878,
-0.8041684031,
-0.4849376976,
-0.3010959029,
0.3885361552,
0.0932229087,
0.4413645566,
-0.0603068173,
1.164313674,
0.7619184256,
-0.4308302104,
0.2718091309,
0.2365015596,
-0.1568636149,
0.7919095159,
-0.4332413375,
0.5352900624,
0.273556143,
0.0859364793,
-0.8954204321,
0.1171859503,
0.4259058535,
-0.591827035,
0.618385911,
-0.2694509625,
-0.2439976186,
-0.0549995266,
-0.0048583793,
0.6883559823,
0.5954595804,
-0.4193674028,
0.5892295241,
0.4680551887,
-0.4016933143,
-0.3474107981,
-0.9611611366,
0.0643757433,
0.0787241459,
-0.6298472285,
0.3626856804,
0.153086707,
-0.1218913943,
-0.0375173241,
-0.1089805365,
-0.4221985936,
-0.2123764455,
-0.0946265161,
0.0543530434,
-0.2291749865,
0.064173989,
-0.1067414507,
-0.3123752475,
-0.1667490453,
-0.5368477702,
0.6313577294,
-0.0076180659,
-0.1929689646,
-0.6118072271,
0.5012741685,
0.3410089612,
-0.1243442968,
0.1428163648,
0.881223917,
-0.2947410345,
-0.1264330745,
-0.3046742976,
-0.1104087234,
-0.4317666292,
0.4931665361,
-0.5431969166,
-0.4772563875,
0.5198127031,
-0.199598223,
-0.1247056499,
0.219479382,
0.2836859822,
0.1067883,
0.6810392737,
0.421833992,
-0.2908678055,
0.6954698563,
-0.3819655478,
0.1135397926,
-0.7669490576,
0.0007710948,
-0.4500898421,
-0.268201232,
-0.4597846866,
-0.866466105,
0.0392002091,
0.2052121013,
0.0569771379,
0.6203711629,
-0.1798611134,
0.3225999177,
0.5977491736,
0.1075054109,
0.4017945826,
0.4982519448,
-0.2078716457,
0.0632808954,
-0.8823010325,
-0.1353272945,
0.8089607358,
0.243838191,
0.8469967842,
0.2037967592,
0.7243970037,
0.1965905726,
-0.2690769732,
-1.0596882105,
0.4748093486,
-0.4523797333,
-0.1018217951,
-0.5700088143,
-0.6087041497,
-1.1300983429,
0.1967141181,
0.1263030171,
-0.6915432811,
0.4147717953,
0.1356467754,
-0.1158898771,
0.2477061749,
-0.6794551611,
0.6865054965,
-0.2318692505,
-0.1482614577,
-0.6163425446,
-0.5743436813,
-0.1392669231,
-0.0712838918,
0.3091810644,
-0.0083274925,
-0.0660542548,
0.733756423,
-0.1945382506,
0.8169808388,
-0.2155028135,
-0.1508125365,
0.3737558424,
0.1429796368,
0.4907409847,
-0.3904445171,
-0.0415511765,
0.6231608391,
-0.0774863735,
-0.420666635,
-0.4046214819,
0.4181061089,
-0.8606227636,
-0.0562489294,
-0.1144009009,
-0.7551487088,
-0.2616933584,
0.1928043365,
0.4881947339,
0.4628306031,
-0.2144782692,
0.0323082507,
0.6551784277,
0.0105740521,
0.3104470074,
0.5970997214,
-0.0880347192,
-0.5632060766,
1.1091327667,
0.5277525783,
0.6018529534,
0.0896022469,
0.185240835,
-0.3135388196,
-0.6389269829,
-0.6591220498,
0.3609678447,
-0.6949948668,
-0.0860011429,
-0.4052791297,
-0.3932085931,
-0.5540593266,
-0.0217660312,
-0.4302081466,
-0.6238914728,
-0.3178626597,
0.2098754793,
0.2210605741,
0.5413950086,
-0.6493835449,
0.487485081,
-0.8578959703,
0.1849731654,
0.4130370021,
0.2173119187,
-0.1940201223,
-0.9352493882,
-0.3957917988,
-0.0875997618,
-0.1416081041,
-0.8245413303,
0.1616941541,
0.6473686099,
0.5472849607,
0.1956306994,
-0.1525809914,
0.5205706358,
-0.6269261241,
0.3343583643,
0.5998362303,
-1.1192861795,
0.5575453043,
-0.0596891828,
0.1670030504,
0.3650361598,
0.11361292,
-0.7751381397,
0.0429785959,
-0.5206270814,
-0.6349389553,
0.7147372365,
0.1792176515,
-0.123302862,
0.6073568463,
0.0487961993,
0.050422173,
-0.1169710904,
-0.3998475373,
-0.0516109578,
-0.1312341541,
-0.0832005143,
0.0632527694,
-0.1100215614,
-0.1535318196,
-0.17633003,
0.7841556668,
-0.3199227452,
0.0929083973,
-0.0308841001,
-0.2972803712,
-0.5367431641,
0.4382444322,
0.4256091118,
0.477987498,
-0.0021709763,
0.1547906846,
0.6241200566,
-0.7845728993,
0.309684515,
0.4871875346,
-0.1574032456,
0.281109482,
0.3150658309,
0.9392605424,
0.3268449605,
-0.2043501288,
0.5247945786,
0.0762250051,
-0.286103636,
-0.1563514322,
0.0377904251,
0.1572981924,
0.277076751,
0.228213191,
0.2451304048,
0.2727350891,
-0.6110361814,
0.2582123876,
0.2198879719,
-0.3586358726,
-0.6641125679,
0.4025433362,
0.4492205083,
-0.5143839121,
0.2630791664,
-0.2637917101,
-0.5845404863,
0.3920614719,
0.727216959,
0.7657473683,
-0.6252324581,
0.0956344604,
0.3946300447,
0.0540456474,
-0.127398327,
0.5018867254,
-0.1816748083,
-0.9420167804,
-0.3576343358,
-0.467120707,
-0.5925982594,
-0.2035553455,
-0.7683270574,
0.4984919131,
-0.142198354,
-0.0415765345,
0.0251185335,
0.2432509363,
-0.7031825185,
0.1197441742,
0.3380405009,
0.7447885871,
-0.9182127118,
1.0739411116,
0.7230520248,
-0.3316150904,
-0.9379739761,
-0.1736618131,
0.0383335091,
-1.1098315716,
0.8757511377,
-0.1283799708,
-0.5112918615,
0.242127791,
-0.1855531186,
-0.9097622037,
0.935195148,
0.4088428915,
-0.8225650787,
-0.0366555266,
0.2621504366,
0.2240414619,
-0.2347614467,
-0.1329396665,
0.5879205465,
0.4300856888,
0.5788261294,
-1.3098061085,
-0.0755289271,
-0.0079196915,
0.018448025,
0.2101413012,
-0.6648083329,
0.5879051089,
-0.3078469336,
-0.3814667165,
-0.154761821,
0.3661650717,
0.1451631188,
0.4932895899,
0.7316434383,
0.431709528,
0.8164266944,
0.0294052269,
0.5200527906,
-0.3341347277,
0.1454679072,
0.9253427386,
-0.2577459514,
0.9131705761,
0.5215485096,
-0.3500995934,
0.2127541304,
0.5635718703,
0.17460455,
0.5560674667,
0.1632523537,
-0.3372889161,
-0.1443071514,
-0.3343284428,
-0.3449045122,
0.5502112508,
0.4469329715,
-0.0234898012,
-0.1869401187,
0.067375645,
0.0266031884,
-0.0940717608,
-0.3949777186,
0.8028678298,
0.4574003518,
-0.2401539981,
0.9420915246,
-0.4389107525,
0.5923220515,
-0.4832008183,
-0.036351908,
-0.2200139016,
0.1236532927,
-0.281100601,
-0.4946948588,
0.318839401,
-0.2298648655,
0.0610076264,
-0.2050042152,
0.9997637272,
-0.9460325837,
-0.5410605669,
0.7023540735,
0.6190497875,
0.5262742639,
0.2956867516,
-0.7147619128,
0.1235414147,
0.08220312,
0.1047565788,
0.2263367027,
0.5848377347,
0.1319315732,
0.2957496345,
0.6225488186,
0.774258554,
0.0543396734,
0.5030814409,
0.5892378092,
-0.4843771458,
-0.7266117334,
-0.3537470996,
0.1216142997,
-0.1014700383,
-0.0150859151,
0.3769061863,
0.5163478851,
1.0007532835,
0.1697667837,
0.858694613,
0.0913631544,
0.7100393772,
-0.7314913273,
0.626052618,
-0.6374296546,
0.1904673874,
-0.0231350344,
-0.7145540118,
-0.2222889215,
0.7952187061,
-0.1425808221,
-0.1931479722,
0.7310356498,
0.8926583529,
-0.2589413524,
-0.201068759,
0.7096350193,
-0.0473818481,
-0.0662852749,
0.7926934958,
0.5816630125,
-0.8879143596,
0.8976098895,
-0.2701726258,
-0.0677815899,
-0.2654619515,
-0.3794724047,
-0.6565303802,
-0.4230875373,
-0.4495405853,
-0.498557359,
0.3025492132,
0.8545581698,
0.7819666862,
-1.0531338453,
-0.6689618826,
0.0272777583,
-0.0126461703,
-0.3972057104,
-0.1772716343,
0.4357127249,
-0.6284269094,
-0.8969553113,
0.5707660913,
0.1589484811,
0.3168815672,
-0.0170550402,
-0.4047745168,
-0.0142035112,
-0.0080169821,
0.5748969316,
0.4322906733,
-0.5187704563,
-0.2610070109,
-0.0089832554,
-0.2747370303,
0.398882091,
0.9733015299,
-0.3991194963,
0.3069536686,
0.6247593164,
0.6775336266,
0.4515808225,
-0.1891016364,
0.6922620535,
-0.6931657791,
0.4250821173,
0.0996589884,
0.427049011,
0.5710585117,
-0.268237263,
0.778388679,
0.4486140907,
-0.3998166621,
-0.6313031316,
0.2777192593,
-1.0458071232,
-0.1264505535,
1.3422083855,
-0.0967955142,
-0.0610479638,
-0.3440872729,
-0.2446333021,
0.6042736769,
-0.479254663,
0.3377860188,
0.5156196952,
-0.1998928487,
-0.3124656379,
-0.5612726808,
0.5505612493,
0.2539399564,
-0.6110940576,
-0.0316962823,
0.4285110831,
0.5595360398,
0.3491636217,
0.7423713207,
-0.1567385197,
0.5021269917,
0.222081393,
0.1297001094,
0.107341893,
-0.132641986,
-0.4225088656,
-0.2264068872,
0.1052597016,
-0.5773987174
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03303v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03303v1
|
Dyport: Dynamic Importance-based Hypothesis Generation Benchmarking Technique
| 2023-12-06T06:07:50 | 2023-12-06T06:07:50 |
Ilya Tyagin, Ilya Safro
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This paper presents a novel benchmarking framework Dyport for evaluating
biomedical hypothesis generation systems. Utilizing curated datasets, our
approach tests these systems under realistic conditions, enhancing the
relevance of our evaluations. We integrate knowledge from the curated databases
into a dynamic graph, accompanied by a method to quantify discovery importance.
This not only assesses hypothesis accuracy but also their potential impact in
biomedical research which significantly extends traditional link prediction
benchmarks. Applicability of our benchmarking process is demonstrated on
several link prediction systems applied on biomedical semantic knowledge
graphs. Being flexible, our benchmarking system is designed for broad
application in hypothesis generation quality verification, aiming to expand the
scope of scientific discovery within the biomedical research community.
Availability and implementation: Dyport framework is fully open-source. All
code and datasets are available at: https://github.com/IlyaTyagin/Dyport
|
[
-0.0531338751,
-0.4206944108,
0.7872813344,
0.1605524868,
-0.120211333,
0.3048512936,
0.233531788,
-0.4344706535,
0.1641316563,
-0.2202206254,
-0.7069670558,
-0.4014201164,
-0.6253398061,
0.0558659509,
-0.4753288031,
0.6233522296,
0.1826549917,
0.2243470848,
-0.5916430354,
-0.0773418024,
-0.2267014384,
0.2314320058,
-0.0690962523,
-0.3124766648,
0.6099206805,
0.2459741086,
0.661210835,
1.12322402,
0.9688116908,
0.2700569034,
-0.1534790993,
-0.0794380903,
-0.7081347108,
0.6397238374,
-0.2002469301,
-0.6089750528,
-0.515358448,
-0.1268551052,
0.7812169194,
1.0719190836,
-0.2047831565,
0.5431420207,
-0.4387875199,
0.5198634267,
-0.7825648189,
0.3257869482,
-0.8024148941,
-0.0420778394,
-0.4775803983,
-0.3127017915,
-0.0332187861,
-0.6823105216,
0.3418149054,
-0.6172882318,
0.3702483177,
0.363702029,
0.5542682409,
0.7216111422,
-0.270647347,
-0.28474769,
-0.2271725535,
0.7521204948,
-0.5354078412,
0.375371784,
-0.0682718083,
0.6124922633,
-0.5951858163,
-1.0576561689,
-0.3153198361,
-0.038613297,
0.0981960297,
-0.0437765606,
0.0407090522,
0.0004815233,
0.4622754753,
0.6136761904,
-0.2984019816,
0.0228107218,
-0.3572263718,
-0.1182762384,
0.604385674,
0.222249791,
0.3071384132,
0.0836608037,
-0.2830625772,
-0.3165976107,
-0.8368107677,
0.0374500304,
0.3753659129,
0.0340538733,
0.1040302739,
0.5950135589,
-0.6021658778,
0.6373786926,
0.3027902246,
-0.4403755069,
0.7096596956,
-0.2700782716,
0.1833950877,
0.5884504914,
0.689078331,
0.4956616163,
-0.3980956376,
-0.1117423847,
0.1517163664,
0.0980667993,
0.1228080839,
-1.0890957117,
-0.1804460734,
0.6181610823,
-0.5714059472,
-0.7304235101,
-0.0597228445,
-1.1095836163,
-0.5003625154,
0.3486560881,
0.3194680512,
-0.4085237086,
-0.4230585098,
0.2466784269,
-0.5221602917,
-0.3913195133,
0.3314894438,
-0.8412694335,
0.1400703639,
0.526848793,
0.6881351471,
-0.6863431931,
-0.2463054806,
-0.4067142904,
0.2897921801,
-0.144528538,
0.7628131509,
-0.1406375766,
-0.0900832042,
-0.034713272,
-0.0575145818,
0.1268391162,
-0.4190894365,
0.7774050832,
-0.5672049522,
-0.1434312761,
-0.3233656883,
-0.693300426,
0.1801916212,
-0.0850200355,
-0.6647911072,
0.9256851673,
0.198518008,
-1.288315773,
1.0121451616,
-0.7769622803,
-0.4695391357,
0.5798350573,
-0.284924686,
-0.4685090184,
0.1589493901,
-0.2055986524,
0.3010213971,
-0.4640690386,
0.6675732136,
-0.5925110579,
-0.3105804324,
0.4495613873,
-0.1968487948,
0.665964067,
0.3507472575,
-0.742644012,
0.1603879184,
-1.1786231995,
0.3585647047,
0.106038928,
-0.2097270787,
-0.3151049912,
0.4126883149,
-0.3546904027,
0.0279925,
0.2293009609,
-0.8577868342,
0.0947681889,
-0.2848603129,
0.4356436133,
0.3517105877,
0.1177072823,
0.1047112942,
-0.1813840568,
0.4306303859,
-0.286280036,
0.2087026685,
0.153321743,
-0.4333232939,
-0.3060121834,
-0.5977458954,
0.4710769355,
0.0839755461,
-0.3567261398,
0.5342214704,
-0.5950696468,
-0.592728734,
-0.5548282862,
-0.4235826731,
0.1593971103,
0.6511890292,
0.4706366062,
0.0856911615,
-0.3941831291,
-0.9728839993,
0.1367515773,
-0.6570871472,
-0.1274973452,
-0.0357944965,
0.4578793943,
-0.3713598251,
0.9076066017,
-0.818277359,
0.5412927866,
0.1172173247,
-0.0593402907,
0.4796931744,
0.3047286272,
0.62156564,
-0.8079440594,
-0.2204764634,
-0.4512702823,
-0.9120912552,
-0.5084878802,
0.3324435651,
-0.2968798876,
-0.5519499183,
0.3382342756,
-0.6458130479,
0.466860801,
0.4113807082,
-0.0965358168,
0.6990875602,
-0.0989280269,
0.4802508354,
-0.6559180617,
0.3810527325,
-0.571033895,
0.1638816446,
-0.4503275156,
-0.2250964195,
0.0937892348,
-0.0060872138,
-0.2463841885,
0.3813513517,
-0.3578554392,
-0.0306575801,
-0.2349698097,
-0.3565083146,
-0.0902590081,
-0.2764324546,
-0.1166616976,
0.3904272318,
0.5736778378,
-0.5024580359,
0.4526116848,
0.408395499,
-0.7827170491,
0.4259698689,
-0.7593482733,
-0.5953766108,
0.1070483327,
0.1339994371,
-1.0762676001,
-0.3802855611,
0.1177190393,
-0.2917498648,
0.3349054754,
-0.0797988474,
-0.5093107224,
-0.8938952088,
-0.2891869843,
0.5459396243,
0.4760167301,
-0.6125796437,
-0.3602582812,
0.7137094736,
-0.0351845883,
-0.6754772663,
-0.384570539,
-0.3282898366,
-0.4811087847,
-0.5766795874,
0.7346377969,
-0.2126107067,
-0.3686786592,
-0.0393754952,
-0.4215683937,
0.1871726066,
0.1997614652,
0.5533109307,
0.0309767164,
0.0999228507,
0.3428929448,
0.4611410201,
-0.247798115,
0.1576458812,
-0.3763459027,
0.3145275414,
0.1520411074,
-0.6091813445,
-0.2811231315,
0.1096349061,
0.9063888788,
0.0517784916,
0.3962144852,
0.4808430374,
-0.2939136326,
-0.0483316891,
-0.458681196,
-0.2472156435,
-0.4828353226,
0.5608581305,
-0.1432384402,
-0.5690644383,
0.3920047581,
-0.595250845,
-0.0512727387,
0.5839975476,
0.697371304,
-0.1163069978,
0.8610937595,
0.4051299393,
0.2954476774,
0.4085026383,
-0.1649269462,
0.1804299206,
-0.513631165,
-0.1183219478,
-0.5257316828,
-0.3313379586,
-0.8167977333,
-0.5285865664,
0.6697816849,
0.2966840863,
-0.2167857289,
0.170485884,
-0.736651361,
-0.1032755598,
0.3943542242,
0.0772817656,
0.4162715971,
0.2480074465,
-0.4223174751,
0.0066370857,
-0.915227592,
-0.3103161454,
1.2492228746,
0.3625991046,
0.8130230308,
-0.0457702726,
0.6093981266,
0.372779876,
0.329354018,
-0.7601222992,
0.4949173331,
0.6773985028,
-0.7506123185,
-0.6347873211,
-0.5133651495,
-1.2848420143,
0.0106999036,
-0.4845863581,
-0.8127638102,
0.5924949646,
0.1387192905,
-0.2977120578,
0.1451087594,
-0.1579336524,
0.5253208876,
-0.3450419903,
-0.8227052093,
-0.4445032477,
-0.7363463044,
0.1949968785,
-0.1832884997,
0.0501531363,
-0.5896540284,
-0.2033975124,
0.8201893568,
-0.5391080976,
0.317301482,
-0.1588360667,
0.1336092651,
0.1083203554,
-0.0182167701,
0.2299681604,
0.3134568632,
-0.7241274118,
0.3666236103,
0.3454346657,
-0.315079987,
-0.3410405219,
0.9300442338,
-0.5099794269,
-0.3595944941,
-0.5536701679,
-0.7638632655,
-0.0543432944,
0.533195436,
0.4933169782,
0.2934726179,
-0.2730343938,
0.275056392,
0.4410967231,
-0.21074678,
0.2273675352,
0.6108805537,
0.055390615,
-0.6072112322,
0.6577502489,
0.1440628171,
0.2267856002,
0.4619714022,
0.2466483116,
-0.5984942913,
-1.044028163,
-0.4302958846,
0.1315182894,
-0.5410031676,
-0.2884621918,
-0.7572287321,
0.289029032,
-0.398848027,
-0.043693345,
-0.6150301695,
-0.5161361098,
0.3992224336,
-0.1079580933,
0.5059203506,
0.534234345,
-0.1885576248,
0.1291786283,
-0.4589084089,
0.2214798182,
0.1327771842,
0.4992632866,
-0.1221731752,
0.0539918542,
-0.3674645722,
0.0098578893,
-0.4077649117,
-0.9846429229,
0.2679380178,
-0.0410088897,
1.1844851971,
0.3816319406,
0.3833665848,
0.3975404501,
-0.4760353267,
0.2227220088,
0.4230813086,
-0.4809538126,
0.8299892545,
-0.7359261513,
0.0282810107,
0.9359080791,
0.5779700279,
0.0392061099,
-0.037079338,
-1.0044585466,
-1.1623938084,
0.3538511992,
0.4368372858,
-0.8515161872,
-0.1576643288,
0.4327947199,
0.2992047966,
0.7153314352,
-0.0202444158,
-0.3078706264,
0.0082093887,
-0.3281566501,
0.1174753159,
-0.1901973039,
-0.3040350378,
-0.404501617,
0.2964326739,
-0.2871809006,
0.3328687549,
0.2325422168,
0.0130424891,
-0.3213753998,
-0.0448034443,
0.0729322359,
1.0514279604,
-0.7316768169,
-0.0448284745,
-0.0618172623,
-0.5634691715,
0.4020366669,
0.2990261614,
-0.4767793417,
0.05746831,
0.3249868751,
0.4550745189,
0.3666321635,
-0.6027299762,
0.3594007194,
0.0923924223,
-0.0811125636,
0.1403478086,
0.2186705172,
0.05984395,
0.0196467284,
0.5220977068,
-0.056018021,
0.5412371159,
-0.4481634796,
0.3821721077,
0.0461165458,
-0.4318185449,
-0.2805936933,
0.8627485633,
0.284951359,
0.0241490323,
0.3383909762,
-0.0548710488,
-0.1798853427,
0.6808230281,
0.3797263205,
0.513252914,
-0.2576687038,
0.1912337691,
0.7948628068,
-0.2091390938,
-0.2753764987,
0.1371623576,
-0.1126864031,
-0.4307147264,
-0.2236308455,
-0.8500857949,
-0.5960282087,
-0.1895094663,
-0.751291275,
0.4167799652,
-0.049024526,
-0.5012507439,
0.4130427837,
0.2725652456,
-0.4576870799,
0.0267399568,
-0.3420830667,
0.7262670398,
-0.7128012776,
0.7738881707,
0.5928393602,
0.041710794,
-0.1943046898,
0.0790540576,
0.2103688717,
-0.5904065967,
0.7282122374,
0.0428852886,
0.0749551356,
0.1020755768,
-0.3967166841,
-1.3536348343,
1.3879112005,
0.4441567659,
-0.5674504042,
0.3687081933,
0.062238548,
0.6997289658,
-0.4539803565,
0.5963687301,
0.3615976572,
0.5512946844,
0.3381807804,
-0.7178965807,
0.3492262959,
-0.2885715067,
-0.2760439813,
0.1680740565,
-0.5819228292,
0.5056306124,
-0.4044183195,
-0.2730598748,
0.2319169492,
0.2840894163,
0.7101877928,
0.4713058472,
0.5644074082,
0.2782258391,
1.1513011456,
-0.1604711264,
0.921933949,
-0.4531632662,
0.2682698369,
0.817974627,
-0.4522757828,
0.5261480212,
0.6489153504,
-0.5302206874,
0.3900574148,
0.8087770939,
-0.1328092664,
0.6784607768,
0.7805117369,
0.0849813446,
-0.1138706133,
-0.3051452637,
-0.8303720355,
0.192713201,
0.5835441947,
-0.3185122907,
-0.2278911769,
-0.4764350057,
-0.3060261607,
-0.3023044169,
0.0920569971,
0.3287433088,
-0.3895341158,
-0.5521823168,
0.7805866003,
-0.542088151,
0.5121024847,
-0.7047105432,
-0.0722382665,
0.1412836313,
0.3802597821,
-0.2692296207,
-0.6810284853,
-0.0732624754,
-0.4169900417,
-0.4434116185,
-0.1301260144,
0.7467591763,
-0.0746570826,
-0.4458287358,
0.4643343389,
0.5321890712,
0.2525976002,
0.3901885748,
-0.5864447951,
0.1917829067,
0.004555895,
-0.2408960611,
0.6539732814,
0.410528779,
-0.107012257,
0.946084559,
0.7308068275,
0.2675272822,
-0.1520551741,
-0.1922434568,
0.9432448745,
-0.5164462924,
-0.2916454077,
-0.4494027495,
0.3494563699,
-0.4348618686,
-0.2401993722,
0.8191845417,
0.6574860215,
0.2417351305,
-0.0111663761,
0.6470584273,
-0.3904567063,
0.7223482132,
0.0319886394,
0.858577311,
-0.4730356038,
0.3400621116,
-0.3970976472,
-0.6931155324,
-0.2118473202,
0.2241695523,
-0.276640445,
-0.3417985141,
0.8656359315,
0.5641772747,
0.0899417922,
0.0554521978,
0.14449507,
0.3412104249,
0.4707557857,
0.2126269937,
0.8487874866,
-0.4308470786,
0.2953006327,
-0.2711999118,
-0.7498980165,
-0.3926774859,
-1.1465512514,
-0.4513137937,
-0.407281518,
-0.7185038924,
-0.4121592045,
0.1486170143,
0.5642559528,
0.93391186,
-0.7625182271,
-0.1091980562,
-0.0583173782,
0.1719906479,
-0.4350894988,
-0.2022843361,
0.6691266298,
-0.278521806,
-0.5576873422,
0.5972788334,
0.4420225024,
0.033104632,
-0.0232288241,
0.1713722497,
-0.3360669315,
-0.4349883795,
0.3602421284,
0.3883170187,
-0.3897940218,
-0.1147091612,
0.0238838363,
0.0055790558,
-0.2128405273,
0.6287600994,
-0.7909459472,
0.5266600251,
1.1165499687,
0.3067396879,
0.6087713242,
-0.0753978193,
0.8206171989,
-0.1749300212,
0.3680719137,
0.1990998685,
0.3102217913,
0.1592528224,
-0.5139699578,
0.8321200013,
0.5204507113,
-0.7091620564,
-1.249889493,
0.0187175348,
-1.0917576551,
0.0361050144,
0.9557090998,
-0.2268995345,
-0.2966218293,
-0.3376691937,
0.3173903525,
0.1723092347,
-0.4060713649,
0.9085762501,
0.1127566248,
-0.3176675737,
0.5225785375,
-0.6272127032,
0.6740775108,
0.265327543,
-0.6082254648,
0.0900964811,
0.3500604033,
0.4238494039,
0.3239359856,
0.4637272954,
-0.3925753534,
0.1707312465,
0.2629454732,
0.2578696012,
0.0514425077,
-0.0689053088,
0.2681239247,
0.3752939105,
-0.0887690485,
-0.2620723844
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03290v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03290v1
|
Can language agents be alternatives to PPO? A Preliminary Empirical Study On OpenAI Gym
| 2023-12-06T04:48:26 | 2023-12-06T04:48:26 |
Junjie Sheng, Zixiao Huang, Chuyun Shen, Wenhao Li, Yun Hua, Bo Jin, Hongyuan Zha, Xiangfeng Wang
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
The formidable capacity for zero- or few-shot decision-making in language
agents encourages us to pose a compelling question: Can language agents be
alternatives to PPO agents in traditional sequential decision-making tasks? To
investigate this, we first take environments collected in OpenAI Gym as our
testbeds and ground them to textual environments that construct the TextGym
simulator. This allows for straightforward and efficient comparisons between
PPO agents and language agents, given the widespread adoption of OpenAI Gym. To
ensure a fair and effective benchmarking, we introduce $5$ levels of scenario
for accurate domain-knowledge controlling and a unified RL-inspired framework
for language agents. Additionally, we propose an innovative
explore-exploit-guided language (EXE) agent to solve tasks within TextGym.
Through numerical experiments and ablation studies, we extract valuable
insights into the decision-making capabilities of language agents and make a
preliminary evaluation of their potential to be alternatives to PPO in
classical sequential decision-making problems. This paper sheds light on the
performance of language agents and paves the way for future research in this
exciting domain. Our code is publicly available
at~\url{https://github.com/mail-ecnu/Text-Gym-Agents}.
|
[
-0.0951524153,
-0.7722936869,
0.5761594176,
-0.0240586605,
0.1798910201,
0.0435835309,
-0.4587101936,
-0.3543717861,
0.0331235342,
0.5057306886,
-0.4226624072,
-0.2800506055,
-0.2414882332,
0.1500590593,
0.0476147458,
0.9003496766,
-0.3999031782,
-0.1573453546,
-0.271986872,
-0.3157710135,
-0.5266953707,
-0.5385097861,
-0.8985754848,
-0.770367682,
0.4379283488,
0.4066243768,
0.8857156634,
0.2902071774,
0.0773067698,
0.4355563819,
0.1359473318,
-0.1094641611,
-0.4310183227,
0.0604659691,
-0.2660451531,
-0.8465791941,
-0.2423932701,
0.2805840969,
0.7272633314,
0.4080115855,
-0.0299297422,
-0.2434634268,
-0.2887420356,
0.7287478447,
-0.459089309,
0.068351835,
-0.6581682563,
0.2808363736,
0.099861376,
-0.2902885973,
-0.5901820064,
-0.0402163826,
0.1578784734,
-0.7220159769,
-0.096422255,
0.042331133,
0.6906216145,
0.2491078824,
-0.0413959622,
-0.3638057113,
-0.8043048978,
0.5644164085,
-0.4096390605,
0.2553752661,
0.4790810347,
0.2911596298,
-0.1432634443,
-0.4737514555,
-0.5338439345,
-0.4546034634,
-0.0544335544,
0.3522269726,
-0.0737626255,
0.0920354128,
0.2745457888,
0.0399002358,
-0.7886528373,
0.2289815545,
0.0448851176,
0.2552799881,
0.3429956436,
-0.105092518,
0.7187839746,
0.0281643141,
-0.1320116818,
-0.3090535402,
-0.5304628015,
0.141408667,
0.6420033574,
0.2640151083,
0.1642595679,
0.8190219402,
-0.2655780017,
0.4656554461,
-0.349794656,
-0.1221044138,
0.160351783,
-0.1453794837,
-0.4253127277,
0.2399365008,
0.8549067378,
0.0879413858,
0.413957268,
-0.411857903,
-0.0640781596,
0.1236547753,
0.4052295387,
-0.6829699278,
-0.3462288678,
0.4799050987,
-0.291857183,
-0.2932324409,
-0.0799074769,
-0.5756446123,
-0.3006175756,
0.0439826548,
0.4784314632,
-0.7575249672,
-0.3974738419,
0.1332328618,
-0.3998840451,
0.5089902282,
0.3117288351,
-0.623669982,
0.6070935726,
0.5670477748,
0.9087507129,
0.1664253026,
-0.7432271838,
-0.1950078756,
-0.0066442294,
-0.4763295352,
0.6818750501,
-0.7497434616,
-0.5096772909,
-0.0299458727,
-0.5103775263,
-0.3705725074,
-0.5189087987,
0.3488779962,
-0.5010305047,
0.339559406,
0.0509897396,
-0.4262335002,
-0.0336547084,
0.2845321,
-0.6014233232,
0.7648268938,
0.0998206884,
-0.4194393754,
0.3876327276,
-0.7004470825,
-0.3324880898,
0.2233723402,
-0.3047718406,
-0.4529055655,
-0.0269411989,
-0.1828251183,
-0.1462218612,
-0.0682551414,
0.0701493099,
-0.2379467189,
-0.3218382597,
0.67365098,
-0.2020363659,
0.435883224,
0.2685623467,
-0.4717455804,
0.2453512251,
-0.4404358268,
0.2670449615,
0.3708215058,
-0.1767526418,
-0.5282625556,
0.3829475343,
-0.4161164463,
0.4403492808,
0.0224432927,
-0.2383924723,
0.4974645078,
-0.3788883388,
0.1224478409,
0.8134778738,
-0.2861860394,
0.851634562,
-0.4537027478,
0.7714799643,
-0.4258363843,
0.046468541,
-0.1747321188,
-0.6694735885,
-0.6534879208,
-0.3336336315,
0.3530841172,
0.6613745093,
-1.0948091745,
0.2648008168,
-0.2189313471,
-0.2411204576,
-0.4329663217,
-0.0964618474,
0.5075952411,
0.2803787887,
-0.0096207233,
-0.1439580321,
-0.5069431067,
-0.5140038729,
-0.6496836543,
-0.4996023774,
0.0834099054,
0.4597590566,
0.6822988391,
0.1422156841,
0.987120688,
-0.2360326201,
-0.3157438338,
-0.4874814153,
0.3505782783,
0.1425195783,
0.3046207726,
0.6698177457,
-0.9265133142,
-0.4789916873,
0.2241064608,
-0.9305953979,
-0.1014659181,
-0.4220606089,
-0.0498588458,
0.314119935,
0.2632328272,
-0.5829183459,
0.2604313791,
0.4581837058,
-0.4485652149,
0.4711706936,
-0.4690702558,
0.3266978562,
-0.5983046889,
0.2897389233,
-0.1121357977,
-0.2381603867,
-0.8495374322,
0.2524070442,
-0.1034455895,
-0.3334886134,
-0.4018229842,
0.6459171176,
-0.323933512,
-0.0811065808,
-0.527692318,
0.1785713881,
-0.4803358316,
0.6124975085,
0.2462302595,
0.9087867141,
0.5025543571,
-0.5809068084,
-0.2143582106,
0.1473122537,
-0.2258493006,
0.1704570651,
-0.6434264183,
0.3886245489,
-0.2604604363,
0.392873913,
-0.8679233193,
-0.1729044318,
0.6821172237,
-0.5590209961,
0.1871480495,
-0.3791345954,
-0.6351562142,
-0.4289995432,
-0.5639225245,
0.2442037016,
0.7454966307,
-0.1904243678,
0.4700186253,
0.3787331283,
-0.1865974963,
-0.5897800922,
-0.5843195319,
0.1833563894,
-0.0998932049,
-0.1707248688,
0.1946080029,
-0.2485806644,
-0.4248021543,
0.3737142384,
-0.1472290307,
-0.0076885154,
0.172051698,
0.2676785886,
0.1089202091,
0.1230320856,
-0.0401112176,
-0.218218565,
-0.3420644999,
-0.1679262966,
-0.7519562244,
0.4737993777,
-0.2251770049,
-0.1448995322,
0.0588414632,
0.1895146519,
0.1132574901,
-0.2784116864,
0.8561143279,
-0.0743597597,
-0.3986228108,
-0.3262994587,
-0.087293759,
0.3410130143,
-0.4675338566,
0.2860927582,
-0.5072286129,
-0.5748003721,
0.3663982451,
-0.1411104649,
0.0881820768,
0.1364187747,
0.6037378907,
0.2552908063,
0.9234104753,
0.4324336946,
0.1499529332,
0.6741086245,
-0.2387558371,
0.1398387104,
-0.2927273512,
-0.1449862272,
-0.6960624456,
-0.4074531794,
-0.6014662385,
-0.447811693,
0.3698594272,
0.0624623075,
0.0083287787,
0.38022843,
-0.1425070912,
0.7079288363,
0.5163682103,
-0.012975648,
0.2410987765,
-0.2852740884,
-0.1682139337,
0.1713249534,
-0.9494578242,
-0.6875475645,
0.9448524117,
0.0323409252,
0.4672695696,
-0.0169747565,
0.7916936278,
0.135404408,
0.623437345,
-0.8621876836,
0.6839473844,
0.1169609576,
-0.4758927226,
-0.4321319461,
-0.6459693313,
-1.0167859793,
0.5822911859,
-0.0419310592,
-0.8813552856,
-0.1607338637,
-0.1773266792,
-0.0957919508,
0.4895452559,
-0.9021268487,
1.0706928968,
-0.3263153136,
-0.3775251508,
-0.0573256537,
-0.4160414636,
0.1735225022,
-0.0002299719,
0.3453187346,
0.0086984653,
-0.2955428958,
0.7043359876,
-0.4548872411,
0.632542789,
-0.2558265328,
-0.1270760447,
0.521961689,
0.0500984751,
0.3011281192,
-0.06640663,
-0.3052625954,
-0.1122736707,
-0.4114842117,
-0.1948464811,
-0.6770008802,
0.8426324129,
-0.9076864123,
-0.3714696467,
-0.675678134,
-0.2420229018,
-0.2727399468,
0.4636256397,
0.0642561913,
0.22371158,
-0.4436213374,
-0.1773120612,
0.513160944,
-0.3918281794,
0.5166166425,
0.8821014166,
-0.2460311204,
-0.4730936289,
1.1272605658,
0.2711029947,
-0.0539953932,
0.8380947709,
0.3566685319,
-0.3696014881,
-0.7819290161,
-0.170572415,
0.0838810131,
-0.3448607326,
-0.0525160655,
-0.5553113818,
0.2356147021,
-0.3172422051,
-0.1577674896,
-0.328314662,
-0.0922203735,
0.0594746135,
0.0245299451,
-0.0952442884,
0.5001810789,
0.0287119243,
0.1968767196,
-0.3761574328,
0.4182958007,
0.2605459094,
0.6148563623,
-0.2444768399,
-0.1262653917,
-0.0807966515,
0.0832917839,
-0.1701019555,
-0.9407362938,
0.3603653014,
-0.030733915,
0.5647647381,
0.0471654683,
0.0990342498,
0.4191455543,
-0.7134192586,
0.628199935,
0.1918796897,
-0.6427426934,
0.6386938095,
-0.440487057,
0.3029583395,
0.7296468616,
0.4472719729,
-0.590010047,
-0.5457721353,
-0.7323492765,
-0.6761834621,
1.0750815868,
0.4879183471,
-0.1605493426,
0.0051695351,
0.2012687773,
0.2515283525,
0.2593531311,
-0.8223003149,
-0.3371635079,
-0.141107589,
0.0770072117,
-0.3449887931,
0.0987846702,
0.1278604269,
0.1855114847,
0.6834676862,
-0.2668527663,
0.3460120261,
0.2817243338,
-0.169243589,
-0.3079458475,
0.5101444125,
0.2495407462,
0.5679499507,
-0.1942285448,
-0.2199586332,
-0.1092414185,
-0.1507529318,
0.1591715813,
0.1560697556,
-0.44354105,
-0.1717912853,
0.0777266473,
0.6890209913,
0.3929715455,
-0.994582653,
0.3433437943,
-0.1841056645,
-0.4951079786,
-0.4054973125,
0.1387418807,
-0.3606244028,
0.1368345171,
0.1811747104,
0.067763187,
0.0193799883,
-0.8939649463,
0.0737171173,
0.3798528016,
-0.1174811497,
-0.3390644491,
0.7761413455,
0.1940235645,
-0.6837006211,
0.5564763546,
-0.405933857,
-0.4809365869,
0.6197519302,
0.4578165412,
1.0414253473,
0.0699780434,
0.6029820442,
-0.0610776469,
0.3333809972,
-0.1426036209,
0.0998770818,
0.1013040096,
-0.8201414347,
-0.557097733,
-0.2147210836,
-0.6939322948,
0.1932607144,
-0.1918412298,
0.1495181471,
-0.4612391293,
0.078701131,
-0.1568739861,
0.2526634932,
-0.5758559108,
-0.113991335,
0.3458473384,
0.9362357855,
-0.4593087137,
0.9595072269,
1.1479120255,
-0.5186870098,
-0.4041259289,
0.1998764724,
-0.104979299,
-0.6316949129,
0.2563152313,
0.2361260355,
-0.1452114433,
-0.2552408278,
-0.4917556345,
-0.063310422,
1.0781444311,
0.4029203355,
-0.1065069288,
-0.105139181,
0.1022906378,
0.6571130157,
0.0866843238,
0.6365965605,
0.4172036052,
0.5257094502,
-0.056945011,
-0.7427400947,
-0.1335522532,
-0.2894127965,
-0.1626430452,
0.422526598,
-0.743953526,
0.6632099748,
-0.2597721815,
-0.3435938954,
0.4580574036,
0.5520918965,
0.2354866862,
0.4952524304,
0.467285037,
0.5800158978,
0.5947560072,
0.0763740763,
1.574587822,
-0.1770458221,
0.3201717138,
1.0948959589,
-0.665471971,
0.6863970757,
0.2092890292,
-0.2779298425,
0.4039154053,
0.2559088469,
0.4425617456,
0.5063735843,
0.115412645,
-0.3180075288,
-0.187201634,
-0.0394774154,
-0.0886125788,
0.5339620709,
0.2072706819,
0.0603795983,
-0.148362413,
-0.1017996073,
0.0230706967,
0.2439182401,
-0.2854593396,
0.9122385979,
-0.1892668009,
-1.0066779852,
0.1431160122,
0.2482028306,
0.5491271615,
-1.2361363173,
-0.0970547274,
0.0053596548,
0.1771388054,
0.1722393036,
-0.8143109083,
-0.0721783563,
-0.0140813282,
0.3692445755,
-0.9364977479,
1.0979239941,
-0.4172569215,
0.0918714777,
0.0901566222,
0.7173571587,
0.0941191837,
-0.1490177661,
-0.8586323261,
-0.1977027655,
-0.3550197184,
-0.1591589153,
0.6149810553,
0.4801774621,
0.2110118121,
0.621016264,
0.5100797415,
0.0477633774,
-0.4126466811,
-0.0250337515,
0.7038660049,
-0.5579921603,
-0.6694251299,
-0.7697407007,
0.0655570328,
-0.1319590807,
-0.4303036332,
0.8575128913,
0.5987325311,
1.0942997932,
-0.1106414795,
0.9455670118,
-0.3779997528,
-0.1069802493,
-0.6513441205,
0.6098062396,
-0.4443498552,
-0.141814664,
-0.3572694957,
-0.4011589289,
-0.1246600673,
0.6055147648,
-0.4193709195,
0.0892665982,
0.781419158,
0.4935520887,
0.3525885344,
0.2054963857,
0.4105014801,
0.0912771001,
0.3543509245,
0.7061513662,
0.9840043783,
-0.2413510233,
0.7195946574,
-0.1161248907,
-0.4914250076,
0.079975538,
-0.7564248443,
-0.9707314372,
-0.3365596533,
-0.2548675537,
-0.1085794792,
0.3618538678,
0.9784324169,
0.233449176,
-0.5305790901,
-0.2988397479,
-0.3294701278,
0.5322819352,
-0.6002444029,
-0.2450997531,
-0.1867003143,
-0.4151598811,
-0.8469473124,
0.5228856206,
0.2320556045,
0.0425083004,
0.2259100676,
-0.4074828327,
-0.2548401952,
0.0348355062,
0.5703844428,
0.7395074964,
-0.361191988,
-0.2233829647,
-0.1106954366,
0.0431381129,
0.0361372344,
1.6189130545,
-1.0261942148,
0.4747924805,
0.4143872559,
0.6600939631,
0.1598304212,
-0.2794205844,
0.5811703801,
-0.6633134484,
0.2636211216,
0.2890537679,
0.3541693985,
-0.2199843079,
0.0619731583,
0.5602614284,
0.2481559962,
-0.3722278476,
-0.5053753257,
0.0565539412,
-0.6900596023,
-0.5161450505,
1.3391783237,
-0.1206881553,
-0.3986007571,
-0.0442681238,
-0.4188431203,
0.0591529831,
-0.5915708542,
0.5358060002,
0.7231282592,
-0.1686540395,
-0.0365755633,
-0.6726716757,
0.326977849,
0.4425947666,
-0.9877368808,
0.0600772277,
0.4143618047,
-0.0827478319,
0.0425020009,
1.3220163584,
0.0351049453,
0.1811627299,
0.1750493199,
-0.195942834,
-0.1526046395,
-0.550260067,
-0.278170079,
0.0473174751,
0.2052689642,
-0.1686267555
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06668v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06668v1
|
Evaluating Self-supervised Speech Models on a Taiwanese Hokkien Corpus
| 2023-12-06T01:32:20 | 2023-12-06T01:32:20 |
Yi-Hui Chou, Kalvin Chang, Meng-Ju Wu, Winston Ou, Alice Wen-Hsin Bi, Carol Yang, Bryan Y. Chen, Rong-Wei Pai, Po-Yen Yeh, Jo-Peng Chiang, Iu-Tshian Phoann, Winnie Chang, Chenxuan Cui, Noel Chen, Jiatong Shi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.SD, eess.AS
|
Taiwanese Hokkien is declining in use and status due to a language shift
towards Mandarin in Taiwan. This is partly why it is a low resource language in
NLP and speech research today. To ensure that the state of the art in speech
processing does not leave Taiwanese Hokkien behind, we contribute a 1.5-hour
dataset of Taiwanese Hokkien to ML-SUPERB's hidden set. Evaluating ML-SUPERB's
suite of self-supervised learning (SSL) speech representations on our dataset,
we find that model size does not consistently determine performance. In fact,
certain smaller models outperform larger ones. Furthermore, linguistic
alignment between pretraining data and the target language plays a crucial
role.
|
[
-0.1469302177,
-0.711568594,
0.238863349,
0.3642105758,
-0.4153161347,
0.2211438417,
-0.236976549,
-0.4070682228,
0.2986443937,
0.6695483923,
-0.3928122818,
-0.4568164945,
-0.4711062014,
0.1496170014,
-0.3030552864,
0.7207712531,
0.3413017988,
0.1176362485,
0.2249689996,
-0.2922896445,
-0.3236418962,
-0.7390131354,
-0.8635716438,
-0.2219663113,
0.2553639412,
0.2417905331,
0.6782705784,
0.5939226747,
0.4179695845,
0.2153802514,
-0.322589159,
0.1202658936,
-0.6316078305,
-0.0091201942,
-0.0170237701,
-0.0578481071,
-0.5205270052,
0.1093546301,
0.7492027283,
0.7396374941,
-0.0304531939,
0.3434897959,
0.3046766222,
0.4667502642,
-0.5515161157,
0.3118910491,
-0.5306583643,
0.2305356413,
-0.4581090808,
0.0736220181,
-0.5507586598,
-0.26553002,
0.3276550472,
-0.578112185,
0.2531501353,
-0.1943142712,
0.7249574065,
0.3594941497,
-0.4546510577,
0.0482951142,
-0.7105109692,
0.6628741026,
-0.8230701685,
0.4729841352,
0.4569610655,
0.1409107745,
-0.0021305149,
-0.6992247701,
-0.2737854421,
-0.5437771678,
-0.1133255437,
0.3059512675,
-0.1809547246,
0.0101824244,
0.225350678,
0.3507010341,
-0.6717821956,
0.2849639654,
-0.4605850279,
-0.3533057272,
0.7590248585,
0.0007909227,
0.2667980492,
-0.4993462265,
-0.1015166268,
-0.1014008671,
-0.5858232379,
-0.1349076182,
0.3250671029,
0.542627871,
-0.2268112153,
0.444609642,
-0.0984728187,
0.5473972559,
0.3546947241,
-0.0365838408,
0.2361534983,
-0.3669905365,
-0.2996324897,
0.5115070343,
1.0107836723,
0.1563082039,
0.1336607933,
0.0474800617,
-0.039302472,
-0.1559071988,
0.0588295832,
-0.6064047813,
-0.535361886,
-0.0107657248,
-0.4835766852,
-0.1852877289,
-0.1936239153,
-0.3719714582,
-0.2133679986,
-0.0538276136,
0.3435851336,
-0.3745165765,
-0.6112372279,
-0.1971173137,
-0.1642845869,
0.1622283757,
-0.0646801442,
-1.003064394,
0.1800658554,
0.4550812244,
1.035107851,
-0.3933041692,
-0.2786839902,
-0.3656412363,
0.0802602321,
-0.8967330456,
0.34221977,
-0.4875525534,
-0.8355194926,
-0.2790560126,
0.3653509915,
-0.2343910336,
-0.7695983648,
0.6681795716,
-0.2342442125,
0.2501185238,
-0.3436262012,
-0.5149339437,
0.0638784543,
-0.201343894,
-0.7324957848,
1.2174170017,
0.2977471054,
-0.7387083769,
0.3012835979,
-0.6590522528,
-0.6204462647,
0.2645423412,
-0.0886840671,
-0.6692451835,
0.2204431593,
0.2830612957,
0.5698738694,
0.2341422141,
0.4297996759,
-0.5201493502,
-0.4917770624,
-0.2378118038,
-0.6535966396,
1.3286290169,
0.3798384368,
-0.5089100003,
-0.0412577949,
-0.6533106565,
-0.051621668,
0.3194637597,
-0.2779757977,
-0.5565738678,
-0.1411663294,
0.2059030831,
0.2318325341,
0.3263430595,
-0.6355908513,
-0.0813821703,
-0.6605789661,
0.7763479948,
0.700076282,
-0.2171697766,
0.3706855774,
0.0968065485,
0.3938268125,
0.1613091528,
0.2474218309,
0.0701653734,
-0.542946279,
-0.7389558554,
0.1325117648,
0.5865556002,
0.3097897768,
-0.6877411604,
0.2702170908,
-0.3962424397,
-0.5398612022,
-0.8494551182,
-0.0212186575,
0.3944137096,
0.5343726873,
0.4413219392,
-0.2432244867,
-0.6240577102,
-1.2608110905,
-0.1455241293,
-0.3388434947,
0.176023677,
0.2022519559,
0.2617203593,
-0.0614726208,
0.7332502007,
0.1280902177,
-0.2598352432,
-0.4792607725,
-0.0508015938,
0.0760934278,
0.6363477111,
0.6674826145,
-0.678951025,
-0.8173084855,
0.0963349193,
-0.8665192127,
0.1265807003,
0.1214144453,
0.0302808322,
0.509657979,
0.4090620577,
-0.4587422609,
0.3790022433,
0.8033325076,
-0.0269633457,
0.6094502211,
-0.1425390244,
-0.006799655,
-0.9570252299,
-0.1820573062,
-0.1047846451,
-0.2612697184,
-0.6172828078,
-0.0747777596,
0.0981697813,
-0.3582445681,
-0.4891889691,
0.7169722319,
-0.4704481661,
-0.2413655519,
-0.2387593389,
0.1241147518,
-0.1128737628,
0.3629829884,
0.3995828032,
0.9550715089,
0.7705337405,
-0.6094202995,
0.0714343935,
0.0621412694,
-0.19558236,
0.3705066144,
-0.7081829309,
0.1689244807,
0.2512181401,
0.0725490451,
-0.6642974615,
-0.2753792703,
0.1902157664,
-0.3252721727,
0.4322219789,
-0.2516913414,
-0.2626368999,
-0.5520241261,
-0.1365685016,
0.1754484773,
0.3811032474,
-0.6337141991,
0.5414617062,
0.8648934364,
0.0036926784,
-0.4994156063,
-0.8381656408,
0.2586301565,
-0.3838332891,
-0.3936993778,
0.4106765687,
0.0341073833,
-0.0574571118,
0.1093015671,
-0.1322657913,
-0.1279729605,
0.1097307056,
0.1456141472,
0.1265279502,
-0.6673052311,
0.1473197639,
0.1996576935,
-0.0077515589,
0.2438185662,
-0.3357005715,
0.4124915004,
-0.3296371102,
-0.1109923124,
-0.644991219,
0.1241632402,
0.3869363666,
-0.1573733985,
0.6549364328,
0.802721858,
-0.3494945168,
0.0781708583,
-0.4214558005,
-0.1119862795,
-0.4879977703,
0.6158510447,
-0.5066832304,
-0.9559322596,
0.2519840598,
0.3406329751,
0.0633092746,
0.7636434436,
0.5298788548,
-0.2191314399,
1.2716509104,
0.5387476087,
-0.4228140712,
0.386094451,
-0.2002231926,
0.1724773198,
-0.7232708335,
0.18092601,
-0.1760915071,
0.1352907419,
-1.1048719883,
-0.0424046442,
0.3445505202,
-0.1170687154,
-0.2208640426,
0.5780534148,
-0.6907545328,
0.3835826516,
0.7202026248,
0.0992823467,
0.1470582336,
-0.0119364634,
-0.1370184571,
0.0313785784,
-1.0299546719,
-0.456610322,
1.008660078,
0.3119313717,
0.5105451941,
-0.1703831553,
0.7088663578,
0.4201080501,
-0.0025521973,
-0.4576684833,
0.6141376495,
-0.5910850763,
-0.7623051405,
-0.8216224909,
-0.4607979953,
-1.0894309282,
0.2564760149,
0.094070673,
-0.3791120648,
-0.0453426391,
0.3754115999,
-0.4572072923,
0.2205326855,
-0.8464798331,
1.1880971193,
-0.2524131835,
-0.1765022427,
-0.2396247983,
-0.4888352752,
0.4219839871,
0.0117164804,
0.0666569322,
-0.409696877,
0.5921593308,
0.9795149565,
-0.3289832473,
0.8333715796,
-0.3236165345,
-0.0324133784,
0.5667970181,
0.1603513956,
0.204579249,
0.0632145852,
-0.1227587089,
0.5431880951,
0.2723657787,
-0.5369670391,
-0.2794061005,
0.8135445714,
-0.7965068817,
-0.7910251617,
-0.2281927615,
-0.0095578805,
-0.2919116914,
0.2302582413,
0.5182582736,
0.372906357,
-0.3050098419,
0.2034427226,
0.5342870355,
-0.1262048483,
0.6421101093,
0.4288106859,
-0.3426494896,
-0.1830353737,
1.0609474182,
0.6043547392,
0.2124524117,
0.0011667383,
0.5233514905,
-0.5675409436,
-0.3142501414,
-0.6782339811,
0.3038002849,
-0.6799697876,
0.32716465,
-0.5298377872,
-0.6006096601,
-0.874578774,
0.3157570958,
-0.6488353014,
-0.6255507469,
-0.4538931251,
-0.261466831,
-0.0988505185,
0.7429808378,
-0.1432939917,
0.2288960516,
-0.6643772125,
0.0999738574,
0.4174816906,
0.1307791919,
-0.0649399236,
-0.936909914,
-0.4898542762,
0.0611171648,
-0.1844057292,
-0.7764207125,
0.460865438,
0.3569228947,
0.663633287,
0.1900402755,
0.0844495893,
0.7731077075,
-0.3684431016,
1.0259199142,
-0.0937080979,
-1.0774402618,
0.8260288835,
-0.3229070604,
0.4171019197,
0.1931176633,
0.392824024,
-0.5209028721,
-0.5671547651,
-0.8639290929,
-0.4840806127,
0.5462310314,
0.2671768367,
0.3387783766,
-0.0761842728,
0.3549373448,
-0.0271939524,
-0.0023426039,
-0.9298511744,
-0.5312479734,
-0.615221262,
0.0310924668,
-0.2184557915,
-0.2690595388,
0.2228389084,
-0.3039250672,
0.8050902486,
-0.250564307,
0.1563064754,
0.2201482952,
-0.0063346419,
-0.0633254871,
0.1495258212,
0.4060948789,
0.5043850541,
-0.1124563217,
0.2081115395,
0.5173757672,
-0.5132467151,
-0.0422398187,
-0.0760564655,
-0.2541322708,
0.2522069216,
0.4370384812,
0.8972531557,
0.249352634,
-0.4673607945,
0.3635744154,
-0.0127828196,
-0.0709961951,
-0.3737598956,
0.1614242047,
0.0720688403,
-0.0472551994,
0.0860037431,
-0.081573084,
0.2767964602,
-0.375633657,
0.0867791399,
0.3765394986,
-0.7405344248,
-0.5514960289,
0.9543513656,
-0.0661412328,
-0.102721788,
0.7307479978,
-0.3096289933,
-0.3987944722,
0.4516089261,
0.6539772153,
0.9253367782,
-0.5889768004,
0.4242449105,
0.5454533696,
0.3725516498,
-0.0228248406,
0.1445530802,
-0.0645833164,
-0.6404471397,
-0.4437875748,
-0.4267647266,
-0.2501582503,
0.3324317932,
-0.7733921409,
0.213368386,
-0.2879734635,
-0.4689355493,
0.0320850797,
-0.1693829596,
-0.4412280321,
0.2869276702,
0.3763781786,
0.504490912,
-0.6987352967,
1.1862968206,
0.4013485909,
-0.0816667899,
-0.7495372891,
-0.231898129,
-0.1782321185,
-0.7454572916,
0.7487350106,
0.1084957272,
-0.1241981238,
-0.0011726,
-0.4934691489,
-1.1038341522,
0.6296861768,
0.6734477878,
-0.5754396319,
-0.264811188,
0.2509761453,
0.763376534,
-0.1271502078,
0.0481692702,
0.7167473435,
0.2576553822,
-0.3351046443,
-1.3924999237,
-0.3880466521,
-0.0633201674,
0.0842782632,
-0.1638949662,
-0.9392232895,
0.7847704887,
-0.0070771864,
-0.4508650005,
-0.4731350243,
0.8046537638,
0.1349359602,
0.2682972252,
0.5145990849,
0.4402521253,
0.8401124477,
0.0249167792,
0.8005718589,
-0.3252785802,
0.5269893408,
1.277038455,
-0.2864021659,
0.9907534719,
0.0062621455,
-0.283533603,
0.2662595212,
1.065647006,
0.0578040294,
0.4993014038,
-0.2958440781,
0.0430870689,
-0.6561828852,
-0.1544622332,
-0.3460096121,
0.7268199921,
0.3560995162,
-0.2618279159,
-0.0704422221,
0.2020195872,
-0.2488471419,
-0.2482384145,
-0.4896782637,
0.5715299249,
0.2024455369,
-0.5065643787,
0.7988222837,
-0.2981444001,
0.3627695143,
-0.1560347527,
0.1359595507,
-0.1366879791,
-0.1584798247,
-0.0856105983,
-0.6884405613,
0.511875689,
-0.3620559871,
0.0958745256,
-0.1268014759,
0.719845295,
-0.3166437149,
-0.5305498838,
0.5064134002,
0.5217229128,
0.3972721696,
0.0373412296,
-1.0448231697,
-0.2055995911,
0.0984709263,
-0.2253001183,
0.2856672108,
0.3551833332,
-0.1928463876,
0.7325268984,
0.4420537949,
-0.0286276955,
0.3432319462,
0.2413892448,
0.634573698,
-0.553260386,
-0.6321623921,
-1.04599154,
0.0158855487,
-0.0339550748,
-0.4023072124,
1.1092293262,
0.8687700629,
0.9726797938,
-0.1112935469,
0.8579059839,
0.2627969682,
0.680727005,
-0.6129389405,
0.6872324347,
-0.5696417689,
0.0975870788,
-0.2760069668,
-0.6511775851,
0.0733842254,
0.6820554137,
-0.3007142842,
0.0128039271,
0.3355138898,
0.687056005,
-0.0307522118,
0.1758619398,
0.8590835929,
0.4077398181,
0.1050648838,
0.1405687034,
0.963493228,
-0.4161012769,
0.4173814654,
-0.6434454918,
0.1853306144,
-0.0805326775,
-0.6470684409,
-1.0255663395,
-0.8558849096,
-0.539355278,
-0.3213050365,
0.1637501866,
0.8411023021,
1.0751745701,
-1.0680080652,
-0.3395092785,
0.1174335852,
-0.0026318615,
-0.3161385953,
-0.2988378704,
0.7445915341,
-0.2727828324,
-0.8267325163,
0.8090246916,
0.5036461949,
0.2367835641,
-0.6237380505,
0.1311150342,
0.2121760547,
-0.1629785746,
0.6877734661,
0.2105040848,
-0.940682292,
-0.1726009995,
0.2482870072,
-0.2119660378,
0.3275353909,
0.566824615,
-0.6944227815,
0.3998920918,
0.0009317884,
0.4637721479,
0.6110001802,
-0.1151334867,
0.2759578228,
-0.7048513889,
-0.1190744936,
0.2909303904,
0.4588279724,
0.3280593157,
-0.42993325,
0.5493046045,
0.3439859152,
-0.7000918984,
-0.8024507761,
-0.1544566453,
-0.7857761383,
-0.1831062287,
1.0654565096,
-0.2653852999,
-0.3634646237,
-0.4095333219,
-0.0543775894,
0.2040172219,
-0.3044070303,
0.8076628447,
0.6653456688,
-0.3182473779,
-0.2658396661,
-0.5883843899,
0.652019918,
0.4003074467,
-0.3677346408,
0.2630956173,
0.2217845172,
0.3234833181,
0.3332011402,
0.7954390049,
0.1365327537,
0.284722209,
0.0675778463,
-0.2621079683,
0.2604348361,
-0.2910051644,
-0.4294896126,
0.154205963,
0.0502760373,
-0.1340456903
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03217v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03217v1
|
Rethinking E-Commerce Search
| 2023-12-06T01:15:40 | 2023-12-06T01:15:40 |
Haixun Wang, Taesik Na
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
E-commerce search and recommendation usually operate on structured data such
as product catalogs and taxonomies. However, creating better search and
recommendation systems often requires a large variety of unstructured data
including customer reviews and articles on the web. Traditionally, the solution
has always been converting unstructured data into structured data through
information extraction, and conducting search over the structured data.
However, this is a costly approach that often has low quality. In this paper,
we envision a solution that does entirely the opposite. Instead of converting
unstructured data (web pages, customer reviews, etc) to structured data, we
instead convert structured data (product inventory, catalogs, taxonomies, etc)
into textual data, which can be easily integrated into the text corpus that
trains LLMs. Then, search and recommendation can be performed through a Q/A
mechanism through an LLM instead of using traditional information retrieval
methods over structured data.
|
[
-0.2511293292,
-0.7379191518,
0.811314404,
0.0718446746,
-0.4830305278,
0.2354953736,
-0.1607972533,
-0.7775755525,
0.7257916331,
0.6104774475,
-0.7915962338,
-0.6656830907,
0.1485682428,
0.0910783485,
-0.5328965783,
1.0950561762,
0.0108884191,
-0.1150908768,
-0.2793107629,
0.0990889668,
-0.0363835618,
-0.6970873475,
-0.6873750091,
-0.2107993513,
0.5800223947,
0.4226415157,
0.617610693,
0.340929836,
0.4237596393,
0.2660144567,
0.1737232655,
0.623767972,
-0.7255219817,
0.4056230187,
-0.1728580445,
-0.5182378292,
-0.4815585017,
0.2091255784,
-0.0058787432,
0.6734740138,
-0.632016778,
0.1591328382,
0.1769339442,
0.9107786417,
-0.4799214005,
0.0406293496,
-0.6615780592,
0.1085044146,
-0.00820297,
-0.552202642,
-0.4735322893,
-0.2713423967,
0.171471715,
-1.3171864748,
0.1829236597,
0.6900271177,
0.826657474,
-0.0365065672,
-0.4288045466,
-0.4803205431,
-1.0780547857,
0.8009123802,
-0.3606514335,
0.5552403927,
0.3491624296,
0.2458168268,
-0.3622428775,
-0.8828827143,
-0.2703364789,
0.11760851,
-0.247626543,
0.3559987545,
-0.2138743252,
-0.1227477118,
-0.1237255335,
0.5133206248,
-0.5237725377,
-0.0927606672,
-0.4031927586,
0.2623805106,
1.0177185535,
0.1827410012,
0.1488225162,
0.0476067029,
-0.5042462945,
-0.0946129039,
-0.6575767398,
0.3073079586,
0.4778138399,
0.2523891032,
0.536754787,
0.6025378108,
-0.7390434742,
0.4995532036,
0.464340657,
-0.1445927471,
0.2726234496,
-0.3595699966,
-0.2138740867,
0.2966532409,
0.5257670879,
0.763917923,
0.1135764569,
-0.2794413865,
-0.649479568,
-0.390247643,
0.7485249043,
-0.7348573208,
-0.1826577634,
0.529106617,
-0.9087385535,
-0.3064169884,
0.2826806605,
-0.6966708899,
-0.0665111542,
-0.2995716333,
0.4593731165,
-0.0234418809,
0.2903091908,
0.2380871177,
-0.1565413326,
-0.104174301,
0.4161446393,
-0.779964447,
0.7236261964,
0.5379182696,
0.6430519223,
-0.1427513063,
0.1141807139,
-0.1729806513,
0.3130638003,
-0.1355086863,
1.2179726362,
-0.6903346181,
-0.5295124054,
0.1676822901,
0.1937538832,
0.2986987233,
-0.6220595241,
0.5405797958,
-1.0248004198,
0.238642782,
-0.0551569425,
-0.7069883347,
-0.315228045,
0.6804603934,
-0.8690656424,
1.1599581242,
-0.0611985251,
-0.455863595,
0.5168315768,
-0.4457900524,
-0.3720602691,
0.2775321007,
-0.0229196902,
-0.5826499462,
0.1132553518,
0.6213458776,
0.2475440204,
-0.4388831854,
-0.0497532226,
-0.5074339509,
-0.8372417092,
0.1428314447,
0.187511459,
0.282997787,
0.364710778,
0.0356924012,
-0.316914469,
-0.6626309156,
0.3318353295,
0.2019200027,
-0.7194207907,
-0.5023047924,
0.4666548967,
0.2539628446,
-0.0479884595,
0.4262031317,
-0.6618911624,
0.5983919501,
-0.7079668641,
0.4409762919,
0.5163009763,
0.2581818104,
0.6052516103,
-0.7073372006,
0.5816757679,
-0.0270738788,
0.503911972,
0.0743658096,
-0.4796321094,
-0.7859871984,
0.1417384148,
0.1161866114,
0.3294409811,
-0.5835030079,
0.3378453553,
-0.2653408945,
-0.5132318139,
-0.5700084567,
0.1836944222,
-0.2438230813,
0.1694687158,
0.58040452,
-0.4334669709,
-0.579413414,
-0.7973317504,
-0.4050309062,
-0.3571580946,
-0.3236033022,
0.5936393738,
-0.0873713121,
-0.4845476449,
0.8610379696,
-0.777336061,
-0.6569033861,
-0.1912656575,
-0.1031217128,
0.5377085209,
0.2226882279,
0.0926030427,
-0.9162401557,
-0.338452369,
0.1032762155,
-0.2188505679,
-0.148147732,
-0.0841214731,
-0.0552741773,
0.010818908,
0.4818460345,
-0.4043176472,
0.5759398341,
0.1177794412,
0.0762724504,
0.2770545185,
-0.1854120791,
0.3673735857,
-0.9947282672,
-0.0030494491,
0.1140604094,
-0.1517404467,
-0.3931551576,
-0.1609397531,
-0.0255587827,
-0.1539888978,
-0.4097840488,
0.263738364,
-0.278562665,
-0.1146140546,
-0.1216387525,
0.1884927005,
0.5499005914,
0.5110722184,
-0.0590559244,
0.6963846087,
-0.1683459282,
-0.8244923949,
0.4317650795,
0.5761078,
-0.2728659213,
0.7090544701,
-0.6703307033,
0.0915636644,
-0.2058821023,
0.422663331,
-0.699693203,
0.1412360072,
0.0847234502,
-0.2711555064,
-0.0208650883,
-0.3290843964,
-0.6912360787,
-0.2511499226,
-0.6855692863,
0.4768587947,
0.4209771156,
-0.7378301024,
0.4000251889,
0.2804602385,
-0.1252850145,
-0.1398844272,
-0.4804921448,
0.208567366,
-0.200654611,
-0.7350250483,
0.9290826917,
-0.2195348442,
-0.1046211421,
0.1509284228,
0.070926778,
-0.1554631442,
0.193669796,
-0.0325831547,
0.3110371232,
-0.1603467762,
0.5053498745,
-0.0574469157,
0.0009051088,
-0.0763747543,
-0.7316795588,
0.4269677103,
0.2045220435,
-0.3640602529,
-0.3696021438,
0.5241358876,
0.3006962836,
-0.0812687352,
0.2990611494,
0.1612112224,
-0.3423074782,
-0.5264363289,
-0.5444101691,
-0.3241820931,
-0.5336887836,
0.0163026545,
-0.2636067867,
-0.733384192,
0.0681113303,
-0.3027530611,
0.0321428441,
0.3747369945,
0.4844343066,
-0.7415846586,
1.273665905,
0.7631958723,
0.290617913,
0.4312439263,
0.0311877746,
0.9085989594,
-0.7506042123,
-0.7086120248,
-0.5316900611,
-0.7757602334,
-0.8483632207,
0.0816674754,
0.4416951835,
0.0990741849,
-0.1693349481,
0.2287980318,
-0.6274194717,
0.2789420784,
0.654510498,
0.6036188602,
0.5402528644,
0.3783723116,
-0.0180195812,
-0.0167820342,
-0.4906914532,
-0.559984982,
1.2784751654,
0.0006775251,
0.9725878835,
0.1349963695,
0.6286641955,
0.2670148909,
0.0703793392,
-1.1198253632,
0.2459193915,
-0.3882066011,
-0.5130772591,
-0.0079362728,
-0.2235410511,
-1.0861246586,
-0.0338501036,
-0.3015032709,
-0.4050406814,
0.4222078323,
-0.1089573875,
-0.3333378434,
0.3324644864,
-0.4335966706,
0.2523371279,
-0.4345861375,
-0.3817151189,
-0.0839560777,
-0.0195428319,
0.0399979502,
-0.1750971675,
0.3065537214,
0.2663065791,
-0.1647422612,
0.91945678,
-0.5863835812,
0.4215568602,
0.3788696826,
0.1030594781,
0.1409790367,
0.210034132,
0.7070353627,
0.2026723772,
0.0453263968,
-0.2788275182,
0.08477927,
-0.3623076379,
-0.8242974281,
0.4517906308,
-0.6741510034,
-0.6650853753,
-0.28020823,
-0.1936009675,
-0.4384707212,
-0.0252424981,
-0.0475671105,
0.023256002,
-0.1748702675,
0.3864204884,
0.6695156097,
-0.0389814191,
0.1663048118,
0.5909381509,
-0.3200544119,
-0.4484859407,
0.7229381204,
0.0199679844,
-0.159610495,
0.5498092175,
0.1326119453,
-0.5794487,
-0.4978889227,
-0.2522708476,
0.1421924531,
-0.6020713449,
-0.174481988,
-0.6386386752,
-0.039510563,
-0.2651830018,
-0.1955019683,
-0.2143545449,
-0.2375504524,
-0.7043661475,
-0.2026241422,
0.3219294846,
1.0240364075,
0.3320448101,
0.3089328408,
-0.9625813365,
0.0989322215,
0.4225167632,
0.5121555924,
-0.0474265739,
-0.2164145857,
-0.5123030543,
0.1259068847,
-0.3728258014,
-0.5661764741,
0.56579566,
0.1803064942,
0.4455263913,
0.5513896346,
0.068620339,
0.9089372158,
-0.506827414,
0.7313278317,
0.0883327946,
-0.5491562486,
0.5301490426,
-0.3071406484,
-0.3676959872,
0.6328926682,
0.595777452,
-0.6912127137,
0.1154796854,
-0.5129997134,
-0.9671960473,
0.5208361745,
0.075806126,
0.0243952572,
0.20409742,
0.5092451572,
0.2294397801,
0.5493520498,
-0.4262295067,
-0.0361751094,
-0.0776775554,
-0.0815596879,
-0.184355408,
-0.4871893525,
0.0088767754,
-0.1490611881,
0.6855313182,
0.1147795469,
0.0293039326,
0.466476351,
-0.1237563863,
-0.1509936601,
0.3439148664,
-0.1810104102,
0.5056661963,
-0.3247105479,
-0.0172588192,
-0.301163435,
-0.3389541507,
0.1210083663,
-0.2977071702,
-0.4194254577,
-0.0654719025,
-0.1320878267,
0.1108276173,
0.3682832122,
-0.7639685869,
0.4112988114,
-0.1714828461,
-0.2421445251,
-0.3008165658,
-0.1735246778,
0.0097095408,
0.1919844896,
0.5016397834,
-0.3326920271,
0.6933382154,
-0.8196595311,
0.5413325429,
0.1824461818,
-0.3640057445,
-0.1549277306,
0.3294598758,
0.3599180281,
-0.446859628,
0.7762812972,
0.0380962715,
-0.4442201555,
0.1720246524,
0.4643023014,
0.7659243345,
0.1824380755,
0.3447345793,
0.1351792365,
0.4205592275,
-0.2972212434,
0.2179110795,
-0.0337781794,
-0.5382431746,
-0.1730024666,
-0.7616944909,
-0.6219003201,
-0.0375559218,
-0.6785484552,
0.5711374283,
-0.6006435752,
-0.0194051117,
-0.2490539104,
0.3876886666,
-0.6830996275,
0.489618361,
-0.1060450971,
0.5850235224,
-0.3741734922,
0.500626862,
0.5213757753,
-0.6388041973,
-0.5182693005,
-0.1834953725,
-0.3057282269,
-0.81055969,
0.4774934649,
0.0857448503,
-0.1320875883,
-0.2173042446,
-0.5050874352,
-0.6691356301,
1.2977814674,
-0.0864768326,
-0.899343729,
0.0672745481,
0.0230887569,
0.5653187633,
-0.5097252131,
0.2282536179,
0.4497762024,
0.3229416013,
-0.0110771498,
-0.7469184399,
-0.0883732513,
-0.451916337,
0.0130526107,
0.0932812542,
-0.5301889181,
1.0758574009,
0.2852990627,
-0.4688904583,
-0.1183532253,
0.0601970255,
0.1164685264,
0.5294625163,
0.4380459189,
0.7704102993,
0.8078801632,
0.2519516945,
0.9356370568,
-0.0804073587,
0.450630486,
0.8540077209,
-0.6515735984,
1.2629714012,
0.6383168101,
-0.3298602402,
0.7120435834,
1.0733544827,
-0.1357785463,
0.3838733435,
0.208079502,
0.0135141117,
-0.5861079693,
-0.1253779531,
-0.0657552257,
0.3612757623,
0.2188133746,
-0.1917464286,
-0.3500699103,
-0.5441800952,
-0.2862868905,
0.2833903432,
-0.3046118617,
1.0036189556,
-0.0416097157,
-0.2878895402,
0.3944117129,
0.2563187778,
0.6874790788,
-0.3186970651,
-0.215392217,
-0.2179136425,
-0.1750239432,
-0.5166216493,
-0.5509235263,
0.2117010951,
-0.2501812577,
-0.296667099,
-0.4339748025,
0.7613354921,
-0.203296572,
-0.7097944021,
0.3445117176,
0.8260916471,
0.1262587607,
-0.3109738827,
-0.6236093044,
-0.3358312249,
-0.0360616334,
-0.4168365598,
0.3405268788,
0.2737562656,
0.0425783992,
0.6144465804,
1.2227396965,
-0.0818500817,
-0.1920672059,
-0.1701686084,
0.9155040979,
-0.9322696328,
-0.8997966647,
-0.4488542676,
0.0592919886,
-0.2218016386,
0.0052465913,
0.5797311664,
0.7301272154,
1.1452102661,
0.366130054,
0.8053712845,
0.5316305757,
0.5162193775,
-0.6530604362,
0.771889925,
-0.9583628774,
0.6915992498,
0.1603534967,
-1.1259143353,
-0.213606447,
0.3647917807,
-0.0253783278,
0.01678239,
0.9267712831,
0.7330241203,
-0.1995254904,
0.1752050072,
0.3217110932,
0.2404261827,
0.3515399098,
0.5300372243,
0.8557257652,
-0.5266367197,
0.7739875913,
-0.0676997751,
0.0344986692,
-0.6655096412,
-0.5231450796,
-0.6170426607,
-0.4222078621,
-0.0826150626,
-0.2998228073,
0.0811087936,
0.9352315068,
0.5021178126,
-0.5963705778,
-0.3935675621,
0.1404839754,
0.0916024968,
-0.2992480397,
-0.1266805977,
0.1982916892,
-0.3832787275,
-0.6468417048,
0.6144837737,
0.5969150662,
-0.0141446879,
-0.1964808255,
0.1730886996,
-0.0973068699,
0.2767446637,
0.5807129145,
-0.2296693921,
-0.5304883718,
-0.1032692343,
0.3835027516,
0.0791124478,
0.3781096041,
1.0071121454,
-1.0335501432,
0.4171381295,
0.3342196941,
0.6277403235,
0.6093422174,
0.166488573,
0.5821858048,
-0.3709446788,
-0.2192092389,
0.2832057774,
0.2547393143,
0.0282229725,
-0.5470607877,
0.3792534471,
0.0814018995,
-0.3621829748,
-0.5628663301,
0.2401934713,
-1.1783955097,
-0.4059699774,
1.0324441195,
-0.0221888386,
-0.5063747764,
-0.4583494365,
-0.2478684336,
-0.2663604617,
-0.7060916424,
1.0969524384,
0.5661472082,
-0.085362643,
0.2824890316,
-0.2530908883,
0.1612666845,
0.2541011572,
-0.6688486934,
-0.3605087399,
0.2987659872,
0.1917537749,
-0.1245574653,
0.3838092387,
0.030199714,
0.2551209331,
-0.4301723242,
-0.049345389,
-0.0728321001,
-0.3562366068,
-0.1843775809,
0.375451982,
0.0731932893,
-0.0854018629
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03195v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03195v1
|
Detecting Rumor Veracity with Only Textual Information by Double-Channel Structure
| 2023-12-06T00:08:44 | 2023-12-06T00:08:44 |
Alex Kim, Sangwon Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Kyle (1985) proposes two types of rumors: informed rumors which are based on
some private information and uninformed rumors which are not based on any
information (i.e. bluffing). Also, prior studies find that when people have
credible source of information, they are likely to use a more confident textual
tone in their spreading of rumors. Motivated by these theoretical findings, we
propose a double-channel structure to determine the ex-ante veracity of rumors
on social media. Our ultimate goal is to classify each rumor into true, false,
or unverifiable category. We first assign each text into either certain
(informed rumor) or uncertain (uninformed rumor) category. Then, we apply lie
detection algorithm to informed rumors and thread-reply agreement detection
algorithm to uninformed rumors. Using the dataset of SemEval 2019 Task 7, which
requires ex-ante threefold classification (true, false, or unverifiable) of
social media rumors, our model yields a macro-F1 score of 0.4027, outperforming
all the baseline models and the second-place winner (Gorrell et al., 2019).
Furthermore, we empirically validate that the double-channel structure
outperforms single-channel structures which use either lie detection or
agreement detection algorithm to all posts.
|
[
-0.2358467877,
-1.0919519663,
0.6620883942,
0.3264978528,
-0.4578624964,
0.3298636377,
-0.2361099869,
-0.6797345281,
0.8177729249,
0.3570138812,
-0.3349217474,
-0.4865907729,
-0.6935535073,
-0.4459720552,
-0.6302779317,
0.9695628285,
0.011202069,
0.1315674931,
0.0417786129,
-0.1946477294,
-0.1984071434,
-0.3414717615,
-0.5092849731,
0.1509331912,
0.4419845343,
0.4666825533,
0.7076333165,
0.3439899087,
0.1749305129,
0.1842858493,
-0.2015352398,
0.4151383936,
-0.3072746396,
0.2483354062,
-0.0924162492,
-0.4180402756,
-0.1897371411,
0.2022360563,
0.3975332379,
0.2067675143,
-0.0506536514,
0.3868613839,
-0.0780765638,
0.4660498202,
-0.491982609,
0.2186637372,
-0.6176627874,
-0.2503310442,
-0.200384751,
-0.402685076,
-0.3960192204,
-0.3281314969,
0.0774816424,
-0.2987894118,
0.1237778068,
0.1072632074,
0.8792352676,
-0.004966171,
-0.7308323383,
-0.6801002026,
-0.9555179477,
0.3474740088,
-0.2905671,
0.4045821428,
0.3708825409,
0.4689173698,
0.0574453212,
-0.4115040898,
-0.4245791137,
-0.1444392353,
-0.0432307012,
0.180847019,
-0.4091099203,
-0.1290184259,
-0.0165904742,
0.1303171515,
-0.4688192308,
-0.2699808776,
-0.4294063151,
-0.3565271497,
0.5931451917,
-0.6326960921,
0.277764082,
-0.2400130928,
-0.5381281376,
0.1612590402,
-0.2889874279,
0.0312843584,
0.5917329788,
-0.0250655338,
-0.1560421139,
0.6197152138,
-0.2407342941,
-0.1122268662,
0.0873245448,
-0.1874593347,
0.3130459487,
-0.474059701,
0.0223375149,
0.3349589109,
0.7428497672,
0.4792081714,
0.1818816513,
-0.1754818559,
-0.1141290665,
0.4285434484,
0.1222561821,
-0.523722291,
-0.0279653668,
0.0781492442,
-0.5276506543,
-0.6867426634,
0.3690460026,
-0.8818957806,
-0.4894306064,
0.0526996143,
0.6059804559,
-0.4372451305,
-0.5619566441,
-0.2325097024,
-0.450833112,
-0.003248184,
0.4007663429,
-0.0964965299,
0.1236392856,
0.5388363004,
0.8115585446,
0.5088254213,
-0.062013261,
-0.386403352,
0.2015184909,
-0.5682380199,
1.2700133324,
-0.3449292481,
0.0703557581,
-0.0929676667,
-0.0640623644,
0.2600800991,
0.0357210375,
1.0181663036,
-0.8386961222,
0.0473216586,
-0.449698478,
-0.6216427684,
-0.3143008947,
-0.0245720837,
-0.727872014,
0.9508915544,
0.0228981134,
-0.7659772635,
0.377958864,
-0.0816149265,
-0.4263212681,
-0.1307044476,
-0.1563380361,
-0.3654628098,
0.2477339357,
0.1320271045,
0.0393124893,
-0.2728665769,
0.3930090964,
-0.473353833,
-0.2593393326,
0.5173784494,
-0.7208696604,
0.63828969,
0.1758206189,
-0.5871315598,
-0.1075109541,
-0.4450410604,
0.1025180593,
-0.2573802173,
-0.0806099996,
-0.3162317574,
-0.0161326695,
-0.3243982792,
0.4676692188,
-0.1183562353,
-0.7604730725,
-0.0901668742,
-0.10652937,
0.1447477639,
0.5775215626,
0.2684568465,
0.4911171496,
-0.4348023236,
0.2899422348,
0.083901234,
0.1908958852,
0.0769131333,
-0.5626639724,
-0.838988781,
-0.1991774291,
0.2074690759,
0.3746903539,
-0.8850902915,
0.2855110466,
-0.0875446424,
-0.6311715841,
-0.5680231452,
0.0011298503,
0.4361920059,
0.4583815634,
0.2536463141,
0.5094504952,
-0.7143685222,
-0.9043868184,
-0.6264538765,
-0.5924267769,
0.3182219267,
-0.0048661288,
0.3497662842,
0.0512747839,
0.7789214253,
-0.2667624354,
-0.131921187,
0.0697123557,
0.593310833,
0.1116562188,
-0.0523102917,
0.6915481091,
-1.0401856899,
-0.7188230753,
-0.317286551,
-0.7287251949,
-0.1097608432,
0.0607619919,
-0.1218942553,
0.7447239757,
0.4764691293,
-0.7387049794,
0.7529230714,
0.5169820189,
-0.5754520893,
0.4195544422,
0.1176648811,
0.4731003046,
-0.711553216,
-0.4837647676,
0.1730038375,
-0.4667432308,
-0.6599130034,
-0.3562143743,
0.2023263425,
0.4316629171,
0.0331753567,
0.2207309008,
-0.4803647697,
0.0316447057,
-0.4672245383,
-0.0008677738,
0.010800303,
0.4479940534,
0.161285162,
0.2365090996,
0.650426805,
-0.3878727555,
0.2979320586,
-0.3168002665,
-0.4432195723,
0.6122547388,
-0.5245215893,
0.1397441626,
-0.3854066133,
0.6263895631,
-1.3324403763,
-0.2563524544,
0.3587417305,
-1.0479466915,
0.0290233307,
-0.1948723346,
-0.5113962889,
-0.5556535125,
-0.6935454011,
-0.1368031204,
0.4932813942,
-0.4930402935,
0.469540596,
0.5683739185,
-0.0429952964,
-0.4705382586,
-0.7456502318,
-0.1141626984,
0.0873593166,
-0.9979391694,
0.3507876992,
-0.0851234645,
-0.3739746809,
0.419588685,
-0.5564914346,
-0.4249101579,
-0.4665755033,
0.3915422857,
0.3507876098,
-0.3400211036,
0.3482175469,
0.2087470442,
0.0367070138,
0.1648410112,
-0.3534689248,
0.2462381721,
-0.2135705501,
-0.0840891823,
-0.4551738203,
0.3696056604,
0.7618868351,
0.0603410602,
1.2856069803,
0.7036110759,
-0.5895268321,
-0.4831846952,
-1.0075640678,
-0.1296254545,
-0.3829201162,
0.0637789741,
-0.1757295877,
-0.6456797123,
0.2627936304,
0.3352292776,
-0.1610432565,
0.470264554,
0.2591811419,
-0.1943444759,
1.0421154499,
0.4715365767,
0.1516216099,
-0.0572046414,
0.0349741541,
0.3381637037,
-0.0856616423,
-0.3260498047,
-0.3928837776,
-0.2008407116,
-0.4742160439,
-0.6968559027,
0.3037345707,
0.3886302412,
0.0822021738,
0.2285565585,
-0.2138025314,
0.3834396005,
0.6096709371,
0.2848097384,
0.4966531694,
0.1298149675,
0.1516346186,
0.3145493269,
-0.4095697999,
-0.3726547956,
0.8220775127,
0.6033405066,
0.4906801283,
0.4205423594,
0.2249603868,
0.5417984128,
0.3695834875,
-0.794847846,
0.3705390096,
0.1539003849,
-0.8488017321,
-0.3842196465,
-0.6660453081,
-0.1066747755,
0.0429415666,
-0.3265329301,
-0.4871549606,
0.2678493261,
0.0873347521,
-0.3272713721,
0.4380695224,
-0.6219783425,
0.2509633899,
-0.2225838155,
0.0202967152,
-0.2815107703,
-0.7454453707,
0.4845168889,
-0.4500000775,
0.7455115318,
-0.339331001,
-0.1005361453,
0.7659525871,
-0.5438973308,
0.6108718514,
-0.1919963211,
0.2188053578,
0.8125218749,
-0.0531825423,
0.6847690344,
0.4603334665,
-0.0455743074,
0.1131042838,
0.0822012797,
-0.1969560385,
-0.4531780481,
0.5567460656,
-0.9169364572,
-0.1155931428,
-0.5074151754,
-0.2998024523,
-0.2672177851,
0.0480019338,
0.744318068,
0.3221882582,
-0.2046281397,
0.3025066257,
0.618245542,
0.0475116968,
0.2848390937,
0.9630150199,
-0.1299675554,
-0.3831127882,
0.5492734909,
0.3922432959,
0.0845765695,
0.3810543716,
0.2116164416,
-0.3974372149,
-0.3287396729,
-0.1067324057,
0.3924232721,
-0.5839877725,
-0.3086773455,
-0.7531556487,
-0.6861931086,
-0.6931896806,
-0.047141131,
-0.6930551529,
-0.4435850382,
0.0338752978,
-0.3954954147,
0.3802828491,
0.8314268589,
-0.218634814,
0.2921053171,
-0.672762692,
0.4992955029,
0.3858380616,
0.2568649352,
-0.4803315401,
-0.7480978966,
-0.0570663698,
0.5483352542,
0.1687164605,
-1.3318134546,
0.1989150345,
-0.1013890579,
0.4050468504,
0.4496839643,
0.2739093602,
0.3719145954,
-0.1063327715,
0.2940256596,
0.228098169,
-0.8694804311,
0.3922637403,
-0.4493196607,
-0.3636349142,
0.5104897022,
0.3486356735,
-0.4629261494,
-0.492138207,
-0.8188613653,
-0.3692085743,
0.7619076967,
0.379696697,
-0.098587513,
-0.0206701923,
0.1517683268,
-0.0636250824,
0.4618000686,
-0.8289157748,
-0.6001260281,
-0.1435936838,
-0.0594117567,
0.3095855713,
-1.0266151428,
-0.0425548479,
-0.1258990765,
0.8923392892,
0.1867301911,
0.3459364474,
0.1265917271,
-0.1449078768,
-0.483590275,
0.3004406393,
0.3402394354,
0.6577159762,
-0.5434989333,
0.5039933324,
-0.2903558314,
-0.3987925649,
0.2367182076,
0.0720802993,
-0.3356875777,
0.5265315771,
0.3441450596,
0.6876602173,
0.1560216695,
-0.1813931614,
0.9908539653,
-0.1844473779,
-0.4479351044,
-0.704869628,
-0.2385286093,
0.2343551368,
0.345220685,
0.4105883241,
0.5412288904,
-0.0459009372,
-0.8346297145,
0.255351454,
0.4113236964,
-0.6307765841,
-0.4702742696,
0.4588641524,
0.3687978387,
-0.0771421418,
0.3436515033,
-0.5999753475,
-0.4328312576,
0.6222622395,
0.3575444818,
0.7571493387,
-0.5188538432,
0.8736786246,
0.2444786876,
0.6283339858,
-0.4687274098,
0.2174866349,
0.323409915,
-0.9623478055,
-0.1887168139,
-0.5814054608,
0.1122476235,
0.2011912018,
-0.5385811329,
0.6742619276,
-0.1903107613,
-0.0838304162,
0.313867718,
-0.145205155,
-0.2092823535,
-0.0125037478,
0.3916837275,
1.097314477,
-0.8860135078,
0.9466093183,
0.5426547527,
-0.238866508,
-1.0733916759,
0.1372841001,
0.5563319325,
-0.5963007212,
0.2859080732,
0.2246840745,
-0.3314542174,
-0.3133144379,
-0.5475615859,
-1.1156388521,
1.1200391054,
0.3331630528,
-0.4341215193,
-0.1675794423,
-0.1388913244,
0.384673208,
-0.2805508077,
0.3994173408,
0.3310612142,
0.4093452096,
0.6778107882,
-0.8525846004,
-0.1875596493,
-0.2313346714,
-0.3301728368,
0.3383041024,
-0.8233126998,
0.8352883458,
-0.0203403831,
-0.4288394451,
-0.1139090955,
0.8154354095,
0.0682019517,
0.690097034,
0.7432142496,
0.3011262417,
1.0414311886,
0.0854173899,
0.723102212,
-0.4413215816,
0.43792063,
1.0614694357,
-0.0181771237,
0.4854798019,
0.0793242976,
0.0995935351,
0.7793294787,
0.4025044441,
0.2902376652,
0.507581532,
-0.2602001429,
-0.2068835199,
-0.2135982513,
-0.2614722848,
-0.3546350598,
0.5590133667,
0.4839927256,
-0.5319961905,
-0.2422697991,
-0.0909128487,
0.5087804198,
-0.1182902381,
-0.5334258676,
0.2227868438,
0.0417836569,
-0.8241836429,
-0.0396383442,
0.1788912714,
0.612495482,
-0.6548330188,
0.0375899486,
-0.0225608144,
0.08437296,
-0.2145336419,
-0.717990458,
0.3729518056,
0.0448231697,
-0.2620715499,
-0.1558685303,
1.3017716408,
-0.6326351166,
-0.514549911,
0.5292558074,
0.7223488688,
-0.0065967082,
-0.6027237773,
-0.4261298776,
0.031434197,
0.1399827749,
-0.4043653905,
-0.1069872454,
0.5573794842,
0.0030552736,
0.331315428,
0.5002555251,
0.0657615364,
0.0419284999,
-0.0562103614,
0.8526470065,
-0.52484864,
-0.7168986797,
-0.9457606673,
0.242255345,
-0.4554159343,
0.0227722488,
1.066198349,
0.4658610821,
0.3453810811,
0.378454417,
0.8660851717,
-0.0090588788,
0.8870982528,
-0.3956271708,
0.5437003374,
-0.1943911016,
0.4826156199,
-0.3580207527,
-0.7041970491,
0.1090766042,
0.3261634111,
-0.1920959204,
0.0410402603,
1.125837326,
0.8538646102,
0.1328524649,
0.693166554,
-0.0311771017,
0.5350541472,
-0.0409301631,
0.2273903042,
1.112071991,
-0.156061545,
0.9826150537,
-0.5691693425,
-0.5650167465,
-0.3158675134,
-0.6061266661,
-1.0777426958,
-0.4241973758,
-0.3907152414,
-0.8491292,
0.0777472928,
0.5838527083,
0.8540248275,
-0.4188788831,
0.1500599235,
-0.2249720246,
0.2851560414,
-0.0488965847,
-0.2807484269,
0.3220206201,
0.1250900626,
-0.1989970058,
0.3632064462,
0.4882391989,
-0.0358778127,
-0.0208183546,
0.1492297947,
-0.2117137015,
0.5906659961,
0.4926968217,
0.0725697726,
-0.4038152397,
-0.5046684742,
0.2075472921,
-0.396938622,
-0.2956141829,
0.6486568451,
-0.6538667679,
0.1217459962,
0.5743945241,
0.0224794317,
0.4792934656,
0.2652184367,
0.3506143391,
-0.9546273947,
0.0627330169,
0.1248752177,
0.1826966554,
-0.0019074782,
-0.6810359955,
0.4613748491,
0.4900042117,
-0.5071409345,
-0.7250974178,
-0.0228068493,
-1.0616966486,
-0.6592684388,
1.5105395317,
0.2768470049,
-0.4094642401,
-0.2978125811,
0.0109227169,
0.2433577478,
-0.6254424453,
0.5772667527,
0.9082130194,
-0.1273780763,
0.0150298821,
-0.7262144685,
0.5416283607,
-0.0428924412,
-0.5662221909,
-0.2036355585,
0.483489126,
0.2727174759,
0.3505498469,
1.1136612892,
0.0561159663,
0.3489623964,
0.2371155173,
-0.3918455839,
-0.1478426754,
-0.6497122049,
0.113025628,
0.3035493791,
-0.2328551859,
-0.1510237604
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03194v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03194v1
|
Corporate Bankruptcy Prediction with Domain-Adapted BERT
| 2023-12-06T00:05:25 | 2023-12-06T00:05:25 |
Alex Kim, Sangwon Yoon
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, econ.GN, q-fin.EC
|
This study performs BERT-based analysis, which is a representative
contextualized language model, on corporate disclosure data to predict
impending bankruptcies. Prior literature on bankruptcy prediction mainly
focuses on developing more sophisticated prediction methodologies with
financial variables. However, in our study, we focus on improving the quality
of input dataset. Specifically, we employ BERT model to perform sentiment
analysis on MD&A disclosures. We show that BERT outperforms dictionary-based
predictions and Word2Vec-based predictions in terms of adjusted R-square in
logistic regression, k-nearest neighbor (kNN-5), and linear kernel support
vector machine (SVM). Further, instead of pre-training the BERT model from
scratch, we apply self-learning with confidence-based filtering to corporate
disclosure data (10-K). We achieve the accuracy rate of 91.56% and demonstrate
that the domain adaptation procedure brings a significant improvement in
prediction accuracy.
|
[
-0.2082551122,
-0.5324988961,
0.4529109895,
0.4465691447,
-0.454038918,
0.2153686136,
0.1001869813,
-0.8141480088,
0.2324985862,
0.7146971226,
-0.643678546,
-0.4252015054,
-0.7419275045,
-0.1932386607,
0.0387872979,
1.2442069054,
0.2273421288,
0.5528376698,
-0.047867965,
0.2641066909,
-0.7750682235,
-0.6278743148,
-0.618747592,
-0.0420757085,
0.2883715928,
0.2356712818,
0.4873863459,
0.2458145022,
0.4292530715,
0.1953319907,
-0.1009842157,
-0.3807733059,
-0.4266333878,
-0.0413452983,
-0.0225422941,
-0.2745442986,
-0.5311999321,
-0.0650450811,
0.0455637276,
0.5593363047,
-0.2955887318,
-0.2061171234,
0.2844610512,
1.0361691713,
-0.429492712,
0.3197617531,
-0.7826974988,
0.21953547,
0.3023880422,
0.025262082,
-0.5408496261,
-0.8200744987,
0.8238368034,
-0.4639154971,
0.37440449,
0.3015751839,
0.6719033122,
0.1114498377,
-0.06130955,
-0.7472137809,
-0.6322209835,
0.727373302,
-0.625875473,
0.3137461245,
0.4933074415,
0.3976203501,
0.0166245047,
-0.6826889515,
-0.2728421688,
-0.2441505194,
0.0777112842,
0.2331136763,
-0.1735745221,
0.1642994881,
-0.274248302,
0.2981647551,
-0.5042501688,
0.1521178484,
-0.8142514229,
-0.1808668524,
0.5356699228,
-0.1184792817,
-0.3298445642,
-0.302632004,
-0.7847467065,
-0.2900855839,
-0.3254832625,
0.2307388783,
0.2112061083,
0.3865423203,
0.1090387031,
0.1592851728,
0.3752964139,
0.3507006466,
0.2284873724,
-0.086884737,
0.1412765235,
0.1384541839,
-0.6286078095,
0.5864201784,
0.0345784277,
0.3879954219,
0.3515484631,
0.1008840948,
-0.3733339608,
-0.3799647689,
0.7616836429,
-0.5358698368,
-0.5920408368,
0.4610055685,
-0.9059891105,
-0.2864632308,
0.3716605306,
-1.0540169477,
-0.7480169535,
-0.411442101,
0.5205459595,
-0.7357544303,
0.1913181543,
0.1485973746,
-0.2500229776,
0.0220362321,
0.761238575,
-0.5673855543,
0.0777275786,
0.6536116004,
0.6124261022,
-0.1095397472,
0.1849611551,
-0.4462092817,
0.1915946603,
-0.4129074812,
0.751280129,
-0.315739572,
-0.7052143812,
0.1785910726,
-0.2703329027,
0.0111547299,
-0.7579477429,
0.8510217667,
-0.5251242518,
0.2536620796,
-0.2965059876,
-0.7095831037,
-0.533301115,
0.043871548,
-0.6258927584,
0.4899609983,
0.2126003355,
-0.7212748528,
0.7174278498,
-0.5984385014,
-0.4194776714,
-0.0701928958,
0.2432431579,
-0.5518032312,
0.3586736321,
0.4410717785,
0.7486035228,
0.118206799,
0.3928776979,
-0.4886548519,
-0.0899339616,
0.0877796933,
-0.0852387398,
0.5926941633,
0.4144515693,
-0.0831163228,
-0.1471975744,
-0.7367436886,
-0.1050533801,
-0.1933061928,
-0.2758369148,
-0.4984842539,
0.1642503589,
-0.2414365262,
0.171702534,
0.4477083683,
-0.4181584418,
0.0637798384,
-0.5620716214,
-0.3396571279,
1.1840388775,
0.1877586246,
0.2028453499,
-0.0731091872,
0.5792870522,
0.2132487595,
0.350661397,
0.0500913039,
-0.4637435377,
-0.5093291402,
-0.4424884617,
0.5804262161,
0.7932132483,
-0.4417124391,
0.8202012777,
-0.1831442267,
-0.4357263446,
-0.3545091748,
-0.2090148032,
0.1641876549,
0.5206056833,
0.3858183026,
-0.6901671886,
-0.8922758698,
-0.9594602585,
-0.1758969128,
-0.3757002056,
-0.0033246006,
0.4573729634,
0.1453484297,
-0.0754968449,
0.7747206092,
-0.7173807025,
-0.5450121164,
-0.3248553276,
0.4993229508,
0.5330411792,
0.2762981951,
0.5453182459,
-0.6636446118,
-0.5318892002,
-0.0574426278,
-0.5628271103,
0.4710193276,
-0.1804807335,
0.3937540352,
0.3884799182,
0.0824697018,
0.1537616104,
0.529096067,
0.7298728228,
-0.5102940202,
0.5677493811,
-0.3979874551,
0.1506230533,
-1.1365334988,
-0.093079485,
0.2063165754,
-0.2122674733,
-0.5642815828,
-0.8372907043,
0.0639342293,
-0.1675020158,
-0.0814371035,
0.1292533129,
-0.2121391296,
-0.3627672195,
-0.1925320625,
-0.0989451855,
-0.2127247006,
0.2701930404,
0.0465776101,
0.6320863366,
0.8541867137,
-0.8049477339,
0.1728925407,
0.476829201,
-0.6837916374,
0.2079521716,
-0.4611117542,
-0.2262296528,
-0.1401224285,
0.4411767721,
-1.1629549265,
0.0778704658,
-0.1318082064,
-0.6678833961,
0.4036879838,
-0.0260875523,
-0.2619821131,
-0.5562948585,
-0.5196599364,
-0.3714752197,
0.4234847128,
-0.7723335028,
0.6572728753,
0.1639545113,
-0.7797578573,
-0.7834365964,
-0.9152917862,
0.0741768554,
-0.0334270038,
-0.6987746358,
0.2434509248,
-0.1272109449,
-0.0076331231,
-0.0075176824,
-0.172426939,
-0.4034348428,
-0.0605411828,
0.2716861367,
0.7827478051,
-0.1848291457,
0.0254944582,
0.1428495347,
-0.0780601725,
0.166830793,
-0.2796650827,
0.295660913,
0.0887183324,
0.2604689002,
-0.3513035476,
-0.0793506429,
0.5478001237,
0.1546621919,
0.9586924911,
0.0646285415,
-0.3602880239,
-0.1455713362,
-0.6279659271,
-0.0415743329,
-0.4504075646,
0.1922400892,
-0.1040182561,
-0.7480541468,
0.6609432697,
-0.2000609636,
-0.1684803665,
0.5569059849,
0.6005587578,
-0.1953185797,
0.6675543189,
1.0374964476,
-0.457303375,
0.466037482,
-0.2378995121,
0.6902994514,
-0.3296610713,
-0.5363504291,
-0.4879882336,
-0.1449031681,
-0.5140609145,
-0.2302773595,
0.5321342349,
0.260761559,
0.1895130575,
0.568815887,
-0.3379127681,
0.0785359442,
0.381450206,
-0.2081440091,
0.0405018888,
0.2899101675,
-0.6421861649,
-0.296857059,
-0.2011680752,
-0.2883027792,
1.0714188814,
0.7669160962,
0.7649545074,
-0.1474584043,
0.7137238383,
0.8731666207,
0.355430752,
-0.5243291855,
0.0933858082,
-0.5520223379,
-0.80212152,
-0.2094772309,
-0.2543928623,
-0.5171734095,
0.004685896,
0.0373764522,
-0.9445973039,
0.8886200786,
-0.0170857254,
-0.4927009344,
0.0874545798,
-0.9131438136,
0.4061668813,
-0.0806572512,
0.1999109983,
-0.571934402,
-0.5650584698,
0.5215328932,
-0.6565749645,
0.314997822,
-0.1274616718,
0.2506946623,
0.6814875603,
-0.2519121766,
0.9263871908,
-0.5828897953,
-0.3552805483,
0.2685054839,
0.2403603345,
0.5656802654,
0.1191547439,
-0.3376044929,
0.0755185708,
0.0358177871,
-0.0334199332,
-0.3389647007,
0.5512136817,
-0.5783622861,
-0.2321178913,
-0.6163028479,
-0.339802593,
-0.5114752054,
-0.2411479056,
0.1976347119,
0.0974623263,
-0.4119316339,
0.2422448397,
0.5095733404,
-0.498880595,
0.6494158506,
0.3754427433,
-0.106802687,
-0.9276975989,
0.6295552254,
0.09432742,
-0.1882351339,
0.202253893,
0.217125386,
-0.7759748697,
-0.3471604884,
0.025675755,
0.1297016144,
-0.7344266772,
-0.5043200254,
-0.6287276149,
-0.3171091974,
-0.7481036186,
-0.5114356875,
-0.3670295477,
-0.4987100363,
-0.3578663766,
-0.2774839103,
0.1211031005,
0.9810867906,
-0.3265752494,
0.0258717444,
-0.8682184219,
0.3688012958,
0.248728767,
0.5289402008,
-0.0819552019,
-0.7710781097,
-0.3460002542,
-0.2559017241,
-0.6023765206,
-0.4787465036,
0.6872801781,
0.2767402828,
0.5075135827,
0.7006024718,
0.1881682128,
0.7302731872,
-0.2569911778,
0.9649169445,
0.5332483053,
-1.0251147747,
0.8551486135,
-0.0756387413,
-0.5042821765,
0.5953561664,
0.6015550494,
-0.2169867754,
-0.3286401331,
-0.8314248323,
-0.5723901391,
0.8701902628,
0.0828550607,
0.1215297952,
0.2829298377,
0.2854649127,
0.5010330081,
0.307772696,
-0.4900766909,
-0.3164756,
-0.2149779648,
0.104119502,
-0.1906151325,
-0.6878703833,
0.3161204755,
-0.4766052663,
0.8244628906,
0.1277276427,
0.4335138202,
0.3571262062,
0.2842962444,
-0.3309841454,
0.0110078594,
0.5656430721,
1.0088485479,
-0.5174397826,
-0.3666749001,
0.1420333087,
-0.4128728509,
-0.2738803625,
0.197911486,
0.4621758163,
0.2166790366,
0.2988008559,
0.5747664571,
0.0367861353,
-0.6257677078,
0.5024816394,
-0.0735381991,
-0.5207465887,
-0.4094798863,
-0.1752575189,
-0.0444951244,
0.3804188371,
0.8052656651,
0.1499242485,
0.5067203045,
-0.5898186564,
0.5621014833,
-0.0651431382,
-0.5765557885,
-0.0990232974,
0.6135348678,
0.001638763,
0.3552327156,
0.6489997506,
0.009558361,
-0.5452526808,
0.5754956603,
0.5534036756,
1.3101710081,
-0.7217621207,
0.1303344071,
0.4993682802,
0.1314223409,
-0.0269725956,
0.2574822903,
0.3447141051,
-0.5834853053,
-0.3647009134,
-0.7697392702,
-0.3886820972,
0.1730733365,
-0.7833582759,
0.3065502942,
-0.8043678999,
-0.0906734467,
-0.0634119213,
0.1750217676,
-0.1363926679,
0.8245157003,
0.2645502388,
0.9074561,
-0.5463377237,
1.0470099449,
0.3489595056,
-0.080821842,
-0.471350044,
0.3875218034,
-0.0783111081,
-0.8269393444,
0.8368318677,
0.1987618953,
0.1216100305,
-0.3930366933,
-0.5390909314,
-0.7496807575,
0.999556601,
0.2000703216,
-0.6007698774,
0.2089995891,
-0.3002519608,
0.5710455179,
-0.5624821186,
-0.7854374647,
0.4395548701,
0.4472327232,
0.4280454814,
-0.8536897898,
-0.5054910779,
0.1839053631,
0.1846918315,
-0.1468181163,
-0.1317295283,
0.6861552596,
-0.3658649325,
0.0782611892,
-0.1482413858,
0.9189984798,
0.1319416761,
0.4853564799,
0.5630224943,
0.5079517961,
0.7493633628,
0.0996864438,
1.1606835127,
-0.4154062271,
0.5809285641,
1.0448261499,
-0.3026687801,
0.9772676229,
0.2363580614,
-0.1120962352,
0.6797745228,
0.6512086987,
-0.3803139925,
0.910951674,
0.1598223299,
-0.1910008341,
0.1603753567,
-0.0018767153,
-0.1471944004,
0.1987012774,
0.5338745713,
-0.797440052,
0.0629943162,
0.0106432391,
-0.2137299329,
-0.0539748296,
-0.3034668267,
0.9114945531,
0.2093175054,
-0.4418171048,
0.4175466001,
0.1972987056,
0.5988241434,
-0.5107025504,
0.2024385929,
-0.1509981602,
0.3549689949,
0.0325386971,
-0.7494953275,
0.4373206198,
0.019400483,
-0.2454570681,
-0.2868572474,
0.9485706091,
-0.1647701412,
-0.3841056824,
0.6402509212,
0.2517132461,
0.0019750006,
-0.1934347004,
-0.8581262231,
-0.192783922,
0.1705539078,
-0.1512554884,
0.2183161676,
0.464464426,
0.2696698308,
0.7899340391,
0.3923508227,
-0.0512770861,
0.0840215012,
-0.1443382353,
0.8984408975,
-0.818431735,
-0.782833159,
-0.4779629111,
0.4558506906,
0.0126440832,
-0.162534222,
0.3958002329,
0.8213422298,
0.4928239882,
-0.6618660092,
0.8695811629,
-0.093586646,
0.8013128042,
-0.6529930234,
0.7186967731,
-0.3489614129,
0.0962961391,
-0.3200909495,
-0.9192444682,
-0.240272969,
0.6061276197,
-0.3745258451,
0.3265970349,
0.7742925882,
0.4910722375,
0.0587532632,
0.1925994158,
0.7731761336,
0.452802062,
0.1331550479,
0.0554677062,
0.3397125006,
-0.2738347352,
0.3816665709,
-0.5268669724,
0.1269101202,
-0.7507699132,
-0.8995509148,
-0.6159300804,
-0.7842116952,
-0.3012152314,
-0.4555190504,
-0.1311771423,
0.4682029486,
0.6165768504,
-1.1723028421,
-0.0942421556,
0.1325987577,
-0.2101736963,
-0.0224535763,
-0.290333271,
0.4051153362,
-0.6258254647,
-0.4756301641,
0.435241878,
0.5624952912,
0.1820341796,
0.0032317613,
-0.1029035375,
0.0490095578,
0.3182620704,
0.7263497114,
-0.0939368084,
-0.733432889,
-0.4075757861,
-0.4693288505,
-0.150801912,
0.113888748,
0.9896956086,
-0.4733191729,
0.4882456362,
0.2928867638,
0.6091204882,
0.3152859509,
0.3539206684,
0.8295348287,
-0.8730867505,
-0.0815411955,
0.2821101546,
0.4452778399,
0.0542711169,
-0.7939468026,
0.3638125956,
-0.0077333013,
-0.3878476024,
-0.3195717633,
-0.412890017,
-1.0808976889,
-0.6695184708,
0.672395885,
-0.3024769127,
-0.2234037966,
-0.3146479428,
-0.2585914135,
0.0399061292,
-0.6739888191,
1.1509332657,
0.8842592239,
-0.2753773928,
-0.0083730221,
-0.5522001982,
0.613658309,
0.3536462784,
-0.677195251,
0.4232878387,
0.5006116629,
0.2528400719,
0.0403268747,
0.4141622484,
-0.2590180337,
0.4011982381,
-0.1818471253,
0.4306297004,
0.212199837,
-0.5155482292,
-0.7430548072,
0.2423449159,
0.1639269888,
-0.2137991339
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03173v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03173v1
|
A Comparative Study of AI-Generated (GPT-4) and Human-crafted MCQs in Programming Education
| 2023-12-05T22:29:43 | 2023-12-05T22:29:43 |
Jacob Doughty, Zipiao Wan, Anishka Bompelli, Jubahed Qayum, Taozhi Wang, Juran Zhang, Yujia Zheng, Aidan Doyle, Pragnya Sridhar, Arav Agarwal, Christopher Bogart, Eric Keylor, Can Kultur, Jaromir Savelka, Majd Sakr
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
There is a constant need for educators to develop and maintain effective
up-to-date assessments. While there is a growing body of research in computing
education on utilizing large language models (LLMs) in generation and
engagement with coding exercises, the use of LLMs for generating programming
MCQs has not been extensively explored. We analyzed the capability of GPT-4 to
produce multiple-choice questions (MCQs) aligned with specific learning
objectives (LOs) from Python programming classes in higher education.
Specifically, we developed an LLM-powered (GPT-4) system for generation of MCQs
from high-level course context and module-level LOs. We evaluated 651
LLM-generated and 449 human-crafted MCQs aligned to 246 LOs from 6 Python
courses. We found that GPT-4 was capable of producing MCQs with clear language,
a single correct choice, and high-quality distractors. We also observed that
the generated MCQs appeared to be well-aligned with the LOs. Our findings can
be leveraged by educators wishing to take advantage of the state-of-the-art
generative models to support MCQ authoring efforts.
|
[
-0.3824541867,
-0.7707073689,
0.5686243176,
-0.1522538215,
0.3631086349,
0.3908447623,
-0.2174195498,
-0.0956936777,
-0.171465382,
0.2976952791,
-0.3142961562,
-0.3024595976,
-0.0394660272,
0.4463281631,
-0.186108917,
1.1710357666,
-0.2280010879,
-0.1718494445,
-0.5945308805,
0.1853847206,
-0.3208200336,
-0.7207621932,
-0.5648745298,
-0.4329153895,
0.4286738634,
0.3712325394,
0.7660315633,
0.2499659956,
0.5889365077,
0.3209682107,
0.4311989248,
-0.0681274757,
-0.1126317382,
0.0068335133,
-0.1367504746,
-0.2675444484,
-0.3153824806,
0.4200067222,
0.5855165124,
0.5475998521,
-0.1895450205,
0.5335201025,
0.0532253981,
0.4923546612,
-0.6223155856,
-0.0242179912,
-0.595695436,
0.2142286599,
0.0806932896,
-0.1316109747,
-0.1655370146,
-0.4542158544,
-0.0902050585,
-0.4343320727,
0.1752076745,
-0.2673279643,
0.6536766887,
0.3064063191,
-0.2425164729,
-0.6365719438,
-0.3269482553,
0.8969280124,
-0.5584266186,
0.2258195281,
0.1148542166,
0.3345229328,
0.0121995127,
-0.6740114689,
-0.6898218989,
-0.3663687408,
0.4141607881,
0.3074115217,
0.2630232871,
0.0416093543,
0.5804705024,
0.2959160507,
-0.6069896817,
0.0519392118,
-0.5934358835,
-0.3161036968,
0.6790704131,
0.427442044,
0.5173348188,
-0.2950712144,
-0.1990519911,
0.1565414667,
-0.966725111,
0.060881976,
0.66645962,
-0.0335015543,
0.2076493502,
0.802303493,
-0.0698900148,
0.7658095956,
-0.2061225027,
-0.3129762113,
0.1681266874,
-0.4157126844,
-0.2187963724,
-0.3164701462,
0.9430431128,
0.2635017931,
0.4431990087,
-0.013459879,
-0.0593645833,
0.2194796205,
0.4426689446,
-0.6423560381,
-0.4911520183,
0.38998878,
-0.1093576178,
-0.3638149202,
-0.1180260181,
-0.4379716218,
-0.0719391257,
-0.5124356151,
0.346047312,
-0.1382631809,
-0.2524710596,
-0.2027509511,
-0.296892494,
0.3072650731,
0.1220526397,
-0.8860032558,
-0.1267751455,
0.4887905121,
0.6236310601,
-0.4398603141,
-0.5154174566,
-0.1966664195,
0.0971100852,
-0.4149052501,
0.4383230805,
-0.6648265123,
-0.2385591269,
-0.0261415411,
-0.4792498052,
0.0048881327,
-0.5849564672,
0.1505499333,
-0.3461176157,
0.4396676421,
-0.160047397,
-0.4443525672,
0.2518495321,
0.7048576474,
-0.0781054571,
1.1061840057,
0.4592622221,
-0.5565460324,
0.3005159795,
-0.589507103,
-0.0706947297,
0.3309221864,
-0.8383705616,
-0.3875555992,
-0.25813362,
0.0573805012,
0.4955961108,
-0.1962799132,
0.3008014858,
-0.020956764,
-0.4647538662,
0.402717948,
-0.4283456206,
0.563147068,
0.268873632,
-0.5527496934,
-0.0137321968,
-0.4014366865,
0.5366547108,
0.035816934,
-0.9993896484,
0.1979755908,
0.0777533203,
-0.5392333865,
0.5001853108,
0.2002640218,
-0.4021443725,
0.385391742,
0.0307665337,
0.5897690058,
0.7081974149,
0.0376520529,
0.2446597964,
-0.4290407598,
0.9422531128,
-0.2484101653,
0.0684740841,
0.0225672498,
-0.6402972937,
-0.5580065846,
-0.0423706137,
-0.1431587785,
0.4907414019,
-0.853381753,
0.1215697452,
0.0000744027,
-0.5069434643,
-0.4800929427,
0.2608937323,
0.4189914465,
0.3685400486,
0.3034703434,
-0.0401408896,
-0.4367362559,
-0.4705935121,
-0.2121047676,
-0.1851167381,
-0.2657009959,
0.6537917852,
0.5757698417,
-0.4107460678,
0.7838346362,
-0.4839446247,
0.2229469121,
-0.2705022097,
-0.0292487722,
0.1831452101,
0.5985814929,
0.4262825549,
-0.4843559563,
-0.6418340206,
-0.1773929149,
-0.8846400976,
-0.0832131505,
-0.3308289349,
-0.1587875634,
0.0446267575,
0.2465243638,
-0.6912921667,
0.0700261295,
0.3232839704,
0.0196254682,
1.0928646326,
-0.027863659,
0.4107375145,
-0.8493603468,
-0.1138655618,
-0.3907814026,
0.0521013848,
-0.3064293563,
0.2673693895,
0.1260056794,
-0.5311879516,
-0.3797492981,
0.3253682554,
-0.5837818384,
-0.2051073313,
-0.0009030702,
0.382065326,
-0.0353743955,
0.3812430799,
-0.0023470372,
1.0449082851,
0.5279029608,
-0.6880577207,
0.4552101791,
0.1895372868,
-0.384214133,
0.3721267879,
-0.6220043898,
0.3543552458,
0.369211942,
0.0367206633,
-0.7281156778,
-0.3796423376,
0.0647894591,
-0.6419586539,
0.1180272028,
-0.1024182215,
-0.1400969476,
-0.7706874013,
-0.2706963122,
0.3537092507,
0.7721942663,
-0.4701777995,
0.1699520499,
0.1293631494,
-0.2961230278,
-0.7604960799,
-0.7458167076,
0.0903047249,
-0.1275698096,
-0.4425647855,
0.1680838168,
-0.4253285527,
-0.2254155725,
-0.2960173786,
-0.0983515233,
0.2046871483,
0.0764617622,
0.195010215,
0.3057894707,
-0.2231244445,
-0.0597268082,
0.0517925732,
0.2260448486,
0.275523454,
-0.4002643526,
0.4084803462,
-0.1123546213,
-0.611579895,
-0.2639822662,
0.4104293883,
0.3139206767,
-0.1115614027,
0.3197122812,
0.534117341,
-0.0581158288,
-0.2002856433,
-0.5795561075,
-0.0079315482,
-0.5144613385,
0.2880108356,
-0.4598985612,
-0.8802630901,
0.0989204124,
0.0251618028,
0.2126608491,
0.1969449967,
0.817001462,
-0.1781593859,
1.2896835804,
0.112568371,
-0.044682283,
0.5053188801,
-0.3954249322,
0.1057679653,
-1.0249224901,
-0.1212129369,
-0.4995248616,
-0.0274837669,
-0.4895352721,
-0.3875236511,
0.2671714425,
0.0841619223,
-0.7773073912,
0.0593787357,
-0.8895536661,
0.7052333951,
0.6776224971,
-0.2095134854,
-0.0892659649,
-0.004951986,
-0.3376749456,
0.2175028473,
-0.7106027007,
-0.8870639801,
1.4295040369,
-0.1258541197,
0.5028677583,
0.2421206385,
1.0578894615,
0.2575156093,
0.5934166908,
-0.4540311694,
0.5244630575,
0.2852054536,
-0.7054075599,
-0.2297764122,
-0.753633678,
-0.7484996319,
0.1751456708,
-0.0785862207,
-0.6685379148,
-0.4659967721,
0.090605624,
-0.2979864776,
0.1966840029,
-0.8406283855,
0.9299091101,
-0.3673292398,
-0.5061426759,
0.1573045552,
-0.3732192218,
0.2790831029,
0.0641201809,
0.1482808292,
-0.0547730178,
0.0716137439,
0.6455594897,
-0.2849267423,
0.4737144113,
-0.0946504772,
-0.0771036446,
0.9140114188,
0.0932512134,
0.0807561949,
0.2811152041,
-0.4033395648,
-0.168567583,
0.0927907452,
-0.4531645477,
-0.4767912924,
0.9133015275,
-1.0959374905,
-0.8721399307,
-0.4482350051,
-0.7419966459,
-0.0665090308,
0.1149436757,
0.1589723229,
0.5128451586,
0.0009964807,
-0.1399437934,
0.1984794587,
-0.4481818676,
0.455946207,
0.2625503838,
-0.0119142318,
-0.4026505947,
1.1155189276,
0.0956651345,
0.6237873435,
0.1510530114,
0.2305654883,
-0.1442349851,
-0.5822828412,
-0.593035996,
-0.0278649628,
-0.7765012383,
-0.2509813011,
-0.4055047333,
-0.2959314883,
-0.7203482389,
-0.6435198784,
0.1391723603,
-0.2376198918,
-0.4238583148,
-0.0647796467,
-0.2718639672,
0.8526003361,
0.0388537608,
-0.0360444523,
-0.7652767301,
0.2644292116,
0.5306382775,
0.0401156768,
-0.220588401,
-0.2333946526,
0.0944244713,
0.2265968174,
-0.9355772734,
-0.7728779316,
0.1366003156,
0.2023584247,
0.6848079562,
0.3096054494,
-0.1364755183,
0.5006276369,
-0.3917159736,
1.4163589478,
0.395641923,
-0.8246586919,
0.5106708407,
-0.4408282638,
0.4375789165,
0.429697156,
0.5928545594,
-0.2977849841,
-0.5535284281,
-0.4708495438,
-0.4467871189,
0.6287044287,
0.2689186633,
0.4296372235,
-0.4433533251,
0.5558684468,
0.1286890209,
0.4441164732,
-0.9910392761,
0.1162536144,
-0.4239833951,
-0.3634240329,
-0.0447426401,
-0.0928198919,
0.0998843834,
-0.2308295667,
0.6553032398,
-0.2592673302,
0.3249940276,
-0.1092195138,
0.0509881712,
0.1863304228,
0.4920900464,
0.4277357757,
0.7971899509,
-0.0487073101,
0.1648613811,
0.0267450754,
-0.5107257366,
0.1503596455,
-0.4388357997,
-0.2069211453,
-0.4948053956,
0.2470894009,
0.3381876051,
-0.3401699066,
-0.8794621825,
0.4334845245,
0.2142964453,
-0.3557839394,
-0.283791244,
0.6857688427,
0.1259961426,
0.0684426129,
0.1592006534,
-0.0963244364,
-0.0070060221,
-0.712346971,
-0.0061471551,
0.4778957963,
0.0168683399,
-0.0278872345,
0.6598932147,
0.3420545161,
-0.5129050612,
1.0998542309,
-0.3524927199,
-0.5935795903,
0.747546792,
0.7448529601,
0.4353764653,
-0.1002033949,
0.4333395064,
0.6533679366,
0.0869049206,
0.0651189685,
0.6453380585,
-0.4532118738,
-0.6545735002,
-0.3061978221,
-0.5435569882,
-0.5771067142,
-0.0782738477,
-0.465012908,
0.065606229,
-0.3878832161,
-0.311063379,
-0.302746892,
0.1870221198,
-0.7216079831,
0.3425557315,
-0.0115269134,
0.3056601286,
-0.5595210791,
0.6505175829,
0.8937978148,
-0.8195696473,
-1.1257679462,
-0.1933881342,
-0.1860947609,
-0.535910368,
0.5498321652,
0.2125664651,
0.1505024582,
0.1901922673,
-0.6549364924,
-0.7619994879,
1.265833497,
0.2735057473,
-0.2854588032,
-0.2144936025,
0.5776299834,
0.406665802,
-0.2834847569,
0.6124712229,
0.5022900105,
0.2600423992,
0.0055395737,
-0.6163479686,
-0.2526280284,
-0.2029179484,
-0.1947607398,
0.2809705436,
-0.4131373167,
0.993266046,
-0.5907273889,
-0.1332496852,
0.1601718664,
0.3283409178,
0.6592158079,
0.2133258432,
-0.0405589193,
0.1918389499,
0.7761999965,
-0.1765291691,
0.9525938034,
-0.1385402381,
0.3615043163,
0.9131934643,
-0.2737652063,
0.6685954332,
0.5099077225,
-0.5600386858,
0.5429048538,
0.7935092449,
-0.1452850401,
0.0016036096,
0.7576744556,
-0.2129072845,
-0.4150865674,
0.3862752318,
-0.5463454127,
0.2974455655,
0.3704432845,
-0.1608089358,
0.2541982532,
0.0684778094,
-0.1189636663,
0.0249085948,
-0.3194313049,
0.6603731513,
-0.0263886247,
-1.1180641651,
0.5631893277,
-0.1524961442,
0.6203454137,
-0.3728167713,
0.027779175,
-0.1986613721,
0.0462479256,
-0.3207538426,
-0.9451761842,
0.0021120582,
0.4065865576,
0.0117957359,
-0.1896854639,
0.3466596603,
-0.4262936711,
-0.5092561841,
-0.3053687215,
0.4645754397,
0.6153357625,
0.1865433007,
-0.8101984859,
-0.1177814528,
0.0167491734,
-0.1562815756,
0.4613804519,
0.1334177703,
0.1362600923,
0.7455141544,
0.6173978448,
0.0090408633,
0.3236617744,
0.1454561502,
0.5148283243,
-0.3750725389,
-0.2619663179,
-0.6735910773,
0.3737936318,
0.0367809758,
-0.3658390641,
0.7287422419,
0.6197215319,
0.9919005036,
-0.2038685679,
1.2151905298,
-0.257642597,
0.0852561519,
-0.4482979178,
0.4986739755,
-0.4405445755,
0.3220843971,
-0.5264414549,
-1.0102617741,
-0.0492946208,
0.5153832436,
-0.4124351144,
0.4723468721,
0.5891103148,
0.5364925265,
0.09831319,
-0.3334471881,
0.3591468632,
-0.4007816613,
0.6999785304,
0.8492954969,
1.2218244076,
-0.200912565,
0.6018711925,
-0.1297059059,
-0.1976957023,
0.1933576912,
-0.7826574445,
-1.1310681105,
-0.4951487482,
-0.6492014527,
-0.1034407094,
-0.1302823126,
0.8812890053,
0.4256126881,
-0.592764318,
-0.2257072926,
-0.1750347912,
0.2048860043,
-0.2135906219,
-0.2480383068,
0.3632799983,
-0.5842600465,
-0.6028267741,
0.2063225657,
-0.0261193477,
0.0737681836,
-0.3544903994,
-0.276714474,
-0.1215757877,
0.1616918743,
0.6696150899,
0.1534674019,
-0.6997249722,
-0.6059681177,
0.1222425476,
-0.1512628645,
0.0133373244,
0.8762330413,
-0.6685917974,
0.3270263076,
0.5592418313,
0.6702066064,
0.0526318848,
0.0876826346,
0.4272212386,
-0.7776674628,
-0.5023208261,
0.3943241239,
0.2234788239,
0.3460434675,
-0.3649497628,
0.3935201764,
0.0089313835,
-1.0343010426,
-0.618440032,
0.1799094975,
-0.5932269096,
-0.1840053648,
1.3717501163,
-0.1462397873,
0.2838434875,
-0.0726400688,
-0.4286737144,
0.2216347456,
0.0622903705,
0.7126252055,
0.5886448622,
-0.5961514711,
0.0698007718,
-0.6480477452,
0.4959626496,
0.1518653184,
-0.9865631461,
-0.1852880865,
0.6427434683,
0.5005292892,
0.1281513572,
0.7630442381,
0.0263095908,
0.4251374006,
0.2130281478,
0.2659492493,
-0.3849061728,
-0.2153142691,
0.2884781361,
0.5189214945,
0.1289700717,
-0.0661721751
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03171v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03171v1
|
Combining Counting Processes and Classification Improves a Stopping Rule for Technology Assisted Review
| 2023-12-05T22:28:42 | 2023-12-05T22:28:42 |
Reem Bin-Hezam, Mark Stevenson
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
Technology Assisted Review (TAR) stopping rules aim to reduce the cost of
manually assessing documents for relevance by minimising the number of
documents that need to be examined to ensure a desired level of recall. This
paper extends an effective stopping rule using information derived from a text
classifier that can be trained without the need for any additional annotation.
Experiments on multiple data sets (CLEF e-Health, TREC Total Recall, TREC Legal
and RCV1) showed that the proposed approach consistently improves performance
and outperforms several alternative methods.
|
[
-0.6526460052,
-0.5965171456,
0.5381819606,
-0.0883441493,
-0.5322009325,
0.3150559664,
0.0650397763,
-0.603511095,
0.2288341671,
0.727827549,
-0.0989860073,
-0.5589402914,
-0.7586365342,
0.297557801,
-0.8023746014,
1.1199380159,
-0.1063558012,
0.0020165462,
0.0716513097,
-0.1128920317,
-0.845795691,
-0.3451721668,
-1.0059753656,
-0.2388843596,
0.6344206929,
0.6913816333,
0.167070508,
0.5551682711,
0.6351450086,
0.3129391372,
-0.1250136793,
0.1823867559,
-0.09832564,
0.1945573986,
0.1880134642,
-0.6709229946,
-0.2247788608,
0.0373461694,
0.4521250129,
0.0833330303,
-0.1703211814,
-0.1467402279,
-0.0274093766,
0.6459632516,
-0.6422668099,
0.0883280784,
-0.178840369,
0.2214928567,
-0.205978483,
-0.7400029302,
-0.7018175125,
-0.6202298999,
0.1039412469,
-0.3852617145,
0.4495652914,
-0.0390687361,
0.7098580599,
0.2896908224,
-0.1904939115,
-0.3009486198,
-0.9735667109,
0.4942235649,
-0.3745687902,
0.5272718072,
0.5571935773,
0.0698172897,
0.3248744607,
-0.7374193668,
-0.6604474187,
-0.0739290863,
-0.2110401839,
0.2643777728,
0.0021082475,
0.2264448553,
0.7798261046,
0.3490741551,
-0.3907820582,
-0.0342091136,
-0.990432024,
-0.2211792618,
0.4748698771,
-0.1720198393,
0.2005594522,
0.1114656627,
-0.4747840166,
-0.2514475584,
-0.4679262042,
0.0795316249,
-0.0048165098,
-0.1331952363,
0.1130690351,
0.4142740667,
-0.2628909647,
0.4884481132,
0.1963020712,
-0.4223469794,
0.352694869,
-0.1622927189,
-0.4984038472,
0.6018211246,
0.523214221,
0.4335573614,
0.5479397178,
0.0066643357,
-0.2626082003,
0.2254134268,
0.3176288307,
-1.0135214329,
-0.0261342041,
0.4299280047,
-0.2977356613,
-0.2643534243,
0.6348766685,
-0.6317763925,
-0.186482802,
-0.4255956113,
0.3271998763,
-0.6389527321,
-0.0828948468,
0.2485626638,
-0.5112627745,
-0.0910754725,
0.4493376613,
-0.5784845948,
0.6330704093,
0.6800991893,
1.164126277,
0.0681522563,
-0.0623278171,
-1.1465456486,
0.1798262447,
-0.4562129974,
1.1130788326,
-0.6864666343,
-0.6926279068,
-0.0848948583,
0.1195302233,
-0.0414722338,
-0.3374924064,
0.5395820141,
-0.6174280643,
0.522587955,
-0.247193709,
-0.5102040172,
-0.5657835603,
0.3879474103,
-1.0821124315,
1.1867588758,
-0.3001874387,
-0.7686732411,
1.2973768711,
-0.8202156425,
-0.7751389742,
0.3794843853,
-0.0755583271,
-0.5483411551,
-0.0267231874,
0.0558256321,
0.1987721324,
-0.1117317975,
0.2226063907,
0.0698424205,
-0.6499260068,
-0.3051776886,
0.0621784739,
0.4823900163,
0.3771587014,
-0.4600854814,
0.5465522408,
-0.5581276417,
-0.1370663941,
-0.3732981682,
-0.5846949816,
-0.6672525406,
-0.1657156497,
-0.0009665868,
0.2803052962,
-0.5229439139,
-0.8081182837,
0.1292001903,
0.047086481,
0.0609868281,
0.5076053143,
0.4062457979,
0.1972101182,
-0.7635778785,
0.5221933722,
-0.3164888322,
0.2216106057,
-0.1422172487,
-0.6561092734,
-0.9098549485,
-0.3854362965,
0.6352737546,
0.5558957458,
-1.0030339956,
0.5813183784,
-0.3096297085,
-0.4637627006,
-0.1925389469,
-0.0919068158,
0.3165378571,
0.3146703541,
0.4803616107,
-0.8089450598,
-0.4508551657,
-0.1355206966,
0.1138030738,
-0.4437278211,
0.0056542857,
-0.1479032934,
0.4434733689,
0.3662442267,
0.7264926434,
-0.1650246382,
-0.5838908553,
-0.3102355897,
0.5501283407,
-0.2327635288,
0.3307566047,
0.3998606801,
-0.885251224,
-0.6412280798,
0.0681101456,
-0.6419025064,
-0.1552472264,
-0.3506839275,
0.0569951944,
0.7321564555,
0.7247017622,
-0.3198700547,
1.0476051569,
-0.3317430019,
-0.4208937287,
0.0440772586,
-0.3417062461,
0.8338928819,
-0.3412591815,
0.1924137324,
0.1487849355,
-0.1137272194,
-0.740088582,
-0.2678253055,
0.1988246143,
0.0988735482,
-0.5216198564,
0.5437980294,
-0.4570553005,
0.0746829808,
-0.3538593948,
-0.1665450782,
0.0508015342,
0.205912903,
0.6466409564,
0.5657359362,
0.1325922608,
-0.8879774809,
0.0999992788,
0.2508140504,
-0.2112875432,
0.8399719,
-0.3853310943,
0.1174936593,
-0.1244788393,
0.2629237175,
-0.7102731466,
0.0257344488,
0.288533777,
-0.3726305068,
0.5211087465,
-0.0985018536,
-0.697104454,
-0.4368616939,
-0.8509021401,
-0.0528267063,
0.4762719274,
-0.3438441157,
0.7198078036,
0.3601445854,
-0.0140653113,
-0.3764528632,
-0.6405052543,
0.1855265945,
-0.4664874077,
-0.2416689545,
0.2734105885,
0.0910079852,
-0.4120774865,
0.0719227716,
-0.2571944296,
-0.1752513647,
-0.0563428365,
-0.0094288113,
0.1468956321,
0.3554264903,
0.6671236157,
0.0175376423,
-0.295415163,
-0.1003067121,
-0.3518977761,
0.7179334164,
0.5069835782,
0.0784963667,
-0.6177554727,
0.3426308334,
0.839684248,
-0.2766762674,
0.6298937201,
0.6013954282,
-0.5299143791,
-0.0991008058,
-0.8302020431,
-0.2526238561,
-0.4069634378,
-0.2011883408,
-0.548494637,
-0.5539576411,
0.2448847592,
0.3416401148,
0.3016196489,
0.6585925817,
0.353264451,
-0.02185864,
0.424377352,
0.879114449,
0.0835140646,
0.854940474,
0.0087284688,
0.0554296039,
-0.3171867132,
-0.6620190144,
-0.784907043,
-0.0954710469,
-0.3664826453,
-0.1870390326,
0.6581128836,
-0.1250226945,
-0.1036875769,
0.4495941103,
-0.9945414662,
0.3199854195,
0.795222342,
0.580031693,
0.5709425211,
0.278262496,
-0.1206859723,
0.3093648851,
-0.705293417,
-0.3561954796,
1.0431774855,
0.0929157883,
0.5941542387,
-0.1365727931,
0.8532797098,
0.9162240028,
0.5389643908,
-0.9429991245,
0.6568602324,
-0.14427118,
-0.6372110248,
-0.4657291174,
-0.2315538824,
-0.7968709469,
-0.2404176444,
-0.3764463067,
-0.3686850667,
0.2169522792,
0.0249832384,
-0.3465038538,
0.6610901952,
-0.628549397,
0.3272604048,
-0.3656782806,
-0.4034588337,
-0.6860218644,
-0.3565843403,
0.3270556033,
-0.3498975933,
-0.0780022293,
0.4041559696,
-0.1550729275,
1.2892547846,
-0.8788868785,
0.63034904,
-0.2286580056,
0.2402904779,
0.7962899208,
-0.0212972909,
0.2630188167,
-0.5257378221,
-0.0276953168,
0.0327922404,
0.1946879029,
-0.093474783,
-0.1140234843,
0.2586715817,
-0.1269638687,
-0.2374198288,
-1.026263833,
-0.196324423,
0.2405198961,
0.3615160286,
0.3418215215,
0.5144614577,
0.272459358,
0.2167571783,
0.6514000893,
-0.1070113257,
0.6956573725,
0.4616439641,
0.0758541077,
-0.6774968505,
0.5799798369,
0.5142067671,
0.1710619777,
0.4814908206,
0.2592972517,
-0.5931107402,
-0.6350432038,
-0.4313296974,
0.0373710357,
-0.7800900936,
-0.1257331669,
-0.9364786744,
-0.2678562999,
-0.3287819624,
0.0818425044,
0.4082011878,
-0.2438496798,
0.0443240926,
-0.2310520411,
0.8598611951,
1.1056121588,
-0.1593008935,
0.2735830545,
-1.0819231272,
0.3150788546,
0.1745919734,
0.7427299619,
0.0240765847,
-0.3665346205,
-0.1735694855,
-0.895581305,
-0.1249513328,
-0.7833564281,
0.0684552863,
0.0743079036,
0.7215569019,
0.3678572178,
0.2663598955,
0.551025629,
-0.20676817,
0.2662554085,
0.3824413419,
-0.9122079015,
0.4614822567,
-0.0589329824,
0.2484165728,
0.7091920376,
0.6016373634,
-0.7421631813,
-0.2113115191,
-0.5343043804,
-0.696575582,
0.5767502785,
0.0871538743,
-0.6622682214,
-0.266302228,
0.1670055687,
0.1075636074,
0.1371780783,
-0.1961597204,
0.2693683803,
0.1973003745,
-0.0648789629,
0.5163319707,
-0.5665740967,
0.047502555,
-0.0416613631,
0.8666561246,
0.111185126,
-0.0005755008,
0.4275000393,
-0.2157158554,
-0.1611680984,
0.2106685638,
0.6003226042,
0.3521167338,
-0.2361991554,
0.0435903482,
0.2298322618,
-0.9152519703,
0.0515186675,
0.08574716,
-0.6076695323,
0.0163414776,
0.4123565555,
0.2784333825,
-0.0415496528,
-0.2419115752,
-0.1067228615,
-0.3289389014,
-0.4770939052,
-0.1085395068,
0.2069489062,
-0.497697264,
-0.1376856863,
0.201937899,
0.1381630301,
0.2219139785,
-0.5777952671,
0.9475591183,
0.0322145075,
-0.6995066404,
0.267814517,
0.4632475078,
0.5547322631,
-0.5415930152,
0.3605898321,
-0.1976041943,
-0.5062543154,
0.8051336408,
-0.0275968742,
1.069507122,
-0.1916102171,
0.0794066489,
0.7385923266,
0.4645408988,
-0.5714706182,
0.4290876985,
-0.5240584612,
-0.2164435685,
-0.4653520882,
-0.2774765491,
-0.6982008219,
-0.0018402432,
-0.6915559173,
0.8821884394,
-0.8345030546,
-0.1069341153,
-0.0108544659,
-0.0176284332,
-0.4644493759,
0.5519364476,
0.0759165809,
1.1776000261,
-0.7992010713,
0.6806761622,
0.4663348794,
-0.6082800031,
-0.3620882928,
0.0225261692,
0.1371189058,
-0.1257302612,
0.2629186213,
0.7051100135,
-0.4523982406,
-0.275044322,
-0.2602057159,
-0.361304909,
0.8563653827,
-0.5105732679,
-0.8305735588,
0.5213823318,
-0.3539169133,
0.6418907046,
0.0213321727,
0.6474308968,
0.9727710485,
0.5855710506,
0.4965561628,
-1.2289633751,
0.0761175156,
-0.5359791517,
-0.6536698341,
0.4961673319,
-0.4882662594,
0.3429774344,
-0.1913722754,
-0.6742204428,
0.0355921462,
-0.0557283759,
0.3193126321,
0.8745727539,
0.9759089351,
0.6340361238,
0.7667273879,
-0.2883429229,
1.0087715387,
-0.2510394454,
0.1940494478,
0.9696621299,
-0.2897358835,
0.502209723,
0.1286137253,
-0.1462947726,
0.2955148518,
0.8631368876,
-0.2138618529,
0.2929373384,
0.0483076386,
-0.4618280828,
-0.2220506817,
-0.3271748424,
-0.1800683886,
0.5040561557,
0.2532903254,
-0.3457197249,
-0.1751723439,
-0.0984991267,
0.1307512075,
0.1467902213,
-0.3095358014,
0.9853132963,
-0.2627810538,
-1.0496228933,
0.2481657267,
-0.1795542985,
0.6682339907,
-0.418746531,
-0.5205296278,
0.1472625285,
0.0589448065,
-0.4119970798,
-1.0293123722,
0.3284409344,
0.2929600775,
-0.1579227895,
-0.2832972705,
0.816203773,
-0.2997674644,
-0.7606785893,
0.4323936999,
0.2568500936,
0.4934401512,
0.0244055931,
-0.3360411227,
-0.0079948558,
-0.1110182256,
0.0356348678,
-0.2051308602,
0.3812924325,
-0.7104379535,
0.563708961,
0.835480988,
0.10833399,
-0.2534551919,
0.2395457774,
0.6575346589,
-1.0689656734,
-1.0434741974,
-0.7262226939,
0.473056525,
-0.3742724359,
-0.2012983859,
0.1259349883,
0.6515920162,
0.880936861,
0.1961099803,
1.0248906612,
-0.4786840379,
0.5041956306,
-0.7693454623,
0.6717860699,
-0.2767856717,
0.5114580989,
-0.0020816207,
-0.6550565362,
-0.678406477,
0.4377659857,
-0.3511422276,
0.2882311344,
1.0648972988,
0.3018520772,
0.1621165127,
0.1426279098,
0.2614792585,
-0.2252646536,
0.5894194245,
0.3266534209,
0.4780280292,
-0.3219376206,
0.742123723,
-0.5150048733,
-0.2924506068,
0.0471557677,
-0.7796556354,
-1.1691911221,
-0.247913301,
-0.4092956483,
-0.5158774853,
-0.1566248983,
0.6466822624,
0.810592711,
-0.855358839,
0.0593079403,
-0.151259914,
0.1762317121,
-0.2262755483,
-0.1788274795,
0.4468325675,
-0.2379341722,
-0.5786362886,
-0.099059388,
0.4078609645,
-0.0498574786,
0.1674802154,
0.1352275908,
-0.3025408387,
-0.1367592514,
0.5285459757,
0.4804367423,
-0.4546280205,
-0.5092381239,
-0.0475263298,
0.1891471297,
0.2555910945,
1.1067737341,
-1.0052429438,
0.8032043576,
0.873303473,
0.3088208139,
0.9014996886,
0.2490155548,
0.3080495298,
-0.2891409695,
0.1881357282,
0.0815636963,
0.3006385267,
0.2549375892,
-0.5364618301,
0.9628481269,
0.4474785328,
-0.1247678474,
-0.525711894,
-0.1163654029,
-1.0298374891,
0.05068909,
0.9554901719,
0.0046368432,
0.1100381464,
-0.6476579309,
-0.2228876948,
0.3512230217,
-0.6672853231,
1.0592880249,
0.5984455943,
-0.2172932178,
-0.5453038812,
-0.3760024905,
0.3523729146,
0.0241110884,
-1.1098872423,
-0.4652788639,
0.3570394218,
0.4001853466,
0.3291458189,
0.7741608024,
-0.2923717797,
0.6035683155,
-0.0640479848,
0.2947056293,
-0.2415902615,
-0.9175819159,
-0.3976982236,
0.291398108,
-0.3040730357,
-0.5321133137
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03769v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03769v1
|
GPT vs Human for Scientific Reviews: A Dual Source Review on Applications of ChatGPT in Science
| 2023-12-05T21:41:52 | 2023-12-05T21:41:52 |
Chenxi Wu, Alan John Varghese, Vivek Oommen, George Em Karniadakis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The new polymath Large Language Models (LLMs) can speed-up greatly scientific
reviews, possibly using more unbiased quantitative metrics, facilitating
cross-disciplinary connections, and identifying emerging trends and research
gaps by analyzing large volumes of data. However, at the present time, they
lack the required deep understanding of complex methodologies, they have
difficulty in evaluating innovative claims, and they are unable to assess
ethical issues and conflicts of interest. Herein, we consider 13 GPT-related
papers across different scientific domains, reviewed by a human reviewer and
SciSpace, a large language model, with the reviews evaluated by three distinct
types of evaluators, namely GPT-3.5, a crowd panel, and GPT-4. We found that
50% of SciSpace's responses to objective questions align with those of a human
reviewer, with GPT-4 (informed evaluator) often rating the human reviewer
higher in accuracy, and SciSpace higher in structure, clarity, and
completeness. In subjective questions, the uninformed evaluators (GPT-3.5 and
crowd panel) showed varying preferences between SciSpace and human responses,
with the crowd panel showing a preference for the human responses. However,
GPT-4 rated them equally in accuracy and structure but favored SciSpace for
completeness.
|
[
-0.4571339488,
-0.4006336629,
0.8244673014,
0.335468173,
-0.2735151947,
0.5870391726,
-0.429761529,
-0.7359831929,
0.0040414343,
0.1230973005,
-0.1018375978,
-0.2031901032,
-0.568580091,
0.4222593904,
-0.2766756415,
1.3131330013,
-0.0629295781,
0.4028450549,
-0.3739370406,
0.0898652598,
0.0198530946,
-0.764896512,
-0.5467430949,
-0.5074638128,
0.7237100601,
-0.0726440996,
0.9023835659,
-0.1449405104,
0.7449341416,
0.3162020147,
-0.2087184936,
0.0926416442,
-0.3775509894,
-0.2507276535,
-0.3289068043,
-0.1915030628,
-0.5853628516,
0.3841580749,
0.475941211,
0.69104141,
-0.0528294854,
0.1220280752,
0.1535922438,
0.8535678387,
-0.1371498257,
0.1283220202,
-0.3143107891,
0.2458549142,
-0.0426895991,
-0.0349137969,
-0.1778299361,
-0.4191510677,
0.5378060937,
-0.6240107417,
0.4951465726,
0.0648354143,
0.6454437375,
0.1389908791,
-0.5244971514,
-0.1679295152,
-0.7602522373,
0.5680039525,
-0.4879807234,
0.3543112278,
0.0888069719,
0.2110873759,
-0.1608167142,
-0.6452009678,
-0.7424262166,
-0.6317691803,
0.0304514263,
0.3497781456,
-0.1320660114,
0.1847503334,
0.2926876843,
0.3520002961,
-0.6280627847,
-0.1115614846,
-0.7945794463,
-0.4507381618,
0.8139294386,
-0.0016480769,
0.095770523,
-0.3137899637,
-0.4769625068,
-0.2501671016,
-0.7008937001,
-0.0418780372,
0.3920823634,
-0.0393469483,
0.1642224342,
0.6312518716,
-0.2554115653,
0.3676798344,
-0.0662535727,
0.275698781,
0.116878055,
-0.6686486602,
-0.0918066651,
-0.2770712674,
1.2176699638,
0.4999508262,
0.2961022556,
-0.0248031076,
0.0713121742,
0.4595144689,
0.2228925228,
-0.826625526,
-0.1631821543,
0.1358580142,
-0.5244366527,
-0.2249950171,
0.3198320568,
-0.8461890221,
-0.6125455499,
-0.3033213317,
0.0718209296,
-0.011918392,
-0.2340460271,
0.3349192739,
-0.0641812757,
0.020186333,
0.7950294018,
-0.3384678066,
0.4924544394,
0.7366814017,
1.0248125792,
-0.2474525124,
-0.40151003,
-0.0531071164,
-0.2869136631,
-0.0616298243,
1.2012968063,
-0.4495207369,
-0.6607350707,
-0.5998941064,
-0.2906519175,
-0.065181911,
-0.1493082792,
0.5768942237,
-0.4816692472,
0.687415421,
-0.542069912,
-0.2096124291,
-0.2700326145,
0.0075999675,
-0.4218855798,
0.7776808143,
-0.0091912113,
-0.9293060899,
0.5587106347,
-0.8934574127,
-0.049724672,
0.1770483106,
-0.2504785955,
-0.2381250709,
0.0533737764,
0.2271771431,
0.2826830149,
-0.4278048873,
0.511046648,
-0.5253829956,
-0.3548498154,
0.4661870301,
-0.4378875494,
0.3856039643,
0.399913013,
-0.3083778322,
0.3111171126,
-0.3240408301,
0.0045341472,
0.0657912865,
-0.3284120262,
-0.1712634265,
0.3156601191,
0.2288287729,
0.4269827008,
-0.1781776845,
-0.8046403527,
0.2693500221,
-0.0779440701,
0.7268769741,
0.7619436979,
0.0668220744,
0.1858886927,
-0.3276791871,
0.4042912722,
-0.3108179569,
0.1834194213,
0.2183100879,
-0.8140955567,
-0.3074980974,
0.0372565202,
0.3605577946,
0.3565192819,
-0.4567217529,
0.1666930765,
-0.1049937978,
-0.6846160293,
-0.6963098645,
-0.0530667901,
0.4799983799,
0.2736177444,
0.168620199,
-0.6436773539,
-0.2796214819,
-0.8833292127,
-0.4273676276,
-0.5394285917,
-0.2915098369,
0.460917592,
0.6430674791,
-0.261800468,
0.8996109962,
-0.3322903514,
0.1163948998,
0.0655215457,
0.0695238188,
0.0740370005,
0.0158556532,
0.0591046475,
-0.7897552252,
-0.7075394988,
0.1146088541,
-0.5671396852,
-0.1664768308,
0.1605141759,
0.1940652281,
0.1870324016,
0.0274457932,
-0.9714284539,
0.3213683367,
0.4752087295,
-0.6402754188,
0.8765879273,
-0.0985190421,
0.4913210869,
-0.6244902611,
0.1842947006,
0.1999268681,
-0.1825864017,
-0.5814839005,
-0.1634855568,
0.0241805296,
-0.1427428424,
-0.1982131153,
0.58822155,
-0.5456011891,
-0.1605791152,
-0.3907990456,
0.3092778921,
0.0938962549,
0.1856635809,
0.3741110861,
0.8203514814,
0.2028227597,
-0.2213128209,
0.4478859305,
0.2941941023,
-0.428213805,
0.3117431998,
-0.9742848277,
0.5064628124,
-0.241197601,
0.8687098622,
-0.9760391116,
-0.4125858843,
0.1926631778,
-0.5931095481,
0.0709293932,
-0.0341251642,
-0.5980171561,
-0.7323389649,
-0.6268354058,
0.2496707141,
0.5540720224,
-0.2757433355,
0.0383088812,
0.4493769705,
-0.4990238547,
-0.3860176802,
-0.2481004596,
0.3424876928,
-0.0084419502,
-0.7429639697,
0.0873778909,
-0.1201675236,
-0.5876190066,
-0.0115509005,
-0.3919436932,
0.209505707,
-0.293277204,
0.0686849281,
0.3682935834,
-0.0875218958,
0.125669986,
-0.5287939906,
-0.0923250467,
0.0721971467,
-0.0213082023,
0.3823096454,
-0.5407012701,
-0.5372375846,
-0.2558638155,
0.3252141178,
0.6304940581,
0.0755539462,
0.1582421064,
0.4955058992,
0.1078319475,
0.2917780578,
-0.8952584863,
-0.4192507863,
-0.3573864698,
0.6273698211,
-0.0283556543,
-1.1336146593,
0.2884405851,
0.2420710325,
-0.0110543519,
0.5360662341,
0.6870135665,
-0.2256275713,
0.9276849031,
0.4445369542,
-0.1026695818,
0.1846411824,
0.2141195536,
0.4118735194,
-0.9937560558,
-0.1737172753,
-0.5850927234,
-0.190464735,
-0.636081934,
-0.5650210977,
0.6476770043,
-0.2310029119,
-0.1801541746,
0.0819092393,
-0.724347651,
0.3918895423,
0.3494893909,
0.096174784,
0.5062497258,
0.1482558846,
0.2306475341,
-0.0223915447,
-0.6211054921,
-0.8589878678,
1.240170598,
0.6143710017,
0.8310841322,
-0.1337095201,
0.2174073011,
0.1962362677,
0.7244630456,
-0.7674996853,
0.6343403459,
0.0677752346,
-0.7216992974,
-0.3421835899,
-0.5753344893,
-0.7816590071,
0.7966404557,
-0.084431693,
-0.5868964791,
-0.006210912,
0.0864795744,
-0.3189225495,
0.4316951632,
-0.9088647366,
0.4877216816,
-0.3143453896,
-0.5695582032,
-0.4037235379,
-0.8495576978,
0.4901331961,
-0.206301257,
0.2070904374,
-0.3098873496,
-0.0770213827,
0.8687263727,
-0.3773198426,
0.8863140941,
-0.208670795,
0.0168073438,
0.4363330007,
0.0273073018,
0.3291988969,
0.4490368962,
0.2650524974,
0.3111248314,
0.1801567972,
-0.2187054157,
-0.4361922741,
0.5908856988,
-1.0537381172,
-1.0138164759,
-0.9515764117,
-0.3524830639,
-0.360822618,
-0.0515603162,
0.1000290141,
0.0300981607,
-0.1777017713,
0.0951897427,
0.3808887005,
-0.2869322002,
0.0362179987,
0.6083237529,
-0.1167628691,
-0.4448832273,
0.3513081968,
-0.253108561,
0.3128221333,
0.0955755636,
0.4376733005,
-0.3539506197,
-0.4491216838,
-0.3601077199,
0.5667614937,
-0.2799599171,
-0.0582042523,
-0.967921257,
-0.1449472755,
-0.2458644062,
0.268799752,
-0.2817772329,
-0.413043797,
0.1853894889,
0.0160078909,
0.2657837868,
1.0304816961,
0.0876941085,
-0.0776912048,
-0.6781095266,
0.1901328117,
0.3199527562,
0.5044164062,
-0.1478173882,
-0.3301644623,
0.1656282991,
0.0624250546,
-0.4038766325,
-0.8533185124,
0.0860133469,
-0.0696256235,
0.3632079661,
0.2107181996,
-0.2828526199,
0.7413951159,
-0.5085428357,
0.9728887081,
0.2598890662,
-0.6324236989,
0.1424928755,
-0.5425742269,
0.2647539079,
0.4356177151,
0.4803413749,
-0.9452260733,
-0.1718231887,
-0.408011049,
-0.7369994521,
0.6968771219,
0.238638863,
-0.0650059804,
0.3285881281,
0.0866883025,
0.2688470185,
0.3806454539,
-0.9353275299,
0.3997853398,
-0.3638992608,
0.3656533659,
-0.273594439,
-0.2611981928,
-0.3018451333,
-0.0687621161,
0.4906903803,
-0.1434252411,
0.5006639957,
0.5850865245,
0.1474680007,
-0.1720740497,
0.6328642368,
0.7022851706,
0.6925603151,
-0.4303929508,
0.0988199487,
-0.0304300059,
-0.8525686264,
0.0837790295,
0.1040610448,
-0.0911605135,
-0.1930032969,
0.4467613101,
0.4540948868,
0.0010440927,
-0.5413877964,
0.3553200066,
-0.1621847749,
-0.464311868,
-0.0057539875,
-0.1492174417,
0.0231105052,
0.0659438744,
0.3539175689,
0.4192085266,
0.1907978803,
-0.3941989541,
-0.1665419489,
0.5597635508,
-0.1972221136,
-0.7776500583,
0.6278145909,
0.4294914305,
-0.0562761314,
0.4561243653,
0.0123518966,
-0.6123651266,
0.4557069242,
0.2469720691,
0.9835736156,
-0.0878639743,
0.2857650816,
0.3050224781,
0.3739450574,
-0.1379830986,
0.1355946213,
-0.1864856482,
-0.5514181852,
-0.6209862232,
-0.5452395082,
-0.7774684429,
0.1223233342,
-0.2154510766,
0.1041817293,
-0.2964291573,
-0.3587994874,
0.135962531,
0.2941869795,
-0.4602413177,
-0.3129630089,
0.0591651872,
0.9673003554,
-0.7183772326,
0.6094008088,
0.8534997106,
-0.2949030995,
-0.6399902701,
-0.0561452731,
0.3846413195,
-0.3524538279,
0.3793034554,
0.0115116034,
-0.2381820977,
-0.4836696684,
-0.5151926875,
-0.9580796957,
1.0023179054,
0.0867155716,
-0.6520936489,
-0.0304693189,
-0.2133048326,
1.0664002895,
0.0843987986,
0.6085855961,
0.2967539132,
0.5148798823,
0.1000336111,
-1.3630206585,
-0.0886048079,
-0.3788293898,
-0.1269857734,
0.1263487041,
-1.172891736,
0.7346948981,
-0.2605322897,
-0.3554935157,
-0.1082677096,
0.2962462008,
0.5628719926,
0.4107649922,
0.4069027901,
0.0020668425,
0.5875915289,
-0.030456068,
1.2643370628,
-0.1077082679,
0.4404669702,
0.7287008166,
-0.8329076171,
0.7157959342,
0.5945429802,
-0.9401441216,
0.28664729,
0.8495863676,
-0.1172127053,
0.2413153499,
0.3555086255,
-0.3192466795,
0.0795858651,
0.0657098889,
-0.5235480666,
0.1268000007,
0.2477820069,
0.1628049612,
-0.1872594208,
-0.2657681704,
0.3218737841,
0.0203495063,
-0.1431577504,
0.6540593505,
0.2628872097,
-0.9160643816,
0.2834349871,
0.0394707583,
0.6951829195,
-0.7885591984,
0.1018195301,
-0.1387639642,
-0.0683331639,
-0.4271873236,
-0.9933209419,
0.1787904203,
0.3988675475,
-0.1151066944,
-0.3153594434,
0.6969692111,
-0.0988714397,
-0.2572002113,
0.1942497939,
0.5261082649,
0.394356221,
-0.1798671633,
-0.6664763093,
-0.1590132415,
-0.0243708566,
-0.698164165,
0.2893486917,
-0.0663008541,
-0.4758010209,
0.655705452,
0.9464515448,
0.2893974185,
-0.0861474872,
0.1187691316,
0.9218173027,
-0.7034922242,
-0.3610343039,
-0.8611568213,
0.065094091,
-0.1466059983,
-0.145293802,
0.7888305187,
0.5573726296,
0.6552971601,
-0.2717508674,
0.9898811579,
-0.2613076866,
0.5721452236,
-0.2944152653,
0.6836047769,
-0.0122717135,
0.1866738945,
-0.5061426759,
-1.1936445236,
-0.4383857846,
0.4293756485,
-0.4640635848,
0.4712435901,
1.0959830284,
0.6485708952,
0.0205511246,
0.2711141706,
0.0675002113,
0.3107492626,
0.5003846884,
0.6303061843,
1.2809348106,
0.0021093364,
0.3243112266,
0.1631322354,
-0.4223256707,
-0.0180997383,
-0.8890373707,
-0.9856792092,
-0.3440066278,
-0.1971563846,
-0.4204833806,
-0.1730604768,
0.9971042871,
0.8076412678,
-0.7893929482,
-0.2409034669,
0.154364109,
-0.1098484099,
0.01662408,
-0.2191833854,
0.5794523358,
0.0102651864,
-0.5093333125,
0.3175306618,
0.5172752738,
-0.1435270905,
-0.4642182291,
-0.0594547503,
0.1696173102,
0.0481242351,
0.5455351472,
0.3351480663,
-0.9881514907,
-0.3008101881,
0.0013754477,
-0.1793742031,
-0.0236798245,
1.0770161152,
-0.7356446981,
0.5414640903,
0.6285355091,
0.3712842464,
0.5960838795,
0.157323122,
0.5265691876,
-0.1791438907,
-0.0065905154,
0.4366270602,
0.2493448853,
0.4228618741,
-0.3197413683,
0.7792893052,
0.451438874,
-1.0611679554,
-0.8712915778,
0.0261507295,
-1.178450942,
0.0246883668,
1.2860386372,
0.0610702895,
-0.030265769,
-0.2540766597,
-0.5892382264,
-0.3854088485,
-0.5566884875,
1.0741918087,
0.9289001822,
-0.4214543402,
0.1777235121,
-0.8989059925,
0.497482866,
0.267206192,
-0.7794632316,
-0.0426919758,
0.4356899858,
0.4517433643,
0.1673926115,
0.8824000359,
-0.589705348,
0.4940351546,
-0.3131275475,
0.2360757589,
-0.0749524459,
0.0057963845,
-0.4146724939,
0.1023411602,
0.088339597,
0.4511525035
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03140v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03140v1
|
FlexModel: A Framework for Interpretability of Distributed Large Language Models
| 2023-12-05T21:19:33 | 2023-12-05T21:19:33 |
Matthew Choi, Muhammad Adil Asif, John Willes, David Emerson
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.DC
|
With the growth of large language models, now incorporating billions of
parameters, the hardware prerequisites for their training and deployment have
seen a corresponding increase. Although existing tools facilitate model
parallelization and distributed training, deeper model interactions, crucial
for interpretability and responsible AI techniques, still demand thorough
knowledge of distributed computing. This often hinders contributions from
researchers with machine learning expertise but limited distributed computing
background. Addressing this challenge, we present FlexModel, a software package
providing a streamlined interface for engaging with models distributed across
multi-GPU and multi-node configurations. The library is compatible with
existing model distribution libraries and encapsulates PyTorch models. It
exposes user-registerable HookFunctions to facilitate straightforward
interaction with distributed model internals, bridging the gap between
distributed and single-device model paradigms. Primarily, FlexModel enhances
accessibility by democratizing model interactions and promotes more inclusive
research in the domain of large-scale neural networks. The package is found at
https://github.com/VectorInstitute/flex_model.
|
[
-0.1595619321,
-0.7049350142,
0.5610018969,
0.3583934903,
-0.0517493039,
-0.1712249964,
-0.2341441959,
-0.363773644,
-0.1385798156,
0.2797011435,
-0.6586257815,
-0.29396981,
-0.412267983,
-0.1587491333,
-0.6272743344,
0.7859120369,
-0.1822605133,
-0.0751817524,
-0.4881808758,
-0.2797004879,
-0.1901360005,
-0.1785157919,
0.0252735093,
-0.7548268437,
0.6876305342,
0.1802612394,
1.2427300215,
0.6143730283,
0.3387589455,
0.3998703957,
-0.0330842845,
-0.1546784192,
-0.3716478646,
0.1611623019,
-0.1494225711,
-0.3713831306,
-0.6925734878,
0.0540474392,
0.891102016,
0.9387250543,
-0.3758167624,
0.2597267926,
0.0256569088,
0.114784658,
-0.4840063453,
0.2306475192,
-0.2333298177,
-0.2297786176,
-0.1594402343,
-0.0224600378,
-0.6746371984,
-0.2574603856,
0.1296152174,
-0.6891316772,
0.3063492477,
-0.2568821609,
0.5663463473,
0.059998136,
-0.4243273139,
0.1586636156,
-0.7064749002,
0.4318823814,
-0.5631736517,
0.460090518,
-0.0165297184,
0.7447744012,
-0.2631061077,
-1.1236339808,
-0.5913297534,
0.0062839976,
-0.0903114453,
-0.23978284,
0.0237075873,
0.2411219776,
0.1574367583,
0.3483830988,
-0.5070505142,
0.198338151,
-0.0327105336,
0.1061157435,
0.4898257852,
0.2116772681,
0.6195245385,
0.2277803123,
-0.2175503224,
-0.2107223272,
-0.6991642714,
-0.2428993434,
0.674213171,
0.4994678199,
-0.3187688291,
0.5984678268,
0.0507109836,
0.8131283522,
-0.5631095767,
0.0638278276,
0.2291755974,
0.0967988744,
-0.5340440273,
-0.3508740962,
0.5461762547,
-0.0964795128,
-0.0708219707,
-0.0762135759,
-0.2704937756,
-0.2446526885,
0.1243664548,
-0.8708269,
-0.3564154506,
0.3063775897,
-0.6718725562,
0.0042690518,
0.0975023285,
-0.7274816036,
-0.801494956,
-0.5587681532,
0.3558866978,
-0.079146415,
-1.0369720459,
0.2292906195,
-0.4022412896,
0.0426180065,
0.4822889566,
-0.883826375,
0.443919003,
1.0522990227,
0.9516257048,
-0.0698063076,
-0.5604581237,
-0.266291827,
-0.1292382628,
0.2319338173,
0.3253011107,
-0.5918490887,
-0.2105220258,
0.000995093,
0.0419822633,
-0.4611417055,
-0.1840312034,
0.2315172255,
-0.4924815595,
-0.1365068257,
0.1991512626,
-0.7633209229,
-0.2886933088,
-0.0074446523,
-0.6422364116,
0.669064045,
0.286577493,
-0.9695028067,
0.0376945212,
-0.660038352,
-0.3469697237,
0.3942887187,
-0.2217434198,
-0.3322341442,
0.2819293439,
-0.1875610948,
0.5690630078,
-0.3112547696,
0.3924598992,
-0.8455535769,
-0.4604469538,
0.3149623275,
-0.7138692141,
0.9983330965,
0.2499338984,
-0.3504554629,
0.6481379867,
-0.6365297437,
0.0501037687,
0.0456340238,
-0.2808597386,
0.0359153189,
-0.046056781,
0.6677689552,
-0.0138347,
0.0569894016,
-0.3585877717,
0.3568276763,
-0.1962781847,
0.6935967207,
0.7777867317,
-0.8037217259,
0.3792717755,
0.1431632489,
0.7032676339,
-0.2676382661,
0.4443584383,
-0.3830603659,
-0.491877377,
-0.2236570865,
-0.8588553667,
0.129120186,
0.0906958655,
-0.6129565239,
-0.0546809696,
-0.4325915277,
-0.4227353334,
-0.4339665771,
0.023145996,
-0.0723311454,
0.2455009371,
0.1450874656,
0.3082632422,
-0.363465488,
-0.7299494147,
-0.0865155533,
-0.0796047747,
-0.240081057,
0.4477722347,
0.4548015296,
-0.7247480154,
0.9410012364,
-0.4944448471,
0.2424248308,
-0.5466222167,
0.2333679944,
0.2772579789,
0.3345097601,
0.2582330108,
-0.8996663094,
-0.2316107452,
0.3982636333,
-0.4700536728,
0.0258443374,
0.1363090128,
0.0525979288,
-0.0273321532,
0.3244878352,
-0.815487802,
0.3237204552,
0.9163845778,
-0.4645760059,
0.6489949226,
-0.5457566977,
-0.1948006302,
-0.9320266843,
0.5839990973,
-0.1576951295,
-0.5008384585,
-0.5276507139,
0.4192636907,
0.1549099237,
-0.2925329804,
-0.4748779535,
0.7486505508,
-0.2053604126,
-0.4541536868,
-0.4385426044,
-0.1051595956,
0.1563748568,
-0.1450818181,
0.0775872394,
0.711583972,
0.7106251717,
-0.246899277,
0.4688944817,
0.1158542484,
-0.3047564924,
0.2123194188,
-0.9099669456,
-0.0750005767,
-0.1153740957,
0.2420373708,
-0.7947426438,
-0.6862974763,
0.0024732703,
-0.2156881839,
0.1857252568,
-0.238907963,
-0.5393716693,
-0.3450503945,
0.199217543,
0.6427634358,
0.3369558752,
-0.9818578362,
1.1058996916,
0.4927800596,
0.1238132417,
-0.581061244,
-0.4803724587,
-0.2673966587,
-0.0753489435,
-0.8301686049,
-0.0165502932,
0.0168876648,
-0.1445408016,
0.0013067202,
0.152046591,
-0.4452342689,
0.4780577421,
0.4601728916,
0.2349133193,
-0.3849951923,
0.3100122511,
-0.1595937014,
0.024158746,
-0.2343511432,
-0.2279916257,
0.4709076583,
-0.3829044998,
-0.3224622905,
-0.4023869932,
0.2071112394,
1.0357937813,
-0.1990811825,
0.9734572768,
0.732385993,
-0.2404977232,
-0.6389326453,
-0.0579821095,
-0.1385294944,
-0.5168274045,
0.3436835408,
-0.5435367823,
-0.7977843881,
0.6230487823,
-0.3781971335,
0.110819079,
0.294657141,
0.7690401673,
0.0290092174,
1.1835489273,
1.016109705,
0.1185814962,
0.5654242635,
0.033798553,
0.1117118225,
-0.4449198246,
-0.1641990393,
-0.4241681099,
-0.2417387962,
-0.4289793968,
-0.4731534421,
0.1091850549,
-0.0459197201,
-0.3387070596,
0.2954001427,
-0.5891604424,
0.5511305332,
0.3222745657,
0.0172826145,
0.0843641385,
-0.2436091751,
-0.3001700342,
0.395616889,
-0.8952248096,
-0.1793733835,
0.7295937538,
0.9216820598,
0.9650737643,
0.1356267184,
0.3444619775,
-0.0313875414,
0.5713170171,
-0.759010613,
0.3682151735,
-0.0075118463,
-0.697619915,
-0.1931720078,
-0.8034996986,
-0.9644095898,
0.4244422615,
-0.1191673204,
-0.793469727,
0.2523206174,
0.2087417096,
-0.1653364003,
0.3159572482,
-0.9427445531,
1.3262203932,
-0.0113993138,
-0.2878158092,
-0.4764823616,
-0.4437094033,
0.5582287312,
0.3108168542,
0.3255902529,
-0.3648283482,
0.2420183867,
0.1441608965,
-0.3922358155,
0.8149584532,
-0.2776648402,
0.2396043092,
0.0412222706,
0.1344513446,
0.2959736884,
0.1015437171,
-0.2063862383,
0.0676120594,
0.3445180357,
-0.2115499675,
-0.50158149,
0.7607056499,
-1.0088069439,
-0.2242931724,
-0.2757178247,
-1.1566812992,
0.2483050376,
0.2611260116,
-0.2275706977,
0.5937559009,
-0.2823012471,
0.2031616867,
0.4910963774,
-0.5077780485,
0.3784309328,
0.2059991956,
-0.4667083323,
-0.1108138338,
0.8346476555,
-0.1928152144,
0.1455165744,
0.067429997,
0.3739801347,
-0.4556151032,
-0.2947797775,
-0.4230706394,
0.1516302824,
-0.8686250448,
0.0752429962,
-0.4048180878,
-0.1094631553,
-0.1839960515,
-0.0236358289,
-0.5949968696,
-0.5262669325,
-0.4331641495,
-0.0658529401,
0.470564276,
0.8493009806,
0.2290025055,
0.6704244018,
-0.6269443035,
0.1763568223,
0.0735366791,
0.9028303027,
0.1172292456,
-0.2983758152,
-0.3846975565,
-0.2130082697,
0.0193558764,
-0.6308180094,
0.2775306106,
0.1941039115,
0.5976875424,
0.3541286886,
-0.0465536453,
0.4774318039,
-0.412209481,
0.3093145788,
0.2778938413,
-1.077988863,
0.1977818906,
-0.5346600413,
0.4470444918,
0.2824353278,
0.299983114,
-0.4713709354,
-0.1596339643,
-0.5634638667,
-0.80249089,
0.6917040348,
-0.1544525474,
0.2670404017,
0.3329550624,
0.3593080044,
0.3855415881,
0.2304014266,
-0.6968505979,
-0.0904573202,
-0.3669313788,
-0.5662065744,
-0.0414489992,
0.0052324822,
-0.2053815126,
-0.4653172195,
0.4160087407,
-0.523419857,
0.094743453,
-0.1845683157,
-0.3173719049,
0.1127020568,
0.0579417758,
0.4153814912,
1.0602492094,
-0.1694295853,
0.3884991705,
-0.5722595453,
-0.3758584559,
-0.0808823705,
0.4946351647,
-0.2085151225,
-0.1027786806,
0.2817119658,
1.0430406332,
0.0754482895,
-0.7628339529,
0.4162876904,
-0.3803819418,
0.0237455945,
0.2225352824,
0.0933794454,
0.3975027502,
0.4257015586,
0.0061563924,
0.0090741506,
0.1646735519,
-0.6005920768,
0.3477522731,
0.3138318062,
-0.1944213957,
-0.4713704586,
0.8011377454,
0.2446161062,
-0.0683822855,
0.844509244,
0.2051270902,
-0.3422295153,
0.4964742959,
0.4764735699,
0.8521618247,
-0.2563262284,
0.5631000996,
0.2146580815,
0.0150151569,
-0.4506004155,
0.0683194622,
-0.0554602481,
-0.5947977901,
-0.4365678728,
-0.6031499505,
-0.5815565586,
-0.315569371,
-0.3785297871,
0.2866215408,
-0.4503667355,
-0.2053440809,
0.1803756356,
-0.343924731,
-0.689879477,
-0.0980059877,
0.2920967638,
0.8701258898,
-0.9468638897,
1.2366421223,
0.6429755688,
-0.2018788159,
-0.9327489734,
-0.3445052207,
0.0551168136,
-0.5490069985,
0.4304073453,
0.3820043802,
0.0315210335,
-0.0327550173,
-0.2670310736,
-0.4334203303,
1.0210177898,
0.8793887496,
-0.3373990059,
0.3261237144,
0.2622251511,
0.4546889663,
-0.2735041082,
0.8222852945,
0.6664069295,
0.3135336936,
0.3481272757,
-1.0919438601,
0.0355986878,
-0.1344684809,
-0.1436941475,
0.0438285396,
-0.2524402142,
1.228136301,
-0.0730818063,
-0.148795262,
-0.1386598796,
0.4157741964,
0.1509666741,
0.1672127992,
0.3250809312,
0.1821415424,
1.0376275778,
0.0284761935,
1.327911973,
-0.0278676897,
0.6027533412,
1.2064055204,
-0.2651514411,
0.8999896646,
0.3089607954,
-0.0787488893,
0.2299938798,
0.5019850135,
0.0709794164,
0.1415110081,
0.2489527017,
-0.4358970225,
-0.2721424997,
0.0085070236,
-0.110794276,
0.2601110339,
0.2890951633,
-0.2259307057,
-0.3293770254,
0.2125506699,
-0.2804715037,
-0.0485843867,
-0.4106709063,
0.3060043752,
0.3134098351,
-0.2287417501,
0.3819974363,
0.0358763784,
0.2796760499,
-0.4756552577,
0.0149106495,
0.036859408,
0.7656759024,
-0.4407635033,
-0.8672482967,
0.5081409812,
-0.2502937913,
-0.2581017911,
-0.2849712968,
0.8128714561,
-0.349805057,
-0.5355641842,
0.413048178,
0.5342901349,
0.0075131664,
-0.1112477034,
-0.746811986,
0.5204571486,
-0.5118812919,
-0.3351390958,
0.3571634293,
0.3063858449,
0.0607115068,
1.1217278242,
0.3828349113,
-0.2602643967,
0.1515857726,
0.3802555501,
0.8717558384,
-0.1634001285,
-0.4929873645,
-0.8014178872,
0.6874879003,
0.1590535492,
-0.0199452322,
0.7056615353,
0.3001865447,
0.3794874847,
-0.0018928266,
0.5504687428,
-0.1511680186,
0.1512529999,
0.0904936716,
0.958224535,
-0.6126372218,
0.2303550243,
0.047785338,
-0.7811384797,
-0.5447912216,
0.5135809183,
-0.3470615447,
-0.151935339,
0.3562698364,
0.6118361354,
-0.5839834213,
0.1573840827,
0.2821477652,
0.3042351604,
0.3502276838,
0.0504849069,
0.7926387191,
-0.033895772,
0.3092510998,
0.2044735402,
-0.2797073126,
-0.2792628706,
-0.9036266208,
-0.9570231438,
-0.3520685136,
-0.3513038754,
-0.2801591158,
-0.1191883087,
1.0150111914,
0.9251779318,
-0.6162035465,
-0.4760617316,
-0.3445909023,
0.5477546453,
-0.3282346427,
-0.1653283089,
0.3434625268,
-0.2078955323,
-0.6070607901,
0.2988344133,
0.0707065687,
-0.0741902664,
-0.3767923117,
-0.2297857851,
0.0634917766,
-0.0192592759,
0.3937063813,
0.3994511664,
-0.4365822077,
-0.1057737619,
-0.0451054201,
0.0540697463,
-0.0221893806,
0.9513959289,
-0.5984783173,
0.6799843907,
0.8024675846,
0.8707405925,
0.5741248131,
-0.2772940099,
0.9935665727,
-0.6594244838,
0.471309185,
0.144613117,
0.429226011,
0.3528886139,
-0.2737230062,
0.1733656228,
0.1531628519,
-0.6180176139,
-1.145849824,
0.1701925695,
-0.7155808806,
-0.5864860415,
0.9883018732,
-0.5920852423,
-0.4209378362,
-0.0330731533,
0.0637265369,
0.2652523518,
0.1211880371,
0.3751752377,
0.4657199979,
0.0886283666,
-0.5329749584,
-0.8399478793,
0.2690994442,
0.0474371687,
-0.7143449187,
0.6055889726,
0.4494819641,
0.3733180165,
-0.3938495517,
0.4015561044,
0.0511133559,
0.2850272655,
0.2395320237,
0.3352118134,
-0.314132452,
-0.5041242242,
-0.560159862,
0.2837548256,
0.1812716126,
0.0470725931
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03122v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03122v3
|
Assertion Enhanced Few-Shot Learning: Instructive Technique for Large Language Models to Generate Educational Explanations
| 2023-12-05T20:41:34 | 2024-01-20T15:02:20 |
Tasmia Shahriar, Kelly Ramos, Noboru Matsuda
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Human educators possess an intrinsic ability to anticipate and seek
educational explanations from students, which drives them to pose
thought-provoking questions when students cannot articulate these explanations
independently. We aim to imbue Intelligent Tutoring Systems with this ability
using few-shot learning capability of Large Language Models. Our work proposes
a novel prompting technique, Assertion Enhanced Few-Shot Learning, to
facilitate the generation of accurate, detailed oriented educational
explanations. Our central hypothesis is that, in educational domain, few-shot
demonstrations are necessary but not a sufficient condition for quality
explanation generation. We conducted a study involving 12 in-service teachers,
comparing our approach to Traditional Few-Shot Learning. The results show that
Assertion Enhanced Few-Shot Learning improves explanation accuracy by 15% and
yields higher-quality explanations, as evaluated by teachers. We also conduct a
qualitative ablation study to factor the impact of assertions to provide
educator-friendly prompting guidelines for generating explanations in their
domain of interest.
|
[
-0.2523980439,
-1.1404464245,
0.4837811589,
-0.1447704136,
-0.1426852494,
-0.1090646535,
-0.2027737498,
-0.2831968367,
-0.2219260037,
0.0068823821,
-0.6566255689,
-0.318827033,
-0.461733669,
0.0819496438,
-0.4258008599,
0.5827316642,
0.1155440658,
0.3205448389,
-0.325117141,
0.4467863142,
-0.4471593201,
0.2961550355,
-0.683922112,
-0.5408147573,
0.4145636559,
1.0966564417,
0.4277336597,
0.5325958133,
0.3753992617,
0.2551510334,
0.1339033395,
0.3120799661,
-0.3493400216,
-0.0941989049,
-0.1588281393,
-0.7021992207,
-0.1060708016,
-0.1928700805,
0.7604366541,
0.7917436957,
0.1435103863,
0.2094510645,
0.3133090734,
0.5391498208,
-0.8563759923,
-0.1221663281,
-0.4959182441,
0.1957971454,
-0.0791987255,
-0.1174485013,
-0.5119185448,
-0.5337306857,
0.2843052447,
-0.4665112495,
0.191580385,
-0.2448588461,
0.7139978409,
0.0661333874,
-0.2490519136,
-0.0090976199,
-0.7449684143,
0.7361911535,
-0.6033554673,
0.1582876742,
0.3982473314,
0.622772634,
-0.0739105046,
-0.6354793906,
-0.6785709858,
0.1134716347,
0.0012629224,
0.3847788572,
-0.0872326717,
0.0656044334,
0.4082820415,
-0.0221666694,
-0.6010813713,
0.3737689555,
-0.3856687546,
-0.2839499712,
0.4833996892,
0.131095469,
0.0270031076,
-0.1237827688,
-0.5207546353,
0.0771623105,
-1.0375519991,
0.3709047139,
0.4104543328,
0.3441560566,
-0.2640585899,
0.6369170547,
-0.2241564393,
0.7207235098,
0.1271696538,
-0.3235010207,
-0.3650988638,
-0.1071820259,
-0.089930132,
0.2925490141,
0.5507466793,
0.2304885238,
0.2113303989,
0.2050605118,
-0.0881199837,
0.128343299,
-0.1773457825,
-1.05676651,
-0.1444178522,
0.2990923524,
-0.3632211387,
-0.3043039441,
0.0939705819,
-1.3021372557,
-0.3870269954,
-0.0711027458,
0.6495651007,
-0.6903423071,
-0.2198545337,
-0.1104958206,
-0.2734671831,
0.3420031071,
0.4003019631,
-1.1068599224,
0.1191688254,
0.5919783115,
0.7469617724,
-0.0941368043,
-0.3644088805,
-0.4894079268,
0.1050585881,
-0.3997657895,
1.1148008108,
-0.8254647255,
-0.4675221145,
0.1552008986,
-0.4135766029,
0.1710385084,
-0.5167434216,
0.1544146538,
-0.2469402105,
0.2933522463,
-0.1743928045,
-0.8205872774,
-0.2722572386,
0.3157529831,
0.0793763474,
0.8281679153,
0.1132529974,
-0.3230020404,
0.4546860754,
-0.7970380783,
-0.2401021719,
0.3453061283,
-0.30308792,
-0.3634636104,
-0.0382546932,
0.4318520725,
0.4742221534,
-0.1949589849,
0.0476836711,
-0.0342568383,
-0.5949604511,
0.385666132,
-0.6521056294,
0.9028411508,
0.1420260817,
-0.4617658257,
-0.1008903682,
-0.5070740581,
0.2552447021,
0.3291656971,
-0.0701030716,
-0.0213308856,
-0.3236976266,
-0.5556535721,
-0.2456931472,
0.2361695617,
-0.4325564206,
0.2724553049,
-0.624257803,
-0.0631854907,
0.6357988715,
0.4205744565,
0.4306530356,
-0.3139591217,
0.9115729928,
0.0291517973,
0.1603616178,
-0.743180871,
-0.3883124292,
-0.5207759738,
-0.3400068283,
0.1920068562,
0.3314773142,
-0.7545239329,
0.0159620717,
-0.0630061999,
-0.3208727241,
-0.5129756927,
0.2553525567,
0.5650429726,
0.8940058947,
0.252002418,
0.0373649336,
-0.5939939022,
-0.6092768312,
-0.2683258653,
-0.090247266,
-0.0207052827,
0.0926519483,
0.6784233451,
0.0499206297,
1.2505965233,
-0.4193790853,
0.059208855,
-0.4195418954,
0.2052165121,
-0.0799442828,
0.3638551831,
0.7949970961,
-0.4663332701,
-0.6872426867,
-0.3127520084,
-0.6327825189,
-0.0128051983,
-0.3505553007,
-0.1250065863,
-0.0501008444,
0.1077622101,
-0.4643648863,
0.3451241255,
0.0397109203,
-0.1067116186,
0.8490965366,
0.1249669492,
0.0533387549,
-0.5923276544,
-0.4005720019,
0.061299257,
-0.232684195,
-0.3473467231,
0.1224782839,
-0.1002740115,
-0.1689088494,
-0.5761714578,
0.5736607313,
-0.1460707039,
0.1592467278,
-0.462466836,
0.555760026,
0.1282806695,
0.1968109906,
-0.1215146929,
0.7765243053,
1.1329895258,
-0.7207614779,
0.389393419,
0.3345521986,
-0.2715886235,
0.7974655628,
-0.6032383442,
0.094283171,
-0.1203836948,
0.1635945439,
-1.0609112978,
-0.5743677616,
0.1573216617,
-0.5326789021,
0.2766360044,
-0.4446448982,
-0.311313808,
-0.5048482418,
-0.3979153037,
-0.1074016094,
0.6310972571,
-1.026782155,
0.2622496486,
-0.2451431453,
-0.0991174355,
-0.6901315451,
-0.6650802493,
-0.2166947722,
-0.3616669774,
-0.428966552,
0.1044223085,
-0.0441323742,
-0.3493165076,
0.02381544,
-0.2819920778,
-0.2607786357,
0.3505173028,
0.1748225242,
0.5155726671,
-0.6157265902,
0.3145550489,
0.479121089,
-0.2494055033,
0.1271339059,
-0.0787795112,
0.30765149,
-0.0782564953,
-0.5735732913,
-0.8635938168,
0.4097165465,
0.0247783437,
-0.14348571,
0.7975435257,
0.686681509,
-0.4117235541,
-0.4286759794,
-0.2641412318,
-0.9126105905,
-0.4931277037,
0.1830472052,
-0.2967328131,
-0.4770342708,
0.1351066381,
-0.5200178623,
0.1639049202,
0.3150030077,
0.405897826,
-0.2553728819,
1.2637308836,
0.5039172173,
0.2155506164,
0.6325209141,
-0.5237916112,
0.1783615351,
-0.3618076146,
-0.1155428216,
-0.5836216211,
-0.254332751,
-0.1861643493,
0.0236704163,
0.4023713768,
0.2786020041,
-0.4094435573,
-0.2791401148,
-0.4837023616,
1.0026997328,
0.4022552967,
0.1310672462,
0.228467986,
0.1205947697,
-0.1270343661,
-0.0497771762,
-0.7113887072,
-0.7624812126,
0.8761640191,
0.1440813988,
0.7276072502,
0.23949489,
1.0608154535,
-0.1096078902,
0.3253455162,
-1.2354938984,
0.5378112197,
0.206186384,
-0.8113737106,
-0.5111861825,
-0.121722877,
-0.8391165137,
0.363940388,
-0.5509178638,
-0.955078125,
-0.1138055548,
0.3564032316,
-0.9407966137,
-0.0293109305,
-0.9703923464,
0.6947259903,
-0.3254168928,
-0.4544912577,
-0.4154950976,
-0.5148797035,
0.4747694731,
0.1142513976,
-0.1974198818,
0.1848630309,
0.0961637422,
0.6627264619,
-0.4295629561,
1.1756659746,
-0.5791042447,
0.0892915949,
0.7422392368,
0.1589163691,
0.5539790988,
-0.1234002635,
-0.3442944288,
-0.3608690202,
-0.1561601013,
-0.4604513943,
-0.8450431824,
0.3833109438,
-0.5817247629,
-0.7927260995,
0.0485975556,
-0.1755995154,
-0.1828885078,
0.2544489801,
0.4213012755,
0.6082606912,
-0.0244100131,
0.1186563447,
0.7131957412,
-0.016797293,
0.5064166188,
0.5263206363,
-0.0787223354,
0.1351914704,
0.9090030789,
0.1511580348,
0.2732721567,
0.2078797668,
0.7973034382,
-0.289832443,
-0.7735164762,
-0.3957824409,
0.162629053,
-0.9054372311,
-0.3979594409,
-0.2462793887,
0.1413320005,
-0.4932526648,
-0.6954385638,
-0.3232865632,
-0.4821772277,
-0.2428303063,
-0.34644261,
0.422778219,
0.7292596698,
-0.0982804522,
0.7959942222,
-0.7846382856,
0.3205415905,
0.5674961209,
0.0369800404,
0.196489498,
-0.7948282361,
-0.3504451513,
0.2554549873,
-0.6759443879,
-0.9555499554,
0.2222692668,
0.4893926084,
0.5053653717,
1.1362893581,
0.102368027,
0.9942064285,
-0.3075557351,
1.1165617704,
0.264459461,
-0.9942737222,
0.8707228899,
-0.0092633953,
0.2177227437,
0.2441875488,
0.545887053,
-0.1628300995,
-0.3379375935,
-0.7352845073,
-0.523188591,
0.6284316778,
-0.3833101988,
0.2783150077,
-0.0241395887,
0.4186806381,
0.5289331675,
-0.1406460404,
-0.4328944385,
-0.4283791184,
-0.1821044683,
-0.3371299505,
0.310364902,
-0.4034494162,
-0.4285838008,
-0.2173735797,
0.7703556418,
-0.4499615729,
0.2816231251,
0.0833293721,
-0.218616575,
-0.3546911478,
0.5264971852,
0.7099914551,
0.8664684892,
0.2398124486,
0.3744250834,
0.2831659913,
-0.2064591795,
0.0291552469,
-0.1162836105,
-0.0493969098,
0.0193149541,
0.5459594131,
0.6203725934,
0.0463976525,
-0.532269299,
0.7150533199,
0.2497113943,
-0.0619948171,
-0.2242806852,
0.3573504388,
-0.0731240436,
0.4724116027,
0.5213332176,
-0.1921061575,
0.0415251851,
-0.4004449844,
0.0434031524,
0.529163003,
-0.2574374676,
-0.3943294287,
0.5047910213,
0.1772288978,
-0.2278671563,
0.5692569613,
-0.172248587,
-0.3820664287,
0.6516822577,
0.9462304711,
0.663243711,
-0.2828269303,
0.7000949979,
0.472802788,
0.0508474968,
-0.0570968874,
0.2104140669,
-0.3352452219,
-0.8159621358,
-0.4754153192,
0.0490472429,
-0.7938314676,
-0.2001084387,
-0.6322891712,
0.3215767741,
-0.442871511,
0.1224046946,
0.3202806413,
0.0139751546,
-0.5468065143,
0.0886033028,
0.1451702267,
0.7523178458,
-1.0530531406,
0.4831768572,
0.6222298145,
-0.4879579246,
-0.9189630151,
0.0615009107,
0.3346841037,
-0.8242830634,
0.8085507154,
0.192083478,
-0.4019258618,
0.2506289482,
-1.1430535316,
-0.3506685495,
0.9314746857,
0.6783901453,
-0.3964448571,
0.2475776374,
-0.0802796632,
0.4792443514,
-0.4254559577,
0.4875592589,
0.3973503709,
0.5518401265,
0.2116628736,
-0.332564503,
-0.0924909562,
0.2967651188,
-0.5096924305,
-0.125179708,
-0.4690586329,
0.289280951,
-0.7989853024,
-0.2496984452,
0.0912024677,
0.7401697636,
0.1534514576,
0.5203459859,
0.2420101911,
0.0311025307,
1.0105499029,
-0.2031747103,
1.1639988422,
0.156554997,
0.1734547168,
1.059235692,
0.0217973217,
0.7597670555,
0.5431082845,
-0.2386659086,
0.7045620084,
0.7069460154,
-0.0013170715,
0.3600120842,
-0.2983415425,
-0.5378565788,
-0.4427458942,
-0.3154187202,
-0.1321327835,
0.7855241299,
0.4929907322,
-0.1492953002,
-0.2558914721,
0.2633042336,
-0.1925120503,
0.1060055792,
-0.3990067542,
0.8443382978,
-0.0466649272,
-0.602299273,
0.705714643,
-0.368059516,
0.4837284088,
-0.3990856409,
-0.3254105151,
-0.1409468055,
-0.0508125275,
-0.4632762074,
-0.8025792837,
-0.115057461,
0.2520574331,
0.0103152273,
-0.304350853,
0.6930297017,
-0.4790924788,
-0.0282199048,
-0.3912499845,
0.5959380269,
0.4669903517,
0.3211266398,
-0.6979691982,
-0.5427886844,
-0.0578061305,
-0.2467397898,
0.1330288798,
0.4663827419,
0.1410074085,
0.6000053883,
0.2962036729,
0.0531797968,
0.0269378591,
0.2039832473,
0.5227951407,
-0.2404894978,
-0.2828708589,
-1.0450017452,
0.7584971786,
0.0652703643,
-0.0583170466,
0.7871819139,
0.4234547913,
0.6566828489,
-0.2633022666,
0.8300539255,
0.1159804761,
0.5821453333,
-0.5751248002,
0.235211283,
-0.2579658329,
0.1891567856,
-0.0009018056,
-0.7015596628,
-0.3207555115,
0.8200812936,
-0.3688758612,
-0.0856919289,
0.8805703521,
0.752695024,
0.1096164361,
0.1435166597,
0.4787697494,
0.0722399056,
0.2575545311,
0.1727605015,
1.0117120743,
-0.2245156467,
0.5305424929,
-0.4317602217,
-0.1861097813,
-0.3320528269,
-0.7653267384,
-0.9300513268,
-0.1787144244,
-0.6830413342,
-0.1268967688,
-0.1113047078,
1.171036005,
0.5832235217,
-0.7101878524,
0.1685646474,
-0.0385474712,
0.6865793467,
-0.4709767997,
-0.3062731624,
0.3372361958,
-0.2923349738,
-1.0618197918,
0.6512485147,
0.0615845285,
0.3865396976,
-0.3671012521,
0.0390310511,
0.1617511809,
0.1395086646,
0.6178531051,
0.4603262842,
-0.6064143181,
-0.526913166,
-0.0440805666,
0.0921290368,
0.118281506,
0.8124371171,
-0.862768352,
0.7166180611,
0.4174257219,
0.7286573052,
0.2843462825,
-0.0193575192,
0.2791222632,
-0.9471255541,
0.3118068874,
0.2490682602,
0.2420695424,
0.2774874568,
-0.4313072264,
0.2846532464,
0.0723854154,
-0.3168296218,
-0.8703805208,
0.3115645945,
-0.5966979265,
-0.1628981978,
0.9310595393,
-0.4908033013,
-0.0733366609,
-0.0116485981,
-0.2864328325,
0.3175520599,
-0.4482108355,
0.8619383574,
0.5575345755,
-0.4056883752,
-0.5095277429,
-0.3017611206,
0.1776390225,
0.4107309878,
-0.909838438,
-0.0780309364,
0.476107806,
0.0695691258,
0.0170226935,
0.1367453635,
0.048902031,
0.6315508485,
0.2610198557,
-0.1674914509,
-0.0766341686,
-0.4871473312,
-0.4792217016,
0.1448809803,
0.220904395,
-0.4031270146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03766v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03766v1
|
Mismatch Quest: Visual and Textual Feedback for Image-Text Misalignment
| 2023-12-05T20:07:34 | 2023-12-05T20:07:34 |
Brian Gordon, Yonatan Bitton, Yonatan Shafir, Roopal Garg, Xi Chen, Dani Lischinski, Daniel Cohen-Or, Idan Szpektor
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV
|
While existing image-text alignment models reach high quality binary
assessments, they fall short of pinpointing the exact source of misalignment.
In this paper, we present a method to provide detailed textual and visual
explanation of detected misalignments between text-image pairs. We leverage
large language models and visual grounding models to automatically construct a
training set that holds plausible misaligned captions for a given image and
corresponding textual explanations and visual indicators. We also publish a new
human curated test set comprising ground-truth textual and visual misalignment
annotations. Empirical results show that fine-tuning vision language models on
our training set enables them to articulate misalignments and visually indicate
them within images, outperforming strong baselines both on the binary alignment
classification and the explanation generation tasks. Our method code and human
curated test set are available at: https://mismatch-quest.github.io/
|
[
-0.2249564528,
-0.6542096138,
0.439704746,
-0.0106995348,
-0.382419318,
-0.0687016472,
0.2977220416,
-0.6168287396,
0.0004075111,
0.4555253983,
-0.885628283,
-0.4915899634,
-0.513543129,
0.1395933181,
-0.2446888238,
0.6552437544,
-0.3667254448,
0.3597511649,
-0.6377026439,
-0.4473805726,
-1.3384281397,
0.1028837264,
-0.2834925354,
-0.0860975012,
0.5334063768,
0.6532192826,
1.0823479891,
0.835067451,
1.0456920862,
0.2236007601,
0.2559770644,
0.3923155069,
-0.4121881127,
0.0090231374,
-0.5001254082,
-0.481558919,
0.1124055833,
0.0687848702,
0.3561126292,
0.5249077082,
0.1184832677,
0.0817075223,
-0.077555798,
0.6993491054,
-0.5623384714,
-0.196333766,
-0.3899778724,
0.1620817482,
-0.1586096287,
-0.3761534691,
-0.3195129633,
-0.2724590302,
0.201832965,
-0.8721382022,
0.6009953022,
0.5571208,
1.373426795,
0.8908102512,
-0.2332894802,
-0.0951374769,
-0.5219649673,
0.755830586,
-0.3800473511,
0.313221395,
0.4314909875,
0.4675879776,
0.0522363968,
-0.3181108534,
-0.6409288645,
0.2804115713,
-0.3930046558,
0.1985161453,
0.1893011481,
-0.1138153598,
0.2649591863,
0.3015292883,
-0.8408032656,
0.0222336259,
-0.2106735557,
-0.2586210072,
0.5255019069,
0.1980416626,
0.746814847,
-0.0880127028,
-0.4254835844,
-0.2972621024,
-0.5842970014,
-0.0326499678,
0.1175492182,
-0.016079843,
-0.2919047177,
0.909412384,
0.3802556992,
1.0293684006,
0.3234656155,
0.1524149179,
0.2174754292,
-0.5297082067,
-0.1405834705,
0.0509187169,
0.677670002,
1.1179628372,
0.2152177393,
-0.0402109623,
-0.2388565391,
0.3450199068,
0.4150808752,
-0.4874634147,
-0.2656805813,
-0.0013711917,
-0.63123101,
-0.5808941722,
-0.0191995669,
-0.7913991213,
-0.8337499499,
-0.360132128,
0.6272186041,
-0.4198144078,
0.087647453,
0.1561791003,
-0.7124354243,
0.358164221,
0.4354194701,
-0.7752898335,
-0.2169831842,
0.1548693627,
0.8159556389,
-0.1210059524,
-0.5322031975,
-0.6334540844,
0.071238786,
-0.3937904239,
1.0100765228,
-0.4515130818,
0.0792200044,
0.2509687245,
0.362238735,
-0.0563589856,
-0.4818121791,
0.5322935581,
-0.3754678071,
0.5603480935,
-0.4990485907,
-0.3532523513,
-0.1762625426,
0.5562511086,
-0.7996094227,
0.9904453754,
0.0182938538,
-1.1384929419,
0.5050516725,
-0.5434990525,
-0.0854635835,
0.2560992241,
-0.3546263874,
-0.4561369717,
-0.026083637,
0.5824200511,
0.2390278578,
-0.1374348551,
0.140877977,
-0.1643324792,
-0.777156949,
0.3684993982,
-0.1903922558,
0.5876958966,
-0.2386339158,
-0.4959416389,
0.0003837453,
-0.3731625974,
-0.1783569753,
0.3001980484,
0.0626798049,
-0.3980229199,
0.2506193519,
-0.0413033552,
0.0231332108,
0.3167326748,
-0.2667086124,
0.1528678536,
-0.3421902359,
0.0675920621,
0.4850048721,
0.0322722085,
0.4810891449,
-0.5137240887,
0.3388519585,
0.2753111124,
0.2261279523,
-0.5306134224,
-0.5328330398,
-0.7978969216,
0.1496708244,
0.4376828074,
0.8448457718,
-0.9437464476,
0.2984140515,
-0.2332688272,
-0.0504887775,
-0.680311203,
-0.0788215548,
0.6614782214,
0.5241143107,
0.4260277152,
-0.5223426819,
-0.4350553751,
-1.04829216,
-0.5223786235,
-0.0656625926,
0.1006194204,
0.2437338978,
0.4273518324,
-0.385042429,
0.954574585,
-0.3987981975,
-0.2521985173,
0.3690905571,
0.4009383619,
-0.2895907164,
0.5278478265,
0.6677210331,
-0.9615397453,
-0.1348870993,
0.0668673441,
-0.8093947768,
-0.1186493188,
-0.2568084002,
-0.4990287125,
0.3689750135,
0.6139420271,
-0.3571911454,
0.7209482789,
0.5086327195,
-0.5272065401,
0.741957128,
-0.0663041845,
0.5827357769,
-0.8181446195,
0.1046720818,
0.1705542952,
-0.520083487,
-0.1744762361,
0.0628243908,
0.1917478591,
-0.1090734974,
-0.1796539724,
0.3307515085,
-0.4770411849,
-0.080508247,
0.0027942725,
0.4158112109,
0.3701894283,
0.1964828819,
-0.1072729081,
0.6490207911,
0.515250504,
-0.3612452447,
0.4658523202,
0.6558418274,
-0.2436189204,
0.9934659004,
-0.5578392148,
-0.0575155914,
-0.2688751817,
-0.0814618245,
-1.4026399851,
-0.6868655682,
0.5055155754,
-0.642778635,
0.2237607241,
-0.4178771973,
-0.4917010069,
-0.407017231,
-0.139863953,
0.6826106906,
0.0745644271,
-0.7332351208,
0.3895650208,
0.1244443431,
0.0677405149,
-0.9184378386,
-0.939753592,
0.1882211417,
-0.0939750522,
-0.8890565634,
0.4539029896,
-0.275051266,
-0.069392629,
0.0752743259,
-0.1161996648,
-0.2601412833,
-0.1509842277,
0.4989900589,
0.6130633354,
-0.2379444838,
0.5071632266,
-0.0374569111,
0.0301514044,
-0.11772421,
-0.1641702801,
0.2107191831,
-0.1707338095,
-0.5253074765,
-0.5203844309,
0.3677681088,
0.6078987122,
-0.224869892,
0.5079582334,
0.5933953524,
-0.542807281,
0.3581667542,
-0.6827864051,
-0.0122720329,
-0.4156882465,
0.1435844153,
0.0603348874,
-0.5372277498,
0.2530195117,
-0.0177667048,
0.0581527017,
0.4756971896,
0.0896472782,
-0.5450103283,
1.232052803,
0.9129988551,
0.2465631664,
0.4045473337,
0.0782113299,
0.3087258041,
-0.302409023,
-0.3093659878,
-0.4896089137,
-0.624738574,
-0.1102969721,
-0.440579325,
0.0562178455,
0.2283313721,
-0.171865508,
0.1850197911,
-0.8219276667,
1.1845889091,
0.4561075568,
0.080205746,
0.1639858484,
0.2822694182,
-0.3331286609,
-0.6641569138,
-0.4781728983,
-0.514311254,
0.3711540699,
0.167104587,
0.7237437367,
-0.1212287843,
0.3369557559,
0.301291585,
0.1112874001,
-0.8167754412,
0.1533145756,
-0.2028833777,
-0.5334708095,
-0.2497805506,
-0.2369433194,
-0.7111980915,
-0.161225006,
-0.6604918242,
-0.3995942771,
0.1327366829,
0.5395166874,
-0.2373969555,
-0.0278370865,
-0.8183543086,
1.3588600159,
-0.5384447575,
-0.2348649651,
0.0923845023,
-0.9292900562,
0.3068467975,
0.3407216668,
0.2720026374,
0.3239119947,
0.0551312082,
0.4928315282,
-0.2839880884,
0.9296708107,
-0.2449835986,
0.00127033,
-0.0507615767,
0.2392750233,
0.3531188667,
-0.255959481,
0.4489035904,
0.0942905024,
-0.0424971022,
-0.4140107334,
-0.5696256757,
0.3541679978,
-0.5284579396,
-0.2324456275,
-0.2335765809,
-0.5364790559,
-0.1696699411,
0.2384201884,
0.6537670493,
0.4721070826,
-0.1092964709,
-0.1547535211,
0.9256113172,
-0.3983002007,
0.3238057494,
0.2534491718,
-0.2327049822,
-0.4034901559,
0.8538506031,
-0.4327176809,
-0.0151193021,
0.5143039823,
-0.038728293,
-0.3231030107,
-0.4048168957,
-0.8342822194,
0.4718752205,
-0.7524349689,
-0.4864208996,
-0.0419640951,
0.2149197906,
-0.1938878149,
-0.535227716,
-0.1407337487,
-0.3019610941,
-0.3095535636,
0.0881899968,
0.1835778505,
0.8322238326,
0.1795174032,
0.5628432631,
-0.9345836639,
0.3597081006,
0.2564640045,
0.6290531158,
-0.3708381355,
-0.581564188,
-0.2795649171,
0.3352171183,
-0.4852677882,
-1.0904198885,
0.2970338166,
0.0630473644,
0.1881204545,
0.4150297046,
-0.2967956662,
1.1245883703,
-0.3616265357,
1.0486023426,
0.6702302098,
-0.9901144505,
0.8920689225,
-0.2950255573,
0.3744968772,
0.6487967372,
0.2478754967,
-0.7316621542,
-0.3288411498,
-0.3750860393,
-0.5284383893,
0.7046787739,
0.0260607675,
-0.3841931224,
0.4008038342,
0.584540844,
-0.0243518297,
-0.176941663,
-0.8987118602,
-0.1543999463,
-0.3608662188,
-0.5261132121,
0.088310048,
-0.0374085233,
-0.5313419104,
-0.1208852604,
0.5708281398,
-0.3035364151,
0.1692551374,
0.3850880563,
-0.6648554802,
-0.6109240651,
-0.2113329917,
0.6682459712,
0.6970136166,
0.0754343048,
0.1157195047,
-0.1147793904,
-0.5069228411,
-0.0895186737,
0.0878773555,
-0.1099774465,
0.4062687755,
0.3964176178,
0.7275019288,
0.1488150507,
-0.8667740822,
1.0531870127,
-0.5020766854,
-0.3209874034,
0.0958565399,
-0.2109424025,
0.0691243783,
0.2282324731,
0.2724986076,
0.6194138527,
0.0536926463,
-0.0851151198,
0.0380794778,
0.4081349969,
-0.875682354,
0.0410913378,
0.5360082388,
0.199267745,
-0.3363977969,
0.5944443941,
-0.1937342733,
-0.6525125504,
0.66116184,
0.2416290492,
0.3923242986,
0.0295550413,
0.5232822895,
0.2749553323,
0.6036320329,
-0.3481420279,
0.0948724523,
0.1364032924,
-0.6338071227,
-0.455917418,
-0.0754273981,
-0.3002202511,
-0.1320114732,
-0.5355430245,
0.470987469,
-0.1512548178,
0.0299953092,
0.119664818,
-0.3701385856,
-0.6385903358,
0.2774457932,
0.2247072458,
0.6903526187,
-1.0386683941,
-0.0719588399,
1.0297338963,
-0.5873994231,
-0.7743444443,
0.1903808713,
0.0852333009,
-0.892182827,
0.4850499034,
0.545960784,
-0.0253569447,
-0.3417443931,
-1.2353141308,
-0.5331040621,
0.9971482754,
0.4239555597,
-0.7090178728,
0.0511119328,
0.2304882407,
0.4089488387,
-0.2033993304,
0.0735216215,
0.3635362685,
0.5277335048,
0.0564991869,
-0.6855134368,
0.1102298796,
-0.3444616497,
0.0884716064,
0.5163800716,
-0.2363474965,
0.3183876574,
-0.2973553538,
-0.4296762049,
0.2511912882,
0.3029843569,
0.0524693951,
0.5881915689,
0.6043254733,
0.8021720648,
0.7418145537,
-0.4037749171,
0.8723846674,
0.0390825309,
0.2326755077,
1.0549863577,
0.1271160692,
0.5042569637,
0.5701403022,
0.3497195542,
0.5841424465,
0.8690148592,
-0.1784219444,
0.5080237389,
-0.0294898301,
0.1592819542,
-0.4580768645,
-0.0421385355,
-0.3759733438,
0.1453274786,
0.2968403995,
-0.5298564434,
-0.2493292987,
-0.1873867363,
-0.6481218934,
0.1322230548,
-0.2540314794,
0.7075713873,
-0.2527220249,
-0.9322293997,
0.6926212311,
-0.0891082287,
0.7107254267,
0.007485637,
-0.3087827265,
-0.2364142686,
0.0768998936,
-0.316442728,
-0.9604583979,
0.294359386,
-0.0000276801,
-0.519156158,
-0.0041838586,
0.7734492421,
-0.6429944038,
-0.3353833854,
-0.1610509902,
0.2567915916,
0.1427924484,
-0.0199246481,
-0.8160227537,
-0.0395643488,
0.1412582099,
0.5039873719,
-0.1340144873,
0.6688901782,
-0.1549140662,
0.2805473208,
0.2939341068,
-0.3278195262,
0.15289931,
0.3066464365,
0.3419291079,
-0.8273496628,
-0.2936976254,
-0.604813695,
0.6444894671,
-0.2824679315,
-0.5127578974,
0.3281752169,
0.3868618906,
0.7927087545,
-0.4279338419,
0.5986976624,
0.1761735231,
0.1652233899,
-0.4955732226,
0.5683976412,
-0.8135795593,
-0.0149720451,
-0.2056378424,
-0.7910335064,
-0.6738323569,
0.7615892291,
-0.004385035,
-0.4811915457,
0.998239696,
1.0075047016,
-0.2123236209,
0.0684225261,
-0.0446390808,
0.1062765941,
0.0597939678,
0.233194381,
1.0754932165,
-0.7573193312,
0.6518563032,
-0.0037521522,
-0.2829903662,
-0.3611164391,
-0.9801122546,
-0.8214054108,
-0.6742747426,
-0.6857689023,
-0.280968219,
0.1957323998,
0.3602805734,
0.5979648829,
-0.4627227187,
0.1180159152,
-0.3579449654,
0.2274865508,
-0.1657333374,
-0.2648618221,
-0.0179506745,
-0.3297320902,
-0.4143805802,
-0.0919054076,
0.3237268031,
0.5199048519,
-0.0842605382,
-0.1523889601,
-0.0233540274,
-0.2212614566,
0.235383302,
0.2028340399,
-0.6896918416,
-0.2756859064,
-0.0137484223,
-0.2271422595,
0.1861076206,
0.8468368649,
-0.5123255253,
0.5534539223,
0.5270718932,
0.6403557658,
0.1357854456,
0.2278002948,
0.5395522118,
-1.1205644608,
-0.0188983101,
0.0925210118,
0.4848810434,
0.7783916593,
-0.521068871,
0.4571262896,
0.3886707425,
-0.5546137691,
-0.884524405,
0.1433109492,
-1.2523816824,
-0.1993357837,
0.7003238797,
0.0930505842,
-0.2849591374,
0.0267152041,
-0.6743420362,
0.3525459468,
-0.0228151064,
0.9921964407,
1.0156518221,
0.2409204692,
-0.2618463635,
-0.1583213061,
0.3818088174,
0.6734574437,
-0.8348557949,
-0.0758828148,
1.0384126902,
0.1231756732,
0.4702197015,
0.1452829838,
-0.2650545835,
0.817872107,
-0.1254512072,
0.2026082426,
0.1915099025,
-0.3245249689,
-0.4992188215,
-0.3965445459,
-0.1671044827,
-0.5330253243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03095v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03095v1
|
Understanding Environmental Posts: Sentiment and Emotion Analysis of Social Media Data
| 2023-12-05T19:26:28 | 2023-12-05T19:26:28 |
Daniyar Amangeldi, Aida Usmanova, Pakizar Shamoi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Social media is now the predominant source of information due to the
availability of immediate public response. As a result, social media data has
become a valuable resource for comprehending public sentiments. Studies have
shown that it can amplify ideas and influence public sentiments. This study
analyzes the public perception of climate change and the environment over a
decade from 2014 to 2023. Using the Pointwise Mutual Information (PMI)
algorithm, we identify sentiment and explore prevailing emotions expressed
within environmental tweets across various social media platforms, namely
Twitter, Reddit, and YouTube. Accuracy on a human-annotated dataset was 0.65,
higher than Vader score but lower than that of an expert rater (0.90). Our
findings suggest that negative environmental tweets are far more common than
positive or neutral ones. Climate change, air quality, emissions, plastic, and
recycling are the most discussed topics on all social media platforms,
highlighting its huge global concern. The most common emotions in environmental
tweets are fear, trust, and anticipation, demonstrating public reactions wide
and complex nature. By identifying patterns and trends in opinions related to
the environment, we hope to provide insights that can help raise awareness
regarding environmental issues, inform the development of interventions, and
adapt further actions to meet environmental challenges.
|
[
-0.640856266,
-0.7185559869,
0.7867048383,
0.4133091569,
-0.6164525151,
0.188409254,
0.0298074652,
-0.5303720236,
0.4557975829,
0.0137884747,
-0.6107562184,
-0.7672502995,
-0.9766460061,
0.0319566764,
-0.3688495159,
0.5653226972,
-0.0570051894,
-0.0848422721,
0.3702246547,
-0.3057069778,
-0.240213275,
-0.2622513771,
-0.5971652269,
0.1524725556,
0.8343541026,
0.150045827,
0.464635849,
-0.0927137509,
0.5282825232,
0.3069773614,
-0.3969767392,
-0.2083159685,
-0.6400766373,
-0.2243186831,
-0.5073497891,
0.1332414746,
0.0407807156,
0.1421220899,
0.5392623544,
0.2154349536,
0.1739291847,
0.4746854007,
0.122264117,
0.5688996315,
-0.6998755932,
0.3057888448,
-0.6797514558,
0.007289289,
-0.0729584843,
-0.601401329,
0.2276255935,
-0.3776621819,
0.0280707981,
-0.6236614585,
0.0409110114,
-0.0803309754,
0.87165308,
0.252114594,
-0.7571368217,
-0.3570267856,
-0.672078371,
1.1045490503,
-0.3072551191,
0.4034799933,
-0.1826060563,
0.0889975429,
0.2674115002,
-0.0389224291,
-1.0214122534,
0.5685112476,
0.1209608018,
0.4298391938,
-0.5283156633,
-0.2191328555,
0.0338371582,
0.1061001271,
-0.3855293393,
-0.4812194705,
-0.4614288509,
0.1703197807,
0.742261529,
-0.0387020782,
0.5491534472,
-0.7361266613,
-0.3641885221,
-0.2081875354,
-0.5785933137,
0.3841042221,
0.5269866586,
0.2411560714,
-0.3272435665,
0.6025237441,
-0.12475878,
0.235391587,
-0.132117182,
0.3977406323,
0.1347860843,
-0.4888909459,
-0.1187014505,
-0.0656646565,
0.7228659987,
1.1930205822,
0.0889676809,
0.4040957689,
-0.1528786868,
0.2477043569,
0.2593547702,
-0.7063097358,
-0.0128747812,
0.2578717768,
-0.7874571681,
-0.4875047505,
0.6819452643,
-1.2498955727,
-0.7070634961,
-0.638142705,
0.0712898001,
0.0452081375,
-0.6224529147,
-0.1466218084,
-0.3690348268,
0.303039521,
0.7056557536,
-0.1244734451,
-0.0012025833,
0.9130870104,
1.0846569538,
0.1851212829,
0.0779900625,
0.055270236,
-0.1410558671,
-0.3306179941,
1.0608992577,
-0.7589469552,
-0.5281559229,
-0.0650392622,
0.3707170188,
0.0072393264,
-0.1348939687,
0.3153361976,
-0.4704078734,
-0.0096114995,
-0.7315483093,
-0.1080044806,
-0.3218883276,
0.0659217313,
-0.5712816715,
0.812378943,
-0.0932971239,
-1.1869835854,
0.2974037826,
-0.9320480227,
-0.1959142834,
-0.1920906305,
0.3606702387,
-0.1287575811,
0.251405865,
0.2748631239,
0.2845101953,
-0.2209911346,
-0.0670224801,
-0.8460100293,
-0.3624016047,
0.1121178642,
0.1581647396,
0.8835366964,
0.3909583688,
-0.2408551425,
0.0516514219,
-0.1410299689,
-0.2655975223,
-0.1095898747,
-0.069509618,
-0.3331658244,
0.2514881492,
0.4186834991,
0.3743889034,
0.0554189086,
-0.8569021821,
-0.1296419948,
0.2921310067,
0.9972773194,
1.1600972414,
0.9779655337,
0.2609831989,
-0.3512383103,
0.4434816241,
0.235943675,
0.3067655265,
0.2570906878,
-0.5557533503,
-0.2008739412,
0.4094490707,
-0.5663720965,
0.5680618286,
-0.0880680978,
0.2079087943,
-0.3921931982,
-0.6676905751,
-0.4318756461,
0.131283924,
-0.228726387,
0.2975944281,
0.2508610487,
0.2448181808,
-0.6169449091,
-0.5996851325,
-0.5669887066,
-0.3967112601,
0.1055369079,
0.3590000868,
0.5395103693,
-0.4342432618,
0.7291050553,
-0.6236110926,
0.344081521,
0.238134563,
0.5767216086,
-0.0170764402,
0.2706646919,
0.6136432886,
-1.2754776478,
-0.5355400443,
-0.0353048034,
-0.5695737004,
-0.0350238457,
0.0653638914,
-0.2489315271,
0.1370358914,
0.4756794274,
-0.4531976581,
0.2071354985,
0.5822946429,
-0.3117098212,
0.1599988937,
0.4224266708,
1.0197945833,
-0.8514161706,
0.1296915412,
0.7181662321,
0.3295195699,
-0.3214523196,
-0.4122621119,
-0.2232043445,
-0.429887414,
-0.6178233027,
0.6935597658,
-0.0538766831,
0.0575557426,
-0.1756154448,
-0.0632870272,
-0.0111655584,
-0.015654223,
0.2631944418,
0.3141282201,
0.4982775152,
-0.356398046,
0.4233806729,
0.1388914138,
-0.2041139901,
0.5984780192,
-0.5412726402,
0.3265099227,
-0.7814371586,
0.2842370272,
-1.2029513121,
-0.1225126535,
0.2911384106,
-0.6535265446,
-0.2855270803,
0.0062291636,
-0.5948634148,
-0.5074952245,
-0.4761819541,
-0.2418095618,
0.3155158162,
-0.4197134078,
0.5869624019,
0.6334832311,
-0.4024348557,
-0.1914810836,
-0.510846436,
0.1080633029,
-0.482714057,
-0.5534697175,
-0.0394858755,
-0.1374913007,
-0.7872528434,
0.37524876,
-0.5230510831,
-0.1475414783,
0.1431557387,
0.5431417227,
-0.3008078635,
0.1370598376,
0.1335011423,
-0.0850811675,
0.0210880283,
0.3703663349,
0.0793584958,
0.2341759503,
-0.386746943,
0.1776373684,
-0.4823045433,
0.6088513732,
0.7046384215,
0.0321264565,
0.6809414625,
0.6254285574,
-0.7219401598,
0.1174123585,
-0.2262441367,
0.0075247539,
-0.4192352295,
0.1332569569,
0.0525764599,
-0.6304207444,
0.2745936215,
-0.074316062,
-0.1431655288,
0.4563229084,
0.2191496491,
-0.6499513984,
0.8515390158,
0.4464067221,
-0.1598763019,
0.7247021198,
-0.1484402865,
0.4834860265,
-0.5224858522,
-0.1981330067,
-0.3953093886,
-0.3552925885,
-0.8488482237,
-0.0925717726,
-0.0269986447,
0.0293644033,
-0.3686242402,
0.2802797854,
-0.5065385699,
0.3361382186,
0.3730552793,
0.3209266067,
-0.1327975392,
-0.203650713,
0.7999699712,
-0.1531400979,
0.0593281686,
-0.8589931726,
0.4400195181,
0.1454819441,
0.3760149181,
0.2178536206,
0.5980547071,
0.7005076408,
0.4611883163,
-0.5963885784,
0.6251208186,
0.026698513,
-0.3624788821,
-0.2056738585,
-0.4136474729,
-0.6545283794,
-0.1325431913,
-0.4650093317,
-0.518699646,
0.2138104141,
-0.0622124374,
-0.257984221,
0.4718053341,
-0.7750589252,
0.6924028993,
0.0453577228,
-0.2919843495,
-0.5360822678,
-0.583748579,
0.2268844098,
-0.2052599192,
0.5352255702,
-0.3728712499,
-0.1073687673,
0.7068186998,
-0.1379968822,
0.8069476485,
-0.5715901852,
0.1198514923,
0.6361488104,
-0.3006752133,
0.2461147308,
0.1779506207,
-0.0057514198,
0.1775349677,
-0.0517313555,
-0.5490839481,
-0.4861221611,
0.974334836,
-1.0255898237,
-0.3222623169,
-0.3261094093,
0.0465644933,
-0.0302423388,
-0.1948941797,
0.114676334,
0.0032515398,
-0.2904903591,
-0.1019787043,
0.3207976222,
-0.42124632,
0.3741292655,
0.1636043936,
0.1613645107,
-0.4760086238,
1.0010055304,
0.3329860568,
-0.0830998346,
0.5661119819,
0.6836705804,
-0.215625912,
-0.2921120524,
0.4341281354,
0.0969128087,
-0.7988855839,
-0.1544365436,
-0.8151105046,
0.2427497059,
-0.4581579566,
-0.3165518939,
-0.0282531939,
-0.0127958963,
-0.2249949276,
-0.6250062585,
0.6594184041,
1.084997654,
-0.4018630087,
0.4569820464,
-0.9103201032,
0.3059315681,
0.3070388138,
0.284938395,
-0.1388997585,
0.1520756185,
0.0502698757,
0.0520596132,
-0.4511344135,
-1.3043700457,
0.4906226099,
-0.1112639084,
0.1867690533,
0.7969383001,
0.1400621533,
0.6031796932,
0.1561751515,
0.8328447938,
0.0237474162,
-1.1308635473,
0.7486523986,
-0.7626111507,
0.1280805916,
0.3268451989,
0.6051518917,
-0.9902262092,
-0.3338286877,
-0.7625744343,
-0.7215594053,
0.4775319099,
0.0047381427,
0.1765466034,
-0.1518320143,
-0.0478811786,
-0.1653101891,
0.2197026908,
-0.3717425466,
-0.0162114818,
-0.6321843863,
-0.0730591118,
-0.3673042357,
-0.1824363917,
-0.0179765504,
-0.3200395405,
0.4325148165,
0.2960022688,
0.4840154052,
-0.0036723441,
0.1889588386,
-0.5262660384,
0.3928330541,
0.4536120594,
0.4897934794,
-0.7195695639,
0.4023084044,
0.0009678124,
-0.2539018095,
0.0143127134,
-0.2017223239,
0.1186612397,
0.050423678,
0.2297165543,
0.5295559168,
0.2495935261,
-0.2810013294,
0.4992084205,
-0.0108129308,
-0.1856668741,
-0.2995927334,
-0.5555155873,
0.5715037584,
0.1412111968,
0.4005098939,
0.6012960672,
0.2113394439,
-0.8514223099,
-0.0781882331,
0.0967784002,
-0.5348170996,
-0.9127624631,
0.5811848044,
0.5045425892,
-0.0779166296,
0.500633955,
-0.07876084,
-0.6679517627,
0.5902476311,
-0.1092898399,
0.7124184966,
-0.0499408804,
0.293877095,
0.7951255441,
0.2392617464,
0.0277576093,
0.588950038,
-0.0402084738,
-0.8076088428,
0.003155936,
-0.4480797946,
-0.3369362056,
0.3533991575,
-0.5425816178,
0.3000552058,
-0.7889574766,
-0.3129301667,
-0.033557374,
0.1756888181,
-0.7726402283,
0.3245415986,
0.0700080022,
0.6540113688,
-1.4152377844,
0.220639497,
0.9891421199,
-0.3328016698,
-0.5861424208,
0.1960527897,
0.5982943773,
-0.3276389241,
0.6421236396,
0.4617945254,
-0.2330675423,
-0.301043272,
-1.0445976257,
-0.704023242,
0.9481332302,
-0.1353788674,
-0.3379619122,
0.3163906634,
-0.0974694714,
0.4564514458,
-0.1520359516,
0.1000536829,
0.2700193524,
0.9645680189,
-0.1250933111,
-0.146886155,
0.0798779055,
-0.6978648305,
0.2083429992,
0.3161370158,
-0.8552181125,
0.6298594475,
0.0713415146,
-0.8509455323,
-0.5032474399,
0.3523923159,
0.1888962686,
0.6654663086,
0.8995608091,
0.3184975684,
0.619578898,
-0.1278019845,
1.0166475773,
-0.4827025235,
0.4101583958,
0.5165798664,
-0.1355456412,
1.0881243944,
0.6949933171,
-0.2354897708,
0.2866543233,
0.9678148627,
0.0280528534,
0.6251955032,
0.1095235571,
-0.4283696115,
-0.2244545072,
-0.4548316896,
-0.1248486787,
0.1075867787,
0.3434384465,
-0.0274607427,
-0.4236895144,
0.0270742979,
-0.0699894652,
0.1840411276,
-0.405090183,
0.6152178645,
0.1373485923,
-0.2666968703,
-0.3629546762,
-0.1683007777,
0.7994957566,
-0.0390744731,
-0.2259620428,
0.1299558878,
-0.1262551397,
-0.4563822746,
-1.2240476608,
0.792173326,
0.0391083099,
0.0120235225,
-0.6918444633,
0.5984899402,
0.0540090501,
-0.3113307357,
0.5980911255,
0.3183560073,
0.0970086604,
-0.5629748106,
-0.7114886045,
0.2258147597,
-0.0271997917,
-0.3702764809,
-0.1635079235,
0.467107445,
0.1893699616,
0.1998131275,
0.6034260392,
-0.0813502818,
-0.0624128878,
-0.1140409485,
0.7118458748,
-0.9184859395,
-0.2431981117,
-0.6505280137,
0.4300074577,
-0.3309918344,
-0.3186458647,
0.5874586105,
0.2413951457,
0.604770124,
-0.0646651611,
1.1240468025,
-0.2662540078,
0.7255713344,
-0.0785984397,
0.5933571458,
-0.3587326705,
0.0024660898,
-0.3740071952,
-1.0145283937,
0.103551276,
0.6155281067,
-0.6690003276,
-0.0152514493,
0.5760723352,
0.6538761258,
0.1208469793,
0.4383076131,
-0.1717680693,
0.0595727488,
0.3711864054,
0.3282567561,
1.179708004,
-0.0262082834,
0.3194347024,
-0.4667466283,
-0.0157287791,
-0.0582600869,
-0.9263809323,
-0.4914642274,
-0.6787866354,
-0.4335608184,
-0.430252552,
0.1462999433,
0.8143417835,
0.443805933,
-0.8488947749,
0.0833711326,
-0.4597896039,
0.3282291591,
-0.0585754141,
-0.4205293655,
0.4334693551,
0.1766300648,
-0.8239361644,
-0.1252052784,
0.2881741822,
0.0883182138,
0.1385492235,
0.0080496101,
-0.1742447168,
0.2926515043,
0.5021127462,
0.371773392,
-0.4454596937,
-0.7133864164,
0.154774189,
-0.1375435889,
0.1904266924,
0.6305482388,
-0.1673761308,
0.114496991,
0.9636490345,
0.1103371978,
0.3518751562,
0.4627667367,
0.2993330956,
-0.2765506804,
-0.2578172982,
0.0663636997,
0.45506078,
0.6697497964,
-0.320699811,
0.4248375297,
0.3970849812,
-0.5302372575,
-0.4532879889,
0.0000093728,
-1.2887557745,
-0.4052707851,
1.1473952532,
0.0513917319,
-0.2778859138,
0.1009427533,
-0.1051895991,
0.0724420473,
-1.0585744381,
0.8991633654,
1.0553233624,
-0.1139937714,
-0.5653212667,
-0.3279156685,
0.009564138,
-0.2245213985,
-0.8956904411,
-0.0181721263,
0.4187057316,
0.4433857203,
0.1610876918,
0.6170709133,
0.0856012627,
-0.1309150457,
-0.0204468481,
-0.0987429321,
0.3244220316,
-0.0055782688,
-0.2808060944,
0.1546805501,
-0.3458676636,
-0.1324521154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03093v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03093v1
|
RESIN-EDITOR: A Schema-guided Hierarchical Event Graph Visualizer and Editor
| 2023-12-05T19:25:38 | 2023-12-05T19:25:38 |
Khanh Duy Nguyen, Zixuan Zhang, Reece Suchocki, Sha Li, Martha Palmer, Susan Brown, Jiawei Han, Heng Ji
|
cs.HC
|
cs.HC, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
In this paper, we present RESIN-EDITOR, an interactive event graph visualizer
and editor designed for analyzing complex events. Our RESIN-EDITOR system
allows users to render and freely edit hierarchical event graphs extracted from
multimedia and multi-document news clusters with guidance from human-curated
event schemas. RESIN-EDITOR's unique features include hierarchical graph
visualization, comprehensive source tracing, and interactive user editing,
which is more powerful and versatile than existing Information Extraction (IE)
visualization tools. In our evaluation of RESIN-EDITOR, we demonstrate ways in
which our tool is effective in understanding complex events and enhancing
system performance. The source code, a video demonstration, and a live website
for RESIN-EDITOR have been made publicly available.
|
[
-0.2817853391,
-1.0433826447,
0.7477352023,
0.1679335386,
-0.3417880535,
0.3418704271,
-0.0115170479,
-0.264858216,
0.4506413639,
0.1514930725,
-0.6933100224,
-0.9579960704,
-0.3532629311,
-0.1074329689,
-0.2774957716,
0.9160470963,
-0.0525537953,
-0.1500669122,
-0.1177246422,
0.1171615124,
-0.1553057879,
-0.1646198332,
-0.8183062673,
0.0925273299,
0.8197583556,
0.5252454877,
0.7530621886,
0.9339183569,
0.8710619211,
0.326472193,
-0.2752422392,
0.2402861118,
-0.6621952653,
0.1000937223,
-0.5713256598,
-0.1740227491,
-1.1058434248,
-0.2073078007,
0.7115667462,
0.7611435652,
0.0787356198,
0.3397554755,
-0.1013657451,
0.1610815227,
-0.8154371977,
0.6282220483,
-0.3385594189,
0.2140889913,
-0.6368504763,
-0.7503865361,
-0.5358989835,
-0.108280763,
-0.0977048129,
-1.0260293484,
0.1649254113,
0.1627248526,
0.7680994272,
0.0535750203,
-0.6496787071,
0.1536958218,
-0.7604686618,
0.3500950634,
-0.0807059333,
0.2687782049,
-0.2748681307,
0.4687742293,
-0.36557585,
-1.2894949913,
-0.3836774826,
0.316563189,
-0.2462274283,
0.4154331982,
-0.4815082848,
0.574496448,
0.1048795655,
0.3334499896,
-0.6640694737,
0.1786624789,
-0.276606977,
-0.1959121227,
0.4426779151,
0.7059570551,
0.6733462811,
-0.4182770848,
0.0851432383,
0.0457664803,
-0.591032505,
-0.3158890903,
0.3028347194,
0.0500434227,
0.0945348144,
0.769759953,
-0.1634038091,
0.7034848928,
0.114042744,
-0.343536377,
-0.0068970053,
-0.3190752864,
-0.3474726081,
0.2704724967,
0.8226704001,
0.7680671811,
-0.3333099484,
-0.1110975072,
0.2198921442,
0.1450396627,
-0.0670673028,
-0.9325128794,
-0.5600216985,
0.4564243555,
-0.6966875196,
-0.5861677527,
0.221183911,
-0.9815434217,
-0.6411010027,
-0.2504074574,
-0.083418332,
-0.0648207963,
-0.0986458138,
0.3070504963,
-0.9516660571,
-0.5240442753,
1.0216838121,
-0.6428239942,
0.3253272772,
0.666656971,
0.7790408731,
-0.6525188684,
-0.1056433916,
-0.8968195319,
0.7593955994,
-0.2188659012,
0.901894331,
-0.5438864231,
-0.1893027425,
-0.2862192094,
0.0475344621,
0.1385548264,
-0.2269396186,
0.4088814855,
-0.4862712622,
0.2530683279,
0.1499425918,
-0.6036142111,
0.1492029428,
-0.1431105435,
-0.8040298223,
0.9123321772,
0.1681481153,
-1.2260974646,
0.5565859079,
-0.6193962097,
0.0596763045,
0.2956414521,
-0.3800858557,
-0.2987671793,
-0.0216277037,
0.1338147968,
0.2165145427,
0.227677092,
0.2645803392,
-0.6107206345,
-0.2949383557,
-0.3867459297,
-0.0322569571,
0.8575360179,
0.1491426826,
-0.1813907325,
0.7943477035,
-1.1838954687,
-0.4355512559,
-0.200953424,
-0.5323324203,
0.0822061598,
0.0805938467,
0.5580447316,
0.0691941381,
0.3507450521,
-0.6773721576,
0.7130798101,
0.0578620806,
0.0849083811,
0.853258729,
0.6792931557,
0.3273079693,
0.3217626512,
0.723072648,
0.039863646,
0.2956601679,
-0.2117839456,
-0.3658965528,
-0.8318911195,
-0.48012954,
0.1336616129,
0.6632569432,
-0.5361953378,
0.4087561369,
-0.2521712482,
-0.6599914432,
-0.0784560591,
-0.0255411025,
-0.2430358231,
0.4334153533,
0.0265629776,
-0.5299524069,
-0.6938393116,
-0.8232741952,
-0.4275173247,
-0.360275507,
-0.0829694346,
0.1009986624,
0.3020054698,
-0.2610939741,
1.0294327736,
-0.9206814766,
-0.4008851051,
-0.2940036654,
0.4402560294,
-0.0795075744,
0.4924262762,
0.7650794983,
-0.3244671822,
-0.3876775503,
0.478222847,
-0.7064752579,
-0.4148269594,
-0.519346416,
-0.458574295,
-0.1908852905,
0.8432929516,
-0.8590119481,
0.8356829882,
0.2453133315,
-0.7309728265,
0.8890910745,
-0.1348674595,
0.1302225739,
-0.636956811,
0.286924839,
-0.2203807533,
-0.3278417289,
-0.5853137374,
0.2214550525,
0.0599193685,
-0.1873142421,
-0.3921124637,
0.3183270097,
-0.2609453797,
-0.3052121103,
0.1501484662,
0.4441437125,
0.3020025194,
0.5012859702,
0.2327138335,
0.2102747411,
0.4646151066,
0.0534480289,
0.8256456852,
0.2477376312,
-0.5452676415,
0.6033447981,
-0.5130644441,
0.0290494449,
-0.4357565641,
0.3403037786,
-1.1133234501,
-0.532418251,
0.3163534999,
0.0224474762,
0.2547273636,
-0.3893082142,
-0.7386027575,
0.0266647749,
-0.3177847266,
-0.0193162002,
-0.4066102803,
-0.3072158694,
0.7925054431,
0.2951731682,
-0.3800629079,
-0.2105902731,
-0.4932452142,
0.4702963233,
-0.2698894143,
-0.8713560104,
0.058842618,
-0.2154546976,
-0.4777121842,
0.0597160757,
-0.0479806811,
-0.3474845588,
0.14895612,
0.4265064597,
0.4560645819,
-0.2739938498,
0.1009900048,
0.5174954534,
-0.3701674938,
-0.1442637444,
-0.2779005468,
0.0082124975,
-0.2207289785,
-0.6209238768,
-1.0633529425,
0.4199432433,
0.6789169908,
-0.3770076036,
0.3551398218,
0.6610747576,
-0.3179827034,
0.4911058247,
-0.3107307851,
0.0535464548,
-0.4879695475,
0.5567786098,
-0.3432111442,
-0.9215198755,
0.3297797143,
-0.4595423937,
0.2822417319,
0.5178140998,
0.3355966806,
-0.1546815187,
1.5765092373,
0.2931936681,
0.2547051013,
0.5585255623,
-0.0892231166,
0.0795536563,
-0.5153627992,
-0.1880814731,
-0.508015871,
-0.2557405829,
-0.2408523113,
-0.1842384636,
0.6318179369,
0.1330712587,
0.001787708,
-0.1029013693,
-0.3289411366,
0.5746326447,
0.252406776,
-0.2314854413,
0.7613391876,
-0.2522055507,
0.1561688036,
-0.3827561438,
-0.7469566464,
-0.5408177972,
0.3661378026,
0.2369416207,
0.789788425,
0.1571673602,
0.5819432139,
0.3078432977,
0.0522108488,
-0.5922677517,
0.2626496851,
0.2791658938,
-0.742305696,
-0.4589723647,
-0.1287203878,
-0.9094269872,
0.5135672092,
-0.398598969,
-1.1242283583,
0.864583075,
0.2470908016,
-0.2546524405,
0.5597373843,
-0.8210040331,
1.36135602,
0.1546506435,
-0.13956137,
-0.3310754597,
-0.2996587455,
-0.0020195621,
0.118684113,
0.3816786408,
0.228125602,
-0.2160728276,
0.4568983018,
-0.3249721527,
0.5710269809,
0.0486516543,
0.2997300327,
0.1344693452,
0.7576836944,
0.5414302349,
0.2179187238,
0.0939405113,
-0.3664143085,
0.1195803806,
-0.2508146763,
-0.9274736643,
0.5172602534,
-0.4980005324,
-0.6927887797,
-0.2425026596,
-0.3173689544,
0.1709813476,
0.6457062364,
0.0452112332,
0.8384072781,
-0.4254102707,
0.328368634,
0.3370349705,
-0.1867811084,
0.0875132829,
0.1244455054,
-0.5699981451,
-0.2292089462,
0.910149157,
0.1133228615,
0.1318392009,
0.399805516,
0.0658397228,
0.5182273388,
-0.6396602988,
-0.8552697301,
0.003241302,
-0.8768398166,
0.020445697,
-0.8607045412,
0.1782136708,
-0.2363488376,
-0.4574281275,
-0.1976229846,
-1.212985158,
-0.4815671146,
-0.5902073979,
0.0786046758,
1.0042698383,
-0.1821239889,
0.6638787389,
-0.5706189871,
0.3106047511,
0.245200932,
0.3511008024,
-0.2079497874,
0.2106589824,
-0.2884115279,
-0.559800148,
-0.4400733709,
-1.0335509777,
0.1261296421,
0.2461150587,
0.237184763,
0.8724561334,
-0.258865118,
1.1158156395,
-0.2656895518,
0.8854031563,
-0.0187582541,
-0.9783843756,
0.905246973,
-0.7784430981,
0.485368073,
0.3548254371,
0.1209431514,
-0.6783457398,
-0.978215456,
-0.6800051332,
-0.6191937923,
1.1809229851,
0.118996799,
-0.6542068124,
0.117781125,
0.0688972846,
0.0759442672,
0.1087519005,
-0.2411880493,
-0.4544939995,
-0.2873008549,
0.0411200337,
0.1766854674,
-0.4547077119,
-0.1693905592,
-0.32930246,
0.4430421293,
-0.0824941844,
-0.3691719174,
0.1201573685,
-0.20519723,
-0.4554049373,
0.2265033126,
-0.0108591365,
1.2129836082,
-0.7007821798,
0.2698591352,
0.1836367548,
-0.4307698011,
-0.4665738642,
-0.008876279,
-0.0756766126,
0.1330397874,
0.8091514111,
0.9016131759,
0.3703770041,
-0.5954813361,
0.5501923561,
-0.4970151484,
0.1017194092,
0.1316973418,
0.1342581809,
0.4287746549,
0.1265059561,
0.1014849246,
0.0445176661,
0.7911669016,
-0.6266758442,
0.0530567765,
-0.1858887523,
-0.6237311363,
-0.2289862186,
0.9920170903,
0.118189171,
-0.0906922892,
0.5078375936,
0.0229604691,
-0.0099858129,
0.3422549665,
0.1174020395,
0.38387537,
-0.1123585775,
0.4392159283,
0.2391909063,
0.2121666223,
0.8448624015,
0.2795784175,
0.0653146952,
-0.1162115857,
-0.2543334365,
-0.0889194384,
-0.3830776215,
-0.1822789013,
-0.8811395764,
0.486476928,
-0.393378973,
-0.2318543941,
0.6794500947,
0.078695491,
-0.3285000324,
0.0406272709,
-0.1374252588,
1.293302536,
-0.712649405,
0.4826317132,
0.6616642475,
-0.2174696028,
-0.245500043,
-0.7558674216,
0.5343441963,
0.0401153862,
0.3476413488,
-0.4259115458,
-0.0312845372,
-0.1468496472,
-0.3855080605,
-0.7255917788,
1.0918915272,
0.5122175813,
-0.1972171962,
-0.1819686443,
0.1402318776,
0.766230464,
-0.2734404504,
0.4237119853,
0.8015014529,
0.7311495543,
-0.0044925706,
-0.7572368979,
-0.299441427,
-0.4371015131,
-0.2244230807,
0.1491404623,
-0.5245265961,
0.6562375426,
0.2407978624,
-0.5492525697,
-0.041868411,
0.7481554151,
-0.014410127,
0.2173758745,
0.5053563118,
0.2714130878,
0.7755959034,
-0.2589669824,
0.8794237375,
-0.1732416749,
0.2809402645,
1.3343019485,
0.2057558894,
0.3585906625,
0.3287360668,
0.1757674515,
0.9641143084,
0.7966103554,
0.1112102717,
0.1200518534,
-0.1788901389,
-0.1089936346,
-0.619582057,
-0.1797964424,
-0.1306204796,
0.4333533645,
0.5840244889,
-0.1280005872,
-0.5373982191,
-0.3634261787,
0.2347634584,
-0.3840847909,
-0.2060888559,
0.7062964439,
-0.2448450774,
-0.1655286849,
-0.1692708433,
0.1313005984,
-0.3003430068,
-0.5630146265,
-0.2151203007,
0.109376356,
-0.0376821421,
-0.6556321383,
-1.0474799871,
0.2603797615,
-0.0750171319,
0.1457638294,
-0.1795592159,
0.7646573782,
-0.2865156531,
-0.3136485219,
0.1086959615,
0.5047080517,
0.2126667351,
0.0403493159,
-0.3901753426,
0.5081973672,
-0.0462944247,
-0.4592589438,
0.2071830481,
0.5971844196,
-0.3675982356,
0.5557815433,
0.6032796502,
0.2272183299,
0.0401555486,
0.1895507723,
0.7502218485,
-0.4870253205,
-0.7374843955,
-0.5843521357,
0.7128599882,
-0.5530175567,
-0.351529181,
0.8452768922,
1.1041433811,
0.622941196,
-0.1087432653,
0.7006824017,
0.1431331336,
0.1989329904,
0.0911677778,
0.7234582901,
-0.4736279249,
-0.1041598022,
-0.6352448463,
-0.8227078319,
-0.814271152,
0.1383813173,
0.2100016922,
-0.7752553225,
0.6674534678,
0.7330545187,
-0.2301605493,
0.2450138032,
-0.1871057004,
0.3880328536,
0.6467100382,
0.055261109,
0.8289819956,
0.1376675814,
0.6129822731,
-0.3337805271,
-0.4898810983,
-0.4591779411,
-0.8238780499,
-0.9552496076,
-0.4737193584,
-0.425244242,
0.0075908764,
0.0316654257,
0.6757792234,
0.4464316666,
-0.6777652502,
-0.4769327939,
0.2809537351,
0.3653966188,
-0.0377071463,
-0.2783144414,
0.9747022986,
0.0003313989,
-0.8188787103,
0.2300671637,
0.9334746599,
-0.2461501211,
-0.139578715,
0.3364358842,
0.1160166189,
-0.2202721536,
0.6948885918,
0.1279326528,
-0.2703787088,
-0.5123662949,
-0.4352017343,
-0.0902957246,
0.1645500213,
0.7082172036,
-0.3117435873,
1.0688832998,
1.0690873861,
-0.0427465588,
0.7911324501,
-0.1451930702,
0.5889891982,
-0.5511430502,
0.2620376945,
-0.2429444492,
0.6284794211,
-0.075909242,
-0.6288944483,
0.4976966977,
0.3081736565,
-0.3517483771,
-1.0422705412,
0.0270357653,
-1.3859761953,
-0.1843389571,
0.8290641904,
-0.0471776947,
-0.2642568648,
-0.363232851,
-1.0005578995,
0.3000164926,
-0.3181973994,
0.6889238954,
0.7659366727,
-0.6932192445,
0.0168623663,
-0.2937262058,
0.6102458835,
-0.3185356259,
-1.1024901867,
0.0363270864,
0.9113779068,
-0.0665189922,
0.2182182074,
0.6690118909,
-0.0730070174,
0.7257085443,
0.1371454597,
-0.001953216,
-0.0320665538,
-0.5663299561,
-0.091895394,
0.2831081152,
0.0543267578,
0.4104786217
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03088v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03088v1
|
LLMs for Multi-Modal Knowledge Extraction and Analysis in Intelligence/Safety-Critical Applications
| 2023-12-05T19:04:50 | 2023-12-05T19:04:50 |
Brett Israelsen, Soumalya Sarkar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models have seen rapid progress in capability in recent years;
this progress has been accelerating and their capabilities, measured by various
benchmarks, are beginning to approach those of humans. There is a strong demand
to use such models in a wide variety of applications but, due to unresolved
vulnerabilities and limitations, great care needs to be used before applying
them to intelligence and safety-critical applications. This paper reviews
recent literature related to LLM assessment and vulnerabilities to synthesize
the current research landscape and to help understand what advances are most
critical to enable use of of these technologies in intelligence and
safety-critical applications. The vulnerabilities are broken down into ten
high-level categories and overlaid onto a high-level life cycle of an LLM. Some
general categories of mitigations are reviewed.
|
[
-0.3246365488,
-0.9231378436,
0.8214017749,
0.010327938,
0.2772007585,
0.279466331,
-0.1435422748,
-0.9706962109,
-0.2645454705,
0.3774763346,
-0.3687849045,
-0.1996627748,
-0.7370757461,
-0.2798954844,
-0.3636928201,
0.6438219547,
0.0734500811,
-0.0974168256,
-0.3667123914,
-0.175478369,
-0.4379683435,
-0.9741379023,
-0.3040455878,
-0.2188478112,
0.4834658802,
0.2467626482,
0.689915061,
0.1280660033,
0.9364646673,
0.3692097366,
-0.1006256565,
0.0929489359,
-0.0093187122,
0.4466809332,
-0.1933976561,
-0.3697600067,
-0.8448128104,
0.1396873146,
0.5802482963,
0.7164910436,
-0.1288170218,
0.1441636086,
-0.103801325,
0.4776768088,
-0.8075629473,
0.1986944228,
-0.646809876,
0.0308599491,
-0.1870760173,
-0.2177622616,
-0.248731181,
-0.3397890925,
0.4731708765,
-0.3303771317,
-0.5141602755,
0.2439697534,
0.3280093372,
0.1048734039,
-0.5968272686,
-0.3103456497,
-1.0506342649,
1.1862444878,
-0.6301618218,
0.4911668897,
0.3637185097,
0.6173879504,
-0.2527010739,
-0.6599190831,
-0.2108126283,
-0.3785172403,
0.3641788065,
-0.0786072463,
-0.0820998624,
0.0607595854,
0.1632766277,
0.2449676692,
-0.3423782289,
0.4002700746,
-0.4231154025,
-0.3927868903,
0.7735744119,
0.5658561587,
0.4546762407,
-0.1685718298,
-0.6814110279,
0.0684789345,
-0.9136933684,
0.1042706594,
0.2423244119,
0.0568709411,
0.0021876055,
0.3923275173,
-0.2027280331,
0.4595820606,
-0.7361373305,
-0.7157305479,
0.2530820966,
-0.6293590069,
-0.2833994329,
-0.4070854485,
0.7750415206,
0.2482845336,
0.3251754045,
-0.3097695112,
-0.3341774046,
-0.2665622234,
0.2023465037,
-0.3487775624,
-0.0260067154,
0.304194659,
-0.3309990168,
-0.4437883198,
-0.1817103773,
-0.9903584123,
-0.8359846473,
-0.1209280863,
0.2431780547,
-0.4631119072,
-0.532717526,
0.2207370698,
0.0862479359,
0.4436891079,
0.3524829149,
-0.5317773819,
-0.0843161121,
0.6363492608,
0.6059849858,
-0.3425574005,
-0.1814710051,
-0.3774244487,
0.3234708011,
-0.0368968025,
0.7594987154,
-0.3991105855,
-0.3392677009,
0.0475463457,
-0.1899181902,
-0.125845015,
-0.481962651,
0.4618185461,
-0.7536282539,
-0.1561812162,
-0.2529411614,
-0.2530903816,
-0.4159107506,
0.4811075628,
-0.6272999048,
0.9371268749,
0.006041781,
-0.5390514135,
0.164614141,
-0.6736857295,
-0.4791589677,
0.0197605472,
-0.2348810881,
-0.3109298646,
0.1006471664,
-0.0516791157,
0.5486933589,
-0.6511902809,
0.1638786495,
-0.4593693912,
0.1301059425,
0.7950457931,
-0.7365466952,
0.781124711,
0.3243789971,
-0.171107173,
0.287350595,
-0.8650111556,
-0.0093809078,
0.0583706908,
-0.608317256,
-0.2608765662,
0.3233681619,
0.1258741915,
0.3972468674,
0.4088875949,
-0.3303185105,
-0.0925733596,
-0.2968166471,
0.6494514346,
0.703506887,
0.1898520738,
0.3606710732,
-0.3319758177,
0.5475509167,
0.1257096976,
0.6450722218,
-0.0624464564,
-0.2294190973,
-0.5773543715,
-0.3371346295,
0.1079564765,
0.9570307136,
-0.6248252392,
0.3857724369,
-0.0787706152,
-0.4943327606,
-0.1007887796,
0.2923714519,
0.2270495445,
0.1842024028,
0.3131014407,
-0.1026243567,
-0.3333209157,
-0.7733839154,
-0.1907871664,
-0.3738836944,
0.1584659368,
0.0990374908,
0.1855640262,
-0.4122714996,
0.6383160949,
-0.3355986476,
-0.0702510476,
-0.4014084339,
-0.0112502193,
-0.2052711993,
0.4184679985,
0.5055940151,
-0.8010171652,
0.1959711164,
0.1578417569,
-1.1743465662,
0.3078783154,
0.0399362035,
0.0523037873,
0.1541496068,
0.8264248967,
-0.672759831,
0.4118312597,
0.3249697685,
0.0128565021,
0.5826424956,
0.0010118359,
-0.0222824998,
-0.9476109147,
0.0889951289,
-0.0198925883,
-0.2872811258,
-0.7872966528,
0.3528192043,
0.0524006709,
0.0535337925,
-0.7836868763,
0.2789204121,
-0.6554597616,
-0.1026120484,
-0.0836125687,
0.2058555633,
-0.2154989839,
0.1098727807,
-0.4849317372,
0.6343646049,
0.6172240973,
-0.6610734463,
0.7303410172,
-0.2950371802,
-0.5521153212,
0.1595052928,
-0.3835797906,
0.1309217662,
0.1661673486,
-0.3369274139,
-0.7009316087,
-0.2819148004,
0.2177437097,
-0.1457319707,
0.4408726692,
0.3211489916,
-0.7037661672,
-0.2902809978,
-0.5311398506,
0.3099796474,
0.3703514338,
0.0177795477,
1.0287940502,
0.7708275318,
-0.3127456009,
-0.5860512257,
-0.4376604259,
0.1163946316,
-0.5038998723,
-0.5953867435,
-0.2334390432,
-0.384219408,
-0.5867566466,
-0.2615036964,
-0.0840136036,
-0.1316800565,
0.6963660717,
0.4785132706,
0.4751137197,
-0.1999590397,
0.1437944621,
-0.1737020612,
-0.3085183501,
0.3414306939,
0.248299107,
0.3957436383,
-0.4420188665,
-0.6659237742,
-0.2495950311,
0.5076560378,
1.1216777563,
-0.447186023,
0.673412323,
0.5430681109,
-0.4296780825,
0.1428674906,
-0.857521832,
-0.0086465934,
-0.5043233037,
0.6365966797,
-0.1384215653,
-0.8114814758,
0.5560663939,
-0.4557032585,
0.1650215089,
0.3199553192,
0.6284372211,
-0.1692771316,
0.7632251978,
0.8218044639,
-0.3616019487,
0.4870533943,
0.1853710711,
0.3746146858,
-0.6869466305,
-0.5185618997,
-0.365594238,
-0.0342226215,
-0.282982409,
-0.214474991,
0.7711223364,
0.0514099076,
-0.0184771828,
-0.0287969783,
-0.0089000082,
0.2478634119,
0.3933520317,
0.0622276217,
0.5218170881,
-0.0717366859,
0.0915793851,
0.1305646896,
-0.4664453864,
-0.4220699668,
1.0544717312,
0.665941596,
0.8961812854,
0.2976831794,
0.1827537566,
0.1601770967,
0.2034629136,
-0.8933138847,
0.6998053789,
0.1741179824,
-0.8211661577,
-0.4890390337,
-0.2460841984,
-0.6313406229,
0.0785937011,
-0.4406617284,
-0.7515724897,
0.0446828306,
-0.2083771676,
-0.5984874368,
0.3634964824,
-0.7231624722,
0.3791800141,
-0.5884852409,
-0.2126367986,
-0.2796783745,
-0.81612432,
0.4704372585,
-0.3039161563,
0.4055556953,
-0.4213625789,
0.0114502795,
0.4372423887,
0.1794224083,
0.9506407976,
0.0312421545,
-0.2325698584,
0.2764942944,
0.0477826148,
0.2782845497,
0.0097441114,
-0.2359017432,
0.0990443155,
0.1663993001,
-0.1189177185,
-0.3439626396,
0.646908164,
-0.7292971611,
-0.8445461988,
-0.5232149363,
-0.8906753659,
-0.5273735523,
0.1471581161,
-0.0347688496,
0.4858886003,
-0.068918407,
0.3241610825,
0.8488252759,
-0.4241009355,
0.820933938,
0.4052654505,
-0.160658583,
-0.3158681095,
0.8713542223,
0.3173161149,
0.422611773,
0.1194158494,
-0.0488421731,
0.0527771227,
-0.8781984448,
-0.0596248098,
0.0402954929,
-0.8483451605,
-0.4665136635,
-0.5860978961,
-0.6136191487,
-0.3483694494,
-0.0320841931,
-0.3719991446,
-0.4654448032,
-0.2979647815,
-0.2478690594,
0.442038238,
0.7433100343,
-0.0623815767,
0.0088018114,
-1.0477054119,
0.1495005339,
0.4307764173,
-0.0080093257,
-0.0467699654,
0.1230880916,
-0.2491900772,
-0.2933174372,
-0.3985280097,
-0.7915161848,
0.1908934712,
-0.05780866,
0.9639264345,
0.2906644046,
0.1429441571,
0.2656596899,
-0.2083159685,
0.7931526899,
0.3972268105,
-0.6315839887,
0.5087913871,
-0.2199853212,
-0.0279086232,
0.5547279716,
0.5000547767,
-0.2081456631,
-0.2041456401,
-0.1436247379,
-1.0087089539,
0.2176793665,
-0.1629814059,
0.0475097746,
0.1838334501,
0.2563038766,
-0.0649129972,
0.0440437011,
-0.5441090465,
-0.0788008347,
0.1776019633,
-0.0678763017,
0.3097114265,
-0.5236163139,
-0.4017026424,
-0.0957666859,
0.4034543335,
-0.1240065545,
0.1405939758,
-0.1093932241,
-0.3474590182,
0.0753234252,
0.5331813693,
0.5144147277,
0.9063165188,
-0.1199409217,
0.336905539,
0.4309144914,
-0.5286857486,
0.0266060662,
-0.0304476731,
0.1518606991,
-0.7128489614,
0.6738608479,
0.328794241,
0.2779547572,
-0.8990007043,
0.5924320221,
0.1168610901,
0.0571023636,
-0.594715476,
0.3356766403,
0.0194478203,
0.6881828308,
0.3633068502,
0.094812572,
0.1567443162,
-0.6703956127,
-0.0206712205,
0.4787549078,
-0.3862825036,
-0.3920348585,
0.2479761988,
0.2843251228,
0.0227538161,
0.4075582922,
0.1622942537,
-0.3847121894,
0.3747087121,
0.2995165586,
0.7900565267,
-0.4122710824,
-0.1963018626,
-0.1490175575,
0.6454951763,
0.0448514745,
0.332472831,
0.2162450552,
-0.7368159294,
-0.3077777624,
-0.5655497313,
-0.4795834124,
0.2479115576,
-0.5662351847,
0.0148340436,
-0.6887056231,
-0.4461326301,
-0.1883774251,
-0.068046689,
-0.6303350925,
-0.0155972438,
0.1400762647,
0.7676371932,
-0.6910924911,
0.7204594016,
0.7437275648,
-0.443873316,
-0.5421617031,
0.0032527414,
0.2937676311,
-0.7379386425,
0.6120328307,
-0.232708931,
-0.3186015785,
-0.3286471069,
-0.4965430796,
-0.9167624712,
1.3522527218,
0.4224193394,
-0.2384758443,
-0.2448002994,
0.256814748,
0.2086596787,
-0.2349669486,
-0.0732107386,
0.769749701,
0.6702937484,
-0.3076087236,
-0.9118266702,
0.0649719015,
-0.0605659895,
-0.0509847701,
-0.0684407875,
-0.5954384208,
0.7884687185,
-0.0802203119,
-0.2347803712,
-0.0532420129,
0.5325625539,
0.3796851337,
0.4093401432,
0.306446135,
0.2106560022,
0.715382874,
0.0753527731,
0.949298203,
-0.2048354745,
0.1212401092,
0.7575131655,
-0.3968501389,
0.8522395492,
0.5296275616,
-0.1552504152,
0.2733504772,
0.3479510248,
0.4163798094,
0.409234494,
-0.142585516,
-0.5721051097,
-0.3709335029,
-0.1403674632,
-0.3735035956,
0.4514239132,
0.7238722444,
-0.2923805118,
-0.0851512477,
0.1648048908,
0.2371637672,
-0.3179674149,
-0.1700846553,
0.7617263198,
0.3113678098,
-0.1336730421,
0.1887930483,
0.0346941873,
0.5729827285,
-0.5566250682,
0.1538606137,
-0.0654756129,
0.1258377135,
-0.1427732855,
-0.7607886791,
0.3904531896,
-0.2896558046,
-0.3063901365,
0.0115108034,
1.1267008781,
0.0523531921,
-0.3648346066,
0.6410725117,
0.8632626534,
-0.2562470138,
0.0110383146,
-0.5062825084,
0.3219202459,
-0.3566217124,
-0.4668637216,
0.5084062815,
0.5889834166,
-0.0185340811,
1.0294533968,
0.5426338911,
0.1244792044,
0.3963178992,
-0.0886278078,
1.1645002365,
-0.7843122482,
0.1655620039,
-0.8213426471,
0.5378068686,
-0.0297261048,
-0.1327499449,
0.7300408483,
0.1988652498,
0.252253145,
0.1671263576,
1.02820158,
0.1004353687,
0.3015808761,
-0.7232221961,
0.860689342,
-0.3860817254,
0.5670808554,
-0.1543024182,
-0.6234343052,
-0.548956275,
0.1552713066,
-0.4026582837,
-0.061131686,
0.8495063782,
0.783591032,
0.0672345608,
-0.0526514053,
0.626314342,
0.0922659636,
0.6131694317,
0.6684865355,
1.2836208344,
-0.3089594245,
0.3858841956,
-0.0087839598,
-0.2762686908,
-0.3138509691,
-1.0376591682,
-0.8421432376,
-0.4799005389,
-0.2317464352,
-0.0751468837,
-0.041112911,
0.6750811338,
0.7737258673,
-0.6661632061,
0.0032524131,
0.3737917244,
0.3393568099,
-0.0173371714,
-0.1801256984,
0.0155844335,
-0.3534319699,
-0.234475553,
0.7299169898,
0.6445692778,
0.0194187891,
-0.6492603421,
0.0604948513,
-0.233640939,
0.1315235198,
0.9886461496,
0.3845791817,
-0.6057889462,
-0.6922935247,
0.1432690769,
-0.1572389901,
-0.1802542806,
0.7434810996,
-0.4513246715,
0.1693351567,
0.5557195544,
0.9846835136,
0.0242733825,
-0.3450174034,
0.403575927,
-0.4991392493,
0.0472235419,
0.0802206919,
0.401651293,
0.3495256007,
-0.455603987,
0.4724810421,
0.3858884871,
-0.6058934331,
-0.8618822694,
0.4426574409,
-1.098641634,
-0.3087691069,
1.2689058781,
-0.1026058421,
-0.0384243429,
-0.4843368232,
0.0726938471,
0.0696206167,
-0.0352580622,
0.630808413,
0.72197932,
-0.2313437015,
-0.2523874342,
-1.0511386395,
0.229332298,
0.0895408317,
-1.218757391,
0.1060177237,
0.4075423479,
0.3423477113,
0.4476611316,
0.4473366737,
-0.5860112309,
0.1079900637,
-0.2748457491,
-0.0824472532,
0.0044271024,
-0.726131618,
-0.2402510941,
0.5531719327,
0.4684713185,
0.0795307159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03077v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03077v1
|
Clinical Notes Reveal Physician Fatigue
| 2023-12-05T19:00:18 | 2023-12-05T19:00:18 |
Chao-Chun Hsu, Ziad Obermeyer, Chenhao Tan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
Physicians write notes about patients. In doing so, they reveal much about
themselves. Using data from 129,228 emergency room visits, we train a model to
identify notes written by fatigued physicians -- those who worked 5 or more of
the prior 7 days. In a hold-out set, the model accurately identifies notes
written by these high-workload physicians, and also flags notes written in
other high-fatigue settings: on overnight shifts, and after high patient
volumes. Model predictions also correlate with worse decision-making on at
least one important metric: yield of testing for heart attack is 18% lower with
each standard deviation increase in model-predicted fatigue. Finally, the model
indicates that notes written about Black and Hispanic patients have 12% and 21%
higher predicted fatigue than Whites -- larger than overnight vs. daytime
differences. These results have an important implication for large language
models (LLMs). Our model indicates that fatigued doctors write more predictable
notes. Perhaps unsurprisingly, because word prediction is the core of how LLMs
work, we find that LLM-written notes have 17% higher predicted fatigue than
real physicians' notes. This indicates that LLMs may introduce distortions in
generated text that are not yet fully understood.
|
[
0.1423950493,
-0.476764679,
1.2302582264,
0.4146382213,
-0.1868787706,
-0.1222844198,
-0.278039515,
-0.7143975496,
0.4346075058,
0.8151732087,
-0.4278291762,
-0.5807111859,
-0.77808249,
0.215434134,
-0.355851084,
1.291025877,
-0.0540774763,
0.5332852602,
-0.2656182647,
-0.0665823072,
-0.3105663061,
-0.4172514379,
-0.6130903363,
-0.5527701974,
0.5258835554,
0.101746209,
0.5854164958,
0.3485182822,
0.8414264321,
0.1932801008,
-0.0441634431,
-0.4327081442,
-0.5795472264,
0.0678681135,
0.2017850578,
-0.7775267363,
-0.6715486646,
-0.0461894348,
0.3603109419,
0.8111817837,
-0.3526226878,
0.2067716271,
-0.1373390108,
0.5257681608,
-0.0957437307,
0.0836997852,
-0.5226723552,
0.2297028005,
-0.3156669736,
-0.2557892799,
-0.6650865078,
-0.2482167035,
0.1959308386,
-0.3511446118,
0.4718500674,
0.098722823,
0.7130166292,
0.16089876,
-0.4798578322,
-0.2182989269,
-0.5851923823,
0.559869051,
-0.7115901113,
-0.0271861237,
0.6120297313,
0.1714497656,
-0.187326014,
-0.4834489524,
-0.5162101984,
-0.4941428602,
-0.1257421821,
0.3871318698,
0.3324998319,
0.4869529903,
0.564122498,
0.5648992062,
-0.3146090209,
-0.0188798159,
-0.6504256725,
0.3114126623,
0.7896870971,
0.5771017075,
0.3640523851,
-0.0823010281,
-0.3639739156,
0.3929730356,
-0.5325005651,
-0.2117021531,
-0.1160681918,
-0.0161560792,
-0.4850578308,
0.7216904759,
0.2921289504,
0.7783029079,
-0.2165988982,
-0.4094311893,
0.1498719305,
-0.0237030108,
-0.242212072,
0.2202823162,
0.7345218658,
0.9180544615,
0.4714000821,
-0.111037761,
-0.3152850568,
-0.0473075211,
0.461114943,
-0.5888748765,
-0.3865962625,
0.2188183516,
-0.9265460372,
-0.2957935035,
-0.1772310287,
-0.8785888553,
-1.0430532694,
-0.1925566196,
0.1134774536,
-0.2972356677,
-0.0869618654,
0.1255962551,
-0.3467922211,
-0.2960477471,
0.5425412655,
-0.7411836982,
0.4185785055,
0.4942619801,
0.8637809157,
-0.1583156437,
-0.2068956941,
-0.3465341032,
0.1594024152,
-0.3690422177,
0.7498435974,
-0.4610334933,
-0.6879125834,
0.0744960234,
0.0543231741,
-0.4288595617,
-0.5683018565,
0.6915978789,
0.1597367972,
0.1110802889,
-0.4266035259,
-0.4583375454,
0.1128916889,
-0.0495381206,
-0.4659843445,
0.6712578535,
0.593485713,
-0.6894651651,
0.4923971593,
-0.2107227594,
-0.6239254475,
0.051038187,
-0.3120376766,
-0.699167788,
0.6031066775,
-0.2330703288,
0.3817449212,
-0.5123665333,
0.1763060838,
-0.2582021654,
-0.233314693,
0.6264714003,
0.0185020398,
0.4231856763,
0.2792138755,
-0.2255057245,
-0.2696997523,
-0.6790605187,
-0.1415906549,
0.1885670722,
-0.7854598165,
-0.3306801617,
0.2955791354,
0.1249726117,
0.3524066806,
-0.2198454291,
-0.8207252622,
0.1973825544,
-0.2979290783,
0.1935443878,
0.5307162404,
0.1807318032,
-0.1978964657,
-0.8033757806,
0.8357403874,
-0.0028667278,
0.037913084,
-0.22738868,
-0.6159962416,
-0.7846132517,
-0.0545822829,
-0.0599694848,
0.5022422671,
0.2565568388,
-0.0639685243,
-0.3150534928,
-0.5076630116,
-0.6366658807,
0.2257795185,
0.664070785,
0.6944234371,
0.3350358307,
-0.3059789538,
-0.498516798,
-0.5629637241,
-0.5947832465,
0.0417964533,
0.2477803379,
0.4892852306,
0.3884126544,
-0.2655282915,
0.1456802636,
-0.7372152209,
-0.3174813986,
-0.662340641,
0.0973388031,
0.3316928148,
0.3446767628,
0.4843975008,
-0.136594072,
-0.6673036814,
-0.2171846479,
-0.6332784295,
-0.1991437376,
-0.6990789771,
0.2002482265,
0.2366619706,
0.7348186374,
-0.6119507551,
0.3741084933,
0.4718099535,
-0.4879603088,
0.4340659082,
-0.3015095592,
-0.2273391336,
-0.967397511,
-0.063707009,
0.158430472,
-0.1839665323,
-0.3727290332,
-0.5046395063,
-0.115238674,
-0.355373621,
0.3259221315,
0.2953730226,
-0.5429733396,
0.1397398114,
-0.0496329665,
0.0906277224,
-0.0329083689,
-0.0452372804,
-0.1196631789,
0.180711478,
0.4426013529,
-0.1310511529,
-0.0228749774,
0.0096088313,
-0.5706524253,
0.4216322005,
-0.7115312219,
-0.243917942,
-0.2295722812,
0.3535494208,
-1.055836916,
-0.3654795885,
-0.4126720428,
-0.3241333961,
0.3556283414,
-0.1382014751,
-0.1292529106,
-0.6499963403,
-0.0030327612,
0.173122853,
0.5504328012,
0.0899681747,
0.5335250497,
0.5242547989,
-0.6320056915,
-0.2055044323,
-0.9150776267,
0.058692757,
0.183928892,
-0.3798085749,
0.2854477465,
0.1092731208,
-0.5008716583,
-0.2006986439,
-0.0866172686,
-0.0480854437,
0.0812114179,
0.817903161,
0.420560807,
-0.3579930067,
0.3959453702,
-0.220222652,
0.077787295,
0.4822905064,
0.1020475477,
0.7215822935,
0.1386994123,
-0.3339390159,
-0.5570315123,
0.6400236487,
0.9394534826,
-0.0261739194,
0.8173062205,
0.2760183811,
-0.3983789086,
-0.0294697676,
-0.8446643949,
-0.0723481774,
-0.3608070314,
0.3973699212,
0.0113344854,
-0.1185759902,
0.4180233181,
0.0913102105,
0.0004248628,
0.63764292,
0.4549192786,
-0.2047275603,
1.2020046711,
0.6031028628,
-0.0022238863,
0.2294829786,
-0.2032320797,
0.205413267,
-0.6139760017,
-0.5425762534,
-0.3330907822,
-0.3880298436,
-0.5083828568,
-0.4094866812,
0.5228680968,
-0.1751206517,
0.3236949444,
-0.1991035491,
-0.6105307341,
0.4838919044,
0.2296923846,
0.0913284048,
-0.0035068367,
-0.2122725844,
-0.1788266301,
-0.1333947331,
-0.4322475791,
-0.3068095744,
1.4494991302,
0.3433852792,
0.8538821936,
-0.2113503665,
0.8732225299,
0.250511378,
0.5935202241,
-0.3220594823,
0.4632453918,
-0.3139901459,
-0.5712636709,
0.032008484,
-0.3522871435,
-0.8614477515,
-0.0911335051,
-0.3599603772,
-0.3764845729,
-0.0602257699,
0.3526619375,
-0.6026074886,
0.1591910869,
-1.0458220243,
0.7787115574,
-0.5238419175,
-0.0055097197,
-0.4956633449,
-0.6543216705,
0.3574623764,
0.2558145523,
0.2710503936,
-0.274515599,
0.1456689537,
0.7443196177,
-0.6321983933,
0.9645200372,
-0.1839123666,
-0.02435017,
0.1500114352,
0.0947157443,
0.5375623107,
0.0907536671,
-0.1204981282,
-0.1513625979,
0.0519210771,
-0.3796112537,
-0.1240334958,
0.6837019324,
-0.6334397793,
-0.4305098057,
-0.7203272581,
-0.54886657,
-0.0700584948,
0.0433658026,
0.55112499,
0.8117811084,
-0.1921234429,
-0.1615307182,
0.3006084859,
-0.3067977726,
0.1085477546,
0.6741689444,
-0.050362993,
-0.3595184684,
0.6458596587,
0.2028925419,
0.4304455221,
0.1983959228,
0.2792131305,
0.1543637365,
-0.5963445902,
-0.0761858597,
0.6902585626,
-0.513088882,
0.1797296554,
-1.1559939384,
-0.0548739508,
-0.6082497835,
-0.5717102885,
-0.0345511287,
-0.5649222732,
-0.1566721648,
-0.0895578116,
0.307495743,
0.9698623419,
0.5250977278,
0.2934207022,
-0.7476964593,
0.2162347883,
0.0560396053,
0.1615680605,
-0.1285513639,
-0.2760128379,
-0.3329437971,
-0.3609241545,
-0.5153476596,
-0.9524368048,
0.374263972,
0.1914127916,
0.4152887464,
0.6569437385,
-0.169273138,
0.5112671852,
-0.3232103586,
0.8386598825,
0.453366816,
-0.5927504897,
0.5148778558,
-0.4983774722,
0.1889504939,
0.5967726707,
0.1110583693,
-0.8045665622,
-0.8155792356,
-0.8003454804,
-0.7556542158,
0.50987041,
-0.3551687598,
0.0170630924,
-0.2664305568,
0.4681733251,
0.0524164774,
0.2074934393,
-0.8668512106,
-0.1562599391,
0.0989607126,
-0.4871967137,
-0.3378087878,
-0.6603851914,
-0.3484390378,
-0.2219532132,
0.0316129737,
0.2299488932,
0.2916954756,
0.4333571494,
-0.0269931257,
-0.5653235316,
0.3727850914,
1.1186106205,
0.9953416586,
-0.4313211441,
0.2489643246,
0.2883720994,
-0.7387269139,
-0.2831622064,
0.2276049554,
0.0020084016,
0.3865549564,
0.7832184434,
0.7603317499,
0.1924745142,
-1.0016467571,
0.7904295921,
0.1088173985,
-0.0635459051,
-0.864059329,
0.2436076701,
0.0910599232,
-0.1172136515,
-0.0799985304,
0.3565294445,
0.1038143933,
-0.6806105375,
-0.1024780497,
0.306579113,
-0.6566313505,
-0.6029610634,
0.8272994161,
0.5001291633,
-0.2435147017,
0.406627506,
0.0572869368,
-0.6029022336,
0.8323613405,
0.7926859856,
0.7781116962,
-0.2658065259,
0.1356998682,
0.4318946898,
0.274907887,
-0.1742088497,
0.6679543853,
0.196481511,
-0.0204709601,
-0.0376348309,
-0.577517271,
-0.2899130881,
0.157570824,
-0.7745943666,
0.2602988482,
-0.7788798809,
-0.4890637994,
0.0999480486,
-0.1190407276,
-0.4471681714,
0.4281442761,
0.1613873243,
0.6550719738,
-0.8059074879,
0.4883368909,
0.5770878196,
-0.264514327,
-0.6121058464,
0.0465458706,
0.0962612554,
-0.9993962049,
0.546873033,
0.4125967622,
0.2560609877,
-0.5359707475,
-0.0560521372,
-0.4110711217,
0.8133416772,
0.1167299375,
-0.7906852961,
-0.1306445152,
0.1081992686,
0.8617671728,
-0.6317878962,
0.2962394655,
0.3031250238,
0.1733758599,
-0.3860553503,
-0.8333390355,
0.2346964777,
-0.2752456069,
-0.3549245894,
0.5460777283,
-0.6256098151,
1.2932243347,
-1.0602126122,
-0.0409272239,
-0.2285335213,
-0.0580986589,
-0.0788490102,
0.7422870994,
0.4660980403,
0.8373693824,
0.8642376661,
-0.09623117,
1.6468547583,
-0.3286192715,
-0.160971269,
1.1496647596,
-0.454069525,
0.6682742238,
0.3764505088,
-0.0608985871,
0.7233874798,
0.0933465064,
-0.2865743935,
0.2162315547,
0.4398097098,
-0.4819236696,
-0.3530339897,
-0.0794159994,
-0.7215910554,
-0.0163435042,
0.4841699004,
-1.2893759012,
0.2251855582,
-0.088992767,
0.6345089674,
-0.0206647813,
-0.168322742,
0.8078464866,
0.4959831238,
-1.3205332756,
0.8196099997,
-0.2329781204,
-0.0429046042,
-0.4401984811,
0.2938088775,
-0.007250024,
0.6924532056,
-0.2649406493,
-0.5864216685,
-0.0055925646,
0.0495353825,
-0.5414209366,
-0.3521073759,
0.2937343121,
-0.6550116539,
-0.670452714,
0.2541923523,
0.1654029936,
0.1018860117,
0.0210265703,
-0.4755655825,
-0.0819931403,
0.1239417493,
-0.0484228097,
0.3581247628,
0.351116389,
0.2384088188,
0.5810685158,
0.3044151664,
0.8046194315,
0.0871593431,
0.2923285365,
0.6130616665,
-0.8816631436,
-0.3586807549,
-0.8654950857,
0.2623725533,
-0.4941220284,
-0.8213502169,
0.4581852555,
0.6779956818,
0.1852226406,
-0.2318294942,
0.9336839914,
0.1660842746,
0.8036260009,
-0.788243711,
0.749941051,
-0.6823914051,
0.1807761788,
-0.3790104985,
-0.2323788106,
-0.0862755254,
0.1515100151,
-0.460015893,
-0.0910998434,
0.9697883129,
0.5505160689,
0.1242722869,
-0.0168514922,
-0.0507519543,
0.5478211641,
0.2946875393,
0.8855301738,
0.5622307658,
-0.1867787987,
0.653044045,
-0.2244514674,
0.0121860988,
-0.6186887026,
-0.4624459445,
-1.1394621134,
-0.3199363649,
-0.549485147,
-0.6048272848,
-0.1016972139,
0.6680837274,
0.3163407445,
-0.6720569134,
-0.2505316436,
-0.0596053302,
-0.1177111641,
-0.2509538829,
-0.1922438145,
0.3486697674,
-0.2873246968,
-0.0608332232,
0.0789897665,
0.4730837345,
0.3931343257,
0.2947034836,
0.0178011637,
0.209727928,
0.128509447,
0.2998445034,
0.0733770356,
-0.6774590015,
0.2651969492,
-0.0737264678,
-0.682613492,
0.1321268827,
1.2074689865,
-0.2151060104,
0.6952502131,
0.4561366737,
0.0842325538,
0.435798794,
-0.0163103119,
0.7378531098,
-0.3214722276,
-0.0107050138,
0.5197085142,
0.7374318838,
0.2769368887,
-0.4123947024,
0.1729832143,
0.5387758017,
-0.7255681753,
-1.1185085773,
-0.1006323919,
-1.087426424,
0.0896137208,
1.0050185919,
-0.2626903951,
-0.0704796761,
-0.2184581012,
-0.2381481677,
-0.0918344781,
-0.3929429948,
1.2273459435,
0.6531119347,
-0.058510974,
-0.0223761704,
-1.1108009815,
0.9321240187,
0.7569126487,
-0.6521681547,
0.270678103,
0.4177295566,
0.3282096982,
0.1165732741,
1.1719121933,
-0.1136244386,
0.5797727704,
-0.0517508499,
-0.1189179271,
0.271229744,
-0.020949224,
0.1505550742,
0.0374402478,
0.1623986512,
-0.0097979913
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02974v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02974v2
|
Describing Differences in Image Sets with Natural Language
| 2023-12-05T18:59:16 | 2024-04-26T19:29:58 |
Lisa Dunlap, Yuhui Zhang, Xiaohan Wang, Ruiqi Zhong, Trevor Darrell, Jacob Steinhardt, Joseph E. Gonzalez, Serena Yeung-Levy
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
How do two sets of images differ? Discerning set-level differences is crucial
for understanding model behaviors and analyzing datasets, yet manually sifting
through thousands of images is impractical. To aid in this discovery process,
we explore the task of automatically describing the differences between two
$\textbf{sets}$ of images, which we term Set Difference Captioning. This task
takes in image sets $D_A$ and $D_B$, and outputs a description that is more
often true on $D_A$ than $D_B$. We outline a two-stage approach that first
proposes candidate difference descriptions from image sets and then re-ranks
the candidates by checking how well they can differentiate the two sets. We
introduce VisDiff, which first captions the images and prompts a language model
to propose candidate descriptions, then re-ranks these descriptions using CLIP.
To evaluate VisDiff, we collect VisDiffBench, a dataset with 187 paired image
sets with ground truth difference descriptions. We apply VisDiff to various
domains, such as comparing datasets (e.g., ImageNet vs. ImageNetV2), comparing
classification models (e.g., zero-shot CLIP vs. supervised ResNet), summarizing
model failure modes (supervised ResNet), characterizing differences between
generative models (e.g., StableDiffusionV1 and V2), and discovering what makes
images memorable. Using VisDiff, we are able to find interesting and previously
unknown differences in datasets and models, demonstrating its utility in
revealing nuanced insights.
|
[
-0.7565326095,
-0.5311940312,
0.1992594153,
0.3346663713,
-0.416648984,
0.104850702,
-0.1762425005,
-0.7472178936,
-0.0241416935,
0.3465740681,
-0.4046970606,
-0.3511075377,
-0.8853610158,
0.3948153555,
-0.5880678296,
0.3341405988,
-0.3536636531,
0.1651709229,
-0.4614163041,
-0.2766463459,
-0.743345499,
0.407676369,
-0.5215777159,
-0.3152820468,
0.3587179184,
0.3632876277,
0.8285810947,
0.7999008894,
1.0635348558,
0.3597455323,
-0.1849786639,
0.3760136068,
-0.2051922232,
0.2775451839,
-0.1299924403,
-0.3146685064,
0.4104500115,
0.0840947852,
0.4638608992,
0.4756453037,
0.3285687566,
-0.1030835882,
-0.2639145553,
0.9722953439,
-0.6230689287,
0.473464787,
-0.5129339695,
0.3222835362,
-0.2006816715,
-0.2934096158,
-0.0928856507,
-0.2469994128,
0.4155396819,
-0.6618607044,
0.5246734023,
-0.0840128288,
1.376003623,
0.4066332281,
-0.1903116107,
-0.1887538731,
-0.667493701,
0.6523187757,
-0.645377636,
0.2167166471,
0.4406366646,
0.5251311064,
0.2206232399,
-0.7700930834,
-0.6173132658,
-0.1601311564,
-0.2157506794,
-0.031727165,
-0.1372033954,
-0.1996376514,
0.2838198245,
0.8444721699,
-0.3096598387,
0.1837275177,
-0.4705080688,
-0.2033842057,
0.5648321509,
0.086759761,
0.3090916872,
-0.3483001292,
-0.0991347581,
-0.421432972,
-0.6525886059,
-0.1850848198,
0.0220051017,
0.0477532707,
-0.134844929,
0.4801592529,
-0.4066489637,
0.592695117,
0.0679908544,
-0.1516668051,
0.1618416905,
0.1322425455,
-0.3157174587,
-0.1741279811,
0.5081501007,
0.8657572865,
0.1994535327,
-0.015461674,
-0.4090410769,
0.1302662492,
-0.0949336365,
-1.0038729906,
-0.5689039826,
-0.2237044722,
-0.8642495275,
-0.5898888707,
0.0739075989,
-0.7066276073,
-0.9876815677,
-0.7051818371,
0.6971468925,
-0.2637434602,
-0.0490879826,
0.0893002376,
-0.4389736652,
0.3834680617,
0.3665893376,
-0.2207740396,
0.5416810513,
0.5371677876,
1.0464951992,
-0.2321802676,
-0.1120188385,
-0.3568612337,
-0.2769764662,
-0.551735878,
1.0345220566,
-0.7288350463,
-0.3378276527,
-0.0434608608,
0.0989413038,
0.2470978498,
-0.7973750234,
0.0631256402,
-0.604516089,
0.2625706494,
-0.4879740775,
-0.6069899797,
-0.4476437271,
0.1115448326,
-1.0951346159,
0.8637888432,
-0.116458267,
-1.1318472624,
0.4177199304,
-0.9214365482,
-0.7308815718,
0.1793521941,
-0.3937453926,
-0.342295289,
0.1213042587,
0.4095455408,
0.5019394159,
-0.4873910844,
-0.0823328122,
0.0795973316,
-0.3943930566,
0.2395773679,
-0.2043895125,
0.6656835079,
0.0596320815,
-0.5208785534,
-0.1491426826,
-0.652179122,
-0.1427163333,
0.4908686876,
0.0804543123,
-0.300684005,
0.3264675736,
-0.1139170676,
-0.1029319987,
-0.0269169006,
-0.3172276318,
-0.1035873964,
-0.1580623686,
0.426877439,
0.4954599738,
0.3416960835,
0.2517879009,
-0.4939140081,
0.328420192,
0.3115451038,
0.204840675,
-0.3252757192,
-0.288410455,
-0.8050678968,
-0.0312236305,
0.4401666224,
0.6092182994,
-0.9886167049,
-0.028996205,
-0.0929763019,
-0.3516627848,
-0.5198403001,
-0.2149441838,
0.5515319705,
0.6955939531,
0.5405648351,
-0.5253434777,
-0.4847654402,
-1.2842335701,
0.1605873704,
0.0305951349,
0.2079391629,
0.2817077637,
0.4595442712,
-0.0294964369,
0.7617243528,
-0.8177312016,
-0.1065490618,
0.0794881731,
0.3484292328,
-0.2019937038,
0.1776274592,
0.5076221824,
-1.259242177,
-0.7042016983,
-0.0568635166,
-0.7413314581,
0.1042484418,
-0.0282555558,
-0.1720031798,
0.1579838842,
0.6939870119,
-0.224213779,
0.7846140862,
0.1517569572,
0.1747775078,
0.584323585,
-0.0840155557,
0.4880298376,
-0.742636621,
-0.1416165531,
0.1281939447,
-0.1730129868,
-0.2065995932,
0.0908023641,
-0.2131662816,
0.2001355886,
-0.3745356798,
0.3516600728,
-0.6597616076,
-0.322568953,
-0.2461150587,
0.0117028188,
0.3079937696,
0.1072153822,
0.3600577414,
0.5635824203,
1.1982052326,
-0.6586165428,
0.7094344497,
0.539724946,
-0.550811708,
0.7231397033,
-0.8181266785,
0.1040812954,
-0.2124993205,
0.0859058052,
-0.9746739268,
-0.3339649141,
0.3131403327,
-0.322450608,
0.1764229536,
-0.4409512877,
-0.5818990469,
-0.5007818937,
-0.3694554269,
0.1416767836,
0.4500766993,
-0.6089627147,
0.0871392637,
0.360034436,
-0.193403706,
-0.5566567779,
-0.7238392234,
0.4563470483,
-0.2109189183,
-0.6366715431,
0.4676735401,
-0.127189219,
-0.6807763577,
0.1032695621,
-0.1911623776,
-0.4996443689,
-0.0026961146,
0.4224633574,
0.2548038363,
-0.1797502786,
0.5063425899,
-0.0439865291,
-0.0108034611,
-0.1632165909,
-0.1648797542,
0.1967727542,
-0.410202682,
-0.1124685779,
-0.2441025376,
0.4506217837,
0.2346420139,
-0.3953253925,
0.4920970798,
0.7766550779,
-0.4932686388,
-0.0039723567,
-0.392953068,
-0.0738794208,
-0.4444845915,
0.0639578924,
-0.3413895965,
-0.3604625463,
0.5323777795,
0.2165198177,
0.3200562596,
0.4638441801,
0.3775095642,
-0.1324564368,
0.7238197327,
0.8128677607,
0.3883284926,
0.5501609445,
-0.4615103304,
0.1294376999,
-0.437076509,
-0.1300456375,
-0.2072640508,
-0.6204779744,
-0.5748736262,
-0.5950189233,
0.2472462654,
-0.1129744351,
0.1336954683,
0.3033664525,
-0.7960060835,
1.1877627373,
0.6367257237,
-0.0386340916,
0.3521747291,
0.2669892907,
0.0083963359,
-0.1817198545,
-0.3702646494,
-0.462010771,
0.8444912434,
0.113603279,
0.6734209657,
-0.1791033447,
0.7592464685,
0.758020103,
0.1382232755,
-0.8629062176,
0.6935940981,
-0.459119767,
-0.2316181809,
-0.2719883025,
-0.3570764661,
-1.0244537592,
0.1896354705,
-0.1039017513,
-0.1573623121,
0.2567707598,
0.1520254612,
-0.0334618613,
0.3705996871,
-0.4414662421,
0.7090512514,
-0.1357157081,
-0.1084257439,
-0.2427943051,
-1.0514975786,
0.2160447538,
0.387910217,
0.0538964979,
-0.0654913336,
0.2620684505,
0.7686097622,
-0.0896798,
0.4976761043,
-0.1313242465,
-0.016943235,
0.5437061191,
0.638402462,
0.1068476588,
0.0764088109,
0.1414157897,
0.0608716495,
0.2437937558,
-0.1879610419,
-0.310000658,
0.5368593931,
-0.5059447289,
-0.211674735,
0.0097573996,
-0.516507864,
-0.0657406971,
0.200423345,
0.6170858741,
1.0608321428,
-0.1524118185,
-0.0740117803,
0.7643808722,
-0.5390204191,
0.5814542174,
0.3619450927,
-0.166172415,
-0.030820854,
0.8869522214,
-0.0350718796,
0.2452723533,
0.7032518983,
0.2364294082,
-0.3876799345,
-0.3019095659,
-0.2140485942,
0.2053987831,
-1.2275961637,
-0.3829441965,
-0.3257828057,
-0.0810660124,
-0.2380652726,
-0.1567135155,
-0.1972120702,
-0.4694233537,
-0.0382860973,
-0.0141841453,
0.525822401,
1.048656702,
-0.327539742,
0.0832007006,
-0.544246912,
0.6386600733,
0.4308350086,
0.4876444936,
-0.1035184115,
-0.4433882236,
-0.1728522032,
0.1349597424,
-0.1376021355,
-0.8399778605,
0.4718203247,
0.3892754614,
0.3036589622,
0.3808529377,
0.0719788894,
0.7064027786,
-0.3845342398,
0.6194186807,
0.1748492569,
-0.8115236759,
0.5706766844,
0.0156153468,
-0.0096626282,
0.3153486848,
0.181584537,
-0.784964025,
-0.2173218131,
-0.7332800627,
-0.6901410222,
0.4336153865,
0.2507596612,
-0.1322057098,
-0.1348121762,
0.1307861656,
0.282148838,
0.2308911234,
-0.7083665729,
-0.4567785263,
-0.1350383312,
0.0674503818,
0.1886107028,
0.1181463748,
-0.6737586856,
-0.1794773787,
0.250469923,
-0.0109427841,
0.4798419178,
0.2579942942,
-0.636864543,
-0.1788271964,
0.001815617,
0.4217163026,
0.693785131,
0.03077765,
0.6162820458,
-0.1915670633,
-0.122644335,
-0.1621533781,
0.2980629206,
0.1189256907,
0.4471520483,
0.5712246895,
1.0770821571,
-0.0811577067,
-0.713602066,
0.5733627677,
-0.1899186224,
-0.3818590343,
-0.0357392728,
-0.1839832366,
0.1797083467,
0.3242215216,
0.1111300215,
0.0984923765,
0.3696191907,
-0.233378917,
0.2178305387,
0.0111951493,
-0.248263225,
0.0075977254,
0.0944613814,
0.2603892982,
-0.2350589931,
0.735681951,
-0.4712782502,
-0.4983925223,
1.1031292677,
0.0146206198,
0.760819912,
0.3650383353,
0.7080639601,
0.1332391351,
0.0581927486,
-0.3039087653,
-0.2009531111,
-0.1965503395,
-0.6483183503,
-0.1696471572,
-0.2777352929,
-0.326328814,
0.007451369,
-0.8785398602,
0.1436856985,
-0.4006638825,
0.158262521,
0.4090208411,
-0.2060119063,
-0.8347477317,
0.1790149063,
0.4460332394,
0.7243229747,
-0.9482620955,
0.0685148016,
0.7512768507,
-0.4769777358,
-0.4829597473,
0.0913615376,
0.0806808919,
-0.7117522359,
0.9679761529,
0.4426927865,
-0.0689039007,
-0.2753271163,
-0.9583583474,
-0.5252668262,
1.0141112804,
0.0324311554,
-0.4781001806,
0.4174011648,
-0.2448523045,
0.543738842,
-0.4311568141,
-0.0217706934,
0.5696421862,
0.590087831,
0.3473994136,
-0.8118587732,
-0.2259335816,
-0.178033188,
0.0554959141,
0.1920519769,
-0.1836854815,
1.0835065842,
-0.6938335299,
-0.6238260269,
-0.1125236228,
0.4001028538,
-0.2460727245,
0.4926425517,
0.6713780761,
0.2889447212,
0.5297588706,
-0.0987950638,
0.8993878961,
0.1702834964,
0.3803486228,
1.2385350466,
-0.3178766966,
0.5367866158,
0.2747232318,
-0.2749694586,
0.5112882853,
0.8378105164,
-0.3314263225,
0.4530710876,
0.3598810434,
-0.0417868569,
-0.3661698103,
0.06824404,
-0.2310479134,
0.0946001858,
0.1204046533,
-0.383967191,
-0.5739015937,
0.2306383401,
-0.2221263051,
0.2329508662,
-0.1655151844,
0.7162565589,
-0.1313922405,
-0.597622931,
0.6699986458,
0.0483078286,
0.4057201743,
0.0166219808,
-0.3574566841,
-0.3467601836,
0.0226662345,
-0.2000117451,
-1.3574197292,
0.2350952029,
-0.0133666489,
-0.4178310335,
-0.1929193586,
0.6193062663,
-0.4141197801,
-0.4264336526,
0.065828003,
0.3180541396,
0.319976002,
-0.0907598436,
-1.0324474573,
0.1201988906,
0.0019348166,
0.0872411132,
-0.2432190031,
0.3414208889,
-0.2901647091,
0.7950448394,
0.1368224919,
0.0576853715,
0.2017915845,
0.4388002753,
0.5430216789,
-0.3360717297,
-0.3364046812,
-0.5296176672,
0.2349222153,
-0.4621731937,
-0.0978680179,
0.1740306467,
0.3049768209,
0.6920375228,
-0.3961732984,
0.8690767288,
-0.643389225,
0.5029816031,
-0.5001674294,
0.0327353328,
-0.6090760827,
0.2325790077,
-0.0542196818,
-0.7775736451,
-0.3757671416,
0.9553400874,
-0.2853091359,
-0.3048987389,
0.8252168298,
1.0569761992,
0.0096489526,
-0.2980480492,
0.0128469579,
0.239589572,
0.4194093347,
0.269611299,
1.0295020342,
-0.427382946,
0.5355306864,
-0.4858710468,
0.0870534033,
-0.1220134124,
-0.9437512755,
-0.7149530053,
-0.9874849916,
-0.8642735481,
-0.1307775676,
0.0465122648,
0.6309836507,
0.7647606134,
-0.6763589978,
-0.1481504738,
-0.228984803,
0.379729569,
-0.4734947383,
-0.27993384,
0.2893259525,
-0.1707383096,
-0.725659132,
0.0415698774,
0.4444143772,
0.264808774,
-0.2941327393,
-0.0417021103,
0.032903675,
0.1417955607,
0.2911147773,
0.2529286444,
-0.6929282546,
-0.2461854815,
-0.3548175991,
-0.1167336628,
0.2361730188,
0.8579154015,
-0.5967376828,
0.5870743394,
0.5928878784,
0.3486143053,
0.404843837,
-0.2396907806,
0.3082197309,
-0.6644274592,
0.0986002758,
0.2219681889,
0.2817127109,
0.8051403761,
-0.0812178105,
0.6459008455,
0.4241812229,
-0.2536744773,
-0.7767717838,
0.469579041,
-1.1361578703,
-0.435118705,
1.1410794258,
-0.06114446,
0.2092888504,
0.1628704965,
-0.3586609662,
0.0390872024,
0.038629666,
0.9006109834,
0.8155223727,
0.0365673006,
-0.305201441,
-0.2033026367,
0.5282849073,
-0.1242588088,
-0.833786428,
0.0464815684,
0.8387972116,
0.63971591,
0.0295772217,
0.077734217,
-0.4706404209,
0.3249951899,
-0.033992365,
0.0333333686,
-0.3053220212,
-0.420312047,
-0.005238282,
-0.2184387892,
-0.0344611295,
-0.5475159883
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03052v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03052v2
|
Visual Program Distillation: Distilling Tools and Programmatic Reasoning into Vision-Language Models
| 2023-12-05T18:58:37 | 2024-04-05T04:33:23 |
Yushi Hu, Otilia Stretcu, Chun-Ta Lu, Krishnamurthy Viswanathan, Kenji Hata, Enming Luo, Ranjay Krishna, Ariel Fuxman
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Solving complex visual tasks such as "Who invented the musical instrument on
the right?" involves a composition of skills: understanding space, recognizing
instruments, and also retrieving prior knowledge. Recent work shows promise by
decomposing such tasks using a large language model (LLM) into an executable
program that invokes specialized vision models. However, generated programs are
error-prone: they omit necessary steps, include spurious ones, and are unable
to recover when the specialized models give incorrect outputs. Moreover, they
require loading multiple models, incurring high latency and computation costs.
We propose Visual Program Distillation (VPD), an instruction tuning framework
that produces a vision-language model (VLM) capable of solving complex visual
tasks with a single forward pass. VPD distills the reasoning ability of LLMs by
using them to sample multiple candidate programs, which are then executed and
verified to identify a correct one. It translates each correct program into a
language description of the reasoning steps, which are then distilled into a
VLM. Extensive experiments show that VPD improves the VLM's ability to count,
understand spatial relations, and reason compositionally. Our VPD-trained
PaLI-X outperforms all prior VLMs, achieving state-of-the-art performance
across complex vision tasks, including MMBench, OK-VQA, A-OKVQA, TallyQA, POPE,
and Hateful Memes. An evaluation with human annotators also confirms that VPD
improves model response factuality and consistency. Finally, experiments on
content moderation demonstrate that VPD is also helpful for adaptation to
real-world applications with limited data.
|
[
-0.3610132337,
-0.8086311817,
0.7443922758,
0.2930972874,
-0.4462641478,
0.2245827615,
-0.289850831,
-0.2150001377,
-0.2567414045,
0.6555682421,
-0.4252029955,
-0.5622415543,
-0.6416999102,
-0.1674078107,
-0.4747676253,
0.6421938539,
-0.0724183172,
0.16602543,
-0.2444708943,
-0.049929399,
-0.6750556231,
-0.2513583601,
-0.3188605309,
-0.2243107408,
0.3180096447,
0.3101982176,
0.2148549706,
0.698174417,
0.6931400895,
0.4728483856,
0.0600789674,
0.3492880762,
-0.5942611694,
-0.0206900518,
-0.1835976988,
-0.8349760771,
-0.2999577224,
0.1042909995,
0.211646989,
0.6896964312,
-0.378546685,
0.1677467525,
0.2081606686,
0.7338562012,
-0.7113897204,
0.3226327598,
-0.6807053685,
0.0630006194,
-0.0582570285,
-0.3408060372,
-0.3864850104,
-0.3065857291,
0.1579523236,
-0.694570601,
0.2272084057,
0.0397911482,
0.7563089132,
0.778514564,
-0.003933385,
-0.0650910959,
-0.8747081161,
0.8038316965,
-0.5767716765,
0.1584162116,
0.1885569692,
0.6405546665,
-0.1774427146,
-0.7109377384,
-0.6640616059,
-0.1264983565,
0.2886873484,
0.1525237411,
-0.1342583895,
0.1834105402,
0.5937498212,
0.3122173548,
-0.599086225,
-0.193429634,
-0.7273653746,
0.1457110345,
0.3913846016,
0.2234517485,
0.3319868445,
0.0916457847,
-0.3074176013,
-0.2515829504,
-0.4909333587,
0.0222398881,
0.0929956958,
-0.1045540348,
0.0013593887,
0.6577849984,
-0.2648384571,
1.1401559114,
0.1774417609,
-0.3991595209,
0.042827595,
-0.2605963945,
-0.4853240848,
-0.0268767867,
0.4170888066,
0.5680007935,
0.5734971762,
0.225510478,
-0.1766209602,
0.222676456,
0.3733264506,
-0.7243229747,
-0.7588855028,
-0.069146499,
-0.4281275272,
-0.2656920552,
0.0217217077,
-0.5224416256,
-0.4517656267,
-0.9451293945,
0.4106862247,
-0.4698279202,
-0.0278224368,
0.178293258,
-0.5342286825,
0.0106596211,
0.5778164268,
-0.8396220803,
-0.0000145708,
0.690772593,
0.6962158084,
-0.0461349189,
-0.2907116413,
-0.6795067787,
-0.0228108391,
-0.433070451,
0.5940897465,
-0.6562454104,
-0.2708286643,
-0.3838216662,
-0.1646617502,
0.1477995813,
-0.9145922065,
0.0129990019,
-0.319707334,
-0.1294985712,
-0.4113300145,
-0.4364773333,
-0.0899489224,
0.1002814472,
-0.5515714288,
0.7907764912,
0.1470002085,
-0.5553064346,
0.6494098306,
-0.3040747941,
-0.2857540846,
0.1519639939,
-0.4940715134,
-0.1846275181,
0.5258247256,
0.3507658839,
0.2186311781,
-0.2257147878,
0.3682295084,
-0.3903921545,
-0.5437856913,
0.0455540195,
-0.5924956203,
0.8843387365,
0.0918709636,
-0.4281603694,
0.0858372599,
-0.9987578988,
-0.0546271838,
-0.0301102269,
-0.5099734068,
-0.5161226392,
0.0299971066,
-0.259362191,
0.1571314931,
0.2145591974,
-0.4400861263,
0.2522740066,
-0.2107512802,
0.4915725887,
0.8476827741,
-0.3477462828,
0.4043503404,
0.1379013956,
0.454257071,
0.1788995713,
0.2685876489,
-0.2698068321,
-0.473062098,
-1.0172740221,
-0.3685124516,
-0.1350156665,
0.7000004053,
-1.2434617281,
0.2520338595,
-0.152668789,
-0.4001465738,
-0.492960304,
0.4363561273,
0.5103212595,
0.801692605,
0.3456632495,
-0.1828905195,
-0.4306517839,
-0.7332260013,
-0.082304664,
-0.2297633588,
-0.0244437177,
0.1956277788,
0.3217872083,
0.1995767653,
0.7513902783,
-0.8857731819,
-0.1303214878,
-0.1388518214,
0.2495495379,
0.115573287,
0.3978548348,
0.6021046638,
-0.8279350996,
-0.5794283152,
0.0309790075,
-0.8146989942,
-0.3877258301,
0.0161472727,
-0.1358286738,
-0.0435643867,
0.6216298938,
-0.2599081993,
0.6545184255,
0.5262649655,
-0.3214172721,
0.7199814916,
-0.4647773802,
0.2625827193,
-0.7196421027,
0.0536183305,
0.0793744773,
-0.2317342311,
-0.1873542964,
-0.1005987003,
-0.0871020108,
-0.1491869241,
-0.4419334531,
0.1926287413,
-0.3778621554,
0.0308357719,
-0.4512442052,
0.0849430263,
0.232658878,
0.4498148859,
0.1475927383,
0.6618598104,
0.740617156,
-0.491227895,
0.9352684617,
-0.1101619899,
-0.6265063286,
0.8457987309,
-0.6774527431,
-0.2513740659,
-0.3738522232,
-0.2303453088,
-0.9541344643,
-0.1131651998,
0.0953004509,
-0.0175677612,
0.3411921859,
-0.3073155582,
-0.1925992221,
-0.45069924,
0.075618498,
0.2007487416,
0.5531788468,
-0.5597733855,
0.5082044005,
0.2061725557,
-0.0605311394,
-0.6087168455,
-0.8138094544,
0.1496577561,
-0.1348440647,
-0.6593793035,
0.1565777063,
-0.0223253891,
-0.4699677825,
0.2670527697,
-0.2156938314,
-0.2176793516,
0.0242582057,
0.2648196816,
0.5227367878,
-0.3035390079,
-0.0740123913,
0.0134376092,
-0.1871586144,
-0.1714109331,
-0.4469362497,
0.2480737716,
-0.2001756281,
-0.5773962736,
-0.3986172676,
0.2657529414,
0.7963855267,
-0.4329841435,
0.4487890899,
0.6284170151,
0.0099854339,
-0.5139713883,
-0.4657345712,
-0.1964245141,
-0.5092459917,
0.4852289557,
-0.3854009211,
-0.7149631381,
0.1528799832,
-0.2564760149,
0.0612814166,
-0.187815696,
0.4258596599,
-0.3189263344,
1.0374805927,
0.7570723295,
0.2113873214,
0.7640452385,
-0.3688923717,
0.2136285007,
-0.6098827124,
-0.3030685484,
-0.2303297222,
-0.6184903383,
-0.3417600989,
-0.7836463451,
0.4869218469,
0.1452882886,
0.0213865731,
0.2900070548,
-0.7202448845,
0.7883778214,
0.9248526096,
0.0501583777,
0.2591133416,
0.1147916839,
-0.0406359658,
-0.1094098389,
-0.5174438953,
-0.3714459836,
0.9963646531,
-0.1435479671,
1.054214716,
-0.2351273,
0.6424974203,
0.0393061824,
0.0773357451,
-0.6351523399,
0.5968185067,
-0.5283186436,
-0.2717075944,
-0.2035240084,
-0.3256191015,
-0.3737150133,
0.4257358909,
-0.0086683379,
-0.7675303221,
0.3667188287,
0.5462023616,
-0.4117489159,
0.1160154194,
-0.9384209514,
1.0814845562,
-0.5750449896,
-0.423550725,
-0.2807154357,
-0.5532645583,
0.5600415468,
0.1168389618,
-0.1387289166,
-0.1528896093,
0.283557266,
0.1339876801,
-0.6193692684,
0.8119568229,
-0.4549965858,
-0.0402088389,
0.3897404969,
0.1552824825,
0.2508459687,
-0.047638949,
0.2871416509,
0.0607687309,
0.1488877237,
-0.1974613219,
-0.9658287168,
0.77137959,
-0.5358067155,
-0.8173522353,
-0.0974735096,
-0.4075250328,
0.1481644809,
0.127584368,
0.1681270152,
0.5126130581,
0.0137809878,
0.3631443679,
0.9021238089,
-0.2847542465,
0.3116699159,
0.3341817856,
-0.3664252758,
-0.083721444,
1.0990157127,
0.0683377534,
0.3202628493,
0.4219144881,
0.0388641916,
-0.0025477747,
-0.4614802599,
-0.6901343465,
-0.1850800514,
-0.8130972981,
0.1066256091,
-0.2187701017,
0.1368447691,
0.1272110343,
-0.179149121,
-0.5090551376,
-0.2324901819,
-0.3492735922,
0.0464094393,
0.0112172421,
0.2801015973,
0.0662695542,
0.115031749,
-0.6243516207,
0.6838812232,
0.5210632682,
0.1419676691,
-0.2074608654,
-0.18331258,
-0.0548642948,
0.1548162103,
-0.2745499313,
-0.6641259193,
0.3128323257,
0.3086024225,
0.4566109776,
0.5063951612,
-0.135819301,
1.0568076372,
-0.581166029,
0.6554557681,
0.2537731528,
-0.8619468212,
0.7681711912,
0.0490810089,
0.4487362206,
0.5441172123,
0.0063579637,
-0.2571204901,
-0.3624505401,
0.0554548055,
-0.6423221827,
0.6658346057,
-0.0465513468,
-0.069772765,
0.138634935,
0.2664273679,
0.019487055,
0.3873651922,
-0.3234390616,
0.0199876651,
-0.4984858036,
-0.305854708,
0.0144727025,
0.0764298439,
-0.1379192919,
-0.5522720218,
0.394163847,
-0.1699081808,
-0.4213042259,
0.1577332765,
-0.2345668823,
0.1756987125,
-0.0422918163,
0.5083921552,
0.9539048076,
0.0929030627,
0.4310733378,
-0.2371152192,
-0.5006985068,
0.1323586404,
-0.1936090887,
-0.2353671938,
-0.2114970833,
0.2579835653,
1.0943530798,
-0.0213671476,
-1.0530198812,
0.5614573956,
-0.1935140491,
0.0479932353,
-0.0105621545,
0.5350949168,
0.2107239664,
0.4771134257,
0.146495685,
0.3889559209,
0.2212293297,
-0.5123121142,
0.0508063994,
0.2660787404,
-0.368049711,
-0.2124772072,
0.8053226471,
0.312432766,
-0.0378432646,
0.8851516843,
-0.0928707346,
-0.2677811086,
0.7817654014,
0.3218380809,
0.777644515,
-0.0348822996,
0.2951397896,
0.178642869,
0.3239334226,
-0.0659961328,
0.5191479921,
-0.3860957623,
-0.5126209855,
-0.6828787327,
-0.9725023508,
0.0593047589,
-0.02147994,
-0.5452492237,
0.2426771969,
-0.4272598922,
-0.1442427486,
0.1304415911,
-0.4234441221,
-0.657284081,
0.0910608694,
0.3606389165,
0.7102451324,
-0.8836099505,
0.8075188994,
0.7126275897,
-0.3699315488,
-0.7381056547,
-0.321390599,
0.1899221092,
-0.6240030527,
0.9523898959,
-0.0564139374,
-0.2806219161,
-0.1108909622,
-0.6187197566,
-0.4875259697,
1.0240058899,
0.7764332294,
-1.0772120953,
0.0736165494,
0.0346777663,
0.545835495,
-0.1352483332,
-0.2563127577,
0.6755356789,
0.4425022304,
0.3881506324,
-0.9397090077,
-0.1411533356,
-0.3148131073,
0.2913430333,
0.1077170894,
-0.3327540755,
0.8737848401,
-0.5137221813,
-0.0615378767,
-0.0719234645,
0.3725523651,
0.2812509239,
0.2835580409,
0.2504665852,
0.7361382842,
0.7096970677,
-0.2736070454,
0.8462334871,
-0.2653790414,
0.0029031613,
1.3082543612,
-0.2194321603,
0.6165301204,
0.7997463942,
-0.0751234591,
0.3767139018,
0.2384190559,
-0.231320411,
0.7376468778,
0.26046893,
-0.2487957627,
-0.5493049622,
0.1994886547,
-0.0510167219,
0.8121971488,
0.3100148439,
-0.4490679204,
-0.2420327067,
0.2701349556,
-0.4207753837,
0.2451149076,
-0.2220943421,
0.7274586558,
0.2278106064,
-0.9608202577,
0.5376417041,
-0.1442104876,
0.3266583383,
-0.3651896417,
-0.3688531518,
-0.0282380134,
0.4687909186,
-0.0923011601,
-0.7694789171,
0.356408298,
0.0709351748,
-0.3449463248,
-0.1479632854,
0.6443795562,
-0.5842817426,
-0.6103971004,
0.0082097426,
0.4449820518,
0.0908603892,
-0.239311859,
-0.6369578242,
0.3796509802,
0.1355018765,
-0.0335122347,
0.0638357028,
0.5620462298,
-0.0621200167,
0.7563138008,
0.5564892292,
0.3190648854,
0.376955688,
0.2477405369,
0.8503986597,
-0.3192442954,
-0.3816637397,
-1.0513026714,
0.5716235638,
-0.2792750895,
-0.1516945064,
0.6511506438,
0.4232313335,
0.9976899028,
-0.3470530808,
0.7810567617,
-0.0393786579,
-0.0999343619,
-0.5606141686,
0.6448654532,
-0.6267381907,
0.3967592716,
-0.2063715607,
-1.0506738424,
-0.2029106766,
0.7516010404,
-0.3906596899,
-0.0901863426,
0.4001466632,
0.7936916351,
-0.2680455446,
-0.288438499,
0.390129149,
0.1087646261,
0.4168246388,
0.6016333103,
0.8437873125,
0.0195827279,
0.5035334826,
-0.3785176575,
-0.4937035739,
-0.3191125095,
-0.7871636748,
-0.7888047099,
-0.5916127563,
-0.5336889029,
0.0447422042,
0.0979249403,
0.5340604782,
0.8702465892,
-0.4725846946,
-0.1163909435,
-0.4026552141,
0.1277131885,
-0.4133598804,
-0.2228659689,
0.0939030945,
-0.2130253613,
-0.9701120853,
0.4248820245,
0.8513244987,
-0.0552901998,
-0.4733065665,
0.0681620017,
0.307612747,
-0.0327306204,
0.7507373095,
0.2304990441,
-0.895000577,
-0.11215657,
-0.0454857126,
0.0217502713,
-0.0105955293,
0.774233222,
-0.7686978579,
1.0760930777,
0.7908905745,
0.2176346481,
0.545324564,
0.194428578,
0.6359300613,
-0.7037084699,
0.3019655347,
0.1359987557,
0.4063228369,
0.2747313678,
-0.0377490409,
0.1794779897,
0.2908034921,
-0.3264194131,
-0.7089241147,
0.3107707202,
-0.9786134362,
-0.4541071355,
0.786868751,
-0.3381763101,
-0.5364703536,
-0.0452773124,
-0.6604229808,
0.1058432534,
-0.062516436,
0.8995650411,
0.5601468086,
-0.1149450988,
-0.2420021892,
-0.521664083,
0.5052569509,
-0.0707907304,
-0.578298986,
0.1256863475,
0.8052604198,
0.3836690784,
0.1534006745,
0.3271326721,
-0.1594108194,
0.4944330752,
0.3034214079,
0.0580317751,
-0.4707863331,
-0.6744081974,
0.0409294292,
0.1998330504,
0.0131505048,
-0.357640624
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02969v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02969v1
|
Rank-without-GPT: Building GPT-Independent Listwise Rerankers on Open-Source Large Language Models
| 2023-12-05T18:57:40 | 2023-12-05T18:57:40 |
Xinyu Zhang, Sebastian Hofstätter, Patrick Lewis, Raphael Tang, Jimmy Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Listwise rerankers based on large language models (LLM) are the zero-shot
state-of-the-art. However, current works in this direction all depend on the
GPT models, making it a single point of failure in scientific reproducibility.
Moreover, it raises the concern that the current research findings only hold
for GPT models but not LLM in general. In this work, we lift this pre-condition
and build for the first time effective listwise rerankers without any form of
dependency on GPT. Our passage retrieval experiments show that our best list se
reranker surpasses the listwise rerankers based on GPT-3.5 by 13% and achieves
97% effectiveness of the ones built on GPT-4. Our results also show that the
existing training datasets, which were expressly constructed for pointwise
ranking, are insufficient for building such listwise rerankers. Instead,
high-quality listwise ranking data is required and crucial, calling for further
work on building human-annotated listwise data resources.
|
[
-0.2153868377,
-0.2516086102,
0.8250355124,
0.0821115598,
-0.19207412,
0.0711601302,
-0.2206984907,
-0.2358534485,
0.3377499878,
0.2925410867,
-0.0219137613,
-0.595369041,
-1.0373557806,
0.1259487271,
-0.4499470294,
1.1019958258,
0.1817727536,
-0.2362681031,
0.057926666,
-0.1249282509,
0.0521802567,
-0.6596325636,
-0.6277117729,
-0.0835636407,
0.8015816808,
0.3897515535,
0.7621873617,
0.52851367,
0.4746949375,
0.2346378416,
0.1402534693,
-0.1434542537,
-0.6324775219,
0.0133327264,
-0.1663676202,
0.0826545283,
-0.6072093248,
0.505412221,
0.7814434171,
0.6203908324,
-0.132507354,
0.0164211448,
0.1844568402,
0.704755187,
-0.5399327278,
0.2603683174,
-0.8449856043,
-0.2116701305,
-0.3708891571,
-0.0356803872,
-0.4787684381,
-0.7249913216,
0.060355112,
-0.6121468544,
0.1396542788,
-0.1070598736,
0.6866757274,
0.2345387638,
-0.2719157338,
0.2752722204,
-0.5345851779,
0.6332970262,
-0.6878543496,
0.7247865796,
0.3337177634,
0.2863303125,
-0.1477805525,
-0.624255538,
-0.329212755,
-0.2949028909,
0.3082787395,
0.1124469489,
-0.0492267422,
-0.1268816739,
0.1572188437,
0.3633532226,
-0.6039374471,
0.0314912125,
-0.3459405601,
0.1881535798,
0.5175560117,
-0.524922967,
-0.0194624532,
-0.0139077585,
-0.2144702375,
-0.0037732488,
-0.9927960038,
-0.1723730564,
0.2284001112,
0.4109743536,
0.2624172568,
0.4392564595,
-0.3920882046,
0.4766197205,
-0.0015536861,
-0.101832889,
0.310685277,
-0.1630653441,
-0.0545329116,
-0.0838098973,
0.7836760283,
-0.0059741125,
0.5068076253,
-0.690728724,
-0.2935219705,
-0.2412298322,
0.1672879905,
-0.8574439287,
-0.6533404589,
-0.0692765862,
-0.2350696176,
-0.4974704385,
0.3485895395,
-0.308549583,
-0.3192650378,
0.2312728316,
0.7827736139,
-0.1183166951,
-0.4711360633,
-0.4192560315,
0.0128879752,
0.1692549288,
0.288828969,
-0.7166160941,
0.0105441827,
0.6337023973,
0.7952528596,
-0.3758537471,
-0.616210103,
-0.6590255499,
0.1085713655,
-0.5752735734,
0.687975049,
-0.547279954,
-0.3365806341,
-0.0849631652,
0.0502729565,
0.0209646877,
-0.4115689695,
0.5717549324,
-0.4293132126,
0.1781141162,
-0.3953812122,
-0.536259532,
-0.0232907292,
0.271053046,
-0.5741099119,
0.7748746872,
0.1362918764,
-0.5577356219,
0.5587561131,
-0.5758613348,
-0.3493598402,
0.1448988914,
-0.2664881945,
-0.2526821196,
-0.109500818,
0.321516484,
0.4070378542,
-0.1411197782,
0.3507128954,
-0.5754799843,
-0.4996210933,
-0.0274377223,
-0.5075272918,
0.48287341,
0.007033641,
-0.4238415658,
0.0307709035,
-0.3927006721,
0.2701729238,
0.173750177,
-0.3904390335,
-0.2472770214,
0.126418978,
-0.2590737641,
0.3504842222,
0.1303793639,
-0.6315101385,
0.4866198003,
-0.2945303321,
0.3063240647,
0.9505276084,
-0.1037031338,
0.4107490182,
-0.2467782646,
0.4778227806,
-0.3566628993,
0.1507641226,
0.4268437028,
-0.7868185043,
-0.4924156964,
-0.3596844375,
0.355188489,
0.5218001008,
-0.793599844,
0.388946265,
-0.6231214404,
-0.781319797,
-0.5200089216,
0.1388247609,
0.3126088381,
0.2529231608,
0.4472067058,
-0.094790481,
-0.3559325039,
-0.7666745782,
-0.3710997105,
-0.2649389505,
0.0674990565,
-0.0799490064,
0.2678716779,
0.039941214,
0.8078032136,
-0.5167989731,
-0.0627335533,
-0.5201186538,
-0.139049381,
0.4007003307,
0.3926331699,
0.2089546025,
-0.5092865825,
-0.4569293261,
-0.4364856482,
-0.6859359741,
-0.032705728,
0.5117426515,
-0.0347918533,
0.3081510067,
0.2690235078,
-0.5207412243,
0.4363946021,
0.5393476486,
-0.1678935289,
0.3722371757,
-0.1830250174,
0.1452816278,
-0.7748713493,
0.3192915022,
0.0395347029,
-0.237432912,
-0.5711860061,
0.0083402507,
-0.0302863158,
-0.3196585178,
-0.3838098943,
0.757635355,
-0.1290802062,
-0.0757239014,
-0.2872091532,
0.296102047,
-0.2900761664,
0.474214673,
0.1609559208,
0.7256646752,
0.3914114237,
-0.5207883716,
-0.3034166396,
0.2644726038,
-0.2485812306,
0.3064129651,
-0.7029463053,
-0.0085824914,
0.2016628385,
0.3056619763,
-0.6778536439,
0.1409377754,
0.4294275343,
-0.4460324049,
0.0940639824,
-0.5924159288,
-0.3633889258,
-0.1475789249,
-0.4981012046,
0.3440115452,
0.6144316196,
-0.6431678534,
-0.1720636487,
0.5132639408,
-0.5256775022,
-0.6117432714,
-0.2224703431,
-0.044817958,
-0.0091452543,
-0.3237894773,
0.3005740941,
-0.2347182781,
-0.0885604396,
-0.2070059776,
-0.4161260426,
-0.0197337437,
0.1399484426,
0.2353426516,
0.2112958729,
0.0124594094,
-0.0372619517,
-0.2377224863,
-0.5495308638,
-0.2559843659,
-0.4277663529,
0.1849612147,
-0.1465230882,
-0.5176351666,
-0.1845044494,
0.1834294498,
0.5795506239,
-0.5048385859,
0.5703024864,
0.4902847111,
-0.2720126212,
0.0077731931,
-0.5837851763,
-0.0589508042,
-0.4786199331,
0.1956005394,
-0.1942822784,
-1.0136955976,
0.074692294,
0.2196727246,
0.2297890931,
0.4630891383,
0.1324206293,
0.0989667848,
1.0227478743,
0.5251262188,
-0.3766278028,
0.5949534774,
-0.0209022984,
0.4336414039,
-0.6015978456,
0.145449385,
-0.3643630445,
-0.33302176,
-1.0690634251,
-0.1558403075,
0.4690056443,
0.2058487684,
-0.6206639409,
0.1518339813,
-0.6340780854,
0.5838375092,
0.6815334558,
-0.0236681625,
0.4032325447,
-0.0966174453,
0.1127787158,
0.1146362051,
-0.5133774877,
-0.2206085622,
1.4627947807,
-0.0602096282,
0.6569845676,
0.2939719856,
1.1477543116,
0.1149117723,
0.5013076663,
-0.5684622526,
0.6005681753,
-0.3838574886,
-0.355292052,
-0.6414642334,
-0.4889932871,
-1.0217254162,
0.5614980459,
0.0254726224,
-0.655284524,
0.112552315,
0.0076174135,
-0.1584322155,
0.3421908021,
-0.5453541279,
1.0471086502,
-0.1460679919,
-0.3216761351,
0.1481316984,
-0.4019261599,
0.4173053503,
-0.0476925038,
0.1490105689,
-0.119113192,
0.1127606258,
0.9001837373,
-0.6514422894,
0.2478697598,
-0.668682754,
-0.021710692,
-0.0364314057,
0.0796481147,
0.6935095191,
0.2604184449,
-0.0741672367,
0.2940123677,
-0.0627026483,
-0.4788601398,
-0.4184927344,
1.0831662416,
-0.7356925607,
-0.8343224525,
-0.5512830019,
-0.1673559695,
-0.2466714978,
0.6199188828,
0.1910428405,
0.2901523709,
-0.1033995077,
0.2394007891,
0.5511196256,
0.0116366921,
0.3668342531,
0.4085204601,
-0.4688097537,
-0.6635181904,
1.2506203651,
0.3720969856,
0.1405534893,
0.3439818025,
0.1658306271,
-0.3390250802,
-0.8960925937,
-0.2102185786,
0.2268638611,
-0.4802145958,
-0.0405245237,
-0.4164149165,
-0.4517708123,
-0.3670203984,
-0.1731168777,
-0.5624685884,
-0.6470864415,
0.3130404055,
-0.1583498269,
0.3028434515,
0.8381080031,
-0.2381559461,
-0.0109235896,
-0.5951288342,
0.2814227641,
0.3539179564,
0.5692133904,
-0.0617813095,
-0.2759810686,
-0.2855174839,
-0.1819328368,
-0.1770375669,
-0.5549470186,
0.3545914888,
0.0443477221,
0.9076220989,
0.2194814086,
0.0097400062,
0.5144310594,
-0.4872951806,
0.6352618337,
-0.1148299575,
-0.7481631041,
0.3679226339,
-0.4842398167,
0.230827108,
0.8308261633,
0.32918787,
-0.451192677,
-0.5687913895,
-0.6883823276,
-1.1035060883,
0.5547360778,
0.2452270687,
-0.4689529836,
-0.0777677,
0.1590070277,
0.3139190078,
0.2977533042,
-0.909940064,
-0.3189844489,
-0.5425595045,
-0.056044206,
-0.5295888782,
-0.082784988,
0.2477839589,
-0.3353871405,
0.8471444249,
0.1223122552,
0.2404126227,
0.1334986836,
-0.3491400778,
0.1965446174,
0.4130064845,
0.319240272,
0.7862223983,
-0.6085759401,
0.2032750994,
-0.1753667146,
-0.3788694441,
0.2988337874,
0.4185479879,
-0.2624049187,
-0.1632564068,
-0.0213903487,
0.2873547971,
0.5241957903,
-0.1959321797,
0.7197508812,
0.0940986127,
-0.05173859,
-0.4494856,
-0.0032016844,
0.098282516,
0.1457748115,
0.3582932651,
-0.0237404946,
-0.2053695768,
-0.1582018137,
0.4089527726,
0.5522264242,
-0.3910682201,
-0.2857770324,
0.6831496358,
0.1959490627,
-0.0908327624,
0.811902225,
-0.3862965107,
-0.3747605681,
0.0287338644,
0.4450407326,
0.8331322074,
-0.3486613333,
0.2743103206,
0.2595534921,
0.3867283165,
-0.3905355036,
0.1860719174,
-0.0601333231,
-0.580290854,
-0.2672467232,
-0.3262078166,
-0.5703639984,
0.2447088063,
-0.2803666592,
0.1399927437,
-0.7061483264,
0.1430514902,
-0.2704959214,
0.0711532608,
-0.6435578465,
-0.0179585479,
0.02314841,
0.7898401618,
-0.4785548449,
1.1693154573,
0.3439622223,
-0.604863286,
-0.6258820891,
0.2455058396,
-0.1095847338,
-0.7270057201,
0.4655361474,
0.158711791,
-0.1905667782,
0.4671889544,
-0.4365280867,
-1.1778022051,
1.2720373869,
0.353985101,
-0.2633410692,
0.0037088157,
-0.0515212826,
0.0948353857,
-0.0893119052,
0.5014871955,
0.1531629264,
0.6149706841,
0.0014456353,
-0.9727051854,
0.1946707517,
-0.3688629866,
-0.2992464006,
0.4881311059,
-0.5359278321,
0.9010702372,
-0.2410239875,
-0.0663309023,
0.1274012029,
0.3500711024,
0.5310360789,
0.0966510028,
0.4802289307,
0.6407932639,
0.7955850959,
0.0073783537,
1.0259946585,
-0.3008750081,
0.1444456875,
1.1505872011,
-0.4198049903,
1.1705511808,
0.161910966,
-0.143129319,
0.3468463123,
0.3991921246,
0.0107809389,
0.6646001935,
0.0585436374,
-0.1262663007,
-0.5737007856,
0.3212597966,
-0.8160333037,
0.3575487435,
-0.0648021698,
-0.2358210385,
-0.2716502845,
-0.4630302787,
0.2629418075,
-0.3372395933,
-0.2057628334,
0.4913787544,
0.111872986,
-0.5280082822,
0.7281948924,
-0.0900516585,
0.9083634019,
-0.7452099323,
0.0687863082,
-0.386582613,
0.0275553875,
-0.0859585404,
-0.6244336963,
-0.1183880121,
0.1562942863,
-0.157669276,
-0.5095257163,
0.6207928658,
-0.33790043,
-0.5019220114,
0.1031608284,
0.9835950732,
0.4277333319,
-0.565392971,
-0.3926791251,
-0.2468256652,
-0.0289209634,
-0.4173956215,
0.7729508281,
0.1715289503,
-0.1560800821,
0.6499784589,
0.8602293134,
0.0526553243,
-0.2277745605,
0.0387677141,
0.6218298078,
-0.8673762083,
-0.4388827085,
-0.7804487944,
0.2423652112,
0.0004224505,
-0.1154117584,
0.6998082399,
0.6329707503,
0.9039627314,
0.1642681211,
0.9926342368,
0.0613149107,
0.6465696096,
-0.1231266484,
1.2562941313,
-0.5754162669,
0.1894952804,
-0.4693034291,
-1.1109982729,
-0.5090044737,
0.5517869592,
-0.5517635942,
0.2081822306,
0.6410622001,
0.6599244475,
-0.0096898396,
-0.1589075029,
0.4422180951,
0.1250679791,
0.6296960711,
0.4748244286,
0.7020713687,
-0.1964774877,
0.8519964814,
-0.1945285648,
-0.3184989095,
-0.1723149419,
-0.8838099241,
-0.5283498764,
-0.377779305,
-0.178232342,
-0.0871131718,
0.1684933156,
0.8741106987,
0.5028962493,
-0.7086799145,
-0.099186264,
0.1052399054,
0.5210872293,
-0.2870576084,
-0.2063976079,
0.5110785961,
-0.0109578902,
-0.5317060351,
0.9116402864,
0.172747016,
-0.1859633029,
-0.0729307383,
-0.3332361579,
-0.1766091585,
-0.2727920413,
0.707126677,
0.5195326209,
-0.6216318607,
-0.5758043528,
-0.1189991236,
-0.00064224,
0.1497378498,
0.5721479654,
-1.0480659008,
-0.0255270991,
0.4592449069,
0.4406954646,
0.1714592874,
-0.0163526908,
0.4566169679,
-0.5069357157,
-0.2366796881,
0.0497776717,
0.4181647599,
0.2734443843,
0.1564202607,
0.6668920517,
0.4784851968,
-0.7761813998,
-0.7502320409,
0.1222665235,
-0.9606226087,
0.0784153566,
1.0766646862,
-0.1671937853,
0.1681274325,
-0.0005230141,
0.1489592046,
0.2094083875,
-0.6814913154,
0.6866143942,
0.4285216033,
-0.1780581921,
-0.060073439,
-0.5129039288,
0.3465292752,
0.1350189447,
-0.7498019934,
0.0678395107,
0.1656538993,
0.6018443704,
-0.1863185018,
0.982958436,
-0.2047397792,
-0.0647222623,
-0.0853469223,
0.1161029041,
-0.42573452,
-0.375335604,
-0.0558916368,
0.347692579,
0.7118771076,
-0.1027229875
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.14943v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.14943v1
|
Flood Event Extraction from News Media to Support Satellite-Based Flood Insurance
| 2023-12-05T18:39:42 | 2023-12-05T18:39:42 |
Tejit Pabari, Beth Tellman, Giannis Karamanolakis, Mitchell Thomas, Max Mauerman, Eugene Wu, Upmanu Lall, Marco Tedesco, Michael S Steckler, Paolo Colosio, Daniel E Osgood, Melody Braun, Jens de Bruijn, Shammun Islam
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Floods cause large losses to property, life, and livelihoods across the world
every year, hindering sustainable development. Safety nets to help absorb
financial shocks in disasters, such as insurance, are often unavailable in
regions of the world most vulnerable to floods, like Bangladesh. Index-based
insurance has emerged as an affordable solution, which considers weather data
or information from satellites to create a "flood index" that should correlate
with the damage insured. However, existing flood event databases are often
incomplete, and satellite sensors are not reliable under extreme weather
conditions (e.g., because of clouds), which limits the spatial and temporal
resolution of current approaches for index-based insurance.
In this work, we explore a novel approach for supporting satellite-based
flood index insurance by extracting high-resolution spatio-temporal information
from news media. First, we publish a dataset consisting of 40,000 news articles
covering flood events in Bangladesh by 10 prominent news sources, and inundated
area estimates for each division in Bangladesh collected from a satellite radar
sensor. Second, we show that keyword-based models are not adequate for this
novel application, while context-based classifiers cover complex and implicit
flood related patterns. Third, we show that time series extracted from news
media have substantial correlation Spearman's rho$=0.70 with satellite
estimates of inundated area. Our work demonstrates that news media is a
promising source for improving the temporal resolution and expanding the
spatial coverage of the available flood damage data.
|
[
-0.5306200385,
-0.5275651813,
0.2656859457,
0.5037454963,
-0.2274111211,
-0.0421082675,
0.1320605427,
-0.6602604389,
0.3167147636,
0.3917316198,
-0.2083800584,
-0.2335738391,
-0.535353899,
-0.2879056334,
-0.3412976563,
1.0652323961,
0.0057013906,
-0.4346553385,
0.4709452689,
0.0212015007,
-0.1006029099,
0.0459452011,
-0.2844384313,
0.0506924763,
0.3815449178,
0.5192920566,
0.9906240702,
0.6075940132,
0.7167019248,
0.1375491917,
0.162154153,
0.3439318538,
-0.2435333133,
0.0852409825,
-0.2344933897,
-0.0102980817,
-0.1989756525,
0.2822307348,
0.6880832314,
0.3805015683,
-0.175840199,
0.3300369084,
0.0010779097,
0.9367727041,
-0.9481922984,
0.2940942645,
-0.4449211955,
0.0945196748,
-0.1621716022,
-1.1724210978,
-0.3894989192,
-0.2203955203,
0.2777098417,
-0.8167344332,
0.3710183203,
0.2702414691,
1.1804821491,
0.4408877492,
-0.5725175738,
-0.3362729549,
-1.0492696762,
0.6197386384,
-0.0625879616,
0.0377181582,
0.7265177965,
0.6562381387,
-0.2014800906,
0.0850132629,
-0.3236076236,
0.3564099967,
-0.1202615723,
0.4663829803,
-0.1357087791,
-0.2897726297,
-0.1330234408,
0.1834829599,
-0.673511982,
0.0592014752,
-0.1415642649,
-0.0018113246,
0.942656219,
0.2872467935,
0.0818878561,
-0.7308111787,
-0.7064746618,
-0.0823569596,
-0.9575532675,
0.1503112018,
0.4437592328,
0.2529219985,
-0.5929240584,
0.5444231629,
-0.1979721636,
0.4767620862,
-0.2833532393,
-0.4688110352,
0.1670231223,
-0.2236850113,
-0.1213289797,
0.1922042072,
0.3294942975,
0.6079112291,
-0.077420719,
0.0784958079,
-0.1076567098,
-0.455293417,
-0.0114977788,
-0.7461546659,
0.2204420418,
0.2210137397,
-0.6313585043,
-0.3147876859,
0.4143715799,
-1.5218048096,
-0.7855852246,
0.0067244647,
0.3768332303,
0.1004000157,
-0.4317246079,
0.3302437663,
-0.4364338815,
0.4038570821,
0.2377157211,
-0.3572818935,
-0.1708055437,
0.352866143,
0.7875654697,
0.2070033699,
0.0759855509,
-0.7724255323,
0.4711573124,
-0.280251652,
1.1104772091,
-0.3457024693,
-0.1717704684,
0.2704102099,
-0.1013904735,
0.0843776315,
-0.4925850034,
0.2010319978,
-0.8980642557,
-0.0377708189,
0.4005043209,
-0.2886047661,
-0.3775000572,
-0.110415794,
-0.7607921362,
0.7570355535,
0.2625789344,
-0.870387733,
0.5007410049,
-0.4898262322,
-0.6716051102,
0.2009531111,
0.0093308147,
-0.8756024837,
0.0793217346,
0.5170820355,
0.3287882209,
-0.4995983839,
0.4105839729,
-0.4706930518,
-0.1715313494,
0.2077653408,
-0.7395042777,
0.5679198503,
0.1352389753,
-0.4024997652,
-0.1454552561,
-0.9858207107,
-0.2548920214,
0.1009534299,
-0.4464624226,
-0.466003269,
0.3371972442,
0.6707149744,
-0.0941054597,
-0.1301598251,
-0.5848622322,
0.1475548446,
-0.0961922333,
0.0954574272,
0.4619074166,
0.5247853994,
0.5270909667,
-0.4622862637,
0.439555943,
0.1339962035,
0.1933681965,
-0.3902225792,
-0.3303565979,
-0.3706611395,
-0.5502158403,
0.1083114445,
0.7148531079,
-0.6686671972,
0.1343872398,
-0.611730814,
-0.5455088615,
-0.1275885701,
-0.3885246515,
-0.3056285977,
0.2830875218,
0.5156724453,
0.2088854611,
-0.8766445518,
-0.5687353611,
-0.2762666643,
0.1193897128,
-0.0883441493,
0.3691531122,
0.5073018074,
0.0449282676,
1.3633620739,
-0.7618646026,
-0.3177945614,
-0.2173147649,
0.453690201,
0.3025446236,
0.2326497883,
0.7368804812,
-1.4577220678,
-0.3316501975,
0.1339880973,
-0.5638304353,
-0.0204175208,
-0.5998407006,
0.2740101218,
0.3567528725,
0.00178384,
-0.5554823875,
1.2984746695,
0.5397230983,
-0.4535324574,
0.6240737438,
-0.2171837091,
0.2424236834,
-1.0612239838,
-0.1960897297,
0.267683804,
-0.3670780361,
-0.2185540199,
-0.472335279,
-0.0403600708,
-0.2846715748,
-0.0202149861,
0.7879989743,
-0.6495201588,
-0.3573009968,
-0.4995249808,
0.0192296393,
-0.1222190484,
0.015778441,
0.1257853955,
0.6014176011,
0.4065746069,
-0.5239089131,
0.2879959643,
0.3316241503,
-0.7661060691,
0.1320666969,
-0.2724980116,
-0.6672460437,
-0.4153291285,
0.4895731211,
-0.8072912097,
-0.3568333089,
0.1410802454,
-0.3352148831,
0.191332221,
-0.1962001175,
-0.2735189497,
-0.0993575677,
-0.2763233483,
0.269180119,
0.3246556818,
-0.682595253,
0.7694975734,
0.7443544269,
-0.5613726377,
-0.6455336809,
-0.6190198064,
0.300075084,
-0.5459150076,
-0.3191452324,
0.4572009146,
0.3087240458,
-0.2752358615,
0.4111019969,
-0.3245070577,
-0.3438547552,
-0.0184109807,
0.6510354877,
0.1195674539,
-0.2140268087,
-0.0129318861,
-0.1886821091,
-0.5502178669,
-0.1227886304,
-0.0577263534,
0.2155741751,
0.1495373696,
-0.1581531167,
-0.6045773029,
0.978319943,
0.4529886246,
-0.4745432138,
0.7703416348,
0.1875733286,
-0.6372404695,
-0.1115463674,
-0.61699754,
0.0256530643,
-0.3301362097,
0.4120526314,
0.0479056574,
-0.5464781523,
0.5507233739,
-0.2107494473,
-0.2774476111,
0.3776874244,
0.1067130864,
-0.3936083019,
0.502076149,
0.7639323473,
-0.4235365391,
0.7084999084,
-0.3131917417,
0.3893806338,
-0.31382218,
0.0987786427,
-0.4607302547,
-0.3006316721,
-0.5348398685,
-0.177893877,
0.4769009948,
0.0206701364,
-0.1850097328,
0.2287208885,
0.1603747904,
0.2390417159,
0.3719926775,
0.2315151691,
0.3998656571,
0.3782845736,
0.7338077426,
0.1137837172,
-0.6492068172,
-0.3102456033,
0.6681798697,
0.1153968722,
0.6517995596,
0.0785973519,
0.3799303472,
0.5464906096,
0.7668382525,
-0.4054014981,
0.0859975964,
0.3010466993,
-0.7627626061,
-0.3736898005,
-0.4378010929,
-1.1994123459,
-0.032116767,
-0.2809563279,
-0.5343607068,
0.6476726532,
-0.1466510445,
-0.5938823223,
0.2602546811,
-0.2360787839,
0.2292210907,
0.1416153312,
-0.075578101,
-0.4951581657,
-0.6062642932,
0.0472114943,
-0.0830046386,
0.6989681721,
-0.2237464041,
-0.1999424547,
0.1967040747,
-0.4558456242,
0.9416408539,
-0.2338849157,
0.1557670832,
0.7516789436,
-0.1710567474,
0.5357887149,
0.5882969499,
0.0634656772,
-0.0466985442,
-0.3263585567,
-0.5006914735,
-0.6339064837,
0.2754743397,
-0.4825767577,
-0.3197802901,
-0.51747334,
-1.0777580738,
-0.0471470207,
-0.232033506,
0.1568538547,
0.7007033825,
0.1986891329,
0.1636101454,
0.1500671059,
-0.2264786065,
0.9570234418,
0.7696895003,
0.1210155636,
-0.6846187115,
0.8583660126,
0.344884336,
-0.2818339467,
0.7156264782,
0.1721640676,
0.0980243534,
-0.4228188097,
-0.0413865671,
0.0120143816,
-0.1938585937,
-0.8579943776,
-0.2587330043,
-0.3625699282,
0.2004694492,
-0.2594846785,
-0.24048163,
-0.1526521146,
0.1141638607,
-0.1725468338,
0.2535803318,
0.4285350442,
-0.4465915859,
0.396199137,
-1.249057889,
0.1200504452,
-0.242685616,
0.126590997,
-0.2770006061,
-0.2192553431,
-0.5820522308,
-0.0594068505,
-0.3800728917,
-0.9965043664,
0.7672296762,
0.2955338061,
0.221013248,
0.5554748178,
0.2888506949,
0.9703164697,
-0.4929053783,
0.3329545259,
-0.0817991719,
-0.5082312226,
0.5962636471,
-0.5228822231,
-0.076722607,
0.0700692162,
0.6119713187,
-0.3201622367,
-0.0794126615,
-0.4790328145,
-0.7411655188,
0.086475566,
0.2213434279,
-0.2787653506,
-0.132762745,
0.405076921,
0.0561891496,
0.0862105861,
-0.3799644411,
-0.0438742079,
0.0954580605,
-0.0099821622,
-0.0962108374,
-0.4330891073,
-0.0524102636,
0.0148188137,
0.6231657267,
0.0210039914,
-0.1279796511,
0.5590930581,
-0.1122194454,
-0.2068564445,
0.1154073551,
0.5378151536,
0.4826113582,
-0.0343845859,
0.0683384985,
-0.4347628355,
-0.737822175,
0.0748602003,
0.5321509838,
-0.2452507615,
0.1491013467,
0.6856023073,
0.267103523,
0.5072180033,
-0.6974679232,
0.8020327687,
0.2176241279,
0.140515551,
-0.5261476636,
-0.4644038677,
-0.1616663188,
0.6678286195,
1.0669475794,
0.3150970042,
0.2643197775,
-0.1485052258,
0.3756423891,
0.1904698014,
-0.3716976345,
-0.2544829845,
0.3909719288,
0.2356695682,
-0.061705891,
0.5859774947,
-0.1067247465,
-0.1490198225,
0.8291375041,
0.4042022228,
0.5905331969,
-0.5032917857,
0.3294437826,
0.4182232618,
0.4456948638,
0.139736563,
0.6147994995,
0.1583867222,
-0.8981996179,
-0.7341749668,
-0.5392567515,
0.1823439747,
0.3693919778,
-0.7483227849,
0.0447663292,
0.0711780041,
-0.1191056296,
-0.2051391602,
-0.0173224043,
-0.4996285737,
0.0919794291,
-0.0892541036,
1.040525794,
-0.9932655692,
0.2312794179,
0.5366695523,
-0.2807740271,
-0.4699191153,
0.1385654956,
-0.0455892906,
-0.4541609287,
0.3722815514,
0.4812350273,
0.2294148505,
-0.0578136966,
-0.4270297587,
-0.9811077118,
0.9537826777,
0.0832531154,
-0.4154492021,
0.0286865197,
0.3422656059,
0.1662056893,
-0.4673880339,
-0.1417058557,
0.2193258852,
0.681996882,
-0.2108900398,
-0.6380926371,
-0.2298916727,
-0.0838468075,
-0.0188949201,
0.5108507872,
-0.3335736394,
0.0438392311,
-0.6511877775,
-0.4593880773,
0.1949736476,
0.8694505692,
-0.1122921482,
0.6981177926,
0.5359634161,
0.3478828967,
0.5418627858,
-0.0880695358,
1.2624464035,
-0.3224830031,
0.6173889041,
1.029583931,
-0.0285581965,
1.0398404598,
0.3524378538,
0.0525658578,
0.2211083174,
0.8495231271,
0.014027128,
0.8844077587,
-0.0947115272,
-0.423061043,
-0.203585729,
-0.2588279247,
-0.2590223551,
0.5588001609,
0.5169157982,
0.0284207314,
-0.6696031094,
0.4517197311,
-0.228048116,
-0.0742286965,
-0.4361620843,
0.3152737617,
-0.0505907051,
-0.1902477443,
-0.0105511658,
-0.3337642848,
0.2135149539,
-0.4231248796,
-0.170569703,
-0.1432771236,
0.0083877873,
-0.470318526,
-0.7003154755,
0.752614975,
-0.1671644598,
-0.3809497356,
-0.0876102373,
0.4483773708,
-0.3764807284,
-0.2875390351,
0.2121440619,
0.4501500726,
0.1047315523,
-0.3281495571,
-0.0133894673,
-0.3115628064,
-0.4104250968,
-0.6589026451,
0.1548578739,
0.2314895689,
-0.014723937,
0.6394159794,
0.3867246807,
0.2881515026,
-0.0503520593,
-0.3405366838,
0.4778352082,
-0.8738307357,
-0.4435148239,
-0.6272475123,
0.5404381752,
-0.1932725012,
-0.4350335896,
0.4897538424,
0.9079222679,
0.3290882111,
-0.1159320697,
0.8510228992,
-0.0367554724,
0.2002013922,
-0.2116741836,
0.5536504984,
-0.4580873251,
-0.0209296793,
0.0535456277,
-0.805814445,
-0.4747033119,
0.3032147884,
-0.4431296885,
-0.2800584733,
0.5259532332,
0.5836992264,
0.1984233856,
0.4607013464,
0.1240249351,
0.183259815,
0.2528676987,
0.2905092239,
0.7113941312,
-0.3397439122,
0.613026917,
0.0437288061,
-0.7580624223,
-0.4702249169,
-1.1699472666,
-0.2084190845,
-0.8363976479,
-0.2317329496,
-0.1554671228,
0.1924571842,
0.4912968874,
0.7096201181,
-0.6603681445,
0.0496567562,
0.2668188512,
0.1045455933,
-0.6047754884,
-0.3128448725,
0.7559018731,
-0.1485330164,
-0.4679647088,
0.6104633808,
0.7674082518,
0.1498474926,
0.1109337956,
0.4602313042,
-0.0270220432,
-0.1361155063,
0.4373940527,
0.3170183599,
-0.1423799098,
-0.5270206332,
-0.4592536092,
-0.1600600332,
0.1448527724,
0.6585957408,
-0.7444110513,
-0.1667939425,
0.4723475575,
1.0236673355,
0.5601407886,
0.13462542,
0.3821531534,
-0.3364881277,
0.5024627447,
-0.0036666095,
0.2571301758,
0.1233868226,
-0.6446874142,
0.6280397773,
0.3167636395,
-0.5598763227,
-0.6917595267,
0.2790097594,
-0.8182238936,
0.0314825885,
1.0474295616,
-0.0291401967,
-0.2231849879,
-0.3214375973,
0.0836393237,
-0.0535461567,
-0.1537295729,
0.9327479005,
0.5978170633,
-0.062409766,
-0.0560399778,
-0.7831107974,
0.29513973,
-0.0625385344,
-0.7165548205,
0.0253991745,
0.2564021051,
0.3413836956,
0.4202027619,
0.2284381241,
-0.0812590048,
0.3063849807,
0.1864139438,
0.0539783575,
0.0966018811,
-0.8165744543,
-0.0968101248,
0.5406622291,
-0.7855380774,
-0.2781929374
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02931v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02931v2
|
WhisBERT: Multimodal Text-Audio Language Modeling on 100M Words
| 2023-12-05T18:03:13 | 2023-12-07T00:37:29 |
Lukas Wolf, Greta Tuckute, Klemen Kotar, Eghbal Hosseini, Tamar Regev, Ethan Wilcox, Alex Warstadt
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Training on multiple modalities of input can augment the capabilities of a
language model. Here, we ask whether such a training regime can improve the
quality and efficiency of these systems as well. We focus on text--audio and
introduce Whisbert, which is inspired by the text--image approach of FLAVA
(Singh et al., 2022). In accordance with Babylm guidelines (Warstadt et al.,
2023), we pretrain Whisbert on a dataset comprising only 100 million words plus
their corresponding speech from the word-aligned version of the People's Speech
dataset (Galvez et al., 2021). To assess the impact of multimodality, we
compare versions of the model that are trained on text only and on both audio
and text simultaneously. We find that while Whisbert is able to perform well on
multimodal masked modeling and surpasses the Babylm baselines in most benchmark
tasks, it struggles to optimize its complex objective and outperform its
text-only Whisbert baseline.
|
[
-0.2813952863,
-0.6200986505,
0.3075533509,
0.1162312254,
-0.204587549,
0.0272456836,
-0.5820571184,
-0.7114557624,
0.1366431564,
0.2604107261,
-0.4975364506,
-0.3187604547,
-0.8105524778,
-0.0302564241,
-0.4194205701,
0.8792421818,
0.1953450143,
0.3719266951,
-0.2205568105,
-0.4807416797,
-0.2911221683,
-0.4034284651,
-0.2081264704,
-0.2960227132,
0.6628683209,
0.3345346153,
0.6938807964,
0.4559186995,
0.2970116138,
0.3702073693,
0.0504252799,
0.2484015673,
-0.2587167323,
0.4724391997,
0.2761204839,
-0.076717779,
-0.3307379484,
0.1739470661,
0.483817786,
0.9246398211,
-0.2573721409,
0.2056377381,
0.2405067831,
0.4801204801,
-0.8057179451,
0.0155578144,
-0.4702858627,
-0.0974189416,
-0.195513472,
-0.2144028991,
-0.5789983869,
0.080795601,
0.4535759091,
-0.6169984937,
-0.0164693967,
0.0048533273,
0.7989929914,
0.1988818645,
-0.5476246476,
-0.3285918236,
-1.0816887617,
0.9529454112,
-0.5962223411,
0.7934131026,
0.415543884,
0.1817815304,
0.1075655073,
-0.7318485379,
-0.6834357977,
-0.3135848641,
0.1373974532,
0.0056425389,
-0.1955929399,
0.2132460475,
0.3629481196,
0.114158839,
-0.6160712242,
-0.2971734703,
-0.6626224518,
-0.5355189443,
0.48728773,
-0.0150929866,
0.2670821846,
0.1305136085,
-0.3995512426,
-0.48787871,
-0.1680908054,
0.1658438593,
0.5213554502,
0.2355371565,
0.0686117113,
0.6440101266,
-0.1667446643,
0.8822978139,
-0.4996078312,
-0.6356898546,
0.5152225494,
-0.2114378512,
-0.186172545,
0.2255158275,
0.8885146379,
0.1502199024,
0.2837097943,
-0.1124439761,
-0.3268788457,
0.2715407908,
0.210321933,
-0.7557970881,
-0.3258218765,
0.2945113182,
-0.3656361699,
-0.0731188878,
-0.0674375892,
-0.484424293,
-0.3910885155,
-0.4999248683,
0.8971816301,
-0.7505837679,
-0.2893611491,
0.2583794594,
-0.35003829,
-0.1869872659,
0.3088839948,
-0.906068325,
-0.0603749342,
0.3664990962,
0.7177141905,
0.1451543123,
-0.5931500196,
-0.6860440969,
0.0673105791,
-0.4156006575,
0.6137786508,
-0.6817547679,
-0.294188112,
0.2053576857,
-0.1473388672,
-0.1329407692,
-0.1751450151,
0.3078851104,
-0.3581699431,
0.5776250362,
-0.1512751281,
-0.3607131243,
-0.1619446278,
0.0961874947,
-0.7932281494,
1.0575395823,
-0.0471122712,
-0.7577443123,
0.5741357803,
-0.5965804458,
-0.6265301108,
-0.0613189824,
0.1474823058,
-0.2136580497,
0.2527485192,
0.0027678041,
0.2787177861,
-0.0388144292,
0.2118887752,
-0.2393738925,
-0.3565614522,
0.2576416433,
-0.747688055,
0.6551166773,
0.265065074,
-0.2257119715,
0.1522445083,
-1.0327032804,
0.0983462259,
-0.1954782754,
-0.4806761146,
-0.523494184,
-0.0085589737,
0.5803940296,
0.4658318162,
0.1406691372,
-0.8485494256,
-0.0517645851,
-0.2905627489,
0.4825637341,
0.4346986413,
-0.4461917281,
0.4880308509,
-0.3637556136,
0.6333816051,
-0.1394872963,
0.2908408046,
-0.5703157187,
-0.4653010964,
-0.7948271036,
-0.7375637889,
0.5584753156,
0.2932187021,
-0.9807837009,
0.0549925044,
-0.2630792856,
-0.5397959352,
-0.810744226,
0.0635510981,
0.390019387,
0.3939976692,
0.4465534985,
-0.4093463123,
-0.5368922949,
-1.0776047707,
-0.1512786746,
-0.2109979093,
0.0544180609,
-0.0974967703,
0.2576129138,
-0.2776588798,
0.8760328293,
-0.2158786803,
-0.2768093646,
-0.2823379636,
0.4408842921,
-0.1773453653,
0.3501029015,
0.4372500479,
-0.7244580388,
-0.3239306211,
-0.2673636377,
-0.5431240201,
0.0541601628,
0.0548655577,
0.1160300151,
0.1829957813,
0.4855876267,
-0.5545790792,
0.056169197,
1.0661283731,
-0.1712267548,
0.4872840345,
-0.52504915,
0.2375178635,
-1.1145396233,
-0.088987574,
0.0804536715,
-0.2439951152,
-1.0372442007,
-0.2824211717,
0.2972494364,
-0.2799133062,
-0.753847301,
0.3786364794,
-0.3604024053,
0.0931984112,
-0.3935515583,
0.2270790935,
0.2628785968,
0.6450801492,
-0.1136334613,
0.8843263984,
0.7133585215,
-0.4869222641,
0.3411902785,
0.1694450974,
-0.5401182175,
0.5670616627,
-0.6045951247,
-0.0658529922,
-0.4861798286,
0.2708693743,
-1.1797603369,
-0.1656234115,
-0.1791188568,
-0.2797637582,
0.4762026668,
0.2424504906,
-0.6407155395,
-0.1246039793,
-0.5224399567,
0.4873907864,
0.4329354465,
-0.5347639322,
0.7197269201,
0.4763762057,
-0.060636986,
-0.6667675972,
-0.6359109282,
0.1997110844,
-0.0782401115,
-0.6457996964,
0.280135721,
-0.0736876577,
-0.1162467301,
-0.13832362,
0.1130362526,
-0.0858864188,
-0.1200444549,
0.2719539404,
0.269749701,
-0.0707939267,
0.6996804476,
-0.0722949281,
-0.1110494286,
-0.2751372159,
-0.3517853022,
0.6338174343,
-0.1321947873,
-0.2654852867,
-0.5935093164,
0.4178647697,
0.7135226727,
-0.4825720191,
0.8768948913,
0.8400554657,
-0.2769476473,
-0.0608261451,
-0.4360536635,
-0.1838445663,
-0.4680516124,
0.5586490631,
-0.3094442189,
-0.7440341115,
-0.041830413,
0.1075784862,
0.2787298858,
0.4188352525,
0.4443540871,
-0.5636659265,
1.1373813152,
0.9950711727,
-0.0044930629,
0.7520266771,
-0.1933805496,
-0.0390323177,
-0.7201809883,
-0.3974365592,
-0.4516479075,
-0.3066364229,
-0.5640654564,
-0.188226223,
0.3603871167,
-0.166912958,
-0.0015846641,
0.7561455369,
-0.3790007532,
0.0940917879,
0.5480873585,
0.0865023136,
0.3181694448,
0.1783754975,
-0.1506536603,
-0.3614692986,
-0.8871998787,
-0.6117460728,
1.0332307816,
0.455656141,
1.0293706656,
0.01237325,
0.3320845962,
0.3997234404,
0.3543815911,
-0.7794765234,
0.338395834,
-0.034017019,
-0.7797210813,
-0.3968821466,
-0.3663392365,
-0.9782600999,
0.7591659427,
-0.5368348956,
-0.533328712,
0.0678643435,
0.3658439517,
-0.0103726508,
0.1158386916,
-0.874352634,
0.666952014,
-0.3416098356,
-0.2796496749,
-0.3196187913,
-0.4200496376,
0.2943025827,
-0.1628656238,
0.6187560558,
-0.3273844123,
-0.1227627769,
0.9224088788,
-0.2789234221,
0.6512514353,
-0.1855324507,
-0.3149628341,
0.1447495371,
-0.0585841388,
0.1946311444,
-0.403450489,
0.1031024531,
0.1867496967,
0.2669284046,
-0.4776078165,
-0.318931073,
0.5089936256,
-0.5784868598,
-0.2247975767,
-0.4906909168,
-0.7697645426,
-0.5861087441,
0.0846312568,
0.3061910868,
1.0870103836,
-0.0854617953,
0.1696419269,
0.4337592423,
-0.2773243785,
0.827111423,
0.2706996202,
-0.1008840278,
-0.5057945251,
1.1171388626,
0.046147652,
0.4032703936,
0.1883048117,
0.1526285261,
-0.5009442568,
-0.1523959488,
-0.6534698606,
0.3121412694,
-0.8152233362,
0.0740235001,
-0.9443252087,
0.0559817292,
-0.1228711754,
0.2668834925,
-0.574675262,
-0.6383367181,
-0.0675451458,
0.3207553029,
0.2174571157,
0.571944654,
0.0950967893,
0.3683975935,
-0.7987483144,
0.1603116691,
0.4313945174,
0.3097535372,
-0.1084087193,
-0.7576624751,
-0.4841321707,
0.1719419062,
-0.2770493925,
-0.7477664351,
0.1969590932,
0.5427079201,
0.3925103247,
0.3253673911,
-0.1801169962,
0.6427968144,
-0.7285783887,
0.6856400371,
0.4980985224,
-1.0091825724,
0.2687994838,
-0.1611271054,
0.4113021195,
0.6870399117,
0.3136200309,
-0.8629130125,
-0.4943849146,
-0.5170929432,
-0.6789402366,
0.7273702025,
0.2044543922,
0.498219043,
0.4072532356,
-0.2146621943,
0.0985231102,
0.5923863053,
-0.6089454293,
-0.1088469252,
-0.2660895586,
-0.504127562,
-0.1398962885,
-0.3396359384,
-0.0769584849,
-0.3227102458,
0.7800585628,
-0.0902188718,
0.2130525708,
-0.0549039319,
-0.5546072721,
0.109815605,
0.3650273085,
1.0748881102,
0.8081864119,
0.0724863261,
0.4134777188,
0.1595257521,
-0.6380373836,
0.222816512,
-0.0071763583,
0.2036581039,
0.2802956104,
0.9648275971,
0.8017094135,
0.1925008297,
-1.0978885889,
0.7439930439,
-0.2081758529,
-0.505774498,
-0.016057469,
0.0172283035,
0.0557857156,
0.3448177874,
0.396032244,
0.266136378,
0.015311447,
-0.6182562113,
0.1407257617,
0.534018755,
-0.7033904791,
-0.245701164,
0.8197482228,
0.1000109985,
-0.3825175464,
0.2662265003,
0.1147869527,
-0.4382747412,
0.2165718228,
0.2410077155,
0.4736123383,
-0.2772705853,
0.2309752852,
0.2148192376,
0.4300794303,
-0.1841880083,
0.3338410556,
-0.2138458043,
-0.5578632951,
-0.5543150306,
-0.6980969906,
-0.4369831085,
0.1328650862,
-0.531648159,
0.1989614964,
-0.0591576695,
-0.3381577432,
0.2622364759,
-0.3781796694,
-0.6448892355,
0.2575574815,
0.1272576749,
0.7023268342,
-0.9908519983,
1.0836271048,
0.6715599895,
-0.3199796975,
-0.4955843389,
0.0584162697,
-0.2061776519,
-0.5130985975,
0.5302588344,
0.2849631906,
-0.2951782048,
-0.1873942763,
-0.4026890099,
-0.693505168,
0.8054957986,
0.4128262103,
-0.6979492307,
0.2307561487,
0.0923223943,
0.7819473147,
-0.1849118769,
0.2316343784,
0.281776011,
0.324778676,
-0.1038924828,
-1.0356519222,
-0.4996161163,
-0.2254225314,
0.1604019403,
0.1668546945,
-0.3815441132,
0.870459795,
-0.0566485673,
-0.3017322123,
-0.2244938165,
0.6277856827,
-0.1412479579,
0.0603149012,
0.7687511444,
0.3040114641,
0.5840101242,
-0.0379524007,
1.0691802502,
-0.4064550102,
0.3464275301,
0.9651670456,
-0.1049997658,
0.8742295504,
0.5684008598,
-0.1662249863,
0.4134174883,
0.4882957339,
0.1957332641,
0.7828835249,
-0.1592252254,
-0.4795230329,
-0.3030816615,
-0.2586988211,
-0.1143731922,
0.6851129532,
0.1065705419,
-0.175460428,
-0.1659603417,
0.8946912289,
-0.0815953538,
0.1520144045,
0.2215230912,
0.6554563046,
-0.1087979376,
-0.4014693499,
0.6831514239,
0.2602117956,
0.7924931049,
-0.5822174549,
0.2102241069,
-0.004236971,
0.0851599127,
0.0546150208,
-0.3204275966,
-0.0151568707,
-0.0982532874,
-0.0824008584,
-0.3598383963,
0.5440679193,
-1.0568062067,
-0.506380856,
0.2306477576,
0.4955480099,
-0.0425945185,
0.0288703665,
-0.4969516695,
0.2814693749,
-0.2517457604,
-0.2436866164,
0.0587908849,
0.3053076863,
0.0996362045,
0.6670669913,
0.6042447686,
0.1200229526,
0.0743002295,
0.1616009474,
0.8420583606,
-0.3985953927,
-0.3686183393,
-0.979627192,
0.5778844357,
-0.0069674067,
-0.3372306526,
0.5753685832,
0.6666409373,
0.6483286023,
-0.0964182466,
0.7280040979,
-0.0139848674,
0.2938686311,
-0.440872848,
0.645968318,
-0.9063328505,
-0.0769597068,
-0.3843251765,
-1.109559536,
-0.0563789494,
0.5606148839,
0.084995307,
0.0857243016,
0.9176962376,
0.7839517593,
-0.2327047884,
0.1286090016,
0.6190987825,
-0.2879631519,
0.3479372859,
0.2860220969,
0.9990695715,
-0.5725731254,
0.8321653008,
-0.3166777194,
-0.2747653127,
-0.1213457584,
-0.6800898314,
-1.0053832531,
-1.1529122591,
-0.1390289217,
-0.2785879374,
-0.100619711,
1.0800930262,
1.0779204369,
-0.4984868765,
-0.1300078779,
0.5057169795,
-0.4216448367,
-0.2513088286,
-0.0622432828,
0.209836036,
-0.4078472555,
-0.8769889474,
0.6048715115,
0.4577510953,
0.1064788401,
-0.5198364854,
-0.1271121204,
-0.1441587806,
0.2371049076,
0.9744873047,
-0.0649463832,
-0.4879950583,
-0.273517102,
0.008983369,
-0.4940933883,
0.0499016792,
0.9302806258,
-0.4718710184,
0.868242681,
0.3065817654,
0.5688735843,
0.7788120508,
-0.2805258036,
0.4062834084,
-0.8161945343,
0.6343289018,
0.1148140207,
0.399967581,
0.5304017067,
0.2158186734,
0.0637013465,
0.1738188714,
-0.1979102641,
-0.6625686884,
0.1844299287,
-0.7708318233,
-0.3306273222,
1.236058712,
0.2470451295,
-0.095239684,
-0.2286878973,
-0.3971227407,
0.1745707989,
-0.4186898172,
0.6507185698,
0.9481617212,
0.0173238385,
-0.3340341449,
-0.9526562095,
0.5354836583,
0.5222942829,
-0.6900843382,
-0.0773472339,
0.5237296224,
0.1213666871,
0.2904697061,
0.5363258123,
0.078619644,
0.2334796935,
0.0551338047,
0.3284220397,
-0.3079599142,
-0.6117400527,
-0.2550479472,
0.1636547297,
0.1660103053,
-0.5600972772
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02913v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02913v1
|
Let the LLMs Talk: Simulating Human-to-Human Conversational QA via Zero-Shot LLM-to-LLM Interactions
| 2023-12-05T17:38:02 | 2023-12-05T17:38:02 |
Zahra Abbasiantaeb, Yifei Yuan, Evangelos Kanoulas, Mohammad Aliannejadi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Conversational question-answering (CQA) systems aim to create interactive
search systems that effectively retrieve information by interacting with users.
To replicate human-to-human conversations, existing work uses human annotators
to play the roles of the questioner (student) and the answerer (teacher).
Despite its effectiveness, challenges exist as human annotation is
time-consuming, inconsistent, and not scalable. To address this issue and
investigate the applicability of large language models (LLMs) in CQA
simulation, we propose a simulation framework that employs zero-shot learner
LLMs for simulating teacher-student interactions. Our framework involves two
LLMs interacting on a specific topic, with the first LLM acting as a student,
generating questions to explore a given search topic. The second LLM plays the
role of a teacher by answering questions and is equipped with additional
information, including a text on the given topic. We implement both the student
and teacher by zero-shot prompting the GPT-4 model. To assess the effectiveness
of LLMs in simulating CQA interactions and understand the disparities between
LLM- and human-generated conversations, we evaluate the simulated data from
various perspectives. We begin by evaluating the teacher's performance through
both automatic and human assessment. Next, we evaluate the performance of the
student, analyzing and comparing the disparities between questions generated by
the LLM and those generated by humans. Furthermore, we conduct extensive
analyses to thoroughly examine the LLM performance by benchmarking
state-of-the-art reading comprehension models on both datasets. Our results
reveal that the teacher LLM generates lengthier answers that tend to be more
accurate and complete. The student LLM generates more diverse questions,
covering more aspects of a given topic.
|
[
-0.3295843303,
-1.1345973015,
0.882093966,
-0.0530061014,
-0.1687769592,
0.2134788334,
-0.2677163184,
-0.5606429577,
0.0911030397,
0.390455246,
-0.4597627819,
-0.419449985,
-0.149615556,
0.0899269655,
-0.4955700636,
0.4473099709,
0.0881473869,
0.3158790767,
-0.4292855561,
0.3065491915,
-0.3833302259,
-0.8441032171,
-0.7238225341,
-0.4304940403,
0.5558263063,
0.5616284013,
0.6824347973,
0.5132308602,
0.0842382237,
0.2247859836,
-0.1203146949,
-0.1308997571,
-0.5690395236,
0.2458912283,
-0.1200390682,
-0.5086143613,
-0.2344021648,
0.0470758304,
0.7599101663,
0.7061026692,
-0.1923775524,
0.115914844,
-0.1091358513,
-0.1499671787,
-0.3922886252,
0.0233651064,
-0.6178079247,
-0.0826820582,
0.248720184,
-0.169285953,
-0.3090421855,
-0.259275645,
0.325281918,
-0.5172976255,
0.0837179348,
-0.1458297819,
0.8138437271,
0.0711706504,
-0.6060423255,
-0.2289271802,
-0.852196753,
0.7124890685,
-0.9215276837,
0.159922719,
0.1207628548,
0.3632534146,
-0.3123849928,
-0.3721380234,
-1.1160928011,
-0.3618235588,
0.1724442989,
0.2058653831,
0.1188013032,
0.3208196759,
0.331290096,
0.1670370698,
-0.5248885751,
0.2515235245,
-0.4482165575,
0.0136429006,
0.6449325681,
0.5008775592,
0.4078462422,
-0.2830673456,
-0.3003333807,
-0.1143079177,
-0.6107210517,
0.2372180223,
0.2533562183,
0.2402732074,
-0.0951852798,
0.6802957058,
-0.4227205515,
0.6849505305,
-0.2006279528,
-0.2077700347,
-0.1374458224,
-0.1781762987,
-0.2349924743,
-0.0258561969,
0.826228559,
0.450979501,
0.5666725636,
-0.0892622396,
0.2044639736,
0.1624787003,
0.1399868429,
-1.1594614983,
-0.1278634816,
0.399843663,
0.1616235375,
-0.3028808236,
-0.3683970273,
-0.7741424441,
-0.2178208083,
-0.4098117054,
0.6787516475,
-0.1557505727,
-0.1403443217,
0.3843795359,
0.1899710298,
0.7096163034,
0.4991573095,
-0.6578761935,
0.4363098443,
0.4641890228,
0.5624083281,
-0.0829336718,
-0.4189367592,
-0.346144557,
0.2428200543,
-0.4104574621,
0.5693215132,
-0.5040467381,
-0.5135240555,
0.0456728749,
-0.2351836115,
-0.108707644,
-0.3502278924,
0.3314807415,
-0.6353793144,
0.2903154194,
-0.1941946894,
-0.7931513786,
0.0113403853,
0.720338285,
-0.340371877,
0.9478154778,
0.0945091322,
-0.5080896616,
-0.1179066598,
-0.6755959988,
0.0855651945,
0.2076315433,
-0.4677957296,
-0.1588380188,
-0.2758637369,
0.1803777367,
0.5960130095,
-0.4922439456,
0.3986212611,
-0.2841750979,
-0.9880403876,
0.5618382096,
-0.5626341701,
0.5739899278,
-0.1108271852,
-0.2841081023,
-0.0344694555,
-0.3649880588,
0.2043851763,
0.3302823901,
-0.397313565,
0.0630280226,
-0.1090119556,
-0.0819269121,
0.2064632326,
-0.0836213008,
-0.8729107976,
0.4047017694,
-0.4049996436,
0.303561002,
0.3206125796,
0.4196809828,
0.4875688553,
-0.43251279,
0.8291352391,
0.0842238739,
0.1189510673,
-0.475004226,
-0.36321944,
-0.7852239609,
-0.2633549273,
0.3918015063,
0.7673975229,
-0.9937008023,
-0.1947183758,
-0.3635926247,
-0.4129015803,
-0.5437542796,
-0.0592418462,
0.3920797408,
0.4942510724,
0.2269809395,
-0.2137283385,
-0.2113018483,
-0.6166839004,
-0.0996326581,
-0.4155254662,
-0.2681359947,
0.4284441173,
0.2728186846,
0.0532387197,
1.113524437,
-0.4860364497,
0.0006244146,
-0.1899074167,
0.0080323229,
-0.1231681183,
0.3073167503,
0.4848583043,
-0.4265531301,
-0.280685693,
-0.3991543949,
-0.8187952638,
-0.1074299738,
-0.2613634765,
-0.1582943648,
0.1707740426,
0.454300195,
-0.589926362,
0.5402287841,
0.4547275901,
-0.2687966526,
0.673255384,
0.003473209,
0.1860100031,
-1.1139340401,
-0.0731933117,
0.0070712767,
-0.2261504382,
-0.8029983044,
0.1749407351,
-0.0747363418,
-0.4069438577,
-0.7032748461,
0.9065056443,
-0.4135735631,
-0.0812692493,
-0.1690526158,
0.3995452821,
-0.008798304,
0.5971965194,
0.1239150912,
1.0110884905,
0.4630403817,
-0.4688073397,
0.193569392,
0.1820057034,
-0.173677668,
0.5437663794,
-0.8494474888,
0.178914234,
-0.0892648101,
0.4363628626,
-1.0330934525,
-0.2890069783,
0.3176204562,
-0.5592784882,
-0.016970817,
-0.1032825485,
-0.758534193,
-0.338721633,
-0.4045008421,
0.6155823469,
0.4875660241,
-0.3550390303,
0.6077585816,
0.0588623025,
-0.2714792192,
-0.4405053258,
-0.5132718682,
0.30518049,
-0.0627470613,
-0.5264970064,
-0.0646357387,
-0.3052350283,
-0.1130395681,
-0.226114288,
0.2810304463,
-0.1912622303,
0.205382213,
0.351683259,
0.6078174114,
-0.154932946,
0.1745516956,
0.1392736137,
0.2458566129,
0.1932217032,
0.131432429,
0.7237571478,
0.0275795218,
-0.6167395115,
-0.7260280848,
0.3831792474,
0.553981185,
0.017424278,
0.5918524861,
0.2634792924,
-0.2609113753,
-0.0721235424,
-0.6914519668,
-0.5731868744,
-0.4676680565,
0.2517783344,
-0.4060873091,
-1.1685266495,
0.4960788488,
0.022816604,
0.0530762225,
-0.1485410929,
0.5703765154,
-0.2975057065,
0.8327905536,
0.3949433565,
-0.0466234908,
0.2762311399,
-0.24194175,
0.1327733845,
-0.8416980505,
-0.2272449136,
-0.3684306741,
-0.2137327641,
-0.2719459832,
-0.7552357316,
0.3435373902,
0.2970461547,
-0.3512372375,
-0.0503252037,
-0.2889477611,
0.6618057489,
0.4704373181,
-0.0475921631,
0.2934671044,
0.0167999491,
-0.2575867176,
-0.0266674832,
-0.676051259,
-0.6512383223,
1.0180095434,
0.4259314239,
0.5977236629,
0.0324338749,
0.866532743,
-0.087444745,
0.5498813391,
-0.9259921312,
0.9113653302,
0.445591867,
-0.7398315072,
-0.5728737116,
-0.500513196,
-0.84025383,
0.4787355661,
-0.2417844832,
-0.7436822653,
-0.0491064899,
0.0137189925,
-0.331905365,
0.3880936205,
-0.6195220947,
0.7256354094,
0.0243221652,
-0.3831615746,
0.0650563613,
-0.4270499945,
0.3886073828,
-0.0316914767,
0.0891106129,
-0.1408423185,
0.0532334968,
0.4813115299,
-0.1614225805,
1.1392046213,
-0.1651136726,
-0.2497224659,
0.7453659773,
0.4367309213,
0.1387940943,
0.1085612178,
-0.1767005026,
0.1206461042,
0.4005448818,
-0.6644002199,
-0.5609340668,
0.5597085953,
-0.9524723291,
-0.8467025161,
-0.5249530673,
-0.7134222388,
-0.2975021303,
-0.1630363911,
-0.4309752882,
0.2099276632,
-0.1674625725,
-0.103120409,
0.3915062845,
-0.3133631349,
0.466617018,
0.798039794,
-0.5237917304,
-0.2049616724,
0.7978509665,
0.0383043513,
0.4673257172,
0.0451830849,
0.1416927278,
-0.2831994593,
-0.3068628907,
-0.7352494001,
0.4777643979,
-0.5379952192,
-0.0686397776,
-0.6215822101,
-0.4726767838,
-0.1899390519,
-0.1936119646,
0.0590144135,
-0.2559631765,
-0.4528228641,
-0.0470371507,
0.1680832654,
0.5395506024,
0.1951013952,
0.5990203619,
-0.6902248263,
0.1532451808,
0.7102906704,
0.0959748104,
0.3182720244,
-0.6490095854,
0.0320092104,
0.2530717254,
-0.4975417852,
-0.9367868304,
0.218637228,
-0.0632118657,
0.2299013585,
0.1461195648,
0.1166847497,
0.7043781877,
-0.4436552227,
1.0495642424,
0.1260620356,
-0.9802697897,
0.1524537355,
-0.5941076875,
0.4957526922,
0.4884875715,
0.2551501989,
-0.8225343823,
-0.5436236262,
-0.4017967582,
-0.7104026079,
0.5831718445,
0.1128826365,
0.5308478475,
-0.1511507481,
0.7469117641,
-0.3569387197,
0.1072916016,
-0.7019399405,
-0.0376720168,
0.0772642419,
-0.219132483,
0.005544194,
-0.5183314085,
0.0293616056,
-0.157497555,
0.4690436721,
-0.3226676285,
0.1510347724,
0.3819295764,
0.1231861264,
-0.1835161,
0.5168728232,
0.5393472314,
0.5246505737,
-0.2381497025,
0.0571376421,
0.521586895,
-0.3775182068,
0.2334406674,
-0.0931126475,
-0.2817294896,
-0.1830204725,
0.1431001872,
0.4519914985,
0.3728589416,
-1.0240216255,
0.6896284819,
-0.3110391796,
-0.4595260918,
-0.4024578333,
0.1203334481,
0.5742016435,
0.5132350922,
0.435595572,
-0.748724699,
-0.0381128341,
-0.667730689,
0.127817899,
0.4587889314,
-0.339225024,
-0.2256153673,
0.5718619823,
0.2050094455,
-0.4901486337,
0.5817217827,
-0.1456782818,
-0.6568844914,
0.7245278955,
0.5053124428,
0.3991811872,
-0.3001223207,
0.4246392548,
0.3112871349,
0.0768502355,
0.0657415763,
0.5467597842,
-0.1586699486,
-0.5900875926,
-0.6255731583,
-0.5545583367,
-1.0142760277,
0.1132130623,
-0.5590912104,
0.1076888144,
-0.3494032025,
0.0860649645,
-0.0609263927,
0.3387411833,
-0.6103612781,
0.2302609086,
0.2953446507,
0.693225801,
-0.7466956377,
0.9127927423,
0.6004754901,
-0.4215986431,
-1.1514085531,
0.1479994357,
-0.2175444812,
-0.7083655,
0.6040236354,
0.0406662039,
-0.0111239152,
0.1785387844,
-0.6162117124,
-0.5633736849,
1.5021839142,
0.4769864082,
-0.7084797621,
-0.1665806323,
0.6177527308,
0.7257052064,
-0.2978100479,
0.7063018084,
0.3020610511,
0.0776949599,
0.5701724887,
-1.080645442,
-0.0502510555,
0.1864672899,
0.0273902249,
-0.1160023212,
-0.694621861,
0.8522331119,
-0.3206533492,
-0.2121312618,
0.3153727353,
0.572553575,
0.6638566256,
0.4469205737,
0.3372970223,
0.3369800746,
0.4871735275,
0.1173735186,
1.0550123453,
-0.3094354272,
0.4106723368,
1.1911901236,
-0.6312590241,
1.1237654686,
0.5029317141,
-0.095972389,
0.2248351574,
0.5229022503,
0.1253023744,
-0.1382129043,
0.7773014903,
-0.5520858765,
-0.3305574656,
-0.284086436,
-0.1757302284,
0.4239445925,
0.0889656842,
0.0912141129,
-0.2701697052,
-0.2228363454,
0.2291382402,
0.1340067089,
-0.2221480459,
0.6462364793,
0.1194524914,
-0.3641575277,
0.7058236599,
0.1284616441,
0.6611407399,
-0.2697397768,
-0.1730272919,
-0.2618002594,
-0.1719256043,
0.1621115953,
-0.8852747083,
-0.1428278238,
0.098136656,
-0.0345043913,
0.0946749076,
0.5531668067,
-0.7852983475,
-0.5074946284,
0.3710228503,
0.8017468452,
0.461578995,
-0.0302067194,
-0.4657495618,
0.151931867,
-0.1633918285,
-0.3119302094,
0.5073860884,
0.3519317508,
-0.1646184027,
0.6942559481,
0.7320160866,
0.0147709856,
0.1867073923,
0.2070143223,
1.0204749107,
-0.6237006187,
-0.263299793,
-0.6849928498,
0.3433308005,
0.0268091969,
-0.0509586334,
0.4883666039,
0.4742467105,
0.7214229703,
0.0502515845,
0.5438066125,
0.5404418707,
0.6484376192,
-0.2063192278,
0.7422758937,
-0.4178056419,
0.2518905699,
-0.2266569585,
-0.9676840305,
-0.1560011506,
0.3891735077,
-0.3860532641,
0.1009092852,
0.3530057669,
0.9165962338,
-0.0122985449,
0.107762821,
0.8093851209,
0.0830243453,
0.5265792012,
0.6445886493,
1.1022291183,
-0.4802057147,
0.7059349418,
-0.0608715676,
0.0203949027,
-0.157436803,
-0.5395363569,
-1.1797430515,
-0.3199514449,
-0.1628721654,
-0.1400098205,
0.1419472396,
0.924390316,
0.6783305407,
-0.3685251474,
-0.578258574,
0.2822486758,
-0.2104317099,
0.4529978335,
-0.3090056479,
0.0970502272,
-0.0689972267,
-0.8809655309,
0.2330996096,
-0.0881211758,
0.2517592609,
-0.5434295535,
-0.1105407849,
-0.1938416809,
0.6534200311,
0.5993811488,
0.3746449053,
-0.8213118315,
-0.4127412438,
0.1021679416,
-0.240984872,
-0.0856338069,
0.6058840156,
-1.1259309053,
0.4071139693,
-0.0591376983,
0.9142534733,
0.6651948094,
0.2222962081,
0.2921405733,
-0.7249044776,
0.0372817256,
0.3666505218,
-0.1991612166,
0.3034828007,
-0.257661283,
0.2085476965,
-0.0552284606,
-0.6152795553,
-0.9848009944,
0.2102717757,
-1.0805022717,
-0.2390655428,
1.275868535,
-0.2612330019,
-0.195889622,
-0.0048937905,
-0.3398432732,
0.1404938996,
-0.5086317658,
0.7507413626,
0.6673771143,
0.0201087389,
-0.5162535906,
-0.7971730232,
0.0888984501,
0.513518095,
-0.9614462852,
-0.0808324143,
0.4997138381,
0.5629618764,
-0.070313856,
0.8173638582,
0.116341792,
0.2274248898,
-0.2564224303,
0.4448538125,
-0.113625288,
-0.1290298998,
-0.4161352217,
0.2497279644,
0.1807504147,
-0.1604170203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02901v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02901v1
|
Concept Drift Adaptation in Text Stream Mining Settings: A Comprehensive Review
| 2023-12-05T17:15:16 | 2023-12-05T17:15:16 |
Cristiano Mesquita Garcia, Ramon Simoes Abilio, Alessandro Lameiras Koerich, Alceu de Souza Britto Jr., Jean Paul Barddal
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Due to the advent and increase in the popularity of the Internet, people have
been producing and disseminating textual data in several ways, such as reviews,
social media posts, and news articles. As a result, numerous researchers have
been working on discovering patterns in textual data, especially because social
media posts function as social sensors, indicating peoples' opinions,
interests, etc. However, most tasks regarding natural language processing are
addressed using traditional machine learning methods and static datasets. This
setting can lead to several problems, such as an outdated dataset, which may
not correspond to reality, and an outdated model, which has its performance
degrading over time. Concept drift is another aspect that emphasizes these
issues, which corresponds to data distribution and pattern changes. In a text
stream scenario, it is even more challenging due to its characteristics, such
as the high speed and data arriving sequentially. In addition, models for this
type of scenario must adhere to the constraints mentioned above while learning
from the stream by storing texts for a limited time and consuming low memory.
In this study, we performed a systematic literature review regarding concept
drift adaptation in text stream scenarios. Considering well-defined criteria,
we selected 40 papers to unravel aspects such as text drift categories, types
of text drift detection, model update mechanism, the addressed stream mining
tasks, types of text representations, and text representation update mechanism.
In addition, we discussed drift visualization and simulation and listed
real-world datasets used in the selected papers. Therefore, this paper
comprehensively reviews the concept drift adaptation in text stream mining
scenarios.
|
[
-0.0817395374,
-0.7564527392,
0.6644583344,
0.1285747737,
-0.6984113455,
0.2905946076,
-0.2189831734,
-0.4033094049,
0.235827744,
0.4022772312,
-0.7104018927,
-0.6167393923,
-0.5103808641,
-0.0009726015,
-0.7597844601,
1.1699969769,
-0.2859619856,
-0.3030152321,
-0.2188748568,
-0.1711676866,
-0.6271810532,
-0.4053514302,
-0.6004093289,
-0.1496309638,
0.0693927258,
-0.0120463241,
0.2251951247,
0.5155950785,
0.7368140221,
0.2245060802,
-0.3819582462,
0.0764195099,
-0.7642623782,
0.4174424112,
-0.433591634,
-0.5635592341,
-0.1105937511,
-0.4671081603,
0.6056927443,
0.072260797,
-0.2925679982,
0.1851601601,
0.0200731307,
0.7467386127,
-0.6803040504,
-0.159063831,
-0.924582839,
-0.1729188263,
-0.4624240994,
-0.5486477017,
-0.4272656441,
-0.3146001995,
0.4786801934,
-0.8109409809,
0.5187743306,
-0.1813533306,
0.7433296442,
0.5879122615,
-0.2733035684,
-0.8759657741,
-0.8767716885,
0.5839806199,
-0.7310655117,
-0.1330824941,
0.1191181466,
0.1291089356,
0.1423947513,
-0.4964357913,
-0.372576952,
0.3963503242,
0.1202799827,
0.2198597342,
0.2944501638,
-0.4053499997,
0.0560998991,
0.1309711337,
-0.3035568893,
0.0892299116,
-0.2088479102,
0.0278182831,
0.7670785785,
0.3448029459,
-0.0524114892,
-0.2794531584,
-0.5964322686,
-0.106490247,
-0.1574538201,
0.0006097327,
0.1947630048,
0.3594886065,
-0.3827777207,
0.0450795181,
-0.2823162079,
0.5877867341,
0.0483750664,
-0.0808843672,
0.5453882813,
-0.3640483916,
0.1161324307,
0.3458406031,
0.6134499907,
0.4861522317,
0.2326063067,
0.2482271492,
0.0150795178,
-0.0034749308,
0.5677573085,
-0.6407342553,
-0.0388756357,
0.1411984861,
-0.6500023007,
-0.5013716221,
0.075549677,
-1.1513744593,
-0.6871955991,
-0.2040430158,
0.1613252908,
-0.5351883173,
-0.4906279147,
-0.0200515706,
-0.4429306984,
0.1866925806,
0.4869134724,
-0.7757592201,
0.2345263511,
0.7335262895,
1.3763999939,
-0.5672043562,
0.0454618149,
-0.0070310608,
0.1002452672,
-0.1129378602,
1.1595281363,
-0.5370333791,
-0.2749891877,
0.1079976633,
-0.2540094554,
-0.4432766736,
-0.125486061,
0.9952117801,
-0.5290479064,
0.1707311571,
-0.0578930229,
-0.8298610449,
-0.1243837923,
-0.0370785892,
-0.547314465,
0.9475529194,
-0.14461492,
-1.2838542461,
0.2446818948,
-0.8487533331,
-0.5470394492,
0.0518857427,
0.3118777573,
-0.4048776627,
0.2820719182,
0.0533731468,
0.4192562103,
0.0478413366,
-0.0681523457,
-0.3570811749,
-0.3947607577,
0.2235705853,
-0.046314545,
0.7230120301,
0.432405293,
-0.1140634716,
-0.0703876615,
-0.6030417085,
-0.0972531736,
0.0223849174,
-0.087721847,
-0.9878256917,
0.7216444016,
0.1973551661,
0.1041328534,
-0.2105824351,
-0.3351833224,
0.0209200736,
-0.3046297431,
0.6815232038,
0.9108989239,
0.6553269029,
0.4295107126,
-0.2405431122,
0.3390451372,
0.3515160382,
-0.1639103889,
-0.5459775329,
-0.3004655242,
-0.6376746297,
0.0691108555,
0.6439923644,
0.7010489702,
-0.8549994826,
0.386062026,
-0.6543063521,
-0.5643463135,
-0.5983842611,
0.1273385584,
-0.2138734907,
0.3510559797,
0.1701076031,
-0.1216675639,
-0.4002446532,
-0.2693023086,
-0.303506583,
-0.0629746541,
0.0008055978,
-0.1487779468,
0.3455583453,
-0.3717416823,
1.0842995644,
-0.8291392326,
-0.2978314757,
-0.0640871674,
0.3169879615,
0.0661016479,
0.1066258028,
0.5386070609,
-0.9611726999,
-0.4273567796,
-0.1224595457,
-0.606071949,
0.1096551046,
-0.6436650157,
-0.100538902,
0.4793267548,
0.579657197,
-0.4284114242,
0.2539094985,
0.5701045394,
-0.3149010539,
0.0707143545,
-0.013791278,
-0.2263633311,
-1.3113096952,
-0.261934191,
0.591709733,
-0.2340805531,
-0.6329675317,
0.0175927468,
0.0292363744,
0.17149207,
-0.2359933406,
0.397657305,
-0.2213438749,
0.4282134175,
-0.4083722532,
0.245927155,
-0.3071710765,
0.0787229165,
0.4085772932,
0.2868442535,
0.5177623034,
-1.0309660435,
0.0726221874,
0.1870254278,
-0.3029990792,
0.6172752976,
-0.1788006574,
0.1911171526,
-0.398637861,
0.4083810151,
-0.7618522048,
0.1001330167,
0.0946178287,
-0.5191047192,
0.152378127,
0.0108684329,
-0.182813704,
-0.0978983566,
-0.6575126052,
-0.2376341224,
0.4486329257,
-0.2126372606,
0.3560192883,
0.3832247257,
-0.1181156337,
-0.2206114829,
-0.4305294752,
0.0282630175,
-0.4901510775,
-0.3585632145,
0.5455721021,
-0.1645911932,
-0.2278044224,
0.2530475557,
-0.2656693459,
-0.0137130488,
0.318797797,
-0.1038552448,
0.078073822,
0.0058970251,
0.5458839536,
-0.115434669,
-0.0463501699,
0.0393906571,
-0.0273562856,
0.4071691036,
0.4278175235,
0.1693925411,
-0.2349064797,
-0.0409097113,
0.2859681249,
0.1306817979,
0.7130403519,
1.0166568756,
-0.3797920048,
-0.5503637791,
-0.2073165476,
-0.0865616575,
-0.4438593984,
0.4317536354,
-0.2687311769,
-0.6433540583,
0.3887103498,
-0.3047499955,
0.184046939,
0.6467157006,
0.7394607663,
-0.5728211403,
0.4799760878,
0.7372214198,
-0.0190592781,
0.6840379238,
-0.0402494594,
0.3262063265,
-0.8243624568,
0.0687754154,
-0.5632747412,
-0.4370310903,
-1.0507228374,
-0.2199460715,
-0.1136217266,
-0.0567018539,
0.3407784998,
0.1926884502,
-0.3999772668,
0.1721391678,
0.2024708837,
0.1545992643,
0.3335659504,
0.2012533247,
0.0774110481,
-0.0395034254,
-0.5310024619,
-0.4729740024,
1.1958999634,
0.4263298213,
0.5753607154,
-0.0717077851,
0.6448209882,
0.7592353225,
0.3546327055,
-0.7225016356,
0.2564168274,
-0.315643549,
-0.6586122513,
-0.3632999659,
-0.495226413,
-0.5927662849,
0.0843560323,
-0.322401911,
-0.4458519518,
0.0786408782,
-0.0396736041,
-0.1171111241,
0.2363808006,
-0.8602386117,
0.4870024323,
0.0484410301,
-0.1134153605,
-0.3251835108,
-0.4396477938,
0.3460878432,
-0.4120047688,
0.4827949405,
-0.1937676221,
-0.2926262021,
0.8636311889,
-0.1410489827,
0.829172492,
-0.3088425994,
-0.2040087283,
0.4895117283,
-0.1216803715,
0.591430366,
0.0478213169,
-0.1539416015,
0.1267379969,
0.0995438546,
-0.2474034727,
-0.3760155141,
0.5776049495,
-0.757676959,
-0.2212555259,
-0.6712496877,
-0.0885512382,
-0.2325573713,
-0.0941869691,
0.516125083,
0.1667901278,
-0.3645996153,
0.0717540532,
0.8904600739,
0.1568429619,
0.8965125084,
0.3543764353,
0.0365947671,
-0.1479772627,
1.0090404749,
0.1361862719,
0.1929549277,
0.6671649814,
0.130728513,
-0.2316718251,
-0.9948111176,
-0.3357501328,
0.0277872141,
-0.5312782526,
-0.2414892912,
-0.6200386882,
-0.289914012,
-0.0571048297,
-0.031680163,
-0.0277430508,
-0.3917330503,
-0.6533741951,
-0.1745382994,
0.7871071696,
0.4428542256,
0.3807232678,
0.4723915458,
-0.6823197007,
0.2932042181,
0.0289684515,
0.5112472773,
0.106517978,
-0.6111423969,
-0.4668624699,
0.015121513,
-0.486022681,
-0.7270227075,
0.1223307475,
0.3683433831,
0.2385175526,
0.4430125654,
0.2164704949,
0.4868484735,
-0.4329897463,
0.598477304,
0.085317336,
-0.8429191709,
0.6293334961,
-0.5841798782,
0.401702702,
0.5660279989,
0.5087625384,
-0.9352998137,
-0.1935721338,
-0.4940359592,
-0.8125734329,
0.7319115996,
0.1345206499,
0.3882675171,
0.3758039773,
0.5427414775,
0.230944857,
0.1035922021,
-0.6169376969,
-0.0771420896,
-0.4432436526,
-0.5466129184,
-0.1670551151,
-0.1765164584,
0.3655050099,
-0.048359327,
0.6274417639,
-0.1727074385,
0.2107994854,
0.085084632,
-0.4412459731,
-0.0370043889,
0.2435853928,
0.5354286432,
0.6274534464,
-0.387122333,
-0.1522129029,
0.1662017703,
-0.8864653707,
0.1935379803,
-0.0990453362,
-0.7624078989,
0.4211223722,
0.561409235,
0.8693140745,
0.1152809411,
-0.6199943423,
0.2242838293,
0.0201779976,
-0.2036267519,
-0.2330250591,
0.307641685,
0.3923676014,
-0.3088547885,
0.5685626864,
0.4282682836,
0.134463504,
-0.6165764928,
-0.0633060411,
0.0529728122,
-0.5589695573,
-0.3770696819,
0.2979414463,
0.4176923633,
-0.2719603777,
0.4037280977,
-0.3925042152,
-0.2771992385,
0.1991884559,
0.3219953477,
1.0206754208,
-0.286850214,
0.5326434374,
0.3299841881,
0.2236773074,
-0.2543832064,
-0.0633318648,
0.2293683589,
-0.9360349774,
-0.4939649701,
-0.6934788823,
-0.290258199,
0.0096909292,
-0.590523243,
0.4679309726,
-0.4457416534,
-0.3172600567,
0.2557285726,
0.0752474144,
-0.3863936067,
-0.1565451026,
0.3899433017,
1.0160902739,
-0.839353621,
0.620033145,
0.9085563421,
0.2145327777,
0.1909540594,
0.441822499,
0.2541154027,
-0.3714745343,
-0.0437777415,
-0.0879242644,
0.039879296,
0.0230619349,
-0.362400502,
-0.8561816812,
1.0866159201,
-0.1513166428,
-0.6310914755,
-0.0028445434,
-0.238233,
1.0336934328,
-0.4214830101,
0.1359299272,
0.4961870909,
0.2089026868,
0.2559766173,
-0.5121278763,
0.0275447071,
-0.215897426,
0.3398414254,
0.2529838383,
-0.8282823563,
0.596210897,
0.0535568632,
-0.5526494384,
-0.3579746783,
0.4327388108,
0.1184212565,
0.5603501797,
0.5113493204,
0.5778869987,
0.7874149084,
-0.0405626036,
0.7556702495,
0.1919177175,
0.4591009319,
1.0070501566,
-0.6175702214,
1.1313587427,
0.1917414814,
-0.0638011545,
0.9269865751,
0.8753459454,
0.0314885639,
0.8742067218,
0.0400932953,
0.03504619,
0.0000650654,
-0.0359801948,
-0.3339322507,
0.3813650012,
0.6367595792,
-0.2348694503,
-0.2193920165,
-0.1315920651,
0.0826600567,
0.2149601579,
-0.584834218,
1.0586013794,
-0.020013215,
-0.4141222239,
0.3222758174,
0.2379383147,
1.037784934,
-0.4716154039,
0.3572880626,
0.02122752,
0.3074238896,
-0.2368975431,
-0.5704233646,
0.3983066678,
0.164231047,
-0.2461423874,
-0.3369277716,
0.9540805221,
0.1677303165,
-0.7482007146,
0.1088096127,
0.4686124325,
-0.2745498419,
0.002617779,
-0.7325432897,
0.2585978806,
0.1871216297,
-0.2721733153,
0.3098213971,
0.5942595005,
-0.1036244556,
0.6588090062,
0.5076072812,
0.0966939181,
0.0928546563,
-0.0165421292,
0.707123816,
-0.9081565142,
-0.8564578295,
-0.9490768313,
0.3409251273,
-0.361133337,
-0.4265596271,
0.74833709,
0.3845440149,
0.7433897257,
0.0047244155,
0.9786457419,
0.0097883362,
0.8671584725,
-0.8738931417,
0.4484326541,
-0.0848782137,
0.1161642447,
-0.4963046312,
-0.9643117785,
0.0733172521,
0.4586821198,
-0.2660939991,
-0.2366017848,
1.0278559923,
0.0823546425,
0.0326735564,
0.5405433774,
-0.3869491518,
0.2421539277,
0.0365089998,
0.2951086164,
0.7218444943,
-0.3725112975,
0.4631392062,
0.0949793234,
-0.0710758641,
-0.4830904603,
-0.9550503492,
-0.8340693712,
-0.8163666129,
-0.7390795946,
0.0649473742,
-0.0309937019,
0.5984701514,
0.656270206,
-0.8773362637,
-0.2029037029,
-0.0550327599,
0.445368588,
-0.4517956674,
-0.3334971368,
0.4045795798,
-0.496758461,
-0.4214994609,
-0.2099164873,
0.1654734164,
0.0607003979,
-0.0795129538,
0.0822005719,
-0.4933028221,
-0.0367799252,
0.6530752182,
-0.1060994118,
-0.14249219,
-0.0728263259,
-0.0744981244,
0.1742403209,
0.1764054,
0.9219026566,
-0.7518422008,
0.3364953101,
0.5827260613,
0.59134233,
1.009773612,
0.1505053639,
0.1153525263,
-0.6774252653,
-0.0246131551,
0.1340810508,
-0.0825695544,
0.36249277,
-0.3818162382,
0.441839695,
0.3940850794,
-0.0819865242,
-0.8543821573,
-0.0800327733,
-0.8556569815,
-0.5222573876,
1.0102387667,
0.2571857274,
-0.149220556,
-0.2416392863,
0.0613220818,
-0.0890626609,
-0.5628932714,
1.0199218988,
1.1088360548,
0.0214147624,
-0.1856159121,
-0.7755147219,
0.665850997,
-0.271240741,
-0.8658427,
0.200379014,
0.0911256447,
0.3711962998,
0.2625658512,
0.5760419369,
0.2806963027,
-0.2247417867,
-0.2432688028,
-0.1702541411,
0.4756112397,
0.1350604445,
-0.535682261,
0.156534493,
-0.0761312246,
-0.051767692
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02869v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02869v1
|
Can a Tabula Recta provide security in the XXI century?
| 2023-12-05T16:36:27 | 2023-12-05T16:36:27 |
Francisco Ruiz
|
cs.CR
|
cs.CR, cs.CL, cs.CY
|
In the not so unlikely scenario of total compromise of computers accessible
to a group of users, they might be tempted to resort to human-computable
paper-and-pencil cryptographic methods aided by a classic Tabula Recta, which
helps to perform addition and subtraction directly with letters. But do these
classic algorithms, or some new ones using the same simple tools, have any
chance against computer-aided cryptanalysis? In this paper I discuss how some
human-computable algorithms can indeed afford sufficient security in this
situation, drawing conclusions from computer-based statistical analysis. Three
kinds of algorithms are discussed: those that concentrate entropy from shared
text sources, stream ciphers based on arithmetic of non-binary spaces, and
hash-like algorithms that may be used to generate a password from a challenge
text.
|
[
-0.3250288069,
-0.8030020595,
0.6659520268,
0.2756367028,
-0.1658571064,
0.3494530022,
0.2743532062,
-0.8583160639,
0.3625395,
0.6700366139,
-0.3714913726,
-0.185116455,
-0.3553147316,
0.3260119557,
-0.6081949472,
0.5343529582,
0.1785710007,
0.1982297748,
0.2086981386,
-0.1130232513,
-0.8547047973,
-1.1327248812,
-0.4588013887,
-0.3239252269,
0.4854672253,
0.4910322726,
0.6243425012,
0.3344106376,
1.0226929188,
0.2848956287,
0.2768134177,
-0.2055187821,
-0.2441613972,
0.0911174566,
-0.1432498842,
-0.9865455031,
-0.2283095866,
-0.0837446824,
0.5638495684,
0.6730921268,
-0.0315803587,
0.0200575776,
-0.1565783322,
1.3703160286,
-0.4015468061,
-0.3475467861,
-0.6783864498,
0.0361099616,
-0.8417780399,
-0.6864842176,
-0.7116968036,
-0.7735598087,
-0.117598787,
-0.498510778,
0.3660722971,
0.1425674707,
0.485065192,
0.0023521956,
-0.07342235,
-0.3608107567,
-0.8398973942,
0.7753299475,
-0.2045017928,
0.4990886152,
0.4277061522,
0.6243809462,
-0.6692536473,
-0.919680953,
-0.344984591,
-0.1583218277,
-0.0223073531,
-0.3864747286,
-0.4316096008,
-0.0806494504,
0.2852551639,
0.21208933,
-0.5481836796,
-0.0983186439,
-0.8644014001,
-0.0942082703,
0.4020352662,
0.5035482049,
0.7849882245,
0.1557906419,
-0.403514266,
-0.3272246718,
-0.8711522222,
0.4037159383,
0.5035874248,
0.2711255252,
-0.1033704877,
0.3831713498,
0.2150057703,
0.7504298091,
-0.2746015191,
-0.2926492393,
-0.0935196802,
-0.1947367936,
-0.3176083863,
-0.2967799604,
0.469376117,
0.0181287583,
0.4214423299,
-0.5175178647,
-0.103938587,
0.2522135377,
0.4155810773,
-0.2901210487,
-0.6263303757,
0.2433396429,
-0.4125510752,
-0.5542226434,
0.3624323606,
-0.9545148015,
-0.6167373657,
-0.1487378031,
0.4083132744,
-0.3124213517,
0.1024885699,
0.0686734021,
-0.7433286905,
0.2095984519,
0.3942163587,
-0.8663874865,
0.9768105149,
0.5914872289,
0.8332675695,
-0.1037619486,
-0.1546935886,
-0.3322284818,
0.0282848869,
-0.2441189289,
0.8246275187,
-0.4848935306,
-0.4028190076,
-0.2034080923,
-0.0521568768,
0.1301709116,
-0.0861717314,
0.2676581442,
-0.7292839885,
-0.2078774273,
-0.3788030446,
-0.2118763328,
-0.2586866915,
-0.1013392583,
-1.254447937,
0.3779603839,
-0.0603023358,
-0.997166276,
0.339753598,
-0.5210180283,
-0.5626417994,
0.0252283067,
-0.3699774742,
-0.3486519158,
-0.0143327471,
-0.0097478991,
-0.2023531646,
-0.2962014377,
-0.1807933003,
-0.4500810802,
-0.4843371809,
1.0622264147,
-0.7008428574,
1.3209184408,
0.3871331215,
-0.3426880836,
-0.5271030664,
-0.3830018342,
0.2569415271,
0.0564657375,
-0.130771488,
0.0122523392,
0.022797754,
0.0666802675,
-0.5911725163,
0.5161393285,
-0.7000204921,
0.2513356507,
-0.3825953901,
0.506337285,
0.6588628292,
0.1370070577,
0.4500049949,
-0.377920568,
0.6957104206,
-0.3205106854,
0.0477913804,
0.0501878522,
-0.3591856956,
-0.3175663948,
-0.3970782757,
0.7987151146,
1.0009676218,
-0.5619085431,
-0.1145712137,
0.1495131552,
-0.62537992,
0.2591016293,
0.0532369465,
0.1483444422,
-0.0826902837,
-0.0179551765,
-0.4115373492,
-0.8265001178,
-0.7983792424,
-0.2439427078,
-0.033017613,
-0.0739644691,
-0.1014744937,
0.3292947412,
0.2815031409,
0.5312927365,
-0.7113683224,
-0.4155459106,
-0.2888228595,
0.1165840328,
0.3358800113,
0.6338220239,
0.5973883867,
-0.7782477736,
-0.176842615,
0.0319872424,
-0.663282454,
0.1395139545,
-0.1849767119,
0.0753121898,
0.2682617307,
0.4631761312,
-0.302360028,
0.9345635176,
0.0442319065,
-0.3057178557,
0.4630149901,
-0.6689660549,
0.1934766173,
-0.6185861826,
0.3646504581,
-0.1819274127,
-0.3852720559,
-0.927799046,
0.5910723209,
-0.0452515297,
-0.360347271,
0.0336506218,
0.1813850999,
-0.5300112963,
-0.1454585195,
-0.2256297916,
0.0107194176,
-0.21998474,
0.3243503273,
-0.018346101,
0.5946477056,
0.3069839776,
-0.3939037621,
0.1784945428,
-0.1118993089,
-0.0883743316,
0.5946438909,
-0.5180161595,
0.4079714417,
0.0550942309,
0.3792086244,
-1.2750524282,
-0.2745715678,
0.3821892142,
-0.9627532959,
0.2782157958,
0.161239475,
-0.2901687324,
-0.2555521131,
-0.7015286088,
0.5508698225,
0.2282664031,
-0.282336235,
0.233703956,
0.6653718948,
-0.0178515278,
-0.8393166661,
-0.830319047,
0.6377279758,
-0.1551188231,
-0.6889116764,
0.1115831807,
0.077068679,
-0.5362337232,
-0.0975822881,
0.2434079051,
-0.6040205359,
0.6415228844,
0.3683039248,
0.4367789328,
0.380633235,
-0.2704718113,
-0.2235116065,
-0.2108383626,
-0.0207446143,
-0.1547012478,
0.5212538242,
-0.0841013789,
-0.3067348897,
-0.66348809,
0.7580384016,
0.5268210769,
-0.0404831804,
0.4039734006,
0.2058909684,
-0.6982375383,
-0.004960659,
-0.6031917334,
-0.1889131069,
-0.4824133217,
0.0111237979,
-0.4417833686,
-0.4235745668,
0.5539086461,
0.4377313852,
0.4969927371,
-0.1375112683,
0.2855567932,
-0.4620966315,
0.4817459881,
0.48737818,
-0.1372828633,
0.377938956,
-0.0565932393,
0.2077081949,
-0.2193792164,
-0.0775295496,
-1.0298312902,
-0.4345431924,
-1.0357291698,
0.2188606262,
0.5580250621,
-0.4037680626,
-0.0591389984,
0.6231791377,
-0.7231212854,
0.4883337319,
1.0049291849,
0.3872778714,
0.2369283438,
0.2526329458,
0.3641325533,
0.0195007324,
-0.257715106,
-0.3701778948,
1.3201556206,
0.3093729615,
0.8485726118,
0.2517349124,
1.0445628166,
1.0476571321,
0.2199607491,
-0.2432030141,
0.4424267113,
-0.1606384665,
-0.9369729161,
-0.6810219884,
-0.346860975,
-1.6058015823,
0.0121547142,
-0.273709774,
-1.4698112011,
0.4762750268,
0.1256363243,
-0.4652801454,
0.43116346,
-0.8874942064,
0.5387722254,
0.0386699811,
-0.0858480483,
-0.1902579814,
-0.6390075684,
0.5636362433,
-0.1347735077,
0.3029986918,
0.4202263355,
0.2861794233,
1.0014855862,
-0.4125767946,
0.8209280968,
-0.3121636808,
0.2678731084,
0.5478223562,
0.5400243998,
0.5299040079,
-0.1342520863,
0.2732098997,
-0.0284083057,
0.8135416508,
-0.5483734608,
-0.6064163446,
0.4862072766,
-0.6160170436,
-0.7598435879,
-0.5590136051,
-0.3344350159,
-0.0519004203,
-0.0655901209,
0.2583775818,
0.7858690023,
-0.2323487848,
0.3671165407,
0.4600933492,
0.2025325298,
0.4288092852,
0.0827718526,
-0.0163912885,
-1.0139774084,
1.1958889961,
0.5658013821,
-0.1007964015,
0.7037447691,
0.1238630116,
-0.0678777546,
-0.5363548994,
-0.3596151471,
-0.051947467,
-0.5713689327,
-0.4719727337,
-0.0194500312,
-0.0626474917,
-0.0736903101,
-0.3785386086,
0.3477303088,
-0.6499553323,
-0.0774227604,
-0.0195225365,
0.2236150056,
0.6956228018,
-0.3628356457,
0.2162436843,
-0.7612304688,
0.6447350979,
0.5288317204,
-0.1776044369,
0.2165988982,
0.0812467709,
-0.0600050092,
-0.020171009,
-0.3531011939,
-1.5295519829,
0.1986022741,
-0.4101002514,
0.2827455401,
0.0693014711,
0.0033021332,
0.2574191988,
-0.1851864308,
0.3901673257,
0.3887586296,
-0.882191658,
-0.216595307,
-0.2673944831,
-0.0458663665,
0.7008072138,
-0.1113545448,
-0.5262368321,
-0.4101326764,
-0.5572243333,
-0.3063026667,
0.4383375347,
0.5634089708,
-0.1505762935,
0.4434115589,
0.2951365709,
0.1775320917,
-0.0247524958,
-0.9924497008,
-0.4089491963,
-0.186182335,
-0.304971993,
0.6205918193,
-0.0016928646,
0.0599966943,
0.0267817657,
0.1124483123,
0.3164011538,
0.423412919,
0.3377088904,
0.1331790686,
-0.0892790258,
0.4712340534,
0.630892694,
0.9702830911,
-0.3460964561,
0.3319218159,
0.3530506194,
-1.0802812576,
0.5337377191,
0.0451695956,
-0.3766300082,
-0.2900512815,
0.274276942,
0.0217041038,
-0.0489898734,
-0.4086845815,
0.2736247182,
-0.2938407958,
-0.3492442966,
-0.7747766376,
0.3018488288,
-0.2823799849,
0.1558307707,
0.7062825561,
0.0537269898,
0.2864522338,
-0.7432863116,
0.405988574,
0.8537974954,
-0.1611793786,
-0.5269861817,
0.5732576847,
0.1701144725,
-0.8085602522,
0.1595432758,
0.0409576558,
-0.5183187723,
0.6110398769,
0.5607231259,
0.9529895186,
-0.3166953325,
0.2024500072,
0.0233358629,
0.887783587,
0.2019682974,
0.6871199608,
-0.2018599361,
-0.3703171611,
-0.0069372202,
-0.3656811118,
-0.7635429502,
0.0843210891,
-0.4365929961,
-0.0458282381,
-0.8024588823,
-0.3113686144,
0.2337501049,
0.1264171004,
-0.6472828984,
0.2665909529,
0.0117088435,
0.9418950677,
-0.4886832237,
0.4905945957,
0.1916127354,
-0.1925032735,
-0.4187874794,
-0.4778950214,
-0.2743532956,
-0.6825802922,
0.4325634539,
-0.126912117,
-0.2443310171,
-0.4137245119,
-0.7156974077,
-0.6178585887,
0.8594790697,
0.311958313,
-0.4664373696,
-0.2536506951,
0.7331796288,
0.444922626,
0.1107972711,
-0.0531622693,
0.8385457397,
0.7389346361,
-0.4097051024,
-0.7499191165,
0.0406231359,
0.0413811244,
-0.6185070276,
0.6803935766,
-0.1980961263,
1.0126055479,
-0.1365331113,
-0.6695745587,
0.2552083731,
0.757070601,
0.1238737777,
0.6250078082,
0.5432177782,
0.5440067053,
1.0092542171,
0.0272488017,
0.9138715863,
-0.1428879797,
-0.1523139626,
0.8028661013,
0.0001984265,
0.8523147702,
0.393332243,
-0.7381306887,
0.4242579937,
0.3952875733,
0.1302826554,
0.2011417449,
0.2516295016,
-0.154632315,
-0.010389341,
0.3331921399,
-0.0898476169,
0.220543623,
0.3374726176,
-0.1602630466,
-0.0625048578,
-0.3323178589,
0.0769072771,
-0.0400119461,
-0.1701889187,
0.6707587242,
0.3639266491,
-0.6121008992,
0.3113407493,
-0.0116819357,
-0.1440103352,
-0.5051317811,
-0.033042565,
0.1245319694,
0.0181694329,
-0.3221159577,
-0.9014952779,
0.0263756905,
0.086215809,
0.3688185513,
0.3760704994,
0.8232530355,
0.1458633244,
-0.7080874443,
-0.3489541709,
0.3623101413,
0.0205404628,
0.0469980352,
-0.0910205767,
-0.0491317213,
0.119266592,
0.0955645218,
0.2044199854,
0.1644116938,
-0.175611347,
0.8135737777,
0.6394364238,
0.1166402176,
-0.061743632,
-0.2740055621,
0.6433930397,
-1.0245871544,
-0.8207598329,
-1.2421201468,
-0.017926529,
-0.0978631005,
0.0012697041,
0.6904491186,
0.2975373864,
0.2787693441,
0.2169707417,
0.9279689193,
0.2109508961,
0.413900584,
-0.5012893081,
0.6817340255,
-0.107255809,
-0.165647164,
-0.5512594581,
-0.7096847296,
-0.2635598481,
0.0744956881,
0.0206946526,
-0.3624541461,
0.7834777832,
0.5321469903,
0.3097879589,
0.3063372672,
0.2449680269,
-0.3158071935,
0.468944639,
0.4547749758,
0.462706387,
-0.2506592274,
0.6725481749,
-0.1326754391,
-0.5321380496,
-0.2842196524,
-0.4526083171,
-0.9637158513,
-0.8374941349,
0.2841815054,
-0.183750093,
0.1038494185,
0.5384560227,
0.1724619865,
-0.56051296,
-0.4029564261,
-0.1776662022,
0.5302305222,
-0.1594837606,
-0.1329252422,
0.4866187274,
-0.1805951893,
-0.2533732057,
0.1275297403,
0.2624513507,
0.3319636583,
-0.5729011297,
0.5465701818,
0.3597202003,
0.7053340673,
0.0357477628,
0.7225300074,
-0.2939243317,
-0.238409251,
0.0776160285,
0.0459450632,
0.2976596951,
1.1384956837,
-0.575327158,
0.328325063,
0.9740104675,
0.4250901043,
0.2604243159,
0.1548437327,
0.6357544661,
-0.2400871068,
0.0378967188,
0.036103785,
0.6504428983,
0.0869092792,
-0.5427135825,
0.3253990412,
0.1745260656,
-0.5700087547,
-1.0730824471,
0.4101113081,
-0.9574143887,
-0.3542420268,
0.2934251726,
0.0151904104,
-0.9150242209,
-0.5649756789,
-0.466226548,
-0.3206805289,
-0.364718765,
1.0810199976,
0.7338449359,
-0.0207234509,
0.3122754097,
-0.29909724,
0.5030174255,
0.0099531151,
-1.0229588747,
0.2811805904,
0.1016668826,
0.0435945541,
0.5999775529,
0.5821182132,
-0.1974808872,
0.7859724164,
0.3435080945,
-0.2001967728,
-0.0541224442,
-0.6232637763,
0.0696873963,
0.5479915142,
0.2584140301,
-0.2286588699
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03042v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03042v1
|
Inherent limitations of LLMs regarding spatial information
| 2023-12-05T16:02:20 | 2023-12-05T16:02:20 |
He Yan, Xinyao Hu, Xiangpeng Wan, Chengyu Huang, Kai Zou, Shiqi Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the significant advancements in natural language processing
capabilities demonstrated by large language models such as ChatGPT, their
proficiency in comprehending and processing spatial information, especially
within the domains of 2D and 3D route planning, remains notably underdeveloped.
This paper investigates the inherent limitations of ChatGPT and similar models
in spatial reasoning and navigation-related tasks, an area critical for
applications ranging from autonomous vehicle guidance to assistive technologies
for the visually impaired. In this paper, we introduce a novel evaluation
framework complemented by a baseline dataset, meticulously crafted for this
study. This dataset is structured around three key tasks: plotting spatial
points, planning routes in two-dimensional (2D) spaces, and devising pathways
in three-dimensional (3D) environments. We specifically developed this dataset
to assess the spatial reasoning abilities of ChatGPT. Our evaluation reveals
key insights into the model's capabilities and limitations in spatial
understanding.
|
[
-0.2230723053,
-0.6275216341,
1.0725854635,
0.4453856647,
0.1018609852,
-0.2280721068,
0.0001543035,
-0.4328029752,
-0.3136487007,
0.4630526304,
-0.7351815701,
-0.586233139,
-0.4718213081,
-0.0397126898,
-0.0658784807,
0.523909688,
-0.2580083013,
0.1622164994,
-0.1741233915,
-0.1572235376,
-0.959104538,
-0.3969219625,
-0.4452691376,
-0.2043294907,
0.3303123116,
0.6028280854,
0.889667511,
0.1547133476,
0.7819495201,
0.2444887161,
-0.0398872606,
0.3767530024,
-0.4417707622,
0.078223601,
-0.2043899894,
-0.2458205819,
-0.2395805418,
-0.1961325258,
0.6545264721,
0.979780972,
-0.0259743351,
-0.4148153663,
0.0558306836,
0.8873698711,
-0.3017399907,
0.3179542422,
-0.5091791153,
0.2333837599,
-0.1208441556,
-0.1578217894,
0.0196237061,
-0.485011965,
0.5356639624,
-0.7628850937,
0.1551971883,
0.2810896635,
0.7350937128,
0.3772460222,
-0.4654218554,
-0.5502921939,
-0.7871248126,
0.4676929712,
-0.4298577309,
0.5397853255,
0.6406443119,
0.6544750929,
-0.3251010478,
-0.3807669282,
-0.1997042745,
-0.3985665143,
-0.1719262451,
0.2811090052,
-0.3365974128,
0.0173369274,
0.2441413105,
-0.1607610881,
-0.8974896669,
0.0358332507,
-0.6686359048,
-0.0384646691,
0.4465195835,
0.3120633662,
0.3412862122,
-0.6141253114,
-0.6734918356,
0.2543523312,
-0.7885332108,
-0.1238047183,
-0.0011561397,
0.3487169147,
-0.2566754222,
1.0147274733,
-0.1739918441,
0.5840928555,
-0.5341145992,
0.2164302021,
-0.1724601835,
-0.4304560423,
-0.0400725305,
-0.5076954365,
0.5764622092,
0.4298841655,
0.365837127,
-0.3411617577,
-0.1693725586,
-0.269274652,
0.0783646181,
-0.1691930145,
-0.4348916709,
0.3193300068,
-0.07359007,
0.4540257752,
-0.2603566647,
-0.7346798778,
-0.8591896892,
-0.2079856545,
0.2455386221,
-0.7567477822,
-0.0711858124,
0.3322820663,
-0.1074157804,
0.3191391528,
0.5277200341,
-0.8862313032,
0.103521727,
0.6576813459,
1.0364872217,
-0.1742206812,
-0.5113945007,
0.2029308081,
0.2013556957,
-0.1306277812,
1.1534169912,
-0.4576647878,
-0.6435032487,
-0.3365674317,
-0.238787815,
-0.388397336,
-0.4612833858,
0.5972713232,
-0.4088730514,
-0.1329190433,
-0.4427381456,
-0.1958689094,
-0.3847905695,
0.3362278342,
-0.5772707462,
0.8785744905,
0.391369015,
-0.5414440036,
0.4879722297,
-0.6220350266,
-0.4915782213,
0.2146313488,
-0.3403800726,
-0.0715374947,
-0.0227435175,
0.3680001199,
0.2814965248,
-0.0288793091,
0.2500819564,
-0.1933360249,
-0.3984227479,
-0.0297501534,
-0.477319777,
0.6638889313,
0.0650854558,
-0.1529049277,
-0.0087467292,
-0.7248103619,
-0.1726121008,
0.1805422604,
-0.6832790375,
-0.0423172228,
0.4454256892,
-0.1831523627,
-0.0141384108,
0.426330328,
-0.2810079157,
0.1806353033,
-0.3397259116,
0.4522362053,
0.716088891,
-0.0333004668,
0.749902606,
-0.1079795137,
0.5964627862,
-0.1387716532,
0.0916599482,
0.0710710958,
-0.7301006317,
-0.7728219628,
-0.056606248,
-0.2527123988,
1.0435720682,
-0.8000634909,
0.2166697383,
-0.5392843485,
-0.5305633545,
0.099521406,
-0.1387894452,
-0.0634304807,
0.3194939196,
0.2160344869,
0.2173096091,
-0.735828042,
-0.6601358056,
0.1378379315,
-0.1974696368,
-0.1881600171,
0.6251456738,
0.4937294722,
-0.2475289404,
0.9261046648,
-0.3531466424,
-0.2388592958,
-0.3516204357,
-0.175000295,
0.1602156907,
0.378605336,
0.1985848993,
-0.5194863081,
-0.0642831475,
0.2011515051,
-0.9416341186,
-0.186114639,
-0.2776884139,
-0.3214814365,
-0.2616592348,
0.4013465643,
-0.8042561412,
0.7509673834,
0.335491389,
-0.6342786551,
0.3441270292,
-0.455631882,
0.030242905,
-0.2440144271,
-0.307174772,
0.1780171096,
0.0646000504,
-0.4992014766,
-0.1416678727,
-0.1778811514,
-0.5357025266,
-0.115300864,
0.5666846037,
-0.5008935332,
-0.4990832508,
0.042464342,
0.6294896007,
0.064172551,
0.630753696,
0.3034499586,
0.5590772629,
0.4288232028,
-0.4517839849,
0.3510595262,
0.518181026,
-0.4773416221,
0.6080799699,
-0.673987329,
-0.1862550676,
-0.1223672256,
-0.0157511085,
-1.3597221375,
-0.3038997352,
0.4818513095,
-0.1968466938,
-0.2046490908,
-0.2129007876,
-0.5722674727,
-0.2546454072,
0.2956141233,
0.2779514492,
0.2237673402,
-0.4530434012,
0.6083510518,
0.30631271,
-0.1072757691,
0.0781659856,
-0.7448205948,
0.0447111838,
-0.2909256518,
-1.0089600086,
-0.178557232,
0.1124709621,
-0.2237187326,
-0.1735477746,
-0.1069124341,
-0.1430857927,
0.0066359406,
0.3857096732,
0.2883095145,
-0.0665912107,
-0.0511879735,
-0.3070880175,
-0.1600819826,
0.1110454574,
-0.0286425855,
0.231170848,
-0.1538021266,
-1.0029898882,
-0.1151622981,
0.2942549884,
0.3322167993,
-0.0552819893,
0.2741123736,
0.3101647794,
-0.2590119243,
-0.0366372429,
-0.2028105259,
0.3337233961,
-0.4163157344,
0.5131143332,
-0.4750866592,
-0.8729462624,
0.4477487803,
-0.134614557,
0.0319487564,
0.1690073758,
0.1302482337,
-0.1470329463,
0.8767207265,
0.235072732,
0.3757633865,
-0.0060021244,
-0.0157751404,
0.55747509,
-0.8924503922,
-0.7810414433,
-0.4156793058,
-0.2700706422,
-0.5769038796,
-0.7622185946,
0.6901977658,
0.1233743057,
-0.4751367569,
0.11856585,
-0.3594061434,
0.3603046834,
0.460303992,
0.2906446457,
0.1776756048,
0.182328254,
-0.2465159595,
-0.1767658442,
-1.0008977652,
-0.666934371,
0.7095722556,
0.4773446918,
0.6918228865,
0.3734477758,
-0.0020504459,
0.1874074936,
-0.1794335395,
-0.8662111759,
0.8886610866,
-0.0328155681,
-0.3627720773,
-0.5373288393,
-0.387427479,
-1.0015436411,
0.4448299706,
-0.1460349113,
-0.8765322566,
0.2225579172,
-0.1824008375,
-0.5081871748,
0.3550599813,
-0.968130827,
0.625721097,
-0.545904398,
-0.4175145924,
0.2237096876,
-0.3930049539,
0.2506294549,
0.0346136168,
0.2498057038,
-0.4227091074,
-0.0875312686,
0.3560661674,
-0.2020241469,
0.8087251782,
-0.3208107054,
-0.0631635711,
0.2479467392,
0.3049581349,
0.3208427727,
0.0281074774,
-0.154881373,
0.5113164783,
-0.0740668774,
-0.3456983566,
-0.5637748241,
0.4734627903,
-0.6193279028,
-0.5621249676,
-0.382478267,
-0.6791657209,
-0.6847124696,
0.0161527526,
0.129448384,
0.2175006568,
-0.2836087644,
-0.3092413545,
0.2954005599,
-0.5820188522,
0.1203566492,
0.4033715427,
-0.2634333372,
-0.1345249116,
0.7489762306,
0.076668635,
0.0032274285,
0.2103511691,
0.0380077995,
-0.4827938676,
-0.8950951099,
-0.3130337894,
0.1974804103,
-0.9123564363,
0.1410185248,
-0.1199857593,
-0.3977447152,
-0.0645132661,
-0.3443469703,
-0.0205737222,
-0.5066980124,
-0.2462406456,
-0.0892287791,
0.0191932544,
1.2484190464,
-0.3290944695,
0.4420876503,
-0.4529045224,
0.2656310797,
0.2736294866,
0.47173509,
0.0670892522,
-0.2884162068,
-0.144837752,
0.1738600284,
-0.1726240218,
-0.7232673168,
0.2630464137,
-0.2645098567,
0.6484876275,
0.1428875923,
-0.3533343673,
0.7566506863,
-0.8458528519,
0.8934985399,
-0.0261131953,
-0.4030577838,
0.8477213979,
-0.5467540026,
0.4837233126,
0.2096536011,
0.3070994318,
-0.21270518,
-0.0576033704,
-0.2734678686,
-0.9365528822,
0.5358577967,
0.6063261032,
-0.2544025481,
-0.072577849,
0.2178284526,
-0.1558887064,
-0.3574647307,
-0.6812080145,
0.236787349,
-0.143583402,
0.1958819628,
0.1892921478,
-0.5386198163,
0.0125046996,
-0.286370188,
0.3858792186,
0.2041957974,
0.3791635931,
0.2580346763,
-0.0045446665,
0.3586688638,
0.1447746754,
0.5896245837,
0.9306904674,
-0.2048830539,
0.0832497776,
0.3486113548,
-0.3366373479,
-0.0113317883,
0.22589311,
-0.0634990036,
-0.0987715572,
0.6111671925,
0.8884630799,
0.4006789029,
-0.7014245987,
0.3197327256,
-0.0552009642,
-0.1695625037,
-0.3714736998,
0.0493104272,
-0.0752272233,
0.5337771177,
0.1572778523,
0.3019261658,
0.1128046215,
0.0143104075,
0.0289878901,
0.3535502851,
-0.4694899023,
-0.1444603354,
0.7208836079,
0.0831059366,
-0.0410224907,
0.8679057956,
-0.1291826516,
-0.2607021928,
0.5301545262,
0.1290443242,
0.6314384937,
0.1166268513,
0.1841215938,
0.5093702078,
0.6254618764,
0.0810718834,
0.2607764602,
-0.2344999462,
-0.825074017,
-0.1230923235,
-0.5009703636,
-0.3682537079,
-0.1452646106,
-0.2685753405,
0.087625742,
-0.5163685679,
-0.1632326245,
-0.4166059196,
-0.1318784505,
-0.669976294,
0.0849862769,
0.144616738,
0.8796409965,
-0.5154743195,
0.2216334641,
0.6077597737,
-0.1625567079,
-0.5880888104,
-0.1632786989,
0.1101227775,
-1.1949466467,
0.7889406085,
-0.0098647177,
-0.2711336613,
-0.3169528544,
-0.2655269504,
-0.8070526719,
1.021556139,
0.1414404064,
-0.4713059962,
-0.3854952455,
0.7967834473,
0.4666721225,
-0.053051047,
0.1524982303,
0.8400045633,
0.6545525193,
0.4570713639,
-0.8373640776,
-0.1238323599,
-0.1207545102,
0.2136945724,
-0.2735851407,
-0.5147736073,
0.5250087976,
-0.3770611286,
-0.4860551655,
0.3017239869,
0.311537385,
0.6490903497,
0.124276571,
0.432635963,
0.4655392766,
0.8786553741,
-0.4432127774,
0.9790681601,
0.1144650355,
0.0205690227,
1.1329293251,
-0.3193235099,
0.7521906495,
0.1969012022,
-0.2776711881,
0.3035703599,
0.7214133143,
0.0760544837,
0.5088746548,
0.3379906118,
-0.3074145317,
-0.1822635084,
0.2421599776,
-0.0761806816,
0.7733148336,
0.6241741776,
0.150073275,
-0.5885179043,
-0.0710935146,
-0.1052463576,
0.0616472997,
-0.3242788613,
0.5405871868,
0.025100233,
-0.5413390994,
0.362557888,
-0.2391881645,
0.128450036,
-0.5923936963,
-0.1913887411,
-0.439081341,
-0.0663994029,
-0.2747708261,
-1.3262547255,
0.5450247526,
-0.0256570354,
0.1848897189,
-0.1540120989,
0.6456609964,
0.0451707132,
-0.4886868298,
0.1921943724,
0.6393759847,
0.3552607596,
-0.0083631249,
-0.71611166,
0.2297202647,
0.1196230799,
-0.2122693062,
-0.1032039523,
1.0828454494,
-0.0436354876,
1.1455603838,
0.3133531213,
0.3114478886,
0.0623608343,
0.0359665155,
0.6806204915,
-0.7404900193,
-0.3963567317,
-0.8318578005,
0.4602920413,
0.1262162328,
-0.1751005054,
0.918143034,
0.6400925517,
0.4147872627,
0.1816797704,
0.9557487965,
0.0543760695,
0.4596604705,
-0.846960783,
0.3432465494,
-0.3286345303,
0.9545499682,
0.1343890876,
-0.5367592573,
-0.3576851189,
0.9375869632,
-0.9857255816,
0.1881521344,
0.5994230509,
0.7611991763,
-0.213160947,
0.1329378337,
0.4686368108,
-0.0565057993,
0.2542828023,
1.0887240171,
1.2607932091,
-0.110437803,
0.7099508047,
-0.0863986835,
-0.1223326325,
0.1210801974,
-0.7046623826,
-0.9667907357,
-0.5786985755,
0.1149488389,
-0.1283041537,
-0.0472232886,
0.1015041694,
0.904866755,
-0.3828760684,
-0.3043714762,
-0.4100554585,
0.2430649698,
0.356690824,
-0.2269553244,
0.3586277068,
-0.1040905118,
-0.273537457,
0.5813809037,
0.6908509731,
0.2996057868,
-0.4422141314,
-0.0997590944,
-0.0263123438,
-0.1148164719,
0.6937596798,
0.3030850291,
-0.603589952,
-0.3683924377,
-0.127393499,
-0.0353154913,
0.3259046078,
0.603584826,
-0.5758135915,
0.346711427,
0.3105081022,
0.3141115904,
0.3843384981,
0.0597834662,
0.5932347775,
-0.5410462022,
0.1369591504,
0.2092558444,
0.5437224507,
0.6115442514,
-0.3890838325,
0.8263775706,
0.0389466248,
-0.7349681258,
-0.0458508581,
0.4239181578,
-1.1435431242,
-0.1530536711,
1.4026933908,
-0.0625130385,
-0.0996559337,
-0.3351188302,
-0.6216276288,
-0.2237722129,
-0.0803723708,
0.4232180417,
0.5786361098,
-0.5956159234,
-0.32268399,
-1.0951282978,
0.3260128498,
0.0518956296,
-0.7398227453,
0.1272317767,
0.9749456644,
0.0563023947,
-0.1708401591,
0.8690657616,
0.0122752637,
0.0360154212,
0.1639691442,
-0.341226846,
0.112033017,
-0.2465965599,
-0.1856012046,
0.1664661765,
0.178585723,
-0.0186075512
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02820v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02820v1
|
Clustering Pseudo Language Family in Multilingual Translation Models with Fisher Information Matrix
| 2023-12-05T15:03:27 | 2023-12-05T15:03:27 |
Xinyu Ma, Xuebo Liu, Min Zhang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In multilingual translation research, the comprehension and utilization of
language families are of paramount importance. Nevertheless, clustering
languages based solely on their ancestral families can yield suboptimal results
due to variations in the datasets employed during the model's training phase.
To mitigate this challenge, we introduce an innovative method that leverages
the fisher information matrix (FIM) to cluster language families, anchored on
the multilingual translation model's characteristics. We hypothesize that
language pairs with similar effects on model parameters exhibit a considerable
degree of linguistic congruence and should thus be grouped cohesively. This
concept has led us to define pseudo language families. We provide an in-depth
discussion regarding the inception and application of these pseudo language
families. Empirical evaluations reveal that employing these pseudo language
families enhances performance over conventional language families in adapting a
multilingual translation model to unfamiliar language pairs. The proposed
methodology may also be extended to scenarios requiring language similarity
measurements. The source code and associated scripts can be accessed at
https://github.com/ecoli-hit/PseudoFamily.
|
[
-0.366358757,
-0.4377269149,
0.3257422149,
-0.1101352423,
-0.4907862246,
0.3098180294,
-0.1593572348,
-0.4467358589,
0.3911036551,
0.100357227,
-0.3527730703,
-0.3102198243,
-0.4651316404,
0.3004634976,
-0.201347813,
1.0490379333,
-0.1123041436,
0.2666501105,
-0.0755974799,
-0.4998880923,
0.1811580509,
-0.6850597262,
-0.2473729402,
-0.0777662471,
0.3905268013,
0.5420902967,
0.6927393675,
0.8343858719,
0.5458123088,
0.3002437651,
0.1137254685,
0.1394714117,
-0.859809041,
0.0004848213,
-0.1577558517,
-0.8651718497,
-0.3643842638,
-0.1928170919,
1.0046370029,
0.9181070328,
-0.1176898479,
0.3268183768,
0.0159479063,
0.4995622635,
-0.4602936804,
0.1310854107,
-0.6568525434,
0.1762592793,
-0.3924937248,
-0.5172213316,
-0.3277017772,
-0.3203344345,
0.2067452818,
-0.5354395509,
0.4516626894,
0.5892615914,
0.6479372382,
-0.0149024557,
-0.3007909656,
-0.2220085114,
-0.9345789552,
0.8721730709,
-0.6526729465,
0.4775828421,
0.3523644209,
-0.0798702389,
-0.4049423039,
-0.3125727177,
-0.8018282652,
-0.1624472737,
-0.3318023086,
0.1905360669,
-0.3677145243,
-0.082787931,
-0.184568122,
0.6908669472,
-1.0004546642,
-0.2100424021,
-0.3713068068,
0.0004214217,
0.4478250742,
0.0991581827,
0.392660737,
0.3174595535,
-0.6301206946,
-0.0601822101,
-0.8308703303,
-0.0310018044,
0.5272327662,
0.3134999871,
-0.4757544398,
0.5562443733,
0.038429644,
0.529194355,
0.3273453712,
-0.2731724679,
0.4669314921,
-0.7044093609,
0.276334703,
0.2714391351,
0.6762980819,
0.4187749624,
0.3029359281,
-0.1190691516,
-0.1975698769,
-0.0220789202,
-0.0862813666,
-0.451030612,
-0.3772809207,
-0.193763718,
-0.6983148456,
-0.0958686844,
0.0532960296,
-0.8286601305,
0.1571392715,
-0.1610959768,
0.331815958,
-0.3717295527,
-0.7027320266,
-0.2592657804,
-0.004092474,
0.267873466,
-0.2404074371,
-0.8771669865,
0.2449062169,
0.4931005239,
0.8701241612,
-0.3149969578,
-0.4675643444,
-0.5074273944,
0.1940748692,
-0.5839931369,
0.8823978305,
-0.5283045173,
-0.711311996,
-0.0493505672,
-0.0836273134,
-0.5505844355,
-0.6895647049,
-0.0252860393,
-0.427413106,
0.1970916241,
-0.0789302289,
-0.4552928507,
-0.1597855091,
0.1627528071,
-0.4273388684,
1.0111392736,
0.5148108006,
-0.6741791368,
0.1576999128,
-0.2333028018,
-0.5729233027,
0.3085286617,
-0.0518275313,
-0.5321902633,
0.3913942277,
-0.47585392,
0.2243691534,
-0.2082306147,
0.108705312,
-0.5467047691,
-0.3011154234,
0.3134419322,
0.0477233231,
0.4862360656,
0.5239456892,
-0.0488692522,
0.2253416181,
-0.5997697711,
-0.2180786133,
0.2243846357,
-0.0741056353,
-0.7343379259,
-0.2397624701,
-0.0945549011,
0.3382784724,
0.3375199139,
-0.3177417815,
-0.0488036051,
-0.4863022268,
0.1458916664,
0.3199853301,
-0.0438387915,
0.7551602721,
-0.4478805065,
0.872846067,
0.2395219952,
0.2499305308,
-0.1015224382,
-0.564391613,
-0.6939477324,
-0.133666724,
0.272111088,
0.5057715774,
-1.0558322668,
0.3980866969,
-0.4887334406,
-0.3383189738,
-0.3818790019,
0.4896789193,
0.5456911325,
0.5206481814,
0.2782138884,
-0.5587736368,
-0.5011649132,
-1.0851134062,
0.0077447491,
-0.552934289,
0.3224423528,
-0.2235347927,
0.3762404621,
-0.0829191804,
0.8868523836,
-0.2574019134,
-0.2439555675,
-0.5496327281,
0.1625074744,
0.1283455342,
0.4486473799,
0.7907896638,
-0.9792948961,
-0.6596453786,
0.1915966421,
-0.4319162071,
0.0911240429,
0.1441877633,
-0.1620223224,
0.1570023596,
0.3608544469,
-0.1748989224,
0.1066041812,
0.898070693,
-0.1645611376,
0.4259257019,
-0.1828980297,
0.0167661663,
-1.3105170727,
0.1306459308,
0.1171059385,
-0.2831585407,
-0.8631055355,
0.2381015718,
-0.143718943,
0.3332814872,
-0.5786426663,
0.4527076483,
-0.2417031974,
-0.1066037565,
-0.2925376296,
-0.0801155418,
-0.301384747,
0.6638262868,
0.1082282141,
0.7614030242,
0.1909748912,
-0.39220801,
0.1511532366,
0.0944864377,
-0.1196820661,
0.7550089359,
-0.146929726,
0.0957546011,
0.061327938,
0.3671156764,
-1.0217915773,
-0.0336868502,
0.486907959,
-0.3141101599,
0.4916873276,
-0.2682591379,
-0.4017316103,
-0.1093632281,
-0.4351975322,
0.656529367,
0.3887895644,
-0.3537311256,
0.4846959114,
0.6111201644,
-0.4482560456,
-0.1165336147,
-0.6339254975,
-0.0865936726,
-0.6275035739,
-0.5805163383,
0.4694728553,
-0.3355562985,
-0.3470642567,
0.2166436017,
-0.0975277051,
-0.3837688565,
-0.0467488691,
-0.1417289674,
0.3543043435,
-0.6867189407,
-0.0320545584,
0.1737146825,
-0.3732477725,
-0.2254565507,
-0.4554047287,
0.4721927345,
-0.4006775022,
0.2653680146,
0.0077137658,
0.5760107636,
0.2085453719,
-0.4315275848,
1.127089262,
0.5928411484,
-0.3111281395,
-0.1532676816,
-0.333591491,
-0.0706202313,
-0.416212976,
0.1347894371,
-0.4496600926,
-1.0648437738,
0.6611841917,
-0.2507965565,
-0.270278424,
0.6481594443,
0.6862764955,
-0.214778021,
0.8807896972,
0.8774205446,
-0.0448844768,
0.4610283971,
-0.2721497118,
0.4625264704,
-0.6442883611,
0.0356228799,
-0.3608135879,
-0.1103231609,
-0.5800731182,
-0.4417582154,
0.4132800996,
0.2787285447,
0.4083138406,
0.4362807572,
0.1304177046,
0.3117874563,
0.4627038836,
-0.3913212419,
0.5009601116,
0.1593827158,
-0.3855057657,
0.0860161409,
-1.2413827181,
-0.4596661627,
0.8356255293,
0.0398292318,
0.2483382374,
0.2528655827,
0.885373354,
0.0808953047,
0.5315821171,
-0.6031353474,
0.3282260597,
-0.2232872099,
-0.5675725341,
0.0145192472,
-0.7724823356,
-0.8484635353,
0.339002043,
-0.3867774904,
-0.449418962,
0.570859015,
0.4166422784,
-0.4957115352,
0.0731515363,
-0.7762091756,
0.7657540441,
-0.2530921698,
-0.3293557167,
-0.3075200617,
-0.7865774035,
0.4461030066,
-0.6954068542,
0.5895397067,
0.10522376,
0.2173819393,
0.5627498031,
-0.4321105778,
0.5490601659,
0.261593461,
-0.2012957484,
0.4301272333,
0.2153686583,
0.2133988291,
-0.1655737758,
-0.0276406854,
0.4645162821,
0.4489331543,
-0.3478339911,
-0.3822744191,
0.8584589362,
-0.4387001395,
-0.2712579966,
-0.4113231003,
-0.4778425097,
-0.2176959217,
0.3529216349,
0.4115465283,
0.2093482018,
-0.1882884353,
0.0978432223,
0.4197781086,
0.0740672052,
0.3512346447,
0.8079659939,
-0.3311469555,
-0.2263124734,
1.3454520702,
0.3295301795,
0.2702486217,
0.4903296232,
0.3676514924,
-0.3068831563,
-0.710936904,
-0.5394867063,
0.3413775861,
-0.3425731063,
0.0305016786,
-0.2933202684,
0.2618843019,
-0.2181242257,
-0.0139454855,
-0.3671202064,
-0.5041515231,
0.1159882545,
-0.1257195026,
0.0040198597,
0.6479085684,
-0.2233341187,
0.3913166225,
-1.0364818573,
0.4061355293,
0.0214261375,
0.3688478768,
-0.163651526,
-0.3803773522,
-0.6810312867,
0.0998617858,
-0.0805828646,
-0.7052351832,
0.3096747696,
0.4389568269,
0.6645476818,
0.3992596865,
0.2556939125,
0.6202856898,
-0.5698642731,
0.4888199866,
0.3083786368,
-0.6820462942,
-0.0727847815,
-0.4721043408,
0.105614312,
0.6725945473,
0.3772768378,
-0.3899151087,
-0.381334424,
-0.4242796898,
-0.795425117,
0.6915091276,
0.4134208858,
0.0184623636,
-0.1092437804,
0.1667996347,
0.1523738205,
0.1932229996,
-0.5162193775,
-0.4348856807,
0.0272952821,
-0.5552133918,
-0.4088218808,
-0.3154059052,
-0.046974577,
-0.159383148,
0.6146139503,
-0.0632131696,
0.0319774337,
0.0536968,
-0.4414990246,
-0.7408774495,
0.0543672554,
0.7476585507,
0.6358136535,
-0.0195623208,
0.3996521235,
0.1988051534,
-0.3371244073,
0.2121098191,
0.1955286413,
0.0754975304,
0.0130060939,
0.4577351809,
0.3252634704,
0.4847414494,
-0.3852084577,
0.2483860403,
-0.0455863699,
-0.0742721707,
-0.3376144171,
-0.0811944231,
0.1847980767,
0.0922537521,
0.350856334,
0.0390801318,
0.1124314889,
-0.8338152766,
0.3013733923,
0.1072755903,
-0.3168124259,
-0.777538836,
0.2495045662,
0.2503187954,
-0.303901881,
0.1599239409,
-0.4294657409,
-0.7528708577,
0.3453056216,
0.6400844455,
0.5846582651,
-0.8587583303,
0.1344980747,
0.1063561365,
0.3491544425,
-0.1082679406,
0.0746247768,
0.0134645524,
-0.8758730888,
-0.2184011936,
-0.6945242882,
-0.1960713565,
-0.057563141,
-0.5706560016,
0.0191529207,
-0.1450146437,
-0.0750676394,
-0.473089546,
-0.3164400458,
-0.4053663909,
0.0244477671,
0.2199200243,
0.269574672,
-0.9486674666,
1.0141226053,
0.8207529783,
-0.194213137,
-0.6346008182,
0.0820599422,
0.135047242,
-0.4720976651,
0.2661690116,
-0.1236877441,
-0.4730819464,
0.3004718423,
-0.1142546013,
-0.8950666189,
0.568570137,
0.3809599578,
-0.6262260675,
0.2037885338,
0.4689897597,
0.8346512318,
-0.6100031137,
-0.1710365415,
0.4465552568,
0.4136115313,
-0.0146225616,
-0.7783053517,
-0.2311543822,
-0.5750677586,
-0.0589426868,
0.3430320919,
-0.6430464983,
0.5357365608,
0.1202058196,
-0.2629607618,
0.0832889751,
0.60335958,
0.2147625536,
0.6407608986,
0.7394096255,
0.286554873,
0.4413298965,
0.1897670776,
1.0044215918,
-0.7613781691,
0.3944010735,
1.1291457415,
-0.3759745359,
0.7589867711,
0.6397616267,
-0.263997376,
0.183634147,
0.491003871,
0.1449690908,
0.4010557532,
0.0709863752,
-0.1911249459,
-0.3056505322,
-0.3901588321,
-0.4576411247,
0.3514221311,
0.4717644751,
-0.3458969891,
-0.1880204678,
-0.1831487715,
-0.0287829991,
0.283516258,
-0.1216884851,
0.6022104025,
0.5280698538,
-0.5629277229,
0.4359990954,
0.1700893044,
0.4821971357,
-0.6661883593,
-0.1612588316,
-0.2675513625,
0.1189196631,
-0.2521312833,
-0.2722502649,
0.4676816463,
-0.0849163607,
-0.1827934235,
-0.1771481484,
0.4246786833,
-0.8703044057,
-0.6723800898,
0.4482724667,
0.7330223322,
0.0562195815,
0.3387171328,
-0.6134060621,
-0.2378062159,
-0.0828196481,
-0.0076122712,
0.3660140038,
0.1045758054,
-0.3511378467,
0.3408016264,
0.8524221778,
0.0690764263,
0.4470202923,
-0.2621464431,
0.5169107318,
-0.2112865299,
-0.5785684586,
-0.7418693304,
0.2327365279,
0.4289929569,
-0.3935967982,
0.9790446758,
0.8230676651,
1.1956335306,
-0.1331223249,
0.5340099335,
0.2350133657,
0.397313416,
-0.4279285371,
0.6132596135,
-0.5029671192,
0.0220399089,
-0.2603529692,
-1.3019856215,
-0.415145129,
0.6100188494,
-0.3028255403,
-0.0697610527,
0.8497281075,
0.6728680134,
-0.3164571822,
0.131803304,
0.3365952969,
0.3585867882,
-0.1266655922,
0.3593298197,
0.9211398363,
0.0457496606,
0.6036798358,
-0.4742142558,
-0.2935933769,
-0.3229814768,
-0.644875586,
-0.6746029258,
-0.7386409044,
-0.3490546644,
0.0330012329,
0.076600261,
1.0475330353,
0.5934081078,
-0.9698807597,
-0.4849663973,
0.1185661256,
0.0014023187,
-0.1904256195,
-0.1498231441,
0.1457488686,
0.0476265661,
-0.5634066463,
0.7214087248,
0.4343946874,
0.0187429544,
-0.1886874884,
-0.2476974577,
-0.4334625304,
0.013883031,
0.387472868,
0.3587892354,
-0.3204247952,
-0.0652968436,
-0.1798671484,
0.0253781304,
0.1879873872,
0.9008866549,
-0.3259439766,
0.5720664859,
0.5355072021,
0.1684199721,
0.3548276722,
-0.0270131566,
0.9133306742,
-0.5331910253,
0.2900326252,
-0.0773046836,
0.4593651891,
0.3057613075,
-0.2691224813,
0.3964083195,
0.4753398299,
-0.0209813528,
-0.827270627,
0.367338866,
-0.6705320477,
-0.0334706716,
0.9039592147,
-0.42423141,
-0.2446637601,
-0.4675138593,
0.0977067053,
0.4804615974,
-0.2094635218,
0.6524115205,
0.6266551018,
0.0657287166,
-0.0224414282,
-0.1800349802,
0.1775822937,
0.5897635221,
-0.2294486165,
-0.3597357869,
0.1168100014,
0.228796348,
0.3578564525,
0.4653723836,
-0.1905355155,
0.1748017669,
-0.2418289632,
0.0173109341,
0.0658755749,
-0.2981243134,
-0.6025395393,
0.0639478862,
0.0741939396,
0.1195274815
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02803v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02803v1
|
Leveraging Domain Adaptation and Data Augmentation to Improve Qur'anic IR in English and Arabic
| 2023-12-05T14:44:08 | 2023-12-05T14:44:08 |
Vera Pavlova
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this work, we approach the problem of Qur'anic information retrieval (IR)
in Arabic and English. Using the latest state-of-the-art methods in neural IR,
we research what helps to tackle this task more efficiently. Training retrieval
models requires a lot of data, which is difficult to obtain for training
in-domain. Therefore, we commence with training on a large amount of general
domain data and then continue training on in-domain data. To handle the lack of
in-domain data, we employed a data augmentation technique, which considerably
improved results in MRR@10 and NDCG@5 metrics, setting the state-of-the-art in
Qur'anic IR for both English and Arabic. The absence of an Islamic corpus and
domain-specific model for IR task in English motivated us to address this lack
of resources and take preliminary steps of the Islamic corpus compilation and
domain-specific language model (LM) pre-training, which helped to improve the
performance of the retrieval models that use the domain-specific LM as the
shared backbone. We examined several language models (LMs) in Arabic to select
one that efficiently deals with the Qur'anic IR task. Besides transferring
successful experiments from English to Arabic, we conducted additional
experiments with retrieval task in Arabic to amortize the scarcity of general
domain datasets used to train the retrieval models. Handling Qur'anic IR task
combining English and Arabic allowed us to enhance the comparison and share
valuable insights across models and languages.
|
[
-0.2658940554,
-0.4725434184,
0.0757122263,
-0.0106393956,
-0.255635649,
0.4009830356,
-0.1693142205,
-0.631319344,
-0.0076915817,
0.3741660118,
-0.409137845,
-0.3898539245,
-0.6349056959,
0.4229251146,
-0.2537105381,
0.9604382515,
-0.2391514629,
0.2485482246,
-0.0826186985,
-0.3859339654,
-0.5985854864,
-0.5613735914,
-0.5704264641,
-0.1813386977,
0.3408569396,
0.5185548067,
0.8879618645,
0.3908867836,
0.7569745779,
0.1749118716,
0.1172211245,
0.4964663088,
-0.3861143887,
-0.0394662544,
-0.2604314685,
-0.1695134342,
-0.2292059213,
-0.224735558,
0.7174768448,
0.6856748462,
-0.069100149,
0.0529708229,
-0.0215695631,
1.0424759388,
-0.705426693,
-0.2579111755,
-0.6263346672,
0.044800099,
-0.0350193158,
-0.3636030853,
-0.2648576796,
-0.457777977,
0.3280541897,
-0.6116136909,
0.1011917889,
0.2624455988,
0.8666846156,
0.0204306841,
-0.5994225144,
-0.3754030764,
-0.8343262672,
0.9675614834,
-0.6190460324,
0.6370866299,
0.60940063,
0.1983386725,
-0.1886343062,
-0.6182669401,
-0.5697503686,
-0.4270089567,
-0.1201625094,
0.1242385656,
-0.0433901176,
-0.1068883464,
-0.055892624,
0.3922146559,
-0.5238370895,
-0.4178836048,
-0.2645022869,
-0.1218726337,
0.6420349479,
-0.1164487749,
0.4894909859,
-0.000427134,
-0.2946099043,
-0.2412062734,
-0.9747015834,
-0.0005422952,
0.5044106841,
0.2461233586,
0.0840512887,
0.4674538374,
-0.144938305,
0.5928228498,
-0.0893973187,
-0.0366351604,
0.3494216502,
-0.6149638295,
0.090071857,
-0.0296240132,
0.4393427372,
-0.0031084272,
0.2577270567,
-0.268409282,
-0.2418120354,
-0.2441628724,
0.5400690436,
-0.8983879685,
-0.0219619572,
0.0746105015,
-0.4131306708,
0.3305113912,
-0.035692472,
-0.2685469985,
-0.2445887923,
-0.4701040089,
0.6861382127,
-0.7946490645,
-0.2660463154,
0.180343315,
-0.0222300198,
0.1674781442,
0.3067581952,
-0.6149463058,
0.4308187962,
0.3063955903,
0.6278785467,
-0.3158717752,
-0.1743214279,
-0.1693489552,
0.2019493133,
-0.296898514,
0.6830844879,
-1.0058227777,
-0.3166764975,
0.2755838633,
-0.2494291365,
-0.2643195093,
-0.7365285158,
0.7722673416,
-0.9058821201,
0.3162710369,
0.0253080409,
-0.5617174506,
-0.8022834659,
0.1286697835,
-0.681301713,
0.9391023517,
0.1443223357,
-0.84770751,
0.0053542773,
-0.8963409066,
-0.628313601,
0.0299999304,
-0.0726121366,
-0.3921840489,
0.182283774,
0.3926247656,
0.2803907692,
-0.3588142395,
-0.0661360472,
0.2671156228,
-0.6751161218,
0.3573890626,
-0.3631884754,
0.3668083549,
0.3668650091,
0.0747686401,
-0.1889729351,
-0.6698396206,
0.0364673026,
-0.1936451793,
-0.1754968613,
-0.4937529862,
0.1680340618,
0.3106748164,
-0.0745010972,
0.2545212507,
-0.4855155647,
0.3863502443,
-0.578004837,
0.0446553975,
0.2372897416,
0.1745694131,
0.5341427326,
-0.4999640882,
0.4110492468,
0.1858776808,
-0.0179066807,
0.1287402362,
-0.2086104453,
-0.5259478092,
-0.2858246565,
0.5668358207,
0.646324873,
-1.0977994204,
-0.0125758629,
-0.4122517407,
-0.404206425,
-0.7709926963,
0.2023994774,
0.2605621815,
0.1826181114,
0.5695118904,
-0.5926651359,
-0.5832183957,
-0.7284096479,
-0.4857667387,
-0.0263523348,
0.0471565835,
0.4088727832,
0.5611733794,
-0.2637678683,
0.6896870136,
-0.2924765944,
-0.5372616649,
-0.4221667349,
0.1066588685,
0.4838875532,
0.5378759503,
0.4753551483,
-1.3165135384,
-0.85111624,
0.4599219263,
-0.5330756903,
0.1301599592,
-0.1405062824,
-0.4371154308,
0.0059717544,
-0.0096908575,
-0.3428041935,
0.7921595573,
0.19379206,
-0.3646495044,
0.3761657774,
-0.2069740742,
0.7633880973,
-1.1710708141,
0.0415889993,
-0.2074865997,
-0.0573934689,
-0.9245233536,
0.1434994936,
0.3072913587,
0.2283851504,
-0.4399112165,
0.709666431,
-0.580848217,
0.2331453413,
-0.674484551,
-0.4083263874,
0.0970768034,
0.5279816389,
0.1134245545,
1.2700407505,
0.6172502041,
-0.8962141275,
-0.0426066779,
0.4857456386,
-0.3096125126,
0.0978079215,
-0.3038808405,
0.3291555047,
-0.2583084106,
-0.171276316,
-0.8682360649,
-0.1820271462,
0.3580136895,
-0.5760654807,
0.5360905528,
0.0064873705,
-0.2847602665,
-0.0564177558,
-0.2812236547,
0.9217927456,
0.4826653898,
-0.6319663525,
1.041769743,
0.2530012429,
-0.3885586262,
-0.9270573854,
-0.3175117671,
0.0387736894,
-0.2119581997,
-0.3802032173,
0.7064885497,
-0.0758899972,
-0.1670543402,
0.1254420578,
-0.3038669527,
-0.3712145388,
0.0157757699,
0.1875035018,
0.389223665,
-0.1443365365,
0.1673947126,
0.2553848028,
0.2147911638,
-0.1745114177,
-0.3441511095,
0.2739253342,
0.238818571,
-0.2439686209,
-0.5514368415,
0.6893420815,
0.1622086018,
-0.4138267636,
1.0702700615,
0.3897128999,
-0.4405627549,
0.1234049052,
-0.78560853,
-0.1422951818,
-0.4213472605,
0.5448586345,
-0.5036351681,
-0.6910050511,
0.3827915788,
-0.2055654675,
0.1124399155,
0.3268828392,
0.4943070114,
0.0627002269,
1.0085475445,
0.9245353937,
-0.284116447,
0.6430959105,
-0.2104412019,
0.3422949016,
-0.9023886919,
-0.0867572129,
-0.5749300122,
-0.1716324091,
-0.2775624096,
-0.4076181352,
0.5457622409,
0.0589386709,
-0.1042008996,
0.3702596724,
-0.3320729136,
0.4153335989,
0.3454965651,
0.2937276661,
0.304132998,
0.6525907516,
-0.0325127393,
-0.0395791456,
-0.6246650219,
-0.4057387412,
1.2302439213,
0.0785106644,
0.448530972,
0.4668290317,
0.4680905044,
0.6682969332,
0.4448908269,
-0.5129617453,
0.161309585,
-0.1788086593,
-0.4027943909,
0.0047031022,
-0.4068486989,
-0.9111101627,
0.2860208154,
-0.0848790407,
-0.4030913711,
0.2548947036,
-0.2341812104,
-0.2596912086,
-0.0024828608,
-0.6745115519,
0.4109687209,
0.0521822385,
-0.4204156697,
-0.4250769615,
-0.4590358138,
-0.0574682094,
-0.1759436429,
0.4182298779,
0.0611093715,
-0.1042509452,
0.8700726628,
-0.3030478656,
0.4377203286,
-0.0496581309,
0.113769643,
0.4799533784,
-0.0174732096,
0.3800053895,
-0.0868858323,
-0.449403584,
0.1198447421,
0.0164458193,
-0.6410668492,
-0.7630488276,
0.4070890546,
-1.1547659636,
-0.7657802701,
-0.5414147973,
-0.7905215025,
-0.341242671,
-0.1884536296,
-0.0148674129,
0.5041218996,
-0.1102645695,
0.0289954394,
0.3670443296,
-0.2449997365,
0.256634742,
0.7737068534,
-0.0112499706,
-0.492418766,
0.9562719464,
0.0010003401,
0.0160159823,
0.5231237411,
-0.06238373,
-0.4722454548,
-0.8781436086,
-0.4138908088,
0.3017671704,
-0.594330132,
-0.5263767242,
-0.5743060112,
-0.537184298,
-0.4491004646,
0.200015679,
-0.0211365949,
-0.424085319,
-0.1131965742,
0.0732090399,
0.7515406609,
0.6906280518,
0.0429241285,
0.2783396244,
-1.0657734871,
0.2527008355,
-0.2306752503,
0.0400863178,
0.078499712,
-1.174670577,
-0.6384845376,
0.1707785577,
-0.2834304869,
-0.9156804085,
0.6616958976,
0.7949895859,
0.30186674,
0.0335824117,
0.1713983268,
0.774818182,
-0.7136958241,
0.5453137755,
-0.1444880813,
-0.6993582249,
0.4605119824,
0.146477133,
0.1957019717,
0.5822721124,
0.8997557759,
-0.4873581529,
-0.3531074226,
-0.0994769111,
-0.9597548246,
0.6792163253,
0.5971800685,
0.497038424,
0.0771180019,
0.7751930952,
0.5198887587,
0.2164983749,
-0.4946930408,
-0.3693649173,
-0.0661217645,
-0.4035951495,
0.2774174809,
-0.2206419706,
0.0559588224,
-0.528435111,
1.1267457008,
-0.0763192773,
0.2252967507,
0.4246105254,
-0.4154852629,
-0.009283863,
0.2669560015,
0.2139684409,
0.6157484651,
-0.1483504474,
-0.063617155,
0.2540980279,
-1.0497145653,
0.2500861585,
0.2074947655,
-0.1583539695,
-0.0526467673,
0.2168115377,
0.7140929699,
-0.2217091471,
-0.8247253299,
0.3229675889,
-0.2716723382,
0.0084640579,
-0.3326751888,
-0.0740463138,
-0.3307125866,
0.2081412375,
0.9164510965,
0.1787227541,
0.4323169887,
-0.4592628777,
0.2419217676,
0.3649280071,
-0.064640671,
-0.198672995,
0.3123987019,
-0.0437337607,
-0.2756066322,
0.6275687814,
-0.1671388447,
-0.7368869185,
0.393201828,
0.6338141561,
0.6690650582,
-0.3792990148,
0.1542333812,
0.4444535673,
-0.0222553276,
0.1278111041,
0.5487269759,
-0.1415409893,
-0.8676639199,
-0.6075800657,
-0.5517903566,
-0.414999038,
-0.1010122225,
-0.6915020347,
-0.1709830165,
-0.1005626619,
0.02306021,
-0.3233178258,
0.4154118896,
-0.8832608461,
0.3054254949,
-0.1516424567,
0.8526600599,
-0.4936742783,
0.965184629,
1.0040836334,
-0.2782452703,
-0.8471321464,
0.0843296945,
-0.5407754779,
-0.7956299782,
0.8013294935,
0.1236520186,
-0.2115242481,
0.1995346546,
-0.3162693381,
-1.0944200754,
0.8714368343,
0.051160492,
-0.2792986333,
0.197563827,
0.3119739294,
0.5406295657,
-0.5375952125,
0.657153964,
0.478956759,
0.2466236949,
0.2025055587,
-0.6706680655,
-0.0245165732,
-0.554366529,
0.038144324,
0.2004484981,
-0.2394306809,
0.575428009,
-0.1507217884,
-0.4680444896,
0.4269032776,
1.1412607431,
-0.1580153257,
0.2996528745,
0.327059567,
0.264384836,
0.6862189174,
0.1200609952,
1.1115887165,
-0.5107036233,
-0.0187124461,
0.8359386921,
-0.4865352213,
1.1407234669,
0.5033479333,
-0.104803361,
0.5507121682,
0.5181356072,
0.2888013422,
0.7770488858,
0.0046329228,
-0.7158511281,
-0.0487345159,
-0.6521677971,
-0.510506928,
0.2103431374,
0.4883752167,
-0.0294068735,
0.0505350977,
0.4126807153,
-0.1916658282,
0.259360224,
-0.3692105114,
0.7951145768,
-0.1221352443,
-0.652453661,
0.8230038285,
0.115429908,
0.4455087483,
-0.6816542149,
-0.3105961978,
-0.3382249177,
0.1361914128,
-0.1583779454,
-0.2754609883,
0.3412238359,
0.2428818196,
-0.1586470306,
-0.0694473162,
0.8546305895,
-0.5830117464,
-0.5977621675,
0.255166024,
0.6490287781,
0.212495774,
-0.129922837,
-0.5498155951,
0.0305950064,
0.1549696624,
-0.1949199736,
0.3761948049,
0.4090062082,
-0.0027043063,
0.5915503502,
0.6377145648,
0.1640722603,
-0.110351406,
0.2026933879,
0.921587646,
-0.8105344772,
-0.0031998672,
-0.6885142922,
0.2446862608,
0.1253122687,
-0.0074960943,
0.6789093614,
0.5617291331,
0.8939678669,
-0.2076099366,
0.7681027651,
0.0158824977,
0.7828896642,
-0.6242930889,
0.6681638956,
-0.7898955941,
0.3259667158,
0.0852610916,
-1.0788587332,
-0.2495843321,
0.688298583,
-0.1682730168,
0.1162155047,
0.7056187391,
1.0187609196,
0.0742174089,
0.072829634,
0.2824515998,
0.1997527182,
-0.071851939,
0.6922130585,
1.0761058331,
-0.8900632858,
0.3619530499,
-0.2222693712,
-0.0590308122,
0.0344425514,
-0.4964683652,
-0.9113860726,
-0.5877155662,
-0.4615829289,
-0.2041099668,
0.4572415352,
1.2769855261,
0.4052905142,
-0.9839667678,
-0.3353963494,
0.2628222406,
0.1455105543,
-0.4046157598,
-0.1637716889,
0.6673445702,
-0.3728129268,
-0.8691039085,
0.5005235672,
0.1450966001,
0.072617583,
0.2816972435,
-0.1411548555,
-0.5369288921,
0.195202589,
0.3905287981,
0.2377771586,
-0.3952104151,
-0.4379002154,
0.1183891296,
-0.1199067309,
0.1853595525,
0.6426371336,
-0.9875092506,
0.1941806525,
0.2157757282,
1.0836318731,
0.0237098206,
0.0714851767,
0.7193296552,
-0.7260634899,
0.0735655203,
0.3355554044,
0.1810107529,
0.4415518939,
-0.4850409031,
0.6947820783,
-0.0975196734,
-0.4926582277,
-0.6812909245,
0.2065031379,
-0.7035396099,
-0.1924339384,
0.980232656,
-0.2342954427,
-0.1756739318,
-0.2968977392,
-0.6130865812,
0.3319117725,
-0.3126195371,
0.8645808697,
0.8027758598,
0.0323779732,
0.1098386571,
-0.4409328997,
0.5891997218,
0.9202511907,
-0.4940422177,
-0.2738046348,
0.0296673495,
-0.0448427983,
0.0844186991,
0.4388017356,
0.0933594629,
0.5423079133,
-0.2596116662,
0.0806542262,
0.0321623757,
-0.5031520128,
-0.3174190223,
-0.0236149337,
0.3285229802,
-0.1331322491
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02798v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02798v1
|
Weakly Supervised Detection of Hallucinations in LLM Activations
| 2023-12-05T14:35:11 | 2023-12-05T14:35:11 |
Miriam Rateike, Celia Cintas, John Wamburu, Tanya Akumu, Skyler Speakman
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We propose an auditing method to identify whether a large language model
(LLM) encodes patterns such as hallucinations in its internal states, which may
propagate to downstream tasks. We introduce a weakly supervised auditing
technique using a subset scanning approach to detect anomalous patterns in LLM
activations from pre-trained models. Importantly, our method does not need
knowledge of the type of patterns a-priori. Instead, it relies on a reference
dataset devoid of anomalies during testing. Further, our approach enables the
identification of pivotal nodes responsible for encoding these patterns, which
may offer crucial insights for fine-tuning specific sub-networks for bias
mitigation. We introduce two new scanning methods to handle LLM activations for
anomalous sentences that may deviate from the expected distribution in either
direction. Our results confirm prior findings of BERT's limited internal
capacity for encoding hallucinations, while OPT appears capable of encoding
hallucination information internally. Importantly, our scanning approach,
without prior exposure to false statements, performs comparably to a fully
supervised out-of-distribution classifier.
|
[
-0.1807904691,
-0.8984854221,
0.6426398158,
-0.0360816121,
-0.2782899737,
-0.4670849144,
-0.1913757473,
-0.5124657154,
0.5243601799,
0.8159442544,
-0.8121631145,
-0.4692027271,
-0.714496851,
0.2570535541,
-0.9281312823,
0.6645767689,
0.2276793718,
0.3795475066,
-0.063890785,
0.160638541,
-0.2331103981,
-0.7061396241,
-0.6842526793,
-0.3457458317,
0.0895132273,
-0.0959341899,
0.3878145218,
0.4046368599,
0.3967733979,
0.2344710678,
-0.3869231045,
0.4431066513,
-0.5732970238,
0.125721544,
-0.0127915768,
-0.4352900684,
-0.3326086998,
-0.3998176754,
0.4281424582,
0.707054317,
0.1354917139,
-0.1555381715,
0.2883906364,
0.4736454785,
-0.6131718755,
0.1220361143,
-0.883503139,
0.1937122792,
-0.1077544615,
-0.2234499007,
-0.6600296497,
-0.1862385422,
-0.0823299959,
-0.1192783415,
0.3091286421,
-0.1395638883,
0.8174780011,
0.5765587091,
-0.2472179234,
-0.6139235497,
-0.3307194412,
0.7500044107,
-0.6379365325,
0.3322765827,
0.6610521078,
-0.1089773402,
-0.4116639495,
-0.588924706,
-0.2800232172,
-0.3089172244,
-0.4863969386,
-0.0749952123,
-0.2268515378,
0.1826162934,
0.2142859548,
0.3281415701,
-0.3234479427,
0.2818745971,
-0.321344167,
-0.6509832144,
0.626210928,
0.2822989821,
0.184154734,
-0.2163187116,
-0.1732883304,
0.0770488605,
-0.5915684104,
-0.2536710799,
0.6337382197,
0.4215679765,
-0.0763810501,
0.6978636384,
-0.0422601849,
0.3059434593,
0.1746231467,
0.0131070213,
0.2008511871,
-0.3984536529,
-0.1373743862,
0.4623151422,
0.5404404998,
-0.0797783881,
0.3069921434,
-0.2291667759,
-0.5995739102,
0.2012373507,
0.4479987025,
-0.4822773039,
-0.3480987549,
0.2202900946,
-0.6632347703,
-0.2861073911,
0.0567295998,
-0.6877154112,
-0.8664489388,
-0.3193608522,
0.3921450078,
-0.3644769788,
-0.2458444834,
0.2125767171,
-0.1320173889,
0.2540656924,
0.2144444585,
-0.8395087123,
0.2432652563,
0.5008851886,
0.6184136271,
-0.2948656976,
-0.3081792891,
-0.476105839,
-0.0450928137,
-0.342807889,
0.6888421178,
-0.2903295457,
-0.2482651323,
0.4653274715,
0.2824626267,
0.073347345,
-0.807036221,
0.5262512565,
-0.2810361683,
-0.1742067486,
-0.1497514248,
-0.4892609119,
-0.3385861516,
0.1674879193,
-0.5453771353,
1.0677636862,
0.0320718922,
-0.7291141152,
0.3998763263,
-0.2613317072,
-0.4747061431,
-0.1131140515,
-0.3645097017,
-0.4902835488,
0.3978723884,
0.4951675534,
0.5236368775,
0.2403130531,
0.3222872317,
-0.3762164116,
-0.6592820883,
0.0365047082,
-0.3596790433,
1.0111274719,
-0.2637016773,
-0.4863346219,
0.1832111627,
-0.7093302608,
-0.2975492775,
0.0769953653,
0.0995809585,
-0.3283854127,
0.2007430941,
-0.2174467146,
-0.1535406411,
0.4584261179,
-0.0942407101,
0.3262994289,
-0.3775577247,
-0.0158412755,
0.8768060803,
0.4777381718,
0.2562416792,
-0.2260507643,
0.1916885674,
0.4769820571,
0.1476557702,
-0.1082097813,
-0.5058143735,
-1.0745726824,
-0.4921050966,
-0.278878659,
0.4703844488,
-0.4637619555,
0.8324736357,
0.0765811801,
-0.0360526405,
-0.642950058,
0.4198681414,
0.1243316084,
0.4210207462,
0.4469857514,
-0.3237638175,
-0.7911164761,
-1.1596785784,
-0.075669311,
-0.1192627251,
-0.1452860534,
0.2723623514,
0.6284430027,
-0.8739586473,
0.6771243215,
-0.1894428432,
-0.945951581,
-0.3325517476,
0.2553206384,
0.5163871646,
0.3415045738,
0.3790997863,
-0.4423583746,
0.0024305277,
-0.1607841849,
-1.0576946735,
-0.2248235345,
-0.4584563375,
0.1447340548,
0.2789081335,
0.7525230646,
-0.2440567911,
0.5567462444,
0.3931596875,
-0.1513664573,
0.3356782198,
-0.319509685,
-0.224842146,
-0.663692832,
-0.3684865832,
-0.1045825258,
0.0690727308,
-0.5673505068,
-0.3009208441,
0.1194098443,
0.2254846096,
-0.2683044374,
0.0915048122,
-0.6696059704,
-0.2568143606,
-0.202612415,
-0.0670414567,
-0.3540134728,
0.5698850155,
0.2719059289,
0.5478214025,
0.9479869604,
-0.5122259259,
0.0979341269,
0.0317659415,
-0.4724445939,
-0.0437464751,
-0.2599852681,
0.462053597,
-0.3938881159,
0.0218508728,
-0.8989189863,
-0.209626779,
0.1765912026,
-0.1381608993,
0.2564758658,
-0.2998562157,
-0.6607677341,
0.1155167893,
-0.5138428211,
0.1671548486,
0.5143318772,
-0.7997576594,
0.5806917548,
0.3587266207,
0.3860012889,
-0.4685709476,
-0.7782505155,
-0.1827701926,
-0.2251616865,
-0.4586904347,
-0.0378599875,
0.4533594549,
-0.2277464122,
-0.0034967046,
-0.2624496222,
-0.0819970891,
0.2754400671,
0.3526055813,
0.0762540624,
-0.401286304,
-0.263135314,
0.0928122997,
0.0332868174,
0.3337371647,
-0.1707267463,
0.653858304,
0.0009705173,
-0.4937733412,
-0.7069091797,
0.2229082137,
0.2888716459,
0.289031595,
0.6001274586,
0.5668004751,
-0.6979329586,
-0.6860451698,
-0.5948551893,
-0.7353628874,
-0.5081145763,
0.3637117445,
-0.2317539304,
-0.6971999407,
0.8819537163,
-0.0191263147,
-0.4690437615,
0.2142702788,
0.6497330666,
-0.0725561082,
1.1241685152,
0.7390546799,
-0.2187037468,
0.5280894637,
-0.378567785,
0.4839565754,
-0.7295973301,
-0.253873378,
-0.2692823112,
-0.0494429693,
-0.5901849866,
-0.2516703904,
0.4851766527,
0.1655814648,
0.3234170973,
0.106914103,
-0.5563429594,
0.501875639,
0.4182421863,
0.1719259769,
0.1227883399,
-0.0571175963,
0.0227603447,
-0.0224002283,
-0.3841898143,
-0.637642622,
1.058137536,
0.2885944545,
0.8757537603,
-0.1332621276,
0.9101459384,
0.611081183,
0.334197551,
-0.8231756687,
0.6400654912,
-0.1542013139,
-0.5773794055,
-0.2945161164,
-0.1488257647,
-0.8348602057,
0.2431132048,
-0.1417145133,
-1.3831444979,
0.5480927825,
0.1056352407,
0.0727124512,
0.3466592729,
-0.8536925316,
0.6268328428,
-0.0856866241,
-0.1931774765,
-0.0197255909,
-0.1483810097,
0.7684525251,
-0.1690285951,
0.0185895208,
0.0664927363,
0.1459207833,
0.5424040556,
-0.10712827,
1.2475020885,
-0.1231718957,
-0.2792743742,
0.2624916732,
0.2135974616,
0.8300068974,
0.2633595765,
-0.0485245325,
0.322080493,
-0.2882242501,
-0.262005657,
-0.4222264588,
0.5326058865,
-0.6136934757,
-0.6309664845,
-0.3614712358,
-0.365405798,
-0.2371219248,
0.1785277873,
0.404186368,
0.2406182736,
0.0202368237,
0.1129953414,
0.7026184201,
0.0809765682,
0.3565539718,
0.0517746061,
0.0350133479,
0.0438802987,
0.7999562621,
-0.0915435255,
-0.1444442719,
0.2319605798,
0.08238893,
-0.3295271099,
-1.2362868786,
0.0061234287,
0.3589413166,
-0.9305754304,
-0.07063023,
-0.608581543,
-0.2416254729,
-0.521548748,
-0.2107133418,
-0.3144882023,
0.0330036506,
-0.4807347655,
0.0335209183,
-0.0106943045,
0.8658131361,
-0.0954530761,
0.1777791679,
-0.4028254151,
0.4195925593,
0.2182412744,
-0.0059569553,
-0.0779806897,
-0.5413327813,
-0.157054469,
-0.0990034044,
-0.03300751,
-1.0823488235,
0.5238514543,
-0.0819950327,
0.7405481935,
0.985162735,
0.1614343673,
0.5958573818,
-0.2335099429,
0.9288882613,
-0.1483049989,
-1.0434328318,
0.6455635428,
-0.2212181985,
-0.0753142983,
0.6987497211,
0.4189938009,
-0.0174533166,
-0.9178952575,
-0.392773807,
-0.8414826393,
0.8405016065,
-0.0085799471,
0.1557295322,
-0.081713289,
0.1793988794,
0.1554845423,
0.0086672977,
-0.8654808998,
-0.1371021569,
-0.0782160535,
-0.0135527896,
-0.0205379464,
-0.4229196012,
-0.2339755595,
-0.1735584438,
0.6861524582,
-0.2277628779,
0.3727483749,
0.353049159,
-0.4656269848,
0.0382754281,
-0.0827938244,
0.6036763191,
0.6364923716,
-0.6389887929,
0.4186522365,
0.4307194352,
-0.5781822801,
-0.1347719282,
-0.3229494989,
-0.2027609348,
0.2445300668,
0.8509882092,
0.5127639771,
0.0068459711,
-0.647759676,
0.5430798531,
0.051856555,
-0.3393756449,
-0.5211232901,
0.1481439918,
-0.3356812,
0.2882782519,
0.4214178622,
-0.3145872355,
0.3651946187,
-0.6077314615,
0.2021000832,
0.4976039231,
-0.4912542403,
-0.374061197,
0.3396301568,
-0.1571758687,
-0.2945508659,
0.9427180886,
-0.4499776661,
-0.657656908,
0.5407834053,
0.5433287621,
1.3165581226,
0.1215541139,
-0.3073941171,
0.2173624933,
0.8130171299,
-0.1237636209,
0.2822460532,
-0.2019044608,
-0.9858795404,
-0.2310162038,
-0.3825030923,
-0.3073177636,
0.713371098,
-0.8370752335,
0.3860586882,
-0.3291315734,
0.0392416455,
-0.1264497936,
-0.1760465205,
-0.345204711,
-0.0563137233,
0.3533403575,
0.5685016513,
-1.1691824198,
0.9844939113,
0.5341458917,
-0.2337438166,
-0.3704578578,
0.4067572355,
0.2460202277,
-0.9415634871,
0.7159190774,
0.1700690389,
-0.2910177112,
-0.252959311,
-0.5280900598,
-0.4531411231,
0.8071722984,
0.3039702475,
-0.3344276249,
-0.0654646382,
-0.0801493302,
0.4811776578,
-0.2648064792,
0.0519966483,
0.6046426296,
0.3153182864,
-0.3094221354,
-0.5556496978,
0.2221207172,
-0.02636794,
-0.2650437057,
0.2010793537,
-0.2377961576,
0.537148416,
-0.0614696629,
-0.2798964381,
-0.1065294743,
0.5284582376,
0.0167127121,
0.2438036054,
0.6047273874,
0.276294291,
0.8926890492,
-0.0447741412,
0.9113305807,
-0.3693127036,
0.2805994153,
0.9557560682,
-0.2808301747,
0.5508242249,
0.8471317887,
0.1974963397,
0.1390701234,
0.4842679799,
-0.1299117655,
0.7640673518,
0.3980987668,
-0.0811698288,
-0.5146202445,
-0.1636114866,
-0.3020128608,
0.4487524629,
0.5669530034,
-0.3989645541,
-0.2291850746,
-0.1218095049,
-0.2028719634,
-0.0915599093,
-0.2313704193,
0.9317330718,
0.174042657,
-0.4083540738,
0.5489269495,
-0.2703940868,
0.845275104,
-0.5858424306,
-0.0585862063,
-0.4872751236,
0.4020963907,
-0.2632910907,
-0.3494771421,
0.4100922942,
0.0350515433,
0.1112357974,
-0.6035135984,
0.7769528031,
-0.0272712111,
-0.2810060382,
0.6071471572,
0.4279025495,
0.4542485774,
0.1532498598,
-0.338462621,
0.1357324272,
-0.0306107793,
-0.2313115001,
0.3641111553,
0.6175212264,
-0.1981302053,
0.3752627373,
0.5180830956,
0.2012387067,
0.1678877324,
0.3712964356,
0.8884756565,
-0.5194481015,
-0.494979471,
-0.9108176231,
0.3327501714,
-0.1242310107,
-0.2881067097,
0.8498573899,
0.6814752221,
0.9744642377,
-0.0915459394,
0.4751825333,
0.4344432652,
0.0563458838,
-0.777760148,
0.6229701638,
-0.535720706,
0.531218648,
-0.1217093542,
-0.7496579885,
-0.215194121,
0.7642853856,
-0.3231622875,
-0.1886116713,
0.8520691991,
1.2396757603,
-0.2433768213,
0.1627679467,
0.3021280468,
0.4959411025,
-0.0108860536,
0.387417376,
1.2951296568,
-0.1419708878,
0.3133191764,
-0.3876692653,
0.1121236756,
-0.4605788589,
-0.8195291162,
-1.4247585535,
-0.5242291689,
-0.3917072415,
-0.4935794473,
0.0190926269,
0.6037473083,
0.6671028733,
-1.0673851967,
-0.2311185449,
-0.266728729,
0.4213400781,
-0.3348433971,
-0.2450111061,
0.5048630238,
-0.7014307976,
-0.6748816371,
0.7285376787,
0.3008806705,
0.1764365286,
-0.397869885,
0.1762227118,
0.0338774286,
0.0792686492,
0.2480043024,
-0.1608981341,
-0.7828860879,
-0.3042956889,
-0.062357083,
0.0019335171,
-0.0044808704,
0.9111412764,
-0.4880243838,
0.3193521798,
0.4809686542,
0.6485616565,
0.7094569206,
-0.3553419411,
0.1910333037,
-0.8427329063,
0.4352628589,
0.6622794867,
0.5070834756,
-0.0613997318,
-0.6334039569,
0.4024783373,
0.1635192037,
-0.1156303287,
-1.4470449686,
0.0821706131,
-0.9827336073,
-0.3354555964,
1.1647465229,
0.0721120462,
-0.3490829468,
-0.4041910172,
-0.0357876308,
0.0202523507,
-0.144872278,
1.0430147648,
0.7637587786,
-0.4228577614,
0.1280288845,
-0.4215540588,
0.7064527869,
0.4923460484,
-0.7141085267,
0.0492618345,
0.3511987627,
-0.1757513881,
0.1965165287,
0.594050765,
0.0812817737,
0.1380971819,
0.28188169,
-0.2959480584,
0.0095523158,
-0.2458364516,
-0.7530933022,
0.2270235121,
-0.1454890817,
-0.2573302984
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02783v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02783v2
|
Large Language Models on Graphs: A Comprehensive Survey
| 2023-12-05T14:14:27 | 2024-02-01T22:51:24 |
Bowen Jin, Gang Liu, Chi Han, Meng Jiang, Heng Ji, Jiawei Han
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large language models (LLMs), such as GPT4 and LLaMA, are creating
significant advancements in natural language processing, due to their strong
text encoding/decoding ability and newly found emergent capability (e.g.,
reasoning). While LLMs are mainly designed to process pure texts, there are
many real-world scenarios where text data is associated with rich structure
information in the form of graphs (e.g., academic networks, and e-commerce
networks) or scenarios where graph data is paired with rich textual information
(e.g., molecules with descriptions). Besides, although LLMs have shown their
pure text-based reasoning ability, it is underexplored whether such ability can
be generalized to graphs (i.e., graph-based reasoning). In this paper, we
provide a systematic review of scenarios and techniques related to large
language models on graphs. We first summarize potential scenarios of adopting
LLMs on graphs into three categories, namely pure graphs, text-attributed
graphs, and text-paired graphs. We then discuss detailed techniques for
utilizing LLMs on graphs, including LLM as Predictor, LLM as Encoder, and LLM
as Aligner, and compare the advantages and disadvantages of different schools
of models. Furthermore, we discuss the real-world applications of such methods
and summarize open-source codes and benchmark datasets. Finally, we conclude
with potential future research directions in this fast-growing field. The
related source can be found at
https://github.com/PeterGriffinJin/Awesome-Language-Model-on-Graphs.
|
[
-0.1428381056,
-1.1949542761,
0.9529977441,
-0.077358216,
-0.1759786606,
0.253800422,
-0.3956983089,
-0.7617704868,
0.0579689108,
0.739463985,
-0.0635803863,
-0.7677979469,
-0.6972273588,
0.2512691915,
-0.5852513313,
0.6591850519,
-0.3499501944,
0.0673226491,
-0.1367960125,
-0.0857649669,
-0.1150168851,
-0.8170476556,
-0.7110184431,
-0.5143995881,
0.5524621606,
0.0941397995,
0.6537974477,
0.6159205437,
0.3913772702,
0.292221725,
-0.3532204032,
0.3326337636,
-0.5676746368,
0.2208758742,
-0.048992008,
-0.2359141409,
-0.5273838043,
0.0071437429,
0.8010553122,
1.0374757051,
-0.0025268444,
-0.1037001535,
-0.1384898722,
0.3081133068,
-0.2173760086,
0.3917514086,
-0.5124872923,
-0.0264191199,
-0.1284037381,
0.092333138,
-0.5939630866,
-0.4502796829,
0.0582718886,
-0.355047971,
-0.1878254116,
0.3214622438,
0.7439054847,
-0.1084475815,
-0.7373036146,
-0.548836112,
-0.7931531668,
0.543538332,
-0.7865020633,
0.4715019166,
0.2959304452,
0.2879337966,
-0.397433877,
-1.1455070972,
-0.5526947975,
-0.1732621044,
0.0697581992,
-0.1414812207,
-0.4348071814,
0.2942520976,
0.3562970459,
0.4018855393,
-0.4480638802,
0.3752851486,
0.0213518068,
-0.1617022902,
0.4211659133,
0.2058477104,
0.6118797064,
-0.0787576288,
0.0040242742,
0.134906888,
-0.908370316,
-0.228551656,
0.2843569219,
0.3594148159,
-0.0412413441,
0.8606865406,
-0.3060654402,
1.0323214531,
-0.4445701241,
-0.0436385907,
0.1703796387,
-0.5314999819,
-0.2066809684,
-0.1592586637,
0.8826409578,
0.1302209496,
0.6631593108,
-0.3082131147,
-0.1404444575,
0.0779202804,
-0.2698232234,
-0.7902188301,
-0.2704741359,
0.0972794071,
-0.3425528407,
-0.067215234,
-0.3135489225,
-0.4543357491,
-0.3603196144,
-0.3377461135,
-0.1639123261,
-0.3230884969,
-0.1036400422,
0.2049591541,
-0.0606238805,
0.1799545735,
0.4072172046,
-0.6194761395,
0.3859900832,
0.6971500516,
0.9820702076,
-0.1000632942,
-0.2210189849,
-0.3242008388,
0.3504507542,
-0.3098216355,
0.8349820971,
-0.6270262003,
-0.2991188765,
0.1571255624,
0.0722138286,
-0.0565251783,
-0.3323052227,
0.6528090239,
-0.7125916481,
0.0179203395,
-0.1573681533,
-0.7410802841,
-0.1795056164,
0.5244005322,
-0.725372076,
0.7216439843,
-0.016799612,
-0.9700884819,
-0.0217056461,
-0.3570094705,
-0.7148485184,
-0.0063766558,
-0.0855201781,
-0.3334179521,
-0.2491877377,
0.2358327657,
0.4889024496,
-0.4675710797,
0.4314666092,
-0.5328522921,
-0.2355835438,
0.4578944743,
-0.3126648664,
0.8348881602,
0.2173247188,
0.0074551557,
0.2735029161,
-0.4602133036,
0.0956942961,
0.3947392702,
-0.2741274238,
-0.2503808439,
0.1692340374,
-0.1173930913,
0.1572220325,
0.2886629701,
-0.5597991347,
0.3966126442,
-0.3566725552,
0.9615008235,
0.6412106752,
-0.0197225474,
0.1910195798,
0.1688724756,
0.4175487757,
-0.3049637675,
-0.0007929488,
-0.198560223,
-0.6661167741,
-0.5265301466,
-0.3045980334,
0.4041905403,
0.4904600084,
-0.7410544157,
0.2684796154,
-0.2635861337,
-0.3399495482,
-0.0688819215,
0.0662596375,
0.2348650694,
0.4858565331,
0.1991024911,
-0.1495865285,
-0.5410770774,
-0.711992979,
-0.1723870337,
-0.2244308144,
0.2043841183,
0.457079947,
0.4266632795,
-0.5133863688,
0.9177615047,
-0.785772562,
0.0815089345,
-0.6345897317,
-0.1881055832,
0.0951947197,
-0.0597201586,
0.426959455,
-0.6151458621,
-0.3689119518,
0.1124970838,
-0.9534546733,
-0.1001552567,
0.4337289333,
0.0350298434,
0.1599252522,
0.6257004142,
-0.7487145066,
0.1001532152,
0.8132041693,
-0.2342897505,
0.4751918316,
-0.1272736937,
-0.0090205604,
-0.8062064648,
0.0186784323,
0.1560346931,
-0.5411328673,
-0.7309266329,
0.1720090955,
-0.2054282874,
-0.2216700315,
-0.0371903032,
0.6752938628,
-0.6102471352,
-0.3254610896,
-0.341581732,
0.3421935737,
-0.0874011964,
0.2028007805,
-0.0210141335,
0.6980368495,
0.5083723068,
-0.3380234838,
0.544824481,
0.2031005621,
-0.3786676228,
0.0915204957,
-0.76240623,
0.2665655017,
-0.056398768,
0.695620358,
-1.1777406931,
-0.3404420316,
0.3916732073,
-0.2043359578,
0.271635443,
-0.1825695634,
-0.948278904,
-0.6374435425,
0.0211990569,
0.3135662675,
0.3552080393,
-0.4997430146,
0.3195138276,
0.742209971,
-0.3219363987,
-0.3037985861,
-0.5510313511,
0.4590089023,
-0.1163846403,
-0.5675645471,
0.079122819,
-0.0407439619,
-0.317856133,
0.1449005157,
0.2203043699,
-0.0795460492,
0.0693803802,
0.0262722354,
0.2769190967,
-0.0613133609,
0.1022496596,
-0.1132301092,
-0.1327955276,
-0.1054043248,
-0.5078698397,
0.7557958961,
-0.2537689209,
-0.371348083,
-0.1601803005,
0.1533379406,
0.291282475,
-0.3068056405,
0.615237236,
0.3580925763,
-0.3688087761,
-0.1365328282,
-0.3506867588,
-0.001636296,
-0.3767826259,
0.391582191,
-0.1382796764,
-1.2796702385,
0.5045561194,
-0.4386638701,
-0.1590965241,
0.2688804269,
0.6686528921,
-0.0452075824,
1.3227730989,
0.5657184124,
-0.2298948616,
0.4591239691,
-0.3186778724,
0.6682130694,
-0.7863573432,
-0.0984534696,
-0.6777771115,
0.0081569767,
-0.6202065349,
-0.5604975224,
0.0456999056,
0.0744569227,
-0.3187881112,
0.1621131152,
-0.30428949,
0.4711681902,
0.0332060605,
-0.1353376061,
0.590388298,
0.0993027985,
-0.170760721,
0.2670864463,
-0.7718163133,
-0.7320711613,
1.0842342377,
0.3654148281,
0.82008636,
-0.1515320987,
0.4214059711,
0.088488251,
0.521281004,
-0.8308238387,
0.7738856673,
-0.2665582895,
-0.3899081051,
-0.3598556221,
-0.7163832784,
-1.0939106941,
0.2183232307,
0.0004940508,
-0.8491557837,
-0.2489498556,
0.0954160914,
0.3555467129,
0.5951309204,
-0.5810679793,
0.7114194632,
-0.3304241002,
-0.1312445998,
-0.0204792842,
-0.5225524902,
0.4829953313,
-0.0204861686,
0.5572788119,
-0.2212620229,
0.083632879,
0.5304890275,
-0.2184654176,
0.9277448058,
0.0147939874,
-0.3329503536,
0.6129675508,
-0.0494956933,
0.7997020483,
-0.2143011689,
-0.1815947592,
0.4766431153,
-0.1777763963,
-0.2218900323,
-0.4452096224,
0.8327279687,
-0.7828307748,
-0.4443672895,
-0.241102308,
-0.5713636279,
-0.348080188,
0.3958709538,
0.0865678787,
0.4683685601,
-0.2381360531,
-0.0553340241,
0.4693530798,
-0.1052688807,
0.1468931735,
0.2860590816,
-0.6263107061,
-0.4439614117,
0.8985112906,
0.3154436052,
0.3201273978,
0.1649500132,
0.2393096685,
-0.3865031898,
-0.9487329125,
-0.3210797608,
0.6003149748,
-0.9660906196,
-0.0206961129,
-0.6715164781,
-0.2226984799,
-0.4181638658,
0.0118877459,
0.0060286927,
-0.443908304,
-0.154265359,
-0.2932744026,
0.322910428,
0.9666543603,
0.3827376366,
0.2678938508,
-0.4703596532,
0.2714747787,
0.1225129515,
0.50192976,
0.1116872877,
-0.1157213897,
-0.2454758137,
0.0625723004,
-0.0735117123,
-0.9008513689,
0.3608222306,
-0.1281494349,
0.7487930059,
0.1892152131,
-0.1949821413,
0.4338617623,
-0.5065807104,
0.6237884164,
0.1508824974,
-0.8572223186,
0.1767646372,
-0.5086219311,
-0.0781825185,
0.1458968222,
0.4179149866,
-0.6679808497,
-0.4042965174,
-0.3427517414,
-0.8398797512,
0.3665398955,
0.1534140557,
0.0728880167,
-0.170126617,
0.4544421434,
-0.1811614633,
0.2483955026,
-0.8348716497,
-0.1434329599,
-0.0205636173,
-0.2922844589,
-0.2224983275,
-0.1629882157,
-0.200745374,
-0.3133045733,
0.4202249944,
-0.3673484921,
0.0862036943,
0.0233905483,
-0.1549132466,
0.0885223895,
0.3345302343,
0.1983590573,
0.6889280677,
-0.0078978958,
0.3447216451,
0.1860268116,
-0.1470907032,
0.1417336315,
0.0941393822,
-0.0893736333,
-0.2934960127,
0.4622904062,
0.7752569914,
0.2011330128,
-0.8071491718,
0.3367182016,
-0.0062014107,
-0.09128391,
-0.0483732037,
-0.1824525595,
0.4239034057,
0.1244943142,
0.0178578887,
-0.490917623,
0.1301865876,
-0.7650831938,
-0.2329476923,
0.6178574562,
-0.3103980124,
-0.3189643919,
0.5399484634,
0.1297604889,
-0.1618569642,
0.7218004465,
-0.2144571245,
-0.5177699924,
0.5408885479,
0.9502892494,
0.6531877518,
0.1545234323,
0.1242094189,
0.13106668,
0.2567019761,
-0.0316222236,
0.1044188887,
0.2441923469,
-0.9587299824,
-0.698952198,
-0.4503450096,
-0.6295890212,
-0.1128822267,
-0.057910338,
0.089662917,
-0.4403265119,
-0.3327333033,
0.0467784181,
-0.0190294925,
-0.4867909551,
-0.0707389042,
0.3035546839,
0.8073135614,
-0.8198912144,
0.8908811808,
0.8534100056,
-0.2717429101,
-0.7424228787,
-0.1301228255,
-0.1143285334,
-0.8878719211,
0.5191873312,
0.0070515019,
-0.2776538134,
0.1789386123,
-0.8998682499,
-0.8807985187,
0.8918913603,
0.5243339539,
-0.5203871727,
-0.1233193502,
0.1040196493,
0.715621531,
-0.3808931708,
0.2077579945,
0.6686576009,
0.5005390644,
0.2388819456,
-0.7309558988,
0.0896378011,
-0.0441104174,
-0.0038930085,
0.2927262187,
-0.5629885197,
0.9342285991,
-0.25874874,
-0.317438066,
0.0584110171,
0.4775350392,
0.3462908864,
0.1810591668,
0.2219629586,
0.4845427275,
1.0175254345,
-0.1147999838,
1.3535972834,
-0.3098604083,
0.3953485787,
0.8196261525,
-0.7458571196,
0.6283016801,
0.1906448007,
-0.3014877439,
0.7031283975,
0.6558315158,
0.1060536876,
0.0505361706,
0.3718102276,
-0.0478795208,
-0.3499868512,
-0.2453489751,
-0.2962194681,
0.2551813424,
0.5704572797,
-0.2838305235,
-0.2110453546,
-0.1840923429,
0.2504953146,
-0.006761441,
-0.3817838132,
0.7076063752,
0.2986063659,
-0.32415694,
0.299968034,
0.2410356104,
0.3409578502,
-0.6254675984,
-0.0019436713,
0.0374273024,
-0.0317704566,
-0.1818515062,
-1.1501228809,
0.0440187715,
0.0893090963,
-0.0029830649,
-0.198880285,
1.0098924637,
-0.2087906897,
-0.483441323,
0.5126627684,
0.584230721,
0.1323229373,
0.1150359362,
-0.5348291993,
0.2581392229,
-0.1233220696,
-0.2891769111,
0.3431667686,
0.4405948222,
-0.3628515303,
0.8623939753,
0.7620222569,
0.2154756188,
-0.023231687,
0.4505080879,
1.1398074627,
-0.79010427,
-0.4890960455,
-0.7999802828,
-0.0784525126,
-0.1518377215,
0.1219477728,
0.9393497705,
0.6269046068,
0.6036566496,
0.372698009,
0.9943356514,
0.2239443958,
0.2985165715,
-0.6113638878,
0.4330949783,
-0.198858425,
0.015489338,
-0.4901357889,
-0.8885557652,
-0.5073988438,
0.4657571018,
-0.6616828442,
0.0710747615,
0.6311502457,
0.375982672,
0.1138873398,
0.1697735488,
0.0895517319,
0.4323909581,
0.622451365,
0.4105105698,
0.9223473072,
0.0065020574,
0.500662744,
0.2933453321,
-0.0545426905,
-0.220541656,
-0.8428491354,
-0.8464084268,
-0.3312452137,
-0.2693343163,
-0.3583958745,
0.0348906927,
0.6043214798,
0.4771623909,
-0.5857544541,
-0.3807784021,
-0.1777174324,
0.5140609145,
0.1390835196,
-0.1471079737,
0.2754434943,
-0.0786269903,
-0.7112510204,
0.3793335855,
0.3651799858,
0.2303851098,
-0.2660605609,
-0.1838004142,
-0.1952018142,
0.1428597569,
0.9503207207,
0.4300438166,
-0.6473667026,
-0.4334421754,
-0.0017650811,
-0.2607655525,
0.1280853152,
0.9617661834,
-0.6108186841,
0.2820406854,
0.6269489527,
0.4234798253,
0.7626495957,
-0.0515903868,
0.452798754,
-0.2726115584,
-0.0379977226,
0.1661817431,
0.7476570606,
0.5850825906,
0.0011091888,
0.5122442245,
0.2764033675,
-0.5904967785,
-0.9838045835,
0.4642872512,
-0.9266679287,
-0.4102363884,
1.2711970806,
-0.1376552135,
-0.1261434406,
-0.3028103709,
-0.2533830702,
0.3734644949,
-0.0785875544,
0.2391269803,
0.7136274576,
-0.2611147761,
-0.0765589625,
-0.5199161172,
0.0408268236,
-0.2684134543,
-1.0643309355,
0.3352129161,
0.707829237,
0.3596563339,
-0.1296482235,
0.7922907472,
-0.1317148358,
-0.2918378413,
-0.1305600405,
-0.0187070686,
-0.1803388596,
-0.2791473866,
-0.2818309069,
0.3482470214,
0.3746644855,
0.5347707272
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02780v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02780v1
|
Scaling Laws for Adversarial Attacks on Language Model Activations
| 2023-12-05T14:12:15 | 2023-12-05T14:12:15 |
Stanislav Fort
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL, cs.CR
|
We explore a class of adversarial attacks targeting the activations of
language models. By manipulating a relatively small subset of model
activations, $a$, we demonstrate the ability to control the exact prediction of
a significant number (in some cases up to 1000) of subsequent tokens $t$. We
empirically verify a scaling law where the maximum number of target tokens
$t_\mathrm{max}$ predicted depends linearly on the number of tokens $a$ whose
activations the attacker controls as $t_\mathrm{max} = \kappa a$. We find that
the number of bits of control in the input space needed to control a single bit
in the output space (what we call attack resistance $\chi$) is remarkably
constant between $\approx 16$ and $\approx 25$ over 2 orders of magnitude of
model sizes for different language models. Compared to attacks on tokens,
attacks on activations are predictably much stronger, however, we identify a
surprising regularity where one bit of input steered either via activations or
via tokens is able to exert control over a similar amount of output bits. This
gives support for the hypothesis that adversarial attacks are a consequence of
dimensionality mismatch between the input and output spaces. A practical
implication of the ease of attacking language model activations instead of
tokens is for multi-modal and selected retrieval models, where additional data
sources are added as activations directly, sidestepping the tokenized input.
This opens up a new, broad attack surface. By using language models as a
controllable test-bed to study adversarial attacks, we were able to experiment
with input-output dimensions that are inaccessible in computer vision,
especially where the output dimension dominates.
|
[
-0.4190371037,
-1.0592852831,
0.2445137203,
0.3637275994,
0.1017028093,
-0.2022097558,
-0.1160880327,
-0.3073720932,
0.214247331,
0.4776851535,
-0.1555734277,
0.1134181172,
-1.0481857061,
-0.2252678722,
-0.6940796375,
0.854359448,
0.126707375,
0.3349275887,
0.0862958506,
-0.2609640956,
-0.3417786062,
-0.7931075096,
-0.8914804459,
-0.0844197124,
0.7014593482,
-0.209272325,
1.0379751921,
0.8804191351,
0.708191812,
0.2890017927,
-0.1833990365,
-0.5087622404,
-0.5959465504,
0.0098333117,
0.0803540573,
-0.7629377842,
-0.2964626253,
0.1471386701,
0.8203274012,
0.7576864958,
0.1266677976,
-0.0249323528,
-0.1082358062,
0.4116591811,
-0.4674281776,
-0.0963361636,
-0.7966173887,
0.0037734224,
-0.2505158484,
-0.0124992002,
-0.820337832,
-0.0934241116,
-0.3462601304,
-0.4473598897,
0.0792657435,
-0.0426996201,
0.8402085304,
0.259983927,
-0.5680161715,
-0.2976725698,
-0.7213045955,
0.6373656392,
-0.5976182222,
0.3494193852,
0.2907418013,
0.3406431377,
-0.3617086709,
-0.789902389,
-0.346795857,
-0.5631912351,
-0.1800329685,
-0.3330365419,
-0.6779275537,
0.1369292736,
0.6710172296,
0.2666966915,
-0.356295377,
0.1585257798,
-0.4735189974,
-0.1413987279,
0.3501671851,
0.1012762487,
0.731790781,
0.2422690243,
-0.4603966773,
-0.1428488642,
-0.6179841757,
0.0096069621,
0.4599896073,
0.4683336616,
0.0968304649,
0.6778756976,
0.1987810582,
0.5982728601,
0.386005193,
0.2769702375,
-0.2445152849,
-0.434370786,
-0.275703758,
-0.1462935656,
0.7726032138,
0.0309632551,
0.1733042002,
-0.2220875025,
-0.2267728448,
0.045279935,
0.674913764,
-0.8769990802,
-0.2249186337,
-0.0368533321,
-0.291105181,
-0.6919748187,
-0.0335062966,
-0.6485871077,
-0.6805016398,
0.0445849858,
0.7277336121,
-0.3405290842,
-0.229118973,
-0.0861971006,
-0.1860863864,
0.2430656254,
-0.0109625142,
-1.1166383028,
0.5440708995,
0.4621369839,
0.7257014513,
0.0289277099,
-0.2979179919,
-0.6562408805,
-0.3009458184,
-0.674977839,
0.0878933892,
-0.551224649,
-0.2199352235,
-0.0829283968,
-0.298053354,
-0.1812835485,
-0.2930375934,
-0.0101163583,
-1.0027248859,
0.000770117,
-0.1540838778,
-0.3779836595,
-0.1498067081,
0.154016763,
-1.0337491035,
0.6281756759,
-0.0655140355,
-0.6877285242,
0.358571887,
-0.6661028266,
-0.4908187389,
-0.1667104214,
-0.0548514724,
-0.3554090261,
0.3495435715,
-0.033268638,
0.1544280797,
-0.0988154188,
0.0065440768,
-0.4957717955,
-0.2242839187,
0.4576984644,
-0.772580862,
1.20642066,
0.1401851177,
-0.5547145605,
0.390614599,
-0.7332162857,
-0.0298535749,
0.4866895974,
-0.4563000202,
-0.1699722111,
-0.002252301,
-0.2327085882,
0.0463162437,
0.4048069119,
-0.4741721451,
0.3046962023,
-0.2808530033,
0.3535892069,
0.7038332224,
0.2281401753,
0.7264080644,
-0.0012652855,
0.5911585689,
-0.2278570384,
0.3149639666,
-0.0206475519,
-0.2668336034,
-0.6287439466,
-0.3193315864,
0.5125334859,
0.2668637931,
-0.5988621116,
0.1718314439,
-0.2009197474,
-0.5670421124,
-0.3416673541,
0.0981080085,
0.3733591139,
-0.0063223671,
0.2264926285,
-0.238265872,
-0.3219068348,
-0.7731587291,
-0.4262214601,
-0.2490099818,
-0.0578113683,
0.1614322364,
0.4500520229,
0.0359239653,
0.5468960404,
-0.2392061651,
-0.1712111384,
-0.3654543757,
0.1475117803,
-0.0067290985,
0.4809516668,
0.8257127404,
-0.9110155702,
-0.5423370004,
-0.0798435956,
-0.4337002337,
0.0239319541,
-0.3003669977,
0.0356748514,
0.0009683318,
0.7245486379,
-0.3967734873,
0.451741308,
0.533444643,
-0.5227557421,
0.4297326803,
-0.3287582695,
-0.0866054818,
-0.8253886104,
0.0634263828,
-0.2071062624,
-0.0726119801,
-1.1709845066,
0.5928906202,
0.2759979069,
-0.1578131467,
-0.5134822726,
0.4438563883,
-0.1682454646,
-0.0352455042,
-0.3614676893,
-0.4193124473,
-0.1691553742,
0.6463521123,
-0.3871027529,
0.7150942087,
0.5934112072,
-0.4537527263,
0.4361960888,
-0.3181850016,
0.1131447852,
0.1915697902,
-0.7743639946,
0.0699088424,
0.2528175414,
0.2850005925,
-1.0876404047,
-0.0220334996,
-0.0361669734,
-0.7328845263,
0.5278561711,
-0.1728470922,
-0.5619539022,
-0.0817008242,
-0.3319898844,
0.4205013812,
0.3041524887,
-0.6667284966,
0.8060445189,
0.3419536352,
0.2107701749,
-0.5860401392,
-0.7041127682,
0.3396240473,
-0.2227112353,
-0.358632654,
-0.1558821797,
-0.1236588508,
-0.3815244436,
-0.0825263113,
0.1176374853,
-0.0629875511,
0.4707763493,
0.2391917259,
0.1388157755,
-0.1958488375,
-0.1869354993,
-0.2552602887,
0.1276727468,
0.5043974519,
-0.3506581783,
0.8057177067,
-0.1866900772,
-0.4233796895,
-0.2242143303,
0.2548680604,
1.1416524649,
-0.2720926404,
0.9583232999,
0.5922164321,
-0.5692322254,
0.1341530234,
-0.2619482875,
-0.151526764,
-0.4715722799,
0.6839894652,
-0.6467142701,
-0.4661833048,
0.779671073,
0.2805007696,
0.212692976,
0.7994214892,
0.6285818219,
0.3684944808,
1.4914973974,
0.5992980599,
-0.3571413755,
0.7086165547,
-0.3332475126,
0.1401899457,
-0.7376769781,
0.051145535,
-0.507778883,
-0.4121096134,
-0.5581108928,
-0.2844208181,
0.096865654,
0.0357951075,
-0.4066022635,
0.4399826825,
-0.2122110724,
0.4830946922,
0.6849982142,
-0.0281260405,
-0.2402442247,
0.0088689076,
-0.2886484563,
0.0570003577,
-0.7690714002,
-0.0447666198,
1.3586640358,
0.5606339574,
0.7518811822,
0.3253300488,
0.3464410305,
0.4714627862,
0.2582673132,
-0.7545150518,
0.4263486564,
-0.2538908422,
-0.8356113434,
-0.5069601536,
-0.4739480913,
-1.0447400808,
0.2375459671,
-0.1833734363,
-0.6790384054,
0.2302878499,
0.0229039658,
-0.2327212989,
0.8586355448,
-0.7453858256,
0.8322238326,
-0.2189501673,
-0.2172722667,
-0.207757324,
-0.5605635643,
0.0719942972,
-0.2095252872,
-0.0052335267,
0.4724355638,
0.065751642,
0.8310399652,
-0.4294894636,
1.0505416393,
-0.2810520232,
-0.0916654766,
0.2166503817,
0.4984813035,
0.6829649806,
-0.3412168026,
0.1182965338,
0.1304353178,
-0.236880973,
-0.7574611306,
-0.6892261505,
0.6587267518,
-0.8355573416,
-0.6228928566,
-0.2530474365,
-0.5992392898,
-0.0277041588,
0.3862069547,
0.257999897,
0.6921880841,
-0.2691893876,
0.4414917827,
0.6934108138,
-0.002702326,
0.3733589053,
0.449955821,
-0.2268051952,
-0.3592237234,
1.2084544897,
0.2554446161,
0.8375199437,
0.405503124,
0.2164445221,
-0.1825217456,
-0.558105588,
-0.5758503079,
0.0234938469,
-0.6154127717,
-0.0710588321,
-0.4864003658,
-0.3732020259,
-0.4681440592,
-0.1490565091,
-0.3777237236,
-0.5972473621,
-0.1836391687,
-0.1603657156,
0.0628382191,
0.9177832603,
-0.0739742815,
0.3278256953,
-0.3107395172,
0.1758093238,
0.598768115,
0.2698085904,
0.0965269059,
-0.8813690543,
-0.3074836433,
-0.0405004211,
-0.2083145976,
-1.072183609,
0.2021292895,
-0.0603658259,
0.3372767568,
0.684920013,
-0.2172658145,
0.2970513105,
-0.5863073468,
0.7470284104,
0.3536833227,
-0.8217976093,
0.2583646476,
-0.2930588722,
0.3146122098,
0.166264534,
0.2100462466,
-0.2678439319,
-0.7813792825,
-1.128084898,
-0.5553203821,
0.5910838842,
0.1514587849,
0.4625785649,
0.1706862897,
0.3236941099,
-0.2124033868,
-0.0376383774,
-0.787509203,
-0.3833920956,
-0.2058604509,
-0.066532433,
-0.0255244505,
-0.3214703798,
-0.223247543,
0.2252297401,
0.4295866489,
0.0794894919,
0.306327939,
-0.2759884,
0.0441853069,
-0.3828131855,
0.0775281191,
0.765494585,
0.5550456047,
0.1035999507,
0.3830092251,
0.3669064343,
-0.651650846,
0.158913061,
0.0577406958,
-0.2764505148,
-0.2575682104,
0.4403266311,
0.9552740455,
-0.0870312974,
-0.3142651618,
0.5075071454,
-0.2640082836,
-0.1928803325,
-0.1198330149,
0.0181949791,
-0.3300335109,
0.2272454947,
0.4947703481,
0.3148646653,
-0.0711636096,
-0.3561936319,
0.2664368749,
0.761259973,
-0.8302496672,
-0.4433569014,
0.953327477,
-0.0849151835,
-0.3939558566,
0.276586026,
-0.250957787,
-0.7863506675,
0.901306808,
0.6898120642,
0.6790550947,
-0.3095096052,
-0.151803568,
0.32774508,
0.7900124788,
0.236509189,
-0.2734996676,
0.3109043837,
-0.607159853,
-0.2333595157,
-0.4113755226,
-0.1880434752,
0.3503762484,
-0.7260854244,
-0.0130080348,
-0.96481812,
-0.1845273525,
0.1640266925,
0.07865417,
-0.3608030081,
0.2797385156,
0.169897452,
0.9011089206,
-0.9719215631,
0.6890137196,
0.5882742405,
-0.4654222131,
-0.6334801316,
-0.0873628631,
0.141743198,
-0.8721202016,
0.7601989508,
-0.249890089,
0.1530195624,
-0.0895086899,
-0.4444975853,
-0.879200995,
0.6851060987,
0.3709308803,
-0.1964915097,
-0.0477105193,
0.026371168,
0.6659222245,
-0.3622696102,
-0.078696765,
0.5777693391,
0.3208559155,
0.0585594065,
-0.7061443329,
0.3113489151,
-0.1848795861,
-0.1359189004,
0.5283278823,
-0.5968049765,
0.8624945283,
-0.222409904,
-0.0497112237,
-0.1123697311,
0.8478534818,
-0.1681784689,
-0.1607847512,
0.7751069069,
0.633683145,
0.4394886196,
0.0429708809,
1.3886630535,
-0.3649880588,
0.134418264,
0.8702701926,
0.2543606162,
0.8258817792,
0.3695192635,
-0.3045251071,
0.0856933817,
0.309215188,
-0.0803219974,
0.3222973049,
0.3467384279,
-0.026389394,
-0.0041655181,
-0.042727869,
-0.1329357028,
0.2418779135,
0.4105395079,
-0.3796717227,
-0.005398524,
0.1669774055,
0.3550182879,
0.0045718434,
-0.4180036783,
0.8175819516,
-0.2968881428,
-0.1895456761,
0.7090454102,
0.101249665,
0.2472481579,
-0.8220968843,
0.2025652677,
-0.1538837105,
0.189347595,
0.1268142611,
-0.3381907046,
-0.0086270599,
0.0273782294,
-0.2216999978,
-0.1678607613,
0.5905617476,
-0.3115929961,
-0.6020133495,
0.3482012451,
-0.0408433154,
-0.1090540662,
-0.1146622896,
-0.5514186621,
0.0393454768,
0.2238051444,
-0.4212391675,
0.6510701776,
0.3705209196,
-0.0414883122,
0.5688433051,
0.5467740893,
0.6225220561,
0.693729341,
-0.0077445013,
0.9350153208,
-0.2966164947,
-0.3861379921,
-0.7791445255,
0.0062299077,
-0.0592516549,
-0.1304674,
0.7095987201,
0.494846642,
0.6142206788,
0.2424322814,
0.7045513988,
-0.1357858032,
0.0174406581,
-0.2391364872,
0.7310071588,
-0.463932544,
0.1644123048,
0.2243516594,
-0.5534878373,
-0.4034404159,
0.0728591084,
-0.3153024018,
-0.0302016512,
0.6475868821,
0.6747341752,
-0.008772525,
-0.3954356313,
0.4300312102,
0.5509642959,
0.7042480707,
0.3532245457,
0.3736219704,
-0.4564081132,
0.9424687028,
-0.1338295788,
-0.4559818804,
-0.2441727221,
-0.3893968463,
-0.9257442355,
-0.4592464268,
-0.129806295,
-0.6032906175,
-0.1698016077,
0.5172548294,
0.4569834173,
-0.8690026402,
-0.1171993837,
-0.1054915413,
-0.0624302849,
-0.4010778666,
-0.241816476,
0.5425406694,
-0.5718704462,
-0.7466885448,
0.3415828645,
0.0876945555,
0.2667910755,
-0.610807538,
0.0432741195,
-0.2108680904,
0.5177123547,
0.273329556,
0.4372368753,
-0.6908704638,
-0.2395031899,
-0.0117627019,
-0.5150700212,
-0.1705988348,
1.0829905272,
-0.3381806314,
0.6871520281,
0.4778592885,
0.9706837535,
0.1798816174,
-0.1834630221,
0.7423309684,
-0.8293007612,
0.1251806766,
0.1411541849,
0.3693148494,
-0.0077648824,
-0.4025775492,
0.1621771157,
0.0949069411,
-0.2144577205,
-0.7874097228,
0.2136208713,
-0.6792350411,
-0.4222567976,
1.1101893187,
-0.2763967514,
-0.3143431246,
0.3141621351,
-0.17424348,
0.0536000691,
-0.1906782687,
0.8815752864,
0.8190460801,
0.1332055181,
0.2846899033,
-0.5756613016,
0.5161281824,
0.6639854908,
-0.3497208655,
0.3891389966,
0.2053202242,
-0.0507710613,
0.459875226,
0.361552,
-0.266087383,
0.3613114953,
0.3139436841,
-0.2120711803,
-0.0349189304,
-0.4603618383,
-0.8015190363,
0.5869655609,
0.2146221697,
-0.2976231277
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02748v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02748v1
|
Compositional Generalization for Data-to-Text Generation
| 2023-12-05T13:23:15 | 2023-12-05T13:23:15 |
Xinnuo Xu, Ivan Titov, Mirella Lapata
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Data-to-text generation involves transforming structured data, often
represented as predicate-argument tuples, into coherent textual descriptions.
Despite recent advances, systems still struggle when confronted with unseen
combinations of predicates, producing unfaithful descriptions (e.g.
hallucinations or omissions). We refer to this issue as compositional
generalisation, and it encouraged us to create a benchmark for assessing the
performance of different approaches on this specific problem. Furthermore, we
propose a novel model that addresses compositional generalization by clustering
predicates into groups. Our model generates text in a sentence-by-sentence
manner, relying on one cluster of predicates at a time. This approach
significantly outperforms T5~baselines across all evaluation metrics.Notably,
it achieved a 31% improvement over T5 in terms of a metric focused on
maintaining faithfulness to the input.
|
[
-0.2658918798,
-0.8379465938,
0.7448775768,
0.4368050992,
-0.4417611957,
0.0396059491,
-0.367421478,
-0.2132406086,
-0.0039990419,
0.4755309224,
-0.4836373329,
-0.8222869039,
-0.5178509355,
0.2238167226,
-0.7658001184,
1.2029651403,
-0.0085172625,
-0.3064809144,
-0.5061255693,
0.1117628068,
-0.665483892,
-0.5673180223,
-0.0358812511,
-0.3321118951,
0.4357381165,
0.2743648887,
0.4202982485,
0.6768891811,
0.5100819468,
0.2433377802,
0.4356625378,
0.2698775828,
-0.6600632071,
0.3098857105,
-0.1087885574,
-0.296957463,
-0.342633605,
-0.0464820229,
0.7531369328,
1.0487226248,
-0.2101399601,
0.0446512066,
0.1010039449,
0.6544776559,
-0.743132174,
0.0914296806,
-0.7536277175,
0.1545141339,
-0.1851085722,
-0.0912659466,
-0.6986678839,
-0.3747197092,
0.2073536068,
-0.6801267862,
0.4323672354,
-0.0524701774,
0.5088293552,
0.2960756719,
-0.2567902505,
-0.308835417,
-1.126429677,
0.7851220369,
-0.4621832967,
0.1333977729,
0.2278268635,
0.2238882482,
-0.2256305516,
-1.1195784807,
-0.3988800943,
0.0104463249,
-0.2242499143,
0.2593028843,
-0.2022374272,
-0.0780601278,
-0.0278552584,
0.5724720359,
-0.6828730702,
-0.3372552395,
-0.1988002509,
-0.0000915726,
0.7825587392,
0.3129506707,
0.1558612436,
-0.0357830897,
-0.058504466,
-0.0286250859,
-0.4496337473,
-0.2809202373,
0.1202982813,
0.265378356,
0.0995967165,
0.7258729339,
-0.2941794693,
0.7579387426,
0.2929575443,
0.2556107938,
0.1280200779,
-0.7245879769,
-0.2761468589,
-0.0240640305,
0.9363915324,
0.3631461561,
0.2907390594,
-0.7680816054,
-0.0455658175,
0.6027004719,
0.6901215911,
-0.9069056511,
-0.3607376516,
0.1718871444,
-0.6095766425,
-0.5913270712,
0.3221703768,
-0.8479201198,
-0.0700356588,
-0.1319521964,
0.3858936131,
-0.3658514321,
0.098654218,
0.2574061751,
-0.055219736,
-0.0207092836,
-0.1316374987,
-1.0232225657,
0.5295725465,
0.6397470236,
0.6175760031,
-0.6128943563,
-0.2132228911,
-0.4752944708,
0.5860010982,
-0.3858261406,
0.8554289341,
-0.7202600241,
-0.7353460193,
-0.1354446858,
-0.344527185,
-0.2415342182,
-0.6817496419,
0.4862597585,
-0.026194213,
0.6100003123,
0.0344699621,
-0.7229753137,
0.1265575141,
-0.0813942924,
-0.5787872672,
1.0416001081,
0.1956172138,
-0.5446824431,
0.5329321027,
-0.6141633391,
-0.7502855062,
-0.0877052248,
-0.3828485012,
-0.6521120071,
0.6329009533,
0.1778554022,
0.4788385332,
-0.4767183661,
0.5539470911,
-0.0510930344,
-0.4095657766,
0.3488317132,
-0.0686318874,
0.0085010994,
0.1605288535,
-0.338783145,
0.0681584254,
-0.8832899928,
0.2550595105,
0.1401964277,
-0.3216641843,
-0.3033584058,
0.2606374323,
0.0028934588,
-0.1818827987,
0.1291565597,
-0.3585304916,
0.2030731738,
-0.5299992561,
0.4366848767,
0.5561990142,
0.0889280364,
0.4940240979,
-0.5583438873,
0.2890757024,
0.1901924759,
0.0288056936,
-0.2542225718,
-0.3677641749,
-0.5846287012,
-0.0747952685,
0.3182267845,
0.2209298462,
-0.5812003613,
0.7274806499,
-0.4243206382,
-0.6047564745,
-0.1099174023,
-0.0288764592,
0.4279921651,
0.5576188564,
0.5376673341,
-0.297706902,
-0.5174028873,
-0.9032648206,
-0.36241889,
-0.0905402601,
-0.1798996627,
-0.0265958253,
0.3049921691,
-0.4092855453,
1.0121071339,
-0.7964257002,
-0.2641811669,
-0.1578446329,
0.4109058678,
-0.138667658,
0.5613099933,
0.4174252152,
-0.7896254063,
-0.4288269281,
0.0003150424,
-0.7485592961,
-0.3144595623,
-0.0006952334,
-0.1713102758,
0.1617221087,
0.386995405,
-0.3749543726,
0.4581992328,
0.3613392115,
-0.2868720591,
0.5534392595,
-0.0440315902,
0.0095969206,
-1.4939873219,
0.1595008671,
-0.2184068263,
-0.0814538226,
-0.6322976351,
-0.0521147475,
-0.3014938533,
-0.0474489741,
-0.0475837328,
0.1307478249,
-0.2946336269,
0.0434828289,
-0.1655650437,
-0.1134626195,
0.1133808941,
0.3705827296,
-0.1118652672,
0.6809780002,
0.5579941869,
-0.6945679188,
0.3166792095,
0.3188048899,
-0.1030870229,
0.5348853469,
-0.7242468596,
0.1969828904,
-0.2381268442,
0.3995952308,
-0.8818314672,
-0.3503921926,
0.0409581475,
-0.3943183124,
-0.0142267831,
0.2000591606,
-0.4748298526,
-0.1104492247,
-0.1938992143,
0.6022225022,
0.3709689379,
-0.1658242196,
0.8912711143,
0.1216808632,
0.0012879203,
-0.1581117809,
-0.8286334872,
0.0796220228,
-0.4265038967,
-0.6001306176,
0.8500782847,
-0.1545546204,
-0.190076232,
0.1299658269,
-0.0706272051,
-0.1909268945,
0.0048529305,
0.1969487667,
-0.0179958139,
-0.099777028,
0.3850082755,
0.1167484596,
-0.0173109863,
0.1676685065,
-0.4401169121,
0.718535006,
0.0281837098,
-0.1128588617,
-0.117243737,
0.8424650431,
0.245795995,
-0.3615073264,
0.6044211984,
0.4387517571,
-0.3188881874,
-0.6368216872,
-0.2716082931,
-0.172925204,
-0.4528242946,
0.2398792654,
-0.4204074442,
-0.8069249988,
0.5138592124,
-0.1051826105,
0.0429834612,
0.6029188037,
0.3523587286,
-0.1730516851,
0.9901943207,
0.4880312383,
0.1726506501,
0.3488084078,
-0.0980201811,
0.1601481587,
-0.3634416163,
-0.3528950512,
-0.4763675928,
-0.2404329926,
-0.7242046595,
-0.2954651713,
0.4327138662,
-0.1916472316,
-0.0271438491,
0.1169186383,
-0.6613013744,
0.4757787585,
0.3672196269,
0.1403681785,
0.3895075619,
0.2767228186,
-0.0219485015,
-0.0645896867,
-0.5006806254,
-0.6185168624,
1.5176856518,
-0.2429927886,
0.6434488893,
0.1469034702,
1.0052281618,
0.5262024403,
0.2312720716,
-0.574554503,
0.6170819998,
-0.7481557727,
-0.2778148949,
-0.1776876599,
-0.5273966789,
-1.1965067387,
0.0991458222,
-0.2964196503,
-0.5227511525,
-0.1631272435,
-0.0540213436,
-0.2036143243,
-0.1876343191,
-0.7282559276,
0.8363319039,
-0.0359405093,
-0.2832883894,
-0.0478772111,
-0.5367525816,
0.34605515,
-0.3805178106,
-0.08309035,
0.3037841916,
0.1880197227,
0.5809583664,
-0.4503581524,
0.6338953972,
0.0721861124,
-0.0725227892,
0.3279969096,
-0.0942960009,
0.3049756885,
-0.2116097361,
0.1022116244,
-0.1687808186,
-0.1126813963,
-0.4276034534,
-0.8383366466,
0.4538289905,
-0.5353752971,
-0.2965719402,
-0.0482897982,
-0.5680263638,
-0.4998874068,
0.1471437663,
0.6437059045,
0.4983167052,
-0.5967315435,
0.3514051437,
0.8148127198,
-0.1023531407,
0.42518574,
0.0603067912,
-0.3769598603,
-0.4754886031,
0.9846267104,
0.0069211149,
0.2987666726,
0.5111651421,
0.1964843869,
-0.2950032651,
-0.5134167671,
-0.2519266605,
0.0836386159,
-0.3799209893,
-0.0191824306,
-0.673771739,
-0.0677244291,
-0.5338118672,
-0.0804017484,
-0.2979463935,
-0.467775315,
-0.5200209022,
-0.06182478,
-0.2191585153,
0.9168373942,
0.2964238822,
0.5257368684,
-0.7460446358,
0.6002438664,
0.4281500578,
0.3246840537,
-0.21930255,
-0.2109406143,
-0.1767800897,
-0.0572322942,
-0.6148066521,
-0.8659823537,
0.0801019669,
0.3878576756,
0.5021212101,
0.2598591745,
0.0324169733,
0.5646668077,
-0.4383525252,
0.7381289005,
0.1197554693,
-1.091678381,
0.693043232,
-0.5001569986,
0.2757127285,
0.6454711556,
-0.0250785369,
-0.3636058867,
-0.5082169175,
-0.548368156,
-0.7468752861,
0.2040100098,
0.4653327763,
0.075757198,
-0.0148200262,
0.3442910016,
0.3868924677,
0.4109147191,
-0.7239357829,
-0.1483232975,
-0.3461047113,
-0.5803329945,
-0.2694339752,
-0.1424949914,
-0.1488347501,
0.0015351252,
0.3846556246,
-0.2168466151,
0.4238685369,
0.0997342989,
-0.1625989228,
0.0623236485,
0.4133258462,
0.6175470352,
0.6181393266,
0.157403037,
0.2435966283,
-0.2961750925,
-0.4693425,
0.2536230087,
0.1577865928,
-0.3196752071,
-0.0407117493,
0.3868906498,
0.5699357986,
-0.0537569076,
-0.4500628114,
0.4485504329,
-0.1070638224,
-0.3824033737,
0.0832233503,
0.2069477439,
-0.0641951337,
-0.1528130472,
0.4844017327,
-0.0954176784,
0.2706072628,
-0.7293027639,
0.2567472458,
0.1948605031,
-0.056581609,
-0.3662031889,
0.6903270483,
0.1288648695,
0.0831019282,
0.4093972743,
-0.0542378463,
-0.3427203,
0.4206688702,
0.6894541979,
1.1745591164,
-0.145608753,
0.4974712133,
-0.0094375424,
0.2016091645,
-0.0565886982,
0.4029720724,
-0.1995359808,
-0.7088535428,
-0.3269635737,
-0.542747736,
-0.2783745527,
0.0655054823,
-0.6655880213,
-0.0477659255,
-0.4172751606,
-0.1654018015,
0.0744684935,
-0.129402101,
-0.3424198925,
0.5333538651,
-0.061098367,
0.2526803315,
-1.0299856663,
0.4829676449,
0.7846657634,
-0.3283115625,
-0.6809962392,
0.2918446362,
-0.5733023882,
-0.2971214652,
0.1808869839,
0.2566655576,
0.0539170466,
0.032814689,
-0.5676417947,
-0.487308681,
0.8926523924,
0.4773212671,
-0.3317565024,
-0.1094697714,
0.7063826919,
0.8386304975,
-0.7203765512,
-0.300552547,
0.6364433765,
0.6234015822,
-0.0418377444,
-0.6548475623,
0.039780315,
-0.2800225317,
0.180061847,
0.1762873977,
-0.6343019009,
0.7778462172,
0.1336454004,
-0.3635240495,
0.1235350966,
0.6614679098,
0.1667336375,
0.5079048872,
0.2099574506,
0.7746235132,
0.7366845012,
-0.2897543013,
0.8728727698,
-0.0384986587,
0.0937431231,
1.3658183813,
-0.19989416,
0.4238568246,
0.4740897715,
-0.0954243243,
0.6127197146,
0.3668112755,
-0.0922965035,
0.6605114341,
0.4001196921,
-0.3889091313,
-0.1974062324,
-0.1815365851,
-0.3780052066,
0.6069715619,
0.193394646,
-0.6158708334,
-0.1310483813,
0.0264636222,
-0.2257717848,
0.6212236881,
-0.1941997856,
1.0605431795,
-0.2923463285,
-0.9400864244,
0.350551039,
0.0577507541,
0.4499312937,
-0.4413344264,
0.0350815803,
-0.2254773527,
0.0392020047,
-0.3131935298,
-0.6102704406,
0.6111391783,
0.044779893,
-0.613730371,
-0.2750671208,
0.7285078168,
-0.5219766498,
-0.6138111949,
0.108638972,
0.5338638425,
0.0079391552,
-0.267295599,
-0.1043738648,
-0.0431009531,
-0.0781556517,
0.0872760937,
0.1470551491,
0.5036622882,
-0.1727179736,
0.2513325214,
0.4396365881,
-0.0227843132,
0.3667434454,
0.1184147373,
1.0049716234,
-0.6770416498,
-0.5301508307,
-0.8654122353,
0.3995549679,
0.0527102537,
-0.2643779516,
0.5086574554,
0.9348857999,
0.8502542377,
-0.19700104,
1.0219484568,
-0.0857808366,
0.3404313028,
-0.5094409585,
0.5588050485,
-0.4161029458,
-0.0235012211,
-0.473633498,
-1.3056704998,
-0.3270899057,
0.2712521851,
-0.116911754,
0.0966760963,
0.8896166086,
0.4647318423,
-0.0272726435,
0.2492906749,
0.3160272837,
0.0551236756,
0.358494103,
0.7034582496,
0.8421478271,
-0.5385365486,
0.5626972318,
-0.0722949803,
0.0778209865,
0.1938806325,
-0.8300455809,
-0.8369166851,
-0.6611153483,
-0.2089791,
-0.1524492502,
-0.0165601261,
0.4554695487,
0.5581814051,
-0.7184325457,
-0.2307810932,
-0.5238180161,
-0.2210559696,
-0.1556403041,
-0.221807465,
0.0982998163,
-0.3889980912,
-0.7232480049,
0.3999468982,
0.2169211805,
0.1372967511,
-0.2382621318,
0.1156798303,
0.1714943945,
0.256599009,
0.646299541,
-0.2655684054,
-0.3091254532,
-0.0596783198,
-0.1502359807,
-0.1152864322,
0.1778944433,
1.0040426254,
-0.6800656319,
0.3758846521,
0.3322245777,
0.7397161722,
0.6461977959,
0.481592536,
0.7950795293,
-0.9073424935,
-0.2194070071,
0.1983428299,
-0.0815427452,
0.3179529309,
-0.2404972464,
0.5756466985,
0.4283543527,
-0.4731043875,
-0.6908201575,
0.404404521,
-1.0681079626,
-0.2357006222,
0.9364868402,
0.0368763357,
-0.0586992316,
0.1686363965,
0.0035314374,
0.2670789063,
-0.3395133018,
0.9938545823,
0.8356388211,
-0.0404229872,
0.2362556607,
0.112477392,
0.2740707099,
0.603600502,
-1.2386021614,
0.1558594257,
0.8689078093,
0.0537744686,
0.1121774465,
0.501788497,
-0.1639150381,
0.1298623681,
-0.1200663745,
-0.1224379316,
0.0499264672,
-0.4484197497,
-0.117150262,
0.5205743909,
-0.371925205,
-0.2279756665
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02730v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02730v1
|
Towards Measuring Representational Similarity of Large Language Models
| 2023-12-05T12:48:04 | 2023-12-05T12:48:04 |
Max Klabunde, Mehdi Ben Amor, Michael Granitzer, Florian Lemmerich
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Understanding the similarity of the numerous released large language models
(LLMs) has many uses, e.g., simplifying model selection, detecting illegal
model reuse, and advancing our understanding of what makes LLMs perform well.
In this work, we measure the similarity of representations of a set of LLMs
with 7B parameters. Our results suggest that some LLMs are substantially
different from others. We identify challenges of using representational
similarity measures that suggest the need of careful study of similarity scores
to avoid false conclusions.
|
[
-0.5649220943,
-0.2840777338,
0.8062316179,
0.2074249238,
-0.5163969994,
-0.0800449476,
-0.3300871253,
-0.3837257326,
0.2712335587,
0.8133907914,
-0.128701508,
-0.5767661929,
-0.7149223089,
0.2200361043,
-0.6254791617,
0.0921673253,
-0.2554391921,
0.3453153372,
-0.3941122591,
-0.3885275722,
-0.3715318739,
-0.48260656,
-0.5359963179,
-0.5266913772,
0.7261836529,
-0.1423438042,
0.7210062146,
0.6504873037,
0.6889105439,
0.3442238569,
-0.159806937,
0.0148416413,
-0.5153488517,
0.2175792903,
-0.0970795602,
-0.715331912,
0.0441850163,
0.0826449543,
1.0679084063,
1.0340040922,
-0.0005326297,
0.3120086491,
0.1892987043,
0.5294960737,
-0.4575550258,
0.2796191871,
-0.6226534247,
-0.1270654351,
-0.2934116423,
0.0396933444,
-0.5006073117,
-0.3993748128,
-0.1908124685,
-0.2632377446,
0.1188548133,
0.4562824667,
0.5694624186,
0.0510334186,
-0.5019155741,
-0.3682459593,
-0.4361053407,
0.9594652653,
-1.1303639412,
0.4888560176,
0.0597338378,
0.4841915667,
-0.33206743,
-0.4268814623,
-0.5689929128,
-0.7921940684,
-0.0682007074,
-0.2321842164,
-0.1009804457,
-0.0347530358,
0.6754820943,
0.3276504874,
-0.6130005121,
0.3424791694,
-0.2560054064,
-0.2879884839,
0.6108021736,
0.3929128349,
0.1256070584,
-0.0610584915,
-0.3410290778,
-0.2599383891,
-1.0447884798,
-0.2869374752,
0.5404533148,
0.2868835628,
-0.0009632775,
0.467810154,
0.0913072899,
0.6315284371,
-0.277551502,
-0.2441293448,
0.3197249174,
0.1728487611,
-0.2979418039,
-0.1813656092,
0.6735820174,
0.4665695131,
0.4541813135,
-0.1369175017,
-0.3588548303,
-0.0706407502,
0.2551413178,
-0.6600744724,
0.2379030436,
-0.3849969208,
-0.8028101325,
-0.1008109823,
0.1759880334,
-0.323540777,
-0.5616847277,
-0.4627458751,
0.239982307,
-0.1913253963,
-0.2900736928,
-0.0488008931,
-0.0030918305,
0.7411298156,
0.2928340435,
-0.7151662707,
0.4610200822,
0.7583789229,
0.8848997951,
-0.4897951484,
-0.3276674449,
-0.0708012506,
0.0681977049,
-0.8286722302,
0.6234580278,
-0.7389208674,
-0.3879318237,
0.0821700916,
0.0157588478,
0.055988051,
-1.08951056,
0.1827469915,
-0.7038761973,
-0.2973344028,
-0.6710896492,
-0.8088421822,
-0.6216722727,
0.5793074369,
-0.991017282,
0.8950994611,
0.0511850044,
-0.5281369686,
0.343664974,
0.0026478441,
0.0562663935,
-0.1540462673,
-0.2893003225,
-0.3296900094,
0.5737959743,
-0.1787175238,
0.6369568706,
-0.3861131668,
0.0190790482,
-0.802485168,
-0.569016099,
0.4185885489,
-0.5277917385,
0.4651788771,
0.2550400496,
-0.0169958882,
0.1562063694,
-0.6070790291,
-0.0987990797,
0.0531925373,
-0.2227495015,
-0.5004397631,
-0.0618413128,
0.1400496513,
0.0789627731,
0.4723843932,
-0.300096333,
0.2939356863,
-0.3442091942,
0.1755059063,
0.5667193532,
-0.1517406404,
0.1800393611,
-0.6584807634,
0.516918242,
0.066138275,
-0.4091238081,
0.0027402008,
-0.4261640608,
-0.5387925506,
-0.2395511419,
0.4628873765,
0.0116637573,
-0.1662518382,
0.2469233721,
-0.2540138066,
-0.761590004,
-0.3010720015,
0.2610943913,
0.3183064163,
-0.194884181,
0.0720233396,
-0.4697982371,
-0.2632552385,
-1.0780991316,
-0.4514009655,
-0.0834592506,
-0.0604175963,
0.292006284,
0.5699828863,
-0.0999491289,
0.3718302846,
-0.1971011311,
-0.0387840085,
-0.1984666288,
0.0328766368,
0.3093413711,
0.1567145437,
0.9848409891,
-0.4499863982,
-0.4496396184,
-0.0468046889,
-0.8825495839,
-0.1632817537,
0.0122853043,
0.4129949212,
0.1716366857,
0.88722229,
-0.5872772932,
0.2161277831,
0.5414816737,
-0.1637784541,
0.4709221721,
-0.3441957235,
0.4136018157,
-1.1336424351,
0.0604862012,
-0.1683883965,
-0.4800125659,
-0.1576836109,
0.4189213514,
0.01653919,
-0.0177221783,
-0.5941160321,
0.6306061745,
-0.7592363358,
-0.6637628078,
-0.3394393325,
0.1351497322,
-0.1411826611,
0.0325779617,
-0.2674251199,
0.6763398647,
0.6657974124,
-0.4070107341,
0.7983922958,
-0.1491088271,
-0.6095727682,
0.3188008368,
-0.6026313901,
0.1724729091,
-0.1450284272,
0.0314311869,
-1.133225441,
0.0102052549,
0.1123588905,
-0.2318404913,
0.2735328674,
-0.070174098,
-0.699981153,
-0.1332073659,
-0.3838897347,
0.2623461783,
0.5457083583,
-0.4133684933,
0.8423483968,
0.1790401489,
-0.030070113,
-0.3689928651,
-0.5785279274,
0.1142636091,
-0.7614697814,
-0.4331037104,
0.2212534845,
0.1193077415,
-0.5376941562,
-0.0410358347,
-0.1441233009,
0.3109743297,
0.2047692388,
0.3954063356,
-0.188921541,
-0.5261207223,
0.0992550924,
-0.1157187074,
0.0377740376,
0.5309149623,
0.1124433354,
0.7484185696,
-0.0072789928,
-0.8851674199,
0.0110146469,
0.4721064568,
0.6193808317,
0.0725489333,
0.6745516062,
0.374969691,
-0.5333755612,
-0.0823355839,
-0.742377162,
-0.0278929975,
-0.4391743839,
0.4499492049,
-0.5998606682,
-0.9161361456,
1.0767222643,
-0.1683322936,
-0.1090290472,
0.3438732028,
0.8008233905,
0.1215517446,
0.8848682046,
0.3697707951,
-0.2075872272,
0.3262195289,
0.0262729824,
0.1828647852,
-0.6858679652,
-0.2656389177,
-0.6090304255,
-0.4480938911,
-0.7320334911,
-0.4965335727,
-0.1360555738,
0.3710358441,
-0.3629803658,
0.2409288138,
-0.1275181621,
0.554344058,
0.4452024698,
-0.177135095,
0.2985761464,
0.1006272957,
-0.1956163347,
-0.1675928235,
-0.1991847008,
-1.0413382053,
0.9859519005,
0.3702648282,
1.0148252249,
0.3608992398,
0.9673967957,
0.213058278,
0.407597661,
-0.8159455061,
0.7825413346,
-0.1616693586,
-0.4575745165,
-0.1207097173,
-0.4592020214,
-1.0282503366,
0.3564780653,
0.0106085008,
-0.9382283688,
-0.1129651293,
-0.0003779286,
0.0737838969,
0.2728941739,
-0.4948039353,
0.6729870439,
-0.0015227795,
0.19443506,
-0.4421213567,
-0.2604523599,
0.0676817745,
0.0400860459,
0.0360138714,
-0.2893942893,
-0.0625334755,
1.0430593491,
0.0935618058,
0.826058805,
0.0123703303,
-0.1708448231,
0.3977484107,
0.4079133272,
0.0531770587,
-0.0437767468,
-0.1703523397,
0.240594849,
0.2766333818,
-0.376724124,
-0.7085436583,
1.1956951618,
-0.7027922869,
-0.9310634136,
-0.5212917328,
-0.5961830616,
-0.1350839138,
0.2375056297,
-0.0463646464,
0.3236882687,
-0.2699790001,
0.3182547092,
0.4937206805,
-0.2206278294,
0.4618402421,
0.4294660389,
-0.5763162374,
0.1168569401,
0.72775805,
0.2789516747,
0.3435820937,
0.3129380345,
0.1207972467,
-0.6108739376,
-0.8350204229,
-0.1434519887,
0.4734256566,
-0.9709967971,
-0.1580067426,
-0.0852152705,
-0.1201565191,
-0.3677354455,
0.0975684151,
-0.2386826724,
0.0062256083,
-0.511725843,
-0.0416199677,
0.2665777206,
1.2019606829,
0.0681546107,
0.3432062566,
-0.7995656729,
0.2195540518,
0.2401191443,
0.4590446651,
0.2969698906,
-0.8398228884,
-0.0400829986,
-0.1498582065,
-0.3517515957,
-1.1299715042,
0.353171289,
0.0004110194,
0.966262579,
0.5501269102,
-0.2647712231,
0.3576413095,
-0.3250701725,
0.846100986,
0.1594330519,
-0.9162551761,
0.088109076,
-0.1343013048,
0.097976014,
0.2039654702,
0.6776711345,
-0.3549767137,
-0.2164894193,
-0.4580691159,
-0.4632224143,
0.2486369312,
-0.0793252736,
0.518723309,
-0.0190820657,
0.4545732439,
0.1167431697,
0.0693558082,
-0.6957885623,
-0.3658853471,
0.119949162,
-0.3099444211,
-0.0473472737,
-0.376737088,
0.0881293043,
0.1485559195,
0.4034552574,
-0.0850018412,
0.1776711047,
-0.3136111498,
-0.1570467055,
0.1042902991,
0.2238571346,
0.4662543833,
0.8718631864,
0.0031425485,
0.4998238087,
0.5407696366,
-0.3527700603,
0.2071423382,
-0.0786306262,
0.3197939694,
-0.0367246903,
0.8058392406,
0.5904434323,
0.1139845923,
-0.7786607146,
0.2902909815,
0.167775467,
-0.1500100493,
-0.2605340183,
0.1966575533,
0.5979369283,
0.4028655887,
0.0168516841,
-0.2496320009,
0.1211173534,
-0.8083871007,
0.0403408632,
0.4839504957,
-0.5690509081,
-0.1466775537,
0.1658654809,
-0.2090271562,
-0.521938622,
0.5288975835,
-0.1897420287,
-0.3454051614,
0.6501376629,
0.5671206713,
0.2774882615,
-0.223074466,
-0.1053126976,
0.2988514006,
0.2568957806,
-0.4862340391,
0.3649369478,
0.3940931857,
-0.7659745216,
-0.4567784071,
-0.5161629915,
-0.2499600947,
0.2641630471,
-0.8271310329,
0.3124807179,
-0.425126493,
-0.062005017,
-0.0101290969,
0.0501522459,
-0.6348199844,
0.006385318,
0.5227526426,
0.8156491518,
-0.9909407496,
0.7658519745,
0.722109437,
-0.4180592597,
-1.0705218315,
-0.2971063554,
-0.1912667304,
-0.9338974953,
0.5881447792,
0.315150857,
-0.0568853915,
-0.3738929927,
-0.5809096098,
-0.756968677,
0.9520824552,
0.917755127,
-0.9742158055,
-0.0268372502,
0.4425831735,
0.5768972635,
-0.6006525755,
0.3584542274,
0.6050482988,
0.3316309452,
-0.0604394451,
-0.8789476156,
0.4005291164,
0.0969905704,
0.319304049,
0.1441941708,
-0.477101773,
0.7847982645,
-0.2072349936,
-0.1769814938,
0.0982363448,
0.5020366311,
0.6527923942,
0.1512150168,
0.4690673351,
0.6197783351,
0.5500871539,
0.0344377905,
0.8806650639,
0.0467409156,
0.635381341,
0.9383870959,
-0.5195069313,
0.8595638275,
0.5564092398,
-0.3236040175,
0.0577578247,
0.5910500884,
-0.2318598479,
0.208364144,
0.8118835092,
0.1003249735,
-0.5815006495,
0.1190053821,
-0.4819637835,
0.3035045564,
0.3788227737,
-0.6807999015,
-0.4061654508,
-0.1083785594,
-0.1020247042,
0.391181618,
-0.3694387674,
0.8333183527,
0.6386298537,
-0.3153874278,
0.6549883485,
-0.1893483996,
0.4497995675,
-0.329874903,
-0.2942523658,
-0.2325206399,
-0.0961658508,
0.0509530343,
-1.1336140633,
0.4842280746,
-0.2467971593,
-0.2841816843,
0.027937945,
0.5323516726,
-0.2114533931,
-0.5741788149,
0.8085356355,
0.4685320258,
0.5010326505,
-0.1979717165,
-0.5890924335,
0.5428648591,
-0.1268696934,
-0.2752907872,
0.4123239219,
0.566781342,
-0.2089986205,
0.9202727675,
0.1715632826,
0.392167449,
0.3959947824,
0.3524346352,
0.5866034031,
-0.9799332619,
-0.2649969161,
-0.9809291959,
-0.2116100639,
-0.0247617457,
-0.3573175669,
0.7153459191,
0.533036232,
0.8721823692,
-0.1768589765,
0.4432726502,
0.2771305144,
0.5682431459,
-0.7480669618,
0.6325227022,
-0.515830934,
0.5439198017,
-0.1627760082,
-1.5732188225,
-0.3506401777,
0.7532132268,
-0.3196871579,
0.1491186172,
0.6644787788,
1.09823668,
-0.2095347941,
-0.1876951754,
0.8458729386,
0.3285638392,
0.463431865,
0.4071595371,
1.1491082907,
-0.2799422741,
0.3941100538,
0.3267676234,
0.2234254032,
-0.1560817957,
-0.8912293315,
-1.1447068453,
-0.7256566882,
-0.2745140493,
-0.2376750112,
-0.0431507453,
0.9758637547,
0.5422749519,
-0.8577082753,
-0.4222773612,
0.3970442116,
0.1931340843,
-0.0908735394,
-0.0938643441,
0.37227121,
0.0427974388,
-0.515045166,
0.1827242821,
0.0481609255,
0.0429288447,
-0.7613989711,
0.0028892602,
0.1417562664,
0.0652300417,
0.3538593948,
-0.1635734737,
-1.1190290451,
-0.7832600474,
-0.2603188157,
-0.1796939522,
0.0699386597,
0.8863356709,
-0.4587061107,
0.0862249359,
0.7816389203,
0.6613124609,
0.5479955673,
-0.4705275297,
0.4102353156,
-0.4700948894,
0.0212454069,
0.1503784359,
0.7759296298,
0.6953576207,
0.2009450197,
0.1303699464,
-0.0927458033,
-0.3103099465,
-0.8080681562,
0.3986898363,
-1.3726854324,
-0.0126994969,
1.2483348846,
-0.4296848774,
-0.1018878892,
0.0158431027,
-0.1252425909,
0.0207507592,
-0.2759538889,
0.597682178,
0.8672381043,
0.1304549128,
-0.3480384946,
-0.3568581343,
0.0639707744,
-0.0409932472,
-0.5030069351,
-0.0495849103,
0.1297020763,
0.7098555565,
0.2530533671,
0.1838170886,
-0.2866718471,
-0.1728111655,
-0.012455429,
-0.2148029506,
0.0886802673,
-0.0026438441,
-0.3142648041,
0.3165385723,
0.6040911674,
0.095914945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02706v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02706v2
|
Large Knowledge Model: Perspectives and Challenges
| 2023-12-05T12:07:30 | 2024-06-26T16:11:55 |
Huajun Chen
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Humankind's understanding of the world is fundamentally linked to our
perception and cognition, with \emph{human languages} serving as one of the
major carriers of \emph{world knowledge}. In this vein, \emph{Large Language
Models} (LLMs) like ChatGPT epitomize the pre-training of extensive,
sequence-based world knowledge into neural networks, facilitating the
processing and manipulation of this knowledge in a parametric space. This
article explores large models through the lens of "knowledge". We initially
investigate the role of symbolic knowledge such as Knowledge Graphs (KGs) in
enhancing LLMs, covering aspects like knowledge-augmented language model,
structure-inducing pre-training, knowledgeable prompts, structured CoT,
knowledge editing, semantic tools for LLM and knowledgeable AI agents.
Subsequently, we examine how LLMs can boost traditional symbolic knowledge
bases, encompassing aspects like using LLM as KG builder and controller,
structured knowledge pretraining, and LLM-enhanced symbolic reasoning.
Considering the intricate nature of human knowledge, we advocate for the
creation of \emph{Large Knowledge Models} (LKM), specifically engineered to
manage diversified spectrum of knowledge structures. This promising undertaking
would entail several key challenges, such as disentangling knowledge base from
language models, cognitive alignment with human knowledge, integration of
perception and cognition, and building large commonsense models for interacting
with physical world, among others. We finally propose a five-"A" principle to
distinguish the concept of LKM.
|
[
-0.3055799305,
-0.7214019299,
0.7664144635,
-0.1186883599,
-0.0137935691,
0.2018823624,
-0.2964603901,
-0.7786210179,
-0.0553790294,
0.6001470089,
-0.3301973939,
-0.2330309898,
-0.7222373486,
-0.1219906881,
-0.3887925148,
0.7043477893,
0.0614661649,
-0.020996673,
-0.2998706996,
-0.0291428491,
-0.2917934358,
-0.8773850203,
-0.6368812919,
-0.712825954,
0.771107316,
0.0366213433,
0.927461803,
0.5394480824,
0.4768503606,
0.3987684846,
-0.3306729198,
0.1411152482,
-0.4631887674,
0.149721995,
-0.0597585738,
-0.636072576,
-0.3984594941,
-0.1223859787,
0.7289476395,
0.9275180101,
0.0045147329,
0.0269078705,
0.1038566902,
0.6255215406,
-0.2875212133,
0.5590948462,
-0.5938171148,
0.1398970932,
0.0219647698,
0.2301495969,
-0.2372685075,
-0.1876703948,
0.3033404648,
-0.7214544415,
-0.2948206961,
0.1619896293,
0.6624979973,
0.4027488828,
-0.832634747,
-0.0588571057,
-0.8445309997,
0.6345288754,
-0.6153117418,
0.5769004226,
0.3305955529,
0.5224294066,
-0.4070547819,
-0.7926242352,
-0.5762691498,
-0.4545087516,
0.0149572827,
-0.0344756953,
-0.0460793525,
0.244397819,
0.4998137653,
0.118755661,
-0.1607165635,
0.2827253342,
-0.3932947218,
-0.2275765687,
0.6609554887,
0.2153429389,
0.3820749521,
0.0248462614,
-0.269715488,
-0.0423732027,
-0.9854947329,
-0.2371810526,
0.3003919721,
0.0299426336,
-0.0331651568,
0.6367452145,
-0.2555847764,
0.9387395382,
-0.3118182123,
-0.1846006811,
0.0195191111,
0.0964639336,
-0.1971412897,
-0.1493248194,
0.6417523623,
0.0311968792,
0.6099950671,
-0.2989651561,
-0.1146579385,
0.0121573694,
0.3132243156,
-0.7223822474,
-0.1288279742,
-0.0688262507,
-0.3261529803,
-0.2497098893,
-0.1938196868,
-0.2856688201,
-0.8480709195,
-0.7210077047,
0.4619376361,
-0.5313639641,
-0.3030431569,
0.1322627664,
-0.1179280281,
0.240696609,
0.6692750454,
-0.7367219925,
0.13019602,
0.9404055476,
0.5469883084,
0.0760408416,
-0.4512778223,
0.1758177131,
0.5155277848,
-0.284774363,
0.5604504943,
-0.4585388899,
-0.1877634525,
-0.0477510132,
-0.1718292683,
0.0923095867,
-0.3307225704,
0.164732039,
-0.7583213449,
-0.0201885644,
-0.4814272523,
-0.7215594053,
-0.4180536568,
0.7044280171,
-0.6165537238,
0.591958046,
-0.0927496776,
-0.7065845132,
0.2349180877,
-0.9153148532,
-0.3646518886,
0.1318639666,
-0.1706776917,
0.2099583894,
0.0634283349,
0.0036256139,
0.4897094369,
-0.5326419473,
0.3119724691,
-0.3556853533,
0.0309971552,
0.3964202404,
-0.3227492571,
0.6332581043,
0.3752113879,
0.0778063834,
0.2386352867,
-0.5952965021,
-0.0991876274,
0.2971475422,
-0.3252676129,
-0.3821415305,
0.2262246162,
-0.1753448993,
0.4041442871,
0.4831299484,
-0.1976801753,
0.3179814816,
-0.3777806163,
0.7476079464,
0.8010125756,
-0.077215232,
0.4519521296,
-0.3556824028,
0.2875984311,
0.1500551701,
0.3311856985,
0.0633088201,
-0.4726923704,
-0.6933453083,
-0.0389900096,
0.2616811395,
0.3822886646,
-0.7322830558,
0.409324944,
-0.3585225642,
-0.6656002998,
0.0479701199,
0.2595644593,
0.0406171568,
0.208631143,
-0.0364379212,
-0.230723545,
-0.42838341,
-0.6969358325,
-0.2358252704,
-0.2208728194,
0.0043752142,
0.2669511735,
0.6054902077,
-0.2632091343,
0.9318299294,
-0.6281211376,
-0.102206409,
-0.3671417236,
-0.2644777596,
0.0047135418,
0.2447834462,
0.2225180417,
-1.023576498,
-0.2601264119,
0.1282517314,
-1.1128718853,
0.2527547479,
0.1968244016,
-0.1732798219,
-0.1643130332,
0.7151891589,
-1.0543513298,
-0.0309347641,
0.2822751105,
-0.3009297848,
0.5081583858,
-0.2717459202,
-0.1731528491,
-1.2800508738,
-0.1854159087,
-0.0274673477,
-0.0953673795,
-0.6448396444,
0.3441986442,
-0.1216280237,
-0.2193906307,
-0.481056571,
0.7557860017,
-0.4728550315,
-0.171556592,
-0.1781568378,
0.2301135212,
-0.1952446699,
0.4592504799,
0.0587518625,
0.2607847452,
0.486926496,
-0.539901793,
0.7445822358,
0.1860148758,
-0.5579022765,
0.3737255931,
-0.6552568674,
0.1731782407,
-0.2062346041,
0.4441151917,
-0.6363002658,
-0.3709277213,
0.1121608913,
-0.280743897,
0.3097268939,
-0.0936788172,
-0.9074002504,
-0.4831955135,
0.1571812183,
0.4539966881,
0.6607788801,
-0.3889510036,
0.6585039496,
0.5039544106,
-0.0493280366,
-0.5126265883,
-0.2796930373,
0.2934709787,
-0.3118951023,
-0.6790027022,
-0.0551853776,
0.0300749931,
-0.5248596668,
-0.0763460025,
0.0672673658,
-0.0479554981,
0.1766135246,
0.3456003964,
0.2074289471,
-0.2105466425,
0.4455805123,
-0.2874825299,
-0.0612779893,
0.2770769298,
-0.7249669433,
0.691403091,
-0.0941661,
-0.594337225,
-0.1127713397,
-0.0185831599,
0.7653220892,
-0.3111248016,
0.8925972581,
0.4065982401,
-0.573514998,
0.0531049706,
-0.635148108,
-0.2411014438,
-0.4473713338,
0.7109125257,
-0.2736337185,
-1.0501968861,
0.4949153662,
-0.4218181372,
0.0025866469,
0.3701227009,
0.6597720981,
-0.1413944811,
0.9773751497,
0.6697975397,
-0.4153476655,
0.5465969443,
-0.1394626945,
0.3157548904,
-0.7951765656,
-0.2371111661,
-0.4160110056,
-0.4640893638,
-0.469596982,
-0.3952937722,
0.4342333376,
0.0598090328,
-0.9186653495,
-0.014454213,
-0.153257221,
0.4773958325,
0.5410769582,
0.1418340504,
0.4485366642,
-0.0926368758,
0.062667653,
0.2471399307,
-0.8053467274,
-0.5398958325,
1.083954215,
0.5330666304,
0.9106580019,
-0.0191182103,
0.4934670627,
0.0932909995,
0.1541891545,
-0.7764952779,
0.6842390895,
0.1299250573,
-0.6411730051,
-0.4357143044,
-0.5535069108,
-0.822506249,
0.2061544359,
-0.3254438043,
-0.7798503637,
-0.25588727,
0.159762606,
-0.1447162032,
0.5471256375,
-0.6932585239,
0.7573401928,
-0.5064184666,
-0.0258933157,
-0.4314862192,
-0.7356839776,
0.4836955369,
-0.1086936817,
0.3073264956,
0.0197239313,
0.0106018018,
0.6745445132,
-0.188162595,
1.170623064,
-0.0919536799,
-0.3278247714,
0.2107489109,
0.037342716,
0.7455565333,
-0.2067031115,
0.2749350369,
0.251752764,
0.0133429747,
-0.3125863671,
-0.6770861149,
0.5041185021,
-1.2028040886,
-0.8033293486,
-0.2574408352,
-0.9904767871,
-0.4419327378,
0.2259564698,
0.0096200081,
0.2090516388,
-0.2832484543,
0.2249346077,
0.7065156698,
-0.3601459861,
0.0611710846,
0.2586391568,
-0.5240208507,
-0.1108051911,
0.843744278,
0.1807077825,
0.4810773432,
0.5297800899,
0.239820227,
-0.3146724105,
-0.4176888764,
-0.0333806761,
0.2318521589,
-0.9090723395,
-0.0112285484,
-0.7194010019,
-0.629717648,
-0.2567000985,
0.0605025776,
-0.2315934598,
-0.4895077646,
0.1565540582,
-0.1048573256,
0.49197492,
1.1139986515,
0.047072988,
0.4178735912,
-0.8490381837,
0.267729044,
0.5475094914,
0.1507066935,
0.3220714033,
-0.2781096399,
-0.4338599443,
0.269780755,
-0.3747215271,
-0.5761928558,
0.2254538834,
-0.2089075595,
0.6170601249,
0.4811851084,
-0.1020767018,
0.448369205,
-0.527222991,
0.6977171302,
0.2941587865,
-0.72945261,
0.2556706965,
-0.4671424925,
0.1655931026,
-0.0923587382,
0.4286278486,
-0.8118981123,
-0.3609351516,
-0.6428107619,
-0.7426205277,
0.4110152721,
0.0259406157,
0.2861627638,
0.2119660228,
0.3952146769,
-0.1859046817,
0.4883975089,
-0.8786026835,
0.0210776702,
-0.0899638683,
-0.2331902534,
-0.2255620807,
-0.2502713501,
-0.3058668971,
-0.3056567907,
0.5809644461,
-0.0366842374,
0.159819603,
-0.240859136,
-0.2251799405,
0.0204297155,
0.3435915112,
0.4333226681,
0.7551410198,
0.171308279,
0.2243694663,
0.3287730515,
-0.375261575,
0.0826313719,
-0.1130021587,
-0.0603383631,
-0.7089725137,
0.5088011622,
0.7982463241,
0.2092668563,
-0.5526711941,
0.114110738,
0.2678633928,
-0.150498867,
-0.4094142616,
0.1709035635,
0.4587581158,
0.6322126985,
0.2264691442,
-0.0836477652,
-0.3447733521,
-0.6953679323,
-0.2865310013,
0.5374222398,
-0.2444607913,
-0.2901760936,
0.5327342153,
0.0409141704,
-0.1879053861,
0.7923176289,
0.0785776228,
-0.8323196173,
0.6408131719,
0.5315020084,
0.4784429073,
-0.038591288,
-0.0158054903,
0.0520865247,
0.4249376953,
-0.2089245766,
-0.0259689596,
-0.0094764214,
-1.14377141,
-0.4410595894,
-0.6829756498,
-0.4132424295,
0.1172493994,
-0.1688699275,
0.1649623215,
-0.5065481663,
-0.0338212959,
-0.1854738444,
0.0768021196,
-0.7397201657,
0.1301163882,
0.3103856444,
0.9699507356,
-0.7164191604,
0.9922234416,
0.7697477937,
-0.3623800576,
-1.0539369583,
-0.1695308685,
-0.1166956872,
-1.0701520443,
0.9290302992,
-0.0725158006,
0.3044611812,
0.0293515828,
-0.6510080099,
-0.9108638763,
1.1079874039,
0.502179563,
-0.6118988395,
-0.4210273623,
0.395694524,
0.5870875716,
-0.2297239751,
-0.0224026348,
0.4716849029,
0.7365928888,
0.2972565293,
-0.9076313972,
0.0434301272,
-0.0201991741,
0.0143024381,
0.4310805202,
-0.7622207403,
0.8128905296,
-0.257032454,
0.2615805268,
-0.0752169117,
0.6019860506,
0.2089132667,
0.0224938896,
0.5368354321,
0.5964739919,
0.7358891964,
0.0285618678,
0.9836895466,
-0.3870046139,
0.1649946719,
0.873890698,
-0.3566514254,
0.635774672,
0.3848157525,
-0.2413128018,
0.2159274071,
0.6552264094,
0.0056415256,
0.2444241792,
0.4002561569,
-0.2403672785,
-0.501534462,
0.0083074067,
-0.5396379232,
0.6534891725,
0.5298040509,
-0.2365648448,
-0.2356510758,
-0.0605555698,
-0.0220613293,
-0.2445073277,
-0.4741167724,
0.854624629,
0.4475004375,
-0.4837709665,
0.3003856838,
-0.1301466972,
0.3516924083,
-0.8381012082,
-0.0179249514,
0.0789547786,
0.1837940365,
-0.0724969059,
-0.6983795166,
0.1950127482,
-0.2427400202,
-0.103899017,
-0.1403916925,
0.9869622588,
-0.271458149,
-0.5300015211,
0.2307503521,
0.8024704456,
0.0857908502,
-0.3355774581,
-0.5548275113,
-0.0987176374,
-0.2448974848,
-0.3106438518,
0.6791825891,
0.819447577,
-0.282835871,
0.8978140354,
0.6519128084,
0.1479468346,
-0.0353014879,
0.0411544293,
0.9157714844,
-0.8966730237,
-0.5604453683,
-0.9312683344,
0.1515153497,
-0.02042781,
0.1222064197,
0.6119503975,
0.2606598437,
0.6096429825,
-0.026683921,
0.908665359,
-0.0838857666,
0.1072072536,
-0.5020389557,
1.188452363,
-0.4558444917,
0.1275614351,
-0.2287644297,
-0.9639303088,
-0.2182327658,
0.5192499757,
-0.5645172596,
0.2459248602,
0.4838845432,
0.4317373931,
0.0627158061,
0.0918595269,
0.617536664,
0.6341395378,
0.3882342279,
0.7349988222,
1.3693578243,
0.0571967401,
0.4278389513,
0.0444340259,
-0.0001455843,
0.0473595485,
-0.8657557368,
-1.0100011826,
-0.7226051092,
0.036522314,
-0.1619032323,
-0.098774381,
0.979321897,
0.7042767406,
-0.3009661734,
-0.3348338902,
-0.0402926914,
0.3412791789,
0.0923361257,
-0.1380607337,
0.266435653,
-0.3286749721,
-0.4046178758,
0.1218790561,
0.179580614,
0.1879648864,
-0.4391381145,
-0.1300989985,
0.0922741517,
-0.1085336059,
1.0056126118,
0.2596317828,
-0.5480657816,
-0.5188395977,
-0.1207223237,
0.0834102184,
-0.1315449923,
0.8025516272,
-0.7672145963,
-0.007321463,
0.2362817824,
0.6473359466,
0.4795462787,
-0.4340418279,
0.7252026796,
-0.4860770404,
0.3572649956,
0.0919919387,
0.5974826813,
0.3483119607,
-0.3592728674,
0.4387971461,
0.2123314142,
-0.5545369983,
-0.7457302213,
0.5442809463,
-0.8281753063,
-0.3253315985,
1.1626883745,
0.0205026455,
-0.234932974,
-0.0236831531,
-0.2455614954,
0.3776216507,
-0.0735897198,
0.8873858452,
0.8570820689,
-0.1063916236,
-0.2075029463,
-0.7981040478,
0.3948839307,
0.0828908607,
-0.9872148633,
0.1357896924,
0.6024090052,
0.2962949872,
0.2122810334,
0.3229153752,
-0.0296746958,
-0.0655606911,
-0.1270445883,
0.1121653169,
-0.2354339957,
-0.3639353216,
0.0340659097,
0.268342346,
0.4811303318,
0.172065556
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03759v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03759v1
|
How should the advent of large language models affect the practice of science?
| 2023-12-05T10:45:12 | 2023-12-05T10:45:12 |
Marcel Binz, Stephan Alaniz, Adina Roskies, Balazs Aczel, Carl T. Bergstrom, Colin Allen, Daniel Schad, Dirk Wulff, Jevin D. West, Qiong Zhang, Richard M. Shiffrin, Samuel J. Gershman, Ven Popov, Emily M. Bender, Marco Marelli, Matthew M. Botvinick, Zeynep Akata, Eric Schulz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY, cs.DL
|
Large language models (LLMs) are being increasingly incorporated into
scientific workflows. However, we have yet to fully grasp the implications of
this integration. How should the advent of large language models affect the
practice of science? For this opinion piece, we have invited four diverse
groups of scientists to reflect on this query, sharing their perspectives and
engaging in debate. Schulz et al. make the argument that working with LLMs is
not fundamentally different from working with human collaborators, while Bender
et al. argue that LLMs are often misused and over-hyped, and that their
limitations warrant a focus on more specialized, easily interpretable tools.
Marelli et al. emphasize the importance of transparent attribution and
responsible use of LLMs. Finally, Botvinick and Gershman advocate that humans
should retain responsibility for determining the scientific roadmap. To
facilitate the discussion, the four perspectives are complemented with a
response from each group. By putting these different perspectives in
conversation, we aim to bring attention to important considerations within the
academic community regarding the adoption of LLMs and their impact on both
current and future scientific practices.
|
[
-0.1039650366,
-0.1593996435,
1.0817272663,
0.2754279971,
-0.219994396,
0.2147978246,
-0.3016347885,
-0.9876596332,
0.1481509805,
0.6955451369,
0.0099115307,
-0.0455168672,
-1.0255128145,
0.4392166436,
-0.3601563573,
0.6896400452,
-0.2381913066,
0.3744296134,
-0.5770961642,
0.0323188007,
-0.1463239044,
-0.5590415597,
-0.2558126748,
-0.6801585555,
0.9954187274,
0.1561440825,
0.7877030373,
0.6834406853,
0.5449550152,
0.399602741,
-0.4618098438,
-0.132163316,
-0.3662356138,
0.3124358058,
-0.392721504,
-0.7486693263,
-0.285946101,
0.1760856062,
0.7543802261,
1.1820694208,
-0.065465793,
0.2053758949,
0.0770437121,
0.3549387455,
-0.289458245,
0.0416187011,
-0.2350841612,
0.1410789341,
-0.3111947477,
0.0341325067,
-0.3335992992,
-0.1148238182,
0.3758530915,
-0.2460415214,
-0.0321503989,
0.1804006845,
0.2903757989,
0.1041343361,
-0.4003051519,
-0.1832032055,
-0.8317933679,
0.9071434736,
-0.8455640078,
0.2759052217,
-0.0288417507,
0.1756816208,
-0.610117197,
-0.744797051,
-0.4148604274,
-0.1077018678,
0.1396795362,
-0.0997103825,
0.0253943726,
-0.0312663577,
0.3688775301,
0.1315656304,
-0.1958574057,
0.524887383,
-0.8905397654,
0.0650555566,
0.450568229,
0.2637169957,
0.0154257324,
-0.0192260258,
0.054554034,
0.3926533759,
-1.0005425215,
-0.2335306853,
0.2105562687,
0.3435065448,
0.0946914405,
0.7109188437,
0.11182338,
0.6041216254,
-0.4017164707,
0.1689939946,
0.1493562758,
-0.2213220745,
-0.1718724966,
0.0323812403,
0.9327224493,
0.1705623567,
0.3719008863,
-0.0505688563,
0.1423898041,
-0.0546970144,
0.2775816917,
-0.7779143453,
0.211233288,
0.0474388152,
-0.1353866458,
-0.2310492843,
0.0469058007,
-0.6762004495,
-0.6888111234,
-0.3239787817,
-0.1781560332,
0.1957446635,
-0.203748256,
0.1840621382,
-0.0778146386,
-0.0015551513,
0.7699459195,
-0.7793236971,
0.1429176182,
1.0244281292,
0.838974297,
-0.099271372,
-0.3174466789,
-0.234584257,
0.3661762774,
-0.5073276162,
0.5929769278,
-0.6441920996,
-0.7917077541,
-0.1097242013,
0.1016912609,
0.2237452269,
-0.548768878,
0.114794001,
-0.2353389561,
0.1113135889,
-0.643576324,
-0.5490502119,
-0.0979348794,
-0.1305594295,
-0.4557153583,
0.3005124032,
-0.2907579541,
-0.5044933558,
0.3704289496,
-0.820745647,
-0.3502273858,
0.4402994812,
-0.3545725048,
0.1041367799,
0.4008063078,
-0.2924388945,
0.3697963059,
-0.3522810042,
0.3319857419,
-0.6810740829,
-0.1508692354,
0.6084635258,
-0.2044456005,
0.6206588149,
0.4186120927,
-0.1159990281,
-0.024527289,
-0.2552062273,
0.0052901558,
-0.2027544081,
-0.2067756504,
-0.1263209879,
0.3901306987,
0.0125411265,
0.2971002162,
-0.0168370884,
-0.6291914582,
0.2694212794,
-0.5230122209,
0.8400648236,
0.857766211,
-0.0875677764,
0.6508171558,
-0.1546916515,
0.5752475858,
-0.2780660093,
0.3049032986,
-0.0550118312,
-0.5968767405,
-0.168433696,
-0.1393226236,
0.2550852895,
0.0285419356,
-0.0783674046,
0.0283583831,
-0.1308564693,
-0.7130664587,
-0.4529514611,
0.3268456161,
0.1193524525,
0.1940222085,
0.0493238941,
-0.209310025,
-0.460713625,
-0.8231242895,
-0.3434845209,
-0.2144026905,
-0.0595071986,
0.4038436413,
0.7722118497,
-0.2068879604,
0.8906788826,
-0.4107542038,
0.1122595444,
-0.2401272655,
0.1295633018,
0.1686515659,
0.3812217414,
0.2981556952,
-0.6223548055,
-0.4220654666,
-0.1610026807,
-0.8692030311,
-0.0860545263,
0.4719741642,
0.1345091611,
0.3611428738,
0.4361201525,
-1.0053377151,
-0.0242597759,
0.729524076,
-0.3575419188,
0.480270505,
-0.0427453965,
0.029418163,
-0.9013981819,
0.0002341975,
0.0911243334,
-0.0086663524,
-0.6270827651,
0.0832418203,
-0.1660740376,
0.2644847035,
-0.7113779783,
0.6108934879,
-0.563852191,
-0.2550748587,
-0.4707914293,
0.0523241796,
0.0097458065,
-0.5492354631,
0.2094228268,
0.5774928331,
0.6196983457,
-0.4992933273,
0.2773453593,
0.0602763891,
-0.5048635006,
0.2195371687,
-0.7907371521,
0.0830595195,
-0.1747348458,
0.6855093241,
-0.4329922795,
-0.3854768574,
0.3279085457,
-0.3401916623,
0.2513043582,
0.0098175863,
-0.7563861609,
-0.5627093315,
-0.127562657,
0.2091024369,
0.4516062438,
-0.2424600869,
0.4626014531,
0.45337677,
-0.2606401443,
-0.4867061079,
-0.7107642889,
0.3980382681,
-0.224867329,
-0.800868392,
0.0789239407,
-0.0639586821,
-0.8310634494,
-0.0353393592,
-0.2382457554,
0.1073533967,
0.1258437485,
0.3872145116,
0.1589580625,
-0.0878791586,
0.2172547579,
-0.4141945243,
0.2036040127,
0.2179747075,
-0.0492075831,
0.3827940822,
-0.1804051101,
-0.2384102196,
-0.0617018938,
0.4979765117,
0.894821465,
-0.0398945212,
0.7179183364,
0.0348191783,
-0.088918075,
0.1787029952,
-0.5188564062,
-0.3036353886,
-0.4966508746,
0.4259443879,
0.2297818363,
-1.1081123352,
0.2459430397,
-0.0169315767,
0.1228799373,
0.2424748689,
0.6531275511,
-0.7075909972,
0.8171668649,
0.7849080563,
0.0645711944,
0.3659724891,
-0.0192150883,
0.3616716564,
-0.8936145902,
-0.2287165821,
-0.6877599359,
0.0177082438,
-0.487041086,
-0.5034413934,
0.2631525397,
-0.1806232631,
-0.0316059776,
-0.0626261532,
-0.2614448369,
0.1935638487,
-0.0450642146,
-0.2139568925,
0.1955640912,
-0.3352908194,
0.5334857106,
-0.0344015099,
-0.6046419144,
-0.8496944904,
0.9935219288,
0.5206284523,
1.0315783024,
-0.0623554587,
0.5837154388,
0.0492877662,
0.5918004513,
-0.7888871431,
0.6263235211,
0.1705203652,
-0.7944490314,
-0.3525082171,
-0.2495514005,
-0.9972221255,
0.5655668378,
0.0782396123,
-0.7342381477,
0.0995399728,
-0.0211625732,
-0.1965433359,
0.310642451,
-0.4505681098,
0.6001060009,
-0.3005108833,
-0.3969061971,
-0.3030142188,
-0.6473006606,
0.36325562,
-0.1732218266,
0.6531515718,
-0.2791817784,
-0.0660634041,
0.9725629687,
-0.4343424439,
1.0936287642,
-0.0559911132,
-0.4535998106,
0.5538591146,
-0.2739215195,
0.3944014609,
-0.1055724546,
-0.0114799757,
0.3234349191,
0.2147297412,
-0.2791992724,
-0.294005543,
0.699403882,
-0.6356145144,
-1.1872047186,
-0.7187488675,
-0.6294322014,
-0.1982916594,
-0.0233512819,
-0.0494613498,
-0.0021946079,
-0.0816787854,
0.204602316,
0.4849717617,
0.0762316808,
0.4003942907,
0.6537791491,
-0.3579932749,
0.0175466686,
0.5930963755,
0.4199174345,
0.678362906,
-0.1586065888,
0.3286958635,
-0.1809958071,
-0.5718188286,
-0.1366179287,
0.7544463277,
-0.779769361,
0.1685885489,
-0.8550226092,
0.0263502263,
-0.4386771023,
-0.2059682608,
-0.4389365613,
-0.1502060443,
-0.6504748464,
0.0371833593,
0.3621092141,
0.9045081735,
0.0860272795,
0.1248065829,
-0.8624374866,
-0.239784956,
0.0205325801,
0.0962230638,
-0.2373606712,
-0.5468541384,
-0.2413858622,
0.0297672991,
-0.042980995,
-0.6169074178,
0.1698058397,
-0.1489958316,
0.5868880153,
0.239264667,
-0.3809963465,
0.4489108026,
-0.6408904791,
0.877730906,
0.3475981653,
-0.7206050158,
0.1712254137,
-0.33560583,
0.3080584407,
0.2077472061,
0.6168484092,
-0.8833508492,
-0.6571156979,
-0.3816161752,
-0.6096717715,
0.4783166647,
-0.3473962247,
0.267999649,
0.2592335343,
0.1024775505,
0.087536186,
0.4889657199,
-0.6638843417,
0.2110516131,
0.1135864556,
0.0962400362,
-0.2713273466,
-0.2007068545,
-0.2136120796,
-0.3473175168,
0.1419925094,
0.0368263386,
0.0169990826,
0.0091749756,
0.0782748088,
-0.5385844707,
0.478582412,
0.4318441749,
1.0578609705,
0.1398738921,
0.1594751626,
-0.057968501,
-0.4610976875,
0.0554939695,
-0.3334318995,
-0.26115188,
-0.1032454893,
0.4740801454,
0.357483834,
0.11445494,
-0.7324498892,
0.2103015333,
0.4700892568,
-0.3781597018,
-0.079553172,
0.1464166343,
0.4384240508,
0.4962386191,
0.2268669307,
0.2286646515,
-0.0210767277,
-0.9213970304,
-0.2624232173,
0.5492447615,
-0.1916229725,
-0.4407907724,
0.3435187042,
0.0909298137,
-0.3474059999,
0.2360713482,
0.3342587948,
-0.5627334118,
0.5945676565,
0.434889853,
0.5609394908,
-0.4740536809,
0.1267772168,
-0.153562203,
0.4241891503,
-0.3921095431,
0.1600384116,
0.3802855313,
-0.5956688523,
-0.8191136718,
-0.5553503036,
-0.7309387326,
-0.0788516775,
-0.0838904381,
0.3008828759,
-0.3324207366,
-0.2056786567,
0.2871549428,
-0.2229730189,
-0.3643345535,
-0.2547468245,
0.3201218247,
0.8748589754,
-0.7409688234,
0.7987841964,
0.6742146015,
-0.2044663578,
-0.4215839505,
-0.2861349881,
0.1981644779,
-0.320633918,
0.8270190358,
-0.0065576541,
-0.166264236,
-0.2363071591,
-0.8682156801,
-1.2093224525,
0.7999968529,
0.1799212992,
-0.6581296325,
0.1744269878,
-0.0001159776,
0.880071938,
-0.4605139494,
0.0151086869,
0.241423279,
0.7945426106,
0.2647645473,
-1.0805145502,
-0.0020004902,
0.1075693071,
-0.2147293985,
0.1554462314,
-0.7125122547,
0.9134635329,
-0.4635338485,
-0.1494116485,
-0.1243865192,
0.5621053576,
0.1257427037,
0.2222835273,
0.1938005835,
-0.1499113739,
0.5362383127,
0.248658523,
1.0159986019,
0.1378782988,
-0.0562804677,
0.7187401652,
-0.9259204865,
0.719094336,
1.0614939928,
-0.5533488989,
0.2162719965,
0.589024961,
-0.316886425,
0.36013484,
0.6387595534,
-0.3352561593,
-0.0692839026,
-0.3079793155,
-0.3791085482,
0.4287588,
0.5695280433,
-0.3592838347,
-0.0771837085,
-0.0254860148,
0.2285617739,
0.0351368301,
-0.2283805162,
0.2579409182,
0.4078027606,
-0.7351719141,
0.1685004234,
0.0253628753,
0.4735769033,
-0.5475388169,
0.0798778608,
0.1948350072,
-0.145370245,
-0.4135992527,
-0.9684172869,
0.1906620413,
0.1205177307,
-0.0809995532,
-0.252420336,
0.4146042764,
-0.2755372226,
-0.3510112166,
0.1408346444,
0.6834457517,
0.3814350069,
0.0477390289,
-0.2400211543,
0.3312979043,
-0.2403865606,
-0.4546812177,
0.465854466,
0.191712901,
-0.1468137652,
0.751737237,
0.6618442535,
0.347174257,
0.0448619463,
-0.0347513743,
0.8516118526,
-0.6846806407,
-0.0394770801,
-0.9294218421,
0.2324803025,
-0.0415579565,
-0.0292694811,
0.8303430676,
0.367210865,
0.4002353847,
0.0796958506,
0.9043287635,
-0.013666016,
0.3357473016,
-0.2173176259,
0.7025011182,
-0.4471679628,
0.3730666339,
-0.3695707321,
-0.8010087013,
-0.3330878019,
0.3462132812,
-0.4393762052,
0.2625028789,
0.7887706161,
0.3597212732,
0.33226794,
0.2480953038,
0.1339646876,
0.416875869,
0.642488122,
0.2035693973,
1.1640466452,
0.2343508303,
0.1600976735,
0.0654731765,
-0.1882156134,
-0.3094075322,
-1.1154452562,
-0.6826195121,
-0.1939351261,
-0.3188554347,
-0.0163370539,
-0.268851459,
1.0076220036,
0.2931474149,
-0.5055598617,
-0.4454779923,
-0.0102602709,
0.2312850356,
0.1269475669,
-0.1806764007,
0.0167765208,
-0.197953999,
-0.7605445981,
0.4306920469,
0.4949894547,
0.1114131585,
-0.663585484,
-0.1382744014,
-0.0903991386,
0.1546403915,
0.6862957478,
0.4674470127,
-0.9231211543,
-0.38827613,
0.1219961941,
-0.3137713671,
-0.0440950245,
0.82377702,
-0.4069105089,
0.2880208194,
0.1514039189,
0.3380850255,
0.490822494,
-0.5617935061,
0.8026899695,
0.1269159764,
-0.0763582885,
0.499222517,
0.4336568117,
0.3597144485,
-0.2000650913,
0.5513283014,
0.3203164041,
-0.6951107383,
-1.3224489689,
0.168277666,
-0.7015346885,
-0.4871737957,
1.195691824,
0.0916849226,
-0.4365030527,
-0.1770912707,
0.0955576673,
-0.1733371168,
-0.2373982221,
0.6278585196,
0.8836500645,
-0.2729932964,
-0.185867995,
-0.8210180998,
0.2679234445,
0.3266679943,
-0.5676179528,
0.2031631619,
0.4545257092,
0.3498171866,
0.1291465163,
0.6019477248,
-0.279127866,
-0.0392095,
-0.2453994155,
0.2152944952,
-0.0228429567,
-0.2633118927,
-0.290799588,
-0.0829914585,
0.3412435055,
0.5075542927
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02614v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02614v3
|
Prompt Optimization via Adversarial In-Context Learning
| 2023-12-05T09:44:45 | 2024-06-22T15:19:11 |
Xuan Long Do, Yiran Zhao, Hannah Brown, Yuxi Xie, James Xu Zhao, Nancy F. Chen, Kenji Kawaguchi, Michael Shieh, Junxian He
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
We propose a new method, Adversarial In-Context Learning (adv-ICL), to
optimize prompt for in-context learning (ICL) by employing one LLM as a
generator, another as a discriminator, and a third as a prompt modifier. As in
traditional adversarial learning, adv-ICL is implemented as a two-player game
between the generator and discriminator, where the generator tries to generate
realistic enough output to fool the discriminator. In each round, given an
input prefixed by task instructions and several exemplars, the generator
produces an output. The discriminator is then tasked with classifying the
generator input-output pair as model-generated or real data. Based on the
discriminator loss, the prompt modifier proposes possible edits to the
generator and discriminator prompts, and the edits that most improve the
adversarial loss are selected. We show that adv-ICL results in significant
improvements over state-of-the-art prompt optimization techniques for both open
and closed-source models on 11 generation and classification tasks including
summarization, arithmetic reasoning, machine translation, data-to-text
generation, and the MMLU and big-bench hard benchmarks. In addition, because
our method uses pre-trained models and updates only prompts rather than model
parameters, it is computationally efficient, easy to extend to any LLM and
task, and effective in low-resource settings.
|
[
-0.5034180284,
-0.8873768449,
0.5490330458,
0.0275655743,
-0.2242383361,
-0.0566188097,
-0.2608547807,
-0.0470216461,
-0.6068959832,
0.1872274727,
-0.8292409778,
-0.3967288435,
-0.3245817721,
0.1891633868,
0.03327737,
1.1772645712,
0.0598201752,
0.4217306674,
-0.4675411284,
-0.0441406108,
-0.6581839323,
-0.4473190904,
-1.0182807446,
-0.1947969794,
0.4553118944,
0.4551613033,
0.3212765455,
0.6112828851,
0.1155467778,
0.2611748278,
-0.289806366,
0.5377892852,
-0.5874398351,
0.287827611,
0.0343753994,
-0.4293939173,
0.1243624017,
0.1688681245,
0.5861675739,
0.4884769917,
0.103079617,
0.1012530401,
0.2846413255,
0.5173252225,
-0.8424515128,
0.0288505908,
-0.7117156982,
0.0673856363,
-0.0148636354,
-0.4631212056,
-0.7418686152,
-0.5255586505,
0.138279289,
-0.7610146999,
0.280121088,
0.1087299064,
0.5793249607,
0.5482017398,
-0.5085532069,
-0.537665844,
-0.5239957571,
0.661585331,
-0.386387229,
0.0578810945,
-0.0682958141,
0.4165653288,
-0.3495708704,
-0.4886510968,
-0.4327522516,
-0.5405546427,
0.0251996312,
0.3425017893,
-0.3114564121,
0.1771548241,
0.4868322313,
-0.0350819975,
-0.4614904523,
0.3240784705,
-0.092457056,
-0.0923314914,
0.4565675557,
0.27822721,
0.270381093,
0.2226222306,
-0.745256424,
-0.2121688873,
-1.030479908,
0.552937746,
0.4059979916,
0.4389385283,
0.189590469,
0.1655205339,
0.1554790139,
0.7688494921,
0.4339894056,
-0.0477892868,
-0.184985742,
-0.220105812,
0.150096029,
0.4080007076,
0.6792405844,
0.408585161,
-0.2508406043,
-0.0950774997,
-0.3866265416,
0.0174545068,
0.0935066342,
-0.8221473098,
-0.1059536263,
-0.1324875355,
-0.3129504025,
-0.4939804971,
-0.1372514963,
-0.4552253783,
-0.5936985612,
-0.4223616719,
0.6040109396,
-0.5019514561,
0.4081555605,
-0.3872409165,
-0.1519747078,
0.0792585984,
0.5858826637,
-0.5921438932,
0.1743161529,
0.4685682654,
0.8640655875,
-0.1105509847,
-0.1513499916,
-1.2231707573,
-0.0282455292,
-0.4240366518,
0.6278079748,
-0.2598096728,
-0.5532177687,
-0.1287790686,
-0.3857119083,
-0.0490359478,
-0.4377308488,
0.2868692279,
-0.6673164964,
0.5510094762,
-0.4074901044,
-0.5645542741,
-0.32280913,
0.3258647323,
-0.6144063473,
0.8019180298,
-0.0008906795,
-0.6688079238,
0.5166062713,
-0.8691046238,
-0.3824689686,
0.2880935073,
-0.0964280441,
-0.4293674827,
0.0297729354,
0.4739209414,
0.3551813364,
-0.5229713321,
0.2424079329,
-0.1504119039,
-0.6281856894,
0.2350035757,
-0.5886634588,
1.1163719893,
0.3416220248,
-0.4221761227,
0.3270633817,
-0.4800361395,
-0.3044780195,
0.0117619336,
-0.5240251422,
-0.3247520924,
0.1053143963,
-0.1852348298,
0.1571014673,
0.1906711906,
-0.502096653,
0.3628248274,
-0.5633725524,
0.2331946045,
0.9237152934,
0.1626686454,
0.5068469644,
-0.2302905023,
0.6795288324,
0.0495527759,
0.2917489707,
-0.4698355496,
-0.1984611154,
-0.350544095,
-0.3343969882,
0.0976980925,
0.5996142626,
-1.1291946173,
0.2734286785,
0.2292437106,
-0.3132080138,
-0.4534822106,
-0.0942403227,
0.6399552822,
1.1055004597,
0.3933934569,
0.1770314425,
-0.3451652229,
-0.5538925529,
-0.2797012329,
-0.3281220198,
0.1413322687,
0.5321558118,
0.2541474402,
0.1378363669,
0.8581508994,
-0.4712942243,
-0.0802311003,
-0.4031419158,
0.1313499361,
0.0518913753,
0.3635703325,
0.665758431,
-0.9676297903,
-0.7047476172,
-0.1875955611,
-0.7006148696,
-0.2465596646,
-0.3293886483,
0.1039422452,
0.0462546945,
0.5951805711,
-0.455390662,
0.3016142249,
-0.0351489224,
-0.3443567753,
0.653907299,
-0.3144764602,
0.0738232732,
-1.0297228098,
-0.0409055576,
-0.0617951825,
-0.1673534364,
-0.6966069341,
0.1923812777,
0.2361540645,
-0.480327934,
-0.7257794738,
0.6717665195,
-0.3476549685,
0.2491281331,
-0.1964011788,
0.2012687474,
0.0696015805,
0.5313214064,
-0.3203936815,
1.1898936033,
0.6387025714,
-0.8514097929,
0.5364997983,
0.1889598966,
-0.1239922643,
0.6405550241,
-0.5764024258,
0.0922433063,
-0.5342001319,
0.4776428938,
-1.00735569,
0.0552835353,
0.3366020918,
-0.4983765781,
0.3493476212,
-0.0187932998,
-0.3522675931,
-0.1870164126,
-0.5081649423,
0.4386764765,
0.4383989573,
-1.1071043015,
0.2954725623,
-0.0333461687,
0.1922238022,
-0.6264805794,
-0.2944083512,
-0.0185457636,
-0.6216964126,
-0.4287181795,
0.5011095405,
-0.4763691425,
-0.1764301658,
-0.1353928596,
0.3208903968,
0.2318252027,
0.5121421218,
-0.0545487218,
0.3610593081,
-0.1078738794,
0.1194482297,
-0.0484911986,
-0.0882363021,
0.0853377655,
-0.4165292084,
0.2297722548,
-0.0749532059,
-0.1839666069,
-0.5048979521,
0.5032939911,
0.3144795597,
-0.2221580297,
0.5791134238,
0.54855901,
-0.2228591591,
-0.5778298378,
-0.1703985035,
-0.1947207749,
-0.5027545691,
0.3704823554,
-0.3772463799,
-0.5531291366,
0.3960641026,
-0.1882671118,
0.0768627077,
0.2529182434,
0.3822576404,
0.0733210221,
1.5716471672,
0.409119457,
0.0501102619,
0.6271882057,
-0.3638976812,
-0.0634660646,
-0.8773936629,
-0.2290349454,
-0.3925724626,
-0.2900335789,
-0.1818643361,
0.1149557605,
0.7419067025,
0.1932323575,
-0.4455028474,
0.1685808897,
-0.615840137,
0.5849538445,
1.0355665684,
0.3797643483,
-0.1449200213,
-0.3087489605,
-0.1190195531,
-0.0887780413,
-0.8461167812,
-0.2896748185,
0.9056850672,
0.0203026235,
0.6231590509,
0.0109599456,
0.6701737046,
0.4159193039,
0.2094477266,
-0.8581469655,
0.5805320144,
-0.1919112206,
-0.2305740565,
-0.1088956892,
-0.5485877991,
-0.753556788,
0.2286757976,
-0.0282155909,
-0.5594930649,
0.150557518,
0.4267884195,
-0.7148546576,
0.3029117882,
-0.7226775289,
1.0149769783,
-0.1583244205,
-0.0793239474,
0.039442718,
-0.7101166248,
0.4108455181,
0.1184141859,
-0.1761084497,
0.2555133104,
-0.1891049147,
0.5169321895,
-0.4738796353,
0.6209357977,
-0.5992035866,
0.0926546007,
0.4573919177,
0.0820061788,
0.8954145908,
0.1821252555,
-0.1098371446,
-0.4106335044,
-0.4615368247,
-0.0913460255,
-0.7986149788,
0.5958464146,
-0.7747520208,
-0.6513132453,
-0.3594183624,
-0.4803574085,
-0.0643758923,
0.0085806167,
0.7303283811,
0.9746585488,
-0.3305788338,
0.1957585663,
0.9034292698,
-0.3596126139,
0.6528124213,
0.5093047619,
0.5347549319,
-0.4059320986,
0.9182860851,
-0.1262439191,
0.2017806768,
0.4706226885,
0.4114255607,
-0.3909416497,
-0.6042712331,
-0.7128864527,
-0.2065894753,
-0.9245430231,
-0.5474755764,
-0.3996654153,
-0.0404979624,
-0.1969301254,
-0.5156140924,
-0.0039711879,
-0.0630794838,
-0.7731716037,
0.2293221802,
0.1781378686,
0.4550945759,
0.0388708748,
0.5672758818,
-0.4918682873,
0.128177166,
0.3790562451,
-0.3383747041,
-0.0579955801,
-0.6004548073,
-0.1811917424,
0.0529941693,
-0.547506988,
-0.9267278314,
0.2113613039,
0.33682549,
0.5005002618,
0.5710868239,
0.4560291767,
0.5626871586,
-0.5308071971,
0.8895514011,
0.2659449279,
-0.8388502598,
0.6558052301,
-0.1956528872,
0.4949243367,
0.5808246136,
0.2720698118,
-0.3979298174,
-0.2157513946,
-0.3569253981,
-0.6060751677,
1.2101155519,
-0.1356853843,
-0.0874958709,
-0.1306407303,
0.2912720442,
0.1659782976,
0.2014414221,
-0.4211921096,
-0.3764235377,
-0.1047510952,
-0.3196309507,
0.037217848,
-0.2230727524,
-0.2037684768,
0.0579649359,
0.8154965639,
-0.3026223779,
0.0378300212,
0.1481352448,
-0.1630244255,
-0.092054449,
0.0025977765,
0.573035419,
0.4160363972,
-0.0070870072,
0.1058334634,
0.4028195143,
-0.2570334971,
0.354472369,
0.3716498911,
-0.7308530211,
-0.1785837561,
0.3274871111,
1.055939436,
0.0798860267,
-0.6544222832,
0.8827569485,
-0.364192158,
-0.0258841347,
-0.2127334625,
0.1617479622,
-0.5676441193,
0.5077784061,
0.4910176694,
0.4479063153,
0.4098060429,
-0.2484252304,
0.1908194572,
0.6674414277,
-0.4880444109,
-0.3029149771,
1.1021541357,
0.1221040338,
-0.4246641695,
0.4079517424,
-0.5898374915,
-0.7024365664,
0.6600007415,
0.7480014563,
1.1200146675,
-0.2777864337,
0.3065661192,
0.3504133224,
0.0170145687,
0.0794135556,
-0.0250672791,
-0.1671891212,
-0.3600248992,
-0.2145856172,
-0.1708665341,
-0.3599557877,
0.1889691353,
-0.5114533901,
0.5579763055,
-0.4361185133,
0.1076185331,
-0.0397600457,
0.1861102879,
-0.698562324,
0.1344066411,
0.1076174155,
0.6918300986,
-0.5415563583,
0.463534683,
0.7848688364,
-0.2477850318,
-0.4418977201,
-0.0156927276,
0.1589580774,
-0.6562901139,
0.8056958318,
0.4021264613,
-0.1620254964,
0.1543993503,
-0.7286437154,
-0.6384508014,
1.125852704,
0.5748865604,
-0.2574690282,
-0.1473821402,
-0.4865198135,
0.1650166214,
-0.5315073133,
0.2893593013,
0.0523644909,
0.1372607946,
0.0609967075,
-0.3802586794,
0.2394303977,
-0.1517376304,
0.2372735739,
0.1433529109,
-0.7040216923,
1.0308642387,
-0.3006106615,
-0.4610689878,
-0.0340819247,
0.7897211313,
0.2649402022,
0.3530935347,
0.7306028605,
0.2268746644,
0.7309571505,
-0.036091499,
1.0048798323,
-0.3547438085,
0.0205875468,
0.9291529059,
-0.0017924011,
0.1973545551,
0.3071315289,
0.1006177962,
0.1273332685,
0.8915964961,
0.0698702559,
0.8695511222,
0.1742854118,
-0.7118977904,
-0.1049616337,
-0.4479504824,
-0.161675185,
0.2242432982,
0.272678107,
-0.1540021002,
-0.398778379,
0.4825617373,
0.1306200624,
0.272367537,
-0.3178847432,
1.0019999743,
-0.2172991633,
-0.8848958015,
0.6730660796,
0.0058623804,
0.5006421804,
-0.678735137,
-0.1250199378,
-0.1917702109,
0.2549083233,
0.2372239232,
-0.2971351147,
-0.1717142016,
0.0909929276,
-0.1620843709,
-0.167537719,
0.5643244386,
-0.5718811154,
-0.1972129494,
0.0463855974,
0.0258647446,
-0.0748892874,
-0.1868062615,
-0.7372575402,
-0.2736119926,
-0.0049502421,
-0.3307479322,
0.1506951004,
0.452465564,
0.0614289008,
0.650146544,
0.5444496274,
0.075920634,
-0.1704038978,
-0.0038485413,
1.0823554993,
-0.3626224101,
-0.8398499489,
-1.0845214128,
0.3750342727,
-0.0609562062,
-0.5569259524,
0.7828937173,
0.5103678107,
0.8265711665,
0.1066958606,
0.9546958804,
0.0974112824,
0.2552177608,
-0.6172645092,
0.29997769,
-0.6634469032,
0.2290814072,
-0.0451560691,
-0.7426460385,
-0.2450025082,
0.2289108485,
-0.1945445389,
-0.1549383998,
0.4839719534,
0.7745503783,
-0.0212155133,
-0.1800550073,
0.2412759215,
-0.2474172562,
0.5102559924,
0.8471325636,
1.0427706242,
-0.3554507494,
0.720118165,
-0.2736558616,
-0.5012282133,
-0.3481168747,
-0.7490552068,
-1.1180301905,
-0.5991668701,
-0.2585822344,
-0.3273393512,
0.2058684677,
1.1994422674,
0.5888958573,
-0.5927596092,
0.0391940251,
-0.1153686643,
0.1911761612,
-0.4344293177,
-0.2481709421,
0.4709139168,
-0.7921569943,
-0.7747397423,
0.9909466505,
-0.0010626195,
0.0944180042,
-0.3746058047,
-0.3090718985,
-0.0738830417,
-0.0237022452,
0.5915558338,
0.1484467238,
-0.6802290082,
-0.0735470429,
0.0100042541,
-0.0527843423,
-0.144301638,
0.8143919706,
-0.8695778847,
0.8308363557,
0.5585086942,
0.7861174345,
0.1644812077,
0.3545089662,
0.7563920617,
-1.0565029383,
0.1908977628,
0.4022191465,
0.2673176229,
0.4118438065,
-0.7737988234,
0.1460431814,
0.1408207566,
-0.6576422453,
-0.9436179996,
0.3729348481,
-0.3172532022,
-0.4999325275,
0.8946328163,
-0.2190930843,
-0.2301323563,
0.1159600616,
-0.5102739334,
0.3983686864,
-0.6338421702,
0.6986871362,
0.3948629498,
-0.1799044162,
0.1036703065,
-0.2977788448,
0.9800007939,
0.2198613882,
-0.5535645485,
0.0077387244,
0.5905777812,
-0.3388242424,
-0.1789819151,
0.3589043915,
0.2909597456,
0.5444728732,
-0.0713953078,
-0.2010205537,
-0.5378596187,
-0.5791338682,
-0.6245791316,
0.1292739511,
-0.1028823629,
-0.4100069702
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02598v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02598v1
|
Impact of Tokenization on LLaMa Russian Adaptation
| 2023-12-05T09:16:03 | 2023-12-05T09:16:03 |
Mikhail Tikhomirov, Daniil Chernyshev
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Latest instruction-tuned large language models (LLM) show great results on
various tasks, however, they often face performance degradation for non-English
input. There is evidence that the reason lies in inefficient tokenization
caused by low language representation in pre-training data which hinders the
comprehension of non-English instructions, limiting the potential of target
language instruction-tuning. In this work we investigate the possibility of
addressing the issue with vocabulary substitution in the context of LLaMa
Russian language adaptation. We explore three variants of vocabulary adaptation
and test their performance on Saiga instruction-tuning and fine-tuning on
Russian Super Glue benchmark. The results of automatic evaluation show that
vocabulary substitution not only improves the model's quality in Russian but
also accelerates fine-tuning (35%) and inference (up to 60%) while reducing
memory consumption. Additional human evaluation of the instruction-tuned models
demonstrates that models with Russian-adapted vocabulary generate answers with
higher user preference than the original Saiga-LLaMa model.
|
[
0.1167385429,
-0.6551443338,
0.1496331394,
0.1422418356,
-0.6111767888,
0.1385793239,
-0.2447219193,
-0.4859448373,
0.3770741522,
0.0717693567,
-0.1541682482,
-0.3202894926,
-0.7613208294,
0.1512414217,
-0.1416372061,
1.1215012074,
-0.1814496368,
0.4746135175,
-0.2239253819,
-0.0234669261,
-0.9145714045,
-0.576500833,
-0.5597022176,
-0.5144891739,
0.4877990186,
0.5680861473,
0.6654108763,
0.791432023,
0.3735366762,
0.3056191504,
-0.1217196062,
0.0449010879,
-0.4669720232,
-0.0661448836,
-0.1883929968,
-0.8510911465,
-0.5437830091,
-0.0395084955,
0.862126708,
0.3114017248,
-0.2967121899,
0.3394114375,
-0.145303458,
0.4288634658,
-0.4712167978,
-0.0525153689,
-1.1633656025,
-0.0356718339,
-0.2232425809,
-0.1859129816,
-0.1324997246,
0.3830924928,
-0.1488643289,
-0.9634734988,
-0.0512712114,
0.1293064952,
0.9212586284,
0.3030082583,
0.049044814,
-0.1428305358,
-0.3628073633,
0.8436552286,
-0.8526165485,
0.1943452954,
0.5537571311,
0.0747334734,
-0.4929687679,
-0.5443564653,
-0.5949499011,
-0.2997758985,
-0.0104089351,
-0.0019377728,
-0.2690951824,
0.0859845877,
-0.1528415233,
0.1335886121,
-0.2028332949,
0.5203998685,
-0.4260008037,
-0.3357606232,
0.4544639885,
0.2462882847,
0.3077603579,
-0.1964386255,
-0.1505926847,
0.0220348816,
-0.7379001975,
-0.0469032265,
0.655016005,
0.3972733021,
0.025184622,
0.4517865777,
-0.2415766865,
0.8265485168,
0.1122949347,
-0.21127069,
0.2228492051,
-0.3203233778,
-0.3553061783,
-0.0877163187,
0.376843363,
0.3511803746,
0.1312492192,
-0.2862926424,
-0.1736966968,
0.0001584143,
0.1369568408,
-0.6564903259,
0.0146362614,
-0.0245381966,
-0.3627281487,
-0.0464019962,
-0.1793705076,
-0.3078854382,
-0.1478224695,
-0.223866418,
0.6936123967,
-0.2924102247,
0.066045925,
0.5279104114,
-0.0948840603,
0.3451726437,
0.3722286522,
-1.0416932106,
0.4145649076,
0.9179923534,
0.9049016237,
-0.5373936892,
-0.6757237315,
-0.8287844062,
-0.0177342966,
-0.5068156719,
0.7717341185,
-0.8376128674,
-0.4406430721,
-0.3207452893,
-0.0092305001,
-0.029371433,
-0.6516184807,
0.1039079577,
-0.4710410237,
-0.0533439666,
-0.2938731015,
-0.381637007,
0.0238540266,
0.1479256153,
-0.3137259185,
0.9890046716,
0.0545613319,
-0.4319555163,
0.5049811602,
-0.5935043097,
-0.4203745127,
0.0726794973,
0.2841578424,
-0.1943048984,
0.4649532437,
0.1717366129,
0.5126013756,
-0.2621102333,
0.1487749815,
0.1379490495,
-0.9325904846,
0.4258227944,
-0.2618920505,
0.0835551322,
-0.0515104942,
-0.0789490864,
0.1159784421,
-0.7187933326,
-0.2786173224,
-0.080973208,
-0.5919548869,
-0.2619372904,
-0.0020087347,
0.040959686,
-0.0910205245,
0.4372709095,
-0.3428839445,
0.2990053892,
-0.5022341013,
0.3410105109,
1.0985597372,
-0.0445059501,
0.5218018293,
-0.3522853553,
0.7854222059,
0.3778115511,
0.1680150926,
-0.1294436902,
-0.4915032685,
-1.2190810442,
-0.1372893304,
0.6687374115,
0.4718514681,
-0.6779307127,
-0.0569820367,
-0.3621612191,
-0.3172864318,
-0.7347511053,
0.2737314999,
0.4523976147,
0.3704153001,
0.3860808015,
-0.3295894563,
-0.6316487789,
-0.8599905372,
-0.4748501778,
-0.2497295737,
0.0642458722,
0.1164801642,
0.7079287767,
-0.0174452662,
0.663069427,
-0.1359857321,
-0.2531676888,
-0.1775299609,
-0.1954448521,
0.2734713554,
0.5636603236,
0.332713455,
-0.4876981676,
-0.5802869201,
0.2105734348,
0.0521201082,
-0.0196194761,
-0.2398822904,
-0.0808991268,
0.3770725131,
0.4380639493,
-0.4081228375,
0.5003222823,
0.698720336,
-0.2647361457,
0.6749863625,
-0.4496860206,
0.0008509302,
-1.1101980209,
0.0161706191,
-0.3426819444,
0.0101605142,
-0.8068435788,
0.0347215161,
-0.2049024403,
0.1326567531,
-0.6743649244,
0.6257674694,
-0.3477650881,
-0.3085624874,
-0.1187029481,
-0.0555667952,
-0.114160195,
0.3009622097,
-0.0309171062,
1.3339388371,
0.6043058634,
-0.4293825924,
0.0068301,
0.1763506085,
-0.5458578467,
0.2717437446,
-0.8250674009,
0.3189683855,
-0.0525144041,
0.1036868468,
-0.9926452637,
-0.2961545289,
0.4475748539,
-0.4205804765,
0.3712385893,
-0.1870930046,
-0.6896085739,
0.3277979493,
-0.2377345413,
0.1715281606,
0.4172725976,
-0.5202253461,
0.48026824,
0.0798207372,
0.107878089,
-0.8243511319,
-0.7613874078,
0.4321406186,
-0.3930687308,
-0.2786548138,
0.4769248366,
-0.1731176972,
-0.033449579,
-0.2680958211,
-0.2063698769,
0.1906274259,
0.280354619,
-0.0106688384,
0.3541251421,
-0.2348401695,
0.4607412517,
0.1436507553,
-0.0563464612,
-0.3546797633,
-0.3589447737,
0.5815699697,
-0.2943595648,
-0.215529874,
-0.5880420208,
0.0524864532,
0.426117599,
-0.0398445651,
1.1277549267,
0.5001155138,
-0.1638047546,
0.0201157443,
-0.5846611857,
-0.0161656309,
-0.5072094798,
0.5707671642,
-0.4027344286,
-0.8868435025,
0.713445425,
-0.0433805473,
-0.1553629488,
0.1491085142,
0.4013083279,
-0.117784813,
0.5463185906,
0.5113679171,
-0.1800265312,
0.5236500502,
-0.043125961,
0.0312159136,
-0.9593012333,
-0.0885689706,
-0.347859621,
-0.6839676499,
-0.5086350441,
-0.6581808925,
0.2610310912,
0.1050893366,
0.1306102574,
0.2321027368,
-0.1758633554,
0.8046195507,
0.1546956748,
0.0372911654,
0.2251927555,
0.2203229219,
0.0022369092,
-0.0736737251,
-0.8711286187,
-0.4115704,
1.2270821333,
0.1723553836,
0.5783218145,
-0.0553739592,
0.6130492091,
0.1795877516,
0.2691240907,
-0.9251629114,
0.600686729,
-0.4047574103,
-0.3141265512,
-0.2022934258,
-0.1444965154,
-1.044506669,
0.3094397485,
-0.2894152403,
-0.8615497351,
-0.1902215779,
0.1615516245,
-0.1500181854,
0.1042721197,
-0.6751781702,
0.7076058984,
0.0256884154,
-0.1152514592,
-0.4675815105,
-0.2282803059,
0.0796813145,
-0.3621354997,
0.158365801,
-0.0137117086,
-0.5961452127,
0.8417448997,
-0.2184867859,
1.0324655771,
0.0039609796,
0.0988636464,
0.0112208072,
-0.1058600545,
0.5867983103,
0.1201353371,
-0.2677482367,
0.499474138,
-0.1858960986,
-0.5720694661,
-0.6210439205,
0.7381463647,
-0.9816382527,
-1.1997531652,
-0.2519681752,
-0.7289878726,
-0.2021621913,
-0.1566450745,
0.0799186453,
0.077305913,
-0.1818433702,
0.0052591446,
0.1462326795,
-0.1748421192,
0.4353210926,
0.5835519433,
-0.2278761417,
-0.3398334086,
0.9363896847,
0.2890947163,
0.3243813813,
0.2795075178,
0.4892321229,
0.0411916599,
-0.911200583,
-0.5716509223,
0.3892123997,
-0.8546903133,
-0.2555386126,
-0.1586889774,
0.2270053178,
-0.0415249579,
-0.2224173099,
-0.2300563455,
-0.5599137545,
-0.9500347376,
-0.0287459604,
0.5098119378,
0.6973387599,
0.0410154723,
0.6741622686,
-0.4708262384,
-0.061622031,
0.3607450426,
0.3761140108,
-0.0225107707,
-1.191590786,
-0.5868678689,
-0.1111499071,
0.0412602723,
-0.6499982476,
0.0935526043,
0.6233563423,
0.3963530362,
0.0157540422,
-0.6083351374,
1.1386379004,
-0.7693433762,
0.8833392859,
0.1111874059,
-1.2602373362,
0.2015560865,
-0.2987112701,
0.545191884,
0.245691821,
0.0820958391,
-0.6258658767,
0.0379155241,
-0.2715243399,
-0.419614017,
0.7041858435,
-0.0781497136,
0.6515930295,
-0.0104600936,
0.6797660589,
0.3734463453,
0.031683594,
-0.3563067913,
-0.0666670203,
-0.2204390019,
0.2176239789,
-0.2766081989,
-0.2629957199,
0.3078121841,
-0.3758253157,
0.6792682409,
-0.2290141881,
0.0885138288,
-0.1803915203,
-0.2145101875,
-0.0717555434,
0.2656375766,
0.8446525931,
0.5880178213,
0.3263017237,
-0.2354565114,
0.8467845917,
-0.5909474492,
0.2008995712,
-0.3959261179,
-0.0512749441,
0.0082749585,
0.2417613417,
0.9351254106,
0.3948133886,
-0.5866837502,
0.2804305851,
-0.0432149731,
-0.0408582203,
-0.0942739993,
0.2914045155,
0.3691622019,
0.0518045127,
0.4312132597,
0.2019410431,
-0.1689696759,
-0.4982851446,
-0.189140588,
0.5552102923,
0.0296345148,
-0.5442705154,
0.255384624,
-0.1409257054,
-0.604457736,
0.2977747321,
-0.0289610121,
-0.3570213616,
0.5898177624,
0.8704615235,
0.4896263778,
-0.520219326,
0.309006989,
0.0753937662,
0.1915116906,
-0.1299207062,
0.1504645497,
0.1036167964,
-0.6791690588,
-0.7343070507,
-0.8032559752,
-0.2723002136,
0.1948631406,
-0.5954982042,
0.3628818393,
-0.6515730619,
-0.1495846808,
-0.2014465481,
-0.2049532086,
-0.6116082668,
0.0531105958,
-0.0649007633,
0.9641337395,
-0.7878715992,
0.9545629621,
0.9101663828,
0.0436791964,
-0.499263078,
0.078014411,
-0.448740989,
-0.9875240326,
1.0028589964,
-0.0257667601,
-0.1937019974,
-0.0555520467,
-0.4710407257,
-1.1748706102,
0.9713363051,
0.5527783632,
-0.3059885502,
0.1506120116,
0.3596611917,
0.8295050859,
-0.493204087,
0.0094601614,
0.8211238384,
0.3404515088,
0.0380232856,
-1.1223591566,
-0.0951755047,
-0.1547506154,
0.4873226583,
-0.0524698645,
-0.8255646825,
0.7464395761,
-0.0854372457,
-0.1500770152,
0.3530575931,
0.756713748,
-0.0449414477,
-0.2375237048,
0.353294611,
0.3038107455,
0.6182333827,
0.1558180004,
0.6696321964,
-0.1452263743,
-0.1166602448,
0.8785401583,
-0.0030727673,
1.3245873451,
1.0472928286,
-0.2245021462,
0.6684294939,
0.5099915266,
0.0772770271,
0.3715067208,
0.4635156095,
-0.1915618628,
-0.2341092825,
-0.2396030128,
-0.1179781109,
1.0496628284,
0.6539522409,
0.004063359,
0.1129708886,
0.0357205123,
0.1892092675,
-0.1130422577,
-0.5365323424,
0.6606527567,
-0.1246199682,
-0.7480168939,
1.0985581875,
0.2358266264,
0.8389649391,
-0.5647366047,
-0.0302878246,
-0.4145537317,
-0.0140524618,
-0.1448028535,
-0.2277084589,
0.2964797914,
0.0885891169,
0.010565171,
-0.0258219577,
0.6477720141,
-0.2528330982,
-0.4128356874,
0.0594987907,
0.304900378,
0.4287277758,
0.3542800546,
-0.6441265345,
0.3485177755,
-0.1625891328,
-0.2595458925,
0.897497654,
0.0250855032,
-0.0480587147,
0.585303247,
0.9373989105,
0.3682308197,
0.0896403044,
-0.2392747998,
0.9810184836,
-0.2577027977,
-0.4372799993,
-0.9116360545,
0.5382499695,
0.2538517118,
-0.5962666273,
0.7428979278,
0.1969218403,
0.8417652249,
-0.3242423832,
0.4773150384,
0.4205105007,
-0.0754876211,
-0.8473340869,
0.6938954592,
-0.7172119617,
0.3444282711,
-0.1302157342,
-0.7854306698,
-0.3466965258,
0.5152757764,
-0.271530807,
-0.1075882614,
0.5576319695,
0.9424394965,
-0.1026770622,
-0.4606146812,
0.6962819099,
0.1429874599,
-0.0275977235,
0.3860669434,
0.7481947541,
-0.6756774783,
0.5508410335,
0.1823350042,
0.0499336384,
-0.2889647782,
-1.1597507,
-1.1281030178,
-0.6587781906,
-0.2682898939,
-0.0156520363,
0.3203947246,
0.8164806366,
0.5891035199,
-0.7290185094,
-0.3193923533,
0.0622531176,
0.0429935642,
-0.0699196979,
-0.0882246718,
0.2730217576,
-0.4670407474,
-0.6647638679,
0.6355104446,
0.3273834288,
0.2063646168,
-0.2444653511,
-0.1536425054,
-0.1160367131,
0.2436233759,
0.3360277116,
0.0587317385,
-1.0738655329,
-0.5507237911,
0.2590791285,
0.2827036083,
0.3303506672,
0.5845001936,
-0.8936128616,
0.4813063741,
0.2814769745,
0.6991248131,
0.4565498531,
-0.1108867452,
0.4275746644,
-0.8834577799,
0.4152325392,
-0.1778621972,
0.3759562373,
0.5143832564,
-0.4436551332,
0.1247387305,
0.1572273672,
-0.3397274315,
-0.733610332,
0.1720877141,
-0.4281075895,
-0.1815895289,
1.265214324,
-0.2571426034,
-0.387354672,
-0.1195071712,
-0.3039178848,
0.1799413264,
-0.3945722878,
0.9919179082,
1.0624643564,
0.0871878341,
-0.0558112189,
-0.3476889431,
0.388669908,
0.8241861463,
-0.7184981108,
-0.045056235,
0.0826250091,
0.4754052162,
-0.0535705946,
0.3791589439,
0.3062995076,
0.5134885311,
-0.0312682875,
-0.2601058781,
-0.1679608673,
-0.1851378828,
-0.7525439858,
-0.4553529918,
0.4094909132,
-0.2251073271
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02590v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02590v1
|
Text Intimacy Analysis using Ensembles of Multilingual Transformers
| 2023-12-05T09:04:22 | 2023-12-05T09:04:22 |
Tanmay Chavan, Ved Patwardhan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Intimacy estimation of a given text has recently gained importance due to the
increase in direct interaction of NLP systems with humans. Intimacy is an
important aspect of natural language and has a substantial impact on our
everyday communication. Thus the level of intimacy can provide us with deeper
insights and richer semantics of conversations. In this paper, we present our
work on the SemEval shared task 9 on predicting the level of intimacy for the
given text. The dataset consists of tweets in ten languages, out of which only
six are available in the training dataset. We conduct several experiments and
show that an ensemble of multilingual models along with a language-specific
monolingual model has the best performance. We also evaluate other data
augmentation methods such as translation and present the results. Lastly, we
study the results thoroughly and present some noteworthy insights into this
problem.
|
[
-0.2344557792,
-0.9536006451,
0.5257939696,
0.621082902,
-0.276707381,
-0.174925521,
-0.4166762531,
-0.8832262754,
0.2043986619,
0.4801347852,
-0.4265611172,
-0.5034321547,
-0.6805742979,
0.2525491118,
-0.5222271681,
0.6825520396,
-0.1375581026,
-0.0943963826,
-0.4846224189,
-0.3378262818,
-0.2931205928,
-0.4026875198,
-0.3125810921,
-0.0110264532,
0.3136630356,
0.3630903959,
0.5116610527,
0.2887205184,
0.724750638,
0.4318816364,
-0.0786279663,
0.1117808968,
-0.5930538177,
0.4529802799,
-0.0846492574,
-0.2245013565,
-0.5444728136,
-0.1005215719,
0.6435004473,
0.6433295608,
0.1006366089,
0.3117672503,
0.1943588257,
0.6940233707,
-0.5361732841,
-0.0147076342,
-0.185890615,
0.2646664977,
-0.3364856243,
-0.2746247053,
-0.3672869802,
-0.2952487171,
0.523709178,
-0.2071584016,
0.000459314,
0.1253756583,
0.6854920983,
0.0701331943,
-0.6571732163,
-0.0368067995,
-0.7091594338,
1.079262495,
-0.5740659833,
0.7351313233,
0.6117507219,
-0.152127713,
0.1762245297,
-0.3471441865,
-0.3715550303,
-0.3390476406,
-0.5473554134,
0.1208162606,
-0.1962044835,
0.0314936526,
-0.1401401907,
0.6232799888,
-0.5853533745,
-0.2022047937,
-0.3756072819,
0.0840643644,
0.8408708572,
-0.1221596673,
0.6919856668,
-0.3235414624,
-0.5240256786,
0.1634289324,
0.1228113398,
0.2004046738,
0.5246344805,
-0.0195856858,
-0.2588341534,
0.6503987908,
0.0688992664,
0.3038487136,
-0.200951606,
0.0692720562,
0.3245002925,
-0.4136372209,
-0.2057785988,
0.0340561233,
1.0978152752,
0.3397078216,
0.31905967,
-0.1270094812,
-0.0068870131,
0.287801981,
0.3438767791,
-0.4199890196,
0.125717327,
0.4553405643,
-0.3972548544,
-0.490576148,
-0.2116473466,
-0.7660727501,
-0.1844057888,
-0.2220426947,
0.3119455278,
-0.612673521,
-0.500366807,
0.1527187079,
0.0607259199,
0.1146306992,
0.2155786753,
-1.0589026213,
0.4589332342,
0.6890234351,
0.636208415,
-0.4150368571,
-0.6807847619,
-0.1458156705,
-0.2397988588,
-0.4343939424,
0.66346246,
-0.5908645988,
-0.2374041826,
-0.001997594,
0.0920996219,
-0.2127991915,
0.0679623485,
0.8241801858,
-0.3574460745,
0.3324107826,
0.0376162753,
-0.8038914204,
-0.2164485455,
0.3210321665,
-0.801777482,
1.2332004309,
-0.3022221327,
-0.9773376584,
0.1261060387,
-0.8520007133,
-0.6369922757,
-0.1033106297,
0.0147664705,
-0.5212206244,
0.1522646099,
0.4052182138,
0.675783217,
0.0468287244,
0.1817064583,
-0.3775414228,
-0.1182470843,
0.6146296859,
-0.2656697631,
0.3456671834,
0.0042303028,
-0.2274127454,
0.1042133272,
-0.3910188973,
-0.1606255621,
-0.0190490801,
0.2477262616,
-0.6020773053,
-0.4086404741,
0.1443914026,
-0.1091394722,
0.4551464319,
-0.7364203334,
-0.1922332644,
-0.7080917954,
0.0448875837,
0.6331944466,
0.1422350109,
1.0324457884,
-0.0210438576,
0.6759086847,
0.0058918293,
0.1661582738,
-0.1818094999,
-0.3548524976,
-0.371168077,
0.0895856321,
0.4616303742,
0.3092879057,
-0.4140922725,
0.1907031536,
-0.2241926938,
-0.6422946453,
-0.7342067361,
0.0779456645,
0.2937219739,
-0.0774978697,
0.1429019272,
0.0701102093,
-0.3667980433,
-0.9297219515,
-0.4133630693,
0.0445326976,
0.4070708454,
0.388479203,
0.3657253683,
0.0619474128,
0.697625041,
-0.4273474216,
-0.1506962925,
-0.4020723999,
-0.0467417426,
-0.0182715096,
0.6993785501,
0.6788942218,
-1.1222630739,
-0.5665957928,
0.2279810756,
-1.0924938917,
0.2874191105,
0.1196327806,
-0.344178468,
0.048786737,
0.171864152,
-0.1719413102,
0.3389642835,
0.9280456901,
-0.4188816547,
0.4243976176,
-0.1833400577,
0.6482899189,
-1.220810771,
-0.1034145355,
0.2961365879,
-0.3790484965,
-1.1280574799,
-0.0149573665,
0.1553196013,
0.0937237069,
-0.4467198849,
0.825853467,
-0.5175182223,
-0.0710086375,
-0.1263391525,
0.1148053631,
-0.0651813745,
0.5409923196,
0.0723996386,
0.5824861526,
0.6157261729,
-0.3993289769,
0.2445257008,
0.5400315523,
-0.1522911638,
0.5090286732,
-0.6485567093,
0.3781617582,
-0.0805904567,
-0.0811678469,
-1.0883411169,
-0.5181213021,
-0.0780987814,
-0.9282442331,
0.0565198809,
0.0512222014,
-0.3403714597,
0.0260997508,
-0.4874846041,
0.5811098814,
0.1076662615,
-0.5026441813,
0.6490054131,
0.6896942258,
-0.3690426052,
-0.7623506188,
-0.6391047835,
0.0049540126,
-0.3263658583,
-1.1650474072,
0.1595103592,
0.0996588543,
-0.2514714599,
0.078533791,
0.0109213833,
-0.4914100468,
0.3464883268,
0.415300101,
0.3034622967,
-0.0917736366,
0.4249178171,
0.3447986841,
0.0350155197,
-0.0497310385,
0.0704042092,
0.6374241114,
-0.5484270453,
-0.1591476798,
-0.4529038668,
0.7383930087,
0.2266711295,
-0.4876819849,
1.2067488432,
1.0415627956,
-0.5432817936,
-0.0559996106,
-0.4514038861,
-0.0401017107,
-0.4533679783,
0.1846134812,
-0.3728807569,
-1.105943203,
0.5203155279,
0.1440073103,
-0.0564457178,
0.447177887,
0.2738343179,
-0.1623591781,
0.7465497851,
1.0795009136,
0.0704997405,
0.4064542651,
-0.2136906385,
0.0474715494,
-0.6170466542,
-0.0447050668,
-0.3363083601,
-0.5380988717,
-1.0743354559,
-0.0617719069,
0.4896989763,
-0.0116781574,
0.1706384569,
0.6462976336,
-0.2732135952,
0.4657046497,
0.518001616,
0.3479546607,
0.3016951978,
-0.1108483374,
0.2272008806,
-0.3800240755,
-0.0808354691,
-0.5422823429,
0.6790143251,
0.3531203866,
0.5880615711,
0.4172309935,
0.8252055645,
0.2762413323,
-0.2427013814,
-0.6300725341,
0.4165638685,
-0.0969239548,
-0.6466648579,
-0.5332478285,
-0.478787303,
-1.0633587837,
0.0124890739,
-0.237875104,
-1.0975297689,
0.1981999725,
-0.1860542446,
-0.1567830294,
-0.1196746603,
-0.7576387525,
1.0846083164,
-0.0735980496,
-0.4775848687,
-0.0607473776,
-0.7294421196,
0.5025331974,
-0.0326122455,
0.1044121012,
-0.2698048055,
-0.1927066743,
0.8527790904,
0.0933939889,
0.567422092,
0.2166565657,
-0.2819184065,
-0.0754289031,
0.0368100516,
0.3572722375,
0.0804335549,
-0.36146909,
0.0157275889,
-0.0419836305,
-0.4580194652,
-0.5245539546,
0.8750177026,
-0.7877932191,
-0.0964435264,
-0.3179381788,
-0.2548254728,
-0.3674981594,
0.1306386739,
0.1913561225,
0.6966592073,
-0.5098346472,
0.3717079461,
0.4076387584,
-0.2699812949,
0.6729232073,
-0.0239446964,
-0.3726744652,
-0.3078480661,
0.6844245195,
-0.009983913,
0.1586042047,
0.4499364495,
0.3629733622,
-0.5411754847,
-0.2186449915,
-0.3408989012,
0.137615189,
-0.409086585,
0.0816104412,
-1.1936864853,
-0.2179686427,
-0.6216859818,
-0.2632164061,
-0.5492973328,
-0.3789336383,
-0.125975132,
-0.2625829577,
0.5026322007,
0.6651521921,
0.0894343033,
0.2895632684,
-1.436217308,
0.1018606126,
0.0479136445,
0.326651305,
-0.2245579362,
-0.3615829349,
-0.2406315207,
-0.135714978,
0.0399446376,
-1.0407414436,
0.6593543291,
0.2967520356,
0.3912620842,
0.1500749439,
0.3039624095,
0.4115701914,
-0.1955298185,
0.8657681942,
0.0306851584,
-1.0626782179,
0.5846229196,
-0.6018012762,
-0.0025371544,
0.5722056031,
0.3698387444,
-0.8450117111,
-0.2837730646,
-1.0342392921,
-0.7739750147,
0.6775742173,
0.9019019008,
0.4522973299,
0.2671334743,
0.0996413305,
0.1025502607,
0.5596162677,
-0.7964103222,
-0.4325873256,
0.3087991178,
-0.3632602394,
-0.0408195481,
-0.1625016183,
0.2043618411,
-0.0576160289,
0.5117156506,
0.2187325209,
0.6612389684,
0.2235636562,
-0.261506021,
-0.1284402609,
0.5078883171,
0.5055730939,
0.4067069292,
-0.1675493419,
0.0494458787,
0.3330337703,
-0.4124060571,
0.1710164398,
0.1354452223,
0.424220264,
0.0610717051,
0.5573506355,
0.9085054994,
0.1726804823,
-0.3974688649,
0.84014678,
-0.1690033376,
0.1331518441,
-0.4648240507,
-0.2727471292,
0.3260847628,
0.2749656737,
0.0437415801,
0.3131089509,
0.3993011713,
-0.4305512607,
0.5559711456,
0.0709407628,
-0.7691494226,
-0.7046344876,
0.2428551614,
0.3916873038,
-0.3139295578,
-0.0167189352,
-0.3989663124,
-0.8125911951,
0.4570999146,
0.2948093116,
0.9659343362,
-0.5503451824,
0.4158835411,
0.3787135184,
0.2800191641,
0.0845854655,
0.1747111827,
-0.0210324097,
-1.0260752439,
-0.6433646083,
-0.7471818924,
-0.4278012216,
-0.0895060971,
-0.5825700164,
0.2591770589,
0.1757040471,
0.1946664155,
0.126172483,
0.0956354365,
-0.601323545,
-0.0071418178,
-0.011103197,
0.4261539876,
-0.9095675349,
0.5410242677,
0.7268027663,
-0.0629993975,
-0.8613701463,
-0.1190204024,
-0.0354259461,
-0.6638697982,
0.1293365955,
0.3149388134,
-0.1040850431,
0.0558731072,
-0.5299832225,
-0.5143586993,
0.7180918455,
0.3146926165,
-0.066086635,
0.1348524541,
0.3581874371,
0.7918182015,
-0.2964767218,
0.3518776298,
0.6179632545,
0.3749781847,
-0.0581586175,
-0.99004668,
-0.2448309213,
-0.5702892542,
-0.2784295678,
0.6574892998,
-0.4296558201,
0.5912900567,
0.2430111021,
-0.2413200438,
0.0198379103,
0.8995456696,
-0.1846666187,
0.5275903344,
0.6001926661,
0.4295531213,
0.5398353338,
-0.0070789913,
1.0252605677,
-0.1101208329,
0.7835534811,
1.1579912901,
-0.0819339827,
0.9945890307,
0.2273150682,
-0.2119845748,
0.0653942525,
0.5820301175,
0.2027576417,
0.0372332819,
-0.3113813698,
-0.4119898081,
-0.1905702204,
-0.5821031332,
-0.2223399132,
0.7747351527,
0.219174087,
-0.4359692037,
0.0720754713,
0.3284009099,
0.1576786637,
0.2597002685,
0.0815606862,
1.0063861609,
0.1275932342,
-0.4829069674,
-0.1741666347,
-0.3072153032,
0.616957128,
-0.1375264227,
0.1459750384,
-0.1836894006,
0.1993018687,
-0.3177137375,
-1.0158319473,
0.2360631078,
-0.0222839024,
0.1450916231,
-0.260453254,
1.1387327909,
-0.9459145665,
-0.6397666931,
0.5363786221,
0.819378078,
0.1431045383,
-0.3667583764,
-0.5287188292,
-0.1045901775,
0.1548658758,
-0.2208042741,
0.0422456153,
0.6156725883,
0.4619970024,
0.4492976665,
0.5779882669,
-0.1714112014,
0.0210875329,
-0.0603071041,
0.590189755,
-0.6005586386,
-0.502671957,
-1.0694162846,
0.6769706011,
-0.3503361642,
-0.4102666676,
1.0386955738,
0.2927309275,
0.4377620518,
0.140322268,
0.6218080521,
0.1133386642,
0.5734362602,
-0.2604292631,
0.4969189465,
-0.6138201952,
0.1763249934,
-0.728140533,
-0.9949284792,
-0.0316789113,
0.3197518289,
-0.3557577133,
-0.1302702129,
0.693082571,
0.5317956805,
-0.2861814201,
0.6013910174,
0.5941099524,
0.0062415716,
0.0351698883,
0.1461197585,
1.1779158115,
-0.7939512134,
0.291474402,
-0.6768832803,
-0.0316932388,
-0.1621573418,
-0.7601700425,
-0.7530986667,
-0.7765365243,
-0.1138262004,
-0.1985428035,
-0.258400619,
1.1195867062,
0.3591588438,
-0.489934206,
-0.2275200784,
0.0108431438,
-0.050713934,
-0.1832658052,
-0.1798325181,
0.4576052129,
-0.4089013338,
-0.9565786719,
0.3080127239,
0.3067260385,
0.1291267872,
-0.1776694804,
0.0515404604,
-0.5632038116,
0.0874590278,
0.4866483808,
-0.4015285671,
-0.1203390658,
-0.3826809227,
0.4763445258,
-0.1315314025,
0.1274828315,
0.4489513934,
-0.0633771718,
0.5443559885,
0.5941445231,
0.6798407435,
0.5206350684,
0.0492025875,
0.8655290604,
-1.1849800348,
0.0579919927,
0.2916620374,
0.432782203,
0.4148575962,
-0.5370514989,
0.7280040383,
-0.1176127568,
-0.8532928824,
-0.7957233191,
-0.2111352086,
-1.1733521223,
0.1514517069,
1.2110825777,
-0.2773418128,
-0.4967974722,
-0.0390367657,
-0.0829013735,
0.2539920509,
-0.6796202064,
0.4560315609,
0.8851178288,
0.0253987163,
-0.1987499595,
-0.4938495457,
0.5460252762,
0.3780764639,
-1.0816065073,
-0.1549752802,
0.0418063179,
-0.3135073781,
0.4598454833,
0.6087604761,
0.136746645,
0.2388581783,
-0.2092297226,
0.0092821904,
0.4477182329,
-0.2540360391,
-0.2951649129,
0.2777630687,
-0.2890567183,
-0.4643232226
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02578v1
|
Empathy and Distress Detection using Ensembles of Transformer Models
| 2023-12-05T08:50:34 | 2023-12-05T08:50:34 |
Tanmay Chavan, Kshitij Deshpande, Sheetal Sonawane
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper presents our approach for the WASSA 2023 Empathy, Emotion and
Personality Shared Task. Empathy and distress are human feelings that are
implicitly expressed in natural discourses. Empathy and distress detection are
crucial challenges in Natural Language Processing that can aid our
understanding of conversations. The provided dataset consists of several
long-text examples in the English language, with each example associated with a
numeric score for empathy and distress. We experiment with several BERT-based
models as a part of our approach. We also try various ensemble methods. Our
final submission has a Pearson's r score of 0.346, placing us third in the
empathy and distress detection subtask.
|
[
-0.7334922552,
-0.4603297114,
0.6685401797,
0.7271553874,
-0.2479953319,
-0.0617635064,
0.0790266916,
-0.7009708285,
0.2460865825,
0.2808221281,
-0.8383386135,
-0.3583413064,
-0.8474206328,
0.2849700749,
-0.4366242588,
0.8360058069,
0.2326780856,
0.1987968981,
-0.0290807784,
-0.240879029,
-0.202860415,
-0.574752748,
-0.9788340926,
-0.3543362021,
0.4831669927,
0.2434088439,
0.3259466588,
-0.1290620267,
0.7248182297,
0.4048879743,
-0.1507051587,
0.0013150633,
-0.1681013256,
0.0935450792,
-0.1454044878,
-0.0447641425,
-0.716765821,
0.115211077,
0.2147893459,
0.3739279807,
0.0864663348,
0.1141210496,
0.2369532138,
0.5801657438,
-0.5470404029,
0.0727768242,
-0.282926023,
0.2654109001,
0.2447123677,
0.1374435276,
-0.6467679739,
-0.1784553975,
0.2815365791,
-0.329020828,
0.2189222574,
0.2871825099,
0.7369600534,
0.3896415234,
-0.6024315953,
-0.4666262567,
-0.3702347279,
1.1059656143,
-0.3420920074,
0.1050998643,
0.2381251007,
-0.1222927496,
0.2083407789,
-0.5737104416,
-0.6917837262,
0.0403353758,
-0.3757524788,
0.4218660295,
-0.7478164434,
0.0336386077,
0.2592352331,
0.4727160931,
-0.4707806706,
0.142499432,
-0.1752532125,
-0.0522377081,
1.0402696133,
0.3164082468,
0.3317030966,
-0.7639011145,
-0.52064991,
-0.2478420436,
0.0587895736,
0.0906205401,
0.5597153902,
0.1578641534,
-0.5921257734,
0.2093731016,
0.48554793,
0.269305557,
-0.139731884,
0.1557841152,
0.2189717144,
0.1604228914,
-0.2050482184,
-0.0581453107,
0.9214211702,
0.6599680185,
0.6608124971,
0.3135209978,
-0.2348992079,
0.4080789387,
0.8086555004,
-0.4699182212,
-0.0583308563,
0.2324211597,
-0.9348295331,
-0.412960887,
-0.1068618372,
-1.3095897436,
-0.6214416623,
-0.2249936759,
0.2726705372,
-0.4030522406,
-0.3092657626,
0.0753559396,
-0.2364664823,
0.4550803006,
0.135507673,
-0.7449752688,
0.7733131647,
0.4783954024,
0.7912467122,
-0.3679786623,
-0.1218113378,
-0.1889309883,
-0.5242680907,
-0.0550248809,
1.0215504169,
-0.4421102107,
-0.811306715,
-0.1115164086,
0.1114692688,
0.0083597563,
-0.1845407188,
1.1967955828,
-0.1190195084,
0.2848589122,
-0.3803175986,
-0.4335603416,
-0.2869104743,
0.2265615761,
-0.7779568434,
1.0206611156,
0.4270994961,
-0.8303568959,
0.1881290376,
-1.3396648169,
-0.3488440514,
-0.2139435261,
0.4141574502,
-0.5494037271,
0.2070633769,
0.2582981586,
0.7422024012,
-0.3615005016,
-0.0347517841,
-0.2714341879,
-0.3899093866,
0.1669042706,
-0.4331369698,
0.4460015297,
0.1352029294,
-0.1500297487,
0.1464324445,
-0.5901037455,
-0.0963832885,
0.037120264,
0.0897735804,
-0.4075803459,
0.1151679382,
0.4155944288,
-0.0733543262,
0.1022913828,
-0.7267742753,
0.1546456665,
-0.1230240911,
0.1773277968,
0.88663131,
0.2081878483,
0.3530133665,
-0.0896535218,
0.5539572239,
0.3011245728,
0.507122457,
0.0641790479,
-0.7153965831,
-0.668533504,
-0.5397755504,
-0.2880825996,
0.4777558744,
0.0517396145,
0.8510536551,
0.0323052108,
-0.3935991228,
-0.5712085366,
-0.5683584213,
0.384136498,
0.6247118115,
0.7232459784,
-0.2569487393,
-0.8701450229,
-1.0709890127,
-0.3129003942,
-0.2199421972,
-0.136385113,
0.31541273,
0.4428600669,
-0.4998129904,
0.7826245427,
-0.5775806308,
-0.3118384182,
-0.165816471,
0.6234603524,
0.1153626963,
0.471984148,
0.526211679,
-1.0469632149,
-0.368347168,
-0.2167871594,
-0.6975371838,
-0.1654327661,
0.2307305485,
-0.0065617883,
0.3649477959,
0.3079749048,
-0.498575151,
0.735986948,
0.6592268348,
-0.5061898232,
0.2867268324,
0.1160795614,
0.4794096053,
-1.3201830387,
0.0960858092,
0.2817772031,
0.102516897,
-0.6335259676,
-0.4699706137,
-0.0309658665,
0.1787280589,
-0.4174600244,
0.6238862276,
-0.1003687009,
-0.086855635,
0.0675212219,
-0.1040789559,
0.0342729092,
0.4095498025,
0.1335359812,
0.4702153504,
0.5739910007,
-0.3505896628,
0.3986629248,
0.4826378226,
-0.1855405271,
0.9536725879,
-0.5865551829,
0.1415976584,
-0.1744229794,
0.1376154423,
-0.9790245295,
-0.4929918945,
0.2057386935,
-0.4534241855,
0.0335430503,
0.0049423268,
-0.1220017672,
-0.7736796737,
-0.2939145267,
0.2735862732,
0.7132146955,
-0.6280366778,
1.1037213802,
0.1946202517,
-0.2679873407,
-0.3814128935,
-0.617857933,
0.0892387927,
-0.5991427302,
-0.5834624767,
0.3702288866,
-0.0247786716,
-0.4340093434,
0.0445607975,
0.2608084679,
-0.2754172385,
-0.027229283,
0.7013617754,
0.3951280713,
0.0680300072,
0.1453763992,
0.1350581944,
-0.2808758318,
0.398000598,
0.5001974702,
0.494027108,
-0.5067234635,
-0.6015760303,
-0.5418506265,
0.7243021727,
0.8332074881,
-0.0515431613,
0.6716253161,
0.8311340213,
-0.548874855,
0.0738461167,
-0.5155892372,
-0.3634616733,
-0.4503893554,
0.1295513064,
-0.1691998988,
-0.7248587608,
0.9007495046,
0.0417164117,
-0.3647985756,
0.1721051633,
0.6011786461,
-0.1664766222,
1.3788986206,
0.5135686994,
-0.4850061834,
0.1289400905,
-0.1453344971,
0.7698594332,
-0.9867712259,
-0.0882715434,
-0.4751113653,
-0.5522996187,
-0.6903136969,
0.0547437556,
0.5950784683,
-0.4399373829,
-0.2465337217,
0.0494511575,
-0.644245863,
0.3124376833,
0.4095307887,
0.2514652014,
-0.0152671337,
-0.5183580518,
0.4179573059,
-0.0661204606,
-0.1211431101,
-0.8323358893,
0.7052263021,
0.4753138423,
0.6577581167,
-0.0623961389,
0.7160337567,
0.6259040833,
0.707894206,
-1.2525781393,
0.4636678398,
-0.1137708053,
-0.4220668972,
-0.3871750236,
0.0357918143,
-1.0163421631,
0.0335169956,
-0.0176773351,
-1.0858216286,
0.3313957453,
0.253421247,
-0.4335847795,
0.1178790405,
-1.0580726862,
0.8592560887,
0.1641796529,
-0.0866350234,
-0.0975778922,
-0.816408813,
0.4040626884,
-0.1222168654,
0.3348705173,
0.086310409,
0.2731306255,
0.8399388194,
-0.1059518158,
1.0343724489,
-0.3073212504,
0.0364312306,
0.3653877974,
-0.0189015884,
0.465637207,
-0.0559401587,
-0.1987498999,
-0.2375066578,
0.0029862265,
-0.3926887512,
-0.6495123506,
0.3760572374,
-0.6506719589,
-0.2455483973,
-0.4020937383,
-0.5796922445,
-0.2968989313,
-0.1019763947,
0.2997781336,
0.1966799647,
-0.3556227684,
0.0919118673,
0.5267409086,
-0.1039203554,
0.6913884878,
0.4110837281,
0.0519053154,
-0.1242810339,
0.4611075222,
-0.3938231766,
-0.1125713065,
-0.0010052089,
0.4074987471,
-0.3858997226,
0.0120316874,
0.2527424097,
0.1170818508,
-0.4962639809,
-0.4767559171,
-0.7910709977,
0.0224601161,
-0.3544088602,
-0.4891839921,
-0.4359275699,
0.3052363098,
-0.4344246984,
-0.2891926467,
0.6711207032,
1.0384408236,
-0.4957949519,
0.3664489686,
-1.0268040895,
0.2693963051,
0.3846174777,
0.3377167583,
0.0561221018,
-0.3112826347,
0.052180659,
-0.0904157534,
-0.3279975653,
-0.8219815493,
0.8030574322,
0.0469668247,
0.016390048,
0.7089232802,
0.3920150995,
0.5493773222,
-0.1431788951,
0.9909570813,
0.1970688552,
-1.3415355682,
0.3770764172,
-0.2100837231,
-0.221467644,
0.1711031199,
0.7683406472,
-0.5433672071,
-0.1673312485,
-0.8330013156,
-0.6041522622,
0.6904779673,
-0.0500899516,
0.4244175851,
-0.2530373037,
0.0364026874,
-0.0921699777,
-0.2714392543,
-0.7126810551,
0.0301616378,
-0.2102477103,
-0.5816916227,
-0.0435784236,
-0.5418425798,
-0.1141512319,
-0.2045296878,
0.1461983919,
-0.2018786222,
0.6627851725,
0.3220421672,
0.2500899136,
-0.5067374706,
0.0489064828,
0.4500823021,
-0.1247726679,
-0.3336397111,
0.1486950368,
0.4510279894,
-0.6006783247,
0.1421533227,
-0.1490842253,
0.9075998068,
-0.3205288947,
0.9294720292,
0.7935115099,
0.5231384039,
-0.5177088976,
0.8912343383,
-0.2437894195,
-0.2538750768,
-0.4711990952,
-0.1554930955,
0.088335596,
0.5369787216,
0.3982368112,
0.1805882305,
0.4591338634,
-0.5441617966,
0.3050463796,
0.2119254321,
-0.5092129111,
-0.654445231,
-0.0302740298,
0.1013513356,
-0.5788212419,
0.8231470585,
-0.2509275973,
-1.0509763956,
0.46331653,
0.428155154,
0.9612142444,
-0.6359447837,
0.1465457827,
0.1937213689,
-0.0509864353,
0.0425945893,
0.702578187,
0.0782038942,
-1.1391115189,
-0.1875328571,
-0.5414353609,
-0.7134119272,
0.184352681,
-1.5751724243,
0.161871314,
-0.0374154449,
-0.2041355819,
-0.1360436529,
-0.2102511376,
-0.6748673916,
0.5618228316,
-0.0194308981,
0.9247825146,
-1.3917430639,
0.3387673199,
0.5680159926,
-0.0556909665,
-0.9470753074,
0.1155255586,
-0.1189929619,
-0.9707788229,
0.6733051538,
0.2632584274,
-0.0493945107,
0.1381720752,
-0.7087487578,
-0.5114534497,
0.808344245,
0.0124641825,
-0.0344491862,
-0.030947119,
-0.1277945042,
0.8222700953,
-0.3120771945,
0.2712799907,
0.7747380137,
0.9659842253,
-0.135096401,
-0.6401429176,
-0.1545953304,
-0.3720981181,
-0.3304203153,
0.2554564476,
-0.6037855148,
0.8079683781,
0.0496773832,
-0.121117644,
0.0701154992,
0.4657622576,
0.1188287213,
0.4338425398,
0.7898874879,
0.6699730158,
0.6316410899,
-0.1394229531,
1.253614068,
-0.1419614553,
0.3836579323,
0.5823333263,
-0.289081037,
0.7743142843,
0.4655716419,
-0.3599325418,
0.5419313312,
0.6137422323,
0.1686583459,
0.2815544605,
0.0658805147,
-0.6022299528,
-0.2164096385,
-0.2026569098,
0.0502340347,
0.8758701682,
0.6240296364,
-0.3479670584,
-0.1127069294,
0.3313023448,
0.0657873377,
-0.0751989335,
-0.1255453527,
0.6925132275,
0.246737048,
-0.6577225327,
0.1914273649,
-0.2927313745,
0.6008988619,
-0.3030202389,
-0.1088947728,
-0.2270471752,
-0.0909057334,
-0.2405626923,
-1.0444533825,
0.5648288131,
0.3084596694,
-0.3006052673,
-0.3169762194,
0.8496383429,
0.083517313,
-0.3225434422,
0.7421140671,
0.3771936297,
0.2129848599,
-0.2683331668,
-0.472478658,
0.3712593615,
-0.231162563,
-0.6025314927,
0.1700355113,
0.5890155435,
0.0248339586,
0.7324690819,
0.3463668823,
-0.3577568829,
-0.1177193671,
0.2682684362,
0.8630882502,
-0.5757908821,
-0.2937267423,
-0.767835319,
0.8616502285,
-0.251979351,
-0.3437364101,
0.3235395849,
0.0716628879,
0.1146848276,
-0.3629383147,
0.6425082684,
-0.1349214166,
0.793556869,
-0.3097702563,
0.4430423379,
-0.3164384365,
-0.2634786069,
-0.7118446827,
-0.7876926064,
-0.3659760356,
0.9311999679,
-0.4199456871,
0.014333332,
0.6832158566,
0.8611770868,
-0.1105172709,
0.3921221793,
0.4139807522,
0.0979220346,
0.2891268134,
0.4106493294,
1.0338445902,
-0.3543894589,
-0.0872319043,
-0.1737952828,
-0.3687200248,
-0.1192397699,
-1.2281306982,
-0.721347034,
-0.8581487536,
-0.1502906382,
-0.1356742084,
-0.2593248785,
0.9638468027,
0.5957195163,
-0.9220226407,
0.0283389483,
-0.3066029549,
0.0338198915,
0.0760181025,
-0.3446539938,
0.4489671886,
-0.3004945815,
-0.8658140898,
0.2609705925,
0.2988133729,
0.2548978925,
-0.1275869906,
-0.1218991503,
-0.0435948782,
0.2607139349,
0.85514009,
-0.102861315,
-0.4790732861,
-0.9009844661,
-0.0221041404,
0.2618936002,
-0.1740457714,
0.742620945,
-0.6124830246,
0.0974539518,
0.126524359,
0.3098340034,
0.0558667257,
0.2782562077,
0.4276213348,
-0.8389375806,
0.0779076517,
0.4530101418,
0.4998469353,
0.3447318077,
-0.6278594136,
0.4455483556,
0.0731038973,
-0.7032270432,
-1.0749188662,
0.267160058,
-1.2025318146,
0.1665120274,
0.7182689309,
-0.3414269388,
-0.065695107,
-0.080772981,
-0.4766144753,
0.3164157867,
-0.4997822642,
0.9063689709,
0.6766889691,
-0.6838337779,
-0.3059806228,
0.1702468693,
0.4242549539,
0.3519757688,
-0.774530232,
-0.0775793046,
0.116801843,
-0.3875572085,
0.4346052706,
0.1918222606,
0.0320731774,
0.1237757504,
-0.0969245881,
0.3575887978,
0.5111552477,
-0.0456247218,
-0.2599566281,
0.1447093189,
-0.3271387517,
-0.0403757505
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03025v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03025v1
|
Training on Synthetic Data Beats Real Data in Multimodal Relation Extraction
| 2023-12-05T08:11:34 | 2023-12-05T08:11:34 |
Zilin Du, Haoxin Li, Xu Guo, Boyang Li
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
The task of multimodal relation extraction has attracted significant research
attention, but progress is constrained by the scarcity of available training
data. One natural thought is to extend existing datasets with cross-modal
generative models. In this paper, we consider a novel problem setting, where
only unimodal data, either text or image, are available during training. We aim
to train a multimodal classifier from synthetic data that perform well on real
multimodal test data. However, training with synthetic data suffers from two
obstacles: lack of data diversity and label information loss. To alleviate the
issues, we propose Mutual Information-aware Multimodal Iterated Relational dAta
GEneration (MI2RAGE), which applies Chained Cross-modal Generation (CCG) to
promote diversity in the generated data and exploits a teacher network to
select valuable training samples with high mutual information with the
ground-truth labels. Comparing our method to direct training on synthetic data,
we observed a significant improvement of 24.06% F1 with synthetic text and
26.42% F1 with synthetic images. Notably, our best model trained on completely
synthetic images outperforms prior state-of-the-art models trained on real
multimodal data by a margin of 3.76% in F1. Our codebase will be made available
upon acceptance.
|
[
-0.422508955,
-0.5693698525,
0.3259454668,
0.2300939858,
-0.322568208,
0.2457573563,
-0.2843801975,
-0.6048978567,
-0.0415940918,
0.0124348141,
-0.6074873209,
-0.1640987247,
-0.6073944569,
-0.005845183,
-0.119359076,
0.8651757836,
-0.0494558215,
0.2868662775,
-0.67142272,
-0.4116017222,
-0.3074426055,
-0.4044480622,
-0.108271867,
-0.1966321468,
0.5470761061,
0.3249199092,
0.6414657235,
0.4413067997,
0.2530020177,
0.3205857575,
0.5296697021,
0.7599672675,
-0.4668140113,
0.213932246,
-0.2639760673,
-0.4288747311,
0.0930255577,
0.1717247367,
0.6361281872,
0.4802077413,
0.130169943,
-0.0201271623,
-0.2477349639,
0.5950404406,
-0.7637450695,
0.4727564156,
-0.741531074,
0.2779635489,
-0.1864734292,
-0.3638209701,
-0.4899341464,
-0.0312676542,
-0.0443727896,
-0.810839951,
0.3780253232,
0.1310555488,
0.9128462076,
-0.0531039983,
-0.8505381942,
-0.1680988222,
-0.8753580451,
0.761708498,
0.0231778342,
0.8028265834,
0.3969717324,
0.45589903,
-0.0111490646,
-0.8317737579,
-0.9453157187,
-0.0837705731,
-0.1546574831,
0.4283843338,
-0.1895112395,
-0.1595903486,
0.2454001009,
0.3527643085,
-0.4487368762,
-0.4467887878,
-0.6024470925,
-0.3146749437,
0.5698283315,
0.0225527473,
0.4040913284,
-0.2654575706,
-0.8253289461,
-0.4604795277,
-0.5529765487,
-0.0091379927,
0.2093376219,
0.0795250311,
-0.1782713979,
0.6905606985,
-0.0164564997,
0.4669551849,
-0.1132536456,
-0.087908268,
0.4831885993,
-0.7313486934,
0.066831626,
-0.2453291416,
1.1518362761,
0.5418701172,
0.3179085255,
-0.302429527,
-0.1686006188,
0.3611661494,
0.0121409958,
-0.7806631327,
-0.31000337,
-0.3142087758,
-0.3360925615,
-0.0829630867,
0.2728365362,
-0.8491977453,
-0.0955141857,
-0.4816061556,
0.5198393464,
-0.5462296009,
-0.4183576703,
-0.408196032,
-0.2485950887,
-0.332247138,
0.15052782,
-0.9346022606,
-0.1848145574,
0.2962926924,
0.8420296907,
-0.0163838305,
-0.1186535135,
-0.3461257219,
0.2831935585,
-0.2315631211,
0.6160152555,
-0.7399145365,
-0.3525916338,
-0.2595639229,
0.0167301055,
-0.3980963528,
-0.6085544825,
0.2514839172,
-0.4731757939,
0.513015449,
-0.0376854688,
-0.3163437545,
-0.0785323307,
0.3513184488,
-0.8011911511,
0.9238273501,
0.3488485515,
-0.8878184557,
0.4475919902,
-0.3159989119,
-0.3307594061,
-0.3607616425,
-0.5291007161,
-0.5059267879,
-0.1182724759,
0.1803220063,
0.2694067955,
-0.5709836483,
0.442104727,
-0.4879746139,
-0.0846754164,
0.4463778138,
-0.6935150623,
0.4298531413,
0.2807969451,
-0.0464584418,
-0.0211076494,
-0.986517489,
0.006170271,
-0.0299755409,
-0.3622344136,
-0.4744384587,
-0.3328640759,
0.3688825071,
0.6813005805,
-0.2311072946,
-0.817530334,
0.2345805913,
-0.0476902053,
0.2207583338,
0.7525988221,
-0.087236993,
0.581445992,
-0.4918622673,
0.5882126689,
0.3775797188,
-0.0191057008,
-0.1726186574,
-0.4698646963,
-0.5750424266,
-0.6043559909,
0.3697613776,
0.3647700846,
-1.3188606501,
0.0390825383,
-0.4954180419,
-0.3850779831,
-0.5203854442,
0.2452210337,
0.4197236598,
0.4188468754,
0.4539914727,
-0.3080051839,
-0.7583602071,
-1.0446246862,
-0.0582083315,
0.0166022107,
0.1087321639,
0.35015288,
0.313375324,
-0.7454688549,
1.1186023951,
-0.2576512992,
-0.3322879672,
-0.2104296982,
0.3975732327,
-0.2399665415,
0.6398513913,
0.4804266393,
-1.0842283964,
-0.5606588721,
-0.0467626788,
-0.9961627722,
0.2065825611,
-0.3809524477,
-0.2542994916,
0.147946164,
0.0655825064,
-0.7567330599,
0.1632682085,
0.6015252471,
0.0161389485,
0.2124876082,
-0.1596315056,
0.0426083542,
-1.3767377138,
-0.1699287146,
0.0401749574,
-0.1905274838,
-0.4021933079,
-0.3336978853,
0.1947301328,
-0.1335385293,
-0.1250068843,
0.6256527305,
-0.6872643828,
-0.1355709136,
0.0575118735,
-0.16385144,
0.0872225389,
0.5699027777,
0.2037409544,
0.6865693927,
0.5061857104,
-0.3570467532,
0.5342490673,
0.3668612838,
-0.2374953181,
0.3961835802,
-0.0251292363,
0.0860323012,
-0.3204297125,
0.3532252312,
-0.9440208673,
-0.389739275,
0.3911304772,
-0.5319145918,
0.4378438294,
-0.0049630473,
-0.543078661,
-0.0061406363,
-0.3650940657,
0.7123789191,
0.2459668219,
-0.8776875138,
0.7540098429,
0.1816300899,
0.129445985,
-0.552528739,
-0.6134302616,
-0.1257836074,
0.1097132713,
-0.777387917,
0.3987650871,
0.0145243062,
-0.0117727909,
0.0784770846,
-0.2456549704,
-0.3770451844,
-0.3242310882,
0.5033581257,
0.3235440552,
-0.0130554149,
0.5054505467,
0.1830616295,
-0.1533416212,
0.0424785018,
0.2805528343,
0.5202662349,
0.2409730554,
-0.1725727469,
-0.5467607975,
0.3150977194,
0.5869489312,
-0.1917933226,
0.7398285866,
1.0734415054,
-0.2149386704,
-0.1616646796,
-0.2316325903,
-0.2761507928,
-0.4678740501,
0.3897419572,
-0.5173712969,
-0.6079237461,
0.0937352404,
-0.0786871761,
-0.1684997082,
0.213129729,
0.3951131403,
-0.1955545694,
1.0388028622,
0.5224366784,
0.1589727849,
0.6613516212,
-0.4527767301,
0.0977467224,
-0.6400486231,
-0.8544614315,
0.1154474691,
-0.2851835191,
-0.7394450903,
-0.6375312805,
0.5949887037,
0.0785132796,
0.2792909145,
0.2887066901,
-0.1614036113,
0.1633897424,
0.5610803366,
0.4910212457,
0.3735420704,
0.5540047884,
-0.1292445362,
-0.3198291659,
-0.8354002237,
0.084230952,
1.2293037176,
0.1062393114,
0.7756152749,
0.0435843654,
0.4626632929,
0.1798273027,
0.4818300605,
-0.5300472975,
0.4414197505,
0.0800990388,
-0.6159854531,
0.204204604,
-0.901982367,
-0.8025273681,
0.5164283514,
-0.7003272772,
-0.1473387033,
0.4145306647,
0.1989147365,
0.1499007493,
0.2891767919,
-0.6738771796,
0.6731971502,
-0.2602003515,
-0.7132512927,
-0.209761411,
-0.7998427749,
0.5756776929,
-0.1993539482,
0.3797042966,
-0.078105025,
0.1702863127,
0.6098117828,
-0.2956240475,
0.5661722422,
-0.1275923401,
0.0896441489,
0.1743039042,
-0.0234485287,
0.3257948458,
0.2165960371,
0.2357391715,
0.097753495,
-0.1743421257,
-0.3118890524,
-0.8392688632,
0.6196406484,
-0.8519586921,
-0.0656153038,
-0.515088439,
-0.9746996164,
-0.5194038153,
-0.1182577163,
0.3845581412,
0.5724401474,
0.0727851391,
0.4107571244,
0.3526783288,
-0.1607881337,
0.4890069962,
0.1285725087,
-0.0759068951,
-0.8458661437,
1.2444336414,
0.0418765284,
0.4666343629,
0.3501343131,
0.0324301235,
-0.4381656051,
0.2716767192,
-0.6589429975,
0.2173974663,
-0.5713057518,
-0.2019407749,
-0.8561000228,
-0.1414549798,
-0.3361518681,
0.2004565448,
-0.4828300774,
-0.6559232473,
-0.2980557084,
-0.0444674753,
0.2257586271,
0.2763601542,
-0.3990042806,
0.1131048054,
-1.1044912338,
0.4462762773,
0.4790355563,
-0.0072059445,
-0.2366046757,
-0.2540958226,
-0.0473260246,
0.3670229018,
-0.3214596808,
-0.8428788185,
0.4488362968,
0.4998344779,
0.3726581931,
0.5342290998,
-0.0326717831,
0.701317966,
-0.0543261878,
0.2887327969,
0.5037155747,
-0.4697769284,
0.1281824857,
-0.2748848796,
0.078374356,
0.4861564934,
0.807708323,
-0.4546436667,
0.1541654915,
-0.4633297324,
-0.65203619,
0.6748973131,
0.4599955082,
0.2175800949,
0.0116098253,
0.0232132804,
0.2538456023,
0.4117364883,
-0.9281215072,
-0.0883949101,
-0.3507077992,
-0.4297359586,
0.01743754,
-0.2114490122,
-0.0715532824,
-0.48562181,
0.4688856602,
-0.0588157177,
0.5302525759,
0.1122936383,
-0.3761652112,
-0.180504933,
0.1732947677,
0.3728557229,
0.455131948,
-0.075468868,
0.4081395566,
-0.2324719578,
-0.2691032887,
0.3023201227,
0.2710142732,
-0.1964457482,
0.2131168991,
0.4775005579,
0.8487714529,
0.0772542655,
-0.8185479641,
0.6113789082,
-0.0086517558,
-0.1391738206,
-0.1686699837,
0.0091890646,
-0.0489336029,
0.3454293311,
0.1536360681,
0.3873559833,
-0.0096993325,
-0.8858550787,
0.4218146801,
0.5798799396,
-0.3544404805,
-0.5477280617,
0.5982387662,
0.0308330655,
0.1274416447,
0.7462443113,
-0.1930193305,
-0.4636303782,
0.4521559179,
0.8644325137,
0.3595757186,
-0.1361813396,
0.4153021276,
0.5115220547,
0.0245406106,
0.0628190935,
0.2446545511,
-0.5262278914,
-0.9919480085,
0.0812675282,
-0.4778065979,
-0.1796495616,
-0.0964490399,
-0.5149148703,
0.0557852313,
-0.5185388327,
-0.0934872627,
-0.225847736,
-0.4432257712,
-0.4186372757,
0.3239322305,
-0.0442974642,
0.3024083674,
-0.8821978569,
0.9898880124,
0.59747684,
-0.5575907826,
-0.5408918262,
-0.288998723,
-0.1743563265,
-0.6442307234,
0.938280642,
0.4930952191,
0.0131644011,
-0.1565515101,
-0.377368927,
-0.5724911094,
1.1392726898,
0.3415829837,
-0.6864315271,
-0.0782212242,
0.4591196477,
0.3111341894,
-0.3390218318,
0.3221918643,
0.0731215477,
0.378097266,
0.3934683502,
-0.5856713653,
-0.0698922724,
-0.6176614165,
0.042930834,
0.2410561889,
-0.6733794212,
0.9838358164,
-0.1050780788,
-0.4162155986,
-0.0922212452,
0.4898858368,
0.2594273984,
0.6031354666,
0.640902698,
0.5884696841,
0.3889384866,
-0.0948124751,
0.8464489579,
-0.1463252157,
0.3836693466,
1.1995891333,
-0.174926877,
0.4807913303,
0.5805932283,
0.0711451173,
0.4076510668,
0.6339842677,
-0.1705812365,
0.7104805112,
-0.2865920365,
-0.6381732225,
-0.5011770725,
-0.3096572757,
-0.4458284378,
0.5131382942,
0.0821966827,
-0.6550235152,
-0.2874074578,
0.4503483772,
-0.1714918315,
0.0630887449,
0.2013800591,
0.6112022996,
-0.0272342823,
-0.3666886091,
0.460541755,
0.0318642743,
0.6789700389,
-0.5310689211,
-0.2811394036,
-0.2495367676,
0.2348126024,
-0.1756990999,
-0.2629333138,
0.1586965621,
-0.3284635544,
-0.3583412766,
-0.1766582429,
0.6706528664,
-1.0026115179,
-0.4790374041,
0.3394195437,
0.3489922583,
-0.2698583603,
-0.1299369335,
-0.5030782819,
-0.0817515701,
0.0044997642,
-0.0247042533,
0.443852663,
0.3035429716,
-0.1692165136,
0.6492045522,
1.0183062553,
-0.2251948118,
0.2405500859,
-0.2486537993,
1.096177578,
-0.4084761739,
-0.1261636764,
-0.7358167171,
0.4522487819,
-0.2397881448,
-0.2008786052,
0.59281528,
0.827470839,
1.0404936075,
-0.1965579242,
0.7513282299,
-0.1385689825,
0.1904371083,
-0.508408308,
0.5296570659,
-0.6898167729,
-0.034448076,
-0.0661958903,
-1.0274343491,
-0.0577004626,
0.5939893126,
0.1158393472,
0.0761988685,
0.5904741287,
1.0850621462,
-0.5278578997,
0.0044225031,
0.1839753985,
-0.1213265136,
0.2918466032,
0.6344420314,
1.1152024269,
-0.6537278891,
0.5203253627,
-0.6974726319,
-0.0731133372,
0.0443863086,
-0.403699398,
-0.9711769819,
-0.7942920327,
0.0024053447,
-0.2122028768,
-0.0263421796,
1.2337087393,
0.8435266018,
-0.3919079602,
0.0344219431,
-0.0382682085,
-0.1228491068,
0.232866779,
-0.2383646667,
0.05805647,
-0.0890460014,
-0.690438509,
0.5312694907,
0.0511355326,
0.249079138,
-0.0675320104,
-0.1787016094,
-0.4683026969,
-0.1154753491,
0.677754283,
0.1372510493,
-0.2537393868,
-0.100885585,
-0.1937381774,
-0.1073245928,
0.2635590732,
0.801512897,
-0.6546308398,
0.9779557586,
0.5785511732,
0.6944330931,
0.7539146543,
0.1550504714,
0.5523842573,
-0.963781476,
0.4394180775,
-0.0209890977,
0.3374536335,
0.3415401578,
-0.1835303754,
0.5885329247,
0.8339173198,
-0.1339335293,
-0.664721787,
0.3413071334,
-1.0453644991,
-0.1531561911,
1.1726762056,
-0.0093129855,
-0.0639788657,
0.1829090118,
-0.3383054733,
0.5284042358,
-0.3661770225,
0.8147082925,
0.2790461183,
-0.1313692927,
-0.3745300174,
-0.1769565344,
0.2660904229,
0.3476039469,
-0.9930437207,
-0.3146308959,
0.8489097357,
0.3442471623,
0.2529743314,
0.4629701078,
-0.0739705786,
0.2594533861,
0.1173083857,
0.1908247918,
-0.4513482153,
-0.6877944469,
0.0666044801,
0.2525716126,
-0.4573473036,
-0.4166246057
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02554v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02554v2
|
ULMA: Unified Language Model Alignment with Human Demonstration and Point-wise Preference
| 2023-12-05T07:52:12 | 2024-02-26T08:51:03 |
Tianchi Cai, Xierui Song, Jiyan Jiang, Fei Teng, Jinjie Gu, Guannan Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Aligning language models to human expectations, e.g., being helpful and
harmless, has become a pressing challenge for large language models. A typical
alignment procedure consists of supervised fine-tuning and preference learning.
Most preference learning methods, such as RLHF and DPO, depend on pairwise
preference data, which inadequately address scenarios where human feedback is
point-wise, leading to potential information loss and suboptimal performance.
Addressing this gap, we introduce Point-wise Direct Preference Optimization, a
novel preference learning method designed to harness point-wise feedback
effectively. Our work also uncovers a novel connection between supervised
fine-tuning and point-wise preference learning, culminating in Unified Language
Model Alignment, a single-step method that unifies the alignment with human
demonstrations and point-wise preferences. Extensive experiments on point-wise
preference datasets with binary or continuous labels validate the effectiveness
of our methods. Our code and a new dataset with high-quality demonstration
samples on harmlessness are released.
|
[
-0.1719881296,
-0.6046672463,
0.5024365783,
-0.0911071673,
-0.3015612364,
-0.2813330889,
-0.2009842843,
-0.2020969242,
-0.0966919363,
0.5436176658,
-0.2640580237,
-0.574159205,
-0.2889732718,
-0.2020271868,
-0.1942374706,
0.8836237192,
0.1831613034,
-0.0373030491,
-0.3528900146,
-0.2386711389,
-0.5305913687,
-0.5502032042,
-0.5914629698,
-0.5123006701,
0.6768932343,
0.8080430627,
0.8105380535,
0.9802321196,
0.3850055039,
0.2274422497,
0.355790168,
0.1626146436,
-0.3589387536,
0.0601733401,
-0.2052689791,
-0.1483422369,
-0.6432833076,
0.0650344193,
0.5802105069,
0.8461204171,
-0.2012177557,
0.0333158299,
0.2118780166,
0.8691049814,
-0.7088740468,
-0.1193284914,
-0.7034201622,
-0.1726937443,
-0.1330578923,
-0.0890719071,
-0.5998159647,
-0.4903957546,
0.008246718,
-0.6623477936,
-0.120459713,
-0.0683211163,
0.8492860794,
0.4474595785,
-0.5176172256,
0.1537765265,
-0.671906054,
0.9043300748,
-0.6791930199,
0.3247903287,
0.4456822574,
0.1799169779,
-0.2587422132,
-0.27548033,
-0.4763719141,
-0.1644919813,
-0.069826588,
-0.102225244,
-0.4409390688,
0.246079281,
-0.0915733352,
-0.0955082625,
-0.5251778364,
0.4651655257,
0.1930191815,
-0.1585186273,
0.8713988066,
-0.0385692716,
0.3002322316,
-0.1721938401,
-0.3307547271,
-0.2404718995,
-0.9747080207,
0.3814982176,
0.5416861773,
0.6248755455,
0.1181049794,
0.4712063074,
-0.3751506507,
0.7869118452,
0.2211283594,
-0.1424153,
0.1329724342,
0.025008494,
-0.253198266,
-0.0331790186,
0.9769363999,
0.7683079243,
0.3926132023,
-0.0417061187,
-0.0769621581,
0.1948745847,
0.3187089562,
-0.4907850921,
-0.3662124574,
0.1257805675,
-0.1812967807,
-0.4277469218,
0.1161908209,
-0.7178965807,
-0.4117591381,
-0.5054784417,
0.4286800027,
-0.1555844694,
-0.3042339981,
0.2272727787,
0.4874198139,
-0.1657050252,
0.1842285395,
-1.2252521515,
0.0287705064,
0.7003722191,
0.2895682752,
-0.2640743554,
-0.4241471291,
-0.6486341357,
0.1428568661,
-0.3708660603,
0.8833139539,
-0.6045427322,
-0.3365737498,
-0.1601328105,
-0.1004039943,
-0.0796168819,
-0.4820537269,
0.7571070194,
-0.0700559914,
0.2300724983,
-0.2578758597,
-0.3793051541,
-0.3252430856,
-0.1272871047,
-0.128241688,
1.1389776468,
0.0103534106,
-0.6360486746,
0.4251579642,
-0.6859287024,
-0.3071912229,
-0.2123225778,
-0.1784085184,
-0.4222212136,
0.1947657317,
0.2457148731,
0.6621566415,
0.1234833002,
0.4872267544,
-0.4522607625,
-0.260507524,
0.196012482,
-0.3205774128,
0.6821315885,
0.2761944234,
-0.3804520965,
0.6742696762,
-0.7341054082,
-0.1401712894,
0.3390843272,
-0.0684321299,
-0.7332196832,
0.0749410614,
-0.3077876568,
0.1847103238,
0.3371035159,
-0.3776671886,
0.5069085956,
-0.3280271888,
0.026958691,
1.0152119398,
-0.2009842396,
0.7073346376,
-0.1512339264,
0.3556704819,
-0.1132404283,
0.5711448193,
0.2569380105,
-0.4786047935,
-0.7307703495,
-0.0195377003,
0.2307633013,
0.3021990657,
-0.0825707838,
0.6913563609,
-0.1944657862,
-0.2387910485,
-0.6889355779,
0.3797908425,
0.5511141419,
1.0440307856,
0.1890159845,
-0.2460965663,
-0.6154299378,
-1.0844138861,
-0.1054620817,
-0.3792907298,
-0.0853020698,
0.1366974562,
-0.1186389327,
-0.3867270947,
1.0113195181,
-0.2986291349,
-0.2134978175,
-0.1449003071,
-0.0372091681,
0.030511491,
0.4095088542,
0.4535768926,
-0.6340071559,
-0.4679988921,
0.0840642452,
-0.5482425094,
-0.3313534856,
0.1593675762,
-0.1765562892,
0.4807121456,
0.2600908577,
-0.1517124027,
0.2567820847,
0.7420197129,
-0.3087978661,
0.1826744378,
-0.4375040531,
0.0513290539,
-1.0814166069,
0.2159897685,
0.096284084,
-0.1612927765,
-0.7162041664,
0.1222484857,
0.1968025416,
0.2232324928,
-0.3883897364,
0.6533592343,
-0.3804617226,
0.0221713483,
-0.4517865479,
0.1858380288,
0.0035291039,
0.5354745984,
0.100140579,
0.5366036892,
0.6083211303,
-0.5331520438,
0.1554688066,
0.117261976,
-0.0224143527,
0.494440496,
-0.4573602378,
0.5070031881,
-0.0022413833,
-0.0930763111,
-0.9832454324,
-0.2953819633,
0.1748768687,
-0.4414378703,
0.2906599343,
-0.2530762851,
-0.2823995054,
-0.2196948826,
-0.2957294583,
0.2576496601,
0.4898269176,
-0.6612368822,
0.3763890266,
0.698520422,
-0.0908792019,
-0.8206883073,
-0.1730075926,
-0.2604446411,
-0.4869261086,
-0.3075808287,
-0.0180381425,
-0.1306853443,
-0.2685296237,
-0.3808425963,
-0.1350496411,
0.2574884295,
0.3410743475,
0.5656119585,
0.4818619788,
0.1272414327,
0.067455776,
0.126383692,
-0.4362437725,
-0.1647758186,
-0.1685709953,
0.4655562937,
-0.2591189742,
-0.4726401567,
-0.4539462626,
0.3758688867,
0.225613296,
-0.1222456247,
0.085866034,
0.3521248698,
-0.3765071929,
0.1490057111,
-0.3972505033,
-0.0842992067,
-0.4882862568,
0.1613983959,
-0.3077888191,
-0.724206686,
0.1076240316,
0.1126759797,
0.2550054789,
0.4009563029,
0.3850808442,
-0.2026685476,
1.6253194809,
0.8603345156,
-0.3054394722,
0.3016370237,
0.1351281255,
0.2547872066,
-0.5981809497,
-0.2475848794,
-0.6766024828,
-0.3080930412,
-0.3390994966,
0.0357970335,
0.1844683737,
0.5324091911,
-0.4429447353,
0.4818652868,
-0.7239479423,
0.6433218122,
0.6753216982,
-0.0643269569,
0.4635905921,
0.080487892,
-0.4796597362,
-0.2057490945,
-0.4507029057,
-0.706938684,
1.2095633745,
0.3233905137,
0.8711520433,
0.083138153,
0.8160114288,
-0.0135709532,
0.2954714298,
-0.7717039585,
0.5579906702,
-0.3249357641,
-0.2585217953,
-0.4797541201,
-0.3465562761,
-1.1540373564,
-0.0073101637,
-0.2377982438,
-1.10460186,
0.1016117036,
0.5225918889,
-0.5842326283,
0.1841493249,
-0.8734036088,
0.9132524133,
-0.4560854733,
-0.0923980922,
-0.0627300665,
-0.8982938528,
0.1259445399,
0.0630063117,
0.2509534657,
-0.3144789934,
0.0549590215,
0.6410446763,
-0.0001510913,
0.8225744367,
-0.2474269122,
-0.4115216434,
-0.1806302518,
0.2876562178,
0.3095999956,
-0.0236983337,
0.0044230125,
0.1472772509,
-0.1658499837,
-0.4127044082,
-0.5031011701,
0.9161864519,
-0.7701994777,
-0.6625959277,
-0.2105911821,
-0.7572482228,
-0.518563211,
0.394105792,
0.1388007253,
0.2612528503,
-0.1722192466,
-0.0747109652,
0.5292941332,
0.0702293366,
0.4748381972,
0.5563292503,
-0.6154732704,
-0.2388519794,
1.0120776892,
-0.4609856009,
0.3331809044,
0.5731855035,
0.4956911802,
-0.6609788537,
-0.6826544404,
-0.4232790172,
0.1722959578,
-0.6221169233,
-0.1247396991,
-0.520200789,
0.1751338691,
-0.7024769187,
-0.3052404225,
-0.4859754443,
-0.4713715315,
-0.2784906626,
-0.1742041856,
0.1233624369,
0.8549921513,
-0.3529216349,
0.2429987192,
-0.6808574796,
0.2854631245,
0.5492589474,
0.3321840465,
-0.2903656065,
-0.5114561319,
0.014615003,
0.2804726362,
-0.4336087108,
-0.5350279808,
0.2940184474,
0.1030767262,
0.6297103763,
1.0045096874,
0.1921175867,
0.5449268818,
-0.2725616395,
0.4843473434,
0.2669498324,
-0.7770204544,
0.7738839984,
-0.4945161939,
0.1454187632,
0.7900066972,
0.5948450565,
-0.5357528925,
-0.1342979074,
-0.5764306784,
-0.6341389418,
0.5063211322,
-0.39696908,
0.0922266915,
0.1536817849,
0.2178857923,
0.2852806449,
-0.0750261173,
-0.7008842826,
-0.4755818248,
-0.0997802094,
-0.3035830259,
-0.3249208033,
-0.1128711179,
-0.4016320109,
-0.4891177416,
0.7250421643,
-0.4783090949,
-0.0058284341,
-0.2616995573,
-0.0676896051,
-0.468003571,
0.4100821614,
0.6929827929,
0.7645934224,
-0.4298560321,
0.155213967,
-0.1798332185,
-0.2366462201,
0.3495983183,
0.2445582449,
-0.3819307685,
-0.2423129231,
-0.1550500542,
0.8017783165,
0.3421720862,
-0.3724532723,
0.5937409401,
-0.1699212939,
-0.0099071236,
0.1809279919,
0.2176697403,
0.1597297639,
-0.1541223675,
0.3182169497,
0.0332638994,
0.0314331539,
-0.4872213602,
0.2258467674,
0.630267024,
-0.631116271,
-0.3680919707,
0.6450977325,
0.2003074437,
-0.326239109,
0.3837397099,
0.0176711269,
-0.2148332447,
0.1188187897,
0.4663034379,
0.7430272698,
-0.5918986201,
0.4379989207,
0.3486885428,
0.0623299815,
0.0289070029,
0.0108406134,
-0.0842048004,
-0.8245079517,
-0.1555647105,
-0.5210391283,
-0.485711962,
0.0571297146,
-0.8932818174,
0.262955308,
-0.2297185361,
-0.0033479554,
-0.054034207,
0.006828628,
-0.2409378886,
0.1518680304,
0.040364597,
0.4664323926,
-0.869544208,
1.2437702417,
0.7278903723,
-0.2113211006,
-0.9957334399,
-0.1035836861,
0.1968168616,
-0.9958258271,
0.1719776839,
0.1714199334,
-0.1568057239,
0.1376344264,
-0.4929648638,
-0.6303620338,
0.8507322073,
0.7667662501,
-0.6362468004,
-0.1316442043,
0.1949220896,
0.3762547374,
-0.4403382838,
0.0051856344,
0.5989141464,
0.4610046744,
-0.0178995449,
-0.835105896,
0.0456409976,
-0.1231334433,
-0.0773130804,
0.4235903621,
-0.5328701735,
0.2614364922,
-0.5896158218,
-0.3057763278,
0.043276839,
0.6138718128,
0.3082849085,
0.2262718678,
0.7516076565,
0.7613154054,
0.7500550747,
-0.1858335286,
0.8836628199,
0.0137645788,
0.2491211742,
1.2043693066,
-0.4210191369,
0.9697839022,
0.733676374,
-0.1289085299,
0.3446130157,
0.6827604175,
0.421587497,
0.5113118887,
-0.0313474722,
-0.1394128501,
-0.46560058,
-0.2863982022,
-0.2916824818,
0.5833933949,
0.0312925354,
-0.0502867326,
-0.2303453088,
-0.1363167763,
0.0067650755,
0.3349624574,
-0.1672550291,
1.0008409023,
-0.0354174636,
-0.8752097487,
0.7311907411,
-0.2133568376,
0.8022282124,
-0.5184302926,
0.0309065357,
-0.4377464056,
0.2200065702,
-0.1412327886,
-0.6611768603,
0.1370427012,
-0.1355481744,
-0.0262054857,
-0.2454799563,
0.5791081786,
-0.4472782016,
-0.2417123616,
0.4806376994,
0.1835995615,
0.0613834374,
-0.0638497621,
-0.717972517,
-0.2337733805,
0.1845659763,
-0.0342143066,
0.7578734159,
0.0746015757,
-0.1172127798,
0.6894605756,
0.78405267,
0.0065929373,
-0.1815581322,
0.3565487564,
0.5704228878,
-0.4768640995,
-0.2914128304,
-0.7690889239,
0.4529232383,
0.1412779093,
-0.3747342229,
0.7510545254,
0.4206714034,
0.9630024433,
0.0876148567,
0.5304723382,
0.2769647837,
0.6213512421,
-0.4391773939,
0.6907510757,
-0.6342347264,
0.0780527368,
-0.4197312891,
-0.9899090528,
-0.557031095,
0.5095476508,
-0.077153787,
-0.1778907031,
0.5110411644,
0.9131705761,
-0.1968043149,
-0.2135517597,
0.6954131126,
-0.1147033572,
0.0938017368,
0.6897735596,
0.6260994673,
-0.1518467516,
0.5038862228,
-0.6954308748,
-0.407175988,
-0.2073235214,
-1.1959781647,
-0.6565052271,
-0.7904863954,
-0.3128982484,
-0.1291775256,
-0.1003271565,
0.973017633,
0.8096314669,
-0.8945736289,
-0.2990460694,
-0.0438945778,
0.0972223133,
-0.1518569142,
-0.2098508328,
0.4265896082,
-0.0299911778,
-0.8188630342,
0.5423688889,
0.3947942555,
0.2369885147,
-0.0969489142,
-0.3455524743,
-0.2462883741,
-0.153785333,
0.3129315078,
0.6118718982,
-0.8472567201,
-0.4955611229,
0.0383505858,
-0.2858410478,
0.2919140756,
0.6832200885,
-0.4074718058,
0.4351031184,
0.3077577055,
0.6089293957,
-0.1070085615,
0.1786080152,
0.7927783728,
-0.7576929331,
0.1107931733,
-0.0086884173,
0.5377104282,
0.5306279063,
-0.4402885735,
0.3562266231,
-0.0892321616,
-0.7297480702,
-0.7046453953,
0.2990648448,
-1.2402187586,
-0.0467263721,
1.2165961266,
-0.1770837754,
-0.0221954193,
-0.0840721503,
-0.3906764388,
0.354817301,
-0.6115992665,
0.9001479745,
0.3132170141,
-0.2991530895,
-0.0934790373,
-0.1450749934,
0.5337708592,
0.715867579,
-0.8752782345,
0.2285189033,
0.593310535,
0.3045143485,
0.0107011534,
0.6947303414,
-0.0988108888,
0.2530277967,
-0.6132916808,
0.2657386661,
-0.1216714159,
-0.5889605284,
-0.902861774,
-0.1121814847,
0.4418076575,
-0.2614324391
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02549v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02549v1
|
DemaFormer: Damped Exponential Moving Average Transformer with Energy-Based Modeling for Temporal Language Grounding
| 2023-12-05T07:37:21 | 2023-12-05T07:37:21 |
Thong Nguyen, Xiaobao Wu, Xinshuai Dong, Cong-Duy Nguyen, See-Kiong Ng, Luu Anh Tuan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Temporal Language Grounding seeks to localize video moments that semantically
correspond to a natural language query. Recent advances employ the attention
mechanism to learn the relations between video moments and the text query.
However, naive attention might not be able to appropriately capture such
relations, resulting in ineffective distributions where target video moments
are difficult to separate from the remaining ones. To resolve the issue, we
propose an energy-based model framework to explicitly learn moment-query
distributions. Moreover, we propose DemaFormer, a novel Transformer-based
architecture that utilizes exponential moving average with a learnable damping
factor to effectively encode moment-query inputs. Comprehensive experiments on
four public temporal language grounding datasets showcase the superiority of
our methods over the state-of-the-art baselines.
|
[
-0.1618924141,
-0.9956672788,
0.4672257006,
0.4192100763,
-0.241941005,
0.0611991771,
0.0133335115,
-0.0533060022,
0.2827638388,
0.1938553751,
-0.4730911255,
-0.5287885666,
-0.8030363917,
-0.1548880637,
-0.6551727653,
0.4177212417,
-0.0138542559,
-0.1523281336,
0.1490675509,
-0.5049320459,
-0.1682258695,
-0.3881343007,
-0.731438756,
-0.5051574111,
0.125240773,
0.0679944009,
1.0026119947,
0.6458052993,
0.4929385483,
0.2409022897,
-0.0723554492,
-0.3824000657,
-0.3856209219,
0.1213552877,
-0.1807480454,
-0.4731618464,
-0.3583124876,
-0.0482407548,
0.8693884611,
0.668708086,
-0.4345391095,
0.179997474,
-0.6859053373,
0.8218179345,
-0.9334666729,
0.1126853079,
-0.5992045999,
0.554284215,
0.1660395563,
-0.6356184483,
-0.3025556803,
-0.2272365093,
-0.2901418805,
-0.0974146426,
0.4637799859,
0.0191080719,
0.9548385143,
0.7816098332,
-0.5576196313,
0.1851520538,
-0.9630792737,
0.8185750246,
-0.5635518432,
1.0750520229,
0.5159776807,
0.5537135005,
0.2807082534,
-0.6727672815,
-0.6505764723,
-0.0721309856,
0.1425855607,
0.2734040618,
-0.354270488,
0.271805346,
0.45092085,
0.3537404537,
-0.304063946,
-0.064286828,
0.1114977673,
0.322116524,
0.0453525744,
0.3383838236,
0.3375871778,
-0.235286355,
-0.3795212209,
-0.274739325,
-0.3029821515,
-0.0231883004,
0.454502821,
-0.0968954489,
-0.2758129537,
0.4085848033,
-0.1640485674,
0.5128875971,
0.4056924582,
-0.1956247538,
0.0395189859,
0.4230964482,
-0.5500049591,
0.2459508032,
0.5788106322,
0.5813674331,
0.0049420372,
-0.3392370939,
-0.308999002,
0.0185689777,
0.1675014347,
-1.1692962646,
-0.2981190681,
0.2575024068,
-0.4533898532,
-0.2151622176,
0.0524292104,
-0.9720488191,
0.1384822875,
-0.5082665086,
0.3308870792,
-0.3042673767,
-0.4183975756,
0.3171228468,
-0.2098891437,
0.2674313188,
-0.0958401784,
-1.1557703018,
0.5030064583,
0.3950415254,
0.8311837912,
0.1641359478,
-0.0367811397,
-0.411095351,
0.4025781751,
-0.1442914903,
0.5808947086,
-1.0456753969,
-0.3734565973,
-0.0726783574,
0.2536184192,
-0.4255591035,
-0.2829203904,
0.5027894378,
-0.9925339222,
0.3538550436,
0.107014887,
-0.1200529039,
-0.2682440281,
0.1164072454,
-0.6604260802,
1.2634278536,
0.1528051645,
-0.8941533566,
0.3830827475,
-0.640865922,
-0.3654159009,
-0.3445505798,
-0.0679953843,
-0.3826578856,
0.4175962508,
0.413308531,
0.3896697462,
-0.2285333574,
0.4638599753,
0.1029635519,
-0.3058436215,
-0.0194061566,
-1.2349222898,
0.3547485173,
0.2641996741,
-0.6445307732,
-0.2657044232,
-1.1084619761,
-0.1816251576,
0.2209274322,
-0.2536584437,
-0.1368615329,
0.3428043723,
0.0500132628,
0.2189270705,
-0.1694203317,
-0.316216141,
-0.1636034548,
-0.569699347,
0.2940541208,
0.4056967497,
0.3812730014,
0.6380962133,
-0.0303232465,
0.7359540462,
0.0245855674,
0.0610642955,
-0.449867934,
0.2050592154,
-0.9094879031,
0.0017234224,
0.1010993049,
0.5046957135,
-0.4515667558,
0.2308866829,
-0.7751505375,
-0.3126586974,
-0.4119992852,
-0.2885436118,
0.09762609,
0.4502923489,
0.6257487535,
0.3409866989,
-0.2295303345,
-0.6890994906,
-0.0914165378,
-0.1139702424,
-0.2949241102,
0.288187772,
0.1196437031,
-0.1729350686,
0.9311882854,
-0.5926321745,
-0.100213781,
0.213825956,
0.2541967034,
0.170829311,
0.2414913625,
0.890604198,
-1.1172822714,
-0.3221560419,
-0.1311722696,
-0.7594107985,
-0.1749902815,
-0.3058846295,
0.1435435414,
-0.0872400478,
0.5610858798,
-0.5683829188,
0.169990167,
0.7146819234,
-0.3579861224,
0.0769826099,
-0.1259111613,
0.6436079144,
-0.9691151977,
-0.0188837554,
-0.0980678201,
-0.394790858,
-0.3463196754,
-0.1360451579,
0.0891188532,
-0.5755463243,
-0.7206117511,
0.4136302173,
-0.5279582739,
0.1902252883,
-0.5050746202,
0.0704103485,
-0.009925453,
0.6102265716,
-0.0010799785,
0.6400795579,
0.6435449719,
-0.7651103735,
0.2507114112,
0.0411343724,
0.2401727736,
0.6901129484,
-0.7567549348,
0.2694953382,
-0.4122669101,
0.0470304489,
-0.6312987208,
-0.3373500705,
-0.0556264818,
-0.3387659192,
0.5985301733,
-0.5299713612,
-0.3619150817,
-0.2058900744,
-0.1124186069,
0.4764561355,
0.7215729356,
-0.8274627328,
1.1713461876,
0.5427447557,
0.0985977873,
-0.5000117421,
-0.6074929237,
0.2951791286,
-0.5217624307,
-0.7149307728,
0.5229438543,
0.3799301386,
-0.3644403219,
-0.1079541072,
-0.5255922079,
-0.0784336999,
0.1193033904,
0.4347129166,
-0.5220200419,
-0.0680172145,
0.4155109525,
0.1832588166,
-0.456900835,
0.393565625,
-0.3532966673,
0.4574548006,
0.194596976,
-0.6919206977,
-0.4033561945,
0.4059765935,
0.8107316494,
0.0113409786,
0.7979835272,
0.7062968016,
-0.5589321256,
-0.1337274909,
-0.5949395299,
-0.274397701,
-0.5345470905,
0.3156600893,
-0.3677254021,
-0.5470283628,
0.3544248343,
-0.3460626602,
-0.0541136041,
0.4484479725,
0.4937539995,
-0.0968742669,
1.2022233009,
1.0445569754,
-0.057756003,
0.9687094092,
-0.3670003712,
0.0886961147,
-0.3646720648,
-0.1061220691,
-0.4219221473,
-0.4158791304,
-0.3626428545,
-0.5028191209,
0.2965579927,
0.2174602598,
-0.1696959585,
0.1925812662,
-0.3107355535,
0.5671923161,
0.0301109403,
0.0316021591,
-0.0158308726,
0.0271571837,
0.0199832767,
-0.2407746017,
-0.5195348263,
-0.5949627757,
0.4555800855,
0.4134978056,
1.0154086351,
0.0991609246,
0.2447642237,
0.356587708,
-0.0906815827,
-0.6864113212,
0.3894924819,
0.1576022953,
-0.2297217995,
-0.2339051217,
-0.3874971867,
-0.7087012529,
0.3941156864,
0.1266018301,
-0.6289574504,
0.1247318164,
0.1212013289,
0.0690139383,
0.5206295848,
-0.463042289,
0.711792469,
-0.2501709759,
-0.3031282127,
-0.4634164572,
-0.753418982,
-0.1544500291,
0.081316337,
0.225244537,
-0.464704752,
-0.047597643,
0.8543149233,
-0.158732757,
0.7791626453,
-0.5273268819,
0.0258633886,
0.361828357,
0.0655134842,
0.6704502106,
0.2743326426,
-0.2219080627,
0.0423184708,
-0.2941777408,
-0.5060480237,
-0.8535776734,
0.6190468669,
-0.471167624,
-0.8477240205,
-0.2224642932,
-0.2517189682,
0.0037540598,
-0.0404431596,
0.0266691875,
0.4727132618,
-0.2654632032,
0.4079077244,
0.7930762172,
0.1949488074,
0.9448590875,
0.808437705,
-0.0239506289,
-0.4936488271,
0.8142475486,
-0.0069859992,
0.0820691586,
1.0999536514,
0.1008000299,
-0.2809747159,
-0.4076639414,
-0.1859565973,
-0.0495934337,
-0.8545744419,
-0.1602156907,
-1.3205983639,
0.1827340573,
-0.2408745289,
-0.326338768,
-0.5072643757,
-0.5903550386,
-0.2328549922,
-0.6678487659,
0.4858494997,
0.0000757051,
0.1014169157,
0.6550526619,
-0.9651551843,
0.6101768613,
0.35631302,
0.2635842264,
-0.1808884144,
-0.736833334,
-0.2859096825,
-0.0918626264,
-0.4391513169,
-0.9065592289,
0.6084033251,
0.4867224991,
0.6457618475,
0.5320824981,
0.1871310174,
0.6496270895,
-0.7314432263,
0.8254367709,
0.2733235359,
-0.945569396,
0.8142046928,
-0.2941401601,
0.4632720053,
0.3479791284,
0.4412754476,
-0.610265553,
-0.3413207233,
-0.71517241,
-1.0741647482,
0.4383729398,
0.271282196,
0.579838872,
-0.429738462,
0.0553737544,
-0.2621040046,
0.0617743395,
-0.5519713759,
-0.3225812912,
-0.3856808543,
-0.1691416055,
0.2400741577,
-0.2837459743,
-0.0163411088,
-0.0240302607,
0.4011499584,
-0.3104338944,
0.2662033737,
0.0470988713,
-0.4524105191,
-0.5394841433,
0.34392488,
0.3661046326,
0.5114253759,
-0.3909804821,
0.4150447547,
0.6287213564,
-0.7061923742,
0.4955162704,
0.0604473613,
-0.1206109822,
0.4317992628,
0.1011483744,
0.8397452235,
0.8530947566,
-0.4443573952,
0.3739807308,
-0.0286033042,
0.0119859045,
-0.4339684248,
-0.0080524608,
-0.0919841081,
0.1535275877,
0.7074562907,
0.1092347652,
0.0586429015,
-0.1114937067,
0.2680357993,
0.0438282266,
-0.7632542849,
-0.8969533443,
1.2687401772,
0.2500396669,
-0.4282125235,
0.2755860984,
0.1508098543,
-0.4570817947,
0.6040426493,
0.5055222511,
1.1303818226,
-0.373077482,
-0.0008546452,
0.2930115461,
0.2293433249,
-0.0578410849,
0.2990189195,
-0.3711653352,
-0.262488097,
-0.309673816,
-0.8050694466,
-0.3246667385,
-0.4042348266,
-0.7268825769,
0.4886931479,
-0.4191110134,
-0.4769180715,
-0.2551040649,
-0.2498745322,
-0.7344779372,
0.4827770293,
0.0112164626,
0.8168079853,
-1.0541929007,
0.6603658199,
0.6914748549,
-0.2977618873,
-0.3511839211,
0.1114576906,
-0.2729844749,
-0.495526731,
0.8114434481,
0.1592683047,
-0.3527140021,
0.3123787344,
-0.3391699791,
-0.952434659,
1.3360937834,
0.5679457784,
-0.4544465542,
-0.158527866,
0.0453733914,
0.5085455775,
-0.0557119139,
0.5869346857,
0.3961262405,
0.3883686364,
0.1493463516,
-0.4321063161,
-0.1426433176,
-0.0922702253,
-0.1072786376,
0.6553243995,
-0.9375678301,
0.4937221706,
-0.1281731427,
-0.8264819384,
-0.6768055558,
0.8277708888,
-0.1201835275,
0.6031584144,
0.3362787962,
0.8682301044,
0.5120512843,
-0.0991530716,
0.9159783721,
-0.7614236474,
0.6266326308,
0.8739013672,
-0.1270893365,
0.6760771871,
0.5829943419,
-0.4487656057,
0.4011805654,
0.1834740341,
0.0836173072,
0.6724238396,
-0.2347486466,
-0.3797110319,
-0.3264622986,
-0.0660154447,
-0.4668270051,
0.2833219171,
0.3537382185,
-0.5437102914,
-0.5225524306,
0.1894761026,
-0.2302468121,
0.1309503466,
-0.0622168481,
0.5905703306,
0.2769026756,
0.0579750612,
0.5467445254,
0.0796834528,
0.3539431989,
-0.4515771568,
-0.2542519569,
-0.1937138885,
0.0553877577,
-0.1609417349,
-0.2986138165,
0.3728497624,
-0.0696263462,
-0.5651264191,
-0.4607288241,
0.5310031772,
-0.1134689525,
-0.4782302082,
0.3271623254,
0.2179089189,
0.0750664696,
-0.0130426213,
-0.6341461539,
-0.046780698,
-0.429271698,
-0.6456454992,
0.1712888926,
0.9102762938,
0.163299039,
0.9108226895,
0.4705440402,
-0.2449977547,
0.1231386065,
0.5535193086,
0.8952786922,
-1.0927324295,
-0.5372854471,
-0.8526774049,
0.3942866027,
0.2006945163,
0.047783263,
0.7633502483,
0.4396314025,
0.3000864983,
0.0672358871,
0.2826699615,
0.0079353405,
0.0953327194,
-0.8345394135,
0.6008027196,
-0.1893583089,
0.2604094148,
0.0305182673,
-1.2075508833,
-0.1442184597,
0.1778288633,
-0.2289082706,
0.0451340005,
0.7941560149,
0.542563498,
-0.3716794252,
-0.1266392767,
0.788017869,
0.1004043967,
0.548156321,
0.3726200461,
0.6199535728,
-0.7362900376,
0.5715167522,
-0.2283204049,
-0.0287856273,
-0.1628245413,
-1.0460679531,
-1.0419931412,
-0.120641917,
-0.4291941822,
0.0807250515,
0.2515761852,
1.0215735435,
0.8016509414,
-0.9341776371,
0.3506271541,
-0.2991235256,
0.0300801788,
-0.2334678173,
-0.3141544759,
0.6305732131,
-0.3294638991,
-1.0109784603,
0.6058979034,
0.5155357718,
0.3499267399,
-0.1263666302,
0.1398211718,
0.0066348054,
0.0785635114,
0.4774072766,
0.1331544966,
-0.4854648709,
-0.3743616343,
0.0768222734,
-0.0545767993,
0.2545994222,
0.8115252852,
-1.0088909864,
0.3979905546,
0.4317601919,
0.4935355484,
0.6502106786,
0.328573823,
0.5042355061,
-1.0204225779,
0.7246866822,
0.4201600552,
0.4953510165,
0.3782287538,
-0.390465945,
0.5390326381,
0.470710516,
-0.5141106844,
-0.6395867467,
-0.0079129403,
-0.8155316114,
0.1146054715,
1.0614056587,
0.0778290182,
-0.2804327011,
0.1348780692,
0.1084875986,
0.3459826112,
-0.4193157256,
0.9168682098,
0.2436977774,
0.314411819,
-0.4383641481,
-0.6826377511,
0.0476436615,
0.3994343877,
-0.365237385,
0.0128600467,
0.4047344029,
0.220965758,
0.2060067803,
0.2983961105,
-0.1693221033,
0.11336115,
0.4355840087,
-0.0289443936,
-0.0690910146,
-0.4783204496,
-0.480674535,
0.5541870594,
-0.3048818111,
-0.2876895368
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.03022v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.03022v2
|
Beyond Isolation: Multi-Agent Synergy for Improving Knowledge Graph Construction
| 2023-12-05T07:27:08 | 2023-12-29T07:34:30 |
Hongbin Ye, Honghao Gui, Aijia Zhang, Tong Liu, Wei Hua, Weiqiang Jia
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Knowledge graph construction (KGC) is a multifaceted undertaking involving
the extraction of entities, relations, and events. Traditionally, large
language models (LLMs) have been viewed as solitary task-solving agents in this
complex landscape. However, this paper challenges this paradigm by introducing
a novel framework, CooperKGC. Departing from the conventional approach,
CooperKGC establishes a collaborative processing network, assembling a KGC
collaboration team capable of concurrently addressing entity, relation, and
event extraction tasks. Our experiments unequivocally demonstrate that
fostering collaboration and information interaction among diverse agents within
CooperKGC yields superior results compared to individual cognitive processes
operating in isolation. Importantly, our findings reveal that the collaboration
facilitated by CooperKGC enhances knowledge selection, correction, and
aggregation capabilities across multiple rounds of interactions.
|
[
-0.6366474032,
-0.7676547766,
0.6945319176,
-0.0463011116,
-0.0172281396,
0.7282681465,
-0.5383862257,
-0.7139076591,
0.3815120459,
0.3036378622,
-0.5851335526,
-0.6718382835,
-0.8905649781,
0.1741310358,
0.1014159396,
0.7840442061,
0.0700970218,
-0.2377511114,
-0.7488043308,
-0.2049881965,
-0.2755049467,
-0.1350311935,
-0.8604693413,
-0.6952636242,
0.6992821097,
0.6085000634,
0.8828255534,
0.5332667232,
0.5252136588,
0.3694409132,
0.0053247125,
0.5244464278,
-0.5461806059,
0.3714940548,
-0.0782772526,
-0.2146942168,
-0.3384390771,
0.1299346834,
0.5662385821,
1.035167098,
-0.1918072253,
-0.188533172,
0.1241971552,
0.6623763442,
-0.8045403957,
0.7805114388,
-0.4838463664,
-0.0489576049,
-0.0160685219,
0.2243442237,
-0.3907251656,
-0.0891456604,
0.161831975,
-0.8192017674,
0.2044263929,
-0.0112256873,
0.497428,
0.0842289552,
-0.6786319017,
-0.4001106918,
-0.6561096311,
0.3328205347,
-0.1719192266,
0.6430883408,
0.2954442203,
0.2679015398,
-0.5138401985,
-1.0494995117,
-0.7653759122,
-0.2857049704,
-0.3459492326,
0.6412488222,
0.0354132988,
0.2763240039,
0.1124845445,
0.1815492362,
-0.1840830743,
-0.0501252711,
-0.4938522279,
-0.1990913153,
0.5219956636,
0.2551520467,
0.3274489641,
-0.1705952436,
-0.1743718088,
0.2169438004,
-0.5332643986,
0.04475113,
0.2790512145,
0.342961967,
0.0166779384,
0.4353407621,
-0.4876902401,
0.3441607058,
0.0166495331,
-0.2777143419,
0.043007724,
-0.5675280094,
0.0483076759,
0.224260807,
0.8951866031,
0.0891979337,
-0.0878729075,
-0.9073254466,
0.39379704,
0.1313061118,
0.355397433,
-0.5144579411,
-0.7464846969,
0.0193749946,
-0.449593991,
-0.2628952563,
0.2705431581,
-0.5370495915,
-0.3654953539,
-0.3963351846,
-0.1135421395,
-0.1542132944,
-0.5874221325,
-0.448464334,
-0.2711290419,
-0.1155762672,
0.260441035,
-0.4933826327,
0.5820088983,
0.6635007262,
0.8015879989,
-0.4946640134,
-0.473477453,
-0.5763255954,
0.6498600841,
-0.2301659137,
0.7665079832,
-0.5777233839,
-0.5619792938,
-0.4850417972,
0.245830819,
-0.0441644266,
-0.4883081019,
0.1995824277,
-0.6843633652,
-0.1818856746,
-0.4627478123,
-0.440803498,
0.0121407881,
0.3549621105,
-0.9123411775,
0.8106776476,
0.1610764116,
-0.8062843084,
0.3313682973,
-0.7381974459,
-0.612052381,
0.38465029,
-0.271165967,
-0.3816146553,
-0.3964948952,
0.1076973081,
0.4528907537,
-0.2766862214,
-0.0152578158,
-0.6846629381,
0.1477650106,
0.0725417137,
0.430544138,
0.7372595668,
0.5139687657,
-0.1010256186,
-0.0555493757,
-0.6954020858,
0.0391394347,
0.0416764468,
-0.3827694654,
-0.4577726126,
0.0057329014,
-0.7661749125,
0.2804646194,
0.1451254934,
-0.5305249095,
0.3013674021,
-0.0921088681,
0.1415729374,
0.5333977938,
0.0555508249,
0.786945343,
-0.1461265534,
0.4903942049,
0.1816004366,
0.0850378424,
0.3816374838,
-0.4616238177,
-0.4579045773,
-0.4680296779,
0.0380399898,
0.1723200977,
-1.1736690998,
0.1370146424,
-0.2817671895,
-0.6090624332,
-0.2050049156,
0.3883492947,
0.1777250022,
0.606097877,
-0.0052797501,
-0.5364432931,
-0.4722667336,
-0.611182332,
0.1111501753,
-0.3571436107,
0.4237805605,
0.4131677747,
0.0650176182,
-0.2712582946,
0.9791366458,
-0.6256558895,
-0.2361197919,
-0.5016453266,
0.2062264979,
0.1172803938,
0.2841023505,
0.0722434223,
-0.8159291148,
-0.7202497721,
0.3538330793,
-1.0050852299,
-0.033054404,
0.2173244506,
-0.4603379369,
0.1182086915,
0.7154987454,
-0.9398004413,
0.2956544757,
0.4820704162,
-0.2214436829,
0.6841184497,
-0.0364531614,
0.2168008387,
-1.1699886322,
-0.1023409516,
-0.4904368222,
-0.3730654716,
-0.5850157738,
0.3268788159,
-0.2306382954,
0.1201942191,
-0.0482364409,
0.1990123689,
-0.7662737966,
-0.0502599329,
-0.2767310441,
0.6615542769,
0.006223748,
0.4885579944,
-0.0888076499,
0.4278331697,
0.3929919899,
-0.5951133966,
0.6737133861,
0.3995220661,
-0.1254421026,
0.3959529698,
-0.2584046423,
0.4558199346,
-0.0777156428,
0.2446758747,
-0.7309693098,
-0.3260101676,
0.4923830926,
-0.4863668382,
0.244748041,
-0.0892864317,
-0.6724041104,
-0.3322151005,
0.0305247176,
0.3475878835,
0.1569716334,
-0.5697606206,
1.0384452343,
0.7199541926,
-0.1369740814,
-0.4974267185,
-0.480394423,
0.0862787738,
0.2110604197,
-0.9178700447,
0.0123392483,
-0.0722944587,
-0.5043253303,
0.3046411276,
-0.1219611764,
-0.0720722973,
0.2476814687,
0.5562852621,
0.0842646584,
0.1326426864,
0.2674385905,
-0.1363059133,
0.0034218247,
0.0358938836,
-0.3855645657,
0.300039202,
0.1253740489,
-0.1862882972,
0.0463252626,
0.4823383391,
0.4058882594,
-0.3229270279,
1.1825584173,
0.6553528309,
-0.1577596217,
-0.3681797087,
-0.4729364812,
-0.187423721,
-0.4586086273,
0.3169357181,
-0.426763773,
-1.2178310156,
0.6197759509,
-0.5082722306,
-0.2792108953,
0.2554448247,
0.6681413054,
0.1315785348,
0.7556005716,
0.7503902316,
-0.0230185706,
0.2065649629,
-0.0343186148,
0.5712972283,
-0.812217176,
-0.5039058328,
-0.4127583504,
0.0035171243,
-0.5952397585,
-0.1472294927,
0.6455304027,
0.4969102144,
0.1880735904,
0.400649935,
-0.4383779764,
0.5926454663,
0.6128914356,
0.2020255774,
0.6603873968,
-0.209763661,
-0.424003005,
0.3251779974,
-1.0879427195,
-0.0616028011,
1.0152964592,
-0.2606497407,
0.3968679011,
0.1724304259,
0.802416563,
0.209375903,
0.4282253385,
-0.5994495153,
0.6970320344,
-0.038862817,
-0.3946074545,
-0.4337947071,
-0.8366677165,
-1.0670442581,
0.2062345892,
-0.389695406,
-0.980352819,
-0.1240017191,
-0.1512152106,
-0.210434854,
0.4147770703,
-1.0019165277,
0.740260303,
0.4119891226,
-0.4452067912,
-0.4758199453,
-0.6437045336,
0.4715195,
0.0180836357,
0.303799808,
-0.0271815807,
0.2932186723,
0.3649481237,
-0.4442035854,
0.6030765176,
0.1922988296,
0.1576681435,
0.713463366,
0.3351503909,
1.0410331488,
0.0882460102,
0.1593193114,
0.1192080081,
-0.2196241021,
-0.2836652398,
-0.6736841202,
0.6788547635,
-1.0595866442,
-0.5292740464,
0.0127777588,
-0.9203590155,
-0.1523216665,
0.2341897488,
-0.1529201865,
0.2665439844,
-0.2297274172,
0.1807135493,
0.2227938324,
0.1401087195,
0.5127629042,
0.3988771141,
0.0172266085,
-0.6078057289,
0.7623873949,
0.2417727411,
0.5963444114,
0.0965195149,
-0.0284520611,
0.0567599833,
-0.404438138,
0.2804688513,
0.2391679585,
-0.9144308567,
-0.0107124308,
-1.1907746792,
-0.3646515608,
-0.9347191453,
-0.1209048182,
-0.2564840913,
-0.3618173301,
-0.033069063,
-0.2421338856,
0.1632324904,
0.8648849726,
-0.44729954,
0.2750431597,
-0.8638215065,
0.3966262341,
0.6807142496,
0.2510895133,
0.1590540111,
0.4934535623,
-0.5539861321,
-0.312456876,
-0.2870201766,
-0.5952294469,
-0.029839417,
-0.1356184483,
0.7032374144,
0.2172995806,
0.3125409484,
0.55776757,
-0.1381160617,
0.7309718728,
0.3912663758,
-0.6372819543,
0.0961218774,
-0.3793589771,
0.4458033442,
0.3768621683,
0.2892811,
-0.7666840553,
-0.7749205828,
-0.8037173152,
-0.8466570377,
0.9682464004,
0.4884833694,
-0.7608073354,
-0.1034325361,
0.2558928728,
0.0237315893,
0.2807144225,
-0.7363416553,
-0.2319148779,
0.1164208651,
-0.0766400844,
0.0833644569,
-0.1759753376,
-0.4289730787,
-0.0768936351,
0.6673882604,
-0.2429809719,
0.1744456291,
0.2858296931,
-0.0680257902,
-0.3289065957,
-0.0069564381,
-0.0065221493,
0.6166342497,
0.2325774878,
0.5352214575,
0.2630468011,
-0.433298111,
-0.1478529423,
0.2082724273,
0.0904728547,
-0.4126080573,
0.6788510084,
0.3221780658,
-0.2953743041,
-0.2169960886,
0.2336795479,
-0.1834587902,
-0.1403179318,
-0.156551525,
0.2343726158,
0.4194632471,
0.8036120534,
0.0824315771,
0.1062565371,
-0.0760805011,
-0.4704809785,
0.2593335509,
0.5923755765,
-0.2959425151,
-0.2126757503,
0.5099933743,
0.2213530242,
-0.0740383863,
0.7225151658,
-0.6267696023,
-0.5690420866,
0.7859119177,
0.2262256145,
0.8145216703,
0.09336555,
0.4499879479,
0.3472885787,
0.4818313718,
0.0669592842,
-0.1807156354,
-0.5104561448,
-1.0192806721,
-0.5207765102,
-0.1927852035,
-0.3974070549,
-0.3488372862,
-0.234126851,
0.0265506208,
-0.3399198651,
-0.0028824781,
-0.0118142935,
0.4185200334,
-0.6188985705,
-0.2048826963,
0.1062081084,
0.3086881936,
-0.4961273372,
0.9452081323,
0.5354793072,
-0.2911494672,
-1.2062200308,
-0.3805401325,
-0.0004390312,
-0.3765241802,
0.5407429934,
-0.0716609508,
-0.2235760391,
0.0310575888,
-0.7597669959,
-0.8486776352,
1.3994477987,
0.281619519,
-0.3899343908,
0.1677493304,
0.2410597503,
0.3807474375,
-0.5115303993,
0.1714363247,
0.5685018897,
0.4474730194,
0.3801884055,
-0.8702554703,
0.1496263742,
-0.0272004884,
-0.473086834,
0.4039114714,
-1.0959750414,
0.784089148,
-0.0903796405,
-0.4108581543,
-0.1555562764,
0.5942141414,
0.2703186274,
0.3400841951,
0.6199929714,
0.6964761019,
0.8775610924,
-0.0637261048,
0.8264368176,
-0.2999152243,
0.2805781662,
1.3556624651,
-0.3221692145,
-0.0277891792,
0.3726009727,
-0.0531261973,
0.5627686381,
0.3342575133,
0.232663095,
0.552628696,
-0.2209793627,
-0.6094816327,
-0.6477799416,
-0.4814347327,
-0.0830187351,
0.2498480976,
0.1259000897,
-0.1011492312,
-0.2472523451,
-0.2656001151,
0.2114658058,
-0.0378233418,
-0.4142484963,
1.0028933287,
0.3199632466,
-0.8633036017,
-0.1970930845,
-0.2927471697,
-0.0077282111,
-0.6936611533,
-0.0106889242,
0.0278235227,
0.2564627826,
-0.2942585945,
-0.5409705639,
0.3610040247,
-0.5765330791,
-0.2360768616,
0.0443511382,
1.0765241385,
-0.6873473525,
-0.279332757,
0.7859022021,
0.7240053415,
-0.0391337648,
0.0032292611,
-0.3119127154,
-0.1188111976,
-0.2461415082,
0.0392239951,
0.1723755151,
0.8862625957,
0.0228782315,
0.6239416003,
0.7813800573,
0.2451397181,
0.0678993613,
0.0797014087,
1.1585294008,
-0.3913953602,
-0.5253870487,
-0.7435464859,
0.3203957081,
-0.3025758564,
0.215955168,
0.8514840603,
0.3666439354,
1.0300896168,
0.3102991581,
0.8326079249,
-0.426676929,
0.1504295021,
-0.191350162,
0.7774162889,
-0.264138341,
-0.0107307928,
-0.5343302488,
-0.7259919643,
-0.2434143126,
0.0012838175,
-0.1078749076,
-0.2325138152,
0.982082665,
0.8817331195,
0.1719456613,
0.2808283865,
0.297006458,
0.3159995973,
0.5248357058,
0.5928970575,
0.8739230037,
0.0176899638,
0.8934962153,
-0.3914707005,
-0.092016764,
0.4167907536,
-0.7616305351,
-1.3239042759,
-0.5873132944,
-0.4228318334,
-0.4714515805,
0.0133561771,
1.1830279827,
0.7089664936,
-0.5313350558,
-0.1802625358,
-0.2662180066,
0.5838751793,
-0.3021613955,
-0.2222564667,
0.3222744465,
-0.3335202336,
-0.3560471237,
0.4477019906,
0.3527002931,
-0.289127171,
-0.1422873586,
-0.3318583965,
-0.3351093829,
-0.4432059228,
0.5195294023,
0.0442291275,
-0.2194818258,
-0.4271589816,
-0.1973185688,
-0.0220351815,
0.0190848708,
0.9807497263,
-0.8016557097,
0.8266964555,
0.3470335901,
0.716278255,
0.5754565001,
-0.1260828376,
0.5859120488,
-0.8635585308,
0.2068636119,
-0.1545975059,
0.1151357368,
0.1415231526,
-0.5904570222,
0.7211565375,
0.7972015142,
-0.6623311043,
-0.4678309262,
0.2710679173,
-0.9958484769,
-0.4201352298,
1.0639572144,
-0.1280294806,
-0.4635277092,
-0.2881459594,
0.0540838838,
0.7949619293,
-0.3720073998,
0.9337360263,
1.0514256954,
-0.180515632,
-0.2995595336,
-0.184892416,
0.259257555,
-0.1578248888,
-0.9151942134,
-0.098433353,
0.4288032055,
0.0926396698,
0.3642129004,
0.7910984755,
0.0880301967,
0.0428496823,
0.1896214336,
0.2745133042,
-0.4219694436,
-0.5342661142,
0.356916815,
0.6233054996,
0.0032620037,
0.0390760154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02532v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02532v1
|
DRAFT: Dense Retrieval Augmented Few-shot Topic classifier Framework
| 2023-12-05T06:28:45 | 2023-12-05T06:28:45 |
Keonwoo Kim, Younggun Lee
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
With the growing volume of diverse information, the demand for classifying
arbitrary topics has become increasingly critical. To address this challenge,
we introduce DRAFT, a simple framework designed to train a classifier for
few-shot topic classification. DRAFT uses a few examples of a specific topic as
queries to construct Customized dataset with a dense retriever model.
Multi-query retrieval (MQR) algorithm, which effectively handles multiple
queries related to a specific topic, is applied to construct the Customized
dataset. Subsequently, we fine-tune a classifier using the Customized dataset
to identify the topic. To demonstrate the efficacy of our proposed approach, we
conduct evaluations on both widely used classification benchmark datasets and
manually constructed datasets with 291 diverse topics, which simulate diverse
contents encountered in real-world applications. DRAFT shows competitive or
superior performance compared to baselines that use in-context learning, such
as GPT-3 175B and InstructGPT 175B, on few-shot topic classification tasks
despite having 177 times fewer parameters, demonstrating its effectiveness.
|
[
-0.5263856649,
-0.6949490905,
0.172917679,
-0.2182888389,
-0.1798380613,
0.0660686046,
-0.0369972065,
-0.1528020799,
0.2521497011,
0.4501142502,
-0.4101614654,
-0.2075392753,
-0.4901753068,
-0.2236686945,
-0.3964706659,
1.0003980398,
0.2948504984,
-0.0260449909,
0.1866071224,
-0.1401425153,
-0.3674352169,
-0.3146300614,
-0.645103991,
-0.2416692674,
0.6242147088,
0.7092635036,
0.1986141354,
0.4285209477,
0.470315516,
0.2675176263,
-0.1120223179,
0.1738348156,
-0.9264235497,
0.0464612506,
0.1342006475,
-0.363124907,
0.0351047814,
-0.0254245382,
0.7439343929,
0.5344956517,
-0.1432682723,
0.2179190367,
0.0482147448,
0.5532188416,
-0.980129838,
-0.2282327563,
-1.0251822472,
0.1820312589,
-0.6282579899,
-0.2863675058,
-0.5009357333,
-0.050647825,
0.2662575543,
-0.4650859535,
0.6582949162,
0.1711854786,
0.6549931169,
0.1638944447,
-0.6192699075,
0.1545802951,
-0.4498970807,
0.6732208133,
0.0350545757,
0.3115605712,
0.3761154115,
0.9183508158,
0.0574758649,
-0.9579709768,
-0.594825685,
0.3504159451,
0.0825675875,
0.1857905835,
0.1751846671,
-0.0573804863,
0.357719183,
0.3883620203,
-0.8463051915,
0.026617974,
-0.650187254,
-0.4013454318,
0.7143082619,
0.4693520367,
-0.1068585739,
-0.2948000133,
-0.1042004898,
0.040934056,
-0.380063951,
-0.0349755213,
0.2053526193,
0.5964847207,
0.0310481042,
0.7908616066,
-0.6166327596,
0.9379301667,
0.3143844306,
-0.2756447792,
0.3627124429,
-0.2036705464,
-0.2374206632,
0.1566665173,
0.4469991028,
0.2242636383,
-0.4048256874,
0.0685437247,
-0.1844578981,
-0.2286802232,
0.3094147444,
-1.1158618927,
-0.1122138277,
0.2551109493,
-0.6160427332,
-0.1037153378,
0.0353062823,
-0.5170167089,
-0.5773600936,
-0.1018795446,
0.2495899647,
-0.3560135365,
-0.0499175377,
0.1603269428,
-0.4891096652,
0.4094111323,
0.7230495214,
-0.9627412558,
0.0687765554,
0.7218575478,
0.8642969131,
-0.3332147002,
-0.3381165266,
-0.7252876163,
0.2310847491,
-0.1314129978,
1.3210707903,
-0.635530293,
-0.2114764899,
-0.0478076413,
-0.2647490501,
0.1291259229,
-0.3909025788,
0.4775403738,
-0.6085285544,
0.245062083,
-0.2772060633,
-0.8477158546,
0.1784165949,
0.74033463,
-0.6398004889,
0.703661561,
0.2265697718,
-1.102763176,
1.0023218393,
-0.3461570442,
0.0340397321,
0.3800877929,
-0.3182761073,
-0.3807955682,
-0.131020382,
-0.1194653884,
0.5359171629,
-0.1839877367,
0.0239665657,
-0.5378648639,
-0.6727372408,
-0.1118042693,
-0.392686069,
0.3678941727,
0.5113889575,
0.3330793381,
0.0035288881,
-0.8257923126,
0.3783713877,
-0.1487689316,
-0.6836063862,
-0.1702226549,
-0.425020963,
0.4383924007,
0.1275318116,
-0.1655149311,
-0.5076173544,
0.3823685348,
-0.2667056918,
0.1391339302,
0.2986731827,
0.3575283587,
0.7989752293,
-0.6532675624,
0.3458168805,
-0.0200964939,
-0.1443783194,
-0.188961044,
-0.3815021813,
-0.4842680991,
-0.5683293939,
0.3764511049,
0.4382006526,
-0.6828769445,
0.3269818127,
-0.160245195,
-0.7316051722,
-0.3134515285,
0.2834352553,
0.0105163017,
0.4159857035,
0.3231300116,
0.0543456711,
-0.4967955947,
-0.5222127438,
-0.1980689615,
-0.0387310758,
0.0550600104,
0.5375053883,
0.4315761924,
-0.267206043,
0.8987477422,
-0.9017071128,
-0.5717048049,
-0.3561298251,
0.5408723354,
-0.049805671,
0.5173521042,
0.6679437757,
-0.8771641254,
-0.4568715692,
-0.2421219945,
-0.5803887248,
0.2638035119,
-0.1591099948,
-0.4282570779,
-0.3630182147,
0.3803182542,
-0.3430676162,
0.261351198,
-0.1646360159,
-0.0996976718,
0.2294971794,
0.272723496,
-0.0127014862,
-1.0654835701,
-0.2112261653,
-0.10633827,
0.1384339482,
-0.316449374,
-0.1507855058,
0.1707464755,
-0.4777264595,
-0.8120766878,
0.9299256802,
-0.038006112,
0.062550813,
-0.5650160313,
-0.1868018806,
0.1601852775,
0.1069391295,
0.1841000617,
0.5919944048,
0.3922687769,
-0.6660253406,
0.302965045,
0.5158324242,
-0.2384401113,
0.647015214,
-0.3820155561,
0.1926978528,
-0.5795863867,
0.491858691,
-0.7307060361,
-0.5634322762,
-0.0530411862,
-0.2152355611,
0.4107843935,
-0.6152787209,
-0.5399602652,
-0.2533917725,
-0.3212752044,
0.2586815357,
0.0916322991,
-0.5021868348,
0.4493342042,
0.3223986626,
0.1474585533,
-0.6149736047,
-0.8330072761,
-0.3993365467,
-0.2879404724,
-0.3243390322,
0.5106633902,
-0.1858117133,
0.1380629838,
-0.0576556996,
-0.0938827023,
-0.7073061466,
0.0010812259,
0.1861547828,
-0.2491320223,
-0.3075187504,
0.5720356107,
0.4111783803,
-0.0666270852,
-0.5443507433,
-0.0360672995,
0.3572318852,
-0.0583312064,
-0.4463018775,
-0.0661762357,
0.2994652987,
-0.0106478082,
-0.1494102031,
0.504533112,
1.0359466076,
-0.4065488279,
-0.3865720928,
-0.8025322556,
-0.2618141472,
-0.3956709504,
0.1374983341,
-0.7392342687,
-1.1070225239,
0.3338547647,
-0.2229894549,
0.0113456938,
0.4930221736,
0.2818018198,
-0.0850081742,
0.668328464,
0.7506719232,
-0.1251127273,
0.8291525841,
-0.6813397408,
-0.5375651717,
-0.7231652737,
-0.1957218796,
-0.7256351113,
-0.3615340889,
-0.4561415315,
-0.0635886937,
0.1049170569,
0.2188474834,
-0.4344386458,
0.0277574845,
-0.506449461,
0.8299009204,
0.3329244554,
0.3694469929,
0.0402808897,
0.0654904321,
0.0841815621,
-0.0997681096,
-0.7671039701,
-0.4761240184,
1.2902342081,
-0.1265691668,
0.8828477859,
0.1115587726,
1.1346663237,
0.2827901542,
0.3456322551,
-0.9184277058,
0.2271716446,
-0.2306278646,
-0.908456862,
-0.3468055129,
-0.4481498003,
-0.8726191521,
0.5725624561,
-0.6011613607,
-0.3351842165,
0.4013156593,
0.038542904,
-0.5172780752,
0.0870594308,
-0.8195709586,
0.9499027133,
-0.2100010067,
-0.5895295739,
-0.0972597823,
-0.4189212918,
0.5649836659,
-0.2585214674,
-0.5239720345,
-0.1953213513,
-0.0949752033,
0.6061344743,
-0.2435623705,
0.7049195766,
-0.2792781889,
0.6052647829,
0.4441058338,
-0.2473487556,
0.0142583093,
0.4627180099,
-0.6147318482,
-0.2837192118,
0.0061862026,
-0.6649357677,
-0.7003093362,
0.4890258908,
-0.7900208235,
-0.2641840577,
-0.5698798299,
-0.2224094272,
-0.1453831643,
0.5611100793,
0.6097524166,
0.3808165193,
-0.5423737764,
0.3895511925,
0.678881228,
0.0471457243,
0.2001028955,
0.6218217015,
0.0446801037,
-0.4659477472,
0.7510812879,
0.2945855856,
-0.2934927344,
0.5994147658,
0.2617478371,
-0.1603803039,
-0.7947317958,
-0.4429302216,
-0.1876189262,
-0.8717070818,
-0.7020402551,
-0.8614308834,
-0.3600867987,
-0.2101666033,
-0.2546631396,
-0.2137426287,
-0.2749689221,
-0.5007727742,
-0.0755563676,
0.2212001532,
0.2387157977,
0.1897705197,
0.6024065018,
-0.9103412032,
0.6014463305,
0.5327654481,
0.3081882298,
-0.3407838047,
-0.7151817083,
0.0408171304,
-0.1490261555,
-0.59950459,
-0.5322549939,
0.2244891226,
0.5888188481,
0.8418893814,
0.6973522902,
0.3652356267,
0.8129370213,
-0.3236612082,
0.4727437794,
-0.0249617696,
-0.6268029809,
0.952614665,
-0.0848183781,
0.4324163198,
1.148272872,
0.640242815,
-0.0172460768,
0.0677425563,
-0.5431013107,
-0.4986501038,
0.7946502566,
-0.1865897179,
0.2723867595,
-0.0395690128,
0.560626924,
0.3462727666,
0.2468579561,
-0.3218833506,
0.0150446454,
-0.396769315,
0.0243894644,
0.1373116672,
-0.4252671003,
-0.0371980034,
-0.1599004716,
0.2359844595,
-0.5959721208,
0.2003202885,
-0.00133863,
-0.3727880716,
-0.0162549242,
0.3738586903,
0.4159249961,
0.4863363802,
-0.5645774603,
0.043316558,
0.1858005673,
-0.4024325311,
0.2082010508,
0.2964034975,
-0.3680022359,
-0.0920460075,
0.268068701,
0.6592273712,
0.115988262,
-0.4769605398,
0.5224810243,
-0.2866535783,
-0.227007255,
-0.0446399674,
0.2415246814,
-0.3881946206,
0.3151189089,
0.4840323329,
0.1653995961,
0.6296330094,
-0.4136443734,
0.4731544852,
0.329972297,
-0.3117522299,
-0.0216680951,
0.3191565871,
0.1981278509,
0.2472586185,
0.7280234694,
-0.5688465834,
-0.2865547538,
0.3408682942,
0.373876214,
0.7606548071,
0.2094008327,
0.2122015804,
0.4818929732,
-0.0217914246,
-0.3763431013,
0.5206766725,
-0.2624371052,
-0.9273737073,
-0.1932291687,
-0.5923296809,
-0.521571815,
0.1728945374,
-0.5291173458,
0.523165524,
-0.618601203,
-0.2574355006,
0.2304800004,
0.4812656343,
-0.7190054655,
0.1196008474,
-0.0774867237,
0.9492630363,
-0.8192492127,
0.7868939042,
0.9723939896,
-0.6917167306,
-0.3695662618,
0.0997902006,
0.2707577348,
-0.2977636755,
0.8981323242,
0.2308632433,
0.1202178374,
-0.0575224683,
-0.5921531916,
-0.678568542,
1.0625345707,
0.2488964498,
-0.2783508599,
0.2275220007,
-0.3206241429,
0.4156883657,
-0.438462913,
0.408161819,
0.0031415632,
0.1936408728,
0.5663426518,
-0.5729418993,
-0.2837250531,
-0.1654311717,
-0.012590426,
-0.1021638438,
-0.9018086195,
0.6604934335,
-0.2108220309,
-0.0843306258,
-0.1043381467,
0.8604755402,
0.484390229,
0.8454495668,
0.1684832871,
0.4313877523,
1.0435262918,
-0.1344135553,
0.8908840418,
0.0712073371,
0.1570638418,
1.1901391745,
-0.535351038,
1.0732573271,
0.0853359699,
0.0211116113,
-0.1439743042,
0.8139979839,
-0.0581137836,
0.8022639751,
0.2338595688,
-0.1499830484,
-0.2811665833,
-0.1305759996,
-0.5219413042,
0.6887283921,
0.4954049289,
0.0260556173,
-0.2513142824,
0.2383411229,
-0.4971362352,
-0.1640303582,
-0.2813315094,
1.1481266022,
0.0110502737,
-0.1649720371,
0.5166047812,
0.0060886014,
0.924677372,
-0.4791652262,
-0.0195852742,
-0.3340467513,
0.2033790797,
-0.4533181489,
-0.6998162866,
0.3751187921,
-0.119289659,
-0.4755350351,
-0.1705286056,
1.0265103579,
-0.3055676818,
-0.4331350625,
-0.2871392965,
0.7384800911,
0.0797064751,
-0.30723387,
-0.9501712918,
0.2059612572,
-0.4800276756,
-0.1264830828,
0.557474792,
0.9225990772,
0.0326158404,
0.6536252499,
0.5571916103,
-0.0192518048,
0.168256551,
0.0663650632,
1.0057607889,
-0.7705860734,
-0.5289765,
-0.2861465514,
0.2508170307,
-0.1995243877,
-0.5471765995,
0.4254627526,
1.0870951414,
0.9440467358,
-0.1036817729,
0.8247320652,
0.067959182,
0.63540411,
-0.5797889233,
0.5996562839,
-0.6675761342,
0.2770108879,
0.0191871766,
-0.8006737232,
-0.409129113,
0.6173176169,
-0.2048422545,
0.1449129134,
0.5182450414,
0.5788969398,
-0.3817032874,
-0.0622894652,
0.3450332582,
-0.385956347,
0.2273687124,
0.1787328422,
1.0539326668,
-0.5067307949,
0.6934376955,
-0.4864815176,
0.0108455066,
-0.5439533591,
-0.5969585776,
-0.9516121745,
-0.3823079765,
-0.5164530277,
-0.1214064881,
0.1085004732,
0.9878076315,
1.0783975124,
-0.674115181,
-0.0417283699,
0.0175254382,
0.0994961411,
0.0389864855,
-0.3029372692,
0.1937339753,
-0.5601605773,
-0.45604074,
0.3295321167,
-0.0347312316,
0.2299405038,
0.1258026212,
0.0980582908,
-0.0829206854,
-0.4752290845,
0.7781565189,
0.3518889248,
-0.500009656,
0.0215963051,
-0.0443019383,
-0.3153357208,
-0.0449181497,
1.0505759716,
-0.8650662899,
0.3728223741,
0.9240178466,
0.9917808175,
1.0547955036,
0.0419369489,
0.0456489511,
-1.0165395737,
0.3317170143,
0.44459939,
0.3016489446,
0.1267570555,
-0.387830615,
0.5202665925,
0.1826189309,
-0.3111953437,
-0.829351306,
0.1840023696,
-1.0059324503,
-0.251319617,
0.8855985403,
0.18894355,
0.1389975101,
-0.3205063641,
-0.3729504347,
-0.0852544904,
-0.7150086761,
0.6149639487,
0.3896011412,
-0.2723542154,
-0.5553926229,
-0.4743997157,
0.4233507812,
-0.0822610781,
-0.9117043614,
-0.2976064384,
0.6470059752,
0.1004476696,
0.03917519,
0.9433514476,
0.2119173706,
0.2216327339,
0.2232673615,
-0.2496671826,
0.0204883907,
-0.3092086613,
-0.3143903911,
0.4939097762,
0.2623524964,
-0.0078727221
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.06798v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.06798v1
|
Building Trustworthy NeuroSymbolic AI Systems: Consistency, Reliability, Explainability, and Safety
| 2023-12-05T06:13:55 | 2023-12-05T06:13:55 |
Manas Gaur, Amit Sheth
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG, I.2; I.2.7; J.3; H.3.3
|
Explainability and Safety engender Trust. These require a model to exhibit
consistency and reliability. To achieve these, it is necessary to use and
analyze data and knowledge with statistical and symbolic AI methods relevant to
the AI application - neither alone will do. Consequently, we argue and seek to
demonstrate that the NeuroSymbolic AI approach is better suited for making AI a
trusted AI system. We present the CREST framework that shows how Consistency,
Reliability, user-level Explainability, and Safety are built on NeuroSymbolic
methods that use data and knowledge to support requirements for critical
applications such as health and well-being. This article focuses on Large
Language Models (LLMs) as the chosen AI system within the CREST framework. LLMs
have garnered substantial attention from researchers due to their versatility
in handling a broad array of natural language processing (NLP) scenarios. For
example, ChatGPT and Google's MedPaLM have emerged as highly promising
platforms for providing information in general and health-related queries,
respectively. Nevertheless, these models remain black boxes despite
incorporating human feedback and instruction-guided tuning. For instance,
ChatGPT can generate unsafe responses despite instituting safety guardrails.
CREST presents a plausible approach harnessing procedural and graph-based
knowledge within a NeuroSymbolic framework to shed light on the challenges
associated with LLMs.
|
[
-0.1018042564,
-0.6072565913,
0.448335439,
0.289273113,
0.1419399232,
0.2587703764,
-0.2102362663,
-0.5852066875,
0.3621178567,
0.3277986646,
-0.2675801218,
-0.4007614553,
-0.7964750528,
-0.0759667605,
-0.2324519902,
1.0478855371,
-0.0031264664,
0.2239303142,
-0.0861212388,
-0.0459220298,
-0.1993163675,
-0.7964134216,
-1.147090435,
-0.7290912867,
0.4403287172,
0.0100809932,
1.3250313997,
0.6250644922,
0.3914792836,
0.1464655846,
-0.1058462262,
0.1070488021,
-0.2996968627,
0.2490040809,
-0.249745205,
-0.5655854344,
-0.801240325,
-0.2947543859,
0.2460084707,
0.6956105232,
-0.2555094957,
-0.0625995025,
0.1781994551,
0.4037579,
-0.5057197809,
0.5748354793,
-0.3082063496,
-0.1010347977,
0.1904969513,
-0.0147977741,
-0.3128178716,
-0.5360995531,
-0.0513156578,
-0.4903205037,
-0.4499136806,
0.0319862701,
0.750582099,
0.4036362767,
-0.4651809931,
-0.271851927,
-0.5661940575,
0.472713083,
-0.8213604689,
0.4295686483,
0.7328566313,
0.3356088102,
-0.4276292026,
-0.8472086191,
-0.5280394554,
-0.4372828901,
0.1756401509,
-0.0597743616,
-0.2833776474,
0.1752118617,
0.0623102114,
-0.1804379672,
-0.6694221497,
0.4943548739,
-0.0707453266,
-0.5849775672,
0.6747267842,
0.3593886495,
0.7694820762,
-0.4206477404,
-0.1696328819,
0.0109647429,
-0.8747321963,
0.0559825711,
0.2843573689,
0.3177554905,
-0.2515196204,
0.5492214561,
0.1033300459,
0.5142448545,
-0.1450652629,
-0.4080223739,
0.173529312,
0.155780986,
-0.0411675498,
0.1691978872,
0.8681550622,
0.6415774822,
0.7776995301,
-0.3536849618,
-0.1262685061,
0.4549830258,
0.3951448798,
-0.6383236647,
-0.2498355657,
0.432207346,
-0.4498081505,
-0.1598781347,
-0.4385499954,
-0.5194686651,
-0.4909403324,
-0.5112954974,
0.3537002206,
-0.9917020798,
-0.4531487525,
0.1106390879,
0.0302722249,
0.0390224233,
0.1531842053,
-0.9919258356,
0.3015001118,
1.1019647121,
0.8102363944,
-0.142073974,
-0.2885007262,
-0.1707410067,
0.0727409944,
-0.5181273222,
0.4194901288,
-0.5029161572,
-0.0010195995,
0.1280638427,
-0.0175293256,
-0.1702223718,
-0.1968068779,
0.1974742264,
-0.5252420306,
-0.2732628286,
0.1037960574,
-0.4632758796,
-0.1859647483,
0.3966068625,
-0.4745164812,
0.4057538807,
0.0642591864,
-0.5736382008,
0.2185506076,
-0.5399894714,
-0.5624475479,
-0.0557966232,
-0.1448096931,
-0.155652836,
-0.0339224003,
0.2364644259,
0.420350492,
-0.1618069112,
0.4284918904,
-0.677765429,
-0.3444446623,
0.5233068466,
-0.5545552969,
1.0017806292,
0.143528387,
-0.2063798904,
-0.0173807107,
-0.5199545026,
0.2258436531,
-0.1619562358,
-0.151330933,
-0.1895906627,
0.081128642,
0.0526890196,
0.2516424656,
0.4485618174,
-0.2731539309,
-0.2466537654,
-0.3857865632,
0.8813410997,
0.7055966854,
0.0392415747,
0.2572884262,
-0.2853223085,
0.6855049729,
-0.1876017749,
0.4556777179,
-0.0265039802,
-0.3910281658,
-0.2582947016,
-0.4156263471,
0.4151079953,
0.5001650453,
-0.7438519597,
0.3943693936,
-0.3105506003,
-0.2856329978,
-0.2754798532,
-0.1057223156,
0.335540086,
0.5716730952,
0.2500359118,
-0.2714053988,
-0.2397754639,
-0.9502946734,
-0.0274066124,
-0.4767780602,
-0.0867444724,
0.076505281,
0.3763223886,
-0.3073254526,
0.5565949678,
-0.2145398855,
-0.0220249891,
-0.2461817116,
-0.0824672431,
0.1629460752,
0.5019802451,
0.3899596632,
-0.6338692904,
-0.1702328771,
-0.1267455369,
-0.9612026215,
0.3413548172,
0.2925346792,
-0.0527642705,
0.2066987008,
0.5664125085,
-0.867564559,
0.3561773002,
0.5660241842,
-0.1757447869,
0.2659719884,
-0.3232436776,
-0.0652585849,
-1.1623057127,
0.208568424,
0.0499155,
-0.2348180115,
-0.6816586256,
0.1229868755,
0.1215706244,
-0.1598371565,
-0.2417116165,
0.4477972686,
-0.1022153273,
0.1789627522,
-0.4163756967,
0.0774737969,
-0.2932322323,
0.4462322891,
-0.2079396099,
0.3366997838,
0.94573915,
-0.5114651918,
0.0914510041,
0.384275943,
0.0828841403,
0.9706600308,
-0.8977214694,
-0.0733410269,
-0.1846229285,
0.3264747858,
-0.9892222881,
-0.5545555949,
0.1977512389,
-0.7405059338,
0.5119994283,
-0.157204181,
-0.6514120698,
-0.3471211195,
0.041149959,
0.1398069113,
0.7583657503,
-0.5673924088,
0.5198629498,
0.9543813467,
-0.3384852707,
-0.7384405732,
-0.6859161854,
0.3094051778,
-0.1690634638,
-0.6508852839,
0.019764699,
0.1362465918,
-0.175609991,
-0.0941692218,
-0.3222552836,
-0.2993582487,
0.2878850996,
0.7238653898,
0.4637979567,
-0.2358051091,
0.3273065388,
0.0748810247,
-0.3541655242,
0.3469426036,
-0.2697591782,
0.6204919815,
-0.2145571858,
-0.3534175754,
-0.6260250211,
0.1280709356,
0.768340826,
-0.2106409222,
0.805580616,
0.2555543482,
-0.6404363513,
-0.3203076422,
-0.1720436215,
-0.3793179393,
-0.4180721045,
0.3351852298,
0.0002960519,
-0.9812161326,
0.4075529873,
-0.0870522112,
-0.0391316935,
0.1562899351,
0.4947301745,
-0.1508932859,
1.3080842495,
0.6872522831,
-0.3543717861,
0.115687713,
0.1989133954,
0.3743996024,
-0.6473603845,
-0.3394839466,
-0.4891688824,
-0.3178218007,
-0.5915902257,
0.0042748628,
0.4693636298,
-0.0536545999,
-0.6157005429,
0.3675710559,
-0.4050252438,
0.1747958362,
0.2276483029,
0.3322743177,
0.1851729751,
0.0136882411,
0.0065735355,
0.0567998812,
-0.8115662336,
-0.7079384923,
1.1786146164,
0.5577782989,
1.0709360838,
0.0214703549,
0.6272220612,
0.0522396527,
0.4419082403,
-0.5789243579,
0.5439729691,
-0.1616242826,
-0.5953256488,
-0.3591754436,
-0.2893895805,
-1.1724668741,
-0.0447979271,
-0.1756383926,
-1.0056126118,
-0.076458618,
0.2418902367,
-0.4898292124,
0.0740387142,
-0.4460277259,
0.5620267987,
-0.248003915,
-0.2253952473,
-0.3458342552,
-0.9178259969,
0.4229169488,
-0.0815343931,
0.1558083445,
-0.1466344893,
-0.0847624019,
0.6054172516,
-0.2998121977,
0.9410933852,
0.0995371193,
0.0037234148,
0.1448366046,
0.2360170037,
0.1841066331,
0.141884774,
-0.2390109897,
0.4516731203,
0.0089233946,
-0.1184371561,
-0.7679146528,
0.9679040909,
-0.8087700009,
-0.5039075017,
-0.2838285267,
-0.7309968472,
-0.6389637589,
0.2166179419,
-0.2047462761,
0.5649364591,
-0.0037016724,
0.0948221236,
0.680096209,
-0.1841728985,
0.4171182215,
0.300044328,
-0.3283513486,
-0.5158786178,
0.8393086791,
0.2180448771,
0.1863291264,
0.1519953161,
-0.202501893,
-0.3436901271,
-0.5410957932,
-0.1793362498,
0.3348990977,
-0.696064353,
-0.2477259338,
-0.4171327055,
-0.5549306273,
-0.3031588793,
-0.1090810373,
-0.2716976404,
-0.6558335423,
0.0539537594,
-0.1784099936,
0.3208023608,
0.7640222907,
-0.3100950122,
0.2305147797,
-0.5479068756,
0.4189299047,
0.0803705156,
0.5032781959,
0.0297433939,
-0.1843418926,
-0.1080672517,
0.1853423417,
-0.0737376809,
-0.8710485101,
0.4410368204,
-0.2557633817,
0.7961518764,
0.1153551936,
0.0261177681,
0.3716578186,
-0.4866270423,
0.6346274018,
0.3478860557,
-0.8482894301,
0.3112591207,
-0.2405962646,
-0.0729870126,
0.4899451733,
0.8165547252,
-0.370619297,
-0.5370095968,
-0.7938631177,
-0.8896050453,
0.2299034595,
0.0977121145,
0.0670594871,
-0.230464533,
0.4302343726,
-0.0722750947,
0.2349765003,
-0.4073421955,
-0.0001260762,
-0.1812462062,
-0.4861172736,
-0.1990598589,
0.0872186348,
-0.3726843596,
0.1845440269,
0.5746505857,
-0.4339926243,
0.1859707683,
-0.0167419408,
-0.1693716198,
0.090206787,
0.0692963451,
0.3062985241,
0.9164227843,
0.0054389583,
0.3834868968,
-0.0424554572,
-0.430167079,
0.1445315182,
-0.0922154635,
0.0035010665,
-0.265658468,
0.3539883792,
0.4881858528,
0.1834057122,
-0.6905661821,
0.4409567714,
0.1057626233,
-0.0099483868,
-0.2550429404,
0.3458786011,
0.4596493244,
0.4475623071,
-0.0128895724,
0.1063015833,
-0.2196474075,
-0.4579261839,
0.4254205823,
0.6091682315,
-0.5613099337,
-0.2938682139,
0.7100493908,
-0.1606683582,
-0.5552419424,
0.8757033348,
0.3770513237,
-0.3932060301,
0.7937780023,
0.6072868109,
0.628585279,
-0.2894697785,
0.4130501449,
0.269520998,
0.4664220512,
-0.2897254825,
0.3314123452,
0.2949891984,
-0.5232924819,
-0.3226488233,
-0.4590529799,
-0.562312305,
0.1225275099,
-0.603615582,
-0.0792592689,
-0.888890624,
-0.5514655709,
-0.0171370674,
-0.4274033606,
-0.4711171687,
0.3448925018,
0.2207348943,
0.8797420859,
-0.7308469415,
0.672228694,
0.4534786642,
-0.5495188832,
-1.1747097969,
0.1834016293,
-0.0636818409,
-1.1370542049,
0.6514362693,
-0.0259803161,
0.022024475,
-0.414858371,
-0.7497332096,
-0.8660739064,
1.0722265244,
0.714187324,
-0.2747179568,
-0.0987061486,
0.2623462677,
0.9685093164,
-0.2294274718,
0.2884832025,
0.4003016651,
0.4889209867,
-0.0748526827,
-1.0728121996,
0.3398948908,
-0.1325801164,
-0.0138134668,
-0.0733767152,
-0.6873769164,
0.7784092426,
-0.2809803486,
-0.0146942679,
0.0078725219,
0.5986557603,
0.5104478598,
0.2573152184,
0.2164711654,
0.3995490074,
1.0533504486,
0.1498861015,
1.1563174725,
-0.7970157862,
0.0572417602,
1.0550072193,
-0.3560388088,
1.0005060434,
0.3956327438,
0.0222757813,
0.6010004878,
0.47786057,
0.2722617686,
0.2269246131,
0.2974129021,
0.1399679482,
-0.3800961673,
-0.0615752675,
-0.2474850118,
0.4090726078,
0.5079321861,
-0.4735310078,
-0.2672320008,
0.0084568989,
0.4496048689,
-0.1100756899,
-0.3975010216,
0.392734915,
0.5678197742,
-0.8625840545,
0.535395503,
-0.1479890496,
0.237987414,
-0.7642735839,
0.0343317688,
-0.1569004357,
0.2877885997,
-0.2821975946,
-0.8933576345,
0.221001178,
-0.2581565082,
0.1168582216,
-0.0637238026,
0.7417593598,
-0.1450058818,
-0.2405474037,
0.1888284981,
0.4396384954,
0.0963036567,
0.2481297702,
-0.6011362076,
0.0416411087,
-0.430434674,
-0.0887695551,
0.5641913414,
0.2908523977,
-0.2202012241,
1.1582804918,
0.6080065966,
0.0932193175,
-0.2051658481,
-0.1832182407,
0.6151881218,
-0.4341438413,
-0.6677761674,
-0.9427167773,
0.3539559245,
-0.0351352356,
-0.1974951774,
0.8899224997,
0.2267032117,
-0.0222699177,
0.1992047429,
0.8865643144,
0.1880826056,
0.060540501,
-0.4355707467,
1.1640241146,
-0.355007261,
0.0015852964,
-0.0386750065,
-0.6403972507,
-0.6345095634,
0.6693133712,
-0.3175638318,
0.0414939933,
0.7035167217,
1.0357662439,
0.0412526429,
0.3225971758,
0.288596034,
0.3871975243,
0.4225148559,
0.8717544079,
0.8183020353,
-0.1442497075,
0.1927972287,
0.1777974516,
-0.3089801669,
-0.0030295441,
-0.836789608,
-1.0728440285,
-0.381845504,
-0.3741485178,
-0.8243784308,
0.4120601416,
0.9055797458,
0.8166527152,
-0.5665374398,
-0.1408724189,
0.0437907055,
0.3149153292,
-0.225329861,
-0.1661673188,
0.4193399549,
-0.4072241187,
-0.319881022,
0.3825562298,
0.4797770381,
-0.1482723057,
-0.3981122077,
-0.204559058,
0.3030984998,
0.3611086607,
0.3798670173,
0.4642450809,
-0.4220864773,
-0.4050657153,
-0.1395405978,
-0.404758364,
0.0229497012,
0.4204623401,
-0.6218053102,
-0.0167747308,
0.4004516602,
0.7183690667,
0.2627530396,
-0.3816597462,
0.7704588175,
0.1603277624,
-0.2430223078,
0.2293628156,
0.5217961669,
0.3910120428,
-0.3492004573,
0.5365654826,
-0.2115705162,
-0.6153637171,
-0.8574194908,
0.2492379248,
-1.0295485258,
-0.2615527213,
1.1178129911,
-0.2270980179,
-0.6958335638,
-0.3036836982,
-0.0159287509,
0.1066779047,
-0.2010810077,
0.8476603031,
0.5128111839,
-0.4064279795,
0.0613399483,
-0.475156039,
0.4855968356,
0.2641265988,
-0.8470976353,
0.0017765785,
0.3951166272,
0.6323388219,
0.3721177578,
0.5261896253,
-0.3246936798,
0.318736434,
0.1962852478,
-0.1282163709,
-0.1482705325,
-0.5414692163,
-0.4085202515,
0.6846708655,
0.0363039188,
0.0769934952
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02496v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02496v1
|
MKA: A Scalable Medical Knowledge Assisted Mechanism for Generative Models on Medical Conversation Tasks
| 2023-12-05T04:55:54 | 2023-12-05T04:55:54 |
Ke Liang, Sifan Wu, Jiayi Gu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Using natural language processing (NLP) technologies to develop medical
chatbots makes the diagnosis of the patient more convenient and efficient,
which is a typical application in healthcare AI. Because of its importance,
lots of research have been come out. Recently, the neural generative models
have shown their impressive ability as the core of chatbot, while it cannot
scale well when directly applied to medical conversation due to the lack of
medical-specific knowledge. To address the limitation, a scalable Medical
Knowledge Assisted mechanism, MKA, is proposed in this paper. The mechanism
aims to assist general neural generative models to achieve better performance
on the medical conversation task. The medical-specific knowledge graph is
designed within the mechanism, which contains 6 types of medical-related
information, including department, drug, check, symptom, disease, food.
Besides, the specific token concatenation policy is defined to effectively
inject medical information into the input data. Evaluation of our method is
carried out on two typical medical datasets, MedDG and MedDialog-CN. The
evaluation results demonstrate that models combined with our mechanism
outperform original methods in multiple automatic evaluation metrics. Besides,
MKA-Bert-GPT achieves state-of-the-art performance. The open-sourced codes are
public:
https://github.com/LIANGKE23/Knowledge_Assisted_Medical_Dialogue_Generation_Mechanism
|
[
-0.1232989058,
-1.1007301807,
0.9130011797,
0.0917255208,
-0.4760847986,
-0.0118092112,
0.0612962209,
-0.2904565334,
0.5653625727,
0.2930006087,
-0.4583112001,
-0.6119832993,
-0.7502353787,
-0.1381120682,
-0.0708026364,
0.7120162249,
0.4061259925,
0.5321473479,
-0.683999002,
-0.3149050176,
-0.6971724629,
-0.6080147028,
-1.0860285759,
-0.4250386655,
0.6211503148,
0.1687475294,
0.8655840158,
0.6018174291,
0.6903680563,
0.3811513186,
-0.0663792491,
0.4992453158,
-0.1276285797,
0.3376641273,
0.146896556,
-0.531673193,
-0.6467916965,
-0.4024797082,
0.3799391687,
0.6487193704,
-0.1966052502,
-0.1520193517,
-0.1976029873,
0.6932990551,
-0.1814346761,
0.4771683216,
-0.5043129325,
0.102240853,
0.0347506776,
-0.2865776122,
-0.3546801209,
-0.4660707116,
0.1502191275,
-0.5807448626,
-0.2647303045,
-0.1501061469,
0.7500750422,
0.4385372102,
-0.212690413,
-0.5014278889,
-0.6129662991,
0.3449010551,
-1.0573462248,
0.1902691424,
0.3266711831,
0.6937981844,
-0.1965579838,
-0.8768318295,
-0.5573199987,
-0.4417766929,
-0.2228224725,
0.0776847824,
-0.3772421181,
0.3214916587,
0.037454322,
0.4016986489,
-0.3595914543,
0.2015577406,
-0.0748454705,
-0.1029238626,
0.0036841843,
0.3866537511,
0.6559625268,
-0.3571566939,
-0.1668116599,
0.1430255771,
-0.5967764854,
-0.3553457856,
-0.2355430126,
0.195487529,
-0.3355536163,
0.6633921266,
-0.3453535438,
0.8652620316,
0.0350118279,
-0.3859935403,
0.3613175452,
-0.4371950328,
-0.4601270556,
-0.2726340592,
1.1614644527,
0.5043023229,
-0.1689643562,
-0.1899811774,
0.1696757525,
0.0210588016,
0.4053292572,
-0.9477695823,
-0.2070357502,
0.3803708255,
-0.5488988161,
-0.4732217491,
-0.6577591896,
-0.5887944698,
-0.4622986019,
-0.2705239952,
0.533837378,
-0.7589126229,
-0.166195333,
-0.0053302152,
0.2355552316,
-0.1626813412,
0.1358225793,
-0.891197443,
0.003802646,
0.5789234042,
0.9196348786,
0.0115471892,
0.3936415911,
-0.4226720035,
-0.0764079466,
-0.1928529143,
0.5576198697,
-0.5694579482,
-0.3319502771,
-0.1264038384,
-0.2762655616,
-0.2651681006,
-0.7026649714,
0.4913100898,
-0.3797390163,
0.3283835948,
-0.0345278569,
-0.7958342433,
-0.3291245699,
0.4288779497,
-0.4668338001,
0.3911083937,
0.236431092,
-0.6345045567,
0.4296607375,
-1.0107648373,
-0.4466676116,
0.4315719903,
-0.4182903767,
-0.7061756849,
-0.1738261431,
0.6452934146,
0.7128222585,
-0.5658999085,
0.7671903372,
-0.3494655192,
0.1358582973,
0.2850309312,
-0.4887341857,
0.7543136477,
0.1890802979,
0.0104438085,
0.3379471302,
-0.8281172514,
0.0442430228,
0.1386535615,
-0.2621447742,
-0.2893897891,
0.1049869135,
-0.4736229479,
0.2966076732,
0.0984955356,
-0.3174885809,
0.2817427814,
-0.7170241475,
0.3947444558,
0.3415848911,
0.4480489194,
0.3387319744,
-0.3344348073,
0.5623809695,
0.1770533472,
0.5897983313,
-0.226321131,
-0.9481464028,
-0.7337018251,
-0.4788328111,
0.4042102098,
0.5795112252,
-0.9215263724,
0.5690462589,
-0.2185333222,
-0.5515300035,
-0.7915341854,
-0.1895951927,
0.5117154121,
0.9233723283,
0.283606112,
-0.1451347172,
-0.5853154063,
-0.9170066118,
0.2796933949,
-0.2988991737,
-0.3997695148,
0.7318941951,
-0.0831301883,
-0.6322102547,
0.7920108438,
-0.4046248794,
-0.3967136443,
-0.2435798049,
0.1579409093,
0.1016148254,
0.5758391023,
0.5296372175,
-0.5472589731,
-0.2516418099,
0.2244145125,
-1.1038515568,
-0.046833802,
-0.1355022341,
-0.2327183038,
0.0243314691,
0.362018019,
-0.7563185692,
0.2339216769,
0.72441715,
-0.2665533721,
0.1460940689,
-0.3104278147,
0.24918966,
-1.6634756327,
0.0646783635,
-0.3356571198,
-0.2791624665,
-0.7201594114,
0.0917589366,
-0.0896689594,
-0.3151055872,
-0.1919282526,
0.2705200016,
-0.0122380182,
0.2667093575,
-0.1654811203,
0.1933547258,
-0.2204770893,
0.5778269172,
-0.158704713,
0.4413113892,
0.8093865514,
-0.7204898596,
0.3896341324,
0.3817808628,
-0.0964206606,
0.7997550964,
-0.5231994987,
0.2015144676,
0.129705146,
0.0871613622,
-0.7514987588,
-0.0641310364,
0.5714794993,
-0.797078073,
0.2409385443,
-0.2621250451,
-0.5312233567,
-0.3562480211,
0.4313278794,
0.2973335385,
0.4562629759,
-0.3488458991,
0.8882634044,
0.6014020443,
-0.2626393139,
-0.1425098032,
-0.2923674285,
0.2069746405,
-0.0600486062,
-0.7697829008,
0.0376168638,
-0.1251143664,
0.0427355245,
-0.161975801,
0.0357634984,
-0.1793988496,
-0.0897523612,
0.4491615593,
0.6057009101,
-0.3968208134,
0.5111498833,
0.3537869453,
-0.2316923141,
0.1039884165,
-0.3246193528,
0.7427795529,
0.27411744,
-0.4588841796,
-0.6849716902,
0.2814976871,
0.9383906126,
0.0594799258,
0.9048233628,
0.4298720956,
-0.3197138608,
0.262632072,
-0.5369445682,
-0.4242109358,
-0.4373055398,
0.3465082943,
-0.1510918438,
-0.8507228494,
0.4532158673,
-0.3284415305,
0.0099764802,
0.4354227185,
0.8811454177,
-0.0099950824,
1.168007493,
0.5003063679,
-0.2073603272,
0.0571246967,
-0.0339874253,
0.3349987268,
-0.548643887,
-0.4528045058,
-0.347584933,
-0.199654758,
-0.2943719029,
-0.7746052742,
0.7739754915,
-0.2082397044,
0.2812417448,
0.0738522634,
-0.4828096032,
0.0412843302,
0.4380914867,
0.2445487827,
0.2770921588,
-0.2648918331,
-0.5627419353,
-0.0308288764,
-0.9141824841,
-0.0645892695,
1.2093303204,
0.2676226795,
0.3801855147,
-0.0898141339,
0.4089676738,
0.1663846672,
0.4147294462,
-0.9133117199,
0.6169017553,
-0.0796492025,
-0.2786787748,
-0.2797678113,
-0.7394708395,
-0.842576921,
0.1023410931,
-0.361859262,
-0.3397165537,
-0.0944527537,
0.2480003536,
-0.346758455,
0.3163177073,
-0.7735502124,
0.722953558,
0.0554003417,
0.438129127,
-0.3438171446,
-0.6219314337,
0.3760429919,
-0.2468283474,
-0.0692018345,
-0.0579965971,
0.2162984163,
0.5954514742,
-0.7607263923,
0.8231444955,
-0.4343253672,
0.0974713191,
0.0217962284,
-0.1546753943,
0.5635256767,
0.236790657,
0.3752470315,
0.2963480055,
-0.2632092237,
-0.086792469,
-0.928434968,
0.4065135121,
-0.38885957,
-0.4003259838,
0.1338248104,
-0.6963027716,
-0.6426203847,
0.0917598009,
0.1704515368,
0.5233957767,
-0.0804724321,
0.2474206686,
0.6110737324,
-0.3845500648,
0.0489823967,
0.827172339,
-0.2783050537,
-0.3377629817,
0.7797600627,
-0.1410650164,
0.4230451882,
0.7179852128,
0.3527518511,
-0.0855821669,
-0.6316875815,
-0.6829465628,
0.0966592059,
-0.4462606609,
-0.60687989,
-1.0780258179,
-0.5470660329,
-0.2920052707,
0.0259458795,
-0.3204053044,
-0.4187945127,
-0.1914349645,
-0.0971629322,
0.5201284885,
0.4224448502,
0.1416165531,
0.2655746341,
-0.7441318035,
0.6399543881,
0.5424158573,
0.3172573745,
0.0145001365,
-0.1911403388,
-0.1409891695,
0.0563043654,
-0.0637774765,
-0.6453418136,
0.3530328274,
-0.2237846106,
0.4131866395,
0.7766961455,
-0.1390957087,
0.6857429147,
-0.5963766575,
0.4746325314,
0.4439556003,
-0.621206522,
0.5985867977,
-0.2030115277,
0.4215203822,
0.3246347904,
0.2757288516,
-0.6536108851,
-0.9702140689,
-0.4834481776,
-0.5925013423,
0.3959825635,
0.274425894,
0.0837504044,
-0.153397426,
0.0977812335,
-0.0283260718,
-0.030136751,
-0.2760763466,
-0.4011463523,
0.1872638315,
-0.3364759386,
0.2673500478,
-0.3983566761,
-0.3481228054,
-0.2852356434,
0.6139919162,
-0.1708520651,
0.4650751054,
0.1525869519,
0.2574456632,
0.1143618822,
0.2365954518,
0.5599092245,
0.5514950752,
0.0240949858,
-0.3914697468,
-0.0136654694,
-0.6216879487,
-0.097326979,
0.2228893787,
-0.3729479611,
0.1986009926,
-0.0679983869,
0.8309580684,
0.267516315,
-0.6880974174,
0.4001354277,
-0.2986700535,
-0.2809897363,
0.0505919084,
-0.08754576,
0.359634459,
0.2364313304,
-0.043378409,
0.4015314877,
0.2205670327,
-0.1600231528,
0.3710608482,
0.535048008,
-0.3560502529,
0.0396909006,
0.7286475897,
0.3489413857,
-0.4192728102,
0.6940476298,
-0.165372625,
-0.1131989583,
0.334654212,
0.3957600594,
0.7728338242,
-0.2890646756,
0.4677200913,
0.3623909652,
0.0971159488,
0.2755892873,
0.0619233958,
-0.0697622448,
-0.6932761073,
-0.5804234147,
-0.5771078467,
-0.4414069355,
0.2669872046,
-0.3103944957,
-0.147836715,
-0.3781295419,
-0.2657417953,
0.4358379245,
-0.3652945459,
-0.4254603684,
0.1024151742,
-0.067959033,
0.5569036007,
-0.5080094337,
0.9201000333,
0.2128533125,
-0.4444000721,
-0.9254825711,
-0.2075660974,
0.0386429988,
-1.1191375256,
0.3778842986,
-0.1942327321,
0.220341906,
-0.4392701089,
-0.2386687249,
-0.6422407627,
0.8520928621,
0.3684966862,
-0.6663669348,
-0.2082347721,
0.2576777041,
0.5915578604,
-0.48379457,
-0.1071998328,
0.3074617386,
0.2951787412,
0.312600702,
-0.987449646,
0.1877429187,
-0.2631653845,
-0.1548907012,
0.1791768521,
-0.1777213067,
0.3162735701,
-0.2094461322,
-0.0704102591,
0.2822158933,
0.3898066878,
0.2371931672,
0.2669126987,
0.4922049344,
0.7526583076,
0.8561726213,
-0.1093582213,
1.0290505886,
-0.4194968641,
0.0201795995,
0.8133891821,
0.0415379293,
0.4471265078,
0.2072213143,
-0.2418705672,
0.4804001153,
0.0375890173,
0.0422411896,
0.2678614557,
0.0732414126,
-0.6513541341,
-0.167789638,
0.0231425408,
-0.2913759053,
0.3904573917,
0.6095675826,
-0.7612282038,
-0.0513299927,
0.3194200695,
0.3247132897,
-0.1794243604,
-0.2748440504,
1.2840327024,
-0.0167790633,
-0.7176523805,
0.6404378414,
-0.1421867013,
0.4392565787,
-0.8943734169,
-0.1603277773,
-0.1678132713,
0.0462836958,
0.1330062151,
-0.2584649026,
0.2948585749,
-0.3041161597,
-0.2286737263,
0.1345874071,
0.7592331171,
-0.4523070455,
-0.5994043946,
0.0107357567,
0.5539249778,
0.1778443754,
-0.0628750995,
-0.8371963501,
-0.2481667548,
-0.0573445223,
0.3222959042,
0.3923127949,
0.5405620337,
0.1848255396,
0.9206925035,
0.7967726588,
0.0771373659,
-0.134215638,
0.5306198001,
0.9215797186,
-0.3330949843,
-0.4876611233,
-0.712107718,
0.2794383168,
-0.1904780865,
0.055124376,
0.4590139091,
0.5154389739,
0.123317793,
-0.0618906096,
0.4302453697,
-0.088309586,
0.5870887637,
-0.6186891794,
1.2312376499,
-0.1941525638,
0.0756886899,
-0.0983286947,
-0.1930628866,
-0.4660020471,
0.1980032027,
0.0928904414,
0.1057423726,
0.6695917249,
0.7641233802,
0.2328411192,
-0.0686382055,
0.7698460221,
0.3997510672,
0.3195021152,
0.5146548748,
0.182711184,
-0.0232182145,
0.6067216396,
-0.0912864357,
-0.216888532,
-0.2483908087,
-0.4041239321,
-0.878893137,
-0.6615555286,
-0.2572264373,
-0.2682428062,
0.1639423519,
0.5141465068,
1.1093289852,
-0.5215170383,
0.3787496984,
-0.235225141,
0.0469808131,
-0.4385097325,
-0.234291181,
0.3680747449,
-0.6282663345,
-0.4698496163,
0.5613573194,
0.6693328619,
-0.0807757601,
-0.2650746107,
0.0095273172,
0.0559419543,
0.1497678161,
0.7199579477,
0.1538634747,
-0.575498879,
-0.0538017862,
-0.2588059902,
-0.0738347396,
0.2572386265,
0.9708558321,
-0.9378406405,
0.918397963,
0.1253763586,
0.909881413,
0.1882562041,
-0.2103214711,
0.7404584885,
-0.7698213458,
-0.0318096727,
0.4417739809,
0.3817412853,
0.2875428796,
-0.4708066881,
0.3386565149,
0.1411455572,
-0.5729256868,
-0.4587846398,
0.1056582853,
-1.1640776396,
-0.032070417,
0.8434258699,
-0.1579954624,
0.0520048402,
-0.1388745606,
-0.3138257265,
0.342479527,
-0.3043617606,
0.9094244242,
0.2889355421,
-0.1510027945,
-0.1281630099,
-0.5107334256,
0.5926319957,
0.383135438,
-1.188361764,
-0.1109218672,
0.4360159934,
0.1635871828,
0.1951329261,
1.0360502005,
-0.4879278839,
0.4073118567,
0.0084491856,
-0.1195122898,
-0.1810137779,
-0.0365148261,
-0.0823882669,
0.2675622106,
-0.2549933195,
-0.577167809
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2312.02441v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2312.02441v1
|
MedDM:LLM-executable clinical guidance tree for clinical decision-making
| 2023-12-05T02:44:07 | 2023-12-05T02:44:07 |
Binbin Li, Tianxin Meng, Xiaoming Shi, Jie Zhai, Tong Ruan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
It is becoming increasingly emphasis on the importance of LLM participating
in clinical diagnosis decision-making. However, the low specialization refers
to that current medical LLMs can not provide specific medical advice, which are
more like a medical Q\&A. And there is no suitable clinical guidance tree data
set that can be used directly with LLM. To address this issue, we first propose
LLM-executavle clinical guidance tree(CGT), which can be directly used by large
language models, and construct medical diagnostic decision-making dataset
(MedDM), from flowcharts in clinical practice guidelines. We propose an
approach to screen flowcharts from medical literature, followed by their
identification and conversion into standardized diagnostic decision trees.
Constructed a knowledge base with 1202 decision trees, which came from 5000
medical literature and covered 12 hospital departments, including internal
medicine, surgery, psychiatry, and over 500 diseases.Moreover, we propose a
method for reasoning on LLM-executable CGT and a Patient-LLM multi-turn
dialogue framework.
|
[
-0.195875138,
-0.7886244059,
1.0444996357,
0.0106361257,
-0.5643072128,
0.0210955795,
-0.0665128082,
-0.2069391459,
0.3791395426,
0.5356088281,
-0.7238824368,
-1.1264971495,
-0.5481027365,
0.0268051066,
-0.2069273591,
0.9787265658,
-0.1174340099,
0.4566309452,
-0.3410249949,
-0.0009171407,
-0.4227730334,
-0.4145651162,
-1.0160102844,
-0.1197938547,
0.544891119,
0.5074052215,
0.6429332495,
0.6183565855,
0.6047847271,
0.1678123176,
-0.1230000407,
0.3668026626,
-0.2460129112,
0.2539865077,
-0.1138843298,
-0.5751076341,
-0.8266432285,
-0.1454582065,
0.2914636135,
0.6926319599,
-0.2489905357,
-0.0427175425,
-0.0732329115,
0.6213397384,
-0.0128602302,
0.2215693742,
-0.3255512416,
0.3837851584,
-0.2500446141,
-0.5658202171,
-0.4459124207,
-0.582546711,
0.3215834498,
-0.564519763,
0.1886823475,
-0.0821405053,
0.5095751882,
0.3862793446,
-0.4083363414,
-0.6009147167,
-0.5533950925,
0.3422726989,
-0.6432539225,
0.0262634959,
0.4441463351,
0.7085384727,
-0.0680795163,
-0.7787959576,
0.2853985727,
-0.2283498943,
-0.231443435,
0.3130203784,
0.0559580699,
0.4447199404,
0.3052786589,
0.1932736784,
-0.4911127687,
0.244072184,
-0.3063798249,
-0.1001593694,
0.4664744437,
0.6812707782,
0.1988698542,
-0.0450042896,
-0.2935028076,
0.2236230671,
-0.8976026177,
-0.1274576336,
-0.3879536092,
-0.0188379418,
-0.081390433,
0.526753366,
-0.0101231402,
0.6572954655,
0.0777817369,
-0.5308145285,
-0.0088195289,
-0.4733363092,
-0.4026185274,
0.1190393865,
0.5279420614,
0.5837765932,
0.1299838424,
0.1078565419,
0.0080658467,
0.0957131237,
0.162695244,
-0.7024302483,
-0.2897881269,
0.3263606429,
-0.7782785892,
-0.3062096834,
-0.4713769257,
-0.7585402131,
-0.6620588303,
-0.4099506438,
-0.1559293419,
-0.5446938276,
-0.0733417943,
0.097489655,
0.0430746041,
-0.0265467539,
0.898763597,
-0.4094310105,
0.2335909009,
0.3288824558,
0.6769379377,
-0.2251635194,
0.351377964,
-0.3961313665,
0.1985357255,
-0.4228755534,
0.8316904306,
-0.6501531601,
-0.7141618133,
-0.1473543942,
0.1134617329,
-0.0906918272,
-0.628919661,
0.749040246,
-0.0102272108,
0.1698461026,
-0.0363287106,
-0.6806266904,
-0.1456532925,
0.3392478228,
-0.3294816613,
0.3237499893,
0.2862685621,
-0.5803161263,
0.5370482802,
-0.6270033121,
-0.3165623546,
0.4433442652,
-0.7848192453,
-0.3940592706,
-0.1921378672,
0.2031528503,
0.5134136677,
-0.5612160563,
0.578522861,
-0.2029016614,
0.1538137645,
-0.3279325664,
-0.3868588209,
0.9164762497,
0.4562501311,
0.1055285111,
0.1512430161,
-0.5739995241,
0.0744528845,
-0.1536155343,
-0.4235256314,
-0.3455918133,
0.2545784712,
-0.288526088,
0.0553031415,
0.146229282,
-0.0987288356,
0.5133447647,
-0.1889049858,
0.1431480497,
0.6317762136,
0.1569092274,
-0.0474928431,
-0.5191557407,
1.0269192457,
0.3176904023,
0.333030045,
-0.0857572481,
-0.9432277679,
-0.6407387257,
-0.2940040231,
0.1291140169,
0.5995583534,
-0.743421793,
0.3065372109,
0.0670429468,
-0.4028781652,
-0.4709931612,
-0.2406015992,
0.3328864872,
0.6978211999,
0.1771125495,
-0.0664498135,
-0.5846135616,
-0.765434742,
0.2043967545,
-0.0994504392,
0.3396051526,
0.5911197662,
0.2030379176,
-0.3243013024,
0.8336437941,
-0.6716761589,
-0.5005407333,
-0.1971427053,
-0.3116885722,
0.5955215693,
0.2633782327,
0.604841888,
-0.3757844865,
-0.6397954226,
0.2355046421,
-0.8541396856,
-0.1790747941,
-0.0262812637,
-0.0967433974,
0.0546891503,
0.6524909735,
-0.5375906229,
0.4445253611,
0.3457188308,
-0.6725584865,
0.5465647578,
-0.4149887562,
-0.0132399146,
-1.0364557505,
-0.0081440452,
-0.0818172172,
-0.3717059791,
-0.4117336571,
-0.2693711817,
-0.098877795,
-0.0101857353,
-0.1542590857,
0.4963320792,
-0.1542040557,
0.2063474059,
0.2666310668,
0.0193449445,
-0.3253681064,
0.2478507012,
0.0640107319,
0.4045398533,
0.8575325608,
-0.653021574,
0.3648622334,
0.2801669538,
-0.3419647217,
1.0235691071,
-0.2315093726,
-0.3642745018,
-0.1519444585,
0.161128968,
-0.6091514826,
-0.0865089446,
0.4327615499,
-0.239080742,
0.381310761,
-0.4010626674,
-0.3314457536,
-0.4271791577,
-0.1051465198,
0.362823844,
0.5500135422,
-0.3554815948,
0.3698637784,
0.4789812267,
-0.4494224191,
-0.3007504642,
-0.4842259884,
-0.0247413497,
-0.3300748765,
-0.6047331691,
0.2909636497,
-0.2041246444,
-0.2591458857,
-0.009983887,
0.0211803038,
-0.0691340193,
-0.0283705629,
0.2345559895,
0.3716941178,
-0.3231537044,
0.230510816,
0.2181449085,
-0.2904418409,
0.2407647967,
-0.0426010899,
0.2017057538,
0.1463139802,
-0.6521778703,
-0.2898958027,
0.3259882033,
0.7255219817,
0.1175890192,
0.0987090245,
0.1611945778,
-0.3561329842,
-0.2321097851,
-0.1717678607,
0.0040464709,
-0.3807873726,
0.2976365983,
-0.1676276773,
-0.7377321124,
0.3086449802,
-0.2603614032,
0.1919298023,
0.2708361745,
0.7718381882,
-0.2562304139,
1.4680986404,
0.2147080898,
0.399384737,
0.0681861788,
-0.2721628249,
0.0113724116,
-0.6767383218,
-0.4381810129,
-0.3124187589,
-0.1337581724,
-0.5816793442,
-0.4469755888,
0.9250092506,
-0.0199508164,
-0.0543835871,
-0.0030291886,
-0.6989911795,
0.0832305774,
0.2899863124,
0.2916381061,
0.6058489084,
-0.0378748588,
-0.6983535886,
0.0207881033,
-0.8679434061,
-0.5616875291,
1.118909955,
0.4406952858,
0.8551620245,
-0.0561584234,
0.6035338044,
0.1736175269,
0.6573051214,
-0.9799390435,
0.5342140794,
-0.4379802942,
-0.4835608006,
0.0801035389,
-0.4216755033,
-1.0874644518,
0.187956363,
0.0070778904,
-0.5610383153,
0.0105699077,
0.1435286105,
-0.6328755021,
0.1390077621,
-0.8597683311,
0.7048210502,
-0.3370172679,
0.2046276331,
-0.245033592,
-0.4558420181,
0.5247809291,
-0.1094097272,
0.382180959,
-0.1211426109,
-0.1410928369,
0.8059268594,
-0.7523283958,
0.8733157516,
-0.3189505041,
-0.1691818833,
0.2265324742,
0.0548873395,
0.3166653812,
0.412255913,
0.2115852088,
-0.3050791621,
0.5646843314,
0.0491279215,
-0.4737747312,
0.4262059331,
-0.5369864702,
-0.7811437249,
-0.3521266878,
-0.2811970413,
-0.6619254947,
0.127303049,
0.2037652135,
0.6934930682,
-0.2439710051,
-0.0571487546,
0.2696763575,
-0.181761235,
0.0688148513,
0.5735558271,
-0.5673242807,
-0.4283059537,
0.4903459549,
0.1336015314,
0.1239154041,
0.2110963911,
0.3074353635,
-0.2169656605,
-0.8984895349,
-0.3328457773,
0.2634626329,
-0.8647009134,
-0.3758057058,
-0.4010555446,
-0.5370965004,
0.0330526382,
-0.1294101626,
0.1840749681,
-0.2593952119,
-0.3494290113,
-0.0737943724,
0.5893265009,
0.8993656039,
0.1070013419,
0.1602166891,
-0.7977465391,
0.1897815764,
0.0437560044,
0.4257863164,
-0.1402212679,
-0.0759620667,
-0.2863425314,
0.0408651121,
-0.3140574992,
-0.7929449677,
0.2894489765,
-0.1435462683,
0.6185942292,
0.9368101954,
-0.0931037813,
0.6721885204,
-0.3202449381,
0.4247210324,
0.4567371607,
-0.3763705492,
0.6724642515,
-0.3366054893,
0.1036553979,
0.4027675688,
0.3105991781,
-0.4888827205,
-0.4112347066,
-0.77092278,
-0.2676679194,
0.7809668779,
-0.0372283868,
-0.5525323153,
-0.0219625253,
0.2629311681,
0.1082545221,
0.0773978457,
-0.196875006,
-0.371134609,
0.2631079555,
-0.4142930806,
-0.0468819216,
-0.0326396413,
-0.5095009208,
-0.7866620421,
0.2423368543,
-0.3386591971,
0.2600469589,
0.4192978442,
0.2501831651,
-0.0678560659,
0.1814228892,
0.3677403927,
0.7855631709,
-0.3162838221,
0.2742255032,
0.1155710742,
-0.7471037507,
0.1130059734,
-0.0229115356,
-0.1256581992,
0.2277507037,
0.3021454811,
0.4842857718,
-0.0327520743,
-0.691198349,
0.3552472889,
-0.05986505,
-0.4096304178,
-0.1827236861,
0.1632729173,
0.2719361782,
0.180308938,
-0.2384356111,
0.1863464713,
-0.0407490693,
-0.4645825624,
0.4121644795,
0.5460965037,
-0.6122452617,
-0.0307505485,
0.3768129647,
0.3780529201,
-0.1140988022,
0.5409542918,
-0.1695401371,
-0.0984782279,
0.8875337243,
0.4404339194,
0.5865342021,
-0.0152151538,
0.3844245076,
0.2718678713,
0.047716368,
0.1222047433,
0.4511148036,
0.1625630558,
-0.4617535174,
-0.5208917856,
-0.2478494942,
-0.5021152496,
0.2050907761,
-0.3758856952,
0.7578023076,
-0.8248211741,
-0.3637916446,
-0.0358114243,
-0.2237650007,
-0.5393137932,
0.3094263971,
0.1146746278,
1.2154070139,
-0.1993949711,
0.8830783963,
0.7652803063,
-0.2222713083,
-0.6146300435,
-0.3063102067,
0.1672334969,
-1.1327813864,
0.3596034348,
-0.0219954755,
0.1817047447,
0.0323288552,
-0.5398814678,
-0.5378519297,
1.3329827785,
0.3449840844,
-0.5996224284,
-0.2887686491,
-0.099375993,
0.4899503291,
-0.6945939064,
0.5342091322,
0.6713833213,
0.6360052228,
0.4812063873,
-0.9181224108,
0.17647627,
-0.026036378,
-0.4999139011,
0.3351173103,
-0.3151953816,
0.6577910185,
-0.4937740862,
-0.5325113535,
0.000223469,
-0.2957583666,
0.399617821,
0.2803268135,
0.3509153128,
0.7797241211,
1.0349609852,
-0.0218905956,
0.9346683621,
-0.3123863935,
0.1811824739,
0.7762436867,
-0.1290501803,
0.4504708052,
0.2181466818,
-0.4159617424,
0.3040583134,
0.9792509079,
-0.0198858865,
0.5803200006,
0.0886445493,
-0.3637830317,
-0.4958450198,
-0.1442769468,
-0.6280143261,
0.0259269346,
0.9403185844,
-0.790789485,
-0.5326334834,
-0.3374431133,
0.2108321488,
-0.449569732,
-0.5440993905,
0.731261313,
0.3446000814,
-0.7200109959,
0.7878486514,
-0.1378305852,
0.3377243876,
-0.6920687556,
-0.271409601,
-0.0737615973,
0.1577249467,
-0.5101041198,
-1.0020830631,
0.3300239444,
0.0092594074,
0.0941816941,
-0.3344009817,
0.5179032683,
-0.3123499751,
-0.5567942858,
0.1469886601,
1.0056143999,
0.261507988,
0.2989622056,
-0.6986863613,
-0.4808374047,
0.1997365355,
0.2233694941,
0.2027264088,
0.5921827555,
-0.1493780315,
0.8503751755,
0.4543553591,
0.3288660347,
-0.2736511827,
0.1490148306,
0.8785699606,
-0.6638286114,
-0.4554858208,
-0.8981181383,
0.1283215582,
-0.013018677,
-0.2656199336,
0.3942548037,
0.3592672646,
0.3284464478,
0.1005133986,
0.9914682508,
-0.0508514047,
0.5348361135,
-0.8369579315,
0.6875123382,
-0.4614011645,
0.322427541,
-0.0583822615,
-0.4583289027,
-0.3972072899,
0.3999407589,
-0.0628101528,
0.0379950292,
1.1532026529,
0.7411580682,
-0.0011145747,
0.1046451852,
0.346242696,
0.4573723376,
0.4375282228,
0.9430121779,
0.7678969502,
0.3111469448,
0.6145681143,
0.0364485644,
-0.489294529,
-0.3096399903,
-0.7427560687,
-0.9116636515,
-0.4121558666,
-0.5136517882,
-0.3861415386,
-0.1039281711,
1.0087549686,
0.899923861,
-0.6577036381,
-0.1816629618,
-0.2662257254,
0.4683091938,
-0.1695391685,
-0.1826538444,
0.6604946852,
-0.3156873286,
-0.2356665581,
0.3907303512,
0.4609644413,
0.2037421614,
-0.3662707806,
-0.2269096971,
0.0554846227,
-0.3257237673,
0.5260794163,
-0.0080917319,
-0.4916084707,
0.1292674243,
-0.311696887,
-0.1564629525,
0.4701558352,
1.0625617504,
-0.8417852521,
0.4744091928,
0.2624764442,
0.4167053103,
0.3226202428,
-0.1955821961,
0.6195457578,
-0.2655469477,
-0.2825248837,
0.5580803752,
0.5677498579,
-0.1505226046,
-0.3220512569,
0.5963151455,
0.398735255,
-0.3120388687,
-0.3629740477,
0.3139255345,
-0.9864000082,
-0.1764403433,
1.2172003984,
-0.1112337857,
-0.1494741887,
-0.5680530071,
-0.8533038497,
-0.1565313041,
-0.4426583052,
0.3317436576,
0.5832119584,
-0.8519875407,
-0.1803729087,
-0.6197806001,
1.0465694666,
0.2133904994,
-1.2134071589,
-0.0636148155,
0.5015373826,
0.1640165299,
-0.0610335991,
1.0369269848,
-0.4134712219,
0.2566187978,
-0.2556472123,
-0.4699622393,
0.1299030036,
-0.1524079144,
-0.1169946268,
0.033818163,
0.3446090221,
-0.0797210559
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.