id
stringlengths 33
34
| doc_url
stringlengths 33
34
| title
stringlengths 10
211
| publication_date
timestamp[s] | update_date
timestamp[s] | authors
stringlengths 5
20.1k
| category_primary
stringclasses 78
values | category_all
stringlengths 5
138
| abstract
stringlengths 123
3.09k
| embeddings
listlengths 768
768
|
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03932v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03932v2
|
CleanGraph: Human-in-the-loop Knowledge Graph Refinement and Completion
| 2024-05-07T01:40:23 | 2024-05-08T00:18:45 |
Tyler Bikaun, Michael Stewart, Wei Liu
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This paper presents CleanGraph, an interactive web-based tool designed to
facilitate the refinement and completion of knowledge graphs. Maintaining the
reliability of knowledge graphs, which are grounded in high-quality and
error-free facts, is crucial for real-world applications such as
question-answering and information retrieval systems. These graphs are often
automatically assembled from textual sources by extracting semantic triples via
information extraction. However, assuring the quality of these extracted
triples, especially when dealing with large or low-quality datasets, can pose a
significant challenge and adversely affect the performance of downstream
applications. CleanGraph allows users to perform Create, Read, Update, and
Delete (CRUD) operations on their graphs, as well as apply models in the form
of plugins for graph refinement and completion tasks. These functionalities
enable users to enhance the integrity and reliability of their graph data. A
demonstration of CleanGraph and its source code can be accessed at
https://github.com/nlp-tlp/CleanGraph under the MIT License.
|
[
-0.2889234722,
-0.6408028007,
0.4274471402,
-0.3235698342,
-0.0581136681,
0.504347682,
0.0295616593,
-0.5990206599,
0.1048377454,
0.7397427559,
-0.3771397769,
-0.8403512239,
-0.109808214,
0.1125066876,
-0.297280997,
0.8327511549,
-0.1426184922,
-0.3818093538,
-0.5625712872,
-0.09957508,
-0.4504439533,
0.019080637,
-0.6400585771,
-0.7239074707,
0.4216612875,
0.677552402,
0.991818428,
0.6778885722,
0.3191876411,
0.2478560805,
0.2265575081,
0.670244813,
-0.8192998767,
0.4769179523,
-0.4990649521,
-0.2071406692,
-0.4748542011,
-0.0012648212,
0.2982677221,
0.9952768087,
0.057200633,
0.3338467181,
0.187386319,
0.7346449494,
-0.5290499926,
0.3973728716,
-0.2891840041,
-0.3288655281,
-0.2375276685,
-0.0520096347,
-0.2340007126,
-0.9497466683,
0.0327077135,
-1.1527484655,
0.1119332016,
0.2993968427,
1.2217922211,
0.3384952545,
-0.5503353477,
-0.0536468104,
-0.5130813718,
0.2826497555,
-0.5496445298,
0.4407604337,
0.5202011466,
0.4661012888,
-0.3798342645,
-1.1430939436,
-0.5574276447,
0.1339886189,
-0.3968722522,
-0.0374771878,
-0.1176830381,
0.1870111376,
0.3664803505,
0.2256845683,
-0.2844783068,
-0.1267663389,
-0.6808065176,
-0.654303968,
0.5195359588,
0.1834958494,
0.4482884705,
-0.1538629979,
-0.2533501387,
0.0800982416,
-0.6835650206,
0.0151140932,
0.5940102339,
0.3034659028,
0.1910985261,
0.7166240811,
-0.9083883762,
1.0013090372,
-0.4422996342,
-0.3060846627,
0.5426806808,
-0.4324073195,
-0.0059782714,
-0.2579374909,
0.8683902621,
0.4052800834,
0.3627204597,
-0.4030463099,
-0.1998322606,
-0.2960728407,
0.2454787642,
-0.5060620308,
-0.7183684707,
0.4964500666,
-0.2350426167,
-0.40888834,
0.1766691953,
-0.6883031726,
-0.5888448954,
-0.6253516674,
0.2493072003,
-0.7454047203,
-0.1103071794,
0.1709269732,
-0.5958792567,
-0.213430956,
0.7669664621,
-0.1722473651,
0.4305151403,
0.4868761301,
0.6096172333,
0.2145851105,
-0.2364471406,
-0.4785553515,
0.6282667518,
-0.0980919003,
0.7344655991,
-0.2825868428,
-0.1244219691,
-0.1265684664,
-0.2973232865,
0.1762765944,
-0.39651528,
0.4928431809,
-0.8981983066,
0.1217649952,
-0.4771799445,
-0.7991612554,
-0.505402565,
0.3751556575,
-0.992112577,
1.0369234085,
0.424339205,
-1.0580260754,
0.5244842172,
-0.7687785029,
-0.4351593852,
0.2802861929,
0.0889564231,
-0.1992684305,
-0.6040322185,
0.0629823431,
0.1667700112,
-0.0957462788,
0.0868110806,
-0.7947080135,
-0.4407783151,
-0.1834212095,
0.3199583888,
1.0543521643,
0.3548368812,
-0.0443998724,
0.1987934411,
-0.8013226986,
0.4636769295,
0.0934097543,
-0.235356763,
-0.1849954724,
-0.0152986217,
-0.3884909451,
0.3081173897,
0.4394560754,
-0.744787693,
0.3045609891,
-0.0603783615,
0.3670600951,
0.5140300393,
0.3340687156,
-0.0713581964,
-0.3044052422,
0.3037010133,
-0.142062217,
0.2903504968,
-0.0296810903,
-0.6124184728,
-0.6497920752,
-0.3457745612,
0.6240452528,
0.7199784517,
-0.9052067399,
0.448266387,
-0.4706598818,
-0.5992744565,
-0.5024979115,
0.3578071892,
0.2788277268,
0.882370472,
0.3788005114,
-0.2298510522,
-0.3192261755,
-0.6987299919,
-0.2121576667,
-0.3175204396,
-0.320372045,
0.1995541304,
0.371833533,
-0.3262328506,
1.3966867924,
-0.9678294659,
-0.3531737626,
-0.0302507747,
0.00605954,
-0.179536134,
0.173477307,
0.1785719246,
-0.4984015524,
-0.2515556216,
0.0345991403,
-0.9880129099,
-0.1798915118,
0.5475025177,
-0.4546495378,
-0.2148612589,
0.5905795097,
-0.4103201628,
0.6545853615,
0.1154232472,
-0.4730699956,
0.6734842062,
-0.0913904086,
0.2517592609,
-0.6532644629,
0.5379280448,
-0.3896304071,
-0.8218334913,
-0.5214005709,
0.1554974616,
-0.0464038327,
-0.356446147,
-0.1644128859,
0.5942766666,
-0.191726774,
0.0246935058,
0.1835702211,
0.6495805979,
0.5062195063,
0.2870622873,
-0.5105978847,
0.4126158357,
0.175380215,
-0.4372024834,
0.592536211,
0.4344759881,
-0.1281376332,
0.4606837332,
-0.5684970021,
0.2299245745,
0.0075503523,
0.232675001,
-0.9288417101,
-0.7478041053,
0.3322019279,
-0.2701457143,
0.0737816319,
-0.2445961237,
-0.862118721,
-0.5459703803,
-0.2774985731,
0.0744184181,
0.2884962559,
-0.4562335312,
0.3491952121,
0.5290051103,
0.1666025221,
-0.5017690063,
-0.1274172664,
0.1099231541,
0.2649384737,
-0.9155424833,
0.0635729581,
0.2575436234,
-0.390488416,
0.3063720465,
0.086625047,
-0.1756045818,
0.1719374955,
0.248351872,
0.0286184456,
0.4388699532,
0.2791431248,
0.007220184,
-0.2080180347,
-0.2421441972,
-0.5693231821,
0.2292165905,
-0.145532921,
-0.5868864059,
-0.7801926136,
-0.0521711372,
0.5678391457,
-0.2743577361,
0.2801021039,
0.6287277341,
-0.5491089821,
-0.0936330184,
-0.5042908788,
-0.1206603572,
-0.4817673266,
-0.1111327633,
-0.2295655459,
-0.7812976241,
0.5678334236,
-0.2961674333,
0.1896770149,
0.4510100782,
0.0129023865,
-0.4216878414,
0.7377462983,
0.3065955043,
0.1825518012,
0.1201191321,
-0.319145292,
0.1419373006,
-0.6123162508,
-0.4125986397,
-0.5489566326,
-0.2739577293,
-0.19235228,
-0.1030117795,
0.1989420354,
0.5489589572,
-0.496076107,
0.154203549,
-0.6268182993,
0.3785622418,
0.8128379583,
0.3363056481,
0.631675899,
-0.1070545837,
-0.1947882324,
0.2114453763,
-0.363117516,
-0.7354021668,
0.8747487664,
0.1059886813,
0.7291629314,
0.1373404115,
0.9075148106,
0.4857640266,
0.2413889617,
-0.415931344,
0.5587908626,
0.1997758299,
-0.5556591749,
-0.546626389,
-0.5886645317,
-0.7807494998,
-0.0535162315,
-0.0849526599,
-0.7595004439,
-0.0639644787,
0.534295857,
-0.1791205257,
0.5837699771,
-0.8400784731,
0.9591876864,
0.233258307,
-0.4181129336,
-0.0535079874,
-0.7232320905,
0.5142513514,
0.1512095481,
0.1232790723,
-0.3703732193,
0.1267995685,
0.6246066093,
-0.9033911228,
0.9055415392,
-0.4138444066,
0.2450719029,
0.7515924573,
0.3838603199,
0.6100517511,
0.0029547284,
-0.1379493624,
0.2768754065,
0.0992517769,
-0.4376523197,
-0.6363535523,
0.354591012,
-0.8534321785,
-0.4125994146,
0.1609333754,
-0.3369297087,
-0.2417292446,
0.8769657612,
-0.1413699538,
0.5872822404,
0.0328766592,
-0.1546263993,
0.3662760854,
-0.0783507079,
-0.0623478554,
-0.0559086204,
-0.4707299769,
-0.5703734756,
0.9144073725,
0.0828437954,
0.4858011603,
0.0868260115,
0.0563352481,
-0.3194863796,
-0.4406588972,
-0.257281363,
0.2916236818,
-1.0694853067,
-0.5271083117,
-0.7051802278,
-0.0308807287,
-0.3244255185,
-0.0507080033,
-0.1147521287,
-0.8836185932,
-0.2276282907,
-0.29030478,
0.5193802118,
0.9657879472,
0.0902994499,
-0.0023015055,
-0.7196075916,
0.4259491563,
0.3877349198,
0.669113636,
-0.1414799541,
0.1355951726,
-0.2641249299,
0.1592214853,
-0.4762235284,
-0.8220793009,
0.06517113,
0.0383971669,
0.3140039742,
0.4080146551,
0.3764589727,
0.6908065677,
-0.1192798465,
0.5927962065,
-0.0011398389,
-0.7266072035,
0.551240623,
-0.6196474433,
0.2830343843,
1.1245951653,
0.0210077092,
-0.4700939655,
-0.7215899229,
-0.5659748316,
-0.7786813378,
0.5539508462,
0.1253813803,
-0.5887373686,
0.1258069724,
0.6006005406,
0.034180522,
0.2318892628,
-0.1254729331,
-0.1393702924,
-0.5894147158,
-0.2372986972,
0.6670446992,
-0.0744455382,
-0.5439293385,
-0.1683990806,
0.7989851832,
-0.4710685015,
-0.0322520062,
0.2045032531,
-0.2540511787,
0.0315788165,
0.023182191,
0.0891834497,
1.038643837,
-0.4285379946,
0.1846030056,
0.0652479678,
-0.4920245707,
-0.17552571,
0.1559379101,
-0.3821502626,
-0.2791412175,
0.529784739,
0.222961843,
0.1676695347,
-0.606785357,
0.5157999396,
0.0373657085,
-0.0023354804,
-0.2790241838,
0.3056313694,
0.1531521231,
-0.0986602828,
0.0786264315,
0.1772651821,
0.2010513842,
-0.172174409,
0.4723952413,
-0.0336130448,
-0.7370458245,
-0.1499872357,
0.8706589937,
0.4575608075,
-0.1204135939,
1.3666561842,
-0.6581189632,
-0.5136418343,
0.2321503758,
0.116879411,
0.5701200366,
0.3183479011,
0.0769598112,
0.5150662661,
-0.0093107754,
0.3124632239,
0.4970113337,
0.1253235191,
-0.7492670417,
-0.4947296381,
-0.4119439125,
-0.487752527,
-0.3980569839,
-0.4936861396,
0.5255960822,
-0.2641564906,
-0.3472872674,
-0.134519279,
0.2162972689,
-0.8018953204,
0.1922340244,
-0.2213824093,
1.1685113907,
-0.4641104341,
0.8528094292,
0.5873588324,
-0.5945842266,
-0.9236071706,
-0.3816767931,
0.2983299792,
-0.4262048304,
0.5857289433,
-0.0041036797,
-0.2963806689,
0.1973007321,
-0.4956668615,
-0.8389242291,
1.4205958843,
0.4446939826,
0.0450643897,
-0.1136304662,
0.0684667304,
0.3470441103,
0.068632789,
0.1964949965,
0.4661460221,
0.8334043026,
0.0910241753,
-0.9086132646,
0.2956967056,
-0.1900767684,
-0.4349629283,
0.2383634746,
-0.6031748056,
0.2974345982,
-0.5397090316,
-0.3837909997,
-0.3192374706,
0.6138138771,
0.3685797453,
0.0798038691,
0.7533960938,
0.8900432587,
1.3601480722,
-0.4116949737,
1.1403243542,
-0.4299815595,
0.3375263214,
1.1212881804,
-0.3236923814,
0.4076637924,
0.0055541722,
-0.1399675906,
0.7803786993,
0.5474421978,
0.0627925694,
0.1050717458,
0.0619677044,
-0.2157506198,
-0.3340481818,
-0.1740151644,
-0.0221301727,
0.2944302559,
0.2498217374,
0.1209190488,
-0.3467068076,
-0.4603093863,
0.3624207973,
-0.0806477889,
-0.1178532541,
0.6089872718,
-0.2719810605,
-0.610165894,
0.1773337424,
-0.2491278648,
0.000778836,
-0.5665380955,
-0.3245515525,
0.133273676,
-0.0593037084,
-0.6830126047,
-1.088296771,
0.3077921271,
-0.5481770635,
-0.0463388301,
-0.2246810496,
1.0387952328,
-0.3105840385,
-0.0168888234,
0.3329434991,
0.4333646894,
0.0226160809,
0.1099491045,
-0.5145165324,
-0.0898025259,
0.2380637378,
-0.2409977019,
-0.2681923807,
0.3952366412,
-0.204957664,
1.0821415186,
0.9380083084,
-0.0318181962,
-0.0543932058,
0.3560439944,
0.9905253649,
-0.6545892358,
-0.3595685363,
-0.3413302302,
0.73295331,
-0.6362837553,
-0.1159826219,
0.6986820102,
0.7434892058,
0.8458100557,
0.3121133447,
0.961387217,
-0.1788313389,
0.709391892,
-0.1651085615,
0.9744634628,
-0.2530874908,
0.0750883222,
-0.1793608814,
-0.5166652799,
-0.4625514746,
0.0201827455,
-0.0083327871,
0.0224106498,
0.6152967215,
0.5978209972,
0.0410747379,
0.1632853001,
0.016791828,
0.0971060544,
0.7594281435,
0.0367027074,
0.598634541,
-0.180734694,
0.7428426743,
-0.4678984284,
-0.2422392666,
-0.0558440126,
-0.7632077336,
-0.5830767751,
-0.4176530838,
-0.4836398065,
-0.7134883404,
-0.2318708152,
0.5882207155,
0.723703146,
-0.5375602245,
0.0244124513,
0.2387598455,
0.7913131118,
-0.2728019059,
-0.3152413666,
0.5187055469,
-0.6160641313,
-0.2568859458,
0.1688343734,
0.2868590355,
-0.1974662542,
-0.0647353381,
0.1811118722,
-0.0800616294,
-0.3349345028,
0.3391860723,
0.5121067762,
-0.4253122807,
-0.6810305119,
-0.3119807541,
-0.1392321736,
0.0001136874,
0.7465308905,
-0.9584835768,
0.9489161372,
0.7322634459,
0.2422444671,
0.5111855268,
0.3099374771,
0.6967197657,
-0.789198935,
-0.2061674893,
0.0613508932,
0.4898489416,
0.4934451282,
-0.3702282608,
0.8726517558,
0.3781611025,
-0.6108182669,
-0.6943139434,
0.2440801859,
-0.8933559656,
-0.1829295009,
0.9046714306,
-0.1807077676,
-0.2429795414,
-0.9719592333,
-0.2180222869,
0.4830970466,
-0.4140691459,
0.4909296334,
0.5842840075,
-0.4190526605,
0.4455670118,
-0.5948973894,
0.571782887,
-0.6177885532,
-1.0796334743,
0.2467262447,
0.8039669394,
0.681129396,
0.4128103852,
0.7087436914,
-0.324036628,
0.1436376125,
-0.1093951389,
0.5868058801,
-0.6489274502,
-0.1413820684,
0.3101923764,
0.4698520303,
0.1098621711,
0.1951175481
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03920v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03920v1
|
A Roadmap for Multilingual, Multimodal Domain Independent Deception Detection
| 2024-05-07T00:38:34 | 2024-05-07T00:38:34 |
Dainis Boumber, Rakesh M. Verma, Fatima Zahra Qachfar
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.MM, I.2.6; I.2.7; I.2.10; K.4.4
|
Deception, a prevalent aspect of human communication, has undergone a
significant transformation in the digital age. With the globalization of online
interactions, individuals are communicating in multiple languages and mixing
languages on social media, with varied data becoming available in each language
and dialect. At the same time, the techniques for detecting deception are
similar across the board. Recent studies have shown the possibility of the
existence of universal linguistic cues to deception across domains within the
English language; however, the existence of such cues in other languages
remains unknown. Furthermore, the practical task of deception detection in
low-resource languages is not a well-studied problem due to the lack of labeled
data. Another dimension of deception is multimodality. For example, a picture
with an altered caption in fake news or disinformation may exist. This paper
calls for a comprehensive investigation into the complexities of deceptive
language across linguistic boundaries and modalities within the realm of
computer security and natural language processing and the possibility of using
multilingual transformer models and labeled data in various languages to
universally address the task of deception detection.
|
[
-0.5819555521,
-0.8886194229,
0.3486175537,
0.4460744858,
-0.0168097671,
0.2947838306,
-0.1348806918,
-0.7196391225,
0.2063221037,
0.6218034625,
-0.8963481188,
-0.3271121383,
-0.7351903319,
0.16743204,
-0.0583267398,
0.7933962345,
-0.0693648905,
0.2198871672,
-0.3152467012,
-0.230728507,
-0.4008567035,
-0.6732641459,
-0.4975272119,
-0.3519588411,
0.3636373281,
0.2134460062,
0.7141099572,
0.1757310629,
0.6103643179,
0.3945942223,
0.4247305095,
0.3546849489,
-0.2026116401,
0.0944206789,
-0.2705868483,
-0.46238482,
-0.1672161371,
0.1792436689,
0.3533245325,
0.4978704751,
0.0950257853,
-0.0266424138,
-0.249637723,
0.392021507,
-0.7184668183,
0.3225907683,
-0.4537829161,
-0.2095846683,
-0.1993658245,
-0.2475497425,
-0.5927381516,
-0.2086698264,
-0.1463691592,
-0.5551708341,
0.2694905698,
-0.1034467593,
0.6340278983,
0.1077907905,
-1.0458629131,
-0.5325655341,
-0.8252646923,
0.8368023038,
-0.1918949634,
0.5991594791,
0.4872025847,
0.4930219054,
0.0112634711,
-0.6731656194,
-0.6455282569,
-0.1513821185,
-0.2191539258,
-0.0042775907,
-0.4064716995,
-0.1220791191,
0.0275662988,
0.025140509,
-0.4825160205,
-0.1057098135,
-0.130376339,
-0.707133472,
0.6380957961,
-0.0894535854,
0.5857637525,
0.054748442,
-0.5933277607,
-0.1217821836,
-0.4535877109,
-0.1422562897,
0.5389582515,
0.2272288352,
-0.3169559836,
0.123607561,
-0.155068472,
0.6127699018,
-0.0544197224,
-0.5802353621,
0.2629808784,
-0.5619017482,
0.0986313075,
-0.0640771464,
0.6999537945,
0.3856201768,
0.1726321429,
0.0438655913,
-0.2294015288,
0.6941065788,
0.1387271732,
-0.596047461,
-0.2798349857,
0.081244953,
-0.4716900587,
-0.2206130475,
0.0404515974,
-0.8588122725,
-0.6528136134,
-0.3753599524,
0.3524238765,
-0.511501193,
-0.5859287381,
0.1310815662,
-0.0609467998,
0.2496726811,
0.3319503665,
-0.4258384407,
0.1626942605,
0.4230538011,
0.369725436,
-0.237790823,
-0.3058253527,
-0.3322173953,
0.0445726514,
-0.134871617,
0.6995601654,
-0.7611092925,
-0.1570602953,
0.1506014615,
0.3051604629,
-0.1180597395,
-0.2832194567,
0.8264554143,
-0.6438435316,
0.4813607633,
-0.1085453779,
-0.1223924831,
-0.5673338175,
0.6983772516,
-0.937905848,
0.4905916452,
-0.151857689,
-0.5564973354,
0.0780872405,
-0.596870482,
-0.6146558523,
0.0631605834,
-0.1291493326,
-0.4755040407,
-0.0371328741,
0.3790428638,
0.3075408041,
-0.2471335679,
0.2604104578,
-0.012119255,
-0.0855897218,
0.7692885399,
-1.0308873653,
0.9828990102,
0.2032922953,
-0.5185875297,
-0.2011675984,
-0.6907548904,
0.0253047533,
0.1479982436,
-0.258130759,
-0.4405988455,
-0.2772450447,
0.4053229392,
0.2699786425,
0.3979398906,
-0.5606316328,
0.1187744141,
0.0828305334,
0.0845423788,
0.4709610343,
0.0814366192,
0.2665624619,
-0.1773227304,
0.7207320333,
0.4234675765,
0.4915941358,
-0.5432770252,
-0.6214625239,
-0.6824288964,
-0.4514540136,
0.3138710558,
0.6008442044,
-1.2264317274,
0.0588005818,
-0.2479261011,
-0.1118032336,
-0.6682664752,
-0.1862415224,
0.5865675807,
0.0280486178,
0.3130731285,
-0.089175947,
-0.4858119786,
-1.1568825245,
-0.4732001722,
-0.0178217143,
0.2082378119,
-0.2385492027,
0.4457767606,
-0.5196018815,
0.6189930439,
-0.3519560695,
-0.6669903994,
-0.1735220253,
0.2308942229,
-0.190062806,
0.3333118856,
0.4488513768,
-1.5466455221,
-0.71903795,
0.0785324648,
-0.8046759367,
0.015988091,
-0.3627967536,
0.2020804286,
0.3051820993,
0.3896246254,
-0.5294771194,
0.3403208852,
0.8256127238,
-0.4102650881,
0.522366941,
-0.0886220634,
0.6507487297,
-0.8170401454,
-0.2357717305,
0.112455003,
-0.1531829387,
-1.1308153868,
0.4133141637,
0.2623030543,
0.0038668485,
-0.4964247346,
0.3571351171,
-0.8866088986,
0.3748945296,
-0.2216401547,
0.0515847094,
0.0613335334,
0.5052208304,
-0.0529976562,
0.5603145957,
0.7237189412,
-0.4110919237,
0.5179671049,
0.1217228696,
-0.2732926011,
1.0942755938,
-0.1098554879,
0.1480575055,
-0.3481273651,
0.2382438332,
-1.0780937672,
-0.2845748663,
0.522221148,
-0.6528567672,
0.3918398023,
-0.1596771777,
-0.4141002297,
-0.1203199923,
-0.2509076595,
0.539175272,
0.1175931767,
-0.5459719896,
0.9457387328,
0.2839283049,
0.1884246767,
-0.7873256207,
-0.8088755608,
0.3833616376,
-0.1425199509,
-0.8531441092,
0.3242523074,
-0.210987553,
-0.4263324738,
-0.2821249962,
0.0327224582,
-0.381613791,
-0.0203524567,
0.2070967257,
0.2527025938,
0.0914010331,
-0.0822924152,
-0.179678902,
-0.2959108055,
0.1733306646,
-0.0815275162,
0.3582324982,
-0.0793070868,
-0.5990831256,
-0.6389827132,
0.6753940582,
0.7648410797,
-0.3998275399,
0.6195374727,
0.8720518947,
-0.5209451318,
-0.1348171681,
-0.7391552925,
-0.2054896504,
-0.5136721134,
0.0093691396,
-0.6542927027,
-0.6498355269,
0.5644232035,
-0.2060341239,
-0.3699405491,
0.1182362065,
0.5425954461,
0.3707506657,
1.2059854269,
0.9815096855,
0.1248340011,
0.1374674588,
0.0482601225,
0.5738839507,
-0.1958564669,
-0.5308015347,
-0.2466433048,
-0.178873077,
-0.8734643459,
-0.5510112643,
0.6095738411,
-0.2573827803,
0.4892593622,
0.3147725165,
-0.4957988858,
0.6152464747,
0.4352244735,
-0.0885048062,
0.6566807032,
0.1345742494,
0.1028504968,
-0.2965407968,
-0.3097494841,
-0.3607644141,
0.8306690454,
0.2557504177,
0.7537786365,
0.3275179565,
0.2713480294,
0.4925982654,
0.2758411467,
-0.6110611558,
0.4932086766,
0.094053857,
-0.9388597012,
-0.0176131409,
-0.2293536514,
-1.0147174597,
0.608360827,
-0.0590056889,
-0.4485071898,
0.2388542295,
-0.1634698808,
0.1421947628,
0.1828233153,
-0.7067341805,
0.8222147822,
-0.3298312426,
-0.1243653297,
-0.2537577748,
-0.8232675791,
0.5801376104,
-0.294855088,
0.6599795818,
-0.1880997419,
-0.0366476178,
0.3701625168,
0.1431151778,
1.1372518539,
-0.208177343,
-0.3959533572,
0.1026017219,
0.4026598036,
0.4856370986,
-0.1067864969,
0.4249488413,
0.3813770711,
0.0970889032,
-0.319511354,
-0.3654306531,
0.6698355079,
-0.4374166429,
-0.3644909561,
-0.4937418401,
-0.5124900341,
-0.4685980678,
0.1653310359,
0.2562113106,
0.3446791172,
-0.4132665098,
-0.066295594,
0.8458285332,
-0.322640717,
0.3500552177,
0.8109229803,
-0.1089366674,
-0.2195162773,
1.1394971609,
-0.23778373,
0.2344898432,
0.4663751721,
0.1146697924,
-0.3804802299,
-0.1539820731,
-0.324447304,
0.4260883629,
-1.0399779081,
-0.1654558182,
-0.4053032696,
0.032028947,
-0.44395262,
-0.0406245291,
-0.2253115028,
-0.2229471505,
0.0238029994,
0.1449619979,
0.0533649847,
0.6385092139,
-0.1471949667,
0.2626568675,
-0.7167590261,
0.666983664,
0.1644237339,
0.1509322822,
-0.3193302155,
-0.166945219,
-0.0806079581,
0.409222573,
-0.2895562649,
-0.914909184,
0.3675658703,
0.0944927558,
0.7102898359,
0.4895066023,
0.0824889466,
0.3395434618,
-0.3278957903,
0.6748967767,
0.4547300041,
-0.8479781747,
0.3835280538,
-0.225648582,
0.1193124205,
0.2061037123,
0.9489170313,
-0.962090373,
-0.3512243032,
-0.4976670146,
-0.3747711182,
0.5267779231,
0.1084075272,
0.2544512153,
0.2033166885,
-0.3303422332,
0.438442111,
0.2950592935,
-1.1906369925,
-0.519790411,
-0.0329190828,
-0.1084484309,
0.0133646494,
-0.013854865,
-0.4654648006,
0.0030038808,
0.4633123875,
-0.403034687,
0.406252414,
-0.1010675281,
-0.3137435913,
-0.0110644754,
0.3200573921,
0.6388681531,
0.7277095318,
0.4641754031,
0.4200461209,
-0.3677099049,
-0.4194124639,
0.3160943687,
0.0740072355,
-0.2288250178,
0.1863852739,
0.5044503212,
0.5685384274,
-0.1157876328,
-0.6165004969,
0.8804561496,
-0.018400846,
-0.3239500225,
-0.4058507085,
-0.4015250504,
-0.1289370805,
0.2288895994,
0.483022958,
0.2182133049,
0.1416375488,
-0.7173863649,
0.2131496966,
0.622037828,
-0.3165427744,
-0.5769708157,
0.6191250682,
0.2470987588,
-0.2533481419,
0.4675053358,
-0.357442826,
-0.8561438918,
0.2535832822,
0.5721908212,
0.682354629,
-0.6608849168,
0.6420846581,
-0.1728469431,
0.7698802948,
0.0008936049,
0.3159665763,
-0.0179414265,
-1.0594297647,
-0.3051955998,
-0.271658659,
-0.1316573918,
0.181224823,
-0.4401746094,
0.1029370949,
-0.1433008015,
-0.0679767355,
0.202396214,
-0.3756678402,
-0.7008395195,
0.2613064945,
0.5025005341,
0.5668619275,
-0.8879657388,
0.7111923695,
0.5303658247,
-0.3429141045,
0.0026576745,
0.0029659471,
0.5202730894,
-0.9354604483,
0.580663085,
0.2821485698,
-0.4515691698,
-0.2893000841,
-0.6409947872,
-0.585873127,
0.5991914272,
0.3753513098,
-0.1736106426,
0.1376940459,
0.7467082739,
0.543038547,
-0.2730447054,
-0.0795421153,
0.5291703343,
0.8019473553,
-0.0548859127,
-0.8650631309,
0.1154714227,
-0.1021624058,
-0.1736150235,
0.3827708662,
-0.6665828824,
0.8756096959,
0.0952543244,
-0.5785062909,
-0.2694757879,
0.3414114118,
-0.2924744189,
0.4468765855,
0.4054612517,
0.3157044053,
0.5280116796,
-0.3971172571,
0.7744362354,
-0.2204188854,
0.1627777964,
0.5823410153,
-0.1865025014,
0.3173258901,
0.4189942479,
-0.0004508868,
0.6542602181,
0.3911441267,
-0.0242878869,
0.5073443651,
-0.0709757954,
-0.491346091,
-0.5101903081,
-0.3329248428,
-0.0172953811,
0.6511006951,
0.6880905628,
-0.1547416449,
-0.243226856,
0.5529054999,
0.1029398963,
0.2542776763,
-0.191053167,
0.515560627,
-0.1031728983,
-0.6353490353,
0.6501991749,
0.4080388248,
0.9101460576,
-0.731310904,
0.0172496364,
-0.0992750823,
0.4153307378,
-0.2041255385,
-0.6564899087,
0.1851159632,
-0.4344121218,
0.0874501094,
-0.5326853395,
0.9726400971,
-0.6343611479,
-0.3510966599,
0.4850174785,
0.7248260975,
0.0092626829,
-0.3263302445,
-0.8935639858,
0.3018038571,
0.1484612226,
-0.0827327296,
0.2739767432,
0.4907614291,
-0.2358365059,
0.9921531081,
0.7087338567,
-0.3845050931,
0.2227059901,
0.1690444797,
0.5828522444,
-0.3990559578,
-0.6332575083,
-0.5772262216,
0.5068797469,
-0.1557151973,
-0.1426084936,
1.1980901957,
0.3818984926,
1.0596718788,
-0.2254455537,
0.8339981437,
-0.0086727683,
0.2611321807,
-0.4209240079,
0.3710812032,
-0.4500930011,
-0.0868165791,
-0.0483217165,
-0.7655395865,
-0.3536747396,
0.3321034312,
0.087463595,
-0.0776414797,
0.8097212911,
0.8491396308,
-0.2062847912,
0.1263877004,
0.5050646067,
-0.0558008365,
0.2971944809,
0.3484818339,
0.9462231398,
-0.6121777296,
0.6326313019,
-0.2218874246,
-0.1642185897,
-0.1017347276,
-0.6843005419,
-0.9683208466,
-0.8679671288,
-0.5433790684,
-0.1972376406,
-0.2709385455,
0.3875867426,
0.620419085,
-0.8238995671,
-0.1676385701,
0.4092403352,
0.1561598033,
-0.3957296014,
-0.2815791965,
-0.0764959976,
-0.0207349658,
-0.8664029837,
0.52711761,
0.3408336341,
0.2847697437,
-0.7965277433,
0.0502948985,
-0.2720233202,
0.3230008185,
0.7265409827,
0.0842214525,
-0.8453018665,
-0.2537435591,
0.0784378275,
-0.0566377304,
0.0247079283,
1.0898112059,
-0.4919300079,
0.6898693442,
0.1948233843,
0.5166057348,
0.3576566279,
-0.1512712836,
0.3587478697,
-1.1818345785,
0.2224397659,
0.2173106223,
0.1421973854,
0.6489707828,
-0.4075192213,
0.4042313993,
0.5951030254,
-0.2490826696,
-0.7229372263,
0.6134320498,
-0.8218917251,
-0.6444666982,
1.0631525517,
0.163340345,
-0.0320796333,
-0.5484874249,
-0.1682846397,
-0.112577796,
-0.0853435174,
0.6374285817,
0.8642436862,
0.0341163762,
-0.0550175868,
-0.4275827706,
0.5997533202,
-0.1012233645,
-0.8648530841,
0.1490133405,
0.7165053487,
0.1684630811,
0.7559454441,
0.6173357368,
-0.0429523326,
0.1753120124,
0.152310282,
0.066076085,
0.1219440699,
-0.5528153777,
-0.3285247684,
0.2987474501,
-0.4919277728,
-0.2706400454
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03862v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03862v1
|
Conformity, Confabulation, and Impersonation: Persona Inconstancy in Multi-Agent LLM Collaboration
| 2024-05-06T21:20:35 | 2024-05-06T21:20:35 |
Razan Baltaji, Babak Hemmatian, Lav R. Varshney
|
cs.AI
|
cs.AI, cs.CL, I.2.7
|
This study explores the sources of instability in maintaining cultural
personas and opinions within multi-agent LLM systems. Drawing on simulations of
inter-cultural collaboration and debate, we analyze agents' pre- and
post-discussion private responses alongside chat transcripts to assess the
stability of cultural personas and the impact of opinion diversity on group
outcomes. Our findings suggest that multi-agent discussions can encourage
collective decisions that reflect diverse perspectives, yet this benefit is
tempered by the agents' susceptibility to conformity due to perceived peer
pressure and challenges in maintaining consistent personas and opinions.
Counterintuitively, instructions that encourage debate in support of one's
opinions increase the rate of inconstancy. Without addressing the factors we
identify, the full potential of multi-agent frameworks for producing more
culturally diverse AI outputs will remain untapped.
|
[
-0.6637757421,
-0.3065388501,
0.4223712683,
0.4066746235,
0.2431375384,
0.5443356037,
-0.066646941,
-0.6259694099,
0.3313886821,
0.3918648362,
-0.5949848294,
-0.0207324103,
-0.6186644435,
0.1766258031,
0.1256762594,
1.2103219032,
0.1048511565,
0.2138670087,
-0.310428679,
-0.8850667477,
-0.6157108545,
-0.7845467329,
-0.6514087319,
-0.4687862098,
0.3969693184,
0.5755240917,
0.9749953151,
-0.0338414386,
0.420020014,
0.4568880796,
0.3380821347,
0.2070218772,
-0.7228119373,
0.7419463992,
-0.2516931891,
-0.3752744794,
-0.1697417349,
0.3836449981,
0.5052047372,
0.4830556214,
-0.1386443079,
0.0502645709,
0.1287254095,
0.5072079301,
-0.187670216,
0.1799060851,
-0.6154846549,
-0.1155100614,
-0.0507970639,
0.0749034956,
-0.3979563415,
-0.6258168817,
0.3956739902,
-0.3304379582,
-0.0194126088,
-0.1883072108,
0.5928534269,
0.3850689828,
-0.3863347173,
-0.396889627,
-1.1198245287,
0.3792855442,
-0.2194610834,
0.019316718,
0.1294959933,
0.3241838813,
-0.2644121051,
-0.6054143906,
-0.6743745804,
-0.3274477124,
-0.1436013132,
0.3834169507,
0.0725420937,
-0.1480145007,
0.0763369724,
0.0497500375,
-0.25352332,
0.0611565784,
-0.160655275,
-0.2157516629,
0.6163429022,
0.3403506577,
0.3215737343,
0.4728677869,
-0.2947539389,
-0.1512655467,
-0.6389361024,
0.2368541658,
0.5822376013,
-0.0372091159,
-0.2028386891,
0.1497282386,
0.0217558667,
-0.2088687122,
0.5369723439,
-0.0373625346,
0.2572334111,
-0.2395330966,
-0.0156136081,
-0.1761507988,
0.7038897872,
0.4629122317,
0.308893621,
-0.1522427797,
0.3708715737,
0.1596434563,
0.3709509969,
-0.6404180527,
-0.2296955436,
0.4794942141,
-0.4323922694,
0.1090678871,
0.5073925853,
-0.6420201063,
-0.8034698963,
-0.276955992,
0.0173110086,
-0.3816796243,
-0.3171932995,
-0.4467267394,
-0.2735468149,
0.2282446027,
0.9507883787,
-0.4882410467,
0.1525916606,
0.5804982185,
0.5057157874,
-0.1754224896,
-0.8199266195,
-0.1791855693,
0.3711359203,
-0.3332091272,
0.7888160348,
-0.5864576101,
-0.5643571019,
-0.160735622,
0.2438854426,
-0.2794555128,
-0.5852460265,
0.0399481542,
-0.2192876637,
0.1552900672,
-0.4332149029,
-0.3710546494,
-0.0039715925,
0.5208866,
-0.4778055549,
0.4034593403,
0.0231151991,
-0.4198074639,
0.3598798811,
-0.428308934,
-0.0885789767,
0.3118807077,
-0.5724193454,
-0.1646764576,
-0.0251529086,
-0.3463872075,
0.1089370847,
-0.0442096293,
-0.1452469826,
-0.4825193584,
-0.3822038472,
0.7365499735,
-0.1714522094,
0.6261127591,
0.2706418037,
-0.3293391168,
0.2405659407,
-0.2435358465,
-0.1301067024,
-0.2040658146,
-0.2737906277,
-0.0332303531,
-0.0007073798,
-0.372648865,
0.4219250679,
0.1329486072,
-0.316768378,
0.3236132264,
-0.1508651823,
0.227693975,
1.0440183878,
0.2939104438,
0.5421404243,
-0.9792912602,
0.6712079644,
0.208146736,
0.3627750874,
-0.108300291,
-0.6541972756,
-0.7333408594,
0.0060337218,
-0.5320093632,
0.5682373047,
-0.961692512,
-0.2617776692,
-0.2353388667,
-0.7597839236,
-0.5891996026,
-0.0684111714,
0.4049183726,
0.1173501536,
-0.0947561786,
-0.4434108138,
-0.2630057335,
-0.8717749119,
-0.0858967453,
-0.6775941849,
0.2110846341,
0.2683261931,
0.4018498957,
-0.3021970689,
0.6783602834,
0.1826189309,
-0.2036392689,
-0.16407381,
0.256000489,
-0.1031337902,
0.7162926197,
0.7575395703,
-0.7216277719,
-0.8781278133,
-0.0359539911,
-0.6175963283,
0.2763978541,
-0.2395944148,
-0.0296642743,
0.6622743011,
0.2981510758,
-0.4679249525,
0.3771672249,
0.5085007548,
-0.1925264597,
0.4923483729,
-0.1170818508,
0.6133984923,
-0.9719690681,
-0.3660522997,
-0.117124103,
-0.028852107,
-0.7009931207,
0.1034912094,
-0.4867523611,
0.1959127039,
-0.3390798569,
0.2212116569,
-0.3286569715,
0.4208552241,
-0.2123232186,
0.0080862129,
-0.0604331642,
0.4279869497,
0.0440358594,
0.8612167239,
0.2589532733,
-0.5364080667,
0.3255545497,
0.5103779435,
-0.0006252908,
1.0566071272,
-0.320900619,
0.7072965503,
-0.3909746706,
0.3873514533,
-1.1177716255,
-0.376968354,
0.4434504509,
-0.4179041982,
0.187657997,
-0.1736720055,
-0.3588621616,
0.0931555852,
-0.5992671847,
0.374814868,
0.1809157878,
-0.1014891863,
0.6750622392,
0.7109991312,
-0.1630852371,
-0.5686124563,
-0.8761746883,
0.1469853669,
-0.2648076117,
-0.8272402287,
0.0737092644,
-0.7496177554,
-0.6606045365,
-0.2847963572,
0.289142698,
0.0880308673,
0.0290206112,
0.5339251757,
0.0832860842,
0.0687082261,
-0.1063042432,
-0.3838270307,
0.180964008,
-0.1072629392,
0.0564458929,
0.6208566427,
-0.5196781158,
-0.4497890472,
-0.4567452371,
0.6634454727,
0.9708257318,
0.1360229254,
1.0696009398,
0.0516268574,
-0.0960766375,
0.110320054,
-0.7372125983,
-0.0225746967,
-0.4423933923,
0.1091803312,
-0.2992726266,
-0.9304170012,
1.0651593208,
0.0442528613,
0.2587226927,
0.0284113418,
0.80527246,
-0.322920233,
0.5898352265,
0.4725861847,
0.2436101288,
0.3517541885,
0.0760764331,
-0.0051523144,
-0.5375355482,
-0.5743800402,
-0.5259974003,
-0.7155986428,
-1.0517189503,
-0.2007258832,
0.5223830938,
-0.7469161749,
-0.3556462824,
-0.0015240654,
-0.3353187144,
0.3217288256,
0.412150979,
-0.1110302135,
0.2374257743,
-0.390335232,
0.1960713863,
-0.2733406723,
-0.3138383329,
-0.5894706249,
0.6415663362,
0.324962467,
0.7224835157,
0.7468254566,
0.3886646032,
0.3539922833,
0.8531768322,
-0.5118752718,
0.4633435905,
0.0869854018,
-0.6298481226,
-0.2665869892,
-0.0832208917,
-0.9129516482,
0.3823639452,
-0.2993989885,
-0.8581958413,
0.5993783474,
-0.0072719227,
-0.2101176232,
0.0605609529,
-0.5700795054,
0.7284876704,
0.2053675354,
-0.4409373999,
-0.0498631559,
-1.0584664345,
0.4723181427,
-0.0515278205,
0.2576150596,
-0.1782270968,
0.1293156445,
0.2168680131,
-0.4218797386,
0.9169270992,
-0.0068724556,
-0.1445908844,
0.3081538081,
0.4159052968,
0.4571259022,
0.2129285336,
-0.3040456176,
0.3055176735,
0.0915818587,
-0.1813527793,
-0.5415223241,
0.645563364,
-1.2241102457,
-1.0053358078,
-0.4493781626,
-0.7265108228,
-0.3398430645,
-0.2672249377,
0.3487058878,
-0.0345764682,
-0.428845644,
0.2689741254,
0.5438050032,
0.0912540033,
0.4555347264,
0.6607757211,
-0.0092851631,
-0.8091440201,
0.5216057301,
0.4158815444,
0.6072583795,
-0.2350591123,
-0.194972232,
0.2057260871,
-0.4468340278,
-0.1971209496,
0.0286623519,
-0.7141221166,
0.0196284857,
-0.4571032822,
-0.1561961472,
-0.6390736103,
-0.0850226507,
-0.3147422671,
-0.4548115134,
0.1244018301,
0.0877352878,
-0.1519981325,
0.8187029958,
0.0710634664,
0.4289024472,
-0.7275201678,
-0.2543912828,
0.1745428443,
-0.013386447,
-0.1715884954,
-0.4150112271,
-0.3287661672,
-0.0708717406,
-0.5734428763,
-1.1502883434,
-0.1182757467,
0.0678839609,
0.6904470325,
0.5634646416,
0.2464475036,
0.6206775308,
-0.2411191463,
0.9913669229,
-0.0604554676,
-0.7807587981,
0.2491296232,
-0.3444543183,
0.233553499,
0.7865994573,
0.2004872113,
-0.8664544821,
-1.1620306969,
-0.6700700521,
-0.5537557602,
0.8094055653,
0.2199662477,
0.3451225162,
0.0098995548,
0.3861531019,
0.3582519293,
0.4522882402,
-0.8278166652,
-0.7153475285,
-0.2987441719,
0.0839293897,
0.144627139,
-0.2659547925,
-0.7528417706,
-0.0462410711,
0.4627992511,
-0.1971773654,
-0.1426034272,
0.1899898201,
0.1486444622,
-0.2549417913,
0.177191332,
0.8014464378,
1.0124351978,
0.1235384643,
0.1878285259,
0.1308533549,
-0.5630687475,
0.5324926376,
-0.0774212852,
-0.0796088278,
-0.2717660964,
0.2715859711,
0.5197757483,
-0.2257633507,
-0.1089581028,
0.3998721242,
-0.5483141541,
-0.0769654736,
-0.5360848904,
0.1153646037,
-0.0575447939,
0.4623540044,
0.2583019435,
0.5184066892,
-0.2772610784,
-1.2225245237,
0.1182437837,
0.6723293066,
-0.1321715862,
-0.3907435834,
0.6821806431,
0.2155947983,
-0.3486239016,
0.4534876943,
-0.124714084,
-0.1996082366,
0.7084122896,
0.1667388827,
0.9599778056,
-0.6768091917,
0.4973351359,
-0.227988556,
0.6399208307,
0.1184462905,
-0.0730398223,
0.2159507424,
-1.1039166451,
-0.0182232317,
-0.0611688942,
-1.0142903328,
-0.0697452947,
-0.3405747712,
0.1341131479,
-0.7635937333,
-0.3464925587,
-0.3972882032,
-0.1023800448,
-0.4386036992,
-0.120933719,
0.1546851844,
0.3954929411,
-0.5827991366,
0.8160759211,
0.8998277783,
-0.6507594585,
-0.6711236835,
0.5866692662,
0.1641580462,
-0.4952337146,
0.3167111278,
0.1465002,
-0.2998818755,
-0.4552713633,
-0.7626058459,
-0.7924140096,
1.1496661901,
0.8374143243,
-0.118565537,
0.3416086137,
0.2404643744,
0.7100661993,
-0.6630859971,
0.2369164228,
0.3036063612,
0.524282515,
0.4915479422,
-1.1431586742,
0.0709307045,
-0.2592086196,
-0.2640891373,
-0.2630252242,
-1.5212563276,
0.9225344658,
-0.0379760265,
-0.26782915,
0.1073461026,
0.6741945148,
0.5314603448,
0.5845240951,
0.4701235592,
0.1245699003,
0.9550620317,
-0.0558555722,
0.7840348482,
-0.4632512629,
0.0045032417,
1.2292125225,
-0.7151654959,
0.2766374946,
0.4970851541,
-0.1421501487,
0.9622995853,
0.4788396955,
-0.0101544382,
0.2090367675,
-0.0726108477,
-0.3161762953,
-0.0501012318,
-0.1073845699,
-0.4126252234,
0.4827723503,
0.2183392942,
0.0670121163,
0.2464395911,
-0.1153554171,
0.2542356849,
0.2300508022,
-0.0342171267,
0.876283288,
-0.0565001406,
-1.0500315428,
-0.0001004166,
-0.297886759,
0.3279686868,
-0.5750908852,
-0.0125895347,
-0.4208067954,
0.0565303676,
-0.2814369798,
-0.6359208226,
0.544210732,
-0.5850843787,
-0.3988775909,
-0.3828524649,
0.3280358016,
-0.4822298586,
-0.0725710317,
0.220297724,
0.7604142427,
0.2349169254,
0.1907670498,
-0.4475072026,
0.1465221941,
-0.2193353921,
-0.1026477516,
0.5147476792,
0.6543622613,
-0.0302929897,
0.6295390725,
0.2781043947,
-0.1476946175,
-0.155720681,
0.0013001716,
0.8313238621,
-0.0947342366,
-0.3704002202,
-1.0232139826,
0.6187568903,
-0.1355142891,
-0.0335469581,
0.9114826918,
0.2539403737,
0.7918403745,
-0.0470704883,
0.7552523613,
0.0458151624,
0.0805161297,
-0.2054054886,
0.8733150363,
-0.2795710564,
0.4126886725,
-0.3479413688,
-0.631734848,
0.1097697467,
0.3038281202,
0.0384092368,
0.2306195349,
0.7961966395,
0.5516781807,
0.566323936,
0.1445325017,
0.2624053061,
0.2951567769,
0.5669192672,
0.564874351,
1.1140565872,
0.1532415152,
0.5092076063,
-0.1140694767,
-0.1449329704,
0.1160480976,
-0.6655020118,
-0.7627465129,
-0.7517586946,
-0.5531430244,
-0.7164384127,
-0.2040473968,
1.1611227989,
0.5873658061,
-0.7431364655,
-0.4622024,
0.3059241474,
0.3314045966,
-0.1126135588,
-0.2799624503,
-0.1587668508,
-0.1768671423,
-1.1760824919,
0.1740124822,
0.4630122185,
0.3314990401,
-0.6396363378,
-0.1843644083,
-0.0695527196,
0.4916470945,
0.2281423211,
0.3817805946,
-0.6261927485,
-0.5174177885,
-0.3599264026,
-0.1103778034,
0.3671151102,
0.7967002392,
-0.5144454837,
0.3687854409,
0.1360047013,
0.2783372104,
0.0031415084,
0.343496263,
0.7635446191,
-0.8210985065,
0.4319752455,
0.2144152671,
0.3891946971,
0.3769456148,
-0.6509999633,
0.4688447416,
0.4907331169,
-1.0282799006,
-0.5590422153,
0.5309237838,
-0.6714612842,
-0.1185373589,
0.8692704439,
-0.4379518032,
0.0778841972,
-0.3956484795,
-0.203883782,
-0.1037609503,
-0.548782289,
1.0090383291,
1.2464071512,
-0.8546344638,
-0.1833084077,
-0.2495742291,
0.6313402057,
0.2074783444,
-0.7826435566,
-0.1515427977,
0.8438981771,
0.1967791468,
0.5250118971,
0.9422982931,
0.1723191291,
0.1329201311,
-0.1714101434,
-0.3427757621,
0.0416968279,
-0.3492189944,
-0.1400981098,
0.6327174902,
0.182314381,
0.017658947
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03845v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03845v1
|
Self-Improving Customer Review Response Generation Based on LLMs
| 2024-05-06T20:50:17 | 2024-05-06T20:50:17 |
Guy Azov, Tatiana Pelc, Adi Fledel Alon, Gila Kamhi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Previous studies have demonstrated that proactive interaction with user
reviews has a positive impact on the perception of app users and encourages
them to submit revised ratings. Nevertheless, developers encounter challenges
in managing a high volume of reviews, particularly in the case of popular apps
with a substantial influx of daily reviews. Consequently, there is a demand for
automated solutions aimed at streamlining the process of responding to user
reviews. To address this, we have developed a new system for generating
automatic responses by leveraging user-contributed documents with the help of
retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) and advanced Large Language Models (LLMs).
Our solution, named SCRABLE, represents an adaptive customer review response
automation that enhances itself with self-optimizing prompts and a judging
mechanism based on LLMs. Additionally, we introduce an automatic scoring
mechanism that mimics the role of a human evaluator to assess the quality of
responses generated in customer review domains. Extensive experiments and
analyses conducted on real-world datasets reveal that our method is effective
in producing high-quality responses, yielding improvement of more than 8.5%
compared to the baseline. Further validation through manual examination of the
generated responses underscores the efficacy our proposed system.
|
[
-0.5321570039,
-0.3364817202,
0.4093851447,
0.4185104668,
-0.107326299,
0.2597336769,
0.0630549416,
-0.4545180202,
0.6603270769,
0.8431767225,
-0.6391458511,
-0.2226277292,
-0.1132749096,
0.3989423811,
-0.272957474,
1.2431907654,
-0.1339162439,
-0.0702097416,
-0.3807725608,
-0.162204355,
-0.5141691566,
-0.2658642232,
-0.505512774,
-0.2349644303,
0.58706218,
0.8309088945,
0.4176918566,
-0.01530605,
0.6676988006,
0.3446768224,
0.2911081314,
0.4507909715,
-0.3245981932,
0.6963930726,
-0.1430353671,
0.0334021263,
-0.664390862,
-0.0519925505,
0.2199763358,
0.1146147177,
-0.3868914247,
0.567080915,
0.3995093405,
1.0215001106,
-0.5127988458,
-0.177726984,
-0.4747645855,
-0.0670731217,
0.288890183,
-0.5188530684,
-0.172953248,
-0.5602447987,
-0.0812073201,
-0.4212793112,
0.219562158,
-0.0793835372,
0.6561421752,
0.1838723719,
-0.1309846938,
-0.6347483993,
-0.9536231756,
0.4067651629,
-0.5245008469,
0.1075292602,
0.1978522837,
0.5593534708,
-0.2410794944,
-0.5504007339,
-0.4565330148,
-0.5138261318,
-0.0254959855,
0.5591544509,
-0.2877033949,
-0.3165190518,
0.1962666512,
0.3130212724,
-0.5177590251,
0.006019982,
-0.315662384,
-0.3311861157,
1.0170676708,
0.5604125857,
-0.0907764956,
-0.3943990171,
-0.4465266466,
-0.0117360819,
-0.4241594374,
0.295419544,
0.379237026,
0.0277215987,
0.4002224207,
0.6487697363,
-0.578999877,
0.4770821333,
0.3300389647,
0.1233294159,
0.2887226641,
-0.3142835498,
-0.173882857,
-0.1226275116,
0.8508238792,
0.7873361111,
0.03316053,
0.0852216184,
-0.7054792047,
0.1920862198,
0.4985304773,
-0.7130743861,
-0.0757178664,
0.4080093205,
-0.4259300828,
-0.4300203919,
0.0941286758,
-0.5622209907,
-0.5952441692,
-0.3140572906,
0.1933227926,
0.0150690945,
-0.0758571476,
0.0016171533,
0.2066081315,
0.0125376489,
0.5318043232,
-0.5849391818,
0.4090327322,
0.3183989227,
0.356565237,
-0.3715352714,
-0.1941199452,
-0.8384050727,
0.161903739,
-0.2719685137,
1.3920977116,
-0.2493517995,
-0.5633500814,
-0.1141037717,
-0.2764603198,
0.2604241371,
-0.8605542779,
0.6218580008,
-0.6039929986,
0.2113201022,
-0.0806372389,
-0.400806725,
0.2494092435,
0.586173296,
-0.4021109343,
1.213467598,
0.276578933,
-0.5707355738,
0.1026133522,
-0.5370263457,
-0.2940825224,
0.3671542406,
-0.0537489764,
-0.5831270814,
0.5469468236,
0.4865045249,
0.3219251335,
-0.3229816556,
-0.0678095818,
-0.1342051476,
-0.1196064577,
0.5078845024,
-0.1343764961,
0.184828192,
0.6803417802,
-0.010680275,
0.3997260928,
-0.6635767221,
0.2771512568,
0.1707468182,
-0.571798861,
0.0874678344,
-0.2091458738,
0.037646357,
0.2825900912,
0.2521165311,
-0.6411280036,
0.3063006997,
-0.3177057803,
0.1296817213,
0.8323634267,
0.4999019206,
0.4599507451,
-0.2961006165,
0.8551537395,
-0.1727885455,
0.5207024217,
-0.3614926338,
-0.1516450197,
-0.8146311045,
0.1075068265,
0.2276371568,
0.3850907385,
-0.6458684802,
0.5175811052,
-0.1821255386,
-0.6799172163,
-0.4317079186,
0.5385503769,
0.3279446363,
0.6363757253,
0.1502332985,
-0.5982835889,
-0.4530595541,
-0.6784422398,
-0.4846963882,
-0.4172219038,
-0.291587621,
0.6957957745,
0.0443881303,
-0.4686427116,
1.1377182007,
-0.7236366272,
-0.5042011738,
-0.2595017254,
0.0634215698,
0.0806395262,
-0.0455067903,
0.1797867864,
-0.473462224,
-0.7938820124,
-0.0789029896,
-0.4739982188,
-0.641207695,
-0.1271623671,
-0.0268089361,
0.5234530568,
0.3920046389,
-0.3934519589,
0.3726491928,
0.5056500435,
-0.1816214919,
0.9410917163,
-0.3359681368,
0.307801038,
-1.0171869993,
-0.0285192039,
-0.0063841837,
-0.2913975418,
-0.3445195854,
-0.2060859203,
0.0803581625,
-0.312148869,
-0.3662238121,
0.6019613147,
-0.3738584518,
-0.392427206,
-0.5717494488,
0.1595792621,
0.1793853641,
0.315343827,
-0.3068523407,
0.7015972733,
0.0721461102,
-0.7139943242,
0.4587411284,
0.2645563185,
-0.346021831,
0.795044899,
-0.767426908,
0.0786028206,
-0.083689563,
0.4416517913,
-1.2663416862,
-0.3941970766,
0.4311085343,
-0.5501100421,
-0.1994203776,
0.0846843123,
-0.4154457748,
-0.8147917986,
-0.356025368,
-0.2593102455,
0.4030697048,
-0.4938461185,
0.9754104614,
0.3040517271,
-0.543749392,
-0.1221093684,
-0.2291636616,
0.465492487,
0.0105479052,
-0.6466247439,
0.0194819402,
-0.3584563136,
-0.1136063859,
-0.2829306126,
-0.204697758,
0.1942516118,
-0.0947370827,
0.2521512806,
0.0956847593,
0.0692900792,
0.1786934286,
-0.1194496155,
-0.4575691521,
0.1303037256,
-0.061445713,
0.5323828459,
-0.133552283,
-0.2084839046,
-0.594725728,
0.2061747462,
0.6974122524,
-0.4955000877,
-0.2490887195,
0.3832795024,
0.0188244507,
-0.2036988735,
-0.8330729008,
-0.4324047863,
-0.5416427255,
0.0997403339,
-0.5430047512,
-0.7059628367,
0.5212132931,
-0.1469658315,
0.0508339554,
0.3395510912,
0.7752837539,
-0.4780386686,
1.2931839228,
0.2514434159,
0.0220158137,
0.6025535464,
0.0789273605,
0.0987501442,
-0.7883653641,
-0.2263440192,
-0.6732929349,
-0.1565031409,
-0.3371522427,
-0.0547770411,
0.4601939619,
-0.0279255062,
0.0353421979,
0.2286179811,
-0.6969285011,
0.3507688642,
0.283058852,
0.0246933158,
0.3519711196,
0.3531504571,
-0.1407594383,
0.0244819075,
-0.4787026346,
-0.5915982127,
0.7784338593,
0.4638391733,
1.1215475798,
0.013945654,
0.9506396651,
0.5650460124,
0.7410871983,
-0.6834105253,
0.6660155058,
0.1149870679,
-0.079078801,
-0.1692228019,
-0.4798262119,
-0.8005158305,
0.0678490475,
-0.4562168717,
-0.2685995102,
-0.0595655441,
0.3022151589,
-0.5534591079,
-0.3018705547,
-0.7097206116,
0.3732478619,
-0.6081058979,
-0.5168071389,
-0.1142460704,
-0.256670177,
0.114164643,
-0.1700528264,
0.0814215839,
-0.1373835206,
0.1957380623,
0.5752742887,
-0.6737020612,
0.6359344125,
-0.3846584558,
-0.3545491397,
0.4887309372,
0.4857503772,
0.7057569027,
0.1208171472,
-0.0530504845,
-0.232939288,
-0.267590344,
-0.117968291,
-0.8726825714,
0.8384362459,
-0.4665694237,
-0.5582610965,
-0.4662819505,
-0.3750823438,
-0.2922612131,
0.2600342631,
-0.0195143241,
0.2519363165,
-0.0765296966,
-0.1186169758,
0.2682163119,
-0.1637780368,
0.4049459696,
0.9547475576,
-0.5346308947,
-1.028849721,
0.6910524964,
-0.0791112036,
0.0117745288,
-0.3337789774,
0.40643543,
-0.5947857499,
-0.297091186,
-0.6350641847,
0.1671142578,
-0.4440523386,
-0.5961368084,
-0.7417752147,
-0.0857711434,
-0.5091025233,
0.1144130155,
-0.3228452504,
-0.3151967525,
-0.0919891,
0.0375836417,
0.1997595876,
1.1183054447,
0.2032702416,
0.260189116,
-1.0447485447,
0.5669592619,
0.4572955668,
0.5973951221,
0.0536931157,
-0.6355761886,
-0.3563036323,
-0.1784169078,
-0.5529588461,
-0.6712355018,
0.4578951895,
0.0533493496,
0.5958306789,
0.1701333672,
0.2461595237,
0.7260501385,
-0.5427939296,
0.7219009399,
0.2782941163,
-0.6256175041,
0.6998281479,
-0.3000606298,
0.4049223661,
0.6458921432,
0.0837288201,
-0.518424809,
-0.5265756845,
-0.4301654994,
-0.9149556756,
0.3569172919,
0.1294478178,
0.3930054903,
0.0771860927,
0.5939734578,
0.0571420155,
0.0090787327,
-0.5046744347,
0.1162685454,
-0.2191767991,
-0.0637438446,
-0.1749904603,
-0.4919455349,
0.0288861115,
0.0226631854,
0.6636787653,
-0.2368644029,
0.0716458261,
0.4576114714,
-0.1590757072,
-0.4898759425,
0.2539791763,
0.4830951095,
0.5562747121,
-0.0943962559,
-0.2510765195,
-0.0001777128,
-0.3978514373,
0.1678676158,
-0.1219846681,
-0.2388169169,
-0.2271582484,
-0.1850859225,
0.3255747557,
-0.1382672042,
-0.5145068765,
0.4346535802,
-0.6109315753,
-0.2154941112,
-0.4366452098,
0.1512818635,
-0.094179444,
0.1856764257,
0.6864334941,
0.2416247725,
0.3033332825,
-0.1996901929,
0.3585512042,
0.3786951602,
-0.4869253933,
-0.0172302667,
0.4184065461,
0.6315837502,
-0.6872672439,
0.3728928566,
-0.0916985571,
-0.5369855165,
0.2394035012,
0.5770043135,
1.1820526123,
-0.4934480488,
0.3132555187,
0.3880959749,
0.0727593675,
0.1765109599,
0.28876701,
-0.2870586812,
-0.401552856,
-0.2693748176,
-0.9033337235,
-0.7360054851,
-0.1272616833,
-0.7207171321,
0.2139227241,
-0.5088968873,
-0.3081099093,
-0.0878979117,
0.1298615634,
-0.4135449827,
0.3693941832,
-0.0593036562,
0.8857498169,
-0.6943895221,
0.3991518021,
0.6094495654,
-0.4515839815,
-0.7366702557,
0.2420760244,
-0.2974830866,
-0.3687143028,
0.5979869366,
0.3032668829,
-0.7024430633,
-0.0580512471,
-0.2855611742,
-0.5870019197,
0.8116397858,
0.0509777442,
-0.6842185259,
0.7303705215,
0.1796058565,
0.9682536721,
-0.5596180558,
0.3756231666,
0.3066516519,
0.1129758209,
0.0788275152,
-0.6680790782,
-0.123531729,
-0.5273333192,
0.1412570477,
-0.0825354457,
-0.4790861011,
0.2599832118,
0.0841466561,
-0.1205924675,
0.2767929733,
0.7838039994,
0.4131014645,
0.5171100497,
0.6385555267,
0.3764793575,
0.4933204353,
0.2735112309,
1.0581330061,
-0.5507371426,
0.2015277147,
1.2449936867,
-0.7413059473,
1.0762535334,
0.4878807366,
0.0416639671,
0.6888372898,
0.5718293786,
-0.0136551559,
0.19157812,
0.3937391639,
-0.2535664737,
-0.2612257004,
-0.2047408819,
-0.081046775,
0.5636000633,
0.1382860094,
-0.2575193942,
-0.1547408998,
0.0209153667,
-0.3808720708,
0.4058223367,
-0.4592767358,
1.2347575426,
-0.1820866317,
-1.0950863361,
0.6570132375,
0.0121452389,
0.6024567485,
-0.5624403954,
0.1159907356,
-0.6822113991,
0.2679311633,
-0.5338391066,
-0.9382699728,
0.2156650722,
0.3675721884,
-0.313211441,
-0.4670474827,
0.9765483737,
-0.0965390354,
-0.6171909571,
0.283870697,
0.5357681513,
0.1643879265,
-0.0488931388,
-0.8495282531,
0.102919437,
-0.0117077967,
-0.518676877,
0.0636624917,
-0.0325335637,
-0.2653632462,
0.7829918861,
0.85662359,
-0.0107139247,
-0.1567727178,
0.3828258514,
1.0330634117,
-0.6403095126,
-0.7561990023,
-0.43770051,
0.467626363,
-0.2735683024,
-0.2539819479,
1.0127491951,
0.7448866963,
0.4663673043,
-0.2124103904,
0.7781498432,
0.4036179483,
1.0031645298,
-0.1797144711,
0.7600495219,
-0.5208667517,
0.6532546282,
-0.3384692967,
-1.3164454699,
-0.4584036469,
0.3654032052,
-0.1333773881,
0.0527024306,
0.3078899086,
0.966109097,
0.0862126052,
-0.2561204433,
0.0444684774,
0.2329713404,
0.4697158039,
0.1586315036,
1.1192724705,
-0.4253069162,
0.8127391338,
0.0795936361,
-0.2750611603,
-0.454123646,
-0.8731564879,
-0.6214965582,
-0.2065678239,
-0.2644067407,
-0.808609426,
0.0060993913,
0.8133423924,
0.2982631922,
-0.7677126527,
-0.4300125539,
-0.0475605913,
-0.343931824,
0.0445427746,
-0.2325803936,
0.1101120859,
-0.6011317968,
-0.3788255751,
0.3477977216,
0.4360096157,
0.0207068566,
-0.4805721939,
-0.5918596387,
0.5211774707,
0.3446012139,
0.5911832452,
0.3023968339,
-0.5520454645,
-0.1589683741,
0.357701242,
-0.4344620109,
0.0608917959,
0.7796488404,
-0.8643316627,
0.6197898984,
0.5622426867,
0.3344352543,
0.5825790763,
0.2894756794,
0.4205523431,
-0.5645905733,
-0.5615608692,
0.3977583647,
0.0967232287,
0.4161503911,
-0.3547994196,
0.3089905977,
-0.1260215938,
-0.7624098063,
-0.7852270007,
0.4957318902,
-0.8818349242,
0.0101687759,
1.0577796698,
0.0716110244,
-0.2029450983,
-0.0019936617,
-0.6262744665,
-0.2279963195,
-0.501639545,
1.1497683525,
0.2426606119,
-0.5833487511,
-0.0322939157,
-0.051370427,
0.4491856992,
0.4479195774,
-1.0006325245,
0.2819586694,
0.6547393799,
0.4925720692,
0.2133676559,
0.9374101162,
-0.1306774318,
0.5561603904,
-0.4849225879,
0.2045642287,
-0.1321274191,
-0.4255323708,
-0.6300503612,
0.1671211123,
0.2069921196,
0.0991914645
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03832v3
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03832v3
|
Guylingo: The Republic of Guyana Creole Corpora
| 2024-05-06T20:30:14 | 2024-07-02T21:23:32 |
Christopher Clarke, Roland Daynauth, Charlene Wilkinson, Hubert Devonish, Jason Mars
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
While major languages often enjoy substantial attention and resources, the
linguistic diversity across the globe encompasses a multitude of smaller,
indigenous, and regional languages that lack the same level of computational
support. One such region is the Caribbean. While commonly labeled as "English
speaking", the ex-British Caribbean region consists of a myriad of Creole
languages thriving alongside English. In this paper, we present Guylingo: a
comprehensive corpus designed for advancing NLP research in the domain of
Creolese (Guyanese English-lexicon Creole), the most widely spoken language in
the culturally rich nation of Guyana. We first outline our framework for
gathering and digitizing this diverse corpus, inclusive of colloquial
expressions, idioms, and regional variations in a low-resource language. We
then demonstrate the challenges of training and evaluating NLP models for
machine translation in Creole. Lastly, we discuss the unique opportunities
presented by recent NLP advancements for accelerating the formal adoption of
Creole languages as official languages in the Caribbean.
|
[
-0.4151702523,
-0.6733700037,
0.31130898,
0.5227899551,
-0.2311154306,
0.7330802679,
-0.7450767159,
-0.4998387992,
0.6556010842,
0.7900764346,
0.0514020212,
-0.5038161874,
-0.7852252722,
0.7597789168,
-0.3329795301,
0.9136465192,
0.0547720864,
0.0124688884,
0.2024036944,
0.0696001351,
-0.3744825423,
-0.6307433844,
-0.9048143625,
0.2146700621,
0.6598246694,
0.4581790864,
0.6416043639,
0.4100485742,
0.5640976429,
0.3778476417,
-0.069778204,
0.5626062155,
-0.4024808705,
-0.0151758101,
-0.2107269913,
-0.6425001025,
-0.3798570335,
-0.2708106935,
0.3676883876,
0.746103704,
-0.3992291093,
-0.0753130838,
-0.2715930045,
0.5955882668,
-0.4066287577,
0.5705619454,
-0.7021274567,
0.0098529998,
-0.2395927012,
-0.2992798686,
-0.1592180133,
-0.6537149549,
0.0145372041,
-0.595834136,
0.1314968467,
0.1128080934,
0.5775183439,
-0.1673032045,
-0.4419705272,
-0.3652592003,
-0.5214250088,
0.6248860359,
-0.4127378762,
0.4489446282,
0.7739903927,
0.4213106334,
0.0087315962,
-0.6972590685,
-0.7088669538,
0.0020533265,
-0.1597231627,
0.1265084594,
-0.0996171832,
0.0525144935,
-0.41255337,
0.2433198988,
-0.614269197,
-0.0750869215,
-0.7687831521,
0.0251966398,
0.7120913267,
-0.0863221511,
0.5466958284,
-0.2605158091,
0.2533631623,
0.2129574418,
-0.4415281713,
-0.144477427,
0.6087163091,
0.808391273,
-0.1565183997,
0.4835422337,
0.2447807044,
0.8779897094,
-0.0819306523,
-0.1666943133,
0.0149871688,
-0.2769025862,
-0.2228362709,
0.0665971413,
0.5249336958,
0.1897394657,
0.4381348789,
-0.1707920134,
-0.0332034938,
-0.3823110759,
0.2061425894,
-0.3902538121,
-0.3967668712,
0.2641740739,
-0.2368959785,
-0.019950835,
-0.0586273521,
-0.7423594594,
-0.0060038669,
-0.4992053807,
-0.5822309852,
-0.5162894726,
-0.3670555949,
0.1158206612,
0.0422868691,
0.0773602948,
0.3559067249,
-1.5212090015,
0.2825010419,
0.8660746217,
0.9951648116,
-0.159507826,
-0.3154839575,
-0.3720910251,
0.0174560249,
-0.7444418669,
0.7523310781,
-0.9513763785,
-0.7450508475,
0.1216920987,
0.331527859,
-0.2381227016,
-0.5156452656,
0.7277334332,
-0.5964131355,
0.2676196098,
-0.0862858593,
-0.3498451114,
-0.1192849502,
0.2106305808,
-0.3204239607,
0.4850147069,
0.9094710946,
-0.525804162,
0.1773052514,
-0.1985947788,
-0.2934635878,
0.3364862502,
-0.3244090676,
0.0242756531,
0.2068384439,
0.0591352321,
0.3344538808,
-0.3167492747,
0.475142777,
0.0984236747,
-0.2563291788,
0.0661049187,
0.0365631096,
0.9486934543,
0.5293520689,
0.1442078501,
-0.1737094074,
-0.5542790294,
-0.0597786382,
-0.0487348326,
-0.5725824833,
-0.4560392201,
-0.1823267788,
0.1924026012,
0.0775550976,
0.1712255925,
-0.3727115989,
0.4361603856,
-0.3802168965,
0.6198327541,
0.4122612476,
-0.1033142656,
0.5410814285,
0.1448429823,
0.9574493766,
-0.1706713736,
0.0056433063,
-0.2040507197,
-0.7655836344,
-0.4654926658,
-0.4696359038,
0.7321818471,
0.8524003625,
-0.7417989969,
0.4271000624,
-0.2212333679,
-0.2015108168,
-0.5474872589,
0.069638446,
0.1250377595,
0.5667091608,
0.4710903764,
-0.3956309557,
-0.8528841138,
-1.2614629269,
0.0721432045,
-0.3537000716,
-0.3717727065,
0.186756596,
0.2660709918,
-0.2726893127,
0.4678339958,
-0.4299223125,
-0.1115494817,
-0.4238271415,
-0.1846756339,
0.1577672213,
0.380769223,
0.6701427698,
-0.6717562079,
-0.7231789827,
0.6462319493,
-0.7481372952,
0.0063792919,
0.0784560665,
-0.0308591425,
0.2566632926,
0.4882241488,
-0.2152439058,
-0.1440514475,
0.7509694099,
-0.0553672835,
0.558216393,
-0.2733940482,
0.6643320918,
-0.8153140545,
0.1509294361,
-0.1665693223,
-0.34796381,
-0.7677375078,
0.2999802232,
-0.131235972,
-0.4149734378,
-0.2947554588,
0.4765289128,
-0.2897177935,
0.3020465672,
-0.1932516247,
0.3875272572,
-0.0491048284,
0.2324755341,
0.2995914817,
0.8497928977,
0.3423731327,
-0.3720060587,
0.0297414437,
0.5040747523,
-0.0439134389,
0.77806288,
-0.5264529586,
0.0436396636,
-0.0989826694,
0.0086204223,
-0.3900381327,
-0.4641913176,
0.2125121206,
-0.4399091005,
0.7053670287,
-0.630771935,
-0.0891556963,
-0.3557274342,
0.1318703294,
0.0574957393,
0.2498118281,
-0.1114592329,
0.0578378588,
0.8351630569,
-0.7774341702,
-0.7342261076,
-0.9035459161,
0.8049401045,
-0.2286180109,
-0.4592965245,
0.0244981647,
0.0897337198,
-0.4735307395,
-0.6493315101,
0.349272579,
-0.5015736222,
-0.0647877529,
-0.3457963765,
0.124639228,
-0.1793213189,
0.0412710123,
0.211338371,
0.0793094262,
-0.0163478591,
-0.6811022758,
0.517393589,
-0.2867449522,
0.1893051118,
0.0537498817,
0.702165544,
0.1093437076,
-0.122953929,
0.5843856931,
0.3796519339,
-0.1165045425,
-0.1040423736,
-0.1654305905,
0.1099940315,
-0.4474054277,
0.3317715526,
-0.6091794372,
-0.866206646,
0.4182635546,
-0.0977945924,
0.0082932413,
0.0886252671,
0.3635596037,
-0.2075664103,
0.5053033829,
0.8291329145,
-0.0509017445,
0.2854099274,
-0.1860270649,
0.3137095869,
-0.5076710582,
-0.1648563892,
-0.819660008,
-0.0391650721,
-0.9989027977,
-0.7922257781,
-0.1495585889,
0.1771462113,
0.0925155431,
0.9288815856,
-0.5383655429,
0.4862577021,
0.2211923897,
-0.225846827,
0.5889259577,
0.2422531843,
0.1217752472,
-0.4334442019,
-0.8773863316,
-0.9377102256,
1.1008211374,
-0.0224144999,
0.1713714004,
0.2360065132,
0.6738662124,
0.5355206132,
-0.0544606782,
-0.3316350579,
0.4979396462,
-0.4538912475,
-0.3023226261,
0.0683730543,
-0.3419299126,
-1.2423267365,
0.0598556288,
0.1054140851,
-0.6051478386,
0.5666211843,
0.1734875143,
0.1155130118,
0.2746848464,
-0.6066852212,
0.6343490481,
-0.034670677,
-0.084313564,
-0.0875707939,
-0.6765570045,
0.6552542448,
-0.1050935388,
0.4043584168,
0.2892767191,
-0.2659417689,
0.1957923025,
-0.3494780362,
0.2852043211,
0.1278693825,
-0.3854423463,
0.5874800682,
0.3875840008,
0.2817825675,
0.5287004709,
-0.1150893793,
0.5127354264,
0.0039093159,
-0.8427910209,
-0.3425525129,
0.7264192104,
-0.634667635,
-0.3166100979,
-0.2564104497,
-0.1643548012,
-0.2176117599,
-0.1046423167,
0.0172036253,
-0.0968257338,
-0.3868106008,
-0.2356092334,
0.6306941509,
-0.2394152135,
0.2628834844,
0.3272604644,
-0.7528475523,
-0.4905916154,
1.1500536203,
-0.0354374275,
0.1480856687,
0.4459903836,
-0.1837025732,
-0.0139470259,
-0.7860273123,
-0.7049520016,
0.2671556771,
-0.5648233891,
0.1823874116,
-0.9103358388,
0.194691509,
-0.2520175576,
-0.6190410256,
-0.3224592805,
-0.8573336005,
-0.137378186,
-0.3233498633,
-0.0459379517,
0.3680987358,
-0.2053995878,
0.3194831312,
-0.6205778122,
0.0447128154,
0.4414542317,
-0.0928898901,
-0.5548743606,
-0.5714649558,
-0.2062333375,
-0.0412595794,
0.1632196605,
-0.7837473154,
0.7393301129,
0.3014080226,
0.34065938,
0.2218224406,
-0.5046555996,
0.4124492109,
-0.4244832695,
0.8193189502,
0.2605260611,
-0.7748740911,
0.6057127714,
-0.8526312113,
0.095747225,
0.8825181723,
0.6326631904,
-1.01676476,
-0.546734333,
-0.5915762782,
-0.7979141474,
0.2754597664,
0.2511317432,
0.2386666387,
-0.6714798212,
0.3019628525,
0.3075932264,
0.8261114359,
-0.3365922868,
-0.1144416854,
-0.4482553899,
0.08505252,
-0.1871905923,
0.0636143833,
-0.3835378587,
-0.2114952356,
0.4800294638,
-0.5164735317,
0.5300263166,
0.2865756452,
-0.3453095257,
0.1031118631,
0.444614023,
0.8250226378,
1.0031040907,
-0.2118748873,
0.0792040303,
0.1102120131,
-0.7046828866,
0.0356470458,
0.0459922366,
-0.3765089214,
0.2561533451,
0.5118192434,
0.3684252501,
0.1091524661,
-0.6707437634,
0.0956494287,
-0.2800577879,
0.0310426578,
-0.3864037693,
0.1182217449,
0.424995631,
-0.0514212102,
0.483936131,
0.3262477517,
-0.0823991746,
-0.7944388986,
0.1483447552,
0.0736701787,
-0.5491623282,
-0.564168036,
0.6100286841,
0.598449707,
-0.4771754146,
0.5545641184,
-0.5972890854,
-0.4145826101,
0.7450453043,
0.5415987968,
0.6308950782,
-0.0953606963,
0.4407854378,
0.6912413836,
0.5790997744,
0.1424488723,
0.6212505698,
0.1067538559,
-0.3754135966,
-0.3175045252,
-0.6838560104,
-0.4742785394,
-0.2302788049,
-0.1749276519,
0.3136241734,
-0.6074513793,
-0.1804580688,
-0.1961806118,
0.0523087196,
-0.6635321975,
0.0358300209,
0.2396986932,
0.7539774776,
-0.4833824039,
0.8521192074,
0.4917763472,
-0.4408341646,
-0.3035897017,
-0.3661591411,
-0.0335990116,
-0.7305237055,
0.7301829457,
-0.2838814855,
-0.0719339848,
0.1719394326,
-0.3505799472,
-0.5372627378,
0.8538557887,
0.4412423968,
-1.0503988266,
0.3091241419,
0.0913884193,
0.8459448218,
-0.6984787583,
0.4833902419,
0.7101686597,
0.8411879539,
-0.8233640194,
-0.9338470101,
-0.4199763834,
0.0583404824,
0.0915479362,
0.1046222448,
-0.8688146472,
0.7447695136,
-0.0989018753,
-0.1567480266,
-0.1850254387,
0.8787121773,
0.1217849404,
0.0253766533,
0.150328517,
0.0803737268,
1.0932701826,
-0.2506614625,
1.0456148386,
-0.4986841083,
0.0405357592,
1.0417739153,
-0.319521755,
0.542820096,
0.4035319984,
-0.8040061593,
0.7562660575,
0.853423655,
0.2232468575,
0.1494909227,
0.3849336505,
-0.5798727274,
0.1388868392,
-0.2285655439,
-0.3200965822,
0.6082575321,
0.4595294893,
-0.2558805346,
0.232649833,
-0.092072174,
0.222446233,
0.6132290363,
-0.3485756218,
0.3444175422,
0.1537895203,
-0.7528321743,
0.5844761729,
-0.0100568766,
0.6239185333,
-0.9320239425,
0.1176463068,
-0.6727906466,
-0.3582219779,
-0.3076785505,
-0.4638597965,
0.6718346477,
-0.0336779505,
-0.1209072918,
-0.0698682442,
0.5048922896,
-0.5818993449,
-0.5017528534,
0.490743041,
0.7311113477,
0.4304856956,
0.1923190653,
-0.7988215685,
-0.3175109327,
0.1476315409,
-0.1261459887,
0.4504308403,
0.2057989538,
-0.1861242652,
0.6501429081,
0.559894383,
0.3843201995,
0.0966726094,
0.178054601,
0.3645405173,
-0.5963606834,
-0.5088596344,
-0.5409281254,
0.0047090873,
-0.1606529653,
-0.5700108409,
0.7957680821,
0.6992086172,
0.9243513346,
-0.2953128517,
1.0109232664,
-0.3825369775,
0.0807290748,
-0.2233713865,
0.5735314488,
-0.2104075402,
0.1377339363,
-0.2256653011,
-1.0165262222,
-0.3576687872,
0.4379987717,
-0.0555628575,
-0.238144815,
0.815747261,
0.5640622973,
-0.1799518168,
0.1727404892,
0.5127815604,
0.0821823403,
0.074393779,
0.1005062014,
0.4638766944,
-0.2811972499,
0.6842560172,
-0.2444005609,
0.0414156839,
0.0001554339,
-0.7710041404,
-0.5142804384,
-0.5846871138,
-0.281676501,
-0.2337395847,
0.321769923,
0.8805731535,
0.723456502,
-1.0555535555,
-0.5376550555,
-0.2260448486,
0.1960614473,
-0.2297948748,
-0.2640551329,
0.0820270106,
-0.3954370916,
-1.267490983,
0.89128685,
0.6771759391,
-0.0768838972,
-0.4025407732,
-0.0425599627,
-0.672406733,
0.0377249792,
0.8933590055,
0.7447677851,
-0.2543592751,
-0.3060669303,
-0.0135048395,
-0.1463989764,
0.2705361247,
1.1823836565,
-0.6488485336,
0.5277270675,
0.5012968779,
0.5298531651,
0.4918233454,
-0.0300875846,
0.9030111432,
-0.9509996176,
0.3197701573,
0.3872753978,
0.4538324773,
0.6280415058,
-0.2578950226,
0.9727101326,
0.264644742,
-0.7846984267,
-0.491637677,
0.3170260787,
-0.8275409341,
-0.4843842685,
0.5992106795,
-0.3702223897,
-0.2940764129,
-0.8496627212,
-0.2663873732,
0.0425305776,
-0.5963137746,
0.84021312,
0.6977710128,
0.0905189142,
-0.2125388682,
-1.1459618807,
0.4368282855,
0.1340845525,
-0.8064498305,
0.0998174921,
0.2648182809,
0.1526879221,
0.295255959,
0.915153563,
0.1835639328,
0.065770261,
0.1011913121,
0.151535064,
0.2384464294,
-0.3206403553,
-0.3101490736,
0.1430196315,
-0.1674745083,
0.4469660819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03794v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03794v1
|
Detecting Anti-Semitic Hate Speech using Transformer-based Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T19:00:31 | 2024-05-06T19:00:31 |
Dengyi Liu, Minghao Wang, Andrew G. Catlin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Academic researchers and social media entities grappling with the
identification of hate speech face significant challenges, primarily due to the
vast scale of data and the dynamic nature of hate speech. Given the ethical and
practical limitations of large predictive models like ChatGPT in directly
addressing such sensitive issues, our research has explored alternative
advanced transformer-based and generative AI technologies since 2019.
Specifically, we developed a new data labeling technique and established a
proof of concept targeting anti-Semitic hate speech, utilizing a variety of
transformer models such as BERT (arXiv:1810.04805), DistillBERT
(arXiv:1910.01108), RoBERTa (arXiv:1907.11692), and LLaMA-2 (arXiv:2307.09288),
complemented by the LoRA fine-tuning approach (arXiv:2106.09685). This paper
delineates and evaluates the comparative efficacy of these cutting-edge methods
in tackling the intricacies of hate speech detection, highlighting the need for
responsible and carefully managed AI applications within sensitive contexts.
|
[
-0.5116358995,
-1.138188839,
0.0356356539,
-0.1908872128,
-0.1413386017,
0.2642475367,
-0.3096169531,
-0.6643921137,
0.1241619512,
0.3843513727,
-0.3484746516,
-0.3149076104,
-0.8342888951,
-0.1887456179,
-0.9317598939,
1.2004520893,
0.2121294737,
0.0736885294,
0.2601617873,
-0.17877464,
0.0207462776,
-0.5002796054,
-0.799308002,
-0.2618596256,
0.8585957885,
0.0617248639,
0.9612269998,
0.5015483499,
0.5890366435,
0.2380072474,
-0.341155231,
-0.2046370059,
-0.5479707122,
0.2919439077,
-0.1117644832,
-0.3045720458,
-0.2504092753,
-0.0261948984,
0.4208432734,
0.0672804266,
0.1406856775,
0.292321384,
-0.1767350137,
0.2670640051,
-0.5296902061,
-0.1512028724,
-0.8326866031,
0.1332983673,
-0.7258768678,
0.3129150569,
-0.4341982901,
-0.3848766685,
-0.0362633206,
-0.2208699584,
0.3891267478,
-0.1076852083,
0.5017370582,
0.4748192728,
-0.2606736422,
-0.4910301268,
-1.07660079,
0.683830142,
-0.7927196026,
0.5393989682,
0.196710214,
0.316510886,
0.0649636015,
-0.5799469948,
-0.8104445934,
-0.2677517831,
0.2392151952,
0.108874999,
-0.8241041899,
-0.2308432758,
0.2652853727,
0.2316517681,
-0.528106451,
0.6620743275,
-0.3901405931,
-0.3351134956,
0.6661435962,
0.0475125238,
0.3510324955,
0.0753264129,
-0.2253676355,
-0.0057451986,
-0.5514202714,
-0.1896482557,
0.7760284543,
0.3724668026,
0.0674562976,
0.5079272389,
0.0956200585,
0.2755940557,
-0.0631550103,
0.0763053149,
0.2175576836,
0.1972289979,
0.0282306746,
0.1678901613,
0.7601901889,
0.2322741896,
0.5255092382,
-0.2980054319,
-0.0287423823,
0.7657824755,
0.5391671658,
-0.7631850839,
-0.2997810543,
0.009041572,
-0.2156747133,
-0.4923915267,
-0.4642054141,
-1.1091455221,
-0.9387177825,
-0.0278411414,
0.138472259,
-0.3580726683,
-0.3796806633,
-0.3066254556,
-0.009927569,
0.4227377176,
0.2223754078,
-0.6758100986,
0.0634086728,
0.7383382916,
0.703132689,
-0.4709016085,
0.1507444531,
-0.5806189179,
-0.114427194,
-0.1105992496,
0.7003667951,
-0.8233450055,
-0.2745898366,
0.1510244459,
-0.4094552696,
0.3121369779,
-0.5975490808,
1.0464422703,
-0.8172185421,
0.0931819454,
0.174701795,
-0.471776396,
-0.0043985718,
0.2489859611,
-0.6402897835,
0.9290415049,
0.1160923764,
-0.7788258791,
0.0366951972,
-0.7155759335,
-0.4621612132,
0.1830636263,
-0.1092467234,
-0.9069142938,
0.076793395,
0.0297613069,
0.0722221136,
-0.2995245159,
0.2899752557,
-0.2640853822,
-0.1032553539,
0.2978915274,
-0.7767027617,
0.774471283,
0.4928072691,
-0.7697554231,
0.5534456968,
-0.5734261274,
-0.3434473276,
0.531737566,
0.0744654834,
-0.2300161272,
0.138728559,
0.4770510197,
0.1147480607,
-0.0301363152,
-0.8882092237,
-0.2651961446,
-0.3153329492,
0.3127333224,
0.8741039038,
-0.59265697,
-0.010470422,
-0.1826872379,
0.7447391748,
0.0283304732,
0.2436915338,
0.3929870129,
-0.6570457816,
-0.6305074096,
-0.0133568551,
0.06888064,
0.6500436664,
-0.4821403623,
0.3957058489,
-0.0691468716,
-0.7746456861,
-0.547595799,
-0.2914187908,
0.2950073481,
0.5492886305,
0.678571403,
0.0536756888,
-0.7658853531,
-0.9901685715,
-0.4607582688,
-0.2669223547,
0.1690861583,
0.069107376,
0.4170366824,
-0.334605217,
0.9415240288,
-0.2696618438,
-0.1003473699,
-0.3102210462,
0.1428009421,
-0.1198355332,
0.2447051108,
0.6121813059,
-1.2550936937,
-0.7788530588,
-0.2154131681,
-0.2619387209,
-0.1768130213,
0.3349810243,
0.153915748,
0.0620908141,
0.3660384417,
-0.2189263552,
0.6730656624,
0.6131708026,
-0.3700852394,
0.5682142973,
0.534304738,
0.2607599497,
-0.7703755498,
-0.1939940453,
0.0964547917,
-0.250748843,
-1.1234618425,
-0.0393094532,
-0.2466230839,
-0.1047148034,
-0.703281939,
0.359503001,
0.2425314188,
0.3634952903,
-0.4826889932,
0.065276064,
-0.5668259263,
0.1481738091,
-0.1270676702,
0.6841073036,
0.2036895156,
-0.1956932694,
0.587087214,
0.3567192852,
-0.4386300743,
0.552982986,
-0.5510392189,
0.2002159506,
-0.1729635596,
0.3206754029,
-0.965667963,
-0.0382118449,
0.6190481186,
-0.576259613,
-0.1143573597,
-0.2145428061,
-0.5353915691,
-0.4949839711,
-0.2412279546,
0.6818141937,
0.616758883,
-0.4320866764,
0.6321678758,
0.655031383,
-0.1782147437,
-0.4974558353,
-0.6822341681,
0.0607639998,
-0.6395142078,
-0.4075941741,
0.442697376,
-0.0607459024,
-0.5544634461,
-0.0678582117,
0.0192079935,
-0.0804900378,
0.2187547535,
0.3199826181,
0.1141908094,
-0.2329644114,
-0.0052938191,
-0.1842802614,
-0.0082047414,
0.2004778534,
0.0669336468,
0.7378584743,
0.0357106291,
-0.368739903,
-0.3533144295,
0.2927174568,
0.6937023997,
-0.2885711491,
0.6918054223,
1.1937973499,
-0.4184402525,
0.0421686806,
-0.6744732261,
-0.0864233077,
-0.4133640826,
0.4661379158,
0.1229131892,
-0.9864513278,
0.5212839246,
0.1609255075,
-0.0033178492,
0.5925716758,
0.8377878666,
0.1459927708,
1.0029181242,
0.387529254,
-0.4152327776,
0.7354183793,
0.1815956384,
0.6959819198,
-0.5047416091,
0.0676611736,
-0.80693084,
-0.2222312391,
-0.6644487977,
-0.3239306808,
0.5132206082,
-0.3461391628,
-0.3234740794,
0.2444865555,
-0.6123697162,
0.4278165698,
0.40862149,
-0.2193706036,
0.1302758157,
0.0988227352,
0.4997251928,
-0.0808798671,
-0.2859775424,
-0.4211922288,
0.9573388696,
0.4141424596,
0.4395774603,
0.3060475588,
0.2766784132,
0.7455608845,
0.468226552,
-0.7970170379,
0.4488568306,
-0.3027845025,
-1.0129189491,
-0.3254745007,
-0.2654243708,
-0.9442510605,
0.2511649132,
-0.1142605245,
-0.8959405422,
-0.2251521647,
0.1058712229,
-0.2883155942,
0.7984374166,
-0.3272827566,
0.7307821512,
-0.0414144844,
-0.3223251998,
-0.4152678549,
-0.3947595656,
0.0184940174,
-0.215568766,
0.3978908062,
-0.3870325685,
0.374011606,
1.0314539671,
0.0279468652,
0.9862542748,
-0.298654139,
-0.5380158424,
0.2562195063,
-0.1297255307,
0.6332814097,
-0.3860748708,
-0.2572015226,
0.346803546,
-0.3205262721,
-0.246574834,
-0.271150142,
0.4998515248,
-0.5667508841,
-0.4681444764,
-0.1790260375,
-0.614790082,
-0.1837201864,
0.2590534985,
0.2754716277,
0.3138998449,
-0.5089285374,
0.3124123812,
0.8036291003,
-0.4356686473,
0.2035594732,
0.3709020317,
-0.274731189,
-0.2751502693,
0.9492129087,
0.1669978201,
0.0846405178,
0.068491891,
0.3387034833,
-0.2367922366,
-0.7560493946,
-0.5252577662,
-0.0148244854,
-0.4389078319,
-0.2405835837,
-0.6877402663,
-0.2957695127,
-0.6140868664,
-0.2392623425,
-0.54157269,
-0.1123992577,
0.0766605362,
0.1144897267,
0.4617867768,
0.6599920392,
0.0345600843,
0.5631294847,
-0.4511490464,
0.5353124142,
0.1211632341,
0.2611988187,
-0.1284721047,
-0.7757814527,
-0.2615213096,
0.3639342189,
-0.2084152699,
-0.8704296947,
0.3013595045,
-0.3418726921,
0.3542398214,
0.0756290108,
0.4157629907,
0.4593008757,
-0.611626327,
0.733864069,
0.038151022,
-0.7519968748,
0.664344728,
-0.3972202241,
-0.0459503904,
0.2307945639,
0.6118753552,
-0.6907354593,
-0.608150959,
-0.6944262385,
-0.8922536373,
0.5769677758,
0.3067418337,
0.2617405653,
0.0081355385,
-0.1019944772,
0.155085206,
0.0430569313,
-0.8159067035,
-0.638638556,
-0.1537581384,
-0.4252515435,
0.0838822946,
-0.2627645731,
-0.2276150435,
-0.113275446,
0.8934679031,
0.1328562498,
0.16801323,
-0.2077106088,
-0.155569911,
-0.0587670207,
0.4562700689,
0.4076619446,
0.4206437767,
0.0813438818,
-0.0873933062,
0.0125194704,
-0.4952846766,
0.0764746442,
0.286351651,
-0.4710123837,
0.0585766211,
0.2958191931,
0.7639026642,
-0.2914025187,
-0.7120127678,
0.5634486079,
0.1610791236,
-0.0698794574,
-0.6695880294,
0.0475630239,
-0.1795195341,
0.4822009504,
0.1315099895,
-0.1870780289,
0.1247306839,
-0.249638617,
0.1623145044,
0.5915099382,
-0.5648542047,
-0.3486990631,
0.7674803138,
0.0433133021,
-0.5209857821,
0.5808032155,
0.007997782,
-0.7332775593,
0.5763943195,
0.7209754586,
0.7286146283,
-0.5042233467,
0.2944250405,
0.110411033,
0.2614577711,
0.4188992679,
-0.2077317536,
0.0016128054,
-1.0848687887,
-0.2300744206,
-0.5847388506,
-0.4046268165,
0.4834481776,
-0.6236717701,
-0.028183056,
-0.3521187603,
-0.0938999504,
0.53795892,
-0.1497258991,
-0.4792427123,
-0.059782397,
0.8433427215,
0.6332710981,
-0.9028021097,
0.7993758321,
0.34941715,
-0.1681677103,
-0.1329370886,
0.0476284362,
0.4425510764,
-0.9363778234,
0.4511975348,
0.1526626796,
-0.5387952924,
0.1852455884,
-0.6131898761,
-0.5749021769,
0.4041826725,
0.2266527414,
-0.561185658,
0.2052495033,
0.4802213013,
0.7053311467,
-0.1001220495,
0.0653521195,
0.7849974036,
0.5571329594,
0.0084798923,
-0.7824010849,
-0.1231141165,
-0.2005161494,
-0.2559451163,
0.4967646897,
-0.5352344513,
0.4415036142,
0.1803413332,
-0.203386277,
-0.1243813634,
0.666598618,
-0.2482357174,
0.2721646428,
0.7595173717,
0.6254592538,
0.5736628175,
-0.0031168694,
0.5991253853,
0.0541565157,
0.149377197,
1.0230408907,
-0.2272649407,
0.5263742208,
0.067336835,
-0.2857267559,
0.4295137227,
0.1988536119,
-0.3320376277,
0.2772557437,
0.5199363232,
-0.5781777501,
-0.0444229767,
-0.6953770518,
-0.2931694984,
0.6560279131,
0.6660320759,
-0.3049445748,
-0.3531728983,
0.3515450358,
0.2918793261,
0.2399189323,
-0.3726682961,
0.7091934085,
-0.3908730149,
-0.246733278,
0.347286433,
0.0772992671,
0.9797724485,
-0.4142881334,
0.2518698275,
0.1327733994,
0.1581852436,
-0.1250674576,
-0.701605916,
0.5783184767,
0.5794374943,
-0.1287367493,
-0.2287645191,
0.6504747272,
-0.3157232702,
-0.3089101315,
0.4658325613,
0.2631106675,
0.0620053224,
-0.1924422979,
-0.8112057447,
0.4784125984,
0.1718308777,
-0.1156142503,
0.17721349,
0.0397612117,
-0.215812698,
0.5024319291,
0.5716850758,
-0.089178443,
0.0543137528,
0.4299631715,
0.823582828,
-0.6105101109,
-0.2208109498,
-1.0745717287,
0.2013279796,
-0.039468471,
-0.3270516396,
0.6759223342,
0.6874213815,
1.0828688145,
0.3499532938,
0.9187761545,
-0.2461438179,
0.7721887827,
-0.1349502653,
0.410623163,
-0.2061394751,
-0.0959777832,
-0.3792588711,
-0.7964637876,
-0.6503698826,
0.5024757385,
-0.6838112473,
-0.1861127615,
0.1383930743,
0.8412720561,
-0.1129637808,
0.2919134796,
0.2448925972,
0.4683604836,
0.8483288884,
0.1721179187,
0.9632940888,
-0.3240069151,
0.6773467064,
-0.2016036808,
-0.1520440429,
-0.2643828094,
-0.4849295616,
-0.6311740875,
-0.5597062111,
-0.4698903263,
-0.4152420461,
0.1313252002,
0.9070057273,
0.384285301,
-0.8856965303,
0.0990693122,
0.1899764091,
-0.0081453444,
-0.0402029492,
-0.2093975544,
0.3223286867,
-0.022300994,
-0.9628230929,
0.3876053393,
0.0729535297,
-0.0077553983,
-0.0801187083,
0.1951426566,
-0.1712382883,
0.1031448022,
0.6551027894,
0.2485012859,
-0.9067785144,
-0.341121763,
-0.5385454297,
0.050326705,
0.1234781146,
0.7613356113,
-0.6461468339,
0.1103351563,
0.1725560576,
1.0356926918,
0.382561177,
-0.0409374759,
0.1221674606,
-0.2948467731,
0.0948677212,
0.6337447166,
0.1947854608,
0.2390817255,
-0.1885157228,
0.5918968916,
0.0981670991,
-0.5512577891,
-0.9140322208,
0.6930459738,
-0.6854177713,
-0.2140301019,
1.1214002371,
0.1578758061,
-0.0219608005,
-0.3308409452,
-0.1342172325,
0.5470101833,
-0.3207403421,
0.8608685136,
0.4950139821,
-0.024325069,
0.1573553681,
-0.4404992163,
0.3776578903,
0.4717493355,
-0.6560647488,
0.2771210968,
0.5862680674,
-0.1612974703,
0.3235135972,
0.312527597,
-0.1263865829,
0.0480784029,
-0.1263649464,
-0.0184839815,
0.1501401067,
-0.2361821085,
-0.2384369075,
0.1532149166,
-0.2662188113,
-0.0605299473
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03789v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03789v1
|
On Adversarial Examples for Text Classification by Perturbing Latent Representations
| 2024-05-06T18:45:18 | 2024-05-06T18:45:18 |
Korn Sooksatra, Bikram Khanal, Pablo Rivas
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.CR, 68T01, 68T50, I.2.7
|
Recently, with the advancement of deep learning, several applications in text
classification have advanced significantly. However, this improvement comes
with a cost because deep learning is vulnerable to adversarial examples. This
weakness indicates that deep learning is not very robust. Fortunately, the
input of a text classifier is discrete. Hence, it can prevent the classifier
from state-of-the-art attacks. Nonetheless, previous works have generated
black-box attacks that successfully manipulate the discrete values of the input
to find adversarial examples. Therefore, instead of changing the discrete
values, we transform the input into its embedding vector containing real values
to perform the state-of-the-art white-box attacks. Then, we convert the
perturbed embedding vector back into a text and name it an adversarial example.
In summary, we create a framework that measures the robustness of a text
classifier by using the gradients of the classifier.
|
[
-0.2499683946,
-1.1403810978,
0.4008552432,
-0.3227419257,
-0.3239782751,
0.0529638156,
0.1138561815,
0.0347853564,
-0.2367297709,
0.4248417616,
-0.2577243149,
-0.436662823,
-0.7206736207,
-0.2183781117,
-0.7005952597,
1.5567257404,
-0.0253556948,
-0.1790402085,
-0.0076644067,
-0.0806225464,
-0.1108097285,
-0.9863390326,
-0.5679752231,
-0.0569996201,
0.4706515372,
-0.040711049,
0.8369598985,
0.2322226614,
0.4045222104,
0.3640126288,
-0.1031513959,
-0.2964476049,
-0.5680097938,
0.2685093284,
0.0616882555,
-0.5727118254,
-0.1494438648,
0.3571620584,
0.5776375532,
0.4072645605,
0.0618531667,
-0.3266467452,
-0.0132154906,
0.1272634119,
-0.7614699006,
-0.0881426409,
-0.8305015564,
0.3725016117,
-0.1951552331,
-0.1632990688,
-0.4950559437,
-0.4303742945,
0.0157113001,
-0.2783913612,
0.228422299,
-0.4215004146,
0.8294023275,
0.4762043059,
-0.37320593,
-0.359041959,
-0.8077679873,
0.7126460671,
-0.5540390015,
-0.0042712023,
0.2521051764,
0.5090205669,
-0.387670815,
-0.8005151153,
-0.6542003751,
-0.0109005561,
-0.0288881436,
0.2040545791,
-0.4725754559,
-0.0167148355,
0.2461727411,
0.4529761672,
-0.4901426435,
-0.0499145277,
-0.0745745301,
-0.080409877,
0.5429139733,
0.1088493541,
0.3615255058,
0.2766797841,
-0.5715911388,
-0.6411501765,
-0.4085782766,
0.205051586,
0.5987285972,
0.0087200366,
0.0766850859,
0.3586454988,
0.5239698887,
0.5473594666,
0.1118560135,
-0.0494451746,
0.1085119545,
-0.1731179655,
-0.2550413311,
0.0860514939,
0.9460509419,
0.1915242374,
0.0730242506,
-0.1493130773,
-0.3182425499,
0.5269040465,
0.6625867486,
-1.0496379137,
-0.3204492033,
-0.0357654393,
-0.3909574747,
-1.0503007174,
0.1488845795,
-1.0267882347,
-0.5564088821,
0.4703756571,
0.4461399615,
-0.1368862689,
0.1244621798,
0.0688204989,
-0.154135555,
0.0140173892,
0.3606373966,
-0.9108415246,
0.4338226914,
0.5011731982,
0.6380675435,
0.0421202853,
-0.1572280228,
-0.5448485613,
-0.2209596485,
-0.3670571744,
0.642054081,
-0.4547989964,
-0.467657119,
0.1272885203,
-0.1933098435,
0.2039433867,
-0.2591561973,
0.5582398772,
-0.629823029,
0.363848865,
0.3420234025,
-0.3053667545,
-0.2325803787,
0.4982997179,
-0.6192439795,
0.7341304421,
0.1258957237,
-0.9372379184,
0.0011994357,
-0.3178840578,
-0.4305668175,
-0.0742795691,
-0.3697904646,
-1.0737349987,
0.1856648326,
0.091228202,
0.7451892495,
-0.0903072953,
0.0214582775,
-0.5394750237,
-0.4275711179,
0.7139700055,
-0.9979263544,
0.9700171351,
0.0592158735,
-0.3946179748,
-0.1510109305,
-0.7104508281,
-0.3172816038,
0.2821790874,
-0.2203402519,
-0.5274067521,
0.0922274217,
0.0406502821,
0.2152498066,
0.0718974769,
-0.4526953101,
0.2641508281,
-0.5611487627,
0.4598035216,
0.8000613451,
0.0739955828,
0.446980536,
-0.3092251718,
0.6877797842,
0.0023196177,
-0.1511905938,
-0.0905553699,
-0.3486672938,
-0.437559545,
-0.1965918541,
0.5124325156,
0.5978295803,
-0.9124803543,
0.4476837814,
-0.0107803298,
-0.5667415857,
-0.178204447,
-0.1225937083,
0.2899898887,
0.4347136021,
0.2040597647,
0.0514981262,
-0.076141648,
-0.5165308118,
-0.2107415497,
-0.2249824554,
-0.0798103362,
0.1124218926,
0.6447013021,
-0.4912667274,
0.416344434,
-0.6108796597,
-0.0303483084,
0.2519530058,
0.2957450747,
-0.0807213783,
0.4947223663,
0.8108677864,
-1.2003805637,
-0.2909759581,
-0.0934728757,
-0.6090058684,
0.1751250923,
-0.3755417168,
0.0609888025,
-0.1698446274,
0.8417460322,
-0.096191451,
0.7849239111,
0.5600317717,
-0.6077066064,
0.3908166885,
-0.1452682167,
-0.0707861856,
-1.0260813236,
-0.2265412807,
-0.0494049825,
-0.2515608668,
-0.6322542429,
0.1487982571,
-0.0172168724,
-0.4468998015,
-0.3330704868,
0.3404702246,
0.2168111056,
0.2896849513,
-0.1722663641,
-0.1144226342,
-0.0334547125,
0.2775975466,
-0.3509725034,
0.544852674,
0.3547886312,
-0.6483616829,
0.4134319127,
0.2123643458,
0.1136752814,
0.6387039423,
-0.6903120875,
0.0555117838,
-0.1050461531,
0.3411508501,
-1.0191227198,
0.1583585888,
0.4249523878,
-0.6809536219,
0.659627378,
-0.0784000158,
-0.2510745823,
-0.0157890841,
-0.7502490282,
0.3369033039,
0.5006161332,
-0.7662252784,
0.4837136269,
0.2130790651,
-0.0803332627,
-0.7634132504,
-0.9729375839,
0.1581264436,
-0.2999461293,
-0.1858010739,
0.6336170435,
-0.230433926,
0.0101481546,
0.1895591617,
-0.0410680324,
-0.099403888,
0.732960403,
0.215375632,
0.0837825537,
-0.1154220328,
-0.0734029561,
0.0499663427,
-0.3001342714,
0.3293159604,
-0.2513256967,
0.295969367,
-0.0604196414,
-0.2557301223,
-0.4015956521,
0.3911821246,
0.758097291,
-0.0970226228,
0.6216993928,
0.7372676134,
-0.7175755501,
-0.4927178621,
0.1132988632,
-0.030831676,
-0.4942465723,
0.5660709143,
-0.453138411,
-0.6675824523,
0.3287782073,
-0.0429767221,
0.047010377,
0.4880010486,
0.3767561913,
-0.1343774199,
0.9867975116,
0.4517033696,
0.10209959,
0.5802993774,
-0.4405225217,
0.1477866918,
-0.4997864962,
-0.0474792384,
-0.7019252777,
-0.1015437618,
-0.7878127098,
-0.2107842714,
0.0497488156,
0.116770938,
-0.3720629215,
0.2796331942,
-0.5591917038,
0.2252323776,
0.2722318172,
0.2898196876,
-0.3097870648,
0.2544440329,
-0.2786119282,
-0.2927652597,
-0.6541763544,
-0.7439323664,
1.0611726046,
0.5411733389,
0.9875847101,
0.3057887256,
0.6566820741,
0.4303002059,
0.439068377,
-0.7305488586,
0.3017566204,
-0.8317120075,
-0.2910111845,
-0.2131457627,
-0.5729012489,
-0.9982164502,
0.229337737,
-0.5241675377,
-0.5840817094,
0.2730332613,
0.1256725043,
-0.2415603101,
0.6015806198,
-0.462079823,
1.0287480354,
-0.2889132202,
-0.1543104649,
0.1672405452,
-0.1251401305,
0.0761657879,
-0.324929893,
0.1487050503,
0.4865829945,
-0.118141003,
0.6863402128,
-0.373315841,
0.9276918173,
-0.1603077799,
-0.133837387,
0.0103437044,
0.1224964261,
0.5556147695,
0.1419506818,
0.0566293746,
-0.0866309553,
-0.3821535707,
-0.5350835919,
-1.0064898729,
0.6191604733,
-0.7622683048,
-0.44334957,
-0.7774866223,
-0.0782428235,
-0.0743313655,
0.0220696647,
0.4805109799,
0.604321003,
-0.3684862256,
0.4600701034,
0.9271531701,
-0.4222768247,
0.5389193296,
-0.0290344507,
0.1892767996,
-0.6176959276,
1.161057353,
0.0271431487,
0.0764007196,
0.6474959254,
0.3399147093,
-0.3231973946,
-0.8782075644,
-0.4639164507,
-0.4142984152,
-0.6907948852,
-0.3044852018,
-0.5075192451,
-0.2458694875,
-0.2735019922,
-0.6138063669,
-0.1448966861,
-0.1659988761,
-0.7496749759,
-0.0232708324,
-0.0208460204,
0.8505267501,
0.4154345989,
0.3904242218,
-0.5024113655,
0.3019691706,
0.7150916457,
0.2858005762,
0.0656944662,
-0.3938862979,
-0.0703492686,
-0.0507686362,
-0.5600624084,
-1.036991477,
0.403054595,
-0.1237685978,
0.578122735,
0.5148821473,
0.3085702658,
0.2474467754,
-0.4564619064,
0.7288638353,
0.3638905287,
-0.8388829231,
0.4865957499,
-0.1693105549,
-0.0401297137,
0.5122041702,
0.4918795526,
-0.1119922251,
-0.3470153809,
-0.8953353763,
-0.5496362448,
0.4227766991,
0.3301436603,
0.1354831159,
0.3213852346,
0.4702945352,
0.0081193484,
0.070954226,
-0.9420234561,
-0.4661096334,
-0.7018555999,
-0.5266981721,
-0.308701545,
-0.3645499945,
-0.0379937887,
0.2081258744,
0.5277887583,
0.0180556886,
0.286775589,
0.1730633825,
-0.0615054294,
0.3859651387,
0.249811098,
0.5674943924,
-0.2289657593,
-0.0727352127,
0.527127564,
0.2081442475,
-0.8124952316,
0.5968569517,
0.5269215703,
-0.5570952892,
-0.1056133211,
0.4090687931,
0.4740029573,
0.2038616836,
-0.2231990248,
0.8489257693,
-0.6538104415,
-0.1971586049,
-0.3229978085,
0.0377212353,
-0.3998595476,
0.0533526763,
0.4373172522,
0.4447574914,
0.2418496013,
-0.4675304294,
0.2559477985,
0.5061866641,
-0.8746942282,
-0.1989277005,
0.7154518366,
0.1993766576,
-0.4377236962,
-0.0064180065,
-0.5215739608,
-0.9714771509,
0.5224146843,
0.5270895958,
0.8631808758,
-0.2776195109,
0.1435618848,
-0.0222728997,
0.3559936583,
0.0649226084,
-0.1619170457,
0.0261369459,
-0.5816708803,
-0.0669098049,
-0.3485128284,
-0.2869992256,
0.4519867599,
-0.5299632549,
0.1583797038,
-0.8443314433,
-0.1708519012,
0.3779183924,
0.1459190696,
-0.3048707545,
0.4213446379,
0.0741579086,
0.3980287015,
-0.9329934716,
0.5305547118,
1.0294761658,
-0.2583606541,
-0.0020274436,
0.2776693404,
-0.0890350491,
-0.1577434242,
0.3021851182,
0.112669535,
-0.1627710164,
-0.4663135707,
-0.6017152071,
-0.2225236446,
0.7029083967,
0.4064652622,
-0.2891450524,
0.1715454608,
-0.2516274452,
0.4987975657,
-0.1751876175,
0.039377518,
-0.0150576476,
0.1309111863,
-0.3406662643,
-0.140639022,
0.1737229526,
-0.3908886909,
0.0996893942,
0.1019242406,
-0.4768702984,
1.1359872818,
0.171347633,
-0.2816295326,
-0.2027088404,
0.5459482074,
-0.1028379574,
0.441234678,
0.5484492183,
0.5665937662,
0.7350117564,
-0.2496887594,
1.2244255543,
0.1678011864,
0.2678114176,
0.851718843,
0.1292868555,
0.7760670781,
0.037878748,
-0.2189718485,
0.5741674304,
0.4489522278,
-0.4056596756,
0.5531181097,
0.4036917388,
-0.4058103561,
0.0066506504,
0.3183583915,
-0.306804508,
0.4275508523,
0.6714912057,
-0.3202790618,
-0.2283938527,
0.3237572908,
0.2315942049,
0.6462658048,
-0.2666345537,
0.6161642671,
-0.0511621907,
-0.0930866003,
0.6158853173,
0.2564759254,
1.0611803532,
-0.4488024414,
-0.197680831,
0.2315049171,
0.5269632936,
-0.2081673741,
-0.5713902712,
0.2385800183,
0.0169248153,
-0.2175485939,
-0.2054625899,
0.7999691367,
-0.1285490096,
-0.5620504618,
0.1674273163,
-0.1591856182,
-0.0088495174,
-0.0035772102,
-0.7079470754,
-0.1872313023,
0.0449351333,
-0.0933376923,
0.4137277901,
0.6397361755,
0.2426778078,
0.4360117614,
0.6124096513,
0.0296747647,
-0.2467640042,
-0.2268825471,
0.8225773573,
-0.776060462,
-0.6049262285,
-1.1085014343,
0.2392747402,
-0.1478795856,
-0.4785731137,
0.7570946217,
0.36745435,
0.794834733,
0.1144285351,
0.9850567579,
0.3870414495,
0.073407717,
-0.4068530202,
0.8739458919,
-0.4301956296,
0.3695857823,
-0.3963598311,
-0.3692549467,
-0.5795571208,
0.8785322309,
-0.0927079171,
-0.0809670985,
0.7062757015,
0.4015424252,
-0.019211771,
-0.0512759909,
0.4818773568,
0.2485918999,
0.5124693513,
0.5405148864,
0.7184891701,
-0.9037203789,
0.9930072427,
-0.3159638941,
-0.3663487732,
-0.2418535501,
-0.9714906216,
-1.3085980415,
-0.5723127127,
-0.5851355791,
-0.8637036681,
0.2579030097,
0.3226675093,
0.5488824844,
-0.9795641303,
0.3840142488,
-0.2346423119,
0.4012432694,
-0.0293662399,
-0.2300171852,
0.5087711215,
-0.1743634939,
-0.6138643622,
0.0804853812,
0.027519444,
0.8076491356,
-0.5337394476,
0.3512439728,
0.0718892589,
-0.0660802722,
0.5216134191,
0.1525390148,
-0.1977144182,
-0.0700387806,
-0.2684709132,
-0.3329697847,
-0.2412155271,
0.7483679056,
-0.7721557617,
0.2809452713,
0.3095554709,
1.1579090357,
0.5089942813,
-0.1503363848,
0.4820271432,
-0.8308286667,
0.2221620232,
0.6082400084,
0.2647770345,
0.3462856114,
-0.5184809566,
0.0575261675,
0.2474489063,
-0.311237812,
-0.9192492366,
0.2461549938,
-0.6676253676,
-0.6010047197,
0.8890020251,
-0.5299258232,
-0.3621301651,
-0.24471578,
-0.2112955451,
0.0367957503,
-0.3941624165,
0.7424978018,
0.7066367865,
0.452188462,
0.1039592102,
-0.430152148,
0.580776751,
0.0487342551,
-0.6507887244,
-0.1094446108,
-0.0297044348,
-0.0675913095,
0.4152716398,
0.2327380478,
-0.3142560124,
0.396176219,
0.6276973486,
-0.2209479213,
0.0667237416,
-0.1081801504,
-0.8807669878,
0.4954794347,
-0.1032014564,
-0.3268061578
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06687v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06687v1
|
Hire Me or Not? Examining Language Model's Behavior with Occupation Attributes
| 2024-05-06T18:09:32 | 2024-05-06T18:09:32 |
Damin Zhang, Yi Zhang, Geetanjali Bihani, Julia Rayz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the impressive performance in various downstream tasks, large language
models (LLMs) have been widely integrated into production pipelines, like
recruitment and recommendation systems. A known issue of models trained on
natural language data is the presence of human biases, which can impact the
fairness of the system. This paper investigates LLMs' behavior with respect to
gender stereotypes, in the context of occupation decision making. Our framework
is designed to investigate and quantify the presence of gender stereotypes in
LLMs' behavior via multi-round question answering. Inspired by prior works, we
construct a dataset by leveraging a standard occupation classification
knowledge base released by authoritative agencies. We tested three LLMs
(RoBERTa-large, GPT-3.5-turbo, and Llama2-70b-chat) and found that all models
exhibit gender stereotypes analogous to human biases, but with different
preferences. The distinct preferences of GPT-3.5-turbo and Llama2-70b-chat may
imply the current alignment methods are insufficient for debiasing and could
introduce new biases contradicting the traditional gender stereotypes.
|
[
-0.2745375931,
-0.5616509318,
0.7533378005,
0.1071404442,
0.2377718538,
0.0727239251,
-0.0479929522,
-0.372023046,
0.1233226955,
0.7743863463,
-0.7618375421,
-0.3931806982,
-0.5940951109,
0.4147565365,
-0.4457724094,
0.7694922686,
0.2837818265,
0.221740514,
-0.3061775565,
0.0552703924,
-0.7058055997,
-0.753819108,
-0.5165535808,
-0.2102983147,
0.3377175927,
0.4227728546,
0.8488445878,
0.4165204167,
0.1103524491,
0.3555961847,
-0.0164393988,
-0.0140296733,
-0.2489306629,
0.2582578361,
-0.001826168,
-0.8144389391,
-0.3534181118,
0.5195767879,
0.1223299727,
0.8547772169,
-0.3008993566,
0.4445278347,
-0.283608377,
0.5110096931,
-0.5345108509,
0.1412619799,
-0.8441429138,
-0.0967999995,
-0.2898081541,
0.1664005518,
-0.3087093234,
-0.4833770692,
0.1491950005,
-0.1828163415,
0.4711949527,
0.3935630322,
0.599761188,
-0.0339562111,
-0.5610861778,
-0.3421285152,
-0.638379097,
0.9409079552,
-0.8405375481,
0.4310410023,
0.6970484853,
0.497841239,
-0.1121075749,
-0.0074248351,
-0.5678422451,
-0.3243196011,
-0.1443337053,
-0.1955069005,
-0.0035214829,
0.091341503,
0.3353693187,
0.2782301903,
-0.5930275917,
0.4880088568,
-0.6379298568,
-0.1354884803,
0.3659055531,
0.1177675352,
0.3389807642,
-0.0903903097,
-0.1405891478,
-0.0581294,
-0.4094599783,
0.0890199244,
1.0355724096,
0.2597578168,
0.0094680199,
0.7201822996,
-0.3546152711,
0.6787557602,
0.1619283259,
-0.1440341473,
0.2332072556,
0.2205964923,
-0.2460111529,
0.0778199956,
0.6812805533,
0.4658646882,
0.5310852528,
-0.197353214,
-0.2461210042,
-0.0703511983,
0.4806443155,
-0.3295148909,
0.2932327688,
0.2706854641,
-0.4285666645,
-0.3852792382,
-0.1150090471,
-0.696495235,
-0.566516161,
-0.1768984497,
0.0801249221,
0.0288819354,
-0.3589530587,
-0.024877971,
-0.3182108998,
0.2832269967,
0.144094348,
-1.2812379599,
-0.0354671888,
0.6685364246,
0.5408399701,
0.0956646875,
-0.1520233154,
-0.4587265551,
0.0233495515,
-0.4409983456,
0.3762741983,
-0.7287142873,
-0.3486601114,
0.2306158394,
0.0260881148,
-0.2823802233,
-0.8477132916,
0.5699036121,
-0.6146348715,
0.3632319868,
-0.2903313935,
-0.3348352909,
-0.1049938574,
0.4140435755,
-0.4221990108,
0.9968895912,
0.2314030975,
-0.5445792079,
0.5692629814,
-0.4887142777,
0.0444600061,
-0.3227152526,
-0.5493177772,
-0.2461915463,
-0.0116559183,
0.1512479782,
0.4794516265,
-0.262393862,
0.5552532077,
-0.7438157201,
-0.2310224175,
0.58544451,
-0.2263067663,
0.8604014516,
0.2408268154,
-0.1017441973,
-0.1060197875,
-0.299638927,
-0.3544885218,
0.0336915702,
-0.2765091658,
-0.4191243052,
-0.0336617604,
-0.4129275382,
0.4640074968,
0.0771595463,
-0.719355464,
0.1673385501,
-0.3070683181,
0.1858205199,
1.0281512737,
-0.4586201906,
0.6651213765,
-0.3629639745,
0.8108510375,
-0.2131784111,
-0.0133528141,
0.5857285261,
-0.4604009688,
-0.5987179279,
-0.1422697902,
-0.018762866,
0.5466303825,
-0.6661818624,
0.3097608387,
-0.1386310309,
-0.2570929527,
-0.5487915874,
0.2944258749,
0.3691594899,
0.3190585077,
0.0639618412,
0.0827070102,
-0.628811419,
-1.3396048546,
-0.6117227077,
-0.3077768087,
-0.0889886096,
0.2226061076,
0.4037486911,
-0.1246749088,
1.1932051182,
-0.4808093905,
-0.2905331254,
-0.2981128991,
0.1586423218,
0.5546219945,
0.1722204983,
0.9176313281,
-0.550955236,
-0.1111600101,
-0.394818753,
-0.7830978036,
-0.3304436505,
0.1630965173,
-0.1489726901,
0.2060754597,
0.5701659918,
-0.6510061026,
0.1563458294,
0.7740573287,
-0.4797398746,
0.7806223035,
-0.008652471,
0.1035006046,
-0.6101723909,
-0.3160995543,
0.1714036614,
-0.1884080917,
-0.6240801811,
-0.2622172236,
-0.3167664707,
-0.1206605062,
-0.3767048717,
0.5791050792,
-0.4881549478,
-0.3720305562,
-0.0336206779,
-0.0765942633,
-0.0337635912,
0.412575841,
0.1197593659,
0.868026793,
0.2781968713,
-0.86723423,
0.0252769273,
0.5288410187,
-0.3706831038,
0.6107799411,
-0.3127861321,
0.3260087371,
-0.475373894,
0.1916789412,
-0.9933790565,
-0.1678668708,
0.092790693,
-0.3426096141,
-0.0214236006,
-0.2456787229,
-0.6255126595,
-0.6116364598,
-0.2604171932,
0.2758736312,
0.5236917138,
-0.3725334704,
0.3066602647,
0.5188837647,
-0.3150947392,
-0.7126219869,
-0.8062725067,
-0.1542814076,
-0.4869422019,
-0.6267553568,
-0.0132595105,
0.1646737009,
-0.7421481013,
-0.5545186996,
-0.1709350646,
-0.3555599749,
-0.0739880353,
0.144317776,
0.2824984491,
-0.0821966082,
-0.1682775319,
-0.1019943282,
0.092903398,
0.179993242,
0.1120365337,
0.4416869879,
0.0839303732,
-0.4298639297,
-0.0507712141,
0.0191462822,
0.7574815154,
0.0524426736,
0.7858117819,
0.7709697485,
-0.0424719676,
0.0716969818,
-0.9952162504,
-0.2658940554,
-0.5011337996,
0.4544129968,
0.0182274375,
-1.1659784317,
0.4082709253,
0.3180189431,
0.1953360736,
0.1953373849,
0.4969298244,
-0.3112545013,
1.0667709112,
0.5220969915,
-0.2089405656,
0.3107979298,
0.0333537348,
0.278490901,
-0.7425538301,
-0.2009259462,
-0.6723824143,
-0.3722421229,
-0.6123813391,
-0.4401135445,
0.3836141527,
-0.2567833662,
-0.2588120103,
0.0444447473,
-0.2462686002,
0.0826608166,
0.5417406559,
-0.1301455796,
0.1720588952,
-0.2620905936,
0.1450245231,
-0.1325482577,
-0.4514445364,
-0.7656433582,
0.8713558912,
0.3249934614,
0.6580194235,
0.4466739297,
0.3142132461,
0.4940999746,
0.0989212468,
-0.2531372607,
0.6320245862,
-0.3129872084,
-1.2175198793,
-0.3824047148,
-0.3725999594,
-0.9131696224,
0.4412639439,
-0.338139832,
-0.8489829302,
0.3411073089,
0.1206997037,
-0.1018990949,
0.546243906,
-0.7691645622,
0.7284194231,
-0.4803298116,
0.0831918046,
-0.1255197227,
-0.3977180719,
0.6986339092,
-0.0342480764,
0.822435081,
-0.7913156152,
0.1160979718,
0.6495346427,
-0.5033653975,
1.0257058144,
-0.2853201628,
-0.1861257851,
0.2006719112,
0.1785313189,
0.472417295,
-0.1685842425,
-0.7163624763,
0.2428848147,
-0.0385919698,
-0.2679334581,
-0.341797024,
0.4632137716,
-0.6898631454,
-0.6767814159,
-0.4483252764,
-0.5347998142,
-0.4100465178,
0.0660638288,
0.0945728272,
0.176010713,
-0.2105028927,
0.0059392187,
0.2748879492,
-0.6373070478,
0.1312394589,
0.4342544079,
-0.5389908552,
0.2527284026,
0.6128529906,
0.0756702572,
0.3791139722,
0.1351592243,
-0.0165728498,
-0.5528764725,
-0.1697021574,
-0.4792170525,
0.2245509475,
-0.3904193044,
-0.0009371854,
-0.6969641447,
-0.0225186329,
-0.6679005027,
0.0335966274,
-0.23698394,
-0.1320525706,
-0.0780403018,
-0.1640046239,
0.3776153028,
0.6565868258,
0.3286991715,
0.3443497419,
-0.4265107512,
0.5152962208,
0.6306292415,
0.3757743537,
-0.2159188986,
-0.5243417621,
0.0498279668,
0.1425055414,
-0.2732884884,
-0.9035009742,
0.4449148178,
0.0169108622,
0.8383995295,
0.1737340391,
0.0875290111,
0.2400514334,
-0.175176248,
0.7557261586,
-0.0335048661,
-0.5249474645,
0.1615442485,
-0.7392904162,
-0.0694122687,
0.5470957756,
0.1849167794,
-0.442566365,
-0.8706643581,
-0.6516203284,
-0.6650750041,
1.0997006893,
0.4401827753,
0.4506565332,
-0.1859047562,
0.3366791308,
0.1870674342,
0.7228910923,
-0.7112147808,
-0.4551778436,
0.1011066213,
0.0909455344,
0.2299821079,
-0.5058358908,
0.3574337959,
-0.0714730248,
0.6188957095,
0.1706636995,
0.2537847459,
-0.2252527475,
-0.2234283984,
0.332007736,
0.7492154241,
0.3094453812,
0.630302906,
-0.6203303337,
0.1124682799,
0.3393453956,
-0.0678007305,
0.3001683652,
-0.2854664028,
-0.0904162228,
0.2149976343,
-0.0265969243,
0.6983305812,
0.026698675,
-0.7517291307,
0.5341665149,
0.0214171745,
-0.4090112448,
-0.417195797,
0.1648079604,
0.0482573472,
0.2404966801,
0.2383070439,
-0.118075043,
0.1826940179,
-0.6480036974,
-0.3146200776,
0.7220463753,
-0.4516831934,
-0.0286842883,
0.7390189767,
0.2713425756,
-0.0779123679,
0.9174751639,
-0.346247822,
-0.4024806321,
0.7251793146,
0.3756816983,
0.676820755,
-0.0622634888,
0.3281133175,
0.2804740667,
0.4145839512,
-0.1286231875,
0.0387463085,
0.6262132525,
-1.0003737211,
-0.3319855332,
-0.5771951079,
-0.4415345192,
0.1605063528,
-0.4999217987,
0.4499904215,
-0.445361197,
-0.3930956721,
-0.1528595686,
-0.6261438131,
-0.7976304889,
0.2783714831,
0.3135553896,
0.5674282908,
-1.0092135668,
0.462592721,
0.7539263964,
-0.3932833076,
-0.5219689012,
-0.1003906131,
0.2217476964,
-1.0476791859,
0.7049987316,
0.1734383255,
0.0028845205,
-0.2378327847,
-0.4007072151,
-0.6319690347,
0.877481699,
0.8509127498,
-0.2485142946,
-0.2088948637,
0.200857088,
0.2653646767,
-0.4442330301,
0.6040578485,
0.7729018331,
0.5163400769,
-0.2327103019,
-1.2281373739,
-0.2462704033,
0.0648892224,
0.0211487766,
-0.076740928,
-0.7172294855,
0.9561851025,
-0.173490122,
0.2426135093,
-0.1102376431,
0.4486334026,
0.4632068276,
0.0166997313,
0.9082615376,
0.1563416719,
0.8695041537,
0.0264827367,
1.0683120489,
0.1268001795,
0.2589571476,
0.8160355091,
-0.3869362175,
0.3509939313,
0.3788687885,
-0.4733490944,
0.7377718091,
0.5646708012,
-0.0299199764,
0.0798400119,
0.1848082542,
0.0570283942,
-0.5334666371,
-0.3827233613,
-0.2972947657,
0.6885807514,
0.1085970253,
-0.3224681318,
-0.3207438886,
-0.1919967234,
0.1574550122,
0.1345034689,
-0.2308101505,
0.5342780948,
0.1639074683,
-0.4599754512,
0.3700505495,
0.2144509405,
0.9217845798,
-0.5006093979,
-0.059459392,
-0.126060769,
-0.1435203701,
-0.3767742217,
-0.7754454613,
0.2900424004,
0.0753699988,
-0.5367154479,
-0.3154251277,
0.3636817038,
-0.3936009705,
-0.5548545122,
0.1405314952,
0.672072649,
0.2801887095,
-0.2781106234,
-0.690256834,
-0.2981750965,
0.1512778848,
0.060407646,
0.5874122381,
0.2552059591,
-0.2888785005,
0.8639394641,
0.6947082877,
0.0090632001,
0.1780618429,
0.2171705067,
0.2879071236,
-0.5886461735,
-0.5095318556,
-0.9161963463,
0.326446414,
-0.0438722149,
-0.1867706925,
0.7252028584,
0.5910288692,
0.5164337754,
-0.3131998181,
0.9147906899,
-0.0105432663,
0.8863331676,
-0.5540177822,
0.4341724813,
-0.4497691393,
0.4822355509,
-0.4793745577,
-1.0027456284,
0.2155814022,
0.5384694934,
-0.6905986071,
0.4560977519,
0.3665151596,
0.9475435019,
-0.1107770726,
-0.0964903012,
0.3385761678,
0.1597697884,
0.2150901407,
0.1650572717,
0.9817258716,
0.0649594963,
0.6481763124,
0.0625605509,
0.0590880737,
-0.3610886037,
-0.8212084174,
-0.9007302523,
-0.2193879336,
-0.2760640085,
-0.3630936444,
-0.1634233296,
1.0256354809,
0.6706514955,
-0.6761104465,
-0.5850827694,
0.4068035185,
0.407124877,
0.1289543808,
-0.2669686079,
-0.0817877799,
-0.3622927964,
-0.7667399645,
0.3079383075,
-0.0540190786,
-0.1898367852,
-0.2240373939,
-0.0233058054,
-0.4245290458,
-0.1188722327,
0.2819007635,
0.1383375227,
-0.8130010962,
-0.2715896666,
-0.0072218878,
-0.2547321618,
0.0215231143,
0.6607478857,
-0.4552659988,
0.3382093906,
0.2166509628,
0.3575435579,
0.1995875388,
0.081082277,
0.9697538018,
-1.0305669308,
0.2840210199,
-0.001218995,
0.3787290454,
0.4433090985,
-0.467951268,
0.5531579256,
0.0435569175,
-0.5598532557,
-0.6607125401,
0.1505275518,
-0.5670877695,
-0.1838974059,
1.5177390575,
0.4077111185,
0.1795438826,
-0.4747256935,
-0.1843168288,
0.064677462,
-0.6409127712,
0.689614594,
0.7101948261,
-0.2202955037,
0.0345729627,
-1.2321527004,
0.3982623816,
0.4440177679,
-0.3665760458,
0.0452915654,
0.6091961265,
0.3906670511,
-0.0521763861,
1.0191351175,
0.0514419973,
0.0199245643,
-0.4681612253,
0.2953442037,
0.0409606099,
0.2062408775,
-0.0447084457,
-0.1238882691,
0.6153085828,
-0.2412892729
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03764v1
|
GOVERN: Gradient Orientation Vote Ensemble for Multi-Teacher Reinforced Distillation
| 2024-05-06T18:02:00 | 2024-05-06T18:02:00 |
Wenjie Zhou, Zhenxin Ding, Xiaodong Zhang, Haibo Shi, Junfeng Wang, Dawei Yin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Pre-trained language models have become an integral component of
question-answering systems, achieving remarkable performance. For practical
deployment, it is critical to carry out knowledge distillation to preserve high
performance under computational constraints. In this paper, we address a key
question: given the importance of unsupervised distillation for student
performance, how does one effectively ensemble knowledge from multiple teachers
at this stage without the guidance of ground-truth labels? We propose a novel
algorithm, GOVERN, to tackle this issue. GOVERN has demonstrated significant
improvements in both offline and online experiments. The proposed algorithm has
been successfully deployed in a real-world commercial question-answering
system.
|
[
-0.5232490301,
-0.5011044741,
0.6420650482,
0.4778155386,
-0.1799659431,
0.2792210877,
-0.3042570353,
0.1580426842,
0.053164266,
0.5361489654,
-0.4147640169,
-0.4770412147,
-0.6385219097,
-0.1222416312,
-0.3873194754,
1.2701112032,
0.167661339,
0.4605024755,
-0.649079442,
-0.0825832933,
-0.1886972487,
-0.3474887311,
-0.3860326409,
-0.6753531694,
0.250998497,
0.5357023478,
0.3942737281,
0.4522017837,
0.2466710359,
0.3904496133,
-0.1158212498,
0.2324534059,
-0.5331740975,
0.1249869168,
-0.2350288332,
-0.8544285297,
-0.1155890897,
0.2215638161,
0.5176783204,
0.4933450222,
-0.8921507001,
0.0189306531,
0.3118303418,
0.6409487128,
-0.8330997825,
-0.2406554222,
-0.663428545,
-0.0578906238,
0.1068310291,
-0.3118198514,
-0.3387646973,
-0.6822813153,
0.1570072174,
-0.6872406006,
0.1065483168,
-0.0533528887,
0.3056563139,
0.501665175,
-0.4499852955,
-0.356150955,
-0.8469120264,
0.6919654608,
-0.6068433523,
0.0460271202,
0.2987682521,
0.4663305581,
-0.2255745381,
-1.0283147097,
-0.831053853,
0.3532171845,
-0.141057685,
0.2074782252,
0.2453559935,
0.415292263,
-0.1413332224,
0.3706058264,
-0.1826057136,
-0.075424619,
-0.4984216392,
-0.1058863178,
0.3357617557,
-0.0270901546,
-0.2125955522,
0.1475089043,
-0.5207727551,
-0.2916218936,
-0.3536708057,
0.2826825082,
0.4235788584,
0.0874518901,
0.3152636588,
0.3425320983,
-0.2310731262,
0.7289168239,
0.567932725,
-0.0654340088,
-0.029597044,
-0.2133621722,
-0.2256873101,
0.2749471664,
0.7151072025,
0.2576416135,
0.0022076226,
-0.0203882288,
-0.0612996221,
0.0109575605,
0.1065584347,
-0.9210838675,
-0.3920128942,
0.1571757346,
-0.0267124232,
-0.5748015046,
0.276702106,
-1.2668370008,
-0.634575069,
-0.4908750355,
0.665275991,
0.0333179981,
-0.448323071,
0.0976455882,
-0.4319885373,
0.1617739797,
0.2266654968,
-0.9160678983,
0.2688568532,
0.857688725,
0.5913251638,
0.0671542212,
-0.4789710045,
-0.5364323258,
-0.0520634726,
-0.0112992357,
0.4242390096,
-0.7899153829,
-0.3669652939,
-0.1665559858,
-0.2751144469,
-0.04644005,
-0.4193305671,
0.3657833934,
-0.627802968,
0.6961525083,
-0.1311630756,
-0.7793725133,
-0.0921237916,
0.3248085976,
-0.223836422,
0.9889647365,
-0.2073849738,
-0.7087516785,
0.4230564833,
-0.5520086884,
-0.2704513073,
-0.1623705328,
-0.1323058307,
-0.3235292435,
0.0261628479,
0.5801090002,
0.3371964395,
-0.1923100054,
0.603964448,
-0.1662988216,
-0.3925179541,
0.0037462027,
-0.4219350219,
1.0173496008,
0.1377149671,
-0.324585557,
0.1484998912,
-0.7724224925,
0.2228449285,
-0.4960238636,
-0.3398094177,
-0.4719212949,
0.1507428288,
-0.2899937332,
0.1553291082,
0.2266154438,
-0.5113152862,
0.5227062702,
0.0174137298,
0.5451608896,
0.8393548131,
0.0652129725,
0.8816608787,
-0.1403327733,
0.5910857916,
0.2064338923,
0.3167653382,
0.0979463011,
-0.4462823868,
-0.6750414371,
-0.360789299,
0.437042743,
0.5608471632,
-0.9705954194,
0.2141325623,
-0.0724282041,
-0.7671019435,
-0.6274992824,
0.2809846699,
0.2525707185,
0.8519381881,
0.4624601305,
0.1767670065,
-0.3268516362,
-0.5993380547,
-0.1418290436,
-0.2544757724,
-0.0617932566,
0.205605641,
0.1747868657,
-0.0328723192,
1.0795369148,
-0.9496110082,
-0.2482783496,
0.1262937188,
0.5680959225,
0.2630116642,
0.4579380155,
0.6010286212,
-0.898609221,
-0.3674830496,
-0.2687536478,
-0.4618039429,
-0.0743896291,
0.1595496833,
-0.4549703598,
-0.2254890949,
0.4593266249,
-0.2793512046,
-0.0025592924,
0.6432375312,
-0.2865848839,
0.1832897514,
-0.4610153139,
0.3446796536,
-0.9585953951,
-0.2528546154,
-0.1620793641,
-0.2067876756,
-0.5790343881,
0.0585376471,
0.0880685449,
-0.0512365252,
-0.4243638813,
-0.0342346951,
-0.2990436554,
0.4920712709,
-0.1342245936,
0.0075237113,
0.2378195226,
0.5461329818,
0.1926712096,
0.6269522905,
0.9706591964,
-0.9399900436,
0.5698875785,
-0.0183263645,
-0.5286718607,
1.0013171434,
-0.3684912622,
0.2639296055,
-0.5887429118,
0.3263005912,
-1.119740963,
-0.1010587662,
-0.2093527019,
-0.3462732136,
0.2281643897,
-0.3731081188,
-0.0369767807,
-0.2542544007,
-0.2503618896,
0.207045421,
0.498277992,
-0.8227108121,
0.7243276238,
0.4130955935,
0.3746972084,
-0.8697315454,
-0.5203003883,
-0.2943574488,
-0.6030200124,
-0.4990944564,
0.1349788606,
0.0641101152,
-0.1491807401,
0.0231910665,
-0.0063287085,
-0.442854166,
0.3094967008,
0.0670402944,
-0.1243099719,
-0.1538119316,
0.2053145617,
0.3180070519,
0.2585636973,
0.1131776944,
-0.5683162808,
0.3852189183,
0.0888204426,
-0.1008290127,
-0.1573278606,
0.1781701446,
0.9559178948,
-0.3460244834,
0.9542014599,
0.4145620763,
-0.0377417691,
-0.6601989865,
-0.4013407528,
-0.4255455434,
-0.5869032145,
0.1921015084,
-0.1690953374,
-0.6144610643,
0.5826676488,
-0.3756095767,
0.0964358672,
0.050627891,
0.3470777869,
-0.2140029073,
0.73069489,
0.4170250595,
-0.0751028284,
0.4687390625,
-0.1493721306,
0.1777258366,
-0.3912042379,
-0.4616825879,
-0.6173298359,
-0.4739970267,
-0.7085236311,
-0.3799166977,
0.7482572794,
0.4899959266,
-0.0316622928,
0.0241325833,
-0.8091452122,
0.6278189421,
0.9327921271,
0.160670206,
0.2444408685,
-0.0824606568,
-0.1459816545,
0.1977578551,
-0.6480624676,
-0.2050797939,
1.2395194769,
0.0061037238,
0.7404332757,
0.3098453283,
1.0274401903,
0.0356955677,
0.3634006381,
-0.3667020798,
0.4515575171,
-0.0358897746,
-0.8625254035,
-0.551335454,
-0.4583584666,
-0.5996534824,
0.6754775047,
-0.2760740519,
-0.2732660472,
0.1919095814,
0.4050526023,
-0.4615194798,
0.3780862391,
-0.9264762402,
0.6901459098,
-0.1993288398,
-0.5601855516,
-0.1582664102,
-0.5501269698,
0.3441992104,
-0.0240734983,
0.2383681536,
0.2620835006,
0.2665249705,
0.6843284369,
-0.6323081851,
0.5070884228,
-0.7852445245,
-0.0688708872,
0.7313120365,
-0.1837494671,
0.4741456211,
0.2916475534,
-0.084491156,
-0.03662429,
0.4057456851,
-0.2482405305,
-1.060239315,
0.849062562,
-0.8598586917,
-0.9103057981,
-0.3128261268,
-0.0177334361,
-0.4558921158,
0.0594028011,
0.4731404483,
0.2851226032,
-0.0695148259,
0.3999307156,
0.6665189266,
0.4699108005,
0.5813714862,
0.4790329039,
-0.4745746851,
-0.5148623586,
0.9554693699,
0.1820834577,
0.1768460274,
0.5289957523,
0.5889163017,
-0.7511706948,
-0.4467099011,
-0.6828749776,
-0.3266931176,
-0.5562395453,
-0.0326868445,
-0.3361182511,
0.0894779935,
-0.5475433469,
-0.0428399853,
-0.3367435038,
-0.5035136938,
-0.4922646582,
-0.109406583,
0.3501005769,
0.8713659644,
-0.1905399263,
0.5657244921,
-0.4746606946,
0.0515558124,
0.9406220317,
0.4616916776,
-0.1939916015,
-0.2980666459,
0.0609333031,
0.3702862561,
-0.4809469581,
-1.1086658239,
-0.1034566388,
0.4460614026,
0.5037300587,
0.7251147032,
0.4487012327,
0.7167323828,
-0.3495581448,
0.6148085594,
0.1216122061,
-0.9612237811,
0.4394385815,
-0.2332650721,
-0.0054617929,
0.9715836644,
0.4498414993,
-0.3318253458,
-0.4624672532,
-0.2975670397,
-0.6978917718,
0.6579333544,
-0.0113278711,
0.1417861581,
0.2813738883,
0.3308048546,
-0.0744829252,
0.6152682304,
-0.5241247416,
-0.473665148,
-0.5425510406,
-0.448055923,
-0.2846057117,
-0.0818883926,
-0.1811463982,
-0.5159726739,
0.6404743195,
-0.0318621136,
-0.2085420936,
0.1802086234,
0.079429701,
0.2115581334,
0.4006121755,
0.597826004,
0.6007385254,
-0.1975548863,
0.3913861513,
-0.0319928676,
-0.6865453124,
0.4912951589,
-0.0425419472,
-0.2957349718,
-0.3870598674,
-0.0838423297,
0.7416428924,
-0.0574190728,
-0.0541040674,
0.497189641,
-0.1071666181,
-0.4279362559,
-0.1356683075,
0.3227314353,
0.0438545682,
0.2106106281,
0.5582523346,
0.2141610235,
0.1329046339,
-0.4681708217,
0.1933763474,
0.2814732492,
-0.2928144038,
-0.1402837485,
0.5440200567,
0.5394032598,
-0.0905933306,
0.5313642621,
-0.1673278809,
-0.7941319942,
0.5420491695,
0.2402139604,
0.475823462,
-0.5415831208,
0.4301528037,
0.390312314,
0.1962454915,
-0.4403999746,
0.1223031357,
-0.3469397724,
-0.7634248137,
-0.1578256935,
-0.5715497732,
-0.3986793458,
-0.0101701478,
-0.801849544,
0.2022946924,
-0.5769966841,
-0.1325675547,
0.072410509,
-0.1132116988,
-0.3340623379,
0.1950308979,
-0.0407405235,
0.3756576478,
-1.0948784351,
0.8313961029,
0.8848339915,
-0.0321368612,
-0.8072736859,
-0.0564482622,
-0.1186744943,
-0.4269933701,
0.4239805341,
-0.0242385641,
-0.2497964501,
0.3843233287,
-0.7116478682,
-0.6268808842,
0.9839717746,
0.237093702,
-0.6433885098,
0.2188341767,
0.0726295859,
0.6615923047,
-0.0672738999,
0.4651310146,
0.454720825,
0.6074463725,
0.3572340608,
-0.8369464874,
-0.4658850729,
0.1003141552,
-0.5026900172,
0.2225408107,
-0.6437389255,
0.8646313548,
-0.0419568494,
-0.1371096224,
-0.6579834223,
0.7821312547,
0.1049228832,
0.5446582437,
0.7382454872,
0.6823780537,
1.2514688969,
-0.1901423931,
0.5109653473,
-0.3024279177,
0.5512573719,
1.2268192768,
-0.2435380071,
0.5870078802,
0.794827044,
-0.3482697308,
0.5675544143,
0.3178374469,
0.277908206,
1.0686401129,
0.4677443504,
-0.4627158642,
-0.5121149421,
0.0863339901,
-0.1591125727,
0.7237728238,
0.0631346032,
-0.0241691265,
-0.048690103,
0.0917992443,
-0.0489878915,
0.4583092332,
-0.6129566431,
0.7017970681,
-0.3532570302,
-1.4389915466,
0.4170189202,
0.0557117574,
0.9125241041,
-0.323310256,
-0.1192836016,
-0.2571316659,
0.40877527,
-0.26538679,
-0.8944764137,
-0.0064867879,
-0.2153120935,
-0.2898805141,
-0.3156703115,
0.2309550494,
-0.8922898173,
-0.5260361433,
0.0755430385,
0.3199860752,
-0.1693664044,
-0.0497870669,
-0.1435565501,
-0.6923951507,
0.0878001004,
-0.1919019669,
0.1223870367,
0.5802922845,
-0.0181433503,
0.5434408784,
0.4903847277,
-0.0824587867,
0.6362709403,
-0.2049783021,
1.0383862257,
-0.0148320738,
-0.7208216786,
-0.8182243109,
0.4365674853,
-0.1400984377,
-0.3975698948,
0.7413605452,
0.4515015781,
0.7789455056,
0.0326345973,
0.586900413,
-0.0398177356,
0.348829329,
-0.3395485878,
0.9203017354,
-0.5135363936,
0.0172588322,
-0.1319376528,
-0.7978168726,
-0.0701947883,
0.6056413054,
-0.322270751,
-0.136119917,
0.3762345314,
0.8443233967,
-0.0541521311,
0.2288787067,
0.2153928578,
-0.1040256917,
0.3568785489,
0.5754182339,
0.8185447454,
-0.2007888556,
0.4642326236,
-0.5170548558,
-0.2338868231,
0.1301233768,
-0.9476304054,
-1.0152293444,
-0.6845548749,
-0.3889472783,
-0.2598891556,
-0.2099422514,
0.6926993728,
0.7974380255,
-0.8481621742,
0.0168690346,
-0.3915028274,
0.3677098155,
-0.1837694347,
-0.1947194785,
0.3127781749,
-0.158119157,
-0.904156208,
0.3586833775,
-0.3296728134,
-0.1213513538,
-0.5875011086,
-0.1983076632,
-0.3444892764,
0.1095011756,
0.1539078504,
0.0554835312,
-0.2193700671,
0.0642005652,
-0.0615265258,
0.0725819916,
-0.0810715705,
0.9607700706,
-0.7720522285,
0.5448240042,
0.7666912079,
0.4768718481,
0.6544552445,
0.4029470682,
0.3924967945,
-1.0133962631,
0.2664182782,
0.2590454221,
0.0286882967,
0.0925980657,
-0.3577052355,
0.1542275548,
0.1734634191,
-0.6380022168,
-0.7681907415,
-0.0099415397,
-0.4524930418,
-0.1474486589,
1.082798481,
-0.3835779428,
-0.1533071697,
0.0062055588,
-0.0876497999,
0.1378853917,
-0.3941782713,
0.6784023643,
0.8264739513,
0.1944949329,
-0.1981081665,
-0.0426486507,
0.6200726032,
0.4189339578,
-0.454998672,
-0.1322480291,
0.5236068964,
0.4173745811,
0.2137964368,
0.501370728,
0.1626590937,
-0.1098148823,
-0.1905764937,
-0.0020449336,
-0.3659769595,
-0.578866601,
-0.3926101327,
0.6082012057,
-0.1229548678,
-0.5743644238
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03689v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03689v1
|
Pose Priors from Language Models
| 2024-05-06T17:59:36 | 2024-05-06T17:59:36 |
Sanjay Subramanian, Evonne Ng, Lea Müller, Dan Klein, Shiry Ginosar, Trevor Darrell
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
We present a zero-shot pose optimization method that enforces accurate
physical contact constraints when estimating the 3D pose of humans. Our central
insight is that since language is often used to describe physical interaction,
large pretrained text-based models can act as priors on pose estimation.
We can thus leverage this insight to improve pose estimation by converting
natural language descriptors, generated by a large multimodal model (LMM), into
tractable losses to constrain the 3D pose optimization. Despite its simplicity,
our method produces surprisingly compelling pose reconstructions of people in
close contact, correctly capturing the semantics of the social and physical
interactions. We demonstrate that our method rivals more complex
state-of-the-art approaches that require expensive human annotation of contact
points and training specialized models. Moreover, unlike previous approaches,
our method provides a unified framework for resolving self-contact and
person-to-person contact.
|
[
-0.2080657184,
-0.4146786928,
0.8770044446,
-0.2434707433,
0.0635251328,
-0.3656592667,
0.0437062532,
-0.7196912169,
0.2562550902,
0.5445921421,
-0.5671098232,
-0.5229821801,
-0.2447157055,
-0.024734959,
-0.0244030971,
0.4787341654,
0.0471565165,
-0.3024889827,
-0.3623610139,
-0.1225621924,
-0.2404905409,
-0.869456768,
-0.2191138566,
-0.21181871,
0.5307643414,
0.2355224192,
0.7580761313,
0.5013982058,
0.325304389,
0.236891523,
0.1769580543,
0.2037160695,
-0.3197232485,
-0.0131454514,
-0.1570263803,
-0.3631346822,
-0.2344769537,
0.2395221442,
0.6582863331,
1.0296770334,
-0.0524801984,
0.0074887602,
-0.4344139993,
0.6635524035,
-1.1308745146,
-0.2174980789,
-0.2895879447,
0.1124248728,
-0.5984379053,
-0.0898113325,
-0.4870710671,
-0.0191655997,
0.1389683038,
-0.6752029061,
0.4527889192,
-0.1599113047,
0.8610956669,
0.3475669622,
-0.4185716808,
0.3201629519,
-1.0299841166,
0.6854180694,
-0.6615855098,
0.6966317892,
0.7292435169,
0.4394237697,
-0.2721077502,
-0.2904450297,
-0.7683701515,
-0.1744466126,
-0.1891395897,
0.0044409386,
0.0842950493,
0.3108237386,
0.5083302855,
0.2058631927,
-0.5698973536,
-0.0861623064,
-0.2571251392,
-0.2066568434,
0.7711679339,
0.1226083487,
0.4409586191,
-0.0176963285,
-0.2678111196,
-0.1960648894,
-0.8782125711,
0.1113396883,
0.4963324666,
0.2891253233,
-0.3208484352,
0.7265824676,
-0.2662953436,
1.1147379875,
0.0412613899,
-0.2069478035,
0.0081271632,
-0.3451225758,
-0.0666388795,
-0.0454020761,
0.8123220801,
0.5334740877,
0.4673740864,
-0.1089880913,
0.2755720615,
-0.099086158,
0.1079799533,
-0.5662621856,
-0.386754185,
0.0716856867,
0.0444460027,
0.040256694,
0.1765599251,
-0.592498064,
-0.6585308909,
-0.38613078,
0.2585553229,
-0.0803950876,
-0.5696151853,
0.4658933282,
0.1384268701,
0.4438388944,
0.4217596948,
-1.0798609257,
0.3184092641,
0.3541721404,
0.6789540052,
0.4772493839,
-0.2352151722,
-0.3271367848,
0.6353382468,
-0.617934823,
0.9140834808,
-0.282758832,
-0.2132720202,
-0.0323825702,
-0.1082033366,
-0.0891985595,
-0.2620891929,
0.2230923921,
-0.2552002072,
0.4696736634,
-0.0849634036,
-0.4546096921,
-0.1328772753,
0.3935132027,
-0.7569514513,
0.919362247,
-0.015368606,
-0.7446328998,
0.1767953336,
-0.4676252604,
-0.3428254724,
-0.1421549916,
-0.2273924053,
-0.2135040611,
0.2742639482,
0.4393167496,
0.5967852473,
-0.0627045333,
-0.1473103613,
-0.6165083647,
-0.0752397776,
-0.0198861435,
0.2239406258,
0.5576459169,
-0.0004765957,
0.0040929099,
0.0863954425,
-0.6237781048,
-0.192255035,
0.3538752198,
0.1706636548,
-0.5923248529,
0.2045644671,
-0.4074622393,
0.3664973378,
0.2745046318,
-0.6848065257,
0.2330740094,
-0.6604551673,
-0.0145213474,
0.3201818168,
-0.1598748118,
0.7612626553,
-0.0508985966,
0.4990589917,
-0.2653732002,
0.0962217301,
-0.5194012523,
-0.178019926,
-0.2769479156,
-0.3304094374,
-0.0626014546,
0.3786225915,
-0.6008939147,
0.2782397866,
-0.3730405867,
-0.5512114167,
-0.3271644711,
-0.0054511302,
0.5707419515,
0.5117756128,
0.1314297169,
-0.1226139441,
-0.4370464981,
-0.8810592294,
-0.330855906,
-0.3089646697,
-0.3535468578,
0.0076162973,
0.0589149669,
0.177327618,
1.2158828974,
-0.6709786654,
-0.2839024067,
0.0954656973,
-0.0291913245,
0.0351832621,
0.5072752833,
0.9864592552,
-0.785471499,
-0.3570121527,
0.0964044258,
-0.8335471153,
0.0810805857,
-0.0972454771,
-0.2588330507,
0.2984991968,
0.590631485,
-0.623470962,
0.5184128284,
0.5566833615,
-0.2257507294,
0.4019848406,
-0.0953367203,
0.213264972,
-1.0266706944,
0.3972676992,
0.4601875246,
-0.5604766607,
-0.7594537735,
0.0897521749,
-0.0351116434,
-0.5222017169,
-0.6735834479,
1.0243148804,
-0.8003752828,
-0.0444978476,
-0.0812901855,
0.2354354858,
0.1418481916,
0.4198542237,
0.4765766561,
0.3613934219,
0.3815890551,
-0.5791918039,
0.114666082,
0.3121182621,
-0.0760148168,
1.0875527859,
-0.7622588277,
0.5488095284,
-0.3029955626,
0.2567696869,
-1.079932332,
-0.6790428758,
0.4762783051,
-0.5243605971,
0.4110244811,
-0.2970745862,
-0.5239927173,
-0.5330768228,
-0.4282122552,
0.7169804573,
-0.127608791,
-0.3822725415,
0.6526824236,
0.5230593681,
0.114285171,
-0.5051292777,
-0.4283453524,
0.1348264515,
0.0240646787,
-0.5439268351,
0.4168759882,
-0.0917022154,
-0.1251446009,
-0.2081707865,
-0.1228180975,
-0.3526388407,
-0.1710427105,
0.1373561174,
0.2019778341,
-0.0414304696,
-0.1310069561,
-0.4262523949,
-0.3055638373,
-0.1974107027,
0.1839912832,
0.4772346318,
0.258831501,
-0.5739358068,
-1.08357656,
0.3615085781,
0.6132314205,
-0.133728385,
0.4127700329,
0.1227599904,
-0.7987260818,
0.4420111179,
-0.7367040515,
-0.018480951,
-0.4701113999,
0.3592464626,
-0.5408294797,
-0.5756964087,
0.24567765,
0.1250906736,
0.0112017244,
0.1593159288,
0.1584682316,
-0.2177319676,
1.0657904148,
0.8920047283,
0.0132921143,
0.5698949695,
0.1111366302,
0.0823741332,
-0.7723395824,
-0.2638850808,
-0.7000645399,
-0.2478210479,
-0.0708169416,
-0.568530798,
0.0771887526,
0.2759316862,
-0.4844553173,
0.7393991947,
-0.4524884224,
0.6216242313,
0.4098861814,
0.267164886,
0.0122310054,
-0.1410464495,
0.008615341,
-0.4970141947,
-0.2436603606,
-0.3438469768,
0.7624159455,
0.1770856082,
0.65893507,
0.1678505987,
0.7509915829,
-0.3178928494,
0.3656626046,
-0.8674568534,
0.4255384505,
0.0914131254,
-0.9587740302,
-0.2190796882,
-0.3777993321,
-0.9546715617,
0.1677262187,
-0.128389433,
-1.0941509008,
0.2161842585,
0.4744452834,
-0.6061809659,
0.2338622212,
-0.7974515557,
1.0899939537,
-0.2537277043,
-0.2231282741,
0.0477807038,
-0.9441106319,
0.4643237889,
-0.0271154307,
0.2407081574,
-0.497243911,
-0.0658302084,
0.5362878442,
-0.4440120459,
1.0968801975,
-0.4104064107,
-0.2905689478,
0.0807653368,
0.3093245327,
0.2137756348,
-0.4810771346,
-0.2195365131,
0.1760853231,
0.3298889101,
-0.5426284671,
-0.7304342985,
0.3671245873,
-0.6551974416,
-0.4140454531,
-0.3822612166,
-0.5725264549,
-0.4963536859,
0.2718553841,
0.1552775651,
0.3653428257,
-0.4158807099,
0.0187494867,
0.2070005536,
-0.3482286036,
0.4827419817,
0.4412774146,
-0.2920013964,
-0.6216378212,
0.609523952,
-0.0442698225,
0.4251073301,
0.702080369,
0.2406471819,
-0.6261870265,
-0.1937106252,
-0.2364912033,
0.6314020157,
-0.4825595617,
-0.1790847331,
-0.3817874491,
0.1523084342,
-0.6753211617,
-0.5239930153,
-0.553773284,
-0.342310518,
-0.0797338262,
0.1104287282,
0.1554820836,
0.5921052098,
-0.2359400243,
0.55781883,
-0.8885473609,
0.6412597895,
0.3553957045,
0.3252947032,
-0.3533065915,
-0.2317218482,
-0.0600888468,
0.4033669531,
-0.2932763994,
-0.7452314496,
0.1274431795,
0.3652746379,
0.7659409046,
0.4759458899,
0.3865685761,
1.1228756905,
-0.6276043057,
0.727198422,
0.6907131672,
-0.7497500777,
0.7958772182,
-0.5408818126,
0.4717279971,
0.5677295923,
0.5299032927,
-0.6469736099,
0.1361206472,
-0.5456210375,
-0.6915841103,
0.7459456325,
0.0670554489,
0.4732163548,
-0.1272253245,
0.7071703672,
-0.4766977131,
0.0636915416,
-0.8225015998,
-0.1087742522,
-0.0591201335,
-0.3273762465,
-0.1217156798,
-0.3305998147,
-0.2177863419,
-0.4260954261,
0.3459861875,
-0.1862502396,
0.1599594057,
0.266594559,
-0.1687058806,
-0.2993518412,
-0.4944609404,
0.9642630816,
0.5959964991,
-0.1510772705,
0.2209236175,
-0.0702376515,
-0.21102494,
0.1880740821,
0.03819374,
0.0147037748,
0.1150140241,
0.3100882173,
0.4228515327,
0.5816254616,
-0.4380476773,
0.8796852827,
0.0823255852,
-0.0281027798,
-0.2630258203,
-0.2643530071,
0.0809770301,
0.0628296211,
0.2109806091,
0.1451784968,
-0.212396279,
-0.2866449654,
0.2524537444,
0.4271838069,
-0.4968516827,
-0.7981879115,
0.8027201891,
0.3210417032,
-0.479221046,
0.1439912617,
0.063003771,
-0.2753668427,
0.2778091133,
0.4603700936,
0.7761798501,
-0.8208497763,
0.2388779521,
0.7908567786,
0.0770350993,
-0.3235187531,
-0.1145416945,
-0.1435800493,
-1.0168778896,
-0.6375768781,
-0.4674322009,
-0.4851227999,
-0.0345577598,
-0.4566081464,
0.6250444651,
-0.3803275228,
0.0320053846,
0.1239394769,
-0.00060128,
-0.6639124155,
0.1335793287,
0.5062035322,
0.2474038005,
-0.5804166198,
0.7003725767,
0.7806529403,
-0.5355460644,
-0.6031740904,
0.076574035,
0.3720365763,
-0.7216867208,
0.4880207479,
0.4737891555,
-0.5174277425,
0.145948872,
-0.6043247581,
-0.7778055072,
0.7168754935,
1.1447747946,
-0.4537793696,
-0.292406708,
0.2337372005,
0.3166341484,
0.1098197624,
-0.0840294436,
0.1699801385,
0.2177637666,
0.5217052698,
-1.0231391191,
-0.1271160543,
-0.0535062365,
0.1460604817,
0.4784977734,
-0.2754707932,
0.4300432503,
-0.3152371943,
-0.4849588275,
0.2594044209,
0.5058294535,
0.1938227266,
0.0310112778,
0.5147505999,
0.8160382509,
0.5683745742,
0.2952283323,
1.3171221018,
0.001440843,
0.4357241094,
1.3473936319,
-0.5456480384,
0.9099614024,
0.2291886955,
-0.3792631626,
0.2367472649,
0.6822679043,
0.4239562154,
0.6103488207,
0.09329395,
-0.541588366,
-0.4888923168,
-0.1314130425,
-0.2008110583,
0.5645356774,
0.258841306,
0.0995592922,
-0.5631358027,
-0.1593277901,
0.3596624136,
0.4937858284,
-0.1071800366,
0.7128999233,
-0.0487890914,
-0.3528013527,
0.552831471,
-0.4062687755,
0.5110762119,
-0.5476820469,
0.0842303261,
0.0738697276,
0.1964566708,
-0.1066323891,
-0.6777629256,
0.624275744,
-0.3629552722,
-0.0791390315,
-0.2128704786,
0.7655290365,
-0.4797249734,
-0.6577702165,
0.1755817533,
0.2576150894,
0.3351606429,
-0.5434837937,
-0.4397485554,
-0.231529668,
-0.3936893642,
-0.0690283477,
0.2297083139,
0.5730274916,
0.0574077889,
0.3414898515,
0.7476863861,
-0.1502399296,
-0.1510996073,
-0.0366376936,
0.4955722094,
-0.638727963,
-0.136164248,
-0.8058817387,
0.6089695692,
-0.1990725398,
-0.336553812,
0.2527083457,
0.3240532875,
0.9493815899,
-0.050747741,
0.2412888557,
-0.0047479239,
0.5615327358,
-0.3658776581,
0.5543936491,
-0.6140049696,
-0.3724146783,
-0.6133120656,
-0.9344179034,
-1.1246682405,
0.9570502043,
-0.5073276162,
-0.1129311994,
0.3841283619,
0.8157200217,
-0.0502029844,
-0.6955741644,
0.8058966994,
-0.341355592,
0.3664244711,
0.3740516007,
0.7349296212,
-0.4019945562,
0.2656230927,
-0.591770947,
-0.1369411051,
-0.0154600563,
-1.2435498238,
-0.7797385454,
-0.6851849556,
-0.5386054516,
-0.0055430094,
-0.2911772132,
0.9184664488,
1.1346139908,
-0.534046948,
-0.2105090022,
0.2614860237,
-0.258433491,
-0.0273710936,
-0.175452888,
0.1604197919,
-0.1249988675,
-0.968557477,
0.288643986,
0.4066515863,
0.3829603195,
-0.2332251519,
-0.1852283627,
-0.5159763694,
-0.0978385359,
0.8293731809,
0.8778173923,
-0.7616721392,
-0.6841987967,
0.0555899441,
-0.0963973626,
0.1785113662,
0.8432510495,
-0.6589006186,
0.7396810055,
0.2276104987,
0.5642234683,
0.6055464745,
0.2236954719,
0.8407672644,
-1.2362600565,
0.882812202,
0.2865305245,
0.3990922272,
0.7276911736,
-0.2918635905,
0.5524678826,
0.2963072956,
-0.2334547937,
-0.7890939713,
0.5311498642,
-1.1433069706,
-0.1052785441,
0.9011127353,
-0.2228499353,
-0.3336543143,
-0.1789422184,
-0.3418589234,
0.1433258951,
0.170648396,
0.7142689228,
0.5026367307,
-0.2771708071,
-0.635114491,
-0.4628109634,
0.3939259052,
0.1869863719,
-0.7727481127,
0.0484863073,
0.8386621475,
0.1219049692,
0.3977283239,
0.9980808496,
-0.2340448052,
0.087594606,
-0.3661679327,
0.7014678717,
0.0542648025,
-0.3428117931,
0.1241569519,
-0.136827141,
0.1017616689,
-0.5694922209
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03688v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03688v1
|
Large Language Models Reveal Information Operation Goals, Tactics, and Narrative Frames
| 2024-05-06T17:59:07 | 2024-05-06T17:59:07 |
Keith Burghardt, Kai Chen, Kristina Lerman
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Adversarial information operations can destabilize societies by undermining
fair elections, manipulating public opinions on policies, and promoting scams.
Despite their widespread occurrence and potential impacts, our understanding of
influence campaigns is limited by manual analysis of messages and subjective
interpretation of their observable behavior. In this paper, we explore whether
these limitations can be mitigated with large language models (LLMs), using
GPT-3.5 as a case-study for coordinated campaign annotation. We first use
GPT-3.5 to scrutinize 126 identified information operations spanning over a
decade. We utilize a number of metrics to quantify the close (if imperfect)
agreement between LLM and ground truth descriptions. We next extract
coordinated campaigns from two large multilingual datasets from X (formerly
Twitter) that respectively discuss the 2022 French election and 2023 Balikaran
Philippine-U.S. military exercise in 2023. For each coordinated campaign, we
use GPT-3.5 to analyze posts related to a specific concern and extract goals,
tactics, and narrative frames, both before and after critical events (such as
the date of an election). While the GPT-3.5 sometimes disagrees with subjective
interpretation, its ability to summarize and interpret demonstrates LLMs'
potential to extract higher-order indicators from text to provide a more
complete picture of the information campaigns compared to previous methods.
|
[
-0.5074686408,
-0.9446346164,
0.8343718648,
0.3000048697,
-0.432394594,
-0.1198967248,
-0.6401231289,
-0.3840568662,
0.1461156607,
0.8302409649,
-0.461801827,
-0.5124789476,
-0.9806183577,
-0.0863215104,
-0.3625476062,
1.4429762363,
-0.2395633757,
-0.0404411331,
0.3881080747,
-0.0731533691,
-0.2605732679,
-0.8557465672,
-0.6888902187,
-0.4318524897,
0.6470037103,
0.0226244535,
0.8833169341,
0.6786472201,
0.6898460388,
0.2321822643,
0.0602494627,
0.1118035838,
-0.7869476676,
-0.1194080338,
-0.241192922,
-0.5211010575,
-0.1403527707,
0.2901453376,
0.7346124053,
0.3982004821,
-0.1691984534,
-0.1841341108,
0.0868394896,
0.5017597675,
-0.4926222265,
0.5382765532,
-0.6141070724,
-0.314935863,
-0.2987152636,
-0.2533412874,
-0.2781563401,
-0.2850761116,
0.2936530113,
-0.6141028404,
0.1116498634,
-0.1639155149,
0.8084991574,
0.1287137121,
-0.4178266823,
-0.6675140858,
-0.8031566143,
0.6621587873,
-0.6343811154,
-0.0802830756,
0.4113743901,
0.0625917092,
-0.3752861619,
-0.5699988604,
-0.5570610762,
-0.0303013157,
-0.1215050966,
0.1487038881,
-0.3640871346,
0.2895204127,
0.2207121551,
-0.0059314799,
-0.2096304595,
0.0354495049,
-0.3566270769,
0.0025618104,
0.5738546252,
-0.0201632157,
0.3052344322,
-0.3401726186,
-0.5752634406,
-0.1042606011,
-0.920422554,
-0.2341837287,
0.4842147231,
0.296266675,
-0.4037766755,
0.5744886398,
-0.201341942,
0.4890800118,
-0.108769469,
0.2239909023,
-0.1798293293,
-0.4838090837,
-0.3665205836,
-0.0354068577,
1.0986773968,
0.3590962589,
0.31506598,
-0.129932031,
-0.1468517482,
0.1490737945,
0.171843648,
-0.8119061589,
-0.2126436234,
-0.1575316042,
-0.3507169187,
-0.3088792264,
0.3300212324,
-0.6584239006,
-0.685985148,
-0.465269506,
0.42165941,
-0.174956128,
-0.2250206769,
0.0611153618,
-0.0251771528,
-0.0106049972,
0.4452834129,
-0.5604403615,
0.0321277939,
0.9161166549,
0.8438346386,
-0.1116220132,
-0.1159714237,
-0.4709554017,
0.072628513,
-0.4848383665,
0.3138268292,
-0.6392823458,
-0.2389597446,
0.0351709612,
0.108751677,
-0.1684664488,
-0.121196501,
0.5353577733,
-0.8417269588,
0.3200510144,
-0.3577117622,
-0.5399010777,
-0.3443186879,
0.3637723625,
-0.8569155931,
0.5966197252,
-0.2220568806,
-0.6702882051,
0.1636490077,
-0.5885912776,
-0.2543553412,
-0.3607898951,
-0.3161853254,
-0.1661204994,
0.1390055567,
0.3324494362,
0.6945617795,
-0.485308826,
0.6117388606,
-0.2488354146,
-0.3633680344,
0.1354836673,
-0.4484769702,
0.6821520925,
-0.1617142707,
-0.7625297904,
0.0878682733,
-0.478515029,
-0.5678778887,
0.0812068433,
-0.4362878203,
-0.3033049405,
0.1675224602,
-0.2434562743,
0.0578520745,
0.3233853281,
-0.302960664,
0.5276988149,
-0.2378912419,
0.2942204177,
0.8609299064,
0.2738190293,
0.3940944672,
-0.0564305037,
0.4615273774,
-0.1829956025,
0.1022275016,
-0.2015125602,
-0.6185092926,
-0.6554167867,
-0.0570886917,
-0.0439535193,
0.6521273851,
-0.9915462136,
0.0175827947,
-0.5156615376,
-0.415803194,
0.0324914381,
0.0458949879,
0.3135867715,
0.167680636,
0.0643423051,
0.053120058,
-0.5361630917,
-0.7448573709,
-0.2799291313,
-0.4440877736,
0.19678545,
0.0296078678,
0.4676048458,
0.0175751057,
0.6852471828,
-0.2684142888,
-0.2065199763,
-0.1739822924,
0.4935588241,
0.3161360621,
0.0023092616,
0.39387694,
-1.1107705832,
-0.1380728632,
0.1662698388,
-0.636987865,
-0.0632449016,
-0.3069873452,
0.0688770637,
0.174740091,
0.4408490658,
-0.6629427671,
0.2495915145,
0.822535336,
-0.2010100782,
0.4291635752,
-0.0701804608,
0.6286728978,
-0.851285696,
-0.1580688506,
-0.0095333923,
-0.0116843758,
-0.7142878175,
-0.0740257576,
0.0441366807,
0.1316792518,
-0.196887657,
0.4595195055,
-0.3567073345,
0.1330689043,
-0.2701406181,
0.5155104995,
-0.0320132785,
0.2412709147,
0.0111292042,
0.5966881514,
0.3733200133,
-0.3750214577,
0.455984205,
0.0315589085,
-0.5159734488,
0.5123354793,
-0.5128949285,
0.2527193725,
-0.2627437413,
0.4252789915,
-0.9751191139,
-0.4719072878,
0.3317004442,
-0.3816363513,
0.2832340002,
-0.3030741215,
-0.5494722724,
-0.0218978692,
-0.1989018619,
-0.1058764458,
0.073259294,
-0.574841857,
0.4312472939,
0.4117557704,
-0.092312701,
-0.6628348827,
-0.6747308373,
0.4099877775,
-0.4486880898,
-0.4715073109,
-0.0773668811,
0.4096722305,
-0.4305959344,
-0.0182732698,
0.2949295044,
-0.0276529044,
-0.1364760101,
0.315320313,
0.3500432074,
-0.1423076242,
0.2613118887,
-0.4886766076,
0.1132758707,
0.1139306128,
-0.239831537,
0.3028641939,
0.07091479,
-0.4735116363,
-0.0910797641,
0.2705070376,
0.5826097727,
-0.144808054,
0.8700945377,
0.8227105737,
-0.266158551,
0.2276792973,
-0.7790277004,
-0.1081895307,
-0.367089957,
0.5462246537,
-0.0761124194,
-0.9244727492,
0.4591547847,
0.0548700653,
0.1190093234,
0.4082695842,
0.5812048316,
0.2354863286,
1.073798418,
0.370324254,
-0.4508168995,
0.6850193739,
-0.1417762488,
0.116633825,
-0.6601849198,
-0.1057686135,
-0.3523539007,
-0.0420928188,
-0.6696053743,
-0.5642476678,
0.45507285,
0.2403334081,
-0.1873728335,
0.0770436898,
-0.290406853,
0.216166243,
0.4038195312,
0.0934666842,
0.0648179427,
0.1233680248,
0.5107066631,
-0.0791601762,
-0.5534285307,
-0.6057519913,
1.1965463161,
0.1679161042,
0.7226794958,
0.1341694444,
0.5371183157,
0.2394004613,
0.7045046687,
-0.4982867837,
0.3837951124,
-0.2305523753,
-0.5941477418,
-0.1810309738,
-0.551297307,
-0.8984544277,
0.1964367181,
-0.1361371875,
-0.8765981197,
0.0341592282,
-0.0035114426,
-0.1302540004,
0.4465612471,
-0.7871935368,
0.6924635172,
-0.2679071426,
-0.3467195034,
-0.2348335981,
-0.5515663624,
0.3956199288,
-0.1821372807,
0.563426435,
-0.1802764386,
-0.3019109666,
0.8027892113,
0.124026835,
1.0434683561,
-0.2363817245,
-0.2133292109,
0.2000821978,
-0.095517315,
1.1930826902,
-0.1349555403,
-0.250618875,
0.1202829555,
-0.215116173,
-0.1034443751,
-0.7254431248,
0.877599895,
-0.7428123951,
-0.8012320399,
-0.0842045769,
-0.430639267,
0.0814648494,
0.2148910016,
0.2612125576,
0.574539721,
-0.4852448404,
0.348521024,
0.4306541085,
0.0853707418,
0.3840497434,
0.3669923246,
0.0026171964,
-0.4790100157,
0.8118229508,
0.1557074934,
0.4572178125,
0.3693455756,
0.3237610459,
-0.29581815,
-0.6625010967,
-0.413235873,
0.1955069155,
-0.8888459206,
-0.0346200988,
-0.4877907038,
0.3786845505,
-0.0515818745,
-0.086899139,
-0.2374629378,
-0.2112416923,
-0.3230441809,
0.0303361285,
0.2251330465,
1.3487796783,
-0.1020684168,
0.7089937329,
-0.3707714081,
0.2356283367,
-0.1100574583,
0.114054136,
-0.4715120494,
-0.2243501246,
-0.3430251181,
0.1780369431,
-0.1925924718,
-1.3233983517,
0.1180459782,
0.0181472525,
0.3113499284,
0.37793836,
-0.0005774344,
0.4402424395,
-0.1865638644,
1.0189496279,
0.0550477691,
-0.7978194952,
0.4553070664,
-0.7548674345,
0.1661033928,
0.2558626533,
0.2816364765,
-0.2789050639,
-0.5427677035,
-0.7577176094,
-0.7357441783,
0.8447300792,
0.2760059536,
0.1083865762,
-0.0785604566,
0.3533127308,
-0.3915868998,
0.3833563626,
-0.7296513915,
-0.1584168673,
0.1731220633,
-0.1085145548,
-0.2818650305,
-0.2920975089,
-0.3708466589,
0.3529157639,
0.8206557035,
-0.1634627283,
-0.1586693823,
0.2789611518,
0.2187391222,
-0.0015560365,
0.295426935,
0.5266059637,
0.7293358445,
0.0915250406,
0.2207449675,
-0.0175822675,
-0.4114466608,
-0.0518716946,
0.392636627,
-0.1358090937,
-0.0193496644,
0.7731462717,
0.8903311491,
0.2887477577,
-0.2927531898,
0.6855654716,
0.0609243326,
-0.0042220051,
-0.0812308639,
-0.216505453,
0.1418569535,
0.4701412022,
0.4914778173,
-0.0268714782,
0.0034055556,
-0.6030675173,
0.1698891371,
0.7308096886,
-0.5429035425,
-0.3210775554,
0.4488113821,
0.1341713518,
0.0008080128,
0.1294863075,
-0.2613676488,
-0.8046545386,
0.7203218341,
0.1366363317,
0.677747488,
-0.272138536,
0.2547811568,
0.1997222602,
0.8510333896,
-0.3538059294,
-0.1239294484,
0.1656797081,
-0.6344767213,
-0.6765930057,
-0.1827641577,
-0.2277017832,
0.4318589866,
-0.508338213,
0.3032069504,
-0.3501490355,
-0.1746662259,
0.0792671293,
0.1261122972,
-0.7252876759,
0.1983758062,
0.1163708568,
0.2443318069,
-0.7186425328,
0.5462719202,
0.5530007482,
-0.06092811,
-0.7358634472,
0.0125630377,
0.3261838257,
-0.8215233088,
0.6053957343,
0.1193090603,
-0.0924163535,
-0.1986119002,
-0.5878252387,
-0.7995586991,
0.7607367635,
0.4695876539,
-0.6719911695,
-0.0279798657,
0.0522345006,
0.3378308117,
-0.4610016942,
0.1371010393,
0.8136649132,
0.7254464626,
-0.1215175986,
-0.8724913597,
0.1681224406,
0.1788526475,
-0.2571395338,
0.4519800842,
-0.6200591326,
0.8431977034,
-0.1672082841,
-0.412034452,
-0.1636103988,
0.3095189035,
-0.1898362488,
0.046731323,
0.4928381145,
0.1260888427,
0.5615927577,
-0.3957610726,
1.3235458136,
-0.2592038214,
0.4870404601,
1.0611015558,
0.1074421406,
0.4386484325,
0.5436375141,
-0.0863170773,
0.1979091316,
0.4319548607,
0.1858701408,
0.2380668372,
0.0729239509,
-0.2275987864,
-0.1120685562,
-0.133740142,
-0.1536211669,
0.4706911743,
0.6474719644,
-0.5475108624,
-0.3580947816,
-0.0179571211,
0.427906096,
-0.0107525066,
-0.1773504913,
0.6862699389,
-0.0777396336,
-0.8639266491,
0.4281776547,
-0.1608936191,
0.4779364765,
-0.7710259557,
-0.2336914092,
0.181820333,
0.2409397215,
-0.0921299756,
-0.8935130239,
0.1388928145,
-0.1375330836,
0.0310802795,
-0.0384740494,
0.5237047076,
-0.6296033859,
-0.4326996803,
0.4504761696,
0.2611908913,
-0.1681324393,
-0.4455442429,
-0.5741800666,
0.676496923,
0.2100609094,
-0.7379918694,
-0.1136899889,
0.5856798291,
-0.078977257,
0.3612775803,
0.582734704,
0.555701077,
-0.1319500059,
0.0762145743,
0.810642302,
-0.2920425832,
-0.3573998809,
-1.1891386509,
0.094049871,
-0.3277382553,
-0.0382399894,
0.8256800175,
0.3337650895,
0.6483114958,
0.2439381033,
1.1900970936,
-0.0564331934,
0.3172269762,
-0.6214895844,
0.4427855015,
-0.3339571655,
0.4053099751,
-0.2701142728,
-0.6597455144,
-0.2241207063,
0.2858181,
-0.7316844463,
-0.0540949069,
0.3442183435,
0.7036352158,
0.0697186962,
0.2202613652,
0.0243934914,
0.3080881536,
0.6580116749,
0.5421124697,
0.8294928074,
-0.2314880192,
0.8280153275,
-0.1766327173,
-0.4495683312,
-0.1393144727,
-0.9033715129,
-1.0849288702,
-0.6010317206,
-0.0646779984,
-0.2861874998,
0.2588758767,
0.5872652531,
0.6264636517,
-0.393414557,
-0.0938648507,
-0.0407542139,
0.2335811555,
0.3335469961,
-0.2499327064,
0.6190412045,
-0.1401786059,
-0.819750607,
0.1530220807,
0.2981680036,
-0.0204284843,
-0.475654155,
0.0841983855,
-0.143192336,
0.1237617508,
0.4857608378,
0.078779541,
-0.846203506,
-0.5947209597,
-0.2443519831,
-0.008327703,
-0.2246939391,
1.0649546385,
-0.3624198735,
0.6477698684,
0.2823980749,
0.5339028835,
0.5478956699,
0.2304409146,
0.736087203,
-0.7621099353,
0.3013878763,
0.044372391,
0.195877552,
0.6479617953,
-0.4390532374,
0.6316357851,
0.124746874,
-0.4944266081,
-0.4678059816,
0.1477005333,
-0.5136138201,
-0.0407635383,
1.6698774099,
-0.1758345962,
-0.081684798,
-0.1235242784,
-0.3612108827,
0.300452739,
-0.3359967172,
0.6077246666,
1.2112361193,
-0.1001914218,
-0.0300354436,
-0.9309408069,
0.5896021128,
0.0856939182,
-0.7586917281,
0.3026441932,
0.607989192,
-0.0708738938,
0.3451146781,
0.7399147153,
0.0412343927,
-0.030283371,
-0.2444023639,
-0.4074386656,
0.1378552467,
-0.174917087,
-0.0778207853,
0.2000209242,
-0.2720051408,
-0.1193795204
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03685v1
|
Language-Image Models with 3D Understanding
| 2024-05-06T17:57:27 | 2024-05-06T17:57:27 |
Jang Hyun Cho, Boris Ivanovic, Yulong Cao, Edward Schmerling, Yue Wang, Xinshuo Weng, Boyi Li, Yurong You, Philipp Krähenbühl, Yan Wang, Marco Pavone
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Multi-modal large language models (MLLMs) have shown incredible capabilities
in a variety of 2D vision and language tasks. We extend MLLMs' perceptual
capabilities to ground and reason about images in 3-dimensional space. To that
end, we first develop a large-scale pre-training dataset for 2D and 3D called
LV3D by combining multiple existing 2D and 3D recognition datasets under a
common task formulation: as multi-turn question-answering. Next, we introduce a
new MLLM named Cube-LLM and pre-train it on LV3D. We show that pure data
scaling makes a strong 3D perception capability without 3D specific
architectural design or training objective. Cube-LLM exhibits intriguing
properties similar to LLMs: (1) Cube-LLM can apply chain-of-thought prompting
to improve 3D understanding from 2D context information. (2) Cube-LLM can
follow complex and diverse instructions and adapt to versatile input and output
formats. (3) Cube-LLM can be visually prompted such as 2D box or a set of
candidate 3D boxes from specialists. Our experiments on outdoor benchmarks
demonstrate that Cube-LLM significantly outperforms existing baselines by 21.3
points of AP-BEV on the Talk2Car dataset for 3D grounded reasoning and 17.7
points on the DriveLM dataset for complex reasoning about driving scenarios,
respectively. Cube-LLM also shows competitive results in general MLLM
benchmarks such as refCOCO for 2D grounding with (87.0) average score, as well
as visual question answering benchmarks such as VQAv2, GQA, SQA, POPE, etc. for
complex reasoning. Our project is available at
https://janghyuncho.github.io/Cube-LLM.
|
[
-0.5691400766,
-0.8575505018,
0.9172105193,
0.3837684095,
-0.1661951691,
-0.182909146,
-0.1020402983,
-0.4957435727,
-0.5227721334,
0.4995202422,
-0.2675186992,
-0.5222313404,
-0.3729026914,
-0.0465194471,
-0.2316206545,
0.3701700866,
-0.1612325311,
0.3002722263,
-0.6761561632,
-0.1980516762,
-0.3380971253,
-0.578104198,
-0.5418394804,
-0.1781018078,
0.5030507445,
0.3806424141,
0.9098227024,
0.63924402,
0.39012447,
0.3145523071,
-0.0398966707,
0.202754885,
-0.5130938292,
-0.2506936789,
-0.0286686365,
-0.3844439387,
-0.3686499894,
0.0446236469,
0.6122033596,
0.8908936381,
0.1045776755,
-0.1903418601,
-0.155921489,
0.8873819709,
-0.5425878167,
0.1414968967,
-0.4970231652,
0.0914485082,
0.1226605028,
-0.0766424388,
-0.195284307,
-0.13325499,
-0.0378656574,
-0.7258352041,
0.1517530382,
0.2890663445,
0.6758326888,
0.2620125711,
-0.5938970447,
-0.1070700809,
-0.6409205794,
0.6691999435,
-0.4400329292,
0.7133393288,
0.3874477148,
0.5975190997,
0.0118157323,
-0.449216038,
-0.7414565086,
-0.1698940843,
-0.079343982,
0.2316014916,
0.0784561783,
-0.0508067273,
0.3683378696,
0.649990201,
-0.5803751945,
0.1738362908,
-0.403211832,
-0.0075467494,
0.5075523257,
0.2219658047,
0.0888575539,
0.0177802108,
-0.5906105638,
-0.1888299584,
-0.8678694367,
0.3271049559,
-0.0282506663,
-0.0766736567,
-0.3072688282,
0.6661997437,
-0.1037509143,
1.0856345892,
-0.1932117343,
-0.1052514091,
0.3404297531,
-0.2249238491,
-0.532512486,
-0.3154604733,
0.6868535876,
0.50782305,
0.1038480923,
0.0288186111,
-0.3222897053,
-0.2621984482,
0.1798168421,
-0.7106798887,
-0.1609422415,
0.3225049973,
-0.5991290212,
-0.0997166485,
0.0001622216,
-0.4250223041,
-0.8251468539,
-0.6944933534,
0.4408015311,
-0.4991175234,
-0.4692382812,
0.5946122408,
0.0696070492,
0.5077439547,
0.7017549276,
-0.7083649039,
0.1895306259,
0.6738460064,
0.6917384267,
-0.0716360286,
-0.4484878182,
-0.3195381463,
0.1323474497,
-0.5147903562,
0.9413250089,
-0.3271906972,
-0.1739471257,
-0.0517672226,
-0.1585151553,
0.1449551582,
-0.6679495573,
0.1013029367,
-0.3764815927,
0.3183480799,
-0.0088300994,
-0.3020938933,
-0.4148060977,
0.6511257887,
-0.7072905898,
0.7649778724,
0.1286967993,
-0.508363843,
0.2702309489,
-0.4224691391,
-0.4595601559,
-0.0064351717,
-0.579280436,
-0.2608911097,
0.206642434,
0.5329468846,
0.658477664,
-0.4475663006,
0.0773694813,
-0.426512152,
-0.2990091443,
0.0925451666,
-0.3031507432,
0.848723948,
0.0823780373,
-0.0762705728,
0.1831133217,
-0.8940581083,
-0.0575668104,
0.227982536,
-0.4458812773,
-0.0274481568,
0.0374870561,
-0.0321840234,
0.3136749268,
0.1823451668,
-0.2421664745,
-0.0061457516,
-0.2267062813,
0.0788401961,
0.5197876096,
-0.3747258186,
0.4313832819,
-0.2735828459,
0.3299245834,
0.3080601394,
0.1974027753,
-0.1841276884,
-0.4289250374,
-0.7782222629,
-0.4607104659,
-0.3992346525,
0.6405454874,
-0.809663415,
0.2504860461,
-0.2477897257,
-0.4135763347,
-0.3087179065,
0.142393738,
0.2368524671,
0.5161964893,
0.5151051879,
0.314661175,
-0.554228127,
-1.158899188,
-0.109323509,
-0.1191192195,
-0.5083988905,
0.4778236449,
0.2612921894,
-0.1230110899,
0.7798389792,
-0.4964463413,
-0.4064421952,
-0.2902461886,
-0.1327866316,
0.4839744568,
0.330955714,
0.5167559385,
-1.1122053862,
-0.2970623076,
0.1254544556,
-0.9972427487,
0.2286440432,
-0.2417784035,
-0.0054287622,
-0.1073933616,
0.8472525477,
-0.6450551748,
0.3373952806,
0.4696756899,
-0.5069291592,
0.3403874636,
-0.2431095392,
0.1054198891,
-0.8512845039,
-0.2491483092,
-0.1409512758,
-0.2755328715,
-0.7510217428,
-0.023285808,
0.0880953074,
0.0383494645,
-0.7212063074,
0.5395399332,
-0.6606609225,
-0.3744348288,
-0.1543363184,
0.3755806088,
0.2454751134,
0.5628014803,
0.419852078,
0.4445263743,
0.9903382063,
-0.7163071632,
0.5118743181,
0.2459543347,
-0.8892828822,
0.6827864647,
-0.5231544971,
0.2534801662,
-0.3476839662,
0.1392262131,
-0.8555213213,
0.0201760363,
-0.0050734146,
-0.2751349211,
0.053310886,
0.0255403947,
-0.5831573009,
-0.2713532448,
-0.043489553,
0.5007014275,
0.2546523809,
-0.7510662079,
0.9629073143,
0.2951827645,
0.2804272771,
-0.2315147221,
-0.5282281041,
0.1035986841,
-0.1982646585,
-0.5693413019,
0.0491534062,
-0.1186961979,
-0.5205292702,
-0.0695971102,
-0.0286658946,
-0.0461777821,
0.1159691066,
0.4039661586,
0.2989342511,
-0.3552283347,
-0.0288752615,
-0.4467862844,
-0.0251933429,
0.2382702231,
-0.1874471307,
0.385184139,
-0.6999812126,
-0.311553508,
-0.1581021547,
0.2154028416,
0.7716869712,
0.0647370666,
0.6902719736,
0.70742172,
-0.4681270719,
0.2992925346,
-0.5874869823,
0.1001162305,
-0.4346162379,
0.5040407181,
-0.9038549066,
-0.9001056552,
0.1093617603,
0.0156966448,
0.0789819583,
0.2622484565,
0.7569565773,
-0.5171270967,
1.3035315275,
0.4716462791,
0.1672989726,
0.0952395871,
-0.2646003366,
0.3448435366,
-1.0748995543,
-0.6034579277,
-0.1650826931,
-0.3450381458,
-0.187648505,
-0.7094445229,
0.2950060964,
0.4741587043,
-0.4168886244,
-0.0181802772,
-0.1610529423,
0.5823704004,
0.2455656379,
0.0203117765,
0.202870965,
-0.0148978708,
-0.1422536522,
0.2708647847,
-0.6627262831,
-0.3635886014,
0.748778522,
0.4755805731,
0.6153406501,
0.1498751491,
-0.0391454063,
-0.0823666155,
0.2909160554,
-0.8045412302,
0.6785569191,
-0.0318324789,
-0.4771668911,
-0.3680345416,
-0.4195905924,
-0.7665869594,
0.7573745251,
-0.4513389468,
-0.3441139758,
0.1290312111,
0.1750009358,
-0.2918859124,
0.5877223611,
-0.5327797532,
0.7324059606,
-0.5678254962,
-0.2151428163,
-0.2026858926,
-0.5040593743,
0.5579451323,
0.0167580172,
0.5819674134,
-0.3021433353,
-0.0214374568,
0.2635835707,
-0.1307390332,
0.54842484,
-0.2862266898,
-0.2867550254,
0.0075024562,
0.2078528255,
0.1515294909,
0.3970183134,
0.1723164618,
0.5633058548,
-0.1198884323,
-0.4494746923,
-0.8453552723,
0.5578908324,
-0.9211665988,
-0.8941714764,
-0.0895394236,
-0.8945421576,
-0.5292882323,
0.2983220816,
0.1727051586,
0.4054535925,
-0.0065505286,
0.4759912491,
0.6028299928,
-0.3728289008,
0.0511315502,
0.4489784539,
-0.6917282343,
-0.4335372448,
0.680136621,
-0.6086571813,
0.2419294268,
0.7251977921,
0.2915534973,
-0.4608177841,
-0.692468226,
-0.3962149918,
0.1002039686,
-0.8445725441,
-0.182278052,
-0.665366888,
-0.3118803501,
-0.2202675045,
-0.3456712365,
-0.3022675216,
-0.4528322518,
-0.2187086642,
-0.3412008584,
0.0882745311,
0.8233444095,
-0.1457896531,
0.0495491214,
-0.530210793,
0.9249738455,
0.5615736842,
0.3380066752,
-0.1799958646,
-0.5006575584,
-0.2766900063,
0.2541655004,
0.1483406425,
-0.3279859722,
0.0796509907,
-0.0712517202,
0.5089253187,
0.5926185846,
-0.4307741225,
0.8282802105,
-0.6031250954,
0.6552690268,
0.4778437614,
-0.7378525734,
0.395812273,
-0.2305166274,
0.6061925888,
0.2637951374,
0.2893418074,
-0.4112485051,
-0.3471008539,
-0.1882517189,
-0.5592901111,
0.619066596,
0.2331329286,
-0.0238754321,
0.1664148569,
0.2276327759,
0.0613667481,
0.0275643859,
-0.7907437682,
-0.2106379569,
-0.7108210325,
0.0106222862,
-0.2641403079,
-0.3752760291,
-0.1468829215,
-0.5052286983,
0.2170972675,
-0.1023846939,
0.1877088994,
0.1476714313,
-0.2113870084,
0.2647540569,
-0.056998875,
0.7882450819,
0.7428335547,
-0.2371030748,
0.7239662409,
0.2558488548,
-0.3487797081,
0.1454786509,
-0.1661313325,
0.19111076,
-0.4042416811,
0.6418160796,
1.0065720081,
0.0120914262,
-0.6031555533,
0.4809720218,
-0.2659724057,
-0.7126243114,
-0.3976943195,
-0.1210724041,
0.245980233,
0.3419491351,
0.3328584433,
0.1414691061,
-0.0450979732,
-0.3645668626,
-0.0748944208,
0.3426332772,
-0.4757812917,
-0.2573073208,
0.5813649297,
-0.0493066795,
-0.1006992236,
0.7408512831,
0.065076299,
-0.4264290035,
0.6067560315,
0.590030849,
0.51174438,
-0.0354259834,
-0.0741066635,
0.4891466498,
0.3862862289,
0.0660573915,
0.3134580851,
-0.080961436,
-1.2517468929,
-0.2043964118,
-0.3784458339,
-0.1968696117,
0.6601619124,
-0.4723265767,
0.2571464777,
-0.7391847372,
0.2895774841,
-0.2624788582,
-0.3021110892,
-0.9356390834,
0.5269238949,
0.5437962413,
0.8796708584,
-0.61187011,
0.7344552875,
0.8316687346,
-0.0337066017,
-0.3966071308,
-0.3503186107,
0.0358523503,
-1.0485684872,
0.8219285011,
0.4168518484,
-0.3517727554,
-0.0809205323,
-0.5864187479,
-0.9228745699,
1.0954239368,
0.1388877779,
-0.6013931036,
0.1842857748,
0.2994818985,
0.3050743043,
-0.6759624481,
0.1057137698,
0.6068868637,
0.5325695276,
0.2686926723,
-0.5282108188,
-0.0192881357,
-0.2865138352,
0.1205346212,
-0.085038662,
-0.3786153793,
0.7802042365,
-0.3920372128,
-0.2297465354,
-0.1471384317,
0.7357235551,
0.5782400966,
0.1157578379,
1.0515594482,
0.6243789792,
0.5424233675,
0.0358530916,
1.0353778601,
0.0167172067,
-0.0550055429,
1.1630315781,
-0.3139302135,
0.672023356,
0.5162575841,
-0.0808279067,
0.4374396205,
0.6011368036,
-0.030351799,
0.5327544808,
0.2278603315,
-0.0385513045,
-0.6004989743,
0.2046729028,
-0.1819533706,
0.5096410513,
0.592592597,
0.1569054425,
-0.1445018798,
0.2741574347,
-0.2137324214,
0.0616327412,
-0.4287851751,
0.6291331053,
0.1973909438,
-0.3002157807,
0.7690001726,
-0.3257763982,
0.1528080851,
-0.2719231248,
-0.1153585166,
-0.3049652278,
0.1990234703,
-0.2698131204,
-1.0011786222,
0.244278878,
-0.2329508066,
-0.1580782831,
-0.5673291087,
0.2871748507,
-0.384236604,
-0.580275774,
0.2249082476,
0.4424602687,
0.2890069783,
-0.2406852543,
-0.7131924629,
0.1596348286,
0.0127877565,
-0.2486257404,
0.0983313099,
0.6336550713,
0.0379321724,
0.6976276636,
0.6986948848,
0.0561135672,
-0.098248519,
0.3319252729,
0.7888737917,
-0.6791141629,
-0.1451521963,
-0.8080045581,
0.3992096484,
-0.1181335226,
-0.0048383581,
0.6694767475,
0.9410435557,
0.8184868693,
-0.0922251642,
0.6622677445,
0.1062581837,
0.3470165133,
-1.0044938326,
0.3802379668,
-0.891418159,
0.2592998445,
0.2177728415,
-1.0089348555,
-0.7458064556,
0.89794451,
-0.3285102546,
-0.0195028223,
0.8871241808,
0.6548618078,
-0.1089269817,
-0.2066104859,
0.7631635666,
0.5191126466,
0.5318776369,
0.7466717362,
1.3303214312,
-0.2082475424,
0.5660044551,
-0.1730783433,
-0.2519186139,
-0.0511238314,
-0.7827143073,
-1.2517575026,
-0.6513800025,
-0.1259907931,
-0.1881311834,
-0.5494871736,
0.4026878476,
0.7672072649,
-0.6494063139,
-0.245668903,
-0.2404880822,
0.2063983977,
-0.2048936337,
-0.1663461477,
0.3766644001,
-0.1641703993,
-0.4691078067,
0.6452014446,
0.6414839625,
0.2789043784,
-0.3270530403,
-0.1582520008,
-0.110797219,
-0.1012411043,
0.9324219227,
0.0224850364,
-0.8742060661,
-0.2808925509,
-0.0063690469,
-0.1565888524,
0.3368525803,
0.9153039455,
-0.8627815843,
0.4090774059,
0.3959292769,
0.3528705835,
0.6985951066,
-0.0753683597,
0.6375474334,
-0.3515419066,
0.4446825981,
0.2096341699,
0.5751958489,
0.6310876012,
-0.2892097235,
0.4735612869,
-0.0631524548,
-0.2759151757,
-0.4452373683,
0.4600323141,
-0.8091012836,
-0.545722425,
1.2494221926,
0.0485923886,
-0.2181821018,
-0.29476583,
-0.3321885765,
-0.2418472171,
0.3121333122,
0.6869201064,
0.6175065041,
-0.2243446857,
-0.7038507462,
-0.4951999187,
0.5649208426,
0.2345935106,
-1.029389143,
0.0604283847,
0.7172850966,
-0.0227686018,
0.133483991,
0.6337668896,
-0.1843491942,
0.2811626494,
-0.1194419563,
0.0194735024,
-0.3881390691,
-0.5112015009,
-0.3241816759,
0.1866255701,
-0.0289342627,
-0.0453983583
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03677v1
|
Towards A Human-in-the-Loop LLM Approach to Collaborative Discourse Analysis
| 2024-05-06T17:53:33 | 2024-05-06T17:53:33 |
Clayton Cohn, Caitlin Snyder, Justin Montenegro, Gautam Biswas
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
LLMs have demonstrated proficiency in contextualizing their outputs using
human input, often matching or beating human-level performance on a variety of
tasks. However, LLMs have not yet been used to characterize synergistic
learning in students' collaborative discourse. In this exploratory work, we
take a first step towards adopting a human-in-the-loop prompt engineering
approach with GPT-4-Turbo to summarize and categorize students' synergistic
learning during collaborative discourse. Our preliminary findings suggest
GPT-4-Turbo may be able to characterize students' synergistic learning in a
manner comparable to humans and that our approach warrants further
investigation.
|
[
-0.5890679359,
-0.8131716847,
0.7016137838,
0.0566996001,
-0.1971921772,
1.0060652494,
-0.2194556892,
-0.1999007314,
0.4624994993,
0.0814274997,
-0.5555768013,
-0.3480015993,
-0.1287370026,
0.5119408965,
-0.0629112273,
1.0385909081,
-0.1325110942,
0.1556467116,
-0.4266887307,
-0.0970379859,
-0.873668015,
-0.7805005908,
-0.4796832502,
-0.6493175626,
0.6355916262,
0.7555399537,
0.4275527894,
-0.0918250084,
0.2603466809,
0.3999184072,
-0.0499914885,
-0.1916782856,
-0.4037368,
0.358186245,
-0.4907637835,
-0.1827058792,
-0.3993214667,
0.5093568563,
0.7191333771,
0.9243152738,
-0.1379990727,
0.060756173,
0.5207085609,
0.2090407014,
-0.2212150544,
0.1381860524,
-0.4013299048,
-0.0073959851,
-0.2379228175,
-0.2919920981,
-0.2840639055,
-0.2983339429,
0.3027646542,
-0.8563767672,
0.074721694,
0.2223636359,
0.4735200405,
0.111451745,
-0.3497973084,
-0.3771770298,
-0.4902931452,
0.7019791007,
-0.3468220532,
0.0955571607,
0.0527327061,
0.314579308,
-0.3638696969,
-0.9002943039,
-0.6354151964,
0.0807095692,
0.0027631435,
0.6815302968,
0.0655990914,
0.3160476685,
0.1359088719,
0.2747241557,
-0.6536052227,
0.3973540664,
-0.326616168,
-0.4443891048,
0.5611462593,
0.4725075066,
0.3256368339,
-0.1949792653,
-0.6787401438,
0.1521960795,
-0.3426687717,
0.1627879441,
0.3785409331,
0.2816027701,
-0.1648911387,
0.3597503901,
0.2112149596,
0.3647376597,
0.0673319548,
-0.318169862,
0.0065605729,
-0.6871246099,
-0.2012157291,
0.0377443023,
0.9596128464,
0.0941742957,
-0.0228407718,
-0.2508096695,
0.0511693656,
0.1321392804,
0.2372436523,
-0.5138888955,
-0.2411402166,
-0.1968220025,
-0.2965743244,
-0.3482723832,
-0.0362109616,
-0.7965148687,
-0.1357701421,
-0.487734586,
0.2771148086,
0.0053570205,
-0.134990409,
-0.1194422841,
-0.2392400354,
0.3063970804,
0.1537810564,
-0.6423113346,
0.665101409,
0.9231471419,
0.9027360082,
-0.45353508,
-0.6243820786,
-0.2931288183,
0.1595919281,
0.0101503497,
0.8965181112,
-0.5342299938,
-0.8510546684,
-0.3127505481,
-0.136160329,
-0.0730310902,
-0.4337851405,
0.5642876625,
-0.4637010396,
0.6514123678,
-0.5075783134,
-0.7593253255,
-0.3069395125,
0.2510327101,
-0.4035696983,
0.8606711626,
0.2925340533,
-0.9422490001,
0.1855925322,
-0.5856252313,
-0.3094511926,
0.506267488,
-0.7386499047,
-0.2574453354,
-0.1506072879,
-0.1055136621,
0.2449747175,
-0.3169440031,
0.6498735547,
-0.2058406919,
-0.662083447,
0.2517153621,
-0.1316185445,
1.003541708,
0.0960857421,
-0.3505717218,
0.2731942236,
-0.2555394173,
-0.1659038663,
-0.0966833383,
-0.1877352297,
-0.0647380278,
-0.3677443862,
-0.3553688228,
0.2818629444,
0.056851998,
-0.3569949269,
0.3789845407,
-0.4501785934,
0.3622217178,
0.8115254045,
0.0337765142,
0.6657880545,
-0.4408052862,
1.0105912685,
-0.3486503959,
-0.3269383907,
-0.3065784872,
-0.9133591056,
-0.4911677539,
-0.1387996972,
0.1192453504,
0.6292265058,
-1.0409767628,
0.1614386588,
0.0986042768,
-0.0788582712,
-0.2000752538,
0.1567080766,
0.4267510772,
0.745092988,
0.2771159708,
-0.7257561088,
-0.718482554,
-0.5743163824,
-0.3181251287,
-0.5432342887,
-0.0125704557,
0.3007189333,
0.5959818363,
-0.0958966762,
1.2851403952,
-0.3217233121,
-0.1567753553,
-0.5196168423,
0.8517484665,
0.1426639408,
0.3256719708,
0.362927258,
-0.2629030049,
-0.5368208885,
-0.2116564214,
-0.8336708546,
-0.3576960266,
-0.1183568314,
-0.2266145349,
-0.1424213201,
0.3789815605,
-0.4124532044,
0.3381067514,
0.229202643,
-0.2883303165,
0.7774582505,
-0.1331456751,
-0.1422818154,
-1.0726041794,
-0.1308398545,
-0.1073753908,
-0.1690436155,
-0.3774082959,
-0.1342188269,
-0.3187241256,
-0.2124162763,
-0.2950247228,
0.4056303203,
-0.5660764575,
-0.4468377233,
-0.4374164045,
0.2421980202,
-0.0776370168,
0.5100111365,
-0.2018799931,
1.0970504284,
0.2617688477,
-0.0458002798,
0.3577979803,
0.1499457955,
0.1061986163,
0.8848753572,
-0.5422077775,
0.5205166936,
0.3127712607,
0.7760890126,
-1.1210025549,
-0.4713297188,
0.3629671037,
-0.4835266769,
0.1474790126,
0.1478120834,
-0.683801055,
-0.6030732393,
-0.5348417163,
0.6278630495,
0.3926558495,
-0.4399884641,
0.58053267,
0.6140269637,
-0.465138644,
0.0103788087,
-0.204182595,
0.2947157025,
-0.4589261711,
-0.7715618014,
0.6043432355,
-0.1908887476,
-0.4578464031,
-0.4019789696,
0.1501899958,
-0.2296644598,
0.2943647504,
0.2853617072,
0.450055033,
0.0531207845,
0.012598509,
-0.0742428005,
-0.3260531723,
0.3990446329,
-0.0426262133,
0.2279364616,
-0.3309926689,
-0.1333462745,
-0.72962147,
0.420443058,
0.2970499694,
0.1818073541,
0.1594310552,
0.4557762742,
-0.0637249053,
-0.0302768666,
-0.3774419129,
-0.3314876854,
-0.5567493439,
-0.1274871528,
-0.1174089164,
-1.3217619658,
0.5217508078,
-0.4805354774,
-0.1159430817,
-0.0114608416,
0.5828805566,
-0.6340399981,
0.7721040845,
0.7223219275,
-0.344594717,
0.2201842517,
-0.1789325923,
0.0924723148,
-0.770381093,
-0.2179311961,
-0.4522796869,
-0.5444212556,
-0.4911379516,
-0.4306399822,
0.5463202,
0.090632081,
-0.3802647889,
0.0427525416,
-0.5021952987,
0.5738120675,
0.4817273617,
-0.0909123495,
0.2692562938,
-0.3302213848,
-0.6695613861,
-0.265791595,
-0.5926811099,
-0.56897223,
0.5944936872,
0.2083352655,
0.5319281816,
-0.0661816075,
0.9724475741,
-0.1095860153,
0.6303465366,
-0.786223948,
0.846335113,
0.3301387727,
-0.3137409985,
-0.0917659402,
-0.196984753,
-1.1227926016,
0.3045095503,
0.15037857,
-0.8487889767,
-0.3206183612,
0.0005436373,
-0.5160750151,
0.1636760086,
-0.6869131327,
0.7003463507,
-0.3934274018,
-0.5257580876,
-0.0579550117,
-0.8381825089,
0.5015807748,
-0.1138593033,
0.506628871,
0.1138037443,
-0.1552250832,
0.7591632009,
-0.4620195925,
1.1181550026,
-0.1048416495,
-0.1860061586,
0.5800566077,
0.0130946487,
0.346491158,
0.0457794704,
0.0983543918,
0.0085492041,
-0.6689472198,
-0.1634214818,
-0.5385723114,
0.7443596125,
-0.7502144575,
-0.8743665218,
-0.558182776,
-0.7022385001,
-0.3360804319,
-0.0586936735,
0.1241822317,
0.0776773095,
-0.1770907044,
-0.3569822609,
0.1612061411,
-0.1258097738,
0.8033735156,
0.4621242881,
-0.2134969085,
-0.5181360841,
1.0109171867,
0.0769576654,
-0.0170915201,
-0.1801367998,
0.4597379863,
-0.3680152297,
-0.4203125834,
-0.1200949401,
0.3489179015,
-0.7166974545,
-0.0687770322,
-0.4016584456,
-0.0030350743,
-0.1615284979,
-0.7432461381,
0.0626286417,
-0.2677448392,
-0.7694392204,
-0.110682413,
-0.0941138193,
0.9724930525,
0.1649693251,
0.4335120022,
-0.5733084679,
-0.0056315074,
0.5392587185,
0.2196235955,
0.0232937317,
-0.4543804526,
-0.0308002308,
-0.2956765592,
-1.0810302496,
-0.9255716205,
0.3575681746,
0.0170755982,
0.7436188459,
0.0490102544,
-0.1473931968,
0.7508387566,
-0.3095704019,
1.2502717972,
0.4505274892,
-0.9928892255,
0.6508819461,
-0.5355775952,
0.3901663721,
0.5540502071,
0.4124708474,
-0.2367990613,
-0.5587207675,
-0.7017024159,
-0.7985733747,
0.5186107755,
0.1822745502,
-0.123618193,
-0.0149287041,
0.3159652948,
0.3519769609,
0.0069042332,
-0.5830574632,
-0.1017970219,
-0.078670986,
-0.0196340121,
0.1454330087,
-0.0309391581,
-0.0599641204,
-0.5969203115,
0.3908607662,
-0.4181793332,
0.0777701065,
-0.0623383448,
-0.1685030609,
0.0703775436,
0.4089955986,
0.511203289,
0.6243107319,
-0.0060150563,
0.242824927,
0.4029169977,
-0.4754763246,
0.4572492242,
-0.0832908303,
0.1686009914,
-0.0467927009,
0.35480389,
0.3301605284,
0.7826222777,
-0.2399853766,
0.6155803204,
-0.2410649061,
-0.3831428885,
-0.1690504998,
-0.0199752469,
0.217021063,
0.3973593712,
0.3235438168,
-0.0937963575,
0.324352175,
-0.4739031196,
0.3607320786,
0.3116323054,
-0.1903975606,
-0.9222747684,
0.7076120377,
0.7419211864,
-0.4922546148,
0.4340135157,
-0.4789261818,
-0.7542462349,
0.5449197292,
0.5676136613,
1.2648359537,
-0.0748732165,
0.2749648392,
0.4070057869,
-0.1571604013,
-0.0224074554,
0.401669234,
-0.3515024185,
-0.5885642171,
-0.5954061747,
-0.2095565498,
-0.7796237469,
-0.3147643209,
-0.6830101013,
0.2758838236,
-0.3756529987,
-0.3143498898,
0.0780093074,
0.0901147798,
-0.6086931825,
-0.2831067741,
0.2146575153,
0.3865452111,
-0.6795732975,
0.9462718368,
0.9697882533,
-0.3076532185,
-0.9938052297,
-0.0004621944,
0.5436726213,
-0.4618271589,
0.995690465,
0.3091611564,
-0.1790696979,
0.2031776458,
-0.6495210528,
-0.5285708308,
1.42796278,
0.3901907504,
-0.4956439435,
-0.0776634067,
0.0603096038,
0.5337955356,
-0.4347710609,
0.5120822787,
0.5687641501,
0.3072717488,
0.1366679817,
-1.231595397,
-0.0365481339,
-0.0358280875,
-0.0597076304,
-0.0396398269,
-0.7874697447,
0.8959451318,
-0.3860106468,
-0.6174089909,
-0.0250347927,
0.6236766577,
0.3498865962,
0.7205483317,
0.3960328996,
0.6157607436,
0.9964668751,
-0.0391398259,
0.8863314986,
-0.0425264835,
0.584574461,
1.4775139093,
-0.6278111935,
0.4714513123,
0.6203245521,
-0.3352425992,
0.6377813816,
0.5933397412,
0.4064054191,
0.2557148933,
0.457537204,
-0.5214157701,
-0.1645492166,
-0.2162286043,
-0.2381851077,
0.4944479764,
0.349213779,
0.0114543112,
-0.3431749642,
0.0551299565,
-0.0504176207,
0.0349872485,
-0.2964011133,
1.0506726503,
0.3462561667,
-0.8364280462,
0.443058759,
-0.4534229636,
0.9214455485,
0.0890621468,
-0.1699874848,
-0.1645610183,
-0.2721729875,
-0.0874523968,
-0.9963475466,
0.1729156077,
-0.0502359495,
0.0521840863,
-0.5081436634,
0.7899855375,
-0.2275010347,
-0.2354672998,
0.4656124711,
0.5806437731,
0.1553490907,
0.3919617832,
-0.5691466928,
0.0477979444,
-0.2017440796,
0.0512096435,
0.3521501422,
0.2854985893,
-0.1505922526,
0.471577704,
0.4771219194,
-0.3430464268,
-0.22081846,
0.2810064256,
1.1749111414,
-0.9598780274,
-0.499900192,
-0.9674643874,
0.645670712,
0.0553871989,
-0.3090771437,
0.8624800444,
0.5502688289,
0.8466271758,
0.4879395962,
0.9672724605,
0.3891164064,
0.5105230808,
-0.1802405417,
0.2199295163,
-0.0821547508,
0.5336815715,
-0.5510709286,
-0.6848272681,
-0.0665826052,
0.5112689734,
-0.0539346412,
-0.1147416383,
0.9202373028,
0.4043869972,
0.2220691144,
0.7489666939,
0.1811759025,
0.0600318201,
0.4659129083,
0.515804708,
1.4398422241,
0.0649090856,
0.2406052947,
-0.246946767,
-0.5445485711,
-0.0665115193,
-0.8500599265,
-1.014446497,
-0.3669500053,
-0.1548881084,
-0.1328546256,
-0.1673140228,
0.9061888456,
0.2775378525,
-0.3685643375,
-0.6194348335,
-0.2033150941,
0.1305956393,
0.1425761133,
-0.2344146669,
-0.131786868,
-0.5741860867,
-0.3972126842,
0.6164187789,
0.4713945091,
0.0431082472,
-0.4322022498,
-0.2881589532,
-0.1076145992,
-0.2048102021,
0.5808920264,
0.2185370922,
-0.8695844412,
-0.2987479866,
0.0993287489,
-0.0124382023,
0.2177324295,
1.3311654329,
-1.1787286997,
0.6932022572,
0.4654321671,
0.6281744838,
0.3528148532,
0.203413263,
0.7639089227,
-0.8710948825,
0.0191076361,
0.4415053725,
0.3622503579,
0.2248309851,
-0.2807943523,
0.5241053104,
0.6441940665,
-1.082352519,
-0.5793788433,
-0.1776447594,
-1.2285647392,
-0.1186297163,
0.8375645876,
-0.3244164288,
0.1545570493,
-0.6007409692,
-0.4577766061,
0.3675623834,
-0.415918231,
0.6278863549,
0.9146656394,
-0.5508812666,
0.0695039034,
-0.4292135239,
0.1257406175,
0.3498499393,
-1.0977413654,
-0.3843820691,
0.4266200066,
0.2045818567,
0.1257625669,
0.9363971949,
0.3205266893,
0.1905476898,
-0.2486686409,
-0.190731138,
0.1945018321,
-0.2319815904,
-0.3664121926,
0.1755541861,
-0.0529017113,
0.1031502411
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.15793v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.15793v2
|
SWE-agent: Agent-Computer Interfaces Enable Automated Software Engineering
| 2024-05-06T17:41:33 | 2024-05-30T19:09:01 |
John Yang, Carlos E. Jimenez, Alexander Wettig, Kilian Lieret, Shunyu Yao, Karthik Narasimhan, Ofir Press
|
cs.SE
|
cs.SE, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.HC, cs.LG
|
Language model (LM) agents are increasingly being used to automate
complicated tasks in digital environments. Just as humans benefit from powerful
software applications, such as integrated development environments, for complex
tasks like software engineering, we posit that LM agents represent a new
category of end users with their own needs and abilities, and would benefit
from specially-built interfaces to the software they use. We investigate how
interface design affects the performance of language model agents. As a result
of this exploration, we introduce SWE-agent: a system that facilitates LM
agents to autonomously use computers to solve software engineering tasks.
SWE-agent's custom agent-computer interface (ACI) significantly enhances an
agent's ability to create and edit code files, navigate entire repositories,
and execute tests and other programs. We evaluate SWE-agent on SWE-bench and
HumanEvalFix, achieving state-of-the-art performance on both with a pass@1 rate
of 12.5% and 87.7%, respectively, far exceeding the previous state-of-the-art
achieved with non-interactive LMs. Finally, we provide insight on how the
design of the ACI can impact agents' behavior and performance.
|
[
-0.6789899468,
-0.6677467227,
0.4811248779,
0.131783694,
0.3499747813,
0.3978616297,
0.1409396529,
-0.9995933771,
0.1377425343,
0.3867642283,
-0.42384547,
-0.2656854093,
-0.1200054437,
0.0903119966,
-0.3167287409,
0.3531056941,
-0.167031765,
-0.1591877192,
-0.2793415189,
-0.0531975105,
-0.3417980373,
-0.4380757511,
-0.7045068145,
-0.6193748116,
0.4229693413,
0.1699044555,
1.1405143738,
0.5292239189,
0.4075285494,
0.4928122461,
0.3842048645,
-0.152989924,
-0.0430904701,
0.2767108679,
-0.0947485417,
-0.3913681805,
-0.779871583,
0.1545432955,
0.1976338923,
0.4871284962,
-0.0614562035,
0.0319547765,
-0.0911979228,
0.6331372261,
-0.3914830685,
0.1768496782,
-0.1318766326,
-0.0766042396,
0.1382265687,
-0.3108954132,
-0.7284883857,
-0.2241800576,
0.0147614442,
-0.8005996346,
-0.151635468,
0.1140421033,
0.8574565053,
0.3714579046,
-0.4136594236,
-0.2060693353,
-0.7919624448,
0.6586669683,
-0.7535144091,
0.5610787272,
-0.1144971773,
0.335390389,
-0.5305250883,
-0.4351086318,
-0.3760500848,
-0.6126157045,
-0.1643021554,
-0.0958383158,
-0.235635072,
0.5610827208,
0.3567015529,
0.0245578606,
-0.7317666411,
0.3860791922,
0.0078902571,
-0.1089611575,
0.8621333241,
0.2646690905,
0.7866317034,
0.3512381613,
-0.1103492379,
-0.190533936,
-0.4694075882,
0.364161551,
0.4046242833,
0.1718257964,
0.0280631315,
0.4204673469,
-0.1001388654,
0.6458626986,
-0.2762820423,
0.0438903421,
0.1912870854,
0.1450665742,
-0.21568878,
-0.4418704212,
0.5905326009,
0.128468588,
0.354367137,
-0.2694124877,
-0.6660194397,
0.1771249473,
0.3965153396,
-0.5869445801,
-0.0773240402,
0.4549722075,
-0.5511273146,
-0.4635478556,
-0.0693842843,
-0.1143804044,
-0.5684463978,
-0.7785939574,
0.8040795326,
-0.0911857262,
-0.4187799692,
-0.2524030507,
-0.5665535927,
0.528852582,
0.4592437744,
-0.2831459343,
0.6559380889,
0.5638580918,
0.5313585997,
-0.3550594747,
-0.4922406077,
-0.5680371523,
-0.0605871864,
-0.455293119,
0.8258182406,
-0.7666302919,
-0.517406404,
-0.2569108605,
-0.0705142096,
0.0512840971,
-0.6248722672,
-0.2046687156,
-0.5573774576,
-0.2402217835,
-0.1269101351,
-0.5975936055,
0.0870384797,
-0.1911157668,
-0.6530299783,
0.8032693267,
0.0709878728,
-0.2311879545,
0.1229848489,
-1.0698997974,
-0.5216144323,
0.2503189147,
-0.2902004123,
0.2157500535,
0.1492393017,
-0.4572322369,
0.1080454886,
-0.0999444798,
-0.1167753413,
-0.3727646172,
-0.5843290091,
0.339192152,
-0.0141742099,
0.6056973934,
0.353511095,
-0.5107988715,
0.1502525657,
-0.7572885752,
0.2142626941,
0.0291922521,
-0.2260619849,
-0.3897249699,
0.117916815,
0.1758841872,
0.4030461907,
0.3834189773,
-0.612739265,
0.2097939402,
-0.3097623289,
-0.034162648,
0.8361900449,
-0.2060119212,
0.632378459,
-0.5197333097,
0.6295167208,
-0.1898946911,
0.4216155112,
0.1800625324,
-0.3874922395,
-0.6123335958,
-0.114521049,
0.0530618615,
0.6728187203,
-0.7051826119,
0.0323632471,
0.3134906292,
-0.5443289876,
-0.5085669756,
0.1963454485,
0.1482992172,
0.021440262,
0.1734632701,
-0.3876949847,
-0.3117778897,
-1.0396236181,
-0.3618086278,
-0.3471190035,
-0.1369131655,
0.700170815,
0.2927961946,
-0.4794678986,
1.1934696436,
-0.3808332682,
0.1433770508,
-0.3964259923,
0.327319622,
-0.0233310219,
0.2774407864,
0.6360444427,
-0.486409694,
-0.4441978633,
0.2332459688,
-0.8377503753,
-0.7283487916,
-0.1877382398,
-0.2058148831,
0.5914139748,
0.4188529849,
-0.610104382,
0.5151690245,
0.341473639,
-0.3937811255,
0.5289346576,
-0.4559958577,
0.1777659953,
-0.4659691751,
0.1151811481,
0.1204524711,
-0.0770315453,
-0.8458358645,
0.4554607868,
0.0548184104,
-0.2356040329,
-0.5217733383,
0.9390946031,
-0.5062910914,
-0.2961950898,
-0.8492088914,
0.2709982693,
-0.1250464469,
0.5310766697,
0.1769680828,
0.9695664644,
0.4016144872,
-0.661858201,
0.1145036668,
-0.1850908399,
0.2438711524,
0.4426243007,
-0.7789475322,
0.3483721018,
-0.1005010977,
-0.0346248969,
-0.6602973938,
0.0465594344,
-0.2688676715,
-0.4303661287,
0.2816002667,
0.3027071059,
-0.2684953511,
-0.2265403867,
-0.4689921737,
0.181744352,
0.5310793519,
-0.3637643754,
1.0063910484,
0.5289697647,
-0.0672703087,
-0.4566250145,
-0.4174229801,
0.2561825216,
0.3684596717,
-0.6708649993,
-0.0242642798,
-0.2495688945,
-0.7342092991,
0.0583032593,
-0.0348268822,
-0.2364027202,
0.3806262314,
0.4774595797,
0.3236466944,
-0.1973796636,
0.0181057658,
0.0856550708,
-0.0955149382,
0.1936273426,
0.2273984998,
0.3212677836,
-0.2045988888,
-0.3898148537,
-0.6161429286,
0.5401159525,
0.7853707075,
-0.1585825682,
0.6173463464,
0.2201043963,
-0.3746346235,
-0.3498980403,
-0.6268140078,
-0.1797116995,
-0.5942783356,
0.2837469876,
-0.7126092911,
-0.507974267,
0.5111609101,
-0.0868590549,
0.5121920705,
0.1486536115,
0.1332917213,
-0.2354062945,
1.2495727539,
0.9677677751,
-0.3770662844,
0.7243924141,
-0.1238231286,
0.2392352968,
-0.3975823224,
0.0824692845,
-0.717366159,
-0.435126245,
-0.6691560149,
0.030136751,
0.2181272805,
-0.3568200767,
-0.4783639014,
0.5493283272,
-0.4293309748,
0.3612766266,
0.4083695114,
-0.0850702524,
0.3702002168,
-0.4716136456,
0.1058350652,
0.2899503708,
-0.5796379447,
-0.7352964282,
0.6651293039,
0.6958246827,
1.2510145903,
0.1961114258,
0.8037378192,
0.7245870233,
0.4419513643,
-0.5434552431,
0.8403892517,
0.1753540933,
-0.2244971395,
-0.5537982583,
-0.1809217632,
-0.917006731,
0.2955587208,
0.0139482394,
-0.5621495843,
0.4354740679,
0.0342669487,
0.1454456151,
-0.1209445968,
-1.1023526192,
0.8099890351,
-0.3102055192,
-0.291736573,
-0.6238279939,
-0.3382705152,
-0.0648756847,
0.1090300009,
0.3523152769,
-0.0104577169,
-0.354711026,
0.4418103993,
-0.6404141784,
0.8423039913,
-0.4470567107,
-0.0583293438,
0.1887390018,
0.3184928,
0.8343924284,
-0.31295982,
-0.2459178269,
-0.1365834624,
0.0943121985,
-0.4226247668,
-0.7943721414,
0.7008014917,
-0.9561073184,
-0.7499370575,
-0.3071822524,
-0.5405133367,
-0.0874495953,
0.0545942523,
-0.2910091579,
0.4688613713,
-0.4127343595,
-0.275238663,
0.5181618929,
-0.3803668916,
0.6277396679,
0.9569507241,
-0.2508207262,
0.1853967607,
0.8900853395,
0.1150007322,
0.4555135071,
0.2333988845,
-0.1371376514,
-0.1262170225,
-0.2339654863,
-0.3914166391,
0.216032654,
-0.7523089051,
0.0713528469,
-0.5598983765,
-0.5222018361,
-0.1013259813,
-0.5168768764,
-0.2787038684,
-0.2773693204,
-0.0470108241,
0.1972211301,
0.1459822357,
1.1265528202,
0.2847573757,
0.0397782661,
-0.5313935876,
0.2348193675,
0.1853432208,
0.3186054528,
0.0607393757,
-0.2755749226,
-0.1806223094,
-0.2080544829,
-0.2974611819,
-0.8641316295,
0.1189495474,
0.1019756049,
0.9786161184,
0.0854609609,
0.2334931195,
0.2103217691,
-0.2502446473,
0.5299823284,
-0.3277075589,
-0.9265210032,
0.4302268028,
-0.1994031519,
0.4187750816,
0.2974662781,
0.1017438099,
-0.5201011896,
-1.0759735107,
-0.4849128723,
-0.6613720655,
0.5083944798,
0.1681887507,
-0.1447445899,
0.2405223399,
0.2879083753,
-0.0164505374,
0.2552625835,
-0.7474759221,
-0.3412297368,
0.1212855354,
-0.1737589836,
0.2240216285,
0.0883251727,
0.1814460754,
-0.0998084694,
0.7818905115,
-0.1191873923,
0.2162275314,
0.2054635435,
-0.517983377,
-0.1810805798,
0.3261365294,
0.6534458399,
0.6517480016,
0.0377752446,
0.0044703097,
0.1866033375,
-0.3851500452,
0.2127869129,
0.0038882091,
-0.1404399574,
0.0523320027,
0.2824671566,
0.5636076927,
-0.154083252,
-0.7672770619,
0.4093478024,
-0.1543501168,
-0.1788255274,
-0.2866941392,
0.5340036154,
-0.155555293,
0.3818998337,
0.4223798215,
0.1212266088,
0.4187836051,
-0.5856202841,
0.120776765,
0.6056734324,
-0.116474025,
-0.2512276471,
0.5411112905,
0.5583000183,
-0.8219230175,
0.2301108986,
-0.0208871346,
-0.165197432,
1.0347243547,
0.4060026705,
1.1407724619,
-0.3502190411,
0.1759886891,
-0.097201705,
0.5295962095,
0.2796362638,
0.3590550125,
-0.1583102643,
-0.4642118514,
-0.4016117156,
-0.4558546841,
-0.7053757906,
-0.0643893704,
-0.0712177306,
0.2690781653,
-0.3408804238,
-0.1169854999,
-0.1206424534,
0.077659905,
-0.7021284699,
0.1331008226,
0.1272740662,
1.2713911533,
-0.8648262024,
0.6734881401,
1.0024900436,
-0.2174481452,
-0.8919593096,
-0.3297279179,
-0.0836827606,
-0.4098846614,
0.4445631802,
-0.0383914262,
-0.5427731276,
-0.0994255468,
-0.20024468,
-0.7396222949,
0.9985803366,
0.2242319286,
-0.4262819588,
0.0818681121,
0.4556924999,
0.8355417252,
-0.449896723,
0.8618834615,
0.5303431153,
0.5804930925,
-0.3531469405,
-1.2020378113,
0.0596423112,
-0.6866180301,
0.2538077831,
0.2827096283,
-0.6400357485,
0.3666426539,
-0.1154362932,
0.0349310674,
-0.0450464338,
0.3652353287,
0.1743435711,
0.4034482837,
0.6330395937,
0.0801926404,
0.5762552619,
0.1331375241,
0.9353640676,
-0.6013716459,
-0.0860944912,
0.6797180772,
-0.4866259396,
0.8266227841,
0.3619164228,
-0.1431295127,
0.5471919775,
0.5311214924,
0.4040139019,
0.0514644831,
0.140374884,
-0.4478081465,
-0.1816624403,
-0.062992163,
-0.1701926738,
0.1783958375,
0.0257176217,
0.0098563889,
0.0218971055,
0.3498417139,
-0.3844515383,
0.0443766713,
-0.1604360193,
0.8019959331,
0.1545922905,
-0.4091895521,
0.1616280079,
-0.1198299378,
0.4317120314,
-0.5169478655,
-0.1126709953,
-0.3533875346,
0.145695284,
-0.3792453408,
-0.6029576659,
0.2542568147,
-0.223335892,
-0.1387848407,
-0.2485910505,
0.9414102435,
-0.0781666189,
-0.0341603905,
0.4866591692,
0.6756240129,
0.3033655584,
0.0649138242,
-0.6071341038,
0.1970480382,
-0.4441510439,
-0.6298158765,
0.5115409493,
0.270971179,
-0.3379476964,
1.1711053848,
0.3685440123,
-0.0900730416,
-0.1491454989,
0.2555330396,
0.9104543924,
-0.7615289688,
-0.2816027105,
-0.6334182024,
0.4243902266,
-0.0514917038,
0.1117844433,
0.3769746721,
0.7142302394,
0.5265960693,
-0.1357142776,
0.856480062,
-0.1865687668,
0.1555585116,
-0.0316072218,
0.8810849786,
-0.7549606562,
0.4018089473,
-0.4768321812,
-0.6426486373,
0.1162326485,
0.296287775,
-0.1038324982,
0.2554006875,
0.7375085354,
1.0766782761,
0.2249002904,
-0.1429485381,
0.5118614435,
0.1404785067,
0.5243643522,
0.3890662193,
0.8166880608,
-0.2874191701,
0.4188826382,
-0.1313132793,
-0.4349960983,
-0.0326645449,
-0.5807185173,
-0.8151038885,
-0.4517537057,
-0.4330286086,
0.0248901099,
0.0206456743,
1.0363003016,
0.5176653266,
-0.6575793028,
-0.7059331536,
-0.0901793167,
0.3212076724,
-0.2166915685,
-0.2408220321,
-0.2556885183,
-0.7420036197,
-0.570281744,
0.570127964,
0.4981382489,
0.1186656728,
-0.3135934174,
-0.4686748385,
0.1791415066,
0.4328447878,
0.6037937999,
0.4637132883,
-0.5220451951,
-0.2637552023,
0.3752908111,
-0.5997458696,
0.0085249618,
0.8391554356,
-0.8622098565,
0.1418175846,
0.4827380478,
0.6201751828,
0.1107735261,
-0.0259912666,
0.8682100177,
-0.2603698373,
0.0934208855,
0.0096664606,
0.141429171,
-0.2403954715,
-0.638353169,
0.3803919554,
0.0894703344,
-0.9066351056,
-0.7844483852,
0.0878279656,
-0.9148874879,
-0.4976189435,
0.8478937149,
0.2801516056,
-0.4145990312,
-0.5174079537,
-0.5171799064,
-0.1027385592,
-0.5089633465,
0.6085548997,
0.6335293651,
-0.7140356302,
-0.3776077926,
-0.6489571929,
0.4581870139,
0.3601137102,
-0.9885367155,
-0.09534318,
0.4543656707,
0.2617846131,
-0.0799665526,
0.7695894241,
0.2671054006,
0.6553936005,
0.0525070503,
0.69953233,
-0.2238417417,
-0.2887301147,
-0.1714277864,
0.06430576,
0.8394756913,
-0.0505619869
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03595v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03595v1
|
GREEN: Generative Radiology Report Evaluation and Error Notation
| 2024-05-06T16:04:03 | 2024-05-06T16:04:03 |
Sophie Ostmeier, Justin Xu, Zhihong Chen, Maya Varma, Louis Blankemeier, Christian Bluethgen, Arne Edward Michalson, Michael Moseley, Curtis Langlotz, Akshay S Chaudhari, Jean-Benoit Delbrouck
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Evaluating radiology reports is a challenging problem as factual correctness
is extremely important due to the need for accurate medical communication about
medical images. Existing automatic evaluation metrics either suffer from
failing to consider factual correctness (e.g., BLEU and ROUGE) or are limited
in their interpretability (e.g., F1CheXpert and F1RadGraph). In this paper, we
introduce GREEN (Generative Radiology Report Evaluation and Error Notation), a
radiology report generation metric that leverages the natural language
understanding of language models to identify and explain clinically significant
errors in candidate reports, both quantitatively and qualitatively. Compared to
current metrics, GREEN offers: 1) a score aligned with expert preferences, 2)
human interpretable explanations of clinically significant errors, enabling
feedback loops with end-users, and 3) a lightweight open-source method that
reaches the performance of commercial counterparts. We validate our GREEN
metric by comparing it to GPT-4, as well as to error counts of 6 experts and
preferences of 2 experts. Our method demonstrates not only higher correlation
with expert error counts, but simultaneously higher alignment with expert
preferences when compared to previous approaches."
|
[
0.1323577762,
-0.6036057472,
0.9657458663,
0.4068894982,
-0.3027709723,
0.2435887456,
-0.1359147727,
-0.4923835695,
-0.0747453272,
-0.0862007141,
-0.1353259832,
-0.7672088146,
-0.8896844983,
0.0756268352,
0.0465494916,
1.011692524,
-0.1875324249,
0.4070159197,
-0.1376817971,
-0.4944133162,
-0.7922720313,
0.2352129519,
-0.5536369085,
-0.0730885342,
0.434810251,
0.5670660734,
1.2058719397,
0.5530622602,
0.8610849977,
0.3210524321,
0.3854065537,
0.2911981642,
-0.3625624776,
-0.3098847568,
-0.1215847209,
-0.1127180159,
-0.5928167701,
0.0813275278,
0.5185962915,
0.427069962,
-0.2600895464,
-0.0243928656,
-0.3870659173,
0.8411978483,
-0.5605659485,
0.5474233627,
-0.3797828257,
0.3004744053,
-0.1524303555,
-0.6733598113,
-0.3441433907,
-0.7299392819,
-0.0515995398,
-0.8331406713,
0.3131358027,
-0.0174694117,
1.0939934254,
0.2063107789,
-0.1880238205,
-0.4076075554,
-0.8128623366,
0.7320085168,
-0.6180763245,
0.2263155729,
0.2118058354,
0.7715637684,
0.2479764968,
-0.7003822327,
-0.5195177794,
-0.30122298,
-0.3454203308,
0.7342166305,
-0.3932197094,
0.19337897,
0.0284163672,
0.6145190001,
-0.606587708,
0.0006029134,
-0.5667268038,
-0.3526130617,
0.7025201917,
0.3058941066,
0.7062713504,
-0.2164848447,
-0.2371583283,
-0.0713694543,
-0.2171880454,
-0.7518692613,
0.1348119378,
0.0818171427,
-0.3221527338,
0.5759428144,
-0.1447696835,
0.5528132915,
0.1662817001,
-0.2587998211,
0.4626607895,
-0.5276215076,
-0.2298760265,
0.0877514631,
0.9287451506,
0.8071280718,
-0.1302919388,
-0.2139067799,
-0.0712222308,
0.49458915,
0.2645761073,
-0.5181652308,
-0.5298572183,
0.3731857538,
-0.539393127,
-0.2095480859,
0.1632100344,
-0.8028813004,
-0.2891622782,
-0.2256904393,
0.5303786993,
-0.6857792139,
-0.4067154229,
0.3175680041,
-0.2288604677,
0.1080392972,
0.77423805,
-0.5783866644,
0.1912565529,
0.3594549,
0.8748090863,
0.1036488712,
0.0322954059,
-0.6184075475,
-0.0303028543,
-0.4405585527,
0.8675025105,
-0.4203640521,
-0.5948544741,
-0.2808816135,
-0.2387628257,
-0.3382994235,
-0.4104959369,
0.5868675709,
-0.4686566889,
0.3254974186,
-0.0740067437,
-0.3347506821,
-0.2112065703,
0.1286834925,
-0.4570184648,
0.7347767949,
0.4891875386,
-0.8707380891,
0.6272505522,
-0.848721385,
-0.1447340548,
0.5405780077,
-0.4503634572,
-0.4640358984,
0.0114134094,
-0.0055922591,
0.3077489436,
-0.3255153894,
0.1645537466,
0.1645121276,
-0.3108206093,
0.1047629714,
-0.1334192157,
0.5711408854,
0.3635428548,
-0.3470503688,
0.3830462396,
-0.7952857018,
0.4327220619,
0.3220684528,
-0.2477232218,
-0.0470065624,
-0.195628792,
-0.196340844,
-0.0757953525,
0.0270114243,
-0.7328560948,
-0.4273651838,
0.0253420342,
0.0740155578,
0.4058943689,
-0.0133072408,
0.0766523033,
-0.4442266822,
0.8375290036,
0.0127289891,
0.1194260642,
0.0569174513,
-0.5926965475,
-0.4380026758,
-0.4330374897,
0.4196241498,
0.7135121226,
-0.333712548,
0.3123211563,
-0.4655554593,
-0.8428198099,
-0.6067358851,
-0.2384339273,
0.4688614309,
0.7703815103,
0.3780723214,
-0.2825999558,
-0.3881663382,
-0.8147559762,
-0.0767722577,
-0.4400865734,
0.0732945129,
0.3130994141,
0.1908214092,
-0.5672724843,
0.7002878785,
-0.8487834334,
-0.3901606202,
0.0071697822,
0.5831030607,
0.0400244482,
0.2257580906,
0.2702617347,
-0.6871855855,
-0.5058988929,
0.4795584977,
-0.8403717875,
-0.0214977078,
-0.2594889998,
0.014455691,
0.233416453,
0.3308996856,
-0.4170186818,
0.3224247992,
0.6632793546,
-0.4225215912,
0.7050957084,
-0.6378946304,
0.5577818155,
-0.3767113388,
0.0768249705,
0.3113445342,
-0.2281100154,
-0.1760175526,
0.0363328047,
0.2148060203,
-0.0500302725,
-0.0753099099,
0.2414750159,
-0.506080687,
-0.2517996728,
0.2113361806,
0.1360630691,
0.0418305956,
-0.0923371315,
0.0297899731,
0.5613603592,
0.316452831,
-0.2340397835,
0.2964149415,
0.3148796856,
-0.290073663,
0.5234185457,
-0.5248903036,
0.2985385656,
-0.184612453,
-0.0529083982,
-1.0224096775,
-0.3752425313,
0.2509360611,
-0.6649389267,
0.4295168519,
-0.1854169667,
-0.2997255921,
-0.236317113,
-0.2294671685,
0.3302428424,
0.5085377097,
-0.3077658713,
0.3542732,
0.2989675701,
-0.1167683899,
-0.4192171395,
-0.6683695912,
0.183233887,
0.0047160783,
-0.7343549132,
0.2941172719,
-0.1263490766,
-0.3723384142,
0.2902414501,
-0.0420962013,
-0.1661587954,
0.0430378504,
0.0567769967,
0.3660031259,
-0.5276725888,
-0.047976952,
-0.407808125,
-0.3434120715,
0.1526978165,
0.0491835363,
-0.0454470105,
-0.5857877731,
-0.4854770005,
-0.3654879332,
0.1311527789,
0.6679750681,
-0.0270323791,
0.3320675492,
0.518345654,
-0.4208327532,
0.086988464,
-0.4655291438,
0.3426685333,
-0.4040630758,
0.4908854663,
0.0542771481,
-0.4416228235,
0.1927620918,
0.2486285418,
0.0729145855,
0.9042695761,
0.5298167467,
-0.1992052644,
1.0412862301,
0.2870648503,
0.6317113638,
-0.2106625289,
0.1202548742,
0.3639714718,
-0.6157798171,
-0.4213119149,
-0.498085916,
0.2229043394,
-0.5669703484,
-0.6527544856,
0.5382646322,
-0.1369275153,
0.0729871467,
-0.3261865079,
-0.781568408,
0.4790935516,
-0.0496971831,
0.0868647099,
0.4611753821,
-0.0306223501,
0.0214447156,
-0.2951574326,
-0.7685837746,
-0.7059806585,
0.8494116068,
0.6046487689,
0.5597786307,
0.1415663362,
0.6155241728,
0.2724877894,
0.7663462162,
-0.93002671,
0.332821548,
-0.4422475398,
-0.2725733817,
-0.3471168876,
-0.4061079323,
-0.6795489788,
0.192567423,
-0.228145659,
-0.1578121632,
-0.1025724038,
0.4608992338,
-0.6005055308,
0.0670110881,
-0.8055647612,
1.0044834614,
-0.3840219975,
0.0231714044,
-0.3557491601,
-0.4703498483,
0.3206499219,
0.0986734629,
0.4304112494,
-0.1647334099,
-0.0781599507,
0.6393404007,
-0.473076582,
0.6491008401,
-0.3121923208,
0.1098320857,
0.1092014983,
0.1623046547,
0.3086562157,
0.0428868085,
0.0875925571,
0.271366477,
-0.0351273678,
-0.2307680398,
-0.4636877179,
0.3578595221,
-0.7206533551,
-0.4145202041,
-0.7852019072,
-0.3686518073,
-0.3915758133,
0.1421397626,
0.4138923585,
0.3916194737,
-0.4196853638,
-0.3351184428,
0.4317134321,
-0.3859793842,
-0.22639817,
0.5621754527,
-0.0014526161,
-0.3134282529,
1.0644072294,
0.1186337844,
0.1930756122,
0.2182934433,
0.5513711572,
-0.2384197861,
-1.1621809006,
-0.6092736125,
0.2877934873,
-1.0758248568,
-0.2118010223,
-0.8920652866,
-0.2648633122,
0.1039640233,
-0.2791163623,
-0.1388297677,
-0.2319619358,
-0.1800126582,
-0.2296611071,
0.4088146091,
0.6977447271,
-0.2631986141,
0.0452793203,
-0.9071845412,
0.2564314306,
0.2302145213,
0.4388295114,
-0.2415969968,
-0.2363526374,
-0.2690090835,
-0.1921043992,
-0.2804059684,
-0.844460547,
0.3393012881,
-0.0550793484,
0.5045106411,
0.1522886753,
-0.2474596798,
0.8213515282,
-0.3853808641,
0.6416735053,
0.7150055766,
-0.7950980067,
0.69338274,
-0.6991220117,
0.313002944,
0.6739826202,
0.1814702451,
-0.5428265929,
-0.645080924,
-0.9703533649,
-0.7306188345,
0.4642137587,
-0.0386325419,
-0.1911325157,
-0.4528807402,
0.059451811,
0.1973333657,
-0.2500013411,
-0.4838333726,
0.0313341729,
-0.4531355202,
-0.3671073914,
0.1098265648,
-0.3260783255,
-0.4908786118,
-0.1056317762,
0.6890244484,
-0.6188924313,
0.6212329268,
0.4149743617,
-0.172557205,
-0.512155354,
0.3953595459,
0.6801058054,
1.3315941095,
-0.3922519684,
0.0418447591,
0.0927604437,
-0.5546363592,
-0.150669843,
-0.0458284728,
0.1884940863,
0.3339858651,
0.4427055418,
0.5142737627,
0.2263968885,
-0.3931052089,
0.587323308,
-0.3854146004,
-0.411277324,
-0.4613568187,
-0.0832828581,
0.1619899273,
-0.2665367126,
0.2449178249,
0.5514475703,
0.2311461568,
-0.2928868234,
0.1346338391,
0.3503940701,
-0.5367518067,
-0.2720408738,
0.6715890765,
0.3857213557,
0.1868868768,
0.6987910271,
-0.4514883161,
-0.1505816579,
0.8408205509,
0.4667606354,
1.0132784843,
0.1307674944,
0.7282757759,
0.8051319122,
0.1677371711,
0.0046681785,
0.4228520989,
0.4291602373,
-0.8579262495,
-0.6160204411,
-0.2947271764,
-0.6154739261,
0.0007421102,
-0.7799300551,
0.2170272321,
-0.9146052003,
-0.0805729404,
0.3521945179,
-0.2488525212,
-0.5525602102,
0.6309921741,
0.0440809093,
0.7318956256,
-0.6726406813,
0.3208179474,
0.7944668531,
-0.3752207756,
-0.968522191,
0.1076145917,
0.2379437238,
-0.9649948478,
0.937959671,
0.0372658372,
-0.2764212191,
-0.3226846457,
-0.0104598207,
-0.5053170919,
1.0930687189,
0.2309499681,
-0.6213162541,
0.3519609272,
-0.2325527221,
0.6306464672,
-0.1948454231,
0.5307020545,
0.4711919427,
0.720962286,
0.056759607,
-0.9112468958,
0.4008949101,
0.0587416589,
-0.1243809089,
0.1696077734,
-0.5765943527,
0.3072733581,
-0.7134578228,
-0.8008543253,
-0.128536135,
0.5424593091,
0.1342425495,
0.3345080912,
0.5184797049,
0.460709244,
1.0573829412,
-0.2812170088,
1.4236613512,
0.0739280581,
0.3907668591,
0.6933580041,
-0.1549058259,
0.2456127256,
0.1228515208,
-0.486926198,
0.4809379578,
0.4610013068,
-0.2707925439,
0.4465996027,
-0.0132545652,
-0.1595626622,
-0.1095401868,
0.1978087872,
-0.2276770771,
0.2792528868,
0.3586770594,
-0.1759853959,
-0.3372020721,
-0.4976813197,
0.1356943399,
0.2863536477,
-0.2405776381,
0.7506885529,
-0.0893726125,
-0.6089912057,
0.5814125538,
0.1543318182,
0.5188055634,
-0.688467443,
-0.1975723505,
0.0074964124,
0.1879293174,
-0.7733056545,
-0.7469826937,
0.7580422163,
0.0066738022,
-0.1491810679,
-0.0342399105,
0.268055588,
-0.1633353978,
-0.5355915427,
0.0701860264,
0.2743649781,
0.0308718774,
0.513589859,
-0.7474839091,
0.0689953491,
0.2022878081,
0.3570003211,
0.0550001226,
0.3214030862,
-0.0792363659,
0.2550907135,
0.4665008187,
0.477108866,
-0.3344469666,
0.1259369105,
0.3738277853,
-0.5649528503,
-0.655602634,
-0.581301868,
0.6952065229,
-0.1475053132,
-0.4701617956,
0.640630722,
0.4022982717,
0.4880682826,
-0.1435375363,
0.9692090154,
-0.1028018892,
0.4751794338,
-0.7776619196,
0.5687083006,
-0.1537923515,
0.2782489359,
-0.2392565608,
-0.5411964655,
-0.4727417827,
0.6810197234,
-0.3108383417,
0.1732420176,
1.0583958626,
0.7439653873,
-0.0294106249,
0.1936366111,
0.2929233909,
0.4134016931,
0.2120334804,
0.2026443183,
0.8858041763,
-0.2300403267,
0.4206498861,
-0.0303455275,
-0.5230898261,
-0.2402952611,
-1.0246156454,
-0.1749637872,
-0.2264902592,
-1.2474592924,
-0.5708938837,
0.2014767081,
0.390034318,
0.6434851289,
-0.8204719424,
0.2042514384,
-0.0959357992,
-0.1083190739,
-0.3063536286,
-0.2728617489,
0.6341245174,
-0.4589899182,
-0.3841814697,
0.2858611047,
0.5112646818,
-0.0887678191,
-0.0237300005,
-0.3683464527,
0.2937784791,
-0.1572027504,
0.226396665,
0.4402085841,
-0.5274076462,
-0.4993691742,
-0.5174764991,
-0.2487341762,
0.4675366282,
0.6474705338,
-0.5181654096,
0.7999597788,
0.3631807566,
0.4527602792,
0.3374313712,
-0.1844974905,
0.6808546185,
-0.4041666985,
-0.2365258932,
0.4834854305,
0.3207948804,
0.7578560114,
-0.714379549,
0.6984180808,
0.2756871581,
-0.4153417349,
-0.574957788,
-0.1117982343,
-1.0022226572,
-0.1100865155,
1.1315535307,
-0.2577866614,
0.0604920983,
-0.2687835395,
-0.126575321,
0.0655120313,
-0.1520887762,
0.7641547322,
0.4977716804,
-0.3458481431,
-0.0393671431,
-0.8119344711,
0.6233403683,
0.4494406581,
-0.8969194889,
-0.165211305,
0.8241021037,
0.7100564837,
0.4656686187,
1.0922226906,
-0.7596740723,
1.0634155273,
0.054152526,
-0.066194132,
-0.1782480627,
0.0798148364,
-0.3756322861,
-0.0387399681,
0.3845236301,
-0.3448294103
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03594v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03594v1
|
Enabling High-Sparsity Foundational Llama Models with Efficient Pretraining and Deployment
| 2024-05-06T16:03:32 | 2024-05-06T16:03:32 |
Abhinav Agarwalla, Abhay Gupta, Alexandre Marques, Shubhra Pandit, Michael Goin, Eldar Kurtic, Kevin Leong, Tuan Nguyen, Mahmoud Salem, Dan Alistarh, Sean Lie, Mark Kurtz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) have revolutionized Natural Language Processing
(NLP), but their size creates computational bottlenecks. We introduce a novel
approach to create accurate, sparse foundational versions of performant LLMs
that achieve full accuracy recovery for fine-tuning tasks at up to 70%
sparsity. We achieve this for the LLaMA-2 7B model by combining the SparseGPT
one-shot pruning method and sparse pretraining of those models on a subset of
the SlimPajama dataset mixed with a Python subset of The Stack dataset. We
exhibit training acceleration due to sparsity on Cerebras CS-3 chips that
closely matches theoretical scaling. In addition, we establish inference
acceleration of up to 3x on CPUs by utilizing Neural Magic's DeepSparse engine
and 1.7x on GPUs through Neural Magic's nm-vllm engine. The above gains are
realized via sparsity alone, thus enabling further gains through additional use
of quantization. Specifically, we show a total speedup on CPUs for
sparse-quantized LLaMA models of up to 8.6x. We demonstrate these results
across diverse, challenging tasks, including chat, instruction following, code
generation, arithmetic reasoning, and summarization to prove their generality.
This work paves the way for rapidly creating smaller and faster LLMs without
sacrificing accuracy.
|
[
-0.3322833478,
-0.8554955721,
0.2563742399,
0.6370541453,
-0.2715452611,
0.0905713663,
-0.5896959305,
-0.1963460445,
0.2875324488,
0.671635747,
-0.5065946579,
-0.4769918621,
-0.8170033097,
-0.0336095504,
-0.479197681,
1.0828326941,
0.2462415397,
-0.494523406,
0.1166047677,
-0.0662380606,
-0.5750185251,
-0.4569497705,
-0.3709296584,
-0.1479019076,
0.3938874602,
0.3265800178,
1.027870059,
0.8166764379,
0.3205929101,
0.3028219044,
-0.3126019239,
0.2444272339,
-0.7958828807,
-0.0232685842,
0.2338104546,
-0.3329421878,
-0.5941191316,
-0.2193116397,
0.7481511235,
0.94275105,
-0.5042698979,
0.1567650884,
0.2591139078,
0.5398641229,
-0.8334271312,
-0.1553916633,
-0.8821818233,
-0.0740114599,
-0.1870928556,
-0.0166966598,
-0.1568574458,
-0.2857297063,
-0.0147675974,
-0.9300527573,
0.2261777073,
-0.1522413939,
0.775645256,
0.5706314445,
-0.1287964284,
-0.0558402464,
-0.464597702,
0.7560044527,
-0.7579601407,
0.2994596362,
0.3919681013,
0.0821048766,
-0.3732882738,
-0.8374720812,
-0.3852138221,
-0.2699557543,
0.1132664084,
-0.3298478127,
-0.2269298583,
0.1096664667,
0.3713929951,
0.4082496166,
-0.6547300816,
0.0701693296,
-0.1166234389,
0.0236967616,
0.184973985,
0.0777567625,
-0.1458920538,
0.2178933322,
-0.1231036708,
0.1003266871,
-0.9745190144,
-0.2923053801,
0.0027595253,
0.2135744393,
-0.0478633232,
0.543898344,
-0.2592737079,
0.7248289585,
0.1604391187,
-0.2067835629,
0.1208689138,
-0.3139440417,
-0.4185053408,
-0.0329058953,
0.652289927,
-0.1855447143,
0.3709348738,
-0.224224776,
-0.2072342336,
0.2396617234,
0.2142572105,
-0.9818868637,
-0.1330050677,
-0.1220260486,
-0.1331633478,
-0.216896981,
-0.4329514503,
-0.4540835619,
-0.4614103138,
-0.2312635034,
0.4154447913,
-0.2112414092,
-0.3505214751,
0.5822729468,
0.368270278,
0.0387798771,
0.2661821842,
-1.028293848,
0.66344136,
0.9300982356,
0.8881127834,
-0.0001122661,
-0.2309794724,
-0.5863322616,
0.0926297903,
-0.5811915994,
0.6327139735,
-0.2738022804,
-0.1286544204,
-0.2285351902,
-0.2790479362,
0.0734128579,
-0.6272375584,
0.3403422534,
-0.4830221534,
-0.3420644403,
-0.0375825912,
-0.1652973145,
0.186909914,
0.410384357,
-0.5088818669,
1.3333939314,
0.0613942891,
-0.4692518711,
0.1388201565,
-0.3602356315,
-0.4950398207,
-0.0077728033,
0.0408636928,
-0.3329546452,
0.4506651163,
0.1794892251,
0.6902880669,
-0.3918303847,
0.4986647964,
-0.2024664283,
-0.8208324909,
0.1663938463,
-0.5182940364,
0.469909966,
0.0678556263,
-0.4656932056,
-0.1442338228,
-1.0144084692,
-0.0753417611,
0.0717006251,
-0.3431856334,
-0.2895574272,
-0.1055527255,
-0.1882162094,
-0.0246004425,
0.3351088166,
-0.1319751441,
0.142929554,
-0.8048058748,
0.3690255582,
0.7628316879,
-0.3890534639,
0.3365412951,
-0.0603552237,
0.3832688928,
-0.3848259449,
-0.0603024215,
-0.0408651568,
-0.3263387084,
-0.9333081245,
-0.5744211674,
0.376234889,
0.4006394148,
-0.4345133007,
0.6576464772,
-0.5960509181,
-0.3386092186,
-0.4884956181,
0.472699374,
0.5394441485,
0.414572984,
0.3116902709,
-0.2324454188,
-0.4845355451,
-0.675022006,
-0.018045187,
0.1852963716,
-0.1353324503,
0.0110973269,
0.3454855382,
-0.2749095559,
0.7238217592,
-0.4933314323,
-0.1776497662,
-0.1330839097,
0.1448829174,
0.5126784444,
0.6916921735,
0.3079454601,
-0.5513839722,
-0.2654679716,
-0.0253305957,
-0.5273268819,
-0.3430519998,
0.1373047531,
-0.386211127,
-0.0668983757,
0.2328065038,
-0.8623166084,
0.3874400854,
0.6006326675,
-0.1181477159,
0.2524830401,
-0.1100833863,
-0.1838801652,
-1.0827288628,
0.097410731,
0.0672180727,
-0.3114029467,
-0.6368690729,
0.0192050375,
-0.1134478524,
-0.0965976864,
-0.1737982482,
0.3528758287,
-0.4297156632,
-0.3027331829,
-0.4237779379,
0.0543489456,
0.0502633788,
0.5585029125,
0.1001715511,
0.9826536179,
0.2715753019,
-0.6461430788,
-0.0482118391,
0.1145488396,
-0.321728617,
0.1888875216,
-0.9262959361,
0.0519640855,
0.0654914454,
0.1850605309,
-0.8123745918,
-0.0917915255,
-0.0517993644,
-0.339971453,
0.2927611768,
-0.1676602215,
-0.6569479108,
-0.0498246886,
-0.294940263,
0.320518136,
0.7301756144,
-0.4979209006,
0.5671352148,
0.3627246916,
-0.1467809379,
-1.071497798,
-0.6910223365,
0.1889334917,
-0.0574060082,
-0.5646916032,
0.3161337376,
0.024157552,
-0.1322690099,
-0.2106701285,
-0.1508761793,
-0.21374394,
0.6162108183,
0.2211007327,
0.1297143102,
-0.4408091009,
-0.0028682672,
0.083083123,
-0.2903994918,
-0.1617328376,
-0.2174627632,
0.6084321737,
-0.4034392834,
-0.0496899225,
-0.2406548709,
0.0845117196,
0.2598366737,
-0.1931858063,
0.7945879698,
0.6039666533,
-0.6706455946,
-0.2338561267,
-0.9181393385,
0.0242452491,
-0.4907647073,
0.4658575654,
-0.3686616421,
-1.1328896284,
0.0521194264,
-0.2568023205,
0.0728752688,
0.257874161,
0.6955331564,
0.1283487976,
0.9156042337,
0.9240728617,
-0.1541466117,
0.4093604088,
-0.4098806679,
0.0380590186,
-0.6043490171,
0.1256251782,
-0.6028610468,
-0.0513203144,
-0.1059742719,
-0.6193748116,
0.3159096539,
0.4260382056,
-0.4570633471,
0.2967922091,
-0.5154877901,
0.7250546217,
0.3132669628,
0.0249982513,
0.3550711572,
0.3087886274,
0.2016363144,
-0.0001033846,
-0.7620655894,
-0.5536879897,
1.0016748905,
0.2261000872,
0.7470671535,
-0.0071776868,
0.376766026,
0.0974627733,
0.6150808334,
-0.5457833409,
0.5690225363,
-0.2796562016,
-0.3091165125,
-0.2082891166,
-0.429089874,
-0.8378856182,
0.4819122255,
-0.4358198345,
-0.5498476028,
-0.0184468199,
0.354580462,
-0.5439145565,
0.0252900608,
-0.5596563816,
0.8529564142,
-0.0760043561,
-0.5191130042,
-0.4780650139,
-0.5738894939,
0.5959869027,
-0.1340785921,
0.0958269015,
-0.3761807382,
-0.2827688754,
0.5431516767,
-0.5817701817,
1.0071491003,
-0.0596105568,
-0.1577812582,
0.1621683985,
0.2004704773,
0.5410431027,
0.0789007992,
-0.0920518041,
0.3188223541,
-0.2643643618,
-0.4536952078,
-0.5966334939,
0.8664654493,
-0.8260747194,
-0.5925272703,
-0.2283837199,
-0.5514823198,
-0.4524929821,
0.012186883,
-0.1577497125,
0.2014293224,
-0.1142015606,
0.3538622558,
0.988696754,
-0.0892850086,
0.1459199935,
0.4750489593,
0.2469731867,
-0.5287175179,
0.8879969716,
0.1358553022,
0.1498399079,
0.3545117378,
0.0888696685,
-0.089307256,
-0.7773489952,
-0.4866573513,
0.2819924057,
-0.4011663795,
-0.4595314562,
-0.6025645733,
-0.1555832773,
-0.3574047685,
-0.3542462289,
-0.5979237556,
-0.5705246329,
-0.471257031,
0.0096279085,
0.3095912039,
0.6502360106,
-0.1176531389,
0.8709847927,
-0.6422260404,
0.4390981197,
0.2319979966,
0.3070546389,
0.0845202282,
-0.6986038089,
-0.4402771592,
-0.0259762947,
-0.2890663445,
-0.4301185608,
0.5077655315,
0.3662376404,
0.1563982069,
0.1783283949,
-0.390512526,
1.2165366411,
-0.4644403756,
0.5509363413,
0.1684472561,
-1.0362607241,
0.4437482357,
-0.1717023849,
0.1163635477,
0.5716281533,
0.4252660573,
-0.2412942797,
-0.0028775639,
-0.3684413135,
-0.7353154421,
0.3846947551,
0.1704621017,
0.2089540064,
-0.0651362464,
0.654936254,
0.1179950908,
0.3804497719,
-0.7413950562,
0.0888660252,
-0.225851208,
-0.4713183641,
-0.1618986577,
-0.436329633,
-0.1416573226,
-0.1413178146,
0.7351979017,
-0.4078240693,
-0.085807316,
-0.0395305529,
-0.37381652,
0.0076115285,
0.1737621576,
0.4143332541,
0.5550236702,
-0.0809771568,
0.1892361045,
0.3686100543,
-0.5515365601,
0.233499825,
0.262411952,
0.0259990264,
-0.2164750695,
0.2990734279,
0.6869626641,
0.5870747566,
-0.8009915352,
0.7460843325,
-0.1015714332,
0.0308857262,
-0.1899748892,
0.0017510148,
0.0542288497,
0.2361479551,
0.342338711,
0.0388044193,
0.0052368199,
-0.0906324387,
-0.1031617522,
0.5592918396,
0.1850653291,
-0.3267365098,
0.6558207273,
0.0334058478,
0.0983696729,
0.5331706405,
0.0944993645,
-0.1457482576,
0.4967072308,
0.7645699978,
0.6113106012,
0.0229408611,
-0.068959944,
0.2646099031,
0.3266117275,
-0.5189811587,
-0.0017963663,
-0.3397015333,
-0.6994946003,
-0.9519894123,
-0.9391070604,
-0.21274665,
0.0504296571,
-0.3860708773,
0.0304217823,
-0.787129581,
-0.1702173501,
-0.335937649,
0.1564524472,
-0.4120263755,
0.1622150391,
0.2043012232,
0.8627554178,
-0.6426447034,
0.7875378728,
0.1902497113,
0.0135214906,
-0.7383580208,
-0.3244467676,
-0.4000733197,
-0.9423361421,
0.5411909819,
0.2462191433,
-0.1915518194,
0.1698120385,
-0.7312426567,
-1.0765126944,
1.0422894955,
0.8276364207,
-0.7420970798,
-0.0941472277,
0.1135293543,
0.5667397976,
-0.0962154791,
0.1475836039,
0.75535357,
0.1259821206,
0.01360483,
-0.8983306885,
0.1207955778,
-0.1844294369,
0.2860470414,
0.1751021594,
-0.5603742599,
0.8292793632,
-0.0820749775,
-0.1233589724,
0.4781607687,
0.8759559989,
0.68910712,
-0.0280894414,
0.4685875475,
0.871797204,
0.8634786606,
-0.0947659835,
0.9913648963,
-0.4635539949,
0.0374516211,
0.8355748057,
-0.2745597959,
0.8807424903,
0.4308218956,
-0.0610521026,
0.3636532426,
0.4046969712,
0.2742660642,
0.4029314816,
0.4984750152,
-0.428429544,
-0.401152283,
-0.309548527,
-0.3629202247,
0.0450082198,
0.6731092334,
0.0445715338,
0.0344260782,
-0.050953377,
0.1905401051,
0.0921863988,
-0.5457262993,
0.5841804743,
0.1796691865,
-0.521586895,
1.1093883514,
0.1460285932,
1.0960965157,
-0.8887934685,
-0.094366774,
-0.3278994858,
0.2726272047,
-0.198562786,
-0.3417865038,
0.2490536422,
0.2269090563,
0.0059708226,
-0.1936661452,
0.9221368432,
-0.1992686093,
-0.4773397148,
0.0191519596,
0.4230398536,
0.080727838,
-0.2441241145,
-0.5006597638,
0.3575390875,
-0.3736184835,
-0.471180588,
0.5383762717,
0.4467840493,
-0.139986068,
0.718509078,
0.7899162173,
0.2525739074,
0.4730898142,
-0.0451622866,
1.114536047,
-0.4626600444,
-0.2672560215,
-0.7862023711,
0.251724869,
0.1856014729,
-0.4090804458,
0.552575469,
0.4817957282,
0.6584614515,
0.1572158635,
0.4263516068,
0.1130139753,
0.2642405033,
-0.5422250032,
0.4107717276,
-0.3813077509,
0.3841916621,
-0.1711805165,
-0.8177964687,
-0.4992787242,
0.9185292125,
-0.0173319783,
-0.0612051412,
0.2878379226,
1.071033597,
-0.0780210122,
-0.233645469,
0.3535422683,
0.3822700381,
0.0348998494,
0.7090514898,
0.8350915909,
-0.4900867343,
0.6699176431,
-0.3664546013,
-0.2290074825,
0.0665175915,
-0.8607279658,
-0.7809557915,
-0.1108468771,
-0.1472803354,
-0.4101205468,
0.3555207849,
1.0069533587,
0.9408749342,
-0.5282582045,
-0.3634299636,
-0.3328878582,
0.0303359795,
-0.0677787662,
-0.1795881689,
0.2600211501,
-0.3683879673,
-0.4918754697,
0.6089556813,
0.2920068204,
0.1123813465,
-0.2986164689,
-0.1778586507,
0.0085193776,
-0.013920241,
0.6645482183,
0.3774357438,
-0.5671026111,
0.1336974204,
-0.1973787546,
-0.0984734967,
0.0551802367,
0.7926550508,
-1.1110918522,
-0.2735372782,
0.1286702454,
1.0873949528,
0.6639214754,
0.02205039,
0.4512216747,
-0.9844164848,
0.4826123118,
0.2472264022,
0.3182778955,
0.3477226794,
-0.3136515915,
0.6496165991,
0.3289653957,
-0.4719064534,
-1.1216863394,
-0.0954079777,
-0.9391012192,
-0.1112270206,
1.0290529728,
-0.1475568414,
-0.3436636627,
0.1583410054,
-0.1196885854,
0.082072705,
-0.2109509706,
0.6258172393,
0.3411491215,
0.2318637371,
-0.0740814209,
-0.4243596494,
0.3085429966,
0.6799940467,
-0.7190887332,
0.2162729949,
0.5283966064,
0.2972867787,
-0.0987517312,
1.0390737057,
0.0369327441,
0.249633342,
-0.0090930909,
0.1029702947,
-0.1452072561,
-0.438559413,
-0.4557057917,
0.3218343258,
0.1734892875,
0.3097676039
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03553v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03553v2
|
AlphaMath Almost Zero: process Supervision without process
| 2024-05-06T15:20:30 | 2024-05-23T05:07:24 |
Guoxin Chen, Minpeng Liao, Chengxi Li, Kai Fan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Recent advancements in large language models (LLMs) have substantially
enhanced their mathematical reasoning abilities. However, these models still
struggle with complex problems that require multiple reasoning steps,
frequently leading to logical or numerical errors. While numerical mistakes can
be largely addressed by integrating a code interpreter, identifying logical
errors within intermediate steps is more challenging. Moreover, manually
annotating these steps for training is not only expensive but also
labor-intensive, requiring the expertise of professional annotators. In our
study, we introduce an innovative approach that bypasses the need for process
annotations (from human or GPTs) by utilizing the Monte Carlo Tree Search
(MCTS) framework. This technique automatically generates both the process
supervision and the step-level evaluation signals. Our method iteratively
trains the policy and value models, leveraging the capabilities of a
well-pretrained LLM to progressively enhance its mathematical reasoning skills.
Furthermore, we propose an efficient inference strategy-step-level beam search,
where the value model is crafted to assist the policy model (i.e., LLM) in
navigating more effective reasoning paths, rather than solely relying on prior
probabilities. The experimental results on both in-domain and out-of-domain
datasets demonstrate that even without GPT-4 or human-annotated process
supervision, our AlphaMath framework achieves comparable or superior results to
previous state-of-the-art methods.
|
[
-0.3697084188,
-0.7896937728,
0.9887735248,
-0.0868592933,
0.0082562212,
0.0895698667,
0.0153546315,
-0.1217419729,
-0.0282160714,
0.5128208399,
-0.8838711977,
-0.6197544932,
-0.5162391067,
-0.2835793197,
-0.0538595468,
0.8654538989,
-0.2503003776,
0.0667180717,
-0.0113102729,
0.2873165607,
-0.0825852081,
-0.3351063132,
-0.7435972691,
-0.609521091,
0.2410423905,
0.4508537352,
0.8901141286,
0.6582885981,
0.5244663954,
0.1729689538,
0.0388494432,
0.1868526191,
-0.0624380782,
0.0459099375,
-0.2792710662,
-0.2756096125,
-0.6526350975,
0.1460232586,
0.2921049893,
0.6948527098,
-0.2695273459,
0.0873852968,
-0.4469548464,
0.6216987371,
-0.6820472479,
0.6780539155,
-0.6031062603,
0.256339103,
-0.0111573394,
-0.4337181151,
-0.4751106203,
-0.4113146365,
-0.1706038564,
-0.7282010913,
0.1139401793,
0.0807336494,
0.7248533368,
0.3026405275,
-0.2482922673,
-0.4042770267,
-0.6021757722,
0.8433127403,
-0.7254841924,
0.0575940572,
0.6777989268,
0.4920060933,
-0.2808297276,
-0.3610277772,
-0.2985946536,
-0.2219454348,
0.0300476458,
0.1315189004,
-0.0523725562,
0.603469193,
0.5969278216,
0.0441358835,
-0.1730748117,
-0.2117401361,
-0.2087423503,
-0.2429902554,
0.5877415538,
0.0191651899,
0.1074603125,
-0.1273226887,
0.1016193405,
-0.2687974274,
-0.7001024485,
-0.1225503534,
0.2410223335,
0.3313291967,
0.334877491,
0.7189438343,
-0.2531567812,
0.303971976,
-0.3430086672,
-0.1607686579,
0.2539153993,
-0.1834778637,
-0.2793122828,
0.2117351145,
0.6906231046,
-0.1384002864,
0.6720507145,
-0.0557564907,
-0.447999835,
0.2764999866,
0.2908554971,
-0.747433424,
-0.3582268953,
0.1022186056,
0.096430324,
-0.1820784509,
-0.1919115186,
-0.4249660373,
-0.1912298352,
-0.3701967001,
0.434176892,
-0.5398602486,
-0.0959225297,
-0.0701657906,
0.1802804917,
0.0705960691,
0.6018701792,
-0.7665748596,
0.3277907073,
0.6360497475,
0.8992645741,
0.080919221,
0.128336519,
-0.6167857647,
-0.0183986593,
-0.7500585318,
0.5700583458,
-0.6850099564,
-0.3510764837,
-0.2059707493,
-0.3007241189,
-0.064423047,
-0.2800980508,
0.6890235543,
-0.5355945826,
-0.0951724574,
0.0297838431,
-0.4626094699,
-0.3041933775,
0.3788045049,
-0.3305825293,
0.8863335252,
0.1745702475,
-0.4930517375,
0.2959549129,
-1.2586100101,
-0.2018865645,
-0.0881336555,
-0.4162891209,
-0.6696608067,
0.1076788753,
0.6156753302,
0.3583780229,
-0.0697009638,
0.4108662605,
-0.6575722694,
-0.4792530537,
-0.0153645705,
-0.4306447506,
0.7659661174,
0.1336603612,
-0.532212615,
0.162172243,
-0.7283351421,
0.2042911649,
0.0551110208,
0.1606582105,
-0.1786231399,
0.1161036491,
-0.3710598946,
0.5643567443,
-0.141941309,
-0.551255703,
0.420645237,
-0.341576755,
0.287433207,
0.8646788597,
0.3247048557,
0.4889319241,
-0.163864255,
0.8753308654,
0.0424859338,
0.169756487,
-0.6149738431,
-0.6624691486,
-0.6206874847,
-0.3408710659,
-0.0541914776,
0.6519038081,
-0.8559836745,
0.0042142328,
-0.015213591,
-0.2948585451,
-0.6567528844,
0.1625163108,
0.5184828639,
0.4554486275,
0.443103075,
-0.259784013,
-0.5065072775,
-0.730625689,
-0.0186375529,
-0.2023766637,
0.0329822004,
0.1613430083,
0.6056290269,
-0.2085263133,
1.0091243982,
-0.4832077324,
-0.4081827998,
0.0900260732,
0.3438024223,
0.5273073316,
0.5177722573,
-0.0766673163,
-0.3093796074,
-0.2200271785,
-0.0266227089,
-1.0276488066,
-0.1591648459,
-0.131532982,
-0.277631253,
0.163943857,
0.6580249071,
-0.5783650875,
0.6331036091,
0.2294390053,
-0.1145622134,
0.3462865055,
-0.3479855061,
-0.0114537058,
-0.5225010514,
0.0891238973,
0.2412673384,
-0.2446667254,
-0.4694106877,
0.0480251759,
0.1261754334,
-0.1868731081,
-0.4500194192,
0.5466375351,
-0.5769281387,
-0.2433325648,
-0.1126183942,
-0.0199498758,
-0.1905301809,
0.8045479059,
0.1864488423,
0.8892608881,
0.6775563955,
-0.37065956,
0.0541966744,
0.0927926749,
-0.0508243367,
0.6119763255,
-0.284180522,
-0.0142282238,
-0.1710614115,
0.1942058653,
-0.8404276967,
0.0518097878,
0.4654970169,
-0.4419751763,
0.2621745765,
-0.4536217749,
-0.6300691366,
-0.2150078714,
-0.3919711113,
0.1789931804,
0.6338111758,
-0.1814520955,
0.6129882336,
0.1870285124,
-0.0934335291,
-0.4154474735,
-0.5975641608,
0.0360086486,
-0.0081551522,
-0.3235629797,
-0.2501429915,
0.0717893243,
-0.2950239778,
-0.0919184834,
-0.4880101979,
-0.189637199,
0.2661192417,
0.4371981323,
0.3231960833,
-0.2621376514,
-0.2054894865,
0.1870950907,
-0.4819281995,
0.3488125801,
-0.3265411258,
0.1319030225,
-0.1595895737,
-0.915789187,
-0.5013496876,
-0.0721771345,
0.4947107434,
-0.2339141369,
0.44475618,
0.3382179439,
-0.3685446382,
-0.3196549416,
-0.3016340435,
-0.3273902237,
-0.4605716467,
0.0511903353,
-0.4126964509,
-0.6326649189,
0.2483761609,
-0.2167333066,
0.3741295338,
0.2860815227,
0.3061889708,
-0.1019146815,
1.5093659163,
0.4413864315,
0.3022830188,
0.3950752318,
-0.374674052,
0.4449442923,
-0.8419347405,
-0.214979127,
-0.1679624766,
0.0902635604,
-0.400904566,
-0.6706851721,
0.5605176687,
0.0286619477,
-0.3407127857,
0.144992888,
-0.493363589,
0.556004107,
0.4713312387,
-0.0538430698,
0.5692076683,
0.0155054219,
-0.3327729702,
-0.1652101427,
-0.751085639,
-0.5610957146,
1.3040566444,
0.3864373267,
0.7249088287,
-0.1397964656,
0.8189801574,
0.2003941238,
0.7874651551,
-0.764849484,
0.5577856898,
0.4238203168,
-0.7375653386,
-0.3522154689,
-0.7544130683,
-0.6834152341,
0.5073073506,
-0.0036564206,
-0.8338214755,
-0.1445412487,
0.2825291455,
-0.48121503,
0.3519181907,
-0.6508827806,
0.8124884367,
-0.1640117019,
-0.4845866263,
-0.034322761,
-0.4000543952,
0.7003474236,
-0.45179528,
0.7623889446,
-0.4603802264,
0.0524281114,
0.4875819385,
-0.5433801413,
0.5180830956,
-0.4124995172,
0.0062569859,
0.3067654967,
0.4510103464,
0.5227516294,
0.1904041767,
-0.1287146956,
0.0319427624,
-0.1488513499,
-0.46278736,
-0.5070781708,
0.4959638119,
-0.5498831272,
-0.5029622912,
-0.9463756084,
-0.6994125843,
-0.4754513204,
0.2030686885,
-0.3008263707,
0.0915811881,
0.0937494114,
-0.2061515898,
0.7125796676,
-0.0065184915,
0.6508148313,
0.4108948112,
-0.506311655,
-0.1707582623,
0.7170237899,
0.0705587566,
0.2176363021,
0.0814672485,
0.0037882493,
-0.2894107103,
-0.4720655084,
-0.4602176845,
0.2516418695,
-0.6752224565,
-0.1672786772,
-0.6159476638,
-0.3270192742,
-0.0163041539,
-0.3512902558,
-0.5500884652,
-0.3679315746,
-0.0212703981,
-0.1571175456,
0.2827555239,
0.5336062312,
-0.1345490515,
0.451028496,
-0.496696949,
0.426471442,
0.1665803194,
0.3664439321,
0.0222783834,
-0.4509118199,
-0.2545107305,
0.2136700302,
-0.4925771654,
-0.6524460316,
0.5367856622,
0.1378582567,
0.5041455626,
0.4087218344,
-0.0153946467,
0.8069400191,
-0.5554007888,
0.2898577452,
0.1209581196,
-1.1274738312,
0.6723970175,
-0.380789876,
0.4357859194,
0.694606781,
0.4077883959,
-0.1738723516,
-0.6093041301,
-0.8865850568,
-0.969350934,
1.1689298153,
0.6381773949,
-0.2101832628,
-0.0534809865,
0.1317195892,
-0.4429474473,
0.3581664264,
-0.3904437721,
-0.0477021001,
0.0119143222,
0.0269040745,
-0.0105737345,
0.1786314696,
-0.1455177665,
-0.3108988404,
1.0918403864,
-0.3132858574,
0.1306930333,
0.0848263055,
-0.2016008347,
-0.4003931284,
0.1069269776,
0.3792508543,
0.9530857801,
-0.4497639239,
0.2313523144,
0.2503813207,
-0.1487028003,
0.2873591781,
0.0459468886,
-0.117176272,
0.1788297296,
0.3558842838,
0.6229071617,
0.5070000291,
-0.7742653489,
0.4668494463,
0.0216335114,
-0.3683110476,
-0.4814792275,
0.0721867383,
0.0938857421,
0.2091946006,
0.4315279722,
0.0727069825,
0.0236500781,
-0.5432855487,
0.6224789619,
0.5120173693,
-0.5103952885,
-0.1232489422,
0.7313317657,
-0.2745179832,
-0.220660001,
0.6937987208,
-0.4118115604,
-0.2906963825,
0.5694779158,
0.0905438066,
0.6755882502,
-0.2625568211,
0.3409351707,
0.2744778991,
0.4751227796,
-0.3818298578,
0.1573287249,
-0.1183488294,
-0.5176344514,
-0.8031103611,
-0.5631773472,
-0.9030077457,
-0.1850155443,
-0.5431784391,
0.3277532458,
-0.8798940182,
-0.0836609155,
0.0539577603,
0.1434952766,
-0.3821182549,
0.2593902647,
0.2268051952,
0.6825429201,
-1.0087444782,
0.9874179363,
0.5172513127,
-0.5756670833,
-0.6986920238,
-0.3440410197,
0.2709292471,
-1.0671406984,
0.4080877602,
0.1457465142,
-0.1024091169,
-0.0254473835,
-0.3328888416,
-0.7851211429,
0.9451192021,
0.5397487879,
-0.6221570969,
-0.1960718483,
-0.1062046736,
0.5489726067,
-0.1639960557,
0.8633524776,
0.6725882292,
0.4926452637,
0.7438593507,
-0.7969881296,
-0.1337790638,
-0.1063738987,
-0.0291311834,
0.4209805727,
-0.0392965749,
0.7439332008,
-0.2653643489,
-0.0605308078,
-0.4287753105,
0.4553377628,
0.7174996734,
0.4397875667,
0.2828939259,
0.604807198,
0.5909939408,
-0.0571153611,
0.9177876711,
-0.386592865,
0.5578303933,
1.122623086,
-0.3133754432,
0.4944834113,
0.5376349688,
-0.1092061996,
0.2137004137,
0.624972105,
0.152543202,
0.2780361474,
0.4233097136,
-0.109178938,
-0.4841675162,
0.1017430276,
-0.0542696826,
-0.0480731651,
0.4413767457,
-0.2682192028,
-0.6772642136,
-0.2318413854,
0.5640999675,
0.0357533805,
-0.4519279599,
0.5662075281,
0.4552368522,
-0.599481225,
0.4289055467,
-0.0029978119,
0.4478714764,
-0.7573352456,
-0.2677463889,
-0.2637905777,
0.2928109765,
-0.3293428123,
-0.750420332,
0.5290527344,
0.0725429878,
0.3856630027,
-0.7070804834,
0.1750553101,
-0.2380074114,
-0.7209166288,
0.2656691968,
0.5886369944,
0.20092538,
-0.2973051369,
-0.8420663476,
-0.1252114922,
-0.1775607169,
-0.5531234145,
0.2129777819,
0.6408008933,
-0.5189403296,
0.7920002937,
0.8851079941,
0.2018626183,
-0.0831836537,
-0.1073393375,
0.7262483239,
-0.7027055025,
-0.2709801197,
-1.1194849014,
0.2396364808,
-0.0147960261,
-0.088712126,
0.7195186615,
0.4991466999,
0.6692534089,
0.3257006407,
0.7222944498,
0.2899862528,
0.2751626968,
-0.3958874941,
0.4800368547,
-0.2937942147,
0.5084522963,
-0.5110861063,
-1.2269877195,
-0.640806973,
0.9985627532,
-0.5468963385,
0.088803716,
0.9056300521,
0.8180767894,
-0.3821871877,
-0.0747225136,
0.414373517,
0.0492610708,
0.6082264185,
0.754791975,
0.5205156803,
-0.1754928827,
0.4167868495,
-0.1672763675,
-0.2483746707,
-0.0233370829,
-0.9667708874,
-0.9000031948,
-0.0326777063,
-0.4116709828,
-0.2998180389,
0.1910905242,
1.0608811378,
0.7710880637,
-0.8795059919,
-0.403121531,
-0.4706368744,
0.1621819437,
-0.1033622995,
-0.1475258917,
0.2743938565,
-0.5588726401,
-0.4119130671,
0.49492383,
0.3514168561,
-0.2169162929,
-0.3551590145,
-0.0935817584,
-0.2951635122,
0.372892648,
0.2895450592,
0.3409127295,
-0.5529646873,
-0.1067372337,
-0.1724488288,
-0.0084951306,
0.3269953132,
0.6328372955,
-0.6632885933,
0.626144588,
0.0807248726,
0.5494735837,
1.039586544,
-0.1335507929,
0.503565073,
-0.4996824563,
0.0476668775,
0.4424058199,
0.301610738,
0.1982838213,
-0.0804704428,
0.7640811205,
0.2651335597,
-0.3148318231,
-0.8902705908,
0.2174241841,
-0.7206499577,
-0.0580073185,
1.00661695,
-0.3747107387,
-0.3327125013,
-0.03360603,
-0.2512419224,
0.2538738847,
-0.6831865907,
0.6893904805,
0.714356482,
-0.4299381971,
-0.3872042298,
-1.030148983,
0.496866852,
0.4145497084,
-0.8989707828,
-0.1280562282,
0.4086225927,
0.0250729453,
0.0963445678,
0.8709741831,
-0.1921189874,
0.2182057649,
-0.1146516129,
0.3138800859,
-0.3470239341,
-0.3865535855,
-0.4954870045,
0.3125852346,
0.1678220481,
-0.0420560353
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03548v4
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03548v4
|
MAmmoTH2: Scaling Instructions from the Web
| 2024-05-06T15:11:38 | 2024-05-23T16:34:35 |
Xiang Yue, Tuney Zheng, Ge Zhang, Wenhu Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Instruction tuning improves the reasoning abilities of large language models
(LLMs), with data quality and scalability being the crucial factors. Most
instruction tuning data come from human crowd-sourcing or GPT-4 distillation.
We propose a paradigm to efficiently harvest 10 million naturally existing
instruction data from the pre-training web corpus to enhance LLM reasoning. Our
approach involves (1) recalling relevant documents, (2) extracting
instruction-response pairs, and (3) refining the extracted pairs using
open-source LLMs. Fine-tuning base LLMs on this dataset, we build MAmmoTH2
models, which significantly boost performance on reasoning benchmarks. Notably,
MAmmoTH2-7B's (Mistral) performance increases from 11% to 36.7% on MATH and
from 36% to 68.4% on GSM8K without training on any in-domain data. Further
training MAmmoTH2 on public instruction tuning datasets yields MAmmoTH2-Plus,
achieving state-of-the-art performance on several reasoning and chatbot
benchmarks. Our work demonstrates how to harvest large-scale, high-quality
instruction data without costly human annotation or GPT-4 distillation,
providing a new paradigm for building better instruction tuning data.
|
[
-0.4117041826,
-0.7565458417,
0.2889108658,
-0.0674639195,
-0.3700769246,
-0.2879467607,
-0.4143761098,
-0.2859645188,
-0.2240163535,
0.7885409594,
-0.5773737431,
-0.347587347,
-0.7295095325,
-0.0702929869,
-0.1240423694,
0.9032976627,
0.3306266963,
0.1097708642,
-0.4412493706,
0.156314373,
-0.2878890038,
-0.297845304,
-0.558914423,
-0.1520190984,
0.4090059996,
0.7549960017,
0.6360568404,
1.4458252192,
0.4873944819,
0.3127148747,
0.1575475931,
0.671566844,
-0.8545110822,
-0.0965120792,
-0.1584269851,
-0.6781535745,
-0.6619380116,
0.2660535276,
0.5042369366,
0.4073704779,
-0.3102023005,
0.5232878923,
0.1226272881,
0.8757066131,
-0.5505216718,
0.3629049659,
-0.889690876,
-0.3621620834,
-0.3425181806,
-0.2919729054,
-0.570494473,
-0.509806931,
0.0704464689,
-0.928658247,
0.3229193687,
0.093812868,
0.6489331722,
0.5199998021,
-0.1882587224,
-0.6263285279,
-0.4033172131,
0.9669517279,
-0.62932688,
0.2333114743,
0.8529048562,
0.2844049335,
-0.1360567063,
-0.7842223644,
-0.3172818124,
0.0830327868,
0.1041639373,
0.0695062131,
-0.1827968806,
-0.2079703212,
0.4832105041,
0.4998193979,
-0.4427033663,
0.2717682421,
-0.6114048958,
-0.1707793623,
0.543941021,
0.1445516348,
-0.0276341699,
0.1469982713,
-0.1555707604,
-0.3544853628,
-0.9222618341,
-0.1294788271,
0.6101273298,
0.2293087095,
0.0563004725,
0.3558902442,
-0.1541233659,
1.0022605658,
0.1915825009,
-0.2336042672,
-0.0763079002,
-0.0044437586,
-0.1338016838,
0.0048705786,
0.3615913391,
0.4370065033,
0.0099676261,
-0.1366574615,
-0.2117671371,
-0.1723589897,
0.4995159209,
-1.057790041,
-0.4771278203,
0.0822657943,
-0.3840638399,
0.2054359466,
0.0442667268,
-0.9004359245,
-0.4060129225,
-0.746663034,
0.3158683479,
-0.3387323022,
-0.1546640843,
0.1460521221,
-0.2621644139,
0.4449996352,
0.4628840685,
-1.4159464836,
0.2161659449,
1.227011323,
0.6830582619,
-0.1850852221,
0.0313180611,
-0.6890790462,
0.0954345241,
-0.3394892216,
0.8371214271,
-0.5313233733,
-0.3888815045,
0.1444322467,
-0.1435268819,
0.0848521888,
-1.0203361511,
0.62248981,
-0.6940182447,
0.1814340949,
-0.3355452716,
-0.7704910636,
-0.10627684,
0.2557346523,
-0.7755504847,
0.8599163294,
0.0885043219,
-0.5211389661,
0.0922979936,
-0.4887179434,
-0.506485641,
0.0343045928,
0.2073839158,
-0.1803284287,
0.1550863981,
0.3867782056,
0.2874478698,
-0.7442380786,
-0.280552417,
-0.319444865,
-0.3859006464,
-0.1402592957,
-0.4435960054,
0.7266631126,
0.3479409814,
-0.2762760222,
-0.2450705022,
-0.8246886134,
0.3499884605,
-0.0223229211,
-0.7022576928,
-0.216105327,
0.092360571,
-0.5378572941,
-0.1791896522,
0.5176352859,
-0.236204043,
0.429338634,
-0.2165689319,
0.6481460333,
0.7973555326,
-0.4303306043,
0.4924262762,
-0.2567972839,
0.2950794995,
-0.3391810358,
0.1248632818,
-0.2165447026,
-0.4666179121,
-1.065844059,
-0.277327925,
0.1198916659,
0.6554613113,
-0.7470546365,
0.3867520094,
-0.3668241799,
-0.5749360323,
-0.8625551462,
0.3380489945,
0.5328972936,
0.6259308457,
0.5178317428,
0.1098431572,
-0.4376249015,
-0.9028285146,
-0.2368736118,
-0.1160552725,
-0.4586494267,
0.4732292295,
0.0899635702,
-0.1213484108,
0.6503990293,
-0.63996315,
-0.0264081396,
0.1053995416,
0.2907932699,
0.2461867332,
0.3909989297,
-0.070536986,
-0.6259983182,
-0.2403223962,
-0.0080076186,
-0.7244582176,
-0.1410586834,
0.1843894273,
-0.3730401993,
0.1303331852,
0.3662803769,
-0.6285847425,
-0.0968946591,
0.5339794755,
0.1299113035,
0.364947319,
-0.3844254911,
0.0960759744,
-1.0964893103,
-0.3013278544,
-0.1365691721,
0.0115975142,
-0.2598564327,
0.1836134493,
0.2257130742,
0.1735711247,
-0.304197371,
0.2391795218,
-0.7187607288,
-0.0035731222,
-0.3712299466,
0.0905317366,
-0.0055488753,
0.309210211,
-0.1175780073,
1.0709033012,
0.4843393564,
-0.6241294742,
0.5262374878,
0.1352111697,
-0.4786984921,
0.4374824464,
-0.5890213251,
0.6764259934,
0.2811844051,
0.2164669335,
-0.6283251047,
-0.4728659391,
-0.0766632035,
-0.3357036114,
0.3563514352,
-0.4393342435,
-0.5764327645,
-0.4026475549,
-0.2415498197,
-0.1248262897,
0.8155530095,
-0.8844391704,
0.4763389826,
0.6351149678,
0.0077129067,
-0.4524779618,
-0.4214403033,
-0.0534705259,
-0.3037152588,
-0.6285467744,
-0.0510565117,
0.039462354,
-0.2709069848,
-0.1942042261,
-0.2161811739,
-0.2224868983,
0.0436442867,
0.2177595794,
0.2488666326,
-0.3373668194,
0.0733840391,
0.1921932697,
-0.1451952755,
0.2757840455,
-0.8757197857,
0.3073322475,
-0.1169864014,
-0.1163494587,
-0.5776434541,
0.042253226,
0.4041875899,
-0.1095516607,
0.4459625781,
0.7246463895,
-0.2619163096,
-0.2274862081,
-0.6772385836,
-0.3852081001,
-0.5360847116,
0.2666285634,
-0.203964293,
-1.0751675367,
-0.1019168571,
-0.5448500514,
0.3992583454,
0.4964857996,
0.809433043,
-0.1851631403,
1.0468534231,
0.3079429269,
0.0604526103,
0.3434055448,
-0.4233729243,
-0.2295018286,
-0.9218972921,
-0.141408518,
-0.5376563668,
-0.2885422707,
-0.526638329,
-0.8412492871,
0.3412550986,
0.2667040527,
-0.2388148755,
0.3544740677,
-0.7225829363,
0.7284254432,
0.8894393444,
0.0800808445,
0.0256146286,
0.2814882696,
0.2735581994,
0.0702872574,
-0.5057352185,
-0.7966310978,
1.2346355915,
0.0072864527,
0.7575759292,
0.2586353421,
0.3901851177,
0.3207348585,
0.3090586066,
-0.5979581475,
0.4937480986,
-0.3249473274,
-0.6888027191,
-0.3498006761,
-0.6516097784,
-1.0527368784,
0.1691474915,
-0.0791342556,
-0.7071589828,
-0.509355545,
0.5695659518,
-0.2392407358,
0.1933549643,
-1.1442534924,
0.6106068492,
-0.1639713794,
-0.6070899367,
-0.54389745,
-0.6329897642,
0.4470635355,
0.0506012924,
0.1781456769,
-0.1236181706,
-0.0516998097,
0.7467301488,
-0.6332893372,
0.7515559196,
-0.2038625777,
-0.2558699548,
0.6494968534,
0.1207503974,
0.6448579431,
0.1785581857,
-0.1813069284,
0.3793753088,
-0.1715005636,
-0.5710604787,
-0.7306880951,
0.9481253624,
-1.1466400623,
-1.1110221148,
0.0818109512,
-0.6028383374,
-0.2734341323,
0.0464242883,
0.2618979812,
0.4702559412,
0.1414055675,
0.4281771183,
0.8889227509,
0.0411370136,
0.1907213181,
0.5159623027,
0.303722024,
-0.514402926,
1.169549942,
0.1107007787,
0.3181488812,
0.6457256675,
0.3151681721,
-0.4864750206,
-0.4344350398,
-1.0555779934,
0.0001340748,
-0.5309900641,
-0.2388473004,
-0.5155164003,
0.0922050998,
-0.3506729901,
0.0094025442,
-0.3767927885,
-0.5719003677,
-0.5965481997,
-0.0076561421,
0.5525228977,
0.6909908652,
-0.1969302744,
0.4686656296,
-0.973023355,
0.1302587539,
0.7358417511,
0.0584036894,
0.0665671825,
-0.8645114899,
-0.4398004115,
0.3001877367,
-0.3606443703,
-0.4022540748,
0.1473971158,
0.2137522846,
0.2473524362,
0.6414901018,
-0.213028565,
1.0381367207,
-0.7073526978,
0.7620140314,
0.0751812235,
-0.7877790332,
0.5595957041,
-0.3987096548,
0.3511066139,
0.3556442559,
0.4348506629,
-0.1633193791,
0.0776717365,
-0.3304415643,
-0.6685382128,
0.993316412,
0.003354935,
0.2786920965,
0.0139230918,
0.6244343519,
0.3940799534,
-0.0592785366,
0.080713585,
-0.0516584255,
-0.2397888452,
-0.0554559939,
-0.0563335195,
-0.1989471167,
-0.2864542007,
-0.378012687,
0.6851090193,
-0.2181788236,
0.145865798,
-0.3489814997,
-0.2247773707,
-0.0998352468,
-0.1111686379,
0.564330399,
0.7685456872,
-0.0529462695,
0.3652785122,
0.2125018239,
-0.7260748148,
-0.1613790244,
0.0420586541,
-0.0044615832,
-0.5424458385,
0.5619471669,
0.7948304415,
0.0335976817,
-0.6535135508,
0.0794708654,
-0.0939669833,
-0.0764472336,
-0.1443628073,
0.5258911848,
0.4149270356,
0.2125220895,
0.3199264705,
-0.2079301924,
0.1161941066,
-0.2511986196,
0.2098426521,
0.1898873299,
-0.2372056544,
-0.4822553992,
0.6481133103,
0.31669572,
-0.4724242985,
1.0716234446,
-0.2805523574,
-0.0174823236,
0.631614089,
0.8102298379,
0.4038540721,
0.0100966794,
0.0358899757,
0.6919584274,
0.2091728002,
-0.2339429557,
0.0208080374,
-0.1396491528,
-0.5168302655,
-0.4288770258,
-0.615260005,
-0.5720895529,
0.0390129238,
-0.8640480042,
0.087418586,
-0.5619813204,
0.0075398302,
-0.0898655429,
0.1147096157,
-0.5650870204,
-0.0138609195,
0.2971319258,
0.8038151264,
-0.3457074165,
0.9584338069,
0.5537449718,
-0.0374000855,
-0.9406715035,
-0.3300963938,
0.4077328742,
-1.2281837463,
0.3374215662,
0.2813895643,
-0.0881402344,
0.2326848656,
-0.7027314901,
-0.8385766149,
1.2224881649,
0.6063927412,
-0.8087381124,
0.1641146243,
0.0544820838,
0.4105869532,
-0.1460749507,
0.3554399908,
0.8650442362,
0.4133971035,
0.416257143,
-0.5705049038,
-0.1454766393,
-0.2090827674,
-0.1862103641,
0.329863131,
-0.7323815823,
0.9414715171,
-0.2540827394,
-0.1239062473,
0.0070249517,
0.6710763574,
0.2074482143,
0.0337878391,
0.4736416936,
0.9774353504,
1.1751158237,
-0.1375068128,
1.1153316498,
-0.3148917258,
0.1731953174,
1.0776029825,
-0.133422941,
0.8677147627,
0.1254893988,
-0.2183831632,
0.4221563637,
0.8397980332,
0.0808079541,
0.3999530673,
0.335378617,
-0.1887510568,
-0.5609934926,
-0.0127785467,
-0.2993881106,
0.5618952513,
0.6055707335,
-0.0451482013,
-0.2067546993,
-0.4756136537,
0.3480661511,
-0.0380275063,
-0.4007023871,
0.9072552323,
-0.0005507625,
-0.957770288,
0.9616375566,
0.037962772,
0.4422312677,
-0.4543364644,
-0.2911666334,
-0.230520457,
0.3346594572,
-0.0779523253,
-0.4073635936,
0.0788268074,
0.2519990206,
-0.2943279147,
-0.2989701033,
0.4936435819,
-0.2522708476,
-0.4653535187,
-0.0829430297,
0.4937935472,
0.5197248459,
-0.0310472585,
-0.5324673057,
0.0697541609,
0.0623578168,
-0.2550912499,
0.5599384904,
0.7085891962,
-0.0823118091,
0.463870734,
1.0108501911,
-0.098882392,
0.2324053347,
-0.1692105532,
1.0009652376,
-0.328145653,
-0.1342336386,
-0.9438114762,
0.0819147453,
-0.2155982405,
-0.5189678073,
0.6824947596,
0.7481256127,
0.8991010189,
-0.0065010521,
0.4922176301,
0.0024555745,
0.4619411528,
-0.6062868237,
0.4914931059,
-0.3242180049,
0.0965517908,
0.6112321019,
-0.8733915687,
-0.0293526724,
0.4006852806,
-0.3095300496,
-0.2794739008,
0.4442906678,
0.9601665735,
-0.0191176217,
0.2473112047,
0.1197133437,
0.2296442688,
0.2055657208,
0.5442765355,
0.7525314689,
-0.0273883343,
0.6796842217,
0.0546777546,
-0.5717983842,
-0.302680254,
-0.7342503667,
-0.8958185911,
-0.4040473104,
-0.0401320867,
-0.1909676492,
0.1052129939,
0.8892205954,
0.9395682216,
-0.5670021176,
-0.2343233228,
0.1550115347,
0.142401278,
-0.3851191103,
-0.1378101856,
0.4992164373,
-0.509878695,
-0.8705386519,
0.5141307712,
0.2471735328,
-0.4279355705,
-0.1803504676,
-0.2074010223,
0.1772451848,
0.1888061315,
0.7321320176,
0.208703205,
-0.6661080718,
-0.2072817087,
0.0562918298,
-0.1859134585,
0.0733874366,
0.8352099657,
-0.527823627,
0.5408052802,
0.2742315233,
0.9063053131,
0.5814828873,
0.219629094,
0.3559299409,
-0.3810324371,
0.1163692847,
0.0345458426,
0.0358725078,
0.3567290008,
-0.311789602,
0.4920338392,
0.1620263159,
-0.6864216328,
-0.4837203026,
0.1437603682,
-0.8096895218,
-0.132200554,
1.4077256918,
-0.4209724963,
-0.3744216561,
0.1848389655,
-0.0744745508,
0.3362060785,
-0.4030067325,
1.1119294167,
0.6526341438,
-0.1379815787,
0.0728988349,
-0.708404243,
0.3824923933,
0.1826126724,
-0.9842358232,
0.2618874311,
0.7143675685,
0.0956768617,
-0.0233720243,
0.2043667436,
-0.0919051617,
0.1800074428,
0.2853695452,
0.0019242426,
-0.3019996285,
-0.1715141982,
0.0996793211,
0.2075487822,
-0.014748266,
-0.2793984115
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06686v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06686v1
|
Word2World: Generating Stories and Worlds through Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T14:21:52 | 2024-05-06T14:21:52 |
Muhammad U. Nasir, Steven James, Julian Togelius
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have proven their worth across a diverse
spectrum of disciplines. LLMs have shown great potential in Procedural Content
Generation (PCG) as well, but directly generating a level through a pre-trained
LLM is still challenging. This work introduces Word2World, a system that
enables LLMs to procedurally design playable games through stories, without any
task-specific fine-tuning. Word2World leverages the abilities of LLMs to create
diverse content and extract information. Combining these abilities, LLMs can
create a story for the game, design narrative, and place tiles in appropriate
places to create coherent worlds and playable games. We test Word2World with
different LLMs and perform a thorough ablation study to validate each step. We
open-source the code at https://github.com/umair-nasir14/Word2World.
|
[
-0.1957089901,
-0.8005895615,
0.6725879312,
0.3362034261,
-0.3468021452,
0.3313544989,
-0.3657431006,
-0.6561760306,
0.012329476,
0.6654477119,
-0.7774905562,
-0.6717674136,
-0.4336894155,
-0.0583698563,
-0.203449443,
0.744453907,
-0.036850322,
-0.2558259368,
-0.4451532066,
0.1539741755,
-0.4393922091,
-0.1458875239,
-0.4826726317,
-0.5146985054,
0.5483832955,
0.5025338531,
0.6780782342,
0.7611778975,
0.4576430917,
0.2980143428,
0.0027004504,
0.6690197587,
-0.8118572831,
0.5576540828,
-0.1322841644,
-0.3802543879,
-0.1419496983,
-0.0966484174,
0.2776811421,
0.4707892537,
-0.1890074313,
0.2428466231,
0.1414607316,
0.3944378197,
-0.1635872126,
0.1169524789,
-0.5903329849,
0.3186550438,
-0.0484700315,
-0.2706258595,
-0.1436924189,
-0.3506872654,
-0.0380309224,
-0.8860073686,
0.09059266,
0.4060206413,
0.4270110726,
0.0085715689,
-0.1552615315,
-0.8419060111,
-0.9322796464,
0.6079169512,
-0.6674597859,
0.1635774821,
0.1203444153,
-0.0098388242,
-0.4923021793,
-0.6977669597,
-0.8338124156,
-0.1547097415,
0.352232188,
0.1933115721,
-0.0712801442,
0.087269567,
0.4399992526,
0.5073657036,
-0.7407729626,
0.3692136407,
-0.4064698517,
-0.2313539684,
0.6626712084,
0.3890552819,
0.5107559562,
0.0376542844,
-0.2667854726,
0.1257024258,
-1.155056119,
0.0688792616,
0.7233802676,
0.2529553473,
-0.1246239766,
1.0672097206,
0.2489967942,
0.5136152506,
-0.2905385196,
-0.7618898749,
-0.0234558657,
0.0270129181,
0.1184314415,
0.0439028144,
0.7412890792,
0.6034758687,
0.092295669,
-0.3344862461,
-0.315461129,
0.297714144,
0.2827579975,
-0.971152544,
0.0962456092,
0.4856874645,
-0.3915678561,
-0.4090257883,
-0.1558334976,
-0.5446492434,
-0.8048662543,
-0.2559130192,
0.1892792881,
-0.4161601961,
-0.379823029,
0.1730924696,
-0.6462082863,
0.1890870333,
0.1735193431,
-0.8906741738,
0.1831163317,
0.999990046,
1.0485701561,
-0.4170732796,
-0.2048288435,
-0.444948405,
0.4839575589,
-0.6616997719,
0.7574473023,
-0.4187602699,
-0.7884129286,
0.3703092039,
-0.1998229474,
0.8563901782,
-0.6786194444,
0.1330876201,
-0.4655284584,
0.187050581,
-0.2867974043,
-0.7127313614,
0.1787436903,
0.519512713,
-0.283531189,
0.7868559957,
0.1605663747,
-0.5195798278,
0.1443903744,
-0.4815873504,
-0.6349880695,
0.4615436494,
-0.0221251789,
0.1056883261,
0.615191102,
-0.2873794436,
-0.0342022255,
-0.2585054338,
0.1078459099,
-0.0971025229,
-0.4468246102,
-0.1053474024,
-0.0793949664,
0.3744151592,
0.3880262971,
-0.0874463469,
-0.0207249057,
-0.6901345253,
0.18100968,
0.1583871692,
-0.5960322618,
-0.0750861093,
0.4374819398,
0.1289571971,
0.5131368041,
0.2619315982,
-0.8149676919,
0.5574364662,
-0.5032249689,
0.4629764855,
0.3932059407,
-0.0294442512,
0.2949471474,
-0.4751639068,
0.7290217876,
-0.1183391139,
-0.4226557314,
-0.2553587258,
-0.5875175595,
-0.5780957341,
0.0889241174,
0.0883969516,
0.595615983,
-1.0901426077,
0.4498523772,
-0.0630183592,
-0.6772217155,
-0.0999826118,
0.258248806,
0.2564310431,
0.2080060393,
0.0922734812,
-0.3465360403,
-0.7259272337,
-0.5010492206,
-0.0101149455,
-0.3865756989,
-0.4675275981,
0.3761846125,
0.1818894148,
-0.2269580364,
0.8981690407,
-0.6664723754,
-0.2785659432,
-0.5322998762,
0.168636471,
-0.1044809669,
0.2912195623,
0.1403483152,
-0.2606092095,
-0.2910402715,
-0.0135748181,
-0.8576083183,
-0.311879456,
-0.0234485641,
-0.1196041033,
0.0673672408,
0.5232824087,
-0.6656981707,
0.1884993017,
0.7834614515,
-0.2548032105,
0.5760685205,
-0.6036539078,
-0.1858461797,
-1.0657628775,
-0.097005561,
-0.1824883074,
-0.1967170089,
-0.4280512929,
0.360830605,
-0.2885350585,
-0.3877645135,
-0.4404591024,
0.8489499092,
-0.6173449159,
-0.2666343451,
-0.6717061996,
0.2287178785,
0.086731717,
0.2712242305,
0.2803833187,
0.6170965433,
0.4182336032,
-0.5453878641,
0.6282728314,
0.4048140645,
-0.6472620964,
0.3085296154,
-0.6630399823,
0.1369528919,
-0.08276169,
0.325658381,
-0.880435884,
-0.2363420278,
-0.050985761,
-0.3229645193,
-0.0770225823,
0.0661965385,
-0.9392179251,
-0.7560532093,
-0.1201727763,
0.0070464723,
0.9218097329,
-0.5338000059,
0.1811723858,
0.7095487714,
-0.3645470142,
0.0566929691,
-0.9288678169,
0.3297731578,
-0.1658220142,
-0.5922387242,
0.5493600965,
-0.4965565801,
-0.406051755,
-0.2247324586,
-0.0103132948,
0.0578156598,
-0.1177355424,
0.4620611966,
-0.0892533362,
-0.1436848193,
0.1726708859,
0.214747563,
0.1159571037,
0.1504600644,
-0.5007136464,
0.8539168835,
0.2944332063,
-0.2505171001,
0.1315803379,
0.480185926,
0.3881787658,
-0.272598803,
0.4736908972,
0.5172312856,
-0.4611480832,
-0.6283625364,
-0.4038385749,
0.1735109836,
-0.5637591481,
0.4631875753,
-0.2662154734,
-1.1484985352,
0.6070266962,
-0.2776315808,
0.4337566793,
0.1995891333,
0.8288787603,
-0.0423975475,
1.072368741,
0.7423270941,
0.4156110287,
0.0722030625,
-0.0616411977,
0.2713273168,
-0.6617526412,
-0.4105543494,
-0.1038485616,
-0.5358538032,
-0.5428143144,
-0.6821994185,
0.2179139555,
0.2883850038,
-0.1051235795,
0.004253536,
-0.356216073,
0.8804507852,
0.3858417571,
-0.0528595708,
0.3388046324,
0.3400404155,
-0.2980955541,
-0.1680110097,
-0.516025126,
-0.6545086503,
0.8423947692,
0.2699894011,
0.6950538754,
0.3252680302,
0.6850070357,
0.2549960911,
0.0887704417,
-0.8700785637,
0.5591778159,
-0.1977754086,
-0.4986696839,
-0.3669862449,
-0.1460186541,
-0.9127201438,
0.0371672139,
-0.4112171531,
-0.5169322491,
-0.3803776205,
-0.1246988624,
-0.5648511052,
0.4134651423,
-0.1358411014,
0.3927289248,
-0.1734499186,
-0.4976804256,
-0.2416401356,
-0.3106507361,
0.4375603199,
0.0271196943,
0.2815906405,
-0.0937235281,
-0.281983465,
0.2721541822,
-0.5598963499,
0.5973498821,
-0.1611754894,
-0.6590594053,
0.7554321289,
0.7090553641,
0.4042611122,
0.2895081043,
-0.0152475629,
0.1146279126,
-0.2694917917,
-0.0511761792,
-0.1997534484,
0.9704838991,
-0.73040694,
-0.6101080775,
-0.388229996,
-0.997086823,
-0.2956180871,
0.2617525458,
0.2391139567,
0.4665206075,
-0.4755660892,
0.0845945328,
0.6673115492,
-0.6365010142,
0.5091056228,
0.5536091328,
-0.56590873,
-0.135451138,
1.0880166292,
-0.0281625111,
0.1199406683,
0.1107665151,
0.1685093641,
-0.3605201542,
-0.8476934433,
-0.4369134605,
-0.0476079658,
-0.3271036744,
-0.1410178989,
-0.5211339593,
-0.4537784159,
-0.1761147231,
-0.158890903,
-0.1652992815,
-0.2191880643,
-0.1748693883,
-0.2570110261,
0.1282011569,
1.2036137581,
-0.3640243113,
0.3962149322,
-0.8150616288,
0.3809067905,
0.2639207542,
0.478061527,
-0.190889284,
-0.3671309054,
0.0188841,
0.1098397672,
-0.5233306289,
-0.491343677,
0.5823050737,
0.1206371188,
0.2178265452,
0.3989278078,
-0.3065237105,
0.706530571,
-1.0786397457,
1.1609617472,
0.3511670232,
-0.751568377,
0.4358789623,
-0.6541204453,
0.4476649761,
0.234940514,
0.2044842541,
-0.9776872993,
-0.6403996348,
-0.4396238625,
-0.7925671935,
0.682528913,
0.0541912392,
0.3975933492,
-0.271071732,
0.4801811278,
0.4766722023,
0.3327879906,
-0.56378901,
-0.1447175741,
0.0192319024,
-0.1967109591,
-0.138165608,
-0.5097472668,
-0.102783978,
0.1640727371,
0.4523604214,
-0.0911448523,
0.0878233537,
-0.1006177813,
-0.2571322322,
-0.3484106362,
-0.1118238196,
0.740355432,
0.8533113599,
0.1534232646,
0.1653045118,
-0.0299099237,
-0.442104727,
0.1323353946,
-0.1940893233,
-0.1057090983,
-0.1232818812,
0.5113888383,
0.6782650352,
-0.1536147594,
-1.0013532639,
0.4127371609,
-0.138390258,
-0.6519128084,
-0.3392358124,
0.3233636022,
0.5434100628,
0.3301067352,
0.2113782912,
-0.2341377884,
-0.2137579471,
-0.6305109262,
0.0190601051,
0.4183426797,
-0.3341757357,
-0.3043278754,
0.6003885269,
0.3852889538,
-0.5719021559,
0.6962456107,
-0.5827389956,
-0.1989836395,
0.6853474379,
1.0910198689,
0.3817387819,
0.1315407008,
0.3991098106,
0.3939607441,
0.2370618135,
-0.1602764577,
0.4909010828,
0.313921839,
-0.76715976,
-0.4361256659,
-0.8199931383,
-0.4313998222,
0.3943328857,
-0.1456956267,
0.219914034,
-0.7712635994,
0.235889703,
-0.4525563121,
0.2001306415,
-0.4828028083,
0.0068184896,
0.8456034064,
0.893933177,
-0.6603054404,
0.4207774103,
0.6040922403,
-0.1472805738,
-0.6201895475,
-0.0716670081,
0.2300757021,
-0.8357166648,
0.2980358005,
0.1810441464,
0.3304027617,
0.1532819867,
-0.6072614789,
-0.7189827561,
1.2082620859,
0.159017995,
-0.9061180949,
-0.2395572662,
0.6795585752,
0.8071539998,
-0.5814896226,
0.071035102,
0.2400318384,
0.3120933473,
0.4181762934,
-0.5089067817,
-0.1665010452,
-0.0962151811,
0.2910349667,
-0.0946104601,
-0.5545299053,
0.6381043196,
-0.4289571047,
-0.257977128,
0.3806294501,
0.7626127005,
0.7275915146,
-0.0780552477,
0.430687964,
0.777058363,
0.8779726028,
-0.1951701939,
0.9331074953,
-0.5992166996,
0.0002034562,
0.8846099973,
-0.5966962576,
0.6143523455,
0.1584572196,
-0.0149793318,
0.5972755551,
0.7793837786,
-0.0744526014,
0.4983423054,
0.9050368667,
-0.3351606131,
-0.2528488338,
-0.2756778598,
-0.4195827544,
0.4628535211,
0.462821722,
0.0594800897,
-0.3130228817,
0.017263053,
-0.149989143,
0.0790267065,
-0.411329776,
0.7671177387,
0.1299683303,
-0.7160688043,
-0.0195446219,
0.1946288198,
0.841393292,
-0.8235364556,
-0.1690579504,
-0.4482804835,
0.0159506816,
-0.1696159989,
-0.787170589,
0.2463655323,
0.3139094114,
-0.1873277575,
-0.4518491924,
0.6586294174,
-0.8565882444,
-0.7576670051,
0.0649937093,
0.7695665956,
0.269426167,
0.0044017448,
-0.3867524862,
0.2496548444,
-0.119150959,
-0.2365356684,
0.3347087801,
0.7856010795,
0.0266002044,
0.3433915377,
0.7996858358,
0.4472312927,
-0.1835208833,
0.0663058385,
0.5506278276,
-0.6064756513,
-0.6914377809,
-0.7638847232,
0.3856236339,
0.1070712358,
-0.3090466559,
0.6414735913,
0.9869331717,
0.5991455317,
0.0231126156,
0.9867398143,
-0.3279237449,
0.3382335901,
-0.3572234809,
0.7449234724,
-0.4925159514,
0.1947403699,
0.128961578,
-1.2296644449,
-0.246784389,
0.3537096381,
0.3145925701,
-0.2757501304,
0.6505513191,
0.7731636763,
0.0876978636,
-0.0029605536,
0.4085934758,
0.2233962864,
0.5948336124,
0.612942338,
1.0122810602,
-0.0020863998,
0.5589355826,
0.0415446721,
-0.188731879,
0.2940275371,
-1.0563634634,
-1.0754631758,
-0.2673027217,
-0.0899913162,
-0.5290096998,
0.0479420535,
0.7306458354,
0.4410564005,
-0.503639698,
-0.4381704628,
-0.3889841437,
-0.1106984019,
0.1757820994,
-0.1656559706,
-0.0951502249,
-0.2712876797,
-0.7546014786,
0.6114590168,
0.3431882262,
-0.0428038798,
-0.7018550038,
-0.1759894639,
0.3295826912,
0.1301897466,
0.8292880058,
0.1901127547,
-0.5892271996,
-0.3587622344,
-0.1734215021,
-0.279489547,
0.0227935165,
0.9679361582,
-0.6001986861,
0.2296036333,
0.5679488182,
0.4328817725,
0.4128963947,
-0.1679334193,
0.7389881611,
-0.8407073617,
0.3430443108,
0.1856362075,
0.1982078403,
0.35705024,
-0.1895359904,
0.430444926,
0.2165251374,
-0.4106192291,
-0.6894296408,
0.3867194653,
-0.6528782845,
-0.4229125977,
1.6861129999,
-0.0104769934,
-0.2091221511,
0.1440113634,
-0.2892175317,
0.1359074861,
-0.0459886566,
0.6251608133,
1.073330164,
0.0099838721,
0.1744373143,
-0.4921642244,
0.5355046988,
-0.2345707119,
-0.8674937487,
0.1405949742,
0.8042159081,
0.3638008237,
0.1601677984,
0.5712616444,
-0.09480232,
0.0029012829,
0.2066909224,
0.4458995461,
-0.5450482368,
-0.3244411647,
-0.0528907888,
0.2618566155,
0.0371206887,
0.3310472965
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03452v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03452v2
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) as Agents for Augmented Democracy
| 2024-05-06T13:23:57 | 2024-05-07T08:57:18 |
Jairo Gudiño-Rosero, Umberto Grandi, César A. Hidalgo
|
cs.CY
|
cs.CY, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
We explore the capabilities of an augmented democracy system built on
off-the-shelf LLMs fine-tuned on data summarizing individual preferences across
67 policy proposals collected during the 2022 Brazilian presidential elections.
We use a train-test cross-validation setup to estimate the accuracy with which
the LLMs predict both: a subject's individual political choices and the
aggregate preferences of the full sample of participants. At the individual
level, the accuracy of the out of sample predictions lie in the range 69%-76%
and are significantly better at predicting the preferences of liberal and
college educated participants. At the population level, we aggregate
preferences using an adaptation of the Borda score and compare the ranking of
policy proposals obtained from a probabilistic sample of participants and from
data augmented using LLMs. We find that the augmented data predicts the
preferences of the full population of participants better than probabilistic
samples alone when these represent less than 30% to 40% of the total
population. These results indicate that LLMs are potentially useful for the
construction of systems of augmented democracy.
|
[
-0.751984179,
-0.9720033407,
0.6605938673,
0.159781456,
0.0436397456,
0.4106475115,
-0.5613947511,
-0.2305355668,
0.4598860443,
0.8520999551,
0.0945841968,
-0.2253796011,
-0.6835048199,
0.1688688993,
-0.3803264499,
0.8276512623,
0.1376593858,
0.0899698809,
-0.130343914,
0.263173908,
0.0940200165,
-0.4002510905,
-0.4408736527,
-0.6455799341,
0.3975863755,
0.3849624693,
1.0688387156,
0.4725934863,
0.1294252574,
0.268491596,
-0.073253721,
0.4516170919,
-0.4536227584,
-0.2656472623,
-0.3562376201,
-0.3373712301,
-0.6666737199,
0.1905424148,
0.7799666524,
0.6216263175,
-0.0679749846,
-0.0517151505,
0.1897071451,
0.4617749453,
-0.6578784585,
0.2486459911,
-0.6565124989,
-0.2599221766,
0.1226280034,
-0.2832627296,
-0.2495421916,
-0.3044668138,
0.1368520707,
-0.1900039762,
-0.1249516755,
0.0769194961,
0.5063676834,
-0.1003977135,
-0.5479720831,
-0.3658767641,
-0.807926178,
0.4993527532,
-0.5877078772,
0.47104159,
0.6488166451,
0.0837332159,
-0.6062534451,
-0.4448904693,
-0.8886144757,
-0.3568913937,
0.1965308934,
-0.0011244935,
-0.0738164708,
0.4937607348,
0.0378371179,
0.3520572484,
-0.4353160858,
0.2608471215,
-0.4134960175,
-0.1618760377,
0.7453197837,
0.0164087918,
-0.0786624476,
-0.2763416469,
-0.3040889204,
0.2204975635,
-0.803425312,
-0.0605034679,
0.6603475213,
0.5459654331,
-0.1613919437,
0.8459014297,
-0.2868431807,
1.1550456285,
0.1217625737,
-0.2745255232,
-0.0364558883,
-0.1853968352,
-0.4434331656,
-0.3075148463,
1.0201041698,
0.0171993691,
0.3730351925,
-0.0184749253,
-0.5143888593,
0.050066445,
-0.0637860373,
-0.637034297,
-0.2274220586,
0.4244689643,
-0.2653219402,
-0.0857733041,
0.0424166135,
-0.6429953575,
-0.6677794456,
-0.6017343998,
0.5781009793,
-0.0719349608,
-0.1178756282,
0.089591004,
0.2847206891,
-0.0027597032,
0.6088389158,
-0.8948870301,
0.3468938172,
0.8912477493,
0.802459836,
-0.3096333146,
-0.20048289,
-0.6774836183,
0.0099857273,
-0.6079992652,
1.0193613768,
-0.9008811712,
-0.5330511332,
0.3552087843,
-0.0424221009,
0.1911618263,
-0.6952144504,
0.2050699443,
-0.6557607055,
0.2566840649,
-0.2147206515,
-0.5084913969,
0.0920072347,
0.4946692288,
-0.798189044,
0.8491600752,
0.0337195806,
-0.0333587937,
0.5698400736,
-0.5469840169,
-0.2185379565,
-0.1081373841,
-0.2776310146,
-0.1570894867,
-0.0860632211,
0.3298223019,
0.6139950156,
-0.2075214684,
0.4773947895,
-0.5533220768,
-0.4707035124,
0.2674868405,
-0.3015640378,
0.6850176454,
0.1036226377,
-0.0824117139,
0.3471545279,
-0.7133589983,
-0.3459750712,
-0.3599928916,
-0.6712494493,
0.0685948506,
0.1604122669,
0.0049817478,
0.1492283493,
0.5052841902,
-0.6103446484,
0.7180950046,
-0.3699739575,
0.2122853547,
1.1682950258,
-0.1152303144,
0.7997533083,
-0.2954849303,
0.5736420751,
-0.2430356443,
0.0810507014,
0.1306938231,
-0.475812763,
-0.5300832987,
-0.5601806045,
0.4047895074,
0.6052891016,
-0.6862553358,
0.5565621257,
-0.2353492081,
-0.3307246864,
-0.2400861531,
0.1382320672,
-0.2358670384,
-0.0105610341,
-0.2291754782,
0.0556115806,
-0.6560121775,
-0.5937937498,
0.0718565583,
-0.5244939327,
0.1965259165,
0.2420765311,
0.905877471,
-0.281801492,
0.9959978461,
0.0095205298,
-0.1772858053,
-0.1373964399,
-0.2245265394,
0.2666369081,
0.032718543,
0.2336662859,
-0.7818290591,
-0.0653384104,
0.2087179869,
-0.4121856093,
-0.0337706022,
0.1877944916,
0.1999538243,
0.392486155,
0.0403964594,
-0.3890283406,
0.3644878864,
0.926371932,
-0.1827698648,
0.4269952774,
-0.4281288683,
0.3548795879,
-1.2006393671,
-0.2466929704,
-0.0220857132,
-0.4834988415,
-0.1512646377,
-0.2225975543,
-0.258906126,
-0.116139546,
-0.3682385683,
0.8176784515,
-0.3774776161,
-0.4175672531,
-0.5989099145,
0.2882224619,
-0.1275507212,
-0.0071821962,
0.1084594205,
1.0106317997,
0.4014823139,
-0.5470020771,
0.830260098,
0.1744481474,
-0.671659112,
0.4614852965,
-0.7063878179,
0.1939644217,
-0.1487646997,
0.5374144912,
-1.0891056061,
-0.3892174065,
-0.0596595928,
-0.4076018333,
-0.0777501836,
-0.0698590726,
-0.7700746059,
-0.1611208171,
-0.0804357603,
-0.2256005406,
0.3495570123,
-0.6553968191,
0.7933225632,
0.8513721824,
-0.1561874598,
-0.7010683417,
-0.4677196741,
0.2420195192,
-0.0297518242,
-0.3959163427,
-0.0090227993,
0.2060347348,
-0.4571517706,
0.0681763589,
0.5642955303,
0.1897802949,
-0.2791916728,
0.4949228764,
0.1583843976,
0.1048709825,
0.2978858352,
0.01447237,
0.125836581,
-0.3144978881,
-0.2036778778,
0.7195717096,
-0.2544306517,
-0.361610055,
-0.0429633744,
0.2530226707,
0.6248657703,
-0.4253472686,
0.8941428661,
0.3264551759,
-0.5545752048,
-0.072469376,
-0.7338936925,
-0.1293375343,
-0.4266439974,
0.3597277403,
-0.4065209627,
-1.0751075745,
0.8621270061,
-0.2008166462,
0.2226582617,
0.0548929311,
1.1257352829,
0.0888761356,
1.1288106441,
0.5590885878,
-0.2983968556,
0.5439528823,
-0.2563026845,
0.0659683198,
-0.7232818007,
-0.3035992086,
-0.4880629182,
-0.3344319761,
-0.949030757,
-0.4573995769,
0.6632236242,
-0.0725310072,
-0.6657951474,
-0.0517491214,
-0.3964008689,
0.375539273,
0.7472332716,
0.1656721532,
0.3653732538,
0.3305749297,
0.4224458933,
0.2303768694,
-0.5226665139,
-0.8681545258,
1.378180027,
0.0747215971,
0.9252327085,
0.1058680043,
0.8266349435,
0.7726825476,
0.3604633808,
-0.5576623678,
0.573664546,
-0.0417857319,
-0.7418718338,
-0.4134777784,
-0.2447540164,
-1.1030404568,
0.3421165645,
-0.6181868315,
-0.7294976115,
0.4504573345,
0.2200807035,
-0.4781640172,
0.5748096108,
-0.3412200809,
0.5281144381,
-0.3277613521,
-0.4376477301,
-0.2906017303,
-0.357026577,
0.1268105209,
0.0568680204,
0.2311259657,
-0.0963903964,
-0.4209478796,
0.8167234063,
-0.1429218799,
0.6877465248,
-0.073064588,
-0.1222145632,
0.3715970814,
-0.1367257237,
0.7783045769,
0.0524410792,
-0.4885858893,
-0.0109018227,
-0.0644007921,
-0.6057738066,
-0.7033957243,
0.9854034781,
-1.2110632658,
-0.788431406,
-0.6910441518,
-0.6127278209,
-0.1125836745,
0.0256128609,
0.0085707055,
0.2901529968,
-0.4546052217,
0.2044386417,
0.4315441549,
-0.1165778264,
0.2411248833,
0.4799014926,
-0.779671967,
-0.6914345026,
0.748742044,
0.4406481385,
0.2913323641,
0.3601912558,
0.2011954635,
-0.4649689198,
-0.5600605011,
-0.5823165178,
0.1485927701,
-0.3600178361,
-0.0401759259,
-0.4251866341,
0.2205189168,
-0.5558978915,
-0.175582096,
-0.2099291086,
-0.2768545449,
-0.4063204825,
-0.2768585384,
0.319470346,
0.8775823712,
-0.3935816586,
0.4201835096,
-0.2288052291,
0.3584027886,
0.3846021593,
0.273717314,
-0.5485667586,
-0.7011754513,
-0.0556431748,
0.2749073207,
-0.26970613,
-1.0335770845,
0.4077062607,
0.160624221,
0.3280193806,
0.4217916429,
0.0677607208,
0.4824858904,
-0.3500248194,
0.9729599953,
-0.2864652276,
-0.6426334977,
0.4082859159,
-0.4530384243,
-0.1073491946,
0.2782170475,
0.0183467288,
-0.0074797925,
-0.3025041819,
-0.5364489555,
-0.4239244759,
0.4255149662,
-0.3208112717,
0.5236175656,
-0.0385302119,
0.2780119777,
0.0653788522,
0.4046222568,
-0.5417075157,
-0.0228640791,
0.2152398229,
0.132557258,
-0.2358202934,
-0.2737247646,
-0.2677442133,
-0.1522566527,
0.8140737414,
-0.1734164804,
0.1570995748,
0.0912698433,
0.3676835895,
-0.357508868,
0.509057045,
0.7593694925,
1.0572177172,
-0.2428093106,
0.1457757503,
0.106900245,
-0.0052346797,
0.3646551967,
0.191366151,
-0.1950200349,
-0.1635310948,
0.1937130094,
0.8917956352,
-0.4037300646,
-0.7161186337,
0.3477901518,
0.4466073215,
-0.0380810238,
-0.6670714617,
-0.2218007892,
0.0283891298,
0.4583288431,
0.5396806598,
-0.0254774075,
0.0459789,
-1.1092382669,
0.0857795998,
0.8612285256,
-0.393155247,
-0.2821238339,
0.344537437,
0.3980469108,
-0.6119618416,
0.2018305361,
-0.2596741915,
-0.5967091322,
0.3847265244,
0.4775168598,
0.3372711539,
-0.4077299833,
0.3476813138,
0.006929094,
0.7287580371,
-0.2203753442,
0.3637332022,
0.1835526973,
-0.8383562565,
-0.5976671576,
-0.5965486169,
-0.7097405791,
0.2422348261,
-0.4117024839,
0.3646425307,
-0.5294239521,
-0.4060549438,
-0.3866266012,
0.4492836595,
-0.4743559062,
0.2959518433,
0.1933814734,
0.6500258446,
-1.1727466583,
0.5961350203,
0.8010168076,
-0.1543476731,
-0.4758327305,
-0.4593190849,
-0.181131348,
-0.9568635225,
0.266489774,
-0.5314946175,
0.1176458299,
-0.3567503095,
-0.6309962273,
-0.6670203209,
0.6551544666,
0.8436877728,
-0.6048633456,
-0.2476987988,
0.232013911,
0.4871995151,
-0.5088658333,
0.3496508896,
0.6605200768,
0.5927035213,
-0.2211068273,
-1.1742043495,
-0.2958001494,
0.0882620886,
-0.2901109159,
0.4148219526,
-0.7907886505,
0.9052507281,
-0.4238733053,
0.2432311475,
-0.0135369375,
1.0142506361,
0.3769100904,
0.4079247713,
0.4139750004,
0.3559789062,
0.6550754309,
-0.1208699942,
1.22610116,
-0.3241906762,
0.2154054344,
0.8438123465,
-0.2720532119,
0.9090636969,
0.5824064612,
-0.4447170794,
0.4361105263,
0.7225400209,
0.2144999355,
0.1982539147,
0.1007556468,
-0.5544797182,
-0.5525498986,
-0.3080432415,
-0.3060993552,
0.4872024059,
0.5711834431,
-0.4769611955,
0.1019492149,
0.4463417828,
0.0026789689,
0.4504804313,
-0.5387260914,
0.7632845044,
0.0430420451,
-0.7829110026,
0.418607384,
-0.2609009743,
0.5173429847,
-0.2696375847,
-0.1384063959,
0.0199418329,
0.1938726306,
-0.3665782809,
-1.0912264585,
-0.1620781422,
-0.1810601652,
-0.2285249978,
-0.0437980928,
0.4103109837,
-0.6525133848,
-0.7991928458,
0.0357553884,
0.6468926668,
0.124912709,
-0.0798937231,
-0.5047009587,
0.3546584845,
-0.1081148088,
-0.4674458802,
0.2800979018,
0.2443906814,
-0.2055247277,
0.7819420695,
0.5258790255,
0.6601315737,
-0.0213401858,
-0.270817548,
0.7659516335,
-0.0851810202,
-0.44818452,
-0.7273890972,
0.1934568882,
-0.1078629121,
-0.2038976401,
0.5194326043,
0.7439876199,
0.7855113745,
0.1776593328,
1.2506033182,
-0.0163715128,
0.6337528825,
-0.2454517484,
0.4897598028,
-0.4748031199,
0.2240761369,
-0.0684150532,
-1.1165697575,
-0.0190464836,
0.7053517699,
-0.7710844278,
0.2389160097,
-0.0593503416,
1.0443813801,
-0.0143670682,
-0.319806993,
0.5261038542,
-0.0105869547,
0.481857419,
0.4183050692,
0.7543971539,
-0.1734196544,
0.381532073,
-0.0890803784,
-0.3078513741,
-0.2256901413,
-0.4864726663,
-0.9350440502,
-0.7489826083,
-0.1063120961,
-0.744040668,
0.3210332692,
1.3105095625,
0.7903575897,
-0.725435853,
-0.5162199736,
0.4011951089,
0.2581421137,
0.3672327101,
-0.2122964263,
0.5010432005,
0.3685461879,
-1.1461513042,
0.202339381,
0.2703895271,
-0.0747623518,
-0.660120666,
-0.3247687221,
-0.1753166169,
0.3030441999,
0.7600919604,
0.3948433101,
-1.1190860271,
-0.6299180984,
-0.0053150421,
-0.0763604939,
-0.1753946543,
0.6991567612,
-1.0594013929,
0.8846073151,
0.6082237959,
0.2739484012,
0.4030836225,
0.22292988,
0.6273677945,
-0.2833989859,
0.4334199727,
0.3098063469,
0.35716784,
0.4362084866,
0.1061064154,
0.3130618632,
-0.1340026855,
-0.9486919641,
-1.0267394781,
0.298486501,
-1.0719416142,
0.1496005058,
1.5394384861,
0.1857705116,
-0.1752217114,
-0.116884321,
-0.4705619216,
0.2442711145,
-0.7551842928,
0.7320340872,
0.4619383812,
-0.1434837729,
-0.3786399662,
-0.360989511,
0.1971589774,
-0.0703903139,
-0.7119194865,
-0.3090650141,
0.704228878,
0.1190289855,
0.1023226827,
0.7875391245,
0.0502262115,
0.3388768733,
-0.2835477293,
-0.0406289957,
-0.0650455058,
-0.1935357302,
-0.1992616802,
0.3800492585,
0.0983164161,
-0.0218709838
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06685v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06685v1
|
Multigenre AI-powered Story Composition
| 2024-05-06T12:54:41 | 2024-05-06T12:54:41 |
Edirlei Soares de Lima, Margot M. E. Neggers, Antonio L. Furtado
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper shows how to construct genre patterns, whose purpose is to guide
interactive story composition in a way that enforces thematic consistency. To
start the discussion we argue, based on previous seminal works, for the
existence of five fundamental genres, namely comedy, romance - in the sense of
epic plots, flourishing since the twelfth century -, tragedy, satire, and
mystery. To construct the patterns, a simple two-phase process is employed:
first retrieving examples that match our genre characterizations, and then
applying a form of most specific generalization to the groups of examples in
order to find their commonalities. In both phases, AI agents are instrumental,
with our PatternTeller prototype being called to operate the story composition
process, offering the opportunity to generate stories from a given premise of
the user, to be developed under the guidance of the chosen pattern and trying
to accommodate the user's suggestions along the composition stages.
|
[
-0.2498918623,
-0.4694586694,
0.7984057069,
0.8367965221,
-0.1404093504,
0.4734148383,
-0.0172031168,
-0.1855303347,
0.6040379405,
0.6805475354,
-0.6133723855,
-0.537778914,
-0.2376497984,
0.2825531662,
-0.4551312327,
1.0827834606,
-0.2133816332,
-0.421184659,
-0.181215331,
-0.31869784,
-0.7666031718,
-0.2656712532,
-0.3296100497,
-0.331997931,
0.5681657791,
0.40414235,
0.3358117044,
1.0067824125,
0.576456666,
0.3689141572,
0.3431398571,
0.5464725494,
-0.1613602936,
0.7903094888,
0.282605499,
-0.7690095901,
-0.1927137524,
0.3629107177,
0.5311301351,
0.2345184982,
-0.147168234,
-0.1283991635,
0.0026158763,
0.5017712116,
-0.2437400818,
0.2276332676,
-0.2335598767,
0.1870187074,
-0.1380593032,
-0.567284286,
-0.4989791512,
-0.2010428756,
-0.2823173106,
-0.6449658275,
0.250859946,
0.3012263179,
0.5958481431,
0.1169403195,
-0.5084791183,
-0.4963521063,
-1.334097147,
0.6625019908,
-0.2483800948,
-0.3354324102,
0.2948660553,
0.4807075262,
0.1332945377,
-0.8225083351,
-0.5388593078,
-0.5058932304,
-0.1834864765,
0.260612011,
0.0515068658,
-0.2004901916,
0.0480125248,
0.2994313836,
-0.593609035,
-0.2130304426,
-0.0883423239,
-0.1714391857,
0.8225069642,
0.7219831347,
0.6001744866,
-0.1778260469,
-0.3007147908,
0.0967720971,
-0.4450396597,
0.1011642814,
0.5717402697,
-0.0595723577,
-0.2744940817,
0.5075439811,
0.232962355,
0.4037555754,
0.1761616617,
-0.7165371776,
0.0303288251,
-0.7186332941,
0.2966238558,
0.2856020331,
0.9061905742,
0.6645572186,
0.2697150409,
-0.2768496871,
0.0018855178,
0.0471637845,
0.4431637228,
-0.4242112339,
-0.2235201597,
0.268386066,
-0.5862184763,
-0.5406407118,
0.1855950654,
-0.387689203,
-0.6054114699,
-0.5696572065,
0.3432302177,
-0.6383211017,
-0.141723752,
-0.141265735,
-0.7664304972,
0.1129515991,
0.125595808,
-0.8725047112,
0.0593315624,
0.6477330923,
0.9368408918,
0.2323217839,
-0.5038836598,
-0.3273604214,
0.6964492798,
-0.3657827079,
1.0046367645,
-0.4994995296,
-0.2918005586,
-0.2641870081,
-0.2328767926,
-0.0267546624,
-0.2877483368,
0.3743883669,
-0.114721179,
0.2789346278,
0.0233959276,
-0.5554440022,
-0.2507803142,
0.0716436505,
-0.5904340744,
0.6385658383,
-0.0488522723,
-0.3787620068,
0.4109249115,
-0.4111566246,
-0.8235099912,
0.1840086579,
-0.3572189212,
-0.1219102442,
-0.0000111017,
-0.0047594453,
0.1516993642,
-0.2188805938,
0.2561593652,
0.0599730797,
-0.4211875498,
0.1166168898,
-0.2542884946,
0.6139572263,
0.3715847135,
-0.617757082,
0.4301821589,
-1.05257833,
-0.2097675353,
-0.0002196789,
0.0838526785,
-0.4784598947,
0.338190943,
0.186282292,
0.1383654177,
-0.0740680471,
-0.3465844095,
0.3765171468,
-0.0691751242,
0.8204072714,
0.6079476476,
0.0935328752,
0.2726601064,
-1.1478732824,
0.9186421633,
0.1038166285,
0.1032099649,
-0.9484604597,
-0.4602923095,
-0.8041061759,
-0.4491200447,
-0.0114601683,
0.7982957959,
-0.5926797986,
0.8807860613,
0.1442662179,
-0.8605066538,
-0.5078666806,
0.0192948952,
0.0388414115,
0.1310709864,
0.1755195111,
-0.4694010019,
-0.5935692787,
-0.684271276,
-0.0653336272,
-0.0511058159,
0.0905408114,
0.2136782557,
-0.0334381238,
0.2232413739,
1.2052631378,
-0.3367434144,
-0.4233023226,
-0.7260338664,
0.4437094331,
0.1417668015,
0.5705432296,
0.9109496474,
-0.7380755544,
-0.8474895954,
-0.2402025908,
-0.9106850624,
-0.066192843,
-0.4013566673,
0.0380527824,
-0.0857985243,
0.5767277479,
-0.410243988,
0.1434284002,
0.2090342343,
-0.3693816066,
0.4163959324,
-0.1748839915,
0.4139668345,
-1.399741292,
-0.0608242378,
0.0758579373,
-0.0756196678,
-0.7248552442,
0.1019530296,
-0.4901252687,
-0.0768333822,
-0.0484833978,
0.3742963076,
-0.3819913268,
0.2672141194,
-0.2220243365,
-0.15722619,
0.2353813052,
0.2972631752,
-0.2406384349,
0.2918004096,
0.5957891345,
-0.5129455924,
0.5475353599,
0.1302840263,
-0.3677160442,
0.8203354478,
-0.6999844909,
0.2365507334,
-0.5416396856,
0.5092981458,
-1.0351040363,
-0.2950137854,
0.3818878531,
-0.0686091706,
-0.037977919,
-0.1882761866,
-0.6852194071,
-0.0449063033,
-0.2956813276,
0.2127981782,
0.6363021731,
0.2246982008,
1.0413960218,
-0.0860001519,
-0.3612609506,
-0.1999526918,
-0.4973556995,
0.2039726377,
-0.6453509331,
-0.8417757154,
0.3386462331,
-0.4415752292,
-0.3760601282,
-0.1031607091,
0.4114963412,
0.1590004265,
0.0563742481,
0.421402365,
-0.1475362778,
-0.41522789,
-0.217219919,
0.1456719786,
0.0081830984,
-0.2987884879,
-0.0555972755,
0.8284624219,
0.408477664,
-0.3177514672,
-0.745357275,
0.8294062018,
1.0069173574,
-0.5550971627,
0.5047297478,
0.7393702269,
0.2341859788,
-0.285191685,
-0.2767986655,
-0.0653225258,
-0.4908679128,
-0.227561295,
-0.3147274852,
-0.7229462266,
0.7943714857,
0.1251782924,
0.2512814105,
0.6908019185,
0.3561995327,
-0.1931144893,
1.081069231,
0.842987895,
0.0544573814,
0.4726131856,
-0.171300903,
0.1946758479,
-0.4259393513,
-0.3479321599,
-0.5809954405,
-0.760217607,
-0.6718834043,
-0.0138592189,
0.7311592698,
0.0785212591,
-0.2767644525,
0.1181518435,
-0.4107115567,
0.681569159,
0.8979133964,
-0.2244022489,
0.5704792738,
0.0818374008,
0.0222640671,
-0.0202760473,
-0.497962296,
-0.547044754,
1.0163049698,
0.1337686777,
0.6655970812,
0.3526828885,
0.9439361691,
0.4450852871,
0.1546654254,
-0.7050863504,
0.3644283116,
-0.4397279322,
-0.4914120734,
-0.2185449004,
0.1455941647,
-0.8937758803,
-0.1185416803,
-0.05173219,
-0.5962044597,
0.165958643,
0.0431696363,
-0.5916739702,
-0.0020512294,
-0.398275584,
0.5843146443,
-0.159323886,
0.086809285,
-0.3142232597,
-0.8976977468,
0.3964194059,
0.1223778203,
0.1923724562,
-0.20460473,
0.3547763526,
0.3694610596,
-0.2467120886,
0.8275093436,
0.2668797374,
0.10817004,
0.7819302082,
0.2091194987,
0.1557952017,
0.0018041523,
0.1418907344,
-0.2895869017,
-0.1605833769,
-0.2994972467,
-0.5533167124,
0.1576113254,
-0.7998331785,
-0.5919532776,
-0.3497329354,
-0.7700619102,
0.1053692549,
0.1545640528,
0.3577876985,
0.9637255073,
-0.1329269856,
0.3046876192,
0.2436342835,
0.2399469912,
0.9819841981,
0.3519133031,
-0.1881625503,
-0.4877697229,
0.9148582816,
-0.1140921339,
0.1159791425,
0.4502699673,
0.1148188859,
0.224141255,
-0.4448847175,
-0.6529658437,
-0.0687003508,
-0.3644790947,
0.0582955033,
-0.819627285,
-0.4098660648,
-0.2797853947,
-0.417203933,
0.1419972777,
-0.0824385732,
-0.2177236527,
0.1810988039,
0.4969759285,
1.0286231041,
-0.145131737,
0.4119482338,
-1.0021874905,
0.3413376212,
0.2877337933,
-0.0418784283,
0.0781850442,
-0.1198081225,
-0.0404621363,
-0.2821705937,
-0.541864574,
-0.6555910707,
0.2546051145,
0.4182787836,
0.4989500344,
0.3816249669,
-0.2299352884,
0.3720984459,
-0.740781486,
0.9732073545,
0.1852297932,
-0.8081675768,
0.6796419621,
-0.6182662845,
0.0372063369,
0.4919639528,
0.4980260134,
-0.8448988199,
-0.7898640037,
-0.6703804731,
-0.8386795521,
0.6889246702,
0.2600872517,
0.4124648869,
0.2344348282,
0.3387955725,
0.500726223,
0.4393621087,
-0.4421016872,
-0.6433555484,
-0.4518846869,
-0.4803895652,
-0.4683375061,
-0.0025666633,
-0.5283744931,
-0.0784152076,
0.1355727911,
-0.0953070745,
0.1208735108,
0.009021705,
0.2531944215,
-0.167170465,
0.2760754526,
0.9858454466,
0.7961438894,
-0.0708297864,
0.0651059672,
-1.1696387529,
-0.4988321662,
0.6293189526,
0.198720932,
-0.4966731966,
-0.030619733,
0.838393867,
0.8752044439,
-0.2759863734,
-0.4426742196,
0.1680552214,
0.0003098882,
-0.2059485614,
-0.3918354213,
0.5981106162,
-0.0685898811,
0.4064346552,
0.5593032837,
0.1786010712,
0.0203776453,
-1.3334839344,
0.3778906167,
-0.0148049444,
-0.2867712677,
-0.2495649755,
0.5792523026,
0.2163281143,
-0.4680600762,
0.6419112086,
-0.3345329165,
-0.251978308,
1.1773372889,
0.7028297782,
1.0606133938,
-0.2078994215,
0.6986863017,
0.0142968111,
0.4035735726,
0.0688860863,
0.3581468761,
0.1955385208,
-0.7577410936,
-0.3552281857,
-0.6831831932,
-0.1346138567,
-0.0327176116,
-0.2462332994,
0.3287045658,
-0.6524786949,
0.3809817433,
0.4541213512,
-0.4090131521,
-0.1686144322,
-0.1238270998,
0.0108077088,
0.5129708648,
-0.9018924236,
0.3925363719,
0.8474037051,
-0.7495796084,
-1.152326107,
0.2815715373,
0.2401124835,
-0.5716878772,
0.4297265112,
0.111545682,
0.2658111155,
0.331605494,
-0.48339504,
-0.772085011,
1.1829521656,
-0.0004415926,
-0.394141227,
0.0353276245,
-0.1497948468,
0.771356225,
-0.9925710559,
0.0880403817,
0.3419428468,
0.6598124504,
0.4634028971,
-0.8960552812,
-0.2031254023,
-0.2685231566,
-0.285607338,
0.2482844144,
-1.0053610802,
0.8423944712,
-0.0199555568,
0.0112683298,
0.5324877501,
0.5080580115,
0.3098698556,
0.6537613869,
0.3136915267,
0.3112487197,
0.2404933125,
-0.0786257312,
1.0202081203,
-0.4481030703,
-0.0409847088,
0.9400942922,
-0.3709017336,
0.0619875081,
-0.0806186348,
-0.2042353749,
1.0883055925,
0.5267947912,
-0.2979331315,
0.6980804205,
0.1837345213,
-0.3164331317,
-0.2793624103,
-0.3647188544,
-0.2631080151,
0.8977076411,
0.0040880754,
-0.3681153357,
-0.0593219921,
0.1347079575,
-0.0465354398,
0.3012904227,
-0.2861606181,
0.9907096624,
0.0001714677,
-0.7311291695,
-0.0258981306,
0.2226993591,
0.3889442682,
-0.8815641403,
-0.218017906,
-0.4110605717,
-0.1899580657,
0.0015768439,
-0.6763644218,
-0.0276320167,
-0.4103152156,
-0.5567466021,
-0.2191939801,
0.4105352163,
-0.6917846203,
-0.4863267243,
-0.4231987894,
0.4928251803,
-0.0349915847,
0.2665433586,
-0.4014796913,
-0.1431478411,
-0.1635490507,
0.2786812186,
0.0953212678,
0.5635172129,
-0.3060227931,
0.3138858974,
0.3130391538,
-0.1652323306,
-0.1787703335,
0.3568857908,
0.2882187068,
-0.7436999679,
-0.9224233627,
-0.9558719993,
0.754776299,
0.110858798,
-0.474768579,
0.678884685,
0.3822441995,
0.1620510221,
-0.0823818818,
0.8479383588,
-0.4098313451,
-0.0100486251,
-0.5418342948,
0.6987805963,
-0.4745035768,
0.0427309684,
-0.2729316354,
-1.1362628937,
-0.2050129622,
0.1006901488,
0.5541651845,
0.2814406157,
0.8980509043,
0.3626204431,
0.0891470686,
0.1444011927,
0.0194185562,
0.0123056797,
0.4053073525,
0.1191445962,
0.9509948492,
-0.0857396349,
0.1067468598,
-0.3055596948,
-0.2956061959,
-0.205669716,
-0.9270529747,
-0.7891945243,
-0.7795701027,
-0.2859762013,
-0.1336613297,
-0.1397688538,
0.8074663877,
0.5895584226,
-0.6387379169,
-0.4437357187,
-0.0896885619,
0.2297135592,
-0.5936889052,
-0.2760578394,
0.1053541303,
-0.2960243523,
-0.5757356882,
0.526478231,
0.695217669,
-0.0260509551,
-0.5560765862,
0.2549269795,
-0.0510596558,
0.2779569924,
0.6136257052,
0.0590679795,
-0.6937573552,
-0.3343007863,
-0.0760280937,
-0.0848048553,
0.1620488912,
1.5593621731,
-0.3034790456,
0.2870810926,
0.4041539431,
0.1703501344,
0.0512855053,
0.0856305361,
0.9134315252,
-0.9674680233,
0.1733916104,
0.2279934436,
0.1466275752,
-0.0191644914,
-0.519690752,
0.386212796,
0.6655600667,
-0.4496747255,
-0.3628716767,
0.3868258595,
-1.2359400988,
-0.2036628276,
0.85989362,
0.0804115012,
0.1389684677,
-0.2324739546,
-0.3398934305,
-0.0014712214,
-0.2641995549,
0.7665020823,
1.0403096676,
-0.6750613451,
-0.135906592,
-0.1283919513,
0.5625298023,
0.0682979971,
-0.7618717551,
-0.3523728549,
0.7497009635,
0.2992163599,
0.5327326059,
0.5732459426,
0.0955976471,
0.2819529474,
0.1304598451,
-0.012300266,
-0.0763732195,
-0.7872080207,
0.0323991328,
0.6565151811,
-0.0632638931,
0.1614575535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03425v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03425v1
|
Gaussian Stochastic Weight Averaging for Bayesian Low-Rank Adaptation of Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T12:44:37 | 2024-05-06T12:44:37 |
Emre Onal, Klemens Flöge, Emma Caldwell, Arsen Sheverdin, Vincent Fortuin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Fine-tuned Large Language Models (LLMs) often suffer from overconfidence and
poor calibration, particularly when fine-tuned on small datasets. To address
these challenges, we propose a simple combination of Low-Rank Adaptation (LoRA)
with Gaussian Stochastic Weight Averaging (SWAG), facilitating approximate
Bayesian inference in LLMs. Through extensive testing across several Natural
Language Processing (NLP) benchmarks, we demonstrate that our straightforward
and computationally efficient approach improves model generalization and
calibration. We further show that our method exhibits greater robustness
against distribution shift, as reflected in its performance on
out-of-distribution tasks.
|
[
-0.0063856891,
-0.7317707539,
0.5469651222,
0.1953791231,
-0.2181657553,
0.0065609105,
-0.413987875,
-0.3181308508,
0.0600380935,
0.4437025487,
-0.326654315,
-0.6873786449,
-0.8090187907,
-0.430606246,
-0.1108085364,
0.9218364954,
0.2103942484,
0.0488526486,
0.0067108613,
-0.2756501436,
-0.3292778432,
-0.2520261705,
-0.7140696049,
-0.2555929422,
0.5879456997,
0.2994014025,
0.772072196,
0.0954571739,
0.685721755,
0.1582223922,
0.0905682445,
0.3006466627,
-0.634740293,
0.0619200505,
-0.4546674192,
-0.5704564452,
-0.6921677589,
-0.3037719727,
0.8192301989,
1.0219640732,
-0.5490242839,
0.2456959486,
0.0936866105,
0.732608974,
-0.9884735942,
0.0635253713,
-0.8121141195,
-0.2657765448,
-0.0052641272,
-0.1143308654,
-0.5178397298,
-0.3216070831,
0.0090015363,
-0.6069306135,
0.0844419226,
0.0844704285,
0.4992962182,
0.3807318211,
-0.3187730908,
-0.1513471752,
-0.822149694,
1.0127922297,
-1.1345616579,
0.0757167116,
0.4117765725,
0.3522640765,
-0.6095743179,
-0.2363309115,
-0.406183362,
-0.123439379,
0.3554107845,
0.1287153363,
-0.37674281,
0.0944094285,
0.2017653883,
0.2022678256,
-0.4016462266,
0.4440766275,
-0.1158222854,
0.3322628438,
0.7899122834,
-0.0667630211,
0.1031574309,
0.3366847038,
-0.2188545614,
-0.3580251634,
-0.6830226779,
-0.0966442004,
0.4308482111,
0.683259964,
-0.1879364848,
0.4598917365,
-0.1422545165,
0.7045660615,
0.0287662297,
-0.1904389262,
0.1576381475,
-0.15035294,
-0.4152671695,
-0.0705149248,
0.5025082827,
0.3423297405,
0.2206232548,
0.018122023,
0.0518122129,
-0.0226260498,
0.0816706866,
-0.7602527142,
-0.3794671893,
0.0917164385,
-0.3512026668,
-0.2288939059,
-0.1217292547,
-0.8585083485,
-0.6607084274,
-0.0318849608,
0.8756320477,
-0.121299915,
-0.043050088,
0.2703524828,
-0.0197908431,
0.3863583803,
0.571249783,
-1.0736168623,
0.5480388999,
0.4435940981,
0.9102688432,
-0.2489515096,
-0.1355916411,
-0.9462053776,
0.3132526875,
-0.62818712,
0.7989387512,
-0.541666925,
-0.2591377497,
-0.1366964877,
0.0363541916,
-0.3477844298,
-0.5409879684,
0.5232301354,
-0.2614042163,
0.0356040075,
-0.0806535557,
-0.3931394219,
0.001701499,
-0.163387388,
-0.3224489093,
1.2741720676,
0.3543223143,
-0.5734900236,
0.459522754,
-0.4340223372,
-0.356461972,
-0.2984042466,
0.1414864361,
-0.3597752452,
0.6886916161,
0.5404722691,
0.4679829478,
-0.4240876138,
-0.0908506289,
-0.8513513803,
-0.5694718957,
0.1888397634,
-0.348708719,
0.569840312,
-0.0520832837,
-0.0527490936,
0.0781836063,
-0.8934650421,
0.0040523061,
0.0782780647,
-0.2718924284,
-0.6539333463,
0.4534890652,
-0.0951441973,
-0.0406694412,
0.2056191117,
-0.2457593828,
0.5196431279,
-0.6606508493,
0.3329429626,
0.6750442982,
0.0474602096,
0.7599537373,
-0.3163850009,
0.3983312249,
0.0608188584,
-0.2218022346,
0.4780135155,
-0.5451068282,
-0.7149819136,
-0.5459327698,
0.3850609362,
0.5643097162,
-0.5264886618,
0.5794965625,
-0.6631946564,
-0.6525768638,
-0.6284405589,
0.4955095351,
-0.1242507622,
0.3386562467,
0.5125937462,
-0.2448681593,
-0.0342126749,
-0.6768474579,
-0.1644937694,
-0.2729542255,
-0.5542672873,
-0.0209311172,
0.3878661692,
-0.3491727114,
0.7726072073,
-0.4591397047,
-0.3449179828,
-0.3460429907,
0.335265547,
0.5408608317,
0.3969338238,
0.72571069,
-0.1550337374,
-0.3944579959,
0.0893067122,
-0.2242977023,
-0.3568195701,
-0.0034045859,
-0.2566438019,
0.2702899277,
0.3810148239,
-0.3809162974,
0.4860662222,
0.859223783,
-0.2134712338,
0.339432478,
-0.6837983727,
-0.1156678349,
-1.1711883545,
0.0128651597,
0.1380170137,
-0.3070746958,
-0.7475414872,
-0.0471046902,
-0.0463939458,
0.058521606,
-0.0382489152,
0.5612837672,
-0.3351766765,
-0.3841730058,
-0.4676593244,
0.2933551073,
-0.1071113274,
0.4343526661,
0.0424599349,
0.5885887742,
0.4996750653,
-0.5282330513,
0.0408561081,
0.0541832596,
-0.6321488023,
0.7698512077,
-0.5735446811,
-0.1156234369,
-0.1762240976,
0.3351491392,
-1.1848860979,
-0.0315042846,
0.1538307667,
-0.2036993951,
0.2471256405,
-0.4335901141,
-0.4039399326,
0.091796644,
-0.4259654582,
0.1907567382,
0.5361862779,
-0.6428331733,
0.6767556071,
0.3324138224,
-0.5392101407,
-0.4271335304,
-0.9107668996,
-0.0032461563,
-0.3020684719,
-0.3164763749,
0.3422560394,
-0.1011159271,
-0.3595080972,
-0.5099702477,
-0.1043744981,
0.0457228869,
0.223591879,
0.200667426,
0.1736039221,
-0.3170225322,
0.0280171558,
0.1733067185,
0.1293209791,
-0.0910945013,
0.1015451401,
0.3000641763,
0.0674925596,
-0.5473841429,
-0.1305465251,
0.2966938019,
0.4795278907,
0.2705914378,
0.7687376738,
0.6356862187,
-0.4260783195,
-0.6994554996,
-0.3052340448,
-0.0455872081,
-0.4377196133,
0.5598456264,
-0.1865745932,
-0.4350643456,
0.5965266228,
0.0802922621,
0.0153089743,
0.325476557,
0.7159214616,
-0.2481074333,
1.2616431713,
0.8087918162,
-0.5082758069,
0.5507856011,
0.1752968132,
0.3747926056,
-0.6804112196,
0.4024584889,
-0.6166082621,
-0.5212199092,
-0.6594153047,
-0.7828207016,
0.1994313449,
0.3864662051,
-0.0868915915,
0.0743907988,
-0.0868255347,
0.152965799,
0.5856633186,
0.1089783683,
0.3585102856,
0.2660203278,
0.3029539585,
-0.0664708838,
-0.6420260072,
-0.2073574662,
0.9654145837,
0.4176596403,
1.3040997982,
0.4496199489,
0.5007643104,
0.3893527687,
0.4002946317,
-0.879320085,
0.3818977773,
-0.4620789289,
-0.1453160346,
-0.3999689519,
-0.5164011717,
-0.6804466248,
0.4954660237,
-0.2577127516,
-0.9929408431,
0.486088872,
0.1012266874,
-0.4207503498,
0.1336404979,
-0.6827107668,
0.5834870934,
0.0436690152,
-0.2672696412,
-0.3804192841,
-0.3735700548,
0.2639188468,
-0.1815893352,
0.3602144122,
-0.5149672627,
-0.2511051297,
0.8042783141,
-0.4184015989,
0.8860135674,
-0.3797773719,
-0.4879950881,
-0.0502269901,
-0.0984460488,
0.718721509,
0.0901104435,
-0.1650248766,
0.1335613281,
0.3019866943,
-0.6108742356,
-0.6723651886,
0.6789313555,
-0.7882748246,
-0.461640656,
-0.4464451969,
-0.8029506803,
-0.6925498247,
-0.1458135843,
-0.0938100815,
0.020465916,
-0.1172180921,
0.1149219796,
0.582187891,
-0.1511695683,
0.4378804266,
0.3756769001,
-0.226618886,
-0.4502027035,
0.793582499,
0.1217076033,
0.5220813751,
0.4615122378,
0.211376667,
-0.0969794318,
-0.9742389321,
-0.4524562955,
0.2316446304,
-0.6835482121,
-0.1053190976,
-0.2735036612,
-0.027712021,
-0.5616234541,
-0.4141348004,
-0.1795955598,
-0.5023733377,
-0.3397560716,
0.1159146726,
0.3576842546,
0.3513614535,
0.1959524602,
0.6577578783,
-0.3983218074,
0.3564097881,
0.4788377285,
0.0087516559,
-0.2290176004,
-1.163620472,
-0.1705489457,
0.1872997433,
0.119191274,
-0.5602177382,
0.4690233171,
0.8095908761,
0.5593993664,
0.4330540299,
0.0584112443,
0.9262517095,
-0.2499739975,
0.4779856801,
0.0221061744,
-0.7428675294,
0.3755911589,
-0.4681572616,
0.520157218,
0.7512901425,
0.080870524,
-0.2616325617,
-0.2859991789,
-0.1547284126,
-0.7510361671,
0.4108454883,
-0.1169583052,
0.1552376896,
0.2263786793,
0.0519987978,
-0.0326919891,
0.1053548828,
-0.6457558274,
0.0888460129,
0.1452707499,
-0.5404686928,
-0.5364125371,
-0.2351470143,
-0.2070270032,
-0.1715842187,
0.7217724919,
-0.7784968019,
0.3020776808,
-0.1825096309,
-0.481416285,
-0.1145344228,
0.4178922176,
0.7054186463,
0.8370434046,
-0.5676477551,
0.1307553798,
0.6451420784,
-0.4684122503,
-0.0261982065,
0.2362073958,
0.029238198,
-0.0813524723,
0.4529500008,
0.7057444453,
0.7406519055,
-0.6702778935,
0.6454572082,
0.0990234837,
-0.2417644262,
0.0661775693,
0.1855317652,
0.3412853777,
0.2988046706,
0.6194084287,
-0.0638683885,
-0.2079756409,
-0.5352966785,
-0.157918781,
0.6254464388,
-0.1466047913,
-0.2428944707,
0.4186958075,
-0.092024453,
0.1612191349,
0.078779161,
0.0829090551,
-0.0294517595,
0.2603420019,
0.6722877026,
0.6019569039,
-0.1774098575,
0.2289772779,
0.1552274674,
0.348410368,
-0.4282291234,
0.3843370974,
0.036154259,
-0.7672762275,
-0.5354172587,
-0.9611954689,
-0.6520615816,
-0.1950713396,
-0.7287089229,
0.2767528892,
-0.711052537,
-0.0348012894,
-0.1053608209,
0.1611435115,
-0.441082567,
0.0146266082,
0.1878733933,
0.940336585,
-1.0618898869,
1.1886515617,
0.4554794729,
-0.0790231973,
-0.1708327681,
-0.0782174915,
-0.3444280624,
-0.8646385074,
0.3351873755,
-0.203060925,
-0.2658286691,
0.1456280649,
-0.3822736442,
-1.0302374363,
1.032794714,
0.6380862594,
-0.6048415303,
-0.1568975449,
0.0885998458,
0.6087149382,
-0.4774247706,
0.1043210775,
0.713246882,
0.2903271914,
0.0564169511,
-0.7251849771,
-0.02407768,
0.1252325475,
0.2798576951,
0.1184332296,
-0.3747570217,
0.5767608881,
-0.1675263643,
-0.1031679735,
0.1876186877,
0.782805562,
0.4260813892,
0.0840094909,
0.5086431503,
0.5892937779,
0.9460074902,
0.0966947302,
0.6000444889,
0.0314936787,
0.3283753693,
1.3886494637,
-0.5123957992,
1.4336688519,
0.7220271826,
-0.5561062098,
0.5537437201,
0.4949422479,
0.0006623478,
0.7272772789,
0.1994992793,
-0.2593120337,
-0.3170802295,
0.1838067174,
-0.3789689243,
0.2546182275,
0.5688023567,
-0.2810579836,
-0.3207205534,
-0.0260635559,
-0.1891022921,
-0.1037355959,
-0.6634504199,
0.6669591665,
0.2644880712,
-0.2244888395,
0.6056863666,
0.0204076506,
0.8863139749,
-0.6484280229,
0.2324903011,
-0.1105893478,
0.3509155512,
-0.1304308623,
-0.2840728164,
-0.0330699459,
-0.2367208749,
-0.1812753677,
0.0148992492,
0.8853037953,
-0.4991261363,
-1.0130583048,
0.3281992078,
0.3651668429,
-0.0433082134,
-0.0463550799,
-0.5533648729,
-0.0829382241,
-0.4744717181,
-0.3538214564,
0.6987364292,
0.0487748943,
-0.157062605,
0.7076718807,
0.7589092851,
0.4857441783,
0.2485055029,
0.2387823015,
0.5462350249,
-0.5801061392,
-0.5113492608,
-0.687430799,
0.2065253854,
0.0588629805,
-0.1229458675,
0.6560778022,
-0.0103652319,
0.5058675408,
-0.0068479767,
0.804074347,
0.036522314,
0.4516133368,
-0.6538695097,
0.70094347,
-0.5583847165,
0.1439969838,
-0.4123395979,
-1.1567937136,
-0.4825993776,
0.7572906017,
-0.5646775961,
0.0631635636,
0.4459913671,
0.931746304,
-0.2215055972,
-0.3764173985,
0.5360608101,
0.0784252211,
0.2281011492,
0.7372703552,
0.4467476904,
-0.4522965252,
0.2855118215,
-0.0428004898,
-0.2228770703,
-0.5884869695,
-1.1752312183,
-0.9416744113,
-0.1253496408,
-0.429861635,
-0.1174824089,
0.0782614052,
1.0023486614,
0.7841419578,
-1.0963280201,
-0.1614176333,
0.147885859,
0.0749919489,
-0.569008112,
-0.1419261545,
0.3334445655,
-0.2749474645,
-0.81071347,
0.7415926456,
0.2797522247,
-0.0453046709,
-0.3469594717,
-0.0491304472,
-0.2203941047,
0.3276832998,
0.6295503974,
0.2339721322,
-0.464912951,
-0.4918400049,
-0.5902255774,
-0.2680192292,
0.0951320231,
0.375973314,
-0.4453921616,
0.2769085169,
0.6623438001,
0.7478593588,
0.4216384292,
0.2150374055,
0.6689367294,
-0.6697464585,
0.1321372092,
-0.0872570351,
0.4218885899,
0.2599596083,
0.0116481259,
0.5180623531,
0.0625082925,
-0.5508121252,
-1.151838541,
-0.0313182808,
-1.2984522581,
-0.2109575123,
1.1268287897,
0.0158284362,
-0.3301368356,
0.0170831215,
-0.0322281159,
-0.0920837596,
-0.3162398934,
0.7402046323,
0.7558022738,
0.0828297362,
-0.1861388236,
-0.835285604,
0.3273499906,
0.5236962438,
-0.9075995088,
0.2178124487,
0.3674730361,
0.4353048503,
-0.1268632859,
0.4123525918,
0.3078243732,
0.1712798178,
-0.1778271943,
-0.0231651179,
0.4443866611,
-0.0301977489,
-0.737952888,
0.1762313992,
0.4542171955,
-0.0653589517
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03387v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03387v1
|
The high dimensional psychological profile and cultural bias of ChatGPT
| 2024-05-06T11:45:59 | 2024-05-06T11:45:59 |
Hang Yuan, Zhongyue Che, Shao Li, Yue Zhang, Xiaomeng Hu, Siyang Luo
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Given the rapid advancement of large-scale language models, artificial
intelligence (AI) models, like ChatGPT, are playing an increasingly prominent
role in human society. However, to ensure that artificial intelligence models
benefit human society, we must first fully understand the similarities and
differences between the human-like characteristics exhibited by artificial
intelligence models and real humans, as well as the cultural stereotypes and
biases that artificial intelligence models may exhibit in the process of
interacting with humans. This study first measured ChatGPT in 84 dimensions of
psychological characteristics, revealing differences between ChatGPT and human
norms in most dimensions as well as in high-dimensional psychological
representations. Additionally, through the measurement of ChatGPT in 13
dimensions of cultural values, it was revealed that ChatGPT's cultural value
patterns are dissimilar to those of various countries/regions worldwide.
Finally, an analysis of ChatGPT's performance in eight decision-making tasks
involving interactions with humans from different countries/regions revealed
that ChatGPT exhibits clear cultural stereotypes in most decision-making tasks
and shows significant cultural bias in third-party punishment and ultimatum
games. The findings indicate that, compared to humans, ChatGPT exhibits a
distinct psychological profile and cultural value orientation, and it also
shows cultural biases and stereotypes in interpersonal decision-making. Future
research endeavors should emphasize enhanced technical oversight and augmented
transparency in the database and algorithmic training procedures to foster more
efficient cross-cultural communication and mitigate social disparities.
|
[
-0.720407486,
-0.6545426846,
0.1183195636,
0.5281533599,
0.2096636593,
0.3134699464,
-0.302595526,
-0.6469992399,
0.155676648,
0.2513768673,
-0.6178815961,
-0.1492917836,
-0.6582644582,
-0.2255864739,
0.1072461829,
1.1387383938,
0.2445890754,
0.2122557014,
-0.0476878285,
-0.0706524551,
-0.4709382951,
-1.1851129532,
-0.6929951906,
-0.5431060195,
0.0894228444,
0.2451035827,
0.9422444701,
0.4203713536,
0.6485637426,
0.1875130236,
-0.0494585261,
-0.2689897716,
-0.6054080725,
-0.2974231839,
-0.0965850651,
-0.5001684427,
-0.4702355266,
0.6319822073,
0.2360610664,
0.4497286677,
0.0409647822,
0.4244202375,
0.1080271825,
0.7992866039,
-0.1332855523,
0.6058962941,
-0.2229335904,
0.3164970279,
-0.2383657843,
0.0909931734,
-0.150192067,
-0.4777311385,
0.4351786673,
-0.3828476071,
0.2694633305,
0.0341516733,
0.7612429857,
0.2557175756,
-0.7716094851,
-0.2151009142,
-1.1266980171,
0.6398419738,
-0.134170562,
0.1868334711,
0.6087663174,
0.4075959325,
0.0670593157,
-0.1734927744,
-0.3568793833,
-0.4647890627,
-0.0878497139,
0.178717494,
0.0399887934,
-0.0006773586,
0.5548934937,
0.0875442699,
-0.4184418321,
0.1348262876,
-0.6192585826,
-0.3662796915,
0.932372272,
0.2600707114,
0.3265444338,
-0.0686916187,
-0.2078917623,
-0.3134658933,
-0.5872852206,
0.3008052707,
0.5153229833,
0.0375721939,
-0.2067471892,
0.3266116381,
-0.3437179625,
-0.0452891588,
-0.0846177787,
-0.1165354177,
0.2692543268,
-0.1322490126,
0.2573991418,
0.1450039297,
0.7989163399,
0.5109990835,
0.8705483079,
0.1355253458,
0.3180467784,
0.4149810076,
0.1179295033,
-0.8942092061,
-0.2265900373,
-0.0604993068,
-0.8706232905,
-0.1735065132,
-0.0638256967,
-0.8519843817,
-0.5303501487,
-0.1802168787,
0.1389212012,
-0.4801670909,
-0.2181476504,
-0.1230685338,
-0.0816373527,
0.4444741309,
0.1762490124,
-0.8155459762,
0.3282591701,
0.5900829434,
0.75316751,
-0.2312983274,
-0.3532723486,
0.1615488976,
-0.2371223569,
-0.2230486125,
0.6144340634,
-0.7772914767,
-0.4271326065,
-0.3265881538,
-0.5186592937,
0.094140254,
-0.2910110354,
0.6722000837,
-0.2179784328,
0.4436057508,
-0.5689890385,
-0.1844016314,
-0.3514823914,
0.3606466353,
-0.3406200111,
0.724694252,
-0.0525845774,
-0.5606710315,
0.7127286792,
-0.8954286575,
-0.3008024096,
0.2516333163,
-0.3218729496,
-0.1827666759,
-0.2298113555,
0.2945236266,
0.2004071027,
-0.2574285269,
0.0452795848,
-0.2327757478,
-0.5943819284,
0.2511788309,
-0.7519832253,
1.0365210772,
0.2259587795,
-0.379783392,
-0.1002798975,
-0.6090166569,
-0.1693202257,
0.1122582257,
-0.3938410878,
-0.1071803048,
0.2964735329,
-0.0123734521,
0.7742484808,
0.2579981089,
-0.5400419831,
0.1375393271,
-0.0256798714,
0.6877577901,
0.7680413127,
-0.0064405967,
0.2427893728,
-0.4039289057,
0.6552360654,
-0.0397594236,
0.5460687876,
0.3267925978,
-0.581415832,
-0.4194418788,
-0.2449206263,
0.0467424393,
0.9351846576,
-0.0899848789,
0.3679926097,
-0.1305059195,
-0.5791426897,
-0.5155537724,
-0.2862782478,
0.2161697745,
0.2062921226,
-0.0717308,
-0.5017968416,
-0.2564616799,
-1.086961627,
-0.3517957628,
-0.4285378754,
-0.1497909278,
0.5966527462,
0.6124884486,
-0.0069947746,
0.7835183144,
-0.3121127784,
-0.5378223658,
0.0474306978,
0.1368519068,
0.1881774962,
0.4080330431,
0.5968635082,
-0.8003066778,
-0.5362095237,
-0.0829186812,
-0.8111715913,
0.1141878814,
-0.085010916,
-0.2954530418,
-0.0131506706,
0.1839997619,
-0.6526557803,
0.5708073974,
0.1621083021,
-0.5572790504,
0.7512869239,
-0.168026194,
0.4636968672,
-0.6174439192,
-0.0596957579,
0.115539819,
0.3111431897,
-0.5523999333,
-0.1748166978,
-0.1035154089,
-0.2201518565,
-0.1103504896,
0.3517989814,
-0.0827213302,
-0.0839276388,
0.1724725962,
-0.041479867,
-0.2485697269,
0.6469757557,
0.1651120484,
0.7912261486,
0.3885425031,
-0.2699752152,
0.5421834588,
0.419087857,
-0.4778226912,
0.899599731,
-0.6429099441,
0.0975512937,
-0.2920267284,
0.4860186577,
-0.6296103001,
-0.1007465795,
0.0474214368,
-0.5805417895,
-0.3686819375,
0.0027004599,
-0.5096653104,
-0.3606466055,
-0.0432874896,
0.410972476,
0.9503535628,
0.0115557276,
0.4150273204,
0.4344096184,
-0.1987584829,
-0.4382682145,
-0.4960125387,
0.1823857278,
-0.5046247244,
-0.6852625608,
0.1433614939,
-0.1500052214,
-0.481600821,
-0.4181538522,
0.1327692568,
0.1666520834,
0.01074774,
0.2769324481,
0.1845631897,
-0.1047823951,
-0.1408709437,
-0.5227041245,
-0.1843848675,
0.3796350062,
-0.1912122518,
0.7485537529,
-0.3931538165,
-0.4101920426,
-0.4747984707,
0.3603865206,
0.6836007833,
-0.5294963717,
0.8156061769,
0.8072670698,
-0.0563727319,
0.3288653791,
-0.4680636823,
-0.3348453641,
-0.3768995106,
0.6547740698,
-0.2373342514,
-0.6100200415,
0.8405203223,
0.1783976406,
-0.1340851039,
0.1422190815,
0.7314133048,
-0.0290639233,
1.5988017321,
0.594281733,
-0.3771401048,
0.4216817021,
0.0505592935,
0.5647349954,
-0.4132663608,
-0.4048285484,
-0.5373895168,
-0.5773048401,
-1.1784616709,
-0.0027822389,
0.7468300462,
-0.3066702783,
-0.987075448,
-0.4532072842,
-0.5598424077,
0.4888785481,
0.8947048783,
0.1254882365,
0.0518845506,
-0.0465860441,
0.0472281165,
-0.2030779272,
-0.3659413457,
-0.5043916106,
0.7484566569,
0.5415996313,
0.7849128246,
0.003461648,
0.3470608294,
0.5224890113,
-0.0574607104,
-0.6323280931,
0.4282812178,
0.0053060488,
-0.7561509609,
-0.2520953715,
-0.2734746635,
-0.5792273283,
0.234497726,
-0.1759105921,
-1.0635470152,
0.0626330599,
0.0511427149,
-0.2531385422,
0.1160873547,
-0.8564581871,
0.7260314822,
-0.2575613558,
-0.1027791053,
-0.2360158265,
-0.7953538895,
0.3715777993,
0.1358419806,
0.2533114851,
-0.4483571351,
0.3123134077,
0.7541643381,
-0.0792324841,
0.8804531693,
-0.237667948,
0.1197205335,
-0.0795972124,
0.4018329978,
0.3985100985,
0.1240942627,
-0.1799447238,
0.3744158745,
0.2852564454,
-0.6513133645,
-0.3785499036,
0.4665937424,
-1.4132766724,
-0.7327148914,
-0.4920497239,
-0.8003011942,
-0.3242036998,
0.0120989783,
0.2465554178,
0.2429089248,
-0.4852136374,
0.0518696755,
0.479822576,
-0.5640989542,
0.1684641689,
0.1559887677,
-0.1342974603,
0.1370697469,
0.8934059143,
0.1267261207,
0.2843344808,
0.0730703548,
0.2466833889,
-0.0252289288,
-0.0239598453,
-0.1557112783,
0.1227366403,
-0.5404882431,
0.4289703965,
-0.3877129555,
-0.3936783075,
-0.3720603287,
-0.0343248732,
-0.2976329625,
-0.1631033719,
0.3140848279,
0.0040242695,
0.3066967726,
0.7724446058,
-0.0355079621,
0.3174283504,
-0.4471764266,
0.020179186,
0.1444507688,
0.3923586905,
0.0374209359,
-0.2333872467,
-0.125882268,
0.3483260274,
-0.334738493,
-0.5399129987,
0.310089916,
0.0330698043,
0.4692975581,
0.5506051183,
0.0579259656,
0.3764022589,
-0.2957258821,
1.0549143553,
-0.452023834,
-0.674687326,
0.3796846867,
-0.5177379847,
0.2880497575,
0.1622153968,
0.4864807129,
-1.0614097118,
-0.2478343248,
-0.6242031455,
-0.4029074907,
0.9418393373,
0.2601047158,
0.3772197366,
0.0209294744,
0.1309605837,
0.0439680777,
0.0763893276,
-0.8860099912,
-0.3508648276,
-0.2753698826,
-0.0150077259,
0.0023426972,
-0.1104876474,
-0.1641893685,
-0.2327011228,
0.5393330455,
0.0840327814,
0.5177246928,
-0.1078379676,
0.1681707203,
0.0525177345,
0.0988201499,
0.4519692361,
0.6594799757,
-0.2597104907,
-0.2126084566,
0.2076711506,
-0.6791736484,
0.1905385256,
-0.0664860979,
-0.0941401646,
-0.6659142971,
0.4316164851,
0.7509726286,
-0.6684642434,
-0.5745421648,
0.3778358102,
-0.2899986506,
-0.1925324649,
-0.4550759792,
0.1006948277,
-0.2034350336,
0.3839427233,
0.2447167039,
0.2653161585,
-0.0269487221,
-0.7994192839,
-0.0752865821,
0.5177474618,
-0.5295068622,
-0.212434575,
0.6108785272,
0.1901462227,
-0.5293108225,
1.1812939644,
-0.1885870099,
-0.7577850223,
0.6604137421,
0.2534857392,
0.476000756,
-0.0963263959,
0.5109923482,
0.0948564485,
0.4568985403,
0.1175489202,
0.1171457916,
0.0232034028,
-0.972797811,
-0.203383401,
-0.4712656438,
-0.1681593657,
-0.0538739264,
-0.5446368456,
0.1361876726,
-0.3722386062,
-0.0547842942,
-0.2463856936,
0.2408715636,
-0.9032506943,
0.2169440091,
0.3258403242,
0.6221010089,
-0.8802396655,
0.6351099014,
0.443854481,
-0.5424226522,
-0.5644717216,
0.1540786028,
0.3037580252,
-1.0689074993,
1.0281550884,
0.1643386483,
0.0885264277,
-0.3186832368,
-0.3611726165,
-0.9742584825,
0.772313416,
0.1403843015,
-0.0207162891,
-0.2866173387,
0.5933085084,
0.829470396,
-0.264113605,
0.6356380582,
0.8974875808,
0.4745343924,
-0.1217208728,
-1.1420938969,
-0.198213473,
-0.2464184016,
0.1690468043,
0.1981899887,
-1.1843767166,
0.8297800422,
-0.0827298909,
0.0043826317,
-0.3303644359,
0.3635870516,
0.2648408413,
-0.1226472929,
0.2590422332,
0.072343871,
0.5915397406,
-0.1072106808,
0.8733021021,
-0.3484894931,
0.1593918055,
0.6073692441,
-0.3977741599,
0.277236104,
0.093347989,
-0.356824398,
0.432085216,
0.8292818666,
-0.209897995,
0.3016484082,
0.1889502704,
-0.0442747958,
-0.0750469193,
-0.3067575395,
-0.1948487163,
1.0965445042,
0.4843403995,
-0.1997425407,
0.0653069243,
0.1767716557,
0.1958484352,
-0.0692738816,
-0.3201907575,
0.6819285154,
-0.2427774221,
-0.7130087614,
0.2911139429,
-0.1652657837,
0.784409821,
-0.4064081311,
-0.0247995518,
-0.320065856,
0.2799309194,
-0.0421981812,
-0.8398575783,
0.0744176134,
-0.0976892933,
-0.1622145176,
-0.2307747304,
0.4195190668,
-0.0193969682,
-0.387132436,
0.2006897181,
0.5700442791,
0.3258778751,
-0.2116840333,
-0.7537808418,
-0.2206160128,
0.0799881667,
-0.2223350108,
0.4727056324,
0.5005139112,
-0.5639035702,
0.9334504008,
0.3194263577,
0.2342988104,
-0.1353961974,
0.0247760583,
0.136865288,
-0.7055411935,
-0.7607612014,
-1.0828367472,
0.0962106436,
-0.2261437923,
-0.4248279333,
0.4787341356,
0.3078898489,
0.8935002685,
0.1081044376,
0.9441394806,
-0.297105968,
0.1941416115,
-0.2102605104,
0.8416128159,
0.1372898221,
0.0827227011,
-0.1555167288,
-0.9192005396,
0.0934873074,
0.6510266066,
-0.6110479236,
0.5604916811,
0.3509991467,
0.6564353704,
0.1863453239,
0.1952859014,
0.2402612418,
0.3642055094,
0.5601074696,
0.5157378912,
0.9389699101,
0.0167372227,
0.4622462392,
-0.4494771361,
-0.5521706939,
-0.0442380272,
-0.6215698719,
-1.0080269575,
-0.6814427972,
-0.0355283692,
-0.1477619708,
-0.2818377316,
1.1352465153,
0.9122010469,
-0.5596475601,
-0.4942924678,
0.5395675302,
-0.0418406911,
-0.5340704918,
-0.3365927637,
0.3802739084,
0.0191289205,
-0.6390632391,
-0.3772285879,
0.2456442267,
-0.1314417124,
-0.5237345695,
0.0619403012,
0.0368610695,
0.1529493779,
0.7845743895,
-0.0275310241,
-0.7379674315,
-0.6222669482,
-0.1509446651,
-0.0093783755,
0.2004507631,
0.6160384417,
-0.6465906501,
0.0471264608,
0.4629148543,
0.1636327356,
0.3733288348,
-0.0436622985,
0.8064294457,
-0.5422485471,
0.238988176,
0.1598205268,
0.1881507486,
0.0651270971,
-0.7305936217,
0.50194484,
0.1163704321,
-0.9634708762,
-0.4443939924,
0.3096461296,
-0.5295094252,
-0.1016698107,
0.7958789468,
0.090942502,
0.1196672097,
-0.0422107317,
-0.6515151858,
0.1781694442,
-0.5259494185,
1.2336075306,
0.9991931915,
-0.6696754098,
-0.1863836795,
-0.9524191022,
0.7507084608,
0.3071516454,
-0.6404883862,
0.1078552157,
0.4369907677,
0.0963690877,
0.1456499994,
0.3135835826,
-0.1592510194,
0.1163963601,
0.0367637537,
0.226267904,
0.2086389363,
0.0141395926,
0.0421461575,
0.1070590988,
0.0913012028,
0.0499781296
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03371v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03371v2
|
Explainable Fake News Detection With Large Language Model via Defense Among Competing Wisdom
| 2024-05-06T11:24:13 | 2024-06-20T04:33:33 |
Bo Wang, Jing Ma, Hongzhan Lin, Zhiwei Yang, Ruichao Yang, Yuan Tian, Yi Chang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Most fake news detection methods learn latent feature representations based
on neural networks, which makes them black boxes to classify a piece of news
without giving any justification. Existing explainable systems generate
veracity justifications from investigative journalism, which suffer from
debunking delayed and low efficiency. Recent studies simply assume that the
justification is equivalent to the majority opinions expressed in the wisdom of
crowds. However, the opinions typically contain some inaccurate or biased
information since the wisdom of crowds is uncensored. To detect fake news from
a sea of diverse, crowded and even competing narratives, in this paper, we
propose a novel defense-based explainable fake news detection framework.
Specifically, we first propose an evidence extraction module to split the
wisdom of crowds into two competing parties and respectively detect salient
evidences. To gain concise insights from evidences, we then design a
prompt-based module that utilizes a large language model to generate
justifications by inferring reasons towards two possible veracities. Finally,
we propose a defense-based inference module to determine veracity via modeling
the defense among these justifications. Extensive experiments conducted on two
real-world benchmarks demonstrate that our proposed method outperforms
state-of-the-art baselines in terms of fake news detection and provides
high-quality justifications.
|
[
-0.2625401318,
-0.9108505845,
0.7581601143,
0.0421894975,
-0.3916297853,
0.0753021762,
-0.0192803219,
-0.5111064911,
0.155483976,
0.2660461664,
-0.46794644,
-0.2525303662,
-0.3953990936,
-0.1197010577,
-0.4567124546,
0.8360025883,
0.2253682017,
-0.000758717,
-0.1580169648,
-0.174281612,
-0.2803249061,
-0.4026295245,
-0.2613390982,
-0.1180849299,
0.3129178882,
0.5379375219,
0.5247658491,
0.5404698253,
-0.1350988001,
0.2887339294,
-0.0634463504,
0.3457635343,
-0.2913438082,
-0.1466837823,
-0.5773118734,
-0.1940832138,
-0.0680186599,
0.0692681745,
0.342030853,
0.2512612343,
-0.0680429339,
0.020854732,
-0.4115826786,
0.3097112477,
-0.4656943381,
-0.2567088604,
-0.8513991833,
-0.0936140269,
-0.2522345185,
-0.1580079645,
-0.4958738685,
-0.2760919631,
0.1774411649,
-0.4734897316,
0.3774087727,
0.0002761758,
0.9814966917,
-0.1313854754,
-0.4543858171,
-0.1854674965,
-0.4977219999,
0.6361584663,
-0.681615293,
0.1728047878,
0.1048193946,
0.4185137451,
0.047325965,
-0.3546860814,
-0.9923914671,
-0.1989426613,
0.1134586707,
0.3030100763,
-0.6106752753,
-0.1935853213,
0.0256464537,
0.2383768111,
-0.7108037472,
0.2907986641,
-0.1335977912,
-0.3644244373,
0.61962533,
-0.2472517937,
0.3499597907,
-0.2810368836,
-0.6447660327,
0.0041221944,
-0.5506601334,
-0.1124064699,
0.6654679775,
0.0315101966,
-0.0115266806,
0.3131791949,
-0.5293777585,
0.5057364702,
0.1922755837,
-0.2337818295,
0.1417041272,
0.0315747969,
-0.1245304495,
0.398026228,
0.7193840742,
0.3175601959,
0.0960543677,
-0.0984673873,
-0.2477910966,
0.2234229147,
0.3202174008,
-0.6998234987,
-0.048352506,
0.1842504442,
-0.751172781,
-0.6678669453,
0.3090403676,
-0.8828893304,
-0.5527696013,
0.0577929094,
0.4996910989,
-0.4252270162,
-0.6744497418,
0.1772772223,
-0.3646476567,
0.0171039458,
0.3863782883,
-0.4491320252,
-0.062955983,
0.7221627235,
0.8835884333,
-0.1093058288,
0.0622818023,
-0.6067954898,
-0.0681186244,
-0.4196480513,
1.0155260563,
-0.3461960852,
0.133490935,
-0.10960567,
0.047038164,
0.3915398121,
-0.5452459455,
0.5507979393,
-0.8328514695,
0.332962811,
-0.0733554661,
-0.5479413867,
-0.454914391,
0.3977525532,
-0.6819801331,
0.5038011074,
-0.0545789823,
-0.732824564,
0.3894571066,
-0.6105148196,
-0.5087170601,
0.3033856153,
0.1044287905,
-0.5491955876,
0.2750836611,
0.3324744105,
0.2965250313,
0.0792546868,
0.6036232114,
-0.4924334586,
-0.0816108361,
0.4576027691,
-0.8576576114,
0.8580119014,
0.4400356412,
-0.4984395504,
0.2177893221,
-0.6562566161,
-0.195937559,
0.2656522989,
-0.1633159965,
-0.5704308152,
0.0341944806,
-0.3469482064,
0.0962428749,
0.0186747704,
-0.6165416837,
-0.0137225669,
-0.3271214962,
0.3029111028,
0.7262775898,
0.0928266123,
0.3498437405,
-0.2408542782,
0.3719823956,
0.2935091257,
0.1245451421,
-0.4198936522,
-0.4018010795,
-0.4959950745,
-0.2032303959,
0.168260932,
0.4498236477,
-0.9947522879,
0.3498693407,
-0.2051943243,
-0.2592228651,
-0.4886463583,
-0.1531317383,
0.4198547602,
0.5713656545,
0.358977437,
0.0072371857,
-0.4879612625,
-0.9111922383,
-0.6673511267,
-0.3366120756,
-0.004536374,
-0.1822244525,
0.4492714405,
0.2751046717,
1.0233248472,
-0.2156639397,
0.1320886314,
-0.3165154755,
0.0429620966,
0.1979103684,
0.2354224175,
0.4759518206,
-1.302061677,
-0.0873147398,
0.018435007,
-0.7600809932,
-0.3975317478,
-0.2821894884,
-0.0787155703,
0.2964491248,
0.3857063949,
-0.7113822103,
0.528836906,
0.3347503245,
-0.573846519,
0.7958135009,
0.2009962499,
0.0345161408,
-1.0420114994,
-0.1711222678,
0.2413282394,
-0.5340545177,
-0.6571086645,
0.1179170683,
0.0147046801,
0.104529202,
-0.409621805,
0.5932348371,
-0.255423665,
0.1468334794,
-0.639275074,
0.0872784033,
0.2727181315,
0.0789025426,
0.1817343235,
0.166850701,
0.2895057797,
-0.5418589115,
0.8287748694,
-0.1837528497,
-0.6083735228,
0.7592667341,
-0.7023727894,
-0.2927962244,
-0.1365585327,
0.5874499083,
-0.7988144159,
-0.3846990764,
0.3965156674,
-0.7578688264,
-0.0296405405,
-0.5645028353,
-0.6117878556,
-0.5407109261,
-0.0374625884,
0.1833257079,
0.3255480826,
-0.9794230461,
0.3663039207,
0.1596868634,
0.0435108542,
-0.6091929078,
-0.6487031579,
0.2835677862,
-0.5473242998,
-0.7542432547,
0.4042386413,
0.0084359627,
-0.6904552579,
0.2436718792,
-0.3980659842,
-0.1038004085,
0.1309611797,
0.1532315463,
0.2189176381,
-0.4016137421,
0.4735353291,
-0.080221571,
0.0741217732,
0.1440941989,
-0.7684985399,
0.3165402114,
-0.0636009499,
-0.5172265172,
-0.7029038072,
0.4539512396,
0.7544650435,
-0.1378781646,
0.8713706136,
0.5935609937,
-0.4610409141,
-0.5520436764,
-0.8778421879,
-0.2813760638,
-0.4459581375,
0.5016205907,
-0.1132536754,
-0.5817675591,
0.3681711853,
-0.0110683236,
-0.1207177117,
0.512070775,
0.4359295964,
0.3669350147,
0.8240636587,
0.2479232103,
-0.0503277779,
0.434935838,
0.0437088609,
0.1964804083,
0.184497267,
-0.317278862,
-0.1555899531,
-0.0665604398,
-0.1065890342,
-0.2199836969,
0.0355103947,
0.0143301161,
-0.0367450155,
0.0366769023,
-0.5140930414,
0.74481529,
0.5430650115,
0.2601226568,
0.4242925644,
0.2167866379,
0.0853139088,
0.210141927,
-0.6943009496,
-0.4235900342,
0.5678104162,
0.4949652553,
0.5218608379,
0.3800029457,
0.2766955197,
0.5682614446,
0.3211334646,
-0.8043255806,
0.4194823205,
-0.090484947,
-0.7992554903,
-0.2021722645,
-0.6642105579,
-0.5606133342,
0.4079176188,
-0.1695714295,
-0.4002608359,
0.034184292,
0.021607548,
-0.3589464128,
0.6118404269,
-0.8263782263,
0.7974115014,
-0.3730234802,
-0.4283756614,
-0.459194392,
-0.4399238825,
0.6411657333,
-0.0167798139,
0.270003885,
-0.066912353,
0.109937802,
0.5859421492,
-0.5377166271,
0.8833947778,
-0.4309569299,
-0.1243969873,
0.3782203496,
-0.0379821323,
0.2947438061,
0.3813449442,
-0.0460550748,
0.0405327678,
-0.4739232659,
-0.4853459597,
-0.4751262665,
0.7732554674,
-0.3603331149,
-0.7335999608,
-0.290548712,
-0.5244878531,
0.1363351196,
0.1793803722,
0.3948937654,
0.3261868656,
-0.3729791939,
0.0715155602,
0.9325464964,
-0.4461560547,
0.5499777198,
0.8347418308,
0.0614791624,
-0.2279218733,
1.0186355114,
0.1435426474,
0.0375219993,
0.3373574913,
0.4840112627,
-0.4319470227,
-0.6190782785,
-0.6130614877,
-0.1311556846,
-0.4590085447,
-0.2441845387,
-0.6498331428,
-0.1357553005,
-0.3940088749,
-0.0521717891,
-0.3255842924,
-0.3776513934,
-0.0138916988,
-0.1146184579,
0.4532951415,
0.6427602172,
-0.1509230584,
0.1734620631,
-0.5432035923,
0.6357440948,
0.5424569845,
0.1886610091,
0.0990766585,
-0.7803348303,
-0.2183256596,
0.2523966134,
-0.3728250563,
-1.1921169758,
0.3955906332,
-0.2183864713,
0.7084785104,
1.0034527779,
0.4925381839,
0.367584914,
-0.0406940915,
0.6830333471,
0.1817375422,
-0.9769570231,
0.5990123153,
-0.4561741948,
0.0894306749,
0.1110362262,
0.3970265687,
-0.2145396471,
-0.1158300713,
-0.8275274634,
-0.6232620478,
0.6134582162,
-0.0177901387,
0.1394317597,
0.0189344082,
0.1104820445,
0.3320172429,
0.1195771024,
-1.1939804554,
0.0948104411,
-0.5121350288,
-0.0664387494,
0.3898070157,
-0.2471888661,
-0.239369899,
0.0247544367,
0.8471084833,
-0.037555404,
0.0245192815,
0.181253776,
-0.3286906183,
0.1523730904,
0.3588787615,
0.732937932,
0.5482811928,
0.1864258498,
0.3500812352,
0.0034939249,
-0.2384958118,
0.0920325518,
0.295581311,
-0.2597685158,
0.3367281854,
0.4894124269,
0.6372798085,
-0.2373277396,
-0.6308563352,
0.9744398594,
0.0937557667,
-0.278830111,
-0.5305047631,
-0.0816388279,
0.0830195174,
0.452350378,
0.8023231626,
0.2443140447,
-0.020355951,
-0.5512350798,
0.150692597,
0.5498828888,
-0.3409335017,
-0.4227955341,
0.5020925403,
0.2484163493,
-0.079629831,
0.2802583575,
-0.515476346,
-0.7539433837,
0.7898301482,
0.564463973,
0.5854349732,
-0.3792149425,
0.5183263421,
0.0185394492,
0.4416494071,
-0.3657751381,
-0.1060980558,
0.0692995712,
-0.858535111,
-0.3985947073,
-0.4166852534,
-0.0281868707,
0.7253212929,
-0.3113908768,
0.173616752,
-0.2438913733,
0.1912006736,
0.1734535694,
-0.204752773,
-0.1494394839,
0.0872614011,
0.3992011845,
0.9776096344,
-0.9202606678,
0.5009947419,
0.5392515063,
-0.1731143445,
-0.3837961555,
0.3954244256,
0.4177523851,
-0.6124967933,
0.303099364,
0.4215762317,
-0.0187512636,
-0.4017000794,
-0.8639158607,
-0.2831362486,
0.6874899864,
0.5814751983,
-0.4356725216,
0.1375162899,
-0.165924713,
0.3336634338,
-0.4765364826,
0.0553522594,
0.0466108136,
0.609951973,
0.0678679645,
-0.4144534171,
0.2101503015,
-0.2949478328,
-0.3271417916,
-0.1626758277,
-0.7794695497,
0.58787328,
-0.3803076446,
-0.1672769934,
0.0523209199,
0.8953388929,
0.3224604726,
1.0522531271,
0.6965030432,
0.672883749,
0.6746683717,
-0.0579880923,
0.8868396878,
0.0491352268,
-0.0091197491,
0.8933885694,
0.0192723852,
0.4530432224,
0.1569273621,
0.2059832811,
0.828666389,
0.6052430272,
-0.3143049777,
0.4657703042,
0.369050771,
-0.6353405118,
-0.5079298019,
-0.3033164144,
-0.3299779892,
0.7086515427,
0.3365336955,
-0.5182266831,
-0.1167858317,
0.2001256049,
0.242948845,
0.2863060534,
-0.4624367058,
0.5065198541,
-0.0905155689,
-0.8651919365,
0.3604592383,
0.1235614866,
0.7608440518,
-0.5191649199,
-0.0066845915,
-0.0972128808,
0.213872999,
-0.3738471866,
-0.620536983,
0.1274262667,
0.1121479124,
-0.443257004,
-0.1622992605,
0.9818800092,
-0.4608960152,
-0.1405002177,
0.1302958578,
0.5877091289,
0.0455211923,
-0.5506297946,
-0.4112690985,
-0.2108062059,
-0.1030354649,
-0.3651884794,
0.2088901103,
0.8134468198,
-0.2412811965,
0.5882543921,
0.9030402303,
0.0018332481,
-0.2183151543,
0.1132127568,
0.8791871667,
-0.3549160957,
-0.8161511421,
-1.0605077744,
0.2637659013,
-0.5877045393,
-0.0792806894,
0.7731810808,
0.5550348759,
0.4589009881,
-0.0845245272,
1.0394679308,
0.0916413888,
0.5085390806,
-0.5780231953,
1.0347607136,
-0.541913569,
0.2929053009,
-0.1251119375,
-0.6594982147,
-0.038630072,
0.3851867318,
-0.1154493839,
0.0248625558,
0.5013614297,
0.7195622325,
-0.2810941041,
0.1569322497,
0.2790156305,
0.4491140842,
0.1592430919,
0.4126125276,
1.076974988,
0.0716026649,
0.9664185047,
0.098267287,
-0.3004545569,
-0.4059044123,
-1.0056397915,
-0.9311591387,
-0.411693275,
-0.3283299208,
-0.7044191957,
0.2334240079,
0.3850749433,
1.0741579533,
-0.7093920708,
0.4764639139,
-0.1912436783,
0.4662993252,
-0.2713160217,
-0.4144232273,
0.204520762,
0.1709592789,
-0.4105536342,
0.7283457518,
0.0084322626,
0.1273499578,
-0.2566635907,
-0.0597128235,
-0.1416829377,
0.3177429438,
0.4287614226,
0.5504406095,
-0.8861823678,
-0.3504428566,
-0.2531030774,
0.1459785104,
-0.3837535977,
0.6815143228,
-1.0999652147,
0.3885170817,
0.4592007399,
0.513292551,
0.2617252767,
0.2100794911,
0.4988338053,
-0.8627350926,
0.1798761487,
0.0462564304,
0.2064364105,
0.4278179407,
-0.4365692139,
0.3083513677,
0.6667592525,
-0.3332745135,
-0.8101072311,
0.3825895488,
-1.0182534456,
-0.7121661305,
1.2110767365,
-0.2164380401,
-0.1849040836,
-0.4901786149,
0.1246639937,
0.2104552835,
-0.6454755664,
1.0014929771,
0.7009701133,
0.3457376063,
-0.1436029375,
-0.4394799769,
0.3423374295,
0.232395798,
-0.7342088819,
0.0826204792,
0.5979070067,
0.371262908,
0.2756820619,
0.3084454238,
-0.1101477221,
0.5896548033,
0.097468704,
-0.1398762167,
-0.3657850325,
-0.2476426214,
-0.3365133405,
0.3370325267,
-0.5986155868,
-0.1064704508
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03359v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03359v1
|
MedDoc-Bot: A Chat Tool for Comparative Analysis of Large Language Models in the Context of the Pediatric Hypertension Guideline
| 2024-05-06T11:11:23 | 2024-05-06T11:11:23 |
Mohamed Yaseen Jabarulla, Steffen Oeltze-Jafra, Philipp Beerbaum, Theodor Uden
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
This research focuses on evaluating the non-commercial open-source large
language models (LLMs) Meditron, MedAlpaca, Mistral, and Llama-2 for their
efficacy in interpreting medical guidelines saved in PDF format. As a specific
test scenario, we applied these models to the guidelines for hypertension in
children and adolescents provided by the European Society of Cardiology (ESC).
Leveraging Streamlit, a Python library, we developed a user-friendly medical
document chatbot tool (MedDoc-Bot). This tool enables authorized users to
upload PDF files and pose questions, generating interpretive responses from
four locally stored LLMs. A pediatric expert provides a benchmark for
evaluation by formulating questions and responses extracted from the ESC
guidelines. The expert rates the model-generated responses based on their
fidelity and relevance. Additionally, we evaluated the METEOR and chrF metric
scores to assess the similarity of model responses to reference answers. Our
study found that Llama-2 and Mistral performed well in metrics evaluation.
However, Llama-2 was slower when dealing with text and tabular data. In our
human evaluation, we observed that responses created by Mistral, Meditron, and
Llama-2 exhibited reasonable fidelity and relevance. This study provides
valuable insights into the strengths and limitations of LLMs for future
developments in medical document interpretation. Open-Source Code:
https://github.com/yaseen28/MedDoc-Bot
|
[
-0.111689508,
-0.7880675793,
0.8683399558,
0.1161896661,
-0.3519727886,
-0.1797062457,
-0.2206514478,
-0.3836193383,
-0.1650661975,
0.5630934834,
-0.4224092364,
-0.6593890786,
-0.8170182705,
0.3682746589,
-0.2769905925,
1.2233103514,
-0.0780264214,
0.2469409406,
-0.3858775198,
0.3037381768,
-0.0050409022,
-0.2406067699,
-0.7101734281,
-0.3837584555,
0.5823796391,
0.3165304363,
0.7896457314,
0.6273357868,
1.1962372065,
0.2821439207,
-0.391430825,
0.0705029368,
-0.3881501853,
0.278128773,
-0.2163630873,
-0.244070664,
-0.7087862492,
-0.1504755318,
0.4050943553,
0.4267175198,
-0.2009614855,
0.1540356725,
0.1053506657,
0.5023413897,
-0.2743190527,
0.5008944273,
-0.477501452,
-0.1873519719,
-0.0596575476,
-0.6067358255,
-0.3080948293,
-0.2721568346,
0.4134779572,
-0.5936587453,
0.1329656094,
-0.0368756801,
0.8851829171,
0.3250292242,
-0.4733911753,
-0.6236841679,
-0.5900786519,
0.6242780685,
-1.0132912397,
0.243632704,
0.4660693407,
0.3134039342,
-0.3795492351,
-0.8454043269,
-0.6539856791,
-0.3559761345,
0.00217399,
0.2927353382,
-0.3312527239,
0.2951135635,
0.0995689034,
0.3749811947,
-0.7351286411,
0.2649931908,
-0.6616610885,
-0.1093530804,
0.30681023,
0.2670888901,
0.1290216297,
-0.3583588302,
-0.2498150468,
-0.1164138913,
-0.6111697555,
-0.2384670824,
0.2318098247,
0.1291315109,
-0.3980337977,
0.587865293,
0.0189608168,
0.645401299,
-0.2834766805,
-0.5519472957,
0.2804209888,
-0.1666410118,
-0.2011001408,
-0.3019932508,
1.0569961071,
0.7588648796,
0.4789720178,
0.176679045,
-0.0812596977,
-0.1005906612,
0.4096702635,
-0.8177861571,
-0.1139193326,
0.3784545362,
-0.8306997418,
-0.5858341455,
-0.1770378649,
-0.7896367908,
-0.6291227937,
-0.3652266264,
0.0032962686,
-0.1490812898,
-0.020800706,
-0.0728835464,
-0.0823922604,
-0.0011269009,
0.5272607803,
-0.6384299397,
0.4502644539,
0.8976100087,
0.9894769788,
-0.2712184489,
-0.2198198736,
-0.1191910356,
-0.0822147503,
-0.2437007874,
1.0590891838,
-0.3891082108,
-0.7391844988,
0.0379629917,
0.1139617413,
0.0173987132,
-0.6350296736,
0.914690733,
-0.0082331179,
0.2408756167,
0.2972382009,
-0.5208230615,
0.0893918276,
0.2664338648,
-0.5523877144,
0.7932069898,
0.1996734291,
-0.8772429824,
0.1910335571,
-0.6036561131,
-0.3220034838,
0.09897203,
-0.3577837944,
-0.3410712183,
-0.141294688,
0.3682447672,
0.5119300485,
-0.9150724411,
0.3328675926,
-0.325769037,
-0.1996107697,
0.2565300167,
-0.6497040987,
0.4717350006,
0.2855611145,
0.1146860346,
0.4620396793,
-0.4722338319,
-0.0678608865,
0.182919085,
-0.5122150779,
-0.0138919475,
0.1615813076,
0.3778339922,
0.2887583971,
0.1757865846,
-0.43853423,
0.156939134,
-0.1879788637,
0.599185884,
0.8259046674,
0.3016375899,
-0.1277550459,
-0.509393096,
0.6010711789,
-0.3827778697,
0.6881043315,
-0.0384919159,
-0.7773771882,
-0.3545520604,
-0.4243177772,
-0.0550051183,
0.2744722068,
-0.5525410175,
0.5176292658,
-0.5289620757,
-0.7472449541,
-0.5361328125,
0.0579305217,
0.2108947933,
0.9064059854,
0.1721565872,
-0.0892144367,
-0.3985973299,
-0.9921554327,
0.1003101468,
-0.5498151779,
-0.1837527752,
0.7254055738,
0.6410284638,
-0.3530034125,
0.4792697132,
-0.4292121232,
-0.2733332813,
-0.1955380142,
-0.0492783524,
0.4429536462,
0.2988871038,
0.4299715161,
-0.6066498756,
-0.5762569308,
0.0388214178,
-0.5628976226,
-0.3684952259,
0.0583001748,
-0.0032580467,
-0.1233038977,
0.4615437984,
-0.3684177995,
0.3245347142,
0.9536830783,
-0.2992811799,
0.5211483836,
-0.4057364464,
0.2129851282,
-1.0392006636,
0.2541826963,
0.1336793154,
-0.3275302649,
-0.4515380263,
-0.095202446,
0.0497275181,
-0.183104977,
-0.6031433344,
0.7634545565,
0.0673127174,
0.2627153695,
-0.2611045837,
0.3252376914,
-0.2064892352,
0.3056013882,
0.1363414377,
0.8019381762,
0.4946824312,
-0.1601140052,
0.4054766893,
0.1159436554,
-0.1947494,
0.6724178195,
-1.1122105122,
0.011279216,
0.0819314122,
0.5421960354,
-0.8267595172,
-0.1582796425,
0.2792808115,
-0.4796549082,
0.0782587081,
-0.3964241743,
-0.8341781497,
-0.5774303079,
-0.3414029181,
0.0293621477,
0.5523384809,
-0.3108538389,
0.1839845479,
0.5392386913,
-0.5141584277,
-0.3017317653,
-0.2510184348,
-0.0638202131,
0.0460538156,
-0.4395123124,
0.0859929025,
-0.1113389358,
-0.209705919,
0.0423340462,
-0.3439922035,
-0.2643474638,
-0.154857263,
0.6168476343,
0.6554735303,
-0.2333657146,
0.163984254,
0.1578087956,
-0.0979534388,
0.0346675441,
-0.0504626706,
0.6185735464,
-0.3476599753,
-0.2220216691,
-0.5697462559,
0.068226181,
0.9582080841,
0.0804931149,
0.6808975935,
0.2743126452,
-0.2566550076,
0.0657765195,
-0.3603225648,
-0.0749364346,
-0.4109216332,
0.2763112783,
0.0379679278,
-0.5144981742,
0.1800248921,
-0.250050813,
0.1640710235,
0.6707957387,
0.9883375168,
-0.2984212935,
0.8359203339,
0.48452124,
0.0188459102,
0.3514313698,
-0.2233729064,
-0.2662945092,
-0.9444997907,
-0.2267040014,
-0.6332889199,
-0.0572310723,
-0.4649197757,
-0.5684409738,
0.4799413681,
-0.250503242,
-0.11920809,
0.2519811988,
-0.5610271692,
0.341540724,
0.0886783749,
-0.0055076825,
0.392254144,
-0.0858111531,
-0.1626915783,
-0.0460467599,
-0.6052712798,
-0.9191157222,
1.5352303982,
0.5861960649,
0.9520549774,
-0.0568631664,
0.3746204674,
0.3763225377,
0.6980404854,
-1.0034432411,
0.356223166,
-0.226375252,
-0.7370173335,
-0.1232448593,
-0.478594631,
-1.0385785103,
0.3792492151,
-0.4707517922,
-0.8775978684,
-0.1983287632,
-0.1811483353,
-0.1939216852,
0.2156995982,
-0.642363131,
0.793035686,
-0.2088586241,
-0.090657644,
-0.3400433064,
-0.491071105,
0.0612025261,
-0.3441067636,
0.1820199937,
-0.3083861768,
-0.3449512124,
0.8102037311,
-0.6626932621,
0.6943215728,
0.2932762802,
-0.2159291059,
0.1044131592,
-0.0540348068,
0.2414296716,
0.1436425894,
-0.1752004027,
0.3266247213,
0.4070487916,
-0.3357637525,
-0.6382111907,
0.8970637321,
-0.911053896,
-0.4030164182,
-0.529045105,
-0.4730619192,
-0.0502100326,
0.3962497711,
0.0295567438,
0.5105101466,
-0.2354816496,
0.4199324846,
0.1829939634,
-0.2357026935,
-0.0114086419,
0.7723736167,
-0.1553779691,
-0.3977077901,
0.3793368936,
-0.2270875424,
0.2799315751,
0.2953827381,
0.6095126271,
-0.2637907565,
-0.5247632861,
-0.312264353,
0.6980547309,
-0.7859640121,
0.0455621406,
-0.4648091793,
-0.4082718194,
-0.4056604803,
-0.1800574064,
-0.1185481101,
-0.1781189293,
-0.0293928552,
0.1949162036,
0.3679542243,
0.7651744485,
0.246164009,
0.4671747386,
-0.7675133348,
0.1743629128,
-0.1615355164,
0.2269792408,
-0.0765707046,
-0.5101916194,
0.1048441306,
-0.3655677736,
-0.4153535962,
-0.9230747819,
0.2342431992,
-0.0731819868,
0.5802678466,
0.6513050199,
-0.0339294374,
0.3937237263,
-0.5084053278,
0.6093419194,
0.183251828,
-0.5993146896,
0.6475498676,
-0.514983952,
0.1655182391,
0.4879254997,
0.5044159293,
-0.8171104789,
-0.457028389,
-0.6719788909,
-0.6903947592,
0.5253865719,
0.4410570562,
-0.1468968242,
0.1274515092,
0.0704974979,
0.1808784753,
0.1801134646,
-0.2936769724,
-0.1033488065,
0.2794279754,
-0.4760959446,
-0.1979964375,
-0.1131174117,
-0.3331629336,
-0.0339261182,
0.4363870323,
-0.0498336479,
0.0759769604,
0.3594846129,
0.1470789313,
-0.1473555118,
0.357601434,
0.6777953506,
0.8834852576,
-0.386308372,
0.1163853109,
-0.067296885,
-0.9208210111,
-0.2764506638,
0.2114874572,
-0.0601855852,
0.1056105494,
0.7981160879,
0.4232878387,
0.1558191627,
-0.967599988,
0.6516531706,
-0.3365646899,
-0.2029319853,
-0.1486749798,
-0.0735049397,
-0.0028291065,
0.0426074192,
-0.0365524478,
0.0149663277,
-0.1511926055,
-0.5238510966,
0.0867107809,
-0.0979390219,
-0.4151069224,
-0.1113748699,
0.4682537019,
0.4192667007,
-0.3994342983,
0.5587902069,
0.3328489959,
-0.3253675401,
0.6381537914,
0.4202544689,
0.4797784686,
0.0820467621,
0.1390837729,
0.3073625267,
0.3263574839,
0.1526285708,
0.3283765018,
-0.0811108425,
-0.2235813141,
-0.2165549397,
-0.2582559288,
-0.6313638687,
0.3455322981,
-0.4400200844,
0.254688561,
-0.6372776031,
-0.4656290114,
0.3141036928,
0.1336084306,
-0.7131494284,
-0.0825561285,
-0.0432258025,
0.8811665773,
-0.673309207,
0.8380224705,
0.720023334,
-0.4882999659,
-0.635981977,
0.1814803779,
0.4617572725,
-0.7820782065,
0.5153024197,
-0.2385179251,
-0.0506590977,
-0.4111087918,
-0.4857114553,
-0.5565315485,
0.9792866111,
0.0215986948,
-0.5072163343,
-0.1701533198,
-0.00705428,
0.9616333246,
-0.2052108049,
0.653003037,
0.3506895304,
0.283272028,
0.0136563508,
-1.3542140722,
-0.1041753963,
-0.4085688889,
-0.3674893975,
-0.0084799305,
-0.4601375759,
0.741792798,
-0.0936916471,
0.01213161,
0.2404887229,
0.0542682447,
0.2073399127,
0.1116069108,
0.3373767734,
0.1662870795,
0.675819695,
-0.0074617229,
1.3186110258,
-0.4448759854,
0.5924094915,
1.0795099735,
-0.116519466,
1.099085331,
0.6336781383,
-0.416017741,
0.3272613585,
0.6010130644,
-0.0908804163,
0.2411789745,
0.2078400105,
-0.0089214211,
0.0249358658,
-0.2871716619,
-0.3111181855,
0.0982050821,
0.5376372337,
-0.5711624622,
-0.4551314712,
-0.3325204849,
0.2781950831,
-0.0966041684,
-0.2585682273,
0.6835576296,
0.3328466415,
-0.5319207311,
0.6288986206,
-0.0847770497,
0.4721280038,
-0.6958896518,
-0.1131081507,
-0.0189501736,
0.4065116644,
-0.338658303,
-1.1655544043,
-0.0033255294,
0.5430589914,
0.011260584,
-0.0184528492,
0.5747614503,
-0.0542383268,
-0.4214863777,
0.199854359,
0.5001303554,
0.5433425903,
0.1563813239,
-0.9995340109,
0.0049289111,
-0.3430483937,
-0.0860283971,
0.0392884351,
0.2294775248,
-0.0494259447,
1.0274041891,
0.9170370102,
0.6749734879,
-0.3066907823,
0.3657402098,
0.7545329332,
-0.1706790328,
-0.3143874705,
-0.7059438229,
0.0961529166,
-0.0920300782,
-0.6243326068,
0.6545760632,
0.5731867552,
0.616199255,
-0.1227590591,
0.6060596704,
0.0345130339,
0.6363668442,
-0.248343274,
0.9416961074,
-0.5954202414,
0.0978390351,
-0.3771000504,
-0.7073966265,
-0.3262989819,
0.5039060712,
-0.433734715,
-0.2981396914,
0.9767765999,
0.7757166624,
0.0335177183,
-0.2153150737,
0.1473641843,
0.0887498781,
0.6661779881,
0.5008836389,
0.8836172223,
-0.187986359,
0.7566568851,
-0.1443130821,
-0.2950745225,
-0.4473806024,
-0.5667833686,
-1.0157436132,
-0.4915753603,
-0.1690200865,
-0.3140639663,
0.0936088413,
1.1406266689,
0.7922437191,
-0.5537794232,
-0.1722504944,
0.1985374242,
0.1293258667,
-0.0981976986,
-0.1700665802,
0.6231247783,
0.047786396,
-0.7728276253,
0.1212278306,
0.3229215741,
0.2119974047,
-0.154633373,
-0.1010507569,
0.1376501173,
0.0814002901,
0.3601825833,
0.2079210132,
-0.856132865,
0.0368211232,
-0.0307973828,
-0.5728355646,
0.15206559,
0.9712000489,
-0.3650996983,
0.7079329491,
0.6952022314,
0.2897512615,
0.2663249671,
-0.0775756016,
0.4299789369,
-0.020612929,
0.1539137065,
0.3198932409,
0.4286773801,
0.0873355567,
-0.0547153838,
0.6458126903,
0.0640775412,
-0.5790408254,
-0.6995367408,
-0.1358698159,
-1.0498052835,
-0.3288903236,
1.2862021923,
-0.1862997413,
-0.3050391376,
-0.0681208596,
-0.6152635813,
0.2099415511,
-0.647618711,
0.6412382126,
0.5676050782,
-0.0940045267,
0.1880895942,
-1.0184799433,
0.3264623582,
-0.0288537759,
-0.95679456,
-0.0750234649,
0.1447939873,
0.3088363707,
-0.0294813346,
0.6422265768,
-0.4579045177,
0.2903767824,
0.1199432239,
-0.1307427436,
-0.0288474299,
-0.1498270184,
-0.4109635353,
-0.2771710753,
0.1539461315,
0.0651893243
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06684v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06684v1
|
QuakeBERT: Accurate Classification of Social Media Texts for Rapid Earthquake Impact Assessment
| 2024-05-06T10:52:21 | 2024-05-06T10:52:21 |
Jin Han, Zhe Zheng, Xin-Zheng Lu, Ke-Yin Chen, Jia-Rui Lin
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG, cs.SI
|
Social media aids disaster response but suffers from noise, hindering
accurate impact assessment and decision making for resilient cities, which few
studies considered. To address the problem, this study proposes the first
domain-specific LLM model and an integrated method for rapid earthquake impact
assessment. First, a few categories are introduced to classify and filter
microblogs considering their relationship to the physical and social impacts of
earthquakes, and a dataset comprising 7282 earthquake-related microblogs from
twenty earthquakes in different locations is developed as well. Then, with a
systematic analysis of various influential factors, QuakeBERT, a
domain-specific large language model (LLM), is developed and fine-tuned for
accurate classification and filtering of microblogs. Meanwhile, an integrated
method integrating public opinion trend analysis, sentiment analysis, and
keyword-based physical impact quantification is introduced to assess both the
physical and social impacts of earthquakes based on social media texts.
Experiments show that data diversity and data volume dominate the performance
of QuakeBERT and increase the macro average F1 score by 27%, while the best
classification model QuakeBERT outperforms the CNN- or RNN-based models by
improving the macro average F1 score from 60.87% to 84.33%. Finally, the
proposed approach is applied to assess two earthquakes with the same magnitude
and focal depth. Results show that the proposed approach can effectively
enhance the impact assessment process by accurate detection of noisy
microblogs, which enables effective post-disaster emergency responses to create
more resilient cities.
|
[
-0.4248872697,
-1.111122489,
0.4497953951,
0.9854528904,
-0.4526972771,
0.2726556957,
-0.2527045608,
-0.6426714659,
0.5431687236,
0.1397596896,
-0.0188611168,
-0.6695619822,
-0.9553522468,
0.1527807117,
-0.7055764198,
0.7133843899,
-0.0322472788,
0.096631363,
0.012616897,
-0.1676429212,
-0.1151677668,
0.0378917418,
-0.5958333611,
-0.1317557842,
0.4993147552,
0.0590573326,
0.7905306816,
0.0078289723,
0.8150092959,
0.2410972416,
-0.5263059735,
0.0640320554,
-0.6309856176,
-0.6305267215,
0.0178563949,
0.0196184237,
-0.327391088,
-0.1181416586,
0.5476580858,
0.3497097492,
-0.0733457059,
0.515017271,
0.2805733681,
0.1735349745,
-0.4341091216,
0.051865451,
-0.2627751231,
-0.0548960306,
0.3166176677,
-0.6477890015,
-0.2450546771,
-1.0220059156,
0.3213486075,
0.1151404381,
0.0154517069,
-0.1686222702,
0.5030292869,
0.3647089899,
-0.487021625,
-0.1362358332,
-0.8780296445,
0.6657193899,
-0.3422980011,
0.4130714536,
-0.000265599,
0.279594332,
-0.0756472871,
-0.6126616597,
-0.3362908959,
0.1745393872,
0.1936559975,
-0.0093032783,
-0.0397119932,
-0.1293667406,
0.0131963063,
0.1428080648,
-0.3498451412,
-0.2521497309,
-0.5940282941,
0.0564794429,
0.8260855675,
0.381437093,
0.1621529311,
-0.4981615841,
-0.7510183454,
0.0032726533,
-0.569598496,
0.2975792587,
0.0953716338,
0.4430921078,
-0.3817512095,
0.1708676666,
-0.2599239647,
0.2999117672,
-0.0441957191,
-0.573071301,
0.1876732409,
-0.2240106314,
-0.2389314622,
0.2679377794,
1.0672510862,
0.4635744989,
0.2022887319,
-0.1042437032,
0.0565473959,
-0.2234187722,
0.3783701062,
-1.0970956087,
-0.1150223687,
0.3753940165,
-0.583368361,
-1.0133664608,
0.1036905199,
-0.7944526672,
-0.934015274,
-0.1551263928,
0.5027858615,
-0.0500489548,
-0.3765084445,
0.2856209278,
0.1285745502,
-0.0043035303,
0.7300539613,
-0.2036682069,
0.0082391817,
0.4642257094,
1.0550662279,
0.3420170546,
-0.1443765014,
-0.1534082592,
-0.3046768308,
-0.0979059413,
1.2205566168,
-0.3193908632,
-0.4181478918,
0.3689134717,
-0.0225822516,
0.3525079489,
-0.2590726316,
0.7540003061,
-0.5716599822,
-0.321652025,
-0.0389960445,
-0.1347390562,
-0.6596776247,
0.157566756,
-0.5290858746,
1.1979510784,
0.181794256,
-1.1775943041,
0.430840224,
-0.0668620467,
-0.6925783753,
0.0920620859,
0.0990052,
-0.2775824666,
0.1960393488,
0.3186234236,
0.6539233327,
-0.655294776,
0.479605943,
-0.6207401752,
-0.459690541,
-0.0866620317,
-0.3530648351,
1.0573716164,
-0.1250426173,
-0.264495194,
0.0176923312,
-0.9604843855,
0.1301630139,
0.0933041424,
-0.7590531707,
-0.2754517496,
0.380528152,
0.2031022906,
0.1008398607,
0.1418180615,
-0.3161380589,
0.1597581059,
0.0625834391,
0.0892480761,
0.5538586378,
0.2631260455,
0.2576534748,
-0.0273597781,
0.2153168023,
-0.2446828932,
0.5469095111,
0.3128741086,
-0.4026124775,
-0.1830138564,
-0.3643543124,
0.4396253228,
0.728605628,
-0.4094608128,
0.4423331618,
-0.7029889822,
-0.8772276044,
-0.8112672567,
-0.0370163657,
-0.1132688448,
0.2222575843,
0.3966619372,
-0.0735912919,
-0.7184282541,
-0.2685410976,
-0.3394858837,
-0.3074425757,
0.1273152232,
0.2727657855,
0.2362753153,
-0.4979038239,
0.7940853238,
-0.3094483614,
0.0679297969,
-0.2629496157,
0.3827249706,
0.1416080445,
-0.4097309411,
0.671158433,
-0.9194999933,
-0.6360318065,
-0.2136250287,
-0.853710115,
-0.3692369461,
-0.0491008051,
0.2654533982,
-0.5720145702,
0.0224858839,
-0.2921270728,
0.4690586925,
0.5264441371,
-0.166018486,
0.4088811576,
0.3669172227,
0.4221907258,
-0.8936390281,
-0.3377647102,
0.1930335462,
-0.5119520426,
-0.7162851691,
-0.3412195742,
0.1161130741,
-0.1088609621,
-0.7997330427,
0.4655708075,
-0.1230877265,
0.1303248554,
-0.4867027104,
0.2338270247,
-0.2016040385,
-0.2224211544,
-0.147670418,
0.210511595,
0.5471255183,
-0.5000625849,
0.2656215429,
0.2332130373,
-0.6689860225,
0.1954920292,
-0.7913233042,
-0.054087963,
-0.1946728081,
0.5003067255,
-0.8769239187,
-0.1461506039,
0.196521461,
-0.4669228196,
-0.0200978778,
-0.0796898454,
-0.6194158196,
-0.5567694306,
-0.7181255817,
0.1378553063,
0.2889475822,
-0.7950328588,
0.9052298069,
0.6080793738,
-0.2323744744,
-0.3631466627,
-0.4646244943,
0.1007477865,
-0.3502036929,
-1.0370839834,
-0.1300822198,
-0.0709600151,
-0.327884376,
-0.0745102987,
0.044208657,
-0.2521232963,
0.2236547768,
0.3968474269,
-0.0278424341,
0.1636141986,
-0.0055499882,
-0.1217462942,
0.1552272439,
0.1109205335,
0.4309074283,
0.5994471908,
-0.1847922653,
0.358743161,
-0.4583564997,
-0.0917208493,
0.6294508576,
0.109611325,
0.8961399794,
0.7807132602,
-0.2580967844,
-0.1342522204,
-0.5147996545,
-0.0606287159,
-0.4180592,
0.0552669875,
-0.0943411663,
-0.8918139935,
0.4643873274,
-0.7286371589,
0.0150195612,
0.3306773901,
0.6628568769,
-0.1654611379,
0.6954402328,
0.6857175231,
-0.5102220774,
0.429615736,
-0.1330918819,
0.4910223186,
-0.5397222638,
0.0004728194,
-0.5127583742,
-0.2618099749,
-0.2432792932,
-0.345839113,
0.3422240913,
0.1763071865,
0.1739441454,
0.5178097486,
-0.5573621988,
0.1759361625,
-0.0483914651,
0.4163100123,
0.2177036405,
0.1803119779,
0.5711935163,
0.1798081398,
-0.4460263848,
-0.5704393387,
0.9388814569,
0.4988393486,
1.1036239862,
-0.0011649348,
0.8669432402,
0.6663060188,
0.8336694241,
-0.6690915227,
0.4666404128,
0.218155548,
-0.5447849035,
-0.1073178574,
-0.5180020928,
-0.5045024753,
0.3209763169,
-0.5023668408,
-0.7025888562,
0.2718863189,
-0.1131379828,
-0.5880441666,
0.1674167216,
-0.4401108325,
0.2352052629,
-0.4147873521,
-0.0989748836,
-0.4186409116,
-0.5653712153,
0.3477611244,
-0.2255205363,
0.6258955598,
-0.3315188289,
0.2825632691,
0.4475867152,
-0.0491442829,
1.1114512682,
-0.08028166,
-0.0574659705,
1.0190945864,
0.0655209944,
0.7850495577,
0.1481105089,
-0.0203329343,
0.5872963667,
-0.3693786263,
-0.0232035536,
-0.4730275571,
0.5945387483,
-0.8219735622,
-0.2573739588,
-0.0529281907,
-0.2991441786,
0.2610175908,
-0.0184697937,
0.0638147444,
0.3530569375,
-0.4857436121,
0.1583830565,
0.4184431732,
-0.0141791096,
0.3641639054,
0.7552293539,
-0.3455039263,
-0.8248699903,
0.8274772763,
0.1849766076,
-0.4005971253,
0.2592207789,
0.3903468847,
-0.0956726745,
-0.4029381871,
-0.00723253,
0.079663597,
-0.6773074865,
-0.2740368545,
-0.8380420804,
-0.0261796117,
-0.3637700677,
-0.3679851294,
-0.2380994111,
-0.2213435769,
-0.0447959751,
-0.1789941788,
0.1414249092,
0.5966356397,
-0.1531987339,
0.354169637,
-1.0274579525,
0.2235500216,
-0.0395159051,
0.1613317281,
-0.1233182028,
-0.4394417405,
-0.4718574286,
-0.2547527552,
-0.3114247322,
-0.8591552973,
0.1972973198,
-0.0758376569,
-0.103220135,
0.7049749494,
0.167328164,
0.581713438,
-0.6152645946,
0.4904164672,
0.3501333594,
-0.4940180779,
0.5070179105,
-0.2947379947,
-0.0377057493,
0.5529776812,
0.6813567877,
-0.2566514313,
-0.1977002919,
-0.6706886888,
-0.8636989594,
0.1668379605,
0.0885593668,
0.0174172223,
-0.3466221094,
0.0850671828,
-0.1853518188,
0.1772030592,
-0.6962787509,
0.0996625647,
0.086034894,
-0.0536444075,
0.1953061372,
-0.6704220176,
-0.3127909601,
-0.4946497977,
0.3508412242,
0.1688610911,
0.2987150252,
0.3039348125,
-0.2410240471,
-0.3001597524,
-0.0416965932,
0.4682240784,
0.4089009166,
-0.3649585843,
0.2856138647,
0.5505885482,
-0.5845760107,
0.1103214175,
-0.0055849035,
-0.2774683535,
0.2496033162,
0.6003901362,
0.2006855309,
0.4429039657,
-0.4633933306,
0.5503284931,
-0.1381058693,
-0.0587459169,
-0.270214051,
-0.2615788877,
0.231728971,
0.8140680194,
0.1847272366,
0.0626423955,
0.3743723631,
-0.2974130213,
0.0014030779,
-0.0834472179,
-0.472772032,
-0.5901690722,
0.559515655,
0.5481466651,
-0.2942022979,
0.1032167226,
-0.0522906221,
-0.5968036056,
0.5553658009,
0.1696050465,
1.188929677,
-0.5642790794,
0.2594915628,
0.5882422924,
0.5655334592,
-0.3953945339,
0.6032065749,
0.159577921,
-0.7623114586,
-0.1233075261,
-0.8756839633,
-0.1084015667,
-0.1314949244,
-0.232155025,
0.6294075847,
-0.8118274808,
-0.6271185875,
-0.1127891093,
-0.0192739218,
-0.6283183694,
0.4206097126,
0.0039825547,
1.0505467653,
-0.9809109569,
0.2574586272,
0.9514729977,
-0.3822795451,
-0.6901683211,
0.339195013,
0.0239638239,
-0.5341261625,
0.4088350236,
0.2074455768,
-0.2918124199,
-0.1011319235,
-0.8350293636,
-0.7709581852,
1.0181138515,
0.054838907,
-0.322675705,
0.4241288304,
0.354753077,
0.7533553839,
-0.2826197743,
0.2433960885,
0.3102121651,
0.535797596,
-0.2361833453,
-0.7265361547,
0.0644235909,
0.0971442237,
-0.0480223484,
0.3785740137,
-1.3110878468,
0.3116407096,
-0.3258876503,
-0.2964895666,
-0.4448298514,
0.6797468066,
-0.2751094699,
0.5307492614,
0.541721344,
0.7097632885,
0.6049960256,
-0.0318357572,
1.2686027288,
-0.6042736173,
0.9699567556,
0.8326804638,
0.0170236472,
0.8842113018,
0.0595730394,
-0.3448112011,
0.2732218504,
0.8027045727,
0.0326587483,
0.7225806713,
0.0808097869,
-0.5447198153,
-0.0513624437,
-0.2297397256,
-0.1349877268,
0.3040608764,
0.1437843442,
-0.4498903155,
-0.3156032562,
-0.0831704736,
0.3082247972,
-0.5265510082,
-0.3083719313,
0.4572835267,
0.1647104919,
0.1588570625,
0.427085191,
-0.0997424275,
0.3260751069,
-0.039428208,
0.2892620564,
-0.0370354801,
0.1043078303,
-0.5916700363,
-0.8115825057,
0.3737798631,
0.0614312142,
-0.2495750189,
0.1574775279,
1.1510746479,
-0.2141031474,
-0.586517036,
0.7520788908,
0.2823399007,
0.178804636,
-0.1329378933,
-0.3637381494,
0.3111713231,
-0.0993213207,
-0.5395357609,
0.015376566,
0.6266818047,
0.1382143945,
0.6337509155,
0.1436576843,
-0.0866197199,
0.1412244141,
0.269541651,
0.9798653126,
-0.5830588341,
-0.1850604564,
-0.6970253587,
0.5964277983,
-0.0818122029,
-0.1827288568,
0.6255469918,
0.2988449633,
0.1826425195,
0.0529075563,
0.9080992937,
-0.3515039682,
0.3987824321,
0.2243909389,
0.5930040479,
-0.5611010194,
0.2669765055,
-0.4047351182,
-1.1165999174,
-0.4412857592,
0.4529803097,
-0.3981380165,
-0.194082588,
0.5027469993,
0.417542249,
0.0045963093,
0.0665005744,
0.1744430065,
0.5072634816,
0.2338656336,
-0.0369922481,
0.7777523994,
-0.6042669415,
0.8170138001,
-0.1296539009,
-0.590395093,
-0.5942097306,
-0.590038836,
-1.1322243214,
0.0396803021,
-0.322124213,
-0.5711404085,
-0.0699555129,
0.8453813195,
0.2201379985,
-0.5262976289,
0.055213552,
0.521797061,
0.1993535161,
0.0350635573,
-0.3288651705,
0.4796064794,
0.0813607201,
-0.4056695104,
0.394832164,
0.6701101065,
-0.1636097282,
-0.0845690668,
0.0984932408,
0.0146407504,
0.3507514596,
1.0390739441,
-0.0167957246,
-0.3772345483,
-0.7728854418,
-0.2709199488,
-0.2830449045,
0.016591398,
0.5347148776,
-0.4274412096,
0.3269103467,
0.7428597212,
0.689293623,
0.0929055735,
0.2042582184,
-0.1339049339,
-0.5493171215,
0.2212989628,
0.0258608535,
0.2862558961,
0.3459405601,
-0.4744887352,
0.9713181853,
0.4169193208,
-0.678270638,
-0.6385061741,
-0.2173799872,
-0.8683820963,
-0.0102143204,
1.3775464296,
0.0657620206,
-0.1269419342,
-0.0708416328,
-0.1524164677,
0.2707951963,
-0.3477204442,
1.6412867308,
0.798615694,
0.0451738648,
-0.256321609,
-0.5012069345,
0.0586779788,
-0.1818695813,
-0.5643177629,
-0.3015606999,
0.1277923882,
0.2179876566,
0.3347610831,
0.6930872202,
0.0209891945,
0.1936186254,
0.05433226,
0.2530211806,
0.4723727107,
-0.6668916941,
-0.1418168545,
0.4151892364,
-0.2509108782,
0.2977401614
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2407.00020v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2407.00020v1
|
Visual Language Model based Cross-modal Semantic Communication Systems
| 2024-05-06T08:59:16 | 2024-05-06T08:59:16 |
Feibo Jiang, Chuanguo Tang, Li Dong, Kezhi Wang, Kun Yang, Cunhua Pan
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.IT, cs.LG, math.IT
|
Semantic Communication (SC) has emerged as a novel communication paradigm in
recent years, successfully transcending the Shannon physical capacity limits
through innovative semantic transmission concepts. Nevertheless, extant Image
Semantic Communication (ISC) systems face several challenges in dynamic
environments, including low semantic density, catastrophic forgetting, and
uncertain Signal-to-Noise Ratio (SNR). To address these challenges, we propose
a novel Vision-Language Model-based Cross-modal Semantic Communication
(VLM-CSC) system. The VLM-CSC comprises three novel components: (1) Cross-modal
Knowledge Base (CKB) is used to extract high-density textual semantics from the
semantically sparse image at the transmitter and reconstruct the original image
based on textual semantics at the receiver. The transmission of high-density
semantics contributes to alleviating bandwidth pressure. (2) Memory-assisted
Encoder and Decoder (MED) employ a hybrid long/short-term memory mechanism,
enabling the semantic encoder and decoder to overcome catastrophic forgetting
in dynamic environments when there is a drift in the distribution of semantic
features. (3) Noise Attention Module (NAM) employs attention mechanisms to
adaptively adjust the semantic coding and the channel coding based on SNR,
ensuring the robustness of the CSC system. The experimental simulations
validate the effectiveness, adaptability, and robustness of the CSC system.
|
[
-0.4757350385,
-0.8700755835,
0.4611623883,
0.2970994413,
-0.4706654251,
-0.1155455932,
-0.3749994338,
-0.7786732912,
0.2177274078,
0.3330869079,
-0.677215457,
-0.4868269563,
-0.4945169091,
0.088547945,
-0.3556841016,
0.4637844861,
0.0286616664,
0.1632491052,
-0.3248408139,
-0.3199411631,
-0.6453901529,
-0.3660720885,
-0.3029073775,
0.1384874582,
0.3669091463,
0.0242969152,
0.6769468784,
0.2015131116,
0.4728985429,
0.3375281096,
-0.0866262615,
0.0746827126,
-0.6638308764,
-0.0460495986,
-0.427544266,
-0.2267279178,
-0.3286936581,
-0.4524122477,
0.7418882847,
0.4146719873,
-0.167344451,
-0.1562329978,
-0.0835530311,
0.4969821274,
-0.9716206789,
0.3758332431,
-1.0495983362,
-0.0420950837,
0.1449081302,
-0.3909762204,
-0.4481165409,
0.5034015179,
0.1242911071,
-0.5995899439,
-0.3669769764,
0.1028328687,
0.8874431849,
0.325827986,
-0.3154829443,
-0.2570650876,
-0.8297684789,
0.780013442,
-0.478782922,
0.68099159,
0.3286453485,
0.4006157815,
0.0503346995,
-0.4104271233,
-0.6612873673,
-0.1763548106,
0.2983259261,
0.5132752657,
-0.122729823,
-0.1663031429,
0.0145663079,
0.1365383565,
-0.3779868186,
-0.1287204623,
-0.3598723412,
-0.2478882521,
0.163098067,
0.47510463,
0.238140136,
-0.1923340857,
-0.856628418,
0.323623389,
-0.3421462774,
-0.1249051988,
-0.1934193075,
0.1860157549,
-0.3750596046,
0.4048871398,
-0.6043827534,
0.8733864427,
-0.2295391858,
-0.1528357416,
0.0516956449,
-0.6467136741,
-0.3251078725,
-0.024689069,
0.6758048534,
0.5054944158,
-0.0715517625,
-0.2068533301,
-0.2567051053,
0.4858176708,
0.3474595845,
-0.3536841571,
0.094020322,
-0.1789170504,
-0.8212558627,
-0.3294391334,
-0.1781753153,
-0.3977887034,
0.130140543,
-0.3439025879,
0.6875743866,
-0.5604194999,
-0.2117655575,
0.3237269223,
0.0557801425,
0.5368704796,
0.6406600475,
-0.6904212832,
0.2964227796,
0.0788403079,
0.696513176,
-0.2719285488,
-0.2565197051,
-0.2176237106,
0.4598661959,
0.1265579313,
0.7125680447,
-0.5045685172,
-0.2987621725,
-0.2474197745,
0.1656664759,
-0.1396309286,
-0.29045403,
0.1770414561,
-0.689512372,
-0.047709953,
-0.2365941852,
-0.1792564839,
0.0041251751,
0.2690087557,
-0.4549856484,
0.6264948249,
0.112218678,
-0.8199441433,
0.2616363168,
-0.2328475565,
-0.2072378844,
0.2379182577,
-0.1607812643,
-0.2105105966,
-0.1166039258,
0.0175065324,
0.2611756921,
-0.5318598747,
-0.0946548209,
-0.5322666168,
-0.3623287678,
0.2644161582,
-0.6229296327,
0.4563047588,
0.3867023289,
-0.2319385558,
0.1130221039,
-1.1191241741,
0.1721963882,
0.234675467,
-0.541759491,
-0.5340943933,
0.0284531713,
0.2327674478,
0.5967939496,
0.3235033751,
-0.6728563905,
-0.169130668,
0.0747378618,
0.4753375351,
0.506865561,
-0.2131359577,
0.2633573711,
0.0105791381,
-0.0192590449,
0.1857625395,
0.3687840998,
-0.0379493237,
-0.3576459885,
-0.9364871979,
-0.301209271,
0.007137476,
0.9436203241,
-1.315554738,
0.4478479028,
-0.4100426137,
-0.107632786,
-0.1656159461,
-0.0079231989,
0.354511857,
0.629240334,
0.3839763403,
-0.5515438318,
-0.2772007585,
-0.7871497273,
0.0836313888,
-0.1835561991,
0.2631576955,
0.6919404864,
0.3783310652,
-0.3230170906,
0.6129577756,
-0.0312223267,
-0.3299063146,
-0.2970480919,
-0.3322470784,
-0.4715467691,
0.3717826605,
0.3615876138,
-0.7738602161,
-0.2161530852,
0.0884435847,
-0.8769157529,
-0.0938489512,
-0.2563860714,
-0.3691147268,
0.492339015,
0.5365284085,
-0.4326449335,
1.0401449203,
0.7374099493,
-0.4182357788,
0.3091262579,
-0.2765210569,
0.2056174278,
-0.8008896112,
-0.0856378525,
-0.2824609578,
-0.3888585269,
-0.2596906126,
-0.240052551,
0.1185478643,
-0.0227032118,
-0.6875651479,
0.109406583,
-0.4267649055,
-0.107286416,
-0.467181772,
0.1312117279,
-0.1622022539,
0.7185323834,
0.5179056525,
0.3316065669,
0.8077652454,
-0.5945970416,
0.5552434921,
0.2574157715,
-0.1749530286,
1.0527845621,
-0.3984349668,
-0.3319171667,
-0.1046531647,
0.3227461874,
-0.6606585383,
0.2642497718,
0.2699424326,
-0.3400073349,
-0.1010688916,
0.0001672898,
-0.2275926471,
-0.2115898281,
0.295720607,
0.4736592472,
0.3070877492,
-0.2821199596,
0.8863298297,
0.1491728425,
0.1098687574,
-0.245420143,
-0.9281751513,
0.6121097207,
0.2139678746,
-0.9762068391,
0.1914925873,
0.0276949164,
0.2927925289,
0.3554038703,
-0.030866066,
0.0155541021,
-0.2677842677,
0.3046923876,
0.5399505496,
-0.2136914283,
0.0960660726,
-0.1817015857,
-0.2577457428,
-0.0272826254,
-0.5396406054,
0.4371725023,
-0.3902665079,
-0.6644356847,
-0.5737982988,
0.8691371679,
0.6141763926,
-0.3852089942,
0.8321405053,
0.5625121593,
-0.1763891876,
-0.2364052385,
-0.4882844388,
-0.247535035,
-0.4283807278,
0.6553177834,
-0.5193542838,
-0.9309589863,
0.574060142,
-0.0991551727,
-0.5042241216,
0.0607763194,
0.7580288053,
0.0742484108,
0.6809524894,
0.8530842066,
0.3115221858,
0.474825263,
-0.0967087895,
0.2825394273,
-0.5621870756,
-0.3233006895,
0.1744751185,
-0.162587598,
-0.1902334392,
-0.6647126079,
0.2474966943,
-0.0081527997,
-0.1159501821,
0.4681639075,
-0.2943029702,
-0.0161907766,
0.5000491142,
0.2479680777,
0.4669570327,
0.2058727443,
-0.2147115469,
-0.0222713202,
-0.9084609747,
-0.2486270964,
0.503914535,
0.3159623742,
1.1932355165,
0.087603882,
0.1367813796,
-0.0045473673,
-0.3076881468,
-0.6695133448,
0.8973031044,
-0.0229896531,
-0.3295888603,
-0.2696196437,
-0.4607242346,
-0.3909476995,
0.4217160344,
-0.5884332657,
-0.7000306249,
0.4307139814,
-0.0244517364,
-0.0702221245,
0.5574282408,
-0.3976878822,
0.6650130749,
-0.2031972557,
-0.4341938496,
-0.3677035868,
-1.0144090652,
0.2290625125,
0.1085853577,
0.0844682753,
-0.0182654578,
-0.2414776534,
0.2467985749,
-0.5527657866,
0.979986012,
0.1731543243,
-0.0453393944,
0.5546872616,
0.1021128818,
0.6601486802,
0.0118690487,
0.3513197005,
0.2842048407,
0.1619990617,
-0.4729413092,
-0.5642445683,
0.6574776769,
-0.556578815,
-0.2120517045,
-0.204931885,
-0.7763548493,
-0.20809187,
0.1826412231,
0.098246485,
0.3722811639,
-0.0479066223,
0.3022483289,
0.6409583688,
-0.3338755667,
0.4285105467,
0.7807069421,
-0.0531460121,
-0.4814896584,
1.2506666183,
-0.0289388727,
0.9102137089,
0.3472613394,
-0.3477938473,
0.2028872371,
-0.3643305004,
-0.5409760475,
0.1143437326,
-0.8875926733,
-0.1259391159,
-0.8711771369,
-0.432521075,
-0.2743805349,
-0.3130244911,
-0.6195189357,
0.0364158377,
-0.1642474681,
0.3199266195,
0.3397201598,
0.3578667939,
-0.1098860428,
0.1496609002,
-0.8153669238,
0.4763601422,
0.3555598855,
0.4832576215,
0.0205874834,
-0.2440130562,
-0.3520849049,
0.0216631889,
0.1974606961,
-0.6962939501,
0.4530671537,
-0.0287118498,
0.407484889,
0.0236620996,
0.1473904997,
0.6239314079,
-0.22791408,
0.5292705297,
0.4307354391,
-0.9077677131,
0.3710474968,
-0.3918187618,
0.4871531725,
0.2062529474,
-0.206861347,
-0.6282743216,
-0.4633132517,
-0.2351205349,
-0.8386441469,
0.6284890771,
0.2106970698,
-0.1329188049,
0.098305814,
-0.0206715129,
-0.2346206754,
-0.0600668453,
-0.740067184,
0.0274855271,
-0.4984684885,
-0.293566823,
0.4840438068,
-0.2164350152,
-0.07445205,
-0.1796264946,
0.3679856062,
-0.2413969636,
0.4102706015,
0.3378923237,
-0.3192207813,
-0.0615562461,
0.2245992422,
0.7609875798,
0.6167914867,
0.1213264838,
0.1903268993,
0.6629383564,
-0.552167058,
-0.1401402205,
-0.1545438915,
-0.1298914105,
-0.2450289577,
0.2099137753,
1.2164061069,
0.4796884656,
-0.6917984486,
0.7668059468,
-0.278835535,
-0.0657368004,
-0.301025182,
-0.1893411577,
0.3868183792,
0.1975673735,
0.1307519227,
0.4896704555,
-0.0424167663,
-0.3504650593,
0.1392231137,
0.5209589601,
-0.8544876575,
-0.1397399306,
0.5555885434,
0.323200047,
0.2423039824,
0.3382166624,
0.1531559676,
-0.3798567057,
0.3155343235,
0.5767707825,
0.3705923259,
0.1819573641,
0.1431303024,
-0.0899721086,
0.2985222638,
0.1690986902,
0.5771130919,
-0.4294564128,
-0.6046189666,
-0.4125204384,
-0.6047487259,
0.0633603036,
-0.2726154327,
-0.4883543551,
0.3636023402,
-0.3022301793,
0.0569691323,
-0.4585101306,
-0.5039634109,
-0.589522481,
0.3781447411,
0.5659319758,
1.0365246534,
-0.6366920471,
1.0531326532,
0.427056253,
-0.3667005002,
-0.7440690994,
-0.5633919835,
0.0250343494,
-0.9062116742,
0.8051394224,
-0.2841609418,
-0.6732472777,
-0.1255570501,
-0.523153007,
-0.9562623501,
1.233409524,
0.0263327938,
-0.5131909251,
0.1915856004,
0.1909386814,
0.3974050879,
-0.5910875797,
-0.0100045232,
-0.0745418072,
0.3523890376,
0.5284640193,
-1.1961704493,
0.0703218132,
-0.3296935558,
0.4840579331,
-0.1193246916,
-0.8203079104,
0.6942797899,
-0.2372232974,
-0.3238455355,
0.3320978284,
0.9700841904,
0.0385366715,
0.0562081635,
0.5825431943,
0.6150712371,
0.0335550942,
0.1018638611,
0.8119442463,
-0.2783329487,
0.23610349,
0.8251720667,
-0.2702183425,
0.9020510912,
0.8809227943,
0.1675021797,
0.3090902269,
0.1843377203,
0.1545914263,
0.7483854294,
0.073057726,
-0.4995058775,
-0.8748086095,
-0.1023011208,
-0.381433785,
0.4800790846,
0.5040357709,
-0.331787467,
-0.4409236908,
0.4276776314,
-0.4744403958,
0.0535321236,
-0.261211127,
0.7406166792,
0.1306911409,
-0.0692459941,
0.7354217768,
-0.1121758595,
0.8906207085,
-0.6842791438,
-0.0382335708,
0.333896488,
0.2639960051,
-0.0211738124,
-0.5596111417,
0.284139812,
-0.4557835162,
-0.3635376394,
-0.032908529,
1.2039018869,
-0.7918417454,
-0.4862620831,
0.5332546234,
0.3918917477,
-0.0513305217,
0.1937117577,
-0.5661659241,
0.8074253798,
-0.2901806831,
-0.0593239591,
0.3044263721,
0.6426919103,
-0.2952755094,
0.9164279103,
0.5518154502,
0.1549780369,
0.4442008138,
0.0790600106,
1.08180511,
-0.7589433789,
-0.7555572987,
-0.2637317777,
0.4740603566,
-0.0552568622,
-0.1618418843,
0.5624235272,
0.162657693,
0.7232474685,
-0.2243145108,
0.7430033684,
-0.1944618672,
0.1440370679,
-0.5056579113,
0.7244793773,
-0.525141418,
0.2370505333,
-0.2084576637,
-0.5752623677,
-0.2139095664,
0.4142436087,
-0.2287351936,
0.0181606486,
0.7569431663,
0.9487890601,
-0.2053565532,
0.1071786135,
0.7305550575,
0.0737626851,
0.0495124646,
0.9497933388,
0.91267097,
-0.4972084463,
0.9226465225,
-0.2652294934,
-0.1314923614,
-0.3671265244,
-0.7524572015,
-0.6755489707,
-0.8095462918,
-0.2753280103,
-0.501275003,
0.2937266231,
0.4088508189,
0.7207919359,
-0.4955452085,
0.0589234382,
-0.0424686447,
-0.1335472316,
-0.0852119252,
-0.2267358303,
-0.0255123638,
-0.2040914297,
-0.3488537073,
0.1501541287,
0.9167534709,
0.1516740769,
-0.4504788816,
-0.2556098998,
-0.164178133,
0.2067865133,
0.7692582011,
0.2930031717,
-1.0330750942,
-0.5672653317,
0.0325443968,
-0.6045492887,
-0.1769898683,
0.8911321163,
-0.9203033447,
0.434030354,
0.655785501,
0.496388942,
0.38446334,
-0.3028858602,
0.4609813392,
-0.0623135157,
0.5765801668,
-0.0139382621,
0.304989934,
0.2155794799,
-0.1975704879,
-0.0729861706,
0.6427128911,
-0.1896290928,
-0.4753102064,
0.2644393742,
-1.6151268482,
-0.4839185178,
1.1809283495,
-0.0579567216,
-0.699195087,
-0.3139944971,
-0.4143635035,
-0.1352600008,
-0.2836092114,
0.3659774065,
0.4678132832,
0.2087391317,
-0.5179877281,
-0.4567796886,
0.1000697911,
0.4312882423,
-0.4665605128,
-0.0104768928,
0.5894206166,
0.3491978943,
-0.0368407629,
0.5780413151,
-0.3489259183,
0.4846250713,
0.2092700303,
0.1756519526,
-0.1602158397,
-0.2359077334,
0.1053123847,
0.0342452042,
-0.610462904,
-0.1903609186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03279v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03279v2
|
Lifelong Knowledge Editing for LLMs with Retrieval-Augmented Continuous Prompt Learning
| 2024-05-06T08:52:11 | 2024-05-08T03:45:51 |
Qizhou Chen, Taolin Zhang, Xiaofeng He, Dongyang Li, Chengyu Wang, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Model editing aims to correct outdated or erroneous knowledge in large
language models (LLMs) without the need for costly retraining. Lifelong model
editing is the most challenging task that caters to the continuous editing
requirements of LLMs. Prior works primarily focus on single or batch editing;
nevertheless, these methods fall short in lifelong editing scenarios due to
catastrophic knowledge forgetting and the degradation of model performance.
Although retrieval-based methods alleviate these issues, they are impeded by
slow and cumbersome processes of integrating the retrieved knowledge into the
model. In this work, we introduce RECIPE, a RetriEval-augmented ContInuous
Prompt lEarning method, to boost editing efficacy and inference efficiency in
lifelong learning. RECIPE first converts knowledge statements into short and
informative continuous prompts, prefixed to the LLM's input query embedding, to
efficiently refine the response grounded on the knowledge. It further
integrates the Knowledge Sentinel (KS) that acts as an intermediary to
calculate a dynamic threshold, determining whether the retrieval repository
contains relevant knowledge. Our retriever and prompt encoder are jointly
trained to achieve editing properties, i.e., reliability, generality, and
locality. In our experiments, RECIPE is assessed extensively across multiple
LLMs and editing datasets, where it achieves superior editing performance.
RECIPE also demonstrates its capability to maintain the overall performance of
LLMs alongside showcasing fast editing and inference speed.
|
[
0.1564077735,
-1.0291758776,
0.769353807,
0.1531543732,
-0.0128381569,
0.2994467616,
-0.2880409658,
-0.2224983275,
0.2250091881,
0.6318165064,
-0.6493498683,
-0.6479682922,
-0.5013328195,
0.1457481086,
-0.080730848,
0.4278212488,
-0.1062287465,
0.1436005384,
-0.5650964379,
-0.1146287173,
-0.9972367287,
-0.5237656236,
-0.9960050583,
0.0406339876,
0.7267815471,
0.4829853177,
0.5078296065,
0.6561745405,
0.008261825,
0.2255799174,
-0.4884079099,
0.7034258246,
-0.4936413467,
0.7458922267,
-0.3389153183,
-0.3976542652,
-0.4333252907,
-0.2754970789,
0.6481170654,
0.5167613626,
0.1188101694,
0.0413380861,
0.2146549523,
0.6751282811,
-0.7878350616,
-0.0589641333,
-0.7316720486,
-0.0395930931,
-0.0929262564,
-0.1411779225,
-0.6804669499,
-0.5581535101,
-0.2118985802,
-0.626806736,
-0.0873593166,
-0.0465031862,
0.3396104574,
0.2306037694,
-0.2808375061,
-0.543831408,
-0.5311159492,
0.5923774242,
-0.7302604318,
0.5255173445,
0.2300525457,
0.1949196607,
-0.5594654083,
-0.8375223875,
-0.634586513,
-0.2225607485,
0.1580269933,
0.1054688767,
0.0167614091,
0.0325023197,
0.1258322597,
0.0189227741,
-0.3366196156,
0.2160627246,
0.0549505353,
-0.1718509346,
0.3368775547,
0.4390011728,
0.3965267539,
-0.1771818846,
-0.1703602076,
0.2331730872,
-0.8340734243,
-0.0670231134,
-0.040864002,
0.1483041048,
0.4589251578,
0.7020382881,
-0.2169952393,
0.9549356103,
0.0292540081,
-0.3568650782,
-0.0557273924,
-0.2942108214,
-0.0347226709,
-0.0671677813,
0.6365972757,
0.422115922,
0.0537199005,
-0.1065328717,
-0.3173479438,
-0.197023958,
0.0529502146,
-0.5396125317,
-0.0289255995,
0.0033690149,
-0.0248484965,
-0.0725182593,
-0.2494917512,
-0.5925853848,
-0.4763669968,
-0.3405518234,
0.5861731172,
-0.5788336992,
0.2915113866,
0.112873584,
-0.1982457042,
-0.1503872722,
0.6053199172,
-0.7947536111,
0.0167182162,
0.5454689264,
0.992331028,
-0.0448166542,
-0.387096554,
-0.9992153049,
0.3358449042,
-0.347245127,
0.7262380123,
-0.6911769509,
-0.573777616,
-0.0427306816,
0.058461953,
-0.2130105048,
-0.6344279647,
0.3948663771,
-0.9775968194,
-0.0789564922,
-0.5050601363,
-1.0593799353,
0.0535406955,
0.2039965838,
-0.5571093559,
1.0946490765,
0.1096586585,
-0.3911778331,
0.4915659726,
-0.5892735124,
-0.3851352036,
0.1636092067,
0.111291036,
-0.2590590119,
-0.0575070828,
0.3900000751,
0.4374914467,
0.0306279697,
0.575034678,
-0.1905193329,
-0.2099495381,
0.2013121545,
-0.3739256263,
0.344863385,
0.0295709483,
0.0153743681,
0.2796255648,
-0.6505245566,
-0.218737036,
0.1209295914,
-0.5578920245,
-0.3795170486,
-0.0190860368,
-0.2226572633,
0.0966835171,
0.397983551,
-0.483895421,
0.5672389865,
-0.112125203,
0.3475557566,
0.9612854123,
0.5897065997,
0.3349877596,
-0.420191586,
0.5511436462,
-0.0895097479,
0.2970397174,
-0.3248203397,
-0.484693408,
-0.7517923117,
-0.292193234,
0.4406546056,
0.7113869786,
-0.9168335199,
0.4974321425,
-0.1943978071,
-0.4767346084,
-0.5456849933,
0.4864310622,
0.1961417645,
0.9458113313,
0.4941936731,
-0.0720374659,
-0.5830116868,
-0.494137764,
-0.4973088503,
0.2751305103,
-0.0469251536,
0.033009924,
0.5463163853,
-0.4091722369,
1.1292229891,
-0.4604071081,
-0.0227837879,
-0.3270634711,
-0.0688481405,
0.1747781336,
0.5080555081,
0.1093988046,
-0.4925160706,
-0.7075489759,
-0.2008068413,
-1.0000706911,
-0.1631625146,
-0.3581390977,
-0.2284190804,
0.2370553017,
0.5072805882,
-0.7423964143,
0.4127603173,
0.0398717821,
-0.3244923949,
0.9600477815,
-0.1956874579,
0.3378039002,
-1.0429878235,
-0.0724383295,
-0.2780682743,
-0.3179293871,
-0.4876277149,
0.059984792,
0.4104101658,
0.0094908476,
-0.6447532177,
1.0360774994,
-0.4250950217,
0.1481574029,
-0.0369413197,
0.149754703,
0.1712679416,
0.2986553907,
0.0251735281,
1.0141537189,
0.2850190103,
-0.7176802158,
0.4876824021,
0.3427133262,
-0.4200171828,
0.5144609809,
-0.5626151562,
0.2662057877,
0.0636534914,
0.2516191006,
-0.5142315626,
-0.1692579687,
0.3765358627,
-0.3419725597,
0.100683257,
-0.2115992457,
-0.9534531832,
-0.0134737985,
-0.1545756459,
-0.0717175379,
0.4504972398,
-0.7697222233,
0.7590172291,
-0.1581719071,
-0.3645089567,
-0.4036273956,
-0.4467042983,
0.3386980891,
-0.0606627129,
-0.6191462278,
0.3725119233,
-0.3597014546,
-0.1644713134,
0.1348879486,
0.0369392671,
0.2152875215,
0.0121892123,
0.0498000868,
0.3205350339,
0.0847925693,
0.2553855777,
0.566406846,
-0.078083016,
-0.1103786975,
-0.3177427649,
0.2783920467,
0.2850264609,
-0.3081348538,
-0.4479234219,
0.2435323894,
0.6057094336,
-0.2641475499,
1.1800152063,
0.1229432821,
-0.3003214598,
-0.1748231053,
-0.8408680558,
-0.1013290659,
-0.4619171023,
0.1333780885,
-0.3864616454,
-0.9746745825,
0.6306834221,
-0.3284027278,
0.0738815069,
0.4118032157,
0.2582713962,
-0.1100188792,
0.5776495337,
0.2775326073,
0.0516273044,
0.4299513698,
-0.0253146496,
-0.3782107234,
-1.1388200521,
-0.395993799,
-0.2397816926,
0.0249002371,
0.0206300765,
-0.5479874015,
0.6129526496,
0.2512299716,
-0.4287276268,
0.0267304108,
-0.2389526367,
0.7365803123,
0.5262659192,
0.6205481887,
0.5220599771,
-0.2875716686,
-0.4490010142,
-0.2820327282,
-0.8362550735,
-0.4136216938,
1.0776342154,
0.0809940472,
0.5844247341,
0.0075728637,
0.780916214,
0.5897920728,
0.1289318651,
-0.6295258403,
0.6088601947,
0.0897380859,
-0.1823036224,
-0.305038631,
-0.4440822303,
-0.4886149466,
-0.0370188467,
-0.267830193,
-0.433963716,
0.0711532459,
0.3937446475,
-0.3426165879,
0.4834560752,
-0.7375623584,
0.8362857103,
-0.4215128422,
-0.8000509143,
0.0207192004,
-0.6303142905,
0.1616485417,
-0.217117846,
0.3119907081,
0.3486958742,
-0.0128456987,
0.7041766047,
-0.6048390865,
0.9760885835,
-0.3498550355,
0.2443263978,
0.1615070254,
0.4566614926,
0.8645448685,
0.3132814169,
-0.2229615748,
-0.2725852728,
-0.2149071544,
-0.3253263235,
-0.9471468329,
0.6114812493,
-0.3889933825,
-0.7015197873,
-0.3401418626,
-0.3835994005,
-0.2903011739,
0.2867832184,
0.0603238419,
0.4117676318,
-0.1728249788,
-0.0380634815,
1.0154989958,
-0.4193496704,
0.156853199,
0.4550382495,
-0.3152378798,
-0.558752954,
0.7844399214,
0.2519438565,
0.5353998542,
0.4398298264,
0.1602921784,
-0.1805558205,
-0.4364489615,
-0.4781022072,
0.1573663354,
-1.1249184608,
-0.2030341774,
-0.8370917439,
-0.2565055788,
-0.359554857,
-0.6266570091,
-0.2854822874,
-0.3027081192,
-0.6389996409,
0.0458438508,
0.6284800172,
0.6098516583,
-0.2731589675,
0.2209145129,
-0.9472031593,
0.2829008102,
0.4550662339,
0.104730323,
0.0781690851,
-0.767871201,
-0.2548036575,
-0.0482805334,
-0.1477175802,
-0.9226077199,
0.5460288525,
0.310733825,
0.4899799526,
-0.035503801,
-0.0588140041,
0.8128898144,
-0.5756233931,
0.8608608246,
-0.0876833647,
-1.0319106579,
0.8250643611,
-0.1819879115,
0.7065644264,
0.6622688174,
0.4649170935,
-0.8875538111,
-0.3492415249,
-0.1695200354,
-0.857475698,
0.1383971125,
-0.3490197062,
0.0544042066,
-0.308149308,
0.6751667261,
0.3701130748,
0.1505123675,
-0.3195174336,
0.0548275001,
0.057407584,
-0.0492226966,
0.1356022209,
-0.6237641573,
0.1867853105,
-0.4900802076,
0.957557261,
0.088094838,
-0.0125475395,
0.1699259132,
-0.4603412747,
-0.0093977293,
0.3434889019,
0.4252699316,
0.7995049953,
-0.3471243083,
-0.0624114722,
0.438705951,
-0.2645300031,
0.1411963552,
-0.2672695518,
-0.2461613268,
-0.0368105769,
0.6098741293,
0.7798570991,
0.6243420839,
-0.7039346099,
0.0646373928,
-0.1798632592,
0.0577324629,
-0.2960264683,
0.241922915,
0.3735440969,
0.207765907,
0.3146744668,
0.240251109,
-0.0867174044,
-0.2669027448,
0.2098730505,
0.1033977494,
0.0536663495,
0.066547662,
0.6311715841,
0.0541539006,
-0.3623427749,
1.0199338198,
-0.2117993683,
-0.58057338,
0.2351830304,
0.5363440514,
0.7523753643,
-0.2171226442,
0.0990274101,
0.3694449365,
0.1266298443,
-0.0392835662,
0.0563130565,
-0.0996493772,
-0.5920075774,
-0.4087360501,
-0.6867908835,
-0.6594145298,
-0.1417686194,
-0.5952817202,
0.272526741,
-0.3852680326,
0.1259511858,
-0.2562607527,
-0.3370311558,
-0.6222879291,
0.1426418275,
-0.3522194326,
1.1824412346,
-0.6651452184,
0.796251893,
0.4293668568,
-0.431720376,
-0.5089023113,
-0.2048452944,
0.2044197768,
-0.6390450597,
0.6783002615,
0.0432443768,
-0.004703009,
0.1947613358,
-0.5983345509,
-0.6224538088,
1.1678608656,
0.4401432276,
-0.8405897617,
-0.2024741322,
-0.0900980756,
0.2881623805,
-0.2458878607,
0.0677690953,
0.5649098754,
0.4452860653,
0.4534228146,
-0.5608610511,
-0.0519637316,
-0.1527213305,
0.0424329564,
-0.0736364871,
-0.30954355,
0.5458238721,
-0.1390736401,
-0.0404377282,
0.1341766119,
0.6565858722,
0.5182315111,
0.2093102336,
0.170041129,
0.6306034923,
0.7353767753,
0.1856579632,
0.8088886738,
-0.2330653071,
0.1284960657,
1.4414279461,
-0.4325820804,
0.961530745,
0.382239908,
0.0907625407,
0.5078353286,
0.774815619,
0.1604667157,
0.5198880434,
-0.0548524857,
-0.7276386619,
-0.3159563839,
-0.1214533523,
-0.2365102172,
-0.014991005,
0.5231124759,
-0.3698628843,
0.0689001828,
0.3643799722,
0.4756234288,
0.214352265,
-0.2471104711,
0.8846562505,
-0.0379814543,
-0.6083446145,
0.5351692438,
-0.0204226207,
0.5631269217,
-0.7405244708,
-0.2497253418,
-0.4947821498,
-0.2070927471,
-0.0221011918,
-0.8358082771,
0.2521890402,
0.1163068637,
-0.3276893795,
-0.2243822515,
0.684083879,
-0.3789330125,
-0.4713045359,
0.2449398786,
0.3852019608,
-0.2420137227,
-0.099801302,
-0.6625219584,
0.425242424,
-0.2140620947,
-0.3263225853,
0.3162317872,
0.4025815427,
0.2507559061,
0.758618176,
0.7439420819,
0.3069642782,
0.089759171,
-0.16755642,
1.07115376,
-0.7271535993,
-0.4599493444,
-0.9320573211,
0.8300244212,
0.0940082967,
-0.0942294374,
0.6797511578,
0.4541285336,
0.7163706422,
-0.3617121875,
0.8784911036,
0.0323094428,
0.3657666147,
-1.1369875669,
0.7559504509,
-0.4080785513,
0.4502921999,
-0.0525674112,
-0.9199234843,
-0.5132122636,
0.1089676321,
-0.4666154385,
-0.1032134518,
0.591828227,
0.9445216656,
0.1572051793,
-0.1681830287,
0.4082803726,
0.2118013948,
0.3461786509,
0.4792226255,
0.7568026781,
-0.0533816218,
-0.1301225275,
-0.255022794,
-0.2407039106,
-0.0757308677,
-0.8650036454,
-0.8354639411,
-0.5164176822,
-0.0434614867,
-0.2694347501,
0.7716109157,
1.1806819439,
0.393607527,
-0.4750272632,
0.029789187,
-0.0794523358,
0.3350161314,
-0.2542711496,
-0.2448001057,
0.446262002,
-0.4472236037,
-0.4338899255,
0.8913792968,
0.3386627138,
-0.255345881,
-0.0123545555,
-0.1378092617,
-0.531175673,
0.1062756851,
0.7511870265,
0.3874465227,
-0.5736652613,
-0.2371408045,
0.0945661291,
0.1663267314,
-0.0658076257,
0.4889444113,
-0.8655170798,
1.132094264,
0.1112831905,
0.9601039886,
0.3526038826,
-0.2076886147,
0.3691807091,
-0.7679969668,
-0.2182713896,
0.1876156926,
0.2185477912,
0.4879482985,
-0.6725106835,
0.2087590843,
0.5190547705,
-0.8731705546,
-0.6028766632,
0.059024021,
-0.748931706,
-0.1230295673,
1.0412578583,
-0.3051564097,
-0.3216482997,
0.1093927026,
-0.2962798476,
0.381141454,
-0.4278118312,
0.5834412575,
0.5715638399,
-0.0564740114,
-0.3360637724,
-0.6373195648,
0.2772746384,
0.2243619859,
-0.8212428689,
0.0303340144,
0.7916449904,
0.4362053573,
-0.4269586205,
0.4319529235,
-0.0561212525,
0.5309257507,
-0.1009411812,
0.1407092214,
-0.3685620725,
-0.5466096997,
-0.3246170282,
0.0743149221,
0.400968641,
0.1469908357
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03207v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03207v1
|
A Philosophical Introduction to Language Models - Part II: The Way Forward
| 2024-05-06T07:12:45 | 2024-05-06T07:12:45 |
Raphaël Millière, Cameron Buckner
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, the second of two companion pieces, we explore novel
philosophical questions raised by recent progress in large language models
(LLMs) that go beyond the classical debates covered in the first part. We focus
particularly on issues related to interpretability, examining evidence from
causal intervention methods about the nature of LLMs' internal representations
and computations. We also discuss the implications of multimodal and modular
extensions of LLMs, recent debates about whether such systems may meet minimal
criteria for consciousness, and concerns about secrecy and reproducibility in
LLM research. Finally, we discuss whether LLM-like systems may be relevant to
modeling aspects of human cognition, if their architectural characteristics and
learning scenario are adequately constrained.
|
[
-0.1099737138,
-0.7272255421,
0.985842824,
-0.0582513399,
-0.1436704546,
-0.1495079696,
-0.3199104071,
-0.690810442,
-0.0491154157,
0.8377125859,
-0.4622896314,
0.146850422,
-0.734210968,
-0.1432797164,
-0.6451856494,
0.5275126696,
0.0094122607,
0.2020408362,
-0.1024041474,
-0.0453365073,
-0.4491089582,
-0.5038843751,
-0.9587298632,
-0.483224839,
0.457634449,
0.2702466249,
0.6960816383,
0.4622569084,
0.3618740439,
0.3531886041,
-0.1105471104,
-0.3076243103,
-0.111627385,
0.3706220388,
-0.367297709,
-0.8263110518,
-0.2216601074,
0.0437813997,
0.9656001925,
1.0411497355,
-0.1156097502,
0.0921918452,
0.2680011988,
0.573512435,
-0.1985614896,
0.3828295767,
-0.3757252693,
-0.0169017259,
-0.1260227412,
0.0504840463,
-0.6222290397,
-0.2331229895,
0.1206438914,
-0.2081594616,
-0.1275333911,
0.1115950793,
0.239163667,
0.1462467611,
-0.7653338909,
-0.6707897186,
-0.9854520559,
0.785456419,
-0.7842027545,
0.4109921753,
0.3778696954,
0.1912632883,
-0.386375457,
-0.8331598043,
-0.6879110932,
-0.340631336,
-0.2390180379,
-0.0131395152,
-0.2208340764,
0.1654107124,
0.0800974891,
0.2218075842,
-0.43366611,
0.3172732294,
-0.4378418326,
-0.2494930029,
0.4369970262,
0.250561744,
0.3902710676,
-0.1300314516,
-0.3246102929,
0.2303365022,
-0.6723755002,
-0.1648057252,
0.4053090811,
-0.0389273986,
-0.0205238983,
0.5871506333,
0.0882397145,
0.8172259927,
-0.4023983181,
-0.0687977076,
-0.4467381835,
-0.3088037074,
-0.0807139948,
-0.1112442985,
0.4357965291,
0.1918807328,
0.2391040772,
-0.0612713434,
-0.0147754205,
0.0745948479,
0.1947109848,
-0.537945807,
-0.4911126792,
0.3304409981,
-0.4116799235,
0.0257207435,
-0.1118349731,
-0.3944443464,
-0.3980177045,
-0.6015743017,
0.1762016267,
-0.3902907968,
-0.4864246547,
0.4267898798,
0.2666313946,
0.50541085,
0.6621515155,
-1.0043303967,
0.5187233686,
1.2325232029,
0.5522209406,
0.146721676,
-0.1284736842,
0.0376905948,
0.2657081783,
-0.422239095,
0.5749664307,
-0.6213003397,
-0.4304961264,
0.1750925779,
0.3052299023,
0.0787263289,
-0.1803983599,
0.6627532244,
-0.6579416394,
0.5798048377,
-0.4985040128,
-0.6956902742,
-0.5403844118,
0.0678886473,
-0.4560860693,
0.6703337431,
-0.2192689925,
-0.5714701414,
-0.1860213727,
-0.6089417934,
-0.5238162875,
0.049620524,
-0.2593932152,
0.4925721288,
0.4696004093,
-0.4962412417,
0.3949657083,
-0.5614618063,
0.2589430511,
-0.3697049022,
0.0665466264,
0.5504146814,
-0.467133522,
0.8720046878,
0.2730792165,
-0.1008524746,
-0.23092255,
-0.7167139649,
0.1055804193,
0.1929471791,
-0.1064983979,
-0.533703804,
0.5637015104,
-0.2391591519,
0.2382184416,
0.4655031264,
-0.560156405,
0.0916060954,
-0.4365766943,
0.8304848075,
0.9894427657,
-0.2093473226,
0.5857215524,
-0.0621043108,
0.351567775,
-0.2200378329,
0.2206997126,
-0.3988493979,
-0.667653203,
-0.8544270396,
-0.0916886926,
0.020134462,
0.473906219,
-0.4126904011,
0.2673626542,
-0.0949299261,
-0.0372144654,
0.0606890991,
0.1352061778,
0.5118606687,
0.3999581635,
-0.075265564,
-0.4633546174,
-0.4490106106,
-1.0167807341,
0.0139730647,
-0.68145895,
-0.034152545,
0.3272469044,
0.5310788155,
0.0267305337,
0.8002328277,
-0.6935626864,
0.4065332115,
-0.2120308578,
-0.2974922061,
0.061950922,
0.549118638,
0.2444036305,
-0.4294798374,
0.0275198799,
-0.1337565035,
-0.9090067744,
0.1081818119,
0.1227310672,
-0.0373140015,
-0.1788021922,
0.5906835794,
-0.6466498971,
0.0167265963,
0.467869401,
-0.2151905,
0.2781225443,
-0.2782755494,
-0.3287983239,
-1.3637751341,
-0.2503061891,
-0.2273050398,
-0.0763726383,
-0.9354740381,
0.3536157608,
-0.2497191578,
-0.0564047359,
-0.3153144419,
0.7342604399,
-0.3840419352,
-0.3499917686,
-0.6600579619,
0.2188706994,
-0.0125878863,
0.2485174984,
0.0967582837,
0.3885050416,
0.6507222056,
-0.603579998,
0.3360492289,
0.0131470021,
-0.4636047184,
0.5179756284,
-0.7046034336,
0.2819487751,
-0.3121864796,
0.5878531337,
-1.2459449768,
-0.4312830567,
0.5467969775,
-0.2271645963,
0.242611438,
-0.0363777019,
-0.5859595537,
-0.2245933414,
-0.0584144592,
0.5381534696,
0.5903077722,
-0.2870443165,
0.4247121215,
0.3294248879,
-0.3166428506,
-0.2099518925,
-0.7208973169,
0.1329413652,
-0.0979353189,
-0.5946409106,
-0.2776015997,
-0.0243787225,
-0.8457961082,
-0.076261133,
0.3178201914,
-0.037660908,
0.2448993474,
0.3063521087,
0.3059619069,
-0.3901055157,
0.3722824752,
-0.0028802899,
-0.1172784641,
0.4070735872,
-0.6673973799,
0.4248221517,
-0.1104668304,
-0.5138776302,
-0.3765178323,
0.408221513,
0.2780160606,
0.0343605541,
0.5919283628,
0.2218598723,
-0.5149421692,
-0.0009856854,
-0.4614644647,
-0.3630683124,
-0.4520561099,
0.417051971,
-0.2314825058,
-0.9768216014,
0.393607378,
-0.2066913396,
-0.0018620851,
0.3374785781,
0.7587561607,
-0.3034196198,
0.59969908,
0.8034704924,
0.1979937255,
0.4422520101,
-0.0581539683,
0.2500623167,
-1.1299146414,
-0.2237935513,
-0.5164724588,
-0.116043739,
-0.5597406626,
-0.5857325792,
0.0327180587,
0.2865903378,
-0.1801994741,
0.3445810676,
-0.1611988991,
0.38552472,
0.1117448285,
-0.0040315804,
0.4179518521,
-0.2048110962,
-0.0059107123,
0.0028540976,
-0.5302464962,
-0.9016917348,
1.0604777336,
0.6905763149,
0.8326160908,
0.5274665952,
0.1388190687,
-0.0646492764,
0.3631975353,
-0.6425023675,
0.7155886292,
0.0220981557,
-1.0988547802,
-0.3298912346,
0.1134608537,
-0.7155197263,
0.5128653646,
0.1550826132,
-1.2105196714,
0.2037566304,
0.0489077829,
-0.2676790655,
0.4973409474,
-0.6241717935,
0.333227396,
-0.3885413706,
-0.2379864454,
-0.5551452041,
-0.9819659591,
0.9465101957,
-0.1433791369,
0.5196244121,
-0.1121533439,
-0.4263459146,
0.7012732029,
-0.2084777653,
1.059492588,
0.0545878559,
-0.7213441133,
0.3578390479,
0.0752301514,
0.3132020831,
0.1823992431,
-0.0060277022,
0.0029339835,
0.1408231705,
-0.3477910459,
-0.7446998954,
0.7413958907,
-0.5807539821,
-0.9005399346,
-0.2679954469,
-0.6865465045,
-0.3439820111,
0.2230386287,
-0.2268876433,
0.6599928141,
-0.0541071184,
0.128221482,
1.0219887495,
-0.3498015404,
0.4841583967,
0.6358631253,
-0.4741641283,
-0.1727468073,
0.5287626982,
-0.1303574592,
0.5425977111,
0.5039722919,
0.2448923886,
-0.4274340868,
-0.4575712681,
-0.2005897015,
0.3679561913,
-0.9480913281,
0.5578048229,
-0.5375313163,
-0.0088806292,
-0.2700040042,
0.2230463028,
-0.3759904206,
-0.6064124107,
-0.3707667291,
-0.0077641835,
0.0908916742,
1.1524857283,
-0.0717801303,
0.3974793851,
-0.5336053967,
-0.0711606815,
0.4702821076,
0.2392293513,
0.2297324836,
-0.7192631364,
-0.2228405625,
-0.0962380916,
-0.1286383569,
-0.8126686811,
-0.3375597894,
-0.1625257581,
0.352527678,
0.5385691524,
-0.1536723971,
0.3732208908,
-0.7056130171,
0.8468568325,
0.2488658577,
-0.6900008917,
0.3245007992,
-0.2698433697,
-0.1694803834,
0.2272171378,
0.342780143,
-0.4792806208,
-0.2306435555,
-0.4308489859,
-0.3258303702,
0.490247488,
-0.0940321088,
0.5099801421,
0.254158169,
0.8926921487,
0.054381717,
0.0892368332,
-0.5533726215,
-0.2179118246,
0.1916114986,
-0.073674649,
-0.4771366715,
-0.5339876413,
-0.1359095275,
-0.130763337,
0.360098511,
0.0399474613,
0.3100836575,
0.0590577386,
0.0682730079,
0.0414744951,
0.41514346,
0.9300251007,
0.7748317122,
0.2648604512,
0.3570687473,
0.0221062656,
-0.183190763,
0.3082675934,
-0.1529071927,
-0.0432230867,
-0.2650004029,
0.7304807305,
0.772126019,
0.3981129527,
-0.3595498502,
0.1345265657,
0.0998176262,
-0.0601350814,
-0.5671254396,
-0.0579401404,
0.2669373155,
0.5615638494,
0.1009507552,
-0.1727025062,
0.1286446303,
-1.1069462299,
-0.0749621466,
0.5559483171,
-0.3961958587,
-0.7452819347,
0.5931762457,
-0.1047828943,
-0.4561726749,
0.2407131344,
0.2099272311,
-0.5802071691,
0.2198152095,
0.4841207862,
0.8740038872,
-0.2158369869,
-0.0359956734,
-0.0088530006,
0.5262771249,
-0.1389034688,
0.1581075042,
-0.1981745958,
-0.8481717706,
-0.6053339839,
-0.4282225966,
-0.6054538488,
-0.122075364,
-0.6268772483,
0.0430424884,
-0.4000828862,
-0.0963871777,
0.0374445058,
-0.0314002931,
-0.1139750704,
-0.0714210868,
0.319178015,
0.8135835528,
-0.7815503478,
1.1260631084,
0.7025799751,
-0.2282856107,
-0.7215787768,
-0.0376279503,
-0.0452698879,
-0.7558804154,
0.6307987571,
-0.3759565651,
-0.2731795311,
-0.0595111735,
-0.6464232802,
-0.8227646351,
0.8523321748,
0.6127021909,
-0.4094631672,
-0.4452035725,
0.1059527248,
0.5318470001,
-0.0606418103,
0.2451370507,
0.441937238,
0.3791732192,
0.1006742492,
-0.6006315947,
0.048738163,
0.0450075679,
0.1607137769,
0.1898832917,
-0.8840355277,
1.0710976124,
-0.0597481653,
-0.0695073456,
0.4985095263,
0.7046691179,
-0.1064612418,
0.0619602315,
0.1355215311,
0.4850930274,
0.6065354943,
0.0540236756,
1.2680932283,
-0.5532175899,
0.3050440252,
1.1076132059,
-0.5099054575,
0.8010376692,
0.5408498049,
-0.491132617,
0.5347855687,
0.5446421504,
0.5098624825,
0.3154344261,
0.2915379405,
-0.4643733799,
-0.1864229292,
-0.0816331059,
-0.4706027508,
0.2955792844,
0.5416829586,
-0.2435918301,
-0.0909087583,
0.0102689145,
-0.022185253,
-0.0472262986,
-0.0435713381,
0.6467497945,
0.5320590138,
-0.6609185934,
-0.1083933488,
0.299074918,
0.2155647278,
-0.6170732379,
0.1686730087,
-0.260989964,
0.2657338381,
0.0768548697,
-0.7853218913,
0.2716940045,
-0.2562360168,
-0.0803212449,
-0.2007883489,
0.8007543087,
-0.2425027341,
-0.5600796938,
0.1433165222,
0.5775300264,
0.3481718898,
0.499461621,
-0.5131860971,
0.1313085407,
-0.2019695044,
-0.2590588331,
0.3198273778,
0.3075440526,
-0.1384992599,
0.8828251958,
0.5853097439,
-0.0241943151,
0.2263644785,
-0.3376241326,
0.6513184309,
-0.7322212458,
-0.2967097461,
-0.9941623211,
0.015300964,
0.354223758,
-0.0561646707,
0.8036734462,
0.3750549555,
0.6894900799,
0.1625684798,
0.544033587,
0.010348524,
0.3490146995,
-0.7242382765,
0.2909546494,
-0.4284079671,
0.4105990529,
-0.2771791816,
-0.6905122399,
-0.1466376036,
0.5563960075,
-0.4375347495,
-0.0855998024,
0.7497931123,
0.56815207,
0.0826238245,
0.355884105,
0.3336870074,
0.2767604589,
0.2988483012,
0.5661408305,
1.1756500006,
-0.3025599718,
-0.0340767689,
-0.0609080307,
-0.0074811107,
0.0232317839,
-0.6349889636,
-0.5900378227,
-0.5673892498,
-0.2104905844,
-0.2695009112,
-0.1656144112,
0.678094089,
0.4901091754,
-0.6355589628,
-0.4757342041,
-0.0609051138,
0.1486442238,
0.246810481,
-0.0915848613,
0.2806787491,
-0.0069719432,
-0.7929056287,
0.2859127223,
0.4631894231,
-0.0110488338,
-0.9026144743,
-0.1992978752,
-0.0971750244,
0.5217629671,
0.928329587,
0.4468169808,
-1.1031274796,
-0.623296082,
-0.2175110579,
-0.0444955938,
-0.2350602001,
0.9576104283,
-0.390178144,
0.3586005867,
0.3295322657,
0.590166688,
0.1685579419,
-0.2872815728,
0.4922988117,
-0.0625977218,
0.4580216408,
0.1428087056,
0.5838621855,
0.1982787699,
0.0917534977,
0.3986070454,
0.2316506356,
-0.2947404087,
-0.985440433,
0.7421679497,
-0.8347075582,
-0.3029336631,
1.0219347477,
-0.0861489996,
-0.112371698,
-0.1143751666,
-0.0011351195,
0.1285669059,
0.2343714982,
0.1992618442,
1.053407073,
-0.1971703321,
-0.3328472078,
-0.8856954575,
0.083678849,
0.4868657291,
-0.5843906999,
-0.0436035842,
0.5413562059,
0.472060442,
0.1731575131,
0.7575967908,
-0.268764466,
-0.0823804513,
-0.0753047988,
-0.2535597086,
0.2677251995,
-0.2851490974,
-0.6490299106,
0.1151366904,
0.485078007,
-0.093661949
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03206v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03206v1
|
Vietnamese AI Generated Text Detection
| 2024-05-06T07:12:22 | 2024-05-06T07:12:22 |
Quang-Dan Tran, Van-Quan Nguyen, Quang-Huy Pham, K. B. Thang Nguyen, Trong-Hop Do
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In recent years, Large Language Models (LLMs) have become integrated into our
daily lives, serving as invaluable assistants in completing tasks. Widely
embraced by users, the abuse of LLMs is inevitable, particularly in using them
to generate text content for various purposes, leading to difficulties in
distinguishing between text generated by LLMs and that written by humans. In
this study, we present a dataset named ViDetect, comprising 6.800 samples of
Vietnamese essay, with 3.400 samples authored by humans and the remainder
generated by LLMs, serving the purpose of detecting text generated by AI. We
conducted evaluations using state-of-the-art methods, including ViT5, BartPho,
PhoBERT, mDeberta V3, and mBERT. These results contribute not only to the
growing body of research on detecting text generated by AI but also demonstrate
the adaptability and effectiveness of different methods in the Vietnamese
language context. This research lays the foundation for future advancements in
AI-generated text detection and provides valuable insights for researchers in
the field of natural language processing.
|
[
-0.1148524731,
-1.0875859261,
0.9128220081,
0.0619050674,
-0.3674556017,
0.0523828492,
-0.0861033648,
-0.5963936448,
-0.0965452641,
0.784175396,
-0.2807139158,
-0.7716614008,
-0.6207537055,
0.7248468995,
-0.4307044446,
0.6895846128,
-0.1654227078,
-0.3305791914,
-0.3184131086,
0.0652056038,
-0.3567963839,
-0.5110254288,
-0.613896668,
-0.1305193901,
0.3521387875,
0.3267969489,
0.0566678047,
0.5608279705,
0.7200525403,
0.402890414,
0.0369027667,
0.5504145026,
-0.3436613381,
0.3314879239,
0.0485138372,
-0.3418902159,
-0.3620342016,
-0.076418601,
0.4967807531,
-0.4106637239,
0.210428521,
0.0617790073,
-0.0275179781,
0.4537872374,
-0.6048041582,
0.1069322973,
-0.8529387116,
-0.2028715312,
-0.3912659287,
-0.2379378974,
-0.534807086,
-0.3433923721,
0.2047481984,
-0.3365738392,
0.0429139398,
-0.4227184355,
0.6324337721,
0.3140006661,
-0.4625673294,
-0.3982721865,
-0.6168792844,
0.6215044856,
-0.6154822111,
-0.0604895949,
0.3538988233,
0.167207852,
-0.0837717205,
-0.660520196,
-0.9207917452,
-0.2456544936,
0.0155989667,
0.3103654385,
-0.3271563053,
-0.013743504,
0.1830591261,
0.2576686144,
-0.7959933281,
0.2630397379,
-0.230377987,
-0.3903345466,
0.8293130398,
0.1868557781,
0.640063107,
-0.5258100629,
-0.530621469,
-0.0857277066,
-0.4744814038,
-0.1552205682,
0.2468883246,
-0.0450201444,
-0.03534187,
0.6408175826,
-0.1157785803,
0.551548183,
-0.5360981226,
-0.4259085953,
0.1931854039,
-0.3344270885,
-0.3080441952,
-0.0741494447,
1.0863146782,
0.4754523933,
0.8298206329,
0.3111903965,
-0.503457725,
0.3286585212,
0.2031175494,
-0.6664874554,
0.0436486751,
0.0865023583,
-0.5876682401,
-0.5560104847,
0.3705510199,
-0.4783653021,
-0.6078621149,
-0.2483529747,
0.2879638076,
-0.4959881306,
-0.3755542338,
0.0363451354,
-0.2003507763,
0.4427144527,
0.2931659818,
-0.3912823796,
-0.0667374209,
0.756285429,
0.8541588783,
-0.7305598855,
-0.3056463599,
-0.5577199459,
0.0467191711,
-0.0824917778,
1.1748598814,
-0.3683678806,
-0.5421947241,
0.2555137873,
-0.0352858528,
-0.0539470688,
-0.8085874915,
0.8026944399,
-0.2169545889,
0.2024662197,
0.0719345063,
-0.6763465405,
-0.0740976408,
0.2695280015,
-0.7725949883,
1.0716257095,
0.1588503122,
-0.8862699866,
0.3956773877,
-0.4174821973,
-0.4543900192,
0.2861762643,
-0.3077251911,
-0.9306492209,
0.1271385401,
0.2653085887,
0.7041049004,
-0.2633522749,
0.1403291821,
-0.0281313118,
-0.4164224565,
0.4522687495,
-0.8072069287,
0.6860437989,
0.1502829492,
-0.3436371386,
0.1558063179,
-0.9701325297,
-0.3048946857,
0.2003673315,
-0.5972166061,
-0.6140124798,
-0.1793520004,
0.3339526057,
0.1581852287,
0.3008915782,
-0.6213759184,
0.001184451,
-0.1033413634,
0.3311900198,
0.913827002,
0.2066347301,
0.0148269432,
-0.2528697252,
0.7865496278,
0.1283926219,
-0.2265738547,
-0.5532438159,
-0.5870744586,
-0.6468715668,
-0.6241906285,
-0.0961772427,
0.8360411525,
-0.991661489,
0.5292788744,
-0.1707390547,
-0.4441225827,
-0.6679520607,
0.1122978404,
0.4212628305,
0.3496269286,
0.2494857013,
-0.0417526811,
-0.6460919976,
-0.9314897656,
-0.3422051668,
-0.4548729956,
-0.2069409937,
0.2451016903,
0.7038283348,
-0.6987400055,
0.9510386586,
-0.5757195354,
-0.256680578,
-0.3511631191,
0.2781542242,
-0.1612183303,
0.0933914036,
0.6801534891,
-0.6882796288,
-0.7737154961,
0.1015423685,
-1.0388233662,
-0.4661425948,
-0.2285631746,
0.040282581,
0.4691320658,
0.6814166307,
-0.5456020236,
0.6314489245,
0.1931852549,
-0.2327679247,
0.5515216589,
-0.1656631678,
0.0450164378,
-1.2863401175,
-0.0183786899,
0.2331005633,
-0.5214987993,
-0.3938763142,
-0.1487872452,
-0.0468158387,
0.214370057,
-0.2503642142,
0.6974061131,
-0.238445878,
0.3754540086,
-0.6478806138,
0.0924563333,
0.0000505323,
0.0387764983,
0.1838294417,
0.9615766406,
0.1474751085,
-0.4270581305,
0.3063600659,
0.0473218188,
-0.2977887094,
0.7386900783,
-0.6566271186,
0.1986348182,
-0.1567195356,
0.1058448404,
-0.9941068292,
-0.1514587998,
0.2182090729,
-0.5062685609,
-0.1259381026,
0.0869205892,
-0.3551228344,
-0.1924027205,
-0.5115562677,
0.1446857601,
0.4114796221,
-0.400778532,
0.3674930632,
0.4299908876,
-0.2859745324,
-0.2598340213,
-0.3729520142,
0.3142569363,
-0.5738669634,
-0.4939908087,
0.0276113395,
0.0256747957,
-0.6338176131,
-0.3165080845,
0.343269676,
-0.1402573436,
0.2501477003,
0.1858988255,
0.2392133325,
-0.4444814324,
0.0755108818,
-0.0267094206,
-0.2705275714,
0.1609370708,
-0.4019374549,
0.3670766354,
0.0703384206,
-0.0966896936,
-0.8072652817,
0.3409943283,
0.7452283502,
-0.3500372171,
0.5402623415,
0.9969971776,
-0.269085139,
-0.1926090866,
-0.4693877399,
-0.0389506556,
-0.4588378668,
0.3706429899,
-0.2229117453,
-0.7928618789,
0.1017441079,
0.1933145374,
-0.0375294201,
0.5742505193,
0.8062070608,
-0.0602065027,
0.775670588,
0.6026070714,
-0.4358746111,
0.5487017632,
0.0016605232,
-0.043003004,
-0.4601552188,
0.1827973425,
-0.5314021111,
0.0702975914,
-1.1579641104,
-0.3960507512,
0.1301228553,
-0.6183465123,
-0.0205745846,
0.2927809954,
-0.6676695347,
0.388060987,
0.7616625428,
0.0107789952,
0.5998853445,
0.1597312689,
0.0779891685,
-0.0248594973,
-0.0607684813,
-1.0310682058,
1.1968599558,
0.1442454904,
0.446053654,
-0.1992849708,
0.8598022461,
0.7601032853,
0.2344141752,
-0.5779001117,
0.6086456776,
-0.2451750785,
-0.1764195412,
-0.2199794203,
-0.2912553251,
-1.0585838556,
0.1665914506,
-0.1619585305,
-0.6398012638,
-0.1683335155,
-0.2232143581,
-0.0000508737,
0.1237778366,
-0.6756517887,
0.5429462194,
-0.1949371547,
-0.1324760765,
0.0536049791,
-0.3400292993,
0.3290133476,
-0.1302486211,
-0.0849292055,
-0.1653850079,
0.0257803742,
0.6650843024,
-0.1592604369,
0.6572501659,
0.0804091394,
-0.5080376267,
0.8112340569,
-0.1072527692,
0.3958274424,
0.3853334486,
-0.051483497,
0.0949445963,
-0.39558658,
-0.1897786558,
-0.1230896935,
0.4745155573,
-0.7470456362,
-0.4769035578,
-0.5315691233,
-0.382114172,
0.4869458675,
0.4552977085,
0.5809826255,
0.0603331514,
-0.4665448368,
0.0022177561,
0.6136856675,
-0.5020971894,
0.3817748427,
0.4671157897,
-0.1251613796,
-0.5242734551,
1.1906335354,
-0.2812819779,
-0.045248948,
0.6666294336,
0.1325245053,
-0.0263611041,
-0.5502911806,
-0.2281632423,
0.2432219833,
-0.3929299712,
-0.1820828021,
-0.7479120493,
-0.5257252455,
-0.4003868401,
-0.0886853933,
-0.0837249085,
-0.1924923509,
-0.5169998407,
-0.2886800468,
0.4160293043,
0.9589698911,
0.1639624685,
0.5575711727,
-0.6645017266,
0.5361829996,
0.1903353333,
-0.2130498737,
-0.4231685102,
-0.2308439761,
-0.1175130606,
-0.1119098812,
-0.4384981692,
-0.5836042166,
0.4873929322,
0.0368182249,
0.294695735,
0.7514750361,
0.0485708266,
0.0009285004,
-0.282050699,
0.6714054346,
-0.3550525308,
-0.6529854536,
0.6618434787,
-0.5523592234,
0.4087542295,
0.4425362945,
0.0653537363,
-0.4347168207,
-0.6126825809,
-0.4759388268,
-0.6660866737,
0.3459771872,
0.6064210534,
0.0860635638,
-0.0086621419,
0.4508751333,
0.2473633587,
0.165670827,
-0.8576818109,
0.0895112231,
0.0711843818,
-0.4549924135,
-0.0946428552,
-0.395162642,
0.430575043,
0.0812791511,
0.3305775523,
-0.1353072375,
0.3872151375,
0.2189010829,
-0.3398997486,
0.2815084159,
0.0341925211,
0.823654592,
0.3883404136,
-0.0215326436,
0.1784459651,
-0.1042695418,
-0.8550354242,
0.1873389333,
-0.0075187958,
-0.4621317983,
0.2357322425,
0.9763465524,
0.6510357857,
-0.5983837843,
-0.881996274,
0.4539029896,
-0.4305115044,
-0.0132141635,
-0.5385519862,
0.3830608726,
-0.1987521201,
0.1639167517,
0.1838454008,
-0.2305701971,
0.1311965734,
-0.2676672339,
0.2638587058,
0.4227394462,
-0.4219844639,
-0.4514091909,
0.5461556911,
0.3369542658,
-0.6099681258,
0.7912088037,
-0.0044084601,
-0.7379969954,
0.7671058774,
0.3177209496,
1.3284515142,
-0.2816783488,
0.3688548505,
0.216663301,
0.5426343083,
0.2148508132,
0.4773759246,
-0.0416306481,
-0.8800355196,
-0.0911280438,
-0.5602088571,
-0.1572037786,
0.4649814367,
-0.390232265,
0.3873446286,
-0.0707913116,
-0.1689697504,
-0.1246799976,
-0.1314698607,
-0.5635186434,
0.1463932246,
0.3547320962,
0.643860817,
-0.9118788838,
0.5907872915,
0.7854456306,
-0.3153042197,
-0.1226081178,
0.4056156576,
0.2751403749,
-0.745762527,
0.2102144361,
0.5413616896,
-0.1577012092,
-0.0692385137,
-0.6335961223,
-0.2646309137,
1.081474185,
0.2325813323,
-0.1430282295,
0.1591035426,
0.5066385269,
0.7975596786,
-0.283669889,
0.2715604305,
0.9418116212,
0.5824753642,
-0.4543519616,
-0.5980501771,
-0.1372558475,
-0.3496456742,
0.0254204497,
-0.1947313696,
-0.5864991546,
0.8302146196,
0.0494040437,
-0.1038236395,
0.24783355,
0.7103058696,
0.5520480871,
0.5652059317,
0.3985491097,
0.3113535941,
0.7545934916,
0.1672047973,
0.8860575557,
0.0447495766,
-0.0331169926,
0.7596070766,
-0.3495360613,
0.6201754808,
0.2467083186,
-0.0265778415,
0.4745691121,
0.5739204288,
-0.0606181324,
0.0811741874,
0.20352301,
-0.4626298547,
-0.0774038881,
-0.2614434958,
-0.1565657109,
0.8951326013,
0.3182757199,
-0.4581793547,
0.1666946411,
0.1290869564,
0.176339522,
0.3936976194,
0.0125124883,
1.1384099722,
0.2203674018,
-0.8089287877,
0.2700179815,
0.0598743521,
0.7521108985,
-0.2772965431,
-0.1676172316,
-0.2600259483,
0.4615745246,
0.0135801677,
-0.7575849295,
-0.0516407341,
0.3838202357,
-0.1343671083,
-0.1735097915,
1.0536862612,
-0.277906239,
-0.7294810414,
0.3091400564,
0.6568785906,
0.0719504878,
-0.3068724871,
-0.2174495161,
0.0764732584,
0.0336865038,
-0.2411652654,
0.0271688476,
0.837870717,
-0.2850348651,
0.4997911453,
0.3917721212,
-0.0075562662,
-0.1502895355,
-0.2510989904,
0.6507197022,
-0.6306440234,
-0.4952369332,
-1.2676780224,
0.3552191556,
-0.2827087939,
-0.4601831734,
0.8062210679,
0.6878449321,
0.83540833,
-0.1845062226,
1.4459056854,
0.3134405315,
0.4831700325,
-0.6602002382,
0.9393638968,
-0.3847852051,
0.2701543868,
-0.7409011126,
-0.8562558889,
-0.1750327498,
0.6309552789,
0.0253980812,
-0.0493109077,
0.509960413,
0.5187182426,
0.1201467961,
-0.149041608,
0.2911531627,
0.1761747748,
0.6978217363,
0.3283685446,
1.0391181707,
-0.2936636209,
0.4306893051,
0.1008555517,
-0.0962114483,
-0.3598767519,
-0.6502403021,
-1.1328378916,
-0.6834114194,
-0.2292423397,
-0.1124135479,
0.0310238693,
0.6321656704,
0.0994353443,
-0.7441443801,
-0.3288713396,
-0.071670711,
0.4086778164,
0.0555514134,
-0.2145165205,
0.4665059149,
0.0135601684,
-0.9193415046,
0.3071596622,
0.4077708423,
0.2007327229,
-0.3757627606,
0.0403163731,
-0.3021826446,
0.1836745292,
0.8990421295,
-0.0472018123,
-0.4690301716,
-0.3221298456,
0.1291579157,
-0.3958380222,
0.1266403198,
0.9316683412,
-0.8514045477,
0.401562959,
0.8716650009,
0.6189427972,
0.143978253,
0.1603641957,
0.7304491401,
-0.5003067851,
0.1108173877,
0.1471381187,
0.2582073808,
0.4020198882,
-0.4194262624,
0.5944782495,
0.3615327775,
-0.6804299951,
-0.7999079227,
0.1113112718,
-0.6549590826,
-0.1770524681,
1.197281599,
-0.130768314,
-0.2142475396,
-0.263864547,
-0.5827127099,
0.2579005957,
-0.4348252416,
0.9149390459,
0.6541241407,
0.0022571366,
-0.0225167237,
-0.4502005875,
0.5713772774,
-0.0183839649,
-1.1978259087,
-0.0923839286,
0.4539424777,
-0.057671871,
-0.145933181,
0.7394861579,
0.2994138896,
0.2783776224,
-0.2906164825,
-0.0523977429,
0.2282741666,
-0.3124488592,
-0.1767261326,
-0.1510841548,
0.0277194269,
-0.1407700777
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03205v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03205v2
|
Anchored Answers: Unravelling Positional Bias in GPT-2's Multiple-Choice Questions
| 2024-05-06T07:10:09 | 2024-05-23T07:47:02 |
Ruizhe Li, Yanjun Gao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs), such as the GPT-4 and LLaMA families, have
demonstrated considerable success across diverse tasks, including
multiple-choice questions (MCQs). However, these models exhibit a positional
bias, particularly an even worse anchored bias in the GPT-2 family, where they
consistently favour the first choice 'A' in MCQs during inference. This
anchored bias challenges the integrity of GPT-2's decision-making process, as
it skews performance based on the position rather than the content of the
choices in MCQs. In this study, we utilise the mechanistic interpretability
approach to identify the internal modules within GPT-2 models responsible for
this bias. We focus on the Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) layers and attention
heads, using the "logit lens" method to trace and modify the specific value
vectors that contribute to the bias. By updating these vectors within MLP and
recalibrating attention patterns to neutralise the preference for the first
choice 'A', we effectively mitigate the anchored bias. Our interventions not
only mitigate the bias but also improve the overall MCQ prediction accuracy for
the GPT-2 family across various datasets. This work represents the first
comprehensive mechanistic analysis of anchored bias in MCQs within the GPT-2
models, introducing targeted, minimal-intervention strategies that
significantly enhance GPT2 model robustness and accuracy in MCQs. Our code is
available at https://github.com/ruizheliUOA/Anchored_Bias_GPT2.
|
[
-0.2087719738,
-0.8297032118,
0.7488421202,
-0.0246502347,
-0.1918098778,
0.1293269098,
-0.0044953348,
-0.277030915,
-0.1733299792,
0.3323866725,
-0.6334609985,
-0.1337023526,
-0.8108206987,
-0.190456897,
0.2117191553,
0.9728237391,
-0.2254348844,
-0.0362671912,
-0.2357002348,
-0.3204834759,
-0.3199473023,
-0.5217020512,
-0.5517463684,
-0.4661535025,
0.5146811008,
0.4981792569,
0.9646204114,
0.4151411057,
0.0985822007,
0.0768745095,
-0.3431275487,
0.0581716187,
-0.4506835938,
-0.0985204577,
-0.3910380602,
-0.5137670636,
-0.4843709171,
0.0513376743,
0.5507849455,
0.3806387484,
0.0093834121,
0.3794916272,
0.385610193,
0.4982211292,
-0.6039074659,
0.0901857316,
-0.6040158272,
-0.07594423,
-0.0563850813,
-0.1235211194,
-0.4201937914,
-0.0177224129,
0.295784086,
-0.3364257812,
0.178432703,
-0.3591355383,
0.5375214219,
0.5445727706,
-0.7499759793,
-0.1855819523,
-0.3313504457,
0.8378938437,
-0.5996105671,
0.2003487051,
0.3142252266,
-0.1172838062,
-0.1037234068,
-0.2189373225,
-0.3075657487,
0.0275985748,
-0.2290143669,
0.3944368064,
0.1086298376,
0.0629496798,
0.2844641805,
-0.1647819728,
-0.836412847,
0.1146650463,
-0.2855500877,
-0.0840530023,
0.3166305423,
-0.156489104,
0.1723927557,
-0.0000498441,
-0.399448216,
-0.0430538766,
-0.8655753732,
0.1890391409,
0.40449512,
-0.0292468052,
0.1083556265,
0.8160547018,
-0.1909971386,
0.3414367139,
0.4689817429,
-0.0904141963,
0.0685838461,
-0.135169208,
-0.1015322283,
0.2318194956,
0.2351934314,
0.418798089,
0.1026172116,
0.2588849664,
-0.0220423602,
0.0331255719,
0.1900826842,
-0.5283432007,
-0.0727752149,
0.573984623,
-0.3327941895,
-0.3887579739,
-0.166835919,
-0.491660893,
-0.2523779869,
-0.0704167783,
0.5672695041,
0.0998047143,
-0.5164272785,
-0.152891919,
-0.0251596645,
0.4888059199,
0.1680306792,
-1.0374335051,
-0.03476559,
0.8028146625,
0.7266134024,
-0.1053121984,
-0.3184604645,
-0.1296800226,
0.5943416953,
-0.1094756871,
0.7753808498,
-0.6494275331,
-0.1010078788,
-0.0022938685,
0.074645102,
-0.2360390574,
-0.3084459603,
0.6044935584,
-0.6417341232,
0.3355403543,
-0.6852935553,
-0.2167245895,
-0.1402106434,
0.4359641969,
-0.5158906579,
1.0844515562,
0.2300310433,
-0.9957432151,
0.3861911297,
-0.5815847516,
-0.1691842079,
-0.4864896536,
-0.3581548035,
-0.4686575234,
0.1245291904,
0.5629637241,
0.2371951044,
-0.1414260268,
0.1984633505,
-0.327108413,
-0.3177980781,
0.0876009986,
-0.4316453636,
0.7950304151,
-0.1528326124,
-0.5832773447,
0.006589951,
-0.3338071704,
0.0298707131,
0.0652554929,
-0.3412213922,
-0.158983767,
0.0955285206,
-0.2968811691,
0.5652576089,
0.159359321,
-0.2721534669,
0.4420852363,
-0.0954363719,
0.6301007271,
1.0005664825,
0.0205953214,
0.5357421637,
0.0629834756,
0.6010996103,
0.2844070792,
0.2766870558,
-0.0188598726,
-0.7727423906,
-0.3383714557,
0.1339752972,
-0.0348105207,
0.6368065476,
-0.7056403756,
-0.1370574981,
-0.1910874397,
-0.0981611311,
-0.4402805865,
0.0359280482,
0.543638587,
0.7073159814,
0.4565083981,
-0.176099658,
-0.2168736756,
-1.1129369736,
-0.3151445985,
-0.2793201506,
-0.1434651315,
0.265451014,
0.4416145086,
-0.2557706833,
0.8819984198,
-0.4555384517,
0.0570781156,
0.0213303678,
0.0077120005,
0.3153131008,
0.5241517425,
0.2389057875,
-0.6646472812,
-0.3877528906,
-0.2196623236,
-0.697280705,
0.0138130132,
0.0482982248,
-0.2194724083,
0.0652072132,
0.0897229761,
-1.0076586008,
0.2836969495,
0.5213189721,
-0.4468488097,
0.7117163539,
0.1011095122,
-0.1599863768,
-0.7026888728,
-0.1577985287,
-0.1270070374,
0.0856035948,
-0.5274423957,
0.0156619363,
0.1680682898,
0.2978909016,
-0.1575793326,
0.5562160611,
-0.4779099226,
-0.3341958523,
-0.1449985206,
0.0650233179,
0.1193200946,
0.6516055465,
0.1016581729,
0.9758062363,
0.2916942537,
-0.2047978044,
-0.1546315402,
0.6125867367,
-0.093536973,
0.3972019255,
-0.8226387501,
0.6094461083,
-0.1741193235,
0.4679291844,
-1.301353097,
-0.3380778432,
0.4151166677,
-0.5626242757,
0.4833901227,
-0.594470799,
-0.2099729627,
-0.2040074915,
-0.4475914836,
0.8406302333,
0.2049954236,
-0.4807087481,
0.4069440067,
0.4100900888,
-0.3827713728,
-1.2568633556,
-0.6682210565,
-0.1272795349,
-0.2541126311,
-0.6558499336,
0.1472938508,
0.1085809246,
-0.2017102391,
-0.1239832789,
-0.6499067545,
0.0072013615,
-0.141073212,
-0.0770449415,
0.1827950776,
-0.4025894105,
0.0662032217,
0.4711854458,
-0.3769020736,
0.1480534673,
-0.7516494989,
0.2466437072,
-0.0834210068,
-0.405724287,
0.0157396458,
0.2293334156,
0.6154329777,
-0.2543389201,
0.5428872108,
0.5187336802,
-0.2254075557,
0.0828734487,
-0.6337290406,
-0.2648197412,
-0.4212120473,
0.5117296576,
-0.4407874942,
-1.0623933077,
0.4796774387,
0.2265042365,
-0.1657302827,
0.4197640121,
0.7884121537,
-0.0768530294,
1.3256492615,
0.2234074324,
-0.2001451254,
0.2064211071,
-0.0393447243,
0.1126248166,
-1.3484727144,
-0.083482638,
0.0325041562,
-0.3715980053,
-0.4303280413,
-0.5861299634,
0.6159566045,
0.0606961399,
-0.3868429959,
0.0658809915,
-0.6909679174,
0.4681405723,
0.6433369517,
0.4114643633,
0.07527107,
-0.0814360231,
-0.2931242883,
0.1817448735,
-0.7204108834,
-0.6894029975,
1.3547762632,
0.6080353856,
0.3835759163,
0.1865961552,
0.141622752,
0.077722393,
0.3513703048,
-0.538903296,
0.1984929144,
0.1373967081,
-0.9212257862,
-0.4216061532,
0.0363859795,
-0.5984681845,
0.5087783933,
0.1777292043,
-0.8808053136,
0.2935402989,
0.4360764623,
-0.4521034658,
0.1843411177,
-0.5989823341,
0.8766536713,
-0.4243136644,
-1.0493940115,
-0.192457214,
-0.9170417786,
0.4285872579,
0.1615121663,
0.049687732,
-0.1220280081,
-0.1276716441,
0.514939189,
-0.0257403143,
0.6940600872,
-0.4287786782,
-0.3764439523,
0.3806571662,
-0.0512950793,
0.7376843691,
0.386839956,
-0.1872769147,
0.156689778,
0.0734124854,
-0.6327691674,
-0.608207047,
0.5845220685,
-0.7823654413,
-0.7508132458,
-0.3607498109,
-0.4575122297,
-0.4773563743,
0.0370149314,
0.2691645622,
0.4438958168,
0.2980372906,
-0.1291214228,
0.8725233078,
-0.1668146402,
0.2133237571,
0.2713415027,
0.0675070062,
-0.3233507872,
0.420730412,
0.257280618,
0.3307645619,
0.4144644141,
0.2087344527,
-0.496176213,
-0.7122491598,
-0.5596794486,
0.1601715088,
-0.7175621986,
0.1157786623,
-0.3253214955,
0.1496403664,
-0.1470183879,
-0.0150079569,
-0.3108776212,
-0.5268596411,
-0.1349678338,
-0.6410988569,
-0.149627775,
0.7143306732,
0.1054921299,
0.3932296932,
-0.4721729457,
0.2346431315,
0.4004404545,
0.4307055771,
-0.0370803066,
-0.4939278662,
-0.1021647453,
0.0712956339,
-0.2767944634,
-0.9631393552,
-0.0785982013,
-0.2344487011,
0.5313873887,
0.532278657,
-0.3174476027,
0.6040449739,
-0.4656840861,
0.6969019175,
-0.1568776518,
-0.730183363,
0.5440592766,
-0.6871296167,
0.2812660336,
0.5927191973,
0.2473982871,
-0.0372691564,
-0.0662279055,
-0.6062049866,
-0.869345963,
0.6703612208,
0.2728952765,
-0.056036599,
0.0683913305,
0.7371079326,
0.020351639,
0.3423824608,
-0.7315320969,
-0.1578740627,
-0.1076432317,
-0.0893398896,
-0.0175608285,
-0.9365522265,
-0.1750215739,
-0.2505514622,
0.6508351564,
-0.3442432284,
0.4145202637,
0.452560842,
-0.3391614258,
-0.1267011762,
0.2407841235,
0.7573975921,
0.9254549146,
-0.3688896596,
0.3089017272,
0.2357554138,
-0.4956874847,
0.2214265764,
-0.1719371378,
-0.4472382069,
-0.3062156737,
0.2466457039,
0.6001560688,
0.3579776585,
-0.3040824831,
0.3273334503,
0.3272398114,
0.00127502,
-0.3579728901,
-0.2144342363,
-0.0459201746,
0.4751463234,
0.3820434213,
-0.0312898085,
0.0522299185,
-0.5998630524,
0.4311907589,
0.5991474986,
-0.6019234061,
-0.4968629181,
0.9288326502,
-0.0805972442,
0.1181560308,
0.5785656571,
0.056247279,
-0.8215361238,
0.4413403571,
0.4837037921,
0.8148416877,
-0.4649547338,
0.2172852457,
0.4851256311,
0.5392452478,
-0.1351734996,
0.2147528082,
0.1191479117,
-0.9747569561,
-0.4423422217,
-0.3039444089,
-0.3594480157,
0.0997691676,
-0.7788165808,
-0.0615094677,
-0.4170778692,
-0.2400799692,
-0.3698962033,
-0.1182408705,
-0.3304063082,
0.2092053443,
0.2408003956,
0.589563489,
-0.8360256553,
0.708272934,
0.8788290024,
-0.3379687071,
-0.5592440963,
0.2543616891,
0.332036972,
-1.0372931957,
0.1593305171,
0.2778376043,
-0.1404295415,
0.0619283989,
-0.748547852,
-1.09864223,
1.3139243126,
0.3382728696,
-0.2638892829,
-0.1864388585,
0.2128129601,
0.1543378681,
-0.1629298776,
0.7418465018,
0.9147697687,
0.534267664,
-0.0415499583,
-0.8533396721,
0.2488511801,
-0.1010546461,
-0.2992691994,
0.0706026927,
-0.8997063637,
0.8616893888,
-0.3624413311,
0.2859152555,
-0.2024341077,
0.2008336931,
0.5567953587,
0.3801081181,
0.2660897076,
0.480174154,
0.794259429,
-0.0661912635,
0.9918062687,
-0.1378249824,
0.4971686006,
1.2446748018,
-0.1667717695,
0.8469685912,
0.7535085082,
-0.3898480833,
0.428243041,
0.7733929157,
-0.0071405261,
0.5666854978,
0.0501590483,
-0.232913956,
-0.1245963871,
0.1735180467,
-0.1624000967,
0.3821712136,
0.4759941399,
-0.2216733098,
0.024141375,
-0.3661685586,
0.1466214955,
-0.4669137895,
-0.3683901429,
0.587127924,
0.0408712998,
-0.8540814519,
0.2529633641,
-0.1038206741,
0.3353924155,
-0.4908739626,
0.0333381854,
-0.1634501368,
0.2710496783,
-0.3753313124,
-0.8815522194,
0.036606092,
-0.2262159437,
-0.4284993708,
-0.0969263837,
0.8094714284,
-0.3950383365,
-0.3436952531,
0.2931526005,
0.5480388403,
-0.1496105641,
-0.5096246004,
-0.7610391974,
-0.0747403279,
0.1560297757,
-0.6096265316,
0.4316059351,
0.0232264735,
-0.3746028543,
0.5933304429,
0.5351856947,
-0.4012607038,
0.1356581599,
-0.1007491276,
0.7618072629,
-0.4106094241,
-0.2987927198,
-0.9180079699,
0.9150335789,
0.1302385032,
-0.2129695565,
0.6279742718,
0.4651342332,
0.5865502357,
-0.1347995996,
0.9692236185,
0.1988001168,
0.3235899508,
-0.6012804508,
0.4882884622,
-0.2160020918,
0.3739055991,
-0.3511544466,
-1.0011042356,
-0.1292500794,
0.6571871638,
-0.5074917674,
0.0763208643,
0.6662485003,
0.6748110652,
-0.1504530311,
-0.2040064782,
-0.0037673658,
0.4377344251,
0.155509159,
0.780167222,
0.9785530567,
-0.3989606798,
0.4452736378,
-0.1428742707,
-0.3903704882,
-0.1220938638,
-0.8040885925,
-0.6634299159,
-0.2170717716,
-0.2541979253,
-0.3326970041,
0.1670975238,
0.7194553018,
0.3984543681,
-1.025832057,
0.0030309928,
0.0731490329,
0.338473171,
-0.259888649,
-0.1724604666,
0.7140261531,
0.0070488746,
-0.5027104616,
0.3093667924,
0.2994045019,
-0.2206620127,
0.0567484684,
0.0112983538,
-0.321785897,
-0.1141075715,
0.8031104803,
0.1328295469,
-0.910835743,
-0.5722208023,
-0.0106412936,
0.4097610116,
0.3115812838,
0.6882207394,
-0.5679864883,
0.2935606539,
0.1429601759,
0.5141785741,
0.4459029138,
0.5256405473,
0.6090701818,
-0.7696847916,
0.0603519939,
0.0938304886,
0.3383391798,
0.1516341716,
-0.4734406769,
0.7200441957,
0.0877049863,
-0.6643342376,
-0.7693839669,
0.3317757249,
-0.9585036039,
-0.0263294801,
1.4230076075,
-0.0077854502,
0.2393496484,
-0.2010251433,
-0.3017056882,
0.2910825908,
-0.1536249071,
0.6512196064,
0.9153969288,
-0.3402868807,
-0.4557186663,
-0.8882486224,
0.501992166,
0.6626160741,
-0.2118954808,
0.0475585014,
0.4433077574,
0.4595501423,
0.0090822205,
0.5369847417,
-0.2415222675,
0.1174830645,
-0.1283129007,
-0.4763126969,
0.0380871557,
-0.2589814961,
-0.5629617572,
0.2999044657,
0.1014093608,
-0.0713979527
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03170v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03170v1
|
Oracle-Checker Scheme for Evaluating a Generative Large Language Model
| 2024-05-06T05:36:29 | 2024-05-06T05:36:29 |
Yueling Jenny Zeng, Li-C. Wang, Thomas Ibbetson
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This work presents a novel approach called oracle-checker scheme for
evaluating the answer given by a generative large language model (LLM). Two
types of checkers are presented. The first type of checker follows the idea of
property testing. The second type of checker follows the idea of program
checking. Their applications are demonstrated in two separate contexts, entity
extraction and paraphrase decision, respectively.
|
[
-0.2420776188,
-1.032107234,
0.6081625223,
0.3893446326,
-0.3733537197,
-0.0539686643,
-0.0608433299,
-0.2799194753,
0.1345214993,
1.0072023869,
-0.4339076579,
-0.3820475042,
-0.6145107746,
0.2515403926,
-0.6306065321,
0.7017842531,
-0.3469503224,
-0.105311431,
-0.2361162901,
0.0416161753,
-0.1519776881,
-0.3148057461,
-0.9908538461,
-0.6201182008,
0.0830997899,
-0.0501223691,
0.6463010907,
0.3156779706,
0.8379544616,
0.4276670218,
-0.3988463879,
-0.0898837447,
-0.180032149,
0.0804744065,
-0.0472080447,
-0.8400682807,
-0.4316329956,
-0.3225050867,
0.4787788391,
0.3528802097,
-0.3286167383,
0.2441102564,
-0.3315099478,
0.4622974098,
-0.7066121101,
0.3700496852,
-0.6173007488,
0.0078462288,
-0.1729347408,
-0.2075508237,
-0.558003068,
-0.7207583189,
-0.041994378,
-0.2487856448,
0.0857373476,
0.0361485556,
0.8438938856,
0.249176845,
-0.4761656225,
-0.337146014,
-0.8164298534,
0.7407020926,
-0.7143218517,
0.1937806457,
0.3539844453,
0.6850069761,
0.1114765257,
-0.4929101169,
-1.1181858778,
-0.5780017376,
-0.0927762017,
0.0227613524,
-0.0595009327,
0.4082058966,
0.3200239837,
1.0631855726,
-0.6549784541,
0.2617847919,
-0.2229617387,
-0.2285814434,
0.540402174,
0.204393059,
0.5635330677,
-0.2886410952,
-0.5029915571,
-0.0698860735,
-0.8950794935,
-0.3041810393,
0.2419872284,
-0.087790519,
0.0325941592,
1.1686081886,
-0.2231365144,
1.0765961409,
-0.0282651056,
-0.3648465872,
-0.0592501312,
-0.607465148,
-0.6424831152,
-0.0540719479,
0.4102483392,
0.2182489932,
0.1617434621,
-0.1823531687,
-0.7264019847,
0.3482619226,
-0.2422977388,
-0.5952869058,
-0.0537407286,
0.325879693,
-0.5689235926,
-0.3321942687,
-0.0699616373,
-0.818831563,
-0.3936136067,
-0.300958544,
0.3528813422,
-0.3659961522,
-0.194456175,
0.1072049811,
-0.0209320299,
1.0269327164,
0.1970769167,
-0.7918293476,
0.3387095928,
1.0903967619,
0.5100576878,
-0.1559447795,
-0.1806243211,
-0.5056571364,
0.2116280049,
-0.3598028719,
0.8838857412,
-0.6966568232,
-0.1106763557,
0.3557015955,
-0.2499753535,
-0.0551674068,
-0.8528447151,
0.5737859607,
-0.8643319011,
0.1868007481,
-0.0194819104,
-0.7868118286,
-0.1562579423,
0.3509518504,
-0.7632809877,
1.2590326071,
0.4090656638,
-0.470055908,
0.7148361206,
-0.6890606284,
-0.2213935852,
0.4571301937,
-0.1946138144,
-0.5392600298,
-0.0067465003,
0.0137146674,
0.139762938,
-0.6881312132,
0.3525719643,
-0.2892078161,
-0.3787989318,
0.2105436921,
-0.184535861,
1.0577744246,
0.3901914954,
-0.4168262184,
0.3060794473,
-1.1029185057,
0.0900423303,
0.0718748271,
-0.6775445938,
-0.478821069,
-0.0034133268,
0.0896929801,
0.1553936452,
0.4967389107,
-0.4852203727,
0.3884405792,
-0.5287731886,
0.1693071872,
0.5654158592,
0.0804706514,
0.2577983439,
-0.2189197093,
0.7331980467,
-0.0410194211,
0.0706534311,
-0.0590516105,
-0.2132657915,
-1.4668812752,
-0.3334992528,
0.191881761,
0.7752406597,
-1.0151246786,
0.857480824,
0.0941367447,
-0.4471669197,
-0.3628057241,
0.2855071127,
0.8788843155,
-0.2634271681,
0.2388276458,
0.1282803267,
-0.6128214002,
-0.9011670351,
-0.1246802583,
-0.4803157449,
-0.0621520691,
0.1027127653,
0.7308120728,
-0.2132062763,
0.5347735286,
-0.5647084713,
0.1881925166,
-0.7068721056,
0.1650007963,
0.2548445761,
0.1622171551,
0.4527084231,
-0.5964230299,
-0.473952949,
0.1940712035,
-0.7412909865,
-0.1350479126,
-0.2967268825,
0.0505270474,
0.1715678722,
0.5669634342,
-0.891911149,
0.3416432738,
0.4246350527,
-0.4185368419,
0.5816152096,
-0.3087055683,
-0.039127443,
-0.9689487815,
-0.179190442,
-0.1740557849,
-0.20065175,
-0.478076458,
0.7025945187,
-0.026597593,
0.0516561531,
-0.2429176569,
0.4587221742,
-0.5761024952,
-0.3131831288,
-0.3460171819,
-0.0855616778,
-0.3538464904,
0.0571114086,
-0.0328396745,
0.904877007,
0.7306659222,
-0.8142766953,
0.7223704457,
0.2507081032,
-0.5559011698,
0.7504284978,
-0.8213837147,
0.3633206487,
-0.2982911766,
0.0362949185,
-0.850271821,
-0.187684387,
0.0830302909,
0.0771347061,
0.2136482298,
0.1584195346,
-0.5465271473,
-0.7673729062,
-0.3195165992,
0.0376216322,
0.2248181552,
-0.7203894854,
0.8558977246,
0.167039603,
-0.1914711744,
-0.5246887803,
-0.5164610744,
0.2447484881,
-0.4685109556,
-0.7424408793,
0.132866621,
-0.1081191376,
-0.7328078747,
-0.2911498845,
-0.0249964315,
-0.4204007387,
-0.0946948379,
0.0039114351,
0.4154461026,
-0.4978689849,
-0.3064252138,
0.0520721599,
-0.1018894091,
0.2250663936,
-0.2170043737,
0.6785817146,
-0.1544701904,
-0.5554130673,
-0.3127194941,
0.210572347,
0.6320671439,
-0.358335644,
0.7369560599,
0.2470093817,
-0.3767823875,
-0.2574943006,
-0.8813084364,
-0.1310872287,
-0.4840483367,
0.4239354134,
-0.6188970804,
-0.8207953572,
0.657523334,
-0.0456147678,
-0.2958864868,
0.4481203556,
0.892611444,
0.2977543771,
0.3182455003,
0.8685485125,
0.0365116857,
0.2132654041,
-0.1407079548,
0.4304576814,
-0.5096970201,
-0.3722712994,
-0.7015808821,
0.1878222674,
-0.4017091393,
-0.4172468483,
0.0685410723,
0.271992147,
-0.2670615315,
0.5438383222,
-0.1240953133,
0.7528612018,
0.365593344,
0.0003025197,
0.6017636657,
-0.2374362499,
-0.146034196,
0.1588277668,
-0.0720946342,
-0.6019048691,
0.8520195484,
0.2546113729,
0.7737345099,
0.4453553855,
0.7993751168,
0.2106485963,
0.4709805846,
-0.8907179832,
0.8914314508,
-0.1615088433,
-0.757085979,
-0.490691334,
-0.2049643844,
-0.8073621392,
0.2311141789,
0.0167376734,
-0.7500147223,
0.3577638865,
0.0069322335,
-0.1434831619,
0.2591356635,
-0.3670946956,
0.6445786357,
-0.2552849948,
0.2028759122,
-0.0390476286,
-0.2756072879,
0.7746353745,
-0.3209471703,
-0.3250728846,
0.2296608537,
-0.0107910912,
0.4859558046,
-0.5299162865,
0.5845732689,
-0.027230015,
-0.4169085622,
0.5969833136,
0.3461256921,
0.9554095864,
-0.0628517643,
-0.2448181063,
-0.3320458829,
-0.1281203777,
-0.147124812,
-0.5282659531,
0.2840631604,
-0.6500610113,
-0.6524531841,
-0.3112218082,
-0.3345704377,
0.1187972054,
0.3379918039,
0.2472596616,
-0.0576224774,
-0.1976452321,
0.2241092175,
0.6465741992,
-0.3184488118,
0.2917383015,
0.8378830552,
-0.4911927283,
-0.0541924946,
0.728631258,
-0.4917099476,
0.5024056435,
0.9082689881,
0.0905793235,
-0.3810754418,
-0.8236609697,
-0.1238468885,
0.3873892128,
-0.9275842905,
-0.0178380944,
-0.191089496,
-0.4106336236,
-0.1088293046,
0.1068165228,
-0.4360128641,
-0.1655205339,
0.1879169047,
-0.2076919079,
0.2043790966,
0.772642076,
0.3916820288,
0.2380017191,
-0.3817276359,
0.2447822392,
0.7538968921,
0.2295021266,
-0.3569974303,
-0.3980619609,
0.3659644127,
-0.5128443241,
-0.1443934739,
-1.0194259882,
0.3086833656,
0.2024543285,
0.7236197591,
0.4949917197,
-0.4087933004,
0.3559387028,
-0.2333552241,
0.8046222329,
0.1844984591,
-0.8457148075,
0.7300463319,
-0.2770313025,
-0.1522058994,
0.5651497245,
0.1538846046,
-0.2318269312,
-0.2755085826,
-0.2700841725,
-0.6843726635,
0.3643496037,
0.2636894882,
0.0861527175,
-0.0525279194,
0.49120152,
0.072061345,
-0.0022797633,
-1.041965127,
-0.6128798723,
0.0594009981,
0.2882430553,
0.0882008001,
-0.6720420718,
-0.1969792694,
0.1472394168,
0.3219977915,
-0.0860692859,
0.1502154469,
-0.1875422746,
-0.1866397858,
-0.1581813395,
0.7520675659,
0.4126766026,
0.7599367499,
-0.4075801671,
0.2266075611,
0.2656418681,
-0.2915135622,
0.3696660697,
0.0388557985,
-0.583124578,
-0.1684513241,
0.2627657652,
0.9354575872,
-0.0882743895,
-0.4650815129,
0.5166166425,
0.1896449924,
-0.2607357502,
-0.4122681916,
0.073373504,
0.0172695778,
0.1867702007,
-0.0541740246,
-0.2163153738,
0.3928349912,
-0.535391748,
0.1014625132,
0.3276592195,
-0.1298826039,
-0.1731080264,
0.4561836123,
0.0038596112,
-0.4588283896,
0.6661784053,
-0.5281054974,
-0.3999498188,
0.8013041019,
0.9985496402,
1.0156484842,
-0.5112471581,
0.3949671388,
0.2136355788,
0.4608211219,
-0.1004705057,
0.666369915,
0.0368637852,
-0.6908732653,
-0.8688547611,
-0.7876256108,
-0.5039873719,
0.5701405406,
-0.7062474489,
0.3684627712,
-0.1754971743,
0.1810665578,
0.2456502318,
-0.4265402257,
-0.6467506886,
0.1555012614,
0.2294279635,
0.8782674074,
-0.7678616643,
1.0359289646,
0.8786013722,
-0.5044491291,
-0.6172091961,
0.1709894985,
-0.1414735317,
-0.9617494345,
1.1560227871,
-0.2289980352,
-0.0807809904,
-0.4517136514,
-0.2506895661,
-1.0461623669,
0.9585665464,
0.5126619339,
-0.6933557987,
0.0515770577,
0.1895099878,
0.6605163813,
-0.0268514976,
0.2898103297,
0.8513096571,
0.6800096631,
0.1711182147,
-1.0412095785,
0.0899597108,
-0.1926891506,
0.3377420008,
0.3543992341,
-0.4806501567,
0.9568590522,
-0.1530747712,
-0.1520516723,
0.3987440765,
0.735439837,
0.5986032486,
0.0433662198,
0.5644505024,
0.8158220649,
0.6664606929,
-0.0708687678,
1.4863806963,
-0.3328453302,
0.6236736774,
0.8628603816,
-0.3946243525,
0.8845370412,
0.3385383189,
-0.8316149712,
0.4353315532,
0.2913677394,
-0.1850547343,
0.3127007782,
0.576566875,
-0.5488116145,
-0.3408993781,
0.2336756587,
-0.3979675174,
0.768319428,
0.4167587161,
-0.2598101497,
-0.1882896572,
-0.439761579,
-0.098221913,
-0.0280740112,
-0.2503636181,
0.7417936325,
-0.0077356342,
-1.011906147,
0.5270234346,
0.2168043256,
0.5619677305,
-0.4274358451,
-0.0780617818,
-0.2064625025,
0.3908539116,
-0.1156748831,
-0.7907918692,
0.5045732856,
-0.107438907,
-0.1288308501,
0.1417970508,
0.9017464519,
-0.4425121248,
-0.57687217,
0.474652499,
0.4406498075,
0.1573974043,
-0.0130285351,
-0.8060417175,
-0.0388077945,
-0.105874978,
-0.2876782715,
0.0073038861,
0.359952569,
-0.0637467951,
0.8352587223,
0.4568821788,
0.2030635178,
0.1295851618,
0.4251139462,
0.8079765439,
-0.6172909141,
-0.367557019,
-0.9940686226,
0.0314880013,
-0.0772025511,
-0.3103075624,
0.9091438651,
0.6222857833,
0.539262116,
-0.2699509859,
0.6975569725,
-0.0889828354,
0.2473487407,
-0.6616653204,
0.2035588473,
-0.1928082705,
0.5081012845,
-0.3330473304,
-1.3300052881,
-0.4526058435,
0.6636232734,
-0.4469229281,
0.2539276481,
0.9661068916,
0.8332568407,
0.2289306819,
0.003763071,
0.3216213286,
0.3020662665,
0.2784403861,
0.6654692888,
1.1109440327,
-0.2774761617,
0.5169677138,
-0.1899881512,
-0.3156035542,
0.015159497,
-0.9284861088,
-1.155215621,
-0.2786543965,
-0.3746160865,
-0.6009442806,
0.063549459,
0.4398964942,
0.3539066017,
-1.0884637833,
-0.1757902652,
-0.3501134515,
0.222128883,
-0.1278360039,
-0.1966294199,
0.6065489054,
-0.217529878,
-0.5208142996,
0.2356634289,
0.5504626632,
-0.1915134639,
-0.5283094645,
-0.2034727037,
0.0506568216,
0.161779657,
0.6711901426,
0.1591210812,
-1.0966038704,
0.0088383621,
-0.0508442707,
-0.1666188687,
0.012142051,
0.9376574755,
-0.2648333311,
0.4938373268,
0.6622774005,
0.6381133795,
0.6715969443,
-0.3042353988,
0.3564004302,
-0.3014798164,
0.0561344475,
0.0708316118,
0.6635640264,
0.1078639776,
-0.4406479001,
0.3395263553,
0.0306386705,
-0.5235401988,
-0.5620222092,
0.5008759499,
-1.2347631454,
-0.0678193644,
1.2769178152,
-0.1895691603,
-0.1575980932,
-0.239606902,
-0.1892686784,
0.0021648973,
-0.0493398197,
0.9137663841,
0.6570391655,
-0.0285871513,
-0.2902109325,
-0.2115179151,
0.4079443812,
0.2801772952,
-1.2179744244,
-0.126205489,
0.1396640092,
0.3269148171,
0.4047143459,
0.658260107,
-0.4562324286,
0.3398681283,
0.080912523,
0.1894606799,
0.278970629,
-0.0343063585,
-0.318420887,
0.1819981039,
0.313124299,
0.0972015038
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03162v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03162v1
|
Advancing Multimodal Medical Capabilities of Gemini
| 2024-05-06T04:44:22 | 2024-05-06T04:44:22 |
Lin Yang, Shawn Xu, Andrew Sellergren, Timo Kohlberger, Yuchen Zhou, Ira Ktena, Atilla Kiraly, Faruk Ahmed, Farhad Hormozdiari, Tiam Jaroensri, Eric Wang, Ellery Wulczyn, Fayaz Jamil, Theo Guidroz, Chuck Lau, Siyuan Qiao, Yun Liu, Akshay Goel, Kendall Park, Arnav Agharwal, Nick George, Yang Wang, Ryutaro Tanno, David G. T. Barrett, Wei-Hung Weng, S. Sara Mahdavi, Khaled Saab, Tao Tu, Sreenivasa Raju Kalidindi, Mozziyar Etemadi, Jorge Cuadros, Gregory Sorensen, Yossi Matias, Katherine Chou, Greg Corrado, Joelle Barral, Shravya Shetty, David Fleet, S. M. Ali Eslami, Daniel Tse, Shruthi Prabhakara, Cory McLean, Dave Steiner, Rory Pilgrim, Christopher Kelly, Shekoofeh Azizi, Daniel Golden
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Many clinical tasks require an understanding of specialized data, such as
medical images and genomics, which is not typically found in general-purpose
large multimodal models. Building upon Gemini's multimodal models, we develop
several models within the new Med-Gemini family that inherit core capabilities
of Gemini and are optimized for medical use via fine-tuning with 2D and 3D
radiology, histopathology, ophthalmology, dermatology and genomic data.
Med-Gemini-2D sets a new standard for AI-based chest X-ray (CXR) report
generation based on expert evaluation, exceeding previous best results across
two separate datasets by an absolute margin of 1% and 12%, where 57% and 96% of
AI reports on normal cases, and 43% and 65% on abnormal cases, are evaluated as
"equivalent or better" than the original radiologists' reports. We demonstrate
the first ever large multimodal model-based report generation for 3D computed
tomography (CT) volumes using Med-Gemini-3D, with 53% of AI reports considered
clinically acceptable, although additional research is needed to meet expert
radiologist reporting quality. Beyond report generation, Med-Gemini-2D
surpasses the previous best performance in CXR visual question answering (VQA)
and performs well in CXR classification and radiology VQA, exceeding SoTA or
baselines on 17 of 20 tasks. In histopathology, ophthalmology, and dermatology
image classification, Med-Gemini-2D surpasses baselines across 18 out of 20
tasks and approaches task-specific model performance. Beyond imaging,
Med-Gemini-Polygenic outperforms the standard linear polygenic risk score-based
approach for disease risk prediction and generalizes to genetically correlated
diseases for which it has never been trained. Although further development and
evaluation are necessary in the safety-critical medical domain, our results
highlight the potential of Med-Gemini across a wide range of medical tasks.
|
[
-0.3686366081,
-0.333628118,
0.6648461819,
-0.0278507974,
-0.1516209394,
-0.0109460186,
0.183891356,
-0.7469968796,
0.2507533133,
0.6519474387,
-0.4164598286,
-0.5323234797,
-0.9612380862,
-0.0391957425,
-0.4113335311,
1.0672674179,
0.3455601633,
0.2719945908,
-0.34518525,
-0.1558211744,
-0.3651808798,
-0.5926004052,
-0.6142833233,
0.1070611104,
0.7984740138,
0.2159629464,
1.2297664881,
0.787761271,
1.061342001,
0.2679544389,
0.2248322368,
0.1986592412,
-0.0370776877,
0.0440037884,
0.0622993149,
-0.4666285217,
-0.6599292159,
0.0003566133,
0.3075295091,
0.5773632526,
-0.1305287182,
-0.2210160941,
-0.6625910997,
0.7326788902,
-0.5450758338,
0.22542952,
-0.0864363983,
0.0624172874,
-0.2272360772,
-0.2077586502,
-0.1511829495,
-0.2568124831,
0.3860268295,
-0.6778794527,
0.1330861002,
-0.1053576991,
0.4341941178,
0.1811483055,
-0.8066602349,
-0.4128798842,
-0.5239317417,
0.4217403233,
-0.2890521586,
0.2510423958,
-0.0221966077,
0.7214438319,
0.1548637599,
-1.1521527767,
-0.1407146752,
-0.6107217073,
-0.1052473858,
0.4984770119,
-0.2646297216,
0.0293260366,
-0.0204771496,
0.2788296342,
-0.5489079952,
0.0011484341,
-0.795961082,
-0.16818887,
0.7316119075,
0.4907639921,
0.3150301874,
-0.3148680031,
-0.4592728019,
-0.3234745264,
-0.3270701468,
-0.075821124,
-0.4346463084,
-0.0517905988,
-0.2990202308,
0.7076449394,
-0.0257652942,
0.5038699508,
-0.0191473886,
-0.1192240417,
0.5057221055,
-0.3413287997,
-0.0525089838,
-0.045772735,
0.6228432059,
0.466040343,
-0.1559574902,
0.1521791518,
0.0956798941,
0.3383948505,
0.4853256345,
-0.6286758184,
-0.2010795772,
0.4062247872,
-0.9128513932,
-0.4428479373,
0.2161325514,
-0.370757103,
-0.5458192825,
-0.3094892502,
0.4963667691,
-0.5489076376,
-0.4410696924,
0.3731324673,
-0.3170438409,
-0.2293449491,
0.3081837296,
-0.5340561867,
0.1295337975,
0.5182619095,
0.6658814549,
-0.1637289524,
0.021376539,
-0.4375611544,
0.1328210086,
-0.489110142,
0.6668999791,
-0.4130188823,
-0.5717021227,
-0.2916254997,
-0.2406011373,
-0.1083970368,
-0.6035839915,
0.2509320378,
-0.0826012492,
0.1875501424,
0.0342375487,
-0.078966178,
-0.1022272035,
0.3438723683,
-0.5603805184,
0.553892076,
0.3937020898,
-0.5166578889,
0.2880731523,
-0.7006267905,
-0.2484212071,
-0.0321150608,
-0.5288784504,
-0.3676536679,
0.4160595834,
0.2167956531,
0.5044230223,
-0.4370345175,
0.2096854597,
-0.0905130804,
0.0473943353,
0.3465346098,
-0.2610343993,
0.3717870116,
0.2519683838,
-0.006299254,
0.2888823152,
-0.9099546671,
0.1972810775,
0.0054917112,
-0.299482584,
-0.1427884847,
-0.2226400822,
0.0998973325,
0.5736291409,
0.1098155305,
-0.7802484035,
0.0642931834,
-0.3555760384,
0.2429049611,
0.4122178555,
-0.1825022846,
-0.006891476,
-0.6627426147,
0.4792298973,
0.3990381062,
0.8605300188,
-0.3676766455,
-0.6796306968,
-0.4485412836,
-0.7344631553,
0.0815662369,
0.4181262255,
-0.7139250636,
-0.0449507982,
-0.3243500292,
-0.720133841,
-0.4455899298,
-0.3865805864,
0.532096684,
0.4324066639,
0.3111124635,
-0.5827439427,
-0.3675742745,
-1.1732798815,
0.243731454,
0.0667850226,
0.0843479112,
0.4655994177,
0.2384705096,
-0.4897297919,
0.4414194822,
-0.5924021602,
-0.401550144,
-0.2493215352,
0.3161844015,
0.4506950378,
0.4113726616,
0.70293504,
-0.9393119812,
-0.4951314628,
0.2461781651,
-0.757144928,
0.2250931114,
-0.0276013277,
-0.0778577924,
0.3121222854,
0.528365016,
-0.4973825514,
0.4261008501,
0.8605418801,
-0.3756876588,
0.2090556771,
-0.6662193537,
0.2502685487,
-1.0407030582,
0.1583970487,
0.1183843836,
-0.3902375102,
-0.5840760469,
0.0434506387,
0.2342389077,
-0.1323688626,
-0.385814935,
0.2845172286,
-0.390503943,
0.0235159695,
-0.2027288675,
-0.2813251615,
-0.0724705383,
0.0064377817,
0.1254885644,
0.1520037353,
0.730640769,
-0.4981367886,
0.3568997979,
0.3425016701,
-0.2503392994,
0.5190271139,
-0.6218451858,
0.0351740979,
-0.4540474713,
0.2593846917,
-0.7434726357,
-0.1243260428,
0.0224231891,
-0.7015762329,
0.474760443,
0.0178384371,
-0.221324861,
-0.7183798552,
-0.2796648741,
0.277541399,
0.4283443987,
-0.2263719141,
0.8616204262,
0.317066431,
-0.2497200668,
-0.6432488561,
-0.7108393312,
0.2688367367,
0.2594692707,
-0.8719509244,
0.5875276923,
-0.2489681542,
-0.1552440375,
-0.0685863867,
-0.070942983,
-0.1479103416,
-0.2668734789,
0.4793971479,
0.7294742465,
-0.2650386095,
-0.1560242176,
-0.050083831,
-0.5074512959,
0.1343144178,
-0.074651517,
0.2016720325,
0.062856026,
-0.4603993595,
-0.4528628588,
0.5101640224,
1.0532034636,
-0.2440837026,
0.5741876364,
0.5855615139,
-0.283826977,
0.4553726912,
-0.6381307244,
-0.0471323244,
-0.3611596227,
0.586743772,
-0.285522759,
-0.6342090964,
0.1609423459,
0.2869700193,
0.1292349398,
0.5484955311,
0.5942202806,
-0.1959825754,
1.4462975264,
0.6274384856,
0.3173894882,
0.1396674365,
-0.2399278879,
-0.1172062382,
-0.6035749912,
-0.5911337733,
-0.457986623,
-0.177141577,
-0.6605343819,
-0.5301285982,
1.2704949379,
-0.7284886241,
-0.1754511595,
-0.1935775429,
-0.7330780625,
0.0957086608,
0.6829898357,
0.4438124001,
0.3394419551,
-0.1672694534,
-0.0433012918,
-0.0070230966,
-0.7104908824,
0.0217556413,
1.5797780752,
0.2029914558,
0.6100814342,
0.1450802088,
0.4075791538,
0.3439381719,
0.5461612344,
-0.493386507,
0.0778450966,
-0.9028504491,
-1.0415972471,
0.1634507328,
-0.3698307276,
-0.9294880629,
0.263851881,
-0.6803673506,
-0.1872803122,
-0.0240775868,
0.1696525812,
-0.7068313956,
-0.0088481782,
-0.3790628314,
0.5706413984,
-0.553479135,
-0.1202827767,
-0.4642648697,
-0.9998978972,
0.392257154,
-0.1201754212,
0.3537780344,
0.0492867902,
-0.2516757846,
0.3114472032,
-0.3188805878,
0.7044181228,
-0.1377790272,
0.2507038116,
-0.0745166019,
-0.058818467,
0.0234241262,
0.1737383604,
0.1522345841,
0.2115573138,
0.4596131146,
-0.1447873861,
-0.3589276075,
0.7112052441,
-1.0214174986,
-0.3653856516,
-0.6585286856,
-0.8643077612,
-0.1040889025,
0.0177586246,
0.2460420579,
0.7524648309,
0.0229486581,
0.3712936044,
0.4178153574,
-0.548607409,
0.0436515175,
0.457518667,
-0.1927769929,
-0.7982234359,
0.7201794386,
0.0508359671,
0.2081283778,
0.6429082155,
0.2861197293,
-0.2570416927,
-0.5799586773,
-0.3041490614,
0.2185160518,
-0.5105752349,
-0.2937269509,
-0.8165116906,
-0.4510202408,
-0.3934209049,
-0.2904222906,
-0.5660129189,
-0.4691990316,
-0.0111298962,
0.2864120305,
0.1021534204,
0.7511312366,
-0.2428408563,
0.2025863528,
-1.2591587305,
0.5582386851,
-0.010388718,
0.0829168484,
-0.5440410376,
-0.1116839722,
-0.1619656384,
-0.1366281062,
-0.3894757032,
-0.4269881546,
0.345105201,
-0.1377271265,
0.4419352412,
0.3725773096,
-0.2908566594,
0.5202106237,
0.098985903,
0.5780980587,
0.7531268001,
-0.6668807268,
0.5352761745,
-0.4075804055,
0.2977206111,
0.1563755274,
0.2071230561,
-0.5348271132,
-0.1915110946,
-0.7132290006,
-0.7406727076,
0.6974024773,
0.3411998749,
0.1134153754,
-0.1983822137,
0.5667274594,
0.3407736123,
0.1583108902,
-0.3973412812,
-0.2396139652,
-0.3055709004,
-0.3305481374,
-0.2811818421,
-0.1108090878,
-0.2409936041,
-0.2351220548,
0.3251113296,
-0.317519784,
0.4043599963,
0.4236650467,
0.1132342443,
0.1133762449,
-0.0410816371,
0.5762571692,
0.7028638124,
-0.1481914073,
-0.0191764534,
-0.2474369556,
-0.6551882029,
-0.2112551779,
0.3392751813,
0.4070940912,
-0.2076885849,
0.3161732554,
0.3353284001,
0.104411684,
-0.6755978465,
0.7471544147,
-0.3160789907,
-0.3474293053,
-0.4735770822,
0.2825427949,
0.0554698333,
0.3686511517,
0.1749196947,
0.7074650526,
0.1651250273,
-0.4665078819,
0.2343932092,
0.3559181988,
-0.5208227634,
-0.0767969936,
0.7852228284,
0.361595124,
0.5710806251,
1.0647780895,
0.5479011536,
0.0874217078,
1.0428574085,
0.4071446359,
0.188192144,
-0.1933404356,
0.2783913612,
0.5178956985,
0.2719741464,
-0.0571486987,
0.6220085621,
0.3503355384,
-0.6248270869,
-0.1691661477,
-0.0391529389,
-0.4007231593,
-0.1266666502,
-0.8134285212,
0.2943630517,
-0.7785798907,
-0.4054213166,
0.3021019399,
-0.2009085864,
-0.4578182101,
0.7070271969,
0.5599579811,
1.094661355,
-0.2381044775,
0.7404974699,
0.6631702781,
-0.3068526089,
-0.274376601,
-0.6044205427,
0.4224124551,
-1.0785113573,
0.4332997501,
0.3217513561,
0.079262428,
-0.1524680555,
-0.2811074853,
-0.9669473767,
1.4242246151,
0.3115735352,
-0.6242232323,
-0.0011981194,
0.2247269154,
0.4838312268,
-0.6210140586,
0.5078755617,
0.3474328816,
0.4868747592,
0.297865212,
-0.8661978245,
-0.0652935579,
-0.3314266503,
0.0982702821,
0.2274998724,
-0.7268505692,
0.9395323396,
-0.6957345605,
0.1023093313,
0.508042872,
0.2956089079,
0.3376667202,
0.529039681,
0.4371160865,
0.4309842288,
0.4907577634,
-0.3331926167,
1.5392116308,
-0.4011593461,
-0.2466446906,
0.583522737,
0.0440562181,
0.536631465,
0.1783796847,
0.2044490874,
0.3514635563,
0.3165681958,
-0.0925449729,
0.3037213087,
0.0317726806,
-0.1244706064,
-0.2860889435,
-0.0421877392,
-0.5845965147,
0.6919436455,
0.6069150567,
-0.6183418632,
0.25456357,
0.3401323259,
-0.0668955371,
-0.3358098865,
-0.5435346961,
0.5656753778,
-0.0493202582,
-0.5673940778,
0.251285553,
0.0671474412,
0.6833091378,
-1.0052758455,
0.1394235045,
-0.0641867518,
0.6023662686,
-0.2643027008,
-0.8330284357,
0.5819314122,
-0.3073882461,
-0.2108288258,
0.0684569851,
0.3726018667,
0.1419008821,
-0.7354089618,
0.2951024175,
0.5469107628,
-0.1152605861,
-0.2289684117,
-0.5473390222,
0.0655424222,
-0.0153051298,
0.0126316166,
0.2442706674,
0.1086356938,
-0.0108287446,
0.7829635143,
0.6369581819,
-0.0149304206,
-0.0470901616,
0.0158175528,
0.9793816209,
-0.7782632709,
-0.1957640052,
-0.3214857876,
0.8303340673,
0.0447522253,
-0.6010693908,
0.1522429436,
0.6021568179,
0.5281422138,
-0.0093723061,
0.9745334983,
-0.2275817096,
0.2803871632,
-0.4830718935,
0.5490609407,
-0.8859857321,
-0.0587643646,
0.0417362191,
-0.3887386024,
-0.811493814,
0.2214300334,
0.0504576713,
0.2486783862,
0.9327964783,
0.8165292144,
-0.108668305,
-0.007402,
0.5113855004,
0.416636616,
0.3648298681,
0.6198964715,
0.8628835678,
-0.3124067485,
0.8755843043,
-0.4062137902,
-0.7779760361,
-0.1275400072,
-0.3830861747,
-0.7762185931,
-0.522644937,
-0.4297302067,
-0.4277519584,
0.1085169762,
0.7813082933,
1.1134138107,
-0.4095324874,
0.132754162,
0.3151032031,
-0.5127167106,
-0.4193354845,
-0.1060243323,
0.3865950108,
0.0197815448,
-0.571357429,
0.2558333278,
0.743252337,
0.00452221,
-0.0572802387,
0.0034060031,
0.277828306,
-0.0933239311,
0.6565688848,
0.0645446479,
-0.6275219321,
0.0113476906,
0.1361352056,
-0.3531540632,
0.2739240825,
0.9090980887,
-0.7002569437,
0.631976366,
0.3263584077,
0.2402691543,
0.4846264124,
-0.3599654436,
0.5653892756,
-0.1616513878,
-0.1167075559,
0.2534899414,
0.3762682378,
0.1694174111,
-0.6562638283,
0.2966437936,
0.105803661,
-0.3544366062,
-0.1981356889,
0.1478598267,
-1.3546556234,
-0.4374682009,
0.7121372819,
0.1146165952,
-0.0001529703,
-0.0504169427,
-0.3701714575,
0.0724176317,
-0.1805846691,
0.9819076657,
0.0632130057,
-0.5823470354,
-0.3694996834,
-0.4207307696,
0.1425378323,
0.2184617072,
-0.9979422688,
-0.4211141765,
0.6000928283,
0.4170579314,
0.2615991533,
0.6677234173,
-0.8771678209,
0.8782835007,
-0.025861904,
-0.0044664438,
-0.432751745,
-0.5552212,
0.1059260219,
0.3836254478,
-0.2363600135,
-0.3261777461
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06683v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06683v1
|
ERAGent: Enhancing Retrieval-Augmented Language Models with Improved Accuracy, Efficiency, and Personalization
| 2024-05-06T04:42:18 | 2024-05-06T04:42:18 |
Yunxiao Shi, Xing Zi, Zijing Shi, Haimin Zhang, Qiang Wu, Min Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) for language models significantly
improves language understanding systems. The basic retrieval-then-read pipeline
of response generation has evolved into a more extended process due to the
integration of various components, sometimes even forming loop structures.
Despite its advancements in improving response accuracy, challenges like poor
retrieval quality for complex questions that require the search of multifaceted
semantic information, inefficiencies in knowledge re-retrieval during long-term
serving, and lack of personalized responses persist. Motivated by transcending
these limitations, we introduce ERAGent, a cutting-edge framework that embodies
an advancement in the RAG area. Our contribution is the introduction of the
synergistically operated module: Enhanced Question Rewriter and Knowledge
Filter, for better retrieval quality. Retrieval Trigger is incorporated to
curtail extraneous external knowledge retrieval without sacrificing response
quality. ERAGent also personalizes responses by incorporating a learned user
profile. The efficiency and personalization characteristics of ERAGent are
supported by the Experiential Learner module which makes the AI assistant being
capable of expanding its knowledge and modeling user profile incrementally.
Rigorous evaluations across six datasets and three question-answering tasks
prove ERAGent's superior accuracy, efficiency, and personalization, emphasizing
its potential to advance the RAG field and its applicability in practical
systems.
|
[
-0.3474330902,
-0.9932624102,
0.3726154864,
-0.1828562617,
0.2177982777,
0.1805621684,
-0.1590213329,
-0.4279355705,
0.1929100901,
0.5577663183,
-0.3817420602,
-0.193085894,
-0.3854548335,
0.043143712,
-0.4737729132,
0.9142413735,
0.3051088154,
-0.0003969895,
-0.2154857218,
-0.3011842668,
-0.4339697957,
-0.3753910065,
-0.8686224222,
-0.4281718433,
0.5299049616,
0.2333448827,
0.5466814041,
0.559209466,
0.365623951,
0.4247414172,
-0.0334841125,
0.3550289273,
-0.2326414287,
0.7866439223,
-0.3177512586,
-0.5703144073,
-0.6319339275,
-0.2875317931,
0.4751160741,
0.8628234863,
-0.3577357531,
0.2403526753,
0.1413159668,
0.6469792724,
-0.8081997633,
-0.2011172324,
-0.4624388814,
-0.1352440417,
-0.0114866532,
-0.4366643727,
-0.4367857277,
-0.0652281046,
0.1491526067,
-0.8794749379,
0.4383978546,
0.3134658039,
0.5412713885,
0.3769406676,
-0.4127967954,
-0.2509637177,
-0.8321390748,
0.7783174515,
-0.5807698965,
0.7861371636,
0.3420038223,
0.537536025,
-0.3059361875,
-1.0012028217,
-0.5207130313,
-0.1872155368,
-0.0755479336,
0.3276259303,
-0.0450652204,
0.0034294024,
0.146210283,
0.2721264362,
-0.7652570605,
-0.1551038325,
0.0785376579,
-0.062140014,
0.3318828046,
0.4144296944,
0.3041347265,
-0.1249724627,
-0.3321843147,
-0.189960286,
-0.4613243341,
0.0539338253,
0.4374751151,
0.2173558027,
0.2526262999,
0.3744898438,
-0.5431115031,
1.005725503,
-0.041486375,
0.0362036116,
0.1893660873,
-0.2702686787,
-0.0950046703,
-0.4606557786,
0.3636093438,
-0.0659886971,
-0.1511348784,
-0.1272151172,
-0.3584583998,
-0.3989275098,
0.3984262645,
-0.5692823529,
-0.2114861906,
0.2479991466,
-0.5136303902,
-0.1887164563,
0.2436569631,
-0.8204575777,
-0.4323267937,
-0.5094697475,
0.4166611433,
-0.3835740685,
-0.390448451,
0.0307063665,
-0.2917773426,
0.3652213812,
0.548669517,
-0.5754011869,
0.3890690804,
0.8652855158,
0.3363872766,
-0.0694891438,
-0.2168953568,
-0.6422757506,
0.2030857652,
-0.2281463444,
1.0174052715,
-0.7088406682,
-0.351208806,
0.0288412608,
-0.2056257129,
0.0902039483,
-0.6710580587,
0.2876039445,
-0.8954690695,
0.4791378379,
0.0843390152,
-0.6928038001,
-0.108142443,
0.1622575969,
-0.5312876701,
0.9897809625,
0.1087482274,
-0.5634515285,
0.3064149022,
-0.5817559958,
-0.3451367021,
0.268324554,
-0.0501984805,
-0.1640770435,
0.241984576,
0.1182173416,
0.170408383,
-0.5564489365,
0.215475738,
-0.1035610512,
-0.2040382326,
0.2482636422,
-0.4080224633,
0.6815605164,
0.4653944969,
0.019295672,
0.1166798845,
-0.7779221535,
0.1707982868,
0.237558797,
-0.3878720403,
-0.5533322692,
-0.1344107836,
0.0655978844,
-0.1110280678,
0.4230483174,
-0.5724188089,
-0.2219431549,
-0.5178418756,
-0.0418328084,
0.7452734709,
0.0345879346,
0.4672614336,
-0.475730896,
0.6182706356,
-0.2901394069,
0.1310129911,
-0.3864178956,
-0.2400106937,
-1.0370624065,
0.114679724,
0.1540779173,
0.5399572253,
-0.9572572708,
0.2960645556,
-0.1671606749,
-0.2513345182,
-0.5769331455,
0.1078701243,
0.5511662364,
0.6983481646,
0.4111630321,
-0.2064810097,
-0.534487009,
-0.6794970036,
-0.6388685107,
-0.2840977907,
-0.0400030352,
0.6600337625,
0.0659722611,
-0.0303387549,
1.0821815729,
-0.63598001,
-0.1140247583,
-0.3818743527,
0.1385093927,
0.177385658,
0.3385743797,
-0.0098354863,
-1.1413323879,
-0.4054421186,
0.0993976593,
-0.6719260812,
-0.4158306122,
0.0992014259,
-0.1135415509,
0.3699240685,
0.5914418697,
-0.0853767544,
0.3139577508,
0.343334496,
-0.4775324762,
0.4726353586,
-0.4547241926,
0.4015019536,
-1.3349112272,
0.4772528708,
-0.3052223027,
-0.4702078402,
-0.8713607788,
0.3835223019,
0.0646676868,
-0.0610681288,
-0.2626111209,
0.8169901967,
-0.2911024094,
-0.1026068553,
-0.4968737662,
0.2077159286,
0.1554990262,
0.2663175166,
-0.2184796184,
0.8391427994,
-0.076099433,
-0.6296488047,
0.4260799289,
0.2933232188,
0.0368217975,
0.7649801373,
-0.6791364551,
0.3958705068,
-0.2654114664,
0.1633692235,
-0.8490352631,
-0.3582178056,
0.0185962431,
-0.8373652101,
0.5017470121,
-0.0292295795,
-0.4102469683,
0.122058481,
-0.2470338345,
0.2570919394,
0.6211050153,
-0.651144743,
0.9990243912,
0.4285331666,
-0.1793724746,
-0.7954488397,
-0.3693593442,
0.0807011798,
-0.0426440686,
-0.4582939148,
0.2697358727,
-0.0731850788,
-0.2352183014,
0.1687647253,
-0.0044291341,
-0.0550692156,
0.2223856896,
-0.0847076625,
0.3258920908,
-0.0973054171,
0.3982794285,
0.0496855825,
-0.4139746428,
-0.1830852479,
-0.2927355766,
0.6645695567,
0.1484808028,
-0.3066963553,
-0.0713921487,
0.4064191282,
-0.0227038171,
-0.4273786545,
0.7025370002,
0.6410699487,
-0.2614091337,
-0.3843455911,
-0.7032200694,
-0.2519285083,
-0.5174951553,
0.4071713984,
-0.670580864,
-1.2225426435,
0.5268009901,
-0.1227256805,
0.2580122948,
0.3901460469,
0.3461077809,
-0.1010925323,
1.0735611916,
0.7331786156,
0.1691370457,
0.6549387574,
-0.0341755189,
0.1627877355,
-1.2229660749,
-0.2466422468,
-0.7039098144,
0.1262322366,
-0.6217163801,
-0.2342775762,
0.5648723245,
0.0224404987,
-0.3581315577,
0.2736570239,
-0.3791787326,
0.1160390452,
0.4406909347,
0.0337211378,
0.4580263793,
-0.1944648623,
0.0003289017,
0.131918624,
-0.7687498331,
-0.3266938627,
1.0438315868,
0.2011855096,
1.0901460648,
0.4700551331,
0.8009460568,
0.332485348,
0.2670817077,
-0.4583733976,
0.5799236894,
-0.1969842464,
-0.6363431215,
-0.2272075117,
-0.6227750778,
-0.9929575324,
0.3674239218,
-0.1230034977,
-0.4793148637,
0.0236175172,
0.4231440723,
-0.4542941451,
0.0034513336,
-0.5882772207,
0.5335379839,
-0.0576836728,
-0.5063318014,
-0.3303476274,
-0.6676088572,
-0.0270270277,
-0.0632290691,
0.116728574,
0.0755744055,
-0.5125603676,
0.5694006085,
-0.3137427568,
0.6205880642,
-0.220427826,
0.1292118877,
0.0729664713,
0.1607263088,
0.4525841475,
-0.0763420388,
-0.0325923339,
-0.3806040883,
-0.1664900482,
-0.1378938258,
-0.8990678787,
0.7849761844,
-0.6243651509,
-0.8538517952,
-0.196558699,
-0.5122102499,
-0.2091142833,
0.2521283031,
0.0387545973,
0.6418274641,
-0.3208474219,
-0.0303491578,
0.7821241617,
-0.6570447087,
0.0711638331,
0.6719255447,
-0.4317287803,
-0.4795074463,
1.0480610132,
-0.166609332,
0.339010179,
0.5143661499,
0.2378657013,
-0.391928792,
-0.1948096603,
-0.3683303595,
0.0866859928,
-0.8403860331,
-0.4054902494,
-1.0402847528,
-0.1339005679,
-0.8405045867,
0.0024429294,
-0.2529123724,
-0.4815483987,
-0.1235667318,
0.3450621665,
0.3134758472,
0.8091150522,
-0.086133264,
0.1514611691,
-0.5994485021,
0.3833282292,
0.2870773673,
0.2785059214,
-0.0316780098,
-0.7906858325,
-0.1916765422,
-0.2739855647,
-0.0790887177,
-0.6594309211,
0.3006817997,
0.4285436273,
0.6952491999,
0.0106213223,
-0.0008907616,
0.6632472277,
-0.5063893199,
0.4965209961,
-0.2887404561,
-0.790359199,
0.6076261401,
-0.2427920848,
0.3365990818,
0.5028436184,
-0.060104616,
-0.7646326423,
-0.4520401359,
-0.6883389354,
-1.1387289762,
0.6333605647,
-0.1869199425,
0.2298697978,
0.086357221,
0.4699808657,
0.2138339132,
0.1503628343,
-0.0586239211,
-0.3329342604,
0.0693138987,
-0.2736077607,
0.07053186,
-0.1821076423,
0.2842083871,
0.0123946024,
0.8548663259,
-0.2266597748,
0.332211405,
0.2867266536,
-0.3244144619,
-0.0650240257,
0.3469623327,
0.1553480625,
0.4992458224,
-0.0962812081,
0.0921240598,
0.3456485868,
-0.3054141998,
0.0777800828,
0.3540867865,
-0.021712983,
-0.1784215569,
0.3594280481,
0.3476435244,
0.0708383843,
-0.6540346742,
0.2895907462,
-0.2510172725,
0.414303422,
-0.6885374188,
0.359775722,
-0.1183845177,
0.219860211,
0.3470001519,
-0.0306124296,
0.6433498263,
-0.2308866382,
0.4513177574,
0.3552623391,
-0.1465933472,
-0.0910930559,
0.7426396608,
0.1950029731,
-0.384604007,
0.4847870767,
-0.1145864725,
-0.4696089327,
0.3786438107,
0.6299715042,
0.9100145698,
-0.495900631,
0.039532017,
0.3506018519,
-0.0593577325,
0.1844025254,
0.3066069484,
-0.2926921844,
-0.8533921242,
-0.438195914,
-0.7592887878,
-0.3841176927,
-0.1603443027,
-0.8380168676,
-0.0001877357,
-0.4353941977,
-0.1247331128,
-0.0762690604,
-0.055367697,
-0.7081947327,
0.0113994367,
-0.2046677619,
0.8760309219,
-0.5212560296,
0.6705597639,
1.0860931873,
-0.3823846281,
-0.5642988086,
-0.0130182607,
0.0567246899,
-0.7495490313,
0.7274739146,
0.0243387315,
-0.3314476013,
0.3604091108,
-0.2086802125,
-0.8012689948,
1.0986212492,
-0.003065458,
-0.1285260916,
0.2171369493,
-0.0285436846,
0.5380390286,
-0.373973012,
0.4496812522,
0.6166759133,
0.1595275402,
-0.061229147,
-0.7466447353,
-0.0899530128,
-0.4200707376,
0.340559572,
0.4526879489,
-0.4774931967,
0.7430512309,
-0.039209675,
-0.2421247661,
0.3184092641,
0.7901543379,
0.2219223827,
0.19734855,
0.530002594,
0.6752784252,
0.3910420239,
-0.0250878483,
1.2164318562,
-0.3162935078,
0.1943424195,
1.2864441872,
-0.2412454784,
0.8526847959,
0.3316098452,
-0.0849472135,
0.4204953611,
0.1594333202,
0.467620641,
0.3697023988,
-0.1347521693,
-0.5483443737,
-0.2344727069,
-0.5470110178,
0.0237664618,
0.445230782,
0.4137874842,
-0.291801542,
-0.2539906204,
0.1086929142,
-0.150547266,
0.3385272622,
0.0990253016,
1.1221129894,
0.0257317256,
-0.6752341986,
0.1346787959,
0.0365580544,
0.6183267832,
-0.4936438501,
-0.4414638877,
-0.2698255181,
0.3831433058,
-0.0218887497,
-0.6861125827,
0.2596823275,
0.0115690054,
-0.0407599434,
-0.2735560238,
1.174877882,
-0.4984461665,
-0.0410063639,
0.3836002648,
0.9761678576,
0.0047613415,
0.2496871948,
-0.92838341,
0.0293954033,
-0.1122989878,
-0.562040031,
0.133407101,
0.2484032959,
0.2471286952,
0.6960440874,
0.7353770137,
0.0854847655,
-0.0152120879,
0.340334475,
0.8106245995,
-0.5233407021,
-0.3495074511,
-0.4362668693,
0.4970950484,
-0.2343724221,
-0.2457271814,
0.6953713298,
0.5032909513,
0.9775868058,
0.2716602385,
0.8027654886,
-0.3359004855,
1.0507513285,
-0.3426245749,
0.7490466237,
-0.7435601354,
0.3557410836,
-0.0271935761,
-0.9040269852,
-0.291395992,
0.4899889827,
-0.21953547,
0.560021162,
0.3487213254,
0.9156724811,
0.0360286161,
-0.1598076671,
0.5339632034,
-0.0245179348,
0.6149915457,
0.2982524633,
0.8572967052,
-0.3525256217,
0.2030546665,
-0.2467738986,
-0.3953706324,
-0.142427519,
-0.3974408507,
-0.6425596476,
-0.7810769081,
0.1220119298,
-0.2885988951,
0.3951926231,
1.1135700941,
0.5030058026,
-0.6710211039,
-0.279316783,
-0.1035548672,
-0.1889362782,
0.0938433856,
-0.2685266435,
0.2583155334,
-0.8391035795,
-0.7189741135,
0.4109526575,
0.2466281205,
-0.1494591236,
-0.3224163651,
-0.0378579944,
-0.2088892907,
-0.0651190579,
0.4757390916,
0.2999776304,
-0.5770981908,
-0.2220665663,
0.2832655609,
-0.1017622054,
-0.2584255934,
0.8299883008,
-0.9341310859,
0.7700284719,
0.7109136581,
0.981210351,
0.1169833988,
0.1075022146,
0.7112431526,
-0.6702092886,
0.0471911319,
0.3435634077,
0.2785161436,
0.4925363362,
-0.3548587263,
0.5526320338,
0.0331701972,
-0.694892168,
-0.5227502584,
0.4150734246,
-0.3579084575,
-0.3860569894,
0.9504330754,
-0.2528286874,
-0.3009327352,
-0.3732657433,
0.0250689629,
0.4167779684,
-0.4270070493,
0.4334225953,
0.2931789458,
-0.4383208156,
-0.1622914672,
-0.8638600111,
0.4670988619,
0.8189374804,
-0.9723514915,
0.0837336779,
0.6131859422,
0.3183383346,
0.0921804681,
0.4920436144,
-0.1404666603,
0.4123854637,
-0.074759461,
0.124184005,
-0.1943060607,
-0.4318907261,
-0.5161511898,
-0.0360929146,
0.3451187313,
0.040626768
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03153v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03153v1
|
Exploring the Potential of the Large Language Models (LLMs) in Identifying Misleading News Headlines
| 2024-05-06T04:06:45 | 2024-05-06T04:06:45 |
Md Main Uddin Rony, Md Mahfuzul Haque, Mohammad Ali, Ahmed Shatil Alam, Naeemul Hassan
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CY, cs.LG
|
In the digital age, the prevalence of misleading news headlines poses a
significant challenge to information integrity, necessitating robust detection
mechanisms. This study explores the efficacy of Large Language Models (LLMs) in
identifying misleading versus non-misleading news headlines. Utilizing a
dataset of 60 articles, sourced from both reputable and questionable outlets
across health, science & tech, and business domains, we employ three LLMs-
ChatGPT-3.5, ChatGPT-4, and Gemini-for classification. Our analysis reveals
significant variance in model performance, with ChatGPT-4 demonstrating
superior accuracy, especially in cases with unanimous annotator agreement on
misleading headlines. The study emphasizes the importance of human-centered
evaluation in developing LLMs that can navigate the complexities of
misinformation detection, aligning technical proficiency with nuanced human
judgment. Our findings contribute to the discourse on AI ethics, emphasizing
the need for models that are not only technically advanced but also ethically
aligned and sensitive to the subtleties of human interpretation.
|
[
-0.0141910724,
-0.7784773111,
0.9063229561,
0.4804632068,
-0.1886322945,
0.1557587385,
-0.2308893651,
-0.8167047501,
-0.1544101387,
0.3751214743,
-0.3271367848,
-0.3623328507,
-0.8730085492,
0.1162436455,
-0.7000263929,
0.9914954901,
0.2448512018,
0.2566480339,
-0.0826648474,
0.2836980224,
-0.4353239834,
-0.3811737299,
-0.9116336703,
-0.3459433913,
0.553124845,
0.1399565339,
0.9060636759,
0.6588639617,
0.5645361543,
0.1986112446,
-0.2015392929,
0.2189237475,
-0.4173191786,
-0.355589211,
-0.2815006077,
-0.5097846389,
-0.2254980952,
0.4511718154,
0.4421254992,
0.466650188,
-0.2266089767,
0.23422499,
-0.0650085509,
0.5063409805,
-0.4477421343,
0.0812181309,
-0.671184063,
-0.0860310718,
-0.1188738197,
-0.2745904028,
-0.5580288172,
-0.4294655323,
0.0758589879,
-0.3972236514,
-0.0816708282,
0.3476976454,
1.0584014654,
0.4134503305,
-0.5746288896,
-0.5492504239,
-0.795425415,
0.8216293454,
-0.8966517448,
0.4551786482,
0.333283186,
0.2881629765,
-0.2750641704,
-0.4378141463,
-0.598395288,
-0.3859674633,
0.0919876546,
0.0504074916,
-0.49832654,
-0.0941761062,
0.1760585904,
0.2092819512,
-0.4595078528,
0.6944499016,
-0.3625848591,
-0.4193430543,
0.6542335153,
-0.0236100499,
0.3394035399,
-0.3609196842,
-0.3654749393,
0.237090081,
-0.7524158359,
-0.2200021595,
0.6245077252,
0.3429954946,
-0.3582712114,
0.6270434856,
0.0372564755,
0.6813797951,
0.105676204,
-0.5986179709,
0.20451352,
-0.2593249381,
-0.2456339151,
0.2646925449,
0.8641873002,
0.60918051,
0.3783127069,
-0.093264699,
-0.3094191253,
0.2178297937,
0.4663292468,
-0.4863735139,
0.1597082615,
0.1965087354,
-0.5455799699,
-0.5325298905,
0.0225341525,
-0.6894308329,
-0.9812124372,
-0.4186471701,
0.4132542312,
-0.2762797177,
-0.0181184784,
0.3637913465,
-0.0915824994,
0.2561801672,
0.4389144182,
-0.3355566263,
-0.0766564831,
0.713490665,
0.4529857635,
-0.0116191544,
0.0363390036,
-0.3571523726,
-0.0051974924,
-0.5028293133,
0.6934997439,
-0.6728826761,
-0.2790440619,
-0.0727890432,
-0.1109218076,
-0.0054686312,
-0.5096663833,
1.1426638365,
-0.6033914089,
0.3296384513,
-0.175578028,
-0.3870375156,
-0.2929447591,
0.4611208439,
-0.6935515404,
0.6431441903,
0.0077553098,
-0.9812624454,
0.2933505476,
-0.53188622,
-0.4242156744,
-0.1339894682,
-0.1792455316,
-0.5610456467,
0.1683686972,
0.4313378334,
0.3341478705,
-0.4993511736,
0.5466498733,
-0.0218787398,
-0.4397192299,
0.4712550044,
-0.9653582573,
0.6675311327,
0.3350242078,
-0.3543259501,
-0.0589553602,
-0.5333282948,
-0.401966989,
0.1913288236,
-0.6329820752,
-0.3426078856,
-0.0426594988,
0.1053208634,
0.2267625034,
0.261795491,
-0.4984298944,
-0.0240731239,
-0.1178854033,
0.2852775753,
0.6593803763,
-0.0632706806,
0.0332906619,
-0.5457639694,
0.3932255805,
0.3229516745,
0.2453495264,
-0.0720454603,
-0.4899181426,
-0.4812710285,
-0.2437916994,
0.4759528935,
0.5939286351,
-0.5957993865,
0.4780106246,
-0.4667534828,
-0.436445266,
-0.7007878423,
-0.0886210129,
0.3306742311,
0.5527277589,
0.1583668888,
0.2105724365,
-0.4902611375,
-1.1599590778,
-1.0128213167,
-0.131938234,
-0.0379938111,
0.2526127994,
0.3944735527,
-0.3993899822,
0.9482336044,
-0.0023434968,
-0.0131850187,
-0.222858876,
0.2716050446,
0.286473304,
0.1267628074,
0.412902236,
-1.1799788475,
-0.1899361908,
-0.1620353609,
-0.698733151,
-0.2047245502,
-0.3381537199,
0.42022717,
0.2547175884,
0.2318570614,
-0.783331275,
0.2613911629,
0.5964280367,
-0.4376311004,
0.6695072055,
0.0225477871,
0.2887851894,
-0.9623458385,
-0.0092204576,
0.4621479511,
-0.4190324247,
-0.4932103753,
-0.2402722836,
0.2007313371,
0.0844256952,
-0.4466398954,
0.5153785944,
-0.4454756677,
-0.1053425148,
-0.3005379736,
0.2466696054,
0.0208132062,
-0.2604175508,
-0.1957071871,
0.6167356372,
0.3649965227,
-0.3889088631,
0.2551232874,
-0.0671301857,
-0.5303094983,
0.5702347755,
-0.5117956996,
-0.1903018355,
-0.480432421,
0.484437108,
-0.7558239698,
-0.4421286285,
0.3351569474,
-0.6856258512,
0.3315991461,
0.0834674537,
-0.9067184329,
-0.6472043395,
-0.223816365,
0.1452929527,
0.5052217245,
-0.5012322068,
0.3510174751,
0.384299159,
0.0202450175,
-0.7667497396,
-0.855499804,
0.4035959542,
-0.4650112391,
-0.4776939154,
-0.0078632226,
0.2474482059,
-0.5652801394,
-0.0043609133,
-0.2726762593,
0.0084974086,
0.2187966853,
0.0411291048,
0.4480947554,
-0.0925680622,
0.2224105299,
-0.2689070702,
0.0218233932,
0.1093393341,
-0.0921514407,
0.3229358196,
-0.0957478881,
-0.3819876015,
-0.7787474394,
0.078477256,
0.9136668444,
-0.2330634743,
0.8731366992,
0.7175123096,
-0.4900388122,
0.1722581983,
-0.9399917722,
-0.1075036675,
-0.3993664086,
0.4727858603,
0.2764148116,
-0.7697464824,
0.1472468972,
-0.0113454349,
-0.0757821649,
0.5656055808,
0.4114767909,
0.1047411934,
1.046667099,
0.5997958779,
-0.4403871596,
0.2019860744,
0.2047481835,
0.5898491144,
-0.591855824,
-0.2685257196,
-0.4783711135,
-0.1162895262,
-0.5690181851,
-0.3787815273,
0.4041408002,
0.0266172383,
-0.2015458494,
-0.1014950424,
-0.4859641492,
0.4904544353,
0.3303973973,
0.1539535224,
0.6377012134,
0.0520914569,
0.3670983613,
-0.0234432332,
-0.3902635276,
-0.8968875408,
1.0084034204,
0.7550908923,
0.995552063,
-0.0078766802,
0.3551222086,
0.585711956,
0.5524750948,
-0.8045537472,
0.2734979987,
-0.066591084,
-0.8048237562,
-0.0777001977,
-0.5612100363,
-0.8947702646,
0.1295851022,
-0.2523536384,
-0.8120374084,
-0.1146295965,
-0.1296298653,
-0.5024463534,
0.3468929827,
-0.6618545055,
0.5045941472,
-0.5243763328,
-0.0953202248,
-0.2974667549,
-0.553614378,
0.6795017123,
-0.4048432112,
0.7167932391,
-0.2647705376,
-0.1899323612,
0.6165118814,
0.3988421857,
1.0158494711,
0.1349792928,
-0.3350481689,
0.1446586847,
-0.2955753207,
0.652146101,
0.0731325001,
-0.181113258,
0.3851397336,
-0.3656980395,
-0.2245972306,
-0.1316656619,
0.6260415912,
-0.7390558124,
-0.6967818141,
-0.5612366796,
-0.7434585094,
-0.1933945417,
0.3440344036,
0.1687038541,
0.0812874138,
-0.0210100356,
0.2518649399,
0.5935266018,
-0.5398122668,
0.2054793686,
0.7865942717,
-0.1922401488,
0.0720476657,
0.7045813203,
0.068136923,
0.0028054861,
0.2227499783,
0.2508428693,
-0.2491909266,
-0.6516196132,
-0.2594112158,
0.4478862584,
-0.5704034567,
-0.2051176429,
-0.5557760596,
-0.470164597,
-0.2422166169,
0.0770625994,
-0.4236599505,
-0.0016285599,
-0.3573561013,
-0.1131941751,
0.0882858485,
0.8619119525,
0.0958332121,
0.4129831493,
-0.8031544089,
0.3715875745,
-0.0939847529,
0.1777409017,
-0.3125936389,
-0.4893461466,
-0.1779573709,
0.4224090278,
-0.4767481685,
-0.8188383579,
0.2628537118,
-0.3615001738,
0.8207322955,
0.4901932478,
-0.040161442,
0.29114452,
-0.333242923,
0.8892782331,
0.2735384405,
-0.7713608742,
0.2764361501,
-0.6912175417,
0.0351428054,
0.1948110908,
0.7278696895,
-0.4366944432,
-0.435631454,
-0.5989330411,
-0.6630227566,
0.4816935658,
0.1569189429,
0.2187886834,
-0.1381763518,
0.3332660198,
0.1280003637,
0.4639647305,
-1.0459934473,
-0.1485165358,
0.2288757265,
-0.2876936197,
0.0452034846,
-0.419546783,
-0.0684003085,
0.1147371233,
0.5657474995,
0.1119457632,
0.2851769328,
0.149422273,
-0.0482721813,
-0.1337838769,
0.5154711008,
0.7281904817,
0.8432999849,
0.1791689396,
0.016406931,
-0.15562509,
-0.4355063736,
-0.0155865895,
0.2278841734,
-0.1105324924,
0.0458711646,
0.5467231274,
0.5377229452,
0.2472098023,
-0.775858283,
0.7818936706,
0.0565633774,
0.1186846495,
-0.308573395,
-0.2293837368,
0.2374581844,
0.4297321439,
0.6015737057,
0.2065203488,
0.2420424074,
-0.6725190878,
-0.0270668268,
0.5694901347,
-0.1001670137,
-0.1030064225,
0.6693060398,
0.1129926667,
-0.1612814516,
0.6612309217,
0.0148274796,
-0.541528821,
0.6137758493,
0.4564852118,
0.5448904037,
-0.3815873861,
0.2472775429,
0.1086524501,
0.7756271362,
-0.5610209107,
0.0246174838,
0.5277811885,
-0.8616451621,
-0.3825308084,
-0.6672405005,
-0.1491789371,
0.4516276717,
-0.324632138,
0.3021722138,
-0.1826476753,
-0.360047102,
0.1697414368,
-0.1663005501,
-0.4868573248,
0.1782844961,
0.6541807055,
1.0036481619,
-0.8220522404,
0.5938602686,
0.51280123,
-0.1556337625,
-0.6810901165,
0.5034583807,
0.3700626791,
-0.7522219419,
0.4855131507,
0.4245420694,
0.0855871066,
-0.1502300054,
-0.7918183804,
-0.7911651134,
0.9304739833,
0.6608465314,
-0.7742925882,
-0.3672733009,
0.318846792,
0.396306783,
-0.2959283888,
0.142395407,
0.6492344141,
0.8736363649,
0.0798091367,
-1.3994891644,
-0.0941946432,
0.18925111,
-0.1417066455,
0.0579204224,
-0.6903194785,
0.8589506745,
-0.3736515343,
-0.152648598,
-0.0923805907,
0.3317129612,
0.2198071331,
0.422477752,
0.3716411293,
0.4278537631,
0.9416514635,
-0.1227427199,
1.3290798664,
-0.1721707731,
0.3592065275,
0.7627834082,
-0.0224486031,
0.4989411831,
0.3836955726,
-0.0566701591,
0.3877058625,
0.8112543821,
-0.0966468975,
0.3056072295,
0.2270867527,
-0.0755694509,
-0.3118225932,
-0.3398763835,
-0.144809857,
0.5421848297,
0.7473880053,
-0.6495563984,
-0.4158096313,
0.0195221864,
0.5006843805,
-0.0058309999,
-0.6143091917,
0.2312913537,
0.2225329131,
-0.5976704359,
0.4323459566,
0.2783572376,
0.8418706059,
-0.3638607562,
0.1573264301,
0.1432387382,
0.1171806231,
-0.3616309464,
-0.7941262722,
0.2208939642,
-0.0072993604,
-0.1189323142,
0.1347711533,
0.7803437114,
-0.3531749547,
-0.6495744586,
0.1464096606,
0.4449871778,
0.0427880622,
-0.2504632175,
-0.7284724116,
0.4008719325,
0.1029219553,
-0.3100448847,
0.0587674789,
0.2234259546,
-0.2373684347,
0.8963928223,
0.5989122391,
0.0368513316,
-0.0024351079,
-0.0859295502,
0.6390540004,
-0.6359465718,
-0.4646930099,
-1.0195018053,
0.3891856968,
-0.2895843089,
-0.0306120366,
0.9424964786,
0.5204342604,
0.404910028,
0.0216838904,
0.9695130587,
0.1918290854,
0.5895373225,
-0.6339880824,
0.7439967394,
-0.4368710816,
0.5824671984,
-0.1053154618,
-0.7496686578,
-0.3531677425,
0.4153335989,
-0.6582980156,
0.4074762464,
0.5019775033,
0.5240870714,
-0.0997018889,
0.2587987781,
0.3053918779,
0.5713216662,
0.2599079907,
0.4148662984,
1.0731157064,
-0.1677213311,
0.4093779624,
0.2224363238,
-0.2395336777,
-0.5689905882,
-1.0152550936,
-0.9398068786,
-0.0786954612,
-0.2744356692,
-0.2330695987,
0.2811917067,
0.8867046237,
0.5420140624,
-0.294297874,
0.2139632255,
0.1546720266,
0.1524110138,
0.0768107697,
-0.3048647642,
0.248080641,
-0.1647034734,
-0.7608787417,
0.3751533329,
0.2672087252,
0.0227389149,
-0.339395225,
0.1107901409,
-0.0898440704,
0.4009840488,
0.5198518634,
0.0268678293,
-1.0139853954,
-0.3905192614,
-0.2786175013,
-0.4613804519,
-0.1539928019,
0.6474760771,
-0.7710573077,
0.0320471153,
-0.0633841008,
0.7720339298,
0.0124909384,
0.3134189546,
0.4388016164,
-0.5293878913,
0.0280597657,
0.3537519276,
0.2649744153,
0.7169285417,
-0.7889611125,
0.3514408171,
0.0771655068,
-0.6151641011,
-0.8789269924,
0.0125234919,
-0.8991236091,
-0.2867301702,
1.4669498205,
0.1950242519,
-0.2244692296,
-0.2616721094,
-0.2072263062,
0.1154597104,
-0.4396120608,
1.017480731,
0.7454595566,
0.0137979761,
-0.1225980967,
-1.0204372406,
0.3758332729,
-0.011157033,
-0.7881993055,
0.0219550412,
0.5556382537,
0.4095194936,
0.2727971971,
0.2826289237,
-0.3957543671,
0.3020453751,
-0.23450692,
-0.1719492227,
-0.0191624351,
-0.2406619489,
-0.2376907915,
-0.2367744744,
0.0407968722,
-0.0013733412
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03146v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03146v2
|
Quantifying the Capabilities of LLMs across Scale and Precision
| 2024-05-06T03:42:34 | 2024-05-08T02:10:36 |
Sher Badshah, Hassan Sajjad
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Scale is often attributed as one of the factors that cause an increase in the
performance of LLMs, resulting in models with billion and trillion parameters.
One of the limitations of such large models is the high computational
requirements that limit their usage, deployment, and debugging in
resource-constrained scenarios. Two commonly used alternatives to bypass these
limitations are to use the smaller versions of LLMs (e.g. Llama 7B instead of
Llama 70B) and lower the memory requirements by using quantization. While these
approaches effectively address the limitation of resources, their impact on
model performance needs thorough examination. In this study, we perform a
comprehensive evaluation to investigate the effect of model scale and
quantization on the performance. We experiment with two major families of
open-source instruct models ranging from 7 billion to 70 billion parameters.
Our extensive zero-shot experiments across various tasks including natural
language understanding, reasoning, misinformation detection, and hallucination
reveal that larger models generally outperform their smaller counterparts,
suggesting that scale remains an important factor in enhancing performance. We
found that larger models show exceptional resilience to precision reduction and
can maintain high accuracy even at 4-bit quantization for numerous tasks and
they serve as a better solution than using smaller models at high precision
under similar memory requirements.
|
[
-0.5168795586,
-0.59569484,
0.6889380217,
0.2372563183,
-0.2725140154,
-0.170705989,
-0.2810856402,
-0.5372018814,
-0.1337367743,
0.416352123,
-0.0392785631,
-0.2626852989,
-0.655862093,
0.2641220093,
-0.3335136473,
0.6514991522,
-0.0901536569,
0.134907648,
-0.52957654,
-0.308300525,
-0.4781138897,
-0.6523430347,
-0.4471951425,
-0.2395765781,
0.5207033157,
0.378681004,
0.8460608125,
0.9835547209,
1.1082537174,
0.314863801,
-0.3479683101,
0.0304916315,
-0.3716082275,
0.0750054941,
-0.1195529699,
-0.8166445494,
-0.7502395511,
-0.0181945432,
1.0856482983,
0.6262350678,
-0.0820025206,
0.7014917135,
-0.0361173339,
0.5886672139,
-0.8166435361,
0.1101627871,
-0.4377776682,
-0.0861718282,
-0.1187638044,
0.2202661037,
-0.2005999684,
-0.3926005661,
-0.1626066267,
-0.6579017639,
0.1191506535,
0.1281363666,
0.6337983012,
0.5681737065,
-0.4501033425,
-0.1384691745,
-1.0274477005,
0.9782209396,
-1.0081869364,
0.2034564912,
0.2044778466,
0.3478989303,
0.2036153972,
-0.6890788674,
-0.095170334,
-0.2225140035,
0.0761514232,
-0.3316434622,
-0.418715328,
0.1373727173,
0.7124344707,
0.6733473539,
-0.4107526839,
0.4073008895,
-0.5952429175,
-0.1488176137,
0.4884087741,
0.5127944946,
-0.0696026534,
-0.0950226411,
-0.0517846458,
-0.2027469873,
-0.6814418435,
-0.0556828231,
0.0457002409,
0.322293967,
0.1003255025,
0.62356776,
-0.2931240201,
0.700583756,
0.0295262244,
-0.3641396761,
-0.3340237141,
-0.3042072654,
-0.5392947793,
-0.2126279771,
0.5995147824,
0.1738932878,
0.0377559923,
-0.0514305383,
-0.1285366565,
-0.0425974354,
0.4708198607,
-1.220621109,
0.1144281253,
0.1336557418,
-0.6415798664,
-0.2269169986,
-0.3968193531,
-0.4036192298,
-0.4853491783,
-0.2835336328,
0.7612236142,
-0.309661001,
-0.2049082071,
0.0400733016,
-0.0109244194,
0.0668536574,
0.3542965353,
-0.7843372226,
0.2990420163,
0.7663211226,
1.1437011957,
0.0566137061,
0.2105574608,
-0.2775099277,
0.0561023057,
-0.5177368522,
0.4296298921,
-0.3416076005,
-0.644743681,
-0.6584542394,
-0.4315240681,
0.3075935245,
-0.9849101305,
0.2412066907,
-0.5554538369,
-0.5333171487,
-0.4591234922,
-0.606785059,
-0.2972802222,
0.2611048818,
-1.0179729462,
0.738176167,
0.265021801,
-0.4306156039,
0.4059965909,
-0.4724371731,
-0.0044631218,
-0.0014817514,
-0.033835832,
-0.4602503181,
0.7904672027,
0.1073607281,
0.4995959103,
-0.7100136876,
0.0949584544,
-0.4445392489,
-0.5417572856,
0.216700837,
-0.5811389089,
0.3472323716,
0.1970510781,
-0.0615863241,
0.0742833391,
-0.9021441936,
0.1657445133,
0.0257546809,
-0.3720413744,
-0.3071487546,
-0.2013367116,
-0.4749011397,
-0.1328011602,
0.4519104958,
-0.237960577,
0.1514471322,
-0.2981863916,
0.6874632835,
0.607658267,
-0.0629668236,
0.6029648781,
-0.3954924345,
0.7296926379,
-0.1474289149,
0.3291945457,
-0.1239497438,
-0.2578748465,
-0.6327826381,
-0.5680202842,
0.5655114055,
0.2740931511,
-0.2658630311,
-0.0470528565,
-0.4250817299,
-0.5535458326,
-0.3423977196,
0.1681843102,
0.3420957029,
0.1943198591,
0.2150045186,
-0.3349015415,
-0.2999630868,
-1.0929112434,
-0.0928165019,
-0.2770787477,
-0.6063956022,
0.2158868462,
0.5519564152,
0.1207846254,
0.9009275436,
-0.2891474962,
-0.0217765011,
0.07691513,
0.0424973778,
0.1216464415,
0.2293827832,
0.3571573198,
-0.6426364779,
-0.1264831573,
-0.0224628169,
-0.7260218859,
-0.0774285048,
0.0437177271,
0.2424537987,
0.1678065062,
0.3641589284,
-0.5085169077,
0.4945059717,
0.6230350137,
0.0636659637,
0.5559625626,
-0.418153882,
0.1185572892,
-0.816116631,
0.0247905329,
0.1507632434,
-0.1020451561,
-0.469984442,
0.2646902502,
0.4465421438,
0.1114797071,
-0.3181578517,
0.2480329275,
-0.4347516596,
-0.482631743,
-0.0980590954,
-0.0623846725,
0.2206855565,
0.0257540997,
-0.1084074676,
1.0410084724,
0.1136266142,
-0.6429504156,
0.2844250202,
-0.2529390156,
-0.4072988331,
0.7623064518,
-0.9712167978,
-0.126240015,
0.2050810307,
-0.092845276,
-0.9244527817,
-0.0961304978,
-0.3260748684,
-0.2826346457,
0.2298428118,
0.0003663455,
-0.8501029611,
-0.2528164387,
-0.3813886046,
0.5694845915,
0.5387406349,
-0.3126274049,
0.6427754164,
-0.0918156654,
0.2115138918,
-0.0666819736,
-0.6970819831,
0.0041530184,
-0.6391304731,
-0.7146841884,
0.2218195647,
-0.0844432637,
-0.6864563823,
-0.1906763166,
-0.3732123971,
0.0071195648,
0.2275662273,
0.4610523283,
0.2514309883,
-0.3937209845,
0.3928593695,
-0.0123382397,
-0.0131368702,
0.1784726232,
-0.0375443473,
0.3094976544,
-0.5193419456,
-0.3888147771,
-0.3540706336,
-0.0433442555,
0.7771223783,
-0.263066411,
0.9000991583,
0.4422113299,
-0.3318198025,
-0.0931489542,
-0.584967494,
-0.2603248358,
-0.5152324438,
0.2800567448,
-0.3970055878,
-0.9556487799,
0.7017161846,
-0.3790085614,
-0.1770076752,
0.390522331,
0.4967797995,
0.1110213622,
0.8179515004,
0.5064944625,
-0.0388416275,
0.107067354,
-0.3182617426,
0.1319795251,
-1.0714278221,
-0.0118404925,
-0.4611626863,
-0.5058068037,
-0.617625773,
-0.8145525455,
0.647973001,
0.4365536869,
-0.5827048421,
0.2485139072,
-0.6057631373,
0.3562538326,
0.5290791392,
0.1230047494,
0.6395521164,
-0.0148935933,
0.3437110186,
-0.1735998988,
-0.6593980789,
-0.8402747512,
1.4291876554,
0.548763454,
0.7781931162,
0.2569950521,
0.5105922222,
0.1652569622,
0.3376068175,
-0.8210821748,
0.6061889529,
-0.2306072265,
-0.5741035342,
-0.6857031584,
-0.6714870334,
-0.6554066539,
0.4815637767,
0.0015184078,
-0.4893526435,
-0.0241897609,
0.0263339449,
-0.7360320091,
0.5578953624,
-0.6409489512,
0.5292033553,
-0.1442204118,
-0.1590809375,
-0.406632334,
-0.3643834889,
0.3529224396,
-0.35247311,
0.3189243376,
-0.1398193836,
-0.5628831983,
0.567163825,
-0.4086911678,
0.8987098932,
0.2641587853,
-0.3874713778,
0.2981139719,
0.3633140624,
0.371280551,
0.1591803133,
-0.3241803944,
0.6181342006,
0.2119523883,
-0.3287089765,
-0.6007146835,
0.7352992892,
-0.8228760958,
-0.7348768115,
0.0145736048,
-0.8824306726,
-0.1838114411,
-0.0115870489,
0.1378501803,
0.3185675442,
-0.019837277,
0.4798214436,
0.8447992802,
-0.1485916078,
0.4759453237,
0.5191895366,
-0.1334562749,
-0.3976545632,
0.7070105672,
0.6423505545,
0.7243502736,
0.3769705296,
0.210154891,
0.0633502007,
-0.8521895409,
-0.3844935894,
0.2804709971,
-0.461640507,
-0.4527017772,
-0.1592033356,
-0.0951217934,
-0.2363283932,
-0.1044094712,
-0.4254079461,
-0.6855065227,
-0.6344155669,
-0.0482360348,
0.5233726501,
0.708186686,
-0.2327874005,
0.5678742528,
-0.7018657327,
0.2823385,
0.3518243134,
0.4166228175,
0.1613894701,
-0.7480960488,
-0.4525064826,
0.0732084513,
-0.4199343026,
-0.5750525594,
0.2744345963,
-0.0700654611,
0.2009875774,
0.3797107041,
-0.0494135171,
0.7535997629,
-0.271974057,
0.6802466512,
-0.0655974001,
-1.103212595,
0.5406904817,
-0.3325174749,
0.5310330391,
0.1743683666,
0.3494681418,
-0.1594546735,
-0.1834478378,
-0.485953033,
-0.6455276608,
0.5194145441,
0.1794958115,
-0.1412825435,
0.3438635767,
0.8216256499,
-0.1085933521,
0.2673768103,
-0.4026768506,
-0.0033014128,
0.2471963018,
0.1072314158,
-0.1023613214,
-0.3898455203,
0.0153819565,
-0.1785342395,
0.2945386171,
0.0596851893,
-0.0302020963,
-0.1071790904,
0.1044014096,
-0.1633774042,
0.048429586,
0.5619416833,
0.7504330873,
-0.2608627975,
0.0119460942,
0.6141779423,
-0.323065877,
0.1098773554,
-0.374912113,
0.0172525123,
-0.3271739185,
0.5574815869,
0.6287077665,
0.1397454739,
-0.587002933,
0.04493526,
0.0913297236,
-0.1461329013,
0.0060336269,
0.2241555601,
0.2236741781,
0.6020479202,
0.1277683675,
-0.1868362725,
0.1268349439,
-0.2111930102,
-0.1954488009,
0.5681570172,
0.1083986908,
-0.1280841827,
0.648891747,
-0.1385894865,
-0.2696889341,
0.6984403133,
0.0181245506,
0.0227334499,
1.1806600094,
0.2764531076,
0.4820438921,
-0.2480656207,
0.0622962415,
0.4169997573,
0.5687772036,
-0.4085303247,
-0.1252445877,
-0.1214287877,
-0.406342119,
-0.6167039871,
-0.643684566,
-0.6462920308,
0.0832770914,
-0.9596093297,
-0.0012634305,
-0.8460245132,
-0.5955861807,
-0.1332992315,
0.1746327281,
-0.4712569118,
0.1931445599,
0.1842829585,
0.7792927623,
-0.5024045706,
0.5442215204,
0.5242414474,
-0.3638249636,
-0.9213740826,
-0.3790717423,
0.0115461983,
-0.752968967,
0.7701426148,
0.009984972,
0.0217947587,
-0.0606301576,
-0.3868519068,
-1.1954587698,
1.4956775904,
0.5409176946,
-0.74002105,
-0.101651825,
0.4698764384,
0.7476156354,
-0.1336156279,
0.294953078,
0.6530579329,
0.348348856,
0.1411955208,
-1.3840279579,
0.2261257172,
0.4237474203,
0.6636374593,
0.4528189898,
-0.9321733713,
1.2247298956,
-0.3034100533,
-0.0519091971,
0.1704985052,
0.4968505204,
0.4529462457,
0.1705483198,
0.1840543449,
0.7119538188,
0.7072217464,
0.022924697,
0.908977747,
-0.2642455995,
0.334638536,
0.8373615742,
-0.2949000299,
0.9526367188,
0.516682744,
-0.5400107503,
0.143484056,
0.5668916106,
-0.0461430624,
0.0254738126,
0.5630025864,
-0.3769534528,
-0.3223468363,
-0.0293747969,
-0.2124222368,
0.2617875636,
0.4867520928,
-0.3556235135,
-0.1419405341,
0.1204654723,
0.0106949061,
-0.0313266516,
-0.7264285684,
0.5052870512,
0.1316196173,
-0.0618470199,
0.7007609606,
0.0735556632,
0.6074300408,
-0.3993475735,
0.0873123854,
-0.267164886,
0.2521581948,
-0.1220085025,
-0.4410914779,
0.4693897665,
-0.004478178,
-0.2882707417,
-0.1249465272,
0.5982010961,
0.2096182406,
-0.7265795469,
0.1050617695,
0.3540299833,
0.1261381209,
-0.5630403757,
-0.16641666,
0.4917188287,
-0.3294429779,
-0.3472775817,
0.6055938005,
0.739610374,
-0.3369173408,
0.9514222145,
0.336415112,
0.2535995543,
0.0734247416,
-0.2075953931,
0.7139284611,
-0.5976693034,
0.1142489091,
-1.0692769289,
0.1643933952,
0.1466325372,
0.0113633489,
0.97829175,
0.503728807,
0.7401189208,
0.0868945643,
0.4576838315,
0.1455283612,
0.235422194,
-0.1847498268,
0.4031009376,
-0.6445934176,
0.5702930689,
0.1141405627,
-0.9097862244,
-0.3842876554,
0.5057272315,
-0.4819944203,
0.1365549564,
0.3732505143,
0.7207760811,
0.2564724386,
-0.1026158482,
0.7836797237,
0.0536722951,
0.2727220953,
0.6896920204,
0.651632905,
-0.335573405,
0.6829271317,
-0.3199895024,
-0.2793848813,
-0.2284462601,
-0.9060083032,
-0.8966822624,
-0.3102034628,
-0.3612960279,
-0.1152213812,
-0.2549508512,
0.3500898778,
0.8088003993,
-0.4083943367,
-0.3459726274,
0.0954547599,
0.0240703244,
-0.003914861,
-0.1524845064,
0.1061605737,
-0.2272779495,
-0.5482641459,
0.0145773431,
0.4190651774,
0.2356099784,
-0.7120339274,
0.1912730336,
0.3657854497,
0.4058614373,
0.7671121359,
0.0613309592,
-0.71426934,
-0.2179684639,
0.1342877746,
-0.1017627865,
-0.0573219582,
0.7571359873,
-0.7392784357,
0.195802927,
0.3367125988,
0.3869060874,
0.5103552341,
0.0497891828,
0.3397193253,
-0.4230200648,
0.0269889329,
0.1633746177,
-0.0096914647,
0.1181803271,
-0.4537187517,
0.6698838472,
-0.0685032979,
-0.7649125457,
-0.9421617985,
0.0984738097,
-0.7133298516,
-0.4032860398,
1.0575042963,
0.0114303641,
-0.014437425,
0.4722341299,
-0.0815525353,
0.102987282,
-0.1237420738,
0.7535842061,
0.8985599875,
-0.2618517876,
-0.1617276073,
-0.7870736122,
0.1145298854,
0.3191099763,
-0.6371764541,
0.0620207451,
0.5711785555,
0.2338927984,
0.2448672652,
0.3462910056,
-0.1135268509,
0.0261866748,
0.1850795746,
0.0283412859,
-0.1257015765,
-0.134277761,
-0.6838757992,
0.3882948756,
0.3974079788,
-0.0905264989
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03138v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03138v1
|
CRAFT: Extracting and Tuning Cultural Instructions from the Wild
| 2024-05-06T03:21:55 | 2024-05-06T03:21:55 |
Bin Wang, Geyu Lin, Zhengyuan Liu, Chengwei Wei, Nancy F. Chen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have rapidly evolved as the foundation of
various natural language processing (NLP) applications. Despite their wide use
cases, their understanding of culturally-related concepts and reasoning remains
limited. Meantime, there is a significant need to enhance these models'
cultural reasoning capabilities, especially concerning underrepresented
regions. This paper introduces a novel pipeline for extracting high-quality,
culturally-related instruction tuning datasets from vast unstructured corpora.
We utilize a self-instruction generation pipeline to identify cultural concepts
and trigger instruction. By integrating with a general-purpose instruction
tuning dataset, our model demonstrates enhanced capabilities in recognizing and
understanding regional cultural nuances, thereby enhancing its reasoning
capabilities. We conduct experiments across three regions: Singapore, the
Philippines, and the United States, achieving performance improvement of up to
6%. Our research opens new avenues for extracting cultural instruction tuning
sets directly from unstructured data, setting a precedent for future
innovations in the field.
|
[
-0.0952510461,
-0.5177271962,
0.2660796046,
0.2198839039,
-0.3109695017,
0.3399209678,
-0.6731674075,
-0.138253063,
0.1087383404,
0.9932053685,
-0.9235199094,
-0.9580518603,
-0.3277901709,
-0.077353254,
-0.1836780459,
0.8326855302,
0.116600126,
-0.0400725491,
0.1161904857,
-0.0084033534,
-0.624168992,
-0.3403463066,
-0.2212660015,
-0.0831139758,
-0.0432719812,
0.9192365408,
0.4502629042,
1.2095071077,
0.3982710838,
0.3519513607,
0.0731028542,
0.7027525902,
-0.4772559106,
0.1919269562,
-0.386212796,
-0.5146003366,
-0.2531608045,
0.1087817401,
0.4571814537,
0.6078135371,
-0.2566585243,
0.5140159726,
-0.1036594883,
0.6015839577,
-0.5406576991,
0.1527433097,
-0.963059485,
0.2007983923,
-0.3454814553,
-0.6360004544,
-0.4532909691,
-0.3605928719,
0.0762980133,
-0.5614491105,
0.5310297608,
-0.0423123389,
0.4441674352,
0.4647782147,
-0.4164792895,
-0.4483295679,
-0.6389220357,
0.9861716032,
-0.5382866263,
0.1393082887,
0.5208137631,
0.1075500622,
-0.3977259398,
-0.7229540348,
-0.0644640177,
0.3105432093,
0.0320703834,
0.103618145,
0.1118862033,
-0.1535719037,
0.2598102987,
0.6545918584,
-0.4823563397,
0.5229758024,
-0.6822787523,
-0.3066591918,
0.8281475306,
0.2853969932,
0.3744015992,
-0.2533387244,
-0.1587114483,
-0.0232936349,
-0.769261241,
0.1077665091,
0.2655527294,
0.3663253486,
-0.3196266592,
0.4355144799,
-0.2918577492,
0.8169043064,
-0.0048847543,
-0.2712545991,
-0.0453343466,
-0.114057377,
-0.2338119745,
0.0486926883,
0.4607946873,
0.3418800533,
0.3460846543,
-0.2853517532,
-0.0156503115,
-0.1012313738,
0.1425677538,
-0.6924058199,
-0.4670567513,
-0.0116826883,
-0.482362777,
-0.0991471857,
-0.0082652625,
-0.8724487424,
-0.4209889472,
-0.571174562,
-0.2367294729,
-0.259671092,
-0.0930688158,
-0.0548200682,
-0.1771650612,
0.5638417006,
-0.0069542248,
-1.4154032469,
-0.1777763069,
0.8401688337,
0.7388041019,
-0.2985714674,
-0.1577181965,
-0.423543781,
0.2030955255,
-0.5944385529,
0.7354009151,
-0.8851658106,
-0.5308700204,
0.0804291293,
0.3361732066,
0.0850805268,
-0.627420485,
0.6579256058,
-0.5001457334,
0.1815522462,
-0.3153353035,
-0.4003394544,
0.0021037539,
-0.1277218312,
-0.412255615,
1.0360777378,
0.0380478799,
-0.2608358562,
0.383108288,
-0.7008626461,
-0.6100879312,
0.225159958,
-0.1425478011,
0.0333557054,
0.2685843706,
0.6705693603,
0.4838801324,
-0.4038875401,
0.0820900574,
-0.199431017,
-0.6971787214,
0.0047880611,
-0.5944584012,
0.8857339621,
0.4700196385,
-0.3673110008,
0.0050271107,
-0.8934494853,
0.337181747,
-0.0153432693,
-0.433265835,
-0.421521157,
-0.1565783024,
-0.4843010306,
0.0665228739,
0.203958869,
-0.4085823298,
0.4395687282,
-0.3755583167,
0.7391465306,
0.8716423512,
-0.0690259114,
0.8242430687,
0.1385596991,
0.7071353793,
-0.1693185717,
0.0577390045,
-0.4902245998,
-0.1716037989,
-0.7882508039,
-0.4848874509,
0.2188964635,
0.589464128,
-0.8175794482,
0.4157710969,
-0.1691490859,
-0.5594313145,
-0.9490661621,
0.5427249074,
0.1637451202,
0.4624841809,
0.278552115,
-0.2211462706,
-0.6499145627,
-0.5064513683,
-0.1139700189,
0.3421465456,
-0.2734695971,
0.1228837967,
0.0690193102,
-0.0089826752,
0.7940198779,
-0.6075743437,
-0.2305280864,
-0.0770449564,
0.2394859046,
0.415884167,
0.4815805852,
0.1455493569,
-0.3654566109,
-0.3182466626,
0.0956930742,
-0.9683125615,
-0.2934367359,
-0.1458792686,
-0.5710542202,
0.4332873523,
0.8267609477,
-0.2113802433,
0.2192476094,
0.5943518877,
-0.228674531,
0.3559306264,
-0.4468305111,
0.0920067728,
-0.8722521067,
-0.2750883996,
-0.1379701346,
0.3330049217,
-0.2125172317,
0.1792061627,
0.1344115436,
-0.2427294403,
-0.1632951349,
0.3675815761,
-0.8388798833,
-0.0774035379,
-0.4030965269,
-0.0585726649,
0.0144557394,
0.4607400298,
0.5287929177,
0.754329443,
0.638461411,
-0.3942303956,
0.3950374424,
0.045852311,
-0.6597143412,
0.4237272739,
-0.3829328716,
0.4198399782,
-0.1381477267,
0.1880795211,
-0.3459567726,
-0.3550848067,
-0.0612147786,
0.0134032136,
0.3486610353,
-0.6866999865,
-0.3848362565,
-0.3862334788,
0.1032131836,
-0.067334719,
0.5833029747,
-0.726023972,
0.5566714406,
0.3129451573,
0.0589033514,
-0.7457402349,
-0.6174275875,
-0.1344367713,
-0.6070522666,
-0.5436381698,
0.0974959061,
0.0148488218,
-0.0500929654,
-0.3282731473,
-0.2044485211,
-0.0764502957,
0.2245346606,
0.2697533071,
0.2386176139,
-0.5453903079,
0.1889725327,
0.3252975941,
0.0362525247,
0.2423124909,
-0.6408877373,
0.2970460951,
-0.0594582185,
-0.2642090619,
-0.1077683493,
0.4045999646,
0.4913201928,
-0.7475604415,
0.6744981408,
0.9034596682,
-0.006604454,
-0.722653091,
-0.4570802748,
-0.3238214552,
-0.6024445295,
0.3220413625,
-0.2630848885,
-0.8587568998,
0.3854811192,
-0.4601306319,
0.2047076523,
0.0943858027,
0.4414670765,
-0.1963121593,
0.7979953885,
0.7086896896,
0.1070333272,
0.3768639863,
-0.468865484,
0.1324937195,
-0.6373381019,
-0.2029567808,
-0.3749623597,
-0.3302967846,
-1.0562932491,
-0.7702870369,
0.456934303,
0.0014560604,
-0.3819875121,
-0.0181428101,
-0.6219853759,
1.1093765497,
0.7719932199,
-0.0538050197,
0.2436790764,
0.267719835,
-0.1070424914,
-0.087156333,
-0.8432650566,
-0.6999490261,
1.11967659,
0.2757885158,
0.8996373415,
0.094759725,
0.5592280626,
0.2754685879,
0.3126996458,
-0.6641973853,
0.2953649163,
-0.7959920764,
-0.5710883737,
-0.3586513996,
-0.3277667165,
-0.8010988235,
0.1075903326,
-0.188803032,
-0.6894964576,
0.0014537663,
0.1917224377,
-0.3417284489,
0.2140370458,
-1.0204598904,
0.9508535862,
-0.4969345033,
-0.2671436667,
-0.0170381907,
-0.6570500731,
0.526932478,
-0.0759197846,
0.3224960864,
-0.214341417,
0.3468204141,
0.3411909938,
-0.0781114474,
1.1275931597,
-0.0873697922,
-0.3185527623,
0.3468415141,
0.2720156014,
0.1980855763,
0.0336881094,
-0.3135231435,
0.3309467733,
-0.0226498488,
-0.3815999329,
-0.7609155178,
0.8888534904,
-0.8970014453,
-0.7804446816,
0.0611775778,
-0.7958894968,
-0.1774733365,
-0.0478535965,
0.2135746032,
0.596161902,
0.0833625048,
0.2454432249,
0.8085042238,
-0.4126566052,
0.3658882678,
0.8881534934,
0.2438242435,
-0.0931378677,
1.0152603388,
0.075309366,
0.2007988095,
0.2897945344,
0.2712779939,
-0.2370200604,
-0.3819493651,
-0.8766101003,
0.1322645098,
-1.0219842196,
-0.1604283005,
-0.1808691919,
-0.126665771,
-0.4181261361,
-0.2884645164,
-0.2889871001,
-0.1826700568,
-0.4292089343,
-0.1108270213,
0.2593513131,
0.6375707984,
-0.222674787,
0.3831752539,
-0.8747912049,
-0.0298204459,
0.3021770716,
0.3051337004,
-0.0672029033,
-0.9092031717,
-0.3686673939,
0.1361403614,
-0.1610926092,
-0.6178381443,
0.5685350895,
0.299898982,
0.5501708984,
0.4841625392,
0.2663429677,
1.024975419,
-0.4914239049,
0.6766337156,
-0.3882932961,
-0.7990319133,
0.8131206632,
-0.2689650059,
0.6943138838,
0.2290088683,
0.5210412145,
-0.525206089,
-0.3620710075,
-0.2130165845,
-0.8852143884,
0.8295016289,
-0.4758530855,
0.463236928,
-0.1736885309,
0.3283810914,
0.2372186929,
-0.181212008,
-0.5118617415,
-0.0599929504,
-0.3897746801,
-0.2291096896,
0.0961564928,
-0.0260638557,
-0.244755581,
-0.2917119563,
0.5405976176,
-0.4669977129,
-0.1519494653,
-0.1069999933,
-0.2008949518,
-0.3987965882,
0.278185457,
0.3941280544,
0.797180891,
-0.021979548,
0.0476676114,
0.3215623796,
-0.3186614811,
-0.1771990359,
-0.124799557,
-0.1268607229,
-0.4494969845,
0.5688819885,
0.7037718892,
0.129945159,
-0.619720161,
0.0058231996,
-0.151490882,
0.2636691034,
-0.520414412,
0.3532161117,
0.0143092806,
0.3007372022,
0.3176456988,
-0.2080161124,
-0.1078317538,
-0.6592907906,
0.0328353122,
0.3716343939,
-0.2821975648,
-0.1081070602,
0.3926674128,
0.4648360014,
-0.1720768213,
1.2279012203,
-0.0837727636,
-0.35538885,
0.6364321709,
0.6320846677,
0.4489243031,
0.0019226344,
0.480035305,
0.4137462676,
0.4094996452,
0.143951565,
0.1306330413,
-0.3387441933,
-0.6909967661,
-0.8937348127,
-0.8832044005,
-0.1728589833,
0.1033086926,
-0.6926550269,
0.2983417809,
-0.2632050514,
0.3408395946,
-0.2683653533,
-0.0405616127,
-0.7599033713,
0.2318191677,
0.4543296397,
0.86024189,
-1.0659897327,
0.876372993,
0.5591805577,
-0.0047620595,
-0.943780303,
0.0097552249,
0.1889048219,
-1.1032309532,
0.7082048655,
0.0406011827,
-0.1642890424,
-0.1057314053,
-0.7465476394,
-0.929721415,
1.0274566412,
0.3585188389,
-0.4957485199,
0.1295819879,
0.2110850811,
0.7894497514,
-0.5517534018,
0.2400081903,
1.0195301771,
0.1230518594,
0.440826416,
-0.6208091378,
-0.1330180615,
-0.1646506637,
-0.2163737267,
0.0697014481,
-0.5638156533,
0.3268382251,
-0.3814988136,
-0.144023791,
-0.0317345485,
0.931707859,
0.3419494927,
0.1413584352,
0.1266489476,
0.2496847957,
0.9900669456,
-0.1693798304,
0.8256295919,
-0.3156093359,
-0.216183126,
1.2179496288,
-0.0531688593,
0.5536018014,
0.0958872586,
0.2745274305,
0.7905330062,
0.8954217434,
-0.1410501301,
0.5718044639,
0.3556089997,
-0.0778709352,
-0.5502457023,
-0.3095278144,
-0.2031341344,
1.2702811956,
0.7219661474,
-0.5140603185,
0.0136693353,
-0.315605104,
0.0935705379,
0.3239517212,
-0.4972681105,
0.688624084,
-0.0473625362,
-1.1100884676,
0.6881294847,
0.0922107399,
0.6431120634,
-0.6260202527,
-0.2653859556,
-0.5604372621,
0.0102048134,
-0.1847331822,
-0.6262824535,
0.2776970863,
0.1982555091,
-0.2666473389,
-0.4396438599,
0.4298873842,
-0.6273192167,
-0.535995841,
-0.0389087871,
0.3620879352,
0.2737457454,
0.3883316815,
-0.5575054884,
0.0959216878,
0.177597627,
0.0772581846,
0.2007949799,
1.0260527134,
-0.3363237977,
0.569554925,
0.7023894191,
0.1729918122,
0.1572623998,
0.174675107,
0.5318092704,
-0.6044558883,
-0.3722904027,
-0.6272391677,
0.4406377971,
-0.1732485741,
-0.4143883288,
0.6317592263,
0.1969140917,
1.1203722954,
-0.1806536913,
0.596216917,
0.0889435858,
0.4332587719,
-0.7882903218,
0.5055329204,
-0.2663736641,
0.5187758803,
0.1928151995,
-0.6645424366,
0.0019484725,
0.5312445164,
-0.5379339457,
-0.0987176895,
0.5060787797,
0.9417969584,
-0.1987715513,
0.4011248052,
0.17824018,
0.1995628178,
0.0662925765,
0.1660955697,
0.8156943917,
0.2536597252,
0.4744018614,
-0.5467346907,
-0.2903947234,
0.4142903686,
-1.1187148094,
-0.9414812326,
-0.4138881266,
-0.2332694232,
0.0415545627,
-0.0784036741,
1.0678563118,
0.9162806273,
-0.8143410683,
-0.4285877645,
0.4546253979,
0.1711298376,
-0.3229382932,
-0.2532158792,
0.5240371823,
-0.4430744946,
-0.7281427383,
0.859107852,
0.2361987829,
-0.2032492608,
-0.4399855137,
0.1034766659,
0.2262710929,
0.032203462,
0.6757502556,
0.3643330336,
-0.7247692943,
-0.1743986309,
0.279966712,
0.2747609913,
-0.2568659484,
1.0080244541,
-0.5221151114,
0.5837892294,
0.1051466241,
0.4609633386,
0.3755321205,
0.0726997107,
0.7255158424,
-1.2189540863,
0.129871577,
0.0236323066,
0.204234913,
0.5636520982,
-0.4622385502,
0.6913316846,
0.0547361001,
-0.6624696255,
-0.5343900919,
0.1952269822,
-0.5251526833,
-0.4043085277,
1.1961858273,
-0.3625427186,
-0.2997864485,
-0.0890118778,
0.0148054613,
0.2839307487,
-0.1142216101,
1.1752030849,
0.562648654,
0.036612127,
-0.156515196,
-0.5900126696,
0.419069767,
0.3879609704,
-0.7485714555,
0.2443936616,
0.6490662098,
0.3356042802,
-0.1771985888,
0.2136629522,
-0.1305496246,
0.2856829166,
-0.4311873615,
-0.001074572,
0.0113488212,
-0.3460571468,
-0.2075479925,
0.1111868173,
-0.0303728245,
-0.0283083506
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03133v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03133v1
|
Lory: Fully Differentiable Mixture-of-Experts for Autoregressive Language Model Pre-training
| 2024-05-06T03:06:33 | 2024-05-06T03:06:33 |
Zexuan Zhong, Mengzhou Xia, Danqi Chen, Mike Lewis
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Mixture-of-experts (MoE) models facilitate efficient scaling; however,
training the router network introduces the challenge of optimizing a
non-differentiable, discrete objective. Recently, a fully-differentiable MoE
architecture, SMEAR, was proposed (Muqeeth et al., 2023), which softly merges
experts in the parameter space; nevertheless, its effectiveness was only
demonstrated in downstream fine-tuning on classification tasks. In this paper,
we present Lory, the first approach that scales such architectures to
autoregressive language model pre-training. Lory introduces two key techniques:
(1) a causal segment routing strategy that achieves high efficiency for expert
merging operations while preserving the autoregressive nature of language
models; (2) a similarity-based data batching method that encourages expert
specialization by grouping similar documents in training instances. We
pre-train a series of Lory models on 150B tokens from scratch, with up to 32
experts and 30B (1.5B active) parameters. Experimental results show significant
performance gains over parameter-matched dense models on both perplexity
(+13.9%) and a variety of downstream tasks (+1.5%-11.1%). Despite segment-level
routing, Lory models achieve competitive performance compared to
state-of-the-art MoE models with token-level routing. We further demonstrate
that the trained experts in Lory capture domain-level specialization without
supervision. Our work highlights the potential of fully-differentiable MoE
architectures for language model pre-training and advocates future research in
this area.
|
[
-0.4862407744,
-0.7235122919,
0.3058250546,
0.1810522228,
-0.1783428639,
-0.0045746146,
-0.3032819033,
-0.3328407705,
0.4530590773,
0.5960233212,
-0.4918031991,
-0.318523705,
-0.8980872631,
-0.2534223795,
-0.6437035203,
0.8008064628,
0.1565225571,
-0.1282323301,
0.2160796523,
-0.2397686839,
-0.1076231301,
-0.4016156197,
-0.7757498026,
-0.0687821209,
0.7167602777,
0.1294982284,
0.5079834461,
0.9194321632,
0.6080327034,
0.4446616769,
0.1164368615,
0.2295808196,
-0.4144001603,
0.1338246167,
-0.2508817613,
-0.3005858064,
-0.6756757498,
0.0690657645,
0.5779235363,
0.8389829397,
-0.5659874082,
-0.1290369183,
-0.1016770676,
0.6471036673,
-0.7178055048,
-0.1399155557,
-0.8700853586,
-0.1326026022,
-0.2670168579,
-0.1038251966,
-0.3557567298,
-0.1121730283,
0.2089749873,
-0.3277769387,
0.2914811075,
0.1228953823,
0.7057624459,
0.6135054827,
-0.4852000475,
-0.1293380558,
-0.6496501565,
0.9396108389,
-0.9728696942,
0.3534735739,
0.1769296825,
0.3179194927,
0.0495653041,
-0.6439703703,
-0.2542332709,
0.0647071749,
0.1392784715,
-0.0161444396,
-0.1018431261,
0.0820144042,
-0.2006334066,
0.5636124015,
-0.3904142976,
0.4138868451,
-0.4100716412,
-0.0885934085,
0.7776891589,
0.1807673872,
0.0368326046,
0.3878122866,
-0.2888731658,
0.1278664917,
-0.4231200516,
-0.2462546527,
0.5153748393,
0.4143970013,
-0.0401147008,
0.3085138202,
-0.4166474938,
0.9293332696,
0.5081635118,
-0.153889969,
0.183321476,
-0.0076902336,
-0.231810987,
0.0560548119,
0.9330461621,
-0.2251523882,
0.0529856309,
-0.2596088648,
-0.2216341048,
-0.1172933504,
0.3457990587,
-0.7125363946,
-0.6079663038,
-0.0798388869,
-0.212582767,
-0.4497005939,
-0.3419961035,
-0.4989867508,
-0.0512786731,
-0.4493660629,
0.61348629,
-0.2467299104,
-0.4789561629,
0.2685755193,
0.3761439323,
0.1025264859,
0.5250542164,
-1.0201735497,
0.2088521421,
0.5395403504,
0.5224311352,
-0.3089735806,
-0.4685431123,
-0.580014348,
0.0035381103,
-0.2322947085,
0.801540494,
-0.6692303419,
-0.3682769239,
-0.2184607238,
-0.3458860517,
-0.4162825644,
-0.488422364,
0.1150152907,
-0.7952845097,
0.3459461629,
0.0343717523,
-0.4146650434,
0.0015117052,
0.2525176704,
-0.4567382336,
0.9212970734,
0.133350119,
-0.8631439209,
0.3015416265,
-0.4634951353,
-0.5836116672,
-0.0764577165,
-0.2649095654,
-0.0932222009,
0.1212514937,
0.1891085953,
0.3955135942,
-0.3656204641,
0.2596860826,
-0.2912662029,
-0.0049812836,
-0.1339244694,
-0.5710043907,
0.7125597596,
0.2047049701,
-0.5157933831,
0.1151263863,
-0.8323088884,
0.050712619,
-0.2250049263,
-0.4861249924,
-0.4449698329,
-0.0022977253,
-0.1968521178,
0.2095568627,
0.5338782072,
-0.3539350331,
0.1954586357,
-0.3021313846,
0.384695977,
0.8252715468,
-0.1546721905,
0.4940972626,
-0.0562715046,
0.2807488143,
0.2536976337,
0.303616643,
-0.0503787845,
-0.4829993844,
-1.1341334581,
-0.5706342459,
0.3150550723,
0.3738723099,
-0.5808351636,
0.7661068439,
-0.2503370941,
-0.6157731414,
-0.7018771172,
0.2042845786,
0.4920294285,
0.6521475911,
0.4420019984,
-0.5654978752,
-0.1813213527,
-0.9452112317,
-0.1527358443,
-0.207618162,
0.238274008,
0.1184562817,
0.1120932102,
-0.4591256976,
0.994630456,
-0.6509382129,
-0.1956928819,
0.0254399851,
0.49910146,
0.089868553,
0.5975590348,
0.2207194567,
-0.8163702488,
-0.6609800458,
0.1101024598,
-0.5024390817,
-0.1124227047,
0.387856096,
-0.2931262255,
0.035072282,
0.5943551064,
-0.4382954836,
0.1853464097,
0.6515603065,
-0.0739721432,
0.2811394036,
-0.3922587633,
0.0941834375,
-1.1139194965,
-0.1405213028,
-0.097129792,
-0.2129776776,
-0.6715521812,
0.1996723115,
-0.1861715168,
0.0873148441,
-0.3983207345,
0.6971629262,
-0.3053044379,
0.1489659697,
-0.3076152205,
0.0224887356,
-0.134385556,
0.6053658128,
0.1309974939,
0.4649849236,
0.8340252042,
-0.7464415431,
0.1353336871,
-0.1911536157,
-0.2243413776,
0.6720244884,
-0.5475014448,
0.1172699481,
-0.0561079159,
-0.1412665397,
-0.8730271459,
-0.2564638853,
-0.1112684831,
-0.2975692451,
0.3457706571,
-0.2394827902,
-0.2445599437,
-0.1543334424,
0.1757351905,
0.5548837185,
0.7654320598,
-0.3056606352,
1.0534793139,
0.3804408014,
-0.1017304361,
-0.5941400528,
-0.8214913607,
-0.3031851649,
-0.2554970086,
-0.5701913834,
0.1313626915,
-0.1671007723,
-0.1447103322,
0.0883178189,
-0.0818386525,
-0.5628338456,
0.0750957802,
0.0647000819,
0.0410735644,
-0.4995937645,
-0.2440060824,
0.2533213496,
-0.1611850411,
-0.1711532474,
-0.5701014996,
0.4919215739,
-0.0383371376,
-0.784335196,
-0.2888845801,
0.2690904737,
0.5116173029,
-0.4556095302,
0.8030666113,
0.7930009961,
-0.0350675918,
-0.0780379176,
-1.0961844921,
0.0501327366,
-0.5407623053,
0.3567175269,
-0.2187999338,
-1.0316582918,
0.393781215,
-0.0330107547,
0.2678050697,
0.5354570746,
0.52717942,
0.1483691931,
0.8367062807,
0.8643702865,
-0.4238755703,
0.4740055799,
-0.1119863316,
0.3964139223,
-0.5563425422,
0.0115812337,
-0.4259605408,
-0.143734917,
-0.444167316,
-0.7453307509,
0.3078111112,
0.3025652468,
-0.4095122814,
0.1653795838,
-0.2945807278,
0.4737509489,
0.5106500387,
-0.1672908962,
0.3580490053,
0.143143788,
-0.0609267764,
0.2788698077,
-0.788180232,
-0.1568520069,
0.9270134568,
0.2073180526,
0.9849616289,
0.0851872936,
0.9394780993,
0.2810969949,
0.3673388362,
-0.6388291121,
0.6458046436,
-0.5527590513,
-0.5735015869,
-0.5041547418,
-0.6205039024,
-0.7363348007,
0.3524520099,
0.1280275732,
-0.6409182549,
0.3870846629,
0.4735165238,
-0.3260800838,
0.5242394209,
-0.6680113673,
0.437081784,
-0.3521742225,
-0.251169771,
-0.2744110823,
-0.6317161918,
0.2064057738,
-0.3318960369,
0.186139226,
-0.0185015015,
-0.0530867912,
0.7327529192,
-0.4042117596,
0.7801140547,
-0.3197999895,
-0.1514689177,
0.2961793542,
0.1392601281,
0.4466261566,
-0.3112785816,
-0.1250979155,
0.1486590952,
-0.4174358845,
-0.5780850649,
-0.5591855645,
0.8238096833,
-1.1131211519,
-0.5835188627,
0.1355070919,
-0.4205301702,
-0.3941515684,
0.4314087927,
0.2897891998,
0.6814613342,
0.0075945621,
0.1649720222,
1.0698230267,
0.300483942,
0.4163137376,
0.7883298397,
-0.0722321048,
-0.3513850868,
0.9236029983,
0.0183272418,
0.3433120251,
0.6677467227,
0.0954050869,
-0.0806201026,
-0.6526948214,
-0.2730877101,
0.1554826945,
-0.5483864546,
0.0016432904,
-0.9499323368,
-0.4075523913,
-0.3430716693,
-0.3466472328,
-0.9424976707,
-0.2500593662,
-0.3113145232,
0.2067230493,
0.1490278393,
0.8159502149,
-0.1413817406,
0.5956586003,
-0.6316057444,
-0.0450096838,
0.7983427644,
0.2491753399,
0.2860932052,
-0.74678725,
-0.4959585071,
-0.1069583669,
0.1003474295,
-0.213956058,
0.3845075667,
0.1487664133,
0.6886820197,
0.7550528646,
-0.0269053895,
0.8179498911,
-0.5629395843,
0.5913763642,
0.3092479408,
-0.8196190596,
0.2798986137,
-0.5410768986,
0.0864255354,
0.8252416849,
0.5419169068,
-0.0467227697,
-0.3338018358,
-0.524104178,
-1.0267632008,
0.5286080837,
-0.0111138998,
0.0442084186,
0.0181857105,
0.1537753344,
0.1632419974,
0.377484262,
-0.4885012209,
-0.2035471946,
-0.0951026827,
-0.4070860147,
-0.1608662754,
-0.0580040999,
-0.1893304139,
-0.0559903085,
0.5904245973,
0.044575505,
0.2149476409,
0.017277969,
-0.2427292913,
0.087183103,
0.11749883,
0.3534630835,
0.6200531721,
-0.2437439114,
0.0850170255,
-0.0289215427,
-0.4226234853,
0.1953144968,
0.1147459447,
0.1170112714,
-0.2374930382,
0.474622488,
0.9471691251,
0.2261917889,
-0.397051692,
0.5457171798,
0.0277710818,
-0.404840827,
-0.084949635,
0.375990361,
-0.0450168289,
0.2734901011,
0.4451209605,
0.2232752591,
-0.066343613,
-0.1756968796,
0.0212276038,
0.1795485914,
-0.4999214411,
-0.3734563291,
0.5317570567,
0.5169419646,
-0.2263462245,
0.4964796305,
-0.2284660339,
-0.2258151174,
0.3646301031,
0.1695166528,
0.7779701948,
-0.450202167,
-0.0515824221,
-0.0754055157,
0.2249536365,
-0.1966491044,
-0.1800872982,
-0.1168814674,
-0.6932027936,
-0.4328331351,
-0.6452501416,
-0.2006792575,
-0.0572059713,
-0.8153175712,
0.0782332569,
-0.4833120704,
-0.0774964616,
-0.2158595771,
-0.1675821543,
-0.7150117159,
0.4802215993,
-0.1228703931,
0.8717594743,
-0.8875334859,
0.9840682745,
0.836628437,
-0.0990501568,
-0.8888681531,
0.0584441572,
-0.247478053,
-0.9098952413,
0.8520452976,
-0.1564748734,
-0.3880930841,
0.268568337,
-0.2083624452,
-0.964250803,
0.9440060854,
0.0972437039,
-0.7382209897,
-0.3238775134,
-0.0695261583,
0.501078546,
-0.546223402,
0.2845216691,
0.2366339862,
0.1036234647,
0.1722989678,
-0.8567917943,
-0.3363770843,
-0.1814621985,
-0.0627982244,
0.3874816597,
-0.8690171242,
1.2517750263,
0.1270861626,
0.1629501134,
-0.0262896232,
0.7253788114,
-0.0313951448,
0.0291166436,
0.8280907869,
0.7514601946,
0.8010639548,
0.287339896,
0.6873891354,
-0.4933794141,
0.3267760575,
1.3026026487,
-0.3312292993,
0.9512908459,
0.3265978396,
-0.1136097312,
0.6651751995,
0.4245576262,
0.4441337287,
0.8443593383,
0.0316060111,
-0.3932469785,
-0.5008407831,
0.1439555585,
-0.4448405206,
0.2653895915,
0.2304701656,
-0.2069963962,
-0.2921821177,
-0.0253025759,
0.025142204,
-0.1083019748,
-0.5073986053,
0.7115027905,
-0.1075259894,
-0.538387537,
0.3238317072,
0.132632032,
1.0178843737,
-0.9077210426,
0.4278692901,
-0.4575354755,
0.1433305442,
-0.1219079494,
-0.3112713099,
0.043547824,
-0.0767822191,
-0.385959506,
0.0052186078,
0.5692673326,
-0.5415399075,
-0.5212602019,
0.2830808461,
0.5979990363,
0.1826857626,
-0.0375089198,
-0.5920590162,
-0.1126765311,
0.0859817192,
-0.2176211923,
0.5671012402,
0.7199779153,
-0.03454151,
0.7262093425,
0.3468676507,
0.2686565816,
0.4332191348,
0.0665738806,
1.0395340919,
-0.419705838,
-0.5974375606,
-0.6578967571,
0.6077771187,
0.0400096215,
-0.2204146683,
0.5236622095,
0.3525881469,
0.8717864156,
0.0297973994,
0.6138477325,
-0.0967755243,
0.4464718103,
-0.4931594729,
0.5438449979,
-0.6996864676,
0.1659590453,
-0.0161304921,
-0.780135572,
0.0077171633,
0.4496061206,
-0.6471173763,
0.277372539,
0.5365327001,
0.8251668811,
-0.3900494576,
-0.3157643974,
0.3662434816,
0.204398632,
0.243308723,
0.3430813849,
0.6479494572,
-0.1473271698,
0.3952250481,
-0.1093469933,
-0.2432028055,
-0.3678957522,
-0.7614206076,
-1.1430777311,
-0.5557820797,
-0.5286794901,
0.1320490092,
0.1082832664,
0.8718621731,
1.1759827137,
-0.55843997,
-0.1992887855,
-0.1840566993,
-0.1517548114,
0.2551496625,
-0.2062650919,
0.282998234,
-0.5559515953,
-0.5528531671,
0.4066279233,
0.4211030602,
-0.0719227791,
-0.5827265978,
-0.0074141058,
-0.1954972595,
0.272959888,
0.4695811868,
0.1888176352,
-0.590075314,
0.1140412316,
-0.3887085617,
-0.1466799527,
-0.114200756,
0.9121404886,
-0.5434723496,
0.3490622938,
0.3280911744,
0.8512177467,
0.3707522154,
0.0610821024,
0.4781512916,
-0.6248578429,
0.2991867959,
0.1928871721,
0.1277426928,
0.275072515,
-0.2556281388,
0.3251656294,
0.1693829745,
-0.6346600652,
-0.6659809947,
0.226491183,
-0.8446475267,
-0.1077594757,
0.8800672889,
-0.3940666616,
-0.1418544054,
-0.0710529163,
0.0421802215,
-0.0073292581,
-0.407595247,
0.6214348078,
0.5639532804,
-0.0972391069,
-0.0435919091,
-0.1961022764,
0.1187127605,
0.4663495719,
-0.7391504049,
-0.1147543862,
0.2350339144,
0.3623236418,
0.1601040065,
0.9615371227,
-0.0469715782,
-0.2630847692,
0.0640917569,
-0.0009694421,
-0.1969731301,
-0.499614507,
-0.1756645888,
0.1125475243,
0.3281243145,
-0.0328273252
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03111v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03111v1
|
An Active Inference Agent for Simulating Human Translation Processes in a Hierarchical Architecture: Integrating the Task Segment Framework and the HOF taxonomy
| 2024-05-06T02:07:13 | 2024-05-06T02:07:13 |
Michael Carl
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
In this paper, we propose modelling human translation production as a
hierarchy of three embedded translation processes. The proposed architecture
replicates the temporal dynamics of keystroke production across sensorimotor,
cognitive, and phenomenal layers. Utilizing data from the CRITT TPR-DB, the
Task Segment Framework, and the HOF taxonomy, we demonstrate the temporal
breakdown of the typing flow on distinct timelines within these three layers.
|
[
0.1726359427,
-0.9415034056,
0.7432696223,
0.2027664036,
0.0007827963,
0.3308422863,
0.0384618677,
-0.369897455,
0.013341031,
0.6013014913,
-0.6926091313,
-0.6002845764,
-0.2055761814,
-0.047769431,
-0.5327531099,
0.3838415146,
-0.1318351328,
-0.1733054072,
0.1045691967,
0.0186399333,
0.1469498426,
-0.740404129,
-0.5714625716,
-0.5216577649,
0.2607865334,
0.2428747863,
1.0076534748,
1.0110806227,
0.4601487219,
0.2488674968,
-0.1238538548,
-0.1533086747,
0.2021704912,
0.4568790793,
-0.1924892217,
-0.4615947306,
-1.0379410982,
-0.0616467595,
0.7256374359,
0.790674746,
-0.1016870216,
-0.0130489003,
0.0168232489,
0.0796449855,
-0.430790633,
0.0866185054,
-0.1115176305,
0.2096849531,
-0.1899940521,
-0.141933322,
-0.3345097899,
0.0410829149,
0.2322897911,
-0.5936929584,
0.219917506,
0.0053996244,
0.6724919677,
0.2739147246,
-0.8069556952,
-0.0259160213,
-0.7876511812,
0.4642536342,
-0.7782462239,
0.3082775474,
0.4387927651,
0.2034723908,
-0.0342611112,
-0.8764422536,
-0.4336701334,
-0.1255436838,
0.0154596129,
0.0914200097,
-0.116222024,
0.3708319068,
-0.0260192491,
0.1504177153,
-0.5403588414,
-0.1305718124,
-0.0597509742,
-0.1109563634,
0.3006539643,
0.3403581977,
0.4866533279,
-0.4126397967,
-0.0698222071,
-0.2782928646,
-0.3555023074,
-0.2233667076,
0.2964892983,
0.002365248,
-0.2141222209,
0.5695828199,
-0.0209428538,
0.5903850198,
0.0165019743,
-0.3799198568,
0.4371029735,
-0.2993629575,
-0.3706951737,
-0.0749415159,
0.8111829758,
0.1361211985,
-0.178002283,
-0.4859965146,
-0.339060992,
0.1521972865,
0.5788101554,
-0.4486754239,
0.2019607127,
0.4346960485,
-0.3128816783,
-0.4943509698,
-0.0566983745,
-0.425975889,
0.151028946,
0.1150512695,
0.3011377454,
-0.4335294068,
-0.2806920111,
-0.0892877132,
-0.2012605518,
0.272270143,
0.0980879217,
-0.5977229476,
0.5316018462,
0.6526106596,
0.9505248666,
-0.5198732018,
-0.6180068851,
-0.3178910315,
0.5726569295,
-0.4756346047,
0.7179026604,
-0.6285088658,
-0.5115784407,
0.2431153357,
0.0876388922,
-0.4110732675,
-0.5931892991,
0.516371429,
-0.7430908084,
-0.2353604585,
0.1158801168,
-0.3109950423,
0.0149749154,
0.2955656648,
-0.6660176516,
1.1580227613,
0.2834531665,
-0.3293126523,
0.3345626295,
-0.8113404512,
-0.8336197734,
0.080644317,
0.0445311293,
-0.2985085845,
-0.2337337583,
-0.099992238,
0.4828155339,
-0.0889031291,
0.3073997498,
-0.3998390734,
-0.0310715381,
0.3548644483,
0.038674932,
0.5084645152,
0.4153273404,
-0.7337559462,
0.2115294486,
-0.6754864454,
-0.3437621891,
-0.243567273,
-0.490203619,
-0.1197358742,
0.2796747983,
0.1695130765,
0.3225675225,
-0.0143963164,
-0.558793664,
0.3216222227,
0.0566608645,
0.737210691,
0.0909177214,
0.8040917516,
0.868069768,
-0.0770682245,
0.8261013031,
0.4417221248,
0.1310777217,
0.2056710869,
-0.530305922,
-0.4989313781,
-0.0788030103,
-0.0081700319,
0.5730980039,
-0.8287108541,
0.2365112752,
-0.3095468879,
-0.203928709,
-0.3925569952,
-0.2009630352,
0.5007343888,
0.3743968606,
0.0730807334,
-0.084312968,
-0.1097869352,
-1.0189272165,
-0.2505598962,
-0.5064405799,
-0.2450229824,
-0.0619484782,
0.440362215,
-0.3374049366,
0.4699476063,
-0.3487112224,
-0.2465616912,
-0.2405545712,
0.7543674111,
-0.1347205192,
0.6747527719,
0.5054075122,
-0.6631756425,
-0.1574242115,
0.2381925434,
-0.5192113519,
-0.3128933311,
-0.3670838177,
-0.616661191,
0.0696625188,
0.6253294349,
-0.7339800596,
0.3911162317,
0.399078846,
-0.5223201513,
0.2964769006,
-0.1007864028,
0.4153594375,
-1.2213793993,
0.2654992938,
-0.1635307968,
-0.2936510146,
-0.6340180635,
0.3619101942,
0.2104496658,
-0.2848136127,
-0.5164009333,
0.5072280169,
-0.7678073645,
-0.6328178048,
-0.1668077856,
-0.0375127085,
0.0006363216,
0.8368434906,
0.3246430755,
0.6951648593,
0.4950451255,
-0.6410385966,
-0.1256106943,
0.2489589751,
-0.4424159825,
0.242882207,
-0.8384803534,
-0.1323641539,
0.3233293593,
0.0139073478,
-0.7737687826,
-0.7698844075,
0.3973912597,
-0.5015386939,
0.1799494326,
-0.211898461,
-0.8934643865,
-0.2646472752,
0.2689225376,
0.242927283,
0.7730811834,
0.1243090108,
0.8686705828,
0.4254128337,
0.0988680273,
-0.0450999811,
-0.8868451715,
0.0640170425,
-0.0386359356,
-0.5346379876,
0.7567788363,
0.41130808,
-0.3821312487,
0.169305563,
-0.2513291538,
-0.2932853103,
0.3345335126,
0.4574704766,
0.0463049076,
-0.2255885899,
-0.27573663,
0.3426651061,
0.4668968022,
0.1348159462,
-0.0862730518,
0.0432221889,
0.1189320311,
-0.574732244,
-0.4786784351,
0.3973515332,
1.2936185598,
-0.2484467477,
0.5838637948,
0.5417517424,
-0.5469176173,
-0.1026863009,
-0.0667620152,
-0.0801715478,
-0.3539183438,
0.3639827371,
-0.5297468901,
-0.4976557195,
0.7114235759,
0.1989326179,
0.3769096732,
0.4707272351,
0.7898033857,
-0.0676202998,
1.3159065247,
0.0972332954,
0.3922655284,
0.5771710277,
-0.3991403878,
0.0840362161,
-1.0071629286,
-0.1420888007,
-0.4311414361,
-0.4926970899,
-0.0662306324,
-1.005644083,
0.6375828981,
0.3013499081,
-0.1579193324,
0.452932179,
0.0398919098,
-0.1739858091,
0.6038613915,
0.1856467426,
0.2124371678,
-0.1248140857,
-0.6513780951,
0.3503569067,
-0.7189002633,
-0.73428303,
0.5561353564,
0.4929160476,
0.7188085914,
0.1263179034,
0.47389552,
0.7546166182,
0.3135948777,
-0.7079339027,
0.4701025784,
0.1643321216,
-1.0806545019,
-0.2734955251,
-0.0249154437,
-0.5998196006,
0.206434235,
0.070207797,
-0.5117686391,
0.4086713195,
0.3736541569,
-0.5219295621,
0.2709222436,
-0.6105125546,
1.1224461794,
-0.0236941576,
-0.5465720892,
-0.2909453213,
-0.9140608907,
0.1630243212,
0.1514276564,
0.1219557524,
-0.0743937567,
-0.2636362314,
0.8626729846,
-0.4037987888,
1.2514972687,
-0.2357805967,
0.0852601156,
0.694788456,
0.5012711883,
0.38023296,
-0.285705179,
-0.1101906821,
-0.1080933288,
0.0022821289,
-0.4280451834,
-0.4323683381,
0.2673429549,
-0.9716764092,
-0.4017079771,
-0.1702572405,
-0.4451503754,
-0.3590915799,
0.0353896171,
0.2518500388,
0.4145655334,
-0.3947671354,
-0.0149203734,
0.242401585,
0.3194851875,
0.3618729413,
0.3568606377,
0.1008572206,
-0.3266164958,
0.341540128,
-0.2027218342,
0.4017930627,
0.8219274879,
-0.1246283203,
-0.2068510056,
-0.4519218802,
-0.5053474307,
0.2592686713,
-0.5734433532,
-0.0607727952,
-1.1258995533,
-0.0218222644,
-0.8045216799,
-0.3980749547,
-0.1891099066,
-0.4685673714,
-0.4393065572,
-0.2851094306,
0.0004097468,
0.8707284927,
-0.010818189,
0.7524656653,
-1.0732427835,
0.4408351779,
0.2956816256,
-0.1555576026,
0.2153800279,
-0.5748749375,
-0.4417696595,
0.1546180248,
-0.4224674404,
-1.1658189297,
0.4823980033,
0.3743424118,
0.7234953642,
0.5289952159,
-0.1620237529,
0.5718168616,
-0.417075634,
1.1006416082,
-0.1100764647,
-1.0468784571,
0.2727456093,
-0.6550704837,
0.6328145266,
0.1707830727,
0.3134422302,
-0.6626397371,
-0.715918541,
-0.5395685434,
-0.7405372262,
0.6880987883,
0.3443903923,
-0.5927306414,
-0.4196174443,
0.2913906276,
-0.1100986227,
0.2364850491,
-0.3447664678,
0.2005161941,
0.0675681308,
-0.0103697861,
0.2505388856,
-0.0701287016,
0.0810938254,
-0.0647923574,
0.7260830998,
-0.2106755525,
0.4106541276,
0.4727546275,
-0.498788178,
-0.2509529293,
0.279617995,
0.5060089231,
0.4477551877,
-0.3216089606,
0.2501325905,
-0.4588394761,
-0.4286386073,
0.2420863807,
-0.5034053922,
-0.1475667208,
-0.0297281649,
0.9193793535,
0.9758275747,
0.7965740561,
-0.3453943431,
0.3464644849,
0.3701741099,
-0.5234655738,
-0.1166512594,
0.1209641024,
0.4030435383,
0.450625658,
0.4575524032,
0.1349090487,
0.2189735472,
-0.8331485391,
0.3744405806,
-0.238816753,
-0.466401726,
-0.936894536,
1.166203618,
0.470210582,
-0.3629144132,
0.4575051665,
-0.1581503302,
-0.7651112676,
0.7870718837,
0.4536058307,
1.3401353359,
-0.2654326856,
0.3117862344,
0.3324869275,
0.158156082,
-0.2216863632,
0.3550103009,
-0.4104786515,
-0.5995383263,
-0.5760053992,
-0.8669514656,
-0.3146798313,
-0.3756150603,
-1.0951539278,
-0.339928627,
0.045181375,
-0.5919461846,
0.0586264655,
-0.3794566095,
-0.6473869681,
-0.0424873494,
0.2937934101,
1.064396143,
-1.0998108387,
1.1971709728,
1.2693055868,
-0.3731114566,
-0.3628295362,
0.4011103809,
0.0446385257,
-0.7302394509,
0.9500871301,
-0.4981092811,
-0.2327363789,
0.0383812264,
-0.2357756197,
-0.6215824485,
1.1099156141,
0.0285418648,
-0.2708983719,
-0.7387781143,
-0.036193043,
0.9013410211,
-0.65064013,
-0.4228759408,
0.9162577391,
0.4865632355,
-0.0097905146,
-0.7666153908,
-0.1499999613,
-0.2379318327,
0.1856021434,
0.0665271357,
-0.352063179,
0.6472529769,
-0.1772322655,
-0.4364967346,
0.2001053542,
0.7767096162,
-0.0144850528,
-0.195666045,
0.5419539809,
0.543802917,
0.0199354924,
0.1625535488,
1.1509484053,
-0.6438735127,
0.1267234981,
1.0400217772,
-0.5186687112,
1.0126258135,
0.5379568338,
-0.1795931607,
0.3760060668,
0.8709293008,
0.3985621929,
0.7776249647,
-0.2467752248,
-0.2469849288,
-0.5843083262,
0.0117436517,
0.2355535179,
0.3401086032,
0.5975009203,
-0.4696316719,
-0.2116348743,
0.1366441399,
-0.0519713126,
-0.2999784946,
-0.1756590605,
0.6976751685,
0.0628150254,
-1.1212201118,
0.351192981,
0.2455607802,
0.0859328583,
-0.5664305687,
-0.085567832,
-0.1752168387,
0.021131251,
0.138774991,
-0.9864711761,
0.3451164067,
-0.1157794371,
0.0253763702,
-0.6862769127,
0.536806941,
-0.6808190346,
-0.2594297528,
0.523067832,
0.6435716748,
0.1554091126,
-0.0090801371,
-0.5731630325,
0.078777127,
-0.0883103088,
-0.6697278619,
0.0362310708,
0.5209051371,
-0.2161210328,
0.40732494,
0.2569562197,
0.039864812,
0.6310037374,
0.2281946391,
0.3867420554,
-0.7727416158,
-0.7042554021,
-0.443677932,
0.3132717907,
0.0742869377,
-0.4324006736,
0.4005755484,
0.3255179226,
0.3657772541,
-0.2157826275,
0.6708883643,
-0.2602346539,
0.3526570797,
-0.1595779955,
0.7246562243,
-0.6424509883,
-0.1637798697,
-0.1953337193,
-0.747123301,
-0.2101448625,
0.3043594658,
0.0247063469,
-0.3353786469,
1.0694094896,
0.5686632991,
-0.2446725518,
-0.313895613,
0.5268484354,
0.4106171429,
0.1321633458,
0.2548671961,
0.3804799616,
-0.3235917985,
0.4108045399,
-0.4367794693,
-0.1943834126,
-0.48522982,
-0.5563566089,
-0.8307596445,
-0.9561042786,
-0.4689593613,
-0.2256934494,
-0.0511482619,
0.7121072412,
0.8778275251,
-0.6066451669,
-0.5109625459,
0.0260211062,
-0.0802982897,
-0.7324209213,
-0.2642745674,
0.2895880342,
-0.1619600803,
-0.8665345311,
0.4692597687,
0.438570708,
0.1888927072,
-0.3840919435,
0.0840847045,
-0.3383721411,
-0.1566536278,
0.7507565618,
0.2501597404,
-0.8129034638,
-0.1829942763,
0.4265371263,
-0.4355290234,
-0.1132789105,
1.2852085829,
-0.3383733332,
0.0567622855,
0.6757134199,
0.7326403856,
0.6047552824,
0.0096492665,
0.9019893408,
-0.8205502629,
-0.0275328718,
0.3763945401,
0.3437788785,
0.1109420434,
-0.3438169062,
0.5080954432,
0.367184639,
-0.4156611562,
-0.6198815107,
0.2506650984,
-1.1290152073,
-0.328777045,
1.1859520674,
-0.1100671664,
-0.9700146914,
-0.2546951473,
0.3493182361,
0.565341115,
-0.4521805346,
0.4249321818,
0.7911085486,
-0.3837218881,
0.0577184483,
-0.4583587646,
0.2862175405,
0.1239178628,
-0.6710327864,
0.1340141743,
0.6297726631,
0.0566493273,
0.2242364883,
0.6063643694,
-0.3369464874,
0.3855195642,
0.4100615978,
0.5094642043,
0.250870198,
-0.4226636291,
0.07392551,
0.264662385,
0.0585201904,
-0.3193013966
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03098v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03098v1
|
FairMonitor: A Dual-framework for Detecting Stereotypes and Biases in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T01:23:07 | 2024-05-06T01:23:07 |
Yanhong Bai, Jiabao Zhao, Jinxin Shi, Zhentao Xie, Xingjiao Wu, Liang He
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Detecting stereotypes and biases in Large Language Models (LLMs) is crucial
for enhancing fairness and reducing adverse impacts on individuals or groups
when these models are applied. Traditional methods, which rely on embedding
spaces or are based on probability metrics, fall short in revealing the nuanced
and implicit biases present in various contexts. To address this challenge, we
propose the FairMonitor framework and adopt a static-dynamic detection method
for a comprehensive evaluation of stereotypes and biases in LLMs. The static
component consists of a direct inquiry test, an implicit association test, and
an unknown situation test, including 10,262 open-ended questions with 9
sensitive factors and 26 educational scenarios. And it is effective for
evaluating both explicit and implicit biases. Moreover, we utilize the
multi-agent system to construst the dynamic scenarios for detecting subtle
biases in more complex and realistic setting. This component detects the biases
based on the interaction behaviors of LLMs across 600 varied educational
scenarios. The experimental results show that the cooperation of static and
dynamic methods can detect more stereotypes and biased in LLMs.
|
[
-0.5098634362,
-0.953091085,
0.6430852413,
0.0903590545,
0.1994641125,
0.1342073083,
-0.438165158,
-0.2290664613,
-0.0301698707,
0.2710268497,
-0.5065457225,
-0.7437926531,
-0.5569522977,
-0.0147626512,
-0.1548479497,
0.9185999632,
-0.0659555048,
0.2768537104,
-0.3085009456,
-0.1938601881,
-0.5875784159,
-0.3826821744,
-0.7047179937,
-0.2110843509,
0.1835307479,
0.3495075405,
0.5704858303,
0.1965361238,
0.3558287024,
0.3785639107,
-0.250842005,
0.1854421794,
-0.4324736297,
0.4750800133,
-0.3525318801,
-0.5576713085,
-0.3763816357,
0.3159666955,
0.6111204028,
0.494817555,
0.0067206253,
0.5321005583,
0.0721077397,
0.2785957456,
-0.7915024161,
0.4477985799,
-0.5418841243,
0.3056071103,
-0.3435400128,
0.0054131551,
-0.1628028303,
-0.3399270773,
-0.2817565799,
-0.3579359353,
0.2246558517,
-0.009198661,
0.428058058,
0.1607060581,
-0.8750540018,
-0.1765148342,
-0.3718679547,
1.0745784044,
-0.5734364986,
0.3427925706,
-0.0038667193,
0.6455757618,
-0.3164931238,
-0.2499094158,
-0.665035367,
-0.2773505449,
0.0109726032,
-0.0064002872,
0.0823488459,
0.0586318672,
0.4044412374,
0.1191166192,
-0.3781319261,
0.1913389266,
0.0589643121,
-0.3147892654,
0.4936266243,
0.1624640226,
0.4793376029,
-0.265817374,
-0.2008318305,
-0.0883910954,
-0.2873842716,
0.1234896407,
0.7067275643,
0.3140552044,
-0.2616617084,
0.2356871367,
-0.0434073061,
0.3576371968,
0.1271148622,
-0.409170419,
0.5348568559,
-0.2246893793,
0.1288618892,
0.2350787371,
0.4705904126,
0.6150351763,
0.6055564284,
0.1110038236,
-0.5977419615,
0.511372447,
-0.2337424606,
-0.6253755689,
0.1797338724,
0.0719614178,
-0.5254284739,
-0.6125873327,
-0.1330798715,
-1.3130996227,
-0.762747407,
-0.3301236033,
0.0793352127,
0.0654368103,
-0.5517271757,
0.1819494069,
-0.1383139789,
-0.0390246585,
0.3757924438,
-0.4295223355,
0.3355607092,
0.6919506788,
0.6696407199,
-0.1085947752,
-0.0001637594,
-0.9062210917,
-0.0124906357,
0.0285718907,
0.6472450495,
-0.6867011786,
-0.0237180833,
0.3567593694,
-0.1101722568,
0.1745071411,
-0.5866312385,
0.6689541936,
-0.3919970393,
0.2775515616,
-0.2375133634,
-0.3663283885,
-0.0254048202,
0.5349577665,
-0.6594934464,
1.0759557486,
-0.0120504349,
-0.9729400277,
0.4950205982,
-0.5162407756,
-0.1585003287,
-0.3422308564,
-0.6288257837,
-0.2197870314,
0.0792704597,
0.3238933682,
0.3862336576,
-0.3205721378,
0.9193381071,
-0.6499369144,
-0.5885286331,
0.2769538462,
-0.858656168,
0.8869668841,
0.0791723952,
-0.6457920671,
0.0114584733,
-0.7142910957,
-0.3935914934,
0.247820586,
-0.2735197246,
-0.5154310465,
0.1188841239,
0.0629517213,
0.5097463131,
0.2681251168,
-0.6076824069,
-0.0930640101,
-0.0953057408,
-0.3232652545,
1.189868331,
-0.266569376,
0.3876588643,
-0.2144409418,
0.6945639253,
0.2522889674,
0.1870225668,
0.2220167816,
-0.1666832417,
-0.7289461493,
-0.5286212564,
-0.1699530482,
0.5999091864,
-0.4730084538,
0.3924853206,
-0.1452044249,
0.1547130495,
-0.4314290285,
0.3239734173,
0.4698174894,
0.363568157,
0.0814389884,
-0.1457518488,
-0.4421391785,
-0.8108320236,
-0.6783204675,
0.0168045294,
0.0708217844,
0.2383529544,
0.4430787861,
-0.1407087296,
0.8553823233,
-0.3660555482,
-0.3231495023,
-0.0298379567,
-0.1317274272,
0.3694273531,
0.2070835084,
1.0023635626,
-0.7249478698,
-0.3552082181,
-0.450245291,
-0.9072232246,
-0.6053650379,
0.3356869817,
-0.0350413062,
0.0512320548,
0.6337381601,
-0.3569665253,
0.2509374917,
0.603207469,
-0.6609439254,
0.5609341264,
0.2792391181,
0.2368282527,
-0.6799963713,
-0.1767550856,
0.3495750129,
-0.447444737,
-0.4391061664,
0.0393677913,
-0.252158463,
0.1329570115,
-0.3799889982,
0.9777424932,
-0.4038063288,
0.1091010869,
-0.1420126706,
0.5152628422,
-0.0199074894,
0.2529523969,
-0.348770082,
0.7533354759,
0.473317951,
-0.2768945396,
0.4046457708,
-0.1317606419,
-0.5591272712,
0.8288434148,
-0.350146383,
-0.0249059331,
-0.5385575891,
0.4340405762,
-0.8599354625,
-0.0462325886,
0.3958560824,
-0.2014755905,
0.1497290432,
-0.2173198164,
-0.6019901633,
-0.2982741892,
-0.73643893,
0.534313798,
0.2888203561,
-0.7167087197,
0.5468816161,
0.6955381036,
-0.1599422544,
-0.8585096598,
-0.3531216681,
-0.1886822432,
-0.344492048,
-0.6171953082,
-0.2288515717,
-0.014942877,
-0.9305653572,
-0.0952313542,
-0.3217445016,
0.0462276191,
0.311452359,
0.1243016943,
0.2801129818,
-0.1995760351,
0.1567996144,
0.2337211818,
0.1058060676,
0.1420720965,
-0.1513464898,
0.6601356268,
-0.3480349183,
-0.3497960567,
-0.2790831029,
0.1366738528,
0.6946689487,
-0.1857538074,
0.7242462039,
0.7815112472,
-0.2803692222,
-0.48982656,
-0.7640321851,
-0.3101384044,
-0.5508279204,
0.616240859,
-0.2751558721,
-0.9417513013,
0.5659668446,
0.0132976528,
-0.0026454725,
0.0285659209,
0.4900754988,
0.305695504,
1.3467358351,
0.6236099601,
-0.2000064552,
0.4977662563,
0.160722062,
0.3685735762,
-0.424826324,
-0.2651214004,
-0.4929628968,
-0.3169533908,
-0.6604353189,
-0.5457374454,
0.4422800541,
-0.1402614117,
-0.5035273433,
-0.4997288883,
-0.3069725335,
0.4262355864,
0.3344374597,
-0.0849956274,
0.4455981553,
0.0374841318,
-0.3697037697,
-0.1320612282,
-0.2023764551,
-0.8533005118,
0.9493367672,
0.550232172,
0.6088514924,
0.4193409085,
0.5408635139,
0.3605433702,
0.6533970833,
-0.7200241685,
0.733420074,
-0.2933661938,
-0.8820175529,
-0.0005927643,
-0.6383756399,
-0.3456403315,
0.4679649174,
-0.3021342754,
-0.8089228868,
0.2975723743,
0.3066472411,
0.1183260083,
0.3925158679,
-0.357891649,
0.8004799485,
-0.2557170093,
-0.4091043174,
-0.1135615706,
-0.3152305186,
0.7799056768,
-0.2588594854,
0.7729038596,
-0.6289171576,
0.0397968441,
0.6893042922,
-0.02165341,
0.9253211021,
-0.5701725483,
-0.3172607422,
0.0914254934,
0.2167908102,
0.4482821822,
0.278321296,
-0.4376934767,
0.0601922907,
-0.1142570525,
-0.1903449446,
-0.5159181356,
0.7471107244,
-0.6755841374,
-0.6160518527,
-0.6508252621,
-0.6963427067,
-0.3704808354,
0.2049890161,
-0.3249245882,
0.2980209589,
-0.2914913595,
-0.1853529811,
0.617018044,
-0.6243608594,
-0.1095454395,
0.7357116342,
-0.4747537076,
0.1306495517,
0.5250154138,
-0.2275995016,
0.0309740044,
-0.0285574608,
0.3110951781,
-0.1324236989,
-0.1699246615,
-0.0248674899,
0.3190556467,
-0.706035316,
-0.1555123031,
-0.6262446046,
0.130128786,
-0.659679234,
-0.0131414607,
-0.363800317,
-0.0496706404,
0.110996969,
-0.1819835007,
0.1971019953,
0.3757325411,
-0.2490436733,
0.164760828,
-0.3255084753,
0.3137429059,
0.2869376242,
0.2878620028,
0.0570473038,
-0.4994551539,
0.2320406288,
0.010756786,
-0.079871051,
-0.701535821,
0.2303513885,
0.0979167968,
0.6842029691,
0.7040222287,
0.1210425794,
0.0285299625,
-0.4851137102,
0.4650758803,
0.1644907743,
-0.95011729,
0.236988768,
-0.3443484306,
-0.1138801575,
0.6849261522,
0.0929240733,
-0.5666826367,
-0.8306025863,
-0.1166508496,
-0.6052676439,
0.8022356629,
-0.2031863183,
0.2487390935,
-0.1788457632,
0.1252516508,
-0.0609376095,
0.3913154006,
-0.7476571798,
-0.4658141434,
-0.0426281802,
-0.6336629987,
-0.15399234,
-0.2932865918,
-0.3139185607,
-0.1090886295,
0.4760019779,
-0.0354662053,
0.0039389255,
-0.3721547425,
-0.0818478912,
0.1363866478,
0.5424668193,
0.1478057951,
0.2420522273,
-0.5463038087,
0.4749170542,
0.1150837243,
-0.4561000764,
0.300483793,
0.2181120813,
-0.205000177,
0.1286259294,
0.1700262874,
0.5142104626,
0.1331587285,
-0.9100195169,
1.0407297611,
-0.165848121,
0.2379068732,
-0.3244925737,
0.1506275088,
-0.2579800487,
0.4430156946,
-0.1109810323,
-0.0908929855,
0.3188013136,
-0.8805838823,
0.1853522062,
0.5232546926,
-0.4408865869,
-0.2821629047,
0.5046519637,
0.4021276236,
0.0854967758,
0.4019007683,
-0.356729269,
-0.803575933,
0.9010173082,
0.5775929689,
0.6166589856,
-0.2476207614,
0.4332945049,
0.0727410093,
0.3631406724,
-0.2517546117,
0.2522925436,
0.1586071402,
-1.2078369856,
-0.0707048327,
-0.7365432382,
0.0042289509,
0.1495375484,
-0.617423594,
0.4181149006,
-0.3544478118,
-0.2880022824,
-0.0924489051,
0.0844186321,
-0.9338845611,
0.0193924531,
0.364536047,
0.8654641509,
-1.1951801777,
0.3812324703,
0.8451641798,
-0.1714844108,
-0.5838886499,
0.1763711274,
0.769705832,
-0.831467092,
0.9805967808,
0.4436236322,
-0.5037325621,
-0.4011416137,
-0.4106405675,
-0.4591893554,
0.6765786409,
0.6167716384,
-0.6675902605,
0.1146391481,
-0.1271475405,
0.49733302,
-0.1978212446,
0.413079232,
0.6850040555,
0.7833734751,
-0.4362080693,
-0.8305636048,
0.1683478951,
-0.2859890461,
-0.2799763978,
0.1143698171,
-0.68449229,
0.9110735059,
0.1476812512,
-0.1706194282,
-0.2991632521,
0.4060041606,
0.530315578,
0.6577692628,
0.8795017004,
0.1706514508,
0.9680888653,
0.0430173017,
0.7595642805,
-0.3341730237,
0.4391989112,
0.9221068621,
-0.6011939049,
0.1721513122,
0.3440576792,
0.0307956412,
0.4531103671,
0.1748378426,
0.0854471996,
0.4040066898,
0.5757368803,
-0.7447016239,
-0.3295145929,
-0.5385026932,
-0.2859095633,
0.4634114206,
0.4317252934,
-0.0858343542,
-0.3485714793,
0.1715555191,
0.6055984497,
0.4611752629,
-0.3291123807,
0.1375412792,
0.1920998693,
-0.3961781859,
-0.0294732805,
0.3334183693,
1.2757991552,
-0.3070790172,
0.0792853385,
-0.4633494914,
0.4867510498,
-0.0267825536,
-0.6419435143,
-0.1701906323,
0.2598595321,
-0.2007822394,
-0.1135549769,
0.8297622204,
-0.5215809941,
-0.4475160241,
0.6648174524,
0.6439755559,
-0.021136729,
0.2007430494,
-0.5857267976,
0.1548824161,
-0.1814454794,
-0.2381856889,
0.3504447043,
0.542814672,
-0.2713171542,
0.590331018,
0.299374491,
0.1202483699,
0.0608070157,
0.4434464276,
0.7191338539,
-0.2533428073,
-0.3518924415,
-0.6019096971,
0.0942769125,
-0.3192276061,
-0.0357979164,
0.8426074386,
0.3479098976,
0.7732490897,
0.0605719686,
0.8071992993,
0.2240912616,
0.4774585366,
-0.3988066614,
0.5384569168,
-0.7740049362,
0.508898437,
-0.4482250512,
-0.952131927,
-0.2372840047,
0.7730221152,
-0.4493202567,
0.3376756608,
0.499022007,
0.8729876876,
-0.3768832684,
-0.1661121845,
0.0604574867,
0.3190921545,
0.5203313828,
0.3436065316,
0.9382180572,
0.0464798883,
0.3507950902,
0.1417425573,
-0.5400782228,
-0.188765794,
-0.7697471976,
-1.2355577946,
0.0845248103,
-0.2439014614,
-0.4431009889,
0.4089074135,
1.1332330704,
0.3110735714,
-0.8262159228,
-0.2598737776,
0.4051642418,
0.3955976069,
0.056738846,
-0.3689101934,
0.2249783725,
-0.3417644501,
-0.9553723931,
0.2514047921,
0.1233695298,
-0.3017528653,
-0.3390007019,
0.1168693602,
-0.0123701366,
0.2654158175,
0.5409634709,
-0.072507605,
-0.268858552,
-0.6092776656,
-0.3320167959,
-0.2085119933,
-0.3299599886,
0.6893995404,
-0.6153331995,
0.3544379473,
0.4640646577,
0.3223751783,
-0.0218126588,
-0.270332098,
0.4998700619,
-0.8686082363,
0.576654017,
0.1637598574,
0.3685717881,
0.2714488506,
-0.2460510731,
0.2108561397,
0.3418949246,
-0.3326483071,
-1.1415935755,
0.3039202094,
-0.7243005633,
-0.2327443361,
1.2356294394,
-0.0096446956,
0.0925318301,
-0.3656127155,
0.07060761,
0.3415947258,
-0.6046894193,
0.7739922404,
0.5578927994,
0.3059025705,
0.2524921596,
-1.0115625858,
0.3576809764,
0.3518127203,
-0.6484476328,
-0.171827063,
0.7192969322,
0.5894301534,
-0.0021294577,
0.683808744,
-0.2446445674,
-0.0562681369,
-0.2674285173,
0.0596829355,
0.0282412004,
-0.2892206013,
-0.3106872141,
0.0242273621,
-0.1444841772,
0.0300169159
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03097v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03097v1
|
To Each (Textual Sequence) Its Own: Improving Memorized-Data Unlearning in Large Language Models
| 2024-05-06T01:21:50 | 2024-05-06T01:21:50 |
George-Octavian Barbulescu, Peter Triantafillou
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
LLMs have been found to memorize training textual sequences and regurgitate
verbatim said sequences during text generation time. This fact is known to be
the cause of privacy and related (e.g., copyright) problems. Unlearning in LLMs
then takes the form of devising new algorithms that will properly deal with
these side-effects of memorized data, while not hurting the model's utility. We
offer a fresh perspective towards this goal, namely, that each textual sequence
to be forgotten should be treated differently when being unlearned based on its
degree of memorization within the LLM. We contribute a new metric for measuring
unlearning quality, an adversarial attack showing that SOTA algorithms lacking
this perspective fail for privacy, and two new unlearning methods based on
Gradient Ascent and Task Arithmetic, respectively. A comprehensive performance
evaluation across an extensive suite of NLP tasks then mapped the solution
space, identifying the best solutions under different scales in model
capacities and forget set sizes and quantified the gains of the new approaches.
|
[
0.0606649108,
-0.5369293094,
0.3918571472,
-0.0134494072,
-0.2378856242,
0.2468214184,
-0.2338885218,
-0.118769899,
-0.0476461649,
0.7669767141,
-0.452681452,
-0.6549283862,
-0.6888400912,
-0.0598759279,
-0.7187567949,
1.1830532551,
0.2229071558,
0.2005936354,
-0.3189472556,
-0.2060358226,
-0.2770034969,
-0.7992979884,
-0.5218014717,
-0.3828388155,
0.5199061632,
0.4780446291,
0.552580595,
0.8553799987,
0.443638891,
0.3554991484,
-0.3561246693,
0.2485528737,
-0.7653790712,
0.1170360222,
-0.2241461426,
-0.5447983146,
-0.4063032269,
-0.2575053275,
0.9356418252,
0.7087203264,
-0.2806489766,
0.3060143888,
0.3191933632,
0.9748734236,
-0.6269180775,
-0.1061795428,
-0.5412277579,
0.1271476001,
-0.1642436385,
-0.4013394415,
-0.527130723,
-0.2805785835,
0.016674839,
-0.5011458993,
0.3106746078,
-0.1081509069,
0.444506675,
0.3432697952,
-0.1912920922,
-0.3692452312,
-0.708214283,
0.8963075876,
-0.7792947292,
0.303306818,
0.2504601479,
-0.0906700715,
-0.3403457105,
-0.8377877474,
-0.1349077672,
0.1828379035,
0.1624468565,
0.129371047,
-0.1334564686,
-0.1004279032,
0.1840025336,
0.4939813316,
-0.4545467496,
0.3624370396,
-0.3812410831,
-0.1601776183,
0.8693688512,
0.2359319031,
0.1339503527,
0.0051804157,
-0.3405421376,
0.0644958243,
-1.0347493887,
0.0401390344,
0.5370970368,
0.1911303997,
0.2407925129,
0.3894461691,
-0.0384873413,
0.2462436408,
-0.2210191488,
-0.1188197434,
0.2308520824,
-0.0113235321,
-0.282958895,
-0.0648409948,
0.9291057587,
0.0635034293,
0.3166308999,
-0.5236395597,
-0.229277283,
-0.3869380355,
0.3217555881,
-0.4680429399,
-0.2784339786,
0.1310890615,
-0.5741589665,
-0.0770081133,
-0.0172271617,
-0.8837367892,
-0.6351600289,
-0.4829622507,
0.4911383986,
-0.521263361,
0.0142176421,
0.2269799858,
-0.025510639,
-0.2490156889,
0.25283283,
-0.9445644021,
0.3517299592,
0.6846931577,
0.5910180807,
-0.2006524801,
-0.5465630889,
-0.3549228609,
0.0413771085,
-0.3521411419,
0.4440968633,
-0.3604303896,
-0.5712260008,
0.045170933,
-0.0839156806,
-0.030197667,
-0.64837116,
0.3061973751,
-0.5365818143,
0.4253780246,
-0.4137861431,
-1.0034697056,
-0.3298623562,
-0.1076088101,
-0.6123910546,
0.8663423657,
-0.2504317164,
-0.6995850801,
0.0763271302,
-0.5437886715,
-0.3006908894,
-0.010549468,
-0.012104799,
-0.5812234282,
0.4069779217,
0.0382027254,
0.6270620823,
-0.2846242785,
0.3360008597,
-0.0662089139,
-0.3528336585,
0.4245567918,
-0.4955124855,
0.8167013526,
0.2022700012,
-0.1489678025,
0.1088804156,
-0.9098787904,
0.0913597345,
0.239580363,
-0.5648216009,
-0.3043252826,
0.0844997838,
-0.3220733702,
-0.0605327114,
0.4289503992,
-0.3880356848,
-0.0175888315,
-0.5302317142,
0.5075377822,
0.9884718657,
0.070773229,
0.7586622238,
-0.4962323308,
0.1901374012,
0.0046865516,
0.1820127964,
-0.4731211066,
-0.3171062768,
-0.7392809987,
-0.1527031809,
0.3010783792,
0.513551414,
-0.2653945982,
0.3104826212,
-0.2177479863,
-0.4261681437,
-0.4654955566,
0.5787844658,
0.719779551,
0.1595461816,
0.2327600569,
-0.584972918,
-0.481323123,
-0.4850335121,
-0.5394170284,
0.0047374601,
-0.0287376959,
-0.0273197759,
0.5076423883,
-0.1610552818,
0.7196335196,
-0.2646145225,
-0.4155139029,
-0.0294925477,
0.1342576742,
-0.0766066387,
0.3346675336,
0.0589144193,
-0.6222125888,
-0.0735194907,
-0.2177040428,
-1.0491997004,
0.2681179345,
-0.0750773028,
0.1296653003,
0.3832186162,
0.6124919653,
-0.3324846029,
0.3690429032,
0.330791086,
-0.0990479141,
0.2677708864,
-0.4695076644,
-0.1327602565,
-1.050804019,
-0.1114500761,
-0.4278290272,
-0.0978479013,
-0.7518178225,
0.1190056577,
0.1230257601,
0.1100696251,
-0.6606479287,
0.4212112427,
-0.6199532151,
-0.2745699883,
-0.2400925756,
0.0953683481,
-0.0720555708,
0.6684411168,
-0.3547691405,
0.7369679809,
0.3389669359,
-0.7899615169,
0.2679181099,
0.3075709343,
-0.2788447738,
0.0704466999,
-0.2349618673,
0.3394550979,
-0.4813043177,
-0.1181808636,
-0.8927028179,
0.0640406683,
-0.1905601174,
-0.6165307164,
0.5544299483,
0.1467945725,
-0.5898164511,
-0.0380322672,
-0.380201906,
0.3703882694,
0.5695958138,
-0.6813343763,
0.3943089843,
0.4917720854,
-0.0384365991,
-1.0410863161,
-0.4906175435,
0.211431846,
-0.3940253556,
-0.3432534039,
0.2878699601,
-0.0413752832,
-0.1707594991,
-0.0926226974,
-0.1241682544,
-0.1237544119,
0.2383123338,
0.4667912126,
0.0207839422,
0.0088024558,
0.2893099785,
-0.3321994841,
-0.2091103792,
0.2273530215,
-0.5381986499,
0.6570252776,
-0.071455732,
-0.2964859307,
-0.2934854627,
0.3415904343,
0.3210817277,
-0.2297821939,
0.7431617975,
0.2708438933,
-0.4309307039,
-0.3003033698,
-0.4690847993,
0.0090208342,
-0.4696997106,
0.4546515644,
-0.0064022918,
-0.9598608017,
0.6594392061,
-0.1263794452,
0.4465115666,
0.2849931419,
0.6436877847,
-0.361161679,
0.5918428898,
0.9153100848,
-0.2991954684,
0.4309010208,
-0.3917322755,
0.3398787975,
-0.6742722988,
-0.5011866689,
-0.3955512047,
-0.3182600737,
-0.6324264407,
-0.1841531843,
0.107976146,
0.2748748958,
-0.3591643274,
0.2235699445,
-0.2728369534,
0.6785461903,
0.7205656767,
0.16435799,
0.7000620961,
0.163644433,
0.054256659,
-0.094496645,
-0.6110889912,
-0.7009190321,
1.4924381971,
0.4315980673,
0.7307726145,
0.1756248474,
1.0897693634,
0.1462290287,
0.2954647243,
-0.5553926826,
0.6135355234,
-0.6074252725,
-0.5514766574,
-0.4562756121,
-0.5188332796,
-1.073969841,
0.0064461795,
0.0137841087,
-0.9086862206,
-0.1492521018,
0.1781333089,
-0.3894077539,
0.6249687076,
-0.4403750896,
0.664907217,
-0.1987835914,
-0.3844219148,
-0.1109086871,
-0.6257303953,
0.4279545546,
-0.3714777529,
0.1815243959,
-0.0683857501,
-0.041706495,
1.0242697001,
-0.1977267563,
0.9733820558,
0.0325133763,
-0.2542465031,
0.1619003564,
0.0246913806,
0.2594924867,
-0.070064418,
0.0513995998,
0.3482914865,
-0.1210779846,
-0.3115311861,
-0.5309729576,
0.6400583982,
-0.6897997856,
-0.493399322,
-0.2041553855,
-0.5703296661,
-0.0914165825,
0.2221491337,
0.6982293129,
0.313575536,
-0.4906962514,
0.1485457718,
1.0978629589,
-0.4988034964,
0.7445364594,
0.675889194,
0.0005612856,
-0.2644321024,
0.9005571008,
0.2724470794,
0.2150936574,
0.6627064943,
-0.0411130041,
-0.4532749355,
-0.6711830497,
-0.2406232953,
0.2297932804,
-0.9402401447,
-0.3029654026,
-0.6049099565,
-0.3869358301,
-0.348421067,
0.0735090375,
-0.5063349009,
-0.4620548189,
-0.5473603606,
-0.0786020458,
0.3716529906,
0.8805875182,
-0.1312241554,
0.5024602413,
-0.9479046464,
0.2182555199,
0.0476344936,
0.2525389791,
0.0575136691,
-0.8204739094,
-0.1982205957,
-0.0557812452,
-0.5181558728,
-0.590518415,
0.6237465143,
0.1942606419,
0.4156030715,
0.2329153568,
-0.0781910345,
0.4518528879,
-0.6630762219,
0.537848115,
0.2033472955,
-0.8725571036,
0.3286629617,
-0.2318882346,
0.0286358986,
0.3213088512,
0.2420575172,
-0.5720335841,
-0.4364929795,
-0.9140041471,
-0.9745340943,
0.5053268075,
-0.1027574465,
0.3710727394,
0.1435060799,
0.6237976551,
0.1421062648,
0.4875113666,
-0.601667881,
-0.4865508676,
-0.0272966754,
-0.4504770339,
-0.4615803063,
-0.5111014247,
-0.0643028766,
-0.0180911534,
0.5102775097,
0.1988234371,
0.2788069546,
-0.2020791769,
-0.2776879072,
-0.0095058056,
0.4640294313,
0.2280932963,
0.7305796146,
0.0301503204,
0.0591677949,
0.3649096489,
-0.4653378129,
0.2883775532,
-0.2493114173,
-0.3091259897,
-0.0300186202,
0.3738532662,
0.4463395476,
0.3967694044,
-0.6346459389,
0.5917076468,
0.0885115042,
-0.2965338528,
-0.4736673534,
0.2481102049,
0.1026721224,
0.1240481883,
0.1420156658,
0.0672091469,
0.1399775445,
-0.6042718291,
0.4090520144,
0.2942459583,
-0.2080186307,
-0.177694574,
0.6274077892,
-0.1195595711,
-0.4470818341,
0.6068425179,
-0.0139085762,
-0.4093540013,
0.5069172382,
0.5276879668,
0.8282532692,
-0.5057072043,
0.1227152199,
0.142884329,
0.3053759634,
-0.5440446734,
0.2263901085,
0.1259358525,
-0.6758563519,
-0.4064000547,
-0.4428207874,
-0.3054768443,
0.2946347892,
-0.7794436812,
-0.0818712041,
-0.7897776365,
0.0602864176,
-0.0746585354,
0.0495062433,
-0.6260712743,
0.2901649177,
-0.1710759997,
0.6473895907,
-0.7030339241,
0.7065317035,
0.4371800721,
-0.3556012511,
-0.5778734088,
-0.112602137,
0.2862654328,
-0.9399598241,
0.4949014783,
0.1046833917,
-0.059318386,
0.0985178426,
-0.3371057212,
-0.8986561894,
0.819968462,
0.4116450548,
-0.6983668208,
-0.0415012576,
0.2478332967,
0.5714658499,
-0.0628274754,
-0.1279777437,
0.7477732301,
-0.0589259304,
-0.2046027333,
-0.5539309978,
-0.2506493628,
-0.0964979082,
-0.136278823,
0.4375843108,
-0.5166864991,
0.8264063001,
-0.343888104,
-0.408603847,
0.3309968114,
0.5364915729,
-0.1061797962,
0.5420038104,
0.0814685822,
0.6724224091,
1.104557991,
-0.0251400918,
0.7849609852,
0.1097308099,
0.2037159353,
1.3207373619,
-0.0585973039,
0.8838282824,
0.1749183685,
-0.031784974,
0.0230865516,
0.5374537706,
0.1001556888,
0.5074201226,
0.4383105934,
-0.241927743,
0.1407286227,
0.1167181656,
-0.1052934304,
0.4315913916,
0.3003735244,
-0.4353578985,
-0.18303518,
0.0809605718,
0.1678144336,
0.5328033566,
-0.3068108559,
1.0858920813,
0.2804815471,
-0.468396008,
0.5967611074,
0.1561537981,
0.6407783031,
-0.3561374843,
0.3458225429,
-0.4592704773,
0.5074821711,
-0.301977098,
-0.5740916729,
0.2767741978,
0.1232858598,
-0.3982419074,
-0.387709558,
0.2247819006,
-0.406080842,
-0.3051060438,
0.4201525152,
0.5189509392,
0.3483633995,
-0.0896272883,
-0.5980788469,
-0.2255953103,
0.1226564497,
-0.1712482274,
0.5969949961,
0.6330151558,
-0.055297602,
0.8550757766,
0.5370666981,
-0.0054553319,
0.2597945333,
0.3192411363,
0.7058825493,
-0.9146746993,
-0.3148888946,
-1.0621908903,
0.3557502925,
0.0400107242,
-0.4112783372,
0.8862406611,
0.5497203469,
1.0560212135,
0.265992105,
0.5822153687,
0.6419807673,
0.6932358146,
-0.8495155573,
0.5830370784,
-0.5880946517,
0.6769475341,
-0.1659302562,
-0.8176592588,
-0.3943146765,
0.4028066099,
0.0102875959,
0.0154301571,
0.7608744502,
0.797208786,
0.2177671343,
0.2057876885,
0.428089112,
0.0725303292,
0.2315984964,
0.795607388,
1.135654211,
-0.6299220324,
0.4086997807,
-0.119900994,
-0.1153136641,
0.030303875,
-0.682487309,
-0.8133304715,
-0.7253013253,
-0.2178803086,
-0.1779986918,
0.2579134703,
0.670427382,
0.3062149882,
-0.6431165338,
-0.2814545929,
-0.0734942853,
0.1677874774,
-0.1235409528,
-0.0956746116,
0.3836193979,
-0.5360842347,
-0.5429381132,
0.3807574809,
0.3989097774,
0.1560192406,
-0.2052875459,
-0.1326269805,
0.1583254337,
-0.0221984405,
0.4146350026,
0.4525452852,
-0.5690914392,
0.1582513154,
-0.0063158008,
-0.0877041593,
0.1349641532,
1.0537899733,
-0.4776016176,
0.2332635224,
0.324798584,
0.7930241227,
0.3394592404,
-0.0471438244,
0.4663492143,
-1.1141664982,
0.081651099,
0.2215651274,
0.4229958355,
0.4363454282,
-0.4352018237,
0.3648575842,
-0.0448048823,
-0.6906632185,
-0.9255809784,
0.2166171372,
-0.3361283541,
-0.5965638161,
0.914281249,
-0.3271417618,
-0.2459954023,
-0.1430359632,
0.1336984932,
0.3148587346,
-0.2080415785,
1.0422645807,
0.605956018,
0.3238496482,
-0.1253502369,
-0.5964626074,
0.6776072383,
0.6097733974,
-0.7066701055,
0.4450006187,
0.4816645682,
0.2839545906,
0.0851973519,
0.8224782348,
-0.4570840299,
0.1607356966,
-0.311963737,
-0.044325117,
-0.1018052846,
-0.7133364081,
-0.7054265141,
0.0934330225,
0.057090506,
-0.3420528173
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03085v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03085v1
|
Compressing Long Context for Enhancing RAG with AMR-based Concept Distillation
| 2024-05-06T00:18:43 | 2024-05-06T00:18:43 |
Kaize Shi, Xueyao Sun, Qing Li, Guandong Xu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have made significant strides in information
acquisition. However, their overreliance on potentially flawed parametric
knowledge leads to hallucinations and inaccuracies, particularly when handling
long-tail, domain-specific queries. Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG)
addresses this limitation by incorporating external, non-parametric knowledge.
Nevertheless, the retrieved long-context documents often contain noisy,
irrelevant information alongside vital knowledge, negatively diluting LLMs'
attention. Inspired by the supportive role of essential concepts in
individuals' reading comprehension, we propose a novel concept-based RAG
framework with the Abstract Meaning Representation (AMR)-based concept
distillation algorithm. The proposed algorithm compresses the cluttered raw
retrieved documents into a compact set of crucial concepts distilled from the
informative nodes of AMR by referring to reliable linguistic features. The
concepts explicitly constrain LLMs to focus solely on vital information in the
inference process. We conduct extensive experiments on open-domain
question-answering datasets to empirically evaluate the proposed method's
effectiveness. The results indicate that the concept-based RAG framework
outperforms other baseline methods, particularly as the number of supporting
documents increases, while also exhibiting robustness across various backbone
LLMs. This emphasizes the distilled concepts are informative for augmenting the
RAG process by filtering out interference information. To the best of our
knowledge, this is the first work introducing AMR to enhance the RAG,
presenting a potential solution to augment inference performance with
semantic-based context compression.
|
[
-0.60563308,
-0.787676692,
0.5746266842,
-0.1054668427,
-0.7325587273,
0.321544826,
-0.3199310899,
-0.5731579065,
0.5048416257,
0.515817821,
-0.3365726769,
-0.2690479457,
-0.7475726604,
0.2613251507,
-0.3065929115,
0.9138140678,
-0.0173019823,
-0.3562090397,
-0.3921885788,
-0.1424568892,
-0.4873252809,
-0.4330491722,
-0.5529902577,
-0.5883187056,
0.2859123945,
0.1960958391,
0.3190175295,
0.5293046236,
0.3718252778,
0.3207686543,
-0.4377156496,
0.5468418002,
-0.5006148815,
0.5353153348,
-0.2715196609,
-0.3449314535,
-0.4076943398,
-0.1541698575,
0.4398570359,
0.6336221099,
-0.2572649717,
0.1683054268,
0.3405584395,
0.8899395466,
-0.7994401455,
0.2192973197,
-0.841773808,
-0.2095788717,
-0.1341357529,
-0.5381122231,
-0.3512963653,
0.0546936244,
-0.0234795026,
-0.7000061274,
0.2938215435,
0.1182679459,
0.8556800485,
0.7402020693,
-0.3475739956,
-0.542886734,
-0.7148079872,
0.7393712401,
-0.5001112819,
0.2181101143,
0.5245619416,
0.1702539474,
-0.1734253913,
-0.5443356037,
-0.8639822602,
0.0936170518,
-0.2473617941,
0.1474896222,
-0.0787473843,
0.0319989286,
0.2808946669,
0.3993771076,
-0.1737566143,
-0.2828224599,
-0.5090830326,
0.0032145001,
0.438737154,
-0.1676739156,
-0.1156674325,
-0.4647053778,
-0.4415465295,
-0.1365600526,
-0.4158252478,
-0.1613621712,
0.0534320958,
0.1274110228,
0.1418685913,
0.709407568,
-0.2556433976,
0.82742697,
0.2044134289,
-0.2714826167,
0.4292057455,
-0.2220070213,
-0.0746781081,
0.1906237304,
0.3665808439,
0.2780705094,
0.1045595333,
-0.2216590047,
-0.2643935978,
0.0994077697,
0.4155286252,
-0.6522300243,
0.0459285118,
0.3005192578,
-0.1989949644,
-0.185648486,
0.076741606,
-0.8234106898,
-0.4784851074,
-0.5847907662,
0.1880947202,
-0.4303744733,
-0.2015343457,
0.1673870832,
-0.4003563523,
0.0443203822,
0.3403367698,
-0.5766543746,
0.1942443103,
0.7253991365,
0.8365571499,
-0.2982062697,
0.1843337119,
-0.4976583421,
0.5170315504,
-0.1453084797,
0.8763620853,
-0.5410354137,
-0.440345943,
-0.3562123775,
-0.2604886889,
0.2687986791,
-0.6638798714,
0.7611659169,
-0.771713376,
-0.1531171948,
-0.0217843801,
-0.617284894,
-0.0811702907,
0.3902880251,
-0.7745390534,
0.9399905801,
0.032771267,
-0.9858112335,
0.1895480454,
-0.5649477243,
-0.3738511205,
0.0530103073,
-0.4155530035,
-0.2699558139,
0.3566725254,
0.2367516905,
0.3445530534,
-0.5090891719,
0.1819767058,
-0.1476586759,
-0.2759848535,
0.3591055572,
-0.326402992,
0.3499826491,
0.3115675747,
-0.0430708006,
-0.2889104187,
-0.8052644134,
-0.0129443863,
-0.0298798941,
-0.295165509,
-0.9691126347,
-0.1058761403,
-0.3424837291,
0.1231137142,
0.2717259526,
-0.5992414951,
-0.0843420625,
-0.4427455366,
0.2499764264,
0.5483313203,
0.3619927466,
0.4326986372,
-0.4189643264,
0.4140604734,
0.2733628154,
-0.4981648028,
-0.244623661,
-0.1720375121,
-0.7904054523,
-0.4026115239,
0.3037894964,
0.3309949338,
-1.0902366638,
0.5729207397,
-0.5115959048,
-0.1348960102,
-0.4149184525,
0.1488174796,
0.3989843428,
0.879327774,
0.5815617442,
-0.036113847,
-0.4852562547,
-0.6069010496,
0.0022270666,
-0.116763927,
-0.168241322,
0.3245049119,
0.333106935,
-0.0724992156,
1.0879411697,
-0.840057075,
-0.5247058868,
-0.1330703646,
0.295906812,
0.3119309545,
0.2877110541,
0.0560571589,
-1.19036901,
-0.3758195937,
-0.0824315399,
-0.5836657882,
-0.1748852134,
0.0226839632,
-0.187072143,
0.2133542746,
0.6344726682,
-0.540276289,
0.463332355,
0.2885797322,
-0.3343036473,
0.4368796349,
-0.3730657101,
0.0940737352,
-1.4359693527,
0.2190955281,
-0.0058752685,
-0.1342706084,
-0.3809165061,
0.0935726166,
0.1356340498,
0.1090370566,
-0.1660117805,
0.8031492829,
-0.6212958694,
0.3261324465,
-0.62011379,
0.2197530419,
0.396173507,
0.3743286431,
0.2194009572,
0.6749433279,
-0.0112547604,
-0.7675549388,
0.0957473889,
0.3777086735,
-0.3195987344,
0.5790913701,
-0.5366085768,
0.1361881346,
-0.5118456483,
0.3945288062,
-0.7050703764,
-0.2871399522,
0.053341832,
-0.4316682816,
0.5540575385,
-0.0949237645,
-0.3493265212,
-0.1446007788,
-0.1059339494,
0.2989505231,
0.5515432358,
-0.5121251345,
0.6893830299,
0.5172430277,
-0.1128583476,
-0.9042007327,
-0.6610370278,
0.0698660165,
-0.5253403783,
-0.3870759606,
0.6517727375,
0.0800591931,
-0.3858291507,
0.1744102538,
-0.548151195,
-0.2025287151,
-0.1024688929,
0.0773719102,
0.2617682517,
0.060956385,
0.3027040362,
0.2685500085,
-0.1811567843,
-0.0109804524,
-0.1806908846,
0.3519524038,
0.2934845984,
-0.1124477535,
0.1980673969,
0.3640368879,
0.3864311278,
-0.3107206821,
0.6757888794,
0.3462433517,
-0.302883476,
-0.5577799082,
-0.5961837769,
-0.2059897035,
-0.4902714789,
0.2497856468,
-0.6252209544,
-0.9988199472,
0.4151379764,
-0.3317843378,
-0.0422384553,
0.1742370278,
0.2329047322,
-0.1544135958,
0.3997022212,
0.4148449302,
0.1671592742,
0.3424348831,
-0.3465772569,
0.1282889694,
-1.1696624756,
-0.0531120636,
-0.4732103944,
-0.2838498056,
-0.2808856666,
-1.0811371803,
0.5519939065,
0.3691185415,
0.199856177,
-0.1243853718,
-0.5197613835,
0.6182025671,
0.3112838566,
0.2895227671,
0.6467548609,
0.1931612939,
-0.1642407924,
0.0848043934,
-0.3449623287,
-0.4480506182,
0.9589047432,
0.1776423901,
0.9051686525,
0.225908488,
0.9125439525,
0.2187094688,
0.1185365468,
-0.8704627156,
0.4160573184,
-0.241273582,
-0.5588479042,
-0.3583918512,
-0.4921527505,
-0.7901554108,
0.3435773253,
-0.1934626997,
-0.4986813664,
0.3393290341,
0.1306913793,
-0.2364633828,
0.0573182963,
-0.4529452026,
0.2611606419,
0.2139250934,
-0.383595407,
-0.2611767352,
-0.6353164315,
0.4966379106,
-0.5609773397,
0.2840849757,
-0.0861182511,
-0.3804677129,
0.4176470637,
-0.4037378132,
0.6803854704,
-0.2037496418,
-0.094907701,
0.4865510464,
-0.1884323657,
0.5899569988,
0.0362646319,
-0.262561202,
0.0061668889,
-0.0827588141,
-0.2134316862,
-1.0300221443,
0.4371954203,
-0.3827846944,
-0.7071139216,
-0.4423391819,
-0.504989922,
-0.3295128942,
0.1479385495,
0.220893994,
0.3097521663,
-0.0985215306,
0.3639204502,
0.9706119299,
0.0300701875,
0.2100247294,
0.4608864784,
-0.0066619581,
-0.3347639441,
0.8241310716,
0.0386282615,
0.2811767757,
0.6299192905,
0.1660620719,
-0.524920404,
-0.6574195027,
-0.3417978883,
0.1878893524,
-0.7722744942,
-0.4289647341,
-0.7515596151,
-0.2905331254,
-0.1714450419,
0.0233765393,
-0.0870094076,
-0.4821963906,
-0.2584241927,
0.0582599528,
0.3972288072,
0.4042583704,
-0.0489374399,
0.1508254111,
-0.8502254486,
0.687746346,
0.0100847827,
0.1600620002,
-0.000435111,
-0.5397641063,
-0.3728571832,
0.1448790878,
-0.2024514824,
-0.6450423598,
0.38926211,
0.3558761477,
0.4297465682,
0.2755122483,
0.6680502892,
0.885156095,
-0.6108644605,
0.3543645144,
0.079573229,
-0.6894293427,
0.3802236617,
-0.0921429992,
0.3697391748,
0.6895871162,
0.3042385578,
-0.3288834393,
-0.6081366539,
-0.4908406436,
-1.0011767149,
0.5014617443,
0.095041059,
0.2237940878,
-0.2243865132,
0.5897045732,
0.0532472804,
0.2640920579,
-0.37912637,
-0.2519646287,
-0.0364604183,
-0.2747136652,
-0.2134498209,
-0.3348511755,
-0.0894696787,
-0.0524042882,
0.6961764693,
-0.2435948253,
0.1212983429,
0.4373650551,
-0.1466289759,
0.1285675317,
0.410762459,
0.3477183282,
0.5128029585,
-0.2451740354,
0.3658156395,
-0.0320727974,
-0.6676512957,
0.4114954472,
0.2354927063,
-0.1541632265,
0.066381067,
0.1518045962,
0.6498405933,
0.0462553762,
-0.6875531673,
0.2183156759,
-0.1863634288,
-0.0744712204,
-0.3948220909,
0.2256011516,
0.0771499276,
0.2086015195,
0.6524028778,
0.0531068258,
0.2988244593,
-0.2204313576,
0.3869945705,
0.4626178145,
-0.0780502111,
0.054375466,
0.4203392863,
0.1830901802,
0.1882425994,
0.215803951,
-0.3258625567,
-0.2371885478,
0.3638014793,
0.5271839499,
0.7803401947,
0.0196324363,
0.0308905058,
0.4440326989,
-0.0180052277,
-0.0739809424,
0.1287025958,
-0.4891134202,
-0.8489860892,
-0.7303697467,
-1.1884346008,
-0.2874690294,
0.1703825742,
-0.7926203609,
0.2916496098,
-0.0783382207,
-0.1661865711,
0.0003412976,
0.1131018326,
-0.2028831542,
0.221696347,
0.0077436832,
0.8616095781,
-0.4584253132,
0.9859941006,
0.7196003795,
-0.2639288306,
-0.6073838472,
0.4332610071,
-0.1420436502,
-0.4206236005,
0.6331475973,
-0.032997299,
-0.2751155496,
0.1562924683,
-0.0077503216,
-0.9390123487,
1.0463358164,
0.257617712,
-0.4865488708,
-0.2711693048,
0.0762634948,
0.5402656198,
-0.3387727737,
-0.0798495561,
0.4638340175,
0.3501953781,
0.8503736258,
-0.6359182,
0.1814023405,
-0.3260066807,
0.0448283479,
0.3218161464,
-0.3157499731,
0.4367095232,
-0.0896638185,
-0.3566867113,
-0.0636903569,
0.8095847368,
0.5115917325,
0.3142154515,
0.6020242572,
0.63479954,
0.9043097496,
0.2054776102,
0.8179696202,
-0.4331470132,
0.1101427749,
1.5666429996,
-0.0539117195,
0.9490171671,
0.8230121136,
0.1229244918,
0.3667393923,
0.3363341689,
0.4501612186,
0.6208029389,
0.1848186702,
-0.5341397524,
0.0154268164,
-0.1582798511,
-0.283992976,
0.4843920469,
0.652092576,
-0.3514187932,
-0.2973919213,
0.069485575,
-0.0883148238,
0.2421709597,
-0.1090493575,
1.0715748072,
0.2980073392,
-0.8243053555,
0.9628174305,
-0.0813390315,
0.769045949,
-0.5148822665,
-0.1718256623,
-0.0395083092,
0.1169829518,
-0.059930671,
-0.6784676909,
0.6425930858,
0.0793419778,
-0.443649739,
-0.2710959613,
0.851927042,
-0.5446615815,
-0.4355792403,
0.1589404643,
0.6886290312,
0.1389995068,
-0.1057933122,
-0.4570271969,
0.1309035867,
0.0421420969,
-0.2330732197,
0.2081668079,
0.8022898436,
0.0594178624,
0.3989253342,
0.4669712484,
0.3178489208,
-0.1249172911,
-0.1667358726,
1.0963253975,
-0.5319401622,
-0.5382573009,
-0.7012920976,
0.5341071486,
-0.3360566199,
-0.0224855598,
0.5657918453,
0.4443740845,
0.7300860882,
0.1027054191,
0.8346710205,
-0.184990406,
0.8196128011,
-0.6596528292,
0.7905446887,
-0.6468362212,
0.4491762817,
-0.218791455,
-1.0387836695,
-0.0795764551,
0.538453877,
-0.1862032413,
-0.1040335819,
0.643001616,
0.6398457289,
-0.22864829,
-0.0800644606,
0.3424389064,
0.2003905326,
0.1931413859,
0.1633019,
0.6540058255,
-0.1162356213,
0.3812657595,
-0.2769872844,
-0.3875771165,
-0.0230455492,
-0.9162262082,
-0.8094993234,
-0.7789229155,
-0.2603516281,
-0.4772782028,
-0.0168359876,
0.8011578321,
0.4292570949,
-0.4795275629,
-0.0049199588,
-0.2097602785,
0.1138805747,
0.0760659277,
-0.221262008,
0.3239699602,
-0.7223385572,
-0.8466989994,
0.3529735804,
0.0815316141,
0.0771114677,
-0.1525151581,
-0.0484797135,
-0.1165507212,
0.2383520752,
0.6353257895,
0.0698645338,
-0.555739522,
-0.0084644482,
-0.1767325103,
0.1003067717,
0.0820228532,
0.6819099784,
-0.9621988535,
0.6114450693,
0.4284521937,
0.7212888598,
0.6210010648,
0.3880593181,
0.498170644,
-1.0020500422,
0.3459941447,
0.3610014319,
0.2371155769,
0.2731137574,
-0.4327897131,
0.5844752192,
0.0219935831,
-0.3214175105,
-0.9153932333,
0.1841850281,
-0.8092632294,
-0.5568771958,
1.1760439873,
-0.162223801,
-0.4530507326,
-0.2630577981,
-0.1078747436,
0.2783295512,
-0.4736251831,
0.8705886602,
0.7550180554,
-0.1170890778,
-0.00563577,
-0.5102712512,
0.6141147614,
0.17637676,
-0.7138344049,
0.2726979554,
0.7147064805,
0.052680824,
0.4667246342,
0.5059205294,
-0.1363555491,
-0.0712812692,
-0.0915073529,
-0.1228298768,
-0.2615405023,
-0.186773181,
-0.2969835699,
0.1767323762,
-0.0045110174,
0.014772987
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03084v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03084v1
|
Analyzing Emotional Trends from X platform using SenticNet: A Comparative Analysis with Cryptocurrency Price
| 2024-05-06T00:18:35 | 2024-05-06T00:18:35 |
Moein Shahiki Tash, Zahra Ahani, Olga Kolesnikova, Grigori Sidorov
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
This study delves into the relationship between emotional trends from X
platform data and the market dynamics of well-known cryptocurrencies Cardano,
Binance, Fantom, Matic, and Ripple over the period from October 2022 to March
2023. Leveraging SenticNet, we identified emotions like Fear and Anxiety, Rage
and Anger, Grief and Sadness, Delight and Pleasantness, Enthusiasm and
Eagerness, and Delight and Joy. Following data extraction, we segmented each
month into bi-weekly intervals, replicating this process for price data
obtained from Finance-Yahoo. Consequently, a comparative analysis was
conducted, establishing connections between emotional trends observed across
bi-weekly intervals and cryptocurrency prices, uncovering significant
correlations between emotional sentiments and coin valuations.
|
[
-0.6255760193,
-0.4741138816,
0.2171784937,
-0.0364644155,
-0.3929811418,
0.4628371,
-0.0939637497,
-0.7929626107,
0.9147619009,
0.5160374045,
-0.8529528975,
-0.6072515249,
-0.4377313852,
-0.0034633668,
-0.501224637,
1.1258665323,
0.0482661501,
-0.2062668651,
0.3548498452,
-0.0955553129,
-0.265717715,
-0.6386454701,
-0.703690052,
-0.2155299932,
0.4932668805,
0.4170140624,
0.680036664,
0.3110047877,
0.8869740963,
0.3940376043,
0.085215807,
-0.216845423,
-0.3532747626,
0.3476859629,
0.0818806738,
-0.6703565717,
-0.4923167825,
0.2326011807,
-0.0550664924,
0.2726658583,
-0.0546323657,
0.0333796218,
-0.2526513934,
1.0625505447,
-0.4069028497,
0.4342639744,
-0.5896091461,
0.3906744719,
-0.3974694014,
-0.4298809171,
0.1309900582,
-0.233130157,
0.160352394,
-0.6943889856,
0.0514582954,
0.3767445683,
0.598236084,
-0.0395819098,
-0.0752210692,
-0.8062807918,
-0.1391109675,
0.7689279318,
-0.2900508344,
0.4589756429,
0.2480110377,
0.1967806965,
0.1349362433,
-0.6524846554,
-0.3822160363,
-0.2557594776,
0.2350135595,
0.1365515739,
-0.8216125965,
-0.1798051298,
0.0913234204,
0.3855722845,
-0.5580604672,
-0.3524356484,
-0.1934773326,
-0.11466939,
0.7238920331,
0.5000494719,
0.5943590403,
-0.3752723038,
-0.4244506061,
-0.3630213141,
-0.5870099664,
0.2116495967,
0.9281993508,
0.2944766581,
-0.4286146462,
0.5012447834,
-0.0284062587,
0.1537270844,
0.2013934702,
0.1998184174,
0.6080456972,
-0.121521689,
-0.0905325413,
0.5971259475,
1.1652501822,
0.6863284111,
0.2056307942,
0.0124987774,
-0.3009574413,
0.2325848788,
0.2791191638,
-0.7886404395,
-0.0981286094,
0.5384171009,
-1.1132639647,
-0.697639823,
0.1524818391,
-1.3766636848,
-0.4716229737,
-0.318090409,
0.0431541838,
-0.0721395388,
-0.6938927174,
0.1444756389,
-0.3673330545,
-0.1278773993,
0.0170343071,
-0.8531609774,
0.60348773,
1.20588696,
1.1208022833,
-0.1999809146,
0.0872980133,
-0.0579615533,
-0.7659274936,
-0.7433523536,
0.5644634962,
-0.3901930451,
-0.4182701409,
-0.0365357026,
0.0271635298,
0.2033104151,
-0.5141028166,
0.2826910615,
-0.5262453556,
-0.1045920327,
-0.5030990243,
-0.0921986103,
0.1060122401,
0.640391171,
-0.7623991966,
0.8446543217,
0.1602657139,
-1.2335890532,
0.1831240356,
-0.9289963245,
-0.1380090266,
-0.0131387319,
-0.2547677755,
-0.0532824285,
-0.0637325644,
-0.3412008584,
0.2199798822,
-0.3302101195,
-0.1147334874,
-0.5206515789,
-0.276801616,
1.0609650612,
-0.1547793746,
0.493630141,
0.3918031454,
-0.8869181275,
0.3298513293,
-0.7962195277,
-0.3093161583,
-0.3088935316,
0.6049544811,
-0.4506966174,
0.1351632476,
0.2716166973,
0.4621882141,
0.2544451356,
-0.775333941,
0.175587371,
-0.7125151753,
0.7346878648,
0.8892877698,
0.1482126117,
0.1414890289,
-0.0264315866,
0.8605088592,
0.1134554446,
0.5700027943,
0.1244276911,
-0.6505226493,
-0.4266906977,
-0.0350243486,
-0.4422265887,
0.5190176368,
-0.0628200695,
0.2085909098,
0.1671515852,
-0.5945988894,
-0.3905655444,
-0.2497060597,
-0.012341843,
0.5086085796,
0.0672191605,
-0.1004002094,
-0.6508063674,
-0.6325361729,
-0.0243593827,
-0.2813673615,
0.3697099686,
0.3674123287,
0.3488662541,
-0.5138543844,
0.6918784976,
-0.4705221951,
0.2598786056,
0.2539308071,
0.6840355396,
0.4202711582,
0.2133974731,
0.4239292443,
-0.8419865966,
-0.4213019609,
0.7146775723,
-0.4283652604,
0.1462598145,
-0.1183739826,
-0.3757555485,
0.2493580133,
0.4652307034,
-0.6813989282,
0.6000643373,
0.4535666704,
-0.7014577389,
0.5351625085,
0.0693263263,
0.7708740234,
-0.9186698794,
0.1954024583,
-0.0689853653,
-0.0226951856,
-0.2215572596,
-0.3047992885,
-0.0729846731,
-0.4668913186,
-0.3397679627,
0.1699375659,
-0.265470773,
-0.1642678976,
-0.6150813103,
0.2979750931,
-0.3929659724,
0.0759643838,
0.0777960941,
0.6613517404,
0.9018012881,
-0.198946014,
0.8088469505,
0.1252124459,
-0.2641202509,
0.3435359299,
-0.6582185626,
0.105093129,
0.3301651776,
-0.3161154091,
-1.0601547956,
0.3002824783,
0.838223815,
-0.6858644485,
-0.0750372037,
0.3707809448,
-0.0635582358,
-0.6196806431,
-0.6077091694,
0.0892779678,
0.2731693685,
-0.1300415695,
0.5866467953,
0.1301597953,
-0.2721130848,
-1.044870615,
-0.782816112,
0.4006319046,
-0.4559951723,
-0.4551666677,
0.2976038754,
-0.5704797506,
-0.7909467816,
-0.0295055509,
0.0296773333,
0.3397506475,
0.0911545828,
0.9051020145,
0.4672278464,
-0.0542536192,
-0.0218842402,
-0.2148454338,
-0.5895385742,
0.7513506413,
-0.3164773881,
0.620049417,
-0.3032239974,
0.0423752815,
-0.5062094927,
0.3792410195,
0.719522357,
-0.0717734322,
0.5837619305,
0.3930176198,
-0.3622210026,
-0.0047902758,
-0.2624647617,
-0.1164129674,
-0.5325248837,
0.1682325453,
-0.2959835827,
-0.7095201015,
1.124399662,
0.2714698911,
-0.2455169708,
0.5270588398,
0.7767800689,
-0.0231730435,
1.1547296047,
0.5479081273,
-0.2791836858,
0.508269012,
-0.192679435,
0.2170978338,
-0.4264692366,
-0.4837599397,
-0.4640441835,
-0.6139881015,
-1.1729662418,
-0.0011354737,
-0.1322408319,
-0.4674313664,
-0.3239763379,
0.223787576,
-0.6132269502,
-0.081989795,
0.3137023449,
0.2167753428,
-0.0410702638,
-0.1508397162,
0.1798650324,
-0.126629442,
-0.0213010591,
-0.163495943,
1.1784021854,
0.166271612,
0.5227923393,
-0.2511193454,
0.4404794872,
0.6735162735,
0.5665616989,
-0.9950951338,
0.2413657755,
0.1111468226,
-0.641151607,
0.0094367499,
-0.4733919799,
-1.1828277111,
-0.3264722824,
-0.2356410176,
-0.7958423495,
0.7886253595,
-0.2616954148,
-0.2251320779,
0.2541283369,
-0.0270940792,
0.9030526876,
-0.260346204,
-0.2908569276,
-0.4100097418,
-0.6917502284,
0.2039701045,
-0.2708948553,
0.3290973604,
-0.2996950746,
-0.4484198391,
0.9242293239,
-0.6654300094,
0.5258306861,
0.1738702357,
0.0243703723,
0.5574035048,
-0.2163482457,
0.3123171926,
0.1161214188,
-0.1231186241,
0.1003211811,
-0.011005572,
-0.2422395647,
-0.5062245727,
1.084286809,
-1.1207802296,
0.1462314129,
-0.3213451207,
-0.3959723115,
0.0764334351,
0.0215910468,
0.5054228902,
0.4469284117,
-0.3480168879,
-0.0683397874,
0.6004875898,
0.0368052535,
0.7144432664,
0.181855008,
-0.1944801807,
-0.989192903,
0.8951393962,
-0.0436996296,
-0.1332938373,
0.4511823058,
0.5582945347,
-0.166334793,
-0.1545243114,
0.0286208671,
0.1390705705,
-0.5270072818,
-0.3293576241,
-0.8357475996,
0.460442096,
-0.4823631048,
-0.2645266056,
-0.8333963156,
-0.0249776561,
-0.4356282055,
-0.2954881489,
0.6552761197,
0.7037215829,
-0.2277177721,
0.3617675602,
-0.7652882934,
0.0439455025,
-0.0168987624,
0.3612383306,
-0.0476449467,
0.0443375409,
-0.1745715439,
-0.0558079407,
-0.058979895,
-1.3370226622,
0.7695227265,
-0.4216099083,
0.2273657024,
1.1646589041,
-0.0262026452,
0.4651550055,
0.3090678155,
0.6697507501,
0.7155841589,
-1.2881373167,
0.6810997128,
-0.4094997048,
-0.2809977233,
0.306111753,
0.6322216988,
-1.0717266798,
0.0020547556,
-0.8854136467,
-0.7601097822,
0.6430835724,
0.155407384,
0.1190512627,
-0.2715008855,
0.6073445082,
0.3665609658,
0.5387378335,
-0.5527863503,
-0.6930648685,
-0.4715695977,
-0.4882977307,
0.0972207636,
-0.1780110002,
0.1032949165,
-0.0044123847,
0.4081197977,
-0.1229417324,
0.3585371375,
0.0437355973,
0.3259537518,
-0.5221924186,
-0.0556803606,
0.2680225372,
0.5629147291,
-0.4798746109,
0.0986255407,
-0.1378973722,
-0.5342655182,
0.0475742854,
0.082650125,
0.1355829239,
-0.0967425704,
0.3242603242,
0.8381943107,
0.4370650351,
-1.0205148458,
0.6115084887,
-0.1774584949,
-0.5675160885,
-0.2960355878,
-0.051984068,
0.0026711305,
0.547794044,
0.293641448,
0.3384572864,
0.6355508566,
-0.8744282126,
0.3298021257,
0.1690018624,
-1.1681113243,
-0.7392806411,
0.5345795751,
0.0941517875,
-0.2330776304,
0.9355536103,
0.0984881073,
-0.6651188731,
0.9634764791,
0.2450700253,
1.0533804893,
-0.1517859846,
0.2155466378,
0.2769021988,
0.2695117593,
0.0094466759,
0.6803125739,
-0.0860490203,
-0.631170392,
-0.1371540278,
0.1018043384,
-0.3275228739,
-0.248116836,
-0.7705768347,
0.3239462376,
-0.5216879249,
-0.6972901225,
-0.0372833647,
0.6015065908,
-0.6128584743,
0.4814713001,
0.5084781647,
0.7900895476,
-0.8515329957,
0.2338129878,
0.6810321808,
-0.2221094519,
-0.5507740378,
-0.5910686255,
-0.0559939481,
-0.623799324,
0.7075445056,
0.2746170759,
-0.2900553942,
-0.4177871644,
-0.6702709198,
-0.6949791312,
0.9466849566,
-0.1652211994,
-0.8790804744,
0.5301569104,
0.2101266682,
0.6052738428,
-0.6366442442,
0.8123241067,
0.3689182103,
0.5911151171,
0.0002845382,
-0.1419387162,
-0.1333206743,
-0.7762519717,
-0.6164294481,
0.73082304,
-0.9433804154,
0.8801485896,
0.1593747437,
-0.1757589281,
-0.2599189878,
0.6520466805,
0.077976279,
0.9296534061,
0.7844887972,
0.4319999516,
0.8920139074,
-0.0433857106,
0.6724633574,
-0.8724450469,
0.4248425066,
0.4547527432,
-0.0610226728,
0.916646421,
0.3049207032,
-0.2512995899,
0.8623179197,
0.9399345517,
0.2345612496,
0.2615714371,
0.2116471529,
-0.0630194247,
-0.2678414583,
0.188278988,
-0.5416221023,
0.3986007273,
0.4230791926,
-0.4068295062,
0.3605911732,
0.2592219114,
0.0805683061,
-0.4240958691,
-0.5201351643,
0.3629386127,
0.0673665553,
-0.3323382437,
-0.2426316887,
-0.2540273666,
0.719281137,
-0.5619559884,
0.2915090621,
-0.4343430996,
0.129154712,
-0.1678914428,
-0.5322512388,
0.409971714,
0.0163218994,
-0.0906174406,
-0.124584578,
0.9049348831,
-0.053423509,
-0.3742381036,
0.6308362484,
0.1684931815,
0.2055793554,
-0.5155795217,
-1.1947407722,
0.3760045171,
0.0017206866,
-0.5877823234,
0.1507420093,
0.6514643431,
0.2187649161,
0.852621913,
0.6863551736,
-0.0690533444,
-0.2187146842,
-0.1107440889,
0.8426063657,
-1.1439551115,
-0.7865285277,
-0.9238286018,
0.3511183262,
-0.223917827,
-0.5808596015,
0.4440144897,
0.5032026768,
0.0885837153,
0.2752185166,
0.4150303006,
0.1192363501,
0.0415458158,
-0.0028885589,
0.7348490357,
-0.6366709471,
0.0382134505,
-0.4171216488,
-0.8027265668,
0.0130974343,
0.4849724472,
-0.2683342397,
-0.2163365185,
0.6052138805,
0.8608140349,
0.2944278717,
0.6355410814,
0.0686853081,
0.0095982682,
0.0837325156,
0.1532164663,
1.1170014143,
-0.3912069201,
0.3739642501,
-0.5900276899,
-0.4980894625,
-0.4807858169,
-0.8641732931,
-0.7121066451,
-0.3061309159,
-0.7769892812,
-0.4535012841,
0.2074077725,
1.0556317568,
0.7018554211,
-0.8236255646,
-0.4577585459,
-0.3551027775,
-0.0340260528,
-0.3795089722,
-0.330780834,
0.4173747897,
-0.0718057752,
-0.539868176,
-0.0221197661,
0.6071796417,
-0.1876567453,
-0.2829687595,
0.0767012239,
0.384139508,
0.3659913242,
0.4429874718,
0.0915366337,
-0.1260615289,
0.0361693501,
0.4133729935,
-0.3226095438,
0.239961639,
1.1282228231,
-0.4271668196,
0.3616376221,
0.8449138403,
0.0811258256,
0.5188606977,
0.0652389228,
0.38489905,
0.0495514981,
-0.0124827875,
0.0103728995,
0.3047630787,
0.1433746368,
-0.6210795641,
0.1789240986,
0.4505952597,
-0.7798646092,
-0.2981872857,
-0.2864835262,
-1.2651335001,
-0.3920413852,
0.5154070258,
0.0253332164,
-0.5538912416,
0.2344778329,
-0.1778327972,
0.2720859647,
-0.4835745096,
0.900588572,
0.6283398867,
-0.3291408122,
-0.2638715506,
-0.5587357879,
0.2284853011,
0.2578851283,
-0.8483798504,
0.1161326319,
0.2122948617,
-0.0237931572,
0.1485569626,
0.3407110274,
-0.0542512834,
0.07406158,
0.5653137565,
0.261487782,
0.2332058549,
-0.0555178635,
0.1319208443,
0.286254406,
-0.3429476023,
-0.4555003345
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06682v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06682v1
|
Self-Reflection in LLM Agents: Effects on Problem-Solving Performance
| 2024-05-05T18:56:46 | 2024-05-05T18:56:46 |
Matthew Renze, Erhan Guven
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
In this study, we investigated the effects of self-reflection in large
language models (LLMs) on problem-solving performance. We instructed nine
popular LLMs to answer a series of multiple-choice questions to provide a
performance baseline. For each incorrectly answered question, we instructed
eight types of self-reflecting LLM agents to reflect on their mistakes and
provide themselves with guidance to improve problem-solving. Then, using this
guidance, each self-reflecting agent attempted to re-answer the same questions.
Our results indicate that LLM agents are able to significantly improve their
problem-solving performance through self-reflection ($p < 0.001$). In addition,
we compared the various types of self-reflection to determine their individual
contribution to performance. All code and data are available on GitHub at
https://github.com/matthewrenze/self-reflection
|
[
-0.2125925571,
-0.7264692187,
0.8489705324,
0.5516884327,
0.1446224898,
0.2671639323,
0.0399807468,
-0.5710898638,
0.456446439,
0.8119039536,
-0.4163661897,
-0.1092132181,
-0.464830935,
0.4430780709,
-0.3813933134,
0.8534915447,
0.0719431639,
0.4124420285,
-0.4245378077,
0.0049424684,
-0.6389333606,
-0.3743601441,
-0.6023816466,
-0.3864754736,
0.6192273498,
0.5740677714,
0.4644363225,
0.5414857864,
0.7433466911,
0.46286726,
0.1107995585,
0.0849980265,
-0.6033534408,
0.5105115771,
-0.455173254,
-0.542352736,
-0.4155178368,
0.2197818309,
0.7032500505,
0.2579820156,
-0.4340374172,
0.3370193243,
0.3118178248,
0.6879694462,
-0.560924232,
0.1909650862,
-0.3088002801,
-0.1397365779,
0.0001982165,
-0.4685591757,
-0.3791979551,
-0.161676079,
-0.0405267067,
-0.5050899982,
0.2797211707,
0.0199482143,
0.2512021363,
0.611014843,
-0.4117075801,
-0.4793086052,
-0.7988914847,
0.5817641616,
-0.7001190782,
-0.0280192643,
0.0747487694,
0.1170099825,
-0.4452904761,
-0.5584086776,
-0.2869969606,
-0.2826072574,
-0.1347591579,
0.4406854212,
0.1493529528,
0.1604104191,
0.3470993042,
0.2772735059,
-0.3873801827,
0.1036407501,
-0.2636297345,
-0.1430127323,
0.8855022788,
0.4877895117,
0.0734320059,
0.0784760043,
-0.1915724427,
0.0159375258,
-0.6484693289,
0.0197078921,
0.1172365844,
0.3951872885,
0.3422522247,
0.4750553966,
-0.292476356,
0.4666874409,
0.0508265123,
-0.3492409885,
0.1408861876,
-0.3712398708,
0.1497741193,
-0.0157909896,
0.5350491405,
0.3011032641,
0.2695920765,
-0.0693622008,
-0.4309066534,
-0.3618564308,
0.4141761363,
-0.8002225757,
0.0825898871,
0.0923829377,
-0.519497335,
-0.2885864079,
-0.1446727067,
-0.7069578171,
-0.6196963191,
-0.2032572329,
0.8905482292,
0.1918364614,
-0.3080702424,
0.2245551497,
-0.0534121357,
0.3743203878,
0.6525223255,
-0.5141385198,
0.5754668713,
0.4606726468,
0.755959332,
-0.1835449189,
-0.6942192912,
-0.484574914,
0.0646750331,
-0.3062282503,
0.9104491472,
-0.3441729546,
-0.5843295455,
-0.0126828831,
-0.1140696257,
-0.0877419263,
-0.9616892338,
0.1698796749,
-0.4187966585,
-0.0241745971,
-0.619966507,
-0.5335154533,
0.051131133,
0.1987542659,
-0.6421271563,
1.1487621069,
-0.0590117648,
-0.4948830903,
-0.0818530619,
-0.6878408194,
-0.2928587198,
0.0737261474,
-0.1892420501,
-0.3494418859,
0.2578210533,
-0.1041475832,
0.5044143796,
-0.237812981,
-0.0751556754,
-0.3349682689,
-0.3991139531,
0.4832820892,
-0.1550623477,
0.4998218417,
0.0363745093,
-0.5039935112,
-0.070060879,
-0.7002930641,
0.0840473399,
0.4086293876,
-0.4583633542,
-0.0557858832,
-0.0162562635,
-0.459313482,
0.5599324703,
0.4535249174,
-0.6491576433,
0.4830773771,
0.0123777073,
-0.0668848753,
0.9644287825,
0.166810751,
-0.0039363955,
-0.4801706672,
0.7350969911,
-0.0059974315,
0.0555088967,
-0.0548406728,
-0.6041794419,
-0.7163383365,
0.0909432769,
-0.0311335251,
0.4582085013,
-0.7406867743,
-0.4711396992,
0.2722165883,
-0.44457829,
-0.6578230858,
0.4886579812,
0.7056465745,
0.49229002,
0.2937993705,
-0.2480457872,
-0.4033117592,
-0.9081940055,
-0.5390332341,
-0.1131385267,
0.4240290225,
0.3637738824,
0.889218092,
0.0155978883,
0.9898909926,
-0.8518713117,
-0.4624051452,
-0.1606851369,
0.1681642979,
-0.0690182149,
0.4187530875,
0.3395023346,
-0.4821785092,
-0.5689958334,
-0.5474353433,
-0.6688768268,
-0.3832574189,
0.0427947156,
0.010947872,
0.3811310828,
0.5919100046,
-0.4731362462,
0.338852942,
0.6989462972,
-0.4458837807,
0.9931230545,
-0.4383946955,
0.003200328,
-0.7974675894,
-0.1938531697,
0.0290667862,
-0.3158853948,
-0.6524905562,
-0.1534607708,
-0.1689307094,
0.2834636867,
-0.5323209763,
0.4644100368,
-0.5945211053,
-0.3788905144,
-0.490414381,
0.2309437543,
-0.0406894162,
0.3780116737,
-0.0463570766,
1.2718063593,
0.3883481622,
-0.6156060696,
0.3648051023,
0.059008278,
-0.143564716,
0.3121682703,
-0.6326366067,
0.3781165183,
-0.2231327295,
0.0792259872,
-1.206412077,
0.0599165633,
0.2281282544,
-0.2552815974,
0.2685429454,
0.1282561719,
-0.4722064137,
-0.3189477921,
-0.2871595025,
0.3869242072,
0.1031565592,
-0.41312626,
0.7328961492,
0.1633735597,
-0.0374997184,
-0.6271508932,
-0.5861496329,
-0.0024462701,
-0.0713586733,
-0.4522635341,
0.193289265,
-0.5818559527,
-0.3990816772,
0.0471637361,
-0.0081541035,
0.179108575,
0.2343830168,
0.125627026,
0.0185442287,
-0.1040245891,
0.2506438792,
-0.4893188477,
-0.1820106506,
0.3596218526,
0.0758747086,
0.6372740865,
-0.7048907876,
-0.4083952606,
-0.2431329638,
0.4461747706,
0.4116774499,
-0.3604390025,
0.9977141619,
0.019903833,
0.0246922001,
-0.2530965507,
-0.9059122801,
-0.2255560607,
-0.568176806,
0.2677907348,
-0.4542408288,
-0.8353396058,
0.8363749981,
0.0455428921,
-0.1206451356,
0.4725542963,
0.7529170513,
-0.5197244883,
1.1990126371,
0.5897573233,
0.03234227,
0.3931841254,
-0.393835336,
-0.1147066653,
-0.7538566589,
-0.3137647212,
-0.4525473416,
-0.2148113698,
-0.843688786,
-0.2794697285,
0.2094605565,
-0.2653664947,
-0.0549108312,
0.0876229554,
-0.6572369337,
0.5764478445,
0.6500579715,
-0.0439568982,
0.5899938345,
-0.5893984437,
0.2008963227,
0.0554696098,
-0.636177361,
-0.5380501747,
1.1240394115,
0.3746862113,
0.9599431753,
0.1712769121,
1.1837854385,
0.1803583354,
0.5326964855,
-0.6613502502,
0.8660358787,
0.2979104221,
-0.8429328799,
-0.6006525755,
-0.4606481194,
-1.0512551069,
0.436417371,
0.201558128,
-0.4345597923,
0.1015680283,
0.1617901027,
-0.2568613291,
0.0451169498,
-0.5835182667,
0.7662216425,
-0.569767952,
-0.3702207208,
-0.4166448414,
-0.3749969304,
0.0601815879,
-0.1005244181,
0.0865237191,
-0.1083134934,
-0.169834286,
0.9706964493,
-0.1542810351,
0.9921889305,
-0.3497259617,
-0.5332973599,
0.4864951968,
0.2077112347,
0.5590902567,
-0.1047479212,
0.0366729274,
-0.0445413068,
0.1100899428,
-0.3046485782,
-0.8544160724,
0.5830907226,
-0.8514723778,
-1.2193783522,
-0.6323465109,
-0.6111584306,
-0.015572398,
0.2494710833,
-0.0349243432,
0.4827803671,
-0.0661773458,
-0.1052934378,
0.7049532533,
0.1246464998,
0.7243636847,
1.2083507776,
-0.6230574846,
-0.3531748056,
0.955065906,
0.7669581175,
0.4361990988,
0.0110452538,
0.1699478328,
-0.1380692571,
-0.63356179,
-0.0341878682,
0.6699750423,
-0.7942424417,
-0.1938076019,
-0.2818415463,
-0.1563562304,
-0.3540069461,
0.1874427348,
-0.6907247305,
-0.4596345127,
-0.3368176818,
0.1366078258,
-0.0728401765,
1.2236324549,
-0.1494106501,
0.2422810346,
-0.5731185079,
0.0452231579,
0.5011912584,
0.6678533554,
-0.0229104441,
-0.3309974968,
-0.6048847437,
-0.0519865341,
-0.5936937332,
-0.9940894246,
0.1601679772,
0.0731888786,
0.7013372183,
0.2511700094,
0.0537048355,
0.6118999124,
-0.4232683778,
0.6161305308,
-0.0917158648,
-0.7596293688,
0.5189423561,
-0.3286283314,
0.2903192341,
0.5658063293,
0.1585832238,
-0.6427873969,
-0.6797353029,
-0.4172537625,
-0.4091209769,
0.7666445374,
0.2038239092,
0.0121667357,
-0.0059924885,
0.6966911554,
-0.0919205248,
0.2302278578,
-0.9028856754,
-0.7475056648,
-0.1565104574,
0.244823128,
-0.4301681221,
-0.6486494541,
-0.2859636843,
-0.3179731071,
0.6789236069,
-0.1883001924,
0.5709555745,
0.5741156936,
-0.2363892347,
-0.3147968352,
0.259157151,
0.9369629622,
0.6317077875,
-0.2300178409,
0.1352602541,
0.335901767,
-0.3797885776,
0.3958641291,
-0.1062825918,
0.0425259061,
-0.2336758375,
0.422375828,
0.1280741841,
-0.1469801366,
-0.5197911859,
0.3895699978,
-0.0937315375,
-0.3572637737,
-0.5131360292,
0.2683941722,
0.1781303436,
0.4372029901,
0.5362679362,
-0.3481235206,
0.3578288853,
-0.7035898566,
0.020920001,
0.467055887,
-0.0438740216,
-0.1357335597,
0.1908293813,
0.1716577709,
-0.782266438,
0.5151329637,
-0.1641117036,
-0.7944997549,
0.7615941763,
0.9834498763,
0.8287112713,
-0.6372796893,
0.4041242003,
0.0444684923,
0.0640693605,
-0.1218535751,
0.5081566572,
0.1032731459,
-0.8272566795,
-0.5342476368,
-0.2017876953,
-0.7482864261,
-0.1020493209,
-0.6791516542,
-0.2110923082,
-0.3779426813,
-0.2082857043,
-0.2751611471,
0.3815985322,
-0.5045236349,
0.1511761844,
0.0605028979,
0.8755627275,
-0.6001124382,
0.4742105305,
0.8507888913,
-0.5537628531,
-0.8738176227,
0.0647745803,
-0.1098320037,
-0.8198391795,
0.7910135984,
0.193448171,
-0.7364146709,
0.155776456,
-0.6735936403,
-1.3658845425,
1.2450330257,
0.3992314935,
-0.4308091104,
0.1466793269,
0.6186954975,
0.8987113833,
-0.4515208006,
0.4558235407,
0.4812376201,
0.4355056286,
-0.0538074151,
-1.1311178207,
0.0969620049,
-0.2872486115,
-0.0738306791,
0.0895472839,
-1.278834343,
0.6953536272,
-0.2077984363,
-0.0021474888,
-0.1628905982,
0.5234230757,
0.1457884908,
0.420727551,
0.3773522973,
0.3587692678,
0.658611834,
0.0829962492,
0.908682704,
-0.4717792571,
0.5199615359,
1.1880625486,
-0.3218883276,
0.7503288388,
0.4996921718,
-0.0244906526,
0.6914229989,
0.2161471695,
0.0066186972,
0.4877155721,
0.2317513674,
-0.1506179124,
-0.3237850368,
-0.1133954599,
-0.4283253551,
0.7055118084,
0.1058886647,
-0.136867851,
-0.1301169842,
0.0124623012,
-0.1131276786,
0.0326959901,
-0.4530828297,
0.7648444176,
0.1293034405,
-0.8799806833,
0.3570410311,
-0.1680519283,
0.3956671655,
-0.252251029,
-0.1310359836,
-0.2866866589,
0.3599695563,
-0.3616912961,
-1.1531201601,
0.260720551,
-0.472284317,
-0.0961596593,
-0.6564896107,
0.8655596375,
-0.3331044316,
-0.1445813328,
0.6498459578,
0.8452965021,
0.2033622861,
-0.0864071548,
-0.6504926682,
-0.2633212209,
-0.2184233218,
-0.6471511126,
0.4334158301,
0.1309333593,
0.2120241821,
1.3240637779,
0.3196564913,
-0.1302112043,
0.1739364713,
0.0079952329,
0.868688643,
-0.7999928594,
-0.1067897081,
-0.8525822163,
0.4728023708,
0.0683048218,
-0.1780002415,
1.1489757299,
0.7610889077,
0.7346676588,
-0.097723484,
0.4046903253,
0.2809405327,
0.687533021,
-0.4084666967,
0.458516866,
-0.6637672186,
0.3895056546,
-0.4128289521,
-0.9439452887,
-0.0373792462,
0.4437273741,
-0.6038474441,
0.2475439906,
0.7608497143,
1.0709431171,
0.6463620663,
-0.1981016248,
0.3862587214,
0.4957922995,
0.5018828511,
0.2019679993,
1.4024281502,
-0.0585917644,
0.6385226846,
-0.3677350581,
0.1070940644,
-0.3055998087,
-0.6146019697,
-0.7856696248,
-0.5648070574,
-0.4630138278,
-0.5381417274,
0.1334475726,
0.9842172861,
0.2940431833,
-0.497690618,
-0.5382447839,
0.0976839364,
0.1859320551,
-0.2166487873,
-0.2127589434,
0.1431800872,
-0.5308468938,
-0.3550349772,
0.3229441643,
0.1168149859,
0.1322969347,
-0.5619803667,
-0.3638697267,
-0.1799165308,
0.2583966255,
0.494496882,
0.1411728561,
-0.567768991,
-0.4753833711,
0.0719885305,
-0.3989831507,
0.4963572025,
0.9665095806,
-0.8733764291,
0.3751420081,
0.1354971826,
0.3471591771,
0.710393846,
0.0507168882,
0.3442772031,
-0.442086935,
-0.5052573681,
0.3015078902,
0.289059788,
-0.0498788096,
-0.5407694578,
0.6047490835,
0.1783486605,
-1.0090235472,
-0.7059545517,
0.1680716276,
-0.576221168,
-0.2189695388,
1.1188472509,
-0.0297976471,
-0.1058070734,
-0.1223642007,
-0.487588793,
0.0139188441,
-0.4400453269,
0.9827689528,
0.8416187763,
-0.600161016,
-0.490804702,
-0.5409184098,
0.4986611307,
0.6834306717,
-0.8022610545,
0.0190175828,
0.382540226,
0.6353413463,
0.2889067233,
1.066382885,
0.2255618423,
0.3500474393,
-0.1380651444,
0.0028061739,
-0.1664862782,
-0.560256362,
-0.5476397872,
0.1470475048,
0.3774397075,
-0.0293243565
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06681v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06681v1
|
Leveraging Lecture Content for Improved Feedback: Explorations with GPT-4 and Retrieval Augmented Generation
| 2024-05-05T18:32:06 | 2024-05-05T18:32:06 |
Sven Jacobs, Steffen Jaschke
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CY
|
This paper presents the use of Retrieval Augmented Generation (RAG) to
improve the feedback generated by Large Language Models for programming tasks.
For this purpose, corresponding lecture recordings were transcribed and made
available to the Large Language Model GPT-4 as external knowledge source
together with timestamps as metainformation by using RAG. The purpose of this
is to prevent hallucinations and to enforce the use of the technical terms and
phrases from the lecture. In an exercise platform developed to solve
programming problems for an introductory programming lecture, students can
request feedback on their solutions generated by GPT-4. For this task GPT-4
receives the students' code solution, the compiler output, the result of unit
tests and the relevant passages from the lecture notes available through the
use of RAG as additional context. The feedback generated by GPT-4 should guide
students to solve problems independently and link to the lecture content, using
the time stamps of the transcript as meta-information. In this way, the
corresponding lecture videos can be viewed immediately at the corresponding
positions. For the evaluation, students worked with the tool in a workshop and
decided for each feedback whether it should be extended by RAG or not. First
results based on a questionnaire and the collected usage data show that the use
of RAG can improve feedback generation and is preferred by students in some
situations. Due to the slower speed of feedback generation, the benefits are
situation dependent.
|
[
-0.45163095,
-0.5963670015,
0.4987202585,
0.204176411,
-0.1138132289,
0.3503541052,
-0.2663133442,
-0.2310272902,
0.2066454589,
0.4406037331,
-0.0825639665,
-0.1564177275,
-0.3234722316,
0.0779883713,
-0.2936811149,
1.5766679049,
-0.0432420745,
0.0969719216,
-0.2012719363,
0.0896033272,
-0.55082798,
-0.5314365029,
-0.7314416766,
-0.2609624565,
0.3852866292,
0.3612034917,
0.3367695808,
0.1783128083,
0.507322073,
0.3787512779,
0.003809667,
0.1386312842,
-0.4783951044,
-0.0206993241,
-0.4435620308,
-0.4145897031,
-0.379365325,
-0.1034624428,
0.7982654572,
0.4286560118,
-0.1748627275,
0.2863964736,
0.335973829,
0.6136396527,
-0.5259238482,
0.1495111883,
-0.1004650965,
0.052290082,
-0.2449058592,
-0.7315182686,
-0.5489165783,
-0.4918896258,
0.0269884579,
-0.6149520874,
0.3538163304,
-0.2463350445,
0.6437784433,
0.311404109,
-0.1073447838,
-0.5478445292,
-1.0989189148,
0.8560244441,
-0.5974143147,
0.4244549274,
0.451549083,
0.4647672176,
-0.1179737002,
-0.7355151772,
-0.4125784039,
-0.4455856085,
-0.0328379683,
0.1440964937,
0.4198130071,
0.0459782034,
0.5895333886,
0.6114808917,
-0.3204578459,
-0.4175117612,
-0.5989623666,
-0.2907043099,
0.5127390027,
-0.0916727185,
0.1445766985,
-0.5228766799,
-0.0475281253,
-0.2767618597,
-0.7002980113,
-0.0481054708,
0.5817598701,
0.1130415872,
0.2875671983,
0.619051218,
0.0457229428,
0.7801427841,
0.1170922965,
-0.455894798,
0.5497663617,
-0.3606260717,
0.0612777658,
-0.3235012293,
0.3517321348,
0.1739760339,
-0.2299568057,
-0.1852996796,
-0.2292913198,
-0.1701323688,
0.5497623682,
-0.8548706174,
-0.5744590759,
-0.0947484374,
-0.3977510929,
-0.1376033872,
-0.061872188,
-1.1891238689,
-0.3148413897,
-0.6803363562,
0.5068906546,
-0.283880502,
-0.4094158411,
-0.3479696512,
-0.2787894905,
0.130781278,
0.4583124816,
-0.855822742,
0.395735234,
0.4926294684,
0.773411274,
-0.3619293571,
-0.0291992463,
-0.8394669294,
0.3290581405,
-0.1576294154,
0.7232910395,
-0.7217361331,
-0.7131491899,
-0.1118045226,
0.0570715368,
0.2442915887,
-0.6151399016,
0.4665326178,
-0.5571030974,
0.5857069492,
-0.1718846858,
-0.6074541807,
-0.2395631373,
0.4042323232,
-0.5126675963,
1.2038832903,
0.4771699607,
-0.7566269636,
0.0928580612,
-0.9214485288,
-0.0552066378,
0.4131360352,
-0.4471005201,
-0.2389742434,
-0.1377553493,
0.1422375441,
0.1069848239,
0.2087877691,
0.0430441499,
0.1546825767,
-0.3444458842,
-0.0310527924,
-0.0834750906,
0.1844992936,
0.2753412127,
-0.7031036615,
0.0911033005,
-0.7739256024,
0.3497953713,
-0.2173411697,
-0.7768998146,
-0.3988961577,
-0.0956534371,
-0.2116114348,
-0.109833464,
0.1388252079,
-0.4041377306,
0.4472608268,
-0.2041208297,
-0.0508387722,
0.7942372561,
0.357172966,
0.503924787,
-0.1555949301,
0.9504509568,
-0.3298731148,
-0.0065588234,
-0.2304756045,
-0.296974808,
-0.6375647187,
0.0640266761,
0.3664981723,
0.4457631707,
-1.2111809254,
-0.4324993789,
0.0994566977,
-0.3188831508,
-0.3924617171,
0.3681239784,
0.520737052,
0.4458949268,
0.4979474545,
-0.4193706512,
-0.7583993673,
-0.3259366751,
-0.086187616,
-0.1574486941,
-0.1086419523,
0.6711911559,
0.1534466147,
-0.4185459316,
0.6576054692,
-0.6852762103,
0.0024947228,
-0.2880117595,
0.3473061621,
0.2741067111,
0.5240132213,
0.4570583701,
-0.6983741522,
-0.5662139654,
-0.0554082021,
-0.3927056789,
-0.1630769372,
-0.0721255094,
-0.2290335745,
0.3625096977,
0.3683094084,
-0.1215453818,
0.351218909,
0.5116354823,
-0.0801282898,
0.9042071104,
-0.1033436805,
0.415581286,
-0.9233209491,
0.0803795457,
-0.3596363068,
-0.2485027313,
-0.2681701481,
0.1906977147,
-0.1955634505,
-0.1691833884,
-0.0096728653,
0.4678190649,
-0.4971578717,
-0.2201142311,
-0.6508315802,
0.2353970408,
-0.0992420539,
0.4259088337,
-0.0595180839,
0.952190876,
0.1837777197,
-0.7247119546,
0.5036625862,
0.1375523508,
-0.0816077814,
0.3059835732,
-0.5249467492,
0.633182466,
0.1286393851,
0.3008861244,
-0.6756104231,
-0.2912259996,
0.1664124429,
-0.7032368779,
0.7833669782,
-0.4007589519,
-0.1361596584,
-0.5461237431,
-0.4530982971,
0.2948293388,
0.4631244242,
-0.5954306722,
0.4942214787,
0.3516148329,
-0.375846684,
-0.8154553175,
-0.2114519179,
-0.094940871,
-0.0175378583,
-0.3799519539,
0.2141673118,
-0.3478129506,
-0.0933295041,
0.083641775,
-0.1321540326,
0.1952141374,
-0.367829144,
0.2059336454,
0.3428583741,
0.0655939803,
0.4071670771,
-0.2644954622,
-0.1277433485,
0.025131952,
-0.3680769503,
0.5993926525,
-0.1524582356,
-0.374940902,
0.006932186,
0.3781565726,
0.0597295612,
-0.1301493198,
0.3790414631,
0.7968067527,
-0.0279903039,
-0.1599199921,
-0.771938026,
-0.3650940657,
-0.516264379,
0.3546991348,
-0.2044312954,
-0.98542732,
0.2222629189,
-0.3336909711,
0.1856078058,
0.1104881391,
0.6793389916,
0.0607915968,
0.906722784,
0.8362968564,
0.0287444312,
0.7918044925,
-0.6936679482,
0.2499030232,
-1.2254070044,
-0.4239315987,
-0.6319351196,
-0.1548451185,
-0.5475263,
-0.6574062705,
0.3758674562,
0.0876363739,
-0.1301949173,
0.1067839563,
-0.8531078696,
0.5823777914,
0.7790626287,
0.1051707417,
0.1275641024,
-0.0021084151,
-0.0542812645,
-0.2929918468,
-0.4932532012,
-0.4176047444,
1.2840940952,
0.140492022,
0.8660154343,
0.2480401695,
0.9356219172,
0.2483548522,
0.5405966043,
-0.6563462019,
0.5205287337,
0.1329003274,
-0.535394311,
-0.2579827309,
-0.7188318372,
-0.8169693947,
0.0881656557,
0.1755470484,
-0.6513875723,
-0.21067065,
0.3418343365,
-0.2870481014,
0.2202876657,
-0.8571096063,
0.6536799073,
-0.1675943285,
-0.719828248,
-0.3345771134,
-0.4171268642,
0.2601111531,
0.0968266129,
0.2955825329,
0.6002005339,
0.3065017462,
0.8738856316,
-0.5963828564,
0.56134969,
-0.58421278,
-0.1013375595,
0.7053613663,
0.1170744598,
0.4930993319,
0.1174668074,
0.1085357144,
-0.5985859632,
-0.0506467223,
-0.1893448681,
-0.8937221766,
0.7638044357,
-0.8843978047,
-0.834444046,
-0.3435707688,
-0.5733129382,
-0.2170903385,
0.0241837744,
0.0120506361,
0.7611692548,
0.4581875205,
0.1517247409,
0.5282869935,
-0.3801803291,
0.3352598846,
0.5479553342,
-0.6123840213,
-0.4607190788,
1.2555072308,
0.0298740678,
0.2499839664,
0.2244228721,
0.1939167827,
-0.3249108493,
-0.5005796552,
-0.417912364,
0.2508801818,
-0.8170586228,
-0.3496469855,
-0.5564849377,
-0.1619261503,
-0.6730996966,
0.0437994264,
-0.1339486986,
-0.6500009894,
0.1005391926,
-0.1553578377,
0.3081742525,
1.0697534084,
-0.4588415027,
0.2352949828,
-0.9597088099,
0.3418649733,
0.4698159099,
0.4248850346,
0.003063519,
-0.5965817571,
-0.4948693514,
-0.1841348112,
-0.9165709615,
-0.9933035374,
0.2671656013,
0.0867971107,
0.6429982185,
0.2166897953,
-0.2209636718,
0.5819804668,
-0.5059236288,
0.9993502498,
-0.1016137227,
-0.9183856845,
0.7866451144,
-0.2612270713,
0.2096980065,
0.2911602557,
0.3651625514,
-0.4708521962,
-0.504575789,
-0.6367511749,
-0.8454883099,
0.7203420997,
0.0544472039,
0.0456135124,
-0.0097049,
0.4999864995,
0.0756702945,
0.2906671762,
-0.8675865531,
0.0894475356,
-0.4280384481,
0.1995940804,
0.0116999894,
-0.3931819201,
-0.1983478069,
-0.313010931,
0.9234771132,
-0.157646507,
0.3315040469,
0.147231549,
0.1699598134,
-0.1921542287,
0.3156024516,
0.5997108221,
0.827121675,
-0.1873520166,
0.0700494498,
0.120620124,
-0.8737359643,
0.074002564,
-0.0131873144,
-0.0987518057,
0.305524081,
0.1265729517,
0.5388342142,
0.0950687006,
-0.409686327,
0.3544638753,
0.0725927353,
0.1412393153,
-0.4093976021,
0.1701780558,
-0.2878277004,
0.2560223043,
0.3417136371,
-0.0692345724,
0.5252190232,
-0.5722839236,
0.2273704708,
0.2155573815,
0.0594472401,
-0.2241963595,
0.5281023979,
0.3481676877,
-0.4396862686,
0.5108969808,
-0.5186532736,
-0.8970432878,
0.3273992538,
0.6639959216,
0.5596128106,
-0.6218004823,
0.4186618924,
0.8662182689,
-0.0322519504,
0.0288729556,
0.2572339177,
-0.4673319757,
-0.2176751792,
-1.0914020538,
-0.6568031311,
-0.8600295782,
0.0897540748,
-0.7081233263,
0.3074630797,
-0.2933425307,
-0.1242188364,
-0.4208836257,
0.2750735879,
-0.4239288867,
0.0230753981,
-0.0482946709,
0.5264236331,
-0.4134846032,
0.7069925666,
0.9281740189,
-0.4220068753,
-1.3247196674,
-0.2148305923,
-0.0402194299,
-0.3392401636,
0.8525110483,
0.0441010855,
0.0205483548,
-0.1634165049,
-0.552488327,
-0.8478327394,
0.8065254092,
0.0647111461,
-0.371483624,
-0.0814866275,
-0.1451521963,
0.705450654,
0.0482829437,
0.4481468201,
0.3757579625,
0.4288747311,
0.3939450383,
-0.959878087,
-0.2225527912,
-0.4036054909,
-0.1315808147,
0.5562034249,
-0.3891371489,
0.8489319682,
-0.2758220136,
-0.0213759132,
-0.0409331582,
0.6441517472,
0.4100153744,
0.4673893154,
0.4161069393,
0.6386109591,
0.7768208385,
-0.0270286035,
1.312174201,
-0.0981508866,
0.4323275089,
1.4683351517,
0.1201858148,
0.7095779181,
0.6077458858,
-0.4310422242,
0.8209420443,
0.31216079,
0.058628846,
0.6278654337,
0.4995678961,
-0.4032519162,
0.1891537756,
0.0515911244,
-0.7998952866,
0.0599116199,
0.4853003919,
-0.0792384595,
-0.0392371118,
0.2962578833,
-0.0393626802,
-0.066354692,
-0.2980062962,
0.867326498,
-0.0590957999,
-0.9975553155,
0.5411579013,
-0.2456933409,
0.4512121975,
-0.5570240617,
-0.5316857696,
-0.264970988,
0.4520989656,
-0.4557934403,
-0.606461823,
0.4514826536,
0.1936273575,
-0.1027612165,
-0.227122575,
0.5688072443,
-0.4120197892,
-0.2205152661,
0.0999005437,
0.1865705699,
0.5004993081,
0.2172041386,
-0.2465161979,
0.120773688,
0.2581549883,
-0.2558136582,
0.234721601,
0.5478420854,
0.1330821365,
0.4724785388,
0.5522379875,
0.2204020321,
0.2672569156,
0.2009285837,
1.119777441,
-0.4714739621,
-0.3328753114,
-0.4327069521,
0.3069647849,
-0.2909018099,
-0.0547823906,
1.1077954769,
0.5624873638,
1.0386414528,
-0.1174783185,
0.739847362,
-0.3335588276,
1.1644778252,
-0.4088278413,
0.2020740658,
-0.3420409262,
0.5004315972,
-0.6600464582,
-1.1635091305,
0.168522343,
0.6283281446,
-0.3744014204,
0.2911757231,
0.7675676346,
0.5425357819,
0.1310589612,
-0.0324348323,
-0.058086846,
0.1089663282,
0.752252996,
0.4034022689,
0.9306771755,
-0.1983855367,
0.7024422288,
-0.3641449511,
-0.4818058312,
-0.2832513452,
-0.674859941,
-0.8978105187,
-0.5095183849,
-0.3592241108,
-0.6108067036,
-0.0649395809,
0.6653007269,
0.6123309731,
-0.845323801,
-0.1590826958,
0.0559966043,
0.0300208833,
0.0858927518,
-0.3756070435,
0.4673255682,
-0.7592042089,
-0.7700999975,
0.3689022362,
0.0178653318,
0.035541486,
-0.4210617244,
-0.267352283,
0.0819810927,
-0.2717751265,
0.645865798,
0.4045903981,
-0.2823884189,
-0.4696355164,
0.1225379556,
0.2692321837,
-0.1673296392,
1.0497282743,
-0.9873484969,
0.6301059127,
0.5396491289,
0.818614006,
0.8292209506,
0.0825501904,
0.6159250736,
-0.9479530454,
0.2475323528,
0.444182992,
0.2056693882,
0.553206563,
-0.4327403605,
0.9343758821,
0.1936669797,
-1.1249289513,
-0.8962850571,
-0.0070198029,
-0.7451480031,
0.0709647536,
1.1996583939,
-0.2561382949,
0.1492525637,
0.0759832114,
-0.7856144905,
0.2415299416,
-0.2685385346,
1.0845910311,
0.8137988448,
-0.3690355122,
-0.2507182658,
-0.9734707475,
0.7489398718,
0.4845588505,
-0.9828333259,
-0.336661756,
0.5212590098,
0.1239805371,
0.606246531,
0.6848198771,
-0.3549862206,
0.3879928291,
-0.1401380748,
0.0379657708,
0.0274984296,
-0.4108757973,
-0.044029098,
0.0696361512,
0.1256036311,
-0.2368218154
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03007v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03007v1
|
On the performativity of SDG classifications in large bibliometric databases
| 2024-05-05T17:28:54 | 2024-05-05T17:28:54 |
Matteo Ottaviani, Stephan Stahlschmidt
|
cs.DL
|
cs.DL, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Large bibliometric databases, such as Web of Science, Scopus, and OpenAlex,
facilitate bibliometric analyses, but are performative, affecting the
visibility of scientific outputs and the impact measurement of participating
entities. Recently, these databases have taken up the UN's Sustainable
Development Goals (SDGs) in their respective classifications, which have been
criticised for their diverging nature. This work proposes using the feature of
large language models (LLMs) to learn about the "data bias" injected by diverse
SDG classifications into bibliometric data by exploring five SDGs. We build a
LLM that is fine-tuned in parallel by the diverse SDG classifications inscribed
into the databases' SDG classifications. Our results show high sensitivity in
model architecture, classified publications, fine-tuning process, and natural
language generation. The wide arbitrariness at different levels raises concerns
about using LLM in research practice.
|
[
-0.5823784471,
-0.3788121343,
0.5237269998,
0.0544964448,
-0.282684505,
0.1348563433,
-0.4601985812,
-0.5857900381,
0.023692077,
0.6361836195,
-0.5155568123,
-0.8911309242,
-0.8982086778,
0.3668833971,
-0.2211219072,
1.2121119499,
-0.0760098919,
0.2510865629,
-0.2039457858,
-0.2051277757,
-0.1037357226,
-0.2415057421,
0.0682996586,
-0.3407442272,
0.4977293313,
0.1569334865,
0.7009579539,
0.6026557684,
0.7098782063,
0.0797105953,
-0.2546467781,
0.3287394047,
-0.7266963124,
-0.1237105951,
-0.6929616332,
-0.4406114221,
-0.1082617417,
0.0675493181,
0.8051403165,
0.9125441313,
0.0620492995,
0.5940630436,
0.3476053774,
0.5497659445,
-0.4097887874,
0.5227592587,
-0.3627019823,
-0.1201144233,
-0.2521222234,
0.1981950402,
-0.3203419447,
-0.3799516857,
-0.0690937415,
-0.2549955249,
0.4574444592,
0.1237183437,
0.7507504225,
0.4612012804,
-0.42980811,
-0.3950997293,
-0.6637986302,
0.854724884,
-0.5237815976,
0.411521107,
0.2568715215,
-0.015515497,
-0.2431119084,
-0.3594049513,
-0.4731537998,
0.1533240378,
0.2304149717,
-0.0963363126,
0.1991286427,
0.0659187883,
0.5475007892,
0.3550601602,
-0.4598656297,
0.4014078379,
-0.4770502746,
-0.0270955116,
0.8057966232,
0.0958824754,
-0.1981226504,
-0.2377638966,
-0.335624665,
0.0780480206,
-0.9256144762,
-0.2665020227,
0.4894651473,
0.7082705498,
-0.1055713072,
0.6726183295,
-0.2359026819,
0.6270379424,
-0.2045493871,
-0.0321070291,
0.2995623648,
-0.7873151898,
0.046294935,
0.0281677656,
0.5391205549,
0.6015839577,
0.0357613936,
-0.2661691904,
-0.0002505909,
0.3266777694,
0.1945646554,
-0.9480700493,
-0.2048347443,
0.1182405278,
-0.5926272869,
0.0250916779,
0.0513243824,
-0.7173539996,
-0.6021130085,
-0.5426339507,
0.016213093,
0.0011363871,
-0.1207330003,
0.2810558379,
0.1389755309,
0.0100184213,
0.1797655225,
-0.6251395941,
0.0305536352,
0.569140017,
0.8991786242,
-0.207103461,
-0.0062986244,
-0.2451684177,
0.3397481441,
-0.0834936425,
0.7444670796,
-0.6386008859,
-0.5534768701,
-0.0354573876,
-0.0471481569,
0.1804636121,
-0.5293210149,
0.9795607924,
-0.3944059908,
-0.2344731539,
-0.9066174626,
-0.6781225801,
-0.0915663317,
-0.0208802428,
-0.7697607279,
0.8386207223,
-0.0587084889,
-0.7420566082,
1.1483011246,
-0.5613983274,
-0.3479714394,
0.2127753198,
-0.291394949,
-0.348320961,
0.1746675074,
0.095284991,
0.6898885965,
-0.5880842805,
0.5176666379,
-0.4135243297,
-0.274033308,
-0.0817870945,
-0.0214376859,
0.6011017561,
0.2020625323,
0.0434043221,
-0.1570345014,
-1.0840030909,
0.0628044978,
-0.2741209567,
-0.751731813,
-0.4633212388,
0.40780586,
0.1798108667,
0.1986423135,
0.227536127,
-0.628960371,
0.5152322054,
0.0029345767,
0.3548646271,
0.809472084,
-0.1783748865,
0.1707901657,
-0.2822963595,
0.3276220858,
-0.0537476093,
-0.080897361,
0.2570074797,
-0.4045384824,
-0.1708012074,
-0.5323388577,
0.6202324629,
0.2022308409,
-0.4270867109,
0.789855361,
-0.4859892726,
-0.4371848404,
-0.5717033744,
0.3909192085,
0.1181319878,
0.1768835783,
0.239451617,
-0.2694113553,
-0.5228164196,
-0.7001305223,
-0.3800332248,
-0.0886406749,
-0.0369418226,
0.47377038,
0.7942239046,
-0.5113535523,
0.7294902205,
-0.2672358751,
-0.2732329071,
0.122562483,
0.2105425596,
0.3666610122,
0.0559491292,
0.4630313218,
-0.9859892726,
-0.2728429139,
-0.0933428332,
-0.7750965953,
-0.4582867324,
0.2409238368,
0.0686963499,
0.0422734283,
0.3604421616,
-0.6161183715,
0.0832945332,
0.5424663424,
-0.417105794,
0.4715325236,
0.0423105098,
-0.0588341393,
-0.750706017,
-0.0692690238,
0.3799393177,
-0.0361409336,
-0.2560465336,
0.0453249849,
0.2352429479,
0.1542068571,
-0.0549241751,
0.3402124941,
-0.5127922893,
-0.1693771929,
0.0126302019,
-0.0238060933,
-0.1591306925,
-0.2506408393,
-0.0261088014,
0.523278892,
0.5262233615,
-0.8540253639,
0.2230345607,
0.3372441232,
-0.7248933911,
0.5676141977,
-0.5403490663,
-0.1493057013,
-0.3441916406,
0.3056152463,
-0.7918992043,
-0.2248144895,
-0.198860392,
0.0138002764,
0.1863247007,
-0.2710213959,
-0.8932408094,
-0.4867988825,
-0.1974025816,
0.1861557513,
0.2010463327,
-0.7431918979,
0.2092205137,
0.3789474666,
-0.1344465166,
-0.4496383369,
-0.5909121037,
-0.0388222449,
-0.3802590668,
-0.5982968211,
0.142877847,
-0.1322263926,
-0.2712750137,
-0.0987762362,
-0.2230998427,
0.6268652081,
-0.1607466787,
0.3667069674,
0.0377322659,
0.0804331452,
0.2608779669,
-0.0934985951,
0.3362170756,
0.1398731023,
-0.2562354505,
0.4580702186,
0.0865768939,
-0.2746157646,
0.1165505201,
0.1408835649,
0.4792539179,
-0.3966170847,
0.9309237003,
0.5663733482,
-0.1667071879,
-0.4709790945,
-0.4657767713,
-0.0690492094,
-0.432169646,
0.343912214,
-0.2106121182,
-1.0117551088,
0.6735874414,
-0.3853619397,
0.1140970513,
0.1365563422,
0.6326833367,
0.1388627887,
1.0696667433,
0.5061188936,
0.0247600339,
0.2503761947,
-0.1332428157,
0.246024251,
-0.8921501637,
-0.2839644551,
-0.8024472594,
-0.3056798875,
-0.9005947113,
-0.5437438488,
0.2647525966,
0.4760562778,
-0.2291211337,
0.0466549098,
-0.6283337474,
0.3589591086,
0.167753458,
-0.1514390856,
0.2918165326,
0.156109035,
-0.0596496984,
-0.2628135383,
-0.4619062841,
-0.8661425114,
1.2751783133,
0.3263697922,
1.153796792,
0.2046327293,
0.7415944338,
0.4448913336,
0.2202602178,
-0.5558691621,
0.3707277477,
-0.4109351039,
-0.571383059,
-0.1675639898,
-0.6014076471,
-0.7740747333,
0.216364041,
-0.1489292681,
-0.6877805591,
0.5796234012,
-0.1274109185,
-0.1342047751,
0.1673731208,
-0.6005695462,
0.458494246,
-0.1886334121,
-0.5142015219,
-0.1650783122,
-0.2649999559,
0.1404763013,
-0.0201248787,
0.5132399201,
-0.4252655506,
-0.0376248136,
0.7236348391,
0.0338324644,
0.8375028372,
-0.2735239267,
-0.3438278735,
0.1665445417,
-0.0586838983,
0.6302264333,
0.2267558724,
-0.3517849445,
0.4366984665,
-0.0500202365,
-0.4430686533,
-0.0841921642,
0.8028004766,
-0.5666789412,
-0.4768619239,
-0.4318649471,
-0.5108651519,
-0.2701177299,
0.3780142367,
-0.0442123786,
-0.1976448148,
-0.3247433007,
0.2644969821,
1.0059206486,
-0.2388083786,
0.0934710354,
0.6824817657,
-0.1867803633,
0.086657159,
0.8867020607,
0.6146406531,
0.3709408343,
-0.0034846503,
0.0878668353,
-0.4713881314,
-0.9110229015,
-0.2831314504,
0.4261719882,
-0.5587428212,
-0.2921372056,
-0.4112082422,
0.0907543972,
-0.4593195617,
0.0183436535,
0.0153966444,
-0.1188105568,
-0.4305039942,
-0.3165977001,
0.4643940032,
0.8791320324,
-0.0888738558,
-0.0534959994,
-0.5601075292,
0.3749350309,
-0.1000682041,
0.6422048211,
-0.3750442863,
-0.1810630113,
-0.3577472568,
0.202780515,
-0.2155935466,
-0.5737271905,
0.1881836504,
0.258413583,
0.5960092545,
0.3869059682,
0.171307534,
0.3370040953,
-0.5082137585,
0.6799963117,
0.0360076614,
-0.6266932487,
0.3911221623,
-0.7514400482,
0.1057588309,
0.4369786382,
0.5744299293,
-0.1250242144,
-0.0348300152,
-0.2636739612,
-0.9833436012,
0.6644598246,
-0.1661209762,
-0.0616329238,
0.0243002865,
0.3678213954,
0.3418283463,
0.5771480203,
-0.6875631809,
0.0581298843,
-0.1019923836,
-0.1711718291,
-0.1500285566,
-0.2328851521,
-0.3549482226,
0.0106073916,
0.5781420469,
-0.3627263308,
-0.0564296767,
-0.060909342,
0.0222437121,
-0.0584664829,
0.4901774526,
0.2561403513,
0.8339954615,
-0.218526572,
0.0772608146,
-0.0765483007,
-0.4314357042,
-0.1436188668,
0.1729371101,
-0.4694031775,
-0.235964492,
0.122308597,
0.6514094472,
-0.090398699,
-0.785793066,
-0.065917708,
0.0938450769,
-0.1880466044,
0.1236661598,
0.105818212,
0.2077769786,
0.4141618013,
0.1806871742,
-0.1627845019,
0.1703531742,
-0.6685650945,
-0.0836514011,
0.5389699936,
0.0881694928,
-0.0636912286,
0.7072379589,
0.2386711091,
0.0951349884,
0.3330889642,
-0.316249907,
-0.2589333057,
0.4192125797,
0.4441396594,
0.2394761294,
-0.0916810483,
0.2557597756,
0.3849789202,
0.440987587,
-0.462200582,
0.6938029528,
0.1283430755,
-0.7517798543,
-0.4189541638,
-1.0922219753,
-0.1999675184,
-0.1364146173,
-0.8588396907,
0.3196655214,
-0.4364904463,
-0.3961786628,
0.4570347667,
0.1701340824,
-0.9392822981,
0.0588026941,
0.0525138676,
0.5079774261,
-0.7574748993,
0.6603287458,
0.6904016137,
-0.3305031955,
-0.3769139349,
-0.0704554915,
-0.1480824947,
-0.6530157924,
0.7956156731,
0.0133104473,
0.0772461817,
-0.3079864383,
-0.7214043736,
-0.8707123399,
0.9297308922,
0.5686213374,
-0.8326602578,
-0.1167826355,
0.3720502555,
0.6894811988,
-0.1985307187,
-0.2671741545,
0.6707798243,
0.7934962511,
-0.2533720136,
-1.0685346127,
-0.0332475156,
0.1093477309,
0.0114340689,
0.3053485751,
-1.0620678663,
0.7803076506,
-0.164944455,
-0.0534144454,
-0.3455385566,
0.3974493742,
0.2118626088,
0.114929609,
0.1331924647,
0.6075943708,
1.0004661083,
-0.3794338703,
1.0594033003,
-0.1598276794,
0.5705350637,
0.6891306639,
-0.7624000907,
0.4359989166,
0.3598325551,
-0.5445920825,
0.1752542406,
0.6183659434,
-0.6116808057,
0.608115077,
0.6006276011,
-0.2049316913,
-0.2274538726,
-0.4749971628,
-0.3042553961,
0.3076176643,
0.7418520451,
-0.4593022764,
-0.1212276071,
0.0564779639,
-0.0501668751,
0.289762944,
-0.792617023,
0.3285838962,
0.0894299522,
-0.2974610627,
0.5942834616,
0.164952144,
0.8342937231,
-0.3130262494,
-0.0246629175,
0.1765218377,
0.1974919736,
-0.530972898,
-0.9226898551,
0.1037905514,
0.0170677006,
-0.5335955024,
-0.1857616156,
0.4760763049,
-0.3065239489,
-0.7146279812,
0.3363168836,
0.183984533,
0.049229905,
0.2259411961,
-0.4017737806,
0.306278199,
0.0676390827,
-0.150753051,
0.3916522861,
0.5161230564,
-0.2997721434,
0.6511259675,
0.4127200842,
0.3857835233,
0.2228691429,
0.2189891636,
0.6485792994,
-0.4599097669,
-0.4326098561,
-0.6242095232,
0.0234768763,
-0.0156596415,
-0.1680752039,
1.0908607244,
0.7016946077,
0.9927139878,
0.1641933024,
1.0701476336,
-0.1437217146,
0.8308178782,
-0.4350632727,
0.5327928662,
-0.2920957208,
0.4571117461,
-0.4256109893,
-1.0167196989,
-0.2140522152,
0.5575101972,
-0.340188086,
0.3396461904,
0.1167465746,
0.5307148099,
0.0591913573,
0.139229849,
0.0734570771,
0.2735051811,
0.3478093445,
0.1338172257,
0.4236973822,
0.0338834822,
0.1256235093,
0.2087288052,
-0.0503886268,
-0.1269776523,
-0.8459590077,
-1.09762609,
-0.3201645315,
-0.4402124882,
-0.4050865769,
0.2033387721,
0.7473833561,
0.5258030295,
-0.8563753963,
-0.0164313652,
0.0849378482,
0.0857599974,
-0.0199839845,
-0.2046481818,
0.5876024365,
0.2480021119,
-0.7459646463,
0.1322354078,
-0.0452808589,
-0.1238646656,
-0.5710560679,
-0.0655139983,
-0.1996495426,
0.0288600326,
0.4751403928,
0.1830770075,
-0.4365133941,
-0.4299504459,
-0.28543064,
0.1231622919,
-0.2218070328,
0.7269445658,
-0.6142417789,
0.3269432485,
0.3724886775,
0.5807137489,
0.5826956034,
0.0264969841,
0.2689278722,
-0.628415823,
-0.0717626512,
0.2200392187,
0.3484123051,
0.4546591341,
-0.345438242,
0.619386673,
0.0486385375,
-0.7804012299,
-1.1402584314,
0.2575177252,
-0.7305042744,
-0.1855756193,
1.4983986616,
0.0128743956,
0.2344206572,
-0.2185185552,
-0.0250545423,
0.12828435,
-0.4146690965,
0.945366621,
1.1315103769,
-0.2594392002,
-0.0449722148,
-0.6645376682,
0.547244966,
0.1262197047,
-0.6095209122,
0.3218521476,
0.7215256691,
0.2265124619,
0.1995114088,
0.1327753663,
-0.2619330287,
-0.1166811883,
-0.2569161952,
0.2849532664,
0.1548169702,
-0.187429294,
-0.2455347478,
0.0421541706,
0.3307928145,
0.3566887379
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03004v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03004v1
|
Exploring prompts to elicit memorization in masked language model-based named entity recognition
| 2024-05-05T17:19:35 | 2024-05-05T17:19:35 |
Yuxi Xia, Anastasiia Sedova, Pedro Henrique Luz de Araujo, Vasiliki Kougia, Lisa Nußbaumer, Benjamin Roth
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Training data memorization in language models impacts model capability
(generalization) and safety (privacy risk). This paper focuses on analyzing
prompts' impact on detecting the memorization of 6 masked language model-based
named entity recognition models. Specifically, we employ a diverse set of 400
automatically generated prompts, and a pairwise dataset where each pair
consists of one person's name from the training set and another name out of the
set. A prompt completed with a person's name serves as input for getting the
model's confidence in predicting this name. Finally, the prompt performance of
detecting model memorization is quantified by the percentage of name pairs for
which the model has higher confidence for the name from the training set. We
show that the performance of different prompts varies by as much as 16
percentage points on the same model, and prompt engineering further increases
the gap. Moreover, our experiments demonstrate that prompt performance is
model-dependent but does generalize across different name sets. A comprehensive
analysis indicates how prompt performance is influenced by prompt properties,
contained tokens, and the model's self-attention weights on the prompt.
|
[
-0.308860302,
-0.4880498052,
0.7249943614,
0.0660301745,
-0.0727695003,
-0.0359997563,
0.0224764403,
-0.4184563458,
-0.0334719084,
0.4868973494,
-0.4583379924,
-0.4561718106,
-0.4393621385,
0.2041872591,
-0.0955362767,
0.8580502868,
0.1574255079,
-0.0240471046,
-0.1666180342,
0.0183239561,
-1.0419898033,
-0.6956154704,
-0.72248137,
0.199572891,
0.6271997094,
0.1602326334,
0.1822440773,
0.8383305073,
0.2542957366,
0.2820204198,
-0.229702875,
-0.2059156448,
-0.070926778,
0.5480288267,
0.0014826461,
-0.62435776,
-0.2655561864,
0.1234805286,
0.8919621706,
0.6641317606,
0.1214053184,
0.1129086837,
0.0163052641,
0.306432277,
-0.7245178223,
0.2050281465,
-0.7643691301,
-0.1242813542,
-0.0708578452,
-0.1719664335,
-0.6284172535,
-0.0595393851,
0.2891999185,
-0.4829031527,
0.5476999283,
0.3754781187,
0.7403439283,
0.1507982761,
-0.2246006727,
-0.3811219037,
-0.5632607341,
0.6527107954,
-0.3263928592,
0.5175110698,
0.5095243454,
0.3954556286,
-0.0740616918,
-0.603035748,
-0.29132393,
-0.2929708958,
-0.1120810732,
-0.3196853399,
-0.2039809376,
0.2939562798,
1.0024782419,
0.19165124,
-0.299122721,
0.1631655842,
-0.4964592755,
-0.415103972,
0.3090575933,
0.1508314461,
0.5986178517,
-0.1775738746,
-0.4689289331,
0.0354732163,
-0.6553933024,
0.5846785307,
0.4918660223,
0.5578045845,
0.1026352718,
0.2031088024,
-0.2524024546,
0.6156603098,
0.1440261155,
-0.1690776646,
0.1732265055,
0.0164459273,
-0.399604857,
0.3063622713,
0.5493677855,
0.2915647626,
0.3618859053,
-0.2306826562,
-0.5091186166,
-0.1485962719,
0.0318189524,
-0.9335756898,
-0.4431023002,
0.0454441458,
-0.4413334131,
-0.1243141368,
0.0585256778,
-0.4735684097,
-0.6764689088,
-0.3211286962,
0.4940467477,
-0.5291564465,
-0.051328402,
0.0111905178,
-0.3045903742,
-0.0186432526,
0.4816379547,
-0.9611487985,
0.2220105082,
0.5991234183,
0.7836899161,
-0.0494953878,
-0.0888900012,
-0.8478748798,
-0.0786204785,
-0.1468380839,
0.6878859401,
-0.6300900578,
-0.4335387647,
-0.2034221888,
0.1405712813,
-0.4522782564,
-0.5084187388,
0.229578048,
-0.563637197,
0.3664551079,
-0.5669298172,
-0.7625854611,
-0.2607753277,
0.0485514663,
-0.9336104393,
0.7262633443,
-0.2780162394,
-0.7129075527,
0.3881379664,
-0.2581811547,
-0.1934256554,
0.3250944614,
-0.3078886569,
-0.2960625589,
0.1880048215,
0.3126458526,
0.6513306499,
-0.0665212199,
0.2848680615,
-0.0460178368,
-0.3210644722,
0.5182013512,
-0.4197756648,
0.8165233135,
0.0486811474,
-0.3556912839,
-0.2062910199,
-0.952224493,
-0.1058860719,
-0.0543837883,
-0.0498643443,
-0.623750031,
-0.3899546564,
-0.3979211748,
0.188606441,
-0.1109518781,
-0.2968837023,
0.0645381063,
-0.1447977275,
0.2009380311,
0.8257278204,
0.4902735353,
0.3313704729,
-0.3343084753,
0.7797246575,
0.1792201549,
0.0280628931,
-1.0745682716,
-0.8109094501,
-0.601703465,
-0.5129685998,
0.6764094234,
0.5074267387,
-0.4520430863,
0.0208849665,
-0.0503678918,
-0.2224300355,
-0.4790474772,
-0.2547894418,
0.5849084854,
0.7727493644,
0.1921501458,
-0.2551058829,
-0.3650860786,
-0.9548174143,
-0.4809404016,
-0.3807872236,
-0.1245352998,
0.5202453732,
0.4833872616,
0.1530474275,
1.0605311394,
-0.3626457155,
-0.1491038203,
0.093497619,
0.0617198609,
0.0823153257,
0.5681584477,
0.5464271307,
-0.6826783419,
-0.3426967561,
-0.5254629254,
-0.4657117724,
-0.1219864637,
-0.3280234635,
0.2558830976,
0.1050735712,
0.4861675501,
-0.6381926537,
0.3060688376,
-0.0169183426,
-0.3286348879,
0.6218976378,
-0.0757629052,
0.1502845883,
-0.9468672872,
0.2280392051,
-0.0746322796,
-0.0642923713,
-0.9668992758,
-0.0471400619,
0.2723103762,
-0.1375613809,
-0.5583238006,
0.7267714739,
-0.9624555707,
-0.0697658807,
0.1072590649,
-0.052383434,
-0.0170417763,
0.49442029,
0.0179244,
1.1237748861,
0.6915769577,
-0.9252432585,
0.0283878017,
-0.0138078444,
-0.4905249178,
0.5716016293,
-0.5840004086,
0.4567330182,
-0.1050419509,
-0.1143990755,
-0.9996135235,
-0.2374277115,
0.4100951552,
-0.6218005419,
0.4815013111,
-0.2932136357,
-0.3251157105,
-0.068577677,
-0.2587305903,
0.438881129,
0.3799991608,
-0.4733295441,
0.5800492167,
0.3656178713,
-0.149590537,
-0.6990392208,
-0.4884650409,
0.0920269787,
-0.4191561043,
-0.349070847,
0.2219692767,
-0.1987138093,
-0.3050976992,
-0.2284742296,
-0.2960681319,
-0.0477919728,
0.5195893049,
0.6292545199,
0.3567572832,
-0.0009539577,
0.4973528385,
-0.0623014197,
-0.0329315662,
0.3796952963,
-0.4107634127,
0.4711140692,
-0.1361841112,
-0.0496303625,
-0.4786902368,
0.2511694431,
0.2697187662,
-0.4099403024,
0.9304123521,
-0.0311956592,
-0.7176217437,
-0.3543577492,
-0.6842961907,
-0.3136381805,
-0.5060559511,
-0.0269105099,
-0.7690918446,
-0.8154212236,
0.9336738586,
0.1739156991,
-0.2745922208,
0.1915159971,
0.2902101278,
0.0235290527,
0.9042883515,
0.5469280481,
0.076881513,
0.6694765091,
0.0478274897,
0.09386269,
-0.7696251869,
-0.534824729,
-0.5061025023,
-0.1773245037,
-0.501304388,
-0.2400481105,
0.0599092767,
0.0594455115,
0.1345842034,
0.320063889,
-0.5080627203,
0.7048706412,
0.6455021501,
0.0747870654,
0.2902990282,
-0.030110823,
-0.503732264,
-0.0414209999,
-0.4578273892,
-0.5050836205,
0.921631217,
0.5358552337,
0.4055771828,
-0.2294059992,
0.8283079267,
0.4619473517,
-0.2176824957,
-0.5724957585,
0.740791142,
0.479513377,
-0.5998901725,
-0.2124501765,
-0.3880614638,
-0.9722155929,
-0.0402925238,
0.1517304331,
-0.8830895424,
0.458021611,
0.2261439711,
-0.7343511581,
0.0862095058,
-0.8045241833,
0.7966677547,
-0.1442993581,
0.1082327962,
0.3187171221,
-0.6212502718,
0.3907488585,
0.0068310313,
-0.0578166693,
-0.163775444,
-0.088290751,
0.8829532266,
-0.0490274914,
0.8476797938,
-0.3132699728,
0.0397694819,
0.1921493858,
0.0732647851,
0.6681127548,
0.0682953522,
0.1805095822,
0.036527276,
-0.3726141155,
-0.0525000542,
-0.7131629586,
0.5385372043,
-0.4347959459,
-0.9035744071,
-0.2884258032,
-0.5053212643,
-0.1176878214,
0.2904143929,
0.4686028957,
0.414267987,
0.0048935385,
-0.1019345373,
1.3085078001,
-0.3217083514,
0.3103120923,
0.5312172174,
-0.3147975206,
-0.2501608431,
0.8438125849,
0.4346179962,
0.3318668306,
0.2903690636,
-0.1966223866,
-0.2448295355,
-0.5141138434,
-0.4649920762,
0.2691046596,
-1.0069694519,
-0.2232584804,
-1.1158442497,
-0.1683539301,
-0.4464299381,
0.1871537119,
0.1314458996,
-0.6718966961,
-0.6251742244,
-0.3815026283,
0.3024891019,
0.4087570012,
0.2986611128,
0.2224880606,
-0.5852389336,
0.0295192059,
0.5434998274,
0.3983501196,
0.0048100301,
-0.5197779536,
0.0715040192,
-0.2668149471,
0.2596569061,
-1.3316124678,
0.1841885298,
0.0641156584,
0.7376128435,
0.4724746644,
0.1704039425,
0.3599840701,
-0.3788351417,
0.6475149393,
0.0347497687,
-0.9372714162,
0.6458460689,
-0.3817367256,
0.0591741353,
0.4978412688,
0.1900177598,
-0.7463522553,
-0.4042338133,
-0.7191462517,
-0.5989077091,
0.9354529977,
0.1102948785,
0.0920342132,
-0.1078504398,
0.4239589274,
0.0691075325,
0.344799459,
-0.5483739376,
-0.3973443806,
0.1342548877,
0.1414374858,
0.330250293,
-0.4801762998,
0.203934297,
0.1354524642,
0.4721154869,
0.1131278351,
0.3781229556,
-0.04512766,
-0.3104628026,
0.1562320441,
0.3922027349,
0.6862884164,
0.0400617123,
-0.1518856883,
0.1226595938,
0.2247252315,
-0.4252825975,
0.1696819067,
0.1629068553,
-0.5649870038,
0.2673662901,
0.2405638248,
1.2720868587,
0.2687741816,
-0.5273845792,
0.3402576149,
-0.2449320555,
0.1883633435,
-0.1868331134,
0.5496071577,
-0.195258975,
0.1365156025,
0.4203161597,
0.0490276255,
0.4396402836,
-0.3896825612,
0.187883094,
0.40873155,
-0.3378155529,
-0.3969656229,
0.6849821806,
0.0007223173,
-0.6543335319,
0.6650409698,
-0.30654791,
-0.7493137121,
0.9246541262,
0.5027158856,
1.0580960512,
-0.7364136577,
0.118574053,
0.5221551657,
0.4110215008,
-0.1336881667,
0.1164121479,
-0.2607186437,
-0.3971801698,
0.2171540111,
-0.2126559764,
-0.3302124441,
0.1617692411,
-0.7714588642,
0.5031868219,
-0.7226055861,
-0.4000926912,
0.0780861378,
-0.1692434996,
-0.8788582683,
0.2074203789,
0.3190121055,
0.9114608169,
-0.778608799,
0.5119435787,
0.6671370864,
-0.3875409961,
-1.1069725752,
0.0280570947,
0.0134713594,
-0.7108727694,
0.6990209818,
0.9956396222,
0.1160231978,
0.1497744471,
-0.260784328,
-0.9634177089,
1.2029815912,
0.407943666,
-0.7074762583,
-0.3279807568,
0.0437351912,
0.4953589737,
-0.5539702177,
0.3969736099,
0.5075028539,
0.2516950369,
-0.1305453777,
-0.9566182494,
0.175346911,
-0.3194562793,
0.1846488416,
0.1080844998,
-0.3670213223,
1.1088066101,
-0.444311887,
-0.917399168,
-0.0949197933,
0.5423007011,
0.4934799671,
0.5326775908,
0.5247778296,
0.2302554399,
1.2585701942,
0.0402501896,
0.9768797159,
-0.2394152731,
0.2255943269,
1.025365591,
-0.2005106062,
0.4184245467,
0.3451401293,
0.0816265047,
0.4730761051,
0.5625155568,
-0.2362020463,
0.5062472224,
0.145937413,
-0.3192266822,
-0.2373700291,
-0.4213098586,
-0.4242887795,
-0.0252075586,
0.4418205619,
-0.7047765255,
-0.0000793388,
0.37624228,
0.0492842272,
-0.2607627213,
-0.3875287473,
0.5952609181,
0.1490418762,
-0.8763890862,
0.3343560994,
-0.0405689515,
0.3271665275,
-0.2959246933,
0.0796443224,
-0.198445946,
-0.0462593399,
0.0875718743,
-0.4999489486,
-0.2218381017,
0.0732417703,
-0.5249444842,
-0.2131059468,
0.9254966974,
-0.4355628192,
-0.2573772669,
0.1255930662,
0.3861913681,
0.2281784862,
-0.3906305134,
-0.4927611649,
-0.2234948128,
-0.0788577199,
-0.3127812147,
0.4442947507,
0.4405092895,
-0.2779442072,
0.8635091782,
0.6902871728,
-0.2043013424,
0.4293819964,
-0.0341474153,
0.7173917294,
-0.5357658863,
-0.7809969783,
-0.9743980765,
0.4845167994,
-0.0690890178,
-0.1468969733,
0.8296254873,
0.479588896,
0.7493132353,
-0.2437237054,
0.602279067,
0.3673532605,
0.4841851294,
-0.702459693,
0.734744668,
-0.0615155175,
0.619166255,
-0.119041644,
-0.7547434568,
-0.2652333975,
0.2416772246,
-0.3474216759,
0.3087682426,
0.5120721459,
0.8867370486,
0.2520267963,
-0.0594745018,
0.4763942957,
-0.2194488049,
0.2991030812,
0.5312270522,
0.9572359324,
-0.4136626124,
0.3557029366,
-0.1536325961,
0.0171690527,
-0.2156200856,
-0.8575910926,
-1.3781417608,
-0.7449916005,
-0.4069877267,
-0.2375359088,
0.2679388821,
0.9333306551,
0.4764567316,
-0.8715707064,
0.3323816359,
0.1157561913,
0.2294298857,
-0.0778183118,
-0.2145653814,
0.4395262003,
-0.4494179785,
-0.6892897487,
0.2955648899,
0.2131277621,
0.4616624415,
0.0070497803,
0.114295505,
0.246965766,
0.1329309195,
0.0456173532,
0.4000967741,
-0.7846145034,
-0.156960845,
0.4522400796,
-0.3335919678,
-0.0307257269,
1.0351800919,
-1.1003923416,
0.6513075233,
0.3882651627,
0.51327461,
-0.0121304728,
-0.0715042949,
0.4688789845,
-1.1805665493,
-0.0967417955,
0.1249142066,
0.4484513998,
0.4469606876,
-0.6394241452,
0.1353404075,
0.5463204384,
-0.4355973899,
-1.1388671398,
0.0939968377,
-0.6944512725,
-0.0310527999,
1.1767132282,
-0.470138669,
-0.0662029535,
-0.2228657007,
-0.1332742423,
0.1930925846,
-0.6664565802,
0.7963601947,
0.8612148762,
0.2302830219,
-0.4722038209,
-0.5365897417,
0.6072428226,
0.3334163427,
-0.4777665436,
0.189885065,
0.5495452285,
0.3684765697,
0.1690919846,
0.6444801688,
0.3082182109,
0.5967150927,
-0.1045572683,
-0.0230425652,
-0.5625840425,
-0.6893492937,
-0.902513504,
0.2157905549,
-0.1155146658,
-0.4118904471
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03003v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03003v1
|
Parameter-Efficient Fine-Tuning with Discrete Fourier Transform
| 2024-05-05T17:15:24 | 2024-05-05T17:15:24 |
Ziqi Gao, Qichao Wang, Aochuan Chen, Zijing Liu, Bingzhe Wu, Liang Chen, Jia Li
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Low-rank adaptation~(LoRA) has recently gained much interest in fine-tuning
foundation models. It effectively reduces the number of trainable parameters by
incorporating low-rank matrices $A$ and $B$ to represent the weight change,
i.e., $\Delta W=BA$. Despite LoRA's progress, it faces storage challenges when
handling extensive customization adaptations or larger base models. In this
work, we aim to further compress trainable parameters by enjoying the powerful
expressiveness of the Fourier transform. Specifically, we introduce FourierFT,
which treats $\Delta W$ as a matrix in the spatial domain and learns only a
small fraction of its spectral coefficients. With the trained spectral
coefficients, we implement the inverse discrete Fourier transform to recover
$\Delta W$. Empirically, our FourierFT method shows comparable or better
performance with fewer parameters than LoRA on various tasks, including natural
language understanding, natural language generation, instruction tuning, and
image classification. For example, when performing instruction tuning on the
LLaMA2-7B model, FourierFT surpasses LoRA with only 0.064M trainable
parameters, compared to LoRA's 33.5M. Our code is released at
\url{https://github.com/Chaos96/fourierft}.
|
[
-0.8707142472,
-0.7519926429,
0.2968554497,
0.2528304756,
-0.5127469301,
-0.1816026866,
-0.4450623691,
-0.5470662713,
0.0862269327,
0.4550417662,
-0.5681912899,
-0.2552537322,
-0.5472842455,
-0.1696681976,
-0.4668530524,
0.8586902022,
0.0047763842,
-0.1406656504,
0.2559818923,
-0.0733599886,
-0.322617054,
-0.1040972695,
-0.7202869058,
-0.5472412109,
0.675827384,
0.5526282191,
0.552852273,
0.5941220522,
0.663754046,
0.2784467936,
-0.0306876339,
-0.0625796989,
-0.8914051652,
-0.0454910509,
0.0036667455,
-0.2626385093,
-0.4935652316,
-0.21266976,
0.698982656,
0.8868679404,
-0.4393990636,
0.4393042922,
0.1134305745,
1.1306775808,
-0.7378338575,
0.1544145346,
-0.7809858322,
0.1129296049,
-0.1818555444,
-0.2187182009,
-0.1214184687,
-0.593010664,
-0.1317875981,
-0.8015893698,
0.1450870931,
-0.1747889519,
0.8837279081,
0.7932450771,
-0.3164278865,
0.5099858642,
-0.9241421819,
0.7204856873,
-0.4982678294,
0.8071106076,
0.6329622269,
0.7974526882,
-0.1246132329,
-0.6786900163,
-0.3849933147,
0.2949950695,
0.1427450776,
-0.0245514903,
-0.3694292903,
0.0869619623,
0.3865902424,
0.4534358084,
-0.3238292038,
0.1819896251,
-0.4318375289,
0.0372159183,
0.5057830215,
-0.0501976795,
-0.5038976669,
0.1328786165,
-0.1486245096,
-0.5083979964,
-0.8135923743,
0.2152152807,
0.3194176853,
0.3804887831,
-0.2194062024,
0.231813401,
-0.4889911711,
0.7413589358,
0.6075208187,
-0.0909507349,
0.0526560917,
0.2098638862,
-0.5792434216,
-0.0741911605,
0.230322808,
-0.01603489,
0.2502150238,
-0.1018592268,
-0.1668108702,
-0.1379258484,
0.2771155238,
-1.0323672295,
-0.4178466201,
-0.1239482164,
-0.4779421091,
-0.0411664471,
-0.149493739,
-0.7742012143,
-0.3300420642,
-0.4846695065,
0.6296957135,
-0.2840364277,
0.164332673,
0.2467832863,
-0.0827339292,
0.4871841669,
0.8456875682,
-1.1437233686,
0.5635175109,
0.5016400218,
0.3905565143,
0.0232469477,
-0.0397751518,
-0.7290719151,
-0.0134737836,
-0.2967740595,
0.7561876774,
-0.3782470226,
-0.3092023134,
-0.3431116343,
-0.2672757208,
0.0491039753,
-0.5185142159,
0.5523895025,
-0.7681701779,
-0.0855369568,
-0.4433211982,
0.0747679025,
-0.3500592709,
0.0649519563,
-0.7192661166,
1.2463415861,
0.4825743139,
-0.267051816,
0.2344025224,
-0.6373298764,
-0.342359513,
-0.2127517164,
-0.0364745073,
-0.471469909,
0.4006277025,
0.3010649085,
0.4346529245,
-0.5149312615,
-0.0099855242,
-0.4700290561,
-0.8143143654,
0.0129335169,
-0.4256704152,
0.3073479533,
0.0521338135,
-0.2668392658,
-0.2881866992,
-1.0560994148,
0.1191851944,
-0.0568086654,
-0.6670792699,
-0.1468599886,
-0.1463180631,
0.0580459721,
-0.0011638792,
0.1379885077,
-0.3868058622,
0.2562863827,
-0.5678423643,
0.1694301665,
0.7947722077,
0.072716482,
0.4497274756,
-0.3100839853,
0.2654210031,
-0.2442184985,
0.1290900558,
0.3664696515,
-0.2517723441,
-0.8823236823,
-0.4724344909,
0.5278610587,
0.092984654,
-0.6092780232,
0.5093842149,
-0.4992923141,
-0.7039846778,
-0.3206067085,
0.2851548493,
0.061379943,
0.6464694738,
0.5067815185,
-0.0977065936,
-0.4533517957,
-1.0101382732,
0.029813746,
0.0278020985,
0.0534657277,
0.1458696276,
0.4177462757,
-0.1108253822,
1.1092994213,
-0.717828989,
-0.3467006683,
0.1798159629,
0.1501577348,
0.4523950517,
0.6468206048,
0.8238915205,
-0.7437410951,
-0.6055805683,
0.0418778621,
-0.3689027727,
-0.0507893823,
0.1946250647,
-0.3582788408,
-0.0659528375,
0.2118131965,
-0.4447354674,
0.3222984672,
0.5342622995,
-0.1538317353,
0.0554025136,
-0.1107211486,
0.140325129,
-0.7177557945,
0.2797394097,
-0.1051543579,
-0.4150925875,
-0.5194962621,
-0.0002773436,
0.0351524726,
-0.1615589708,
-0.3457624912,
0.4456090629,
-0.1593171805,
-0.0304295029,
-0.1091875881,
-0.1995555311,
-0.1577941477,
1.028865099,
-0.0000603701,
0.4656221569,
0.4377997816,
-0.6284306049,
0.0056022769,
0.3339191079,
-0.3319660425,
0.698269546,
-0.5367965698,
0.2169240117,
-0.0110754715,
0.1659834683,
-0.6921483874,
-0.1183075458,
0.2524506748,
-0.0212396104,
0.2965505421,
-0.4797177017,
-0.4644169211,
-0.08211606,
-0.5526951551,
0.2139545828,
0.74346596,
-0.9044091105,
0.5713845491,
0.0835937411,
-0.1047002971,
-0.5507982969,
-0.7410690784,
-0.3340673447,
-0.3349569738,
-0.3825848103,
0.4652374685,
-0.3244957328,
0.0183363017,
-0.2289281189,
-0.3347239196,
-0.1571694314,
0.4558887184,
0.3397240043,
-0.1001066342,
-0.4429973364,
-0.0079252757,
0.6849073768,
-0.1803874969,
-0.1869589835,
-0.0399465375,
0.3990620375,
-0.2708151937,
-0.3621154726,
-0.0924264863,
0.3328284621,
0.4363357425,
-0.0459805131,
0.5873177648,
0.7599175572,
-0.6368783116,
-0.5008910298,
-0.3134599924,
-0.2726147175,
-0.6146213412,
0.3096155226,
-0.2610098422,
-0.7986612916,
0.5129368901,
-0.2883291543,
0.0280243736,
0.4393588901,
0.3890649676,
-0.3119521439,
0.6967920661,
0.7559027672,
0.067285113,
0.6496893764,
-0.4649066031,
0.0219847821,
-0.6712876558,
0.1461354345,
-0.6497000456,
-0.8837555647,
-0.3772758245,
-0.2102755904,
0.6403948665,
0.5150975585,
-0.7792492509,
0.4023494422,
-0.3781202435,
0.553634882,
0.3856843114,
0.2256385684,
0.2980339825,
0.3897468448,
0.4052667022,
-0.1509044915,
-0.4966643751,
0.0456485897,
0.7740601897,
0.4028987288,
1.0676430464,
0.4099182189,
0.8334525824,
0.3027788997,
0.2160925567,
-0.746062398,
0.4856266081,
-0.4196586013,
-0.132306397,
-0.4738381505,
-0.4505583644,
-0.8842067719,
0.3854081929,
-0.4055153131,
-0.8709264398,
0.7982926369,
0.3690192997,
-0.5443280339,
0.0707591921,
-0.500421226,
0.477463156,
0.0292610135,
-0.0827629864,
-0.3934310079,
-0.4400408864,
0.3403400183,
-0.5925989151,
-0.0567415878,
-0.2111177891,
0.0979272127,
0.7512809634,
-0.3510344923,
0.8989419341,
-0.4519953728,
-0.4537397325,
-0.2638383806,
0.1266531795,
0.6179854274,
0.1396503299,
-0.222928986,
0.2342300117,
0.1646564305,
-0.221017167,
-0.8763182759,
0.7513198853,
-0.9180999994,
-0.3660238683,
-0.0380188562,
-0.5257439017,
-0.7345918417,
0.1664596498,
0.205943808,
0.3936818242,
-0.2223266363,
0.374961406,
0.7344307899,
0.1282578558,
0.5882033706,
0.6320365667,
-0.1121878698,
-0.3632521927,
1.0468764305,
0.068836838,
-0.0039689634,
0.5873695612,
0.3398950398,
-0.1210408509,
-0.6965257525,
-0.4380889237,
0.0838155523,
-0.8861451149,
-0.6747162342,
-0.1638059318,
-0.1118279994,
-0.0216598958,
-0.4200277925,
-0.5144308209,
-0.8350290656,
-0.3502456844,
0.236786291,
0.7090613842,
0.4130494595,
-0.198231563,
0.7159291506,
-0.7056107521,
0.6092457771,
0.5016582012,
0.6808801293,
0.0225405339,
-0.6856281757,
-0.5270446539,
0.0713857114,
-0.1599525064,
-0.5366550088,
0.1421606243,
0.7867712379,
0.5019454956,
0.4308278859,
0.2287641317,
0.9322738647,
-0.3473894298,
0.4028613567,
0.0345460139,
-1.0166456699,
0.3782702386,
-0.4424541891,
0.3123470545,
0.9098735452,
0.0858206302,
-0.1431799531,
-0.0514953956,
-0.3259079158,
-0.6059605479,
0.8906515241,
0.0708178654,
0.1577143371,
0.612252295,
0.4380621016,
0.264818579,
0.1920309365,
-0.6583105326,
-0.3061302006,
-0.2996878624,
-0.2312179357,
0.0720868409,
0.0472422093,
-0.3584822118,
-0.623352468,
0.655941546,
-0.5502028465,
0.5376569629,
-0.1967722028,
-0.2354476452,
-0.5120242238,
0.1842838824,
0.6162204742,
0.3645271361,
-0.3832637966,
0.193852663,
0.3974689245,
-0.5496256351,
0.0967162028,
0.5133448839,
-0.0139583107,
-0.3447830677,
0.2379845828,
0.709415555,
0.6874587536,
-0.4264142513,
0.160850957,
-0.0608871579,
-0.3043338656,
-0.1119249016,
0.4258992076,
-0.0575548261,
0.4901079237,
0.5312454104,
0.4251439273,
0.1085273102,
-0.1003355384,
-0.0173605531,
0.2906017005,
-0.2673356533,
-0.2557221353,
0.4913446307,
0.1007369831,
0.104060404,
0.3243468702,
0.0096549131,
-0.0685038716,
0.3709309101,
0.4512726367,
0.6921076179,
-0.0034528556,
0.0801449418,
0.1942662746,
0.2555437386,
-0.1086116359,
0.4534927011,
-0.3821333349,
-0.5903350115,
-0.2268428355,
-0.9647618532,
-0.25391379,
0.0017995533,
-0.8052638173,
0.2930836976,
-0.754080236,
0.002153696,
0.0842181519,
0.101288639,
-0.5638095737,
0.102877751,
0.0962152481,
1.1240893602,
-0.7022436857,
1.1541587114,
0.4403429925,
-0.0727254823,
-0.6274179816,
-0.0813618377,
-0.3071891665,
-0.6802511811,
0.6446996331,
-0.3654402792,
-0.3943681419,
0.3326691687,
-0.5569112897,
-1.1425778866,
1.2599304914,
1.1417889595,
-0.52975142,
0.1779565364,
0.1964064538,
0.6162837744,
0.1068955511,
-0.2580432594,
0.6068682671,
0.744750917,
0.1202402115,
-0.8273959756,
0.0008763564,
-0.1556895971,
0.0154716475,
0.4633606076,
-0.5308348536,
0.8534238338,
0.1606035233,
-0.1728797257,
0.1378571689,
0.6814118028,
-0.0098365648,
-0.126314342,
0.6442289948,
0.507833302,
0.8766151667,
-0.2201524228,
0.8277656436,
-0.0364430398,
0.5255579948,
0.9690140486,
-0.1029367521,
1.0896910429,
0.4909779429,
-0.1426058412,
0.4500799775,
0.6979699135,
-0.1291588545,
0.7947162986,
0.0261359345,
0.0608593039,
-0.365884155,
0.2880473435,
-0.5178333521,
0.6428533792,
0.2870289981,
0.0154747348,
-0.5043584704,
0.1492694914,
-0.2978675961,
-0.0145236533,
-0.6016523242,
0.5878719091,
0.1925351173,
-0.3595080674,
1.169562459,
0.2215738595,
0.4650973082,
-0.8586612344,
-0.2435958385,
-0.2635354102,
0.2668677568,
-0.2252610922,
-0.2999631763,
0.3136076331,
-0.209592998,
-0.2989466488,
-0.3000074625,
0.5927423239,
-0.3703165352,
-0.3939223588,
0.2133262008,
0.299937427,
-0.3085663319,
-0.2205537409,
-0.5234435797,
0.1512368917,
-0.3049780726,
-0.2502872646,
0.5009665489,
-0.0036131816,
-0.0754690096,
0.4708406031,
0.5748311877,
-0.0808142573,
-0.189935863,
-0.1213326454,
0.9571389556,
-0.5951262712,
-0.5668958426,
-0.4716924429,
0.1243375838,
0.2753995657,
-0.3253851831,
0.3593591154,
0.3804466426,
0.4890095592,
-0.206286788,
0.3151941597,
0.0332298838,
0.2689463198,
-0.8493657708,
0.9149651527,
-0.6576216817,
0.2892739475,
-0.4024620652,
-0.9750561118,
-0.3112501204,
0.6696147919,
-0.0760927722,
0.2063254863,
0.5655160546,
0.6307970285,
-0.4423040748,
0.1608522981,
0.4016962349,
0.1512967795,
-0.0089627048,
0.6655691862,
0.5767839551,
-0.6040593386,
0.4411025345,
-0.4419963062,
-0.0018853259,
-0.2074889839,
-0.8971331716,
-0.7224716544,
-0.656098485,
-0.3131017983,
0.0025507254,
-0.1254560798,
0.8375287652,
1.1323587894,
-0.8372144103,
-0.0854931474,
0.1972027421,
0.0507291183,
-0.5888129473,
-0.1517655253,
0.4639214277,
0.1958099306,
-0.6242274046,
0.6080183387,
0.1137039065,
0.1141076982,
-0.1814388037,
-0.2098242193,
0.0115598543,
0.1781729311,
0.6354245543,
0.4304634631,
-0.3764989972,
-0.5839266777,
-0.194287613,
0.0269166306,
0.2103363872,
0.6466063261,
-1.0209132433,
-0.0949201882,
0.3548552394,
0.7009881139,
0.9502623677,
-0.1071598679,
0.4327287674,
-1.0342612267,
-0.0621661134,
0.0595962852,
0.3489166498,
0.1874963343,
-0.4204513729,
0.6047829986,
0.1026552022,
-0.1681257784,
-0.7459402084,
0.0297989063,
-1.5483009815,
-0.1505477279,
0.7201669812,
0.2815871537,
-0.1428980976,
0.0514603257,
-0.2458664477,
-0.0417425372,
-0.4519481957,
0.777354002,
0.2123985291,
-0.2700941265,
-0.3282546103,
-0.2837416232,
0.6623632312,
0.2031130791,
-0.9206225872,
0.0313119553,
0.2745821476,
0.1199726835,
0.0367666148,
0.5472679734,
0.1544242799,
0.5904855728,
-0.292247951,
-0.1229730174,
-0.2951352298,
-0.2140982896,
-0.7983547449,
0.2933853269,
0.2336832881,
-0.0126476418
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.03000v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.03000v1
|
MedAdapter: Efficient Test-Time Adaptation of Large Language Models towards Medical Reasoning
| 2024-05-05T17:06:31 | 2024-05-05T17:06:31 |
Wenqi Shi, Ran Xu, Yuchen Zhuang, Yue Yu, Hang Wu, Carl Yang, May D. Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite their improved capabilities in generation and reasoning, adapting
large language models (LLMs) to the biomedical domain remains challenging due
to their immense size and corporate privacy. In this work, we propose
MedAdapter, a unified post-hoc adapter for test-time adaptation of LLMs towards
biomedical applications. Instead of fine-tuning the entire LLM, MedAdapter
effectively adapts the original model by fine-tuning only a small BERT-sized
adapter to rank candidate solutions generated by LLMs. Experiments demonstrate
that MedAdapter effectively adapts both white-box and black-box LLMs in
biomedical reasoning, achieving average performance improvements of 25.48% and
11.31%, respectively, without requiring extensive computational resources or
sharing data with third parties. MedAdapter also yields superior performance
when combined with train-time adaptation, highlighting a flexible and
complementary solution to existing adaptation methods. Faced with the
challenges of balancing model performance, computational resources, and data
privacy, MedAdapter provides an efficient, privacy-preserving, cost-effective,
and transparent solution for adapting LLMs to the biomedical domain.
|
[
-0.0987502113,
-0.4553720355,
0.7206617594,
0.1422843188,
-0.5392862558,
-0.0101913037,
-0.1398214102,
-0.4405838549,
-0.0963594392,
0.321187228,
-0.4411268234,
-0.2809324563,
-0.4731624424,
-0.0329386108,
0.2792325616,
1.0463266373,
-0.2669220865,
0.1607842147,
-0.1290802211,
-0.479993999,
-0.3907463849,
-0.3435800672,
-0.5882019401,
-0.603772521,
0.343614459,
0.048729647,
0.6089529991,
0.4611783624,
0.6542357802,
0.2463458329,
0.2253478765,
0.0415487885,
-0.384319365,
0.1379598379,
-0.8698189259,
-0.2958962023,
-0.7486679554,
-0.2574123144,
0.536162436,
0.6912872791,
-0.1540743858,
0.3591260612,
-0.1619904488,
0.5358125567,
-0.5446740389,
0.0809323713,
-0.7212349176,
-0.2160133421,
0.0643108189,
-0.5870419145,
-0.4720655382,
-0.4413500428,
-0.0472135469,
-0.8152225614,
-0.0483691134,
0.1345492154,
0.5020608902,
0.5445353985,
-0.3028826416,
0.2884724736,
-0.7316631079,
0.6969094276,
-0.6711835861,
0.4486053586,
0.0690959468,
0.6531186104,
-0.5884945393,
-0.7131478786,
-0.3703878224,
0.0613382272,
0.2621297538,
0.2439566255,
-0.2620556056,
0.1648134738,
0.0525261573,
0.1482600123,
-0.8125988245,
0.2652649283,
-0.1792604178,
-0.254239887,
0.6117360592,
0.0269197673,
0.2469483167,
0.1188948378,
-0.0392958149,
-0.1006788462,
-0.6076852083,
-0.1763277054,
-0.3590976298,
0.0177050382,
-0.0944569409,
0.502245307,
0.0008256944,
0.751063168,
-0.0045001432,
-0.1864738464,
0.2247644961,
-0.144354865,
-0.3822897673,
0.138445437,
0.5636766553,
0.4994495213,
0.1680350602,
0.0431484282,
0.1359102875,
0.3038342595,
0.2040718943,
-1.1899626255,
-0.4831343293,
0.4297963381,
-0.6797322631,
-0.2041646689,
-0.5710601211,
-0.7513740659,
-0.8033972979,
-0.0504660197,
0.4729734659,
-0.4474864006,
-0.1605705172,
0.6207342744,
-0.1284005195,
0.3926765323,
0.5144184232,
-0.4903299809,
0.4142750204,
0.6615853906,
0.8411240578,
-0.2191896141,
-0.131536305,
-0.7682833672,
0.3428781629,
-0.3077780008,
0.9353491068,
-0.366684407,
-0.4514179826,
-0.4669347107,
0.4066732824,
-0.2978430986,
-0.3614237607,
0.4466573298,
-0.5498743653,
0.2539818585,
0.1528600156,
-0.5656482577,
0.1075387895,
0.1606690139,
-0.2559415698,
0.649276197,
0.2346730679,
-0.7608407736,
0.4856199622,
-1.1599321365,
-0.5978794098,
0.3705178499,
-0.1689238846,
-0.5030581355,
0.149405241,
0.2970637679,
0.4660387039,
-0.3280967176,
0.1955408603,
-0.5497185588,
-0.465585053,
0.3965230584,
-0.0111545529,
0.8230694532,
0.1707506478,
-0.2522416413,
0.387999922,
-0.9356001616,
0.0553467683,
0.2850802839,
-0.409906745,
-0.5221123099,
0.240470767,
0.1447270513,
0.3028756082,
-0.129593119,
-0.7738184333,
0.249154076,
-0.5552520156,
0.5752343535,
0.9283743501,
-0.0702516511,
0.4136138558,
-0.5153574944,
0.5315787196,
-0.2319262624,
0.1952276528,
0.2251856178,
-0.4098174572,
-0.3044730127,
-0.6254836917,
0.3599900305,
0.5732880831,
-0.6792892814,
0.4571245015,
-0.6753038764,
-0.4880822599,
-0.9403874278,
-0.2207834274,
0.0791969001,
0.5048619509,
0.4673259258,
-0.0982210711,
-0.5152167082,
-0.6655458212,
-0.4276693165,
-0.2587720156,
-0.5323576331,
0.4724327326,
0.5700922012,
-0.6667687893,
0.42230165,
-0.3952517509,
-0.0875980034,
-0.1652753949,
-0.3127582371,
0.4588393867,
0.409357965,
0.6423024535,
-0.4393906295,
-0.0685462356,
0.3590913117,
-0.6513509154,
-0.2108013183,
-0.1080630347,
-0.2835892141,
0.2085890621,
0.4961110353,
-0.2825245857,
0.2736168504,
1.123252511,
-0.6094259024,
0.5778352022,
-0.6314646006,
0.1095128953,
-1.3293998241,
0.2389391661,
-0.3564291298,
-0.5222594142,
-0.3778320849,
-0.0575680919,
0.1079535335,
-0.1448428482,
-0.3777115047,
1.0082184076,
-0.1667806357,
0.1051708534,
-0.4459927082,
-0.0695991591,
0.0809084773,
-0.0194792543,
-0.1065292656,
0.7133165002,
0.6429665685,
-0.6680140495,
0.2037985921,
0.439901948,
-0.2707258463,
0.7342658043,
-0.8795449138,
0.0691205263,
-0.1413841397,
0.5278553963,
-0.7972841263,
-0.4642523527,
0.0907060951,
-0.1825280786,
0.0274615046,
-0.3475450277,
-0.2434168309,
-0.4372099042,
-0.4295168519,
0.6211319566,
0.7047201991,
-0.7710638046,
0.8691973686,
0.4301904738,
-0.3273691535,
-0.1570526809,
-0.7005805373,
-0.1955470145,
0.0360889621,
-0.4057194889,
0.3812302947,
-0.4632048309,
-0.0612428114,
-0.2102648169,
-0.2997907996,
-0.0096141007,
0.1938352287,
0.4644041955,
0.4985521138,
-0.3179151714,
0.2701588571,
0.4373752177,
-0.2691616118,
-0.0470366366,
-0.4209215343,
0.2780294716,
0.1531306207,
-0.3352241218,
-0.3889124393,
0.1732004583,
1.0079485178,
-0.0689667463,
0.858618319,
0.2724443376,
-0.3564735353,
-0.3085425496,
-0.3388178349,
-0.2217917144,
-0.4907351136,
0.6460226774,
-0.4167517126,
-0.8687463999,
0.2782687843,
-0.4986136556,
0.1241476685,
0.1828177869,
0.781699717,
-0.0705629364,
0.9098169804,
0.470505476,
-0.1480658352,
0.427649051,
0.4129136205,
0.1115711257,
-0.8553262949,
0.0679559931,
-0.2457525134,
-0.3849676847,
-0.6079580784,
-0.5873096585,
0.4680756629,
-0.4913782179,
-0.4142916203,
-0.0768037438,
-0.5666270256,
0.4071290791,
0.1045354903,
0.3024677336,
0.2838021815,
-0.1052254885,
-0.0371372178,
0.1013996452,
-0.6560201645,
-0.2346880585,
1.2002311945,
0.2785279453,
0.8630120158,
-0.0093290824,
0.3007844985,
-0.085532926,
0.624992907,
-0.7945086956,
0.3665874302,
-0.2151593417,
-0.6738465428,
-0.07628306,
-0.501181066,
-1.1130359173,
0.3171615899,
-0.2247991115,
-0.5970293283,
0.2405232638,
0.2193947881,
-0.3569255769,
0.4023877084,
-0.517577529,
1.0483897924,
-0.0975547358,
-0.2891738415,
-0.0699177682,
-0.6498481035,
0.1049048528,
-0.4929907918,
0.6004347205,
-0.3303833008,
0.0293849986,
0.846891582,
-0.3000454009,
0.5477814674,
-0.2523536086,
0.212406069,
-0.2273009121,
0.3268009126,
0.3974270821,
0.0786440745,
-0.2505737841,
0.0220358688,
0.4145636559,
-0.7509554625,
-0.3280674815,
0.7007867694,
-0.6639714837,
-0.3326918781,
-0.4213782847,
-1.1377791166,
-0.3680213988,
0.523150444,
0.0846970379,
0.355242908,
-0.3841527402,
0.1724704951,
0.5218706727,
-0.5322027206,
0.2130453736,
0.7439065576,
-0.4460063875,
-0.2695560157,
0.6223971248,
-0.3446817398,
0.2932068408,
0.3041604757,
0.3732571602,
-0.2621451914,
-0.8132013083,
-0.3598589003,
0.6347982287,
-0.383420378,
-0.2187512666,
-0.5564315915,
-0.0378402658,
-0.2506511211,
-0.4284225702,
-0.4931781888,
-0.5126918554,
-0.0166460369,
0.0081724767,
0.7170034647,
0.2443428189,
0.0848460495,
0.3905408084,
-0.7290038466,
0.5935798287,
0.2092318237,
0.714723289,
-0.7226210237,
-0.8706302047,
0.0601019152,
-0.2494754493,
0.0806420222,
-0.5150238872,
-0.045133274,
0.3500094414,
0.3885453641,
0.1017987654,
0.0348601639,
0.6098703742,
-0.8189155459,
0.3253865838,
0.0020486256,
-0.6885023117,
0.6255555153,
-0.3770847619,
0.4022662938,
0.6840230823,
0.1165495515,
-0.2613260448,
-0.1524306983,
-0.2273758203,
-0.4118402898,
0.3761582971,
-0.137930125,
-0.0975040197,
0.4046615362,
0.4917367995,
0.2145528048,
-0.1914061308,
-0.3928920031,
-0.1151051298,
-0.1175175905,
-0.4942730665,
-0.2812661231,
-0.0017430821,
-0.3085787892,
-0.6009812951,
0.4991002381,
-0.4290459454,
0.1813434064,
0.2241663337,
-0.236805439,
-0.180668816,
0.6191306114,
0.3577626348,
0.7710445523,
-0.4421013296,
0.1492491513,
0.3501813114,
-0.6349430084,
0.3104482889,
0.5946518183,
0.1587240547,
0.0115557397,
0.3401922882,
0.4637711644,
0.2955821455,
-0.8439439535,
0.6574879289,
-0.2171279341,
-0.3450589776,
0.241961807,
0.1204597726,
0.0635525212,
0.3218655586,
-0.1252094954,
0.2936507761,
0.0902205408,
-0.4062556922,
0.2487474084,
0.1693997979,
-0.2071418911,
-0.427290976,
1.098187685,
0.0382605344,
-0.1503145844,
0.0916726738,
0.1998599917,
-0.1487247348,
0.1009773985,
0.8885324001,
0.5416458845,
-0.9006657004,
0.0263759289,
0.0437098891,
0.1550801247,
0.007907562,
0.653428793,
0.3828866482,
-0.6758342385,
-0.7887153625,
-0.6900134087,
-0.4475292861,
0.0305107851,
-0.4976830184,
0.0620244965,
-0.5839520097,
-0.1002497226,
0.2431084067,
-0.3832771778,
-0.6767395139,
0.1139307842,
0.0332347639,
1.0867648125,
-0.7700826526,
0.9826629162,
1.0559747219,
0.2136813402,
-0.4285351336,
-0.3966940939,
-0.0318305492,
-0.8777667284,
-0.0444805697,
-0.242943421,
-0.0858189166,
-0.0123023149,
-0.2489865571,
-0.4424814582,
1.0726133585,
0.5931874514,
-0.7003801465,
0.1589073092,
-0.1257415861,
0.5972765088,
-0.1590369791,
-0.0097786598,
0.8393261433,
0.3050869703,
-0.0373912454,
-1.0312656164,
0.4842950106,
-0.3011832237,
-0.0852648914,
0.1592724174,
-0.2485581189,
0.4033280611,
-0.2562828064,
0.2845312059,
-0.0276239347,
0.1319480687,
0.8103135824,
0.3185697198,
0.459415555,
0.1746826619,
0.9977294803,
0.1720513254,
1.3713086843,
-0.1151497737,
0.1485179067,
1.0586944818,
-0.6489384174,
0.6724412441,
0.5562126637,
-0.2535453439,
0.575968504,
0.3063050508,
0.1729391366,
0.539703548,
0.2883558273,
-0.2220485657,
-0.2131745815,
-0.0340916999,
-0.6795152426,
0.2791391015,
0.3457336426,
-0.3346631527,
-0.1316334307,
0.1196697503,
0.0878964886,
-0.2192630023,
-0.4037546813,
0.7271679044,
0.2139725238,
-0.2083856016,
0.5976216197,
-0.2566762865,
0.3843407333,
-0.486274749,
0.0723691285,
0.1545602232,
0.7882068753,
-0.1293199658,
-0.4567855597,
0.1715458632,
-0.2065384239,
-0.205925867,
-0.0211981647,
0.9718215466,
-0.0720898435,
-0.6506342888,
0.5300785899,
0.4569115341,
0.2011344135,
-0.1491293162,
-0.7431813478,
0.2746624947,
-0.2940293849,
-0.2288623452,
0.4116460681,
0.4592644572,
0.0440024398,
0.6227589846,
0.7701601982,
0.3394615948,
-0.049055066,
0.2725598812,
1.1068617105,
-0.6283643842,
-0.4852664769,
-0.7998867035,
0.3891761005,
0.0342928469,
-0.1222576946,
0.3804570735,
0.503062129,
0.4867378771,
-0.1547610611,
0.9995113611,
0.3210735917,
0.643641293,
-0.2931218445,
0.9450051785,
-0.5623986721,
0.0468899198,
-0.2665885687,
-0.5103304982,
-0.8321650624,
0.6532495618,
-0.4926924407,
-0.2099847794,
0.8806099296,
0.6570560336,
-0.3712205887,
-0.1903240234,
0.2943865061,
0.5582706928,
0.5707755685,
0.8172035217,
0.5679095984,
-0.5067955852,
0.4220207334,
0.1810786128,
-0.75404948,
-0.4455608428,
-0.955593586,
-1.0713922977,
-0.0436111577,
-0.4549395442,
-0.4455603063,
0.2162237465,
1.0231901407,
0.8774546385,
-1.086782217,
0.0730175525,
0.0376361832,
-0.0247813035,
-0.2205980718,
-0.1590542197,
0.5637285113,
0.0527745113,
-0.2589387894,
0.6208629608,
0.4961802363,
-0.0945452675,
0.4899432361,
-0.1155163869,
0.0642158762,
0.3267488778,
0.748184979,
0.3057888448,
-0.439032793,
-0.3803701103,
-0.1633995473,
-0.0010238794,
0.119905062,
0.8252306581,
-0.7064678669,
0.7075644135,
0.180773139,
1.000703454,
0.4551857412,
-0.1212590188,
0.4848871827,
-0.2705871463,
0.4118215442,
0.2378755957,
0.5498410463,
0.1511548609,
-0.1618859321,
0.3322149217,
0.137967959,
-0.9052918553,
-1.0376888514,
0.1100687981,
-1.1975685358,
-0.4810856283,
1.0613424778,
0.0696466565,
-0.5378656387,
-0.3549422622,
-0.3936565518,
0.4292649925,
-0.1217266992,
0.7805829644,
0.1986147761,
-0.1420412809,
0.0528763644,
-0.6803935766,
0.3967870772,
0.3745926917,
-1.1895799637,
0.0114538642,
0.2956934571,
0.760512352,
-0.3609110415,
0.9697548747,
-0.4005592167,
0.5262383223,
-0.2935470939,
0.1419240981,
-0.0570346899,
-0.0612904392,
-0.5093249083,
-0.1638921499,
0.1377653033,
-0.4764319062
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06680v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06680v1
|
Exploring the Compositional Deficiency of Large Language Models in Mathematical Reasoning
| 2024-05-05T16:35:30 | 2024-05-05T16:35:30 |
Jun Zhao, Jingqi Tong, Yurong Mou, Ming Zhang, Qi Zhang, Xuanjing Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Human cognition exhibits systematic compositionality, the algebraic ability
to generate infinite novel combinations from finite learned components, which
is the key to understanding and reasoning about complex logic. In this work, we
investigate the compositionality of large language models (LLMs) in
mathematical reasoning. Specifically, we construct a new dataset
\textsc{MathTrap}\footnotemark[3] by introducing carefully designed logical
traps into the problem descriptions of MATH and GSM8k. Since problems with
logical flaws are quite rare in the real world, these represent ``unseen''
cases to LLMs. Solving these requires the models to systematically compose (1)
the mathematical knowledge involved in the original problems with (2) knowledge
related to the introduced traps. Our experiments show that while LLMs possess
both components of requisite knowledge, they do not \textbf{spontaneously}
combine them to handle these novel cases. We explore several methods to
mitigate this deficiency, such as natural language prompts, few-shot
demonstrations, and fine-tuning. We find that LLMs' performance can be
\textbf{passively} improved through the above external intervention. Overall,
systematic compositionality remains an open challenge for large language
models.
|
[
-0.2428907305,
-0.6614668369,
0.9030711055,
0.251393199,
-0.197423026,
0.30499053,
-0.386111021,
-0.327758491,
-0.0303263552,
0.5639640093,
-0.6563467383,
-0.489821583,
-0.4729368091,
0.0957104787,
-0.1693126112,
0.7947937846,
-0.3424668014,
0.0915645733,
-0.4926222563,
-0.0462357588,
-0.663110733,
-0.451343596,
-0.258238107,
-0.4213730991,
0.3854746222,
0.1614602059,
0.4817978442,
0.4402289391,
0.4314775467,
0.3055655956,
0.035144154,
0.3027875423,
-0.5275699496,
0.2053623796,
-0.1608476639,
-0.9111012816,
-0.1762304455,
-0.2431399971,
0.7491711974,
1.0304508209,
-0.1579564065,
-0.1808465123,
-0.015634181,
0.5980879664,
-0.75478971,
0.4334010184,
-0.7288753986,
0.1307004541,
-0.2830648124,
0.2460288405,
-0.5269046426,
-0.0188240968,
0.0107213669,
-0.6948005557,
0.0423954725,
-0.3139719963,
0.4015338123,
0.311958909,
-0.4035024941,
-0.4320283532,
-0.9421523809,
0.9751551747,
-0.7053416371,
0.1029164791,
0.3207018375,
0.3317199051,
-0.3365042508,
-0.2789184451,
-0.4548963606,
-0.2452030778,
-0.0526869111,
0.122930117,
-0.1269230545,
-0.0926748738,
0.485194087,
0.1548733115,
-0.6563839912,
-0.1174029559,
-0.2843632996,
-0.3316298723,
0.7173320651,
0.4975713789,
0.4763227999,
-0.0009304051,
-0.0133255254,
0.1015768498,
-0.9485846758,
-0.1266349703,
0.3895124495,
0.1220307723,
-0.1549719125,
0.7756444216,
0.0920305401,
0.7890370488,
-0.4070293605,
-0.238808766,
-0.2229049504,
-0.2643923163,
-0.1109511033,
-0.1014862061,
0.4614093602,
-0.2560984194,
0.6588513851,
-0.0504713692,
-0.4766733646,
0.5557045341,
-0.074382171,
-0.5288738608,
-0.438573271,
-0.0652149618,
-0.0253887307,
0.0206157751,
0.0911643505,
-0.162935704,
-0.3817274868,
-0.5242961645,
0.4750614762,
-0.2956425548,
-0.1526064724,
0.5502223372,
-0.0389814973,
-0.0473667867,
0.2120510042,
-0.962210536,
0.3203504384,
0.9309017062,
0.5356327891,
0.0698758587,
-0.1774777472,
-0.3608812988,
0.2496594936,
-0.5326709747,
0.7836974859,
-0.7006806135,
-0.3493199944,
0.0279578939,
-0.3036010265,
-0.271122247,
-0.8133713007,
0.5665448308,
-0.3786173165,
0.2184434384,
-0.3254268467,
-0.5502685308,
-0.2442370802,
0.1325868517,
-0.6846549511,
0.6062751412,
0.1725716293,
-0.476685077,
-0.0377433226,
-0.3781936765,
-0.5947752595,
0.0136744222,
-0.4033746123,
-0.1972591728,
0.5646603107,
0.1545431614,
0.2225931734,
-0.345428139,
0.2914836109,
-0.435416013,
-0.5220634937,
0.6907140017,
-0.299217999,
0.6999773383,
0.0255470313,
-0.1759059578,
-0.0190317146,
-0.6827688813,
-0.2259481698,
0.3391028345,
-0.1570430249,
-0.5195980072,
0.0274890047,
-0.3701960742,
0.1791035533,
0.110225074,
-0.1852491349,
0.3387711644,
-0.5311583281,
0.5447879434,
0.8770834208,
-0.2011551708,
0.5501728654,
-0.4403805733,
0.6082659364,
0.1221791506,
-0.082997568,
-0.4189020395,
-0.4721130431,
-0.8906137943,
-0.4490125179,
0.1662442684,
0.4978506863,
-0.5989209414,
0.3806149662,
-0.2379097641,
-0.1299145967,
-0.1383048296,
0.3366287947,
0.3477998972,
0.4046929181,
-0.0609216839,
0.016228484,
-0.4475072622,
-0.9712436199,
-0.3236481249,
0.2841277719,
-0.2106915265,
0.1891614199,
0.5715993047,
-0.2372264862,
0.6457865238,
-0.7908735275,
-0.3044375479,
-0.2088830173,
0.0001762922,
0.2854201794,
0.2569168806,
0.3607345521,
-0.3869213462,
-0.3713675439,
-0.2693014145,
-0.9921668172,
-0.1176572442,
-0.0766915306,
-0.2370936275,
0.19451648,
0.2227298468,
-0.8560496569,
0.3064391613,
0.4447858334,
-0.2909319699,
0.6183482409,
0.0399653465,
-0.4446588755,
-0.8744412661,
-0.171587199,
0.0213364679,
0.1128886417,
-0.3700947165,
0.1312251389,
-0.1224936843,
-0.248678118,
-0.0289679021,
0.5638520122,
-0.7414902449,
-0.0167799555,
-0.2965230346,
0.2000620663,
0.0660507232,
0.437240392,
-0.0958580375,
0.4981529713,
0.6553462148,
-0.5992753506,
0.3531095088,
0.0648091063,
-0.3279390335,
0.5039081573,
-0.690336585,
-0.0543624125,
-0.2452333272,
0.5138055682,
-0.9374859929,
-0.4514043331,
0.2030002773,
-0.3082000911,
0.1642628461,
-0.1889534891,
-0.5524343848,
-0.3579654396,
-0.2089053094,
0.6730166674,
0.5184918642,
-0.1621496677,
0.7904480696,
0.1485753506,
-0.2096830159,
-0.4133748412,
-0.7485851645,
0.0238303654,
-0.1227953136,
-0.99110955,
0.0288590845,
-0.2011229247,
-0.529188931,
0.1106832922,
-0.2535984814,
0.10967803,
0.1843367517,
0.0874332488,
0.4363093972,
-0.37164855,
0.2956242263,
0.0180271957,
-0.2666559517,
0.458250314,
-0.4521096051,
0.5112051964,
0.0157402288,
-0.778193891,
-0.1995812058,
0.5540399551,
0.5401331782,
-0.3102408946,
0.6315723658,
0.3041701913,
-0.6595736146,
-0.6196631193,
-0.259280324,
-0.4833211601,
-0.4200121462,
0.1868151873,
-0.4556813538,
-0.9638513923,
0.8735398054,
0.1867972612,
-0.1221199632,
0.4456149042,
0.4639902115,
0.0762501508,
1.2227444649,
0.2519097626,
0.0750445351,
0.178711921,
-0.3772325516,
0.3724073172,
-0.7984839082,
-0.241712302,
-0.3772033751,
-0.2797704935,
-0.3066906333,
-0.4829282165,
0.5354169607,
0.0060129622,
-0.3813334405,
-0.0545139536,
-0.1947415024,
0.788233459,
0.3658134043,
0.101984255,
0.3875401616,
0.0567565113,
-0.3686490655,
-0.3013667762,
-0.7390441895,
-0.3393936157,
1.1067461967,
0.0688699558,
1.0136623383,
0.3227760196,
0.5835663676,
-0.175957039,
0.2447578013,
-0.9061455131,
0.5547985435,
-0.0753461868,
-0.614833653,
-0.0381131247,
-0.6951941848,
-0.7971253991,
0.2214799672,
-0.2131265849,
-0.6634842753,
-0.1594699025,
0.2174356878,
-0.2989355326,
0.151269272,
-0.6719969511,
0.7236174345,
-0.2293796241,
-0.437592119,
-0.1244707257,
-0.4763153195,
0.9988659024,
-0.1318899244,
0.2441595048,
-0.1109101251,
0.1321247816,
0.364616096,
-0.425206691,
0.948713541,
0.0952076092,
-0.5177669525,
0.4148009121,
0.5724430084,
0.7931476831,
0.1155520976,
0.2398055345,
-0.292309314,
-0.3528310657,
-0.5746853352,
-0.8123400807,
0.8425402045,
-0.5061377883,
-0.6406072974,
-0.4396062791,
-0.6153708696,
-0.4110734165,
-0.0278918706,
0.1213689893,
0.6805764437,
0.1983005255,
0.1159732342,
1.0402587652,
-0.0641320571,
0.2733412385,
0.2417916507,
-0.1098145917,
-0.3377817273,
0.8372206688,
0.0624153204,
0.3351766467,
0.3506402969,
0.3837273419,
-0.4511978626,
-0.3907947242,
-0.3093504012,
0.6818021536,
-0.8567192554,
-0.2395543307,
-0.364350915,
-0.2943312228,
-0.217405647,
-0.1306290627,
-0.1599332839,
-0.3520904481,
-0.3637695909,
-0.007097193,
0.1111366525,
0.6955066323,
0.0344035812,
0.1111875996,
-0.9600785971,
0.3215457201,
0.3974703252,
0.316041261,
0.2769046426,
-0.5820248723,
-0.2086372375,
0.1563586295,
-0.1887031198,
-0.7762435675,
0.0501284078,
0.0550067984,
0.6585509181,
0.5073038936,
-0.0206861999,
0.6062396765,
-0.3553656936,
0.5615296364,
0.0747921169,
-1.048889637,
0.3047366738,
-0.649828136,
0.4514772892,
0.1231586933,
0.2502892613,
-0.4634988308,
-0.2675757706,
-0.4264726043,
-0.5559111238,
0.4319915175,
0.1323808581,
0.374612689,
0.0920008421,
0.1485473663,
-0.063937217,
0.1093422249,
-0.7967633605,
0.0476454981,
0.1539072543,
-0.4583925903,
-0.0994861275,
-0.2319079489,
-0.4871760011,
-0.2971437275,
0.5120272636,
-0.1683559716,
0.1468786448,
-0.1214384064,
-0.20800367,
-0.119343996,
0.0696167722,
1.1351813078,
1.0027339458,
0.3148279488,
0.4567017555,
-0.1326201856,
-0.2258021683,
0.1136071086,
-0.0059098215,
-0.1706219018,
-0.275316298,
0.7064532042,
0.6451125145,
0.3815143406,
-0.9412327409,
0.4035133719,
0.1962716579,
-0.259724766,
-0.4304503798,
0.1174927801,
0.4595627785,
0.2113031596,
0.378939867,
0.0220578667,
0.0209391993,
-0.6592974663,
-0.1190298349,
0.6387218833,
-0.0216075238,
-0.5063687563,
0.4818762243,
-0.0574158505,
-0.0325390287,
0.6597504616,
-0.2605037391,
-0.7613458633,
0.5159265399,
0.7922593355,
0.7420076132,
-0.0830878913,
0.1250914484,
0.2366785109,
0.4223667979,
-0.080125235,
0.2482838631,
0.0893201679,
-0.8010447621,
-0.8034911156,
-0.4061434567,
-0.1543103456,
0.1531241685,
-0.119527936,
0.2000112534,
-0.3995530307,
0.31284374,
-0.1460652053,
-0.2362942398,
-0.3735125065,
-0.1586045325,
0.1851555258,
0.5253750086,
-1.1659628153,
0.2997790575,
0.5877082348,
-0.2184470296,
-0.9621717334,
-0.1760139167,
-0.0364262089,
-0.7766551375,
0.477822125,
-0.022417888,
-0.1298593432,
-0.2321657985,
-0.6751122475,
-0.5994781256,
0.511793375,
0.6621738076,
-0.4249172807,
0.1653872132,
0.2521120012,
0.5411706567,
-0.2905067503,
-0.0809596553,
0.3423761129,
0.6513451338,
0.4089306593,
-0.5749706626,
0.1484146416,
-0.1261682361,
-0.057799872,
0.4715696871,
-0.4795984328,
1.0840010643,
-0.2998735905,
-0.20856224,
0.0189428702,
0.388302803,
0.6290297508,
0.4830284417,
0.1148434207,
0.8323913813,
0.6190863252,
-0.1155682206,
0.8943057656,
0.1140785217,
0.2336587757,
1.0472093821,
-0.5029917955,
0.4949874878,
0.2936691046,
-0.156329751,
0.4134837687,
0.3064983785,
0.1335472763,
0.2065368444,
0.6865108013,
-0.6972500682,
-0.721301496,
0.1540418565,
-0.2970160544,
0.5524895191,
0.5279000998,
-0.1782265902,
-0.2657155693,
0.0195092689,
0.1911308467,
0.5077955723,
-0.1226106733,
0.6120576262,
0.3738501668,
-0.7750937343,
0.7245330215,
0.0227161702,
0.4074189961,
-0.6179218888,
-0.1918930113,
-0.4748292267,
0.2974886894,
-0.227616474,
-0.6695849895,
0.3572664857,
-0.1607435197,
-0.0991432667,
0.1904161721,
0.6688682437,
-0.401249975,
-0.7520952821,
-0.0967131108,
0.5678893924,
-0.0151825584,
-0.3631269634,
-0.3361121416,
0.2295614779,
-0.1383317113,
0.2438103408,
0.1923450828,
0.7161868811,
-0.3800363541,
0.7638587356,
0.7078761458,
0.0724521503,
0.1272895187,
0.049293831,
1.0373373032,
-0.6877347231,
-0.3192311525,
-1.0399301052,
0.3865537345,
0.1666332483,
-0.049527321,
0.7517446876,
0.58154881,
0.7066642046,
-0.5068677664,
0.7601578236,
0.4124410748,
0.1755349934,
-0.7243822217,
0.3723492622,
-0.3614985943,
0.4766608477,
-0.1506169587,
-1.1024669409,
-0.5496293306,
0.6253736615,
-0.1855513304,
0.0802385509,
0.726908505,
0.7199402452,
-0.3136776984,
-0.0822295696,
0.4311451316,
0.1822024584,
0.1450614929,
1.1250557899,
1.2593518496,
-0.158930555,
0.4072802663,
-0.017079955,
-0.1295167804,
-0.2812972963,
-0.788195014,
-0.9411180615,
-0.4502030611,
-0.1786335856,
-0.2343113273,
-0.1815178096,
0.6758353114,
0.510817349,
-0.6194324493,
-0.19878003,
-0.3211016357,
0.4311286211,
0.0780899599,
-0.2023248225,
0.0081739631,
-0.1950069517,
-0.5924572349,
0.3009958267,
0.3011854291,
0.20143646,
-0.497281462,
0.0203645881,
0.1957440227,
0.3195404112,
0.6943585277,
0.1956594735,
-0.6841930747,
-0.1370069087,
0.3059766889,
0.0096936515,
-0.0841990113,
1.1806894541,
-0.5132561326,
0.2635611892,
0.6174110174,
0.6334944367,
0.4207529426,
-0.2279929221,
0.5608332753,
-0.6306621432,
0.147818163,
0.4659396708,
0.5070784688,
0.4295206964,
-0.0664508268,
0.217442587,
0.6668362021,
-0.2283446938,
-0.7712141871,
0.6754127145,
-1.0257225037,
-0.3864933848,
1.0024625063,
0.0197788402,
-0.1839902401,
0.1874085963,
-0.1532095969,
-0.0281233508,
-0.0828932524,
0.7517101765,
1.0330957174,
-0.0079893218,
-0.0586039759,
-0.4721504152,
0.2297425419,
0.421097368,
-0.8246392608,
0.0024939582,
0.7814603448,
0.269749403,
0.0353136025,
0.2477458715,
-0.1317262501,
0.1931271702,
-0.0125093311,
-0.1904170364,
0.0561615266,
-0.4747827053,
-0.3178673685,
-0.000451192,
0.0703284889,
0.1425605416
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02985v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02985v1
|
Can Large Language Models Make the Grade? An Empirical Study Evaluating LLMs Ability to Mark Short Answer Questions in K-12 Education
| 2024-05-05T16:11:06 | 2024-05-05T16:11:06 |
Owen Henkel, Adam Boxer, Libby Hills, Bill Roberts
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
This paper presents reports on a series of experiments with a novel dataset
evaluating how well Large Language Models (LLMs) can mark (i.e. grade) open
text responses to short answer questions, Specifically, we explore how well
different combinations of GPT version and prompt engineering strategies
performed at marking real student answers to short answer across different
domain areas (Science and History) and grade-levels (spanning ages 5-16) using
a new, never-used-before dataset from Carousel, a quizzing platform. We found
that GPT-4, with basic few-shot prompting performed well (Kappa, 0.70) and,
importantly, very close to human-level performance (0.75). This research builds
on prior findings that GPT-4 could reliably score short answer reading
comprehension questions at a performance-level very close to that of expert
human raters. The proximity to human-level performance, across a variety of
subjects and grade levels suggests that LLMs could be a valuable tool for
supporting low-stakes formative assessment tasks in K-12 education and has
important implications for real-world education delivery.
|
[
-0.3396971226,
-0.9283364415,
0.8570410609,
0.0459599309,
-0.0588395447,
0.0837873444,
-0.2144050747,
-0.6588190198,
-0.0661923438,
0.0237121265,
-0.3476375043,
-0.4532875419,
-0.4854210019,
0.0998607054,
-0.3435953259,
0.8436316848,
-0.0272588059,
0.174473986,
-0.5191532969,
0.0805224627,
-0.531262815,
-0.7169498801,
-0.6520441175,
-0.366797477,
0.7649189234,
0.6062802672,
0.6128646135,
0.6453873515,
0.6375650167,
0.2013842165,
-0.1939145178,
-0.238527447,
-0.2773378491,
-0.0703043789,
-0.0315356888,
-0.4694977403,
-0.6588092446,
0.2968933284,
0.8064050674,
0.9778177142,
0.238480702,
0.2282031178,
0.3702828586,
0.5869945288,
-0.3187809885,
0.0919732004,
-0.275516808,
-0.1575026661,
-0.1071362272,
0.068090193,
-0.5690774322,
-0.5477640033,
0.193105951,
-0.6198933125,
-0.0788250938,
0.0811048374,
0.8070708513,
0.0553110838,
-0.4981805384,
-0.5778959394,
-0.5495442152,
0.9065880179,
-0.660842061,
0.1487463862,
0.4619849324,
0.4082805216,
0.089495413,
-0.8154205084,
-0.2811314166,
-0.4423797727,
-0.0707148984,
0.0844561532,
0.1785661578,
0.0152846137,
0.4064815044,
0.4862266779,
-0.5354658961,
0.3668677807,
-0.601156354,
-0.2595903575,
0.4033305943,
0.3889126182,
0.1721041203,
-0.1463893056,
-0.1981572211,
-0.1140838563,
-0.8902058005,
0.6112475395,
0.4568967521,
0.5071507692,
0.0982049108,
0.821289897,
-0.2809309065,
0.6589379907,
-0.0804967061,
-0.0256686043,
-0.010117176,
-0.2262888849,
-0.0005390625,
-0.1241961569,
0.6036359072,
0.5839333534,
0.501505971,
0.0473423563,
-0.4065880775,
0.1642139107,
-0.1742442101,
-1.0275659561,
-0.3315372467,
-0.0854366869,
-0.2546800971,
-0.2727173269,
-0.2286399603,
-0.800906837,
-0.3887913227,
-0.3783173859,
0.751281321,
-0.1885890961,
0.1490835398,
0.25208655,
0.1035252512,
0.3115617633,
0.6160327792,
-0.8189407587,
0.3734380007,
0.5552768111,
0.8580674529,
-0.2336513102,
-0.4887597561,
-0.5051505566,
-0.3048522174,
-0.3557513058,
0.8471234441,
-0.6224933267,
-0.450871557,
0.081882298,
-0.0429957397,
-0.0658601746,
-0.5526016951,
0.4546594918,
-0.8519383669,
0.4073670506,
-0.3397913277,
-0.8665917516,
0.168187201,
0.6376776099,
-0.5860376358,
0.9886974096,
-0.0416943282,
-0.5365114808,
0.302094698,
-0.4780079126,
-0.2320365757,
-0.0275329854,
0.0240673851,
-0.1232282668,
-0.1948770285,
0.2419822365,
0.3355260789,
-0.2810791433,
0.0842733905,
-0.2375797927,
-0.5944878459,
0.3720311224,
-0.4795808196,
0.3687109351,
-0.1911254376,
-0.0761274919,
0.016852593,
-0.7683945298,
0.3396238089,
0.1291683465,
-0.662905395,
-0.4756730795,
-0.1907613873,
-0.1108447015,
0.4092827737,
0.4363782108,
-0.6487113237,
0.3903738558,
-0.1853156686,
0.3693671525,
0.883415997,
0.0585705601,
0.5143874884,
-0.559410274,
0.7335056663,
-0.3297371268,
-0.0353609361,
-0.2928777337,
-0.7436202765,
-0.5832132101,
-0.2778096497,
0.4326179624,
0.3916113377,
-0.4257308841,
-0.0242583528,
-0.3345046937,
-0.6259092689,
-0.5278142095,
-0.058274135,
0.2962125242,
0.7603794932,
0.3452886641,
0.0019641146,
-0.0902437195,
-0.7225537896,
-0.4609415531,
-0.3342915475,
-0.3316578567,
0.2595667839,
0.7062723041,
0.2568387389,
1.1526492834,
-0.6496635079,
-0.0542033799,
0.0058231819,
0.1359082013,
0.2579037845,
0.3143178523,
0.3576759696,
-0.4567822814,
-0.5139348507,
-0.2229867876,
-0.6056970358,
-0.2951059639,
0.3200834394,
0.0377361104,
-0.115791589,
0.4991344213,
-0.5366050005,
0.2327292264,
0.3106172085,
-0.5232343674,
0.7309339046,
-0.1517887712,
0.2777638733,
-0.5393765569,
0.0286643747,
-0.028987037,
-0.1804767549,
-0.6026798487,
-0.1060029045,
0.3486455977,
-0.1215315759,
-0.5627216697,
0.9031445384,
-0.1463171393,
-0.0620072857,
-0.3817783594,
0.1130065769,
0.0104300687,
0.3654763699,
-0.1308780164,
0.9194822907,
0.2124036551,
-0.4936544001,
0.0735413805,
-0.0011076647,
-0.5774900317,
0.5531976819,
-0.8945065141,
0.1658628881,
-0.0834012404,
0.2166523486,
-1.1569913626,
-0.3699090183,
-0.0777647123,
-0.4638169408,
0.0115033481,
-0.2975862026,
-0.6319624782,
-0.4869597554,
-0.3458756208,
0.4639964402,
0.706807375,
-0.4857805371,
0.1979893297,
-0.0584829487,
-0.5153135657,
-0.2600691915,
-0.5411878824,
-0.2159940153,
-0.2953989506,
-0.6331358552,
-0.0392971188,
-0.4205142558,
-0.245858103,
-0.0407800451,
-0.1164543405,
-0.2586500943,
0.1538139582,
0.0212333817,
0.444999516,
-0.4478527009,
0.2083628625,
-0.1190819368,
0.0898940787,
0.2893417776,
0.092694357,
0.3584892452,
-0.3149044812,
-0.4820649028,
-0.1928538978,
0.0957446992,
0.8023685217,
-0.0651493296,
0.4659220576,
0.0324558802,
-0.4218686819,
-0.0830460936,
-0.322148025,
-0.4766327739,
-0.4857198596,
0.2668333948,
-0.3660672903,
-1.295994401,
0.5168931484,
0.1482653916,
0.1162493825,
0.3167882264,
0.4571740627,
-0.2594550848,
1.0763090849,
0.3583859503,
-0.0361618064,
0.227640152,
-0.0026972799,
0.2689549625,
-0.5149675012,
-0.0479488522,
-0.663500607,
-0.4573855996,
-0.5176577568,
-0.2805671692,
0.3235786557,
0.2702117562,
-0.3545254469,
-0.319024086,
-0.2829227448,
0.7243574858,
0.5754241943,
-0.1736152023,
0.4891891479,
-0.1896757036,
-0.1030973047,
-0.1798524559,
-0.1998243481,
-0.9665433764,
1.0275185108,
0.467477113,
0.7061910629,
-0.0237367004,
0.3984428346,
0.3051346838,
0.6156508923,
-0.9435701966,
0.7148547173,
0.2078175247,
-0.8497280478,
-0.7360447645,
-0.2894764841,
-0.7631724477,
0.3654167652,
0.1717056483,
-0.5512312651,
-0.1840791702,
0.0042819609,
-0.222270593,
0.1458366662,
-0.831810534,
0.7949421406,
-0.0199477635,
-0.3801805079,
0.2739411592,
-0.5356419683,
0.3788245618,
-0.3013167381,
0.3606390655,
-0.2647372186,
-0.032971181,
0.967479825,
-0.2540732026,
0.828425467,
-0.3835388124,
-0.2877601385,
0.6528817415,
0.075465396,
0.497184068,
0.0133064408,
-0.1798925996,
-0.3075883389,
0.1016379967,
-0.5473647118,
-0.6647014618,
0.7999299169,
-0.7896543145,
-0.6406559944,
-0.5348006487,
-0.6666564941,
-0.4283090532,
0.239148587,
-0.0054568141,
0.3612329364,
-0.0416690223,
0.1179472357,
0.6683490872,
-0.0329328179,
0.5482515097,
0.7358970642,
-0.3235787749,
-0.3821923137,
0.8507706523,
0.3883979321,
0.4529016912,
0.2620553374,
0.465583086,
-0.4375009537,
-0.4548398256,
-0.471234262,
0.3345599174,
-0.9977712631,
-0.0248618871,
-0.4783000052,
-0.1236639246,
-0.2601395547,
-0.26802513,
-0.1553285569,
-0.5751945376,
-0.2008854598,
-0.3176753223,
0.1559532434,
0.9834404588,
0.0940446183,
0.3775191605,
-0.6386463046,
-0.0637018904,
0.7097052932,
0.376033932,
0.0536114834,
-0.7324336767,
-0.2116549015,
0.1010870934,
-0.421444267,
-0.5136098862,
-0.0541209057,
-0.0296295621,
0.2063970417,
-0.0893835127,
-0.0382100418,
0.4402344823,
-0.7137430906,
1.2192467451,
0.0413272902,
-0.7389048934,
0.3236098886,
-0.5479227304,
0.5341429114,
0.4376411438,
0.375785619,
-0.6642292142,
-0.4653135538,
-0.136485979,
-0.7357399464,
0.6698405743,
0.0147576481,
0.134110406,
-0.107347101,
0.255451113,
0.1841168255,
0.1169005707,
-0.8544003963,
-0.1540668458,
-0.0112905372,
-0.3406565785,
-0.2510275245,
-0.3491134942,
0.2099752724,
-0.1204771847,
0.6051581502,
-0.1642778963,
0.0374241881,
0.1042162701,
-0.1446171254,
0.0325448513,
0.6827080846,
0.8524718881,
0.7479939461,
-0.3231459856,
0.1072455794,
0.1130179614,
-0.6945385337,
0.5123812556,
0.0471206903,
-0.1421245337,
-0.2678998709,
0.4277817309,
0.205876857,
0.0298171993,
-0.6760253906,
0.6222814322,
-0.1644313633,
-0.3226048648,
0.0105366418,
-0.2017754167,
0.1285429597,
0.1103253737,
0.5365200043,
-0.4393103123,
-0.0819379836,
-0.2600273192,
0.0758090466,
0.0504434668,
-0.3459050953,
-0.5833646655,
0.5759652853,
0.1289103031,
-0.1806114167,
0.5447242856,
0.0375565253,
-0.2468763143,
0.7398715019,
0.4495047331,
0.4049720466,
-0.2340466678,
0.151507318,
0.400213033,
0.4121244252,
-0.188380748,
0.3529636264,
0.1071277708,
-0.3540847003,
-0.6609811187,
-0.5885977745,
-0.6177774668,
0.2503370345,
-0.5505373478,
0.2741419375,
-0.4434697926,
-0.132605046,
-0.1328451335,
0.0338680074,
-0.6196091175,
0.5938445926,
0.0067499308,
0.8559083343,
-1.0494778156,
0.6618683934,
1.0034775734,
-0.418543458,
-0.7283476591,
-0.1770185977,
-0.0628786013,
-0.594738245,
0.7757152319,
0.331658572,
0.1304833889,
0.1432507187,
-0.5101553798,
-0.9270476699,
0.93572855,
0.0464925542,
-0.4210408926,
-0.3786923885,
0.5017752051,
0.6400598884,
-0.1461271346,
0.4262604713,
0.5168786645,
0.5106662512,
-0.046535369,
-0.9649653435,
-0.1049754322,
-0.1075679585,
-0.2947934866,
0.2200976759,
-0.5436282158,
0.7979895473,
-0.0913526341,
0.1561248004,
0.3463987708,
0.7362370491,
0.5510267019,
0.7473341823,
0.3697224855,
0.5697181821,
0.7603567839,
-0.2299072593,
0.9339619279,
-0.0395406336,
0.3512599468,
1.0208719969,
-0.3927209973,
0.8950914741,
0.6675474048,
-0.1932239234,
0.2665521502,
0.7702915668,
0.1979154795,
0.6731876135,
0.5328726172,
-0.1795670986,
-0.2434903234,
-0.193504557,
-0.3672935367,
0.1232173294,
0.2036191076,
-0.0996672884,
-0.0932485834,
0.2385113537,
0.0859616101,
0.1440307051,
-0.5758873224,
0.4423881173,
0.1999474466,
-0.6457371116,
0.3773587942,
-0.0537572727,
0.6277350187,
-0.4527679682,
0.0967326313,
-0.4453724325,
0.1594771445,
0.0691763386,
-1.1427218914,
-0.1009632945,
0.2833723128,
-0.4192524254,
-0.2934826612,
0.6198751926,
-0.2996653616,
-0.3807151318,
-0.0085098147,
0.5662485957,
0.1532505304,
0.1062648669,
-0.1365395933,
-0.0391505286,
-0.3720464408,
-0.456828773,
0.4753064513,
0.5823630095,
-0.1169300377,
0.6054759622,
0.4736847878,
-0.1000545397,
0.3614239097,
0.000037481,
0.6635552645,
-0.656157434,
-0.4743357003,
-0.7150366902,
0.5979872346,
0.0263017267,
-0.3251565695,
0.8254266977,
0.6173686385,
0.9499077201,
-0.1439072341,
0.7857595086,
0.2597992718,
0.795465827,
-0.4686153829,
0.442687571,
-0.3684234619,
0.1510593742,
-0.2834666967,
-0.9547902346,
-0.2507895529,
0.1368212849,
-0.803129971,
0.2224068046,
0.9422594309,
0.5300405025,
0.1785822958,
0.0373517051,
0.5601344705,
-0.0071479613,
0.7017909288,
0.5030336976,
1.3774915934,
-0.3689953387,
0.6681370139,
-0.1810844988,
-0.0606098175,
-0.1388069093,
-0.610047698,
-1.1359313726,
-0.3131894767,
-0.2645278871,
-0.267978102,
0.0488922857,
0.6221340299,
0.1827639788,
-0.4117259085,
-0.2318538874,
0.286273241,
-0.0585508198,
0.1155048609,
-0.2502193749,
0.5634610057,
-0.3037965894,
-0.7860981822,
0.4375629127,
-0.0192932691,
0.3514096141,
0.0041610044,
0.0226397868,
0.0392303877,
0.0945259705,
0.5965852141,
0.1448671818,
-0.6167777181,
-0.612562716,
0.3868535459,
-0.4114334583,
0.0427742079,
0.7334291339,
-0.718570888,
0.1050555706,
0.4914293885,
0.6718631983,
0.2152764797,
0.0201324075,
0.1934374422,
-0.6248219013,
-0.1435709,
0.4689332843,
0.2135609537,
0.5140405297,
-0.0463175327,
0.3564668298,
0.2237506956,
-1.0121330023,
-0.8399620652,
-0.0692373738,
-0.6551366448,
-0.118360877,
1.1504377127,
-0.0973968953,
-0.1434994191,
0.0355202928,
-0.212573573,
-0.2624373436,
-0.3887557089,
0.7072199583,
1.3034009933,
0.1399798244,
-0.0198961031,
-0.768804729,
0.3120512068,
0.446516484,
-0.8567216396,
-0.0379400216,
0.6018645763,
0.4348305464,
0.0044496679,
0.6918492913,
-0.1118959561,
0.3858911097,
-0.3499312103,
-0.1499858052,
0.0455361642,
-0.3498636484,
-0.4619832933,
0.3777378201,
0.5151632428,
-0.1815889478
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02984v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02984v1
|
E-TSL: A Continuous Educational Turkish Sign Language Dataset with Baseline Methods
| 2024-05-05T16:07:23 | 2024-05-05T16:07:23 |
Şükrü Öztürk, Hacer Yalim Keles
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CV, cs.LG
|
This study introduces the continuous Educational Turkish Sign Language
(E-TSL) dataset, collected from online Turkish language lessons for 5th, 6th,
and 8th grades. The dataset comprises 1,410 videos totaling nearly 24 hours and
includes performances from 11 signers. Turkish, an agglutinative language,
poses unique challenges for sign language translation, particularly with a
vocabulary where 64% are singleton words and 85% are rare words, appearing less
than five times. We developed two baseline models to address these challenges:
the Pose to Text Transformer (P2T-T) and the Graph Neural Network based
Transformer (GNN-T) models. The GNN-T model achieved 19.13% BLEU-1 score and
3.28% BLEU-4 score, presenting a significant challenge compared to existing
benchmarks. The P2T-T model, while demonstrating slightly lower performance in
BLEU scores, achieved a higher ROUGE-L score of 22.09%. Additionally, we
benchmarked our model using the well-known PHOENIX-Weather 2014T dataset to
validate our approach.
|
[
-0.0257993378,
-0.6613398194,
0.1175695509,
-0.0847592577,
-0.495154649,
0.0896010622,
0.1084676385,
-0.4776669741,
-0.1552648842,
0.3130306304,
-0.479529649,
-0.6672562957,
-0.956823945,
0.0871779025,
-0.4619165957,
0.8444114327,
-0.002307011,
-0.0816577002,
0.4723172486,
-0.2042562664,
-0.2023121566,
-0.1236436367,
-0.9079198837,
-0.164152056,
0.1467925608,
0.5474281311,
0.4523427486,
0.4439952672,
0.4676784873,
0.1367539912,
-0.16440548,
-0.0864874572,
-0.2978645563,
0.0186938252,
0.2249842882,
0.193660602,
-0.3775541782,
-0.1528667361,
0.8196043372,
0.6589796543,
-0.059540309,
0.6150686145,
0.1248626187,
0.5851770043,
-0.3800633848,
0.0785307959,
-0.3251658976,
0.1962695718,
-0.2623125017,
0.3001073003,
-0.5369750261,
-0.4634097815,
0.2130553573,
-0.5241419673,
0.2246108502,
0.0574909486,
0.9959475398,
0.2083624601,
-0.9439163804,
-0.2917086482,
-0.6548463702,
0.7050048113,
-0.7709305286,
0.7742052078,
0.2309066951,
0.5011060834,
-0.0423961133,
-0.9532953501,
-0.5677820444,
-0.6165367365,
-0.1247787699,
0.2454702556,
-0.0149611589,
0.2715270221,
0.2870590687,
0.3670417666,
-0.8612219691,
-0.1084005758,
-0.6774288416,
-0.1137117445,
0.513420403,
0.3206653893,
0.3868690729,
0.1730640382,
-0.2328655571,
-0.1657600254,
-0.5842899084,
0.3233703971,
0.1077234223,
0.6677823067,
-0.2746186852,
0.8719206452,
-0.1904264987,
1.2201474905,
0.0235498454,
-0.1123310477,
0.0825693533,
-0.3604069054,
-0.3171452582,
0.0406280793,
0.55893296,
0.1832793951,
0.1791651845,
0.0068995068,
-0.2091723084,
0.0943977386,
-0.2027215958,
-0.7235208154,
-0.1438533068,
0.2453372777,
-0.2311153263,
-0.1029472947,
0.0448922999,
-0.3879841268,
-0.4339130819,
-0.2869316638,
0.5063156486,
-0.3210313916,
-0.2395102978,
0.0848928243,
0.0721156672,
0.4390136302,
0.4168996513,
-0.6602288485,
0.6164737344,
0.3943792284,
1.1824578047,
-0.1743436456,
-0.0916055962,
-0.3571312726,
0.1091696545,
-0.1905644983,
0.3680271506,
-0.3957667947,
-0.1699290723,
0.1047851071,
-0.0070518041,
-0.4129510522,
-0.0834097713,
0.6225489378,
-0.1281763762,
0.4370687008,
0.0077221668,
-0.7300843596,
-0.125655964,
0.3058592975,
-0.8539478779,
1.2578480244,
0.2266641557,
-0.3921166658,
0.4514564574,
-0.5670849085,
-0.4523157775,
0.2358952761,
0.0302595403,
-0.7295385003,
-0.0976408646,
0.0672457814,
0.3235757351,
0.0051247375,
-0.1033191904,
0.146277234,
-0.4756955802,
-0.0375663787,
-0.077222161,
0.7856929302,
0.2264152914,
-0.6204177141,
-0.0327589773,
-0.616743803,
-0.0146412961,
-0.0484519638,
-0.3427630067,
0.0012155919,
-0.1921461225,
0.4455099106,
0.7003291249,
0.0972318873,
-0.772733748,
-0.0053961268,
-0.1421817094,
0.0142084239,
0.4445008636,
-0.0068446011,
-0.119158797,
-0.3013762832,
0.3801912367,
0.2098559886,
0.2169844508,
0.0771996602,
-0.8633740544,
-0.9799531698,
0.0623399727,
-0.1257521361,
0.4423699379,
-0.4037846625,
0.4547436535,
-0.4123290777,
-0.4632086456,
-0.4233833551,
-0.1089029759,
0.5280669928,
0.6689724922,
0.407028079,
0.0129285948,
-0.4206198454,
-0.5837556124,
-0.2450357825,
-0.2727694213,
-0.0515894294,
-0.0480012856,
0.5251122713,
0.4632012248,
0.5191442966,
0.0068287142,
-0.6472314,
-0.4275947213,
-0.1943080723,
0.5041540861,
0.3624919951,
0.3203724921,
-0.6628081203,
-1.0487800837,
0.3336815834,
-0.5640681386,
0.0661866516,
-0.0328668915,
0.2781769335,
0.4002779722,
0.3959166706,
-0.3335780799,
0.5356394649,
0.8330168724,
-1.1509931087,
0.4688186347,
-0.0160713792,
0.2939295769,
-1.246922493,
0.326321274,
0.3511355519,
-0.3768253624,
-1.182852149,
-0.0617978238,
-0.0629167482,
-0.2752252519,
-0.7677039504,
0.7588821054,
-0.5625036955,
-0.0063315528,
-0.0965650603,
0.1664404571,
-0.2426439673,
0.2193037868,
0.1356626749,
0.6985640526,
0.4238619506,
-0.607937336,
0.3011544645,
0.2890252471,
-0.3290196955,
0.446365416,
-0.7042070627,
0.1870236397,
0.2078762501,
0.0418555625,
-0.9670109749,
0.0381099097,
0.5607274175,
-0.4567990601,
0.4126673341,
-0.2156112194,
-0.0793836042,
-0.3991800845,
0.125011161,
0.1512965709,
0.5141753554,
-0.3162770569,
0.6837667823,
0.150276199,
0.01624294,
-0.6594097614,
-0.53312397,
0.2603400648,
-0.336101681,
-0.5341219902,
-0.0360285789,
0.1550710648,
-0.154872328,
0.0195342451,
-0.1821385324,
0.0005191275,
0.014673667,
-0.0620354675,
0.1359135211,
-0.3300805688,
-0.0292343032,
-0.3174014986,
-0.0208050925,
-0.2363094836,
-0.6857588291,
0.4061327875,
-0.4736325145,
-0.3361867964,
-0.72296983,
-0.1005884334,
0.6122631431,
0.1604931355,
1.0900230408,
0.4626796544,
-0.5945128202,
0.0628632233,
-0.3281128705,
0.1030961126,
-0.4166801572,
0.5907853842,
-0.5341451168,
-0.8497727513,
0.604852736,
0.1646773815,
0.4127560258,
0.288441509,
0.5631870031,
-0.1824473441,
0.7939801216,
0.4318417609,
-0.0473310426,
0.5566236973,
-0.1557567418,
-0.0012820552,
-0.653878808,
-0.4269184768,
-0.3671308756,
-0.3039317429,
-0.3328815699,
-0.049233444,
0.3365215957,
-0.0105223292,
-0.5157910585,
0.4943515062,
-0.4915885329,
0.2635059953,
0.1573088914,
0.302100271,
0.2830356658,
0.1483726203,
0.0612349957,
0.0492044687,
-0.3569449186,
-0.6074115634,
1.3017495871,
0.2463252544,
0.1482624859,
0.6190406084,
0.403855443,
0.5513195395,
0.2999168038,
-0.7025424242,
0.5262776017,
-0.3095763922,
-0.6583452821,
-0.8894110322,
-0.2048632503,
-1.1402505636,
0.3931832612,
-0.0748414323,
-0.9598424435,
-0.3060871959,
0.260109663,
-0.0768278614,
0.3385433853,
-0.6325836778,
0.9490222931,
-0.1667319983,
-0.3636075258,
0.0166895259,
-0.6155434251,
0.3284150958,
-0.1095912308,
0.054370638,
-0.1913113892,
-0.0222953204,
0.7548416257,
-0.599326849,
0.7001680136,
-0.3078594208,
0.0958258659,
0.2542352676,
-0.0575446822,
0.5915825367,
-0.3619914353,
-0.1678173542,
-0.1442041397,
0.0252227131,
-0.8562778831,
-0.4141679704,
0.3298780024,
-0.9883116484,
-0.4138972759,
-0.6635122895,
-0.242827177,
-0.1498195082,
0.3035932779,
0.3024709523,
0.4898317754,
-0.4875290692,
0.0177905541,
0.4339393079,
0.2443134934,
0.5015864372,
0.5635486245,
-0.0766865313,
-0.4489187896,
0.8036543727,
0.1840274036,
0.4431833029,
0.1559734643,
0.3626042306,
-0.5852580667,
-0.6808507442,
-0.612439692,
0.2246237397,
-0.7529658675,
0.2338268012,
-0.2360087931,
-0.2676903307,
-0.537350595,
-0.0348307528,
-0.2671890557,
-0.6069393754,
0.1511675864,
-0.3266106844,
0.2352994382,
0.8942679167,
0.1547002643,
0.4910352528,
-0.6368294954,
0.1358960867,
0.0691477731,
0.2229982913,
-0.1237715706,
-1.0200138092,
-0.5044615269,
0.0153387319,
-0.1407104582,
-0.8402593732,
0.2093750387,
0.6807649732,
0.5490788817,
0.2972689569,
0.0375932828,
0.4050872028,
-0.1439763904,
1.1056352854,
0.3500207365,
-0.8830866814,
0.4815141857,
-0.5068486929,
0.5002995133,
0.4011747837,
0.1806930304,
-1.1732807159,
-0.383476615,
-0.5541961789,
-0.8406685591,
0.8118101358,
0.778537631,
-0.0754786283,
0.3383736312,
0.1209390163,
0.019779982,
0.0282421689,
-0.8767718673,
-0.5644271374,
-0.5272811055,
-0.4223332405,
-0.2433584481,
0.0488525443,
0.0068624173,
-0.3187061846,
0.7981919646,
0.0260874182,
0.0243000537,
-0.1511100978,
-0.4383630753,
-0.095270507,
0.1720474362,
1.0956215858,
0.6151307821,
-0.2182768881,
0.0151105383,
0.4310334623,
-1.1900368929,
0.4760065079,
-0.01360323,
-0.2635938525,
0.1470858157,
0.4928630888,
1.0804055929,
-0.2975781858,
-0.146399051,
0.3901883066,
-0.0964814126,
-0.1178198084,
-0.642249763,
-0.4251048267,
-0.1466813982,
-0.0703904927,
0.5398132801,
-0.3636569381,
-0.1753114462,
-0.1087076142,
0.4407138526,
-0.0533208698,
-0.4925534129,
-0.6046286225,
0.5501917601,
0.1401997209,
-0.337187618,
0.8486081362,
0.1324884146,
-0.3961970806,
0.724065423,
0.678599596,
0.9109331965,
-0.5877488256,
0.4573092163,
0.8019720316,
0.5237514973,
0.0565648451,
0.386829108,
0.0266566239,
-0.6185575724,
-0.1780982912,
-0.4943177104,
-0.4950068891,
0.4647666216,
-0.5845887065,
0.5445592999,
-0.4012358785,
-0.1785415411,
-0.4843660593,
0.2962254584,
-0.815973103,
0.6560164094,
0.4264241457,
0.7940237522,
-1.4153407812,
0.7839077115,
0.9999668598,
-0.4777689278,
-0.836856544,
-0.0980474502,
0.1385469586,
-0.5452959538,
0.5618156791,
0.1578947604,
-0.0732158497,
0.4802543819,
-0.1610022783,
-1.0461457968,
1.1147760153,
0.1490007937,
-0.454933852,
-0.0486196503,
0.8180381656,
0.7145015597,
-0.2224176675,
0.4588951468,
0.7310654521,
0.5567054749,
0.3165584207,
-0.9800367355,
0.0704603568,
-0.2853723764,
-0.2360315621,
0.1363051832,
-0.7104034424,
0.4089957774,
0.0866772383,
-0.4457139969,
-0.0452790111,
0.7854451537,
0.5961976051,
0.4907481372,
0.3864451945,
0.609633863,
0.7012397647,
-0.1551831067,
0.6642410159,
-0.5074891448,
0.474147141,
0.8297948837,
0.0078805322,
0.7305110097,
0.5325907469,
-0.2227313221,
0.198480472,
0.7999641299,
0.2016228139,
0.365858525,
0.1330039054,
-0.4942429066,
-0.3751381338,
-0.0820498466,
-0.2674648762,
0.178980872,
0.5598604679,
-0.1148802489,
-0.4245630801,
0.0540515333,
-0.1376954913,
-0.0523725972,
-0.4576716423,
0.4954788685,
0.375333786,
-0.2416261435,
0.5398408771,
-0.3479328156,
0.231039241,
-0.5754367709,
0.0612560809,
-0.3909646273,
0.2472197413,
-0.1810309887,
-0.8953764439,
0.3297133744,
-0.2260565311,
0.3693808019,
-0.2011230737,
0.573728025,
-0.5518927574,
-0.8160122633,
-0.0395844169,
0.4589111805,
0.4436559081,
0.4619732797,
-0.7279247642,
-0.0707130209,
-0.2097357064,
-0.6023065448,
0.1255589724,
0.2657790184,
-0.3201056421,
0.732865572,
0.3883755803,
0.1599916071,
0.4627830386,
0.0847709849,
0.5713025331,
-0.5057783127,
-0.6162138581,
-0.57775563,
0.8270270824,
-0.0912734568,
-0.6187468171,
0.7458265424,
0.7208083272,
0.6938821077,
-0.2648017406,
0.9159767628,
-0.222168982,
0.4178208113,
-0.5286077261,
0.8392406702,
-0.4494614601,
-0.2100460529,
-0.265924722,
-1.0553177595,
-0.4271370173,
0.3976700604,
-0.1053972393,
-0.0148097863,
0.7896690369,
0.4638719261,
-0.0802560225,
-0.1828989536,
0.7996750474,
-0.0903192088,
0.4318479598,
0.789386034,
0.6047609448,
-0.9295136929,
0.6136510372,
0.0249046199,
0.0092140278,
-0.1022160053,
-0.6710807085,
-1.0780260563,
-0.9299228787,
-0.446903646,
-0.5711541176,
0.3591192961,
0.9036185145,
0.3313261569,
-1.2072175741,
-0.6316325068,
-0.165849492,
-0.2244284451,
-0.4314843714,
-0.1215718463,
0.7969311476,
-0.0180420429,
-0.6297742724,
0.3498001099,
-0.1967659444,
0.334154129,
0.1260940433,
-0.4090312719,
-0.2188172191,
-0.1710610092,
0.4774651527,
0.6014909744,
-0.7385531068,
-0.6967625618,
0.1503340006,
-0.3163433969,
0.0187563542,
0.5161079168,
-0.5179694891,
0.4392084777,
0.5554617643,
0.2939787507,
0.7317034006,
0.1729186773,
0.4441839159,
-0.7304255962,
0.1807748526,
0.1454942077,
0.2988791168,
0.37803936,
-0.2186457068,
0.4366282821,
0.3896697164,
-0.2651881576,
-0.663544178,
0.3101464808,
-0.899523735,
0.2106150389,
1.1666455269,
-0.243655771,
-0.0665096492,
-0.7077407241,
0.0703847334,
0.67019701,
-0.2370824367,
0.8294292092,
0.6284564734,
-0.1634896249,
-0.6758615375,
-0.329506129,
0.5516799688,
0.1902017593,
-0.4233815074,
-0.1807778329,
0.3968480229,
0.3799420595,
-0.1717083603,
0.6635094881,
0.092195414,
0.3457069993,
0.1035680324,
0.1440950334,
-0.4805578589,
-0.2526854277,
-0.4253302813,
0.0509775393,
0.1313728094,
-0.3460647464
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02937v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02937v2
|
Unraveling the Dominance of Large Language Models Over Transformer Models for Bangla Natural Language Inference: A Comprehensive Study
| 2024-05-05T13:57:05 | 2024-05-07T17:34:13 |
Fatema Tuj Johora Faria, Mukaffi Bin Moin, Asif Iftekher Fahim, Pronay Debnath, Faisal Muhammad Shah
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Natural Language Inference (NLI) is a cornerstone of Natural Language
Processing (NLP), providing insights into the entailment relationships between
text pairings. It is a critical component of Natural Language Understanding
(NLU), demonstrating the ability to extract information from spoken or written
interactions. NLI is mainly concerned with determining the entailment
relationship between two statements, known as the premise and hypothesis. When
the premise logically implies the hypothesis, the pair is labeled "entailment".
If the hypothesis contradicts the premise, the pair receives the
"contradiction" label. When there is insufficient evidence to establish a
connection, the pair is described as "neutral". Despite the success of Large
Language Models (LLMs) in various tasks, their effectiveness in NLI remains
constrained by issues like low-resource domain accuracy, model overconfidence,
and difficulty in capturing human judgment disagreements. This study addresses
the underexplored area of evaluating LLMs in low-resourced languages such as
Bengali. Through a comprehensive evaluation, we assess the performance of
prominent LLMs and state-of-the-art (SOTA) models in Bengali NLP tasks,
focusing on natural language inference. Utilizing the XNLI dataset, we conduct
zero-shot and few-shot evaluations, comparing LLMs like GPT-3.5 Turbo and
Gemini 1.5 Pro with models such as BanglaBERT, Bangla BERT Base, DistilBERT,
mBERT, and sahajBERT. Our findings reveal that while LLMs can achieve
comparable or superior performance to fine-tuned SOTA models in few-shot
scenarios, further research is necessary to enhance our understanding of LLMs
in languages with modest resources like Bengali. This study underscores the
importance of continued efforts in exploring LLM capabilities across diverse
linguistic contexts.
|
[
-0.2039884925,
-0.8404535055,
0.3553474247,
0.3616618216,
-0.0864432529,
0.0733060464,
-0.2527312338,
-0.6379396915,
0.0401286595,
0.5978378654,
-0.3980481625,
-0.1573641449,
-0.6801326275,
0.3724017143,
-0.3619158864,
0.8942174911,
0.1703265607,
-0.004051771,
-0.0727341622,
-0.0665994212,
-0.4695250094,
-0.2676033378,
-0.5351555347,
-0.6554690003,
0.428688556,
-0.0009846495,
0.7181885242,
0.4124154747,
0.4194644988,
0.2631300092,
-0.482952863,
0.0314645246,
-0.386182487,
0.0851605311,
-0.2780143619,
-0.9027401209,
-0.1592929512,
-0.1579056531,
0.73421067,
1.0185935497,
0.1321153194,
0.1682090014,
0.0371759795,
0.7080654502,
-0.934030354,
0.0250643212,
-0.6774040461,
-0.1188922375,
-0.1890921742,
-0.0531642288,
-0.6153544188,
-0.3782941401,
0.2371313125,
-0.150775075,
0.0512686521,
0.1917333603,
0.9812763333,
0.3724611104,
-0.5449087024,
-0.2834170759,
-0.8610783219,
1.0796430111,
-1.0551970005,
0.3421477079,
0.305403918,
0.2528877258,
-0.2042083293,
-0.2055788189,
-0.6703196168,
-0.1529159546,
-0.1909552962,
0.1733270586,
-0.348842293,
0.1073018238,
0.3362440467,
0.3507673144,
-0.5830118656,
0.3971371949,
-0.2330238074,
0.1452750266,
0.5923953652,
0.0939360335,
0.1501731575,
-0.6575741768,
-0.1972170174,
0.3145798445,
-0.8407012224,
-0.0053570289,
0.3421574831,
0.463534981,
-0.1606425345,
0.6830702424,
-0.0422651544,
0.9160451293,
0.0517153591,
-0.3020105958,
0.0369732007,
-0.5092489123,
-0.5421055555,
0.131714046,
0.757879734,
0.1128718853,
0.3451691866,
-0.2786302269,
0.0259448849,
0.0859438255,
0.0818479434,
-0.7260970473,
0.281183362,
0.1700902283,
-0.4997318685,
-0.087031357,
-0.1297065616,
-0.8560264707,
-0.5895849466,
-0.305942744,
0.3985100687,
-0.340831697,
-0.4873933494,
0.0228167046,
-0.0099307643,
0.676171422,
0.0195378624,
-0.9616361856,
0.2320000082,
0.8166787028,
0.8357493281,
-0.1885598898,
-0.1304984242,
-0.0511309355,
0.1182909161,
-0.4670842886,
0.7551850677,
-0.7049022317,
-0.3868106902,
0.1474289745,
-0.2004650384,
-0.3072842062,
-0.7654713392,
0.7815243602,
-0.5624338984,
0.0321324691,
-0.0658943802,
-0.7174702883,
-0.2187446505,
0.2536665499,
-0.701954782,
0.8569498062,
-0.0655813068,
-0.9566400051,
0.4174962342,
-0.5541548133,
-0.412240684,
-0.0128887203,
-0.1533284634,
-0.359814167,
0.3094372451,
0.0572004542,
0.447989136,
-0.6560672522,
0.5227950811,
-0.303068459,
-0.4807617366,
0.2407936454,
-0.5198296905,
0.867880404,
0.047651805,
-0.2488025278,
0.1984020174,
-0.8730739355,
-0.154919073,
0.1292415559,
-0.145211935,
-0.489690125,
-0.0711895078,
0.021294063,
-0.0058867419,
-0.104453586,
-0.6104093194,
0.2343631238,
-0.8817138672,
0.4669194818,
0.487475425,
-0.0290390085,
0.6006481051,
-0.0786901638,
0.5133705139,
-0.3471855819,
-0.0434274562,
-0.1370506138,
-0.5516906977,
-0.7428917885,
-0.2923221886,
0.5043874383,
0.4833779931,
-0.480227083,
0.3718693852,
-0.3770876229,
-0.3958941698,
-0.8035751581,
0.176227659,
0.2933292389,
0.2667064667,
0.1402055919,
0.2749177516,
-0.8686836958,
-1.135784626,
-0.4035404623,
-0.1131072789,
-0.1259569675,
0.0388888642,
0.6192179322,
-0.3859746754,
1.3660399914,
-0.2197762281,
-0.1036860272,
-0.9019274116,
0.3369522393,
0.7073478103,
0.2376670986,
0.5336609483,
-1.0321832895,
-0.4871162772,
-0.0772000253,
-0.7041399479,
-0.2457111776,
-0.3107409477,
-0.0420323238,
0.5524836779,
0.2231399119,
-0.624112606,
0.5557914972,
0.64508003,
-0.2554345429,
0.6701981425,
0.129692167,
-0.0602196865,
-0.9329504967,
0.1874387711,
0.1626668721,
-0.0688157082,
-0.8624433875,
0.1180180758,
-0.1626381725,
0.1765588969,
-0.1823598295,
0.6905499101,
-0.3615354002,
-0.0858675539,
-0.3906990588,
0.0425048843,
-0.1144355163,
0.2557436824,
0.1232059672,
0.6436709762,
0.5029029846,
-0.3856414557,
-0.0929550454,
0.1901251078,
-0.3886632323,
0.2858343124,
-0.831389606,
-0.2154826522,
-0.0403535962,
0.1244046986,
-1.0555317402,
-0.23044312,
-0.0721985921,
-0.2668827474,
0.492815733,
-0.2522784472,
-0.4788991213,
-0.2666755021,
-0.1537463218,
0.2220579088,
0.5384941101,
-0.4470951259,
0.8161087632,
0.2230212837,
-0.0157314409,
-0.672403276,
-0.8673143387,
0.23255077,
-0.226397723,
-0.5168406963,
0.0994408652,
0.0869875699,
-0.5333338976,
-0.1300444007,
-0.2711160481,
-0.2649534047,
0.0482284911,
0.4333961308,
0.4458027482,
-0.1806120276,
-0.1153251976,
-0.0763426125,
-0.2120361328,
0.0606020167,
-0.0335007831,
0.5275162458,
-0.1493049711,
-0.4239829183,
-0.3818606138,
0.3310196996,
0.3982459009,
-0.0444109403,
1.0899494886,
0.5764741898,
-0.324888587,
-0.0584395677,
-0.8339554667,
0.0134842135,
-0.3808898032,
0.220260933,
-0.3919431269,
-0.9212415814,
0.4372943342,
-0.1075848788,
-0.1537780166,
0.3792945147,
0.6390501261,
0.1392513514,
0.8626934886,
0.8343174458,
-0.2632801533,
0.1965313703,
-0.4172357917,
0.7016750574,
-0.8322475553,
-0.0656683147,
-0.5068600774,
-0.1088634655,
-0.9519641995,
-0.1919812858,
0.1248355731,
0.1953592002,
-0.0840486363,
0.2658199072,
-0.1352695525,
0.5090021491,
0.493404448,
-0.1839185655,
0.3926557302,
-0.3241112828,
0.1732404083,
-0.1018313169,
-0.7618031502,
-0.6780490875,
1.0506987572,
0.276966989,
0.7129938006,
0.1801056415,
0.6706106067,
0.1094716489,
0.2389697731,
-0.8667636514,
0.4599963725,
-0.0288733859,
-0.8274733424,
-0.1363540143,
-0.4001373053,
-0.9420697689,
0.329739958,
-0.3046647906,
-0.7987280488,
0.1670273542,
-0.0511727333,
-0.3724344373,
0.3863939643,
-0.8152612448,
0.804579854,
0.1133694202,
-0.635725975,
-0.1400471479,
-0.6946923137,
0.7071959972,
-0.1270452142,
0.2363327742,
-0.0890092999,
0.1332835108,
0.6426279545,
-0.0002503951,
1.0400868654,
-0.0087197507,
-0.2652805746,
0.4085502028,
-0.0130102281,
0.2153698951,
-0.0896129757,
-0.431309998,
0.3747341037,
0.0760579258,
-0.5783236623,
-0.7422195077,
0.5518935323,
-0.627524972,
-0.504298389,
-0.3112107217,
-0.5160703659,
-0.0941350311,
0.1060668007,
0.2202195674,
0.4253153503,
-0.0598644577,
0.2448349148,
0.4453177154,
-0.2791235149,
0.5130890608,
0.4276123941,
-0.1994064152,
0.0181350969,
0.7373102307,
0.1765847057,
0.411259681,
0.5490548611,
0.3816613555,
-0.4059202671,
-0.8319935799,
-0.1993569583,
0.357881248,
-0.5203644037,
-0.0962539241,
-0.6093502641,
-0.3636552393,
-0.385754019,
-0.189283818,
-0.3605914116,
-0.2065014243,
0.1927428395,
0.0397045016,
-0.0124274129,
0.8986752033,
0.077383481,
0.2601725161,
-0.6534440517,
0.3570144475,
0.1574418396,
0.2093682885,
0.0561772697,
-0.7607091069,
-0.10778182,
-0.0872582868,
-0.0907579437,
-0.808578968,
0.3980973959,
0.1769965738,
0.529930532,
0.5458064675,
0.129182905,
0.7285869718,
-0.4506535828,
0.7888081074,
0.1024293378,
-0.9376258254,
0.5139220357,
-0.2901828587,
0.3124805689,
0.4311513305,
0.5771248341,
-0.371701628,
-0.457972765,
-0.4370379746,
-0.9251084924,
0.4334975481,
0.3237339258,
-0.0360145867,
-0.0211835299,
0.3163662851,
0.2428800315,
0.2470528185,
-0.8867718577,
-0.2143891752,
0.1659340411,
-0.1296702027,
0.0317002125,
-0.5600423217,
0.2058359683,
-0.2820580304,
0.5826115608,
-0.1750046313,
0.2062454224,
0.1145190001,
-0.1482208222,
0.0674129054,
0.636920929,
0.3793839216,
0.7721279263,
-0.3688796163,
0.1097937897,
0.3476913869,
-0.196753636,
0.0385022685,
-0.1265842468,
-0.3353606761,
-0.0894586593,
0.9440543056,
0.9938283563,
0.3130319715,
-0.802547276,
0.4418464899,
0.1947428137,
0.1265891194,
-0.2464784533,
-0.041107595,
0.0186454728,
0.2354930788,
0.422644943,
0.1971052587,
0.1851458102,
-0.6797863841,
-0.0751987696,
0.5031659603,
-0.2430636287,
-0.4524070919,
0.3850135207,
-0.0382401049,
-0.285651058,
0.3586903214,
-0.3891870677,
-0.5407492518,
0.4770022035,
0.8082456589,
0.7981164455,
-0.0958553925,
0.0575023107,
0.5117861032,
0.3775603175,
-0.0330062583,
0.0541407317,
0.0465436392,
-0.8703269958,
-1.0247420073,
-0.8729878664,
-0.4924013615,
0.199646771,
-0.7818369865,
0.1347967982,
-0.2060596198,
-0.0198490173,
-0.0293874331,
0.0931518003,
-0.5024924278,
-0.0305908974,
0.2325724959,
0.9129744768,
-1.0209605694,
0.7473369241,
0.4844996333,
-0.3104355931,
-0.6080207825,
0.1670222431,
0.0350735672,
-0.6512578726,
0.867875278,
0.3066156805,
-0.2675520778,
-0.1250812411,
-0.4769444764,
-0.6896743774,
0.6364936829,
0.4332844913,
-0.5448035002,
-0.0931612402,
0.248757273,
0.6766542196,
-0.1646422893,
0.6727336645,
1.0552904606,
0.5927602053,
0.146035105,
-0.8780176044,
-0.0060965912,
-0.1978584081,
0.0650993139,
0.1888057441,
-0.4833246171,
0.4736308157,
-0.3406410515,
-0.2498514801,
0.2281344831,
0.6744442582,
0.2655949891,
0.2545945048,
0.4181274772,
0.405118376,
0.4164399207,
-0.0670294985,
1.2101405859,
-0.0678575188,
0.1813005656,
1.1255639791,
-0.4990805387,
1.1464412212,
0.6181620955,
-0.4033691883,
0.4636262059,
0.3386650681,
0.0035589479,
0.2086175084,
0.1167507246,
-0.0754821524,
-0.3907476962,
-0.5005226135,
-0.0323104225,
0.8411713243,
0.2098464519,
-0.0267961267,
-0.2434647828,
-0.0703361705,
-0.039100226,
0.3070758581,
-0.0976810232,
0.7451776862,
0.0139149455,
-0.519705236,
0.7667037249,
-0.2528904974,
0.9960879683,
-0.7462206483,
0.0476167314,
-0.0769269541,
0.1624530256,
-0.3273231685,
-0.733705759,
0.710657239,
0.2471625507,
-0.2934289575,
-0.0273643564,
0.6872227788,
-0.2469709218,
-0.5852101445,
0.6516612172,
0.4098846018,
0.0852560997,
0.0157564171,
-0.4804513752,
0.2356871665,
0.0052385498,
-0.2183889002,
0.3744494915,
0.2303808033,
0.1075754538,
0.8092306256,
0.3889745474,
0.3645064235,
0.0901116431,
0.320761025,
0.5471277237,
-0.5950173736,
-0.1111908853,
-1.1352518797,
0.3361523151,
-0.1824257821,
-0.0657358095,
0.943040669,
0.5335741043,
0.6424733996,
-0.0297361147,
0.7917788029,
-0.0477660112,
0.6047495008,
-0.543125391,
0.5951166153,
-0.4269882739,
0.1026116461,
-0.2129638791,
-0.9249628782,
-0.4189809561,
0.5821195245,
-0.5996230245,
-0.0776185393,
0.5478967428,
0.7413274646,
0.0735383779,
0.1539141238,
0.3922868669,
0.4723359942,
0.2730837464,
0.4726715386,
0.9422759414,
-0.4220288098,
0.4347192049,
-0.0599420667,
-0.2113469094,
-0.0661337376,
-0.9481920004,
-1.2020208836,
-0.3323157132,
-0.2273355126,
0.1000914872,
-0.0629277006,
0.9939790368,
0.6932251453,
-1.1048099995,
-0.3274188042,
-0.2160989344,
0.3013956249,
-0.113669619,
-0.2690063715,
0.36583215,
-0.3798141778,
-0.9719229341,
0.5212954283,
0.3613641858,
-0.2131844312,
-0.3152861595,
0.1050843373,
-0.5643300414,
0.3140467405,
0.6383777857,
0.1717569232,
-1.0256836414,
-0.017321378,
-0.1516773105,
0.1197028011,
0.0453280583,
0.6649826169,
-0.7090343237,
0.3141405582,
0.5392026901,
0.8866164088,
0.2811942399,
-0.0548013486,
0.4955907762,
-0.6656620502,
0.2613357902,
0.0324375294,
0.3632785082,
0.4096903503,
-0.0134467883,
0.6104860306,
0.1407483816,
-0.5082529187,
-1.0201585293,
0.3414161503,
-0.8018789887,
-0.2572569847,
1.2025967836,
-0.0083530275,
-0.3973012865,
-0.2094426006,
-0.1892801672,
0.2850334644,
-0.1435004175,
0.6821854115,
0.5142456889,
-0.1104580313,
-0.0942583233,
-0.8580302,
0.2436295897,
0.5365158319,
-0.5984789729,
0.09958601,
-0.0211105011,
-0.0241397768,
0.413528353,
0.2251422405,
0.2264147997,
-0.2492256612,
-0.0092187962,
0.0307426732,
0.1703424454,
-0.202482298,
-0.5146662593,
0.2494197488,
0.0438665673,
0.082439661
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02935v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02935v1
|
Enabling Patient-side Disease Prediction via the Integration of Patient Narratives
| 2024-05-05T13:54:02 | 2024-05-05T13:54:02 |
Zhixiang Su, Yinan Zhang, Jiazheng Jing, Jie Xiao, Zhiqi Shen
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Disease prediction holds considerable significance in modern healthcare,
because of its crucial role in facilitating early intervention and implementing
effective prevention measures. However, most recent disease prediction
approaches heavily rely on laboratory test outcomes (e.g., blood tests and
medical imaging from X-rays). Gaining access to such data for precise disease
prediction is often a complex task from the standpoint of a patient and is
always only available post-patient consultation. To make disease prediction
available from patient-side, we propose Personalized Medical Disease Prediction
(PoMP), which predicts diseases using patient health narratives including
textual descriptions and demographic information. By applying PoMP, patients
can gain a clearer comprehension of their conditions, empowering them to
directly seek appropriate medical specialists and thereby reducing the time
spent navigating healthcare communication to locate suitable doctors. We
conducted extensive experiments using real-world data from Haodf to showcase
the effectiveness of PoMP.
|
[
-0.325132817,
-0.4286940098,
0.8422058821,
-0.1121759117,
-0.4598863125,
0.141103819,
0.269428879,
-0.6354590654,
0.840220809,
0.8183994293,
-0.6647925973,
-0.6805092692,
-0.4046773314,
-0.1640010774,
0.049348563,
1.0223267078,
0.0461548083,
0.4085438251,
-0.6690911055,
0.1930765063,
-0.4552804232,
-0.5563213229,
-0.4891845286,
-0.4911238849,
0.5978014469,
0.5487386584,
0.8816078305,
0.6898677945,
0.5352014303,
0.0976362601,
0.2703038454,
0.0279043522,
-0.0188835748,
0.4481677711,
-0.1505990624,
-0.3742853105,
-0.5477420688,
0.1299614012,
0.0100438651,
0.8984977603,
-0.2720779777,
-0.0096789589,
-0.3396882415,
0.5045620203,
-0.1369404197,
0.0396599546,
0.0319859385,
0.7728505731,
-0.4693096876,
-0.6492823362,
-0.0238325763,
-0.1927426606,
0.6058901548,
-0.5877315402,
0.2105966359,
0.2594521046,
0.4532287419,
0.2830886841,
-0.4851945043,
-0.0785682201,
-0.6884721518,
0.2848317325,
-0.5965123177,
0.0928064436,
0.9092566967,
0.9943010211,
-0.3599925637,
-0.779014945,
-0.1951250434,
0.0368868411,
-0.4660664201,
0.6016098857,
0.1338227242,
0.1236845478,
-0.2360125482,
0.4294317961,
-0.5441766977,
-0.0118635343,
-0.3039792776,
-0.1917403489,
0.8511949182,
0.7101495862,
0.4149938226,
-0.0783017874,
-0.5360410213,
0.452755928,
-0.5851293206,
0.0688783824,
-0.0282908939,
0.0092824697,
-0.4179121852,
0.4379824996,
-0.2393070906,
0.6067136526,
0.4194432199,
-0.3168467879,
0.3899649382,
-0.205713585,
-0.0025525189,
0.402518481,
0.6386008859,
0.3741127551,
-0.3050161898,
-0.2176051438,
0.1539279372,
-0.2298999727,
0.2079225332,
-0.9252979159,
-0.5768834352,
0.5646731257,
-0.7253757119,
-0.4231598973,
-0.0377761535,
-1.1322675943,
-1.1970412731,
-0.0510217436,
0.1357311159,
-0.3364680409,
-0.1054989323,
0.2718441188,
-0.206883505,
-0.3658566475,
0.5089482665,
-0.6038703322,
0.2611593604,
0.4583780169,
0.5625289679,
-0.0814877898,
-0.1478801072,
-0.9413054585,
0.5535479188,
-0.120763652,
1.0006006956,
-0.8431406617,
-0.6201481819,
-0.0285502821,
-0.2407764643,
0.0545049906,
-0.5154568553,
0.3217945993,
-0.0861764997,
0.4351962805,
-0.1868755221,
-0.459577322,
0.1105247959,
-0.0294327475,
-0.5816173553,
0.2218301147,
0.5150800347,
-1.228390336,
0.3603047431,
-0.3677827418,
-0.8333332539,
0.3819584846,
-0.7258732319,
-0.794765532,
0.3908142745,
0.2977250814,
0.6290191412,
-0.4397361875,
0.2626588643,
-0.4010049105,
-0.2394816726,
0.0779046118,
0.3340093493,
0.1697236001,
0.0715469047,
-0.1051608324,
0.3261377215,
-0.4774032831,
-0.4611864984,
0.1877031028,
0.1918028593,
-0.3619888723,
0.2818315923,
-0.631968677,
0.0831677765,
0.0059168567,
-0.3534735739,
0.3443040252,
-0.4791662693,
0.2140666544,
0.5243867636,
0.305156827,
0.4313423932,
-0.6612061262,
1.1034429073,
0.1917081326,
0.4907115698,
-0.3068513274,
-1.1501758099,
0.1572426558,
-0.3160052896,
0.1137939617,
0.5104253888,
-0.7029021978,
0.1173223853,
-0.1273176074,
-0.5095942616,
-0.4327512681,
-0.2553221881,
0.2123448402,
0.9993823171,
0.2875924408,
-0.4255243838,
-0.6622550488,
-0.542303741,
-0.1429140419,
-0.3354348838,
-0.3501588404,
0.5123426914,
0.0557752326,
-0.4212391675,
0.8858268857,
-0.8015805483,
-0.6240891218,
-0.6026200652,
-0.0280089118,
0.2795817852,
0.2524638772,
0.4006607234,
-0.8563857675,
-0.6647822261,
0.2466626465,
-0.739068985,
-0.1985977292,
0.1106013507,
-0.0885307267,
-0.2656959593,
0.1489794254,
-0.2307849526,
0.9608882666,
0.7967664003,
-0.7888197303,
0.4820899665,
-0.6372831464,
0.0192265827,
-1.0354491472,
-0.153858006,
-0.002972574,
-0.4310100377,
-0.6402971148,
-0.5021207929,
-0.1832659692,
-0.4881173372,
-0.1243200526,
0.7700238228,
-0.1502095014,
0.0466294736,
0.0427196771,
-0.3567740619,
0.0842167065,
-0.095946826,
0.1570513397,
0.285908103,
0.5324013233,
-0.2546679676,
0.1707725525,
0.4085120261,
-0.4970208704,
0.6807530522,
-0.4808365107,
0.0061653135,
-0.1456921399,
0.7291820645,
-0.6112699509,
-0.6598168612,
0.5211800337,
-0.6989774108,
0.2577613294,
0.1099894643,
-0.240391016,
-0.5200226307,
-0.2656780779,
0.3687261045,
0.6030573249,
-0.3002644181,
0.9459424019,
0.7354421616,
-0.3391581178,
-0.0922720581,
-0.8930054307,
-0.0538460203,
-0.2991088033,
-0.6504217386,
0.5742766261,
-0.0260878205,
-0.0947821438,
-0.0759689584,
-0.0049087373,
-0.126624018,
-0.0716009811,
0.814265728,
0.3657930791,
0.0051345737,
0.4083011448,
0.144414261,
-0.4571293592,
-0.2212935984,
-0.1964116842,
0.4171921313,
0.357614547,
-0.4838291407,
-0.8032671809,
0.7416362762,
0.5317100883,
-0.3781610429,
0.812206924,
0.3923096657,
-0.604842782,
0.1486303657,
-0.4426790476,
-0.2325033396,
-0.376390934,
0.0808250085,
-0.3086237013,
-0.341444999,
0.66580832,
0.0236046724,
-0.3333611488,
0.2037639469,
0.4434411526,
-0.4465722442,
1.4641548395,
0.5559365749,
0.0780660361,
0.2218457609,
0.0560856387,
0.1277285665,
-0.4115320444,
-0.6605803967,
-0.1575039178,
-0.3741760552,
-0.4716407359,
-0.4288767278,
0.6099426746,
-0.1168899313,
-0.1984999329,
0.0789545253,
-0.6514268517,
-0.049378965,
0.3640299439,
0.5499290824,
0.4222294092,
-0.1680677384,
-0.1704010218,
-0.2157203406,
-0.5333814025,
-0.1335671097,
1.0688738823,
0.4146886766,
0.5879268646,
-0.2483866215,
0.9788349867,
0.5624072552,
0.4805848002,
-0.4083060026,
0.1082992181,
-0.4081581831,
-0.5563660264,
0.0006414261,
-0.3637944162,
-1.1871904135,
-0.2594454288,
-0.1663662642,
-0.7014667392,
0.3803091347,
0.4027798176,
-1.0006862879,
0.1429496109,
-0.7096017599,
0.8320714831,
-0.3204573095,
-0.0857490301,
-0.0681129918,
-0.9707297087,
-0.1434915215,
-0.0680959076,
0.4581693411,
-0.2467229813,
-0.2759271562,
0.611497879,
-0.5846376419,
0.8071981072,
-0.3477143049,
0.2799920738,
-0.0903982744,
-0.0343886763,
0.4781260192,
0.447914809,
-0.2022811025,
0.0054077799,
0.1529643834,
-0.6377542019,
-0.3551631868,
0.6742472053,
-0.6112712026,
-0.6277458668,
-0.5324764252,
-0.2924446762,
-0.5927627087,
-0.0606511012,
0.3736694753,
0.4737711847,
0.0510852225,
-0.3805253804,
0.267173022,
-0.514528513,
-0.2361611575,
0.4757610261,
-0.4868502319,
-0.5189564824,
0.7288963199,
0.0510582216,
0.0520254001,
0.6228201389,
0.954194665,
0.0236312952,
-0.6606473327,
-0.2002827227,
0.1875337213,
-0.4575044215,
-0.3493340909,
-0.647058785,
0.1239376143,
-0.5257542729,
-0.3187903762,
-0.0127290953,
0.1067666113,
-0.2177861333,
0.0049692774,
0.135692507,
0.7402223349,
0.1364167929,
0.4789344072,
-0.6685714126,
0.4316343367,
0.0934029371,
0.1868763864,
-0.4539217055,
-0.3851726949,
-0.2755749524,
-0.051155977,
-0.0801227465,
-1.1584694386,
0.6651024818,
0.1063440144,
0.5962602496,
0.7419870496,
0.3974903822,
0.4936259091,
-0.4288682342,
0.3069781363,
0.55363065,
-0.5510716438,
0.8732395172,
-0.225152269,
0.2324952334,
0.5552845001,
0.4888059199,
-0.5188319683,
0.0560157709,
-0.5895503163,
-0.3789569438,
0.3811108768,
-0.1973386854,
-0.2829296887,
0.0808963552,
0.2315265238,
0.7123431563,
0.2063489556,
0.1367257684,
-0.1194368973,
-0.3358605504,
-0.3094507754,
-0.4687889218,
-0.1033409312,
-0.1546421349,
-0.4430185854,
0.1665263921,
-0.1483977139,
0.46308887,
0.5748639703,
0.3820709884,
-0.3949446976,
-0.1203708723,
0.2738952041,
0.704949677,
-0.4015577734,
0.248412475,
-0.0080273291,
-0.4720366001,
-0.3294171393,
0.281303972,
0.3072562516,
0.2014784366,
0.3931361437,
0.5816758871,
0.1393702775,
-0.7582000494,
0.6991131902,
-0.1184230596,
0.1203328371,
-0.5634145141,
-0.2185803801,
0.196802184,
0.4095915258,
0.2622012496,
0.0492030047,
0.2898721993,
-0.5039445758,
0.2081490755,
-0.0451616123,
-0.8462981582,
-0.6842454076,
0.8135626912,
0.3620403707,
-0.3747822642,
0.4560762644,
-0.0300232675,
-0.3413047791,
0.6684643626,
0.422868669,
0.3827040792,
-0.6458699107,
0.4508078098,
0.0279993191,
-0.2898441255,
0.0525027104,
0.1614238918,
0.3866048455,
-0.103717871,
-0.4952844083,
-0.42568928,
-0.5827142,
-0.0208349861,
-0.3981903493,
0.7185972333,
-0.4640380144,
-0.30442518,
0.2199838012,
0.1874596179,
-0.5425477624,
0.4261006117,
0.6416476965,
1.007212162,
-0.6828445196,
1.0255001783,
0.8647966981,
-0.3465120792,
-0.3166723847,
0.1875280142,
0.058470957,
-0.9139914513,
0.1626388878,
0.5325193405,
0.5083310008,
-0.320756048,
-0.0890428275,
-0.402133137,
1.2018307447,
0.6017374992,
-0.5818365216,
-0.2806394994,
0.105709672,
0.6023972631,
-0.7401897311,
0.0775761083,
0.3512255847,
0.4737019539,
0.4414579272,
-0.9004330039,
0.1260379404,
-0.143833369,
-0.3710314333,
0.2798951268,
-0.2004000396,
0.8567144275,
-0.8330232501,
-0.1650270075,
0.1682183594,
0.5062530637,
0.0643880442,
1.2234430313,
0.3632244468,
0.4083751738,
0.9029023051,
0.0928663164,
1.5315382481,
-0.2368951142,
-0.0574488677,
1.2282618284,
-0.3477086425,
0.6237834096,
0.2269849032,
-0.3359717131,
0.4937665164,
0.9121826887,
0.2744972408,
0.9644893408,
0.1838063896,
-0.4316139519,
-0.3531833291,
-0.2383976877,
-0.8586996198,
0.3530036211,
0.3993847668,
-0.6548200846,
0.1486237049,
0.3334026933,
-0.0428099111,
0.0572942235,
-0.3706802726,
0.575886786,
-0.1031879336,
-0.5425960422,
0.08765468,
-0.3636527061,
0.5119698048,
-0.49113819,
-0.0991170108,
-0.3713079989,
0.3469107151,
-0.5141272545,
-0.669549644,
0.3558410406,
-0.653026104,
-0.1788012981,
-0.1438076049,
0.9882799983,
-0.4355243742,
-0.3658589125,
0.3090134561,
0.7357225418,
0.1730589867,
-0.3549692929,
-0.2880317569,
-0.1644183844,
-0.1374790072,
-0.021987265,
0.6307780147,
0.2312627137,
-0.0166155454,
0.704754293,
0.3294463754,
0.2713012695,
-0.5388284326,
-0.3075376153,
0.857994616,
-0.6266502142,
-0.6920424104,
-0.5625772476,
0.2769742906,
-0.0728237331,
-0.2542774975,
0.327459693,
0.3953618407,
0.3471692502,
0.0075500342,
0.9849056005,
0.2988406718,
0.8315551281,
-0.0257059019,
0.9458094239,
-0.5716909766,
0.1729171872,
0.1402659118,
0.0624664873,
-0.3164309561,
0.1450388134,
-0.6564441919,
-0.1419048905,
0.6859986186,
0.1709554642,
0.1309710741,
0.113442421,
0.4974668026,
0.1151021644,
0.3652783036,
0.5940927267,
0.6781926155,
0.1971138716,
0.2857367098,
-0.7151925564,
-0.6252918243,
-0.6432591677,
-0.7289707661,
-1.0406503677,
-0.457357347,
-0.3699105382,
-0.3307414651,
0.3793964684,
0.6169093847,
0.7949271202,
-0.7188773751,
0.2025497556,
0.0829749256,
-0.1001215875,
-0.1344046593,
-0.0499272533,
0.4832716584,
0.2916461229,
-0.3069044054,
0.3232378662,
0.4202028215,
0.0314812437,
-0.1300955266,
-0.3758819997,
0.3183307946,
-0.1261559576,
0.1334290802,
0.3191905022,
-0.3886814415,
0.1837677211,
-0.0379900709,
-0.219949007,
0.2165376097,
0.9741626978,
-1.3417599201,
0.679895103,
0.460658282,
0.5166478753,
0.295185715,
-0.0078877481,
0.8631637096,
-0.0369360372,
-0.1541801244,
0.6501281261,
0.2945177555,
0.3746014535,
-0.6907943487,
0.2886795402,
0.3394889534,
-0.3447355926,
-0.6247751117,
0.061086487,
-0.8247348666,
-0.2364279181,
0.9702072144,
-0.4987493455,
-0.3596817255,
-0.5354181528,
-0.419378072,
0.2374944538,
-0.485819608,
0.8548675179,
0.0058227489,
-0.7376961708,
0.1416537315,
-0.6994070411,
0.545194149,
0.3610580862,
-1.159411788,
-0.4365636408,
0.0602369197,
0.1459129155,
-0.0816886276,
0.7729563713,
-0.1059640571,
0.3888351619,
-0.2758528292,
-0.2332813889,
-0.4120138884,
-0.1975047886,
0.1611314118,
0.1339502037,
-0.4007989764,
-0.351203382
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02933v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02933v1
|
Relay Decoding: Concatenating Large Language Models for Machine Translation
| 2024-05-05T13:42:25 | 2024-05-05T13:42:25 |
Chengpeng Fu, Xiaocheng Feng, Yichong Huang, Wenshuai Huo, Baohang Li, Hui Wang, Bin Qin, Ting Liu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Leveraging large language models for machine translation has demonstrated
promising results. However, it does require the large language models to
possess the capability of handling both the source and target languages in
machine translation. When it is challenging to find large models that support
the desired languages, resorting to continuous learning methods becomes a
costly endeavor. To mitigate these expenses, we propose an innovative approach
called RD (Relay Decoding), which entails concatenating two distinct large
models that individually support the source and target languages. By
incorporating a simple mapping layer to facilitate the connection between these
two models and utilizing a limited amount of parallel data for training, we
successfully achieve superior results in the machine translation task.
Experimental results conducted on the Multi30k and WikiMatrix datasets validate
the effectiveness of our proposed method.
|
[
-0.2309669107,
-0.4876084924,
0.2093607336,
0.5419037938,
-0.3677184284,
0.1875794679,
-0.3183246255,
-0.4752617776,
-0.0959383845,
0.7786184549,
-0.5217959285,
-0.4475054145,
-0.7502421141,
0.3561040759,
-0.6182431579,
0.8197274208,
-0.1717345566,
0.2190550715,
-0.0582526326,
-0.1043194532,
-0.7989917994,
-0.5614738464,
-0.5675148964,
-0.3761473298,
0.5935268402,
0.7279951572,
0.5379636884,
0.3902710676,
0.6335759759,
0.3181516528,
0.236234501,
0.6868374944,
-0.3996168673,
0.5520954132,
-0.0811561421,
-0.1785311997,
-0.2924031019,
-0.2518232763,
0.8338711262,
0.8543717861,
0.0950556621,
0.122832641,
0.1287406087,
0.9187597632,
-0.6564008594,
0.3313460946,
-0.5230672956,
-0.1432693005,
-0.2134557366,
-0.2374405563,
-1.0224384069,
-0.2638585269,
-0.1109747589,
-0.5363880396,
0.1164863706,
0.1590922177,
0.4711352885,
-0.0932945013,
-0.6775161028,
-0.2978650331,
-1.0926388502,
0.8158746362,
-0.465996474,
0.3651839495,
0.4427436888,
0.4650562406,
-0.0294132922,
-0.6947798133,
-0.4866010845,
-0.1888035685,
-0.2976271808,
-0.0371369794,
-0.3201105893,
-0.0408565328,
0.0985121429,
0.0553328022,
-0.6577587128,
0.1097064763,
-0.3631303012,
0.0369503126,
0.4896564186,
0.1454130262,
0.2773959041,
0.0288763121,
-0.4454703927,
-0.2668857276,
-0.780158937,
-0.3469137847,
0.0946860388,
0.768586576,
-0.2193303853,
0.586209774,
-0.206000641,
0.8425012231,
-0.1351106018,
0.1597314626,
0.0566084385,
-0.5741767883,
-0.171641767,
0.0953613892,
0.7539156675,
0.1559714824,
0.2085445821,
-0.42521438,
-0.1492788643,
-0.0113242427,
0.1570504457,
-0.6672922373,
-0.1083078086,
0.0829516649,
-0.3466000557,
-0.050905399,
-0.0124672055,
-0.610329628,
-0.1120425537,
-0.2973379493,
0.3974411786,
-0.3989851773,
-0.2308996469,
0.3805963695,
-0.1264567375,
0.0993275419,
0.2204682231,
-1.0068318844,
0.4576814473,
0.6765804887,
0.8937236071,
0.1974013448,
-0.5517369509,
-0.8169196844,
0.3612943292,
-0.3046921492,
0.6411569118,
-0.4053912759,
-0.1172006205,
0.1706280112,
0.0389752127,
-0.1592295766,
-0.475053817,
0.3624583781,
-0.867051363,
-0.143185854,
-0.222625643,
-0.3533382118,
-0.3576101661,
0.0506390482,
-0.8813406229,
0.7075919509,
0.4101731479,
-0.7439677119,
0.0390404053,
-0.3629520833,
-0.6304512024,
0.1534417719,
0.29985255,
-0.5650007725,
0.1677413881,
0.2778479159,
0.4721355736,
-0.6004106998,
0.181085676,
-0.1597615629,
-0.1630802453,
0.2129780203,
-0.2383404672,
0.723544836,
0.3142014742,
-0.1154632866,
0.0145769939,
-0.4049477577,
-0.2093748748,
-0.0600870438,
-0.2801540494,
-0.5639957786,
-0.0143532278,
0.3721571565,
0.2965272367,
0.0738103688,
-0.4351074696,
0.3932934105,
-0.1210605726,
0.3252268136,
0.2643618584,
-0.2397006601,
0.8008257747,
-0.1972254068,
0.6114262342,
0.1593307257,
-0.1452774256,
-0.2952072918,
-0.4355634153,
-0.73517102,
-0.2872568965,
0.4756355286,
0.4245984256,
-0.9931610823,
0.2450347245,
-0.3593314588,
-0.3322444856,
-0.82649225,
0.2214572281,
0.5118297338,
0.4381260276,
0.6286004186,
-0.1902663559,
-0.9940232038,
-0.6952967048,
-0.1907315552,
0.3062259555,
0.0103597287,
-0.1924532354,
0.5048273802,
-0.2536465824,
0.7011296749,
-0.2186368704,
-0.3946990669,
-0.8072934747,
-0.0273522846,
0.2306693196,
0.6295964718,
0.4646612406,
-0.7858273983,
-0.7916548252,
0.5698718429,
-0.760157764,
0.0929189175,
-0.0453988835,
-0.1720414758,
0.0175394341,
0.3405973911,
-0.7265498042,
0.0528004579,
1.0017871857,
-0.2357459813,
0.5383000374,
-0.4959109128,
0.2002996504,
-1.1178643703,
0.2173871398,
-0.122317709,
-0.4781140685,
-0.9082009196,
0.1826711893,
0.3393286169,
-0.1596893072,
-0.4189909697,
0.5472310185,
-0.7190716267,
-0.0123898052,
-0.4747723043,
-0.0357500687,
0.1351253241,
0.0415525846,
-0.065921858,
0.5514476895,
0.3245504498,
-0.4683510363,
0.6792294979,
0.316683799,
-0.4971710145,
0.1080202833,
-0.4827186167,
0.1433395743,
-0.1967554092,
0.6722109318,
-0.6633626223,
-0.2932449877,
0.161021024,
-0.1850246787,
0.2489937246,
-0.2192867696,
-0.5981479883,
-0.5255454183,
0.086330466,
0.7597872615,
0.5551513433,
-0.5416027308,
0.4106025398,
0.3142746091,
0.0410842709,
-0.4991619587,
-0.7939383388,
0.2072793692,
-0.2192563564,
-0.6063669324,
0.2529792488,
0.3152246177,
-0.0515593439,
-0.0635381117,
0.2051550746,
-0.1374613494,
-0.1280864924,
0.0593749359,
0.1749661565,
-0.1438300312,
0.00908658,
0.1395850331,
-0.6325856447,
-0.3448052406,
-0.8220243454,
0.6894382834,
0.3358947039,
-0.2594086826,
-0.539616704,
1.1209760904,
0.7710558772,
-0.5735931396,
1.1849706173,
0.3512340188,
-0.3821421266,
-0.5920552015,
-0.2648437917,
-0.192492038,
-0.4642066061,
0.4124861956,
-0.5388647914,
-0.8730227947,
0.4526493549,
-0.1810704172,
-0.2047637105,
0.2294940948,
0.6901245713,
-0.2075383067,
1.009947896,
0.896869421,
-0.3106505573,
0.4261934161,
-0.3861379027,
0.491656661,
-0.571103394,
-0.3036768734,
-0.8625427485,
-0.32829386,
-0.3671455085,
-0.6596141458,
0.2347023785,
0.1332147568,
-0.2953704298,
0.7307912111,
-0.3516134918,
0.3533177972,
0.7055181861,
0.197602585,
0.5901609063,
0.2151795924,
-0.0186461229,
0.0165439323,
-0.9928196669,
-0.245433256,
0.9634753466,
0.245837912,
0.7869529724,
-0.0218571499,
0.3875076175,
0.1942317188,
0.3441136777,
-0.5914493799,
0.3451918364,
-0.5512285233,
-0.3928198218,
-0.1467586458,
-0.6211361289,
-0.9051920772,
0.4106936157,
-0.1531734616,
-0.1772798151,
0.2075394243,
0.2595917284,
0.0715452358,
0.2529867589,
-0.7518779039,
0.8602825403,
0.0286972262,
0.0328259505,
-0.3779889345,
-0.6558401585,
0.502551198,
-0.1410204917,
0.3705930114,
0.2446422577,
0.3087193072,
0.3700677752,
-0.3534051478,
0.7049018145,
0.0204303097,
0.0687358826,
0.0665909946,
0.0591971464,
0.8162175417,
-0.1986753643,
-0.1907472759,
-0.0386960916,
-0.377327472,
-0.6079255939,
-0.5684759021,
0.6145654321,
-0.6355136633,
-0.1185639203,
-0.2410814464,
-0.8979853988,
-0.0582089312,
0.1772839427,
0.1980407685,
0.3964259326,
0.0430343188,
0.2369086444,
0.4985093474,
0.0063304082,
0.2656186819,
0.5716729164,
-0.1425172836,
-0.544118166,
0.8699578047,
-0.0859931558,
0.4629930258,
0.7453383803,
-0.0728635788,
-0.1819095612,
-0.5766011477,
-0.3301356137,
0.4798748791,
-0.4252528846,
-0.6044715047,
-0.7369403243,
-0.2918589413,
-0.2918269634,
-0.1881547719,
-0.5309283137,
-0.2667692602,
-0.0728747174,
0.021453768,
0.3057211041,
0.7042312622,
-0.1221841425,
0.4721899331,
-1.2058725357,
0.3475253582,
0.191167146,
-0.0985829011,
0.1817980707,
-0.3405072093,
-0.9457724094,
0.2497848719,
-0.1989251524,
-0.9524171352,
0.7038790584,
0.1974716187,
0.2861565948,
0.2875066102,
0.3615657687,
0.6306778789,
-0.847214818,
0.3020994365,
0.4039209187,
-1.0472508669,
0.4805066288,
-0.2329577953,
0.2476499975,
0.270788312,
0.3564376831,
-0.834241569,
-0.6285095215,
0.0008475605,
-0.8662194014,
0.6486455202,
0.1021971703,
0.1246514618,
-0.0448358431,
0.0591559559,
0.2973421812,
0.0173562132,
-0.5537027717,
-0.0207094774,
0.1525527835,
-0.3069560528,
-0.4191670716,
-0.3504829109,
-0.2994852066,
-0.2882906497,
0.2506031394,
0.002911,
0.2828818262,
-0.1776400805,
-0.2852801979,
-0.1878017485,
0.0785868838,
0.5225779414,
0.4328719974,
-0.0162020158,
0.409876138,
-0.0405604057,
-0.3918884397,
0.3844163716,
-0.030389633,
-0.1248987839,
0.2460858673,
0.6454930902,
0.9121714234,
0.3384007215,
-0.3659053445,
0.3006739616,
0.2121880651,
-0.1365603805,
0.1581457704,
-0.284196645,
0.2843159437,
0.3707958758,
0.4037764668,
0.1556763947,
-0.1792753041,
-0.3454894722,
0.3729309142,
0.4096942544,
-0.0904337317,
-0.5261645317,
0.6059202552,
0.3547621071,
-0.2680381835,
0.8850147724,
0.220495984,
-0.5857520103,
0.6287339926,
1.0323625803,
0.9603434205,
-0.3809574246,
0.3463057876,
0.3820208609,
0.4665840864,
-0.4560568035,
-0.0427746847,
-0.1508078426,
-0.5954455733,
-0.8026379347,
-0.4792719483,
-0.4584465027,
-0.2235133499,
-0.6856699586,
0.2008791119,
0.2433944345,
0.0901320875,
-0.3762324452,
-0.0009701507,
-0.6731621027,
0.0871245041,
-0.0786563382,
1.1390957832,
-1.1067250967,
1.3401036263,
0.4104560018,
-0.2535096705,
-0.7035187483,
-0.299846977,
-0.4011508524,
-0.4478043914,
0.8995230794,
0.1207203642,
-0.0298519768,
0.158930704,
-0.2150575817,
-0.6373863816,
0.9187540412,
0.6906594038,
-0.7045713663,
-0.196861282,
0.2918534279,
0.2536015809,
-0.6226109266,
-0.0273902398,
0.4899652302,
0.4528392255,
0.0425003767,
-0.8385016322,
0.0623536743,
-0.0091838334,
0.0904306024,
0.2124413848,
-0.4397513568,
0.8829814196,
-0.1292141378,
-0.3578382134,
0.1308180988,
0.685208261,
0.2144666612,
0.2394180745,
0.0746600106,
0.4192504585,
0.5014823675,
-0.0198010765,
1.1145472527,
-0.2003903687,
0.7433421612,
0.9457883835,
-0.1248327047,
0.9500498176,
0.5043096542,
-0.0907412842,
0.2189543992,
0.4308694601,
0.3807902336,
0.9825106263,
0.0348486938,
-0.5761390328,
-0.3278843462,
0.1465649456,
-0.5983085632,
0.1875762492,
0.348356694,
-0.3465817869,
-0.5543976426,
0.5337494016,
0.0124016488,
0.167637229,
-0.07628607,
0.4802500308,
0.3475696445,
-0.5540254116,
0.6236609221,
0.1266812682,
0.3496398926,
-0.8047385216,
-0.1049687043,
-0.5060793757,
0.4085735679,
-0.059904296,
-0.4049994648,
0.4703533649,
0.1204344407,
-0.4699029624,
-0.7181486487,
0.3917042911,
-0.8449075222,
-0.521809876,
0.5418604612,
0.3542094827,
-0.1913195997,
0.0312099773,
-0.2104780227,
0.4269131124,
-0.1233875304,
-0.0209947247,
0.409207195,
0.5088264942,
0.0256899484,
0.8825219274,
0.6342411637,
0.2987585664,
0.15707241,
-0.0387389697,
1.1006649733,
-0.6222047806,
-0.4598461986,
-0.8004969358,
0.8352386355,
0.1884931326,
0.0507495403,
0.8965772986,
0.4576989114,
0.7738380432,
-0.5011627078,
0.8789559007,
0.1627644151,
0.3076357841,
-0.5364620686,
0.8075149655,
-0.3242416084,
0.1579499394,
-0.1027011648,
-1.0030879974,
-0.659797132,
0.3885821998,
-0.0856677145,
-0.2877419889,
0.808826685,
0.645993948,
-0.1304862499,
-0.2577982247,
0.2802489698,
0.0706661642,
0.3607231081,
0.9051827192,
0.7441060543,
-0.5795645118,
0.3689604402,
-0.0862217471,
-0.4081950188,
-0.39220801,
-0.6906887293,
-0.7505815029,
-0.7571521401,
-0.0230755005,
-0.5381807685,
0.2817730308,
0.6319377422,
0.773029387,
-0.952755928,
-0.5090319514,
-0.1246919185,
0.4335020185,
-0.6309814453,
-0.0498877242,
0.3015522063,
-0.5864543319,
-1.0788784027,
0.5631606579,
0.2884696424,
-0.2293185592,
-0.3136051595,
-0.259722054,
-0.1230847538,
-0.0872910172,
0.7650114298,
0.3443615437,
-0.3370385766,
-0.0384914204,
-0.0458815508,
-0.4371676147,
-0.2498290837,
1.0855537653,
-0.7905227542,
0.6129636765,
0.6218061447,
0.8530498743,
0.6392753124,
0.0079643745,
0.8993552923,
-0.5695189834,
0.5414948463,
0.1699649543,
-0.0263405014,
0.3295076489,
-0.0365570374,
0.1076411456,
0.1165471151,
-0.4728471637,
-0.9436628819,
0.383648932,
-1.0777151585,
-0.1240226179,
0.8717639446,
-0.3206887543,
-0.0535874031,
-0.1441482902,
-0.0324230455,
0.2558606267,
-0.0831528008,
0.5947111249,
0.5042837858,
0.3274976015,
-0.2914249897,
-0.5601856709,
0.374125421,
0.1246914193,
-0.5085576177,
0.1083732173,
0.1714587957,
-0.058711078,
-0.1786088496,
0.4152282774,
0.0750700906,
0.2623308897,
0.1940080374,
-0.0301460531,
-0.0732098445,
-0.6015014052,
-0.3340863883,
0.4091417193,
-0.1115263328,
-0.6350060105
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02925v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02925v1
|
A Two-Stage Prediction-Aware Contrastive Learning Framework for Multi-Intent NLU
| 2024-05-05T13:09:55 | 2024-05-05T13:09:55 |
Guanhua Chen, Yutong Yao, Derek F. Wong, Lidia S. Chao
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Multi-intent natural language understanding (NLU) presents a formidable
challenge due to the model confusion arising from multiple intents within a
single utterance. While previous works train the model contrastively to
increase the margin between different multi-intent labels, they are less suited
to the nuances of multi-intent NLU. They ignore the rich information between
the shared intents, which is beneficial to constructing a better embedding
space, especially in low-data scenarios. We introduce a two-stage
Prediction-Aware Contrastive Learning (PACL) framework for multi-intent NLU to
harness this valuable knowledge. Our approach capitalizes on shared intent
information by integrating word-level pre-training and prediction-aware
contrastive fine-tuning. We construct a pre-training dataset using a word-level
data augmentation strategy. Subsequently, our framework dynamically assigns
roles to instances during contrastive fine-tuning while introducing a
prediction-aware contrastive loss to maximize the impact of contrastive
learning. We present experimental results and empirical analysis conducted on
three widely used datasets, demonstrating that our method surpasses the
performance of three prominent baselines on both low-data and full-data
scenarios.
|
[
-0.314973861,
-0.5563387871,
0.538620472,
0.2358821034,
-0.398134917,
-0.151178807,
-0.0990510508,
-0.5228435397,
0.0208953563,
0.4306136072,
-0.822076261,
-0.3545435071,
-0.8444629312,
-0.066728197,
0.1037592962,
0.8469344974,
0.0086935097,
0.0973253548,
-0.0911450759,
-0.3558676839,
-0.8346129656,
-0.0108413203,
-1.0566763878,
-0.4146361351,
0.5736519098,
0.6448754072,
0.4887472391,
0.3599593043,
0.0963994935,
0.1736348718,
0.0850712135,
0.4068740904,
-0.6700055599,
0.0243223328,
0.123182334,
-0.3538888991,
-0.1346764565,
0.179538399,
0.2139534652,
0.7629637718,
-0.0373806655,
-0.3076150417,
0.3035858572,
0.5676290393,
-0.6928161979,
0.4894361496,
-0.8782883883,
0.1189851239,
0.2753916085,
-0.1574186981,
-0.6893522739,
0.0097352583,
0.4436858296,
-1.1339802742,
0.0430382378,
0.152002573,
0.5674448013,
0.5887162089,
-0.4389789999,
-0.4856756926,
-0.3986567855,
0.9487692118,
-0.6104089022,
0.5067279935,
0.6009799242,
0.2058621794,
0.0970045701,
-0.6148427725,
-0.5330615044,
0.0912326202,
-0.4197638929,
0.2891363204,
0.2030387372,
0.1892462075,
-0.2657941878,
0.2107954025,
-0.4660903811,
0.1390770525,
-0.22300978,
-0.0439800955,
0.2340041995,
-0.1022319123,
-0.1431382895,
0.1486372948,
-0.6537691951,
-0.0426219478,
-0.474021703,
-0.0530470498,
0.0270495284,
0.6194210649,
-0.2449569404,
0.2738807201,
-0.0937798992,
0.4312925041,
0.1723317802,
0.0444640107,
0.2342907488,
-0.4655144513,
-0.3803667724,
0.4293978214,
0.6869741082,
0.2069084942,
-0.0327920169,
-0.1492136121,
-0.0185814779,
0.1813368052,
0.323479712,
-0.8115246296,
-0.1417353302,
0.3233199418,
-0.1081874445,
-0.2747357488,
-0.1045174599,
-0.4570884109,
-0.7380409241,
-0.4715406299,
0.6640889645,
-0.5604143739,
0.081107676,
0.5423073173,
0.3111072481,
0.1456391364,
0.7149812579,
-0.7276466489,
0.3065867722,
0.8118354678,
0.5018029809,
-0.0674223974,
-0.4842117429,
-0.7745099068,
0.2442731708,
-0.364492923,
0.4795156419,
-0.6201374531,
-0.1855318993,
0.0801268369,
-0.2029405832,
-0.2816040218,
-0.1422350705,
0.8100758791,
-0.4626183212,
0.5044229627,
0.0481688865,
-0.6616479754,
-0.3550983667,
0.3354901373,
-0.8350811005,
0.7725422978,
-0.1640810072,
-0.8144122362,
0.5856454372,
-0.6955137253,
-0.6942258477,
-0.1721210778,
-0.1692031771,
-0.6031989455,
0.1455365866,
0.2058839947,
0.5336096883,
0.1750911772,
0.3767594695,
-0.1993668228,
-0.4458148181,
0.0217811521,
-0.5058465004,
0.3006487787,
-0.0229240675,
-0.2578732371,
0.2785877585,
-0.801813066,
-0.4297134876,
-0.1169167683,
-0.3223485351,
-0.3597391546,
0.004868242,
-0.2827547491,
0.4663191736,
0.084092848,
-0.4103500545,
-0.0153830005,
-0.4630706608,
-0.1267013103,
0.7353746295,
-0.218473658,
0.5546343327,
-0.1599354744,
0.2463794351,
0.1747841537,
0.3467167914,
-0.1882053316,
-0.6177092791,
-0.7336128354,
0.0794023499,
0.0622843616,
0.3850720823,
-0.8894274831,
0.2625333667,
-0.1386671811,
-0.1394195557,
-0.877162993,
0.2271133959,
0.621188879,
0.6650112271,
0.7025485039,
-0.0894782096,
-0.5701867938,
-0.4847343862,
-0.1148527414,
0.0646048114,
0.1906879544,
0.7380408049,
0.0784220994,
-0.4557144642,
0.504137814,
-0.5147294998,
-0.8621523976,
-0.3918606639,
0.4383866489,
0.2540687323,
0.3109285831,
-0.0399162173,
-1.0867909193,
-0.5090969205,
-0.0758036226,
-0.4257087409,
0.2536702454,
-0.2637701035,
-0.1727216244,
0.0031336914,
0.5562443137,
-0.2115142345,
0.2381182909,
0.8407764435,
-0.4946503639,
0.3697313666,
-0.4011832476,
0.0500615686,
-1.3217232227,
-0.2741891742,
-0.0442585908,
0.1587511152,
-0.9663559198,
-0.5961992145,
0.0181860849,
0.0788119137,
-0.5906128287,
0.6502913237,
-0.2287802845,
-0.074811928,
-0.2261303365,
0.1676025391,
0.3434245884,
0.4065489471,
0.2091986686,
0.6849941015,
0.4742534757,
-0.8783928752,
-0.3461288512,
0.4727760553,
-0.3823412657,
0.1383634359,
-0.4234035611,
-0.0610128194,
-0.2087310404,
0.4043368399,
-1.250846386,
-0.1692698151,
0.1838190258,
-0.4267754257,
0.302315563,
0.0069198697,
-0.108488135,
0.0222673211,
-0.321544528,
0.5528182983,
-0.0583225377,
-0.7420700192,
0.7399516106,
0.2180397809,
-0.0786927938,
-1.1228324175,
-0.7680487633,
-0.3640179634,
-0.0788518414,
-0.3664326072,
0.4546822309,
-0.1758779436,
0.165546149,
-0.1291476041,
0.0221648347,
-0.071329996,
0.2821446955,
0.3710358739,
0.3509410024,
-0.0358157344,
0.4271824062,
0.1697571129,
-0.2166384608,
-0.1452191174,
-0.2080401033,
0.7240411043,
-0.0321114026,
-0.2491951138,
-0.4150582254,
0.0950539485,
0.3168923259,
-0.2288505584,
0.9183145165,
0.9718176723,
-0.2713632286,
-0.0673613027,
-0.3602221608,
-0.2048576623,
-0.4189648926,
0.0903430209,
-0.4244543612,
-0.8803267479,
0.2110416144,
-0.1482281685,
0.4059040248,
0.2582604587,
0.193566516,
-0.0000575708,
0.7517022491,
0.7439994216,
0.145012483,
0.5605775714,
-0.4149924815,
0.3052045107,
-1.0533871651,
-0.4864120483,
-0.1203728169,
-0.3214074075,
-0.3040935099,
-0.7174810171,
0.0158766024,
0.1988322884,
0.010780612,
0.1129732057,
-0.2160621732,
0.4096097946,
0.2693337202,
0.1345341653,
0.288210839,
-0.2153859288,
-0.0445315614,
0.0757650062,
-0.4294136167,
-0.1317234635,
1.0570361614,
0.1069200486,
0.6440678239,
0.1307578683,
0.8125246167,
0.0522577539,
0.2714771926,
-0.9765297771,
0.1733508557,
-0.5292881131,
-0.3709736466,
-0.4446541369,
-0.3318932354,
-1.1663365364,
0.6354691386,
-0.5006967187,
-0.4293717742,
0.3277641833,
0.3079496324,
-0.4448836446,
0.0104136067,
-0.7948385477,
0.954480648,
-0.1954383403,
-0.5182732344,
-0.3237870038,
-0.8429293036,
0.371673286,
-0.0974193886,
0.5137674212,
-0.3466002047,
-0.2147362083,
0.6811583042,
0.2179736942,
0.8471447825,
-0.1496509165,
-0.0951819941,
-0.0504786707,
-0.0843129903,
0.3156360984,
0.2630757391,
-0.4452786744,
-0.2926675081,
-0.6711523533,
-0.2740507126,
-0.3143306971,
0.6652106643,
-0.6840430498,
-0.1063768417,
-0.2541158795,
-0.608130157,
-0.574095428,
0.289408505,
0.2618416846,
0.5584741831,
-0.4407840073,
0.2028037012,
0.8181004524,
-0.1812366694,
0.3526984751,
0.3522432745,
0.0915390849,
-0.2553302348,
0.8457527161,
-0.5204850435,
0.3140851259,
0.6339707971,
0.4474382997,
-0.6795746088,
-0.6046287417,
-0.1583255678,
0.0938140973,
-0.6559544802,
0.0054778862,
-0.7198154926,
0.2236088514,
-0.4517335892,
-0.4076958597,
-0.4186167121,
-0.0303543638,
-0.5367201567,
-0.0863986909,
-0.032551758,
0.6774717569,
0.0554492585,
0.4812352359,
-0.4394487739,
0.5390754342,
0.3330689669,
0.4787081182,
-0.2316262722,
-0.4528589845,
-0.1476099789,
-0.0717935562,
-0.0412529036,
-0.364690721,
0.4008179903,
0.5774457455,
0.5116696358,
0.6650856733,
0.1404838264,
0.601888299,
-0.4316778779,
0.5037974715,
0.5467685461,
-0.6822422147,
0.7830594778,
0.1278957725,
0.3423518836,
1.2559143305,
0.5159499645,
-0.4586976469,
-0.1013348252,
-0.5912765861,
-0.8803649545,
0.9625487328,
0.0673221946,
-0.0700165629,
0.1926273406,
0.1580702066,
0.6118296385,
0.271843344,
-0.7267498374,
-0.4919898808,
-0.1963816285,
-0.2577472329,
-0.49785164,
-0.0588438958,
0.0750666708,
-0.1950774044,
0.7347121239,
-0.3770113885,
-0.0890115201,
0.023055736,
-0.2567310929,
0.2085511535,
0.5175865889,
0.5559772253,
0.5750104785,
-0.2969952822,
0.1709209532,
0.1364079714,
-0.5095501542,
-0.07112097,
0.4060802162,
0.084631145,
-0.0074509466,
0.1043109,
1.386090517,
0.6663816571,
-0.451438576,
0.5089920163,
-0.5501980782,
-0.1917503923,
0.0137022622,
-0.2419193387,
0.0218301453,
-0.0859608129,
0.0722584575,
0.1994068772,
0.4707312882,
-0.6306617856,
0.4243143797,
0.2040140182,
-0.7753453851,
-0.0261498988,
0.3491709232,
0.3080697358,
0.1619102359,
0.2486719936,
-0.4403010905,
-0.3876907527,
0.422147423,
0.5086777806,
0.5665067434,
-0.457469821,
0.3773948252,
0.3593255877,
-0.0420201533,
0.0437758155,
0.1285170615,
0.046918232,
-0.9759614468,
-0.4318979979,
-0.7876829505,
-0.461268872,
0.2926451862,
-0.576253593,
0.2561236918,
-0.2959454358,
0.2498564571,
0.1205639988,
0.2708437443,
-0.7227984071,
0.404715538,
0.2585977316,
0.5213370323,
-0.8675618172,
1.0396836996,
0.5268821716,
-0.0236934125,
-0.9061089158,
0.1003320515,
0.0101268915,
-0.9020528793,
0.2356368899,
0.8004330397,
-0.3667274117,
-0.0341726691,
0.0609370023,
-0.4961901307,
1.2575044632,
0.122981593,
-0.4273996949,
0.0620935522,
-0.0642524958,
0.2621848285,
-0.7667430043,
0.1424093544,
0.5931716561,
0.4512929618,
0.492749244,
-0.3951182961,
-0.1320514679,
0.2359838188,
-0.2881832719,
0.1285809278,
-0.2370561361,
0.8390238285,
-0.5476962924,
-0.3032321334,
-0.3432963192,
0.6426709294,
0.4057399333,
0.6781313419,
0.7171096802,
0.5922187567,
0.8510396481,
-0.1432303488,
0.9854390621,
-0.2908170819,
0.2530032694,
1.5499426126,
-0.1151251867,
0.958948791,
0.4193852842,
0.2806889713,
0.3870506585,
0.4583080411,
0.3262296617,
0.8279474378,
-0.1742032766,
-0.361907959,
-0.1998387426,
-0.407289058,
-0.0951133072,
0.5004863143,
0.7676154971,
-0.1608822346,
-0.0284083262,
0.0017693361,
-0.2429313809,
0.0358776338,
-0.3667152822,
1.1103093624,
0.0773478299,
-0.6731780767,
0.2680300772,
-0.4422937036,
1.0290682316,
-0.5569280386,
-0.0398890637,
-0.0753552094,
0.4120363295,
-0.1952372044,
-0.9867929816,
0.0538201295,
-0.5859156847,
0.1194571257,
-0.1276868284,
0.7754933834,
-0.7705108523,
-0.235344097,
0.6766973734,
0.3702086508,
-0.0785638317,
0.0053150188,
-0.9837213755,
0.0926301777,
0.0006071771,
0.0584064238,
0.222002238,
0.4112819731,
0.5242247581,
0.5855177641,
0.4466996789,
-0.0593074262,
0.0295757651,
0.5956491232,
0.6701744795,
-0.0561241843,
-0.6070204973,
-0.4654564261,
0.4339713752,
-0.1818508953,
-0.3854174018,
0.3010024726,
0.6177937984,
0.9023408294,
0.059022896,
0.6837757826,
0.2483825684,
0.2286379784,
-0.5636100173,
0.3180998862,
-0.7230610847,
0.2117014676,
0.006578722,
-0.674844861,
-0.2952025533,
0.4700242579,
-0.1934907585,
-0.1940681189,
0.6676399112,
0.5219869614,
-0.2151503712,
0.1336045116,
0.5255827904,
0.0831920132,
0.2556041777,
0.775832057,
0.4957511425,
-0.6255910993,
0.6574238539,
-0.5589501262,
-0.1766144186,
-0.4062884152,
-0.6590783,
-0.5833203197,
-0.646751821,
-0.2048041373,
-0.050541006,
0.0749554411,
0.5273236632,
0.6892725229,
-0.8161444664,
0.0542717203,
-0.3414661884,
0.1499858946,
-0.1293606162,
-0.170086652,
0.400846988,
-0.6273065805,
-0.6344656944,
0.565002799,
0.2765569091,
0.0262676235,
0.1464483738,
-0.5451582074,
-0.5529153943,
0.1904696226,
0.8375248909,
0.0330440886,
-0.7908726931,
-0.1415580213,
-0.3238837123,
-0.259121865,
0.1884790361,
0.7174569964,
-0.7982293963,
0.521055758,
0.246788308,
0.790767312,
0.5145384073,
0.0723672584,
0.3766766489,
-1.1027042866,
0.0976326242,
0.3403295875,
0.5183216929,
0.3721618056,
-0.5047734976,
0.5085681081,
-0.3133364916,
-0.3148884475,
-0.1952565014,
0.3014598787,
-1.4202060699,
-0.5057333708,
1.1371320486,
-0.1422583014,
0.3025999963,
-0.4353418052,
-0.2542212903,
0.5906916261,
-0.617493093,
0.6521880627,
0.360062331,
-0.3250642121,
-0.1482841223,
-0.3218812943,
0.7601827979,
0.5589376688,
-1.0138671398,
0.2769755721,
0.4021309316,
-0.2474405318,
0.4036297202,
0.5298376679,
0.1425228715,
0.2275248468,
-0.1206300259,
-0.2374109179,
-0.0493578091,
-0.6362353563,
-0.4515381455,
0.0687236339,
0.0263129398,
-0.4261258841
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02917v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02917v1
|
Overconfidence is Key: Verbalized Uncertainty Evaluation in Large Language and Vision-Language Models
| 2024-05-05T12:51:38 | 2024-05-05T12:51:38 |
Tobias Groot, Matias Valdenegro-Toro
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Language and Vision-Language Models (LLMs/VLMs) have revolutionized the field
of AI by their ability to generate human-like text and understand images, but
ensuring their reliability is crucial. This paper aims to evaluate the ability
of LLMs (GPT4, GPT-3.5, LLaMA2, and PaLM 2) and VLMs (GPT4V and Gemini Pro
Vision) to estimate their verbalized uncertainty via prompting. We propose the
new Japanese Uncertain Scenes (JUS) dataset, aimed at testing VLM capabilities
via difficult queries and object counting, and the Net Calibration Error (NCE)
to measure direction of miscalibration. Results show that both LLMs and VLMs
have a high calibration error and are overconfident most of the time,
indicating a poor capability for uncertainty estimation. Additionally we
develop prompts for regression tasks, and we show that VLMs have poor
calibration when producing mean/standard deviation and 95% confidence
intervals.
|
[
-0.3299750686,
-0.9262423515,
1.1262687445,
-0.0123278024,
-0.1773344874,
0.1165114641,
-0.2888332903,
-0.3274619579,
-0.4067632854,
0.224817574,
-0.5936937928,
-0.3742907941,
-0.8270990849,
0.1665025949,
-0.1221018434,
0.5453397632,
-0.2588523328,
0.2105959058,
-0.2923309803,
0.1055502221,
-0.5086352825,
-0.2307951152,
-0.6715666652,
-0.0154192923,
0.2785818875,
0.2241444439,
1.1550382376,
0.0161485132,
0.2442343384,
0.4125657082,
0.1702466011,
0.2733379602,
-0.1678934246,
0.1848784983,
-0.1788627058,
-0.8404157758,
-0.0301266015,
-0.1654145122,
0.5765093565,
0.5127296448,
-0.0461161397,
0.1024473161,
-0.1344632953,
0.6142265201,
-0.9641525149,
0.540117085,
-0.6591863632,
-0.0486368015,
-0.1123121455,
-0.0250690412,
-0.1352328211,
-0.3579949737,
0.1930856109,
-0.9818703532,
-0.1457715929,
0.1653409004,
0.9928845763,
0.6501404643,
-0.0214622412,
-0.2845004797,
-0.7093476653,
0.9073466659,
-0.7044071555,
0.3176119626,
0.8368680477,
0.4676864743,
-0.2484994382,
-0.4628359377,
-0.6503967643,
-0.3569591343,
0.2747738659,
0.4337286949,
-0.2754006088,
0.0588489994,
0.2049246728,
-0.1759967655,
-0.4286187589,
0.1971513778,
-0.1670898199,
-0.1452898532,
0.4836399853,
0.2286381721,
0.0001197437,
-0.3050222695,
-0.2741098106,
-0.2838719189,
-0.3868122697,
0.0852229074,
0.3510118127,
0.0683419257,
0.002964471,
0.6218527555,
-0.2047781646,
0.8052163124,
-0.0855216905,
-0.3046018481,
0.2023484707,
-0.4221001267,
-0.3319507241,
-0.2301264405,
0.9859514236,
0.6289240718,
0.7135084271,
0.2075030953,
-0.1111357659,
0.1132729948,
0.2893638909,
-0.2760948539,
0.2034147978,
0.4199784994,
0.1072032228,
-0.20409742,
-0.0327667631,
-0.5688893199,
-0.5397624969,
-0.2031588554,
0.6254691482,
-0.522449851,
-0.0069037261,
0.2395349294,
-0.2743109763,
0.3477433622,
0.6447324157,
-0.4456576109,
0.0598456189,
0.4404012263,
0.530703187,
0.1217667311,
-0.4532547295,
-0.0589332655,
-0.1735734642,
-0.7302556634,
0.5437848568,
-0.3561557233,
-0.6491256356,
-0.016653249,
-0.2036808133,
-0.2518067062,
-0.1649387926,
0.6227780581,
-0.2232457697,
0.283136636,
-0.4232946038,
-0.4634269476,
-0.1002563983,
0.5658043027,
-0.3049553037,
1.1016322374,
0.3195618689,
-0.7741980553,
0.3820565641,
-0.1859906912,
-0.0174365602,
0.1324496567,
-0.7407026291,
-0.3886731565,
0.0750742927,
0.641548872,
0.5202858448,
-0.4571732283,
0.6082360148,
-0.4130367637,
-0.4344231188,
0.7409533262,
-1.0851755142,
0.6197021008,
0.0326884873,
-0.2205108851,
-0.03535771,
-0.4740484655,
0.2072976232,
0.1041501611,
0.0361249484,
-0.3876973391,
0.1755730659,
-0.4027616978,
0.1720125973,
0.400813818,
-0.3851676583,
-0.034588147,
-0.3598298132,
0.3124929667,
0.7153493166,
-0.0408480614,
0.0833388939,
-0.1741630584,
0.6199387312,
-0.0075052292,
0.6000936031,
-0.165996179,
-0.6315730214,
-0.8520143032,
0.1921955645,
-0.1064919755,
0.7282972932,
-1.1808373928,
0.1868446767,
-0.3100088835,
-0.6073454022,
-0.5525471568,
-0.0401554443,
0.5875992179,
0.5790694952,
0.1961497217,
-0.1040613204,
-0.3319680393,
-0.6944310069,
0.0002336689,
-0.6085698605,
-0.2070688456,
0.4435766935,
0.3834301829,
-0.0527728461,
0.8325217366,
-0.314160645,
-0.0393701792,
-0.0649864227,
0.0616572984,
0.015127331,
0.153775081,
0.3580105901,
-0.7114530802,
-0.248204127,
-0.2893546522,
-0.7350285649,
0.1651782691,
-0.1858172119,
0.1665895581,
0.4791639149,
0.6161330342,
-0.6756944656,
0.5631579757,
0.5274765491,
-0.0075854943,
0.7310782671,
-0.2297900915,
0.2470839769,
-0.8172935247,
-0.0205346011,
0.2725954056,
-0.2175608575,
-0.2639266253,
0.0352577493,
0.0153551241,
0.1630717665,
-0.4385815263,
0.3937168419,
-0.5308378935,
-0.3064908087,
-0.0646447018,
0.384418726,
0.0886541381,
0.3635574877,
0.2668832541,
0.7705796957,
0.7656463385,
-0.2583815455,
0.3645389676,
0.0588254631,
-0.7046367526,
0.7822782993,
-0.7376702428,
-0.1468065828,
-0.3259012103,
0.1852592826,
-1.1718380451,
-0.5145277381,
0.4313464165,
-0.5322104692,
0.4267456532,
0.1017590985,
-0.2112057954,
-0.708663404,
-0.4004091024,
0.2505997121,
0.4786214232,
-0.0243894476,
0.3760867119,
0.0951607823,
-0.1924072355,
-0.8964340091,
-0.793746531,
0.2357749194,
0.0997751504,
-0.4049303234,
-0.0666431934,
0.0920118988,
-0.2857486606,
-0.0593543239,
-0.1049694046,
-0.00151669,
0.1334020197,
0.6026082039,
0.5137250423,
-0.0874527395,
0.0605681576,
-0.118655026,
-0.1946039498,
0.1805728376,
-0.0534295142,
0.2993219793,
-0.319591254,
-0.8608137965,
-0.4106300771,
-0.0575761907,
0.4895159006,
0.0901128277,
0.4984646142,
0.6397612095,
-0.3476552367,
0.2302442044,
-0.6369627118,
0.0939497203,
-0.4643862844,
0.5411673188,
-0.4083013833,
-0.6827084422,
0.3751569688,
0.0956864432,
-0.1423496455,
0.4584189355,
0.3604590893,
-0.2368421108,
1.0306949615,
0.3842541873,
-0.1724357307,
0.2466184646,
-0.0466885455,
-0.103105545,
-0.6650230885,
-0.2053240985,
-0.5327409506,
0.0508574173,
-0.473416537,
-0.7146844268,
0.5915993452,
-0.0524701588,
-0.4173212647,
-0.0050523444,
-0.0538087487,
0.5605547428,
0.6951293945,
0.1927452385,
0.0507961176,
-0.2832519114,
-0.008611789,
-0.1703411937,
-0.6909078956,
-0.5378909707,
0.9578481913,
0.5113920569,
0.9974293113,
-0.2715284228,
0.2811791003,
-0.1867834628,
-0.0372272544,
-0.9606933594,
0.32572034,
0.0275597721,
-0.5945141315,
-0.7477574348,
-0.2585890591,
-0.630240202,
-0.1053534895,
-0.167695269,
-0.9494505525,
0.3544696569,
0.1308564544,
-0.7041036487,
0.0048299008,
-0.4706617296,
0.6084830761,
-0.2912017703,
-0.1010230184,
0.2347711772,
-1.0574765205,
0.3939643502,
-0.2170713842,
0.357581079,
-0.1409845799,
-0.3236792684,
0.2954777777,
-0.341838479,
1.1500252485,
-0.1052867025,
-0.0038612145,
0.5293242931,
0.0901074708,
0.6565029621,
0.1125000566,
-0.2811427116,
0.1932812184,
-0.1006039828,
-0.1823033392,
-0.6901900768,
0.4092867076,
-0.9904198647,
-0.6088237166,
-0.5230569839,
-0.2621085346,
-0.4865089357,
-0.0150861936,
0.7516998053,
0.3202873766,
-0.1674654335,
-0.159382239,
0.41896981,
-0.3576184809,
0.4222873151,
0.4084851742,
-0.1274136007,
-0.4191749096,
0.729820013,
0.2768034041,
0.6412100792,
0.1395255178,
0.1494034231,
-0.4436731935,
-0.6019328833,
-0.6708886027,
-0.0620862842,
-0.6808749437,
-0.2996017039,
-0.1655878872,
-0.4784652889,
-0.2207935303,
-0.3121481538,
-0.5941449404,
-0.2296735793,
-0.3906961977,
-0.1912487298,
0.2813193202,
0.642850697,
0.1273416281,
0.4409313202,
-0.6483030915,
0.0746071115,
0.1723495424,
0.2214471996,
-0.3856145442,
-0.573184073,
-0.0557651855,
0.2310988158,
-0.0166530777,
-0.8633427024,
0.3799769878,
0.1598763317,
0.5124592781,
0.3144206405,
0.1570480615,
0.8867424726,
-0.2423713952,
1.0342731476,
0.1342986822,
-1.0386315584,
0.5169365406,
-0.2152357101,
0.4888471067,
0.7813552022,
0.5725945234,
-0.4108630717,
-0.6318104863,
-0.7385683656,
-0.7761606574,
0.5372280478,
0.3188794553,
0.0051184576,
0.0668142587,
0.369276911,
-0.2382447571,
0.3235268891,
-0.4145620167,
-0.2220811993,
-0.3139637411,
-0.2694860101,
-0.3122944832,
-0.3959395587,
0.0124625582,
0.0473248623,
0.5233240128,
-0.2340595722,
0.0031863686,
0.5076861978,
0.1770932972,
-0.288988471,
0.1455818415,
0.4846053421,
0.5397775769,
-0.1928451508,
0.0557854623,
0.3260074854,
-0.425193876,
0.0291374698,
-0.0580972917,
-0.277860105,
0.0949708,
0.4842211008,
1.1252373457,
0.2022821307,
-0.665145576,
0.785594523,
-0.1833036691,
-0.164235428,
-0.6159999371,
0.1047395989,
-0.1166941375,
0.135890767,
0.1464392841,
0.329467833,
0.0787927881,
-0.3485727608,
-0.0708823726,
0.4513858855,
-0.4829974174,
-0.0835565776,
0.4558508098,
-0.024333708,
0.0884518027,
0.5031408668,
-0.2813023329,
-0.59966892,
0.6648542285,
0.2887679338,
0.7042337656,
-0.3285198808,
0.3835941553,
0.3772917986,
0.6621659398,
-0.3605451584,
0.5135834813,
0.2189075798,
-1.0096906424,
-0.5598714352,
-0.4091418982,
-0.6909340024,
0.0559222251,
-0.6689602733,
0.1678510159,
-0.5311025381,
-0.4705607891,
-0.1666951925,
-0.198327437,
-0.754185617,
0.3653669357,
0.1376523376,
0.6218661666,
-0.829513073,
0.6229516268,
0.3969471157,
-0.2407546192,
-0.9866066575,
-0.1097180769,
0.1625130773,
-1.1966933012,
0.3987761438,
0.0576396324,
-0.0995731652,
-0.1674158424,
-0.7201067805,
-0.9456593394,
0.9474287033,
0.4563006759,
-0.9487383366,
-0.0186365843,
0.2470499426,
0.4645670652,
0.1095530763,
0.547713697,
0.664468646,
0.7871055603,
0.225361675,
-0.9701135755,
-0.0747000054,
0.0498412214,
0.2756673396,
0.1314233392,
-0.4531223476,
0.7216048241,
-0.4487764537,
-0.2919017375,
0.174399972,
0.5157616138,
0.3210476339,
0.3072434068,
0.5312598348,
0.2776094377,
0.7573598027,
-0.222439453,
1.2034621239,
-0.0355153717,
0.0498816334,
1.3688904047,
-0.2325011641,
1.0522171259,
0.5987542272,
-0.3984477222,
0.23458983,
0.5822461843,
0.0858523548,
0.1223827749,
0.2015318871,
-0.0989829153,
-0.4522929788,
0.0091536688,
-0.0843470469,
0.4408035874,
0.9362468123,
-0.2802757025,
-0.1210785881,
0.060758803,
0.0355148651,
-0.0582487173,
-0.1691826284,
0.5538227558,
0.2959976494,
-0.8572425842,
0.5178771019,
-0.1180369705,
0.5110829473,
-0.5829042792,
0.4143680334,
-0.0252131633,
-0.0830745101,
0.0359695777,
-1.2251625061,
0.2402485162,
0.0646588057,
0.3614472449,
0.3275099993,
0.6764944196,
-0.2668216825,
-0.8619217277,
0.0095465193,
0.5966829062,
0.3378477395,
-0.3544291854,
-0.8972432017,
0.2003339976,
0.089990072,
-0.5213544369,
-0.1036591902,
0.4041566253,
-0.2507035136,
1.0328910351,
0.3669421673,
0.0586370789,
0.0464509279,
0.3119771481,
0.6006852984,
-0.4079000354,
0.1086425781,
-0.9778569341,
0.4666642249,
0.1150437891,
-0.6323441267,
0.7395090461,
-0.060994871,
0.7339913845,
0.0379652418,
0.8997237682,
0.1248804852,
0.0201772805,
-0.707629025,
0.2744037509,
-0.3891674876,
0.1222289205,
-0.3905386925,
-0.5803620815,
-0.3289084435,
0.7008814812,
-0.3736588657,
0.1829247475,
0.4433251917,
0.8629057407,
0.2317620814,
-0.0810037032,
0.5704005361,
0.2980078161,
0.1322456598,
0.6589255333,
0.9298426509,
-0.5923552513,
0.4503024518,
-0.3788224161,
-0.1081367433,
-0.1284675747,
-1.0380815268,
-0.5648637414,
-0.5127646923,
-0.469647944,
-0.135144949,
0.2699063718,
0.6185213923,
0.4270595312,
-0.5228495002,
0.0298588835,
-0.3340729475,
-0.0394429602,
0.0531812347,
-0.1414887458,
0.3116644621,
-0.3236286342,
-0.8217746019,
0.3413469791,
0.2750678658,
0.6224138141,
-0.5587127805,
-0.1242835224,
0.2773656249,
0.1888725311,
0.287604481,
0.1603803188,
-0.9785109162,
-0.3811476231,
-0.0497651175,
-0.3457100391,
-0.1879334152,
-0.0175688211,
-0.719886899,
0.6659916639,
0.3792937994,
0.3419916332,
0.2708269954,
0.1736348867,
0.8571438193,
-0.7664632797,
0.0955150127,
0.2365604937,
0.5160377622,
0.5063613057,
-0.3429894745,
0.4249669015,
-0.0388555601,
-0.5529154539,
-0.5351785421,
0.1836279184,
-0.9596915245,
-0.3507139981,
1.2503526211,
-0.3706479669,
-0.4435170889,
-0.2079150826,
-0.5171771646,
0.1824914366,
-0.3841328025,
0.434604764,
0.938503027,
0.2050181478,
-0.0807899684,
-0.7421070337,
0.5626401305,
0.465731442,
-0.7006572485,
-0.0485654436,
0.6282321215,
0.0982630998,
0.2900920808,
0.5130342245,
-0.072285004,
0.2943437397,
0.3183682263,
-0.1310602427,
0.0101521062,
-0.2923204899,
-0.3462278843,
-0.2245165408,
0.3855289817,
-0.2576466203
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02887v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02887v1
|
Sentiment Analysis Across Languages: Evaluation Before and After Machine Translation to English
| 2024-05-05T10:52:09 | 2024-05-05T10:52:09 |
Aekansh Kathunia, Mohammad Kaif, Nalin Arora, N Narotam
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
People communicate in more than 7,000 languages around the world, with around
780 languages spoken in India alone. Despite this linguistic diversity,
research on Sentiment Analysis has predominantly focused on English text data,
resulting in a disproportionate availability of sentiment resources for
English. This paper examines the performance of transformer models in Sentiment
Analysis tasks across multilingual datasets and text that has undergone machine
translation. By comparing the effectiveness of these models in different
linguistic contexts, we gain insights into their performance variations and
potential implications for sentiment analysis across diverse languages. We also
discuss the shortcomings and potential for future work towards the end.
|
[
-0.3887568414,
-0.1189063415,
0.3437505364,
0.6343483329,
-0.21077317,
0.3404636979,
-0.3653835356,
-0.6067726016,
0.0264167525,
0.1391148865,
-0.4045802355,
-0.3895803094,
-1.0117696524,
0.6392943859,
-0.3361058831,
1.0771365166,
0.0575324111,
0.6324939132,
-0.1705806553,
-0.6028254032,
-0.3553310633,
-0.656665504,
-0.3263837695,
-0.4196445048,
0.3976512551,
0.1361201108,
0.8470870256,
-0.2751511931,
0.8158246875,
0.3671344221,
-0.2583819628,
0.0028912814,
-0.2643042803,
0.1506952494,
-0.2550526559,
-0.7679342628,
-0.0801113322,
-0.0274930689,
0.7390750051,
0.666636765,
0.2034500241,
0.0679237545,
0.1551315486,
0.7110432386,
-0.5053240061,
0.1644488871,
-0.3281893134,
0.1227010339,
-0.107791692,
0.3975945115,
-0.4937652946,
-0.4348323643,
0.3111463189,
0.0797924325,
-0.0466792732,
-0.1515443623,
0.7355368137,
0.1214698702,
-0.5359963775,
-0.4315820932,
-0.823091805,
1.2478048801,
-0.6565325856,
0.5600055456,
-0.0366797,
0.3037038147,
0.4111255109,
-0.5439402461,
-0.5243213177,
0.03985871,
-0.4391063452,
0.3309595287,
-0.4662079215,
-0.3992339671,
0.0814702883,
0.6171960235,
-0.3666307032,
-0.1292552799,
-0.3634122014,
0.105128102,
0.5900951624,
0.2253933549,
0.2474291623,
-0.6895463467,
-0.2112855613,
-0.2004223317,
-0.2370969206,
0.2883769572,
0.3991146982,
0.3721583188,
-0.2267316729,
0.3703358769,
0.159788847,
0.5434288383,
-0.2543429136,
-0.2549755871,
0.4711922109,
-0.2283517569,
-0.2264767736,
-0.3726171851,
1.223102212,
0.4471874237,
0.2260087878,
-0.2055470198,
-0.3350461721,
0.4309638441,
0.2723445296,
-0.5779710412,
0.241951257,
0.1545643508,
-0.7367373705,
-0.21568425,
0.1367845982,
-1.0559020042,
-0.590282023,
-0.0959585756,
0.0640731677,
-0.3064184189,
-0.6852853894,
0.1609410197,
-0.2297596335,
0.6425196528,
-0.1675721854,
-0.4882521033,
0.3304649591,
0.6397728324,
0.8023612499,
-0.3983588219,
-0.4035715461,
0.1230543703,
-0.6706805229,
-0.3213785887,
0.8684629202,
-0.8845668435,
-0.8794754148,
0.115239948,
0.1876346767,
-0.3958213031,
-0.4741548896,
0.7673436999,
-0.5112453103,
0.4749068618,
-0.344165653,
-0.2250450701,
-0.4224616885,
0.3508929014,
-0.8307154775,
0.9939861298,
0.1370363533,
-0.9123941064,
0.3140088022,
-0.7723333836,
-0.802161634,
-0.2627401352,
-0.024048619,
-0.4473308921,
0.5260720849,
0.4148892164,
0.4654963911,
-0.5055146217,
0.1811811328,
0.1054310277,
-0.1308125108,
0.5214342475,
-0.4454453886,
0.695047915,
0.4667082429,
-0.3272021413,
0.0251040421,
-0.5893055797,
-0.1639218479,
-0.0615470856,
-0.0469869114,
-0.3272641003,
0.1237968504,
0.5165518522,
0.5111768246,
0.0074198148,
-0.7976240516,
0.0875968486,
-0.6844943166,
0.5515873432,
0.2030425817,
-0.2252663523,
0.5149073601,
-0.0008984891,
1.0952723026,
0.3248554468,
0.1724166721,
-0.2433709055,
-0.6059800386,
-0.7130235434,
0.0711219311,
0.2566856444,
0.6663182378,
-0.5135955215,
-0.0419691652,
-0.6719689369,
-0.5760560632,
-1.0887411833,
-0.1712378711,
0.3122895658,
0.0951386839,
0.3364175558,
-0.1241992339,
-0.6741632223,
-1.1486252546,
-0.6858747005,
-0.014206863,
0.1383263916,
-0.1589940637,
0.3830724955,
-0.5303803682,
0.8660185337,
-0.2576550245,
-0.0685765371,
-0.7616736889,
0.1609764546,
0.3060602248,
-0.08260075,
0.5184948444,
-0.9919188023,
-0.734193027,
0.3072717488,
-0.7476764321,
0.1686980724,
-0.0674751177,
0.0238753743,
0.5713390708,
0.20832026,
-0.5368509293,
0.2307171822,
1.0724149942,
-0.0412741713,
0.0500278547,
0.3068018258,
0.5856964588,
-1.4416947365,
0.0962518752,
0.1490302086,
-0.1784398705,
-0.6397559643,
-0.0671934932,
0.0633912459,
-0.3023533821,
-0.5941045284,
0.4711205065,
-0.4216172695,
0.2078892589,
-0.2099220157,
-0.0438675918,
-0.0660985261,
0.1463269889,
0.0194749571,
0.7614479065,
0.5373752117,
-0.1321164072,
0.1434698403,
0.196756199,
-0.3028636277,
0.6957273483,
-0.6211066842,
-0.1318320632,
-0.310328275,
0.0223975256,
-1.2707425356,
-0.0108020194,
0.0413974673,
-0.6436198354,
0.2421474457,
-0.0394271687,
-0.216699928,
-0.4364877939,
-0.3239846826,
0.0702695996,
0.6561213732,
-0.3409343958,
0.9761390686,
0.4861593246,
-0.0494616181,
-0.6952146888,
-0.8898239136,
0.1985802799,
-0.4577572048,
-0.718791306,
-0.1586752087,
0.1104490384,
-0.6151939034,
-0.1675740629,
0.093705751,
-0.0370486788,
-0.0971033052,
0.3808396757,
0.1216968969,
-0.0162036158,
0.0656829402,
-0.1311938465,
-0.2333824635,
0.0775399208,
-0.044244092,
0.4929163754,
-0.3677534461,
-0.2477667332,
-0.2557352781,
0.570120275,
0.9370571971,
-0.2647946477,
0.9467131495,
0.7055766582,
-0.1228687093,
-0.0000981405,
-0.5505734682,
0.0827671289,
-0.4014494121,
0.3843808174,
-0.5354465842,
-0.7211888433,
0.7264174223,
-0.0356697664,
0.0663219392,
0.9128131866,
0.6665970683,
-0.0006260276,
1.2353998423,
0.7771710157,
-0.7018687725,
0.2910859287,
-0.0459805802,
0.7174165249,
-0.4789475203,
-0.1130019948,
-0.6415237784,
-0.2557460368,
-1.0832977295,
-0.0893321186,
0.5259997249,
-0.1431164891,
0.4110899866,
0.2041075081,
-0.5736271143,
0.4293908477,
0.1092730388,
-0.3306171,
0.2679287195,
0.0605752394,
0.1530994177,
-0.4497051835,
-0.47555691,
-0.727150321,
0.818872869,
0.3676479161,
0.558376193,
-0.0029543492,
0.4326163828,
0.1803210825,
0.4958047271,
-0.9918316603,
0.2661393881,
-0.465620935,
-0.4049874842,
-0.0488941483,
-0.2023243308,
-0.8830420375,
0.5756713152,
0.1540996879,
-0.1967081428,
-0.0221916214,
-0.3563972414,
0.0864167362,
0.2576311827,
-0.7534793019,
0.8388130665,
-0.0238762405,
0.1469279379,
-0.258362025,
-0.6821706891,
0.3052176237,
-0.1063934714,
0.7811970115,
0.1519583017,
0.2615485191,
0.7532071471,
-0.0535658635,
0.7572212815,
-0.1541744918,
-0.2208081633,
0.2169913948,
-0.2070227265,
0.2821359932,
-0.1313940734,
-0.429485321,
0.4795815051,
0.0554356501,
-0.2195630521,
-0.4061051905,
0.5457679033,
-0.896868825,
-0.3079725206,
-0.3554085493,
-0.291598618,
-0.2971102893,
-0.0639281422,
0.4839965105,
0.16024822,
-0.1215897128,
0.2012828439,
0.2412862182,
-0.269425869,
0.6938945055,
0.39394328,
-0.2276554108,
-0.3502908349,
0.8368070126,
0.1345336139,
0.0722612441,
0.4443552196,
0.2536974847,
-0.40287745,
0.0467363857,
-0.5027583241,
0.260347873,
-1.012316823,
-0.1037175208,
-0.8512467742,
0.1021167934,
-0.4026683867,
-0.2046716958,
-0.5977071524,
-0.2446007729,
0.316074729,
-0.049440112,
0.3710668981,
1.0616071224,
0.258305788,
0.3578935266,
-1.0756233931,
0.0922391266,
0.002802738,
0.3774200678,
-0.1215326414,
-0.4681711793,
-0.2888551354,
-0.0510918014,
-0.2457727343,
-0.9892737269,
0.6400111318,
-0.0190612972,
0.5352299809,
0.0001783007,
-0.3315393329,
0.5583001971,
-0.4165148139,
1.1548149586,
0.1679907441,
-1.1657752991,
0.3207445145,
-0.1220472902,
0.4735410511,
0.343228817,
0.825239718,
-1.0300559998,
-0.5694154501,
-0.3163838089,
-0.786423564,
0.5098594427,
-0.0483755618,
0.5819056034,
-0.0916792452,
-0.1461078972,
0.3303057849,
0.093949087,
-0.8444708586,
-0.3379661143,
-0.2211977094,
-0.2874904871,
-0.4169670343,
-0.1393520385,
0.0782869011,
-0.292650938,
0.4861704409,
0.0559693575,
0.267020762,
0.022625396,
-0.3551620841,
0.0033168676,
0.6274133325,
0.2766265571,
0.608615756,
0.3430223167,
-0.0693293288,
0.3948546648,
-0.4463693202,
0.0234336313,
-0.0132909473,
-0.0381748229,
0.3289469182,
0.3940873146,
0.8331989646,
0.2883119881,
-0.5138735175,
0.4096879363,
-0.2552755177,
0.1218806654,
-0.174068749,
-0.3947685957,
0.1728058159,
0.131202057,
0.2720599771,
0.2625541091,
0.2219113857,
-0.350656867,
-0.1007259786,
0.3045911789,
-0.5946848392,
-0.6081710458,
0.436668843,
0.1180595532,
-0.1961483657,
0.5688777566,
0.0372617617,
-0.9094700217,
0.2599843442,
0.2307507992,
1.0821772814,
-0.351831913,
0.1692556739,
0.2184273601,
0.3467824161,
-0.2311790287,
0.4057903886,
0.3246778846,
-0.6337171197,
-0.5653002858,
-0.8953630924,
-0.5280086994,
-0.3210040629,
-0.7753723264,
0.3544634283,
0.3140582442,
-0.4000696242,
0.108842425,
-0.2191524655,
-0.9232405424,
0.3121145964,
0.1740965098,
0.5401037335,
-1.2652391195,
0.5989140868,
1.1947149038,
-0.5274325609,
-0.682929635,
-0.1293347478,
-0.139783144,
-0.5218957663,
0.6510051489,
0.2558043599,
-0.4073815346,
-0.1620549709,
-0.2935941517,
-0.6473740339,
0.4430977106,
-0.0639891401,
-0.3439767659,
0.3269395828,
0.6166298389,
0.954980433,
-0.209550187,
0.5716283321,
0.7770231366,
0.5184531212,
-0.2154265493,
-1.0326925516,
-0.4446730614,
-0.5113723278,
0.10235928,
0.3477509618,
-0.7417672873,
0.7919056416,
0.3450025022,
-0.2061856538,
-0.383192271,
0.4627043903,
-0.1891785413,
-0.0238136128,
0.4054653943,
0.2709755301,
0.4516787529,
-0.2004812807,
1.359136343,
-0.6138210297,
0.4639647901,
0.500536263,
-0.2443668097,
0.9113385081,
0.4764045179,
-0.6875628233,
0.6405955553,
0.3202369511,
0.1293668598,
0.176353991,
-0.1494084597,
-0.1981699914,
-0.1069054455,
-0.1533825994,
-0.2503583133,
0.6710115075,
0.2020388097,
-0.4186029434,
-0.0897571146,
0.3867925406,
0.1126414388,
0.243643105,
-0.1613634229,
0.6520884037,
0.1543557942,
-0.8189725876,
0.405162394,
0.1384592056,
1.1127490997,
-0.4368966818,
0.2627474368,
-0.5003799796,
0.3017008603,
-0.3695745468,
-1.0478916168,
0.807543695,
0.2101564854,
-0.4343812466,
-0.3550570309,
0.6071851254,
-0.2458128929,
-0.7709207535,
0.5856533051,
0.6439061761,
0.2876771688,
-0.0162752196,
-0.5138162971,
0.3484975994,
0.1234619096,
-0.6232850552,
0.1966641992,
0.3913849592,
-0.2373059839,
0.6734416485,
0.2206408679,
-0.0723714456,
0.2208362371,
0.2545190454,
0.6725755334,
-0.6461144686,
-0.2919459343,
-1.0423127413,
0.9056841731,
-0.0091810608,
-0.4476731718,
1.1303335428,
0.4873750508,
0.8827363253,
-0.3966738284,
1.1037752628,
-0.0594236255,
0.735344708,
0.0554013103,
0.565095067,
-0.466021657,
-0.0353560708,
-0.4862834215,
-0.9835811257,
-0.4206867218,
0.6050224304,
-0.5277809501,
-0.0331814811,
0.6399988532,
0.6244843602,
0.0037557939,
0.3459911048,
0.3305111527,
-0.023935087,
0.3262756467,
0.0723683685,
1.0183854103,
-0.7741848826,
0.5283118486,
-0.1867183,
0.1658715606,
0.2746483088,
-0.6795833111,
-0.7084701061,
-0.4866987765,
-0.0176713429,
-0.3049420118,
-0.4040124118,
0.7017179728,
0.4668642581,
-1.094072938,
-0.471065104,
0.2602347136,
0.0561566204,
0.0382220522,
-0.2649131417,
0.2062260509,
-0.5587305427,
-1.0659006834,
0.280805707,
0.1559607536,
-0.3228029311,
-0.5318902135,
0.0552950278,
0.1167402267,
0.1230051219,
0.8720202446,
-0.1010975689,
-0.6331694722,
0.0083081899,
0.2785628736,
-0.2283377051,
0.2515247762,
1.0156350136,
-0.5770608187,
0.5742229819,
0.6215042472,
0.558673799,
0.2027799487,
-0.009394994,
0.4897454977,
-0.644325912,
0.2615970969,
0.1781778485,
0.3105076551,
0.7349182963,
-0.1225033849,
0.4309109151,
0.0900432393,
-0.6000345945,
-0.6866816282,
-0.0199734494,
-0.4904086888,
-0.2310356498,
1.1297210455,
-0.0446665771,
0.0437567383,
-0.0112645859,
-0.1062557548,
0.1015114561,
-0.2482358068,
0.5443443656,
0.9557316899,
-0.0536851138,
-0.1932689101,
-0.5191895366,
0.3480764031,
0.5566794276,
-0.6764354706,
-0.0706463307,
0.2838527858,
0.1725436598,
0.3675107062,
0.4159668386,
-0.2884394228,
-0.2471697032,
-0.1501034051,
0.1788454801,
0.7414850593,
-0.1605547071,
-0.7164752483,
0.2805123329,
0.1375469416,
0.0148683684
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02861v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02861v1
|
Revisiting a Pain in the Neck: Semantic Phrase Processing Benchmark for Language Models
| 2024-05-05T09:20:38 | 2024-05-05T09:20:38 |
Yang Liu, Melissa Xiaohui Qin, Hongming Li, Chao Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.LG, 68T50, I.2.7
|
We introduce LexBench, a comprehensive evaluation suite enabled to test
language models (LMs) on ten semantic phrase processing tasks. Unlike prior
studies, it is the first work to propose a framework from the comparative
perspective to model the general semantic phrase (i.e., lexical collocation)
and three fine-grained semantic phrases, including idiomatic expression, noun
compound, and verbal construction. Thanks to \ourbenchmark, we assess the
performance of 15 LMs across model architectures and parameter scales in
classification, extraction, and interpretation tasks. Through the experiments,
we first validate the scaling law and find that, as expected, large models
excel better than the smaller ones in most tasks. Second, we investigate
further through the scaling semantic relation categorization and find that
few-shot LMs still lag behind vanilla fine-tuned models in the task. Third,
through human evaluation, we find that the performance of strong models is
comparable to the human level regarding semantic phrase processing. Our
benchmarking findings can serve future research aiming to improve the generic
capability of LMs on semantic phrase comprehension. Our source code and data
are available at https://github.com/jacklanda/LexBench
|
[
-0.2662555873,
-0.7398948073,
0.6951366663,
0.3262256086,
-0.3019837439,
0.0671730265,
-0.2814836204,
-0.6183887124,
-0.1143175662,
0.5594641566,
-0.4881416261,
-0.6892308593,
-0.3415184021,
0.1235444769,
-0.4392325282,
0.513053894,
0.2189565301,
0.3085378408,
-0.3617517054,
-0.312258929,
-0.3326321542,
-0.2945299745,
-0.6647555828,
-0.446413219,
0.3770589828,
0.115570128,
0.9460273385,
0.6145917177,
0.6600530148,
0.3050454557,
-0.4519066513,
-0.181019932,
-0.3790905774,
0.1865386665,
-0.4663204551,
-0.2796135843,
-0.3867224157,
0.0221997965,
0.663608551,
1.1924740076,
-0.0848461017,
0.1835559905,
-0.0795235336,
0.5441620946,
-0.5422767401,
-0.0084719239,
-0.9024603963,
-0.1323192418,
-0.290604502,
0.1863101274,
-0.3714417815,
-0.1616166532,
-0.0881482363,
-0.2560985386,
0.3126883507,
0.2537066936,
1.0925011635,
0.2575628459,
-0.1474783868,
-0.0538758822,
-0.1148817837,
0.5494010448,
-0.7611563206,
0.32069543,
0.0868657678,
0.2011865377,
-0.1787210405,
-0.9528942704,
-0.4828823507,
-0.4957273602,
0.0479120091,
-0.1249193028,
-0.5029994845,
0.1790261865,
0.4949835241,
0.515620172,
-0.6932820678,
0.3635099828,
-0.1172482595,
-0.0414382964,
0.4668870866,
0.3548739851,
0.2648798525,
-0.3432168663,
-0.5645674467,
-0.2459020913,
-0.6263771653,
-0.0249803271,
0.0975549519,
0.610815227,
0.0743610933,
0.6062566042,
-0.4504925907,
1.0288392305,
-0.2696741521,
0.2186233252,
0.3423459828,
-0.3064314723,
-0.2208860517,
-0.0564715862,
0.7700560093,
0.482547313,
0.1305095702,
-0.4374077618,
-0.1447232813,
0.2633268535,
0.4366308749,
-0.8482086062,
0.1156171933,
0.0363504104,
-0.4900457561,
-0.0769905001,
-0.0766397566,
-0.802982688,
-0.4618425667,
-0.3093260527,
0.2716914713,
-0.4081399739,
-0.3228421807,
0.5190612078,
-0.1984907985,
0.4157348871,
-0.0362756625,
-0.4810622036,
0.7496602535,
1.0645896196,
0.8966715932,
-0.2042463571,
-0.1916638762,
-0.518206656,
-0.2681572139,
-0.3982736468,
0.8952355981,
-0.5333827138,
-0.479396075,
0.0249255151,
0.0397386886,
-0.2332537174,
-0.9132413864,
0.6665983796,
-0.4713139534,
-0.3837845623,
-0.248188287,
-0.895532012,
0.0898734778,
0.2467179745,
-0.7107791305,
0.9220219254,
0.2040990889,
-0.6129909158,
0.0919874161,
-0.541809082,
-0.4087159038,
0.0777779296,
-0.1354699284,
-0.2687455416,
0.503210187,
-0.1487343013,
0.2761607766,
-0.7646175623,
0.1033599526,
-0.6968022585,
-0.3376790881,
0.3162047267,
0.1532925814,
0.779641211,
0.3148336411,
-0.148732543,
0.1543680131,
-0.9696774483,
0.398301959,
0.1222180277,
-0.0103947651,
-0.3531104922,
-0.1628555208,
0.0670786723,
0.3238168955,
0.0532877818,
-0.6962972879,
-0.0725994632,
-0.3542799056,
0.2617959976,
0.4071383178,
-0.1648656726,
0.2966699302,
0.0394548997,
0.5506470203,
-0.1947195232,
-0.1851907521,
0.0301153734,
-0.1922992915,
-0.6269991398,
0.0148011288,
0.4395810068,
0.3499727845,
-0.3976169527,
0.3219424784,
-0.4594468176,
-0.5897855163,
-0.464840591,
0.079765968,
0.615578115,
0.4791756272,
0.3924276233,
-0.4125131667,
-0.2283270508,
-0.9532750845,
-0.61877352,
-0.3419415653,
-0.2284793705,
-0.0757008046,
0.368157506,
0.0456805527,
1.0835107565,
-0.5405974984,
-0.2626808882,
-0.550219059,
0.6114019752,
0.0602851585,
0.3335687816,
0.4814364016,
-0.6242117882,
-0.1582178175,
-0.0601825416,
-0.5923119783,
-0.3984884024,
0.0988574401,
-0.0046116859,
0.0602755584,
0.9887152314,
-0.554461062,
0.2901299298,
0.4740999341,
-0.4369331598,
0.5513631105,
0.0017286191,
-0.3766751885,
-0.8558011651,
0.1870109588,
-0.1876217276,
-0.1138129085,
-0.4284889996,
0.4989462495,
0.2691318691,
-0.1922464073,
-0.4304615557,
0.5853261352,
-0.2800998092,
-0.4953744411,
-0.3993525803,
0.3256918788,
0.0793706626,
0.2134411782,
-0.0111096306,
0.7408633232,
0.4042076766,
-0.3574815392,
0.3052960038,
-0.047689233,
-0.4863885939,
0.6552842259,
-0.9901377559,
0.1269197166,
0.0765940994,
0.0017350477,
-0.8919628263,
-0.0373481475,
-0.1323265582,
-0.2897211611,
0.1727052033,
-0.0588580295,
-0.6998878717,
-0.2958269119,
-0.1622612327,
0.1416879296,
0.3205749393,
-0.3614898622,
0.5200996995,
0.3380230665,
-0.0135240238,
-0.0384662636,
-0.5746850967,
0.3078815639,
-0.2246798277,
-0.6171235442,
0.5912818313,
0.0610738434,
-0.6952899098,
0.1468698978,
-0.265378058,
-0.1635427177,
0.3626552224,
0.0284263324,
0.0260296259,
-0.3126836121,
0.6207535267,
-0.2861624062,
-0.2387155592,
0.1560995281,
-0.0499875732,
0.6819747686,
-0.6415715218,
-0.1543601602,
-0.1896651089,
0.2381542176,
0.205012992,
-0.4064627886,
0.5102645159,
0.6571566463,
-0.2083031088,
0.0312090665,
-0.5110026598,
-0.0240262486,
-0.3823781013,
0.4987364411,
-0.7074512243,
-0.919403553,
0.5089412928,
-0.3685043156,
-0.2244470865,
0.5642377138,
0.2084202766,
0.2243530452,
0.860312283,
0.5926204324,
-0.1164961308,
0.1554847956,
-0.0756920651,
0.1493934244,
-0.7545137405,
0.3812341392,
-0.8709561229,
-0.1572957635,
-0.7418670058,
-0.5415757895,
0.2429555058,
0.3997453153,
-0.0541286394,
0.4241707921,
0.006911519,
0.5415756106,
0.2664825618,
-0.0946253762,
0.2442985028,
-0.2653540075,
-0.3659864366,
-0.0853563547,
-0.5620061159,
-0.4604994953,
0.7601534724,
0.195710361,
0.6897640228,
-0.009103979,
0.7496445179,
0.0609921329,
-0.0088412883,
-0.8824974298,
0.8689153194,
-0.472448647,
-0.4529187977,
-0.2042152435,
-0.342941612,
-0.9502059817,
0.5854028463,
0.0502221324,
-0.820235908,
0.070234403,
-0.1720390767,
-0.5069861412,
0.2420723885,
-0.4618815184,
1.4070034027,
-0.0675826669,
-0.6644252539,
-0.518714726,
-0.7418736815,
0.1757690907,
0.1000806689,
0.2785436213,
-0.5164333582,
-0.0931976736,
0.4682618976,
-0.5193968415,
0.6420853138,
-0.0965647772,
0.0329918154,
0.144373402,
0.1564711183,
0.1880247891,
-0.1099606231,
-0.311270237,
0.1151991189,
0.1005197093,
-0.3738595247,
-0.4909150004,
0.5816656351,
-0.3357797861,
-0.3891699016,
-0.4095908999,
-0.4277116954,
-0.4533040524,
0.1344889402,
-0.0097683994,
0.5643683076,
-0.5030050278,
0.2750232518,
0.4110604227,
-0.2020974606,
0.3994156122,
0.5778961182,
-0.3297537565,
-0.0277070645,
0.7031590343,
-0.2224526554,
0.4647237062,
0.3640552759,
0.1063338146,
-0.1709645241,
-0.6201946139,
-0.2030676007,
0.3336655796,
-0.7634250522,
-0.2128243893,
-0.4871142507,
-0.1368014961,
-0.3663162887,
0.2194544077,
-0.643622458,
-0.3375093341,
-0.0057197618,
0.0219749007,
0.1884825677,
0.5002613068,
-0.0365386195,
0.4650985897,
-0.6948460937,
0.3302744031,
0.1311868578,
0.3792141378,
-0.3141095936,
-0.2595486343,
-0.1942694187,
-0.2610854805,
-0.2280310243,
-0.5106993318,
0.2675173581,
0.2271494567,
0.3955081403,
0.2327062339,
0.134533003,
0.9085553288,
-0.5693912506,
0.7592508793,
0.0992477238,
-1.0671191216,
0.3129751682,
-0.0039286315,
0.679125011,
0.7673080564,
0.0898801088,
-0.7128996253,
-0.4867601693,
-0.6127232909,
-0.955131948,
0.5432173014,
-0.0276391283,
0.0941271633,
-0.3272729814,
0.2678711414,
-0.0485450663,
0.0406469293,
-0.5044214725,
0.0782710984,
0.2977310717,
-0.1092037633,
-0.2497926205,
-0.3806623518,
0.0906401053,
-0.0784687176,
0.3248212039,
-0.312402904,
0.1436022669,
0.0993455872,
-0.4753218591,
-0.0438320711,
0.4142461121,
0.3733782768,
0.812074542,
-0.2991657257,
0.2269375622,
0.072330825,
0.0374304429,
-0.3268941641,
0.339235276,
0.0762879625,
0.3938660622,
0.4648887813,
0.7953351736,
0.7555271983,
-0.8736416698,
0.4129567742,
-0.2388190478,
-0.0554640926,
-0.2289626896,
-0.1105687469,
0.2528674006,
0.2165682912,
-0.080702655,
-0.2718223631,
0.3011887372,
-0.4119876921,
0.2023497969,
0.4201829433,
-0.4022447467,
-0.2170334607,
0.5546770096,
-0.1668128073,
-0.0368719399,
0.5570275784,
-0.3909090757,
-0.4766619802,
0.4218462706,
0.3674215972,
0.9034651518,
-0.0057958094,
0.1573058665,
0.4655703604,
0.0681214854,
-0.2354805171,
0.2081282586,
-0.1469799131,
-0.7247956395,
-0.1899664104,
-0.8896408677,
-0.4698250592,
-0.1606314629,
-1.0219162703,
0.1563108563,
-0.2502095103,
-0.2597017884,
0.285577625,
0.0000561031,
-0.5735285282,
0.0255269408,
0.1249832809,
1.0896923542,
-0.5023528934,
0.8601671457,
0.6083176136,
-0.4550242722,
-0.5585064292,
0.0345443152,
0.1390306801,
-0.7359609008,
0.7717113495,
0.2944028974,
-0.262735039,
-0.0458135642,
-0.361197561,
-0.7602712512,
0.7160540819,
0.1898774654,
-0.5592201352,
-0.0290238429,
0.3472257853,
0.8094714284,
-0.402739346,
-0.0838300139,
0.9713167548,
0.2312104255,
0.113007158,
-1.0260443687,
-0.0146870399,
-0.2661411464,
0.4424536228,
0.0435373783,
-0.3738886416,
1.0233585835,
-0.0233257767,
-0.1888694614,
0.6172632575,
0.6196761131,
0.0669037476,
0.1431972533,
0.7227692008,
0.883232832,
0.613617599,
-0.2258831263,
1.3495013714,
-0.4035945833,
0.2860223353,
1.5917479992,
-0.656948626,
1.2077015638,
0.5629523396,
-0.3869331479,
0.426310122,
0.5477322936,
0.119943656,
0.3381899595,
0.5740957856,
-0.127906546,
-0.3979856968,
-0.3719682395,
-0.3359874785,
0.7232789993,
0.280606091,
-0.2569260001,
-0.5787376761,
-0.0652792677,
0.1961111575,
0.3206614256,
-0.3263314068,
0.9213391542,
0.166203618,
-0.5600072145,
0.6336138248,
0.1509408206,
0.2080207169,
-0.7359313965,
0.3185819685,
-0.2440808266,
0.590107739,
0.2861440182,
-0.4955786169,
0.4811728597,
-0.0239179395,
0.1212011278,
-0.155534476,
0.764921844,
-0.3134789169,
-0.3925698996,
0.6724604368,
0.5132799745,
0.2448671311,
-0.3844935,
-0.7810112238,
0.5159932375,
-0.4193897843,
-0.1125497147,
0.4304981232,
0.4630875885,
0.0146769788,
0.4050240815,
0.2048453242,
0.1401429027,
0.0971289426,
0.5440544486,
0.8246486783,
-0.8973270059,
-0.3730065525,
-0.7597038746,
0.2751601338,
-0.3632336855,
-0.366411984,
0.684910655,
0.5566307306,
1.0762301683,
-0.0085405549,
0.2879164517,
-0.067369312,
0.7962878346,
-0.5546379685,
0.3525535464,
-0.7025027275,
0.1774900109,
-0.2657264769,
-0.6830484867,
-0.6024206877,
0.5371556878,
-0.3764084578,
-0.1660880297,
0.9722293615,
0.8770079017,
0.1640296131,
0.1578416824,
0.4085471928,
0.2880656719,
0.1046316028,
0.1874793321,
0.8721386194,
-0.357951045,
0.3261503577,
-0.4541439116,
0.0502247475,
-0.1455803961,
-0.8035151958,
-0.6299775243,
-0.3641337156,
-0.3337611854,
-0.3285841942,
0.0948059559,
0.9704568386,
0.4562859237,
-0.6209150553,
-0.7664441466,
-0.2163823247,
0.0851182789,
-0.4232390225,
-0.2479223907,
0.2491307259,
-1.1182795763,
-0.634951055,
0.3801644444,
0.1791484654,
-0.2780680954,
0.04598419,
0.0598112084,
-0.1355953962,
-0.2419117093,
0.6841588616,
0.1311068982,
-0.8812478185,
-0.2449161708,
-0.1806346178,
-0.2107731104,
-0.020470323,
1.0477286577,
-0.6624701619,
0.5467075706,
0.232935369,
0.7745357752,
0.2992611527,
-0.1528051794,
0.4656572342,
-0.5150204301,
0.2306181788,
0.0994820669,
0.5537022352,
0.2878617942,
0.2699623108,
0.842125535,
0.1612605453,
-0.2327995896,
-0.9407069087,
0.2095347792,
-1.1161293983,
-0.5286608338,
0.9611398578,
-0.2876541317,
-0.3809741735,
0.1186369732,
-0.119630456,
0.0592757501,
0.0502117574,
0.492582649,
0.5922647119,
-0.0777398124,
-0.0689178035,
-0.4885227978,
0.3878364265,
0.5783308744,
-0.6987751722,
0.3622470796,
0.5482388139,
0.2144897282,
0.1329209208,
0.2830748856,
-0.3475199342,
0.3300790191,
0.163936764,
0.2326217443,
0.1502119452,
0.0344169289,
-0.6592877507,
0.2746062875,
0.3349105418,
-0.0888930336
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02858v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02858v1
|
Language Evolution for Evading Social Media Regulation via LLM-based Multi-agent Simulation
| 2024-05-05T09:02:54 | 2024-05-05T09:02:54 |
Jinyu Cai, Jialong Li, Mingyue Zhang, Munan Li, Chen-Shu Wang, Kenji Tei
|
cs.SI
|
cs.SI, cs.CL
|
Social media platforms such as Twitter, Reddit, and Sina Weibo play a crucial
role in global communication but often encounter strict regulations in
geopolitically sensitive regions. This situation has prompted users to
ingeniously modify their way of communicating, frequently resorting to coded
language in these regulated social media environments. This shift in
communication is not merely a strategy to counteract regulation, but a vivid
manifestation of language evolution, demonstrating how language naturally
evolves under societal and technological pressures. Studying the evolution of
language in regulated social media contexts is of significant importance for
ensuring freedom of speech, optimizing content moderation, and advancing
linguistic research. This paper proposes a multi-agent simulation framework
using Large Language Models (LLMs) to explore the evolution of user language in
regulated social media environments. The framework employs LLM-driven agents:
supervisory agent who enforce dialogue supervision and participant agents who
evolve their language strategies while engaging in conversation, simulating the
evolution of communication styles under strict regulations aimed at evading
social media regulation. The study evaluates the framework's effectiveness
through a range of scenarios from abstract scenarios to real-world situations.
Key findings indicate that LLMs are capable of simulating nuanced language
dynamics and interactions in constrained settings, showing improvement in both
evading supervision and information accuracy as evolution progresses.
Furthermore, it was found that LLM agents adopt different strategies for
different scenarios.
|
[
-0.3662864566,
-1.3431624174,
0.4725888073,
0.4394755065,
-0.4613634348,
0.4627740979,
-0.6308928132,
-0.2980593443,
0.4031425416,
0.6752533317,
-0.6078409553,
-0.3034803271,
-0.47878775,
0.2254602611,
-0.4587277174,
0.8576824069,
-0.1209138259,
-0.130713582,
0.0766345114,
0.1027412191,
-0.0907123312,
-0.5518785119,
-0.6267573237,
-0.3691944778,
0.5911509991,
0.1519411206,
0.4413922131,
0.3549495935,
0.5008829832,
0.3066827953,
-0.3125628531,
0.352252692,
-0.8227440119,
0.1732956469,
-0.0826548487,
-0.0606528595,
-0.2615367472,
-0.2731802762,
0.6562892795,
0.092220284,
-0.4066473246,
0.0107963374,
0.1872094274,
0.2241135091,
-0.4950839281,
0.2704590261,
-0.7042377591,
-0.4292818308,
0.153094992,
-0.6858136654,
-0.2991542518,
-0.3129519224,
-0.0923615471,
-0.3993801177,
-0.1868427247,
-0.1704711169,
0.8393039703,
-0.0418995656,
-0.4872710109,
-0.266276598,
-1.1083315611,
0.5011729598,
-0.5749391913,
0.295501709,
0.0782485083,
0.4463896751,
-0.446342051,
-0.875516355,
-0.6138026714,
-0.184990868,
0.309592694,
0.1136821732,
-0.2325068116,
0.0884750485,
0.0930691436,
-0.3288181424,
0.0230790656,
0.2452536076,
-0.3922907412,
0.1344099939,
0.7174847126,
-0.0411531143,
0.3506084681,
-0.1084917188,
-0.3478513956,
-0.1623002738,
-0.6250955462,
-0.0726820454,
0.4904151261,
0.5228329301,
-0.2591625154,
0.1462031156,
-0.1181991547,
0.2112213522,
-0.0906339362,
-0.1799514294,
0.2010944933,
-0.2060481161,
-0.084493421,
0.0370591916,
0.8869201541,
0.5053290129,
0.452940017,
0.1538227648,
-0.2339903712,
0.0808235034,
0.4128659964,
-0.7113399506,
0.1528455317,
0.1560566276,
-0.3405920267,
-0.5966999531,
-0.0158451088,
-0.9692653418,
-0.7177839279,
-0.2113617957,
0.2206071019,
-0.2051512748,
-0.5533828735,
0.1639053077,
-0.0664349422,
0.4509268105,
0.3456587791,
-0.785579145,
0.2916610241,
0.7785087228,
0.8638234735,
-0.013152794,
-0.4061399996,
-0.3173923194,
0.2342048585,
-0.4109965563,
0.5724956989,
-0.5365576148,
-0.4015814662,
0.5332356691,
0.0954944119,
0.0294198859,
-0.2513384521,
0.490570575,
-0.9238488674,
-0.3022499084,
-0.091273807,
-0.254098773,
0.0049917074,
0.1689598411,
-0.6342013478,
0.6469137669,
-0.0351469368,
-0.5217631459,
0.2671446204,
-0.9229751825,
-0.5044355392,
0.2990633547,
-0.2635695338,
-0.373111397,
0.0044435086,
0.0765640736,
0.4343125522,
-0.2739072144,
0.432261616,
-0.641520679,
-0.4800035059,
0.5270898938,
-0.5264207721,
0.6059262156,
0.1563123018,
-0.3623942435,
0.3461900949,
-0.420923233,
-0.1119948849,
0.2966603637,
-0.3693624735,
-0.1708489954,
0.2677666843,
0.2445619255,
0.3638508022,
-0.0596753359,
-0.3860520422,
0.0595187135,
-0.1662755311,
0.7548687458,
0.9050046802,
0.6765310168,
0.2605805099,
-0.5117105842,
0.6162399054,
-0.2349664271,
0.3664996326,
0.1408501267,
-0.3054921925,
-0.4161636829,
-0.1568971723,
-0.0137439128,
0.4780757725,
-0.8939452171,
0.087937817,
-0.506636858,
-0.4304876626,
-0.6884375811,
0.2539332211,
-0.0001882867,
-0.2552527487,
0.1525559425,
0.2206561714,
-0.4303227365,
-0.7084398866,
-0.2718554735,
-0.4067198038,
0.1611662954,
0.2619452775,
0.3441334665,
-0.6383185387,
0.8064364791,
-0.1140537262,
0.1281352043,
-0.7276450992,
0.0608513206,
-0.2495201677,
0.0643970743,
0.5042681098,
-0.9373905659,
-0.490146637,
0.1418734789,
-0.494025588,
-0.5168491602,
-0.5842934251,
-0.1103189886,
0.2714563012,
0.7483768463,
-0.4249983728,
0.2848109007,
0.7582530975,
-0.0073940712,
0.6681732535,
-0.0718549117,
0.2593644261,
-1.1788520813,
-0.0791259706,
0.0703402981,
-0.3661226332,
-0.941234529,
0.2386933863,
0.0452231541,
0.1639412642,
-0.6721040606,
0.6695888042,
-0.5438958406,
0.2163883001,
-0.5462904572,
0.2977104187,
-0.32712695,
0.4686100781,
-0.200432986,
0.6101064086,
0.6097002029,
-0.7435594797,
0.4476599991,
-0.0947526693,
-0.417871654,
0.1523170024,
-0.4661958814,
0.1386674494,
-0.1631097645,
0.2420791686,
-0.6228761077,
-0.3290081918,
0.2394946516,
-0.1639183164,
0.1465663165,
-0.0366331227,
-0.7769370079,
-0.2433752716,
-0.4565053284,
0.040228717,
0.4757041037,
-0.44086501,
0.7327548265,
0.5072741508,
-0.1608277857,
-0.4186185598,
-0.5284790397,
0.2829137743,
-0.548676908,
-0.5943402052,
0.1415047199,
-0.2293154895,
-0.6356881857,
-0.2371211797,
0.1873351783,
0.1747224331,
0.3594270647,
0.1335667074,
0.0116375322,
0.0265921541,
-0.0682576522,
0.3658768833,
0.5122183561,
0.2931098342,
0.1770260632,
0.9309096336,
-0.1629100889,
-0.1285580248,
-0.6235154867,
0.1297557801,
0.6536704898,
0.062932238,
0.8165767193,
0.3987328708,
-0.1569933146,
-0.5049825311,
-0.5420280695,
-0.433182776,
-0.5854565501,
0.3669719696,
-0.1779486537,
-0.9116199017,
0.7160667181,
-0.4098036289,
0.2403634191,
0.0144949406,
0.7394368649,
0.1324605495,
0.7952007055,
0.7404834032,
0.2118195295,
0.8856883645,
0.1486536115,
0.0387726277,
-0.5143255591,
0.0420362577,
-0.1920259744,
-0.1257919967,
-0.8116243482,
-0.418807894,
0.1652637869,
-0.0112200128,
0.1597633809,
0.369571954,
0.2106799781,
0.5037968159,
0.2302082032,
0.0777483955,
0.1350248158,
0.2485332787,
0.0668685585,
0.2806892991,
-0.5092033744,
-0.6921793818,
0.8456770182,
0.5080788732,
0.9334770441,
0.2727708817,
0.7972833514,
0.5974490643,
0.6636508703,
-0.5237534642,
0.6774930954,
0.1014375091,
-0.4086840451,
-0.1764819026,
-0.5526439548,
-0.780338347,
0.3572137058,
-0.4131035507,
-0.7978702784,
0.1254478693,
-0.0080300383,
-0.0721015707,
0.2284181714,
-0.6195638776,
0.6378660202,
-0.2880952358,
-0.4863333702,
-0.2721311748,
-0.6324859858,
0.2370614111,
-0.4895894825,
0.5018476844,
-0.0531074442,
-0.0394157805,
0.4655638635,
-0.0504933894,
1.1104594469,
0.0695469379,
-0.2605168223,
0.5821783543,
0.0387698077,
0.5224506855,
0.0670732111,
0.0220167208,
0.0534508638,
-0.0226327684,
-0.1939190328,
-0.4921702147,
0.6176000834,
-0.8945357203,
-0.5168852806,
-0.0256248694,
-0.2676984072,
-0.1676743478,
0.2273306549,
0.15258497,
0.0948781893,
-0.5261037946,
0.2332603931,
0.2256348133,
-0.1893226802,
0.4405451417,
0.6437872052,
-0.3993901908,
-0.3318366706,
0.7132140994,
0.0082529327,
0.4827628136,
0.0418759212,
0.4332484901,
-0.2725134492,
-0.3104725182,
-0.2455353737,
0.429538995,
-0.7470400333,
-0.0709421635,
-0.6285823584,
-0.3391642272,
-0.5946971774,
-0.2091933936,
0.0302262176,
0.0335723311,
-0.1053957939,
-0.1303503364,
0.1877483875,
0.7440758348,
-0.1345802546,
0.6653607488,
-0.4775182009,
-0.0099365395,
0.1326466799,
0.2775486112,
-0.2391848713,
-0.5310290456,
-0.1072471887,
0.196309343,
-0.2577250898,
-1.217322588,
0.269913435,
0.0753651559,
0.5099284649,
0.5253988504,
0.1364981532,
0.5400992632,
-0.5099684596,
0.3740935624,
-0.0688777342,
-0.8067424297,
0.2768091857,
-0.6022863984,
-0.0574582219,
0.3485127687,
-0.0061632902,
-0.9296827316,
-0.8446055651,
-0.4519669116,
-0.8409825563,
0.6703384519,
0.1756118238,
0.7490351796,
-0.021469377,
0.4411948621,
-0.1994533837,
0.2752475441,
-1.010509491,
0.0370309204,
0.108656466,
0.0319666117,
0.021057846,
-0.3573912978,
-0.3569897711,
0.116257593,
0.6985149384,
-0.0571432225,
0.167794466,
-0.1639895141,
-0.0205654167,
-0.2265613526,
0.5349652171,
0.8274958134,
0.6133905053,
-0.0576040596,
-0.0538198613,
0.0699286535,
-0.4226074219,
-0.0170760024,
0.0029240448,
-0.3217224777,
-0.1461674124,
0.1361819655,
0.9565380812,
0.1375175864,
-0.8130243421,
0.5079947114,
-0.1629657447,
-0.4140436947,
-0.2780005336,
0.1034623086,
0.2284195274,
0.5773952007,
0.2794208825,
-0.390529573,
-0.1108598858,
-0.577681303,
0.2079572082,
0.3682122827,
-0.1954862922,
-0.275033325,
0.3941247165,
0.2524519265,
-0.559448421,
-0.0024008704,
-0.3989723325,
-0.4542062283,
0.6319258213,
0.7837206125,
1.0732409954,
-0.1883875579,
0.4233753979,
-0.0460307673,
0.5164626837,
-0.2010995597,
0.2586326003,
0.1670629382,
-0.8950406909,
-0.2553364933,
-0.6970083117,
-0.5383191109,
0.3650025427,
-0.311083436,
0.6600077748,
-0.5716304183,
-0.3316623271,
-0.0666336417,
-0.2289343327,
-0.2676063478,
-0.3805968761,
0.3022680879,
0.6277086139,
-0.9180372953,
0.8338896632,
0.8866900802,
-0.039427951,
-0.5211696625,
0.4835297167,
0.1287817359,
-0.6986542344,
0.2598140538,
0.2839894593,
-0.5802818537,
0.0819476917,
-0.9209641814,
-0.5298342109,
0.9278562665,
0.3347260058,
-0.4025409818,
0.1305110157,
0.1282902509,
1.0654958487,
-0.3989858925,
-0.097951971,
0.3135692477,
0.1791873425,
-0.0128974263,
-0.6234083772,
0.0260405131,
-0.2394652069,
0.1637611836,
0.1493599266,
-0.8010767698,
0.6422598362,
-0.057393495,
-0.6796728969,
-0.1715017855,
0.5375592709,
0.1634407789,
0.2434409112,
0.5263834,
-0.2738422751,
0.2418702245,
0.2441501915,
0.7770221829,
-0.6750984192,
0.4629667699,
0.8116211295,
-0.6252228618,
0.960159719,
0.3930484354,
0.2961836755,
0.7521929145,
0.4386843741,
0.0364772677,
0.2246972471,
0.3287335932,
-0.3555055857,
-0.1171537265,
-0.2997855246,
-0.0760195032,
0.6213616729,
0.4094216526,
-0.2799978554,
-0.1388026476,
-0.0516071208,
0.3099442422,
0.267442286,
-0.2022372633,
0.8955822587,
-0.0407749303,
-0.5305538774,
0.4448186159,
0.3927479982,
0.6272889376,
-0.7140032649,
0.1120273471,
-0.1660595238,
0.1406781077,
0.0889115632,
-0.5441789031,
0.0639010444,
0.171716556,
0.4750232995,
-0.4987361133,
0.8175213337,
-0.5674344897,
-0.2911411822,
0.8558496833,
0.5841201544,
-0.0214563403,
0.1244737208,
-0.7657840848,
0.3683611751,
-0.3104912937,
-0.4330783188,
0.2456214875,
0.4082880616,
-0.1716905534,
0.7321307063,
0.6989466548,
0.1999165267,
0.1093741879,
0.334392041,
1.0556417704,
-0.4506720006,
-0.7515422702,
-1.06138587,
-0.01410593,
-0.3530546725,
-0.001821932,
0.5660631061,
0.1155635566,
0.6243509054,
0.1309500188,
0.8319015503,
0.0675736144,
0.257884711,
-0.4895571768,
0.9511800408,
-0.7038532495,
0.3291964829,
-0.5300967693,
-0.847791791,
-0.1826339513,
0.3116984069,
-0.2154678851,
0.1287104934,
0.4526850283,
0.8377013206,
0.0443025194,
-0.056126792,
0.2221672833,
0.3029071987,
0.5735323429,
0.1764387637,
0.9375891089,
0.1344043165,
0.7210896015,
-0.2141876966,
-0.2587423027,
-0.3803630471,
-0.6353005171,
-1.0217909813,
-0.4197077751,
-0.1537059695,
-0.5524235964,
0.1245304644,
1.3422135115,
0.3978573084,
-0.4560762644,
-0.6468042731,
0.0753497928,
0.0247114524,
-0.2026952505,
-0.2965901792,
-0.1089185327,
-0.1659777313,
-0.6605052948,
0.3169857264,
0.3364436328,
0.2276593596,
-0.4315429628,
-0.1714417189,
-0.323300153,
0.5074847341,
0.7026777267,
0.4448848367,
-0.7001566291,
-0.299857378,
0.0835841149,
-0.3924489319,
-0.130896613,
0.6995649338,
-0.2009455562,
0.4791392088,
0.4499699771,
0.76689744,
0.1238714382,
0.2736369371,
0.5103002787,
-0.7592669129,
-0.0854765102,
0.1299000233,
0.1066289619,
0.2921537757,
-0.0655763224,
0.2265771478,
0.2428370714,
-0.5840206146,
-1.0322751999,
0.3463712335,
-0.8355736732,
-0.4839138687,
1.8665858507,
0.2740172744,
-0.2739623189,
-0.0339571387,
-0.1411106884,
0.2996318936,
-0.770236969,
1.2048509121,
0.8322483301,
0.1096161157,
-0.4259368777,
-0.7258471847,
0.5807040334,
0.021736769,
-1.0356752872,
0.4070415199,
0.3447241187,
0.2175155133,
0.1077563763,
0.8111932278,
0.2339756489,
0.1256595403,
-0.2794339359,
-0.120808363,
0.2428893745,
-0.3948881924,
-0.5122228265,
-0.0103379358,
0.0438432023,
0.1584905535
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02817v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02817v1
|
HuixiangDou-CR: Coreference Resolution in Group Chats
| 2024-05-05T05:43:20 | 2024-05-05T05:43:20 |
Huanjun Kong
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
How to eliminate pronominal reference in group chats? In this work, we have
preprocessed 58k authentic chat data and manually annotated 2.3k questions. The
reliability of this annotation was confirmed by the scaling law. After this, we
conducted fine-tuning on Qwen models, ranging from 0.5B to 32B parameters. The
optimal version improved 29.07 in F1 score. This confirms the viability of
fine-tuning Large Language Model (LLM) for downstream Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. Our contributions are: 1) Created Supervised
Fine-Tuning (SFT) training data in alpaca format, along with a set of Low-Rank
Adaptation (LoRA) weights, and 2) Developed a method for acquiring high-quality
data leveraging scaling law principle. The script, raw data with alpaca format
and experiments track are open-sourced on Github
https://github.com/InternLM/HuixiangDou/tree/main/web/tools, HuggingFace
https://huggingface.co/tpoisonooo and WandB
https://wandb.ai/tpoisonooo/huixiangdou-cr/table?nw=nwusertpoisonooo . The
privacy of the data involved has been authorized by users.
|
[
-0.4709284902,
-0.5692721009,
0.0551928766,
0.2583426237,
-0.5295291543,
-0.0600843392,
-0.5745974779,
-0.6727719307,
0.0733696222,
0.7210392356,
-0.4092330337,
-0.5779492259,
-0.5589321256,
0.1184129491,
-0.1750817448,
1.0732403994,
0.1906088144,
-0.1232256293,
0.0285782889,
-0.4403202832,
-0.050311856,
-0.8498725891,
-0.8410386443,
-0.214025259,
0.4353874922,
0.7671989799,
0.9992082715,
0.6805483103,
0.5180076957,
0.339836657,
-0.2888946533,
0.4091621935,
-0.6425449252,
-0.0723204985,
-0.1174902767,
-0.3707478046,
-0.8284033537,
0.0495725833,
0.5275276899,
0.5939139128,
-0.0961718634,
0.2256157845,
0.4591421783,
0.5600778461,
-0.3846983612,
0.2983326614,
-0.8618392944,
-0.1149042472,
-0.3880986273,
-0.068315126,
-0.3771861494,
-0.3955146074,
-0.1052146032,
-0.7721908092,
0.5040086508,
0.3218319416,
1.1670187712,
0.1727366894,
-0.3664840758,
-0.3569933474,
-0.4507463574,
0.823113203,
-0.9747543335,
0.0365413129,
0.920881927,
-0.0269893818,
-0.3751172721,
-0.5297161341,
-0.5224371552,
-0.3290236592,
-0.137946859,
-0.1262335032,
-0.1803537011,
0.3538717031,
0.3899242282,
0.3749945462,
-0.3900705874,
0.3671675026,
-0.5267063975,
-0.3718726933,
0.5954930782,
0.0604160652,
0.0863338709,
-0.1991033107,
0.1109695062,
0.2605686486,
-0.4827263355,
0.0449621007,
0.2918738425,
0.6015303731,
0.0774981529,
0.4621314704,
-0.3606290519,
0.4133069217,
0.8095417619,
-0.2552051842,
0.3767552376,
-0.5052312016,
-0.0714789182,
-0.1348708868,
0.9294168949,
0.6601110101,
0.369225055,
-0.3059692085,
0.4275501966,
-0.2640215456,
-0.0433493666,
-0.8873046041,
-0.269174695,
0.2971859574,
-0.4647595882,
-0.1735779345,
-0.0700365454,
-0.3894019425,
-0.4334245324,
-0.4420026839,
0.0737982169,
-0.4718801379,
-0.1949385554,
-0.1787033975,
0.24896653,
0.0286457893,
0.2771545053,
-0.9952787757,
0.333101213,
0.5444511175,
0.6954394579,
0.0094012907,
-0.1400041133,
-0.6388552785,
0.1064327359,
-0.1477061808,
0.6525900364,
-0.3044721782,
-0.5532308221,
-0.2994264066,
0.1403171718,
0.1141106337,
-0.9566152096,
0.9783412218,
-0.1341638714,
0.1300037503,
-0.3824037015,
-0.5202638507,
0.0519553013,
0.2448677421,
-0.4664235115,
0.9095913172,
-0.16153346,
-0.7357397079,
0.0839680284,
-0.2832155228,
-0.1280511767,
0.2025381774,
-0.0102055874,
-0.1476264,
-0.2438130528,
0.3330870271,
0.5866526961,
-0.3634614348,
0.3993848264,
-0.1133739501,
-0.1743628681,
-0.0627461374,
0.0816650465,
0.7312607169,
0.1423761845,
0.0786286965,
0.4858576655,
-0.8282591105,
0.1770305783,
-0.2880980968,
0.0381746106,
-0.4739512503,
-0.0883715004,
-0.3292638063,
0.1752444655,
0.3743438125,
-0.4380859435,
0.1653211266,
-0.1004579812,
0.5637680888,
0.5674523115,
0.0711864009,
0.552565515,
-0.0104061784,
0.1815204918,
0.132013768,
0.5997011065,
0.2936468124,
-0.3571917117,
-0.6699165702,
-0.1619658917,
0.1864224374,
0.3932007253,
-0.7376771569,
0.7123168707,
-0.0300355107,
-0.8871830702,
-0.3584202528,
0.3077415824,
0.1551824659,
0.7221477628,
0.603623569,
-0.1470095515,
-0.5434606075,
-0.9406580925,
0.0754838735,
-0.4164312482,
-0.4165679216,
0.2807938755,
0.1056307033,
-0.0898042321,
0.9854489565,
-0.188398838,
-0.5510067344,
-0.047848206,
0.2652639151,
0.3826084435,
0.4875158668,
0.5517687201,
-0.7133262157,
-0.3930193484,
-0.0303936768,
-0.4582391977,
-0.3968595266,
0.2003320605,
-0.367349416,
-0.0815869719,
0.6924529076,
-0.5071424246,
0.2754200995,
0.7785499692,
-0.3175460696,
0.8543083072,
-0.0409683995,
0.2047965527,
-1.1955417395,
-0.0795248896,
0.154397741,
-0.2437622696,
-0.5351605415,
-0.0330754146,
0.0499750078,
0.1968667507,
-0.3531350791,
0.2747191489,
-0.3817571104,
0.45642519,
-0.4145987928,
0.4952577949,
-0.0471519567,
0.7493988276,
-0.1489650309,
0.735883534,
0.2831085622,
-0.9705067277,
0.7182636857,
0.309225738,
-0.0738145933,
0.5016334653,
-0.7861976624,
0.3178486526,
0.1800982356,
0.3315616846,
-0.6750491261,
0.0733646676,
0.4904040992,
-0.455571115,
0.0193527378,
-0.2657341361,
-0.3470670879,
-0.2370948941,
-0.2274657339,
0.4775116146,
0.1212723106,
-0.397136122,
0.6163649559,
0.424921006,
-0.2073808461,
-0.6119142771,
-0.262688309,
0.1291423887,
-0.2566609085,
-0.4553954601,
0.6228093505,
-0.0853253603,
-0.2952442169,
-0.1096560657,
-0.0597611032,
-0.0827635974,
-0.2282431126,
0.455542922,
0.2976370156,
0.0271676742,
0.2118399143,
-0.1674216092,
-0.086275436,
-0.136826992,
0.0508041717,
0.6386579275,
-0.3761139214,
0.0614612661,
-0.4027208388,
0.1527992487,
0.1775199622,
-0.1312144399,
0.8947575092,
0.8141543865,
-0.3470885456,
0.3219335079,
-0.5810669661,
-0.1106194183,
-0.5068965554,
0.4752879143,
-0.3068451583,
-1.1870080233,
0.9518917203,
-0.0784175098,
0.2730160058,
0.5457444787,
0.5525505543,
-0.0748675317,
0.5024299026,
0.5224420428,
-0.3093605936,
0.5618626475,
0.0776999369,
0.2102042288,
-1.0350095034,
0.065256685,
-0.9247333407,
-0.1839268953,
-0.6836278439,
-0.4940948486,
0.2829419971,
0.5436370969,
-0.2749065161,
0.6863926649,
-0.2979382575,
0.5003169179,
0.5406033993,
0.3567313552,
0.425819397,
-0.4468227625,
0.1929319203,
-0.2093076855,
-0.4601350129,
-0.5389550328,
0.7501397729,
0.2986887097,
0.5250617862,
-0.0078113014,
0.4170733988,
0.2014372647,
0.3578092754,
-0.8637118936,
0.8485399485,
-0.2463350147,
-0.2518070638,
-0.5392795801,
-0.6713722348,
-0.9140626788,
0.2741166949,
-0.1020218059,
-0.9755969644,
0.1941386759,
0.1914946139,
-0.3965081275,
0.2651755512,
-0.4883360565,
0.7151360512,
0.2095340937,
-0.3511483371,
-0.3411168456,
-0.6261434555,
0.2570765615,
0.161407724,
0.2380224317,
-0.6019034982,
0.298099637,
0.9195557833,
-0.5974086523,
1.0435112715,
-0.1189928353,
-0.3289095163,
0.5105656981,
0.0453932434,
0.4651861191,
0.0320801102,
-0.164271906,
0.5257612467,
0.2066512853,
-0.3241884708,
-0.466728121,
0.4639386237,
-0.786780417,
-0.6326052547,
0.0644481182,
-0.5779573321,
-0.3417721987,
-0.0638900399,
0.449492991,
0.4374419749,
-0.100584574,
0.4966383278,
0.3291184902,
0.0196792725,
0.2470650822,
0.2722244561,
-0.2801109552,
-0.308444947,
0.4914964139,
0.2732880414,
0.2804741561,
0.0264047664,
0.2160213888,
0.0834057257,
-0.4254766405,
-0.1355060339,
0.433155477,
-0.6146562696,
-0.3557109833,
-0.3530377448,
-0.2577587664,
-0.6890122294,
0.2624613941,
-0.4393377006,
-0.497584939,
-0.4140079319,
-0.1169424951,
0.361313045,
-0.0353167541,
-0.0907057822,
0.5231192708,
-1.012050271,
0.4146099389,
0.182264775,
-0.0261502732,
-0.1765833497,
-0.9814109206,
-0.5326846242,
0.1836325675,
-0.2554927468,
-0.5732238889,
0.233918637,
0.2772705555,
0.4342370629,
0.5761876702,
0.5182449222,
0.8883607984,
-0.2104176879,
0.8637411594,
0.0108664567,
-0.9982324243,
0.4916039407,
-0.2703917325,
0.254597187,
0.7119527459,
0.2673945129,
-0.8355563879,
-0.5263490081,
-0.587731719,
-0.9654045105,
0.2775268555,
0.1573033482,
0.1626292914,
-0.0912716091,
0.8306022286,
0.0130612375,
0.0794150159,
-0.4314356148,
-0.102244474,
0.063504979,
-0.1292432398,
0.0961665288,
-0.5443639159,
-0.1711591184,
-0.5360611677,
0.7915290594,
-0.4370946586,
0.0989405215,
0.1090256795,
0.0177150015,
-0.1827936918,
0.185829103,
0.5257573724,
0.6706681848,
-0.0717335418,
-0.0455781594,
0.2569097281,
-0.7957424521,
-0.2708643675,
-0.2059058249,
0.093829751,
-0.02472114,
0.3885007203,
0.6744066477,
-0.006105273,
-0.374340862,
0.1256849617,
-0.0592146702,
-0.3316970468,
-0.242236495,
0.2015447468,
-0.0289418027,
0.2593212724,
0.5968689322,
0.0498383641,
-0.0111196311,
-0.4078364968,
0.0383282341,
0.129745096,
-0.1757078916,
-0.3442824483,
0.4501021206,
0.4712217152,
-0.0952582583,
0.7672415972,
-0.1462463289,
-0.5001686215,
0.5123395324,
0.2738859355,
0.648195684,
-0.5025817752,
0.1489767879,
0.778191328,
0.2518209815,
-0.0286091901,
-0.1194977015,
-0.2020749003,
-1.2850325108,
-0.4303979874,
-0.2533334494,
-0.9275234938,
0.0531476773,
-1.0077615976,
0.2427251786,
-0.4209249318,
-0.6093488932,
-0.1943784952,
0.2378024906,
-0.3760781288,
0.0391945727,
-0.067621097,
0.5867497921,
-0.5124956369,
1.008528471,
0.1852978468,
-0.104111366,
-0.837936759,
0.0236734692,
-0.1322433352,
-0.6245757341,
0.3645226061,
-0.0530947112,
-0.2110106051,
-0.0661361068,
-0.8813797235,
-0.683560133,
1.0000021458,
0.2888519466,
-0.7114931345,
-0.1952928901,
-0.072189495,
0.5937837958,
-0.1336910725,
-0.0215002969,
0.6427509189,
0.3544946909,
0.2477664798,
-1.585209012,
-0.0577611364,
-0.2439318448,
-0.2819956541,
-0.1434270442,
-1.0028967857,
0.7442369461,
-0.1716475785,
-0.1232436597,
0.0037988238,
1.1303200722,
0.1908940077,
0.0210898723,
0.6412756443,
0.1918219626,
1.067689538,
-0.1117937714,
0.4447226226,
-0.3167361617,
0.3568890989,
1.4743528366,
-0.4278725088,
0.731931746,
0.5582115054,
-0.1535074413,
0.2663556933,
0.6537991762,
0.0892289579,
0.1899162978,
0.0979977027,
-0.1045951173,
-0.2410720289,
-0.524920702,
-0.3035002649,
0.3224241138,
0.5224253535,
-0.1873192042,
0.0098669287,
0.1255353391,
0.3919724226,
0.1705570668,
-0.5295926929,
0.6716402769,
0.0227644779,
-0.3478831649,
0.4897978306,
0.079503864,
0.9004679918,
-0.60220927,
0.2261417359,
-0.3825700879,
0.2542451322,
-0.3239761591,
-0.4454360008,
0.322514683,
-0.0377313569,
-0.0455280989,
0.1428506523,
0.5885504484,
-0.52359128,
-0.2349110693,
0.1991184801,
0.3147428036,
0.2796984315,
-0.3762388229,
-0.5260397196,
0.0191386417,
0.0459346697,
-0.3906925619,
0.227935791,
0.5274311304,
-0.358446002,
0.7304432392,
0.4182191789,
-0.0126621276,
-0.1608416438,
0.4029814005,
0.8449550867,
-0.5994548202,
-0.3096082211,
-0.7380593419,
-0.1277533472,
-0.1533950269,
-0.4347016811,
0.7495800257,
0.4000940025,
0.7071845531,
0.2869969904,
0.3406811059,
-0.1921312362,
0.5385055542,
-0.4342309535,
0.3531615138,
0.1113267243,
-0.1196066663,
-0.2372527868,
-0.7083188295,
-0.4319066107,
0.6133587956,
-0.3407286406,
-0.095540598,
0.5066298842,
0.8136150241,
0.3632966578,
0.1600597948,
0.313116312,
0.3979209363,
0.4449864924,
0.4817765057,
0.3702687919,
-0.5242259502,
0.5906909108,
-0.300185889,
-0.2604174018,
-0.1855208129,
-0.9569965601,
-0.8874959946,
-0.6320713758,
-0.6475194097,
-0.529555738,
-0.299187839,
1.2947789431,
0.7495039701,
-0.8699224591,
-0.2483910471,
0.4125027955,
-0.1164785028,
-0.5266902447,
-0.2132689059,
0.3593179584,
-0.1954074651,
-0.8890563846,
0.1173330992,
-0.0958264992,
-0.0572711602,
-0.052277606,
-0.0562411211,
-0.0407266468,
-0.2815847993,
0.6075407863,
0.2775059342,
-0.6087023616,
-0.5075327158,
-0.1064799652,
-0.3077791929,
0.1835255921,
0.8946651816,
-0.3332805932,
-0.036078006,
0.1992824972,
-0.0059995884,
0.3177891374,
0.4667506814,
0.3803291023,
-0.9198024869,
0.481482774,
0.2258980572,
0.2746902704,
0.1387445778,
-0.5850192308,
0.6661126614,
0.1614036262,
-0.7278475761,
-0.502594173,
-0.0298308879,
-1.2787759304,
0.0792056248,
1.1867001057,
-0.2109372169,
-0.2574391365,
-0.2459412068,
-0.7707176805,
0.428227663,
-0.3101106584,
0.7995992899,
1.0125509501,
-0.2288018614,
-0.4105764925,
-0.3801172078,
0.5212776065,
0.1560626924,
-0.6604832411,
0.5094919801,
0.4149142802,
0.0798470154,
0.2440474331,
0.8528050184,
-0.1456809789,
-0.0670839995,
-0.2383549362,
0.4636717439,
-0.2334176451,
-0.0577023476,
0.2013772726,
0.1834162772,
0.0939106867,
-0.3238835335
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02816v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02816v1
|
Stochastic RAG: End-to-End Retrieval-Augmented Generation through Expected Utility Maximization
| 2024-05-05T05:42:33 | 2024-05-05T05:42:33 |
Hamed Zamani, Michael Bendersky
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR, cs.LG
|
This paper introduces Stochastic RAG--a novel approach for end-to-end
optimization of retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) models that relaxes the
simplifying assumptions of marginalization and document independence, made in
most prior work. Stochastic RAG casts the retrieval process in RAG as a
stochastic sampling without replacement process. Through this formulation, we
employ straight-through Gumbel-top-k that provides a differentiable
approximation for sampling without replacement and enables effective end-to-end
optimization for RAG. We conduct extensive experiments on seven diverse
datasets on a wide range of tasks, from open-domain question answering to fact
verification to slot-filling for relation extraction and to dialogue systems.
By applying this optimization method to a recent and effective RAG model, we
advance state-of-the-art results on six out of seven datasets.
|
[
-0.4422081709,
-0.8255664706,
0.5666245222,
-0.0248618461,
-0.3224799931,
0.1261899024,
-0.2466873378,
-0.1653869301,
0.3945111036,
0.6182444692,
-0.6652752161,
-0.0748463571,
-0.4527607262,
-0.2796688676,
-0.1602874696,
1.262704134,
-0.1728359908,
-0.1814149022,
-0.4949184358,
0.0070243026,
-0.0713973641,
-0.222429648,
-0.9314737916,
-0.2596402168,
0.5289441347,
0.329713136,
0.5296138525,
0.4634933472,
0.4047177136,
0.1648816317,
-0.1104658768,
0.2856113613,
-0.9210597277,
0.3949686289,
-0.2862632871,
-0.3866448104,
-0.1833448261,
0.0761872903,
0.3825271428,
0.6636180878,
-0.6256151199,
0.655333221,
-0.2416682988,
0.761746347,
-0.983512044,
-0.4234883785,
-0.4135473967,
-0.0156269502,
-0.0292870477,
-0.728405118,
-0.4714021087,
-0.623223424,
-0.095174484,
-0.5955998302,
0.4547703564,
0.1049061567,
1.0076239109,
0.4837897718,
-0.3391460776,
-0.4075051546,
-1.0150140524,
1.0457359552,
-0.3160146773,
0.2303036004,
0.636605978,
0.5995640755,
-0.5135589838,
-0.8647285104,
-0.3380573094,
-0.3191378117,
0.2257470787,
0.5749913454,
-0.0132713923,
0.0438802652,
0.1846625656,
0.3832470775,
-0.3127928376,
-0.2152803391,
-0.3515891135,
0.378472954,
0.706987679,
-0.1752307713,
-0.1093436033,
-0.2948590517,
-0.6140155196,
-0.2244839519,
-0.378775388,
0.3204827309,
0.805300653,
0.0406790748,
0.0918942243,
0.6175088882,
0.0173976589,
0.4643914104,
0.0185481478,
-0.1370760053,
-0.1087783575,
-0.2798074782,
-0.3745938838,
-0.344859302,
0.4250610173,
0.2453505546,
-0.0388767458,
-0.1442000419,
-0.3501109481,
-0.3799621165,
0.4942025542,
-0.4623749852,
0.1965595037,
0.3470164537,
-0.5830354691,
-0.5684538484,
-0.2826913297,
-0.8140290976,
-0.1171288714,
-0.4259959459,
0.3335929513,
-0.2607122958,
-0.556812644,
-0.0895014703,
-0.2881411016,
0.1656371653,
0.2219956517,
-0.4192079604,
0.3489231169,
0.5901988745,
0.4622975886,
-0.0989159793,
0.2503787577,
-0.4873259068,
0.121026963,
-0.7290606499,
1.0628203154,
-0.6067754626,
-0.5811175108,
-0.1400071383,
-0.2339863777,
0.1177531555,
-0.5165752769,
0.9205737114,
-0.6855763793,
0.2304071337,
-0.0671610683,
-0.3937754333,
-0.0142686488,
-0.0456788577,
-0.7102889419,
1.2835234404,
0.3639883995,
-0.7002479434,
0.4359768927,
-0.4212539494,
-0.1141847,
-0.1860705316,
-0.0404615924,
-0.5914728045,
0.59152776,
-0.3936006427,
-0.0168153923,
-0.7775830626,
0.4630623162,
-0.3052251339,
0.0256554,
0.1773170382,
-0.4561586082,
0.7985397577,
0.5677998662,
0.0719612017,
0.1496748924,
-0.8717906475,
0.1392307729,
0.1372666508,
-0.246740818,
-0.688998878,
0.153720066,
0.118631795,
0.106700629,
0.3407016993,
-0.5961421728,
0.124272123,
-0.3133646548,
-0.4350398779,
0.7460548878,
0.2957098186,
0.5650045872,
-0.8773037791,
0.6339341998,
-0.0689870194,
0.3275167942,
-0.0568980873,
-0.2152056992,
-0.4970577657,
-0.4048495889,
0.4424586296,
0.309863925,
-0.7887615561,
0.0247385483,
-0.0499042943,
-0.4727092385,
-0.4026251137,
-0.3095894158,
0.4494863451,
0.4196343422,
0.2136137784,
-0.3519927263,
-0.6511915326,
-0.8632256389,
-0.2039290965,
0.0612043142,
-0.2051995844,
0.6472539306,
0.0026932883,
-0.095197916,
1.021057725,
-0.4955566227,
-0.0277012195,
-0.2894893289,
0.5089365244,
0.5029827952,
0.2855650783,
0.2706985772,
-1.2024037838,
-0.5463781357,
-0.0388643146,
-0.5178541541,
-0.216371879,
-0.3038709164,
-0.392450124,
0.3780078292,
0.2990553379,
-0.5980151296,
0.605475843,
0.2108992636,
0.1799399853,
0.7854901552,
-0.5838894844,
0.1973108798,
-1.2108364105,
0.2121108025,
-0.0828426182,
-0.1558786035,
-0.7896919847,
0.3247721195,
-0.1286675185,
0.0240391642,
-0.1933673918,
0.5380018353,
-0.7069875002,
-0.3153590262,
-0.5458641052,
-0.0716444328,
-0.2349347025,
0.5285933614,
-0.2165799439,
0.7155145407,
0.1771142334,
-0.5478909612,
0.0307607818,
-0.1619865149,
0.0530832075,
0.5408273339,
-0.4326575994,
0.0335135423,
-0.8229883313,
0.082061179,
-1.0272666216,
-0.2840867043,
-0.1944389343,
-0.5199273825,
0.668466568,
-0.2485909164,
-0.2500044405,
-0.1649687737,
-0.5080606341,
0.3668855727,
0.6620076299,
-0.3944286704,
0.8098079562,
0.8012647033,
-0.3144307137,
-0.9287304878,
0.1840279549,
-0.181901142,
-0.077628009,
-0.3558495641,
0.2684234977,
0.1295061409,
-0.175456062,
0.0115196612,
-0.3326894343,
-0.1001784131,
0.0058999518,
-0.2072123885,
0.3355876207,
0.2161985785,
-0.0000674568,
0.2193718404,
-0.2884373069,
-0.2849555016,
-0.1812845021,
0.5498256683,
0.4625032842,
-0.2612250447,
0.3346098661,
0.8010216951,
0.085434325,
-0.0603847876,
0.3053199947,
0.4202459455,
-0.4192219675,
-0.4169098139,
-0.5897160172,
0.1624561995,
-0.4591450989,
0.2675056159,
-0.5014373064,
-0.6744453311,
0.4596160352,
-0.367210865,
0.4479089081,
0.2240980268,
0.4065002799,
-0.3087890446,
0.7892100215,
0.7356548905,
0.5825029016,
0.338118583,
-0.2282467484,
0.3135348558,
-0.9481253624,
0.0591341853,
-0.5644613504,
-0.2142502815,
-0.970523715,
-0.8781651855,
0.5249199867,
0.5439715981,
-0.0820530504,
0.1804057807,
-0.6739088893,
0.1724282205,
0.8061186075,
-0.0322973356,
0.2425260246,
0.0738755837,
-0.3063194752,
-0.1328596026,
-0.5281200409,
-0.3526824713,
1.2097957134,
0.0097946338,
0.9988496304,
0.2717577517,
0.9680835605,
0.0786271021,
0.5201309919,
-0.6393864751,
0.4519761205,
-0.3013189435,
-0.5250449777,
-0.4169412553,
-0.6044164896,
-1.2082529068,
0.2234968692,
-0.0270389523,
-0.7634266019,
0.3400937617,
-0.0971479863,
0.0833161548,
0.3231485188,
-0.4561491609,
0.3336926997,
0.0645878688,
-0.5622621775,
-0.1710814536,
-0.5196443796,
0.4497556686,
-0.1661782712,
0.3508851826,
-0.0196071547,
-0.1763189733,
0.6573953629,
-0.1792304367,
0.2675469518,
-0.4564359188,
0.1997534484,
0.5086167455,
-0.1659399867,
0.7735210657,
-0.2749217749,
0.1031158492,
-0.3671911359,
0.1275046766,
-0.2938992381,
-0.6028997898,
0.2320132554,
-0.5361137986,
-0.6590729356,
-0.3758730292,
-0.5490955114,
-0.2122342438,
0.0966286138,
0.4084403217,
0.375397265,
-0.2837062478,
0.0227448437,
0.7867668867,
-0.5169022083,
0.4373703897,
0.238195613,
-0.3296138942,
-0.2841411233,
0.8934167624,
0.2556131482,
0.2463942021,
0.523662746,
0.2508651912,
-0.4791471362,
-0.4015151262,
-0.425632298,
0.3643580675,
-0.3840171695,
-0.1144201905,
-0.8923539519,
-0.2772672772,
-0.3141157031,
-0.2296462953,
-0.4653518796,
-0.623729229,
-0.1146240309,
-0.0355903246,
0.1805038452,
0.4501555562,
-0.4559982717,
0.0897440538,
-0.5631515384,
0.5771968961,
0.0877739713,
0.3885074556,
-0.0297043975,
-0.3951509595,
-0.2402099818,
-0.0851097852,
-0.5055987239,
-0.8705381155,
0.6319655776,
0.1231049448,
1.0027093887,
0.1048105285,
0.3874182701,
0.6396608949,
-0.670114696,
0.3789785504,
0.3686515689,
-0.2256279737,
0.3640319407,
-0.5564502478,
-0.0725719258,
0.5017065406,
0.593865931,
-0.3483677208,
-0.4291759431,
-0.9710398912,
-1.3436594009,
0.482052356,
0.0953076705,
-0.1249678135,
0.0810989216,
0.2123462409,
0.1447793394,
0.5230068564,
-0.082764253,
-0.3082944453,
0.0658921525,
-0.2891758978,
0.1343815476,
-0.5828619599,
-0.3362646401,
0.4161766469,
0.7340027094,
-0.0138050895,
0.6880044937,
0.2343077958,
0.1133002639,
-0.331047684,
0.548202455,
0.6012107134,
0.6183676124,
-0.4116684496,
-0.1393364072,
-0.0150091927,
-0.5198411942,
0.358042717,
0.3206993937,
-0.3376613259,
0.3227190077,
-0.3340989053,
0.4900350869,
0.2924875021,
-0.4153517187,
0.3203883171,
-0.1298993528,
-0.0977760106,
-0.8088588715,
-0.046120476,
-0.1046080142,
0.1563289762,
0.9705936909,
0.0932958871,
0.3848019242,
-0.2979159951,
0.6547678709,
0.608422935,
-0.0757561773,
0.0584524721,
0.7863585949,
-0.4286554456,
-0.5140480399,
-0.3068479002,
-0.3996100426,
0.0677307397,
0.6184253097,
0.3663458824,
1.1329262257,
-0.2924886048,
0.3452319503,
0.5116624236,
0.1498188674,
-0.0462041236,
0.4269635081,
-0.3145510256,
-0.3734806776,
-0.5879607201,
-1.1177934408,
-0.7758311033,
-0.1801460385,
-1.0686875582,
0.0910848305,
-0.2469924241,
-0.4615532458,
-0.1369121075,
0.1330753714,
-0.5165472031,
0.2155231386,
-0.5680736899,
0.9271809459,
-0.2793423533,
0.593388319,
0.5383935571,
-0.3442255557,
-0.7215906978,
-0.1527762115,
-0.1477332413,
-0.5331288576,
0.4719420671,
-0.2762388289,
-0.1641958803,
0.1312401444,
-0.4268499315,
-1.1780185699,
0.911078155,
0.1125470623,
-0.0782925114,
-0.2266804129,
-0.2270739824,
0.4448980391,
-0.263569355,
0.6237955689,
0.3511301577,
0.2722408772,
0.5237321854,
-0.710634172,
-0.2007845938,
-0.350962311,
0.5197173357,
0.4290991127,
-0.5217115879,
0.7964624166,
-0.2151906341,
-0.5788214803,
0.1485069245,
0.6656651497,
0.6542563438,
0.4720588326,
0.45363608,
0.738837719,
0.7165656686,
0.0137606729,
1.2492070198,
-0.0549538024,
0.4361337125,
1.2717169523,
-0.2531635463,
0.7960893512,
0.5672189593,
-0.2771765292,
0.2449227124,
0.7040834427,
0.3820234239,
0.8231716752,
0.1579891145,
-0.5732161999,
0.0696182325,
-0.2137243748,
-0.1061192453,
0.1124885604,
0.2332838029,
-0.1317480654,
-0.4793225825,
0.0784977078,
-0.093630746,
0.0939684585,
-0.1583874077,
0.9319450259,
-0.0032924425,
-1.0465459824,
0.5739382505,
0.1014086306,
0.6387760639,
-0.574252367,
0.0261376798,
-0.3042990863,
-0.0909472555,
0.007485698,
-0.5212439895,
0.4079156816,
0.018170502,
-0.3919678926,
-0.3402046561,
1.0395070314,
-0.2896336019,
-0.4827450216,
0.2299749553,
0.5694845319,
0.3683992624,
0.6717507243,
-0.3664543033,
-0.4281623662,
0.0289786551,
-0.6014323235,
0.6129283905,
0.388664782,
-0.108767435,
0.6123010516,
1.0900268555,
0.3681323826,
0.0739980787,
0.0005956804,
0.7472176552,
-0.5813602209,
-0.6848326325,
-0.1187287569,
0.6217924356,
-0.3847529888,
-0.1233386323,
0.3977742195,
0.5426512361,
0.799100399,
0.1327828169,
0.9062988758,
-0.1194549128,
1.1778749228,
-0.2114343792,
0.6002522707,
-0.7534862757,
0.0097233355,
-0.1526382864,
-0.7391523123,
0.2121891826,
0.5768145919,
-0.2023105025,
0.2790360451,
0.5286675096,
0.8192785978,
-0.0191090778,
0.1003386825,
0.6453780532,
-0.1085969731,
0.2644127905,
0.3261594772,
0.6796339154,
-0.3267673552,
0.4416430593,
-0.1136425212,
-0.7979257107,
-0.1528859735,
-0.7265561819,
-0.3479970992,
-0.761470437,
0.1880886257,
-0.3435944915,
0.0398856327,
0.7907053828,
0.431858182,
-0.3924013674,
-0.3438699841,
-0.0911632776,
0.1999495924,
-0.2573049963,
-0.280410856,
0.2597310543,
-0.7949351072,
-0.7854315042,
0.1146746725,
0.2413302511,
-0.2242286056,
-0.1585836858,
0.1836306006,
-0.4604385495,
0.3731184602,
0.531031549,
0.4604501426,
-0.188113898,
0.001829576,
0.2036898881,
-0.1873004735,
-0.0009335316,
0.7860288024,
-0.4978313744,
0.4757477641,
0.4643697143,
0.791318357,
1.0665524006,
0.339577198,
0.5933708549,
-0.8058775067,
0.1117845774,
0.3651922345,
0.1226385683,
0.1148454472,
-0.491759032,
0.8150027394,
0.1180083752,
-0.8465012312,
-1.0286684036,
0.4785159826,
-0.960934639,
-0.2492245883,
1.0648337603,
0.0002540759,
-0.5003131628,
-0.3735578954,
-0.0112108449,
0.6143853664,
-0.3746168315,
0.6253349781,
0.310781002,
-0.3436876237,
-0.4360494912,
-0.956340909,
0.6468265653,
0.322147578,
-0.6972772479,
0.0328641646,
0.5499680042,
0.0195704196,
0.2381675094,
1.0157724619,
-0.0728294179,
0.3896570802,
0.0975942016,
0.0092248535,
0.0044841142,
-0.153669104,
0.1346440613,
0.3451537192,
-0.1689209938,
-0.0561604649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02814v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02814v2
|
NegativePrompt: Leveraging Psychology for Large Language Models Enhancement via Negative Emotional Stimuli
| 2024-05-05T05:06:07 | 2024-05-12T16:11:48 |
Xu Wang, Cheng Li, Yi Chang, Jindong Wang, Yuan Wu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have become integral to a wide spectrum of
applications, ranging from traditional computing tasks to advanced artificial
intelligence (AI) applications. This widespread adoption has spurred extensive
research into LLMs across various disciplines, including the social sciences.
Notably, studies have revealed that LLMs possess emotional intelligence, which
can be further developed through positive emotional stimuli. This discovery
raises an intriguing question: can negative emotions similarly influence LLMs,
potentially enhancing their performance? In response to this question, we
introduce NegativePrompt, a novel approach underpinned by psychological
principles, involving ten specifically designed negative emotional stimuli. We
embark on rigorous experimental evaluations of five LLMs including
Flan-T5-Large, Vicuna, Llama 2, ChatGPT, and GPT-4, across a set of 45 tasks.
The results are revealing: NegativePrompt markedly enhances the performance of
LLMs, evidenced by relative improvements of 12.89% in Instruction Induction
tasks and 46.25% in BIG-Bench tasks. Moreover, we conduct attention
visualization experiments to decipher the underlying mechanisms of
NegativePrompt's influence. Our research contributes significantly to the
understanding of LLMs and emotion interaction, demonstrating the practical
efficacy of NegativePrompt as an emotion-driven method and offering novel
insights for the enhancement of LLMs in real-world applications. The code is
available at https://github.com/wangxu0820/NegativePrompt.
|
[
-0.6985108256,
-1.0976332426,
0.6448374987,
0.3420325518,
-0.1922044456,
-0.1848457158,
-0.4440231919,
-0.6808228493,
0.4527563453,
0.2879898548,
-0.7829605937,
-0.7099651694,
-0.6472212672,
0.0543926805,
-0.6426048279,
0.8441900611,
0.3665112853,
0.0795019418,
-0.1877610683,
-0.1105533838,
-0.5278024077,
-0.8382576108,
-0.5281422734,
-0.6447612047,
0.6488272548,
0.6459790468,
0.5617859364,
-0.1303948164,
0.3449347019,
0.2211502194,
0.319408834,
-0.2273074538,
-0.6386275887,
0.2677822709,
-0.0775446743,
-0.4663664699,
-0.5000107288,
0.1697832495,
0.188449651,
0.3358803988,
-0.0697454736,
0.1920807511,
0.0405701175,
0.6078274846,
-0.7450683117,
0.049098812,
-0.3338404894,
0.0948280171,
-0.2889464498,
-0.3494282365,
-0.4441845119,
-0.2447139025,
-0.066781275,
-0.3132682145,
0.0552084744,
-0.2429569662,
0.5717403889,
0.2251200378,
-0.4328264594,
-0.219908312,
-0.4887239933,
0.7093856931,
-0.8311497569,
0.5317856073,
0.1775237918,
-0.1511945873,
-0.0201071277,
-0.0432442985,
-0.7928056121,
-0.6932983398,
0.1392418593,
0.2939038575,
-0.0474092774,
0.2062990367,
0.4206441939,
0.1988449991,
-0.5020776391,
0.4547684193,
-0.0721035972,
-0.0102384668,
0.6760239601,
0.2698166966,
0.5842103362,
0.179028213,
0.0803988129,
-0.0052765775,
-0.8357700706,
-0.0680556297,
0.4098852277,
0.2891980112,
-0.2517216802,
0.8038280606,
-0.0366454981,
0.6341521144,
-0.0488090403,
0.1839042753,
0.1856490672,
0.2553352714,
-0.2096681446,
0.1271249354,
0.5601378083,
0.3112002909,
0.4732212424,
-0.0905959383,
-0.1204723492,
0.8760810494,
0.1632826626,
-0.9690073133,
-0.0779780075,
0.350261569,
-0.1544253379,
-0.3226364553,
-0.3889152408,
-0.8519612551,
-0.9896357059,
-0.728995502,
0.5461474657,
-0.5062468052,
-0.4848442376,
0.0452186204,
-0.0034744283,
0.21186243,
0.3382392824,
-0.7529429793,
0.4112238884,
1.0139334202,
0.5980389118,
0.139204815,
-0.3699418008,
-0.7259500623,
-0.2759187222,
-0.4933085144,
0.6918987036,
-0.8820855021,
-0.2297209948,
0.0046804496,
-0.2650940716,
0.0629829764,
-0.7342117429,
0.5522054434,
-0.3458014131,
0.2444907129,
-0.2848681808,
-0.5019972324,
-0.1141419336,
0.5324798822,
-0.518383801,
0.8204498887,
-0.1270541996,
-0.4172058105,
-0.0184382293,
-0.8378334045,
-0.78468889,
-0.0829439238,
-0.2452763021,
-0.1773679405,
0.5531773567,
-0.1277917624,
0.5202202201,
-0.4606611133,
0.028258644,
-0.8302411437,
-0.5664429665,
0.3957554996,
-0.212918967,
0.5195351839,
-0.1557184756,
-0.4514505565,
0.1250766516,
-0.6051905751,
-0.1066461056,
0.1701918542,
0.1882546842,
-0.4901783168,
-0.0809397474,
-0.2130949199,
0.5154459476,
0.226725921,
-0.4960691035,
0.2495748848,
-0.4150013328,
0.3406016529,
0.771592319,
0.0895600617,
0.3293449283,
-0.0102944626,
0.8041136861,
-0.0644608364,
0.1160461307,
0.1691224575,
-0.2075334936,
-0.7664244175,
-0.1676029414,
-0.3319716752,
0.4857414961,
-0.4633558393,
0.0072468366,
0.2221972942,
-0.6670271158,
-0.4705038667,
0.2471985072,
0.2658828795,
0.6299452782,
0.4018374383,
-0.2266031057,
-0.530923605,
-0.6834354997,
-0.3244391382,
-0.0529366657,
0.0492898151,
0.3348168135,
0.3097044528,
-0.3118927181,
0.3707585335,
-0.7323527932,
-0.2871863842,
-0.2178042382,
0.4181961417,
0.4922274947,
0.183862552,
0.4984505773,
-0.5184397697,
-0.4480121136,
-0.4019956589,
-0.5206074119,
-0.4633639753,
-0.1611905545,
-0.2271054834,
0.3919511735,
0.3156991303,
-0.9945474863,
0.1216148213,
0.6764102578,
-0.6472430825,
0.9375966191,
0.0403618366,
0.0933923125,
-0.6040754318,
-0.001092798,
0.5052583814,
0.1484197825,
-0.7895094752,
0.0755415559,
0.0119083468,
-0.3885875046,
-0.4005292058,
0.5784412026,
-0.2947997153,
0.1224651188,
-0.4191028774,
0.3013615012,
-0.0278080795,
0.4882015586,
0.0960547701,
0.5506847501,
0.6472246051,
-0.6374576092,
0.2892951369,
-0.061366234,
-0.1416451037,
0.845784843,
-0.4680672288,
0.0710707158,
-0.2774033546,
-0.0034536412,
-0.8445513844,
-0.130993858,
0.146646902,
-0.3827314377,
0.4143282473,
0.3988250494,
-0.5514589548,
-0.3560626507,
-0.5990718007,
0.0319615416,
0.7516281009,
-0.4283595681,
0.4274767339,
0.0742397085,
-0.3495002687,
-0.2514757216,
-0.6952362657,
0.3585138917,
-0.4260015786,
-0.3038911819,
0.2093403488,
-0.1843194216,
-0.4658198357,
-0.096962221,
0.0083888434,
0.1675353944,
0.2877280116,
0.3892838657,
0.2279429734,
-0.1572181135,
0.3745124936,
-0.128268376,
-0.0955613479,
0.3384228051,
-0.0111080147,
0.8650439978,
-0.1857397109,
-0.5292642713,
-0.7089115977,
0.1626673192,
0.7954420447,
-0.2793418765,
0.738222599,
0.8197377324,
-0.2932620943,
-0.2768066227,
-0.4925321043,
-0.5863602757,
-0.4773661792,
0.4726762474,
-0.1826123148,
-0.4732187688,
0.339219451,
-0.0489920378,
-0.3855744302,
0.0762271807,
0.6909595132,
-0.1983556598,
1.2227276564,
0.6650456786,
-0.1779631823,
0.7585386038,
-0.1613485664,
0.3826376796,
-0.8662173748,
-0.1097963005,
-0.2479252368,
-0.6532433629,
-0.5208188295,
-0.1194884703,
0.2194983512,
-0.0778269395,
-0.5287950039,
0.0208515003,
-0.3140240014,
0.306599766,
0.434128046,
0.0727393553,
-0.0365213007,
-0.4130859375,
0.2677657306,
-0.2644178867,
-0.1908603609,
-0.2836265862,
0.6573691368,
0.2619753182,
0.7938076258,
0.1977740079,
0.8856201172,
0.4263746738,
0.7623051405,
-0.9954861999,
0.8629920483,
-0.3118929565,
-0.5029645562,
-0.1496192366,
-0.2684236765,
-0.5445351005,
0.0202581882,
-0.3428352475,
-1.0786212683,
0.0912656263,
0.3995263875,
-0.1916322261,
-0.1969213933,
-1.0970628262,
0.9547517896,
-0.674028337,
-0.6801703572,
-0.460983336,
-0.2741979659,
0.482919395,
-0.1546243876,
0.1169715449,
-0.1853686422,
-0.0588888749,
0.5049689412,
-0.1176440343,
1.0349472761,
-0.5494285226,
-0.5811084509,
0.0744678453,
0.4116576016,
0.8037641048,
-0.0055506774,
-0.2993452847,
0.0036680987,
-0.3154568076,
-0.2667927146,
-0.9595003724,
0.8024724722,
-0.6928498149,
-0.7690140605,
-0.1407431066,
-0.5945108533,
-0.5034188032,
0.1898111999,
-0.0624936856,
0.3906591237,
0.0109466324,
0.0311265066,
0.4654415548,
-0.650061667,
0.1063725799,
0.8153418899,
-0.3444911838,
-0.0462971106,
1.3534865379,
0.2347808182,
0.2950727046,
0.4982636571,
0.2022827566,
-0.2980161309,
-0.4408833385,
0.1602416188,
0.3519914448,
-0.5271093845,
-0.0856782794,
-0.3480971158,
0.0048375423,
-0.4261033237,
-0.1279740632,
-0.4053954184,
-0.306104362,
-0.5663660765,
-0.1551541239,
0.2859228849,
0.6360984445,
-0.0343176685,
-0.0027129559,
-0.5993508697,
0.4740406275,
0.0446025953,
0.3582842052,
0.3015984297,
-0.3749527633,
-0.1654035449,
-0.0674341768,
-0.4304289222,
-1.0061560869,
0.6840072274,
0.1677081138,
0.2455848306,
0.6193010807,
0.3645958602,
0.7365953922,
-0.3301471174,
0.777723074,
0.2970702946,
-1.0798722506,
0.3645663261,
-0.2925597727,
0.3089027405,
0.2642248869,
0.4360458851,
-0.7419207692,
-0.7577772737,
-0.5497601032,
-0.924559772,
0.5244609118,
-0.1333404183,
0.261056453,
-0.0666610301,
0.3076218367,
0.0642257631,
0.1190758571,
-0.6964526772,
-0.1386090517,
-0.1907672286,
-0.506911099,
-0.4392465949,
-0.3540624976,
-0.0308419224,
-0.1574257165,
0.7287397385,
0.1394084394,
0.3718661666,
-0.0127888387,
-0.192001909,
0.0033236525,
0.5269672871,
0.8871017098,
0.2646069825,
-0.3219023943,
0.3284686506,
0.2926205695,
-0.2532329857,
0.2067584991,
0.1305417567,
0.162856847,
-0.4283484519,
0.6124321818,
0.603443563,
-0.0719749406,
-0.8261172771,
0.3743081689,
-0.0500571243,
-0.0672376677,
-0.2977207899,
0.225922972,
0.2927467227,
0.6180070043,
0.3365770876,
-0.2028364241,
0.138212204,
-0.6434355378,
-0.1002807319,
0.5396028161,
-0.4266548753,
-0.6858102679,
0.3970383704,
0.2962997854,
-0.5059147477,
0.6988818645,
-0.416161418,
-0.650278151,
0.7191813588,
0.9086710215,
0.8253254294,
-0.024843866,
0.2844011188,
0.0577802882,
0.1547284722,
0.24925901,
0.4698321819,
-0.0189470332,
-0.5781809688,
-0.6011244655,
-0.3286566138,
-0.5460344553,
0.5606538653,
-0.5972535014,
0.4720888138,
-0.2940455675,
-0.1890947819,
-0.213706851,
0.2886555195,
-0.6244459152,
0.3058509827,
0.7504470348,
0.8246409297,
-1.0793217421,
0.740904212,
0.7754135132,
-0.1877955943,
-0.6349838376,
0.2216408402,
0.1517718583,
-0.7294629216,
0.7929338217,
0.4148050547,
-0.1203073114,
0.0471441522,
-0.4303764999,
-0.6443251371,
0.8181296587,
0.7137221098,
-0.7377148271,
0.2813098431,
0.1662486345,
0.9321695566,
-0.007335471,
0.3081884682,
0.4022747278,
0.5801731944,
-0.2770771682,
-0.339283973,
0.3099351227,
-0.5330172181,
-0.4232043326,
0.4254016578,
-0.6446800232,
0.7608042955,
-0.4136736989,
-0.2139976323,
-0.0679345429,
0.3096870184,
0.3839156926,
0.4396216273,
0.2755688131,
0.7027468085,
0.7055086493,
0.2269705236,
1.0488350391,
-0.6359945536,
0.2274118811,
1.0802271366,
-0.7663664818,
0.7838414311,
0.6793922186,
-0.0263241585,
0.5546004772,
0.5508444905,
0.1138668954,
0.4195789099,
0.3175619543,
-0.3328015506,
-0.2209071815,
-0.4782022238,
-0.4394885302,
0.2968296409,
0.5650575161,
-0.161236614,
-0.0554244183,
0.1606948972,
-0.0072130566,
0.0912224501,
-0.2687451541,
0.4771176875,
0.3308440447,
-0.50148803,
0.5880795717,
-0.1957720518,
0.6986358762,
-0.4157815278,
-0.0799224228,
-0.2961060703,
0.4121989608,
-0.3577544689,
-0.6987429857,
0.1296792775,
0.1371310055,
0.0149962772,
-0.296215862,
0.8385114074,
-0.296572417,
-0.3446696103,
0.6068799496,
0.3681664467,
-0.1341323555,
-0.3554078639,
-0.4227333665,
0.244433701,
-0.3838844895,
-0.4782907069,
0.5064396858,
0.4840945005,
0.1539316326,
0.6013331413,
0.427413553,
0.2095945776,
-0.3993065357,
0.4755645096,
0.7868956327,
-0.8914794922,
-0.1571348011,
-1.4236748219,
0.3194845021,
0.0907707736,
0.0223100893,
0.765689671,
0.2569921613,
0.5126292109,
-0.1249008179,
0.6744243503,
0.0084644891,
0.2229939103,
-0.2930889726,
0.5691047907,
-0.7126901746,
0.1955439746,
-0.5814164877,
-0.8280291557,
-0.3825675249,
0.2119347453,
-0.9561321735,
-0.1917506158,
0.4619022012,
0.8898608088,
0.2152456492,
0.0121938772,
0.3261038661,
0.5547049046,
0.4921891391,
0.8470598459,
1.21889925,
0.2148030698,
0.2534756064,
-0.2832813859,
-0.2090176642,
-0.2888673842,
-0.9486707449,
-0.7642353177,
-0.2257612199,
-0.2816529572,
-0.2323526144,
0.0981857851,
1.0912122726,
0.4328469336,
-0.5829993486,
-0.1519967169,
-0.3979874849,
0.1007294357,
-0.1365062892,
-0.3127219081,
0.1531547308,
-0.3769105077,
-0.5453315377,
0.1730876267,
0.2468917966,
0.0291669276,
-0.2745247483,
-0.2695744038,
-0.1304659843,
0.2292445004,
0.9443187118,
0.3039290011,
-0.3078254759,
-0.1940884441,
0.0010680532,
-0.0051803277,
-0.1981816888,
0.5383480191,
-0.733442843,
0.0589844882,
0.4921441078,
0.4381555617,
0.3704644144,
0.1104349941,
0.5891426802,
-0.5933386087,
0.2206999958,
0.5088154674,
0.139990896,
0.3030664027,
-0.5893403292,
0.3729607165,
0.1162042394,
-0.3411519229,
-1.0442090034,
0.3952501118,
-0.672816813,
-0.3274388909,
1.1791584492,
0.2411417514,
-0.087791115,
0.4989597201,
-0.2193301171,
0.2118870318,
-0.469738245,
1.2066347599,
0.6731831431,
-0.6157869697,
-0.2884091735,
-0.7315583229,
0.0486456752,
0.7553640604,
-0.8775100708,
0.1285304278,
0.457885921,
-0.0263324101,
0.1123225763,
0.566614151,
0.1118791401,
0.1822285354,
-0.2016967535,
0.2987554073,
-0.1181691587,
-0.2542599738,
-0.3613639176,
0.267231524,
0.2319041342,
0.0683715194
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02793v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02793v1
|
ImageInWords: Unlocking Hyper-Detailed Image Descriptions
| 2024-05-05T02:15:11 | 2024-05-05T02:15:11 |
Roopal Garg, Andrea Burns, Burcu Karagol Ayan, Yonatan Bitton, Ceslee Montgomery, Yasumasa Onoe, Andrew Bunner, Ranjay Krishna, Jason Baldridge, Radu Soricut
|
cs.CV
|
cs.CV, cs.CL
|
Despite the longstanding adage "an image is worth a thousand words," creating
accurate and hyper-detailed image descriptions for training Vision-Language
models remains challenging. Current datasets typically have web-scraped
descriptions that are short, low-granularity, and often contain details
unrelated to the visual content. As a result, models trained on such data
generate descriptions replete with missing information, visual inconsistencies,
and hallucinations. To address these issues, we introduce ImageInWords (IIW), a
carefully designed human-in-the-loop annotation framework for curating
hyper-detailed image descriptions and a new dataset resulting from this
process. We validate the framework through evaluations focused on the quality
of the dataset and its utility for fine-tuning with considerations for
readability, comprehensiveness, specificity, hallucinations, and
human-likeness. Our dataset significantly improves across these dimensions
compared to recently released datasets (+66%) and GPT-4V outputs (+48%).
Furthermore, models fine-tuned with IIW data excel by +31% against prior work
along the same human evaluation dimensions. Given our fine-tuned models, we
also evaluate text-to-image generation and vision-language reasoning. Our
model's descriptions can generate images closest to the original, as judged by
both automated and human metrics. We also find our model produces more
compositionally rich descriptions, outperforming the best baseline by up to 6%
on ARO, SVO-Probes, and Winoground datasets.
|
[
-0.4935092926,
-0.3049747944,
0.3285775781,
0.2063777149,
-0.6407472491,
-0.1192924753,
-0.2853549421,
-0.9729688168,
-0.0912889838,
0.8350899816,
-0.1576087177,
-0.4568476975,
-0.6061764359,
0.2848616838,
-0.6364335418,
0.9387264848,
-0.1437749416,
0.0643658862,
-0.443816781,
-0.2658625841,
-0.3513599634,
-0.066766046,
-0.3913297653,
-0.2737448215,
0.4715400338,
0.3228251934,
0.9649274349,
1.1966742277,
0.9741225243,
0.1253467649,
0.1044198647,
0.3674904108,
-0.3860733807,
-0.1360722184,
-0.1509589106,
-0.1722454876,
-0.1245367154,
0.0364669003,
0.4094393551,
0.4450684488,
0.2228946835,
0.1528251171,
0.1618715227,
0.6130279303,
-0.6542509198,
0.351044327,
-0.8430709243,
0.3030526936,
-0.2840817273,
-0.3269281983,
-0.1069785655,
-0.0012273586,
0.4143348038,
-0.9412069321,
0.4140208364,
0.1375712305,
1.3988666534,
0.2065191269,
0.2293664068,
-0.3092644215,
-0.5314155221,
0.5030806661,
-0.6587779522,
-0.0078137657,
0.6874142289,
0.3494742215,
0.0666691288,
-0.8998291492,
-0.7043622732,
-0.2920802832,
-0.1017159,
0.1243026778,
-0.2342979014,
0.2528875768,
0.3743246794,
0.5079569817,
-0.4401888549,
0.1939254701,
-0.4581528902,
-0.1776726991,
0.7224786878,
0.3232195675,
0.1804502457,
-0.0822001025,
-0.5103386045,
-0.2014007121,
-0.5093793273,
-0.0585519336,
0.3821915686,
0.0401201211,
0.0478844829,
0.7266642451,
-0.4499135911,
0.7430292964,
-0.1891177893,
-0.0601090789,
0.048502665,
-0.1749248803,
0.0056510288,
-0.1359077841,
0.7070460916,
0.9631804824,
0.4721553028,
-0.5161109567,
-0.5556175113,
0.0357129909,
0.315312624,
-1.0462032557,
-0.3495519459,
0.0908996612,
-0.6596209407,
-0.4816044569,
0.1967645884,
-0.7740995288,
-0.6853078008,
-0.4208455682,
0.5895053744,
-0.2533678114,
0.1710658818,
0.1905501336,
-0.3631542623,
0.1159195155,
0.2455875576,
-0.4721375406,
0.0956020877,
0.3339605033,
0.7647927403,
-0.2009499073,
-0.4733719826,
-0.3409955204,
0.2351559401,
-0.6951190233,
0.8531877995,
-0.7592217326,
-0.0954918414,
0.1434345692,
-0.0847367048,
0.5798245072,
-0.8618062139,
0.3099099398,
-0.2186474949,
0.0523512997,
-0.0735529065,
-0.5749250054,
-0.163458392,
0.2376745194,
-0.6487259269,
0.831243515,
-0.0513098203,
-0.8834480047,
0.4680976272,
-0.7644072175,
-0.3439776599,
0.6549526453,
-0.2993954122,
-0.3458963037,
0.4283684194,
0.3168736398,
0.666218698,
-0.4223189354,
0.1318351626,
-0.1400551945,
-0.7658395171,
0.4463561177,
-0.1157025769,
0.1491110623,
0.1227636486,
-0.5483017564,
0.0885948092,
-0.7418817282,
0.0730064213,
0.2674427927,
-0.1483846009,
-0.185398832,
-0.1027262285,
0.3091363311,
0.0934561715,
0.2547779381,
-0.6408029199,
-0.0418304987,
-0.2846719027,
0.3104419112,
0.6933652163,
-0.1938498169,
0.1820273548,
-0.0897684395,
0.5235138535,
0.1396416873,
0.2715326548,
-0.6621803045,
-0.3972836733,
-0.5932509303,
-0.1444880813,
0.0934540033,
0.5529670119,
-0.9084506631,
0.4576967061,
-0.43635571,
-0.6336631775,
-0.7110944986,
0.2958156466,
0.7939127684,
0.6915250421,
0.4168763757,
-0.6387594938,
-0.1574828625,
-1.323574543,
-0.2819205225,
0.0569196381,
0.0604526661,
0.3746662736,
0.5290247798,
-0.5321027637,
0.7865751386,
-0.5218801498,
-0.5554456711,
0.0188659206,
0.3145866692,
-0.1638417393,
0.2267200351,
0.2323002219,
-0.6458001137,
-0.2568808794,
0.117323935,
-0.9160534739,
0.1359450221,
-0.3901937306,
-0.1425838321,
0.0482819751,
0.3626296818,
-0.5699617863,
0.9096175432,
0.2473393232,
-0.1298276186,
0.6964096427,
-0.3787683845,
0.0026425074,
-0.9457192421,
0.1793031394,
0.4068379104,
-0.0039678845,
-0.0068640723,
0.3951680064,
0.0583436042,
-0.1926663667,
-0.2102500051,
0.6604439616,
-0.4538267851,
0.0408112668,
-0.4975861609,
0.0622053966,
0.1026509479,
0.4096218348,
0.1258410811,
0.6225794554,
0.9729880095,
-0.3522647023,
0.7114446759,
0.2871694863,
-0.6846653223,
0.6173869371,
-0.8271357417,
0.1798631996,
-0.2340551615,
0.3531907201,
-0.8438842297,
-0.7396814823,
-0.1006693244,
-0.1758396775,
0.1357702315,
-0.0517572388,
-0.9708935618,
-0.5517200828,
-0.1732169092,
0.2768618166,
0.3898424208,
-0.6785218716,
0.1966716498,
0.2731720209,
0.0635391474,
-0.5083122253,
-0.7500457168,
0.8149203658,
-0.1882540584,
-0.37198627,
0.4233455956,
0.2267430574,
-0.0379017666,
0.102524586,
0.2464043051,
-0.1811125875,
-0.1712259501,
0.3938379586,
0.1840954721,
0.1762279421,
0.4162216485,
-0.1711810082,
-0.0763757229,
-0.0182768274,
-0.421313405,
0.2612821758,
-0.2105977088,
0.016814135,
-0.6354936957,
0.3546369374,
0.5081223845,
-0.4067110717,
0.1562389284,
1.0416338444,
-0.6685585976,
0.0553613566,
-0.4644509852,
-0.1925056577,
-0.4013945758,
0.7367284298,
-0.3332064748,
-0.5114198327,
0.4323565066,
-0.011057388,
0.1042951867,
0.3064298034,
0.1396713704,
-0.5846581459,
1.1133111715,
0.5686986446,
0.2616961598,
0.3330107331,
-0.3735047877,
0.1875871122,
-0.8259087205,
-0.2886318266,
0.0347614363,
-0.6371700764,
-0.4443595409,
-0.3092544973,
0.3609463573,
0.016087627,
0.2408979535,
0.2801772952,
-0.8006048203,
0.81568259,
0.5803924799,
0.3051401377,
-0.1065654457,
0.4829745889,
0.2047747076,
-0.2740829587,
-0.2416773587,
-0.6758829355,
1.1337821484,
0.2671661377,
0.9276083708,
-0.4606228173,
0.4932619929,
0.3058841527,
0.1249001846,
-0.7079455256,
0.6717341542,
-0.5056432486,
-0.4237753749,
-0.0636484101,
-0.1165179685,
-0.8873362541,
-0.194445163,
-0.4187943339,
-0.501241684,
-0.0260307323,
0.4441574812,
-0.274425,
0.4250981808,
-0.2987086475,
0.7258790731,
-0.4150283933,
-0.4545595944,
-0.2176375836,
-0.9378175139,
0.1366197467,
-0.0052088867,
0.0065873428,
-0.0121443132,
-0.1801636517,
0.5557484627,
-0.2622541785,
0.7590824366,
-0.1428015679,
0.0655192584,
0.1720667779,
-0.0262197424,
0.4089204967,
-0.2981180251,
0.3870129585,
0.3277859092,
-0.1067074537,
-0.4815653265,
-0.4139078259,
0.5190990567,
-0.479375571,
-0.1956684887,
0.0750396773,
-0.6814423203,
-0.0771978199,
0.0238242783,
0.7652868032,
0.8492706418,
0.1666564941,
0.1652985215,
0.7086878419,
-0.4568650424,
0.3662552834,
-0.3631691635,
-0.2687828839,
-0.6107584834,
1.0500764847,
-0.0098211998,
0.0251798462,
0.2811582386,
0.2285596132,
-0.18041192,
-0.634739399,
-0.8573078513,
0.1656011343,
-0.9491993189,
-0.5197104812,
-0.6579266191,
0.0762655661,
-0.1296536475,
-0.2674062252,
-0.1479322463,
-0.3325058818,
-0.138381958,
-0.0064945975,
0.4229037762,
0.8877594471,
0.1743467897,
0.5138702989,
-0.6662145853,
0.533398509,
0.1902387291,
0.5393968821,
-0.1306576431,
-0.5892643332,
-0.6275381446,
0.0346531682,
-0.2507832944,
-0.6150127649,
0.3666551709,
0.4613456428,
0.2178569585,
0.5605269074,
-0.3271951973,
1.1620285511,
-0.1784120351,
0.8701749444,
0.2958468199,
-0.6241798401,
0.6325333118,
-0.1792800426,
0.3635577857,
0.5029895902,
0.0446038097,
-0.2762494385,
-0.5375915766,
-0.5853648782,
-1.1331816912,
0.3304309249,
0.1063370705,
0.630597353,
0.0841767043,
0.7582625747,
0.2830384374,
0.2549159527,
-0.6170976758,
-0.0057602478,
-0.3335438967,
-0.4344388247,
0.1627533436,
-0.2594769597,
-0.2747691274,
-0.3474315107,
0.5257461071,
-0.3493242562,
0.1448551267,
0.2244802713,
-0.3439352214,
-0.0952246338,
-0.1679279208,
0.3983130157,
0.6748059988,
0.0995702446,
0.3393106759,
-0.1123484597,
-0.6320381165,
-0.3968138695,
0.1423950791,
-0.1294912398,
0.1806119382,
0.7010635734,
0.9915207624,
-0.0596639961,
-1.0845406055,
0.6385569572,
-0.0774196386,
-0.0782713518,
-0.1965990067,
-0.1317706257,
-0.1421052068,
0.0150390007,
0.4220329523,
0.3216994405,
0.3484426141,
-0.3170869052,
0.0706484839,
0.3125595748,
-0.7069962621,
-0.2550724447,
0.5046190023,
0.1377666593,
0.0175737608,
0.7841166854,
-0.328735888,
-0.3636355996,
0.5046907663,
0.374160558,
0.9895603061,
0.56456846,
0.0927828774,
0.3435771465,
0.3768636286,
-0.1429848522,
0.2773175836,
-0.0440472215,
-0.4202938974,
-0.194027409,
-0.6694081426,
-0.1642838567,
0.0965332314,
-0.7678129673,
0.103938587,
-0.5033897758,
-0.3245407939,
0.0302862599,
-0.2582034767,
-0.9494636059,
0.5259365439,
0.3620450795,
0.8905687928,
-0.6878657937,
0.5039913058,
0.9741508961,
-0.5943174362,
-0.6791051626,
0.0887437239,
-0.4986220598,
-0.7264303565,
0.6703380346,
0.5371486545,
0.0590724163,
-0.1336194128,
-1.1872326136,
-0.4191239476,
1.0796943903,
0.412086606,
-0.6051764488,
-0.0385539457,
0.1630918682,
0.6079508662,
-0.5795408487,
-0.1456752867,
0.2786474824,
0.5028662682,
0.0982494652,
-0.7634234428,
-0.1544621438,
-0.3480563164,
0.3477281034,
-0.2161057293,
-0.1365601867,
0.5467412472,
-0.7233039737,
-0.1285224557,
0.4192575514,
0.4985580742,
-0.0251385197,
0.2820494473,
0.4080734253,
0.8028987646,
0.5984287858,
-0.2209431231,
1.3522270918,
-0.3493074775,
-0.0204848796,
1.2114701271,
0.0787138045,
0.6840979457,
0.3874615729,
0.2159568816,
0.2651340365,
0.7039219141,
-0.3227261603,
0.455337882,
0.2704696953,
-0.0757179037,
-0.5003353357,
-0.4566714764,
-0.0621353574,
0.6345775127,
0.2508935332,
-0.7148415446,
-0.104898423,
0.2513171732,
-0.2213692069,
0.147947371,
-0.3283347785,
0.89821136,
-0.1235494986,
-0.4272539318,
0.3932644725,
-0.1437881291,
0.7018377185,
-0.2756127119,
-0.269305259,
-0.1747674793,
0.2328461111,
-0.4210011363,
-1.1497627497,
0.1959673315,
0.1650812626,
0.0252997633,
-0.0045006066,
0.6389220953,
-0.6472587585,
-0.6913869977,
0.0442292914,
0.0018386402,
0.4620653093,
-0.4211805165,
-0.7167267203,
-0.0576557927,
-0.1597024649,
0.1720013916,
-0.1294259131,
0.5860455632,
-0.3333170414,
0.5996131301,
0.4227909744,
0.389275521,
0.056815818,
0.0829598978,
0.5487247109,
-0.6272005439,
-0.231915921,
-0.7252958417,
0.4370860159,
-0.3522721529,
-0.57732898,
0.3416313529,
0.6994825602,
1.0443111658,
-0.2706280649,
0.9878308177,
0.0869387612,
-0.1406421214,
-0.2799964845,
0.7407292128,
-0.6751436591,
-0.2090781182,
-0.2535963356,
-0.8955919743,
-0.4123847783,
0.6541715264,
0.2393252254,
-0.2520932555,
0.3760105073,
0.8210136294,
-0.0473416932,
-0.2217011899,
0.3955304921,
0.0689863563,
0.2107824087,
0.1785114408,
0.9484685063,
-0.5707472563,
0.6090192199,
-0.5851598978,
-0.2372264266,
-0.1408274919,
-0.7961741686,
-0.7167155743,
-0.7883053422,
-0.5958197713,
-0.3718499541,
-0.1742280722,
0.6902444959,
0.8378605247,
-0.4667285085,
-0.1886086464,
-0.0043126428,
-0.4778656662,
-0.2318739444,
-0.1880468875,
0.3216751218,
-0.3152240813,
-0.5397303104,
-0.3334390819,
0.7463439703,
0.2372607887,
-0.4285027683,
-0.1295752525,
0.4747257829,
0.0251388103,
0.6128123403,
-0.0574044362,
-0.9956235886,
-0.1497425735,
-0.1373378634,
-0.2579236925,
0.0218732003,
0.7280425429,
-0.6007482409,
1.0084414482,
0.1960374266,
0.6289227009,
0.2430292517,
-0.0765102133,
0.3412660658,
-0.6792010069,
0.1316215098,
0.2741540372,
0.4305357337,
0.8250637054,
-0.3321575224,
0.5440492034,
0.1560287327,
-0.2348404825,
-0.8067263961,
0.2444293797,
-1.1042784452,
-0.080844529,
1.0781034231,
-0.3402731419,
-0.1321297586,
0.242249921,
-0.342484653,
0.1269134879,
0.004986072,
1.0460085869,
0.5660965443,
0.0662636235,
0.0348895043,
-0.3183217943,
0.3793876171,
0.0948743075,
-0.8376509547,
0.1976813376,
0.649166882,
0.0418610945,
0.2267459184,
0.1702911854,
-0.4705438018,
0.3506087065,
-0.181028828,
0.52386415,
-0.2115172893,
-0.3944893479,
-0.1720816344,
-0.1159640104,
0.0382380001,
-0.3502829969
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06677v1
|
ATG: Benchmarking Automated Theorem Generation for Generative Language Models
| 2024-05-05T02:06:37 | 2024-05-05T02:06:37 |
Xiaohan Lin, Qingxing Cao, Yinya Huang, Zhicheng Yang, Zhengying Liu, Zhenguo Li, Xiaodan Liang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Humans can develop new theorems to explore broader and more complex
mathematical results. While current generative language models (LMs) have
achieved significant improvement in automatically proving theorems, their
ability to generate new or reusable theorems is still under-explored. Without
the new theorems, current LMs struggle to prove harder theorems that are
distant from the given hypotheses with the exponentially growing search space.
Therefore, this paper proposes an Automated Theorem Generation (ATG) benchmark
that evaluates whether an agent can automatically generate valuable (and
possibly brand new) theorems that are applicable for downstream theorem proving
as reusable knowledge. Specifically, we construct the ATG benchmark by
splitting the Metamath library into three sets: axioms, library, and problem
based on their proving depth. We conduct extensive experiments to investigate
whether current LMs can generate theorems in the library and benefit the
problem theorems proving. The results demonstrate that high-quality ATG data
facilitates models' performances on downstream ATP. However, there is still
room for current LMs to develop better ATG and generate more advanced and
human-like theorems. We hope the new ATG challenge can shed some light on
advanced complex theorem proving.
|
[
-0.5365231633,
-0.4891405404,
0.6019226313,
-0.3174391091,
-0.3166702986,
0.1632754505,
-0.2074895799,
-0.3240346014,
-0.0638470575,
0.6045850515,
-0.3452017009,
-0.7546488643,
-0.554390192,
0.4096369445,
-0.5437645912,
0.3537628651,
-0.1393532306,
-0.2506856024,
-0.3077321053,
-0.1654700786,
-0.3044968545,
-0.2363427877,
-0.6444722414,
-0.5289772153,
0.0795619115,
0.4002303183,
0.8930720091,
1.0563122034,
0.4252070487,
0.4159456789,
0.3246227503,
0.3344614804,
0.1285420954,
0.3949520588,
0.0525463521,
-0.4751555622,
-0.5181646347,
-0.0040729968,
0.8389213681,
0.6085911989,
-0.2376544178,
0.2700034082,
-0.1157512888,
0.621160984,
-0.6924265027,
0.2922281027,
-0.775164187,
0.0144925779,
-0.4258193076,
-0.1415256262,
-0.1783935875,
-0.765976727,
0.0411370918,
-0.5643392801,
0.5231688023,
-0.00273175,
0.9858624935,
0.6233989,
-0.3490078151,
-0.3371390104,
-0.3176389635,
0.6915150881,
-0.7876466513,
0.3191123605,
0.3765035868,
0.6880857944,
-0.2292361706,
-0.8593048453,
-0.4833901525,
-0.266779691,
-0.0672915429,
-0.1638934612,
-0.433003813,
-0.1958172172,
0.2882329524,
0.3367553949,
-0.5304903388,
-0.3452798724,
-0.0235245135,
-0.0982405841,
0.7855334282,
0.1779619902,
0.1246399581,
-0.516210556,
0.0833627582,
-0.4526704848,
-1.0092976093,
-0.1801965535,
0.5033665299,
0.1028920189,
0.4257757068,
0.5257844925,
-0.2282411456,
0.6590486169,
-0.3546979725,
0.0915455595,
0.4025865197,
-0.3675360382,
0.0845379978,
-0.0808105543,
0.8468194604,
0.2515206635,
0.4991623163,
-0.104242079,
-0.4626903832,
-0.0531867743,
0.3310282826,
-0.8561933041,
-0.2642991543,
0.1573898047,
-0.4425590038,
-0.4320565164,
-0.0952918753,
-0.6626184583,
-0.2917917669,
-0.3167064488,
0.3281739354,
-0.5945701003,
-0.185623765,
0.1783663034,
-0.0252050627,
0.0557551421,
0.0168336183,
-0.5919836164,
0.5168194771,
0.6445953846,
0.6854378581,
-0.1282216311,
-0.4825318158,
-0.766287446,
0.2166635245,
-0.3784157932,
1.2957932949,
-0.3424714208,
-0.3148820996,
0.1292280406,
-0.2091114968,
0.0045993375,
-1.1185275316,
0.5779989362,
-0.3921453953,
0.0032945895,
-0.3613904715,
-0.689225018,
-0.0517093651,
0.3451812267,
-0.4647538662,
0.8713799715,
-0.101213716,
-0.3894102871,
0.6047677398,
-0.8936314583,
-0.3669186831,
0.1841349751,
-0.4995495379,
-0.7085362077,
0.0817476287,
0.2545217276,
0.3000567257,
-0.8857912421,
0.3173699975,
-0.2475512773,
0.0246944092,
0.3499326706,
-0.1762146354,
0.5612391829,
0.2676196992,
-0.4320448339,
0.1396606714,
-1.0240613222,
0.5431743264,
0.1932474226,
-0.3270418644,
-0.1795931458,
0.4517182708,
-0.3978725374,
-0.0796602592,
-0.0969923735,
-0.3948835135,
0.296302259,
-0.1439432502,
0.4173961878,
0.6590062976,
-0.1186344102,
0.0429393835,
-0.4656861424,
0.6458940506,
-0.3078918755,
-0.2020962834,
-0.1195439026,
-0.4582410157,
-0.79229635,
-0.4090147316,
0.3890007436,
0.2641451955,
-0.7038915753,
0.7120640874,
-0.4105838835,
-0.453887701,
-0.5376737118,
0.1766572297,
0.3055763841,
0.2155602723,
0.3367248178,
-0.4006404877,
-0.293802619,
-0.9142700434,
-0.4621418715,
-0.3358283043,
-0.4568320513,
0.5393906236,
0.5643219352,
-0.4866241515,
1.2535253763,
-0.7579337955,
-0.0856869295,
0.0406642333,
0.6458333135,
-0.099851653,
0.3427219391,
0.4267867804,
-0.3488592505,
-0.4548020959,
-0.181687966,
-0.9631811976,
-0.6369377375,
0.2773309052,
-0.2014524043,
0.107628569,
0.5690897107,
-0.6155980825,
0.2751072943,
0.139226675,
-0.3453985155,
0.7230761647,
-0.4244561195,
0.1063882262,
-0.9398521781,
-0.02514828,
-0.3403316736,
-0.4635120034,
-0.2387803942,
0.1228420213,
0.0743801072,
-0.3634161651,
-0.0998929888,
0.6194972396,
-0.5177685618,
-0.3079662025,
-0.548684299,
-0.1534439027,
-0.1344531178,
0.1068811119,
0.0046723629,
0.6014577746,
0.7350664735,
-0.7252822518,
0.7449117303,
0.1324682981,
-0.3308951855,
0.3538148999,
-0.7597870231,
-0.0195098147,
0.1580667049,
0.3937399089,
-0.7970169783,
-0.2839434445,
0.0399987809,
-0.4605385959,
-0.022957243,
-0.189314425,
-1.0958228111,
-0.3087141216,
-0.1909552515,
0.6768290401,
0.7345831394,
-0.6768205762,
0.8249018192,
0.0946167633,
0.0263903402,
-0.2310643047,
-0.3828090131,
0.210646674,
-0.5318912864,
-0.9342457652,
0.3603666127,
0.2550704479,
-0.5066260695,
0.0825940669,
0.1980853081,
0.1029177904,
-0.0124567449,
-0.0002996529,
-0.2260383219,
-0.2180230618,
0.1733709574,
-0.1716855913,
-0.5888326764,
0.3837256134,
-0.7148617506,
0.5999796987,
-0.2565010786,
-0.7634442449,
0.0147581669,
0.2191038728,
0.566324532,
-0.4345650375,
0.3416651487,
0.5695675015,
-0.6536536217,
-0.4029850066,
-0.4899471402,
-0.2193334401,
-0.5145845413,
0.1879353076,
-0.3584146798,
-0.1460748762,
0.735571444,
-0.1782507598,
0.1483328044,
0.4809651375,
0.5307041407,
0.3542658389,
0.7181830406,
0.3008490205,
0.3102481067,
0.2741824687,
-0.3779095113,
-0.0259751659,
-0.3934542835,
0.1304419786,
-0.6060108542,
0.0101083694,
-0.6356191039,
-0.6747428775,
0.4720446765,
0.0424051844,
-0.235453859,
0.5931122899,
-0.429369837,
0.6707069278,
0.676105082,
-0.1233032048,
0.5086035728,
-0.0731620491,
-0.1962526888,
0.1124275327,
-0.5474008918,
-0.7721890211,
1.4669928551,
0.0523678213,
0.6992332935,
0.2863863409,
0.9043627977,
0.5776380301,
0.5447666645,
-0.5157713294,
0.6900322437,
-0.0940088928,
-0.5639071465,
-0.2744369507,
-0.5953131318,
-0.9899274707,
0.2802939415,
0.079171434,
-0.5780172348,
-0.0146371955,
0.4120699763,
-0.2724476457,
0.2178367823,
-0.5478826761,
0.9806157351,
-0.1603771001,
-0.5363757014,
-0.3141966462,
-0.4237119853,
0.2654989958,
-0.2053398639,
-0.082608901,
-0.2068000138,
-0.0218972228,
0.6836611032,
-0.943656683,
0.4503036737,
-0.2389877588,
-0.3594341874,
0.7230133414,
0.1714187264,
0.6067852974,
0.0473088883,
-0.0917775109,
-0.1827369183,
-0.4315910935,
-0.4009543061,
-0.4191857874,
0.4142583311,
-0.6423037648,
-0.5691085458,
-0.4262430966,
-0.446451813,
-0.125943169,
0.3134334981,
0.4698185623,
0.4695835412,
-0.0029907154,
0.1090812981,
0.5598065853,
-0.3366692364,
0.2624088824,
0.6829614639,
-0.1676965505,
-0.3900940716,
1.0987964869,
-0.0164182428,
0.3396297097,
0.0816108957,
0.352291435,
-0.5756493807,
-0.4975197911,
-0.5701987743,
0.0614877604,
-0.9229050279,
-0.363301456,
-0.5351167917,
-0.1075374857,
-0.363032937,
-0.1159346774,
-0.7439799309,
-0.3309563696,
0.1665924788,
0.2803404331,
0.3481269181,
0.5496178269,
-0.2317979187,
0.0068132547,
-0.7728098035,
0.3583403826,
0.6981409192,
0.2359979153,
-0.0908222944,
-0.2777491808,
-0.0924350843,
-0.178668946,
-0.8744217157,
-0.6360874772,
0.354419142,
0.243548274,
0.569265902,
0.4126881361,
0.0595826842,
0.4597526193,
-0.7626828551,
0.5175645351,
-0.1493056864,
-1.1607238054,
0.5164467096,
-0.6149001718,
0.2639587224,
0.4567509592,
0.0744500756,
-0.2380258739,
-0.5089355707,
-0.8846293688,
-0.8636325598,
0.3442833126,
0.5771051049,
-0.2772749662,
-0.0399748944,
0.3526330292,
0.0855185241,
0.3601979017,
-0.6742458344,
-0.157149449,
-0.3187724054,
-0.0801138878,
0.0047924151,
0.1449000835,
-0.158799693,
-0.1765225679,
0.5142996907,
-0.3853896558,
0.4237067401,
-0.2207699269,
-0.0446776673,
-0.330789268,
0.1998858303,
0.4170884192,
0.688999176,
-0.3509763479,
0.421402961,
0.1216790006,
-0.0680180266,
0.3297130466,
0.5717610121,
-0.0310110822,
0.1155256927,
0.5698463917,
0.4163811207,
-0.2845682502,
-0.9880961776,
0.409494549,
-0.1577854753,
-0.4382127523,
-0.4891381562,
0.2895150185,
0.0390333049,
0.1925709248,
0.575348258,
0.054669328,
0.0295513459,
-0.4738516808,
0.463185966,
0.5236817598,
0.2522259057,
-0.2749183476,
0.842433691,
0.1845436245,
-0.4435884058,
0.4424172044,
-0.4673658013,
-0.6821253896,
0.660389483,
0.4269424677,
1.214861393,
0.084425211,
-0.0173866414,
0.4673714936,
0.0717951432,
-0.1291135848,
-0.0930996016,
-0.3353214264,
-0.8050948381,
-0.1484336853,
-0.4515058994,
-0.5639085174,
-0.0476724803,
-0.4560975432,
0.4256365001,
-0.0933183208,
-0.0946263373,
0.0761692151,
0.0573243201,
-0.5126578808,
0.1045078784,
0.0390689597,
0.5111731887,
-0.7696311474,
0.845126152,
0.6865888238,
-0.1533078551,
-0.5436148643,
0.3269490302,
0.0614863895,
-0.7806209326,
0.6114808321,
0.1540912092,
-0.2844850421,
-0.0769169778,
-0.3893827498,
-0.8483893275,
1.2858548164,
0.3945138752,
-0.0344412364,
0.204008162,
0.3249210715,
0.5939961672,
-0.5159474611,
0.2074771523,
0.572548449,
0.5383399725,
0.1833835542,
-0.5724924803,
0.165303573,
-0.377548039,
-0.0855620578,
0.2332125008,
-0.4825397134,
1.1122021675,
-0.1198119149,
-0.2518507242,
0.0890319943,
0.6755793095,
0.6180130243,
0.1875175685,
0.8073420525,
0.6969960928,
0.7983723283,
-0.1614583582,
1.1486330032,
-0.4090366364,
0.3473547399,
0.8923776746,
-0.4527868629,
0.5433092713,
0.0907040313,
-0.1098017618,
0.4100150168,
0.5101799965,
-0.1542814821,
0.4426064789,
0.7772392631,
-0.3718170822,
-0.4039644897,
0.0527088568,
-0.547591567,
0.2571272552,
0.0002715286,
-0.3402878642,
-0.3507696986,
-0.2223739773,
-0.0790081397,
0.1192446649,
0.1790700257,
0.6191775799,
-0.1611173153,
-1.0256752968,
1.1045765877,
0.1503982544,
0.4126715064,
-0.6306702495,
0.0440236777,
-0.3308531046,
0.6148133874,
-0.0505837426,
-0.487783134,
0.3796419203,
0.3891100883,
0.066788815,
-0.3059308231,
0.6794000268,
-0.2840739787,
-0.4150273204,
0.2597283125,
0.7198761106,
0.2466614693,
-0.0113176135,
-0.4857825935,
-0.2572057843,
-0.0393302627,
-0.3120509386,
-0.0312888809,
0.8032849431,
-0.0557572357,
1.1284623146,
0.5569967628,
0.1372989863,
0.2421056628,
0.0375305973,
0.8639435768,
-0.6975557208,
-0.3174560368,
-0.874705255,
0.2764089406,
-0.0246864986,
-0.2192438096,
0.7566739917,
0.5465257764,
0.665597558,
-0.0158701539,
0.8864457011,
-0.1952065527,
0.4122410119,
-0.4556325674,
0.5654277802,
-0.8692036867,
0.4460124671,
-0.3722849786,
-1.107234478,
-0.3134243786,
0.6559066772,
-0.1811083406,
0.0432104245,
0.8592050672,
0.7351414561,
-0.206786871,
-0.0985113531,
0.0575573966,
-0.188765794,
0.9359635115,
0.5241431594,
0.9026474357,
-0.4900536835,
0.759711206,
0.0837766454,
-0.1568017304,
-0.0033456078,
-1.0471937656,
-0.8362615108,
-0.3421502411,
-0.5125413537,
-0.4184683561,
-0.0859760344,
1.1048191786,
0.6761435866,
-0.6054114699,
-0.4284766316,
-0.6883969903,
0.0477477387,
-0.2371444106,
-0.1965049356,
0.5240347981,
-0.4651965499,
-0.6652840972,
0.2469562739,
-0.1430288851,
0.1796684563,
-0.2921299934,
-0.2922544181,
0.0281545091,
0.1259556264,
0.1783279181,
0.3705106676,
-0.4787732959,
-0.2983255982,
-0.2597195506,
-0.0736879632,
0.0531087779,
1.1085216999,
-0.7738835812,
0.3263428807,
0.4155271351,
0.7297832966,
0.4521676004,
0.1067633182,
0.9721087813,
-0.7301885486,
-0.1027490944,
0.2152754217,
0.5074914098,
0.3667765558,
0.2386895269,
0.5867323279,
0.4290825725,
-0.7407536507,
-0.9573795199,
0.4414465725,
-0.4009177685,
-0.126103878,
1.1482287645,
-0.1884146482,
0.0217186324,
0.0888307095,
0.2946333885,
0.3103987873,
-0.3549720347,
0.9705014825,
0.7744835615,
-0.1400862336,
0.1095276102,
-0.4764915407,
0.7323892117,
0.6361279488,
-1.2021808624,
0.5962463617,
0.3781982362,
0.3550074399,
0.2503024936,
0.6063176394,
-0.1345319748,
0.2916035354,
0.1217484176,
0.2392808646,
-0.1670519114,
-0.2919750512,
0.0797079727,
0.0561698601,
0.0860920176,
-0.266771853
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02774v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02774v1
|
Get more for less: Principled Data Selection for Warming Up Fine-Tuning in LLMs
| 2024-05-05T00:08:00 | 2024-05-05T00:08:00 |
Feiyang Kang, Hoang Anh Just, Yifan Sun, Himanshu Jahagirdar, Yuanzhi Zhang, Rongxing Du, Anit Kumar Sahu, Ruoxi Jia
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
This work focuses on leveraging and selecting from vast, unlabeled, open data
to pre-fine-tune a pre-trained language model. The goal is to minimize the need
for costly domain-specific data for subsequent fine-tuning while achieving
desired performance levels. While many data selection algorithms have been
designed for small-scale applications, rendering them unsuitable for our
context, some emerging methods do cater to language data scales. However, they
often prioritize data that aligns with the target distribution. While this
strategy may be effective when training a model from scratch, it can yield
limited results when the model has already been pre-trained on a different
distribution. Differing from prior work, our key idea is to select data that
nudges the pre-training distribution closer to the target distribution. We show
the optimality of this approach for fine-tuning tasks under certain conditions.
We demonstrate the efficacy of our methodology across a diverse array of tasks
(NLU, NLG, zero-shot) with models up to 2.7B, showing that it consistently
surpasses other selection methods. Moreover, our proposed method is
significantly faster than existing techniques, scaling to millions of samples
within a single GPU hour. Our code is open-sourced (Code repository:
https://anonymous.4open.science/r/DV4LLM-D761/ ). While fine-tuning offers
significant potential for enhancing performance across diverse tasks, its
associated costs often limit its widespread adoption; with this work, we hope
to lay the groundwork for cost-effective fine-tuning, making its benefits more
accessible.
|
[
-0.7061297894,
-0.6739245653,
0.4273759425,
-0.0059340931,
-0.4688680172,
-0.1036954448,
-0.6652982235,
-0.289452225,
0.0089829937,
0.696267128,
-0.8229632974,
-0.4972110689,
-0.5007787347,
-0.113969408,
-0.0960285366,
0.9403326511,
0.2316048145,
-0.1914089918,
-0.1052911878,
-0.126242891,
-0.350336194,
-0.1394518614,
-0.8652351499,
-0.4832504094,
0.4386568069,
0.8098745942,
0.6048642397,
1.0028413534,
0.809186697,
0.163482964,
-0.1488514692,
0.3771083355,
-0.894087851,
0.129913792,
0.1474363953,
-0.5272045732,
-0.452203095,
0.1066342443,
0.5074883699,
0.7579311132,
-0.193816185,
0.5677386522,
0.0406998843,
1.0104014874,
-0.8606165051,
0.0922196656,
-0.983309567,
0.1667974591,
-0.3763052523,
-0.1626671106,
-0.2334814221,
-0.2331276536,
-0.079257533,
-0.7016749382,
0.2591831386,
0.1352425367,
0.7483071685,
0.6638602018,
0.0452934541,
0.0563983545,
-0.6793412566,
1.0632332563,
-0.50140661,
0.6030917764,
0.5286665559,
0.2428462207,
0.3179542124,
-0.5406056046,
-0.2625355721,
-0.3662187755,
0.1877189279,
0.0601708926,
-0.0994468331,
0.0287378486,
0.4726754725,
0.4540157914,
-0.5800104737,
0.4205293655,
-0.2004343718,
0.0772352442,
0.5647522807,
0.210413143,
-0.0764543191,
0.2865914702,
-0.0517677143,
-0.2668462396,
-1.0740978718,
-0.0879007056,
0.3365870714,
0.6630052924,
-0.1521721929,
0.573525548,
-0.6112030745,
0.887788415,
0.1925920397,
-0.0667124167,
0.0522916056,
-0.4519560635,
-0.4781255126,
-0.1968740523,
0.5128268003,
0.3358269632,
0.2860851288,
0.0136682773,
-0.3436140716,
-0.0236398019,
0.0870530903,
-1.0018385649,
-0.4768774211,
-0.0604590215,
-0.4096963108,
-0.2539538443,
-0.3625248671,
-0.6616277695,
-0.3513781726,
-0.7987310886,
-0.0272116493,
-0.1160482392,
-0.1652866155,
0.2572580874,
0.0393266305,
0.0090590026,
0.2525061071,
-1.0470970869,
0.3724375665,
0.5276336074,
0.8209183216,
-0.2822098136,
-0.0938273594,
-0.6022720337,
-0.0310040656,
-0.5735949874,
0.7152005434,
-0.6777185798,
-0.2475622892,
-0.1934569776,
-0.2549404204,
-0.0344180092,
-0.8018834591,
0.6121297479,
-0.5090512633,
-0.105882138,
-0.3774082065,
-0.3756785095,
0.3442333341,
0.0419413485,
-0.6847994328,
1.2062969208,
0.1094241664,
-0.6698626876,
0.7265146971,
-0.5442147255,
-0.4540764689,
0.0022022782,
-0.0914893225,
-0.4982748926,
0.2595831156,
0.3614692688,
0.6534245014,
-0.5355755687,
-0.0654972196,
-0.3753859401,
-0.261359632,
-0.2154647112,
-0.2715167999,
0.47872594,
0.6558812857,
-0.2043837905,
0.1867332608,
-0.8079868555,
0.1351118088,
0.0333155058,
-0.3223717809,
-0.2085609585,
-0.0301906448,
0.0582787283,
0.0428345352,
0.2343067527,
-0.3050818741,
0.1778589636,
-0.4445730746,
0.2492517084,
0.7284448743,
-0.2519119382,
0.7977439165,
-0.4178101718,
0.5822666883,
-0.2755371034,
0.306150049,
0.3027867079,
-0.0081673181,
-0.6707407832,
-0.4372536838,
0.3202623725,
0.3612099588,
-0.6123534441,
0.4262988269,
-0.2636719346,
-0.4761652946,
-0.7182118893,
0.668074131,
0.2975660264,
0.3753978014,
0.4809889793,
-0.0782131478,
-0.5542240143,
-0.8161461949,
0.0097185913,
0.2983751297,
-0.1676165611,
0.5449571013,
0.0710592866,
-0.1917771399,
0.8026095033,
-1.0645192862,
-0.4927650392,
-0.3615350723,
-0.2106073648,
0.2747909725,
0.4221500158,
0.5322927237,
-0.5532329082,
-0.6109653711,
0.1910103112,
-0.3238627911,
-0.0689216778,
0.0060818773,
-0.2585785687,
-0.153571859,
0.6511927843,
-0.5421769619,
-0.046058774,
0.611704886,
0.0326752365,
0.1616926342,
-0.3946953714,
-0.089459382,
-0.9003652334,
-0.024935931,
0.0801961496,
-0.2664474845,
-0.4538088143,
0.0405828021,
0.0343558863,
-0.1580995321,
-0.3796586692,
0.6597576141,
-0.6215716004,
0.0817850903,
-0.3183531463,
0.0897393897,
-0.2511307597,
0.3554059863,
0.1137710512,
0.7257726789,
0.7976769805,
-0.8687481284,
0.198309049,
0.129596442,
-0.4814881682,
0.3173751533,
-0.5894063115,
0.1583582759,
-0.0261459835,
-0.1733748466,
-0.724578619,
-0.1631492376,
-0.038119752,
-0.155407548,
0.4571745396,
-0.2871443629,
-0.4755559564,
-0.0749206841,
-0.4172383845,
0.3251734972,
0.6639120579,
-0.65847826,
0.0529797003,
0.6432230473,
-0.1945939511,
-0.4031027257,
-0.5016403794,
-0.301622659,
-0.3101141155,
-0.2903743982,
0.2578656971,
-0.2084878534,
-0.216226384,
-0.2702152431,
-0.3095589578,
-0.0827479661,
0.327313602,
-0.0082605109,
0.118523173,
-0.1355121732,
-0.0023846009,
0.2633998692,
-0.2917568684,
-0.3671978414,
-0.356367588,
0.5688239932,
0.1914217025,
-0.284280628,
-0.1995988339,
0.001597213,
0.3091225028,
-0.2723349035,
0.5341203213,
0.7121666074,
-0.266266346,
-0.436825484,
-0.4259547889,
-0.4154276252,
-0.5278086662,
0.3372363746,
-0.3927128911,
-0.946313262,
0.1822390258,
-0.202115491,
0.2175445408,
0.1036254913,
0.7161647677,
-0.0443092287,
0.9374738932,
0.9197552204,
-0.342556566,
0.9108133912,
-0.2543932199,
0.0055493861,
-0.7327714562,
0.1669612825,
-0.6213796139,
-0.3027067184,
-0.5679367185,
-0.5316747427,
0.2656266093,
0.0694129467,
-0.1240532845,
0.1699274629,
-0.7400256395,
0.8352341056,
0.5477645397,
0.1664364785,
0.1653851718,
0.0465894863,
0.0964217633,
-0.0786100253,
-0.7193658948,
-0.2643601596,
1.3505500555,
0.1271597445,
0.985922277,
-0.1153609157,
0.6755053997,
0.1257371902,
0.1309167147,
-0.6100850701,
0.5176361203,
-0.3676143885,
-0.475928247,
-0.5593330264,
-0.5337691307,
-1.1899037361,
0.2060702741,
-0.1682166457,
-0.4734416604,
0.0035795697,
0.4209251404,
-0.5781689882,
0.1656843126,
-0.6775587201,
0.6907097101,
-0.0257244539,
-0.2105929404,
-0.4058425725,
-0.5680040121,
0.2219884694,
-0.1386220604,
0.1286949813,
-0.5516873598,
-0.0084276795,
0.6307958961,
-0.1656696647,
0.7361696959,
-0.1950715333,
-0.0702475384,
-0.0608067103,
-0.0568036772,
0.6446691751,
0.1860729307,
-0.0511868373,
-0.0179951284,
-0.080225341,
-0.5336616039,
-0.3378311992,
0.8984190822,
-0.7614476681,
-0.4124107659,
0.1469694823,
-0.5617930293,
-0.4057250619,
0.2343852222,
0.3547068238,
0.2356908619,
0.0488909222,
0.4163437486,
0.9676244855,
0.051340498,
0.2418686748,
0.3549868464,
-0.039285671,
-0.3086845279,
1.0413197279,
0.0898058414,
0.4754536152,
0.5924862027,
0.1695113182,
-0.3084364235,
-1.0659686327,
-0.2241012305,
0.0873396248,
-0.4528673291,
-0.3092080057,
-0.5201201439,
0.1090102121,
-0.4958196878,
-0.2033024579,
-0.6395249367,
-0.4111117423,
-0.4953660965,
-0.1998636425,
0.4264707267,
0.3048394322,
-0.2224719226,
0.5392164588,
-0.4886420667,
0.544190228,
0.2163316309,
0.3818582892,
-0.289514035,
-0.6543103456,
-0.4599230587,
0.0191474687,
-0.1658390611,
-0.1392025948,
0.4336895645,
0.3081010282,
0.5311952829,
0.3792170882,
0.1908480227,
0.7898682952,
-0.4915792346,
0.3517583013,
0.1153836623,
-0.6336685419,
0.7537005544,
-0.2549641728,
0.2292935401,
0.9385464787,
0.3350331187,
-0.2729727924,
-0.2496930361,
-0.5347762108,
-0.9230079055,
0.738199532,
0.1515569389,
0.1730890423,
0.2649250329,
0.3254690468,
0.17078273,
0.2864025831,
-0.3644528687,
-0.4387429059,
0.1677872092,
-0.1963728815,
-0.3814001679,
-0.0686147287,
-0.3072372973,
-0.4843561351,
0.5544468164,
-0.4996860921,
0.0781538337,
-0.2428685427,
-0.2285517454,
-0.2545241416,
0.017381113,
0.5239539146,
0.568643868,
-0.3337755501,
-0.0513097197,
0.3408747911,
-0.4840595722,
-0.1096100882,
0.2548927069,
-0.2500708401,
-0.1552784741,
0.0570630692,
1.1751328707,
0.2635346651,
-0.6465319991,
0.0519061796,
-0.0173604991,
-0.2238023132,
0.0551028028,
0.2619034052,
-0.0118377171,
0.3365381062,
0.0906440988,
0.2056221366,
-0.0137404781,
-0.2866087258,
0.1848897487,
0.7537284493,
-0.1931597441,
-0.2726386189,
0.6001729369,
0.0386802405,
0.0039554327,
0.4999341965,
-0.0851926729,
0.1677915156,
0.4502700865,
0.1225577891,
0.6970745325,
0.0722801238,
0.143983081,
0.2215713561,
0.3583813906,
-0.2685707808,
0.3336237371,
-0.1805029213,
-0.9374257326,
-0.4350008667,
-0.8112491965,
-0.4305137396,
0.212452352,
-0.7065961957,
0.4046056271,
-0.6199201941,
-0.2520517707,
-0.0260853246,
0.4150820076,
-0.8784812689,
0.2798626721,
0.1709161103,
0.7902832031,
-0.8001036048,
1.0362286568,
0.5335185528,
-0.1146865934,
-0.666888535,
-0.1155771092,
-0.0200883243,
-1.0025901794,
0.4439000487,
-0.2920023501,
0.0411912203,
0.3903615177,
-0.5706099272,
-1.0297161341,
1.1103326082,
0.7663944364,
-0.8047826886,
-0.011277725,
-0.0222370569,
0.3885950148,
-0.2213473469,
0.1169426963,
0.8088223934,
0.3390287161,
0.3397312462,
-0.8840820789,
-0.0149591994,
0.2034002692,
-0.0343206041,
0.3834506273,
-0.6080276966,
0.8030844927,
-0.3376926482,
-0.1028493866,
-0.1229927093,
0.3366810977,
0.3988079131,
0.1098603904,
0.3947053254,
0.6607611179,
1.0107796192,
0.0371619314,
1.0516223907,
-0.3798521161,
0.5716314316,
1.1623117924,
-0.3461943567,
0.7939639091,
0.4535160661,
-0.3662558794,
-0.3181630671,
0.9456067085,
0.1043754071,
0.9133152366,
0.2243010104,
-0.2033140212,
-0.3623022437,
-0.1519576013,
-0.3354994357,
0.0221723039,
0.2183029354,
-0.0429792628,
-0.3735399246,
0.0329102464,
-0.09543363,
-0.1631455868,
-0.4267214835,
0.8849824071,
0.1122440323,
-0.3373523653,
0.829431057,
-0.1862448603,
0.7725903392,
-0.6006627679,
0.3426466584,
-0.428522259,
0.3191293478,
-0.1435952485,
-0.5168740749,
0.2859314084,
-0.0421657339,
-0.2128967047,
-0.5862128139,
0.746303618,
-0.4356610775,
-0.4269160628,
0.0521070138,
0.6577963829,
0.055210188,
-0.3126686513,
-0.7145204544,
0.2490508407,
0.2228498757,
-0.3516953886,
0.7521857023,
0.4536222816,
0.1281760484,
0.771353066,
1.0133116245,
0.50709939,
0.0541485846,
0.1063062847,
1.0002744198,
-0.5778542161,
-0.2204866558,
-0.883194387,
0.1990906745,
-0.0379415266,
-0.4518571198,
0.5975544453,
0.6385638714,
1.0234630108,
-0.1420388073,
0.6948550344,
0.2114223093,
0.5178906322,
-0.7718251944,
0.4816093445,
-0.5872462988,
0.2951845229,
-0.1425054669,
-0.8920367956,
-0.3913311064,
0.6102645993,
-0.2683842778,
-0.1958578378,
0.4940828979,
0.9405686259,
-0.1111164242,
-0.259459585,
0.6691079736,
-0.1347104907,
0.2005039155,
0.3966047168,
0.6477544904,
-0.0046221265,
0.388263315,
-0.3615230024,
-0.0908155516,
-0.2149609923,
-0.7392064929,
-0.9387085438,
-0.3851238787,
-0.4272018373,
-0.0126651451,
-0.0527130067,
1.1879521608,
1.1261012554,
-0.738737464,
-0.2424679846,
-0.1739475876,
0.2263324857,
-0.2620439529,
-0.1316698939,
0.0396828018,
-0.6943437457,
-0.8048250675,
0.4294742644,
0.2143257111,
-0.0743663907,
0.0671144798,
-0.0837758258,
0.1233503744,
-0.0357856005,
0.6327394843,
0.2452278286,
-0.3306283951,
0.1108086333,
0.0243197158,
-0.0636322349,
0.1556238979,
0.9148258567,
-0.6103117466,
0.0407136157,
0.3616601527,
0.9097745419,
0.8363503218,
-0.1487387717,
0.3626573682,
-1.0471923351,
0.3173679113,
0.3398434222,
0.1767777205,
0.1155397594,
-0.4006792307,
0.6394265294,
0.0763167366,
-0.5792389512,
-0.9955515862,
0.2189549506,
-0.9401034713,
-0.3175616264,
1.3756867647,
0.166302219,
0.0825272053,
0.1136740446,
-0.3026888072,
0.0084800124,
-0.4796411693,
0.5830774307,
0.4171740711,
-0.3175877035,
-0.3435841501,
-0.7405917048,
0.9534132481,
0.4649195671,
-0.9102945924,
0.4712598324,
0.4812666476,
0.2595924735,
-0.2450056821,
0.7350968122,
0.2749909461,
-0.0979958326,
-0.2179923207,
-0.1241138279,
0.0644895583,
-0.2861258388,
-0.3470811546,
0.0381119289,
0.4603128433,
-0.2559321821
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02765v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02765v2
|
Detecting Edited Knowledge in Language Models
| 2024-05-04T22:02:24 | 2024-07-01T19:20:58 |
Paul Youssef, Zhixue Zhao, Jörg Schlötterer, Christin Seifert
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Knowledge editing methods (KEs) can update language models' obsolete or
inaccurate knowledge learned from pre-training. However, KEs can be used for
malicious applications, e.g., inserting misinformation and toxic content.
Knowing whether a generated output is based on edited knowledge or first-hand
knowledge from pre-training can increase users' trust in generative models and
provide more transparency. Driven by this, we propose a novel task: detecting
edited knowledge in language models. Given an edited model and a fact retrieved
by a prompt from an edited model, the objective is to classify the knowledge as
either unedited (based on the pre-training), or edited (based on subsequent
editing). We instantiate the task with four KEs, two LLMs, and two datasets.
Additionally, we propose using the hidden state representations and the
probability distributions as features for the detection. Our results reveal
that, using these features as inputs to a simple AdaBoost classifiers
establishes a strong baseline. This classifier requires only a limited amount
of data and maintains its performance even in cross-domain settings. Last, we
find it more challenging to distinguish edited knowledge from unedited but
related knowledge, highlighting the need for further research. Our work lays
the groundwork for addressing malicious model editing, which is a critical
challenge associated with the strong generative capabilities of LLMs.
|
[
-0.0097821355,
-0.7354437709,
0.7802420259,
-0.2544649839,
0.0247756392,
0.0577837862,
-0.165815413,
-0.42591241,
-0.0498500317,
0.800324142,
-0.2711071372,
-0.6811872125,
-0.7829566598,
-0.0021785342,
-0.56355232,
0.940700531,
-0.0719989613,
-0.1454670131,
-0.4698347449,
-0.138984859,
-0.3065438569,
-0.594764173,
-0.520706296,
-0.236976698,
0.1232955679,
0.1728228331,
0.7315251231,
0.6363243461,
0.155369997,
0.2918857634,
-0.4985515773,
0.4389641285,
-0.2473946661,
0.1078700125,
-0.2582578063,
-0.6443660259,
-0.7458604574,
-0.1167340279,
0.4433165491,
0.2336871475,
-0.0891787261,
0.0382474586,
0.1542305052,
0.461617142,
-0.8967123032,
0.1191732213,
-0.9710870981,
-0.010801075,
-0.3499453366,
-0.1974099278,
-0.592849791,
-0.0900356546,
-0.3226676285,
-0.6443235278,
0.3181572855,
-0.1905762404,
0.6836614013,
0.3838684559,
-0.3174982667,
-0.3811791837,
-0.5106871724,
0.3665154576,
-0.8809815645,
0.5520101786,
0.4359005094,
-0.0273409393,
-0.3939843476,
-0.6046856046,
-0.9102413058,
-0.1460876018,
-0.2484138161,
-0.1196185127,
-0.6821075678,
0.2129793167,
0.4212632775,
0.2166004032,
-0.2032755166,
0.3265631795,
-0.2865051329,
-0.6739177704,
0.5009097457,
-0.0407644361,
0.4793980122,
-0.3312972188,
-0.0278392322,
0.0429460071,
-0.829608798,
-0.0204565525,
0.6064741611,
0.1087184399,
0.1352764219,
0.7153570652,
-0.2503481507,
0.7826388478,
0.1405736506,
-0.1232163236,
0.1550735682,
-0.2220814675,
-0.2941462696,
-0.0065200049,
0.6549397111,
0.2370900065,
0.1736723334,
0.0913485661,
-0.5391690731,
-0.035336718,
0.2093349546,
-0.436980933,
-0.4185861945,
0.0394444168,
-0.1066923514,
-0.6418946385,
-0.2788771987,
-0.3395518661,
-0.9000965953,
-0.0842791721,
0.56986022,
-0.4608656168,
-0.1665412188,
0.0972059295,
-0.0438295975,
-0.2977330387,
0.5995098948,
-0.6977581978,
0.0083815595,
0.6427134275,
0.5560081601,
0.1204791367,
-0.1551188976,
-0.5159475207,
0.2325971872,
-0.3141838312,
0.8049008846,
-0.6149536371,
-0.143267408,
0.0078086243,
-0.0694734603,
0.1981830001,
-0.5424062014,
0.4940240681,
-1.0286755562,
0.1727892309,
-0.1612884402,
-0.8852697015,
-0.0903849378,
0.2324212939,
-0.6174981594,
0.9873850942,
-0.0702302679,
-0.919369638,
0.5665661097,
-0.5926138163,
-0.3829168677,
-0.1733464152,
0.0391845293,
-0.6204686165,
0.0420675091,
0.5261824727,
0.5013417602,
0.4233832657,
0.2889853716,
-0.3470022976,
0.0481364615,
0.3338274956,
-0.4067422748,
0.7876316309,
0.0455628969,
0.124391973,
0.1659315526,
-0.7748536468,
-0.1770828068,
0.0754572079,
-0.6173034906,
-0.5682705641,
-0.1359681189,
-0.4115650952,
0.0889185965,
0.4090687633,
-0.719997108,
0.3256536126,
-0.2352533787,
0.0564811565,
0.9840809703,
0.273034513,
0.2973519266,
-0.2112312317,
0.5735545754,
0.3588790894,
0.2687146664,
-0.1939853579,
-0.4944223464,
-0.9711201787,
-0.0894206092,
0.3889501989,
0.6046303511,
-0.863030076,
0.5007001162,
-0.1791909784,
-0.3576968312,
-0.7714316845,
0.4404228926,
0.3978465497,
0.5650372505,
0.4350534081,
-0.0630613416,
-0.4796670377,
-0.7262087464,
-0.7510006428,
-0.2877104282,
-0.0286049936,
0.2283750325,
0.4429757595,
-0.2700937092,
0.9237921238,
-0.5819333792,
-0.3354168534,
-0.0393909663,
0.136801362,
-0.0751791596,
0.4586455822,
0.4355908036,
-0.3290418088,
-0.2638825476,
0.0553707667,
-0.7568371892,
-0.389533788,
-0.0708227307,
0.0801283866,
0.1169652715,
0.6540311575,
-0.4974801838,
0.5435734987,
0.3560286164,
-0.2741482556,
0.5602304339,
-0.3972512186,
0.2387951612,
-0.9270130992,
-0.1386197209,
-0.2736671865,
-0.4882542193,
-0.7800393701,
-0.033809647,
0.3704440296,
0.1502595991,
-0.449829787,
0.5596324801,
-0.4553894997,
0.1742686927,
-0.2032117397,
0.0956658572,
0.0021529698,
0.4958693981,
0.0551119372,
0.6643358469,
0.4882123768,
-0.4803932011,
0.3050304055,
0.5057862997,
-0.7635009289,
0.3416989446,
-0.2584550083,
0.6282795072,
-0.2460802346,
-0.0399410129,
-0.6745123863,
-0.2049748749,
0.2437705994,
-0.5858169794,
0.39537552,
-0.4488490224,
-0.6838138103,
-0.030473778,
-0.0287580416,
0.1479299814,
0.3524284363,
-0.4834090173,
0.5675354004,
0.5035660863,
-0.2002458274,
-0.8369262815,
-0.5398566127,
0.0373332724,
0.0883888081,
-0.6397173405,
0.1313954145,
0.1622202992,
-0.2735524178,
0.3246860504,
-0.2888246775,
-0.2258959562,
0.3155754507,
0.1037308276,
0.2608085275,
-0.0875069201,
0.1701949835,
0.491312176,
0.0768584386,
-0.0187357739,
-0.1142305806,
0.1493282765,
0.1427591294,
-0.5736518502,
-0.3972283602,
-0.159334898,
0.5692201853,
-0.3498854935,
0.78041327,
0.2904517353,
-0.5265609026,
-0.3587062061,
-0.6861575246,
-0.028147608,
-0.4754945934,
0.586866498,
-0.2403923273,
-0.9517788887,
0.5356546044,
-0.0152105382,
0.0833626837,
0.4187979996,
0.3669233322,
-0.0783068091,
1.0370407104,
0.716067791,
0.0038842333,
0.4582608342,
-0.0081764413,
0.094384186,
-0.7620975375,
-0.1871676594,
-0.2456928641,
-0.1603938341,
-0.3584450185,
-0.4663831592,
0.5090566874,
0.3330801129,
0.1927602291,
0.2770948708,
-0.1633963734,
0.7601339221,
0.4145504236,
0.5411692858,
0.5962908268,
-0.3260340691,
-0.2483060956,
0.1790293455,
-0.7377938628,
-0.5028064847,
1.3647201061,
0.2618566751,
0.5418559909,
0.1294159144,
0.6475863457,
0.7766472101,
0.4924838245,
-0.6271608472,
0.5694852471,
-0.054555241,
-0.6732486486,
-0.2189730853,
-0.2459638864,
-0.5013925433,
0.0518189371,
-0.3764139712,
-0.5120112896,
0.3395183682,
0.6867402196,
-0.4747803807,
0.6873672009,
-0.5980353951,
0.9035156369,
-0.0200892128,
-0.2110800743,
-0.3191998005,
-0.2685885131,
0.5083515048,
-0.4195457101,
0.3815856576,
0.031527359,
0.1264016181,
0.8433796167,
-0.5717999935,
0.8645941615,
-0.331915766,
-0.1396705359,
0.085917145,
0.4838159382,
0.8401865959,
-0.0613296106,
0.0122814002,
0.074653931,
-0.1254412979,
-0.1530807614,
-0.7132753134,
0.3597021103,
-0.4818525612,
-0.9079042673,
-0.3584495187,
-0.4666446447,
-0.4010249376,
0.2812204957,
0.2277389467,
0.1520688236,
-0.2135259211,
-0.1242916211,
0.7967997193,
-0.3690591455,
-0.0263450779,
0.7531604767,
-0.2896414995,
-0.0624752715,
0.5811232924,
-0.0502865873,
0.4019141495,
0.3158076108,
0.1624874473,
-0.0597025715,
-0.9029777646,
-0.3664585054,
0.0365577713,
-1.0228842497,
-0.3879219294,
-0.765753746,
-0.3090344667,
-0.4741107821,
-0.0339907445,
-0.3539119959,
-0.4920428991,
-0.3845331073,
-0.2939745486,
0.4794234037,
0.9674891233,
-0.4234852195,
0.3533955216,
-0.8795019388,
0.2445043176,
0.4555079937,
0.286904335,
-0.10059423,
-0.8767027259,
-0.2375992388,
0.1922331452,
-0.1573338509,
-1.0953965187,
0.3249081671,
0.2282245308,
0.5084664226,
0.6902068853,
0.0372116081,
0.4806572199,
-0.4440426528,
0.5595010519,
-0.1719861031,
-1.1672055721,
0.7734911442,
-0.1124585792,
0.0468138866,
0.3618310392,
0.2733543813,
-0.6886175871,
-0.7189560533,
-0.6159876585,
-0.1727268547,
0.8709434867,
0.1062352806,
0.1684396267,
0.0630251691,
0.2391967773,
0.0876596645,
0.3120262325,
-0.7208487391,
-0.180035919,
0.0015194268,
-0.0062119788,
0.2206191272,
-0.6153755784,
0.004254017,
-0.2746568024,
0.9118120074,
0.2084454745,
-0.0518429056,
-0.0579351559,
-0.5943967104,
-0.1773214936,
0.5188117623,
0.4203619957,
0.5233179331,
-0.1065582037,
0.1963041872,
0.3189290166,
-0.4399915636,
0.0206078477,
-0.1298904866,
-0.4606137574,
-0.0263423342,
0.6398634315,
0.9025409818,
0.2225664407,
-0.5566132665,
0.7616383433,
0.281347394,
0.0728831813,
-0.0282730106,
0.2824100256,
-0.1490853429,
0.1356539428,
-0.1236821637,
0.6153083444,
0.0287354756,
-0.3812328875,
0.4302155375,
0.2341609299,
-0.2221717089,
-0.5015912056,
0.5376775861,
0.0874401554,
-0.219073981,
0.5804747343,
-0.4069215953,
-0.9841173887,
0.1464346945,
0.2249006331,
0.7122768164,
-0.5820065737,
0.0640541837,
0.2177399993,
0.5724368095,
0.1370564997,
0.1562442183,
-0.1687566042,
-1.3337627649,
-0.2342536151,
-0.608726263,
-0.1559889466,
0.5070288777,
-0.6019334197,
0.4494676888,
-0.4226509631,
-0.0407545678,
0.1920266002,
-0.6308352947,
-0.7567173243,
0.0329396464,
0.100373894,
0.7442108989,
-1.2192718983,
0.9664699435,
0.6137015224,
-0.1642997414,
-0.3851086497,
-0.0627989545,
0.2723953724,
-1.1991635561,
0.6122046113,
-0.2750216722,
0.0568382517,
-0.0344692208,
-0.5024152994,
-0.6568777561,
0.6027514338,
0.4149850905,
-0.4802111387,
0.0130210854,
0.1581115425,
0.4112400115,
0.1716889292,
-0.171104908,
0.6111302972,
0.4452199042,
-0.0449955761,
-0.979349792,
-0.0774089769,
-0.2967574,
-0.4035471082,
0.2579320371,
-0.0521033779,
0.5813353062,
-0.3813322484,
-0.3506687284,
-0.186177507,
0.647206068,
-0.0196464863,
0.1040992439,
0.6683310866,
0.7986631989,
1.016831398,
0.0505202301,
0.7311090827,
-0.1742063612,
0.1034209207,
1.2211693525,
-0.1535397023,
0.6871994138,
0.2854919434,
-0.2515517175,
0.4697649181,
0.4071869552,
0.0125838332,
0.5469619632,
0.0023049652,
-0.4754547179,
-0.565357089,
-0.0054819733,
-0.1136934236,
0.64020437,
0.4416019917,
-0.3919430673,
-0.0944869742,
0.25424999,
0.4460222423,
0.1297126114,
-0.4025898874,
1.0961945057,
-0.1843628436,
-0.4967533946,
0.3702954948,
0.1861766875,
0.5774287581,
-0.4476934075,
-0.0702323616,
-0.1476866156,
0.1246927604,
-0.2789388299,
-1.0488934517,
0.3007803559,
0.3961915672,
-0.150949806,
-0.1946885735,
0.9689619541,
-0.5592783093,
-0.4026049972,
-0.0193096381,
0.4437725246,
-0.0294794142,
-0.344812274,
-0.4157087803,
-0.0431361087,
0.1874194443,
-0.171896264,
0.1510908604,
0.4958446622,
-0.0837946236,
0.6656880379,
0.7758172154,
0.3776217103,
0.2290702015,
-0.1731190681,
0.8333195448,
-0.2203424275,
-0.582059443,
-0.7627472878,
0.5029838681,
-0.1854845881,
-0.110811457,
0.7325341105,
0.4870680273,
1.0110160112,
-0.1326655298,
1.0010302067,
0.1218102053,
0.4012081623,
-0.8181388378,
1.0186674595,
-0.5138122439,
0.516697526,
-0.1961214989,
-0.420930624,
-0.1540551484,
0.2954611778,
-0.4348352253,
-0.1722328961,
0.476944387,
1.0760314465,
-0.1683868915,
-0.0634128153,
0.4081250429,
0.6236658692,
0.1407600194,
0.2857201695,
0.9875756502,
-0.2299577445,
0.270424366,
-0.4812847376,
-0.2189984471,
-0.0565653034,
-0.9821429849,
-0.9610332847,
-0.6543904543,
-0.4417972863,
-0.3224207461,
0.2837238312,
0.6138519049,
0.3760932386,
-0.9993566275,
0.2652366161,
0.0812803581,
0.321672529,
-0.1574520022,
-0.151943922,
0.4526671171,
-0.0606858619,
-0.4345617592,
0.6767428517,
0.0604145825,
0.1190910041,
0.0062381676,
0.2121445686,
-0.041077964,
0.1412912309,
0.4089783728,
0.2427036166,
-0.7144607902,
-0.5454443097,
-0.2470797896,
0.1334116161,
-0.1408596933,
0.7620743513,
-0.6719616055,
0.8550736904,
0.5401263237,
0.6869571209,
0.3005112708,
-0.2389645278,
0.4718316495,
-1.1940033436,
-0.0187446456,
0.2108581513,
0.588899374,
0.4032605886,
-0.5326436162,
0.0660146549,
0.3944946229,
-0.3994103968,
-1.0438861847,
0.1507738829,
-0.6311077476,
-0.1990849525,
1.026072979,
-0.2994171977,
-0.0256302245,
-0.1634700298,
-0.0331866331,
0.4381021559,
-0.1940502822,
0.8858546019,
0.7811613083,
0.0284266807,
-0.0123957889,
-0.4017707705,
0.9275967479,
0.2175802737,
-0.8195367455,
0.3629997075,
0.7318020463,
0.4955770671,
-0.0876450613,
0.4013075531,
-0.0797837675,
0.4575836062,
-0.1629189104,
0.2928439081,
-0.5517160296,
-0.3502736688,
-0.3647891879,
-0.0216276404,
0.1212498918,
0.0258054808
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02764v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02764v1
|
Assessing Adversarial Robustness of Large Language Models: An Empirical Study
| 2024-05-04T22:00:28 | 2024-05-04T22:00:28 |
Zeyu Yang, Zhao Meng, Xiaochen Zheng, Roger Wattenhofer
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) have revolutionized natural language processing,
but their robustness against adversarial attacks remains a critical concern. We
presents a novel white-box style attack approach that exposes vulnerabilities
in leading open-source LLMs, including Llama, OPT, and T5. We assess the impact
of model size, structure, and fine-tuning strategies on their resistance to
adversarial perturbations. Our comprehensive evaluation across five diverse
text classification tasks establishes a new benchmark for LLM robustness. The
findings of this study have far-reaching implications for the reliable
deployment of LLMs in real-world applications and contribute to the advancement
of trustworthy AI systems.
|
[
-0.2737255394,
-1.1606212854,
0.4440124631,
-0.0123711471,
-0.0449840687,
0.1330035925,
-0.2881182432,
-0.435400933,
-0.3672433496,
0.5668848753,
-0.2098151594,
-0.5851022005,
-0.9287216067,
0.1940331757,
-0.7897067666,
0.9694404602,
0.204577446,
-0.1313373893,
-0.1819906831,
-0.2363340408,
-0.308598578,
-0.564342916,
-0.6096115708,
-0.0903232694,
0.394662112,
-0.024515219,
1.0357900858,
0.5791544318,
0.6894580126,
0.3701916933,
-0.3388411403,
-0.1084604189,
-0.6625288129,
0.2316768616,
-0.0619446822,
-0.7872065306,
-0.5127173066,
-0.2592585385,
0.6517394185,
0.480168432,
0.0868271217,
0.1739861965,
0.0381386429,
0.455172956,
-0.7368109226,
-0.108709842,
-1.1236522198,
-0.0321379043,
-0.3935314715,
0.0007151066,
-0.6550355554,
-0.2107422501,
-0.0482941903,
-0.3220802248,
0.0175212063,
-0.0432428159,
0.5931099057,
0.5712526441,
-0.3954511881,
-0.18084611,
-0.6577587724,
0.7497394681,
-0.8092660904,
0.1431030035,
0.2027374953,
0.3900675178,
-0.4910368323,
-0.6926804781,
-0.3107515872,
-0.5329474807,
0.1298656166,
-0.1757740974,
-0.5503908992,
-0.0177371223,
0.2911675572,
0.4491191804,
-0.6147350669,
0.4441002607,
-0.1512331963,
-0.1131870076,
0.6631281376,
0.1316998899,
0.5272960663,
0.3391883671,
-0.4099435508,
-0.1280430257,
-0.8174045086,
-0.1978021562,
0.6416328549,
0.2573326826,
-0.1372722685,
0.620813787,
0.0675566941,
0.5290739536,
-0.2093518078,
-0.1793073118,
-0.2724062204,
-0.2004988194,
-0.3850872517,
-0.0437383838,
1.0426706076,
0.1665793359,
0.2272015959,
-0.3093602061,
-0.2038855702,
0.1010423824,
0.6552670002,
-0.6334798932,
-0.1150050983,
0.2339961678,
-0.2630798817,
-0.7252098918,
-0.0929187015,
-0.7917613387,
-0.6904731989,
0.3019903898,
0.3459053636,
-0.3301033974,
0.0039075497,
-0.0614966303,
0.19964616,
0.0326504633,
0.169099167,
-0.8376989365,
0.3860102594,
0.838888824,
0.7584220767,
-0.2375033498,
-0.2123108357,
-0.4861419201,
0.0713606179,
-0.4399764538,
0.5480330586,
-0.3741758466,
-0.346434623,
0.1898268014,
-0.2325202078,
0.2233204693,
-0.4196957052,
0.699747026,
-0.7261708379,
-0.0470439717,
0.1046396941,
-0.3184534013,
-0.0475404449,
0.6540714502,
-0.7363071442,
0.7540029883,
-0.0905155763,
-0.9172351956,
0.0441603176,
-0.5312930942,
-0.5350203514,
-0.1474430412,
0.0256481413,
-0.5893861651,
0.2196836919,
0.2654640377,
0.4815281034,
-0.3324634433,
-0.0015746319,
-0.8484134674,
-0.2172875851,
0.6223254204,
-0.9008472562,
0.8675871491,
0.1902442425,
-0.1262308657,
0.2911331058,
-0.9446724057,
-0.1879474074,
0.4343711138,
-0.2234374881,
-0.3250961006,
0.0953700915,
-0.1291529983,
-0.119974941,
0.2746672332,
-0.3801654875,
0.2552283406,
-0.5007023811,
0.6069869399,
0.7894263864,
-0.1381474286,
0.1921964288,
-0.0419608206,
0.6197630763,
-0.2722008824,
0.2008944154,
-0.0434697755,
-0.1079292893,
-0.6343411207,
-0.2866556048,
0.3683186471,
0.4423859119,
-0.5361683965,
0.3737680614,
-0.189839527,
-0.704164207,
-0.1988992095,
0.2133033127,
0.3474032581,
0.1644370705,
0.2270198613,
0.0609907731,
-0.2905251086,
-0.8335151672,
-0.3099170029,
-0.252530694,
-0.0285864938,
0.0137362452,
0.636115849,
-0.4654279947,
0.3610811234,
-0.4815867245,
0.0338917486,
-0.18496418,
-0.0768821388,
-0.106531322,
0.1445536017,
0.6444329619,
-0.6044515371,
-0.2440297455,
-0.0388991646,
-0.6275550127,
-0.0327790864,
0.1166831031,
0.022407664,
0.2457443923,
0.6994014978,
-0.4397442043,
0.3199497461,
0.7043993473,
-0.272913605,
0.4642615318,
-0.1365914792,
-0.1880001873,
-0.9584079385,
0.0148503603,
0.0236510299,
-0.1971586198,
-0.7570716739,
0.2121056467,
-0.056271892,
-0.0756487548,
-0.4666133821,
0.4018154442,
-0.1685027629,
-0.12605986,
-0.1821007878,
-0.0610114373,
-0.2118208408,
0.0661679506,
-0.4678867161,
0.6950999498,
0.4632552564,
-0.4924856424,
0.3546237946,
0.0276564732,
-0.2572885156,
0.4387606382,
-0.7213253975,
0.2819488049,
0.0746968985,
0.1816138625,
-0.9916585088,
-0.2218809128,
0.0772595853,
-0.5148956776,
0.5181984305,
0.0929804221,
-0.535587728,
-0.0485431626,
-0.5437005162,
0.2383447886,
0.2771451473,
-0.4663699567,
0.4671595693,
0.3412427008,
-0.1505064964,
-0.6083039045,
-0.5977481008,
0.4421264231,
-0.3913787603,
-0.5948626995,
0.1097176,
-0.1152084693,
-0.5628817677,
-0.2344347984,
-0.0307445414,
-0.1451703608,
0.8233646154,
0.1374842823,
0.1001871601,
-0.2558281422,
-0.2963930666,
-0.4197629094,
0.0508899093,
0.2220658809,
-0.0311329737,
0.4608458579,
-0.24365291,
-0.4120523036,
-0.2667268813,
-0.0209891759,
0.9896172881,
-0.3011320531,
0.8176900744,
0.6134775877,
-0.4784998,
-0.4257098138,
-0.33680287,
0.1259812564,
-0.4897423387,
0.7514134049,
-0.1780007184,
-0.8731927276,
0.3732488155,
0.2320508361,
0.1744695306,
0.5095862746,
0.6918241382,
0.1636026055,
1.0207715034,
0.6993120313,
-0.38073349,
0.3476770222,
-0.0004809386,
0.1885664761,
-0.6061900258,
-0.0664941669,
-0.7137927413,
-0.0674952492,
-0.5690783858,
-0.0375645235,
0.2662597001,
-0.0208867863,
-0.3279999197,
0.1663890183,
-0.1521294117,
0.2950357199,
0.3417433798,
-0.1567895859,
0.3596400619,
-0.0273573231,
0.115294978,
0.3014903069,
-0.466587007,
-0.9091469049,
1.3266913891,
0.7609121203,
0.9368698001,
0.4073164761,
0.3183623254,
0.3529695868,
0.4224047065,
-0.6695522666,
0.6070988178,
-0.3558968306,
-0.5227979422,
-0.4213567674,
-0.3118240833,
-0.891431272,
0.2104092389,
-0.3528448939,
-0.8404868841,
-0.3733902872,
-0.0229704678,
-0.3923206329,
0.5403683186,
-0.5987789631,
0.7147346139,
-0.5763411522,
-0.2401439995,
0.0247066449,
-0.4037679732,
0.5937494636,
-0.3141379058,
0.1481262445,
0.0247950293,
-0.3359560966,
0.4023649991,
-0.223053053,
0.8609205484,
0.329883635,
-0.3904038966,
-0.0741399303,
0.229669109,
0.5556309223,
0.1829425395,
-0.1674497575,
0.3562674522,
-0.1752904952,
-0.4170477986,
-0.5621958375,
0.8115518689,
-0.8036304116,
-0.6838209629,
-0.4662799537,
-0.6077608466,
-0.3511628211,
0.3137717545,
0.1991445422,
0.2509630024,
-0.5305375457,
0.51813972,
0.7878344059,
-0.3633605242,
0.4859062731,
0.4052443206,
0.0886828899,
-0.5674890876,
0.7010016441,
0.0496652648,
0.5894883871,
0.5252267718,
0.0470787808,
-0.1218136624,
-1.1461299658,
-0.4437054694,
-0.1855171323,
-0.5923517942,
-0.235066846,
-0.3989195526,
-0.2111338973,
-0.4020670354,
-0.1597637236,
-0.5118959546,
-0.0054010851,
-0.3131423295,
0.0216941368,
0.1246171147,
1.0521024466,
0.7117844224,
0.2306328565,
-0.6077498198,
0.2048927248,
0.3827980757,
0.3387313485,
-0.1532693803,
-0.4638149142,
-0.0567792058,
-0.0926457644,
-0.461455375,
-0.7116008401,
0.2401707619,
-0.0352731906,
0.4957455993,
0.4720513225,
0.1878499985,
0.2370109856,
-0.5122025609,
0.8847949505,
0.0775099918,
-0.7254786491,
0.3862581253,
-0.4196507633,
0.2972600162,
0.3423822224,
0.137267217,
-0.0456436612,
-0.5933797359,
-0.7049295306,
-0.6844826341,
0.503158927,
0.3347321153,
0.0218200926,
0.1952597201,
0.2015818059,
0.0133984191,
0.133638978,
-0.8110349774,
-0.3568471372,
-0.1723780781,
-0.3363082409,
-0.2991956174,
-0.3780906498,
-0.2392554283,
0.2896400094,
0.5870057344,
-0.1027949303,
-0.0390776433,
-0.0504315607,
-0.1403318793,
0.0356113203,
0.5188764334,
0.7505223751,
0.4602151513,
-0.0779832229,
0.4175294638,
0.562679708,
-0.490295589,
0.1555923969,
0.1368344724,
-0.3868468702,
-0.3836935461,
0.8288218379,
0.6646231413,
0.1738420278,
-0.635358572,
0.3840470612,
-0.357761234,
-0.0609454215,
-0.2127553523,
0.1468303353,
-0.1086915731,
0.2736717165,
0.1501905769,
0.0576588139,
-0.0705416873,
-0.6156847477,
-0.1698992699,
0.8595479727,
-0.3523658216,
-0.2926497459,
0.6296627522,
-0.0178381559,
-0.3713737726,
0.0437887348,
0.161320284,
-0.6939982772,
0.5905616879,
0.6399073005,
0.9575579166,
-0.070010148,
-0.187871635,
-0.0895841196,
0.8362995982,
-0.1459666491,
-0.2873975635,
0.2256982327,
-0.5077531934,
-0.1085090637,
-0.5554019809,
-0.5296896696,
0.5868459344,
-0.4640488029,
0.2039454579,
-0.7538624406,
-0.164668873,
0.009403972,
0.0142326886,
-0.1945510358,
0.1390636116,
0.485809058,
0.9455266595,
-0.5926413536,
0.6757715344,
0.8598056436,
-0.0742491409,
-0.3861805201,
0.3224675059,
0.167821452,
-0.586931169,
0.3958874047,
-0.0005922731,
-0.165616855,
-0.395378828,
-0.5884379745,
-0.8896182775,
0.9481998086,
0.7912212014,
-0.4240094423,
0.2673917413,
0.1326282322,
0.630715847,
-0.0297672004,
0.1950908452,
0.5971627235,
0.2728737295,
-0.1596996784,
-0.8172120452,
0.0580516756,
-0.1777548045,
0.0832512081,
0.2728980184,
-0.8398740888,
0.5709290504,
-0.0425668284,
-0.1579450667,
0.139348194,
0.7297000289,
0.1187616363,
0.0717296526,
0.5385732651,
0.6210603118,
0.7166799307,
-0.0795627162,
1.1633892059,
-0.2572680414,
0.0897304565,
0.8855356574,
-0.2027393579,
0.9394533038,
0.2645333409,
-0.3632535934,
0.0413744897,
0.3307647109,
-0.1090778783,
0.3204717934,
0.3657422662,
-0.0989062339,
-0.0612210706,
0.0897183716,
-0.2894637287,
0.3933804631,
0.2952961922,
-0.2593134344,
-0.1001822799,
-0.0776061937,
0.2926769257,
0.1603752375,
-0.4547235668,
0.7035089731,
0.1586866379,
-0.477895081,
0.609885931,
0.0576019287,
0.750755012,
-0.6354482174,
0.2140420079,
-0.0027579209,
0.5327633023,
-0.1604677439,
-0.6778278947,
0.1724141538,
0.3223464489,
0.0578657575,
0.130045414,
0.790116787,
-0.1256303191,
-0.5626891255,
0.3123602867,
0.0014140519,
-0.2970592976,
0.1075158268,
-0.5193654895,
0.5186610222,
-0.0946900472,
-0.3734174967,
0.5698618293,
0.2727734149,
0.0055506872,
1.0114861727,
0.6219193935,
0.2509501576,
0.0763879567,
-0.1043559462,
0.7306489348,
-0.4820438623,
-0.1595730931,
-1.2921726704,
0.2076064497,
-0.0532608218,
-0.324534446,
1.0466947556,
0.3162299693,
0.8193636537,
0.2515735626,
0.84772861,
0.3192573786,
0.1498849243,
-0.5622102618,
0.8473422527,
-0.3884034455,
0.7162145972,
-0.3029156923,
-0.6771458387,
-0.5629813075,
0.1664343029,
-0.2617665827,
-0.1154445112,
0.5004029274,
0.6711382866,
0.1568685621,
-0.0848433524,
0.4170420766,
0.5708791018,
0.6276553273,
0.460776031,
0.9156528115,
-0.403429836,
0.8286116123,
-0.1628510356,
-0.1161263362,
-0.2042512,
-1.0035502911,
-1.283203125,
-0.1203045323,
-0.3020050526,
-0.4484722018,
0.2735174596,
0.6255017519,
0.3552610576,
-0.8296564221,
0.0159105174,
0.036959447,
0.2725396752,
0.0993514955,
-0.1463998705,
0.3742506504,
-0.2375155091,
-0.5842957497,
0.465829581,
0.3120133579,
0.1219953075,
-0.6676588655,
0.10116864,
0.0955970734,
0.1470160335,
0.6529285908,
0.1363375783,
-0.7835097313,
-0.2526485324,
-0.1207718849,
-0.3034076393,
-0.2227911651,
0.3727468848,
-0.2625609636,
0.2973196208,
0.3019604683,
0.9866828918,
-0.0797240362,
-0.0742519945,
0.7071227431,
-0.4149778485,
0.0312245432,
0.2000633627,
0.4337878227,
0.3402953148,
-0.3498906493,
0.3681041002,
-0.108633168,
-0.4999826252,
-1.1959741116,
0.1137174144,
-0.7899327278,
-0.3176429272,
1.3036583662,
-0.1797312051,
-0.3357191384,
-0.055810377,
-0.1326599717,
0.0680953935,
-0.2298634946,
0.7721946239,
0.8531599045,
0.4401393831,
0.1066600233,
-0.7797285914,
0.2894496322,
0.191925168,
-0.8891534209,
0.1390585899,
0.2061989605,
0.2107445598,
0.1380295008,
0.1380912066,
-0.2048189342,
0.026857052,
-0.0285727847,
-0.2963424027,
-0.2762754858,
-0.2456186265,
-0.6816262603,
0.5301789641,
0.3861573935,
-0.0171388797
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06676v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06676v1
|
EDA Corpus: A Large Language Model Dataset for Enhanced Interaction with OpenROAD
| 2024-05-04T21:29:37 | 2024-05-04T21:29:37 |
Bing-Yue Wu, Utsav Sharma, Sai Rahul Dhanvi Kankipati, Ajay Yadav, Bintu Kappil George, Sai Ritish Guntupalli, Austin Rovinski, Vidya A. Chhabria
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.AR
|
Large language models (LLMs) serve as powerful tools for design, providing
capabilities for both task automation and design assistance. Recent
advancements have shown tremendous potential for facilitating LLM integration
into the chip design process; however, many of these works rely on data that
are not publicly available and/or not permissively licensed for use in LLM
training and distribution. In this paper, we present a solution aimed at
bridging this gap by introducing an open-source dataset tailored for OpenROAD,
a widely adopted open-source EDA toolchain. The dataset features over 1000 data
points and is structured in two formats: (i) a pairwise set comprised of
question prompts with prose answers, and (ii) a pairwise set comprised of code
prompts and their corresponding OpenROAD scripts. By providing this dataset, we
aim to facilitate LLM-focused research within the EDA domain. The dataset is
available at https://github.com/OpenROAD-Assistant/EDA-Corpus.
|
[
-0.3789173663,
-0.7298054695,
0.7365517616,
0.238695994,
-0.1121825203,
0.1919844896,
-0.4594828188,
-0.4213169813,
0.4832787514,
0.6253070235,
-0.2966946363,
-1.0182855129,
-0.1448533982,
-0.1636653543,
-0.2476330101,
0.7183607221,
-0.455068469,
-0.0825364217,
-0.491684556,
-0.1421628743,
-0.4033534527,
-0.251600951,
-0.1135800183,
0.1716885269,
0.6025188565,
0.5623701215,
0.5048475862,
0.6641694307,
0.4048784077,
0.1019122973,
0.1393987983,
0.1394771636,
-0.3189201653,
0.0963324457,
-0.2134294063,
-0.0833757967,
-0.7540521026,
0.0869892985,
0.573310256,
0.6803843975,
-0.126653105,
0.4462048113,
-0.040672332,
0.1705893427,
-0.4801169932,
0.3073907197,
-0.5337118506,
-0.4005511701,
-0.5662133694,
-0.0675611123,
-0.4152165055,
-0.6392219067,
-0.3460819721,
-0.8104860187,
-0.1903494745,
-0.1012849659,
0.5402109623,
0.1897909045,
0.0515248589,
-0.5005788207,
-0.9083933234,
0.5852733254,
-0.5576679111,
0.4022472501,
0.5525726676,
0.1733769178,
-0.1859256923,
-0.5763123631,
-0.5595130324,
0.0215846412,
0.2180218548,
-0.0149535798,
-0.3208569884,
-0.0081552006,
0.0097261742,
0.2681565881,
-0.5854534507,
0.5146507025,
-0.4911879897,
0.0624835119,
0.3721504807,
0.0981369913,
0.323420018,
-0.0016242347,
-0.3819000125,
-0.1320601702,
-1.1420035362,
0.0418768488,
0.6603696346,
0.577917397,
-0.1976714432,
0.7414139509,
-0.0641469732,
0.773237884,
-0.3842391372,
0.2559730113,
0.4948345423,
-0.1483299881,
-0.1340222657,
0.0146177812,
0.9242678285,
0.1404492557,
0.1815042943,
-0.1152806431,
-0.339210242,
-0.2079117298,
0.1093252748,
-0.7453556657,
-0.1827118993,
0.6542881131,
-0.1281137764,
-0.1490698308,
0.2730304301,
-1.0612950325,
-0.2868496478,
-0.4042916894,
-0.0760797039,
-0.1725834459,
-0.3124848604,
0.1165839657,
0.0520368218,
0.2781581283,
0.0125076016,
-0.7239784002,
0.1230840683,
0.9183833599,
0.9767403603,
-0.084882848,
-0.0609015934,
-0.5709305406,
0.3671572506,
-0.5717280507,
0.821028173,
-0.930459559,
-0.3951768577,
0.3221660852,
-0.0702407509,
0.1284120828,
-0.6179139018,
0.5862750411,
-0.9140505195,
-0.1345419586,
-0.027470313,
-0.2061671764,
0.0245038345,
-0.0535490736,
-0.9007917643,
1.0859391689,
0.1216779798,
-0.5875256062,
0.0926359296,
-0.8454581499,
-0.391549319,
0.3190980852,
-0.6660427451,
0.0297459979,
-0.0045670546,
0.159312889,
0.2484759539,
-0.3427070677,
0.4501776695,
-0.537065208,
-0.2152600139,
0.1498853862,
-0.102201283,
0.9591144919,
0.2972355187,
0.1502083093,
0.3998705745,
-0.9094862938,
-0.0977944583,
0.1464170367,
-0.403801173,
-0.755769074,
-0.1754731387,
0.080747582,
0.1315464675,
0.4260835648,
-0.9670475125,
0.2818408012,
-0.2446738333,
0.3539979458,
0.9878821969,
-0.3062210381,
0.2195600718,
0.0341046005,
0.779004097,
-0.0984327197,
-0.1035139263,
-0.0479483753,
-0.5607099533,
-0.3031119406,
-0.5048601627,
0.3235244751,
0.5547901392,
-0.798011601,
0.4146188498,
-0.3639858365,
-0.3516663015,
-0.944709003,
0.1886308938,
0.2463399172,
0.4005229473,
0.2589491904,
0.1035112217,
-0.5585231185,
-0.8991320729,
0.323808521,
-0.1640882045,
-0.5204054117,
0.4509992003,
0.3360588849,
-0.1072760522,
1.2407964468,
-0.8797982931,
-0.37177369,
-0.1024917215,
0.0707088187,
0.2524732649,
0.3208542764,
0.6767064333,
-0.2681356072,
-0.3165322244,
0.0602104031,
-0.6898790598,
-0.5091984272,
0.2653301358,
-0.3594374061,
0.0266701225,
0.5967742205,
-0.4064623713,
0.1194216982,
0.917707324,
-0.1521421522,
0.198299244,
-0.2088905126,
-0.0007155981,
-1.3957169056,
0.3548602164,
-0.116099827,
-0.0188220348,
-0.3691762984,
0.133455053,
0.1396621615,
-0.1603573412,
-0.5184397697,
0.5506958365,
-0.1991678774,
-0.2608526051,
-0.1383583248,
0.4655109346,
-0.0943889543,
0.2546980381,
0.0065123653,
1.233543992,
0.5554469228,
-0.3841891289,
0.3707310259,
0.7325645685,
-0.4880635142,
0.3995736837,
-0.9740621448,
0.4546112716,
-0.071124427,
-0.0708775893,
-0.7487722039,
-0.3229072094,
0.2921730876,
-0.2339555174,
-0.1025288105,
-0.020189289,
-0.791162014,
-0.1992328316,
-0.483142823,
0.5105928183,
0.4569100142,
-0.9582226276,
0.385738343,
0.8408339024,
-0.4855302274,
-0.1583347172,
-0.4405153394,
-0.0734830573,
0.0417695791,
-0.7664375901,
0.5732621551,
-0.3770168424,
-0.4860457778,
0.0315372013,
0.6264532208,
-0.1623324156,
-0.1802735031,
0.4700479209,
0.5163097978,
-0.2897130847,
0.4552263319,
0.1392627656,
0.0047982228,
0.0930997282,
-0.138315931,
0.7052419186,
0.1058948413,
-0.3828218281,
-0.0038515818,
0.3981747031,
0.4482573569,
-0.5596821904,
0.5935220122,
0.0923316628,
-0.4702824652,
-0.5447570086,
0.0931275263,
0.2396965027,
-0.5328195691,
0.09492746,
-0.4366102219,
-0.8620476127,
0.5577223897,
-0.0508700088,
0.4098542035,
0.3137273788,
0.6345506907,
-0.0471449383,
0.6551838517,
0.7955973744,
-0.0983720571,
0.4044852853,
0.0544268712,
0.0646980479,
-0.935739398,
-0.2995559871,
-0.6878585219,
-0.275788337,
-0.2854441702,
-0.5878992081,
0.1915515959,
-0.1654234678,
-0.0733779445,
0.2905750871,
-0.2903147042,
0.5462687612,
0.5537651777,
-0.004918349,
0.453951329,
0.0801135227,
-0.1796466559,
0.2797067761,
-0.5829768181,
-0.7829523087,
1.1392599344,
0.477366209,
0.9666875601,
0.2244719118,
0.399307698,
0.0199150294,
0.2180965841,
-0.6537264585,
0.6638031006,
-0.1989438087,
-0.4806929231,
-0.2535457313,
-0.2963656485,
-0.9941577315,
-0.4588744044,
0.157904163,
-0.3684365153,
0.1413951218,
-0.1443999857,
-0.5949227214,
0.3956544995,
-0.2404536009,
0.688719511,
-0.1395507902,
-0.2525377572,
-0.0665603727,
-0.2523065805,
0.3394826651,
-0.3180435598,
0.4126290083,
-0.128856495,
-0.1381367445,
1.0444680452,
-0.2701277733,
0.9463701844,
0.0223663114,
-0.5698800087,
0.5113860369,
-0.0861476362,
0.4889768064,
0.0330643579,
-0.201943621,
0.1566183567,
-0.2943748534,
-0.2000110298,
-0.1312381923,
1.1292852163,
-0.8447833061,
-0.2271785587,
-0.1225230172,
-0.7236549854,
-0.2492390871,
0.06035579,
-0.1594235301,
0.5911135077,
-0.4148111045,
0.1785195768,
0.8136358261,
-0.6274815798,
0.5012364984,
0.566036284,
-0.5635169744,
-0.4734943211,
0.8817560673,
0.0082953973,
0.2716486752,
0.0985562578,
-0.0048883399,
-0.1923555583,
-0.5563060045,
-0.7701597214,
0.2927612662,
-0.8813875914,
-0.1099032983,
-0.4993506968,
-0.0374213234,
-0.5697308183,
-0.1215149164,
-0.1611699164,
-0.3301953077,
-0.48508811,
-0.4588284492,
0.8801457286,
1.0834213495,
0.0365670249,
0.1166499183,
-0.7308924198,
0.2883784771,
-0.0376024321,
0.9982402921,
-0.1716617644,
-0.3565350473,
-0.218920961,
-0.0980027542,
0.0457192622,
-0.7520968318,
0.1905155927,
-0.0395359881,
0.5556022525,
0.2463498712,
0.2461083829,
0.2317443192,
-0.4960426688,
0.6199519634,
-0.1762757003,
-0.5573354363,
0.5943695903,
-0.576038599,
0.1681721658,
0.581084013,
0.6032443047,
-0.3457517624,
-0.2498446852,
-0.3265163004,
-0.8991314769,
0.5853285193,
-0.0808107555,
0.1734335274,
-0.1440912038,
0.1194620058,
0.4097270668,
0.1931252778,
-0.1825138927,
-0.0689273849,
0.0282677356,
-0.6545677781,
0.0884267241,
-0.0166405495,
-0.3839451969,
-0.0499405563,
0.6169587374,
-0.1417926848,
0.1101718619,
-0.2024725825,
-0.0554412194,
-0.1386247277,
0.2173852175,
0.6273094416,
0.7807713747,
-0.2922307849,
0.2424257696,
-0.2346488684,
-0.5941202044,
-0.1083728522,
0.2362464815,
-0.4488031864,
-0.0068820277,
0.1104188412,
0.5277468562,
-0.0838265568,
-1.1061627865,
0.408095926,
0.1695785522,
-0.0570801981,
-0.4267651737,
-0.3651910722,
0.1186474562,
0.2043545395,
0.1493588686,
-0.6080616713,
-0.1514413059,
-0.3934984207,
0.4246432185,
0.4123345912,
-0.5283102989,
-0.4908679426,
0.672693491,
0.4603382349,
-0.3726270497,
0.7415232658,
-0.1281131804,
-0.1114054099,
0.6314088106,
0.4023519754,
0.964243412,
-0.1159037873,
0.3237560093,
0.2924194932,
0.29475227,
0.4459942579,
0.7005440593,
0.4888809025,
-0.5403953791,
-0.4573597014,
-0.7303168178,
-0.5250871181,
0.3308731019,
-0.3848768175,
0.5704451203,
-0.7165178061,
0.1704318076,
-0.1932542473,
-0.6348000765,
-0.54678303,
-0.1989396811,
-0.0335824117,
1.0076990128,
-0.7157934308,
0.9638487697,
0.8113346696,
-0.7859101295,
-0.5767990351,
-0.1645759195,
-0.1993486732,
-0.8959413767,
0.5919492245,
-0.0889511406,
-0.1112077087,
0.058006335,
-0.5088751912,
-0.7425171733,
1.1594839096,
0.3135766685,
-0.5984456539,
0.1691338271,
0.3854911327,
0.3061101735,
-0.5968843102,
0.0707587376,
0.4314469695,
0.368740201,
0.1441086382,
-0.8243796825,
0.1497197002,
-0.1462406218,
-0.350595504,
0.41203022,
-0.538908124,
0.8491716385,
-0.1387441307,
-0.1685542613,
-0.0223467276,
0.6505544186,
0.3250423968,
0.1936938614,
0.2768732607,
0.4746084213,
0.7487545013,
0.1580249369,
0.6850001812,
-0.5950417519,
0.0301585887,
1.2872650623,
-0.5188270211,
1.3655189276,
0.4550827742,
-0.1451385021,
0.5035021901,
0.5181283951,
0.1444083154,
0.4114673436,
0.2247173935,
-0.3016320765,
0.0714961812,
-0.4357216358,
-0.3610694408,
0.228732571,
0.3028824627,
-0.4999116957,
-0.2419378757,
0.13573578,
-0.0559383258,
0.1977216005,
-0.3080436289,
0.6762039065,
-0.0205578357,
-0.2035451829,
0.1003089547,
0.034628883,
0.5406086445,
-0.4864169359,
-0.2412635237,
-0.1566297859,
0.0401496813,
-0.1474501193,
-1.2507441044,
0.4327486455,
0.2521676719,
-0.1089654416,
-0.4278065562,
0.5836175084,
-0.5630308986,
-0.4842327535,
0.4291535616,
0.5515500307,
0.2975528836,
0.08804515,
0.018362822,
0.4687059224,
-0.3521905243,
-0.0729169324,
0.35159114,
0.3529110253,
-0.1094785035,
0.3858900666,
0.6343668103,
0.1121395007,
-0.0225523114,
0.1345186085,
1.1906219721,
-0.6661043167,
-0.364238888,
-0.5007021427,
0.2766206861,
-0.0035517847,
-0.3766693771,
0.51536268,
0.8225044608,
0.9365736246,
-0.1847902238,
1.0221371651,
-0.1499118209,
0.7165065408,
-0.6501550078,
0.6545577049,
-0.1703364849,
0.4561819732,
-0.0457441397,
-0.7866027951,
-0.1770464629,
0.2019014657,
-0.2751184106,
-0.1579268724,
0.3654008508,
0.9123305678,
-0.2110940218,
0.0657619536,
0.1263578236,
0.0289029051,
0.5202077031,
0.5946702361,
0.6259524226,
0.0177795198,
0.5991629958,
-0.1105432138,
-0.5897420049,
-0.1064531058,
-0.9053510427,
-0.8549540043,
-0.6266492009,
-0.1675604433,
-0.1300134063,
-0.1622278541,
1.161907196,
0.2996816039,
-0.7918639779,
-0.3651541173,
0.0558647998,
-0.0758873448,
0.1354785115,
-0.1402803063,
0.3637990654,
0.0887036175,
-0.788962543,
0.7859782577,
0.1627856195,
0.0112515455,
-0.6728894114,
0.0168876555,
-0.1269344687,
0.2992679775,
0.6511127949,
0.2331127971,
-0.4140661955,
-0.3050126433,
0.3073386252,
-0.1939390153,
0.2087437212,
0.9885693192,
-0.8198060989,
0.3415437341,
0.7245407701,
0.8388292789,
-0.112550199,
0.0175412614,
0.7697808743,
-0.8392440677,
0.0470198132,
0.1062845811,
0.2009254843,
0.1845786721,
-0.0920651183,
0.4547152817,
-0.0695013702,
-0.3970380723,
-0.7092530131,
0.2989925742,
-1.001548171,
-0.3293373883,
1.3170195818,
-0.102952905,
-0.1657319516,
-0.2464912981,
-0.2463399172,
0.0571847931,
-0.6278935671,
0.3887860179,
0.6160796285,
0.0326975435,
0.0176734496,
-0.9041464329,
0.3302132487,
-0.198667407,
-1.2510485649,
0.5747876167,
0.6962136626,
0.1026701331,
0.1745466888,
0.5374959111,
-0.2232274264,
-0.0875244513,
-0.1327405125,
0.3390373886,
-0.418179512,
-0.6982315183,
-0.5538061261,
0.3343289495,
0.3058171272,
-0.5016036034
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02750v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02750v1
|
Enhancing Contextual Understanding in Large Language Models through Contrastive Decoding
| 2024-05-04T20:38:41 | 2024-05-04T20:38:41 |
Zheng Zhao, Emilio Monti, Jens Lehmann, Haytham Assem
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large language models (LLMs) tend to inadequately integrate input context
during text generation, relying excessively on encoded prior knowledge in model
parameters, potentially resulting in generated text with factual
inconsistencies or contextually unfaithful content. LLMs utilize two primary
knowledge sources: 1) prior (parametric) knowledge from pretraining, and 2)
contextual (non-parametric) knowledge from input prompts. The study addresses
the open question of how LLMs effectively balance these knowledge sources
during the generation process, specifically in the context of open-domain
question answering. To address this issue, we introduce a novel approach
integrating contrastive decoding with adversarial irrelevant passages as
negative samples to enhance robust context grounding during generation.
Notably, our method operates at inference time without requiring further
training. We conduct comprehensive experiments to demonstrate its applicability
and effectiveness, providing empirical evidence showcasing its superiority over
existing methodologies. Our code is publicly available at:
https://github.com/amazon-science/ContextualUnderstanding-ContrastiveDecoding.
|
[
-0.4907820225,
-0.7895979285,
0.6435644627,
0.0373301283,
-0.5332629085,
-0.3447531462,
-0.3113382757,
-0.2273000181,
-0.2735877037,
0.5257538557,
-0.3507466316,
-0.4488925338,
-0.4535308778,
-0.0802925527,
-0.1759662032,
1.0144783258,
-0.0432052985,
0.15672566,
-0.5633936524,
-0.3833906651,
-0.4409772456,
-0.4919469059,
-0.6822843552,
-0.4840893447,
0.3569271863,
0.1953334957,
0.6089350581,
0.4006530643,
0.0121285543,
0.179531619,
-0.299331665,
0.2032842189,
-0.708362937,
0.1833008677,
-0.5151761174,
-0.3298891485,
-0.0867852494,
-0.1108145118,
0.5073844194,
0.906095922,
0.0344273932,
-0.1113898307,
0.3568795025,
0.3674519956,
-1.0341384411,
-0.0190480947,
-0.8209080696,
-0.139192611,
0.0433274992,
-0.6179759502,
-0.5263513923,
-0.0057827611,
0.1115046367,
-0.675275445,
0.2916792333,
-0.2870794237,
0.6053492427,
0.2926989198,
-0.6094852686,
-0.4544667006,
-0.5244232416,
0.7857653499,
-0.8737080693,
0.2259739637,
0.3093626499,
0.0270167328,
-0.0550250672,
-0.4863639176,
-0.69231534,
-0.0205537733,
-0.3188175261,
0.2348300219,
-0.0616632253,
0.0078999065,
0.0806833506,
0.3662157059,
-0.453615725,
0.0967005938,
-0.038231682,
-0.0814640671,
0.1399093866,
0.1219767109,
0.3059939146,
-0.0122910105,
-0.2601403296,
-0.0736333579,
-0.8064881563,
0.0413140021,
0.1583422571,
0.3901382685,
-0.2473243326,
0.4012552798,
-0.1815553159,
0.8956810236,
0.2160720527,
0.1724183261,
0.1216238365,
-0.4328031838,
-0.2888334394,
-0.0718307942,
0.5352579951,
0.404384762,
0.01313903,
-0.3090672791,
-0.125332281,
0.045014739,
0.2292862833,
-0.9952582121,
-0.1516165733,
0.2828514278,
-0.2394493222,
-0.3844609857,
-0.0512934774,
-0.7438526154,
-0.625477612,
-0.3557688892,
0.4579187334,
-0.450203985,
-0.044572629,
0.055947274,
-0.1681875437,
0.5232465267,
0.4452134073,
-0.7002075315,
0.1114535779,
0.4482291639,
0.5716280937,
0.0374968238,
-0.1865013838,
-0.8571152687,
0.2372908592,
-0.413395375,
0.5662362576,
-0.3806208372,
-0.2460688204,
0.0873491019,
-0.1460576206,
-0.0282799918,
-0.5985434651,
0.6204783916,
-1.0683158636,
0.3265909553,
-0.2066272497,
-0.4387875795,
-0.1278415173,
0.3844776452,
-0.4487012923,
0.6036961079,
-0.035928186,
-0.9918379188,
0.1704850197,
-0.3288786113,
-0.6625443697,
0.0211803373,
-0.3804633021,
-0.2132522762,
0.2086260617,
0.6502272487,
0.486448139,
-0.3307948411,
0.4424010217,
-0.3261217177,
-0.3772972524,
0.2633184195,
-0.4745049179,
0.8173655868,
0.3138936162,
-0.4518727064,
0.0757177919,
-0.6725119948,
-0.1724865735,
0.3880375326,
-0.3124505281,
-0.6539489627,
-0.0426734276,
-0.1263231933,
0.2975741923,
0.1115094423,
-0.2666628957,
-0.2368736118,
-0.5009351373,
0.4170992374,
0.6019229293,
0.1157688424,
0.5787168145,
-0.1376239806,
0.3625585437,
0.3532473445,
-0.463044554,
-0.4980985224,
-0.0634306073,
-0.7141076326,
0.0182309411,
0.1829243004,
0.4307945669,
-1.0793932676,
0.4558216929,
-0.1345719099,
-0.0501130112,
-0.2455039322,
0.2499577254,
0.4701368809,
1.0558770895,
0.6275016069,
0.1633738875,
-0.5689276457,
-0.736764729,
-0.079026103,
0.1674029827,
-0.358230412,
0.5494567752,
0.4038797617,
-0.2635887265,
0.864182055,
-0.6092916131,
0.0504799262,
-0.207683742,
0.156588912,
0.0854942128,
0.510221839,
0.4875923693,
-0.8595893383,
-0.2470274717,
-0.0702764168,
-0.9719429612,
-0.1788538843,
-0.114370428,
-0.3388429284,
0.0434654318,
0.8328774571,
-0.5207266808,
0.0639164299,
0.6869710088,
-0.4803205431,
0.2759869993,
-0.1888997108,
0.1827575564,
-1.2905590534,
0.394695729,
-0.0985673144,
-0.1353825182,
-0.7600051165,
0.3479183018,
0.1864130646,
-0.1957143694,
-0.3304697573,
0.7077302933,
-0.4415233731,
0.1521515697,
-0.4009107351,
0.4646567702,
0.3826628625,
0.3898472786,
0.1141475439,
0.9914000034,
0.2928547263,
-0.716770649,
-0.0251214523,
0.250736475,
-0.3740444183,
0.6447417736,
-0.5728254914,
0.0725954026,
-0.4018538594,
0.4842269719,
-1.1759181023,
-0.1796303242,
0.2510078549,
-0.4568058848,
0.3606601357,
-0.0961259231,
-0.1822257489,
0.1073935479,
-0.2046882808,
0.7610139847,
0.5366663933,
-0.8539410233,
0.4376326203,
0.1999741495,
-0.2507924139,
-0.585950911,
-0.731300056,
0.1124046296,
-0.3441843092,
-0.5018225908,
0.4418018162,
-0.0862726122,
-0.3277468383,
-0.0267868061,
-0.1801925898,
-0.0775272101,
0.2878669202,
-0.1902660578,
0.0949462876,
-0.5288410783,
0.0508267805,
0.0905627981,
0.0250685178,
0.2097559422,
-0.4567038715,
0.5952521563,
0.206720829,
-0.1960822642,
-0.2206111848,
0.3668588102,
0.5785040855,
-0.2651540935,
1.0615253448,
0.4496966004,
-0.2988132536,
-0.3954417109,
-0.3941461742,
-0.1164946407,
-0.4451462626,
0.2383105457,
-0.3732774854,
-0.8463125825,
0.6184590459,
0.1019336656,
-0.1779949814,
0.3064174056,
0.4791102111,
-0.0198493581,
0.8958047032,
0.2209255248,
0.0899293423,
0.4858494997,
-0.0478088669,
0.0707221702,
-0.9838576317,
-0.0286239181,
-0.3707205951,
0.0183481351,
-0.1112986729,
-0.5780562162,
0.2028921545,
0.5312700868,
-0.2085695565,
-0.1488781869,
0.0042465357,
0.5663465261,
0.4826189876,
0.407545805,
0.160731256,
-0.095936209,
-0.1684887707,
0.0585122406,
-0.7055583,
-0.422154367,
1.0747275352,
0.1217540801,
0.65065974,
0.0817322806,
0.4514554739,
-0.0095200082,
0.3158998191,
-0.5758168101,
0.366595149,
-0.1794892699,
-0.4280137718,
-0.2466500849,
-0.5591850281,
-0.8833492994,
0.5745456815,
-0.1374734193,
-0.3496812284,
0.1273884475,
0.3606160879,
-0.3820154965,
0.2433754504,
-0.6072531939,
0.9671364427,
-0.0111943893,
-0.6648739576,
0.0452453271,
-0.6437032819,
0.4992910922,
0.0459023528,
0.2554000318,
0.482581526,
-0.0058384589,
0.5052187443,
-0.2278808951,
0.8108127713,
-0.3271120489,
-0.5214205384,
0.2734670639,
0.0383896194,
0.5809904337,
0.2384388894,
-0.1442957371,
-0.0167723913,
-0.43944785,
-0.5905985236,
-0.699826777,
0.8259465098,
-0.7200462222,
-0.5826937556,
-0.0705123469,
-0.6417455077,
-0.4330178499,
0.2291640043,
0.4325149357,
0.5949980021,
-0.2614899576,
0.5028360486,
1.0524727106,
-0.5321429372,
0.1298790872,
0.5569624305,
0.2449231595,
-0.5292159319,
0.8104371428,
-0.3337746859,
0.3693203926,
0.6670879126,
0.2155060619,
-0.3738436103,
-0.9077168107,
-0.3952122331,
0.1227487847,
-1.0199326277,
-0.1626587212,
-0.6958133578,
-0.0525123514,
-0.5701192617,
-0.371312052,
-0.0517914109,
0.1276908964,
-0.5201373696,
-0.0734517723,
-0.2441328168,
0.3823404312,
0.2327545732,
0.3269248903,
-0.7005977631,
0.5598551631,
0.3617084324,
0.1088441387,
0.144103691,
-0.6690593362,
-0.286476016,
0.2065465599,
-0.1755945683,
-0.7996085286,
0.1669948846,
-0.0753735155,
0.6452490687,
0.4387723505,
0.3844044507,
0.6401518583,
-0.3897809982,
0.8451442719,
-0.0196490251,
-1.0492303371,
0.4681304097,
-0.5848067999,
0.6944566369,
0.6699635983,
0.2471134216,
-0.2914350033,
-0.3915892541,
-0.3200916648,
-1.0079506636,
0.8666013479,
0.2612125278,
0.2454381436,
-0.0732890368,
0.3760638535,
0.0827133879,
0.2382549793,
-0.8770594001,
-0.1791317463,
-0.2711579204,
-0.2582935691,
-0.6082476974,
-0.4025973082,
-0.4541022182,
0.0879146755,
0.5792664289,
-0.2064946443,
-0.0344891846,
0.1957972795,
-0.4350169301,
0.0233715847,
0.4655764103,
0.8742529154,
0.7109273076,
-0.1316150427,
0.5392003655,
0.2804141045,
-0.1137411222,
-0.020074755,
0.1345970929,
-0.2677499652,
-0.2585369349,
0.5474374294,
0.7731136084,
0.2489315569,
-0.6077280641,
0.6143784523,
-0.0670316815,
-0.3138613701,
0.0038103242,
-0.0774457231,
0.1843234748,
0.2329423279,
0.2703469694,
-0.0421250053,
0.0121167656,
-0.3790807426,
0.1270566434,
0.5217190385,
-0.1817679107,
-0.2036876827,
0.6445044279,
0.4081580341,
0.1494455934,
0.4731029868,
-0.1097308621,
-0.3963112533,
0.6079897285,
0.7969881892,
0.7922317982,
-0.0652310401,
-0.0451705419,
0.2199186832,
0.0460141264,
0.2041692585,
-0.0570072457,
-0.3977831304,
-0.9265801311,
-0.4036880434,
-0.567874074,
-0.3950169384,
0.735611558,
-0.6957758665,
0.1303582639,
-0.2534084618,
0.4397112429,
-0.1802766621,
-0.3270325065,
-0.5615657568,
0.5110126138,
0.3120584786,
0.654512465,
-0.8910554647,
0.6639742851,
0.7962466478,
-0.2615101337,
-0.3591800332,
0.5940204263,
-0.260672152,
-0.71852386,
0.6191925406,
0.2646105289,
-0.3450758159,
0.0343375057,
-0.4400169253,
-0.589858532,
0.9524176717,
0.4904227555,
-0.1204003245,
-0.0208935272,
-0.0974383429,
0.5413390994,
-0.384986937,
0.1587109268,
0.4095481634,
0.1682972014,
0.2948713303,
-0.2224228829,
0.4562261105,
-0.3717190921,
0.037069127,
0.1157207862,
-0.2557642162,
0.9245095849,
-0.0772201717,
-0.3674528301,
0.0664634928,
0.5599616766,
0.3063254058,
0.3388073146,
0.4799619019,
0.5990670919,
0.4861246645,
0.2178969532,
0.9792086482,
-0.5625459552,
0.1430382282,
1.3623164892,
-0.2126616538,
0.675758183,
0.6316969991,
0.1719268858,
0.2940514684,
0.4749492407,
0.4006925225,
0.7436271906,
0.1558226049,
-0.46856305,
-0.3329360187,
-0.0851281658,
-0.5775004625,
0.2140332609,
0.3493805528,
-0.4897252917,
-0.4867491126,
-0.0208295677,
-0.0381119549,
0.3742350936,
-0.2192003727,
0.8874487281,
-0.0696721077,
-0.8938485384,
0.8594656587,
0.0539326854,
0.6552484632,
-0.6183717847,
-0.0243562963,
-0.3257184327,
0.2815593183,
-0.1117076501,
-0.7443055511,
0.2452039272,
-0.0069141667,
-0.3199547827,
-0.2911468446,
0.4648326039,
-0.4804703593,
0.0762024745,
0.38451913,
0.4292814434,
-0.297435075,
-0.2224676907,
-0.3043718934,
-0.0613609254,
-0.0722458065,
-0.2910964191,
0.417327255,
0.5967208743,
0.2536456585,
0.1588958502,
0.6110035181,
-0.2180876285,
-0.2965832949,
0.1100899354,
1.1339677572,
-0.6001060009,
-0.7569784522,
-0.9743238091,
0.5541947484,
0.015993828,
-0.3068223596,
0.7501985431,
0.364335984,
0.9359481335,
-0.111175932,
0.8758124709,
0.1414209306,
0.1886017621,
-0.9187396765,
0.5499308109,
-0.7057209611,
0.4222564101,
-0.254293412,
-0.7305139303,
-0.3606532514,
0.4550709128,
-0.5229870677,
0.0348646119,
0.6205515862,
0.6415911317,
-0.1691679806,
-0.0893123597,
0.4194929898,
0.2568517625,
0.388694644,
0.6499232054,
0.964825511,
-0.3390989602,
0.6597667933,
-0.0716966093,
-0.2060448676,
-0.2247633785,
-0.8770666122,
-1.0689027309,
-0.2535966635,
-0.0610202663,
-0.4972189069,
0.11427062,
0.5433275104,
0.5647104383,
-0.9505881667,
-0.0566531718,
-0.5685911775,
0.0173105448,
0.1486184746,
-0.2653824389,
0.234844774,
-0.6211416721,
-0.6344203353,
0.637765646,
-0.0812563822,
0.121195361,
-0.0898081362,
-0.1506107897,
-0.1623800695,
0.1526611,
0.727776587,
0.1187569648,
-0.5949055552,
-0.1147651896,
-0.2433274239,
-0.2637061179,
0.0498431809,
0.8953587413,
-0.7458466291,
0.3433411419,
0.6102727056,
0.9507231116,
0.2994918525,
0.4004756808,
0.8024733663,
-0.8535868526,
0.2839079201,
0.1584391892,
0.3989378512,
0.4312386215,
-0.424480319,
0.1769421101,
0.1711169481,
-0.3184836805,
-0.7309591174,
0.3786649406,
-0.7372817397,
-0.8163425326,
1.1657164097,
-0.263120383,
0.0785741284,
0.0030859453,
-0.2407815605,
0.2302312553,
-0.2453321964,
0.5094497204,
0.7116798162,
0.0816653073,
-0.0832211524,
-0.3138227463,
0.353844434,
0.6179670691,
-0.8735979199,
0.2070943266,
0.6844159365,
0.2218795866,
0.0872621834,
0.543173492,
0.0037238915,
0.1451920569,
0.174671188,
-0.2995137274,
-0.1761360019,
-0.2118729204,
-0.8814194798,
0.4763529897,
-0.0784873962,
-0.0765101463
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02743v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02743v1
|
Beyond Performance: Quantifying and Mitigating Label Bias in LLMs
| 2024-05-04T19:53:03 | 2024-05-04T19:53:03 |
Yuval Reif, Roy Schwartz
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Large language models (LLMs) have shown remarkable adaptability to diverse
tasks, by leveraging context prompts containing instructions, or minimal
input-output examples. However, recent work revealed they also exhibit label
bias -- an undesirable preference toward predicting certain answers over
others. Still, detecting and measuring this bias reliably and at scale has
remained relatively unexplored. In this study, we evaluate different approaches
to quantifying label bias in a model's predictions, conducting a comprehensive
investigation across 279 classification tasks and ten LLMs. Our investigation
reveals substantial label bias in models both before and after debiasing
attempts, as well as highlights the importance of outcomes-based evaluation
metrics, which were not previously used in this regard. We further propose a
novel label bias calibration method tailored for few-shot prompting, which
outperforms recent calibration approaches for both improving performance and
mitigating label bias. Our results emphasize that label bias in the predictions
of LLMs remains a barrier to their reliability.
|
[
-0.5447808504,
-0.6062585711,
0.6185620427,
0.0573414378,
0.1587175876,
-0.0116999652,
-0.1901347935,
-0.3888394535,
-0.1414638162,
0.5080407858,
-0.6437389255,
-0.3776954412,
-0.8503252864,
-0.0983903557,
0.0170415826,
1.1159380674,
0.0670845136,
0.2493622452,
-0.5778593421,
-0.175753355,
-0.6185907722,
-0.5851758122,
-0.4392386377,
-0.8204531074,
0.6334497333,
0.3238345981,
0.4631655812,
0.4360438585,
0.3391852379,
0.1057026088,
-0.3079476357,
0.1119996533,
-0.6441457868,
0.0835776478,
-0.1073592082,
-0.6769911051,
-0.6326984167,
0.0750670061,
0.9684824944,
0.8588930368,
0.1329147816,
0.439668417,
0.4579375684,
0.7443679571,
-0.9745265841,
0.0505309664,
-0.5472638011,
0.03551111,
-0.3583582044,
-0.0257795248,
-0.7058007121,
-0.2491542995,
-0.1316185892,
-0.4879136384,
-0.218664661,
-0.0095548443,
0.2858182788,
0.4592244029,
-0.3473128676,
-0.2594590187,
-0.7633969188,
1.0879335403,
-0.7619696259,
0.4760492146,
0.5646361709,
0.2593536675,
-0.1263247281,
-0.4025944471,
-0.0744625032,
-0.2808545828,
0.0861724541,
0.0423197635,
-0.2736056745,
0.101235494,
0.6109554768,
-0.068317458,
-0.2877480388,
0.6200121641,
0.0057689599,
-0.3472916484,
0.3161377013,
0.259288609,
0.0159557126,
0.2774945796,
-0.3367505968,
-0.0526973009,
-0.9677645564,
0.1821726859,
0.3588680327,
0.1675644666,
0.0499459282,
0.4923435748,
-0.1543665081,
0.8193103671,
-0.098649919,
-0.3316271901,
0.1486628205,
-0.1731752306,
-0.119469814,
0.1833117306,
0.528504014,
0.4555999339,
0.2755081952,
0.04188646,
-0.320222795,
0.2015362978,
0.0723943859,
-0.8249955177,
-0.1487596929,
0.0099905869,
-0.3220462203,
-0.1909417361,
-0.302877903,
-0.6561276317,
-0.8164337873,
-0.1114974245,
0.3338457644,
-0.082415767,
-0.0152399568,
-0.2890940011,
0.002356587,
-0.0441116877,
0.2039113492,
-0.8041900992,
0.116692178,
0.8660309315,
0.6591829658,
-0.3716694713,
-0.1796286106,
-0.7279501557,
0.1817223877,
-0.4747785628,
0.8577118516,
-0.702267766,
-0.4468711019,
-0.211956203,
-0.2924329638,
0.1385155022,
-0.718405664,
0.6162266135,
-0.5014138818,
-0.2240001708,
-0.5872403979,
-0.8157113194,
-0.0953343287,
0.5213944912,
-0.6488974094,
0.9418014884,
-0.0893181264,
-0.894014895,
0.6951637864,
-0.5226860046,
-0.1389762163,
-0.1043495163,
-0.1073975116,
-0.3398804963,
0.2713332772,
0.2638872564,
0.3556998372,
-0.4465370774,
0.2996014059,
-0.5132060647,
-0.5393102765,
0.5694337487,
-0.6954939961,
0.428902179,
0.0241075419,
-0.2544782162,
0.0082831886,
-0.7463042736,
0.1934619695,
-0.3116948903,
-0.3936390877,
-0.3989565074,
-0.0870450586,
-0.369474709,
0.1545573771,
0.046106901,
-0.501092732,
0.1074735001,
-0.3381833732,
0.1125512645,
0.9356172085,
-0.1857151985,
0.4988442957,
-0.4122095406,
0.8668177724,
-0.1078642756,
0.0285644587,
-0.2321328968,
-0.3824590743,
-0.6152495742,
-0.3326587975,
0.3715392649,
0.408369422,
-0.547003746,
0.0014110467,
-0.3312475979,
-0.5753551722,
-0.401632905,
0.2350797802,
0.6079173684,
0.576200366,
0.2287733555,
-0.3148661256,
-0.3669154346,
-0.908762455,
-0.6035857797,
-0.1584023237,
-0.2538567781,
0.4240705073,
0.4563976526,
-0.4328007102,
0.8675364852,
-0.5772522688,
-0.2029463649,
-0.1562488973,
0.1391510516,
0.2103665024,
0.2771800756,
0.3413550556,
-0.2106997073,
-0.2007507831,
-0.2729970813,
-0.4676479101,
-0.5667293072,
0.0325740688,
0.1147294268,
0.349227041,
0.4770011306,
-0.1532134116,
0.2862335145,
0.7102335095,
-0.0167561583,
0.655634284,
0.0605266094,
-0.0346552022,
-0.3573108912,
-0.0030819313,
0.2505712509,
-0.1695033312,
-0.5391629338,
-0.3178899288,
0.0311000962,
0.4206027985,
-0.488856405,
0.8055079579,
-0.3452626467,
-0.3338173926,
-0.4690045714,
0.0301033575,
0.1945517212,
0.063879706,
0.0075609717,
0.8479481339,
0.4867937267,
-0.6993134618,
0.1637063622,
-0.1209987178,
-0.6000044942,
0.6089796424,
-0.5353748202,
0.0716486871,
-0.1745763421,
0.6098025441,
-1.2267338037,
0.1475441903,
0.2763281465,
-0.3544061184,
0.4123143852,
-0.1755018383,
-0.4289793968,
-0.3746288717,
-0.4321380556,
0.6578569412,
0.499448806,
-0.4532342255,
0.3164364994,
0.3241941035,
0.0398919955,
-0.5367005467,
-0.8421481848,
-0.1845689863,
-0.3873184025,
-0.216617018,
0.1764465868,
-0.1666275263,
-0.2907940149,
-0.5211888552,
-0.3206321299,
0.0586201027,
0.1266392469,
0.3428483009,
0.1175589338,
-0.083512947,
0.306654036,
-0.0848379433,
-0.2433885783,
0.2331918627,
-0.2376572639,
0.4152815342,
0.184060961,
-0.3701136112,
-0.2825764418,
-0.1615200788,
0.4232724309,
-0.0305569936,
0.6723460555,
0.6341009736,
-0.2045614868,
-0.312649399,
-0.7584055066,
-0.3947449028,
-0.4600430727,
0.3782219589,
-0.2978194356,
-0.7650855184,
0.4276445806,
-0.3302817345,
-0.0991471633,
0.1069035307,
0.6413574219,
-0.1352814585,
0.9815078378,
0.5852726102,
-0.0391564518,
0.3674027324,
-0.0512074977,
0.1169802397,
-1.2410151958,
-0.1817019284,
-0.4823707938,
-0.4075320065,
-0.6222414374,
-0.5669875741,
0.4926983118,
0.0620892495,
-0.2610097229,
-0.1283250451,
-0.4101985693,
0.4973060489,
0.4960079193,
-0.0169564579,
0.1972859353,
-0.1460584551,
-0.109273009,
-0.2864725292,
-0.8808370829,
-0.7980768681,
1.221118331,
0.6181179285,
1.026358366,
-0.2018761039,
0.5648083091,
0.2802376747,
0.7024762034,
-0.8634977341,
0.3941588104,
-0.0320258699,
-0.840595603,
-0.3669624925,
-0.3646262288,
-0.7437947392,
0.4404536784,
0.0048005129,
-1.0935131311,
-0.0153059149,
0.3301735818,
-0.3816695809,
0.2302538007,
-0.4523176551,
0.7868145704,
-0.3234838545,
-0.4817900062,
0.1300559789,
-0.3753258586,
0.5203482509,
-0.310302943,
0.5444924235,
-0.2225399464,
-0.2417816371,
1.0044642687,
-0.077664651,
1.1211236715,
-0.0134241115,
-0.4820627868,
0.2930861115,
0.1136583984,
0.466460675,
-0.1078193262,
-0.3332084715,
0.1162976325,
0.1144851819,
-0.2552610636,
-0.5124629736,
0.8235445619,
-0.4687704146,
-0.4439831972,
-0.2894453108,
-0.6353592873,
-0.5958378911,
-0.0096198879,
0.350568682,
0.3248294294,
-0.2581360042,
-0.0384684354,
0.7874311805,
-0.5243091583,
0.355679214,
0.4955252111,
-0.1961421371,
-0.2836168706,
0.8351593614,
0.3949438632,
0.4650374055,
0.3470266163,
0.3816208243,
-0.4472764432,
-0.3634691238,
-0.2666296363,
0.1090654209,
-0.9036117792,
-0.2774231732,
-0.4477937222,
0.27858302,
-0.3694531918,
0.0119168395,
-0.4242094457,
-0.3257412612,
-0.4187061191,
-0.1754250824,
0.0818681121,
0.846650362,
-0.0348957852,
0.5539138317,
-0.7244005203,
0.1203751788,
0.1858900338,
0.4600284696,
0.2131501734,
-0.7874696851,
-0.0925923139,
0.2155694366,
-0.5242081881,
-0.8773721457,
0.1552851051,
0.0771913603,
0.6648739576,
0.2665284276,
0.0996520147,
0.3521012664,
-0.4286468029,
0.8564953804,
0.1620109379,
-1.0280373096,
0.5196264982,
-0.1009946093,
0.592066586,
0.3547218442,
0.4177091718,
-0.3324144781,
-0.2998224199,
-0.2801281512,
-0.7393482924,
0.7424442768,
-0.1382284164,
0.010503252,
0.1355388314,
0.1639568508,
0.1849348694,
0.2712998986,
-0.7942441702,
-0.3450240791,
0.2171113044,
0.2060816139,
-0.3383768201,
-0.5791482925,
-0.0704006553,
-0.2531255186,
0.7464773655,
-0.1819203198,
-0.0933002383,
-0.1763167083,
-0.2323034108,
0.0616524182,
0.4894953966,
0.7588050365,
0.9148984551,
-0.0732915625,
0.1274727881,
0.4614609778,
-0.1702962369,
0.2462444603,
-0.1298713684,
-0.3314937055,
-0.0458030067,
0.5490460992,
0.9197114706,
0.2132526636,
-0.6584455967,
0.3121730387,
0.3797575831,
0.140735656,
0.0557995439,
0.0434885807,
0.0847348571,
0.2230156213,
0.1686094701,
-0.3535605669,
0.2559820414,
-0.4786438346,
0.1676094979,
0.5684310198,
-0.7242002487,
-0.1538706422,
0.6882882118,
0.0814319029,
-0.0404775515,
0.2151779532,
0.0634693429,
-0.5709061623,
0.7149353623,
0.4792906642,
0.6208555102,
-0.2855536938,
0.3283205032,
0.2362658828,
0.4570716619,
-0.1711170822,
-0.1815443337,
-0.0678383261,
-0.7132719159,
-0.4712081552,
-0.5688385963,
-0.4573773742,
0.1536405385,
-0.7104956508,
0.0968767107,
-0.3185946345,
-0.6828779578,
0.1555311233,
-0.1428398788,
-0.6007675529,
0.2943966091,
0.5688851476,
0.8149788976,
-0.9664037228,
0.7439616919,
0.7826282382,
-0.0384288654,
-0.4981972575,
-0.0479256064,
0.2082358897,
-0.7548694611,
0.8704860806,
0.2703176141,
-0.2455128431,
-0.1481729299,
-0.3544137478,
-0.7566013932,
0.8961685896,
0.4496263564,
-0.7584432364,
0.2047724575,
0.2699003816,
0.4450105429,
-0.275734514,
0.6407038569,
1.0013110638,
0.6411841512,
0.0582768209,
-1.0169273615,
0.0588730425,
0.4826564789,
0.1842758358,
0.1231378466,
-0.4630911648,
0.4723829925,
-0.2227007151,
0.1345307231,
-0.1625055969,
0.2927107811,
0.5583798885,
0.5148572922,
0.3084367216,
0.4149519503,
0.8653978705,
-0.2055208087,
1.0734864473,
0.0794020444,
0.2501021922,
1.2360805273,
-0.4999326468,
0.5138891935,
0.6866927743,
-0.3555663526,
0.1701844037,
0.6138512492,
0.0501236953,
0.4981153905,
0.6945030689,
-0.2140327096,
-0.4167336822,
-0.5093061924,
-0.4242424071,
0.3664730191,
0.4976989031,
-0.4006709158,
-0.1423207074,
0.2837121785,
0.0234636087,
-0.0416719057,
-0.4845100045,
0.864187181,
0.2608007491,
-0.7689054608,
0.7916249037,
-0.2042641342,
0.9335253239,
-0.3481870592,
0.1148364097,
-0.1865551621,
0.2780793905,
-0.1793698817,
-0.9370562434,
0.0788390711,
-0.1524651498,
-0.2949105203,
-0.3352140188,
0.6633675694,
-0.2768455148,
-0.5820115805,
0.2839586735,
0.4826542735,
0.0901497528,
-0.0963337272,
-0.5060254335,
0.6652714014,
-0.0244245026,
-0.3627113402,
0.3862141669,
0.2791880071,
-0.0753595978,
0.9591216445,
0.1865262538,
0.1255189478,
0.1902686357,
0.0341930762,
0.7176810503,
-0.4040980935,
-0.1943083256,
-1.1200860739,
0.3158831596,
0.2341971397,
-0.1622809917,
0.7655827999,
0.5121706724,
0.835095644,
-0.0017258155,
0.7013351917,
0.5827592611,
0.4309060574,
-0.4583321214,
0.582544148,
-0.4937357008,
0.6466893554,
-0.5504161119,
-0.9953809381,
-0.2424995899,
0.3983495533,
-0.5809259415,
0.2448075563,
0.4316342771,
0.7399303913,
0.2031067908,
-0.2317903787,
0.4842267334,
0.0430946387,
0.3372581005,
0.6565811038,
1.0071943998,
-0.2205184698,
0.4887542427,
-0.1074441895,
-0.3237210214,
-0.1949016601,
-1.150978446,
-0.9191604257,
-0.1154505461,
-0.5379221439,
-0.3137430251,
0.0933325812,
0.4636853337,
0.709723413,
-0.852119565,
-0.1817885637,
0.2220214009,
0.4545655251,
-0.0154473875,
-0.1737707704,
0.0865584463,
-0.1984609812,
-0.6535250545,
0.2051839679,
0.1111209467,
0.1202683449,
-0.2258686572,
-0.0472992249,
0.1752783209,
0.1415187865,
0.7215676904,
0.1448284537,
-0.9618341327,
-0.0398655944,
-0.2228899449,
-0.0369278118,
-0.026694525,
0.6698397398,
-0.9765013456,
0.44539994,
0.4724883437,
0.6504699588,
0.3936926126,
0.0399629734,
0.6127746105,
-0.7861838937,
-0.0293092858,
0.3010329306,
0.0449748933,
0.4442127049,
-0.1985073686,
0.4158106148,
-0.1897828579,
-0.6542788744,
-1.1660658121,
0.3912008107,
-0.4815212488,
-0.3092160523,
1.3594390154,
-0.1440991759,
-0.0117981834,
0.2333327234,
-0.1611583531,
0.1243458539,
-0.2962061763,
0.4664726853,
0.9880260825,
-0.1880805492,
-0.1422205716,
-0.7916195393,
0.4303243458,
0.537707448,
-0.6317559481,
0.2913097739,
0.6895638108,
0.3042954803,
0.0207939576,
0.6199346185,
0.1530239433,
0.0304374844,
-0.2658762932,
-0.1411189288,
0.0666016117,
-0.3180059493,
-0.5215480924,
-0.1318434179,
0.4191545546,
-0.1278187186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02738v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02738v1
|
Relations Prediction for Knowledge Graph Completion using Large Language Models
| 2024-05-04T19:04:51 | 2024-05-04T19:04:51 |
Sakher Khalil Alqaaidi, Krzysztof Kochut
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, I.2.4
|
Knowledge Graphs have been widely used to represent facts in a structured
format. Due to their large scale applications, knowledge graphs suffer from
being incomplete. The relation prediction task obtains knowledge graph
completion by assigning one or more possible relations to each pair of nodes.
In this work, we make use of the knowledge graph node names to fine-tune a
large language model for the relation prediction task. By utilizing the node
names only we enable our model to operate sufficiently in the inductive
settings. Our experiments show that we accomplish new scores on a widely used
knowledge graph benchmark.
|
[
-0.4057763219,
-0.4737992883,
0.7861221433,
-0.0982345641,
-0.1771638095,
-0.0315335579,
-0.3271921873,
-0.8080542088,
0.2488968372,
0.6058392525,
-0.5890533328,
-0.3940120935,
-0.5992636681,
0.0560256615,
-0.2357499599,
0.9431666136,
-0.02779538,
-0.0580334365,
-0.6230934858,
-0.0921401903,
-0.4983472228,
-0.2385262847,
-0.6146884561,
-0.8071829677,
0.6618723869,
0.4643352032,
0.9986350536,
0.8666331768,
0.4088663161,
0.2879217863,
-0.1553753614,
0.4061242342,
-0.4731047153,
0.3449450731,
-0.2068766654,
-0.0189611278,
-0.4397678971,
-0.1028262153,
0.8628279567,
1.4269448519,
0.3003275692,
0.1106264368,
0.0173633508,
0.6133274436,
-0.3880032301,
0.8387387991,
-0.6266569495,
0.0888315216,
-0.0760646462,
-0.0407651365,
-0.4258050323,
-0.3760065436,
0.2860833406,
-0.6358584166,
0.0368651599,
0.2644681931,
0.6840328574,
-0.0452462994,
-0.6075509787,
0.028184589,
-0.9445735812,
0.4171318412,
-0.5642799139,
0.5549323559,
0.710999608,
0.3371499181,
-0.4516121149,
-0.7330669165,
-0.3663433194,
-0.4720828533,
-0.4532238245,
-0.0740652606,
0.1776475459,
0.2517141104,
0.602540493,
0.2949630022,
-0.1737909317,
-0.1280460656,
-0.3591781855,
-0.0288778786,
0.5211492777,
0.2763690352,
-0.0093361419,
-0.1027998179,
-0.1893853545,
0.2066354901,
-0.6556473374,
-0.0882889405,
0.1805351377,
0.5966207981,
0.289613694,
0.6970674992,
-0.6801204681,
1.1353815794,
-0.0988366157,
-0.288954705,
0.3385817111,
-0.2864353657,
-0.2609500587,
-0.0288198795,
0.8532034159,
0.385896951,
0.8468890786,
-0.6710488796,
0.0223429017,
-0.2736750245,
-0.0551467016,
-0.7035602331,
-0.4628712535,
0.0384329148,
-0.0513041131,
-0.0051922388,
-0.161795646,
-0.3745009601,
-0.5967988968,
-0.5011868477,
0.1489264965,
-0.5940840244,
-0.3974662423,
-0.1827093065,
-0.1310700327,
-0.219838649,
0.4588819146,
-0.602147162,
0.4347112477,
0.5055258274,
0.60663867,
0.17824696,
-0.6124636531,
-0.528898716,
0.4815223217,
-0.3514753282,
0.6746920347,
-0.73178339,
-0.1592071056,
-0.0259472989,
0.0099110147,
-0.0763761401,
-0.4565652609,
0.344168961,
-0.6783890128,
-0.1496403217,
-0.3930612504,
-1.0466022491,
-0.0309346821,
0.2866312861,
-1.0517705679,
0.7996039391,
0.3951404989,
-1.1742217541,
0.1797806174,
-0.3268061578,
-0.7860906124,
0.1720142215,
0.1402728111,
-0.3044290841,
-0.2774764299,
-0.1228993014,
0.6913994551,
-0.2839073539,
0.2714194059,
-0.4699988961,
-0.0874141008,
0.1698462367,
0.4368625581,
0.4335083663,
0.0818308741,
0.1971492469,
0.0053378977,
-0.7938110232,
0.0254532844,
0.0224134326,
-0.0743159726,
-0.4711628258,
0.1914152801,
-0.3470327556,
0.1364994645,
0.1420214921,
-0.5879872441,
0.2354210317,
-0.3732296824,
0.3318663836,
0.4680669606,
0.2218368053,
0.6363953352,
-0.1013488472,
0.4903634787,
-0.1609507948,
-0.0634789988,
0.0839281753,
-0.5921922922,
-0.4921286106,
0.305967629,
0.699203968,
0.2214011252,
-0.746027112,
0.3234761059,
-0.5510572195,
-0.6833753586,
0.0945956334,
0.1395969838,
0.3530286551,
0.7547883987,
0.276381135,
0.0702688843,
-0.6826206446,
-0.6032819748,
-0.1999748796,
-0.2837803662,
0.1537657529,
0.449681133,
0.3128228784,
-0.0765497386,
0.9614656568,
-0.8755376935,
-0.4899051189,
-0.1875552684,
-0.1338226795,
0.2218498588,
0.1914604902,
0.2765803635,
-0.5818728209,
-0.6238145828,
0.2679811716,
-0.615996778,
0.4594987631,
0.2774023116,
-0.1884533465,
-0.2314854115,
0.6255481839,
-0.6725494266,
0.1715545058,
0.4929050803,
-0.3734846115,
0.5930259228,
0.1338068545,
-0.2552912533,
-1.0974930525,
0.0867646635,
-0.041636847,
-0.7184874415,
-0.4287638664,
-0.1315829754,
0.0581264086,
-0.0166120119,
-0.0839359984,
0.7156071067,
-0.5769860744,
-0.0750328153,
0.0942009091,
0.2841272056,
-0.0759679675,
0.31416291,
0.120273605,
0.2806242108,
0.4361841679,
-0.6576904058,
0.8012250662,
0.3827509284,
-0.4924742579,
0.1321701407,
-0.5155600309,
-0.0618744045,
-0.1053026766,
0.0881192163,
-0.9898687601,
-0.4901609421,
-0.0685843527,
-0.6214780807,
0.4093084633,
-0.3340937197,
-0.5977838635,
-0.440202266,
0.0972621888,
0.4219026566,
0.121808067,
-0.3433493376,
0.6779215336,
0.4847634137,
-0.0853852481,
-0.6440109015,
-0.4086151719,
-0.0636430383,
0.0883856416,
-0.5464326739,
0.3483557105,
0.0733338967,
-0.1582183838,
0.5127131939,
0.1453972161,
-0.1423887759,
-0.0515287593,
0.4793604016,
0.118045859,
0.0394009836,
0.6870236993,
-0.2401345819,
-0.0374717601,
0.093315728,
-0.0293279067,
0.5249039531,
0.2208336294,
0.0419105068,
0.0024140663,
0.0392788015,
0.6805061102,
-0.3189077377,
0.9957644939,
0.1738423556,
-0.6604394913,
-0.0397172347,
-0.4260872602,
-0.036716938,
-0.3409820795,
0.5031098127,
-0.5360221863,
-0.9213069081,
0.6944603324,
-0.2518460453,
-0.2723959982,
0.4888676703,
-0.0263509136,
0.1156722158,
0.8984487057,
0.6631900668,
-0.3834968805,
0.4783257842,
-0.3138295412,
0.2762932777,
-0.9899831414,
-0.3090070188,
-0.4530514777,
-0.0475734584,
-0.5180879235,
0.0949631631,
0.3198480606,
0.3460409343,
-0.3083305359,
0.6433000565,
-0.1818742454,
0.5436312556,
0.5005886555,
0.0818539783,
0.6076847911,
0.1046911627,
-0.281712532,
0.1077275127,
-0.5044384599,
-0.0253822058,
0.9774466157,
0.1342238188,
0.5580580831,
-0.2146251798,
0.6105846167,
-0.0343556255,
0.4298297763,
-0.9056851268,
0.3154209256,
-0.0357691422,
-0.4796194732,
-0.6580961943,
-0.757338047,
-1.1084142923,
-0.2673555017,
-0.2923196554,
-0.8208640814,
-0.2302048504,
0.0096150134,
-0.1738792211,
0.1383000165,
-0.3891834617,
0.9208551645,
0.2281360328,
-0.0114808008,
-0.0922834724,
-0.4996551275,
0.4476255178,
0.1285648048,
0.2104845345,
-0.3225003481,
0.4782269001,
0.8885504007,
-0.6926333904,
0.596483171,
-0.1045712829,
0.1705874652,
0.2415635586,
0.0980270803,
0.8782750368,
0.0495011546,
-0.4119802117,
-0.3196443915,
-0.0757164359,
-0.0918870792,
-0.542072773,
0.717120111,
-0.8233813047,
-0.2509425282,
-0.0770314932,
-0.6954076886,
-0.5569192171,
0.5078037381,
0.2701630294,
0.6190632582,
-0.2234642506,
-0.0298490319,
0.467236042,
0.2540866435,
0.1731051356,
0.2386741638,
-0.5317608118,
-0.5181639194,
0.6190991402,
0.4885783792,
0.2570535839,
0.2659630775,
0.0798202157,
-0.4517189562,
-0.3528944254,
-0.2227759957,
0.480599761,
-0.7434443235,
-0.7560551763,
-0.7814345956,
-0.5418874025,
-0.5917919874,
0.3094167113,
-0.3469543755,
-0.4935252666,
0.0070950594,
-0.2663280368,
0.5488935113,
1.0553970337,
0.3890678287,
0.1775329411,
-0.7399564981,
0.2820534706,
0.4537642002,
0.7898749709,
0.2065950334,
-0.1888636053,
-0.4693609774,
-0.1195990518,
0.0411333293,
-0.85337919,
0.0312413909,
0.3360179663,
0.3918248713,
0.2001263201,
0.3906566799,
0.6713535786,
-0.5729476213,
0.1381475627,
0.2009809613,
-0.6444376707,
0.5495183468,
-0.3932492733,
0.1041710451,
0.4356005192,
0.4356812239,
-0.6021569371,
-0.3994850814,
-0.7093487978,
-0.743539691,
0.5548206568,
0.0358302742,
-0.0315688476,
-0.0714768022,
0.4863987267,
-0.0331296921,
0.2045943439,
-0.6872102022,
-0.3679991663,
0.0968702137,
-0.0785697848,
-0.1278073341,
-0.398429364,
-0.0988717303,
-0.4832562208,
0.7572715282,
-0.0650755167,
0.0909085944,
-0.0368567184,
0.1646997333,
-0.6115801334,
-0.0118253073,
-0.0773675814,
1.098934412,
-0.1924733818,
0.0704551116,
-0.025423713,
-0.0915350914,
-0.0237077847,
0.421816051,
-0.1559227258,
0.163643837,
0.4978185892,
0.6886460781,
0.0619363636,
-0.3874384165,
0.5457159281,
0.0415522009,
-0.1228142977,
-0.65074265,
-0.1028048098,
0.6360883117,
0.2024188638,
0.0667728037,
0.0549424253,
0.0566727929,
-0.633518219,
0.0221078973,
0.4724735022,
-0.5096079707,
-0.1300875694,
0.4394220114,
-0.0196563844,
-0.1128121316,
0.7843085527,
-0.5500115156,
-0.7567482591,
0.6834501028,
0.6214578152,
0.4173936844,
-0.2012131661,
0.2003269494,
0.7604346275,
0.0723672062,
-0.2716667652,
0.1182733774,
0.1963613927,
-1.039452076,
-0.8710467815,
-0.9054003954,
-0.519161284,
0.1138104647,
-0.4267272949,
0.3228266835,
-0.5073732138,
-0.2027850449,
0.2719459534,
0.2982281744,
-0.8655596972,
0.3611815572,
-0.0186509453,
0.8575822115,
-0.8989698887,
1.250493288,
0.8270831108,
-0.3976089954,
-1.4031975269,
-0.2893368304,
-0.5035105944,
-0.3346404135,
0.7099749446,
0.1199923903,
-0.0140135055,
0.0479943082,
-0.2868549824,
-1.2988576889,
1.0021948814,
0.4968433976,
-0.4608397484,
-0.007765905,
0.1782861054,
0.3611813784,
-0.4910426736,
0.0444903336,
0.4322159886,
0.6824960113,
0.3754757643,
-1.0468621254,
0.346247375,
-0.239695102,
0.0120643601,
0.4803861678,
-0.326174289,
0.9428092241,
-0.2374938726,
-0.1423865408,
0.1589194536,
0.7744971514,
-0.0357810035,
0.1974304318,
0.5597466826,
0.5640904903,
1.016217947,
-0.0387937464,
0.9949165583,
-0.3397710621,
0.5277372599,
1.4465510845,
-0.323376298,
0.81034863,
-0.0754326805,
-0.5185955763,
0.6038225889,
0.5235580206,
0.043910943,
0.3174059391,
-0.0104784379,
-0.0843137652,
-0.3842978776,
-0.5133476257,
-0.5585267544,
0.3343368173,
0.3697014153,
-0.435406357,
0.0184424631,
-0.3010848463,
0.175032109,
0.0738330334,
-0.4941383004,
0.7259668708,
-0.104484193,
-0.8832705021,
0.3712667227,
-0.1919995695,
0.0507929176,
-0.4754384458,
-0.051436387,
-0.0393717736,
0.2115353495,
-0.4529883265,
-0.9282418489,
0.2617634833,
-0.6105421782,
-0.5091629028,
0.2809863985,
1.0070514679,
-0.8324531317,
-0.607462883,
0.746304512,
0.5783001781,
-0.2183697671,
-0.3966256678,
0.0455987938,
-0.4470164776,
-0.154576838,
-0.1040364504,
0.2115735114,
0.6752604842,
-0.0314710326,
0.6692888141,
0.2156824619,
0.1644572467,
-0.100522235,
0.0550842956,
1.139685154,
-0.6428877115,
-0.1395261139,
-0.7034935951,
0.169298321,
-0.2377975136,
-0.0542345382,
0.6535603404,
0.5484260321,
0.8021345139,
0.0061825607,
0.8816801906,
-0.1668332666,
0.7470580339,
-0.3243251145,
0.4808759689,
-0.301258862,
-0.0735907778,
-0.4637891948,
-1.2768621445,
-0.3084839284,
0.1963942498,
-0.3002167344,
-0.0208849125,
0.9312838912,
0.4070820808,
-0.0071702269,
-0.1089791954,
0.3529344201,
0.3679072559,
-0.1137817129,
0.5963995457,
0.744451046,
-0.2866203189,
0.6818732619,
-0.6504240036,
-0.0586680174,
-0.0988823399,
-0.8578022122,
-1.0617883205,
-0.6777583361,
-0.3349937201,
-0.5821443796,
-0.0534016974,
0.7786500454,
0.6572941542,
-0.6641660929,
-0.1523063481,
-0.0207733829,
0.5408762693,
-0.1625064015,
-0.1986214668,
0.4395887256,
-0.4232313037,
-0.4597718418,
0.1644173861,
-0.0330240913,
-0.1612760425,
0.0566011257,
-0.1200264022,
-0.3555776179,
-0.5683465004,
0.6031638384,
0.1939645261,
-0.3401549459,
-0.4774066806,
-0.2537052333,
0.0329185203,
-0.0394212976,
0.7490869761,
-0.9184703827,
0.4590685368,
0.6328822374,
0.2835176587,
0.5688079596,
-0.0412688553,
0.7592021227,
-0.9529670477,
-0.1095812768,
0.0756964236,
0.7979800701,
0.5046224594,
-0.4821733236,
0.8637075424,
0.1353418529,
-0.456555903,
-0.3891243935,
0.4348874092,
-0.8668832779,
-0.1922423989,
1.2477788925,
-0.4184724092,
-0.1570952833,
-0.195653677,
0.1092446297,
0.6140438318,
-0.379030019,
0.3934219182,
0.6637598276,
-0.1683943868,
-0.0134818796,
-0.4691703916,
0.6573905945,
0.0460681245,
-0.4550874233,
0.3101509809,
0.4740266204,
0.4032298326,
0.3350205421,
0.6963401437,
0.0691143721,
0.0278298296,
-0.2294382751,
-0.0588447899,
-0.2754960656,
-0.4347843528,
0.4206570387,
0.2147218287,
0.6359133124,
0.3143742085
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02732v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02732v1
|
Recall Them All: Retrieval-Augmented Language Models for Long Object List Extraction from Long Documents
| 2024-05-04T18:32:08 | 2024-05-04T18:32:08 |
Sneha Singhania, Simon Razniewski, Gerhard Weikum
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Methods for relation extraction from text mostly focus on high precision, at
the cost of limited recall. High recall is crucial, though, to populate long
lists of object entities that stand in a specific relation with a given
subject. Cues for relevant objects can be spread across many passages in long
texts. This poses the challenge of extracting long lists from long texts. We
present the L3X method which tackles the problem in two stages: (1)
recall-oriented generation using a large language model (LLM) with judicious
techniques for retrieval augmentation, and (2) precision-oriented
scrutinization to validate or prune candidates. Our L3X method outperforms
LLM-only generations by a substantial margin.
|
[
-0.2152553648,
-0.800896883,
0.9384449124,
0.0158518869,
-0.0959182307,
-0.1037259102,
-0.1803241074,
-0.7615431547,
-0.0112632355,
0.9152525067,
-0.2829287052,
-0.322283119,
-0.3840296268,
0.1918075979,
-0.8190136552,
0.9161881208,
-0.1530990899,
-0.6039426923,
-0.0320282765,
-0.052803997,
-0.3116103113,
-0.7577320337,
-0.3285439014,
-0.2688973546,
0.6216922402,
0.567057848,
0.5767755508,
0.8804832697,
0.4090184569,
0.1775324047,
-0.1968431771,
0.2291589975,
-0.5305233598,
0.2465369701,
-0.4060647488,
-0.49799335,
-0.4248143137,
-0.3180336654,
0.7959681153,
0.6621501446,
-0.0861981809,
-0.0459828898,
-0.0375800952,
0.7581367493,
-0.9407660961,
0.0325883031,
-0.6191455126,
-0.0969587192,
-0.3595395088,
-0.0442408361,
-0.6251129508,
-0.3176153898,
0.0859431475,
-0.5443710685,
0.2462142408,
0.1766667515,
0.6529564857,
-0.2540922463,
-0.3443542719,
-0.2874313593,
-1.0124310255,
0.933940053,
-0.4600081444,
0.3149948418,
0.5645896792,
0.1359696686,
-0.1136630774,
-0.8600974083,
-0.4045176804,
-0.2618780434,
0.0969773233,
0.1814369112,
0.1072180569,
-0.1360896826,
0.5277808905,
0.419270128,
-0.2126974761,
0.1127882525,
-0.5478634834,
0.0496681072,
0.7120885849,
-0.1707689911,
0.0330208801,
-0.3636447489,
-0.5143222213,
-0.1899851561,
-0.9625458121,
-0.317350924,
0.1817736179,
0.3858670592,
0.5323837399,
0.6965703964,
-0.2490702122,
0.6639139056,
-0.0437215753,
-0.3417891264,
0.0114498986,
-0.2408925146,
0.0071370248,
0.125141561,
0.7411661148,
0.1958862692,
0.3818130195,
-0.0650964007,
-0.3208276331,
-0.5107240081,
0.1604351848,
-0.590975225,
0.1167504638,
0.1760427505,
-0.5075401664,
0.0248187389,
-0.094328694,
-0.7805054188,
-0.3367456496,
-0.197753191,
0.4205833972,
-0.4580080807,
-0.2437369376,
0.1041875705,
0.0345825776,
0.1102075502,
0.2705991566,
-0.9803734422,
0.3866190016,
0.7471525073,
0.5547465086,
-0.4215330482,
-0.4690645337,
-0.7252278924,
0.6161655784,
-0.1818541884,
0.8208056688,
-0.5475993752,
-0.6579386592,
0.279728055,
-0.0537843555,
0.310449332,
-0.7072100639,
0.7008424997,
-0.4631231725,
0.080473803,
-0.1678302139,
-0.8616982698,
-0.1785122007,
0.2919613719,
-1.0112440586,
1.3641415834,
0.2335169166,
-0.5226182342,
0.0320863016,
-0.2133930475,
-0.4224517941,
-0.0588999167,
-0.1973397583,
-0.5293068886,
0.0556608625,
0.3777925372,
0.9103982449,
-0.4914363325,
0.2492415458,
-0.3243898451,
-0.307707876,
-0.0484186485,
-0.2307211012,
0.4188021719,
0.1927840263,
-0.0734036863,
0.0749810934,
-0.8176032305,
-0.217982918,
0.2619583309,
-0.3228871822,
-0.4608788788,
0.1855109185,
0.0023358886,
0.1328473389,
0.2485375255,
-0.348972261,
0.3214733005,
-0.3812042475,
0.2014298737,
0.4840156734,
0.1281718165,
0.5773012042,
-0.2612408996,
0.2709957063,
0.0365595222,
-0.0072656306,
-0.5903906822,
-0.1592900455,
-0.5577895045,
-0.2555885613,
0.0301193893,
0.4902049303,
-0.6267888546,
0.5573114157,
-0.4643645585,
-0.4137566984,
0.0977130458,
0.4150641263,
0.2606416345,
0.2157235593,
0.4004582763,
0.0319550671,
-0.4217015207,
-0.8705952764,
-0.2182690203,
-0.2112897485,
-0.0958884731,
0.2343041003,
0.5716725588,
0.0125973569,
0.8924583793,
-0.6390919089,
-0.2459676713,
-0.4292779267,
-0.0069366144,
0.1595879346,
0.3931461871,
0.422218293,
-0.8037313819,
-0.2729287446,
0.0427780338,
-0.6888515949,
0.4484163821,
-0.2599285841,
-0.1766988635,
0.2470347583,
0.7746934295,
-0.7888267636,
0.44190979,
-0.176918149,
0.0923314691,
0.3453381062,
-0.1443922669,
-0.1563563347,
-1.3302547932,
0.251655966,
-0.0542774536,
-0.5403113961,
-0.4467112124,
0.2308372855,
0.5122026801,
-0.2007538378,
-0.5507858992,
0.6790918708,
-0.8031882048,
-0.218934983,
-0.2852605283,
0.6081175804,
0.1408961415,
0.2240563482,
0.2814469039,
0.4879767001,
0.2082619071,
-0.6974512935,
0.5911144018,
0.2023909241,
-0.3775163591,
0.5636824965,
-0.1763087511,
0.2006673515,
-0.2056313902,
0.2439073026,
-0.568785131,
-0.0751771182,
0.0638216287,
-0.0459309965,
0.4567324221,
0.0657795593,
-0.5708726048,
-0.5160640478,
-0.3063533902,
0.3767546415,
0.3411215544,
-0.6760009527,
0.6893968582,
0.1865477264,
-0.3677140474,
-0.8623771667,
-0.2047013789,
0.0306163747,
-0.263158977,
-0.107734628,
0.3482678831,
0.0163254645,
-0.3097498417,
-0.168194145,
-0.1373430938,
0.0203246344,
0.0910825208,
0.0590096638,
0.3423220217,
0.0220204815,
0.202531606,
-0.3577023745,
-0.0708253086,
-0.1235675737,
-0.1130096465,
0.4053935111,
0.1860725284,
-0.3474205136,
-0.0801284686,
0.7455771565,
0.5456484556,
-0.3063709736,
0.3501940668,
0.2913813293,
-0.7534315586,
0.0607264154,
-1.0941662788,
-0.0977528691,
-0.3398871124,
0.70420295,
-0.5096632838,
-0.724627912,
0.540584743,
0.0259975828,
0.1249924377,
0.4563933313,
0.2344978005,
0.2092760354,
0.9140431285,
0.5744159818,
-0.5826523304,
0.3960057795,
-0.116027385,
0.0455775075,
-0.9415768385,
-0.140572682,
-0.6649708748,
0.153570205,
-0.2223780155,
-0.3110429943,
0.0076346258,
0.4331119359,
-0.1555722505,
0.3626491725,
-0.3025346398,
0.747025013,
0.5946986079,
0.2022242248,
0.403101325,
0.1394221038,
0.4210214019,
0.1947517544,
-0.255285114,
-0.3603804708,
1.2187852859,
0.3173752725,
0.5676218271,
0.0447575003,
1.0524315834,
-0.1393983364,
0.435764432,
-1.0389568806,
0.7432615161,
-0.2358917594,
-0.7299802303,
-0.280914396,
-0.2634007335,
-1.0454990864,
-0.0893782228,
-0.1963247508,
-0.9541541338,
0.0949679688,
-0.1516366303,
-0.4888943136,
0.3737103939,
-0.1908189803,
0.3686648309,
-0.2637361586,
-0.6862127185,
-0.2271755785,
-0.6095771194,
0.5339477062,
-0.4280114472,
0.1417556405,
-0.1310291588,
-0.0323735662,
0.6958257556,
-0.1494781524,
0.491720587,
0.0577943251,
-0.3372391462,
0.380910188,
0.2008835673,
0.9989458323,
-0.0983467996,
-0.350343585,
-0.1994856447,
-0.0180916376,
-0.3245565891,
-0.6074582934,
0.8595491648,
-0.4846072793,
-0.5996869802,
-0.4206418991,
-0.494120717,
-0.0949527696,
0.46176669,
0.0199505053,
0.1921928972,
-0.1879198849,
0.3329096735,
0.5922045708,
-0.0685021728,
0.5890244246,
0.3710229993,
-0.5887911916,
-0.4725088477,
0.8511120677,
0.1656723022,
0.289670676,
0.5193573236,
-0.0776659325,
-0.3521533608,
-0.40486449,
-0.262525171,
0.3338276744,
-0.7655121088,
-0.2747131586,
-0.4893031418,
-0.1931973249,
-0.1876506209,
0.0145209292,
-0.4485834539,
-0.4179491103,
-0.4933825135,
-0.0795550868,
0.4185142219,
0.809722662,
0.0726250634,
0.3030106723,
-1.1603984833,
0.5995346308,
0.2626141012,
0.1617619693,
-0.0835064724,
-0.1111400872,
-0.2827865481,
-0.1500914991,
-0.30284217,
-0.9638211727,
0.4148729146,
0.113167055,
0.507075429,
0.4760226011,
-0.1189754307,
0.7525740266,
-0.5790207386,
0.8236185908,
0.2470018715,
-0.7521098256,
0.646314919,
-0.3628660142,
-0.0134596284,
0.3404210508,
0.411476016,
-0.418813169,
0.0409406312,
-0.7627424002,
-1.0415661335,
0.6740715504,
0.0772640184,
-0.0628547892,
-0.4502301514,
0.9093593955,
0.0878509805,
-0.0676863417,
-0.6706501245,
-0.0557491966,
0.155321911,
-0.2711503506,
-0.2017294019,
-0.6407949924,
-0.1506794989,
0.1426295489,
0.6147326827,
-0.1128921732,
-0.0064834836,
0.3292533457,
-0.2262880653,
0.0437556207,
0.2764468193,
0.584818542,
0.9618737102,
-0.4034918249,
0.031897787,
0.1485084891,
-0.4656960964,
0.1143390611,
0.1428383887,
-0.0545671135,
-0.0895270184,
0.3070209026,
0.4908758104,
0.2795398533,
-0.6601249576,
0.5094373226,
0.1743898839,
-0.1922810376,
-0.5505273938,
-0.1903524101,
0.020517014,
0.1693806648,
0.5275968909,
-0.3358023465,
0.1733407229,
-0.6679288149,
0.2142175585,
0.3085391521,
-0.1440704465,
0.007058776,
0.4503993392,
0.1280159652,
-0.2032380998,
0.78280586,
0.215650633,
-0.239591077,
0.3853890598,
0.8042060137,
0.7683954835,
-0.1667283177,
-0.1459515244,
0.5712102056,
0.0218242258,
-0.9857532978,
0.0792102516,
-0.2446636111,
-0.5010944605,
-0.6301472187,
-0.3276631534,
-0.3720612228,
0.2133415192,
-0.996581614,
0.2560039759,
-0.3153862953,
0.0033978112,
-0.2332251966,
-0.0055564316,
-0.3477829099,
0.2369781435,
0.2753690779,
0.8887054324,
-0.5044624209,
0.950409472,
0.1496803761,
-0.5000166893,
-0.7003475428,
-0.1288327128,
-0.3211316168,
-0.7913936377,
0.8484094739,
0.2340808958,
-0.0314305164,
0.2132943571,
-0.475304395,
-0.9751794934,
0.8968509436,
0.0855195224,
-1.001357913,
-0.2889609933,
0.0384437479,
0.0795366988,
-0.1624283791,
0.2617087364,
0.8391850591,
0.2819159329,
-0.0152732739,
-0.8604567647,
0.0943200886,
-0.0128893033,
0.0022750541,
0.5086086392,
-0.4341775179,
0.6950304508,
-0.0871591792,
-0.1838192493,
0.4718087614,
0.8477646708,
0.5191933513,
0.1165474355,
0.5274168253,
0.4355846345,
0.9201565385,
0.1341781169,
1.0552040339,
-0.1765555143,
0.2078832388,
1.257974267,
-0.6737447977,
1.2790070772,
0.5595152378,
-0.0984247997,
0.0911621302,
0.4536295533,
0.2281222492,
0.112048097,
0.1329427809,
-0.3789056242,
-0.2845470607,
0.0935120061,
-0.3267399669,
0.281388402,
0.5569037199,
-0.4730732441,
-0.0160867032,
0.1329110116,
0.2067122459,
0.2381146103,
-0.3620453179,
0.9124366641,
0.0708321705,
-0.9387720227,
0.6139237881,
-0.1999449283,
0.3376996517,
-0.435007453,
-0.2719968855,
-0.177788198,
0.3701863289,
0.0084105488,
-0.844891727,
-0.0016031795,
-0.177428931,
-0.4200490415,
-0.0941403508,
0.7742372751,
-0.415106982,
-0.6122125983,
0.3054598868,
0.4629027545,
0.2921518385,
-0.3539249301,
-0.3623096347,
-0.0219836291,
0.1684413552,
-0.3295764029,
0.17870377,
0.3458536863,
-0.4214488566,
0.6869239211,
0.5474973321,
0.2760749459,
-0.1502838582,
0.1557170302,
0.6532661915,
-1.055279851,
-0.0217648856,
-1.0003529787,
0.2942374945,
-0.3382969797,
0.0449390151,
0.5851694345,
0.8124099374,
0.6271769404,
-0.0467635132,
0.7559755445,
0.2535029352,
0.9552366138,
-0.6068207622,
0.3259055018,
-0.5580010414,
0.2511995435,
-0.2227798849,
-1.4030008316,
-0.5299289823,
0.5402849913,
-0.1265936941,
-0.0443968102,
0.7510414124,
0.6519172192,
-0.0721484795,
-0.1374355406,
0.2190247923,
0.2048984319,
0.4756846428,
0.6120125651,
0.9530689716,
-0.5707974434,
0.7753972411,
-0.4134291708,
-0.0256841704,
-0.3925460875,
-0.9230687618,
-0.6844730377,
-0.4583239257,
-0.1057470441,
-0.4268166721,
0.1245117709,
0.8684171438,
0.4926123917,
-0.5326821208,
-0.3064098656,
0.1360033453,
0.0796725377,
-0.0785429031,
-0.1379864961,
0.6648042798,
-0.1132718697,
-0.9919775128,
0.5335059762,
0.3335773647,
0.1934902072,
-0.1644548625,
0.1199295297,
-0.3546581268,
-0.280181855,
0.7159000039,
0.5608439445,
-0.7041107416,
-0.4950217009,
0.0458619148,
-0.0089168204,
0.011046011,
0.6805186868,
-0.8799079657,
0.3456870615,
0.466526866,
0.3548747599,
0.778739512,
0.1800836474,
0.7270478606,
-0.7420666814,
0.2752360106,
0.1841876358,
0.4190431237,
0.3046256602,
-0.2764939666,
0.5075303316,
0.031060759,
-0.7140084505,
-0.9737632871,
0.2942668498,
-1.0312740803,
-0.3378446698,
1.2689399719,
0.0200708322,
-0.3525984585,
-0.0039453143,
-0.6065940857,
0.2390514463,
-0.1238875836,
0.6634474993,
0.6127972007,
0.0221616272,
-0.2242934704,
-0.5374723673,
0.4789566994,
0.4116002917,
-0.7927073836,
0.3504374623,
0.5782641172,
0.144920975,
0.4441460371,
0.4659878612,
-0.2189675868,
0.1897677183,
-0.3390813768,
0.2852833271,
0.1832168698,
-0.3319404423,
0.0425656512,
0.2264137864,
0.2368694097,
0.1161558107
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02714v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02714v1
|
Beyond Relevance: Evaluate and Improve Retrievers on Perspective Awareness
| 2024-05-04T17:10:00 | 2024-05-04T17:10:00 |
Xinran Zhao, Tong Chen, Sihao Chen, Hongming Zhang, Tongshuang Wu
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.CL
|
The task of Information Retrieval (IR) requires a system to identify relevant
documents based on users' information needs. In real-world scenarios,
retrievers are expected to not only rely on the semantic relevance between the
documents and the queries but also recognize the nuanced intents or
perspectives behind a user query. For example, when asked to verify a claim, a
retrieval system is expected to identify evidence from both supporting vs.
contradicting perspectives, for the downstream system to make a fair judgment
call. In this work, we study whether retrievers can recognize and respond to
different perspectives of the queries -- beyond finding relevant documents for
a claim, can retrievers distinguish supporting vs. opposing documents? We
reform and extend six existing tasks to create a benchmark for retrieval, where
we have diverse perspectives described in free-form text, besides root, neutral
queries. We show that current retrievers covered in our experiments have
limited awareness of subtly different perspectives in queries and can also be
biased toward certain perspectives. Motivated by the observation, we further
explore the potential to leverage geometric features of retriever
representation space to improve the perspective awareness of retrievers in a
zero-shot manner. We demonstrate the efficiency and effectiveness of our
projection-based methods on the same set of tasks. Further analysis also shows
how perspective awareness improves performance on various downstream tasks,
with 4.2% higher accuracy on AmbigQA and 29.9% more correlation with designated
viewpoints on essay writing, compared to non-perspective-aware baselines.
|
[
-0.2771260142,
-0.1124748737,
1.0084308386,
0.0175032914,
-0.0735023767,
-0.0732874274,
0.0409838893,
-0.7313584089,
0.3178153336,
0.4216847122,
-0.149781093,
-0.3218598962,
-0.6515357494,
0.0167997871,
-0.3716123104,
0.9077537656,
0.0716084018,
-0.1228318214,
-0.4066547453,
-0.3244787157,
-0.5961949229,
-0.5072421432,
-0.2485010922,
-0.2258524299,
0.653511703,
0.2459194064,
0.1887275577,
0.2655665278,
0.7646303177,
0.2313464135,
-0.0244904831,
-0.2129442394,
-0.5739531517,
0.4676367342,
-0.4993151426,
-0.7414010167,
-0.0682162493,
0.1915816367,
0.554297626,
0.6052284241,
-0.1068299487,
0.3390832841,
0.3038198352,
1.0057880878,
-1.2921849489,
-0.0227772892,
-0.6905236244,
0.2399463505,
-0.3330338001,
-0.3618988693,
-0.5215337276,
-0.4418343902,
0.5010308027,
-0.8429846764,
0.4080340564,
0.0224538501,
0.7916309834,
0.154793635,
-0.4994071722,
-0.0581090003,
-0.6307259202,
0.7742797136,
-0.2287412882,
0.6896969676,
0.179090336,
0.4448793828,
0.1651943624,
-0.4520496428,
-0.2227023989,
-0.054086484,
-0.171880126,
0.4554411173,
-0.1832165271,
-0.1340800971,
0.5395982265,
0.5267593265,
-0.360578835,
-0.4877729416,
-0.1313508898,
-0.1733366847,
0.1781303734,
-0.2040809244,
-0.2105987072,
-0.3569012284,
-0.4050224125,
-0.1973447949,
-0.465098083,
0.1734325141,
0.2271863818,
0.1657140702,
0.4014068246,
0.6805002093,
-0.5782445073,
0.66986233,
0.3682032824,
0.066893518,
0.3949026167,
-0.0606330782,
-0.3230684698,
-0.1102151275,
-0.0155102909,
0.6176567674,
-0.2414509654,
-0.1608954817,
-0.1386972666,
-0.2887919545,
0.8127645254,
-0.5929694176,
0.035796728,
-0.0514533557,
-0.8005674481,
0.0759448037,
0.1102948859,
-0.6401423216,
-0.9865365624,
-0.3935721815,
0.6584665179,
-0.6555417776,
-0.4465690255,
-0.0678407922,
-0.5082399249,
0.5666445494,
0.7743071318,
-0.2642531693,
0.0784499124,
0.5912756324,
0.6047036648,
0.2427882552,
0.2077804655,
-0.7163792849,
0.2011247277,
-0.2240986079,
0.9842871428,
-0.554859221,
-0.2725989223,
-0.046945855,
-0.2805909514,
-0.1633412689,
-0.6148396134,
0.6942333579,
-0.7541396022,
0.3332764208,
-0.984650135,
-0.4589100182,
-0.4378527999,
0.9007812142,
-0.5684733391,
0.9397479296,
0.1675973535,
-0.9258286953,
0.7084162831,
-0.5230672956,
-0.2396458536,
0.2755874395,
-0.4453694224,
0.1216708422,
0.5644940734,
-0.0420799442,
0.0129936831,
-0.1965859979,
-0.1130011231,
-0.0001573135,
-0.0661106631,
0.0300118346,
0.0437984243,
0.4373600185,
0.0382260196,
-0.2973343134,
-0.1897194684,
-0.6444661021,
0.1227409765,
-0.2495177835,
-0.3570192456,
-0.9282277822,
0.1919358522,
-0.2103751004,
0.2428288907,
0.2254909575,
-0.7110170722,
-0.1249406859,
-0.4502459466,
-0.3256424963,
0.4450923502,
0.0607766844,
0.3884902894,
-0.2640145123,
0.4572434127,
0.1559439003,
0.0144945914,
-0.1045760363,
-0.1789341718,
-0.7208386064,
-0.0777709857,
0.0621470474,
0.6276605725,
-0.7547938228,
0.1815771013,
-0.310533613,
-0.3319058716,
-0.4075762331,
-0.0221766606,
0.6739609838,
1.2568744421,
0.5280386806,
-0.6790501475,
-0.5496202111,
-1.0042139292,
-0.819778502,
-0.4127440453,
-0.3212002516,
0.6500925422,
0.2783415318,
0.5235106349,
0.8838244677,
-0.5309306383,
-0.6110413074,
-0.1250452548,
0.0726413429,
0.0578072593,
0.1959785223,
0.621928215,
-1.1340670586,
-0.3951139748,
0.1360824257,
-1.0769072771,
0.0143861212,
-0.0217275061,
-0.3319299519,
-0.1111667529,
0.314700067,
-0.4180825055,
0.6372898221,
-0.3969563246,
-0.3209805191,
0.1474056393,
-0.0260320548,
0.4092422426,
-0.7603109479,
0.4087307155,
0.3431655765,
-0.10804452,
-0.4302802682,
0.19817321,
0.276273042,
0.1799132228,
-0.4222154617,
0.3252631128,
-0.7604177594,
-0.1988981962,
-0.1793876886,
0.3774883747,
0.3032718897,
0.1193385869,
0.1619820148,
0.5507954359,
0.362904042,
-0.3897102177,
-0.1834881902,
0.2306316346,
-0.4052107036,
1.1397873163,
-0.2699786127,
0.0784327537,
-0.5559977889,
0.1932602227,
-0.9269241095,
-0.0743453056,
0.208896324,
-0.4908521771,
0.3707181513,
-0.1437376738,
-0.2581985593,
-0.2835316956,
-0.6402595639,
0.2555176318,
0.138148129,
-0.302480489,
0.9151061177,
0.25600034,
0.0890344232,
-0.9447848201,
-0.5400295854,
0.2802378535,
-0.3389237225,
-0.1841870099,
0.347126931,
0.256551832,
-0.4008604884,
-0.1289203763,
-0.5270256996,
0.133898288,
0.0014719174,
0.1983794719,
0.0680708662,
-0.18075113,
-0.0343751684,
-0.1168640405,
0.0676557571,
0.1467726082,
-0.38054654,
0.0190007966,
-0.0414818972,
-0.4818581641,
-0.1347740442,
0.5447182655,
0.1860188842,
-0.4555074573,
0.6735426188,
0.1766037941,
-0.4556247592,
0.3955049217,
-1.0918126106,
0.0279382914,
-0.3752260506,
0.1664443314,
-0.5350814462,
-0.7450529337,
0.5813808441,
0.1264648438,
0.0407968871,
0.4095039368,
0.0585528053,
-0.057366807,
0.8372642398,
1.1270228624,
0.0710916445,
0.7393736243,
0.0015572158,
0.4049881995,
-1.3326413631,
-0.7055808306,
-0.7675126791,
-0.3717439175,
-0.3706235588,
-0.3707755506,
0.4441877902,
0.1612869501,
0.0659691244,
0.3725671768,
-0.7584933043,
0.4746120274,
0.5133529305,
0.3195156455,
0.4301200807,
-0.0565555207,
-0.2410998493,
-0.3576090038,
-0.1351810396,
-0.5265678763,
1.0093911886,
-0.0817864835,
0.4131954908,
0.1793894172,
0.7891218066,
0.1512271613,
0.6330429316,
-0.8831664324,
0.4839053452,
0.043200884,
-0.7928090692,
0.1507832259,
-0.1862291098,
-0.5483651757,
0.6963041425,
0.0414721668,
-1.1553971767,
0.6798205972,
0.0300283637,
-0.5132522583,
0.0007216576,
-0.7418744564,
0.6020507216,
-0.0611822531,
-0.5250636339,
-0.2655337453,
-0.949334383,
0.0316905789,
0.1504350156,
-0.1248482615,
-0.0015447597,
-0.1439272314,
0.4849648476,
-0.0345843062,
0.4876858294,
-0.535140574,
-0.0713053122,
0.2457889467,
0.1777559817,
-0.0347631052,
0.0004465943,
-0.6011033654,
-0.2447850108,
-0.1149025336,
-0.1808166802,
-0.6599543691,
0.4759643376,
-0.3555776775,
-1.0890192986,
-0.5231718421,
-0.4333910346,
-0.2714833021,
0.5437550545,
0.0841616839,
0.2836075127,
-0.3649969995,
0.419496417,
0.9589603543,
-0.0721595958,
0.1962740123,
0.7388504148,
-0.0197346509,
0.0115325972,
0.528044343,
0.2636481225,
-0.1553112119,
1.1074615717,
-0.2128733844,
-0.4340615273,
-0.4404476285,
-0.1853623688,
-0.1028385833,
-0.7821969986,
-0.5859273672,
-0.8622028232,
-0.0690007657,
-0.3810033798,
-0.0244989973,
-0.0525053293,
-0.4322529733,
-0.2064896375,
-0.130916968,
0.0490152873,
0.3358237147,
-0.0923359171,
-0.0308254194,
-0.5379113555,
0.315769136,
0.2306866646,
0.3905553818,
0.0635970235,
-0.4445961416,
-0.2153657824,
-0.170489043,
-0.6617212296,
-0.836356461,
0.136679098,
-0.0136937844,
0.8049605489,
0.433894664,
0.1815040857,
0.6303591728,
-0.4236795902,
0.5243406892,
-0.0296728536,
-0.8036547899,
1.0013241768,
-0.2064741403,
0.0313570127,
0.9569091797,
0.4537802339,
-0.3432245553,
-0.4311795533,
-0.359993279,
-0.7769031525,
0.81889534,
0.2952771187,
-0.0875486135,
-0.0030339097,
0.7165661454,
0.0455858074,
0.4502737224,
-0.503033638,
0.0766899735,
-0.5627276301,
0.1244520992,
0.3603077829,
-0.2124034017,
-0.2082049698,
-0.0879682377,
0.4153534174,
-0.2607706785,
0.2472392023,
0.6873102188,
-0.2466843575,
0.0653011054,
0.4542632699,
0.1773271859,
0.7587377429,
-0.4621048272,
0.1893905252,
-0.1653965861,
-0.5020677447,
-0.0681002364,
0.4933891296,
-0.2871550918,
-0.0929658562,
0.0664545,
0.3271683156,
-0.0051319697,
-0.4250111282,
0.6121593714,
-0.3088861108,
0.0417224653,
-0.221743986,
0.1016740128,
-0.2480098903,
0.5010587573,
0.8016111851,
0.2966598272,
0.7815921903,
-0.3961662054,
-0.0725388229,
0.6901208162,
-0.5767403245,
-0.1724105626,
0.7365949154,
0.1258829832,
-0.0173694585,
0.530415833,
0.1323631853,
-0.3539249599,
0.5179918408,
0.2454881966,
0.9593192935,
-0.0653950498,
-0.0127878897,
0.1860838681,
0.2462417334,
-0.0081062997,
0.2568544149,
-0.5465826392,
-0.708568573,
-0.1207487509,
-0.5373763442,
-0.304538399,
0.0415820628,
-1.1603419781,
0.0309527963,
-0.2931050062,
-0.3184469044,
0.1921866983,
0.2676994801,
-0.6197077036,
0.3076683879,
0.0617679097,
1.1328917742,
-0.4304514825,
0.4676074684,
1.1260510683,
-0.6173363328,
-0.4645715356,
0.4325355589,
0.2078973204,
-0.5616777539,
0.6111811996,
0.5550852418,
-0.5732758045,
-0.3134205937,
-0.3420237899,
-0.8990048766,
1.0171511173,
0.4653581977,
-0.2631492615,
-0.04915208,
-0.1918031722,
0.7818694115,
-0.2402933389,
0.4822912216,
0.3018179834,
0.2821427584,
0.2490061074,
-0.7458100319,
0.0224553719,
-0.3893500268,
0.3265727162,
0.2094916403,
-0.6639785767,
0.4468021989,
-0.1072521508,
-0.2840987742,
0.0338950008,
0.712279737,
0.247210905,
0.4103505909,
0.5276689529,
0.5010195374,
0.7431366444,
0.0693391263,
1.0750851631,
-0.0719147995,
0.1150956973,
0.9977709651,
-0.7529004812,
0.8568979502,
0.7525272965,
0.2144881636,
0.7114742398,
0.2776968479,
0.3424983025,
0.7644962072,
-0.100876011,
-0.3944696486,
-0.3777906001,
-0.4960156977,
-0.5695934296,
0.3311370313,
0.4629000723,
-0.3845975995,
-0.4777933061,
-0.0309338383,
-0.1942224205,
0.3760421276,
-0.2447760105,
0.874199152,
0.0423811972,
-0.7338699102,
0.1316755563,
-0.1582817286,
0.499327302,
-0.2720999718,
-0.0014467763,
-0.2317234129,
0.5279832482,
-0.3440947235,
-0.9825135469,
0.3700914383,
0.0233988017,
-0.6178783774,
-0.47321859,
0.9823668599,
0.0927473381,
-0.3666809201,
0.3623788357,
0.7243409753,
0.0272570401,
-0.4612346888,
-0.4759174883,
-0.2027519196,
0.0536162555,
-0.4220365584,
0.4824418724,
0.7557277679,
-0.2765864134,
0.3753830194,
0.1861803532,
-0.1999649256,
-0.2302688807,
0.2031049728,
1.0112410784,
-0.6841361523,
-0.3311386704,
-0.5086892843,
0.4060468972,
-0.4135549366,
-0.166517511,
0.9160503745,
0.8981536627,
0.931601882,
0.023548767,
0.7117466331,
-0.5130109787,
0.9810621738,
-0.0984347165,
0.5419338346,
-0.8246382475,
0.1229124665,
-0.3720885813,
-0.8856304884,
-0.4218150079,
0.871127367,
-0.5768944025,
0.0896049514,
0.4662628174,
0.4865390956,
-0.128669247,
-0.016189469,
0.0752094761,
0.0013660786,
0.2956081033,
0.5909238458,
0.9577176571,
-0.518463254,
0.5956637263,
-0.1467880458,
-0.3399739563,
-0.0795097798,
-0.9081861377,
-0.6579042077,
-0.4052799642,
-0.2766004801,
-0.1886695623,
0.1148526222,
0.3405174613,
0.5649163127,
-0.517331183,
-0.0479920618,
0.0845758095,
0.1756816357,
-0.1712170839,
-0.2810875475,
-0.0558074042,
-0.3599595726,
-0.2796350718,
0.1579001993,
0.572262764,
-0.3369950056,
0.1625582874,
0.4419378042,
-0.3599453866,
-0.0901277736,
0.8016741276,
0.4103828967,
-0.5711372495,
-0.5864387155,
0.3298218548,
-0.0313323326,
0.5294978619,
1.0226727724,
-1.2623143196,
0.4607959688,
0.4609671533,
0.5728756189,
0.6069310904,
0.2408817559,
0.3700246215,
-0.8832440972,
-0.0283458866,
0.4975532889,
0.129520148,
0.5960892439,
-0.6623666286,
0.4863895476,
0.0452297851,
-0.2895205319,
-0.6447848082,
0.0828590915,
-0.7662542462,
0.0743399113,
0.6198368669,
-0.2525413334,
-0.0418570675,
-0.0430850796,
-0.1629476845,
0.2218759805,
-0.4653241932,
0.9467042089,
0.6775616407,
-0.5988068581,
-0.1183129922,
-0.5645778179,
0.2249467671,
0.5852860212,
-0.8266847134,
0.047291711,
0.818993926,
0.310243696,
0.6132169962,
0.8862291574,
-0.4491769075,
0.1209118962,
-0.3315449655,
-0.1418267637,
0.6265380383,
-0.3648084998,
-0.0852945969,
0.2734710276,
0.0692820251,
-0.1485006511
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02712v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02712v1
|
CoE-SQL: In-Context Learning for Multi-Turn Text-to-SQL with Chain-of-Editions
| 2024-05-04T16:56:14 | 2024-05-04T16:56:14 |
Hanchong Zhang, Ruisheng Cao, Hongshen Xu, Lu Chen, Kai Yu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, Large Language Models (LLMs) have been demonstrated to possess
impressive capabilities in a variety of domains and tasks. We investigate the
issue of prompt design in the multi-turn text-to-SQL task and attempt to
enhance the LLMs' reasoning capacity when generating SQL queries. In the
conversational context, the current SQL query can be modified from the
preceding SQL query with only a few operations due to the context dependency.
We introduce our method called CoE-SQL which can prompt LLMs to generate the
SQL query based on the previously generated SQL query with an edition chain. We
also conduct extensive ablation studies to determine the optimal configuration
of our approach. Our approach outperforms different in-context learning
baselines stably and achieves state-of-the-art performances on two benchmarks
SParC and CoSQL using LLMs, which is also competitive to the SOTA fine-tuned
models.
|
[
-0.4521495402,
-0.9856079221,
0.6800236106,
0.2680236995,
-0.3801147044,
0.0842205435,
-0.4213799536,
-0.2152010053,
-0.168639496,
0.7748977542,
-0.9435113668,
-0.6106701493,
-0.0606911592,
0.4573620558,
-0.2556425035,
0.9254972935,
0.2867433727,
0.2288208306,
-0.5095433593,
-0.3451315463,
-0.6551499963,
-0.8473797441,
-0.678129673,
-0.1556017846,
0.4731012285,
0.5431002975,
0.2557206154,
0.1615336835,
0.0868549719,
0.2468450516,
-0.2010792494,
0.6555214524,
-0.4347543418,
0.616116643,
-0.329285413,
-0.3332130611,
-0.3268087506,
-0.3649042845,
0.6966890097,
0.6970630884,
-0.2295342982,
-0.3206303418,
0.2278060764,
0.8334878683,
-0.4886666834,
-0.3572283983,
-0.9806718826,
-0.2991268933,
0.0789917633,
-0.4179195762,
-1.0313835144,
-0.164955169,
0.1341198683,
-0.4794819355,
0.0661585778,
0.6420378685,
0.364054203,
0.0801042244,
-0.677090764,
-0.6520095468,
-0.4531057775,
0.7748274803,
-0.3868435621,
0.584554255,
-0.2158038318,
0.1964655668,
-0.4615723491,
-0.5795993209,
-0.3807375133,
-0.3183353841,
-0.0997903422,
-0.0774274841,
0.3141611814,
-0.11929629,
0.2848060131,
0.184833169,
-0.4788683057,
0.1612371802,
-0.0074099647,
0.15215832,
0.6016869545,
0.3397904038,
0.1026014239,
0.0400459841,
-0.7446291447,
0.1973222345,
-1.2228039503,
-0.1339406967,
0.0401391983,
0.7800694704,
0.0434374288,
0.6029269099,
-0.0172470976,
0.9957694411,
0.1694541723,
0.163763687,
-0.0810316205,
-0.3743247986,
-0.2249721736,
0.1079521328,
0.7160824537,
0.1452478319,
-0.0340167135,
-0.1696481109,
-0.175732702,
-0.2130888999,
0.1437821984,
-0.7389688492,
0.3064414561,
0.2571526766,
-0.041567035,
0.0947832242,
-0.1775262207,
-0.7505507469,
-0.5492658615,
-0.5943444371,
0.1650288552,
-0.5543388724,
-0.0636397004,
-0.1714331657,
0.1168624237,
0.315312773,
0.4641495943,
-0.7582823634,
0.39248541,
0.496981293,
0.7464908957,
-0.7308629155,
-0.1748447567,
-0.8227558732,
0.3232623637,
-0.2787206471,
0.8088564873,
-0.5057573915,
-0.647465229,
0.1371664107,
0.0316955,
-0.0318119228,
-0.5467715859,
0.1673726439,
-0.6539716125,
0.2157770842,
-0.490398109,
-0.686986804,
0.2976455688,
0.3575438857,
-0.3847103119,
1.0690364838,
0.0615836531,
-0.5958597064,
0.2776667476,
-0.6178421974,
-0.7299410105,
0.0398685522,
-0.3605220616,
-0.2695156932,
0.0083911205,
0.3021458983,
0.2852874696,
-0.3008869886,
0.1802107245,
-0.0669879392,
-0.2087099701,
0.331857115,
-0.078572996,
0.8143255711,
0.216098994,
-0.0909497216,
0.2143316418,
-0.6049943566,
-0.2336625457,
-0.0171083175,
-0.362739563,
-0.3543058038,
0.0234652199,
-0.164002493,
0.2827430665,
0.0897862315,
-0.3217537999,
0.4514397681,
-0.4473074079,
0.3107374609,
0.6009107232,
0.219384715,
0.6982991099,
0.0237143356,
0.214750126,
0.2340167761,
0.0901878625,
-0.3673389256,
-0.2087211907,
-0.7021846175,
-0.2271371484,
0.042542506,
0.478351891,
-0.9953567982,
0.2895110548,
0.2330508381,
-0.2716096342,
0.0771322623,
0.0434673131,
0.2835026085,
0.4859944582,
0.554246068,
0.0069028623,
-0.4541057646,
-0.4193613231,
-0.6307449341,
0.1225393042,
0.1958528161,
0.7313145995,
0.3741259575,
-0.0661163032,
1.0349570513,
-0.5403727293,
-0.357899785,
-0.3995200098,
-0.0519930832,
0.1506620049,
0.3748508096,
0.3493364751,
-0.57205832,
-0.5106288791,
0.0216624606,
-0.6977926493,
0.0365091041,
-0.2267110199,
-0.3563456535,
0.8268166184,
0.740886569,
-0.2984249592,
0.0285827499,
0.2539054453,
-0.4186130464,
0.6909927726,
-0.2734042704,
0.1420086324,
-1.1007143259,
-0.2535669208,
0.0837054849,
-0.0855512992,
-0.5500211716,
-0.1124024689,
0.0331672728,
-0.2069942355,
-0.6123230457,
0.6245802641,
-0.6336954832,
-0.1297359169,
-0.0295996647,
0.356795758,
0.142001465,
0.5501119494,
0.2824853063,
1.0180106163,
0.4128935337,
-1.0329360962,
0.1471861303,
0.4129287899,
-0.2575817108,
0.942846179,
-0.5480893254,
0.2919592559,
-0.1186568066,
0.4068465829,
-1.0785832405,
-0.1052146405,
-0.1138724387,
-0.2910473943,
0.2237003595,
-0.17631872,
-0.3576158583,
-0.0288791358,
0.0471562408,
0.1081110612,
0.2792241573,
-0.8923125863,
0.6984639168,
0.1018185988,
-0.1648008823,
-0.552235961,
-0.6313824058,
0.0158889256,
-0.2468894869,
-0.540887773,
0.5762073398,
-0.1039950326,
-0.2973978221,
-0.4497085512,
-0.0305048637,
-0.0157772508,
-0.1465987265,
-0.1679266095,
0.498354286,
0.0162189957,
0.2879632115,
0.3805121779,
0.0822759643,
0.0173334666,
-0.2912479937,
0.5928022265,
-0.0127891973,
-0.2369211018,
-0.1581672132,
0.7551730275,
0.4583513439,
-0.1519507766,
0.8819577098,
0.1083774418,
-0.1616712213,
-0.5384613872,
-0.4740645885,
-0.4168616235,
-0.4881497025,
0.1809340715,
-0.5896491408,
-0.9461914897,
0.3339423537,
-0.5488845706,
0.1866138875,
0.2636737525,
0.770144999,
-0.1472187787,
1.0013076067,
0.3841242492,
0.3571650684,
0.7302772999,
-0.1202850342,
0.0928994268,
-0.9198919535,
-0.4660071731,
-0.7773928642,
0.424949646,
-0.297637105,
-0.1548001617,
0.6537916064,
-0.029640371,
-0.5002405047,
0.2825832665,
-0.6156381369,
0.4943059981,
0.3181875944,
0.3263965845,
0.4682376683,
0.1923547089,
-0.3809093237,
0.1019641608,
-0.7182322741,
-0.3382350206,
0.7338801026,
-0.280377984,
0.8053556681,
0.166777432,
0.7333409786,
0.2457942814,
0.1035985053,
-0.5637564659,
0.5135830641,
-0.1004722267,
-0.413836509,
-0.2858059406,
-0.4125855565,
-0.7743970156,
0.2675809264,
-0.2501473427,
-0.5752601027,
0.0700474083,
0.1024372876,
-0.216112569,
-0.0997351706,
-0.7632530928,
0.8031973243,
-0.3394475877,
-0.7445229292,
-0.1517809331,
-0.6672218442,
0.2090332657,
0.2593788803,
0.2698800266,
0.1342394948,
-0.2091161609,
0.3049884439,
-0.4234793782,
0.6677334905,
-0.2617839277,
-0.1666788757,
0.4508783221,
0.0325348452,
0.8188773394,
0.2433287948,
-0.4976781309,
-0.3591938317,
-0.2111967951,
-0.0703648925,
-0.6741420627,
0.695468843,
-0.4602605999,
-0.6619060636,
-0.3304320276,
-0.4042996764,
-0.3628950715,
0.0765750706,
0.3873325586,
0.7384641171,
-0.3972470164,
0.0332357287,
0.866620481,
-0.3529255092,
0.3549292088,
0.3682744503,
-0.1150793731,
-0.3384540379,
0.6645613909,
0.037800312,
0.4648887813,
0.3353660107,
0.0201459732,
-0.8605729342,
-0.3839831948,
-0.727258563,
0.2310254425,
-0.7633128762,
-0.2523797154,
-0.6632750034,
-0.0702819303,
-0.2795225382,
-0.3986418843,
-0.1385488361,
-0.1133178324,
-0.5174543262,
0.3115540743,
0.6578830481,
0.583779335,
0.5458606482,
0.4218587577,
-0.5839059353,
0.0068307407,
0.1769087017,
0.2424134165,
-0.108777836,
-0.508243084,
-0.1313329339,
-0.2639681399,
-0.4112611413,
-0.9894860387,
0.230799526,
0.2925465703,
0.519505918,
0.039518971,
0.4222303033,
0.4625617564,
-0.6470037699,
0.9056435227,
0.3588918149,
-0.981921494,
0.7408319116,
-0.3160487413,
0.2216941863,
0.6318644285,
0.4150141478,
-0.4329178333,
-0.3029472828,
-0.6035391688,
-0.817966938,
0.6860287786,
-0.0680218711,
0.0410111584,
-0.2074251026,
0.4254619181,
0.3163920641,
0.1698714942,
-0.4524442255,
-0.2927198112,
0.1304629892,
-0.0418415554,
0.2497202158,
-0.248462826,
0.0314160921,
-0.2767619789,
0.7224326134,
-0.4858947992,
0.2167103291,
0.2644577026,
-0.2836837471,
0.3983678222,
0.5391099453,
0.5216908455,
0.8265247941,
0.0530547276,
0.0671092793,
0.5508087873,
0.0477787852,
0.1099606305,
-0.3780753911,
0.0649978444,
-0.074039489,
-0.061802417,
0.8204600215,
0.0870818719,
-0.5987846851,
0.4167702794,
-0.0765575767,
-0.1045368463,
-0.1283672601,
0.0558069423,
0.1658569872,
0.1835568249,
0.451824367,
-0.0241090413,
0.190461874,
-0.5826585293,
0.2613277435,
0.5025100708,
-0.3216185272,
0.0942780823,
0.3632636666,
0.3928673267,
-0.4406169057,
0.7713360786,
-0.2069662213,
-0.431334734,
0.2926330268,
0.9658578634,
0.4868617654,
-0.302824527,
-0.0846895576,
0.4932392538,
-0.0389762782,
-0.0437350199,
0.4830578566,
-0.1227185577,
-0.5550182462,
-0.4422419667,
-0.3153010607,
-0.6920775175,
-0.3608682156,
-0.5268290043,
0.699549675,
-0.3144237995,
-0.032553602,
-0.2032776028,
-0.0648167804,
-0.2910020351,
0.1691109389,
-0.2092045546,
1.0024881363,
-0.6257057786,
0.7759702206,
0.5389149189,
-0.2830122411,
-0.463426441,
-0.2233437896,
-0.1561451256,
-0.4657514989,
0.2192077935,
0.0896945074,
-0.1452271193,
0.1911078393,
-0.6404889822,
-0.3683419824,
0.9287071824,
0.4802794158,
-0.6659021378,
0.0836310536,
0.0285670888,
0.2590987086,
-0.8432018161,
0.166257143,
0.7726814151,
0.1913105547,
0.4657478929,
-0.3486003876,
0.12907888,
0.1856693476,
0.0079056062,
0.1097172499,
-0.509675324,
0.7918563485,
-0.3636112511,
-0.1424237937,
-0.0266561192,
0.8470598459,
0.8217033744,
0.2355825007,
0.63519454,
0.0582784452,
0.8297482133,
-0.1436787844,
0.931755662,
-0.0857939571,
0.2095007598,
1.2078106403,
-0.5343004465,
0.8147008419,
0.7968962789,
-0.0670188814,
0.7833449841,
0.6863558888,
0.3879892826,
0.5593893528,
0.2741057873,
-0.5266734958,
-0.3604223728,
-0.3011086285,
-0.2932565212,
0.0102562048,
0.6983131766,
-0.1639168262,
-0.133554697,
0.1327391565,
0.0068868217,
0.2627609968,
-0.2413921356,
1.1327605247,
0.2175522745,
-0.8854429722,
0.5799456835,
-0.1819549203,
0.579544127,
-0.4631351829,
-0.0415772386,
-0.3402727842,
0.135684371,
-0.2484769672,
-0.6585930586,
0.425898999,
-0.0793708339,
-0.1165322512,
-0.0366554894,
0.5694676638,
-0.6816119552,
-0.3034090102,
0.2644143403,
0.5129816532,
0.0242743175,
-0.1190652996,
-0.6580315828,
0.2570354044,
-0.1544533521,
-0.2039930969,
0.3136402369,
0.6134086251,
-0.1456883252,
0.485147506,
0.3965574205,
-0.2669166923,
-0.0255513508,
0.3473499119,
0.9118530154,
-0.4863177538,
-0.5417323112,
-1.0263239145,
0.4157886803,
-0.2648496926,
-0.1578989923,
0.5793966055,
0.6311326623,
0.4931445718,
-0.028699033,
0.6735950112,
-0.1052584574,
0.3218303919,
-0.7287641764,
0.25036937,
-0.7217601538,
0.4238296747,
-0.2626199126,
-0.8845059872,
-0.2989826202,
0.2726995647,
-0.1583516151,
0.0655223429,
1.0179340839,
0.9029313326,
0.3067544997,
0.2244614363,
0.1290983558,
-0.0442591645,
0.2484111786,
0.5363714695,
0.9943691492,
-0.2722691,
0.4551475048,
0.2875651419,
-0.326513052,
-0.2839664519,
-0.9835470915,
-1.0793862343,
-0.8032553196,
-0.1625807732,
-0.6050359011,
0.1756845266,
1.232937932,
0.6026438475,
-0.7066185474,
-0.4240539968,
-0.197374329,
0.5061446428,
-0.4010642469,
-0.1652646363,
0.4449299276,
-0.9244397879,
-0.7184014916,
0.5957148671,
0.2400851697,
-0.1342793107,
-0.1980993003,
-0.2380435765,
-0.470949918,
0.1681249589,
0.9319396615,
-0.1234091446,
-0.5528006554,
-0.1686703712,
0.219520539,
-0.1662179828,
0.2703166008,
1.0775051117,
-0.7734111547,
0.1050189883,
0.4493230283,
0.6618734598,
0.7125934958,
0.0142546669,
0.6861909628,
-1.1435079575,
0.0573636889,
0.11331328,
0.2883319557,
0.3804864585,
-0.6613518596,
0.4731093347,
0.1471872926,
-0.54112041,
-0.6899386048,
0.3480485082,
-1.0547822714,
-0.4684531391,
1.3476917744,
0.1117977351,
-0.3642074168,
-0.3384719789,
-0.4582878649,
0.2420085818,
-0.5455186963,
0.262337774,
0.357381314,
-0.3849593103,
-0.1667694747,
0.0829453394,
0.5470845699,
0.2337049842,
-0.9440672994,
0.4461465478,
0.5731434822,
0.1839574128,
-0.2332545519,
0.5931928754,
-0.2255071402,
0.0496570356,
-0.2397593707,
-0.130636245,
0.0223534033,
-0.681783855,
-0.1719347388,
0.2004646659,
0.1584411412,
0.185240835
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02710v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02710v1
|
Enhancing News Summarization with ELearnFit through Efficient In-Context Learning and Efficient Fine-Tuning
| 2024-05-04T16:48:05 | 2024-05-04T16:48:05 |
Che Guan, Andrew Chin, Puya Vahabi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
With the deluge of information delivered by the daily news cycle, there is a
growing need to effectively and efficiently summarize news feeds for quick
consumption. We leverage large language models (LLMs), with their advanced
learning and generative abilities as compared to conventional language models,
to generate concise and coherent summaries for news articles from the XSum
dataset. Our paper focuses on two key aspects of LLMs: Efficient in-context
Learning (ELearn) and Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning (EFit). Under ELearn, we
find that increasing the number of shots in prompts and utilizing simple
templates generally improve the quality of summaries. We also find that
utilizing relevant examples in few-shot learning for ELearn does not improve
model performance. In addition, we studied EFit using different methods and
demonstrate that fine-tuning the first layer of LLMs produces better outcomes
as compared to fine-tuning other layers or utilizing LoRA. We also find that
leveraging more relevant training samples using selective layers does not
result in better performance. By combining ELearn and EFit, we create a new
model (ELearnFit) that leverages the benefits of both few-shot learning and
fine-tuning and produces superior performance to either model alone. We also
use ELearnFit to highlight the trade-offs between prompting and fine-tuning,
especially for situations where only a limited number of annotated samples are
available. Ultimately, our research provides practical techniques to optimize
news summarization during the prompting and fine-tuning stages and enhances the
synthesis of news articles.
|
[
-0.346825242,
-0.7020583153,
0.3667869866,
0.010902104,
-0.4321213365,
0.0452935621,
-0.4295480847,
-0.5023996234,
0.2682017982,
0.1653582454,
-0.5504912734,
-0.5317328572,
-0.4481937289,
0.0859036371,
-0.7204491496,
1.4611781836,
0.2183032483,
-0.1595939249,
-0.1014210507,
-0.0945197195,
-0.1176704541,
-0.145858705,
-0.9977661967,
-0.1978069246,
0.7204703093,
0.5797150731,
0.5149553418,
0.6570421457,
0.4199638367,
0.1742094606,
-0.1402725428,
0.4147786796,
-0.7685574293,
0.0536908321,
-0.024556227,
-0.3988218904,
-0.4631731808,
-0.2462081015,
0.5265412331,
0.7237407565,
0.0496372879,
0.182580471,
0.3199150562,
0.7863752246,
-0.5953803658,
0.02501137,
-0.6430819035,
-0.2188362777,
0.0025961276,
-0.2108067572,
-0.1031005159,
-0.0848971158,
0.2587274611,
-0.7330693603,
0.1979550719,
-0.0237451065,
0.9069724083,
0.3363221884,
-0.4321825504,
-0.2752148211,
-0.5257885456,
0.709959805,
-0.7891043425,
0.3907691836,
0.2964042425,
0.0515415333,
0.0282565728,
-0.6699925065,
-0.2712997496,
-0.1217767373,
-0.210153982,
0.282369107,
0.0470858961,
0.0315815397,
-0.0296194535,
0.4312138855,
-0.5948802829,
0.2525903583,
-0.2792262733,
0.1144094989,
0.6344795823,
0.1891271472,
-0.0172291547,
-0.3036609888,
-0.1098138392,
-0.0237233862,
-0.7704493999,
-0.1046125889,
0.2933383882,
0.4002679586,
-0.0861434266,
0.436852932,
-0.4309944808,
0.6644586921,
-0.059433572,
-0.4236704409,
0.1330913305,
-0.456289947,
-0.1830156744,
0.0993432105,
0.2925291657,
0.6757891178,
0.1555103809,
0.1707918644,
-0.3708874285,
-0.1854786575,
-0.0205480643,
-0.8132051229,
-0.1528948992,
0.3668569028,
-0.3218437433,
-0.4405997992,
0.1891729981,
-0.7062076926,
-0.1427088827,
-0.450216651,
0.3949045241,
-0.2321975827,
0.1250444949,
0.2428506464,
-0.2357012779,
0.1033184305,
0.6810905337,
-0.8238331676,
0.2426572442,
0.7527960539,
0.9211755395,
-0.2380539179,
-0.2767241597,
-0.7403581738,
0.252348125,
-0.1566570699,
0.8632355332,
-0.147395581,
-0.026535064,
0.1657590121,
-0.1435221583,
0.0163336638,
-0.4064542651,
0.3221280277,
-0.5515924692,
0.3895045221,
-0.1864840835,
-0.8399091959,
-0.1919527799,
0.2946517169,
-0.7132572532,
0.861911118,
0.1203697994,
-0.6628121138,
0.3941627145,
-0.6748813391,
-0.8434891701,
-0.2438967228,
0.1025847942,
-0.4280106425,
0.200739488,
0.5896712542,
0.7053610086,
0.1918298155,
0.0146440035,
0.1160280257,
-0.2923672497,
-0.2032892704,
-0.2785470188,
0.4127908051,
0.1929911673,
-0.2671112716,
-0.0932369307,
-0.7777703404,
-0.295524776,
-0.03091418,
-0.5531489253,
-0.4723298252,
0.0360028408,
0.1913961321,
-0.0496438965,
0.0979972035,
-0.1795589626,
0.01114845,
-0.6014873385,
0.4091366827,
0.4231322706,
0.2969191968,
0.5623651743,
-0.7008667588,
0.2691899836,
-0.1423661858,
-0.1645699292,
-0.9716745615,
-0.0538124777,
-0.82097435,
-0.1784659922,
0.425241977,
0.5198776722,
-0.6285299063,
0.1749755591,
-0.279504478,
-0.3056927919,
-0.2805122137,
0.3262692392,
0.1916563809,
0.5905430913,
0.2633491457,
0.1603295654,
-0.6247401237,
-0.640604198,
-0.3789053559,
0.142377466,
-0.1155221686,
0.0525387451,
0.6020732522,
0.1625641137,
0.722926259,
-0.5147178173,
-0.4361833334,
-0.476719588,
0.1481585205,
0.2499335855,
0.2081339061,
0.6094961166,
-0.8543976545,
-0.448867023,
0.0685170293,
-0.4448203146,
-0.1757549644,
-0.4425487816,
0.1670841873,
0.31239748,
0.663951993,
-0.253731519,
0.2497427911,
0.479170382,
-0.1195313409,
0.3328682184,
-0.0557763055,
0.2160627246,
-1.138507247,
-0.1229861677,
0.1367018968,
-0.8049356341,
-0.4255213737,
0.1922571361,
0.0977894366,
-0.0231493488,
-0.8255812526,
0.728718102,
-0.3302629292,
0.1384829581,
-0.4349783063,
0.4344518483,
0.3333616555,
0.4379611611,
0.0007487019,
0.6900458336,
0.0552311651,
-0.7542943954,
0.0413424335,
0.1388725787,
-0.5784087777,
0.2852464318,
-0.769182384,
-0.4192151129,
-0.3767428994,
0.3131006658,
-0.7348490953,
-0.6069610715,
-0.3413048387,
-0.1932735592,
0.1311866343,
0.261074394,
-0.4925915301,
-0.0325062126,
-0.7906857133,
0.1923201829,
0.3927257955,
-0.6002116799,
0.3457024097,
0.2101596445,
-0.414010644,
-0.2682136297,
-0.6366415024,
-0.0757629052,
-0.2279230803,
-0.5128390789,
0.7238842845,
0.0170685686,
-0.2702763081,
0.1407933682,
-0.0825767741,
0.1439756602,
0.2019528747,
-0.2108937651,
0.0592645295,
-0.2066758424,
0.2880053222,
0.4294891059,
-0.0504972637,
-0.3622514307,
-0.2503789365,
0.2885791361,
0.0972947255,
-0.2295507193,
-0.4550001025,
0.6260128617,
0.6455637813,
-0.2824991643,
0.7009444833,
0.4627305865,
-0.4511758387,
-0.2760307789,
-0.4983742237,
-0.4562818408,
-0.326775372,
0.6534905434,
-0.0459090099,
-1.0269197226,
0.601627171,
0.0385967232,
0.5681781769,
0.4998297393,
0.6201715469,
-0.3072605729,
1.1415786743,
0.7157006264,
-0.2102066129,
0.9841912389,
-0.3368850648,
-0.1141660064,
-0.5268848538,
0.0098836385,
-0.2564592957,
-0.4094994962,
-0.340446353,
0.1896633208,
0.7062447071,
-0.1661450118,
-0.1558018774,
0.1122003421,
0.0342672542,
0.9015100002,
0.6130200624,
0.2133302391,
0.6648187041,
0.1352078617,
0.2643380761,
0.1115641892,
-0.9198518395,
-0.3724721372,
0.8691408634,
0.3844165802,
0.9017605782,
0.0365443006,
0.7088705301,
0.2340941131,
0.0271624085,
-0.69587183,
0.120565705,
-0.4660235643,
-0.3739625812,
-0.1748090386,
-0.2513984442,
-0.7739490867,
0.2844951749,
-0.3060987592,
-0.4382033348,
0.0715226084,
0.1401135772,
-0.8573223948,
0.1716174483,
-0.7193587422,
0.4842319191,
-0.0793064162,
-0.3259710968,
-0.4025362134,
-0.5160163641,
0.3713587224,
-0.0889873132,
0.2326057404,
0.0876227543,
-0.1892005205,
0.6307752728,
-0.4350230098,
0.8917849064,
0.297576189,
-0.1980110109,
0.1284333766,
-0.2536360919,
0.5502843857,
0.3917016983,
-0.0813796148,
-0.1630443037,
-0.1521079391,
-0.461892724,
-0.6228192449,
0.7035765052,
-0.7452697158,
-0.5473603606,
-0.0903953314,
-0.6412164569,
-0.0205778405,
0.1603380442,
0.5161538124,
0.712440908,
-0.2336392999,
0.5078118443,
0.7040172219,
0.0513412543,
0.5796740651,
0.3384036422,
-0.2423653603,
-0.3984130323,
0.6778686643,
0.3572059274,
0.2228842676,
0.6805204749,
0.0665710494,
-0.0768524781,
-0.4147255421,
-0.3173385561,
0.2160684913,
-0.5657185316,
-0.5505981445,
-0.7483144999,
-0.3014905751,
-0.3031278849,
-0.5356135368,
-0.3281700015,
-0.6369052529,
-0.3674275577,
-0.2175625414,
0.2857194245,
0.5209516883,
0.0436502062,
0.6249873638,
-0.8673195243,
0.2995480597,
0.3294066191,
-0.0350889117,
0.0343670733,
-0.5745489001,
-0.7817280889,
0.0758667737,
-0.3007205427,
-0.7347512245,
0.2734302282,
0.5333528519,
0.3352551758,
0.5501849055,
0.0390376933,
0.6127305627,
-0.4039663374,
0.8023633957,
-0.1154391542,
-0.8042764068,
0.841332078,
-0.7272636294,
0.4787631631,
0.764836967,
0.2815908492,
-0.3973333538,
-0.6003196239,
-0.4837094247,
-1.1543097496,
0.3876723051,
0.1418673843,
0.3911249638,
-0.1183511615,
0.471293807,
0.2696792483,
0.3221816719,
-0.4972181022,
-0.0807271227,
-0.0447282195,
-0.2780859768,
-0.0239994507,
-0.201416105,
-0.0580281131,
-0.4732462764,
0.8783962131,
-0.164938882,
-0.2025231421,
0.1994186044,
-0.5802366734,
-0.034771651,
0.0100923721,
0.8768132925,
0.6056743264,
-0.0782168582,
0.0637018457,
0.3246029019,
-0.3240314722,
-0.0860853791,
0.0837213546,
-0.3824629486,
0.2052733004,
0.6573064923,
0.8101343513,
0.6456514597,
-0.6786466241,
0.7076619267,
-0.0259125214,
-0.2590056658,
-0.1878434718,
0.3683528304,
-0.0912129804,
0.3395524025,
0.5538878441,
-0.1487905085,
0.1162877083,
-0.3847127557,
0.3076205254,
0.1846864522,
0.1351865232,
-0.2096103281,
0.7266378999,
0.4282208681,
0.0782243237,
0.4130269885,
-0.2264208496,
-0.3181215823,
0.6744653583,
0.5248507261,
0.7092695832,
0.0102669951,
0.249287039,
0.3760074973,
0.2502267063,
-0.2293006927,
-0.0541221686,
0.1008894145,
-0.5615531206,
-0.7742714286,
-0.4093648195,
-0.4643998444,
0.2380231917,
-0.602953136,
0.6204843521,
-0.1779461503,
0.0650953427,
-0.0469024144,
0.3176493943,
-0.5886994004,
0.0969257727,
0.0508560985,
1.2581677437,
-1.0287343264,
0.3721137643,
0.8248605728,
-0.3011983931,
-0.6060875058,
0.1039705649,
0.075824447,
-0.4596655369,
0.0213565119,
0.0935654417,
0.2650280297,
0.2800487876,
-0.4347445369,
-0.7426880002,
1.2898273468,
0.5053751469,
-0.6858518124,
-0.1896983236,
-0.3384132981,
0.2345176786,
-0.5089951158,
0.2227735966,
0.5245431066,
0.5185314417,
-0.0689219609,
-0.7082715034,
-0.3806773722,
-0.0270909183,
-0.1184067279,
0.1987053454,
-0.6934992075,
0.7535138726,
-0.4136126339,
-0.1726053506,
-0.0689326599,
0.934189558,
0.0030882452,
0.3597299755,
0.3556161225,
0.5576091409,
0.8326960802,
0.1242501438,
1.1483381987,
-0.331073463,
0.4112715423,
1.325095892,
0.0649977773,
0.8052071333,
0.3790804446,
0.167731449,
0.5244320631,
0.6745944023,
0.1359309256,
0.6822065115,
-0.2502241731,
-0.3266459703,
-0.030919563,
-0.2053319067,
-0.2234372795,
0.5428331494,
0.3520222306,
-0.4445454776,
-0.7757408619,
0.5032900572,
0.3109138906,
0.0674027503,
-0.6158044934,
0.9483965635,
0.1200188696,
-0.609680295,
0.1977778822,
0.1031983495,
0.6805975437,
-0.5020087361,
0.0640466437,
-0.4131174684,
-0.0405095629,
-0.4231210053,
-0.4945115149,
0.3240891397,
0.1196111515,
-0.3998575509,
-0.0919436067,
0.775801897,
-0.691558063,
-0.4993516803,
-0.0492431894,
0.8708873391,
-0.1085057557,
-0.1708575636,
-0.3867332041,
-0.0212174319,
-0.106834121,
-0.76771909,
0.2966046631,
0.3975064158,
-0.1126017645,
0.3719779551,
0.7116627097,
0.1645771116,
-0.239416644,
0.274392873,
0.9132364988,
-0.4629249573,
-0.7147152424,
-1.0164532661,
0.565610826,
-0.0255071335,
-0.2801953852,
0.5756951571,
0.5942482948,
1.0156296492,
0.0250544567,
0.6383541822,
0.1923769712,
0.3986379504,
-0.769462049,
0.7565985918,
-0.7584760785,
0.2872367203,
-0.1615338922,
-0.9444023967,
-0.6799801588,
0.5956424475,
-0.1224137843,
0.0996977538,
0.7069817185,
0.7398383021,
-0.1689555049,
0.0516637824,
0.446709305,
0.0868444219,
0.1758353114,
0.4274653792,
0.531168282,
-0.4572574496,
0.3808547556,
-0.3047392666,
-0.2274285257,
-0.5595325828,
-1.1304411888,
-0.8480170369,
-0.594597578,
-0.430632025,
0.0241180453,
0.2300902754,
1.1524184942,
0.8555272222,
-0.7378384471,
0.0805626959,
-0.017217461,
0.3897784054,
-0.2946985066,
-0.2516531348,
0.4491910338,
-0.5887383223,
-1.0129203796,
0.1681972891,
0.271720171,
0.0096375011,
-0.1537888348,
0.0950795114,
-0.068939358,
0.0466390513,
0.9996545911,
0.0735009387,
-0.2240644395,
-0.2409615964,
0.0453580879,
-0.0494380556,
-0.0212126169,
0.8070798516,
-0.9066724777,
-0.0478210561,
0.577332437,
0.8936918974,
0.4054874778,
0.0786573589,
0.3833268881,
-1.0648611784,
0.0300358962,
0.018416049,
0.3743534386,
0.2842489183,
-0.5399674773,
0.4500626028,
-0.1341791749,
-0.5688408017,
-0.6888491511,
0.0417662747,
-0.6004914045,
-0.2677517235,
1.1618076563,
0.0841216221,
-0.3287993073,
0.0494161285,
-0.1721058339,
0.1600829363,
-0.5067880154,
0.6434008479,
0.5144944191,
-0.2023554742,
-0.3789454401,
-0.7957330346,
0.3658635616,
0.3530748188,
-0.823402524,
-0.1512506455,
0.3719220459,
0.1944628954,
-0.1173152551,
0.5389207006,
0.1084687561,
0.4115123749,
-0.4182053208,
-0.4402567744,
-0.2141834944,
-0.5522183776,
-0.4161899686,
0.1458704174,
-0.1248810291,
-0.0312048364
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06674v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06674v1
|
Open-SQL Framework: Enhancing Text-to-SQL on Open-source Large Language Models
| 2024-05-04T15:40:17 | 2024-05-04T15:40:17 |
Xiaojun Chen, Tianle Wang, Tianhao Qiu, Jianbin Qin, Min Yang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Despite the success of large language models (LLMs) in Text-to-SQL tasks,
open-source LLMs encounter challenges in contextual understanding and response
coherence. To tackle these issues, we present \ours, a systematic methodology
tailored for Text-to-SQL with open-source LLMs. Our contributions include a
comprehensive evaluation of open-source LLMs in Text-to-SQL tasks, the
\openprompt strategy for effective question representation, and novel
strategies for supervised fine-tuning. We explore the benefits of
Chain-of-Thought in step-by-step inference and propose the \openexample method
for enhanced few-shot learning. Additionally, we introduce token-efficient
techniques, such as \textbf{Variable-length Open DB Schema}, \textbf{Target
Column Truncation}, and \textbf{Example Column Truncation}, addressing
challenges in large-scale databases. Our findings emphasize the need for
further investigation into the impact of supervised fine-tuning on contextual
learning capabilities. Remarkably, our method significantly improved Llama2-7B
from 2.54\% to 41.04\% and Code Llama-7B from 14.54\% to 48.24\% on the
BIRD-Dev dataset. Notably, the performance of Code Llama-7B surpassed GPT-4
(46.35\%) on the BIRD-Dev dataset.
|
[
-0.462693423,
-1.053014636,
0.3918910325,
0.1491568238,
-0.2655001283,
-0.3290857673,
-0.6263122559,
-0.431294024,
0.032580357,
0.7682381868,
-0.5286977291,
-0.8184350729,
-0.2034547478,
0.1358401924,
-0.4086517096,
0.8442691565,
0.1134461984,
0.0989946127,
-0.2111369818,
-0.1834806204,
-0.4501125515,
-0.5560817122,
-0.4268780351,
0.120443888,
0.4831759334,
0.6570606828,
0.4991758466,
0.6634169221,
0.7278962135,
0.1160954237,
-0.2328252643,
0.1552973688,
-0.8098671436,
0.289848417,
-0.5143776536,
-0.6108127236,
-0.5519461036,
-0.4639814496,
0.5077752471,
0.8584959507,
-0.2854160666,
0.2493526191,
0.1232236177,
0.8521792293,
-0.8288513422,
0.273804009,
-0.7534013391,
0.1685928404,
-0.4525910318,
-0.13430731,
-0.5143550634,
-0.0842216015,
-0.0559456311,
-0.612372458,
0.0876296684,
0.2159948051,
0.3773663342,
0.2951929867,
-0.3089546859,
-0.2105123252,
-0.700168252,
0.6032798886,
-0.6205536127,
0.3000601828,
0.2786322534,
0.3869914412,
-0.4092696011,
-0.702074945,
-0.4030202925,
-0.1525356025,
-0.0313502625,
-0.02339218,
0.119129613,
0.0676132515,
0.3404601812,
0.5360846519,
-0.5517548919,
0.2048539221,
-0.1716148555,
0.0763768628,
0.5085878372,
0.0866716579,
-0.1435321569,
0.1375647485,
-0.1706500053,
0.048694808,
-0.9535246491,
-0.275051415,
0.1257343292,
0.7799828649,
0.1818666756,
0.8717390895,
-0.4823390245,
0.9173110723,
-0.1479273587,
0.3612715602,
0.0286491066,
-0.5831543803,
-0.4470022619,
-0.0209571701,
0.5972189903,
0.2059816569,
0.219827503,
-0.2678568363,
-0.0834721103,
-0.1998381615,
0.0525733382,
-0.8377511501,
-0.0345511623,
0.4358050227,
-0.3732741773,
-0.1586993188,
-0.0027411524,
-0.817067802,
-0.4625618756,
-0.2112302929,
0.3394606113,
-0.2565207183,
-0.3686624467,
0.0385752358,
0.0772037879,
0.1924594194,
0.4540781081,
-0.8401935697,
0.3666858077,
0.7876619697,
0.8370699286,
-0.3555242419,
-0.001856398,
-0.7810960412,
0.2860701382,
-0.5242151618,
0.667263329,
-0.4628735185,
-0.326585412,
0.1024746746,
-0.1480838656,
0.2226686776,
-0.5993480682,
0.4429021478,
-0.425265938,
0.3261142075,
-0.3595426083,
-0.615937829,
0.0739963055,
0.2234191447,
-0.6686930656,
1.118632555,
-0.0028761521,
-0.6860942841,
0.4639190435,
-0.8978847265,
-0.435192883,
-0.0799059719,
-0.2510065138,
-0.2839872241,
0.3199109733,
0.414516896,
0.5474538207,
-0.3957258761,
0.1032880917,
-0.4942673743,
-0.5521755219,
-0.0629563555,
-0.0269963834,
0.8174592853,
0.1980219781,
-0.1853557974,
0.3856463432,
-0.8156991601,
0.1695391983,
0.0675923526,
-0.3633915186,
-0.3757392466,
0.0472284779,
0.1032160893,
0.0109624844,
-0.0925643668,
-0.3419977129,
0.270911783,
-0.7119487524,
0.4005235136,
0.5579371452,
0.0026209874,
0.5633111596,
0.1731682569,
0.3577759266,
0.2395666838,
0.006633102,
-0.4335861802,
-0.2134887129,
-0.6326420307,
-0.3850837052,
0.1947291195,
0.4577977657,
-0.6049153805,
0.4789874256,
-0.0950863659,
-0.2266658396,
-0.3236366212,
0.1458190084,
0.2374844551,
0.4613134265,
0.6429267526,
-0.5163326263,
-0.5489935875,
-0.6395416856,
-0.383163929,
-0.0785153732,
-0.1711127609,
0.3263326585,
0.6383616328,
0.0743526891,
1.1373131275,
-0.6918553114,
-0.6833322048,
0.0340256765,
-0.1875942498,
0.1798244417,
0.537242949,
0.4750874639,
-0.503187418,
-0.3576130867,
0.0495457463,
-0.6869068146,
0.0372685306,
0.1665556729,
-0.2210933119,
0.5258827209,
0.6721496582,
-0.6692792773,
0.3001980782,
0.1828575134,
-0.4108697474,
0.4212854505,
0.0181433242,
-0.0464990214,
-1.2411822081,
0.1751910597,
-0.0432786904,
-0.1302762628,
-0.3055953383,
0.3547122777,
0.0354388021,
-0.0947375149,
-0.570736289,
0.4041333199,
-0.5477848053,
-0.3405459225,
0.0567454807,
0.1952031851,
-0.2976456285,
0.3703332245,
0.0377441607,
0.8751931787,
0.4626813531,
-0.4306814373,
0.2810213864,
0.4040879011,
-0.4907444715,
0.8212243319,
-0.5442085862,
0.186736241,
-0.1043150797,
0.3214356601,
-0.8124129772,
-0.4648685157,
0.1750133187,
-0.180251509,
0.25099805,
-0.1878162622,
-0.6100668311,
-0.1805158257,
-0.213928178,
0.1093396544,
0.2455241978,
-0.6696302295,
0.2787730396,
0.1323275715,
-0.0808073804,
-0.7016296387,
-0.8263420463,
0.291708082,
-0.0890998244,
-0.5131047964,
0.3166182637,
0.090738602,
-0.2996626496,
0.0364733711,
-0.1669233292,
-0.3833680451,
0.0211673677,
-0.0075848252,
0.0757799521,
-0.5715960264,
0.4230440259,
0.1583337635,
0.2479267567,
-0.027339682,
-0.5577527285,
0.319157958,
-0.2516325116,
-0.4255378842,
-0.0188039504,
0.3257390261,
0.0702550709,
-0.5086210966,
0.9816915989,
0.5425666571,
-0.4470464885,
-0.4281789958,
-0.2477576286,
-0.3761793673,
-0.3794205785,
0.521676898,
-0.442032814,
-1.2271192074,
0.3236801624,
-0.1830759943,
0.071588397,
0.3980725706,
0.5485047698,
-0.1230761111,
0.7737571597,
0.7506243587,
0.106432274,
0.5698161125,
-0.0949471742,
0.0047145481,
-0.5409036875,
-0.2348338813,
-0.7489866018,
0.0684145838,
-0.3241117001,
-0.5443794727,
0.2037408501,
0.4348283708,
-0.3295198381,
0.2566433549,
-0.2816385329,
0.7604621053,
0.1675292552,
0.1578128189,
0.6204852462,
0.213402614,
-0.0847263113,
0.065415509,
-0.6283011436,
-0.2983467877,
1.2029212713,
0.3148619235,
0.8171890974,
0.3199876845,
0.6701030135,
0.0957039669,
0.2460724115,
-0.7728918791,
0.6243988276,
-0.1206995547,
-0.8240323663,
-0.478520751,
-0.4240659773,
-0.6114789248,
0.3707376719,
-0.3487760425,
-0.7238051295,
-0.0598378479,
0.291051805,
-0.1128895432,
0.0302587822,
-0.6892155409,
0.954264462,
-0.016860323,
-0.7875316143,
-0.1821150929,
-0.6018976569,
0.5095927715,
-0.1662240326,
0.0363183431,
0.0725460947,
-0.3298613131,
0.4781596363,
-0.5636225939,
0.8827752471,
-0.2354999781,
-0.3025010526,
0.3354357481,
-0.1170842648,
0.4167788625,
0.1167977005,
-0.2644744515,
0.2311424613,
0.0610971265,
-0.4454790056,
-0.6215317249,
0.7046480775,
-0.2164178193,
-0.501122117,
-0.2668247521,
-0.5516417623,
-0.4029706717,
0.4336776733,
-0.0136951497,
0.345228374,
-0.441482693,
0.6349269748,
0.7099376917,
-0.1747350097,
0.3637337089,
0.4578233659,
-0.4387844503,
-0.3952942789,
0.4183906019,
0.0317748636,
0.1930404902,
0.5894674063,
0.0428950079,
-0.4067594707,
-0.6520075202,
-0.5501346588,
0.0392098129,
-0.7833328843,
-0.2397092432,
-0.2685186267,
0.2712574899,
-0.3484525383,
0.1918833107,
-0.1794554144,
-0.630146265,
-0.4151375294,
-0.0816664696,
0.3924848437,
0.5699100494,
0.2723309398,
0.3937038183,
-0.6520603299,
-0.0204503052,
-0.1929287612,
0.7461238503,
-0.1079976037,
-0.1899985671,
-0.3920522928,
-0.0810401887,
-0.1437672228,
-0.8044066429,
0.054876104,
0.4483321011,
0.3506633341,
0.1970345527,
0.1733702123,
0.7371787429,
-0.4576887786,
0.850135684,
0.0699590221,
-0.9151078463,
0.7278811336,
-0.482122153,
0.2346238941,
0.6203920841,
0.2916822433,
-0.1258373559,
-0.1790738553,
-0.117323041,
-0.8408863544,
0.7273295522,
0.246257633,
-0.108010754,
-0.0194321796,
0.5444591641,
0.0584573634,
0.4154635966,
-0.6108144522,
-0.0130732954,
-0.0159499999,
-0.368661195,
-0.3380134106,
-0.0525342971,
-0.1921537668,
-0.1720793247,
0.4488073885,
-0.6068934202,
0.1295257062,
0.1557699293,
-0.2908852398,
-0.1307591349,
0.4634503722,
0.6157346368,
0.7328374386,
-0.3134969473,
-0.0496762209,
0.2854375243,
-0.3028828502,
-0.2476047873,
-0.0192479845,
-0.0129172141,
-0.2402870059,
0.3866950572,
0.6154959202,
0.0546892919,
-0.7878902555,
0.4321725965,
0.0768917575,
-0.1254135221,
-0.0429382138,
0.1462777704,
0.179189086,
0.2467639744,
0.2806324363,
-0.0936458185,
0.1195909157,
-0.6657503247,
0.1006710604,
0.6140573025,
-0.5264846087,
-0.0609906763,
0.7487800121,
0.2828980684,
-0.0965231657,
0.4532391131,
0.1875710636,
-0.1351706684,
0.4647434652,
0.6892505288,
0.7632734179,
-0.0209960975,
-0.2156202048,
0.3631514609,
0.323132515,
-0.2779615521,
0.5994823575,
-0.2478225529,
-0.2810825408,
-0.5860789418,
-0.5244553685,
-0.4967140555,
-0.034049768,
-0.7109829187,
0.392531991,
-0.3533059061,
-0.0261198506,
-0.2167405188,
-0.0577806383,
-0.4028596282,
0.1023155898,
-0.2667572796,
1.4530543089,
-0.6242140532,
0.9095370173,
0.6906894445,
-0.6100537181,
-0.4856889844,
0.1016709805,
-0.1546486169,
-0.3067296743,
0.4819130301,
0.1440642476,
0.0682749823,
0.1235402003,
-0.6985439658,
-0.6527668238,
0.9976065755,
0.5939899087,
-0.7364886403,
-0.051410336,
0.2186053544,
0.7096019983,
-0.4695394933,
0.1837371439,
0.6686909199,
0.2291396111,
0.0255578626,
-0.926528573,
0.0758292228,
0.1566804647,
0.0954364389,
0.4144414663,
-0.3804807365,
0.6266078949,
-0.4897200763,
-0.0275904052,
0.0339849144,
0.8356506824,
0.0679157749,
0.3207506537,
0.3394723237,
0.5147743821,
0.7384787798,
-0.0947218761,
0.8146153688,
-0.0182210188,
0.4656270146,
1.3487048149,
-0.4696907401,
1.3929771185,
0.6467924714,
-0.2608369887,
0.3716252744,
0.6003735065,
0.2560757697,
0.4245961905,
0.2538610399,
-0.1001754478,
-0.0602012575,
-0.0236146487,
-0.4042815566,
0.4014813602,
0.484679848,
-0.2912449539,
-0.2451908737,
0.0178924911,
-0.1824867129,
0.2383151054,
-0.3682112396,
0.8581441641,
0.1181656346,
-0.5744692683,
0.5820372105,
-0.0991320834,
0.5246235728,
-0.4363746047,
-0.0748389438,
-0.2103079855,
0.3412045836,
-0.4600446224,
-0.8718551397,
0.5600904822,
0.0269556735,
-0.1284194589,
0.0230145454,
0.7431785464,
-0.6330437064,
-0.1696560234,
0.1744291633,
0.468626827,
0.0448403433,
-0.3896161616,
-0.4521681368,
0.1765647382,
-0.2358853072,
-0.3040808737,
0.3333414197,
0.3275479078,
-0.1422307938,
0.4408380091,
0.5810191631,
0.0598578379,
-0.1529514045,
0.039399676,
0.7364297509,
-0.6190863252,
-0.5044100881,
-0.8468920588,
0.3550788164,
-0.2224085182,
-0.0987618342,
0.6484282017,
0.8680117726,
1.0950747728,
-0.3109849989,
0.5576464534,
-0.1371168494,
0.5471791029,
-0.759493649,
0.6874200106,
-0.6442655921,
0.4788451493,
-0.2502684593,
-1.19427526,
-0.5221762657,
0.4257053435,
-0.1750998497,
-0.0129683893,
0.7634857893,
0.961732626,
0.0038950248,
0.1025043428,
0.1788869202,
0.3386932015,
0.2418664843,
0.4763702154,
0.51825881,
-0.2736248672,
0.7505685091,
0.0297000203,
-0.2818394303,
-0.3269544244,
-1.0770535469,
-1.0458254814,
-0.5326178074,
-0.2655553818,
-0.4425476193,
0.2679317892,
1.043712616,
0.7032574415,
-0.9413888454,
-0.3684221208,
-0.3905393481,
-0.0346805975,
-0.3307289481,
-0.1901511997,
0.2639229894,
-0.4256882071,
-0.4782032073,
0.4522617161,
0.3121856153,
-0.0949077755,
-0.3723441958,
0.0443814807,
-0.1023297161,
0.0164460205,
1.0008355379,
0.1984285414,
-0.7326783538,
-0.1350115538,
0.0414065868,
-0.1128948033,
0.0403504446,
0.7119413614,
-0.7438306212,
0.3719227612,
0.5620507598,
0.7025380135,
0.546536684,
0.0649010241,
0.5917639136,
-0.965403676,
0.1752372384,
0.2468014508,
0.1404698044,
0.2184967846,
-0.3024184406,
0.8198869228,
0.1654767096,
-0.3227106035,
-1.1021944284,
0.2321175188,
-0.900023818,
-0.4437563419,
1.0198687315,
-0.0317886323,
-0.2365426719,
0.0509481914,
-0.3828366101,
0.0862968564,
-0.2854301333,
0.380664587,
0.598626256,
-0.0808496252,
-0.1022821143,
-0.4295057952,
0.5299594998,
0.3839354217,
-1.2048273087,
0.2739503086,
0.7288020849,
0.1590527296,
-0.1014485434,
0.6153565645,
-0.1327643692,
0.1261522323,
-0.0979013816,
-0.1227937192,
-0.245101735,
-0.3305579126,
-0.5395383835,
0.4403897524,
0.1874732971,
-0.0680671558
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02677v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02677v1
|
Evaluating the Ability of Computationally Extracted Narrative Maps to Encode Media Framing
| 2024-05-04T14:40:28 | 2024-05-04T14:40:28 |
Sebastián Concha Macías, Brian Keith Norambuena
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.IR
|
Narratives serve as fundamental frameworks in our understanding of the world
and play a crucial role in collaborative sensemaking, providing a versatile
foundation for sensemaking. Framing is a subtle yet potent mechanism that
influences public perception through specific word choices, shaping
interpretations of reported news events. Despite the recognized importance of
narratives and framing, a significant gap exists in the literature with regard
to the explicit consideration of framing within the context of computational
extraction and representation. This article explores the capabilities of a
specific narrative extraction and representation approach -- narrative maps --
to capture framing information from news data. The research addresses two key
questions: (1) Does the narrative extraction method capture the framing
distribution of the data set? (2) Does it produce a representation with
consistent framing? Our results indicate that while the algorithm captures
framing distributions, achieving consistent framing across various starting and
ending events poses challenges. Our results highlight the potential of
narrative maps to provide users with insights into the intricate framing
dynamics within news narratives. However, we note that directly leveraging
framing information in the computational narrative extraction process remains
an open challenge.
|
[
-0.6685376763,
-0.7531810403,
0.9698688984,
0.0449291505,
-0.2796618342,
0.3385592103,
-0.23142232,
-0.5307766199,
0.3053323925,
0.3345400393,
-0.4109915495,
-0.4645472467,
-1.0009675026,
0.0009922057,
-0.5969250202,
0.7439764738,
-0.3947128654,
-0.270780921,
0.082362242,
-0.059191227,
-0.5528519154,
-0.4986070693,
-0.074903883,
-0.0703569204,
0.2392679155,
0.2016409189,
0.8361594081,
1.0649225712,
0.503267765,
0.1660833359,
-0.0046939356,
0.1309812665,
-0.5527051687,
0.186649099,
0.0700397491,
-0.2778610885,
0.0048773619,
0.623041749,
0.6985633373,
0.6321899295,
0.0329493582,
0.557331562,
0.0259605963,
0.6461136937,
-0.6710714698,
0.2196744829,
-0.4125098288,
0.2946894467,
-0.3256314397,
-0.5007890463,
-0.3751417696,
-0.3224092722,
0.1615660489,
-0.7858935595,
0.153818354,
0.3939253092,
0.9435120225,
0.0851522237,
-0.63216573,
-0.5528839827,
-0.8350672126,
0.2494061887,
-0.1698169708,
0.0659762025,
0.5796370506,
0.6859822869,
-0.0601744168,
-0.5161154866,
-0.3649324775,
0.284312427,
-0.1584639698,
0.2211953551,
-0.4058691561,
-0.3417966068,
0.4154108763,
0.2320205867,
-0.3695548773,
-0.280341804,
-0.5552529097,
-0.1126156077,
0.5455867648,
0.3610147536,
0.4578492045,
-0.5250941515,
-0.5038855672,
0.0046963328,
-0.469438225,
0.0912057534,
0.3608372211,
0.291356504,
-0.3785813451,
0.5655781031,
-0.1563705057,
0.7176240087,
-0.0752339289,
-0.0563491546,
0.1594402343,
-0.0514233261,
-0.0712292939,
0.4133328497,
0.722063303,
0.738008976,
0.2057965696,
-0.0678885132,
-0.037202239,
-0.0694491863,
0.4294980764,
-0.4551587701,
0.1570744514,
-0.0924802348,
-0.5639542937,
-0.2958393693,
0.4530012906,
-0.8918600678,
-0.4958412051,
-0.2617881,
0.1298140287,
-0.0611741431,
-0.3796442747,
0.161597535,
-0.6526011229,
0.3201831281,
0.218576014,
-0.7768957019,
0.0939221233,
0.7216344476,
0.9714996815,
-0.3069015145,
0.1167767569,
-0.4251312315,
0.340836823,
-0.4583737552,
0.7246570587,
-0.6969345808,
-0.1936219037,
0.1648329049,
-0.3009411097,
0.1828695685,
-0.4742872417,
0.2842893302,
-0.7335848212,
0.1637371033,
-0.3939385712,
-0.6033329368,
-0.2660621107,
0.4519516528,
-0.9871588945,
0.5891932845,
-0.0075920997,
-0.5583679676,
0.162382856,
-0.4450401068,
-0.2475244403,
-0.0832003206,
-0.2991500795,
-0.0838388056,
0.4611444771,
0.7548237443,
0.1561748236,
-0.3652089834,
0.3601256013,
-0.1776858866,
-0.3977407217,
0.3334745169,
-0.4363073409,
0.6757345796,
0.2055050433,
-0.1771552712,
-0.2381973267,
-0.4374269247,
-0.3567438126,
0.3150451183,
-0.2108228654,
-0.0072004762,
0.0561149083,
0.1702102423,
-0.0286910776,
-0.1736221611,
-0.4405160546,
0.1119866073,
-0.0975582451,
0.3922999799,
0.5853995681,
0.2930449843,
0.7009195089,
-0.4056631327,
0.7646949887,
-0.0630095154,
-0.3834422231,
-0.7689272165,
-0.5379568338,
0.0064630015,
-0.3076972067,
0.443983525,
0.3808250427,
-0.7089874744,
-0.0991538167,
-0.2938228548,
-0.2296870053,
-0.4078999162,
-0.4127013683,
-0.0425731279,
0.5556931496,
0.0870241672,
-0.3097440004,
-0.6422356367,
-0.5977863669,
-0.4424998164,
0.0478823818,
-0.0374652073,
0.0375763625,
0.2377545238,
0.3862251043,
1.551066637,
-0.7855276465,
-0.2046232522,
-0.2032003701,
0.4219061732,
0.2554686964,
0.1145500913,
0.6225661039,
-1.1761615276,
-0.1778241098,
-0.2332468033,
-1.2260907888,
-0.180157125,
-0.5023687482,
0.1122934744,
-0.1784174293,
0.4790325761,
-0.5627017021,
0.8413978219,
0.3963833153,
-0.2573684752,
0.6838015914,
0.2053078264,
0.5941208005,
-0.6864067316,
-0.2003070265,
-0.0993776843,
-0.4346562326,
-0.3209013641,
0.0938168317,
-0.1037209779,
-0.4194260836,
-0.4027917087,
0.3121562302,
-0.7725832462,
-0.3892840147,
-0.3827813566,
0.4631086588,
0.1691780984,
0.431291312,
0.0213131979,
0.3881828189,
0.4646425545,
0.143451646,
0.3119502664,
0.1652269363,
-0.7342901826,
0.2780364454,
-0.2346792519,
0.1027471796,
-0.3549583554,
0.4490716159,
-0.8673695922,
-0.3356807232,
0.4497788846,
-0.5497918725,
0.0369902737,
-0.1196261123,
-0.6383774877,
-0.1292648911,
-0.1544156075,
0.2986196876,
0.3457000852,
-0.4867597818,
0.5290758014,
0.8133678436,
0.052006878,
0.0832547471,
-0.7262290716,
0.2410351634,
-0.3857688308,
-0.4125239253,
0.1743019968,
0.3198255301,
-0.237640664,
0.3384475112,
-0.3518306613,
-0.1671875119,
-0.0625587553,
0.5087924004,
0.1401647478,
-0.2783280313,
0.0486136675,
0.0594812967,
-0.5096125007,
0.1256580949,
-0.0569899753,
0.2125518471,
0.0460483953,
-0.5100073814,
-0.2819343209,
0.9253200889,
0.5724122524,
-0.4555697143,
0.5029568672,
0.6436750293,
-0.6407841444,
-0.003313076,
-0.2976415157,
-0.0288466457,
-0.3810034394,
0.0370170325,
-0.2842518985,
-1.0320411921,
0.5291470885,
-0.4585975111,
-0.182405442,
0.2856109738,
0.3040820956,
-0.3271887004,
1.0311077833,
0.2699544132,
-0.0297419317,
0.2116965652,
-0.1218929142,
0.3072065711,
-0.802611649,
-0.0563366264,
-0.3562723994,
-0.707947135,
-0.0850806534,
-0.2433004379,
0.4777397215,
0.2594692111,
0.053833399,
0.1913523823,
-0.5183880925,
0.7060958743,
0.430988878,
-0.1345328838,
0.5341037512,
0.1508962065,
0.3379503489,
-0.2383898348,
-0.5686882138,
-0.6042460799,
0.9082764387,
0.0041893627,
0.3834168017,
0.0597086623,
0.6198757887,
0.482606113,
0.2645227015,
-0.360068351,
0.4224426448,
0.3626871705,
-0.7196739912,
0.0582394861,
-0.2676959634,
-0.948030293,
0.280872345,
-0.5905457735,
-0.9271437526,
0.3815971911,
-0.3543892503,
-0.4272516966,
0.3023106754,
-0.736859262,
0.7194088101,
-0.0631795526,
0.2391453832,
-0.1474380642,
-0.7435188293,
0.1383317411,
-0.1976119131,
0.6844723225,
-0.4851128459,
0.1387265623,
0.502974391,
0.0924682915,
0.6992220283,
0.0265247896,
0.5071815848,
0.5829529762,
0.235962823,
-0.0192917176,
0.064959988,
0.0408452004,
0.3965416551,
-0.057217706,
-0.2037917525,
-0.8448854685,
0.1031762809,
-0.5130889416,
-0.7325229049,
-0.5050777197,
-0.7177619338,
0.0310824458,
0.0183785222,
0.2288852185,
0.7266819477,
-0.2163545638,
0.1355369538,
0.0073638191,
0.0664573386,
0.7325447798,
0.1791218519,
-0.4316297174,
-0.3164811432,
0.8165904284,
0.3594023287,
-0.1001667976,
0.1915029585,
0.2085864991,
0.0819205269,
-0.7685803771,
-0.6524168849,
-0.2735738754,
-0.5591632128,
-0.3416059613,
-0.2123913765,
-0.1818841398,
-0.0196151864,
-0.5408254266,
-0.1458007991,
-0.3754742742,
-0.3209404647,
-0.4178306758,
0.0220560785,
0.6148559451,
-0.2934678197,
0.3185479343,
-0.9736613631,
0.5280254483,
-0.0332563482,
-0.1848155707,
-0.1616616249,
-0.0305981804,
-0.3826151192,
0.0527321547,
-0.4178138077,
-1.5382819176,
0.4091494977,
-0.1246027797,
0.5307254791,
0.211994499,
0.3031826913,
0.7751967907,
-0.6546854377,
0.8541778326,
0.1497573555,
-0.7616034746,
0.8039616346,
-0.5292688012,
0.5409191847,
0.4633336365,
0.558124125,
-0.3066142201,
-0.4033669829,
-0.4631628394,
-0.6295262575,
0.7631329298,
0.3020881712,
0.1005466208,
-0.2877264917,
0.3242227733,
0.0256758109,
0.20906578,
-0.2690410614,
0.0972281173,
-0.0609745011,
-0.1074985191,
0.1163222566,
-0.0932051092,
-0.2951051891,
-0.1575207859,
-0.0022330778,
-0.0350950025,
0.1286399662,
0.3378311992,
-0.3337356448,
-0.1278357357,
-0.1076874211,
0.1667629778,
0.6847993135,
-0.0564705096,
0.2023204714,
-0.2523777783,
-0.3884418011,
-0.1084696203,
0.2125843912,
-0.1742375344,
-0.0146104833,
0.7051561475,
0.7270707488,
0.3668333292,
-0.7750306129,
0.6477146745,
-0.0430363044,
0.0103763733,
-0.0183998905,
-0.1754185855,
0.067337513,
0.6773405671,
0.7579036355,
0.1302632689,
0.3142505884,
-0.653518796,
0.3361665606,
0.1506716609,
-0.1633330733,
-0.1765484661,
0.5751317739,
-0.0132929413,
-0.5104750991,
0.8161918521,
-0.12458276,
-0.3780069053,
0.6427682042,
0.6548710465,
0.7449909449,
0.1973814517,
0.3196763992,
0.2941009998,
0.4207230806,
0.0471711457,
-0.315140754,
-0.2990325987,
-0.8179842234,
-0.2561925054,
-0.4709686935,
-0.323436439,
-0.6906310916,
-1.1038594246,
0.0417716429,
-0.2082033157,
-0.4200365245,
0.0359471738,
-0.3076772988,
-0.3831370175,
-0.0816570371,
0.733546555,
0.8760799766,
-0.7252008915,
0.3911828697,
0.3320356011,
-0.156149596,
-0.6694883704,
0.0778494552,
0.6806237698,
-0.5953282118,
0.1188774779,
0.3983803093,
0.0446531698,
-0.2142975628,
-0.4644747674,
-0.7212908268,
1.0696835518,
0.7663040161,
-0.3508533537,
-0.0522298664,
0.2888350785,
0.359518826,
-0.9722450376,
-0.0118599441,
0.6660721302,
0.4268638492,
0.232710883,
-0.5134884119,
0.0559663214,
-0.1540952921,
-0.1190324426,
0.1531465203,
-0.0882361829,
0.2868106365,
-0.2176194042,
-0.6754912138,
-0.3768188655,
0.5029081702,
0.1579955369,
0.6847640276,
0.2571498454,
0.4398852289,
0.6037986875,
-0.3523953557,
1.1812646389,
-0.1413397193,
0.3047740459,
1.2434527874,
-0.0285484418,
0.7818369865,
0.3389593959,
0.2115599811,
0.499550581,
0.5190674067,
0.0676926225,
0.6722486615,
-0.1401864588,
0.0425803773,
-0.2506019473,
0.0006286276,
-0.165386796,
0.8951402307,
0.315983355,
-0.3949285746,
-0.6767177582,
0.3351143897,
-0.0098576751,
0.390239954,
-0.1329577565,
0.5919637084,
0.1579075158,
-0.5199636221,
0.0641809776,
-0.0702076852,
-0.0731146857,
-0.4669578075,
-0.1624441445,
0.0869081765,
-0.5020483732,
0.0126016047,
-0.9109690189,
0.9620718956,
0.0510005914,
-0.3508573174,
-0.8957298398,
0.7610446811,
-0.333573699,
-0.2073640227,
0.1075348035,
0.611880362,
-0.0167647824,
-0.3385153115,
-0.2605006397,
0.8437350988,
-0.1806392968,
-0.495688796,
0.3099452853,
0.3061472774,
0.0292543415,
0.0101196766,
0.6313873529,
-0.1189379767,
0.001888604,
-0.2930832803,
0.5494946241,
-0.7890843153,
-0.6300801039,
-0.9680020809,
0.653975904,
-0.1878592521,
-0.3991307616,
0.661831975,
0.6184777617,
0.5059310198,
0.1445257068,
0.5004611015,
0.144977048,
-0.0669751391,
-0.3792293072,
0.7792741656,
-0.2248242497,
0.1456896514,
0.0896444321,
-0.8955908418,
-0.4003274143,
0.4070018232,
-0.3288462758,
-0.5265253782,
0.5231456161,
0.4342408776,
0.1142302081,
0.8363189101,
0.078628324,
0.1156263202,
0.2232677191,
0.5285609961,
0.7954316735,
-0.2028836906,
0.4505919814,
0.0949963927,
-0.4204953313,
0.0934101045,
-0.9212918878,
-0.5460404158,
-0.9838147163,
-0.1894585937,
0.019130582,
0.0969272181,
0.4507955909,
0.8991095424,
-0.1532237679,
-0.1201878041,
0.31766361,
0.3553850949,
-0.3832750022,
-0.1820726097,
0.4454649687,
-0.0756405368,
-0.4441100955,
0.5043289065,
0.6998391151,
-0.2988215089,
-0.0119788684,
0.1125235111,
-0.0003525009,
0.155157581,
0.4140119851,
0.1807002425,
-0.3482558727,
-0.4678624272,
-0.3058935404,
-0.087739937,
0.3397421539,
1.1138423681,
-1.1194242239,
0.7618445754,
0.4409529567,
0.800604701,
1.0865924358,
0.0867414996,
0.6674028635,
-0.7467733622,
0.1130283922,
-0.0132509805,
0.1518471539,
0.333910197,
-0.2078353912,
0.592463553,
0.3612949848,
-0.0832895637,
-0.9328413606,
0.1747549921,
-1.2462952137,
-0.3505040407,
0.938067615,
0.058240559,
-0.4648742676,
-0.154411152,
-0.1978120804,
0.0466779061,
-0.1056311056,
0.5865282416,
0.9856441617,
-0.0533625931,
-0.2537170053,
-0.853077352,
-0.0733637735,
-0.372618258,
-0.6706353426,
-0.1899882406,
0.6434900761,
-0.1576711684,
0.3368982077,
0.9074142575,
-0.2591153383,
0.2746579349,
0.2609676421,
-0.5675483942,
-0.3503908813,
-0.3716573417,
-0.164628461,
0.9801923633,
-0.8430730104,
-0.3995715976
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02673v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02673v1
|
On the Information Redundancy in Non-Autoregressive Translation
| 2024-05-04T14:20:28 | 2024-05-04T14:20:28 |
Zhihao Wang, Longyue Wang, Jinsong Su, Junfeng Yao, Zhaopeng Tu
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Token repetition is a typical form of multi-modal problem in fully
non-autoregressive translation (NAT). In this work, we revisit the multi-modal
problem in recently proposed NAT models. Our study reveals that these advanced
models have introduced other types of information redundancy errors, which
cannot be measured by the conventional metric - the continuous repetition
ratio. By manually annotating the NAT outputs, we identify two types of
information redundancy errors that correspond well to lexical and reordering
multi-modality problems. Since human annotation is time-consuming and
labor-intensive, we propose automatic metrics to evaluate the two types of
redundant errors. Our metrics allow future studies to evaluate new methods and
gain a more comprehensive understanding of their effectiveness.
|
[
-0.2231324017,
-0.6743251681,
0.1400010735,
0.5036433339,
-0.3709694743,
0.1029640958,
-0.0562849157,
-0.5086929202,
0.3058276474,
0.196359694,
-0.4173785448,
-0.0442759581,
-0.6551843882,
0.5128899813,
-0.698859334,
0.9873268604,
-0.4202269614,
0.195764631,
-0.0459088273,
-0.5674303174,
-0.8233466744,
-0.7288123369,
-0.5665155649,
0.0241618715,
0.5507706404,
0.2349944711,
0.701433897,
0.6005964875,
0.7507545948,
0.2773550153,
0.1284534335,
0.5589985847,
-0.2116030455,
0.0526097566,
0.0563143156,
-0.3195401132,
-0.3996608555,
-0.0010537462,
1.0285989046,
0.8385713696,
0.1094620675,
0.2317524552,
-0.3069940507,
0.6793830991,
-0.4009212852,
0.1717439592,
-0.3731722236,
0.156124115,
-0.1304403394,
-0.4074884355,
-0.2297053486,
-0.4228834808,
-0.0917590186,
-0.5714128613,
0.2215298265,
0.3129119277,
0.6935014725,
0.4552738965,
-0.6645791531,
-0.065902099,
-0.9100900888,
0.8829804063,
-0.5541276336,
0.3867413402,
0.3575506806,
0.0466353782,
-0.1411467046,
-0.3250545859,
-0.7095931768,
-0.2235569805,
-0.3778767586,
0.0084653273,
-0.3029572964,
-0.0742273405,
0.0990081429,
0.334220469,
-0.2669395804,
-0.266887188,
-0.594019115,
-0.3141489625,
0.4155519009,
0.2897273302,
0.3937833011,
-0.3584316075,
-0.632489264,
-0.00127375,
-0.1646539122,
-0.3620584905,
0.2339951545,
0.1671747118,
-0.2874767482,
0.5401614904,
-0.0859826505,
1.0321731567,
-0.0319833867,
-0.2028083354,
0.6912577748,
-1.2682840824,
0.0561088733,
-0.2212243527,
0.7434696555,
0.3199875951,
0.0414754227,
-0.2955285907,
-0.4173610508,
-0.3075576127,
0.2650381029,
0.0391908772,
-0.114222765,
0.0271229297,
-0.3294957578,
-0.2595877945,
0.1549315602,
-0.5975356102,
0.0131860524,
-0.4175076485,
0.4575403333,
-0.3878693879,
-0.4951231182,
-0.0947632417,
-0.3357138336,
-0.0523908064,
0.432949841,
-0.4948978424,
-0.1311271042,
0.4804944992,
1.1671156883,
-0.4445738196,
-0.6767874956,
-0.2560764849,
-0.0967194885,
-0.4833422303,
0.5485375524,
-0.2574227452,
-0.2703568637,
-0.2841688693,
0.1538024396,
-0.3548374176,
-0.3725703061,
0.2703639865,
-0.4187525809,
0.1459949017,
-0.5792675614,
-0.2817996144,
-0.5252600908,
0.4787362814,
-0.9825407267,
0.8313081861,
0.3600929379,
-0.8566417098,
0.311655283,
-0.6505339146,
-0.3376200795,
-0.1192827672,
0.2035031468,
-0.2744799256,
0.5030726194,
-0.5160737038,
-0.1743036807,
-0.4013032019,
0.429122597,
0.1054694355,
-0.2170078605,
0.5438418984,
-0.8007082939,
0.4674316049,
0.1119533554,
-0.5061694384,
0.1024917513,
-0.9550071955,
-0.2114202827,
-0.0487584583,
-0.6304544806,
-0.3225695789,
-0.2747320235,
0.199687168,
0.3709713519,
0.4047990143,
-0.6085458398,
0.0834269077,
0.1067937687,
0.3635466993,
0.5700566769,
0.0440401584,
0.1813331544,
-0.6361272931,
0.3138835728,
0.4394113421,
0.2161959857,
-0.0441034883,
-0.537330091,
-1.0013684034,
-0.1605391353,
0.3706424534,
0.5652442575,
-0.7619367242,
0.1395680904,
-0.4364949167,
-0.38469854,
-0.3693432212,
-0.0769803002,
0.6499170661,
0.5335131884,
0.614697814,
-0.6709166765,
-0.612067163,
-0.9245635867,
-0.0874308273,
-0.2607289851,
0.4960516393,
0.132865712,
0.5829827785,
-0.4205868542,
0.8344116807,
0.2543390989,
-0.3120516241,
0.0289659798,
0.8061406612,
-0.230156377,
0.6300297976,
0.3318234086,
-0.8024346828,
-0.1932676136,
-0.1005686149,
-0.6693381071,
-0.2622201741,
-0.5553677082,
0.0342366137,
0.5778453946,
0.2788640857,
-0.4621631503,
0.4709068537,
0.4829541147,
-0.2913381159,
0.6829319,
-0.1894979179,
0.439022243,
-0.7841009498,
0.5097151399,
-0.3253665864,
-0.320987314,
-0.7116656303,
-0.343093276,
0.2296046317,
0.2552703023,
-0.4995604455,
0.6795746088,
-0.6009988785,
-0.2383030653,
-0.2860788107,
0.1080071554,
0.1658530235,
0.4100774825,
-0.0888566598,
0.8509850502,
-0.1997329444,
-0.5611559153,
0.6474584937,
0.1538007557,
-0.0298350025,
0.7162017822,
-0.3155510426,
-0.1088159233,
-0.4712033272,
0.2611227334,
-1.2276855707,
-0.2158591002,
0.3488591909,
-0.442620486,
0.2032357156,
0.018462427,
-0.7760211229,
-0.18769674,
-0.1372396648,
1.0920871496,
-0.0058413283,
-0.296600759,
0.2209422737,
0.1539039463,
0.0382629372,
-0.6517635584,
-0.884391129,
0.1746132672,
-0.0550977439,
-0.2344440073,
0.0134386802,
0.0383511111,
-0.1083553061,
0.2279849499,
-0.0276951622,
-0.2929590344,
0.1652246267,
0.0499226339,
0.2928352952,
-0.0346593596,
0.4705740511,
-0.3226546049,
-0.2229741216,
-0.1610355526,
-0.2876191735,
0.4845099449,
-0.2998449802,
-0.6874951124,
-0.8772764802,
0.75625664,
0.8884792924,
-0.0859053656,
0.7160688639,
0.515365541,
-0.4003002346,
0.7008833289,
-0.9146912694,
0.1942850947,
-0.3008697033,
0.5523821115,
0.0085394606,
-0.4236813784,
0.4956228137,
0.2857375741,
0.3468010426,
0.5362455249,
0.1689113677,
0.138762176,
0.5993986726,
0.4060290456,
-0.0796582773,
0.4335934818,
-0.0068915444,
0.1402629614,
-0.9020816088,
-0.5069280267,
-0.1914484203,
-0.7477819324,
-0.1656883955,
-0.5624914169,
0.3279602826,
0.2063187957,
-0.3481643796,
0.4953721464,
-0.3494806886,
0.2760840058,
0.6021863222,
-0.5588206053,
0.7090952992,
0.146187976,
0.0328516178,
-0.0879769549,
-0.6768811941,
-0.1575928628,
0.9121854305,
0.1288397759,
0.5242693424,
0.3765588999,
0.4899642766,
0.3401987553,
0.5073933005,
-0.6809777021,
0.2246634215,
0.0851172134,
-0.7771850824,
-0.3090099692,
-0.7612624168,
-0.9952791333,
0.2405568808,
-0.1125598028,
-0.4251363277,
0.4270136356,
0.3143157959,
-0.34803316,
0.5623784661,
-0.5737982988,
0.7940559387,
-0.539062798,
-0.0035591125,
0.09566129,
-0.6193582416,
0.2891401947,
-0.5311800838,
0.4348327816,
-0.0235275347,
-0.3719751835,
0.6678031087,
-0.390060395,
0.9514770508,
-0.1336096674,
0.3472834527,
0.2129395753,
0.25480178,
0.5162469149,
-0.2211039662,
0.1043325365,
0.4637955427,
0.0668365881,
-0.4539789855,
-0.3421232998,
0.370272845,
-0.781223774,
-0.1664330214,
-0.725242734,
-0.5216952562,
0.0824223608,
0.2823559642,
0.305008024,
0.3461671174,
0.003180352,
0.1572265029,
0.1433505267,
-0.0593231358,
0.5828449726,
0.5386714339,
0.0951732025,
-0.7124009132,
0.9792894721,
0.4379940927,
0.5542097092,
0.1421810091,
-0.0976824537,
-0.2434403002,
-0.4353731573,
-0.5878001451,
0.5034213662,
-0.7153500319,
-0.3850643933,
-0.8087930679,
-0.1766808927,
0.0589249358,
-0.0344837829,
-0.5800935626,
-0.7390865684,
-0.5022161007,
0.036635112,
0.3059975803,
0.673053503,
-0.4708313346,
0.2429429591,
-1.0456768274,
0.1871758997,
0.0624836385,
0.3105734885,
0.2425867468,
-0.5725694299,
-0.2119155973,
0.1356611103,
-0.1557407528,
-0.9711973667,
0.439756155,
0.0421779007,
0.4754501283,
0.0117270257,
-0.0177232586,
0.844208777,
-0.2231913358,
0.8607953191,
0.5978881121,
-0.864546597,
0.0594133772,
-0.1150211319,
0.3296175897,
0.7953703403,
0.3206715286,
-1.0985314846,
-0.1840642095,
-0.5997114182,
-1.1641782522,
0.5913286805,
0.1019913778,
0.0825260282,
-0.6244960427,
0.4282177091,
0.1076752618,
0.6052801609,
-0.9619399905,
-0.3283789158,
-0.3497671187,
-0.0130847394,
0.0727519915,
-0.400985837,
-0.1777417213,
-0.081234768,
0.6208055615,
0.075851284,
0.3367942572,
0.444950372,
-0.3819372058,
-0.2664072812,
0.1460221112,
0.9552719593,
0.6632640958,
0.1584531665,
0.1302662641,
0.2866560519,
-0.1788329929,
0.4452990294,
-0.3031571507,
-0.2790053785,
0.4257810414,
0.3854671121,
0.9059818387,
0.3834186792,
-0.4496549964,
0.7126303911,
0.0221450347,
-0.1009827182,
-0.876298964,
-0.5360087752,
-0.1134058684,
0.0034871784,
0.2573246956,
0.4639685452,
-0.1935842931,
-0.4950231612,
0.2064645439,
0.4215349555,
-0.4141952991,
-0.4647552371,
0.5629800558,
0.3292161226,
-0.5059661269,
0.7446380854,
-0.4905909598,
-0.3585703671,
0.4115219116,
0.5426461697,
0.9069683552,
-0.026701102,
0.1488466263,
0.470361948,
0.3204510212,
-0.5170106888,
0.2438739389,
-0.0462773181,
-0.4497227073,
-0.387160629,
-0.5070698261,
-0.2830860615,
0.0646572188,
-0.5841529965,
-0.0070242514,
-0.3940286934,
-0.4835742116,
-0.2648802698,
-0.4744057357,
-0.5948107243,
-0.1698269993,
-0.1052842885,
0.5087363124,
-0.8523358107,
0.4202279747,
0.519461453,
-0.6123837233,
-0.5016762614,
-0.0622477308,
0.1825999618,
-0.5657060146,
1.0346791744,
0.0157830492,
-0.2029266208,
-0.19152987,
0.1496311426,
-1.319423914,
0.9686358571,
-0.01713554,
-0.3774173558,
-0.2406906933,
0.1827735305,
0.4469037056,
-0.1845867634,
0.166872561,
0.4833703041,
0.8664373755,
-0.0290285032,
-1.3016841412,
0.0345770232,
-0.2820561528,
0.0554508194,
0.4416197836,
-1.0706181526,
1.0733542442,
0.1027714536,
-0.4526818991,
0.1508574635,
0.1965986341,
-0.3498649895,
0.1270915717,
0.531045258,
0.5206956267,
0.7255243659,
-0.1065711156,
0.8818698525,
-0.360004276,
0.3088727891,
1.1125160456,
0.2657987475,
0.5471409559,
0.5696988106,
0.0160522405,
0.1508939713,
0.375808388,
-0.2132409364,
0.1144414544,
0.1435462832,
-0.2677613497,
-0.0759926066,
0.0064053708,
-0.4533232749,
0.4100365639,
0.1981782466,
-0.3814955652,
-0.2970392108,
-0.1110531464,
-0.0267992038,
-0.3918013275,
0.0504190773,
0.7654848695,
-0.1236952245,
-0.8247343898,
1.0137710571,
0.3214576244,
0.6880964637,
-0.3732128441,
0.1721880436,
-0.4617261887,
-0.2770180106,
-0.2650465369,
-0.1049424484,
0.7800337076,
-0.0993687063,
-0.3061972558,
-0.1054093987,
0.0327596702,
-0.4846800864,
-0.5564882755,
0.1655399948,
0.5333873034,
0.3059747219,
0.1542908549,
-0.5019195676,
0.0064848056,
0.1168899462,
-0.0496350452,
0.0807059705,
0.4629223347,
-0.3431794047,
0.5533750057,
0.6062672138,
0.2264424264,
0.5630559921,
-0.2271780968,
0.4409681261,
-1.1126019955,
-0.3019990325,
-0.7956728935,
0.3837548792,
-0.154635936,
-0.4774762392,
0.6405097842,
0.4582847655,
0.7929467559,
-0.0270861909,
0.8581739068,
0.1648686975,
0.3903775811,
-0.1302886754,
0.3696493208,
-0.7064074874,
0.3113802373,
-0.1128967628,
-0.9570542574,
-0.3884504139,
0.5068828464,
0.000409049,
-0.1730410457,
0.9644927382,
0.4343379438,
-0.0828995183,
-0.1547911018,
0.1887328923,
-0.0976145193,
0.141782254,
0.4963464141,
0.7215489149,
-0.4816044271,
0.6577651501,
0.0088776741,
-0.2078977674,
-0.5529677868,
-0.6936085224,
-0.3520817459,
-0.8074378371,
-0.4794214666,
-0.3701341152,
-0.119049266,
1.0408518314,
0.4984426796,
-0.6651788354,
-0.0876062736,
-0.1309822798,
0.1514243782,
-0.1950091571,
-0.1808190346,
0.1454664916,
-0.6217716932,
-0.6386029124,
0.2549448311,
0.4135026634,
0.6692039371,
-0.3126420081,
0.3281875551,
-0.3178219199,
0.1699745357,
0.3497773111,
0.6376398802,
-0.8261625171,
-0.5487131476,
-0.2451032996,
-0.1179879606,
0.2570998669,
0.8955016732,
-0.4519547522,
0.7806420326,
0.5913784504,
0.7131174803,
0.1077050343,
0.3330821395,
0.4624960423,
-0.8504696488,
0.2633863986,
0.0830238834,
0.3436768055,
0.5711766481,
-0.0937316269,
0.331058681,
0.7883219123,
-0.2531214952,
-0.8800228834,
0.5250268579,
-0.7365684509,
-0.0365955457,
1.32964468,
-0.1616592705,
-0.012722061,
-0.5915499926,
-0.014309641,
0.1963594556,
-0.1504290849,
0.9558807611,
1.103110075,
-0.0624041967,
0.0769838169,
-0.6189318895,
0.3823135495,
0.5826556087,
-0.3636591434,
0.0591053255,
0.758883059,
0.3698511422,
0.7067765594,
0.9421489239,
-0.5144352317,
0.3413758576,
0.1410981566,
-0.1552604735,
-0.3682996333,
-0.438955307,
-0.2444199324,
0.0505735129,
0.1553408802,
-0.3570652008
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02659v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02659v2
|
R4: Reinforced Retriever-Reorder-Responder for Retrieval-Augmented Large Language Models
| 2024-05-04T12:59:10 | 2024-06-25T09:24:01 |
Taolin Zhang, Dongyang Li, Qizhou Chen, Chengyu Wang, Longtao Huang, Hui Xue, Xiaofeng He, Jun Huang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Retrieval-augmented large language models (LLMs) leverage relevant content
retrieved by information retrieval systems to generate correct responses,
aiming to alleviate the hallucination problem. However, existing
retriever-responder methods typically append relevant documents to the prompt
of LLMs to perform text generation tasks without considering the interaction of
fine-grained structural semantics between the retrieved documents and the LLMs.
This issue is particularly important for accurate response generation as LLMs
tend to "lose in the middle" when dealing with input prompts augmented with
lengthy documents. In this work, we propose a new pipeline named "Reinforced
Retriever-Reorder-Responder" (R$^4$) to learn document orderings for
retrieval-augmented LLMs, thereby further enhancing their generation abilities
while the large numbers of parameters of LLMs remain frozen. The reordering
learning process is divided into two steps according to the quality of the
generated responses: document order adjustment and document representation
enhancement. Specifically, document order adjustment aims to organize retrieved
document orderings into beginning, middle, and end positions based on graph
attention learning, which maximizes the reinforced reward of response quality.
Document representation enhancement further refines the representations of
retrieved documents for responses of poor quality via document-level gradient
adversarial learning. Extensive experiments demonstrate that our proposed
pipeline achieves better factual question-answering performance on
knowledge-intensive tasks compared to strong baselines across various public
datasets. The source codes and trained models will be released upon paper
acceptance.
|
[
-0.3682485819,
-0.7083764076,
0.3651699126,
-0.1157509983,
-0.079812102,
0.2026979625,
-0.0691472292,
-0.3689134419,
0.2834053338,
0.6353459954,
-0.496052593,
-0.1954808086,
-0.5575361252,
0.3441703022,
-0.427290082,
0.9837387204,
0.066769965,
-0.0740457326,
-0.151863873,
0.0329449996,
-0.4657907784,
-0.5000023246,
-0.7239030004,
-0.2351728082,
0.8820616603,
0.2971646786,
0.5633795261,
0.6252269149,
0.4416413903,
0.4426442683,
-0.0106494268,
0.187239781,
-0.7216896415,
0.3282724023,
-0.3180907071,
-0.4050751328,
-0.4707233012,
-0.1708091944,
0.6178273559,
0.4264401793,
-0.1399969012,
0.0410446264,
0.046057824,
0.68432796,
-0.6915053725,
0.0414979048,
-0.7285469174,
-0.0900383219,
0.0629672185,
-0.6059512496,
-0.6762467027,
-0.3189454675,
0.053842742,
-0.5045214891,
0.7117358446,
0.2479557395,
0.7402085066,
0.2026541233,
-0.2388477176,
-0.3361655474,
-0.3889296949,
0.5109984279,
-0.5295424461,
0.5643665195,
0.2018064708,
0.2526203096,
-0.425887078,
-1.0345386267,
-0.6289075017,
0.124450542,
-0.132010892,
0.2172252387,
0.125214383,
0.0628540143,
0.2288623452,
0.443828851,
-0.617176652,
0.1585170925,
-0.4012205005,
-0.2593518496,
0.5096263885,
0.2534385026,
0.0307374708,
-0.2357325107,
-0.1984394789,
-0.2771506608,
-0.6110692024,
-0.2244137973,
0.2686355412,
0.3961515427,
0.3306120336,
0.60625422,
-0.1890042275,
0.642041564,
0.5405488014,
0.0324314497,
0.4149477482,
-0.2996931374,
-0.2734915018,
0.0700355247,
0.7073046565,
0.1481888145,
-0.1659065187,
-0.1923756003,
-0.5523653626,
-0.3049724698,
0.7178541422,
-0.8928921223,
-0.0556644127,
0.2130869776,
-0.2943221033,
-0.2452627569,
-0.2613389194,
-0.7734933496,
-0.3211373985,
-0.2821867168,
0.2236016095,
-0.3287496865,
0.0933713764,
0.1507807821,
0.1382988989,
0.2151688933,
0.3072435856,
-1.0896431208,
0.2865047753,
0.554646194,
0.5792523623,
-0.0133338151,
-0.2232755423,
-1.1211594343,
0.1240452752,
-0.2428129166,
0.8835012913,
-0.4372532368,
-0.2300028354,
0.2958159745,
0.2451466471,
0.0463224612,
-0.4793773293,
0.912316978,
-1.0767530203,
0.5320073962,
-0.3149456978,
-0.3997431993,
-0.0098230084,
0.5440319777,
-0.6681086421,
0.95263201,
0.1723200977,
-0.9887549281,
0.015630085,
-0.1760333478,
-0.2977948487,
0.1259424835,
-0.1598595232,
-0.437967509,
-0.0351685062,
0.3965489566,
0.5554047823,
-0.1665955484,
0.1143418625,
-0.2305895388,
-0.3610714972,
0.1721455604,
-0.3926993608,
0.2520723343,
0.1302936077,
-0.0263129454,
0.2506701648,
-0.6743381023,
-0.0176617652,
0.2050763518,
-0.929805994,
0.0571586341,
-0.1398003697,
-0.0393986627,
0.2050901055,
0.2955436409,
-0.5058475137,
-0.0018663516,
-0.6764489412,
0.208966732,
0.7632586956,
0.0151140206,
0.5189983249,
-0.3231856525,
0.4425641894,
-0.230584532,
-0.2511293888,
-0.2530661225,
0.0552574582,
-0.6612545252,
-0.1535036117,
0.1826210022,
0.521448493,
-0.9523261189,
0.3372021914,
-0.5114018321,
-0.1198693961,
-0.2931012213,
0.1421280652,
0.7142161727,
0.7686826587,
0.5152752399,
-0.1474752873,
-0.5487928391,
-0.6544849873,
-0.0472805761,
-0.2943673134,
-0.1966526061,
0.2251273096,
0.2214780897,
-0.0137154832,
0.5129874945,
-0.6075931191,
-0.1274276674,
-0.2350193113,
0.2708024979,
0.0417860411,
0.1031538248,
0.2579625547,
-0.7685397267,
-0.0440288521,
-0.2162791938,
-0.5972008109,
-0.0204183012,
0.0766796023,
-0.1638634354,
0.4331741929,
0.5076593161,
-0.6267849803,
-0.0185441207,
0.1896362603,
0.0186654869,
0.5759776235,
-0.3081718385,
0.055583749,
-1.2792260647,
0.0429084823,
-0.1557013839,
-0.1408676356,
-0.5609666705,
0.1192612648,
0.1846899092,
-0.1888239086,
-0.3614135683,
0.432253778,
-0.622559309,
-0.4313176572,
-0.4298500121,
0.4258910716,
0.1908705086,
0.5788115263,
0.1716759652,
0.6963947415,
-0.0002031955,
-0.5247702599,
0.3770416081,
0.576820612,
-0.1268763989,
0.5050140619,
-0.6073662639,
0.220042035,
-0.4056669772,
0.4538420737,
-1.0920909643,
-0.3842996061,
0.1358425915,
-0.6623591185,
0.6818279624,
-0.0615069382,
-0.3807930946,
-0.5887070894,
-0.3561322093,
0.1648585945,
0.120019339,
-0.6888167262,
0.7335011959,
0.0556691103,
-0.4310289025,
-0.9575891495,
-0.5496690273,
0.0453493036,
0.0107475845,
-0.6261286139,
0.4424116313,
-0.1988059878,
0.2178777158,
-0.1316075921,
-0.1428505629,
-0.0262834113,
-0.0251794923,
-0.0813120306,
0.2844604254,
-0.1887813359,
0.2024207115,
0.0077515901,
-0.0277856141,
0.207617119,
-0.041738119,
0.4639379084,
0.0952198505,
-0.1313459873,
0.0082152691,
0.2422641218,
0.5568342209,
-0.4116799831,
0.6955440044,
0.5373871326,
-0.2694471776,
0.1001412123,
-0.6724075675,
-0.4340907335,
-0.5065345764,
0.5455231667,
-0.5428953171,
-1.0031967163,
0.3730187118,
0.1461937279,
0.4141225517,
0.1451247036,
0.5688208938,
0.0829064548,
0.9142503142,
0.190168947,
-0.1108296365,
0.5142295361,
-0.104914017,
0.305859983,
-0.9213386178,
-0.2955382764,
-0.6018905044,
-0.2155416459,
-0.3280936182,
-0.264788866,
0.0296862312,
0.1312846243,
-0.3297744393,
0.1804153174,
-0.5631275773,
0.3691821098,
0.1957206577,
0.2110967338,
0.1143087819,
0.2014747858,
-0.1459254473,
0.1593742669,
-0.7184666395,
-0.4169900417,
0.8138054013,
0.319417119,
0.7683579922,
0.1725529283,
0.745339036,
0.1099084616,
0.3033789098,
-0.7278086543,
0.5609204173,
0.0940035507,
-0.2721030116,
-0.3065782785,
-0.3723837435,
-1.0581688881,
0.367529273,
-0.2375425398,
-0.3202003837,
0.1559125334,
0.0296903588,
-0.4325599372,
-0.0191244856,
-0.6712089181,
0.5385049582,
-0.1437446922,
-0.6170816422,
0.0683128759,
-0.7076570988,
0.407461822,
0.0026375034,
0.0895227045,
0.3066169322,
0.0733256191,
0.6227699518,
-0.3887932897,
0.6710572243,
-0.0753589123,
-0.2992622852,
0.1168014184,
0.199347049,
0.8904402852,
0.051791735,
-0.1772111654,
-0.5808989406,
-0.3413690329,
-0.4051010907,
-0.8415299058,
0.9272097945,
-0.6976643801,
-0.9532637596,
-0.3251811862,
-0.677524209,
-0.203387633,
0.2840816379,
0.1776054204,
0.7086858749,
0.045682475,
0.1513702273,
0.82453233,
-0.0624164455,
0.3750375509,
0.6922848225,
-0.0046888669,
-0.7548177242,
0.8448857069,
0.1102994755,
0.1207650304,
0.6710626483,
-0.1547174007,
-0.6125152707,
-0.7579030991,
-0.2987608612,
0.3962227404,
-0.741135776,
-0.4125102758,
-1.007433176,
-0.269792825,
-0.5590983033,
-0.3073428273,
-0.0572766364,
-0.2555919588,
-0.4857264757,
-0.387733072,
0.0986883044,
0.5083227158,
0.1867106855,
-0.0372808427,
-0.9089546204,
0.4197711051,
0.2753566504,
0.1735649109,
0.0733663663,
-0.7757020593,
-0.239311263,
-0.0746744201,
-0.4914291501,
-0.6161490679,
0.4274766743,
-0.1256995946,
0.5186939836,
0.174871102,
0.3611845672,
0.5756024122,
-0.6308789253,
0.5804281235,
0.0618720241,
-0.4330300987,
0.3765879869,
-0.3631112576,
0.1968010813,
0.3293082714,
0.2455468625,
-0.1761000603,
-0.3659599721,
-0.3632981479,
-0.9933212399,
0.7283892035,
0.0780876055,
0.1968662292,
-0.4741391242,
0.5966185331,
-0.1082981825,
0.0826180428,
-0.4679968059,
0.1473899931,
-0.432757616,
-0.2090818286,
-0.0723023564,
-0.483874023,
0.0000738929,
0.2626262605,
0.7429878116,
-0.3928838074,
0.3353518248,
0.2692232728,
-0.1242688745,
-0.0861704871,
0.4648350775,
0.5191518068,
0.4380479157,
-0.3769866824,
0.3462920487,
0.1775869429,
-0.3622511029,
0.169660911,
0.2646101713,
0.1259056032,
-0.2516877651,
0.3081473112,
0.6674057245,
0.2566409111,
-0.4893918633,
0.3995834887,
-0.1965761036,
-0.3158200979,
-0.1739379466,
-0.0559661724,
0.0064298273,
0.3196085989,
0.4828402698,
-0.1742377728,
0.1566250622,
-0.3321634829,
0.3210995793,
0.3913858831,
-0.1851013005,
-0.1779434383,
0.6679654717,
0.3031821251,
-0.3804542124,
0.7545889616,
0.0083434349,
-0.5225868225,
0.2604110241,
0.8350209594,
0.6006267667,
-0.1848929524,
0.1090339944,
0.5535804033,
0.07383205,
-0.2656541467,
0.2294295579,
0.1172739491,
-0.7246672511,
-0.5294450521,
-0.5907503963,
-0.1159730107,
0.1789782196,
-0.7117869854,
0.0908307284,
-0.4973360896,
-0.0615224913,
-0.2184161842,
0.1364737451,
-0.3654039502,
0.2696151137,
-0.0828138739,
0.8367826343,
-0.4448646605,
0.5769687295,
0.5345479846,
-0.6286110878,
-0.7588643432,
0.1134356633,
-0.2223136723,
-0.6301118135,
0.811240375,
0.1396259516,
-0.2807229161,
0.2543964982,
-0.3814582229,
-0.8742063642,
1.2080645561,
0.4455684423,
-0.3903304636,
-0.1689172387,
-0.2147721201,
0.6108903289,
-0.2283287495,
0.5054491162,
0.1662273258,
0.0662745163,
0.4793933332,
-0.3847045302,
0.3840328753,
-0.3352876008,
0.1983752102,
0.3247118592,
-0.6328136325,
0.4971387088,
-0.1159185842,
-0.2995148003,
0.2826637328,
0.9739609957,
0.5891034603,
0.1169742495,
0.2259660065,
0.6001751423,
0.8224689364,
0.0329892635,
1.1237682104,
-0.2732075751,
0.0996542946,
1.1835089922,
-0.452740252,
1.0402946472,
0.4181101918,
0.0337014273,
0.5033038259,
0.6212034822,
0.242291078,
0.5270010829,
0.273057282,
-0.3387315869,
-0.0747028738,
-0.2388753295,
-0.3417918086,
-0.0665316433,
0.3470514715,
-0.4140566885,
-0.1497124285,
-0.1321562082,
-0.1864592135,
0.1308499575,
-0.1443907917,
0.7325466871,
-0.1801670343,
-0.8082701564,
0.9834568501,
-0.0119777247,
0.5129458904,
-0.3133922517,
-0.0516192429,
-0.553560853,
0.1652762741,
-0.2443581522,
-0.9284312129,
0.1908464432,
-0.0225153603,
-0.6974480748,
-0.2145814002,
0.8096820116,
-0.4625350833,
-0.2729369104,
0.3412089646,
0.161527738,
0.0607436001,
0.2079748362,
-0.6507264972,
-0.0415905975,
-0.1698088795,
-0.4960793257,
0.5137924552,
0.4826269746,
-0.0176680293,
0.6996367574,
0.7538979053,
-0.322604239,
0.158319205,
0.1876757592,
1.0813976526,
-0.3107028902,
-0.2718613148,
-0.3340513706,
0.3587414324,
0.0283519011,
0.2753209174,
0.5269562602,
0.6294615269,
0.7386626005,
-0.1050262824,
0.6004390717,
0.0599310584,
0.5909644961,
-0.6130843163,
0.349424094,
-0.4457859099,
0.3471094668,
-0.0993061885,
-0.9146561623,
-0.2917006016,
0.3020345569,
-0.3636388183,
0.0531107672,
0.6855056286,
1.1156251431,
-0.0855723917,
-0.2093527317,
0.2520829737,
0.207585901,
0.3954840899,
0.4920715094,
0.6322262883,
-0.636536777,
0.9180488586,
0.1594757438,
0.1338039935,
-0.2177262157,
-0.4768283963,
-0.8934462667,
-0.396115154,
-0.0590928793,
-0.672499299,
0.2283324748,
0.7644819021,
0.2202265412,
-0.5685931444,
0.0695318207,
-0.2031110823,
0.0850364789,
0.1149149463,
-0.2811480165,
0.4460605681,
-0.6817508936,
-0.6920229793,
0.4891350865,
0.0825233161,
0.0588520616,
-0.1142904013,
-0.4336574078,
-0.350159049,
0.0298178289,
0.6281357408,
0.3826268315,
-0.7233436704,
-0.3047912121,
0.2555923462,
-0.2278492749,
0.0978320315,
0.6523074508,
-0.8640932441,
0.3934918642,
0.7919433117,
1.0080151558,
0.4577843547,
0.1356607229,
0.5885034204,
-0.9233191609,
-0.1567172408,
0.0123408297,
0.4200368226,
0.4704515934,
-0.5254528522,
0.3921356499,
0.1206273958,
-0.6700697541,
-0.7051161528,
0.2302048802,
-0.7182777524,
-0.1234840527,
0.9895663857,
-0.2706742585,
-0.2961681485,
-0.145001933,
-0.4046092033,
0.3659054935,
-0.489135325,
0.8281943798,
0.4312712252,
0.1297821999,
-0.5884873867,
-0.2435016334,
0.2072678059,
0.4990589023,
-0.6476947665,
0.3308062255,
0.838935554,
0.2579500675,
0.333018899,
0.6625419855,
-0.2008360475,
0.2503879368,
-0.2743447423,
-0.0058019855,
-0.1792681664,
-0.3116160035,
-0.2477230281,
0.4347316921,
0.0956292972,
-0.1174100637
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02650v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02650v1
|
Identifying Narrative Patterns and Outliers in Holocaust Testimonies Using Topic Modeling
| 2024-05-04T12:29:00 | 2024-05-04T12:29:00 |
Maxim Ifergan, Renana Keydar, Omri Abend, Amit Pinchevski
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
The vast collection of Holocaust survivor testimonies presents invaluable
historical insights but poses challenges for manual analysis. This paper
leverages advanced Natural Language Processing (NLP) techniques to explore the
USC Shoah Foundation Holocaust testimony corpus. By treating testimonies as
structured question-and-answer sections, we apply topic modeling to identify
key themes. We experiment with BERTopic, which leverages recent advances in
language modeling technology. We align testimony sections into fixed parts,
revealing the evolution of topics across the corpus of testimonies. This
highlights both a common narrative schema and divergences between subgroups
based on age and gender. We introduce a novel method to identify testimonies
within groups that exhibit atypical topic distributions resembling those of
other groups. This study offers unique insights into the complex narratives of
Holocaust survivors, demonstrating the power of NLP to illuminate historical
discourse and identify potential deviations in survivor experiences.
|
[
-0.2426607013,
-0.9440469742,
0.7020871639,
-0.2054596245,
-0.451731056,
0.3010327518,
0.1335016787,
-0.3516443372,
-0.0633517355,
0.7021286488,
-0.7074579,
-0.6334787011,
-0.7037186027,
-0.1737807244,
-0.8748301268,
1.2133870125,
-0.0680340827,
-0.1148228049,
-0.1948384196,
-0.11012429,
-0.3884881437,
-0.6021327972,
-0.3099273145,
-0.063113451,
0.0314464904,
0.3182301223,
0.5593395829,
0.7957721949,
0.511711061,
0.2072499543,
-0.1599795073,
-0.2729353905,
-0.3699618876,
0.3483812511,
-0.1338141412,
-0.5543377399,
0.0029591427,
-0.0019443927,
0.3981506228,
0.7943032384,
-0.1234357208,
0.1072244942,
-0.339845717,
0.2395406961,
-0.2837914824,
-0.192099154,
-0.7739683986,
0.1675847918,
-0.6203772426,
-0.3092523217,
-0.4963999689,
-0.8051339984,
0.4465983212,
-0.1367449313,
1.0580734015,
0.0023420881,
0.5198299289,
-0.0773705542,
-0.4434012175,
-0.6117011309,
-0.4645052552,
0.969435513,
-1.0008816719,
-0.0160146821,
0.63069731,
-0.008128101,
-0.2792143524,
-0.6017797589,
-0.2327716798,
-0.1900410652,
-0.211269632,
-0.1762580127,
-0.3793306947,
-0.4180614054,
0.1160265356,
0.3909106255,
-0.9192079902,
0.0807404369,
-0.2263952494,
-0.4163501561,
0.5779187083,
0.3685069382,
0.678345561,
-0.4788267612,
-0.3634760678,
-0.1563920081,
-0.4279816747,
0.099929288,
0.4652798772,
0.2557182908,
-0.2451830953,
0.4713090956,
-0.0461974852,
0.4461368322,
-0.3772748113,
-0.0979574472,
0.1497273147,
-0.0458158664,
0.3097279966,
0.4052427113,
0.282632798,
0.3895298541,
0.1421949267,
-0.1522422433,
0.3594574928,
0.210277915,
0.6309493184,
-0.6412677169,
-0.1350644678,
-0.0521386117,
-0.9815564156,
-0.3163962066,
0.0613660254,
-1.2000515461,
-0.7189532518,
0.1720677763,
0.0183892529,
-0.3323012888,
-0.1665815562,
0.2075386196,
-0.7614693046,
0.1529174596,
0.2893584967,
-0.945707202,
0.4944146574,
0.7714832425,
0.7416920066,
-0.4245814979,
0.1369610131,
-0.4394583702,
0.093938604,
-0.1410862654,
0.8600121737,
-0.7428075671,
-0.5592364073,
0.34765625,
-0.0977184325,
0.1962952912,
-0.4472501576,
0.826023221,
-0.6360602379,
0.479262799,
-0.0338368677,
-1.0303983688,
-0.428334862,
0.0229242016,
-0.3676106632,
0.7797098756,
0.0862537697,
-0.9588461518,
0.1405820549,
-0.2675366104,
-0.2188649923,
0.0297361203,
-0.3489025831,
-0.5145328045,
0.5803721547,
-0.0938687548,
0.2177062184,
-0.3162174523,
0.575795114,
-0.3958462477,
-0.320592016,
0.2493201643,
-0.4946593046,
0.7302550673,
-0.0370923541,
-0.3419173062,
0.2942088246,
-0.9314801693,
-0.1693276018,
0.3110824227,
-0.0799068958,
-0.5308531523,
0.2738450766,
0.2070395797,
-0.0068895007,
-0.0477519371,
-0.470497489,
0.0444025174,
-0.5334784389,
0.2787623703,
0.6427798867,
0.5103085041,
0.0877369642,
-0.3062373102,
0.3752986193,
-0.049185127,
0.1574094892,
-0.2631414235,
-0.9347503185,
-0.4687297046,
0.3458481431,
-0.0851599127,
0.311681211,
-0.1269721836,
0.3419730067,
0.2164386064,
-0.4556822479,
0.0228888821,
-0.0266865436,
0.1488940567,
0.8294584155,
0.5619516969,
-0.3209676743,
-0.5467889309,
-1.1870294809,
-0.1794760972,
-0.5792421699,
-0.3014519811,
-0.2833809257,
0.591324985,
-0.0069822758,
1.098593235,
-0.7060638666,
0.1687988341,
-0.1710247099,
0.8868993521,
0.1028467789,
0.6765332222,
0.5175823569,
-1.0795001984,
-0.1901550293,
-0.1201223657,
-0.6904755831,
0.0148276128,
-0.0923467875,
-0.1278095245,
-0.1251448095,
0.4587391317,
-0.2566961348,
0.8024603724,
0.3914400041,
-0.7712935805,
0.6957592368,
0.0170238838,
0.0919541642,
-0.8770245314,
-0.2042656094,
-0.2141340524,
0.0243725739,
-0.7978653312,
-0.0411977135,
0.0079270238,
-0.0749803856,
-0.4571064413,
0.3119881153,
0.1327431351,
-0.0303519033,
-0.4223250151,
0.0039621918,
-0.0833871067,
0.4896021783,
0.3855451643,
0.188047722,
0.4716919065,
-0.1595741212,
0.3737030327,
0.642837882,
-0.1732463986,
0.3926986456,
-0.4286631644,
0.1947090775,
-0.1275808513,
0.2162865996,
-0.9781380892,
-0.3327309191,
0.2041339725,
-0.2188290358,
0.1507497579,
-0.0020168696,
-0.4137133956,
-0.127029255,
-0.6417587996,
0.4349545836,
0.4339071512,
0.1270103455,
0.6095158458,
0.2574682534,
-0.590243578,
-0.1538877338,
-0.3897770345,
0.1160986051,
-0.648449719,
-0.4756523669,
0.5726245046,
-0.2509512305,
-0.586673677,
-0.0078985011,
-0.2830132842,
-0.3749983609,
0.1616148353,
0.3378587067,
0.232074514,
-0.3573019803,
0.3054737449,
0.0575296097,
-0.1431391537,
0.1094995439,
0.4514511228,
0.6844498515,
-0.1005659774,
-0.4529395103,
-0.370652616,
1.0588613749,
0.2452186793,
0.0600115173,
0.7795143723,
0.3090624809,
-0.4934144914,
0.1021035761,
-0.737768352,
-0.4124643207,
-0.3554449677,
0.3089954555,
0.1200685576,
-0.796857655,
0.6817064285,
0.0265939254,
0.2657139599,
0.5087608695,
0.6638067365,
-0.1897467822,
0.7704544067,
0.6724376678,
-0.0064155939,
0.5210867524,
0.0936649293,
-0.0657882467,
-0.4409837723,
-0.1000618413,
-0.6895227432,
-0.0132875349,
-0.3903978169,
-0.2826270461,
0.1300349385,
0.0789094195,
-0.1701939255,
0.1459260732,
0.1263424605,
0.0027438779,
0.6708566546,
0.2363173813,
0.5475535989,
-0.200276047,
0.4091733098,
-0.2994783223,
-0.3480473161,
-0.7929366827,
0.858053565,
0.308426708,
0.3228851855,
0.0198557284,
0.529835403,
0.8644332886,
0.3151708841,
-0.2874082625,
0.4467341602,
-0.1569862068,
-0.8066042662,
-0.2692057192,
-0.1439561248,
-0.687730372,
0.1017730609,
-0.1574091166,
-1.0101438761,
0.3527955711,
-0.3366576135,
-0.4507852495,
0.1553893536,
-0.2899462581,
0.9925550222,
0.0287489761,
0.2648663521,
-0.2717995048,
-0.9288260341,
0.2014520466,
-0.2514382899,
0.3129974604,
-0.337438941,
0.1214545369,
0.9138534665,
-0.4354774654,
0.9558361769,
0.2450478971,
-0.1756451428,
0.3294772506,
0.1544708908,
0.3340384066,
0.1312740445,
-0.19544366,
0.0742221028,
-0.2224730849,
-0.4416235387,
-0.5739892125,
0.3352228999,
-0.6034032702,
-0.7500275373,
-0.0974856615,
-0.6213828325,
-0.412951529,
-0.107620649,
0.1717430353,
0.7164624929,
-0.3810477257,
0.4424001873,
0.6957852244,
-0.4709771574,
0.7001502514,
0.5685516,
-0.0524722077,
-0.0882138014,
0.5056115985,
-0.2785990834,
0.1108983085,
0.2879860699,
0.4084114134,
-0.1063632891,
-0.8988234401,
-0.3469282687,
0.2482920885,
-0.8182458282,
-0.0118934428,
-0.6896936893,
0.0104799718,
-0.3414055407,
-0.317196101,
-0.2511270046,
-0.1531350613,
-0.374006927,
-0.372490257,
0.2849459648,
0.1658900678,
0.2773807049,
0.4471084774,
-0.8444573879,
0.6996982694,
0.4980318248,
-0.2352983356,
-0.1935397983,
-0.7020986676,
0.1187832281,
-0.1230471507,
-0.2713029683,
-1.3414709568,
0.2907541096,
-0.054918427,
0.6755559444,
0.5368279815,
0.3522453606,
0.5385383964,
-0.4151641726,
0.8764006495,
0.0082255779,
-0.913720727,
1.1076772213,
-0.5119300485,
-0.0428661779,
0.5255945921,
0.4392981529,
-0.5661104918,
-0.8844260573,
-0.8230392337,
-0.8889150023,
0.6751691103,
0.2993938327,
0.3206120431,
-0.0139609752,
0.2054612637,
0.6342269778,
0.2370481789,
-0.6598569155,
-0.1031866893,
-0.1801146567,
-0.2920230627,
0.188941285,
-0.4543133378,
-0.3191090524,
-0.0860347599,
0.4824444056,
-0.1363284439,
-0.086083442,
-0.2752974331,
-0.1397953182,
-0.2425268292,
0.2674536109,
0.5371316075,
0.8703925014,
-0.2870075703,
0.1948783696,
0.1357019246,
-0.3369290531,
-0.0928475112,
0.1235904023,
-0.2184637338,
0.2327702492,
0.933942914,
0.830593884,
0.5084404945,
-1.0459908247,
0.6068372726,
-0.2555892467,
-0.146334067,
-0.2359080613,
0.0824794918,
-0.0456079729,
0.5745701194,
0.7243161798,
0.0002746813,
0.2117600143,
-1.0975263119,
0.2729835808,
0.1634923369,
-0.281001538,
-0.1382575333,
0.4435081184,
-0.2099547088,
-0.3650742173,
0.9211563468,
0.5075624585,
-0.4328128994,
0.670669198,
0.5675485134,
0.6644656062,
0.003333837,
0.7362541556,
-0.0736267269,
-0.1088974029,
-0.0056582969,
0.0014948813,
-0.1037653983,
-0.6528548598,
-0.0836577863,
-0.7486336827,
-0.498714149,
0.006427594,
-1.0292298794,
-0.0830154568,
0.0751697794,
-0.0190676041,
-0.0607161969,
-0.2045280635,
-0.3666716516,
0.1364597976,
0.4473265111,
0.6330553293,
-1.1298376322,
0.4786694944,
0.2198418975,
-0.2274760306,
-0.2530045509,
0.1210911572,
0.0037137016,
-0.5814836621,
0.3947510719,
-0.0317301974,
0.3583804369,
-0.0825222656,
-0.197832495,
-0.5945193768,
0.6151214242,
0.4312067032,
-0.3563905358,
-0.1911768466,
0.0797830075,
0.6185053587,
-0.2509122789,
-0.1288884282,
0.6244488955,
0.450704366,
-0.0507708229,
-0.3451232314,
0.0065676402,
-0.1785571128,
0.010383077,
-0.0046404218,
-0.2144935876,
0.6002341509,
0.0477983169,
-0.1828238815,
0.2439107746,
0.7345274687,
0.4940489531,
0.4888144135,
0.4347210824,
0.2211692929,
0.6358609796,
-0.0989544317,
0.9939847589,
0.0909982324,
0.1284092516,
1.1125257015,
-0.0446712822,
0.7566623092,
0.4619148672,
-0.1983570606,
0.8582636714,
0.6079303622,
-0.1032639295,
0.6586014628,
0.3517153859,
-0.2792602181,
-0.2658464313,
-0.173031792,
-0.535428822,
0.566264987,
0.0823547989,
-0.4733063877,
-0.5712925196,
0.4380905628,
-0.027835235,
0.1751867533,
-0.2653953731,
0.7423580289,
0.0272478778,
-0.239829421,
-0.2535846233,
0.0447062142,
0.3761329949,
-0.7621337175,
-0.1761737615,
-0.1758425832,
-0.0401326977,
0.0726838782,
-0.5992595553,
0.5988635421,
0.2060356438,
-0.3697250485,
-0.3349781334,
0.7709277868,
-0.1512337625,
-0.4995254278,
-0.0909098461,
0.7159567475,
0.1186271384,
-0.202985242,
-0.4767607152,
0.2962020636,
-0.0291162115,
-0.5201718807,
0.3737151921,
0.3387369812,
-0.4992022812,
0.4400520027,
0.5430961251,
-0.0636331588,
0.1669587493,
0.4949842989,
0.7663772702,
-0.8916805387,
-0.6180357933,
-1.1820985079,
0.4587824941,
-0.2005820721,
-0.602961123,
0.8579071164,
0.528559804,
0.5403152704,
-0.0807989985,
0.4132943749,
0.1917283535,
0.6139193177,
-0.4384200573,
0.5329862833,
-0.2742675841,
-0.1182158217,
-0.3786425591,
-0.7225590944,
-0.267252773,
0.6248865724,
-0.2626260221,
-0.3812185824,
0.4484115243,
0.2886743844,
0.3855353892,
0.77344203,
0.1359851658,
0.1405946612,
0.3721680939,
0.1562663466,
1.1247065067,
-0.2587989569,
0.4084104598,
-0.1611440331,
-0.0072290548,
-0.439350456,
-0.8861739635,
-0.7034569383,
-0.5739072561,
-0.4662594795,
0.3240987062,
-0.0172393676,
0.4984104633,
0.5366714597,
-1.0819350481,
-0.0258814897,
-0.219261378,
0.0938879624,
-0.3418081999,
-0.3079930246,
0.5552746654,
-0.090317376,
-0.4769049287,
0.5716898441,
0.3252483606,
0.1650035828,
-0.2057632208,
0.1480792314,
-0.1997596771,
0.0739131495,
0.3262584507,
-0.0325707681,
-0.813614428,
-0.3996017575,
-0.4009525478,
0.2510574758,
0.0610005818,
1.3006843328,
-0.5545401573,
0.3549934924,
0.3004341424,
0.5682908297,
0.7490182519,
0.224551782,
0.6433115005,
-0.8312091827,
0.0561887324,
0.5864596367,
0.5536096692,
0.0495946743,
-0.1657465398,
0.3924278617,
0.4564380944,
-0.2401268482,
-1.0475674868,
0.2560313344,
-0.9455242753,
-0.6327940822,
0.6297957897,
-0.2505517602,
0.2165118605,
-0.6639460325,
-0.2859602869,
0.3879162073,
-0.2263978571,
1.0933561325,
1.0423403978,
-0.3340166807,
-0.1795592755,
-0.8411377668,
0.2582979798,
0.1792041808,
-0.8499852419,
0.1757595092,
0.6537832618,
0.089432247,
0.2488470674,
0.4236107171,
-0.1591782123,
0.2301668674,
0.1556004286,
-0.2472144961,
0.1821612269,
-0.1042372063,
-0.1002301648,
0.7750704885,
-0.5165774226,
0.1837590784
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02637v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02637v1
|
TREC iKAT 2023: A Test Collection for Evaluating Conversational and Interactive Knowledge Assistants
| 2024-05-04T11:22:16 | 2024-05-04T11:22:16 |
Mohammad Aliannejadi, Zahra Abbasiantaeb, Shubham Chatterjee, Jeffery Dalton, Leif Azzopardi
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Conversational information seeking has evolved rapidly in the last few years
with the development of Large Language Models (LLMs), providing the basis for
interpreting and responding in a naturalistic manner to user requests. The
extended TREC Interactive Knowledge Assistance Track (iKAT) collection aims to
enable researchers to test and evaluate their Conversational Search Agents
(CSA). The collection contains a set of 36 personalized dialogues over 20
different topics each coupled with a Personal Text Knowledge Base (PTKB) that
defines the bespoke user personas. A total of 344 turns with approximately
26,000 passages are provided as assessments on relevance, as well as additional
assessments on generated responses over four key dimensions: relevance,
completeness, groundedness, and naturalness. The collection challenges CSA to
efficiently navigate diverse personal contexts, elicit pertinent persona
information, and employ context for relevant conversations. The integration of
a PTKB and the emphasis on decisional search tasks contribute to the uniqueness
of this test collection, making it an essential benchmark for advancing
research in conversational and interactive knowledge assistants.
|
[
-0.7519396544,
-0.7150253654,
0.6154105663,
0.1392452419,
-0.1425657123,
0.5565699935,
0.0778114423,
-0.6311809421,
0.1414982975,
0.6237997413,
-0.5267530084,
-0.5147394538,
-0.4946707785,
0.245275259,
-0.4872385561,
0.6547320485,
-0.084737055,
-0.3387423158,
-0.2548670769,
-0.336243093,
-0.8476157784,
0.0321878158,
-0.5965043306,
-0.0955083966,
0.6565854549,
1.0247088671,
0.543730855,
0.2084680796,
0.636361599,
0.2861251533,
-0.0563436896,
-0.0281323437,
-0.3632209301,
0.3851990998,
0.0865793079,
-0.4236083925,
-0.3280239999,
0.1067594141,
0.4170773923,
0.5810850859,
0.0004106102,
0.20756419,
-0.1895080954,
0.5261794925,
-0.5405353308,
0.3268782496,
-0.406232059,
-0.1069448292,
-0.2460040748,
-0.10959097,
-0.4079618454,
-0.6164816022,
0.8174185753,
-0.5993492603,
-0.2102430463,
0.1751047224,
0.7142430544,
-0.1304557025,
-0.9490152001,
-0.6564571857,
-0.7679772973,
0.7593472004,
-0.4702065587,
0.5466451049,
0.5884512067,
0.6488302946,
-0.2329250574,
-0.9674372077,
-0.6031003594,
-0.5465141535,
0.1060184315,
0.2773873508,
0.0082696145,
0.1851821989,
-0.0404729471,
0.443020165,
-0.5270401835,
-0.3481207192,
-0.2656959593,
-0.0229262076,
0.4031242728,
0.2007135153,
0.266208142,
-0.3210047781,
-0.2091126591,
-0.423679173,
-0.4277300239,
0.1335906535,
0.5001968145,
-0.0305758249,
-0.035114944,
1.0006046295,
-0.4529650807,
0.6530746222,
-0.076619871,
-0.1065379977,
0.1511251926,
-0.5064371228,
0.075507991,
0.0090915682,
0.6468615532,
0.1079217941,
0.2061665654,
-0.0638455823,
0.1558642536,
-0.3899257183,
0.3555726111,
-0.3995824754,
-0.2582886815,
0.2696770728,
-0.2644346356,
-0.3144812882,
0.1656458825,
-1.0082947016,
-0.3963663876,
-0.4674823582,
0.2836673558,
-0.6149952412,
-0.2391922176,
-0.0818612203,
-0.0275918245,
0.5128048062,
0.1479522139,
-0.4140426517,
0.1880580932,
0.5188664794,
0.6010816097,
-0.4574649334,
-0.139514938,
-0.2385456264,
0.0723605305,
-0.1936546415,
0.961173594,
-1.0394884348,
-0.6270025373,
0.0980381444,
-0.0589911975,
-0.1308556497,
-0.3763540387,
0.4833562076,
-0.7632807493,
0.3448522985,
-0.5677347779,
-0.2101706713,
-0.3253221214,
0.6405088305,
-0.8519461155,
1.380595088,
0.463193357,
-0.516359508,
0.4695912898,
-1.2182480097,
-0.4317903519,
0.2794522643,
-0.0914083347,
-0.2446097434,
-0.23624596,
-0.0054989425,
0.3589423299,
-0.4296231866,
0.2874387205,
-0.2643391192,
-0.4404750168,
0.3882793486,
-0.0331821665,
0.2818722129,
0.4867626727,
-0.6072731614,
-0.1113732308,
-0.7704812288,
0.0693581626,
-0.0352829322,
-0.575579226,
-0.3919730484,
-0.2175144106,
-0.1933950037,
0.0552522242,
0.3515993357,
-0.670075357,
0.0979047045,
-0.2967615426,
0.036561437,
0.7653896809,
0.2232586592,
0.0106738545,
-0.2674388289,
0.7701666355,
0.0783162117,
0.2711442709,
-0.2619801462,
-0.597971499,
-0.9694625139,
0.0147077171,
0.2871594727,
0.3533931077,
-0.9760413766,
0.3599713445,
-0.3711798191,
-0.4815232754,
-0.5088284612,
-0.0603279062,
0.3247294426,
0.5128324628,
0.1387962401,
-0.3075197637,
-0.6383697391,
-0.85941571,
-0.217255339,
-0.3946335316,
-0.1067206562,
0.8197523355,
0.5644529462,
-0.2719706893,
1.1148833036,
-0.1619865,
-0.2160382718,
-0.5659227371,
0.4826852381,
-0.2600781024,
0.1086672321,
0.4242634177,
-0.9536956549,
-0.6580995917,
0.3134129643,
-0.518155396,
-0.0973053128,
0.2222566754,
-0.1676460505,
0.0945448652,
0.144484356,
-0.3801816404,
0.4944470227,
0.4461209178,
-0.5496980548,
0.3222208321,
0.2577663064,
0.7251909971,
-1.1938766241,
0.4315878153,
-0.3590498269,
-0.1467364281,
-0.3695086539,
-0.056376949,
-0.2850079834,
-0.1535396874,
-0.3586352468,
0.6644890904,
-0.3459698856,
-0.0813995376,
-0.1156504154,
0.313049823,
-0.1098399013,
0.5752264857,
-0.1762543321,
0.9233013391,
0.0670723766,
-0.7058598399,
0.5010656714,
0.6271312237,
-0.3647800088,
0.947273016,
-0.438411355,
0.6479462385,
0.1983267516,
0.0493052788,
-1.1388511658,
-0.4224213064,
0.1028560996,
-0.5421043038,
0.0921219736,
0.2792753577,
-0.278847903,
-0.4713478386,
-0.3236475587,
0.4174752235,
0.3928343058,
-0.5560062528,
1.1312084198,
0.5626706481,
-0.2969779372,
-0.6006133556,
-0.4795031548,
0.3150809705,
-0.0969971791,
-0.5270692706,
-0.2143477798,
-0.2412446141,
-0.2011391521,
-0.1607322246,
-0.1694333106,
0.0358448513,
0.0930340439,
0.1600221097,
0.0340972692,
-0.231753841,
-0.0601062588,
-0.2017372102,
0.1041592285,
0.0624491759,
-0.0946907699,
0.8536277413,
-0.4609689116,
-0.5561783314,
-0.1752429605,
0.3173305094,
0.6519748569,
-0.0839235634,
0.5178521276,
0.6166322827,
-0.0506119914,
0.562725246,
-1.1525347233,
0.0143654328,
-0.5223307014,
0.2968603373,
-0.5881386995,
-1.0612610579,
0.6829789281,
-0.1855565757,
0.0799957067,
0.3443754911,
0.3316242993,
-0.2146886438,
1.1522971392,
0.5427683592,
0.0076217633,
0.4010055065,
-0.2767686844,
0.1693853438,
-0.9349954128,
-0.8898202777,
-0.7382122874,
-0.3143389821,
-0.500900507,
0.0277470034,
0.4256493449,
-0.7387788296,
-0.0668420568,
0.4160394967,
-0.3396811485,
0.3565934896,
0.831266284,
0.2399806231,
0.3889721334,
-0.3819903433,
-0.3955747187,
-0.1210335121,
-0.248263821,
-0.4770599604,
1.2091674805,
0.191915825,
0.4817138016,
0.1400731504,
0.1683057845,
0.6497594714,
0.3355331123,
-0.9651787877,
0.9185605049,
0.303894043,
-0.5957568884,
-0.277281791,
-0.3909199238,
-1.0164718628,
-0.3474300504,
0.3067193329,
-0.7362545729,
0.1210233122,
-0.0267306399,
0.0608231686,
0.2403111309,
-0.597812295,
0.7657417059,
-0.2588117421,
0.0277443416,
-0.0747631937,
-0.8526920676,
0.4826738536,
-0.1606822312,
-0.2434230149,
-0.1214027703,
-0.0118687414,
0.8940061927,
0.0443534814,
0.525246501,
-0.2199240029,
0.3686034679,
0.4626373649,
0.3637317121,
0.6818063855,
-0.1896528453,
0.0242870376,
-0.297789067,
0.3236929774,
-0.3703828454,
-0.3324968517,
0.515368104,
-0.7004343867,
-0.4938248098,
-0.53334409,
-0.6170918345,
-0.5833908319,
0.3378478587,
-0.1074525192,
0.2612296343,
-0.4556812644,
0.7589671612,
0.8262928724,
-0.2646199763,
-0.0729594678,
0.7223027349,
-0.0097233038,
-0.3533563912,
0.748873651,
-0.2957117558,
0.2060741782,
0.4987227321,
0.2707073987,
-0.4951542914,
-0.6245383024,
0.1964371502,
0.0564024895,
-0.7098683715,
-0.1912335306,
-0.8970683813,
-0.0441152975,
-0.6336377263,
0.0545560122,
-0.1691310257,
-0.04819436,
-0.1122193485,
-0.1348823309,
0.6227328777,
1.0644364357,
0.2244090885,
0.632583499,
-0.4827825427,
0.3609308302,
0.5163981915,
0.4095992744,
-0.3453435004,
-0.5200487375,
-0.0655965954,
0.0004968608,
-0.4269105196,
-0.7986318469,
0.2010333687,
0.0769596025,
0.5677113533,
0.2683115602,
0.1966791898,
0.7387857437,
0.1510959715,
0.8854916692,
-0.0363870151,
-0.7069725394,
0.6120051146,
-0.4250749052,
0.5786871314,
1.085474968,
0.4678240418,
-0.8862522244,
-0.5365689397,
-0.6169355512,
-0.7160315514,
0.9179466963,
0.2394046932,
-0.1714697182,
-0.158189401,
0.2522306144,
0.1007526517,
0.2686075568,
-0.4341268241,
-0.0130494311,
-0.1044045314,
-0.532084167,
0.4549614191,
-0.6072546244,
-0.0923608616,
0.0598003045,
0.7610834241,
-0.2932940125,
0.4106405675,
0.1580986828,
0.0952797979,
-0.0308998972,
0.2897903323,
0.4172230363,
0.5760273337,
-0.4530454576,
0.0483677201,
0.4250384271,
-1.0955125093,
0.028917145,
0.0529440157,
0.0419549495,
-0.2174260914,
-0.0746570528,
0.6608185768,
0.3347720206,
-1.0241829157,
0.3799900115,
-0.3657324016,
-0.0945787281,
-0.7362043858,
-0.1163251027,
-0.0963108242,
-0.0153712742,
0.3443204761,
-0.0493643582,
0.3388233483,
-0.5083790421,
0.3451331258,
0.3443855941,
-0.719848752,
-0.3066144586,
0.4389283955,
0.3461484313,
-0.3480528295,
0.7664375305,
0.0181443393,
-0.4771740139,
0.4899408221,
-0.0260618981,
0.9771459103,
-0.2790150642,
0.3489797413,
0.0698823482,
0.3151465952,
0.0981530473,
0.3139593303,
-0.3472287059,
-0.3788109422,
-0.1982379705,
-0.4364379942,
-0.8938407302,
0.4395437837,
-0.706923008,
0.3656264842,
0.0624456294,
-0.0124554737,
-0.4279799461,
0.4290910661,
-0.9611507654,
0.0719867796,
-0.2517226338,
1.1525626183,
-0.3664331734,
0.5527919531,
0.5841849446,
-0.2428323925,
-0.7461310625,
-0.1915562153,
-0.0157969911,
-1.0480531454,
0.3591039181,
0.0495854616,
-0.2153090984,
-0.0887728035,
-0.5652505159,
-0.9035843015,
1.3138767481,
0.1810585856,
-0.2740778029,
-0.1027532145,
0.8371702433,
0.4948367774,
-0.2477372289,
0.6465030313,
1.1564034224,
0.889908433,
0.6391274929,
-0.9283989668,
-0.171628803,
-0.2607151866,
-0.2562032938,
0.0233711097,
-0.6764555573,
0.2241109461,
0.1117788702,
-0.1605715007,
0.524695158,
0.460406065,
0.5527129769,
0.5417560935,
0.6792083979,
0.3294302821,
0.4892953038,
-0.4320340157,
1.104095459,
-0.13378793,
-0.1322413385,
1.1206790209,
-0.368458122,
0.4979805946,
0.5392203331,
-0.0139817651,
0.4145977199,
0.7631570101,
0.2568500042,
0.3452580571,
-0.1511120498,
-0.3063054085,
-0.085344024,
-0.4843410254,
-0.1248582676,
0.5624158382,
0.3964770138,
-0.09689904,
0.084640421,
0.33478719,
0.0103020407,
-0.0231331829,
0.1998992562,
0.9863256216,
-0.1158126444,
-0.989339292,
-0.1249285117,
-0.43864429,
0.3392971754,
-0.8910172582,
-0.1417915225,
-0.3215634525,
0.0948801115,
0.2517681718,
-1.0193800926,
-0.0023838261,
-0.136785537,
0.5629996657,
-0.0805719048,
0.7776066661,
-0.2344911546,
-0.3195398152,
0.2088772506,
0.4390493929,
0.3246828318,
-0.0046331515,
-0.5943040848,
0.0247898828,
0.0788691267,
-0.7435901165,
0.0902490839,
0.4923734367,
0.0115829213,
0.9413052201,
0.5739016533,
-0.0683558062,
0.1513341218,
0.0961348712,
0.8634536266,
-0.8624500036,
-0.2632702589,
-0.1428753734,
0.4253191054,
-0.1264478415,
-0.5793536305,
0.5320252776,
0.7096067071,
0.7018575072,
0.0211206917,
0.782583952,
-0.3235371411,
0.8123334646,
-0.2722679377,
0.3584528267,
-0.383515656,
0.281675905,
-0.1343662441,
-0.732689321,
0.0296700075,
0.228203997,
-0.2652631998,
0.3281732202,
0.715270102,
0.4129526913,
-0.0531137846,
0.340249598,
0.3159108758,
0.0956154317,
0.6078029275,
0.5655037761,
1.2150212526,
-0.4732966125,
1.1329209805,
-0.3741033077,
0.0242894161,
-0.3328941762,
-0.7471671104,
-1.0428814888,
-0.8210096955,
-0.0765635297,
-0.1330706328,
0.0919078887,
0.7736329436,
0.5078833699,
-0.9640017748,
-0.1874973476,
-0.1360316873,
0.0126563571,
0.0651632622,
-0.3633016944,
0.1017384753,
-0.0720375553,
-0.8106358647,
0.3978487551,
0.2128747553,
0.2627829611,
-0.4647300541,
-0.1173664331,
-0.3511562645,
0.0364694223,
0.5029434562,
0.4931007922,
-0.602940917,
-0.6931263208,
0.8105371594,
0.102897726,
0.0694088712,
0.9612129927,
-0.9300396442,
0.8497570753,
0.4651705623,
0.5860937834,
0.7523722053,
-0.0576820746,
0.8220698237,
-0.684255898,
-0.0675408095,
0.7225805521,
0.094255805,
0.1970201284,
-0.3219295442,
0.7177052498,
-0.0675229132,
-0.6551112533,
-1.0318945646,
-0.0239639357,
-1.4407619238,
0.3049083054,
1.0271645784,
-0.0334974416,
-0.0963011533,
-0.6441524029,
-0.4497179091,
0.2450009584,
-0.5822467804,
1.0293675661,
0.8126497865,
-0.1617954522,
-0.2695663571,
-0.5913587809,
0.3167360127,
0.4094713926,
-1.1203876734,
-0.2633910477,
0.117526561,
0.1285688579,
0.1969735473,
0.3936255872,
-0.3691512942,
0.4066528678,
-0.4613956511,
0.1448763609,
-0.0646283329,
-0.4595320821,
0.1640082151,
0.0116914306,
0.1617278755,
-0.0858971477
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02602v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02602v1
|
Astro-NER -- Astronomy Named Entity Recognition: Is GPT a Good Domain Expert Annotator?
| 2024-05-04T08:04:39 | 2024-05-04T08:04:39 |
Julia Evans, Sameer Sadruddin, Jennifer D'Souza
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IT, math.IT
|
In this study, we address one of the challenges of developing NER models for
scholarly domains, namely the scarcity of suitable labeled data. We experiment
with an approach using predictions from a fine-tuned LLM model to aid
non-domain experts in annotating scientific entities within astronomy
literature, with the goal of uncovering whether such a collaborative process
can approximate domain expertise. Our results reveal moderate agreement between
a domain expert and the LLM-assisted non-experts, as well as fair agreement
between the domain expert and the LLM model's predictions. In an additional
experiment, we compare the performance of finetuned and default LLMs on this
task. We have also introduced a specialized scientific entity annotation scheme
for astronomy, validated by a domain expert. Our approach adopts a scholarly
research contribution-centric perspective, focusing exclusively on scientific
entities relevant to the research theme. The resultant dataset, containing
5,000 annotated astronomy article titles, is made publicly available.
|
[
-0.5156641006,
-0.3681000471,
0.7034993768,
-0.2271549553,
-0.1726167202,
-0.0130774565,
-0.2426863313,
-0.9686254859,
0.6528084278,
0.7394697666,
-0.361826092,
-0.4402057528,
-0.9550555944,
0.5126284361,
-0.5118207335,
1.3668407202,
0.1631709188,
-0.0951039046,
-0.636654079,
0.261099875,
-0.2243988067,
-0.1725118607,
-0.8852849603,
-0.2057410032,
0.7624305487,
0.258392185,
0.6516619325,
0.7285833955,
1.0898464918,
0.2545558214,
-0.1978720129,
0.4986557364,
-0.4259916246,
-0.1352903843,
-0.477845937,
-0.1211545318,
-0.7551496029,
0.1200380102,
0.2798469663,
0.820476234,
0.1279225051,
0.2246828079,
-0.0480250791,
0.2982831895,
-0.2916460931,
0.2000321299,
-0.9876998067,
-0.1376663744,
-0.5458165407,
-0.2869340777,
-0.3010724485,
-0.2828429937,
0.308944732,
-1.4546283484,
0.4072187543,
0.4920075238,
0.9385861754,
0.6827630997,
-0.2355857342,
-0.4111739099,
-0.9290117621,
0.6796835065,
-0.4340252876,
0.0882378817,
0.4358600676,
0.1390610188,
-0.181900844,
-0.6495100856,
-0.4918058813,
-0.217586875,
-0.0793512315,
0.0879329965,
0.0071419599,
-0.1400112957,
0.1207749769,
-0.0785822198,
-0.3566882312,
0.1741557419,
-0.4242984951,
-0.1955920607,
0.5833135843,
0.1011055186,
-0.1828936785,
-0.2769099474,
-0.2445392311,
0.410651356,
-0.6824766994,
-0.6158101559,
0.3870130777,
0.2043221295,
0.4632362127,
0.8552094102,
-0.1557526886,
0.4804888368,
0.568295002,
-0.0182597451,
-0.109259285,
-0.1189269349,
-0.1026040837,
-0.0619380176,
0.5240998864,
0.4059960544,
0.2476776093,
-0.6658779383,
0.0015437158,
0.1229937375,
0.2606498301,
-0.4225588739,
-0.5250262022,
-0.0055003823,
-0.0513858199,
-0.113763608,
0.0080803772,
-0.643497467,
-0.5836586952,
-0.5452759862,
0.6547574997,
-0.2341488749,
0.0051484718,
-0.1609797478,
0.1113735065,
-0.262111485,
0.7775515318,
-0.9133279324,
0.403285116,
0.9429852962,
0.5607626438,
-0.0637626126,
-0.2248864919,
-0.2023931444,
0.2448643297,
-0.1347513199,
1.0340864658,
-0.7452381253,
-0.4774772227,
-0.6130470037,
-0.101332888,
-0.0407780074,
-0.4049096704,
0.5390664935,
-0.9641566277,
0.0905786678,
-0.139124766,
-0.9472873807,
-0.2732878327,
-0.0885345712,
-0.6670818329,
0.7803446651,
-0.0770657882,
-0.7315788865,
0.907076478,
-0.6759712696,
0.2241596878,
0.6231766343,
-0.2407713681,
-0.4112843871,
0.0350681618,
0.1717183292,
0.3055474758,
0.0112927584,
0.3486044705,
-0.3167196512,
-0.0439281464,
0.3428034186,
0.0450615957,
-0.0604433343,
0.1501309574,
-0.0792540684,
-0.1272536665,
-0.6684367061,
-0.1000236645,
-0.1895070374,
0.1021918282,
-0.6990104318,
0.0020327622,
0.3251319826,
-0.1885643154,
0.478916198,
-0.562918067,
0.5528799295,
-0.2237960845,
-0.0210944489,
0.5623212457,
0.1883633733,
0.7021252513,
-0.0671873093,
0.2376964241,
-0.2223389447,
-0.0029234311,
0.3751100004,
-0.712721467,
-0.6791968942,
-0.0894138217,
0.5393166542,
0.2423829436,
-0.5234758258,
0.180760771,
-0.0908362865,
-0.7319100499,
-0.4745242596,
0.0894706026,
0.5701431036,
0.76936692,
0.5414072871,
-0.3425439,
-0.6699232459,
-0.8121442199,
-0.2064748257,
-0.2106626183,
0.1642390043,
0.7428919673,
0.9975525141,
-0.2819729149,
0.9178643227,
-0.4130839407,
-0.349468112,
0.6034712791,
0.3284168839,
0.1400616467,
0.2041989118,
0.1843111068,
-0.786488533,
-0.416649431,
0.24734734,
-0.7606288195,
-0.1451804638,
0.0517075993,
-0.0130953174,
0.2307083458,
0.3284139931,
-0.5119236708,
0.3124039769,
0.3161930442,
-0.4662072659,
0.5502421856,
-0.1942057014,
0.1661881655,
-0.8458867073,
0.3628047109,
0.2588577569,
-0.0648769662,
-0.4696922898,
-0.217645973,
-0.0970143825,
0.1489665061,
-0.1965480745,
0.6625992656,
-0.5609544516,
-0.1184268817,
-0.651701808,
0.092969507,
-0.2783925235,
-0.1666990519,
0.6331695318,
0.686114192,
0.466316998,
-0.5702598691,
0.0854427963,
0.5938832164,
-0.1860090196,
0.6454386115,
-0.5942112803,
0.3695668578,
-0.2151279747,
0.0345230922,
-0.4619161189,
-0.5194813609,
0.1950591207,
-0.4243816435,
0.3768202662,
-0.607196331,
-0.1919758618,
-0.2236406654,
0.5936956406,
0.3014093637,
0.1861603409,
-0.3491956294,
0.4833106101,
0.4705630243,
-0.4036028981,
-0.7746313214,
-0.1853710413,
0.4628615379,
-0.4479934275,
-0.5569858551,
0.8302311897,
0.1344775558,
-0.3427644968,
0.4722024798,
0.0207872223,
-0.0241683535,
0.0504014455,
0.5470943451,
0.4491422474,
-0.0564351566,
0.0646577999,
-0.4521055222,
-0.600763917,
0.0248061158,
-0.5680524111,
-0.193426922,
-0.2493474931,
-0.1114120111,
-0.148897633,
0.0999492705,
0.0375426076,
0.0272679776,
0.4132098258,
0.4432922006,
-0.5751562715,
0.022900274,
-0.6124784946,
-0.3079782426,
-0.3998140395,
0.1330631971,
-0.1853515357,
-0.9389004111,
0.5488102436,
-0.0132578062,
-0.0559278987,
0.7765966654,
0.2452184409,
-0.2460223436,
0.3368718922,
0.7677412033,
0.0553061664,
-0.1114665121,
-0.3121296465,
-0.0195721183,
-0.8947512507,
-0.4211432636,
-0.6385104656,
-0.2622728944,
-0.432038784,
-0.6203633547,
0.3437446058,
-0.1025242209,
0.0240540151,
0.6165959835,
-0.8046317101,
0.7800872326,
0.4749603868,
-0.2111620307,
0.4013896585,
-0.1749582589,
0.4883041084,
-0.3691336513,
-0.2188316286,
-0.921795547,
1.1313561201,
0.0700246319,
0.9465481043,
-0.1358516812,
0.9105908275,
0.0390420631,
0.6604965329,
-0.5201833248,
0.490789175,
-0.2106382847,
-0.7773805261,
-0.2521913648,
-0.3795399368,
-0.7293917537,
-0.1819023788,
-0.4342423975,
-0.6333682537,
0.5366664529,
-0.047851298,
-0.3965342939,
0.2129198313,
-0.3134411871,
0.5186639428,
-0.0703243241,
-0.2027499229,
-0.0030749787,
-0.4778712392,
0.0467019901,
-0.5030755401,
0.2012866139,
-0.150123477,
-0.4212562442,
1.0396335125,
-0.0576767474,
0.7490913868,
-0.3075656593,
0.1907146126,
0.242650345,
0.1442177594,
0.4981354773,
0.5054957867,
-0.0813371688,
0.2158937454,
-0.3306591809,
-0.1361445785,
-0.236107111,
0.902536273,
-0.9316593409,
-0.6642902493,
-0.609128952,
-0.4860664308,
-0.0800029635,
0.2342824638,
0.2520530522,
0.1129472628,
-0.1146631911,
-0.0062846518,
0.6738491654,
0.3163520396,
0.1973883808,
0.5382521749,
-0.2115236968,
-0.6065747738,
0.7133664489,
0.2997814715,
-0.2530007362,
0.4398598373,
-0.2853248119,
-0.2651827037,
-1.019294858,
-0.261418581,
0.1865785122,
-0.5512245893,
-0.2845102847,
-0.798507154,
-0.0386290513,
-0.0625070184,
-0.3841881454,
-0.3014444411,
-0.7015962005,
-0.7917656898,
-0.1018950567,
0.7791287303,
0.8861064315,
0.0845701247,
0.090252921,
-0.3625065088,
-0.062853165,
0.0234663244,
0.1722600907,
-0.3950037658,
-0.599743247,
-0.5028725266,
-0.3488245904,
-0.1885433793,
-0.5688311458,
0.4895688593,
0.4679093659,
0.4248977304,
0.2364833504,
-0.157306686,
0.7218037844,
-0.4820325673,
0.6366805434,
-0.0616238378,
-0.5600880384,
0.3471897244,
-0.5658820868,
-0.3624075055,
0.7185236812,
0.4673928618,
-0.2144403309,
-0.5389342308,
-0.8413796425,
-0.7950452566,
0.3755493164,
0.1908620149,
-0.1095828041,
-0.0558836497,
0.8702113032,
0.5756094456,
0.1851145774,
-0.7031072974,
-0.2294309586,
-0.1478174031,
0.1540285647,
-0.1850871146,
0.1248228028,
0.0062671551,
0.245840475,
0.7899720073,
-0.1465686858,
0.3125469983,
0.3963344395,
0.0304411612,
-0.3815360367,
0.1262044758,
0.3965023458,
0.7018718123,
-0.3073479533,
0.1073402539,
0.1412410736,
-0.5732741952,
-0.1949877888,
0.4173074663,
-0.4817401171,
-0.0247536954,
0.2807617486,
0.4897566736,
0.1530936807,
0.0635337159,
-0.0273924042,
0.238692224,
-0.3460121453,
-0.4891507328,
0.0352506265,
0.2620660365,
0.2203014046,
0.6644394994,
0.5400242805,
0.3455197513,
0.1304671317,
0.2537173033,
0.5230302215,
-0.2180044502,
-0.459281832,
1.1380087137,
0.1815366596,
-0.050267078,
0.2765702903,
-0.3572070003,
-0.2179586291,
0.7948111892,
0.2765797377,
0.6739991307,
0.1727879643,
0.1498931944,
0.196849063,
0.1744434983,
0.1196373329,
0.079293482,
0.346922189,
-0.4613239169,
-0.7694091797,
-0.5718691945,
-1.0283271074,
-0.1662198156,
-0.3286624551,
0.3629142344,
-0.375138402,
-0.5835083127,
0.8686103225,
0.4923378527,
-0.8804994226,
0.302015394,
0.217628479,
0.6660634875,
-0.5743457079,
0.6005331874,
0.9605354667,
-0.4918428659,
-0.6502978802,
-0.4477248192,
0.1120603457,
-0.5000796318,
1.05392766,
-0.0729985386,
-0.0012811883,
0.1346156299,
-0.432189554,
-1.1343120337,
1.2322955132,
-0.0356713869,
-0.8447301984,
0.0645153522,
-0.1528120488,
0.7519041896,
-0.5976109505,
0.5386683345,
-0.1683049649,
0.8585253954,
0.2706413865,
-1.0629141331,
-0.1890021116,
-0.2507081032,
-0.2627464235,
0.4825965464,
-0.5287462473,
0.6765382886,
-0.4293017387,
-0.0270336568,
0.2616972625,
0.9704732895,
0.0677568614,
0.9923212528,
0.1893410236,
0.6492791176,
1.0645612478,
-0.1552342325,
0.7603377104,
-0.2381720692,
0.5686578751,
0.7467841506,
-0.4956945479,
0.6210819483,
0.7780616879,
-0.1612302363,
0.2683267891,
0.808208406,
-0.5238858461,
0.5697187781,
-0.1177456975,
-0.1987621039,
-0.171342805,
-0.3879465759,
-0.3146243691,
0.1632981151,
0.4899449646,
-0.2231081575,
0.0537829734,
-0.2047334015,
0.0531382151,
0.0477973334,
-0.4959480762,
0.9197862148,
0.2941892445,
-0.5506852269,
0.0337544456,
0.0208892394,
0.8646979928,
-0.2045228481,
0.1679997742,
0.1183129549,
-0.0261728242,
-0.6420336962,
-0.7420428395,
0.5025468469,
0.2013739198,
-0.3955547214,
0.1104909927,
0.9235825539,
-0.3729576766,
-0.5929229856,
0.0942546427,
0.4998779297,
0.478662461,
0.1506671757,
-0.22379677,
-0.5308898687,
-0.2936919034,
-0.1932820678,
0.272175163,
0.4073006213,
-0.1204305217,
0.4861794412,
0.7268003821,
0.2546294928,
-0.0901664197,
-0.206651181,
0.5546751022,
-0.689247787,
-0.0413600914,
-0.4798023105,
0.2021045089,
0.0186054129,
-0.6355512142,
0.8747518063,
0.5197719336,
0.7583437562,
-0.3532055914,
0.5783244371,
-0.1291014552,
0.4942649007,
-0.2334426343,
0.5838929415,
-0.3283747733,
0.3385536075,
-0.3973246217,
-1.1258823872,
-0.5736865401,
0.3565114141,
-0.7312990427,
0.1975586116,
0.438816011,
0.7620351911,
-0.1003586799,
0.1458461285,
0.0688547269,
0.0021487903,
0.1999723613,
0.5599917769,
0.9161018133,
-0.2046347708,
0.3669413626,
-0.2616806328,
-0.0042441413,
-0.4426109195,
-1.1410826445,
-0.825661242,
-0.3606151044,
-0.7871158719,
-0.1160237864,
0.1126233414,
0.8336082101,
0.7602538466,
-0.7160139084,
0.3840796351,
-0.1086801142,
-0.2521392703,
-0.1339227259,
-0.1373978555,
0.6293079853,
0.1120224744,
-0.6976627707,
0.3857147098,
0.1636282206,
-0.1091064438,
-0.0890841261,
-0.1411788464,
0.3945654333,
0.1510559618,
0.0410359316,
0.1773033291,
-0.7766571641,
-0.5695485473,
0.3378182054,
-0.0154502923,
-0.2904850245,
0.2696089149,
-0.6645992994,
0.3511619866,
-0.1063067093,
0.5151994228,
0.4457426071,
0.0337686017,
-0.1276486665,
-0.4701404274,
-0.3460987806,
0.5455362797,
0.2595406771,
0.3936000168,
-0.8101525903,
0.7400657535,
0.2975466251,
-1.2355211973,
-0.5287635922,
-0.0812817067,
-1.2888519764,
0.3207530379,
1.066287756,
0.0096872309,
-0.051783096,
-0.2894515693,
-0.1351403296,
-0.2495604753,
-0.6385825872,
0.9861097336,
0.6601862311,
-0.3584153354,
-0.132936582,
-0.4953272939,
0.5109199882,
0.2320045978,
-0.7310420871,
-0.165850386,
0.4488624334,
0.3375247419,
0.6907092333,
0.4530289173,
-0.1069218814,
0.3071585,
-0.0218503755,
0.1987106204,
-0.4255674779,
-0.5807368159,
0.1335585117,
0.0216588415,
0.3426856399,
0.4258162677
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02596v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02596v1
|
Random Masking Finds Winning Tickets for Parameter Efficient Fine-tuning
| 2024-05-04T07:44:18 | 2024-05-04T07:44:18 |
Jing Xu, Jingzhao Zhang
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.AI, cs.CL
|
Fine-tuning large language models (LLM) can be costly. Parameter-efficient
fine-tuning (PEFT) addresses the problems by training a fraction of the
parameters, whose success reveals the expressiveness and flexibility of
pretrained models. This paper studies the limit of PEFT, by further simplifying
its design and reducing the number of trainable parameters beyond standard
setups. To this end, we use Random Masking to fine-tune the pretrained model.
Despite its simplicity, we show that Random Masking is surprisingly effective:
with a larger-than-expected learning rate, Random Masking can match the
performance of standard PEFT algorithms such as LoRA on various tasks, using
fewer trainable parameters. We provide both empirical and theoretical
explorations into the success of Random Masking. We show that masking induces a
flatter loss landscape and more distant solutions, which allows for and
necessitates large learning rates.
|
[
-0.6679210663,
-0.7937250733,
0.5019735694,
0.0616616048,
-0.5269887447,
0.0360095017,
-0.4738561511,
-0.4996209741,
-0.0087019484,
0.6721447706,
-0.5202508569,
-0.2953262627,
-0.6151891947,
-0.1946277022,
-0.4011766613,
0.9744521976,
0.1017843112,
-0.1694947332,
0.3047624528,
0.1562813967,
-0.0183370635,
-0.4857175648,
-1.1811554432,
-0.3986169994,
0.7758890986,
0.3338039219,
0.4046560526,
0.8862610459,
0.4214146137,
0.1505342424,
0.0368919969,
0.388520807,
-0.8117287159,
-0.115731962,
0.0895592198,
-0.7746774554,
0.179411456,
0.1115269512,
0.908569634,
0.8279519081,
-0.3301816881,
0.0255339071,
0.0274218675,
0.7156054378,
-0.618113637,
-0.2005692422,
-0.9448339343,
0.2553061843,
-0.5146618485,
-0.2181634009,
-0.3245190978,
-0.1392706037,
-0.0986862183,
-0.6175560355,
0.262978822,
0.2790917158,
1.010404706,
0.4114782214,
0.030960381,
0.1380293667,
-0.9985547662,
0.7700845599,
-0.5450133681,
0.3767391443,
0.4314071238,
0.4823840857,
-0.2750552297,
-0.5520060658,
-0.3523873687,
0.0834000111,
0.122031033,
-0.4058302045,
-0.0877458528,
0.2513802052,
0.4308517277,
0.381261766,
-0.3464772999,
0.3889458776,
-0.3646689057,
-0.309025079,
0.4679259956,
0.0428908579,
0.0661496446,
0.4638914168,
-0.1945220232,
-0.2651358247,
-0.7912976742,
0.2715601921,
0.7595351934,
0.3696376085,
0.3177901208,
0.2572208047,
-0.6620136499,
1.0565072298,
0.2003481239,
-0.2619599104,
-0.271846652,
0.1859440804,
-0.3662421107,
-0.2573729157,
0.4887351692,
0.0892797336,
0.6666070819,
-0.4258517921,
-0.4032027423,
-0.3276194036,
0.0144899525,
-0.754652977,
-0.392839402,
-0.1006669179,
-0.2748578489,
-0.5663816929,
-0.0411611721,
-0.3920553327,
-0.3525752127,
-0.4060931504,
0.6157085299,
-0.2810834944,
0.0527799763,
0.5326597095,
-0.0850764289,
0.4057850838,
0.5676723123,
-0.9120803475,
0.3309047222,
0.7646095753,
0.4947440028,
-0.0541902781,
-0.3716261983,
-0.9524177909,
-0.0942469761,
-0.4524430037,
0.9120411277,
-0.4886495173,
0.1540843993,
-0.3443407416,
-0.2251905352,
-0.2369785756,
-0.7360547781,
0.2223045677,
-0.6761739254,
-0.0921123251,
-0.0720165744,
-0.3295357525,
-0.1809810251,
-0.0774387196,
-0.6467788815,
0.698481977,
-0.0154363895,
-0.1106746495,
0.7514704466,
-0.2650869191,
-0.4138106704,
-0.0198535901,
-0.0796933994,
-0.6151506901,
0.5479325652,
0.0840319544,
0.5083723664,
-0.177877143,
0.159643963,
-0.359089613,
-0.6230338812,
0.1390468031,
-0.4183168411,
0.5500842929,
0.6423377395,
-0.4312873781,
-0.2393700033,
-1.0294795036,
0.073568061,
0.0475652777,
-0.4807935655,
-0.3675225973,
-0.0377156138,
0.0050043068,
0.1326438636,
-0.0178889092,
-0.470279932,
0.0142414859,
-0.6585615277,
0.4864905179,
0.8645883203,
-0.0777078718,
0.5976836085,
-0.5020641088,
0.3851565421,
-0.139983058,
0.1175129563,
0.0067653558,
-0.3871174753,
-0.6492195129,
-0.5353733301,
0.6545663476,
0.2350231856,
-0.2253055423,
0.1174414828,
0.181910798,
-0.510646224,
-0.6026089191,
0.439362675,
0.3707888722,
0.276955694,
-0.0519324504,
-0.2938465774,
-0.3503373861,
-1.162653327,
-0.6059408784,
0.2570621669,
-0.1988799274,
0.2382709682,
0.0822877735,
0.1803717464,
0.7449941039,
-0.5355002284,
-0.4154343903,
0.0345556214,
0.1155075431,
0.1717812717,
0.7944946289,
0.5886013508,
-0.6476419568,
-0.6232967377,
0.0349472314,
0.0286815614,
-0.1598979533,
-0.3038211167,
0.0194614474,
0.1332813352,
0.5632657409,
-0.4050043225,
0.1813895851,
0.3447779119,
-0.0021925841,
0.1945009232,
-0.2156965137,
0.0244425163,
-0.5210235119,
-0.0311764479,
-0.1574094892,
-0.6630513072,
-0.4432050288,
0.3352939487,
-0.2155067176,
-0.3223541081,
-0.4548467398,
0.4886625111,
-0.3605214357,
0.3724295199,
-0.3258116245,
-0.2035818398,
-0.0931246206,
0.6221359372,
-0.0694375262,
0.4540066421,
0.5904986858,
-0.4783742428,
-0.1123322174,
-0.4826478064,
-0.6082843542,
0.4280442595,
-0.4800482094,
0.3045120537,
-0.0995038524,
0.0609239079,
-1.0479977131,
-0.4351215363,
0.2551605403,
0.0477397256,
0.3819377422,
-0.1691488326,
-0.6074572206,
-0.1635186821,
-0.3408111036,
0.5170540214,
0.7797726393,
-0.73897475,
0.4443511963,
0.3890349865,
0.2091085166,
-0.3160844445,
-0.5183476806,
0.0161336381,
-0.4696216285,
-0.4512034357,
0.4155354202,
-0.2176503837,
-0.0346771143,
-0.3614452481,
-0.269448787,
-0.1299780309,
0.3640821874,
0.0185743626,
-0.5389090776,
-0.1903530955,
-0.0542432368,
0.0848753303,
-0.1092311442,
-0.2115475088,
-0.3572487533,
0.6657586694,
-0.1202201843,
-0.4355018437,
-0.2177401483,
0.4338953197,
0.3287178874,
-0.111354053,
0.8863332868,
0.6254987717,
-0.6783399582,
-0.7215721607,
-1.0089761019,
-0.2874125242,
-0.5011001229,
0.282351464,
-0.6350390315,
-1.1917688847,
0.8713119626,
-0.1666566283,
-0.0439930558,
0.2596155107,
0.3044853806,
-0.1572817862,
1.1174526215,
0.9109977484,
0.1880262494,
0.618157208,
0.0835706443,
0.2834735513,
-0.3697635829,
-0.1402502954,
-0.5184183121,
-0.6179760695,
-0.6577276587,
-0.2786281407,
0.1229503453,
0.5297610164,
-0.3104457259,
0.119596988,
-0.7017868161,
1.1843420267,
0.9380789399,
0.3994272649,
0.37612167,
0.4094251692,
0.248091951,
-0.0263704974,
-0.8167555332,
-0.2251763344,
0.9869989753,
0.4541722834,
0.9403403997,
-0.3828091919,
1.0889121294,
-0.1619363129,
0.0723851472,
-0.4898658097,
0.4040794671,
-0.3194569647,
-0.5699868798,
-0.6256234646,
-0.3163439929,
-0.7399209142,
-0.0028568346,
-0.1758943945,
-0.7947804928,
0.4998452067,
0.3580766618,
-0.6740349531,
0.5963836312,
-0.7650005221,
0.5133568048,
0.1225211844,
-0.1053576469,
-0.1128165722,
-0.7056116462,
0.3763048351,
-0.7501714826,
-0.0078472849,
-0.0919352695,
0.044115711,
1.0574380159,
-0.2930745184,
0.9444720745,
-0.234569639,
-0.1274861097,
0.1409731805,
-0.0246120673,
0.7639458776,
0.0739053562,
0.0141739426,
0.0396469608,
-0.0147917755,
-0.5085631609,
-0.5816121101,
0.7279580235,
-0.69062078,
-0.7803687453,
-0.0580822229,
-0.4760298729,
-0.1686331779,
0.328641206,
0.3796168864,
0.1851682812,
0.171684891,
0.3757581115,
1.1298291683,
-0.1863612235,
0.2080537379,
0.6013124585,
-0.2224195898,
-0.1971279234,
1.1364071369,
0.4709084928,
0.294437319,
0.4796907604,
0.2517935038,
0.1958161891,
-0.9264367223,
-0.1466216892,
0.3688231409,
-0.5406009555,
-0.1769493818,
-0.4360579848,
-0.3826660216,
-0.0867326558,
-0.2665557265,
-0.4680698812,
-0.6509872675,
-0.0889522135,
0.0267633051,
0.3299387991,
0.3293717504,
-0.2836634219,
0.5851212144,
-0.1691706032,
0.1510010809,
0.7514708638,
0.9582752585,
-0.1615941375,
-0.533536315,
-0.3494023085,
-0.0311309528,
-0.0711114705,
-0.3380606174,
0.0128755374,
0.4487782419,
0.5070735812,
0.4628752172,
0.1803217381,
0.784340024,
-0.6575055122,
0.4554323256,
0.0577472411,
-0.6542455554,
0.3721985817,
-0.5152113438,
0.2063426375,
0.8052088022,
-0.0705915838,
-0.0874898881,
-0.6281893849,
-0.5931562781,
-0.8438002467,
0.7261306047,
0.0622871332,
0.3060351908,
0.1822285056,
0.5871016979,
0.2318924218,
0.058107201,
-0.8409497738,
-0.2246465236,
0.2626850605,
0.0788120031,
-0.2466588765,
-0.3002307713,
-0.3339284658,
-0.3042310178,
0.5408221483,
0.0435300916,
0.2544139326,
-0.0899697617,
-0.0007113777,
-0.5343001485,
0.0761654973,
1.0209825039,
0.4747330546,
-0.3857470751,
0.3636740744,
0.2112970948,
-0.222584784,
0.0186012872,
0.2293805629,
-0.054549437,
-0.169413954,
-0.0221264418,
0.7919385433,
0.1963302344,
-0.7098183632,
0.188458249,
0.0273755621,
-0.3403953016,
0.0541162081,
0.4924786389,
-0.0178051218,
0.236169681,
0.5398761034,
0.3069552481,
0.0804537162,
-0.1427443326,
0.3256235123,
0.6610204577,
-0.1095486879,
-0.030642312,
0.8201050758,
-0.1217995062,
-0.6281234026,
0.2453446388,
-0.0905940831,
-0.2660211623,
0.687188983,
0.5595555902,
0.7680183649,
-0.1189199686,
0.0060357684,
0.0543469153,
0.6360077262,
-0.2493451685,
-0.1235340685,
-0.1411328018,
-0.3879604638,
-0.5991779566,
-0.9629124999,
-0.3495985866,
0.5162194967,
-0.3367269039,
0.337477386,
-0.5572274327,
0.2281513065,
0.0499194786,
-0.0582587644,
-0.8550136685,
0.2894455492,
0.1997862756,
0.9696359038,
-0.875968039,
0.8294506669,
0.5091884732,
-0.0455531627,
-1.1617828608,
-0.1707206517,
-0.3669595122,
-1.1526433229,
0.6174747348,
0.0443386547,
0.0095480066,
0.3061937094,
-0.741084218,
-0.8529046178,
0.6048500538,
0.7130404115,
-0.8638048172,
-0.1212036684,
0.448022455,
0.4607924223,
-0.3231094182,
-0.3238243759,
0.5571233034,
0.3618325591,
-0.1685349792,
-0.9321364164,
0.0474647023,
-0.0819501206,
0.0266103819,
0.4379532337,
-0.5882002711,
0.7608604431,
0.0785481706,
-0.08101134,
-0.0409617163,
0.185692504,
0.1563833654,
0.3385553658,
0.6844257116,
0.7344329953,
0.7502580881,
-0.1121777967,
0.9535583854,
-0.1551461667,
0.3869389296,
0.9607867002,
0.0714166313,
0.6326622963,
0.6896813512,
-0.1763326377,
0.0371491425,
0.7132102251,
0.0474857949,
0.7798598409,
0.5725928545,
-0.1892020851,
-0.7143787742,
0.1276597381,
-0.3040803075,
0.3056197464,
0.0053339493,
-0.3416070342,
-0.3966665864,
0.4136369228,
-0.1370730698,
-0.0552938618,
-0.2917068899,
0.62816751,
0.3149222434,
-0.5315417647,
0.7260404825,
-0.0382652208,
0.609546721,
-0.635222435,
0.1227682531,
-0.2569540143,
0.1674337387,
-0.0602840669,
-0.3580934703,
0.3114452958,
-0.3696550727,
-0.362185359,
-0.3306367993,
0.7487183809,
-0.5091192722,
-0.2547188699,
-0.0944377705,
0.311093837,
0.1300303489,
-0.3117709458,
-0.4287791252,
0.0050005945,
0.0093686366,
-0.5274071693,
0.8877199888,
0.581461072,
-0.0192551911,
0.6340743303,
0.7603812218,
0.1920703351,
0.0624051504,
-0.0921610594,
0.824886024,
-0.3855910003,
-0.5845236778,
-0.8719226122,
0.3483167291,
0.0375151411,
-0.1995390058,
0.539465189,
0.5040864944,
1.0330953598,
-0.2807609141,
0.3544879854,
0.3489549756,
0.3832138479,
-0.5245633721,
0.8184992075,
-0.6059941053,
0.5426940918,
-0.2023378462,
-0.9598332644,
-0.7064194083,
0.7281490564,
-0.3296773434,
-0.0213843454,
0.3917935193,
0.8921852112,
-0.3612854779,
-0.2436744571,
0.7329676747,
-0.0774753988,
0.1812980324,
0.6801576614,
0.5932485461,
-0.3148285449,
0.6548200846,
-0.6843786836,
-0.3512432575,
-0.2044015825,
-0.9607007504,
-1.0162448883,
-0.5740820169,
-0.4888400733,
-0.1542046517,
0.1704047322,
0.6136389971,
1.0749201775,
-0.8747216463,
0.0914762765,
-0.2961320579,
0.1769390404,
-0.3972361088,
-0.2405625433,
0.2786829472,
-0.5410311818,
-0.7018280029,
0.1140066311,
0.2001730353,
-0.0039835381,
-0.0232084785,
0.1183843389,
0.0822618678,
0.3631181121,
0.4346192479,
0.5246307254,
-0.6459201574,
-0.5238005519,
0.0062549501,
-0.0401582941,
-0.2035739124,
0.693351388,
-0.7490640283,
0.386674881,
0.228036195,
0.8363977075,
0.6137923598,
-0.3291007578,
0.6469011307,
-0.7438342571,
0.0438586883,
0.0897650942,
0.1041168272,
-0.1208446771,
-0.338370502,
0.5519197583,
0.180975005,
-0.6125311852,
-1.401142478,
0.2080224603,
-1.034111619,
-0.342995733,
0.8808985353,
0.1523267031,
-0.1011826545,
-0.0648424923,
-0.3115064204,
-0.0506051295,
-0.1452939808,
1.0667645931,
0.7589720488,
-0.1526863724,
-0.27031371,
-0.3889958858,
0.8279162645,
0.6633213758,
-0.5073255897,
-0.1058650017,
-0.0119570615,
0.5963881612,
0.0563233942,
0.6706032753,
0.3243475556,
0.3854835629,
-0.2194566578,
-0.445006758,
-0.2690925896,
-0.3527539074,
-0.5096423626,
0.4691300392,
0.343973577,
-0.0712495819
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02578v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02578v1
|
Mixat: A Data Set of Bilingual Emirati-English Speech
| 2024-05-04T06:06:34 | 2024-05-04T06:06:34 |
Maryam Al Ali, Hanan Aldarmaki
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces Mixat: a dataset of Emirati speech code-mixed with
English. Mixat was developed to address the shortcomings of current speech
recognition resources when applied to Emirati speech, and in particular, to
bilignual Emirati speakers who often mix and switch between their local dialect
and English. The data set consists of 15 hours of speech derived from two
public podcasts featuring native Emirati speakers, one of which is in the form
of conversations between the host and a guest. Therefore, the collection
contains examples of Emirati-English code-switching in both formal and natural
conversational contexts. In this paper, we describe the process of data
collection and annotation, and describe some of the features and statistics of
the resulting data set. In addition, we evaluate the performance of pre-trained
Arabic and multi-lingual ASR systems on our dataset, demonstrating the
shortcomings of existing models on this low-resource dialectal Arabic, and the
additional challenge of recognizing code-switching in ASR. The dataset will be
made publicly available for research use.
|
[
-0.6305216551,
-0.4271583259,
-0.184694767,
0.458070457,
-0.1298985481,
0.5044265985,
-0.3969974816,
-0.7571866512,
0.5986216068,
0.5166825652,
-0.2464279383,
-0.236572057,
-0.5550482869,
0.1870803535,
-0.6072090864,
1.0218151808,
-0.1853642315,
0.364723593,
0.261626184,
-0.5254969001,
-0.7848812342,
-0.4996548593,
-0.4798614681,
-0.2969967127,
0.2129079401,
0.9716098309,
0.9897223711,
0.3772634268,
0.0566778593,
0.1575461179,
0.0098263128,
0.1540798843,
-0.2648795247,
-0.0900854245,
-0.0541189499,
-0.402264148,
-0.1776736975,
-0.3614121675,
0.3659588099,
0.5829182863,
-0.339373976,
0.1025603637,
-0.2363660038,
0.4493556917,
-0.4034530222,
0.151704967,
-0.4804421067,
-0.0844632015,
-0.6731764674,
-0.0496127792,
0.0732588023,
-0.1698370278,
-0.1033255532,
-0.0071874298,
0.0101198126,
-0.040788956,
0.6626600027,
0.1332698315,
-0.6808015704,
-0.570170939,
-0.9393696785,
0.6880972981,
-0.512211442,
0.6857936978,
0.6531042457,
0.5032404065,
0.1553530991,
-0.3990145624,
-0.7128165364,
-0.0247509368,
0.0019718958,
0.0162417348,
-0.1176244617,
-0.4642189741,
-0.0681944638,
0.3880290091,
-0.4690334499,
-0.0223849192,
-0.5894523859,
-0.1714268476,
0.8349446058,
-0.0842144638,
0.7089668512,
-0.0059022168,
0.1503803283,
-0.1664944142,
-0.7588607669,
0.0741557255,
0.5078344345,
0.4627790153,
-0.490277499,
0.7300406694,
-0.1098625883,
0.4428614676,
-0.0375128761,
-0.0117374798,
0.6179948449,
-0.5088380575,
0.1137891188,
0.5580574274,
0.6293691397,
0.0915609673,
0.3267811835,
-0.0644047707,
-0.3696066737,
0.3061372042,
-0.2087027133,
-0.7256354094,
-0.3932920396,
0.3547216654,
-0.069767952,
0.2731708884,
-0.0181740932,
-0.7975425124,
0.0454641394,
-0.3819029927,
0.146933198,
-0.4284566939,
-0.428142637,
0.375369966,
0.0773386657,
0.2062011212,
0.0010027235,
-0.7661777735,
0.5090463758,
0.2791722417,
0.6752108932,
-0.0859422684,
-0.3424030542,
-0.3980548084,
0.2499439716,
-0.1352742761,
0.5493325591,
-0.6412308216,
-0.6980261207,
0.1254323721,
-0.2201651633,
0.0146630332,
-0.8023276329,
0.6338549852,
-0.4954206944,
0.2861106396,
-0.0625827238,
-0.1804590374,
-0.2182196677,
-0.2491392195,
-0.9570376873,
1.0665528774,
-0.2400778085,
-0.9631586671,
0.5532575846,
-0.7498464584,
-0.9104430676,
0.1535352618,
-0.4771510065,
-0.4175720811,
-0.2157012522,
0.6963605881,
0.1120987087,
-0.1662402153,
0.218406707,
0.3643736541,
-0.317497164,
0.4485260248,
-0.0867256671,
0.803855598,
0.4307615459,
-0.5499363542,
-0.1535771936,
-0.8300186396,
-0.0228520613,
-0.0371265821,
-0.143230617,
-0.2005004883,
0.4029663503,
0.7551341057,
0.2835911214,
0.3898405433,
-0.500105083,
-0.0031240867,
-0.1645000726,
0.176996991,
0.1651766151,
-0.0577400662,
-0.0402147435,
-0.6403241754,
0.6844915748,
0.4562589526,
-0.3913945556,
0.1898323447,
-0.5344510674,
-0.8502851129,
-0.6017574072,
0.3957199156,
0.8575307131,
-0.9011228085,
0.4839258194,
-0.2757959068,
-0.4355380535,
-0.6954903603,
0.2271589041,
0.2596771121,
-0.173502028,
0.4394678771,
-0.2442028075,
-0.9210635424,
-1.0985625982,
-0.1772248596,
0.0020426305,
0.0048996033,
0.3190090358,
0.605868876,
-0.5252658129,
1.112754941,
0.1021427959,
-0.0311240666,
-0.6090081334,
0.2997742891,
0.2307113856,
0.4921108782,
0.4638884366,
-0.9438678026,
-0.5152927637,
0.2627972066,
-0.3699045181,
-0.366997093,
-0.0788841173,
0.012048468,
-0.1073195338,
0.2731359005,
-0.0680818632,
0.2902285159,
0.8286088109,
-0.4675708711,
0.3174732029,
0.1532379389,
0.5786240101,
-1.2342911959,
-0.2490333766,
-0.2427943647,
-0.3853064477,
-0.6020637751,
-0.1479624063,
-0.0599892586,
-0.147619158,
-0.5624777079,
0.4285831153,
-0.5209727883,
0.0068126987,
-0.0847350657,
-0.3774247169,
-0.445098877,
0.2508791387,
0.1419851184,
1.5169868469,
0.6420654655,
-0.3501050174,
0.1752336323,
0.5813638568,
-0.4170345068,
0.5101745725,
-0.5497463942,
0.4254333079,
-0.082539618,
-0.10910438,
-0.8854545951,
-0.2762528062,
0.0607135221,
-0.2178865224,
0.2033467293,
-0.1543199718,
-0.6676568985,
0.1330218464,
-0.0710561574,
0.7845778465,
0.5326307416,
-0.6301699281,
0.5328335762,
0.9146258831,
-0.5659289956,
-0.1472412199,
-0.7134267688,
0.3344947696,
-0.321156472,
-0.6470738053,
0.1274933964,
0.0321756564,
-0.3365463912,
-0.187747702,
0.0290094111,
-0.4988783896,
-0.2526464164,
0.4865921736,
-0.106804572,
-0.25118047,
-0.38700068,
0.1675952375,
0.2060640156,
-0.0050377725,
0.0500620417,
0.7082136869,
-0.156062752,
-0.4230210781,
-0.4038853943,
0.6634571552,
0.2913550735,
-0.3535307944,
0.5286302567,
0.233259812,
-0.3186078668,
-0.272277534,
-0.4073286057,
0.1518272012,
-0.418380022,
0.3353284597,
-0.5524688363,
-0.7584667802,
0.8179057837,
0.3297453821,
0.0023454358,
0.1799338162,
0.77390486,
-0.0107953567,
0.7860109806,
0.2971417606,
-0.5216028094,
0.601768136,
-0.0349956378,
0.2389480621,
-0.0506361313,
-0.0868656561,
-0.8258328438,
-0.3565067649,
-0.67597574,
-0.5108697414,
0.3463895023,
-0.0622805916,
-0.0590371378,
0.2779952288,
-0.0306769572,
0.7591485977,
0.5175452828,
0.0354819894,
0.3762629032,
0.0930978805,
0.1230458915,
-0.293882072,
-0.7262329459,
-0.3785383701,
1.1082259417,
0.0790022835,
0.7882091403,
0.4426338673,
0.8050341606,
0.6367055178,
0.0079610609,
-0.420374006,
0.3751391768,
0.1103779823,
-0.4251462221,
0.0360897034,
-0.5330453515,
-1.0067522526,
-0.0754153952,
0.065456219,
-0.4054889083,
0.1179051772,
-0.0522614978,
0.1415199786,
0.0976642147,
-0.735065341,
0.5083560348,
-0.3624486327,
-0.0799635053,
-0.1693625599,
-0.4942927659,
0.1704817414,
-0.2603695989,
0.5436815023,
-0.0161600802,
0.285538733,
1.1886162758,
-0.3707526922,
0.660315752,
0.0823580846,
0.1369232088,
0.2853518426,
0.1032163799,
0.051439926,
-0.0436092988,
0.2932020426,
0.6426066756,
0.2977302372,
-0.6413245797,
-0.1171520278,
0.3609927595,
-1.0919514894,
0.040547885,
-0.5783742666,
-0.4936422706,
-0.5131115317,
-0.0673034862,
0.1056280881,
0.4649721086,
-0.2078311443,
-0.034028694,
0.2446015328,
-0.1288751364,
0.283223778,
0.4171265662,
-0.5630049706,
-0.5533464551,
0.8868851662,
0.2058351487,
-0.0595201291,
0.0723916218,
-0.0425191633,
-0.3619458079,
-0.5231317282,
-0.5599603653,
0.3066720366,
-0.6187159419,
-0.0076755988,
-0.2562739551,
-0.1748739928,
-0.15200001,
-0.2374424338,
-0.3498020768,
-0.4732553065,
0.1124879047,
-0.0778658837,
0.465621084,
0.8746040463,
0.0718153492,
0.3064348996,
-0.7017705441,
0.4581812322,
0.2149378806,
0.2483878881,
-0.617851615,
-0.4982026815,
-0.490891397,
0.2829347253,
0.1578644514,
-1.2288007736,
0.4724829197,
0.2838564813,
0.4423099756,
0.1130092517,
-0.2424828559,
0.6635197401,
-0.4953666627,
0.7007222176,
-0.1098255515,
-1.142244339,
0.5179480314,
-0.4617328048,
0.2190923542,
0.8496726751,
0.3075678647,
-0.7442082167,
-0.557125628,
-0.4756078124,
-0.8498494029,
0.5650215745,
0.3838821948,
-0.0575697124,
0.0248544011,
-0.2871930599,
0.2954179049,
0.4031565189,
-0.5782709122,
-0.390614599,
-0.2131134272,
-0.463211894,
-0.2138349712,
-0.2800813317,
-0.3667681217,
-0.484506309,
0.6378988028,
0.0799162984,
0.0772926211,
-0.2841317952,
-0.4888412654,
0.0312537998,
0.568644166,
0.3918794394,
0.7982748747,
-0.2917295396,
0.0750733465,
-0.0671434402,
-0.5989899039,
0.178379938,
0.314152807,
-0.2931027412,
0.2356518209,
0.260769248,
0.6893283725,
0.3666040003,
-1.209664464,
0.4572754502,
0.0094057312,
-0.0761023015,
-0.4712287188,
-0.1586902142,
0.0442247055,
0.0400216915,
0.2450686395,
0.0486950912,
0.2462346405,
-0.5576920509,
0.4566279948,
0.030139029,
0.0269562043,
-0.3183694482,
0.7100660801,
0.4411505759,
-0.5276585817,
0.3613663316,
-0.1956511736,
-0.5284760594,
0.434512049,
0.4018407166,
0.8055070043,
-0.1199670807,
0.1516636461,
-0.1006536409,
0.1225922629,
0.0782059208,
0.9010314941,
-0.1549990773,
-0.9755824208,
-0.2447960526,
-0.4573526978,
-0.6784552336,
-0.1934144646,
-0.8043991327,
0.2809721231,
-0.2171020359,
0.2022343129,
-0.1250554472,
-0.0593362302,
-0.8822593093,
-0.0471330136,
0.2610088885,
0.7209174633,
-1.2546702623,
0.9056980014,
0.9194757938,
-0.4530253112,
-0.8426188231,
-0.1712983549,
-0.0516849607,
-0.8701512218,
0.7024946213,
0.0029652519,
-0.4117114544,
-0.1911486685,
-0.3439751267,
-0.4927805364,
0.5177955031,
0.1191854849,
-0.4148816764,
0.4809744954,
0.6259689927,
0.3642025888,
-0.2887852788,
0.2085895091,
0.9308543205,
0.2356732935,
0.1009695679,
-1.3287963867,
-0.4870202243,
-0.4402420223,
-0.4055816531,
0.3024460375,
-0.4008670747,
0.8820664883,
0.3488623798,
-0.2169086933,
-0.3440589905,
0.597904861,
0.1618696898,
0.3229393959,
0.4549418092,
0.5326117873,
0.390501827,
-0.0954171047,
0.6743034124,
-0.4591825008,
0.0575235672,
1.1438910961,
-0.6253141165,
1.0959812403,
0.6113752723,
-0.3565681577,
0.3493043184,
0.2964995205,
0.3706192672,
0.4987479448,
-0.1259017885,
-0.3523523808,
0.1264546961,
-0.1197698191,
-0.4864133894,
0.777638793,
0.291480422,
0.2288982272,
-0.2279712409,
0.0884764567,
0.2349876314,
0.0219887942,
-0.196695894,
0.8396829367,
-0.4528138638,
-0.2583845854,
0.5073683262,
0.0651827231,
0.8853389025,
-0.522166729,
-0.0703599006,
-0.3193538189,
-0.1709709764,
-0.2704449296,
-0.6152945161,
0.3586713374,
0.1552421153,
0.1021079868,
-0.3212304711,
0.1529026926,
-0.9288740158,
-0.8328226209,
0.1830494404,
0.8483581543,
0.2887215614,
0.3206247687,
-0.4712897837,
0.2544795573,
0.2508632243,
0.1925345659,
0.0703741461,
0.4107888341,
-0.127460137,
0.3690767884,
0.5485962033,
0.6299051642,
0.5319822431,
0.2060732841,
0.6551667452,
-0.7399383187,
-0.915433228,
-0.477378726,
0.453486979,
0.0907758027,
-0.3556792438,
0.7094267011,
0.9794889092,
1.1160911322,
0.0015744212,
0.9659221768,
-0.0445892513,
0.8592002988,
-0.6813359857,
0.5780953765,
-0.3163248897,
0.2223129869,
0.0945415422,
-0.6557776332,
-0.0523245893,
0.636913538,
-0.2655748725,
0.0902180523,
0.3940112293,
0.8670537472,
-0.4218399227,
0.2432220131,
0.2399579585,
0.0943490565,
0.3690712452,
0.4409209788,
0.8460955024,
-0.3439918756,
0.0837503597,
-0.1604906321,
0.0226604957,
-0.2605022192,
-0.440874815,
-0.7492533922,
-0.5056906939,
-0.3493549824,
-0.295756489,
0.119022131,
1.1368455887,
0.6712991595,
-1.2162652016,
-1.0203454494,
0.2354952544,
-0.2657200098,
-0.1962163001,
-0.1810078919,
0.0051228418,
0.2018076628,
-0.6750418544,
0.5634258986,
0.0690082908,
0.1625879705,
0.086748518,
-0.1063823625,
-0.3422400355,
0.1440607309,
0.0548710115,
0.6488636136,
-0.3158656657,
-0.2375082672,
-0.5481568575,
-0.0412896276,
0.3904395998,
0.9743308425,
-0.5986660123,
0.4245570004,
0.087086685,
0.9311978817,
0.7192832828,
-0.1269941032,
0.4862481654,
-0.9708896875,
0.7449120879,
0.4955943823,
0.5885173678,
0.5109940171,
0.0928523466,
0.2493922561,
0.024831539,
-0.4427436888,
-0.6107526422,
0.1954696923,
-1.1246542931,
0.195525974,
1.0845708847,
0.3455639184,
0.0994694307,
-0.4598692954,
-0.5403231382,
-0.0700914487,
-0.5842288733,
0.598418951,
0.8707099557,
-0.2218326181,
-0.2635326684,
-0.6966647506,
0.4253543317,
0.6794341207,
-1.0418089628,
-0.2709876299,
0.7183884978,
0.350861311,
-0.1305753142,
0.8002656698,
0.2295119464,
0.2966240346,
0.0997308195,
0.1890119314,
0.0962976217,
-0.3839027584,
-0.5439915657,
0.081310302,
0.2196221501,
-0.4831621945
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02573v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02573v1
|
A Combination of BERT and Transformer for Vietnamese Spelling Correction
| 2024-05-04T05:24:19 | 2024-05-04T05:24:19 |
Hieu Ngo Trung, Duong Tran Ham, Tin Huynh, Kiem Hoang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Recently, many studies have shown the efficiency of using Bidirectional
Encoder Representations from Transformers (BERT) in various Natural Language
Processing (NLP) tasks. Specifically, English spelling correction task that
uses Encoder-Decoder architecture and takes advantage of BERT has achieved
state-of-the-art result. However, to our knowledge, there is no implementation
in Vietnamese yet. Therefore, in this study, a combination of Transformer
architecture (state-of-the-art for Encoder-Decoder model) and BERT was proposed
to deal with Vietnamese spelling correction. The experiment results have shown
that our model outperforms other approaches as well as the Google Docs Spell
Checking tool, achieves an 86.24 BLEU score on this task.
|
[
0.0322737098,
-0.6407722235,
0.306237936,
0.2200174183,
-0.2224948108,
0.0942560732,
-0.2346611917,
-0.3661254644,
0.3637363911,
0.50841856,
-0.2691686749,
-0.4427157342,
-0.8334555626,
0.4524151683,
-0.2193120718,
0.5772957802,
-0.1591974646,
0.0790514871,
0.1053266004,
-0.0618931055,
-0.6962723732,
-0.5550755262,
-0.5703082085,
-0.3395664096,
0.4976367056,
0.4313626587,
0.7388097644,
0.2319609374,
0.6995139122,
0.3441157341,
-0.2240767479,
0.4458783269,
-0.447258532,
0.036338646,
-0.0267492589,
-0.6050351858,
-0.566870153,
-0.128925845,
0.6452714205,
0.2595416605,
-0.0668878108,
-0.1149473116,
-0.0882904306,
0.7383936644,
-0.5969271064,
-0.0463357121,
-0.7027230859,
-0.1618254781,
0.0561231524,
-0.055283051,
-0.5388452411,
-0.3845102489,
0.3960565031,
-0.2246839106,
0.3772014976,
-0.3203261197,
1.0311391354,
0.4335238039,
-0.5528975129,
-0.3050906062,
-0.9486258626,
0.5916491747,
-0.5599600077,
0.4890187681,
0.0872947648,
0.3615109622,
-0.0295458008,
-0.5502777696,
-0.8539003134,
0.0985634029,
-0.3754696846,
0.5297270417,
-0.3191081583,
0.489869535,
0.0698266104,
0.322136879,
-0.6831790805,
0.1477150768,
-0.520812273,
-0.2246184349,
0.5042796135,
-0.4468891621,
0.1713269055,
-0.5955017209,
-0.2585803568,
-0.2168298066,
-0.4014854729,
-0.1984732151,
0.2481054962,
0.2054169029,
0.1772528589,
0.7812022567,
0.0437933058,
0.6042946577,
0.0802692324,
-0.0100674862,
0.1864442378,
0.072078526,
-0.4813400507,
0.3286777139,
0.416323483,
0.5005087852,
0.2021456212,
-0.1964396685,
-0.5567167401,
0.158191368,
0.5106354356,
-0.3463151157,
-0.1602456421,
0.4165977836,
-0.5329346657,
0.0987779722,
0.4629080594,
-0.5283079743,
0.139546603,
-0.3184299171,
1.1049525738,
-0.6715996861,
-0.0610332526,
0.3089240193,
-0.5092965364,
0.3736515939,
0.3075862229,
-0.5903551579,
-0.1336476058,
0.7559730411,
0.8988702893,
-0.0848474652,
-0.3720999062,
-0.361992538,
0.2331438959,
-0.101735346,
0.8719069958,
-0.3398363888,
-0.5655401349,
0.6253204942,
0.1578007787,
-0.4163569808,
-0.7008802891,
0.8230614066,
-0.5850325823,
0.276238054,
-0.0004759365,
-0.7750988603,
-0.4721332192,
0.1051538587,
-0.9791420102,
1.1779437065,
0.1145239472,
-0.5269623399,
0.2648517489,
-0.5851168633,
-0.6121788621,
0.324154526,
0.6107584834,
-0.4268434346,
0.2382431179,
0.394182086,
0.2623884976,
0.198138237,
0.0124969427,
0.5031614304,
-0.6507501006,
0.0066256612,
-0.5149696469,
0.9260870218,
-0.1666396558,
-0.3918887973,
0.201757282,
-0.7876477838,
-0.1502621025,
-0.136295706,
-0.5976702571,
-0.4913932383,
-0.3400200307,
0.3148878813,
0.2149368227,
0.5303291082,
-0.6970380545,
0.230586946,
-0.4143898189,
0.3695192337,
0.5357115269,
-0.2873834074,
0.5160119534,
-0.4175011814,
0.2425278127,
-0.0460579246,
0.2141041458,
-0.1571937352,
-0.6843822002,
-1.1228561401,
-0.4885731339,
0.4978467226,
0.8858902454,
-1.0947030783,
0.8154402971,
-0.3295303583,
-0.710291028,
-1.3460470438,
-0.1062252745,
0.321066469,
0.4399715662,
0.5807359219,
-0.0182868689,
-0.8205507398,
-0.8230412602,
-0.1805513799,
-0.2355083376,
-0.5012985468,
-0.1450358927,
0.5058938861,
-0.7201948762,
0.9080572128,
-0.5134724379,
-0.578355968,
-0.1750090718,
0.3148789704,
0.3714921772,
0.2431225628,
0.337485373,
-0.9619221687,
-0.3634919226,
-0.1382340938,
-0.3786067963,
-0.1501969546,
0.1159086153,
-0.1325419545,
0.8317096829,
0.1234149635,
-0.722728014,
0.5036976337,
0.6409628391,
-0.0806429312,
0.7524679899,
-0.8984495401,
0.1990396082,
-0.847933054,
-0.1554452777,
-0.1419156492,
-0.1945579052,
-0.7633311749,
0.1303690374,
0.4185635448,
0.1776659787,
-0.4135247767,
0.2952209413,
-0.0892693326,
0.4124343097,
-0.3401751518,
-0.1329195946,
-0.1118427515,
0.2571561635,
0.1911816895,
0.6248120666,
0.2272974402,
-0.459823519,
0.4537062049,
0.1904166788,
0.1368688196,
0.742210567,
-0.7741187215,
0.1962399781,
-0.2350627333,
0.3219074309,
-1.0430675745,
0.1089339703,
-0.0730646625,
-0.3272265196,
0.2973400056,
0.0614767857,
-0.7409092784,
-0.9061498642,
-0.3542633355,
-0.067962788,
0.7177738547,
-0.9583280683,
0.693031013,
0.0732673928,
0.209686771,
-0.3670195937,
-0.4390561283,
0.13249892,
-0.062179476,
-0.6293177605,
0.7054046392,
0.0464749634,
0.0994161069,
-0.0390508845,
0.1618632674,
-0.2442355901,
-0.5317443609,
0.1449273378,
0.6320434809,
-0.2224517316,
0.2846315503,
-0.0640886873,
-0.294860661,
-0.1345669776,
-0.4551470876,
0.2622922063,
-0.0334153362,
-0.0680318475,
-0.4227389395,
0.3279854655,
0.783423245,
-0.3120010197,
0.906703949,
0.7390785813,
-0.5809258819,
0.0809691697,
-1.1229281425,
-0.1524356455,
-0.4887236655,
0.1958919615,
-0.1997856945,
-0.8714337945,
0.2409581393,
-0.0322939903,
-0.0947547704,
0.4978241026,
0.6041153669,
-0.3028746843,
0.8160867095,
0.6911321878,
-0.1496305168,
0.2887206972,
-0.2524531484,
0.5560781956,
-0.5792255998,
-0.0663067251,
-0.3784227371,
-0.5593728423,
-1.0232429504,
-0.6615732908,
0.4248934388,
-0.2552927136,
0.0292275026,
0.6141115427,
-0.7326112986,
0.1085269302,
1.3591815233,
0.2931610048,
0.4419955909,
-0.062466789,
-0.123131983,
-0.231052205,
-0.5915692449,
-0.6481269598,
1.0382018089,
-0.0391622745,
0.4128040373,
-0.1743804961,
0.868722558,
0.1568370908,
-0.1355353445,
-0.8320627213,
0.4011535943,
-0.6290392876,
-0.395057559,
-0.4220671058,
0.0166365299,
-0.8806326985,
0.0861732438,
-0.2312539369,
-0.348105818,
0.0926481336,
-0.0411098897,
-0.0143643124,
0.4091350138,
-0.9604421854,
0.7114182115,
-0.1482449621,
0.135363251,
-0.3782243431,
-0.7220417261,
0.1111429036,
-0.0818053558,
-0.1273776442,
0.3391145468,
0.3080968559,
0.557107687,
-0.5802639723,
0.4894700944,
-0.1422691196,
-0.3061177731,
0.307064712,
-0.3805227876,
0.2818231881,
-0.0673937798,
-0.2311078757,
0.4888735712,
-0.1732833534,
-0.2603777647,
-0.5501779914,
0.4203532636,
-0.8097769618,
-0.456283927,
-0.3066298664,
-0.5612697601,
0.3276939094,
0.1798403263,
0.4866683781,
0.012287491,
-0.208442837,
-0.1486926377,
0.5454442501,
-0.1123697162,
0.4682515562,
0.5408884883,
0.1433303505,
-0.5185135603,
0.8409859538,
0.3319550455,
-0.0422876813,
0.9598733187,
0.0152993146,
-0.2507787049,
0.0306132045,
-0.2353653461,
0.6270717978,
-0.4760867953,
-0.0968651474,
-0.4624099731,
-0.7604336143,
-0.4394737482,
-0.5642871261,
-0.3340633214,
-0.3349457681,
-0.0697751269,
0.0538515113,
0.3181119859,
0.9198281169,
-0.1774608791,
0.5732952952,
-0.8676914573,
0.5777819157,
0.7975185513,
0.1911225319,
-0.2346274555,
-0.3325399756,
-0.2216366529,
0.2407124341,
-0.3750527501,
-0.813834846,
0.5181857347,
0.1399948448,
0.2821722329,
0.3037507534,
-0.054428,
0.780421555,
-0.8259117007,
0.6048340201,
-0.2369899601,
-1.0233668089,
0.8861785531,
0.083768934,
0.4855636656,
0.0682324842,
0.1699715257,
-0.8498833179,
-0.5173728466,
-0.5674616694,
-0.6424127817,
0.50110811,
0.3553079665,
-0.0903039873,
0.0762006491,
0.3196907043,
0.1531791091,
0.1291584373,
-0.1714970171,
-0.2890259624,
-0.1348907351,
-0.161531359,
-0.1990286857,
-0.672247529,
0.2356472313,
-0.5097783804,
0.8379181027,
0.2139471918,
0.4324662983,
0.3067116141,
-0.4450163245,
-0.0543801785,
0.2839789391,
0.5001882911,
0.3879574835,
-0.5403546691,
0.0784169883,
0.1289046258,
-0.7881489396,
0.0382509232,
0.2803747058,
-0.3521587551,
0.7427819967,
0.4404983222,
0.5568054914,
0.4036246538,
-0.4746938646,
0.3760405481,
-0.1036818773,
-0.2754863203,
-0.0289237369,
-0.3233007193,
0.0835303366,
0.1803990602,
0.5939750671,
-0.0199229084,
-0.021009583,
-0.1654192507,
0.0692396984,
0.3174507618,
-0.3837822676,
-0.3336119056,
0.5735633969,
0.2308985442,
-0.7776609063,
0.9310019612,
-0.2835516036,
-1.0449824333,
0.4695471227,
0.7312638164,
1.0609792471,
-0.7584350109,
0.4548678994,
0.395601511,
0.6048372388,
-0.1451252997,
0.5564098954,
0.3427952826,
-0.5777013302,
-0.2737703919,
-0.6385213733,
-0.6524423361,
-0.1505790353,
-0.6098718643,
0.6251481175,
0.4001282752,
0.0713520646,
-0.3778397739,
-0.1459908932,
-0.8613462448,
0.219960615,
0.221854493,
0.7935435176,
-0.7129223943,
0.8777426481,
1.1357562542,
-0.0607047155,
-0.5640522242,
0.0733215809,
-0.1467749327,
-0.832849443,
0.7060648799,
0.44908306,
-0.1123383492,
0.0648399368,
-0.0236548074,
-0.5980417728,
0.8919677138,
0.2491762042,
-0.6230815649,
-0.2432346642,
0.4148898721,
0.7835274935,
0.0955941081,
0.2230864167,
0.9229730964,
0.634457171,
0.2168330401,
-1.3190770149,
-0.4340217113,
-0.0879194438,
0.2631552517,
0.1260686666,
-0.4019143283,
0.6964023113,
-0.072617434,
-0.0836463049,
-0.1592083573,
0.7494203448,
0.0191867482,
0.0918275937,
0.4235936701,
0.7718386054,
0.8527935743,
-0.0939757153,
0.565418601,
-0.3937740624,
0.3984058201,
0.6349280477,
-0.1149638966,
1.1306892633,
0.3983191848,
-0.3699145317,
0.495973289,
0.2167851031,
0.1492126584,
0.4142997265,
-0.1968561113,
-0.1413757652,
0.0981362462,
-0.034048669,
0.0090090893,
0.8397802114,
0.331787914,
-0.1417659074,
-0.1614415199,
0.3450298607,
-0.0296047423,
0.1470129937,
-0.3817249238,
0.6229781508,
-0.2513221204,
-0.6522243619,
0.5256890059,
0.0533607937,
1.2083297968,
-0.3850888312,
-0.2666186392,
-0.036712274,
0.4512678981,
0.0084428359,
-0.7286774516,
0.3358316422,
-0.0509446897,
-0.2846859992,
-0.3609448373,
0.7919803858,
-0.8767182827,
-0.855660677,
0.4919289947,
0.4825583994,
-0.1523277462,
-0.3168621659,
-0.2476245165,
-0.1509189606,
-0.4486005604,
0.4211632311,
-0.3397520781,
0.5114521384,
0.3074694574,
0.2787516713,
0.2437430769,
0.2211325169,
0.3678199053,
0.3093234003,
0.4831145108,
-0.4775197804,
-0.5581230521,
-0.7859590054,
0.334138304,
0.0387616679,
-0.1646144688,
0.8651285172,
0.6715308428,
1.003356576,
-0.4907515645,
0.8185700774,
0.1344297081,
0.5270100236,
-0.3711001873,
0.7717285752,
-0.3564932346,
-0.1767858118,
-0.3468336463,
-1.1018983126,
-0.4479806423,
0.6547139287,
-0.1528520584,
-0.3967467248,
0.9715192318,
0.7261896133,
0.3487239778,
0.0766036138,
0.3723093569,
0.252148509,
0.2613469064,
0.679902792,
0.4489887953,
-0.7822130919,
0.3891515434,
-0.5595549941,
-0.2356464714,
-0.7026309967,
-0.5245289803,
-0.8816791773,
-0.8752145767,
-0.1377708614,
-0.1478471905,
0.4352975488,
0.7976307273,
0.2574323118,
-0.8516536951,
-0.2688048482,
0.3340442777,
0.4507706463,
-0.7246534824,
-0.2303719372,
0.7063953876,
-0.2386987656,
-1.1699557304,
0.097913295,
0.6177583933,
-0.0893954486,
-0.1566840112,
0.0360304154,
-0.4927322567,
-0.0301692579,
0.9895435572,
-0.2184449136,
-0.9054841995,
-0.5022335649,
0.2739729881,
-0.3279833794,
0.3252146244,
0.6510013342,
-1.0540031195,
0.9198933244,
0.6223083735,
0.4648551643,
0.0590814948,
-0.0941321403,
0.6464371085,
-0.6865231991,
-0.0071965698,
0.1348900199,
0.5014292002,
0.4594511986,
-0.4719820917,
0.3960365057,
0.1145623177,
-0.8100530505,
-0.3039408326,
-0.2535870969,
-0.9350712895,
0.0684602931,
1.0120337009,
0.2065520287,
-0.3659263849,
-0.1475123614,
-0.7694179416,
0.6357761621,
-0.2956120372,
1.2392914295,
0.7733556628,
0.1775327325,
0.1504888982,
-0.3028531373,
0.0605560951,
0.3043099642,
-0.3880630732,
-0.2954301238,
0.2129956484,
-0.1867765933,
0.3380130827,
0.1647034138,
0.3306858838,
0.5382084846,
-0.245089218,
0.3168866634,
0.3261862993,
-0.2326691896,
-0.5196287036,
-0.1099323928,
-0.3111481667,
-0.4190490842
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02559v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02559v1
|
A Literature Review and Framework for Human Evaluation of Generative Large Language Models in Healthcare
| 2024-05-04T04:16:07 | 2024-05-04T04:16:07 |
Thomas Yu Chow Tam, Sonish Sivarajkumar, Sumit Kapoor, Alisa V Stolyar, Katelyn Polanska, Karleigh R McCarthy, Hunter Osterhoudt, Xizhi Wu, Shyam Visweswaran, Sunyang Fu, Piyush Mathur, Giovanni E. Cacciamani, Cong Sun, Yifan Peng, Yanshan Wang
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
As generative artificial intelligence (AI), particularly Large Language
Models (LLMs), continues to permeate healthcare, it remains crucial to
supplement traditional automated evaluations with human expert evaluation.
Understanding and evaluating the generated texts is vital for ensuring safety,
reliability, and effectiveness. However, the cumbersome, time-consuming, and
non-standardized nature of human evaluation presents significant obstacles to
the widespread adoption of LLMs in practice. This study reviews existing
literature on human evaluation methodologies for LLMs within healthcare. We
highlight a notable need for a standardized and consistent human evaluation
approach. Our extensive literature search, adhering to the Preferred Reporting
Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA) guidelines, spans
publications from January 2018 to February 2024. This review provides a
comprehensive overview of the human evaluation approaches used in diverse
healthcare applications.This analysis examines the human evaluation of LLMs
across various medical specialties, addressing factors such as evaluation
dimensions, sample types, and sizes, the selection and recruitment of
evaluators, frameworks and metrics, the evaluation process, and statistical
analysis of the results. Drawing from diverse evaluation strategies highlighted
in these studies, we propose a comprehensive and practical framework for human
evaluation of generative LLMs, named QUEST: Quality of Information,
Understanding and Reasoning, Expression Style and Persona, Safety and Harm, and
Trust and Confidence. This framework aims to improve the reliability,
generalizability, and applicability of human evaluation of generative LLMs in
different healthcare applications by defining clear evaluation dimensions and
offering detailed guidelines.
|
[
-0.0744575858,
-0.4041835964,
0.7272410393,
0.2056832761,
-0.1241897792,
0.1377641857,
-0.218739152,
-0.4606486857,
0.0599041432,
0.4237976074,
-0.5365177989,
-0.5859192014,
-0.3897226155,
0.4554210007,
-0.2821945846,
0.53238976,
-0.0525737517,
0.5720160604,
-0.4680252075,
-0.0759401768,
-0.2961269617,
-0.6364566088,
-0.6106671095,
-0.6227663159,
0.5569028854,
0.0064796894,
0.6890719533,
0.2161452323,
0.6363642812,
0.3682376146,
-0.2607128024,
0.2163679749,
-0.3762910366,
0.0531747639,
-0.1632204652,
-0.2435584962,
-0.5154677629,
-0.0553877056,
0.6982552409,
0.8780656457,
-0.35611251,
0.1536415964,
0.0140899392,
0.8134943247,
-0.5756595731,
0.0683800057,
-0.1051897034,
0.3915290236,
-0.1676874757,
-0.2351355106,
-0.2242580056,
-0.4155195355,
0.5070649385,
-0.4981595576,
0.0726484284,
0.0863744318,
0.4777932167,
0.1134846732,
-0.5621352196,
-0.3533411026,
-0.7657266855,
0.7879427075,
-0.7737756968,
0.3265132308,
0.1942970753,
0.4458312094,
-0.2613068223,
-0.6370248199,
-0.4607546628,
-0.4552518427,
-0.1017990783,
0.0450739935,
0.040886987,
0.5029069781,
0.1471675783,
0.687741816,
-0.7299691439,
0.2942891419,
-0.2158420533,
-0.219802931,
0.8394710422,
0.5781002045,
0.7284881473,
-0.4205378294,
-0.1743955016,
0.246871531,
-0.6077709794,
-0.2346245795,
0.0253153164,
-0.0782817006,
0.0279978868,
0.4818655849,
-0.359572798,
0.649327755,
-0.3227348328,
-0.5977161527,
0.4291068316,
-0.3297127485,
-0.4004461467,
-0.3230531812,
1.0283699036,
0.4951858521,
-0.0133252097,
-0.7288194895,
-0.2158153504,
-0.0358290449,
0.5637922883,
-0.7146601677,
0.274856478,
0.1984428912,
-0.8604124188,
-0.2752098739,
-0.11086528,
-0.8287736177,
-0.6907879114,
-0.4222639203,
0.1229906306,
-0.2347063571,
-0.0492007248,
0.2505695224,
0.1063421443,
0.3291147649,
0.3313536942,
-0.7825939059,
0.3223592639,
0.7531285882,
0.563875258,
-0.4731608033,
-0.2834062576,
-0.2527880967,
-0.0674628839,
-0.4479091465,
0.5841389298,
-0.3378244042,
-0.5561948419,
0.3757820427,
-0.0045487261,
-0.1154445857,
-0.7056093812,
0.9774106741,
-0.5470208526,
0.218642503,
-0.2831392288,
-0.4142797589,
-0.1378796697,
0.2994882762,
-0.6695060134,
0.3382568359,
0.3698662817,
-0.5441805124,
0.3921581507,
-0.8151988983,
-0.576317668,
0.4980090857,
-0.2879580855,
-0.4585356116,
0.1218706742,
0.3394827545,
0.3633361459,
-1.0202692747,
0.4584828615,
0.0153770102,
-0.5932817459,
0.3292917311,
-0.4268145263,
0.917663753,
0.1963881105,
-0.3432792425,
0.4763098061,
-0.5658290386,
0.2315533459,
-0.0580367707,
-0.5096713901,
-0.0281328354,
0.1332067251,
0.1671986282,
-0.0964877233,
-0.0530081019,
-0.2739034891,
0.0616198741,
-0.6492267847,
0.5372066498,
0.4351086915,
0.2719325721,
0.4061958492,
-0.4366917312,
0.9427841306,
-0.5137301683,
0.5584998727,
0.0528318696,
-0.3388963938,
-0.4771598577,
-0.32664904,
0.2499537468,
0.4442895949,
-0.7631270885,
0.6333887577,
-0.3722636998,
-0.5901834965,
-0.7741914392,
0.1753228605,
0.6299007535,
0.3885171711,
0.1549375206,
-0.3935694993,
-0.5073004961,
-0.9853758216,
-0.2999197841,
-0.291041702,
-0.3505845666,
0.3681212068,
0.3497241437,
-1.0188038349,
0.8061689734,
-0.0811023861,
-0.1927902251,
-0.3430582583,
0.3097306788,
-0.0116596883,
0.1437698752,
0.4085074663,
-0.6866404414,
-0.0466900319,
-0.0911050141,
-0.890388608,
-0.0663060918,
-0.052667547,
-0.1150117293,
0.0747025833,
0.0494692922,
-0.5621660352,
0.351964891,
0.4241734743,
-0.1819067746,
0.7207455635,
-0.0692576915,
0.5021855235,
-0.8569554687,
0.2348834276,
0.0739714205,
-0.081135489,
-0.5740327239,
0.2832851708,
-0.126825422,
-0.0655159056,
-0.1804864705,
0.7345497012,
-0.4830078781,
-0.1494679451,
-0.0708161294,
-0.0162070189,
0.1271310896,
0.132575646,
-0.24302122,
0.6393658519,
0.257160604,
-0.2800108194,
0.676761508,
0.3124051392,
-0.765802443,
0.699843049,
-0.8913163543,
0.141990304,
-0.0322745107,
0.292004317,
-0.5811174512,
-0.3417032957,
0.3252258599,
-0.203839913,
0.2828036845,
0.1067762524,
-0.770416677,
-0.5353380442,
-0.1952810585,
0.322049886,
0.5859246254,
-0.1737575084,
0.5562573671,
0.5714134574,
-0.1998933107,
-0.396363318,
-0.2527180016,
0.5020592809,
-0.1397124529,
-0.7027053237,
0.2721780539,
-0.1413794905,
-0.553689003,
-0.2101667076,
0.0318393894,
-0.1564156711,
0.2016277015,
0.2042538226,
0.4310336411,
0.0360908434,
0.1783126295,
-0.0472487472,
0.0708794966,
0.2850493789,
0.0144533049,
0.3285811245,
-0.3315923214,
-0.6168172956,
-0.7322894931,
0.4045308232,
0.7570868134,
-0.0643020943,
0.3636951149,
0.6846287847,
-0.3717998266,
0.2134523541,
-0.6589950323,
-0.1759386808,
-0.3455670774,
0.6395314932,
-0.0642824993,
-0.7377774119,
0.3014468849,
-0.0798762441,
0.0345089622,
0.5766811371,
0.9684887528,
-0.1471871436,
1.0387016535,
0.401201725,
-0.1354346722,
-0.0270960853,
-0.0661523193,
0.225015983,
-1.1128606796,
-0.4865206182,
-0.5023001432,
-0.0025256972,
-0.4011385441,
-0.5465244651,
0.7058241367,
-0.0539852493,
-0.0888519883,
-0.3206376731,
-0.4688906372,
0.1036103964,
0.0800934508,
0.1396863014,
0.3909259439,
-0.0476009361,
-0.2348921895,
0.0003551424,
-0.5569035411,
-0.7020418048,
0.9780955315,
0.6353159547,
0.8299418092,
-0.0034378436,
0.5480328202,
0.5129204988,
0.6592245698,
-1.0292950869,
0.4239331782,
-0.0144310445,
-0.6657297611,
-0.604265213,
-0.4978090227,
-1.0557960272,
0.2992628515,
-0.2632316351,
-0.6212041378,
-0.2489957213,
-0.2546369135,
-0.4957238138,
0.050464619,
-0.5634230375,
0.7222799063,
-0.4737273455,
-0.0545361117,
-0.2933321893,
-0.6277172565,
0.380479157,
0.014718785,
0.1230447367,
0.0290694926,
0.019724153,
0.8098627925,
-0.3630984128,
0.8074371219,
0.0277791079,
-0.1430840939,
0.0710562244,
-0.1307113767,
0.0830350071,
0.0647488758,
-0.2159796953,
0.2932382822,
0.157027483,
-0.2544552386,
-0.7396383882,
0.5182632208,
-0.9309383631,
-0.5679358244,
-0.3976648152,
-0.4691435099,
-0.6571807861,
0.1271801442,
0.1519665122,
0.4350920022,
-0.5561775565,
-0.0165410545,
0.5471839309,
-0.5590933561,
-0.1981249005,
0.4797468483,
-0.1174048483,
-0.4648863971,
0.6431788206,
-0.2450086027,
-0.0073756827,
0.3334256709,
0.2603288293,
-0.3150252998,
-0.675295949,
-0.736517787,
0.4222807288,
-0.5802358389,
0.0122209713,
-0.4330177903,
-0.4231263101,
-0.4455142617,
-0.0348497629,
0.045804821,
0.1642306447,
-0.4157362878,
0.1743881106,
-0.1042134389,
0.9624233246,
0.5269734859,
0.1428778023,
-0.8533165455,
0.4368790686,
0.4478161335,
0.5176308751,
0.194588393,
-0.3780355453,
-0.13831608,
-0.0758907124,
-0.1698126048,
-0.7959436774,
0.379235357,
0.0382959284,
0.9900975823,
0.5174751878,
-0.1852425784,
0.5458955169,
-0.6586559415,
0.7690297961,
0.4867341816,
-0.7492467761,
0.1811083555,
-0.2375800312,
0.2576313317,
0.620885253,
0.4492109418,
-0.8272949457,
0.1496905535,
-0.2146339417,
-0.8601504564,
0.4327552617,
-0.0169627815,
0.0884923041,
0.0800735503,
0.4452176988,
-0.0596631393,
0.2526892722,
-0.4174939692,
-0.048703827,
0.3408796787,
-0.1149278879,
-0.0050281482,
-0.6182230711,
-0.5332301259,
-0.0223513618,
0.4169130027,
-0.0741398335,
0.3139082789,
0.2089205831,
-0.1636708975,
-0.2263002098,
0.656755209,
0.3221199811,
1.0932753086,
-0.0458077304,
-0.3332888186,
0.009289871,
-0.2861686051,
0.1123059615,
0.079123348,
-0.1839196533,
-0.0333806276,
0.6035997272,
0.6326796412,
0.2710909843,
-1.0494157076,
0.6121841073,
-0.227798596,
-0.1307949126,
-0.4753338993,
-0.0824310035,
0.0605314374,
0.0761881247,
0.3719544411,
-0.2003980875,
0.5481466055,
-0.6210424304,
-0.0772997513,
0.4730158448,
-0.4632048905,
-0.202720806,
0.2700891495,
0.4633077085,
-0.4060474634,
0.713076055,
-0.2171166688,
-0.4653427303,
0.3368609846,
0.1902465075,
1.138961792,
-0.2294577807,
0.3445905149,
0.1299915314,
0.3064939976,
-0.0980177522,
0.2228821516,
0.1650808901,
-0.383394599,
-0.6539557576,
-0.9636756182,
-0.5055131316,
0.1673255861,
-0.566180706,
0.0367795825,
-0.2746478319,
-0.23785083,
-0.1423943937,
0.105635345,
-0.7793933749,
0.1246572733,
0.2233671099,
0.7606965303,
-0.5079287887,
0.4218104184,
0.7117089629,
-0.2948977053,
-0.6460184455,
0.2204907835,
0.1567585617,
-0.7551968694,
0.52202636,
-0.07097435,
-0.1156390756,
-0.5135325193,
-0.2210900635,
-0.4721196294,
1.1905362606,
0.2062527984,
-0.6606510282,
-0.5221730471,
0.1022158489,
1.0199506283,
-0.38847664,
0.4708518386,
0.7872377038,
0.4722040892,
0.0759013146,
-1.2044727802,
0.0354096442,
-0.2893376648,
0.4261125326,
-0.2617353499,
-0.5172891021,
0.3361725509,
-0.2414515465,
-0.319277972,
0.5701529384,
0.2367723286,
0.2629657984,
0.3302156329,
0.4468841553,
0.4293649197,
0.7958726883,
0.026186645,
1.3853662014,
-0.1022492945,
0.183962822,
0.6507236362,
-0.4967474937,
0.4007875323,
0.1724346876,
-0.6332771778,
0.6201733351,
0.5436906815,
0.0786750317,
0.1130183488,
0.6461055875,
-0.3341618776,
-0.1578613371,
-0.1919891238,
-0.2131153196,
0.4766420126,
0.4063717425,
-0.5571446419,
-0.0643894672,
-0.0004061159,
-0.0852643698,
-0.0132759046,
-0.3541229069,
0.915807724,
0.0732585415,
-0.7645162344,
0.7517418265,
0.2182652801,
0.3891611695,
-0.4523430467,
0.0029476988,
0.0432360657,
-0.2207224071,
-0.3386268914,
-0.349689424,
0.1110015213,
0.0161764473,
-0.2200212628,
-0.1034780294,
0.6141927242,
0.0123561099,
-0.5272058845,
0.1880260408,
0.542960465,
0.1590879709,
0.0722532421,
-0.8154223561,
0.0285216961,
-0.1639278233,
-0.2079369575,
0.4232865274,
0.1747952104,
-0.1066648439,
0.7298530936,
0.5401359797,
0.3086161911,
-0.2952843308,
0.6513821483,
0.7213753462,
-0.5598140955,
-0.1372771412,
-0.7258344889,
0.278907299,
0.0287260097,
-0.122779958,
0.4362979233,
0.3909154832,
0.2479866892,
0.0029486783,
1.0282962322,
0.1346433312,
0.6971389055,
-0.3849293888,
0.8937298656,
-0.4392149448,
0.268193543,
-0.3516995907,
-0.6845260859,
-0.4004950523,
0.5338697433,
-0.4018193483,
0.1694297791,
0.5136607885,
0.445194006,
0.4710302651,
-0.0485705994,
0.5381977558,
0.2077120841,
0.3888968825,
0.369435519,
1.0355499983,
-0.2420475036,
0.285505861,
0.1397633702,
-0.5254998207,
-0.4697083533,
-0.6265344024,
-0.8380474448,
-0.5292596817,
-0.0207337197,
-0.219150126,
0.2387721539,
0.9549967051,
0.8345261812,
-0.5420119762,
-0.2360830009,
0.2817584872,
0.1408200115,
-0.1301411837,
-0.2433068156,
0.3653796613,
-0.3841506839,
-0.7804000974,
0.2846075296,
0.6373724937,
-0.2068313658,
-0.9164834023,
-0.3469820619,
0.2421149015,
-0.0995765254,
0.7548860312,
0.153031975,
-1.0662437677,
0.1555562764,
0.0692386627,
-0.4177832603,
-0.167955026,
1.0063893795,
-0.6826890111,
0.6624529958,
0.4454713464,
0.8270533085,
-0.0750716254,
-0.0608295016,
0.5465362072,
-0.0738849193,
-0.2764389515,
0.7295035124,
0.5006037951,
0.50628829,
-0.3703776896,
0.4725202918,
0.1247965768,
-0.8020328283,
-0.7666704059,
0.1499861926,
-0.8362350464,
-0.1336802095,
1.2796646357,
-0.285163939,
-0.1489548832,
-0.3769347966,
-0.2310838997,
0.0095551489,
-0.0974950343,
1.1210967302,
0.4987852573,
-0.3143493831,
0.167400375,
-0.6014814973,
0.5803588629,
0.2877800167,
-0.9738499522,
-0.1395024061,
0.5755417347,
0.2382292897,
0.0947217122,
0.7873652577,
-0.5053432584,
0.3914726377,
-0.5886590481,
0.1831493378,
0.3624593914,
-0.1006822437,
-0.4215838909,
-0.0421587899,
0.3112268448,
0.3254558146
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06673v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06673v2
|
Overview of the EHRSQL 2024 Shared Task on Reliable Text-to-SQL Modeling on Electronic Health Records
| 2024-05-04T04:12:18 | 2024-05-23T17:25:21 |
Gyubok Lee, Sunjun Kweon, Seongsu Bae, Edward Choi
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Electronic Health Records (EHRs) are relational databases that store the
entire medical histories of patients within hospitals. They record numerous
aspects of patients' medical care, from hospital admission and diagnosis to
treatment and discharge. While EHRs are vital sources of clinical data,
exploring them beyond a predefined set of queries requires skills in query
languages like SQL. To make information retrieval more accessible, one strategy
is to build a question-answering system, possibly leveraging text-to-SQL models
that can automatically translate natural language questions into corresponding
SQL queries and use these queries to retrieve the answers. The EHRSQL 2024
shared task aims to advance and promote research in developing a
question-answering system for EHRs using text-to-SQL modeling, capable of
reliably providing requested answers to various healthcare professionals to
improve their clinical work processes and satisfy their needs. Among more than
100 participants who applied to the shared task, eight teams were formed and
completed the entire shared task requirement and demonstrated a wide range of
methods to effectively solve this task. In this paper, we describe the task of
reliable text-to-SQL modeling, the dataset, and the methods and results of the
participants. We hope this shared task will spur further research and insights
into developing reliable question-answering systems for EHRs.
|
[
-0.0303169545,
-1.0366164446,
1.0127841234,
-0.2660807669,
-0.1772835702,
-0.1754214168,
0.3515821695,
-0.6784640551,
0.0503882095,
0.8980129957,
-0.5399513245,
-0.5657444,
-0.315233171,
0.3335438371,
-0.5416015983,
1.247451663,
-0.1686846614,
0.1212859452,
-0.6456185579,
-0.2506780326,
-0.5264835358,
-0.8633551002,
-0.3401285112,
-0.1370963454,
0.3320799768,
0.2623209059,
0.444553256,
0.6205940247,
0.7120245695,
0.1514101774,
0.0979325771,
0.174722001,
-0.4677250683,
0.3906881511,
-0.0485656932,
-0.5498856902,
-0.7683752775,
-0.7186339498,
0.4246385694,
0.4959513247,
-0.6519145966,
0.2802759707,
-0.0620699525,
0.7338793278,
-0.1175613701,
0.0285472795,
-0.63691324,
0.0264362264,
-0.3013210297,
-0.3621041775,
-0.4563761652,
-0.4044471085,
0.1668135673,
-0.4852738976,
0.1726462245,
0.2693037689,
0.9136970043,
0.2780739665,
-0.6634324193,
-0.1964398623,
-0.7962210774,
0.7848355174,
-0.4761098325,
0.5731665492,
0.4280954897,
0.3569725156,
0.0947813988,
-0.7898523211,
-0.242480725,
0.2313090414,
-0.243383795,
0.0146805169,
0.1580163687,
0.1205579564,
0.0072172019,
0.1338754147,
-0.6888927221,
-0.4581241012,
-0.1858730763,
0.0716048107,
0.6260410547,
0.5428171754,
0.4465819299,
-0.2378763407,
-0.4280596673,
0.4410152435,
-0.5302069187,
-0.2445541322,
-0.4854007065,
0.2675711513,
-0.0224119313,
0.7490239143,
-0.2749908864,
0.6861349344,
0.1522360742,
0.193772465,
0.290876478,
-0.8157373071,
-0.1932346523,
0.0714234486,
0.6285268664,
0.2670896947,
-0.1419236809,
-0.332716316,
-0.4033512473,
-0.2464811653,
0.4714854658,
-0.5389527678,
-0.2881068587,
0.8003948331,
-0.6551653743,
-0.0071824533,
-0.3018539548,
-0.8294502497,
-0.0245964341,
-0.3761219382,
0.6809632778,
-0.3688680828,
-0.1135590523,
0.0531551242,
0.0577464141,
-0.0374721214,
0.3699485064,
-0.6666370034,
0.8306677341,
0.6765403152,
0.5556104779,
-0.3388337493,
0.0205601696,
-0.5600917339,
0.2516134977,
-0.131038323,
0.7511754632,
-0.0976545364,
-0.3971905112,
-0.0088007171,
0.0707160309,
-0.2707196474,
-0.6086761355,
0.6815603375,
-0.7268192768,
0.2615584731,
-0.5120298266,
-0.8673396707,
0.1666096747,
0.5594444275,
-0.8600875139,
0.793974936,
-0.1452077478,
-0.8103384376,
0.1159222797,
-0.6372548342,
-0.1105779856,
0.4130062759,
-0.3187304735,
-0.9059062004,
-0.170639798,
0.1115119904,
0.4419759214,
-0.4283588529,
0.3987952471,
-0.0165534206,
-0.2703044415,
0.1176433191,
0.0119820032,
0.6868566275,
0.0331467651,
-0.0228007063,
0.009981608,
-0.5505187511,
0.3791389167,
0.2818063796,
-0.3443295062,
-0.195083335,
0.2551864088,
0.1790305823,
0.1032464728,
0.4620499313,
-0.4884702563,
-0.4150318205,
-0.2189171016,
0.1293744296,
0.1707438976,
0.5134469271,
0.1188275665,
-0.7902804613,
0.5051116943,
-0.0099504339,
0.4638629258,
-0.3017143309,
-0.5685008168,
-0.2277526557,
0.0751606375,
0.1204073653,
0.7430465817,
-0.6705342531,
0.2565105855,
-0.331456244,
-0.3298388124,
-0.4792591035,
-0.2510682344,
0.3546155393,
0.7364834547,
0.7176141739,
-0.1418498009,
-0.4485363662,
-0.7523295283,
-0.36122033,
-0.228632018,
-0.0243089572,
0.3909754753,
0.3977406919,
-0.0517469607,
0.7352301478,
-0.3328922093,
-0.3850373924,
-0.1315402389,
-0.0485614762,
0.1801157743,
0.2669416964,
0.2493702322,
-0.9790557623,
-0.5236719251,
0.0439566262,
-0.9063674212,
0.2392245084,
0.2314878255,
-0.1667455286,
0.1719047576,
0.2534824908,
-0.4544832408,
0.2882436514,
0.5170420408,
-0.4627155066,
0.5599582791,
-0.3230784535,
0.5612871647,
-1.1793282032,
0.3482621312,
-0.0732447654,
-0.327870667,
-0.7520478964,
-0.0382666364,
0.1135300994,
-0.1381382495,
-0.2985341549,
0.1644982994,
-0.5425719023,
-0.0047706873,
0.2877925634,
-0.1878662854,
0.2809809148,
0.0956780538,
0.0177962929,
0.5174435377,
0.3968705535,
-0.4568298459,
0.3020559251,
0.6799268126,
-0.0465707444,
0.9925031066,
-0.8861714602,
0.360358417,
-0.1259118766,
0.0264046844,
-0.7085518837,
-0.3904271722,
0.09918008,
-0.4529431462,
0.1156358793,
-0.1096102968,
-0.4951376617,
-0.2793429196,
0.0637008473,
0.3587370217,
0.3440819085,
-0.2592819333,
0.7597716451,
0.7643169165,
-0.4645175338,
-0.3521420062,
-0.749031961,
0.0232690405,
-0.1222652569,
-0.6227927208,
0.7580838203,
-0.0027644027,
-0.3066271245,
0.4854314327,
0.1889688969,
-0.7251168489,
-0.1980452985,
0.094992578,
0.6455780268,
-0.1831081361,
0.5716541409,
0.0253200158,
0.1981286108,
0.3242681026,
-0.079576239,
0.3320112526,
0.001938815,
-0.6333250403,
-0.6180469394,
0.878118813,
0.4715437293,
-0.5918868184,
1.0099653006,
-0.1958058476,
-0.7025055289,
0.0261695608,
-0.5171105862,
-0.3563622236,
-0.3513875306,
0.5546896458,
-0.1271564811,
-0.7647325993,
0.4948517382,
0.0437083319,
0.3410425186,
0.4675120413,
0.3151953518,
-0.2711671889,
1.0393536091,
0.5748461485,
0.363977164,
-0.0530358069,
0.334942311,
0.010457241,
-0.5986809134,
-0.7941557765,
-0.8589920402,
0.3040745258,
-0.2117136121,
-0.4905042946,
0.6745587587,
-0.3618144989,
-0.2783540189,
0.1361619532,
-0.6141312122,
0.1813156903,
0.0194382742,
0.5798094273,
0.5931953192,
-0.0197858289,
-0.0273685418,
-0.0582179837,
-0.4237476587,
-0.565625906,
1.1500620842,
0.1882232428,
0.4030269384,
0.0627185628,
1.0417052507,
0.2126215994,
-0.1491365284,
-0.3553409874,
0.4675036073,
-0.1301659048,
-0.9502218366,
-0.5624883175,
-0.3766691089,
-0.9118934274,
-0.1369456351,
-0.3376549482,
-0.4183765352,
-0.1274083853,
0.4357723594,
-0.4090895057,
0.2747466564,
-0.4026542008,
1.0154799223,
-0.4764169157,
-0.3866198659,
-0.0542016439,
-0.8318095207,
-0.0487290807,
-0.2683964074,
0.3130351007,
0.1034349427,
-0.0505816936,
0.7395607233,
-0.3652963042,
0.4111074209,
-0.0243812948,
0.1864218265,
0.4235855043,
-0.13956967,
0.5597002506,
-0.1487893164,
-0.4409933388,
0.1292708665,
0.5748819709,
-0.5082056522,
-0.3165356219,
0.3890585005,
-0.4522184134,
-0.2484727502,
-0.3831997812,
-0.2713178992,
-0.358186245,
0.3311766088,
0.0491549782,
0.6278405786,
-0.4708555043,
0.0453806743,
0.9498015046,
-0.1992587745,
-0.1021355093,
0.3859681785,
-0.1999384612,
-0.1206673831,
0.5974243283,
0.2339363843,
0.2385695428,
0.6397402883,
-0.1416781992,
-0.5405524969,
-0.5778161883,
-0.5614179969,
0.3612386584,
-0.5293927193,
-0.160483703,
-0.8901948333,
-0.332811743,
-0.142619133,
0.1435765028,
-0.2606489956,
-0.2005555481,
-0.5110381842,
-0.1174222603,
0.486631304,
0.8386332989,
0.5412890315,
-0.3109254539,
-1.3738365173,
0.3126806319,
0.2152314484,
0.4389735758,
-0.2151023149,
-0.3002280295,
-0.2432966083,
-0.0742474273,
-0.1522727162,
-1.2200061083,
0.370754689,
0.1999047548,
0.7335755229,
-0.2307554334,
0.2913076878,
0.4227192998,
-0.8816071749,
0.8179985285,
0.1792382002,
-0.7727406025,
0.7163085938,
-0.5641695261,
0.0926534981,
0.9196938276,
0.5134779215,
-0.4959661663,
-0.0540110208,
-0.4916929603,
-0.8689395785,
0.354902178,
0.0559408925,
-0.209140718,
0.0282717533,
0.5181036592,
-0.0318581499,
0.2707351148,
-0.3882585168,
-0.2984315157,
-0.0755640194,
-0.5676701069,
0.276994735,
-0.2374157608,
-0.1273262501,
0.0213872511,
0.506783545,
0.0887830332,
0.5389951468,
0.2547027469,
0.1966559589,
-0.4792483747,
0.5599039197,
0.0014321458,
0.6716319919,
-0.3318483531,
0.0088919997,
0.3032948077,
-0.3520337045,
-0.0318531059,
0.3373380601,
-0.2638703287,
0.1725735217,
-0.1528173238,
0.5794027448,
-0.0067611169,
-0.7749690413,
0.4906671941,
-0.2566789389,
-0.2635043263,
-0.4155891538,
-0.2872199714,
0.3993653953,
-0.134495616,
0.4001273215,
-0.0136245359,
0.4509544671,
-0.4031001627,
0.7436116338,
0.2534066439,
-0.7903414965,
-0.2720271051,
0.9294525981,
0.173799783,
-0.3743486702,
0.6041008234,
0.2957167625,
-0.415081799,
0.6834510565,
0.5210140944,
0.3672842681,
-0.5774666071,
0.1288420409,
0.4537993968,
-0.0837262422,
-0.3208946586,
0.7708770633,
0.394382447,
-0.2785191536,
-0.4530776441,
-0.2988196611,
-0.7130153775,
-0.1750192642,
-1.0155857801,
0.2790084183,
-0.0080274595,
-0.264614284,
-0.2904990911,
-0.1382282972,
-0.6802046895,
0.5045590997,
-0.25603351,
0.5318386555,
-0.7747217417,
0.6578187346,
0.7885955572,
-0.1892614365,
-1.0814535618,
-0.0773051605,
0.0694190487,
-0.4393084943,
0.262711674,
-0.20801723,
0.2179481685,
0.0969006792,
-0.3980919719,
-0.7142789364,
1.1207914352,
0.0607101955,
-0.6904118061,
-0.3508844078,
0.3823984861,
0.6595676541,
0.007991707,
0.1073581725,
0.2828775942,
0.2017186433,
0.0035492014,
-1.2406578064,
0.3036147952,
-0.1645912975,
-0.4435819387,
0.5035372376,
-0.2992043495,
0.8964492083,
-0.2930810452,
-0.1077489555,
0.1453611404,
0.3966650665,
0.4406549335,
0.5678129196,
0.28022632,
0.4087886512,
0.9665395021,
-0.0316561386,
1.2302280664,
-0.2638387382,
0.4129094481,
1.1210473776,
-0.5927868485,
1.1078953743,
0.5676259995,
-0.3246682584,
0.3520314097,
0.188173458,
0.2218856066,
0.4855596721,
-0.1680515707,
-0.5779334903,
-0.212120533,
-0.504742682,
-0.4634206891,
-0.0298838317,
0.3414573371,
-0.4019870162,
0.0061632036,
-0.2823511362,
-0.2305868268,
0.2398461103,
-0.1739574224,
0.8540945053,
0.3119634092,
-0.6790149808,
0.0833684728,
-0.288302362,
0.2691787183,
-0.4374848008,
-0.3325600028,
0.2765740752,
-0.0381429531,
-0.2526705563,
-0.866171658,
0.6007276773,
0.1068163514,
-0.2423771024,
-0.1901601851,
0.933973968,
-0.5930758715,
-0.2551639378,
0.1220359504,
0.6891795397,
0.1069370061,
0.0105021577,
-0.7941223383,
0.0216197148,
-0.0883114412,
0.1398582458,
0.2703897953,
0.6232290268,
0.1482873261,
0.4230405688,
0.2828151584,
0.2817395031,
0.1035958752,
-0.1173582673,
0.5600780845,
-0.5131090879,
-0.4341223836,
-0.5144200921,
0.709631443,
-0.0908817276,
0.0552812517,
0.6231010556,
0.7045565844,
0.4501966238,
-0.0423320979,
0.8316527009,
0.08000388,
1.457721591,
-0.3623817861,
0.8972668648,
-0.6588047147,
0.0640202239,
-0.206889689,
-0.4379279613,
-0.2474098206,
0.2557306886,
-0.0422423519,
-0.0200547092,
0.7638458014,
0.493785888,
0.446467787,
0.1164450794,
0.3941721022,
-0.0148297371,
0.342131108,
0.5414412618,
0.5263209343,
-0.731126368,
0.6927189231,
-0.2347972244,
0.0794520974,
-0.2157549858,
-0.7102169991,
-0.4056522846,
-0.6293435097,
-0.4558760524,
-0.4484502971,
0.5429546237,
0.9144230485,
0.5846380591,
-1.0755888224,
-0.0659176782,
-0.1770115048,
-0.1958445907,
-0.1841103435,
-0.1662708372,
0.5123283267,
0.0810165256,
-0.3930624723,
0.0039137066,
0.2048572004,
-0.0468323939,
0.3175121844,
0.011176249,
-0.110595189,
0.0336678401,
0.2530278862,
0.3566150665,
-0.3027806282,
0.0269544944,
0.5062296987,
-0.3745037615,
0.2353490442,
0.379616946,
-0.49542436,
0.4756497145,
0.5264693499,
0.8372502923,
0.4900388122,
0.3940645456,
0.4325695634,
-0.4011307955,
-0.6757675409,
0.668473959,
0.1755268425,
0.4792306423,
-0.5896964073,
0.11538212,
-0.026464371,
-1.0532946587,
-0.6728616357,
-0.0032273433,
-0.9666055441,
-0.0337683521,
0.8134557605,
-0.1374493837,
-0.1230922416,
-0.7957682014,
-0.1077774987,
0.4254051447,
-0.3369146883,
0.7016971707,
0.2368843406,
-0.3997434974,
-0.2849149108,
-0.8633100986,
0.4577620029,
0.5175914764,
-1.3959138393,
-0.137113601,
0.5001938343,
0.4273788333,
-0.1150476262,
1.0628695488,
-0.5453498363,
0.4282713234,
-0.3258159161,
0.0432755686,
0.3065989614,
-0.3028482497,
-0.1116693988,
0.3516511619,
0.1587981284,
-0.2458198816
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02517v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02517v1
|
Mothman at SemEval-2024 Task 9: An Iterative System for Chain-of-Thought Prompt Optimization
| 2024-05-03T23:04:52 | 2024-05-03T23:04:52 |
Alvin Po-Chun Chen, Ray Groshan, Sean von Bayern
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Extensive research exists on the performance of large language models on
logic-based tasks, whereas relatively little has been done on their ability to
generate creative solutions on lateral thinking tasks. The BrainTeaser shared
task tests lateral thinking and uses adversarial datasets to prevent
memorization, resulting in poor performance for out-of-the-box models. We
propose a system for iterative, chain-of-thought prompt engineering which
optimizes prompts using human evaluation. Using this shared task, we
demonstrate our system's ability to significantly improve model performance by
optimizing prompts and evaluate the input dataset.
|
[
-0.5741001964,
-0.7557700276,
0.7616422772,
0.4814792573,
-0.1583065838,
0.1129244119,
-0.074507162,
-0.2167281359,
0.411480248,
0.4466956556,
-1.2282804251,
-0.1858476847,
-0.2664471865,
0.4104811251,
-0.0100147985,
0.7690399885,
-0.0711030737,
-0.062272802,
-0.2978959382,
-0.0473869853,
-1.0377099514,
-0.4640664458,
-1.0127563477,
-0.4867447019,
0.7307510376,
0.3908679783,
0.5188367963,
0.3488090932,
0.4284065962,
0.2811869681,
0.0098362621,
0.1388241053,
-0.3977070153,
0.3441187441,
-0.6796748638,
-0.1918581724,
-0.3138729036,
-0.2223618478,
0.0993418023,
0.6902836561,
-0.05371264,
0.1879931688,
-0.0603170022,
0.7535310388,
-0.7501179576,
-0.0372009575,
-0.4416123927,
0.1148392707,
-0.0945508406,
-0.3718955517,
-0.3648095131,
-0.5387402177,
0.1724694371,
-0.5987865925,
-0.1016645581,
0.3521415293,
0.3379811943,
0.4182341397,
-0.2102211565,
-0.263995111,
-0.2473884076,
0.7259827852,
-0.432412535,
0.2376153022,
0.326495409,
0.4876507521,
-0.169759661,
-0.452010721,
-0.415243119,
-0.00924771,
0.2690221071,
0.2272381186,
-0.3249710798,
-0.0414818488,
0.3346196711,
-0.1580689102,
-0.7317532897,
0.0413131826,
-0.5455513597,
-0.2848741412,
0.6685115695,
0.6625190973,
0.3436400294,
-0.1249035969,
-0.3871528804,
-0.1482656598,
-0.3396564424,
0.3660043776,
0.2195709646,
0.1425113082,
0.3392696083,
0.5815804601,
-0.3905216157,
0.5933104157,
0.1614200324,
0.5648249388,
0.223433122,
-0.2226014435,
0.0181051865,
-0.0009310386,
0.7068886757,
0.6203993559,
0.1251968145,
-0.2253215015,
-0.5155066252,
0.5893470645,
0.4647576213,
-0.6466234922,
-0.3884777427,
0.2318025529,
-0.2874996364,
-0.3380327821,
-0.2657764554,
-0.8258728385,
-0.6591201425,
-0.2974036038,
0.8360555768,
-0.5063391328,
0.0551151447,
0.3744225204,
-0.4998154938,
-0.2747997344,
0.0945190117,
-0.6008967757,
0.3453883231,
0.4907179177,
0.6170459986,
-0.4934907258,
-0.4591776133,
-0.6912096143,
-0.1211692244,
-0.2977803648,
0.9378321171,
-0.4981923401,
-0.3339101374,
-0.3477268517,
-0.1472964883,
-0.1453885138,
-0.5539483428,
0.6604760885,
-0.7345705032,
0.0790380314,
-0.79372859,
-0.4782282412,
-0.2945353687,
0.2667417228,
-0.755441308,
0.7797929049,
-0.1101626381,
-0.7747541666,
0.1925401092,
-0.8864930868,
-0.4784066081,
0.0945122764,
-0.3550461233,
-0.036697913,
0.0582234934,
0.5737138391,
0.3527604043,
-0.5647135377,
0.5171766877,
-0.2383089215,
-0.5604467392,
0.3315760493,
-0.2438250482,
1.1750696898,
0.1505623311,
-0.5832935572,
0.4551618993,
-0.6207568645,
0.09408281,
0.1989812702,
-0.0477329567,
-0.2061946094,
-0.1865173578,
-0.239287883,
0.2674048245,
0.380009681,
-0.4136675894,
0.3546880782,
-0.3051467538,
0.2699724138,
1.1247763634,
0.4514056444,
0.3171597123,
-0.4092490077,
0.822758615,
0.138586387,
0.2713269889,
-0.1302317977,
-0.4992456734,
-0.9034001827,
0.0327370875,
-0.2190138102,
0.7948179841,
-1.1089359522,
0.4314396679,
0.1109404862,
-0.4102304578,
-0.2953651547,
-0.0661196113,
0.2524172664,
0.6106425524,
0.3853182197,
-0.1358572543,
-0.6678564548,
-1.1830550432,
-0.4742074013,
0.1784509122,
0.0277638715,
-0.095062308,
0.5236792564,
-0.5383300781,
0.7332630754,
-0.649736166,
0.1759486198,
-0.1262044758,
0.2035485059,
0.6019866467,
0.3781152964,
0.1066907495,
-0.3986396492,
-0.1207521707,
-0.3193303049,
-0.7512108088,
-0.4058035612,
-0.0745772272,
-0.3244724274,
-0.072686173,
0.3164943755,
-0.6414732933,
0.4522534609,
0.242322728,
-0.5235174894,
0.5206706524,
-0.231807664,
0.2550421357,
-0.8300897479,
0.2807429433,
-0.2497118711,
0.0498354249,
-0.3947983682,
-0.0787572786,
0.0395312831,
-0.4588158429,
-0.0929397792,
0.4775529206,
-0.4723000228,
0.0184335578,
-0.3400337398,
0.1511377841,
0.0006491207,
0.8282621503,
-0.2583182454,
1.0373991728,
0.6631170511,
-0.8425947428,
0.4130867124,
0.2948400378,
-0.2155757695,
0.6918168664,
-0.7608460784,
0.6567243338,
-0.3600082994,
0.0057155681,
-0.918795526,
0.0102832485,
0.3321931064,
-0.2695360184,
-0.1962854266,
0.7773413658,
-0.391099453,
-0.8046180606,
-0.4348374903,
0.4544876218,
0.3920595646,
-0.6524948478,
0.4933108687,
0.5760125518,
-0.2710222304,
-0.355007261,
-0.3654951751,
0.1782896966,
-0.2291825712,
-0.7368056774,
0.1826656759,
-0.2762650847,
-0.2646760046,
-0.2034057081,
-0.2864391208,
0.0228777342,
0.0365998335,
0.2721579969,
0.3430487216,
0.2417647392,
0.0395455658,
0.160008505,
-0.2529601455,
0.400534004,
-0.43260023,
0.6541935802,
-0.2367631942,
-0.2176886201,
-0.5809016228,
0.5055859089,
0.2397576571,
-0.2087480873,
0.2756052315,
0.2442618906,
-0.4407516718,
-0.426224649,
-0.5335693359,
-0.4328170419,
-0.5610103607,
0.1565692425,
-0.5967792273,
-0.7961652279,
0.58761549,
-0.0307880472,
0.0532417968,
0.4482750893,
0.4220551252,
-0.2002757937,
1.1571730375,
0.4504202008,
-0.0818366557,
0.0582026802,
-0.231739521,
0.1362467706,
-0.5919889808,
-0.2844521105,
-0.4235483408,
-0.5814860463,
0.0139216632,
-0.475815922,
0.5156701207,
-0.0572962053,
-0.3802603781,
0.6307793856,
-0.7853016853,
0.5040345192,
0.6579995155,
0.4543300569,
0.024605358,
-0.2177442908,
-0.5999791026,
-0.083650738,
-0.9047806859,
-0.4336820245,
0.7242338657,
-0.0147671578,
0.6512944102,
-0.2689251006,
0.571811676,
0.3583593965,
-0.1024229527,
-0.5601853728,
0.9667961001,
0.1629701406,
-0.5819255114,
-0.2589843273,
-0.269884795,
-0.9194565415,
0.0642624274,
0.224606961,
-1.0041053295,
0.270180434,
0.0683683231,
-0.5967102051,
-0.1237021312,
-0.4180611968,
0.822896421,
-0.1261940449,
-0.4084708095,
-0.4116302431,
-0.6450580359,
0.2085824907,
-0.1742999256,
-0.0686388835,
0.2055528164,
-0.073175855,
1.0431220531,
-0.3851100802,
0.6206344962,
-0.2957213521,
0.049285721,
0.4973140955,
0.1227105334,
0.6689177155,
-0.0971279889,
-0.3044974506,
-0.1565237045,
-0.2147827595,
-0.1526453793,
-0.8137114048,
0.5071584582,
-0.6173610687,
-0.8367385268,
-0.1916746199,
-0.5743849874,
-0.3730160296,
0.1771522015,
0.4339419007,
0.4920548499,
0.0374485962,
0.0844323039,
0.5161206722,
-0.3249945343,
0.5116474032,
0.0906703919,
-0.2872163653,
-0.8012465835,
0.7106745243,
0.0032221125,
-0.1959399879,
0.2373736203,
0.2037443072,
-0.3723619282,
-0.1476379037,
-0.2339535952,
-0.091377534,
-0.9717600942,
-0.174276337,
-0.8656241298,
-0.0414105244,
-0.178034246,
-0.3748345673,
-0.1599924117,
-0.5965011716,
-0.1434616446,
-0.1306993365,
0.1719729006,
0.6043065786,
-0.006728177,
0.257981807,
-0.5571985841,
0.2635498047,
0.3211413622,
-0.0319334008,
0.1023792028,
-0.2557869852,
-0.1915903091,
-0.0999738127,
-0.5311552882,
-1.0316052437,
0.2179513574,
-0.3673040867,
0.6736811996,
0.2532224655,
0.1152268946,
0.8054510355,
-0.5027360916,
0.5843740106,
0.3541113734,
-1.0603294373,
0.8859522343,
-0.4304200113,
0.619055748,
0.8704069853,
0.3278957307,
-0.4615348279,
-0.3456860781,
-0.5175366402,
-0.6395575404,
0.5823138356,
0.2265828252,
-0.4263367355,
-0.1101850644,
0.1711175889,
0.2343319952,
0.233981818,
-0.2427706718,
0.0568733849,
0.0435402691,
-0.1654379219,
-0.0217190366,
0.0502798297,
-0.044138439,
-0.3789640963,
0.641808033,
-0.1240855604,
0.2566381693,
0.197797358,
-0.0552275032,
-0.315888226,
0.1437342018,
0.5645320415,
0.8018741012,
0.0905166194,
0.1521652341,
0.4151076972,
-0.2703123093,
0.3049764335,
-0.1463115811,
-0.3206878304,
-0.1353469491,
0.0227714032,
0.9559528828,
0.2007804811,
-0.6858836412,
0.3792703152,
0.0685957372,
-0.0184790194,
-0.2054103762,
0.3581720293,
0.1828784794,
0.6335796118,
0.3145501614,
0.6545581222,
0.5154203773,
-0.3035323322,
0.400138855,
0.1743459553,
-0.2759198844,
-0.5109813213,
0.8106549978,
0.3125981092,
-0.7000551224,
0.5264958143,
-0.2216613889,
-0.8886702061,
0.7166486979,
0.4695961177,
1.2480983734,
-0.17475079,
0.0736785755,
0.4138315618,
0.3385166228,
-0.1292872727,
0.876747191,
-0.1219247952,
-0.5143063664,
-0.2707000971,
-0.2066529244,
-0.3827735782,
-0.0457664244,
-0.5161220431,
0.5655556917,
-0.5280460715,
-0.5765629411,
-0.1725967824,
0.0773687512,
-1.0229182243,
0.2131791413,
-0.2498461455,
1.0208224058,
-0.5204746723,
0.5016496778,
0.69799757,
-0.3447187841,
-0.7713137269,
-0.1728300899,
0.0266490132,
-0.6361882687,
0.9770835042,
0.5523727536,
-0.3741966784,
0.1502292156,
-0.2874915302,
-0.5394819975,
1.1338423491,
0.209296152,
-0.6676967144,
-0.1426533014,
-0.1709393859,
0.2544971406,
-0.26138255,
0.2693271637,
0.3744743764,
0.5219582319,
0.0178218763,
-0.7724500895,
0.2851418257,
-0.4484825432,
0.1809487194,
0.1007741839,
-0.5566583872,
0.8999732733,
-0.2632665634,
-0.3229232132,
-0.0337607712,
0.593583107,
0.6582269669,
0.3807083964,
0.690990448,
0.5379081368,
1.0067975521,
0.3745184541,
0.7408836484,
-0.2404204756,
0.019024251,
1.0975195169,
-0.4952183068,
0.7019447088,
0.7297166586,
-0.0293336697,
0.259827435,
0.570797801,
0.1433826834,
0.6768689156,
0.4696599543,
-0.1788978279,
-0.1976705492,
-0.0959468633,
-0.0278921723,
0.2989263535,
0.0619041547,
-0.0073314607,
-0.147890836,
0.3393939734,
-0.3202391267,
0.0546447337,
-0.2661531866,
0.5959075689,
0.0253958087,
-1.1083048582,
0.4394329786,
-0.2073313296,
0.6488136649,
-0.2305214554,
0.3103830218,
-0.1917430758,
0.417255491,
0.1591820121,
-0.5795856714,
0.3523144722,
0.0308183916,
-0.0989890322,
-0.3137601018,
0.9227408767,
-0.0939169526,
-0.4399460852,
0.3071101904,
0.4128858149,
0.0176204983,
-0.228296712,
-0.6038473845,
0.3119776547,
-0.0482906736,
-0.4005649686,
-0.2707884908,
0.5033069849,
-0.1319564581,
0.9575130343,
0.4534868598,
-0.1324705482,
-0.0715297088,
0.0290861875,
1.0723013878,
-0.9851933718,
-0.7676000595,
-1.0827461481,
0.53849262,
-0.3511220515,
-0.4615049064,
0.7661674619,
0.7137294412,
0.4788700044,
-0.3066217899,
0.6249194145,
0.1994889379,
0.4143244028,
-0.3239063323,
0.6916790009,
-0.3854687214,
0.1081506312,
-0.4514823854,
-1.0020290613,
0.0379508287,
0.5976866484,
-0.2430581003,
-0.1896864623,
1.043666482,
0.7785215974,
0.1418924183,
0.6114741564,
0.334505707,
-0.2109366208,
0.152964741,
0.9523530602,
1.208969593,
-0.46603778,
0.2439754456,
-0.2462447882,
-0.3397959173,
-0.0847042426,
-0.642026782,
-1.1989873648,
-0.7990035415,
-0.1636377275,
-0.0674586967,
0.2875740826,
1.1715787649,
0.3911008537,
-0.6426750422,
-0.5166186094,
-0.3588181734,
-0.3289860785,
-0.2474367023,
-0.2278626561,
0.0962298438,
-0.4890155196,
-0.3205799162,
0.587495625,
0.6423896551,
-0.4044038057,
-0.228052333,
0.0207440928,
-0.1654409021,
0.2220199257,
0.5227483511,
-0.2033279836,
-0.4969460368,
-0.2358229905,
0.4885147214,
-0.1163736731,
-0.1813786775,
0.9709817767,
-0.9049687386,
0.3839488328,
0.7135524154,
1.1417328119,
0.3077553213,
-0.0729273111,
0.881473124,
-0.2370576113,
0.0088795526,
0.6037634611,
0.2846369743,
0.1464796513,
-0.5185061097,
0.5395923853,
0.2230960429,
-0.6962477565,
-0.5174772739,
0.0913426131,
-0.8713003993,
-0.2898025811,
0.714099884,
0.1517332792,
-0.4099958837,
0.0426663645,
-0.5041902065,
0.2964450717,
-0.4359254539,
0.8469941616,
0.808255136,
-0.2922696769,
-0.263897717,
-0.347523272,
0.3034372628,
0.6897469759,
-0.9603517056,
-0.1293657869,
0.4594588876,
-0.0165368784,
0.1578725427,
0.8604626656,
0.3941137195,
0.3234837055,
0.0312371682,
-0.0485451072,
-0.0025253934,
-0.4896860421,
-0.2179716527,
0.1610858142,
-0.3784887195,
-0.2352554649
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02501v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02501v2
|
PICLe: Eliciting Diverse Behaviors from Large Language Models with Persona In-Context Learning
| 2024-05-03T22:17:22 | 2024-05-14T05:53:07 |
Hyeong Kyu Choi, Yixuan Li
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Large Language Models (LLMs) are trained on massive text corpora, which are
encoded with diverse personality traits. This triggers an interesting goal of
eliciting a desired personality trait from the LLM, and probing its behavioral
preferences. Accordingly, we formalize the persona elicitation task, aiming to
customize LLM behaviors to align with a target persona. We present Persona
In-Context Learning (PICLe), a novel persona elicitation framework grounded in
Bayesian inference. At the core, PICLe introduces a new ICL example selection
criterion based on likelihood ratio, which is designed to optimally guide the
model in eliciting a specific target persona. We demonstrate the effectiveness
of PICLe through extensive comparisons against baseline methods across three
contemporary LLMs. Code is available at
https://github.com/deeplearning-wisc/picle.
|
[
-0.3001048267,
-0.8912779093,
0.5863464475,
0.3929457068,
0.0774956346,
0.2279491574,
-0.2045072764,
-0.3597777486,
-0.2019856274,
0.3017992675,
-0.5900291204,
-0.635229528,
-0.2345026135,
-0.1395340413,
-0.1420962811,
0.9769746661,
0.5045032501,
0.249258697,
-0.1919741482,
0.1303949803,
-0.3294176459,
-0.5522010326,
-0.8890067935,
-0.4806717932,
0.8496239185,
0.6871436834,
0.2334702462,
-0.2190250158,
0.2688382864,
0.2156073004,
0.0363447666,
0.0130364085,
-0.6153588295,
0.224026978,
-0.4245803058,
-0.4475315213,
-0.2820212245,
0.0883286372,
0.7798668146,
1.0326676369,
0.1441483349,
0.0063094622,
0.1669481695,
0.4602355063,
-0.7685011029,
0.1433702409,
-0.485349834,
0.1003819257,
0.0012707231,
-0.003005147,
-0.6884760261,
-0.2507918477,
0.2610997856,
-0.2031168491,
0.0107115302,
0.2044489831,
0.4077360034,
-0.157261312,
-0.7566875219,
-0.1417588145,
-0.7601019144,
0.8367208242,
-0.4455804825,
0.3305375576,
0.4772773087,
0.2361320257,
-0.2332369685,
-0.458412081,
-0.4939568341,
-0.3535126448,
-0.1098831296,
0.2120096982,
0.0304590221,
0.088052839,
0.310998559,
0.5031858087,
-0.5731310844,
0.4287682474,
-0.0030060506,
0.0695960596,
0.4137178063,
0.0194686577,
0.2059529871,
-0.1239201352,
-0.3826961219,
-0.136526376,
-0.6990768313,
0.3764611185,
0.4513984621,
0.1468857229,
-0.2853398323,
0.6221331954,
-0.1208432764,
0.4810864925,
0.5420389771,
-0.3608571291,
0.2767556608,
0.2796918452,
-0.2842238843,
-0.0355694629,
0.655372858,
0.1904299557,
0.0062393947,
-0.3131315708,
-0.1204378307,
-0.1714666188,
-0.0100008966,
-0.9474723935,
-0.4165516794,
0.490945369,
-0.3826337457,
-0.3960452378,
0.0351274721,
-0.868673563,
-0.5395976901,
-0.245724529,
0.2106304765,
-0.7987526059,
-0.1189876944,
-0.0861468092,
-0.1148555502,
0.6556966305,
0.3891980648,
-1.1361333132,
0.1569434553,
0.690680027,
0.6652799845,
-0.3104629517,
-0.5073346496,
-1.0110595226,
0.3838130236,
-0.2341066748,
1.0159007311,
-0.6995651126,
-0.5185471773,
-0.02250861,
-0.2386659235,
-0.1756405681,
-0.4723953903,
0.4292802513,
-0.3626544178,
0.3926224113,
-0.3491156399,
-0.8796645403,
-0.0610730462,
0.3625988662,
-0.4445259869,
0.6695480943,
0.4608538747,
-0.601578474,
0.5569435954,
-0.6087174416,
-0.4624468088,
0.4424113035,
-0.4115808904,
-0.2114122063,
0.1877679825,
0.0776626989,
0.7584524751,
-0.1747932434,
0.2048770189,
-0.5292607546,
-0.3236676157,
0.5011847019,
-0.1098590642,
0.9515373111,
0.2632811069,
-0.0702288225,
0.3686025143,
-0.3604439199,
-0.1043322533,
-0.0458936132,
-0.6478030682,
-0.2106095552,
0.0504918993,
0.2366981059,
0.14534612,
0.2911200821,
-0.4864254296,
0.3499577641,
-0.3618778586,
0.0902172402,
0.5952270627,
0.0804251283,
0.7205393314,
-0.4503639936,
0.4726012945,
-0.0265303701,
0.0811243281,
-0.2620955706,
-0.4178653657,
-0.1714265198,
-0.8196756244,
-0.0411157161,
0.6047298908,
-0.50631392,
0.6286091805,
-0.0596682355,
-0.5700753331,
-0.0713230819,
0.0293242708,
0.4009606838,
0.5245483518,
0.0012385201,
-0.1785122156,
-0.2452342212,
-0.8452361822,
-0.2715887427,
-0.3693027198,
-0.214347899,
0.5534061193,
0.3185292184,
-0.3359400928,
0.8760075569,
-0.19076626,
0.0045596957,
-0.7541835308,
0.1558379531,
0.0994920954,
0.3889511228,
0.9251345992,
-1.0257927179,
-0.5595784187,
-0.1116186678,
-0.5551914573,
-0.1578297019,
-0.1673276275,
-0.1508970708,
-0.0313154981,
0.4976921976,
-0.4910041094,
0.0974500626,
0.6473857164,
-0.5671150088,
0.7521157861,
-0.0467400551,
0.3221218884,
-1.1699109077,
0.1800029427,
0.3007246852,
-0.2485444248,
-0.5752267241,
0.2259452194,
0.1939843297,
-0.1354206055,
-0.5846418142,
0.9431077838,
-0.1708519757,
-0.2155158222,
-0.1358552426,
-0.1257322729,
-0.0264527444,
0.6130830646,
0.1863928288,
0.6256647706,
0.6161469817,
-0.6642558575,
0.3286309838,
0.4080749154,
-0.6615982056,
1.0655851364,
-0.3800469935,
0.0780889243,
-0.2371273786,
0.2691613734,
-1.0919866562,
-0.5451151133,
0.2193495333,
-0.1766198725,
0.2637661397,
-0.4218540192,
-0.5705204606,
-0.1118182391,
-0.1749740094,
0.2833288908,
0.5209241509,
-0.732247591,
0.5330383182,
0.4527091086,
-0.1923837662,
-0.2515949309,
-0.5654529333,
0.0383974873,
-0.5463531017,
-0.1404440701,
0.5205535889,
-0.6440945268,
-0.4192051589,
-0.5071822405,
0.2798565328,
-0.1758856326,
0.087960273,
0.145347923,
0.2270081192,
0.0062466036,
0.1642073393,
0.2066717148,
0.2068830281,
-0.0023475133,
-0.2052673399,
0.7291200757,
-0.3849273026,
-0.3289702535,
-0.3380133808,
0.5674567819,
0.5266759396,
-0.0610612407,
0.6541720033,
0.6771661639,
-0.1668538451,
-0.2381130159,
-0.4690279663,
-0.3195804656,
-0.4722914994,
0.4336290061,
-0.5281571746,
-1.0380339622,
0.5661588907,
-0.3843557835,
0.0350637734,
-0.1874175966,
0.5670083165,
-0.3220053911,
0.8492088914,
0.7820020318,
-0.2578897178,
0.8184560537,
-0.0887145996,
0.2700154185,
-0.9803282022,
-0.3766562343,
-0.3070290089,
-0.5521672964,
-0.4961839318,
-0.1918799728,
0.1759454757,
0.0916450694,
-0.5000547767,
0.0908031166,
0.0396219119,
0.4885448515,
0.6608569622,
0.3173755109,
0.1491761953,
0.0333248712,
-0.1981773973,
-0.1534010619,
-0.5837661028,
-0.4595046937,
0.7840383053,
0.1438568532,
0.9151403308,
0.4533390701,
0.6244968176,
0.0524558052,
0.4928742349,
-1.1355006695,
0.6956487298,
-0.1961680949,
-0.5782426,
-0.1577132046,
-0.3808307648,
-1.0050535202,
0.2185107023,
-0.3913158476,
-1.290823698,
0.2937244177,
0.3991625309,
-0.265047431,
0.3153790236,
-0.5817015171,
1.168762207,
-0.4837251306,
-0.461120218,
-0.2150625288,
-0.5120050311,
0.4573708475,
0.0022342501,
-0.1526825279,
-0.186823085,
-0.1012121215,
0.1633422524,
0.2885624766,
1.09887743,
-0.0612710007,
-0.0810560584,
-0.0895630419,
0.4250623286,
0.3437974453,
0.2471167594,
-0.2493839264,
-0.1269994378,
-0.0598089024,
-0.3992088437,
-0.5340140462,
0.854308784,
-0.6035601497,
-0.3274136484,
-0.3085297644,
-0.6522350907,
-0.5473082066,
0.1151782349,
0.4624990225,
0.2895096838,
-0.630145371,
0.3390355706,
0.8930767775,
-0.6473320127,
0.4028621912,
0.6000670791,
-0.5265366435,
-0.0634449422,
0.6403905749,
-0.5153778791,
0.1793500483,
0.8268738389,
0.2525069416,
-0.1527108401,
-0.276720196,
-0.0984543264,
0.1399114281,
-0.6278858781,
0.1991142631,
-0.5640822053,
-0.041997835,
-0.3767524958,
-0.3969339132,
-0.2280632854,
0.0706742257,
-0.181574136,
0.2295406014,
-0.0246457532,
0.5153448582,
0.3918913007,
0.4164128602,
-0.5490112901,
0.1401219517,
0.431660533,
0.1913817227,
-0.1276151985,
-0.6088407636,
0.0204206705,
-0.1741431803,
-0.2821922004,
-0.9136753082,
0.5635322332,
0.387978524,
0.7333906293,
0.5961797237,
-0.1487398744,
0.3652157485,
-0.4143863022,
0.5746865869,
0.224056527,
-0.7831795216,
0.8844413757,
-0.6042126417,
0.4998091757,
0.4768506289,
0.6556036472,
-0.6836660504,
-0.3077709377,
-0.5958787799,
-0.5516941547,
0.1865730286,
-0.210110113,
0.2130663246,
-0.2594841719,
0.4964545071,
0.3407019079,
0.3524557948,
-0.9306920767,
0.0649030656,
0.1675523371,
-0.3654016852,
-0.1293383539,
-0.2486299872,
0.0700603351,
-0.3558212519,
0.3655149043,
-0.5136832595,
0.3235295117,
-0.0570515543,
-0.2421019673,
0.0722578689,
0.2806950808,
0.0267427675,
0.6233599782,
-0.2845413387,
-0.0467422381,
0.0023071957,
-0.2583957911,
-0.1102980226,
-0.0610221103,
-0.2921605408,
-0.4537416101,
0.1774851233,
0.6375669241,
0.7907783985,
-0.9804913402,
0.7588865161,
-0.1721669436,
-0.068184644,
-0.5451282263,
0.3622494638,
0.0368495956,
0.5362431407,
0.3024777472,
-0.214056015,
0.2351463288,
-0.8164843917,
0.0952430069,
0.6379703283,
-0.2395068705,
-0.3022259772,
0.4560005963,
0.1294947565,
-0.2541559339,
0.7877941728,
-0.2972624898,
-0.1055841893,
0.3585389853,
0.7547021508,
0.932403028,
-0.3038043678,
0.4075146914,
0.382566154,
-0.0899211466,
0.1528175622,
0.2927355766,
-0.179098323,
-0.8829177618,
-0.6055238247,
-0.6805297732,
-0.7807882428,
0.4200151563,
-0.4951907694,
0.300873369,
-0.6235601306,
0.0907589346,
-0.1374228597,
0.0695445836,
-0.7187557817,
-0.0084313005,
0.2984933257,
0.7287065983,
-0.8434156775,
1.0079057217,
1.0224087238,
-0.2662526369,
-0.5139788985,
0.2746404111,
0.150807783,
-0.3861505091,
0.684445262,
0.1562431753,
0.0503414758,
0.1702864319,
-0.6768831015,
-0.5114776492,
0.9904551506,
0.6788765192,
-0.5418470502,
0.030104151,
-0.1752313972,
0.2572665513,
-0.746894598,
0.1074524969,
0.3544393182,
0.1567768157,
0.1722922772,
-0.5739569068,
-0.3115310669,
-0.2819041014,
-0.0327531137,
-0.2181228697,
-0.6933411956,
0.7352722287,
-0.3283245564,
0.2298033834,
0.2467107773,
0.7200995088,
0.7074139118,
0.2600445449,
0.5918293595,
0.27062428,
1.0135976076,
0.1801567823,
1.1703835726,
-0.1929079443,
-0.0085297702,
1.3349992037,
-0.4781481922,
1.0038180351,
0.383390069,
0.0521459132,
0.8066737652,
0.8971849084,
-0.0388366543,
0.5298995972,
-0.1421290934,
-0.7189514041,
-0.3249575496,
0.1088742614,
0.2504905164,
0.544724226,
0.5721421242,
-0.1822901517,
0.0282444581,
0.3348680437,
-0.1683348119,
0.0390080251,
-0.2950740159,
0.5945883393,
0.0581213571,
-0.7223730683,
-0.3066384196,
-0.1795467734,
0.6938327551,
-0.5424880981,
0.1089264303,
-0.4636053145,
0.1893054545,
-0.0153140165,
-0.7123922706,
-0.1542773247,
-0.1588972509,
-0.2942874134,
-0.2498424649,
0.7818754315,
-0.519528687,
-0.4559818208,
0.2900065482,
0.5630021095,
0.2902297676,
-0.240010798,
-0.7687636018,
-0.2774998844,
-0.2131175995,
-0.3002302945,
0.670185864,
0.384890914,
0.0597068593,
0.8602027893,
0.4499198794,
-0.0721147731,
-0.2827620208,
0.3821170926,
0.5946480036,
-0.5161873698,
-0.6594731212,
-0.7336531281,
0.580042541,
-0.1719220281,
-0.4126344621,
0.9739755988,
0.766694963,
0.9243200421,
-0.362488389,
0.7773973346,
-0.1732571274,
0.408354193,
-0.4460573494,
0.433137238,
-0.3062581122,
0.3584389389,
-0.4642990232,
-1.0877139568,
-0.1692098975,
0.9211580753,
-0.4956913888,
0.343950361,
0.7260204554,
0.7731105685,
-0.3457385004,
-0.0794012174,
0.546150744,
0.0133402189,
0.3388967216,
0.8152729273,
0.9473611712,
0.0719531327,
0.1922619939,
-0.2387234867,
-0.4923110902,
-0.2845782638,
-0.9881292582,
-1.1722608805,
-0.7277334332,
-0.5055095553,
-0.1994961947,
-0.1360276639,
1.1091586351,
0.9210182428,
-0.6745270491,
-0.4776300788,
-0.0766180456,
0.0588594228,
-0.1792985946,
-0.2391353101,
-0.0133106755,
-0.3966098726,
-1.0499184132,
0.5674331784,
0.3611258566,
0.0860459879,
-0.2646467388,
-0.1829408854,
-0.2320389748,
-0.1336925924,
0.9178820848,
0.3861831725,
-0.4979152679,
-0.2650764585,
-0.1211797073,
-0.1862021089,
-0.0309191179,
0.9628145695,
-0.8850106001,
-0.0337275378,
0.3556484282,
0.4549874067,
0.6039449573,
-0.1988629848,
0.5054081082,
-0.8546218872,
0.3295819759,
0.4131782651,
0.424746871,
0.3767011762,
-0.4604689777,
0.2869445682,
0.0707033575,
-0.6923111677,
-0.4087038338,
0.6238319278,
-1.2310889959,
-0.7146478295,
1.2755060196,
-0.1170544401,
-0.2281050235,
0.0002062416,
-0.299962908,
-0.2150864601,
-0.3190384209,
0.7369021773,
0.4277720749,
-0.4263643622,
-0.4568428695,
-0.4598154426,
0.433542788,
0.2663148046,
-0.9044153094,
-0.0593071617,
0.8519545197,
0.3411163092,
-0.2781195939,
0.5944693685,
0.09297622,
0.2451666594,
-0.3211821616,
0.0057097604,
0.4350240231,
-0.3569275737,
-0.2122747004,
0.1650741398,
0.3208056986,
0.3677338362
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02472v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02472v1
|
Semantic Scaling: Bayesian Ideal Point Estimates with Large Language Models
| 2024-05-03T20:20:15 | 2024-05-03T20:20:15 |
Michael Burnham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
This paper introduces "Semantic Scaling," a novel method for ideal point
estimation from text. I leverage large language models to classify documents
based on their expressed stances and extract survey-like data. I then use item
response theory to scale subjects from these data. Semantic Scaling
significantly improves on existing text-based scaling methods, and allows
researchers to explicitly define the ideological dimensions they measure. This
represents the first scaling approach that allows such flexibility outside of
survey instruments and opens new avenues of inquiry for populations difficult
to survey. Additionally, it works with documents of varying length, and
produces valid estimates of both mass and elite ideology. I demonstrate that
the method can differentiate between policy preferences and in-group/out-group
affect. Among the public, Semantic Scaling out-preforms Tweetscores according
to human judgement; in Congress, it recaptures the first dimension DW-NOMINATE
while allowing for greater flexibility in resolving construct validity
challenges.
|
[
-0.5426976085,
-0.9092621803,
0.7387551665,
0.0980904102,
-0.0020564771,
-0.3381897807,
-0.4036619663,
-0.3002593219,
0.4130504727,
0.5916677713,
-0.5095388293,
-0.6673076153,
-1.0351326466,
-0.2229949236,
-0.3945267797,
0.8611449599,
0.3402833939,
0.0126004741,
-0.0035696891,
-0.2859806716,
0.1315951049,
-0.3053618968,
-0.4541889131,
-0.2283044904,
0.8091970086,
0.5678328872,
1.141160965,
0.8718417287,
0.7994280457,
0.2692830265,
0.064641811,
-0.29922086,
-0.4705219865,
0.0404164568,
-0.4013437629,
-0.4456503093,
-0.7100377083,
0.2446817905,
1.0317385197,
1.0820661783,
0.035500247,
0.3321917355,
-0.0920722112,
0.7740172744,
-0.7213546634,
0.2300030142,
-0.9397542477,
-0.2613850534,
0.0469808951,
0.0214940291,
-0.3716994822,
-0.4034902751,
0.2519658804,
-0.8120307326,
0.0907180309,
0.0608180165,
0.7637048364,
0.062117599,
-0.8824442029,
-0.1969990432,
-0.6391790509,
1.0707405806,
-0.6994229555,
0.222999081,
0.5788006783,
0.1088329926,
-0.087805368,
-0.665299654,
-0.5395878553,
-0.2348638475,
0.020511223,
-0.1207029521,
-0.1801353246,
0.2378611118,
0.2882319093,
0.2355634421,
-0.2405734807,
0.1361779124,
-0.0564867333,
0.0366299637,
0.7556326985,
0.2208258957,
0.2521201074,
-0.361762315,
-0.2450239658,
-0.3682691455,
-0.4944887161,
-0.0450902469,
0.272669524,
0.5492955446,
0.2403526902,
0.8750131726,
-0.4451055527,
0.8772566319,
-0.0604057796,
-0.0471608005,
-0.0358873606,
-0.2547262311,
0.1098623946,
0.0397573635,
0.6439079642,
0.8140816092,
0.0584509932,
0.2490922213,
0.0962095708,
0.1080137417,
0.3161840439,
-0.9718415141,
-0.1012252793,
0.0221984386,
-0.7213445306,
-0.0987657607,
0.048281949,
-0.823918879,
-0.613918066,
-0.481285125,
0.5402939916,
-0.3505565822,
-0.6027568579,
0.1434880495,
-0.3197660446,
0.431827873,
0.4697638154,
-1.0347087383,
0.4660148919,
1.0836055279,
0.8726066351,
0.0035859311,
-0.0512905307,
-0.1245346144,
0.0779383034,
-0.5487612486,
0.9895226359,
-0.7930529118,
-0.4195823669,
0.0341207497,
-0.2861565351,
0.1989230514,
-0.3550807834,
0.5066531301,
-0.1704333723,
0.0684600323,
-0.4620407522,
-0.8471832275,
0.075373359,
0.5595837831,
-0.5808945298,
0.8496101499,
0.2803714573,
-0.8169953227,
0.8650007844,
-0.6761796474,
-0.0267307851,
-0.2327462435,
-0.0147549631,
-0.0652713478,
0.2969786823,
-0.0383331142,
0.4658236802,
-0.3277610838,
-0.1218706146,
-0.7268611193,
0.1909067482,
0.1764867455,
-0.223344788,
0.5824286342,
0.1855054051,
0.0609642081,
0.3302467167,
-1.0579853058,
0.4803090096,
-0.0399074703,
-0.0904367715,
-0.9410515428,
0.4687202275,
0.0863206536,
0.012629482,
0.5715227127,
-0.962230742,
0.2299917042,
-0.5256065726,
0.2275816053,
0.5979549289,
0.0155233378,
0.7034019232,
-0.1137437522,
0.0453479141,
-0.5395787954,
0.0516062826,
0.3821450472,
-0.3833868206,
-0.4623317122,
-0.3546463549,
0.0966804177,
0.2862690985,
-0.2192260474,
0.7205355763,
-0.5922311544,
-0.7842108607,
-0.2949387133,
-0.3019042313,
0.0363147035,
0.2961426675,
0.3118497133,
-0.1707457155,
-0.0512512363,
-0.919772625,
-0.5155016184,
-0.8594212532,
-0.6637310386,
-0.0127764801,
0.4055880606,
0.1246460378,
1.1152107716,
-0.7576655149,
-0.1676916331,
-0.0386018232,
0.5982741714,
-0.0923052654,
0.3167746961,
0.1743652076,
-0.8617449999,
-0.246172294,
0.0484890752,
-0.3344452381,
-0.1730411202,
0.2421615571,
-0.2267743051,
-0.0256073009,
0.2841354907,
-0.3099146187,
0.1874367893,
0.4601279795,
-0.7771606445,
0.2516221404,
-0.2858033776,
0.2363540381,
-1.3489972353,
-0.1717055291,
0.3578794897,
0.1297084242,
-0.6633599401,
-0.0299391281,
0.2320231199,
0.2464662045,
-0.147571072,
0.5333283544,
-0.0217435099,
-0.1530245543,
-0.2802143395,
0.2763641179,
-0.0405824557,
0.0102439821,
0.2564880252,
0.00092726,
-0.006136395,
-0.1225833669,
0.1966456473,
0.1006729975,
-0.2541256547,
1.1648859978,
-0.5982925296,
-0.2588690519,
-0.1014307737,
0.2703644633,
-1.1715781689,
-0.2183939517,
-0.1755007356,
-0.5670029521,
0.081396535,
-0.0932229459,
-0.3801215589,
-0.0477040596,
-0.4688814878,
0.2430433482,
0.2235051841,
-0.0225326903,
0.3646391034,
0.7077652812,
-0.093400307,
-0.1555971354,
-0.2978965938,
0.0362194031,
-0.4644861817,
-0.615316093,
0.250213474,
0.1755266786,
-0.7536205053,
0.2510420084,
-0.2114334553,
-0.308796823,
-0.1349510103,
0.1198619604,
0.2343300581,
-0.3732454181,
0.2896434069,
0.0343919694,
-0.1687169969,
0.3013306856,
-0.440756619,
0.2635873854,
-0.3604109883,
-0.156818524,
-0.2442264408,
0.6632785797,
0.6010586619,
-0.1538299471,
0.6878424883,
0.4049874544,
-0.4484453797,
0.0599271767,
-0.4325722456,
-0.1992663592,
-0.3598571122,
0.6635787487,
-0.289907515,
-0.8694571257,
0.329826653,
-0.2557623982,
0.3605103791,
0.9694527984,
0.6421093345,
0.132818833,
1.2791007757,
0.8777168393,
0.0973045081,
0.4729692936,
-0.156691581,
0.3580121398,
-0.7347730994,
-0.0193962976,
-1.1140055656,
-0.3442611694,
-0.9036990404,
-0.408228308,
0.5612693429,
-0.1261324733,
-0.4701155722,
0.2197325528,
-0.4828284979,
0.3106013834,
0.3509337902,
-0.0295859985,
0.3520228267,
-0.0197738949,
0.3815357089,
-0.2331596166,
-0.2950778902,
-0.6217775941,
1.10323596,
0.3672966659,
0.8649877906,
0.0447358415,
0.5622833371,
0.2012299001,
0.4713831246,
-1.2812414169,
0.57883811,
-0.2023949176,
-0.622477591,
-1.0981965065,
-0.6101801395,
-0.839230597,
0.5254269242,
-0.287861973,
-0.9358503819,
0.1716969907,
-0.1208751947,
-0.1412108839,
0.3632449806,
-0.642144978,
0.7993099689,
0.1488810629,
-0.0180534851,
-0.5308952332,
-0.7239874601,
-0.0848250613,
0.0480914153,
0.2154064775,
-0.755168736,
-0.6251468062,
1.0267374516,
-0.5391477942,
0.6239526868,
-0.2673155963,
-0.2887074351,
0.033879824,
0.1580486149,
0.2776370049,
0.0054249661,
-0.2417995036,
0.1994483918,
0.5488396287,
-0.764644444,
-0.9968498945,
0.7098152041,
-0.9896115065,
-0.5193868279,
-0.2718786299,
-0.877614975,
-0.5396118164,
0.3028900921,
0.1720761061,
0.3748817742,
-0.4617091715,
0.4753985405,
0.543368578,
0.2779819071,
0.1276656091,
0.631728828,
-0.0338564813,
-0.3011713922,
0.8279185295,
0.5600776076,
0.5794973969,
0.7584241629,
0.5354080796,
-0.4385113716,
-0.4004359245,
-0.2461621463,
0.0823987797,
-0.4534390867,
0.1140685901,
-0.672107935,
-0.0203566886,
-0.3830038309,
-0.3254011869,
-0.6799576283,
-0.8621035814,
0.2284470946,
-0.1115383133,
0.2850229442,
0.8261808157,
-0.0620686933,
0.2528301775,
-0.3905537724,
0.1130461842,
0.1708909571,
0.2762670517,
-0.302395314,
-0.4105285108,
-0.0565466769,
0.0593540072,
-0.1109698266,
-0.7865753174,
0.2305349857,
0.2319796383,
0.3513805568,
0.5533568859,
0.4845603704,
0.3223417997,
-0.3721806109,
0.9039819837,
0.3086854517,
-0.7411053181,
0.5895134807,
-0.5695726871,
0.3846296668,
0.5823000669,
0.7062569857,
-0.6499106288,
-0.6169618368,
-0.5221521258,
-1.0216716528,
0.2555987537,
0.0129033606,
0.3829115927,
-0.1800363511,
0.244712472,
-0.0512426309,
-0.0959032625,
-0.2614651322,
0.058774665,
-0.1813569367,
-0.4599357843,
-0.2911953628,
-0.3791697025,
-0.1715800017,
-0.3372271657,
0.4210101664,
-0.334885776,
0.0976672992,
0.1608660221,
0.1948327124,
0.0171778519,
0.4619008303,
0.3868417144,
0.9983838797,
-0.3328819573,
0.4185989797,
0.0441414677,
-0.4162103236,
0.2609696984,
0.0015747016,
0.0603935309,
-0.2489317358,
0.362932831,
0.2952082157,
0.1626856178,
-0.3639492393,
0.4336917996,
-0.1146924049,
-0.3276428878,
-0.2033937275,
-0.1725250483,
-0.0636071488,
0.0689994693,
0.2188643515,
-0.2705809772,
0.180844143,
-0.6158366203,
0.2036718279,
0.521718204,
-0.7856593132,
-0.1591127664,
0.3291495442,
0.0557911769,
-0.1415654123,
0.4498105645,
0.1443048567,
-0.0308010932,
0.5572202206,
0.5227844119,
0.7602550387,
-0.1842068583,
0.4414433539,
0.5668510795,
0.3688340783,
-0.0416850224,
-0.1264081448,
-0.1101199165,
-0.8807370067,
-0.1357782632,
-0.8369022608,
-0.4983086586,
-0.3353767693,
-0.9004003406,
0.064627856,
-0.5517932177,
-0.3599466085,
0.2797282636,
0.4439505339,
-0.1332772672,
0.0899754688,
-0.0905178785,
0.8707849383,
-0.8897222877,
0.7021453381,
0.7422159314,
-0.046108719,
-0.6749126911,
0.2359606624,
0.3989636898,
-0.674446404,
0.2670420706,
-0.1163935885,
-0.1512918323,
0.0195834339,
-0.2346483022,
-1.0806665421,
0.691216588,
0.2015069574,
0.0058732987,
-0.2569764256,
0.2986853123,
0.5247320533,
-0.3894407749,
0.2512931526,
0.8038839102,
0.5867227316,
0.1236215755,
-0.7479525805,
0.0343689956,
-0.0942979679,
0.1708153039,
0.6802882552,
-0.4330273569,
0.7009984255,
0.0518247262,
0.1852174252,
0.0172751062,
0.8285951614,
-0.2657139003,
0.1912574321,
0.7791492939,
0.5605854988,
0.7754262686,
-0.0488412976,
0.9147180319,
-0.3267363608,
0.4307207167,
0.9833965302,
-0.1856462955,
1.0931748152,
0.5429101586,
-0.201203078,
0.4963900745,
0.6356187463,
0.3159066439,
0.1865002513,
0.3595174551,
-0.4258797169,
-0.1668204814,
-0.4589957297,
-0.2375907153,
0.488322556,
0.7382962704,
-0.1799926907,
-0.5445031524,
-0.0029427179,
0.3776403666,
0.3561808765,
-0.5562440753,
1.0352679491,
-0.0557612292,
-0.4905880392,
0.2333361953,
0.1434067637,
0.3648615777,
-0.8446319699,
0.0933497399,
0.1083961725,
0.162816301,
-0.0376928151,
-1.0223950148,
0.5956414342,
-0.0016321092,
-0.3571742475,
-0.2878528535,
0.7048957944,
-0.3276664019,
-0.8023687601,
0.2356500328,
0.2875311077,
0.1164168715,
-0.3299509287,
-0.340695411,
-0.0858928934,
-0.4231858253,
-0.585359931,
0.5033617616,
0.6449022889,
-0.2794971168,
0.3483387828,
0.3261188567,
0.188862741,
0.0124517316,
-0.1936544031,
0.5548115969,
-0.5299080014,
-0.2776768506,
-0.7516967654,
0.1475457251,
-0.434879601,
-0.4502967,
0.7688807845,
0.4384024739,
0.9024364948,
0.4035349786,
0.5033117533,
-0.4804037809,
0.4671387374,
-0.2551837564,
0.7004933953,
-0.5941072106,
-0.3110145628,
-0.3084516227,
-0.8607700467,
-0.5428410769,
0.5989843607,
-0.7813248038,
-0.2205735743,
0.6025297046,
0.911683619,
0.1636200845,
-0.0846808329,
0.5592803955,
0.1787126362,
0.4047040939,
0.2743623853,
0.5865749121,
0.0942938551,
0.3330236077,
-0.179782182,
-0.744858861,
0.0553692505,
-0.6627993584,
-0.551474154,
-0.9661362171,
-0.3222120702,
-0.3577938676,
-0.2655655742,
1.1019096375,
0.7674776316,
-0.2750891447,
-0.4039998651,
0.232297346,
0.2696191669,
-0.1813752651,
-0.255458951,
0.4412563145,
-0.4246837795,
-0.7852677703,
-0.1730222851,
0.3376564682,
-0.4841124713,
-0.4005478621,
0.2355702519,
-0.0840751156,
0.5049099326,
0.9435385466,
0.1583203822,
-0.7921281457,
-0.8596202135,
-0.3236987293,
-0.2096278071,
-0.0771133825,
0.9369497299,
-0.2503167391,
0.4892470539,
0.7640517354,
0.4066231549,
0.1338438541,
-0.0126004359,
0.4127079546,
-0.3219228983,
0.1246135235,
0.2315612286,
0.0580139197,
0.011888653,
-0.1653918326,
0.3141767085,
0.053942997,
-0.5092897415,
-0.4625769258,
0.463811934,
-1.1010109186,
-0.2861512899,
1.1569966078,
-0.1226983815,
-0.4586595893,
0.1486425996,
-0.2297056913,
-0.0816674531,
-0.2884860039,
0.787217021,
0.7719893456,
-0.1750340462,
0.1343226135,
-0.5852963924,
0.1940403581,
0.2701708376,
-0.7545292377,
0.2283779234,
0.6329784393,
0.1829311848,
0.245641306,
0.7279239893,
-0.3348804414,
-0.1479528695,
0.2454521209,
-0.1144695058,
0.5617007613,
-0.2386353761,
-0.0771290511,
0.4667242765,
0.3139764667,
0.0464517102
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02454v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02454v1
|
What is Sentiment Meant to Mean to Language Models?
| 2024-05-03T19:37:37 | 2024-05-03T19:37:37 |
Michael Burnham
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI
|
Sentiment analysis is one of the most widely used techniques in text
analysis. Recent advancements with Large Language Models have made it more
accurate and accessible than ever, allowing researchers to classify text with
only a plain English prompt. However, "sentiment" entails a wide variety of
concepts depending on the domain and tools used. It has been used to mean
emotion, opinions, market movements, or simply a general ``good-bad''
dimension. This raises a question: What exactly are language models doing when
prompted to label documents by sentiment? This paper first overviews how
sentiment is defined across different contexts, highlighting that it is a
confounded measurement construct in that it entails multiple variables, such as
emotional valence and opinion, without disentangling them. I then test three
language models across two data sets with prompts requesting sentiment,
valence, and stance classification. I find that sentiment labels most strongly
correlate with valence labels. I further find that classification improves when
researchers more precisely specify their dimension of interest rather than
using the less well-defined concept of sentiment. I conclude by encouraging
researchers to move beyond "sentiment" when feasible and use a more precise
measurement construct.
|
[
-0.5358184576,
-0.7833411694,
0.5096078515,
0.3586937487,
-0.3688920736,
0.0026535923,
-0.0983716995,
-0.4214005768,
0.2254413813,
0.1274470687,
-0.3188493848,
-0.5528256893,
-0.7798913121,
-0.0191725828,
-0.394603312,
1.5624290705,
0.0972652286,
0.3972906768,
-0.4801389575,
-0.4732813239,
-0.1287220865,
-1.0288017988,
-0.4461829662,
-0.4186883569,
0.9584280252,
0.1205871031,
0.9760184884,
0.0821103305,
0.7455532551,
0.2780041099,
-0.3432805538,
-0.3879243433,
-0.1581175625,
0.2959837317,
-0.1043415964,
-0.5764312148,
-0.6682440042,
0.6492711902,
0.2961840332,
1.1031082869,
0.2174855769,
0.0180375017,
0.1074490771,
0.8076022863,
-0.4556873143,
0.114948757,
-0.0124925878,
0.0771751851,
-0.1410696208,
0.0689764768,
-0.3694790304,
-0.5797210932,
0.4237184823,
-0.0079755401,
0.1166178584,
-0.1342259645,
0.8358931541,
-0.0590250827,
-0.6692711711,
-0.6435009241,
-0.526330173,
1.0981471539,
-0.4609254599,
0.3807885945,
0.1758415252,
0.1360149235,
0.3376368284,
-0.2424383909,
-0.6425141692,
-0.203174755,
-0.05955562,
0.2965911925,
-0.1684994996,
0.2307593971,
0.3503345847,
0.5373415351,
-0.3068958819,
-0.1815575957,
-0.0812964663,
0.0112122009,
0.5850359797,
0.080330953,
0.3617831171,
-0.3480750322,
-0.5108965635,
-0.179571569,
-0.4840687215,
0.3061933219,
0.40394333,
0.6127755046,
-0.2764695883,
0.3882693052,
0.150219053,
0.5402679443,
-0.132744953,
-0.0748955533,
0.3909439743,
-0.035057202,
-0.352722466,
-0.1104191318,
0.8094733357,
0.5797862411,
0.1914902627,
0.1176266819,
-0.550090611,
0.4415230453,
0.1254000068,
-0.6479542851,
-0.1470427364,
0.4501207769,
-0.5732471347,
-0.5548146367,
0.1281622052,
-0.8926632404,
-0.5941126943,
-0.4798839986,
0.2966880798,
-0.0813336298,
-0.4372758567,
0.1863607019,
-0.4511814415,
0.2715836763,
0.2488311231,
-0.7920649052,
0.1859446913,
0.9205003977,
0.6669124961,
0.0767509863,
-0.1308459342,
-0.2923885584,
-0.6210455298,
-0.5161435008,
0.815444231,
-0.6974515319,
-0.762162447,
0.0868084058,
-0.0244880784,
0.0925976858,
-0.1558144093,
0.6182507873,
-0.4228143096,
0.5481305718,
-0.6443895698,
-0.7103433609,
-0.4750926197,
0.6405975223,
-0.5426347256,
0.8828210831,
0.1297954172,
-0.7312779427,
0.3165273964,
-0.4063928425,
-0.3220254779,
-0.1693224758,
0.1408242583,
-0.2618329823,
0.6047737598,
-0.5366578102,
0.6113799214,
-0.4622496963,
0.1469937116,
-0.5236279964,
0.0175043885,
0.8601338267,
-0.2081073374,
0.5164396167,
0.2200394273,
0.1203379408,
-0.1036952436,
-0.5255746245,
-0.1123880818,
-0.2740349472,
-0.2956777215,
-0.9193547964,
0.1752082855,
0.0939605981,
0.1955861449,
0.3332580626,
-0.6609021425,
0.1897204965,
-0.7037084699,
0.1480149627,
0.5069980025,
0.0002932257,
0.7448758483,
0.06509047,
0.6805326939,
0.1391352862,
0.2775103748,
-0.0311557613,
-0.4545259774,
-0.7150453925,
-0.0180328377,
0.276437223,
0.3541156054,
0.1132925749,
0.1439378709,
-0.0160591863,
-0.4980962276,
-0.4662517309,
-0.1463330686,
0.2582274079,
0.5073482394,
0.189486891,
-0.1913855821,
-0.3665522635,
-0.809065938,
-0.3582068086,
-0.4812943637,
0.4592800438,
-0.0377395675,
0.3985906541,
-0.2509859502,
0.645827651,
-0.4920535386,
0.0695737675,
-0.2094038129,
0.6307321191,
0.2656801045,
0.0356097519,
0.5687583685,
-0.8446460366,
-0.4387779832,
0.0746814087,
-0.7746882439,
-0.0362312198,
0.0137693519,
-0.068591401,
0.38425529,
0.337168932,
-0.5880660415,
0.0429147556,
0.6801843643,
-0.3064635098,
0.4946219921,
0.225236252,
0.0768216997,
-0.9403281808,
-0.2111452818,
0.3832642436,
0.0233279299,
-0.8105485439,
0.2313732505,
-0.0917737857,
-0.0347577706,
-0.5843882561,
0.6579167247,
-0.141427204,
0.2469010502,
-0.4708300531,
0.0313655324,
0.4839498699,
-0.0328403264,
-0.1266094893,
0.3939990103,
0.810895741,
-0.6018013358,
0.5499736667,
0.2050304115,
0.104318589,
0.9624962211,
-0.2736636698,
0.1263004094,
-0.3962529004,
-0.1087009534,
-1.0423835516,
-0.075886637,
0.2101472169,
-0.7198920846,
0.1916555464,
-0.0969368145,
-0.2751512825,
-0.1233333275,
-0.3823265135,
0.1855554283,
0.2149889618,
-0.3400689065,
0.7289210558,
0.5946620107,
-0.1419166476,
-0.5056384802,
-0.7837209702,
-0.0390295088,
-0.5186501741,
-0.3767510056,
-0.086591512,
-0.0514979102,
-0.8724334836,
-0.068779476,
0.0165842716,
-0.2063886821,
0.1888258904,
0.3450314403,
0.3801132143,
-0.1868900955,
0.7671704888,
-0.0640987083,
-0.1628848463,
0.3481290042,
0.0887225866,
0.3041311502,
-0.2847092748,
0.0440030172,
-0.0004211153,
0.7057417631,
0.8277215362,
-0.1356942207,
0.789173305,
0.4339815974,
-0.2949789166,
-0.2373514175,
-0.1934966743,
0.0605150759,
-0.36109519,
0.0951568708,
-0.3570107222,
-0.7333001494,
0.4424675107,
0.012497114,
-0.2435792834,
0.4019814134,
0.5133205652,
-0.624481678,
1.3065769672,
0.7233911157,
-0.4522813559,
0.2067999244,
-0.042422168,
0.7350536585,
-0.6077242494,
-0.1122549176,
-0.9279039502,
-0.1741075218,
-0.7136367559,
-0.263006568,
0.1514698118,
0.1581960171,
0.0050410614,
-0.0993853509,
-0.3870477974,
0.3046861589,
0.1794413328,
-0.2904295623,
-0.0315109044,
-0.2550357282,
0.0930762514,
-0.2890286148,
-0.1093161628,
-0.8633949757,
0.6413861513,
0.4221729338,
0.7446872592,
-0.0457304306,
0.6497951746,
0.3759273589,
0.462739259,
-1.4186681509,
0.6668069959,
-0.4139717817,
-0.5819824338,
0.0447935723,
-0.0717102662,
-0.6355327964,
0.2736605704,
-0.2727259099,
-0.3633249104,
0.2632653415,
0.21097444,
-0.113899976,
0.0741319656,
-0.6842235923,
0.8583719134,
-0.368217051,
-0.0527064875,
-0.2282493562,
-0.3167391717,
0.2246602029,
0.0501497649,
0.405813545,
-0.3542411923,
0.1485502571,
0.5985816717,
-0.316215694,
0.8893345594,
-0.3948450685,
-0.3205075264,
0.4142454267,
0.1820522547,
0.2008386999,
-0.3917038739,
-0.3056070805,
-0.0080389949,
0.234438315,
-0.1050865501,
-0.7497276664,
0.5318644643,
-0.7571716309,
-0.2877589166,
-0.6287052035,
-0.3276735842,
-0.3234309852,
-0.2522535622,
0.148096621,
0.5541947484,
-0.5188739896,
0.1574225724,
0.6068023443,
-0.3866790831,
0.064720504,
0.3512191772,
-0.4044627845,
0.0610329807,
1.1963788271,
0.0414380804,
0.1860658228,
0.7099192142,
0.5550373197,
-0.5449460745,
-0.0221878104,
0.1429398805,
0.1711635143,
-1.0908252001,
-0.058671739,
-0.6322976947,
0.1279425025,
-0.2782408595,
-0.1669707894,
-0.2123878449,
-0.4022315145,
-0.3171539903,
-0.4533808231,
0.3263611197,
0.6237925887,
0.0341966599,
0.411370486,
-0.9102964997,
0.008313573,
0.2644341588,
0.2280970663,
-0.1706396043,
-0.2553447485,
-0.278788805,
-0.1137618273,
-0.1578261852,
-1.2282828093,
0.5920436382,
0.0658403635,
0.3428850472,
0.323503077,
-0.0984575152,
0.1608000696,
-0.0139172729,
0.9083672762,
0.3588974774,
-1.1495269537,
0.5485010743,
-0.4671707451,
0.1034283713,
0.3494512737,
0.5039038062,
-0.9465619326,
-0.552510798,
-0.3652502596,
-0.7018290162,
0.1605851948,
-0.5586926937,
0.7170784473,
-0.4126642644,
0.1906483173,
0.3337119818,
0.3361761272,
-0.7586398721,
-0.1036186218,
-0.3611082435,
-0.5222337842,
-0.2047321349,
-0.4966962636,
-0.1814742684,
-0.0863325968,
0.4146592319,
-0.1027005687,
0.3024885058,
-0.1858929545,
-0.1966937035,
-0.0994019285,
0.5930452943,
0.0355478637,
0.2910889983,
-0.0768468156,
0.2992990315,
-0.1762213856,
-0.0998951718,
0.1360721737,
-0.2950337231,
-0.167145744,
0.0439696237,
0.0981509611,
0.8624186516,
0.0519027337,
-0.1494971663,
0.5907765627,
0.0598479547,
-0.0842090249,
-0.0432728194,
-0.0738017112,
0.0626313239,
0.0789106861,
0.0364014842,
0.0716141537,
0.3452695012,
-0.8682681918,
-0.2304055393,
0.5573894978,
-0.7784001231,
-0.6825445294,
0.1870768815,
0.3210827112,
-0.0066899327,
0.3865716159,
-0.1387459934,
-0.7092325091,
0.4880816638,
0.1370753944,
0.9691029191,
-0.2223142385,
0.6156929731,
0.3733587563,
0.0152086951,
-0.1869650036,
0.4420966506,
0.2769963741,
-1.0682946444,
-0.1791262329,
-0.9467992187,
-0.623889327,
-0.1217083186,
-0.8827599287,
0.1836025268,
-0.3050189614,
-0.555367291,
0.1427613646,
-0.1103271469,
-0.5387198329,
0.8352407813,
0.3969364464,
0.7948347926,
-1.2168465853,
0.4898731112,
1.1213554144,
-0.5540775061,
-0.7722273469,
-0.0962431952,
0.4136746824,
-0.1796387434,
0.5790759325,
0.3090872765,
-0.3535735607,
-0.342561096,
-0.8667904139,
-0.4119053483,
0.1117405817,
-0.176495716,
-0.2947534919,
0.2356237322,
0.0097777229,
0.9677950144,
-0.4020020962,
0.082543008,
0.5090059638,
0.489723742,
-0.2180154026,
-0.2934484184,
-0.3023311794,
-0.4126466513,
-0.222873047,
0.1990833879,
-0.5084754229,
0.9644918442,
0.113013193,
-0.077075094,
-0.1207534969,
0.5264130831,
-0.1179642305,
0.1858433038,
0.4918532073,
0.2763027549,
1.0176501274,
-0.4431938231,
1.2185206413,
-0.3662815392,
0.5030585527,
0.4434453547,
-0.3412192762,
0.8473252654,
0.4199840128,
-0.2007884085,
0.6648705006,
0.6777125597,
0.0315079875,
0.4812399745,
0.1121815443,
-0.3925932944,
-0.3867135346,
-0.1873671114,
-0.10844969,
0.3836224377,
0.5294624567,
-0.2502013147,
0.0006627374,
0.2199470699,
0.1237199828,
0.1792133898,
-0.3420101404,
0.7694807053,
0.462629348,
-0.695422709,
-0.1141932234,
0.0543790162,
0.5189017057,
-0.4776813686,
0.2649686933,
-0.4056756794,
0.1752682775,
-0.3113152087,
-1.2020632029,
0.3901050091,
0.1728518009,
-0.5770656466,
-0.3941384554,
0.6639466286,
-0.2149267346,
-0.5592750907,
0.5066689849,
0.7749126554,
0.3036996424,
0.0259912573,
-0.6543998122,
0.2165711075,
-0.2287671715,
-0.3804754913,
0.4428629577,
0.628380537,
0.0398630649,
0.4425235987,
0.3383716047,
0.2368431836,
-0.2408374548,
0.5908648372,
0.6109363437,
-0.9382775426,
-0.3589188159,
-0.8581090569,
0.7126896977,
0.2052073926,
-0.3420533836,
0.7462123632,
0.325615257,
0.5038702488,
0.0273969434,
1.0120537281,
0.0220614783,
0.6630221605,
-0.2271948904,
0.4368740916,
-0.6439301968,
0.1388746798,
-0.5795083046,
-0.7588087916,
-0.4640077949,
0.7443974018,
-0.4742177129,
-0.1205674857,
0.6128655076,
0.6122505665,
0.1893545836,
0.2045999914,
0.2358180732,
0.1488450319,
0.2881178558,
0.1050669551,
1.2789444923,
-0.1036569774,
0.1044522822,
-0.0781055242,
0.0084712943,
-0.0184491221,
-0.6218588352,
-0.7801792026,
-0.6117121577,
-0.553142488,
-0.4047085047,
-0.0808455348,
0.7852082253,
0.4492881894,
-0.7110887766,
-0.3565093279,
0.2172253877,
0.1220454127,
0.0457995571,
-0.2371264845,
0.089504458,
-0.6737282276,
-0.819584012,
0.0520880781,
0.3969475925,
0.1011290625,
-0.462824434,
0.0429691151,
0.2166435272,
0.3240214288,
0.7281787992,
0.1005454063,
-0.4693530202,
-0.4268396199,
0.1625562608,
-0.4822083116,
0.1855417937,
0.6235876083,
-0.4058343172,
0.6550680995,
0.7126006484,
0.0719220936,
-0.0539223775,
0.1282503307,
0.6537914872,
-0.8472138643,
-0.0188375395,
0.1984645128,
0.3816924989,
0.6985422969,
-0.2430824935,
0.151398614,
0.1941665858,
-0.3865764439,
-0.8847509623,
0.4070582092,
-0.8901245594,
-0.3233238161,
0.972228229,
0.0820737481,
-0.1833499968,
0.106169872,
-0.0970122293,
0.0802736431,
-0.3214623332,
0.6472871304,
1.0341566801,
-0.0258952901,
-0.2929288149,
-0.373634845,
0.382419914,
0.2094702125,
-0.6162567139,
0.0294321459,
0.544918716,
0.1213943437,
0.3939397931,
0.5543912649,
-0.2359631509,
-0.0062316488,
-0.1899808198,
0.2038054317,
0.6855539083,
-0.2972810864,
-0.5637985468,
0.3889093697,
0.1964026541,
-0.0068407222
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2406.02566v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2406.02566v1
|
Combining X-Vectors and Bayesian Batch Active Learning: Two-Stage Active Learning Pipeline for Speech Recognition
| 2024-05-03T19:24:41 | 2024-05-03T19:24:41 |
Ognjen Kundacina, Vladimir Vincan, Dragisa Miskovic
|
eess.AS
|
eess.AS, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Emphasizing a data-centric AI approach, this paper introduces a novel
two-stage active learning (AL) pipeline for automatic speech recognition (ASR),
combining unsupervised and supervised AL methods. The first stage utilizes
unsupervised AL by using x-vectors clustering for diverse sample selection from
unlabeled speech data, thus establishing a robust initial dataset for the
subsequent supervised AL. The second stage incorporates a supervised AL
strategy, with a batch AL method specifically developed for ASR, aimed at
selecting diverse and informative batches of samples. Here, sample diversity is
also achieved using x-vectors clustering, while the most informative samples
are identified using a Bayesian AL method tailored for ASR with an adaptation
of Monte Carlo dropout to approximate Bayesian inference. This approach enables
precise uncertainty estimation, thereby enhancing ASR model training with
significantly reduced data requirements. Our method has shown superior
performance compared to competing methods on homogeneous, heterogeneous, and
OOD test sets, demonstrating that strategic sample selection and innovative
Bayesian modeling can substantially optimize both labeling effort and data
utilization in deep learning-based ASR applications.
|
[
-0.0174554773,
-0.5357127786,
-0.0102259861,
-0.3046321869,
-0.205887422,
0.3732122183,
-0.0374748111,
-0.2054708451,
-0.1825499684,
0.2503039837,
-0.3682212234,
-0.3876927495,
-0.5222121477,
-0.5219932199,
-0.7478837967,
0.5206375122,
-0.0063760951,
0.3979848623,
0.2900893092,
-0.2154079378,
-0.310795188,
-0.3015004694,
-1.216979146,
-0.1836069971,
0.4033004642,
0.4041925669,
0.4109348357,
0.8735078573,
0.330187887,
0.2900148034,
-0.0465359427,
0.0064895311,
0.1869978309,
0.5136300921,
0.008885717,
-0.5013406277,
-0.3613616824,
0.0592408106,
0.9169445038,
0.8014113903,
-0.2901984453,
0.1647884399,
-0.1087448075,
0.3456504047,
-0.7079749107,
0.1911578923,
-0.8309652805,
0.2792680562,
-0.2041932046,
0.2773100138,
0.0040143155,
0.0515733436,
0.1055688411,
-0.4836306274,
0.4633007944,
-0.0430367291,
0.3555737436,
0.5757539868,
-0.3767686784,
-0.4222631752,
-0.9734594822,
0.9193279147,
-0.4034529626,
0.6467140317,
0.2034346312,
0.5939887762,
0.2174969465,
-1.0173934698,
-0.669800818,
0.066446133,
0.5736606121,
0.1567288488,
-0.5126247406,
0.0096139545,
0.0226174351,
0.4356076717,
-0.5467752218,
0.3885166347,
-0.7169311047,
-0.2137578577,
0.7139233947,
-0.3949844241,
-0.0046021356,
0.2526319325,
-0.3461423516,
-0.4328745008,
-0.419254303,
0.4189044535,
0.1302400976,
0.9020344615,
0.2520180345,
0.6090970039,
0.0773675814,
0.576918602,
0.0798474029,
-0.076056622,
0.4950801432,
0.0126957716,
-0.2475035936,
0.6162796021,
0.7947360873,
-0.2680261731,
-0.090631932,
-0.0624858811,
-0.4080897868,
0.5735242963,
0.342983067,
-0.3038574457,
-0.3310556114,
0.3961799145,
-0.220110178,
-0.3108917475,
0.2688470185,
-0.3677690625,
-0.353046149,
-0.369772017,
0.7331671119,
-0.0502998903,
-0.0978175104,
-0.0796449855,
-0.0345346592,
0.0036454697,
0.2690956295,
-0.406822592,
0.4756736755,
0.5195908546,
0.5759726763,
-0.4864858389,
0.0291946679,
-1.1749463081,
0.2601726055,
-0.4945212007,
0.6031665206,
-0.586088419,
-0.3395144045,
-0.1790227741,
-0.0495010354,
-0.0337186083,
-0.6495428085,
0.7682639956,
-0.3549695015,
0.0679911003,
0.166856721,
-0.350171715,
-0.5215852261,
-0.346444577,
-0.6261469722,
0.9554344416,
-0.253716141,
-0.2015422881,
0.7653488517,
-0.5169606805,
-0.6489757895,
0.0583787188,
-0.576851964,
-0.8570366502,
-0.0345022343,
0.2248448282,
0.5898559093,
-0.0023386728,
0.0034206235,
-0.1556896418,
-0.0958053246,
0.2047002017,
-0.5439515114,
0.6134472489,
0.3958126605,
-0.6028876901,
0.4439791739,
-1.24348557,
0.0790373608,
-0.3023186624,
-0.4699055851,
-0.1090770438,
0.2103682756,
-0.012080973,
0.3410481215,
-0.1571916938,
-0.7139825225,
-0.0467482954,
-0.1260629296,
0.3740631938,
0.4692360163,
-0.1327128112,
0.6206551194,
-0.07113415,
0.4699515998,
0.1146201193,
0.0181627125,
0.0336132161,
-0.5849274397,
-0.797783792,
-0.6673460007,
0.3628112972,
0.8445683122,
-0.4806378782,
0.6242769361,
0.1180177554,
-0.4605237544,
-0.793987751,
0.1797706932,
0.5487639308,
0.4443956017,
0.5088040829,
-0.3992774189,
-0.5505506396,
-0.4178988636,
0.0075845276,
-0.3875927329,
-0.3030443788,
0.258997798,
-0.0573928952,
-0.2643277645,
0.7573667765,
-0.2283446044,
-0.5762305856,
-0.2307076156,
0.3632512987,
0.1921001971,
0.5136054158,
0.079448849,
-0.8217833638,
-0.460352391,
0.1640462726,
-0.3713340759,
0.0533023961,
0.1037546694,
0.140341416,
0.0711304769,
0.4716393948,
-0.2209326625,
0.7064322233,
0.4651359618,
-0.129163757,
-0.3076451123,
0.0553776659,
-0.0316334181,
-0.7723545432,
-0.0535385646,
0.0882096589,
-0.0104749221,
-0.7999657393,
-0.4445131123,
0.1738585383,
-0.3466494679,
-0.4445604086,
0.4107729793,
-0.543640852,
-0.2738264501,
-0.4417046309,
-0.2251552939,
-0.2155997604,
0.2920541763,
0.2094761878,
0.4760804772,
1.0469032526,
-0.6677026749,
0.4940520227,
0.2868708968,
-0.1958025694,
-0.1269060224,
-0.6310433149,
0.1236786991,
-0.1146516725,
0.1861507446,
-1.2312067747,
0.0455442332,
0.3213357329,
-0.7693955302,
0.6721271873,
-0.3237840831,
-0.1785874963,
-0.3559378386,
0.117615141,
0.3044315875,
0.7076724768,
-0.3950181603,
0.6217077374,
0.6272112131,
-0.3789108396,
-0.5306507349,
-0.8250773549,
-0.275342375,
-0.0695398077,
-0.1070502624,
0.2844574749,
0.2426499128,
-0.2138957083,
-0.1354581416,
-0.5423257351,
-0.3430989981,
-0.1882826686,
0.5968561769,
0.1079249606,
0.0153707592,
-0.0218749102,
0.3463665843,
-0.169841513,
-0.0355904475,
-0.3435883522,
0.1297234446,
0.3595791459,
-0.715482235,
-0.634315908,
0.4253019691,
0.3959176838,
-0.4748556912,
0.2925702035,
0.9680420756,
-0.5682086349,
-0.3776719868,
-0.3519587815,
-0.1677397937,
-0.40361619,
0.2486412078,
-0.1224719286,
-0.7274906635,
0.2317076772,
0.3064389825,
0.4391438961,
0.3318939209,
0.5384770632,
-0.0041760285,
1.1411246061,
0.2511893511,
-0.1256894022,
0.6122583747,
-0.5049219728,
0.3198669553,
-0.5029405355,
-0.3327430785,
-0.4288046956,
-0.3840895295,
-0.2981615067,
-0.883505106,
0.419498086,
-0.1252219826,
-0.3022843897,
-0.1164992526,
-0.4496994913,
-0.2197573483,
0.9272608757,
0.0194599815,
0.0882625729,
0.2914889157,
0.1170709059,
0.2919513583,
-0.8272675872,
-0.3429763913,
1.2429773808,
0.3951405287,
0.8639478087,
0.1499927342,
0.2653879225,
0.478541553,
-0.3130192757,
-1.1146407127,
0.4538474381,
-0.3499524593,
-0.68792665,
-0.5096769929,
-0.4082512259,
-1.1506842375,
0.0899568126,
-0.2341152877,
-0.3125394583,
0.5099591017,
0.2497677952,
-0.8479498625,
0.3420849144,
-0.5283372402,
0.3101593852,
-0.2044035643,
-0.2628982663,
-0.1112798154,
-0.9211077094,
-0.1200732589,
-0.2816212475,
0.1548337191,
-0.0549009889,
-0.1734404415,
1.135987401,
-0.0827097893,
0.7312763333,
-0.5318783522,
0.1515155584,
0.6316652298,
-0.3731799722,
0.2786518633,
0.0768249854,
-0.199979201,
0.0320615806,
-0.3146580458,
-0.2577451169,
-0.5052544475,
0.4546753764,
-0.9216563106,
-0.0222142786,
-0.6577470303,
-0.4978531599,
-0.3871324956,
0.0469668098,
0.0027139361,
0.6717771888,
0.1185947806,
0.2679419518,
0.7943557501,
-0.0472560637,
0.5100238323,
0.5753478408,
0.1272024214,
-0.6478053927,
0.8663734198,
0.4013834,
0.0648109615,
0.4678298533,
-0.039468497,
-0.3147718012,
-0.8183377981,
-0.2911771238,
-0.0803668872,
-0.3517844975,
-0.2238335907,
-0.7546842098,
-0.4738238454,
-0.6172545552,
0.0864484608,
-0.6232869625,
-0.7193216085,
-0.4543662071,
-0.0848297626,
0.1887686849,
0.4915218949,
-0.2848269641,
0.4881940186,
-0.6071540713,
0.667568922,
0.708751142,
-0.0139449323,
-0.1085517332,
-0.8294653296,
-0.1991773397,
0.1849486381,
-0.1904408783,
-0.6031736732,
0.4431359172,
0.7021994591,
0.9909995794,
0.8393912911,
0.1393163651,
0.3797507882,
-0.5333560705,
0.4877609909,
0.1662020236,
-0.652331233,
0.8603711128,
-0.1229725033,
0.0631257072,
0.4805611372,
0.5560065508,
0.0656442493,
-0.0588813759,
-0.4890359342,
-1.0671910048,
0.7016732097,
0.201351881,
-0.2892146707,
0.1793442219,
0.3111403286,
0.1362045705,
0.3695289195,
-0.2087685168,
-0.4546934664,
-0.1443142891,
-0.2344547659,
-0.2662699521,
0.0466668122,
-0.2355009317,
-0.5162681341,
0.9664216042,
0.0380185917,
0.3402125537,
-0.1508323103,
0.0240841806,
-0.2920977175,
0.0903937146,
-0.0049873427,
0.382470578,
-0.2698140144,
0.003404761,
-0.0229580812,
-0.7050941586,
0.357855469,
0.5505619049,
-0.0341488272,
0.0856278017,
0.1744844913,
1.1844038963,
-0.0079130298,
-0.6142825484,
0.5139328837,
-0.1481096148,
-0.2868405282,
-0.5181328654,
0.3689982295,
-0.4964465201,
0.6218308806,
0.9495443702,
0.3712145388,
0.3895532787,
-0.6488841772,
0.4305418134,
0.396448791,
-0.8801420927,
-0.2080808133,
0.8588995337,
0.1384965628,
-0.2696927786,
0.5512832999,
-0.2059201002,
-0.3080441356,
0.2972613573,
0.1553910524,
0.8182046413,
-0.783888638,
0.0213195514,
0.2323194295,
-0.0699838251,
-0.0840207487,
0.4951957166,
-0.2165606767,
-0.7385547757,
-0.336671114,
-0.5460889935,
-0.4971682131,
-0.0056821876,
-1.136063695,
0.4056982696,
-0.4446970224,
-0.1720625907,
0.033454448,
0.2634860873,
-0.3014712334,
0.6486109495,
0.3987202346,
0.519067347,
-1.0107359886,
1.0591602325,
1.0162155628,
-0.0843645781,
-0.7416441441,
-0.0675071925,
0.0826096088,
-0.8853296638,
0.1079506874,
0.0028306453,
0.0585062616,
0.2386053056,
-0.17634736,
-0.970087111,
1.2052663565,
-0.1005562171,
-0.6789194942,
0.1445047259,
-0.2932904661,
0.2024040073,
-0.19720456,
-0.2476429045,
0.3976224363,
-0.005310873,
0.8357723355,
-0.6753923893,
-0.3787701726,
-0.3946141899,
-0.204109937,
0.2216228843,
-0.2678412199,
0.6853855848,
-0.2383715361,
-0.0955993682,
-0.1536502242,
1.1284375191,
0.6415272355,
0.6173442006,
0.8208268285,
0.4817689359,
0.9234300852,
0.0405800417,
0.3148722947,
-0.1163438484,
-0.1740706414,
0.9895006418,
-0.324885726,
1.1783666611,
0.2721813023,
-0.3744767904,
0.1386970282,
0.5841106176,
-0.1210960448,
0.7934095263,
0.1741695404,
-0.6444820762,
-0.1059973389,
0.1814130694,
-0.2573334277,
0.6283499002,
0.559794426,
-0.3914984763,
0.2270090729,
0.4099364579,
0.0094399527,
-0.230998069,
-0.7153689265,
0.7756187916,
0.0237846486,
-0.4045474231,
0.2107700855,
-0.1351381093,
0.5651897788,
-0.6270074844,
0.0712587759,
0.2434286177,
0.347946465,
-0.2211165279,
-0.6554322839,
0.220846042,
0.1503550708,
-0.2601545751,
-0.2190130949,
0.569293499,
-0.5928459167,
-0.9603085518,
0.0567784533,
0.5128984451,
0.2003993392,
-0.2386111468,
-0.6576231718,
0.2443924844,
0.0046441914,
-0.0898970664,
0.103098467,
0.3597469032,
-0.2417532653,
0.6280354857,
0.6913903356,
0.2190834731,
0.4169693887,
0.2257837951,
0.9116654992,
-0.2276616544,
-0.419008702,
-0.2658339143,
0.7108289003,
0.2135908157,
0.0709099993,
0.6255584359,
0.6383190751,
0.5396572351,
0.4163047075,
1.1602156162,
-0.0747232437,
1.1346452236,
-0.1629831791,
0.5882169008,
-0.4246234,
0.2865187526,
-0.225940153,
-0.6951562762,
-0.515372932,
0.9926199317,
-0.0982198566,
0.3150581121,
0.276432991,
0.6709504128,
-0.2510544062,
-0.1572040021,
0.3042460978,
0.1527314186,
0.1450357884,
0.1709600836,
0.5842726827,
-0.6121174097,
0.5883594751,
-0.3056154549,
-0.5932851434,
0.1685946435,
-0.2971606553,
-0.7448479533,
-0.8138142228,
-0.7747581005,
-0.1086178422,
0.1506780386,
0.8857037425,
0.8437208533,
-1.0880076885,
-0.3117642403,
-0.2142232656,
-0.3748307228,
-0.4382426739,
-0.1071933284,
0.3107903302,
-0.1375293285,
-0.8734265566,
0.904086411,
0.0529659465,
0.1257376075,
-0.1871190071,
0.0187117215,
-0.2561841011,
0.0169504154,
0.4438137114,
0.3718433976,
-0.59111619,
0.1979784817,
-0.2680023015,
0.3056136072,
0.0093682539,
0.5456732512,
-0.9725084901,
0.5164519548,
0.4644623995,
0.5062035322,
0.5847497582,
0.0793569013,
0.6449779272,
-0.7031278014,
0.2226304412,
0.535399735,
0.0990497172,
0.3930758238,
0.0305267368,
0.40299505,
0.0104444651,
-0.5648859143,
-0.9951804876,
0.0100937774,
-1.2730642557,
-0.0901175812,
1.2135856152,
-0.1912618876,
0.098960124,
-0.2940048873,
-0.1553777158,
0.846247375,
-0.6471612453,
0.475892216,
-0.0921176225,
-0.4601712227,
-0.3697189391,
-0.554035306,
0.3552635014,
0.0538586602,
-0.3085505366,
-0.2801254392,
0.4259332418,
0.0205986407,
-0.0196134616,
0.2343444675,
0.0826129019,
0.2219574153,
-0.0626398474,
0.1643568873,
-0.0048468853,
-0.6232314706,
-0.6354253888,
0.2426319271,
0.0671808273,
-0.8980901241
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02429v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02429v1
|
CALRec: Contrastive Alignment of Generative LLMs For Sequential Recommendation
| 2024-05-03T18:51:19 | 2024-05-03T18:51:19 |
Yaoyiran Li, Xiang Zhai, Moustafa Alzantot, Keyi Yu, Ivan Vulić, Anna Korhonen, Mohamed Hammad
|
cs.IR
|
cs.IR, cs.AI, cs.CL, cs.LG
|
Traditional recommender systems such as matrix factorization methods rely on
learning a shared dense embedding space to represent both items and user
preferences. Sequence models such as RNN, GRUs, and, recently, Transformers
have also excelled in the task of sequential recommendation. This task requires
understanding the sequential structure present in users' historical
interactions to predict the next item they may like. Building upon the success
of Large Language Models (LLMs) in a variety of tasks, researchers have
recently explored using LLMs that are pretrained on vast corpora of text for
sequential recommendation. To use LLMs in sequential recommendations, both the
history of user interactions and the model's prediction of the next item are
expressed in text form. We propose CALRec, a two-stage LLM finetuning framework
that finetunes a pretrained LLM in a two-tower fashion using a mixture of two
contrastive losses and a language modeling loss: the LLM is first finetuned on
a data mixture from multiple domains followed by another round of target domain
finetuning. Our model significantly outperforms many state-of-the-art baselines
(+37% in Recall@1 and +24% in NDCG@10) and systematic ablation studies reveal
that (i) both stages of finetuning are crucial, and, when combined, we achieve
improved performance, and (ii) contrastive alignment is effective among the
target domains explored in our experiments.
|
[
-0.343442142,
-0.471847862,
0.4520021975,
0.2507688701,
-0.1720539629,
0.0824611336,
-0.1161324307,
-0.1042682379,
0.0522125214,
0.6657814384,
-0.6456840634,
-0.5286514759,
-0.3227627277,
-0.0375768095,
-0.4727369845,
1.1804171801,
-0.2249772698,
0.2718976736,
-0.2518143654,
-0.1573973149,
-0.7543556094,
-0.2063649893,
-0.5806269646,
-0.8153296709,
0.7896889448,
0.7513846159,
0.6722493172,
0.4044227898,
0.5704874396,
0.2877127528,
0.1262939274,
0.2992618084,
-0.8698045015,
0.2965452373,
-0.1496557444,
-0.4872489572,
-0.2409511954,
-0.1654246151,
0.5638091564,
0.7407580018,
-0.3171595633,
-0.1339472383,
0.4025666118,
0.9214859009,
-0.4960488975,
-0.2841773331,
-0.5214655995,
-0.0411603637,
-0.1314819157,
-0.3670506477,
-0.5815811753,
-0.5845352411,
0.3243021071,
-0.5609098077,
0.3064056337,
0.1573430002,
0.5773952603,
0.2430169433,
-0.3941756189,
-0.1441364437,
-0.8743392229,
0.7366943359,
-0.3558974862,
0.4847121239,
0.434769392,
0.2267963886,
-0.2289334387,
-0.7762986422,
-0.4104553163,
-0.1413368136,
-0.0325205587,
0.1215692237,
0.0225467794,
-0.0847840682,
0.007206216,
0.5577036142,
-0.7668741345,
0.4105331898,
-0.1570384502,
-0.1893381625,
0.2597006857,
0.3007960021,
0.0579156056,
0.2959722281,
-0.6650905013,
-0.1588446051,
-0.9770087004,
-0.2464274466,
0.4076625705,
0.195107013,
-0.2783747911,
0.6965763569,
0.0329249874,
0.5112990141,
0.4086819589,
0.1569753885,
0.0388012789,
-0.5710910559,
-0.0909192264,
0.1703643799,
0.8200444579,
0.6177251935,
0.521954,
-0.0048084003,
-0.0816556513,
0.1035841703,
0.3508488536,
-1.0133709908,
-0.3992925584,
-0.0609001629,
-0.3207345009,
-0.1965896189,
0.070859842,
-0.4180112481,
-0.5973322392,
-0.5122981071,
0.2088056952,
-0.3963294625,
0.2648802102,
0.0059191459,
0.2598554194,
0.0717146695,
0.3639538884,
-1.0790697336,
0.6230682731,
0.6616443992,
0.9242159128,
-0.2528059781,
-0.3090699613,
-0.5624780655,
-0.1294353008,
-0.3475968838,
0.8731920719,
-0.5117416382,
-0.5044757128,
0.1946946681,
-0.0625345111,
0.1572714448,
-0.6065297127,
0.5051755309,
-0.7854853272,
0.2018562108,
-0.1078244001,
-0.567926228,
-0.2220838815,
0.0545519628,
-0.6081236601,
0.9330112934,
0.1371644139,
-0.6143959761,
0.2385245413,
0.1103634015,
-0.5265275836,
-0.0040671448,
-0.2525058687,
-0.2873754203,
0.0703380927,
0.0335994102,
0.4237955511,
-0.5551258922,
0.2775548697,
-0.4081320167,
-0.5174081326,
0.3016142249,
-0.228570208,
0.1758968234,
0.267773658,
-0.0509130731,
0.3582816124,
-0.5595514178,
-0.2571631968,
-0.1132674813,
-0.1981948167,
-0.3330410719,
0.1558252126,
0.1503098756,
0.1732716411,
0.2974381745,
-0.1409337074,
0.1523579955,
-0.5884848237,
0.2642455101,
0.7149736881,
-0.1368499696,
0.8300094008,
-0.6378501058,
0.4703317285,
-0.0333046019,
-0.4016168118,
-0.3726651073,
-0.1189691648,
-0.8367342353,
0.1280020177,
0.3858813047,
0.7070147991,
-0.5661627054,
0.5044623613,
-0.1683692634,
-0.2576200068,
-0.2511154413,
0.3957841098,
0.4578676522,
0.4615782797,
0.302940011,
-0.6069481373,
-0.7242003083,
-0.8940197825,
0.1304412633,
0.0237025786,
-0.0114402045,
0.3033982515,
0.028250685,
-0.4095979929,
0.617752254,
-0.6113842726,
-0.5867835879,
-0.1487460285,
0.2269408405,
0.1827415377,
0.4547592402,
0.2295022905,
-0.4705803692,
-0.4679483473,
0.1704754084,
-0.3505813777,
-0.2366639078,
-0.1482649446,
-0.2616316378,
-0.0622519664,
0.3968290687,
-0.009591857,
0.144395113,
0.5812574625,
-0.1441237926,
0.3355249763,
-0.3414768875,
0.1091342047,
-1.1769841909,
-0.1174852028,
0.2842483819,
-0.2287326157,
-0.5713754296,
-0.3231059611,
0.024121657,
0.1784023494,
-0.0835806504,
0.6364058852,
-0.0906954408,
0.1264931262,
-0.4397942722,
0.2564492226,
-0.0065627624,
0.4199148118,
0.0212876778,
0.7463713288,
0.0875129327,
-0.4947030246,
-0.0626621768,
0.4549894035,
-0.4428245425,
0.6234939694,
-0.5743591785,
0.2344806045,
0.1163061708,
0.5020871162,
-1.2919404507,
0.0858203173,
0.1164896637,
-0.0721269846,
0.2335119098,
-0.036496859,
-0.3196890056,
-0.139087379,
-0.2717713714,
0.8942853808,
0.3544819951,
-0.4997828007,
0.3770280778,
0.1611795574,
-0.430799365,
-0.6366913915,
-0.5949649215,
-0.1663472205,
-0.1202692613,
-0.58423841,
0.7799111009,
-0.3223316073,
-0.0546938106,
-0.3169643283,
-0.101829648,
0.118890807,
-0.1314296722,
0.5381048918,
0.545419991,
-0.2592670023,
-0.0070219752,
-0.0944931209,
-0.2620674372,
-0.264893055,
-0.4939880371,
0.8153868318,
0.0100916773,
-0.1055641025,
-0.5719295144,
0.181664288,
0.3077854514,
-0.0229146536,
0.4358146489,
0.7084494233,
-0.3587334156,
-0.0658688247,
-0.9744595885,
-0.257381171,
-0.4532208741,
0.3328591585,
-0.2644883394,
-1.0329405069,
0.5945780873,
-0.0850336924,
0.0021443795,
0.4404300749,
0.7436549664,
-0.0818775967,
0.9050252438,
0.6476246119,
-0.1675475389,
0.7965602279,
-0.3595705628,
0.0451832004,
-0.8903396726,
-0.3646101654,
-0.4582950771,
-0.510607779,
-0.6545559168,
-0.3357738554,
-0.0603602305,
0.363481015,
-0.50683707,
0.3222433031,
-0.1083015874,
0.4715738297,
0.5131982565,
0.201464802,
0.2486425936,
0.2123348117,
-0.5630144477,
-0.2202569544,
-0.510833621,
-0.4791174531,
0.9628624916,
0.1568570733,
1.0127851963,
0.0396679305,
0.7441912889,
0.1670996249,
0.3261262178,
-0.9494004846,
0.4248862267,
-0.6703711748,
-0.114258185,
-0.0453016236,
-0.3062233925,
-0.8873165846,
0.0391845815,
-0.3209299743,
-0.5191781521,
0.3904075325,
0.2243110389,
-0.5456816554,
-0.0540405288,
-0.417717278,
0.7435819507,
-0.2388156652,
-0.7262064815,
-0.4951492846,
-0.5846171379,
0.3212106526,
-0.1974395066,
-0.0373675488,
-0.019464653,
0.0611898154,
0.71234864,
-0.4668486714,
0.6937329769,
0.2443258464,
-0.1422510743,
0.0868356526,
0.4800962806,
0.65063411,
-0.1251267791,
-0.0239814036,
-0.0803338513,
-0.124039866,
0.0419765674,
-0.5260709524,
1.1845105886,
-0.6711734533,
-0.3192161024,
-0.2633497119,
-0.458255887,
-0.1633498222,
0.290061295,
0.1555297077,
0.6349388361,
-0.4151378274,
0.301818043,
0.5008481741,
-0.0317103863,
0.0081390021,
0.4827159941,
-0.1984190792,
-0.8491836786,
0.9206780791,
-0.2524968088,
0.1564507633,
0.6855842471,
0.221737504,
-0.4709403813,
-0.7152204514,
-0.1257230788,
0.2551660836,
-0.5965377688,
-0.2278784662,
-0.4064250588,
-0.1230775118,
-0.2995972633,
-0.3969779015,
-0.1111711785,
-0.2858205736,
-0.5541058183,
0.0230619516,
0.1038407013,
0.8788808584,
0.0743312687,
0.489231348,
-0.5867919922,
0.4575537145,
0.1264781803,
0.4236812592,
-0.0723354965,
-0.6966357231,
-0.3154738843,
-0.1502973437,
-0.5061279535,
-0.4922518432,
0.3952743709,
0.157512933,
0.28391096,
0.7282440662,
-0.0930437744,
0.8521359563,
-0.9004285336,
0.4268194139,
0.5688746572,
-0.3783593476,
0.3305905163,
-0.1589121968,
0.4513212442,
0.9508552551,
0.4800574481,
-0.6504917741,
-0.0386595912,
-0.2434389442,
-0.8467534184,
0.6379443407,
-0.1292861104,
-0.0484919809,
-0.1133375689,
0.3356283903,
0.3752455711,
-0.0091329087,
-0.3631390631,
-0.3773193955,
0.0799193829,
-0.3630389869,
-0.5095307231,
-0.6376292706,
-0.2004632801,
0.0470718592,
0.5369634032,
0.0065823556,
-0.0410745293,
-0.0326721929,
-0.1850934625,
-0.255215764,
0.181391269,
0.7725248933,
0.4479010999,
-0.300139457,
0.2392461598,
0.0721186399,
-0.4181227684,
0.2176377028,
0.3693439364,
-0.0379292294,
-0.4380994737,
0.149587065,
0.7124112844,
0.7640191317,
-0.3367130458,
0.2667881548,
-0.0347557813,
-0.3038099408,
-0.3239461482,
-0.0758145154,
-0.0391255096,
0.2751007676,
0.1567855328,
0.2375353575,
0.1232452393,
-0.401773721,
0.3369782865,
0.3583398461,
-0.582403183,
-0.1447990239,
0.6003426909,
0.3987956345,
-0.3573858738,
0.7167084813,
0.2612864077,
-0.3044528067,
0.212249279,
0.6628995538,
1.0183047056,
-0.1355346888,
0.0069067003,
0.4665775597,
-0.1073876992,
-0.5249598622,
-0.1217821613,
-0.193568334,
-0.8761377335,
-0.3719428778,
-0.6897500157,
-0.3242535889,
-0.1120198742,
-0.6285023689,
0.380497843,
-0.417327702,
-0.1346292645,
-0.0070422785,
0.1368497312,
-0.8704568148,
-0.0047071027,
0.2124012113,
0.6472061872,
-0.7088111639,
0.7721316218,
0.3890556395,
-0.2680564821,
-0.5550295115,
-0.1867168248,
0.1945638508,
-0.8433094621,
0.7626906037,
0.2100355476,
-0.4360776544,
0.0992333442,
-0.0416288078,
-0.5821083784,
1.2463675737,
0.2399442643,
-1.0927299261,
-0.0077375495,
-0.1580801606,
0.4131942391,
-0.6646515727,
0.3609101176,
0.523994565,
0.1960057914,
0.5730518103,
-0.7723926902,
0.1299643964,
-0.0987003446,
0.0981544629,
0.3336179852,
-0.3258298039,
0.4474909902,
-0.477666229,
-0.3874500692,
0.5769302845,
0.7116507888,
0.3447947204,
0.3491049111,
0.4800181985,
0.6783699393,
0.5970878601,
-0.1036689356,
0.9889216423,
-0.2761244178,
0.0189566929,
1.5316690207,
-0.5060457587,
1.0214666128,
0.3568452299,
-0.246132046,
0.817286551,
0.7794644237,
0.0345424339,
0.5985100865,
0.3032597601,
-0.1936876625,
-0.2378744185,
-0.2263093293,
-0.3895123005,
0.0725702047,
0.2673187256,
-0.4478501678,
-0.0260896534,
-0.1411856115,
-0.3216201961,
0.2665663958,
-0.065488182,
0.9671519995,
0.3298650384,
-0.8676178455,
0.5912678838,
-0.1342088133,
0.7252599597,
-0.6614716649,
-0.1602279693,
-0.4210425615,
0.4058122635,
-0.2749641538,
-0.6520339847,
-0.2083410472,
-0.2291186601,
-0.4260919094,
-0.3083623648,
0.455027014,
-0.7651973963,
-0.4446873665,
0.2449985147,
0.2603521645,
0.0060320105,
0.2569536567,
-0.5699496865,
0.0247439481,
-0.0421665497,
0.1300504953,
0.3644125164,
0.0630288348,
-0.0718244016,
0.6532718539,
0.5912600756,
0.0432436354,
-0.3102471232,
0.73315382,
0.64299649,
-0.6045453548,
-0.3786083162,
-0.8315138817,
0.2930760086,
0.3278122246,
-0.1203151643,
0.5688304901,
0.6585623026,
0.8741267323,
0.1765604466,
0.2908380628,
0.4164990783,
0.1797117889,
-0.6247195005,
0.1905096024,
-0.374578774,
0.6369182467,
0.0078276163,
-1.2239472866,
-0.4593069851,
0.4893539846,
-0.3172440827,
0.2299097627,
0.9250940681,
1.0479178429,
0.125813812,
-0.0221544672,
0.1415751278,
0.1109837219,
0.0039176624,
0.6261724234,
0.9024709463,
-0.3282625973,
0.5505219698,
-0.2859525383,
-0.0890092254,
-0.4740902781,
-0.7040370703,
-0.7522450686,
-0.602238059,
-0.3336326182,
-0.5419835448,
0.0094287619,
1.011336565,
0.4927425086,
-1.0028973818,
-0.5756003261,
-0.2170342803,
0.0833916962,
-0.1269170195,
-0.1634137779,
0.3455542922,
-0.1382675618,
-0.5938808918,
0.4942887425,
0.1926773041,
0.2240181863,
-0.269878,
-0.2954470813,
-0.1876994967,
-0.2752155662,
0.4674376845,
0.1721510142,
-0.8924051523,
-0.1278593689,
-0.1741775125,
-0.3554227948,
0.0119452663,
1.2526643276,
-0.8988916874,
0.5170326829,
0.6171774864,
0.48154369,
0.6435753107,
0.1657665819,
0.9214667082,
-0.4803733528,
-0.0729644373,
0.056888178,
0.4395272136,
0.2788837552,
-0.1472875327,
0.4007974267,
-0.2040460408,
-0.7617622614,
-0.5827447772,
0.2126367092,
-1.2643066645,
0.0592508875,
1.1119166613,
0.1019755825,
0.3469015062,
0.0740060136,
-0.4474828541,
0.1411210001,
-0.3998423219,
0.5192009211,
0.5702107549,
0.0713101178,
0.0020595337,
-0.2834025323,
0.2807531953,
0.6030246615,
-0.2468519211,
0.0014890772,
0.6799026728,
0.1821542978,
-0.0224003959,
0.533826232,
0.0366844498,
0.2053445578,
-0.3708120286,
-0.0479461476,
0.063395068,
-0.4398953915,
-0.6224704981,
0.0940108821,
0.3054676354,
-0.0140679292
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02421v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02421v1
|
What does the Knowledge Neuron Thesis Have to do with Knowledge?
| 2024-05-03T18:34:37 | 2024-05-03T18:34:37 |
Jingcheng Niu, Andrew Liu, Zining Zhu, Gerald Penn
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
We reassess the Knowledge Neuron (KN) Thesis: an interpretation of the
mechanism underlying the ability of large language models to recall facts from
a training corpus. This nascent thesis proposes that facts are recalled from
the training corpus through the MLP weights in a manner resembling key-value
memory, implying in effect that "knowledge" is stored in the network.
Furthermore, by modifying the MLP modules, one can control the language model's
generation of factual information. The plausibility of the KN thesis has been
demonstrated by the success of KN-inspired model editing methods (Dai et al.,
2022; Meng et al., 2022).
We find that this thesis is, at best, an oversimplification. Not only have we
found that we can edit the expression of certain linguistic phenomena using the
same model editing methods but, through a more comprehensive evaluation, we
have found that the KN thesis does not adequately explain the process of
factual expression. While it is possible to argue that the MLP weights store
complex patterns that are interpretable both syntactically and semantically,
these patterns do not constitute "knowledge." To gain a more comprehensive
understanding of the knowledge representation process, we must look beyond the
MLP weights and explore recent models' complex layer structures and attention
mechanisms.
|
[
-0.0944844782,
-0.4093191922,
0.574355185,
-0.0953089222,
0.1887844056,
-0.2427369803,
-0.2560526729,
-0.4252353013,
0.2418971509,
0.3577795625,
-0.0678130984,
-0.2686276138,
-0.624587059,
-0.2729558051,
-0.3826068342,
0.900526762,
0.0432745107,
0.1352324337,
-0.6109939814,
-0.1250916868,
-0.2311066538,
-0.5206975937,
-0.3936520815,
-0.8244324923,
0.7454591393,
0.2058199942,
0.5233793855,
0.5630981326,
0.1716534048,
0.2780592144,
-0.3887384832,
-0.2164796144,
-0.3173952401,
0.057618916,
-0.1445407569,
-0.9959948063,
-0.3130070269,
-0.00164013,
0.667008996,
1.2708818913,
-0.0063607208,
0.0343560502,
0.0578844883,
1.0631878376,
-0.6612210274,
0.3364340961,
-0.6073653102,
0.1149783954,
0.2101860493,
-0.1220497414,
-0.3966631889,
-0.2047917843,
0.5088982582,
-0.5407146215,
0.2866406441,
-0.0371616632,
0.8183975816,
0.0962016508,
-0.4219981134,
-0.1996554583,
-0.5770246387,
0.54346627,
-0.7515090108,
0.1575934887,
0.4207849801,
0.2993270457,
-0.2102848142,
-0.579798758,
-0.7093762159,
-0.424318403,
-0.1918949932,
0.1567655206,
0.0408857837,
0.2609690428,
0.6733734608,
0.071326375,
-0.2790765464,
-0.1900990456,
-0.6517192721,
-0.3703113496,
0.3407994509,
-0.0512969159,
0.3277797699,
-0.3792161942,
-0.4107200503,
0.1000213474,
-0.5758379698,
0.1099216565,
0.4776450694,
-0.024059562,
0.0909266174,
0.6864619851,
-0.3942219913,
0.8821591139,
-0.3490041494,
-0.1107686237,
0.136821419,
0.3336614072,
-0.255272001,
0.5051860809,
0.5658141375,
0.5189833045,
0.5107486248,
-0.4702017605,
-0.0182840079,
0.0507166535,
0.6807206273,
-0.4193134308,
-0.5219349265,
0.0173367187,
-0.5920544267,
-0.4200808108,
-0.1935488284,
-0.3573378325,
-0.3612597883,
-0.5565484166,
0.7201973796,
-0.6010518074,
-0.4345829189,
0.2568044364,
-0.6375187635,
-0.0607440285,
0.288523972,
-1.0016026497,
0.3182079196,
0.5941181779,
0.6301507354,
-0.1217539385,
-0.5957997441,
0.5299577713,
0.3170606196,
-0.5916334987,
0.6376591325,
-0.4074902236,
0.0313270092,
-0.0407045707,
-0.0722088516,
-0.2217027992,
-0.5539759994,
0.1131447405,
-0.9610010386,
-0.0089152502,
-0.8752100468,
-1.0188164711,
-0.5963120461,
0.205847159,
-0.5465014577,
0.4683805108,
-0.0200861674,
-0.9445778131,
0.583768487,
-0.6304337382,
-0.3311877549,
-0.3378278315,
-0.021030983,
0.1363275051,
0.3159966469,
-0.4223640561,
0.4539761245,
-0.1074504331,
0.1714317203,
-0.5035552979,
-0.0525463372,
0.5356913805,
-0.163857311,
0.6320616603,
-0.1178216115,
-0.0255961511,
-0.1392508447,
-0.8942617178,
-0.190386489,
0.06725315,
-0.5714526772,
-0.6245008707,
-0.0502835289,
-0.529509902,
0.3063693345,
0.3423246145,
-0.7452728748,
0.4052584767,
-0.5103132725,
0.3518897593,
0.8129680157,
-0.0081920056,
0.8312737346,
-0.3737568259,
0.1314127445,
0.1483664662,
-0.094925724,
0.1987396926,
-0.4954895079,
-0.9833567739,
0.4219614863,
0.4438016415,
0.1756571233,
-0.5633439422,
-0.0158554185,
-0.1848320067,
-0.512401998,
-0.3695662916,
-0.1824529916,
0.1422223002,
0.8131216168,
0.3519531786,
-0.1691347808,
-0.4212523103,
-1.210370779,
-0.5246864557,
-0.0665458962,
0.1876510978,
0.0728121176,
0.645748198,
0.3929107189,
1.0159695148,
-0.4669823647,
-0.0899130255,
-0.1295417994,
0.3292920291,
0.256835252,
0.5803182721,
0.6426059008,
-0.6154367328,
-0.2024930716,
-0.0405826643,
-1.045894742,
0.0017242262,
-0.1527659297,
0.0479118228,
0.0690169856,
0.5040705204,
-0.9648587704,
0.3977160454,
0.1824033707,
-0.1468221992,
0.9077659845,
-0.4441980422,
-0.0632663593,
-0.8157387972,
0.1577610075,
-0.3867985606,
0.2649450004,
-0.7121713758,
-0.3161069453,
0.1770569682,
0.1475325376,
-0.2046998441,
0.3418347538,
-0.3290050626,
-0.4009294808,
-0.7655923367,
-0.0356989577,
0.0847542211,
0.7348169684,
-0.0429007933,
0.2659902275,
0.7115722299,
-0.9947490096,
0.3375470936,
-0.0014843702,
-0.7804408669,
0.3274151683,
-0.5075582266,
-0.0473272167,
-0.3489499986,
-0.1556442529,
-0.7761847377,
-0.2103175521,
0.2361223996,
-0.5949098468,
0.5657083988,
-0.3007572889,
-0.5409491658,
-0.0758652985,
0.1880337745,
0.2049426734,
0.4406268001,
-0.2429724485,
0.6796435714,
0.4321853518,
0.0574622341,
-0.7749740481,
-0.8150875568,
0.0330856107,
-0.0289589744,
-0.4568007886,
0.2676449418,
0.3558356166,
-0.3064672947,
0.2366684824,
-0.4512294829,
-0.1117374301,
0.0376478881,
0.2433284223,
-0.0516236015,
-0.159608826,
0.555421114,
0.2005200982,
-0.1653168201,
0.5147894621,
-0.4611451328,
0.5001395941,
0.2613379061,
-0.3481781483,
-0.3422338068,
-0.0305336341,
0.4737955332,
0.190480426,
0.8432635665,
0.3659032583,
-0.3893369436,
-0.148266241,
-0.4319913387,
-0.2412598431,
-0.3846490383,
0.4311706126,
-0.3346584737,
-0.6802241802,
0.5320933461,
-0.2347109169,
-0.0978218243,
0.6019874811,
0.1856219172,
-0.488581419,
0.7451097965,
0.6116363406,
0.0336857922,
0.1970621347,
-0.3800831437,
-0.0197421666,
-1.1425857544,
-0.2914420068,
-0.4583879709,
-0.6767734289,
-0.0977841392,
0.0367618538,
0.15537256,
0.3805911541,
-0.2745442092,
0.3347721696,
-0.1480875611,
0.3915021122,
0.6366468072,
0.0904508084,
0.0986602157,
-0.1303030103,
-0.3836904764,
-0.1186723411,
-1.1902952194,
-0.5384958386,
1.2822461128,
0.173146829,
0.5356121063,
-0.0971946791,
0.1918561906,
0.1914159209,
0.1856268197,
-0.7561254501,
0.6690948606,
0.1709377021,
-0.8168687224,
-0.0559730716,
-0.396900475,
-0.8342710733,
0.2994243801,
-0.2728473544,
-0.813388288,
0.3155970275,
0.27660954,
-0.2742261291,
0.6713067293,
-0.7912960649,
0.7992631793,
0.0260660723,
-0.0994851962,
-0.6568347812,
-0.5912259817,
0.527191937,
0.1669057906,
-0.0836296454,
0.0525555573,
0.0362341218,
1.185115695,
-0.3120763004,
1.0501323938,
-0.4184914231,
0.0022295469,
0.2795347571,
0.3266035914,
0.1626601964,
-0.3465910554,
-0.0613140799,
0.1040886715,
-0.0200519506,
-0.3747494221,
-0.9573590755,
0.6199982762,
-0.8263517022,
-0.5544953942,
-0.303037107,
-0.8739541173,
-0.0978099182,
0.233358115,
0.1544798315,
0.5226462483,
0.106806308,
0.1600263864,
0.7912426591,
-0.3461874425,
0.2187093496,
0.3819455802,
-0.3473185301,
-0.0654444322,
0.9811962843,
0.6462361217,
0.5313380361,
0.5222622752,
0.2890093029,
-0.0172340907,
-0.5899285078,
-0.0971706957,
0.0891482756,
-1.1910811663,
0.1234906763,
-1.0450031757,
-0.0900618955,
-0.3984954357,
0.0546780452,
-0.261251837,
-0.8818904161,
-0.0534041598,
-0.1326768696,
0.3657902181,
0.960745573,
-0.3218609989,
0.4154455364,
-0.5744068623,
0.4249619544,
0.4532082081,
0.2099122703,
0.5298438072,
-0.473372221,
-0.4971795082,
0.0725240037,
-0.0897298157,
-0.9088213444,
0.0806877241,
-0.0508183874,
0.6446405053,
0.3903468549,
-0.0433766842,
0.2701114714,
-0.3737867177,
0.7177157998,
0.217835471,
-0.6885198951,
0.3016505241,
-0.0775195584,
0.3268480599,
0.2579539716,
0.5691435933,
-0.6053549051,
-0.1396325827,
-0.8652741909,
-0.5744330287,
0.8092896938,
-0.1721459031,
0.0799518898,
0.1241105199,
0.5865228772,
0.059961319,
0.5379946232,
-0.5412696004,
-0.3518845737,
-0.311412394,
0.0925163031,
0.262932539,
-0.5653337836,
-0.1448469907,
-0.3518278003,
0.6971152425,
0.0322536752,
0.3662951291,
0.3165770471,
-0.2631788552,
0.038689781,
0.0928179473,
0.5492632389,
0.82030195,
-0.114018321,
0.2324019223,
0.1859519631,
-0.4413041174,
-0.2045979947,
-0.3442180753,
-0.4514272511,
0.032567244,
0.5253600478,
0.8393858671,
0.3702321351,
-0.1600997001,
0.3612409532,
0.2468009889,
-0.479274869,
-0.28643924,
0.2238054127,
0.240165323,
0.2718807161,
0.0835049525,
0.7906349301,
0.0423364304,
-0.5574939847,
0.1585241705,
0.2795013785,
-0.4996465445,
-0.357195437,
0.5284280181,
-0.3925929964,
-0.0255204886,
0.3897622824,
0.0234236792,
-0.8280536532,
0.7701820731,
0.393768698,
0.5679391026,
-0.0034459156,
0.2175435573,
0.5903741121,
0.4214666188,
-0.1551694125,
0.2055596262,
-0.0713018849,
-1.1543661356,
-0.7000645399,
-0.6406009197,
-0.1227599159,
0.0101307696,
-0.5720568895,
-0.1687501818,
-0.4981447458,
-0.0854927897,
0.1800849438,
-0.3988525867,
-0.40167436,
0.2910771966,
-0.0024620167,
1.1361763477,
-0.6694350839,
1.0837805271,
0.5323122144,
-0.4050966203,
-0.7653561831,
-0.1654112339,
-0.2281548381,
-0.7730821371,
1.02579391,
0.1459760368,
0.1817612797,
0.0201123822,
-0.7426750064,
-0.8831345439,
0.7717871666,
0.3033830822,
-0.2033875287,
-0.1324795336,
0.2461272031,
0.4673868418,
-0.2190081775,
-0.1902083755,
0.3816148043,
0.6003395319,
-0.10859029,
-0.5370271802,
-0.0840357617,
-0.1355124265,
-0.2590362132,
0.1008094251,
-0.2610948086,
0.8039487004,
-0.336486131,
-0.0230352823,
-0.1539863795,
0.6663250923,
-0.2749123573,
-0.016233284,
0.3572293818,
0.890645504,
0.6007229686,
-0.0179346185,
1.2162361145,
-0.2299513072,
0.1696637273,
1.0850117207,
-0.1066021621,
0.5150532126,
0.5737546086,
-0.0682458058,
0.4679668844,
0.2035109103,
0.0003791147,
0.6437591314,
0.3561044931,
-0.074352704,
-0.3990680575,
-0.0663613454,
-0.2548135221,
0.4964751005,
0.3185903728,
-0.4751067162,
-0.1692706645,
0.0054106438,
-0.0071166507,
-0.082391113,
-0.4493695199,
0.8117246628,
0.3241407871,
-0.5983957052,
0.4416871667,
-0.1694955826,
0.2383974046,
-0.7859129906,
-0.1812040657,
0.4217124581,
0.0952204242,
-0.1672973186,
-0.7852475047,
0.4696529806,
-0.4533313811,
-0.3900855482,
-0.2056347281,
1.0945955515,
-0.2386474013,
-0.0397502631,
0.2618940175,
0.4103803933,
0.2490248233,
-0.1938027591,
-0.6417065263,
-0.3171898127,
-0.0766772926,
-0.4004905224,
0.4646378756,
0.5887721777,
0.4485313296,
0.7054749131,
0.6728419662,
0.3739190698,
0.1305904537,
0.1396513283,
0.7533212304,
-0.7583586574,
-0.1915716678,
-0.7556624413,
0.4198491871,
-0.1556771696,
-0.211285606,
0.6659328938,
0.3847808838,
0.8810604811,
-0.2907965481,
0.9347407818,
-0.2641930282,
0.4209270477,
-0.7357094288,
1.0909729004,
-0.4817339182,
-0.0293861181,
-0.2993721664,
-0.6472987533,
-0.2055995762,
0.6741912961,
-0.5911397934,
-0.1298553646,
0.8895190358,
0.5786693692,
0.0991077349,
0.2807649672,
0.5206520557,
0.6833447218,
-0.1366183311,
0.4184502661,
1.0665141344,
-0.3906672299,
0.3685066104,
-0.5462267995,
0.0160052516,
0.0126557266,
-0.8254796863,
-0.9198028445,
-0.638628602,
-0.1606046706,
-0.4182757437,
-0.1112943068,
0.6561751962,
0.5108189583,
-0.5865465999,
-0.2086665183,
-0.3027665317,
0.312959075,
-0.4038611054,
-0.2003620416,
0.4782579839,
-0.5794790983,
-0.0997610167,
0.4644700587,
0.3028684855,
0.0554437079,
-0.2653061748,
0.0821926966,
-0.3184641898,
-0.370886445,
0.6118066907,
0.1749803126,
-0.4274156392,
-0.3103776574,
0.006443575,
0.0448927321,
0.0657823309,
0.8829938173,
-0.7694925666,
0.5431480408,
0.7280305624,
0.6615299582,
0.3440116644,
-0.6562950611,
0.829113245,
-0.411519438,
-0.0599212907,
0.1494477242,
0.6637730002,
0.2670514286,
-0.0032477654,
0.0626307204,
0.5472522974,
-0.6057847142,
-0.4761555791,
0.4805949628,
-0.8790249228,
-0.6441233158,
0.9058001637,
-0.1841155142,
-0.6096243858,
-0.3129914999,
-0.1668103337,
0.4841735959,
-0.0743950605,
1.0317790508,
0.9688318372,
0.1364854574,
0.1083863601,
-1.0486979485,
0.6652400494,
0.4238864779,
-0.1936833262,
0.1488253772,
0.2609623373,
0.2993763387,
0.4391092658,
0.2473234385,
0.0077405847,
0.2156018317,
0.1282805055,
0.4221171141,
-0.0439369045,
-0.4508667886,
-0.1205141917,
0.4361207485,
-0.0494810157,
0.1442970186
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02411v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02411v1
|
The Call for Socially Aware Language Technologies
| 2024-05-03T18:12:39 | 2024-05-03T18:12:39 |
Diyi Yang, Dirk Hovy, David Jurgens, Barbara Plank
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL
|
Language technologies have made enormous progress, especially with the
introduction of large language models (LLMs). On traditional tasks such as
machine translation and sentiment analysis, these models perform at near-human
level. These advances can, however, exacerbate a variety of issues that models
have traditionally struggled with, such as bias, evaluation, and risks. In this
position paper, we argue that many of these issues share a common core: a lack
of awareness of the factors, context, and implications of the social
environment in which NLP operates, which we call social awareness. While NLP is
getting better at solving the formal linguistic aspects, limited progress has
been made in adding the social awareness required for language applications to
work in all situations for all users. Integrating social awareness into NLP
models will make applications more natural, helpful, and safe, and will open up
new possibilities. Thus we argue that substantial challenges remain for NLP to
develop social awareness and that we are just at the beginning of a new era for
the field.
|
[
-0.1513755769,
-0.5923138857,
0.5866962671,
0.3637515306,
0.1831801683,
0.389647454,
-0.2810228169,
-0.9398212433,
0.1679672003,
0.2267332375,
-0.0664347187,
-0.3689449728,
-0.857791543,
0.0785846859,
-0.5604152679,
0.6534706354,
0.3303214312,
-0.2886002958,
-0.0621312559,
-0.0637738183,
-0.2344797999,
-0.7104432583,
-0.8458849788,
-0.4853264987,
0.5422118902,
0.285153836,
0.7347902656,
0.1415863037,
0.3435798883,
0.3160789311,
-0.6100857258,
-0.0004298268,
-0.1086250395,
0.0997771546,
-0.2252083123,
-0.292013824,
-0.5998445153,
-0.0813131034,
0.6678371429,
0.9443964958,
0.2063209563,
0.2716925442,
0.1472479701,
0.9832231998,
-0.4282237887,
0.0681593567,
-0.730224669,
0.144326672,
-0.0664273426,
-0.0487925075,
-0.1861332804,
-0.3652521074,
0.454292357,
-0.4082460403,
-0.1014585197,
-0.0881730169,
0.517084837,
0.0901776925,
-0.3988999128,
-0.27662009,
-0.8313047886,
0.6431443691,
-0.577077806,
0.5063954592,
0.3664896786,
0.2068707198,
-0.1118945926,
-0.2950835824,
-0.546946764,
0.0590325147,
0.3992486596,
-0.1140797734,
-0.2821713984,
-0.1973274052,
0.2021918893,
-0.0835303813,
-0.2415412962,
0.0605587065,
-0.356418401,
-0.1784045845,
0.5983016491,
-0.04857504,
0.4107840359,
-0.3813576996,
-0.2422321886,
0.4825515151,
-0.5350604057,
0.0696510151,
0.0059360177,
0.2950927913,
-0.3615503907,
0.373087436,
-0.1758404076,
0.4307104349,
-0.2133340836,
-0.0305619109,
0.2680716217,
-0.2790363133,
-0.1402942836,
0.1314354986,
0.4550359845,
0.4964399338,
0.6377891898,
0.2225949019,
-0.1619672477,
0.3213127255,
0.0999274254,
-0.1241500974,
0.2403526306,
0.3962968886,
-0.1373367012,
-0.4046445787,
-0.3001907468,
-0.471374929,
-0.9195165038,
-0.3143169284,
0.0857559294,
-0.1849422753,
-0.7069904208,
0.4148066342,
-0.1328393221,
0.5054241419,
0.4970001578,
-0.9323353767,
0.1907519549,
1.062925458,
0.8714352846,
0.4438120127,
0.1466138065,
0.0252051465,
0.2492690086,
-0.2262355238,
0.780168891,
-0.5430695415,
-0.638514936,
0.2255782783,
-0.0434054844,
0.0979359075,
-0.2130487412,
0.2089899331,
-0.1968258172,
-0.1303486824,
-0.5783721805,
-0.2451627553,
0.0542438999,
0.425326556,
-0.0707831904,
1.1947804689,
-0.0676871687,
-0.8384128213,
0.2125822902,
-0.7120297551,
-0.6544288397,
0.47379601,
-0.0412571356,
-0.1040695161,
0.3198375106,
-0.0333709866,
0.4810222387,
-0.1281920522,
0.4462681115,
-0.4309871495,
-0.3141537011,
0.2654234171,
-0.2166073471,
1.0090405941,
0.1071611494,
-0.5275447965,
0.0105685722,
-0.5120604634,
-0.272600323,
0.0328951441,
-0.1928913891,
-0.5814230442,
0.0938465297,
-0.0751336515,
0.2397854775,
0.5323542953,
-0.4518565834,
-0.4555702806,
-0.4691787958,
0.5630806088,
1.3070721626,
-0.304355979,
0.7539440393,
-0.3737207353,
0.4217474759,
-0.20950149,
0.5489344001,
0.296045512,
-0.8443282843,
-0.7553101778,
0.1809464246,
-0.2456248254,
0.5648460984,
-0.3546490967,
0.6335608959,
-0.1727466881,
-0.632068634,
-0.4355551302,
0.1947793216,
0.1279936582,
0.2950391173,
-0.0843152478,
-0.1344607919,
-0.571320951,
-0.6732112169,
-0.3769266903,
-0.5452071428,
0.2761855721,
0.4876663089,
0.1907933503,
-0.4237829149,
0.7940348983,
-0.1682850122,
-0.1688758135,
-0.5559415221,
-0.2562725246,
-0.0331779197,
0.3548378348,
0.2012364417,
-0.7556452751,
-0.6623948216,
0.3697911799,
-0.8495038152,
-0.2685318589,
0.2636421025,
0.1070890799,
0.4416284561,
0.671187222,
-0.4796015322,
0.1129687652,
0.5141319633,
-0.0933571458,
0.2971543968,
-0.0837045163,
-0.137608692,
-1.1459546089,
0.0696789175,
0.2837394178,
-0.1910401583,
-0.748262465,
-0.350708127,
-0.1471732259,
-0.3701035678,
-0.4743000567,
0.8210154772,
-0.5974452496,
-0.1899150461,
-0.1944597811,
0.6125027537,
0.0977653638,
-0.2162569165,
0.0608090498,
0.3154372573,
0.8019090295,
-0.6768431067,
0.2487068027,
-0.067241773,
-0.3650228083,
0.4871282578,
-0.9561739564,
0.1783476621,
-0.286780417,
0.0536083207,
-0.7195458412,
-0.1655987948,
0.1886169612,
-0.7416285872,
0.182987079,
0.122495845,
-0.3332433701,
-0.4794965088,
-0.3437714875,
0.0974599198,
0.6655288339,
0.0065970053,
0.6044418812,
1.015019536,
-0.4171129465,
-0.7185537815,
-0.5655968189,
0.2830109,
-0.0607141033,
-0.8871566057,
-0.1655895561,
0.2800060213,
-0.664323926,
-0.0701464936,
-0.1484792829,
0.0915257335,
0.644818902,
0.2574264109,
0.1924375147,
0.0711046755,
0.381429106,
-0.1502916515,
-0.3701506257,
0.2695359886,
-0.3194520772,
0.4525661767,
-0.4315063357,
-0.1499615759,
-0.2876312733,
0.4510010183,
0.2145801485,
-0.1841936857,
0.4911012948,
0.5850868225,
-0.7074933648,
-0.0288133882,
-0.8439953327,
-0.000674048,
-0.5253993273,
0.5189525485,
0.1492479593,
-1.3501055241,
0.3501646817,
0.0092607373,
0.0514359623,
0.1722284257,
0.3584072888,
-0.3059251904,
1.0426198244,
1.089364171,
-0.0721905157,
0.7651336193,
0.2543224096,
0.5661097765,
-0.8293417692,
-0.1143532321,
-0.8660919666,
-0.0200821012,
-0.5669135451,
-0.2505177557,
0.3838805556,
-0.342569977,
0.0351968333,
0.2712072134,
-0.5413176417,
0.2881208658,
0.3316099346,
-0.0329838581,
0.3168649077,
-0.146732673,
0.3175193369,
-0.0015210285,
-0.7504960299,
-0.9067993164,
0.7906085253,
0.4843892455,
0.4639572203,
-0.030036943,
0.6849753857,
0.401150018,
0.3603503406,
-0.5605731606,
0.8504238129,
-0.1017236337,
-0.7852521539,
-0.2682467997,
-0.1850602925,
-0.7603812218,
-0.1079140082,
-0.2874610126,
-0.7289408445,
0.2167001367,
0.2045369148,
-0.440887332,
0.1092656106,
-0.819378376,
0.7626689672,
0.0033746725,
-0.2892518342,
-0.1855836809,
-0.819393456,
0.2358005643,
-0.0203936007,
0.8014263511,
-0.6266773343,
0.3495403826,
0.680665493,
-0.0803884417,
1.3012282848,
-0.1587902308,
-0.3348314762,
0.5143043399,
-0.2440428585,
0.4059650898,
-0.0931092277,
-0.0313109942,
-0.0200668257,
-0.077701658,
-0.3893455863,
-0.2047962993,
0.6267390847,
-0.5828797817,
-0.8887112737,
-0.5613342524,
-0.2537255883,
-0.0243127123,
0.0649858117,
-0.2936695814,
0.2754452825,
-0.1746537089,
0.0484834239,
0.8961548805,
-0.4739623368,
0.2216900885,
0.2640724182,
-0.3646212816,
0.2465383708,
0.8231940269,
0.2265042961,
0.443003267,
0.0524797514,
0.3635748625,
-0.150501281,
-0.3967899382,
0.0880678818,
0.3724998832,
-0.881845355,
0.1361309886,
-1.029207468,
-0.0572982952,
-0.9413111806,
-0.6926937699,
-0.2827289999,
-0.3738619387,
-0.1867349595,
-0.1324508339,
0.3628793955,
0.7860457897,
-0.3415155709,
0.2145031095,
-0.9820633531,
0.1494951248,
0.3640759885,
0.3620379865,
0.0989197865,
-0.390357554,
-0.2299286872,
-0.1451666653,
0.0452908836,
-0.4767595828,
0.1207457259,
0.0103727272,
0.3820382655,
0.1435079277,
0.0307892524,
0.2106969208,
-0.383444041,
0.6660844088,
-0.0010601801,
-1.0957689285,
0.6417765617,
-0.347339958,
0.2784843743,
0.3897146285,
0.3628343046,
-1.1486802101,
-0.503403008,
-0.5440039039,
-0.9732183814,
0.2476326227,
-0.272390306,
0.4884212613,
-0.5082197785,
0.0996929258,
-0.1998315006,
0.003670847,
-0.9084749818,
0.1387024522,
0.0592188127,
0.1002507806,
0.0616714321,
-0.5384913683,
0.1596279889,
-0.1118338928,
0.7153071165,
0.1573706716,
0.0578887872,
0.2405011952,
0.0176400673,
-0.1181656346,
0.6065998077,
0.2788828015,
0.6098439097,
-0.1580161154,
0.2988948822,
0.006832689,
-0.3506472111,
0.0549146235,
-0.2689288855,
-0.3934173584,
-0.2323314101,
0.0626904517,
0.3311175704,
0.4621552825,
-0.4274195433,
0.5430677533,
0.1969479769,
0.0042576324,
-0.7320910096,
-0.060165748,
0.4579257369,
0.247773096,
0.2196050882,
0.170526132,
0.0457349978,
-0.6722289324,
-0.0644290075,
0.7544979453,
-0.910639286,
-0.4307806194,
0.5075051188,
0.5993919373,
-0.5808693171,
0.0422548912,
-0.1711528599,
-0.6705449224,
0.474950403,
0.468805939,
1.0508050919,
-0.281098932,
0.3442518711,
0.1069453657,
0.8294055462,
-0.1273375899,
0.4871860147,
0.2220435739,
-1.0387563705,
-0.3337051272,
-0.567251265,
-0.3386946917,
-0.4765050411,
-0.2727100551,
0.3146774769,
-0.7557154298,
-0.5690053105,
-0.002138437,
-0.1358415037,
-0.3774397075,
-0.0653495267,
0.0637833476,
0.8460313082,
-1.0237841606,
0.6156843901,
0.7204784751,
0.0711545348,
-0.3282497525,
-0.3583550155,
0.0867096931,
-0.7163302302,
0.5259745121,
0.4682226777,
-0.4917081296,
0.1245022193,
-0.6434053779,
-0.4763095379,
0.7607543468,
0.0183167234,
-0.3329880536,
-0.0257526804,
0.0721948668,
0.5443651676,
-0.2614916265,
-0.2761376202,
0.250574559,
0.6649165154,
-0.3007574081,
-0.6208960414,
-0.0303929877,
-0.2932844162,
0.3512777388,
0.1756633669,
-0.5544428825,
0.4673273265,
-0.232839942,
-0.5919636488,
-0.5633797646,
0.5364938378,
-0.0343046635,
0.4594419897,
0.4647722542,
0.1219467819,
0.6357347965,
0.0622675642,
1.1119978428,
-0.115301311,
-0.048164662,
0.6726508141,
-0.8587425947,
0.6004191041,
0.3655751646,
-0.2252413481,
-0.0480321236,
0.3156432509,
0.5579294562,
-0.1419047266,
0.1784570515,
-0.6630581617,
-0.4571891725,
-0.6260938048,
-0.4793952703,
0.2178300917,
0.6081499457,
-0.1499403119,
-0.0294760242,
-0.2490526438,
0.0941089317,
0.5920194983,
-0.3070567846,
0.6845683455,
0.3589250445,
-0.1166260689,
0.1423013955,
-0.0376780964,
0.9613590837,
-0.4880328476,
0.1832141876,
-0.0290055424,
-0.1097031906,
-0.2064644843,
-0.6042792797,
0.6752781272,
-0.0242000353,
-0.0587578081,
-0.2808353007,
1.2141497135,
-0.1862328798,
-0.5275233984,
0.6458106041,
0.6501418352,
0.1923167259,
-0.1775827408,
-0.607285738,
0.2055891901,
-0.086479485,
-0.0252835657,
0.389023751,
0.6355156898,
-0.0137680387,
0.8684782386,
0.6806260347,
0.0504836626,
0.2903628349,
0.2362640202,
0.6122595668,
-0.6605442762,
-0.1491936296,
-0.9173573852,
0.4887699485,
-0.1564257443,
-0.1931719184,
0.6455208063,
0.0304831658,
0.4800166488,
0.3587966263,
1.0324919224,
-0.1028011441,
0.5459666252,
-0.0803527758,
0.693593502,
-0.4451358914,
0.3445852101,
-0.7152663469,
-0.7746540904,
-0.4000329673,
0.6876259446,
-0.3909558058,
0.0568923019,
0.3793763816,
0.6603017449,
0.4690773487,
0.2570205033,
0.4162653387,
0.1376904696,
0.3047019243,
0.3666228652,
0.7496228814,
-0.1133774891,
0.1547791511,
-0.2630472183,
-0.458818078,
-0.1928944737,
-1.0787078142,
-0.7891737819,
-0.5534697175,
-0.3704695404,
-0.4482585788,
0.2263819724,
1.0995564461,
0.1383745372,
-0.4518739283,
-0.3469236195,
0.0652889758,
0.4999048412,
0.0220632032,
-0.2322717309,
-0.1542272866,
-0.475418359,
-0.5416489244,
0.1666534543,
0.9091873169,
0.1730010808,
-0.3224981725,
0.2342316657,
-0.6763322353,
0.0884313732,
1.0388277769,
0.4417391121,
-0.4413754046,
-0.777405858,
0.2825177014,
-0.2372119278,
-0.1114749983,
0.4553642273,
-0.3409822285,
0.2756830752,
0.3869740665,
0.8020324707,
-0.001046747,
-0.4143876731,
0.7069289684,
-0.5233467817,
0.0296274647,
0.272017777,
0.377027452,
0.7531530857,
-0.3626342714,
0.4906347394,
0.3346011937,
-0.52602458,
-0.9215897322,
0.5401227474,
-0.8511736989,
-0.00344089,
1.0882146358,
0.2226234376,
-0.3530387282,
-0.6348741055,
-0.0172372703,
0.3440280259,
-0.4190095961,
0.8426124454,
0.7473312616,
0.4040816128,
-0.2339434922,
-0.6185394526,
0.4148628712,
0.5916759968,
-0.7303549647,
0.4708297253,
0.286331892,
0.0595543124,
0.3578587174,
1.1666493416,
-0.5126927495,
0.0560110994,
-0.1553210467,
0.3476834595,
0.3598690629,
-0.3222017586,
-0.2740491331,
-0.0018533893,
0.4177634418,
0.5299255848
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02287v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02287v1
|
Vibe-Eval: A hard evaluation suite for measuring progress of multimodal language models
| 2024-05-03T17:59:55 | 2024-05-03T17:59:55 |
Piotr Padlewski, Max Bain, Matthew Henderson, Zhongkai Zhu, Nishant Relan, Hai Pham, Donovan Ong, Kaloyan Aleksiev, Aitor Ormazabal, Samuel Phua, Ethan Yeo, Eugenie Lamprecht, Qi Liu, Yuqi Wang, Eric Chen, Deyu Fu, Lei Li, Che Zheng, Cyprien de Masson d'Autume, Dani Yogatama, Mikel Artetxe, Yi Tay
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.CV
|
We introduce Vibe-Eval: a new open benchmark and framework for evaluating
multimodal chat models. Vibe-Eval consists of 269 visual understanding prompts,
including 100 of hard difficulty, complete with gold-standard responses
authored by experts. Vibe-Eval is open-ended and challenging with dual
objectives: (i) vibe checking multimodal chat models for day-to-day tasks and
(ii) rigorously testing and probing the capabilities of present frontier
models. Notably, our hard set contains >50% questions that all frontier models
answer incorrectly. We explore the nuances of designing, evaluating, and
ranking models on ultra challenging prompts. We also discuss trade-offs between
human and automatic evaluation, and show that automatic model evaluation using
Reka Core roughly correlates to human judgment. We offer free API access for
the purpose of lightweight evaluation and plan to conduct formal human
evaluations for public models that perform well on the Vibe-Eval's automatic
scores. We release the evaluation code and data, see
https://github.com/reka-ai/reka-vibe-eval
|
[
-0.2820303142,
-1.0300581455,
0.5679869056,
0.4867455661,
0.0319690853,
0.3174261451,
-0.4303484857,
-0.3155066967,
0.0791683197,
0.3285204768,
-0.9341343641,
-0.5183323026,
-0.084346585,
-0.1325313002,
-0.5394321084,
0.7809427977,
0.147979334,
0.0932992697,
-0.3798777163,
-0.0680205151,
-0.6511554122,
-0.2620157897,
-0.2896232009,
-0.1841828078,
0.3812960684,
0.2943554223,
0.828748703,
0.0001798236,
0.6550773382,
0.3258733153,
-0.2234389186,
-0.1571272314,
-0.6109527946,
0.3815632761,
-0.1527600437,
-0.5754763484,
-0.7003307343,
0.0375134423,
0.5470396876,
0.6363543272,
-0.2398357689,
0.3606086075,
-0.0594372824,
0.8575347662,
-0.718485713,
0.0644104928,
-0.4530236423,
0.0119860983,
-0.143548429,
0.0625388399,
-0.461158812,
-0.4097557664,
0.1626310199,
-0.3095351756,
-0.2373044789,
0.1901063621,
0.7752870321,
0.107131891,
-0.6749507189,
-0.0239552595,
-0.6123134494,
0.872395277,
-0.2614465058,
0.9887474179,
0.12400271,
0.5629512072,
-0.2818940282,
-0.6422007084,
-0.51694417,
-0.5454026461,
0.4506850243,
0.2512611449,
-0.5561064482,
-0.0329590403,
0.0174147803,
0.6140702963,
-0.3947332203,
-0.2873487473,
-0.3713180125,
-0.3836601079,
0.461717397,
0.4518921673,
0.3342181444,
-0.3358923793,
-0.3006338179,
-0.3032799959,
-0.3742673993,
0.322868228,
0.4318183362,
0.3282738328,
-0.3933148086,
0.5638852119,
-0.33360219,
0.5715562105,
0.020157814,
0.0126954503,
0.5936510563,
-0.6521561146,
-0.0443049856,
-0.6677748561,
1.1357769966,
0.4851377904,
-0.1627732813,
-0.0472656563,
-0.3910188675,
0.0398723632,
0.4806152284,
-0.5998666286,
-0.1001623571,
0.3031077683,
-0.6003298759,
-0.5052090287,
-0.3473853171,
-1.0476064682,
-0.3177455664,
-0.4346744418,
0.5126851201,
-0.5340822339,
-0.4625447392,
0.0751907229,
-0.1026175767,
0.3476101756,
0.7059367895,
-0.3470444679,
0.0459331796,
0.814088881,
1.0301493406,
-0.0461301506,
-0.2881028354,
-0.3841465712,
-0.9534925222,
-0.5221925974,
0.8040995598,
-0.67336905,
-0.4772329032,
-0.1495037675,
-0.1395877302,
0.0881291702,
-0.1078460068,
0.8624230623,
-0.3034948111,
0.2169273198,
-0.2756981254,
-0.5043078661,
-0.1218701378,
0.3301843405,
-0.4185757041,
1.0559959412,
0.3489394486,
-0.5518319011,
0.2495907247,
-0.8295474648,
-0.0152116464,
-0.0447585769,
0.0378870107,
-0.0303038917,
0.4008601904,
0.0693899468,
0.1585270017,
-0.5169488192,
0.2225738764,
-0.59520787,
-0.1735668927,
0.5953299999,
-0.5434732437,
0.6927762628,
0.5071587563,
-0.062525101,
0.6079796553,
-0.7176976204,
0.4409373999,
-0.181310311,
-0.1660177112,
-0.1129861996,
-0.286242038,
0.4330506325,
0.3630696833,
0.319871515,
-0.4683170915,
0.2285092771,
-0.0188369602,
0.2480035126,
0.8351266384,
-0.3008215427,
0.1121571884,
-0.2132440805,
0.8556569815,
-0.0799579844,
0.3823127449,
-0.4545843005,
-0.4702932537,
-0.6866133809,
-0.2803246975,
0.3807078302,
0.4091970623,
-0.7535276413,
0.4040586054,
-0.2250390649,
-1.0946389437,
-0.869502008,
0.0089554619,
0.6569667459,
0.2783602178,
0.061899092,
-0.4174573123,
-0.2873598933,
-1.0459811687,
-0.4040556252,
-0.3147730827,
-0.0870123878,
0.452734977,
0.5778026581,
-0.3673689663,
1.0435253382,
-0.3977770507,
0.1554376632,
-0.2903594375,
0.3639447391,
0.1028172001,
0.2531621754,
0.5701215863,
-0.7158902287,
-0.2429153025,
-0.2159352154,
-0.6464986205,
-0.187612921,
0.1859388351,
-0.3180891275,
-0.2686870396,
0.236895591,
-0.3949334025,
0.1740274578,
0.6913511753,
-0.7966532707,
0.872572422,
0.0572140776,
0.715113163,
-0.7717541456,
0.0067646131,
0.16330266,
-0.4508958161,
-0.7221191525,
0.2726019025,
0.3016535044,
-0.5191012025,
-0.7680146098,
0.6211572289,
-0.1177920476,
-0.0400377773,
-0.1353904158,
0.09293513,
0.1190739125,
0.5924047828,
-0.1842351407,
0.8018016815,
0.8074580431,
-0.4573000371,
0.5215960741,
0.0321763009,
-0.517604351,
0.9231461287,
-0.6234708428,
0.514682591,
0.0074045183,
0.263502866,
-1.0543479919,
-0.2379957736,
0.0899163187,
-0.3647898734,
-0.0316106305,
-0.1772539765,
-0.1924452037,
-0.491115123,
-0.5167019963,
0.2657969594,
0.6002659798,
-0.4508880973,
0.6143270135,
0.4188813269,
0.148501575,
-0.2371587455,
-0.3342695534,
0.118869625,
-0.2195293158,
-0.7773968577,
-0.0664987266,
-0.1909312755,
-0.4560613632,
-0.248527348,
0.0922240168,
-0.2728199363,
0.3012046218,
0.3836881518,
0.2371062934,
-0.1320092231,
0.1557357013,
-0.2966157794,
0.1159692556,
0.1183893308,
-0.0761261433,
0.5977236032,
-0.9713004827,
-0.5296550393,
-0.6536314487,
0.0136804469,
0.910036087,
-0.0598009527,
0.2625331879,
0.7791467309,
-0.2195385396,
0.4506351948,
-0.6786071062,
-0.0004644161,
-0.4584956765,
0.4768516719,
-0.5808405876,
-0.6779735088,
0.5748698115,
0.0061549852,
0.1752228439,
0.408018142,
0.829180479,
0.1487602741,
0.9470927119,
0.7816862464,
0.0985653251,
0.5087953806,
0.228519842,
-0.0163875502,
-0.9399915934,
-0.2005485296,
-0.4503664374,
-0.2000427842,
-0.4967831969,
-0.5480780602,
0.3678244054,
0.1421536207,
0.1093811765,
0.351672411,
-0.2749836147,
0.3471536934,
0.3964270949,
0.2028797865,
0.2773700058,
-0.5207112432,
-0.0944470316,
-0.2306619585,
-0.2097993493,
-0.5344002247,
1.3554393053,
0.6546584368,
1.0406637192,
0.2061804533,
0.4255929291,
0.3772506416,
0.4045347273,
-0.9158461094,
0.5414494276,
0.3077844083,
-0.6481153965,
-0.0914198607,
-0.5168398619,
-0.7308706641,
0.4822706282,
-0.2547932863,
-0.9966028333,
-0.0151938526,
0.2806807458,
-0.3840498626,
0.1684457809,
-0.7955085039,
0.9929417968,
-0.3730069399,
-0.4422759414,
-0.3644823134,
-0.3446374834,
0.6841731668,
0.0082189096,
0.3920485079,
-0.3568382859,
0.1204599291,
0.7993719578,
-0.2716846764,
0.6139728427,
-0.1044582278,
-0.2235760391,
0.4776138961,
0.2682096958,
0.068784751,
-0.0225591157,
0.0504865274,
0.3793238401,
0.1602059156,
-0.1790093184,
-0.78460145,
0.5178850889,
-0.6406481862,
-0.2069632262,
-0.2011347413,
-0.2404325306,
-0.3168098927,
0.0330030583,
0.0916962624,
0.7534862161,
-0.5670129657,
0.3814012408,
0.2020628899,
-0.3763686717,
-0.018675264,
0.5657407045,
-0.9702112675,
-0.3761101365,
0.9265531898,
-0.4425924718,
0.284940809,
0.2455887944,
0.4291363657,
-0.3835614026,
-0.0413010344,
-0.49650684,
-0.2989073992,
-0.7657541633,
0.0136965653,
-0.8000141978,
0.1981572509,
-0.2769896984,
0.1285710484,
-1.0606769323,
-0.3166639209,
0.2180965543,
0.3235895932,
0.3377274275,
0.7560414076,
-0.0708946884,
0.0078154402,
-0.7150323987,
0.1580098867,
0.2137468606,
0.4525251091,
-0.0441265404,
-0.4109497964,
-0.0698982403,
0.2377551645,
-0.6576139331,
-0.9136323333,
0.2396394908,
-0.0211554021,
0.1609209329,
0.3509213328,
-0.045359008,
0.7019463778,
-0.5218064785,
0.9410558939,
0.4937527776,
-1.276827693,
0.5721231699,
-0.4880103469,
0.3419984579,
0.7058224678,
0.0196525417,
-0.8920364976,
-0.5384643674,
-0.6631987691,
-0.6711676717,
0.4711176157,
0.4500195682,
0.1063523293,
-0.0469408818,
0.1600769311,
0.1135567352,
0.4653177261,
-0.6194836497,
-0.2206919044,
-0.3665833175,
-0.0233163759,
0.1933798343,
-0.2699316144,
0.1577147245,
-0.223745957,
0.3378753662,
-0.1767071784,
0.4449703097,
0.0134098595,
-0.1644756794,
-0.1128328964,
0.7379952669,
0.5063175559,
0.7870127559,
-0.3656079471,
-0.1820365936,
0.1545929015,
-0.3489266932,
0.0879659951,
-0.3812480867,
0.1556136906,
-0.0763248205,
0.2942436934,
0.9817869663,
0.5796765089,
-0.9468013644,
0.6876081824,
-0.5830469728,
-0.0172738731,
-0.2029076517,
0.0347908996,
-0.1524904519,
0.263314724,
0.3151962459,
0.0617335737,
0.3457272649,
-0.8298016191,
0.1665527821,
0.4572228491,
-0.7280210257,
-0.7532962561,
0.5312582254,
0.4694310725,
-0.428424418,
0.5406214595,
-0.4041225016,
-0.6371644735,
0.4156640172,
0.171852693,
1.0817257166,
-0.0437199958,
0.1636954844,
0.2891910672,
0.1468043476,
0.0168242361,
0.4998962879,
-0.0232502986,
-0.5363300443,
-0.3701145053,
-0.6158564687,
-0.921421349,
0.0857375413,
-0.851220727,
0.5542698503,
-0.2424082309,
-0.4043024182,
0.0599278659,
-0.2195692956,
-1.0658590794,
-0.1182208806,
0.0165300872,
0.9005833268,
-0.7573767304,
0.3232271075,
0.7834400535,
-0.1757195741,
-0.5620048642,
-0.0321802199,
0.469660759,
-0.5517400503,
0.7491381764,
0.2943571508,
-0.2401770651,
-0.3957233727,
-0.5264394879,
-0.7636638284,
0.6960326433,
0.3920287788,
-0.7092565894,
0.1731356978,
-0.5085781813,
0.7259200215,
-0.1734383255,
1.0664864779,
0.5386868119,
0.5251729488,
-0.0284059122,
-1.3292179108,
-0.2438933402,
-0.4835066795,
-0.1735010296,
0.135592103,
-0.8488411307,
0.9922693372,
-0.1701701283,
-0.244726643,
0.0788494274,
0.7613121867,
0.0504013076,
0.2640678585,
0.9254681468,
0.3802312016,
0.8466094136,
-0.2705158889,
1.2428059578,
-0.415771544,
0.5490726233,
0.839880228,
-0.2127664387,
0.82462883,
0.2472919822,
-0.4734328091,
0.5502168536,
0.565382421,
0.3022757471,
0.3203088045,
0.1489028037,
0.086409837,
-0.4790885448,
-0.2009130269,
-0.2141227275,
0.7820106745,
0.2266393751,
0.3014377058,
-0.3047417998,
0.1190072,
-0.1801304966,
-0.1521277875,
-0.1736885458,
0.6034225821,
0.0135071948,
-0.6969916821,
0.3361911774,
0.015225973,
0.7799853683,
-0.4575995505,
0.2265613377,
-0.1133247018,
0.186020866,
0.0694619268,
-0.8551601768,
0.1779249012,
0.1442566067,
0.038365081,
-0.1615923345,
0.6933033466,
-0.3294867575,
-0.5811648369,
0.1849888116,
0.7842873931,
0.3598012328,
-0.1670535207,
-1.0225894451,
0.2199746221,
-0.0807700753,
-0.5168486834,
0.2028082609,
0.4653658271,
0.0447765775,
1.1260800362,
0.7822580934,
-0.3697313368,
-0.1935306937,
0.2110102475,
0.808406651,
-0.8860038519,
-0.7430839539,
-0.943187654,
0.4891682565,
0.1435962915,
-0.5925167799,
0.7461531758,
0.3866363764,
0.2156350613,
0.0780714974,
0.5306529403,
-0.1113628075,
0.423913002,
-0.5087777972,
0.5174832344,
-0.7689814568,
-0.005666425,
-0.663079977,
-0.7860118151,
0.2072634548,
0.5583813787,
-0.0652789623,
0.1283151358,
0.6590675116,
0.6248149872,
-0.0168226212,
0.3136728108,
0.3779042065,
0.0337485895,
0.456510812,
0.5741435885,
1.409237504,
-0.2762922049,
0.4526057243,
-0.4101263285,
-0.3773902059,
-0.2577719092,
-1.0086253881,
-1.0072665215,
-0.6978663802,
-0.5335968733,
-0.5158336163,
-0.0845164284,
1.3121262789,
0.7693878412,
-0.49261567,
-0.2225613296,
0.0560443066,
0.2690871656,
-0.2131620795,
-0.32911098,
0.1164814904,
-0.4943991303,
-0.7276819348,
0.6885067225,
0.3954667747,
-0.1058241278,
-0.702527225,
0.0767521039,
0.1579610258,
-0.0717835575,
0.545298934,
0.0797279999,
-0.767216146,
-0.3455744982,
0.1386602223,
-0.0877607092,
0.056988202,
0.8881724477,
-0.7546908259,
0.6112709045,
0.4309172034,
0.3441577852,
0.1075824723,
-0.079523474,
0.7739424706,
-0.6614403129,
0.1014646068,
0.0218126718,
0.5062664747,
0.3557952642,
-0.0855159387,
0.4621352553,
-0.0468506254,
-0.4489211142,
-1.0501013994,
0.2008320391,
-0.8223897815,
-0.0104376301,
1.0674315691,
-0.0837905034,
-0.4859302044,
0.0299444869,
-0.169092983,
-0.1920892447,
-0.7016394734,
0.6692756414,
0.8784660101,
-0.0321603231,
-0.083479248,
-0.6942443848,
0.3264746964,
0.4274817407,
-0.7654776573,
0.2192368209,
0.4855622053,
0.1993064582,
0.4221051037,
0.7394161224,
-0.1276572794,
0.4088511765,
-0.0744887739,
0.2676394582,
0.1335847378,
-0.3631136417,
-0.5326943994,
-0.0497139394,
-0.0223886874,
-0.0040601268
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02267v1
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02267v1
|
Structural Pruning of Pre-trained Language Models via Neural Architecture Search
| 2024-05-03T17:34:57 | 2024-05-03T17:34:57 |
Aaron Klein, Jacek Golebiowski, Xingchen Ma, Valerio Perrone, Cedric Archambeau
|
cs.LG
|
cs.LG, cs.CL
|
Pre-trained language models (PLM), for example BERT or RoBERTa, mark the
state-of-the-art for natural language understanding task when fine-tuned on
labeled data. However, their large size poses challenges in deploying them for
inference in real-world applications, due to significant GPU memory
requirements and high inference latency. This paper explores neural
architecture search (NAS) for structural pruning to find sub-parts of the
fine-tuned network that optimally trade-off efficiency, for example in terms of
model size or latency, and generalization performance. We also show how we can
utilize more recently developed two-stage weight-sharing NAS approaches in this
setting to accelerate the search process. Unlike traditional pruning methods
with fixed thresholds, we propose to adopt a multi-objective approach that
identifies the Pareto optimal set of sub-networks, allowing for a more flexible
and automated compression process.
|
[
-0.5919101238,
-0.7039086223,
0.5168663859,
0.3371992111,
-0.4686336219,
-0.1608592719,
-0.3515672386,
-0.2145736814,
0.2643074691,
0.1234250516,
-0.5528362989,
-0.3750507534,
-0.4776004255,
-0.1364177018,
-0.1408817619,
0.5071955323,
0.0418999642,
-0.1028597876,
0.0462968238,
-0.0917467177,
-0.5614821911,
-0.5634559989,
-0.6857930422,
-0.3076016605,
0.5764530897,
0.1504219472,
0.7499584556,
0.8218538761,
0.3603313863,
0.3042416573,
-0.4556223154,
0.2460957617,
-0.2220073044,
0.0541958325,
-0.0767833069,
-0.4260679185,
-0.4485179484,
-0.0812648311,
0.7491394281,
0.8027257323,
-0.1425787359,
0.2534305155,
-0.0946889371,
0.6700783372,
-0.5646628141,
0.3507326543,
-0.5628088713,
0.2212364078,
-0.2950467169,
-0.1726123393,
-0.3389206231,
-0.167531386,
0.2544767559,
-0.6132898331,
0.3125885129,
0.0530250594,
1.0461283922,
0.3783714473,
-0.0885897502,
-0.0054642758,
-0.3990277052,
0.7803974152,
-0.6842140555,
0.4351086617,
0.422744453,
0.0904138535,
-0.1348282844,
-0.6478322148,
-0.1430304199,
-0.2513845265,
-0.093038179,
-0.1920614094,
-0.1356676072,
0.4841780961,
-0.2039999664,
0.4548118711,
-0.7939458489,
0.1295049638,
-0.5461380482,
-0.265965879,
0.3727869689,
-0.3334512115,
0.4310635328,
-0.0866388455,
-0.2488197535,
-0.2003463358,
-0.7067349553,
-0.1584543735,
0.5082683563,
0.4011606872,
0.3268766701,
0.379758209,
-0.0007375127,
0.9417368174,
-0.3377922177,
0.2744460106,
0.1436371356,
-0.6405033469,
-0.3115684092,
-0.0167057589,
0.5089581609,
-0.2075026929,
0.5200275183,
-0.1903670281,
-0.2395931184,
0.095972985,
0.4987923205,
-0.6397040486,
-0.4561233222,
-0.0357720926,
-0.7878814936,
0.0057534515,
-0.2466215193,
-0.3576135635,
0.32600981,
-0.4003531933,
0.3246533573,
-0.4420189857,
-0.2401302606,
0.3242573142,
-0.2037202567,
-0.031153921,
-0.0583735853,
-0.6233571768,
0.3409695029,
0.6367914677,
1.0749642849,
0.139718771,
-0.0899073929,
-0.5755144358,
-0.1608102024,
-0.4887192249,
0.4523563981,
-0.4903808534,
-0.0376374684,
-0.3192949295,
-0.302391082,
-0.2870640755,
-0.4647562504,
0.5621909499,
-0.7384905815,
-0.1787420809,
-0.0166891664,
-0.2971824408,
-0.2805868387,
0.3538028002,
-0.7988660932,
0.8498693109,
0.0006995957,
-0.5224855542,
0.1897459477,
-0.5455078483,
-0.697586596,
0.0322873481,
-0.1091910824,
-0.5413361788,
0.5385642648,
0.3881193995,
0.5070977211,
-0.294472307,
0.7210143805,
-0.1190656647,
-0.5028676987,
-0.3695101142,
-0.214795202,
0.570007205,
0.2927129269,
-0.1762716472,
0.2698186636,
-0.5664827824,
-0.0361580402,
0.1546230167,
-0.5121777058,
-0.6257686019,
0.2104892582,
-0.2209829688,
0.0965811834,
0.2964467704,
-0.3197646439,
0.1327182204,
-0.7438336611,
0.5959718227,
0.7150425315,
-0.2389783859,
0.6556682587,
-0.2920389175,
0.5251962543,
-0.0396826565,
0.275003314,
0.089579165,
-0.2814929485,
-0.7170371413,
-0.1047927886,
0.4803025723,
0.1556472629,
-0.5984597802,
0.4681411386,
-0.2437882274,
-0.3623532653,
-0.6441808343,
0.1953852177,
0.5785791874,
0.269623965,
0.5794551969,
-0.4559953511,
-0.6868268847,
-1.2485238314,
-0.108126238,
-0.0912768468,
-0.0585464276,
0.4726928473,
0.2200378925,
0.1876642406,
0.8430125117,
-0.4691407084,
-0.4266827404,
-0.4547163844,
0.350153625,
0.4065334499,
0.5219785571,
0.4924066961,
-1.151360631,
-0.2850421071,
-0.1471444815,
-0.1628227383,
-0.0131580727,
-0.2045065463,
0.1164434552,
-0.3439683616,
0.4214164317,
-0.4718125463,
0.2122319639,
0.704908371,
0.1590920538,
0.458961457,
-0.3971668184,
-0.4003327191,
-0.8277530074,
0.0687601045,
0.1584955603,
0.0175460745,
-0.5104920268,
0.1838629693,
0.0140023548,
-0.0945339724,
-0.3152714074,
0.4470670819,
-1.0422081947,
-0.4786148369,
-0.0436097495,
0.002648029,
0.1340127736,
0.8770701289,
0.2189604938,
0.9706911445,
0.4817881584,
-0.8223434687,
-0.144417122,
0.1190437526,
-0.6237669587,
-0.2278084606,
-0.7390255928,
0.0243065301,
-0.3635087609,
0.252663672,
-0.7048969269,
0.1419944912,
0.0844613686,
-0.2893994153,
0.2517956495,
-0.3723987937,
-0.3194288313,
-0.1396816671,
-0.2389286011,
0.6133288741,
0.0990021676,
-0.3611113429,
0.6203164458,
0.4685921967,
-0.2372869104,
-0.5725950599,
-0.6992147565,
0.0765312314,
-0.0103586968,
-0.7048421502,
0.7096507549,
0.0056692972,
-0.0170177016,
0.0311434064,
-0.4392940998,
-0.2848792672,
0.3594267964,
0.049207449,
-0.0190303065,
-0.5145469308,
0.1584298164,
0.1195430309,
-0.0403236337,
-0.1080489159,
-0.3746286631,
0.9471510053,
-0.3042967319,
-0.2141253948,
-0.4032862186,
0.2147411555,
0.3008577228,
-0.6390004158,
0.778919816,
0.3451089263,
-0.2649481893,
-0.3965373337,
-0.3894026279,
-0.1228891313,
-0.4409308434,
0.5871023536,
-0.5590447187,
-0.7873128653,
0.3102916479,
-0.1427133232,
0.0531282276,
0.2723093629,
0.3276130259,
0.2756573856,
0.9915133715,
0.4826589525,
-0.0822846219,
0.7080521584,
-0.4079303145,
0.3149302006,
-0.9311017394,
-0.0457365364,
-0.6402800679,
-0.6827855706,
-0.1352737993,
-0.5835538507,
0.2458259463,
0.1121644676,
0.0313037075,
0.6284124851,
-0.6037629843,
0.51798141,
0.7724571228,
0.1044017598,
0.1632882655,
-0.067843385,
-0.1634799838,
0.1392569691,
-0.9293915629,
-0.1370312721,
0.6695546508,
0.4104982316,
0.2799697518,
-0.0584234148,
0.482267648,
-0.0453900956,
0.1748597473,
-0.8385471106,
0.5418761969,
-0.4792593122,
-0.6978652477,
-0.3883836567,
-0.7243025899,
-0.8791486025,
0.4094951451,
0.1800927669,
-0.4806320667,
0.4978009462,
0.2299975157,
-0.4155699909,
0.2711093128,
-0.6598262191,
0.8045278192,
-0.3636312485,
0.0489999987,
-0.3026351631,
-0.7185593843,
0.2889365256,
0.0643470064,
0.0908069909,
-0.0707992315,
0.1075032875,
0.7600106001,
-0.2354015857,
0.6699808836,
-0.2279442251,
0.3228815496,
-0.0042024357,
0.1087796167,
0.4225598872,
-0.0627799258,
-0.3290546834,
0.1982222795,
-0.3196095228,
-0.3008613884,
-0.3896089196,
0.4023351073,
-0.640175283,
-0.4057831466,
-0.1005787998,
-0.5160035491,
-0.1810979545,
0.1426448226,
0.1318944544,
0.452234596,
-0.1591841578,
0.6181730032,
0.5824603438,
-0.275739491,
0.4086134136,
0.173085466,
0.2316853255,
-0.1327761412,
0.8834164739,
0.2955535948,
0.0033633041,
0.6512461305,
0.2875912786,
-0.1938625872,
-1.2269095182,
-0.2012314945,
0.0501227453,
-0.1575353444,
-0.3692605495,
-0.5421184301,
-0.2377167046,
-0.2354136556,
-0.0415695719,
-0.559499979,
-0.1558826566,
-0.4076825082,
-0.1656416059,
-0.1401689202,
0.3477143943,
-0.0709836707,
0.8421385884,
-0.7462201118,
0.2957075238,
0.0970858857,
0.4354836941,
0.1551753134,
-0.2296521217,
-0.2400436252,
-0.0115273623,
0.0582019836,
-0.7774651647,
0.6719408035,
0.5645192862,
0.5446597934,
0.3417588472,
-0.0306692589,
0.7712268829,
-0.3629414737,
0.2719631195,
0.0592737943,
-0.7863658071,
0.3863668442,
-0.0717026293,
0.1677151918,
0.7643725872,
0.493508786,
-0.3143551052,
0.0949763358,
-0.4791448414,
-1.1141700745,
0.8050968647,
0.3545047641,
-0.0889340118,
0.0163942818,
0.3947967291,
-0.2819756866,
0.2417524904,
-0.6004186869,
-0.043203488,
0.0457845554,
-0.192879349,
0.0422157943,
-0.2416597158,
-0.0150733748,
-0.1380960345,
0.6523056626,
-0.2466454059,
-0.071828343,
0.2417831123,
-0.4369363189,
0.2117098719,
0.2311069369,
0.2748090327,
0.6952700019,
-0.1916783005,
0.2169720232,
-0.1350082755,
-0.2685545683,
-0.038571801,
0.1089475155,
-0.2181475312,
0.0659695938,
0.2222608924,
1.1027058363,
0.5148162246,
-0.6363574266,
0.4722414613,
-0.3434053361,
-0.3010156155,
-0.0064839222,
-0.0003163777,
0.1931105703,
0.2264651358,
0.2833269835,
0.0933047235,
0.1555372328,
-0.4348885119,
0.2965008914,
0.5094260573,
-0.0960994512,
-0.3980172873,
0.3851276338,
0.0287401006,
-0.4842248559,
0.848553896,
-0.0696208328,
-0.6880612373,
0.7688077688,
0.2975029945,
0.6597176194,
-0.0625270531,
0.3429420292,
0.1377248466,
0.448680073,
-0.3422359526,
0.1152090281,
-0.4001409709,
-0.8795511127,
-0.8557819724,
-1.0691123009,
-0.0791183561,
0.2132227421,
-0.6127539873,
-0.1332234889,
-0.5741064548,
-0.1297301352,
-0.0818440765,
0.2011128366,
-0.533195138,
0.1775070429,
-0.0095506832,
1.0628452301,
-0.6619258523,
0.9187511802,
0.5724730492,
-0.3766084909,
-0.9665467739,
-0.2860312462,
-0.2504759133,
-0.7611849308,
0.7121470571,
0.1833033711,
0.1275200397,
0.0417083353,
-0.2022202313,
-0.8405416608,
0.7137872577,
0.6183633804,
-0.7500664592,
-0.7466207147,
-0.2524619102,
0.4971958399,
-0.216237396,
0.0229159426,
0.4766969979,
0.554895699,
0.0061534429,
-0.8321542144,
-0.1882091016,
-0.4046637416,
0.2005684525,
0.420940578,
-0.5177763104,
1.0972133875,
0.2723616064,
-0.2485866398,
-0.0884313881,
0.6858837605,
0.230543226,
0.0626382977,
0.8760268092,
0.6527068615,
0.4871121347,
0.1143479943,
0.7681449056,
-0.3459801674,
0.2409404814,
1.2001206875,
0.0187667739,
0.7729312181,
0.4414991736,
-0.0072728237,
0.2049598992,
0.8909176588,
0.130554378,
0.4296184182,
0.4399288893,
0.038916491,
-0.4405918121,
-0.0747809783,
-0.1293845624,
0.351257652,
0.3154836595,
-0.3518713117,
-0.2955511212,
-0.2601815462,
-0.1021028683,
-0.1027638391,
-0.1271014363,
0.7054464221,
0.1560607851,
-0.7453443408,
0.2718632221,
0.1539201438,
0.7171887755,
-0.7824181318,
0.0640987009,
-0.3072770834,
0.0611682609,
0.0765350014,
-0.3122572005,
0.6414136887,
-0.4123727977,
-0.1311625689,
-0.7111661434,
0.7844436765,
-0.3188049197,
-0.1784187555,
0.6412700415,
0.506313026,
0.1388654113,
-0.5165150762,
-0.6475359797,
0.146728456,
-0.0390055031,
-0.6198043227,
0.5174533129,
0.0969116762,
-0.0320970453,
0.4778608382,
0.7810979486,
0.4914392233,
0.2138258964,
0.0142962104,
0.9119250774,
-0.2638093233,
-0.5847640038,
-0.6552016735,
0.0815552324,
-0.0531194285,
-0.3159691691,
0.3180136979,
0.578379333,
0.8958297372,
0.1236426532,
0.2437293828,
0.0662668422,
0.1667068899,
-0.5240943432,
0.7085648179,
-0.7841804028,
0.2028514892,
0.1135202274,
-0.9784246683,
-0.2921735048,
0.8573049903,
-0.2931496501,
-0.194125995,
0.4222520888,
0.8560214043,
-0.3366213143,
-0.095460467,
0.1647706777,
0.2337182462,
0.1824948937,
0.5232275724,
0.1999049485,
-0.1454214007,
0.7164794803,
-0.1849892586,
-0.0723375082,
-0.1116623282,
-0.7739260793,
-0.5572035909,
-0.6618061066,
-0.0325884037,
0.2768925726,
0.2299515456,
0.7421016097,
1.1500716209,
-0.5482669473,
-0.0567287132,
-0.49882707,
0.2053575814,
-0.203446731,
-0.1610842943,
0.4562099576,
-0.3431042135,
-0.6143661141,
1.0561152697,
0.3411637545,
-0.3267405033,
-0.2648176253,
-0.0108716059,
-0.7480264306,
-0.026489241,
0.3218129873,
0.3473567963,
-0.3218174875,
-0.0347717367,
-0.0732585639,
0.2767893076,
0.1010957509,
1.0081732273,
-0.7263999581,
0.1420436203,
0.7943379283,
1.0508127213,
0.6060504913,
0.136554718,
0.9070920348,
-1.2416186333,
0.2821397483,
0.5399754047,
0.5276316404,
0.1075180024,
-0.1557530314,
0.5420809984,
0.1018477082,
-0.3076697588,
-0.8278679252,
0.248031795,
-0.655813396,
-0.6921949387,
0.7094125748,
-0.2176294476,
-0.4495828748,
-0.0915354639,
0.0285393614,
0.411931932,
-0.25124529,
0.4027892649,
0.5675191283,
-0.0194977373,
-0.1953998059,
-0.3206001222,
0.3958815038,
0.7585431933,
-0.6181225777,
-0.1294083744,
0.3121446073,
-0.1025184467,
0.3768920898,
0.5985196829,
0.1595647484,
-0.0954398289,
-0.2883876264,
-0.1001502275,
-0.3861711919,
-0.9285865426,
-0.2664497793,
0.6116914153,
-0.1401782334,
-0.3013480902
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.06671v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.06671v2
|
Parameter-Efficient Instruction Tuning of Large Language Models For Extreme Financial Numeral Labelling
| 2024-05-03T16:41:36 | 2024-05-15T14:43:23 |
Subhendu Khatuya, Rajdeep Mukherjee, Akash Ghosh, Manjunath Hegde, Koustuv Dasgupta, Niloy Ganguly, Saptarshi Ghosh, Pawan Goyal
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.CE, cs.LG
|
We study the problem of automatically annotating relevant numerals (GAAP
metrics) occurring in the financial documents with their corresponding XBRL
tags. Different from prior works, we investigate the feasibility of solving
this extreme classification problem using a generative paradigm through
instruction tuning of Large Language Models (LLMs). To this end, we leverage
metric metadata information to frame our target outputs while proposing a
parameter efficient solution for the task using LoRA. We perform experiments on
two recently released financial numeric labeling datasets. Our proposed model,
FLAN-FinXC, achieves new state-of-the-art performances on both the datasets,
outperforming several strong baselines. We explain the better scores of our
proposed model by demonstrating its capability for zero-shot as well as the
least frequently occurring tags. Also, even when we fail to predict the XBRL
tags correctly, our generated output has substantial overlap with the
ground-truth in majority of the cases.
|
[
-0.3575736284,
-0.7932708859,
0.1868543029,
0.0549478829,
-0.3397402167,
0.1823046356,
-0.224366501,
-0.7427443862,
0.0206919964,
0.8405518532,
-0.1839108914,
-1.0049036741,
-0.4811398685,
-0.2589045465,
-0.4101983011,
1.4041079283,
0.1252002418,
-0.1967142671,
0.2957755029,
-0.0890363529,
0.0622049272,
-0.6476221085,
-0.7554330826,
-0.2820158303,
0.2808555961,
0.4710353017,
0.8162308931,
1.2986810207,
0.7909317613,
0.3179685175,
-0.219098255,
0.2346327454,
-0.3500893712,
-0.1832005233,
0.1168710068,
-0.5197139382,
-0.7237864137,
-0.1707321256,
0.8302820921,
0.7779003978,
-0.3511177301,
0.3950075209,
-0.2900320292,
0.6741973758,
-0.5498166084,
0.6040856838,
-0.5295731425,
0.0411468819,
-0.2553430498,
-0.4051786363,
-0.7092859149,
-0.2953165174,
0.0494007654,
-0.7270810008,
0.2111975104,
0.3647215962,
0.9691957235,
0.213245064,
-0.311958015,
-0.3506866097,
-0.745082736,
0.5783720613,
-0.8058238029,
0.3325694799,
0.3609384596,
0.1574673206,
0.1209558249,
-0.5620421171,
0.0630814731,
-0.1064632237,
0.3728690743,
0.0036569862,
-0.3307311535,
0.1834830046,
0.4613585174,
0.3422014117,
-0.3635023236,
0.6906926036,
-0.1561009735,
-0.0820595399,
0.6449332833,
0.2125797123,
-0.2063489854,
0.2599550784,
-0.4128703475,
-0.4752570093,
-0.7118745446,
-0.1617579758,
0.4960602522,
0.3944395185,
-0.0951509625,
0.3784655333,
-0.1761259139,
0.9753416777,
-0.0822249949,
-0.2675786018,
0.2452045232,
0.183226645,
-0.3759555519,
0.4172669947,
0.2600726187,
0.315391928,
0.1296337992,
-0.022768883,
-0.6864362955,
-0.1116449237,
-0.017545132,
-0.4923816621,
-0.2394328713,
-0.1019492224,
-0.1540106535,
-0.3946234584,
0.0711734295,
-0.6356058717,
-0.1603087634,
-0.3869544566,
0.6232436299,
-0.3474131525,
0.204368487,
0.3173466623,
-0.0738398805,
0.3931075633,
0.1093590185,
-1.2593585253,
0.1507800221,
1.01108706,
0.6570159197,
0.5786550045,
0.279494077,
-0.9317852259,
0.3224194646,
-0.5438420773,
0.9156498313,
-0.9364339113,
-0.3636088371,
-0.0175312366,
-0.4681490958,
0.1506267637,
-0.5322754383,
0.3843329251,
-1.098267436,
-0.4502105713,
-0.1127425209,
-0.8804638386,
-0.2035638839,
-0.1517615318,
-0.7409911156,
0.8015834093,
0.2698433101,
-0.5712187886,
0.3996110559,
-0.8103447556,
-0.3516961634,
0.337238431,
0.0138491075,
-0.4952475429,
0.0594275966,
0.0756474212,
0.568003118,
-0.4938084781,
0.0991772413,
-0.3212916851,
-0.3679208159,
0.4994136393,
-0.484940201,
0.3246389627,
0.0489276014,
-0.569675386,
0.0265195332,
-1.1532049179,
0.3229388297,
-0.1062004566,
-0.214371562,
-0.6998415589,
-0.2383084893,
-0.0237066839,
-0.1220407933,
0.1195614189,
-0.3039363623,
0.2434374839,
-0.4575827718,
0.4351728559,
1.1073681116,
-0.187288478,
0.3420801759,
-0.2410052866,
0.5373561978,
-0.2980292737,
0.081333749,
-0.3670803308,
-0.4126797616,
-0.8488019109,
-0.3712188303,
0.9253391027,
0.5555512309,
-0.4225006104,
0.5525756478,
-0.1766369492,
-0.4299584925,
-0.4215425849,
0.2145778239,
0.6980137825,
0.6195474267,
0.2425595075,
0.0326738916,
-0.4392623603,
-1.0042358637,
0.0615417138,
-0.0708900765,
0.1380048692,
0.1961676627,
0.458071053,
0.1283907443,
0.5513640642,
-0.9573712945,
-0.3767761588,
0.0088217026,
0.6701934934,
0.3481816351,
0.3188830316,
0.603317976,
-0.8261207342,
-0.5604640841,
0.3806540966,
-0.3991582394,
-0.261939615,
-0.3774192333,
-0.1471816152,
0.6291068792,
0.5707816482,
0.0779711381,
0.4457115829,
0.459687382,
-0.3012251258,
0.2444287091,
-0.5685813427,
-0.1289960146,
-0.5620241165,
-0.0342014953,
0.4630512297,
-0.2530822158,
-0.5214676857,
0.1098510399,
0.3875117898,
0.2389353812,
-0.0991854593,
0.5094250441,
-0.4466672838,
-0.0296971463,
-0.281452626,
0.0867169872,
-0.197418943,
0.4702708423,
0.188935563,
0.6398876905,
0.4872007966,
-0.4979383349,
0.2695894539,
0.1128063425,
-0.7121220231,
0.3809940219,
-0.3533660173,
-0.0311755277,
-0.0944424421,
0.3104693294,
-0.829302907,
-0.1506512612,
0.0386358909,
-0.087502338,
0.5849329233,
-0.0830707029,
-0.6122106314,
-0.1356663704,
-0.1500412971,
0.0694725513,
0.7076867819,
-0.6503825188,
0.336558044,
0.2977043986,
-0.2143991292,
-0.5626368523,
-0.5631964207,
0.0806711838,
-0.4099838436,
-0.4955067933,
0.4068414271,
-0.0334468037,
-0.3498647809,
-0.1615949571,
-0.1415308714,
0.0965545103,
0.1511982828,
0.1461840719,
0.7252817154,
-0.6588907838,
0.1349507123,
0.0614467897,
-0.5669656396,
-0.0168153215,
-0.5231215358,
0.3959101439,
-0.3310651779,
-0.1026854515,
-0.274921447,
0.4251819551,
0.2327247411,
-0.3237056732,
0.9727402329,
0.4295123816,
-0.12320856,
-0.5151666403,
-0.6452462673,
0.4146876335,
-0.5294944048,
0.3418084085,
-0.3822079003,
-0.8880402446,
0.7043536901,
0.0553475842,
0.3911435306,
0.4362204671,
0.389772296,
0.2038593143,
1.2060701847,
0.8308362365,
0.1568939835,
0.4422567487,
-0.6097816825,
0.0968044326,
-0.6415153742,
-0.1967198402,
-0.5123436451,
-0.257278204,
-0.3219458461,
-0.560677588,
0.4471271932,
-0.0879794881,
-0.2501678467,
0.1486789882,
-0.2301641554,
0.7686918974,
0.5893759727,
-0.0889095888,
0.2257568985,
0.0060618343,
-0.0384419821,
0.0441253632,
-0.5544990301,
-0.5254421234,
1.23848176,
0.290225029,
0.9406241775,
-0.0146231037,
0.7110164762,
0.3212203383,
0.640839994,
-0.6897237897,
0.3894334435,
-0.5513624549,
-0.4883913696,
-0.2895818949,
-0.605537653,
-0.431155026,
0.0302893687,
-0.018398989,
-0.7413751483,
0.0284784194,
0.2400702238,
-0.9578217268,
0.5162819624,
-0.6926375628,
0.6424458623,
-0.3653943241,
-0.1252701581,
0.08937186,
-0.67824471,
0.4656676948,
-0.7086787224,
0.3616714478,
-0.1443974823,
-0.46304667,
0.8567998409,
-0.5898566842,
0.8929043412,
-0.0783336237,
-0.8378878832,
0.1914163977,
-0.3173688054,
0.5646357536,
0.1036710441,
-0.3227233887,
0.0934860781,
-0.1079254076,
-0.2814032733,
-0.7035872936,
0.6950295568,
-0.7183514833,
-0.6083038449,
-0.2509630024,
-0.6731711626,
-0.2613765597,
-0.1151829213,
0.1194932833,
0.7967333198,
0.0256455448,
0.3428344131,
1.0599974394,
0.0571091883,
0.4769076407,
0.8763346076,
-0.2271218598,
-0.5301373601,
1.0361938477,
0.4538694322,
0.3853781521,
0.8435245752,
0.1206692681,
-0.4410202801,
-0.4925172627,
-0.5436785817,
0.2060115933,
-0.9642634392,
-0.5880197287,
-0.3599680066,
-0.2552823722,
-0.4222533703,
-0.5439895988,
-0.2226041853,
-0.5490098,
-0.5307661891,
-0.2224087566,
0.7071635127,
0.6194108129,
-0.5205171108,
0.5092850924,
-1.1278095245,
0.3523956835,
0.1401834488,
0.5414264798,
0.1527001262,
-0.9910858274,
-0.476935178,
0.0386879668,
0.1463139057,
-0.5374898911,
0.3098882735,
0.5128247142,
0.3532904387,
1.0129327774,
0.412189573,
0.79551965,
-0.2964266837,
0.1664266139,
0.1182058156,
-1.0504046679,
0.2439638078,
-0.3326733708,
0.1911578327,
0.2808788121,
0.5131577849,
-0.5017747879,
-0.3137742877,
-0.6413932443,
-1.2134648561,
0.8629325032,
-0.163815394,
0.1487487406,
-0.0486478917,
0.5822182298,
0.4068087339,
-0.169780612,
-0.3334829211,
-0.4176333547,
0.0893539414,
0.0017175697,
-0.0445262752,
-0.3980439007,
-0.1782221049,
-0.10235475,
1.0147346258,
-0.2478524148,
-0.2367954552,
-0.2215098739,
0.2023648024,
-0.2340489179,
0.1035554484,
0.6507555842,
0.6886706948,
-0.2844485939,
-0.0089599108,
0.0981921554,
-0.2310276777,
0.1931043267,
0.2573910058,
-0.1234931499,
-0.1770276427,
0.3545939028,
1.0631736517,
0.7108162642,
-0.8362160325,
0.1322675198,
0.0455968902,
-0.4433599412,
-0.4452922642,
0.4118049443,
0.0613586754,
0.2445971072,
0.5775933862,
-0.0626415908,
-0.0935677812,
-0.3400199413,
0.2269246429,
0.4291947186,
-0.3013492823,
-0.1893924922,
0.8186411858,
0.2209237367,
-0.2715418637,
0.8402557969,
-0.1611007452,
-0.2725081444,
0.8399768472,
0.8470374942,
0.7446838021,
-0.1038519591,
0.5411341786,
0.0014328824,
0.1529901922,
-0.102303274,
0.2544613779,
-0.2108890861,
-0.4286076427,
-0.5630991459,
-0.8836199045,
-0.5271472931,
0.0391883515,
-1.049571991,
0.2893712521,
-0.8344858885,
-0.2455634624,
0.7366307378,
-0.1050708964,
-0.3643421829,
0.1849195063,
0.6177552938,
1.0748827457,
-0.9377656579,
0.7632007003,
0.7652491331,
-0.2321880907,
-0.7204096317,
-0.6265751123,
-0.0164641142,
-0.9667486548,
0.804371953,
0.089191556,
-0.1099224463,
0.3739396036,
-0.4537677467,
-1.0902254581,
0.7870029807,
0.3079794049,
-0.8676056266,
-0.1827469915,
0.2926976681,
0.4821525216,
-0.3946720362,
-0.0592183433,
0.750870347,
0.6857158542,
0.5653860569,
-0.634180963,
-0.3237477243,
-0.2506078184,
-0.0137466798,
0.7315738797,
-0.8428413272,
0.4408776462,
-0.348451823,
0.0146041801,
0.2153078169,
0.919424057,
0.0844306573,
0.1737119406,
0.489829421,
0.7194890976,
0.8639373183,
-0.0965483487,
0.9543808699,
-0.4004252553,
0.2751358747,
0.9739062786,
-0.4850030839,
0.8857325315,
-0.022607876,
-0.1608132124,
0.20849289,
0.6541551948,
-0.3394160569,
0.0990927666,
0.3320039809,
-0.3855289817,
-0.6564702392,
-0.1126505658,
-0.4040411711,
0.6291350126,
0.50065732,
-0.4993883967,
-0.1917941421,
0.0222754236,
0.185759604,
-0.0631564856,
-0.4494208992,
0.6896720529,
0.1706622541,
-0.31614393,
0.6963125467,
0.3665115237,
0.558921814,
-0.9993042946,
-0.1086861938,
-0.2519910932,
0.2216443419,
-0.068188034,
-0.4547282755,
0.1209465787,
0.1944505572,
-0.2783656418,
-0.3216962814,
0.0384256579,
-0.2588267028,
-0.8707206249,
-0.0303103253,
-0.121380493,
0.1205148622,
0.0653018877,
-0.4341264963,
0.0024651976,
0.0901497453,
-0.1459652334,
0.5540004969,
0.47204566,
-0.2356978953,
0.6687483788,
0.8070207834,
0.009607967,
0.0805180147,
0.1212009639,
0.8355739117,
-1.0160542727,
-0.676897049,
-0.7646334767,
0.079936929,
0.105178833,
-0.4011742473,
0.5937444568,
0.7338679433,
0.7015255094,
-0.0449378416,
0.532151103,
0.327725172,
0.1840232611,
-0.8387137055,
0.6611086726,
-0.4199938178,
0.6041227579,
-0.2977752388,
-1.080053091,
-0.7336801887,
0.3978424668,
-0.2651269734,
-0.1649551392,
0.4528313279,
0.6635810733,
0.1282209903,
0.3709122241,
0.5112233758,
0.1342426836,
0.107619606,
0.496835947,
0.6054154038,
-0.2057897151,
0.71706599,
-0.4243378043,
-0.4637151659,
-0.3995258808,
-1.0138434172,
-0.566375196,
-0.370832175,
-0.8542350531,
0.0408464931,
-0.0006667715,
0.8700519204,
0.4418472946,
-0.6515767574,
-0.189421609,
0.4788579941,
-0.1560131162,
-0.2581592202,
-0.1811463088,
0.6378303766,
-0.3601583838,
-0.6259664297,
0.224368915,
0.651843369,
0.2767680883,
-0.2640504539,
0.2109999955,
0.1152863577,
0.2592937052,
0.4723255932,
0.3208298087,
-0.4060022831,
-0.2265764773,
0.0706994534,
0.1397294849,
0.1295270175,
0.7693463564,
-0.4501413107,
0.1419056654,
0.1634183526,
0.5534513593,
0.3114257455,
0.290880084,
0.3784174919,
-0.4282091856,
-0.1290291697,
0.1211187467,
0.0261904709,
0.1305307895,
-0.3350781202,
0.4168077707,
-0.1454601139,
-0.4636986852,
-0.8613623977,
-0.1392751932,
-0.8929064274,
-0.159452796,
1.0489234924,
-0.3732094467,
-0.6330667138,
0.0481482595,
-0.0036460038,
-0.0425843559,
-0.3979576528,
0.7490813136,
0.4484575689,
-0.099340722,
0.153209269,
-0.545448184,
0.1869132966,
0.2055440843,
-0.5124534965,
0.4030827284,
0.5023677945,
0.0517338328,
0.1455693841,
0.349201113,
-0.0104909511,
0.2859952152,
0.2041113973,
0.0399372838,
-0.1701666862,
-0.2163043618,
-0.3032414317,
0.2285765558,
0.0619439855,
0.1058115065
] |
http://arxiv.org/abs/2405.02228v2
|
http://arxiv.org/pdf/2405.02228v2
|
REASONS: A benchmark for REtrieval and Automated citationS Of scieNtific Sentences using Public and Proprietary LLMs
| 2024-05-03T16:38:51 | 2024-05-09T00:23:16 |
Deepa Tilwani, Yash Saxena, Ali Mohammadi, Edward Raff, Amit Sheth, Srinivasan Parthasarathy, Manas Gaur
|
cs.CL
|
cs.CL, cs.AI, cs.IR
|
Automatic citation generation for sentences in a document or report is
paramount for intelligence analysts, cybersecurity, news agencies, and
education personnel. In this research, we investigate whether large language
models (LLMs) are capable of generating references based on two forms of
sentence queries: (a) Direct Queries, LLMs are asked to provide author names of
the given research article, and (b) Indirect Queries, LLMs are asked to provide
the title of a mentioned article when given a sentence from a different
article. To demonstrate where LLM stands in this task, we introduce a large
dataset called REASONS comprising abstracts of the 12 most popular domains of
scientific research on arXiv. From around 20K research articles, we make the
following deductions on public and proprietary LLMs: (a) State-of-the-art,
often called anthropomorphic GPT-4 and GPT-3.5, suffers from high pass
percentage (PP) to minimize the hallucination rate (HR). When tested with
Perplexity.ai (7B), they unexpectedly made more errors; (b) Augmenting relevant
metadata lowered the PP and gave the lowest HR; (c) Advance retrieval-augmented
generation (RAG) using Mistral demonstrates consistent and robust citation
support on indirect queries and matched performance to GPT-3.5 and GPT-4. The
HR across all domains and models decreased by an average of 41.93%, and the PP
was reduced to 0% in most cases. In terms of generation quality, the average F1
Score and BLEU were 68.09% and 57.51%, respectively; (d) Testing with
adversarial samples showed that LLMs, including the Advance RAG Mistral,
struggle to understand context, but the extent of this issue was small in
Mistral and GPT-4-Preview. Our study contributes valuable insights into the
reliability of RAG for automated citation generation tasks.
|
[
-0.4515221417,
-0.6046273112,
0.9443774223,
0.0795811117,
-0.075133428,
-0.2412796319,
-0.0578380078,
-0.5087540746,
-0.0623663068,
0.4042205215,
-0.206608355,
-0.4103794098,
-0.4082406163,
0.6910042763,
-0.5856972933,
0.9675084949,
-0.1024031192,
0.0539882518,
-0.523027122,
-0.0591080524,
-0.0386845767,
-0.6761282682,
-0.3826817274,
-0.2391791195,
0.7865413427,
0.2099389881,
0.5438078046,
0.6125496626,
0.7320961356,
0.2962915301,
0.0605312213,
0.4696518183,
-0.2188863605,
0.370395422,
-0.3298378885,
-0.347555995,
-0.3137167394,
0.0857603177,
0.5312068462,
0.468131274,
0.1757478416,
0.2526066303,
-0.0598825254,
0.7136583924,
-0.6432731152,
-0.0603916049,
-0.945975244,
-0.2455313355,
-0.4234059155,
-0.4698310792,
-0.4680080712,
-0.3897996247,
0.0472730212,
-0.4586873055,
0.3191548288,
0.2891426384,
1.0001181364,
0.3274332285,
-0.4838154018,
-0.4023632705,
-0.5041804314,
0.763332963,
-0.5159430504,
0.2082228661,
0.364893198,
0.0689053014,
-0.2850821316,
-0.8589327931,
-0.4476601183,
-0.5192040205,
-0.157533139,
-0.1358255744,
-0.4102795422,
-0.1871319264,
0.4950647056,
0.1042963192,
-0.6446151137,
-0.2441105992,
-0.3303944767,
0.0472396836,
0.5920998454,
0.1538434923,
0.014110893,
-0.330270499,
-0.3055593073,
0.0762116164,
-1.1110819578,
-0.3110877275,
0.3581896126,
0.244742766,
0.4637174606,
0.6985551119,
0.0492236279,
0.694601357,
0.0341575779,
-0.0082571702,
0.0581774265,
-0.4163817763,
-0.0584049188,
0.0111529836,
0.8576105833,
0.1855266243,
0.269536674,
-0.4136371911,
-0.0584263355,
-0.29449597,
0.2992659211,
-0.940866828,
-0.044148054,
0.0847786814,
-0.1844825,
-0.1330610365,
0.2212775499,
-0.4135916531,
-0.296033591,
-0.4754962921,
0.3686323166,
-0.3235715032,
0.1472223103,
-0.3467950225,
-0.0607278012,
0.0621832274,
0.3016787171,
-0.3372248113,
0.266851455,
0.4383225739,
0.9262022972,
-0.5007702708,
-0.2052888274,
-0.5612231493,
0.1792101264,
-0.3888265789,
0.9853467941,
-0.5159309506,
-0.3715287447,
-0.1359104812,
-0.0066172467,
-0.1862947196,
-0.7967532277,
0.4230883121,
-0.5757989883,
0.2043979466,
-0.5229864717,
-0.4062971175,
0.0447710045,
0.0030759193,
-0.5489845872,
0.954031527,
-0.1271848828,
-0.9490636587,
0.1843200475,
-0.4874789119,
-0.4133622348,
0.0070903362,
-0.3577668667,
-0.3627711535,
0.0688438192,
-0.0076104491,
0.3227018416,
-0.6828834414,
0.5838855505,
-0.2832025588,
-0.2800157666,
0.4860509634,
-0.1795955002,
0.4323444664,
0.4088529646,
-0.4473812282,
-0.0620062202,
-0.7368938327,
0.0034003505,
0.1556903422,
-0.2932116389,
-0.4514049888,
0.184060812,
-0.0436071344,
0.0734452009,
0.0896952897,
-0.3692931831,
0.0448669307,
-0.0203799568,
0.2587777674,
0.6151141524,
0.2711248398,
0.0816523284,
-0.3637071252,
0.5240596533,
-0.0823535696,
-0.3434676826,
-0.2218655646,
-0.3740869462,
-0.6319872141,
-0.1721335799,
0.254522413,
0.3263795674,
-0.6207742691,
0.1860795021,
-0.2084447294,
-0.3165139854,
-0.3137960136,
0.1419555992,
0.4346241057,
0.6179689169,
0.3775095642,
0.2630315721,
-0.6676825285,
-0.9767856598,
-0.3726307452,
-0.1387129724,
-0.0685347095,
0.5752507448,
0.7337294817,
-0.097144343,
1.0791805983,
-0.3520350158,
0.0431995317,
0.029137833,
0.2484983951,
0.1803308427,
0.0833525956,
0.4924312532,
-0.9126987457,
-0.4745630622,
-0.2149865776,
-0.8227114677,
-0.456553638,
0.0214463789,
-0.2206744403,
0.3211843669,
0.5939129591,
-0.7143465877,
0.1547271013,
0.2839823067,
-0.2779538035,
0.7571783066,
-0.0317946747,
0.1013567075,
-1.0836404562,
0.6534956694,
0.2174364924,
-0.2135174721,
-0.3594210148,
0.0759177878,
-0.096554026,
-0.0892468691,
-0.2032401562,
0.5639947653,
-0.5787923932,
-0.0331531763,
-0.4622208178,
0.1956754029,
-0.0194278359,
0.0362768434,
0.0200092681,
0.9555212855,
0.2206724435,
-0.7346571088,
0.1917603314,
-0.0359207317,
-0.1439508051,
0.4045341611,
-0.9070717692,
0.1103281155,
-0.1189510003,
0.3797670603,
-0.7272896767,
-0.287460804,
0.0022713197,
-0.3066155016,
0.0651395023,
0.1671132147,
-0.5526533723,
-0.2338184714,
-0.2286120057,
0.2334594131,
0.2982245684,
-0.5134088993,
0.3660008013,
0.3039452136,
-0.3200137019,
-0.5462285876,
-0.4199730456,
0.3337720037,
-0.20915775,
-0.6324879527,
0.3781592846,
-0.1957970709,
-0.7497368455,
0.1670065522,
-0.2358237058,
0.154590711,
0.0502838567,
0.2974592149,
0.3150604665,
-0.3088272512,
0.2453441322,
-0.0641568005,
0.0866821632,
0.1840412766,
-0.0685073435,
0.3616634309,
-0.1161919534,
-0.2510449886,
-0.132149294,
0.4469547868,
0.5571212769,
-0.0150964707,
0.4967413545,
0.3490548134,
-0.092400223,
-0.1550949216,
-0.7072318792,
-0.2486941516,
-0.4118421376,
0.1192490309,
-0.3736039102,
-0.7300335765,
0.3873255253,
0.0606470034,
-0.0706490725,
0.6057229638,
0.5776370168,
0.2102867216,
0.7864758968,
0.1178232133,
-0.0543811992,
0.1684452593,
0.0321458951,
0.1828820407,
-0.7570157647,
-0.078758359,
-0.8472718,
0.0499942452,
-0.6238795519,
-0.3662619889,
0.5024385452,
0.1040717885,
-0.2685934603,
0.1553524584,
-0.5479879379,
0.3943082988,
0.6344916224,
-0.0865036026,
0.5218280554,
0.1837361008,
-0.2215471864,
0.1313671917,
-0.4172945023,
-0.8114292026,
1.0723121166,
0.1154187694,
0.7497247458,
0.0471679941,
0.7864950299,
0.199179545,
0.3223724067,
-0.5062298179,
0.7521643639,
0.019068107,
-0.7589051127,
-0.0226338711,
-0.560786128,
-1.0564388037,
0.3514848053,
0.0585493296,
-0.4606837332,
0.1968396604,
-0.0256129317,
-0.2120583951,
-0.11310222,
-0.4440368712,
0.3839422166,
-0.1342062801,
-0.6098948717,
0.0606102534,
-0.4621859193,
0.426535368,
-0.299507916,
0.0681743473,
-0.126092568,
-0.019638475,
0.7525345683,
-0.3993597627,
0.5499670506,
-0.0567509718,
0.048177436,
0.3917024434,
-0.0313208736,
0.6363645792,
0.1388213336,
-0.2696782649,
-0.0696945265,
-0.1416804343,
0.0143175432,
-0.38865906,
0.9350313544,
-0.5866203904,
-0.9508338571,
-0.716171205,
-0.6058416963,
-0.1513376385,
0.162349999,
0.4061898589,
0.1808203906,
0.059712939,
0.5344661474,
0.6689605117,
-0.1054820195,
0.2520551682,
0.7231705189,
-0.0351083614,
-0.3027296364,
0.6847473979,
0.1775313765,
0.0432660952,
0.2622434795,
0.0998577252,
-0.1496704668,
-0.5749666095,
-0.2042449564,
0.469806999,
-0.5060936213,
-0.4205715656,
-0.8733952045,
-0.2431207448,
-0.5316132903,
0.102542758,
0.0544044636,
-0.3098666668,
-0.2934912741,
-0.0381665975,
0.431373924,
0.6401850581,
-0.0006197001,
-0.229564175,
-0.5461297631,
0.3555015624,
0.204777658,
-0.1429662257,
-0.0308570545,
-0.3966637552,
-0.0801126063,
-0.33222875,
-0.4111780524,
-0.8700347543,
0.3729407191,
0.195111081,
0.6794544458,
0.089969784,
0.2262979299,
0.619458735,
-0.7274099588,
0.7959045172,
-0.1354566813,
-0.5492727757,
0.5173731446,
-0.4175360799,
0.1496492475,
0.5082491636,
0.7163366079,
-0.1722875983,
-0.6172196269,
-0.5539403558,
-1.1064469814,
0.6206621528,
0.2710018754,
-0.1579279602,
-0.3532406092,
0.3923532963,
0.0966597348,
0.1590402573,
-0.7068225145,
-0.2580120862,
0.1188857257,
-0.0040210779,
-0.0971547142,
-0.3057357967,
-0.3653204739,
-0.0046801493,
0.8385462761,
-0.1377293169,
0.3440994024,
0.5141119361,
-0.0907085612,
-0.1176029146,
0.2863200903,
0.8091714978,
0.8311746716,
-0.1453314871,
0.2250033766,
-0.0977220237,
-0.3313423097,
-0.0009980695,
0.3751572967,
-0.3829008937,
0.3735869527,
0.2148815244,
0.5027605891,
-0.0426750891,
-0.6570543647,
0.3551334143,
0.1403825879,
-0.2851171792,
-0.4320180714,
0.0052983686,
0.071480155,
0.2118309885,
0.928160131,
-0.1569931805,
0.3517042696,
-0.3728211224,
0.2282908708,
0.5757425427,
0.1447245628,
-0.2328802496,
0.6742216349,
-0.0146465395,
0.0537227765,
0.3497611284,
-0.1457000673,
-0.233405292,
0.4951733351,
0.6437356472,
0.7539533973,
-0.005874096,
0.1908812374,
0.4539882541,
0.0341687575,
-0.2885818779,
0.1369546652,
-0.102331683,
-0.3633622527,
-0.3619248271,
-0.8590326309,
-0.4845901728,
0.3162417412,
-0.5247163177,
0.1039584503,
-0.1688842773,
-0.4181549847,
0.1575262398,
0.0470483489,
-0.4945020974,
-0.0576110072,
0.0580606535,
0.7735949159,
-0.6534805894,
0.7467920184,
0.7362467051,
-0.5309209228,
-0.7399072051,
-0.0603163317,
0.0702196062,
-0.4969163239,
1.0477534533,
-0.1019191667,
-0.2194568217,
-0.1343093365,
-0.5967612267,
-1.0245279074,
1.0896849632,
0.4269766808,
-0.5841547847,
-0.3441645503,
0.0064419531,
0.5260210037,
-0.4426367879,
0.2708138824,
0.2577970028,
0.6691972613,
0.2356717885,
-0.8345435262,
0.3261262476,
-0.3675259352,
0.1308154613,
0.076917544,
-0.4731017649,
0.8912320733,
-0.1628463417,
-0.1283469796,
0.3573320508,
0.5109607577,
0.7838716507,
0.4863231778,
0.1393078119,
0.3736907542,
0.815174222,
-0.054322429,
1.1073566675,
-0.4481135905,
0.0453364998,
0.9815351963,
-0.4373444021,
0.8278705478,
0.7096575499,
-0.1394421905,
0.5711138248,
0.4305816889,
-0.2329844534,
0.3941219151,
0.2729587853,
-0.1947243959,
-0.1797370464,
-0.1886089891,
-0.6109416485,
0.1474845856,
0.0924605802,
-0.7628512979,
-0.3155984282,
-0.0348181762,
0.2357578576,
-0.0069587976,
-0.0784625188,
0.5379737616,
0.2378265709,
-0.9277863503,
0.5937644839,
-0.1341655701,
0.4339578748,
-0.554749012,
0.0639500841,
-0.20521833,
0.1565243304,
-0.3488239348,
-0.3324932456,
0.0845362023,
0.3457918167,
-0.3038542867,
-0.0656847283,
0.7028300166,
-0.1865059882,
-0.4791969955,
-0.0307043809,
0.5280546546,
0.4877703488,
-0.123535715,
-0.4620374739,
0.023141358,
-0.0369412079,
-0.6441626549,
0.4782525599,
0.5163505077,
-0.1544015259,
0.4820700288,
0.6835172772,
0.2452802658,
0.0608509183,
0.0408816524,
0.8033774495,
-0.6889258623,
0.0420189723,
-0.7951844931,
0.1653635502,
-0.2663576901,
-0.2584475875,
1.1044453382,
0.6266429424,
0.4985882342,
0.0487416722,
0.8790206313,
-0.0482469536,
0.668438673,
-0.5248847604,
0.5396313667,
-0.5825881958,
0.3137882054,
-0.2317299098,
-1.068857193,
-0.3028050363,
0.4631427824,
-0.4319051504,
0.1479600817,
0.8788784742,
0.7535215616,
0.1991077811,
-0.2585882246,
0.0909209847,
0.1967441142,
0.4428183436,
0.1601139903,
0.7407702804,
-0.2634325624,
0.7656319141,
0.0972721502,
0.080352515,
-0.2977126241,
-0.89052248,
-0.7720463872,
-0.5100528002,
-0.4171541035,
-0.5143277645,
0.3532899022,
0.844409585,
0.480425477,
-0.7154041529,
-0.1083244309,
-0.2429106086,
-0.0427835174,
0.1773221493,
-0.2765668035,
0.4272476435,
-0.6814539433,
-0.71270293,
0.4358816445,
0.0553705283,
-0.1962058395,
-0.1753042489,
-0.0751566216,
-0.1824979335,
0.1441203356,
0.4921528399,
0.3432647288,
-0.7995471954,
-0.1344223171,
0.2040306777,
-0.4771235287,
-0.1603200734,
0.9349652529,
-0.7917739153,
0.0766825452,
0.4681228399,
0.5174672008,
0.4575085342,
0.2071318179,
0.492413342,
-0.4468708932,
-0.2588769495,
0.3956074417,
0.355900526,
0.3267379105,
-0.3204101622,
0.5895023346,
0.3478037417,
-1.0022712946,
-1.0822408199,
-0.0172473975,
-0.809831202,
-0.3794913888,
1.5370405912,
-0.0664731711,
-0.3099437058,
-0.0940219089,
-0.0637021065,
-0.0455074608,
-0.4693862498,
0.7957485318,
0.7768406868,
-0.3736593723,
0.0253237262,
-0.4343625009,
0.5123414397,
0.2289242446,
-0.5811280012,
0.1046979055,
0.7107599974,
0.2362793833,
0.4454848468,
0.4912557304,
-0.2432123572,
0.3208924532,
-0.1355618238,
-0.0763853341,
-0.3057930768,
-0.282605648,
0.0141250603,
0.4028142095,
0.1882584542,
0.1786346585
] |
Subsets and Splits
No community queries yet
The top public SQL queries from the community will appear here once available.